id
stringlengths
32
39
title
stringlengths
7
232
authors
stringlengths
5
6.98k
categories
stringlengths
12
178
summary
stringlengths
3
3.12k
link_pdf
stringlengths
32
39
updated
unknown
published
unknown
embeddings
dict
http://arxiv.org/abs/1905.09673v2
Deep Q-Learning with Q-Matrix Transfer Learning for Novel Fire Evacuation Environment
Jivitesh Sharma, Per-Arne Andersen, Ole-Chrisoffer Granmo, Morten Goodwin
cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SY
We focus on the important problem of emergency evacuation, which clearly could benefit from reinforcement learning that has been largely unaddressed. Emergency evacuation is a complex task which is difficult to solve with reinforcement learning, since an emergency situation is highly dynamic, with a lot of changing variables and complex constraints that makes it difficult to train on. In this paper, we propose the first fire evacuation environment to train reinforcement learning agents for evacuation planning. The environment is modelled as a graph capturing the building structure. It consists of realistic features like fire spread, uncertainty and bottlenecks. We have implemented the environment in the OpenAI gym format, to facilitate future research. We also propose a new reinforcement learning approach that entails pretraining the network weights of a DQN based agents to incorporate information on the shortest path to the exit. We achieved this by using tabular Q-learning to learn the shortest path on the building model's graph. This information is transferred to the network by deliberately overfitting it on the Q-matrix. Then, the pretrained DQN model is trained on the fire evacuation environment to generate the optimal evacuation path under time varying conditions. We perform comparisons of the proposed approach with state-of-the-art reinforcement learning algorithms like PPO, VPG, SARSA, A2C and ACKTR. The results show that our method is able to outperform state-of-the-art models by a huge margin including the original DQN based models. Finally, we test our model on a large and complex real building consisting of 91 rooms, with the possibility to move to any other room, hence giving 8281 actions. We use an attention based mechanism to deal with large action spaces. Our model achieves near optimal performance on the real world emergency environment.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1905.09673v2
"2019-05-29T16:35:23"
"2019-05-23T14:15:51"
{ "title": [ 0.011878967, 0.026062012, -0.040161133, -0.0036010742, 0.026687622, -0.040130615, 0.031555176, -0.04257202, -0.041625977, 0.03793335, -0.028335571, 0.01939392, -0.03213501, -0.021759033, -0.022079468, -0.030319214, 0.002456665, 0.008407593, -0.015174866, -0.027709961, -0.004295349, -0.044647217, 0.04220581, 0.062683105, 0.005214691, -0.008644104, -0.057800293, 0.009124756, -0.033935547, -0.0335083, -0.0014562607, 0.026672363, 0.052764893, 0.049865723, -0.08929443, -0.018157959, -0.07867432, 0.04196167, -0.030090332, 0.013694763, 0.021408081, -0.022247314, -0.014213562, -0.023590088, -0.03677368, 0.058746338, -0.066223145, 0.0003478527, -0.03970337, 0.027420044, 0.027374268, 0.004875183, 0.019882202, 0.03366089, 0.011665344, -0.012619019, -0.006706238, -0.020385742, 0.047332764, 0.053619385, 0.0002834797, -0.033477783, 0.007858276, -0.046569824, -0.039123535, -0.012512207, 0.030273438, 0.012649536, 0.048065186, -0.020690918, -0.011566162, 0.035736084, -0.0020923615, 0.0259552, -0.055236816, -0.02330017, 0.060272217, 0.012626648, 0.006340027, 0.0035362244, 0.010696411, -0.024169922, 0.0262146, -0.03010559, 0.016189575, -0.030532837, -0.008522034, -0.009170532, -0.05355835, -0.0847168, -0.014640808, -0.014533997, -0.06329346, -0.008094788, -0.01651001, -0.050933838, -0.04284668, -0.011459351, -0.004585266, -0.00018310547, -0.016815186, 0.029953003, -0.035736084, -0.0053367615, 0.009429932, 0.04537964, 0.010192871, -0.019714355, -0.0023880005, 0.015716553, -0.021850586, -0.030334473, 0.015914917, -0.0077705383, 0.02130127, 0.0071640015, 0.0011720657, 0.03744507, 0.027755737, 0.012916565, -0.022766113, -0.02532959, 0.013427734, 0.0138549805, 0.020019531, -0.0017499924, -0.021560669, -0.0064849854, 0.0050201416, 0.0014705658, 0.003753662, 0.070129395, -0.084106445, -0.08117676, -0.06994629, 0.03894043, 0.0051879883, 0.02407837, 0.0128479, -0.052001953, 0.052703857, -0.009544373, -0.020248413, 0.032318115, -0.0126571655, 0.039520264, 0.04663086, -0.010047913, -0.072753906, -0.07824707, -0.0065345764, -0.0037899017, 0.0340271, 0.01158905, -0.07110596, -0.0063438416, -0.08843994, -0.030838013, 0.016082764, -0.030899048, 0.064941406, 0.016815186, -0.018066406, 0.048461914, 0.070251465, -0.045074463, -0.04547119, 0.021606445, -0.00066041946, 0.13098145, -0.03567505, 0.030410767, -0.038360596, -0.012275696, -0.011985779, -0.026443481, 0.031951904, 0.020812988, 0.023223877, -0.023208618, -0.0025691986, -0.028167725, 0.0009908676, 0.028335571, -0.044158936, -0.048950195, -0.0011730194, -0.017547607, 0.07672119, 0.0072746277, -0.032073975, -0.023040771, -0.030334473, -0.033813477, -0.051452637, 0.00057172775, 0.026931763, 0.04055786, -0.010871887, 0.036468506, -0.04168701, -0.028564453, 0.0098724365, 0.0062713623, -0.0014696121, -0.03515625, -0.011642456, 0.015182495, -0.005191803, 0.056365967, 0.025100708, 0.020736694, -0.046203613, 0.014984131, -0.0042877197, -0.049926758, -0.0032367706, 0.0058784485, 0.0009088516, -0.0074539185, -0.0069122314, -0.0066871643, 0.011657715, 0.0082092285, 0.008407593, -0.017028809, 0.005092621, -0.048828125, 0.043823242, -0.009086609, 0.08453369, 0.0071983337, 0.037963867, 0.027114868, -0.0036449432, 0.015716553, 0.019836426, 0.0211792, -0.010887146, 0.00063848495, 0.0021800995, -0.01348114, -0.00793457, 0.027328491, 0.08337402, 0.056549072, 0.010910034, 0.012107849, -0.008110046, 0.021697998, 0.057800293, 0.06524658, 0.037719727, 0.0440979, -0.007926941, 0.07476807, -0.013160706, -0.009063721, -0.008522034, 0.007843018, 0.0035419464, -0.022842407, 0.0052490234, -0.008331299, -0.050933838, -0.0126571655, 0.0055007935, 0.017990112, 0.021408081, -0.020980835, 0.021255493, 0.0071144104, 0.003824234, 0.00655365, 0.017974854, -0.015487671, -0.025253296, 0.004180908, 0.017700195, -0.042510986, 0.017333984, 0.006450653, 0.03778076, -0.018341064, 0.048797607, -0.012306213, -0.0014371872, -0.005996704, -0.019683838, -0.0020523071, 0.04638672, 0.0054740906, 0.002002716, -0.01914978, -0.009979248, -0.01676941, 0.04928589, 0.08862305, -0.043701172, 0.02947998, -0.07366943, -0.013977051, -0.0068588257, -0.029312134, 0.013450623, 0.071899414, 0.04727173, 0.022964478, 0.011917114, 0.0032463074, -0.014656067, -0.0063972473, 0.012046814, -0.0042915344, -0.017303467, -0.027740479, 0.010551453, 0.00026392937, 0.013023376, 0.03817749, 0.06100464, -0.022262573, -0.025756836, -0.015731812, -0.0029697418, -0.025131226, -0.018844604, -0.02557373, -0.005771637, 0.03540039, 0.045013428, 0.03479004, -0.033599854, 0.0076675415, -0.013710022, 0.015174866, -0.017669678, 0.030731201, -0.009613037, -0.008575439, -0.007980347, -0.0032806396, 0.00995636, -0.020462036, -0.034606934, -0.05126953, 0.026885986, -0.0035381317, -0.005718231, -0.0037460327, 0.05493164, -0.024002075, -0.037506104, 0.002998352, 0.032165527, -0.028045654, 0.014350891, 0.02722168, -0.005180359, -0.01727295, -0.015640259, -0.0031108856, -0.053588867, -0.05709839, 0.050598145, -0.023757935, -0.046020508, -0.026473999, -0.016860962, 0.041381836, -0.06768799, -0.007835388, -0.02180481, -0.008987427, -0.00058174133, 0.022567749, -0.0018749237, -0.026657104, -0.01335144, -0.0077781677, 0.009521484, 0.025253296, -0.029968262, 0.053710938, 0.045410156, 0.023635864, -0.014549255, -0.0010652542, 0.0084991455, -0.0001732111, -0.028686523, -0.002500534, -0.026641846, -0.008926392, 0.036254883, 0.005176544, -0.0048446655, -0.00422287, -0.09790039, -0.026153564, -0.0047798157, 0.022262573, -0.02507019, 0.019500732, -0.033721924, -0.013450623, -0.021377563, -0.03869629, 0.024047852, 0.03616333, 0.035858154, -0.051879883, 0.045654297, -0.068115234, 0.024017334, -0.022872925, -0.06378174, 0.0090408325, -0.013923645, -0.013145447, 0.010002136, -0.03704834, -0.0473938, -0.016540527, -0.036834717, -0.008018494, 0.016799927, 0.020568848, 0.011917114, -0.0021018982, -0.02357483, -0.03793335, 0.013305664, -0.0077285767, -0.015136719, -0.023742676, -0.023742676, 0.019577026, 0.015670776, -0.026489258, -0.030838013, -0.008377075, 0.008361816, 0.027069092, 0.021057129, -0.03277588, -0.008300781, -0.0014820099, 0.015914917, 0.017593384, -0.0019741058, -0.021591187, 0.0021076202, 0.0046806335, -0.032440186, 0.064575195, -0.0044555664, 0.039611816, 0.01902771, -0.014770508, 0.02079773, -0.031677246, -0.043945312, 0.054718018, 0.0022640228, -0.0041007996, 0.018096924, -0.020141602, -0.045135498, 0.029144287, -0.031341553, 0.023330688, -0.004547119, -0.010574341, -0.0062179565, -0.018341064, 0.009796143, 0.0076179504, 0.01864624, -0.0036411285, -0.00083112717, 0.0017547607, -0.037719727, -0.033111572, 0.0054359436, -0.0023441315, -0.045898438, 0.01625061, 0.02178955, -0.002500534, -0.020095825, -0.021057129, 0.025177002, 0.025253296, -0.007041931, 0.0128479, -0.008636475, 0.0013380051, -0.018051147, -0.08099365, -0.030197144, 0.03387451, 0.0309906, 0.037353516, 0.00066185, 0.004966736, 0.007827759, -0.045654297, -0.010650635, -0.040039062, 0.056732178, -0.04119873, -0.009895325, 0.030914307, -0.022094727, -0.027923584, 0.040130615, 0.03652954, -0.04360962, 0.0003709793, -0.010551453, -0.0067214966, -0.0052986145, 0.05996704, -0.003736496, -0.0035133362, -0.062347412, 0.027786255, -0.0011720657, 0.013786316, 0.007320404, -0.037750244, 0.0473938, 0.0184021, 0.021591187, 0.06384277, -0.014518738, 0.056915283, 0.0362854, -0.07910156, -0.022338867, 0.013214111, 0.022827148, -0.028625488, 0.0149002075, -0.012123108, 0.010955811, 0.043884277, -0.061309814, 0.018554688, -0.024215698, -0.00003117323, -0.003894806, -0.01902771, -0.06970215, -0.017425537, 0.013069153, -0.00051927567, -0.005050659, 0.02381897, 0.02218628, 0.01461792, -0.016540527, -0.016906738, 0.06286621, 0.02204895, -0.04437256, -0.09729004, 0.036621094, -0.03866577, -0.07293701, -0.043640137, -0.023071289, -0.0009174347, 0.036224365, 0.016723633, -0.021514893, 0.0068855286, 0.053985596, 0.0625, 0.013015747, -0.023605347, -0.048980713, -0.028442383, -0.031707764, -0.04373169, 0.052459717, -0.030822754, -0.008003235, -0.02368164, 0.053222656, -0.01939392, -0.014839172, -0.008934021, -0.019470215, 0.012374878, 0.006214142, -0.008850098, 0.005504608, 0.00064754486, 0.0060691833, 0.007282257, 0.0061798096, -0.023284912, -0.006679535, 0.04055786, 0.0158844, 0.021469116, 0.01638794, 0.034179688, 0.016204834, -0.017288208, 0.005252838, 0.03302002, 0.018310547, -0.013259888, -0.024612427, 0.03414917, -0.019195557, -0.028427124, 0.014877319, -0.0357666, 0.033233643, -0.015472412, 0.07757568, -0.02519226, -0.0020446777, 0.03149414, -0.00036787987, -0.013381958, -0.016815186, -0.0013618469, -0.059020996, -0.06744385, -0.012397766, 0.06707764, -0.011375427, -0.011993408, 0.013542175, 0.013191223, 0.034179688, 0.055908203, 0.020004272, -0.034057617, 0.0021743774, -0.0026550293, -0.017150879, -0.020233154, -0.04119873, -0.0017223358, -0.0038928986, 0.008430481, -0.03414917, -0.006008148, -0.03363037, -0.004535675, -0.0025177002, 0.018508911, -0.0009021759, -0.046722412, 0.0038585663, 0.043518066, 0.030731201, -0.0007004738, -0.0019483566, 0.020370483, 0.02319336, 0.028274536, 0.016052246, 0.0040245056, 0.015457153, -0.035217285, 0.035491943, -0.0005493164, -0.00447464, -0.008529663, 0.00068616867, -0.018325806, -0.008712769, -0.025970459, 0.03475952, -0.0024108887, -0.011985779, -0.028930664, -0.024887085, -0.0042686462, 0.014045715, 0.028656006, 0.015365601, 0.009185791, -0.018463135, -0.020523071, -0.0015850067, -0.05215454, -0.003929138, -0.002817154, -0.005783081, -0.09112549, 0.03744507, -0.061828613, 0.03289795, -0.014137268, -0.02822876, -0.048583984, 0.000028550625, 0.04220581, -0.0008172989, -0.014564514, -0.017700195, 0.0069503784, 0.0074882507, 0.010826111, -0.10546875, -0.020324707, 0.026733398, -0.041046143, -0.06536865, 0.030807495, 0.020370483, -0.025970459, 0.0032215118, 0.010932922, 0.049316406, -0.0068359375, 0.028137207, 0.058746338, -0.030456543, 0.032806396, -0.015182495, -0.014823914, -0.0034313202, 0.019104004, -0.030273438, -0.0014047623, 0.011497498, -0.00062704086, 0.021591187, -0.01802063, 0.007003784, -0.00048971176, -0.030532837, 0.012680054, 0.027755737, 0.00409317, 0.015792847, 0.010192871, 0.03616333, -0.005191803, 0.00415802, 0.0231781, 0.076171875, -0.083862305, 0.025665283, -0.028793335, 0.014427185, -0.04144287, 0.048553467, -0.066223145, 0.0022354126, -0.047912598, -0.07171631, -0.013710022, 0.023895264, 0.03970337, 0.013244629, 0.035308838, -0.038513184, 0.02746582, -0.00046539307, -0.0044021606, -0.059692383, -0.00028896332, -0.0037612915, -0.003753662, 0.041625977, 0.00818634, -0.008415222, -0.01689148, 0.020050049, 0.0062065125, 0.0017356873, 0.0010709763, -0.035583496, -0.0030059814, -0.022232056, -0.01550293, 0.01687622, 0.0011072159, 0.00062417984, 0.05041504, -0.022277832, 0.032806396, -0.023880005, 0.020874023, 0.028823853, -0.004585266, -0.03491211, -0.0067214966, -0.045318604, -0.058013916, 0.07318115, -0.064941406, -0.0063056946, -0.109069824, -0.03390503, -0.103881836, 0.0014858246, -0.004180908, -0.02015686, 0.050628662, -0.024856567, 0.021606445, 0.053649902, 0.011100769, 0.036834717, 0.0028018951, 0.013702393, 0.006084442, 0.0015830994, -0.0047416687, 0.012367249, 0.046081543, 0.0003991127, 0.012458801, -0.013847351, -0.016189575, 0.00579834, -0.0096588135, 0.0335083, -0.040496826, -0.0149383545, -0.027923584, 0.024291992, -0.015037537, 0.009002686, 0.064086914, 0.019363403, 0.013366699, -0.037078857, 0.016693115, 0.013381958, -0.009819031, 0.012634277, 0.04876709, -0.076293945, 0.032104492, -0.004676819, -0.029327393, -0.014259338, 0.029525757, 0.03866577, -0.038604736, -0.017547607, 0.016540527, 0.03555298, -0.012367249, 0.004863739, -0.05340576, -0.02192688, 0.01965332, 0.0067749023, -0.012718201, -0.024230957, 0.032409668, 0.044769287, -0.009689331, 0.025024414, 0.0012512207, 0.013465881, 0.006904602, 0.039154053, -0.066345215, -0.012886047, 0.024124146, -0.025619507, 0.012992859, 0.008277893, 0.01676941, 0.008796692, 0.012825012, 0.022415161, -0.015670776, 0.03552246, 0.0034713745, -0.013809204, -0.022003174, -0.016967773, 0.010971069, 0.027862549, -0.023162842, 0.0069732666, -0.006881714, -0.033355713, 0.027923584, -0.02772522, 0.030929565, -0.057556152, 0.0045394897, -0.021957397, -0.001209259, 0.007881165, -0.028381348, -0.009780884, -0.04525757, -0.024002075, -0.0010061264, 0.015281677, -0.017974854, -0.04916382, -0.0020065308, 0.060272217, 0.0011901855, -0.004043579, 0.0043182373, -0.010131836, -0.03881836, -0.024856567, -0.02722168, 0.015686035, -0.0007638931, -0.032928467, -0.043640137, 0.008155823, 0.029144287, 0.026519775, -0.00422287, 0.00084733963, -0.058929443, -0.026107788, 0.012268066, 0.021911621, -0.016540527, -0.004108429, 0.022537231, 0.001964569, -0.0121536255, 0.024673462, 0.032592773, -0.05343628, -0.037017822, 0.015396118, -0.03555298, 0.06866455, 0.0211792, -0.0016527176, -0.009422302, 0.023376465, -0.026046753, -0.054382324, -0.024139404, -0.0050582886, 0.0046844482, -0.032592773, -0.016662598, 0.05065918, 0.030715942, -0.027618408, -0.018692017, 0.023956299, 0.05831909, -0.0039787292, 0.05923462, 0.015731812, 0.026107788, 0.009269714, 0.06774902, 0.0047340393, -0.057037354, -0.048461914, -0.015014648, 0.06616211, 0.015388489, -0.020645142, -0.02444458, 0.008003235, -0.015426636, 0.0031986237, -0.010734558, -0.0047187805, -0.013305664, -0.007045746, 0.010627747, -0.010124207, -0.020050049, -0.005180359, 0.06536865, -0.026031494, 0.015472412, 0.010612488, 0.008743286, 0.012672424, 0.04067993, -0.013145447, -0.04321289, 0.038757324, 0.024520874, 0.011421204, 0.03302002, -0.0016117096, -0.024902344, -0.014343262, 0.018203735, -0.0103302, 0.015357971, 0.014579773, 0.011550903, 0.0184021, -0.031066895, -0.0340271, 0.0072784424, -0.048187256, 0.032806396, -0.03152466, 0.018554688, -0.009223938, -0.0067329407, -0.0023975372, 0.0362854, 0.0066184998, -0.022247314, -0.034820557, -0.0051002502, 0.045898438, -0.017456055 ], "summary": [ 0.04067993, 0.029586792, -0.00019919872, 0.035736084, 0.010032654, -0.040130615, 0.046936035, -0.07232666, -0.02456665, 0.0061798096, -0.042297363, 0.005592346, -0.02998352, -0.026519775, 0.03152466, -0.041137695, 0.004142761, -0.017349243, -0.02494812, -0.047851562, 0.012702942, -0.0524292, 0.0043296814, 0.050598145, 0.011764526, 0.011062622, -0.0038070679, 0.020324707, -0.0038814545, 0.014411926, 0.0104522705, -0.011886597, -0.00014710426, 0.038391113, -0.044189453, -0.045837402, -0.024887085, 0.024368286, -0.010749817, 0.014373779, 0.02319336, -0.022979736, 0.06088257, -0.033599854, 0.0012197495, 0.044036865, -0.0007915497, -0.02218628, -0.0121154785, 0.018539429, 0.022705078, 0.023422241, 0.01574707, 0.0057868958, -0.0012836456, 0.0038928986, -0.006954193, -0.05859375, 0.021591187, 0.024353027, 0.020141602, -0.029876709, 0.014274597, -0.014289856, -0.055419922, 0.009109497, 0.050994873, -0.019058228, 0.038116455, -0.060058594, -0.015701294, 0.053131104, 0.011604309, 0.0017662048, -0.035491943, -0.013671875, 0.057861328, 0.01247406, -0.010528564, -0.0076828003, 0.017196655, 0.033325195, -0.0066375732, -0.052368164, 0.027450562, -0.020645142, -0.009017944, -0.020690918, -0.055725098, -0.04925537, -0.036315918, 0.000059962273, -0.05215454, -0.039398193, -0.011817932, -0.039978027, -0.037322998, -0.05734253, -0.016723633, 0.0013589859, -0.001282692, 0.009437561, -0.004749298, 0.013931274, -0.02558899, 0.051605225, 0.04748535, 0.0027942657, -0.0513916, -0.004299164, -0.024490356, -0.07952881, -0.012023926, -0.020339966, 0.0002925396, 0.0066223145, -0.026870728, 0.045074463, 0.006641388, 0.017196655, -0.036224365, 0.0009908676, -0.0062332153, 0.012199402, -0.015533447, 0.009521484, 0.022476196, -0.007610321, 0.055480957, -0.017944336, 0.0054016113, 0.0519104, -0.038208008, -0.04559326, -0.05117798, 0.022384644, 0.034820557, 0.008590698, 0.033203125, -0.08984375, 0.10369873, 0.03878784, -0.005432129, 0.07232666, -0.036865234, 0.07421875, 0.03277588, -0.027862549, -0.055786133, -0.09539795, -0.0024280548, -0.049987793, 0.033569336, -0.021392822, -0.012710571, -0.049468994, -0.013580322, -0.022994995, 0.01676941, -0.03326416, 0.06237793, 0.034606934, 0.039520264, 0.041503906, 0.038879395, -0.058502197, -0.033721924, 0.004383087, 0.009819031, 0.109313965, -0.028167725, 0.009727478, -0.053497314, -0.0032253265, -0.019104004, -0.031829834, -0.010574341, 0.028411865, 0.012680054, -0.02670288, 0.010246277, -0.03894043, 0.010978699, 0.021453857, 0.013023376, -0.040161133, -0.010604858, -0.036071777, 0.04586792, 0.0033454895, -0.035888672, -0.004627228, 0.004360199, -0.005958557, -0.017669678, -0.015205383, -0.018356323, 0.016571045, -0.017852783, 0.006881714, 0.01600647, -0.025634766, 0.059020996, -0.027694702, 0.0048980713, 0.00756073, 0.0058670044, 0.02659607, -0.02720642, 0.013648987, 0.040374756, 0.019195557, -0.062927246, 0.041656494, 0.0019264221, 0.0037326813, -0.00047802925, 0.010299683, 0.0069770813, 0.02470398, 0.0031490326, 0.0055732727, 0.009590149, 0.0033245087, 0.0064582825, -0.03479004, -0.009506226, -0.018005371, -0.0041275024, 0.0040130615, -0.019638062, 0.038269043, -0.017684937, 0.023223877, -0.021621704, -0.0014696121, 0.017486572, 0.005355835, 0.011367798, 0.024368286, 0.0055770874, 0.020645142, -0.036376953, 0.013053894, 0.022445679, 0.026290894, 0.0151901245, -0.0025691986, -0.045806885, -0.007774353, 0.013183594, 0.040649414, 0.016738892, 0.06427002, -0.053375244, 0.04727173, -0.010528564, -0.016067505, 0.010231018, -0.012023926, 0.014289856, -0.044006348, -0.029144287, -0.011100769, -0.0072402954, -0.03363037, 0.020721436, 0.017700195, 0.05050659, -0.06225586, -0.006038666, -0.027130127, -0.01335907, -0.0021743774, -0.0025672913, -0.0045051575, -0.046722412, 0.019927979, 0.046569824, -0.0041656494, 0.013938904, 0.034332275, 0.025878906, -0.015052795, 0.04916382, 0.010360718, -0.017913818, -0.025787354, 0.009819031, 0.022857666, 0.042510986, -0.006046295, 0.0073890686, -0.006591797, 0.009315491, -0.025512695, 0.0073661804, 0.050811768, -0.01701355, -0.009468079, -0.03149414, 0.02508545, -0.015007019, -0.02003479, 0.012496948, -0.0030326843, 0.010429382, 0.025909424, 0.009689331, -0.043273926, 0.002620697, 0.0054397583, 0.020904541, 0.059265137, 0.007987976, -0.007888794, 0.028045654, 0.046813965, 0.059661865, 0.053833008, 0.04220581, 0.0032653809, 0.032440186, 0.013504028, 0.0070381165, -0.05493164, 0.030273438, -0.0022449493, 0.01235199, 0.006565094, -0.01776123, 0.020568848, -0.021606445, 0.0262146, -0.0024108887, 0.017684937, -0.012329102, 0.09503174, 0.0038337708, -0.018066406, 0.009132385, -0.030014038, 0.0013875961, 0.020217896, -0.0793457, 0.005783081, 0.02078247, -0.026351929, 0.05899048, 0.008964539, 0.010421753, 0.02017212, -0.057403564, 0.0015068054, -0.019073486, 0.0022182465, 0.07232666, 0.0067863464, -0.0042648315, -0.03451538, 0.026535034, -0.025054932, -0.044128418, -0.07714844, 0.035614014, 0.011375427, -0.036468506, -0.03552246, -0.020690918, 0.03945923, -0.011924744, 0.020019531, -0.020202637, -0.03643799, -0.04736328, -0.0012836456, 0.09942627, -0.004348755, -0.009666443, 0.05935669, -0.001616478, 0.019546509, -0.060394287, 0.016494751, 0.047180176, 0.009063721, -0.021560669, 0.011352539, 0.0038909912, -0.005378723, -0.02456665, -0.008148193, -0.020645142, -0.01285553, 0.028213501, 0.006122589, -0.0121536255, -0.005558014, -0.03173828, -0.025299072, -0.029067993, 0.034942627, 0.0061073303, 0.023376465, -0.030090332, 0.033447266, -0.0129470825, -0.030349731, 0.025436401, -0.032043457, 0.06451416, -0.09436035, 0.07165527, -0.124938965, 0.006275177, -0.033203125, 0.019714355, 0.006298065, -0.046905518, -0.005722046, 0.026687622, 0.019714355, -0.016082764, -0.008514404, -0.03189087, -0.0045776367, -0.008834839, 0.024154663, -0.015617371, 0.022109985, -0.015899658, -0.009559631, -0.014305115, 0.024917603, -0.04196167, 0.028457642, 0.0033817291, -0.016723633, 0.050994873, -0.053894043, -0.038024902, 0.0051460266, 0.009742737, -0.00061130524, 0.0152282715, -0.019226074, 0.0037994385, -0.03778076, -0.024475098, 0.01612854, -0.003835678, 0.020126343, -0.011871338, 0.0112838745, -0.0095825195, 0.015357971, -0.024932861, 0.03643799, 0.06774902, -0.0524292, -0.01739502, -0.027160645, -0.021087646, 0.0340271, 0.007572174, 0.025512695, 0.015731812, -0.0028133392, -0.0284729, 0.03604126, 0.0038414001, -0.022781372, -0.0031871796, -0.0032196045, -0.026229858, 0.0033454895, 0.049835205, -0.014915466, 0.051452637, -0.02357483, -0.001698494, -0.002319336, -0.021896362, -0.023880005, -0.004501343, -0.008979797, -0.05911255, -0.0057373047, 0.03152466, 0.064208984, 0.015991211, 0.014968872, 0.031677246, 0.06512451, 0.020126343, 0.032043457, -0.018539429, 0.04888916, -0.016693115, -0.047729492, -0.027053833, -0.025680542, 0.05029297, 0.02746582, -0.02758789, 0.016174316, 0.039794922, -0.0029716492, 0.01159668, -0.029312134, 0.029052734, -0.03479004, 0.0037517548, 0.041870117, -0.03100586, -0.02670288, 0.04284668, 0.052612305, -0.03930664, -0.011421204, 0.016799927, 0.045715332, 0.00014173985, 0.008071899, 0.020980835, -0.0053520203, -0.011016846, 0.037109375, 0.019897461, -0.001871109, 0.013038635, 0.012779236, -0.03942871, 0.011245728, 0.01838684, -0.023132324, 0.010826111, 0.028549194, 0.04360962, -0.0287323, 0.0042686462, 0.037200928, 0.0016746521, -0.021057129, 0.004272461, -0.0045394897, 0.0017948151, 0.022003174, -0.025970459, 0.023452759, -0.0077552795, -0.011413574, -0.024032593, -0.07446289, -0.04977417, 0.034851074, 0.02255249, -0.0032539368, 0.009941101, -0.01737976, 0.0076408386, -0.013328552, 0.024093628, -0.011077881, 0.05960083, 0.019363403, -0.049591064, -0.079833984, 0.0385437, -0.03100586, -0.06097412, -0.058929443, -0.068725586, -0.05706787, -0.020599365, 0.025436401, -0.04663086, 0.004512787, 0.024749756, 0.07989502, 0.0395813, 0.018600464, -0.06774902, -0.046325684, -0.033966064, 0.0021762848, 0.02116394, -0.0513916, -0.0052337646, -0.005809784, 0.030044556, 0.004020691, -0.0067443848, -0.01876831, 0.0018138885, 0.010925293, 0.014717102, -0.035583496, -0.009811401, 0.001162529, -0.000023186207, 0.022537231, -0.001627922, -0.009239197, 0.019332886, 0.048706055, 0.020401001, 0.021835327, 0.0022144318, 0.01586914, -0.0256958, 0.041259766, -0.021392822, -0.02456665, -0.0024700165, -0.016937256, -0.0061149597, 0.009353638, 0.03439331, -0.010101318, 0.027938843, -0.01576233, -0.0031433105, 0.011550903, 0.051361084, -0.022262573, -0.02027893, 0.033691406, 0.004558563, -0.023666382, -0.00054359436, -0.016921997, -0.022232056, -0.0061912537, 0.008522034, 0.004058838, -0.008529663, -0.017410278, -0.028884888, -0.000037372112, 0.03933716, 0.0132751465, 0.006023407, -0.06817627, -0.03201294, -0.014854431, -0.03302002, -0.013282776, -0.022537231, -0.044128418, -0.011291504, 0.009094238, -0.020462036, 0.02331543, 0.014282227, 0.007587433, -0.025360107, 0.015319824, -0.008636475, -0.028366089, -0.047576904, 0.009979248, 0.014846802, -0.014625549, 0.0287323, -0.014320374, -0.024368286, -0.0016012192, -0.015930176, -0.017044067, -0.029724121, -0.050354004, 0.027069092, -0.0059432983, 0.0027751923, -0.0039634705, -0.019897461, 0.0019950867, -0.032226562, 0.015853882, -0.008155823, -0.026901245, 0.034332275, -0.043151855, 0.0020008087, 0.011306763, 0.045318604, 0.024795532, 0.00039982796, -0.006511688, -0.0262146, -0.00944519, 0.00067567825, -0.017410278, 0.02154541, -0.0071868896, 0.017715454, -0.049072266, 0.04019165, -0.08477783, 0.020370483, -0.0041770935, -0.04550171, -0.017486572, -0.038604736, 0.014907837, 0.018920898, 0.0049934387, 0.017944336, 0.02532959, 0.003873825, -0.03677368, -0.07922363, -0.022613525, 0.017410278, -0.033447266, -0.052978516, 0.008132935, 0.01512146, -0.006717682, -0.011352539, 0.038879395, 0.055908203, -0.035949707, 0.021453857, 0.018035889, -0.036499023, 0.0030460358, -0.028930664, -0.062561035, 0.02357483, 0.010940552, -0.076660156, 0.00016272068, 0.02368164, -0.0020599365, 0.031311035, 0.003894806, 0.007888794, 0.004009247, -0.015823364, 0.00818634, 0.040008545, -0.0035953522, 0.027832031, -0.030410767, 0.016204834, -0.03137207, 0.0064888, 0.02015686, 0.06616211, -0.070739746, 0.03540039, -0.00598526, 0.024887085, -0.033691406, 0.007610321, -0.0061683655, 0.036071777, -0.037109375, -0.054595947, 0.0040245056, -0.019699097, 0.027420044, 0.0059432983, 0.03213501, 0.0043678284, 0.01638794, 0.025024414, -0.020996094, -0.046447754, 0.004096985, -0.011543274, 0.0034255981, 0.056518555, 0.0033817291, 0.0064926147, 0.0044403076, 0.0121536255, 0.0031871796, -0.020401001, 0.00018775463, -0.024002075, 0.02217102, -0.016540527, 0.00011277199, -0.0037288666, 0.00052547455, -0.0035896301, 0.008529663, -0.025115967, 0.024337769, -0.022369385, 0.018295288, -0.0071372986, -0.022338867, 0.011459351, -0.014045715, -0.019104004, -0.041381836, 0.12310791, -0.031921387, -0.00982666, -0.099609375, -0.0736084, -0.072143555, 0.010856628, -0.012229919, -0.06726074, 0.066345215, -0.02468872, 0.017044067, 0.08135986, -0.027923584, 0.024246216, -0.0501709, 0.015655518, -0.011047363, 0.015853882, -0.027679443, -0.0067443848, 0.042266846, 0.026290894, -0.012313843, -0.007980347, 0.02734375, 0.018127441, -0.034820557, -0.0017957687, -0.06518555, 0.0052108765, -0.032592773, 0.013473511, -0.0015363693, -0.008155823, 0.03933716, 0.040405273, 0.06274414, -0.019927979, 0.025665283, 0.08068848, -0.0034484863, 0.035888672, 0.059295654, -0.03265381, -0.023376465, 0.020629883, -0.024307251, -0.012466431, 0.03201294, 0.05355835, -0.03656006, 0.026931763, 0.031463623, -0.0046310425, -0.054626465, 0.046966553, -0.037200928, -0.053710938, -0.019744873, 0.002532959, -0.01789856, 0.03050232, 0.03555298, 0.018249512, -0.03060913, 0.005306244, 0.005142212, -0.0042686462, 0.011924744, 0.044555664, -0.06762695, -0.01737976, 0.037597656, -0.008148193, 0.019927979, 0.01789856, 0.040405273, 0.036590576, 0.03353882, -0.010307312, -0.0075950623, 0.008735657, -0.011650085, -0.009246826, -0.012710571, -0.005252838, -0.013061523, -0.03756714, -0.007183075, -0.011375427, -0.02720642, 0.01259613, -0.006164551, -0.02229309, -0.008331299, -0.027832031, -0.001033783, -0.013092041, -0.025283813, 0.00009089708, -0.0026187897, 0.00674057, -0.042510986, -0.008354187, 0.0066490173, 0.013137817, -0.03253174, -0.0011358261, -0.016189575, 0.010597229, -0.008255005, -0.027618408, 0.007369995, 0.026428223, 0.010597229, -0.05621338, -0.024978638, -0.009666443, -0.03866577, -0.025772095, 0.0037879944, 0.016784668, 0.008346558, 0.0024051666, -0.019042969, 0.052337646, -0.014564514, 0.0016584396, -0.018692017, -0.010292053, -0.024017334, 0.020004272, 0.08734131, 0.020736694, -0.0025997162, 0.08569336, 0.0395813, -0.0040130615, -0.0769043, 0.022735596, -0.009765625, 0.05078125, -0.0440979, 0.008178711, 0.011749268, 0.037078857, -0.018203735, -0.07531738, -0.034851074, -0.041900635, -0.0027503967, -0.0017690659, -0.006969452, 0.025238037, 0.035949707, -0.028640747, 0.011070251, -0.005519867, 0.002281189, -0.014503479, 0.022354126, 0.0012617111, 0.027450562, 0.0079193115, 0.062927246, -0.011070251, -0.04168701, -0.043945312, -0.007167816, 0.101867676, 0.029159546, -0.04727173, 0.010551453, 0.033477783, -0.027297974, -0.0049476624, 0.0076293945, -0.009101868, -0.01574707, -0.015419006, -0.020370483, -0.037139893, -0.017990112, -0.0023784637, 0.04144287, -0.04043579, -0.03112793, -0.0052452087, 0.0060424805, -0.014518738, -0.025665283, -0.017578125, 0.013038635, -0.02520752, -0.0009531975, 0.009857178, 0.008979797, -0.010444641, 0.010635376, -0.01864624, -0.0016355515, 0.002811432, 0.0071411133, 0.017440796, -0.018417358, 0.012229919, -0.004562378, -0.057739258, 0.008644104, -0.045074463, 0.024887085, -0.029968262, 0.029327393, 0.05529785, -0.015991211, 0.020370483, 0.030685425, 0.020126343, -0.013832092, 0.015235901, 0.03427124, 0.02420044, 0.015731812 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1910.09153v1
Entropic Dynamic Time Warping Kernels for Co-evolving Financial Time Series Analysis
Lu Bai, Lixin Cui, Lixiang Xu, Yue Wang, Zhihong Zhang, Edwin R. Hancock
q-fin.ST, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.LG
In this work, we develop a novel framework to measure the similarity between dynamic financial networks, i.e., time-varying financial networks. Particularly, we explore whether the proposed similarity measure can be employed to understand the structural evolution of the financial networks with time. For a set of time-varying financial networks with each vertex representing the individual time series of a different stock and each edge between a pair of time series representing the absolute value of their Pearson correlation, our start point is to compute the commute time matrix associated with the weighted adjacency matrix of the network structures, where each element of the matrix can be seen as the enhanced correlation value between pairwise stocks. For each network, we show how the commute time matrix allows us to identify a reliable set of dominant correlated time series as well as an associated dominant probability distribution of the stock belonging to this set. Furthermore, we represent each original network as a discrete dominant Shannon entropy time series computed from the dominant probability distribution. With the dominant entropy time series for each pair of financial networks to hand, we develop a similarity measure based on the classical dynamic time warping framework, for analyzing the financial time-varying networks. We show that the proposed similarity measure is positive definite and thus corresponds to a kernel measure on graphs. The proposed kernel bridges the gap between graph kernels and the classical dynamic time warping framework for multiple financial time series analysis. Experiments on time-varying networks extracted through New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) database demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.09153v1
"2019-10-21T05:08:09"
"2019-10-21T05:08:09"
{ "title": [ -0.036499023, 0.030593872, -0.052001953, -0.015434265, 0.028381348, -0.010910034, 0.009635925, -0.024734497, 0.0034294128, 0.046173096, -0.026809692, 0.021820068, -0.0073051453, 0.017562866, -0.07165527, -0.009864807, 0.014274597, 0.024475098, 0.011299133, -0.016799927, -0.0066223145, -0.024749756, 0.05126953, 0.018539429, 0.0496521, -0.018554688, -0.054779053, 0.028640747, 0.013374329, 0.0020599365, 0.016540527, -0.046020508, 0.032226562, 0.043670654, -0.011817932, 0.043304443, -0.045013428, 0.037506104, 0.0019721985, 0.007633209, 0.008811951, 0.0010223389, 0.005844116, -0.020629883, -0.019470215, 0.047912598, -0.06161499, -0.010528564, -0.03930664, 0.064697266, 0.030471802, 0.005622864, 0.016525269, 0.079711914, 0.018936157, -0.02319336, -0.0340271, 0.0034046173, 0.01776123, 0.078063965, 0.03878784, -0.02130127, -0.005874634, -0.021133423, -0.06161499, -0.023834229, 0.02229309, 0.009963989, 0.08630371, -0.031173706, -0.0060920715, 0.0770874, 0.020904541, -0.018661499, -0.016311646, -0.0079956055, 0.042633057, 0.018478394, 0.0063095093, -0.038116455, -0.013008118, -0.033081055, -0.009597778, -0.031982422, 0.020523071, -0.034118652, -0.012428284, -0.00030326843, -0.009414673, -0.028167725, -0.014862061, 0.0020256042, -0.014404297, 0.017959595, -0.01158905, -0.016647339, -0.026748657, 0.0131073, -0.037475586, -0.018615723, -0.014709473, 0.012359619, -0.02458191, -0.0025691986, 0.015777588, 0.004016876, -0.016479492, -0.021499634, 0.029556274, 0.023529053, -0.010223389, 0.03845215, 0.011184692, -0.012184143, 0.011245728, 0.024291992, 0.009292603, 0.04208374, 0.022949219, 0.042541504, -0.0010547638, -0.0016498566, -0.0051498413, -0.025604248, 0.016494751, -0.027359009, -0.01399231, -0.0107040405, 0.00036144257, 0.04815674, 0.012687683, 0.006542206, -0.0949707, -0.04458618, -0.029510498, 0.018295288, 0.02809143, -0.013656616, -0.02331543, -0.02935791, 0.034698486, -0.011177063, -0.0158844, 0.013252258, 0.015411377, 0.00289917, 0.050750732, 0.0016479492, -0.025344849, 0.013343811, -0.048095703, 0.03086853, 0.018920898, -0.022338867, -0.019836426, -0.025604248, -0.080322266, -0.007904053, 0.03540039, -0.010505676, -0.0052719116, -0.028762817, -0.062469482, 0.023986816, 0.018737793, 0.024154663, 0.06262207, 0.03643799, 0.022659302, 0.026260376, -0.00065612793, -0.02507019, 0.04724121, 0.027252197, 0.0051498413, 0.051330566, 0.013931274, 0.001619339, 0.023208618, -0.008552551, 0.007843018, -0.018951416, 0.001458168, 0.025634766, -0.032409668, -0.021530151, 0.000954628, -0.012702942, 0.025390625, 0.016738892, -0.027740479, 0.033172607, -0.077819824, 0.0107421875, 0.0071411133, 0.011299133, -0.0135650635, 0.025741577, 0.006614685, -0.039093018, -0.038116455, 0.026123047, -0.060180664, 0.032318115, -0.07348633, 0.004371643, -0.030807495, 0.039642334, -0.03652954, 0.03729248, 0.0569458, -0.0046958923, -0.05419922, 0.045959473, 0.011146545, -0.028747559, 0.015960693, -0.011917114, -0.018417358, -0.01979065, -0.022094727, -0.0033874512, -0.021438599, 0.03062439, 0.0087509155, 0.005443573, 0.010223389, -0.031585693, 0.08508301, 0.009246826, 0.10089111, -0.04977417, -0.0037326813, -0.034301758, -0.05645752, -0.02558899, -0.07476807, -0.012359619, 0.0044288635, 0.04437256, 0.01159668, 0.025222778, 0.013511658, 0.0087509155, 0.04421997, -0.001832962, 0.025878906, -0.0135269165, 0.0049324036, 0.0024471283, 0.07470703, 0.014152527, 0.035186768, 0.017105103, 0.008705139, 0.03994751, -0.02418518, 0.039978027, -0.0345459, 0.004016876, -0.0076675415, 0.011100769, 0.029922485, -0.018829346, -0.04171753, 0.0006337166, -0.02532959, 0.0055503845, 0.004562378, -0.01878357, 0.033172607, -0.0068626404, 0.0054626465, -0.011940002, 0.0053901672, -0.007129669, -0.016586304, 0.0015821457, 0.011024475, -0.037841797, 0.0039520264, 0.039642334, 0.031204224, -0.020904541, 0.0034980774, -0.01461792, 0.005897522, -0.004348755, 0.032165527, 0.031143188, 0.060272217, 0.039031982, 0.02229309, 0.01713562, 0.012481689, -0.0023841858, 0.05532837, 0.041625977, 0.00667572, 0.027633667, -0.0670166, 0.017486572, 0.009918213, 0.017227173, 0.011489868, 0.039855957, 0.026535034, -0.019485474, -0.046661377, 0.032196045, -0.099853516, 0.0013093948, -0.010749817, -0.050354004, -0.033569336, -0.03225708, -0.019317627, -0.032989502, -0.020355225, 0.007255554, 0.010292053, -0.02885437, -0.026000977, -0.0059394836, 0.0023651123, -0.0001475811, 0.0007944107, -0.025756836, 0.0038013458, 0.030319214, 0.030044556, 0.010238647, -0.04373169, -0.015037537, 0.006351471, 0.0051460266, 0.007949829, 0.035217285, -0.0068359375, -0.018554688, 0.0013389587, -0.013801575, 0.021392822, 0.001033783, 0.004585266, -0.034973145, 0.009483337, 0.03111267, 0.0013570786, -0.00021517277, 0.013771057, -0.039794922, -0.05783081, -0.011581421, 0.028152466, -0.0072517395, 0.020553589, 0.0473938, 0.03112793, -0.00033020973, 0.0084991455, 0.0317688, -0.0030822754, -0.08282471, 0.0010824203, -0.0390625, -0.043273926, -0.01637268, -0.031402588, 0.047851562, -0.039093018, -0.013893127, -0.016357422, -0.013587952, -0.015510559, 0.011161804, -0.016708374, -0.03982544, -0.017410278, -0.026290894, 0.004737854, 0.007637024, -0.022445679, -0.0051002502, 0.10290527, -0.0127334595, 0.005580902, 0.036743164, 0.010787964, 0.00025749207, -0.046203613, -0.045684814, -0.078430176, 0.010185242, -0.0034561157, -0.003047943, 0.02279663, -0.038604736, -0.10357666, 0.0007247925, 0.07897949, 0.009742737, -0.023880005, 0.049682617, -0.05758667, 0.040039062, 0.02017212, -0.0026397705, 0.020324707, 0.06384277, -0.03591919, -0.0042037964, -0.03640747, -0.011352539, 0.0035324097, -0.0027980804, -0.0736084, 0.029632568, -0.04019165, -0.03781128, 0.023330688, -0.0736084, -0.010795593, -0.0029773712, -0.018875122, -0.0073661804, 0.048980713, 0.029418945, 0.0074920654, -0.0017309189, 0.0010604858, -0.030715942, -0.03427124, -0.07324219, -0.009513855, -0.02229309, -0.010368347, 0.020507812, -0.026016235, 0.02217102, -0.029388428, -0.004711151, -0.006462097, 0.020446777, -0.003314972, -0.035583496, -0.005077362, -0.0143585205, 0.043914795, 0.01210022, -0.005142212, -0.017181396, 0.032470703, -0.007789612, -0.037384033, -0.050476074, 0.0015659332, -0.014198303, -0.027877808, -0.016799927, -0.008605957, 0.00340271, -0.074157715, -0.02885437, 0.008171082, 0.009025574, 0.030960083, 0.008018494, -0.010772705, -0.003704071, -0.0049095154, -0.0056152344, -0.01977539, -0.0013847351, 0.0030021667, -0.0019426346, -0.02015686, 0.029037476, -0.01473999, 0.0010557175, 0.040100098, -0.0146865845, -0.0010919571, -0.07165527, 0.010765076, -0.0011491776, -0.10974121, -0.0054016113, 0.033294678, -0.07800293, -0.047180176, -0.04574585, 0.0050239563, -0.008934021, 0.0050811768, -0.027648926, -0.016723633, -0.0077171326, -0.01638794, -0.076049805, -0.033172607, 0.07904053, 0.06774902, 0.033447266, -0.027313232, 0.008842468, 0.025177002, -0.046447754, -0.010139465, -0.048034668, 0.029586792, -0.04296875, 0.03967285, 0.04083252, -0.017868042, 0.028823853, 0.03829956, 0.021133423, 0.005794525, -0.0038833618, 0.0005245209, 0.006793976, 0.0055770874, 0.07501221, -0.044799805, -0.013404846, -0.02960205, -0.019515991, -0.018112183, 0.006351471, 0.009109497, 0.0043029785, 0.018478394, -0.0059013367, 0.018508911, 0.004058838, -0.0209198, 0.00087070465, 0.026306152, 0.0037631989, -0.037475586, -0.029144287, 0.032470703, 0.03741455, 0.036193848, 0.010864258, 0.02355957, 0.05532837, -0.04714966, 0.027267456, -0.038269043, -0.007980347, -0.025314331, -0.0017871857, -0.045440674, -0.048065186, -0.019195557, 0.022583008, -0.012466431, 0.033203125, 0.020202637, 0.040222168, -0.05340576, -0.005710602, 0.072631836, 0.00060892105, 0.017593384, -0.016479492, 0.0149002075, -0.011375427, -0.047668457, -0.026245117, 0.00907135, -0.0024585724, 0.041015625, -0.006275177, -0.012825012, 0.0045700073, 0.013305664, 0.024810791, 0.07092285, -0.021575928, -0.044158936, 0.021621704, 0.00020706654, 0.006767273, 0.011711121, 0.041656494, 0.0035953522, 0.0025253296, -0.011497498, -0.023452759, 0.0041618347, 0.011604309, -0.009269714, -0.07208252, 0.04864502, -0.021850586, 0.06463623, 0.0068473816, 0.033966064, -0.0028686523, 0.024093628, -0.022994995, -0.01448822, -0.0032424927, 0.020233154, 0.035461426, 0.011581421, 0.050445557, -0.0002706051, -0.013153076, 0.010177612, -0.016601562, 0.032104492, 0.022827148, -0.0004930496, 0.03100586, -0.019683838, -0.02406311, 0.008674622, 0.0022354126, 0.041900635, -0.034301758, 0.017807007, 0.0068740845, 0.021514893, 0.028274536, -0.029556274, 0.017852783, -0.006549835, 0.003112793, -0.06915283, -0.062164307, -0.016067505, 0.02760315, -0.00554657, -0.01889038, 0.034332275, 0.052612305, 0.056274414, 0.04675293, 0.035491943, -0.005596161, -0.031082153, 0.008651733, 0.014671326, -0.018814087, -0.020217896, -0.0072898865, 0.026748657, 0.02848816, -0.068481445, 0.0423584, -0.028915405, 0.01902771, 0.0065231323, -0.012779236, 0.014091492, -0.058258057, 0.018234253, 0.04928589, -0.020492554, 0.013420105, -0.010726929, 0.044158936, 0.057525635, 0.048187256, 0.047332764, -0.019515991, 0.033935547, -0.021865845, 0.0027637482, -0.008842468, 0.023422241, 0.02180481, 0.00793457, 0.005153656, 0.034210205, -0.05392456, 0.023910522, 0.010345459, -0.0345459, 0.022994995, -0.021575928, 0.002254486, 0.020996094, 0.012916565, 0.022949219, -0.0027656555, -0.028625488, -0.021240234, -0.0023593903, -0.032470703, 0.020721436, 0.02041626, -0.020584106, -0.070739746, 0.012130737, -0.03994751, 0.0037498474, -0.019882202, 0.018997192, -0.039367676, 0.037109375, 0.033447266, -0.041412354, -0.019897461, 0.011756897, 0.018508911, 0.025970459, 0.013267517, -0.033203125, -0.015602112, 0.00029182434, -0.033843994, -0.01751709, 0.02810669, 0.022476196, -0.01373291, -0.021881104, 0.016952515, -0.008460999, -0.03314209, 0.005378723, 0.038513184, -0.05847168, 0.03479004, 0.01158905, 0.038970947, -0.029525757, -0.01826477, 0.046783447, -0.02986145, -0.031463623, -0.02204895, 0.02848816, -0.042541504, -0.029815674, -0.010276794, -0.052001953, 0.012298584, 0.0038414001, 0.003982544, -0.06970215, -0.021636963, 0.008071899, -0.03829956, -0.019577026, -0.042419434, 0.060516357, -0.01991272, -0.045837402, -0.027435303, 0.0012950897, -0.01965332, 0.0703125, 0.013076782, -0.03277588, -0.032714844, -0.02557373, -0.007247925, 0.032226562, 0.0027179718, -0.024887085, 0.002161026, -0.052093506, 0.0060043335, -0.021499634, -0.032714844, -0.028839111, 0.046447754, 0.032165527, 0.01184845, -0.01423645, -0.055145264, -0.010505676, 0.0060920715, 0.01953125, -0.01398468, -0.009017944, -0.005088806, -0.010940552, 0.017211914, 0.0030345917, -0.0003466606, 0.01737976, -0.017105103, -0.007171631, 0.017593384, -0.058654785, 0.05291748, 0.026107788, 0.011306763, 0.019042969, 0.025375366, 0.012306213, -0.0015363693, -0.010131836, -0.033294678, -0.010917664, -0.015319824, -0.051696777, -0.051208496, -0.034606934, -0.06719971, 0.025939941, 0.008270264, 0.030136108, 0.028564453, -0.0021533966, 0.011962891, 0.028335571, 0.021011353, 0.03289795, 0.05126953, 0.013786316, 0.00052547455, -0.0039596558, 0.025100708, 0.011459351, 0.0060272217, 0.0056991577, 0.027664185, -0.017303467, -0.002822876, 0.0013046265, 0.0077590942, 0.015205383, -0.0063438416, -0.005836487, -0.027267456, 0.03515625, -0.019088745, 0.028503418, 0.04525757, 0.017333984, 0.016815186, -0.030578613, -0.0019702911, 0.022537231, -0.06707764, 0.047607422, 0.054748535, -0.057922363, -0.008285522, -0.040649414, -0.028274536, -0.006679535, 0.0058403015, 0.047180176, -0.075683594, -0.047576904, 0.033843994, 0.04675293, -0.0093307495, 0.011199951, -0.04724121, -0.018066406, 0.02053833, 0.024383545, -0.01612854, -0.045318604, -0.020126343, 0.014511108, 0.015090942, 0.03857422, -0.014564514, 0.061645508, -0.018173218, 0.034179688, -0.06573486, 0.016540527, -0.041870117, -0.0259552, -0.011680603, 0.010910034, -0.031402588, -0.042999268, 0.09320068, 0.03982544, 0.03527832, 0.055389404, -0.006504059, -0.012916565, 0.028671265, -0.051513672, 0.03213501, 0.023468018, -0.014312744, -0.0059127808, 0.005104065, -0.0127334595, 0.033111572, 0.012649536, 0.04055786, -0.06762695, 0.036071777, -0.018325806, 0.0027179718, 0.026916504, -0.042816162, -0.033416748, 0.015098572, -0.05444336, -0.005241394, 0.022827148, -0.0026397705, -0.046722412, -0.020904541, 0.044769287, -0.007286072, -0.008232117, 0.0053749084, -0.013839722, -0.01965332, -0.024749756, -0.022842407, 0.02558899, -0.023971558, -0.013786316, -0.042266846, 0.02229309, 0.0042152405, 0.018585205, 0.01146698, 0.00034689903, -0.05581665, 0.0025405884, 0.0068092346, -0.0012187958, -0.016403198, -0.015586853, 0.015914917, 0.020492554, -0.020202637, -0.051086426, 0.011779785, -0.014602661, -0.06939697, -0.027709961, -0.026550293, 0.017562866, 0.068725586, 0.0037345886, 0.023468018, 0.021148682, 0.0053100586, 0.0025596619, 0.023956299, 0.025222778, -0.008583069, -0.072509766, 0.01259613, 0.04949951, 0.043182373, -0.005214691, 0.010803223, 0.05493164, 0.007457733, -0.0357666, 0.048736572, 0.009529114, 0.0067367554, 0.04171753, 0.02999878, -0.0042304993, -0.04373169, -0.07373047, -0.06976318, 0.033477783, 0.029846191, 0.0035495758, -0.02218628, 0.05960083, 0.008796692, -0.0127334595, -0.008460999, -0.028564453, -0.009819031, -0.0026359558, 0.00869751, -0.0035247803, -0.0032901764, 0.05090332, 0.013221741, -0.0068130493, 0.031173706, -0.033599854, -0.0126953125, 0.00207901, 0.0026302338, -0.045074463, 0.013008118, 0.003118515, 0.013618469, -0.002796173, 0.0011529922, -0.009353638, 0.044891357, -0.02935791, -0.008308411, 0.0070610046, -0.0140686035, -0.016616821, -0.02104187, 0.025772095, -0.024276733, -0.029968262, 0.039916992, -0.015327454, 0.0362854, -0.07104492, 0.0075531006, -0.06756592, -0.024887085, 0.009460449, 0.025512695, 0.039093018, -0.0048599243, -0.03942871, -0.03579712, 0.031066895, -0.02281189 ], "summary": [ -0.01991272, 0.014457703, -0.05230713, 0.044311523, 0.0046310425, -0.018997192, 0.013305664, -0.037506104, -0.0023078918, 0.04147339, -0.030456543, 0.0049934387, -0.0075645447, -0.0010185242, -0.048461914, -0.025146484, 0.03201294, -0.027694702, 0.0368042, 0.0009627342, -0.002286911, 0.012489319, 0.07043457, -0.046844482, 0.020996094, -0.013420105, 0.101867676, 0.026916504, 0.059295654, 0.036987305, 0.04824829, -0.11517334, -0.029449463, 0.04815674, 0.008331299, -0.04220581, -0.016326904, 0.028442383, 0.009941101, 0.001376152, 0.035491943, -0.011627197, 0.11218262, -0.04550171, 0.017211914, 0.062561035, 0.0056037903, -0.023727417, 0.03567505, 0.027648926, 0.01525116, -0.015930176, 0.010314941, 0.06604004, -0.054718018, -0.03857422, -0.077941895, 0.029663086, 0.019134521, 0.06036377, 0.031707764, -0.015350342, -0.015029907, -0.025268555, -0.06604004, 0.026550293, -0.0009045601, -0.018966675, 0.06695557, -0.054840088, -0.038208008, 0.041992188, 0.024398804, -0.048217773, 0.011428833, 0.0054512024, -0.008163452, 0.0021781921, -0.0010519028, -0.0019721985, -0.031951904, 0.0018968582, -0.021697998, -0.012245178, -0.03012085, -0.008621216, -0.03765869, 0.004501343, 0.006084442, -0.018157959, -0.015350342, 0.049865723, -0.029968262, 0.018188477, -0.005973816, -0.027282715, -0.0071525574, -0.00060606, -0.018676758, -0.025360107, -0.024658203, -0.0051116943, -0.02986145, -0.006832123, -0.004180908, -0.022827148, 0.0135269165, 0.01927185, 0.016418457, 0.024169922, -0.036376953, 0.02456665, 0.016021729, 0.010032654, -0.028686523, 0.022720337, -0.010986328, 0.03463745, 0.0017585754, 0.05429077, 0.0009126663, 0.029266357, -0.02645874, 0.00995636, -0.006801605, -0.01940918, 0.015914917, -0.014846802, 0.016082764, 0.0026931763, -0.00724411, 0.014053345, -0.02230835, 0.019805908, -0.0029354095, 0.000067174435, 0.028793335, -0.017227173, -0.0043144226, -0.026123047, 0.04421997, 0.009529114, -0.009155273, 0.021484375, -0.023010254, 0.028915405, 0.009979248, 0.005580902, -0.006465912, -0.020019531, -0.016525269, 0.0039711, 0.044799805, -0.032073975, -0.031204224, -0.033325195, -0.039398193, -0.0036716461, 0.02935791, -0.016830444, 0.024871826, -0.0038452148, -0.050354004, 0.033721924, -0.0069122314, -0.008773804, 0.056030273, 0.025756836, 0.018188477, -0.015655518, 0.0134887695, -0.003396988, 0.03656006, -0.010307312, -0.0061416626, 0.008865356, -0.013442993, -0.01209259, 0.016143799, 0.023803711, 0.0052986145, -0.019317627, -0.027191162, 0.027297974, -0.023223877, -0.023391724, 0.016799927, 0.025756836, 0.018051147, 0.016983032, 0.023208618, 0.0044059753, -0.030776978, 0.007572174, -0.03152466, 0.044921875, -0.034698486, 0.054656982, -0.033477783, -0.036712646, 0.02671814, -0.001326561, -0.017196655, 0.015083313, -0.030929565, -0.020721436, 0.001045227, -0.0033512115, -0.058898926, -0.024627686, 0.060058594, -0.0038967133, -0.03753662, -0.0032310486, -0.006286621, -0.0041046143, 0.02432251, -0.07928467, -0.016693115, -0.057556152, -0.038635254, 0.07867432, -0.077697754, 0.058135986, -0.007484436, -0.01928711, -0.022003174, -0.021621704, -0.024246216, -0.000600338, 0.02470398, 0.013458252, -0.015365601, -0.024627686, -0.026031494, 0.008613586, 0.0057754517, -0.04510498, 0.009552002, 0.02809143, 0.009269714, 0.020858765, -0.021850586, 0.00071287155, -0.04135132, -0.033050537, 0.030792236, -0.0053520203, -0.033233643, 0.045928955, 0.051239014, 0.031829834, -0.017852783, -0.003238678, -0.0003736019, 0.021942139, 0.009803772, 0.06567383, -0.036956787, 0.020019531, -0.029922485, -0.00073719025, 0.03439331, -0.020980835, 0.029586792, -0.01902771, -0.0066452026, -0.008346558, 0.0037193298, -0.014953613, 0.011367798, -0.080566406, -0.010131836, 0.012290955, -0.021011353, -0.017440796, -0.010604858, 0.008934021, 0.00044322014, -0.019348145, -0.017715454, 0.03466797, -0.0064353943, -0.008705139, -0.008605957, 0.0039711, 0.015235901, 0.000023901463, 0.011962891, 0.05682373, 0.05630493, -0.005962372, -0.026306152, 0.033355713, -0.026489258, -0.018173218, -0.06744385, 0.009986877, 0.0074272156, -0.009864807, -0.028381348, 0.058166504, 0.018112183, 0.015022278, -0.0038318634, 0.041809082, 0.0047340393, -0.03366089, -0.03253174, 0.001115799, -0.072631836, -0.023605347, 0.001121521, -0.03729248, 0.015777588, -0.0046806335, -0.00020813942, -0.019226074, -0.009994507, -0.014297485, 0.03463745, -0.016815186, -0.034942627, 0.0023040771, -0.014022827, 0.0004069805, 0.015357971, -0.024429321, -0.0395813, -0.0019273758, -0.036193848, -0.053833008, -0.07098389, 0.027359009, 0.0049972534, 0.03213501, 0.016952515, -0.0035858154, 0.003490448, 0.0072746277, 0.031951904, -0.00041508675, 0.016418457, -0.009490967, 0.019454956, 0.0056381226, 0.048706055, 0.023010254, 0.0074501038, 0.034301758, -0.029708862, -0.07098389, -0.029541016, 0.032806396, 0.033325195, -0.032440186, 0.007724762, 0.06573486, 0.046051025, 0.0078048706, 0.004825592, 0.018829346, -0.014533997, -0.051635742, -0.020614624, -0.008224487, -0.01473999, 0.015823364, -0.02482605, -0.011909485, -0.019989014, -0.01751709, -0.019104004, 0.008132935, 0.010231018, 0.019744873, 0.033721924, -0.017044067, -0.0154953, 0.000052928925, -0.00095415115, 0.0028762817, -0.0064353943, -0.009780884, 0.04925537, -0.029373169, -0.03353882, 0.052124023, 0.02330017, 0.018676758, -0.022735596, -0.010940552, -0.037322998, -0.029052734, -0.010971069, -0.001364708, 0.045928955, 0.03353882, -0.002073288, -0.028656006, 0.06213379, 0.023864746, 0.022003174, 0.028839111, -0.050598145, 0.056121826, 0.044677734, 0.026748657, 0.024017334, 0.03488159, -0.007507324, -0.016418457, 0.00010806322, -0.00932312, -0.0020694733, -0.0023498535, 0.06011963, 0.039154053, -0.07891846, -0.064453125, 0.061553955, -0.0011692047, 0.011619568, -0.037963867, 0.012298584, 0.018707275, 0.00033664703, -0.006374359, 0.0045700073, 0.03717041, 0.017929077, 0.00027298927, -0.023605347, -0.059906006, -0.03050232, -0.066345215, -0.022872925, -0.014770508, -0.007408142, -0.019073486, 0.000023066998, -0.023757935, 0.017944336, 0.029525757, 0.019226074, -0.015655518, -0.031066895, -0.0018873215, 0.01878357, 0.061065674, -0.033477783, -0.004760742, 0.017929077, 0.018432617, -0.039215088, -0.044647217, -0.016616821, 0.002286911, -0.007843018, -0.02722168, -0.027374268, 0.0011415482, -0.06542969, -0.029403687, -0.004032135, 0.031799316, -0.00016725063, 0.005680084, -0.017944336, -0.019485474, -0.009803772, -0.016204834, -0.004573822, -0.022521973, 0.004676819, -0.0007171631, 0.025405884, -0.01424408, 0.027542114, -0.0071258545, -0.0085372925, -0.0034923553, -0.027755737, -0.031463623, -0.011268616, 0.006175995, -0.03567505, -0.008705139, 0.00497818, -0.021408081, 0.022842407, 0.0023994446, 0.037017822, 0.02218628, 0.023803711, -0.0463562, -0.027801514, 0.07556152, 0.008796692, -0.08917236, 0.049194336, -0.012580872, 0.046173096, 0.029785156, -0.07489014, 0.016494751, 0.07495117, -0.021774292, 0.009727478, -0.037200928, 0.022323608, -0.042175293, 0.061157227, 0.032836914, -0.015182495, 0.028686523, 0.033447266, -0.0077056885, 0.03543091, -0.0013628006, 0.044281006, 0.03439331, 0.016693115, 0.0206604, 0.0134887695, -0.020523071, 0.0063095093, -0.030715942, 0.008766174, 0.015823364, 0.038330078, 0.016159058, 0.0006709099, -0.0021762848, -0.0027542114, -0.034210205, -0.029937744, -0.0054626465, 0.031311035, 0.037750244, -0.0413208, -0.06591797, 0.008148193, 0.06628418, 0.020309448, -0.004501343, -0.037078857, 0.023269653, -0.037017822, 0.055480957, -0.050476074, -0.070129395, -0.017700195, -0.0032444, 0.03050232, -0.044830322, -0.02571106, -0.022094727, 0.00071048737, 0.013626099, 0.008369446, 0.05291748, -0.047454834, -0.032928467, -0.036346436, 0.0031356812, 0.028305054, 0.0028514862, -0.015914917, -0.0040359497, -0.027130127, -0.030410767, 0.0032730103, -0.0021324158, 0.001745224, -0.008071899, -0.015396118, -0.0045204163, 0.03604126, 0.032165527, 0.0047302246, -0.027709961, -0.032562256, -0.07562256, 0.0015563965, 0.016815186, -0.0126953125, 0.013641357, -0.014602661, -0.0068855286, -0.025390625, -0.010444641, 0.003458023, 0.034698486, -0.068359375, -0.048736572, 0.0061454773, 0.002538681, 0.090026855, -0.020690918, -0.013038635, 0.008712769, 0.023483276, -0.013313293, 0.0017433167, -0.0016117096, -0.042144775, 0.041656494, -0.005935669, 0.050842285, -0.027938843, -0.008773804, 0.015068054, -0.027999878, 0.03857422, 0.03604126, -0.019241333, 0.025115967, 0.0118255615, 0.009887695, 0.009315491, -0.0074539185, 0.019927979, -0.016906738, -0.04260254, 0.021774292, 0.015060425, 0.010673523, -0.02947998, 0.013442993, 0.016693115, -0.007827759, -0.051086426, -0.048461914, -0.03250122, 0.045166016, -0.0030841827, -0.013664246, 0.011650085, 0.00969696, 0.010314941, 0.038085938, 0.010627747, -0.02659607, 0.01612854, -0.019226074, -0.021057129, -0.012313843, 0.0031700134, -0.033477783, -0.00031208992, 0.017196655, -0.008636475, -0.021194458, 0.03439331, -0.011276245, -0.01979065, -0.02017212, -0.00095272064, -0.030776978, -0.023010254, 0.0069007874, -0.04977417, 0.04220581, 0.013587952, 0.0104599, 0.07635498, 0.024398804, 0.028167725, -0.054229736, -0.000446558, 0.012207031, -0.01109314, -0.03793335, 0.010429382, -0.024597168, 0.012756348, 0.0055770874, -0.009292603, -0.057373047, 0.005180359, 0.020309448, 0.033935547, -0.020065308, -0.03363037, 0.050201416, -0.04586792, -0.023544312, 0.03213501, 0.04031372, -0.007926941, -0.023269653, 0.03314209, -0.016525269, -0.00071144104, 0.020141602, -0.008804321, -0.053833008, -0.013130188, -0.0015363693, 0.035308838, -0.021606445, 0.013511658, -0.025680542, -0.015312195, 0.026672363, -0.015258789, 0.02558899, -0.018127441, 0.015655518, 0.008659363, -0.0036411285, -0.039398193, -0.009490967, 0.003780365, -0.022018433, -0.013755798, 0.01737976, 0.0046424866, -0.0021705627, -0.037475586, 0.0076904297, 0.03086853, -0.07611084, -0.026641846, 0.09765625, -0.045410156, 0.0007042885, 0.009292603, 0.030532837, -0.011054993, -0.067993164, 0.011039734, -0.011154175, -0.00037264824, -0.044708252, 0.048950195, 0.018341064, 0.007888794, 0.0065231323, -0.051483154, 0.014472961, 0.008857727, 0.014892578, -0.017578125, -0.018707275, -0.0104904175, -0.0029716492, -0.032714844, -0.022949219, 0.023498535, -0.015007019, -0.018096924, -0.03579712, 0.02192688, -0.04437256, 0.015342712, 0.0029239655, 0.001666069, -0.0056648254, -0.043884277, 0.0068893433, -0.0020580292, 0.009117126, -0.0021018982, 0.019348145, -0.071899414, -0.029830933, 0.023925781, -0.03111267, -0.010826111, 0.045898438, 0.03378296, 0.042755127, -0.04623413, -0.068237305, 0.019256592, 0.011459351, 0.00920105, -0.06762695, -0.05267334, -0.006214142, 0.008132935, 0.061065674, 0.018920898, -0.009056091, -0.025665283, 0.020553589, -0.024291992, -0.0262146, -0.012138367, 0.03842163, 0.04296875, 0.026397705, -0.019943237, -0.029556274, 0.054656982, 0.029174805, 0.0053710938, -0.023742676, -0.007621765, 0.002790451, -0.09875488, -0.08105469, -0.04736328, -0.015083313, 0.056274414, -0.062683105, -0.020812988, 0.0637207, -0.014732361, 0.021530151, -0.011497498, -0.043945312, 0.0063285828, -0.004787445, 0.011688232, 0.003862381, -0.034606934, -0.018737793, 0.012176514, 0.019622803, 0.01828003, 0.0051345825, 0.028457642, -0.04547119, 0.018997192, 0.045928955, -0.004398346, -0.03024292, 0.02607727, -0.034301758, -0.020492554, -0.000957489, -0.0011415482, -0.017745972, 0.0065345764, 0.09814453, -0.016235352, -0.0035171509, 0.035888672, -0.033721924, 0.036590576, 0.03488159, -0.013031006, -0.031280518, -0.012680054, -0.022079468, 0.02330017, -0.06341553, 0.10369873, -0.10461426, -0.066589355, 0.03955078, 0.04296875, -0.041503906, -0.02520752, -0.04135132, 0.021820068, 0.026809692, -0.020568848, 0.015396118, -0.048736572, -0.021987915, 0.012306213, 0.033233643, 0.058410645, -0.0024433136, 0.043518066, 0.00969696, 0.025848389, -0.061920166, -0.022155762, -0.0070533752, -0.0151901245, -0.04046631, 0.023269653, 0.023864746, -0.017211914, 0.06274414, 0.05834961, 0.06591797, 0.05014038, -0.04147339, 0.018371582, 0.064941406, -0.018203735, 0.03729248, -0.010719299, 0.014022827, 0.0046958923, 0.011634827, 0.032836914, 0.029388428, 0.05630493, -0.012290955, -0.024795532, 0.039001465, -0.023468018, -0.0013217926, 0.007865906, -0.037109375, -0.017959595, 0.013145447, -0.077819824, 0.025924683, 0.010513306, 0.003824234, 0.013618469, -0.03164673, -0.000813961, 0.023925781, -0.0044021606, 0.0069389343, 0.0013532639, -0.01940918, -0.005432129, -0.0027980804, 0.049316406, 0.00059890747, -0.048065186, -0.009811401, -0.017593384, 0.01663208, 0.07525635, 0.017562866, 0.04421997, -0.059936523, -0.016723633, -0.012992859, -0.024398804, -0.0335083, -0.011024475, 0.023468018, 0.03479004, -0.01348114, -0.053009033, -0.0066070557, -0.0042686462, -0.029586792, -0.019744873, -0.024917603, -0.009750366, 0.052886963, -0.0050468445, 0.0121536255, 0.024017334, -0.03375244, -0.034484863, -0.0016422272, 0.008872986, 0.010314941, -0.041931152, 0.015686035, 0.023345947, 0.05697632, 0.01676941, 0.06665039, 0.031921387, -0.026550293, 0.0036373138, 0.050323486, 0.01663208, 0.0259552, -0.031066895, 0.055114746, -0.02217102, -0.044067383, -0.026535034, -0.04937744, -0.0077400208, 0.0055007935, -0.0007786751, -0.03793335, 0.038116455, 0.013893127, 0.0016889572, -0.005317688, -0.036224365, -0.022903442, 0.006755829, -0.0031089783, -0.00484848, 0.012184143, 0.092163086, -0.01373291, -0.012077332, -0.021026611, -0.02684021, -0.029541016, -0.034973145, -0.054504395, -0.0075569153, 0.040252686, -0.025344849, -0.026672363, 0.018249512, -0.037139893, 0.00592041, 0.030944824, -0.002401352, -0.018585205, 0.004234314, -0.038513184, -0.0052261353, -0.017822266, -0.02432251, -0.0060195923, 0.004573822, 0.0033111572, -0.001329422, 0.027404785, -0.053649902, -0.017623901, -0.041503906, -0.040374756, 0.010192871, -0.015014648, 0.013946533, -0.019058228, 0.025177002, -0.015609741, 0.004627228, 0.013175964 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1910.12903v5
IPGuard: Protecting Intellectual Property of Deep Neural Networks via Fingerprinting the Classification Boundary
Xiaoyu Cao, Jinyuan Jia, Neil Zhenqiang Gong
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
A deep neural network (DNN) classifier represents a model owner's intellectual property as training a DNN classifier often requires lots of resource. Watermarking was recently proposed to protect the intellectual property of DNN classifiers. However, watermarking suffers from a key limitation: it sacrifices the utility/accuracy of the model owner's classifier because it tampers the classifier's training or fine-tuning process. In this work, we propose IPGuard, the first method to protect intellectual property of DNN classifiers that provably incurs no accuracy loss for the classifiers. Our key observation is that a DNN classifier can be uniquely represented by its classification boundary. Based on this observation, IPGuard extracts some data points near the classification boundary of the model owner's classifier and uses them to fingerprint the classifier. A DNN classifier is said to be a pirated version of the model owner's classifier if they predict the same labels for most fingerprinting data points. IPGuard is qualitatively different from watermarking. Specifically, IPGuard extracts fingerprinting data points near the classification boundary of a classifier that is already trained, while watermarking embeds watermarks into a classifier during its training or fine-tuning process. We extensively evaluate IPGuard on CIFAR-10, CIFAR-100, and ImageNet datasets. Our results show that IPGuard can robustly identify post-processed versions of the model owner's classifier as pirated versions of the classifier, and IPGuard can identify classifiers, which are not the model owner's classifier nor its post-processed versions, as non-pirated versions of the classifier.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.12903v5
"2020-10-31T15:19:17"
"2019-10-28T18:39:49"
{ "title": [ -0.00605011, 0.011627197, -0.04916382, -0.038360596, 0.028625488, -0.030151367, 0.00749588, -0.0211792, -0.042419434, 0.007659912, -0.02230835, 0.019561768, -0.038208008, -0.020080566, -0.02923584, -0.02619934, -0.023071289, 0.036712646, -0.0082092285, -0.029541016, 0.005142212, -0.046844482, 0.046813965, -0.029876709, 0.04159546, -0.064086914, -0.058502197, 0.00995636, -0.0075035095, -0.04333496, 0.007381439, 0.03845215, 0.037261963, 0.028930664, -0.026275635, 0.033325195, -0.05593872, 0.03842163, 0.01600647, -0.013786316, 0.014457703, -0.008232117, -0.014083862, -0.0155181885, -0.021652222, 0.025100708, -0.054656982, -0.031829834, -0.024902344, 0.07696533, 0.028167725, 0.017791748, -0.009056091, 0.085754395, 0.022872925, -0.032165527, -0.005580902, -0.033050537, 0.04788208, 0.0703125, 0.030166626, -0.06402588, 0.011146545, -0.051879883, -0.021255493, -0.023971558, 0.008163452, 0.016204834, 0.051208496, 0.0076141357, 0.0046958923, 0.028961182, 0.01461792, -0.009590149, -0.03768921, -0.004432678, 0.033569336, 0.021728516, 0.046203613, -0.042633057, 0.0021953583, -0.04083252, -0.019683838, 0.012138367, 0.0035820007, 0.010040283, -0.009925842, -0.00983429, -0.010406494, -0.017669678, 0.013122559, -0.038208008, 0.0025043488, 0.039886475, 0.014129639, -0.041503906, -0.029067993, 0.019470215, -0.012588501, -0.0045661926, -0.013473511, 0.012123108, -0.028900146, -0.021957397, -0.014541626, 0.029083252, 0.005264282, -0.028045654, -0.022949219, 0.022018433, -0.032592773, 0.0049591064, -0.0036621094, 0.00040555, -0.01335144, 0.016921997, -0.0077819824, -0.002943039, 0.008735657, 0.01776123, -0.008094788, -0.050689697, 0.029312134, 0.021850586, 0.050445557, 0.023025513, -0.049926758, 0.016113281, -0.0038471222, 0.05050659, 0.005279541, 0.031463623, -0.09667969, -0.08856201, -0.07128906, 0.028656006, -0.021850586, 0.01197052, -0.012962341, -0.000040471554, 0.012939453, -0.02078247, 0.00018084049, 0.015563965, -0.015525818, 0.00541687, 0.061309814, -0.004173279, -0.055847168, -0.05697632, -0.017562866, 0.012382507, 0.033843994, 0.012313843, -0.039123535, 0.009819031, -0.057434082, -0.022415161, -0.00843811, -0.024353027, 0.028198242, 0.010047913, -0.0009431839, 0.056518555, 0.08062744, -0.01889038, -0.0058174133, 0.024963379, 0.0046844482, 0.03894043, -0.019927979, 0.009597778, -0.020462036, -0.013122559, -0.015319824, 0.007904053, 0.052734375, -0.0020503998, 0.005870819, -0.013244629, -0.0041923523, -0.018951416, 0.00497818, 0.020843506, -0.059265137, -0.020614624, 0.009590149, 0.014633179, 0.055725098, -0.003036499, -0.01965332, 0.013839722, -0.06329346, -0.02911377, -0.0680542, 0.0016536713, 0.04156494, 0.03552246, -0.014335632, 0.04284668, -0.020523071, 0.0034389496, -0.03665161, -0.0032653809, -0.018035889, -0.044433594, -0.0021858215, 0.015792847, -0.050231934, 0.058441162, 0.056884766, -0.0027770996, -0.041046143, 0.041168213, 0.032470703, -0.059936523, 0.013366699, -0.01436615, 0.0067481995, -0.019317627, 0.0047302246, 0.012908936, 0.020126343, 0.032196045, -0.003604889, 0.032714844, -0.018554688, -0.0082092285, 0.031677246, 0.03930664, 0.07702637, -0.044403076, 0.04534912, 0.0132751465, -0.012634277, -0.029586792, -0.017150879, -0.087768555, 0.019897461, 0.050048828, 0.009765625, -0.030548096, -0.030914307, -0.030914307, 0.054840088, -0.015808105, 0.00040650368, 0.0022125244, 0.01309967, 0.017700195, 0.042663574, 0.015075684, 0.03829956, -0.0027427673, 0.0149383545, 0.039001465, 0.0015182495, 0.023376465, -0.023529053, 0.0015926361, -0.005519867, 0.033477783, 0.02015686, 0.0112838745, -0.05557251, -0.01184082, -0.030075073, 0.0046157837, -0.003194809, 0.004020691, 0.0435791, -0.022094727, 0.011329651, 0.004180908, 0.011680603, -0.025787354, -0.00440979, 0.0010480881, 0.0055770874, -0.048431396, -0.010421753, -0.0003361702, 0.012939453, 0.0013790131, 0.025894165, -0.0002861023, 0.013252258, -0.0026950836, -0.041381836, -0.026916504, 0.01537323, 0.067871094, 0.0045204163, -0.00655365, 0.02809143, 0.0050735474, 0.0463562, 0.057800293, -0.025360107, 0.032287598, -0.050872803, 0.026733398, 0.018829346, -0.019332886, 0.0048103333, 0.039489746, 0.030761719, 0.0011911392, -0.03112793, 0.038269043, -0.07867432, -0.0057029724, -0.00036907196, -0.04055786, -0.044281006, -0.051818848, -0.029312134, -0.047943115, -0.084228516, -0.014122009, 0.081970215, -0.009185791, -0.0014209747, -0.018249512, 0.004837036, -0.032043457, -0.030715942, -0.034240723, -0.01737976, 0.025985718, 0.026321411, 0.025238037, -0.047027588, -0.0032539368, 0.0043144226, 0.022216797, -0.015258789, 0.06384277, -0.012313843, -0.029067993, 0.012245178, -0.00035214424, 0.005710602, 0.00592041, -0.028900146, -0.05014038, 0.013801575, 0.014694214, -0.07946777, -0.030883789, 0.076293945, -0.027557373, -0.026641846, -0.011566162, 0.03503418, 0.02368164, 0.0009775162, 0.003648758, 0.035614014, -0.019866943, 0.03527832, 0.03314209, 0.02583313, -0.034729004, -0.051605225, -0.0690918, 0.00043082237, 0.00730896, 0.021194458, 0.062042236, -0.04849243, 0.015357971, -0.032348633, -0.010665894, 0.023620605, -0.006996155, -0.026275635, -0.04159546, -0.032989502, -0.0340271, -0.0042915344, 0.010032654, -0.0055389404, 0.008171082, 0.033477783, -0.004585266, -0.056152344, -0.007965088, 0.010032654, 0.0105896, 0.010498047, 0.00881958, -0.02684021, 0.009086609, 0.042510986, 0.011878967, -0.014564514, -0.026779175, -0.097229004, -0.008522034, 0.06878662, -0.0061569214, -0.027359009, 0.015266418, -0.045806885, -0.051879883, 0.02444458, -0.008331299, 0.010093689, 0.04727173, 0.005050659, -0.0062675476, 0.009178162, -0.010826111, 0.033569336, -0.0368042, -0.09661865, 0.024307251, -0.023284912, -0.031463623, -0.050933838, 0.04324341, -0.070739746, -0.017288208, -0.031921387, 0.026123047, 0.01979065, 0.011619568, 0.0056266785, 0.024978638, 0.0022220612, -0.009742737, 0.010406494, -0.0138168335, -0.03543091, -0.009689331, -0.016983032, 0.01537323, 0.020111084, -0.027053833, -0.053497314, -0.018692017, 0.02986145, 0.030181885, 0.023513794, -0.035705566, -0.02909851, -0.02456665, 0.0016412735, 0.008834839, -0.0146102905, -0.004261017, -0.0019359589, 0.005268097, -0.020584106, 0.017288208, 0.028213501, 0.029174805, -0.03857422, 0.00157547, 0.049804688, -0.019500732, -0.03186035, 0.018814087, -0.008346558, 0.012519836, 0.0029354095, -0.018066406, -0.058532715, 0.023132324, -0.044158936, 0.034210205, -0.005218506, -0.024429321, 0.004497528, -0.018173218, -0.0031585693, -0.0020389557, 0.015670776, -0.006210327, -0.017852783, 0.016235352, -0.0423584, -0.046325684, 0.0031757355, 0.00008070469, -0.066711426, -0.02609253, 0.04034424, -0.0635376, -0.044799805, -0.07006836, 0.036193848, -0.06008911, -0.008834839, 0.021774292, -0.00762558, 0.004196167, 0.009719849, -0.057861328, -0.013145447, 0.069885254, -0.011993408, 0.0037612915, 0.0028362274, -0.017440796, -0.03253174, -0.008888245, 0.027572632, -0.022644043, 0.021209717, 0.007423401, 0.0025672913, 0.050872803, -0.033081055, 0.054107666, -0.036956787, 0.03274536, -0.026763916, -0.0033359528, 0.039398193, 0.040283203, -0.026687622, 0.04296875, 0.010192871, -0.010002136, -0.07397461, -0.018081665, 0.00944519, 0.0030765533, 0.028305054, -0.012588501, 0.047332764, 0.03866577, -0.011734009, 0.042877197, -0.01890564, -0.032562256, 0.019836426, 0.008140564, -0.02255249, -0.032928467, 0.01977539, 0.03564453, -0.009094238, -0.0033607483, -0.010314941, 0.012077332, -0.017990112, -0.053588867, 0.013763428, 0.031280518, -0.04598999, -0.02671814, -0.0513916, -0.029327393, -0.0005941391, 0.0025634766, -0.010528564, 0.009780884, 0.016525269, 0.010009766, -0.032806396, 0.0047798157, 0.04055786, -0.003238678, 0.019226074, -0.034851074, -0.0013780594, -0.0019741058, -0.04031372, -0.022888184, 0.030715942, 0.003686905, 0.032958984, -0.034942627, -0.021224976, 0.035339355, 0.0013771057, 0.040527344, 0.043151855, -0.028671265, -0.047027588, 0.027557373, -0.030471802, -0.0069389343, 0.016601562, 0.025512695, -0.019165039, -0.035369873, -0.00434494, -0.016983032, -0.03753662, -0.0546875, 0.031707764, 0.013305664, 0.03137207, 0.021743774, 0.032226562, 0.025421143, 0.018692017, -0.0012588501, 0.00894165, -0.029541016, -0.005065918, -0.015960693, 0.026107788, 0.0032539368, 0.026351929, 0.079956055, 0.0019836426, -0.029083252, 0.026031494, 0.0066986084, 0.054473877, -0.001748085, 0.010879517, 0.004627228, -0.07281494, -0.02255249, 0.0047912598, -0.00066423416, 0.058288574, -0.034973145, 0.04043579, -0.044799805, -0.01751709, 0.015975952, 0.0026245117, -0.00579834, -0.0040740967, 0.016616821, -0.05645752, -0.05239868, -0.018737793, 0.041229248, -0.036865234, -0.014137268, 0.005794525, 0.008079529, 0.016235352, 0.027893066, -0.0022907257, 0.0028018951, -0.0053710938, -0.005332947, -0.012214661, -0.021362305, -0.04626465, 0.01071167, -0.011154175, 0.008598328, -0.039031982, 0.0011577606, -0.0501709, -0.02230835, -0.01802063, -0.016845703, 0.010169983, -0.04937744, 0.031585693, 0.07476807, -0.018630981, 0.04727173, 0.019485474, 0.037872314, 0.025009155, 0.03817749, 0.012565613, 0.014579773, 0.032714844, -0.027435303, 0.015640259, 0.006336212, 0.03857422, 0.006916046, 0.017150879, 0.013381958, 0.00088882446, -0.050231934, 0.026123047, -0.001821518, 0.005554199, 0.005443573, -0.03933716, 0.015411377, 0.01461792, -0.0074539185, 0.007610321, -0.0390625, -0.004524231, 0.036987305, -0.040802002, 0.0015897751, 0.025512695, -0.012672424, -0.046081543, -0.06112671, 0.04147339, -0.009925842, -0.0067596436, -0.014595032, 0.0055351257, -0.0496521, 0.041992188, 0.0077323914, -0.070739746, -0.019104004, -0.0006775856, 0.016311646, 0.025344849, 0.0129776, -0.009384155, 0.0062179565, -0.00907135, -0.04562378, -0.053253174, -0.004486084, -0.03363037, 0.009857178, -0.0034484863, -0.009567261, -0.01737976, -0.022613525, 0.017425537, -0.03567505, -0.014518738, 0.028549194, 0.0043411255, 0.014564514, 0.016311646, 0.032592773, -0.003353119, 0.004924774, 0.018005371, -0.032165527, 0.019042969, 0.0051498413, 0.027236938, 0.01108551, -0.05935669, 0.020690918, 0.020263672, 0.025421143, 0.029571533, -0.00016582012, 0.041168213, 0.0068588257, 0.028762817, 0.037872314, 0.099609375, -0.0748291, -0.043823242, 0.0071372986, 0.018981934, 0.009048462, 0.05532837, -0.025787354, -0.033721924, -0.026748657, -0.06088257, -0.037506104, 0.0037651062, 0.027862549, 0.017929077, 0.0184021, -0.049102783, 0.01713562, -0.045715332, -0.0060043335, -0.031311035, 0.01838684, -0.010520935, -0.002910614, 0.0070648193, -0.017913818, 0.005504608, -0.028121948, 0.015365601, 0.00699234, -0.004627228, 0.008735657, -0.0368042, 0.0065574646, -0.04309082, -0.021713257, 0.02279663, 0.029891968, -0.03756714, 0.020019531, -0.0026931763, 0.06298828, 0.013435364, 0.027908325, 0.042755127, 0.017105103, 0.008422852, -0.005340576, 0.007801056, -0.027542114, 0.0385437, -0.050628662, 0.02116394, -0.06994629, -0.020751953, -0.061065674, 0.018188477, -0.0038757324, 0.038238525, 0.006034851, 0.018844604, 0.027542114, -0.012481689, 0.04248047, -0.0345459, 0.0579834, 0.02859497, 0.019302368, -0.0016126633, -0.034210205, 0.034332275, 0.039733887, -0.010002136, 0.02017212, 0.022033691, -0.04348755, 0.012626648, 0.022369385, 0.026992798, -0.024871826, -0.025054932, -0.015296936, 0.059661865, 0.004146576, 0.044799805, 0.053527832, 0.04989624, -0.025527954, -0.021011353, -0.001991272, -0.030853271, 0.004814148, -0.038726807, 0.018112183, -0.02848816, 0.015129089, -0.022354126, -0.01399231, -0.03829956, 0.017700195, 0.022384644, -0.053863525, -0.011199951, 0.018569946, 0.028900146, -0.0019931793, 0.004058838, -0.034240723, -0.0075798035, 0.02923584, 0.015777588, -0.006298065, 0.012260437, 0.024627686, 0.011482239, 0.0019779205, -0.016448975, 0.0038757324, 0.032958984, -0.014503479, 0.026397705, -0.029846191, 0.014953613, -0.023925781, -0.03338623, -0.015670776, 0.01727295, -0.057861328, -0.019378662, 0.04916382, 0.031433105, 0.033233643, 0.0625, 0.008338928, -0.00894928, 0.016525269, -0.031158447, 0.017807007, 0.02168274, -0.031280518, -0.0048217773, -0.007297516, -0.021148682, 0.027511597, -0.013336182, 0.07849121, -0.0025119781, 0.01197052, -0.0135650635, -0.014053345, 0.06561279, -0.062927246, -0.0021877289, 0.0016307831, 0.019210815, -0.030761719, -0.019195557, -0.01586914, -0.022262573, 0.0033226013, 0.0552063, 0.029891968, 0.0019607544, 0.002729416, -0.019927979, -0.0335083, 0.037872314, -0.025405884, 0.06262207, -0.031677246, -0.008552551, -0.014785767, -0.010009766, 0.00039601326, -0.023742676, -0.0063819885, -0.041229248, -0.05529785, -0.060821533, 0.020584106, 0.009803772, -0.025527954, 0.011734009, -0.07458496, 0.020874023, -0.031066895, 0.052490234, 0.03640747, -0.057525635, -0.0073127747, 0.03326416, -0.048828125, 0.0602417, 0.0037822723, 0.003583908, 0.003255844, 0.02079773, -0.018875122, 0.0035648346, 0.03427124, 0.06500244, -0.0001513958, -0.05847168, 0.0050621033, 0.041900635, 0.055664062, -0.026733398, -0.03048706, 0.03704834, 0.024032593, 0.007926941, 0.06262207, -0.0062942505, -0.0003247261, 0.010536194, 0.043304443, 0.0211792, -0.047332764, -0.047943115, -0.042663574, 0.05517578, 0.03491211, -0.0129852295, -0.015686035, 0.037139893, -0.017440796, -0.011482239, -0.004573822, 0.00065135956, -0.024856567, 0.006046295, 0.0011405945, -0.019943237, -0.035308838, -0.04876709, 0.0345459, -0.0033740997, 0.020248413, -0.012031555, 0.030334473, 0.0058021545, 0.04067993, 0.004020691, -0.05102539, 0.021484375, 0.011779785, 0.0129852295, 0.05041504, -0.01876831, -0.0513916, -0.017852783, 0.0056648254, -0.004043579, 0.02357483, 0.024780273, -0.0061416626, 0.030944824, -0.04248047, -0.060668945, 0.0058403015, -0.025909424, 0.034088135, -0.0446167, 0.019882202, -0.032989502, -0.014083862, 0.00003528595, 0.029205322, 0.025024414, 0.013221741, -0.061645508, -0.054901123, 0.03475952, -0.036132812 ], "summary": [ 0.01637268, 0.029083252, -0.031280518, 0.0009050369, 0.024002075, -0.043060303, 0.020019531, -0.049194336, -0.042114258, 0.0025978088, -0.042236328, 0.019500732, -0.057006836, -0.021392822, 0.009735107, -0.062561035, -0.024536133, 0.036193848, -0.0071983337, -0.026306152, 0.013549805, -0.032073975, -0.026626587, -0.059661865, 0.011703491, -0.04562378, 0.003271103, 0.0016899109, 0.018203735, -0.0018463135, 0.016204834, -0.0020980835, 0.016204834, 0.029342651, -0.013076782, 0.013587952, -0.054779053, 0.048065186, 0.032836914, -0.036010742, 0.018447876, -0.00434494, 0.04751587, -0.038635254, -0.0028190613, 0.06439209, -0.023849487, -0.03161621, -0.0118637085, 0.0703125, 0.008216858, 0.007789612, -0.026519775, 0.089782715, 0.007408142, 0.0057144165, -0.008117676, -0.020553589, 0.01687622, 0.084350586, 0.030044556, -0.0017166138, -0.023513794, -0.064331055, 0.0042304993, -0.01235199, 0.037353516, 0.01335907, 0.023132324, 0.010940552, 0.016220093, 0.023452759, 0.044830322, -0.023132324, -0.01727295, 0.006801605, 0.021987915, 0.039916992, 0.0317688, -0.05050659, 0.008506775, -0.03704834, -0.0016794205, 0.028152466, -0.03237915, 0.017745972, -0.018234253, -0.008049011, 0.013252258, 0.03250122, 0.0069084167, -0.02607727, -0.018600464, 0.0725708, 0.040252686, -0.02748108, -0.05722046, -0.018600464, -0.017044067, 0.0010118484, 0.0054512024, -0.01676941, -0.0017747879, -0.014282227, -0.028289795, 0.02960205, 0.018432617, -0.01626587, -0.027709961, -0.0007176399, -0.029541016, -0.035583496, -0.037139893, -0.03878784, -0.04776001, 0.03933716, -0.014480591, -0.048675537, -0.0039978027, -0.047058105, -0.02760315, -0.01146698, 0.06451416, -0.006843567, 0.035980225, 0.04537964, -0.019882202, -0.034576416, 0.0065193176, 0.016296387, 0.0040245056, 0.00233078, -0.050323486, -0.007297516, -0.030776978, -0.0035305023, -0.024017334, 0.0020217896, 0.013450623, -0.030334473, 0.053527832, -0.007835388, 0.025558472, 0.045135498, -0.014945984, 0.00091552734, 0.013290405, 0.020492554, -0.004360199, -0.036987305, 0.01411438, -0.017440796, 0.04864502, 0.0005841255, -0.017532349, -0.033966064, 0.018371582, -0.029067993, -0.0029640198, -0.041778564, 0.0574646, 0.0000086426735, -0.015640259, 0.10229492, 0.07373047, -0.016204834, 0.020706177, 0.023468018, 0.0064849854, 0.027648926, -0.002855301, 0.0067100525, -0.032928467, 0.0178833, 0.012451172, 0.010917664, 0.0044670105, -0.00014615059, 0.04815674, -0.05065918, -0.03955078, -0.02067566, 0.04046631, -0.010322571, -0.017959595, -0.01727295, -0.0067214966, 0.000034749508, 0.053344727, -0.0029640198, 0.00049495697, -0.0071411133, -0.032684326, -0.0033988953, -0.03656006, 0.0035648346, 0.03768921, 0.03564453, -0.027923584, -0.0060653687, 0.018173218, 0.036254883, -0.0463562, -0.022872925, -0.07159424, -0.015037537, -0.012069702, 0.04019165, -0.10461426, 0.017608643, 0.045959473, -0.038513184, -0.05328369, 0.09429932, 0.07849121, -0.050842285, 0.0006451607, 0.014183044, 0.020126343, 0.00092840195, 0.024642944, 0.003211975, 0.021942139, 0.023483276, -0.039123535, 0.052825928, -0.032958984, 0.046295166, -0.0024108887, 0.05343628, 0.057434082, -0.053131104, 0.030853271, 0.018692017, -0.015014648, -0.011749268, -0.007030487, -0.12054443, 0.005279541, 0.06945801, 0.01966858, -0.00014853477, -0.043670654, -0.046569824, -0.0056495667, -0.023803711, 0.018600464, -0.031234741, -0.015777588, -0.0062446594, 0.016159058, -0.013175964, 0.026779175, -0.025878906, -0.024871826, 0.040527344, 0.0076179504, 0.001414299, -0.014274597, 0.024230957, -0.0087890625, 0.009399414, 0.0016002655, 0.006416321, -0.038482666, -0.034606934, -0.031677246, -0.01852417, -0.00907135, -0.03387451, 0.040405273, -0.006542206, 0.017532349, 0.016937256, -0.0003733635, -0.0071372986, -0.018295288, -0.010345459, 0.019363403, 0.0007004738, -0.008674622, 0.020553589, -0.023406982, -0.013191223, 0.00084352493, -0.0070114136, 0.002149582, 0.020614624, -0.03781128, 0.01486969, 0.0101623535, 0.07122803, -0.0030651093, 0.007129669, 0.012939453, 0.027450562, -0.01902771, 0.014564514, 0.013092041, -0.014755249, 0.019073486, 0.03881836, -0.032165527, 0.023712158, 0.0154418945, -0.012329102, 0.05508423, -0.033325195, -0.012672424, 0.056640625, -0.07531738, 0.031341553, 0.018051147, 0.0023422241, -0.017242432, -0.027511597, -0.039154053, 0.016708374, -0.072143555, 0.012466431, 0.06451416, 0.00027656555, 0.029541016, -0.006214142, 0.0067443848, -0.04925537, 0.015510559, -0.01751709, -0.027160645, 0.023971558, -0.0049476624, -0.0137786865, -0.018661499, 0.021850586, -0.005672455, 0.014518738, 0.009460449, 0.019592285, 0.022949219, -0.007949829, 0.06726074, 0.017700195, -0.009971619, 0.03543091, -0.05319214, -0.003194809, 0.041229248, -0.00283432, -0.07519531, -0.011894226, 0.059143066, -0.037139893, -0.038970947, 0.0032863617, -0.00957489, 0.04055786, 0.047332764, -0.01247406, 0.015991211, -0.045562744, 0.04473877, 0.026245117, 0.027908325, -0.023071289, -0.054656982, -0.05041504, 0.014427185, 0.011917114, 0.026611328, 0.06124878, -0.02355957, 0.040496826, -0.009552002, -0.006248474, 0.006214142, -0.013420105, 0.026794434, -0.034942627, 0.017669678, 0.027114868, -0.017120361, 0.010093689, 0.017562866, 0.01020813, -0.014945984, 0.015731812, -0.02142334, -0.025787354, 0.01600647, 0.0007581711, 0.023147583, 0.046569824, -0.018600464, 0.0022773743, 0.03753662, 0.007003784, -0.023605347, -0.008621216, -0.07336426, -0.011116028, 0.04711914, -0.005004883, -0.028167725, -0.009178162, 0.021072388, -0.08874512, 0.061584473, -0.007080078, 0.007545471, 0.024047852, 0.015365601, -0.024032593, 0.019866943, -0.026153564, 0.032714844, -0.02079773, -0.023544312, 0.023635864, -0.046875, -0.029052734, -0.033416748, 0.109558105, -0.038848877, -0.01991272, -0.023605347, 0.00541687, -0.0067710876, 0.004962921, -0.004901886, 0.058502197, -0.007762909, 0.0054016113, 0.03640747, 0.010597229, -0.072509766, -0.048614502, -0.014640808, -0.028366089, 0.04425049, -0.073913574, -0.05670166, -0.015602112, 0.03543091, 0.0209198, 0.021743774, 0.002090454, -0.032104492, -0.03253174, 0.029281616, -0.013076782, 0.009521484, -0.007083893, 0.06335449, 0.010192871, -0.014533997, 0.03074646, 0.02607727, 0.029251099, -0.015792847, 0.029769897, 0.049560547, 0.0046310425, -0.035186768, -0.0069465637, -0.035095215, 0.022109985, -0.0041542053, 0.0063705444, -0.043670654, 0.009353638, -0.016220093, 0.034851074, -0.0008773804, -0.02619934, 0.016799927, -0.024963379, 0.021392822, -0.025619507, 0.050842285, -0.0017223358, -0.043426514, 0.027420044, -0.07501221, -0.01737976, -0.004600525, 0.0030288696, -0.02658081, -0.030334473, 0.021011353, -0.015136719, -0.045837402, -0.03527832, 0.04937744, -0.048065186, 0.017608643, 0.036895752, -0.011390686, 0.034210205, 0.00069379807, -0.03869629, 0.015266418, -0.018325806, 0.0005712509, 0.020385742, -0.02861023, 0.014419556, -0.024902344, 0.020431519, 0.030319214, -0.053619385, -0.008361816, -0.012519836, 0.021621704, 0.03878784, -0.02748108, 0.042297363, -0.041931152, 0.05291748, -0.033843994, -0.0069389343, 0.05722046, 0.054840088, -0.00015079975, 0.0075035095, 0.010093689, -0.011566162, -0.020324707, -0.017990112, 0.024627686, 0.0056495667, -0.0038795471, 0.010757446, 0.018569946, 0.03302002, 0.0034294128, -0.049468994, -0.02947998, -0.07659912, -0.010368347, 0.054870605, -0.009346008, -0.03161621, -0.0079956055, 0.0703125, -0.014480591, -0.050231934, -0.030426025, -0.041046143, -0.019470215, -0.07470703, 0.019348145, 0.038238525, -0.011108398, -0.053497314, -0.035125732, 0.017196655, 0.03265381, -0.024856567, -0.0020332336, 0.026794434, -0.020553589, 0.014953613, 0.0011339188, -0.005065918, 0.019546509, 0.029449463, -0.016464233, -0.028823853, 0.020553589, -0.029571533, -0.021530151, -0.03274536, 0.015579224, 0.0042877197, 0.015579224, -0.007247925, -0.004753113, 0.03817749, -0.00592041, 0.009254456, 0.052520752, -0.031951904, -0.07006836, -0.01928711, -0.017166138, 0.03390503, -0.012161255, 0.030822754, -0.012565613, 0.011230469, -0.002714157, -0.002620697, -0.045684814, -0.054016113, 0.029647827, 0.023284912, 0.040771484, 0.024612427, 0.00712204, 0.015625, 0.055664062, -0.036010742, 0.004211426, -0.013458252, -0.009315491, -0.070617676, -0.000259161, 0.02784729, 0.006504059, 0.058929443, -0.027740479, -0.003856659, 0.011932373, -0.024765015, 0.03527832, -0.009101868, 0.0368042, -0.01928711, -0.03491211, -0.026062012, 0.023162842, -0.0008111, 0.038269043, 0.036895752, -0.03503418, -0.0446167, 0.039520264, -0.0005083084, -0.010803223, 0.010276794, 0.020187378, 0.01828003, -0.03744507, -0.030441284, -0.007133484, 0.0345459, -0.029190063, -0.024673462, -0.028030396, -0.02154541, 0.027359009, -0.021835327, -0.041992188, 0.012199402, 0.008460999, 0.008674622, 0.013725281, 0.021850586, 0.008903503, 0.009422302, 0.02482605, -0.00667572, -0.043395996, -0.01876831, 0.014480591, -0.02798462, -0.022415161, -0.018707275, 0.00944519, -0.038085938, -0.024795532, 0.012756348, -0.039398193, 0.0038414001, 0.0368042, 0.04827881, -0.0038890839, 0.014564514, -0.0062561035, 0.005973816, -0.0014772415, -0.03189087, -0.019821167, -0.025009155, 0.008895874, 0.038208008, -0.00066280365, 0.025314331, 0.004322052, -0.033172607, -0.0079193115, -0.03060913, -0.008117676, -0.028060913, -0.0017795563, 0.018493652, 0.019882202, 0.018432617, 0.002506256, -0.0033073425, -0.014770508, 0.028030396, -0.015548706, 0.01889038, -0.0031852722, -0.005367279, -0.019973755, -0.007671356, 0.060302734, -0.026763916, -0.0158844, -0.0018987656, -0.016204834, -0.018539429, -0.018066406, -0.014724731, -0.04385376, 0.0004093647, 0.017089844, 0.038360596, -0.001824379, -0.043304443, 0.016082764, 0.005630493, -0.027069092, -0.036254883, -0.045532227, -0.03189087, -0.04626465, 0.04815674, -0.0070228577, 0.026519775, -0.0033988953, -0.042816162, 0.009941101, -0.050476074, -0.030715942, 0.009666443, -0.006072998, 0.012527466, 0.019439697, 0.008110046, -0.033813477, -0.0013628006, 0.037597656, -0.055480957, 0.013511658, -0.006565094, -0.0015172958, 0.036193848, -0.050811768, 0.020187378, 0.008628845, 0.012840271, 0.04949951, 0.009170532, 0.02230835, 0.025756836, 0.03652954, 0.04901123, 0.069885254, -0.048614502, -0.053863525, -0.0025501251, 0.025222778, 0.0020523071, 0.030883789, -0.021621704, -0.053253174, -0.004184723, -0.02418518, 0.0054893494, -0.00062417984, 0.022277832, 0.015365601, 0.047027588, -0.04449463, -0.024536133, -0.0005207062, -0.020980835, -0.0007042885, 0.0029563904, -0.002155304, 0.01777649, 0.014274597, -0.022094727, 0.023132324, -0.007335663, -0.0017976761, -0.013015747, -0.020324707, 0.0035266876, -0.029556274, 0.023391724, -0.04144287, 0.027053833, 0.0067329407, 0.061340332, -0.06384277, -0.0066337585, 0.013519287, 0.061035156, 0.0072402954, -0.020370483, -0.0104904175, 0.009391785, 0.008239746, -0.008491516, 0.0063438416, -0.009002686, 0.05807495, -0.029144287, 0.018600464, -0.042175293, -0.032592773, -0.02418518, 0.012290955, 0.010032654, -0.0018959045, 0.043548584, 0.015975952, 0.018997192, -0.008087158, -0.014228821, -0.016281128, 0.013008118, 0.012908936, 0.009727478, -0.017730713, -0.05606079, 0.010566711, 0.03640747, -0.02508545, 0.026275635, 0.048095703, -0.03817749, 0.020507812, 0.019042969, 0.012702942, -0.04949951, 0.00047063828, -0.02619934, 0.0473938, 0.04574585, 0.06616211, -0.010658264, 0.011268616, 0.004558563, 0.0033721924, -0.016601562, -0.020828247, 0.034210205, -0.06210327, -0.031143188, 0.007583618, -0.035736084, 0.00013065338, 0.021316528, -0.008270264, 0.009391785, 0.023406982, -0.03729248, -0.014915466, 0.011520386, 0.008956909, 0.013717651, -0.0031337738, -0.028396606, -0.020874023, 0.03491211, 0.0041160583, -0.010566711, 0.0071754456, 0.026123047, -0.0047912598, 0.04736328, 0.044952393, 0.027267456, 0.05807495, 0.048187256, 0.026428223, -0.045196533, -0.023803711, -0.04522705, -0.022994995, -0.023712158, 0.02078247, -0.022903442, 0.001531601, 0.042175293, 0.01777649, 0.05178833, 0.04675293, -0.04763794, 0.021011353, 0.06341553, -0.020385742, 0.028274536, -0.01663208, -0.0043144226, -0.038513184, -0.013145447, 0.0129470825, -0.004486084, 0.003686905, 0.055145264, 0.020477295, -0.016571045, -0.017456055, -0.035980225, 0.038024902, -0.018798828, 0.013427734, -0.032958984, 0.033172607, -0.0262146, -0.020828247, -0.018844604, -0.03942871, -0.02180481, 0.07940674, 0.01852417, -0.007537842, 0.017288208, 0.009231567, -0.0070381165, 0.01449585, -0.017700195, 0.05657959, -0.029373169, -0.03314209, 0.019119263, -0.019729614, 0.022369385, -0.01713562, 0.0044059753, -0.04031372, -0.017654419, -0.07470703, 0.029144287, 0.0071372986, -0.019195557, 0.009460449, -0.016067505, 0.0055770874, -0.02809143, 0.07672119, 0.020874023, -0.05795288, 0.033843994, 0.04840088, -0.055267334, 0.06878662, 0.0007753372, -0.013626099, 0.0019321442, 0.004558563, -0.034423828, -0.012191772, 0.030548096, 0.044189453, -0.013664246, -0.04550171, -0.031982422, 0.044647217, 0.037902832, 0.004173279, -0.014633179, 0.056549072, 0.005256653, 0.024475098, 0.035308838, -0.048614502, -0.01033783, 0.03564453, 0.049987793, 0.033081055, -0.031021118, -0.04888916, -0.03286743, 0.057922363, -0.018066406, -0.02961731, -0.029663086, 0.018600464, -0.027801514, -0.037322998, 0.0056381226, 0.027801514, -0.054901123, 0.029144287, -0.008300781, -0.041259766, -0.04019165, -0.064086914, 0.017364502, -0.005508423, 0.0052261353, 0.015792847, 0.029678345, -0.0049819946, 0.07849121, 0.039276123, 0.0042915344, -0.034088135, -0.018112183, 0.03286743, -0.003288269, 0.0023040771, -0.040252686, 0.0043258667, 0.011062622, 0.020507812, 0.0446167, -0.0042381287, -0.028533936, -0.0040664673, -0.050354004, -0.055389404, -0.042816162, -0.026367188, -0.007709503, -0.020095825, 0.033172607, 0.038024902, -0.007583618, 0.028549194, 0.024414062, 0.047943115, 0.026550293, 0.0016717911, -0.057525635, 0.016845703, 0.0018835068 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1912.03817v3
Machine Unlearning
Lucas Bourtoule, Varun Chandrasekaran, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Hengrui Jia, Adelin Travers, Baiwu Zhang, David Lie, Nicolas Papernot
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Once users have shared their data online, it is generally difficult for them to revoke access and ask for the data to be deleted. Machine learning (ML) exacerbates this problem because any model trained with said data may have memorized it, putting users at risk of a successful privacy attack exposing their information. Yet, having models unlearn is notoriously difficult. We introduce SISA training, a framework that expedites the unlearning process by strategically limiting the influence of a data point in the training procedure. While our framework is applicable to any learning algorithm, it is designed to achieve the largest improvements for stateful algorithms like stochastic gradient descent for deep neural networks. SISA training reduces the computational overhead associated with unlearning, even in the worst-case setting where unlearning requests are made uniformly across the training set. In some cases, the service provider may have a prior on the distribution of unlearning requests that will be issued by users. We may take this prior into account to partition and order data accordingly, and further decrease overhead from unlearning. Our evaluation spans several datasets from different domains, with corresponding motivations for unlearning. Under no distributional assumptions, for simple learning tasks, we observe that SISA training improves time to unlearn points from the Purchase dataset by 4.63x, and 2.45x for the SVHN dataset, over retraining from scratch. SISA training also provides a speed-up of 1.36x in retraining for complex learning tasks such as ImageNet classification; aided by transfer learning, this results in a small degradation in accuracy. Our work contributes to practical data governance in machine unlearning.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1912.03817v3
"2020-12-15T05:39:28"
"2019-12-09T02:16:53"
{ "title": [ 0.017364502, 0.012138367, -0.001534462, 0.0075302124, -0.044433594, -0.013877869, 0.009483337, -0.03579712, 0.031341553, 0.03857422, -0.066467285, 0.005558014, -0.0030002594, -0.0074920654, -0.00092077255, -0.0018701553, 0.043640137, 0.03213501, 0.049102783, -0.005584717, -0.0119018555, 0.04711914, -0.034698486, -0.017669678, -0.045532227, 0.05392456, -0.019424438, -0.014083862, -0.030349731, -0.026657104, -0.018737793, 0.0069999695, -0.0102005005, 0.026123047, -0.017837524, -0.014457703, -0.075683594, 0.029769897, -0.0036907196, -0.0017318726, -0.018157959, 0.013587952, -0.050750732, -0.033416748, -0.06341553, -0.019256592, -0.03375244, 0.010749817, 0.021057129, 0.002866745, -0.02166748, -0.018463135, -0.017913818, 0.052246094, 0.0036735535, 0.007408142, -0.05670166, 0.025238037, 0.006351471, 0.03579712, -0.0054855347, 0.009284973, 0.024490356, -0.02670288, -0.043701172, -0.051818848, 0.0051193237, 0.008300781, -0.010032654, -0.012939453, 0.031799316, 0.015579224, -0.008987427, -0.009155273, -0.00843811, -0.01727295, 0.057769775, 0.038635254, -0.024856567, -0.01158905, 0.020614624, -0.00023591518, -0.029418945, -0.022857666, -0.010139465, -0.039978027, 0.009147644, -0.0059013367, -0.00447464, -0.040130615, -0.007106781, 0.023223877, -0.031433105, 0.04711914, -0.010910034, -0.013626099, 0.03149414, -0.0017881393, -0.02545166, -0.050201416, -0.026504517, -0.0055351257, -0.046295166, -0.006362915, 0.0011701584, -0.009880066, -0.0006327629, -0.07891846, 0.0491333, 0.046936035, -0.015022278, 0.09576416, -0.023544312, -0.032043457, -0.0056915283, 0.01586914, -0.032226562, -0.0038414001, -0.010513306, -0.028564453, 0.013130188, -0.00039339066, 0.0010566711, 0.016952515, 0.012611389, 0.006477356, -0.03692627, -0.0054512024, 0.03164673, -0.013084412, -0.04119873, 0.04360962, -0.062683105, -0.03665161, -0.008865356, -0.009941101, -0.020950317, -0.046844482, -0.028060913, 0.017547607, 0.025756836, -0.06109619, -0.010375977, 0.02330017, -0.02104187, 0.03781128, 0.013542175, -0.011581421, -0.0032482147, -0.009124756, -0.048339844, -0.016525269, -0.03024292, 0.08190918, 0.013587952, 0.04486084, -0.010314941, -0.009536743, 0.04937744, 0.04586792, 0.07366943, -0.014640808, -0.01991272, 0.014389038, -0.020355225, -0.010032654, -0.019989014, 0.004219055, -0.00040197372, 0.011985779, -0.012290955, 0.0038528442, 0.0049858093, 0.008323669, 0.0082473755, 0.011451721, -0.057800293, -0.0009717941, 0.030929565, -0.0053634644, 0.030197144, -0.02407837, -0.051483154, 0.064575195, -0.033569336, -0.03845215, 0.019851685, 0.042633057, 0.012008667, 0.017959595, -0.016433716, 0.00333786, 0.008369446, 0.0030593872, -0.004447937, -0.011741638, -0.001584053, 0.0075683594, -0.013404846, 0.007209778, 0.0015478134, 0.05606079, -0.02319336, -0.052459717, -0.06185913, 0.0021266937, -0.0184021, 0.045562744, -0.030807495, 0.018966675, 0.026123047, -0.03643799, -0.0047035217, 0.026428223, 0.015579224, -0.021209717, -0.03213501, -0.047607422, -0.024612427, 0.005947113, 0.014015198, 0.0209198, -0.0028934479, 0.040863037, 0.0287323, 0.0043945312, -0.022750854, -0.024887085, 0.0390625, 0.0007457733, 0.04574585, -0.004928589, 0.013954163, -0.029922485, -0.061401367, -0.013420105, -0.03451538, 0.008216858, 0.008872986, 0.057891846, 0.025619507, -0.0016183853, -0.0009288788, 0.0015935898, -0.007675171, -0.003282547, 0.04827881, -0.013420105, -0.02720642, -0.016143799, 0.043670654, -0.010147095, 0.030181885, 0.070251465, -0.025497437, 0.022399902, -0.0048103333, -0.014205933, 0.004371643, -0.0033512115, 0.015304565, -0.014678955, -0.035827637, -0.0013532639, -0.0022468567, -0.025436401, -0.021575928, -0.00034713745, -0.026519775, 0.013771057, 0.029724121, -0.03161621, -0.020996094, -0.053863525, -0.010261536, -0.026229858, -0.052856445, 0.047332764, 0.014160156, -0.051605225, 0.016540527, 0.026504517, 0.0128479, 0.0049743652, 0.03842163, 0.017944336, -0.0061035156, 0.021636963, -0.059417725, 0.008399963, 0.029632568, 0.10406494, 0.027709961, 0.025283813, 0.03552246, 0.07421875, 0.04748535, 0.048706055, -0.021743774, 0.0002772808, -0.024963379, 0.011238098, -0.004524231, -0.0007138252, 0.0014352798, 0.047027588, 0.029464722, -0.018600464, -0.019622803, 0.016952515, -0.08538818, -0.026031494, -0.008811951, 0.0129470825, -0.0519104, -0.068115234, -0.018417358, -0.034088135, -0.04071045, 0.007736206, 0.05718994, -0.00945282, -0.014450073, -0.006801605, 0.0011434555, -0.0368042, 0.0054512024, -0.011489868, 0.031097412, 0.038085938, -0.015159607, 0.031463623, -0.047454834, -0.05911255, 0.0010309219, -0.005596161, 0.022201538, 0.013809204, 0.008880615, 0.014877319, 0.044647217, 0.025222778, 0.023910522, 0.0019950867, 0.017532349, 0.022232056, -0.080322266, 0.036834717, -0.04107666, -0.042816162, 0.032562256, -0.0736084, -0.018981934, 0.025024414, 0.034332275, -0.0435791, 0.0062217712, 0.007549286, -0.010719299, -0.05883789, 0.029220581, -0.0155181885, -0.026626587, -0.00040578842, -0.0032463074, -0.03829956, -0.011734009, 0.0026359558, -0.004585266, 0.02760315, -0.0024261475, 0.044525146, -0.05303955, -0.00687027, -0.04901123, 0.0025558472, 0.045196533, -0.019592285, -0.08251953, -0.014678955, 0.043426514, 0.028656006, -0.008880615, 0.004085541, 0.005832672, -0.015174866, -0.020202637, 0.009033203, 0.055633545, 0.041015625, 0.004676819, -0.02709961, -0.0869751, -0.009490967, 0.037353516, 0.008796692, 0.037353516, -0.022094727, -0.064819336, -0.025009155, -0.046966553, 0.0033664703, -0.045959473, -0.0021476746, -0.060913086, 0.00017404556, -0.040374756, -0.048736572, 0.0113220215, 0.009719849, -0.0055656433, -0.022583008, 0.031143188, -0.06402588, 0.015602112, -0.026397705, -0.066589355, 0.000374794, -0.031021118, 0.070251465, 0.018661499, -0.03363037, -0.038513184, 0.012229919, -0.0076522827, 0.021224976, 0.021133423, 0.02330017, 0.0049743652, 0.011131287, 0.014007568, -0.007610321, -0.005584717, -0.014953613, -0.059020996, 0.014518738, -0.019592285, 0.028930664, 0.032806396, -0.03353882, 0.0129852295, 0.012619019, -0.033447266, 0.002904892, -0.025802612, -0.030014038, 0.019607544, -0.02420044, -0.04168701, -0.01675415, -0.059417725, 0.022018433, -0.044677734, 0.017150879, -0.009429932, 0.03161621, -0.0118637085, 0.019226074, 0.014312744, 0.018585205, 0.0317688, 0.0003092289, -0.040161133, -0.011741638, -0.030227661, -0.014076233, 0.09283447, -0.020248413, -0.021438599, -0.0058555603, -0.044403076, 0.00022757053, 0.0023708344, 0.0018386841, -0.025482178, -0.014976501, 0.011802673, 0.019973755, -0.029296875, -0.030700684, -0.0037384033, -0.0069732666, -0.045898438, -0.035339355, -0.010528564, -0.0009689331, -0.04638672, 0.028198242, 0.021957397, -0.051879883, -0.04989624, -0.045166016, 0.00021016598, -0.05307007, -0.040039062, -0.033569336, -0.013717651, -0.021194458, 0.0048446655, -0.06994629, -0.031799316, -0.0115737915, -0.022872925, -0.026184082, -0.025543213, -0.040130615, -0.002450943, -0.010108948, 0.053833008, 0.028640747, -0.046051025, 0.010192871, 0.0067863464, 0.023544312, -0.031707764, 0.043670654, -0.011024475, -0.008605957, -0.0036754608, 0.017089844, -0.012329102, 0.031204224, 0.0016040802, 0.011116028, 0.020065308, 0.019226074, -0.03186035, 0.07385254, -0.018508911, -0.036834717, 0.06970215, 0.01084137, 0.056243896, 0.03237915, -0.05166626, 0.028671265, 0.00057029724, 0.011306763, -0.00045323372, -0.024353027, -0.01727295, -0.005039215, -0.0028915405, -0.026550293, -0.014678955, -0.061584473, -0.0155181885, 0.04824829, 0.035888672, -0.005302429, 0.061157227, 0.015716553, 0.032989502, -0.0021076202, -0.035736084, -0.012207031, -0.01638794, 0.0052833557, -0.019180298, -0.0014047623, -0.00831604, -0.005783081, -0.033325195, 0.047576904, -0.0154800415, 0.008140564, -0.01109314, -0.05508423, -0.0037574768, -0.00843811, -0.03945923, -0.024917603, -0.060028076, -0.017044067, 0.008895874, 0.044708252, -0.027175903, 0.0032444, 0.02557373, 0.062683105, 0.04699707, 0.034423828, -0.020751953, 0.051757812, 0.03643799, -0.010986328, -0.019088745, -0.040496826, -0.009048462, 0.008804321, 0.00121212, -0.0037441254, -0.008705139, -0.048980713, 0.003967285, -0.0046844482, 0.009262085, -0.012908936, -0.011474609, 0.02017212, 0.0002696514, 0.0015487671, 0.019927979, -0.024520874, 0.016921997, 0.008773804, 0.0491333, -0.029830933, 0.0435791, 0.010063171, -0.010360718, 0.01335144, -0.079589844, 0.06210327, -0.05239868, -0.021865845, 0.026916504, 0.030212402, -0.04550171, -0.037750244, 0.005680084, -0.0052337646, 0.03677368, -0.026397705, -0.036865234, -0.0025157928, -0.01826477, 0.02381897, 0.017486572, 0.011688232, 0.050750732, -0.014923096, -0.064575195, -0.04046631, 0.0028686523, 0.03363037, -0.023956299, 0.01763916, -0.003692627, -0.044158936, -0.012969971, 0.042785645, 0.018005371, -0.06774902, 0.072021484, -0.043914795, -0.005214691, 0.009002686, -0.03970337, -0.005332947, 0.010910034, 0.02671814, 0.02154541, 0.019226074, 0.009994507, 0.011299133, -0.048217773, 0.021591187, 0.02268982, -0.026626587, -0.021438599, 0.07287598, -0.014701843, 0.010177612, 0.019699097, 0.0068626404, 0.03164673, 0.011894226, 0.018310547, -0.038269043, 0.003063202, -0.029525757, -0.008277893, -0.022018433, 0.0088272095, -0.013656616, 0.02949524, 0.013465881, 0.015510559, -0.04309082, 0.0010385513, -0.01852417, -0.03503418, 0.023635864, -0.02999878, 0.008422852, -0.0010681152, 0.015296936, -0.034484863, -0.048980713, -0.031311035, 0.0335083, -0.06939697, -0.016464233, 0.044769287, -0.04171753, -0.008575439, 0.03225708, 0.050689697, 0.011856079, 0.04171753, -0.0042495728, -0.01424408, -0.0076904297, 0.0012407303, 0.024719238, -0.03933716, 0.00023043156, 0.0028648376, 0.042755127, -0.00466156, -0.038360596, -0.03866577, -0.0018863678, 0.007797241, -0.02532959, -0.014343262, 0.012390137, -0.0025024414, -0.0037155151, -0.0036087036, -0.016723633, 0.0009832382, -0.050567627, 0.016174316, -0.0021514893, -0.0024642944, 0.035003662, 0.018447876, 0.011520386, -0.0051116943, 0.002954483, 0.016311646, -0.016571045, 0.008422852, -0.032226562, -0.0069274902, 0.0099105835, -0.042633057, 0.019317627, 0.044158936, -0.019241333, 0.035125732, 0.012519836, 0.031280518, 0.052978516, 0.0026779175, 0.08453369, 0.020462036, 0.02458191, 0.034332275, 0.020217896, -0.06323242, -0.042785645, -0.0036907196, -0.02331543, 0.004550934, -0.006626129, -0.05090332, 0.021896362, -0.04425049, -0.004634857, -0.026245117, 0.04067993, -0.01802063, -0.00434494, -0.054870605, -0.029754639, 0.09509277, -0.008300781, 0.006088257, 0.01348114, 0.014442444, -0.0178833, -0.0008778572, 0.04864502, 0.0074920654, 0.022018433, 0.019592285, 0.0069274902, -0.029281616, 0.009346008, -0.026138306, -0.005886078, -0.045654297, -0.0035476685, 0.02684021, 0.0769043, -0.041503906, 0.020828247, 0.025817871, 0.058258057, -0.0052452087, -0.007926941, 0.02911377, 0.006099701, -0.04598999, -0.017166138, -0.008758545, -0.018173218, 0.0013999939, -0.05316162, -0.028915405, -0.027954102, -0.013908386, -0.06488037, 0.017440796, 0.01676941, -0.025283813, 0.0071411133, -0.0033054352, -0.010520935, -0.02357483, -0.0032463074, 0.012863159, 0.007335663, -0.054779053, -0.013900757, -0.03604126, 0.021102905, 0.0013389587, 0.011756897, -0.01725769, 0.0619812, 0.020751953, -0.014701843, 0.059906006, -0.012901306, 0.01651001, -0.014892578, 0.017456055, -0.007709503, 0.007598877, 0.017654419, 0.009811401, 0.035064697, -0.02130127, -0.04296875, 0.02468872, 0.025405884, 0.043273926, -0.00472641, 0.014633179, 0.062042236, -0.08929443, 0.01499176, 0.03250122, -0.020019531, 0.021835327, 0.08111572, 0.011024475, 0.05114746, 0.049713135, -0.000114917755, 0.003276825, 0.04083252, 0.016937256, -0.054656982, -0.035583496, 0.029129028, -0.00983429, -0.020751953, -0.013755798, 0.04611206, 0.017547607, 0.006576538, 0.03048706, -0.0151901245, 0.04647827, -0.07702637, -0.0038261414, 0.013687134, 0.05545044, -0.023269653, -0.029525757, 0.041229248, 0.021621704, -0.05819702, 0.02053833, 0.053222656, 0.02659607, -0.009536743, 0.038635254, 0.028381348, -0.033721924, 0.0069236755, -0.002401352, -0.023010254, -0.015686035, -0.018173218, -0.01448822, -0.02809143, -0.014198303, -0.0033397675, -0.044403076, 0.02357483, 0.0069465637, 0.042419434, -0.011306763, -0.03692627, 0.020599365, -0.02784729, -0.015472412, 0.0023155212, -0.024810791, -0.026947021, -0.024719238, 0.005809784, -0.039489746, -0.07354736, 0.037719727, -0.01335144, -0.020858765, 0.00756073, -0.019821167, -0.0013837814, -0.0063171387, 0.009498596, 0.036499023, 0.035339355, -0.03753662, -0.012763977, 0.024932861, 0.025985718, 0.0012254715, -0.03149414, 0.018417358, -0.009063721, 0.061828613, -0.07183838, -0.017669678, -0.04220581, -0.0309906, -0.06311035, 0.06427002, -0.053588867, -0.06304932, 0.014373779, -0.017700195, 0.0037994385, -0.0056495667, -0.019989014, 0.007247925, 0.03945923, -0.06512451, 0.03817749, -0.0033721924, -0.044311523, 0.004283905, -0.018463135, 0.026306152, -0.0423584, -0.016326904, -0.0067481995, 0.016433716, 0.041259766, -0.049560547, -0.015853882, -0.0037174225, 0.048675537, -0.04663086, 0.056640625, 0.017959595, -0.0044059753, -0.01737976, 0.02482605, -0.03656006, 0.021118164, -0.0018062592, 0.041778564, 0.019866943, 0.00983429, -0.032165527, 0.0012311935, -0.005344391, -0.02053833, -0.005378723, 0.056793213, -0.055114746, -0.002986908, 0.022140503, 0.03463745, -0.025100708, 0.005218506, -0.04824829, -0.04852295, 0.035003662, 0.02835083, -0.0143966675, 0.009971619, -0.050598145, 0.072509766, 0.029541016, 0.040863037, -0.016021729, 0.00030970573, 0.017715454, 0.007446289, 0.01133728, -0.028503418, -0.020645142, 0.0053100586, 0.03414917, -0.00756073, -0.017684937, -0.009155273, 0.037872314, -0.044311523, -0.034729004, -0.045410156, -0.024841309, 0.03765869, -0.037231445, 0.031951904, 0.008140564, 0.0155181885, -0.00020587444, 0.0004518032, 0.06964111, -0.0032749176, -0.0008716583, 0.027526855, 0.01777649, -0.002784729 ], "summary": [ 0.021911621, 0.0126953125, -0.0463562, 0.0016880035, -0.002691269, -0.046081543, -0.0006303787, -0.04626465, 0.041900635, 0.011489868, -0.039978027, -0.000016629696, -0.037750244, -0.02911377, -0.027511597, -0.018310547, 0.009536743, 0.05078125, 0.04449463, -0.0076828003, -0.009063721, 0.0068473816, 0.014930725, 0.00095653534, -0.017410278, 0.01965332, -0.028289795, 0.0020313263, -0.0041007996, 0.0041236877, -0.0069847107, 0.0026607513, -0.02784729, 0.05444336, -0.007457733, -0.10046387, -0.024917603, 0.03326416, 0.015655518, -0.0066070557, 0.040496826, -0.014556885, 0.015274048, -0.035369873, -0.01058197, 0.02319336, 0.0026741028, -0.029266357, -0.001750946, 0.032318115, 0.0006327629, 0.040008545, -0.0077285767, 0.025146484, 0.010566711, 0.0013389587, -0.0019741058, -0.009284973, 0.027893066, 0.038604736, 0.0021533966, -0.017929077, -0.0077552795, -0.059265137, -0.0010147095, -0.028533936, 0.053253174, 0.011734009, -0.038208008, -0.01828003, 0.045410156, 0.0074691772, -0.003540039, -0.028686523, 0.0082473755, 0.03717041, 0.047302246, 0.03869629, -0.026977539, 0.017562866, -0.024414062, -0.017578125, -0.03970337, -0.017364502, -0.017318726, -0.018341064, -0.016036987, 0.0057907104, 0.008285522, 0.021957397, -0.0039405823, -0.021362305, -0.008476257, 0.061950684, 0.032836914, -0.03640747, -0.028320312, -0.035949707, 0.0008816719, -0.023010254, -0.0042533875, -0.0049972534, -0.053344727, 0.014526367, -0.015144348, -0.0025978088, -0.008781433, -0.07946777, -0.030181885, 0.033233643, -0.03353882, -0.054595947, -0.025970459, -0.055603027, -0.022705078, 0.058624268, 0.016159058, -0.01020813, 0.028366089, -0.0065612793, -0.038726807, -0.0231781, -0.009231567, 0.039978027, 0.035888672, 0.027999878, 0.00969696, 0.014694214, 0.0062561035, -0.022003174, -0.0019054413, 0.048614502, -0.034240723, -0.0181427, -0.03338623, 0.018554688, 0.011100769, -0.005718231, -0.013214111, 0.029174805, 0.027526855, -0.049835205, -0.023605347, 0.034088135, 0.0042304993, 0.042877197, 0.028152466, -0.030532837, -0.01826477, 0.0036716461, -0.031921387, -0.024932861, 0.024459839, -0.008255005, -0.058685303, -0.029251099, -0.05999756, -0.011131287, 0.020309448, -0.022827148, 0.07525635, -0.022003174, -0.018600464, 0.09906006, 0.0289917, 0.027862549, -0.006000519, -0.01285553, -0.0000975728, -0.026611328, 0.011184692, 0.0011377335, 0.000007212162, 0.004135132, 0.015930176, 0.010063171, -0.02734375, 0.047546387, 0.03137207, -0.03591919, 0.013412476, -0.032562256, 0.037261963, 0.024749756, 0.005908966, -0.014091492, -0.0017147064, 0.0026168823, 0.017089844, 0.004020691, -0.02015686, 0.023605347, -0.053131104, -0.013214111, -0.0070343018, 0.017822266, -0.040008545, -0.0004043579, -0.012107849, 0.0019493103, 0.030166626, -0.015541077, -0.0079193115, -0.033325195, -0.08135986, -0.024414062, -0.012374878, 0.032348633, -0.09802246, 0.009727478, 0.06210327, -0.018997192, -0.07208252, 0.10229492, 0.063964844, -0.030700684, 0.029174805, -0.009757996, 0.007221222, -0.015838623, 0.011688232, 0.033111572, 0.011444092, 0.060913086, -0.044799805, 0.009483337, -0.027633667, 0.02067566, 0.0071640015, -0.005844116, 0.12017822, -0.0012054443, 0.013343811, 0.039489746, -0.029541016, -0.030014038, -0.030914307, -0.064575195, 0.01638794, 0.05114746, 0.010063171, 0.0062446594, -0.043762207, -0.007369995, 0.02947998, 0.017074585, 0.014190674, -0.000017285347, -0.005077362, -0.007675171, 0.06573486, -0.023529053, 0.017196655, 0.021072388, -0.013755798, 0.004295349, -0.031585693, -0.009300232, 0.021240234, -0.036132812, 0.024215698, -0.0385437, -0.005836487, -0.005393982, -0.033203125, -0.0077934265, -0.02168274, -0.019836426, 0.013252258, -0.0021362305, 0.01763916, -0.07702637, -0.019866943, -0.042541504, -0.012893677, -0.06793213, -0.026641846, 0.042785645, -0.015930176, -0.05670166, 0.0057678223, 0.011810303, 0.008903503, -0.0018568039, 0.017227173, -0.01335907, 0.019607544, 0.03970337, -0.030136108, 0.043518066, 0.040130615, 0.060424805, -0.002111435, 0.025222778, -0.049591064, 0.036468506, 0.022842407, 0.05722046, -0.02684021, 0.01701355, -0.0048065186, 0.013893127, 0.01058197, -0.021148682, 0.01499939, -0.0027446747, 0.03250122, -0.0118637085, 0.00881958, 0.046081543, -0.064453125, 0.050598145, 0.004085541, 0.04458618, -0.07476807, -0.073791504, -0.03074646, 0.0016775131, -0.04449463, 0.053009033, 0.10784912, -0.047607422, 0.039978027, 0.00843811, -0.030090332, -0.06390381, 0.0715332, -0.016540527, 0.05368042, 0.014076233, -0.044006348, 0.025527954, -0.048675537, 0.016189575, -0.0047912598, 0.011474609, 0.0073280334, 0.005302429, 0.011062622, 0.041748047, 0.06210327, -0.0037651062, 0.016403198, -0.024337769, -0.03652954, 0.0014543533, 0.0129470825, 0.022003174, -0.06451416, -0.03112793, 0.036834717, -0.06359863, -0.0014533997, 0.015174866, 0.023834229, -0.00091838837, -0.007583618, 0.029846191, 0.017028809, -0.037231445, 0.022140503, 0.042907715, 0.0045776367, -0.13916016, -0.015457153, -0.023468018, -0.044555664, -0.024795532, -0.012275696, 0.048736572, -0.04437256, 0.035125732, -0.027328491, -0.022994995, -0.042266846, 0.04296875, 0.06365967, -0.034118652, -0.02859497, 0.022094727, -0.003932953, 0.012039185, -0.050476074, 0.009284973, 0.046539307, -0.019622803, -0.04360962, 0.04260254, 0.0008430481, 0.0029258728, -0.0073623657, 0.015106201, -0.024368286, 0.011276245, 0.013801575, -0.026351929, 0.046142578, 0.02748108, -0.06933594, -0.032562256, 0.022338867, 0.010169983, 0.005569458, -0.0070114136, -0.0037784576, -0.0039596558, 0.029754639, -0.006881714, 0.0061302185, 0.0009498596, 0.062927246, -0.036254883, 0.04626465, -0.01914978, 0.022094727, -0.070251465, -0.00762558, 0.0055122375, -0.06530762, 0.021865845, 0.03945923, 0.039245605, -0.0073242188, 0.008422852, 0.004787445, 0.04647827, -0.012313843, -0.02420044, 0.0027713776, 0.05343628, 0.017028809, 0.0021896362, -0.00062704086, -0.030654907, -0.023986816, 0.039611816, -0.00025224686, 0.050323486, -0.0075035095, -0.019210815, -0.037750244, -0.019927979, -0.014167786, 0.010597229, -0.020401001, 0.019317627, -0.02784729, -0.038269043, 0.0138168335, 0.033294678, 0.007980347, -0.0015640259, 0.004310608, 0.009544373, -0.037841797, 0.013748169, 0.0135269165, 0.031921387, 0.0134887695, -0.011116028, -0.015777588, -0.015319824, 0.003288269, -0.0037879944, 0.02331543, 0.018234253, -0.026535034, 0.0017576218, -0.050750732, 0.022384644, 0.018417358, -0.01876831, 0.002286911, -0.013122559, 0.011772156, -0.0016355515, -0.012794495, 0.010902405, -0.006752014, -0.012527466, -0.015541077, 0.01940918, -0.050567627, -0.03564453, -0.007827759, 0.0025806427, -0.07019043, -0.042755127, 0.014579773, -0.0368042, 0.0052986145, -0.048065186, 0.03479004, -0.021392822, 0.003780365, -0.020462036, -0.020126343, 0.08770752, 0.0112838745, -0.041137695, -0.008605957, -0.011642456, 0.017105103, -0.009628296, -0.047668457, 0.052978516, 0.05496216, -0.00233078, 0.0096588135, -0.07165527, 0.020950317, -0.05657959, 0.026016235, 0.039794922, -0.042388916, 0.019638062, -0.04699707, -0.012626648, -0.036590576, 0.021011353, 0.047424316, 0.061157227, -0.044158936, -0.002128601, 0.059509277, -0.009689331, -0.044128418, 0.035095215, -0.006149292, -0.03353882, 0.05731201, 0.05053711, -0.004928589, 0.01979065, -0.0058288574, 0.0039634705, -0.027297974, -0.0040283203, 0.03768921, 0.02508545, -0.03552246, -0.025985718, 0.027374268, 0.047607422, 0.0067825317, -0.019134521, 0.0014467239, -0.0061569214, -0.027648926, -0.027435303, 0.0021533966, 0.0028972626, 0.010787964, -0.047210693, -0.019577026, 0.0022602081, 0.017791748, -0.00014078617, 0.00012433529, 0.010498047, -0.023391724, -0.020568848, 0.003501892, 0.017440796, -0.02961731, 0.04034424, -0.04574585, -0.05670166, 0.010604858, -0.018798828, -0.06173706, -0.024841309, -0.031311035, -0.028625488, 0.009353638, 0.0041503906, -0.0071411133, 0.0032958984, 0.01423645, 0.017929077, 0.017105103, 0.0077285767, -0.01852417, -0.0047073364, 0.004776001, 0.028015137, -0.03778076, 0.01322937, -0.009490967, 0.031982422, 0.020599365, -0.017501831, -0.020965576, -0.08282471, 0.019012451, 0.02192688, -0.04135132, 0.034851074, 0.03741455, 0.0317688, -0.015579224, 0.025863647, 0.005821228, -0.025558472, 0.014915466, 0.04083252, 0.03781128, -0.018203735, 0.0027256012, 0.03640747, -0.002702713, -0.029724121, -0.00024056435, 0.014007568, -0.00045490265, -0.0031471252, -0.0054626465, 0.025863647, -0.011665344, -0.05432129, 0.0031051636, -0.01033783, -0.0038547516, -0.002878189, -0.024673462, -0.005306244, -0.041992188, 0.0031433105, -0.0072250366, 0.024795532, 0.044799805, -0.0011453629, -0.0390625, -0.007507324, -0.009155273, 0.024627686, -0.01991272, -0.032470703, -0.031463623, -0.045410156, 0.020050049, 0.008583069, 0.02784729, -0.020050049, -0.013893127, 0.0033435822, 0.008987427, 0.00730896, -0.03302002, -0.008110046, 0.0035953522, 0.013771057, 0.04107666, -0.03213501, -0.011238098, -0.007671356, -0.036590576, 0.016921997, 0.008483887, -0.022918701, -0.04660034, 0.020828247, -0.0012760162, -0.017929077, 0.03945923, 0.013191223, -0.0047454834, -0.010749817, 0.013244629, -0.014732361, -0.041900635, -0.0062675476, 0.03930664, -0.005367279, 0.010681152, 0.020843506, -0.0021686554, -0.008369446, 0.00554657, -0.018157959, -0.005718231, -0.06896973, -0.039215088, -0.0016059875, 0.002986908, 0.024169922, -0.016677856, 0.010986328, -0.0012283325, 0.008377075, -0.014060974, -0.019104004, -0.0034999847, -0.028182983, -0.004081726, -0.011398315, -0.017959595, -0.02810669, 0.06390381, -0.021575928, -0.028015137, 0.0054092407, -0.0023155212, -0.012107849, 0.009902954, 0.0005507469, -0.0070343018, -0.049346924, 0.044555664, 0.018814087, -0.030197144, -0.0058670044, 0.014038086, 0.004798889, -0.041381836, -0.040374756, -0.05203247, -0.049560547, -0.024780273, 0.054473877, -0.021484375, 0.03201294, 0.0236969, -0.06982422, -0.009307861, 0.0141067505, -0.012924194, 0.017166138, -0.010734558, -0.018676758, 0.02798462, 0.020736694, -0.06286621, 0.01927185, 0.044891357, -0.059020996, 0.014678955, -0.0015563965, 0.0050735474, -0.01398468, -0.01058197, -0.013557434, 0.04043579, -0.0033073425, 0.048217773, 0.042633057, 0.018188477, 0.060791016, 0.04019165, 0.04815674, 0.04840088, -0.0020771027, -0.010353088, -0.0010356903, 0.0440979, -0.007320404, 0.0029582977, -0.033569336, -0.011894226, -0.014152527, -0.008377075, 0.0013589859, -0.010108948, 0.01675415, -0.023117065, 0.01777649, 0.027267456, 0.010421753, 0.03161621, -0.018310547, -0.028182983, 0.012863159, 0.011329651, 0.038269043, 0.009788513, -0.0067329407, 0.008323669, 0.030944824, -0.0063934326, -0.049804688, -0.019210815, -0.009666443, 0.045898438, 0.05807495, -0.015411377, 0.0463562, 0.04135132, 0.007835388, -0.030700684, -0.0256958, 0.015022278, 0.04168701, 0.0028915405, -0.035095215, -0.020568848, -0.027236938, -0.030838013, -0.004863739, -0.016677856, -0.024780273, 0.08026123, -0.01953125, -0.032043457, -0.05001831, -0.06359863, -0.049591064, -0.0055618286, 0.011367798, -0.047668457, 0.068847656, -0.0021686554, 0.027160645, 0.014328003, -0.025421143, -0.0033817291, -0.02558899, 0.025985718, 0.02746582, -0.01965332, -0.012466431, -0.03152466, 0.015975952, -0.0063705444, 0.0463562, -0.017364502, -0.020507812, 0.041107178, -0.0045166016, -0.011268616, -0.007972717, 0.016036987, -0.017547607, -0.007396698, -0.004337311, 0.034729004, 0.0077285767, -0.01979065, -0.034729004, 0.012046814, -0.0013694763, 0.016021729, -0.0058555603, 0.004211426, 0.044952393, -0.040405273, -0.022888184, -0.009819031, -0.011749268, 0.033569336, 0.030654907, 0.009315491, -0.06414795, 0.00003552437, -0.019546509, 0.003293991, -0.0022716522, -0.03463745, -0.03817749, -0.045013428, 0.01939392, 0.035186768, -0.03845215, -0.020355225, 0.0031738281, 0.013198853, -0.01727295, 0.018035889, -0.0033340454, 0.007144928, -0.0063705444, 0.021896362, -0.05831909, 0.039794922, 0.012329102, -0.013694763, 0.015808105, 0.026306152, -0.018173218, 0.023117065, 0.059417725, 0.034362793, 0.047943115, 0.04260254, -0.033050537, 0.0066986084, 0.08215332, -0.018936157, -0.011680603, -0.025772095, -0.011894226, -0.03387451, -0.02468872, -0.008476257, -0.0129470825, -0.028213501, 0.050628662, 0.0026378632, 0.005722046, -0.014190674, -0.05368042, 0.009819031, -0.018463135, 0.05532837, -0.049682617, -0.053009033, 0.009353638, 0.018188477, -0.024383545, -0.028961182, -0.06756592, -0.006801605, -0.050079346, -0.010803223, -0.0025367737, 0.011314392, 0.033966064, -0.017501831, -0.010795593, 0.031311035, 0.0017766953, -0.06311035, 0.006038666, 0.015670776, 0.051452637, -0.03012085, -0.046173096, -0.0025539398, 0.06628418, -0.062347412, 0.0038146973, -0.018127441, -0.043823242, -0.062561035, 0.020004272, -0.006931305, -0.03265381, 0.038269043, 0.042877197, -0.019760132, -0.042633057, 0.01184082, -0.010124207, 0.0519104, -0.0061798096, 0.01512146, 0.064697266, -0.00283432, 0.0087509155, 0.007633209, 0.024276733, 0.012107849, 0.021957397, -0.08178711, 0.012245178, 0.027816772, 0.03579712, 0.021087646, 0.04446411, 0.07879639, 0.011795044, -0.014846802, 0.04550171, -0.0034122467, 0.026748657, 0.06085205, 0.05923462, 0.019714355, -0.048706055, 0.008575439, -0.016983032, 0.027359009, -0.005844116, -0.019546509, 0.0018100739, 0.024353027, -0.048339844, -0.007820129, 0.044036865, -0.012756348, -0.008155823, 0.013923645, 0.037109375, -0.010406494, -0.03375244, -0.046844482, -0.061462402, 0.04043579, 0.015991211, -0.043151855, 0.040527344, -0.05895996, 0.020187378, -0.0054397583, 0.013221741, -0.016616821, 0.025131226, -0.0029277802, -0.010139465, -0.025527954, 0.0018033981, 0.013313293, 0.022949219, -0.0032539368, 0.047027588, 0.016937256, -0.0036144257, -0.0057792664, -0.029373169, -0.033203125, -0.014297485, -0.02482605, 0.020904541, -0.0077323914, 0.00868988, 0.04147339, -0.0057373047, 0.014266968, 0.027618408, 0.05618286, 0.011558533, 0.0035095215, -0.028060913, 0.028549194, -0.0014448166 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1912.09501v1
A Framework for Explainable Text Classification in Legal Document Review
Christian J. Mahoney, Jianping Zhang, Nathaniel Huber-Fliflet, Peter Gronvall, Haozhen Zhao
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Companies regularly spend millions of dollars producing electronically-stored documents in legal matters. Recently, parties on both sides of the 'legal aisle' are accepting the use of machine learning techniques like text classification to cull massive volumes of data and to identify responsive documents for use in these matters. While text classification is regularly used to reduce the discovery costs in legal matters, it also faces a peculiar perception challenge: amongst lawyers, this technology is sometimes looked upon as a "black box", little information provided for attorneys to understand why documents are classified as responsive. In recent years, a group of AI and ML researchers have been actively researching Explainable AI, in which actions or decisions are human understandable. In legal document review scenarios, a document can be identified as responsive, if one or more of its text snippets are deemed responsive. In these scenarios, if text classification can be used to locate these snippets, then attorneys could easily evaluate the model's classification decision. When deployed with defined and explainable results, text classification can drastically enhance overall quality and speed of the review process by reducing the review time. Moreover, explainable predictive coding provides lawyers with greater confidence in the results of that supervised learning task. This paper describes a framework for explainable text classification as a valuable tool in legal services: for enhancing the quality and efficiency of legal document review and for assisting in locating responsive snippets within responsive documents. This framework has been implemented in our legal analytics product, which has been used in hundreds of legal matters. We also report our experimental results using the data from an actual legal matter that used this type of document review.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1912.09501v1
"2019-12-19T19:07:23"
"2019-12-19T19:07:23"
{ "title": [ -0.045074463, 0.0014638901, -0.03186035, -0.03378296, -0.0008883476, 0.0056152344, -0.025543213, -0.0028705597, -0.0059013367, 0.0037651062, -0.04510498, 0.02520752, -0.019348145, 0.0051994324, -0.042266846, -0.0259552, -0.029541016, 0.057861328, -0.011604309, -0.031951904, -0.007167816, -0.047058105, 0.015838623, -0.01259613, 0.043670654, -0.05340576, 0.0105896, -0.01449585, 0.0118255615, -0.027328491, 0.00844574, -0.030471802, 0.02407837, 0.009735107, 0.017059326, 0.018829346, -0.008331299, 0.024551392, 0.014732361, 0.009506226, 0.011688232, -0.013717651, -0.03314209, -0.0018930435, -0.030090332, 0.015579224, -0.040222168, -0.0066375732, -0.00945282, 0.024032593, 0.001953125, 0.0024662018, -0.010765076, 0.009506226, 0.01210022, -0.020767212, -0.017959595, -0.02015686, 0.042785645, 0.030273438, 0.015556335, -0.048187256, 0.015686035, -0.010597229, -0.053344727, -0.0049324036, 0.0064430237, -0.00333786, 0.049102783, -0.018554688, -0.017471313, 0.03012085, 0.0028533936, -0.046142578, -0.029373169, 0.050323486, 0.012489319, 0.0016450882, 0.029296875, -0.03152466, -0.028442383, -0.011833191, 0.006702423, -0.014907837, 0.0075263977, 0.00033807755, -0.014785767, -0.007259369, -0.04147339, -0.05001831, -0.012496948, -0.004421234, -0.02128601, 0.009216309, -0.032714844, -0.019088745, -0.0027809143, 0.04849243, -0.011352539, -0.05581665, -0.007659912, 0.037475586, -0.0770874, -0.00617218, 0.00598526, 0.03857422, -0.00068092346, -0.03265381, -0.0024223328, 0.009025574, -0.03466797, 0.01008606, -0.003791809, -0.03253174, -0.008491516, 0.013404846, -0.0178833, 0.015281677, 0.039733887, 0.019760132, 0.009567261, -0.01991272, 0.013977051, 0.0059394836, -0.0014371872, -0.02696228, -0.059051514, 0.029083252, 0.04168701, 0.037872314, 0.01864624, 0.027328491, -0.12225342, -0.09918213, -0.0769043, 0.033691406, -0.0385437, 0.0058517456, -0.035461426, 0.017715454, 0.009223938, -0.0027656555, 0.030776978, 0.0017385483, -0.012275696, 0.013069153, 0.06726074, 0.0008678436, -0.052703857, -0.075805664, -0.022155762, 0.044311523, 0.08544922, -0.0413208, -0.11047363, -0.056732178, -0.10467529, -0.03640747, -0.004688263, -0.06640625, 0.045928955, 0.007904053, -0.002614975, 0.003643036, 0.032073975, -0.042663574, -0.033966064, 0.02809143, 0.018814087, 0.012420654, 0.017089844, 0.00015187263, -0.010040283, 0.010665894, 0.0024032593, 0.017044067, 0.037719727, 0.011100769, 0.00844574, -0.008369446, 0.0052108765, -0.036376953, 0.006088257, 0.026641846, -0.063964844, -0.0056762695, 0.019088745, 0.027801514, 0.032196045, 0.0069503784, -0.010391235, 0.034332275, -0.028503418, -0.030471802, -0.038848877, -0.017074585, -0.0009870529, 0.020690918, -0.011581421, 0.01576233, -0.010475159, -0.0027370453, -0.018692017, -0.01335144, 0.008094788, -0.0491333, 0.006290436, 0.015975952, -0.02897644, 0.06707764, 0.055511475, 0.030975342, -0.06298828, 0.05038452, 0.0069351196, -0.07421875, 0.027786255, -0.010643005, -0.009643555, -0.07147217, 0.002462387, 0.007083893, 0.0036125183, 0.06896973, 0.021331787, 0.015792847, 0.014625549, -0.016738892, 0.0769043, 0.031555176, 0.080322266, -0.06964111, 0.0925293, 0.05718994, 0.0034599304, -0.028045654, -0.018936157, -0.06262207, 0.0061950684, 0.032348633, -0.013000488, 0.0033397675, -0.014953613, 0.015464783, 0.052581787, 0.00037884712, 0.01285553, 0.012687683, 0.01828003, 0.013755798, 0.053833008, -0.016693115, 0.05722046, 0.016738892, -0.03765869, 0.07611084, 0.009170532, 0.007888794, -0.023803711, 0.035369873, -0.011413574, 0.0463562, 0.03277588, 0.025375366, -0.030700684, 0.022323608, 0.0008559227, 0.024124146, 0.007709503, -0.0045776367, 0.015174866, -0.0078048706, 0.014762878, -0.004875183, 0.020111084, -0.030303955, 0.0012645721, -0.004386902, 0.020507812, -0.030944824, -0.0026931763, 0.031707764, 0.030761719, -0.013214111, 0.0034313202, 0.0029640198, 0.01965332, -0.0137786865, -0.027038574, -0.020248413, 0.022216797, 0.043518066, 0.030029297, -0.030731201, 0.014175415, 0.008666992, 0.076538086, 0.06768799, -0.026657104, 0.04333496, -0.06500244, 0.008384705, 0.018218994, -0.0007405281, 0.022567749, -0.0041770935, 0.030899048, 0.018661499, -0.020614624, 0.0129776, -0.04840088, 0.0026664734, -0.0019197464, -0.07287598, -0.014213562, -0.049072266, 0.00011301041, -0.054351807, -0.0592041, -0.005455017, 0.08087158, -0.0060577393, -0.025436401, -0.004348755, -0.01739502, -0.025924683, 0.008110046, -0.03189087, -0.018417358, 0.03074646, 0.020355225, 0.014770508, -0.061187744, -0.007965088, -0.007381439, 0.017105103, -0.03604126, 0.048339844, -0.03213501, -0.005207062, -0.044067383, -0.03466797, 0.02458191, -0.03967285, 0.025848389, -0.06427002, 0.01878357, 0.008056641, -0.03390503, -0.013832092, 0.040252686, -0.032714844, -0.027511597, -0.007183075, 0.03967285, -0.039093018, -0.009666443, 0.0236969, 0.009941101, -0.020904541, 0.039031982, 0.053710938, 0.027252197, -0.08337402, -0.066589355, -0.043884277, -0.027313232, 0.013130188, -0.018432617, 0.036132812, -0.019058228, -0.009902954, -0.042877197, -0.01335144, 0.0008416176, -0.005882263, -0.014472961, -0.031341553, -0.008361816, -0.018661499, -0.01537323, -0.011566162, 0.004459381, 0.00995636, 0.010559082, 0.035125732, -0.04171753, -0.011024475, -0.007751465, 0.0029029846, -0.006416321, 0.013160706, -0.036010742, -0.0018911362, 0.016799927, -0.011474609, 0.016296387, 0.021911621, -0.08441162, -0.00018298626, 0.012924194, 0.023513794, -0.03515625, 0.032958984, -0.0680542, 0.014022827, -0.011619568, -0.03756714, 0.021743774, 0.030136108, 0.028961182, 0.024993896, 0.03842163, 0.003929138, 0.0017852783, -0.05581665, -0.09411621, 0.00819397, -0.027938843, -0.020751953, 0.0070533752, -0.035888672, -0.06384277, -0.023544312, -0.0087509155, 0.047576904, 0.020874023, -0.0033473969, 0.01689148, -0.012512207, 0.010543823, -0.020324707, -0.011978149, -0.036224365, -0.0071372986, 0.0035686493, -0.019088745, 0.046569824, 0.0029354095, 0.009651184, 0.0056266785, 0.005832672, -0.028427124, 0.013290405, -0.004470825, -0.053466797, 0.0013313293, 0.008003235, -0.018630981, 0.004840851, -0.0066719055, 0.01234436, -0.04208374, 0.0069618225, -0.014503479, 0.014205933, -0.013542175, 0.00919342, -0.0065994263, 0.004371643, 0.021514893, -0.013626099, -0.004611969, 0.019165039, -0.009811401, 0.03112793, 0.013618469, -0.00642395, -0.032348633, 0.012496948, -0.01499939, -0.01424408, -0.02909851, 0.0041923523, 0.027526855, -0.0012216568, -0.01586914, 0.024047852, -0.010185242, -0.0069885254, -0.0029697418, 0.008079529, -0.0073547363, -0.07763672, -0.01448822, 0.0012149811, -0.101867676, -0.038513184, 0.0014820099, -0.028671265, -0.037750244, -0.036193848, 0.0041389465, -0.02319336, -0.045135498, 0.016403198, -0.009857178, 0.031463623, -0.0056037903, -0.07409668, -0.026748657, 0.067993164, 0.0034122467, 0.020370483, 0.068237305, -0.0090789795, -0.026504517, -0.031585693, 0.029434204, 0.022033691, 0.031677246, 0.0088272095, 0.0038661957, 0.031951904, -0.01411438, 0.034454346, 0.009597778, -0.010269165, 0.0050735474, 0.006286621, 0.0010108948, 0.03579712, -0.030181885, 0.078125, 0.01737976, -0.047821045, -0.03540039, 0.008720398, -0.009399414, -0.01158905, 0.01727295, -0.0046920776, 0.0062446594, 0.005760193, 0.023422241, 0.053222656, -0.015701294, -0.010826111, 0.05444336, -0.0044288635, 0.00044107437, -0.0074653625, 0.009391785, 0.04849243, 0.023483276, 0.014808655, 0.0040359497, 0.01361084, -0.020355225, -0.047698975, -0.0024585724, 0.016571045, -0.034057617, 0.0002644062, -0.023010254, -0.07287598, -0.029586792, 0.010421753, -0.02166748, 0.045166016, 0.053863525, 0.0065193176, -0.048553467, 0.014015198, 0.018829346, -0.0076942444, 0.006717682, -0.067871094, 0.016723633, -0.028533936, -0.09020996, -0.03338623, -0.06616211, -0.0075302124, 0.049987793, 0.03353882, -0.011711121, 0.010871887, 0.008636475, 0.010574341, 0.06185913, -0.0017929077, -0.03302002, 0.031036377, -0.0289917, 0.012802124, 0.0124053955, 0.007106781, -0.00315094, 0.010620117, 0.0335083, -0.021453857, -0.049316406, -0.05883789, 0.023284912, 0.0158844, 0.050079346, 0.066833496, 0.033050537, 0.033691406, 0.0022354126, 0.023071289, 0.015899658, -0.037628174, 0.009391785, -0.013748169, 0.03894043, -0.033416748, 0.009185791, 0.03729248, 0.0012702942, 0.0054626465, 0.0146484375, -0.022888184, 0.021850586, 0.00724411, 0.039611816, -0.0025634766, -0.058044434, -0.026382446, -0.00340271, 0.0023441315, 0.04534912, -0.062561035, 0.024505615, 0.017654419, 0.013053894, 0.037994385, -0.0039863586, 0.025772095, -0.00096178055, -0.0052452087, -0.05041504, -0.003200531, 0.0084991455, -0.02810669, -0.0115737915, -0.022003174, 0.013648987, 0.051940918, 0.029388428, 0.023895264, 0.0073280334, 0.013549805, -0.013038635, 0.0020713806, 0.018005371, -0.012817383, -0.050811768, 0.006916046, -0.019577026, 0.005004883, -0.023361206, 0.021438599, -0.04815674, 0.00856781, -0.021133423, -0.0146484375, 0.0060424805, -0.042633057, 0.026824951, 0.055786133, -0.015640259, 0.04208374, -0.02911377, 0.028518677, 0.00073480606, 0.031021118, -0.01361084, 0.016448975, 0.020339966, -0.03213501, -0.051452637, -0.021850586, 0.042633057, 0.019683838, 0.022583008, 0.03366089, 0.019439697, -0.07739258, 0.006465912, -0.04397583, 0.0002168417, -0.02154541, -0.026565552, 0.0022945404, -0.00030899048, 0.010284424, 0.006538391, 0.0115737915, -0.025817871, -0.0045166016, -0.010658264, -0.013145447, 0.0234375, 0.001001358, -0.07470703, -0.070739746, -0.01109314, 0.0029964447, -0.014335632, -0.032958984, 0.029769897, -0.059295654, 0.022827148, 0.038909912, -0.037902832, -0.015258789, -0.0042304993, 0.013938904, 0.021133423, 0.0054969788, -0.025604248, -0.002243042, -0.05444336, -0.053009033, -0.04046631, 0.0107421875, 0.005962372, 0.027114868, -0.004108429, -0.034088135, -0.053344727, 0.033966064, 0.025817871, -0.004547119, -0.08935547, 0.03540039, -0.005493164, 0.0046806335, 0.011009216, 0.03152466, -0.0051002502, 0.008964539, 0.018447876, -0.04559326, 0.018234253, 0.00028705597, 0.050628662, -0.078125, -0.043518066, -0.01234436, 0.030197144, 0.011543274, 0.025772095, 0.02255249, 0.033569336, 0.05734253, 0.006084442, 0.02078247, 0.07470703, -0.04055786, -0.058563232, -0.037628174, 0.0079193115, -0.017456055, 0.074035645, -0.0029087067, -0.050994873, -0.020324707, -0.025527954, -0.023956299, 0.006351471, 0.025100708, -0.0032615662, 0.014022827, -0.034179688, 0.0043678284, -0.038208008, -0.030288696, -0.050323486, 0.04031372, -0.008117676, -0.032073975, 0.040985107, -0.02633667, 0.006542206, -0.023208618, 0.021881104, -0.01109314, -0.0022964478, 0.027954102, -0.0066375732, 0.020584106, -0.011779785, -0.03338623, 0.0038318634, 0.014282227, -0.029556274, 0.018997192, -0.014389038, 0.051239014, 0.032928467, 0.06524658, 0.031829834, 0.036224365, 0.04837036, 0.006629944, 0.01876831, -0.015686035, -0.00039291382, -0.080078125, 0.0024929047, -0.043426514, 0.014427185, -0.06951904, -0.017364502, 0.020233154, 0.015701294, -0.008705139, 0.0013103485, 0.005004883, 0.004272461, 0.029830933, -0.0035953522, 0.038604736, -0.038360596, -0.012130737, -0.00088357925, -0.018569946, 0.046875, 0.027267456, -0.018341064, 0.023422241, -0.018829346, -0.019851685, 0.000043094158, 0.030822754, 0.010353088, -0.016799927, -0.0009069443, -0.029876709, 0.009277344, -0.021255493, -0.0015382767, 0.040374756, 0.033477783, 0.0018291473, -0.022827148, 0.022644043, -0.042938232, 0.01171875, -0.05999756, -0.022613525, -0.017211914, 0.025863647, -0.009689331, -0.014793396, -0.0026054382, 0.025344849, 0.04650879, -0.049438477, -0.019195557, 0.03552246, 0.022857666, -0.03265381, 0.025741577, -0.030639648, -0.013053894, -0.014183044, 0.011428833, 0.00081443787, 0.022460938, 0.038146973, 0.03048706, -0.0016965866, -0.030593872, 0.01335144, 0.00919342, -0.01222229, 0.025024414, -0.0004119873, -0.0015573502, -0.020019531, -0.036193848, 0.0072135925, -0.0017366409, -0.019210815, -0.023452759, 0.025650024, -0.009178162, 0.0018501282, 0.050567627, 0.027618408, -0.013381958, -0.066345215, -0.035461426, 0.013137817, 0.05895996, -0.013824463, 0.029205322, -0.037017822, -0.03881836, 0.034942627, -0.031280518, 0.058288574, -0.048980713, -0.005241394, -0.01802063, 0.031707764, 0.023513794, -0.036102295, -0.040771484, -0.0055999756, 0.021530151, -0.022277832, -0.012771606, -0.046417236, -0.03656006, -0.010696411, 0.053375244, -0.009284973, 0.025634766, 0.011367798, -0.032806396, -0.024932861, 0.03289795, 0.010505676, 0.06640625, -0.027633667, 0.02281189, -0.016784668, 0.01789856, -0.013206482, -0.037078857, -0.0103302, 0.0019550323, -0.0335083, -0.031143188, 0.004047394, 0.007183075, -0.0206604, 0.012397766, -0.00001513958, 0.010047913, -0.019241333, 0.014945984, 0.010040283, -0.039764404, -0.04397583, -0.0018081665, -0.03250122, 0.029190063, 0.026763916, -0.015182495, 0.037017822, 0.0155181885, -0.011230469, -0.036895752, -0.020751953, -0.016906738, -0.0059013367, -0.039154053, 0.0039482117, 0.02734375, 0.0368042, -0.045715332, -0.06640625, 0.015625, 0.04714966, 0.019577026, 0.088012695, 0.0033836365, 0.00844574, -0.04534912, -0.004272461, -0.013053894, -0.017166138, 0.014343262, -0.009460449, 0.005874634, 0.06665039, 0.00012600422, 0.011299133, 0.03656006, 0.0033416748, -0.02319336, 0.02494812, -0.019256592, -0.015304565, 0.018371582, 0.0013847351, -0.0236969, -0.058166504, -0.02999878, 0.03656006, -0.008407593, 0.025161743, 0.01146698, 0.0078048706, 0.008514404, 0.047546387, -0.038269043, -0.042388916, 0.014183044, 0.026519775, -0.009819031, 0.0357666, -0.025177002, 0.004142761, -0.021194458, -0.011489868, -0.0038585663, -0.013313293, 0.02848816, -0.007865906, -0.0021839142, -0.030532837, -0.04272461, -0.020690918, -0.037017822, 0.044830322, -0.037139893, -0.0003142357, -0.01802063, -0.010215759, 0.0042152405, 0.037322998, 0.00056648254, -0.01449585, -0.02281189, -0.013038635, 0.033233643, -0.024398804 ], "summary": [ -0.04244995, -0.0423584, -0.028503418, 0.0050354004, -0.048858643, -0.00068855286, -0.029296875, 0.011421204, 0.017089844, 0.01436615, -0.07507324, 0.007843018, 0.00023508072, 0.0055770874, -0.01424408, -0.052825928, -0.03277588, 0.08062744, 0.019546509, -0.021347046, -0.015594482, -0.04800415, -0.0050468445, -0.026535034, 0.032928467, -0.04397583, 0.03652954, -0.01007843, 0.053833008, 0.032348633, 0.018157959, -0.07470703, -0.001953125, -0.0013847351, 0.032226562, 0.019683838, 0.023071289, 0.0028152466, 0.02255249, 0.012191772, 0.016693115, 0.0005340576, 0.025512695, -0.019866943, 0.004386902, -0.0038051605, -0.002193451, -0.046905518, 0.013000488, 0.0017461777, 0.00945282, 0.000092089176, 0.0009908676, -0.017089844, -0.024978638, 0.0032653809, -0.032196045, -0.001619339, 0.017181396, 0.027755737, 0.011024475, -0.017456055, 0.0020122528, -0.017501831, -0.050933838, -0.006717682, 0.0022449493, -0.004421234, 0.02708435, -0.027862549, 0.0003824234, 0.028198242, 0.002954483, -0.08392334, 0.00548172, 0.06793213, -0.010757446, 0.0009937286, 0.0012283325, -0.022369385, 0.010253906, -0.016708374, 0.025970459, -0.031280518, 0.0002593994, -0.02319336, -0.007926941, 0.004928589, -0.033172607, -0.01977539, -0.038513184, -0.011199951, -0.0067749023, -0.00038051605, -0.022735596, -0.020339966, -0.001996994, 0.0061950684, -0.018936157, -0.032440186, 0.012023926, -0.021881104, -0.016479492, -0.013191223, 0.0021591187, 0.06298828, 0.018234253, -0.035461426, -0.004333496, -0.017745972, -0.00028586388, -0.014190674, -0.011520386, -0.036071777, -0.014717102, 0.015426636, -0.009109497, 0.0017585754, 0.019882202, -0.017745972, 0.0006875992, 0.0054512024, 0.0019416809, 0.004673004, -0.0074424744, -0.019561768, -0.02418518, 0.021057129, 0.048736572, 0.046142578, 0.0061187744, -0.00048542023, -0.09753418, -0.059570312, -0.059753418, -0.004688263, -0.02243042, -0.009246826, 0.00085163116, -0.02961731, 0.0423584, -0.0029392242, -0.0012111664, 0.025650024, -0.030334473, 0.016189575, 0.025619507, 0.0030403137, -0.038635254, -0.045837402, -0.0068588257, 0.004524231, 0.09698486, -0.018310547, -0.091918945, -0.060943604, -0.01436615, -0.04043579, -0.019989014, -0.0993042, 0.09674072, 0.020050049, 0.004673004, 0.055114746, 0.028182983, -0.051635742, -0.060577393, -0.0027484894, 0.011413574, -0.024642944, 0.0060310364, -0.01576233, -0.00096845627, -0.022781372, 0.0009675026, 0.0011034012, 0.008972168, 0.036315918, 0.0069885254, -0.02229309, 0.0032539368, -0.038909912, 0.04736328, 0.009399414, -0.009429932, 0.057891846, 0.0035419464, 0.02949524, 0.008911133, 0.005958557, -0.017150879, 0.03869629, -0.020996094, -0.022598267, 0.0033988953, 0.03326416, -0.039794922, 0.008956909, -0.00724411, -0.008323669, 0.039764404, -0.007980347, -0.008026123, -0.052978516, -0.037750244, -0.038604736, 0.010261536, 0.029190063, -0.03552246, 0.047912598, 0.0395813, 0.017532349, -0.066711426, 0.037017822, 0.0071372986, -0.055755615, 0.031204224, -0.024337769, 0.018753052, -0.07318115, 0.053009033, 0.053100586, 0.025161743, 0.07244873, -0.02041626, 0.026550293, -0.011352539, 0.02508545, 0.04699707, 0.024368286, 0.10827637, -0.05517578, 0.08026123, 0.07800293, 0.01197052, -0.0018873215, 0.006526947, -0.10925293, -0.0056533813, 0.04534912, 0.024353027, 0.008361816, -0.022064209, -0.0055007935, 0.048065186, -0.0028572083, 0.008766174, -0.018112183, 0.010688782, 0.03970337, 0.008888245, -0.027313232, 0.030639648, -0.016799927, -0.044067383, 0.06237793, 0.0038166046, -0.00066947937, -0.027526855, 0.03466797, -0.02053833, 0.006839752, 0.026321411, -0.0021839142, 0.0102005005, -0.004508972, 0.025894165, 0.021713257, 0.017211914, -0.037017822, -0.0032157898, -0.019699097, 0.021591187, -0.02192688, -0.026519775, -0.0012931824, -0.024719238, 0.006275177, 0.058807373, -0.011077881, 0.0035266876, 0.035217285, -0.05731201, -0.01977539, 0.006591797, 0.012077332, -0.029037476, 0.0052948, 0.002916336, 0.02470398, -0.00072431564, 0.08343506, 0.024230957, 0.024047852, 0.017715454, 0.038757324, 0.0033130646, 0.025375366, 0.0051116943, 0.0007305145, -0.022567749, 0.030044556, -0.020843506, 0.009864807, 0.023208618, -0.027114868, 0.037322998, 0.017929077, 0.0099487305, -0.013763428, -0.024154663, 0.023834229, -0.0024032593, 0.0063438416, -0.03149414, -0.042633057, -0.026412964, 0.00187397, -0.07067871, -0.015274048, 0.14233398, -0.004600525, 0.006668091, 0.007980347, -0.02482605, -0.06878662, 0.06451416, -0.033966064, -0.019180298, 0.020111084, -0.030914307, -0.008758545, -0.013343811, 0.064819336, -0.019744873, 0.0015678406, -0.009147644, 0.032470703, -0.01524353, -0.01361084, -0.015197754, -0.032989502, 0.0049743652, -0.0051956177, -0.004863739, -0.049682617, 0.019561768, -0.0036697388, -0.03945923, -0.01309967, 0.052337646, -0.029846191, -0.047210693, -0.008888245, -0.015289307, -0.031677246, 0.04550171, 0.030929565, 0.009796143, -0.024780273, 0.027648926, 0.06335449, 0.039611816, -0.1227417, -0.0892334, -0.01701355, -0.035125732, 0.03164673, 0.018920898, 0.022415161, 0.016433716, 0.016738892, 0.0046081543, -0.0032634735, 0.0064353943, -0.023391724, 0.028244019, -0.022644043, -0.012374878, 0.014717102, -0.017852783, -0.0124053955, 0.004463196, 0.0026245117, -0.023239136, 0.021270752, -0.059020996, 0.0032806396, -0.017684937, -0.00055360794, 0.017456055, 0.04888916, -0.046325684, -0.014587402, 0.017837524, -0.004852295, 0.023239136, 0.04333496, -0.041778564, -0.035247803, -0.0001988411, 0.024887085, -0.0014724731, 0.01902771, -0.038635254, 0.052978516, -0.0026798248, -0.018325806, 0.02659607, 0.004383087, 0.0847168, -0.0126571655, 0.079711914, -0.015853882, 0.012123108, -0.05480957, 0.011436462, -0.0069999695, -0.013954163, 0.01007843, 0.022521973, 0.0012540817, -0.038635254, -0.0132369995, 0.027954102, 0.047698975, 0.009002686, -0.007648468, -0.00062942505, 0.017730713, 0.033081055, -0.014076233, -0.0051879883, 0.001414299, -0.0052604675, 0.0087890625, -0.0137786865, -0.030090332, 0.0093688965, -0.04333496, 0.030593872, 0.0064735413, -0.043670654, 0.017227173, -0.0035114288, -0.034088135, 0.007507324, -0.017822266, -0.008712769, 0.021057129, 0.0044898987, 0.0020885468, 0.028411865, 0.033447266, -0.020950317, 0.0309906, -0.015083313, 0.048217773, 0.07043457, -0.031143188, 0.012130737, -0.037902832, -0.013137817, 0.053375244, -0.016952515, 0.05923462, -0.014137268, 0.0045166016, -0.03543091, -0.01020813, -0.0007081032, -0.03857422, -0.030166626, 0.012710571, -0.016693115, -0.01374054, 0.032440186, 0.019378662, 0.041778564, -0.017623901, -0.04699707, 0.024017334, 0.0062713623, -0.078063965, -0.011711121, 0.005130768, -0.030151367, -0.03894043, 0.0076789856, 0.00076818466, -0.034210205, -0.019058228, 0.014595032, -0.025604248, -0.013198853, 0.02230835, -0.010040283, 0.08508301, -0.0024681091, -0.043945312, -0.0096588135, -0.02658081, -0.0019607544, 0.007980347, 0.016296387, 0.035491943, 0.039215088, -0.005104065, 0.001531601, 0.0043411255, 0.04348755, -0.029144287, 0.029830933, 0.02381897, -0.011352539, 0.025894165, -0.007194519, -0.0014486313, -0.0006504059, -0.0028953552, 0.021148682, 0.06951904, -0.026443481, 0.03137207, 0.017822266, -0.04067993, 0.0014009476, -0.0035934448, -0.007888794, -0.0002541542, 0.01927185, 0.040924072, -0.014930725, -0.009437561, 0.0119018555, -0.033233643, -0.03866577, -0.026763916, 0.022537231, 0.029724121, -0.042541504, -0.026153564, 0.02029419, 0.070373535, 0.009941101, 0.01953125, 0.012359619, -0.000023961067, -0.036590576, -0.017440796, -0.009086609, -0.001958847, -0.03564453, -0.016540527, 0.016983032, -0.036621094, -0.018310547, 0.004989624, -0.007144928, 0.01424408, 0.021652222, 0.007873535, -0.039764404, 0.006137848, -0.038391113, 0.011390686, -0.036102295, -0.061462402, 0.009559631, -0.032043457, -0.053863525, -0.027877808, -0.056518555, -0.059326172, 0.009918213, 0.030456543, -0.0014734268, 0.01499176, 0.005443573, -0.0149002075, 0.018615723, -0.008590698, -0.014572144, -0.023605347, -0.035980225, 0.037475586, -0.0035552979, -0.030517578, -0.015617371, 0.021072388, 0.05014038, 0.0007805824, -0.057281494, -0.06958008, 0.02722168, 0.03918457, 0.028457642, 0.07458496, 0.024978638, 0.02998352, 0.029342651, 0.00025749207, 0.0038700104, -0.0072402954, 0.0027065277, -0.028396606, 0.028671265, -0.011047363, 0.022735596, 0.02319336, -0.015068054, -0.010543823, 0.007881165, -0.0040893555, 0.013923645, -0.016998291, 0.04083252, -0.0155181885, -0.036071777, 0.002729416, 0.017990112, -0.008026123, 0.030761719, -0.022216797, -0.016021729, 0.054351807, 0.02281189, 0.035736084, -0.011543274, 0.019515991, 0.011077881, -0.015266418, -0.03265381, 0.043701172, 0.005050659, -0.05596924, -0.008460999, -0.029693604, -0.010864258, 0.009216309, 0.0035648346, -0.022659302, -0.0703125, 0.015823364, 0.023956299, 0.00674057, 0.011428833, 0.0033016205, -0.01637268, -0.038024902, -0.053009033, -0.005859375, 0.012428284, -0.004688263, 0.008483887, -0.004688263, -0.00021111965, 0.0028934479, -0.001821518, -0.03111267, -0.01876831, 0.009666443, -0.027420044, -0.014228821, -0.024551392, -0.0009994507, -0.049346924, 0.025253296, -0.053009033, 0.019363403, -0.00042295456, -0.055847168, -0.06427002, -0.04663086, 0.020126343, 0.051879883, -0.012252808, 0.053497314, 0.0041770935, -0.032562256, -0.020858765, -0.055023193, 0.022140503, -0.03945923, 0.0044059753, 0.018814087, -0.01374054, -0.0002374649, -0.016662598, 0.043304443, -0.03845215, 0.010002136, 0.015945435, 0.024856567, 0.0015563965, 0.0019292831, -0.06237793, -0.044036865, 0.0004940033, 0.013595581, -0.020080566, -0.02748108, 0.04156494, -0.030059814, -0.00655365, -0.00018882751, 0.0019388199, -0.052001953, 0.023834229, 0.031433105, -0.040161133, -0.039611816, -0.016448975, 0.00049495697, -0.0736084, -0.027511597, -0.04586792, 0.0036373138, -0.0024681091, 0.06713867, -0.023895264, -0.0070724487, -0.0569458, 0.010139465, 0.012817383, -0.010437012, -0.10473633, 0.011856079, -0.010574341, 0.004837036, 0.007083893, 0.029312134, -0.057159424, 0.006866455, 0.059417725, -0.07897949, 0.0033550262, -0.004623413, 0.060577393, -0.12756348, -0.021484375, -0.025405884, 0.051452637, 0.026565552, 0.022842407, 0.003063202, 0.0009870529, 0.07623291, -0.0090408325, -0.008575439, 0.055145264, -0.012512207, -0.058441162, -0.044403076, 0.018035889, -0.027038574, 0.0209198, 0.0005865097, -0.053131104, 0.01411438, 0.0028438568, 0.015533447, -0.020935059, -0.007698059, -0.018600464, 0.0035533905, -0.020202637, -0.03842163, -0.0006990433, -0.042877197, -0.030654907, 0.011627197, -0.022033691, -0.040527344, 0.078063965, -0.023498535, -0.009925842, 0.003818512, 0.01889038, -0.007217407, -0.005748749, 0.047058105, 0.040252686, 0.0146102905, -0.01486969, 0.03414917, 0.0075302124, 0.03491211, -0.027832031, 0.008270264, 0.017486572, 0.030197144, 0.019927979, 0.006832123, -0.017623901, 0.022018433, 0.090026855, 0.000029563904, 0.0024471283, 0.0146865845, 0.049041748, -0.034423828, -0.0026474, -0.040252686, -0.034606934, -0.04006958, 0.0079574585, 0.013343811, -0.030334473, 0.019958496, -0.013504028, -0.007972717, 0.03616333, -0.03805542, 0.01008606, -0.019943237, -0.033477783, -0.013679504, -0.0056037903, -0.03564453, 0.02279663, 0.03845215, -0.012397766, 0.011695862, 0.018798828, -0.010574341, 0.02986145, 0.0036201477, -0.017532349, -0.053588867, 0.023147583, -0.037017822, -0.00016522408, -0.0057373047, 0.0036849976, 0.020767212, 0.002632141, 0.029190063, -0.018676758, 0.009033203, -0.0028305054, 0.012794495, -0.031585693, -0.03225708, 0.02796936, -0.0038871765, 0.01890564, -0.018493652, 0.040985107, 0.012901306, 0.06793213, -0.045715332, -0.01335907, 0.028198242, 0.013442993, -0.046417236, 0.0016889572, -0.025741577, -0.029296875, 0.025177002, 0.008430481, -0.01651001, -0.009063721, 0.0121536255, 0.004211426, 0.043792725, 0.0007266998, 0.019088745, 0.009498596, 0.046875, 0.030731201, -0.017578125, -0.0036029816, -0.026901245, -0.026931763, 0.016723633, 0.0011920929, -0.015357971, 0.0045204163, 0.008644104, 0.010505676, 0.001996994, 0.029067993, -0.010482788, -0.005710602, -0.004535675, -0.018539429, 0.008743286, 0.05130005, 0.019210815, -0.008735657, -0.0059661865, 0.013267517, 0.0028953552, 0.027511597, 0.022735596, -0.0592041, -0.009170532, -0.0082473755, 0.009185791, -0.025283813, 0.017715454, -0.044128418, -0.021881104, 0.0501709, -0.012046814, 0.009437561, -0.034606934, -0.035736084, -0.019104004, 0.05682373, -0.022613525, 0.03692627, 0.026870728, -0.03640747, 0.021133423, 0.018493652, 0.040405273, 0.06567383, 0.011665344, 0.011695862, 0.00920105, 0.027038574, -0.009536743, -0.042297363, -0.012420654, 0.06060791, 0.00932312, -0.035888672, 0.026550293, 0.022415161, 0.0040664673, 0.008415222, -0.005065918, 0.015335083, -0.014724731, 0.015853882, 0.012367249, -0.0107040405, 0.000063717365, 0.00028204918, -0.029525757, -0.002412796, -0.008232117, 0.0018062592, 0.047790527, 0.029525757, -0.008094788, -0.055847168, -0.044891357, -0.058654785, -0.002922058, -0.044036865, -0.0093307495, 0.006362915, 0.03552246, -0.011070251, -0.03982544, 0.032409668, 0.0065994263, 0.042755127, 0.0552063, -0.0211792, 0.0019874573, -0.06311035, 0.051361084, -0.016571045, -0.0063209534, 0.03277588, 0.018630981, 0.011253357, 0.041748047, -0.009033203, 0.021835327, 0.014968872, 0.0011606216, -0.053466797, 0.01902771, 0.008796692, -0.07348633, 0.031433105, -0.037353516, -0.0335083, -0.078186035, -0.021087646, 0.04852295, -0.022766113, 0.009674072, 0.018997192, 0.00818634, 0.014076233, 0.016418457, -0.028640747, 0.024505615, -0.029266357, -0.0038719177, -0.0026397705, 0.004711151, -0.012008667, 0.019424438, -0.004547119, -0.016799927, 0.001871109, -0.018188477, 0.0110321045, -0.035736084, -0.018630981, -0.029830933, -0.0206604, -0.04437256, -0.03414917, 0.036315918, -0.017211914, 0.0016717911, 0.019226074, 0.011665344, 0.018051147, 0.014228821, -0.0003247261, -0.0015792847, 0.012062073, -0.02722168, -0.0007619858, -0.00003194809 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/1912.12676v1
Grey Models for Short-Term Queue Length Predictions for Adaptive Traffic Signal Control
Gurcan Comert, Zadid Khan, Mizanur Rahman, Mashrur Chowdhury
eess.SY, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SY
Traffic congestion at a signalized intersection greatly reduces the travel time reliability in urban areas. Adaptive signal control system (ASCS) is the most advanced traffic signal technology that regulates the signal phasing and timings considering the patterns in real-time in order to reduce congestion. Real-time prediction of queue lengths can be used to adjust the phasing and timings for different movements at an intersection with ASCS. The accuracy of the prediction varies based on the factors, such as the stochastic nature of the vehicle arrival rates, time of the day, weather and driver characteristics. In addition, accurate prediction for multilane, undersaturated and saturated traffic scenarios is challenging. Thus, the objective of this study is to develop queue length prediction models for signalized intersections that can be leveraged by ASCS using four variations of Grey systems: (i) the first order single variable Grey model (GM(1,1)); (ii) GM(1,1) with Fourier error corrections; (iii) the Grey Verhulst model (GVM), and (iv) GVM with Fourier error corrections. The efficacy of the GM is that they facilitate fast processing; as these models do not require a large amount of data; as would be needed in artificial intelligence models; and they are able to adapt to stochastic changes, unlike statistical models. We have conducted a case study using queue length data from five intersections with ASCS on a calibrated roadway network in Lexington, South Carolina. GM were compared with linear, nonlinear time series models, and long short-term memory (LSTM) neural network. Based on our analyses, we found that EGVM reduces the prediction error over closest competing models (i.e., LSTM and time series models) in predicting average and maximum queue lengths by 40% and 42%, respectively, in terms of Root Mean Squared Error, and 51% and 50%, respectively, in terms of Mean Absolute Error.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1912.12676v1
"2019-12-29T15:33:03"
"2019-12-29T15:33:03"
{ "title": [ 0.0066604614, 0.0046539307, 0.030883789, -0.019302368, -0.012367249, 0.010620117, 0.022491455, -0.0146484375, -0.019943237, 0.035003662, -0.031341553, 0.0067863464, -0.03591919, -0.0116119385, -0.03781128, -0.016952515, 0.014183044, -0.025482178, -0.038085938, -0.047332764, 0.0061836243, -0.051452637, 0.035064697, 0.081726074, 0.02268982, -0.028930664, -0.046875, 0.00093364716, -0.0151901245, -0.014457703, -0.00097608566, 0.002670288, 0.020843506, 0.0011358261, 0.020187378, -0.01802063, -0.050048828, 0.026550293, 0.0013475418, -0.0029506683, -0.008758545, 0.0079193115, 0.012817383, -0.019317627, -0.019805908, 0.05392456, -0.06866455, -0.0137786865, -0.0116119385, -0.0037498474, 0.0030841827, 0.0154800415, -0.0013227463, 0.00007247925, 0.0028820038, -0.01713562, -0.022323608, -0.02204895, 0.04559326, 0.029205322, 0.0016021729, -0.03100586, 0.021026611, -0.015899658, -0.017593384, 0.0027713776, -0.020217896, 0.014511108, 0.055877686, -0.0069770813, -0.03173828, 0.0022964478, -0.0118255615, 0.016693115, -0.03765869, -0.004337311, 0.042388916, 0.0007081032, 0.01737976, 0.010391235, 0.024963379, 0.00573349, 0.027008057, 0.00057697296, 0.006843567, 0.00005143881, -0.0026245117, -0.011932373, -0.027679443, -0.05645752, -0.028076172, -0.00054740906, 0.0011138916, -0.021774292, -0.03314209, -0.046173096, -0.03010559, 0.024505615, 0.016815186, -0.0004911423, -0.02861023, 0.013290405, -0.03555298, -0.021713257, -0.009757996, 0.0055274963, 0.010826111, 0.014175415, 0.013084412, 0.027755737, -0.02015686, -0.011634827, 0.0008468628, 0.05038452, -0.038360596, -0.004802704, -0.023147583, -0.02859497, -0.038909912, 0.023971558, 0.011650085, -0.002855301, 0.038726807, -0.02104187, -0.012969971, -0.033966064, -0.054595947, 0.01134491, 0.0075683594, 0.06262207, -0.0052757263, 0.0068855286, -0.08270264, -0.046844482, -0.04727173, 0.0027770996, 0.019561768, -0.016296387, 0.0016460419, -0.013458252, 0.021881104, -0.032409668, -0.022659302, 0.016159058, 0.0015897751, 0.012779236, 0.051361084, 0.012893677, -0.041534424, -0.04940796, 0.0016384125, 0.043060303, 0.042114258, -0.019561768, -0.08709717, -0.037231445, -0.09814453, -0.015853882, 0.011932373, -0.03668213, 0.009880066, 0.033843994, 0.03475952, -0.0158844, 0.008468628, -0.050933838, -0.026382446, 0.006061554, -0.0031166077, 0.025817871, -0.026763916, 0.006477356, -0.05529785, -0.046020508, -0.0071372986, 0.00283432, 0.01687622, 0.005470276, 0.043762207, -0.071899414, -0.0048446655, -0.008384705, 0.052947998, 0.025177002, -0.05203247, -0.006340027, 0.010253906, 0.038757324, 0.025909424, 0.01626587, -0.024917603, 0.00038027763, -0.060028076, -0.0056037903, -0.0004415512, 0.019897461, -0.027862549, 0.001821518, -0.0004284382, -0.018951416, -0.021118164, -0.02607727, 0.01625061, -0.010414124, 0.002544403, -0.044128418, -0.0033626556, 0.015029907, -0.004776001, 0.039123535, 0.04309082, -0.0027694702, -0.04159546, 0.06896973, 0.0053863525, -0.026672363, 0.022079468, -0.018798828, -0.01979065, -0.039733887, -0.019866943, -0.009902954, -0.016448975, 0.07244873, -0.038879395, 0.015594482, 0.0043792725, 0.013122559, 0.005104065, 0.025756836, 0.095703125, -0.05126953, -0.013473511, 0.017745972, 0.0024547577, 0.00020897388, -0.027832031, -0.036834717, 0.03152466, 0.022064209, 0.007347107, -0.057922363, 0.0031089783, 0.035888672, 0.029800415, -0.008903503, 0.0026607513, 0.012756348, -0.000828743, -0.007850647, 0.07745361, -0.0012845993, 0.020568848, 0.01777649, 0.02772522, 0.021865845, -0.0049057007, 0.024475098, -0.04586792, 0.019256592, 0.009803772, -0.022735596, -0.0031204224, -0.015533447, 0.0013837814, 0.019821167, -0.008682251, 0.019714355, -0.023223877, 0.029006958, 0.016860962, -0.046875, -0.019104004, -0.058502197, -0.02760315, -0.021270752, -0.04559326, 0.06958008, -0.03186035, -0.08215332, -0.004852295, 0.02658081, 0.0055770874, -0.012680054, -0.011390686, -0.041412354, 0.0074691772, 0.020553589, 0.029876709, -0.015068054, 0.042755127, -0.02079773, -0.021972656, 0.012962341, 0.019256592, -0.048034668, 0.0463562, 0.053588867, 0.0026245117, 0.04598999, -0.07122803, 0.015716553, 0.015991211, 0.0011405945, -0.020996094, 0.027694702, 0.00031375885, 0.020523071, -0.012451172, -0.018157959, -0.020843506, 0.015548706, 0.0054130554, -0.068603516, 0.008140564, 0.010093689, -0.015213013, -0.009361267, 0.027252197, 0.052703857, -0.009552002, 0.009773254, -0.040802002, 0.001953125, 0.005443573, 0.015319824, -0.025939941, -0.0036144257, -0.082092285, 0.026489258, 0.034088135, -0.019378662, -0.042999268, 0.012611389, 0.0008158684, 0.031799316, -0.012649536, 0.056854248, -0.027359009, -0.008865356, -0.045806885, -0.055419922, -0.016204834, -0.04953003, 0.034210205, -0.02633667, -0.020446777, 0.014907837, -0.017974854, 0.010772705, -0.004878998, -0.03062439, -0.031555176, 0.0088272095, 0.03338623, -0.042419434, 0.016082764, 0.030517578, -0.006046295, -0.009437561, 0.052215576, 0.0074539185, 0.01675415, -0.06097412, -0.027496338, -0.062805176, -0.009651184, -0.037231445, -0.035247803, -0.004432678, -0.0692749, -0.06097412, 0.020507812, 0.009056091, 0.04421997, 0.03555298, 0.01586914, -0.040771484, 0.026367188, 0.0051574707, -0.011451721, -0.002910614, -0.03729248, 0.0021305084, 0.09265137, 0.018234253, -0.008369446, -0.0013589859, 0.024887085, 0.009185791, -0.032409668, -0.031402588, -0.0680542, -0.013679504, -0.0044555664, 0.019546509, -0.023925781, -0.048065186, -0.052490234, -0.014480591, -0.027648926, -0.014442444, -0.031280518, 0.018539429, -0.044769287, 0.066101074, -0.041870117, -0.028381348, 0.034606934, -0.0027179718, 0.033325195, -0.02709961, 0.035369873, -0.058776855, 0.0077819824, -0.064086914, -0.08129883, 0.024536133, -0.06713867, -0.01789856, 0.022781372, -0.02810669, -0.011978149, 0.0034942627, 0.0340271, 0.039398193, 0.07489014, -0.016281128, 0.027404785, -0.00491333, 0.056121826, -0.04788208, -0.002483368, -0.012832642, -0.006134033, 0.020065308, -0.0178833, 0.034729004, 0.005710602, 0.0022945404, -0.024307251, 0.001748085, -0.008522034, 0.053100586, 0.005794525, -0.042144775, -0.016052246, -0.021316528, -0.005619049, -0.035491943, -0.008972168, 0.009300232, -0.0028705597, 0.0015068054, -0.003293991, 0.015090942, 0.0029830933, 0.030975342, -0.013542175, -0.0025463104, 0.04812622, -0.009277344, -0.07885742, 0.02885437, -0.012359619, 0.013702393, 0.0038433075, 0.014564514, -0.036010742, -0.00027227402, 0.007045746, 0.0038928986, -0.004814148, -0.019088745, 0.0036182404, -0.018463135, 0.01322937, 0.007911682, -0.0059280396, -0.022766113, 0.014556885, 0.0079193115, -0.03338623, -0.068359375, -0.018859863, -0.0011920929, -0.107421875, -0.03753662, -0.0037631989, 0.025421143, -0.000060498714, 0.02999878, 0.0016765594, 0.041931152, -0.030700684, 0.01651001, -0.0018796921, 0.007160187, 0.014480591, -0.047058105, -0.013038635, 0.051696777, -0.011787415, 0.006916046, 0.009796143, 0.021072388, 0.042510986, 0.023422241, 0.005886078, -0.03656006, 0.06817627, -0.015853882, -0.03765869, 0.040252686, -0.0390625, -0.0038890839, 0.007255554, 0.036956787, -0.049957275, -0.0044517517, 0.010299683, 0.030426025, 0.004714966, 0.05871582, -0.022018433, -0.03265381, -0.013908386, -0.021224976, 0.000042140484, -0.044067383, 0.019424438, -0.020874023, 0.035614014, 0.053253174, -0.016845703, 0.07873535, 0.008979797, 0.023895264, 0.017486572, -0.0446167, -0.0058021545, 0.0034046173, 0.011390686, -0.01171875, -0.008811951, 0.034820557, -0.030303955, 0.06463623, -0.037261963, 0.019836426, 0.00030255318, 0.009056091, -0.011131287, -0.009521484, -0.043426514, -0.008735657, -0.01626587, 0.01637268, -0.0027599335, 0.008590698, 0.0131073, -0.0052757263, -0.06689453, 0.024017334, 0.02609253, -0.025619507, 0.05319214, -0.013771057, -0.012023926, 0.024307251, -0.07159424, -0.021469116, -0.07110596, -0.011314392, -0.0070266724, 0.01058197, -0.028930664, 0.0043258667, 0.015525818, 0.046417236, 0.018173218, 0.0109939575, -0.017410278, 0.024139404, 0.0025501251, -0.09313965, 0.020202637, -0.012527466, -0.007091522, -0.053131104, 0.038757324, -0.041748047, 0.015457153, -0.009727478, -0.008308411, -0.06402588, 0.03086853, 0.018234253, 0.08001709, 0.01071167, 0.02078247, 0.011581421, 0.02281189, -0.02909851, -0.02407837, -0.005092621, 0.0027370453, 0.01360321, 0.0009293556, 0.022491455, 0.010749817, -0.01802063, 0.008087158, 0.019577026, -0.0069274902, 0.030838013, -0.012435913, 0.05291748, 0.051452637, 0.009414673, 0.058258057, 0.0143966675, 0.0418396, -0.0026340485, 0.062469482, -0.071899414, -0.016693115, 0.0000654459, 0.002040863, 0.01361084, -0.016555786, 0.014671326, -0.066101074, -0.023376465, 0.011184692, 0.023635864, -0.03616333, 0.0076065063, 0.002632141, 0.01436615, -0.013900757, 0.034423828, -0.022140503, 0.050109863, 0.0021476746, -0.010948181, -0.0063095093, -0.041168213, -0.035858154, -0.022994995, 0.003293991, 0.016311646, -0.0012273788, 0.013343811, -0.053131104, 0.009422302, -0.0019836426, 0.006614685, -0.015945435, -0.032714844, 0.048583984, 0.05697632, -0.011627197, 0.035095215, 0.05596924, 0.012283325, 0.015014648, 0.070617676, -0.010154724, 0.06750488, 0.025985718, -0.015686035, 0.049224854, -0.016494751, 0.00086450577, -0.01348114, 0.015144348, -0.01134491, 0.025817871, -0.040863037, 0.011619568, 0.013458252, -0.0008921623, 0.0021915436, -0.02861023, 0.023880005, 0.041809082, -0.0022621155, 0.03616333, -0.02041626, 0.0079574585, 0.021362305, 0.007835388, -0.0010576248, 0.0005221367, 0.016693115, -0.027313232, -0.014541626, 0.056396484, -0.024505615, 0.01134491, 0.0026493073, -0.013198853, -0.011871338, 0.0063285828, 0.033233643, -0.05505371, 0.041046143, 0.011398315, 0.018554688, 0.05670166, 0.007987976, -0.08569336, -0.012519836, -0.024291992, -0.04058838, -0.07220459, -0.015792847, 0.009757996, 0.048553467, 0.0040245056, -0.009056091, 0.007873535, -0.021636963, 0.021652222, 0.008811951, 0.0064048767, 0.047607422, 0.00023710728, 0.0023708344, 0.024795532, 0.065979004, 0.02192688, 0.006187439, 0.009178162, -0.05645752, 0.024154663, 0.021652222, 0.045654297, -0.029312134, -0.04800415, 0.004425049, 0.018997192, 0.016860962, -0.024475098, 0.040405273, 0.027496338, -0.0211792, 0.0046844482, 0.005077362, 0.061584473, -0.057373047, -0.03918457, -0.0038909912, 0.012954712, -0.013168335, 0.05215454, -0.017913818, -0.032928467, -0.020065308, -0.011779785, -0.019622803, 0.044677734, 0.06695557, -0.010765076, 0.08691406, -0.06896973, -0.06359863, -0.024734497, 0.032684326, -0.015205383, 0.02293396, 0.012519836, 0.014190674, -0.07470703, 0.020446777, 0.0042495728, -0.03591919, -0.009780884, 0.007785797, 0.015808105, -0.0078086853, -0.025405884, -0.014518738, 0.011054993, -0.021957397, 0.0023059845, -0.012390137, 0.007850647, 0.040374756, -0.037322998, 0.009284973, 0.013679504, 0.044036865, 0.047027588, 0.03741455, -0.017715454, 0.006679535, 0.031677246, -0.030288696, 0.017364502, -0.030410767, -0.0713501, -0.08416748, -0.047973633, -0.07354736, 0.014038086, -0.04550171, -0.016143799, 0.015472412, -0.01386261, -0.025527954, 0.02796936, 0.021316528, 0.036621094, 0.02130127, -0.013923645, -0.026626587, -0.0012512207, 0.026168823, 0.028457642, 0.034362793, 0.0056495667, 0.0016384125, -0.014976501, -0.0446167, -0.02571106, 0.040618896, 0.022903442, 0.022109985, -0.004627228, -0.011146545, 0.014289856, 0.0022697449, 0.010971069, 0.04849243, 0.040100098, -0.025039673, 0.0042800903, 0.01626587, 0.06021118, -0.024353027, 0.06744385, 0.07446289, -0.033843994, 0.04232788, -0.003276825, -0.0513916, 0.02784729, 0.01663208, 0.029541016, -0.052001953, -0.033691406, 0.012237549, 0.013282776, 0.0011997223, 0.011054993, -0.03277588, -0.01525116, 0.03274536, 0.017456055, -0.010368347, 0.0102005005, 0.023544312, 0.07141113, -0.034240723, 0.04763794, 0.00541687, -0.015670776, -0.018218994, 0.025421143, -0.08666992, 0.007369995, -0.015640259, -0.037322998, 0.005332947, -0.015960693, -0.016174316, -0.019302368, 0.03186035, 0.05911255, -0.015365601, 0.007091522, -0.029830933, -0.058532715, 0.036956787, -0.023117065, 0.0138168335, 0.061431885, 0.0023422241, 0.047302246, -0.038879395, -0.051818848, 0.06994629, -0.039978027, 0.059783936, -0.046325684, 0.015823364, -0.03677368, 0.046661377, 0.002500534, -0.06933594, -0.033935547, -0.04171753, 0.01121521, -0.011734009, -0.03314209, -0.016906738, -0.0256958, -0.0052452087, 0.059051514, 0.038269043, -0.024780273, -0.008110046, -0.0018081665, -0.035858154, -0.037597656, -0.033233643, -0.0039787292, -0.003829956, -0.012107849, 0.014152527, 0.019683838, 0.008758545, -0.0345459, -0.038269043, 0.011978149, 0.030441284, -0.031341553, -0.0066947937, -0.014854431, 0.0038528442, 0.07208252, 0.036346436, 0.022033691, 0.015640259, 0.006816864, 0.009315491, -0.018920898, -0.026123047, 0.0024700165, -0.05215454, 0.0014619827, -0.00093984604, -0.0020503998, 0.01411438, 0.011161804, -0.005680084, -0.011329651, 0.034454346, 0.034820557, -0.018753052, -0.00957489, 0.016342163, 0.00982666, 0.038726807, -0.045562744, -0.0357666, -0.038726807, 0.0062713623, -0.0024852753, 0.01171875, 0.011924744, -0.0041389465, -0.010276794, 0.004890442, 0.0019025803, -0.019088745, -0.070739746, -0.019195557, 0.08972168, 0.027297974, -0.028076172, -0.014816284, 0.0077552795, -0.022232056, -0.002128601, -0.017059326, 0.012672424, -0.012413025, -0.012886047, 0.024429321, -0.0022830963, -0.011100769, 0.035705566, 0.023223877, -0.015586853, 0.018112183, 0.0027160645, -0.013244629, 0.00014805794, 0.009536743, -0.0135269165, 0.009925842, 0.010437012, 0.016998291, 0.009002686, 0.036865234, -0.014030457, -0.0008940697, 0.013290405, 0.0011177063, -0.013008118, -0.0006875992, 0.03778076, -0.022476196, -0.019973755, -0.0105896, -0.062408447, 0.03540039, -0.0064888, 0.0181427, -0.057159424, 0.040039062, -0.008483887, -0.04034424, 0.0014123917, -0.016601562, 0.021194458, -0.014625549, -0.032836914, -0.021697998, 0.0020275116, -0.0118255615 ], "summary": [ 0.030929565, -0.021728516, 0.05657959, 0.014381409, -0.044158936, -0.006385803, 0.024414062, -0.026992798, 0.0032043457, 0.035125732, -0.04626465, -0.029205322, 0.016601562, -0.010734558, -0.029846191, -0.04888916, 0.025512695, -0.010505676, -0.008583069, -0.044647217, 0.021835327, -0.030273438, 0.017349243, 0.09832764, 0.021377563, 0.0035762787, 0.005104065, 0.0026435852, 0.00983429, 0.00024199486, 0.014266968, -0.014312744, 0.015655518, 0.011405945, 0.009017944, -0.00026988983, 0.0014438629, 0.0050239563, 0.012863159, 0.008003235, -0.015899658, 0.015335083, 0.101989746, -0.031158447, -0.0035915375, 0.060638428, -0.048339844, -0.024902344, 0.014305115, -0.007007599, 0.0072250366, 0.008354187, 0.015701294, -0.009063721, -0.020370483, -0.010673523, -0.030273438, 0.005756378, 0.022506714, 0.034698486, 0.003408432, -0.017700195, -0.003862381, -0.036499023, -0.029846191, -0.016647339, -0.012542725, 0.012237549, 0.039611816, -0.014389038, 0.008491516, 0.028518677, -0.018814087, -0.012260437, -0.0036849976, -0.0025157928, 0.03250122, -0.018981934, -0.009216309, 0.038635254, 0.042053223, 0.014640808, 0.03479004, -0.0446167, 0.02154541, -0.03805542, -0.007633209, -0.0060920715, -0.013412476, -0.041259766, -0.022216797, 0.007411957, -0.040374756, 0.0075149536, -0.01902771, -0.025634766, -0.011131287, -0.0065307617, -0.02041626, 0.02017212, -0.011352539, -0.0024814606, 0.025314331, -0.02255249, -0.0025100708, 0.040802002, -0.011062622, -0.032958984, 0.0076789856, 0.016693115, -0.0053596497, -0.028152466, -0.012710571, 0.045532227, -0.05255127, 0.009796143, -0.03137207, -0.020477295, -0.052947998, 0.031463623, -0.020812988, -0.000112235546, -0.0075645447, -0.016677856, -0.01335907, -0.030532837, -0.02519226, 0.023239136, -0.013298035, 0.051452637, -0.018066406, -0.00945282, 0.011047363, 0.021118164, -0.014373779, -0.02230835, 0.025039673, 0.0037784576, 0.009216309, -0.006252289, 0.029846191, -0.032592773, -0.028030396, 0.024734497, -0.007827759, 0.030593872, 0.019180298, 0.01826477, -0.014602661, -0.05810547, 0.024139404, -0.010192871, 0.04083252, -0.030853271, -0.06921387, -0.056549072, -0.068481445, -0.013038635, 0.015457153, -0.035369873, 0.033935547, 0.016235352, 0.011802673, 0.004886627, -0.033050537, -0.038024902, 0.0057868958, -0.0054473877, -0.0044517517, -0.0340271, 0.014381409, -0.0074043274, -0.067871094, -0.030288696, 0.021072388, 0.0023994446, -0.0019874573, 0.029144287, 0.047302246, -0.04840088, -0.031234741, -0.047332764, 0.06262207, -0.0015926361, -0.048919678, 0.05630493, -0.0025234222, 0.06866455, 0.029907227, 0.0032348633, 0.008354187, 0.013938904, -0.005180359, 0.030883789, 0.005302429, -0.026824951, -0.032043457, -0.0022144318, -0.014816284, -0.044006348, 0.030258179, -0.05984497, 0.0501709, -0.057495117, 0.0028133392, -0.036621094, -0.0025310516, 0.0018930435, 0.021392822, 0.040740967, -0.004081726, -0.024963379, -0.010627747, 0.0395813, 0.012825012, -0.019973755, 0.033050537, -0.017028809, -0.0051498413, -0.031204224, -0.011169434, 0.0031337738, -0.037506104, 0.052978516, -0.05883789, 0.00579834, -0.014076233, 0.016494751, -0.025772095, 0.0024738312, 0.09118652, -0.033325195, -0.020324707, 0.0009784698, -0.02015686, -0.005329132, -0.009971619, -0.050994873, 0.026153564, 0.03164673, 0.027252197, -0.03540039, -0.011360168, 0.018859863, -0.008140564, 0.00617218, 0.027282715, -0.011985779, -0.010520935, -0.016418457, 0.09918213, -0.02609253, 0.00969696, 0.011459351, 0.043548584, -0.019561768, -0.022216797, -0.008300781, -0.009719849, 0.00548172, 0.0043678284, -0.049072266, -0.011924744, -0.011917114, 0.06555176, -0.032104492, 0.02368164, 0.0045166016, -0.010696411, 0.0012550354, 0.0059280396, -0.084228516, -0.015625, -0.08709717, -0.1149292, -0.022384644, -0.061309814, 0.098083496, -0.018707275, -0.08001709, 0.0058898926, 0.018005371, 0.004638672, -0.011299133, 0.013626099, -0.048950195, 0.0032444, 0.02720642, 0.04446411, 0.01828003, 0.04147339, -0.025787354, -0.008232117, 0.014167786, 0.023406982, -0.054473877, 0.00008791685, 0.041534424, -0.0071258545, 0.0073165894, -0.013832092, 0.03186035, -0.014190674, -0.0013427734, 0.0034313202, -0.015525818, 0.0060195923, 0.02128601, 0.0069847107, -0.026733398, -0.031311035, 0.0040740967, 0.015411377, 0.029754639, -0.008544922, -0.0068206787, -0.025497437, 0.0317688, 0.043548584, 0.060699463, 0.015792847, 0.025009155, -0.026260376, -0.006549835, 0.011001587, -0.016357422, -0.017868042, -0.008331299, -0.0491333, 0.0107803345, -0.029296875, -0.03225708, -0.025360107, 0.073791504, -0.0015296936, 0.03074646, 0.011871338, 0.03189087, 0.002916336, -0.0038986206, 0.003578186, -0.004634857, -0.00242424, -0.014907837, 0.0048217773, 0.023208618, -0.023406982, 0.02960205, -0.046661377, 0.019119263, -0.014602661, -0.030075073, -0.025177002, 0.05166626, 0.029418945, -0.046539307, 0.024932861, 0.06762695, 0.012557983, -0.0071258545, 0.024124146, 0.008049011, -0.0069007874, -0.059387207, -0.021469116, -0.022979736, -0.004650116, -0.022476196, 0.0029392242, -0.0052223206, -0.04537964, -0.0061416626, 0.038848877, 0.0028495789, 0.04272461, 0.01676941, 0.057891846, -0.023330688, 0.030899048, 0.039489746, -0.00033664703, 0.0075798035, -0.022827148, 0.0016012192, 0.056671143, 0.003419876, -0.00217247, 0.015380859, 0.040405273, 0.011375427, 0.0019111633, -0.006126404, -0.075683594, -0.017181396, 0.0010719299, 0.019012451, 0.0039482117, -0.010559082, -0.047210693, -0.031082153, -0.0435791, 0.0050582886, -0.015731812, 0.010047913, -0.02468872, 0.10321045, -0.01638794, -0.031677246, 0.042633057, -0.0569458, 0.014060974, 0.00831604, 0.027572632, -0.043273926, -0.017791748, -0.030181885, -0.032043457, -0.0027980804, -0.050811768, 0.007575989, 0.02432251, 0.0074310303, 0.011932373, 0.026153564, 0.06274414, -0.010559082, 0.050750732, -0.045684814, 0.00920105, 0.056396484, 0.051940918, -0.020584106, -0.0034980774, -0.0014467239, 0.012969971, -0.02255249, -0.023086548, -0.047668457, 0.010116577, -0.03451538, -0.049041748, -0.0026874542, -0.010040283, 0.03543091, -0.004348755, -0.021438599, -0.007926941, -0.064208984, -0.001868248, -0.031921387, -0.010787964, 0.009567261, 0.018081665, 0.012382507, -0.010353088, 0.014152527, -0.008308411, 0.014015198, 0.060272217, 0.011390686, 0.0064849854, 0.010421753, -0.055725098, 0.028182983, 0.0043411255, 0.03265381, -0.036010742, -0.0005736351, -0.03881836, 0.0013113022, 0.0047454834, 0.015975952, 0.04168701, -0.021118164, -0.020553589, -0.0435791, 0.05505371, -0.011405945, 0.018997192, -0.043823242, 0.020767212, 0.0051193237, -0.02053833, -0.024551392, 0.0043258667, 0.010414124, -0.08203125, -0.03955078, -0.0016927719, 0.041656494, -0.033996582, 0.028533936, -0.0058250427, 0.039855957, -0.020690918, 0.053497314, -0.0042037964, 0.018737793, 0.017333984, -0.03189087, 0.0070114136, 0.0043640137, -0.031799316, -0.0093688965, -0.013900757, 0.03781128, 0.06359863, 0.033416748, -0.018676758, -0.0368042, 0.047180176, -0.04196167, 0.016403198, 0.030578613, -0.036987305, -0.004699707, -0.007545471, 0.02355957, -0.041748047, 0.0010824203, -0.01084137, 0.025375366, 0.008270264, 0.03375244, -0.013305664, -0.012466431, -0.0018806458, 0.016113281, 0.0011262894, -0.05831909, 0.0256958, 0.0012540817, 0.0075149536, 0.06512451, -0.004146576, 0.050689697, -0.029891968, 0.039154053, 0.02708435, -0.024139404, -0.049682617, -0.038269043, 0.019714355, -0.00006490946, -0.0048332214, 0.03125, 0.0045166016, 0.058685303, -0.053344727, 0.023345947, 0.005756378, 0.0075912476, -0.048583984, -0.020889282, -0.008514404, 0.00349617, -0.007904053, -0.010971069, -0.014755249, 0.016494751, 0.015182495, -0.014877319, -0.03805542, 0.013420105, 0.00856781, 0.001996994, 0.0020771027, -0.034179688, -0.02268982, -0.010971069, -0.051208496, -0.018188477, -0.055664062, -0.034057617, -0.02861023, 0.04058838, -0.024887085, 0.0022525787, 0.01802063, 0.047210693, 0.008338928, 0.021377563, -0.0181427, -0.018981934, -0.010948181, -0.039093018, 0.01953125, -0.034210205, -0.020614624, -0.04763794, 0.021408081, -0.009971619, 0.001159668, -0.030639648, -0.01676941, -0.0061798096, -0.010612488, 0.04257202, 0.06781006, 0.011444092, 0.0036849976, 0.012825012, 0.016174316, -0.011138916, -0.02645874, 0.033416748, -0.039367676, 0.07318115, -0.0028419495, 0.0418396, -0.01486969, -0.0619812, 0.0463562, 0.0096206665, 0.02633667, 0.011222839, -0.0067977905, 0.038208008, 0.04788208, -0.014694214, 0.041259766, 0.011238098, 0.015380859, 0.012413025, 0.018737793, -0.04953003, -0.0154800415, -0.0016002655, -0.022827148, -0.014335632, -0.012069702, -0.0037326813, -0.07879639, -0.02949524, -0.009391785, 0.049865723, -0.03503418, -0.019515991, -0.01008606, -0.02142334, -0.016433716, 0.019439697, -0.041900635, 0.024490356, 0.024765015, -0.0146484375, -0.015731812, -0.025421143, -0.005382538, -0.05633545, 0.0044517517, 0.006210327, -0.000081539154, 0.008422852, -0.007865906, 0.012771606, 0.018203735, -0.011703491, -0.006576538, -0.036499023, 0.009307861, 0.041656494, -0.05899048, 0.022216797, 0.10412598, -0.008934021, -0.0076560974, 0.03463745, -0.016296387, 0.051818848, -0.023254395, -0.0032730103, 0.05529785, -0.013572693, -0.022079468, 0.03262329, 0.031951904, -0.006298065, 0.02558899, 0.015525818, -0.011703491, -0.012931824, 0.020507812, -0.00048565865, -0.018692017, 0.00819397, 0.024383545, 0.0018978119, 0.017593384, -0.011077881, -0.009803772, 0.039794922, -0.0020427704, 0.017425537, 0.0018053055, 0.030319214, -0.013114929, -0.020568848, 0.048675537, -0.049468994, -0.003578186, -0.0017366409, -0.024520874, -0.011360168, 0.019683838, -0.007865906, -0.026901245, -0.0075149536, 0.059814453, 0.023803711, 0.025268555, -0.01259613, -0.047058105, 0.0066986084, -0.061645508, -0.009857178, -0.036956787, 0.00793457, 0.025863647, 0.058807373, 0.03543091, 0.020492554, 0.03894043, -0.039611816, 0.009742737, -0.02418518, 0.037506104, 0.057434082, -0.015182495, -0.030273438, 0.019485474, 0.013999939, -0.024887085, -0.0017757416, 0.0049819946, -0.047180176, 0.01802063, 0.015670776, 0.032440186, -0.028198242, -0.06945801, 0.0149002075, 0.013374329, 0.01600647, -0.02583313, 0.042419434, 0.01058197, -0.042633057, 0.034362793, 0.006198883, 0.02885437, -0.01260376, -0.080444336, -0.012260437, 0.024871826, -0.00415802, 0.004753113, 0.0008735657, -0.062683105, 0.0088272095, -0.0095825195, 0.005771637, 0.010284424, 0.056121826, -0.015640259, 0.09753418, -0.06524658, -0.091796875, -0.008323669, 0.039611816, 0.010681152, 0.022079468, -0.004508972, 0.0049934387, -0.04864502, 0.025421143, -0.023925781, 0.027816772, 0.0011110306, -0.011253357, -0.017990112, 0.026687622, 0.017547607, 0.0107040405, -0.021102905, -0.007610321, 0.021636963, 0.016204834, 0.0023612976, 0.05178833, -0.026290894, 0.018356323, 0.013038635, 0.020965576, 0.022644043, 0.014556885, -0.011154175, 0.007896423, 0.035583496, -0.027496338, 0.013496399, 0.00390625, -0.10498047, -0.083496094, -0.07110596, 0.00040102005, 0.055023193, -0.08874512, -0.021102905, -0.0047073364, 0.003227234, -0.04989624, 0.033081055, -0.03225708, 0.031677246, -0.02633667, 0.014968872, -0.022705078, 0.0069885254, 0.0112838745, 0.008766174, 0.027862549, 0.013961792, -0.004436493, 0.0043640137, -0.01737976, -0.005367279, 0.01727295, 0.0052490234, -0.01007843, 0.0028934479, -0.016448975, 0.0035572052, -0.0042419434, 0.042053223, 0.018203735, 0.0008249283, -0.021957397, 0.012176514, -0.0013837814, 0.068237305, -0.034332275, 0.057403564, 0.072631836, -0.027526855, -0.000002861023, -0.0045700073, -0.035827637, 0.03894043, 0.0013275146, 0.037872314, -0.073913574, -0.024963379, -0.016799927, 0.022445679, -0.019927979, -0.022277832, -0.030563354, 0.0040512085, 0.05810547, 0.0008249283, -0.02456665, -0.029647827, 0.010353088, 0.060272217, -0.003692627, 0.040496826, 0.031433105, -0.020889282, 0.06591797, 0.030334473, -0.101257324, -0.011810303, 0.011787415, -0.013595581, 0.0038108826, 0.02418518, -0.008613586, 0.023529053, 0.009101868, 0.055847168, 0.00070381165, 0.0040664673, -0.05569458, -0.036895752, 0.06237793, 0.0050086975, -0.020141602, 0.02015686, 0.00617218, 0.014167786, -0.0124053955, -0.01159668, 0.047943115, 0.004776001, 0.06021118, -0.053863525, -0.010185242, -0.04071045, 0.033203125, -0.052490234, -0.020217896, -0.0059127808, -0.06616211, 0.031982422, -0.0259552, -0.013618469, 0.0019369125, -0.034118652, -0.026428223, 0.088378906, 0.0317688, -0.02508545, 0.015701294, -0.008117676, -0.018447876, -0.059814453, -0.014175415, -0.0010986328, 0.029815674, -0.03741455, 0.0046806335, 0.037200928, 0.034179688, -0.012863159, -0.038970947, 0.07196045, 0.046325684, -0.038360596, -0.02230835, -0.044036865, -0.016021729, 0.04147339, 0.012313843, 0.022521973, -0.00067949295, 0.018875122, -0.00040006638, 0.003528595, -0.015625, 0.0007677078, -0.017440796, -0.019058228, -0.0053520203, -0.02027893, 0.016052246, 0.01184082, -0.02809143, -0.00094652176, 0.012870789, 0.017349243, -0.019317627, 0.0030441284, -0.0008735657, 0.0066452026, 0.02822876, -0.03048706, -0.012374878, -0.024124146, -0.0060768127, 0.008598328, -0.03805542, 0.006706238, 0.00248909, 0.0022907257, 0.020874023, 0.0026836395, -0.02758789, -0.04095459, -0.01878357, 0.086242676, -0.0012722015, -0.03527832, -0.011428833, 0.0039596558, -0.024841309, -0.064208984, -0.0047683716, 0.017715454, -0.06210327, 0.03543091, 0.012229919, -0.02507019, -0.034606934, 0.08691406, -0.025894165, -0.023391724, -0.009689331, -0.029144287, -0.038208008, -0.03479004, -0.058685303, 0.0062446594, 0.024017334, 0.0021076202, 0.004497528, 0.017364502, -0.0031929016, 0.009902954, 0.0035972595, 0.038482666, -0.0017442703, -0.012672424, 0.014190674, 0.053741455, -0.054534912, -0.034332275, -0.036987305, -0.05404663, 0.025177002, -0.016647339, 0.021362305, -0.037139893, 0.027755737, 0.024276733, -0.014511108, 0.0069274902, -0.005794525, -0.003660202, -0.014472961, 0.022979736, -0.061767578, -0.02571106, 0.012664795 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2001.06631v1
Graph Ordering: Towards the Optimal by Learning
Kangfei Zhao, Yu Rong, Jeffrey Xu Yu, Junzhou Huang, Hao Zhang
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.LG
Graph representation learning has achieved a remarkable success in many graph-based applications, such as node classification, link prediction, and community detection. These models are usually designed to preserve the vertex information at different granularity and reduce the problems in discrete space to some machine learning tasks in continuous space. However, regardless of the fruitful progress, for some kind of graph applications, such as graph compression and edge partition, it is very hard to reduce them to some graph representation learning tasks. Moreover, these problems are closely related to reformulating a global layout for a specific graph, which is an important NP-hard combinatorial optimization problem: graph ordering. In this paper, we propose to attack the graph ordering problem behind such applications by a novel learning approach. Distinguished from greedy algorithms based on predefined heuristics, we propose a neural network model: Deep Order Network (DON) to capture the hidden locality structure from partial vertex order sets. Supervised by sampled partial order, DON has the ability to infer unseen combinations. Furthermore, to alleviate the combinatorial explosion in the training space of DON and make the efficient partial vertex order sampling , we employ a reinforcement learning model: the Policy Network, to adjust the partial order sampling probabilities during the training phase of DON automatically. To this end, the Policy Network can improve the training efficiency and guide DON to evolve towards a more effective model automatically. Comprehensive experiments on both synthetic and real data validate that DON-RL outperforms the current state-of-the-art heuristic algorithm consistently. Two case studies on graph compression and edge partitioning demonstrate the potential power of DON-RL in real applications.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2001.06631v1
"2020-01-18T09:14:16"
"2020-01-18T09:14:16"
{ "title": [ -0.024459839, -0.003566742, -0.052337646, -0.064208984, 0.022857666, 0.008506775, -0.036743164, -0.0019044876, 0.0001322031, 0.016357422, -0.006828308, 0.013427734, -0.04473877, -0.02078247, -0.033325195, -0.0140686035, 0.007881165, 0.01928711, -0.02998352, -0.04034424, -0.03265381, -0.021850586, 0.021316528, 0.057281494, 0.031585693, -0.02998352, -0.03677368, -0.0008945465, -0.027389526, -0.019592285, -0.0052719116, -0.00712204, 0.048980713, 0.0058135986, 0.001326561, 0.006427765, -0.029525757, 0.0053100586, -0.010566711, 0.024932861, 0.000051140785, 0.0041999817, -0.008125305, -0.031982422, -0.0473938, 0.025466919, -0.07080078, 0.00415802, -0.029220581, 0.025619507, 0.0105896, 0.014572144, 0.00043058395, 0.030349731, 0.013214111, -0.051818848, -0.018814087, 0.00042152405, 0.022583008, 0.05532837, 0.021072388, -0.013130188, 0.015281677, -0.007080078, -0.055999756, -0.03414917, 0.010513306, 0.02458191, 0.0552063, -0.0059318542, -0.012428284, 0.03540039, 0.011695862, 0.0066070557, -0.042388916, -0.0052490234, 0.036712646, -0.0008664131, 0.040924072, -0.020248413, -0.010551453, 0.012130737, -0.043914795, -0.036315918, 0.019897461, -0.051727295, -0.029556274, -0.009605408, -0.030334473, -0.05569458, -0.018325806, 0.013946533, -0.0054130554, 0.0088272095, -0.04168701, 0.0016288757, -0.01008606, 0.012481689, 0.0035362244, -0.031555176, -0.017501831, 0.003238678, -0.03652954, -0.010612488, -0.0049324036, -0.032806396, -0.01449585, -0.026809692, 0.008987427, 0.053527832, -0.03439331, 0.021759033, 0.019882202, 0.01876831, 0.021392822, -0.0059776306, -0.013801575, 0.04373169, 0.005367279, 0.038208008, -0.006465912, -0.031311035, -0.0132369995, -0.0129852295, 0.00077438354, -0.023956299, -0.040161133, 0.018173218, -0.0178833, 0.021972656, 0.014190674, 0.0496521, -0.09283447, -0.07067871, -0.057006836, 0.042877197, -0.016159058, -0.013580322, -0.009147644, 0.010147095, 0.017242432, -0.040008545, -0.011650085, 0.018035889, 0.017364502, 0.038146973, 0.057037354, -0.031463623, -0.04727173, -0.02067566, -0.037506104, 0.017868042, 0.033721924, -0.00374794, -0.06201172, -0.023391724, -0.12414551, -0.014793396, 0.019577026, -0.0009870529, 0.013580322, 0.006713867, 0.0055885315, -0.001947403, 0.040649414, -0.012886047, -0.04071045, 0.020126343, 0.020187378, 0.031204224, 0.013931274, 0.0007195473, 0.008216858, 0.007888794, -0.0003838539, 0.010177612, 0.06274414, -0.03451538, 0.01638794, 0.002960205, 0.011299133, 0.0022964478, -0.02822876, 0.060455322, -0.06137085, -0.012992859, -0.009689331, -0.03805542, 0.05593872, 0.006893158, -0.0090789795, 0.039916992, -0.033325195, -0.023544312, -0.04660034, -0.013572693, 0.039978027, 0.05480957, -0.004714966, -0.015464783, -0.066833496, 0.01083374, -0.045074463, 0.023025513, 0.037078857, -0.06585693, 0.010856628, 0.003068924, -0.0066223145, 0.028289795, 0.054901123, -0.016220093, -0.047698975, 0.04119873, -0.0050735474, -0.04824829, 0.03881836, 0.00831604, -0.014678955, 0.0033683777, -0.038513184, -0.026367188, -0.02468872, 0.048065186, 0.016723633, -0.016906738, -0.0022468567, -0.035064697, 0.008483887, 0.01525116, 0.03201294, -0.021820068, 0.009651184, 0.043884277, 0.020935059, -0.013938904, 0.011100769, -0.0014810562, 0.012962341, -0.0058670044, -0.009742737, -0.025466919, 0.0038166046, 0.07470703, 0.044281006, 0.008331299, 0.008926392, 0.031951904, 0.023834229, 0.038635254, 0.06738281, 0.053344727, 0.03967285, 0.033203125, 0.034362793, 0.06036377, 0.02053833, 0.034179688, -0.02949524, 0.03112793, -0.008895874, 0.046142578, 0.0067634583, 0.016540527, -0.06188965, 0.014053345, -0.030273438, 0.0041770935, 0.003419876, 0.0143966675, 0.02029419, -0.03050232, 0.0034179688, -0.025619507, -0.022735596, -0.0107421875, -0.008239746, 0.01651001, -0.013839722, -0.06964111, -0.018676758, 0.009605408, 0.03967285, 0.015571594, 0.03414917, -0.021484375, 0.021057129, -0.0010547638, -0.018737793, -0.021270752, 0.04348755, 0.0390625, 0.0007505417, -0.0061187744, -0.0016355515, 0.006046295, 0.05883789, 0.07458496, -0.031982422, 0.042510986, -0.05041504, 0.020339966, 0.0440979, -0.03540039, -0.0046310425, 0.055664062, 0.026733398, 0.009384155, -0.035247803, -0.011276245, -0.03933716, -0.0072021484, -0.0020694733, -0.03842163, -0.032348633, -0.050445557, 0.0079956055, -0.05340576, -0.027252197, -0.018692017, 0.049957275, -0.015129089, -0.047729492, 0.019439697, -0.0015115738, -0.017196655, 0.012611389, -0.03918457, -0.02229309, 0.027297974, 0.009262085, 0.021713257, -0.06976318, 0.0053367615, -0.0030097961, 0.026168823, -0.019119263, 0.021591187, -0.006916046, -0.0018749237, 0.027236938, -0.0053749084, 0.008529663, -0.031311035, 0.022003174, -0.07635498, -0.0014266968, 0.011054993, -0.006126404, -0.0022678375, 0.021057129, -0.020385742, -0.05267334, 0.020095825, 0.07470703, 0.002855301, 0.004634857, 0.05480957, 0.050201416, -0.016159058, 0.009155273, 0.019195557, -0.010986328, -0.033843994, -0.04034424, -0.042816162, -0.0030384064, 0.0061912537, 0.0107803345, 0.08062744, -0.031311035, -0.0061912537, -0.04260254, -0.0025501251, -0.016662598, -0.0140686035, 0.026229858, -0.011772156, -0.05630493, -0.00945282, -0.018218994, 0.013870239, -0.0395813, 0.0068588257, 0.10827637, -0.011482239, -0.018951416, 0.03668213, 0.025802612, 0.0019235611, -0.019424438, -0.012336731, -0.006855011, 0.0066986084, 0.0034275055, 0.0039596558, -0.0028800964, 0.005077362, -0.085998535, 0.005180359, 0.012413025, -0.0057868958, -0.015182495, 0.0024776459, -0.064331055, 0.025024414, -0.028640747, -0.02748108, 0.037017822, 0.081970215, -0.00970459, 0.028564453, 0.00970459, 0.0070533752, -0.0060691833, -0.016067505, -0.059570312, 0.041900635, -0.029388428, -0.077819824, -0.0077781677, 0.008514404, -0.032470703, -0.022964478, -0.03375244, 0.00995636, 0.044128418, 0.057250977, 0.0067977905, -0.019577026, -0.00069093704, -0.041259766, -0.018875122, -0.008270264, -0.036193848, -0.015655518, 0.0036067963, 0.05267334, 0.034942627, -0.007335663, -0.05709839, -0.02734375, -0.0044555664, 0.03640747, 0.012329102, -0.034210205, -0.014533997, -0.050079346, -0.027267456, 0.006565094, -0.03869629, -0.004562378, -0.03314209, 0.016708374, -0.025726318, 0.029510498, 0.0027236938, -0.002193451, -0.010810852, -0.015129089, 0.013046265, -0.018341064, -0.072509766, 0.020858765, 0.014968872, 0.0440979, -0.008514404, -0.013595581, -0.04840088, 0.030029297, -0.03543091, -0.008430481, 0.010147095, 0.006427765, -0.011741638, 0.019165039, -0.021942139, 0.005142212, -0.03665161, -0.0011548996, 0.026794434, -0.00818634, 0.0016317368, -0.051818848, 0.02659607, -0.00957489, -0.109558105, -0.016464233, 0.005584717, 0.0014896393, -0.00491333, -0.034057617, 0.011512756, 0.011444092, -0.04006958, 0.005783081, -0.027877808, 0.026535034, 0.0045318604, -0.068481445, -0.021850586, 0.06695557, 0.004924774, 0.016647339, 0.01651001, -0.023147583, -0.0054092407, -0.014862061, 0.010345459, -0.028442383, 0.06542969, -0.014801025, -0.013641357, 0.032226562, -0.032958984, 0.011352539, 0.026489258, 0.02633667, -0.019134521, 0.012611389, -0.011779785, 0.018371582, -0.030090332, 0.050964355, 0.036621094, -0.022232056, -0.057861328, 0.027664185, 0.008430481, -0.017547607, 0.008613586, -0.029022217, 0.016082764, 0.02671814, 0.02645874, 0.058166504, -0.008285522, 0.00048708916, 0.053771973, -0.009750366, -0.007843018, -0.015602112, 0.00033855438, 0.013015747, 0.011238098, 0.001250267, 0.00030755997, 0.035308838, -0.01058197, -0.03314209, 0.005432129, 0.024597168, -0.040283203, -0.0002259016, -0.035736084, -0.03189087, -0.013923645, 0.008583069, -0.025604248, 0.014411926, 0.0129852295, 0.00040602684, -0.043792725, 0.009414673, 0.0031490326, 0.0075187683, -0.0018501282, -0.0423584, 0.022003174, -0.018356323, -0.056396484, -0.046691895, -0.025405884, -0.024383545, 0.024108887, 0.013145447, -0.010002136, 0.018234253, 0.043640137, 0.054656982, 0.01259613, -0.019195557, -0.025512695, 0.033477783, -0.0045204163, -0.011940002, 0.010475159, -0.018692017, -0.0036354065, -0.009208679, -0.00043201447, -0.010147095, 0.0027046204, -0.041290283, -0.016220093, -0.01776123, 0.016235352, 0.021438599, 0.04510498, 0.023284912, -0.0006942749, 0.007396698, 0.026321411, -0.036743164, -0.04876709, 0.010879517, 0.031433105, -0.029541016, 0.047546387, 0.08831787, -0.0019550323, -0.030212402, -0.00039958954, 0.022338867, 0.050079346, -0.035736084, 0.004558563, 0.009841919, -0.056274414, -0.0055770874, 0.013664246, -0.0115356445, 0.06237793, -0.04714966, 0.057678223, 0.0010061264, 0.010604858, 0.041168213, -0.011817932, 0.009048462, -0.004512787, 0.0059432983, -0.046966553, -0.076538086, -0.02720642, 0.08557129, -0.036224365, -0.014701843, -0.015808105, 0.04244995, 0.023483276, 0.022994995, 0.029449463, 0.016983032, -0.03692627, -0.022567749, 0.02470398, -0.016983032, -0.04876709, 0.03326416, 0.0030078888, 0.021774292, -0.0019550323, -0.018798828, -0.08850098, -0.00674057, -0.0003502369, 0.012771606, 0.012924194, -0.07751465, 0.014778137, 0.05038452, 0.033447266, -0.0057640076, -0.0038433075, -0.016159058, 0.013694763, 0.025939941, -0.013305664, 0.027053833, 0.019836426, -0.07159424, 0.042633057, 0.00004351139, 0.011909485, -0.022613525, 0.04547119, -0.0042037964, 0.016357422, -0.058013916, 0.012260437, -0.0075645447, -0.004032135, -0.0042495728, -0.030822754, 0.011871338, 0.031173706, 0.0077285767, 0.006942749, -0.008407593, -0.019180298, 0.0013608932, -0.014877319, -0.025985718, 0.017364502, 0.00097465515, -0.023498535, -0.05429077, 0.01928711, -0.02418518, -0.0029907227, 0.002336502, 0.03161621, -0.025360107, 0.021957397, 0.027328491, -0.059417725, 0.02482605, -0.053741455, 0.007827759, 0.053771973, 0.044281006, -0.019485474, 0.0044136047, -0.037841797, -0.0552063, -0.030914307, 0.010925293, 0.021240234, 0.012084961, -0.0036716461, -0.02861023, 0.0036945343, 0.025146484, 0.038757324, 0.0074768066, -0.039916992, 0.047821045, 0.01828003, 0.010910034, -0.040008545, 0.0075950623, -0.027770996, -0.0031089783, 0.029586792, -0.036132812, 0.02029419, -0.0022602081, 0.0064315796, -0.009757996, -0.052124023, 0.017211914, 0.01449585, 0.017349243, 0.0049934387, 0.04736328, 0.04144287, 0.028137207, -0.016342163, 0.02760315, 0.04928589, -0.05142212, -0.015975952, 0.0055236816, 0.005706787, -0.025650024, 0.043884277, -0.015274048, -0.009529114, -0.03778076, -0.05496216, -0.028457642, 0.0012969971, 0.029129028, 0.027145386, 0.035705566, -0.060791016, -0.0040664673, -0.016921997, -0.031234741, -0.04055786, 0.049835205, -0.00097465515, -0.05065918, 0.0030593872, -0.026290894, 0.03994751, -0.0206604, 0.0069236755, -0.05065918, -0.040100098, -0.011772156, -0.016662598, 0.047058105, -0.036132812, -0.022827148, 0.025314331, 0.030761719, -0.027709961, 0.056671143, -0.060760498, 0.05886841, 0.027404785, 0.043762207, 0.048736572, 0.013252258, 0.01007843, 0.005947113, 0.037139893, -0.033477783, 0.007522583, -0.051208496, -0.0015764236, -0.05429077, 0.0010585785, -0.06713867, 0.010177612, 0.03765869, 0.0038375854, 0.028823853, 0.011940002, 0.044921875, 0.020202637, 0.06488037, -0.025009155, 0.05886841, 0.017333984, -0.0030288696, -0.034118652, 0.023223877, 0.024108887, 0.03768921, 0.031951904, -0.015365601, -0.00080394745, -0.03237915, 0.020965576, 0.042419434, 0.015068054, 0.016815186, -0.017227173, -0.037261963, 0.014884949, -0.029144287, 0.043518066, 0.049346924, 0.033203125, -0.024398804, -0.003282547, 0.012626648, -0.0032444, -0.058044434, 0.032043457, 0.02923584, -0.043273926, 0.01838684, -0.051361084, -0.011131287, 0.03604126, -0.0016336441, 0.051727295, -0.06518555, -0.0748291, 0.00034546852, 0.049072266, -0.00039553642, 0.025405884, -0.038391113, 0.0019569397, -0.004436493, 0.02041626, 0.002412796, 0.0058631897, 0.00009036064, 0.016906738, -0.04815674, -0.04260254, 0.024383545, 0.011810303, 0.013893127, 0.028198242, -0.06573486, 0.04623413, 0.02168274, -0.04937744, 0.03036499, -0.010375977, -0.052520752, -0.0010385513, -0.0007786751, 0.046875, 0.07086182, 0.06921387, 0.02217102, 0.00049829483, 0.017211914, -0.06304932, 0.02178955, 0.061187744, -0.021347046, 0.054779053, -0.036987305, -0.02960205, 0.06173706, -0.026046753, 0.048431396, -0.03918457, 0.0015077591, -0.010726929, 0.030075073, 0.017318726, -0.047607422, -0.031555176, -0.0042304993, -0.05529785, -0.003238678, -0.029052734, -0.03488159, 0.0022850037, -0.017501831, -0.0034503937, 0.016601562, -0.012809753, -0.046966553, -0.011741638, -0.026290894, -0.018753052, -0.04043579, 0.02545166, -0.030136108, -0.005382538, -0.00030565262, -0.005771637, -0.022842407, -0.05065918, -0.01751709, -0.029541016, -0.023635864, -0.030380249, 0.026184082, 0.03665161, -0.00919342, 0.0043182373, 0.031555176, 0.0013751984, -0.016571045, 0.004890442, 0.00029230118, -0.06500244, 0.011222839, 0.004196167, -0.045288086, 0.0345459, 0.054992676, -0.0155181885, 0.004535675, 0.01828003, -0.03225708, -0.014442444, -0.011184692, 0.034362793, -0.015670776, -0.06427002, 0.020477295, 0.03866577, 0.043151855, -0.03414917, 0.013328552, 0.039245605, 0.017074585, -0.0069999695, 0.043395996, 0.008926392, -0.012962341, 0.0067443848, 0.039031982, 0.005683899, -0.040283203, -0.044403076, -0.040374756, 0.01751709, 0.025161743, -0.005355835, -0.041259766, 0.010345459, -0.0064964294, -0.0009384155, 0.04144287, -0.0017585754, 0.00056409836, -0.0037651062, 0.009544373, -0.029129028, -0.035858154, 0.03010559, 0.028060913, -0.02760315, 0.004306793, -0.00932312, -0.017913818, -0.012390137, 0.0078125, -0.018371582, -0.033599854, 0.02017212, 0.03491211, 0.0101623535, 0.046722412, -0.03881836, -0.015380859, -0.010406494, -0.009483337, -0.008239746, -0.010948181, 0.024475098, -0.0395813, 0.012924194, -0.0074501038, -0.018035889, 0.020828247, -0.01979065, 0.03866577, -0.027023315, -0.010353088, -0.022857666, -0.0345459, -0.0126953125, 0.021453857, 0.023544312, -0.033599854, -0.030700684, -0.014129639, 0.06768799, -0.010574341 ], "summary": [ 0.035003662, -0.011741638, -0.005405426, -0.043792725, -0.029006958, -0.007549286, -0.031402588, 0.012451172, -0.010864258, -0.029541016, 0.024993896, -0.0071258545, -0.030654907, -0.0690918, 0.07318115, -0.028778076, 0.016082764, 0.011016846, 0.01184082, -0.026794434, 0.029251099, -0.015106201, 0.018707275, 0.040130615, 0.01512146, -0.0019369125, 0.02986145, 0.0073280334, 0.025390625, 0.015960693, 0.035705566, -0.056854248, 0.019226074, 0.0028915405, -0.0062217712, 0.0063705444, -0.015174866, 0.00504303, 0.0065956116, -0.003276825, 0.013793945, -0.015060425, 0.07476807, -0.07501221, 0.01725769, 0.07366943, -0.043823242, -0.02545166, 0.009742737, 0.055603027, 0.00605011, 0.045684814, -0.011405945, 0.017654419, -0.0006303787, -0.0076408386, -0.04034424, 0.011405945, 0.008522034, 0.06616211, 0.018463135, -0.007637024, -0.010131836, -0.05029297, -0.03805542, -0.004753113, -0.003118515, -0.001584053, 0.017501831, -0.0078048706, 0.030227661, 0.00024223328, -0.00060892105, -0.032165527, -0.037475586, 0.01638794, 0.0357666, -0.007587433, -0.01776123, -0.015991211, -0.0026054382, 0.054779053, -0.015617371, -0.015701294, -0.030517578, -0.032073975, -0.02470398, -0.011627197, -0.005897522, 0.00045681, -0.014945984, 0.029891968, -0.023803711, 0.04067993, 0.0064697266, -0.032928467, -0.013801575, -0.02078247, -0.0010328293, -0.010643005, 0.016479492, -0.029800415, 0.009300232, -0.0038204193, -0.0019311905, -0.04055786, -0.009292603, -0.038391113, 0.023330688, 0.024551392, -0.037017822, 0.020584106, 0.013458252, -0.021713257, 0.008583069, 0.0146484375, 0.0020103455, 0.0546875, 0.0043907166, 0.012260437, -0.032958984, 0.003955841, -0.0012655258, 0.040893555, -0.0060653687, 0.0063591003, 0.013961792, -0.014152527, 0.021713257, 0.016113281, -0.015304565, 0.00333786, -0.048583984, -0.021347046, -0.03744507, 0.0047950745, -0.004470825, 0.02658081, 0.016082764, -0.030258179, 0.0501709, -0.030639648, -0.033843994, 0.057861328, 0.011886597, 0.049804688, 0.00995636, -0.0113220215, -0.002275467, -0.018707275, -0.020050049, -0.008529663, 0.00881958, 0.014465332, 0.0046958923, -0.05859375, -0.0036067963, -0.042633057, 0.056152344, -0.03314209, -0.0015382767, 0.00003886223, -0.0017023087, 0.047607422, 0.018371582, -0.011642456, 0.039123535, 0.0053100586, 0.010223389, 0.004550934, 0.0065956116, 0.022216797, -0.033447266, -0.020614624, 0.00680542, -0.0036087036, 0.000351429, -0.022399902, -0.010345459, 0.055236816, 0.018447876, -0.02168274, -0.04220581, 0.023101807, 0.0055770874, 0.028717041, -0.010185242, -0.0044021606, 0.010826111, -0.001203537, -0.01373291, 0.042663574, -0.046173096, 0.010932922, -0.012023926, 0.048095703, 0.020721436, 0.056640625, 0.009117126, -0.06286621, -0.010955811, 0.059448242, -0.045837402, 0.02444458, -0.013114929, 0.0016307831, 0.020233154, 0.016357422, -0.030853271, 0.024993896, 0.034698486, -0.010040283, -0.03918457, 0.03692627, 0.006259918, -0.06903076, 0.03817749, -0.03173828, -0.00000423193, -0.020904541, 0.003047943, 0.026901245, -0.041412354, 0.0357666, -0.00844574, 0.007156372, -0.025360107, 0.0115356445, -0.008560181, 0.015914917, 0.0027999878, 0.0040283203, -0.013031006, 0.027633667, 0.007423401, -0.014892578, 0.019989014, -0.06903076, 0.027542114, 0.025680542, 0.011314392, 0.010528564, -0.029754639, -0.002948761, 0.051239014, 0.023803711, 0.008735657, 0.0029621124, -0.037475586, -0.024353027, 0.047424316, 0.011138916, 0.01626587, 0.008834839, 0.00894165, 0.009773254, 0.0146865845, 0.021438599, -0.0032253265, 0.014884949, -0.004512787, 0.0713501, 0.032592773, 0.008224487, -0.03390503, -0.021408081, -0.013641357, -0.009422302, 0.0206604, -0.025283813, 0.0045661926, -0.052490234, -0.002374649, -0.033355713, -0.07293701, -0.010810852, -0.0368042, 0.034729004, 0.0129470825, -0.0362854, -0.010375977, -0.02633667, -0.020568848, 0.000040888786, 0.030960083, 0.0060272217, 0.019470215, 0.015113831, 0.010025024, 0.062347412, 0.061309814, 0.04675293, 0.010681152, 0.0054130554, -0.0082092285, 0.009849548, -0.012077332, 0.05984497, -0.0335083, 0.002773285, -0.009613037, 0.021865845, -0.019805908, -0.0055999756, 0.00038003922, 0.008613586, -0.008415222, 0.0061950684, 0.0009531975, -0.022872925, -0.026428223, 0.016708374, 0.027496338, 0.05053711, -0.026779175, -0.037994385, -0.016021729, 0.028961182, -0.041107178, -0.012832642, 0.06866455, -0.004852295, -0.047302246, -0.004333496, -0.028823853, -0.00466156, 0.016311646, -0.029006958, 0.012565613, 0.0020332336, -0.035614014, 0.00073957443, -0.033233643, 0.03540039, 0.0007305145, 0.0011119843, 0.004627228, 0.0011386871, -0.0011453629, 0.009681702, 0.025222778, -0.020599365, 0.013587952, -0.0035972595, -0.047454834, -0.00957489, 0.0035686493, -0.020645142, 0.0079193115, 0.0013389587, 0.011909485, -0.008239746, -0.01398468, 0.011703491, 0.021087646, 0.030578613, 0.025161743, 0.008842468, 0.027954102, -0.032684326, -0.008224487, 0.024841309, -0.019699097, -0.09655762, -0.022109985, -0.017990112, -0.012306213, 0.0068855286, 0.048828125, 0.04888916, 0.006767273, 0.041290283, -0.045074463, -0.013023376, 0.0057907104, -0.023757935, 0.117248535, 0.008598328, -0.059906006, 0.04949951, 0.0018253326, 0.020233154, -0.036315918, -0.016235352, 0.08148193, -0.0017557144, -0.014541626, 0.025527954, 0.027511597, -0.005306244, -0.005844116, -0.011390686, 0.0041923523, -0.017486572, 0.022476196, 0.02508545, -0.010696411, -0.0129776, -0.00356102, -0.02255249, 0.05557251, 0.025436401, 0.012619019, 0.019180298, -0.039031982, 0.039154053, 0.014122009, -0.00422287, -0.0012083054, 0.028930664, 0.041381836, -0.026809692, 0.045532227, 0.004470825, 0.033935547, -0.05532837, 0.06500244, 0.03074646, -0.029220581, -0.08874512, 0.009307861, 0.059570312, -0.0068740845, -0.047058105, -0.020721436, 0.044891357, 0.012031555, 0.025939941, -0.0033721924, 0.02470398, 0.019851685, -0.024246216, 0.005168915, 0.048583984, -0.062072754, 0.002506256, 0.0041236877, -0.042633057, 0.09631348, -0.08874512, -0.06021118, -0.021102905, 0.03274536, 0.04397583, 0.029312134, -0.003314972, -0.027130127, -0.058502197, -0.02720642, -0.015655518, -0.03567505, 0.004383087, 0.008743286, 0.031219482, 0.0079956055, 0.046844482, -0.035949707, 0.009765625, 0.025970459, -0.007980347, 0.0054969788, -0.0020980835, -0.032196045, 0.013725281, 0.01713562, 0.056884766, -0.058532715, -0.0035629272, -0.050872803, 0.021835327, 0.010925293, -0.058929443, 0.006931305, -0.019561768, -0.002254486, -0.055480957, 0.025802612, 0.008430481, 0.0135269165, -0.043945312, -0.03765869, 0.00831604, -0.011550903, -0.017150879, 0.0012426376, 0.010307312, -0.0090789795, -0.010734558, 0.027389526, 0.062683105, 0.07537842, -0.05331421, 0.07342529, -0.027496338, -0.03353882, 0.032226562, -0.028839111, 0.12451172, 0.009384155, -0.09124756, 0.049987793, -0.03050232, 0.032409668, 0.029647827, -0.048217773, -0.022766113, 0.054626465, 0.05822754, 0.023284912, -0.0335083, 0.09008789, 0.011871338, 0.099365234, 0.026031494, -0.0005645752, 0.042114258, 0.015586853, 0.03955078, -0.021575928, -0.0022010803, 0.056915283, 0.078552246, -0.040130615, -0.0040359497, 0.048980713, 0.004589081, -0.06793213, 0.024887085, 0.0099487305, -0.010292053, 0.027175903, 0.0041656494, -0.007358551, 0.024765015, 0.0056610107, -0.027938843, -0.021499634, -0.046783447, -0.0023059845, 0.03237915, -0.01309967, -0.01474762, 0.021560669, 0.02720642, -0.018875122, 0.012962341, -0.0082473755, 0.007369995, -0.049926758, -0.037322998, 0.016433716, 0.044891357, -0.06695557, -0.03414917, -0.009490967, 0.03253174, 0.015808105, 0.0063285828, -0.029251099, -0.0066070557, -0.0030555725, 0.029312134, -0.0049476624, -0.018051147, 0.0074882507, 0.034118652, -0.0284729, -0.042877197, -0.0118255615, -0.0053100586, -0.042663574, -0.029190063, -0.033996582, -0.05984497, -0.017028809, -0.01889038, -0.021438599, 0.023406982, 0.010818481, 0.034179688, 0.018753052, 0.0073280334, -0.03540039, 0.03326416, -0.025375366, 0.005619049, 0.018875122, 0.020050049, -0.010749817, -0.005153656, -0.005897522, -0.009857178, -0.039978027, -0.051574707, -0.010231018, 0.027297974, -0.00497818, 0.06549072, 0.04525757, 0.026260376, 0.01574707, 0.02923584, 0.022155762, -0.012527466, -0.044311523, 0.0047912598, 0.019302368, -0.018356323, 0.043182373, 0.09051514, 0.013969421, -0.06323242, 0.009521484, 0.009544373, 0.061065674, -0.03475952, 0.00349617, 0.003484726, -0.009178162, 0.024490356, 0.045837402, -0.01802063, 0.03189087, 0.017929077, 0.0068969727, 0.028656006, 0.008071899, 0.043060303, -0.0129470825, -0.010093689, 0.013252258, -0.008522034, -0.0014333725, -0.079833984, 0.00056409836, 0.057403564, 0.02609253, -0.027526855, 0.008811951, 0.06225586, 0.019760132, -0.0012798309, 0.00017738342, -0.05670166, -0.000746727, -0.02078247, -0.017303467, 0.0211792, -0.03265381, -0.013343811, 0.027832031, 0.006641388, 0.018005371, -0.024932861, -0.015335083, -0.005924225, -0.019088745, 0.025314331, -0.012306213, -0.015197754, -0.037841797, 0.011123657, 0.0098724365, -0.021240234, 0.04800415, -0.030151367, -0.068481445, 0.0024490356, -0.052337646, 0.014770508, -0.007381439, -0.10522461, 0.049346924, 0.0048599243, 0.034332275, 0.003414154, 0.022979736, 0.00504303, 0.005264282, -0.031951904, -0.0087509155, -0.04812622, 0.0284729, -0.04006958, 0.011680603, 0.0041160583, 0.027542114, 0.033233643, 0.0032100677, 0.017486572, 0.039276123, 0.025436401, 0.0076828003, 0.014076233, -0.032073975, -0.015083313, -0.010345459, -0.022415161, 0.00017976761, -0.04107666, 0.003080368, -0.0018920898, 0.013877869, -0.003686905, -0.030044556, -0.0033168793, -0.0037441254, 0.0050697327, 0.026367188, 0.030303955, 0.0022735596, -0.043182373, -0.037628174, 0.0015029907, -0.0019369125, -0.038757324, -0.075683594, -0.04598999, -0.036621094, 0.04937744, 0.0037651062, 0.04071045, 0.04638672, -0.018112183, 0.045806885, -0.025665283, -0.027359009, 0.019378662, -0.006046295, -0.021743774, -0.014472961, 0.030776978, -0.105041504, 0.014457703, 0.06756592, -0.0013341904, -0.0060653687, 0.029586792, 0.01789856, -0.026351929, -0.0234375, -0.002483368, 0.03036499, -0.0010643005, 0.05718994, 0.030258179, 0.010719299, 0.05429077, 0.013626099, 0.030578613, 0.036010742, -0.009315491, 0.035583496, -0.015655518, -0.0016288757, -0.07006836, -0.0034809113, 0.02671814, 0.042938232, -0.042663574, -0.061950684, 0.026123047, 0.00065660477, 0.0070533752, 0.04837036, 0.02722168, -0.054107666, 0.02796936, -0.043945312, -0.018173218, -0.02798462, 0.04034424, -0.02746582, -0.01902771, 0.010406494, -0.03262329, 0.020263672, 0.00038599968, 0.0051612854, -0.042236328, -0.03753662, 0.0016288757, 0.027786255, 0.02772522, -0.0020256042, 0.012298584, -0.004016876, 0.0051727295, -0.014129639, -0.012718201, -0.011276245, 0.030731201, -0.014122009, 0.004032135, 0.00573349, 0.0011663437, -0.0060424805, -0.008613586, -0.005317688, -0.03527832, 0.05822754, -0.02708435, -0.020629883, -0.061431885, -0.055023193, -0.031555176, 0.02166748, -0.015525818, -0.04574585, 0.09265137, -0.010292053, 0.041656494, 0.03768921, -0.03756714, 0.0045051575, -0.0040397644, 0.03668213, 0.007751465, -0.030899048, 0.002462387, -0.0090789795, 0.028747559, 0.026779175, 0.012237549, 0.048858643, -0.014533997, 0.03817749, 0.007972717, -0.011108398, -0.03338623, 0.030227661, -0.03010559, 0.015510559, -0.0019989014, 0.017868042, 0.032592773, 0.017059326, 0.028121948, -0.0095825195, 0.023040771, 0.029815674, -0.012435913, 0.022766113, 0.005680084, 0.024002075, 0.012214661, 0.011207581, -0.015129089, 0.0287323, -0.020843506, 0.055755615, -0.067993164, -0.033203125, 0.026641846, 0.012962341, -0.027618408, 0.008811951, -0.05682373, -0.034179688, -0.00592041, -0.027740479, -0.036254883, -0.046691895, 0.04034424, -0.0044136047, -0.02243042, -0.0056114197, 0.03994751, 0.0012340546, 0.051971436, 0.02545166, -0.06414795, 0.04144287, 0.05142212, -0.021697998, 0.046447754, 0.025238037, -0.015594482, 0.032409668, -0.021194458, 0.038879395, 0.057403564, 0.05819702, 0.004699707, 0.029342651, 0.04522705, -0.006298065, -0.024215698, 0.02670288, -0.016036987, -0.020431519, 0.013465881, 0.0066490173, 0.031402588, 0.017669678, 0.029449463, -0.041259766, 0.017242432, -0.02130127, -0.008529663, -0.022445679, -0.012886047, 0.0017623901, -0.036102295, -0.016143799, 0.043914795, 0.02142334, -0.029571533, 0.046691895, 0.030288696, -0.045196533, 0.0826416, -0.009849548, -0.020462036, -0.0025367737, -0.0057525635, 0.003238678, 0.0073127747, 0.053955078, 0.029251099, -0.0026454926, 0.01902771, 0.04067993, -0.013549805, -0.105285645, -0.018203735, 0.0064926147, 0.04776001, -0.050750732, 0.020523071, 0.027526855, -0.0036907196, 0.00868988, 0.01713562, 0.011917114, -0.005256653, 0.033599854, 0.035308838, -0.014854431, -0.0020065308, 0.019058228, -0.035583496, 0.033111572, -0.017471313, -0.031234741, 0.03567505, -0.034362793, -0.0440979, -0.0154418945, -0.0027942657, 0.012588501, -0.023971558, -0.014213562, -0.0050621033, 0.02166748, 0.046844482, -0.014289856, 0.018295288, 0.0158844, -0.0039405823, 0.0016555786, -0.03778076, -0.011978149, -0.018981934, 0.0026512146, 0.039642334, -0.006679535, 0.008872986, -0.032592773, -0.03567505, 0.066711426, 0.00415802, -0.030563354, -0.008850098, 0.022766113, -0.017547607, -0.00566864, 0.02999878, 0.0041122437, -0.017318726, 0.005050659, -0.018539429, -0.03579712, -0.05529785, 0.031280518, 0.023239136, -0.020599365, -0.0034103394, 0.0031642914, -0.013893127, 0.002199173, -0.006385803, -0.030075073, 0.025161743, -0.0060310364, 0.009895325, 0.018981934, -0.006061554, -0.012680054, 0.019256592, 0.02658081, -0.023773193, -0.034362793, -0.033050537, 0.07122803, -0.0657959, -0.02848816, -0.030303955, -0.044647217, -0.006801605, -0.020233154, 0.01109314, -0.05682373, 0.024871826, 0.01939392, -0.04067993, 0.0043182373, -0.005809784, -0.016433716, -0.01802063, 0.011779785, 0.02243042, -0.010231018, 0.022720337 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2001.09219v4
Explainable Active Learning (XAL): An Empirical Study of How Local Explanations Impact Annotator Experience
Bhavya Ghai, Q. Vera Liao, Yunfeng Zhang, Rachel Bellamy, Klaus Mueller
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.LG
The wide adoption of Machine Learning technologies has created a rapidly growing demand for people who can train ML models. Some advocated the term "machine teacher" to refer to the role of people who inject domain knowledge into ML models. One promising learning paradigm is Active Learning (AL), by which the model intelligently selects instances to query the machine teacher for labels. However, in current AL settings, the human-AI interface remains minimal and opaque. We begin considering AI explanations as a core element of the human-AI interface for teaching machines. When a human student learns, it is a common pattern to present one's own reasoning and solicit feedback from the teacher. When a ML model learns and still makes mistakes, the human teacher should be able to understand the reasoning underlying the mistakes. When the model matures, the machine teacher should be able to recognize its progress in order to trust and feel confident about their teaching outcome. Toward this vision, we propose a novel paradigm of explainable active learning (XAL), by introducing techniques from the recently surging field of explainable AI (XAI) into an AL setting. We conducted an empirical study comparing the model learning outcomes, feedback content and experience with XAL, to that of traditional AL and coactive learning (providing the model's prediction without the explanation). Our study shows benefits of AI explanation as interfaces for machine teaching--supporting trust calibration and enabling rich forms of teaching feedback, and potential drawbacks--anchoring effect with the model judgment and cognitive workload. Our study also reveals important individual factors that mediate a machine teacher's reception to AI explanations, including task knowledge, AI experience and need for cognition. By reflecting on the results, we suggest future directions and design implications for XAL.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2001.09219v4
"2020-09-30T12:43:28"
"2020-01-24T22:52:18"
{ "title": [ -0.0053367615, 0.009437561, 0.017044067, -0.053497314, -0.011772156, 0.0016517639, -0.030426025, -0.038360596, 0.0008659363, 0.0039863586, 0.008300781, -0.006603241, -0.014015198, -0.055541992, 0.0030956268, -0.0019550323, 0.0018920898, 0.03390503, -0.027191162, -0.024459839, -0.06008911, -0.025375366, -0.011817932, 0.003692627, 0.03503418, -0.04916382, -0.021392822, 0.0058937073, 0.037353516, 0.0037593842, 0.01612854, -0.04611206, -0.009162903, 0.056243896, -0.00504303, -0.01537323, -0.028533936, 0.036346436, 0.013641357, 0.026168823, 0.01386261, 0.007835388, 0.015586853, -0.010658264, -0.041137695, -0.009338379, -0.021133423, -0.0078125, -0.025924683, 0.019485474, -0.0014686584, 0.0013713837, -0.003583908, -0.0049858093, 0.009262085, -0.01876831, -0.033721924, -0.025924683, 0.032440186, 0.043121338, 0.021759033, -0.038238525, 0.018218994, -0.007209778, -0.032043457, -0.012107849, 0.0357666, 0.03326416, 0.044921875, -0.009902954, -0.016784668, 0.034332275, 0.010185242, -0.003332138, -0.045013428, 0.01625061, 0.06713867, 0.029296875, 0.00491333, -0.021575928, 0.026611328, 0.021759033, 0.016342163, -0.048065186, 0.017410278, -0.035095215, -0.009742737, -0.0059165955, 0.0008878708, -0.07495117, -0.00027942657, -0.018432617, -0.035095215, 0.043823242, -0.023330688, -0.024459839, 0.0026874542, 0.013389587, -0.008399963, -0.06439209, -0.004219055, 0.0077438354, -0.055480957, 0.010154724, 0.0067634583, 0.017288208, 0.0053596497, 0.008956909, 0.036712646, 0.010955811, -0.005138397, 0.047088623, 0.014060974, -0.009635925, 0.005382538, 0.041748047, 0.003414154, 0.027130127, -0.007575989, 0.043914795, 0.020599365, -0.010147095, 0.023117065, 0.048980713, 0.0054855347, 0.024627686, -0.049835205, -0.013702393, 0.033721924, 0.050231934, 0.024002075, 0.026031494, -0.083618164, -0.07867432, -0.068725586, 0.01574707, -0.04119873, -0.044006348, -0.025817871, 0.019927979, -0.030960083, -0.023498535, 0.04534912, -0.055603027, 0.013771057, -0.015213013, 0.038269043, 0.03640747, -0.014350891, -0.022827148, 0.025177002, 0.017547607, 0.052459717, -0.023757935, -0.046722412, -0.050689697, -0.10803223, -0.01637268, 0.042816162, -0.011314392, 0.048980713, 0.017211914, -0.02507019, -0.0003516674, -0.00016236305, -0.046569824, -0.0033912659, 0.01159668, 0.024383545, 0.017074585, -0.02319336, -0.004425049, -0.014839172, -0.015930176, 0.007068634, 0.025634766, 0.044769287, 0.03805542, 0.014572144, -0.03189087, 0.010421753, -0.016296387, 0.04260254, -0.0046043396, -0.04751587, -0.034179688, -0.007144928, -0.006980896, 0.040130615, 0.012168884, 0.0040397644, 0.024841309, -0.014083862, -0.04083252, -0.013534546, 0.008598328, -0.023376465, 0.028289795, -0.011421204, -0.01499176, -0.016983032, 0.024108887, -0.039215088, 0.010002136, -0.0017366409, -0.026397705, -0.00023412704, 0.0154800415, -0.026672363, 0.047424316, 0.03515625, 0.01448822, -0.0362854, 0.0034427643, -0.0010786057, -0.0703125, 0.010185242, -0.031341553, 0.01335144, -0.03616333, 0.026062012, -0.007369995, -0.007881165, 0.016464233, -0.0034561157, 0.036987305, -0.028060913, -0.0012702942, 0.0121154785, 0.036315918, 0.05041504, -0.028121948, 0.02368164, -0.00014054775, -0.027450562, -0.015991211, -0.034423828, -0.037628174, 0.015388489, 0.039215088, 0.0041389465, -0.029800415, 0.005859375, 0.040100098, 0.021270752, 0.018432617, 0.028121948, 0.0015716553, -0.01737976, -0.0071525574, 0.047912598, 0.030349731, 0.057678223, 0.0005002022, -0.038330078, 0.08654785, -0.0025596619, -0.0109939575, -0.032440186, 0.042633057, 0.0041046143, 0.0033664703, -0.004360199, 0.013282776, -0.078308105, 0.020599365, -0.033203125, 0.009849548, -0.016174316, 0.0028190613, 0.032714844, 0.0062713623, 0.01776123, 0.0017385483, -0.035705566, 0.008354187, -0.025726318, 0.026763916, 0.0115737915, -0.036132812, 0.0020446777, -0.0063819885, 0.020462036, -0.007507324, 0.050720215, 0.0059013367, 0.024795532, -0.014564514, -0.0569458, -0.011947632, 0.03060913, 0.030532837, 0.0137786865, -0.025115967, 0.03314209, 0.016601562, 0.064086914, 0.05316162, -0.040924072, 0.05328369, -0.00063085556, 0.03326416, 0.038635254, -0.008872986, 0.020339966, -0.020431519, 0.033416748, 0.024612427, -0.0072669983, -0.009994507, -0.036254883, 0.035705566, -0.00422287, 0.036102295, -0.08166504, -0.08166504, 0.012207031, -0.011306763, -0.034362793, -0.028549194, 0.07318115, -0.02998352, 0.0047073364, -0.0024433136, 0.0023212433, -0.050842285, 0.006149292, -0.028137207, 0.012359619, 0.030807495, 0.028213501, 0.02394104, -0.07946777, -0.009422302, -0.00712204, 0.008399963, -0.008529663, -0.02243042, -0.032836914, 0.043182373, 0.0044937134, -0.046447754, 0.056365967, -0.025756836, -0.0013303757, -0.054748535, 0.038757324, 0.016967773, -0.025527954, 0.01651001, 0.041229248, -0.039642334, -0.027755737, 0.032592773, 0.05795288, -0.044677734, -0.011390686, 0.055511475, 0.019088745, -0.010795593, 0.060028076, 0.021957397, 0.008163452, -0.1159668, -0.033081055, -0.019683838, -0.0020694733, -0.055999756, -0.036499023, 0.03050232, -0.003004074, -0.025466919, -0.049621582, -0.009925842, -0.02999878, 0.022140503, -0.0023593903, -0.03237915, -0.026550293, -0.016052246, -0.039978027, -0.038909912, 0.0039405823, 0.0015745163, 0.09814453, -0.007926941, -0.016220093, -0.020767212, 0.039276123, 0.020065308, -0.0044021606, -0.060760498, -0.055541992, -0.004447937, 0.00374794, -0.0011405945, 0.0055007935, -0.019485474, -0.08337402, 0.004558563, 0.001540184, 0.013031006, -0.026046753, 0.020935059, -0.07434082, 0.031143188, -0.029266357, -0.0423584, 0.035491943, 0.028259277, 0.010620117, 0.0026817322, 0.00048971176, -0.016311646, -0.0004544258, -0.02407837, -0.078186035, 0.026046753, -0.059814453, 0.001206398, 0.0058937073, 0.01940918, -0.07739258, -0.042297363, 0.015640259, 0.067871094, 0.029312134, -0.012290955, 0.026489258, -0.00096559525, 0.029205322, -0.0031051636, -0.017074585, -0.00907135, -0.052093506, -0.0062942505, 0.032043457, 0.016113281, 0.083618164, -0.043640137, -0.03704834, -0.010017395, -0.049560547, -0.00024533272, -0.029541016, -0.030761719, 0.005279541, -0.03010559, -0.0012989044, -0.009902954, -0.016479492, 0.0076675415, -0.021972656, 0.0023994446, -0.024139404, 0.002538681, 0.012145996, 0.024963379, 0.016098022, 0.00573349, 0.014419556, -0.014884949, -0.03427124, 0.038208008, 0.019500732, 0.0132751465, 0.033721924, -0.0440979, -0.020126343, 0.0025596619, -0.04776001, -0.022628784, -0.02798462, -0.0019073486, 0.027023315, -0.007797241, -0.027557373, 0.016967773, 0.014091492, 0.0087509155, 0.005264282, 0.01083374, -0.026809692, -0.06677246, -0.018554688, 0.013519287, -0.06958008, -0.015068054, 0.023620605, -0.003921509, -0.030685425, -0.0725708, 0.038513184, -0.04611206, -0.045196533, 0.043884277, -0.0024738312, 0.02444458, -0.016571045, -0.093444824, -0.024124146, 0.058044434, 0.032958984, 0.010887146, 0.017532349, -0.041229248, -0.014976501, 0.0049972534, 0.024765015, 0.008140564, 0.061279297, 0.015686035, -0.044128418, 0.019546509, -0.021835327, 0.07507324, 0.015045166, -0.02268982, 0.040740967, -0.00046229362, 0.00198555, 0.014633179, 0.025314331, 0.032318115, -0.00082683563, -0.0236969, 0.0041999817, 0.030151367, -0.035949707, 0.02696228, 0.015342712, 0.0151901245, 0.013900757, -0.029571533, 0.038238525, 0.013938904, -0.027770996, 0.011856079, 0.016937256, -0.022064209, -0.03677368, 0.016098022, 0.029663086, 0.036193848, 0.023422241, 0.022720337, 0.027557373, 0.029830933, 0.00869751, -0.01713562, -0.008514404, -0.0017242432, -0.056610107, -0.0014209747, 0.001241684, -0.04071045, -0.03503418, 0.003293991, 0.0014438629, 0.01852417, 0.007209778, -0.021835327, -0.026382446, -0.002243042, -0.02168274, 0.021316528, -0.041992188, -0.052215576, 0.014793396, -0.006465912, -0.087524414, -0.028808594, -0.04260254, -0.021347046, 0.027679443, 0.00831604, -0.045288086, 0.034240723, 0.018371582, 0.06488037, 0.07922363, -0.016311646, -0.0925293, 0.028793335, -0.030380249, 0.013061523, 0.017471313, 0.011230469, 0.006275177, -0.0005955696, 0.030929565, -0.016494751, -0.03491211, -0.06378174, 0.012214661, 0.00881958, 0.014122009, 0.046936035, 0.034698486, 0.0345459, -0.0075950623, 0.011116028, 0.020401001, -0.042053223, 0.013381958, 0.012687683, -0.005580902, 0.02255249, -0.0036792755, 0.011367798, 0.04815674, -0.01637268, -0.00025177002, 0.017669678, 0.009925842, -0.0039901733, 0.0061187744, 0.02279663, -0.014343262, -0.0032958984, 0.029830933, 0.0104522705, 0.04525757, -0.03930664, 0.02973938, 0.006263733, -0.009101868, 0.022644043, -0.013046265, 0.015617371, 0.017227173, 0.0041122437, -0.06530762, -0.07183838, -0.01625061, 0.051940918, -0.007820129, -0.0048942566, 0.025009155, 0.027069092, 0.008491516, 0.06341553, 0.062927246, -0.022338867, 0.007797241, -0.015930176, -0.0018320084, -0.00945282, -0.049987793, -0.02267456, -0.020889282, 0.027999878, -0.04119873, 0.047180176, -0.0073165894, 0.002576828, -0.007850647, -0.028152466, -0.013702393, -0.058380127, 0.013694763, 0.0317688, -0.040618896, 0.048065186, 0.02178955, 0.016296387, -0.018157959, 0.034301758, -0.00223732, 0.014503479, 0.0010185242, -0.032073975, -0.036987305, -0.0109939575, 0.009750366, 0.024215698, 0.02607727, 0.007865906, 0.029022217, -0.038024902, 0.0368042, 0.020339966, 0.0048294067, -0.02508545, -0.052825928, 0.006023407, -0.02168274, 0.024154663, 0.025878906, -0.043548584, -0.0012054443, -0.0119018555, -0.0289917, -0.056427002, 0.057037354, 0.008628845, -0.020736694, -0.0715332, 0.005306244, -0.006477356, 0.038757324, -0.020309448, 0.0047798157, -0.030685425, -0.0082092285, 0.026000977, -0.037322998, 0.012863159, -0.01725769, 0.016494751, 0.0132751465, 0.0008382797, -0.06939697, -0.005958557, -0.005924225, -0.026977539, -0.015579224, -0.0041007996, -0.002948761, 0.007881165, 0.004470825, 0.015098572, -0.015144348, -0.039367676, -0.0015268326, 0.0058555603, -0.033966064, 0.05218506, 0.012168884, 0.04257202, -0.0154418945, 0.023666382, 0.0020256042, -0.00566864, 0.032287598, -0.019546509, 0.0069770813, 0.022216797, 0.024765015, -0.037200928, -0.051574707, -0.011024475, 0.017333984, -0.014350891, 0.0044898987, 0.038024902, 0.021530151, 0.058013916, -0.012252808, 0.012649536, 0.047729492, -0.017745972, -0.032684326, -0.0021686554, -0.007194519, -0.004547119, 0.06677246, -0.0129776, -0.04598999, -0.026031494, -0.04296875, -0.016311646, -0.0045318604, 0.015914917, -0.0007824898, 0.00484848, -0.022491455, -0.00021409988, -0.026123047, -0.0028686523, -0.017990112, 0.013397217, 0.003627777, -0.040222168, 0.00063323975, -0.006958008, 0.018676758, -0.057678223, 0.020599365, -0.01386261, -0.0019273758, -0.023773193, 0.015274048, 0.012496948, -0.02357483, 0.024337769, 0.019226074, 0.021728516, -0.064697266, 0.009361267, -0.015144348, 0.0625, 0.05001831, 0.03189087, 0.009880066, -0.012542725, 0.024749756, 0.029205322, 0.017745972, -0.00982666, 0.040039062, -0.07055664, 0.014183044, -0.048461914, -0.022354126, -0.093566895, -0.045318604, 0.057495117, 0.0032634735, 0.0063095093, -0.009002686, -0.006679535, 0.028305054, 0.02772522, 0.041412354, 0.038970947, -0.00075674057, 0.009155273, 0.0077285767, -0.050933838, 0.02798462, 0.034301758, -0.010482788, 0.0047912598, -0.057128906, -0.017532349, 0.0038719177, 0.042541504, -0.016662598, -0.0037517548, 0.011253357, -0.045654297, 0.018920898, -0.011009216, 0.039367676, 0.06213379, -0.015403748, 0.011787415, -0.041778564, -0.012619019, -0.020385742, -0.025741577, -0.021774292, 0.036590576, -0.07623291, 0.013145447, -0.015083313, -0.026855469, -0.020706177, 0.051116943, 0.040527344, -0.012565613, 0.021011353, 0.004776001, 0.016326904, -0.008956909, 0.0076942444, -0.036102295, -0.026290894, -0.0009584427, 0.009056091, -0.008163452, 0.013702393, 0.020874023, 0.010948181, -0.0016546249, -0.015403748, 0.004135132, 0.010559082, -0.008026123, 0.025894165, -0.017608643, 0.03982544, -0.0010881424, -0.028274536, 0.044311523, -0.013366699, -0.02494812, 0.0107421875, 0.0047073364, 0.049438477, 0.0084991455, 0.07885742, 0.01083374, -0.016448975, -0.018005371, -0.017593384, 0.0058288574, 0.013259888, -0.018966675, 0.02355957, -0.039489746, -0.022018433, 0.027755737, -0.052703857, -0.006931305, -0.051605225, 0.0020370483, -0.039611816, 0.01651001, 0.018493652, -0.04510498, -0.033691406, -0.0077209473, -0.010177612, 0.01763916, 0.040222168, -0.05432129, -0.007461548, 0.019958496, -0.010505676, 0.023132324, 0.010948181, 0.025772095, -0.014251709, -0.015579224, 0.010154724, -0.029953003, 0.07501221, -0.035186768, -0.043884277, -0.01146698, 0.008308411, 0.033996582, 0.0033950806, -0.037719727, 0.030181885, -0.01802063, -0.030334473, -0.0037117004, -0.009796143, -0.0211792, -0.010047913, -0.00315094, 0.016815186, -0.018157959, -0.009613037, 0.014312744, -0.03881836, 0.017211914, 0.0063285828, -0.02748108, 0.044921875, 0.03225708, -0.009651184, 0.030532837, 0.013618469, -0.0029945374, 0.0057792664, -0.005519867, 0.01121521, -0.0236969, -0.007865906, -0.014968872, 0.014717102, 0.028182983, -0.06317139, -0.057617188, 0.00057935715, 0.055145264, 0.022476196, 0.057434082, -0.02268982, -0.01436615, 0.034942627, 0.007083893, 0.013214111, -0.019973755, 0.0041923523, 0.033081055, -0.013252258, 0.0362854, 0.019073486, -0.01272583, 0.021209717, -0.014839172, 0.013366699, 0.02557373, 0.01838684, 0.031707764, 0.015808105, 0.070617676, -0.04043579, -0.043701172, -0.06878662, -0.0069770813, 0.024551392, 0.017196655, 0.015304565, 0.03604126, -0.02267456, 0.12561035, -0.034301758, -0.070617676, 0.052978516, 0.070373535, -0.0014266968, 0.051971436, 0.0032367706, -0.009170532, -0.009651184, -0.006652832, -0.0027179718, -0.0045394897, 0.0236969, -0.0045051575, 0.016143799, -0.068603516, -0.02911377, -0.016952515, -0.03756714, 0.03567505, -0.038116455, 0.0077285767, -0.020614624, -0.036346436, -0.0033168793, 0.058532715, -0.008331299, -0.01637268, -0.026885986, -0.030838013, 0.049072266, -0.023452759 ], "summary": [ -0.008934021, -0.029678345, 0.018035889, 0.028259277, -0.042816162, -0.013160706, 0.008125305, -0.037353516, -0.035003662, 0.00843811, -0.02973938, 0.0063934326, -0.0003106594, -0.03274536, 0.04360962, -0.029418945, -0.003894806, 0.03149414, 0.017913818, -0.014381409, -0.0088272095, -0.011390686, 0.0024032593, -0.020645142, 0.006641388, 0.015136719, -0.053955078, 0.012428284, 0.03894043, 0.047302246, 0.011634827, -0.06427002, -0.0034942627, 0.008529663, -0.004322052, -0.032348633, -0.01977539, 0.010818481, -0.013420105, 0.030181885, 0.008384705, 0.02180481, 0.055236816, -0.0011434555, -0.025390625, 0.0113220215, -0.02218628, 0.0062065125, 0.01876831, 0.04345703, 0.0064315796, -0.0043525696, -0.0040283203, -0.018447876, 0.0019435883, 0.0020599365, -0.04815674, -0.008026123, 0.01423645, 0.044921875, 0.028778076, 0.0007195473, -0.0031833649, -0.008522034, 0.009025574, 0.00006741285, 0.017456055, 0.036590576, 0.015258789, 0.0005021095, 0.005794525, 0.01991272, -0.00737381, -0.020599365, -0.02319336, 0.018051147, 0.08068848, 0.043395996, -0.04711914, -0.000112354755, 0.020324707, 0.052856445, -0.023544312, -0.034118652, -0.012008667, -0.04458618, -0.007926941, -0.012397766, -0.011260986, -0.03793335, -0.026626587, -0.059020996, -0.003004074, 0.026046753, -0.015487671, -0.023635864, -0.013160706, -0.025161743, 0.001786232, -0.022521973, 0.02305603, -0.02418518, -0.007080078, 0.0029735565, -0.0057868958, 0.059783936, 0.024475098, -0.020324707, 0.010177612, -0.013587952, -0.0013723373, 0.015609741, 0.022628784, -0.047088623, -0.011955261, 0.018737793, 0.0029678345, 0.053375244, 0.03137207, 0.018676758, -0.0012645721, -0.018066406, 0.038116455, 0.048217773, -0.014373779, 0.022994995, -0.02748108, -0.029464722, 0.058044434, 0.019378662, -0.014572144, -0.004886627, -0.029830933, -0.0071792603, -0.005264282, -0.010520935, -0.0045661926, -0.046417236, -0.030532837, 0.01965332, 0.0124435425, 0.006565094, 0.0418396, -0.007297516, -0.02027893, 0.002500534, 0.014221191, 0.029724121, 0.005973816, -0.025726318, 0.015777588, -0.02079773, 0.010231018, -0.0018177032, -0.003572464, 0.0002975464, -0.090026855, 0.03213501, 0.039764404, 0.048431396, 0.048919678, 0.03414917, 0.023864746, 0.014556885, -0.009140015, -0.05987549, -0.025421143, -0.016845703, 0.024307251, -0.0574646, 0.050231934, 0.002626419, 0.0071754456, 0.006023407, 0.010948181, -0.011489868, 0.012077332, 0.021072388, -0.013114929, 0.011909485, 0.020858765, -0.020126343, 0.013305664, 0.010017395, -0.013137817, 0.0028305054, 0.0022354126, 0.0033035278, 0.030838013, 0.0027561188, -0.0181427, 0.008293152, -0.0096588135, -0.018157959, 0.0209198, 0.007320404, -0.027282715, 0.0129470825, -0.013549805, -0.024749756, 0.031982422, 0.035125732, -0.03778076, -0.04611206, -0.109375, 0.0028800964, -0.01977539, 0.052124023, -0.01626587, 0.034484863, 0.021987915, 0.015335083, -0.045135498, 0.038238525, 0.010177612, -0.021835327, 0.003314972, -0.021255493, -0.008232117, -0.025009155, -0.0028476715, 0.02243042, -0.029846191, 0.03463745, -0.055114746, 0.043914795, -0.034484863, 0.053375244, 0.006122589, 0.051574707, 0.074523926, -0.07354736, 0.023345947, 0.008636475, -0.026916504, -0.0090408325, -0.025222778, -0.07269287, 0.0018062592, 0.05706787, 0.004825592, -0.025894165, -0.006515503, 0.048583984, -0.034729004, 0.008460999, 0.047332764, 0.0034255981, -0.05581665, -0.039489746, 0.041381836, 0.01914978, 0.061645508, 0.02217102, -0.038879395, 0.053894043, -0.009056091, -0.016952515, -0.007987976, -0.00055217743, 0.014289856, 0.009300232, -0.026855469, 0.008102417, -0.08203125, 0.028121948, -0.03930664, 0.0018482208, 0.016174316, 0.006061554, 0.017150879, 0.002658844, 0.0034942627, -0.003036499, -0.07305908, -0.0029850006, -0.018356323, 0.03111267, -0.0035552979, -0.031402588, 0.008460999, -0.028533936, 0.05706787, -0.0042915344, 0.0524292, 0.016494751, 0.0501709, 0.02104187, 0.0022945404, 0.04638672, 0.03744507, 0.043914795, 0.0134887695, 0.004623413, 0.044891357, 0.024307251, -0.0069847107, 0.01600647, 0.01109314, -0.022064209, -0.026062012, 0.044952393, 0.0010261536, -0.008407593, 0.017532349, -0.018310547, 0.030258179, 0.028167725, 0.015731812, -0.012451172, -0.011451721, 0.025604248, -0.0008058548, 0.08666992, -0.07598877, -0.072143555, -0.009490967, 0.03274536, -0.012969971, 0.029678345, 0.12335205, -0.01889038, 0.007843018, 0.01348114, -0.0077285767, -0.06011963, 0.05908203, -0.034240723, 0.0052948, 0.01612854, -0.014266968, 0.01020813, -0.030685425, 0.031402588, 0.00025248528, 0.006816864, 0.0073661804, -0.016281128, 0.0043678284, 0.04119873, 0.03967285, -0.015151978, 0.021957397, -0.0124435425, -0.04626465, -0.023086548, 0.033691406, 0.0012292862, -0.017593384, -0.008232117, 0.03717041, -0.021713257, -0.03677368, 0.017715454, 0.004463196, -0.015556335, 0.04232788, 0.027633667, -0.0053596497, -0.035858154, 0.07397461, 0.008552551, 0.005722046, -0.11077881, -0.029083252, -0.019454956, 0.010406494, -0.07067871, -0.01965332, -0.009605408, 0.024917603, -0.003227234, -0.038726807, -0.037017822, -0.04815674, 0.016784668, 0.066223145, 0.010604858, -0.015808105, 0.043426514, 0.02796936, 0.016708374, 0.011413574, 0.0004930496, 0.048797607, 0.010498047, -0.0035495758, 0.0023422241, 0.019683838, 0.003993988, -0.009635925, -0.007041931, 0.022201538, -0.016967773, -0.006450653, -0.018844604, -0.030593872, 0.02116394, -0.04837036, 0.006996155, -0.0034484863, 0.0703125, 0.020477295, 0.04159546, -0.056427002, 0.05090332, -0.025558472, -0.025878906, 0.023345947, -0.01890564, 0.029403687, -0.028518677, 0.006298065, -0.03866577, -0.0037231445, -0.035491943, -0.05105591, 0.014060974, -0.04586792, 0.047302246, 0.017150879, 0.014839172, -0.046295166, -0.0068588257, 0.026611328, 0.10620117, -0.00030589104, -0.019332886, 0.02709961, 0.00869751, 0.05368042, -0.011550903, 0.012130737, 0.046203613, -0.066223145, -0.0071487427, 0.007270813, -0.043518066, 0.0847168, -0.089538574, -0.012527466, -0.030410767, -0.045959473, -0.00063180923, -0.026138306, -0.01348114, -0.005355835, -0.02961731, -0.05987549, 0.00026154518, -0.011047363, 0.015510559, -0.019439697, 0.026748657, 0.0023860931, 0.03451538, -0.0010375977, 0.025039673, 0.043792725, -0.041046143, 0.0049591064, -0.008308411, -0.06970215, 0.011398315, 0.024353027, -0.014083862, 0.06829834, -0.02180481, -0.028259277, 0.027755737, -0.033721924, -0.036346436, 0.0003900528, -0.0046691895, -0.017822266, -0.009422302, 0.000013828278, -0.020370483, 0.05279541, 0.015045166, -0.04937744, 0.043518066, -0.043395996, -0.06903076, -0.046569824, 0.015533447, -0.03793335, -0.04989624, 0.027023315, -0.003704071, 0.004600525, -0.07476807, 0.04522705, -0.06274414, -0.020996094, 0.047546387, -0.023620605, 0.06311035, -0.0025253296, -0.07788086, 0.036071777, -0.020645142, 0.04220581, -0.0062789917, -0.0079956055, 0.023269653, 0.02571106, 0.004081726, 0.018432617, -0.030670166, 0.045532227, -0.01626587, 0.013183594, 0.014816284, -0.014511108, 0.044189453, 0.015281677, -0.046661377, 0.032043457, 0.018234253, -0.023361206, 0.026062012, 0.0038166046, 0.0070877075, 0.012809753, -0.032989502, 0.014671326, 0.05886841, -0.009849548, -0.015029907, 0.028396606, 0.037963867, 0.015556335, 0.020950317, -0.013511658, 0.009017944, -0.048614502, 0.0074501038, 0.02180481, 0.01763916, -0.05316162, -0.027770996, 0.02029419, 0.06402588, -0.022232056, 0.036315918, -0.014183044, 0.025756836, -0.0022029877, 0.0035972595, 0.022018433, 0.003648758, -0.020629883, -0.016189575, 0.021255493, -0.021102905, -0.027511597, -0.00881958, -0.0071372986, 0.01777649, -0.010139465, -0.013252258, 0.0026359558, 0.0033302307, 0.00037407875, 0.030593872, -0.060272217, -0.06549072, -0.045806885, -0.0041236877, -0.045684814, -0.02029419, -0.0635376, -0.029800415, -0.030914307, 0.0033111572, -0.022018433, 0.02619934, -0.016586304, 0.023391724, 0.018218994, 0.04031372, -0.0057907104, 0.058563232, -0.030822754, 0.00021111965, 0.0028972626, 0.011444092, -0.024673462, -0.01159668, 0.024841309, -0.006046295, -0.016311646, -0.05053711, 0.0026664734, 0.019714355, -0.008560181, -0.0023880005, -0.004135132, 0.011894226, -0.032562256, 0.015823364, 0.0050315857, -0.025283813, 0.015258789, 0.024459839, 0.016784668, -0.037902832, 0.026809692, 0.0077781677, 0.0052337646, 0.006198883, -0.03213501, 0.047729492, -0.016052246, -0.06500244, 0.032165527, 0.005859375, 0.04663086, 0.006252289, 0.03591919, 0.05142212, 0.018325806, -0.0015583038, -0.0053977966, -0.011909485, -0.015098572, 0.035308838, -0.003932953, 0.0075149536, 0.041992188, 0.0011873245, -0.03515625, -0.04977417, -0.016235352, 0.056884766, -0.014045715, -0.015045166, -0.044830322, -0.015991211, -0.007598877, 0.03074646, 0.0209198, -0.029434204, 0.028244019, -0.023101807, -0.019073486, -0.0033283234, -0.017807007, -0.03765869, -0.05029297, 0.0056610107, -0.031463623, 0.016555786, 0.041046143, -0.024124146, -0.005542755, -0.02758789, 0.004371643, -0.029129028, -0.02758789, 0.023483276, -0.0625, 0.042816162, 0.049591064, -0.011520386, -0.0006632805, 0.009002686, -0.023803711, 0.008644104, -0.02999878, -0.0033092499, -0.040100098, -0.037506104, 0.04626465, 0.036956787, -0.03265381, 0.03213501, 0.018051147, -0.052612305, 0.017349243, -0.008125305, 0.021408081, -0.019058228, -0.010650635, 0.020446777, -0.037017822, 0.0055122375, 0.0029735565, -0.056274414, -0.01637268, -0.0071983337, -0.03286743, -0.017532349, 0.06585693, 0.010437012, 0.0016622543, -0.03375244, -0.045562744, -0.011054993, 0.027938843, 0.00028252602, 0.02482605, -0.0028324127, 0.0090408325, -0.00349617, -0.017562866, -0.021240234, 0.03656006, 0.017318726, -0.007209778, -0.002155304, -0.03817749, -0.004776001, -0.017440796, -0.0023097992, -0.04901123, -0.06304932, -0.050811768, 0.06262207, -0.0015792847, 0.059936523, 0.0041275024, -0.031951904, 0.009437561, -0.0074501038, -0.074035645, 0.024169922, 0.011947632, 0.033599854, 0.021011353, 0.012168884, -0.018234253, 0.011497498, 0.035125732, -0.033966064, 0.014083862, -0.018157959, -0.04309082, 0.022109985, 0.0032253265, 0.0012235641, -0.005138397, -0.02053833, 0.008140564, 0.010658264, 0.008842468, 0.040161133, 0.008476257, -0.01235199, 0.03552246, 0.000042557716, -0.05834961, -0.041778564, 0.0262146, -0.031585693, -0.0023517609, -0.009346008, -0.053375244, 0.017181396, -0.05142212, 0.00137043, -0.02128601, 0.029312134, 0.029251099, 0.03945923, 0.0044898987, -0.021514893, 0.01864624, -0.013053894, -0.03527832, 0.011169434, -0.012252808, -0.031036377, 0.048950195, 0.025268555, -0.02923584, -0.008201599, 0.016220093, 0.015213013, 0.013252258, 0.025405884, 0.02305603, 0.0034103394, -0.038391113, 0.048583984, 0.03213501, 0.0413208, -0.060272217, -0.0052108765, 0.037231445, 0.04940796, 0.014427185, -0.034240723, -0.033813477, -0.022491455, 0.027709961, -0.019226074, -0.011558533, 0.0061302185, 0.1005249, -0.011528015, -0.026901245, -0.06713867, -0.070251465, -0.053253174, -0.0055351257, 0.010032654, -0.057922363, 0.0692749, -0.021514893, -0.006652832, 0.050689697, -0.019943237, 0.065979004, -0.029067993, -0.020828247, -0.011299133, 0.010223389, -0.021026611, 0.0003721714, 0.034698486, 0.001083374, 0.021438599, -0.011047363, -0.011184692, 0.030532837, -0.0024852753, -0.026031494, -0.059387207, 0.024108887, -0.04437256, 0.022125244, 0.005378723, 0.011047363, 0.03955078, 0.018676758, 0.0062942505, -0.021270752, 0.036743164, -0.030517578, 0.014640808, -0.054504395, -0.021224976, 0.018188477, -0.017486572, -0.024841309, -0.010597229, 0.0021820068, 0.06488037, 0.0418396, 0.015731812, 0.04510498, 0.0049705505, 0.0021762848, -0.021835327, 0.0015411377, -0.032287598, -0.031555176, -0.0012569427, -0.005241394, -0.009239197, 0.009300232, 0.016784668, -0.0028762817, 0.0096206665, 0.020217896, -0.016662598, 0.0574646, -0.023071289, 0.013191223, -0.054473877, 0.018829346, 0.019760132, -0.012069702, 0.028518677, 0.026321411, -0.0135269165, 0.04852295, -0.0010461807, 0.07775879, 0.035186768, 0.041290283, -0.0574646, 0.012321472, 0.06506348, 0.010543823, 0.042236328, -0.02670288, 0.008583069, -0.002023697, -0.018234253, 0.015029907, 0.007434845, 0.017623901, 0.020080566, -0.011459351, 0.010139465, -0.0423584, 0.013717651, -0.011749268, -0.027786255, 0.027893066, -0.045043945, -0.015579224, 0.026351929, 0.064208984, -0.01889038, 0.036010742, 0.010185242, -0.04711914, 0.032684326, 0.0015296936, -0.0035934448, -0.019363403, 0.024612427, 0.017471313, -0.0030822754, 0.08166504, 0.020095825, -0.01638794, 0.052581787, 0.025375366, -0.010185242, -0.031433105, -0.03756714, 0.06640625, 0.0496521, -0.004699707, -0.0077705383, 0.0035190582, -0.030349731, -0.029418945, -0.0066452026, 0.025878906, -0.03262329, 0.0418396, 0.051086426, -0.020568848, 0.01158905, 0.037750244, -0.06390381, 0.04272461, -0.029907227, -0.013366699, 0.044555664, 0.022842407, -0.031402588, -0.03375244, -0.046569824, -0.044158936, 0.0016241074, -0.009529114, -0.019424438, 0.004486084, 0.01651001, -0.038909912, -0.05770874, 0.0070152283, 0.03375244, 0.031799316, -0.01763916, -0.030212402, -0.02758789, 0.010620117, -0.0016918182, 0.007827759, 0.0074043274, 0.038330078, 0.064575195, 0.011245728, 0.033172607, -0.013000488, 0.032073975, 0.008262634, -0.042663574, -0.005710602, -0.00044894218, 0.036865234, -0.019241333, 0.023223877, 0.03262329, -0.048919678, -0.032836914, -0.049041748, -0.0007266998, 0.0041160583, -0.019515991, 0.0047416687, 0.010848999, -0.02545166, 0.05895996, -0.016204834, -0.04849243, -0.006362915, 0.035888672, -0.007701874, -0.010604858, -0.013023376, -0.026306152, 0.017227173, 0.034942627, -0.0039711, 0.052978516, 0.0067253113, 0.021896362, 0.0020217896, -0.071899414, -0.018096924, -0.049560547, -0.025131226, 0.010894775, -0.014762878, 0.007587433, 0.024108887, -0.027420044, 0.025146484, 0.03125, 0.02558899, 0.023254395, 0.0046920776, -0.0024223328, -0.006511688, -0.0049209595 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2001.09773v1
Algorithmic Fairness from a Non-ideal Perspective
Sina Fazelpour, Zachary C. Lipton
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
Inspired by recent breakthroughs in predictive modeling, practitioners in both industry and government have turned to machine learning with hopes of operationalizing predictions to drive automated decisions. Unfortunately, many social desiderata concerning consequential decisions, such as justice or fairness, have no natural formulation within a purely predictive framework. In efforts to mitigate these problems, researchers have proposed a variety of metrics for quantifying deviations from various statistical parities that we might expect to observe in a fair world and offered a variety of algorithms in attempts to satisfy subsets of these parities or to trade off the degree to which they are satisfied against utility. In this paper, we connect this approach to \emph{fair machine learning} to the literature on ideal and non-ideal methodological approaches in political philosophy. The ideal approach requires positing the principles according to which a just world would operate. In the most straightforward application of ideal theory, one supports a proposed policy by arguing that it closes a discrepancy between the real and the perfectly just world. However, by failing to account for the mechanisms by which our non-ideal world arose, the responsibilities of various decision-makers, and the impacts of proposed policies, naive applications of ideal thinking can lead to misguided interventions. In this paper, we demonstrate a connection between the fair machine learning literature and the ideal approach in political philosophy, and argue that the increasingly apparent shortcomings of proposed fair machine learning algorithms reflect broader troubles faced by the ideal approach. We conclude with a critical discussion of the harms of misguided solutions, a reinterpretation of impossibility results, and directions for future research.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2001.09773v1
"2020-01-08T18:44:41"
"2020-01-08T18:44:41"
{ "title": [ -0.0036411285, 0.011222839, -0.028167725, -0.036468506, 0.0045166016, -0.024734497, 0.016647339, -0.0049552917, 0.0026416779, 0.033325195, -0.04660034, -0.004272461, 0.0020561218, -0.0140686035, -0.040252686, 0.0010232925, -0.011695862, 0.042510986, -0.010475159, -0.026321411, -0.022155762, -0.032073975, 0.0128479, 0.01576233, 0.040222168, -0.018753052, -0.052520752, -0.00025439262, -0.005054474, -0.029510498, -0.0029182434, -0.00058603287, 0.043426514, 0.02658081, -0.029754639, -0.005558014, -0.031143188, 0.022033691, -0.013313293, 0.02204895, -0.00018239021, 0.012512207, -0.09863281, -0.00869751, -0.08795166, -0.029296875, -0.037200928, 0.029312134, -0.036315918, 0.064819336, 0.018753052, 0.02670288, -0.0051956177, 0.07501221, 0.021850586, -0.0262146, 0.007881165, -0.041900635, 0.030410767, 0.021469116, 0.023757935, -0.014755249, 0.035888672, 0.003440857, -0.009094238, -0.030883789, 0.025787354, 0.022018433, 0.050933838, 0.012199402, -0.006477356, 0.018569946, 0.020309448, 0.017318726, -0.047607422, -0.023208618, 0.057647705, 0.021743774, 0.029922485, -0.030548096, -0.007160187, -0.0037765503, -0.00079631805, -0.010307312, -0.000051259995, -0.021911621, -0.016815186, -0.01171875, -0.01285553, -0.048675537, -0.00737381, 0.03543091, 0.010070801, 0.012184143, -0.032165527, -0.008674622, 0.006450653, 0.07147217, -0.008934021, -0.036712646, -0.039031982, 0.0051193237, -0.058288574, -0.024490356, -0.01676941, -0.0368042, 0.007648468, -0.013336182, -0.0052261353, 0.059783936, -0.042022705, 0.032806396, 0.02658081, 0.04095459, -0.024093628, -0.022109985, -0.0063667297, -0.019104004, -0.011116028, 0.00982666, -0.008552551, -0.016326904, 0.025222778, -0.027160645, 0.021591187, -0.0047569275, -0.049316406, -0.020904541, -0.0013580322, 0.026519775, 0.002948761, 0.039733887, -0.10461426, -0.07623291, -0.043914795, 0.031951904, -0.026473999, -0.01991272, -0.0335083, -0.004436493, -0.0033111572, -0.00605011, 0.042114258, -0.018417358, 0.020721436, 0.0046424866, 0.05670166, -0.004711151, -0.011100769, -0.010292053, -0.0491333, 0.042144775, 0.0011348724, 0.019439697, -0.02029419, 0.031585693, -0.09539795, 0.0072250366, 0.015731812, 0.04840088, 0.009796143, 0.007419586, -0.00013494492, 0.010070801, 0.048431396, -0.0099105835, -0.021316528, 0.027435303, 0.0069618225, 0.032684326, -0.010047913, 0.014770508, 0.0010566711, -0.014709473, -0.009063721, -0.009666443, 0.040405273, 0.000109791756, 0.005882263, 0.019592285, 0.018707275, -0.012290955, -0.027954102, 0.05316162, -0.09313965, -0.008888245, 0.006652832, 0.018661499, 0.036956787, 0.009025574, 0.010818481, 0.034484863, -0.04031372, -0.016860962, -0.05078125, -0.034851074, 0.0007157326, 0.012809753, -0.010307312, 0.033172607, -0.02519226, 0.00034689903, -0.025115967, -0.0070266724, -0.025726318, -0.026794434, -0.020477295, 0.024841309, -0.047332764, 0.054473877, 0.06951904, 0.009765625, -0.068359375, 0.06756592, 0.013923645, -0.07672119, -0.0025997162, -0.009849548, 0.0056152344, -0.029663086, -0.0011930466, -0.007713318, 0.001964569, 0.030380249, 0.016647339, -0.004295349, 0.0098724365, -0.020553589, 0.06652832, 0.022735596, 0.10839844, -0.054595947, 0.0048065186, 0.027877808, -0.0011386871, -0.02470398, -0.014282227, -0.031555176, 0.01663208, 0.027404785, 0.005596161, -0.032958984, -0.009994507, 0.027435303, 0.039642334, -0.014373779, 0.007713318, 0.0013313293, 0.028839111, -0.0032806396, 0.046447754, 0.004627228, 0.06451416, -0.015625, 0.0256958, 0.07519531, 0.009895325, 0.020446777, -0.02406311, 0.026748657, -0.0077209473, 0.029830933, 0.009002686, 0.022354126, -0.045288086, -0.012001038, -0.04071045, -0.01373291, -0.01158905, 0.00932312, 0.034973145, -0.04458618, -0.011001587, -0.027542114, 0.014144897, 0.005088806, -0.03189087, 0.034362793, 0.008857727, -0.059936523, -0.014877319, -0.002779007, 0.015411377, 0.0031757355, 0.017410278, -0.012496948, 0.0101623535, -0.013641357, -0.004436493, -0.03579712, 0.030670166, 0.031555176, -0.004398346, 0.035614014, -0.0019493103, -0.015426636, 0.0076560974, 0.07092285, -0.027954102, 0.012710571, -0.08886719, 0.018005371, 0.023986816, -0.015281677, 0.0046691895, 0.030517578, 0.015426636, 0.0022506714, -0.018539429, 0.030059814, -0.06390381, 0.0054512024, 0.02015686, -0.054595947, 0.00932312, -0.015625, 0.0007996559, -0.029220581, -0.013633728, 0.002527237, 0.06738281, 0.0034599304, -0.036346436, -0.005207062, -0.0002951622, -0.033233643, -0.017333984, -0.03314209, -0.027420044, 0.025863647, 0.04034424, 0.019424438, -0.048950195, -0.020019531, 0.011291504, 0.021743774, -0.013908386, 0.033081055, -0.022735596, -0.027145386, -0.014785767, -0.015655518, 0.0012836456, -0.04324341, 0.025299072, -0.059387207, -0.013198853, 0.032806396, -0.036071777, -0.021057129, 0.021942139, -0.022537231, -0.05126953, -0.014450073, 0.045410156, 0.0047035217, 0.014694214, 0.02986145, 0.05621338, -0.030761719, 0.053009033, 0.009941101, 0.004043579, -0.028366089, -0.006778717, -0.057769775, -0.009216309, -0.026123047, -0.018218994, 0.027145386, -0.04348755, -0.044403076, -0.008590698, -0.0019626617, -0.0010871887, 0.013412476, -0.03765869, -0.04776001, 0.0030021667, -0.039367676, -0.005756378, 0.00907135, -0.01637268, 0.009284973, 0.04348755, -0.0041046143, -0.040008545, -0.0032367706, 0.020370483, 0.014205933, -0.00466156, 0.011451721, -0.02809143, -0.026535034, -0.009674072, 0.01713562, 0.025024414, -0.024887085, 0.002128601, -0.024230957, 0.062194824, -0.006084442, -0.026611328, 0.030181885, -0.0836792, 0.02468872, 0.00818634, 0.0028419495, 0.040405273, 0.011955261, -0.026260376, 0.01751709, 0.007774353, -0.047058105, -0.0043640137, -0.04815674, -0.14038086, 0.022125244, -0.025238037, -0.005718231, -0.02003479, -0.0022907257, -0.054718018, 0.0024738312, -0.026763916, 0.014305115, 0.03274536, 0.030380249, -0.0010957718, -0.0046424866, -0.0028362274, -0.021560669, 0.012557983, 0.013946533, -0.038269043, 0.008735657, -0.01737976, 0.04220581, 0.046722412, -0.022857666, -0.039794922, -0.017654419, -0.009498596, 0.032226562, -0.008613586, -0.008872986, -0.01751709, -0.030334473, -0.017791748, 0.0030002594, -0.017044067, 0.00074625015, -0.030700684, 0.009429932, -0.014038086, 0.016998291, 0.029296875, 0.021255493, -0.040252686, 0.025405884, 0.033233643, -0.0066223145, -0.026641846, -0.0076408386, -0.013336182, 0.035308838, -0.008171082, 0.013809204, -0.02331543, -0.00088214874, -0.003107071, 0.02305603, 0.0126953125, 0.009727478, -0.006504059, 0.0019416809, -0.028442383, 0.043518066, -0.07495117, -0.005180359, 0.026626587, 0.008728027, -0.0044403076, -0.0597229, -0.0026187897, 0.0053901672, -0.109069824, -0.025131226, 0.008712769, -0.03845215, -0.037506104, -0.035247803, 0.020721436, -0.037994385, -0.016571045, -0.018997192, -0.026046753, 0.010765076, 0.018661499, -0.06323242, -0.009086609, 0.062805176, 0.006011963, -0.016021729, 0.014778137, -0.010116577, 0.0030555725, -0.034729004, 0.022598267, 0.0066833496, 0.026535034, -0.02204895, -0.01373291, 0.021118164, -0.025924683, 0.007972717, 0.031433105, 0.014801025, -0.010818481, 0.0033245087, 0.036987305, 0.023025513, -0.0154800415, 0.046020508, 0.052825928, -0.033691406, -0.06561279, -0.019699097, -0.0079422, -0.037231445, 0.041778564, -0.03262329, 0.031280518, 0.05645752, -0.009300232, 0.09106445, 0.003414154, 0.0024700165, 0.047180176, -0.0049934387, -0.017944336, -0.013763428, 0.00699234, 0.01727295, -0.006965637, 0.0010614395, -0.018798828, 0.04925537, 0.0030536652, -0.018676758, 0.00724411, 0.013206482, -0.03793335, 0.0021247864, -0.05239868, -0.023757935, -0.018295288, 0.005176544, -0.041900635, 0.03778076, 0.02571106, -0.010414124, -0.044799805, 0.01285553, 0.02947998, -0.005065918, 0.033935547, -0.040008545, 0.010856628, -0.0027046204, -0.05734253, -0.041168213, -0.015335083, 0.0015745163, -0.008491516, -0.0013580322, -0.018997192, 0.02355957, 0.0012378693, 0.0007109642, 0.017120361, -0.03173828, -0.015129089, 0.02407837, -0.023208618, -0.0055007935, 0.028671265, -0.025100708, -0.012039185, -0.020309448, 0.018753052, -0.009674072, -0.01373291, -0.07574463, 0.04232788, -0.02192688, 0.04626465, 0.0491333, 0.03652954, 0.043151855, 0.010299683, -0.008216858, 0.009376526, -0.04827881, -0.003162384, -0.014129639, 0.053100586, -0.032104492, 0.023269653, 0.044403076, 0.031341553, -0.0026283264, -0.02848816, 0.038909912, 0.009490967, -0.022155762, 0.04373169, -0.022445679, -0.042236328, -0.054779053, 0.013046265, 0.016021729, 0.055389404, -0.0009331703, 0.035186768, -0.006793976, 0.00831604, 0.022247314, -0.008483887, 0.0473938, -0.0012512207, 0.026473999, -0.04058838, 0.0067863464, 0.017486572, 0.002729416, -0.055236816, -0.0022506714, -0.0068359375, 0.014953613, 0.00415802, 0.031829834, 0.015670776, 0.0067710876, 0.0066070557, -0.029647827, -0.004283905, -0.009605408, -0.05279541, 0.012870789, -0.007434845, 0.034332275, -0.03353882, 0.05279541, -0.058166504, 0.0128479, 0.0071411133, -0.015792847, 0.013671875, -0.08270264, 0.013557434, 0.042022705, 0.0011253357, 0.020858765, -0.019592285, 0.013168335, 0.029769897, 0.052337646, -0.010131836, 0.02331543, 0.034729004, -0.042388916, 0.029769897, 0.008979797, 0.021697998, 0.0072898865, 0.014022827, -0.00048089027, 0.0035820007, -0.03265381, 0.024337769, 0.02230835, -0.025253296, 0.013381958, -0.05392456, 0.017059326, 0.010932922, 0.018951416, 0.044830322, -0.0181427, -0.027664185, 0.0059661865, 0.008071899, -0.019561768, 0.022735596, 0.041778564, 0.0024604797, -0.06311035, 0.047058105, -0.028945923, 0.020309448, -0.006134033, 0.0132369995, -0.038482666, 0.030075073, 0.03164673, -0.0524292, -0.022125244, -0.017364502, 0.014282227, 0.036132812, 0.022827148, 0.00982666, 0.010002136, -0.019546509, -0.07232666, -0.039215088, -0.002910614, -0.010818481, 0.013473511, -0.007484436, -0.011108398, -0.026611328, 0.0005631447, 0.017150879, 0.009048462, -0.054870605, 0.04147339, 0.013534546, -0.0068588257, 0.009941101, 0.047729492, -0.017913818, 0.009262085, 0.026000977, -0.03366089, 0.0206604, 0.0004377365, -0.001203537, -0.03652954, -0.062927246, 0.0096588135, 0.018798828, 0.015151978, 0.00023007393, 0.014183044, 0.040985107, 0.026519775, -0.0154800415, 0.018157959, 0.07159424, -0.0574646, -0.04257202, -0.0096206665, -0.0066566467, -0.000084638596, 0.07977295, -0.013648987, -0.056152344, -0.0335083, -0.056365967, -0.03930664, -0.008979797, 0.027832031, -0.0011644363, 0.005126953, -0.050323486, -0.009559631, -0.0099487305, -0.02998352, -0.031982422, 0.027618408, -0.016601562, -0.06262207, 0.03591919, -0.008026123, 0.033966064, -0.055145264, 0.008003235, 0.012512207, 0.013336182, -0.023834229, -0.045898438, -0.0036182404, -0.040100098, -0.015899658, 0.025543213, 0.036590576, -0.036743164, 0.037750244, -0.058654785, 0.064208984, 0.020523071, 0.024032593, 0.028381348, 0.037902832, 0.029006958, 0.0052604675, 0.0026226044, -0.016601562, -0.007972717, -0.061767578, -0.020645142, -0.032348633, 0.009521484, -0.06536865, -0.024215698, 0.031051636, 0.01222229, -0.01727295, 0.02229309, 0.027694702, -0.01737976, 0.059936523, -0.066711426, 0.057373047, -0.0015563965, -0.005180359, -0.032409668, 0.023666382, 0.003736496, 0.02986145, 0.034729004, 0.008430481, 0.010154724, -0.048187256, 0.01676941, 0.032104492, 0.015213013, 0.0032615662, -0.01663208, -0.02998352, -0.00623703, -0.013801575, 0.025512695, 0.049865723, 0.024414062, 0.051513672, -0.036956787, -0.009498596, 0.0054512024, -0.038848877, 0.035980225, 0.034210205, -0.057250977, 0.038330078, -0.0031280518, -0.03555298, 0.038208008, -0.014427185, 0.046966553, -0.07196045, -0.097961426, 0.016845703, 0.046447754, 0.023666382, 0.0385437, -0.03439331, -0.021987915, 0.005882263, 0.02760315, -0.003019333, 0.02027893, -0.0007452965, 0.027954102, -0.02619934, 0.012611389, 0.0010519028, 0.031555176, -0.030838013, 0.019805908, -0.04815674, 0.010131836, -0.017074585, -0.042999268, 0.018753052, -0.02003479, -0.030899048, -0.007587433, -0.0047340393, 0.054656982, 0.037231445, 0.06451416, 0.0038204193, -0.028045654, 0.0011730194, -0.024307251, 0.037963867, 0.05001831, -0.0211792, 0.05947876, -0.043121338, -0.047790527, 0.051879883, -0.042907715, 0.056671143, -0.019821167, 0.0051231384, -0.027908325, 0.01687622, 0.019958496, -0.05041504, 0.0107803345, -0.023208618, 0.0154953, -0.013008118, -0.015068054, -0.036499023, -0.031433105, -0.016311646, 0.0592041, 0.021728516, 0.0028514862, -0.009857178, -0.041534424, -0.057006836, 0.0014019012, -0.011062622, 0.0335083, 0.009384155, -0.027297974, -0.012420654, 0.0013246536, 0.010749817, 0.0029296875, -0.028518677, -0.008476257, -0.033996582, -0.0053100586, 0.010055542, -0.00730896, -0.004257202, 0.041229248, -0.055908203, 0.044433594, -0.016235352, -0.007633209, 0.0066490173, -0.038146973, -0.019943237, 0.017074585, -0.06768799, 0.014083862, 0.030181885, 0.0034866333, -0.012954712, 0.025009155, -0.015304565, -0.07159424, 0.021255493, 0.05999756, -0.004306793, -0.072387695, 0.03314209, 0.01953125, 0.039245605, -0.020385742, -0.025604248, 0.035003662, 0.0037193298, -0.011260986, 0.057891846, -0.007133484, -0.010032654, 0.02015686, 0.01586914, 0.01058197, -0.03237915, -0.027404785, -0.0042152405, -0.013755798, 0.027923584, 0.009399414, -0.02848816, 0.022155762, -0.013031006, 0.004840851, 0.009170532, -0.010726929, -0.010009766, -0.017959595, -0.008743286, -0.01272583, -0.036468506, -0.020645142, -0.025909424, 0.004699707, -0.001156807, -0.014602661, 0.011367798, -0.046447754, 0.05508423, -0.010124207, -0.048858643, 0.024917603, 0.046295166, -0.015625, 0.06060791, -0.05255127, -0.022369385, -0.0048828125, 0.0025863647, -0.011108398, 0.0011005402, 0.047546387, -0.015853882, 0.0021953583, -0.016311646, -0.04660034, 0.039794922, -0.006706238, 0.025039673, -0.045288086, 0.022018433, -0.03729248, -0.033966064, 0.0029754639, 0.0524292, 0.0038528442, 0.009895325, -0.09576416, -0.03274536, 0.050811768, -0.039611816 ], "summary": [ 0.040130615, -0.024612427, 0.021865845, 0.025115967, -0.037322998, -0.034362793, 0.070007324, -0.017654419, -0.022201538, 0.014976501, -0.033691406, 0.00011384487, 0.0056610107, -0.016662598, 0.0063667297, -0.031280518, -0.011192322, 0.064697266, 0.048217773, -0.016433716, -0.01776123, -0.016494751, 0.037384033, -0.02027893, 0.050109863, -0.012557983, -0.029937744, 0.030914307, 0.04083252, 0.024383545, 0.012626648, -0.03881836, 0.021957397, 0.0077819824, -0.005935669, -0.0031852722, -0.0032081604, 0.018615723, -0.0079956055, 0.028030396, 0.0032463074, 0.0032978058, -0.022277832, -0.016204834, -0.058624268, -0.01727295, -0.005970001, 0.020935059, -0.02746582, 0.06719971, 0.053649902, -0.009132385, 0.03250122, 0.04852295, 0.010215759, 0.013648987, 0.007205963, -0.042053223, 0.01322937, 0.042297363, 0.02720642, -0.010223389, -0.00029063225, -0.026565552, -0.0064888, -0.027770996, 0.06298828, 0.0046195984, 0.029541016, 0.0049476624, 0.03543091, 0.041778564, 0.018035889, -0.027252197, -0.022369385, 0.014411926, 0.044158936, 0.012023926, -0.008483887, -0.038513184, -0.03048706, 0.009857178, -0.016983032, -0.0054130554, -0.044555664, -0.02407837, -0.025527954, 0.0077323914, -0.054229736, 0.00038456917, -0.032409668, -0.020401001, -0.039764404, 0.0118255615, 0.029220581, -0.03286743, 0.023880005, 0.03640747, -0.009887695, -0.03555298, -0.014846802, -0.008720398, -0.039978027, -0.01965332, 0.005771637, 0.04611206, 0.02810669, -0.030349731, -0.008766174, -0.015319824, -0.007835388, -0.0071258545, 0.04699707, 0.004825592, -0.049743652, -0.016189575, 0.015625, -0.005874634, 0.018676758, -0.026992798, -0.031829834, -0.00554657, 0.0036773682, 0.043182373, -0.000936985, 0.026184082, 0.021255493, -0.016204834, 0.033966064, 0.0552063, -0.0046043396, 0.0006418228, -0.06317139, -0.061035156, -0.06768799, -0.021331787, 0.005672455, -0.017089844, -0.01953125, -0.02545166, 0.015266418, 0.006252289, 0.031951904, -0.015327454, 0.015319824, 0.0068359375, 0.015731812, 0.0008006096, 0.0056266785, 0.031021118, -0.04006958, 0.023590088, 0.0070152283, 0.0045051575, 0.004737854, -0.026550293, -0.018295288, -0.0029354095, 0.025283813, -0.0051994324, 0.016067505, 0.008018494, 0.031066895, 0.055114746, 0.032684326, -0.028503418, -0.013916016, 0.012832642, 0.0031642914, -0.0016775131, -0.01159668, 0.025756836, -0.0435791, -0.00034213066, 0.003124237, -0.018981934, 0.010368347, -0.048797607, -0.03878784, 0.053497314, 0.014953613, -0.036499023, -0.1159668, 0.06549072, -0.06298828, 0.03744507, 0.0024147034, 0.06842041, 0.03277588, 0.00047445297, 0.018951416, -0.004261017, -0.020248413, -0.010620117, -0.004524231, -0.018661499, -0.01247406, -0.0076828003, 0.0021400452, 0.01473999, 0.036315918, -0.0041503906, 0.0008468628, -0.058898926, -0.14379883, 0.0052452087, -0.03665161, 0.05404663, -0.101867676, 0.007534027, 0.052093506, -0.048065186, -0.04437256, 0.11694336, 0.078308105, -0.040649414, 0.013961792, -0.06048584, -0.015365601, -0.0725708, -0.019424438, 0.01928711, -0.053253174, 0.05581665, -0.00116539, 0.030151367, -0.014862061, 0.02532959, 0.06732178, 0.0143966675, 0.11303711, -0.040618896, -0.01802063, 0.07116699, 0.0158844, -0.005519867, 0.004180908, -0.030654907, 0.022598267, -0.00070619583, 0.03387451, -0.002714157, -0.008651733, -0.018920898, 0.00894165, -0.0016384125, 0.035705566, -0.025741577, -0.01637268, 0.008491516, 0.057037354, -0.0018596649, 0.011833191, -0.0063209534, 0.0047340393, 0.016845703, -0.0036373138, 0.0029468536, 0.007896423, -0.0007658005, -0.0005660057, -0.018417358, 0.0004544258, -0.014289856, -0.027664185, -0.048828125, -0.03326416, -0.046081543, 0.0058135986, -0.045898438, 0.036193848, -0.006526947, -0.010307312, -0.035614014, -0.036010742, -0.032318115, -0.044921875, 0.06121826, 0.0084991455, -0.051483154, -0.001367569, -0.0031719208, -0.017745972, -0.012954712, 0.042388916, 0.02670288, -0.0076942444, -0.0026836395, 0.020324707, 0.030563354, 0.022354126, 0.026809692, -0.012290955, 0.030639648, 0.0010614395, -0.015388489, -0.009757996, 0.030700684, -0.011940002, 0.0053482056, -0.005935669, 0.02279663, -0.005367279, 0.008956909, 0.012817383, 0.007484436, 0.012458801, 0.021499634, 0.026123047, -0.007736206, -0.041412354, -0.012298584, 0.037902832, 0.0076560974, -0.0008544922, 0.005554199, -0.013008118, 0.036132812, 0.0016870499, 0.052703857, 0.073913574, 0.021026611, 0.0007252693, 0.0045204163, 0.012168884, -0.04272461, 0.020126343, -0.03152466, -0.0096206665, -0.0064582825, -0.0181427, -0.03741455, -0.03643799, -0.027648926, 0.009475708, 0.007801056, -0.003768921, 0.060546875, -0.0026474, -0.057159424, -0.0107040405, -0.007396698, -0.01576233, -0.022232056, 0.023452759, -0.03086853, -0.018218994, 0.0008883476, 0.025909424, 0.0064201355, -0.013298035, -0.0036792755, -0.054504395, -0.003490448, -0.014968872, 0.027069092, 0.06262207, 0.028839111, 0.043151855, -0.016418457, 0.03503418, 0.036987305, 0.0074920654, -0.07525635, -0.038024902, -0.042785645, 0.028213501, -0.028564453, 0.034729004, 0.038330078, 0.017654419, 0.052490234, -0.03829956, -0.021636963, -0.03265381, -0.03390503, 0.01449585, -0.011352539, 0.023406982, 0.008583069, 0.014045715, -0.00019168854, 0.03277588, 0.01966858, 0.037231445, -0.0019836426, -0.013061523, 0.018417358, 0.021987915, 0.014518738, -0.01576233, -0.0021343231, 0.037750244, -0.05206299, -0.005836487, 0.0019721985, 0.0418396, 0.014312744, 0.047576904, -0.043945312, -0.0038776398, 0.050811768, 0.016723633, 0.031585693, -0.053619385, 0.04864502, -0.018539429, -0.013633728, 0.044830322, -0.062194824, 0.022018433, -0.021881104, 0.021636963, -0.051574707, -0.019241333, -0.03366089, -0.046966553, -0.008338928, -0.0040016174, 0.013877869, -0.03414917, 0.042022705, -0.03527832, -0.022277832, -0.003458023, -0.0104599, 0.002948761, 0.007537842, -0.04171753, 0.037200928, 0.0023708344, -0.011314392, -0.018875122, -0.0055274963, -0.06842041, 0.0037822723, 0.01776123, 0.04437256, 0.056854248, -0.047332764, -0.03515625, 0.0009074211, -0.0030555725, 0.014137268, -0.012329102, 0.011558533, 0.008544922, -0.05734253, -0.0023498535, -0.0033226013, 0.0028629303, 0.009971619, 0.044036865, 0.025848389, -0.007709503, -0.0029964447, -0.008369446, 0.027923584, 0.010444641, 0.019088745, 0.02810669, -0.0052719116, -0.00039315224, -0.008255005, 0.00000590086, 0.0048942566, 0.009529114, 0.035095215, -0.0030403137, -0.007522583, 0.020446777, -0.0025138855, -0.02670288, -0.013954163, 0.017425537, -0.04748535, 0.0003361702, 0.017974854, 0.0048217773, -0.012268066, -0.003232956, 0.022659302, -0.035461426, -0.070007324, -0.037384033, 0.013175964, -0.09649658, -0.057281494, -0.0022697449, -0.020889282, -0.008773804, -0.0016832352, 0.04248047, -0.03149414, 0.012382507, -0.008392334, -0.04425049, 0.08099365, 0.07104492, -0.008964539, 0.014190674, -0.018966675, 0.020187378, -0.06335449, -0.030044556, 0.043884277, 0.028625488, -0.016220093, -0.018585205, -0.047943115, -0.014091492, -0.0592041, 0.016784668, 0.028411865, -0.031707764, -0.012435913, 0.021072388, 0.03201294, -0.031219482, -0.0029125214, 0.049591064, 0.049560547, -0.03100586, 0.018188477, 0.06677246, -0.016998291, -0.047180176, 0.0047798157, -0.014320374, -0.048706055, 0.02281189, 0.034301758, -0.019577026, 0.012870789, 0.008262634, 0.021362305, -0.013580322, -0.025222778, -0.013626099, -0.0020275116, -0.02178955, 0.018539429, -0.0079193115, 0.025787354, -0.001581192, -0.010139465, -0.013832092, 0.003332138, -0.009346008, -0.014251709, 0.004337311, 0.0077667236, -0.025314331, -0.041259766, -0.0047569275, -0.01651001, 0.004627228, -0.009391785, -0.005004883, 0.046142578, -0.006866455, -0.0340271, 0.017837524, 0.008888245, 0.03201294, 0.036071777, -0.048675537, -0.0960083, -0.014228821, -0.0061073303, -0.07312012, -0.051574707, -0.054718018, -0.0107040405, -0.033935547, 0.0023021698, 0.01626587, 0.046691895, -0.038757324, -0.03527832, 0.018844604, -0.0075302124, -0.003665924, 0.0602417, -0.019256592, 0.023483276, 0.0044441223, -0.016159058, -0.025512695, -0.009796143, 0.022888184, 0.013938904, -0.050567627, -0.10095215, 0.041809082, -0.010910034, 0.049438477, 0.06604004, 0.0058555603, 0.051116943, 0.026031494, -0.0035552979, 0.002500534, -0.002521515, 0.0004632473, -0.008216858, 0.016998291, 0.0513916, 0.035949707, 0.0025615692, 0.003452301, -0.021392822, -0.016052246, 0.06628418, 0.007091522, -0.07476807, 0.047576904, -0.005405426, -0.0362854, -0.07171631, -0.00008070469, 0.020629883, 0.0051193237, 0.04714966, -0.0046844482, 0.01826477, 0.002111435, 0.024093628, -0.004333496, 0.012123108, 0.019699097, -0.015235901, -0.033294678, 0.00041985512, -0.014678955, 0.009140015, -0.03756714, -0.032836914, -0.022399902, -0.018218994, 0.0058784485, -0.0146484375, -0.0053863525, -0.01876831, 0.014305115, -0.022949219, 0.0058898926, 0.02758789, -0.03353882, -0.02923584, -0.03289795, 0.0061416626, -0.035003662, 0.040802002, 0.025619507, -0.0062713623, 0.023544312, -0.0034923553, -0.0067863464, -0.044006348, -0.0340271, -0.027297974, -0.04925537, -0.039916992, -0.011352539, -0.0184021, -0.00422287, 0.029144287, -0.044067383, 0.012763977, -0.012374878, -0.009788513, 0.0028476715, 0.0019664764, 0.037506104, -0.016693115, -0.0027065277, 0.0039367676, -0.02949524, -0.037475586, 0.004917145, -0.04562378, -0.013290405, -0.021697998, -0.0026874542, 0.041107178, 0.008857727, -0.0030975342, 0.003648758, -0.0052833557, -0.020980835, 0.010215759, 0.0068969727, 0.010604858, 0.018203735, 0.023590088, -0.0022792816, -0.0496521, 0.020507812, -0.04083252, -0.0069274902, 0.0015830994, 0.0022945404, -0.026275635, 0.022994995, 0.0063438416, 0.012908936, -0.05947876, 0.07147217, 0.04397583, -0.0209198, -0.03579712, -0.023071289, -0.017562866, -0.022445679, -0.031707764, -0.027694702, 0.0022239685, 0.0015363693, 0.03488159, -0.0021648407, 0.0006303787, -0.011428833, -0.03173828, -0.0040779114, -0.004547119, -0.025558472, 0.03918457, -0.007068634, 0.0014982224, 0.019256592, 0.06524658, -0.011497498, 0.014625549, 0.020706177, -0.029205322, 0.042510986, -0.014541626, -0.0039901733, -0.0036411285, -0.02368164, 0.002910614, 0.008308411, 0.011184692, -0.013465881, -0.0446167, -0.009292603, -0.011833191, -0.0041275024, -0.031829834, 0.05996704, -0.0029792786, -0.029037476, -0.0385437, 0.0047416687, -0.041778564, 0.03149414, 0.007171631, -0.027633667, -0.016708374, -0.024978638, 0.020477295, -0.0079956055, -0.02406311, 0.00096178055, -0.036712646, -0.036132812, 0.0022201538, 0.020095825, -0.025100708, 0.017440796, -0.008758545, 0.002538681, -0.023406982, 0.04119873, 0.010429382, 0.017120361, -0.0073890686, -0.0236969, 0.018081665, 0.0061836243, 0.011795044, -0.05380249, 0.005302429, -0.026519775, 0.06866455, 0.024169922, 0.004951477, 0.018234253, -0.010429382, 0.00818634, 0.0004248619, 0.0038261414, 0.018981934, -0.014953613, 0.0003490448, 0.038635254, 0.0038051605, 0.000579834, -0.016174316, -0.004802704, -0.010467529, -0.07757568, -0.034362793, -0.026046753, 0.003643036, 0.035095215, -0.039642334, -0.024612427, 0.026031494, 0.01084137, 0.029022217, 0.031463623, -0.012535095, -0.033081055, -0.0005044937, -0.048614502, -0.040802002, -0.04046631, 0.0335083, 0.020889282, 0.03475952, 0.054351807, -0.019699097, 0.026657104, -0.009353638, 0.064941406, -0.03286743, -0.025009155, -0.06488037, 0.016677856, -0.056640625, 0.020980835, -0.0014820099, 0.0017709732, 0.043762207, 0.0064888, 0.078125, -0.0579834, 0.017303467, -0.027648926, 0.009918213, -0.026367188, -0.040039062, 0.0050239563, 0.008918762, 0.006000519, 0.0019989014, 0.06915283, -0.0011711121, 0.034301758, -0.043945312, -0.0597229, 0.014846802, 0.030410767, 0.028656006, 0.025268555, -0.031829834, -0.03265381, -0.008171082, -0.00041103363, -0.0027542114, 0.022888184, 0.012992859, 0.009986877, 0.0031700134, 0.04626465, -0.006210327, 0.05303955, -0.021759033, 0.02532959, -0.049835205, 0.008857727, 0.0340271, -0.003320694, 0.01979065, 0.018600464, -0.0017204285, 0.054718018, -0.0078125, 0.05029297, 0.036193848, 0.064819336, -0.024261475, -0.00061893463, 0.04095459, -0.008094788, 0.016174316, 0.0078048706, 0.014137268, 0.012519836, -0.023361206, -0.0038490295, 0.044555664, 0.03314209, 0.09106445, -0.01927185, -0.0049819946, -0.025299072, 0.0128479, -0.043884277, -0.010627747, 0.016998291, -0.05618286, 0.025650024, -0.007980347, 0.013221741, -0.032348633, 0.0037612915, -0.018859863, 0.0049476624, 0.021987915, 0.002216339, 0.025482178, -0.030471802, -0.042755127, 0.02154541, 0.022781372, 0.07348633, 0.036834717, -0.015945435, 0.0041770935, 0.016021729, 0.02609253, -0.06719971, -0.042938232, -0.018417358, 0.041015625, -0.08087158, 0.03286743, 0.003780365, 0.004688263, 0.064453125, -0.024642944, 0.019546509, 0.0042304993, 0.018463135, 0.018936157, 0.0043411255, -0.027954102, 0.013389587, -0.06829834, -0.014167786, -0.034179688, 0.0047798157, -0.006778717, 0.028671265, -0.010932922, -0.06341553, -0.014717102, -0.009178162, -0.0211792, -0.06744385, 0.000009834766, 0.011367798, 0.022979736, 0.008964539, 0.009292603, 0.068237305, -0.0032653809, 0.005092621, 0.00617218, -0.04675293, -0.022537231, 0.04486084, 0.034698486, 0.018249512, -0.00065660477, -0.022735596, 0.017349243, 0.01210022, -0.011116028, -0.02029419, 0.002292633, 0.018112183, -0.0519104, -0.01159668, -0.006225586, 0.0050735474, -0.036346436, -0.012016296, -0.037078857, -0.028320312, -0.03277588, 0.0039100647, -0.038970947, 0.010917664, -0.007019043, 0.0023860931, -0.011962891, -0.05117798, 0.056610107, 0.05178833, -0.00012731552, -0.052246094, 0.005634308, 0.007259369, 0.01600647, -0.03857422, -0.056396484, -0.010574341, -0.01574707, 0.0051116943, 0.002380371, 0.053344727, -0.05947876, -0.010749817, -0.09692383, -0.04473877, -0.0016145706, -0.018051147, -0.004852295, -0.05419922, 0.05331421, -0.020767212, 0.006210327, 0.028381348, 0.02758789, 0.06536865, 0.026657104, -0.023513794, 0.0017719269, 0.027359009, -0.016494751 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2001.10269v4
Causal query in observational data with hidden variables
Debo Cheng, Jiuyong Li, Lin Liu, Jixue Liu, Kui Yu, Thuc Duy Le
cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
This paper discusses the problem of causal query in observational data with hidden variables, with the aim of seeking the change of an outcome when "manipulating" a variable while given a set of plausible confounding variables which affect the manipulated variable and the outcome. Such an "experiment on data" to estimate the causal effect of the manipulated variable is useful for validating an experiment design using historical data or for exploring confounders when studying a new relationship. However, existing data-driven methods for causal effect estimation face some major challenges, including poor scalability with high dimensional data, low estimation accuracy due to heuristics used by the global causal structure learning algorithms, and the assumption of causal sufficiency when hidden variables are inevitable in data. In this paper, we develop a theorem for using local search to find a superset of the adjustment (or confounding) variables for causal effect estimation from observational data under a realistic pretreatment assumption. The theorem ensures that the unbiased estimate of causal effect is included in the set of causal effects estimated by the superset of adjustment variables. Based on the developed theorem, we propose a data-driven algorithm for causal query. Experiments show that the proposed algorithm is faster and produces better causal effect estimation than an existing data-driven causal effect estimation method with hidden variables. The causal effects estimated by the proposed algorithm are as accurate as those by the state-of-the-art methods using domain knowledge.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2001.10269v4
"2020-11-24T05:11:56"
"2020-01-28T11:23:26"
{ "title": [ -0.024368286, 0.0025348663, -0.04949951, -0.03955078, 0.010505676, -0.015617371, -0.016708374, -0.019042969, -0.0017375946, -0.0011301041, -0.03387451, -0.0007457733, -0.023162842, -0.029022217, -0.008590698, -0.020126343, 0.0016393661, 0.022872925, -0.01927185, -0.026443481, -0.024871826, -0.030014038, 0.029449463, -0.00920105, 0.030731201, 0.035980225, -0.044708252, 0.020462036, -0.014175415, -0.0031967163, -0.005897522, -0.055664062, 0.024368286, 0.0317688, -0.00356102, -0.010772705, -0.021514893, 0.01474762, 0.012290955, 0.013679504, -0.009124756, 0.0011634827, 0.003660202, -0.038879395, -0.03970337, 0.025558472, -0.050048828, -0.01550293, -0.015449524, 0.038024902, 0.013214111, 0.057739258, -0.01739502, 0.0803833, 0.023971558, -0.020599365, -0.022735596, -0.03817749, 0.046325684, 0.037475586, 0.004688263, -0.07104492, 0.034362793, -0.02029419, -0.006511688, -0.026779175, -0.004135132, 0.05783081, 0.05947876, 0.017608643, -0.038085938, 0.013534546, -0.018936157, 0.048309326, -0.050933838, -0.015411377, 0.05343628, 0.0042304993, 0.014205933, 0.010498047, -0.012260437, -0.007888794, -0.010726929, 0.004108429, -0.020477295, -0.01991272, -0.024017334, -0.011474609, -0.025421143, -0.037139893, -0.009918213, -0.013793945, -0.008399963, 0.038513184, -0.01626587, -0.016036987, -0.017501831, 0.0423584, -0.005531311, -0.043304443, -0.05340576, 0.04232788, -0.10784912, 0.0037612915, 0.00048041344, 0.017715454, 0.0211792, 0.021759033, 0.009216309, 0.023269653, -0.015975952, 0.03692627, -0.016036987, 0.021987915, -0.017440796, 0.011230469, -0.025375366, 0.013191223, -0.015060425, 0.041778564, -0.028640747, -0.028656006, -0.01739502, -0.03137207, 0.022964478, -0.034484863, -0.041107178, 0.04949951, -0.04135132, 0.06488037, -0.009262085, 0.0068206787, -0.071777344, -0.03387451, -0.021408081, 0.015640259, -0.0069847107, -0.037322998, -0.009941101, 0.025466919, 0.008476257, -0.03552246, 0.010894775, 0.001786232, -0.001121521, 0.023712158, 0.05911255, -0.020324707, -0.04711914, -0.007205963, -0.037231445, 0.020248413, 0.029541016, 0.02017212, -0.10211182, 0.02305603, -0.12420654, -0.0013437271, -0.0032157898, -0.0021209717, 0.008979797, -0.010116577, -0.02255249, 0.009468079, 0.03564453, 0.015716553, 0.005218506, 0.033416748, 0.0028266907, 0.03152466, -0.011383057, 0.0071372986, 0.012001038, -0.004180908, -0.010467529, 0.017791748, 0.00566864, 0.0039253235, 0.030731201, -0.01159668, 0.018569946, -0.00969696, -0.011070251, 0.07513428, -0.06311035, 0.0016651154, -0.009231567, -0.0047950745, 0.039642334, 0.004749298, -0.030807495, 0.038970947, -0.07312012, -0.029785156, -0.035705566, -0.0059127808, 0.03378296, 0.016143799, -0.0025939941, 0.03640747, -0.0034217834, 0.023361206, -0.04067993, 0.01184845, -0.019073486, -0.038635254, -0.0059509277, 0.009597778, -0.039489746, 0.07171631, 0.06137085, 0.008255005, -0.034057617, 0.024246216, 0.020980835, -0.07476807, 0.029449463, -0.026306152, -0.0043640137, -0.024017334, -0.021133423, 0.00356102, -0.013923645, 0.051727295, -0.003929138, -0.009094238, 0.024780273, -0.035949707, 0.047698975, 0.011314392, 0.105651855, -0.05105591, -0.0025672913, -0.013496399, 0.0008792877, -0.0032577515, 0.003435135, -0.019561768, 0.00868988, 0.021820068, -0.0044288635, -0.032836914, -0.009437561, 0.044403076, -0.0032901764, -0.03277588, 0.0056266785, 0.02935791, 0.019226074, -0.012069702, 0.08685303, 0.00022423267, 0.06707764, 0.0569458, 0.020614624, 0.042816162, 0.028442383, 0.029434204, -0.0049705505, 0.040985107, -0.0061416626, 0.024658203, -0.009918213, 0.0066375732, -0.041137695, -0.00856781, -0.03366089, -0.006904602, 0.0043754578, 0.006248474, 0.025024414, -0.07019043, 0.00004285574, -0.011955261, -0.0044174194, 0.0003976822, -0.025436401, 0.018737793, 0.0044898987, -0.0473938, -0.010040283, 0.02520752, 0.040405273, -0.0019931793, 0.01852417, 0.037109375, 0.016311646, -0.028152466, 0.013511658, 0.010215759, 0.06536865, 0.029327393, 0.016021729, 0.009841919, -0.012878418, -0.009414673, 0.01360321, 0.03668213, -0.013870239, 0.02255249, -0.05407715, 0.033355713, 0.045318604, -0.02645874, 0.01184082, 0.0033740997, 0.024261475, 0.02255249, -0.010322571, -0.0034065247, -0.027450562, 0.032989502, -0.00011563301, -0.044921875, -0.02470398, -0.042144775, 0.0052833557, -0.052246094, -0.04840088, -0.022369385, 0.050811768, -0.010345459, -0.053100586, -0.016708374, 0.009483337, -0.0051727295, -0.044952393, -0.02909851, -0.01448822, 0.030822754, 0.04663086, 0.034088135, -0.048553467, -0.029052734, -0.0010461807, 0.014755249, -0.012954712, 0.013366699, -0.023071289, -0.002122879, -0.007045746, -0.03970337, 0.0209198, -0.037902832, 0.021636963, -0.043762207, -0.0063591003, 0.017349243, -0.03793335, 0.018600464, -0.000041604042, -0.03543091, -0.014656067, 0.024810791, 0.076049805, -0.03793335, -0.033966064, 0.06713867, 0.04159546, -0.0042915344, 0.020126343, -0.015388489, -0.032196045, -0.05078125, 0.021987915, -0.04006958, -0.022384644, -0.03265381, 0.0017662048, 0.04864502, -0.08068848, -0.014373779, -0.021896362, 0.025253296, 0.047607422, 0.03829956, -0.007045746, -0.03741455, -0.017822266, -0.023147583, 0.0012702942, 0.017532349, -0.029846191, 0.018127441, 0.10064697, 0.0049858093, 0.039398193, 0.029907227, 0.051483154, 0.009117126, -0.03817749, -0.043884277, -0.0093307495, -0.0093688965, 0.03152466, 0.027175903, -0.015541077, -0.031982422, -0.068725586, 0.00007593632, 0.007820129, 0.0035743713, -0.017456055, -0.010910034, -0.06512451, 0.006679535, -0.048797607, -0.027038574, 0.03353882, 0.08251953, -0.011787415, 0.026565552, 0.012954712, -0.012191772, 0.00084877014, -0.00969696, -0.06439209, 0.03564453, -0.024032593, -0.065979004, 0.0065727234, -0.03036499, -0.030441284, -0.018005371, 0.0068588257, 0.04333496, 0.028945923, 0.0096206665, 0.0041275024, -0.030410767, 0.0019264221, -0.03125, -0.01436615, -0.026275635, -0.0058784485, -0.018234253, -0.023773193, 0.016967773, -0.011138916, 0.0037651062, 0.002281189, -0.01007843, -0.008598328, 0.030578613, -0.007194519, -0.02607727, 0.0015249252, 0.00079870224, -0.007659912, -0.031463623, -0.01197052, -0.00274086, -0.017608643, 0.0037136078, -0.0025405884, 0.05508423, 0.014533997, -0.0002667904, -0.026870728, 0.0034179688, 0.0025997162, -0.010444641, -0.068847656, -0.02130127, 0.04348755, -0.038970947, 0.07006836, -0.03894043, -0.006378174, 0.023010254, -0.04562378, 0.011932373, 0.018417358, 0.0016994476, -0.00831604, 0.02041626, -0.023590088, -0.009933472, -0.017990112, 0.024108887, 0.040130615, -0.00920105, 0.013366699, -0.041503906, -0.017166138, 0.022979736, -0.1262207, 0.0046463013, 0.018585205, -0.042236328, -0.017242432, -0.07989502, 0.039093018, -0.053894043, -0.047607422, 0.0031776428, -0.009925842, -0.018478394, -0.011886597, -0.07714844, -0.004245758, 0.07336426, 0.013626099, 0.039611816, 0.013122559, 0.0010929108, 0.0019626617, -0.023330688, 0.018127441, -0.005882263, 0.04220581, -0.013061523, 0.014785767, 0.030899048, -0.014770508, 0.013015747, 0.06781006, 0.015411377, 0.011550903, -0.009536743, 0.006702423, 0.008033752, -0.004512787, 0.045410156, 0.02482605, -0.029647827, -0.022781372, 0.0069007874, 0.0041923523, 0.0022258759, 0.009109497, -0.030517578, 0.03704834, 0.018508911, 0.010345459, 0.0501709, -0.027023315, -0.011299133, 0.05783081, 0.013809204, -0.022613525, 0.0051727295, 0.016204834, 0.06011963, 0.013977051, 0.004501343, -0.01663208, 0.052581787, -0.008163452, 0.021636963, -0.009483337, -0.011543274, 0.01914978, -0.008911133, -0.060668945, -0.042297363, -0.0029830933, -0.00093460083, 0.0027580261, 0.026473999, 0.013969421, 0.00920105, -0.059173584, 0.009101868, 0.026611328, -0.008911133, 0.05166626, 0.008430481, 0.054138184, -0.029678345, -0.026428223, -0.05505371, 0.023910522, 0.004890442, 0.041229248, -0.009460449, -0.024520874, 0.028381348, 0.027435303, 0.039794922, 0.055603027, -0.032318115, -0.05316162, 0.005218506, 0.008285522, 0.032043457, -0.016677856, 0.02923584, 0.005268097, 0.005256653, -0.037994385, -0.009002686, -0.0020503998, -0.032226562, 0.015144348, -0.052581787, 0.068725586, 0.024230957, 0.03439331, 0.02848816, -0.0013580322, 0.017242432, 0.01965332, -0.04083252, -0.027633667, 0.020324707, 0.039489746, 0.0016746521, 0.024810791, 0.0012683868, -0.0047035217, -0.011436462, -0.011680603, 0.0340271, 0.0038318634, -0.04309082, -0.017227173, 0.022781372, 0.025909424, 0.0059394836, 0.047454834, 0.009178162, 0.062042236, -0.010185242, 0.031555176, 0.0014591217, 0.019607544, 0.00060653687, -0.018051147, 0.038482666, -0.01928711, 0.02420044, -0.06524658, -0.055419922, -0.0073280334, 0.06427002, -0.04034424, -0.0024929047, -0.0046424866, 0.043029785, 0.026016235, 0.032562256, 0.034057617, -0.016784668, -0.018463135, -0.024871826, -0.0045394897, -0.010467529, -0.061431885, 0.034179688, -0.01713562, 0.022232056, -0.0018863678, -0.0007944107, -0.068481445, 0.015014648, 0.0035953522, -0.021514893, 0.011680603, -0.08514404, 0.010688782, 0.026672363, 0.016418457, 0.00970459, -0.04220581, 0.021102905, 0.04257202, 0.04043579, 0.0064964294, 0.009780884, 0.02067566, -0.023590088, -0.01576233, -0.0020160675, 0.017288208, 0.012496948, 0.012718201, 0.023071289, 0.0022773743, -0.036956787, 0.029815674, 0.031280518, -0.02029419, -0.006439209, -0.052886963, 0.024719238, -0.004173279, 0.00004029274, 0.026763916, -0.0093688965, -0.036010742, -0.0061073303, 0.011077881, -0.01928711, 0.018173218, 0.036499023, -0.018997192, -0.024810791, 0.024993896, -0.006023407, 0.041778564, 0.0042800903, -0.01890564, -0.028869629, 0.0046195984, 0.041381836, -0.041290283, 0.043304443, -0.040252686, 0.01083374, 0.05065918, 0.026321411, -0.007835388, 0.0048980713, 0.0063056946, -0.06304932, -0.015075684, 0.03062439, 0.0049819946, -0.012260437, -0.0043296814, -0.027740479, 0.0063476562, -0.0055656433, 0.024414062, 0.011131287, -0.011817932, 0.043060303, 0.02229309, 0.013977051, -0.0038013458, 0.037078857, 0.0011329651, -0.003293991, 0.018951416, -0.04663086, -0.012329102, 0.022766113, 0.0043945312, -0.04034424, -0.06341553, -0.0076828003, 0.024246216, 0.01864624, -0.025619507, 0.003194809, 0.027389526, 0.017364502, -0.03048706, -0.019470215, 0.060638428, -0.03277588, -0.019851685, 0.013328552, 0.0009794235, -0.022918701, 0.043792725, 0.024673462, -0.007472992, -0.040649414, -0.04196167, -0.037475586, 0.0001732111, 0.03164673, 0.00381279, 0.032348633, 0.019317627, 0.036346436, -0.0074424744, -0.018310547, -0.0059127808, 0.035369873, 0.0012273788, -0.05026245, -0.0070724487, -0.012382507, 0.0037555695, -0.06677246, 0.01576233, 0.019882202, 0.03829956, -0.0037326813, -0.056549072, -0.01411438, -0.010604858, -0.02331543, 0.053741455, -0.0030517578, 0.007511139, 0.06384277, -0.03866577, 0.017745972, 0.02658081, 0.07293701, 0.045440674, 0.02909851, 0.022644043, 0.017440796, 0.025939941, -0.039245605, -0.0124435425, -0.03994751, 0.00806427, -0.02998352, 0.017822266, -0.083740234, 0.03543091, 0.010505676, 0.016448975, -0.011749268, 0.0039749146, -0.022323608, 0.048919678, 0.043945312, 0.0690918, 0.050476074, -0.0028533936, -0.027023315, 0.0065689087, 0.0070533752, 0.018051147, 0.039367676, 0.0028877258, 0.0021896362, -0.02458191, -0.014732361, 0.0093688965, 0.007507324, 0.017608643, 0.0038528442, -0.016342163, -0.020248413, 0.020568848, -0.011428833, 0.027053833, 0.05770874, 0.01890564, -0.03656006, 0.0067596436, 0.018859863, 0.012084961, -0.007080078, 0.012275696, 0.05517578, -0.07556152, 0.039855957, 0.00072574615, -0.03665161, -0.0042419434, 0.04547119, 0.027526855, -0.064575195, -0.026397705, 0.024642944, 0.020263672, 0.013931274, 0.030731201, -0.02519226, 0.028137207, 0.03677368, -0.0057029724, 0.029251099, 0.01939392, 0.015975952, 0.027282715, -0.0041618347, -0.026168823, 0.03390503, 0.011810303, 0.008270264, 0.028823853, -0.024627686, 0.03881836, -0.006793976, -0.040527344, 0.028259277, -0.004360199, -0.03668213, -0.013832092, 0.046203613, 0.021392822, 0.012489319, 0.0680542, 0.027435303, -0.023162842, -0.040863037, -0.032592773, 0.041778564, 0.050201416, -0.015464783, 0.039245605, -0.042663574, -0.049560547, 0.05731201, -0.049041748, 0.07550049, -0.06677246, -0.0069465637, -0.017562866, 0.0050621033, 0.011001587, -0.018478394, -0.03274536, -0.034851074, -0.0064430237, 0.014709473, 0.023742676, -0.042633057, -0.031677246, 0.018753052, 0.021011353, 0.027374268, -0.008865356, -0.010116577, -0.022659302, -0.03414917, 0.012954712, -0.00983429, 0.037750244, -0.015151978, -0.020599365, -0.037597656, 0.013130188, -0.007762909, -0.001332283, -0.003440857, 0.014450073, -0.041381836, -0.021530151, 0.018630981, 0.031082153, -0.01737976, -0.039916992, 0.006839752, -0.01108551, -0.024246216, 0.012229919, 0.0033435822, -0.048187256, -0.026046753, -0.0035533905, -0.027374268, 0.03741455, 0.016616821, -0.0154800415, 0.016983032, 0.041290283, -0.037994385, -0.06567383, -0.04119873, -0.015686035, 0.002653122, -0.057525635, 0.004360199, 0.030853271, 0.023239136, -0.05529785, -0.015716553, 0.0317688, 0.05908203, -0.023284912, 0.08355713, 0.011917114, 0.01612854, 0.036224365, 0.065979004, 0.0011711121, -0.04852295, -0.042297363, -0.009559631, 0.02760315, 0.04043579, 0.0076141357, -0.04031372, 0.016799927, 0.00022733212, -0.00894165, 0.013824463, -0.0037002563, -0.018341064, 0.011627197, 0.0064086914, -0.030044556, -0.033691406, 0.015258789, -0.02104187, 0.01763916, 0.0068626404, -0.024841309, -0.00080394745, -0.036865234, 0.050231934, -0.013221741, -0.041625977, 0.03062439, 0.025939941, 0.02961731, -0.010185242, -0.0015382767, -0.004951477, -0.0056381226, -0.019943237, -0.0036258698, -0.024520874, 0.048034668, -0.06210327, 0.00042176247, -0.03152466, -0.029388428, 0.006626129, -0.03086853, 0.0513916, -0.020507812, 0.003206253, -0.030548096, -0.02658081, -0.014137268, 0.02027893, -0.022750854, -0.06100464, -0.04977417, 0.0035495758, 0.055999756, -0.011116028 ], "summary": [ 0.021057129, -0.008369446, -0.0017299652, -0.006504059, -0.0335083, -0.016906738, -0.031280518, -0.031677246, -0.009750366, -0.013893127, -0.03768921, -0.009391785, -0.013748169, -0.03765869, 0.033447266, -0.04864502, 0.00086927414, 0.028152466, 0.008926392, -0.02267456, 0.001537323, -0.011131287, -0.019256592, -0.017456055, 0.018814087, 0.046417236, 0.021987915, 0.0015630722, 0.043060303, 0.04144287, 0.027175903, -0.09881592, -0.019546509, 0.05038452, -0.0051460266, -0.038970947, 0.015701294, 0.010574341, -0.015327454, 0.03970337, 0.015792847, -0.0046844482, 0.0725708, -0.03540039, 0.022537231, 0.01398468, 0.026062012, -0.03982544, 0.015960693, 0.005130768, 0.0021896362, 0.046722412, -0.0129776, 0.03640747, -0.007801056, -0.006965637, -0.017196655, -0.03186035, 0.028137207, 0.016464233, -0.0020771027, -0.042633057, 0.025894165, -0.024597168, 0.017410278, -0.019927979, 0.009307861, 0.03552246, 0.041870117, 0.04043579, -0.0039596558, 0.017913818, -0.022903442, 0.053527832, -0.041931152, -0.043914795, 0.04699707, -0.013542175, 0.00042152405, 0.03555298, -0.042999268, 0.010040283, 0.0032672882, -0.036224365, -0.008705139, -0.011390686, -0.033416748, -0.0023288727, -0.020141602, 0.005695343, -0.009460449, -0.029769897, -0.02217102, 0.03881836, 0.021118164, -0.03741455, 0.011566162, 0.017410278, -0.005569458, -0.048675537, -0.008773804, 0.0015048981, -0.070007324, 0.0055618286, -0.0064048767, -0.013771057, 0.034088135, 0.06530762, 0.028930664, 0.02458191, -0.025756836, 0.039642334, -0.016601562, 0.0012712479, -0.0317688, 0.050323486, 0.00027227402, -0.0050697327, -0.02670288, 0.04421997, -0.026245117, 0.017700195, -0.07458496, 0.021591187, -0.0036296844, -0.018844604, 0.017318726, 0.04751587, -0.021438599, 0.04296875, -0.050231934, -0.00642395, 0.059387207, 0.037231445, 0.013175964, -0.03967285, -0.016021729, -0.05227661, 0.0064468384, -0.0051727295, 0.038604736, 0.0007157326, 0.026855469, 0.0129470825, 0.012413025, 0.002494812, 0.031188965, 0.0025482178, -0.021118164, 0.010131836, -0.02810669, 0.05126953, 0.04260254, -0.014701843, -0.074401855, -0.058441162, -0.033203125, -0.02973938, 0.02168274, -0.053466797, -0.024749756, -0.014762878, -0.017196655, 0.023605347, 0.02468872, 0.008674622, 0.036834717, 0.028274536, 0.00020849705, 0.0010471344, -0.0064048767, 0.0002951622, 0.016403198, -0.03062439, -0.017242432, -0.006767273, -0.02470398, -0.024673462, -0.01399231, 0.04824829, 0.062927246, -0.0053482056, -0.07525635, 0.07775879, -0.042907715, 0.028411865, -0.015945435, 0.048828125, 0.019577026, 0.0037326813, -0.023284912, 0.01171875, -0.059509277, -0.02041626, -0.014587402, 0.025009155, -0.0010299683, 0.015029907, -0.00415802, 0.0021343231, 0.06335449, 0.027954102, -0.032073975, -0.005455017, -0.076538086, -0.012420654, 0.006843567, 0.011405945, -0.029907227, 0.04147339, 0.030303955, -0.0023078918, -0.013938904, 0.019485474, 0.02432251, -0.045013428, 0.019088745, -0.07965088, -0.016311646, -0.06512451, -0.021240234, 0.030151367, -0.048675537, 0.054504395, -0.013450623, -0.014556885, 0.00289917, -0.015167236, 0.04071045, -0.024307251, 0.09136963, -0.020095825, -0.024230957, -0.017654419, 0.0009851456, 0.0121154785, 0.021255493, -0.05899048, 0.014961243, 0.025054932, 0.0073547363, -0.0048332214, -0.033721924, 0.030380249, -0.06500244, -0.044891357, 0.0024375916, 0.03213501, 0.003332138, -0.0055656433, 0.061035156, -0.020446777, 0.03970337, 0.020629883, 0.048095703, 0.0004582405, 0.019714355, 0.014511108, -0.013870239, 0.041992188, -0.014808655, -0.003850937, -0.02507019, -0.013847351, 0.0075569153, -0.05255127, -0.014053345, -0.019073486, 0.023010254, -0.046936035, 0.007686615, -0.06732178, -0.014122009, -0.04168701, -0.04953003, -0.0050582886, -0.04324341, 0.055114746, -0.002998352, -0.047851562, -0.0060195923, 0.018600464, 0.016189575, -0.00894165, 0.034973145, 0.042510986, 0.0031776428, -0.023223877, 0.0703125, 0.097717285, 0.09173584, 0.017288208, 0.006652832, 0.03378296, -0.028182983, -0.013587952, -0.018600464, -0.009689331, -0.00071144104, 0.0045204163, -0.0032634735, 0.057739258, 0.031829834, -0.015014648, 0.017791748, -0.009063721, 0.004558563, 0.025253296, 0.01751709, -0.004337311, -0.024017334, 0.03466797, 0.018844604, 0.041870117, -0.029159546, -0.036834717, -0.017150879, 0.022445679, -0.026504517, -0.006778717, 0.066223145, 0.0035533905, -0.010528564, -0.007865906, -0.008934021, -0.018630981, -0.015556335, -0.022964478, 0.07080078, -0.006252289, -0.0047035217, 0.016860962, -0.051513672, -0.027542114, 0.0033950806, -0.008026123, -0.0022850037, 0.0012722015, -0.0037727356, 0.007835388, 0.010421753, -0.0045204163, 0.02154541, -0.016052246, 0.012962341, -0.006134033, 0.014541626, 0.0022010803, -0.016845703, 0.033111572, -0.021255493, -0.023132324, -0.016296387, 0.03552246, 0.030075073, -0.023422241, 0.011749268, 0.05899048, 0.03881836, -0.009063721, 0.023773193, 0.010688782, -0.021621704, -0.0637207, -0.012580872, -0.028869629, -0.0032482147, -0.03463745, 0.033966064, 0.02470398, -0.03955078, -0.0009074211, -0.021514893, 0.028808594, 0.068481445, 0.017745972, 0.07080078, -0.017181396, -0.0061912537, 0.035339355, 0.0069274902, 0.01953125, -0.0435791, 0.006439209, 0.080078125, -0.0026569366, 0.040740967, 0.04574585, 0.024459839, -0.0032634735, -0.042114258, -0.04006958, -0.0033130646, -0.040405273, 0.03878784, 0.031341553, 0.022140503, -0.014762878, 0.024368286, -0.048065186, -0.049102783, 0.039123535, 0.029708862, -0.035583496, -0.02470398, 0.023330688, -0.06781006, -0.025421143, 0.011077881, 0.027114868, -0.004135132, -0.0010652542, -0.015083313, 0.000088095665, -0.0068511963, -0.0036716461, 0.047576904, 0.03805542, -0.03640747, -0.08068848, 0.005996704, 0.02658081, 0.0065460205, -0.036743164, 0.028793335, 0.040649414, -0.01436615, -0.0020961761, -0.03857422, 0.0034427643, 0.00422287, -0.025848389, -0.03048706, -0.022247314, 0.0056877136, 0.0031871796, -0.015823364, -0.034088135, -0.007194519, -0.014350891, 0.0012273788, -0.0007915497, -0.0055236816, 0.027557373, -0.007259369, 0.007297516, -0.0036945343, -0.011039734, 0.008071899, 0.0028648376, -0.012962341, -0.008354187, 0.047576904, 0.024169922, -0.016174316, 0.053497314, 0.014923096, 0.014289856, 0.018981934, -0.023269653, -0.02281189, -0.0132751465, -0.04840088, -0.020446777, 0.04208374, -0.03262329, 0.03515625, -0.029586792, -0.030090332, 0.022033691, -0.03164673, -0.006767273, -0.04547119, -0.029678345, 0.008628845, -0.009513855, 0.017456055, 0.0074501038, 0.031799316, -0.005126953, 0.015777588, 0.0056533813, 0.04067993, -0.03768921, -0.035980225, 0.03253174, -0.11437988, -0.031585693, 0.039001465, -0.02128601, 0.020446777, -0.07543945, 0.08380127, -0.089660645, -0.01625061, 0.01576233, -0.032409668, 0.08782959, 0.0026283264, -0.066833496, 0.062469482, -0.027328491, 0.038879395, 0.019729614, -0.016296387, 0.048614502, 0.0647583, 0.014274597, -0.011703491, -0.003894806, 0.02772522, -0.04824829, 0.07110596, 0.0047836304, 0.025299072, 0.007911682, 0.077697754, 0.032104492, 0.022964478, -0.025665283, 0.033325195, 0.045654297, -0.013626099, 0.020446777, 0.022781372, -0.04473877, 0.021209717, -0.0018692017, -0.0020828247, 0.030227661, -0.0026741028, 0.027145386, 0.0008120537, -0.015464783, 0.015380859, -0.0670166, -0.0262146, -0.0015859604, 0.040740967, 0.01586914, -0.025878906, -0.020431519, -0.009002686, 0.045135498, -0.0034542084, -0.009811401, -0.03881836, 0.015640259, -0.033966064, 0.025726318, -0.00018906593, -0.020309448, -0.029449463, -0.02281189, -0.007041931, 0.00061941147, -0.013656616, 0.004825592, 0.0030136108, 0.029006958, -0.05102539, 0.019561768, -0.018753052, 0.009132385, -0.017471313, 0.030517578, 0.0076141357, 0.013313293, -0.021453857, -0.044311523, -0.02911377, -0.037963867, -0.05154419, -0.014801025, -0.003736496, 0.023422241, -0.031982422, 0.011787415, -0.026351929, -0.0004594326, 0.027023315, 0.005710602, -0.012649536, -0.014984131, 0.020339966, 0.055145264, -0.033416748, 0.04260254, -0.0004606247, 0.027526855, -0.0635376, -0.0011444092, -0.039031982, -0.06161499, 0.0013103485, -0.016799927, 0.04067993, 0.08416748, 0.055999756, 0.02885437, -0.015106201, -0.0007510185, 0.0077323914, -0.03753662, -0.0050315857, 0.0070724487, 0.0057868958, -0.01802063, 0.024276733, -0.016693115, -0.03945923, -0.054779053, -0.001531601, 0.038208008, -0.014656067, -0.031982422, -0.026290894, 0.03515625, 0.06982422, 0.03982544, 0.074035645, 0.014564514, 0.030517578, 0.004348755, -0.026916504, 0.009628296, 0.02319336, 0.016403198, -0.018081665, -0.0049819946, 0.009788513, -0.008888245, -0.024612427, -0.028793335, -0.016021729, 0.032714844, -0.021987915, -0.061584473, -0.018371582, 0.044708252, 0.009246826, -0.0038871765, 0.022766113, -0.043395996, -0.029296875, -0.024215698, -0.008270264, 0.01398468, -0.041046143, -0.014434814, -0.018371582, 0.011131287, 0.02607727, 0.0043029785, -0.008354187, 0.028823853, -0.003993988, -0.02444458, 0.036102295, -0.053375244, -0.07092285, -0.011245728, -0.019134521, -0.02999878, 0.0017662048, -0.017410278, 0.020645142, 0.01777649, -0.0289917, 0.0030460358, -0.01966858, 0.004436493, -0.0005440712, -0.017791748, 0.019607544, 0.0098724365, -0.0077285767, 0.017700195, 0.0039901733, -0.027618408, 0.006252289, 0.010498047, -0.015037537, -0.018493652, -0.021316528, 0.06286621, -0.020126343, -0.01524353, 0.001449585, 0.030899048, 0.026031494, 0.03555298, 0.023880005, 0.02255249, -0.019638062, -0.0018692017, 0.03503418, -0.0072135925, -0.025878906, -0.04837036, 0.06390381, 0.010116577, -0.02458191, -0.00008147955, -0.04067993, -0.0021324158, -0.030838013, 0.062042236, 0.0043182373, 0.016098022, 0.031463623, -0.02128601, -0.0049743652, 0.009651184, -0.0070152283, -0.037994385, -0.038848877, 0.03112793, -0.0018606186, 0.01966858, 0.0047035217, 0.02268982, 0.031799316, -0.019195557, 0.02848816, -0.011985779, -0.012588501, 0.02720642, 0.008903503, 0.009544373, -0.014038086, 0.032684326, -0.030517578, -0.015457153, 0.040100098, -0.058532715, -0.016799927, 0.013336182, -0.0005059242, -0.05053711, -0.07141113, -0.007575989, 0.002105713, 0.026138306, -0.002922058, -0.018310547, -0.00064992905, 0.031799316, -0.01612854, -0.027542114, 0.045806885, -0.0031375885, -0.022979736, 0.016082764, 0.015434265, -0.018371582, -0.0014505386, 0.0423584, 0.012588501, -0.0116119385, -0.028121948, -0.0072898865, -0.018676758, 0.00016331673, -0.0046081543, 0.0033931732, 0.064208984, 0.059661865, -0.039245605, -0.0134887695, 0.01108551, 0.014404297, -0.015640259, -0.058288574, 0.02204895, -0.018569946, 0.010627747, -0.03894043, -0.000269413, 0.032562256, 0.029830933, -0.001958847, -0.037261963, -0.012779236, -0.0009651184, 0.0010223389, 0.020233154, -0.015525818, 0.024673462, 0.017333984, -0.004459381, -0.004676819, 0.029037476, 0.044433594, 0.028182983, 0.029907227, 0.018798828, 0.021270752, 0.022216797, -0.019699097, 0.040405273, 0.007270813, 0.015365601, -0.003660202, -0.0074806213, -0.023513794, 0.08874512, -0.014671326, -0.013656616, 0.039733887, -0.00932312, -0.021240234, 0.0793457, -0.017288208, 0.119018555, 0.013313293, 0.0012235641, -0.029663086, 0.03656006, -0.0033473969, 0.010765076, 0.033203125, 0.019515991, -0.0020313263, -0.01927185, -0.0011177063, 0.025985718, -0.019302368, -0.015899658, 0.00030946732, 0.015113831, -0.027572632, 0.011222839, 0.0065460205, 0.02645874, 0.02166748, -0.03161621, -0.0071105957, 0.0075912476, 0.00092458725, 0.081726074, 0.011627197, 0.043701172, 0.06121826, 0.0054626465, -0.008331299, 0.028030396, -0.038391113, 0.05154419, 0.036468506, 0.031982422, -0.03552246, -0.009811401, 0.020370483, -0.0033245087, -0.0076789856, 0.029418945, -0.01171875, 0.040771484, 0.052612305, -0.038146973, 0.03842163, 0.010635376, 0.023971558, 0.009429932, 0.01789856, 0.021835327, 0.022277832, 0.022247314, 0.020370483, 0.031402588, -0.031311035, 0.014671326, 0.038085938, -0.009246826, 0.020095825, 0.0368042, 0.003774643, 0.032073975, 0.013046265, 0.04058838, 0.012893677, 0.06866455, 0.013504028, 0.01083374, -0.007648468, 0.014953613, 0.007972717, 0.039733887, 0.0073928833, -0.0019397736, -0.019622803, -0.009750366, 0.015556335, -0.021835327, 0.036621094, -0.062805176, -0.0064849854, -0.023101807, -0.01361084, -0.03652954, 0.014167786, -0.013793945, -0.06329346, -0.041168213, 0.036834717, 0.042755127, -0.038024902, 0.0048332214, -0.0027008057, -0.05392456, 0.012451172, 0.012710571, 0.02381897, -0.022567749, 0.015312195, 0.022125244, 0.026123047, 0.057159424, 0.013465881, -0.026687622, -0.02218628, 0.039398193, 0.024108887, -0.019729614, -0.026550293, 0.031951904, 0.023864746, -0.03744507, 0.023788452, 0.042877197, -0.025726318, -0.06573486, 0.0056877136, -0.006954193, -0.038757324, 0.013122559, 0.0038108826, -0.0039100647, -0.013458252, -0.010353088, -0.033325195, -0.005420685, -0.0262146, 0.00010180473, 0.033416748, 0.03878784, -0.023239136, -0.046936035, -0.040771484, -0.05596924, 0.011642456, -0.05532837, -0.014854431, 0.013595581, 0.03173828, -0.019378662, 0.023040771, 0.0519104, 0.042877197, -0.0035533905, 0.009841919, -0.03881836, 0.004459381, 0.02986145, 0.09106445, 0.0051956177, -0.02772522, -0.021865845, 0.044403076, 0.047851562, -0.0031166077, -0.013534546, -0.00881958, -0.010475159, -0.05593872, -0.035949707, 0.0020866394, 0.02217102, -0.040985107, 0.020446777, -0.029037476, -0.05206299, -0.055603027, 0.05758667, -0.0368042, 0.00818634, -0.012893677, -0.021743774, -0.026138306, -0.039611816, -0.021697998, 0.04119873, 0.013397217, -0.017456055, -0.009376526, 0.059570312, -0.05722046, 0.015220642, -0.017807007, -0.028305054, -0.029800415, -0.007411957, -0.047058105, 0.055236816, -0.072143555, -0.015640259, 0.006389618, -0.017074585, 0.02456665, -0.027359009, 0.047332764, -0.026947021, 0.0090408325, -0.0053100586, -0.0103302, 0.020553589, -0.010429382, 0.002286911, -0.024429321, 0.01876831, 0.0057754517, -0.00021362305, 0.022277832 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2007.05505v4
Neural Knowledge Extraction From Cloud Service Incidents
Manish Shetty, Chetan Bansal, Sumit Kumar, Nikitha Rao, Nachiappan Nagappan, Thomas Zimmermann
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.DC, cs.LG
In the last decade, two paradigm shifts have reshaped the software industry - the move from boxed products to services and the widespread adoption of cloud computing. This has had a huge impact on the software development life cycle and the DevOps processes. Particularly, incident management has become critical for developing and operating large-scale services. Incidents are created to ensure timely communication of service issues and, also, their resolution. Prior work on incident management has been heavily focused on the challenges with incident triaging and de-duplication. In this work, we address the fundamental problem of structured knowledge extraction from service incidents. We have built SoftNER, a framework for unsupervised knowledge extraction from service incidents. We frame the knowledge extraction problem as a Named-entity Recognition task for extracting factual information. SoftNER leverages structural patterns like key,value pairs and tables for bootstrapping the training data. Further, we build a novel multi-task learning based BiLSTM-CRF model which leverages not just the semantic context but also the data-types for named-entity extraction. We have deployed SoftNER at Microsoft, a major cloud service provider and have evaluated it on more than 2 months of cloud incidents. We show that the unsupervised machine learning based approach has a high precision of 0.96. Our multi-task learning based deep learning model also outperforms the state of the art NER models. Lastly, using the knowledge extracted by SoftNER we are able to build significantly more accurate models for important downstream tasks like incident triaging.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.05505v4
"2021-01-15T21:56:16"
"2020-07-10T17:33:07"
{ "title": [ -0.012962341, 0.010871887, -0.07928467, -0.08135986, 0.022521973, -0.024124146, -0.041168213, 0.028884888, -0.014640808, 0.031204224, -0.013435364, 0.0007543564, -0.005554199, -0.029327393, -0.028045654, 0.0009622574, 0.004585266, -0.01612854, -0.01626587, -0.028518677, 0.0101623535, -0.016616821, 0.048583984, -0.010986328, 0.039642334, -0.024505615, -0.06756592, 0.026763916, -0.019378662, -0.019866943, -0.000105679035, 0.0027275085, 0.03491211, 0.018936157, -0.0143585205, -0.020233154, -0.05770874, 0.023086548, -0.0019493103, -0.0033950806, 0.013870239, -0.001701355, 0.029632568, -0.052947998, -0.006214142, 0.062805176, -0.086120605, -0.04385376, -0.0018415451, 0.035980225, 0.026428223, 0.012268066, 0.0004093647, 0.05090332, 0.011650085, -0.030914307, -0.046905518, -0.00970459, 0.036834717, 0.049194336, 0.028915405, -0.05230713, 0.016204834, -0.015464783, -0.0680542, -0.02507019, 0.060821533, 0.0044555664, 0.05883789, -0.06323242, -0.021957397, 0.064208984, -0.006843567, 0.016235352, -0.033325195, -0.030853271, 0.07562256, -0.003686905, -0.003047943, 0.0054092407, -0.016296387, -0.02204895, -0.012207031, -0.027175903, 0.015449524, -0.03250122, -0.0039711, -0.008857727, -0.041503906, -0.047576904, -0.0038089752, -0.047943115, -0.028198242, 0.025009155, 0.0103302, -0.03869629, -0.035369873, -0.016433716, -0.002916336, -0.036346436, -0.015411377, 0.02494812, -0.08087158, 0.013786316, 0.026397705, 0.014167786, -0.018585205, -0.061279297, 0.0052223206, 0.027389526, -0.03744507, 0.027435303, 0.0178833, -0.010795593, -0.0027637482, 0.011520386, 0.015960693, 0.0013484955, 0.012771606, 0.013053894, -0.024719238, -0.036376953, -0.022994995, 0.01651001, 0.024368286, -0.01171875, -0.02822876, 0.037994385, 0.004714966, 0.011009216, -0.0057907104, 0.028335571, -0.08227539, -0.07043457, -0.05178833, 0.035003662, -0.012268066, 0.00522995, 0.016616821, -0.03237915, 0.08276367, 0.0027694702, -0.00983429, 0.06933594, 0.0209198, -0.002922058, 0.05557251, -0.0032901764, -0.030776978, -0.003780365, -0.016799927, 0.028137207, 0.03604126, 0.0016670227, -0.061828613, -0.023101807, -0.08190918, -0.034332275, 0.01713562, -0.032958984, 0.014282227, -0.0044898987, 0.006259918, 0.021224976, 0.036193848, 0.017486572, -0.017471313, 0.016784668, 0.003786087, 0.025100708, -0.016998291, 0.014801025, 0.00035595894, -0.022598267, -0.0158844, -0.009033203, 0.036987305, 0.028427124, -0.0023231506, 0.0066223145, 0.025650024, -0.028045654, -0.006324768, 0.040893555, -0.064208984, -0.004722595, 0.0030918121, 0.016525269, 0.048675537, 0.0037765503, -0.02166748, 0.010765076, -0.028686523, -0.030349731, -0.021102905, -0.01776123, 0.019241333, 0.019592285, 0.0021305084, 0.0026378632, -0.050354004, 0.000875473, -0.028121948, 0.010726929, -0.014038086, -0.03567505, -0.016860962, 0.021743774, -0.04864502, 0.02810669, 0.07513428, 0.014343262, -0.056640625, 0.033813477, 0.0067253113, -0.051330566, 0.014259338, -0.026489258, -0.0126571655, -0.016799927, -0.027893066, -0.0023765564, -0.008659363, 0.05545044, -0.0069389343, 0.016967773, -0.0023422241, -0.012565613, 0.0440979, 0.018859863, 0.10571289, -0.04019165, 0.062438965, 0.049072266, 0.002122879, -0.038604736, -0.023956299, -0.04812622, 0.007259369, 0.02784729, 0.0078086853, -0.0085372925, -0.002948761, 0.022247314, 0.010917664, -0.039245605, 0.014724731, 0.0063591003, 0.0013494492, 0.019836426, 0.04937744, 0.04095459, 0.047424316, 0.053955078, -0.022064209, 0.06506348, -0.0021572113, -0.009407043, -0.017242432, 0.016189575, 0.0048217773, -0.026626587, -0.01727295, -0.006210327, -0.049987793, 0.0050697327, -0.024139404, 0.0055160522, -0.004070282, 0.00409317, 0.037506104, -0.017211914, -0.0013570786, 0.0061149597, 0.012748718, -0.024673462, -0.012252808, 0.0077934265, 0.005924225, -0.048675537, -0.015777588, 0.0033168793, 0.034942627, -0.009788513, 0.037841797, -0.011039734, 0.00089740753, -0.030166626, -0.041290283, 0.023712158, 0.055419922, 0.083618164, 0.029754639, -0.0051193237, -0.027877808, 0.049316406, 0.06866455, 0.07611084, -0.023757935, 0.054718018, -0.052337646, 0.018753052, 0.007030487, -0.015426636, 0.013206482, 0.029464722, 0.024368286, -0.0008749962, -0.027664185, 0.02571106, -0.062286377, 0.009246826, 0.009796143, -0.011154175, -0.05230713, -0.053222656, -0.02003479, -0.037231445, -0.054016113, -0.03225708, 0.09063721, 0.008857727, -0.03253174, -0.0102005005, 0.000078856945, -0.021957397, -0.025863647, -0.03414917, -0.0068893433, 0.027664185, 0.02470398, 0.037750244, -0.042236328, 0.024871826, -0.007293701, 0.016540527, -0.010368347, 0.03012085, -0.013702393, -0.015426636, 0.0016031265, -0.030136108, -0.002954483, -0.034698486, -0.025054932, -0.020263672, 0.010551453, 0.01889038, -0.024414062, -0.011703491, 0.029785156, -0.032836914, -0.020187378, 0.010688782, 0.050994873, -0.01991272, -0.01020813, 0.019378662, 0.015129089, -0.017990112, -0.002483368, 0.027557373, -0.007858276, -0.043945312, -0.022766113, -0.04660034, -0.012832642, 0.012573242, -0.015411377, 0.02458191, -0.029830933, -0.024368286, -0.066589355, -0.00088882446, 0.009483337, 0.019439697, 0.040924072, -0.010444641, -0.049957275, 0.004714966, 0.00806427, 0.015510559, -0.05026245, -0.019699097, 0.06390381, -0.005432129, -0.04815674, 0.004421234, 0.014961243, 0.018508911, -0.018295288, -0.0072631836, -0.018356323, 0.013214111, 0.028366089, -0.0012130737, -0.00080251694, 0.010566711, -0.103759766, -0.005908966, 0.0065689087, 0.017425537, -0.030883789, 0.014205933, -0.058288574, -0.021316528, -0.014953613, -0.03137207, 0.02986145, 0.038024902, -0.00078582764, 0.012275696, 0.0027713776, -0.024276733, -0.0063171387, -0.025939941, -0.10272217, 0.012039185, 0.012039185, -0.015899658, -0.0076026917, -0.037353516, -0.0569458, -0.0064735413, -0.006626129, 0.003376007, 0.032318115, 0.026306152, 0.0035686493, -0.026672363, -0.012397766, -0.04083252, -0.00932312, -0.039794922, -0.03829956, -0.014183044, -0.012435913, 0.05831909, 0.021270752, -0.00712204, -0.026550293, 0.015144348, 0.036987305, 0.03302002, 0.020080566, -0.04360962, 0.009246826, 0.0007991791, 0.007007599, 0.026794434, -0.005207062, -0.0066375732, -0.016067505, -0.0032291412, -0.028533936, 0.0064697266, 0.0042495728, 0.020889282, -0.04949951, -0.008552551, 0.023498535, -0.029342651, -0.014587402, -0.001613617, 0.025436401, -0.009735107, 0.021865845, -0.0058403015, -0.0236969, 0.019836426, -0.006801605, -0.0009484291, -0.025421143, -0.012931824, -0.011978149, 0.011260986, -0.026428223, -0.010810852, 0.024475098, 0.028961182, 0.006324768, 0.011367798, -0.055633545, -0.059265137, 0.012741089, -0.013717651, -0.10070801, -0.0181427, 0.010238647, -0.041656494, -0.039489746, -0.07043457, 0.015777588, -0.019546509, -0.03869629, 0.013404846, -0.023361206, 0.041259766, -0.020523071, -0.090026855, 0.007663727, 0.0491333, 0.019088745, 0.044830322, 0.0063095093, 0.0025024414, -0.017868042, -0.038726807, 0.019088745, -0.03579712, 0.021713257, -0.021209717, -0.029296875, 0.03161621, -0.03845215, 0.06173706, 0.007980347, 0.014022827, 0.013458252, -0.0055122375, 0.010475159, 0.014282227, -0.04168701, 0.057403564, 0.005783081, -0.02003479, -0.07940674, 0.013755798, -0.01600647, -0.027938843, 0.020004272, -0.0077705383, 0.028305054, 0.021087646, -0.0044784546, 0.057403564, -0.03488159, 0.0010566711, 0.04144287, -0.02027893, -0.012138367, -0.00504303, 0.023590088, 0.035003662, 0.0028591156, 0.05267334, 0.0027046204, 0.07543945, -0.055755615, 0.0048217773, 0.005138397, 0.017227173, -0.051971436, -0.0154800415, -0.049468994, -0.018997192, -0.030838013, 0.020477295, -0.028320312, 0.010810852, 0.03942871, -0.004558563, -0.04095459, 0.017303467, 0.042388916, -0.0011491776, -0.014381409, -0.074157715, 0.03265381, 0.0037994385, -0.05807495, -0.037475586, 0.02909851, 0.020553589, 0.044830322, -0.037261963, 0.009994507, 0.015281677, 0.03778076, 0.03845215, 0.040161133, -0.021865845, -0.0395813, 0.028060913, -0.023757935, 0.014152527, 0.026763916, 0.011672974, 0.01083374, 0.018585205, 0.032043457, -0.024475098, -0.05618286, -0.05557251, 0.044128418, 0.042633057, 0.038513184, 0.013412476, 0.014175415, 0.039276123, 0.007446289, 0.025772095, 0.017196655, -0.037963867, -0.009300232, -0.0025959015, 0.05203247, -0.016159058, 0.0054473877, 0.038635254, 0.015419006, 0.009063721, 0.010566711, 0.0104522705, 0.02319336, -0.00818634, -0.03086853, 0.057373047, -0.020935059, -0.021133423, -0.024749756, 0.0007119179, 0.01940918, -0.083862305, 0.048034668, -0.043182373, 0.011993408, 0.008239746, -0.0018129349, 0.012435913, -0.024551392, 0.018478394, -0.053894043, -0.014968872, 0.014984131, 0.026397705, -0.041809082, -0.0038757324, -0.015914917, 0.013420105, 0.02243042, 0.031829834, 0.00920105, -0.00655365, -0.012832642, -0.010566711, -0.014518738, -0.026947021, -0.059509277, 0.0025634766, -0.0033111572, 0.026535034, -0.02658081, 0.015411377, -0.051116943, -0.0085372925, -0.023742676, 0.016952515, 0.0057296753, -0.051971436, -0.0036392212, 0.066345215, 0.025909424, 0.015808105, -0.031463623, 0.0138549805, 0.022399902, 0.04623413, 0.011604309, -0.0043411255, 0.04284668, -0.06738281, 0.023666382, 0.0063934326, 0.019958496, -0.017730713, 0.021255493, -0.003616333, 0.0067634583, -0.047302246, 0.028198242, 0.015029907, -0.013931274, 0.00497818, -0.040405273, 0.02809143, -0.01348114, 0.0005569458, 0.008720398, -0.033050537, -0.035949707, -0.012428284, -0.011459351, -0.019134521, 0.0234375, 0.020629883, -0.04522705, -0.049560547, 0.023742676, -0.012481689, 0.00831604, -0.012565613, 0.0033493042, -0.055511475, -0.0014533997, 0.051727295, -0.023117065, 0.04534912, -0.02243042, 0.005710602, 0.058441162, 0.0041656494, -0.016296387, -0.0016908646, -0.011543274, -0.04284668, -0.059143066, -0.0072021484, -0.009468079, 0.014373779, 0.0027313232, -0.0104599, 0.022140503, 0.0034427643, 0.0317688, 0.0131073, -0.021408081, 0.043640137, 0.020523071, 0.024642944, 0.016113281, -0.0014715195, 0.022521973, 0.013496399, -0.004699707, -0.017349243, 0.013710022, 0.018325806, 0.016357422, -0.043121338, -0.072631836, -0.006465912, 0.014701843, 0.0041542053, -0.009719849, -0.01966858, 0.037017822, -0.028137207, 0.028793335, 0.011230469, 0.11645508, -0.058532715, -0.0054740906, -0.039642334, 0.0064811707, -0.049713135, 0.04031372, -0.03100586, -0.006034851, -0.03213501, -0.051971436, -0.032714844, 0.0044441223, 0.026794434, 0.015556335, 0.039123535, -0.054351807, 0.0082092285, -0.010971069, -0.010765076, -0.026290894, 0.038238525, 0.011230469, 0.0062217712, -0.013847351, -0.005455017, 0.018585205, -0.042114258, 0.014472961, 0.0079574585, 0.006538391, 0.008285522, -0.04788208, 0.0012893677, -0.02671814, -0.022567749, 0.03378296, 0.015281677, 0.014671326, 0.044799805, -0.044891357, 0.034118652, 0.018371582, -0.0015954971, 0.025177002, -0.010192871, -0.014572144, -0.0025234222, -0.014083862, -0.035461426, 0.036499023, -0.053619385, -0.018585205, -0.0836792, -0.024398804, -0.08502197, 0.022232056, -0.0209198, 0.014846802, -0.0040016174, 0.002067566, -0.014030457, 0.013710022, 0.043823242, -0.0013780594, 0.034454346, 0.009918213, 0.0030002594, -0.0158844, 0.023757935, 0.012084961, 0.018859863, 0.01499939, 0.02458191, -0.009513855, -0.01864624, 0.0030727386, 0.009864807, 0.019989014, 0.0014858246, 0.0019321442, -0.003648758, 0.055419922, 0.01007843, 0.05166626, 0.03137207, 0.048797607, -0.041778564, -0.0014429092, 0.0018949509, -0.022323608, -0.004135132, -0.016601562, 0.03314209, -0.087402344, 0.030059814, 0.0037593842, -0.014320374, 0.0031547546, 0.02822876, 0.0395813, -0.03338623, -0.0023479462, 0.01398468, 0.023422241, 0.0015983582, 0.023345947, -0.037384033, 0.00756073, 0.0132369995, -0.0039405823, 0.000097095966, -0.0018539429, 0.040405273, 0.01247406, -0.014015198, -0.015960693, 0.007972717, 0.022415161, -0.008804321, 0.032714844, -0.023712158, -0.0038375854, -0.008506775, -0.039398193, -0.0050354004, -0.0056533813, 0.011474609, -0.044952393, 0.05255127, 0.0335083, -0.007774353, 0.039031982, -0.0040397644, -0.03527832, -0.03262329, -0.022964478, 0.035217285, 0.05886841, -0.023956299, 0.00459671, -0.027832031, -0.044067383, 0.02003479, -0.031433105, 0.086120605, -0.050231934, -0.0033454895, -0.031951904, 0.011161804, 0.025558472, -0.04876709, 0.0049438477, -0.040283203, -0.03741455, 0.0035991669, 0.019958496, -0.024459839, -0.0340271, -0.0040779114, 0.011367798, 0.0032615662, 0.0041923523, 0.014015198, -0.02444458, -0.04147339, 0.024291992, -0.0395813, 0.06439209, -0.07269287, -0.015060425, -0.021148682, 0.017440796, 0.016921997, 0.0052757263, -0.033996582, 0.036254883, -0.007259369, -0.046569824, 0.03213501, 0.03503418, -0.009399414, -0.009384155, -0.020187378, -0.012237549, -0.022354126, 0.0126953125, 0.015853882, -0.035705566, -0.01461792, 0.008483887, -0.032440186, 0.011421204, 0.009269714, -0.0060424805, -0.030303955, 0.030395508, -0.029586792, -0.019577026, 0.012321472, 0.051818848, -0.006587982, -0.037872314, -0.0057525635, 0.0423584, 0.051452637, -0.03201294, -0.058898926, 0.016281128, -0.0032157898, -0.01826477, 0.06652832, 0.0059509277, 0.0154800415, 0.024108887, 0.07305908, 0.0051231384, -0.06225586, -0.03881836, -0.005596161, 0.058807373, 0.019958496, -0.011810303, -0.022888184, 0.008331299, -0.017593384, -0.0012521744, -0.0026950836, -0.020706177, -0.011962891, -0.0064315796, 0.005012512, -0.0005912781, -0.039764404, -0.007080078, 0.011650085, 0.001127243, 0.04232788, -0.026626587, 0.01675415, 0.0032310486, 0.03387451, -0.02255249, -0.081848145, 0.04864502, 0.053131104, -0.006919861, 0.06341553, -0.029922485, -0.037750244, 0.002811432, -0.007537842, -0.003572464, 0.025436401, 0.019088745, -0.033203125, -0.003408432, -0.043060303, -0.037963867, 0.012840271, -0.04473877, 0.057922363, -0.04928589, -0.0054397583, -0.036193848, 0.0005354881, 0.0034751892, 0.026733398, 0.013031006, -0.036621094, -0.027542114, 0.03314209, 0.045654297, -0.0079956055 ], "summary": [ 0.010070801, -0.004436493, -0.06335449, -0.10021973, -0.0025730133, -0.024429321, -0.07678223, 0.038879395, -0.0048599243, 0.0043029785, -0.0262146, 0.028442383, 0.008201599, -0.036499023, 0.059051514, -0.015853882, -0.0061531067, 0.006549835, 0.013511658, -0.0335083, 0.021636963, -0.03717041, 0.03387451, -0.033325195, 0.025924683, -0.031311035, -0.033813477, 0.040649414, -0.004196167, 0.022460938, 0.018981934, -0.014228821, 0.019439697, 0.00004017353, 0.00019943714, -0.010520935, -0.0362854, 0.006652832, -0.004776001, 0.011390686, -0.0032348633, 0.012825012, 0.09887695, -0.06359863, 0.02015686, 0.06982422, -0.0602417, -0.0491333, 0.03152466, -0.017227173, -0.0011472702, 0.045196533, 0.00022649765, -0.03253174, -0.018066406, -0.019332886, -0.046661377, -0.028945923, 0.009971619, 0.0847168, 0.034423828, -0.02571106, -0.00033712387, -0.041992188, -0.03591919, -0.02734375, 0.1138916, -0.007457733, -0.013641357, -0.051879883, 0.049743652, 0.05343628, -0.0002399683, -0.016983032, -0.0037212372, -0.017105103, 0.041168213, 0.0035419464, -0.0074882507, 0.007785797, 0.019546509, 0.013046265, 0.023345947, -0.02897644, 0.0059280396, -0.024734497, -0.0032196045, 0.0005912781, 0.0030765533, -0.007888794, 0.0012512207, -0.02130127, -0.02508545, 0.06304932, 0.041748047, -0.030670166, -0.032073975, -0.049468994, -0.044830322, -0.06652832, 0.013725281, 0.008255005, -0.05633545, 0.034240723, 0.005882263, 0.036834717, -0.026748657, -0.06890869, 0.010719299, 0.017913818, -0.013725281, -0.007949829, 0.0012722015, -0.05331421, 0.0017557144, 0.0357666, 0.0137786865, 0.015396118, 0.0016765594, -0.014503479, -0.021759033, 0.00009417534, -0.0043945312, -0.020263672, -0.008560181, -0.03326416, -0.023452759, 0.013160706, 0.025924683, -0.021621704, -0.028640747, 0.031707764, -0.0051078796, -0.02079773, -0.014709473, -0.00447464, 0.010627747, 0.022140503, 0.040496826, -0.04800415, 0.06921387, 0.028503418, -0.0037498474, 0.06390381, 0.02331543, 0.0055770874, 0.024749756, 0.0020389557, 0.0027275085, 0.027755737, -0.031021118, 0.011764526, 0.06939697, -0.029693604, -0.0836792, -0.1015625, -0.04559326, -0.05203247, 0.03616333, -0.073913574, -0.008865356, 0.0076904297, 0.04095459, 0.028442383, 0.01524353, 0.013366699, -0.032226562, -0.011146545, 0.004558563, -0.026245117, -0.02432251, 0.04244995, 0.013412476, -0.03652954, -0.0006337166, -0.028823853, -0.02696228, 0.06982422, -0.0031547546, 0.0064735413, 0.03439331, -0.05206299, 0.015182495, 0.042785645, -0.042022705, 0.011642456, -0.00390625, 0.05947876, 0.046142578, 0.021606445, -0.0072517395, -0.009811401, -0.0060310364, 0.013801575, 0.012413025, -0.018295288, -0.017333984, 0.010375977, -0.0119018555, -0.025054932, 0.015609741, 0.050842285, -0.035736084, 0.015174866, 0.019943237, -0.011260986, 0.030563354, 0.010406494, -0.04925537, 0.008476257, 0.04611206, -0.0063476562, -0.045562744, 0.053771973, 0.019104004, -0.03253174, 0.023147583, -0.05505371, 0.001033783, -0.02407837, 0.014930725, 0.038970947, -0.007331848, 0.053833008, -0.017715454, 0.022537231, -0.0018644333, 0.019882202, 0.059570312, -0.0032444, 0.13745117, -0.024627686, 0.04977417, 0.059814453, -0.011871338, -0.017532349, -0.010803223, -0.046081543, 0.0027122498, 0.0259552, 0.03817749, 0.011131287, -0.025848389, -0.026687622, 0.030654907, -0.051574707, 0.0041656494, -0.017486572, -0.038635254, -0.003168106, 0.017089844, 0.029174805, 0.022109985, 0.048675537, -0.047576904, 0.024719238, 0.008888245, -0.038879395, -0.006008148, 0.0132369995, 0.008842468, -0.085998535, -0.059692383, -0.017944336, -0.05834961, -0.006877899, 0.01474762, 0.0067100525, -0.0047683716, -0.028533936, 0.017196655, 0.022216797, 0.0024356842, -0.0031490326, -0.011695862, 0.009460449, -0.021224976, 0.01651001, -0.005306244, -0.018539429, -0.0073013306, 0.004585266, 0.006099701, -0.015510559, 0.044006348, -0.021606445, -0.0051879883, -0.024902344, -0.017456055, 0.05493164, 0.03717041, 0.064697266, 0.0006041527, 0.022750854, -0.010520935, 0.022460938, 0.045898438, 0.03152466, -0.0017652512, -0.004940033, -0.029266357, 0.022705078, -0.018066406, -0.008102417, 0.018844604, -0.021636963, 0.03152466, -0.014381409, -0.010444641, -0.004005432, -0.055389404, 0.017105103, 0.021209717, 0.09362793, -0.05822754, -0.043029785, -0.029632568, 0.048950195, -0.0077056885, -0.01486969, 0.08996582, -0.015823364, -0.005344391, 0.02708435, -0.020889282, -0.04269409, 0.06048584, -0.026504517, 0.011123657, 0.027053833, -0.023025513, 0.04208374, -0.013183594, 0.07458496, -0.026763916, 0.017868042, 0.008918762, 0.02204895, 0.0037326813, -0.02885437, 0.009941101, -0.014953613, -0.029876709, -0.01537323, -0.073913574, 0.013374329, 0.006690979, 0.010223389, 0.01423645, -0.026428223, 0.030685425, -0.013366699, -0.030212402, -0.0018053055, 0.0020694733, 0.007583618, 0.023971558, 0.008049011, 0.031158447, -0.04284668, 0.010879517, 0.03173828, -0.0040359497, -0.034454346, -0.029953003, -0.031677246, 0.010368347, -0.0007209778, 0.022994995, 0.014335632, 0.03564453, 0.0014820099, -0.09289551, -0.0051345825, 0.0041236877, -0.016723633, 0.07928467, 0.00095415115, -0.011734009, 0.048461914, 0.007751465, 0.026443481, -0.042816162, -0.011299133, 0.034088135, 0.010574341, -0.031341553, 0.018066406, -0.016479492, 0.0038032532, -0.03289795, 0.008720398, -0.047790527, -0.013435364, 0.025726318, 0.00484848, 0.022140503, 0.0040359497, -0.035705566, -0.035583496, -0.011184692, 0.013092041, 0.02142334, -0.01739502, -0.036132812, 0.04525757, -0.025878906, 0.0008716583, 0.043823242, -0.013916016, 0.026428223, -0.00831604, 0.021011353, -0.04736328, -0.036254883, 0.0012235641, -0.046936035, 0.0013666153, 0.007030487, 0.04156494, 0.0057411194, 0.012229919, -0.014228821, 0.014694214, -0.015213013, -0.024459839, -0.011604309, 0.026275635, -0.030334473, -0.008392334, -0.03918457, -0.032043457, 0.026062012, -0.011474609, -0.06121826, 0.0010499954, -0.011222839, 0.029388428, 0.008728027, -0.06298828, -0.039367676, -0.0013799667, 0.0035171509, -0.0234375, 0.01020813, -0.036499023, 0.013519287, 0.0007224083, 0.02128601, 0.029190063, 0.015525818, -0.008354187, 0.02897644, 0.017944336, -0.044799805, 0.021514893, -0.01687622, 0.048034668, 0.0154953, 0.0007634163, 0.030227661, -0.030029297, -0.0024986267, 0.029418945, 0.0129776, 0.0025615692, 0.014328003, 0.03086853, -0.01525116, 0.02027893, 0.05407715, -0.044006348, -0.03250122, -0.034820557, 0.00063562393, -0.025787354, 0.03567505, -0.027374268, 0.064575195, -0.012504578, 0.005634308, 0.011146545, -0.06402588, -0.048553467, -0.00819397, -0.012756348, -0.089660645, -0.04650879, -0.007858276, -0.0066070557, -0.019454956, -0.028259277, 0.019546509, -0.0140686035, -0.010314941, 0.004184723, -0.028076172, 0.11022949, 0.0011558533, -0.08709717, 0.020843506, -0.034484863, -0.012329102, 0.033721924, -0.030838013, 0.023635864, 0.014755249, 0.0038795471, 0.0038528442, -0.09991455, 0.02947998, -0.03955078, -0.03439331, 0.013534546, -0.032592773, 0.06414795, 0.017623901, 0.0052948, 0.034851074, -0.020248413, 0.008300781, 0.033325195, -0.012542725, 0.004714966, 0.0048294067, 0.011962891, -0.03491211, 0.048614502, -0.025161743, -0.04144287, 0.019973755, 0.047821045, -0.04675293, -0.0129470825, 0.032165527, -0.016601562, -0.030029297, -0.022460938, -0.021362305, -0.0009317398, -0.030410767, -0.034851074, -0.009796143, 0.038146973, -0.016845703, 0.0848999, 0.009231567, 0.04473877, -0.032806396, -0.013122559, -0.012039185, 0.023452759, -0.06652832, -0.021911621, -0.011245728, 0.023788452, -0.029846191, 0.014808655, -0.03881836, 0.030548096, 0.0015611649, -0.018478394, -0.014312744, 0.013916016, -0.0011739731, 0.025543213, -0.02923584, -0.06512451, 0.00242424, -0.0018119812, -0.04623413, -0.02709961, 0.029846191, -0.02178955, 0.011894226, -0.027801514, -0.0011892319, 0.017715454, 0.007537842, 0.016525269, 0.037200928, 0.0362854, -0.021774292, 0.019592285, -0.006362915, 0.013076782, -0.005065918, 0.0052871704, -0.0074691772, -0.0033817291, 0.025360107, -0.014274597, -0.052856445, -0.05545044, 0.024536133, 0.04925537, 0.011894226, 0.053497314, 0.03765869, 0.033203125, 0.008071899, 0.009277344, 0.010871887, -0.015594482, -0.0043563843, -0.013519287, 0.016067505, -0.005168915, -0.017990112, -0.009460449, -0.022644043, -0.004432678, -0.004547119, 0.012023926, -0.026855469, -0.003583908, -0.019714355, 0.03741455, 0.0035057068, -0.030273438, -0.034606934, -0.012886047, -0.017669678, -0.049560547, -0.006362915, -0.03173828, 0.015991211, -0.024902344, -0.026626587, 0.016220093, -0.023132324, 0.02279663, -0.01802063, -0.019973755, 0.00881958, 0.014579773, 0.00009739399, 0.011459351, -0.028686523, -0.018951416, 0.022140503, -0.02444458, -0.01586914, -0.03111267, 0.003030777, -0.007865906, -0.013717651, 0.029663086, -0.023605347, -0.02986145, 0.017715454, 0.030075073, 0.025146484, -0.012481689, -0.016937256, -0.00749588, -0.047027588, 0.04559326, -0.026229858, -0.033843994, -0.05657959, 0.011505127, 0.06213379, -0.024246216, -0.0007195473, -0.016296387, 0.00003385544, 0.024810791, -0.012619019, -0.020111084, 0.01574707, -0.06390381, 0.00063085556, -0.0060806274, 0.02255249, -0.029159546, 0.02041626, -0.00021243095, -0.01763916, -0.056152344, 0.014053345, 0.009635925, 0.025222778, -0.032684326, -0.003967285, 0.026550293, -0.04916382, 0.01663208, 0.013755798, 0.01991272, -0.022949219, -0.032226562, 0.03378296, -0.03286743, 0.0049476624, 0.028442383, -0.035736084, -0.00340271, 0.031585693, -0.02645874, 0.011329651, -0.0008740425, -0.024337769, -0.021530151, -0.054840088, 0.023956299, 0.019836426, 0.07110596, -0.013031006, -0.00005865097, 0.033325195, -0.0012969971, 0.0034675598, 0.0028438568, 0.006729126, -0.022033691, -0.058776855, -0.026916504, -0.04031372, 0.02470398, 0.0017127991, -0.024276733, 0.013000488, 0.036987305, 0.019760132, 0.020721436, -0.047088623, 0.058044434, 0.005504608, 0.004863739, 0.038879395, -0.019119263, -0.001408577, 0.012382507, -0.0067253113, 0.012672424, 0.03387451, -0.006706238, 0.032806396, -0.051727295, -0.045532227, -0.0045318604, 0.036895752, 0.00283432, -0.014083862, -0.015457153, -0.0022964478, -0.056671143, 0.0446167, -0.011199951, 0.058288574, 0.012191772, 0.00062561035, -0.050720215, 0.041931152, -0.030090332, -0.0060424805, -0.033203125, -0.01939392, -0.0017051697, -0.0037345886, 0.011695862, -0.0057640076, -0.012138367, -0.018844604, -0.016662598, -0.0044937134, 0.0055656433, 0.09075928, -0.017349243, -0.035064697, -0.01197052, 0.030044556, 0.04107666, 0.017730713, 0.03366089, -0.009918213, 0.0018434525, 0.026016235, 0.016952515, -0.010276794, 0.01272583, -0.010818481, -0.00044941902, -0.00019669533, 0.004081726, 0.014152527, 0.010009766, 0.01197052, -0.0031032562, -0.014579773, 0.012252808, -0.005115509, -0.024795532, -0.026153564, -0.012550354, 0.026565552, -0.014930725, -0.041046143, -0.017303467, 0.07336426, -0.021347046, -0.055114746, -0.07891846, -0.06262207, -0.060760498, 0.020690918, -0.050079346, -0.0037498474, 0.033996582, -0.011474609, -0.010627747, 0.009719849, -0.05935669, -0.0019035339, -0.022781372, 0.015960693, -0.033416748, 0.026428223, 0.015602112, 0.00011986494, 0.052612305, 0.036071777, -0.015296936, 0.009063721, 0.013809204, 0.038085938, -0.038970947, -0.020050049, -0.056518555, 0.029876709, -0.04647827, 0.022964478, 0.025222778, 0.04598999, 0.005718231, -0.015113831, 0.00409317, -0.0061187744, -0.0036621094, 0.0067749023, -0.0135269165, 0.006038666, 0.032714844, -0.052246094, 0.0017490387, 0.016830444, -0.00674057, 0.0071029663, 0.0048294067, 0.046722412, -0.029342651, -0.005355835, -0.0079574585, 0.012863159, -0.012748718, -0.00881958, -0.024841309, 0.0340271, 0.03933716, -0.03274536, 0.017852783, -0.02507019, 0.02859497, 0.0026607513, 0.0068244934, -0.0149383545, -0.015266418, 0.009254456, -0.011894226, 0.033569336, 0.014518738, -0.016189575, -0.028259277, -0.032684326, -0.013015747, 0.007980347, 0.018844604, -0.04159546, 0.0859375, 0.026031494, 0.014755249, 0.028305054, -0.04095459, -0.00009137392, 0.01878357, 0.009246826, -0.0040397644, 0.044647217, -0.020889282, -0.050567627, -0.0075950623, -0.004371643, -0.030090332, -0.008743286, 0.0055351257, -0.064453125, -0.014167786, -0.023788452, 0.013908386, -0.053710938, 0.025360107, 0.01171875, -0.034179688, -0.012496948, 0.00497818, 0.043395996, -0.028900146, -0.018844604, -0.044891357, -0.00046563148, -0.04232788, 0.009552002, 0.061920166, -0.008918762, 0.02482605, -0.007080078, -0.026641846, 0.055725098, -0.08477783, -0.01687622, -0.004219055, 0.028396606, 0.015563965, -0.010032654, -0.029785156, 0.044311523, 0.00009047985, -0.062438965, 0.022628784, -0.0073013306, -0.029510498, -0.07019043, 0.0178833, -0.018356323, -0.038208008, 0.017166138, 0.0022125244, -0.018432617, 0.0010738373, -0.00016903877, -0.0054359436, 0.004470825, 0.0052719116, -0.003036499, -0.026138306, 0.038146973, -0.048950195, -0.042144775, -0.009346008, 0.021591187, 0.006134033, -0.045959473, 0.008773804, 0.028656006, 0.057769775, 0.01838684, 0.041229248, 0.038970947, -0.0317688, 0.0049095154, 0.025985718, -0.029541016, 0.02293396, 0.060760498, 0.06890869, 0.026473999, -0.05706787, 0.00012165308, -0.0059509277, 0.045013428, -0.020553589, -0.021652222, -0.014373779, 0.0046157837, -0.014556885, 0.0020713806, -0.012817383, -0.033569336, -0.024505615, -0.0309906, -0.044281006, -0.0030918121, -0.010520935, -0.0026741028, 0.0051002502, -0.015586853, -0.0031280518, -0.012306213, 0.022842407, -0.02998352, 0.00036907196, -0.023803711, -0.021316528, 0.012924194, 0.017227173, -0.001039505, -0.023590088, 0.0026168823, 0.0051574707, 0.036010742, -0.017593384, -0.024932861, -0.032043457, 0.034973145, -0.028015137, -0.05041504, -0.010437012, -0.01737976, -0.008888245, -0.041381836, 0.03466797, -0.026641846, -0.0107803345, -0.010223389, 0.029800415, 0.02357483, 0.043914795, -0.01902771, -0.008468628, 0.026153564, 0.09741211, -0.009674072, 0.014205933 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2007.05798v2
Planning on the fast lane: Learning to interact using attention mechanisms in path integral inverse reinforcement learning
Sascha Rosbach, Xing Li, Simon Großjohann, Silviu Homoceanu, Stefan Roth
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
General-purpose trajectory planning algorithms for automated driving utilize complex reward functions to perform a combined optimization of strategic, behavioral, and kinematic features. The specification and tuning of a single reward function is a tedious task and does not generalize over a large set of traffic situations. Deep learning approaches based on path integral inverse reinforcement learning have been successfully applied to predict local situation-dependent reward functions using features of a set of sampled driving policies. Sample-based trajectory planning algorithms are able to approximate a spatio-temporal subspace of feasible driving policies that can be used to encode the context of a situation. However, the interaction with dynamic objects requires an extended planning horizon, which depends on sequential context modeling. In this work, we are concerned with the sequential reward prediction over an extended time horizon. We present a neural network architecture that uses a policy attention mechanism to generate a low-dimensional context vector by concentrating on trajectories with a human-like driving style. Apart from this, we propose a temporal attention mechanism to identify context switches and allow for stable adaptation of rewards. We evaluate our results on complex simulated driving situations, including other moving vehicles. Our evaluation shows that our policy attention mechanism learns to focus on collision-free policies in the configuration space. Furthermore, the temporal attention mechanism learns persistent interaction with other vehicles over an extended planning horizon.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.05798v2
"2020-09-12T08:33:02"
"2020-07-11T15:25:44"
{ "title": [ 0.016494751, 0.0062561035, 0.003982544, -0.0066871643, 0.0085372925, -0.025054932, 0.045562744, -0.030044556, -0.040405273, 0.0023975372, -0.06414795, 0.02835083, -0.05593872, 0.0015459061, -0.011329651, -0.061645508, -0.009002686, 0.035064697, -0.017745972, -0.030670166, -0.010040283, -0.048919678, 0.023269653, 0.018722534, 0.04498291, -0.016052246, -0.12792969, 0.023483276, -0.033691406, -0.019515991, -0.017868042, 0.025131226, 0.034576416, 0.0067329407, -0.0022087097, -0.004108429, -0.056884766, 0.029937744, 0.00045847893, -0.005504608, 0.014915466, -0.014961243, -0.038879395, -0.023727417, -0.056396484, 0.02760315, -0.05368042, 0.0056877136, -0.021347046, 0.06347656, 0.018112183, 0.03314209, -0.014091492, 0.041656494, 0.018814087, -0.026382446, -0.046081543, -0.021133423, 0.05331421, 0.052612305, 0.011856079, -0.059051514, 0.008308411, -0.04699707, -0.021362305, -0.05203247, -0.023513794, 0.034179688, 0.0657959, 0.016159058, -0.0017499924, 0.029174805, 0.008583069, 0.029434204, -0.059906006, -0.020050049, 0.07763672, 0.033569336, 0.020004272, -0.03552246, 0.024978638, 0.019729614, 0.013435364, -0.019241333, 0.00025582314, -0.03540039, -0.011566162, -0.0079574585, -0.027053833, -0.05114746, -0.01878357, -0.010520935, 0.014503479, -0.013999939, -0.06488037, -0.033111572, -0.044952393, -0.014450073, 0.013092041, 0.0127334595, -0.022079468, 0.0020618439, -0.018508911, -0.013999939, -0.0038013458, -0.008300781, -0.003162384, -0.0058670044, 0.009223938, 0.03668213, -0.028717041, 0.022262573, 0.036590576, 0.041381836, -0.0014734268, -0.041046143, -0.02255249, 0.036499023, -0.011329651, 0.030029297, -0.03540039, -0.019363403, -0.011009216, 0.0034675598, 0.045288086, 0.010551453, -0.008598328, 0.0126571655, 0.018295288, 0.014717102, 0.0068588257, 0.03253174, -0.10412598, -0.075805664, -0.064575195, 0.037384033, 0.009384155, 0.0029125214, -0.016281128, 0.008903503, 0.039215088, -0.014251709, -0.014038086, 0.01222229, 0.022598267, 0.03970337, 0.050109863, -0.010177612, -0.05203247, -0.052124023, -0.0023040771, -0.0010976791, -0.010643005, 0.033721924, -0.039398193, 0.020355225, -0.101257324, 0.0064964294, 0.050354004, 0.011276245, 0.010032654, 0.010116577, 0.019882202, 0.032440186, 0.0546875, -0.02053833, -0.017074585, 0.023086548, 0.013328552, 0.076416016, 0.004512787, -0.003227234, -0.07733154, -0.0259552, -0.0024929047, -0.0065231323, 0.046325684, 0.011421204, -0.012176514, 0.029129028, 0.027679443, -0.038604736, -0.0059394836, 0.026535034, -0.023529053, -0.026611328, -0.037994385, -0.0637207, 0.060699463, -0.0034675598, -0.032043457, 0.030410767, -0.052368164, -0.027664185, -0.05529785, 0.030303955, 0.041259766, 0.048461914, -0.004737854, -0.0006093979, -0.04046631, 0.00409317, -0.029052734, 0.012748718, -0.03366089, -0.015586853, -0.02180481, 0.030334473, -0.014694214, 0.057769775, 0.041900635, 0.0064353943, -0.03479004, 0.031433105, -0.009613037, -0.056671143, 0.018310547, -0.00605011, -0.011642456, -0.0066108704, -0.014640808, -0.004283905, -0.011932373, 0.020050049, 0.005809784, -0.018218994, 0.0076026917, -0.02217102, 0.015686035, 0.015426636, 0.038970947, -0.032104492, -0.053649902, 0.008895874, -0.0082473755, -0.03640747, -0.032073975, -0.011886597, 0.04107666, 0.018951416, -0.011909485, -0.0143966675, -0.011787415, 0.048919678, 0.017532349, -0.008903503, -0.007698059, 0.028915405, 0.014793396, -0.006072998, 0.055358887, 0.008666992, 0.048675537, 0.02545166, 0.004207611, 0.04888916, -0.020553589, 0.0028934479, -0.008895874, -0.00374794, 0.008560181, -0.0006790161, 0.004108429, 0.007167816, -0.047790527, -0.012084961, -0.023910522, -0.010421753, 0.019607544, -0.016845703, 0.030395508, -0.0446167, -0.0030002594, -0.026229858, -0.0029182434, -0.036499023, -0.015075684, 0.03643799, -0.0005745888, -0.072143555, 0.005695343, 0.012825012, 0.04006958, 0.0010070801, 0.033935547, 0.027267456, -0.00019466877, -0.024856567, -0.031402588, 0.00182724, 0.07739258, -0.017608643, -0.014122009, -0.030044556, -0.018432617, -0.030593872, 0.036193848, 0.076538086, -0.031173706, 0.030075073, -0.050109863, 0.024108887, -0.003955841, -0.013755798, 0.006542206, 0.005706787, 0.010673523, 0.032196045, -0.013183594, -0.010040283, -0.018447876, 0.010177612, 0.0048675537, -0.016220093, -0.036499023, -0.033813477, 0.0015363693, -0.012229919, -0.041625977, 0.009017944, 0.061431885, -0.05795288, -0.0016880035, -0.018707275, -0.03137207, -0.020507812, -0.010848999, -0.009407043, -0.024124146, 0.03414917, 0.033081055, 0.016860962, -0.05142212, -0.009185791, 0.002002716, 0.027908325, -0.0027217865, -0.006275177, -0.014427185, 0.0041923523, 0.011161804, -0.027648926, 0.019241333, -0.035705566, 0.0002863407, -0.04699707, 0.0009498596, -0.00048017502, -0.0012598038, 0.0138549805, 0.00522995, -0.0206604, -0.03161621, 0.023910522, 0.045684814, 0.0020141602, 0.015853882, 0.042236328, 0.031082153, 0.0040130615, 0.051818848, 0.017730713, 0.012779236, -0.107543945, -0.026397705, -0.0413208, -0.012359619, -0.03717041, 0.017837524, 0.055145264, -0.06915283, 0.021759033, -0.022369385, -0.00440979, 0.037719727, 0.022338867, -0.005176544, -0.02281189, -0.035064697, -0.015609741, -0.005645752, 0.028686523, -0.042175293, 0.030776978, 0.11090088, -0.011070251, -0.02835083, -0.009971619, 0.037963867, 0.027816772, -0.023101807, -0.053131104, -0.037078857, 0.011054993, 0.019699097, 0.014541626, -0.030563354, -0.04586792, -0.10369873, -0.01789856, -0.018539429, 0.013572693, -0.0071983337, 0.01789856, -0.0552063, 0.0524292, -0.02897644, -0.02357483, 0.023910522, 0.0124053955, 0.018112183, -0.022979736, 0.04421997, -0.034423828, 0.014564514, -0.029922485, -0.044921875, 0.046295166, -0.05014038, -0.05355835, 0.019104004, -0.039001465, -0.007549286, -0.010971069, -0.011161804, 0.050750732, 0.028839111, 0.024765015, 0.0012702942, -0.0060043335, 0.017105103, -0.024932861, -0.0368042, -0.02142334, -0.014793396, 0.005897522, 0.0011262894, -0.0010299683, 0.00459671, -0.005432129, -0.051452637, 0.0011577606, 0.00522995, 0.026412964, -0.009757996, -0.015403748, 0.007003784, -0.031341553, -0.027877808, -0.04006958, -0.010398865, -0.008522034, -0.042999268, 0.010597229, -0.012763977, 0.122924805, -0.0030822754, -0.005420685, -0.012496948, 0.009033203, 0.0058784485, -0.015602112, -0.03479004, -0.0024585724, 0.024124146, -0.0010890961, 0.031707764, -0.026000977, -0.033477783, 0.019348145, -0.03451538, 0.0018854141, 0.005683899, 0.00022923946, -0.04119873, -0.010406494, 0.033233643, -0.0065345764, 0.025009155, -0.013427734, 0.022705078, -0.022583008, -0.006729126, -0.036071777, 0.010719299, -0.002401352, -0.10131836, -0.014312744, 0.0045204163, 0.0231781, 0.025817871, -0.032226562, 0.021835327, 0.0019521713, -0.05102539, 0.010475159, -0.009666443, 0.0034809113, 0.01713562, -0.0368042, -0.03125, 0.061950684, -0.029266357, -0.025604248, 0.04046631, -0.024337769, 0.0047416687, -0.007255554, 0.03857422, 0.043395996, 0.046417236, 0.020263672, 0.007637024, 0.06304932, -0.025177002, 0.017166138, 0.05657959, 0.066833496, -0.009140015, -0.015777588, -0.0034217834, 0.010307312, -0.02960205, 0.043670654, 0.027038574, -0.007160187, -0.059509277, 0.027740479, -0.0050849915, -0.009056091, 0.015602112, 0.00013816357, 0.04168701, 0.022491455, -0.01713562, 0.021759033, -0.012542725, 0.0041542053, 0.082458496, 0.0234375, -0.0038642883, 0.0053367615, -0.0014410019, 0.028656006, 0.0014657974, 0.038208008, -0.002840042, 0.06591797, -0.0035514832, -0.0077285767, 0.005207062, 0.023971558, -0.020233154, -0.019348145, -0.049743652, -0.054901123, -0.001958847, 0.009185791, -0.013130188, 0.005672455, 0.030944824, 0.0070152283, -0.03237915, -0.0011768341, 0.039276123, 0.008239746, -0.015357971, -0.05529785, -0.0027885437, -0.013877869, -0.08453369, -0.03366089, -0.046142578, -0.0362854, 0.020874023, 0.021881104, -0.038879395, 0.027709961, 0.036346436, 0.11401367, 0.064941406, -0.0035934448, -0.07775879, 0.036834717, -0.030761719, -0.017562866, 0.023712158, -0.013648987, -0.005332947, -0.008888245, 0.029220581, -0.0039901733, -0.017410278, -0.05923462, 0.027008057, -0.022766113, 0.051818848, 0.036987305, 0.0463562, 0.029403687, 0.019592285, 0.022415161, 0.011924744, -0.03488159, 0.0004837513, -0.007007599, 0.04067993, -0.008979797, 0.011100769, 0.035614014, 0.032196045, 0.009864807, -0.024429321, 0.0137786865, 0.00077581406, -0.009605408, -0.0725708, 0.06903076, -0.013191223, -0.008377075, 0.039215088, -0.016693115, 0.040924072, -0.0033550262, 0.046936035, 0.0003271103, 0.0149383545, 0.051452637, -0.010871887, 0.012207031, 0.0010032654, -0.015686035, -0.06390381, -0.060668945, -0.03112793, 0.0574646, -0.02798462, -0.0014972687, 0.0039138794, 0.0028266907, 0.024047852, 0.049194336, 0.015808105, -0.01309967, -0.006767273, 0.002538681, 0.00047969818, -0.033050537, -0.05783081, -0.005607605, -0.012313843, 0.004299164, -0.060394287, 0.04348755, -0.028244019, 0.004016876, -0.00081157684, -0.012191772, 0.0063095093, -0.054779053, 0.02671814, 0.046936035, -0.007671356, 0.016693115, 0.043426514, 0.019729614, 0.006008148, 0.031982422, -0.008178711, 0.04840088, 0.00806427, -0.008399963, 0.03253174, -0.001537323, 0.028030396, 0.007888794, -0.011421204, 0.00006657839, 0.019592285, -0.032287598, 0.041656494, -0.009918213, -0.030136108, -0.005836487, -0.0129852295, 0.037261963, 0.011894226, 0.0019102097, 0.019592285, -0.03878784, -0.016708374, -0.0026931763, -0.024902344, -0.026351929, 0.015655518, -0.025985718, -0.019714355, -0.045959473, 0.040161133, -0.04815674, 0.0031528473, 0.018859863, -0.027114868, -0.018112183, 0.022094727, 0.022537231, -0.004306793, -0.0016059875, -0.0012140274, 0.004940033, 0.019500732, 0.02468872, -0.05709839, -0.011222839, -0.014808655, -0.045715332, -0.023620605, 0.020843506, 0.016601562, 0.014518738, -0.0066947937, -0.03665161, 0.009490967, -0.0036907196, 0.026229858, 0.001209259, -0.0047912598, 0.024414062, -0.00086450577, -0.016311646, 0.0087890625, 0.047943115, -0.021575928, -0.0005469322, 0.016799927, -0.0070724487, 0.037963867, -0.02986145, 0.007041931, 0.037597656, -0.039855957, 0.021911621, 0.024459839, 0.008239746, -0.023239136, 0.022918701, 0.042999268, 0.011421204, -0.011383057, -0.0049858093, 0.053375244, -0.025543213, 0.010604858, -0.013198853, -0.010848999, -0.03781128, 0.053771973, -0.0013418198, -0.00831604, -0.04812622, -0.056549072, -0.018112183, 0.0017337799, 0.014373779, -0.0002465248, 0.0042648315, -0.03488159, -0.012588501, -0.022506714, 0.008857727, -0.020904541, -0.003129959, -0.0015354156, -0.011047363, 0.0060310364, 0.013404846, 0.026138306, -0.0211792, 0.007835388, -0.024368286, -0.009017944, -0.01751709, -0.009811401, 0.028137207, -0.009788513, -0.006175995, 0.025848389, -0.02154541, -0.005970001, 0.027420044, -0.04446411, 0.04171753, 0.037994385, 0.07354736, 0.038604736, -0.0020122528, 0.017669678, 0.019104004, 0.017074585, -0.039398193, 0.042663574, -0.06689453, 0.00080919266, -0.050994873, -0.039978027, -0.08514404, -0.033447266, 0.018249512, 0.02520752, 0.03466797, -0.007545471, 0.037353516, 0.038024902, 0.016418457, -0.015014648, 0.033325195, 0.008895874, 0.014381409, -0.00018894672, -0.024383545, 0.03326416, 0.036010742, -0.0024337769, -0.0035896301, -0.014213562, -0.026794434, 0.001326561, 0.0017127991, 0.042938232, 0.0098724365, -0.056762695, -0.015640259, 0.078186035, 0.012756348, 0.021392822, 0.047424316, 0.054656982, -0.027694702, -0.0013589859, 0.02772522, 0.017440796, -0.030914307, 0.020935059, 0.037261963, -0.05001831, 0.027160645, 0.010398865, -0.028335571, -0.019302368, 0.07208252, 0.019485474, -0.02545166, 0.006717682, 0.03753662, 0.012107849, 0.008071899, 0.034057617, -0.021881104, -0.018356323, 0.0068740845, 0.02998352, 0.007881165, 0.06817627, 0.008201599, 0.009986877, -0.026428223, -0.026245117, 0.0060577393, 0.03616333, -0.029754639, 0.02204895, -0.030014038, 0.06896973, 0.037322998, -0.022033691, 0.030761719, 0.021255493, -0.06616211, 0.00894165, 0.017715454, 0.031188965, 0.04171753, 0.061431885, 0.002861023, -0.016418457, -0.0060539246, -0.046295166, 0.02809143, 0.031341553, -0.02154541, -0.0029201508, -0.02848816, -0.036895752, 0.022155762, -0.030319214, 0.060455322, -0.0152282715, 0.0011339188, -0.019317627, 0.018692017, 0.043884277, -0.053649902, -0.02961731, -0.021209717, -0.017959595, 0.010528564, 0.031951904, -0.020507812, -0.0017175674, 0.011039734, -0.00274086, 0.031433105, 0.005214691, 0.014892578, -0.01663208, -0.061920166, -0.007865906, -0.02079773, 0.013496399, -0.01537323, -0.021987915, -0.03652954, 0.04248047, 0.019241333, -0.007896423, -0.04864502, 0.08300781, 0.007408142, -0.04043579, 0.020980835, 0.023712158, 0.000017285347, 0.027740479, 0.015037537, 0.01424408, 0.0056419373, -0.030410767, 0.024887085, -0.009109497, -0.048187256, -0.02003479, -0.028564453, 0.010757446, 0.029388428, 0.00015747547, 0.011489868, 0.03302002, -0.03781128, -0.011810303, -0.0016593933, 0.020370483, -0.004917145, -0.036895752, 0.024017334, 0.019622803, 0.03540039, -0.042175293, -0.05255127, -0.0013103485, 0.018859863, -0.01134491, 0.048034668, 0.022354126, 0.008293152, 0.0035133362, 0.03744507, 0.0069007874, -0.030517578, -0.014671326, -0.005554199, 0.04748535, 0.03869629, -0.015960693, -0.00497818, 0.020187378, -0.008560181, 0.015899658, -0.010932922, 0.0029945374, 0.006919861, -0.015655518, 0.039916992, -0.015808105, 0.0030403137, -0.040893555, 0.029281616, -0.018051147, -0.006252289, 0.0004119873, 0.022644043, -0.021224976, 0.04699707, -0.017562866, -0.0024433136, 0.017166138, 0.038238525, 0.020828247, 0.018753052, -0.034088135, 0.0008482933, 0.00062942505, 0.008079529, 0.0041160583, 0.013893127, 0.030303955, -0.03805542, 0.004169464, -0.05078125, -0.04043579, 0.017562866, -0.02267456, 0.03479004, -0.051513672, 0.018051147, -0.01789856, -0.044311523, -0.025177002, 0.040863037, -0.00881958, -0.07556152, -0.035369873, -0.029190063, 0.064941406, -0.02230835 ], "summary": [ 0.082092285, 0.0010271072, 0.046844482, -0.01309967, -0.010650635, -0.029403687, 0.04119873, -0.05014038, -0.04107666, 0.014877319, -0.059020996, 0.0345459, -0.013214111, -0.00095272064, 0.05340576, -0.03942871, 0.0140686035, 0.014328003, 0.0002206564, -0.04840088, 0.023834229, -0.051239014, 0.015960693, 0.076416016, 0.026489258, 0.020324707, -0.103149414, 0.03793335, -0.008651733, 0.02607727, 0.012458801, -0.014984131, -0.0048446655, 0.01852417, 0.034423828, 0.013549805, 0.008926392, 0.023529053, 0.039276123, -0.005126953, 0.024459839, -0.0066871643, 0.027816772, -0.06542969, -0.021896362, 0.02798462, -0.018417358, 0.0003733635, -0.00995636, 0.038208008, 0.028152466, 0.013259888, 0.011817932, 0.0574646, -0.006839752, -0.02645874, -0.07006836, -0.01701355, 0.005153656, 0.076416016, 0.04336548, -0.024230957, -0.0064353943, -0.047180176, 0.008056641, -0.0038471222, 0.011680603, 0.012718201, 0.0368042, 0.025268555, 0.017227173, 0.0078048706, 0.0035953522, 0.011360168, -0.044158936, -0.026641846, 0.03250122, -0.01890564, 0.00005811453, 0.006275177, -0.004184723, 0.005493164, 0.0051574707, -0.014404297, -0.0085372925, -0.007858276, -0.026931763, -0.0082092285, -0.024459839, -0.003780365, -0.036956787, -0.0018224716, 0.0053749084, 0.0060691833, -0.007118225, -0.025512695, 0.008346558, -0.022079468, 0.018997192, 0.027145386, 0.007221222, -0.04611206, 0.046844482, -0.025497437, -0.0053367615, 0.022659302, 0.025222778, -0.008369446, -0.00051021576, 0.0064353943, -0.018936157, 0.019622803, 0.029663086, 0.03591919, -0.038024902, -0.020324707, -0.0003182888, 0.009750366, -0.025619507, 0.01826477, -0.025619507, -0.0035476685, -0.020339966, 0.038879395, 0.026855469, 0.025726318, -0.00025892258, 0.023086548, 0.014930725, 0.026138306, -0.032073975, -0.0004644394, -0.013122559, -0.019195557, -0.025497437, -0.014213562, 0.025909424, -0.02293396, 0.0013933182, -0.026519775, 0.046447754, -0.015045166, -0.04421997, 0.028778076, 0.014961243, 0.02015686, 0.029449463, 0.015670776, -0.02218628, -0.034118652, 0.037353516, -0.004142761, 0.023101807, -0.0003466606, -0.02217102, -0.06542969, -0.03274536, -0.021392822, 0.05041504, -0.033691406, 0.02748108, -0.016464233, -0.013587952, 0.0007286072, -0.023330688, 0.0046310425, -0.01914978, 0.002035141, -0.006778717, 0.029220581, -0.0005784035, 0.02998352, -0.111816406, -0.048950195, 0.009559631, -0.040802002, -0.009223938, 0.007850647, -0.01637268, 0.010528564, 0.014671326, -0.033935547, -0.0079193115, 0.026733398, -0.004722595, 0.013557434, -0.013343811, 0.026672363, 0.01133728, 0.02420044, -0.041107178, 0.0064926147, -0.052581787, 0.002954483, -0.02532959, 0.052001953, -0.012954712, 0.043792725, -0.013931274, -0.02041626, 0.026275635, -0.010787964, 0.016815186, -0.023925781, -0.05014038, -0.0019512177, -0.024902344, 0.03149414, -0.00094747543, 0.017059326, 0.014556885, 0.00016129017, -0.020324707, 0.020874023, -0.0062561035, -0.012863159, 0.028182983, -0.06774902, -0.027404785, -0.029418945, -0.0440979, 0.055633545, -0.080322266, 0.03543091, -0.0026474, -0.014175415, -0.009757996, -0.0014257431, 0.041534424, -0.0138549805, 0.08282471, -0.0040740967, -0.059661865, -0.024383545, -0.03237915, -0.01247406, -0.014205933, -0.033599854, 0.039794922, 0.034576416, 0.011253357, 0.019012451, -0.023025513, 0.04019165, 0.0045433044, -0.013496399, -0.021484375, 0.029556274, -0.03842163, -0.00075244904, 0.04269409, 0.00680542, 0.009216309, -0.039886475, 0.011482239, 0.021087646, -0.028533936, -0.026931763, 0.026153564, -0.019104004, 0.016189575, -0.031677246, 0.008308411, 0.0007953644, 0.00032615662, -0.06756592, -0.0016803741, -0.014030457, 0.0064468384, -0.0637207, 0.021408081, 0.011100769, -0.009643555, -0.0619812, -0.034118652, -0.047546387, -0.030975342, 0.05984497, 0.01247406, -0.07513428, -0.004886627, 0.007549286, -0.018554688, -0.011116028, 0.02960205, 0.034851074, -0.009002686, 0.0006737709, 0.043823242, 0.029022217, 0.037475586, 0.0030536652, -0.0017538071, 0.027008057, 0.010803223, -0.038360596, -0.014945984, 0.05432129, -0.022476196, 0.005214691, -0.038208008, 0.025360107, -0.007965088, -0.020309448, -0.010551453, 0.07745361, 0.040649414, -0.020812988, -0.0057144165, -0.0041542053, -0.0047569275, -0.010307312, 0.008972168, 0.068725586, -0.052337646, -0.052520752, 0.0010251999, 0.026168823, -0.020721436, 0.025772095, 0.13330078, -0.013374329, 0.046936035, -0.006450653, -0.016220093, -0.07366943, 0.036315918, -0.027267456, -0.03781128, 0.04348755, -0.0036087036, 0.007472992, -0.026351929, 0.020233154, -0.007484436, 0.031066895, 0.008384705, 0.035949707, 0.0028629303, -0.040130615, 0.006095886, -0.0047798157, -0.032714844, 0.002960205, -0.000062942505, -0.028747559, 0.0040016174, -0.020736694, 0.027877808, 0.029571533, -0.025466919, -0.011764526, -0.020904541, 0.060821533, 0.019515991, -0.03894043, 0.029678345, 0.061065674, -0.03060913, -0.0011730194, 0.039886475, 0.02456665, -0.0010948181, -0.09051514, -0.0027275085, -0.03503418, 0.034332275, -0.057037354, 0.025299072, 0.042419434, -0.09448242, 0.06524658, -0.029190063, -0.0017938614, 0.027755737, 0.06945801, 0.062927246, 0.00073719025, 0.00068998337, 0.044708252, 0.027496338, 0.055145264, -0.038146973, 0.015464783, 0.04421997, -0.0149002075, -0.02494812, 0.0019197464, 0.033843994, 0.015914917, -0.0033226013, -0.015541077, 0.02168274, 0.00073575974, 0.011657715, -0.008232117, -0.020141602, -0.029006958, -0.04586792, -0.010276794, -0.008323669, 0.028701782, 0.026275635, 0.0064888, -0.03289795, 0.046875, -0.035217285, -0.011352539, 0.010345459, -0.043304443, 0.04434204, -0.037109375, 0.01789856, -0.025009155, 0.028671265, -0.049987793, 0.08514404, 0.04046631, -0.04446411, -0.07550049, 0.021972656, 0.026443481, 0.019470215, -0.040649414, 0.024139404, 0.009017944, 0.017807007, -0.00919342, -0.012306213, 0.016021729, 0.008056641, -0.029159546, -0.026351929, -0.0009088516, -0.004798889, 0.060516357, -0.0024089813, -0.026824951, 0.021270752, -0.031021118, -0.03289795, 0.009407043, 0.02192688, 0.03656006, 0.020629883, -0.025375366, 0.0017385483, -0.036193848, 0.00006723404, -0.057861328, -0.030853271, -0.016677856, 0.01727295, 0.03186035, 0.011734009, 0.112854004, -0.03741455, 0.02558899, 0.04574585, -0.013198853, 0.018081665, -0.017944336, -0.006778717, 0.03189087, 0.0067977905, 0.00091171265, -0.002286911, -0.013710022, -0.02281189, 0.0062408447, -0.03137207, 0.025939941, -0.031158447, -0.04043579, -0.01977539, -0.07385254, 0.083618164, 0.000044822693, 0.06958008, -0.0541687, -0.015045166, 0.0068740845, -0.023162842, -0.010406494, 0.0063171387, 0.008094788, -0.042633057, 0.015960693, 0.0146865845, 0.05734253, 0.03543091, -0.0065574646, 0.03164673, 0.0385437, -0.026504517, 0.029922485, -0.013977051, 0.055725098, 0.0146484375, -0.028533936, -0.021987915, -0.012489319, 0.04083252, -0.012901306, -0.048797607, 0.009239197, 0.049041748, 0.019180298, 0.006843567, -0.036956787, 0.04473877, -0.019699097, 0.040863037, 0.03173828, -0.026885986, 0.002828598, -0.0047035217, 0.07867432, -0.060058594, -0.012481689, 0.029571533, 0.068359375, -0.04876709, 0.02281189, 0.032470703, 0.016113281, -0.07171631, 0.036987305, -0.0075149536, 0.020324707, 0.016021729, 0.026657104, -0.010307312, -0.025375366, 0.0134887695, -0.05126953, -0.0211792, -0.030349731, 0.07098389, 0.0647583, 0.01637268, 0.0032787323, -0.03463745, 0.043823242, -0.01626587, 0.022781372, -0.012741089, 0.044525146, 0.021728516, -0.0037441254, 0.013961792, -0.00072193146, -0.01285553, -0.03186035, -0.010604858, 0.017791748, 0.016204834, -0.011253357, -0.007549286, -0.002483368, 0.029067993, -0.007949829, 0.013313293, -0.020874023, 0.047973633, 0.01953125, -0.027114868, -0.07635498, -0.033935547, -0.019622803, -0.032714844, -0.022567749, -0.056549072, -0.05810547, -0.002084732, 0.0058135986, -0.028778076, 0.014022827, 0.020507812, 0.06585693, 0.01083374, 0.0501709, -0.035095215, 0.03717041, -0.047332764, 0.023086548, 0.028427124, 0.0009264946, -0.013053894, 0.01637268, 0.025054932, 0.006061554, -0.009109497, -0.040924072, -0.027664185, -0.019897461, 0.015335083, 0.07354736, 0.083984375, 0.011291504, 0.051483154, 0.0021343231, 0.01449585, -0.012306213, -0.026824951, -0.04168701, 0.028747559, 0.027786255, 0.014305115, 0.027160645, 0.00497818, -0.025024414, 0.012962341, 0.013221741, 0.030929565, -0.01928711, -0.048034668, 0.04144287, 0.08282471, 0.016937256, 0.06677246, 0.0018863678, 0.0121536255, 0.038330078, 0.013435364, 0.028564453, 0.0015964508, 0.035705566, -0.014663696, -0.0206604, -0.007926941, -0.027832031, -0.05392456, -0.06512451, -0.04586792, 0.053009033, -0.005493164, -0.04864502, 0.018997192, 0.010887146, 0.016159058, 0.011375427, 0.03591919, -0.05569458, -0.0037193298, -0.0073127747, -0.010032654, 0.000058472157, -0.028503418, -0.05697632, -0.016738892, -0.0015745163, -0.021621704, 0.00945282, 0.036590576, -0.026443481, -0.0075035095, -0.0038375854, 0.012779236, -0.024551392, -0.012084961, 0.04699707, -0.029006958, 0.0068130493, 0.04522705, -0.0018320084, 0.0073394775, 0.004398346, -0.0030670166, 0.0116119385, -0.025466919, 0.00093507767, 0.04119873, 0.012359619, 0.0010328293, 0.029953003, -0.006549835, 0.00983429, 0.007896423, -0.0030899048, 0.01360321, -0.04208374, -0.021636963, -0.037231445, 0.018951416, 0.017044067, 0.026107788, 0.04135132, 0.027832031, -0.017837524, -0.010169983, 0.00024938583, 0.008735657, -0.027893066, 0.020523071, 0.018814087, 0.033355713, -0.05380249, 0.01940918, -0.08013916, -0.006061554, 0.012893677, 0.018981934, 0.020507812, 0.0029697418, -0.01524353, 0.05319214, -0.03829956, 0.05557251, 0.029022217, -0.013389587, -0.007106781, -0.075683594, 0.00055933, -0.033569336, -0.020065308, -0.07739258, -0.028701782, -0.011459351, 0.05407715, -0.008155823, -0.01222229, 0.023590088, -0.029144287, 0.030212402, -0.024093628, -0.031280518, -0.021713257, -0.0007829666, -0.009132385, 0.0074424744, 0.01386261, -0.011940002, 0.0022335052, 0.0082092285, 0.00019454956, 0.029052734, 0.02268982, 0.06237793, -0.052856445, -0.044525146, -0.01158905, 0.050750732, 0.024383545, -0.027908325, 0.007850647, 0.028442383, -0.050964355, -0.020324707, -0.019134521, 0.009346008, -0.007003784, 0.025314331, -0.032196045, 0.015686035, -0.030838013, 0.007133484, -0.02558899, -0.009109497, -0.02331543, -0.014450073, 0.0070877075, -0.017715454, 0.018966675, -0.03515625, 0.03640747, -0.021194458, -0.053649902, -0.04623413, 0.0036697388, 0.034973145, -0.028213501, -0.0076141357, -0.024765015, 0.00844574, 0.013191223, 0.016967773, 0.010627747, 0.015548706, -0.016174316, -0.021606445, 0.019378662, 0.0008430481, 0.026977539, 0.017440796, 0.017349243, 0.006084442, -0.0491333, 0.047943115, -0.04043579, -0.004180908, 0.019638062, -0.0058898926, -0.024429321, 0.018997192, 0.0048103333, -0.05038452, -0.024337769, -0.058776855, -0.05014038, -0.0057792664, -0.029190063, -0.059753418, -0.028640747, -0.047698975, -0.012687683, -0.033325195, -0.00088119507, -0.024429321, 0.07525635, -0.002243042, 0.03152466, 0.028640747, -0.045837402, -0.014755249, -0.02494812, 0.032287598, -0.007621765, -0.019134521, -0.0039520264, 0.022354126, 0.034851074, 0.035217285, -0.012428284, -0.006336212, -0.01676941, 0.009933472, -0.008804321, 0.0060272217, -0.013587952, 0.01713562, -0.01889038, 0.038330078, -0.0075912476, -0.0055885315, 0.04763794, 0.048065186, 0.0016746521, -0.012367249, 0.040924072, 0.061798096, 0.012275696, 0.03378296, 0.044036865, 0.017745972, 0.010528564, 0.011100769, -0.03152466, -0.03503418, 0.039123535, 0.022277832, 0.012138367, 0.050445557, 0.0066986084, 0.0033397675, -0.02859497, 0.016998291, -0.037506104, -0.0345459, -0.0073928833, 0.005870819, -0.034576416, 0.0063285828, 0.036895752, 0.0046195984, 0.010643005, 0.013725281, -0.012771606, 0.030914307, 0.004196167, 0.04626465, -0.040039062, 0.010925293, 0.021438599, -0.013168335, 0.03729248, 0.011634827, 0.009063721, 0.029556274, 0.018829346, 0.010002136, 0.029830933, 0.030471802, -0.048828125, 0.020233154, 0.012458801, -0.00096797943, 0.032592773, -0.033996582, -0.031204224, -0.036590576, 0.022720337, 0.035949707, -0.0042037964, 0.017150879, -0.031951904, -0.0132751465, -0.0053749084, -0.034118652, 0.017852783, -0.030288696, -0.017974854, -0.013763428, -0.033966064, -0.013381958, 0.016342163, 0.0035381317, -0.019714355, 0.037017822, 0.009544373, -0.028274536, 0.06384277, -0.009246826, 0.023040771, -0.00044941902, -0.041931152, -0.02406311, -0.022399902, 0.014511108, 0.0070495605, -0.02986145, 0.0009889603, 0.013290405, 0.02684021, -0.0009384155, -0.057403564, 0.101135254, 0.022354126, 0.016967773, -0.000056684017, 0.036254883, 0.0082092285, 0.02746582, 0.015716553, 0.03503418, -0.012680054, 0.028869629, 0.025665283, 0.014732361, -0.06628418, -0.009605408, -0.028045654, -0.0020446777, -0.027145386, -0.006450653, 0.017349243, 0.014640808, -0.029708862, 0.008934021, 0.014350891, 0.015731812, -0.0034618378, -0.003396988, -0.021133423, 0.03945923, 0.03994751, -0.023773193, -0.00466156, 0.027862549, -0.0054244995, -0.005821228, 0.03289795, 0.013633728, 0.027435303, -0.0044784546, 0.079956055, 0.0045394897, -0.019958496, 0.021575928, 0.056427002, 0.07098389, 0.00077581406, -0.038970947, 0.02558899, -0.014862061, -0.05404663, 0.0011129379, -0.047912598, 0.034088135, -0.00957489, -0.014953613, 0.011444092, -0.042022705, 0.021835327, -0.01398468, -0.0068130493, -0.009140015, -0.007858276, 0.0017347336, -0.0023078918, -0.01802063, 0.05343628, 0.0055389404, 0.0637207, -0.05105591, -0.026397705, 0.04244995, -0.012008667, -0.0022830963, -0.00793457, 0.0029621124, 0.010467529, -0.0020999908, 0.027175903, 0.03161621, -0.039520264, -0.009399414, -0.058013916, 0.0069274902, 0.028656006, 0.004009247, 0.03387451, -0.012458801, -0.01626587, 0.016983032, -0.041046143, 0.011459351, 0.009727478, -0.013801575, 0.01033783, -0.00868988, -0.025665283, -0.012069702, -0.009254456 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2007.12312v1
COVID-19 Remote Patient Monitoring: Social Impact of AI
Ashlesha Nesarikar, Waqas Haque, Suchith Vuppala, Abhijit Nesarikar
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
A primary indicator of success in the fight against COVID-19 is avoiding stress on critical care infrastructure and services (CCIS). However, CCIS will likely remain stressed until sustained herd immunity is built. There are also secondary considerations for success: mitigating economic damage; curbing the spread of misinformation, improving morale, and preserving a sense of control; building global trust for diplomacy, trade and travel; and restoring reliability and normalcy to day-to-day life, among others. We envision technology plays a pivotal role. Here, we focus on the effective use of readily available technology to improve the primary and secondary success criteria for the fight against SARS-CoV-2. In a multifaceted technology approach, we start with effective technology use for remote patient monitoring (RPM) of COVID-19 with the following objectives: 1. Deploy readily available technology for continuous real-time remote monitoring of patient vitals with the help of biosensors on a large scale. 2. Effective and safe remote large-scale communitywide care of low-severity cases as a buffer against surges in COVID-19 hospitalizations to reduce strain on critical care services and emergency hospitals. 3. Improve the patient, their family, and their community's sense of control and morale. 4. Propose a clear technology and medical definition of remote patient monitoring for COVID-19 to address an urgent technology need; address obfuscated, narrow, and erroneous information and provide examples; and urge publishers to be clear and complete in their disclosures. 5. Leverage the cloud-based distributed cognitive RPM platform for community leaders and decision makers to enable planning and resource management, pandemic research, damage prevention and containment, and receiving feedback on strategies and executions.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.12312v1
"2020-07-24T01:09:56"
"2020-07-24T01:09:56"
{ "title": [ -0.0071411133, 0.01586914, -0.018829346, -0.05596924, -0.0013103485, -0.0028133392, -0.015312195, -0.00422287, -0.040924072, 0.035491943, -0.017288208, -0.006175995, 0.019866943, -0.033203125, 0.015007019, -0.030349731, 0.018539429, 0.0010795593, 0.037506104, -0.014823914, 0.0054092407, -0.002817154, 0.03591919, -0.018051147, 0.030548096, 0.00071144104, -0.056365967, -0.0035209656, -0.038726807, -0.050445557, -0.002670288, 0.052520752, 0.023498535, 0.029815674, -0.041229248, 0.012237549, -0.027542114, 0.027175903, -0.019332886, 0.012588501, -0.003534317, 0.0018138885, 0.041900635, -0.027801514, 0.010238647, 0.010307312, -0.045196533, -0.027236938, 0.02192688, 0.011940002, 0.007724762, 0.026046753, 0.009674072, 0.014785767, -0.005886078, -0.0013713837, -0.021118164, -0.010192871, 0.012138367, -0.01966858, -0.024932861, -0.00033450127, 0.052368164, 0.023361206, -0.021392822, -0.039489746, -0.05984497, 0.034698486, 0.02532959, -0.02230835, 0.010879517, 0.0067863464, -0.0010519028, 0.020477295, -0.053375244, -0.06439209, 0.047088623, -0.011482239, 0.017700195, -0.002948761, 0.00223732, -0.018844604, 0.03717041, -0.04171753, -0.0022563934, -0.0413208, -0.0062179565, 0.003545761, 0.0016508102, 0.0031337738, 0.01084137, 0.005115509, -0.066101074, 0.089660645, 0.028045654, -0.031097412, 0.012390137, 0.042938232, 0.036621094, -0.0003466606, -0.05593872, 0.009796143, -0.0769043, -0.004055023, 0.01260376, 0.013542175, 0.04660034, 0.008323669, -0.009048462, -0.0030117035, -0.037872314, 0.04324341, 0.027435303, 0.0018825531, -0.020523071, -0.028900146, -0.0022964478, 0.0131073, -0.00045609474, -0.0048599243, 0.01159668, -0.003047943, 0.013519287, 0.0345459, 0.015274048, 0.009979248, -0.02746582, -0.015182495, -0.015853882, 0.05130005, -0.030670166, 0.033294678, -0.080200195, -0.06817627, -0.062347412, -0.00440979, -0.012817383, -0.0030269623, 0.0033855438, -0.0026874542, 0.039276123, -0.027313232, 0.023834229, 0.06225586, -0.058624268, -0.033294678, 0.017791748, 0.044525146, -0.0042419434, -0.027328491, -0.030273438, -0.0010919571, -0.0022468567, 0.02243042, -0.021514893, 0.028274536, -0.061431885, 0.024337769, 0.011833191, 0.017974854, 0.08190918, 0.020431519, -0.02810669, 0.060791016, 0.04257202, -0.03262329, -0.041046143, 0.01235199, 0.0048332214, 0.015853882, 0.0007176399, 0.006385803, 0.023345947, -0.011260986, 0.00037908554, 0.0010929108, -0.021499634, 0.025314331, 0.015464783, -0.043823242, -0.026535034, -0.04083252, -0.03527832, 0.046569824, -0.03250122, -0.018234253, -0.0024757385, 0.030899048, 0.046051025, 0.006362915, -0.024246216, -0.0149383545, -0.024780273, -0.024856567, -0.04055786, 0.028839111, 0.009979248, 0.052093506, -0.0075645447, -0.0127334595, -0.030166626, 0.03427124, -0.05154419, 0.032684326, -0.025726318, -0.020462036, 0.0011138916, 0.024795532, -0.015113831, 0.044891357, 0.018554688, -0.0010213852, 0.006511688, -0.07775879, -0.014785767, -0.01159668, -0.05230713, 0.0031337738, -0.039916992, -0.0077667236, -0.049713135, -0.013702393, -0.015602112, 0.007698059, 0.018081665, 0.015533447, 0.014785767, -0.006462097, 0.09686279, -0.00017213821, 0.1352539, -0.014724731, 0.0058403015, -0.018661499, -0.057678223, 0.0025405884, 0.021347046, -0.009971619, 0.024108887, 0.025177002, 0.02357483, -0.050323486, -0.005718231, 0.027191162, 0.03274536, -0.010353088, 0.024429321, -0.0035591125, 0.0027713776, -0.025222778, 0.051940918, -0.039001465, 0.056640625, 0.027908325, 0.016723633, 0.02470398, -0.042266846, -0.014678955, -0.050598145, 0.040496826, -0.005832672, 0.0013160706, 0.03955078, -0.0184021, -0.054382324, -0.006084442, -0.04425049, -0.0043792725, -0.036956787, -0.005592346, 0.053710938, 0.015930176, 0.012161255, 0.015159607, -0.014663696, 0.00037622452, -0.0072021484, 0.0024490356, 0.008071899, -0.0050468445, 0.00017666817, 0.010795593, 0.021133423, 0.0018100739, 0.011314392, 0.0046691895, 0.03427124, 0.025161743, -0.08843994, -0.0071029663, 0.016555786, 0.039764404, -0.021621704, -0.026229858, 0.03881836, 0.015052795, 0.010124207, 0.059326172, -0.009223938, -0.008026123, -0.111206055, 0.0051193237, -0.011177063, -0.0014724731, 0.012397766, 0.009407043, -0.007320404, 0.0027446747, 0.0057258606, -0.01285553, -0.017623901, 0.041656494, -0.020126343, -0.012794495, -0.027923584, -0.036743164, -0.022079468, -0.028045654, -0.061187744, -0.022537231, 0.04522705, 0.0053367615, -0.0045700073, -0.048858643, -0.00856781, -0.024368286, -0.045043945, -0.011367798, -0.021820068, -0.0011348724, 0.033111572, -0.0101623535, -0.03829956, 0.03302002, 0.025497437, 0.04348755, 0.011169434, 0.05911255, -0.011291504, -0.099487305, -0.03591919, -0.012931824, -0.019607544, -0.015022278, -0.0056381226, -0.004257202, 0.017364502, 0.01763916, -0.020462036, -0.0042648315, 0.008964539, -0.02722168, -0.016052246, -0.035217285, 0.018341064, -0.048858643, -0.00349617, -0.020370483, 0.0072631836, -0.04269409, 0.04925537, 0.0060043335, 0.023468018, -0.009223938, -0.027526855, -0.04827881, -0.022399902, 0.013961792, 0.0056762695, -0.0025463104, -0.051818848, -0.017471313, 0.018615723, -0.008598328, 0.003868103, 0.003643036, -0.060150146, -0.0513916, 0.0022201538, -0.046539307, 0.0056610107, -0.017669678, 0.054595947, -0.01374054, 0.0592041, 0.011047363, 0.013320923, 0.011665344, 0.03656006, -0.003030777, -0.019241333, -0.026992798, -0.021759033, -0.004131317, 0.053375244, 0.000477314, -0.01576233, 0.043701172, -0.09625244, 0.010154724, 0.042999268, -0.0115356445, -0.026245117, 0.007610321, -0.058624268, 0.024520874, -0.008979797, -0.008575439, 0.021209717, 0.017227173, -0.027954102, 0.027374268, 0.014228821, -0.011642456, -0.0075950623, -0.012626648, -0.06109619, 0.005935669, -0.014755249, 0.0055236816, 0.023788452, -0.02330017, -0.016494751, 0.0026493073, -0.019714355, 0.027175903, 0.012969971, -0.0019836426, 0.017044067, -0.0027484894, 0.006881714, -0.02998352, -0.0048065186, -0.031799316, -0.04333496, -0.0056533813, -0.027572632, 0.026107788, -0.014213562, 0.009628296, -0.05419922, 0.009506226, 0.015235901, 0.012496948, 0.04626465, -0.041107178, -0.025894165, -0.057891846, -0.058929443, 0.0026798248, -0.033843994, 0.03253174, -0.05908203, 0.025436401, -0.019989014, 0.020629883, 0.018554688, 0.05557251, 0.016159058, -0.0048980713, 0.0014066696, -0.022994995, -0.00021672249, 0.018615723, -0.020751953, -0.001953125, 0.06689453, 0.010620117, -0.0287323, 0.019485474, -0.003616333, -0.0076904297, 0.0051193237, -0.014381409, -0.031829834, -0.0368042, 0.007637024, -0.008880615, 0.0435791, -0.0020885468, -0.0017910004, 0.016571045, 0.004722595, -0.03866577, -0.025848389, 0.0064735413, -0.084106445, -0.059509277, -0.015327454, -0.095581055, -0.07989502, -0.04220581, -0.0053482056, -0.08709717, -0.041931152, -0.010276794, -0.0049819946, 0.03164673, 0.0007405281, -0.031021118, -0.053344727, 0.020477295, -0.033050537, 0.00026345253, 0.01713562, -0.009902954, 0.01751709, 0.019088745, 0.044555664, 0.02746582, 0.042907715, 0.008842468, 0.013595581, 0.026855469, -0.034820557, 0.016616821, 0.027511597, 0.011787415, -0.007736206, 0.01626587, 0.040649414, 0.06451416, -0.0625, 0.016708374, 0.121520996, -0.018600464, -0.068603516, 0.035125732, -0.01109314, -0.06854248, 0.0038223267, 0.0038852692, 0.014976501, 0.055725098, 0.00025081635, 0.05621338, -0.0023670197, 0.0032348633, -0.019973755, -0.022918701, -0.048675537, -0.03778076, 0.022506714, 0.0026416779, -0.0047035217, -0.0055236816, -0.0019836426, 0.05038452, -0.00035500526, 0.0051651, -0.002735138, -0.010986328, 0.00819397, -0.034423828, -0.037963867, -0.011375427, -0.023590088, -0.0046691895, 0.027679443, 0.0046539307, 0.03805542, -0.0010728836, -0.013839722, -0.011878967, 0.01687622, -0.003206253, 0.0006599426, -0.06311035, -0.0068588257, -0.007774353, -0.0925293, -0.06958008, -0.016601562, 0.035003662, -0.009674072, 0.0007481575, 0.0038146973, 0.032836914, 0.024459839, 0.014533997, 0.010063171, -0.028625488, -0.020095825, 0.018707275, -0.0064582825, 0.0044784546, -0.025482178, 0.046813965, -0.018920898, -0.033325195, -0.0057678223, -0.01260376, -0.015731812, -0.038757324, 0.014083862, 0.016342163, -0.006175995, -0.015930176, -0.011154175, 0.0058135986, 0.045410156, 0.01360321, 0.0014095306, -0.02293396, -0.034088135, -0.0008530617, 0.06616211, 0.007850647, 0.010040283, 0.032409668, -0.004108429, -0.028015137, -0.005962372, 0.03503418, 0.0030136108, 0.006839752, -0.0076560974, 0.036254883, 0.0069770813, -0.013130188, 0.0096588135, 0.031829834, 0.02986145, -0.0049324036, 0.0635376, -0.050567627, 0.005657196, 0.004501343, 0.0031318665, -0.007411957, -0.020324707, 0.013435364, -0.01966858, -0.011741638, 0.014091492, -0.009185791, -0.008743286, -0.0025844574, -0.012168884, 0.015960693, 0.008071899, 0.0026741028, -0.06384277, 0.021133423, 0.03112793, 0.006855011, -0.0018815994, -0.029510498, -0.0044937134, -0.01121521, -0.006324768, 0.008277893, -0.013511658, -0.02267456, 0.0015497208, -0.029953003, -0.008361816, 0.00096035004, 0.054473877, -0.027175903, -0.0231781, 0.066833496, -0.03086853, 0.017822266, 0.0029335022, -0.016448975, 0.014305115, 0.03250122, -0.026809692, 0.0028305054, 0.027954102, -0.06262207, -0.012420654, 0.000385046, 0.010826111, 0.042999268, 0.03189087, 0.015701294, 0.0034389496, -0.021896362, 0.0041618347, 0.0015926361, -0.015365601, 0.06347656, -0.05239868, 0.038726807, -0.0020828247, -0.018234253, -0.027954102, -0.056152344, -0.070739746, 0.012992859, -0.043640137, 0.0015192032, 0.012367249, -0.017227173, -0.01638794, -0.0090789795, 0.04711914, -0.01209259, -0.006500244, 0.008026123, 0.030258179, 0.011947632, 0.0035572052, 0.0041618347, -0.10247803, 0.0013027191, 0.002773285, 0.03010559, 0.017791748, -0.016433716, -0.038238525, 0.00017273426, 0.016357422, -0.07397461, -0.055664062, -0.0021324158, -0.02079773, -0.016403198, -0.040496826, -0.04486084, -0.05307007, -0.027236938, -0.0206604, 0.019973755, -0.055023193, 0.013679504, -0.014656067, 0.018005371, -0.0012788773, 0.030517578, 0.010055542, -0.010513306, 0.02166748, -0.036010742, 0.016784668, 0.0010404587, -0.0102005005, 0.018814087, -0.029067993, -0.004257202, 0.026641846, 0.017456055, -0.011436462, 0.008552551, 0.024307251, -0.028213501, -0.00015771389, 0.017028809, 0.07873535, -0.06652832, -0.02798462, -0.04647827, 0.008102417, -0.059631348, -0.021911621, 0.021942139, -0.016693115, -0.000854969, -0.011520386, -0.031341553, -0.012374878, 0.029571533, -0.037200928, 0.029037476, -0.03161621, -0.047576904, -0.017471313, 0.02444458, -0.0037651062, 0.012138367, -0.013153076, 0.03149414, -0.012329102, 0.037506104, 0.017288208, -0.017745972, 0.041931152, 0.0024356842, 0.011199951, -0.04196167, 0.0039978027, -0.001162529, -0.0395813, -0.03152466, 0.044281006, 0.038848877, -0.04232788, 0.029968262, 0.011627197, 0.063964844, 0.010070801, 0.029815674, 0.060577393, 0.054870605, 0.00844574, -0.0017528534, 0.0004248619, -0.010154724, 0.033813477, -0.04272461, 0.0032997131, -0.0140686035, -0.015586853, -0.10046387, -0.004386902, 0.032440186, 0.011505127, 0.0041656494, 0.0121536255, 0.009857178, -0.017745972, -0.0030441284, -0.014892578, 0.03768921, 0.004257202, 0.0052490234, -0.023742676, 0.031051636, -0.017364502, -0.0026073456, 0.0034332275, 0.06781006, 0.036224365, 0.031158447, -0.005153656, -0.023925781, 0.0014619827, -0.053619385, 0.029830933, -0.011207581, -0.007293701, 0.0005760193, -0.022705078, 0.03640747, 0.035308838, -0.013870239, -0.018981934, 0.022781372, 0.024765015, -0.028625488, 0.0096588135, 0.050231934, -0.046173096, 0.036987305, -0.004524231, -0.043518066, 0.0026569366, 0.03817749, 0.019699097, -0.01399231, 0.017562866, 0.008598328, -0.0024147034, 0.013259888, 0.0056533813, -0.041809082, -0.03765869, 0.034118652, 0.02420044, -0.038726807, -0.036956787, -0.017333984, 0.06335449, -0.017944336, 0.01966858, -0.044403076, 0.0014123917, -0.05456543, 0.016098022, -0.010055542, 0.05432129, -0.084228516, -0.059417725, 0.014274597, -0.026367188, -0.033294678, -0.041900635, 0.056854248, 0.015266418, -0.027877808, 0.039916992, 0.019180298, -0.011978149, -0.059814453, -0.00078964233, 0.01134491, 0.05355835, -0.025039673, 0.013435364, -0.0069007874, -0.0234375, 0.034210205, 0.020843506, 0.038238525, 0.0053253174, 0.032806396, -0.006275177, -0.0027770996, 0.011787415, -0.018188477, -0.046813965, 0.023040771, -0.01550293, 0.0045051575, 0.016845703, -0.011108398, -0.02822876, -0.004463196, 0.032287598, -0.019332886, 0.021957397, 0.075683594, -0.056396484, -0.052856445, 0.030136108, 0.014923096, 0.06335449, 0.018203735, -0.01953125, 0.0017604828, 0.001534462, -0.0023555756, 0.0031585693, -0.026412964, 0.051330566, -0.029968262, 0.00012946129, -0.0072402954, -0.009887695, -0.029510498, -0.07757568, -0.0050239563, -0.01020813, -0.034576416, 0.003326416, 0.014907837, 0.0020523071, -0.07373047, -0.0036468506, -0.025024414, 0.0064430237, 0.01689148, -0.01675415, -0.026779175, 0.04324341, -0.03857422, -0.032043457, -0.024230957, 0.018356323, -0.032318115, -0.021469116, -0.023864746, 0.0030536652, 0.020065308, -0.052856445, -0.088256836, -0.010917664, 0.09503174, -0.02067566, 0.0034446716, 0.00036215782, 0.048614502, 0.021209717, 0.024337769, -0.0184021, -0.048461914, -0.04031372, -0.029907227, 0.05053711, 0.0033779144, -0.03010559, -0.008590698, 0.0035629272, -0.015014648, 0.022201538, 0.024093628, 0.00018548965, 0.028076172, 0.0000770092, 0.06842041, -0.019500732, -0.006416321, -0.0065727234, 0.014953613, 0.0036067963, 0.015640259, -0.0017223358, 0.0074920654, -0.00093889236, 0.062805176, -0.00003516674, -0.06976318, 0.04058838, 0.046081543, 0.0021915436, 0.038513184, 0.017425537, -0.04675293, -0.010543823, -0.011474609, 0.010673523, -0.007583618, 0.02722168, -0.04812622, 0.0044174194, -0.037353516, -0.040161133, 0.0017786026, -0.0077552795, -0.007270813, -0.05065918, 0.02861023, 0.006919861, -0.013664246, 0.017150879, 0.012329102, 0.02494812, 0.0066337585, -0.04663086, -0.0129470825, 0.006111145, -0.019607544 ], "summary": [ 0.024368286, 0.0013542175, -0.008491516, -0.04510498, -0.0017757416, -0.0021266937, -0.014503479, -0.0046844482, -0.06518555, 0.045684814, 0.010894775, 0.04840088, -0.0039596558, -0.018859863, 0.03225708, -0.016342163, 0.036468506, -0.004184723, 0.040008545, -0.024139404, 0.035095215, -0.0006289482, 0.028656006, 0.0635376, -0.0006766319, -0.019699097, -0.058776855, 0.033721924, -0.06347656, -0.01966858, -0.0045051575, 0.066223145, 0.06414795, -0.0040016174, -0.044555664, -0.03692627, -0.037109375, -0.014724731, -0.068725586, 0.040252686, 0.008880615, -0.0052108765, 0.1315918, -0.04727173, 0.04296875, 0.060913086, -0.034118652, -0.060058594, 0.039855957, 0.012641907, -0.03778076, 0.036712646, -0.03643799, -0.0135269165, 0.0022602081, 0.007637024, -0.0038223267, -0.01776123, 0.038238525, -0.018081665, -0.021881104, -0.02609253, 0.034240723, 0.015151978, -0.040283203, -0.017486572, 0.041381836, -0.010574341, 0.022079468, -0.043426514, 0.018203735, 0.04171753, 0.019332886, -0.037353516, -0.015449524, -0.0151901245, -0.014831543, -0.034454346, 0.022064209, -0.0013790131, -0.002784729, -0.0043640137, 0.051879883, -0.03024292, -0.010856628, -0.030899048, -0.025146484, 0.0052337646, -0.009567261, -0.00033330917, -0.02078247, 0.05307007, -0.054840088, 0.019714355, 0.005962372, -0.008323669, 0.006385803, -0.0019779205, 0.045196533, 0.004009247, -0.022521973, -0.020202637, -0.07720947, -0.0017690659, 0.0039520264, 0.06298828, 0.008003235, -0.003129959, -0.0061035156, -0.014305115, 0.005332947, -0.055419922, 0.003955841, -0.049468994, -0.023422241, 0.05960083, 0.033569336, -0.011054993, 0.017990112, 0.007633209, -0.022994995, -0.003419876, -0.007698059, 0.040100098, 0.011978149, 0.032348633, 0.0057373047, 0.0010671616, -0.019836426, 0.05380249, 0.01776123, -0.0018625259, -0.07342529, -0.024963379, -0.07104492, -0.018066406, 0.013725281, 0.017852783, 0.007858276, -0.018722534, 0.07110596, -0.0095825195, -0.016723633, 0.06628418, -0.0423584, -0.004257202, 0.0058784485, 0.01838684, -0.006134033, -0.0033073425, -0.011108398, -0.031677246, 0.008674622, 0.008834839, -0.050231934, -0.013870239, -0.06109619, 0.011199951, 0.01335907, 0.015548706, 0.06112671, -0.002035141, -0.010215759, 0.043151855, 0.0034866333, -0.011703491, -0.032836914, 0.0003402233, -0.0038471222, 0.00081157684, -0.004310608, 0.035888672, -0.005466461, 0.026992798, 0.022338867, 0.01096344, 0.00028562546, -0.0047912598, -0.00015127659, 0.005241394, -0.012519836, -0.024276733, -0.005722046, 0.024459839, -0.015220642, -0.010246277, 0.011634827, 0.08294678, 0.019241333, 0.035369873, -0.057250977, -0.024291992, -0.0041503906, -0.027877808, -0.02619934, -0.00592041, 0.014755249, 0.026672363, -0.0146102905, 0.03225708, 0.037506104, 0.035614014, -0.0317688, -0.01373291, -0.06768799, -0.013427734, -0.00011795759, 0.025772095, -0.006072998, -0.0030784607, -0.0021152496, -0.021453857, 0.003929138, -0.035705566, -0.01158905, 0.05911255, -0.020904541, -0.015014648, -0.03062439, -0.011001587, -0.058135986, 0.0016336441, -0.070495605, 0.021057129, -0.015098572, -0.005870819, -0.0076446533, -0.008331299, 0.061523438, -0.014587402, 0.109436035, -0.016967773, 0.0015068054, 0.08288574, 0.02658081, 0.0007224083, 0.01361084, -0.007621765, 0.031585693, -0.015670776, 0.020828247, 0.008026123, -0.02798462, -0.006340027, -0.02482605, -0.045532227, 0.0063285828, -0.014457703, 0.0058555603, 0.008232117, -0.011520386, -0.023834229, 0.027374268, -0.017181396, 0.025054932, 0.012649536, -0.040527344, -0.009269714, -0.026184082, 0.016921997, 0.012954712, -0.0042266846, 0.02218628, -0.01374054, -0.01637268, -0.03201294, 0.0018796921, -0.003501892, -0.018005371, -0.031585693, 0.030517578, 0.018173218, -0.0046043396, 0.008506775, 0.0060768127, -0.0027618408, -0.051239014, 0.0031547546, 0.016036987, -0.0024032593, -0.015350342, 0.01525116, 0.028366089, -0.008491516, 0.016098022, 0.021881104, 0.0473938, 0.0068626404, -0.009536743, -0.012420654, 0.0385437, -0.006954193, -0.04345703, 0.005039215, 0.022644043, -0.045166016, -0.06225586, 0.017364502, 0.024383545, -0.017745972, -0.009353638, 0.037231445, -0.031280518, 0.030776978, -0.015853882, 0.028137207, -0.047332764, 0.025848389, 0.015083313, -0.067871094, 0.0637207, 0.08081055, 0.006580353, 0.023345947, -0.01398468, -0.02861023, -0.00982666, 0.006752014, -0.022109985, 0.009712219, -0.007633209, -0.017715454, 0.03225708, 0.017974854, 0.008903503, -0.030700684, 0.029388428, 0.00030851364, -0.044799805, -0.024642944, 0.008148193, -0.052337646, -0.033203125, 0.019363403, 0.022583008, 0.013931274, 0.02192688, 0.048461914, 0.0010099411, -0.07800293, -0.013694763, 0.0024929047, -0.020889282, -0.00037121773, -0.06021118, 0.026123047, 0.0007338524, 0.0071372986, -0.007904053, -0.028945923, 0.015640259, -0.027435303, -0.009674072, -0.025268555, 0.02357483, -0.012649536, -0.004558563, -0.041229248, 0.030273438, -0.052612305, 0.032562256, -0.014480591, -0.016479492, -0.06036377, -0.007320404, -0.006336212, -0.02545166, -0.02645874, 0.035614014, 0.012832642, -0.05227661, 0.014556885, -0.030944824, 0.018951416, 0.057006836, 0.03640747, 0.0021629333, -0.028121948, 0.0012216568, -0.0021743774, 0.004146576, 0.004219055, 0.022583008, 0.002840042, 0.04815674, 0.025253296, 0.059539795, 0.02281189, 0.055633545, -0.008659363, 0.029449463, 0.00086021423, -0.009468079, -0.02708435, 0.016403198, -0.0054779053, 0.02519226, 0.029388428, -0.017196655, -0.016281128, 0.054779053, 0.01084137, -0.004146576, -0.0077667236, 0.013534546, -0.062805176, 0.056518555, -0.006088257, 0.021957397, 0.04840088, -0.021957397, 0.033599854, -0.049804688, 0.05215454, -0.01727295, -0.0005774498, 0.0016202927, -0.015670776, -0.0033817291, 0.016113281, 0.02746582, -0.02494812, -0.009529114, 0.024536133, -0.03475952, -0.003030777, -0.012336731, 0.029342651, -0.041259766, 0.0143585205, -0.0012302399, -0.015151978, -0.014335632, -0.022918701, -0.01864624, -0.023788452, -0.036468506, -0.06573486, -0.02456665, -0.0073623657, -0.07684326, -0.014289856, 0.037200928, -0.0141067505, 0.0262146, -0.010719299, -0.01399231, -0.03967285, -0.012573242, -0.0036964417, -0.041381836, 0.02168274, -0.034088135, 0.025787354, -0.028549194, 0.020767212, -0.030944824, 0.014717102, 0.028060913, -0.032348633, -0.030563354, -0.02407837, -0.0076522827, -0.0075645447, 0.0025291443, 0.00434494, 0.017440796, 0.0026721954, 0.010795593, -0.009750366, 0.016189575, -0.009605408, -0.025543213, -0.021469116, -0.064819336, -0.065979004, 0.07647705, -0.0019207001, 0.10235596, -0.04260254, -0.026687622, 0.024887085, -0.011314392, -0.036499023, -0.025238037, 0.012931824, -0.07324219, -0.05758667, -0.019256592, -0.054901123, -0.025421143, -0.021575928, 0.008766174, -0.030044556, -0.025497437, -0.020645142, -0.012207031, 0.044830322, 0.0018939972, -0.048675537, 0.02508545, -0.0039711, -0.023254395, 0.028274536, -0.015655518, 0.036621094, 0.021774292, -0.00818634, 0.0065727234, -0.018554688, -0.00036263466, -0.041992188, 0.0317688, -0.019805908, 0.0069885254, -0.0054855347, 0.047332764, 0.05633545, 0.0038852692, -0.034820557, 0.072265625, 0.10107422, -0.074645996, -0.009666443, 0.09765625, -0.016418457, -0.070129395, 0.012489319, -0.004714966, -0.00484848, -0.014320374, -0.033081055, -0.0071907043, 0.017715454, 0.061828613, 0.058013916, -0.022583008, -0.020248413, -0.04647827, 0.0052757263, -0.03302002, 0.0007543564, 0.022079468, 0.05078125, 0.022064209, 0.01763916, 0.022125244, 0.029846191, -0.014305115, -0.0016727448, -0.0181427, 0.00059461594, -0.01939392, -0.030197144, 0.004245758, 0.006816864, -0.012573242, 0.0038433075, -0.009216309, 0.011558533, -0.028167725, -0.028244019, -0.015579224, 0.037384033, 0.01890564, 0.034423828, -0.01184082, -0.043426514, -0.017684937, 0.0063209534, -0.0206604, -0.030532837, -0.05105591, -0.05456543, -0.06072998, -0.016464233, 0.013977051, 0.031829834, 0.015686035, -0.008682251, 0.028198242, -0.0154953, -0.0059776306, 0.008773804, -0.005180359, 0.024429321, -0.027755737, 0.040893555, -0.018096924, -0.020080566, 0.008224487, -0.014205933, -0.006324768, -0.009803772, 0.019973755, 0.022399902, -0.004890442, -0.014755249, 0.023025513, 0.0070495605, 0.034423828, -0.025253296, -0.008506775, -0.00046682358, -0.004386902, -0.017593384, 0.033416748, 0.016494751, -0.015411377, 0.0017261505, -0.007484436, -0.062927246, 0.0049591064, 0.03253174, -0.018676758, 0.04324341, -0.0035934448, 0.037017822, 0.026809692, -0.017959595, 0.031280518, 0.040893555, 0.036895752, 0.034484863, -0.00793457, -0.018493652, -0.015419006, -0.02609253, -0.023162842, 0.011161804, -0.017837524, 0.021530151, -0.05505371, -0.030197144, -0.016189575, 0.051696777, -0.012641907, 0.0011930466, -0.0047454834, -0.05709839, -0.010421753, 0.008110046, -0.035186768, 0.040161133, 0.013519287, -0.007698059, 0.0034217834, -0.02218628, -0.013084412, 0.025466919, 0.023040771, -0.0029850006, -0.04901123, -0.03427124, 0.0236969, -0.055023193, -0.003107071, 0.038513184, 0.027770996, -0.01991272, -0.083984375, -0.0061836243, 0.01651001, -0.053588867, 0.015655518, -0.017669678, -0.04827881, 0.02468872, -0.05657959, 0.042938232, -0.019226074, -0.033325195, -0.09136963, -0.03451538, 0.015167236, 0.018951416, -0.013336182, 0.04876709, -0.026306152, -0.03640747, -0.0040512085, 0.0062561035, 0.04244995, 0.0075950623, -0.023330688, 0.03503418, -0.012161255, -0.027999878, -0.015541077, -0.001627922, -0.0446167, -0.016403198, -0.017074585, -0.02861023, -0.016189575, -0.04360962, -0.013145447, -0.013893127, -0.047332764, -0.002166748, -0.0019779205, -0.001156807, 0.055236816, 0.017288208, -0.03074646, -0.010482788, -0.069885254, 0.017303467, -0.010414124, 0.047912598, 0.0007095337, -0.043426514, 0.026687622, 0.013046265, -0.04550171, -0.01928711, 0.019821167, -0.0023841858, -0.008682251, 0.06756592, -0.06591797, 0.03050232, -0.04421997, -0.054840088, 0.014533997, -0.026245117, -0.10107422, -0.042663574, -0.003446579, -0.022583008, 0.03451538, -0.04626465, -0.08135986, 0.052947998, 0.050598145, 0.043182373, 0.022033691, -0.0056152344, -0.02128601, 0.042144775, -0.010643005, -0.0012207031, -0.0008368492, -0.004005432, -0.022781372, -0.010375977, 0.009109497, -0.016433716, -0.018173218, -0.030471802, 0.02670288, -0.0082473755, -0.0058898926, -0.040008545, 0.015731812, -0.017852783, 0.03869629, -0.038360596, -0.048919678, -0.012420654, 0.026123047, 0.0058631897, 0.009307861, -0.0037822723, -0.036071777, 0.002784729, 0.056640625, 0.0077056885, 0.018310547, 0.010864258, -0.014945984, -0.024719238, 0.025756836, 0.10076904, -0.000385046, 0.028320312, -0.013908386, 0.007610321, 0.013343811, 0.016403198, 0.014442444, -0.0047073364, 0.00207901, 0.00078868866, -0.034362793, 0.00014734268, 0.053009033, 0.043914795, -0.035186768, 0.029418945, 0.0769043, 0.0284729, 0.034057617, 0.008117676, 0.0044670105, 0.0060691833, 0.017456055, 0.014778137, 0.01751709, -0.012023926, 0.036499023, -0.0021972656, -0.018310547, -0.03768921, -0.029281616, -0.022415161, 0.033447266, -0.01399231, -0.02180481, 0.0042419434, 0.0027999878, -0.035858154, -0.0058898926, -0.021316528, -0.011932373, -0.019638062, 0.018173218, 0.006919861, -0.02406311, 0.030929565, -0.014129639, 0.008583069, 0.0070648193, 0.05758667, -0.011360168, 0.06451416, -0.030410767, -0.027191162, -0.02178955, -0.0625, 0.053771973, 0.000685215, 0.08239746, 0.060668945, 0.049041748, 0.008262634, 0.016860962, 0.051086426, -0.051727295, 0.016143799, 0.014503479, -0.06085205, 0.043548584, 0.018463135, -0.055603027, 0.0027389526, 0.023284912, -0.011955261, 0.05029297, -0.0020446777, 0.028900146, -0.05340576, -0.032196045, -0.023529053, 0.017105103, 0.0043182373, -0.009155273, -0.027145386, -0.007797241, 0.032836914, 0.019561768, 0.015182495, -0.00995636, -0.05996704, 0.028167725, -0.016159058, 0.031219482, -0.011390686, 0.0018911362, -0.05130005, 0.0069847107, 0.024353027, -0.018081665, -0.016052246, -0.010299683, 0.019454956, -0.016540527, 0.047729492, -0.0032863617, 0.047607422, -0.016326904, -0.04776001, 0.01171875, -0.028518677, -0.024597168, -0.0154418945, 0.003780365, -0.029418945, 0.042633057, 0.018341064, 0.021850586, -0.04446411, -0.018081665, 0.02468872, -0.0068244934, 0.034606934, -0.03036499, 0.015419006, -0.03781128, 0.045959473, -0.042144775, -0.021224976, -0.04043579, -0.02331543, -0.017410278, 0.0016527176, 0.00894928, 0.008972168, -0.001077652, -0.024856567, 0.03540039, 0.012008667, -0.025115967, 0.016342163, -0.0013628006, -0.030349731, -0.036193848, -0.03225708, 0.011955261, 0.016555786, -0.04458618, -0.006576538, -0.013290405, 0.040527344, 0.017913818, -0.013198853, 0.014404297, -0.046173096, -0.04269409, 0.023712158, 0.019729614, -0.011993408, -0.009811401, 0.04095459, -0.013893127, 0.01108551, -0.04837036, -0.0069351196, -0.009048462, 0.017303467, -0.02418518, 0.01335144, -0.03086853, 0.037261963, 0.005367279, -0.052612305, 0.07598877, -0.029815674, -0.03387451, -0.039245605, -0.009170532, -0.050720215, -0.0715332, 0.02998352, -0.03225708, -0.0024375916, -0.02142334, -0.043273926, 0.021530151, 0.0619812, -0.033050537, -0.009140015, 0.03173828, 0.052520752, 0.032470703, 0.045562744, -0.0069618225, -0.07989502, -0.059509277, -0.040740967, 0.023086548, -0.008399963, -0.0051460266, -0.035949707, 0.018722534, -0.031829834, 0.000538826, -0.023712158, 0.021102905, -0.013084412, -0.0129776, 0.037261963, -0.0011119843, -0.030456543, -0.028961182, 0.037597656, -0.016098022, -0.01878357, 0.0036773682, 0.026123047, 0.006954193, 0.021652222, -0.018218994, -0.0046539307, 0.004383087, 0.012825012, 0.015960693, -0.037506104, 0.014640808, -0.006111145, 0.023910522, 0.007972717, -0.0118637085, 0.014175415, 0.00033187866, -0.011169434, -0.015701294, -0.0395813, -0.03640747, -0.037628174, -0.036712646, -0.0043144226, -0.00084877014, 0.010810852, 0.06121826, -0.013366699, 0.00945282, -0.004169464, -0.003063202, -0.03427124, -0.0006685257, -0.021957397, -0.007461548, 0.0053253174 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2007.15270v2
Fairness-Aware Online Personalization
G Roshan Lal, Sahin Cem Geyik, Krishnaram Kenthapadi
cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
Decision making in crucial applications such as lending, hiring, and college admissions has witnessed increasing use of algorithmic models and techniques as a result of a confluence of factors such as ubiquitous connectivity, ability to collect, aggregate, and process large amounts of fine-grained data using cloud computing, and ease of access to applying sophisticated machine learning models. Quite often, such applications are powered by search and recommendation systems, which in turn make use of personalized ranking algorithms. At the same time, there is increasing awareness about the ethical and legal challenges posed by the use of such data-driven systems. Researchers and practitioners from different disciplines have recently highlighted the potential for such systems to discriminate against certain population groups, due to biases in the datasets utilized for learning their underlying recommendation models. We present a study of fairness in online personalization settings involving the ranking of individuals. Starting from a fair warm-start machine-learned model, we first demonstrate that online personalization can cause the model to learn to act in an unfair manner if the user is biased in his/her responses. For this purpose, we construct a stylized model for generating training data with potentially biased features as well as potentially biased labels and quantify the extent of bias that is learned by the model when the user responds in a biased manner as in many real-world scenarios. We then formulate the problem of learning personalized models under fairness constraints and present a regularization based approach for mitigating biases in machine learning. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach through extensive simulations with different parameter settings. Code: https://github.com/groshanlal/Fairness-Aware-Online-Personalization
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.15270v2
"2020-09-06T10:03:27"
"2020-07-30T07:16:17"
{ "title": [ 0.0085372925, 0.006362915, -0.033966064, -0.064453125, 0.02381897, -0.010505676, -0.0012493134, -0.0022277832, -0.010299683, 0.04309082, -0.0035266876, 0.008529663, 0.02116394, -0.027679443, -0.025344849, 0.0256958, -0.01285553, 0.057373047, -0.013702393, -0.04333496, -0.013725281, -0.039520264, 0.0054016113, 0.043304443, 0.03543091, -0.06536865, -0.06298828, 0.014945984, -0.017852783, -0.034942627, -0.010650635, 0.035064697, 0.047027588, 0.020980835, -0.032196045, 0.040130615, -0.059143066, 0.020050049, -0.019378662, 0.024139404, 0.017868042, -0.0018424988, -0.08117676, -0.0013017654, -0.067871094, -0.006416321, -0.030014038, 0.016799927, -0.030578613, 0.050445557, 0.01828003, 0.010314941, -0.0026054382, 0.046966553, 0.02861023, -0.021209717, -0.025726318, -0.030761719, 0.04373169, 0.023101807, 0.021774292, -0.051239014, 0.04373169, -0.006214142, -0.023452759, -0.022018433, 0.015464783, 0.022262573, 0.046783447, -0.000019967556, -0.0061531067, 0.020187378, 0.018615723, -0.000016212463, -0.05505371, 0.018112183, 0.01625061, 0.008781433, 0.043914795, -0.040802002, -0.019302368, 0.0018043518, -0.01335144, -0.03387451, 0.0107803345, -0.026321411, -0.018814087, -0.0038394928, -0.01940918, -0.02859497, -0.0074501038, 0.0054397583, 0.016601562, 0.04724121, -0.023284912, 0.0031833649, -0.0005750656, 0.068847656, -0.020874023, -0.034851074, -0.026870728, 0.02659607, -0.058807373, -0.022827148, 0.012435913, -0.0017337799, -0.0022945404, 0.021728516, 0.026672363, 0.039642334, -0.029708862, 0.060760498, 0.045715332, 0.074523926, -0.03781128, -0.06689453, -0.01448822, 0.0043640137, -0.030838013, 0.027709961, -0.018035889, -0.039916992, 0.040985107, -0.02658081, 0.023391724, -0.01234436, -0.05810547, -0.0016050339, -0.042114258, 0.039794922, -0.0019330978, 0.04272461, -0.085632324, -0.06573486, -0.052093506, 0.015777588, -0.042755127, -0.011566162, -0.018325806, -0.0115356445, 0.015945435, -0.013168335, 0.020996094, 0.016479492, 0.043762207, 0.008834839, 0.057891846, -0.011520386, -0.01737976, 0.0027770996, -0.023208618, 0.026489258, 0.0060157776, 0.016937256, -0.017288208, 0.01727295, -0.10736084, -0.0074272156, 0.02746582, 0.028076172, 0.023590088, 0.012565613, 0.019989014, 0.025848389, 0.053833008, -0.0037822723, -0.022949219, 0.032440186, 0.0017290115, 0.062927246, -0.011749268, 0.023452759, -0.016799927, -0.004901886, -0.0074386597, -0.019592285, 0.040802002, 0.031799316, 0.022460938, -0.006526947, 0.0082473755, -0.030929565, 0.041778564, 0.011024475, -0.08691406, -0.008331299, 0.011947632, 0.037231445, 0.033477783, 0.011909485, 0.011688232, 0.02230835, -0.03326416, -0.036376953, -0.061798096, -0.0070114136, 0.025054932, 0.052642822, -0.009346008, 0.0236969, -0.01020813, -0.014198303, -0.0135650635, -0.022628784, -0.031982422, -0.037994385, -0.01651001, 0.017578125, -0.024246216, 0.04598999, 0.05505371, 0.0029850006, -0.0519104, 0.051757812, 0.0038375854, -0.05722046, 0.008430481, -0.008811951, -0.001876831, -0.026641846, 0.0026073456, -0.012184143, 0.0026626587, 0.047698975, 0.0050811768, -0.0022735596, 0.009994507, -0.014770508, 0.03781128, 0.025512695, 0.08734131, -0.04095459, 0.025650024, 0.023010254, -0.023208618, -0.034942627, -0.023117065, -0.020629883, 0.02168274, 0.03265381, 0.002073288, -0.026367188, 0.00390625, 0.061187744, 0.04586792, -0.018005371, 0.0024299622, 0.040405273, 0.04373169, 0.028015137, 0.013641357, -0.0047836304, 0.056243896, -0.021377563, 0.010894775, 0.07714844, -0.016281128, 0.044189453, -0.040283203, 0.03503418, -0.01889038, 0.039886475, 0.05505371, -0.0024414062, -0.053649902, -0.0023345947, -0.029220581, 0.0023708344, -0.007896423, 0.0031414032, 0.030136108, -0.0066833496, -0.00070762634, -0.021896362, 0.044891357, -0.016601562, -0.02494812, 0.007621765, 0.028076172, -0.05508423, -0.013954163, -0.0066184998, -0.013595581, -0.0038032532, 0.020721436, -0.009597778, 0.0036029816, 0.0110321045, 0.0015153885, -0.036132812, 0.038208008, 0.043151855, -0.00806427, 0.0345459, 0.012260437, -0.018554688, 0.047454834, 0.06793213, -0.024459839, 0.027770996, -0.07324219, 0.022460938, 0.024002075, -0.021591187, -0.0064315796, 0.01725769, -0.0030117035, 0.017028809, -0.0045433044, 0.008934021, -0.028289795, 0.030838013, 0.008178711, -0.06048584, -0.026046753, -0.030410767, -0.009719849, -0.04269409, -0.04714966, -0.008583069, 0.08227539, -0.012458801, -0.022323608, -0.0064697266, -0.012039185, -0.028823853, -0.007827759, -0.023895264, -0.051116943, 0.02230835, 0.03314209, -0.0052452087, -0.049194336, -0.009277344, 0.0063476562, 0.02494812, -0.0079956055, -0.00541687, -0.020339966, -0.0006723404, -0.010398865, -0.011383057, 0.014862061, -0.062561035, 0.020263672, -0.04876709, -0.004463196, 0.01713562, -0.030838013, 0.0016708374, 0.012794495, -0.02520752, -0.042633057, 0.005264282, 0.057281494, -0.02420044, -0.004081726, 0.04135132, 0.037231445, -0.011070251, 0.026733398, 0.007797241, -0.002828598, -0.027633667, -0.0060768127, -0.048950195, -0.0018539429, -0.012077332, -0.022460938, 0.024307251, -0.04824829, -0.032562256, -0.010719299, 0.0025253296, 0.0007762909, 0.025650024, -0.020111084, -0.03704834, -0.010726929, -0.036376953, 0.0029029846, 0.011550903, -0.01953125, 0.00033855438, 0.020965576, 0.02015686, -0.026306152, -0.005531311, 0.0037384033, -0.0041999817, -0.009056091, 0.03390503, -0.0075531006, 0.012046814, 0.01448822, -0.012069702, 0.020187378, 0.02015686, -0.09851074, -0.0132751465, 0.015579224, 0.0073928833, -0.018157959, 0.014266968, -0.07312012, 0.015457153, -0.024627686, -0.023452759, 0.030456543, 0.008934021, -0.011940002, 0.018707275, 0.0067596436, -0.023101807, 0.0048942566, -0.05783081, -0.099731445, 0.024307251, -0.0057373047, -0.034057617, -0.015991211, -0.02897644, -0.043518066, -0.00015544891, -0.0013065338, 0.0569458, 0.015144348, 0.009437561, 0.023025513, -0.032836914, 0.0009813309, -0.028503418, -0.01423645, -0.012184143, -0.024337769, 0.014144897, -0.0067214966, 0.040527344, 0.03265381, -0.010871887, -0.0647583, -0.01436615, -0.02722168, 0.02671814, -0.013694763, -0.032958984, -0.022994995, -0.05987549, -0.028152466, 0.0011062622, -0.009803772, 0.002538681, -0.019042969, 0.01499939, -0.010643005, 0.0335083, 0.017333984, 0.027694702, -0.013076782, 0.01373291, 0.037872314, -0.03744507, -0.0018453598, 0.0211792, 0.015151978, -0.008781433, 0.015640259, -0.0101623535, -0.012786865, 0.0105896, -0.01737976, 0.01109314, 0.006401062, -0.010917664, 0.006450653, 0.0050468445, -0.018554688, 0.032806396, -0.062805176, -0.023071289, 0.02281189, 0.016235352, -0.02142334, -0.095458984, -0.022354126, 0.0035171509, -0.14978027, -0.059814453, 0.009475708, -0.041656494, -0.050231934, -0.026565552, 0.024719238, -0.03564453, -0.014152527, -0.0007791519, -0.0103302, -0.008384705, 0.010353088, -0.08514404, -0.01612854, 0.075805664, -0.0012159348, 0.00843811, 0.012397766, 0.006401062, 0.009338379, -0.039245605, 0.02848816, -0.021347046, 0.054992676, -0.020568848, 0.008506775, 0.025802612, -0.028549194, 0.0039520264, 0.03552246, 0.0039978027, -0.007865906, 0.010482788, 0.04714966, 0.052459717, -0.043518066, 0.043945312, 0.05432129, -0.05050659, -0.050476074, -0.025497437, 0.004257202, -0.025756836, 0.011001587, -0.033081055, 0.015159607, 0.029754639, 0.015853882, 0.07104492, -0.017044067, -0.022491455, 0.045043945, -0.0054130554, 0.0024871826, 0.000017940998, -0.00844574, 0.03564453, -0.004421234, -0.025390625, -0.043548584, 0.005947113, 0.0035572052, -0.041259766, 0.0020885468, 0.012001038, -0.049194336, 0.009338379, -0.022888184, -0.060302734, -0.051879883, 0.022277832, -0.022399902, 0.020645142, 0.021484375, -0.017211914, -0.051696777, 0.030258179, 0.0071258545, -0.0072021484, 0.025619507, -0.043701172, 0.017532349, -0.009162903, -0.054992676, -0.026321411, -0.0036334991, -0.00036883354, 0.011886597, -0.012451172, -0.010559082, 0.021484375, 0.013053894, 0.008674622, 0.045166016, -0.022354126, -0.016693115, 0.053833008, -0.0053710938, -0.037384033, 0.026657104, -0.019958496, -0.0020828247, -0.030792236, 0.020111084, -0.020050049, -0.02154541, -0.06542969, 0.02532959, -0.024230957, 0.049713135, 0.059326172, 0.06939697, 0.04425049, 0.035186768, -0.009727478, 0.019134521, -0.036712646, -0.014785767, -0.036590576, 0.04333496, 0.005710602, 0.0049743652, 0.04348755, 0.02293396, 0.012313843, -0.024047852, 0.00623703, 0.017333984, 0.0065078735, -0.0029296875, 0.039764404, -0.016357422, -0.028259277, 0.0041542053, 0.008407593, 0.04385376, -0.033416748, 0.043029785, -0.0055770874, 0.010871887, 0.021392822, -0.0085372925, 0.040527344, -0.029022217, 0.02229309, -0.048461914, 0.01637268, 0.036224365, -0.012519836, -0.039855957, 0.011352539, -0.0057754517, 0.013908386, 0.014808655, 0.028717041, 0.003370285, 0.029937744, -0.010139465, -0.0053634644, 0.008049011, -0.039031982, -0.03265381, 0.0028209686, 0.032928467, 0.021392822, -0.027557373, -0.0055618286, -0.04159546, -0.036895752, 0.00598526, -0.02557373, 0.009529114, -0.08874512, -0.0017433167, 0.015129089, -0.0062942505, 0.009559631, -0.009498596, 0.017150879, 0.035614014, 0.05130005, -0.0027999878, 0.015823364, 0.038757324, -0.031341553, 0.049468994, 0.0045051575, 0.013267517, 0.0030498505, -0.020080566, -0.0017118454, -0.0048599243, -0.01322937, 0.024291992, 0.010047913, -0.011688232, -0.0041999817, -0.04260254, 0.002193451, 0.02041626, 0.026809692, 0.048034668, -0.028549194, -0.024246216, -0.015838623, 0.007858276, -0.04598999, 0.022949219, 0.04168701, -0.035369873, -0.061920166, 0.038330078, 0.0009613037, 0.007461548, -0.010795593, 0.024993896, -0.04776001, 0.051513672, 0.034851074, -0.034454346, -0.028930664, 0.016830444, 0.015914917, 0.03845215, 0.029418945, -0.012962341, 0.008453369, -0.03579712, -0.0635376, -0.05822754, -0.013252258, -0.0006341934, 0.01448822, -0.0032730103, -0.024658203, -0.023269653, -0.0033054352, 0.019256592, 0.006462097, -0.037506104, 0.03744507, 0.009513855, -0.00024914742, 0.015960693, 0.04714966, -0.013420105, 0.0066947937, 0.017852783, -0.035308838, 0.010688782, 0.015403748, 0.011505127, -0.015487671, -0.05227661, -0.000018656254, 0.024490356, 0.009689331, 0.010520935, 0.037231445, 0.031463623, 0.04650879, 0.00932312, 0.027069092, 0.05444336, -0.022918701, -0.031677246, -0.011138916, -0.0046577454, -0.041931152, 0.037719727, 0.021057129, -0.021972656, -0.03451538, -0.0680542, -0.042999268, 0.010917664, 0.050109863, 0.024307251, 0.041748047, -0.06689453, -0.013259888, -0.049560547, 0.010971069, 0.0053100586, 0.03012085, 0.00043416023, -0.0031089783, -0.04977417, 0.023132324, 0.03289795, -0.04333496, 0.0126953125, -0.016815186, -0.013313293, -0.023361206, -0.042907715, 0.027633667, -0.027160645, -0.032287598, 0.033050537, 0.017700195, -0.008506775, 0.06100464, -0.045532227, 0.05230713, 0.020019531, 0.036895752, 0.053100586, 0.022384644, 0.006263733, 0.004272461, 0.0063476562, -0.040618896, 0.031311035, -0.087402344, 0.02166748, -0.04147339, 0.004108429, -0.088012695, -0.0057792664, 0.043914795, 0.032348633, -0.006549835, 0.019134521, 0.029953003, -0.0027770996, 0.061431885, -0.031036377, 0.079956055, -0.029052734, -0.019897461, -0.03253174, 0.00187397, 0.040649414, 0.048583984, 0.007411957, 0.0050354004, -0.0025024414, -0.024719238, 0.021194458, 0.011161804, 0.011024475, -0.008491516, -0.014312744, -0.03237915, -0.0014219284, -0.010482788, 0.012245178, 0.043914795, 0.025222778, 0.022125244, -0.019470215, -0.006668091, 0.0042762756, -0.024658203, 0.005367279, 0.03866577, -0.0390625, 0.023391724, -0.026016235, -0.027862549, 0.023895264, 0.008010864, 0.031082153, -0.063964844, -0.04269409, 0.013473511, 0.024475098, -0.0006580353, 0.037841797, -0.029296875, -0.03213501, -0.0012922287, 0.038146973, -0.016052246, 0.017288208, -0.011764526, 0.03463745, 0.0030021667, 0.0042266846, 0.0044822693, 0.024307251, -0.022445679, 0.023498535, -0.037841797, -0.014434814, -0.012031555, -0.03186035, -0.0044784546, 0.0074501038, -0.01914978, -0.0030555725, 0.0072250366, 0.0947876, 0.061828613, 0.08148193, 0.0057907104, -0.033203125, 0.044128418, -0.03253174, 0.031051636, 0.030654907, -0.03591919, 0.02218628, -0.028656006, -0.03933716, 0.038391113, -0.043792725, 0.058166504, -0.006591797, 0.008026123, -0.011489868, -0.024108887, 0.041748047, -0.054138184, 0.010627747, -0.01826477, -0.027816772, 0.007896423, -0.004081726, -0.018585205, -0.017532349, -0.010360718, 0.02178955, 0.024475098, -0.02357483, -0.012817383, -0.003047943, -0.06008911, -0.0104904175, -0.052764893, 0.011428833, -0.039642334, -0.026901245, 0.023498535, -0.0284729, 0.015914917, -0.018661499, -0.03756714, -0.034118652, 0.005065918, -0.022827148, -0.0068969727, -0.005935669, -0.024963379, 0.010635376, 0.021652222, 0.011062622, -0.011924744, -0.006668091, 0.023727417, -0.03805542, -0.044525146, -0.0037155151, -0.053863525, 0.01637268, 0.02267456, -0.012077332, 0.009117126, 0.014907837, -0.032958984, -0.05645752, 0.01058197, 0.039031982, 0.0054092407, -0.040222168, 0.0015363693, 0.036071777, 0.04058838, -0.052368164, -0.062561035, 0.02218628, 0.03982544, -0.011146545, 0.06311035, -0.0124435425, -0.023620605, 0.005268097, 0.026397705, 0.01210022, -0.019638062, -0.016159058, -0.012588501, 0.0016078949, 0.030426025, 0.009017944, -0.024414062, 0.017532349, -0.0028266907, -0.001531601, 0.012626648, -0.010932922, -0.0031394958, 0.010505676, 0.03137207, -0.017105103, -0.021911621, -0.017623901, -0.010406494, -0.0020656586, 0.01134491, -0.012481689, 0.0037250519, -0.027359009, 0.064575195, -0.023086548, -0.0541687, 0.026123047, 0.03579712, -0.017837524, 0.068847656, -0.040863037, -0.022033691, 0.005382538, -0.008811951, -0.0051231384, -0.0116119385, 0.033416748, -0.030822754, -0.0027332306, -0.041900635, -0.04562378, 0.024536133, -0.031036377, 0.046203613, -0.041107178, 0.006210327, -0.02230835, -0.02709961, 0.00038075447, 0.025039673, 0.015411377, -0.026489258, -0.060424805, -0.015945435, 0.06060791, -0.017410278 ], "summary": [ 0.066711426, -0.014846802, 0.05001831, 0.021636963, -0.008148193, -0.02746582, 0.05718994, -0.0592041, 0.019119263, 0.017807007, -0.03515625, 0.004261017, 0.028701782, -0.02810669, 0.0026893616, -0.0066337585, -0.028045654, 0.08355713, 0.02822876, -0.035247803, -0.000027358532, -0.059509277, -0.026290894, 0.024810791, 0.035461426, -0.047607422, -0.01146698, 0.040527344, 0.013153076, 0.021972656, 0.008735657, -0.022232056, 0.04360962, 0.016799927, -0.03869629, 0.07196045, 0.029205322, -0.00157547, -0.00554657, 0.027694702, 0.0670166, -0.045806885, -0.053710938, -0.0025959015, -0.018920898, -0.0211792, 0.054534912, -0.016723633, -0.012580872, 0.057281494, 0.03878784, 0.022857666, 0.021774292, 0.046966553, 0.004497528, 0.0031433105, 0.004814148, -0.02482605, 0.023605347, 0.020721436, -0.00674057, -0.012039185, 0.012702942, -0.038360596, -0.026504517, -0.0030117035, 0.03543091, -0.012992859, 0.050598145, 0.002040863, 0.015571594, 0.029434204, 0.019805908, -0.033599854, -0.033081055, 0.024353027, 0.0025424957, 0.0046806335, 0.024230957, -0.027633667, -0.012077332, 0.02217102, -0.013168335, -0.05355835, 0.00057411194, -0.046661377, -0.01802063, -0.0009870529, 0.006149292, 0.021408081, -0.008872986, -0.01751709, -0.0010948181, 0.06585693, 0.026824951, -0.0075569153, 0.031799316, 0.043426514, -0.012298584, -0.029312134, 0.0026245117, -0.017364502, -0.03869629, -0.018035889, -0.0005617142, 0.029541016, 0.024459839, 0.014526367, 0.0011320114, 0.007461548, -0.02017212, 0.0015659332, 0.02960205, 0.035827637, -0.04638672, -0.026550293, -0.005947113, 0.015296936, -0.03387451, -0.00818634, -0.010269165, -0.014816284, 0.03503418, -0.004508972, 0.00944519, 0.005065918, -0.03604126, 0.0040893555, -0.04058838, 0.043518066, -0.02545166, -0.0012588501, 0.005882263, 0.003534317, -0.03274536, -0.030578613, -0.019577026, 0.014129639, 0.021026611, -0.037902832, 0.03125, -0.0020141602, 0.044281006, 0.021942139, 0.03050232, 0.014755249, 0.022979736, -0.010116577, 0.015930176, 0.010520935, -0.013877869, 0.018432617, 0.01374054, 0.013000488, -0.0060043335, -0.018753052, -0.023086548, -0.020507812, 0.028198242, -0.02078247, 0.030563354, 0.013755798, 0.047302246, 0.034606934, -0.008811951, -0.006504059, -0.032165527, -0.010917664, -0.006336212, -0.010253906, -0.025283813, 0.036376953, -0.010498047, -0.011421204, 0.014549255, -0.01574707, 0.006877899, 0.010932922, -0.0026779175, 0.020965576, 0.005897522, -0.03842163, -0.0017347336, 0.018417358, -0.03564453, 0.029144287, 0.0074539185, 0.04849243, 0.018737793, -0.0041923523, 0.04071045, 0.0045700073, -0.0104522705, -0.015808105, -0.022003174, -0.018615723, -0.0090789795, 0.008796692, -0.019729614, 0.035705566, 0.019348145, -0.041412354, 0.029144287, -0.074035645, -0.1026001, -0.00010675192, -0.045074463, 0.055603027, -0.055877686, 0.0032444, 0.02444458, -0.030899048, -0.047668457, 0.09124756, 0.044311523, -0.018676758, 0.040283203, -0.03378296, 0.02168274, -0.056640625, 0.036224365, 0.04232788, 0.0029735565, 0.059539795, -0.025161743, -0.014007568, 0.0077209473, 0.012290955, 0.012359619, -0.0007805824, 0.08123779, -0.014076233, 0.014472961, 0.03640747, -0.0050697327, -0.020355225, 0.012840271, -0.08074951, 0.026031494, 0.045928955, 0.025146484, 0.004585266, 0.0032024384, 0.033111572, 0.044067383, 0.002292633, 0.013710022, 0.010482788, 0.023956299, 0.03237915, 0.0001103878, -0.0030002594, 0.009155273, -0.01361084, 0.021270752, 0.030426025, -0.02192688, 0.02722168, -0.0236969, 0.029174805, -0.021347046, 0.019424438, 0.042175293, -0.004146576, -0.014122009, -0.04171753, -0.03668213, -0.03439331, 0.0012140274, -0.033813477, 0.03668213, -0.00907135, -0.022567749, -0.06427002, 0.025314331, -0.040222168, -0.027435303, 0.041809082, -0.016784668, -0.04812622, -0.010559082, -0.01638794, -0.06036377, -0.0126953125, 0.033325195, -0.010643005, -0.020904541, 0.018920898, 0.0062713623, -0.007003784, -0.0031223297, 0.03756714, -0.023788452, 0.04284668, 0.007987976, -0.024307251, -0.035491943, 0.06561279, -0.009880066, -0.020126343, -0.054229736, 0.00957489, -0.020950317, -0.00944519, -0.005622864, 0.0018014908, 0.010543823, 0.010803223, -0.006877899, -0.0068969727, -0.036224365, -0.013839722, 0.032043457, 0.023712158, 0.0012817383, -0.003282547, -0.010398865, 0.0491333, -0.0031223297, -0.0029125214, 0.118652344, 0.013580322, 0.009208679, 0.015602112, 0.0126571655, -0.0680542, 0.048065186, -0.031433105, -0.024780273, -0.0013723373, -0.03503418, -0.04284668, -0.04437256, 0.012306213, -0.0048713684, 0.005256653, 0.01209259, -0.0077171326, -0.009597778, -0.016937256, 0.009101868, 0.026809692, 0.00365448, -0.017623901, -0.022750854, -0.025909424, 0.017990112, -0.009376526, -0.034729004, -0.0025043488, 0.018035889, -0.030456543, -0.02545166, 0.045410156, -0.011116028, 0.034179688, 0.051483154, 0.017837524, -0.00042581558, -0.017913818, 0.024734497, 0.012825012, 0.00056648254, -0.043029785, -0.023483276, -0.02406311, 0.0209198, -0.028259277, 0.009849548, 0.0042762756, -0.0022621155, 0.00774765, -0.018005371, -0.017303467, -0.006008148, 0.012229919, 0.047943115, -0.0071487427, 0.016983032, 0.018157959, 0.017227173, 0.018218994, -0.008056641, -0.009681702, -0.010986328, 0.029403687, 0.000647068, 0.018447876, 0.0060043335, -0.00522995, -0.0052223206, 0.040222168, 0.0345459, -0.028625488, -0.0033493042, -0.012504578, 0.022155762, 0.054992676, -0.007789612, -0.03665161, -0.034698486, 0.022018433, 0.013626099, -0.010543823, -0.040863037, 0.047424316, -0.03894043, -0.017837524, 0.013511658, -0.036712646, 0.039520264, -0.019210815, 0.039916992, -0.026733398, 0.017623901, -0.06738281, -0.034088135, -0.0048065186, -0.019073486, 0.0019741058, -0.019317627, 0.05987549, -0.012878418, 0.018600464, 0.006729126, 0.032592773, -0.020080566, -0.012367249, 0.0016288757, 0.030822754, 0.0017366409, 0.010635376, -0.014251709, 0.0058631897, -0.01737976, 0.045196533, 0.0066375732, 0.007457733, 0.013046265, -0.030944824, -0.049835205, -0.02720642, -0.021026611, -0.0026454926, -0.028244019, 0.0024089813, -0.028579712, -0.058685303, -0.008468628, -0.0004117489, -0.012367249, 0.009689331, 0.03756714, 0.031585693, -0.0121536255, 0.012710571, 0.00919342, 0.034454346, 0.02885437, 0.034484863, 0.03503418, -0.0209198, 0.015838623, 0.026062012, -0.01574707, 0.0368042, 0.01676941, 0.025726318, -0.016967773, -0.0014562607, 0.038757324, -0.047821045, -0.006931305, 0.0063171387, -0.0018043518, -0.034332275, 0.010040283, 0.04849243, -0.027328491, -0.024551392, -0.019958496, 0.03945923, -0.051879883, -0.074157715, -0.064208984, 0.017227173, -0.122924805, -0.08905029, 0.014831543, -0.035980225, -0.017974854, -0.034698486, 0.047607422, -0.049560547, 0.014770508, 0.00012338161, -0.033203125, 0.11871338, 0.021850586, -0.05999756, 0.035827637, -0.02154541, 0.0071525574, -0.019989014, -0.050964355, 0.027511597, 0.06970215, -0.026031494, 0.024520874, -0.055603027, 0.056640625, -0.041778564, 0.031280518, 0.022949219, -0.017105103, 0.0006275177, 0.037963867, 0.00013613701, 0.015274048, 0.0017127991, 0.04989624, 0.07086182, -0.0552063, -0.0038051605, 0.081726074, -0.027694702, -0.047546387, -0.0015993118, -0.008926392, -0.035247803, 0.02079773, 0.028289795, -0.02041626, 0.016433716, 0.0058555603, 0.008682251, -0.0501709, -0.040496826, 0.029754639, 0.04360962, -0.031280518, -0.01966858, -0.013435364, 0.081726074, -0.017440796, -0.006362915, -0.05368042, -0.029571533, -0.0013551712, -0.040405273, -0.012191772, -0.00623703, -0.05316162, -0.024276733, 0.008491516, -0.056488037, -0.03741455, 0.015930176, 0.00573349, 0.0022621155, 0.0038051605, -0.012275696, 0.0011930466, 0.0044403076, -0.0067214966, 0.033294678, -0.038330078, -0.05429077, -0.029022217, -0.007472992, -0.047698975, -0.018661499, -0.057769775, -0.061035156, -0.02293396, 0.0022239685, 0.0064315796, 0.029464722, -0.0003643036, -0.01586914, -0.000893116, -0.030441284, -0.025558472, -0.0093688965, -0.028244019, -0.00047945976, -0.0042419434, -0.02243042, -0.028121948, -0.022750854, 0.0181427, 0.013122559, -0.039733887, -0.11437988, 0.002155304, 0.009063721, 0.0026359558, 0.103637695, 0.053619385, 0.030334473, 0.04446411, -0.027252197, 0.010421753, -0.007106781, -0.014053345, -0.05847168, 0.017089844, 0.023788452, 0.027740479, 0.05227661, -0.0071907043, -0.026641846, -0.010299683, 0.024414062, 0.016921997, -0.031143188, 0.028549194, 0.010665894, 0.036468506, -0.036499023, 0.01676941, 0.041931152, 0.006095886, 0.036102295, -0.009162903, 0.03466797, -0.016525269, 0.02368164, -0.013008118, 0.01512146, 0.01473999, -0.012756348, -0.00472641, 0.05215454, 0.02722168, -0.04385376, -0.020080566, -0.009506226, -0.03540039, -0.0057029724, -0.0037670135, -0.00052309036, -0.019256592, 0.010612488, -0.00018239021, -0.026535034, -0.011146545, -0.003643036, -0.010665894, -0.025527954, 0.027893066, -0.005580902, 0.018096924, -0.045562744, 0.009429932, -0.04812622, 0.03201294, -0.027877808, -0.008346558, -0.08648682, -0.0713501, -0.07952881, -0.05996704, -0.05038452, -0.0019702911, 0.0047187805, -0.0038967133, 0.043548584, -0.029724121, 0.0009493828, 0.006252289, 0.0020141602, 0.039154053, -0.006641388, 0.019332886, 0.016906738, -0.039154053, 0.013572693, -0.013618469, 0.014503479, 0.00065660477, -0.025680542, -0.0018053055, -0.036224365, 0.015151978, 0.021606445, 0.03845215, 0.02154541, 0.011543274, -0.010398865, 0.0075263977, 0.026107788, -0.0032176971, -0.0014381409, 0.001200676, 0.0020198822, -0.025741577, -0.071899414, 0.01007843, -0.016784668, -0.0022201538, -0.01461792, 0.024932861, -0.034301758, 0.032806396, -0.01637268, -0.030319214, -0.019256592, 0.030044556, 0.015357971, -0.011070251, 0.017318726, -0.04916382, 0.0048103333, -0.05407715, -0.054840088, -0.076049805, -0.006603241, 0.013534546, 0.043670654, -0.007434845, 0.016311646, 0.0053138733, -0.052001953, -0.00090932846, -0.014465332, -0.011711121, 0.028366089, -0.021026611, -0.01776123, -0.0026817322, 0.035095215, -0.031585693, -0.0093688965, 0.008140564, -0.040527344, 0.0071029663, 0.040496826, 0.05154419, -0.02571106, -0.031585693, -0.016082764, 0.043273926, 0.0107803345, 0.02935791, 0.0067443848, 0.012588501, -0.010818481, 0.035247803, 0.030822754, 0.05935669, -0.029800415, -0.041107178, -0.02192688, 0.018081665, -0.03173828, -0.029724121, 0.028518677, -0.021194458, 0.00667572, -0.020736694, -0.0018386841, -0.0052986145, 0.021530151, -0.0019454956, 0.052612305, -0.02330017, -0.041625977, -0.04550171, -0.011367798, 0.024307251, 0.016357422, -0.02204895, -0.051971436, 0.0062217712, -0.020568848, 0.046173096, -0.008003235, -0.0141067505, -0.0390625, -0.02381897, -0.009796143, -0.021759033, 0.039642334, -0.03289795, 0.020309448, 0.009101868, 0.016220093, -0.011558533, 0.018295288, 0.00680542, 0.031021118, 0.0149383545, -0.0075149536, 0.013412476, 0.0060310364, 0.008277893, 0.01777649, 0.010551453, -0.0184021, 0.025100708, -0.013633728, -0.00844574, -0.024383545, -0.020187378, -0.02619934, 0.06640625, -0.01713562, -0.008644104, 0.02015686, 0.007904053, -0.0017490387, 0.033325195, -0.013069153, 0.005470276, 0.0059776306, -0.037963867, -0.03149414, -0.013053894, 0.0019245148, 0.029251099, 0.043670654, 0.009262085, 0.0010538101, 0.039764404, -0.012321472, 0.04107666, -0.019836426, -0.02029419, -0.08166504, 0.004135132, -0.057281494, -0.016723633, -0.013420105, 0.011077881, 0.024795532, -0.03479004, 0.051361084, -0.026229858, -0.010551453, 0.06384277, -0.018798828, 0.03491211, 0.023086548, 0.037200928, -0.010818481, -0.004512787, -0.033294678, 0.06933594, 0.0043296814, 0.03353882, -0.038970947, -0.03173828, -0.008201599, 0.015914917, 0.008666992, 0.03515625, -0.021194458, -0.049316406, 0.018661499, 0.039520264, -0.019866943, 0.027542114, -0.014633179, 0.031066895, -0.00028705597, 0.053375244, -0.02268982, 0.046539307, -0.016403198, 0.0335083, -0.076049805, -0.002281189, 0.03050232, -0.01084137, -0.018844604, 0.034423828, -0.04724121, 0.04055786, -0.018569946, 0.12145996, 0.07501221, 0.08074951, -0.040771484, -0.006538391, 0.08605957, 0.0042648315, 0.012031555, 0.0031986237, -0.0051612854, 0.0016965866, -0.0014467239, 0.0066337585, 0.034729004, -0.008331299, 0.051757812, 0.015205383, -0.015640259, -0.03050232, -0.026046753, -0.0027256012, -0.025222778, 0.0692749, -0.07092285, 0.028518677, -0.00058698654, 0.00047183037, -0.04336548, 0.031036377, -0.01499176, -0.0017671585, 0.027709961, -0.009750366, 0.018356323, 0.011428833, -0.0045661926, -0.019424438, -0.025604248, 0.029769897, -0.026123047, -0.011199951, 0.06112671, -0.0051612854, 0.0070648193, -0.07672119, -0.06390381, 0.02279663, 0.07556152, -0.06286621, 0.026535034, 0.01525116, -0.011672974, -0.029876709, 0.025665283, -0.010482788, -0.013633728, 0.05239868, 0.0035190582, -0.012809753, -0.04336548, 0.004558563, -0.04925537, -0.005970001, -0.020874023, 0.007457733, 0.01828003, 0.0064086914, -0.0126571655, -0.0546875, 0.012199402, 0.0013208389, 0.0077590942, -0.042297363, -0.004135132, 0.02406311, 0.029968262, -0.0023670197, -0.0128479, 0.059448242, 0.0036830902, 0.021484375, -0.026519775, -0.040130615, -0.037628174, -0.0073890686, 0.05783081, 0.0058517456, -0.001581192, 0.033294678, 0.01953125, 0.016235352, 0.008659363, -0.018951416, 0.012969971, 0.002571106, -0.03387451, -0.02406311, 0.016433716, 0.0032958984, -0.0345459, 0.018035889, -0.01878357, -0.049804688, -0.044128418, 0.032806396, -0.060913086, 0.0059661865, -0.038024902, 0.0006685257, -0.01777649, -0.07635498, 0.015129089, 0.01058197, -0.017349243, -0.007858276, 0.0052948, 0.013404846, 0.016677856, -0.0026874542, -0.02571106, 0.0118255615, -0.018798828, 0.00025749207, -0.019973755, 0.024642944, -0.043914795, -0.02166748, -0.06677246, -0.03366089, -0.0079193115, -0.029907227, 0.037963867, -0.04071045, 0.016418457, 0.0070648193, -0.017974854, 0.021591187, 0.033233643, 0.015007019, -0.0013599396, 0.007095337, 0.025726318, 0.018508911, 0.00434494 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2007.16122v2
COLD: Towards the Next Generation of Pre-Ranking System
Zhe Wang, Liqin Zhao, Biye Jiang, Guorui Zhou, Xiaoqiang Zhu, Kun Gai
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Multi-stage cascade architecture exists widely in many industrial systems such as recommender systems and online advertising, which often consists of sequential modules including matching, pre-ranking, ranking, etc. For a long time, it is believed pre-ranking is just a simplified version of the ranking module, considering the larger size of the candidate set to be ranked. Thus, efforts are made mostly on simplifying ranking model to handle the explosion of computing power for online inference. In this paper, we rethink the challenge of the pre-ranking system from an algorithm-system co-design view. Instead of saving computing power with restriction of model architecture which causes loss of model performance, here we design a new pre-ranking system by joint optimization of both the pre-ranking model and the computing power it costs. We name it COLD (Computing power cost-aware Online and Lightweight Deep pre-ranking system). COLD beats SOTA in three folds: (i) an arbitrary deep model with cross features can be applied in COLD under a constraint of controllable computing power cost. (ii) computing power cost is explicitly reduced by applying optimization tricks for inference acceleration. This further brings space for COLD to apply more complex deep models to reach better performance. (iii) COLD model works in an online learning and severing manner, bringing it excellent ability to handle the challenge of the data distribution shift. Meanwhile, the fully online pre-ranking system of COLD provides us with a flexible infrastructure that supports efficient new model developing and online A/B testing.Since 2019, COLD has been deployed in almost all products involving the pre-ranking module in the display advertising system in Alibaba, bringing significant improvements.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2007.16122v2
"2020-08-17T13:13:25"
"2020-07-31T15:06:43"
{ "title": [ 0.041625977, -0.0014801025, -0.00010949373, -0.058135986, 0.017410278, -0.0018815994, -0.0030574799, -0.033233643, -0.010017395, 0.039520264, 0.010185242, -0.001405716, -0.008361816, -0.046783447, -0.04147339, 0.007827759, -0.0079193115, -0.0003323555, -0.016693115, -0.037139893, -0.028244019, -0.06286621, 0.02520752, 0.045440674, 0.034118652, 0.00699234, -0.06854248, 0.0022716522, -0.014808655, -0.012542725, -0.0026073456, 0.016860962, 0.048065186, -0.0043945312, 0.036224365, 0.040924072, -0.0158844, 0.014808655, -0.011528015, 0.04888916, 0.00091838837, -0.0008955002, -0.025161743, 0.011421204, -0.06365967, 0.0036525726, -0.049346924, 0.006164551, -0.043884277, 0.017303467, -0.0045280457, 0.009666443, 0.006839752, 0.0473938, 0.005268097, -0.025024414, -0.01953125, 0.0036792755, 0.02029419, 0.06939697, 0.0011825562, -0.023605347, 0.002336502, -0.030838013, -0.05834961, 0.0017337799, 0.017303467, 0.02330017, 0.08154297, -0.027526855, -0.0335083, 0.064941406, 0.01965332, -0.0423584, -0.0030231476, 0.023620605, 0.018127441, 0.019760132, 0.015808105, -0.026687622, 0.036102295, 0.005115509, 0.010017395, -0.020065308, 0.012550354, -0.020217896, -0.0038108826, -0.017547607, -0.043884277, -0.05557251, -0.023651123, -0.020812988, -0.028213501, 0.01751709, -0.0129470825, 0.0036792755, 0.015975952, 0.03744507, 0.0052108765, -0.025177002, -0.011360168, -0.00020384789, -0.030227661, -0.011360168, -0.015808105, 0.02381897, 0.006038666, 0.037322998, 0.0043296814, 0.046020508, -0.022415161, -0.00031018257, 0.029083252, 0.04473877, -0.018600464, -0.011878967, 0.0045776367, -0.010231018, -0.033477783, 0.041625977, -0.0178833, -0.011955261, 0.047546387, -0.062927246, 0.015129089, -0.008178711, -0.04147339, -0.03314209, -0.04397583, 0.031402588, 0.012702942, 0.039794922, -0.060913086, -0.033477783, -0.042999268, 0.020889282, -0.014755249, -0.016113281, 0.014884949, 0.0032958984, 0.03250122, -0.02822876, 0.0007338524, -0.0045204163, -0.018508911, 0.03161621, 0.0491333, -0.013214111, -0.028823853, -0.026031494, -0.037231445, -0.010368347, 0.043060303, 0.00642395, -0.066345215, -0.0034809113, -0.12432861, 0.0006260872, -0.012496948, 0.006690979, -0.018936157, -0.0029201508, 0.0046424866, -0.012237549, 0.03439331, -0.0007634163, -0.019729614, 0.031921387, 0.014526367, 0.0141067505, 0.019348145, 0.0087890625, 0.01574707, -0.01524353, 0.0018558502, -0.008262634, 0.03781128, 0.0027389526, 0.06866455, -0.034423828, 0.011100769, 0.03466797, 0.06732178, 0.027572632, -0.042541504, -0.045532227, -0.0017089844, -0.015182495, 0.018188477, 0.018035889, -0.03805542, 0.05102539, -0.051239014, -0.005016327, -0.04638672, -0.051239014, 0.05090332, 0.02734375, -0.00491333, 0.00069999695, -0.04421997, -0.0042152405, -0.013168335, 0.022460938, 0.050720215, -0.029083252, 0.02420044, 0.013160706, -0.012611389, 0.04925537, 0.062469482, 0.030563354, -0.05657959, 0.019866943, -0.0017213821, -0.06329346, 0.005130768, -0.022399902, 0.0036792755, -0.01373291, -0.0088272095, -0.00021290779, -0.030975342, 0.018707275, -0.014671326, 0.034973145, 0.00001180172, -0.009086609, 0.057159424, 0.035980225, 0.10211182, -0.036865234, 0.06854248, 0.060333252, 0.012771606, 0.0013895035, 0.031280518, -0.0340271, -0.004245758, 0.009185791, -0.00035738945, 0.010643005, -0.014343262, 0.0501709, 0.02545166, -0.012451172, 0.028030396, 0.022476196, 0.023635864, 0.03253174, 0.024902344, 0.031677246, 0.06286621, 0.06866455, -0.028823853, 0.08258057, 0.05166626, 0.027282715, -0.0124053955, 0.012367249, 0.012809753, 0.050048828, -0.047210693, 0.040618896, -0.037231445, 0.015304565, -0.009178162, 0.017288208, -0.003768921, 0.029083252, 0.037475586, 0.015205383, 0.010131836, -0.0023784637, 0.019500732, -0.0074920654, -0.037750244, 0.012306213, 0.00818634, -0.039794922, -0.03491211, 0.0014801025, 0.0102005005, -0.00047683716, -0.016067505, -0.02670288, 0.033416748, 0.034820557, -0.0066452026, -0.01083374, 0.047943115, -0.000770092, -0.014190674, 0.010513306, 0.012283325, -0.015617371, 0.01977539, 0.090026855, -0.052856445, 0.038146973, -0.06210327, 0.0013332367, 0.03591919, -0.051574707, 0.010528564, 0.037017822, -0.002571106, 0.04034424, 0.0010280609, -0.024597168, -0.04953003, 0.031280518, 0.014251709, -0.03665161, -0.0022563934, -0.030715942, 0.018814087, -0.014060974, 0.0211792, -0.008003235, 0.029037476, -0.007881165, -0.019744873, 0.012046814, 0.008514404, -0.03692627, -0.008071899, -0.01979065, -0.041748047, -0.0004892349, 0.06604004, -0.00018334389, -0.03265381, -0.010551453, 0.029174805, 0.016662598, -0.014778137, 0.004436493, -0.02029419, -0.02041626, -0.0043258667, 0.028259277, 0.013473511, -0.036712646, -0.0025939941, -0.044952393, -0.011383057, 0.016311646, -0.034698486, -0.011756897, 0.03930664, -0.022720337, -0.020950317, 0.02281189, 0.046936035, 0.031677246, -0.015159607, 0.011619568, 0.04296875, -0.04034424, 0.06744385, -0.008811951, 0.019622803, -0.044708252, -0.03717041, -0.037322998, -0.035064697, -0.009529114, -0.049194336, 0.015090942, -0.047821045, -0.027252197, -0.058166504, -0.024673462, -0.056274414, 0.053863525, 0.011360168, -0.020477295, -0.028030396, -0.0008535385, 0.023788452, 0.024612427, -0.015380859, 0.014846802, 0.08758545, 0.0045700073, -0.021850586, -0.0018835068, 0.03189087, 0.012390137, -0.00004261732, -0.031341553, -0.0015859604, 0.0025291443, 0.014526367, 0.010757446, -0.009437561, -0.012046814, -0.07220459, -0.0019435883, 0.014625549, 0.0004954338, -0.010887146, 0.001707077, -0.046295166, 0.043914795, -0.0181427, -0.016159058, 0.041534424, 0.056243896, -0.015037537, 0.03817749, 0.0021343231, 0.0024604797, -0.015716553, -0.010604858, -0.057373047, 0.026763916, -0.030838013, -0.014556885, -0.004737854, 0.024383545, -0.04849243, -0.0059165955, 0.011894226, 0.05670166, 0.031463623, 0.017837524, 0.014892578, -0.034118652, 0.020614624, -0.038360596, 0.014846802, -0.0018634796, -0.044403076, -0.034484863, -0.043823242, 0.0067977905, 0.011024475, -0.036254883, -0.022521973, -0.02861023, -0.020019531, 0.03326416, 0.0109939575, -0.031707764, -0.029769897, -0.028839111, -0.027679443, 0.0027198792, -0.022918701, 0.017028809, -0.054382324, 0.006942749, -0.010635376, 0.0062026978, 0.033599854, 0.018936157, -0.022338867, -0.010192871, 0.011581421, -0.027160645, -0.03112793, 0.005214691, -0.011009216, 0.057434082, -0.022399902, 0.008399963, -0.01763916, -0.02444458, -0.02267456, 0.016540527, -0.0018148422, 0.012084961, -0.0014343262, -0.035339355, -0.013771057, 0.046875, -0.048919678, -0.019866943, 0.028411865, 0.01789856, 0.012756348, -0.08093262, -0.018875122, 0.024246216, -0.11413574, -0.056854248, -0.0019035339, -0.008300781, -0.033294678, -0.034088135, 0.010032654, 0.0053253174, -0.04498291, 0.012191772, -0.01826477, 0.017059326, -0.0050964355, -0.08087158, -0.008361816, 0.03930664, -0.021316528, 0.013717651, 0.049682617, -0.005569458, -0.018966675, -0.017684937, 0.014282227, 0.012687683, 0.046691895, -0.0211792, -0.07104492, -0.004425049, -0.013763428, 0.004398346, 0.036895752, 0.0025634766, 0.012496948, 0.010665894, 0.033843994, 0.02859497, -0.012779236, 0.018966675, 0.060943604, 0.0064353943, -0.07635498, 0.029067993, -0.024810791, -0.06262207, 0.0056533813, -0.003929138, -0.0135650635, 0.03616333, 0.04562378, 0.0770874, -0.020889282, 0.020019531, 0.081848145, 0.008460999, -0.0036296844, -0.0021018982, -0.0011444092, 0.031219482, 0.0096206665, 0.0027332306, 0.014015198, 0.045959473, -0.012840271, 0.0041656494, -0.027404785, -0.0055656433, -0.0446167, 0.006717682, -0.012451172, -0.027923584, -0.048095703, -0.013450623, -0.002319336, 0.06762695, -0.02053833, -0.005050659, -0.043762207, 0.027114868, -0.005077362, 0.018981934, -0.00033521652, -0.033996582, -0.025436401, -0.02557373, -0.06085205, -0.027313232, 0.015159607, 0.013381958, 0.00793457, -0.0071983337, 0.0035953522, 0.0034809113, 0.03967285, 0.011779785, 0.0013008118, -0.007713318, -0.012771606, 0.009902954, -0.014083862, -0.02268982, 0.034240723, 0.015312195, 0.008079529, 0.0062217712, 0.034362793, -0.042785645, -0.014984131, -0.056427002, -0.004207611, -0.0009441376, 0.038909912, 0.046051025, 0.014076233, 0.026535034, 0.054718018, 0.016708374, 0.014953613, -0.013618469, -0.10839844, -0.0054244995, 0.056884766, 0.014839172, 0.0018033981, 0.025680542, 0.035125732, 0.0009651184, -0.0038928986, 0.02230835, 0.009117126, -0.013633728, 0.015899658, 0.02217102, -0.040924072, -0.02571106, -0.0014705658, -0.014289856, 0.019256592, -0.064941406, 0.036590576, 0.00699234, 0.004535675, 0.045562744, -0.020690918, 0.00019264221, 0.015808105, 0.014045715, -0.05581665, -0.051574707, -0.004890442, 0.07128906, -0.0625, -0.024536133, -0.032928467, -0.0014715195, 0.013061523, 0.033721924, 0.014701843, -0.009979248, 0.007003784, -0.008399963, 0.004135132, -0.02520752, -0.074523926, 0.0016489029, -0.0063095093, 0.036376953, -0.02760315, 0.010604858, -0.06335449, -0.020523071, -0.00349617, 0.0099487305, 0.009498596, -0.07739258, -0.024780273, 0.022415161, 0.025390625, -0.00041246414, -0.0045814514, 0.02708435, 0.017913818, 0.035980225, 0.0143966675, -0.026687622, 0.016220093, -0.03768921, -0.026855469, -0.0058135986, 0.03353882, -0.01828003, 0.010307312, 0.010772705, -0.027801514, -0.049560547, 0.026870728, 0.0074043274, 0.022521973, -0.02961731, -0.028289795, 0.016052246, -0.018325806, -0.019882202, 0.030059814, -0.007663727, -0.020431519, -0.014343262, 0.0036468506, -0.07623291, 0.043945312, 0.03704834, -0.034484863, -0.06738281, -0.0025291443, 0.014060974, -0.008918762, -0.012680054, 0.07836914, -0.019577026, -0.018829346, 0.017684937, 0.0042419434, 0.04949951, -0.056854248, -0.014976501, 0.032409668, 0.055236816, -0.011924744, -0.012557983, -0.0044174194, -0.036376953, 0.024215698, 0.016159058, 0.008773804, -0.0076942444, 0.013717651, -0.033111572, 0.012130737, 0.0149383545, 0.03265381, 0.016799927, -0.035980225, 0.023345947, 0.0074768066, 0.0033798218, 0.006965637, 0.0690918, -0.057434082, 0.020492554, 0.035095215, 0.022537231, 0.017532349, -0.009178162, -0.0079956055, 0.007587433, -0.03189087, 0.014007568, 0.028656006, 0.0021400452, 0.014533997, 0.075683594, 0.040283203, 0.07513428, 0.0016260147, 0.015090942, 0.04232788, -0.026992798, -0.04006958, 0.002374649, -0.019607544, -0.03552246, 0.0791626, 0.032104492, -0.012825012, -0.048553467, -0.052124023, -0.028213501, -0.0010299683, 0.025543213, 0.0031738281, 0.0090789795, -0.040161133, 0.014945984, -0.017807007, -0.023071289, -0.018661499, 0.0057373047, -0.00054979324, -0.03213501, 0.048553467, -0.0028972626, 0.0284729, -0.0715332, -0.011688232, -0.015464783, 0.01727295, -0.0135269165, -0.008483887, 0.004928589, -0.040222168, -0.004852295, 0.035705566, 0.027420044, -0.014541626, 0.06951904, -0.047698975, 0.051239014, -0.002161026, 0.04989624, 0.041168213, 0.01499939, -0.011039734, 0.010940552, 0.032562256, -0.023147583, -0.0127334595, -0.041656494, 0.0073280334, -0.022079468, 0.0095825195, -0.06842041, 0.024765015, 0.034179688, 0.0064888, -0.017913818, 0.00868988, 0.0234375, 0.011672974, 0.012069702, 0.007282257, 0.031799316, 0.033233643, 0.0041999817, 0.009124756, 0.006088257, -0.006664276, 0.041290283, 0.0052757263, -0.006828308, -0.010276794, -0.023345947, 0.015655518, 0.015914917, 0.018676758, 0.013175964, 0.0019245148, -0.0027103424, 0.018600464, -0.012145996, 0.054473877, 0.07104492, 0.03225708, 0.022232056, -0.028060913, -0.0154800415, -0.00026202202, -0.03253174, 0.018753052, 0.04714966, -0.0690918, 0.013267517, -0.03677368, -0.019866943, -0.03878784, 0.00024163723, 0.0637207, -0.03717041, -0.029296875, 0.003753662, 0.04626465, -0.01360321, 0.01486969, -0.041290283, -0.0029582977, 0.018539429, 0.041137695, 0.0024337769, 0.031799316, -0.011543274, 0.051879883, 0.010856628, -0.018234253, -0.016342163, -0.020965576, -0.02166748, 0.026535034, 0.007484436, 0.0259552, 0.011299133, -0.037017822, 0.017944336, 0.03253174, -0.08538818, 0.024780273, 0.0054359436, 0.06512451, 0.040649414, 0.07574463, 0.0053749084, -0.0066604614, -0.0012865067, -0.03781128, 0.0317688, 0.050048828, -0.025848389, 0.027130127, -0.02178955, -0.033050537, 0.019485474, -0.049591064, -0.01638794, -0.04296875, 0.015182495, -0.010009766, -0.016983032, 0.019073486, -0.03729248, -0.010948181, -0.006893158, 0.0019159317, 0.0048294067, -0.025482178, -0.049957275, -0.018127441, -0.0032310486, 0.051116943, 0.032318115, -0.04925537, -0.035308838, -0.006706238, -0.03842163, -0.0368042, -0.038116455, -0.007434845, -0.045959473, -0.03286743, 0.006023407, 0.008010864, 0.00032114983, -0.054534912, -0.041778564, -0.018630981, 0.02053833, -0.047180176, 0.02494812, 0.021606445, -0.014221191, -0.009971619, -0.027175903, 0.013999939, -0.029541016, -0.0046195984, 0.0048561096, -0.07043457, -0.043701172, -0.015823364, -0.030899048, 0.06689453, 0.046661377, 0.0026950836, -0.0028648376, 0.022598267, -0.027313232, -0.061584473, -0.01789856, 0.015258789, 0.0112838745, -0.056274414, 0.015541077, 0.010246277, 0.0017089844, -0.040924072, -0.003200531, 0.02822876, 0.076049805, 0.016189575, 0.07305908, 0.02267456, -0.021560669, 0.0059776306, -0.01914978, -0.00088071823, -0.010299683, -0.009361267, -0.020217896, -0.00038409233, 0.012832642, -0.003232956, -0.029876709, 0.03010559, 0.0033950806, -0.0087509155, 0.02420044, -0.027938843, -0.0141067505, 0.022491455, 0.008491516, -0.0211792, -0.007106781, 0.0090408325, -0.018844604, -0.0044059753, -0.01776123, -0.0028247833, -0.0023059845, -0.05557251, 0.052764893, -0.015975952, -0.009719849, 0.022521973, 0.030776978, 0.016647339, 0.039733887, -0.029830933, 0.0039024353, 0.0259552, 0.0014410019, -0.00881958, -0.0034389496, 0.007949829, -0.0004284382, -0.020446777, 0.0034046173, -0.053466797, 0.007381439, -0.022064209, 0.015411377, -0.059265137, 0.03414917, -0.019363403, -0.06121826, -0.0016775131, -0.002216339, -0.019805908, -0.027038574, -0.055114746, -0.005050659, 0.010375977, 0.003944397 ], "summary": [ 0.062805176, -0.009353638, 0.025039673, -0.05606079, 0.0010051727, 0.0050468445, -0.01260376, -0.026184082, 0.0055770874, -0.00066661835, -0.036102295, -0.00025177002, -0.0010881424, -0.028320312, 0.023651123, -0.024215698, 0.009033203, -0.0073280334, 0.0102005005, -0.029907227, 0.020767212, -0.025665283, 0.015281677, 0.072021484, 0.048736572, -0.03262329, -0.037231445, 0.052368164, 0.0045166016, 0.012878418, 0.02217102, 0.015403748, 0.043151855, -0.0015296936, -0.015029907, 0.07067871, 0.00015509129, 0.0032997131, -0.0046958923, 0.02281189, 0.034210205, -0.0309906, -0.009170532, 0.031463623, -0.022018433, 0.03387451, -0.019515991, -0.04272461, 0.009338379, -0.005420685, -0.005001068, 0.031234741, 0.007461548, 0.000032007694, -0.012199402, -0.01576233, -0.03074646, -0.0076560974, 0.022949219, 0.067993164, 0.0110321045, -0.008735657, -0.016723633, -0.0619812, -0.041656494, -0.0028762817, 0.033050537, -0.022491455, 0.059753418, -0.04260254, -0.021820068, 0.06829834, 0.03491211, -0.03250122, -0.005126953, -0.0018234253, -0.01109314, 0.010520935, 0.01777649, -0.014038086, -0.011245728, 0.02746582, -0.02305603, -0.049194336, 0.011062622, -0.020141602, -0.010345459, -0.0051956177, -0.03778076, -0.032836914, -0.030807495, -0.012557983, -0.056854248, -0.0016059875, 0.009780884, -0.02255249, 0.045837402, 0.029663086, 0.03338623, -0.000446558, 0.027770996, -0.051605225, 0.017807007, -0.022018433, -0.0206604, 0.0046806335, -0.020492554, 0.04434204, 0.03265381, 0.033996582, -0.014450073, -0.03878784, 0.0052833557, 0.0041999817, -0.0231781, 0.014701843, -0.019500732, 0.04437256, -0.010772705, 0.053985596, -0.013221741, 0.0051879883, 0.04107666, -0.010871887, -0.007434845, -0.010658264, 0.00674057, -0.039916992, -0.03805542, 0.03656006, 0.0007324219, 0.013290405, -0.0038375854, 0.009315491, -0.023040771, -0.024597168, -0.0045661926, 0.033416748, 0.045318604, -0.013809204, 0.068603516, -0.052246094, -0.036590576, 0.084350586, 0.0055999756, 0.02571106, 0.0075798035, -0.001083374, 0.016204834, -0.0051956177, -0.033996582, 0.009017944, 0.050598145, -0.020523071, -0.064453125, -0.038604736, -0.078552246, -0.004009247, -0.00491333, -0.0052223206, 0.0012283325, -0.0010967255, 0.049102783, 0.026382446, -0.008956909, -0.0050315857, -0.028198242, -0.010887146, 0.020477295, -0.017684937, 0.03717041, -0.00080633163, 0.01374054, -0.03050232, -0.006942749, -0.026611328, 0.008026123, 0.026519775, 0.05886841, -0.026138306, -0.017608643, -0.013717651, 0.121520996, -0.026245117, -0.045135498, 0.03274536, -0.021881104, 0.05392456, 0.03640747, -0.00030612946, -0.038635254, -0.0063972473, -0.035186768, 0.05230713, 0.0059318542, -0.024597168, -0.024475098, 0.011756897, -0.002418518, -0.058380127, -0.03036499, 0.0016784668, -0.0141067505, -0.0075302124, -0.037841797, -0.009170532, 0.004878998, 0.022659302, -0.019760132, 0.0071144104, 0.030349731, -0.0009899139, -0.031036377, 0.0073661804, -0.0025138855, -0.007472992, 0.0055770874, -0.027893066, 0.014007568, -0.032714844, 0.0059318542, 0.04598999, -0.025817871, 0.039276123, 0.009689331, -0.0023498535, -0.0084991455, 0.00010031462, 0.03515625, 0.008232117, 0.047668457, -0.026763916, 0.06561279, 0.086364746, 0.0073928833, -0.013137817, 0.035064697, -0.07086182, 0.020568848, 0.028793335, 0.002008438, 0.008811951, -0.03982544, 0.032196045, -0.0011606216, -0.031921387, -0.0016956329, 0.029190063, 0.0154953, 0.016113281, -0.0039978027, -0.017044067, 0.018722534, 0.038085938, -0.0015735626, 0.027435303, 0.03729248, 0.04827881, -0.025604248, -0.008033752, 0.016540527, 0.0725708, -0.024642944, 0.04083252, -0.05279541, 0.02180481, -0.00036978722, 0.013748169, 0.004234314, -0.016464233, 0.022033691, -0.010559082, -0.022155762, -0.042388916, -0.010398865, -0.07562256, -0.054351807, 0.066223145, -0.017501831, -0.05505371, 0.024887085, 0.006965637, 0.013404846, -0.0039978027, 0.014053345, -0.0010738373, 0.025848389, 0.060791016, -0.025741577, 0.026351929, 0.03741455, 0.026397705, -0.011108398, 0.0017671585, 0.0077323914, 0.002878189, -0.02557373, 0.054656982, -0.024169922, 0.0046310425, -0.033233643, 0.022232056, 0.022888184, -0.05596924, 0.00242424, 0.0014266968, -0.00007593632, 0.0025138855, 0.0018978119, 0.00667572, -0.07879639, 0.01637268, 0.048065186, 0.029708862, 0.008514404, -0.00024867058, -0.0018072128, 0.04748535, -0.0074806213, -0.012191772, 0.08105469, 0.018508911, -0.0014438629, 0.035583496, 0.016189575, -0.05303955, 0.0637207, -0.019088745, -0.0022907257, 0.003293991, 0.021530151, -0.011375427, -0.019866943, -0.010437012, 0.009483337, 0.011810303, 0.005584717, -0.016921997, -0.004283905, -0.011154175, 0.033355713, 0.023223877, -0.003440857, 0.010749817, -0.013137817, -0.0011453629, -0.008522034, 0.01146698, -0.028427124, -0.018173218, 0.00995636, -0.03503418, 0.0017051697, 0.012748718, -0.010688782, 0.058746338, 0.011894226, -0.03463745, -0.0023593903, -0.06573486, 0.015068054, -0.012741089, -0.0061035156, -0.10620117, -0.0023994446, 0.008804321, -0.05886841, -0.007972717, -0.030075073, 0.03173828, 0.01902771, -0.0059127808, -0.06970215, -0.028442383, -0.05795288, 0.033203125, 0.08166504, -0.011360168, 0.005973816, 0.052734375, 0.01776123, 0.029190063, -0.018112183, 0.021148682, 0.074645996, 0.008224487, 0.004760742, 0.009414673, 0.034240723, 0.018737793, -0.008071899, -0.028442383, 0.01449585, 0.014823914, 0.030075073, -0.016189575, -0.041229248, 0.022491455, -0.10852051, 0.011871338, 0.007904053, 0.008842468, 0.012969971, -0.015640259, -0.03314209, 0.046569824, -0.016220093, 0.003578186, 0.02204895, 0.0036525726, 0.012763977, -0.0037937164, -0.006904602, -0.011558533, -0.015357971, -0.028457642, 0.06237793, 0.037719727, -0.07739258, -0.04611206, 0.0066375732, 0.112854004, -0.00983429, -0.02545166, 0.032928467, 0.08093262, -0.011802673, -0.0033092499, 0.008018494, -0.018310547, 0.019821167, -0.027816772, 0.033813477, -0.019241333, -0.04748535, -0.0021438599, -0.042907715, 0.030639648, -0.023895264, -0.050109863, -0.039215088, -0.01146698, -0.0011014938, 0.04373169, -0.007572174, -0.01687622, -0.032043457, -0.056762695, -0.028320312, 0.0029182434, -0.010765076, 0.011993408, 0.0006747246, 0.024337769, 0.0012226105, 0.012504578, 0.015525818, 0.022399902, 0.04550171, -0.01687622, -0.011016846, -0.009727478, -0.04437256, 0.009490967, 0.0013160706, 0.062347412, -0.041046143, 0.036376953, -0.02810669, -0.010604858, 0.029190063, -0.023910522, -0.021270752, -0.007686615, -0.023803711, -0.061035156, 0.061340332, 0.05380249, -0.025299072, -0.08856201, -0.012832642, 0.02192688, 0.022644043, -0.024765015, -0.015289307, 0.01878357, -0.04006958, -0.035339355, 0.011146545, -0.03237915, 0.006313324, -0.05267334, 0.020004272, 0.0030651093, -0.014175415, -0.017242432, -0.002998352, 0.035461426, -0.024353027, -0.08111572, 0.018341064, -0.013961792, -0.0055503845, 0.03930664, 0.01474762, 0.031921387, 0.0004427433, 0.0050621033, 0.0043296814, -0.042266846, 0.04800415, -0.05596924, -0.022354126, -0.0028362274, -0.012199402, -0.02720642, 0.060272217, 0.006401062, -0.011703491, 0.00049495697, 0.042175293, 0.061920166, -0.043548584, -0.0049858093, 0.074157715, -0.022628784, -0.044769287, -0.0029621124, -0.00078582764, -0.071777344, 0.017150879, 0.019760132, -0.027328491, 0.053527832, 0.004714966, 0.015991211, -0.036102295, 0.0073509216, 0.08673096, 0.021652222, -0.012619019, -0.029327393, -0.019470215, 0.06085205, 0.0072517395, 0.0040740967, 0.023345947, 0.010627747, -0.032348633, 0.009216309, -0.03326416, -0.017364502, -0.03515625, -0.024734497, 0.028579712, 0.037902832, -0.033050537, -0.012512207, -0.0075798035, 0.07318115, -0.009475708, 0.015129089, -0.015014648, -0.0034923553, 0.01159668, 0.040618896, -0.052215576, -0.05581665, -0.04159546, -0.02229309, -0.028060913, -0.00020229816, 0.014770508, -0.015289307, -0.011543274, 0.008987427, 0.034820557, 0.019042969, 0.029937744, -0.017456055, -0.0012378693, 0.013938904, 0.029144287, 0.050109863, -0.0005092621, 0.010681152, 0.015525818, 0.03074646, 0.015144348, 0.011444092, 0.020263672, -0.028060913, -0.027374268, -0.10687256, 0.010345459, 0.007965088, 0.007347107, 0.08679199, 0.03326416, 0.027679443, 0.059295654, 0.019836426, 0.014526367, 0.003932953, -0.078186035, -0.015014648, 0.060302734, 0.026290894, 0.0062789917, 0.010261536, -0.003004074, -0.022476196, -0.0023994446, 0.012290955, -0.0066833496, -0.0066490173, -0.011146545, 0.028503418, 0.029159546, -0.019180298, 0.018234253, -0.010055542, -0.020126343, 0.014511108, 0.016601562, 0.0025043488, -0.011734009, 0.04055786, 0.01159668, -0.019348145, 0.025390625, -0.018096924, -0.036254883, -0.034332275, -0.0013208389, 0.059936523, -0.033233643, -0.017181396, -0.06616211, -0.07220459, 0.007537842, -0.0032482147, -0.02935791, -0.0020446777, 0.028274536, -0.017456055, -0.014045715, 0.012565613, -0.020965576, -0.026733398, -0.025253296, -0.017181396, 0.0063095093, -0.018234253, -0.001405716, -0.038513184, -0.01889038, 0.016784668, 0.012535095, -0.04611206, -0.0713501, -0.011726379, 0.011230469, -0.017715454, 0.06439209, -0.007221222, -0.0048561096, 0.015312195, 0.0002168417, 0.004310608, -0.01184082, -0.049682617, 0.0053138733, -0.0043563843, 0.04147339, 0.01285553, -0.027633667, 0.011054993, -0.024551392, -0.0025119781, 0.00096559525, -0.040130615, -0.003293991, -0.04043579, 0.017959595, 0.047821045, -0.009002686, -0.024627686, 0.02230835, 0.021530151, 0.013961792, -0.0027923584, 0.02078247, -0.021972656, -0.024719238, 0.0115737915, 0.004611969, -0.017684937, -0.04107666, -0.028167725, 0.0067710876, 0.0181427, 0.033111572, 0.0054626465, -0.03717041, -0.0026111603, -0.03375244, 0.041168213, -0.04510498, 0.0020942688, -0.003982544, 0.022216797, -0.0066986084, -0.016525269, -0.027862549, -0.01663208, 0.0206604, 0.03414917, 0.030029297, 0.006175995, -0.017288208, 0.003704071, 0.046295166, -0.022140503, 0.029724121, 0.0061836243, -0.036254883, -0.012573242, -0.0009889603, 0.015205383, 0.00038266182, 0.06347656, -0.02178955, -0.0054130554, 0.030258179, -0.04925537, 0.024246216, 0.0052452087, -0.004627228, 0.030303955, -0.022720337, 0.014724731, 0.028686523, 0.0009584427, 0.02848816, 0.03842163, 0.01676941, 0.02142334, 0.037231445, 0.02230835, 0.049041748, -0.014411926, -0.03857422, -0.005077362, 0.00548172, -0.030273438, 0.015548706, 0.06262207, -0.01828003, -0.026153564, -0.06878662, 0.001291275, -0.002828598, 0.03817749, 0.034423828, 0.05810547, -0.011787415, 0.0075187683, -0.019165039, -0.0015859604, -0.022354126, 0.016983032, -0.034454346, -0.020446777, 0.03100586, -0.0049705505, 0.025848389, -0.022232056, -0.025482178, -0.017623901, 0.009628296, 0.0021247864, -0.006668091, 0.006259918, -0.04458618, 0.032714844, 0.010070801, 0.07293701, -0.030044556, 0.025131226, 0.0058517456, 0.042022705, -0.0053138733, 0.039001465, 0.025543213, -0.0019388199, -0.023986816, 0.012176514, 0.062408447, -0.0262146, 0.032928467, -0.038909912, -0.01612854, -0.061065674, -0.024612427, -0.054779053, 0.035736084, -0.010986328, 0.00434494, 0.010017395, 0.008277893, -0.026306152, 0.03375244, -0.016311646, 0.043273926, 0.014572144, 0.06604004, 0.020843506, -0.0018625259, 0.000749588, -0.032714844, 0.019210815, 0.009475708, 0.013053894, -0.007194519, -0.022125244, 0.038635254, -0.010047913, -0.001750946, -0.03677368, 0.0135650635, -0.028213501, 0.035614014, 0.017410278, 0.06561279, 0.016433716, -0.021270752, 0.042053223, -0.025634766, -0.026184082, 0.021469116, -0.019180298, 0.010551453, 0.029327393, 0.0042800903, -0.0184021, -0.03378296, -0.011428833, -0.01335907, -0.0078125, 0.051757812, -0.03741455, 0.008087158, -0.0044555664, 0.024093628, -0.012672424, 0.01461792, -0.022766113, -0.017028809, 0.0072250366, 0.012428284, -0.00434494, -0.0065689087, -0.020080566, 0.030578613, 0.012435913, 0.023284912, -0.026992798, 0.009147644, -0.03390503, 0.023254395, -0.011581421, 0.038726807, 0.048980713, -0.013076782, 0.002483368, 0.047332764, -0.054382324, 0.04776001, -0.016021729, 0.11114502, 0.09649658, 0.0703125, -0.035583496, 0.01361084, 0.12561035, -0.02130127, 0.025787354, 0.039245605, 0.014823914, 0.019836426, -0.007801056, -0.0057792664, 0.025650024, -0.016662598, 0.008110046, -0.050933838, 0.012039185, -0.03237915, -0.0074157715, -0.027038574, -0.020980835, -0.0051498413, -0.039886475, -0.004875183, 0.012634277, 0.02104187, -0.008857727, -0.014785767, -0.015609741, 0.023269653, 0.012001038, -0.046844482, -0.03967285, 0.024047852, 0.028030396, -0.0345459, -0.04385376, 0.022979736, -0.00605011, -0.016540527, 0.05596924, 0.016571045, -0.015823364, -0.08984375, -0.040283203, -0.0010623932, 0.0769043, -0.047729492, 0.02420044, 0.021087646, -0.016983032, -0.041931152, -0.007270813, 0.0073776245, -0.02520752, 0.044769287, 0.005218506, -0.043548584, -0.025390625, 0.027694702, -0.044525146, 0.055267334, 0.024765015, 0.0044174194, 0.00472641, 0.032928467, -0.03152466, -0.058044434, -0.025619507, -0.03265381, 0.034484863, -0.032165527, 0.0104522705, -0.0008292198, 0.00548172, -0.03390503, 0.025558472, 0.021224976, 0.052337646, 0.013015747, -0.033050537, 0.017028809, -0.025146484, -0.013725281, -0.007167816, -0.007183075, -0.007965088, 0.010795593, -0.023651123, 0.008056641, -0.01890564, -0.018600464, -0.0071525574, 0.019561768, -0.01776123, -0.015823364, 0.041992188, -0.033569336, -0.012069702, 0.01625061, 0.00028276443, -0.03152466, 0.0069007874, 0.053344727, -0.01739502, -0.008934021, -0.030303955, -0.0011386871, -0.033966064, -0.03366089, 0.02229309, -0.006034851, 0.0029182434, -0.0022239685, 0.0011816025, 0.016326904, -0.0053863525, -0.0063552856, 0.015625, 0.035949707, -0.009994507, -0.016571045, -0.024230957, -0.001332283, -0.01928711, -0.04196167, 0.025863647, -0.03225708, -0.005176544, -0.009475708, 0.0061683655, -0.050964355, 0.02760315, 0.00844574, -0.04663086, 0.01991272, -0.020217896, -0.015029907, 0.026733398, -0.03186035, -0.018066406, -0.035186768, -0.004016876 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2009.06602v3
VacSIM: Learning Effective Strategies for COVID-19 Vaccine Distribution using Reinforcement Learning
Raghav Awasthi, Keerat Kaur Guliani, Saif Ahmad Khan, Aniket Vashishtha, Mehrab Singh Gill, Arshita Bhatt, Aditya Nagori, Aniket Gupta, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru, Tavpritesh Sethi
cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
A COVID-19 vaccine is our best bet for mitigating the ongoing onslaught of the pandemic. However, vaccine is also expected to be a limited resource. An optimal allocation strategy, especially in countries with access inequities and temporal separation of hot-spots, might be an effective way of halting the disease spread. We approach this problem by proposing a novel pipeline VacSIM that dovetails Deep Reinforcement Learning models into a Contextual Bandits approach for optimizing the distribution of COVID-19 vaccine. Whereas the Reinforcement Learning models suggest better actions and rewards, Contextual Bandits allow online modifications that may need to be implemented on a day-to-day basis in the real world scenario. We evaluate this framework against a naive allocation approach of distributing vaccine proportional to the incidence of COVID-19 cases in five different States across India (Assam, Delhi, Jharkhand, Maharashtra and Nagaland) and demonstrate up to 9039 potential infections prevented and a significant increase in the efficacy of limiting the spread over a period of 45 days through the VacSIM approach. Our models and the platform are extensible to all states of India and potentially across the globe. We also propose novel evaluation strategies including standard compartmental model-based projections and a causality-preserving evaluation of our model. Since all models carry assumptions that may need to be tested in various contexts, we open source our model VacSIM and contribute a new reinforcement learning environment compatible with OpenAI gym to make it extensible for real-world applications across the globe. (http://vacsim.tavlab.iiitd.edu.in:8000/).
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2009.06602v3
"2021-12-04T14:05:24"
"2020-09-14T17:37:13"
{ "title": [ 0.01838684, -0.0060577393, -0.031234741, -0.02746582, 0.00051116943, -0.025543213, 0.0052452087, -0.008857727, -0.062438965, 0.017745972, -0.011558533, 0.02760315, -0.015533447, -0.046447754, 0.023452759, -0.031143188, 0.0024032593, 0.033477783, -0.0042381287, -0.029769897, -0.007659912, -0.046875, -0.00039601326, 0.06021118, -0.0107421875, 0.0007843971, -0.0725708, -0.037261963, -0.03378296, -0.05645752, -0.028167725, 0.07281494, 0.038024902, -0.031341553, 0.005168915, 0.027374268, -0.049621582, 0.005874634, -0.013999939, -0.006362915, -0.001420021, -0.0025691986, -0.0010995865, -0.044281006, -0.006324768, 0.015594482, -0.037841797, -0.024673462, 0.003774643, 0.06451416, 0.018112183, 0.00566864, 0.021560669, 0.050628662, 0.0018091202, -0.043914795, -0.02670288, -0.008674622, 0.036193848, -0.0023555756, -0.02859497, -0.045196533, 0.04675293, -0.030670166, -0.02368164, -0.020996094, -0.026000977, 0.0025558472, 0.03274536, -0.0051231384, 0.00459671, 0.021636963, 0.0046539307, 0.05557251, -0.062805176, -0.085632324, 0.050628662, 0.0021400452, 0.031341553, 0.0073509216, -0.004512787, -0.015220642, 0.025665283, -0.036834717, -0.009819031, -0.03515625, -0.005821228, 0.01058197, -0.019226074, -0.012878418, -0.01537323, 0.044128418, -0.017959595, 0.019332886, -0.03173828, 0.00037240982, 0.031082153, 0.080444336, 0.003921509, -0.02696228, -0.066345215, 0.023773193, -0.09411621, -0.01676941, 0.004589081, 0.054107666, 0.025558472, 0.033355713, 0.0009994507, -0.0052261353, -0.013832092, -0.006412506, 0.016479492, -0.018341064, -0.0053520203, 0.0007481575, 0.0054740906, 0.020095825, 0.007835388, 0.0038051605, 0.009841919, 0.0057678223, 0.02230835, 0.015220642, 0.025360107, 0.034118652, -0.02166748, -0.016799927, -0.004245758, 0.047088623, -0.016921997, 0.041259766, -0.06072998, -0.0713501, -0.05633545, -0.008399963, 0.0039405823, 0.019821167, 0.0006709099, -0.00065374374, 0.011528015, -0.009712219, 0.022766113, 0.015411377, -0.0027751923, 0.01737976, 0.03805542, 0.0037250519, -0.019943237, -0.021148682, -0.059143066, 0.027526855, -0.012664795, 0.01424408, -0.023742676, 0.044036865, -0.07434082, 0.035614014, 0.009986877, 0.035186768, 0.0625, 0.021591187, -0.003955841, 0.041900635, 0.027694702, -0.038360596, -0.03515625, 0.0022449493, 0.01625061, 0.06262207, -0.006389618, -0.013832092, 0.000121474266, -0.030914307, -0.011360168, -0.0054740906, -0.014175415, 0.030792236, 0.014793396, -0.024902344, -0.008201599, -0.04144287, -0.0059776306, 0.044158936, 0.01739502, -0.0692749, 0.008987427, -0.02281189, 0.024230957, 0.02293396, -0.0501709, -0.011390686, -0.046142578, -0.030151367, -0.052764893, 0.024398804, 0.03060913, 0.053588867, -0.007965088, -0.0019950867, -0.044036865, -0.0009889603, -0.0107803345, 0.03918457, 0.02104187, -0.036987305, 0.018051147, 0.0029067993, -0.044433594, 0.051513672, 0.039855957, 0.023361206, -0.03479004, -0.040496826, 0.023391724, -0.031082153, 0.011100769, -0.015571594, -0.04257202, -0.015205383, -0.0569458, -0.013710022, -0.05126953, 0.032928467, 0.032714844, 0.0072746277, 0.0018796921, -0.0075531006, 0.08929443, -0.0007901192, 0.111694336, -0.008049011, 0.0071640015, 0.0051841736, -0.02986145, -0.023117065, 0.00008106232, -0.03353882, 0.030456543, 0.042266846, 0.012390137, -0.024215698, -0.00018942356, 0.017532349, 0.048431396, 0.021530151, 0.027664185, -0.0024719238, -0.00040483475, 0.016311646, 0.05441284, 0.017486572, 0.03866577, 0.03161621, -0.017211914, 0.053344727, -0.030517578, 0.008956909, -0.050079346, 0.03186035, -0.013969421, 0.01272583, 0.05303955, -0.03250122, -0.063964844, -0.024291992, -0.024642944, -0.002292633, 0.021469116, -0.031066895, 0.03375244, -0.035125732, -0.016479492, 0.024871826, 0.023101807, -0.035827637, -0.029953003, 0.011985779, -0.0036354065, -0.017242432, 0.018615723, 0.034118652, 0.05569458, -0.012969971, 0.029388428, 0.027267456, 0.00831604, -0.01525116, -0.05105591, -0.055389404, 0.013687134, -0.008293152, -0.03250122, -0.009101868, 0.025894165, -0.03527832, 0.038970947, 0.0949707, -0.029541016, 0.01977539, -0.08807373, -0.009597778, -0.016204834, -0.025497437, 0.011161804, 0.026123047, 0.00894928, -0.009773254, -0.015327454, -0.011177063, -0.03842163, 0.005302429, 0.0052337646, -0.009391785, 0.010551453, -0.03579712, -0.006664276, 0.015541077, -0.05239868, -0.006790161, 0.034454346, 0.03060913, -0.004650116, -0.021850586, 0.019683838, -0.029327393, -0.039855957, -0.018127441, 0.008140564, 0.014801025, 0.006706238, 0.0044784546, -0.0748291, 0.022506714, 0.011764526, 0.0519104, -0.0021343231, 0.014297485, -0.017074585, -0.059631348, -0.016189575, -0.0039367676, -0.0058135986, -0.02027893, 0.0015735626, -0.0284729, -0.027908325, 0.018508911, 0.036895752, -0.007980347, -0.0009198189, 0.0052223206, -0.0062294006, -0.007446289, 0.046661377, -0.025756836, -0.006385803, 0.015716553, 0.028045654, -0.01739502, 0.05618286, 0.02482605, 0.026748657, -0.08544922, -0.025726318, -0.058044434, -0.000787735, -0.042633057, -0.022125244, -0.010917664, -0.058166504, -0.021987915, 0.00008326769, 0.00016498566, 0.015449524, 0.040618896, -0.0103302, -0.03390503, 0.022338867, -0.008323669, 0.008102417, 0.020889282, -0.0017700195, 0.006416321, 0.062561035, 0.00491333, -0.004421234, 0.0012578964, 0.032836914, -0.01360321, 0.0028839111, -0.006137848, -0.037841797, 0.013595581, 0.01020813, 0.008422852, -0.019363403, -0.011871338, -0.10406494, 0.014022827, 0.011024475, -0.0064468384, -0.02104187, 0.010520935, -0.018447876, 0.024505615, 0.008033752, -0.024658203, 0.024765015, 0.021133423, 0.012458801, -0.009292603, 0.035247803, -0.034942627, 0.010040283, -0.02015686, -0.012428284, 0.014923096, -0.03878784, -0.019866943, 0.04168701, -0.037841797, -0.01902771, -0.014801025, -0.015670776, 0.014572144, 0.032348633, 0.039855957, -0.011123657, -0.015007019, 0.012542725, -0.05117798, -0.0005412102, -0.055389404, -0.021896362, -0.01071167, -0.017166138, 0.041809082, -0.0011749268, 0.032409668, -0.09375, -0.012290955, -0.0018930435, -0.011192322, 0.031188965, -0.041137695, -0.02696228, -0.06793213, -0.014755249, -0.01448822, -0.03567505, 0.00497818, -0.01878357, 0.02671814, -0.026000977, 0.07019043, 0.016601562, 0.03414917, 0.04296875, -0.03741455, -0.016921997, -0.029907227, -0.048034668, 0.015625, -0.016677856, -0.008712769, 0.03527832, 0.022781372, -0.015464783, -0.013771057, -0.010673523, 0.045776367, 0.010246277, -0.0027179718, -0.03579712, -0.05117798, 0.019042969, 0.04434204, -0.011856079, -0.041748047, 0.007949829, 0.0031604767, -0.015640259, -0.016799927, -0.014076233, 0.011642456, -0.06890869, -0.039978027, -0.019744873, -0.02381897, -0.045166016, -0.01586914, 0.007610321, -0.04257202, -0.049743652, 0.011436462, 0.0030059814, -0.00623703, 0.024902344, -0.0152282715, -0.0703125, 0.02407837, 0.0012588501, -0.034179688, 0.026046753, -0.01612854, 0.011711121, 0.023956299, 0.04333496, 0.045135498, 0.03451538, 0.0062408447, 0.032684326, 0.032165527, -0.017456055, -0.0068969727, 0.04309082, 0.046325684, -0.02003479, 0.010734558, 0.052581787, 0.039489746, -0.046783447, 0.023971558, 0.07879639, -0.012771606, -0.07861328, 0.0046806335, -0.0069351196, -0.05709839, -0.018081665, 0.0048599243, -0.017578125, 0.037384033, 0.032440186, 0.050323486, -0.028167725, -0.023590088, -0.019836426, 0.02822876, -0.047790527, -0.05316162, 0.019180298, 0.03643799, 0.0024757385, -0.015670776, -0.010513306, 0.021011353, -0.011680603, -0.0041389465, -0.009719849, 0.010070801, -0.060791016, -0.025558472, -0.04751587, -0.0016813278, -0.018753052, 0.0146865845, -0.016189575, 0.006038666, 0.0440979, 0.014167786, -0.037017822, -0.03604126, -0.022949219, 0.0071792603, -0.027175903, -0.064453125, -0.03439331, -0.004257202, -0.085998535, -0.04333496, -0.053588867, -0.023071289, -0.02798462, -0.0053596497, -0.0023288727, 0.016906738, 0.04083252, 0.062805176, 0.027862549, -0.005771637, -0.036254883, -0.014602661, -0.0021572113, -0.015792847, -0.006126404, -0.003314972, -0.0068130493, -0.03237915, -0.021270752, 0.011001587, -0.050445557, -0.054016113, 0.013305664, 0.0050582886, 0.020324707, 0.07940674, 0.08111572, 0.036712646, 0.00077819824, 0.031433105, 0.007247925, -0.023162842, -0.026184082, 0.05328369, 0.03475952, 0.009277344, -0.021194458, 0.023452759, 0.019058228, 0.009681702, 0.006023407, -0.014320374, 0.00422287, 0.020629883, 0.0022392273, 0.047424316, 0.008865356, -0.0047035217, 0.023162842, 0.0073051453, 0.022750854, -0.025985718, 0.047668457, 0.014305115, -0.0362854, 0.039276123, 0.005847931, -0.030853271, 0.015853882, -0.022842407, -0.035247803, -0.06008911, -0.002298355, 0.0513916, -0.0181427, -0.025543213, -0.027511597, 0.0036830902, 0.032836914, 0.02897644, -0.007545471, -0.0491333, -0.00957489, 0.0019836426, -0.018234253, -0.033935547, -0.043640137, -0.025512695, -0.010650635, 0.01625061, -0.0030994415, 0.020507812, 0.0013856888, -0.019165039, -0.004753113, -0.0006942749, 0.042175293, -0.038848877, 0.010406494, 0.076049805, -0.020385742, 0.0059776306, 0.00052404404, 0.0042800903, 0.016937256, 0.018417358, 0.0040626526, -0.012954712, 0.016586304, -0.072509766, 0.020401001, 0.003932953, 0.010757446, 0.0009946823, 0.019729614, -0.013824463, 0.00078344345, -0.018539429, 0.029800415, -0.011734009, -0.027313232, 0.006095886, -0.01802063, 0.027420044, -0.014007568, 0.006263733, -0.010147095, -0.04345703, -0.0032920837, 0.040618896, -0.051208496, -0.009399414, 0.0023460388, -0.03930664, -0.03665161, -0.026245117, 0.042144775, -0.025009155, -0.0053520203, -0.009338379, -0.0044555664, -0.037322998, 0.018569946, 0.0019006729, -0.057617188, -0.0018424988, 0.020645142, 0.020523071, 0.024124146, -0.0016202927, -0.07312012, -0.025115967, 0.003686905, -0.043182373, -0.02658081, 0.011940002, 0.014266968, -0.019546509, -0.0063209534, -0.017211914, 0.0022602081, 0.007282257, 0.029174805, 0.019485474, -0.04849243, 0.01701355, -0.01713562, -0.016708374, 0.03161621, 0.025726318, -0.052978516, 0.02305603, 0.031585693, 0.011940002, 0.042541504, -0.0061569214, 0.00007933378, 0.019317627, -0.020889282, 0.0050964355, 0.028686523, -0.016937256, 0.0027332306, 0.053131104, 0.030441284, -0.010269165, 0.024337769, 0.03765869, 0.070007324, -0.053222656, -0.004501343, -0.029083252, -0.024658203, -0.066345215, 0.029632568, 0.037139893, 0.011062622, -0.038330078, -0.02796936, -0.017807007, 0.004295349, 0.025726318, -0.0021266937, 0.019439697, -0.039764404, -0.006828308, -0.02319336, 0.021240234, 0.00819397, 0.039123535, 0.0010652542, 0.028030396, -0.051483154, 0.001332283, 0.00015354156, 0.009475708, 0.019866943, 0.0052452087, -0.021606445, 0.021987915, -0.013442993, 0.009185791, -0.023223877, -0.010673523, 0.055755615, 0.00037932396, -0.019973755, 0.029037476, -0.0010108948, 0.053527832, 0.010513306, 0.047729492, 0.04736328, 0.048828125, 0.03857422, 0.011146545, 0.04522705, -0.005882263, 0.066711426, -0.047668457, -0.0051498413, -0.06451416, -0.043151855, -0.11450195, 0.0073013306, 0.005393982, 0.0181427, 0.007633209, 0.008018494, 0.00566864, 0.009056091, 0.020721436, 0.008728027, 0.039794922, -0.0052223206, -0.017929077, -0.0127334595, 0.047546387, 0.0050735474, 0.009597778, 0.026428223, 0.04147339, 0.031921387, 0.01777649, 0.03149414, -0.011161804, -0.011260986, -0.06982422, 0.024734497, -0.027908325, 0.039276123, 0.00038576126, 0.0008177757, 0.07141113, 0.06414795, -0.04901123, -0.01007843, 0.041656494, 0.0093307495, -0.05255127, 0.043151855, 0.054718018, -0.05038452, 0.04232788, -0.021026611, -0.044555664, 0.007789612, 0.043304443, 0.028671265, -0.03845215, 0.0037555695, -0.0033473969, 0.006160736, -0.003332138, 0.013900757, -0.049865723, -0.054351807, -0.003583908, 0.022384644, -0.024429321, 0.02519226, 0.03845215, 0.020339966, -0.017044067, -0.004459381, -0.0043258667, 0.01235199, -0.0077552795, 0.021026611, -0.016998291, 0.052246094, 0.019088745, -0.034729004, 0.051635742, -0.00009173155, -0.018112183, 0.023727417, -0.006904602, 0.024368286, -0.010566711, 0.042022705, 0.00001603365, -0.00969696, -0.017105103, -0.008399963, -0.006454468, 0.029891968, -0.011154175, 0.039642334, -0.032287598, -0.024154663, 0.058258057, -0.016433716, 0.07110596, -0.024841309, -0.011672974, -0.027435303, 0.010375977, 0.019485474, -0.03112793, -0.045562744, -0.031188965, 0.023010254, -0.003288269, 0.016647339, -0.025283813, -0.019561768, 0.0022296906, 0.0546875, 0.014091492, -0.0034751892, 0.02986145, -0.025939941, -0.010848999, -0.00022649765, -0.00856781, 0.042144775, -0.013465881, -0.016174316, -0.012329102, 0.010940552, 0.015411377, -0.03616333, -0.043304443, 0.015045166, 0.0050468445, -0.009101868, 0.0074005127, 0.010650635, -0.017242432, -0.059783936, 0.0395813, -0.011817932, -0.029754639, -0.045806885, 0.04348755, 0.028579712, -0.10003662, -0.03491211, -0.033081055, 0.004196167, 0.0046844482, -0.020706177, 0.038024902, -0.0051612854, 0.008026123, 0.005279541, 0.0065345764, 0.024490356, -0.032928467, -0.003610611, -0.00038814545, 0.0118637085, 0.04849243, -0.034057617, -0.055999756, -0.030792236, 0.031829834, -0.018875122, 0.025466919, -0.00466156, 0.020385742, 0.0010070801, 0.07141113, 0.0037212372, -0.047058105, -0.020996094, -0.0031528473, 0.06518555, -0.00006759167, -0.039398193, 0.009971619, 0.011512756, -0.03567505, 0.01285553, 0.012619019, 0.009429932, 0.020843506, 0.0022678375, 0.058654785, -0.015052795, -0.023788452, -0.025238037, 0.06726074, -0.024246216, 0.019180298, 0.005382538, 0.020858765, 0.022567749, 0.028289795, -0.023330688, -0.04675293, 0.040039062, 0.060516357, 0.00037145615, 0.06915283, -0.031402588, -0.011398315, 0.0059394836, 0.004650116, -0.0061149597, 0.012207031, 0.0037708282, -0.013259888, -0.0028438568, -0.00060510635, -0.049194336, -0.01285553, -0.032348633, 0.039093018, -0.05178833, 0.009178162, 0.00060272217, -0.03100586, 0.014465332, 0.037261963, 0.047729492, 0.0053749084, -0.029006958, -0.028442383, 0.018371582, -0.008544922 ], "summary": [ 0.030761719, -0.007381439, 0.0289917, -0.04244995, -0.030029297, 0.008895874, -0.03643799, -0.031433105, -0.046875, -0.0054359436, -0.026824951, 0.042541504, -0.060272217, -0.029159546, 0.048950195, -0.04232788, -0.0028629303, 0.02960205, -0.0026779175, -0.043273926, 0.027832031, -0.06262207, 0.0032730103, 0.06341553, -0.02734375, -0.017791748, -0.064086914, 0.023361206, -0.040649414, -0.0043945312, -0.015586853, 0.045318604, 0.052093506, -0.07232666, 0.031021118, -0.0007414818, -0.03768921, -0.01751709, -0.022750854, -0.0006570816, 0.026107788, -0.014137268, 0.056732178, -0.046081543, 0.014389038, 0.042663574, 0.010238647, -0.036132812, 0.041748047, 0.06378174, 0.045074463, 0.019760132, 0.0209198, 0.017974854, 0.0026340485, 0.0007967949, -0.03591919, -0.031341553, 0.028076172, 0.030883789, -0.012184143, -0.026519775, -0.00047969818, -0.04046631, -0.0073509216, -0.004749298, -0.0041656494, 0.0069503784, 0.0017642975, -0.021438599, 0.01235199, 0.008110046, -0.0021648407, -0.0066452026, -0.039642334, -0.024246216, 0.03137207, -0.033996582, 0.008712769, 0.0057525635, -0.006690979, 0.014961243, 0.017868042, -0.04421997, -0.016647339, -0.03253174, -0.019470215, -0.00041389465, -0.026947021, -0.0015630722, -0.035125732, -0.008079529, -0.014877319, 0.009101868, 0.0021705627, -0.008293152, 0.010040283, 0.029846191, -0.0071640015, -0.00381279, 0.0024967194, -0.035888672, -0.006855011, -0.017822266, -0.02279663, 0.07196045, 0.038726807, -0.018600464, -0.05441284, -0.016357422, -0.014663696, -0.07733154, 0.0137786865, -0.0037078857, -0.031311035, -0.013015747, -0.0026073456, 0.002811432, -0.010231018, -0.004020691, -0.017745972, 0.02368164, 0.018951416, -0.021209717, 0.028503418, 0.024642944, -0.0043258667, -0.015197754, 0.02017212, 0.056152344, -0.028533936, -0.011230469, -0.004447937, -0.004585266, -0.026977539, -0.037384033, -0.009147644, 0.020980835, 0.0012454987, 0.008552551, -0.013244629, -0.0028934479, 0.03668213, -0.012237549, 0.0027256012, 0.010017395, 0.025360107, 0.011123657, -0.012252808, -0.017028809, -0.0357666, 0.05496216, 0.02609253, 0.0070724487, -0.033355713, 0.008384705, -0.025115967, 0.004886627, -0.02217102, 0.0014734268, 0.055633545, 0.026321411, 0.005706787, 0.041290283, 0.04171753, -0.051239014, -0.022705078, -0.0018463135, 0.022476196, 0.03793335, 0.008598328, 0.019180298, 0.013710022, 0.018569946, 0.009223938, -0.0107421875, -0.041137695, 0.010559082, 0.044799805, -0.07720947, -0.027267456, -0.0178833, 0.008361816, 0.054840088, 0.005332947, -0.068237305, 0.0056991577, 0.0042037964, 0.053894043, 0.0231781, -0.03201294, -0.0625, 0.013961792, 0.0002951622, -0.026123047, -0.0113220215, 0.030197144, 0.04498291, -0.019683838, -0.024673462, 0.03302002, -0.049987793, 0.010147095, -0.0026836395, -0.005302429, -0.063964844, 0.013000488, -0.014884949, -0.044647217, 0.010437012, 0.01878357, -0.023223877, -0.028335571, 0.0015640259, 0.03062439, 0.0006184578, 0.012191772, -0.006374359, 0.008155823, 0.005882263, 0.02053833, 0.017684937, -0.026367188, 0.019699097, 0.028640747, -0.033294678, 0.003704071, -0.022140503, 0.06762695, -0.011619568, 0.062316895, 0.0030002594, -0.040130615, -0.027633667, -0.021011353, -0.0071754456, 0.017715454, -0.05908203, 0.023773193, 0.03778076, -0.0052375793, 0.02619934, -0.039276123, 0.0005545616, 0.013389587, 0.009017944, 0.0132369995, -0.013145447, -0.039916992, -0.020858765, 0.03869629, -0.014022827, 0.02861023, -0.0018644333, -0.032440186, 0.03503418, -0.060943604, -0.003440857, -0.0030574799, -0.0031604767, -0.003118515, 0.016036987, 0.041900635, -0.022872925, -0.08111572, -0.070373535, -0.042236328, -0.045288086, 0.050842285, -0.09301758, 0.0146102905, -0.035247803, -0.014411926, -0.013160706, 0.013442993, -0.016677856, -0.02798462, 0.015258789, 0.0132369995, -0.030166626, 0.028030396, 0.035064697, 0.035705566, -0.0077781677, 0.051605225, 0.00086164474, -0.012290955, 0.0015277863, -0.009223938, -0.037475586, 0.0031604767, 0.0016002655, -0.0155181885, 0.011878967, 0.010887146, -0.058044434, -0.014533997, 0.0592041, -0.0069351196, 0.025909424, -0.026550293, 0.017028809, -0.024093628, -0.00074768066, -0.013465881, 0.030715942, -0.009124756, 0.014831543, 0.0014972687, -0.024383545, 0.00004041195, 0.0028572083, 0.011581421, -0.005706787, 0.015945435, -0.013397217, -0.0064926147, 0.018585205, -0.040222168, -0.02053833, 0.07507324, 0.014945984, 0.027542114, -0.019226074, 0.02619934, -0.06365967, -0.013687134, -0.016052246, -0.010978699, 0.014221191, 0.00072336197, -0.0062065125, -0.04562378, 0.030136108, 0.012481689, 0.031921387, 0.013061523, 0.001613617, 0.00522995, -0.012077332, 0.040222168, 0.0027446747, -0.011482239, -0.0056610107, -0.0025482178, -0.02218628, -0.017456055, 0.0049438477, 0.03074646, -0.00121212, -0.0135650635, 0.0070648193, -0.0027332306, -0.0012159348, 0.0024967194, 0.030334473, 0.006198883, -0.010101318, 0.0027980804, -0.029541016, 0.08630371, 0.03050232, 0.051940918, -0.10614014, -0.026245117, -0.06915283, 0.026367188, -0.05883789, -0.02178955, 0.024093628, -0.039123535, 0.004055023, -0.029663086, -0.014022827, -0.0079422, 0.03048706, 0.061035156, 0.007698059, 0.00970459, 0.041259766, 0.015930176, 0.032196045, -0.0017471313, 0.004234314, 0.08862305, 0.017837524, 0.048858643, -0.005153656, 0.07635498, -0.009132385, 0.024795532, -0.027816772, 0.0030441284, -0.0010213852, -0.0057373047, 0.0061454773, -0.022598267, 0.016571045, -0.056732178, -0.002735138, 0.044769287, 0.009384155, -0.016860962, 0.023864746, 0.0034770966, 0.009643555, 0.051086426, -0.02558899, 0.0104599, -0.015930176, 0.018112183, -0.031280518, 0.00422287, -0.047851562, 0.008331299, -0.0362854, 0.042541504, -0.0054016113, 0.017044067, -0.01083374, 0.008361816, -0.008781433, -0.043670654, -0.00019979477, -0.00466156, -0.023757935, 0.017211914, 0.022903442, -0.014038086, -0.008346558, -0.0076293945, -0.031158447, 0.0040016174, -0.03363037, 0.0062675476, -0.0048561096, -0.006816864, 0.023132324, -0.015022278, -0.013916016, -0.0758667, -0.027236938, -0.00843811, -0.009613037, 0.026992798, -0.025604248, -0.014907837, -0.06378174, -0.004837036, 0.0072288513, -0.029525757, 0.0012187958, 0.01360321, 0.045959473, -0.017669678, 0.06982422, 0.009941101, 0.024017334, 0.09063721, -0.033050537, -0.029891968, -0.016159058, -0.0395813, 0.014762878, 0.015853882, 0.027389526, -0.046691895, 0.033843994, -0.0069122314, -0.02130127, 0.043426514, -0.001405716, -0.006248474, -0.0010633469, -0.030639648, -0.06311035, 0.04714966, 0.044525146, -0.010307312, -0.059509277, -0.026901245, 0.016799927, -0.013977051, -0.040985107, 0.002822876, -0.00096035004, -0.042388916, -0.060913086, -0.025665283, 0.022994995, -0.00868988, -0.023162842, 0.00116539, 0.0052108765, -0.047790527, 0.025848389, 0.0070228577, 0.008384705, 0.02255249, -0.0056495667, -0.0670166, 0.015960693, 0.020980835, -0.025466919, -0.028533936, 0.0037288666, 0.05166626, 0.0008049011, 0.020751953, -0.022064209, 0.05230713, -0.022964478, 0.026657104, 0.028320312, -0.026672363, -0.014549255, 0.023910522, 0.041992188, -0.036468506, -0.003545761, 0.065979004, 0.08404541, -0.041107178, 0.013641357, 0.052215576, -0.015716553, -0.064819336, -0.0019931793, 0.009475708, -0.021820068, -0.015625, -0.001285553, -0.041778564, -0.017944336, 0.062316895, -0.014411926, -0.022369385, -0.056610107, -0.013916016, 0.0703125, -0.02619934, -0.029266357, 0.028198242, 0.08026123, 0.0005078316, -0.054901123, -0.053833008, -0.048950195, 0.004573822, -0.00995636, -0.048828125, -0.038085938, 0.002090454, -0.054504395, -0.028884888, 0.053009033, 0.055755615, -0.03111267, -0.013313293, 0.006652832, 0.01322937, 0.007083893, -0.0034942627, -0.016693115, 0.009002686, 0.03427124, -0.0413208, -0.06750488, -0.030258179, -0.007843018, -0.04397583, -0.015304565, -0.055999756, -0.07165527, -0.058654785, -0.011657715, 0.017700195, 0.024719238, 0.044921875, 0.01737976, 0.044281006, -0.030090332, -0.03010559, -0.025131226, -0.01109314, 0.011734009, 0.047729492, -0.0038814545, 0.0090789795, -0.0030460358, -0.021820068, 0.0037937164, -0.04348755, -0.06286621, 0.0077285767, 0.0074310303, 0.021774292, 0.09362793, 0.0814209, 0.025375366, 0.01058197, 0.05404663, 0.019729614, -0.0027008057, -0.06100464, 0.06933594, 0.0135650635, 0.012710571, -0.050598145, 0.0234375, 0.03012085, 0.026397705, 0.01222229, -0.026626587, 0.0038433075, 0.02947998, 0.0018310547, 0.030914307, 0.09100342, -0.016479492, 0.038482666, 0.014259338, -0.010803223, 0.027008057, 0.05630493, 0.006958008, -0.078308105, 0.031463623, 0.0054512024, -0.049316406, 0.006504059, -0.033447266, -0.026824951, -0.079711914, -0.010986328, 0.053894043, 0.02734375, -0.015556335, -0.012931824, -0.003929138, 0.03866577, 0.012817383, 0.011489868, -0.07922363, -0.030776978, 0.00056028366, -0.038238525, -0.011260986, -0.014884949, -0.01751709, -0.0037078857, 0.007320404, 0.010215759, -0.01737976, 0.017547607, -0.017791748, -0.028427124, -0.031341553, 0.039489746, -0.0317688, -0.061523438, 0.026855469, -0.02520752, 0.018539429, 0.019256592, -0.0067710876, 0.017456055, 0.024154663, -0.010215759, 0.0038967133, -0.0032615662, -0.019165039, 0.055541992, -0.0018959045, -0.008483887, -0.021224976, 0.0075263977, -0.025787354, -0.017974854, 0.023590088, 0.0026416779, -0.019851685, 0.011482239, -0.012962341, 0.0016212463, 0.0178833, 0.0051116943, 0.0017414093, -0.0042648315, -0.021575928, 0.0006995201, 0.049743652, -0.006511688, 0.021575928, -0.006565094, -0.0037174225, -0.0034713745, -0.01486969, 0.03817749, -0.03741455, 0.018463135, 0.015686035, -0.020187378, -0.010948181, 0.00019776821, -0.0021038055, -0.057800293, -0.0041122437, 0.019058228, 0.03479004, -0.017196655, -0.010971069, -0.025238037, -0.010353088, -0.026031494, -0.030563354, -0.0309906, -0.00630188, -0.0045700073, 0.027572632, -0.00982666, 0.0034065247, -0.016098022, 0.013153076, 0.045074463, -0.054718018, -0.058288574, -0.00491333, -0.0065193176, -0.042175293, 0.015701294, -0.0039863586, -0.09698486, 0.029556274, 0.041870117, 0.033477783, 0.07287598, -0.014297485, -0.002609253, 0.06311035, -0.0053977966, 0.024002075, 0.022506714, -0.021270752, 0.009941101, 0.0046424866, 0.008796692, 0.0015535355, 0.0070877075, -0.0070648193, 0.046173096, -0.026382446, 0.023803711, -0.008293152, 0.008666992, -0.0119018555, 0.035095215, 0.010978699, 0.009605408, -0.033721924, -0.032592773, 0.008514404, -0.011917114, 0.0022239685, -0.00087308884, 0.019760132, 0.006214142, -0.0049552917, 0.031982422, 0.030303955, -0.0029964447, -0.0107803345, 0.020233154, 0.08502197, -0.05593872, 0.0418396, -0.014427185, 0.036590576, 0.00856781, -0.014289856, -0.008926392, 0.014732361, 0.023086548, 0.022216797, -0.016098022, 0.026016235, 0.025375366, 0.012176514, -0.017196655, 0.011734009, 0.010543823, 0.031051636, 0.010681152, 0.0015869141, -0.012046814, 0.01977539, 0.041229248, -0.0014181137, 0.030441284, -0.00032114983, 0.10443115, -0.023269653, -0.039611816, -0.09832764, -0.0925293, -0.063964844, -0.000992775, -0.027435303, -0.0118637085, -0.0028743744, 0.0044555664, -0.0041275024, 0.03866577, -0.0066223145, -0.0048980713, -0.014122009, 0.057434082, 0.0019931793, 0.007835388, 0.011169434, -0.0050735474, 0.033721924, 0.02885437, 0.020233154, 0.027252197, 0.0052261353, -0.0018634796, 0.014915466, -0.020324707, -0.10601807, 0.03277588, -0.048553467, 0.04916382, 0.036346436, 0.024795532, 0.04034424, 0.04348755, 0.041107178, -0.025466919, 0.029876709, 0.040039062, -0.02067566, 0.025817871, 0.027297974, -0.025878906, -0.0062065125, 0.021728516, -0.014709473, 0.012992859, -0.024780273, 0.042938232, -0.07293701, -0.05090332, 0.007980347, 0.01828003, -0.011634827, 0.04019165, -0.040771484, -0.05734253, -0.024887085, -0.0037517548, -0.012878418, -0.011665344, 0.0040359497, -0.01159668, -0.0071029663, -0.007396698, -0.0021514893, 0.021881104, 0.0054855347, 0.023391724, -0.028747559, 0.015167236, 0.032318115, -0.00793457, 0.031707764, 0.020980835, -0.00022876263, 0.02178955, 0.022033691, 0.038848877, 0.033966064, 0.068359375, -0.007205963, 0.019348145, 0.022903442, -0.011634827, -0.009483337, -0.005256653, 0.02319336, 0.008018494, -0.0440979, -0.001964569, 0.04522705, -0.0016765594, 0.046813965, -0.029388428, -0.037322998, -0.03994751, 0.022262573, -0.023849487, -0.010108948, -0.015945435, -0.07116699, 0.036590576, -0.015205383, -0.0016593933, -0.029693604, 0.003768921, -0.021331787, 0.026992798, 0.015640259, -0.01260376, 0.0036563873, 0.0007529259, 0.009437561, -0.053894043, -0.044799805, 0.009155273, -0.029693604, 0.00034976006, 0.0146484375, 0.010726929, -0.024414062, -0.06793213, -0.00068616867, -0.008682251, 0.015975952, -0.028915405, 0.014511108, 0.026245117, -0.014953613, -0.025222778, 0.025436401, 0.0004723072, -0.026473999, 0.010635376, 0.028152466, 0.022598267, -0.07183838, -0.019042969, -0.01727295, -0.0014219284, -0.024917603, -0.0030002594, 0.044281006, 0.032165527, -0.0077171326, -0.00919342, -0.01461792, -0.024017334, -0.014953613, -0.046875, 0.030654907, 0.023757935, 0.04147339, 0.013900757, -0.007873535, 0.017730713, -0.023406982, -0.021728516, 0.014404297, -0.025009155, 0.013832092, 0.02684021, 0.11859131, 0.01828003, -0.061584473, -0.035064697, 0.0009765625, 0.042175293, -0.0129776, -0.017715454, -0.013191223, 0.022872925, -0.060028076, -0.014976501, 0.029052734, 0.006084442, -0.012504578, 0.016098022, 0.029067993, -0.010635376, -0.04373169, -0.021850586, 0.022537231, -0.017196655, 0.0030555725, -0.010818481, 0.013214111, -0.00089502335, -0.022735596, -0.027252197, -0.027175903, 0.012962341, 0.021118164, -0.0024604797, 0.029693604, -0.005039215, 0.0020923615, 0.011779785, 0.004486084, -0.001964569, 0.0003476143, 0.020523071, -0.028213501, -0.026779175, 0.039123535, -0.047210693, 0.01878357, -0.021347046, 0.030014038, -0.018630981, 0.0021533966, 0.041809082, -0.033081055, 0.033966064, 0.06323242, 0.08319092, 0.028335571, 0.016052246, -0.01637268, 0.016693115, -0.0045661926 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2009.09422v1
Epidemic mitigation by statistical inference from contact tracing data
Antoine Baker, Indaco Biazzo, Alfredo Braunstein, Giovanni Catania, Luca Dall'Asta, Alessandro Ingrosso, Florent Krzakala, Fabio Mazza, Marc Mézard, Anna Paola Muntoni, Maria Refinetti, Stefano Sarao Mannelli, Lenka Zdeborová
q-bio.PE, cond-mat.stat-mech, cs.AI, cs.LG, G.3; G.4; I.2.11; J.3
Contact-tracing is an essential tool in order to mitigate the impact of pandemic such as the COVID-19. In order to achieve efficient and scalable contact-tracing in real time, digital devices can play an important role. While a lot of attention has been paid to analyzing the privacy and ethical risks of the associated mobile applications, so far much less research has been devoted to optimizing their performance and assessing their impact on the mitigation of the epidemic. We develop Bayesian inference methods to estimate the risk that an individual is infected. This inference is based on the list of his recent contacts and their own risk levels, as well as personal information such as results of tests or presence of syndromes. We propose to use probabilistic risk estimation in order to optimize testing and quarantining strategies for the control of an epidemic. Our results show that in some range of epidemic spreading (typically when the manual tracing of all contacts of infected people becomes practically impossible, but before the fraction of infected people reaches the scale where a lock-down becomes unavoidable), this inference of individuals at risk could be an efficient way to mitigate the epidemic. Our approaches translate into fully distributed algorithms that only require communication between individuals who have recently been in contact. Such communication may be encrypted and anonymized and thus compatible with privacy preserving standards. We conclude that probabilistic risk estimation is capable to enhance performance of digital contact tracing and should be considered in the currently developed mobile applications.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2009.09422v1
"2020-09-20T12:24:45"
"2020-09-20T12:24:45"
{ "title": [ 0.012069702, 0.0074806213, -0.046905518, -0.09259033, 0.013793945, -0.012962341, -0.036224365, 0.003063202, -0.039978027, 0.0075263977, -0.024459839, 0.008842468, -0.04434204, -0.031311035, -0.008102417, -0.023452759, 0.010726929, 0.015716553, -0.008506775, -0.03768921, 0.004737854, -0.053100586, 0.035491943, 0.050079346, 0.0022449493, -0.022598267, -0.04827881, 0.010124207, -0.038757324, -0.039764404, -0.029449463, 0.036132812, 0.06744385, 0.014671326, -0.043945312, 0.009902954, -0.051513672, 0.022888184, -0.035827637, 0.019851685, -0.0004069805, -0.00466156, 0.025680542, -0.04244995, -0.006587982, 0.0107803345, -0.05065918, -0.0435791, -0.0093307495, 0.0541687, 0.006286621, 0.04135132, -0.009780884, 0.04360962, 0.032226562, -0.024642944, 0.0028419495, -0.018173218, 0.028198242, 0.030136108, -0.004207611, -0.013832092, 0.024047852, 0.007549286, -0.01953125, -0.05328369, -0.041381836, 0.022964478, 0.06124878, 0.024673462, 0.011810303, 0.037475586, -0.0016222, 0.019454956, -0.031829834, -0.03237915, 0.059143066, -0.00023031235, 0.013366699, -0.008842468, -0.0066490173, -0.052642822, 0.004989624, 0.00919342, -0.002653122, 0.008377075, -0.00032877922, -0.0062332153, 0.0013208389, -0.044281006, -0.0046958923, -0.0062789917, -0.0029621124, 0.0473938, -0.022659302, -0.017196655, 0.00057554245, 0.05432129, -0.006248474, -0.06121826, -0.04748535, 0.04473877, -0.14355469, -0.0007081032, 0.009460449, 0.06512451, 0.003479004, -0.013023376, -0.014053345, 0.01739502, -0.0016870499, -0.02520752, 0.001581192, -0.015838623, 0.0019168854, 0.005596161, -0.0070991516, 0.0010890961, 0.016952515, -0.0033664703, -0.036315918, -0.03604126, -0.016983032, 0.00084257126, 0.023223877, -0.016464233, -0.029418945, 0.049865723, 0.0059318542, 0.034332275, -0.010612488, 0.027420044, -0.10205078, -0.06970215, -0.046875, 0.019195557, 0.023895264, -0.020690918, -0.0090789795, -0.002653122, 0.020370483, -0.024520874, 0.00090551376, 0.013679504, 0.009216309, -0.021774292, 0.05279541, 0.021209717, -0.038269043, -0.009391785, -0.020614624, 0.062683105, 0.018676758, 0.020462036, -0.05709839, 0.006603241, -0.07928467, -0.02279663, 0.010070801, -0.00024819374, 0.030532837, -0.008773804, -0.03729248, -0.02420044, 0.015487671, 0.008239746, -0.0018529892, 0.033691406, 0.015060425, 0.043121338, -0.018569946, 0.010238647, -0.0058174133, -0.014770508, -0.013427734, -0.0044784546, 0.013153076, 0.017074585, 0.033294678, -0.045196533, -0.0077552795, -0.01914978, -0.0017995834, 0.055633545, -0.081848145, 0.002708435, 0.00026607513, 0.0078125, 0.04748535, -0.008277893, -0.0143585205, 0.034362793, -0.052978516, -0.014694214, -0.025939941, -0.018585205, 0.0024909973, 0.0009522438, -0.0048675537, 0.012573242, -0.036987305, -0.019012451, -0.028686523, 0.028335571, 0.000049948692, -0.057769775, 0.0024719238, -0.0009589195, -0.0021820068, 0.058776855, 0.044403076, -0.0000192523, -0.041656494, 0.02607727, -0.008102417, -0.05834961, 0.009086609, -0.018310547, -0.030578613, -0.004852295, -0.03668213, -0.029037476, -0.034606934, 0.038208008, -0.016616821, -0.024139404, 0.00006484985, -0.03338623, 0.016357422, -0.021194458, 0.11517334, 0.0019350052, -0.016403198, 0.005870819, 0.0057373047, -0.012077332, 0.02319336, 0.0211792, 0.02557373, -0.0051498413, 0.008598328, -0.037597656, -0.0065612793, 0.01322937, 0.030700684, 0.01121521, 0.017730713, -0.0005450249, 0.01763916, -0.0032653809, 0.070373535, -0.002407074, 0.053222656, 0.026672363, 0.024536133, 0.057250977, -0.008201599, 0.023895264, -0.035125732, 0.02180481, -0.0013055801, 0.024108887, 0.014503479, -0.008491516, -0.05895996, -0.039794922, -0.046691895, -0.008987427, 0.037994385, -0.02532959, 0.016143799, -0.06561279, -0.011627197, -0.0011482239, 0.014717102, -0.027313232, -0.035247803, 0.032836914, 0.002439499, -0.044158936, -0.0109939575, 0.045806885, 0.028030396, -0.014442444, 0.0067596436, 0.014892578, -0.0035915375, -0.03881836, -0.028717041, -0.028259277, 0.053894043, 0.006587982, 0.0067253113, -0.026168823, -0.007575989, -0.012237549, 0.036590576, 0.07635498, -0.026412964, 0.029785156, -0.059906006, 0.01574707, 0.02671814, -0.022994995, -0.008003235, 0.03982544, 0.005455017, 0.043029785, -0.0027923584, -0.030212402, 0.026626587, 0.0385437, -0.0012102127, -0.0513916, -0.015007019, -0.026000977, -0.0021343231, -0.035614014, -0.010688782, 0.044403076, -0.006259918, -0.0025520325, -0.04849243, -0.029281616, 0.022125244, 0.01902771, -0.064575195, -0.028640747, -0.018218994, 0.013435364, 0.056884766, 0.026626587, -0.041656494, -0.016555786, 0.018173218, 0.0055351257, -0.010940552, 0.03010559, -0.024429321, -0.028762817, -0.015380859, -0.008323669, -0.0022583008, -0.048339844, -0.002407074, -0.030914307, -0.007080078, 0.016494751, -0.07147217, -0.022079468, 0.037841797, -0.035736084, -0.03060913, -0.034698486, 0.0519104, 0.00075769424, -0.013061523, 0.007873535, 0.06866455, -0.019561768, 0.0713501, 0.026992798, 0.041778564, -0.049591064, -0.027191162, -0.08782959, -0.017715454, -0.019241333, 0.055358887, 0.06677246, -0.062286377, 0.008453369, -0.0115356445, 0.013046265, 0.049224854, -0.009284973, -0.03488159, -0.042419434, -0.015838623, -0.0335083, -0.0035533905, -0.0032253265, 0.008903503, 0.021347046, 0.10247803, 0.012260437, 0.040771484, 0.039093018, 0.037994385, -0.015541077, -0.020462036, -0.0184021, -0.0019760132, -0.00548172, 0.009567261, 0.020828247, 0.0011463165, -0.009864807, -0.055511475, -0.0065193176, 0.030975342, -0.008125305, -0.023605347, 0.024536133, -0.0602417, 0.020645142, -0.02357483, -0.015266418, 0.03050232, 0.05682373, -0.017166138, 0.011795044, -0.0047035217, -0.02748108, 0.00027656555, -0.011192322, -0.03302002, 0.037261963, -0.017089844, -0.07928467, 0.03302002, -0.07409668, -0.0126953125, -0.022720337, -0.011985779, 0.033599854, 0.030258179, 0.033447266, 0.00356102, -0.029586792, 0.0023441315, -0.030044556, -0.008476257, -0.02798462, 0.0059928894, -0.022460938, -0.029327393, 0.050201416, -0.0096588135, 0.015289307, -0.036590576, -0.023452759, 0.0062332153, 0.028930664, 0.011856079, -0.040161133, -0.021774292, -0.010734558, -0.016464233, 0.025283813, -0.023040771, -0.0043907166, -0.06616211, 0.016983032, -0.027572632, 0.031173706, 0.029174805, 0.005836487, -0.030456543, 0.010688782, 0.01322937, -0.0031604767, -0.049072266, -0.010047913, -0.009742737, -0.011329651, 0.05368042, -0.014732361, -0.035217285, 0.008178711, -0.041259766, 0.03894043, 0.015258789, 0.0018568039, -0.026489258, 0.0028514862, -0.0017309189, 0.01713562, -0.006729126, -0.005016327, 0.028884888, -0.01134491, -0.0033397675, -0.05029297, -0.012046814, 0.020233154, -0.12536621, -0.0234375, 0.007850647, -0.024719238, -0.038360596, -0.025482178, 0.007762909, -0.021530151, -0.046875, 0.021240234, -0.0107421875, 0.009773254, 0.0031585693, -0.06414795, -0.009315491, 0.062805176, -0.021438599, 0.020431519, 0.018173218, -0.012641907, 0.010520935, -0.029815674, 0.025009155, 0.008987427, 0.031585693, -0.024856567, -0.0044822693, 0.023208618, -0.015945435, -0.026519775, 0.07598877, 0.018203735, 0.0048217773, 0.0020141602, 0.03439331, 0.022125244, -0.011154175, 0.04916382, 0.045135498, -0.013618469, -0.051330566, -0.014656067, -0.007785797, -0.01499176, -0.009666443, -0.025878906, 0.0077705383, 0.0077552795, 0.032409668, 0.067993164, -0.0154800415, -0.027160645, 0.00001180172, -0.01574707, -0.015625, -0.014099121, -0.0048294067, 0.046051025, 0.009307861, 0.02192688, -0.01763916, 0.062683105, -0.0062217712, 0.028915405, -0.023620605, -0.0107421875, 0.01272583, -0.0035572052, -0.09564209, -0.0037117004, -0.0029773712, 0.022018433, -0.0027809143, -0.009239197, 0.015464783, -0.00055265427, -0.042541504, 0.000351429, 0.003835678, -0.008926392, 0.02658081, -0.026031494, 0.027069092, 0.010856628, -0.06323242, -0.038879395, -0.01902771, -0.030960083, 0.02671814, -0.018753052, -0.0129776, 0.03982544, 0.012229919, 0.02180481, 0.04663086, -0.022827148, -0.026748657, 0.03189087, -0.0021572113, -0.02128601, 0.0011510849, -0.0013399124, 0.002588272, -0.017959595, 0.021591187, -0.0309906, -0.013496399, -0.020690918, 0.038482666, -0.019607544, 0.05142212, 0.0025539398, 0.044403076, 0.024841309, 0.014625549, 0.0022182465, 0.009010315, -0.04034424, 0.00059080124, -0.007381439, 0.047943115, -0.013038635, -0.005970001, 0.023406982, 0.021606445, -0.0054359436, 0.0118637085, 0.016296387, 0.0051078796, 0.027130127, 0.0050354004, 0.027511597, -0.003206253, -0.032714844, 0.018844604, 0.005027771, 0.046051025, -0.010757446, 0.032226562, -0.027450562, 0.003566742, -0.0042419434, -0.015945435, 0.017715454, -0.02027893, 0.02545166, -0.06414795, -0.04940796, 0.0057029724, 0.044525146, -0.030029297, 0.0056915283, 0.0019464493, 0.023544312, 0.021133423, 0.04940796, 0.03289795, 0.0074310303, -0.015174866, -0.0025672913, 0.011054993, -0.021621704, -0.052368164, 0.018127441, 0.022262573, 0.021759033, 0.009033203, -0.010597229, -0.07434082, 0.00843811, -0.01309967, -0.0032157898, 0.028396606, -0.0692749, -0.0009431839, 0.04925537, 0.017364502, 0.004070282, -0.017211914, 0.022857666, 0.03857422, 0.03479004, 0.010795593, 0.015701294, 0.016662598, -0.010864258, -0.018218994, -0.016326904, 0.022827148, -0.028549194, 0.023849487, 0.014312744, -0.0026283264, -0.061584473, 0.022628784, 0.026931763, 0.005924225, 0.022506714, -0.056915283, 0.0025119781, 0.0033512115, 0.0042152405, 0.012374878, -0.005001068, -0.0018348694, 0.03552246, -0.028717041, -0.0013370514, -0.0024471283, -0.011802673, -0.02772522, -0.019805908, -0.012878418, -0.010246277, 0.012313843, 0.019500732, 0.036895752, -0.011314392, 0.046722412, 0.03274536, -0.084228516, 0.0064086914, -0.019302368, 0.021697998, 0.04788208, 0.029937744, -0.03378296, 0.010391235, -0.012382507, -0.07409668, -0.07727051, -0.010688782, -0.006576538, 0.012718201, -0.040008545, -0.025466919, 0.01864624, -0.036224365, 0.010017395, 0.046569824, -0.022460938, -0.0042686462, 0.015342712, -0.012969971, 0.0031490326, 0.04510498, -0.01713562, 0.014823914, 0.01335907, 0.009277344, 0.016052246, 0.00869751, -0.015777588, 0.015090942, -0.04156494, 0.007381439, 0.0131073, 0.0037078857, -0.031066895, 0.003036499, 0.026275635, 0.019180298, 0.0019664764, -0.003025055, 0.07525635, -0.022384644, -0.011009216, 0.015731812, -0.0054016113, -0.016647339, 0.061767578, -0.009216309, -0.007911682, -0.04849243, -0.05230713, -0.042816162, 0.016677856, 0.047973633, 0.022766113, 0.055786133, 0.01008606, 0.040252686, -0.006313324, 0.0048446655, -0.011276245, 0.031051636, 0.015037537, 0.026260376, -0.048706055, -0.0087890625, -0.014633179, -0.029556274, 0.028198242, 0.021499634, 0.008857727, 0.015289307, -0.021575928, -0.0037899017, -0.021453857, -0.06011963, 0.034606934, 0.01979065, -0.01461792, 0.08331299, -0.022506714, 0.031341553, 0.018753052, 0.08709717, 0.052856445, 0.013114929, -0.0010633469, 0.0033111572, 0.017974854, -0.04901123, 0.0056610107, -0.04510498, -0.015716553, -0.055664062, -0.010429382, -0.09075928, 0.018630981, 0.0017528534, 0.0057029724, -0.0010204315, 0.009674072, -0.0033035278, 0.01977539, 0.052001953, 0.026245117, 0.048797607, 0.01033783, -0.016586304, 0.0035209656, 0.025238037, 0.0057373047, 0.029388428, 0.017837524, 0.01751709, -0.03778076, 0.013908386, 0.0129776, -0.01889038, 0.010925293, -0.0060195923, 0.013885498, -0.030685425, 0.031951904, 0.0041618347, 0.03829956, 0.039367676, 0.023345947, 0.0030021667, -0.027496338, -0.013504028, -0.0060424805, -0.0011758804, -0.012702942, 0.027404785, -0.015159607, 0.008491516, -0.0231781, -0.030212402, 0.0056762695, 0.022384644, 0.044433594, -0.07879639, -0.03164673, 0.027511597, 0.025039673, -0.026473999, 0.026428223, -0.02507019, -0.028930664, -0.014884949, 0.036224365, -0.0027561188, 0.020950317, -0.021224976, 0.026870728, -0.045928955, -0.025939941, 0.005580902, -0.0007510185, -0.027832031, 0.02230835, -0.017410278, 0.0075302124, -0.0023918152, -0.035125732, -0.0030136108, 0.010864258, -0.027313232, -0.019546509, 0.043884277, 0.026016235, -0.0057907104, 0.068115234, 0.04284668, -0.017715454, -0.054229736, -0.019470215, 0.03604126, 0.024627686, -0.01713562, 0.01927185, -0.043273926, -0.04083252, 0.054626465, -0.051574707, 0.088134766, -0.05340576, -0.004650116, -0.035095215, 0.021652222, 0.012512207, -0.03414917, -0.019134521, -0.02670288, 0.007904053, -0.038909912, -0.026855469, -0.008903503, -0.028396606, -0.0037059784, 0.05114746, 0.024230957, -0.010803223, 0.012107849, -0.027938843, -0.08300781, -0.001584053, -0.031433105, 0.01852417, -0.036621094, -0.005973816, 0.0007429123, -0.0018835068, -0.0008149147, -0.04043579, -0.03387451, -0.01626587, -0.004207611, -0.03225708, -0.00060749054, 0.00018155575, -0.026687622, -0.007774353, 0.023834229, -0.00762558, -0.022750854, -0.035247803, 0.027435303, -0.018676758, -0.06488037, -0.031677246, -0.016830444, 0.013061523, 0.01878357, -0.016723633, 0.008720398, 0.04019165, -0.04458618, -0.041412354, -0.025924683, -0.0002605915, -0.0050354004, -0.05001831, 0.00013840199, 0.044189453, 0.037963867, -0.036346436, -0.002565384, 0.024871826, 0.030059814, -0.038391113, 0.064697266, 0.038482666, 0.043182373, -0.018829346, 0.06713867, -0.0043563843, -0.075683594, -0.021453857, -0.00945282, 0.037017822, 0.036193848, -0.003753662, -0.017425537, 0.001832962, 0.000103235245, 0.01876831, -0.015258789, -0.0064964294, 0.0084991455, -0.013748169, 0.036865234, -0.013694763, -0.0076293945, -0.011146545, 0.015327454, -0.009056091, -0.012825012, -0.014770508, 0.013389587, -0.032287598, 0.022125244, -0.0059165955, -0.054870605, 0.070129395, 0.044067383, 0.016479492, 0.035308838, 0.004524231, -0.019714355, -0.007007599, -0.0028324127, 0.00068950653, 0.009216309, 0.046875, -0.057159424, -0.00447464, -0.065979004, -0.05783081, 0.040771484, -0.022232056, 0.038116455, -0.032928467, 0.019943237, -0.020858765, -0.034820557, -0.0020332336, 0.00082063675, 0.051757812, -0.08355713, -0.021133423, -0.048339844, 0.07489014, -0.0003437996 ], "summary": [ 0.039123535, -0.009315491, 0.007331848, -0.04824829, -0.026306152, -0.0027198792, -0.033935547, -0.024597168, -0.010803223, -0.004043579, 0.0034332275, 0.00048613548, -0.010375977, -0.05621338, 0.044555664, -0.011520386, -0.001581192, -0.015037537, -0.0009946823, -0.028198242, 0.02935791, -0.023727417, -0.012031555, -0.01979065, 0.0074310303, -0.01713562, -0.04562378, 0.026275635, -0.0231781, -0.0010662079, 0.0052986145, 0.030639648, 0.008766174, 0.034698486, -0.034606934, -0.026382446, -0.017166138, 0.0102005005, -0.02003479, 0.019119263, 0.00598526, 0.0078125, 0.117614746, -0.055389404, 0.052124023, -0.014694214, 0.015304565, -0.06945801, 0.04663086, 0.020141602, -0.025543213, 0.050933838, -0.031433105, -0.008575439, 0.005657196, -0.017990112, 0.01272583, -0.033081055, -0.004573822, 0.009864807, 0.018203735, 0.021102905, 0.0067596436, 0.010246277, 0.002960205, -0.043823242, -0.05697632, 0.0181427, 0.013145447, 0.018463135, 0.030593872, -0.011222839, 0.015426636, -0.04168701, -0.039764404, 0.014854431, 0.026107788, -0.038360596, 0.0022335052, -0.019439697, -0.018234253, -0.058654785, 0.00043463707, -0.0076828003, -0.0034599304, 0.014122009, -0.0027675629, 0.00466156, 0.02078247, 0.007896423, -0.00085163116, -0.0022945404, -0.01235199, 0.054016113, 0.032287598, -0.035583496, 0.009223938, 0.035247803, 0.017410278, -0.037902832, -0.0259552, -0.008758545, -0.09765625, -0.00434494, -0.021575928, 0.094055176, 0.01725769, 0.024810791, -0.01701355, -0.009895325, 0.012023926, -0.06088257, -0.016906738, -0.03302002, -0.022735596, 0.048034668, 0.014129639, -0.006942749, 0.0031929016, 0.009529114, -0.052459717, -0.041900635, -0.04260254, 0.04800415, -0.0027427673, -0.031143188, -0.0032100677, 0.06970215, 0.05026245, 0.017196655, -0.025009155, 0.027420044, -0.033599854, -0.04473877, -0.034332275, 0.0024681091, 0.033691406, 0.015510559, 0.007270813, -0.020141602, 0.044647217, -0.0024356842, -0.002231598, 0.036132812, -0.015670776, -0.029129028, 0.036315918, 0.06463623, -0.022232056, 0.006046295, -0.025939941, 0.099243164, 0.017150879, 0.035705566, -0.015274048, 0.007873535, 0.006263733, 0.00944519, -0.01828003, -0.017105103, 0.037200928, 0.008003235, -0.018127441, 0.033691406, 0.027999878, -0.025161743, -0.00066280365, 0.013877869, -0.0036373138, 0.022537231, -0.045043945, -0.0064697266, -0.0014953613, -0.017211914, -0.019165039, 0.0048103333, -0.017913818, 0.029663086, 0.033935547, -0.05871582, -0.025512695, -0.036254883, 0.04449463, 0.006706238, -0.013671875, 0.03756714, -0.009407043, 0.016052246, 0.0021305084, 0.004085541, -0.00033664703, 0.028869629, -0.057495117, 0.037384033, -0.012054443, -0.0038223267, -0.013244629, 0.01878357, 0.0012302399, -0.031097412, -0.004398346, -0.055419922, -0.018951416, -0.014175415, -0.07067871, -0.059539795, -0.016418457, 0.022567749, 0.02217102, 0.04449463, 0.016098022, -0.0096206665, -0.032928467, 0.050750732, 0.011550903, -0.023513794, 0.030258179, -0.019088745, -0.02154541, -0.021347046, -0.052856445, 0.03515625, -0.075927734, 0.026412964, 0.013786316, -0.032470703, -0.008026123, -0.027435303, 0.037384033, -0.023040771, 0.044158936, 0.026901245, -0.03375244, 0.012908936, 0.0075569153, 0.008811951, 0.042907715, -0.026916504, 0.029403687, 0.007850647, 0.024749756, 0.0018167496, -0.018875122, -0.0041885376, 0.019104004, -0.00036501884, 0.016036987, -0.009162903, 0.02947998, 0.010284424, 0.008346558, -0.036987305, 0.047912598, -0.0005373955, 0.020767212, 0.035980225, -0.028213501, 0.011772156, -0.01184845, -0.003648758, -0.0029830933, -0.020309448, 0.014976501, -0.027008057, -0.049316406, -0.10803223, -0.0395813, -0.0385437, 0.07952881, -0.11651611, 0.0051879883, -0.09307861, -0.013000488, -0.029251099, 0.01928711, 0.00023341179, -0.054138184, 0.032958984, 0.024414062, -0.011894226, 0.002620697, 0.038604736, -0.010246277, -0.017944336, -0.0007352829, -0.013160706, -0.010887146, -0.0012378693, -0.00034308434, 0.034088135, 0.057434082, 0.006401062, -0.0024147034, -0.0118637085, -0.026611328, -0.009864807, -0.026229858, 0.0014810562, 0.033416748, -0.05822754, -0.036193848, 0.04260254, -0.035461426, 0.021865845, 0.0012140274, 0.022445679, 0.008483887, 0.0256958, 0.021011353, -0.047943115, 0.035858154, 0.035095215, 0.0012435913, -0.03366089, -0.016845703, -0.014198303, -0.031158447, -0.009086609, -0.0023097992, 0.07196045, 0.010025024, -0.043823242, -0.023788452, -0.0072669983, -0.027145386, 0.011444092, -0.008544922, -0.0025463104, -0.045928955, -0.0008673668, -0.01777649, -0.020477295, 0.0015211105, 0.053649902, -0.02357483, -0.009895325, -0.0031547546, 0.043884277, -0.00806427, -0.012962341, -0.014709473, -0.0038452148, -0.011177063, -0.024795532, -0.055999756, 0.036132812, -0.029174805, 0.02078247, -0.07598877, -0.039886475, 0.028823853, -0.03778076, -0.009292603, -0.022491455, 0.016906738, -0.0077819824, -0.0047340393, -0.003124237, 0.03265381, -0.048065186, 0.081726074, 0.023849487, 0.041259766, -0.038208008, -0.05996704, -0.04989624, 0.03451538, -0.045288086, 0.09246826, 0.073791504, -0.0791626, 0.028930664, -0.0007619858, 0.03010559, 0.08703613, 0.010299683, 0.005760193, -0.036315918, -0.0021953583, -0.009979248, -0.013298035, 0.0047950745, -0.00024056435, 0.031173706, 0.051940918, 0.0066223145, 0.038269043, 0.015174866, 0.04083252, -0.012306213, -0.021759033, -0.018447876, 0.04574585, -0.013031006, -0.012588501, -0.019332886, 0.0072135925, 0.042633057, -0.0119018555, -0.008865356, 0.034454346, 0.009521484, 0.007865906, 0.016525269, -0.026931763, 0.022079468, 0.026733398, -0.007949829, 0.032226562, 0.05697632, 0.011627197, -0.03439331, 0.018173218, -0.020568848, -0.008773804, 0.007820129, 0.03488159, 0.012008667, -0.016815186, -0.04586792, 0.017440796, -0.032684326, 0.008323669, -0.011795044, -0.017333984, 0.047607422, -0.015556335, 0.026321411, 0.0055503845, 0.010284424, -0.013084412, -0.0019741058, -0.0056533813, -0.044403076, -0.022613525, -0.050842285, -0.036315918, -0.017623901, -0.0013523102, -0.026763916, -0.061645508, -0.02658081, 0.015838623, 0.00050258636, 0.036987305, -0.03250122, -0.010772705, -0.025054932, 0.00016260147, -0.004207611, -0.031799316, -0.0054397583, 0.008232117, 0.033050537, -0.00043654442, 0.05831909, 0.00053453445, 0.016693115, 0.026535034, -0.0052833557, -0.0020179749, 0.0067634583, -0.01802063, -0.011405945, -0.005924225, 0.030685425, -0.010635376, 0.01272583, -0.0317688, 0.0032920837, 0.020523071, -0.0178833, -0.017593384, -0.013114929, -0.03253174, -0.033416748, 0.04296875, 0.0026626587, 0.07922363, -0.0058670044, 0.0055885315, -0.0104599, -0.01285553, -0.0059127808, -0.004081726, 0.004962921, -0.055358887, -0.017700195, 0.0006599426, -0.009048462, -0.02330017, -0.017303467, 0.0093307495, -0.0062026978, -0.029510498, 0.019821167, -0.024093628, 0.08605957, 0.0016784668, -0.04537964, 0.02394104, -0.022598267, 0.024459839, 0.022598267, -0.03463745, 0.039642334, 0.044525146, 0.0036258698, 0.0018186569, -0.06677246, 0.027328491, -0.051940918, 0.03677368, 0.013465881, -0.003993988, -0.00283432, 0.046722412, 0.03286743, -0.013710022, -0.010398865, 0.05947876, 0.06536865, -0.014709473, 0.007850647, 0.049438477, -0.015449524, -0.044128418, -0.010314941, 0.012626648, -0.013717651, -0.009788513, -0.011222839, -0.043914795, -0.0028152466, 0.035308838, -0.009796143, -0.009170532, -0.048797607, -0.0051727295, 0.04067993, -0.0046691895, -0.034362793, -0.022903442, 0.04348755, -0.008239746, 0.03314209, -0.03173828, 0.060302734, -0.027252197, 0.05545044, -0.019577026, -0.031585693, 0.045654297, -0.036468506, -0.076538086, 0.080200195, 0.03604126, -0.001250267, 0.018173218, 0.01537323, -0.0044670105, -0.014732361, -0.010353088, -0.004924774, 0.014877319, 0.018615723, -0.0018968582, -0.05807495, 0.029083252, -0.013969421, -0.043945312, -0.039855957, -0.059814453, -0.038879395, -0.019470215, -0.0024147034, 0.0043907166, 0.02281189, -0.0009784698, 0.02017212, -0.012054443, 0.0019168854, -0.0025367737, 0.009643555, 0.008491516, -0.00699234, -0.031433105, 0.010192871, 0.000034034252, 0.028549194, 0.04055786, -0.050567627, -0.01776123, -0.01474762, 0.010871887, 0.0039482117, 0.023986816, 0.004562378, 0.048919678, 0.0039901733, 0.029754639, 0.0018110275, 0.0059432983, -0.009681702, -0.029266357, -0.007987976, 0.050842285, -0.0061683655, -0.046783447, -0.014694214, 0.030670166, 0.028518677, -0.005054474, -0.012512207, -0.011779785, 0.026412964, -0.0028514862, 0.015670776, 0.08453369, -0.019638062, 0.044433594, 0.02545166, 0.014816284, 0.06555176, 0.02684021, -0.039276123, -0.018676758, -0.016235352, -0.00072050095, -0.0037174225, -0.016525269, -0.0027122498, -0.022964478, -0.0024280548, 0.031051636, 0.010826111, -0.008460999, 0.0013341904, -0.03036499, -0.01651001, 0.005958557, 0.009269714, -0.029541016, -0.0031871796, -0.02078247, -0.0073509216, -0.017822266, -0.038482666, -0.01687622, -0.027679443, 0.0036735535, 0.011184692, 0.043548584, -0.0070343018, -0.023254395, 0.025482178, -0.026535034, 0.011955261, -0.004600525, -0.030715942, -0.076171875, -0.019592285, -0.0035820007, -0.022872925, -0.023880005, 0.00037312508, 0.030471802, 0.03656006, -0.01739502, -0.025115967, 0.033203125, -0.036071777, 0.0055122375, -0.0074920654, -0.007255554, -0.030731201, -0.023605347, -0.006450653, -0.051239014, 0.007232666, -0.0013399124, 0.0206604, 0.06854248, -0.04232788, -0.024017334, 0.010383606, -0.00008970499, 0.01727295, -0.0025920868, 0.037200928, 0.0007762909, 0.023330688, 0.008049011, 0.020111084, -0.029174805, -0.012458801, 0.01576233, 0.02267456, -0.053009033, -0.049224854, 0.015914917, 0.02911377, 0.0385437, 0.04324341, -0.017959595, 0.037750244, -0.005710602, 0.027618408, -0.014381409, -0.005088806, 0.020980835, 0.026885986, -0.007835388, 0.015579224, -0.046051025, -0.020385742, -0.03652954, -0.029541016, -0.021148682, 0.06365967, -0.028305054, -0.005832672, 0.041015625, -0.01171875, 0.018325806, 0.02494812, -0.019439697, -0.004760742, 0.0065612793, 0.0027046204, 0.009788513, 0.021087646, -0.016433716, 0.0062065125, 0.01689148, -0.004070282, 0.028915405, 0.031341553, 0.004863739, 0.00003707409, -0.0058555603, -0.015609741, 0.030532837, -0.016281128, -0.017547607, 0.015777588, 0.0021266937, -0.01928711, 0.036193848, -0.0011854172, 0.023605347, 0.010437012, 0.033233643, 0.030059814, 0.032165527, 0.0058898926, -0.013626099, -0.0012331009, 0.04156494, -0.020812988, -0.014701843, 0.00712204, 0.003604889, 0.008659363, 0.03829956, 0.061523438, 0.036590576, 0.027526855, 0.033325195, -0.009933472, -0.004600525, -0.013923645, 0.033966064, 0.09698486, -0.004425049, 0.011169434, 0.0012464523, -0.017410278, -0.0030765533, -0.029953003, 0.002029419, 0.001660347, 0.0847168, 0.021606445, -0.023422241, -0.025283813, 0.019515991, 0.02709961, 0.00042319298, 0.044433594, 0.021362305, 0.02456665, 0.027130127, 0.027770996, 0.045715332, 0.025054932, -0.014472961, 0.012718201, -0.025482178, -0.03253174, 0.031463623, -0.0073013306, -0.040222168, -0.014556885, -0.03640747, -0.017501831, 0.03692627, 0.0034885406, -0.010673523, 0.0035324097, 0.008842468, -0.0007300377, 0.0041007996, -0.01374054, -0.017105103, 0.013336182, 0.0045547485, -0.019927979, 0.0040664673, 0.03366089, -0.011703491, 0.016647339, 0.023803711, 0.028289795, -0.0024108887, 0.051513672, 0.008491516, -0.04812622, -0.035858154, -0.036010742, 0.06933594, -0.012329102, 0.021530151, 0.026748657, 0.024108887, 0.0070877075, -0.01675415, 0.09222412, -0.046173096, -0.0074157715, 0.0413208, -0.042663574, 0.039855957, 0.012466431, 0.03643799, -0.044189453, -0.04147339, -0.012046814, 0.06970215, 0.009292603, 0.048980713, -0.07727051, -0.005207062, 0.0036392212, -0.005290985, -0.05630493, 0.023956299, -0.039123535, -0.05831909, -0.03579712, 0.023605347, -0.02670288, -0.0084991455, -0.040649414, 0.017059326, -0.050720215, -0.003856659, 0.013282776, -0.015167236, -0.020812988, 0.011436462, -0.027114868, -0.03491211, -0.019241333, -0.015792847, -0.027236938, 0.02293396, 0.0028457642, -0.0131073, 0.09057617, 0.040771484, 0.017089844, 0.07183838, 0.0036201477, 0.008293152, -0.01802063, 0.017044067, 0.026107788, -0.011543274, 0.0027694702, 0.023406982, -0.049865723, 0.003982544, 0.027023315, -0.023345947, 0.036865234, -0.017791748, -0.015586853, -0.03567505, 0.014968872, -0.03668213, -0.0034980774, 0.013664246, -0.0541687, 0.01638794, -0.018630981, -0.03741455, -0.040496826, 0.0047454834, -0.028274536, 0.022155762, 0.016494751, 0.0023078918, 0.050109863, -0.025878906, -0.05697632, -0.006790161, 0.0037994385, 0.03643799, -0.021270752, -0.039978027, 0.046539307, -0.014755249, 0.039215088, -0.062805176, -0.061431885, 0.006137848, 0.064208984, -0.026504517, 0.0013074875, 0.00605011, -0.024642944, -0.014251709, 0.038208008, 0.006340027, -0.024032593, -0.00932312, 0.03201294, 0.00623703, -0.04663086, -0.012069702, -0.010749817, 0.0018024445, -0.020431519, -0.013908386, 0.0025043488, 0.042144775, -0.048461914, -0.08227539, -0.054840088, -0.0597229, -0.0066070557, -0.055358887, -0.0058631897, 0.009346008, 0.028793335, -0.0044403076, 0.019165039, 0.035217285, 0.04058838, -0.030944824, -0.001958847, 0.0052719116, 0.060028076, 0.048309326, 0.08709717, -0.0009822845, -0.09661865, -0.0022773743, -0.022155762, 0.054138184, 0.0017232895, -0.02935791, -0.011886597, 0.012016296, -0.012283325, 0.018966675, -0.049591064, 0.04269409, -0.014968872, -0.03652954, 0.0099487305, -0.017837524, -0.05291748, -0.0102005005, 0.008468628, -0.021911621, -0.07543945, 0.0076293945, -0.0010938644, -0.0579834, -0.004512787, -0.013336182, -0.038635254, 0.013435364, 0.0014028549, 0.007949829, -0.011703491, 0.034973145, -0.012573242, -0.023086548, 0.0077438354, 0.023635864, 0.036468506, 0.03161621, -0.07946777, 0.010108948, -0.110961914, -0.04067993, 0.027297974, -0.0121536255, 0.0033912659, -0.024276733, 0.03543091, 0.025375366, -0.004070282, 0.0028133392, 0.0026550293, 0.02986145, -0.034332275, 0.010803223, -0.042419434, 0.010185242, 0.013145447 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2009.14665v1
Facilitating Connected Autonomous Vehicle Operations Using Space-weighted Information Fusion and Deep Reinforcement Learning Based Control
Jiqian Dong, Sikai Chen, Yujie Li, Runjia Du, Aaron Steinfeld, Samuel Labi
cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SY, eess.SY
The connectivity aspect of connected autonomous vehicles (CAV) is beneficial because it facilitates dissemination of traffic-related information to vehicles through Vehicle-to-External (V2X) communication. Onboard sensing equipment including LiDAR and camera can reasonably characterize the traffic environment in the immediate locality of the CAV. However, their performance is limited by their sensor range (SR). On the other hand, longer-range information is helpful for characterizing imminent conditions downstream. By contemporaneously coalescing the short- and long-range information, the CAV can construct comprehensively its surrounding environment and thereby facilitate informed, safe, and effective movement planning in the short-term (local decisions including lane change) and long-term (route choice). In this paper, we describe a Deep Reinforcement Learning based approach that integrates the data collected through sensing and connectivity capabilities from other vehicles located in the proximity of the CAV and from those located further downstream, and we use the fused data to guide lane changing, a specific context of CAV operations. In addition, recognizing the importance of the connectivity range (CR) to the performance of not only the algorithm but also of the vehicle in the actual driving environment, the paper carried out a case study. The case study demonstrates the application of the proposed algorithm and duly identifies the appropriate CR for each level of prevailing traffic density. It is expected that implementation of the algorithm in CAVs can enhance the safety and mobility associated with CAV driving operations. From a general perspective, its implementation can provide guidance to connectivity equipment manufacturers and CAV operators, regarding the default CR settings for CAVs or the recommended CR setting in a given traffic environment.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2009.14665v1
"2020-09-30T13:38:32"
"2020-09-30T13:38:32"
{ "title": [ 0.008140564, 0.0073165894, -0.018936157, -0.03378296, 0.02619934, -0.030303955, 0.013801575, -0.038238525, -0.051452637, 0.01701355, -0.029769897, 0.039031982, -0.04650879, -0.016677856, 0.006839752, -0.03378296, -0.0079422, 0.020645142, -0.03390503, -0.04324341, 0.008590698, -0.04159546, 0.011741638, 0.088256836, 0.022888184, -0.019042969, -0.123413086, 0.024093628, -0.045440674, -0.03793335, -0.027008057, 0.03515625, 0.035614014, 0.033477783, -0.041992188, 0.008865356, -0.041381836, 0.036895752, 0.008338928, 0.0057868958, 0.015586853, -0.0064964294, -0.020950317, -0.007331848, -0.02456665, 0.023605347, -0.07397461, -0.02394104, -0.0234375, 0.040222168, 0.028930664, 0.0501709, -0.0070266724, 0.0592041, 0.03250122, -0.0003809929, -0.050689697, -0.043151855, 0.05041504, 0.064086914, 0.02116394, -0.084472656, 0.019805908, -0.035125732, -0.0064735413, -0.042938232, 0.021759033, 0.027770996, 0.05407715, 0.013946533, -0.0000936985, 0.039886475, 0.007858276, 0.033081055, -0.016586304, -0.030670166, 0.041748047, 0.01033783, 0.017105103, 0.0030708313, 0.013183594, 0.00283432, 0.041900635, -0.012214661, -0.001953125, -0.043945312, -0.018981934, -0.009735107, -0.021240234, -0.024032593, -0.014785767, -0.0065193176, -0.0048065186, 0.047302246, -0.010597229, -0.024887085, -0.011657715, 0.023712158, -0.008644104, 0.0000017881393, -0.0060310364, -0.00381279, -0.010528564, -0.023910522, 0.0070152283, 0.032928467, 0.010055542, -0.006954193, 0.013191223, -0.0029067993, -0.027130127, 0.033203125, -0.010192871, 0.01449585, -0.0054092407, 0.009498596, -0.019882202, 0.0013837814, -0.007709503, 0.00819397, -0.009407043, -0.025115967, -0.003370285, 0.04135132, 0.044006348, 0.018463135, -0.025131226, 0.014533997, 0.010353088, 0.01838684, -0.005142212, 0.04547119, -0.07055664, -0.09185791, -0.0619812, 0.038482666, 0.008476257, 0.0059013367, 0.008773804, -0.018951416, 0.009857178, 0.00092983246, 0.0037631989, 0.023391724, 0.0154953, 0.00009715557, 0.058776855, 0.014205933, -0.049743652, -0.05279541, 0.016342163, 0.027435303, 0.021850586, 0.0038375854, -0.024932861, -0.00843811, -0.0736084, -0.026428223, 0.027938843, -0.015075684, 0.038391113, 0.021865845, -0.0069084167, 0.041290283, 0.07489014, -0.027450562, -0.018310547, 0.02986145, -0.0099487305, 0.03152466, -0.017929077, 0.009986877, -0.06402588, -0.038848877, -0.0020580292, -0.020965576, 0.032226562, 0.03439331, 0.023605347, -0.003019333, 0.013183594, -0.025024414, 0.062042236, 0.016159058, -0.061462402, -0.007789612, 0.00037789345, 0.012268066, 0.0546875, 0.0067596436, -0.016906738, 0.019638062, -0.056396484, -0.016525269, -0.056915283, 0.017227173, 0.03164673, 0.059539795, -0.021896362, 0.016235352, -0.044128418, 0.0021209717, -0.024032593, 0.0022010803, -0.037353516, -0.04119873, -0.012496948, 0.023757935, -0.03503418, 0.029937744, 0.045898438, -0.0084991455, -0.031585693, -0.008232117, -0.015159607, -0.052093506, 0.021102905, -0.04727173, -0.019744873, -0.035827637, -0.04714966, 0.027679443, -0.048736572, 0.030929565, 0.0072288513, 0.008163452, -0.0015134811, -0.02281189, 0.043029785, -0.0026245117, 0.10449219, -0.040283203, 0.013320923, 0.011795044, -0.0064926147, -0.012413025, -0.024642944, -0.012535095, 0.016921997, 0.009780884, -0.007850647, -0.0140686035, -0.0042800903, 0.05102539, 0.019439697, -0.03302002, -0.02180481, 0.035217285, 0.005317688, 0.0138168335, 0.07342529, 0.0131073, 0.043121338, 0.015266418, 0.022369385, 0.039886475, 0.013290405, -0.0007123947, -0.017684937, 0.011016846, 0.007972717, -0.032562256, -0.015914917, -0.008804321, -0.04663086, 0.0008029938, 0.00011795759, 0.027877808, -0.0005803108, -0.0054969788, 0.03012085, 0.027389526, -0.0028762817, -0.0013027191, -0.02355957, -0.048736572, -0.03552246, 0.04244995, -0.0031929016, -0.061676025, -0.014427185, -0.019744873, 0.032562256, 0.007820129, 0.02583313, 0.00056552887, 0.029266357, -0.017974854, -0.014122009, -0.023208618, 0.060699463, -0.0072517395, -0.015823364, -0.021575928, -0.0010137558, -0.03149414, 0.025512695, 0.07501221, -0.01499939, 0.05319214, -0.05987549, 0.027572632, 0.0317688, -0.017623901, 0.0062713623, 0.01309967, 0.015136719, 0.020935059, -0.019042969, 0.02708435, -0.061279297, 0.029129028, -0.0032444, -0.025787354, -0.06121826, -0.059570312, -0.02470398, -0.049743652, -0.039642334, 0.015838623, 0.09283447, -0.0071792603, -0.0011930466, 0.00566864, -0.00756073, -0.047210693, 0.003036499, -0.017303467, -0.010353088, 0.057525635, 0.03353882, 0.047332764, -0.021530151, 0.0021800995, -0.014335632, 0.005973816, -0.0042915344, 0.018798828, -0.020614624, -0.008552551, 0.008079529, -0.02470398, -0.0032405853, -0.01713562, 0.012588501, -0.05984497, 0.0038890839, 0.015113831, -0.037719727, 0.013572693, 0.01335907, -0.026351929, -0.018539429, 0.03781128, 0.0703125, -0.064575195, -0.0262146, 0.062042236, 0.0048332214, 0.0014257431, 0.013763428, 0.008430481, -0.017669678, -0.07891846, 0.022888184, -0.029296875, -0.0073623657, -0.043792725, -0.015098572, 0.041107178, -0.10180664, -0.014343262, -0.013504028, -0.01687622, 0.034729004, 0.068115234, -0.007511139, -0.025848389, -0.028778076, -0.01828003, 0.016433716, 0.028411865, -0.03579712, 0.008628845, 0.07312012, 0.01146698, -0.009033203, -0.028396606, 0.04397583, 0.005268097, -0.004425049, -0.036132812, -0.019729614, 0.009399414, 0.038330078, 0.005718231, -0.018493652, 0.0028820038, -0.12536621, -0.0026874542, 0.038269043, 0.009269714, -0.022644043, 0.027267456, -0.042114258, 0.019729614, 0.01108551, -0.015914917, 0.0046424866, 0.03955078, 0.020690918, 0.013046265, 0.022705078, -0.0069007874, 0.023788452, -0.04043579, -0.08319092, 0.057037354, -0.055877686, -0.046020508, -0.0044059753, 0.008132935, -0.043792725, -0.027557373, -0.004764557, 0.019989014, 0.037719727, 0.0033855438, 0.020401001, -0.008659363, -0.00017678738, -0.031188965, -0.0030879974, -0.018295288, -0.022323608, 0.0049209595, -0.024673462, 0.018936157, -0.012077332, -0.0056762695, -0.026794434, -0.018325806, 0.018554688, 0.038635254, 0.029205322, -0.04574585, -0.014541626, -0.02128601, -0.008010864, -0.027282715, -0.0009083748, -0.009376526, -0.028808594, 0.013023376, -0.012489319, 0.08343506, 0.0079574585, 0.009719849, -0.009460449, -0.019592285, 0.023849487, -0.016616821, -0.06161499, 0.01876831, 0.028427124, -0.011062622, 0.0045051575, -0.007411957, -0.010276794, 0.00945282, 0.004764557, 0.01751709, -0.002822876, -0.015792847, -0.021194458, 0.002790451, 0.01928711, -0.010940552, 0.01953125, -0.003458023, -0.0043792725, 0.0063667297, -0.02909851, -0.009689331, 0.005176544, 0.0041389465, -0.07116699, 0.0021705627, -0.00023186207, -0.002822876, 0.0004963875, -0.027374268, 0.023620605, -0.01852417, -0.04937744, 0.0076789856, -0.009468079, -0.017150879, 0.0073928833, -0.055603027, -0.030212402, 0.05581665, -0.012756348, 0.00932312, 0.05621338, -0.0034332275, 0.013748169, -0.022506714, 0.007331848, 0.037841797, 0.030181885, -0.0063705444, 0.027496338, 0.04748535, -0.030426025, -0.020629883, 0.046142578, 0.055908203, -0.038635254, -0.00074625015, -0.004688263, -0.0035438538, -0.052520752, 0.05380249, 0.026229858, -0.00022959709, -0.09655762, 0.035217285, -0.011878967, 0.000034928322, -0.01689148, -0.022354126, 0.024032593, 0.01373291, 0.034851074, 0.048339844, -0.0023593903, -0.01260376, 0.037139893, -0.00002938509, -0.0002090931, 0.005393982, 0.012321472, 0.015556335, 0.017211914, 0.014335632, -0.0045204163, 0.05999756, -0.061431885, 0.02897644, -0.011199951, 0.003982544, -0.0056877136, -0.015235901, -0.046569824, -0.012184143, 0.0069351196, -0.0012464523, -0.018310547, 0.020355225, 0.04977417, -0.025772095, -0.03967285, 0.025863647, 0.05682373, 0.0039024353, -0.03479004, -0.10467529, 0.013320923, -0.0075569153, -0.051727295, -0.027938843, -0.0099487305, -0.0038909912, 0.016952515, -0.010391235, -0.019042969, 0.0135650635, 0.035186768, 0.095703125, 0.03262329, 0.01423645, -0.043121338, 0.079833984, -0.016555786, -0.018615723, 0.029785156, 0.024856567, 0.0024318695, -0.03050232, -0.0052719116, -0.022155762, -0.010444641, -0.04333496, 0.02268982, -0.016967773, 0.031280518, 0.01625061, 0.046966553, 0.025665283, 0.0256958, 0.01739502, 0.0074653625, -0.034179688, -0.011070251, 0.0023498535, 0.060638428, -0.026275635, 0.031677246, 0.03439331, 0.011672974, -0.015670776, -0.022491455, 0.035308838, 0.00039696693, 0.0015544891, -0.048675537, 0.05984497, 0.008728027, -0.010765076, 0.02243042, 0.0067710876, 0.02708435, -0.037841797, 0.105651855, -0.027389526, -0.04272461, 0.007499695, -0.0046424866, 0.00010859966, -0.045043945, 0.008354187, -0.06427002, -0.09643555, -0.029022217, 0.09112549, -0.030426025, -0.004333496, -0.0036888123, 0.0065956116, 0.042938232, 0.042266846, 0.034088135, -0.017501831, -0.024139404, -0.0041503906, -0.0020008087, -0.030960083, -0.050354004, 0.005405426, -0.03503418, 0.020767212, -0.006855011, 0.008781433, -0.047851562, 0.008735657, 0.027542114, 0.005836487, -0.02432251, -0.054992676, 0.03387451, 0.025909424, -0.0015592575, 0.003353119, -0.007965088, 0.028640747, 0.017669678, 0.0473938, 0.008850098, 0.039276123, 0.036193848, -0.043518066, 0.026245117, 0.01373291, 0.02935791, -0.0043258667, 0.019561768, 0.0028190613, -0.0037631989, -0.050354004, 0.020248413, -0.024047852, -0.04623413, 0.03967285, -0.043945312, 0.00017082691, 0.009727478, 0.026885986, 0.03778076, -0.0016117096, -0.017913818, -0.006843567, 0.018096924, -0.025360107, -0.0134887695, 0.02255249, 0.014122009, -0.06585693, -0.005947113, -0.07421875, 0.013450623, 0.011436462, 0.0062942505, -0.0025424957, 0.023757935, 0.040496826, 0.003364563, -0.03173828, 0.015579224, 0.02758789, 0.03414917, 0.0071525574, -0.0473938, 0.0040664673, -0.0011034012, -0.053009033, -0.06738281, 0.0016517639, 0.0010757446, -0.002811432, -0.019836426, -0.014556885, -0.012031555, -0.01928711, 0.017730713, 0.014465332, -0.05419922, 0.029571533, 0.0049591064, 0.0015611649, 0.0067596436, 0.03878784, -0.03314209, 0.0047340393, 0.024719238, -0.0059661865, 0.013381958, 0.0031356812, -0.016616821, 0.009338379, -0.041259766, 0.0077323914, 0.0132369995, -0.0038146973, -0.040740967, -0.005466461, 0.01927185, -0.015266418, 0.01424408, -0.018951416, 0.06951904, -0.013175964, 0.012901306, -0.008369446, 0.015327454, -0.02178955, 0.036010742, -0.034118652, -0.012496948, -0.038635254, -0.047668457, -0.03086853, 0.028320312, 0.045562744, 0.011207581, 0.060668945, -0.038330078, 0.013122559, -0.046722412, 0.00089263916, -0.02027893, 0.0066604614, 0.003156662, -0.013328552, -0.012390137, 0.012268066, -0.00052928925, -0.010169983, 0.014259338, 0.023513794, -0.0075302124, 0.0029010773, -0.056884766, -0.0033836365, 0.004825592, -0.027832031, 0.021011353, -0.021118164, 0.0010318756, 0.005012512, -0.017196655, 0.034423828, 0.00067806244, 0.0056152344, 0.04660034, 0.034301758, -0.019470215, -0.0063591003, -0.01550293, -0.049591064, 0.0021800995, -0.053619385, -0.01084137, -0.037872314, -0.01777649, -0.07006836, -0.0073127747, 0.021377563, 0.009025574, 0.028198242, -0.0015554428, 0.03475952, 0.0048217773, 0.030181885, -0.047790527, 0.030349731, 0.019699097, 0.0041236877, 0.00033783913, 0.017349243, 0.024902344, 0.03186035, -0.008483887, 0.033111572, 0.00084352493, -0.019439697, 0.005748749, 0.024459839, 0.00497818, -0.009017944, -0.008255005, -0.022445679, 0.06185913, -0.007080078, 0.019821167, 0.060455322, 0.03881836, -0.0524292, -0.0013360977, 0.026107788, 0.0151901245, -0.02960205, 0.029876709, 0.048736572, -0.06665039, 0.012809753, -0.020935059, -0.019805908, 0.006668091, 0.010406494, 0.03074646, -0.07800293, -0.05960083, 0.034057617, 0.035949707, -0.011917114, 0.040893555, -0.03503418, -0.017227173, 0.0126953125, 0.011245728, -0.019104004, 0.0013198853, 0.036499023, 0.04699707, -0.008453369, 0.023803711, -0.004749298, 0.027664185, -0.016189575, 0.02520752, -0.05255127, 0.01651001, -0.010360718, -0.032836914, 0.021194458, -0.0088272095, -0.031982422, -0.01878357, 0.009498596, 0.019500732, 0.024536133, 0.044952393, 0.020935059, -0.025344849, -0.018371582, -0.05078125, 0.023498535, 0.05731201, -0.03567505, 0.0033245087, -0.016540527, -0.03265381, 0.026657104, -0.026473999, 0.037994385, -0.043029785, -0.004798889, -0.03756714, 0.040985107, 0.01461792, -0.06317139, -0.024658203, -0.022476196, -0.010284424, -0.0010080338, 0.003873825, -0.0073623657, -0.0015888214, 0.0178833, 0.023239136, 0.044281006, -0.0017299652, -0.014877319, -0.018463135, -0.048828125, 0.0048179626, -0.02458191, 0.03265381, 0.02809143, -0.03274536, -0.028366089, 0.0014295578, 0.00579834, 0.019088745, -0.007511139, 0.019470215, -0.037017822, -0.011634827, 0.029083252, 0.04473877, 0.016326904, 0.07318115, 0.006614685, 0.032318115, 0.0046463013, -0.029663086, 0.043548584, -0.01966858, -0.0289917, -0.011856079, -0.033996582, 0.005218506, 0.019256592, -0.03201294, 0.015655518, 0.0071640015, -0.045074463, -0.0060577393, 0.009544373, 0.053344727, -0.011482239, -0.010475159, -0.012527466, 0.046905518, 0.029891968, -0.060668945, -0.042541504, 0.0041542053, 0.032592773, -0.010551453, 0.038757324, 0.010055542, -0.0028877258, -0.027923584, 0.051940918, 0.008453369, -0.03894043, -0.052215576, -0.022628784, 0.0690918, 0.05621338, -0.01890564, -0.014465332, 0.036071777, -0.0007343292, -0.0026378632, -0.00415802, -0.018371582, -0.0027675629, -0.008277893, 0.050231934, 0.007335663, 0.02293396, 0.0019741058, 0.014579773, -0.0058174133, 0.02268982, -0.008964539, 0.0009636879, -0.005859375, 0.042663574, -0.032073975, -0.017913818, 0.026748657, 0.021530151, 0.012634277, 0.051208496, -0.016586304, -0.017105103, -0.010887146, 0.021713257, -0.0032310486, 0.0309906, 0.023864746, -0.010276794, 0.02456665, -0.045410156, -0.047058105, 0.016662598, -0.049743652, 0.039123535, -0.011749268, 0.010726929, 0.0132751465, -0.014526367, -0.016403198, 0.015655518, 0.012649536, -0.036987305, -0.04638672, -0.014282227, 0.044891357, -0.016784668 ], "summary": [ 0.037200928, -0.005756378, 0.020111084, 0.006511688, -0.012550354, -0.03338623, 0.020111084, -0.047790527, -0.05303955, 0.03225708, -0.03363037, 0.06317139, -0.039794922, -0.008255005, 0.034942627, -0.03842163, 0.019470215, 0.030136108, 0.010017395, -0.026672363, 0.014076233, -0.008216858, -0.014083862, 0.08972168, -0.0051727295, 0.03475952, -0.078430176, 0.007896423, -0.02482605, 0.008888245, -0.000395298, 0.007457733, 0.00025606155, 0.046142578, -0.048614502, -0.036132812, -0.017623901, 0.02633667, -0.013313293, 0.021697998, 0.027893066, -0.0021018982, 0.07922363, -0.012802124, 0.017227173, 0.028396606, -0.018173218, -0.033843994, 0.004371643, 0.007385254, 0.008972168, 0.017623901, 0.0039482117, 0.028839111, -0.022445679, -0.012397766, -0.042236328, -0.06713867, 0.033569336, 0.04525757, 0.01574707, -0.06311035, 0.021865845, -0.040008545, -0.0072746277, -0.023071289, 0.015029907, 0.021911621, -0.0005283356, -0.01007843, 0.027816772, 0.0026283264, 0.005882263, 0.0090789795, 0.02998352, -0.010383606, -0.012901306, 0.0007557869, 0.017028809, 0.027954102, 0.022491455, 0.053649902, 0.04788208, -0.062042236, 0.025009155, -0.062469482, -0.013473511, -0.00043010712, -0.009635925, -0.002117157, -0.03152466, 0.0151901245, -0.00793457, 0.030715942, -0.012954712, -0.00856781, 0.008674622, 0.010848999, 0.015556335, 0.04598999, -0.0040359497, -0.06222534, 0.07574463, -0.049957275, 0.016677856, 0.05532837, -0.006816864, -0.029144287, 0.031066895, -0.0057373047, -0.0019044876, 0.056610107, -0.024536133, -0.02204895, -0.012634277, 0.02305603, -0.026290894, -0.008705139, -0.009483337, -0.03555298, -0.021438599, 0.0063476562, -0.03265381, 0.05203247, 0.03253174, 0.029312134, 0.019729614, 0.005672455, 0.025466919, 0.0035171509, -0.019348145, 0.018112183, 0.011764526, -0.017211914, -0.01689148, -0.011558533, 0.025466919, 0.014785767, 0.012641907, -0.032196045, 0.041656494, -0.013145447, -0.0513916, 0.04446411, -0.009460449, 0.02748108, 0.017181396, 0.01133728, -0.00067567825, -0.06665039, 0.008277893, 0.013046265, 0.031341553, -0.0132369995, -0.0057640076, -0.04824829, -0.003019333, -0.028152466, 0.010726929, -0.042510986, 0.050048828, 0.03375244, 0.021392822, 0.074401855, 0.048736572, -0.04446411, -0.023117065, 0.008834839, -0.007499695, -0.005004883, 0.020843506, -0.035339355, -0.0869751, -0.035308838, 0.011268616, 0.00422287, -0.0024776459, 0.05319214, 0.007659912, -0.048980713, -0.021942139, -0.05090332, 0.026672363, 0.0069885254, -0.045959473, 0.04296875, -0.004722595, 0.038208008, 0.024734497, -0.0102005005, 0.022460938, 0.019729614, -0.045013428, 0.025970459, -0.053588867, 0.0395813, -0.022140503, 0.07305908, -0.045410156, -0.031829834, 0.025054932, 0.015220642, -0.0053482056, -0.021865845, -0.068237305, -0.012771606, -0.016830444, 0.018112183, -0.010467529, -0.007068634, 0.007537842, -0.029342651, 0.007850647, -0.04260254, -0.008392334, -0.0069618225, 0.020126343, -0.097229004, -0.015411377, -0.049682617, -0.04598999, 0.08428955, -0.09631348, 0.0056114197, -0.031051636, -0.017501831, -0.014968872, 0.0020942688, 0.037261963, -0.0138549805, 0.10675049, -0.016723633, -0.0090408325, 0.008911133, -0.002527237, 0.0012426376, 0.036834717, -0.06915283, 0.039855957, 0.04144287, 0.01133728, -0.017684937, -0.04928589, 0.027664185, -0.021499634, -0.041381836, -0.027938843, 0.03665161, -0.024765015, -0.014732361, 0.03729248, -0.013122559, 0.027160645, 0.006225586, 0.026473999, 0.011672974, -0.017456055, -0.011375427, -0.015975952, -0.0039901733, 0.010627747, -0.06939697, -0.017684937, -0.025390625, -0.02507019, -0.062683105, -0.0011110306, 0.000081419945, 0.0287323, -0.06970215, 0.022628784, 0.0062179565, 0.010688782, -0.011489868, -0.026916504, -0.053527832, -0.029251099, 0.028747559, 0.025604248, -0.03048706, -0.026351929, -0.019241333, -0.012954712, -0.00037121773, 0.0149002075, -0.03213501, 0.009361267, 0.0004775524, 0.008979797, 0.036590576, 0.06451416, 0.00655365, -0.012786865, 0.0076293945, -0.026550293, -0.011474609, -0.006500244, 0.018127441, -0.008003235, 0.021469116, -0.008506775, 0.0418396, 0.015975952, -0.0039787292, -0.012184143, 0.019897461, -0.00076055527, 0.022125244, -0.0102005005, -0.031585693, -0.009002686, 0.00756073, 0.0032424927, -0.011459351, -0.020126343, -0.0256958, -0.023452759, 0.0020198822, 0.021896362, 0.06549072, 0.10760498, 0.000374794, 0.032318115, 0.014015198, -0.010940552, -0.071899414, 0.04751587, -0.011581421, -0.02798462, 0.030960083, -0.011398315, -0.015182495, -0.016860962, 0.022079468, -0.009223938, 0.0074501038, 0.004234314, 0.028244019, 0.013435364, -0.0076141357, 0.04031372, -0.029418945, -0.011672974, 0.033935547, -0.001461029, -0.04525757, -0.0079956055, 0.0007362366, -0.02935791, -0.0015249252, 0.0124435425, -0.0016803741, -0.0070762634, 0.021606445, 0.049743652, -0.05130005, -0.030197144, 0.034454346, -0.008857727, -0.036132812, 0.032196045, 0.00045609474, -0.006122589, -0.078308105, -0.010665894, -0.013450623, 0.0009288788, -0.030548096, -0.024475098, 0.027252197, -0.075805664, -0.013549805, 0.0051879883, -0.002696991, 0.0023441315, 0.08074951, 0.05529785, -0.0020713806, 0.0020637512, 0.027114868, 0.034332275, 0.024993896, -0.013046265, -0.005748749, 0.070129395, 0.021636963, 0.06225586, 0.01020813, 0.07397461, -0.028839111, 0.009475708, -0.0104599, -0.010269165, -0.00983429, 0.020309448, -0.0048179626, -0.002002716, 0.021362305, -0.058532715, -0.014404297, 0.037506104, -0.0019426346, -0.0004940033, -0.0016851425, 0.009559631, 0.02809143, 0.046295166, -0.013801575, 0.012908936, 0.010307312, 0.00459671, 0.027954102, 0.005596161, 0.01751709, -0.0007805824, -0.013320923, 0.04434204, 0.0262146, -0.018417358, -0.05496216, -0.015464783, 0.05923462, -0.029403687, -0.046569824, 0.020736694, 0.0046653748, 0.013954163, -0.019348145, 0.010505676, 0.008735657, -0.0010032654, -0.014289856, -0.0063552856, -0.012046814, -0.011177063, -0.009315491, -0.018463135, -0.03866577, 0.006214142, -0.037750244, -0.041992188, 0.006980896, 0.029129028, 0.0259552, 0.025009155, -0.01625061, 0.009902954, -0.026733398, 0.013412476, -0.049682617, -0.024902344, -0.020965576, 0.0056991577, 0.024459839, -0.0060806274, 0.14245605, -0.025405884, 0.03845215, 0.05026245, -0.024291992, 0.020584106, -0.0059928894, -0.025634766, 0.027008057, 0.0021343231, 0.04473877, -0.0289917, 0.0033111572, -0.015838623, -0.007434845, 0.011894226, -0.019851685, -0.018661499, -0.023590088, -0.013267517, -0.0029182434, 0.039886475, -0.023239136, 0.07897949, -0.011688232, -0.0012378693, 0.014389038, -0.010620117, 0.025390625, 0.01109314, 0.016525269, -0.02619934, 0.0049362183, -0.008377075, 0.049987793, 0.04095459, 0.031402588, 0.042297363, 0.0259552, -0.014190674, -0.013748169, -0.006061554, 0.020050049, -0.014564514, -0.05819702, -0.02418518, 0.009002686, 0.009140015, 0.03137207, 0.0056152344, 0.04135132, 0.05166626, 0.022369385, -0.00016140938, 0.014328003, 0.015052795, -0.03475952, 0.019485474, 0.032287598, -0.013679504, -0.015022278, 0.018508911, 0.07733154, -0.06317139, -0.011405945, 0.037475586, 0.03326416, -0.03930664, 0.0015096664, 0.056671143, -0.007041931, -0.056884766, 0.049346924, 0.011306763, 0.017486572, -0.013069153, 0.000852108, 0.0060157776, 0.0066452026, 0.03186035, -0.017303467, -0.008346558, -0.008918762, 0.0072669983, 0.013824463, -0.014045715, -0.0024089813, 0.03552246, 0.015716553, -0.0037498474, -0.025802612, -0.04800415, 0.02810669, -0.06591797, 0.049865723, -0.013557434, -0.04046631, -0.02583313, -0.031280518, -0.011566162, 0.047607422, 0.0044555664, -0.009246826, -0.01889038, 0.012580872, 0.0049972534, -0.02067566, -0.026397705, 0.041015625, 0.04034424, 0.020217896, -0.04586792, -0.10998535, 0.027450562, -0.015266418, -0.025436401, -0.023895264, -0.00655365, -0.07495117, 0.0041542053, -0.030227661, -0.035827637, 0.014381409, 0.013771057, 0.08306885, 0.030288696, 0.036743164, -0.049224854, 0.006263733, 0.00089740753, -0.002670288, 0.0154800415, 0.00023245811, -0.004463196, -0.040802002, -0.05419922, 0.0135269165, -0.0137786865, -0.01776123, -0.0052261353, -0.007621765, 0.020111084, 0.0473938, 0.08654785, 0.013664246, 0.036834717, 0.004501343, 0.0095825195, -0.01725769, -0.019821167, -0.033966064, 0.007232666, 0.0028915405, 0.049743652, 0.014801025, -0.011665344, -0.049743652, -0.027908325, 0.0793457, -0.025344849, -0.029449463, -0.06414795, 0.05834961, 0.105163574, 0.008468628, 0.064819336, 0.010299683, -0.008308411, 0.024627686, 0.06518555, -0.006198883, -0.036346436, 0.021453857, 0.01675415, -0.010276794, -0.0018129349, -0.004524231, -0.05029297, -0.11956787, -0.04083252, 0.12243652, -0.0049095154, -0.042053223, 0.0012788773, 0.046875, 0.045013428, -0.017288208, -0.028427124, -0.041259766, -0.042266846, 0.012374878, -0.011039734, -0.012031555, -0.039398193, -0.032104492, 0.012893677, 0.033294678, 0.027786255, -0.010108948, -0.012229919, -0.0014152527, 0.020233154, -0.00025820732, -0.018997192, -0.043121338, -0.023910522, -0.021942139, -0.049468994, -0.030593872, 0.021728516, -0.0029201508, -0.03024292, 0.025985718, -0.011566162, 0.011146545, 0.0030326843, -0.05630493, 0.027664185, -0.012702942, 0.008224487, 0.05621338, -0.0115356445, 0.010498047, -0.00881958, 0.00920105, -0.017623901, -0.052703857, -0.038757324, 0.004688263, 0.003112793, 0.0052833557, 0.042175293, 0.025558472, 0.024261475, 0.012779236, 0.011451721, 0.03842163, 0.020050049, 0.022109985, -0.014511108, 0.03540039, 0.04006958, -0.03491211, -0.019897461, -0.06970215, 0.007522583, 0.0074501038, 0.034301758, 0.03253174, 0.0005478859, 0.0026836395, 0.043395996, -0.03643799, 0.030212402, 0.0018081665, -0.017700195, 0.027053833, -0.028060913, 0.011650085, 0.004257202, -0.053985596, -0.09710693, -0.024658203, -0.03237915, 0.018844604, -0.012809753, 0.0009975433, -0.014022827, -0.018707275, 0.016204834, -0.012779236, -0.04196167, 0.015388489, -0.009674072, -0.014968872, 0.008514404, 0.049835205, -0.047607422, 0.0020542145, 0.040527344, -0.044525146, 0.0014724731, 0.022521973, 0.0021018982, 0.0152282715, -0.0052986145, -0.007572174, 0.025009155, 0.0072402954, -0.056884766, -0.008285522, -0.0073280334, -0.008895874, 0.009750366, -0.04333496, 0.038909912, 0.03677368, -0.017929077, 0.0018548965, 0.025482178, 0.009994507, 0.012893677, -0.023788452, -0.020889282, -0.008087158, -0.011978149, 0.0037879944, 0.009216309, 0.03491211, -0.004421234, 0.066467285, -0.041015625, -0.04727173, 0.026412964, -0.001335144, -0.013931274, -0.005622864, 0.003068924, 0.02142334, -0.0025081635, 0.023666382, -0.023406982, 0.023834229, -0.0057411194, 0.018661499, 0.00088739395, 0.03491211, 0.012168884, -0.014266968, 0.006954193, 0.009391785, 0.019348145, -0.009086609, 0.007423401, -0.0018796921, -0.005405426, 0.010787964, -0.005634308, -0.024291992, 0.031143188, 0.025909424, -0.037475586, -0.012542725, -0.0043945312, -0.02671814, 0.025939941, -0.014945984, -0.0390625, -0.0074272156, -0.04257202, -0.0008773804, -0.031707764, 0.03503418, -0.034576416, 0.050354004, -0.007587433, 0.024642944, 0.027236938, -0.040496826, -0.0101623535, -0.020767212, 0.018295288, 0.011779785, -0.008621216, -0.020324707, -0.004673004, 0.04107666, -0.0033855438, 0.02444458, 0.027740479, -0.027374268, 0.028182983, 0.022033691, -0.009277344, -0.037384033, 0.011672974, -0.037200928, 0.057647705, 0.021469116, 0.041229248, 0.05038452, 0.0231781, -0.0012693405, -0.014892578, 0.033233643, 0.043792725, -0.037872314, 0.057769775, 0.037139893, -0.0013189316, -0.0048675537, -0.0076942444, -0.03741455, 0.05319214, 0.006290436, 0.04574585, -0.07543945, -0.019546509, -0.00036001205, 0.013290405, -0.06085205, 0.000893116, -0.040222168, -0.032592773, -0.0041236877, -0.011581421, -0.015304565, -0.026062012, 0.0099487305, -0.012046814, 0.027755737, 0.0037078857, 0.028533936, 0.024917603, 0.041168213, 0.01940918, -0.051086426, 0.014305115, -0.015037537, -0.02861023, 0.047973633, -0.006084442, 0.006801605, 0.011177063, 0.017196655, 0.01499939, 0.023742676, 0.029006958, -0.012687683, -0.0035419464, 0.027954102, -0.011383057, 0.0036792755, -0.019210815, -0.02319336, -0.026855469, -0.012130737, 0.016723633, -0.022521973, -0.030288696, -0.013946533, -0.033477783, 0.011795044, -0.04107666, 0.024414062, -0.0635376, -0.015014648, 0.019927979, -0.038604736, 0.005367279, 0.003704071, -0.0065193176, -0.008888245, 0.047546387, 0.006778717, -0.019683838, 0.08026123, -0.018066406, 0.023620605, -0.0023784637, -0.044006348, -0.004787445, -0.028030396, 0.031204224, -0.014007568, -0.04837036, -0.00068473816, 0.023162842, 0.04714966, 0.01701355, -0.0440979, 0.10003662, 0.03353882, -0.0149383545, 0.015945435, 0.050964355, 0.010147095, 0.03945923, 0.026657104, 0.023132324, 0.0070610046, 0.015838623, 0.02432251, -0.003396988, -0.017364502, 0.0007638931, 0.0016050339, -0.00032758713, -0.015319824, -0.02456665, 0.01763916, -0.0034427643, -0.046325684, -0.029190063, -0.006450653, 0.01084137, 0.009384155, -0.014945984, -0.032592773, 0.024642944, 0.033416748, -0.024627686, -0.014144897, 0.013114929, 0.024765015, -0.012077332, 0.016494751, 0.0104522705, 0.01902771, -0.02909851, 0.06222534, -0.0090408325, -0.035217285, -0.006298065, -0.015731812, 0.05810547, 0.008041382, -0.04345703, 0.023132324, 0.031066895, -0.025817871, -0.012542725, -0.029541016, 0.01727295, -0.02381897, -0.008323669, 0.010238647, -0.029815674, -0.009986877, 0.03250122, -0.018722534, -0.001244545, 0.017822266, -0.01876831, -0.0053138733, 0.0023078918, 0.022506714, -0.020080566, 0.0016326904, 0.027236938, -0.004547119, 0.025848389, -0.0028743744, 0.025619507, 0.0063438416, 0.02482605, 0.011985779, -0.0047912598, 0.0340271, 0.025604248, -0.036224365, 0.0006842613, -0.09753418, -0.0031280518, 0.02041626, -0.035003662, 0.010810852, -0.011802673, 0.0015745163, 0.017868042, 0.0076789856, 0.004558563, -0.01108551, -0.008453369, -0.03567505, 0.0076141357, 0.0234375, 0.0014429092, 0.0121536255 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2010.00330v3
Workflow Provenance in the Lifecycle of Scientific Machine Learning
Renan Souza, Leonardo G. Azevedo, Vítor Lourenço, Elton Soares, Raphael Thiago, Rafael Brandão, Daniel Civitarese, Emilio Vital Brazil, Marcio Moreno, Patrick Valduriez, Marta Mattoso, Renato Cerqueira, Marco A. S. Netto
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.DC, cs.LG, 65Y05, 68P15, I.2; H.2; C.4; J.2
Machine Learning (ML) has already fundamentally changed several businesses. More recently, it has also been profoundly impacting the computational science and engineering domains, like geoscience, climate science, and health science. In these domains, users need to perform comprehensive data analyses combining scientific data and ML models to provide for critical requirements, such as reproducibility, model explainability, and experiment data understanding. However, scientific ML is multidisciplinary, heterogeneous, and affected by the physical constraints of the domain, making such analyses even more challenging. In this work, we leverage workflow provenance techniques to build a holistic view to support the lifecycle of scientific ML. We contribute with (i) characterization of the lifecycle and taxonomy for data analyses; (ii) design principles to build this view, with a W3C PROV compliant data representation and a reference system architecture; and (iii) lessons learned after an evaluation in an Oil & Gas case using an HPC cluster with 393 nodes and 946 GPUs. The experiments show that the principles enable queries that integrate domain semantics with ML models while keeping low overhead (<1%), high scalability, and an order of magnitude of query acceleration under certain workloads against without our representation.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2010.00330v3
"2021-08-25T14:26:33"
"2020-09-30T13:09:48"
{ "title": [ -0.0413208, -0.011924744, -0.06500244, -0.054382324, -0.011650085, -0.017333984, -0.031951904, 0.027359009, -0.03152466, 0.03778076, -0.0058021545, 0.0138168335, -0.005622864, -0.041534424, -0.018356323, 0.01058197, 0.007534027, 0.007598877, -0.01473999, -0.021331787, -0.029006958, -0.009933472, 0.04425049, 0.0058250427, 0.03842163, -0.021957397, -0.082336426, 0.01574707, -0.01361084, -0.009475708, 0.00018000603, 0.0016679764, 0.033477783, -0.00655365, 0.011070251, 0.039398193, -0.03451538, 0.026535034, 0.017318726, -0.011871338, 0.015930176, -0.0021781921, 0.020858765, -0.053619385, -0.01777649, 0.024032593, -0.05255127, -0.0099487305, -0.0066604614, 0.07519531, 0.018463135, 0.01600647, -0.0013036728, 0.08203125, 0.013534546, -0.016708374, -0.0047454834, -0.054840088, 0.029190063, 0.040985107, 0.017471313, -0.027877808, 0.034301758, -0.011245728, -0.017181396, -0.026138306, -0.037017822, 0.018814087, 0.038482666, -0.008453369, -0.0057296753, 0.0045318604, -0.00047516823, 0.015899658, -0.021499634, -0.023742676, 0.06921387, 0.028869629, -0.0022182465, -0.00415802, 0.0069885254, -0.060455322, 0.012863159, -0.0051460266, 0.016220093, 0.01309967, 0.0006093979, -0.009475708, -0.005580902, -0.035491943, 0.0049095154, -0.010353088, 0.00018298626, 0.049560547, -0.010261536, -0.023895264, -0.008758545, 0.016052246, 0.008712769, -0.030044556, -0.026977539, 0.016098022, -0.07446289, -0.0021018982, 0.000047922134, 0.031555176, 0.010749817, 0.008583069, -0.01789856, 0.009689331, -0.0340271, -0.022399902, 0.014663696, -0.02508545, 0.035858154, 0.0033130646, -0.009841919, 0.05706787, 0.003753662, 0.030380249, 0.0050239563, -0.029388428, -0.0040893555, 0.03152466, 0.036010742, -0.0013113022, -0.049926758, 0.025497437, -0.03314209, 0.050079346, -0.012245178, 0.033843994, -0.06072998, -0.067871094, -0.049804688, 0.010017395, 0.008377075, 0.010437012, -0.01687622, 0.0132751465, 0.02709961, -0.008804321, 0.0075798035, 0.028640747, -0.025939941, 0.0032100677, 0.043518066, 0.00283432, -0.04849243, -0.044036865, -0.029647827, 0.011222839, 0.029418945, -0.023040771, -0.05633545, -0.023223877, -0.096191406, -0.0070152283, 0.03491211, -0.016937256, 0.006149292, 0.015960693, 0.015457153, 0.032043457, 0.06384277, -0.011383057, 0.016159058, 0.027038574, 0.00223732, 0.015396118, -0.010749817, 0.0069770813, -0.013069153, -0.031463623, -0.016830444, -0.0022563934, 0.024978638, 0.022903442, -0.010818481, 0.0137786865, 0.016708374, -0.022384644, -0.013450623, 0.045806885, -0.054229736, -0.042999268, 0.0021514893, -0.009239197, 0.037322998, 0.0062408447, -0.0035114288, 0.024856567, -0.05847168, -0.040405273, -0.021987915, 0.01979065, 0.023635864, 0.041107178, 0.0069465637, -0.018569946, -0.02670288, 0.037963867, -0.053649902, 0.020553589, -0.0067596436, -0.028564453, 0.012329102, 0.019226074, -0.043395996, 0.05960083, 0.05331421, 0.022354126, -0.03237915, 0.0021457672, 0.028671265, -0.04055786, -0.012527466, -0.036499023, -0.025619507, -0.016815186, -0.046539307, -0.006465912, -0.025436401, 0.029220581, -0.024032593, 0.04272461, -0.03375244, 0.022994995, 0.015457153, 0.035308838, 0.097717285, -0.04071045, 0.011306763, 0.0015478134, -0.026992798, -0.029663086, -0.01600647, -0.03189087, 0.022964478, 0.041625977, 0.011550903, -0.017364502, 0.011161804, 0.03793335, 0.06665039, 0.039855957, 0.021697998, -0.0013914108, 0.032958984, 0.04916382, 0.027893066, 0.0056648254, 0.03604126, 0.015472412, -0.008758545, 0.051849365, -0.009361267, -0.020477295, 0.025817871, 0.0067253113, 0.013084412, 0.025939941, 0.0040397644, 0.013191223, -0.073791504, 0.03793335, -0.034423828, 0.025665283, -0.0184021, 0.02407837, 0.043060303, -0.0035152435, 0.012420654, 0.025177002, -0.011268616, 0.006793976, -0.010398865, 0.0011615753, 0.0006542206, -0.019332886, -0.025131226, -0.027328491, 0.04196167, 0.0079956055, -0.013023376, -0.0045280457, 0.06915283, 0.018463135, -0.017364502, -0.002872467, 0.070129395, 0.023834229, -0.0019025803, 0.0077667236, -0.012268066, -0.00041627884, 0.09057617, 0.066345215, -0.026641846, 0.033325195, -0.07659912, 0.014953613, 0.0423584, -0.026138306, -0.0013256073, 0.053131104, 0.04647827, -0.024917603, -0.03390503, 0.029922485, -0.060546875, -0.016540527, 0.020248413, -0.028533936, -0.03805542, -0.054016113, -0.023727417, -0.023544312, -0.087768555, -0.05126953, 0.06817627, -0.00818634, 0.012680054, -0.014099121, 0.003211975, -0.038604736, 0.004070282, -0.023284912, -0.038208008, 0.007297516, 0.0037765503, -0.010063171, -0.06817627, -0.029815674, -0.013374329, 0.023269653, -0.01689148, 0.048828125, -0.011177063, -0.019363403, -0.0077781677, -0.008995056, 0.0031280518, -0.043762207, 0.029724121, -0.06945801, -0.008834839, 0.006450653, -0.018066406, -0.006526947, 0.03451538, -0.0041275024, -0.0012607574, 0.002149582, 0.052001953, -0.040740967, -0.01612854, 0.035491943, 0.049346924, -0.016464233, 0.028839111, 0.024139404, 0.014915466, -0.025726318, -0.04840088, -0.055541992, 0.012275696, -0.0050201416, -0.002002716, 0.026046753, -0.026931763, -0.013626099, -0.023284912, -0.0033569336, -0.0032615662, -0.006652832, -0.00687027, -0.03778076, -0.039276123, -0.0074768066, 0.0030975342, 0.012817383, -0.04159546, -0.021743774, 0.049865723, -0.008392334, -0.05090332, -0.012519836, 0.030288696, 0.03137207, -0.0035877228, -0.025497437, -0.0026798248, -0.00090026855, 0.003774643, 0.0012168884, -0.016723633, -0.0029144287, -0.050628662, 0.004459381, 0.018478394, 0.005569458, -0.024353027, 0.01737976, -0.06726074, -0.0029296875, -0.028533936, -0.0129776, 0.02960205, -0.0034866333, 0.013023376, -0.032348633, 0.024169922, -0.056365967, 0.015235901, -0.06414795, -0.11993408, 0.033447266, -0.046783447, 0.01399231, 0.0053710938, -0.0022964478, -0.036499023, -0.004146576, -0.013687134, 0.054504395, 0.03314209, 0.019454956, 0.002111435, 0.0035762787, 0.028030396, -0.025543213, -0.014717102, -0.04248047, -0.055999756, 0.015655518, -0.00010597706, 0.08294678, 0.0284729, 0.0021190643, -0.0016994476, 0.009269714, 0.006111145, 0.041778564, -0.011238098, -0.027618408, -0.0031490326, -0.013168335, 0.022201538, 0.019897461, 0.0012750626, -0.0024051666, 0.017227173, -0.0036582947, -0.02420044, -0.0010280609, 0.026885986, 0.025634766, -0.037506104, 0.004047394, 0.040405273, -0.015090942, -0.03878784, 0.01687622, 0.008354187, -0.014190674, 0.01574707, 0.008956909, -0.03302002, 0.014892578, -0.015777588, 0.020767212, 0.016464233, -0.0015115738, -0.004322052, 0.000113248825, -0.023788452, 0.02003479, -0.025344849, 0.00051546097, -0.014350891, 0.023101807, -0.030776978, -0.08618164, -0.028152466, 0.012168884, -0.109191895, -0.035705566, -0.004425049, -0.07183838, -0.08135986, -0.03338623, -0.008285522, -0.051879883, -0.02935791, 0.0014362335, -0.0104599, 0.013694763, 0.00084877014, -0.07458496, -0.01272583, 0.060302734, -0.008224487, 0.003063202, -0.01991272, 0.01826477, 0.005466461, -0.028930664, 0.01852417, -0.027664185, 0.010971069, -0.04220581, -0.012619019, 0.026062012, -0.02583313, 0.044769287, -0.0029964447, -0.028182983, 0.012916565, 0.022491455, 0.013206482, 0.038269043, -0.06304932, 0.038726807, 0.05206299, -0.01876831, -0.08251953, 0.02645874, -0.022903442, -0.008430481, 0.026794434, 0.021972656, 0.028884888, -0.007167816, -0.003742218, 0.0317688, -0.010345459, -0.047790527, -0.008987427, -0.008354187, 0.0032024384, -0.005092621, -0.0010519028, 0.022415161, 0.0031585693, -0.0024776459, 0.004508972, 0.04550171, -0.0084991455, -0.015014648, 0.020828247, 0.02960205, -0.008071899, -0.0031089783, -0.06866455, -0.029846191, -0.030136108, 0.019897461, -0.005634308, 0.008850098, 0.028305054, 0.032592773, -0.04522705, 0.0009121895, 0.03805542, 0.007904053, -0.005168915, -0.04626465, -0.0008134842, -0.009490967, -0.076416016, -0.051452637, 0.028274536, 0.014808655, 0.030471802, -0.019195557, -0.033081055, 0.01071167, 0.00945282, 0.04284668, 0.046783447, -0.009140015, -0.049865723, -0.007987976, -0.0051460266, 0.038879395, -0.03161621, 0.024856567, -0.0073928833, -0.006603241, -0.01713562, 0.0023612976, -0.010688782, -0.061035156, -0.0032482147, -0.020050049, 0.02331543, 0.05090332, 0.06951904, 0.024627686, 0.010673523, 0.0033740997, -0.0027427673, -0.036621094, 0.006427765, -0.0079956055, 0.048858643, 0.0011034012, 0.03616333, 0.025299072, 0.01084137, -0.009864807, -0.026000977, 0.04373169, 0.001420021, -0.02508545, 0.0030345917, -0.02331543, -0.046051025, -0.022384644, -0.0032157898, -0.0005865097, 0.055725098, -0.02986145, 0.05291748, -0.0259552, 0.0074653625, 0.030715942, 0.0016527176, -0.0048294067, -0.000259161, 0.0036239624, -0.07891846, -0.062927246, -0.040771484, 0.06262207, -0.041168213, -0.034179688, 0.023025513, 0.037261963, 0.0075302124, 0.038085938, 0.011482239, 0.0064086914, 0.026657104, -0.015853882, -0.01109314, -0.016983032, -0.03439331, 0.03555298, -0.013404846, 0.010665894, -0.018875122, -0.030349731, -0.037231445, -0.010032654, 0.0076560974, -0.006362915, 0.030944824, -0.04196167, 0.03744507, 0.08721924, -0.024368286, 0.041412354, -0.039123535, 0.004016876, 0.07098389, 0.016616821, 0.01158905, -0.0026493073, 0.014930725, 0.0019330978, 0.01828003, 0.0023498535, 0.04449463, -0.01826477, 0.015083313, 0.010177612, -0.010299683, -0.0657959, 0.027633667, 0.012672424, 0.00036287308, -0.004901886, -0.041259766, 0.031829834, 0.013191223, 0.012840271, 0.025543213, -0.041137695, -0.042144775, 0.0008831024, 0.0029525757, -0.0032024384, 0.033233643, 0.033691406, -0.037841797, -0.017837524, 0.0236969, -0.008529663, 0.0027561188, 0.005584717, 0.0021839142, -0.022827148, 0.029830933, 0.035003662, -0.05206299, 0.01739502, -0.027236938, -0.00016534328, 0.032196045, 0.03866577, -0.030731201, -0.016571045, -0.014122009, -0.057403564, -0.019378662, -0.0021018982, 0.011917114, 0.0034179688, -0.018096924, -0.031341553, -0.013908386, -0.026489258, -0.00012040138, 0.020095825, -0.028289795, 0.023162842, 0.010887146, 0.02041626, 0.006641388, 0.06451416, 0.02986145, -0.0044136047, 0.0005879402, -0.02229309, 0.02067566, -0.020812988, -0.026565552, -0.016738892, -0.0395813, 0.004085541, 0.018432617, -0.0077056885, -0.006095886, 0.00091362, 0.044677734, 0.04989624, -0.017044067, 0.012046814, 0.08935547, -0.07922363, -0.03125, -0.0082092285, 0.019500732, 0.001964569, 0.064941406, -0.005279541, -0.018554688, -0.044281006, -0.02949524, -0.03414917, 0.0025348663, 0.024261475, -0.0065307617, 0.02229309, -0.0032749176, 0.017364502, 0.012634277, -0.013687134, -0.0395813, 0.036193848, -0.0008058548, 0.00843811, 0.013114929, -0.016983032, -0.0034446716, 0.00002592802, 0.024169922, 0.016616821, -0.013801575, 0.028915405, -0.038879395, 0.0048980713, -0.045654297, -0.012161255, 0.035858154, 0.07318115, -0.06616211, 0.04257202, -0.025161743, 0.06738281, 0.03050232, 0.03781128, 0.0418396, -0.02027893, 0.002210617, 0.0037631989, -0.007881165, -0.033721924, 0.011627197, -0.039001465, -0.009208679, -0.03829956, -0.013999939, -0.09698486, -0.016357422, 0.046966553, -0.014045715, 0.008163452, -0.013824463, -0.01876831, 0.031036377, 0.0070114136, 0.051116943, 0.018066406, -0.014976501, -0.014122009, 0.005012512, -0.006538391, 0.033935547, 0.040618896, 0.0045318604, 0.0102005005, 0.009056091, 0.0017328262, 0.005947113, -0.0028133392, 0.022155762, 0.0071907043, 0.01550293, 0.0013542175, 0.02859497, -0.017990112, 0.023117065, 0.06335449, 0.054351807, -0.042663574, -0.015914917, 0.009300232, 0.017669678, -0.014831543, 0.0072364807, 0.042388916, -0.057617188, 0.019073486, -0.016983032, -0.02810669, -0.03845215, 0.011291504, 0.02746582, -0.054107666, -0.028167725, 0.04135132, 0.025268555, 0.0048294067, 0.0010976791, -0.03225708, -0.049102783, 0.016937256, 0.040130615, -0.028701782, 0.015274048, 0.0021343231, 0.015930176, -0.012924194, -0.037628174, 0.0061035156, 0.016052246, -0.025787354, 0.015853882, -0.014213562, 0.014556885, -0.04724121, -0.042297363, -0.022949219, 0.012779236, -0.061279297, -0.024856567, 0.06121826, 0.041412354, 0.030639648, 0.08203125, 0.015014648, -0.004558563, -0.014595032, -0.0131073, 0.04144287, 0.022537231, -0.035003662, 0.0041389465, -0.019241333, -0.024108887, 0.033966064, -0.019363403, 0.061065674, -0.029159546, 0.037200928, -0.018951416, 0.006084442, 0.038208008, -0.074523926, -0.010101318, 0.01637268, -0.03074646, 0.0011844635, 0.0071487427, -0.006164551, -0.030044556, -0.0043411255, 0.024032593, 0.015716553, -0.030303955, -0.012428284, -0.01524353, -0.034973145, -0.009002686, -0.03427124, 0.015571594, -0.014656067, -0.021118164, -0.0035114288, -0.015052795, 0.022567749, -0.006099701, -0.030395508, -0.009765625, -0.018814087, -0.039520264, 0.014663696, 0.015403748, -0.032989502, -0.080444336, -0.03237915, -0.018753052, -0.046203613, -0.0016365051, 0.008926392, -0.05203247, -0.01600647, 0.017807007, -0.053497314, 0.033233643, 0.052856445, 0.0040130615, 0.016143799, 0.009483337, -0.008354187, -0.04953003, 0.012016296, 0.014274597, 0.025100708, -0.026062012, -0.029205322, 0.04916382, 0.061645508, -0.050933838, -0.03930664, 0.017425537, 0.018585205, -0.031463623, 0.06738281, 0.00019538403, 0.0027370453, 0.035308838, 0.040283203, 0.0044174194, -0.039398193, -0.05203247, -0.03591919, 0.015701294, 0.028961182, -0.018325806, -0.0107803345, 0.043426514, -0.016952515, 0.012001038, -0.0013008118, -0.035247803, 0.009880066, -0.012275696, 0.0039711, 0.0073127747, 0.00932312, -0.039031982, -0.0058517456, 0.024230957, 0.059143066, -0.03186035, 0.017791748, 0.0040779114, 0.10473633, 0.04815674, -0.05456543, 0.023086548, 0.03463745, 0.031799316, 0.030471802, -0.006084442, -0.08117676, -0.01449585, -0.00944519, -0.0039901733, -0.008148193, 0.027618408, -0.0020961761, -0.009086609, -0.0038433075, -0.035736084, -0.03378296, -0.03186035, 0.032440186, -0.050994873, 0.022384644, -0.05227661, 0.0017433167, 0.00033855438, -0.003232956, 0.0044174194, -0.018585205, -0.052337646, -0.032409668, 0.022491455, -0.011581421 ], "summary": [ -0.014854431, -0.03274536, -0.058898926, -0.029006958, -0.046325684, -0.026184082, -0.03463745, 0.026626587, 0.00749588, 0.012550354, -0.015426636, 0.0128479, -0.018936157, -0.027709961, 0.022750854, -0.025863647, 0.010009766, 0.005859375, 0.015113831, -0.024978638, 0.017044067, -0.022720337, 0.015625, 0.010124207, 0.006084442, -0.018966675, -0.03289795, 0.030090332, -0.010971069, 0.03125, 0.00680542, -0.008781433, 0.016281128, -0.025299072, 0.042175293, 0.054992676, 0.044311523, -0.025741577, 0.023086548, 0.027130127, 0.03237915, -0.013771057, 0.10211182, -0.07318115, 0.028762817, 0.036376953, 0.003921509, -0.03314209, 0.018325806, 0.0076789856, 0.027374268, 0.016693115, 0.016052246, 0.008605957, -0.024749756, 0.00409317, -0.0027694702, -0.06341553, -0.0009241104, 0.022155762, 0.03488159, -0.0053520203, 0.034332275, 0.010658264, -0.008140564, -0.023529053, 0.027557373, 0.007888794, 0.022964478, -0.013809204, 0.0034751892, 0.027679443, 0.00015449524, -0.040374756, 0.015327454, 0.028320312, 0.03314209, 0.025253296, -0.030532837, -0.003921509, -0.01878357, -0.0020980835, -0.017166138, -0.017425537, 0.0027198792, 0.019592285, -0.013122559, -0.002199173, -0.0038070679, -0.022583008, -0.017745972, 0.012580872, -0.030548096, 0.041656494, 0.01663208, -0.022201538, -0.037963867, -0.04598999, 0.023269653, 0.0031642914, 0.02734375, -0.03451538, -0.009773254, -0.0035572052, -0.021575928, 0.05935669, 0.03189087, -0.009521484, -0.025939941, -0.000059962273, -0.0006079674, -0.045928955, 0.00737381, -0.031677246, 0.008987427, 0.034210205, 0.004760742, 0.04232788, 0.0008125305, 0.023483276, -0.016601562, 0.0012168884, -0.037719727, 0.027740479, 0.042388916, -0.007255554, 0.00004053116, 0.03540039, -0.028518677, 0.028869629, -0.021011353, 0.016998291, 0.007850647, 0.009063721, -0.028762817, -0.018585205, 0.04901123, 0.014190674, -0.0030326843, -0.016479492, 0.0463562, 0.020065308, -0.04220581, 0.021438599, -0.015174866, 0.016281128, 0.024307251, 0.0014438629, -0.030212402, -0.014122009, -0.015388489, 0.008026123, 0.061340332, -0.041992188, -0.0647583, -0.07128906, -0.040771484, -0.022476196, 0.008041382, -0.047302246, -0.00497818, 0.018676758, 0.061035156, 0.04638672, 0.050994873, -0.005012512, -0.02229309, -0.011024475, 0.010726929, -0.040924072, 0.011634827, 0.016998291, 0.013908386, -0.026931763, 0.007396698, 0.00080156326, 0.0071983337, 0.04272461, -0.026397705, 0.029876709, 0.025268555, -0.037994385, 0.0014486313, 0.03414917, -0.004501343, -0.024490356, 0.005367279, -0.010673523, 0.01776123, 0.010734558, 0.0014257431, 0.012001038, -0.04324341, 0.020370483, -0.013084412, -0.02494812, -0.033569336, -0.006591797, 0.0079193115, 0.0071411133, 0.006187439, 0.038208008, -0.053466797, -0.009239197, -0.036346436, -0.026275635, 0.035705566, 0.026184082, -0.024658203, 0.04244995, 0.02027893, 0.0021839142, -0.033294678, 0.040130615, 0.036132812, -0.024719238, 0.024353027, -0.039489746, -0.019226074, -0.03793335, -0.03378296, 0.038482666, -0.04196167, 0.040222168, -0.05126953, 0.026504517, -0.03387451, 0.034851074, 0.023376465, 0.011383057, 0.10644531, -0.040740967, 0.0110321045, 0.019104004, -0.00116539, -0.0048332214, 0.025131226, -0.0758667, 0.0015745163, 0.039611816, 0.014671326, -0.04034424, -0.033569336, 0.018676758, -0.0062217712, 0.028030396, 0.014877319, 0.021270752, 0.01134491, 0.046722412, 0.030395508, 0.012481689, 0.0032844543, 0.0007019043, -0.0003437996, 0.024505615, 0.0132751465, -0.014198303, 0.04937744, 0.002916336, 0.006378174, 0.034454346, -0.01902771, 0.024002075, -0.068115234, 0.03036499, -0.014755249, 0.011108398, 0.0007982254, -0.009757996, 0.03050232, -0.011856079, -0.011711121, 0.042419434, -0.11804199, 0.006374359, 0.0132751465, 0.023406982, -0.04437256, -0.0061683655, -0.024749756, -0.035369873, -0.027664185, -0.0057296753, 0.018157959, 0.00084877014, 0.029174805, 0.027282715, 0.06854248, 0.06964111, 0.0597229, 0.034057617, 0.010887146, 0.04953003, -0.018722534, -0.013648987, 0.0597229, 0.0036907196, 0.0075187683, -0.00705719, -0.01398468, 0.03753662, 0.00049352646, -0.008804321, 0.011260986, 0.041168213, 0.015777588, -0.013061523, 0.0036144257, 0.019119263, -0.045898438, 0.0045700073, 0.038330078, 0.024536133, -0.015716553, -0.027694702, -0.01953125, 0.04348755, -0.04321289, -0.007160187, 0.10998535, 0.02848816, -0.0010576248, 0.0015916824, 0.008369446, -0.042755127, 0.020721436, -0.025756836, -0.047058105, -0.032470703, -0.06951904, -0.072631836, -0.05215454, -0.0008301735, -0.0154953, 0.0088272095, 0.00050115585, 0.0053367615, -0.00038003922, -0.01826477, 0.005104065, -0.020690918, -0.010192871, -0.020584106, -0.021453857, -0.021820068, 0.0040740967, -0.0105896, -0.0025501251, 0.008270264, -0.0005469322, 0.02357483, -0.0042915344, 0.028579712, -0.000500679, -0.03262329, 0.033813477, 0.038269043, -0.0099105835, -0.026428223, -0.011711121, 0.0006685257, -0.050079346, -0.05380249, -0.02154541, 0.002576828, 0.022872925, -0.014907837, 0.016464233, 0.030548096, 0.00060224533, 0.019851685, -0.045776367, -0.0073432922, -0.010467529, 0.0028629303, 0.05935669, -0.0048942566, -0.0013332367, 0.03564453, 0.0018196106, 0.001578331, -0.019165039, -0.04034424, 0.052001953, -0.009140015, -0.0060653687, 0.014167786, 0.048461914, 0.019958496, -0.0023765564, -0.036834717, 0.083984375, -0.034332275, 0.010955811, -0.018829346, -0.004673004, 0.06665039, -0.01373291, -0.020858765, 0.028274536, 0.037017822, 0.028549194, 0.00579834, -0.05392456, 0.034576416, -0.034210205, -0.0045700073, 0.012565613, -0.02128601, 0.026367188, -0.048309326, 0.011672974, -0.040161133, -0.003604889, -0.042663574, -0.0473938, 0.018707275, -0.035583496, -0.001996994, -0.030227661, 0.066467285, -0.039733887, -0.008773804, -0.0011968613, 0.023757935, 0.0071372986, 0.03137207, -0.02420044, 0.00459671, 0.0011396408, -0.025817871, -0.03463745, -0.037506104, -0.01675415, 0.02558899, -0.014480591, 0.022354126, -0.017120361, -0.019195557, -0.00015604496, 0.019958496, 0.020935059, 0.03277588, -0.0036735535, 0.009162903, 0.046966553, 0.006401062, 0.08343506, 0.04373169, 0.0070114136, -0.020004272, 0.052124023, 0.001996994, -0.045196533, -0.03665161, 0.012390137, 0.03756714, 0.0063819885, 0.0066452026, 0.039855957, -0.011550903, -0.012641907, 0.010551453, 0.016235352, 0.0031280518, -0.013069153, 0.037353516, -0.013404846, -0.0037021637, 0.029800415, -0.019119263, -0.012069702, -0.013504028, -0.037200928, -0.02305603, 0.025817871, -0.0030899048, 0.054840088, -0.018310547, -0.08703613, 0.050628662, -0.053619385, -0.09869385, -0.0368042, 0.008010864, -0.057159424, -0.07446289, -0.022262573, -0.032836914, -0.0390625, -0.043304443, 0.0063819885, -0.009727478, -0.03527832, 0.0115356445, -0.021087646, 0.15100098, 0.027801514, -0.07543945, 0.03781128, -0.031829834, 0.021224976, 0.025131226, -0.028945923, 0.048828125, 0.0395813, 0.0023326874, -0.0072250366, -0.043395996, 0.018203735, -0.061340332, -0.008728027, 0.00056028366, -0.01008606, 0.03945923, -0.0009651184, -0.03366089, 0.02116394, 0.0079193115, 0.038848877, 0.06732178, -0.041900635, 0.0050735474, 0.052642822, -0.025054932, -0.016662598, 0.012077332, -0.007160187, -0.016693115, 0.024429321, 0.03817749, 0.0026550293, 0.008834839, -0.009544373, -0.013397217, -0.011009216, -0.04901123, -0.01486969, 0.010734558, -0.00038290024, 0.0043563843, 0.0181427, 0.034362793, -0.004234314, 0.042022705, 0.02909851, 0.07373047, -0.030960083, 0.025222778, 0.0037841797, 0.020248413, -0.02229309, -0.033996582, -0.0044555664, 0.0065345764, -0.022583008, 0.0042915344, -0.014030457, 0.023544312, -0.002922058, 0.006778717, 0.000998497, -0.0059165955, 0.07122803, 0.031707764, -0.02154541, -0.07244873, -0.0026454926, 0.0012493134, -0.07458496, -0.020126343, -0.012954712, -0.021224976, 0.010093689, -0.00080394745, -0.00116539, 0.01828003, -0.018600464, -0.01586914, 0.03704834, -0.0287323, -0.03253174, -0.025131226, -0.023803711, 0.08380127, -0.021408081, 0.039123535, -0.01512146, 0.030975342, -0.011581421, 0.022537231, -0.01789856, -0.075805664, -0.0049705505, 0.005836487, -0.041870117, 0.055908203, 0.08258057, 0.014274597, 0.034606934, -0.023712158, -0.0062217712, -0.033813477, 0.029830933, -0.074035645, 0.036010742, -0.0236969, 0.06137085, 0.020004272, -0.034240723, -0.10076904, 0.0019483566, 0.087646484, -0.0012302399, -0.05279541, 0.002986908, -0.03527832, -0.03503418, -0.006336212, 0.010658264, -0.0154953, 0.024047852, 0.02557373, -0.029464722, 0.006702423, 0.038330078, 0.017837524, -0.025222778, 0.011650085, -0.0037994385, 0.0011262894, -0.052856445, -0.064086914, -0.050109863, 0.0546875, -0.0074539185, -0.07305908, 0.008636475, 0.025268555, -0.02607727, 0.031082153, -0.006275177, -0.01399231, 0.08557129, 0.0026474, -0.017166138, -0.0016174316, -0.03982544, 0.0284729, -0.029510498, -0.004310608, -0.0036735535, -0.06304932, 0.009384155, -0.02709961, 0.029006958, 0.00869751, -0.0011425018, -0.026000977, -0.0052604675, 0.016571045, 0.0018129349, -0.019088745, -0.015945435, -0.04019165, 0.007534027, 0.016296387, -0.038513184, -0.0009236336, -0.0075645447, -0.040802002, 0.0063972473, -0.0099105835, -0.00038671494, 0.0017414093, 0.009529114, -0.0032634735, -0.028457642, -0.01676941, -0.010673523, 0.00065279007, 0.007881165, -0.0110321045, -0.0116119385, 0.051879883, 0.026748657, 0.001039505, 0.0039520264, -0.017578125, 0.0057296753, 0.020965576, 0.01159668, 0.015357971, 0.014076233, 0.012611389, -0.027740479, -0.009811401, -0.020843506, 0.01121521, 0.029220581, -0.006980896, 0.0075149536, -0.019042969, -0.014038086, 0.010627747, 0.01424408, -0.0000693202, -0.013198853, -0.020309448, -0.021530151, 0.03225708, -0.032592773, -0.011329651, -0.061462402, -0.021820068, -0.021942139, -0.019592285, 0.015609741, 0.059570312, -0.037841797, 0.0018491745, -0.011260986, -0.03375244, 0.012390137, 0.013198853, -0.057373047, -0.0034179688, -0.0057678223, 0.00024867058, 0.016189575, 0.01247406, 0.01789856, -0.0061073303, -0.016021729, -0.0390625, 0.00042533875, -0.032562256, -0.04034424, -0.020385742, -0.0027389526, -0.004787445, 0.006828308, -0.0020275116, -0.009109497, -0.017623901, 0.0033912659, 0.052215576, -0.009681702, -0.02897644, 0.07128906, -0.027877808, -0.020111084, -0.02960205, 0.035614014, -0.040161133, -0.013191223, -0.02418518, 0.007637024, 0.0032310486, -0.04940796, 0.012481689, -0.03479004, -0.013824463, 0.033721924, 0.0024986267, 0.04232788, 0.047332764, 0.011451721, -0.021530151, -0.04309082, -0.002046585, -0.019378662, -0.01928711, 0.07940674, 0.0039863586, -0.024856567, 0.045318604, 0.0024738312, 0.025253296, -0.023651123, 0.07446289, -0.02609253, 0.0007414818, -0.03842163, 0.029724121, 0.010246277, 0.08148193, -0.053588867, 0.0015163422, 0.03567505, 0.032226562, 0.0143966675, -0.051208496, -0.013130188, -0.017196655, -0.0067977905, -0.013000488, -0.05307007, -0.021087646, 0.022338867, -0.014213562, -0.069885254, -0.05480957, -0.05517578, 0.0016050339, 0.0019779205, -0.00466156, -0.038604736, 0.07067871, -0.026382446, -0.007598877, 0.06689453, -0.081726074, 0.087646484, -0.02659607, -0.0059814453, -0.036132812, 0.01083374, -0.002023697, 0.013893127, 0.05496216, -0.009429932, 0.01878357, -0.005908966, 0.006313324, 0.023269653, -0.0037155151, -0.02079773, -0.0065574646, 0.042785645, -0.020690918, 0.013618469, 0.006565094, 0.056152344, 0.020126343, -0.012245178, -0.0043754578, -0.0031204224, 0.0026817322, 0.042022705, -0.016021729, 0.03074646, 0.03488159, -0.014328003, -0.024154663, 0.007411957, -0.026931763, 0.029525757, -0.003145218, 0.033966064, -0.05883789, -0.021133423, 0.017044067, 0.009101868, -0.014770508, 0.005290985, -0.025894165, -0.013542175, 0.0113220215, -0.0146102905, 0.0044517517, 0.008804321, -0.0021400452, 0.004463196, 0.039611816, -0.022781372, 0.010948181, 0.002910614, 0.022232056, 0.032928467, 0.012207031, 0.008720398, -0.010299683, -0.021331787, 0.0053977966, 0.02217102, -0.0066337585, 0.004837036, 0.05102539, 0.037475586, 0.056610107, 0.05697632, -0.027877808, 0.037841797, 0.067993164, -0.0077934265, 0.004096985, 0.029571533, -0.014045715, -0.032287598, -0.011955261, 0.0043640137, -0.010383606, -0.0012836456, -0.00062942505, -0.032470703, 0.02230835, -0.040405273, 0.018051147, -0.053619385, -0.023254395, 0.022415161, -0.022720337, -0.064819336, 0.028533936, 0.05038452, -0.0051727295, 0.0028209686, -0.01737976, -0.04837036, -0.02470398, -0.023742676, 0.005176544, -0.012207031, -0.047668457, 0.029937744, -0.0042915344, 0.06982422, 0.0041122437, -0.018035889, 0.017654419, -0.0074272156, 0.030700684, -0.023513794, -0.024414062, -0.008377075, 0.0047721863, -0.025390625, 0.054473877, 0.05935669, -0.022338867, -0.07885742, 0.01171875, -0.025909424, -0.0446167, 0.042175293, -0.016052246, -0.018966675, 0.006336212, 0.033966064, -0.047546387, -0.011695862, -0.00945282, 0.049194336, -0.012359619, 0.033172607, 0.004802704, -0.083618164, 0.0007286072, -0.010147095, 0.048339844, -0.050689697, -0.020889282, 0.011299133, 0.023468018, -0.026046753, -0.034454346, 0.040222168, 0.014953613, -0.0021247864, -0.001584053, -0.032165527, -0.02330017, 0.0446167, 0.033843994, 0.010665894, 0.0014820099, -0.00541687, -0.012542725, 0.06964111, 0.0006761551, -0.03677368, 0.020690918, 0.030456543, -0.024398804, 0.00005733967, 0.02229309, -0.016616821, -0.00932312, -0.004337311, 0.0017223358, -0.020370483, -0.033691406, 0.014732361, -0.04434204, 0.01499176, -0.013847351, -0.02961731, -0.004798889, -0.060180664, -0.0011854172, 0.044708252, -0.02041626, 0.012054443, 0.010635376, 0.032806396, -0.03640747, 0.015083313, -0.047698975, -0.03982544, -0.01725769, 0.017578125, -0.019134521, -0.01134491, -0.0098724365, 0.022354126, -0.04147339, -0.014518738, -0.04159546, -0.041015625, 0.02017212, -0.017166138, 0.0049324036, 0.008422852, 0.019210815, 0.01373291, -0.020523071, -0.019165039, -0.007698059, 0.0014066696, -0.02571106, -0.04208374, -0.0009937286 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2010.00353v1
When will the mist clear? On the Interpretability of Machine Learning for Medical Applications: a survey
Antonio-Jesús Banegas-Luna, Jorge Peña-García, Adrian Iftene, Fiorella Guadagni, Patrizia Ferroni, Noemi Scarpato, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto, Andrés Bueno-Crespo, Horacio Pérez-Sánchez
cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.QM
Artificial Intelligence is providing astonishing results, with medicine being one of its favourite playgrounds. In a few decades, computers may be capable of formulating diagnoses and choosing the correct treatment, while robots may perform surgical operations, and conversational agents could interact with patients as virtual coaches. Machine Learning and, in particular, Deep Neural Networks are behind this revolution. In this scenario, important decisions will be controlled by standalone machines that have learned predictive models from provided data. Among the most challenging targets of interest in medicine are cancer diagnosis and therapies but, to start this revolution, software tools need to be adapted to cover the new requirements. In this sense, learning tools are becoming a commodity in Python and Matlab libraries, just to name two, but to exploit all their possibilities, it is essential to fully understand how models are interpreted and which models are more interpretable than others. In this survey, we analyse current machine learning models, frameworks, databases and other related tools as applied to medicine - specifically, to cancer research - and we discuss their interpretability, performance and the necessary input data. From the evidence available, ANN, LR and SVM have been observed to be the preferred models. Besides, CNNs, supported by the rapid development of GPUs and tensor-oriented programming libraries, are gaining in importance. However, the interpretability of results by doctors is rarely considered which is a factor that needs to be improved. We therefore consider this study to be a timely contribution to the issue.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2010.00353v1
"2020-10-01T12:42:06"
"2020-10-01T12:42:06"
{ "title": [ -0.021240234, 0.013572693, -0.01424408, -0.02911377, 0.013435364, 0.0019931793, -0.022262573, -0.04925537, -0.02305603, 0.0032253265, -0.013053894, -0.011306763, -0.015007019, -0.03692627, -0.03677368, -0.021133423, -0.005970001, 0.04324341, -0.0015926361, -0.029190063, -0.019927979, -0.039367676, 0.048919678, 0.048614502, 0.024597168, -0.022384644, -0.06274414, 0.0016231537, -0.044158936, -0.049621582, -0.016571045, 0.02998352, 0.018066406, 0.027664185, 0.002784729, 0.008308411, -0.03213501, 0.036834717, 0.021911621, -0.0088272095, 0.022338867, -0.014984131, -0.022949219, -0.05328369, -0.027954102, 0.017623901, -0.051452637, -0.012413025, -0.0008354187, 0.01979065, 0.020614624, 0.025238037, -0.00042152405, 0.036743164, 0.013595581, -0.027023315, -0.01222229, -0.018356323, 0.032104492, 0.05734253, 0.028625488, -0.039154053, 0.011489868, -0.008720398, -0.03845215, -0.013076782, -0.020858765, 0.02810669, 0.06677246, 0.008888245, -0.023345947, 0.029083252, 0.0029525757, -0.008163452, -0.062683105, 0.013000488, 0.05618286, 0.008903503, 0.014038086, -0.044891357, 0.028900146, -0.020706177, 0.029266357, 0.008201599, 0.013504028, 0.01979065, -0.0154953, -0.02999878, -0.048736572, -0.045288086, -0.005958557, -0.023452759, -0.01574707, 0.0014944077, -0.01651001, -0.024780273, -0.038391113, -0.0031261444, 0.008514404, -0.011756897, -0.0021247864, 0.013313293, -0.05355835, -0.0063476562, 0.013092041, 0.05230713, -0.009315491, -0.047576904, -0.011444092, 0.012680054, -0.016281128, -0.010765076, 0.010734558, -0.012214661, 0.020996094, 0.038604736, 0.008903503, 0.02243042, 0.023529053, 0.032073975, 0.004714966, -0.020751953, -0.0021533966, 0.027648926, 0.015525818, -0.008979797, -0.043151855, 0.001376152, -0.056549072, 0.061065674, 0.027328491, 0.022537231, -0.11303711, -0.060943604, -0.0592041, 0.02960205, 0.016815186, -0.006088257, -0.010826111, -0.012512207, 0.026824951, -0.020248413, -0.01676941, 0.008934021, -0.032562256, 0.013458252, 0.0670166, -0.008377075, -0.06817627, -0.06903076, -0.021469116, 0.005580902, 0.027420044, -0.0011539459, -0.070251465, 0.014022827, -0.11932373, -0.0029411316, -0.000079631805, 0.00843811, 0.030288696, 0.0066337585, -0.013137817, 0.005393982, 0.04562378, -0.015449524, -0.027328491, 0.031921387, 0.008972168, -0.012756348, -0.0036315918, 0.03225708, 0.017333984, 0.0059928894, 0.00440979, 0.0099487305, 0.021560669, 0.009063721, 0.020935059, -0.01537323, -0.0053215027, -0.032836914, 0.009757996, 0.04058838, -0.062347412, -0.008987427, 0.004421234, 0.02243042, 0.046844482, 0.0064697266, -0.05279541, 0.025268555, -0.016647339, -0.03543091, -0.04547119, -0.03237915, 0.025878906, 0.038330078, -0.020980835, -0.0041885376, -0.0018434525, 0.009613037, -0.032989502, -0.0005812645, -0.016555786, -0.020706177, -0.010612488, 0.016525269, -0.02909851, 0.068237305, 0.043029785, 0.015487671, -0.03555298, 0.04574585, 0.028930664, -0.062286377, 0.03463745, -0.007385254, -0.022338867, -0.03945923, -0.04473877, -0.025131226, -0.013259888, 0.058288574, 0.018630981, 0.020904541, -0.003479004, -0.02909851, 0.055633545, 0.014419556, 0.10089111, -0.033355713, 0.01285553, 0.0009965897, -0.020767212, -0.02897644, -0.0030136108, -0.011405945, 0.0154800415, 0.01638794, 0.007698059, -0.013511658, -0.011260986, 0.014663696, 0.07550049, 0.028411865, 0.011260986, 0.006965637, 0.011985779, 0.014198303, 0.05014038, 0.0035877228, 0.052642822, 0.019332886, 0.006538391, 0.050354004, -0.0042533875, -0.010803223, 0.0040664673, 0.022018433, -0.02027893, 0.019927979, 0.017578125, 0.015197754, -0.061401367, 0.032226562, -0.039123535, 0.0015668869, -0.013244629, 0.029937744, 0.043762207, -0.018585205, 0.020462036, 0.01525116, 0.0071792603, 0.0044403076, -0.018508911, -0.0033302307, 0.011871338, -0.03829956, -0.015327454, -0.003435135, 0.016052246, -0.0015001297, 0.024368286, -0.0064468384, 0.01259613, -0.018753052, -0.0051460266, -0.01486969, 0.041656494, 0.039642334, 0.011772156, -0.009010315, -0.015899658, -0.0025596619, 0.06744385, 0.0703125, -0.031433105, 0.024490356, -0.07183838, 0.010040283, 0.003019333, -0.0236969, -0.0004608631, 0.033935547, 0.006778717, 0.032958984, -0.024658203, -0.0024700165, -0.024963379, 0.007381439, 0.0067596436, -0.0057258606, -0.045898438, -0.070373535, -0.01977539, -0.035064697, -0.066711426, -0.02293396, 0.08105469, -0.010917664, -0.014450073, -0.033050537, 0.010116577, -0.025680542, -0.033843994, -0.03186035, -0.021133423, -0.0023021698, 0.031280518, -0.014282227, -0.062805176, -0.0074386597, -0.0019989014, 0.02229309, -0.0211792, 0.028015137, -0.030960083, -0.005340576, -0.0046958923, 0.014152527, 0.023529053, -0.056640625, -0.016983032, -0.04196167, 0.0044555664, 0.016418457, -0.052093506, -0.015037537, 0.045928955, -0.013282776, -0.039916992, 0.024368286, 0.039154053, -0.03616333, 0.01965332, 0.045806885, 0.027770996, -0.004573822, 0.053375244, 0.018295288, 0.028961182, -0.01574707, -0.051940918, -0.07080078, 0.017471313, -0.013694763, -0.0015220642, 0.044708252, -0.064819336, -0.011451721, -0.025482178, -0.0011081696, 0.0256958, 0.026351929, 0.0082473755, -0.004890442, -0.034942627, -0.00059986115, -0.0018701553, 0.010879517, -0.022094727, -0.011329651, 0.067871094, -0.008377075, -0.008018494, -0.0023593903, 0.042114258, 0.014572144, 0.0019741058, -0.029800415, 0.023925781, 0.004016876, -0.008796692, 0.004219055, -0.003692627, 0.009628296, -0.074523926, 0.0090789795, 0.039794922, 0.008666992, -0.031677246, 0.024642944, -0.07684326, 0.023498535, -0.008094788, -0.0021076202, 0.01991272, 0.07507324, -0.01399231, 0.037872314, -0.0019893646, 0.017242432, 0.013298035, -0.016906738, -0.13146973, 0.022964478, -0.008178711, -0.0056991577, -0.0055274963, -0.022506714, -0.06768799, -0.0046958923, -0.019973755, 0.061828613, 0.032958984, 0.0129470825, 0.039154053, 0.007194519, 0.024261475, -0.016540527, -0.019165039, -0.04751587, -0.014961243, -0.0054016113, 0.0017242432, 0.090026855, -0.0048599243, 0.023086548, -0.027252197, -0.0076560974, -0.0035591125, 0.02999878, -0.0067481995, -0.030563354, 0.0045280457, -0.0050468445, 0.0012226105, -0.0042495728, -0.007820129, -0.016693115, -0.015411377, 0.009643555, -0.018249512, 0.027832031, 0.00089645386, 0.012481689, -0.009841919, -0.027191162, 0.010826111, -0.03475952, -0.033355713, 0.018005371, 0.014656067, 0.011238098, 0.029769897, -0.007347107, -0.020462036, 0.013252258, -0.027114868, 0.0021095276, 0.010398865, -0.0020751953, 0.0076789856, 0.013542175, -0.024871826, 0.0127334595, -0.029907227, 0.024887085, -0.026977539, 0.021652222, -0.015731812, -0.10571289, -0.019897461, 0.0041770935, -0.117126465, -0.05014038, 0.022125244, -0.07684326, -0.034088135, -0.077819824, 0.022888184, -0.06878662, -0.029373169, -0.009925842, -0.026870728, 0.008415222, -0.020767212, -0.066467285, -0.03994751, 0.064331055, 0.024414062, 0.029541016, 0.0051460266, -0.018966675, 0.007003784, -0.026748657, 0.010604858, -0.022872925, 0.045288086, -0.0059432983, -0.0016832352, 0.060180664, -0.04135132, 0.01675415, 0.012275696, 0.027999878, -0.013473511, -0.00044298172, 0.0012302399, 0.026351929, -0.029205322, 0.04800415, 0.021347046, -0.027160645, -0.053375244, 0.014045715, 0.0010051727, -0.023910522, 0.027557373, 0.005104065, 0.022109985, 0.024398804, 0.006099701, 0.06384277, -0.012496948, -0.013847351, -0.00944519, -0.026657104, -0.01600647, 0.024932861, 0.039916992, 0.01096344, 0.0018262863, 0.028152466, -0.0020160675, 0.035308838, -0.0022277832, -0.037963867, 0.0045280457, 0.017242432, -0.039520264, -0.015655518, -0.05255127, -0.050811768, -0.024215698, 0.008888245, -0.008850098, 0.018478394, 0.023361206, -0.026123047, -0.033325195, 0.016998291, 0.031463623, 0.010246277, -0.007926941, -0.054534912, -0.0022029877, -0.014122009, -0.06964111, -0.042663574, -0.024597168, -0.005104065, 0.02998352, 0.007331848, -0.017990112, 0.021148682, 0.021728516, 0.048309326, 0.05053711, -0.028671265, -0.06359863, 0.0015459061, -0.048919678, -0.030792236, 0.04006958, -0.031280518, -0.009155273, -0.029785156, 0.023406982, -0.0069618225, -0.019485474, -0.043640137, 0.02519226, 0.0006623268, 0.028945923, -0.0033397675, 0.012519836, 0.021453857, 0.012237549, 0.016159058, 0.007255554, -0.02268982, -0.03527832, 0.00039482117, 0.042510986, 0.0067253113, 0.018981934, 0.042236328, 0.02822876, -0.016647339, 0.007007599, 0.015457153, 0.023803711, 0.0031414032, -0.0044822693, 0.0033092499, -0.04220581, -0.047088623, -0.0008788109, 0.0146865845, 0.05117798, -0.034851074, 0.028945923, -0.0079422, 0.0005760193, 0.013938904, -0.02520752, 0.020355225, -0.020874023, 0.022537231, -0.05480957, -0.04486084, -0.006378174, 0.03062439, -0.031204224, -0.006298065, 0.013305664, 0.009590149, 0.03756714, 0.024139404, 0.02684021, 0.011947632, -0.025558472, -0.0076179504, -0.00141716, -0.02796936, -0.04135132, 0.029342651, -0.0006337166, 0.012138367, -0.034057617, -0.029693604, -0.08203125, -0.021957397, -0.008918762, -0.027664185, 0.018737793, -0.075805664, 0.007774353, 0.048706055, -0.008659363, 0.03652954, -0.0519104, 0.02798462, 0.025634766, 0.034484863, -0.007369995, 0.034423828, 0.019317627, -0.0060806274, 0.009895325, 0.011703491, 0.044647217, 0.025436401, 0.0068092346, 0.0076675415, -0.01448822, -0.040374756, 0.024093628, 0.012672424, -0.013465881, 0.024291992, -0.05429077, 0.021911621, 0.0008378029, -0.020217896, 0.004447937, -0.027999878, -0.010101318, 0.034820557, -0.026824951, 0.009941101, 0.0519104, 0.00044465065, -0.033447266, -0.06774902, -0.005886078, -0.0051727295, -0.0032730103, -0.008888245, 0.035308838, -0.04537964, 0.01713562, -0.022109985, -0.08050537, 0.004989624, -0.0010080338, 0.019073486, 0.021011353, -0.0053520203, -0.07287598, -0.018310547, 0.006454468, -0.07354736, -0.05218506, 0.030883789, 0.027038574, -0.016967773, -0.015075684, -0.034240723, -0.013542175, -0.009552002, 0.003993988, 0.017974854, -0.037628174, 0.038360596, 0.016525269, 0.01928711, 0.004211426, 0.037017822, 0.019424438, -0.0061073303, -0.0024051666, -0.05633545, 0.008743286, -0.016830444, -0.0007033348, -0.011062622, -0.036621094, 0.0051231384, 0.012458801, 0.0024547577, -0.014038086, -0.011657715, 0.036132812, 0.03869629, -0.007183075, -0.00002861023, 0.09655762, -0.06542969, -0.057434082, -0.022750854, 0.017745972, -0.02130127, 0.058410645, -0.034729004, -0.055786133, -0.01524353, -0.04949951, -0.025650024, -0.0027122498, 0.010925293, 0.035614014, 0.022415161, -0.042633057, 0.013725281, -0.022644043, -0.015808105, -0.016433716, -0.001247406, 0.008026123, -0.0064582825, 0.022644043, 0.0042037964, 0.0007019043, -0.043273926, 0.012428284, 0.014572144, 0.016647339, 0.0043029785, -0.036865234, -0.0006403923, -0.042938232, -0.008049011, 0.035308838, 0.0446167, -0.056152344, 0.037841797, -0.013038635, 0.0670166, 0.024505615, 0.012908936, 0.023620605, 0.003446579, 0.023773193, -0.011039734, 0.0032157898, -0.030090332, 0.016952515, -0.04736328, -0.003124237, -0.056854248, -0.0044670105, -0.06738281, 0.0048179626, 0.027832031, 0.03152466, 0.0024700165, 0.007572174, 0.013092041, 0.03781128, 0.04006958, 0.014434814, 0.070129395, 0.030075073, 0.0024871826, 0.011642456, 0.023498535, -0.0049209595, 0.017791748, 0.00447464, 0.02809143, -0.01763916, -0.023529053, 0.0048446655, 0.01890564, 0.007873535, -0.024353027, -0.0042686462, -0.03567505, 0.016967773, -0.034240723, 0.0074920654, 0.07092285, 0.051116943, 0.005290985, -0.019805908, 0.005092621, 0.004863739, -0.015319824, -0.013473511, 0.042541504, -0.06506348, 0.0072135925, -0.009590149, -0.022567749, -0.014968872, 0.048858643, 0.010948181, -0.04031372, -0.017974854, 0.014335632, 0.037506104, 0.017700195, -0.007965088, -0.03363037, -0.0064964294, 0.024536133, 0.03491211, -0.0031375885, 0.0287323, 0.017974854, 0.022857666, 0.000641346, -0.021011353, -0.0055351257, 0.0501709, -0.052856445, 0.015266418, -0.00042033195, 0.0027198792, -0.043823242, -0.03970337, -0.009246826, 0.0008420944, -0.054382324, -0.021408081, 0.056854248, 0.008399963, -0.008666992, 0.05505371, 0.0058403015, -0.024642944, -0.033233643, -0.020614624, 0.02029419, 0.022567749, -0.035125732, 0.017044067, -0.025253296, -0.03540039, 0.040649414, -0.036254883, 0.05871582, -0.050598145, -0.018463135, -0.022750854, 0.03149414, 0.029571533, -0.036224365, -0.021697998, -0.041229248, -0.0036354065, -0.015037537, 0.014694214, -0.03451538, -0.046813965, 0.00030899048, 0.020889282, 0.001625061, 0.011436462, 0.006225586, -0.04949951, -0.07434082, 0.027236938, 0.0077400208, 0.07330322, -0.0071907043, 0.0016832352, -0.021652222, 0.011543274, -0.009490967, -0.010116577, -0.023010254, 0.016220093, -0.007675171, -0.04623413, 0.020080566, 0.031951904, -0.035186768, -0.057556152, -0.010063171, -0.009490967, -0.034576416, -0.0029010773, 0.012550354, -0.042938232, -0.01751709, -0.0020561218, -0.035705566, 0.023773193, 0.034301758, -0.006008148, -0.015899658, 0.030807495, -0.02357483, -0.02658081, -0.013198853, 0.030685425, -0.025436401, -0.07507324, 0.0057296753, 0.01449585, 0.02532959, -0.045715332, -0.040863037, 0.04360962, 0.022613525, -0.003730774, 0.06311035, -0.007904053, 0.009674072, 0.033843994, 0.041809082, 0.022262573, -0.04397583, -0.07171631, -0.020233154, 0.066833496, 0.054229736, -0.0069770813, -0.030899048, 0.03543091, -0.01928711, -0.0062065125, 0.0042686462, 0.0057373047, 0.009513855, 0.009147644, 0.018295288, -0.010894775, -0.039001465, -0.011306763, 0.012313843, 0.00207901, 0.037841797, -0.012496948, 0.0012760162, -0.00207901, 0.08532715, 0.006980896, -0.016403198, 0.029174805, 0.004398346, 0.03741455, 0.03866577, -0.018234253, -0.025634766, 0.0019292831, -0.030044556, -0.017623901, -0.02406311, 0.052581787, -0.04309082, -0.012214661, -0.05682373, -0.044189453, -0.024368286, -0.02470398, 0.024261475, -0.042297363, 0.016983032, -0.04248047, -0.013168335, -0.0033454895, 0.035858154, 0.031951904, -0.011474609, -0.053222656, -0.031021118, 0.052124023, -0.030456543 ], "summary": [ 0.000770092, -0.0021781921, 0.022842407, 0.022979736, -0.030441284, -0.013092041, 0.0035572052, -0.05819702, 0.017044067, 0.013977051, -0.02470398, -0.024993896, 0.0017652512, -0.038116455, 0.0014734268, -0.03201294, 0.012435913, -0.0011224747, 0.054107666, -0.034179688, 0.026763916, -0.040618896, 0.06994629, 0.03878784, 0.0053901672, -0.01739502, -0.035858154, 0.011703491, -0.011177063, 0.0008196831, -0.010192871, -0.004901886, -0.020233154, 0.03717041, 0.010772705, 0.052734375, 0.009063721, 0.04019165, 0.04446411, 0.003396988, 0.03161621, -0.03161621, 0.07312012, -0.0602417, 0.024841309, 0.066101074, -0.0029315948, -0.041534424, 0.0289917, -0.028381348, 0.017303467, 0.022460938, 0.018005371, 0.010749817, -0.030975342, 0.024047852, 0.0014133453, -0.06738281, 0.0151901245, -0.00097608566, 0.020370483, -0.033843994, 0.026412964, 0.011291504, -0.019866943, -0.008140564, 0.05368042, 0.018417358, 0.02015686, -0.02017212, 0.014724731, 0.049346924, 0.007457733, -0.05380249, -0.04333496, 0.057250977, 0.024154663, 0.022491455, -0.01902771, -0.04067993, 0.027496338, -0.0020122528, 0.041625977, -0.0025691986, -0.0018043518, 0.008117676, -0.008995056, -0.027175903, -0.04019165, 0.005256653, -0.030136108, -0.023880005, -0.040740967, 0.051757812, 0.022140503, -0.018417358, -0.0713501, -0.070251465, 0.025436401, 0.013252258, 0.031097412, -0.029281616, 0.013977051, 0.002374649, -0.014907837, 0.090026855, 0.012130737, -0.05001831, -0.03466797, -0.0069618225, 0.011566162, -0.084106445, -0.0013074875, -0.053497314, -0.0070648193, 0.06628418, 0.031951904, 0.0058517456, 0.00030183792, 0.015357971, 0.0032634735, 0.02267456, -0.03213501, 0.021636963, 0.009185791, -0.021133423, -0.0041160583, 0.020614624, -0.044006348, 0.10424805, 0.02168274, -0.019088745, -0.030288696, -0.0010633469, -0.0491333, -0.03024292, -0.010856628, -0.046936035, 0.01071167, -0.009590149, 0.04748535, -0.015838623, -0.015716553, 0.058013916, -0.01612854, 0.007572174, 0.013267517, 0.015487671, -0.0038928986, -0.015899658, -0.005973816, 0.017166138, 0.028778076, -0.014381409, -0.028778076, 0.002708435, -0.017471313, 0.007259369, -0.00026082993, 0.0056533813, 0.014442444, 0.028045654, 0.020614624, -0.016571045, -0.0060272217, -0.028793335, -0.06726074, -0.008071899, 0.012939453, -0.094055176, -0.002855301, 0.034210205, 0.026931763, -0.013534546, 0.018981934, -0.00019836426, -0.037109375, 0.0063285828, -0.017105103, 0.012634277, 0.013404846, -0.042755127, -0.028671265, 0.05291748, -0.0016746521, -0.0016202927, -0.008712769, -0.000061154366, 0.037261963, 0.0090408325, -0.043914795, 0.009567261, 0.010559082, -0.0021419525, -0.0023593903, -0.027175903, 0.009521484, 0.029388428, -0.018203735, -0.03567505, 0.010421753, 0.012420654, -0.018432617, -0.031799316, -0.060424805, -0.0001821518, -0.013084412, 0.028213501, -0.0395813, 0.033813477, 0.02432251, -0.010955811, -0.027435303, 0.04812622, 0.011413574, -0.044067383, 0.02267456, 0.021026611, -0.010726929, -0.010650635, -0.0034008026, -0.01499939, -0.014419556, 0.045318604, 0.015731812, 0.011474609, 0.0043640137, -0.010368347, 0.07305908, 0.009864807, 0.08685303, -0.03213501, 0.0021591187, -0.0016288757, -0.031051636, -0.0009870529, -0.0013513565, -0.052124023, 0.005695343, 0.04269409, 0.0029144287, 0.0055770874, -0.009590149, 0.015312195, 0.06439209, 0.061767578, 0.03427124, 0.004737854, 0.025939941, 0.011650085, -0.033996582, -0.03189087, 0.0513916, -0.002204895, 0.02027893, 0.037841797, 0.005306244, -0.015602112, 0.033203125, 0.026931763, -0.004863739, 0.047851562, 0.007095337, 0.017150879, -0.035339355, 0.000044107437, -0.016983032, -0.011131287, -0.020690918, -0.004257202, 0.019729614, 0.00011587143, -0.0067749023, 0.019226074, -0.0010080338, 0.023834229, -0.009628296, -0.009986877, 0.00844574, -0.0033035278, 0.02746582, 0.012535095, 0.04006958, -0.013771057, 0.0259552, 0.016159058, 0.036102295, 0.04107666, 0.041900635, 0.039489746, 0.05432129, 0.03125, -0.0012207031, 0.020401001, -0.025344849, -0.014671326, 0.013175964, 0.059570312, -0.016967773, 0.007259369, -0.012138367, -0.0003604889, -0.031341553, -0.005973816, 0.005279541, 0.0027713776, 0.0016822815, 0.008529663, -0.0019683838, -0.0140686035, -0.0073165894, 0.026687622, 0.0128479, 0.072509766, -0.06329346, -0.07318115, -0.04788208, 0.009925842, -0.08526611, -0.03274536, 0.07757568, 0.007232666, 0.016448975, -0.009361267, 0.015060425, -0.060546875, 0.021957397, -0.0014286041, -0.014663696, -0.0020618439, 0.011665344, -0.008071899, -0.016098022, 0.037872314, 0.0055503845, 0.008590698, 0.006954193, 0.060058594, 0.012229919, -0.04031372, 0.012641907, 0.027557373, -0.012557983, 0.0013246536, -0.02142334, -0.0024547577, 0.0104904175, -0.014724731, 0.058380127, 0.029464722, -0.035583496, 0.010719299, -0.030288696, 0.061950684, 0.0070114136, -0.044525146, 0.059417725, 0.08258057, -0.006996155, -0.0027275085, 0.04534912, 0.0018072128, 0.02432251, 0.004917145, -0.064575195, -0.023101807, 0.033172607, -0.0033473969, 0.050811768, 0.029022217, -0.058044434, 0.060180664, -0.036071777, 0.022155762, 0.07128906, 0.032684326, 0.045135498, -0.014717102, 0.008979797, 0.041809082, 0.026275635, 0.031402588, 0.022232056, 0.032104492, 0.042663574, -0.0029296875, 0.04385376, 0.0096206665, 0.057647705, 0.000060737133, 0.01083374, -0.024261475, 0.061920166, -0.032592773, -0.0149002075, -0.005859375, -0.030044556, 0.011405945, -0.00035762787, -0.007003784, -0.0023880005, 0.048553467, 0.017440796, 0.023208618, -0.04208374, 0.0635376, -0.028564453, -0.019744873, 0.009208679, 0.021011353, -0.00819397, -0.0058288574, -0.018630981, 0.00074481964, -0.013847351, 0.0046310425, -0.0546875, 0.009567261, 0.00024092197, 0.019363403, -0.030227661, 0.07446289, -0.046142578, 0.0053634644, -0.021453857, 0.015914917, 0.00667572, 0.015533447, 0.012283325, 0.061065674, 0.009056091, 0.0024814606, -0.030960083, -0.045684814, -0.015037537, 0.013999939, -0.002008438, 0.04977417, -0.015594482, -0.0005235672, -0.0014429092, -0.015304565, -0.0064964294, 0.005706787, -0.011619568, -0.0067596436, 0.0016717911, 0.029922485, -0.003921509, -0.020492554, 0.004283905, 0.0008239746, 0.01663208, 0.0385437, -0.004470825, 0.055511475, -0.04727173, 0.037261963, 0.058380127, -0.070495605, -0.012969971, -0.05029297, -0.015106201, 0.034362793, 0.026687622, 0.007610321, -0.025650024, 0.0135650635, -0.025222778, 0.021942139, 0.022369385, -0.02217102, -0.027267456, -0.01171875, 0.0003991127, -0.016479492, 0.0062561035, -0.0112838745, 0.049621582, 0.025939941, -0.043548584, 0.034973145, -0.0049819946, -0.094177246, -0.04916382, -0.010429382, -0.08276367, -0.062561035, 0.042785645, -0.038482666, -0.005973816, -0.041870117, 0.046142578, -0.027023315, 0.010749817, -0.01852417, -0.030517578, 0.10803223, 0.015808105, -0.056732178, 0.02861023, -0.040130615, 0.03744507, 0.018829346, -0.027648926, 0.050598145, 0.063964844, 0.027297974, -0.020645142, -0.033325195, 0.03652954, -0.035949707, 0.028686523, 0.029754639, -0.026260376, 0.017929077, 0.02116394, 0.01512146, 0.0026817322, 0.00066661835, 0.039245605, 0.07043457, -0.033081055, 0.0017337799, 0.029464722, -0.017745972, -0.018127441, 0.024551392, 0.0014314651, -0.024032593, 0.030593872, 0.04901123, -0.018844604, 0.0030136108, -0.0077781677, -0.03274536, -0.022857666, -0.05795288, -0.005958557, 0.045928955, -0.029266357, -0.012321472, 0.013259888, 0.079589844, -0.02229309, 0.013221741, -0.042236328, 0.016433716, -0.033447266, -0.009284973, 0.01637268, 0.008644104, -0.0042037964, -0.03768921, 0.019592285, -0.031082153, 0.0049362183, -0.0027618408, 0.009407043, -0.005054474, 0.01209259, -0.018432617, -0.0053977966, 0.022369385, 0.08312988, 0.013191223, -0.024246216, -0.088378906, -0.000016510487, -0.022979736, -0.040618896, -0.03768921, -0.031555176, -0.012397766, -0.024536133, 0.014549255, -0.0022773743, 0.0057296753, 0.030456543, 0.037597656, 0.014556885, 0.0028076172, -0.03466797, -0.00198555, -0.03552246, -0.0036907196, 0.016494751, -0.016342163, -0.022506714, -0.006416321, 0.0044059753, 0.004096985, 0.0025043488, -0.060791016, -0.0066108704, 0.012184143, -0.016555786, -0.004333496, -0.019607544, -0.012649536, 0.0132751465, 0.011459351, -0.0067977905, 0.012619019, -0.012557983, 0.019485474, 0.04208374, 0.0007300377, 0.0017051697, 0.034820557, 0.0068588257, -0.04019165, 0.01309967, 0.012275696, 0.009498596, 0.022369385, -0.00033712387, -0.0107040405, 0.01448822, 0.00075769424, 0.03111267, 0.020111084, 0.013771057, 0.016647339, -0.018310547, 0.02720642, 0.026977539, 0.0158844, -0.041290283, 0.009765625, -0.021743774, -0.006549835, -0.025604248, -0.047454834, 0.0011825562, 0.029190063, 0.019104004, 0.005973816, -0.0030975342, -0.005104065, 0.018188477, 0.0017709732, -0.033081055, 0.031204224, 0.02003479, 0.029022217, 0.031433105, -0.021713257, -0.018463135, -0.000104129314, 0.009300232, 0.001039505, 0.0061073303, -0.047973633, 0.0019416809, -0.032226562, -0.011749268, -0.010787964, 0.024230957, -0.033111572, -0.029968262, 0.042144775, -0.02482605, 0.017852783, 0.01574707, 0.0040893555, -0.044311523, 0.025634766, -0.046417236, 0.017913818, -0.021057129, -0.0446167, -0.007865906, 0.01777649, 0.018508911, 0.037994385, -0.009162903, 0.008171082, -0.011962891, 0.0051116943, 0.01524353, 0.029937744, -0.0071144104, 0.016281128, -0.02998352, 0.046447754, -0.027923584, -0.00969696, -0.026977539, -0.037322998, 0.01777649, 0.055786133, -0.039886475, 0.025619507, 0.044952393, -0.021911621, -0.025863647, -0.055664062, 0.0011148453, 0.02243042, 0.016540527, -0.030639648, 0.024291992, -0.028762817, -0.03744507, -0.07446289, -0.05557251, 0.010887146, 0.016067505, 0.02217102, -0.036895752, -0.032562256, -0.047698975, -0.027297974, 0.021621704, -0.031677246, -0.027038574, -0.010284424, -0.004760742, 0.017852783, -0.002193451, 0.009140015, 0.0050468445, 0.0050735474, 0.011581421, 0.00983429, -0.065979004, 0.019058228, -0.006549835, -0.0063171387, 0.004508972, 0.016830444, -0.0054855347, -0.0076560974, 0.013206482, -0.057403564, 0.014839172, -0.0129852295, 0.0048980713, -0.037384033, -0.0059928894, -0.008407593, 0.025970459, 0.005996704, 0.019424438, -0.01890564, -0.007865906, 0.053771973, 0.019714355, -0.008766174, 0.07287598, -0.008430481, -0.07397461, -0.026275635, 0.04598999, -0.010604858, 0.020187378, -0.027664185, -0.086120605, 0.033294678, -0.047851562, 0.0056915283, -0.030471802, 0.016555786, 0.05340576, 0.04736328, 0.02192688, -0.0016479492, -0.013031006, -0.031829834, 0.015777588, -0.015899658, -0.0059814453, -0.020690918, 0.071899414, 0.0055618286, 0.025909424, -0.008453369, -0.024749756, -0.021774292, -0.010955811, 0.0023708344, -0.024368286, 0.028198242, -0.029052734, 0.06555176, -0.00065374374, 0.066589355, -0.06008911, -0.026443481, 0.025863647, 0.045135498, 0.018478394, -0.020141602, -0.019134521, 0.008399963, 0.044128418, -0.008613586, -0.016647339, -0.014320374, 0.020965576, -0.004142761, -0.07476807, -0.0793457, -0.047302246, -0.031097412, 0.044433594, -0.053588867, -0.042816162, 0.058532715, -0.012504578, 0.020263672, 0.06719971, -0.018234253, 0.015914917, -0.011695862, 0.030700684, 0.00012981892, 0.023162842, -0.009635925, -0.018585205, 0.02897644, -0.024795532, 0.05053711, 0.010543823, -0.009262085, 0.051757812, -0.015548706, -0.017974854, -0.063964844, 0.02557373, -0.055114746, -0.00018680096, -0.025772095, -0.00737381, 0.03189087, 0.03878784, 0.033996582, -0.015960693, 0.029403687, 0.032196045, -0.026550293, 0.0049324036, 0.023757935, -0.053985596, -0.016174316, 0.016174316, -0.014465332, 0.052581787, 0.025161743, 0.042114258, -0.033569336, -0.011116028, 0.01701355, 0.0137786865, -0.00869751, -0.01423645, -0.036956787, -0.017913818, 0.034606934, -0.010139465, 0.009628296, 0.02947998, 0.034362793, -0.0031719208, 0.041931152, 0.027877808, -0.027511597, 0.06060791, -0.03363037, 0.013198853, 0.0066604614, 0.014450073, -0.069885254, -0.034362793, -0.0055351257, 0.0065727234, -0.036468506, -0.021575928, 0.05441284, 0.014511108, -0.002986908, 0.053222656, -0.0079956055, 0.007106781, -0.00086545944, -0.0018157959, -0.025314331, -0.02583313, 0.0064926147, -0.015350342, -0.0357666, -0.0034866333, -0.00932312, 0.0019369125, 0.043273926, -0.035095215, 0.0068740845, -0.029541016, 0.027191162, -0.042938232, 0.0104522705, 0.018112183, -0.039276123, -0.030883789, 0.026779175, 0.041229248, -0.032196045, -0.013755798, -0.036743164, -0.021606445, -0.039245605, 0.017486572, 0.040283203, -0.05303955, -0.0362854, 0.049224854, 0.05834961, 0.097961426, 0.010063171, -0.0075416565, -0.0141067505, 0.041656494, -0.005958557, -0.029586792, 0.0007901192, 0.051849365, -0.0038490295, -0.053253174, 0.031555176, 0.044830322, -0.029586792, -0.09301758, 0.018218994, -0.031402588, -0.03161621, 0.017593384, 0.006401062, -0.014526367, -0.00472641, 0.01739502, -0.021514893, 0.018936157, 0.0073394775, -0.019897461, 0.024368286, 0.015075684, -0.035858154, 0.008644104, -0.017593384, 0.0064201355, -0.015090942, -0.054504395, -0.005256653, 0.0065994263, 0.029571533, -0.02180481, -0.08673096, 0.04208374, 0.018692017, 0.021026611, 0.02545166, -0.047851562, -0.005264282, 0.035461426, 0.041534424, 0.01576233, -0.008728027, 0.0011825562, 0.01158905, 0.064575195, 0.021072388, -0.03289795, -0.0015087128, -0.0049858093, -0.014694214, -0.023880005, 0.005596161, 0.03668213, -0.0184021, 0.0077209473, 0.018951416, -0.04071045, -0.019180298, 0.03024292, 0.07305908, -0.04699707, 0.009300232, 0.015464783, -0.027908325, 0.037384033, 0.017410278, -0.0010881424, 0.078552246, -0.030792236, -0.036468506, 0.03665161, -0.0060195923, 0.0015001297, 0.008392334, 0.008781433, -0.00932312, -0.01058197, -0.013114929, 0.023620605, 0.00178051, -0.010406494, -0.029449463, -0.004638672, -0.059387207, -0.04916382, 0.044189453, -0.022613525, -0.023010254, -0.020385742, -0.005844116, 0.021484375, 0.020401001, 0.00068473816, 0.0020160675, 0.0014657974, 0.014816284, -0.011657715, -0.0011224747 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2010.00590v3
Quantifying social organization and political polarization in online platforms
Isaac Waller, Ashton Anderson
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
Optimism about the Internet's potential to bring the world together has been tempered by concerns about its role in inflaming the 'culture wars'. Via mass selection into like-minded groups, online society may be becoming more fragmented and polarized, particularly with respect to partisan differences. However, our ability to measure the social makeup of online communities, and in turn understand the social organization of online platforms, is limited by the pseudonymous, unstructured, and large-scale nature of digital discussion. We develop a neural embedding methodology to quantify the positioning of online communities along social dimensions by leveraging large-scale patterns of aggregate behaviour. Applying our methodology to 5.1B Reddit comments made in 10K communities over 14 years, we measure how the macroscale community structure is organized with respect to age, gender, and U.S. political partisanship. Examining political content, we find Reddit underwent a significant polarization event around the 2016 U.S. presidential election, and remained highly polarized for years afterward. Contrary to conventional wisdom, however, individual-level polarization is rare; the system-level shift in 2016 was disproportionately driven by the arrival of new and newly political users. Political polarization on Reddit is unrelated to previous activity on the platform, and is instead temporally aligned with external events. We also observe a stark ideological asymmetry, with the sharp increase in 2016 being entirely attributable to changes in right-wing activity. Our methodology is broadly applicable to the study of online interaction, and our findings have implications for the design of online platforms, understanding the social contexts of online behaviour, and quantifying the dynamics and mechanisms of online polarization.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2010.00590v3
"2021-07-27T22:15:43"
"2020-10-01T11:59:00"
{ "title": [ 0.011917114, 0.02357483, -0.034729004, -0.04711914, 0.030883789, -0.025161743, -0.00071430206, -0.026947021, -0.050628662, 0.042144775, 0.0029582977, 0.021942139, -0.0018644333, -0.013648987, -0.022583008, -0.0037059784, -0.005531311, 0.022766113, -0.011779785, -0.02897644, -0.014572144, -0.03555298, 0.07244873, -0.012931824, 0.024856567, -0.040893555, -0.01689148, -0.012481689, -0.0015392303, -0.020065308, 0.00022566319, -0.002878189, 0.03967285, 0.02281189, -0.00024080276, 0.04067993, -0.043762207, 0.022262573, 0.011146545, 0.0049552917, -0.0052223206, 0.0037059784, -0.012901306, -0.0034694672, -0.026535034, 0.0018777847, -0.059265137, -0.017425537, -0.029403687, 0.0181427, 0.016845703, -0.0032234192, 0.015144348, 0.02848816, 0.00010508299, -0.0423584, -0.0039253235, -0.02709961, 0.028884888, 0.027175903, 0.01109314, -0.042755127, 0.030822754, 0.0010356903, -0.043792725, -0.005908966, -0.006866455, 0.012886047, 0.031799316, -0.027801514, -0.020996094, 0.015068054, 0.01802063, -0.0030784607, -0.033691406, -0.01499939, 0.04034424, 0.007019043, 0.03567505, -0.03286743, -0.01979065, -0.0057907104, -0.018127441, -0.032073975, 0.018875122, -0.028274536, -0.026504517, -0.00062799454, -0.038513184, -0.0390625, 0.0016031265, -0.014587402, -0.026184082, 0.015083313, -0.008300781, -0.026977539, 0.0005931854, 0.079589844, -0.018859863, -0.044433594, -0.06427002, 0.047943115, -0.101623535, -0.011276245, 0.024795532, -0.0016670227, -0.039978027, -0.03781128, 0.022003174, 0.04586792, -0.047943115, 0.037261963, 0.01399231, 0.019622803, -0.00045681, -0.048339844, -0.03765869, 0.042266846, 0.004989624, 0.03540039, 0.0009331703, -0.0035438538, 0.023269653, -0.018157959, 0.010879517, -0.0033359528, -0.04623413, -0.018630981, -0.041625977, 0.054351807, -0.0029125214, 0.042510986, -0.08935547, -0.09277344, -0.07330322, 0.019683838, -0.024642944, -0.0085372925, -0.025466919, 0.016052246, 0.0031204224, -0.053588867, 0.0051651, 0.014411926, 0.0041503906, -0.00027489662, 0.064453125, 0.0008058548, -0.05328369, -0.004966736, -0.04425049, 0.0368042, 0.005340576, 0.018005371, -0.06008911, 0.010932922, -0.10192871, -0.021270752, 0.02696228, -0.00642395, 0.050842285, 0.0051574707, -0.006439209, 0.029586792, 0.038604736, -0.011726379, -0.030288696, 0.024658203, 0.015357971, 0.020370483, -0.015823364, 0.026290894, 0.007587433, -0.013053894, -0.011009216, -0.0055007935, -0.0038013458, -0.01335144, 0.013252258, -0.0041542053, -0.0025939941, -0.023117065, -0.00630188, 0.061676025, -0.07763672, 0.0077590942, 0.00957489, 0.020980835, 0.03729248, -0.0055503845, 0.010627747, 0.03778076, -0.07080078, -0.045440674, -0.037384033, 0.033325195, 0.018371582, 0.04144287, 0.012908936, 0.0041007996, -0.04751587, -0.00844574, -0.03793335, 0.015235901, -0.036132812, -0.044830322, -0.014389038, 0.006542206, -0.0015459061, 0.057373047, 0.039154053, 0.01713562, -0.034057617, 0.024551392, -0.012687683, -0.033172607, 0.012290955, -0.034362793, -0.025375366, -0.040802002, -0.04171753, 0.014053345, -0.026473999, 0.037902832, 0.045532227, -0.021987915, 0.024871826, -0.04537964, 0.089538574, 0.00674057, 0.08917236, -0.04220581, 0.070373535, 0.05178833, -0.006401062, -0.014930725, 0.013221741, -0.04309082, 0.014228821, 0.0138549805, 0.0037250519, -0.0022659302, 0.0018453598, 0.022583008, 0.032684326, -0.03543091, 0.014320374, 0.012832642, 0.042510986, 0.06719971, 0.048431396, 0.017410278, 0.036346436, 0.0124053955, 0.007896423, 0.06121826, -0.020095825, 0.013648987, -0.040252686, 0.020141602, -0.0027599335, 0.02229309, 0.022720337, -0.004257202, -0.048431396, -0.018096924, -0.031585693, -0.005207062, 0.017074585, -0.015686035, 0.029693604, -0.0234375, 0.017868042, -0.0184021, -0.0026340485, -0.029907227, -0.023712158, 0.02583313, 0.0128479, -0.04748535, -0.021026611, 0.00466156, 0.027938843, -0.0053253174, -0.002866745, 0.008384705, 0.027389526, -0.021942139, -0.0259552, -0.042663574, 0.024917603, 0.039123535, -0.0069274902, 0.012382507, 0.020187378, -0.013931274, 0.11791992, 0.067993164, -0.031951904, 0.05038452, -0.028869629, 0.02104187, 0.011421204, -0.026306152, 0.0019464493, 0.0052986145, 0.018814087, 0.01612854, -0.022583008, -0.004081726, -0.031021118, 0.008422852, -0.005645752, -0.061706543, -0.020965576, -0.03704834, -0.0061149597, -0.053863525, -0.07006836, -0.0178833, 0.046203613, -0.050842285, -0.024108887, -0.03286743, -0.03479004, -0.01360321, -0.018218994, -0.01953125, -0.025283813, 0.011894226, 0.041870117, 0.006259918, -0.041137695, -0.026016235, 0.0050964355, 0.018920898, -0.021224976, 0.03439331, -0.019958496, -0.024932861, -0.024765015, -0.019104004, 0.012275696, -0.02229309, 0.051879883, -0.051605225, 0.013259888, 0.037261963, -0.016525269, 0.017959595, 0.0021591187, -0.02796936, -0.006614685, -0.027877808, 0.054901123, -0.017990112, -0.039794922, 0.00044369698, 0.033081055, -0.039154053, 0.015686035, 0.0054016113, -0.011161804, -0.035858154, -0.015838623, -0.012306213, -0.018692017, 0.015930176, -0.0064468384, 0.027755737, -0.041656494, -0.024673462, -0.010848999, -0.009719849, 0.017211914, 0.0029563904, -0.0848999, -0.07434082, 0.017852783, -0.05670166, -0.02507019, -0.029296875, 0.018569946, -0.0049362183, 0.070495605, -0.009666443, -0.02557373, -0.011741638, 0.026016235, 0.013137817, -0.013053894, -0.017654419, -0.04727173, 0.010108948, 0.01058197, -0.008476257, 0.018859863, 0.01953125, -0.095825195, -0.0027542114, 0.04248047, -0.010826111, -0.01675415, 0.015174866, -0.0657959, 0.015167236, -0.010757446, 0.000323534, 0.018692017, 0.053009033, -0.0058059692, -0.0049858093, -0.002111435, -0.017059326, 0.008476257, -0.034240723, -0.08111572, 0.02835083, -0.0012674332, -0.06262207, -0.019592285, 0.00044059753, -0.03857422, -0.0050086975, -0.04421997, 0.06298828, 0.005214691, 0.03250122, -0.014663696, -0.004096985, 0.009498596, -0.015068054, 0.005718231, -0.031311035, -0.0574646, -0.02470398, -0.021362305, 0.085998535, 0.026657104, -0.0064086914, -0.058685303, -0.0068206787, -0.025115967, 0.033416748, -0.0034484863, -0.040985107, -0.02015686, -0.047454834, -0.0107040405, 0.0048980713, -0.008979797, 0.008346558, -0.017196655, 0.014190674, -0.020095825, -0.00856781, -0.0013408661, 0.019760132, -0.036102295, -0.004322052, 0.04800415, -0.009376526, -0.069885254, 0.013999939, 0.01184845, 0.009109497, 0.003578186, -0.0025749207, -0.03286743, 0.024795532, 0.0037021637, 0.013648987, 0.006412506, -0.0061454773, 0.023757935, -0.0008740425, -0.046569824, 0.017028809, -0.0597229, 0.0077171326, -0.005241394, 0.020050049, -0.029708862, -0.048339844, -0.0037765503, 0.0020561218, -0.0690918, -0.036712646, 0.0002746582, -0.032440186, -0.04006958, -0.031433105, 0.006919861, -0.026168823, -0.03387451, 0.018859863, -0.01309967, 0.011566162, 0.0065193176, -0.06555176, -0.0035953522, 0.07305908, -0.0154953, -0.0017251968, 0.0231781, -0.0034542084, -0.0093307495, -0.055603027, 0.010414124, 0.03439331, 0.007896423, -0.02684021, -0.013328552, 0.023773193, -0.027023315, 0.0042266846, 0.042999268, 0.002729416, -0.00029444695, 0.011260986, 0.02961731, 0.02078247, -0.01689148, 0.0513916, 0.019515991, -0.01777649, -0.05758667, -0.0105896, -0.00749588, 0.003736496, 0.026428223, -0.025741577, 0.03161621, 0.018432617, 0.0075149536, 0.059814453, -0.011100769, -0.010475159, 0.00017666817, -0.023254395, -0.012809753, -0.016235352, 0.008071899, 0.0024871826, 0.002117157, -0.008178711, -0.029586792, 0.010475159, -0.008666992, -0.03036499, 0.0032463074, 0.006450653, -0.055389404, 0.011383057, -0.04385376, -0.068115234, -0.06378174, 0.027648926, -0.020523071, 0.039245605, 0.027877808, 0.0047950745, -0.034210205, 0.016815186, 0.0345459, -0.0027179718, -0.003271103, -0.05368042, -0.0011730194, -0.021026611, -0.072753906, -0.05203247, -0.009803772, 0.01499176, 0.0069274902, 0.0046958923, -0.0011606216, 0.015220642, 0.018432617, 0.013549805, 0.0129776, -0.00096035004, -0.011100769, 0.057495117, -0.01272583, -0.013397217, -0.00029444695, 0.009529114, -0.009101868, -0.03640747, -0.008781433, -0.0027198792, 0.005268097, -0.03540039, 0.01737976, -0.026687622, 0.032043457, -0.0209198, 0.020019531, 0.015342712, 0.019592285, 0.00069856644, 0.013381958, -0.031433105, -0.020401001, -0.009529114, 0.03881836, -0.018203735, 0.00995636, 0.02532959, 0.001159668, 0.024719238, -0.036712646, 0.010368347, -0.007068634, 0.009284973, 0.0154418945, 0.003370285, -0.040039062, -0.042114258, 0.0070877075, 0.020111084, 0.05996704, -0.0340271, 0.06665039, -0.045166016, -0.008842468, 0.012268066, 0.014541626, 0.01876831, -0.016036987, 0.026107788, -0.03161621, -0.03225708, 0.020523071, 0.016677856, -0.011238098, 0.015098572, 0.006374359, 0.018295288, 0.026489258, 0.052642822, -0.0035095215, 0.020080566, 0.03652954, 0.01285553, 0.010322571, -0.02532959, -0.044891357, -0.011116028, 0.037017822, 0.025650024, -0.011245728, 0.025009155, -0.06311035, 0.000541687, -0.012306213, -0.026931763, 0.022613525, -0.07220459, 0.024108887, 0.06604004, -0.009140015, 0.051452637, -0.009857178, 0.008148193, 0.036468506, 0.052459717, -0.011756897, 0.0129470825, 0.04135132, -0.056396484, -0.010223389, 0.00932312, 0.037841797, 0.012001038, 0.011146545, 0.022094727, -0.007484436, -0.047027588, 0.027832031, 0.009002686, 0.024505615, -0.0013780594, -0.056915283, 0.007587433, -0.017227173, -0.00116539, 0.0018615723, -0.04788208, -0.042175293, -0.024734497, -0.030807495, -0.037139893, 0.029006958, -0.011276245, -0.042938232, -0.055786133, 0.022155762, 0.0038375854, 0.015541077, -0.02619934, 0.006702423, -0.05709839, 0.041168213, 0.027679443, -0.04751587, 0.0017166138, -0.03314209, 0.006542206, 0.03564453, 0.04425049, -0.009155273, 0.0026817322, -0.05090332, -0.055023193, -0.034332275, 0.020339966, 0.015792847, 0.0345459, -0.012626648, -0.044708252, -0.0056114197, -0.013534546, -0.0014514923, 0.032928467, -0.010643005, 0.023040771, 0.0042877197, -0.0069351196, 0.016281128, 0.03137207, -0.02406311, 0.023239136, 0.014717102, -0.017074585, 0.030914307, 0.018814087, 0.003648758, -0.03378296, -0.082458496, 0.010360718, 0.0051460266, -0.014274597, -0.01876831, -0.00447464, 0.0335083, 2.9802322e-7, -0.037994385, -0.005542755, 0.07080078, -0.06915283, 0.011993408, -0.004322052, 0.004840851, -0.041503906, 0.0022792816, 0.0036811829, 0.022949219, -0.039916992, -0.048339844, -0.029907227, 0.006706238, 0.020019531, 0.023544312, 0.04257202, -0.008666992, 0.027679443, -0.024154663, 0.0036334991, -0.019042969, 0.040405273, 0.006755829, 0.0018167496, -0.03253174, -0.002811432, 0.020874023, -0.031280518, 0.009963989, -0.004901886, -0.0065193176, -0.0140686035, -0.024978638, 0.03427124, -0.016677856, -0.03111267, 0.024291992, 0.0009651184, -0.02293396, 0.0152282715, -0.03265381, 0.05532837, 0.020889282, 0.061676025, 0.028396606, 0.030349731, 0.059051514, 0.0070610046, 0.031982422, -0.019821167, -0.002620697, -0.046844482, -0.01424408, -0.043304443, -0.013458252, -0.060577393, 0.01687622, 0.013160706, 0.024414062, 0.01737976, 0.00730896, 0.028945923, 0.013183594, 0.054504395, 0.009651184, 0.06488037, -0.020980835, -0.01121521, -0.018753052, -0.015274048, 0.032684326, 0.041229248, 0.004386902, 0.012588501, -0.0063552856, -0.019195557, -0.00018131733, 0.022842407, 0.013305664, -0.0077819824, -0.006072998, -0.0090789795, 0.024032593, -0.022644043, 0.012084961, 0.06518555, 0.04135132, 0.0044517517, -0.028442383, 0.010124207, -0.0027713776, -0.0440979, 0.013221741, 0.031585693, -0.027893066, 0.02494812, -0.03475952, -0.030807495, 0.043029785, -0.022247314, 0.052825928, -0.08703613, -0.08026123, -0.0025348663, 0.053527832, -0.005317688, 0.038879395, -0.039794922, -0.027618408, -0.02935791, 0.022323608, -0.015220642, -0.0035381317, -0.0027542114, 0.050231934, -0.04852295, -0.014015198, -0.012161255, -0.017425537, -0.060913086, 0.014633179, -0.019958496, 0.0259552, 0.0016260147, -0.029327393, 0.002380371, 0.010528564, -0.050872803, -0.0038909912, 0.0068359375, 0.026290894, 0.03414917, 0.0770874, 0.018493652, -0.012016296, -0.014099121, -0.037902832, 0.04095459, 0.055603027, -0.01953125, 0.03933716, -0.030532837, -0.05105591, 0.060150146, -0.007209778, 0.092163086, -0.05038452, 0.018997192, 0.0012235641, 0.000007927418, 0.0345459, -0.05328369, -0.036621094, 0.0024299622, -0.020095825, -0.0103302, -0.025253296, -0.028198242, -0.0038719177, -0.017990112, 0.017318726, 0.027175903, -0.006298065, 0.0029468536, -0.021621704, -0.07104492, -0.0005712509, -0.021240234, 0.028137207, -0.03652954, -0.008674622, -0.026412964, 0.006526947, 0.0090789795, -0.0058288574, -0.015960693, -0.008636475, -0.031051636, -0.061309814, 0.021713257, 0.0027046204, -0.015602112, -0.008460999, 0.003419876, -0.008918762, -0.02078247, -0.04156494, 0.06939697, 0.0010719299, -0.099121094, -0.019943237, -0.036102295, 0.021575928, 0.014083862, -0.008590698, 0.0063667297, 0.009635925, 0.0008444786, -0.04144287, 0.026321411, 0.03363037, 0.0041007996, -0.05328369, 0.010032654, 0.031585693, 0.03302002, -0.05041504, -0.025802612, 0.01184845, 0.04360962, 0.012557983, 0.0065612793, 0.021255493, -0.00957489, -0.022827148, 0.009506226, -0.0047836304, -0.031555176, -0.08087158, -0.035369873, 0.024230957, 0.019683838, 0.015319824, -0.04751587, 0.023269653, -0.0067863464, 0.0002155304, 0.02720642, -0.0446167, 0.023590088, -0.00674057, 0.005012512, -0.010871887, -0.005756378, -0.012817383, -0.020996094, 0.00466156, 0.021377563, -0.042175293, 0.021591187, -0.01927185, 0.011405945, -0.013893127, -0.060394287, 0.022384644, 0.06298828, -0.011108398, 0.099975586, -0.05593872, -0.036895752, -0.0074005127, -0.02532959, -0.015296936, -0.04067993, -0.008232117, -0.0007944107, -0.0039901733, -0.0060424805, -0.048583984, -0.020614624, -0.018478394, 0.020889282, -0.037322998, 0.022079468, -0.02973938, 0.002916336, -0.016403198, 0.009033203, -0.0022296906, -0.05718994, -0.028320312, -0.0026397705, 0.05026245, 0.0022830963 ], "summary": [ 0.07922363, 0.004306793, 0.018066406, 0.02267456, 0.024108887, -0.045288086, 0.04196167, -0.05795288, -0.0013742447, 0.033081055, -0.015235901, 0.0024776459, 0.032409668, -0.023666382, 0.009567261, -0.0065231323, -0.00111866, 0.05517578, 0.050445557, -0.024673462, -0.0037765503, -0.03262329, 0.051635742, -0.028030396, 0.028747559, -0.012489319, 0.06726074, -0.021697998, 0.0552063, 0.036865234, 0.037750244, -0.08270264, 0.019424438, 0.025238037, 0.002527237, 0.020095825, -0.0040740967, 0.003709793, 0.02281189, -0.0031585693, 0.0011997223, 0.009178162, 0.070617676, -0.00009995699, 0.0013141632, 0.018356323, -0.03778076, -0.030349731, 0.006752014, -0.039794922, -0.008476257, 0.016586304, -0.0023708344, -0.053894043, 0.0062828064, -0.00010704994, -0.019546509, -0.010063171, 0.0062561035, 0.023391724, 0.017547607, -0.01424408, 0.026321411, -0.016342163, -0.04385376, 0.002149582, 0.047668457, -0.004837036, -0.017105103, -0.053131104, 0.021606445, 0.0031261444, 0.029907227, -0.0546875, -0.028533936, 0.03100586, 0.010467529, 0.000095009804, 0.007183075, -0.04937744, -0.053253174, 0.035980225, -0.057037354, -0.07434082, 0.00774765, -0.055633545, -0.026657104, 0.005077362, -0.003479004, 0.008476257, -0.0000371933, -0.05065918, -0.042053223, 0.08502197, 0.045654297, -0.046020508, 0.023590088, 0.031311035, -0.008010864, -0.024398804, -0.039398193, -0.0057868958, -0.054840088, -0.008590698, 0.017456055, -0.0146865845, -0.039123535, -0.045928955, 0.041229248, 0.038879395, -0.031311035, 0.05166626, 0.014831543, 0.023529053, -0.03643799, -0.017486572, -0.029724121, 0.0234375, -0.011787415, 0.02406311, -0.013092041, 0.03704834, -0.02180481, -0.0071487427, 0.011497498, 0.015426636, 0.0047187805, -0.007396698, -0.08721924, 0.05493164, -0.013175964, 0.016220093, 0.009002686, -0.022491455, -0.04827881, -0.04006958, -0.00592041, -0.04776001, -0.01713562, 0.032073975, 0.009162903, -0.059509277, -0.014961243, 0.010032654, 0.015213013, 0.030303955, 0.017105103, -0.016036987, 0.005092621, -0.0010890961, -0.009597778, 0.0005326271, 0.03640747, 0.016571045, -0.059173584, -0.026748657, -0.028793335, -0.025512695, 0.0075912476, -0.048614502, 0.052124023, 0.0061950684, 0.004573822, 0.044952393, -0.016830444, -0.005836487, -0.044433594, -0.0075035095, 0.010261536, 0.003730774, -0.0055503845, 0.021774292, -0.0023097992, -0.0103302, 0.0025177002, -0.0011262894, -0.021835327, -0.032562256, -0.014808655, 0.023864746, 0.01663208, -0.035491943, -0.07446289, 0.057373047, -0.02758789, 0.04611206, -0.009666443, 0.045074463, 0.014572144, -0.0031661987, 0.012374878, 0.033966064, -0.029296875, -0.025344849, 0.0061950684, 0.044921875, -0.010673523, 0.03451538, 0.00086402893, -0.029586792, 0.031402588, 0.017913818, -0.036132812, -0.017654419, -0.07281494, -0.009002686, -0.017959595, 0.016708374, 0.05227661, 0.0033035278, -0.0026893616, -0.018493652, -0.014549255, 0.029891968, -0.06274414, 0.0041999817, 0.0044021606, -0.07495117, -0.009963989, -0.031311035, -0.023864746, 0.061767578, -0.0635376, 0.04510498, 0.056732178, -0.01600647, 0.0057525635, -0.03765869, 0.0758667, -0.011428833, 0.03201294, 0.007637024, 0.06317139, 0.07324219, 0.006778717, -0.011695862, 0.048309326, -0.07116699, 0.017700195, 0.015510559, 0.03289795, 0.05117798, -0.006137848, 0.0075798035, -0.0053215027, -0.035308838, 0.018356323, 0.006526947, 0.021636963, 0.08795166, 0.025756836, 0.014091492, -0.005706787, -0.021484375, 0.019210815, 0.022277832, -0.02470398, 0.025772095, -0.0049362183, -0.01285553, -0.00894165, 0.0009050369, 0.019515991, -0.011680603, -0.008079529, -0.0736084, 0.003993988, -0.021408081, 0.038360596, -0.078186035, 0.019500732, -0.031204224, 0.012329102, -0.021896362, -0.009727478, -0.054473877, -0.027313232, 0.03149414, 0.0340271, -0.033477783, 0.009300232, 0.010383606, -0.019226074, -0.005958557, 0.012512207, -0.015655518, 0.011802673, 0.029418945, 0.01109314, 0.01626587, 0.014083862, 0.07446289, -0.0068626404, 0.049102783, 0.02229309, 0.014907837, 0.082336426, 0.01977539, -0.018325806, 0.0063095093, 0.04385376, 0.028274536, -0.01335907, -0.0039043427, 0.003982544, 0.039611816, 0.016723633, 0.023971558, 0.009315491, -0.001077652, -0.031921387, -0.017822266, -0.0023212433, 0.016952515, -0.03074646, -0.031066895, -0.009803772, 0.0067329407, -0.030288696, 0.010269165, 0.020584106, -0.049926758, 0.0017518997, -0.027755737, -0.03338623, -0.015548706, -0.0050849915, -0.015853882, 0.005569458, -0.023513794, -0.052703857, -0.058013916, -0.05847168, -0.0036735535, -0.009933472, -0.008224487, -0.009613037, 0.008117676, -0.011688232, -0.03164673, -0.017456055, 0.00019431114, -0.006225586, -0.022415161, 0.03567505, 0.010139465, -0.0013637543, 0.034973145, -0.014183044, 0.021713257, -0.021362305, -0.049102783, -0.001326561, -0.0013179779, 0.005744934, -0.010093689, 0.015129089, 0.0029563904, 0.008888245, -0.041870117, -0.010307312, -0.000582695, -0.03074646, -0.039245605, -0.016967773, 0.022628784, 0.007850647, -0.007797241, 0.00356102, 0.0003745556, 0.017715454, -0.00034308434, -0.0021572113, -0.025802612, -0.029205322, -0.021560669, -0.027542114, -0.051696777, 0.054351807, -0.015579224, -0.0107803345, -0.019058228, 0.039276123, -0.007331848, 0.053527832, -0.012535095, 0.00497818, 0.015731812, 0.043701172, 0.011184692, -0.0047454834, -0.028060913, -0.044891357, -0.0023040771, -0.016174316, -0.007896423, 0.050750732, 0.013961792, -0.03842163, -0.04135132, 0.04159546, -0.0004067421, 0.0037174225, -0.008232117, -0.03656006, 0.03149414, -0.017044067, 0.011016846, 0.00025749207, -0.0047569275, 0.023651123, 0.006526947, -0.024780273, 0.020751953, 0.007118225, -0.054229736, 0.018966675, 0.013465881, 0.012901306, -0.040618896, -0.0423584, 0.07879639, -0.028640747, -0.006916046, -0.018218994, -0.017669678, -0.009437561, 0.006587982, -0.049560547, 0.058502197, 0.002193451, -0.012191772, 0.0030059814, -0.018707275, -0.049072266, -0.026351929, -0.024475098, 0.014175415, 0.027557373, -0.030227661, -0.043273926, 0.015380859, -0.0096588135, 0.027557373, -0.007698059, -0.012756348, 0.006008148, -0.05996704, -0.011779785, 0.010147095, -0.044158936, 0.020889282, 0.02192688, 0.035583496, -0.013702393, -0.00756073, 0.010871887, 0.035247803, 0.007282257, -0.0146484375, 0.049835205, -0.012702942, -0.06744385, 0.03173828, 0.03274536, 0.01574707, 0.009689331, -0.000828743, -0.026901245, 0.033172607, 0.011489868, -0.05218506, 0.012039185, 0.0009784698, -0.013336182, -0.027374268, 0.024841309, 0.00737381, -0.0141067505, -0.040100098, -0.09503174, 0.04937744, -0.07128906, -0.052886963, -0.014305115, 0.0030670166, 0.011222839, -0.005126953, -0.008125305, -0.02017212, -0.043884277, 0.011741638, -0.0037231445, 0.020477295, 0.002319336, 0.013763428, -0.023986816, 0.09124756, 0.03717041, -0.055603027, 0.058929443, -0.021453857, 0.014968872, 0.0045318604, -0.02607727, 0.017440796, 0.032928467, -0.026275635, -0.008850098, 0.003540039, -0.0026855469, -0.036193848, 0.009742737, 0.0032653809, -0.006591797, 0.029190063, 0.042297363, 0.0037765503, 0.03274536, -0.011375427, 0.053375244, 0.061553955, -0.02331543, 0.006706238, 0.024459839, -0.0074691772, -0.032836914, -0.011779785, -0.010040283, 0.012283325, 0.04333496, 0.003501892, 0.042999268, 0.019378662, -0.02281189, -0.0021877289, -0.014892578, -0.009849548, -0.0063209534, 0.0062026978, -0.01309967, -0.021347046, -0.015686035, -0.0071411133, -0.004169464, -0.04714966, -0.0473938, -0.055480957, 0.00060749054, -0.06060791, -0.00019562244, 0.000010848045, -0.033081055, -0.0034675598, -0.025039673, -0.03277588, -0.056427002, 0.028747559, 0.00036406517, 0.019973755, 0.018157959, -0.020629883, 0.019836426, -0.01197052, 0.05996704, 0.0036945343, -0.013664246, -0.07867432, -0.067871094, -0.0065994263, -0.024917603, -0.032165527, -0.006046295, -0.029937744, -0.053253174, -0.008308411, 0.026351929, 0.014884949, 0.026657104, -0.0059661865, -0.045837402, 0.04055786, 0.032592773, 0.07281494, -0.030929565, 0.02394104, 0.004219055, 0.05239868, 0.000808239, 0.00086164474, -0.007144928, -0.00881958, -0.011955261, -0.01083374, -0.011634827, 0.009025574, 0.011291504, -0.04055786, 0.0026474, -0.006893158, 0.04269409, -0.0051345825, 0.018600464, -0.016677856, -0.04272461, -0.021270752, 0.03189087, -0.0053634644, 0.022109985, -0.019073486, -0.016494751, -0.036224365, -0.02041626, 0.05279541, -0.041229248, -0.02027893, -0.0071029663, -0.014060974, 0.0013313293, -0.0009860992, 0.045043945, -0.004196167, 0.05050659, 0.04156494, 0.05596924, -0.040405273, -0.028671265, 0.000749588, 0.009880066, 0.0020179749, -0.0158844, 0.0025043488, 0.009010315, -0.037109375, 0.011421204, 0.025100708, 0.014389038, 0.0077171326, -0.019165039, -0.007358551, 0.03704834, 0.025238037, -0.0018796921, -0.03765869, 0.018997192, 0.0055351257, -0.014961243, 0.0050849915, -0.02545166, -0.058410645, 0.045013428, 0.014579773, 0.017868042, 0.01701355, -0.008285522, -0.00035119057, -0.025466919, -0.03366089, 0.0011177063, -0.06112671, -0.050811768, -0.002248764, -0.026168823, 0.0335083, 0.017715454, -0.006290436, -0.0211792, 0.016403198, -0.024734497, 0.0118637085, 0.0017385483, -0.06359863, 0.002231598, -0.017654419, 0.02998352, 0.050720215, -0.022460938, 0.026382446, 0.02017212, -0.02104187, 0.014480591, 0.0041007996, 0.010620117, -0.05557251, -0.0039253235, 0.0209198, -0.02583313, 0.019180298, -0.025970459, -0.008865356, -0.0541687, -0.017196655, -0.011100769, -0.022567749, 0.010421753, -0.021408081, -0.06317139, -0.026672363, 0.016693115, 0.020599365, -0.0054473877, -0.029174805, 0.0060195923, -0.047058105, 0.011383057, -0.0034332275, 0.0076675415, -0.0068969727, -0.0042381287, 0.0075645447, -0.011489868, 0.028259277, 0.012260437, 0.0036258698, -0.066467285, -0.034729004, -0.00038313866, 0.024856567, 0.011520386, 0.058044434, -0.021270752, 0.008354187, 0.016967773, -0.035369873, 0.0048065186, 0.006336212, -0.021209717, 0.008605957, 0.0038433075, -0.012649536, 0.008659363, 0.01864624, -0.07019043, 0.027786255, 0.022201538, 0.019714355, 0.024520874, 0.030517578, 0.021850586, -0.022613525, -0.06088257, 0.0045814514, 0.029388428, 0.0068130493, -0.0042304993, -0.033203125, -0.008666992, -0.027328491, -0.024215698, -0.022003174, 0.046813965, -0.037872314, 0.043182373, -0.02268982, 0.025680542, -0.10656738, -0.1307373, 0.03375244, 0.094177246, -0.0058784485, -0.03768921, 0.0066223145, -0.011146545, 0.003982544, -0.0046195984, 0.02532959, 0.0082092285, 0.02494812, -0.018188477, 0.010787964, 0.02041626, 0.03640747, -0.005027771, 0.007827759, -0.033935547, -0.010116577, -0.001912117, -0.009796143, 0.02116394, -0.012313843, 0.0041503906, 0.010848999, 0.034118652, 0.0007739067, 0.033172607, 0.0004775524, -0.016418457, -0.03475952, 0.026550293, -0.042633057, 0.015701294, 0.01626587, 0.007106781, 0.0024356842, -0.025909424, -0.027160645, 0.072265625, 0.004348755, -0.016098022, -0.0071258545, 0.012878418, -0.018173218, -0.00970459, -0.019714355, -0.025939941, -0.0049362183, 0.05593872, -0.01398468, 0.013076782, 0.04031372, -0.0011320114, 0.03010559, 0.023498535, -0.024749756, 0.00623703, 0.026397705, -0.036712646, -0.002981186, -0.02848816, -0.057250977, 0.017211914, 0.05316162, 0.014572144, -0.021026611, 0.0003039837, -0.011260986, 0.037475586, 0.002161026, -0.025299072, -0.01789856, 0.03704834, -0.036895752, 0.034301758, -0.017974854, 0.021957397, 0.068847656, 0.015197754, 0.022628784, -0.04071045, 0.031311035, 0.013679504, -0.014945984, 0.006542206, -0.0056915283, 0.024932861, -0.011260986, 0.00053453445, -0.020736694, 0.077697754, -0.04324341, 0.07324219, -0.08850098, -0.07879639, -0.0093688965, 0.047454834, -0.02986145, 0.010726929, -0.058044434, -0.000582695, -0.059661865, -0.059753418, 0.02444458, -0.061401367, -0.0071525574, 0.051635742, -0.018997192, 0.037139893, -0.019241333, -0.0098724365, -0.053009033, 0.017913818, -0.009712219, 0.037322998, 0.012214661, 0.006023407, -0.0010643005, 0.042053223, -0.050964355, 0.025054932, 0.025039673, 0.029052734, 0.06549072, 0.07714844, -0.0069122314, 0.023864746, 0.009315491, -0.005012512, 0.022827148, 0.003780365, 0.013252258, -0.012962341, -0.0059890747, -0.000395298, 0.024734497, 0.060333252, 0.13171387, -0.05419922, 0.010406494, 0.007789612, -0.044158936, -0.024475098, 0.026229858, 0.014564514, -0.025283813, -0.015510559, -0.002632141, -0.011116028, -0.03439331, 0.02420044, -0.027252197, -0.017486572, 0.03149414, -0.010017395, 0.013954163, 0.0006775856, -0.03466797, -0.0209198, -0.02998352, 0.048797607, -0.026489258, -0.01109314, 0.007911682, 0.014579773, 0.005859375, -0.011268616, -0.029388428, 0.05038452, 0.025283813, -0.093566895, 0.03866577, 0.015716553, -0.014289856, -0.0054130554, -0.028381348, 0.0031433105, -0.013748169, -0.017227173, 0.041412354, 0.023773193, -0.11053467, -0.02281189, -0.024597168, 0.010932922, -0.0015850067, 0.010032654, -0.0018053055, 0.008323669, 0.0124435425, -0.028457642, 0.03894043, 0.037994385, 0.0045814514, -0.013587952, 0.00699234, 0.013114929, 0.033111572, -0.018188477, 0.0033168793, 0.02217102, 0.015838623, 0.000119030476, -0.024520874, 0.017929077, -0.016326904, -0.0019817352, 0.0049819946, -0.010025024, -0.017471313, -0.053863525, -0.003786087, 0.025772095, -0.0064964294, 0.0042533875, -0.0496521, 0.0051574707, -0.050994873, -0.023986816, 0.02003479, -0.021942139, -0.0014352798, 0.01071167, -0.019744873, -0.032806396, 0.010238647, -0.028396606, -0.050048828, 0.00029158592, -0.010292053, -0.021652222, 0.024719238, -0.041992188, 0.00062561035, 0.03741455, -0.0032444, -0.04046631, 0.0032024384, 0.002527237, 0.05770874, -0.03173828, -0.064697266, 0.0015172958, -0.049743652, -0.008628845, -0.08325195, 0.007659912, -0.010063171, -0.036010742, 0.020019531, -0.023132324, -0.02128601, -0.039978027, 0.03100586, -0.048187256, 0.020645142, -0.023208618, 0.03253174, 0.01448822, -0.026977539, 0.018554688, -0.034088135, 0.020706177, 0.011749268, -0.008010864, 0.024032593 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2010.06503v2
Transfer Learning and SpecAugment applied to SSVEP Based BCI Classification
Pedro R. A. S. Bassi, Willian Rampazzo, Romis Attux
eess.SP, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.IV
Objective: We used deep convolutional neural networks (DCNNs) to classify electroencephalography (EEG) signals in a steady-state visually evoked potentials (SSVEP) based single-channel brain-computer interface (BCI), which does not require calibration on the user. Methods: EEG signals were converted to spectrograms and served as input to train DCNNs using the transfer learning technique. We also modified and applied a data augmentation method, SpecAugment, generally employed for speech recognition. Furthermore, for comparison purposes, we classified the SSVEP dataset using Support-vector machines (SVMs) and Filter Bank canonical correlation analysis (FBCCA). Results: Excluding the evaluated user's data from the fine-tuning process, we reached 82.2% mean test accuracy and 0.825 mean F1-Score on 35 subjects from an open dataset, using a small data length (0.5 s), only one electrode (Oz) and the DCNN with transfer learning, window slicing (WS) and SpecAugment's time masks. Conclusion: The DCNN results surpassed SVM and FBCCA performances, using a single electrode and a small data length. Transfer learning provided minimal accuracy change, but made training faster. SpecAugment created a small performance improvement and was successfully combined with WS, yielding higher accuracies. Significance: We present a new methodology to solve the problem of SSVEP classification using DCNNs. We also modified a speech recognition data augmentation technique and applied it to the context of BCIs. The presented methodology surpassed performances obtained with FBCCA and SVMs (more traditional SSVEP classification methods) in BCIs with small data lengths and one electrode. This type of BCI can be used to develop small and fast systems.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2010.06503v2
"2021-03-18T06:58:13"
"2020-10-08T00:30:12"
{ "title": [ 0.009086609, 0.02684021, 0.00497818, 0.013572693, 0.0104522705, -0.014533997, 0.03567505, -0.06329346, -0.0070381165, 0.008178711, -0.013664246, 0.0018234253, -0.007217407, -0.047058105, -0.035583496, -0.010101318, -0.014297485, 0.048706055, 0.005332947, -0.01802063, -0.030258179, -0.021774292, 0.03829956, 0.0032253265, 0.035736084, -0.019058228, -0.10333252, 0.011711121, -0.0015192032, -0.011230469, 0.0077819824, 0.006965637, 0.04119873, 0.002008438, -0.010658264, -0.0042533875, -0.049438477, 0.022201538, 0.0013904572, 0.0051193237, 0.0006146431, 0.010772705, 0.011993408, -0.015434265, -0.024871826, 0.012504578, -0.043670654, -0.021484375, -0.011383057, -0.0024700165, 0.00944519, 0.029693604, 0.013175964, 0.014701843, 0.016799927, 0.0019140244, -0.046966553, -0.012825012, 0.037231445, 0.12017822, 0.022506714, -0.045135498, -0.0037021637, -0.075805664, -0.028366089, -0.026123047, -0.02406311, 0.017242432, 0.046173096, -0.014472961, -0.010437012, 0.022384644, 0.0055999756, -0.010498047, -0.011039734, -0.024917603, 0.06488037, 0.009880066, -0.021957397, -0.0054855347, -0.020217896, -0.015159607, -0.016281128, -0.03274536, 0.00012338161, -0.03591919, -0.02017212, 0.009979248, -0.030349731, -0.074035645, 0.0027332306, -0.042938232, -0.049102783, 0.030838013, 0.017288208, -0.061035156, -0.029037476, 0.0060768127, -0.041656494, -0.0069770813, -0.02482605, 0.018432617, -0.022399902, -0.020965576, 0.007160187, 0.00141716, -0.025466919, -0.03945923, -0.0054893494, 0.034454346, -0.025177002, -0.01979065, 0.02809143, 0.018112183, -0.032714844, -0.021881104, 0.00037288666, 0.0013227463, 0.015655518, 0.02432251, -0.008262634, -0.029922485, 0.023071289, -0.008178711, 0.05230713, 0.015777588, -0.037200928, 0.011436462, -0.009239197, -0.0077552795, 0.01625061, 0.046569824, -0.06640625, -0.030410767, -0.04550171, 0.039093018, 0.014343262, 0.0046653748, -0.00008511543, -0.009628296, 0.034973145, -0.027175903, -0.0068092346, 0.023406982, 0.047790527, 0.022491455, 0.054382324, 0.014694214, -0.038238525, -0.042175293, 0.037750244, 0.0031414032, 0.006713867, 0.007270813, -0.04473877, -0.017059326, -0.117614746, -0.011451721, 0.062072754, 0.018081665, 0.030838013, 0.013336182, -0.03338623, 0.05630493, 0.054870605, -0.021255493, 0.013244629, 0.049041748, 0.0074653625, -0.001709938, -0.004463196, 0.013824463, 0.047424316, -0.010505676, -0.0048828125, 0.02420044, 0.011207581, -0.0039405823, 0.020874023, -0.0236969, 0.007183075, -0.0037899017, -0.010353088, 0.03479004, -0.049224854, -0.006629944, -0.013671875, 0.018371582, 0.040924072, 0.025131226, -0.05432129, 0.004016876, -0.013168335, -0.047058105, -0.033355713, -0.012763977, 0.04119873, 0.010215759, 0.0010566711, 0.020690918, 0.0017089844, 0.0050354004, -0.007587433, -0.005886078, 0.0055503845, -0.039245605, -0.0016241074, -0.0068893433, 0.037139893, 0.007949829, 0.010719299, -0.012107849, -0.01058197, -0.017547607, -0.062164307, -0.048919678, 0.037017822, -0.033721924, -0.036621094, -0.055145264, -0.038208008, -0.00067329407, -0.040527344, 0.070739746, 0.012374878, -0.015075684, 0.019546509, -0.034210205, 0.07672119, 0.00831604, 0.0927124, -0.027816772, 0.016036987, 0.0037555695, -0.019760132, -0.0061912537, -0.017456055, -0.022277832, 0.028717041, 0.018295288, 0.018997192, -0.027359009, 0.0046043396, 0.03488159, 0.056610107, -0.01663208, -0.005432129, -0.0034179688, -0.0096206665, -0.021499634, 0.061706543, 0.008544922, 0.030853271, -0.0064964294, 0.028915405, 0.036590576, -0.022888184, -0.019927979, -0.008018494, 0.001660347, 0.0057411194, -0.0005297661, 0.014663696, -0.011306763, -0.024398804, 0.0036678314, 0.010643005, -0.0071754456, -0.010719299, 0.02468872, 0.018585205, -0.01687622, -0.0032176971, -0.0038089752, 0.032562256, -0.04067993, -0.041046143, 0.01914978, 0.011245728, -0.044525146, -0.030548096, 0.0034866333, 0.026794434, -0.013458252, 0.007549286, 0.019012451, 0.027526855, -0.029067993, -0.01777649, -0.005470276, 0.012634277, 0.050598145, 0.012939453, -0.0018177032, -0.010696411, 0.0013170242, 0.03314209, 0.04660034, -0.013153076, 0.020080566, -0.07220459, 0.012634277, 0.0009889603, -0.008293152, 0.0027313232, 0.047729492, 0.018692017, 0.015037537, -0.016601562, -0.005191803, -0.007637024, 0.0069885254, -0.022018433, -0.02243042, -0.06463623, -0.059509277, -0.02027893, -0.040161133, -0.019165039, 0.0058898926, 0.058654785, 0.009689331, -0.03050232, -0.009925842, -0.0034561157, -0.007865906, -0.031143188, -0.028869629, 0.012306213, 0.03857422, 0.050354004, 0.04989624, -0.03338623, 0.00868988, 0.0046195984, 0.00024080276, 0.0045051575, 0.0072898865, -0.0038146973, 0.036956787, 0.05053711, 0.05203247, 0.016021729, -0.013015747, -0.048583984, -0.034240723, -0.009063721, -0.0027332306, -0.06695557, -0.01574707, 0.072265625, -0.022277832, -0.030899048, 0.030456543, 0.043640137, -0.062469482, -0.011207581, 0.05419922, -0.012268066, 0.01625061, 0.07409668, 0.037353516, 0.054351807, -0.03881836, -0.031555176, -0.08178711, 0.0034217834, -0.027374268, -0.008117676, 0.047180176, -0.03491211, -0.003074646, -0.039794922, -0.014640808, -0.017944336, 0.0010814667, 0.013748169, -0.03439331, -0.036621094, -0.017944336, -0.029434204, -0.024475098, -0.011314392, 0.007320404, 0.038208008, 0.016494751, -0.0015983582, 0.0032920837, 0.026916504, -0.009887695, -0.0048217773, 0.0025310516, -0.023910522, -0.015716553, 0.051818848, 0.011451721, -0.0014123917, -0.011482239, -0.08691406, -0.025497437, 0.038970947, -0.03805542, -0.042510986, 0.006389618, -0.022460938, -0.011917114, 0.021560669, -0.03237915, 0.023269653, 0.09814453, 0.025848389, 0.028686523, 0.04397583, 0.052246094, 0.02748108, -0.01576233, -0.06021118, 0.006958008, 0.0033683777, -0.02609253, -0.007843018, -0.012069702, -0.028686523, -0.008354187, 0.0013113022, 0.019805908, 0.06304932, 0.0149002075, 0.04385376, 0.00340271, 0.040924072, -0.030441284, -0.002445221, -0.051239014, -0.011390686, -0.020950317, -0.011436462, 0.030181885, 0.017807007, -0.0049324036, 0.0043182373, -0.006652832, 0.0138549805, 0.027786255, 0.015617371, -0.025268555, 0.0013237, 0.0231781, -0.030181885, -0.007171631, -0.038635254, 0.0068359375, -0.012794495, 0.03149414, -0.012687683, 0.07672119, 0.01725769, 0.0011587143, 0.0031967163, -0.04083252, -0.0085372925, -0.01109314, -0.027389526, 0.0061416626, -0.0036506653, -0.015388489, 0.01550293, -0.006088257, -0.025390625, 0.006412506, -0.036956787, 0.03741455, -0.0014228821, -0.015625, 0.018051147, 0.025970459, -0.023361206, -0.006855011, -0.013755798, 0.008361816, 0.012710571, -0.003490448, -0.08154297, -0.011367798, -0.010681152, 0.008575439, -0.05783081, 0.010444641, 0.0077056885, -0.044158936, -0.015007019, -0.045196533, 0.02973938, -0.027786255, -0.014976501, -0.021240234, -0.0010995865, 0.00020170212, 0.0074920654, -0.04864502, -0.01878357, 0.049743652, 0.0178833, 0.0009822845, -0.008956909, -0.012031555, 0.011169434, -0.04486084, 0.02708435, -0.026504517, 0.03564453, -0.024932861, 0.012084961, 0.053588867, -0.04321289, -0.0049819946, -0.0026359558, -0.016677856, -0.009483337, 0.040405273, 0.012542725, 0.05441284, -0.032287598, 0.06048584, -0.00541687, -0.015335083, -0.07543945, -0.0039367676, -0.0020198822, -0.013381958, 0.010185242, -0.01727295, -0.0012798309, 0.013961792, 0.032684326, 0.059020996, -0.0005068779, 0.022003174, 0.054229736, -0.020080566, -0.014541626, 0.025772095, 0.04006958, 0.0037498474, -0.0024089813, -0.011299133, -0.020507812, -0.0027675629, -0.006843567, -0.06768799, 0.01876831, 0.053863525, -0.050354004, -0.020263672, -0.02078247, -0.091918945, -0.009719849, -0.015274048, -0.028442383, 0.02809143, 0.015319824, 0.010543823, -0.04196167, 0.005130768, 0.024215698, 0.01083374, -0.017730713, -0.0670166, 0.00944519, -0.02810669, -0.03353882, -0.010009766, 0.019989014, -0.0018730164, 0.054138184, -0.046081543, -0.04196167, -0.013435364, 0.047790527, 0.11645508, 0.020828247, -0.0035209656, -0.08111572, -0.04208374, -0.021636963, 0.015579224, -0.0028953552, 0.013633728, -0.025299072, 0.0008029938, 0.042663574, -0.0104904175, -0.011680603, -0.021514893, -0.007873535, -0.021865845, 0.024627686, 0.03286743, 0.06439209, 0.007873535, -0.019241333, 0.046020508, 0.018966675, -0.034606934, -0.06335449, 0.046020508, -0.013587952, 0.012107849, 0.009635925, 0.040039062, 0.030136108, -0.023727417, 0.009857178, 0.032073975, 0.051086426, -0.0011777878, -0.022949219, 0.023727417, -0.037078857, 0.0037727356, 0.009292603, -0.016586304, 0.030288696, -0.050689697, 0.06439209, 0.021865845, -0.028274536, 0.059753418, 0.0045661926, 0.014328003, 0.024261475, 0.004760742, -0.058441162, -0.03579712, -0.0056915283, 0.037384033, -0.041137695, -0.0010375977, -0.0079574585, -0.006248474, 0.05303955, 0.017944336, -0.017425537, -0.03756714, -0.028198242, 0.0013694763, -0.012886047, -0.029632568, -0.037139893, 0.0064697266, 0.0054626465, 0.014465332, -0.03768921, -0.022247314, -0.02986145, -0.031021118, -0.025863647, -0.0044822693, 0.02885437, -0.05770874, -0.015434265, 0.04626465, 0.020721436, -0.010009766, 0.0085372925, 0.05731201, 0.03289795, 0.026397705, 0.027862549, 0.017929077, 0.014419556, 0.0048332214, 0.05722046, -0.016555786, 0.017181396, -0.020507812, 0.042114258, -0.028335571, 0.056152344, -0.083618164, 0.018447876, -0.03010559, -0.011955261, 0.019332886, -0.036865234, 0.023742676, -0.0099105835, -0.028747559, 0.039398193, -0.040100098, -0.01335907, -0.018997192, 0.0007762909, -0.0362854, 0.028320312, 0.03326416, -0.02003479, -0.10546875, 0.022949219, -0.055603027, 0.008216858, -0.028320312, 0.013557434, -0.055023193, -0.0031013489, 0.011955261, -0.062805176, 0.016952515, 0.02407837, 0.051330566, 0.03274536, -0.038116455, -0.019989014, -0.0017976761, 0.013648987, -0.025222778, -0.0002808571, 0.025878906, 0.00819397, -0.019104004, -0.012802124, -0.030639648, -0.03805542, -0.010299683, 0.00026798248, -0.00017917156, -0.015899658, 0.02407837, -0.01084137, -0.00712204, -0.000066399574, 0.0121154785, -0.00014662743, -0.008369446, -0.00434494, 0.005065918, 0.0024337769, 0.0146484375, 0.016021729, -0.0015697479, 0.016555786, -0.010353088, 0.036468506, -0.003458023, -0.030029297, 0.026306152, 0.035491943, -0.017120361, 0.011444092, 0.0050735474, 0.078552246, -0.045166016, -0.03540039, -0.01158905, 0.0005979538, 0.014228821, 0.109558105, -0.02607727, -0.054229736, -0.031036377, -0.032104492, -0.018493652, 0.011917114, 0.04663086, -0.009094238, 0.034606934, -0.062805176, -0.028289795, -0.011688232, 0.021469116, -0.017166138, 0.0047721863, 0.0015535355, 0.006450653, -0.020629883, 0.007621765, 0.016021729, -0.03717041, 0.0024757385, -0.035980225, -0.011161804, 0.013160706, 0.019577026, 0.02078247, -0.01663208, 0.004257202, 0.064941406, 0.013168335, 0.020309448, 0.09649658, -0.017349243, 0.0131073, -0.011161804, 0.027709961, 0.003129959, -0.01751709, -0.04159546, 0.0072021484, 0.034484863, -0.0473938, -0.021087646, -0.0715332, -0.00598526, -0.033843994, 0.0035324097, -0.011505127, -0.010475159, 0.03074646, 0.027694702, 0.0036678314, 0.008651733, 0.04638672, 0.0067710876, 0.03656006, -0.05947876, 0.059509277, 0.0014448166, 0.006175995, -0.023239136, 0.04788208, 0.008811951, 0.0030212402, -0.0149383545, 0.062683105, -0.01612854, -0.027038574, 0.039276123, 0.003824234, 0, 0.0024757385, 0.0015106201, -0.031402588, -0.0029850006, -0.01889038, -0.017578125, 0.03781128, 0.06561279, -0.06488037, 0.020507812, 0.030319214, -0.006008148, -0.009918213, -0.017990112, 0.022125244, -0.09124756, 0.03652954, 0.028167725, -0.013511658, -0.037475586, 0.084228516, 0.0042533875, 0.014907837, 0.028198242, 0.0067481995, 0.007980347, 0.039886475, 0.023010254, -0.030136108, 0.013389587, 0.04324341, -0.0013875961, -0.001531601, -0.013885498, 0.038726807, 0.009185791, 0.0042495728, -0.003955841, -0.049194336, 0.0340271, -0.09057617, 0.019943237, 0.012214661, -0.0040283203, -0.011512756, -0.024414062, -0.029571533, 0.021392822, -0.024307251, 0.0026569366, 0.021194458, 0.04953003, 0.016738892, 0.055389404, 0.00066423416, -0.014144897, 0.020706177, -0.024307251, 0.013252258, 0.02418518, -0.03567505, -0.016479492, 0.018722534, -0.015182495, 0.035308838, 0.0049438477, 0.044952393, -0.049041748, 0.009941101, -0.030914307, 0.008117676, -0.000872612, -0.039855957, -0.019882202, -0.02520752, -0.059051514, 0.034484863, 0.04159546, -0.038635254, -0.003446579, 0.008331299, -0.031280518, 0.022079468, 0.0018367767, 0.016220093, -0.006134033, -0.04498291, 0.0069732666, -0.01876831, 0.040405273, -0.022354126, -0.04360962, -0.02532959, -0.011100769, 0.016906738, 0.022583008, 0.008888245, 0.008613586, -0.037261963, -0.04537964, 0.03012085, 0.02658081, -0.0052604675, 0.04598999, -0.057006836, 0.026245117, -0.0057640076, -0.0040283203, 0.036254883, -0.021118164, -0.070495605, -0.015045166, -0.013763428, 0.029556274, 0.0256958, 0.005317688, 0.029205322, 0.02166748, -0.032684326, 0.05142212, -0.010108948, 0.039031982, 0.007522583, -0.062561035, 0.0019893646, 0.012763977, 0.031433105, -0.03062439, -0.021362305, 0.01751709, 0.053894043, -0.011199951, 0.036010742, 0.012779236, 0.0068130493, 0.039489746, 0.007926941, 0.001947403, -0.026306152, -0.054656982, -0.03451538, 0.07208252, 0.029083252, -0.033813477, -0.036712646, 0.017944336, 0.0059509277, -0.01763916, 0.005794525, 0.00076150894, -0.024597168, 0.011711121, 0.024398804, -0.004234314, -0.038757324, -0.018371582, 0.03881836, -0.008834839, 0.0036697388, 0.026489258, -0.003370285, -0.008491516, 0.09399414, -0.02720642, -0.020950317, 0.04815674, 0.008071899, 0.035247803, -0.007209778, 0.026931763, 0.008644104, 0.00018310547, -0.019104004, 0.00073337555, 0.0044555664, 0.053344727, -0.06530762, 0.009162903, -0.08074951, -0.016830444, -0.03112793, -0.010864258, 0.00919342, -0.022491455, 0.019638062, -0.022109985, -0.009719849, 0.011146545, 0.0009069443, 0.036315918, 0.011421204, -0.028244019, -0.027954102, 0.008354187, -0.011383057 ], "summary": [ 0.027191162, -0.0066833496, 0.0066833496, 0.01626587, -0.027801514, -0.016220093, -0.001294136, -0.04147339, 0.026321411, 0.0033836365, -0.019958496, -0.037200928, 0.023971558, -0.05368042, -0.0158844, -0.025024414, -0.0077400208, 0.057739258, 0.013641357, -0.025054932, 0.0012931824, -0.023071289, 0.006263733, -0.010398865, 0.021774292, -0.0070648193, -0.07507324, 0.017669678, -0.0034503937, 0.0082092285, 0.005634308, 0.029800415, 0.025283813, 0.0054244995, -0.026489258, -0.008811951, -0.030532837, 0.018692017, 0.012191772, -0.0017366409, 0.04385376, -0.020004272, 0.08404541, 0.0032348633, 0.021942139, 0.017288208, 0.02633667, -0.05871582, 0.021209717, -0.007896423, 0.023239136, 0.026046753, 0.019210815, -0.018753052, -0.01171875, 0.01939392, -0.057128906, -0.008346558, 0.012496948, 0.13989258, 0.028503418, 0.0015211105, -0.040374756, -0.11077881, -0.043548584, -0.012329102, -0.005558014, 0.0052490234, 0.033203125, -0.027389526, 0.017852783, 0.030059814, 0.0046691895, -0.0211792, -0.011184692, -0.0054359436, 0.030578613, 0.0056419373, -0.012435913, -0.000007033348, 0.016830444, 0.019973755, 0.015899658, -0.032318115, -0.001241684, -0.031677246, -0.011871338, -0.0032424927, -0.038757324, -0.011688232, -0.013267517, -0.041992188, -0.06341553, 0.051452637, 0.051605225, -0.047790527, -0.022338867, 0.0002156496, -0.02935791, 0.012886047, 0.019470215, -0.018753052, 0.021942139, -0.035736084, 0.011077881, -0.004436493, -0.0473938, -0.072143555, 0.009132385, 0.044921875, -0.024734497, -0.02029419, 0.0012893677, -0.04168701, -0.01184082, 0.027374268, 0.029815674, 0.015052795, 0.024230957, 0.0025138855, -0.014564514, 0.016418457, -0.014343262, 0.0151901245, 0.02128601, 0.022262573, 0.0062828064, -0.010795593, -0.011726379, -0.040802002, -0.010818481, 0.040100098, 0.007385254, 0.012176514, -0.021636963, 0.023880005, -0.009284973, -0.006904602, 0.025115967, -0.033050537, 0.085754395, -0.012458801, -0.02720642, 0.07940674, 0.0368042, 0.0028152466, 0.02720642, 0.035888672, -0.009231567, -0.028289795, 0.0725708, -0.000029087067, 0.024475098, -0.0012559891, -0.04031372, -0.038116455, -0.05239868, -0.018661499, 0.034454346, -0.021362305, 0.028060913, 0.0107803345, -0.0043754578, 0.059539795, 0.024169922, -0.018844604, 0.0050849915, 0.01676941, 0.0035991669, -0.06213379, 0.013847351, 0.026016235, 0.0090789795, -0.02166748, 0.02545166, 0.007575989, -0.016418457, 0.016204834, 0.012817383, -0.030883789, -0.00894928, -0.03074646, -0.0055389404, 0.03125, -0.020355225, 0.027374268, 0.0017137527, 0.08111572, 0.031280518, 0.02331543, -0.038238525, -0.012931824, 0.010902405, 0.012535095, -0.023895264, -0.057006836, 0.005470276, -0.008735657, -0.03543091, 0.030883789, 0.020004272, 0.010116577, 0.0071525574, -0.008743286, -0.038116455, 0.0060691833, -0.019699097, 0.0018529892, 0.046417236, -0.017059326, -0.031829834, -0.045135498, 0.014160156, -0.03994751, -0.07269287, -0.013145447, 0.03250122, -0.032928467, -0.030166626, -0.044433594, -0.015525818, 0.000998497, -0.029510498, 0.09588623, 0.008323669, 0.01675415, -0.012207031, 0.0065345764, 0.07543945, 0.010108948, 0.07165527, -0.02168274, -0.008422852, 0.013648987, -0.0206604, -0.0026016235, -0.0011320114, -0.049224854, 0.02658081, 0.033691406, 0.032440186, -0.0340271, -0.024795532, 0.010772705, 0.005126953, -0.0027713776, 0.012786865, -0.018005371, -0.03390503, -0.022506714, 0.025604248, 0.007045746, 0.023513794, -0.019699097, -0.002298355, 0.019958496, -0.029373169, -0.02784729, 0.012107849, -0.011512756, 0.018173218, -0.022155762, -0.010269165, -0.011512756, -0.021713257, -0.00969696, -0.0012388229, -0.0076141357, 0.02104187, -0.009719849, 0.0029010773, -0.06341553, -0.0020370483, -0.022033691, -0.01386261, -0.026504517, -0.051696777, 0.036346436, 0.01473999, -0.03488159, -0.020690918, 0.0015802383, 0.0009365082, -0.019882202, 0.02760315, 0.038879395, -0.0019292831, -0.045410156, 0.019897461, 0.042419434, 0.030548096, 0.05102539, 0.024459839, 0.0037231445, 0.019073486, -0.006385803, -0.022659302, 0.037078857, -0.018218994, -0.013160706, -0.0152282715, 0.0209198, -0.009674072, -0.010131836, 0.019699097, 0.007881165, 0.033172607, 0.017837524, 0.025634766, -0.011276245, 0.032287598, 0.028747559, -0.0036849976, 0.05731201, -0.06945801, -0.08270264, -0.034454346, 0.012176514, -0.027053833, 0.018966675, 0.06335449, -0.013465881, -0.031143188, -0.0040626526, -0.012763977, -0.024597168, 0.004261017, -0.028244019, 0.020950317, 0.030715942, 0.025665283, 0.052368164, -0.0115737915, 0.02949524, 0.018676758, 0.004650116, 0.026611328, -0.041870117, 0.01852417, 0.040039062, 0.06567383, 0.051635742, 0.007507324, -0.011451721, -0.03668213, -0.004714966, -0.004688263, 0.016571045, -0.08343506, -0.024353027, 0.043060303, -0.057250977, -0.03665161, 0.020690918, -0.012382507, -0.01979065, 0.04248047, 0.03652954, -0.02142334, -0.008224487, 0.062927246, 0.051330566, 0.053894043, -0.09448242, -0.07550049, -0.053863525, -0.013648987, 0.0057411194, -0.0009822845, 0.04458618, -0.02305603, 0.024780273, -0.019088745, -0.01701355, -0.023605347, 0.003004074, 0.08666992, -0.026351929, -0.028335571, 0.02911377, -0.016555786, 0.0075683594, -0.030197144, -0.007194519, 0.015731812, 0.016525269, 0.008079529, 0.0032043457, 0.009750366, -0.013450623, -0.015792847, 0.0012359619, -0.021514893, -0.0151901245, 0.043304443, 0.031021118, -0.0013971329, -0.014572144, -0.040863037, -0.03604126, 0.032836914, -0.025100708, -0.020370483, -0.008804321, 0.00957489, -0.029159546, 0.03933716, -0.028656006, 0.0025138855, 0.071899414, 0.010345459, 0.013801575, 0.011009216, 0.060821533, 0.014732361, -0.012641907, 0.0020580292, 0.0025634766, 0.010505676, -0.014411926, -0.01309967, 0.024154663, -0.02178955, -0.003921509, 0.019714355, 0.027450562, 0.026184082, -0.01007843, 0.02619934, 0.02218628, 0.02583313, -0.02154541, -0.003917694, -0.051849365, 0.0027675629, -0.013664246, -0.031158447, -0.011787415, -0.02684021, -0.007820129, -0.014839172, -0.010749817, -0.00022733212, 0.0072288513, 0.02104187, -0.01878357, -0.0077552795, 0.0047340393, -0.0014667511, 0.008598328, -0.011558533, -0.015556335, 0.03363037, 0.033447266, -0.022979736, 0.073791504, -0.005794525, 0.034973145, 0.07879639, -0.070495605, -0.039123535, -0.028808594, -0.013442993, 0.025009155, 0.020233154, -0.015991211, -0.015686035, 0.02748108, 0.00080776215, 0.007270813, 0.027954102, 0.0033130646, -0.0034809113, -0.027420044, 0.008140564, -0.017425537, 0.027496338, -0.016143799, 0.022521973, -0.028518677, -0.053100586, 0.012649536, -0.08795166, 0.0029525757, 0.004550934, 0.009429932, -0.0062217712, -0.0052108765, 0.008270264, 0.009109497, 0.0178833, -0.009513855, 0.037261963, 0.010192871, 0.0038223267, -0.013465881, -0.016983032, 0.09033203, 0.0121536255, -0.02960205, 0.015151978, -0.015594482, 0.032226562, 0.013328552, -0.052093506, 0.028747559, 0.027709961, 0.024490356, 0.037872314, -0.072265625, 0.021896362, -0.023925781, 0.005634308, 0.053619385, -0.042877197, 0.010803223, -0.030212402, 0.031173706, -0.04611206, 0.005207062, 0.042999268, 0.049743652, -0.02520752, 0.011764526, 0.005268097, -0.012069702, -0.038085938, 0.0047798157, 0.0413208, -0.020996094, -0.00034618378, -0.019866943, -0.019714355, 0.04425049, 0.040161133, 0.037994385, -0.018692017, -0.03137207, 0.05130005, 0.030731201, 0.0032920837, 0.03326416, -0.0034255981, 0.041381836, -0.014198303, 0.007701874, -0.027160645, -0.00013065338, -0.022140503, -0.042419434, -0.0013303757, 0.03164673, -0.015098572, -0.049346924, 0.00071811676, -0.08972168, 0.023208618, -0.033050537, -0.009567261, -0.00067949295, -0.013031006, 0.015083313, 0.020721436, -0.029510498, 0.0317688, 0.024612427, -0.013511658, -0.047821045, 0.0032997131, -0.039276123, -0.013626099, -0.014923096, 0.005996704, -0.039093018, -0.00617218, -0.03137207, -0.062164307, -0.015342712, 0.018096924, 0.08660889, 0.050231934, 0.013687134, -0.11248779, -0.080200195, -0.009513855, 0.0053520203, -0.004585266, 0.0087509155, -0.012039185, -0.015113831, 0.012832642, -0.009635925, -0.010421753, -0.016448975, -0.01423645, -0.020553589, 0.034698486, 0.019760132, 0.037597656, 0.004699707, -0.004497528, 0.005783081, -0.0028209686, -0.012077332, -0.053131104, 0.009796143, -0.024719238, 0.021087646, 0.0073890686, -0.00027394295, 0.031677246, -0.052764893, 0.032073975, 0.034210205, 0.03161621, -0.020812988, -0.02558899, 0.03250122, -0.0028514862, -0.030212402, -0.005290985, -0.006511688, -0.009170532, -0.010375977, 0.03213501, 0.019592285, -0.029937744, 0.053222656, -0.0013961792, -0.012123108, 0.015304565, -0.012069702, -0.059051514, -0.024230957, -0.005207062, 0.016342163, -0.026016235, -0.022827148, 0.0037326813, -0.016998291, 0.0463562, -0.00056791306, -0.0073051453, -0.050323486, -0.02128601, -0.00093460083, -0.0005464554, 0.0058937073, -0.0076026917, -0.010932922, 0.01737976, 0.008361816, -0.03366089, -0.024261475, 0.009475708, -0.013824463, -0.014457703, -0.0151901245, 0.007724762, -0.04827881, -0.048553467, -0.009529114, -0.03164673, -0.014289856, 0.03164673, 0.029693604, 0.0006017685, 0.009765625, -0.004299164, 0.0057296753, -0.025375366, -0.0079193115, 0.041870117, -0.029327393, 0.015686035, 0.019973755, -0.0074653625, 0.005630493, 0.03488159, -0.04333496, -0.010009766, -0.038726807, 0.005832672, 0.029388428, -0.030441284, 0.031066895, -0.014122009, -0.028289795, 0.026367188, -0.012245178, -0.0028572083, -0.016662598, 0.021560669, -0.015777588, -0.007381439, 0.01789856, 0.0038642883, -0.049468994, 0.022979736, -0.06866455, -0.008720398, 0.0018577576, -0.005519867, -0.01084137, -0.017669678, -0.03250122, -0.04083252, 0.0121154785, 0.04550171, 0.057891846, -0.002998352, -0.0715332, -0.0052223206, 0.017608643, -0.005870819, 0.018295288, 0.011398315, 0.006565094, -0.011352539, 0.009544373, 0.00806427, 0.00006753206, -0.0025539398, 0.0033435822, 0.022033691, -0.008834839, -0.039031982, 0.02368164, -0.00085639954, -0.012741089, 0.02935791, -0.052734375, -0.016555786, 0.018081665, 0.0016565323, 0.035614014, 0.011657715, 0.012413025, 0.04800415, -0.04244995, -0.04699707, 0.0052719116, 0.033996582, 0.021087646, 0.0023727417, 0.0107803345, 0.01914978, -0.049072266, 0.010093689, 0.0067367554, 0.054718018, -0.03326416, -0.057434082, -0.016998291, 0.018096924, 0.011665344, 0.06549072, -0.028549194, -0.06695557, -0.015075684, -0.052520752, -0.0077209473, 0.01033783, 0.049224854, 0.0058517456, 0.057769775, -0.070129395, -0.022064209, -0.02217102, 0.027023315, 0.013206482, -0.0012836456, -0.017913818, 0.012214661, -0.03213501, 0.02519226, -0.005016327, -0.008125305, 0.016601562, -0.027114868, -0.01436615, 0.038726807, 0.054229736, 0.016342163, -0.028289795, 0.028442383, 0.04458618, 0.02519226, -0.0027446747, 0.05505371, 0.0051956177, 0.007522583, -0.018981934, -0.028274536, -0.0053710938, -0.004535675, -0.04949951, -0.010932922, 0.019515991, -0.033966064, 0.0056495667, -0.026062012, -0.027923584, -0.050445557, -0.027801514, 0.030685425, 0.028656006, -0.017944336, -0.0024814606, 0.028900146, 0.009170532, 0.06738281, 0.00091934204, -0.03326416, -0.074401855, 0.014343262, 0.03262329, 0.0031394958, -0.0040512085, 0.03479004, 0.0051651, 0.022216797, -0.009292603, 0.068237305, -0.013969421, -0.0066871643, 0.025024414, 0.0041656494, -0.013755798, -0.044830322, 0.018203735, -0.053466797, 0.0052948, 0.0059547424, -0.0003900528, 0.011199951, 0.052581787, -0.04940796, 0.02696228, 0.038513184, -0.015563965, 0.0011701584, -0.030029297, -0.0072135925, -0.061920166, -0.010948181, 0.025772095, 0.01083374, 0.009010315, 0.10253906, -0.016220093, 0.018478394, 0.053009033, -0.002714157, -0.0038280487, 0.04034424, 0.008308411, -0.0345459, 0.029281616, 0.049682617, -0.045440674, -0.0012245178, -0.051971436, 0.046844482, 0.006580353, 0.01625061, -0.009284973, -0.037078857, 0.032562256, -0.029190063, 0.038330078, -0.012214661, -0.03353882, 0.022506714, -0.0013780594, -0.010002136, 0.040740967, 0.007217407, 0.0362854, 0.013580322, 0.04776001, 0.054382324, 0.053894043, -0.029129028, 0.009422302, 0.05316162, -0.01777649, -0.0014715195, 0.008888245, -0.026977539, -0.047790527, 0.051971436, 0.009361267, 0.020187378, 0.050354004, 0.03186035, -0.027954102, -0.02180481, -0.044189453, 0.019073486, -0.041534424, -0.021759033, -0.009002686, -0.059173584, -0.06689453, 0.03375244, 0.053100586, -0.021560669, 0.022918701, 0.014030457, -0.05770874, 0.032836914, 0.00843811, 0.025283813, -0.005027771, -0.031219482, 0.030471802, -0.006752014, 0.056671143, -0.013763428, -0.031799316, -0.022537231, 0.0068588257, 0.025756836, -0.0023345947, 0.0007452965, 0.050201416, -0.02255249, -0.04537964, 0.00248909, -0.0007786751, -0.03869629, -0.006286621, -0.05722046, 0.016860962, -0.019226074, 0.015853882, 0.044830322, 0.0074920654, -0.09674072, -0.028060913, -0.013420105, 0.046417236, 0.020812988, 0.015533447, 0.02027893, 0.028656006, -0.03164673, 0.02848816, 0.00072574615, 0.027542114, 0.013542175, -0.04928589, -0.010627747, 0.011276245, 0.0075645447, -0.032684326, -0.003074646, 0.03665161, 0.07287598, -0.0028915405, -0.028747559, -0.026153564, -0.009414673, 0.079956055, 0.031982422, 0.016418457, -0.03829956, -0.04095459, -0.025421143, 0.082458496, -0.004135132, -0.035827637, -0.03970337, 0.00012397766, -0.012496948, -0.02204895, 0.0047721863, 0.02029419, -0.030303955, 0.02168274, 0.020355225, -0.020904541, -0.05105591, -0.024627686, 0.010368347, 0.0008659363, -0.012382507, 0.0110321045, 0.0070495605, -0.028549194, 0.055145264, -0.0152282715, 0.012840271, 0.028137207, -0.0071754456, 0.04269409, -0.03579712, 0.040100098, 0.02180481, 0.036987305, -0.027420044, 0.0029773712, -0.011184692, 0.03201294, -0.103881836, -0.045288086, -0.089660645, -0.033325195, -0.051971436, -0.037963867, -0.00024092197, -0.021072388, 0.03692627, 0.031677246, -0.006839752, 0.01965332, 0.003326416, 0.0028476715, 0.009590149, 0.0032634735, -0.053863525, -0.019622803, 0.0015106201 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2010.08715v1
Understanding Information Processing in Human Brain by Interpreting Machine Learning Models
Ilya Kuzovkin
q-bio.NC, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T07, 68T30, 92-08, 92-10, 92C20, 92B20, I.2.6; I.5.4; J.3
The thesis explores the role machine learning methods play in creating intuitive computational models of neural processing. Combined with interpretability techniques, machine learning could replace human modeler and shift the focus of human effort to extracting the knowledge from the ready-made models and articulating that knowledge into intuitive descroptions of reality. This perspective makes the case in favor of the larger role that exploratory and data-driven approach to computational neuroscience could play while coexisting alongside the traditional hypothesis-driven approach. We exemplify the proposed approach in the context of the knowledge representation taxonomy with three research projects that employ interpretability techniques on top of machine learning methods at three different levels of neural organization. The first study (Chapter 3) explores feature importance analysis of a random forest decoder trained on intracerebral recordings from 100 human subjects to identify spectrotemporal signatures that characterize local neural activity during the task of visual categorization. The second study (Chapter 4) employs representation similarity analysis to compare the neural responses of the areas along the ventral stream with the activations of the layers of a deep convolutional neural network. The third study (Chapter 5) proposes a method that allows test subjects to visually explore the state representation of their neural signal in real time. This is achieved by using a topology-preserving dimensionality reduction technique that allows to transform the neural data from the multidimensional representation used by the computer into a two-dimensional representation a human can grasp. The approach, the taxonomy, and the examples, present a strong case for the applicability of machine learning methods to automatic knowledge discovery in neuroscience.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2010.08715v1
"2020-10-17T04:37:26"
"2020-10-17T04:37:26"
{ "title": [ -0.013694763, 0.0000071525574, -0.026641846, -0.025268555, 0.002714157, -0.027236938, -0.009460449, -0.033813477, -0.027023315, 0.026977539, -0.007255554, -0.02293396, 0.0039978027, -0.03857422, -0.03491211, -0.0001745224, 0.004207611, 0.027435303, -0.014923096, -0.025100708, -0.04623413, -0.02128601, 0.05319214, 0.013504028, 0.0362854, -0.037384033, -0.0847168, 0.0073890686, -0.03793335, -0.042419434, -0.01890564, 0.04663086, 0.045135498, 0.018035889, -0.013587952, 0.010803223, -0.040008545, 0.028167725, 0.004611969, -0.0184021, 0.0038490295, 0.0052261353, -0.03729248, -0.0068244934, -0.052764893, -0.0009665489, -0.0592041, -0.00818634, -0.0017776489, 0.028152466, 0.008422852, 0.025817871, -0.010604858, 0.05041504, 0.010650635, -0.029632568, -0.03253174, -0.026290894, 0.018661499, 0.080444336, 0.026763916, -0.03756714, 0.01638794, -0.026809692, -0.04953003, -0.030151367, -0.038879395, 0.02381897, 0.056365967, -0.0020523071, -0.010658264, 0.024291992, 0.0044937134, 0.006629944, -0.050994873, -0.017166138, 0.06921387, 0.017684937, 0.018539429, -0.030944824, 0.0149383545, -0.024368286, 0.010437012, -0.013305664, 0.0072250366, -0.011428833, -0.012413025, -0.018951416, -0.03363037, -0.0552063, -0.010246277, -0.0044898987, -0.0038032532, 0.020553589, -0.04196167, -0.013687134, -0.024871826, 0.0045547485, 0.006023407, -0.014503479, -0.030273438, 0.023040771, -0.068237305, 0.003522873, 0.024795532, 0.029205322, -0.017990112, -0.055541992, 0.0024757385, 0.023239136, -0.02154541, 0.037902832, 0.014846802, -0.03286743, 0.010139465, 0.02015686, -0.0034713745, 0.042022705, 0.032165527, 0.028167725, -0.008033752, -0.022888184, -0.014022827, 0.017333984, 0.027191162, 0.010749817, -0.029205322, 0.009765625, -0.027130127, 0.040222168, 0.0027637482, 0.036895752, -0.119018555, -0.078125, -0.068359375, 0.027526855, 0.019638062, -0.0038642883, -0.014503479, 0.00042033195, 0.0050239563, -0.040863037, -0.009239197, 0.006263733, -0.005958557, -0.0038032532, 0.07019043, 0.00028944016, -0.066589355, -0.033203125, -0.027114868, 0.030578613, 0.012001038, 0.018569946, -0.05935669, 0.027908325, -0.1418457, -0.0010318756, 0.018600464, 0.024414062, 0.03277588, 0.00957489, -0.017181396, 0.008857727, 0.051574707, -0.008651733, -0.028900146, 0.037750244, 0.0031261444, -0.018005371, 0.008094788, 0.017471313, 0.0006108284, -0.015853882, -0.004787445, 0.010017395, 0.032958984, -0.0070991516, 0.017410278, 0.020843506, -0.0013065338, -0.027145386, -0.0017614365, 0.0463562, -0.056274414, -0.013328552, 0.00083971024, 0.0044021606, 0.052612305, 0.011833191, -0.056427002, 0.019439697, -0.03817749, -0.05319214, -0.03515625, -0.004878998, 0.05795288, 0.027877808, 0.0031375885, 0.02357483, -0.030731201, 0.0005326271, -0.024627686, -0.014511108, -0.018707275, -0.032440186, -0.0012969971, 0.02796936, -0.0054473877, 0.06008911, 0.036071777, 0.0289917, -0.01914978, -0.017410278, -0.020095825, -0.04434204, 0.014198303, -0.012329102, -0.02709961, -0.008392334, -0.04727173, -0.012512207, -0.019577026, 0.058502197, 0.034088135, 0.0060310364, 0.00957489, -0.045959473, 0.062316895, 0.027114868, 0.06518555, -0.053497314, 0.030578613, -0.0028209686, -0.030426025, -0.025360107, -0.017181396, -0.0047340393, 0.014839172, 0.021728516, 0.011161804, -0.027526855, 0.0036563873, 0.024719238, 0.076049805, 0.013244629, -0.0018978119, 0.005634308, 0.03265381, 0.02986145, 0.064331055, 0.014862061, 0.056488037, 0.015457153, 0.00844574, 0.074523926, -0.0014867783, -0.008262634, -0.012680054, 0.032592773, -0.015716553, 0.03503418, 0.018707275, 0.011734009, -0.038085938, 0.014419556, -0.030838013, -0.0006418228, -0.004787445, 0.02619934, 0.036621094, -0.036132812, 0.012130737, -0.010131836, -0.03604126, -0.021987915, -0.016845703, 0.03466797, 0.0088272095, -0.06137085, -0.01776123, 0.022476196, 0.01285553, 0.0054130554, 0.01651001, 0.013771057, 0.0074501038, -0.01461792, -0.009490967, -0.010536194, 0.043670654, 0.051361084, 0.012756348, 0.005569458, 0.009292603, 0.012306213, 0.08074951, 0.057128906, -0.02999878, 0.022003174, -0.056030273, 0.0209198, 0.012046814, -0.020690918, 0.012130737, 0.043182373, 0.010925293, 0.023269653, -0.03451538, 0.0152282715, -0.06762695, -0.0002989769, -0.0019464493, -0.03677368, -0.022476196, -0.038909912, -0.025024414, -0.049621582, -0.07104492, -0.030853271, 0.059783936, -0.0023918152, -0.031433105, -0.03475952, 0.0051231384, -0.013450623, -0.039764404, -0.042236328, -0.022827148, 0.014099121, 0.049987793, 0.008354187, -0.04824829, -0.014640808, 0.0020542145, 0.03250122, -0.017166138, 0.021652222, -0.024398804, 0.010932922, 0.010910034, 0.010284424, 0.026306152, -0.055786133, -0.021591187, -0.021728516, 0.01600647, 0.028076172, -0.02861023, -0.0074005127, 0.030578613, -0.0209198, -0.02658081, 0.033111572, 0.054992676, -0.028564453, -0.009094238, 0.041412354, 0.019165039, -0.01574707, 0.04321289, 0.0014572144, 0.010101318, -0.035186768, 0.0025787354, -0.06933594, -0.022369385, -0.012107849, 0.0077705383, 0.059051514, -0.059783936, -0.009307861, -0.00018382072, 0.0036182404, 0.005706787, 0.014793396, -0.00010162592, -0.035125732, -0.028366089, -0.013496399, -0.014579773, 0.01586914, -0.015411377, -0.003862381, 0.08618164, -0.010864258, -0.026443481, -0.005683899, 0.04876709, 0.022613525, -0.019577026, -0.037139893, -0.013381958, 0.010116577, 0.005329132, 0.021102905, -0.027557373, -0.023910522, -0.111083984, 0.0066947937, 0.03756714, -0.0070877075, -0.03427124, 0.021759033, -0.07196045, 0.0423584, -0.016845703, -0.00072956085, 0.024017334, 0.07147217, -0.021743774, 0.0064849854, 0.01576233, -0.034423828, 0.026947021, -0.017196655, -0.1105957, 0.02746582, -0.02532959, -0.019500732, -0.007850647, -0.03375244, -0.04257202, 0.000009834766, -0.0077285767, 0.047424316, 0.03591919, 0.0110321045, 0.034362793, -0.005680084, 0.0116119385, -0.02078247, -0.027008057, -0.028427124, -0.015075684, 0.014724731, -0.021759033, 0.05029297, -0.0036506653, 0.01689148, -0.01612854, 0.0044403076, -0.016571045, 0.025146484, -0.0054855347, -0.039245605, 0.011711121, -0.023010254, -0.02760315, -0.0041503906, -0.01210022, 0.000044703484, -0.005039215, 0.02217102, -0.007987976, 0.027420044, 0.016403198, 0.0033798218, -0.006515503, -0.018600464, 0.01751709, -0.027893066, -0.062561035, 0.022445679, 0.018035889, -0.013580322, 0.06512451, -0.00592041, 0.008178711, 0.006286621, -0.019622803, 0.014625549, 0.020812988, 0.0020523071, 0.0040397644, 0.009361267, -0.050628662, 0.010032654, -0.03677368, 0.04031372, -0.0043258667, 0.007282257, -0.039855957, -0.0513916, -0.008155823, 0.013702393, -0.09918213, -0.023529053, 0.010536194, -0.05697632, -0.03353882, -0.06451416, 0.019515991, -0.050628662, -0.054870605, -0.009933472, -0.025924683, -0.02015686, -0.030654907, -0.067993164, -0.028701782, 0.062438965, -0.0018119812, 0.033599854, 0.026977539, -0.018478394, -0.014167786, -0.034332275, 0.028518677, 0.012779236, 0.035614014, -0.0073547363, 0.006061554, 0.04324341, -0.036743164, 0.030212402, 0.016571045, 0.0019798279, -0.0050468445, 0.016693115, 0.007160187, 0.036132812, -0.041809082, 0.046844482, 0.043548584, -0.018035889, -0.07305908, 0.018157959, -0.008560181, -0.035583496, 0.020401001, 0.0031833649, 0.015258789, 0.041656494, -0.005542755, 0.0657959, -0.015808105, -0.0058174133, 0.00063848495, -0.023086548, -0.01852417, 0.010192871, 0.018692017, -0.004360199, -0.0064888, 0.025848389, 0.0062713623, 0.0463562, -0.013725281, -0.04663086, 0.021850586, 0.03024292, -0.02357483, -0.0045318604, -0.06628418, -0.059570312, -0.022003174, 0.010932922, -0.011878967, 0.01889038, 0.0390625, -0.004585266, -0.017425537, -0.0059776306, 0.013618469, 0.0074005127, -0.03466797, -0.062164307, 0.006275177, -0.041259766, -0.06518555, -0.055725098, -0.022750854, -0.023757935, 0.024093628, 0.012329102, -0.01448822, 0.018066406, 0.02935791, 0.08459473, 0.047729492, -0.008666992, -0.060150146, 0.026916504, -0.03677368, -0.008918762, 0.01828003, -0.0057258606, -0.012664795, -0.03062439, 0.006252289, -0.008232117, -0.0044937134, -0.052825928, 0.012886047, -0.007484436, 0.033355713, -0.005344391, 0.026397705, 0.017318726, -0.0043792725, 0.018310547, 0.006038666, -0.038238525, -0.030670166, 0.026138306, 0.04159546, -0.004524231, 0.027175903, 0.058898926, 0.026046753, -0.023513794, -0.0054130554, 0.028366089, 0.038269043, -0.020935059, -0.0011730194, 0.039093018, -0.03817749, -0.034973145, -0.0052375793, 0.012466431, 0.04360962, -0.07775879, 0.05444336, -0.02772522, 0.010597229, 0.03564453, -0.002828598, 0.01109314, -0.0068969727, 0.02079773, -0.06112671, -0.0435791, -0.017990112, 0.039123535, -0.040100098, -0.01083374, -0.003648758, 0.00894165, 0.031921387, 0.043670654, 0.02609253, -0.0155181885, 0.026260376, -0.022201538, -0.0084991455, -0.005393982, -0.043670654, 0.011703491, 0.006046295, 0.023971558, -0.049591064, 0.009628296, -0.04763794, -0.017471313, -0.0053901672, -0.014205933, 0.018112183, -0.084106445, 0.013450623, 0.0569458, -0.007972717, 0.02017212, -0.024505615, 0.01789856, 0.031921387, 0.034606934, 0.002067566, 0.020614624, 0.02532959, -0.030014038, 0.009887695, 0.0013360977, 0.038604736, 0.023010254, 0.02229309, 0.022506714, 0.018798828, -0.03729248, 0.023391724, -0.03173828, -0.021697998, 0.034820557, -0.04925537, 0.01398468, 0.011734009, -0.0093688965, 0.0074806213, -0.04257202, -0.025543213, 0.036132812, -0.041229248, -0.0035247803, 0.028762817, -0.0015573502, -0.04296875, -0.08935547, 0.025268555, 0.0071487427, 0.022155762, -0.04248047, 0.024917603, -0.07598877, 0.028121948, 0.004611969, -0.08337402, 0.013008118, -0.022994995, 0.0181427, 0.038604736, 0.012664795, -0.06317139, -0.0068855286, -0.005016327, -0.08319092, -0.040527344, 0.018463135, 0.017700195, -0.02142334, -0.019607544, -0.044830322, -0.0041656494, -0.0078125, 0.013542175, 0.009643555, -0.027404785, 0.02180481, 0.014266968, 0.02142334, 0.0046844482, 0.049713135, 0.01133728, -0.0060920715, 0.009651184, -0.028274536, 0.007843018, -0.009765625, 0.001958847, -0.027053833, -0.055755615, 0.007850647, 0.021636963, 0.009849548, -0.0061683655, 0.01576233, 0.03060913, 0.013389587, -0.00026893616, 0.022567749, 0.06774902, -0.052368164, -0.0317688, -0.01159668, -0.013130188, -0.036895752, 0.049041748, 0.0066452026, -0.025482178, -0.026779175, -0.045043945, -0.023269653, 0.00844574, 0.02456665, 0.02571106, 0.051971436, -0.04232788, -0.018341064, -0.036315918, 0.004055023, -0.009124756, 0.01689148, -0.017532349, -0.0152282715, 0.000109136105, 0.0062065125, 0.008132935, -0.03366089, 0.014701843, -0.00005686283, 0.0007548332, 0.00064611435, -0.022140503, 0.0044403076, -0.021621704, -0.013046265, 0.05102539, -0.002483368, -0.03250122, 0.008743286, -0.036987305, 0.07476807, 0.024475098, 0.022079468, 0.040740967, 0.01625061, 0.0154953, -0.00894165, 0.022567749, -0.024856567, 0.0034275055, -0.047302246, 0.002632141, -0.051971436, -0.0050849915, -0.06567383, 0.0059509277, 0.024398804, 0.024047852, -0.0007557869, 0.011642456, 0.0073165894, 0.017196655, 0.05908203, 0.00085544586, 0.05331421, 0.01373291, 0.0018730164, 0.011520386, -0.0020046234, -0.00008189678, 0.021392822, -0.006706238, 0.025863647, -0.028167725, -0.0035438538, 0.00932312, 0.0049209595, 0.008728027, -0.011734009, -0.011726379, -0.025848389, 0.03756714, -0.0184021, 0.024993896, 0.05682373, 0.054626465, -0.034332275, -0.013000488, 0.004901886, 0.004169464, -0.018218994, -0.0052833557, 0.046295166, -0.045959473, 0.03186035, -0.019500732, -0.0413208, -0.021636963, 0.054016113, 0.018875122, -0.021743774, -0.020309448, 0.02029419, 0.035949707, 0.02368164, 0.021697998, -0.033111572, -0.007827759, 0.027313232, 0.03201294, -0.00440979, 0.028244019, 0.025787354, 0.03994751, -0.020233154, -0.012504578, -0.00041270256, 0.029174805, -0.025177002, 0.020767212, -0.031677246, 0.038879395, -0.0005245209, -0.05029297, 0.019363403, 0.0041236877, -0.049865723, -0.006980896, 0.010566711, 0.020355225, 0.023834229, 0.057159424, -0.002286911, -0.020706177, -0.012306213, -0.029388428, 0.021652222, 0.03692627, -0.028564453, 0.034973145, -0.03302002, -0.022827148, 0.039611816, -0.027160645, 0.06021118, -0.03778076, -0.011703491, -0.011428833, 0.028930664, 0.032958984, -0.033416748, -0.04586792, -0.013244629, -0.027130127, -0.011413574, -0.009429932, -0.03527832, -0.027297974, -0.0031414032, 0.018173218, 0.011062622, 0.012863159, 0.0031661987, -0.04196167, -0.072631836, 0.028808594, -0.00019073486, 0.043945312, -0.024368286, -0.026306152, -0.03463745, 0.014823914, 0.00065898895, 0.0028190613, -0.020401001, 0.027496338, -0.026321411, -0.023590088, 0.017181396, 0.015655518, -0.013656616, -0.014282227, -0.031799316, 0.009117126, -0.020767212, -0.021392822, 0.048431396, -0.02319336, -0.03579712, -0.0074768066, -0.03881836, 0.038635254, 0.034423828, -0.018051147, 0.010139465, 0.018188477, -0.02545166, -0.011749268, 0.0015583038, 0.04623413, -0.022583008, -0.049194336, -0.012817383, 0.025131226, 0.031311035, -0.07495117, -0.053649902, -0.0031147003, 0.03326416, 0.0009083748, 0.053649902, -0.013687134, 0.006477356, 0.03225708, 0.04397583, 0.01486969, -0.057281494, -0.05859375, -0.013160706, 0.06439209, 0.047546387, -0.010635376, -0.029266357, 0.017990112, -0.0050086975, 0.008850098, 0.020339966, -0.0047035217, 0.034057617, -0.002407074, 0.05633545, -0.008300781, -0.018035889, -0.008430481, -0.004623413, -0.005104065, 0.01574707, -0.013397217, -0.001824379, -0.02508545, 0.07006836, -0.017684937, -0.03729248, 0.03881836, 0.0357666, 0.021957397, 0.046661377, -0.022735596, -0.022537231, 0.0038852692, -0.016952515, -0.0049057007, -0.007461548, 0.02671814, -0.046722412, -0.016555786, -0.016525269, -0.036102295, -0.016998291, -0.03805542, 0.03375244, -0.038909912, 0.0121536255, -0.043273926, 0.0028419495, 0.003063202, 0.025115967, 0.027694702, -0.01020813, -0.054229736, -0.033172607, 0.039611816, -0.025558472 ], "summary": [ 0.021697998, -0.005455017, 0.016113281, 0.036224365, -0.044128418, -0.032592773, 0.013587952, -0.061584473, 0.015899658, 0.014045715, -0.015083313, -0.05319214, 0.00084400177, -0.044647217, -0.019882202, -0.047912598, 0.026031494, 0.051849365, 0.070251465, -0.0010566711, -0.01979065, 0.018554688, 0.042663574, -0.021820068, 0.032104492, -0.026733398, -0.05899048, 0.011657715, 0.02772522, 0.024291992, 0.008720398, -0.029693604, -0.010169983, -0.014045715, 0.03930664, -0.010223389, 0.040985107, -0.008529663, 0.032806396, -0.017700195, 0.0178833, -0.033966064, 0.08380127, -0.031280518, 0.018966675, 0.04336548, 0.011260986, -0.047424316, 0.03286743, 0.006088257, 0.02180481, 0.010757446, 0.025100708, -0.002986908, -0.02760315, -0.002046585, -0.058044434, -0.032836914, 0.01965332, 0.054138184, 0.03866577, -0.038208008, 0.0074653625, -0.041015625, -0.026473999, -0.0362854, 0.01763916, 0.017364502, 0.0064430237, -0.0309906, 0.01802063, 0.029464722, 0.001698494, -0.042877197, -0.045196533, 0.000995636, 0.059539795, 0.0045051575, -0.024673462, -0.031677246, 0.03164673, 0.013130188, 0.018005371, -0.068847656, 0.04083252, -0.018951416, -0.007785797, -0.014595032, -0.009963989, 0.024963379, -0.007358551, -0.0048713684, -0.022399902, 0.08728027, 0.025161743, -0.0073890686, -0.07128906, -0.08685303, 0.032409668, 0.03466797, -0.0025100708, -0.019515991, 0.015686035, -0.017181396, 0.023605347, 0.062072754, -0.01612854, -0.06365967, 0.004436493, -0.014022827, -0.00667572, -0.013847351, 0.021530151, -0.06756592, 0.022109985, 0.07861328, 0.032562256, 0.052459717, 0.020629883, 0.04711914, -0.03768921, -0.024215698, -0.019119263, 0.04840088, 0.0007314682, -0.01776123, 0.017807007, 0.017150879, -0.0014801025, 0.025115967, -0.018157959, 0.0064048767, 0.0021972656, 0.013969421, -0.014251709, -0.019165039, 0.028411865, -0.014816284, -0.017150879, -0.018844604, 0.059783936, 0.0012550354, -0.019622803, 0.01586914, 0.004508972, 0.012916565, 0.006374359, 0.02255249, 0.030044556, -0.009101868, 0.02658081, -0.055419922, 0.031433105, 0.0042533875, -0.002325058, -0.010360718, -0.037719727, 0.01007843, 0.006790161, 0.009536743, 0.036071777, 0.010154724, -0.013725281, 0.006427765, -0.022598267, -0.0067443848, -0.025543213, 0.0033226013, 0.018417358, -0.082458496, 0.024383545, 0.011154175, -0.004142761, -0.007282257, 0.029159546, 0.007534027, 0.0067825317, -0.023651123, -0.05065918, 0.037506104, 0.029296875, -0.030685425, -0.064941406, 0.041625977, -0.03186035, 0.03515625, 0.009735107, 0.084106445, 0.02684021, 0.011177063, -0.020126343, -0.012931824, -0.016601562, 0.024856567, 0.00944519, -0.013252258, 0.00004929304, 0.001824379, 0.0065307617, -0.021972656, 0.03161621, 0.035186768, -0.038970947, -0.032836914, -0.06225586, -0.022613525, 0.0012655258, 0.005012512, 0.01586914, -0.0074806213, -0.0066871643, -0.023422241, -0.004802704, -0.020965576, -0.0413208, 0.010475159, 0.008621216, -0.045959473, -0.04095459, -0.033355713, -0.030532837, 0.008590698, -0.04864502, 0.042999268, -0.0014724731, 0.011421204, -0.0088272095, 0.004360199, 0.035308838, 0.035186768, 0.015060425, -0.035949707, -0.03894043, -0.019561768, -0.019607544, -0.00687027, -0.02078247, -0.06964111, 0.030883789, 0.04345703, 0.019470215, 0.0007815361, -0.02545166, -0.024383545, 0.048553467, 0.03111267, 0.027832031, -0.039123535, -0.017425537, 0.026367188, 0.06286621, 0.019073486, 0.0055999756, -0.012214661, 0.00233078, 0.016738892, -0.003993988, -0.031463623, 0.036834717, -0.0064849854, 0.00034856796, 0.00029110909, -0.009811401, -0.0010213852, 0.0143585205, -0.036865234, 0.004020691, -0.02029419, -0.006164551, -0.013832092, 0.014183044, -0.058258057, 0.0073242188, 0.010925293, -0.056488037, -0.041870117, -0.010383606, 0.024871826, 0.014442444, -0.02658081, -0.012458801, 0.012069702, -0.018737793, -0.009140015, 0.0035858154, 0.026611328, 0.0010824203, 0.015541077, 0.011833191, 0.05130005, 0.046722412, 0.04837036, 0.00056648254, 0.027999878, -0.00356102, 0.015258789, -0.0012578964, -0.0003130436, -0.0064582825, -0.00806427, 0.0028362274, 0.04196167, -0.0074386597, -0.013084412, -0.0023403168, 0.027679443, 0.0017976761, 0.0062065125, -0.012069702, -0.008224487, -0.015434265, -0.004047394, 0.002407074, 0.039367676, -0.05947876, -0.04714966, -0.03765869, -0.0023727417, -0.06161499, -0.037994385, 0.08081055, 0.019821167, -0.0027885437, 0.004886627, 0.006126404, -0.046844482, 0.0126953125, -0.01763916, -0.035339355, -0.015853882, 0.0024147034, -0.044067383, -0.029571533, 0.02444458, 0.0075263977, 0.010391235, 0.013923645, 0.011329651, 0.010147095, 0.00055265427, 0.032592773, 0.06585693, 0.0039100647, -0.0075645447, -0.059936523, 0.015853882, 0.011833191, 0.008125305, -0.020889282, -0.009666443, 0.029541016, -0.011436462, -0.032073975, 0.018066406, 0.0079193115, -0.02432251, 0.043914795, 0.07727051, 0.024627686, 0.020095825, 0.068115234, 0.011474609, 0.025939941, -0.08416748, -0.026504517, -0.052947998, -0.010192871, -0.05343628, 0.047729492, 0.04324341, -0.06689453, 0.0423584, -0.02885437, 0.026229858, 0.050842285, 0.015625, 0.09136963, 0.015380859, -0.03591919, 0.047943115, 0.015464783, 0.0032958984, -0.011558533, -0.029815674, 0.08319092, 0.004585266, -0.0005912781, 0.055389404, 0.041107178, 0.03024292, -0.031280518, -0.042419434, 0.03982544, -0.04144287, -0.011802673, -0.019363403, 0.0146102905, 0.010948181, -0.013046265, -0.016448975, 0.037109375, 0.012382507, 0.012313843, 0.004512787, -0.03564453, 0.048187256, 0.005622864, -0.010124207, -0.008644104, 0.049224854, -0.005592346, -0.04486084, 0.0037384033, -0.018508911, 0.04196167, -0.019378662, -0.023498535, 0.0076560974, -0.027420044, -0.01612854, -0.009162903, 0.040496826, -0.0259552, -0.005443573, 0.0028915405, 0.045288086, 0.00040268898, -0.005695343, 0.020004272, 0.053344727, 0.010177612, 0.015808105, -0.035125732, -0.042114258, -0.014167786, 0.027008057, -0.0085372925, 0.044921875, -0.023666382, 0.0012931824, -0.022750854, 0.0031433105, -0.019378662, -0.0025081635, -0.026824951, -0.026535034, 0.019073486, -0.014816284, -0.002752304, 0.003917694, 0.0050697327, 0.016784668, 0.047790527, 0.009185791, -0.02130127, -0.052642822, -0.012390137, 0.013763428, 0.021316528, -0.043029785, -0.010398865, -0.018692017, -0.040527344, -0.011604309, -0.01826477, 0.0050964355, 0.0074691772, 0.006111145, -0.0152282715, 0.0071372986, -0.020889282, 0.008575439, -0.01725769, -0.012023926, -0.003358841, 0.0064201355, -0.0030994415, -0.015899658, 0.043884277, 0.027008057, -0.04437256, 0.018432617, -0.088134766, -0.03878784, -0.018951416, 0.013755798, -0.049072266, -0.02999878, 0.014579773, -0.004196167, -0.0007004738, -0.037841797, 0.025634766, -0.016799927, -0.02935791, 0.0056533813, -0.026672363, 0.105773926, 0.015472412, -0.058685303, 0.03756714, -0.028778076, 0.06561279, 0.037719727, -0.00957489, 0.008415222, 0.010482788, 0.017974854, 0.011520386, -0.022781372, 0.030700684, -0.013305664, 0.019836426, 0.010635376, -0.029937744, 0.025985718, 0.00881958, -0.04562378, 0.028244019, 0.021102905, 0.046844482, 0.08319092, -0.038116455, -0.00497818, 0.039978027, 0.00068950653, -0.04699707, 0.02810669, 0.0077285767, -0.04647827, -0.003604889, 0.009208679, -0.022766113, 0.03515625, 0.016616821, 0.02192688, -0.021453857, -0.04800415, -0.0524292, 0.011726379, -0.044952393, -0.011917114, 0.01739502, 0.041931152, -0.026809692, 0.0060424805, -0.009147644, 0.03552246, 0.019088745, -0.024093628, 0.02760315, 0.01576233, -0.06173706, -0.009185791, 0.010169983, -0.05908203, -0.046844482, 0.009284973, -0.012939453, 0.013748169, -0.0028533936, 0.015312195, 0.004497528, -0.024765015, 0.03186035, 0.0041046143, -0.017105103, -0.036346436, -0.021499634, -0.022109985, -0.058410645, -0.032470703, -0.036743164, -0.0413208, -0.04058838, -0.0060157776, -0.03527832, 0.002357483, 0.034820557, 0.11578369, 0.011894226, 0.030288696, -0.064575195, 0.01399231, -0.035217285, 0.02217102, -0.011245728, 0.016601562, -0.009498596, 0.009185791, 0.00466156, -0.003238678, -0.031799316, -0.08691406, 0.0062026978, 0.009162903, -0.00819397, 0.038238525, 0.024032593, 0.03024292, 0.0034980774, 0.020629883, 0.0047912598, -0.028945923, -0.03100586, 0.00056934357, 0.023040771, -0.060943604, 0.052459717, 0.056640625, -0.031097412, -0.06359863, 0.0259552, 0.032226562, 0.05090332, -0.03878784, -0.011291504, 0.010612488, -0.010635376, 0.0027866364, 0.01411438, -0.00033950806, 0.023406982, -0.0044021606, -0.014297485, -0.010719299, -0.014472961, 0.050720215, -0.014144897, 0.006549835, 0.062286377, -0.005886078, -0.06488037, -0.0597229, -0.044311523, 0.068115234, -0.024902344, -0.05117798, -0.016952515, -0.013420105, 0.012687683, 0.0045280457, 0.010032654, -0.050689697, 0.017364502, -0.024719238, -0.025421143, 0.01876831, -0.037231445, -0.030700684, -0.007091522, 0.00038194656, -0.03741455, -0.006980896, 0.02571106, -0.041229248, -0.021896362, -0.02355957, 0.024017334, -0.037017822, -0.011077881, 0.040161133, -0.04284668, 0.05758667, 0.008834839, 0.010101318, -0.00004273653, -0.010627747, -0.013687134, 0.000073730946, -0.027175903, -0.008369446, 0.034851074, 0.010414124, 0.010627747, 0.0019245148, 0.028427124, 0.0048103333, 0.00995636, -0.0060424805, -0.0023822784, -0.018539429, 0.047180176, -0.0043296814, -0.025115967, 0.036132812, 0.00308609, -0.023452759, -0.016571045, -0.005657196, -0.0061950684, 0.023803711, -0.015296936, 0.028671265, 0.036743164, 0.008758545, -0.022201538, -0.061523438, -0.017715454, -0.011260986, 0.046905518, -0.025985718, 0.025741577, -0.031280518, 0.0052757263, -0.03967285, -0.025558472, -0.027755737, 0.060760498, 0.027755737, -0.032562256, -0.039611816, -0.020095825, -0.00705719, 0.009475708, -0.032226562, -0.035217285, 0.012504578, -0.019332886, 0.020507812, -0.0015649796, 0.0010919571, -0.0061836243, -0.03390503, 0.000223279, 0.006210327, -0.028030396, 0.029418945, -0.010307312, -0.018630981, 0.010307312, -0.00053691864, -0.06750488, 0.004337311, 0.032318115, -0.015640259, 0.023529053, -0.015167236, 0.040008545, -0.045898438, -0.0074539185, 0.0006303787, 0.02331543, -0.0030155182, -0.00096559525, -0.0043678284, -0.01197052, 0.046783447, 0.018112183, -0.017669678, 0.06842041, -0.01374054, 0.05709839, -0.029174805, 0.04107666, -0.041015625, -0.016067505, -0.045837402, 0.040893555, -0.01626587, -0.06604004, 0.0022563934, -0.0038204193, 0.014175415, 0.04156494, 0.052215576, -0.0056648254, -0.021743774, -0.029052734, 0.019973755, -0.040161133, 0.0022068024, -0.043792725, -0.03704834, 0.0287323, 0.043701172, -0.009605408, 0.011199951, -0.014862061, 0.0103302, -0.0007109642, 0.0052719116, -0.011009216, 0.0042686462, -0.006916046, 0.05343628, 0.013427734, 0.013824463, -0.018600464, -0.033691406, -0.0022087097, 0.030395508, 0.019058228, -0.058166504, -0.0065574646, -0.0073661804, -0.013534546, -0.015083313, -0.01776123, -0.013580322, 0.026473999, -0.0029563904, -0.04522705, -0.062072754, -0.053375244, -0.017486572, 0.036102295, -0.01789856, -0.072265625, 0.081726074, -0.03692627, 0.0018205643, 0.07385254, -0.06210327, 0.083862305, -0.03817749, -0.022918701, -0.0064086914, 0.015068054, -0.021560669, 0.011230469, 0.026870728, -0.000385046, 0.027282715, 0.003929138, -0.01423645, 0.038208008, -0.00712204, -0.039855957, -0.046203613, 0.023406982, -0.05154419, 0.018829346, -0.0004878044, 0.013900757, 0.015914917, 0.023727417, 0.034118652, -0.016067505, 0.0053482056, 0.013214111, 0.013031006, -0.04147339, -0.022064209, 0.027374268, -0.053955078, 0.006465912, 0.008811951, 0.032073975, 0.08288574, 0.03753662, 0.00030207634, 0.040863037, 0.030288696, -0.014915466, -0.015213013, 0.01247406, -0.043884277, 0.012084961, 0.01889038, -0.03744507, 0.014678955, -0.0034713745, 0.043395996, -0.017471313, 0.021072388, -0.006362915, -0.005542755, 0.06298828, -0.007106781, 0.021087646, -0.005607605, 0.05218506, 0.03164673, -0.020568848, 0.016174316, 0.03414917, -0.040222168, 0.038391113, -0.006187439, 0.01928711, 0.009750366, 0.038269043, -0.039489746, 0.004009247, 0.022766113, 0.01789856, 0.012039185, 0.0019721985, -0.005504608, -0.029800415, 0.017822266, 0.021224976, 0.010696411, 0.03363037, 0.015022278, -0.038085938, -0.023208618, -0.015823364, 0.00919342, -0.048217773, 0.028076172, -0.0056877136, -0.022766113, -0.045532227, 0.040924072, 0.06866455, -0.03112793, 0.04159546, 0.001080513, -0.08666992, 0.022857666, 0.022766113, 0.041381836, -0.035827637, -0.020843506, 0.05807495, 0.034332275, 0.10223389, 0.020233154, -0.050872803, -0.0034828186, 0.0045776367, 0.029525757, 0.01574707, -0.025421143, 0.059173584, 0.00541687, -0.042510986, 0.039489746, 0.025100708, -0.012306213, -0.015975952, -0.06506348, 0.01876831, -0.02456665, 0.028884888, -0.0044937134, -0.016220093, 0.021591187, 0.019744873, -0.034851074, 0.0047035217, 0.0073928833, 0.006511688, -0.0017766953, 0.048950195, -0.043823242, -0.04486084, -0.028244019, -0.0028839111, 0.01826477, -0.04763794, -0.00724411, -0.006839752, 0.0074386597, -0.0335083, -0.08569336, 0.029190063, 0.012634277, 0.025009155, -0.0015249252, -0.034576416, 0.012901306, 0.051574707, 0.027297974, 0.020019531, -0.025726318, -0.026885986, 0.013145447, 0.046539307, 0.011352539, -0.01449585, -0.009880066, 0.009971619, -0.038513184, -0.035980225, 0.0001244545, 0.0048675537, -0.035339355, 0.019241333, -0.008049011, -0.019073486, -0.04434204, 0.023788452, -0.02142334, 0.014007568, -0.0004401207, -0.009559631, -0.02078247, -0.021896362, 0.03439331, 0.024871826, 0.045288086, -0.041381836, -0.012893677, 0.040008545, -0.03540039, 0.00031232834, -0.016159058, 0.032043457, -0.028656006, 0.007881165, -0.036834717, 0.02822876, -0.028015137, -0.029953003, -0.07550049, -0.014251709, -0.07220459, -0.036010742, 0.01576233, -0.039489746, 0.009513855, -0.009880066, -0.0006046295, 0.010093689, 0.011543274, -0.008163452, 0.0052757263, -0.008529663, -0.014259338, -0.025283813, -0.008377075 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2010.10992v1
The Effect of the Rooney Rule on Implicit Bias in the Long Term
L. Elisa Celis, Chris Hays, Anay Mehrotra, Nisheeth K. Vishnoi
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.CO
A robust body of evidence demonstrates the adverse effects of implicit bias in various contexts--from hiring to health care. The Rooney Rule is an intervention developed to counter implicit bias and has been implemented in the private and public sectors. The Rooney Rule requires that a selection panel include at least one candidate from an underrepresented group in their shortlist of candidates. Recently, Kleinberg and Raghavan proposed a model of implicit bias and studied the effectiveness of the Rooney Rule when applied to a single selection decision. However, selection decisions often occur repeatedly over time. Further, it has been observed that, given consistent counterstereotypical feedback, implicit biases against underrepresented candidates can change. We consider a model of how a selection panel's implicit bias changes over time given their hiring decisions either with or without the Rooney Rule in place. Our main result is that, when the panel is constrained by the Rooney Rule, their implicit bias roughly reduces at a rate that is the inverse of the size of the shortlist--independent of the number of candidates, whereas without the Rooney Rule, the rate is inversely proportional to the number of candidates. Thus, when the number of candidates is much larger than the size of the shortlist, the Rooney Rule enables a faster reduction in implicit bias, providing an additional reason in favor of using it as a strategy to mitigate implicit bias. Towards empirically evaluating the long-term effect of the Rooney Rule in repeated selection decisions, we conduct an iterative candidate selection experiment on Amazon MTurk. We observe that, indeed, decision-makers subject to the Rooney Rule select more minority candidates in addition to those required by the rule itself than they would if no rule is in effect, and do so without considerably decreasing the utility of candidates selected.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2010.10992v1
"2020-10-21T13:33:00"
"2020-10-21T13:33:00"
{ "title": [ 0.03353882, 0.006126404, -0.018920898, -0.014328003, -0.005317688, -0.048034668, 0.021102905, -0.03567505, -0.030822754, 0.037200928, -0.06707764, 0.0046920776, -0.0077667236, -0.0059547424, -0.023910522, -0.03048706, -0.013427734, 0.028945923, 0.005619049, -0.027130127, 0.0033340454, -0.041290283, 0.022750854, -0.091552734, 0.01852417, -0.03463745, -0.04269409, -0.008621216, 0.01020813, -0.015792847, 0.010635376, 0.010002136, 0.03277588, 0.019088745, 0.0016565323, 0.044799805, -0.034240723, 0.039245605, 0.022460938, -0.0030097961, -0.0016841888, 0.0005745888, -0.044189453, -0.025970459, -0.049865723, -0.025115967, -0.02722168, -0.0072784424, -0.021514893, 0.009567261, -0.024307251, 0.001912117, 0.002155304, 0.036193848, -0.005138397, -0.02507019, -0.04055786, -0.019821167, 0.0006122589, 0.020523071, 0.03665161, 0.0065727234, 0.022155762, 0.021347046, -0.032806396, -0.0008845329, 0.0030078888, 0.017959595, 0.024368286, -0.020431519, -0.016952515, 0.0017280579, 0.020553589, 0.020599365, -0.032409668, -0.043640137, 0.05307007, 0.031311035, 0.032287598, -0.035095215, -0.026107788, -0.00084733963, -0.03793335, -0.0335083, 0.018936157, -0.02027893, -0.024307251, -0.0020217896, -0.020553589, -0.029083252, -0.0050735474, 0.018188477, -0.001584053, 0.0055503845, -0.022521973, -0.043792725, -0.002412796, 0.07989502, -0.04864502, -0.07305908, -0.0914917, 0.053710938, -0.13977051, 0.004627228, 0.0015468597, 0.018417358, -0.0079193115, 0.0042266846, 0.007270813, 0.039245605, -0.012542725, -0.014137268, 0.009552002, 0.020492554, -0.008781433, -0.02671814, -0.030090332, 0.017166138, -0.019744873, 0.02734375, -0.018798828, -0.0104522705, 0.024017334, -0.007926941, 0.034210205, 0.020187378, -0.0440979, -0.002752304, -0.031051636, 0.03152466, 0.000001847744, 0.041656494, -0.08093262, -0.06060791, -0.04650879, -0.010147095, -0.01600647, -0.050720215, -0.024856567, 0.043914795, -0.04699707, -0.0368042, 0.0340271, -0.051727295, -0.013633728, 0.021499634, 0.053527832, 0.005191803, -0.036315918, -0.050628662, -0.030090332, 0.025100708, 0.018554688, -0.013252258, -0.029190063, -0.011276245, -0.07879639, 0.008399963, 0.020843506, 0.026550293, 0.034423828, -0.01991272, -0.046447754, 0.043060303, 0.047088623, 0.025863647, 0.036071777, 0.046691895, 0.0017271042, 0.018295288, -0.028686523, 0.043304443, 0.0129776, -0.04272461, -0.014411926, -0.022491455, 0.010772705, 0.009819031, 0.008834839, -0.045166016, -0.01386261, -0.015823364, -0.03741455, 0.03137207, -0.088256836, -0.008552551, -0.018539429, 0.016403198, 0.054382324, 0.0031204224, 0.012702942, 0.029846191, -0.030578613, -0.056152344, -0.029083252, 0.010536194, 0.015945435, 0.02670288, 0.009277344, 0.011436462, -0.004085541, -0.015289307, 0.017852783, -0.024475098, -0.011642456, -0.033294678, 0.0030345917, 0.0062446594, -0.010192871, 0.04638672, 0.037017822, -0.0004746914, -0.015106201, -0.011161804, -0.018127441, -0.04425049, 0.01184845, -0.039489746, 0.023666382, -0.045288086, 0.038085938, -0.0073776245, 0.02079773, 0.025161743, 0.023361206, -0.010734558, 0.0049591064, -0.027786255, 0.072021484, 0.0045776367, 0.107055664, -0.0012559891, -0.0069465637, 0.0076789856, -0.042877197, -0.0057792664, -0.010177612, -0.0028686523, 0.0022716522, 0.025604248, 0.020095825, -0.008682251, 0.04156494, 0.044891357, 0.034820557, -0.036254883, 0.014984131, 0.0155181885, 0.007926941, -0.03878784, 0.05859375, -0.028427124, 0.055358887, -0.024291992, 0.046569824, 0.0657959, 0.008140564, 0.04272461, -0.036987305, 0.025421143, -0.018005371, 0.01890564, 0.021972656, -0.01285553, -0.030151367, -0.023910522, -0.040374756, -0.011299133, 0.0050315857, -0.010238647, 0.019378662, -0.048828125, -0.0053215027, -0.0034770966, -0.00062179565, -0.012557983, -0.025527954, 0.029968262, -0.022338867, -0.027557373, -0.016067505, 0.035705566, 0.010505676, -0.0010271072, -0.001455307, 0.010238647, 0.01637268, -0.00881958, 0.0027980804, -0.016647339, 0.022994995, 0.043029785, 0.016921997, 0.029403687, -0.0011034012, -0.008491516, -0.010391235, 0.04864502, -0.035736084, 0.00983429, -0.078308105, -0.012138367, 0.014572144, -0.017837524, 0.0056381226, 0.03186035, 0.022201538, 0.0068130493, -0.012260437, -0.019866943, -0.016921997, 0.023254395, 0.020629883, -0.03189087, 0.056915283, 0.017044067, 0.04916382, 0.012397766, 0.04156494, -0.009521484, 0.015655518, -0.00315094, -0.0127334595, -0.037994385, 0.016815186, -0.011932373, -0.060668945, -0.018569946, -0.0074501038, 0.017913818, 0.013763428, -0.03125, -0.07122803, -0.077941895, 0.007286072, 0.01285553, -0.0019874573, 0.0023403168, -0.007637024, -0.016052246, -0.0046043396, -0.059631348, 0.0013723373, -0.018081665, 0.023040771, -0.050750732, -0.030014038, -0.0004146099, -0.037963867, -0.010871887, 0.033203125, -0.00983429, -0.01776123, 0.012161255, 0.04977417, -0.02166748, -0.0046157837, 0.021194458, 0.047668457, -0.017074585, 0.039276123, 0.046020508, 0.018432617, -0.048339844, -0.01499176, -0.07788086, -0.018798828, 0.0140686035, -0.018981934, 0.0065574646, -0.05328369, -0.032318115, -0.035217285, 0.026367188, -0.0005311966, 0.066711426, -0.006614685, -0.03488159, -0.024795532, -0.038208008, 0.01574707, -0.026626587, 0.022384644, -0.006252289, 0.05218506, 0.00919342, -0.039794922, -0.026931763, 0.0076789856, 0.011451721, -0.029327393, -0.029190063, -0.03050232, -0.031677246, 0.004562378, 0.0051345825, 0.03652954, -0.006793976, -0.0146865845, -0.01600647, 0.03869629, -0.01133728, -0.015144348, 0.009429932, -0.03378296, 0.007472992, 0.019439697, -0.020858765, 0.027633667, 0.04626465, -0.035125732, 0.06173706, 0.021347046, 0.021118164, -0.012039185, -0.007633209, -0.10595703, 0.022521973, -0.012054443, 0.0075149536, 0.009407043, -0.026733398, 0.006385803, 0.012748718, -0.00060129166, 0.03338623, 0.020065308, -0.0065841675, -0.01713562, 0.011962891, 0.015701294, -0.014526367, 0.0021877289, -0.025756836, -0.028945923, -0.012428284, -0.02078247, 0.087524414, 0.0072746277, 0.018188477, -0.01802063, -0.029266357, 0.0051612854, 0.042388916, -0.010017395, -0.0029525757, -0.019943237, -0.00082826614, -0.00868988, 0.009277344, -0.0262146, 0.0011291504, -0.008270264, 0.01361084, -0.024032593, 0.05508423, 0.02911377, 0.049743652, -0.034454346, 0.03555298, 0.047851562, -0.012641907, -0.023239136, 0.023971558, -0.029083252, 0.014801025, 0.056488037, -0.0006804466, -0.0011434555, -0.023330688, -0.032562256, 0.00724411, 0.0099105835, 0.0058631897, -0.0037994385, 0.018310547, -0.02305603, 0.005744934, -0.03765869, -0.0026950836, 0.009552002, 0.015792847, -0.010856628, -0.05456543, -0.029785156, 0.027770996, -0.0713501, -0.020553589, 0.02758789, -0.042144775, -0.00894165, -0.04083252, 0.03543091, -0.060546875, -0.02508545, -0.023834229, -0.009384155, 0.007419586, 0.0072631836, -0.101135254, 0.006504059, 0.02722168, -0.036621094, -0.00024223328, 0.027114868, -0.029663086, -0.0067863464, -0.0057373047, 0.013137817, 0.02859497, 0.036956787, -0.0005745888, -0.019165039, 0.033843994, -0.02746582, 0.030685425, 0.0057411194, 0.014419556, -0.0021209717, 0.006877899, 0.030380249, 0.035705566, -0.004173279, 0.04574585, 0.04058838, 0.00048470497, -0.06298828, 0.003326416, -0.03945923, -0.051361084, 0.017349243, 0.03540039, 0.03656006, 0.0463562, 0.0034809113, 0.03503418, 0.005722046, -0.0024719238, -0.0059318542, -0.013618469, -0.03515625, -0.030960083, -0.0024662018, -0.012794495, -0.010665894, -0.02130127, -0.037841797, 0.038726807, 0.009254456, 0.0009775162, -0.005622864, -0.010238647, -0.08874512, -0.019485474, -0.017471313, -0.061920166, -0.058776855, 0.027572632, -0.002840042, -0.018432617, 0.048034668, 0.00085258484, -0.05593872, -0.011177063, -0.006149292, -0.017791748, 0.028335571, -0.060058594, 0.004917145, -0.034332275, -0.03451538, -0.038635254, 0.02545166, 0.0046043396, 0.0057029724, -0.029876709, -0.022155762, 0.016708374, -0.00010317564, 0.03970337, 0.023361206, 0.014930725, -0.01953125, 0.04888916, -0.027740479, -0.012916565, 0.018569946, -0.029891968, -0.021453857, -0.027404785, 0.023971558, 0.007621765, -0.006965637, -0.051361084, 0.00026392937, -0.029647827, 0.0463562, 0.032989502, 0.0055999756, 0.02545166, 0.003944397, -0.0058784485, -0.0090408325, -0.041534424, 0.011383057, 0.010017395, 0.035217285, -0.011703491, 0.015090942, 0.04827881, 0.04220581, -0.060302734, -0.007675171, 0.053955078, 0.034942627, -0.0052833557, -0.019363403, 0.032562256, -0.041809082, -0.019897461, 0.014160156, -0.047790527, 0.02709961, -0.036315918, -0.020309448, -0.028839111, 0.00762558, 0.005264282, -0.010757446, 0.02418518, 0.029052734, 0.022033691, -0.016815186, 0.010009766, 0.06335449, -0.0047912598, -0.028396606, 0.012367249, -0.0057525635, 0.026382446, 0.0011796951, 0.046325684, 0.014419556, 0.0004210472, 0.0309906, -0.014015198, -0.0038871765, -0.0014677048, -0.031082153, 0.011650085, 0.036895752, 0.023788452, -0.05166626, 0.011268616, -0.010971069, -0.0015678406, -0.015426636, -0.01828003, -0.014678955, -0.07714844, -0.012580872, -0.00051259995, 0.018295288, 0.014480591, -0.00844574, 0.021331787, 0.049713135, 0.0413208, 0.0011196136, -0.0040016174, 0.027252197, -0.0061912537, -0.003145218, -0.04284668, 0.022598267, 0.0054893494, 0.013694763, 0.015975952, 0.048034668, -0.09173584, 0.018051147, -0.038848877, -0.037841797, 0.012504578, -0.03894043, 0.00072717667, 0.020614624, 0.02494812, -0.009536743, -0.06933594, -0.009757996, 0.035491943, -0.07244873, -0.002193451, 0.04345703, -0.04425049, -0.03479004, -0.03189087, 0.0154800415, 0.030899048, 0.06488037, -0.021987915, 0.0032730103, -0.053100586, 0.012161255, 0.017242432, -0.04058838, -0.0079574585, -0.024383545, 0.008102417, 0.0154418945, 0.039642334, -0.026885986, 0.0055160522, 0.015113831, -0.061706543, -0.0491333, 0.00088596344, -0.016998291, -0.01739502, -0.017166138, -0.032562256, -0.016464233, -0.018692017, 0.01007843, 0.013290405, -0.047668457, 0.006084442, -0.009811401, 0.015808105, 0.033081055, 0.06185913, 0.034454346, -0.0004963875, 0.0059432983, -0.064208984, 0.019317627, -0.0044898987, -0.025177002, -0.040374756, -0.047424316, -0.001162529, 0.0034809113, -0.017684937, 0.003501892, 0.00573349, 0.03237915, 0.0006041527, 0.00076818466, 0.026107788, 0.105651855, -0.062927246, -0.062438965, -0.011672974, -0.022247314, -0.02130127, -0.004508972, 0.017913818, -0.04257202, -0.0002322197, 0.008552551, -0.03540039, -0.01210022, 0.041900635, -0.09484863, 0.0040130615, -0.012306213, -0.045440674, -0.025985718, 0.013908386, 0.0010175705, 0.009010315, -0.025375366, -0.0670166, 0.021087646, 0.004749298, 0.026153564, -0.0703125, 0.019302368, 0.0037231445, 0.018478394, -0.027893066, -0.0055656433, -0.0076408386, -0.0206604, -0.014984131, 0.046142578, -0.0056610107, -0.029434204, 0.026412964, -0.037628174, 0.05657959, -0.0030899048, 0.059936523, 0.0025520325, 0.011177063, 0.009399414, 0.016036987, -0.014144897, -0.024337769, -0.0012788773, -0.06781006, 0.02508545, -0.010437012, 0.023239136, -0.09863281, 0.012184143, 0.022125244, 0.06222534, -0.019897461, 0.011474609, 0.010177612, 0.0074424744, 0.064208984, 0.015838623, 0.08557129, 0.022766113, 0.009567261, -0.021621704, -0.07800293, 0.02178955, 0.03829956, -0.01701355, 0.026306152, -0.015464783, -0.016571045, -0.02180481, -0.012214661, 0.031982422, 0.012916565, -0.016677856, 0.020812988, 0.026351929, 0.0007305145, 0.020263672, 0.031173706, 0.05166626, -0.022140503, -0.0025196075, 0.0072135925, 0.028366089, -0.059417725, 0.033966064, 0.054504395, -0.049560547, 0.0284729, -0.0231781, -0.05706787, 0.015823364, 0.0072402954, 0.022750854, -0.04727173, -0.028869629, 0.009422302, 0.019592285, 0.030517578, 0.01763916, -0.03564453, -0.059448242, -0.051574707, -0.0012979507, 0.007598877, 0.010551453, -0.01826477, 0.023742676, -0.0034694672, -0.014579773, -0.0076446533, -0.0035305023, -0.021270752, 0.037963867, -0.010307312, 0.052886963, -0.013923645, -0.031143188, 0.0006175041, 0.029449463, -0.07098389, 0.013214111, -0.0053215027, 0.019699097, 0.030761719, 0.05319214, 0.039611816, 0.001156807, -0.07043457, -0.014038086, 0.049224854, 0.045318604, -0.010887146, 0.012329102, -0.03982544, -0.044952393, 0.017715454, -0.029449463, 0.048614502, -0.00409317, 0.01600647, -0.011856079, -0.062042236, 0.050994873, -0.012512207, -0.0110321045, -0.030548096, 0.011650085, 0.01626587, -0.020843506, -0.08306885, -0.013786316, -0.0019874573, 0.023483276, 0.0047302246, 0.016616821, 0.04046631, -0.0496521, -0.042816162, 0.024459839, 0.010871887, 0.0513916, 0.0067710876, -0.031829834, -0.038879395, 0.031829834, 0.017364502, 0.049041748, -0.008613586, 0.03466797, -0.026290894, 0.014305115, 0.0028877258, 0.0027713776, -0.003616333, -0.009941101, -0.019317627, 0.008010864, -0.021514893, 0.011138916, 0.0000030398369, -0.017913818, -0.048797607, -0.0053596497, -0.04144287, 0.018051147, 0.011749268, -0.038238525, 0.02557373, -0.030258179, -0.010437012, 0.0012521744, 0.00793457, 0.04498291, -0.029388428, -0.018066406, -0.010726929, 0.040618896, 0.05456543, -0.041992188, -0.008674622, 0.009742737, 0.0703125, 0.014602661, -0.0032157898, 0.012466431, -0.009017944, -0.009223938, -0.009475708, -0.006942749, -0.02456665, -0.00047135353, 0.0062713623, 0.012702942, 0.0152282715, -0.0012893677, -0.0047416687, 0.012084961, -0.014205933, 0.0060424805, 0.021469116, -0.008491516, 0.00944519, 0.0041160583, 0.028839111, -0.010108948, -0.041931152, -0.003408432, -0.054260254, 0.029312134, 0.0074272156, -0.014221191, 0.01991272, -0.04244995, 0.094055176, 0.028045654, -0.0064086914, 0.05621338, 0.040618896, 0.059570312, 0.0009212494, 0.024551392, -0.019226074, -0.02746582, -0.0053253174, 0.0121154785, -0.011756897, 0.0025558472, -0.0039138794, 0.019119263, -0.011077881, -0.019439697, -0.011894226, -0.007911682, 0.021194458, -0.03768921, 0.022567749, -0.042938232, -0.015991211, 0.013893127, -0.027755737, 0.05328369, -0.055847168, 0.001039505, -0.03149414, 0.016784668, 0.032348633 ], "summary": [ 0.055664062, -0.004688263, 0.016586304, 0.016403198, 0.006958008, -0.0357666, 0.029769897, -0.04699707, -0.009399414, 0.02053833, -0.0670166, 0.032104492, -0.00009793043, 0.0049934387, -0.0065345764, -0.047729492, -0.032440186, 0.022369385, -0.012397766, -0.02748108, 0.021636963, -0.048950195, -0.025924683, -0.1027832, 0.034973145, -0.0030269623, -0.013092041, 0.031097412, 0.0056915283, 0.010665894, 0.0158844, -0.02609253, 0.024536133, 0.010894775, 0.0059127808, 0.083618164, 0.015808105, 0.0029563904, 0.018035889, 0.036254883, 0.017562866, -0.009513855, -0.017425537, -0.045837402, -0.016921997, -0.022842407, 0.025650024, -0.0259552, 0.001991272, -0.02218628, 0.021072388, 0.019882202, 0.020645142, 0.00522995, -0.008262634, 0.014259338, -0.036956787, -0.017318726, -0.0015010834, 0.020812988, 0.039123535, 0.002204895, 0.020217896, 0.02330017, -0.012466431, 0.024719238, -0.019866943, -0.0048980713, 0.04006958, -0.0065307617, -0.019744873, -0.00248909, 0.01322937, 0.015640259, -0.049621582, -0.021697998, 0.060821533, 0.025650024, 0.0004887581, -0.010726929, -0.024414062, 0.03604126, 0.016571045, -0.06311035, 0.023956299, -0.011375427, -0.02784729, -0.0042037964, -0.006591797, 0.028198242, -0.013763428, -0.0027942657, -0.003534317, 0.028900146, 0.008430481, -0.039642334, 0.008407593, 0.046966553, -0.058685303, -0.0473938, -0.0423584, 0.011497498, -0.06542969, 0.019134521, -0.0008993149, 0.043304443, -0.0070877075, 0.00598526, 0.010650635, 0.015701294, -0.010040283, -0.033599854, 0.015945435, 0.024871826, -0.036346436, -0.0473938, -0.04336548, 0.0002913475, -0.012336731, -0.00053453445, -0.01676941, 0.011192322, -0.013877869, -0.0035095215, 0.026275635, 0.012878418, -0.014404297, 0.0146102905, -0.047790527, 0.031982422, -0.008102417, -0.021194458, -0.0021572113, 0.04559326, -0.008979797, -0.028945923, -0.01499939, -0.03366089, 0.008354187, 0.025344849, 0.0048980713, -0.03253174, 0.016067505, 0.0059127808, -0.027893066, 0.033691406, 0.010429382, -0.015289307, -0.004749298, -0.0113220215, -0.04727173, -0.020339966, 0.04663086, -0.022384644, -0.036712646, -0.04333496, -0.0013494492, -0.029953003, -0.023223877, -0.048828125, -0.012512207, -0.013755798, 0.00843811, 0.035949707, 0.023422241, -0.0013408661, 0.016998291, 0.010528564, 0.008079529, -0.042236328, -0.0053710938, 0.05569458, 0.014656067, -0.05380249, 0.00002592802, -0.028381348, 0.024475098, 0.011039734, -0.0030651093, -0.029449463, -0.01826477, -0.031402588, 0.0051116943, 0.0033092499, -0.07196045, 0.091430664, -0.022659302, 0.07556152, 0.025299072, -0.030578613, 0.024795532, 0.015525818, 0.005634308, -0.047180176, 0.015838623, -0.00076436996, -0.011604309, -0.009155273, 0.007106781, 0.012573242, 0.07507324, -0.04119873, 0.019897461, -0.07946777, -0.055511475, -0.048187256, 0.002319336, 0.01259613, -0.0368042, -0.017089844, 0.036865234, -0.036071777, -0.034362793, 0.011619568, -0.018157959, -0.016845703, 0.034179688, -0.0068588257, 0.022583008, -0.027145386, 0.047454834, 0.018234253, 0.016555786, 0.05783081, 0.023101807, -0.0034751892, -0.0138549805, -0.0041999817, 0.08282471, -0.014122009, 0.084472656, 0.009513855, -0.03781128, 0.06359863, 0.009841919, -0.017868042, -0.010215759, -0.035736084, 0.03112793, 0.017684937, 0.009521484, 0.038970947, 0.010269165, 0.043548584, 0.03363037, -0.00027871132, 0.019515991, 0.025726318, -0.038513184, -0.07220459, 0.05895996, -0.021575928, 0.035369873, -0.044647217, 0.043426514, 0.005393982, -0.022994995, 0.036590576, -0.009216309, -0.032104492, -0.010543823, -0.01210022, 0.017120361, -0.02583313, -0.011856079, -0.06072998, -0.033355713, -0.045776367, 0.035217285, -0.04107666, 0.021942139, -0.09008789, -0.021255493, 0.02835083, -0.011650085, 0.005847931, -0.055389404, 0.027236938, -0.006385803, 0.012489319, -0.006626129, 0.054626465, -0.02154541, -0.031585693, -0.017944336, -0.015090942, -0.024597168, -0.021255493, 0.007801056, -0.01008606, 0.026351929, 0.0021266937, -0.021072388, 0.01751709, -0.026550293, -0.0418396, -0.046142578, 0.07574463, -0.012107849, -0.0021266937, -0.093322754, 0.006679535, 0.0206604, -0.06665039, 0.009147644, -0.012664795, -0.01701355, 0.036865234, 0.022583008, -0.04650879, 0.018615723, 0.075927734, 0.028762817, -0.027694702, 0.08795166, 0.0317688, 0.039916992, 0.04937744, 0.048919678, 0.040161133, 0.016662598, 0.020248413, 0.012191772, -0.0023899078, 0.035491943, -0.030776978, 0.0050735474, -0.014694214, -0.04324341, 0.015731812, -0.0071907043, -0.04849243, -0.028884888, -0.022277832, -0.007411957, -0.0061950684, 0.0020561218, 0.02558899, -0.0059280396, -0.0413208, 0.027526855, -0.040496826, 0.0032730103, 0.032470703, 0.005882263, -0.046081543, -0.020446777, -0.0129852295, -0.0042266846, 0.0049819946, 0.0068969727, 0.0046081543, -0.037841797, 0.006706238, 0.005634308, 0.05886841, 0.036956787, 0.0014476776, 0.07946777, -0.02432251, 0.048339844, 0.027038574, 0.02130127, -0.10131836, -0.035888672, -0.04550171, 0.0008659363, -0.034423828, -0.0044174194, 0.01828003, -0.06185913, 0.0056381226, -0.03942871, 0.007904053, 0.012435913, 0.058898926, 0.062438965, -0.008094788, -0.024490356, 0.018295288, 0.029525757, 0.020141602, -0.03253174, -0.0026168823, 0.0070266724, 0.010246277, -0.05545044, -0.02267456, -0.0066337585, 0.01600647, -0.01889038, -0.007019043, 0.0206604, -0.05203247, -0.020690918, -0.00970459, 0.05493164, 0.00060606, 0.062164307, -0.05529785, 0.043701172, 0.01802063, 0.015975952, 0.0020637512, -0.006816864, -0.021194458, 0.02178955, -0.0013580322, 0.019577026, -0.007499695, 0.007511139, 0.039154053, 0.03616333, 0.02848816, -0.013259888, -0.028045654, -0.03353882, 0.0043754578, -0.004184723, 0.0137786865, -0.0025482178, 0.013809204, -0.0064086914, 0.014099121, 0.032928467, 0.03717041, -0.012588501, -0.02558899, -0.013343811, -0.00605011, 0.00774765, -0.015823364, -0.005355835, -0.031173706, -0.056549072, 0.010353088, -0.0014028549, 0.05142212, 0.017471313, -0.012771606, -0.0029907227, -0.040039062, -0.009727478, 0.036987305, -0.03677368, 0.04925537, -0.048736572, -0.014228821, 0.03250122, 0.006477356, -0.002155304, -0.026794434, 0.019485474, 0.0052337646, -0.036102295, 0.06298828, 0.025161743, 0.030029297, -0.013687134, 0.034362793, 0.047790527, 0.00059080124, -0.013748169, 0.00995636, -0.043273926, 0.05883789, -0.0031852722, 0.025787354, -0.026992798, -0.019439697, 0.018203735, -0.031585693, -0.0023021698, -0.0032672882, 0.008872986, -0.0015773773, 0.009727478, 0.013870239, -0.02633667, -0.011047363, -0.026687622, 0.03161621, 0.003162384, -0.04421997, -0.024658203, 0.018722534, -0.05319214, -0.03213501, 0.004032135, 0.006965637, 0.034240723, -0.003917694, 0.06323242, -0.033843994, 0.009666443, -0.030426025, -0.026779175, 0.049804688, 0.032073975, -0.06689453, 0.054779053, 0.00027680397, -0.0013694763, -0.011962891, -0.02217102, 0.034210205, -0.0030975342, 0.011917114, 0.025177002, -0.04763794, -0.0069618225, -0.011634827, -0.004245758, 0.039886475, -0.033111572, 0.011756897, 0.0006842613, 0.046203613, -0.03048706, -0.0051345825, 0.051208496, 0.061187744, -0.019805908, 0.009429932, 0.046325684, 0.003929138, -0.05227661, -0.0054397583, -0.06933594, -0.0657959, 0.017318726, 0.08288574, 0.024902344, 0.028701782, -0.012130737, 0.016098022, 0.005924225, -0.032958984, -0.018295288, 0.03427124, -0.023468018, -0.034698486, 0.002620697, 0.019042969, 0.0026798248, 0.024963379, -0.030288696, -0.013877869, 0.024459839, -0.02305603, -0.033081055, -0.010551453, -0.099365234, -0.020904541, 0.02017212, -0.07165527, -0.06506348, 0.03555298, 0.006164551, -0.03616333, 0.034698486, -0.020004272, -0.0046157837, -0.014091492, -0.0446167, 0.019256592, -0.037078857, -0.05947876, 0.009307861, -0.015625, -0.013206482, -0.029449463, -0.0070228577, -0.026443481, -0.017227173, -0.018936157, -0.0022621155, 0.012825012, -0.011489868, 0.03540039, 0.01625061, 0.025939941, -0.016525269, 0.033325195, -0.040863037, -0.004573822, 0.01007843, -0.07940674, -0.026489258, -0.02243042, 0.041107178, 0.025772095, -0.033355713, -0.07373047, 0.026412964, 0.017791748, 0.031082153, 0.053771973, 0.012496948, 0.030807495, 0.0055389404, -0.0051994324, -0.010955811, -0.004890442, 0.033203125, -0.00066137314, 0.01751709, 0.013580322, 0.020584106, 0.04473877, -0.018615723, -0.04650879, 0.028564453, 0.012763977, 0.043823242, -0.025253296, -0.02331543, 0.01234436, -0.01966858, 0.011428833, 0.018218994, -0.020767212, 0.019256592, -0.0035858154, -0.04788208, 0.029647827, 0.02583313, -0.017242432, -0.03503418, 0.043884277, -0.0012559891, 0.01259613, 0.004650116, 0.03930664, 0.045654297, -0.033966064, -0.025024414, -0.018112183, -0.015144348, 0.049865723, -0.0042419434, 0.012245178, -0.008415222, -0.008781433, 0.032836914, -0.01687622, -0.014587402, 0.0022678375, -0.005027771, -0.023025513, 0.050079346, -0.0028209686, -0.031951904, 0.016723633, -0.005470276, 0.002319336, -0.034576416, -0.012519836, -0.013946533, -0.0602417, -0.081604004, -0.053527832, -0.0013170242, -0.016647339, 0.0068855286, 0.021011353, -0.0044822693, 0.037200928, -0.019332886, -0.018447876, 0.008712769, 0.0006046295, -0.020858765, -0.055755615, 0.0075645447, 0.029174805, 0.032196045, 0.034484863, 0.052337646, -0.07800293, 0.005432129, -0.046051025, -0.016845703, -0.045898438, 0.025497437, 0.0051612854, 0.02558899, 0.046569824, 0.0006098747, -0.061340332, 0.016937256, 0.008361816, -0.046173096, -0.046325684, 0.05114746, -0.021942139, -0.033172607, 0.017684937, -0.04550171, 0.013206482, 0.049926758, -0.0039253235, -0.019378662, -0.029373169, -0.028839111, -0.013175964, -0.023376465, 0.018981934, -0.032836914, 0.008598328, -0.021453857, 0.015144348, -0.006702423, -0.004096985, 0.0077400208, -0.040496826, -0.032287598, -0.010475159, -0.024368286, 0.009155273, -0.00995636, -0.017593384, 0.026672363, -0.02558899, 0.0059013367, -0.012588501, -0.011657715, 0.01109314, -0.003036499, 0.004840851, 0.009262085, 0.05307007, 0.030944824, -0.011314392, -0.01108551, -0.03753662, 0.00894928, -0.009117126, 0.0066223145, -0.056915283, -0.050079346, -0.00289917, 0.015159607, 0.005344391, 0.015609741, -0.031280518, -0.0129852295, 0.03656006, 0.015296936, 0.009056091, 0.07409668, -0.037353516, -0.03552246, -0.012588501, 0.000012040138, 0.015022278, 0.019424438, 0.01966858, -0.03375244, -0.009529114, 0.032318115, -0.00014960766, -0.036987305, -0.0058784485, -0.078125, -0.021316528, 0.021972656, -0.051239014, -0.016113281, -0.024505615, 0.015037537, -0.0032157898, -0.025985718, -0.064208984, 0.04800415, -0.006729126, 0.018188477, -0.051330566, -0.008544922, 0.01171875, 0.014877319, 0.0029678345, -0.008644104, -0.0021247864, -0.03100586, 0.05847168, 0.022247314, 0.014099121, -0.011138916, -0.000088870525, -0.012428284, 0.013282776, -0.005554199, 0.020248413, -0.02748108, -0.03363037, 0.033203125, 0.007217407, 0.003583908, -0.027877808, 0.0046958923, -0.018829346, 0.020095825, -0.008872986, 0.0016870499, -0.020996094, 0.07562256, -0.034606934, 0.023071289, -0.00048446655, 0.005207062, -0.027923584, 0.03894043, -0.030197144, 0.03668213, 0.0042266846, -0.013397217, 0.0309906, -0.020767212, -0.08337402, 0.014122009, 0.024124146, -0.057128906, 0.066467285, 0.018356323, 0.0039520264, -0.01727295, -0.014030457, 0.00756073, 0.009757996, 0.018508911, 0.018722534, 0.043029785, 0.041534424, 0.052093506, -0.018249512, 0.012176514, 0.042755127, -0.015655518, -0.017929077, 0.033111572, -0.056762695, 0.06323242, -0.012413025, 0.035888672, 0.000895977, -0.01876831, -0.041290283, 0.048950195, 0.015510559, 0.02519226, -0.052764893, -0.011199951, 0.017410278, 0.0071983337, -0.009178162, 0.0052948, -0.016860962, -0.017120361, 0.00051021576, -0.001449585, 0.024032593, 0.028793335, -0.029022217, 0.03765869, -0.010368347, 0.037902832, -0.0054740906, 0.011047363, -0.01574707, 0.018753052, -0.04751587, 0.041046143, 0.0026283264, -0.021774292, -0.016815186, 0.036834717, -0.07727051, 0.024337769, -0.029541016, 0.040222168, 0.066467285, 0.04458618, -0.026794434, 0.017425537, 0.028198242, -0.023406982, 0.061309814, 0.06793213, 0.019989014, -0.0073661804, -0.012481689, -0.013092041, 0.028945923, 0.03729248, 0.041992188, 0.013961792, 0.010307312, 0.020950317, -0.10070801, 0.05987549, 0.014572144, 0.035125732, -0.012718201, 0.036224365, 0.014732361, 0.037475586, -0.06616211, -0.01008606, 0.015411377, 0.01537323, 0.00032639503, -0.0028629303, -0.006175995, -0.008766174, -0.00017309189, -0.023544312, -0.0012922287, 0.029830933, 0.007534027, -0.02204895, 0.037994385, 0.013946533, -0.016326904, 0.02218628, -0.016983032, 0.06439209, 0.015853882, -0.008544922, 0.009162903, 0.004550934, -0.017288208, -0.00029850006, -0.04562378, 0.015975952, -0.02468872, 0.076660156, -0.030639648, -0.021942139, 0.01083374, 0.0340271, -0.04522705, 0.014083862, -0.008361816, 0.014511108, 0.019943237, 0.0158844, 0.02394104, -0.035369873, -0.0053863525, -0.025177002, -0.0021953583, -0.0390625, 0.020980835, 0.038604736, 0.0519104, 0.010292053, 0.074035645, 0.047576904, -0.009429932, 0.031036377, -0.029281616, -0.05255127, -0.03527832, 0.031433105, 0.051513672, 0.014465332, -0.010498047, 0.018341064, -0.014778137, 0.009735107, -0.02848816, 0.0033740997, -0.040222168, -0.01864624, -0.017684937, -0.008399963, 0.025146484, -0.026412964, -0.04333496, -0.0001963377, -0.019989014, -0.009506226, -0.07080078, -0.0053863525, -0.05529785, 0.011138916, -0.021316528, -0.0040245056, 0.0017061234, -0.051635742, 0.042877197, 0.0070991516, 0.015312195, 0.002204895, -0.0036354065, 0.035095215, -0.046203613, 0.02166748, 0.0018901825, -0.005077362, -0.021057129, -0.006198883, -0.020355225, 0.022109985, -0.022903442, -0.013252258, -0.010765076, -0.032043457, -0.015853882, -0.022262573, 0.025436401, -0.019897461, 0.0104904175, 0.031280518, -0.008232117, 0.022613525, -0.018692017, 0.06365967, -0.02720642, 0.040039062, 0.0009765625, 0.016540527, 0.04046631 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2010.11917v2
Batch Exploration with Examples for Scalable Robotic Reinforcement Learning
Annie S. Chen, HyunJi Nam, Suraj Nair, Chelsea Finn
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
Learning from diverse offline datasets is a promising path towards learning general purpose robotic agents. However, a core challenge in this paradigm lies in collecting large amounts of meaningful data, while not depending on a human in the loop for data collection. One way to address this challenge is through task-agnostic exploration, where an agent attempts to explore without a task-specific reward function, and collect data that can be useful for any downstream task. While these approaches have shown some promise in simple domains, they often struggle to explore the relevant regions of the state space in more challenging settings, such as vision based robotic manipulation. This challenge stems from an objective that encourages exploring everything in a potentially vast state space. To mitigate this challenge, we propose to focus exploration on the important parts of the state space using weak human supervision. Concretely, we propose an exploration technique, Batch Exploration with Examples (BEE), that explores relevant regions of the state-space, guided by a modest number of human provided images of important states. These human provided images only need to be collected once at the beginning of data collection and can be collected in a matter of minutes, allowing us to scalably collect diverse datasets, which can then be combined with any batch RL algorithm. We find that BEE is able to tackle challenging vision-based manipulation tasks both in simulation and on a real Franka robot, and observe that compared to task-agnostic and weakly-supervised exploration techniques, it (1) interacts more than twice as often with relevant objects, and (2) improves downstream task performance when used in conjunction with offline RL.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2010.11917v2
"2021-04-23T18:27:28"
"2020-10-22T17:49:25"
{ "title": [ 0.0010328293, 0.0037269592, -0.025054932, -0.018539429, 0.008964539, -0.022384644, 0.005962372, -0.01864624, -0.04663086, 0.015403748, -0.057281494, 0.017318726, -0.047668457, -0.0060195923, -0.015731812, -0.05380249, 0.01309967, 0.01600647, -0.016693115, -0.026229858, -0.010604858, -0.018981934, 0.024353027, 0.0736084, 0.029342651, 0.031799316, -0.11895752, 0.016738892, -0.03161621, -0.023971558, -0.013191223, 0.007980347, 0.02998352, -0.0055885315, 0.021102905, 0.005054474, -0.033599854, 0.016448975, 0.013946533, -0.030288696, 0.008705139, -0.0069122314, -0.023605347, -0.03286743, -0.03933716, 0.02407837, -0.059631348, -0.003818512, -0.0256958, 0.05783081, 0.030929565, 0.01826477, -0.0013895035, 0.07232666, 0.017852783, -0.038085938, -0.02381897, -0.035095215, 0.051116943, 0.036254883, 0.014198303, -0.05279541, 0.028045654, -0.011856079, -0.020568848, -0.034698486, -0.03604126, 0.033416748, 0.07165527, -0.0011501312, -0.016174316, 0.031082153, 0.005130768, 0.02810669, -0.042663574, -0.036895752, 0.058624268, 0.017715454, 0.018127441, -0.013336182, -0.033111572, -0.024093628, -0.0007510185, -0.04525757, 0.019851685, -0.02999878, -0.019515991, 0.000497818, -0.04525757, -0.07556152, -0.01234436, -0.008529663, -0.039245605, 0.012763977, -0.031677246, -0.020050049, -0.01878357, -0.022155762, 0.031433105, 0.0008664131, 0.020111084, -0.012451172, 0.0028629303, 0.00049209595, 0.0015182495, 0.0048942566, 0.013053894, -0.021438599, 0.0067710876, 0.009979248, -0.028778076, 0.054138184, 0.004425049, 0.040252686, -0.014076233, -0.037902832, -0.046844482, 0.02746582, -0.0007991791, 0.03741455, -0.00021278858, -0.014083862, -0.0038700104, 0.023757935, 0.0036010742, 0.014205933, -0.02746582, -0.013465881, 0.017364502, 0.041412354, 0.0033988953, 0.03250122, -0.093811035, -0.08477783, -0.056915283, 0.024902344, 0.0044403076, -0.0028438568, -0.010864258, -0.009674072, 0.023010254, -0.0015411377, 0.00831604, 0.009773254, 0.01133728, 0.0056419373, 0.057647705, -0.004634857, -0.028778076, -0.033721924, -0.03112793, 0.041931152, -0.004524231, 0.009963989, -0.0009217262, -0.0022029877, -0.08972168, -0.011154175, 0.05203247, 0.025131226, 0.02670288, 0.023330688, 0.03466797, 0.036590576, 0.07397461, -0.03942871, -0.014289856, 0.024917603, -0.0026550293, 0.050048828, -0.02331543, 0.035888672, -0.0048561096, -0.01737976, -0.012504578, -0.020507812, 0.017028809, 0.011833191, 0.013671875, -0.019744873, 0.014862061, -0.024307251, 0.0090408325, 0.045074463, -0.026748657, -0.046661377, -0.008224487, -0.036376953, 0.043823242, 0.011726379, -0.07110596, 0.028823853, -0.0446167, -0.021133423, -0.0368042, 0.006214142, 0.014587402, 0.051513672, -0.0042304993, -0.009384155, -0.04711914, 0.011276245, -0.036621094, 0.027938843, 0.032470703, -0.04711914, 0.021331787, 0.016998291, -0.015594482, 0.08068848, 0.03564453, 0.025054932, -0.025115967, -0.0124435425, 0.016815186, -0.04711914, 0.030319214, -0.014541626, -0.016799927, -0.01159668, -0.025115967, -0.011512756, -0.009811401, 0.060333252, 0.041534424, 0.0071868896, -0.0046691895, -0.017211914, 0.044799805, 0.025161743, 0.030639648, -0.032073975, 0.029067993, 0.03793335, -0.0038204193, -0.014228821, 0.0033798218, 0.013175964, 0.020736694, 0.0053482056, 0.003232956, -0.0017089844, 0.019439697, 0.057434082, 0.06161499, 0.006259918, 0.008918762, 0.01576233, -0.0013999939, 0.011993408, 0.05038452, 0.023513794, 0.054473877, 0.055419922, -0.012611389, 0.05581665, 0.018844604, 0.014060974, -0.035736084, 0.014961243, -0.0028057098, -0.008491516, -0.014274597, 0.0024757385, -0.0670166, 0.040100098, -0.016464233, 0.027313232, 0.0068244934, 0.016647339, 0.031280518, -0.00712204, 0.00010484457, 0.0009217262, -0.008094788, -0.01777649, -0.0036373138, 0.019302368, 0.014289856, -0.04534912, 0.0018892288, 0.0013046265, 0.066467285, 0.0070877075, 0.02418518, 0.02015686, 0.039642334, -0.022140503, -0.021484375, -0.03942871, 0.03543091, 0.01209259, 0.006832123, -0.013694763, 0.008392334, -0.017730713, 0.06439209, 0.097229004, -0.039764404, 0.041870117, -0.05456543, 0.011245728, 0.0028877258, -0.018417358, -0.0012617111, 0.0040397644, 0.031555176, 0.0056877136, -0.022720337, 0.0079193115, -0.04373169, 0.014785767, 0.024902344, -0.0014390945, -0.021316528, -0.041534424, 0.018554688, -0.021697998, -0.04840088, -0.06072998, 0.0869751, -0.025970459, -0.010871887, -0.0047683716, -0.017791748, -0.030334473, 0.0009217262, -0.026916504, 0.008880615, 0.03062439, 0.028961182, 0.032104492, -0.05886841, -0.0025691986, -0.0015697479, 0.025543213, -0.010910034, 0.03488159, -0.022705078, -0.028747559, -0.004398346, -0.017913818, 0.019073486, -0.026290894, -0.0054740906, -0.060333252, -0.0146865845, -0.0045814514, 0.026428223, -0.012207031, 0.029251099, 0.0058403015, -0.007347107, 0.022964478, 0.07141113, -0.0569458, -0.020629883, 0.03741455, 0.014045715, -0.010238647, 0.018585205, -0.0014801025, -0.017852783, -0.051483154, 0.013961792, -0.039916992, 0.0004196167, -0.026184082, 0.0023994446, 0.060272217, -0.06713867, 0.0010786057, -0.022079468, -0.0043792725, 0.009590149, 0.031066895, 0.015380859, -0.03353882, -0.029190063, 0.009590149, -0.012687683, 0.025161743, -0.032562256, 0.028701782, 0.08520508, 0.006668091, -0.026443481, 0.0024433136, 0.02861023, 0.008361816, -0.029067993, -0.030563354, -0.002773285, 0.0146865845, 0.0031814575, -0.016525269, 0.010734558, 0.005027771, -0.10784912, -0.0026435852, 0.019699097, 0.007545471, -0.047698975, 0.034179688, -0.04864502, -0.016952515, 0.0006098747, -0.048675537, 0.0060310364, 0.049224854, 0.012702942, -0.027404785, 0.036499023, -0.049957275, 0.04498291, -0.049041748, -0.05517578, 0.04534912, -0.06665039, -0.028137207, 0.012908936, 0.0010480881, -0.049041748, -0.040130615, -0.0003671646, 0.02619934, 0.040252686, 0.010871887, 0.029907227, 0.0090408325, 0.023010254, -0.016479492, -0.022232056, -0.039123535, -0.035949707, -0.0032615662, -0.002943039, 0.079833984, 0.018722534, 0.0013856888, -0.050628662, -0.029067993, 0.018508911, 0.012527466, 0.012329102, -0.018875122, -0.014923096, -0.010040283, -0.02015686, 0.006717682, -0.0025978088, 0.008972168, -0.047576904, -0.0024261475, -0.02508545, 0.010345459, -0.01184845, -0.012496948, -0.00022125244, -0.041534424, -0.02482605, -0.020751953, -0.044555664, -0.0154418945, 0.02708435, -0.016815186, 0.032196045, -0.02381897, -0.035827637, 0.028213501, -0.032684326, 0.018875122, 0.018325806, -0.0007753372, -0.019897461, 0.0042877197, 0.01108551, 0.0052948, -0.014717102, -0.0135269165, -0.006816864, 0.0071640015, -0.015533447, -0.04272461, -0.013633728, 0.009590149, -0.0826416, 0.00020813942, 0.025634766, -0.011039734, 0.006149292, -0.05935669, 0.028747559, -0.014579773, -0.046295166, 0.0021438599, -0.013656616, -0.03237915, 0.004901886, -0.04135132, -0.045715332, 0.082092285, 0.024642944, -0.0019817352, 0.06311035, -0.004207611, -0.015838623, 0.0008840561, 0.022476196, 0.040527344, 0.051330566, 0.009628296, 0.0135650635, 0.056610107, -0.030029297, 0.028930664, 0.033050537, 0.018554688, -0.00067281723, -0.0029029846, -0.00020611286, 0.023452759, -0.042633057, 0.036346436, 0.05404663, -0.02116394, -0.053894043, 0.034088135, -0.001666069, -0.004322052, 0.0065689087, -0.010536194, 0.018188477, 0.008781433, 0.005821228, 0.03866577, -0.017669678, -0.013008118, 0.0259552, 0.014434814, -0.015716553, -0.025222778, 0.018249512, 0.027374268, 0.012809753, 0.0026397705, -0.013153076, 0.04260254, -0.023971558, 0.009353638, -0.010971069, -0.007736206, -0.03427124, -0.019104004, -0.06161499, -0.025680542, -0.015823364, 0.017593384, -0.022918701, 0.003850937, 0.044799805, -0.012306213, -0.044677734, 0.021469116, 0.035583496, -0.011955261, -0.014099121, -0.078308105, -0.0011501312, 0.0035991669, -0.076049805, -0.042053223, -0.0027198792, 0.00920105, 0.022827148, -0.00447464, -0.046142578, -0.0030918121, 0.030029297, 0.11138916, 0.059295654, 0.023391724, -0.064697266, 0.014793396, -0.04977417, 0.0023956299, 0.035217285, -0.028121948, -0.017150879, -0.023803711, 0.02835083, 0.008476257, -0.016296387, -0.058624268, 0.023452759, -0.0015897751, 0.02810669, 0.008674622, 0.034484863, 0.041107178, 0.014183044, 0.00806427, 0.012626648, -0.0335083, 0.013290405, -0.009552002, 0.053253174, -0.00548172, 0.03729248, 0.0030136108, 0.011444092, 0.020065308, -0.043823242, 0.03543091, -0.016677856, -0.047790527, -0.010070801, 0.03277588, -0.012435913, -0.0129776, 0.021636963, 0.010292053, 0.029693604, -0.038024902, 0.030319214, -0.017120361, 0.02293396, 0.018692017, -0.010894775, 0.005252838, -0.028030396, 0.00083065033, -0.07421875, -0.054504395, -0.03149414, 0.062316895, -0.042022705, -0.02822876, -0.0070991516, 0.0017929077, 0.021728516, 0.04940796, 0.05569458, -0.014518738, -0.013420105, -0.012672424, -0.0029144287, -0.022079468, -0.058044434, -0.0036735535, -0.060943604, 0.013702393, -0.047821045, 0.06317139, -0.038635254, 0.011497498, 0.008728027, 0.005458832, 0.0068130493, -0.055786133, 0.01776123, 0.045135498, -0.0067710876, 0.0058631897, 0.024841309, 0.010749817, 0.02166748, 0.031799316, 0.0033569336, 0.043792725, 0.014839172, -0.019851685, 0.04083252, 0.012413025, 0.031341553, 0.0011606216, -0.001909256, -0.004058838, 0.0044021606, -0.02911377, 0.023651123, -0.011993408, -0.0038890839, 0.00020337105, -0.03152466, -0.002500534, 0.016311646, 0.023620605, 0.013465881, -0.04940796, -0.030044556, -0.00806427, -0.032714844, -0.040252686, 0.012802124, -0.014572144, -0.009513855, -0.06518555, 0.0032367706, -0.03527832, 0.008102417, 0.00217247, 0.006614685, -0.022125244, 0.051849365, 0.03274536, -0.039916992, -0.0006351471, -0.0031166077, 0.008811951, 0.04284668, 0.025268555, -0.06088257, -0.01210022, 0.004463196, -0.06304932, -0.0592041, 0.01651001, 0.009025574, -0.013374329, -0.023254395, -0.020858765, 0.024093628, -0.04562378, 0.009254456, 0.009033203, -0.0028266907, 0.022399902, 0.010093689, -0.0010795593, -0.0024929047, 0.007068634, 0.00023722649, -0.00047373772, -0.0039520264, 0.029388428, 0.013374329, 0.00003963709, 0.001200676, 0.009124756, -0.060913086, 0.016098022, 0.018234253, 0.006225586, -0.021118164, -0.0151901245, 0.027740479, 0.040252686, -0.018707275, -0.018508911, 0.07543945, -0.0357666, 0.04638672, -0.019515991, -0.0046157837, -0.043029785, 0.060821533, -0.005832672, 0.029830933, -0.0713501, -0.070617676, -0.045196533, -0.01889038, 0.043151855, -0.0075416565, 0.00730896, -0.00724411, 0.023590088, -0.02003479, -0.015838623, -0.050323486, 0.024810791, 0.004421234, -0.016052246, 0.020889282, -0.006916046, 0.013923645, -0.032836914, 0.0044517517, 0.027740479, 0.02835083, 0.0014228821, -0.07977295, -0.011741638, -0.019638062, -0.02331543, 0.03967285, 0.0009822845, -0.02722168, 0.033935547, -0.053253174, 0.053833008, 0.020141602, 0.025863647, 0.035217285, -0.0039863586, 0.0055007935, 0.0018777847, -0.006477356, -0.028762817, 0.022216797, -0.0597229, -0.0126571655, -0.06573486, -0.028518677, -0.071777344, -0.018829346, 0.008361816, 0.028823853, 0.035705566, -0.007118225, -0.0012817383, 0.010131836, 0.029373169, 0.028045654, 0.053344727, -0.009185791, 0.0009403229, -0.00207901, -0.0027561188, 0.017852783, 0.021575928, 0.0044441223, 0.021011353, -0.018051147, -0.024505615, 0.033691406, 0.010772705, 0.004058838, -0.017059326, -0.02003479, -0.040985107, 0.022247314, -0.015838623, 0.012199402, 0.05392456, 0.043304443, -0.027633667, -0.010681152, 0.017059326, 0.012084961, -0.044555664, 0.02355957, 0.039794922, -0.043823242, 0.013824463, -0.015327454, -0.018997192, -0.0030174255, 0.05319214, 0.02029419, -0.05053711, -0.024124146, 0.037139893, 0.019210815, 0.018615723, 0.042663574, -0.0206604, -0.035491943, 0.0021133423, 0.045135498, -0.009963989, 0.046173096, 0.0058403015, 0.012763977, -0.037353516, 0.0020122528, -0.012207031, 0.053710938, -0.062927246, 0.01576233, -0.041412354, 0.08380127, -0.00831604, -0.044952393, 0.03652954, -0.00024580956, -0.07885742, -0.019973755, 0.0024147034, 0.032958984, 0.03829956, 0.044006348, 0.0027122498, -0.021835327, 0.013496399, -0.03704834, 0.023895264, 0.03466797, -0.023376465, 0.023468018, -0.021194458, -0.02319336, 0.048461914, -0.025009155, 0.051757812, -0.04107666, 0.017852783, -0.015960693, 0.020950317, 0.045776367, -0.07196045, -0.045928955, -0.019348145, -0.0019397736, 0.013748169, 0.023117065, -0.028152466, 0.010185242, 0.018295288, -0.018371582, 0.046325684, -0.008979797, -0.008453369, -0.028930664, -0.049194336, -0.016189575, -0.017974854, 0.015975952, 0.013320923, -0.013542175, 0.0048599243, -0.00033330917, -0.02154541, -0.014099121, -0.018539429, 0.0129852295, -0.014717102, -0.0154953, 0.01876831, 0.038330078, -0.0047302246, 0.0032520294, -0.012252808, 0.009361267, -0.015945435, -0.009803772, 0.024597168, -0.013938904, -0.05883789, -0.013191223, -0.034484863, 0.005306244, 0.009101868, -0.022705078, 0.00674057, 0.020492554, -0.042816162, -0.01399231, -0.003271103, 0.045135498, -0.014045715, -0.035980225, 0.0040779114, 0.034729004, 0.05633545, -0.041748047, -0.05105591, 0.0027236938, -0.0018196106, -0.026794434, 0.08282471, -0.009025574, 0.011306763, 0.027572632, 0.08227539, 0.016555786, -0.050689697, -0.02911377, -0.020477295, 0.04748535, 0.0619812, -0.024795532, 0.008987427, 0.039154053, -0.00415802, 0.010879517, 0.01234436, 0.00466156, 0.015213013, -0.014678955, 0.04837036, -0.018173218, -0.008117676, -0.007686615, 0.016113281, 0.010192871, 0.05871582, -0.037017822, 0.008552551, 0.025039673, 0.05117798, -0.03265381, -0.03604126, 0.03692627, 0.018218994, 0.012481689, 0.040039062, -0.0017061234, -0.014282227, -0.021377563, 0.025894165, 0.017425537, 0.04095459, -0.0018024445, 0.021270752, 0.037384033, -0.023361206, -0.052490234, 0.0026187897, -0.028503418, 0.026321411, -0.054534912, 0.02128601, -0.020645142, -0.015327454, -0.012016296, 0.041259766, -0.0071868896, -0.045135498, -0.02305603, -0.009803772, 0.040130615, -0.012016296 ], "summary": [ 0.025360107, -0.01651001, 0.004650116, 0.025390625, -0.03515625, -0.0110321045, 0.012893677, -0.029449463, 0.00029110909, 0.023666382, -0.085632324, 0.0020580292, -0.017471313, 0.012924194, -0.019500732, -0.07775879, 0.014511108, 0.020706177, 0.030685425, -0.0013065338, 0.005470276, 0.013420105, -0.0007071495, 0.010063171, 0.018112183, 0.025772095, -0.10101318, 0.05291748, 0.0016527176, 0.047943115, 0.00617218, -0.035064697, -0.01222229, -0.004470825, 0.051330566, -0.010826111, -0.023468018, 0.023117065, 0.01914978, -0.0028629303, 0.0138549805, -0.0028305054, 0.037872314, -0.030899048, -0.020584106, 0.04876709, -0.036499023, -0.008773804, 0.030639648, 0.04385376, -0.011734009, 0.022521973, -0.047454834, 0.051239014, -0.008781433, -0.05657959, -0.03970337, -0.04598999, 0.054534912, 0.0065956116, 0.009796143, -0.07373047, 0.033325195, -0.008598328, 0.00042414665, -0.028076172, 0.009468079, 0.028564453, -0.008460999, 0.006252289, 0.033081055, 0.0058174133, 0.023635864, -0.004131317, -0.03778076, -0.02279663, 0.049957275, -0.0018148422, -0.02268982, -0.019515991, -0.010604858, 0.0036201477, -0.02748108, -0.04107666, 0.022628784, -0.0054016113, -0.021392822, -0.010887146, -0.023422241, -0.011764526, -0.023635864, 0.039154053, -0.050750732, 0.030349731, -0.00013506413, -0.0047187805, -0.022094727, -0.08276367, 0.07196045, 0.020019531, 0.06750488, -0.08227539, 0.06817627, -0.006061554, 0.014602661, 0.019226074, 0.013214111, -0.040374756, 0.03338623, -0.0037899017, -0.027801514, 0.09307861, 0.016174316, 0.022918701, -0.02154541, -0.00091171265, -0.018875122, 0.019622803, -0.025558472, 0.03074646, -0.016860962, 0.0042800903, -0.031188965, 0.049682617, -0.007972717, 0.01675415, 0.004371643, -0.0013389587, 0.03527832, -0.015701294, -0.007713318, 0.044128418, -0.00036168098, -0.043151855, -0.049224854, 0.008804321, 0.042114258, -0.0112838745, 0.010292053, -0.025604248, 0.04034424, 0.027069092, 0.0035114288, 0.00066804886, -0.008880615, 0.02178955, 0.030303955, 0.009086609, -0.008781433, -0.019882202, -0.026428223, 0.025741577, -0.0056533813, 0.0072517395, 0.056243896, -0.04071045, -0.012916565, -0.01197052, 0.060516357, 0.012512207, 0.010818481, 0.030044556, 0.029937744, 0.033569336, 0.011116028, -0.03704834, 0.009033203, 0.004173279, 0.0014944077, 0.016494751, 0.0055732727, 0.026535034, 0.014457703, -0.02658081, -0.012329102, -0.034332275, -0.007873535, 0.00014305115, 0.0024871826, 0.0012321472, 0.0019397736, -0.019241333, -0.019927979, 0.02885437, 0.011146545, -0.03668213, -0.0413208, -0.042388916, 0.0501709, -0.0056495667, -0.06500244, -0.0056915283, -0.043151855, 0.015975952, -0.0070495605, 0.017532349, -0.028961182, 0.03387451, -0.028244019, -0.05343628, 0.04949951, 0.041168213, -0.02557373, -0.00945282, -0.018157959, -0.016937256, 0.030853271, 0.022537231, -0.0096206665, 0.04901123, 0.015449524, -0.0042877197, -0.020965576, 0.015182495, 0.033233643, -0.03540039, 0.040618896, -0.030075073, -0.0023059845, -0.038604736, 0.0064735413, 0.010253906, -0.024246216, 0.042144775, 0.030029297, 0.019607544, -0.026992798, 0.012397766, 0.0670166, 0.019058228, 0.025543213, -0.013473511, -0.0039520264, 0.03845215, -0.012420654, -0.03262329, 0.030685425, -0.04434204, 0.047058105, 0.0395813, 0.015914917, 0.06335449, -0.00085258484, 0.038909912, 0.030761719, -0.011230469, 0.010154724, 0.012084961, -0.040802002, 0.015098572, 0.01222229, 0.034179688, 0.015342712, 0.057678223, -0.050689697, 0.043304443, 0.0033683777, -0.03186035, -0.014030457, -0.0010280609, 0.023727417, 0.0021514893, -0.04559326, 0.011932373, -0.04647827, -0.008911133, 0.020095825, 0.018096924, 0.030456543, -0.04776001, 0.010498047, 0.018508911, -0.008422852, -0.027236938, 0.0057640076, -0.009048462, -0.030639648, 0.019638062, 0.03756714, -0.0151901245, -0.0014638901, 0.007675171, 0.03503418, -0.009140015, 0.03277588, 0.0725708, 0.03265381, -0.012199402, -0.00843811, 0.056640625, 0.074523926, -0.008201599, -0.015640259, -0.012054443, -0.009429932, -0.0018749237, 0.0049209595, 0.06781006, -0.02671814, 0.01121521, 0.017074585, 0.023849487, -0.0418396, 0.017440796, 0.017242432, -0.043518066, -0.00894928, 0.035705566, 0.0053253174, 0.009613037, -0.06298828, 0.044403076, 0.035949707, 0.06616211, -0.014457703, -0.02960205, 0.018737793, 0.040527344, -0.020904541, -0.04888916, 0.103881836, -0.04586792, 0.0019493103, 0.017929077, -0.03677368, -0.043884277, 0.06896973, -0.033813477, 0.021453857, 0.007873535, -0.008834839, -0.00054073334, -0.028289795, -0.0073242188, 0.0035476685, -0.00092315674, 0.01348114, 0.026473999, -0.0029678345, -0.032318115, 0.011154175, 0.022735596, -0.005760193, 0.011367798, -0.05038452, -0.0028018951, -0.04849243, -0.0020275116, 0.01525116, -0.036315918, 0.03302002, -0.003162384, -0.008918762, 0.044128418, 0.02406311, -0.056854248, -0.0026798248, 0.03982544, -0.031921387, -0.023605347, 0.036315918, -0.008163452, -0.021621704, -0.097229004, 0.020889282, -0.019195557, -0.0127334595, -0.08093262, 0.060699463, 0.051361084, -0.02053833, 0.07086182, -0.032043457, -0.015670776, 0.008766174, -0.0032444, 0.086364746, -0.011405945, -0.005214691, 0.04940796, 0.010322571, 0.003419876, -0.03225708, -0.01966858, 0.09881592, -0.00046682358, -0.00012141466, 0.043914795, 0.05807495, 0.009162903, -0.029006958, -0.04763794, 0.030181885, -0.013771057, -0.0256958, -0.024658203, 0.017166138, 0.03111267, -0.035186768, -0.013534546, -0.02268982, 0.031982422, -0.017593384, -0.00024366379, 0.010070801, -0.033111572, 0.00623703, -0.04321289, -0.008605957, 0.050628662, 0.02998352, -0.054016113, 0.06137085, -0.06359863, 0.04888916, -0.02999878, 0.030212402, 0.032806396, -0.08111572, -0.020080566, 0.012428284, 0.07543945, -0.012489319, -0.040740967, 0.011070251, 0.011749268, 0.042388916, 0.01965332, 0.013031006, 0.006362915, 0.034576416, -0.039276123, 0.003314972, -0.039093018, -0.0803833, -0.012313843, -0.015716553, 0.049560547, 0.008506775, -0.036743164, -0.030654907, -0.02218628, 0.02078247, -0.0067253113, 0.002784729, -0.00006145239, 0.008430481, -0.0024356842, -0.02230835, 0.012870789, -0.013885498, 0.0017299652, -0.012283325, 0.018798828, -0.018630981, 0.0413208, -0.030685425, 0.021499634, 0.048461914, -0.08117676, -0.061401367, -0.034362793, -0.013412476, -0.024414062, 0.042144775, -0.007484436, -0.005771637, -0.006259918, -0.010620117, 0.016479492, 0.011833191, -0.001162529, 0.013626099, -0.00198555, -0.017425537, -0.036468506, 0.024765015, -0.0037612915, 0.027832031, -0.022445679, 0.0011034012, 0.0015640259, 0.02029419, -0.012550354, -0.0071525574, 0.017166138, -0.06677246, -0.03201294, 0.03491211, 0.026443481, 0.010398865, -0.05657959, 0.0625, -0.021820068, -0.017196655, 0.04071045, -0.009109497, 0.026779175, 0.010246277, -0.025634766, -0.017105103, 0.006210327, 0.026824951, 0.011001587, 0.045196533, 0.010803223, 0.01146698, 0.041107178, 0.011856079, 0.022827148, 0.055236816, -0.0058937073, 0.044036865, 0.02116394, -0.004245758, 0.0016078949, 0.022903442, 0.00843811, -0.004432678, -0.0058784485, -0.0013923645, 0.010734558, -0.017929077, 0.009681702, 0.027313232, 0.02281189, -0.032958984, 0.06604004, 0.015151978, 0.00090026855, 0.033935547, 0.021148682, 0.0017814636, 0.009025574, -0.00472641, -0.036193848, -0.024627686, -0.00015950203, 0.023773193, 0.036712646, -0.048980713, -0.06719971, 0.017929077, 0.051483154, -0.0079574585, 0.0031585693, -0.039794922, 0.033447266, -0.017150879, 0.011062622, 0.0017576218, -0.015052795, -0.023880005, -0.049804688, -0.019256592, 0.039093018, 0.015563965, -0.012542725, -0.009887695, 0.009353638, -0.008415222, -0.008995056, -0.0013551712, 0.013046265, 0.04156494, 0.022567749, -0.045196533, -0.07446289, -0.02558899, 0.01751709, -0.06536865, -0.012199402, -0.03945923, -0.062469482, -0.016326904, -0.015548706, -0.06604004, 0.013618469, -0.008712769, 0.11352539, 0.060821533, 0.03475952, -0.09509277, 0.017166138, -0.04421997, 0.016357422, 0.015777588, -0.030960083, -0.0524292, -0.007888794, 0.043884277, 0.01826477, -0.016311646, -0.050628662, 0.0011205673, 0.0065841675, 0.016464233, 0.029388428, 0.034576416, 0.023864746, 0.02217102, -0.022857666, -0.0032424927, -0.013015747, 0.029876709, -0.04837036, 0.018844604, 0.0013885498, 0.054595947, 0.01586914, -0.045196533, -0.0009484291, -0.054229736, 0.048950195, -0.02772522, -0.07562256, 0.0059013367, 0.030792236, 0.010955811, -0.03817749, -0.0030937195, 0.026412964, -0.02607727, -0.0074005127, 0.012794495, 0.0073242188, 0.023117065, 0.028411865, -0.0030574799, -0.011520386, -0.00028562546, -0.02456665, -0.066467285, -0.07562256, -0.029815674, 0.10546875, -0.038208008, -0.03338623, -0.045959473, -0.036621094, 0.033355713, -0.009284973, -0.02268982, -0.043426514, 0.011924744, -0.0030117035, -0.019241333, 0.020889282, -0.038604736, -0.010948181, -0.050567627, 0.013175964, -0.03378296, 0.02154541, 0.03970337, -0.011009216, 0.011543274, 0.016555786, -0.015167236, -0.021240234, -0.028915405, -0.007045746, -0.010795593, -0.021606445, 0.035705566, 0.0015163422, 0.008270264, 0.016021729, 0.002210617, -0.011421204, -0.024642944, 0.026855469, 0.056884766, 0.009933472, -0.003042221, 0.017593384, 0.017532349, -0.0043678284, 0.009651184, 0.0025577545, 0.004634857, -0.036865234, -0.0009937286, -0.030929565, 0.0016975403, 0.0038967133, -0.01637268, 0.016067505, 0.024307251, -0.0088272095, -0.012748718, -0.029876709, -0.0054397583, -0.07354736, 0.013542175, 0.011169434, 0.014389038, -0.05758667, -0.050567627, -0.043060303, 0.024734497, 0.0026741028, 0.0042533875, -0.014511108, 0.012306213, -0.0052604675, 0.0032444, 0.012069702, 0.035949707, 0.025878906, -0.0031394958, -0.011833191, -0.037902832, -0.0109939575, 0.019088745, -0.020599365, -0.048736572, -0.039794922, -0.032165527, 0.037750244, -0.010879517, 0.012954712, 0.04449463, -0.06756592, 0.009117126, -0.01725769, 0.025161743, 0.022872925, 0.017990112, -0.0013618469, 0.0104522705, -0.021438599, -0.02281189, 0.0038375854, 0.006767273, 0.045318604, 0.056243896, 0.010002136, 0.03050232, -0.03942871, -0.05328369, 0.018814087, 0.024429321, -0.015335083, 0.010246277, -0.008522034, 0.011711121, 0.07128906, -0.02658081, -0.023864746, 0.025283813, 0.0158844, 0.040618896, -0.012207031, 0.032348633, -0.02281189, 0.025299072, -0.0050735474, 0.028182983, -0.026824951, -0.019577026, -0.0031013489, -0.024307251, 0.0058784485, -0.025512695, -0.00667572, 0.029571533, 0.020477295, 0.017669678, -0.0317688, -0.03314209, 0.012626648, 0.002128601, -0.008010864, 0.03857422, -0.007751465, 0.0015058517, 0.006729126, -0.012489319, -0.009864807, 0.014678955, 0.0061073303, -0.012062073, 0.0066490173, -0.026428223, 0.031280518, 0.023117065, 0.03277588, -0.045043945, -0.009017944, -0.005344391, 0.047668457, 0.0038814545, -0.024261475, -0.037597656, -0.057037354, 0.0033435822, -0.004257202, -0.022232056, -0.029327393, 0.02142334, -0.017745972, -0.044952393, -0.036102295, -0.053619385, 0.0012836456, -0.0058021545, 0.009010315, -0.01625061, 0.055236816, -0.025527954, -0.024520874, 0.0463562, -0.06451416, 0.081726074, -0.028640747, -0.004722595, -0.0021076202, -0.042236328, -0.012138367, 0.010383606, 0.03338623, 0.016342163, 0.024337769, -0.00223732, -0.0048980713, 0.041503906, -0.00806427, -0.030273438, -0.057281494, 0.0206604, -0.046173096, 0.0028324127, -0.014709473, 0.025634766, 0.050994873, 0.0071525574, 0.020065308, -0.0211792, 0.03250122, 0.029022217, -0.013847351, 0.019744873, 0.012176514, 0.008140564, -0.014389038, -0.0038452148, -0.016143799, 0.029144287, 0.05557251, 0.041870117, -0.04043579, 0.008651733, 0.036132812, -0.0068740845, -0.01802063, 0.0051193237, -0.022094727, -0.026168823, 0.000279665, 0.009338379, -0.0029659271, 0.016204834, 0.0044784546, -0.026412964, -0.009544373, 0.0009160042, -0.007865906, 0.04989624, -0.05419922, 0.01399231, -0.019989014, 0.08062744, -0.005367279, -0.03753662, 0.029525757, 0.0064697266, -0.044677734, -0.012466431, 0.03237915, 0.05493164, 0.015655518, 0.035217285, -0.020507812, -0.006511688, 0.036315918, 0.0066070557, -0.019607544, 0.028259277, -0.011680603, -0.012763977, 0.005302429, 0.00015950203, 0.028640747, -0.008880615, 0.031066895, -0.04852295, -0.008522034, 0.008728027, -0.037719727, 0.022598267, 0.011367798, -0.036590576, -0.01878357, 0.03149414, 0.03326416, 0.038482666, -0.06970215, 0.043151855, 0.024551392, -0.07055664, 0.038085938, -0.015419006, 0.0031986237, -0.012573242, -0.031066895, -0.011787415, -0.01777649, 0.03378296, 0.056549072, -0.048461914, 0.008964539, -0.013046265, 0.010101318, -0.004463196, -0.011238098, -0.00046348572, -0.014465332, -0.007858276, 0.0047912598, 0.025634766, -0.002412796, -0.007572174, -0.010887146, 0.02027893, -0.02154541, 0.019882202, 0.016098022, 0.013404846, -0.05328369, 0.015426636, -0.0423584, -0.023422241, -0.039215088, -0.010604858, -0.017822266, 0.016220093, -0.02670288, -0.031097412, -0.00039362907, 0.020996094, -0.011779785, 0.009559631, -0.005908966, 0.018966675, 0.027450562, -0.029327393, 0.018844604, -0.002483368, -0.013015747, -0.023452759, 0.06121826, -0.03475952, 0.034332275, 0.07196045, 0.10522461, 0.033843994, -0.061584473, 0.017211914, -0.019607544, 0.049926758, 0.0046463013, -0.037200928, 0.02545166, 0.0118255615, -0.024215698, -0.02116394, 0.017791748, 0.044677734, -0.021011353, 0.015388489, 0.034484863, -0.052520752, -0.041107178, -0.004173279, -0.038391113, 0.013252258, -0.008659363, -0.010643005, 0.0059547424, -0.030792236, 0.025253296, -0.021224976, -0.003080368, -0.011016846, 0.0036468506, 0.003736496, 0.03387451, -0.0046958923, -0.0046920776, -0.0034618378, 0.0054893494, 0.025161743, 0.01171875, -0.007637024, 0.0029850006, 0.02810669, -0.04852295, -0.015716553, -0.046722412, -0.030456543, 0.008270264, -0.005622864, 0.0038490295, 0.053741455, -0.021743774, 0.00051641464, 0.029418945, -0.02229309, -0.010475159, 0.022918701, -0.016677856, 0.002002716, 0.0055656433 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2010.12265v2
Model Interpretability through the Lens of Computational Complexity
Pablo Barceló, Mikaël Monet, Jorge Pérez, Bernardo Subercaseaux
cs.AI, cs.CC, cs.LG
In spite of several claims stating that some models are more interpretable than others -- e.g., "linear models are more interpretable than deep neural networks" -- we still lack a principled notion of interpretability to formally compare among different classes of models. We make a step towards such a notion by studying whether folklore interpretability claims have a correlate in terms of computational complexity theory. We focus on local post-hoc explainability queries that, intuitively, attempt to answer why individual inputs are classified in a certain way by a given model. In a nutshell, we say that a class $\mathcal{C}_1$ of models is more interpretable than another class $\mathcal{C}_2$, if the computational complexity of answering post-hoc queries for models in $\mathcal{C}_2$ is higher than for those in $\mathcal{C}_1$. We prove that this notion provides a good theoretical counterpart to current beliefs on the interpretability of models; in particular, we show that under our definition and assuming standard complexity-theoretical assumptions (such as P$\neq$NP), both linear and tree-based models are strictly more interpretable than neural networks. Our complexity analysis, however, does not provide a clear-cut difference between linear and tree-based models, as we obtain different results depending on the particular post-hoc explanations considered. Finally, by applying a finer complexity analysis based on parameterized complexity, we are able to prove a theoretical result suggesting that shallow neural networks are more interpretable than deeper ones.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2010.12265v2
"2020-11-12T21:57:06"
"2020-10-23T09:50:40"
{ "title": [ -0.02772522, 0.011177063, -0.0146865845, -0.07086182, 0.00057172775, 0.018341064, -0.064208984, -0.03186035, 0.00093364716, -0.00015759468, -0.011154175, -0.027664185, -0.047027588, -0.032684326, -0.04296875, -0.017211914, 0.00504303, 0.025665283, -0.010498047, -0.034362793, -0.027862549, -0.02444458, 0.022766113, 0.04171753, 0.03375244, -0.036254883, -0.06124878, 0.019760132, -0.02420044, -0.020187378, -0.014060974, -0.0007185936, 0.027572632, 0.018035889, 0.0062179565, 0.0056610107, -0.01222229, 0.02760315, 0.014137268, 0.01058197, 0.00029325485, -0.0047454834, -0.016983032, -0.050994873, -0.026809692, 0.0047912598, -0.042175293, -0.021636963, 0.010505676, 0.038024902, -0.015007019, 0.019500732, -0.03765869, 0.043792725, 0.010818481, -0.022994995, -0.010185242, -0.030258179, 0.005996704, 0.07470703, 0.03564453, -0.009025574, 0.001964569, -0.011604309, -0.027633667, -0.011131287, -0.02368164, 0.02709961, 0.08325195, 0.0107421875, -0.044036865, 0.02432251, 0.017974854, -0.009025574, -0.02973938, -0.0058517456, 0.064941406, 0.011672974, 0.0010318756, -0.026565552, 0.03326416, -0.021087646, 0.016784668, 0.023468018, -0.0014152527, 0.012817383, -0.00881958, -0.033294678, -0.002840042, -0.050750732, -0.005393982, 0.026321411, 0.018615723, 0.015991211, -0.053771973, 0.007648468, -0.05432129, -0.016616821, 0.004623413, -0.02935791, -0.0067329407, 0.0007328987, -0.051879883, 0.0011911392, 0.010513306, 0.020309448, -0.013832092, 0.011650085, 0.0146484375, 0.046844482, 0.000477314, 0.0022468567, 0.0035037994, 0.002105713, 0.03817749, 0.030014038, -0.013244629, 0.03543091, -0.0070991516, 0.0513916, -0.019561768, -0.023651123, -0.0061531067, -0.00178051, -0.0016822815, -0.022384644, -0.024780273, -0.001750946, 0.006790161, 0.019729614, 0.00034976006, 0.030899048, -0.08496094, -0.05996704, -0.04434204, 0.03491211, 0.039520264, -0.031951904, -0.03781128, 0.010505676, 0.023025513, -0.033050537, -0.01689148, -0.023483276, -0.016296387, 0.024230957, 0.075927734, -0.00013101101, -0.055114746, -0.07446289, -0.027175903, 0.027023315, 0.027770996, -0.0008840561, -0.04486084, 0.032806396, -0.099731445, 0.0019464493, -0.007965088, 0.023880005, 0.027313232, -0.008430481, -0.01689148, -0.008552551, 0.024978638, 0.003435135, -0.026397705, 0.021133423, 0.012519836, 0.015731812, -0.0029010773, -0.0131073, -0.046936035, 0.011672974, 0.013595581, 0.038848877, 0.0032405853, -0.016937256, 0.022384644, 0.015899658, 0.017852783, -0.0061912537, -0.025238037, 0.07354736, -0.07305908, -0.021820068, -0.013313293, -0.001657486, 0.05328369, 0.007671356, -0.03503418, 0.015533447, -0.03765869, -0.029312134, -0.03540039, -0.033081055, 0.033721924, 0.020263672, -0.0046691895, 0.015266418, -0.02268982, 0.024749756, -0.046020508, 0.015235901, 0.008506775, -0.02130127, 0.01197052, 0.025161743, -0.0049095154, 0.07080078, 0.068603516, 0.054656982, -0.085632324, 0.05795288, -0.019577026, -0.07849121, 0.02015686, -0.025009155, -0.020980835, -0.02444458, -0.03527832, -0.019119263, -0.011459351, 0.077941895, 0.008262634, 0.013259888, 0.012626648, -0.017822266, 0.093811035, 0.022781372, 0.10614014, -0.06970215, 0.020324707, 0.005962372, -0.014099121, -0.024475098, -0.01374054, -0.031341553, 0.013473511, 0.039978027, 0.011123657, -0.009338379, -0.0035991669, 0.009506226, 0.034423828, -0.0077323914, 0.02571106, -0.012832642, 0.026168823, 0.0131073, 0.042388916, -0.000077307224, 0.054351807, 0.01737976, 0.0025157928, 0.064941406, 0.015853882, -0.0072631836, 0.0035533905, 0.05947876, -0.020904541, 0.028213501, -0.0023956299, 0.014076233, -0.05126953, 0.0038719177, -0.038909912, -0.000026226044, -0.009819031, 0.014274597, 0.034729004, -0.01751709, 0.016921997, 0.005443573, -0.028152466, 0.011886597, -0.011253357, 0.012168884, -0.004055023, -0.053100586, -0.0056266785, 0.021362305, 0.035308838, 0.0039901733, 0.0047683716, 0.011932373, 0.026870728, 0.014122009, -0.0105896, 0.02218628, 0.06665039, 0.044158936, 0.021133423, 0.008552551, -0.03527832, 0.017715454, 0.075805664, 0.05429077, -0.035461426, 0.036834717, -0.05722046, 0.013214111, 0.045898438, -0.04348755, 0.0020103455, 0.034851074, 0.016693115, 0.029006958, -0.009094238, 0.0030078888, -0.056610107, -0.0022830963, 0.012367249, -0.029785156, 0.006931305, -0.028808594, 0.007904053, -0.014152527, -0.012908936, 0.010131836, 0.05316162, 0.0069999695, -0.02809143, -0.01864624, 0.012207031, -0.026290894, -0.022399902, -0.043182373, -0.053741455, -0.0020923615, 0.023101807, -0.041534424, -0.0690918, -0.04284668, -0.008743286, 0.014472961, -0.017822266, 0.04119873, -0.030929565, -0.0020523071, 0.010055542, -0.023239136, 0.018493652, -0.04119873, -0.009857178, -0.04446411, 0.0104522705, 0.029067993, -0.031555176, -0.010879517, 0.03326416, -0.02192688, -0.02456665, 0.023742676, 0.06939697, -0.05819702, -0.019363403, 0.044189453, 0.026382446, -0.03375244, 0.031707764, -0.005077362, -0.00274086, -0.027130127, 0.010917664, -0.05368042, -0.017227173, -0.013755798, -0.00037121773, 0.043518066, -0.045928955, -0.027832031, -0.044555664, 0.007106781, 0.00881958, 0.019958496, 0.007003784, -0.031402588, -0.033416748, -0.0054779053, -0.012290955, 0.018722534, -0.018051147, 0.031799316, 0.09313965, -0.01499939, -0.0031223297, 0.02835083, 0.059326172, 0.015655518, -0.0184021, -0.021255493, 0.019989014, -0.007751465, -0.021102905, 0.0011844635, 0.009780884, 0.005443573, -0.050964355, 0.008712769, 0.05255127, -0.017578125, -0.03564453, 0.018753052, -0.07043457, 0.050231934, -0.018157959, -0.002571106, 0.029953003, 0.0552063, -0.0048179626, -0.00017988682, 0.01423645, -0.04043579, 0.008300781, -0.020874023, -0.11810303, 0.0340271, -0.023468018, -0.02154541, -0.008834839, -0.024398804, -0.060272217, -0.0063972473, -0.025680542, 0.055725098, 0.014564514, 0.025802612, 0.034301758, -0.011894226, -0.008872986, -0.012367249, -0.025039673, 0.0025596619, -0.0030612946, 0.00023543835, 0.0026245117, 0.030044556, 0.0345459, 0.0019874573, -0.022232056, -0.029403687, -0.022979736, 0.01134491, -0.013641357, -0.023956299, 0.0041885376, 0.011077881, 0.008682251, 0.017501831, -0.019439697, -0.0048332214, -0.016952515, 0.009101868, -0.027038574, 0.01687622, 0.017333984, -0.010261536, -0.012573242, 0.012298584, 0.017654419, -0.013442993, -0.059417725, 0.0009627342, 0.016952515, 0.0049362183, 0.030136108, -0.006252289, -0.010604858, 0.0013198853, -0.02520752, 0.015640259, 0.020874023, 0.033081055, -0.025497437, 0.025054932, -0.016952515, 0.0004761219, -0.008384705, 0.031951904, 0.0013074875, 0.007232666, 0.008918762, -0.0670166, -0.00043082237, 0.026184082, -0.08685303, 0.0043296814, 0.0048980713, -0.014778137, -0.010055542, -0.032684326, 0.02760315, -0.025543213, -0.034362793, -0.02293396, -0.024230957, -0.00818634, -0.031677246, -0.07751465, -0.019241333, 0.062683105, 0.01159668, 0.045440674, 0.012382507, -0.040740967, -0.010391235, -0.04135132, 0.030563354, -0.0021972656, 0.033111572, -0.021743774, -0.012252808, 0.052368164, -0.03086853, 0.029678345, 0.026855469, 0.011291504, -0.0046920776, 0.012557983, -0.024215698, 0.02229309, -0.00091552734, 0.045898438, 0.01687622, -0.027740479, -0.03842163, 0.04119873, -0.007701874, -0.014450073, 0.041137695, 0.0029907227, 0.013832092, 0.014053345, -0.00737381, 0.04498291, -0.0121536255, 0.01083374, 0.0055618286, -0.011695862, -0.03427124, -0.0006418228, 0.025314331, 0.011978149, 0.020751953, 0.016906738, 0.023376465, 0.060180664, -0.009468079, -0.00026774406, -0.010658264, 0.0034999847, -0.041137695, 0.019058228, -0.042938232, -0.034606934, -0.022415161, 0.0076141357, -0.03414917, 0.03225708, 0.02507019, -0.023147583, -0.023010254, -0.018203735, 0.026245117, -0.0001603365, 0.017105103, -0.03503418, 0.028152466, -0.036590576, -0.089904785, -0.066711426, -0.029800415, 0.009750366, 0.034606934, 0.039855957, -0.044708252, 0.030288696, 0.0015745163, 0.04977417, 0.06210327, -0.010108948, -0.07067871, 0.038604736, -0.044281006, -0.0054473877, 0.028060913, -0.033355713, -0.011016846, -0.020080566, 0.018661499, 0.013710022, 0.0062332153, -0.040130615, 0.013877869, -0.040130615, 0.057556152, -0.009613037, 0.0074310303, 0.008377075, 0.009231567, -0.013938904, -0.0062713623, -0.036102295, -0.011291504, -0.011245728, 0.04537964, -0.019165039, 0.020355225, 0.037231445, 0.03543091, -0.0023326874, -0.0079193115, 0.028198242, 0.0016698837, 0.010154724, 0.013374329, 0.016021729, -0.052368164, -0.049621582, 0.003545761, 0.0025539398, 0.04525757, -0.03643799, 0.040863037, -0.0541687, 0.0075302124, 0.0059661865, -0.016784668, 0.03652954, -0.002363205, 0.039398193, -0.03543091, -0.070739746, 0.014450073, 0.045837402, 0.0013751984, 0.02003479, -0.00006365776, 0.022155762, 0.021697998, 0.043395996, 0.06945801, -0.02053833, 0.009162903, -0.021697998, -0.0050811768, 0.0032215118, -0.04055786, 0.037719727, -0.011138916, 0.013877869, -0.042785645, 0.010009766, -0.07727051, 0.023651123, 0.0017709732, -0.023757935, 0.02432251, -0.07489014, 0.017730713, 0.07434082, -0.008743286, 0.035247803, 0.0040664673, 0.0340271, 0.01991272, 0.044921875, -0.0067214966, 0.04736328, 0.022766113, -0.040649414, 0.024002075, 0.014381409, 0.029312134, 0.03591919, 0.04623413, 0.005302429, 0.024093628, -0.024627686, 0.019577026, 0.024612427, 0.0031661987, 0.06323242, -0.07879639, 0.017501831, 0.002357483, -0.00022161007, 0.016738892, -0.024795532, -0.045318604, 0.006614685, 0.00034880638, 0.008659363, 0.039093018, 0.027114868, -0.013374329, -0.056427002, 0.0073013306, -0.011810303, 0.018554688, -0.0046157837, 0.015899658, -0.039093018, 0.009841919, 0.007858276, -0.028900146, 0.010154724, -0.031402588, 0.0057754517, 0.033691406, 0.0045204163, -0.017074585, -0.0038928986, 0.0039596558, -0.06616211, -0.020492554, 0.007701874, -0.008308411, -0.0014009476, 0.0033359528, -0.021881104, 0.01928711, 0.010612488, 0.022872925, 0.031188965, -0.02293396, 0.048675537, 0.00983429, 0.01789856, 0.010726929, 0.018432617, -0.007133484, 0.008377075, 0.018463135, -0.054473877, 0.02267456, -0.03781128, -0.032470703, 0.007205963, -0.0066452026, 0.010681152, 0.0056533813, -0.013404846, -0.030029297, -0.021194458, 0.021560669, 0.038269043, -0.03164673, -0.019180298, 0.06854248, -0.03894043, -0.024047852, -0.01399231, -0.0098724365, -0.02067566, 0.07086182, -0.01776123, -0.03817749, -0.031234741, -0.04095459, -0.017440796, -0.0010614395, 0.015258789, 0.040863037, 0.03857422, -0.035003662, -0.013519287, -0.006385803, -0.024856567, -0.024902344, 0.021728516, -0.009162903, -0.0680542, 0.037597656, -0.010375977, -0.009750366, -0.013305664, 0.013221741, 0.03326416, 0.015808105, 0.003047943, -0.046203613, -0.019485474, -0.04336548, -0.011497498, 0.048614502, 0.040740967, -0.06463623, 0.028579712, 0.003452301, 0.06427002, 0.02230835, 0.019256592, 0.006038666, 0.029205322, 0.051361084, -0.007045746, 0.009025574, -0.018615723, 0.024475098, -0.033233643, -0.025375366, -0.046844482, -0.01638794, -0.07104492, -0.026535034, 0.029174805, 0.023025513, 0.011810303, 0.011260986, 0.015602112, 0.01727295, 0.038513184, 0.03225708, 0.08886719, 0.010551453, 0.012390137, 0.011642456, -0.022750854, -0.009727478, 0.030975342, -0.022369385, 0.018753052, -0.0055732727, -0.023712158, 0.026855469, 0.011505127, -0.008674622, -0.01158905, 0.003917694, -0.037109375, -0.002620697, -0.033599854, 0.014984131, 0.082458496, 0.02784729, 0.06262207, -0.05001831, -0.009719849, -0.0015163422, -0.030258179, -0.001663208, 0.029922485, -0.03829956, 0.010375977, -0.019821167, -0.019989014, -0.01675415, 0.020874023, 0.040222168, -0.03704834, -0.04147339, 0.029052734, 0.044067383, 0.030090332, -0.014152527, -0.043945312, 0.0032367706, 0.01725769, 0.019882202, 0.020614624, 0.010688782, -0.0026493073, 0.0032901764, 0.00006586313, -0.02748108, 0.009025574, 0.047912598, -0.018692017, 0.009468079, 0.0041007996, 0.026275635, -0.019622803, -0.03668213, 0.01210022, 0.0048217773, -0.068725586, 0.0012712479, 0.009925842, 0.047454834, 0.024215698, 0.071899414, 0.00038003922, -0.016937256, 0.009506226, -0.030685425, 0.04168701, 0.015541077, -0.007286072, 0.047180176, -0.053375244, -0.044891357, 0.0423584, -0.04522705, 0.06274414, -0.056671143, 0.013771057, -0.033996582, 0.06365967, -0.0055389404, -0.042022705, -0.037750244, -0.0032863617, -0.029205322, -0.0016584396, 0.0048179626, -0.02243042, -0.014205933, 0.0021343231, 0.015792847, 0.028259277, 0.0158844, 0.021255493, -0.05581665, -0.097839355, 0.034301758, 0.018356323, 0.04824829, 0.012481689, -0.017059326, -0.0141067505, 0.004863739, -0.016433716, -0.024032593, -0.015655518, -0.027770996, -0.026626587, -0.013435364, 0.012451172, 0.0074310303, -0.021377563, -0.017410278, -0.023239136, 0.015090942, -0.03567505, -0.01689148, 0.003736496, -0.047302246, 0.0006494522, 0.007045746, -0.036621094, 0.030456543, 0.04067993, 0.00806427, -0.019546509, 0.03036499, -0.026763916, -0.068603516, -0.013435364, 0.025604248, 0.0013160706, -0.068359375, 0.014442444, 0.0047836304, 0.036987305, -0.042053223, -0.060058594, 0.030960083, -0.016220093, 0.0009174347, 0.06347656, 0.023513794, 0.028717041, 0.0055389404, 0.014350891, -0.0030021667, -0.06085205, -0.042755127, 0.002380371, 0.0061836243, 0.043518066, 0.009239197, -0.011581421, 0.035949707, -0.027191162, 0.018707275, 0.030883789, -0.028839111, 0.03390503, -0.0067596436, 0.03149414, -0.01449585, 0.0022888184, -0.005718231, -0.02357483, 0.013092041, 0.021270752, -0.017807007, 0.0047950745, -0.036071777, 0.0925293, -0.03982544, -0.030426025, -0.009017944, 0.048339844, -0.0026607513, 0.05267334, -0.04196167, -0.010513306, 0.006969452, -0.011421204, -0.010513306, -0.023712158, 0.012939453, 0.0020313263, -0.0021915436, -0.026519775, -0.05239868, 0.0023117065, -0.03564453, 0.012237549, -0.035186768, 0.031311035, -0.018127441, -0.0070991516, -0.0014543533, 0.035369873, 0.00009059906, -0.008682251, -0.066345215, -0.025131226, 0.035461426, -0.03277588 ], "summary": [ 0.00027894974, -0.011520386, 0.03717041, 0.018585205, -0.040802002, 0.018478394, -0.04852295, -0.07556152, -0.028274536, -0.0011167526, 0.003047943, -0.0047912598, -0.031219482, -0.02835083, 0.0010290146, -0.03829956, -0.008842468, 0.020431519, -0.012016296, -0.050872803, -0.00025629997, -0.054779053, -0.008651733, 0.006374359, 0.031677246, -0.04473877, 0.03125, 0.02973938, 0.035003662, 0.02583313, 0.0234375, -0.057159424, 0.0038547516, 0.005104065, 0.011947632, -0.026016235, -0.010520935, 0.020874023, 0.0002975464, 0.0028514862, -0.004611969, -0.0062713623, 0.0769043, -0.058563232, 0.020446777, 0.03869629, -0.010848999, -0.025619507, 0.03515625, -0.022384644, -0.024261475, 0.043273926, -0.013038635, -0.004135132, -0.008995056, -0.005844116, -0.019805908, -0.06549072, -0.00056409836, 0.044128418, 0.059295654, -0.009811401, -0.0059928894, 0.0003941059, -0.0023059845, -0.00027799606, 0.044677734, 0.0068969727, 0.027053833, -0.0014762878, -0.0056266785, 0.03604126, 0.02029419, -0.05215454, -0.0121154785, 0.056549072, 0.02947998, 0.042388916, -0.00018048286, -0.04321289, 0.02798462, -0.016098022, 0.037322998, -0.01625061, 0.0042877197, 0.0073623657, 0.0022277832, -0.012924194, 0.0032100677, -0.0000024437904, -0.0072364807, -0.05291748, 0.009803772, 0.054016113, -0.0030002594, 0.0013446808, -0.050720215, -0.045928955, -0.0045776367, -0.018493652, -0.0040283203, -0.008598328, -0.027709961, 0.010604858, 0.0006752014, 0.004924774, -0.029434204, 0.009864807, 0.045898438, 0.04257202, -0.009597778, 0.00038266182, -0.018417358, -0.052581787, 0.042877197, 0.04550171, -0.018096924, 0.08453369, 0.020507812, 0.049224854, -0.037475586, -0.015380859, -0.013038635, 0.048858643, -0.011764526, -0.010734558, 0.019454956, 0.021377563, 0.006942749, 0.05758667, 0.012321472, -0.011268616, -0.0791626, -0.030151367, -0.046936035, -0.010864258, 0.047332764, -0.005367279, -0.037078857, 0.026107788, 0.013549805, -0.012931824, -0.0030612946, -0.029281616, -0.043395996, 0.021713257, 0.03668213, 0.025939941, -0.019378662, -0.0925293, 0.018615723, -0.0113220215, 0.033325195, -0.016677856, -0.04260254, -0.03186035, -0.06109619, -0.011642456, 0.0098724365, -0.008071899, 0.007358551, -0.0033283234, -0.010787964, 0.0074691772, -0.022369385, 0.007881165, 0.0087890625, -0.004142761, 0.008026123, -0.012023926, 0.028686523, 0.020568848, -0.04925537, -0.0073127747, 0.01763916, -0.02558899, -0.041229248, -0.034820557, 0.016159058, 0.022384644, -0.0015182495, -0.014839172, -0.008453369, 0.032348633, -0.05819702, 0.028961182, 0.0009622574, 0.07940674, 0.04876709, 0.004173279, -0.015472412, -0.015281677, 0.01802063, 0.0231781, -0.00844574, -0.0074005127, -0.037750244, 0.014663696, -0.035095215, -0.019927979, -0.0042495728, 0.025131226, -0.0236969, -0.016693115, -0.050323486, 0.0006804466, -0.00957489, 0.036010742, 0.009292603, 0.041229248, 0.018371582, 0.032196045, -0.04852295, 0.013656616, -0.0018634796, -0.017700195, 0.03652954, 0.009490967, -0.038238525, -0.03778076, -0.03491211, -0.025436401, -0.033447266, 0.0859375, -0.004131317, 0.021331787, -0.0002822876, 0.025009155, 0.08459473, 0.041259766, 0.09790039, -0.07885742, 0.027404785, 0.030731201, -0.012504578, -0.042022705, 0.01222229, -0.09411621, 0.038146973, 0.05947876, 0.029159546, -0.009155273, -0.033813477, -0.03704834, -0.014526367, -0.01449585, 0.040405273, -0.03930664, -0.0021419525, 0.0026931763, 0.035095215, -0.0345459, 0.027389526, 0.006095886, -0.005760193, 0.01058197, -0.0044670105, 0.0062065125, 0.017044067, 0.02532959, -0.02558899, 0.055541992, 0.039276123, 0.0039405823, -0.0005469322, -0.072265625, -0.023239136, -0.033325195, 0.010231018, -0.051239014, 0.026916504, -0.053649902, 0.010314941, 0.0039711, -0.043792725, 0.020187378, -0.020004272, 0.01436615, 0.0043754578, -0.0121154785, 0.019515991, 0.014076233, -0.013511658, 0.0022583008, 0.038513184, 0.007904053, 0.01348114, 0.0635376, -0.024154663, 0.098083496, 0.078125, 0.07324219, 0.043762207, -0.019958496, -0.056518555, 0.060577393, 0.013084412, -0.0146865845, 0.011024475, -0.0132751465, -0.029220581, 0.050323486, 0.04159546, -0.043548584, -0.00014352798, -0.0005002022, 0.0014781952, -0.017745972, -0.030227661, 0.0008339882, -0.05429077, -0.003944397, 0.03643799, 0.035003662, 0.02947998, 0.0047073364, -0.007572174, 0.07067871, 0.018493652, 0.036468506, 0.05441284, 0.046783447, 0.00034356117, -0.02267456, 0.02192688, -0.031707764, -0.04840088, -0.026641846, -0.060333252, -0.018417358, 0.0041618347, -0.06225586, -0.041290283, -0.035064697, -0.0011730194, 0.014564514, 0.0128479, -0.004535675, 0.008163452, 0.012489319, 0.067871094, 0.020202637, 0.007083893, -0.011871338, -0.03640747, -0.008300781, 0.049041748, -0.006126404, -0.025268555, 0.017669678, 0.016845703, -0.024810791, -0.0051002502, -0.009170532, 0.022232056, -0.029174805, -0.004043579, 0.037109375, 0.031799316, -0.04006958, -0.011192322, 0.0064964294, -0.018966675, -0.041137695, -0.034820557, -0.005870819, 0.00013005733, 0.019210815, 0.022781372, 0.015449524, -0.015304565, 0.036621094, -0.051879883, 0.0074424744, 0.022750854, 0.011558533, 0.07458496, -0.01197052, -0.033203125, 0.038757324, -0.0046653748, 0.03024292, -0.013549805, 0.044891357, 0.052856445, 0.009536743, -0.0211792, 0.01802063, 0.029663086, 0.004776001, -0.024627686, -0.011161804, 0.05239868, -0.05340576, -0.03564453, 0.015945435, -0.018737793, -0.035980225, 0.064575195, -0.0021591187, 0.03604126, -0.006969452, 0.008354187, 0.0055732727, -0.053588867, 0.043762207, -0.016220093, 0.007385254, -0.0051612854, 0.040039062, -0.0055770874, -0.04522705, 0.0039634705, -0.045318604, 0.031982422, -0.013900757, -0.042175293, -0.00004196167, 0.009353638, -0.025268555, -0.012168884, -0.014587402, -0.022994995, -0.0019340515, -0.030044556, 0.012756348, -0.02835083, 0.022842407, -0.052490234, 0.030380249, -0.003736496, -0.0042495728, -0.005138397, 0.0021400452, -0.0146102905, -0.015304565, -0.013755798, -0.003572464, 0.018127441, -0.031829834, -0.027450562, -0.022125244, -0.04083252, 0.021133423, -0.016311646, -0.01260376, -0.01398468, -0.028366089, 0.019515991, 0.042236328, -0.0234375, -0.01689148, 0.035461426, 0.02218628, -0.046875, -0.017288208, -0.053955078, -0.0012283325, 0.030395508, -0.024307251, -0.029281616, -0.014587402, -0.028427124, -0.019302368, 0.022338867, 0.021911621, 0.00096559525, 0.0018548965, -0.017410278, -0.0032138824, 0.021514893, -0.034973145, -0.03967285, -0.0063323975, -0.0070228577, 0.0015821457, 0.022277832, -0.015388489, 0.04727173, 0.0069236755, -0.050811768, 0.020614624, -0.008987427, -0.016555786, -0.03366089, 0.023162842, 0.0044517517, 0.03363037, 0.0036849976, 0.022888184, 0.0095825195, 0.0064849854, 0.037994385, -0.025787354, -0.0039901733, 0.0016012192, -0.02949524, 0.058776855, -0.026428223, -0.05984497, 0.02619934, -0.047088623, 0.0062828064, 0.031921387, -0.01159668, 0.01411438, 0.025131226, 0.0231781, 0.02406311, -0.005607605, 0.017089844, -0.030822754, -0.029159546, 0.03955078, -0.05783081, 0.020980835, -0.026184082, -0.017150879, -0.025009155, 0.024108887, -0.0046920776, 0.049224854, 0.007858276, 0.020614624, -0.018814087, -0.014793396, -0.013061523, 0.03579712, -0.0064811707, -0.025604248, 0.021408081, 0.015388489, -0.037139893, 0.007949829, 0.003036499, 0.009567261, -0.03753662, -0.005367279, 0.031219482, 0.030700684, -0.048919678, -0.035461426, 0.0135269165, 0.06677246, 0.005973816, 0.037750244, 0.031173706, 0.038360596, -0.029876709, 0.003227234, 0.02168274, 0.018081665, -0.077697754, -0.001742363, 0.012710571, 0.023513794, -0.05407715, 0.015525818, -0.01914978, 0.02279663, -0.0045700073, 0.019180298, -0.02468872, -0.0010175705, 0.05026245, 0.006576538, 0.000726223, -0.043762207, -0.028640747, -0.0184021, -0.07702637, -0.052581787, -0.083496094, -0.039367676, -0.018463135, 0.024307251, -0.035064697, 0.02557373, -0.0036716461, 0.03466797, 0.048583984, 0.0037441254, -0.07598877, 0.013870239, -0.03616333, 0.00027489662, 0.0028858185, -0.028305054, -0.0066566467, 0.00030326843, 0.029373169, 0.0008893013, -0.010177612, -0.08685303, -0.014015198, -0.023834229, 0.04611206, 0.02909851, -0.038208008, 0.0047798157, -0.011917114, 0.014160156, 0.008644104, -0.0055122375, -0.0034675598, 0.029373169, 0.0076179504, 0.014945984, 0.032562256, 0.04119873, -0.0047416687, -0.045806885, 0.0077323914, 0.040863037, 0.015991211, -0.0259552, 0.0552063, -0.012138367, -0.05429077, -0.027069092, 0.005542755, 0.00843811, 0.020828247, -0.020492554, -0.02696228, 0.0007343292, 0.024169922, 0.017974854, -0.02027893, 0.018356323, 0.0053138733, 0.00089883804, -0.018936157, -0.05731201, -0.003982544, 0.052459717, 0.0072631836, -0.0037975311, -0.038024902, -0.0037269592, 0.0043907166, 0.051696777, 0.03213501, -0.04663086, 0.026992798, -0.019073486, -0.011138916, -0.014915466, 0.0050964355, -0.017318726, -0.009727478, -0.0047187805, 0.029769897, -0.018341064, -0.033233643, 0.021774292, -0.03353882, -0.026809692, 0.016647339, -0.03314209, -0.02571106, 0.037872314, -0.06506348, 0.038604736, 0.057617188, 0.021850586, -0.02368164, 0.0071411133, -0.030517578, 0.040649414, -0.03427124, -0.04876709, 0.049804688, -0.003917694, 0.007160187, 0.029266357, 0.0015354156, -0.006664276, 0.016082764, -0.0022010803, -0.022094727, -0.026947021, 0.076416016, 0.043121338, -0.05130005, 0.020446777, 0.0026721954, -0.017410278, 0.025634766, 0.037139893, -0.014129639, 0.012428284, 0.046417236, 0.0390625, -0.010932922, 0.04385376, 0.0019664764, -0.04309082, -0.01914978, -0.023208618, 0.044189453, -0.0154418945, -0.014762878, -0.040161133, -0.028152466, -0.018966675, -0.016220093, 0.018859863, 0.013442993, 0.016204834, -0.006954193, -0.02357483, -0.018554688, -0.01953125, 0.032592773, -0.010070801, -0.012535095, -0.0087509155, -0.028076172, 0.013259888, 0.024154663, 0.010147095, 0.015419006, -0.021316528, 0.014701843, -0.02973938, -0.0058937073, 0.041168213, 0.009025574, 0.022476196, -0.004550934, 0.03567505, -0.04397583, -0.008026123, 0.056152344, -0.05392456, 0.016998291, -0.021255493, -0.0026168823, 0.0048828125, -0.0067329407, 0.0037517548, 0.003944397, -0.00054883957, 0.003074646, -0.03756714, 0.0054397583, -0.020629883, -0.030899048, -0.016021729, 0.04336548, -0.04043579, -0.0019836426, -0.023223877, 0.0024261475, -0.033050537, 0.024490356, 0.0048103333, 0.0031795502, -0.023101807, -0.045410156, 0.0063591003, -0.0074920654, 0.017333984, 0.042236328, 0.056762695, -0.024719238, -0.033203125, -0.0413208, -0.026107788, -0.008483887, 0.026901245, -0.04208374, -0.095458984, 0.062347412, -0.013641357, 0.0013990402, -0.0099487305, -0.014503479, 0.029571533, 0.024490356, 0.030197144, -0.030151367, -0.014152527, -0.014381409, 0.010826111, 0.02003479, 0.0013990402, -0.018096924, -0.01979065, 0.024047852, 0.030273438, 0.029449463, -0.02420044, -0.04067993, 0.015823364, 0.08648682, -0.014122009, -0.008979797, 0.013626099, 0.038024902, -0.011665344, -0.06829834, -0.04977417, -0.044769287, -0.032073975, -0.015365601, -0.010612488, 0.0052337646, 0.050201416, 0.011856079, -0.004699707, 0.012062073, -0.014328003, 0.068237305, 0.03765869, 0.035736084, 0.020065308, 0.023452759, -0.049102783, -0.003250122, 0.028823853, -0.03086853, 0.035308838, 0.013847351, -0.038330078, 0.023544312, 0.025360107, -0.027435303, -0.05218506, 0.017547607, -0.0423584, -0.033599854, -0.0206604, -0.007045746, 0.027038574, 0.0090789795, 0.10827637, -0.03265381, 0.0016069412, -0.03427124, -0.022338867, -0.02420044, -0.04763794, 0.03186035, -0.020095825, -0.021652222, 0.012062073, 0.0003144741, 0.04019165, 0.018417358, -0.01902771, 0.029891968, 0.009719849, -0.012374878, -0.012161255, -0.040039062, -0.05810547, 0.010536194, 0.0126953125, -0.043029785, 0.035247803, -0.03744507, -0.0009598732, -0.0099105835, 0.056427002, 0.009803772, 0.020141602, 0.04736328, 0.022094727, 0.02029419, 0.02067566, -0.00018596649, -0.0037937164, -0.025375366, 0.0036697388, 0.0067329407, -0.0063095093, 0.035705566, -0.021774292, 0.02748108, 0.030807495, 0.044647217, -0.04714966, 0.015853882, 0.014862061, 0.0034885406, 0.054595947, -0.008308411, 0.020050049, 0.029083252, -0.022827148, -0.006149292, 0.05883789, 0.01663208, 0.08874512, -0.055603027, 0.027893066, -0.027252197, 0.019683838, -0.026321411, -0.008720398, -0.011390686, -0.010635376, -0.031921387, 0.037994385, 0.04107666, -0.026382446, 0.037475586, -0.0104904175, -0.05718994, 0.03152466, 0.028869629, 0.036712646, -0.049804688, 0.001914978, 0.0680542, 0.06750488, 0.10473633, 0.0131073, -0.015792847, 0.0069084167, 0.01272583, -0.0105896, -0.03338623, -0.011459351, -0.018630981, 0.0093688965, -0.067993164, 0.050933838, 0.031982422, -0.014305115, -0.022705078, -0.06994629, 0.0107421875, -0.028198242, 0.027023315, 0.03463745, -0.0309906, 0.036376953, 0.031585693, -0.018936157, 0.05895996, -0.020584106, 0.022781372, -0.0085372925, 0.044677734, -0.02381897, -0.052856445, -0.02128601, -0.009635925, 0.019882202, -0.029876709, -0.010124207, -0.009757996, 0.02104187, -0.049468994, -0.007686615, 0.022720337, 0.05508423, 0.0129470825, -0.0050315857, -0.03414917, -0.0025463104, 0.03086853, 0.05834961, 0.0020313263, -0.027053833, -0.051086426, 0.032440186, 0.049926758, -0.0035076141, -0.019073486, -0.023895264, -0.0134887695, -0.05999756, 0.0143966675, 0.025390625, 0.02784729, 0.022476196, -0.017028809, 0.024032593, -0.03503418, -0.06573486, -0.02470398, -0.041046143, 0.035949707, 0.0262146, -0.01473999, 0.015701294, -0.0178833, 0.07684326, -0.010871887, -0.0009741783, -0.025375366, 0.010124207, 0.00014853477, 0.0028381348, -0.0044174194, -0.009315491, 0.0071144104, -0.008506775, 0.0030403137, -0.011497498, -0.011306763, -0.014183044, -0.0149002075, -0.031280518, -0.027755737, -0.027557373, -0.029220581, 0.016571045, -0.037261963, 0.01612854, 0.0068855286, -0.009277344, 0.029449463, 0.008239746, 0.01234436, 0.016815186, -0.016174316, 0.02017212, -0.011756897, -0.0016489029 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2010.14226v6
Range-Net: A High Precision Streaming SVD for Big Data Applications
Gurpreet Singh, Soumyajit Gupta, Matthew Lease, Clint Dawson
math.NA, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NA
In a Big Data setting computing the dominant SVD factors is restrictive due to the main memory requirements. Recently introduced streaming Randomized SVD schemes work under the restrictive assumption that the singular value spectrum of the data has exponential decay. This is seldom true for any practical data. Although these methods are claimed to be applicable to scientific computations due to associated tail-energy error bounds, the approximation errors in the singular vectors and values are high when the aforementioned assumption does not hold. Furthermore from a practical perspective, oversampling can still be memory intensive or worse can exceed the feature dimension of the data. To address these issues, we present Range-Net as an alternative to randomized SVD that satisfies the tail-energy lower bound given by Eckart-Young-Mirsky (EYM) theorem. Range-Net is a deterministic two-stage neural optimization approach with random initialization, where the main memory requirement depends explicitly on the feature dimension and desired rank, independent of the sample dimension. The data samples are read in a streaming setting with the network minimization problem converging to the desired rank-r approximation. Range-Net is fully interpretable where all the network outputs and weights have a specific meaning. We provide theoretical guarantees that Range-Net extracted SVD factors satisfy EYM tail-energy lower bound at machine precision. Our numerical experiments on real data at various scales confirms this bound. A comparison against the state of the art streaming Randomized SVD shows that Range-Net accuracy is better by six orders of magnitude while being memory efficient.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2010.14226v6
"2021-03-18T18:46:17"
"2020-10-27T15:42:59"
{ "title": [ -0.011764526, -0.01449585, -0.04550171, -0.0892334, 0.026657104, -0.00299263, -0.012992859, 0.01864624, 0.02998352, 0.02468872, -0.026260376, -0.021133423, -0.013305664, -0.02293396, -0.062164307, -0.0107421875, 0.022079468, 0.013008118, -0.008049011, -0.021774292, -0.009635925, -0.025634766, 0.045410156, 0.08569336, 0.02027893, 0.0061302185, -0.105163574, 0.0010766983, -0.047210693, -0.028320312, -0.015113831, 0.051940918, 0.03213501, 0.03262329, -0.01008606, 0.0579834, -0.06048584, 0.048217773, 0.021850586, -0.0015439987, 0.023803711, -0.0009551048, -0.0018358231, -0.023330688, -0.025863647, 0.027770996, -0.058685303, -0.019317627, -0.036468506, 0.07128906, 0.018814087, 0.007637024, -0.012619019, 0.064453125, 0.02003479, -0.02418518, 0.0029773712, -0.004501343, 0.020141602, 0.05532837, 0.002773285, -0.008682251, 0.0075035095, -0.014793396, -0.062316895, 0.014282227, 0.043273926, 0.004169464, 0.06109619, -0.03250122, -0.055633545, 0.037750244, -0.007205963, 0.0317688, -0.021347046, -0.02796936, 0.037506104, 0.014839172, 0.030761719, 0.009208679, -0.021591187, -0.019378662, 0.015220642, -0.02947998, 0.009567261, -0.026123047, -0.027435303, -0.0054969788, -0.006160736, -0.04925537, 0.000020980835, -0.0014533997, -0.011779785, 0.027893066, -0.02229309, -0.024520874, -0.047576904, -0.0046691895, 0.010429382, -0.00006955862, 0.002729416, -0.007949829, -0.021209717, -0.022491455, 0.014450073, 0.03717041, -0.025970459, -0.039489746, 0.011955261, 0.032958984, -0.008415222, 0.020874023, 0.012908936, 0.02116394, -0.0039482117, -0.0056915283, 0.015525818, -0.017715454, 0.005180359, -0.0008044243, -0.013832092, -0.02268982, 0.028778076, -0.019012451, 0.048736572, 0.010749817, -0.046569824, -0.005645752, -0.04248047, 0.01348114, 0.016799927, 0.0496521, -0.08001709, -0.081848145, -0.070129395, 0.027923584, -0.02168274, -0.02142334, 0.0023059845, -0.002336502, 0.00046896935, -0.04083252, 0.0023994446, -0.005264282, 0.028305054, -0.014625549, 0.058013916, 0.01826477, -0.026565552, 0.030441284, -0.008132935, 0.052612305, 0.022979736, -0.012863159, -0.04824829, -0.007820129, -0.11895752, -0.0001553297, 0.017608643, 0.0058021545, 0.008529663, -0.006011963, -0.029907227, -0.003736496, 0.014076233, 0.013076782, 0.014442444, 0.02406311, 0.0079422, 0.0048713684, -0.025924683, 0.012908936, 0.0473938, -0.0050201416, -0.009307861, 0.01625061, 0.02746582, 0.009361267, 0.042907715, -0.030807495, 0.0040283203, -0.016403198, 0.02671814, 0.0368042, -0.057525635, -0.024047852, -0.007118225, -0.0076179504, 0.05368042, 0.007019043, -0.03152466, 0.030029297, -0.046020508, -0.027038574, -0.049316406, -0.038238525, 0.025787354, 0.014755249, -0.015701294, 0.03137207, 0.01322937, -0.0034236908, -0.022247314, -0.011543274, -0.027954102, -0.03314209, -0.011703491, 0.022644043, -0.0037975311, 0.05899048, 0.041381836, 0.013023376, -0.041046143, 0.024810791, 0.0036716461, -0.06616211, 0.021896362, -0.039031982, -0.04107666, -0.019470215, -0.05215454, 0.0146102905, -0.03817749, 0.055541992, -0.00041866302, 0.024932861, 0.0074310303, -0.012870789, 0.046936035, 0.027420044, 0.08404541, -0.059265137, 0.032928467, 0.023361206, 0.021713257, -0.017486572, 0.016403198, -0.00025820732, 0.02319336, 0.0056419373, 0.016204834, -0.007129669, -0.029220581, -0.012786865, 0.022033691, -0.010307312, 0.020828247, -0.0061912537, 0.028335571, 0.011924744, 0.041748047, 0.017547607, 0.03930664, -0.030593872, 0.022155762, 0.060913086, 0.0073509216, 0.02217102, -0.022155762, 0.031799316, -0.0006380081, 0.051605225, 0.016326904, 0.012619019, -0.06695557, 0.01751709, -0.025741577, 0.023971558, 0.013031006, 0.0115356445, 0.026245117, 0.00015258789, 0.0035858154, 0.0068244934, 0.010223389, -0.042266846, 0.010261536, 0.0099487305, -0.033691406, -0.052856445, -0.026107788, -0.0368042, 0.020111084, -0.00029325485, 0.028015137, -0.02748108, 0.033477783, -0.028015137, -0.030822754, -0.018951416, 0.034210205, 0.039489746, 0.008728027, -0.004924774, -0.00894165, 0.0104904175, 0.08239746, 0.08880615, -0.029632568, 0.027160645, -0.059051514, -0.010131836, -0.017578125, -0.009613037, 0.0007662773, 0.057678223, 0.03817749, 0.0032157898, -0.010543823, 0.011947632, -0.038757324, -0.014755249, 0.012451172, -0.044830322, -0.018753052, -0.037139893, -0.011940002, -0.03366089, -0.031585693, -0.012199402, 0.117370605, -0.022705078, -0.017242432, -0.005241394, -0.011276245, -0.052703857, 0.0035800934, -0.04824829, -0.02243042, 0.024505615, 0.033233643, 0.023849487, -0.05230713, 0.0024471283, -0.004234314, 0.017044067, -0.011489868, -0.04638672, -0.03012085, 0.019195557, 0.0058898926, -0.014694214, 0.030410767, -0.07446289, -0.028182983, -0.046875, -0.01184845, 0.01574707, -0.049224854, -0.027770996, 0.06530762, -0.033416748, -0.047698975, -0.019134521, 0.029678345, -0.010612488, 0.0008420944, -0.016525269, 0.0065307617, -0.03390503, 0.009765625, 0.045318604, 0.0028133392, -0.042907715, -0.03756714, -0.05609131, 0.008171082, -0.015602112, -0.015335083, 0.04144287, -0.025344849, -0.02255249, -0.04748535, -0.01802063, -0.03527832, 0.013885498, -0.019729614, -0.04348755, -0.018005371, -0.029678345, -0.011993408, 0.009307861, -0.024108887, 0.016784668, 0.10461426, 0.013580322, 0.031219482, 0.004611969, 0.06536865, -0.000579834, -0.0013885498, -0.030334473, 0.034301758, 0.0069389343, 0.0057258606, -0.0065612793, 0.0024757385, 0.02758789, -0.06719971, -0.0038795471, 0.057403564, 0.020111084, -0.024551392, 0.038116455, -0.05770874, 0.001414299, 0.029510498, -0.011940002, 0.036956787, 0.010360718, 0.036468506, 0.01725769, 0.042388916, -0.016799927, 0.010848999, -0.055603027, -0.05480957, 0.040222168, -0.025741577, -0.06402588, -0.008468628, -0.007209778, -0.036743164, -0.025222778, -0.0118637085, -0.0042495728, 0.02432251, 0.018722534, -0.0073051453, -0.0017528534, -0.0058937073, -0.03201294, 0.00011628866, -0.042938232, -0.0012407303, -0.02897644, -0.008331299, 0.04095459, 0.0014772415, 0.01638794, -0.031021118, -0.019989014, -0.018859863, 0.04827881, 0.005558014, -0.009063721, -0.02166748, -0.022018433, 0.044952393, 0.017242432, -0.02671814, -0.028289795, -0.00045657158, 0.013298035, -0.030471802, 0.01727295, 0.03555298, 0.014297485, -0.03289795, -0.011497498, 0.020263672, -0.016815186, -0.045776367, 0.01953125, 0.033081055, 0.03164673, -0.041656494, 0.031951904, -0.02243042, 0.01525116, 0.029464722, -0.0118255615, 0.0056762695, -0.013244629, -0.0017662048, -0.008773804, -0.013076782, 0.0007004738, 0.00015723705, -0.0040245056, -0.02104187, 0.005962372, -0.046966553, -0.035736084, 0.021987915, -0.014137268, -0.040405273, 0.00028419495, 0.016998291, -0.022064209, -0.037322998, -0.040405273, 0.03314209, -0.013633728, -0.007457733, 0.019042969, -0.026641846, -0.017562866, 0.019470215, -0.07763672, 0.013397217, 0.076293945, 0.025924683, 0.027267456, -0.0019388199, 0.040618896, 0.03152466, -0.034362793, -0.009155273, -0.04434204, 0.03994751, -0.052612305, -0.0128479, 0.05218506, -0.036621094, -0.012138367, 0.02609253, 0.043518066, -0.040222168, -0.011497498, 0.03414917, 0.023269653, -0.045288086, 0.042877197, 0.052337646, -0.019256592, -0.086364746, -0.015090942, -0.0028381348, 0.0059776306, -0.02218628, -0.035186768, 0.01360321, 0.022445679, 0.050201416, 0.04840088, -0.026290894, -0.004207611, 0.03111267, -0.012229919, -0.014228821, -0.0051078796, 0.010566711, 0.021194458, 0.028320312, -0.0107040405, 0.013305664, 0.010131836, -0.046447754, -0.003566742, -0.032409668, -0.0033473969, -0.077819824, -0.02243042, -0.036743164, -0.02468872, -0.009361267, 0.0050964355, -0.02468872, -0.0118637085, -0.008422852, -0.016586304, -0.028030396, 0.017227173, -0.023956299, 0.017791748, 0.010032654, -0.0057296753, 0.018432617, 0.0053977966, -0.011993408, -0.021636963, 0.07788086, 0.02331543, 0.03604126, -0.053588867, 0.005924225, 0.019622803, 0.028823853, 0.034362793, 0.024108887, -0.012908936, -0.04449463, -0.009498596, -0.017440796, -0.026535034, 0.034576416, -0.012680054, -0.013305664, -0.04055786, 0.01084137, -0.01322937, -0.006450653, -0.0034503937, -0.0065727234, 0.0005812645, 0.014228821, -0.009292603, 0.04650879, 0.00491333, 0.0067443848, 0.0001834631, 0.0099105835, -0.046875, -0.03363037, -0.0049057007, 0.051513672, -0.047943115, 0.033721924, 0.02281189, -0.0045776367, -0.054779053, 0.019500732, 0.07244873, 0.03189087, -0.04046631, 0.034576416, -0.010627747, -0.054504395, -0.05380249, -0.0074272156, -0.013420105, 0.04156494, -0.03564453, 0.029083252, -0.028503418, 0.04031372, 0.026611328, -0.003604889, -0.0030956268, -0.0072746277, 0.0036506653, -0.08129883, -0.087646484, -0.033477783, 0.09088135, -0.025131226, 0.0010795593, 0.011619568, 0.025177002, 0.016113281, 0.030288696, 0.010940552, 0.006336212, -0.012077332, -0.008720398, 0.0028152466, -0.019882202, -0.040283203, 0.010635376, -0.009590149, 0.01625061, -0.029571533, -0.0070228577, -0.058135986, -0.013145447, 0.015213013, 0.0077819824, 0.011276245, -0.06964111, 0.004562378, 0.03945923, 0.03793335, -0.001950264, 0.015625, 0.006134033, 0.029418945, 0.030273438, 0.015556335, 0.021911621, 0.022338867, -0.00932312, 0.012786865, 0.0035915375, -0.002166748, 0.006958008, 0.0020713806, -0.0013580322, -0.009140015, -0.030288696, 0.034942627, 0.027252197, -0.048034668, 0.034606934, -0.042755127, 0.03112793, -0.015457153, -0.00655365, 0.028518677, 0.006095886, -0.012123108, 0.007484436, 0.013046265, -0.041381836, -0.006855011, 0.018585205, -0.023101807, -0.030075073, 0.010787964, -0.02482605, 0.0070991516, -0.0009083748, 0.014709473, -0.019607544, 0.010467529, 0.035980225, -0.06878662, 0.0012016296, -0.008346558, 0.03439331, 0.029647827, -0.0033569336, -0.01763916, 0.012016296, -0.032592773, -0.0574646, -0.049591064, 0.00057935715, 0.018081665, 0.026123047, -0.031158447, -0.01550293, 0.0046424866, -0.019256592, 0.0284729, 0.003622055, -0.035827637, 0.00207901, 0.005554199, -0.008468628, -0.0025844574, 0.01210022, 0.024276733, 0.00021266937, -0.023529053, -0.035949707, 0.01285553, -0.00592041, -0.0231781, -0.02748108, -0.092285156, 0.01612854, 0.009803772, -0.0077438354, -0.016143799, 0.04360962, 0.027770996, 0.035980225, 0.012382507, -0.002626419, 0.039978027, 0.0033340454, -0.040985107, -0.011772156, 0.02947998, 0.006111145, 0.064453125, -0.043060303, -0.04940796, -0.022384644, -0.060913086, -0.024993896, -0.0010375977, 0.0206604, 0.0046653748, 0.015899658, -0.041748047, 0.031555176, -0.046417236, -0.023742676, -0.020217896, 0.02960205, -0.0048065186, -0.030822754, 0.008666992, -0.03955078, -0.005218506, -0.021255493, -0.0024490356, 0.0073776245, -0.012229919, 0.031234741, -0.021057129, -0.0042419434, -0.03466797, -0.034851074, 0.046844482, 0.01979065, -0.03363037, 0.054534912, -0.017150879, 0.059265137, 0.0027999878, 0.054107666, 0.03982544, -0.016571045, -0.02331543, 0.014183044, -0.011192322, -0.055511475, -0.06951904, -0.019256592, -0.044677734, -0.029632568, -0.006942749, -0.014884949, 0.025787354, 0.0038528442, 0.023956299, 0.055419922, -0.0007162094, 0.0446167, -0.028381348, 0.012420654, -0.04473877, 0.046844482, 0.033966064, -0.0019931793, 0.004699707, 0.0038166046, 0.009597778, 0.02810669, -0.01789856, 0.03366089, -0.009643555, -0.016555786, -0.0066490173, 0.03475952, 0.023483276, -0.002527237, 0.0045204163, -0.021377563, 0.027664185, 0.012069702, 0.039154053, 0.045898438, 0.035369873, 0.0030326843, -0.023880005, 0.0118637085, 0.012870789, -0.055664062, 0.048217773, 0.046844482, -0.057739258, 0.023590088, -0.022109985, -0.030197144, 0.010002136, 0.01638794, 0.029571533, -0.07196045, -0.05895996, 0.0055236816, 0.042266846, 0.023849487, -0.0062294006, -0.03353882, 0.005420685, 0.029678345, 0.01914978, 0.0071105957, 0.01626587, 0.019607544, 0.010467529, -0.018920898, -0.039093018, 0.02168274, 0.004737854, 0.023284912, 0.041107178, -0.023849487, 0.028549194, -0.017852783, -0.040649414, 0.016357422, -0.0049209595, -0.052490234, -0.019851685, 0.066589355, 0.04244995, 0.024795532, 0.06665039, 0.01889038, -0.01638794, -0.0035686493, -0.033416748, -0.0024528503, 0.017211914, -0.042877197, 0.022735596, -0.027145386, -0.020187378, 0.0357666, -0.04763794, 0.020843506, -0.05987549, 0.015159607, -0.013412476, 0.025787354, 0.0064735413, -0.044677734, -0.013130188, -0.0141067505, -0.032592773, 0.0021839142, 0.004196167, 0.010803223, -0.051330566, 0.0046463013, 0.05984497, 0.015159607, -0.0013284683, -0.0087890625, -0.020462036, -0.06542969, -0.013450623, -0.013969421, 0.026870728, 0.005634308, -0.015449524, -0.033355713, 0.005332947, 0.004673004, 0.03062439, -0.009475708, 0.03062439, -0.051483154, -0.031707764, 0.017486572, 0.016204834, -0.00945282, -0.018081665, -0.01902771, -0.00048327446, -0.03262329, 0.031433105, 0.020858765, -0.052246094, -0.047058105, 0.0072288513, -0.018249512, 0.057800293, 0.010055542, 0.00894928, -0.012428284, 0.023361206, -0.008430481, -0.03918457, -0.0012197495, 0.022766113, -0.0059280396, -0.08215332, 0.0109939575, 0.041290283, 0.036834717, -0.021377563, 0.010559082, 0.06335449, 0.02885437, 0.0052261353, 0.06311035, -0.014816284, -0.0095825195, 0.033355713, 0.046966553, 0.028518677, -0.029342651, -0.029373169, -0.054473877, 0.029693604, 0.0418396, -0.007434845, -0.0012655258, 0.05831909, 0.010032654, -0.00630188, 0.018798828, -0.002588272, -0.004459381, 0.01133728, 0.031219482, -0.016403198, 0.0046424866, 0.0045394897, -0.021942139, 0.0048942566, 0.0043258667, -0.017303467, 0.0021305084, -0.040924072, 0.04675293, 0.011940002, -0.08319092, 0.0289917, 0.018875122, 0.026290894, 0.007358551, -0.0052604675, -0.044006348, -0.010383606, -0.02796936, -0.0015764236, -0.014801025, 0.019424438, -0.06048584, -0.0040779114, -0.047973633, -0.018432617, 0.019546509, -0.035369873, 0.07092285, -0.05053711, -0.015296936, -0.04510498, -0.03363037, -0.0030975342, -0.002603531, -0.01638794, -0.034454346, -0.05722046, -0.027267456, 0.034118652, -0.012664795 ], "summary": [ 0.036499023, -0.035247803, 0.008712769, -0.050109863, -0.025466919, 0.002527237, -0.007789612, 0.005683899, 0.016845703, 0.018096924, -0.022064209, -0.028411865, -0.022201538, -0.030151367, -0.02748108, -0.046966553, 0.02067566, 0.0072402954, 0.00806427, -0.024841309, 0.0184021, -0.0071907043, 0.000166893, 0.09039307, 0.008331299, 0.035217285, -0.04940796, 0.014198303, -0.010879517, 0.018798828, 0.0011100769, -0.0012569427, -0.00079631805, 0.034606934, 0.00035953522, 0.02079773, -0.04284668, 0.038238525, 0.03842163, -0.010192871, 0.0071907043, 0.0025043488, 0.079711914, -0.018600464, 0.018600464, 0.015975952, -0.025863647, -0.058807373, -0.017974854, 0.068359375, 0.003408432, 0.0059661865, -0.023513794, 0.06161499, -0.00066041946, -0.020568848, -0.023498535, -0.034332275, 0.0025959015, 0.042022705, 0.029769897, 0.007286072, 0.010192871, -0.011276245, -0.02998352, 0.0236969, 0.082458496, -0.019515991, 0.02758789, -0.02468872, -0.02267456, 0.023254395, 0.009468079, 0.0074501038, -0.005001068, 0.006336212, 0.0015640259, 0.013252258, 0.01725769, -0.0059280396, -0.0501709, -0.012542725, 0.00995636, -0.054626465, -0.029830933, -0.039001465, -0.03579712, 0.028564453, 0.03930664, -0.023590088, 0.00087451935, 0.020980835, -0.027145386, 0.041625977, 0.0074386597, -0.049682617, -0.029769897, -0.07354736, 0.036712646, 0.008430481, 0.01663208, -0.032684326, 0.010513306, 0.0004248619, 0.0062026978, 0.021530151, -0.019042969, -0.02609253, 0.021499634, 0.020477295, -0.013038635, 0.007522583, -0.00440979, -0.017852783, -0.028015137, 0.004562378, 0.009925842, 0.018173218, 0.022384644, 0.029144287, -0.012809753, 0.013542175, 0.016601562, -0.029922485, 0.022598267, 0.0074157715, -0.020751953, -0.020584106, -0.004081726, 0.054504395, -0.0010690689, 0.016082764, -0.03930664, -0.06378174, -0.06896973, -0.019088745, -0.015640259, -0.029281616, 0.013633728, -0.03967285, 0.038116455, -0.032043457, 0.00017821789, 0.0287323, 0.056854248, 0.020233154, 0.021408081, 0.0055351257, 0.023727417, 0.04046631, -0.010276794, 0.053955078, 0.034332275, -0.02557373, -0.011131287, -0.0635376, -0.041259766, -0.019989014, 0.047210693, -0.02758789, 0.0035572052, -0.014907837, -0.041259766, 0.009307861, -0.022033691, 0.019470215, 0.03933716, 0.013084412, 0.006855011, -0.037841797, 0.006099701, -0.012939453, 0.0019569397, -0.0068740845, 0.0093688965, 0.01763916, -0.028701782, 0.006149292, 0.025482178, -0.022949219, -0.00018429756, -0.03125, 0.00472641, 0.045288086, -0.03540039, -0.010002136, -0.027297974, -0.007686615, 0.06427002, -0.0068969727, -0.009262085, 0.007270813, -0.008033752, -0.016845703, -0.017959595, -0.024124146, -0.02859497, -0.0073547363, -0.02268982, 0.030944824, 0.07519531, -0.0006661415, 0.0038604736, -0.03250122, -0.035308838, -0.03286743, 0.00079774857, 0.0096206665, -0.022262573, 0.023162842, 0.020828247, -0.009063721, -0.024154663, 0.03829956, 0.012176514, -0.039916992, 0.035888672, -0.038482666, -0.021255493, -0.025985718, -0.040863037, 0.046447754, -0.05871582, 0.04815674, 0.016189575, -0.0020008087, -0.0007443428, -0.013427734, 0.021774292, 0.0032081604, 0.053985596, -0.012451172, -0.011558533, 0.059509277, 0.03173828, 0.007820129, 0.084106445, 0.006134033, 0.029556274, -0.017700195, 0.039398193, 0.027862549, -0.025650024, -0.048736572, 0.007633209, -0.0067710876, 0.03756714, -0.05456543, -0.019561768, -0.01386261, 0.032440186, 0.0033454895, 0.03817749, -0.024780273, 0.0027065277, 0.03778076, -0.0021305084, 0.053527832, -0.02192688, 0.017700195, -0.01008606, 0.06414795, 0.04272461, 0.008399963, -0.042236328, -0.01499176, -0.025009155, -0.012390137, 0.009971619, -0.033294678, 0.018417358, -0.028625488, -0.0048065186, -0.008560181, -0.055511475, -0.048034668, -0.012458801, 0.035003662, -0.020065308, -0.042053223, -0.029449463, -0.04714966, 0.004322052, -0.0018091202, 0.03503418, -0.037841797, 0.04623413, -0.0057868958, -0.0103302, 0.044433594, 0.038909912, 0.06970215, 0.038909912, -0.011146545, -0.021820068, 0.04034424, 0.0011558533, 0.048675537, -0.032806396, -0.016113281, -0.023635864, 0.004890442, -0.021972656, -0.0146102905, 0.01008606, 0.02381897, 0.04650879, -0.005039215, 0.015731812, -0.014442444, -0.0050315857, -0.012001038, 0.037139893, -0.00012034178, 0.00484848, 0.009674072, -0.02520752, 0.020965576, -0.03378296, 0.005794525, 0.15856934, 0.008773804, 0.030014038, 0.013793945, -0.013534546, -0.08758545, 0.06439209, -0.04171753, 0.0158844, -0.039276123, -0.029388428, -0.03765869, -0.06201172, 0.0039711, 0.02218628, 0.015426636, 0.0065727234, -0.046691895, -0.036743164, 0.009986877, -0.013916016, -0.018615723, 0.024017334, -0.050720215, -0.0635376, -0.005207062, -0.003238678, 0.0022468567, -0.03463745, -0.020629883, 0.04373169, -0.030517578, -0.043640137, 0.012016296, -0.011581421, 0.026306152, 0.04852295, -0.00566864, 0.006641388, -0.04748535, -0.016098022, 0.049346924, -0.012397766, -0.03942871, -0.021408081, -0.055999756, -0.00491333, 0.010971069, 0.0009007454, 0.014556885, 0.035125732, 0.017440796, -0.04434204, -0.029388428, -0.04925537, -0.0053520203, 0.041656494, -0.02003479, -0.02279663, -0.00045371056, -0.025802612, -0.008476257, -0.007671356, -0.0007677078, 0.09173584, 0.0036010742, 0.053100586, 0.033355713, 0.06964111, -0.000890255, -0.001247406, -0.028381348, 0.11517334, -0.026306152, -0.03765869, 0.000073850155, -0.01399231, 0.010810852, 0.058258057, 0.012481689, 0.03479004, 0.004802704, -0.0051193237, 0.008132935, 0.0009822845, -0.015686035, 0.04360962, -0.0031700134, 0.020492554, 0.01084137, 0.050689697, -0.042236328, 0.06390381, -0.0340271, 0.02142334, -0.043518066, 0.021636963, 0.018966675, -0.01210022, -0.06726074, -0.006099701, 0.044281006, -0.0021381378, -0.012207031, 0.0019388199, -0.04901123, -0.0024375916, 0.0035800934, -0.03543091, 0.027252197, -0.012260437, -0.026657104, -0.01197052, -0.016693115, -0.006538391, -0.017303467, -0.0052108765, -0.033966064, 0.018035889, -0.017440796, -0.038726807, 0.0073165894, -0.003627777, 0.04336548, -0.0014753342, 0.004310608, -0.0031585693, -0.038482666, 0.044647217, 0.020950317, 0.0069389343, -0.026123047, 0.028137207, 0.018234253, -0.042938232, 0.045715332, 0.015174866, 0.035095215, 0.02709961, -0.041656494, -0.04437256, -0.015045166, 0.0061569214, -0.009796143, 0.012817383, 0.035949707, -0.04699707, 0.04019165, -0.014007568, 0.0010318756, 0.05078125, -0.002532959, 0.00012046099, 0.0013637543, 0.00003504753, -0.023132324, 0.0013904572, 0.03302002, -0.023895264, -0.033294678, -0.02545166, 0.0052986145, -0.046447754, 0.0053977966, 0.0435791, -0.020492554, 0.023376465, 0.008743286, 0.007949829, 0.019729614, -0.0017194748, -0.01828003, 0.027770996, -0.013824463, -0.010932922, 0.036468506, -0.014099121, 0.040252686, 0.003047943, -0.070617676, 0.028686523, 0.0075416565, 0.030471802, 0.049468994, -0.039978027, 0.044647217, 0.045410156, -0.0032749176, -0.0034885406, -0.07141113, 0.035583496, -0.051483154, 0.052642822, 0.038635254, -0.018981934, -0.008796692, 0.010543823, 0.01940918, -0.040100098, -0.0021972656, 0.058044434, 0.06970215, -0.0703125, 0.01285553, 0.075805664, -0.0043258667, -0.09399414, 0.013954163, -0.015029907, -0.050476074, -0.02230835, 0.008903503, -0.06890869, 0.00642395, 0.06088257, 0.0067481995, -0.036315918, -0.034973145, -0.032226562, 0.0024814606, -0.015701294, -0.017730713, 0.00041007996, 0.014907837, 0.013298035, -0.039489746, -0.018630981, -0.0231781, -0.014816284, -0.02168274, -0.02949524, -0.0149002075, -0.07989502, -0.054901123, -0.018325806, 0.030975342, -0.022201538, 0.019714355, -0.0067367554, -0.01802063, -0.046051025, 0.006587982, -0.017959595, 0.028717041, -0.06439209, 0.042907715, -0.019958496, -0.0128479, 0.0030822754, 0.003358841, -0.011512756, -0.014434814, 0.060668945, -0.011817932, -0.0073165894, -0.04598999, 0.0011100769, 0.015365601, 0.016235352, 0.021896362, 0.029510498, -0.008560181, -0.032196045, -0.0491333, -0.03692627, -0.018585205, 0.038635254, -0.04043579, -0.025543213, -0.025466919, 0.04260254, -0.014419556, -0.0063819885, 0.005207062, -0.031799316, 0.014320374, -0.016937256, -0.0029754639, 0.070373535, -0.010299683, 0.018997192, 0.02859497, 0.01991272, -0.02418518, -0.043548584, -0.007888794, 0.017822266, -0.00655365, 0.02923584, 0.023406982, -0.030181885, -0.079833984, 0.018676758, 0.047607422, 0.043395996, -0.022735596, 0.03289795, -0.009483337, -0.017059326, -0.041290283, 0.007980347, -0.04147339, 0.009986877, 0.011627197, -0.026062012, 0.020996094, 0.055419922, 0.030044556, -0.010848999, 0.0082473755, 0.002544403, -0.029678345, -0.05291748, -0.05529785, -0.051849365, 0.056549072, -0.025772095, -0.03640747, -0.010955811, -0.0061531067, 0.01260376, 0.007926941, -0.02696228, 0.009994507, -0.014434814, 0.0035514832, 0.026229858, -0.031311035, -0.0087890625, -0.02281189, -0.015312195, -0.008674622, -0.020019531, -0.017501831, 0.009490967, -0.023391724, 0.014038086, 0.012023926, 0.0058555603, -0.06390381, -0.050964355, -0.01676941, 0.0418396, -0.061065674, 0.033477783, -0.02406311, 0.004283905, 0.01121521, -0.014472961, 0.015167236, -0.027404785, 0.026504517, 0.058929443, -0.02772522, -0.016433716, 0.015686035, 0.00096178055, -0.008361816, 0.027252197, -0.022781372, 0.0009417534, -0.024475098, -0.015510559, 0.007446289, -0.017410278, 0.012878418, -0.010803223, 0.024017334, 0.01966858, 0.012145996, 0.02458191, 0.045043945, 0.011177063, 0.009117126, -0.014694214, 0.017990112, -0.0029945374, 0.038757324, -0.029571533, -0.014602661, 0.013023376, 0.019195557, 0.0021781921, 0.018341064, -0.04748535, 0.051605225, -0.022750854, 0.017303467, 0.03555298, 0.06359863, 0.0113220215, -0.095947266, -0.017791748, 0.013870239, -0.013320923, -0.03869629, -0.06994629, -0.026657104, -0.029785156, 0.04559326, -0.007911682, 0.0010576248, 0.014785767, -0.016098022, 0.021713257, -0.014823914, -0.015449524, 0.013153076, -0.011154175, -0.024932861, 0.018096924, 0.0046424866, -0.0039596558, 0.0032997131, -0.010368347, -0.03741455, 0.019058228, 0.00014400482, -0.00009125471, -0.00045514107, -0.056915283, 0.021316528, 0.02178955, 0.012069702, 0.029891968, 0.012649536, -0.0087890625, 0.0637207, -0.014984131, 0.0064811707, -0.0010843277, 0.034454346, -0.07299805, -0.030807495, 0.016662598, 0.0015439987, 0.030410767, -0.011230469, -0.060760498, 0.0017786026, -0.022994995, 0.017700195, -0.004634857, -0.00894928, 0.012176514, -0.004611969, -0.009765625, 0.03024292, -0.038726807, -0.027328491, -0.023147583, 0.03704834, -0.02810669, -0.032714844, 0.03427124, -0.046844482, -0.004219055, 0.020065308, 0.007698059, -0.0068511963, -0.04727173, 0.0390625, -0.006088257, 0.0134887695, -0.04220581, 0.009925842, 0.022644043, 0.061309814, -0.03640747, 0.027938843, 0.027618408, 0.04058838, -0.0020122528, 0.0149383545, -0.004753113, -0.05178833, -0.0335083, 0.010726929, -0.025268555, -0.04876709, -0.047912598, -0.0031528473, -0.071777344, -0.008056641, -0.031158447, 0.03652954, 0.015609741, -0.012504578, -0.011009216, 0.07672119, 0.0006747246, 0.055419922, -0.0054626465, -0.057739258, -0.0473938, -0.004886627, 0.038909912, 0.011276245, -0.041412354, -0.02684021, -0.0015630722, 0.027175903, -0.008369446, 0.044708252, 0.02861023, -0.024017334, 0.009750366, 0.04837036, -0.03717041, -0.025604248, 0.0491333, -0.04144287, 0.0049591064, 0.031951904, 0.025604248, -0.015686035, -0.011627197, 0.056915283, -0.021575928, 0.012771606, 0.06359863, -0.03930664, 0.034332275, 0.023712158, -0.007499695, -0.04458618, 0.000014960766, -0.0035743713, 0.027908325, 0.0042800903, 0.03378296, -0.03768921, -0.034820557, -0.01651001, 0.018600464, 0.020095825, -0.021774292, -0.03591919, -0.009346008, 0.025238037, -0.027282715, 0.0046539307, 0.0010738373, 0.031921387, 0.010253906, -0.010292053, -0.032348633, 0.022888184, -0.023391724, 0.022445679, 0.034210205, 0.0039043427, 0.04425049, -0.004878998, -0.024536133, 0.01612854, 0.009666443, -0.03149414, -0.0052261353, 0.05340576, 0.081970215, 0.056610107, 0.06036377, -0.014877319, 0.0022125244, 0.07659912, 0.0067100525, -0.023910522, -0.029220581, -0.006980896, -0.014961243, -0.026443481, 0.018875122, -0.026046753, -0.011276245, 0.01777649, -0.010513306, -0.008773804, -0.01285553, -0.0039901733, -0.009422302, -0.008003235, -0.00491333, -0.03866577, -0.06939697, -0.0021419525, -0.0038394928, 0.036071777, -0.018157959, -0.04586792, 0.025604248, 0.005634308, 0.0036506653, 0.036956787, 0.0016374588, -0.03237915, -0.0020542145, -0.0025634766, 0.048614502, -0.027359009, -0.036102295, 0.009757996, -0.001578331, 0.024917603, 0.0044517517, -0.027664185, 0.024856567, 0.003370285, -0.027557373, 0.00071668625, 0.01058197, -0.013458252, -0.0005440712, -0.017745972, 0.0154418945, -0.037994385, 0.06665039, 0.0036792755, -0.01676941, -0.022903442, 0.01537323, 0.0039596558, 0.017913818, -0.016204834, 0.023147583, -0.036712646, 0.0345459, -0.010284424, -0.049468994, 0.003408432, -0.0071372986, 0.006881714, -0.0657959, 0.007083893, 0.027664185, 0.044647217, 0.012931824, 0.040130615, 0.05706787, 0.0065574646, -0.007194519, 0.007171631, -0.0256958, 0.016677856, 0.024871826, 0.08239746, 0.015991211, -0.045654297, -0.031066895, -0.055023193, 0.033477783, -0.014221191, -0.016906738, -0.023468018, 0.029388428, -0.0016098022, -0.011985779, -0.009796143, -0.026672363, -0.04360962, -0.0037631989, -0.022491455, -0.00011789799, -0.012939453, 0.014335632, -0.044525146, 0.004085541, -0.012306213, -0.010032654, 0.0020008087, -0.040130615, 0.04031372, 0.038116455, -0.0060310364, -0.048828125, -0.021331787, 0.029556274, -0.02822876, 0.016464233, -0.042297363, -0.007987976, -0.0115737915, 0.02204895, -0.0062446594, -0.0032787323, -0.052246094, -0.002313614, -0.0513916, -0.029846191, 0.019805908, -0.0231781, 0.03967285, -0.06854248, 0.019226074, 0.0010080338, -0.047302246, 0.027130127, 0.0184021, 0.012939453, 0.05456543, -0.047424316, -0.07055664, -0.017669678, -0.019744873 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2011.05411v5
Privacy Preservation in Federated Learning: An insightful survey from the GDPR Perspective
Nguyen Truong, Kai Sun, Siyao Wang, Florian Guitton, Yike Guo
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Along with the blooming of AI and Machine Learning-based applications and services, data privacy and security have become a critical challenge. Conventionally, data is collected and aggregated in a data centre on which machine learning models are trained. This centralised approach has induced severe privacy risks to personal data leakage, misuse, and abuse. Furthermore, in the era of the Internet of Things and big data in which data is essentially distributed, transferring a vast amount of data to a data centre for processing seems to be a cumbersome solution. This is not only because of the difficulties in transferring and sharing data across data sources but also the challenges on complying with rigorous data protection regulations and complicated administrative procedures such as the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). In this respect, Federated learning (FL) emerges as a prospective solution that facilitates distributed collaborative learning without disclosing original training data whilst naturally complying with the GDPR. Recent research has demonstrated that retaining data and computation on-device in FL is not sufficient enough for privacy-guarantee. This is because ML model parameters exchanged between parties in an FL system still conceal sensitive information, which can be exploited in some privacy attacks. Therefore, FL systems shall be empowered by efficient privacy-preserving techniques to comply with the GDPR. This article is dedicated to surveying on the state-of-the-art privacy-preserving techniques which can be employed in FL in a systematic fashion, as well as how these techniques mitigate data security and privacy risks. Furthermore, we provide insights into the challenges along with prospective approaches following the GDPR regulatory guidelines that an FL system shall implement to comply with the GDPR.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2011.05411v5
"2021-03-18T12:32:28"
"2020-11-10T21:41:25"
{ "title": [ -0.011138916, 0.017700195, -0.08166504, -0.06738281, 0.041625977, -0.02178955, 0.012054443, 0.018203735, -0.06323242, 0.035369873, -0.026000977, 0.030334473, -0.009109497, -0.013687134, -0.005809784, -0.019424438, -0.014816284, 0.0134887695, -0.0018033981, -0.021072388, -0.018234253, -0.042266846, 0.049438477, -0.042388916, 0.048065186, -0.03378296, -0.09967041, 0.001627922, 0.0063171387, -0.016540527, 0.0063209534, 0.013786316, 0.020523071, 0.031433105, -0.024932861, -0.004016876, -0.03668213, 0.029586792, -0.0028152466, 0.011947632, 0.024047852, -0.01007843, -0.016708374, -0.0143585205, -0.022567749, 0.008598328, -0.05230713, -0.031799316, -0.028640747, 0.068359375, 0.02204895, 0.009086609, -0.0037879944, 0.09259033, 0.014663696, -0.026977539, -0.028015137, -0.015625, 0.03591919, 0.024612427, 0.009780884, -0.052764893, 0.034851074, -0.0052986145, -0.015281677, -0.038879395, -0.03552246, 0.031433105, 0.049957275, 0.0018825531, -0.00041532516, 0.015235901, 0.031921387, -0.0012216568, -0.036865234, -0.028427124, 0.047424316, 0.011100769, 0.03112793, -0.042114258, -0.021697998, 0.0013570786, -0.046081543, -0.021469116, 0.023086548, -0.0048675537, -0.01927185, -0.016220093, -0.009628296, -0.016403198, 0.0054626465, -0.0063705444, 0.016586304, 0.050720215, -0.013305664, -0.020339966, 0.010681152, 0.0579834, -0.016082764, -0.045135498, -0.04550171, 0.03527832, -0.10144043, 0.00004839897, -0.016616821, 0.046661377, 0.024780273, 0.025634766, -0.019546509, 0.010025024, -0.013633728, -0.004283905, 0.002538681, 0.001405716, -0.019577026, -0.0062561035, -0.017822266, -0.0014829636, -0.008140564, 0.013656616, 0.012359619, 0.004081726, -0.012817383, 0.023071289, 0.021911621, 0.014755249, -0.023330688, -0.007369995, -0.025482178, 0.057006836, 0.017425537, 0.05923462, -0.11376953, -0.10784912, -0.08154297, 0.029342651, -0.006298065, -0.0038108826, -0.026138306, 0.00056505203, 0.0061149597, 0.0022201538, 0.025100708, 0.006416321, 0.004928589, 0.010726929, 0.05496216, -0.019622803, -0.056121826, -0.03982544, -0.031082153, 0.043640137, 0.023620605, 0.004425049, -0.027008057, 0.0041236877, -0.08135986, -0.0006403923, 0.024002075, -0.011390686, 0.027359009, 0.016189575, 0.0036678314, 0.03289795, 0.07366943, -0.019470215, -0.0052108765, 0.033111572, 0.0010166168, 0.06329346, -0.016326904, -0.007904053, -0.034973145, -0.027114868, -0.013153076, 0.0044288635, 0.05822754, 0.022979736, -0.008300781, -0.012557983, 0.0011806488, -0.021057129, 0.017486572, 0.0038604736, -0.037231445, -0.020065308, 0.019180298, 0.008979797, 0.02017212, 0.0064430237, -0.028335571, 0.053588867, -0.048950195, -0.057891846, -0.039123535, -0.006729126, 0.014251709, 0.009498596, 0.0048103333, 0.0121154785, -0.034851074, 0.031311035, -0.068603516, 0.031402588, -0.0357666, -0.028244019, -0.0017747879, 0.025314331, -0.050994873, 0.06451416, 0.0574646, 0.020446777, -0.026855469, -0.019302368, 0.02418518, -0.057739258, 0.0028133392, -0.023925781, -0.012290955, -0.021743774, -0.038513184, 0.0016651154, -0.01713562, 0.015075684, 0.000854969, 0.019836426, -0.011146545, 0.0066108704, 0.05770874, 0.026046753, 0.11834717, -0.05001831, 0.0037574768, 0.009506226, -0.014640808, -0.03503418, -0.03540039, -0.046875, 0.02067566, 0.03274536, -0.011238098, -0.011047363, -0.013145447, 0.045715332, 0.019378662, -0.012641907, 0.003320694, 0.038879395, 0.004753113, 0.020828247, 0.08288574, 0.019638062, 0.028549194, 0.036590576, -0.0005903244, 0.04397583, -0.027740479, 0.0029582977, -0.009117126, -0.007160187, 0.013839722, 0.0129852295, 0.019180298, 0.010093689, -0.089538574, 0.010520935, -0.043151855, -0.00054073334, 0.008178711, 0.007987976, 0.038208008, -0.038024902, 0.009963989, 0.02355957, -0.0028800964, -0.015319824, -0.016998291, 0.000021874905, 0.01058197, -0.020187378, -0.01965332, -0.000037252903, 0.020843506, -0.011184692, 0.017944336, -0.002544403, 0.00756073, -0.04058838, -0.02168274, -0.030960083, 0.03326416, 0.021697998, -0.008872986, 0.00081014633, 0.029693604, -0.02104187, 0.07556152, 0.06237793, -0.03375244, 0.02128601, -0.04824829, 0.010665894, 0.0158844, -0.04055786, 0.0040016174, 0.021331787, 0.020980835, -0.0050201416, -0.024291992, 0.005630493, -0.0335083, 0.037200928, 0.0014305115, -0.050720215, -0.021484375, -0.044799805, -0.0077590942, -0.044036865, -0.06048584, 0.011795044, 0.044128418, -0.020935059, -0.016036987, -0.012313843, -0.008049011, -0.013389587, -0.011520386, -0.01109314, 0.0031490326, 0.015548706, -0.012199402, 0.01234436, -0.07434082, 0.011230469, 0.007987976, 0.034942627, -0.009902954, -0.0057678223, -0.015609741, 0.019943237, 0.0018110275, -0.035217285, 0.029571533, -0.057403564, -0.027770996, -0.043945312, -0.035461426, 0.006160736, -0.028564453, -0.036468506, 0.05899048, -0.012016296, -0.0025291443, -0.04458618, 0.06713867, -0.04434204, -0.051940918, -0.025772095, 0.012840271, -0.053619385, 0.047912598, 0.017913818, 0.015686035, -0.04650879, -0.044555664, -0.045532227, -0.0037822723, -0.019119263, -0.0054130554, 0.04727173, -0.04208374, 0.0024681091, -0.036224365, -0.0151901245, -0.009056091, 0.022537231, 0.02468872, -0.020965576, -0.03656006, -0.012046814, 0.014060974, 0.010360718, -0.018951416, -0.010986328, 0.022201538, 0.03829956, -0.025222778, -0.005710602, -0.001613617, -0.02470398, -0.0005373955, 0.030883789, -0.022415161, -0.0025482178, 0.0143585205, 0.017333984, -0.024505615, -0.013298035, -0.055145264, -0.0029125214, 0.05859375, -0.0076942444, -0.02609253, 0.022232056, -0.03289795, -0.043914795, 0.042877197, -0.014350891, 0.017318726, -0.0015630722, 0.010139465, -0.0024280548, 0.010643005, -0.020614624, 0.016159058, -0.07318115, -0.08081055, 0.024719238, -0.04208374, -0.010276794, 0.005466461, 0.014434814, -0.041748047, -0.014533997, -0.008590698, 0.06210327, 0.027313232, 0.01259613, 0.020706177, -0.015426636, 0.009437561, -0.026245117, 0.0016021729, -0.014923096, -0.076416016, -0.027786255, -0.0062713623, 0.06378174, 0.04019165, -0.024520874, -0.054718018, 0.0038146973, -0.009727478, 0.02229309, 0.015312195, -0.044311523, -0.010185242, -0.047607422, -0.023925781, 0.04232788, -0.022338867, 0.005378723, -0.044128418, 0.010185242, -0.014427185, 0.013320923, 0.0029144287, 0.012039185, -0.04840088, 0.020721436, 0.019897461, -0.004348755, 0.002620697, -0.013000488, 0.026321411, -0.010932922, 0.04144287, -0.0054397583, -0.022842407, 0.031829834, -0.012290955, -0.027374268, -0.015655518, -0.0018815994, 0.01084137, 0.03152466, -0.03149414, 0.023529053, -0.04071045, 0.012008667, -0.015686035, 0.02166748, -0.039520264, -0.07342529, -0.03161621, 0.0059394836, -0.11395264, -0.05545044, 0.030181885, -0.07525635, -0.04837036, -0.06994629, 0.029541016, -0.06677246, -0.0151901245, 0.00969696, -0.0041618347, 0.010246277, -0.0029773712, -0.08135986, 0.006668091, 0.06341553, -0.0020008087, 0.036987305, 0.044403076, 0.005596161, -0.021224976, -0.023864746, 0.021331787, 0.016830444, 0.02166748, -0.008850098, -0.009468079, 0.042877197, -0.033294678, 0.042053223, -0.0042686462, -0.005420685, -0.015975952, 0.017211914, 0.016311646, 0.02029419, -0.053985596, 0.05709839, 0.036956787, -0.029449463, -0.06945801, 0.0049972534, 0.007221222, -0.012260437, 0.022399902, -0.018585205, 0.04534912, 0.039215088, -0.019226074, 0.050689697, -0.004245758, -0.02809143, 0.024368286, 0.008293152, -0.005542755, -0.031143188, 0.006034851, 0.022460938, -0.0030174255, -0.02355957, -0.042907715, 0.00036144257, -0.0077323914, -0.045928955, 0.0064315796, 0.014678955, -0.033935547, -0.0018854141, -0.028442383, -0.055725098, -0.029220581, 0.020187378, -0.02293396, 0.0025596619, 0.016784668, 0.013923645, -0.04421997, 0.006904602, 0.034942627, 0.0029850006, 0.02734375, -0.02267456, 0.01096344, -0.00084781647, -0.052947998, -0.02734375, 0.0070114136, 0.004009247, 0.02319336, -0.026306152, -0.008323669, 0.039794922, 0.0060157776, 0.017364502, 0.05130005, -0.03149414, -0.02319336, 0.03692627, -0.023101807, 0.0071029663, -0.013511658, 0.041534424, -0.03414917, -0.04437256, -0.02116394, -0.0036087036, -0.016555786, -0.054229736, 0.036346436, -0.0032444, 0.031143188, 0.020645142, 0.04776001, 0.03387451, 0.0019350052, -0.0011205673, 0.0020198822, -0.03805542, 0.003643036, -0.010437012, 0.014411926, 0.017868042, 0.021652222, 0.04815674, 0.0075950623, -0.020385742, 0.00957489, 0.014228821, 0.010215759, -0.0017871857, 0.04626465, -0.029205322, -0.05154419, -0.022903442, 0.005142212, 0.017074585, 0.058776855, -0.0340271, 0.039794922, -0.036865234, -0.0096588135, 0.021072388, -0.0007762909, 0.019577026, 0.0010099411, 0.023590088, -0.041992188, -0.021835327, 0.0178833, -0.011276245, -0.022445679, -0.01133728, 0.013938904, 0.03869629, 0.03302002, 0.0256958, 0.010215759, -0.007926941, -0.026290894, -0.005710602, 0.002292633, -0.016052246, -0.04296875, 0.0057411194, -0.023910522, 0.015014648, -0.011955261, 0.006576538, -0.042297363, -0.00085020065, -0.036621094, 0.011268616, 0.0011482239, -0.056274414, -0.0018434525, 0.056762695, 0.029953003, 0.0138168335, 0.012954712, 0.011726379, 0.06021118, 0.040527344, 0.019821167, 0.021728516, 0.009231567, -0.01071167, -0.04421997, 0.008895874, 0.047424316, -0.01109314, 0.011764526, 0.016677856, -0.035064697, -0.06390381, 0.030227661, -0.013496399, -0.01663208, -0.023025513, -0.013633728, 0.025421143, 0.019439697, -0.0006008148, 0.011650085, -0.04220581, -0.047973633, 0.010948181, -0.026504517, 0.0109939575, 0.023651123, 0.004589081, -0.060028076, -0.0335083, 0.052886963, 0.002407074, -0.02557373, 0.0022773743, 0.020935059, -0.029266357, 0.029449463, 0.00085258484, -0.035308838, -0.031066895, -0.0069236755, 0.016921997, 0.0060043335, 0.016525269, -0.022079468, 0.013389587, -0.027618408, -0.06817627, -0.07092285, -0.025512695, -0.021453857, 0.027404785, -0.025802612, -0.016113281, -0.006034851, -0.04638672, -0.0020637512, 0.041870117, -0.018997192, 0.012870789, -0.0071372986, 0.0036945343, 0.024551392, 0.03894043, 0.026763916, -0.0036296844, -0.0035247803, -0.04559326, 0.01713562, 0.02130127, 0.0053520203, -0.018936157, -0.050201416, -0.0041007996, 0.02961731, -0.0069732666, -0.006664276, 0.0059394836, 0.03805542, 0.058898926, -0.006855011, 0.004501343, 0.07373047, -0.03842163, -0.02909851, -0.02130127, 0.0003902912, -0.04776001, 0.035858154, 0.0034999847, -0.016647339, -0.0317688, -0.06713867, -0.047912598, -0.010627747, 0.04345703, 0.03338623, 0.06530762, -0.02734375, 0.009460449, -0.030883789, -0.01612854, -0.037017822, 0.05529785, -0.0070610046, -0.018234253, 0.0066566467, -0.026748657, 0.019638062, -0.07354736, 0.021438599, -0.0025482178, 0.02293396, -0.0473938, -0.021697998, 0.010528564, -0.028442383, -0.004714966, 0.011802673, 0.036193848, -0.05593872, 0.0013027191, -0.025054932, 0.06237793, 0.008621216, 0.04522705, 0.027160645, 0.013595581, 0.0069236755, 0.0017681122, 0.013145447, -0.035827637, 0.040222168, -0.045288086, 0.010513306, -0.04574585, -0.025054932, -0.11437988, 0.009140015, 0.024627686, 0.016464233, 0.0014696121, 0.012130737, 0.010978699, -0.0029621124, 0.031082153, -0.015136719, 0.06036377, -0.021377563, -0.01902771, -0.006679535, 0.016494751, 0.025054932, 0.034362793, 0.010917664, 0.027496338, -0.003900528, -0.017730713, 0.025512695, 0.0021457672, 0.0008573532, -0.011871338, 0.007801056, -0.033416748, 0.020767212, -0.014053345, 0.009864807, 0.04385376, 0.05532837, -0.025115967, -0.00566864, 0.0085372925, -0.0079422, -0.011413574, -0.009025574, 0.026290894, -0.019592285, -0.0021972656, -0.045318604, -0.021606445, -0.036132812, 0.045043945, 0.023406982, -0.036834717, -0.008369446, 0.024993896, 0.016586304, -0.0035495758, 0.033996582, -0.021850586, -0.026504517, 0.00374794, 0.020950317, 0.00001180172, 0.03604126, -0.0010948181, 0.034729004, -0.04071045, -0.02520752, -0.0063476562, -0.008811951, -0.021697998, 0.02166748, -0.044647217, 0.037017822, -0.013633728, -0.04159546, 0.0030288696, 0.016540527, -0.05630493, -0.014503479, 0.042114258, 0.0440979, 0.047546387, 0.07281494, 0.025283813, -0.01473999, 0.012718201, -0.036254883, 0.018356323, 0.042541504, -0.0435791, 0.02520752, -0.039276123, -0.032806396, 0.026260376, -0.066101074, -0.01626587, -0.0076446533, 0.04562378, -0.010795593, -0.011802673, 0.029434204, -0.05432129, 0.038757324, 0.009681702, -0.034423828, 0.0050621033, 0.02494812, -0.002292633, 0.0069007874, -0.0064048767, 0.008018494, 0.011184692, -0.01676941, -0.0231781, -0.028167725, -0.04824829, 0.010131836, -0.030059814, 0.016555786, 0.012992859, -0.012367249, -0.0058555603, -0.006580353, 0.0035915375, 0.0029125214, -0.008110046, -0.013832092, -0.037841797, -0.0112838745, 0.004940033, 0.009513855, -0.034179688, -0.0501709, 0.032562256, -0.0040016174, -0.021850586, 0.012741089, 0.032073975, -0.046417236, -0.039733887, 0.0075798035, -0.037200928, 0.048950195, 0.026046753, -0.017562866, 0.012420654, 0.025741577, -0.040985107, -0.008216858, -0.0035114288, 0.033966064, -0.0038909912, -0.048217773, 0.0033187866, 0.039154053, 0.055114746, -0.030929565, -0.018997192, 0.023254395, 0.029281616, 0.0012950897, 0.07281494, 0.01991272, 0.012908936, -0.0309906, 0.03363037, -0.005329132, -0.03439331, -0.020736694, -0.03955078, 0.03479004, 0.066711426, -0.014465332, -0.0001578331, 0.04925537, 0.02619934, -0.00141716, 0.039031982, -0.042266846, -0.0046424866, 0.0046653748, 0.014266968, -0.007358551, -0.028274536, -0.006412506, 0.008850098, -0.0041160583, 0.01676941, -0.004623413, -0.0010185242, -0.021942139, 0.036315918, -0.016601562, -0.04699707, 0.023635864, 0.031463623, -0.0031986237, 0.06744385, -0.031585693, -0.017730713, -0.02432251, 0.008712769, 0.015625, 0.016082764, 0.035095215, -0.011108398, 0.027694702, -0.03286743, -0.0423584, -0.017074585, -0.053619385, 0.045532227, -0.028381348, 0.0090408325, -0.024246216, 0.002149582, -0.00021266937, 0.00042390823, 0.022140503, -0.03173828, -0.040008545, -0.08483887, 0.037261963, -0.011833191 ], "summary": [ 0.03778076, 0.0024662018, -0.033843994, -0.052856445, 0.02885437, -0.034729004, 0.03765869, 0.0023555756, -0.053741455, 0.043029785, -0.01499176, 0.023727417, 0.026016235, -0.029510498, 0.022903442, -0.018157959, -0.018722534, 0.018630981, 0.022018433, -0.020431519, -0.007293701, -0.027236938, 0.031051636, -0.037902832, 0.052642822, -0.041870117, -0.09240723, 0.021743774, 0.04360962, 0.040771484, 0.03677368, -0.02935791, -0.009559631, 0.05783081, -0.052490234, -0.030593872, -0.02470398, 0.030456543, -0.0030574799, 0.021118164, 0.033599854, -0.01171875, 0.06201172, 0.019454956, 0.012710571, 0.00705719, 0.0069770813, -0.055877686, -0.006111145, 0.06829834, 0.0057868958, -0.0050697327, -0.026397705, 0.08959961, -0.009788513, -0.027404785, 0.018661499, -0.04824829, 0.032714844, -0.010322571, 0.006965637, -0.023666382, 0.03289795, -0.0052490234, 0.018356323, -0.022521973, 0.01675415, 0.02355957, 0.01902771, 0.033599854, 0.019500732, 0.004211426, 0.05407715, -0.033843994, -0.0041236877, -0.02029419, 0.03753662, 0.0077705383, 0.007972717, -0.016403198, -0.0045394897, 0.025375366, -0.013381958, -0.029174805, -0.016220093, -0.023452759, -0.030548096, -0.0031433105, 0.039520264, 0.029907227, 0.0044937134, -0.020431519, 0.0340271, 0.09729004, 0.019638062, -0.020523071, -0.016159058, -0.0158844, 0.006729126, -0.016052246, 0.010032654, -0.03149414, -0.008460999, -0.007068634, -0.025939941, 0.07366943, 0.029342651, -0.005886078, -0.036499023, -0.012771606, 0.006626129, -0.06262207, 0.0066719055, -0.03149414, -0.035705566, 0.05532837, 0.026855469, -0.0008716583, -0.0037231445, 0.036193848, -0.016296387, 0.021331787, -0.07501221, 0.034118652, 0.028289795, 0.015563965, 0.027053833, 0.032806396, -0.0032806396, 0.038970947, -0.005050659, 0.032287598, -0.040527344, -0.039764404, -0.057250977, -0.011657715, 0.02116394, 0.0076789856, 0.028808594, -0.03866577, 0.05218506, 0.015563965, -0.016052246, 0.049987793, 0.013458252, 0.013496399, 0.030563354, 0.0037956238, -0.020874023, -0.004524231, -0.015319824, 0.03829956, 0.037994385, 0.001364708, -0.034606934, -0.025894165, -0.02897644, 0.007598877, -0.0060920715, -0.03488159, 0.063964844, -0.0055770874, -0.023284912, 0.068603516, 0.029953003, -0.0068359375, 0.0008907318, 0.008384705, -0.0025310516, 0.010185242, -0.0075187683, 0.022735596, -0.041656494, -0.030776978, 0.004207611, -0.010787964, 0.021636963, 0.011505127, -0.0007777214, -0.016738892, -0.01979065, -0.034576416, 0.027755737, -0.006416321, -0.002527237, 0.009552002, 0.020248413, 0.022583008, -0.010017395, 0.005378723, 0.0017385483, 0.03955078, -0.028808594, -0.012168884, -0.019500732, -0.014381409, 0.022598267, 0.0026607513, -0.0062828064, -0.0032730103, 0.018325806, 0.030212402, -0.049743652, 0.0009737015, -0.07128906, -0.005947113, -0.008476257, 0.037902832, -0.04269409, 0.04019165, 0.02760315, -0.025726318, -0.018325806, 0.031051636, 0.046173096, -0.031036377, 0.014320374, -0.015045166, -0.0065956116, -0.012924194, -0.024093628, 0.016403198, -0.033233643, 0.011161804, -0.027923584, -0.005153656, -0.023803711, 0.018356323, 0.02558899, 0.019470215, 0.10949707, -0.029907227, -0.027282715, -0.002046585, -0.020141602, -0.025894165, -0.035369873, -0.08959961, 0.0069732666, 0.065979004, -0.005367279, 0.023727417, -0.024887085, 0.040283203, -0.02178955, -0.016906738, 0.010307312, 0.02760315, 0.0077209473, 0.027664185, 0.060180664, -0.017669678, 0.0018730164, 0.013450623, 0.015022278, 0.012619019, -0.017318726, -0.015617371, 0.010269165, -0.0027427673, 0.00022232533, -0.014480591, -0.00007432699, 0.0008907318, -0.06311035, -0.04248047, -0.03741455, -0.022338867, 0.035614014, -0.053619385, 0.02357483, -0.07098389, 0.00081014633, 0.013961792, -0.017791748, -0.009315491, -0.020751953, 0.009773254, 0.0018062592, 0.00038003922, -0.0049476624, 0.020599365, -0.007335663, -0.01651001, 0.026428223, 0.0093688965, -0.01864624, -0.013000488, 0.011627197, 0.029373169, 0.04156494, 0.029403687, -0.027420044, 0.024780273, 0.018096924, -0.01701355, 0.039367676, 0.0385437, -0.0036830902, -0.022262573, -0.012825012, 0.0061454773, -0.04071045, -0.017547607, -0.002325058, 0.034729004, 0.01777649, -0.0057640076, 0.005973816, 0.014709473, -0.026947021, 0.031143188, 0.0018386841, -0.011665344, -0.02558899, -0.048065186, -0.024169922, -0.0033054352, -0.04559326, 0.0602417, 0.084228516, 0.007873535, -0.018096924, 0.0058288574, -0.0070343018, -0.03086853, 0.03668213, -0.028259277, 0.00868988, 0.00038814545, -0.056884766, -0.00793457, -0.040618896, 0.064208984, -0.004989624, 0.013381958, -0.008201599, 0.027816772, -0.0036029816, -0.017990112, -0.0051994324, -0.014389038, -0.0003373623, -0.008544922, -0.09289551, -0.0011930466, -0.010620117, -0.011108398, -0.07366943, -0.043395996, 0.07910156, -0.01927185, -0.0030536652, -0.016921997, 0.02192688, -0.02029419, -0.013069153, -0.029434204, -0.0058517456, -0.057281494, 0.04159546, 0.009857178, 0.003921509, -0.09240723, -0.027160645, -0.017471313, -0.00010544062, -0.024307251, 0.048583984, 0.052947998, -0.027008057, 0.034210205, -0.035827637, 0.0053901672, 0.03640747, 0.011566162, 0.120788574, 0.017028809, -0.037506104, 0.06518555, 0.029418945, 0.020233154, -0.0023536682, -0.011779785, -0.0070228577, 0.024353027, 0.019104004, 0.00043916702, 0.038635254, -0.011817932, 0.002243042, 0.01247406, -0.0026073456, -0.006954193, 0.016052246, -0.010261536, 0.015029907, 0.012298584, -0.0289917, -0.03286743, 0.057861328, 0.014503479, -0.0029792786, -0.00039696693, 0.016418457, -0.036590576, 0.07763672, 0.0012073517, 0.02557373, -0.015930176, 0.022064209, -0.027938843, 0.008674622, -0.02798462, 0.008415222, -0.048339844, 0.010925293, 0.008117676, -0.027694702, -0.013923645, 0.01574707, 0.020614624, 0.0038700104, -0.00056028366, 0.028778076, 0.06262207, -0.0019073486, -0.011787415, 0.02532959, -0.006866455, 0.009384155, -0.023513794, -0.0009994507, -0.012199402, -0.06750488, -0.058563232, -0.009025574, -0.005138397, 0.043945312, -0.05038452, -0.07635498, 0.010353088, 0.0058250427, -0.01499939, 0.01979065, -0.036590576, 0.01789856, -0.059906006, -0.007534027, 0.0519104, -0.024902344, 0.011711121, 0.009094238, 0.020965576, -0.010040283, -0.013427734, -0.02583313, 0.031234741, 0.032989502, 0.0024719238, 0.01889038, 0.0037231445, -0.015808105, 0.01689148, 0.03262329, 0.029632568, 0.013320923, 0.011795044, -0.011856079, 0.013160706, 0.013015747, -0.0625, -0.026428223, -0.007621765, 0.022445679, 0.009239197, -0.009590149, 0.015007019, 0.006790161, -0.0055656433, -0.07312012, 0.05203247, -0.07562256, -0.070251465, -0.07635498, 0.017623901, -0.07885742, -0.08013916, 0.01222229, -0.037231445, -0.055511475, -0.043121338, 0.02381897, -0.050628662, -0.01159668, 0.035461426, -0.007873535, 0.06378174, 0.0023345947, -0.06506348, 0.040771484, -0.017486572, 0.021774292, 0.039154053, 0.0140686035, 0.0463562, -0.009063721, -0.005748749, -0.017745972, -0.025024414, -0.009597778, -0.04837036, 0.022750854, 0.03060913, -0.035186768, 0.050598145, -0.048339844, 0.048828125, -0.04748535, -0.0007815361, 0.03363037, 0.049713135, -0.037200928, 0.028503418, 0.024658203, -0.034606934, -0.038360596, -0.0019226074, 0.0052757263, -0.024291992, 0.019577026, 0.022384644, 0.03086853, 0.04763794, -0.03753662, -0.011642456, -0.015144348, -0.05508423, -0.023925781, 0.01335907, -0.014671326, -0.014404297, 0.0066184998, 0.038604736, -0.0059013367, -0.01713562, -0.041259766, -0.01033783, -0.03768921, -0.020980835, 0.0056648254, -0.0121536255, -0.0035381317, -0.020080566, -0.00818634, 0.023208618, -0.0046577454, 0.013969421, -0.019836426, -0.0013227463, -0.017730713, -0.0029621124, -0.011878967, 0.010650635, 0.053894043, 0.032806396, -0.00037932396, -0.039398193, -0.018554688, 0.0015640259, -0.03753662, -0.001821518, 0.001083374, -0.029754639, -0.02029419, -0.017837524, 0.023895264, 0.04937744, -0.01272583, -0.04522705, 0.017913818, -0.040008545, -0.0013008118, -0.000582695, -0.030731201, 0.03656006, -0.010124207, 0.041931152, -0.043914795, -0.026229858, -0.021743774, 0.013595581, -0.01977539, -0.05444336, 0.011817932, 0.005332947, 0.025161743, 0.045684814, 0.042236328, 0.02722168, 0.023269653, -0.0049209595, 0.011726379, -0.017822266, -0.0059318542, -0.014427185, 0.0011444092, 0.03857422, 0.0116119385, 0.04095459, -0.016174316, -0.024871826, 0.010017395, 0.010070801, -0.0020561218, 0.0013332367, 0.043426514, -0.038909912, -0.030578613, 0.001698494, 0.029129028, 0.025817871, 0.045684814, -0.0007472038, 0.013671875, 0.001783371, -0.03378296, 0.035125732, 0.005882263, 0.003993988, 0.036590576, 0.00033807755, -0.0015497208, -0.011039734, 0.011566162, -0.0055503845, 0.004573822, -0.023330688, -0.013916016, 0.019805908, 0.022766113, -0.011734009, -0.056640625, -0.02470398, 0.021499634, 0.010238647, -0.024902344, -0.0049438477, -0.017837524, -0.013221741, -0.016143799, 0.013137817, -0.006034851, -0.0025959015, 0.028518677, -0.012359619, -0.027313232, 0.04144287, -0.009544373, -0.044158936, -0.07745361, -0.011985779, 0.03338623, -0.060638428, 0.024780273, 0.011207581, 0.04220581, 0.017089844, 0.02432251, -0.013595581, -0.020324707, 0.010261536, -0.061279297, 0.010276794, 0.031188965, 0.017623901, -0.0019798279, 0.014526367, -0.04663086, -0.00039696693, 0.0026893616, -0.057556152, -0.034301758, -0.058776855, 0.04220581, 0.030792236, 0.025009155, 0.018371582, -0.0010814667, -0.0023040771, -0.061676025, -0.029434204, -0.0055656433, -0.012252808, 0.023590088, 0.009246826, -0.0309906, -0.012062073, 0.023773193, -0.024902344, -0.022949219, 0.021606445, 0.018051147, 0.0044555664, -0.012565613, -0.023635864, 0.025054932, -0.070373535, 0.02293396, 0.027450562, -0.055786133, -0.029144287, 0.0016222, 0.007217407, -0.06109619, -0.04248047, -0.055633545, -0.06744385, -0.041778564, 0.08520508, -0.04421997, 0.024230957, 0.017944336, -0.07989502, -0.011978149, 0.047790527, -0.012542725, -0.0001989603, -0.024108887, -0.016357422, 0.018051147, 0.008598328, 0.030975342, -0.014480591, -0.018463135, -0.04852295, 0.022903442, 0.01890564, 0.018966675, -0.04119873, -0.008773804, -0.013885498, 0.032226562, -0.0031642914, 0.0016365051, -0.0026378632, 0.01361084, 0.031204224, -0.0021972656, -0.0035533905, 0.047454834, -0.00079250336, -0.032043457, -0.0061798096, 0.033050537, -0.03817749, -0.0357666, 0.012550354, -0.015068054, 0.014533997, -0.040618896, -0.009140015, -0.009399414, 0.015838623, 0.022354126, 0.0574646, -0.008049011, -0.0016002655, 0.018066406, -0.039031982, -0.00983429, 0.035858154, -0.012580872, -0.032196045, 0.03845215, -0.029922485, -0.00077581406, 0.0020370483, -0.008506775, -0.0052948, 0.011192322, 0.0017299652, 0.008216858, 0.018341064, 0.004573822, 0.03265381, 0.0043792725, 0.019317627, -0.0065231323, -0.02935791, 0.033996582, 0.025268555, -0.018661499, -0.016647339, -0.018188477, -0.0012559891, 0.016479492, -0.019805908, -0.038909912, -0.024017334, 0.07043457, 0.009208679, -0.039367676, -0.063964844, -0.06536865, -0.059051514, 0.04055786, -0.011550903, -0.03857422, 0.04437256, -0.0068473816, 0.014099121, 0.024169922, -0.04812622, -0.006996155, -0.03982544, -0.055664062, -0.028457642, 0.0057792664, 0.014846802, 0.00667572, 0.04437256, 0.0023155212, 0.008590698, 0.03390503, -0.016448975, 0.064819336, -0.04449463, 0.00793457, -0.054351807, 0.0006928444, -0.028396606, 0.031555176, -0.0030517578, 0.00818634, 0.04611206, 0.022338867, 0.017059326, -0.03652954, 0.025115967, 0.023330688, -0.003665924, -0.01033783, -0.009918213, 0.06573486, -0.044433594, -0.024856567, -0.01977539, 0.029754639, 0.0025577545, 0.07501221, -0.0715332, -0.010879517, 0.017959595, 0.003604889, -0.07232666, 0.01928711, -0.018081665, -0.010772705, 0.02432251, 0.017868042, -0.004234314, 0.0038490295, -0.00932312, -0.00016891956, -0.006378174, 0.020614624, -0.011482239, 0.02696228, -0.000027894974, 0.015289307, -0.060455322, 0.012901306, 0.02848816, -0.014831543, 0.0056266785, 0.03326416, 0.0008997917, 0.022445679, 0.03793335, 0.07537842, 0.085510254, 0.08203125, -0.022857666, 0.019927979, 0.07501221, -0.019882202, 0.0317688, -0.0043792725, -0.02897644, -0.024658203, -0.020767212, 0.022994995, -0.027267456, -0.027862549, -0.05569458, 0.005050659, 0.049743652, -0.010292053, -0.03665161, -0.03967285, -0.0085372925, 0.09844971, 0.019699097, -0.022323608, 0.018600464, 0.036376953, -0.011726379, 0.024154663, -0.027008057, -0.020828247, 0.000831604, -0.00059890747, 0.0061416626, -0.018569946, -0.019714355, 0.019470215, 0.0017566681, 0.05102539, 0.045806885, -0.019805908, 0.019760132, 0.0065994263, -0.004131317, -0.021759033, -0.0033416748, -0.0025157928, 0.0005784035, -0.01436615, 0.006755829, 0.011558533, -0.033569336, -0.08465576, 0.0368042, -0.020584106, -0.033325195, 0.030639648, 0.01889038, -0.01448822, -0.011459351, 0.013755798, -0.022567749, 0.016738892, -0.00869751, 0.010604858, 0.0032138824, 0.052764893, -0.004371643, -0.025772095, -0.0045280457, -0.004501343, -0.0071792603, -0.058746338, 0.011581421, 0.01424408, 0.040161133, 0.0005788803, 0.038085938, 0.04486084, 0.018859863, 0.007675171, 0.03640747, 0.009719849, 0.012718201, -0.0053710938, 0.030532837, -0.009277344, -0.03186035, -0.003522873, -0.0023155212, 0.053009033, 0.02897644, -0.017028809, -0.007446289, 0.021133423, 0.008346558, -0.0030841827, 0.03111267, -0.010803223, -0.011192322, -0.0107421875, 0.0062217712, -0.03012085, -0.05126953, 0.008010864, 0.0006017685, 0.0035114288, 0.034118652, -0.009223938, -0.0019626617, 0.0062675476, 0.016113281, 0.01890564, 0.0077819824, -0.0113220215, -0.016540527, 0.018295288, 0.03881836, -0.0062942505, -0.043151855, -0.03225708, 0.000103354454, 0.029388428, 0.021987915, 0.021636963, -0.038208008, 0.038604736, -0.06970215, -0.045684814, -0.037841797, -0.07507324, 0.03060913, -0.033294678, 0.04046631, 0.0107803345, 0.05810547, 0.024032593, -0.012069702, 0.060760498, 0.016159058, -0.010665894, -0.107177734, -0.0034179688, -0.013725281 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2011.08434v4
Simple and optimal methods for stochastic variational inequalities, II: Markovian noise and policy evaluation in reinforcement learning
Georgios Kotsalis, Guanghui Lan, Tianjiao Li
math.OC, cs.AI, cs.LG, 90C25, 90C15, 62L20, 68Q25
The focus of this paper is on stochastic variational inequalities (VI) under Markovian noise. A prominent application of our algorithmic developments is the stochastic policy evaluation problem in reinforcement learning. Prior investigations in the literature focused on temporal difference (TD) learning by employing nonsmooth finite time analysis motivated by stochastic subgradient descent leading to certain limitations. These encompass the requirement of analyzing a modified TD algorithm that involves projection to an a-priori defined Euclidean ball, achieving a non-optimal convergence rate and no clear way of deriving the beneficial effects of parallel implementation. Our approach remedies these shortcomings in the broader context of stochastic VIs and in particular when it comes to stochastic policy evaluation. We developed a variety of simple TD learning type algorithms motivated by its original version that maintain its simplicity, while offering distinct advantages from a non-asymptotic analysis point of view. We first provide an improved analysis of the standard TD algorithm that can benefit from parallel implementation. Then we present versions of a conditional TD algorithm (CTD), that involves periodic updates of the stochastic iterates, which reduce the bias and therefore exhibit improved iteration complexity. This brings us to the fast TD (FTD) algorithm which combines elements of CTD and the stochastic operator extrapolation method of the companion paper. For a novel index resetting policy FTD exhibits the best known convergence rate. We also devised a robust version of the algorithm that is particularly suitable for discounting factors close to 1.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2011.08434v4
"2021-08-13T23:14:14"
"2020-11-15T04:05:22"
{ "title": [ -0.0046424866, 0.017684937, -0.01977539, -0.019332886, 0.04660034, -0.018676758, 0.02998352, -0.03665161, -0.032470703, 0.015159607, -0.019897461, 0.040496826, -0.062042236, -0.017562866, -0.025146484, -0.025054932, 0.0028705597, 0.021865845, -0.03265381, -0.038391113, -0.019454956, -0.05227661, 0.042022705, 0.05508423, 0.03564453, -0.018798828, -0.09777832, 0.009086609, -0.03817749, -0.04345703, -0.014015198, 0.037750244, 0.018707275, 0.027740479, 0.0064697266, 0.00566864, -0.04534912, 0.026519775, 0.0033130646, 0.0011720657, 0.022476196, -0.021148682, -0.042938232, -0.0037345886, -0.021453857, -0.008514404, -0.017196655, -0.021133423, -0.04159546, 0.07531738, 0.03942871, 0.03338623, 0.01158905, 0.068481445, 0.02835083, -0.033843994, -0.024902344, -0.04046631, 0.03503418, 0.07751465, 0.03878784, -0.042755127, 0.002620697, -0.037506104, -0.0060539246, -0.040893555, -0.009101868, 0.033996582, 0.0385437, 0.029251099, -0.0020771027, 0.014289856, 0.015197754, 0.02407837, -0.06506348, -0.029769897, 0.08892822, 0.03479004, 0.016998291, -0.027130127, -0.013259888, -0.009559631, -0.022445679, -0.03213501, 0.034423828, -0.031585693, -0.031341553, -0.012893677, -0.034210205, -0.045959473, -0.011444092, -0.0009050369, -0.021865845, -0.0066871643, -0.034973145, -0.029144287, 0.0029735565, 0.05203247, 0.010620117, 0.016952515, -0.016357422, -0.00030946732, 0.0027580261, -0.031585693, -0.0033931732, 0.009063721, -0.0068092346, -0.002790451, 0.01802063, 0.027069092, -0.008872986, 0.03225708, 0.0003607273, 0.022994995, 0.0049743652, -0.01625061, -0.020050049, 0.03314209, 0.015136719, 0.02330017, 0.009880066, -0.0129776, 0.0023345947, 0.00051116943, 0.020202637, 0.0014781952, -0.04119873, 0.0048217773, -0.03250122, 0.028961182, 0.014060974, 0.0473938, -0.09637451, -0.07330322, -0.068847656, 0.036743164, -0.020080566, 0.037902832, -0.0015830994, -0.00038647652, 0.008369446, -0.0335083, 0.028762817, 0.02758789, 0.017440796, 0.008842468, 0.046539307, -0.0017814636, -0.038208008, -0.03753662, -0.0121536255, 0.022338867, 0.022583008, 0.002374649, -0.03894043, 0.010871887, -0.087768555, -0.006008148, 0.01171875, -0.0065612793, 0.04827881, 0.01222229, -0.00010716915, 0.0680542, 0.07434082, -0.0009021759, -0.023391724, 0.023483276, 0.00737381, 0.055023193, -0.024612427, 0.025131226, 0.015533447, -0.004722595, -0.011436462, -0.0018062592, 0.03503418, -0.026657104, 0.034576416, -0.038330078, -0.0030517578, -0.014007568, 0.016906738, 0.037322998, -0.020217896, -0.08416748, 0.01322937, -0.04949951, 0.044403076, 0.028686523, -0.03439331, 0.0064086914, -0.043792725, -0.03768921, -0.06311035, 0.019866943, 0.039245605, 0.057861328, -0.014404297, 0.011184692, -0.039794922, -0.0129852295, -0.019332886, 0.017166138, -0.011909485, -0.03427124, -0.011161804, 0.0181427, -0.040985107, 0.07519531, 0.04840088, 0.004776001, -0.030380249, 0.027236938, 0.028045654, -0.038635254, 0.036346436, -0.022232056, -0.0019798279, -0.03314209, -0.010696411, 0.012390137, -0.0012569427, 0.06298828, 0.019561768, 0.011100769, -0.0069122314, -0.020065308, 0.038208008, 0.006866455, 0.06652832, -0.015548706, -0.012283325, 0.026977539, -0.0051078796, -0.020309448, -0.01586914, 0.008125305, 0.03378296, 0.015449524, -0.0137786865, -0.0075187683, 0.0057296753, 0.062927246, 0.012481689, -0.002161026, 0.018951416, 0.01979065, 0.010971069, -0.009338379, 0.078063965, 0.0035381317, 0.053009033, -0.00055503845, 0.028762817, 0.039154053, -0.016677856, 0.011749268, -0.016784668, 0.0036563873, -0.009681702, -0.020767212, 0.018554688, -0.010299683, -0.07733154, -0.010299683, -0.043640137, -0.011245728, 0.034973145, -0.022506714, 0.031188965, -0.046020508, 0.004714966, -0.048339844, -0.033721924, -0.026535034, -0.017822266, 0.042144775, 0.020355225, -0.07318115, -0.006526947, 0.014923096, 0.0803833, 0.002544403, 0.019104004, 0.036499023, 0.045776367, -0.04046631, -0.02128601, -0.036376953, 0.054382324, 0.0009226799, -0.016860962, -0.022583008, 0.007926941, -0.03704834, 0.060455322, 0.06463623, -0.016708374, 0.02758789, -0.0803833, 0.01939392, 0.029891968, -0.036834717, 0.00667572, 0.011795044, 0.022460938, 0.01914978, -0.018569946, 0.020401001, -0.06335449, 0.00919342, 0.008140564, -0.06488037, 0.0124435425, -0.019485474, 0.023666382, -0.041015625, -0.023345947, 0.019927979, 0.05041504, -0.022003174, -0.015083313, 0.0062675476, 0.00019669533, -0.011459351, -0.02508545, -0.021102905, -0.0035820007, 0.028030396, 0.0046463013, 0.009246826, -0.06750488, 0.00066185, -0.019760132, 0.024765015, -0.014144897, 0.03062439, -0.013763428, -0.038269043, 0.0059928894, -0.0463562, 0.027572632, -0.0029449463, -0.007575989, -0.04385376, 0.010665894, 0.011054993, -0.026687622, 0.010910034, 0.0061302185, -0.013336182, -0.026824951, 0.021102905, 0.044311523, 0.014305115, 0.014297485, 0.0637207, 0.03543091, 0.019241333, 0.037994385, 0.020370483, 0.008117676, -0.061950684, -0.0413208, -0.022994995, 0.0023899078, -0.030471802, -0.023910522, 0.03967285, -0.06573486, -0.013931274, -0.009422302, -0.0063285828, 0.014144897, 0.03741455, -0.01789856, -0.02003479, -0.030715942, -0.025634766, -0.014724731, 0.0011281967, -0.009681702, 0.012718201, 0.09265137, -0.009590149, -0.016647339, 0.0075683594, 0.027694702, 0.021820068, -0.025344849, -0.026611328, 0.008346558, -0.0050354004, -0.006362915, 0.0037708282, -0.003528595, -0.009407043, -0.042938232, 0.0062332153, 0.01374054, 0.010375977, -0.014205933, 0.026062012, -0.047027588, 0.045074463, 0.003921509, -0.024871826, 0.003917694, 0.0052490234, 0.005710602, -0.029464722, 0.015586853, -0.04888916, 0.01902771, -0.05722046, -0.03213501, 0.057281494, -0.04208374, -0.08703613, 0.022918701, -0.053253174, -0.017990112, -0.042022705, -0.010864258, 0.02999878, 0.040527344, 0.02180481, -0.0035877228, -0.006843567, 0.013809204, -0.030593872, -0.010673523, -0.028244019, -0.0256958, 0.0066070557, -0.0121536255, 0.050445557, -0.0112838745, -0.00036787987, -0.08239746, -0.039276123, -0.005405426, 0.028778076, -0.0022640228, -0.041534424, -0.038360596, -0.050689697, 0.0052757263, -0.00083351135, -0.0016565323, -0.013656616, -0.028686523, -0.00044870377, -0.031921387, 0.050079346, -0.017242432, 0.0001538992, -0.024475098, 0.011436462, 0.027786255, -0.02041626, -0.03479004, -0.006954193, 0.013320923, 0.010116577, 0.03265381, -0.014831543, -0.035217285, 0.021820068, -0.03137207, 0.027114868, 0.0077400208, -0.008979797, 0.014312744, 0.002565384, -0.029876709, 0.017913818, -0.034332275, 0.001909256, 0.0340271, -0.023010254, -0.033203125, -0.0072364807, 0.01689148, -0.008705139, -0.08605957, 0.01084137, 0.0031318665, -0.020462036, 0.0037136078, -0.038635254, 0.032684326, -0.03062439, -0.04647827, -0.014595032, -0.02230835, -0.014549255, 0.008155823, -0.05593872, -0.013946533, 0.06768799, 0.01524353, -0.016098022, 0.039154053, -0.009590149, -0.004108429, -0.04437256, 0.03125, 0.011909485, 0.015289307, -0.011451721, 0.04232788, 0.05709839, 0.00002270937, 0.01687622, 0.053649902, 0.060943604, -0.009155273, -0.035308838, 0.013931274, 0.0104522705, -0.03201294, 0.05130005, 0.040222168, -0.020706177, -0.07366943, -0.010154724, -0.021591187, 0.007091522, 0.019195557, -0.0057258606, 0.021087646, 0.013694763, 0.0048713684, 0.034301758, 0.002943039, -0.0008997917, 0.019073486, -0.010696411, -0.023513794, -0.0029335022, 0.01424408, -0.0011940002, -0.00020051003, 0.045135498, -0.034179688, 0.02911377, -0.0077285767, -0.005996704, -0.017745972, -0.002538681, -0.03942871, -0.017562866, -0.05947876, -0.032440186, -0.020309448, 0.019073486, -0.004825592, 0.019546509, 0.02659607, -0.031433105, -0.028030396, 0.022979736, 0.014099121, -0.0009813309, -0.0019950867, -0.056365967, 0.002527237, -0.026779175, -0.05731201, -0.043823242, 0.0012617111, -0.022888184, 0.038879395, -0.01222229, -0.031433105, 0.001543045, 0.03189087, 0.07171631, 0.039276123, 0.0098724365, -0.028503418, -0.01663208, -0.03793335, -0.028717041, 0.035827637, 0.0032196045, -0.024032593, -0.032806396, 0.030349731, -0.026992798, -0.008674622, -0.015838623, 0.023712158, -0.03729248, 0.06719971, -0.0016651154, 0.043518066, 0.022659302, 0.002840042, 0.031677246, 0.005207062, -0.01687622, -0.017807007, 0.033203125, 0.060302734, 0.00573349, 0.028045654, 0.04510498, -0.023498535, -0.0057296753, 0.0101623535, -0.0002565384, 0.026809692, 0.00049352646, -0.022033691, 0.003583908, -0.050933838, -0.009727478, 0.010475159, -0.0132369995, 0.045440674, -0.034729004, 0.0625, 0.0066223145, 0.0051727295, 0.04901123, 0.0028686523, -0.0054626465, 0.0062789917, -0.016082764, -0.047027588, -0.07336426, -0.017990112, 0.06549072, -0.028045654, -0.009239197, -0.020111084, 0.010215759, 0.060577393, 0.029083252, 0.019073486, -0.02470398, -0.08496094, -0.0071983337, -0.007019043, -0.046142578, -0.040100098, 0.0024318695, 0.005420685, 0.022857666, -0.09246826, 0.05480957, -0.037597656, 0.017822266, 0.0032978058, -0.0017633438, -0.001578331, -0.07446289, -0.0009150505, 0.02507019, 0.004886627, -0.009780884, 0.013389587, 0.0051231384, 0.026672363, 0.0362854, 0.018417358, 0.013328552, 0.041259766, -0.046173096, 0.049926758, -0.0056915283, 0.043426514, -0.017837524, 0.0077323914, -0.00856781, 0.014984131, -0.07537842, 0.015556335, -0.013946533, 0.012237549, -0.0012426376, -0.029281616, 0.006652832, 0.0066108704, 0.0071983337, 0.010826111, -0.03125, -0.032073975, 0.020462036, -0.015716553, -0.015037537, -0.021697998, -0.0209198, -0.038269043, -0.039886475, 0.040527344, -0.038909912, -0.0059013367, 0.0074882507, -0.020095825, -0.03994751, 0.011894226, 0.028823853, -0.068847656, -0.024139404, -0.013214111, 0.024536133, 0.0126953125, -0.015640259, -0.052703857, -0.0058174133, 0.0017995834, -0.059173584, -0.05041504, 0.026107788, 0.008613586, -0.013389587, 0.013671875, -0.011444092, 0.0015058517, -0.02784729, 0.030303955, -0.031234741, 0.0074005127, 0.02406311, 0.022460938, 0.026016235, -0.004524231, 0.0071983337, -0.0079956055, 0.0124435425, 0.005092621, 0.015602112, 0.0033168793, 0.032592773, -0.012229919, 0.033111572, -0.031555176, -0.0032176971, 0.014587402, -0.016555786, -0.039764404, 0.011795044, 0.046020508, -0.027023315, -0.014343262, -0.017730713, 0.061340332, -0.04888916, 0.0054397583, -0.007507324, -0.0056114197, -0.040252686, 0.070617676, -0.0061836243, 0.001168251, -0.058502197, -0.04586792, -0.041290283, 0.0022525787, 0.026412964, -0.013519287, 0.0077209473, -0.012046814, 0.008010864, -0.007850647, -0.0008583069, -0.05429077, 0.015808105, -0.0019245148, -0.015319824, 0.0017089844, 0.01348114, 0.0069503784, -0.020965576, 0.010482788, -0.00333786, 0.00006341934, -0.0068626404, -0.03527832, 0.013259888, -0.012237549, -0.021636963, 0.019134521, -0.013710022, -0.035369873, 0.017929077, -0.06829834, 0.06060791, 0.03955078, 0.03036499, 0.012367249, 0.008934021, 0.037109375, 0.010597229, 0.037231445, -0.027328491, 0.031158447, -0.0317688, -0.021820068, -0.051239014, -0.04058838, -0.06359863, -0.020599365, 0.0095825195, 0.032287598, 0.01663208, 0.010261536, 0.01838684, 0.011192322, 0.07171631, -0.030303955, 0.07525635, 0.041107178, 0.016952515, 0.011222839, 0.010627747, -0.0036830902, 0.024719238, 0.0048561096, 0.021987915, -0.016082764, -0.024307251, 0.018844604, 0.0038585663, -0.019012451, -0.0262146, -0.0054359436, -0.045837402, 0.06213379, 0.013137817, 0.042510986, 0.031585693, 0.031433105, -0.004535675, -0.018371582, -0.014175415, 0.0028686523, -0.05178833, 0.025817871, 0.04827881, -0.06732178, 0.018844604, -0.023239136, -0.012039185, -0.016799927, 0.058441162, -0.003791809, -0.04534912, -0.022750854, -0.0016183853, 0.030181885, 0.032958984, 0.039886475, -0.016967773, -0.0044555664, 0.024536133, 0.042388916, 0.010696411, 0.057159424, 0.008621216, 0.023742676, -0.05886841, -0.010612488, -0.007457733, 0.032409668, -0.05319214, 0.0084991455, -0.064331055, 0.06085205, 0.017120361, -0.03591919, 0.03302002, -0.0029735565, -0.06384277, -0.0058784485, -0.014732361, 0.04849243, 0.01914978, 0.039001465, -0.006641388, -0.036499023, 0.02394104, -0.04244995, 0.011451721, 0.050598145, -0.010871887, 0.04135132, -0.039611816, -0.03074646, 0.043304443, -0.044769287, 0.035064697, -0.029510498, -0.019348145, -0.02519226, 0.021209717, 0.02760315, -0.05239868, -0.018096924, -0.045806885, -0.006904602, -0.0009651184, 0.00092220306, -0.009017944, 0.0069007874, 0.0057029724, 0.011299133, 0.04650879, 0.0023002625, -0.003250122, -0.017059326, -0.062286377, -0.015899658, -0.047027588, 0.029144287, -0.023605347, -0.020263672, -0.017471313, -0.005744934, -0.00793457, -0.003206253, -0.008216858, -0.027770996, -0.01763916, -0.031463623, 0.048461914, 0.054138184, 0.004951477, 0.0107803345, 0.020141602, 0.0021400452, -0.0016994476, -0.012191772, 0.023025513, -0.034851074, -0.029586792, -0.008491516, -0.017349243, 0.019866943, 0.016738892, -0.007133484, 0.0013093948, 0.04248047, -0.039123535, 0.012626648, 0.018493652, 0.050628662, -0.015159607, -0.031799316, 0.0069999695, 0.036254883, 0.051605225, -0.034088135, -0.04220581, 0.011367798, -0.024734497, -0.018005371, 0.041931152, 0.021835327, -0.008331299, -0.008163452, 0.035461426, 0.0026569366, -0.029342651, 0.0010032654, -0.019638062, 0.011833191, 0.04815674, 0.000641346, -0.017822266, 0.023406982, 0.0034236908, 0.0052986145, -0.017730713, -0.0088272095, 0.005771637, -0.02420044, 0.025161743, -0.014015198, 0.048675537, -0.048828125, 0.03111267, -0.00598526, 0.023132324, -0.0060310364, 0.015457153, 0.014030457, 0.07574463, -0.018753052, -0.013336182, 0.0440979, -0.0019207001, 0.04510498, 0.019317627, -0.0022010803, -0.0058135986, -0.026641846, 0.020187378, 0.008979797, 0.05508423, 0.025436401, -0.045074463, 0.03640747, -0.056365967, -0.05166626, 0.00868988, -0.030197144, 0.022888184, -0.0390625, 0.02204895, 0.005355835, -0.039733887, -0.022201538, 0.022781372, -0.0011892319, -0.066101074, -0.03375244, -0.045288086, 0.064331055, -0.013092041 ], "summary": [ 0.049316406, 0.025772095, -0.01083374, -0.02911377, 0.011054993, -0.02949524, 0.011268616, -0.033233643, -0.0061149597, -0.0022354126, -0.070373535, 0.026535034, -0.045288086, -0.007167816, 0.0035591125, -0.053009033, 0.02406311, 0.0116119385, 0.018066406, -0.02557373, -0.006916046, -0.0118255615, 0.014305115, 0.04034424, 0.022445679, 0.002981186, -0.060821533, 0.011451721, 0.021621704, 0.0036087036, 0.016189575, -0.014846802, -0.015296936, 0.038604736, 0.014289856, 0.02267456, -0.0029392242, 0.030563354, 0.03173828, 0.010719299, 0.00944519, -0.030426025, 0.008346558, -0.0112838745, -0.009490967, 0.015426636, 0.005519867, -0.028198242, -0.011024475, 0.059814453, -0.008056641, -0.00198555, -0.023361206, 0.08129883, -0.006679535, -0.039733887, -0.027954102, -0.030853271, -0.012649536, 0.09069824, 0.05215454, 0.029220581, -0.0317688, -0.036010742, 0.026306152, -0.009895325, 0.032684326, 0.025756836, 0.04486084, 0.022323608, -0.018554688, 0.014572144, 0.02041626, -0.0011968613, -0.03567505, -0.030380249, 0.06359863, -0.010246277, -0.021652222, -0.012123108, -0.03086853, 0.0034828186, 0.010093689, -0.07421875, 0.026992798, -0.04309082, -0.026565552, 0.011047363, -0.04284668, 0.0029067993, -0.026016235, 0.03213501, -0.03842163, -0.052978516, -0.0061073303, -0.057128906, 0.033355713, 0.056610107, 0.0030612946, 0.0131073, -0.0209198, -0.02909851, 0.026931763, -0.027038574, -0.036132812, 0.028060913, 0.06124878, 0.03527832, -0.015541077, 0.004764557, -0.010719299, 0.023223877, 0.049194336, 0.018722534, -0.015144348, -0.015304565, 0.025512695, 0.016647339, 0.0066947937, 0.016952515, 0.000895977, 0.055023193, -0.03552246, -0.013031006, -0.015213013, -0.015670776, 0.0062217712, -0.018600464, 0.025146484, 0.033477783, -0.020248413, 0.017852783, -0.07147217, -0.047424316, -0.049835205, -0.015625, 0.005821228, 0.02961731, -0.007045746, -0.026229858, 0.048217773, -0.01713562, 0.000102460384, 0.02659607, 0.006122589, 0.048339844, 0.010940552, 0.0030174255, -0.018844604, -0.020568848, 0.0016584396, -0.021255493, 0.044952393, -0.03314209, -0.030273438, -0.065979004, -0.034973145, -0.03186035, 0.05419922, -0.034484863, 0.016174316, -0.007019043, -0.016082764, 0.06524658, 0.025756836, -0.0051116943, 0.034332275, 0.010726929, 0.012893677, 0.032104492, 0.014030457, 0.003862381, 0.03515625, -0.0067596436, -0.0072669983, -0.003900528, -0.03793335, 0.0009431839, 0.02633667, -0.03652954, -0.013626099, -0.04800415, -0.0066490173, 0.012527466, 0.019973755, -0.10131836, 0.01890564, -0.020187378, 0.009780884, 0.042816162, -0.014320374, -0.012535095, -0.061157227, 0.035888672, -0.05496216, 0.01838684, 0.02861023, 0.058532715, -0.034088135, -0.02961731, 0.006793976, -0.009605408, -0.004322052, 0.0022850037, -0.08508301, 0.0069885254, -0.01637268, 0.036956787, -0.02116394, 0.0552063, 0.015487671, -0.040222168, -0.016540527, 0.072021484, 0.0345459, -0.06500244, -0.0030994415, -0.0703125, 0.013374329, -0.064819336, 0.0049095154, 0.07763672, -0.0050354004, 0.0541687, -0.00459671, -0.014572144, -0.010299683, 0.013160706, 0.01687622, -0.015594482, 0.06903076, -0.0006284714, -0.046569824, 0.024307251, -0.021209717, -0.022415161, -0.05569458, -0.040924072, 0.03942871, 0.053466797, 0.019348145, 0.036224365, -0.01586914, 0.0046806335, 0.026321411, -0.016860962, 0.0034923553, -0.0013217926, -0.019500732, -0.029266357, 0.024612427, -0.025299072, 0.041809082, 0.0013332367, -0.0006365776, 0.022644043, -0.014907837, 0.0501709, -0.05078125, 0.007217407, -0.01914978, -0.05432129, -0.006298065, -0.040527344, 0.018707275, -0.028579712, 0.011230469, -0.008026123, 0.029846191, -0.03933716, -0.0053520203, -0.073913574, 0.012016296, -0.046722412, -0.09210205, -0.048309326, -0.018936157, 0.04925537, 0.043945312, -0.04232788, -0.0112838745, 0.012268066, 0.041992188, -0.012039185, 0.014694214, 0.003036499, 0.046661377, -0.025619507, 0.004673004, 0.01928711, 0.058288574, -0.035308838, -0.040740967, -0.001074791, -0.017578125, -0.053710938, -0.038513184, 0.05154419, -0.01802063, -0.015655518, -0.05380249, 0.009902954, -0.008148193, -0.028793335, 0.0061836243, 0.030181885, 0.035125732, 0.0071029663, 0.018508911, 0.018478394, -0.02748108, -0.0018844604, 0.02192688, 0.012664795, -0.014434814, -0.01802063, -0.015029907, 0.018081665, -0.018753052, 0.044036865, 0.024398804, -0.025878906, -0.0043792725, -0.018798828, -0.0079956055, -0.004585266, -0.019729614, 0.0070381165, -0.03527832, 0.003227234, -0.013725281, -0.026992798, -0.03692627, 0.05029297, 0.007637024, 0.026107788, 0.0007634163, -0.0005784035, 0.0029029846, -0.042175293, 0.016296387, 0.02734375, 0.018737793, 0.0063323975, -0.027954102, 0.026000977, -0.021850586, -0.0059661865, -0.008331299, 0.0033168793, -0.0011587143, -0.019699097, -0.049072266, 0.02508545, -0.007030487, 0.016998291, 0.06323242, 0.0637207, 0.035491943, 0.018630981, 0.06896973, -0.0007786751, 0.02784729, -0.09259033, -0.07080078, -0.0070381165, 0.023788452, -0.040283203, -0.009246826, 0.019973755, -0.022949219, 0.017791748, -0.039733887, -0.013336182, -0.012367249, 0.027038574, 0.040252686, -0.015266418, -0.014625549, 0.012451172, 0.015975952, 0.0181427, -0.011024475, 0.021316528, 0.05505371, 0.006877899, -0.050750732, -0.0118637085, 0.0068626404, 0.021331787, -0.022613525, -0.022125244, 0.021972656, -0.041809082, 0.019378662, -0.004917145, 0.029953003, 0.018615723, 0.00932312, -0.029968262, 0.022384644, 0.018844604, -0.000626564, 0.014808655, -0.0035381317, 0.061340332, 0.026000977, -0.023773193, 0.0018053055, -0.03768921, 0.025680542, -0.04699707, 0.015838623, -0.057159424, 0.022613525, -0.07867432, 0.074523926, 0.02859497, -0.05960083, -0.06188965, 0.043518066, -0.026672363, 0.015052795, -0.026763916, 0.016952515, 0.0009899139, 0.046783447, 0.0036621094, -0.008338928, 0.020462036, 0.03942871, -0.032287598, -0.016311646, -0.008354187, -0.008781433, 0.03125, -0.008140564, 0.028015137, 0.0043296814, -0.02658081, -0.047424316, -0.023422241, -0.03375244, -0.012054443, -0.014282227, -0.009246826, 0.006855011, -0.031066895, 0.039794922, -0.00074386597, -0.027236938, -0.014434814, 0.060699463, 0.022872925, -0.023010254, 0.06951904, -0.018676758, 0.043518066, 0.039154053, -0.056762695, -0.027313232, -0.042266846, 0.008659363, 0.009544373, -0.025283813, 0.053497314, -0.043670654, 0.022598267, -0.030975342, -0.022369385, -0.0035305023, 0.03137207, -0.023651123, -0.026031494, 0.012550354, -0.038116455, 0.024154663, 0.034454346, 0.0077819824, -0.03955078, -0.0010566711, -0.0021438599, -0.017822266, 0.0038642883, -0.003206253, 0.0015602112, -0.027160645, 0.010986328, 0.0236969, 0.0418396, 0.041809082, -0.022491455, 0.06665039, -0.008003235, -0.016601562, 0.004562378, -0.03564453, 0.045806885, 0.0152282715, -0.029891968, 0.021560669, -0.02178955, 0.05987549, -0.020446777, -0.035247803, 0.040161133, 0.05734253, -0.00027036667, 0.035186768, -0.03564453, 0.021591187, -0.030517578, 0.06008911, 0.039489746, 0.012481689, -0.018295288, 0.08251953, 0.08581543, -0.012329102, -0.048614502, 0.060333252, 0.06768799, -0.036621094, 0.03390503, 0.057678223, -0.029846191, -0.04534912, -0.026367188, -0.029571533, 0.019500732, 0.019226074, 0.026123047, -0.006580353, -0.019836426, 0.023376465, -0.027618408, -0.022140503, -0.033050537, 0.0025253296, 0.04977417, -0.01676941, -0.03466797, -0.014945984, 0.059417725, 0.004043579, 0.017822266, -0.047058105, 0.023330688, -0.04498291, 0.0736084, -0.0463562, -0.06311035, -0.037994385, -0.038482666, -0.032470703, 0.07543945, -0.00459671, 0.009315491, -0.0020713806, -0.016983032, 0.019317627, 0.009109497, 0.0014276505, -0.021743774, 0.029159546, 0.014602661, -0.0033912659, -0.04220581, -0.03805542, -0.022827148, -0.042999268, -0.048034668, -0.07373047, -0.03439331, -0.045654297, 0.0032863617, -0.037719727, 0.010757446, 0.025756836, 0.08239746, 0.012298584, 0.0021915436, -0.045837402, -0.045562744, -0.013076782, -0.01020813, 0.060699463, 0.012588501, -0.013961792, -0.011924744, 0.035980225, -0.017822266, -0.036621094, -0.04876709, 0.027954102, 0.0048675537, 0.05368042, 0.02281189, 0.016235352, 0.02798462, 0.012107849, 0.029937744, 0.014251709, 0.005016327, -0.039611816, 0.011985779, 0.03289795, 0.0041542053, -0.0105896, -0.0073242188, -0.020767212, -0.049682617, 0.03366089, 0.012672424, 0.037200928, 0.015075684, -0.0009994507, 0.0104904175, 0.024475098, -0.017990112, 0.03353882, -0.011543274, 0.004081726, 0.03793335, 0.0055351257, 0.038238525, 0.02607727, 0.07635498, -0.013679504, -0.025787354, 0.022109985, -0.046844482, -0.04937744, -0.051940918, -0.018203735, 0.07122803, -0.018814087, -0.032958984, -0.022964478, 0.00039815903, 0.041015625, 0.010047913, 0.015342712, -0.0513916, -0.026382446, -0.012298584, -0.011619568, 0.00047659874, -0.023757935, -0.023910522, 0.028900146, 0.01423645, -0.06744385, 0.053497314, 0.029693604, 0.0259552, 0.011642456, 0.02305603, -0.028152466, -0.026672363, -0.036376953, -0.010444641, -0.010726929, -0.049041748, 0.059326172, -0.023071289, 0.0054893494, 0.013206482, 0.0033454895, 0.012786865, -0.0284729, 0.00039625168, 0.030136108, -0.013587952, 0.014526367, -0.021942139, 0.010803223, -0.012680054, 0.0060691833, -0.03668213, 0.0006098747, -0.016082764, 0.018127441, -0.00015187263, -0.023284912, 0.037322998, -0.011886597, -0.031707764, 0.03781128, -0.013793945, -0.00932312, -0.013923645, 0.0050964355, -0.06463623, -0.0236969, -0.01525116, -0.027801514, -0.024398804, 0.025009155, -0.027435303, -0.015357971, 0.010032654, -0.013534546, -0.022109985, -0.0024871826, -0.0057525635, -0.012916565, 0.003206253, 0.039642334, 0.032928467, 0.006439209, -0.023864746, 0.02268982, -0.0014390945, -0.030563354, -0.048431396, -0.010223389, 0.023529053, 0.009284973, 0.04046631, -0.01550293, 0.019317627, 0.015945435, -0.051757812, 0.031921387, -0.042785645, -0.027923584, -0.006549835, 0.008583069, 0.025970459, 0.029708862, -0.019958496, -0.024368286, 0.025161743, 0.01739502, -0.02444458, -0.005302429, 0.051483154, -0.0007224083, 0.036224365, -0.014678955, -0.0096206665, 0.022583008, -0.008232117, -0.0065193176, -0.0043144226, 0.01852417, -0.016677856, -0.035888672, -0.02267456, 0.015823364, -0.027572632, -0.00010097027, -0.015945435, 0.0043411255, -0.042175293, 0.026016235, 0.03552246, 0.016555786, -0.022384644, -0.024749756, -0.0029830933, -0.044067383, -0.0072135925, -0.042266846, -0.05014038, -0.01852417, -0.018218994, 0.031341553, -0.011512756, -0.029205322, -0.016540527, 0.0048294067, 0.009231567, 0.051330566, 0.022979736, 0.00995636, 0.028884888, -0.0231781, -0.02748108, 0.0034236908, -0.0038051605, -0.011268616, 0.028518677, -0.0011386871, 0.023925781, 0.00598526, -0.022094727, -0.017532349, -0.02684021, -0.022750854, 0.040252686, 0.010673523, -0.0009727478, -0.004989624, 0.010391235, 0.024932861, -0.0029697418, -0.008361816, -0.018829346, 0.028656006, -0.013206482, -0.08465576, -0.032409668, -0.07183838, 0.009231567, -0.023742676, -0.012786865, -0.011665344, 0.07232666, -0.008712769, 0.037841797, -0.0077819824, -0.034332275, -0.054351807, 0.013664246, 0.03692627, -0.0044822693, 0.029724121, 0.02166748, -0.037750244, 0.008918762, 0.013580322, 0.020004272, 0.005970001, -0.008216858, 0.003932953, -0.011314392, -0.00856781, -0.037384033, 0.020141602, -0.018203735, 0.045410156, 0.021408081, 0.017715454, 0.035491943, 0.0018930435, 0.074035645, -0.03527832, 0.0039711, 0.05529785, -0.038635254, 0.050628662, 0.008392334, 0.012275696, -0.03173828, -0.00623703, -0.0047569275, 0.009147644, 0.025375366, 0.022323608, -0.025527954, -0.0045814514, 0.005493164, 0.004760742, 0.00008952618, 0.047851562, -0.012161255, 0.0021514893, 0.039215088, 0.016708374, 0.009132385, 0.044677734, -0.019851685, -0.019058228, -0.049041748, 0.021499634, -0.0021514893, 0.056884766, -0.04309082, 0.010765076, -0.09313965, 0.05987549, 0.025436401, -0.022491455, 0.024749756, 0.028564453, -0.055511475, 0.04824829, -0.023895264, 0.072387695, 0.037078857, 0.033477783, -0.05029297, 0.0002117157, 0.070617676, -0.007419586, 0.0036468506, -0.03338623, -0.0001142025, -0.0025501251, -0.01637268, 0.024017334, 0.0135269165, 0.0010204315, -0.02986145, -0.027328491, 0.014213562, -0.038116455, 0.018615723, -0.04876709, -0.02609253, 0.024551392, -0.059936523, -0.04257202, 0.019012451, -0.0034313202, -0.02973938, 0.011245728, -0.01360321, -0.02456665, 0.020568848, 0.0036392212, 0.021697998, -0.0065574646, -0.039916992, -0.017211914, -0.016906738, 0.02520752, -0.0010166168, -0.025222778, 0.025482178, -0.00667572, -0.01083374, -0.0090789795, -0.009979248, -0.0010890961, 0.00090789795, -0.03314209, 0.014923096, 0.02456665, -0.0014696121, 0.028930664, 0.05130005, 0.012748718, 0.002368927, -0.010734558, 0.0034770966, -0.011299133, -0.011062622, -0.0035762787, -0.015625, -0.012390137, 0.00073862076, 0.019866943, 0.008163452, 0.02178955, -0.015357971, 0.024597168, 0.040740967, 0.03164673, 0.0025119781, -0.070007324, 0.0069885254, 0.008628845, 0.026245117, 0.027404785, -0.014350891, 0.044677734, -0.02142334, -0.034179688, -0.011062622, 0.019088745, -0.0012187958, 0.021408081, 0.033416748, -0.017929077, -0.002960205, -0.0063819885, -0.020889282, 0.04046631, 0.0010318756, -0.041870117, 0.0059165955, 0.018997192, -0.022262573, -0.035980225, -0.014945984, 0.03189087, -0.051239014, 0.015487671, -0.013824463, -0.04449463, -0.007381439, 0.015541077, -0.019683838, 0.0030174255, -0.007713318, -0.005970001, -0.0031929016, -0.027420044, 0.01625061, 0.0015764236, 0.06072998, -0.013618469, -0.014221191, 0.04385376, -0.03616333, 0.010765076, 0.026275635, -0.006931305, 0.008056641, 0.00090551376, 0.016220093, 0.07965088, -0.08807373, -0.00021100044, -0.041992188, -0.026062012, 0.061553955, 0.008049011, 0.014503479, -0.045898438, 0.024856567, 0.011711121, -0.034423828, 0.014724731, 0.036834717, 0.030532837, -0.014762878, 0.010528564, -0.02734375, 0.033172607, -0.0047073364 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2011.10076v5
Optimal Algorithms for Convex Nested Stochastic Composite Optimization
Zhe Zhang, Guanghui Lan
math.OC, cs.AI, cs.LG
Recently, convex nested stochastic composite optimization (NSCO) has received considerable attention for its applications in reinforcement learning and risk-averse optimization. The current NSCO algorithms have worse stochastic oracle complexities, by orders of magnitude, than those for simpler stochastic composite optimization problems (e.g., sum of smooth and nonsmooth functions) without the nested structure. Moreover, they require all outer-layer functions to be smooth, which is not satisfied by some important applications. These discrepancies prompt us to ask: ``does the nested composition make stochastic optimization more difficult in terms of the order of oracle complexity?" In this paper, we answer the question by developing order-optimal algorithms for the convex NSCO problem constructed from an arbitrary composition of smooth, structured non-smooth and general non-smooth layer functions. When all outer-layer functions are smooth, we propose a stochastic sequential dual (SSD) method to achieve an oracle complexity of $\mathcal{O}(1/\epsilon^2)$ ($\mathcal{O}(1/\epsilon)$) when the problem is non-strongly (strongly) convex. When there exists some structured non-smooth or general non-smooth outer-layer function, we propose a nonsmooth stochastic sequential dual (nSSD) method to achieve an oracle complexity of $\mathcal{O}(1/\epsilon^2)$. We provide a lower complexity bound to show the latter $\mathcal{O}(1/\epsilon^2)$ complexity to be unimprovable even under a strongly convex setting. All these complexity results seem to be new in the literature and they indicate that the convex NSCO problem has the same order of oracle complexity as those without the nested composition in all but the strongly convex and outer-non-smooth problem.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2011.10076v5
"2022-06-21T15:53:19"
"2020-11-19T19:22:58"
{ "title": [ -0.03262329, 0.01663208, -0.012229919, -0.06518555, 0.009819031, 0.032348633, -0.06378174, -0.033294678, -0.03137207, 0.013252258, -0.010269165, 0.049926758, -0.04812622, -0.007255554, -0.007194519, -0.010681152, -0.00016355515, 0.014755249, -0.05029297, -0.04284668, -0.008865356, -0.05368042, 0.016601562, 0.07647705, 0.03414917, -0.006767273, -0.083496094, -0.0012331009, -0.03265381, -0.039154053, -0.004966736, 0.039245605, 0.024108887, 0.024993896, 0.0231781, 0.025360107, -0.04940796, 0.031097412, 0.03074646, 0.0019893646, 0.0014276505, -0.0006942749, -0.03753662, 0.0014162064, -0.039642334, -0.01260376, -0.056427002, -0.03060913, -0.041809082, 0.05770874, 0.02684021, 0.0079574585, -0.01574707, 0.042877197, 0.031463623, -0.031585693, -0.0031871796, -0.006980896, 0.04159546, 0.064575195, 0.012199402, -0.0335083, 0.0034427643, -0.017044067, -0.009605408, -0.026290894, 0.013755798, 0.02368164, 0.060028076, 0.03677368, 0.0039978027, 0.010696411, 0.019485474, 0.026519775, -0.032073975, -0.025009155, 0.041412354, 0.023376465, 0.047698975, -0.018951416, -0.023513794, 0.011054993, -0.022125244, -0.04171753, 0.03668213, -0.047912598, -0.033355713, 0.000890255, -0.040802002, -0.042938232, -0.021270752, -0.00422287, -0.004711151, 0.01586914, -0.017318726, -0.008163452, -0.0076065063, 0.029418945, -0.003566742, -0.0016813278, -0.0047187805, -0.0013904572, 0.00047922134, -0.023880005, 0.0049743652, 0.008216858, -0.005748749, -0.010955811, 0.018173218, 0.022201538, -0.012039185, 0.0077400208, 0.016357422, 0.01852417, 0.0047187805, -0.0063972473, -0.008590698, 0.022323608, 0.008132935, 0.026000977, -0.0052833557, -0.018295288, -0.03427124, -0.005874634, 0.009605408, -0.03100586, -0.022628784, 0.02571106, -0.046173096, 0.032196045, -0.0068244934, 0.042999268, -0.07446289, -0.053466797, -0.041534424, 0.03390503, -0.013076782, -0.000426054, -0.005622864, -0.009773254, 0.02708435, -0.046722412, -0.01210022, 0.034973145, -0.006587982, 0.02230835, 0.076049805, -0.010375977, -0.0602417, -0.04083252, -0.04522705, 0.040985107, 0.043395996, -0.013771057, -0.076538086, -0.03845215, -0.10546875, -0.02960205, 0.022201538, -0.03375244, 0.015419006, 0.002878189, -0.0075798035, 0.048736572, 0.079833984, -0.0030555725, -0.00026583672, 0.035461426, 0.019760132, 0.050445557, -0.012397766, 0.008369446, 0.011871338, 0.0049209595, -0.0078125, 0.012542725, 0.07611084, 0.008155823, 0.027374268, -0.03286743, 0.0035514832, -0.017929077, 0.038269043, 0.023910522, -0.04168701, -0.058258057, 0.0023059845, -0.009788513, 0.04348755, 0.036071777, -0.045654297, -0.011070251, -0.06237793, -0.0209198, -0.05810547, -0.00434494, 0.019302368, 0.046051025, -0.012390137, 0.019805908, -0.049468994, -0.0105896, -0.030212402, 0.020874023, 0.008430481, -0.024414062, -0.020263672, 0.030136108, -0.04486084, 0.032470703, 0.06762695, -0.002002716, -0.035705566, 0.010925293, 0.013832092, -0.039764404, 0.045837402, -0.004676819, -0.014640808, -0.019134521, -0.049041748, -0.0022602081, -0.022628784, 0.06439209, 0.054992676, 0.007232666, 0.007331848, -0.029296875, 0.08544922, 0.02130127, 0.05722046, -0.04711914, 0.017089844, 0.03363037, 0.017471313, 0.0060806274, 0.0075531006, 0.017074585, 0.004070282, -0.012214661, -0.016677856, 0.019989014, -0.005882263, 0.044799805, 0.05014038, 0.003435135, 0.0021591187, 0.03363037, 0.03918457, 0.02861023, 0.07281494, 0.0023403168, 0.060516357, -0.037841797, 0.042938232, 0.060302734, -0.004135132, -0.0149002075, -0.0012264252, 0.01171875, 0.000056624413, -0.037109375, -0.008102417, -0.007221222, -0.05886841, -0.0079422, -0.025100708, 0.012886047, 0.0109939575, -0.016403198, 0.021957397, -0.013320923, -0.0036411285, -0.017242432, -0.010505676, -0.03753662, -0.008346558, 0.025787354, -0.010665894, -0.062469482, -0.0004105568, 0.023223877, 0.051818848, 0.014831543, 0.020935059, 0.00029444695, 0.018371582, -0.012168884, 0.002696991, -0.02116394, 0.05807495, 0.015159607, 0.014205933, -0.030792236, -0.016647339, -0.017105103, 0.049560547, 0.052856445, -0.0017356873, 0.0335083, -0.06173706, 0.035003662, 0.030654907, -0.024780273, -0.0011367798, 0.039031982, 0.039855957, 0.012741089, -0.017974854, -0.001332283, -0.029296875, 0.009216309, 0.008514404, -0.05581665, -0.013832092, -0.02835083, -0.007133484, -0.040863037, -0.009216309, 0.000050663948, 0.050811768, 0.008239746, -0.041656494, 0.004802704, 0.012649536, -0.015899658, -0.018218994, -0.029037476, -0.041168213, 0.015602112, 0.02772522, -0.020263672, -0.05682373, -0.014984131, -0.011054993, 0.015823364, -0.015823364, 0.0057678223, -0.022109985, -0.008071899, -0.0034656525, -0.00919342, 0.032409668, -0.037109375, 0.015029907, -0.051330566, 0.0107040405, 0.021865845, -0.06719971, 0.017990112, 0.013542175, -0.033813477, -0.049438477, 0.0017414093, 0.042022705, 0.01234436, 0.013092041, 0.036254883, 0.03994751, -0.01979065, 0.029418945, -0.002090454, -0.014877319, -0.024902344, 0.00049448013, -0.044281006, 0.010795593, -0.03186035, 0.0043754578, 0.07672119, -0.031234741, -0.012588501, -0.04345703, -0.0011177063, 0.0060920715, -0.010604858, 0.037872314, 0.00044608116, -0.03074646, 0.022354126, 0.011100769, 0.021026611, -0.017700195, 0.006713867, 0.08685303, 0.013755798, 0.0024032593, 0.0006504059, 0.022064209, -0.004623413, -0.045440674, -0.018371582, -0.00881958, 0.0028762817, 0.012794495, 0.017364502, 0.00006598234, -0.018478394, -0.071777344, 0.0030326843, 0.03955078, -0.008232117, -0.012290955, 0.0016460419, -0.04156494, -0.00472641, 0.017791748, -0.015144348, 0.021392822, 0.033111572, 0.009094238, 0.028213501, 0.016983032, -0.010177612, 0.017913818, -0.06365967, -0.07800293, 0.054779053, -0.033233643, -0.08868408, 0.0027179718, -0.035583496, -0.030441284, -0.014526367, -0.03994751, 0.025344849, 0.017745972, 0.04650879, 0.0026187897, -0.008430481, -0.011955261, -0.0262146, -0.03338623, -0.026229858, -0.003107071, -0.004890442, -0.01260376, 0.019882202, 0.003850937, 0.007282257, -0.047302246, -0.026306152, 0.014762878, 0.041229248, 0.01374054, -0.024627686, -0.019500732, -0.017562866, -0.0002822876, 0.012329102, -0.034118652, -0.016311646, -0.019073486, 0.0054397583, -0.027313232, 0.0231781, 0.00042009354, 0.0035057068, -0.055145264, 0.020996094, 0.032287598, -0.01576233, -0.049957275, 0.005607605, 0.02545166, 0.013305664, 0.022903442, -0.012268066, -0.03173828, 0.022201538, -0.033691406, -0.0020484924, 0.012489319, -0.0020656586, -0.01789856, 0.00012755394, 0.018157959, 0.024520874, -0.02734375, -0.025283813, 0.006958008, -0.0046195984, -0.0025939941, -0.036346436, 0.0146865845, 0.003698349, -0.070251465, 0.022384644, -0.004863739, -0.015411377, -0.028961182, -0.029525757, 0.0079422, -0.008277893, -0.029312134, -0.010513306, -0.022705078, -0.050445557, 0.0014896393, -0.03579712, -0.037231445, 0.074279785, 0.022338867, -0.008216858, 0.0027008057, 0.021499634, 0.026321411, -0.031463623, 0.008621216, -0.053985596, 0.060424805, -0.036987305, -0.0039024353, 0.06304932, -0.026367188, 0.024841309, 0.033721924, 0.062561035, -0.022415161, -0.03817749, -0.0017194748, 0.012313843, -0.021392822, 0.045959473, 0.045135498, -0.011695862, -0.074401855, 0.02508545, -0.01777649, 0.0013256073, 0.01626587, -0.014320374, 0.022384644, 0.006690979, 0.017211914, 0.048583984, -0.012458801, -0.026931763, 0.021362305, -0.007858276, 0.002439499, 0.013671875, -0.00073575974, 0.010650635, 0.003545761, 0.024276733, -0.015487671, 0.025314331, -0.028518677, -0.029037476, -0.009292603, 0.016738892, -0.008110046, 0.006275177, -0.0803833, -0.015487671, -0.016220093, 0.013893127, -0.0140686035, 0.030883789, 0.044891357, 0.0003502369, -0.036071777, -0.00090026855, 0.07952881, -0.012779236, 0.014060974, -0.062805176, 0.03866577, -0.019424438, -0.029373169, -0.043823242, 0.012237549, 0.012794495, 0.02796936, -0.0035476685, -0.012809753, 0.0054130554, 0.027877808, 0.051635742, 0.025665283, -0.012214661, -0.02885437, -0.008140564, -0.03527832, -0.013580322, 0.037628174, 0.012886047, 0.0049476624, -0.013572693, 0.03353882, -0.031234741, -0.021133423, -0.05834961, 0.04815674, -0.015899658, 0.054473877, 0.020233154, 0.024902344, 0.052581787, 0.016036987, 0.008979797, 0.024902344, -0.031951904, -0.012634277, -0.0060806274, 0.045410156, 0.022094727, 0.021194458, 0.057373047, -0.000644207, -0.021896362, 0.017211914, 0.002588272, 0.037719727, 0.013465881, -0.02029419, 0.0052108765, -0.0206604, -0.014831543, 0.01574707, -0.0071983337, 0.040161133, -0.03894043, 0.037719727, -0.0008535385, -0.01914978, 0.030792236, -0.004043579, 0.0075645447, 0.011940002, 0.0012359619, -0.07904053, -0.05718994, -0.03829956, 0.06341553, -0.049560547, -0.03866577, -0.0020370483, 0.026138306, 0.035003662, 0.0597229, 0.059570312, -0.0067100525, -0.031402588, -0.021118164, 0.00067806244, -0.019348145, -0.046417236, 0.019332886, 0.009017944, 0.017486572, -0.059143066, 0.01209259, -0.06573486, 0.010948181, 0.0024757385, 0.0121536255, 0.014732361, -0.07147217, 0.009986877, 0.04449463, 0.034820557, -0.03125, -0.028564453, -0.0206604, 0.034698486, 0.046051025, -0.0007929802, 0.035461426, 0.039367676, -0.016311646, 0.05218506, -0.00818634, 0.027450562, -0.042633057, -0.004989624, -0.016326904, -0.01335907, -0.047088623, 0.022064209, 0.016586304, -0.017028809, 0.030548096, -0.049743652, 0.02079773, 0.047821045, -0.0075149536, 0.008270264, -0.0107421875, -0.047851562, -0.029556274, -0.01386261, -0.053253174, -0.0004246235, -0.001253128, -0.008880615, -0.011192322, 0.011077881, -0.044555664, 0.013702393, 0.028442383, 0.00012230873, -0.003610611, 0.033599854, 0.015220642, -0.07043457, -0.02331543, 0.00012218952, 0.02861023, 0.037231445, 0.0059280396, -0.05593872, -0.00037813187, -0.04562378, -0.060943604, -0.036956787, 0.02809143, 0.030212402, 0.01184845, -0.011444092, 0.017745972, 0.015144348, -0.047027588, 0.017913818, -0.00017118454, -0.023391724, 0.034454346, 0.031173706, 0.03704834, -0.02418518, 0.022476196, 0.0025844574, -0.0031204224, 0.022460938, -0.03604126, -0.0007519722, 0.00012886524, -0.02772522, 0.008346558, -0.010612488, -0.01134491, 0.004234314, -0.004989624, -0.036376953, 0.020080566, 0.024047852, -0.02645874, 0.010253906, 0.0056266785, 0.053497314, -0.035369873, -0.0418396, -0.0069236755, -0.0032081604, -0.014717102, 0.090148926, -0.017700195, -0.04949951, -0.046417236, -0.04043579, -0.026000977, -0.0019550323, 0.019561768, -0.009132385, 0.0056495667, -0.015945435, 0.018676758, 0.0025100708, -0.013595581, -0.025756836, 0.006275177, 0.002216339, -0.048553467, 0.020248413, 0.010017395, -0.008140564, -0.018157959, -0.013168335, 0.019577026, 0.021270752, -0.0046081543, -0.051452637, -0.0067443848, -0.010467529, -0.021499634, 0.051239014, -0.016738892, -0.000028312206, 0.040893555, -0.024520874, 0.048736572, 0.02357483, 0.039489746, 0.041809082, 0.018417358, 0.021850586, 0.01083374, 0.032165527, -0.030578613, 0.0059776306, -0.015411377, -0.008331299, -0.055755615, -0.015449524, -0.068725586, 0.0317688, -0.00026345253, 0.015853882, 0.018554688, 0.008964539, 0.0063972473, 0.0012016296, 0.050933838, -0.0099105835, 0.056610107, 0.045654297, -0.0033340454, 0.028411865, 0.025909424, 0.0057373047, 0.03161621, 0.011352539, -0.0065574646, -0.020446777, -0.03491211, 0.0048103333, 0.041778564, 0.013069153, 0.018035889, -0.03062439, -0.03527832, 0.0491333, 0.00522995, 0.03491211, 0.04638672, 0.035858154, -0.007095337, -0.025268555, 0.016677856, 0.033935547, -0.06604004, 0.045196533, 0.045959473, -0.0736084, -0.018463135, -0.032989502, 0.0017824173, 0.017303467, -0.012893677, 0.042907715, -0.10595703, -0.09082031, -0.00021100044, 0.04397583, 0.014152527, 0.02684021, -0.022644043, 0.013793945, 0.023208618, 0.043304443, 0.02330017, 0.04699707, 0.007331848, 0.028427124, -0.031341553, 0.008331299, 0.025787354, 0.03149414, -0.008140564, 0.018966675, -0.066711426, 0.030883789, -0.008399963, -0.05029297, 0.025543213, -0.002084732, -0.07763672, 0.003627777, 0.0005040169, 0.033172607, 0.054016113, 0.041412354, 0.0046920776, -0.011360168, 0.011138916, -0.06939697, 0.043823242, 0.017913818, -0.036132812, 0.053253174, -0.03286743, -0.027038574, 0.07598877, -0.049835205, 0.031036377, -0.05230713, 0.012481689, -0.009162903, 0.03427124, 0.0050697327, -0.033355713, -0.013595581, -0.0009393692, -0.077819824, -0.0054244995, -0.006664276, -0.0019102097, -0.013427734, -0.030944824, 0.005214691, 0.011268616, -0.0057029724, -0.012626648, -0.0070762634, -0.07269287, -0.02331543, -0.033843994, 0.021865845, -0.024276733, -0.0039901733, -0.03062439, 0.012054443, 0.0022602081, -0.019927979, -0.011291504, -0.019958496, -0.039642334, -0.017059326, 0.039886475, 0.057495117, -0.0021648407, 0.003522873, 0.04135132, -0.0107040405, -0.00053167343, -0.035369873, 0.022094727, -0.044830322, -0.0234375, -0.009246826, -0.015457153, 0.035369873, 0.036376953, -0.008865356, -0.033203125, 0.043792725, -0.030517578, -0.014419556, 0.019042969, 0.052459717, -0.016326904, -0.052124023, 0.025817871, 0.03427124, 0.0513916, -0.025802612, -0.019134521, 0.031097412, -0.04574585, -0.03878784, 0.048095703, 0.06506348, 0.002336502, -0.00022637844, 0.013038635, -0.010536194, -0.041656494, -0.031829834, -0.0345459, 0.018463135, 0.05166626, -0.005420685, -0.020614624, 0.03466797, -0.002620697, -0.021972656, -0.005027771, 0.00056934357, -0.016159058, -0.0052337646, 0.010749817, -0.027694702, 0.0050239563, -0.022872925, -0.0056648254, 0.005115509, 0.008293152, -0.01474762, 0.0079422, -0.030929565, 0.05456543, -0.0001257658, -0.009796143, 0.0012683868, -0.013252258, 0.03857422, 0.029678345, -0.0073432922, -0.01991272, -0.018630981, 0.011405945, -0.00831604, 0.028167725, 0.0051231384, 0.014221191, 0.04333496, 0.0009241104, -0.03845215, 0.05014038, -0.02999878, 0.043151855, -0.025619507, 0.01436615, -0.028045654, -0.0036945343, -0.017944336, 0.008850098, 0.002872467, -0.056121826, -0.05166626, -0.0052604675, 0.05709839, -0.0101623535 ], "summary": [ 0.000059247017, -0.001080513, -0.0071754456, -0.05645752, -0.013122559, 0.028076172, -0.04321289, -0.005428314, -0.03677368, -0.0015554428, -0.03677368, 0.033721924, -0.06311035, -0.0065460205, 0.0155181885, -0.057556152, 0.010734558, 0.010894775, -0.015159607, -0.042419434, 0.0010709763, -0.042755127, 0.014167786, 0.06530762, 0.015258789, 0.013908386, -0.028381348, -0.0018930435, 0.044067383, 0.028884888, 0.026290894, -0.05706787, 0.0031929016, 0.027114868, -0.0002667904, 0.013923645, -0.049957275, 0.044891357, 0.013282776, 0.007980347, 0.0005173683, -0.018005371, 0.031051636, -0.035461426, 0.027832031, -0.013122559, 0.014274597, -0.054534912, -0.029632568, 0.0289917, 0.0060043335, 0.0043029785, 0.006652832, -0.020553589, 0.0041618347, -0.012641907, -0.05328369, 0.025115967, 0.00819397, 0.068359375, 0.03186035, 0.015525818, -0.011047363, -0.01940918, -0.0033187866, -0.0032920837, 0.043670654, -0.0015659332, 0.011077881, 0.0046577454, 0.01222229, 0.0043525696, 0.013214111, -0.004497528, 0.011291504, -0.005153656, -0.029891968, 0.007598877, 0.03942871, 0.012145996, -0.043182373, 0.03515625, -0.02671814, -0.08532715, 0.034057617, -0.044311523, -0.0345459, 0.014457703, -0.016738892, 0.032684326, -0.025161743, -0.006164551, 0.021026611, 0.01423645, -0.010772705, -0.0072746277, -0.009223938, -0.026977539, 0.032806396, 0.016662598, 0.028060913, -0.05895996, 0.06695557, -0.021453857, -0.015556335, 0.024215698, 0.020584106, -0.013511658, 0.00019669533, -0.0079574585, -0.021957397, -0.009841919, 0.03692627, -0.0038604736, -0.03768921, -0.02758789, -0.011428833, 0.015777588, 0.007827759, -0.015945435, -0.025375366, -0.005710602, -0.048309326, 0.033477783, -0.004547119, -0.0063819885, 0.019058228, 0.033935547, -0.052703857, 0.016967773, -0.023376465, 0.06072998, 0.00907135, -0.0067100525, -0.03173828, -0.00094127655, 0.007797241, 0.0003736019, 0.013511658, -0.019302368, 0.05239868, -0.03765869, -0.030090332, 0.06097412, -0.02746582, 0.048706055, 0.041992188, -0.015022278, -0.044525146, -0.076171875, -0.04156494, 0.017364502, 0.036376953, -0.018737793, -0.071777344, -0.048309326, -0.047943115, -0.01423645, 0.020233154, -0.035339355, -0.012802124, -0.0016765594, 0.0345459, 0.10998535, 0.06945801, 0.029571533, 0.02168274, -0.0010719299, 0.020645142, 0.036224365, 0.024002075, -0.049804688, -0.029083252, -0.011192322, -0.014518738, 0.01763916, 0.014480591, 0.009429932, 0.0020809174, -0.0049362183, -0.011917114, -0.03643799, 0.04083252, -0.02017212, -0.027923584, -0.051483154, 0.0012054443, 0.01940918, 0.038513184, 0.029251099, -0.017150879, -0.03253174, 0.0004708767, 0.010955811, -0.059753418, 0.0021247864, -0.019210815, 0.04559326, -0.058166504, 0.02407837, -0.021209717, -0.0036029816, -0.00043535233, 0.009185791, -0.0060539246, -0.007537842, -0.011230469, 0.023742676, -0.031799316, 0.018127441, 0.038330078, -0.009460449, -0.047821045, 0.04058838, 0.025436401, -0.032348633, 0.0010528564, -0.030899048, -0.027267456, -0.022415161, -0.03265381, 0.000038921833, -0.03274536, 0.04559326, 0.064941406, 0.05239868, -0.03616333, 0.026977539, 0.105285645, 0.025390625, 0.02885437, -0.013748169, -0.021362305, 0.033477783, -0.0021038055, -0.0016641617, 0.0056991577, -0.037963867, 0.03137207, 0.028762817, 0.01007843, 0.045928955, 0.00031781197, 0.023513794, 0.030685425, -0.008026123, 0.020050049, 0.000022292137, -0.0012702942, -0.025146484, 0.08190918, -0.031555176, 0.030059814, -0.0063095093, 0.029464722, 0.0021457672, -0.034698486, -0.025283813, 0.005580902, -0.0055732727, 0.012710571, -0.02217102, 0.0058670044, -0.011268616, -0.016494751, -0.06689453, -0.028808594, -0.037200928, 0.022369385, -0.048736572, 0.009170532, -0.08947754, -0.014282227, -0.045013428, -0.061767578, -0.076538086, -0.029876709, 0.06488037, -0.00579834, -0.05114746, 0.01436615, 0.014343262, 0.0463562, 0.0015087128, 0.046203613, -0.010017395, 0.027038574, 0.011375427, 0.004272461, 0.053894043, 0.059906006, 0.039245605, 0.043151855, -0.026901245, -0.029006958, 0.017196655, -0.019958496, -0.022476196, 0.019165039, -0.020721436, -0.0032157898, 0.06274414, 0.016357422, -0.008773804, 0.02394104, 0.01473999, 0.06677246, -0.014205933, 0.019546509, 0.028701782, -0.04525757, 0.00749588, 0.03668213, -0.00020182133, 0.036834717, 0.0072021484, -0.017990112, 0.05822754, 0.012649536, 0.040039062, 0.020309448, 0.06008911, -0.021743774, 0.02003479, 0.04083252, -0.021408081, -0.005180359, -0.017608643, -0.023223877, -0.0013895035, -0.053100586, -0.055786133, -0.06378174, -0.0079956055, -0.011077881, 0.025314331, -0.000538826, 0.0104599, -0.018753052, -0.03366089, -0.0060691833, 0.044830322, 0.018432617, -0.0149383545, -0.0049476624, 0.017959595, -0.029464722, 0.015472412, -0.094055176, 0.009246826, -0.0005121231, -0.022903442, -0.021942139, 0.033813477, 0.013793945, 0.045013428, 0.024765015, 0.06604004, 0.057800293, -0.004966736, 0.010406494, -0.0060157776, -0.010620117, -0.017150879, -0.011940002, -0.024017334, 0.007675171, 0.006389618, 0.013549805, 0.034454346, -0.0016222, 0.016113281, -0.052337646, -0.0039787292, 0.006526947, -0.0032863617, 0.09631348, 0.017654419, -0.0015258789, 0.066345215, 0.021697998, 0.016189575, -0.011505127, -0.00818634, 0.0317688, 0.00068092346, -0.06311035, -0.013946533, -0.019638062, 0.012924194, -0.040283203, -0.00605011, 0.013572693, -0.032836914, -0.0077171326, 0.028366089, -0.0052757263, -0.04333496, 0.032592773, -0.0059394836, 0.058441162, -0.022460938, 0.005630493, -0.004917145, -0.011962891, 0.0071105957, 0.040893555, 0.0011911392, 0.011268616, -0.0345459, 0.025756836, -0.036010742, 0.010009766, -0.032806396, 0.009986877, -0.061584473, 0.025268555, 0.025482178, -0.0569458, -0.054229736, 0.00019347668, 0.07684326, 0.0055999756, 0.0055122375, -0.058441162, -0.026763916, 0.005138397, 0.066589355, -0.035095215, 0.039733887, 0.0065193176, -0.032958984, -0.04663086, -0.022399902, 0.008987427, 0.0231781, 0.012832642, -0.0052986145, 0.02279663, -0.015808105, -0.069885254, -0.014282227, 0.0033817291, 0.027618408, -0.0118637085, 0.002040863, -0.015930176, -0.054779053, -0.0005197525, 0.049468994, -0.03491211, -0.0065193176, 0.016555786, 0.022491455, -0.03768921, -0.01121521, -0.046569824, 0.014373779, 0.0048828125, 0.0013999939, -0.028182983, -0.008163452, 0.0014925003, -0.021102905, 0.015655518, 0.039520264, -0.024841309, -0.0028762817, -0.03955078, 0.0054893494, 0.014373779, -0.013061523, -0.00012433529, -0.009796143, 0.021102905, -0.010429382, 0.0064697266, 0.015556335, -0.01927185, -0.019805908, -0.042388916, 0.01625061, -0.0027751923, 0.008300781, -0.01234436, 0.022201538, 0.013168335, 0.024368286, 0.021362305, 0.01612854, 0.022521973, -0.012275696, 0.05053711, -0.011199951, 0.015823364, -0.0029468536, -0.02519226, 0.0602417, 0.026306152, -0.012893677, 0.015701294, -0.035949707, 0.02017212, -0.022445679, -0.02619934, 0.068725586, 0.07183838, 0.00844574, -0.02015686, -0.0713501, 0.051818848, -0.07409668, 0.014183044, 0.05545044, -0.028198242, 0.027664185, 0.013969421, 0.07324219, -0.018341064, -0.036224365, -0.020401001, 0.018966675, -0.024337769, 0.024459839, 0.038360596, 0.01687622, -0.06732178, 0.05355835, -0.06210327, -0.022354126, 0.041381836, 0.037872314, 0.01739502, -0.013954163, 0.014961243, 0.00762558, -0.028244019, -0.047088623, 0.037261963, 0.03894043, 0.0034179688, -0.024124146, -0.037322998, 0.04397583, -0.0034809113, 0.024154663, -0.01285553, 0.0317688, -0.041748047, 0.010627747, -0.008132935, -0.0041618347, -0.0395813, -0.031280518, -0.030731201, 0.055633545, -0.0090408325, 0.003993988, -0.020248413, 0.008666992, -0.0015707016, 0.081604004, -0.033111572, -0.041870117, 0.056732178, 0.01789856, -0.0014209747, -0.03729248, 0.007194519, -0.02281189, -0.04006958, -0.043884277, -0.008590698, 0.005821228, -0.0064697266, 0.0010204315, -0.036834717, -0.007511139, 0.0047302246, 0.027740479, 0.0060577393, 0.00969696, -0.014053345, -0.060424805, -0.057159424, 0.038116455, 0.023132324, 0.013923645, -0.009819031, 0.030975342, 0.030227661, -0.011398315, -0.031204224, -0.0970459, 0.034851074, -0.025421143, 0.04876709, 0.054595947, 0.011230469, 0.04623413, 0.021575928, 0.03237915, 0.029174805, -0.00015461445, -0.018447876, 0.013114929, 0.016052246, 0.04171753, -0.0033073425, 0.031402588, 0.014274597, -0.019500732, 0.010414124, -0.002943039, 0.03286743, 0.007896423, -0.010398865, 0.00048828125, 0.00032901764, -0.016052246, 0.013710022, -0.017410278, -0.005126953, -0.0065460205, 0.003227234, 0.020355225, -0.03829956, 0.01687622, -0.0045051575, 0.0012102127, 0.023422241, -0.014152527, -0.004673004, -0.0045776367, 0.010574341, 0.023773193, -0.0062065125, -0.03894043, -0.04727173, 0.02998352, 0.007320404, 0.0473938, 0.047729492, -0.066101074, 0.008117676, -0.02746582, -0.033447266, -0.0073623657, -0.0022773743, -0.0014238358, -0.036315918, 0.00035762787, -0.033813477, 0.01158905, 0.015007019, 0.030349731, -0.024505615, 0.026977539, -0.0042152405, -0.011779785, -0.060272217, -0.0021381378, 0.0007457733, -0.0435791, 0.027526855, -0.045959473, 0.017532349, 0.019180298, -0.032348633, 0.027954102, -0.010505676, -0.011383057, 0.05709839, -0.01991272, 0.032104492, -0.033416748, -0.05166626, -0.014945984, -0.020202637, -0.02355957, 0.0008711815, 0.018081665, 0.011016846, 0.029327393, -0.04550171, 0.038726807, 0.012580872, -0.01512146, 0.0076904297, 0.018218994, -0.009971619, 0.006752014, 0.01184082, -0.012802124, -0.022018433, -0.0019292831, 0.01890564, 0.03164673, -0.034057617, -0.051818848, 0.015838623, 0.0446167, 0.010253906, 0.029953003, -0.0022659302, -0.012283325, -0.009849548, -0.020492554, 0.043304443, 0.036376953, 0.007820129, -0.035583496, -0.06378174, 0.0026760101, -0.043060303, -0.0138549805, -0.027297974, 0.0026683807, 0.019714355, 0.039642334, -0.010482788, 0.0368042, 0.032684326, -0.082214355, -0.0009236336, -0.019714355, -0.01852417, 0.0027637482, 0.019042969, 0.027862549, -0.0211792, 0.020935059, -0.028442383, -0.011833191, 0.03213501, -0.012817383, -0.020828247, 0.020507812, -0.012931824, -0.008934021, 0.04675293, -0.04095459, 0.034973145, -0.0143585205, -0.026351929, -0.017440796, 0.0037403107, -0.07928467, -0.0102005005, -0.010887146, 0.041381836, -0.035888672, -0.025009155, 0.002210617, 0.0059127808, -0.0149383545, 0.04272461, -0.004108429, -0.009552002, -0.033233643, -0.019302368, -0.007522583, -0.033935547, 0.005996704, -0.03515625, -0.03677368, 0.052856445, 0.019729614, 0.011505127, -0.028915405, -0.003030777, -0.020126343, 0.006881714, -0.029052734, 0.06518555, -0.008094788, 0.017333984, -0.00894928, -0.05178833, -0.0059890747, 0.029312134, -0.004951477, -0.03616333, 0.006916046, 0.017868042, -0.010574341, 0.023025513, -0.042388916, 0.0127334595, -0.021820068, 0.029800415, 0.028427124, 0.030776978, 0.026947021, -0.016830444, -0.0057029724, 0.049194336, 0.022750854, 0.04776001, -0.017471313, 0.0028896332, 0.004585266, -0.04232788, -0.026260376, -0.03050232, -0.0060310364, 0.056732178, -0.029144287, -0.025863647, 0.06072998, -0.0015659332, 0.0000166893, 0.019729614, -0.043640137, 0.00982666, -0.025314331, 0.0619812, -0.002445221, 0.033447266, 0.031707764, -0.022277832, 0.011222839, 0.0064315796, 0.0158844, 0.028198242, -0.037994385, 0.02784729, 0.0037631989, 0.007972717, 0.0020961761, -0.0052948, -0.00969696, 0.031173706, 0.019210815, 0.04244995, 0.003255844, -0.008934021, 0.025115967, -0.013793945, -0.0057144165, 0.06677246, -0.07043457, 0.07232666, 0.033477783, -0.00083494186, -0.028579712, -0.022109985, 0.0015335083, 0.03982544, -0.012390137, 0.04763794, -0.088256836, -0.024765015, -0.015556335, 0.0050811768, -0.037719727, 0.019119263, -0.009849548, 0.034179688, 0.045410156, -0.0025634766, 0.030700684, 0.008682251, -0.010803223, 0.01626587, 0.0037765503, 0.027862549, 0.00705719, 0.03643799, -0.007621765, 0.025466919, -0.029937744, 0.062469482, 0.013519287, -0.029281616, 0.033447266, 0.022079468, -0.05255127, 0.04425049, -0.006374359, 0.08294678, 0.04071045, 0.02658081, -0.038238525, -0.004180908, 0.07513428, -0.027282715, 0.020339966, 0.023345947, -0.0017156601, 0.026351929, 0.004383087, -0.015419006, 0.05810547, -0.028533936, 0.024536133, -0.04284668, 0.030639648, -0.019180298, 0.021331787, -0.07006836, 0.00007015467, 0.028762817, -0.01889038, -0.086364746, 0.030792236, 0.03387451, -0.011878967, 0.021881104, -0.0289917, -0.056610107, 0.016815186, -0.024505615, -0.006755829, 0.0076675415, -0.027496338, -0.030456543, -0.012527466, 0.019317627, -0.001253128, -0.00034427643, -0.005332947, 0.029251099, -0.027450562, -0.024429321, 0.014289856, -0.012802124, -0.033355713, -0.021942139, 0.046661377, 0.053710938, 0.01058197, 0.013076782, 0.08154297, -0.009902954, 0.003288269, -0.016281128, 0.011695862, -0.0023860931, -0.022918701, -0.009025574, 0.0008120537, -0.005405426, 0.007663727, 0.016830444, -0.037200928, 0.033172607, 0.021881104, 0.01247406, 0.0592041, 0.061309814, -0.025863647, -0.037628174, 0.0113220215, 0.012969971, 0.06555176, 0.015235901, -0.004348755, 0.021835327, -0.076660156, -0.04748535, -0.0027370453, 0.068603516, 0.033843994, 0.033050537, 0.0056877136, -0.020217896, -0.04550171, -0.018661499, -0.028533936, 0.0064468384, -0.00491333, -0.026168823, -0.0079956055, 0.012504578, -0.025268555, -0.009063721, -0.019851685, 0.005947113, -0.041503906, -0.017791748, -0.010368347, 0.006088257, -0.039520264, -0.006500244, -0.057373047, 0.03338623, 0.018814087, -0.029312134, 0.016036987, -0.03503418, 0.04650879, -0.005241394, 0.032958984, -0.015625, -0.004173279, 0.03643799, -0.0010404587, 0.01878357, -0.004627228, -0.037322998, 0.008911133, 0.013786316, 0.010246277, -0.03829956, 0.023635864, 0.036621094, 0.027740479, -0.045166016, 0.05215454, 0.0003039837, 0.021453857, -0.029678345, 0.04071045, 0.029403687, -0.020874023, 0.019714355, 0.00016307831, 0.031173706, -0.0057296753, -0.0026111603, 0.00018942356, 0.015205383, 0.0010681152 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2011.11938v1
DADNN: Multi-Scene CTR Prediction via Domain-Aware Deep Neural Network
Junyou He, Guibao Mei, Feng Xing, Xiaorui Yang, Yongjun Bao, Weipeng Yan
cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
Click through rate(CTR) prediction is a core task in advertising systems. The booming e-commerce business in our company, results in a growing number of scenes. Most of them are so-called long-tail scenes, which means that the traffic of a single scene is limited, but the overall traffic is considerable. Typical studies mainly focus on serving a single scene with a well designed model. However, this method brings excessive resource consumption both on offline training and online serving. Besides, simply training a single model with data from multiple scenes ignores the characteristics of their own. To address these challenges, we propose a novel but practical model named Domain-Aware Deep Neural Network(DADNN) by serving multiple scenes with only one model. Specifically, shared bottom block among all scenes is applied to learn a common representation, while domain-specific heads maintain the characteristics of every scene. Besides, knowledge transfer is introduced to enhance the opportunity of knowledge sharing among different scenes. In this paper, we study two instances of DADNN where its shared bottom block is multilayer perceptron(MLP) and Multi-gate Mixture-of-Experts(MMoE) respectively, for which we denote as DADNN-MLP and DADNN-MMoE.Comprehensive offline experiments on a real production dataset from our company show that DADNN outperforms several state-of-the-art methods for multi-scene CTR prediction. Extensive online A/B tests reveal that DADNN-MLP contributes up to 6.7% CTR and 3.0% CPM(Cost Per Mille) promotion compared with a well-engineered DCN model. Furthermore, DADNN-MMoE outperforms DADNN-MLP with a relative improvement of 2.2% and 2.7% on CTR and CPM respectively. More importantly, DADNN utilizes a single model for multiple scenes which saves a lot of offline training and online serving resources.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2011.11938v1
"2020-11-24T07:30:52"
"2020-11-24T07:30:52"
{ "title": [ 0.010749817, -0.0018119812, -0.033721924, -0.06304932, -0.0067481995, -0.014564514, -0.043548584, -0.017700195, -0.032165527, 0.021118164, 0.0052223206, 0.011871338, -0.0015993118, -0.04397583, -0.0065078735, -0.0033607483, -0.012458801, 0.032928467, -0.023208618, -0.030395508, -0.029876709, -0.058654785, 0.027404785, 0.059051514, 0.015487671, -0.049224854, -0.09307861, 0.017684937, -0.02734375, -0.029373169, -0.0012426376, 0.049468994, 0.020095825, 0.0501709, -0.018539429, 0.025894165, -0.044525146, 0.03866577, 0.035583496, -0.004924774, 0.011352539, 0.009521484, 0.031341553, -0.057769775, -0.033599854, 0.040802002, -0.052124023, 0.006122589, -0.0003964901, 0.044281006, -0.02935791, -0.000351429, -0.04437256, 0.045166016, 0.0013036728, -0.052337646, -0.04449463, -0.016555786, 0.018127441, 0.08642578, 0.038208008, -0.039520264, 0.010887146, -0.02142334, -0.06414795, 0.0047416687, 0.023422241, 0.020309448, 0.064208984, -0.024246216, -0.044433594, 0.05456543, 0.00028395653, -0.022613525, -0.032409668, 0.023452759, 0.009178162, 0.0005340576, 0.040863037, -0.04220581, -0.0135269165, -0.013687134, -0.016464233, -0.02532959, 0.00013923645, -0.005908966, -0.031341553, -0.02116394, -0.03451538, -0.029327393, -0.013458252, -0.03173828, -0.04119873, 0.044769287, 0.01121521, -0.015609741, -0.032318115, -0.006706238, 0.011734009, -0.012428284, 0.024124146, -0.015823364, 0.0022392273, -0.015808105, 0.02268982, 0.033355713, -0.038269043, -0.041290283, 0.020065308, 0.03652954, -0.00094366074, 0.020599365, -0.00006425381, 0.03010559, 0.015083313, -0.013877869, -0.02319336, 0.015731812, -0.0362854, 0.018615723, -0.0068244934, -0.007648468, 0.01222229, -0.017684937, 0.060424805, 0.019012451, -0.041412354, -0.000084638596, -0.059539795, 0.05279541, 0.004295349, 0.03677368, -0.0748291, -0.04220581, -0.05718994, 0.01838684, 0.0020618439, 0.019577026, -0.005596161, -0.018463135, 0.024765015, -0.021972656, -0.036712646, -0.011978149, 0.036987305, 0.013374329, 0.062042236, 0.013046265, -0.024963379, -0.036102295, 0.01210022, 0.010383606, 0.040405273, -0.0013666153, -0.012840271, -0.03475952, -0.061279297, -0.04623413, 0.020141602, -0.009033203, 0.04156494, -0.021774292, -0.04586792, 0.01512146, 0.04168701, -0.006504059, -0.030395508, 0.029891968, 0.014289856, 0.047424316, -0.020584106, -0.008087158, 0.022872925, 0.0019836426, -0.008392334, 0.018417358, 0.039031982, -0.008674622, 0.03326416, -0.0055656433, 0.0014343262, -0.019332886, 0.02407837, 0.02067566, -0.054595947, -0.0076942444, -0.005683899, -0.009643555, 0.035461426, 0.007293701, -0.016326904, 0.040771484, -0.039886475, -0.043884277, -0.054504395, -0.004257202, 0.041656494, 0.046813965, -0.0031089783, 0.01360321, -0.024490356, -0.030899048, 0.0132751465, -0.013618469, -0.00699234, -0.02571106, -0.013450623, 0.01878357, 0.0046920776, 0.074523926, 0.03100586, 0.0052108765, -0.040008545, 0.034210205, 0.009506226, -0.058013916, 0.016159058, -0.021118164, 0.0034313202, 0.0021419525, -0.010345459, 0.022018433, -0.016357422, 0.0031261444, 0.028747559, 0.008666992, 0.014877319, -0.02243042, 0.060150146, 0.030578613, 0.04486084, -0.046142578, -0.0022125244, 0.032806396, -0.00605011, -0.006996155, 0.0011930466, 0.023986816, -0.005706787, -0.003900528, 0.02053833, -0.019210815, -0.037841797, -0.012825012, 0.03817749, -0.023498535, -0.011726379, 0.0135269165, 0.021209717, 0.024841309, 0.047668457, 0.03579712, 0.04812622, -0.018371582, 0.007320404, 0.059051514, 0.015625, 0.008003235, -0.032165527, -0.010032654, 0.011116028, 0.01020813, -0.036712646, 0.024353027, -0.07543945, 0.023635864, -0.044067383, 0.0014104843, 0.009277344, 0.021331787, 0.026412964, -0.017028809, 0.009162903, 0.014404297, 0.0047569275, -0.039916992, -0.0152282715, -0.00006335974, -0.00063562393, -0.051361084, -0.04067993, -0.012374878, 0.014259338, -0.014312744, 0.024597168, -0.01612854, 0.0009870529, -0.055114746, 0.0096206665, -0.015075684, 0.031021118, 0.019317627, -0.005004883, 0.013656616, 0.011245728, -0.016616821, 0.060913086, 0.027374268, -0.00356102, 0.008300781, -0.00894165, 0.029006958, -0.0072517395, -0.007472992, 0.015319824, 0.081848145, 0.028381348, 0.0076293945, -0.016494751, 0.028015137, -0.06750488, -0.030914307, 0.0010967255, -0.034484863, -0.031982422, -0.037078857, -0.011604309, -0.014389038, -0.05026245, -0.046325684, 0.10797119, -0.016586304, -0.004776001, 0.015991211, -0.0021858215, -0.06604004, 0.032928467, -0.036590576, -0.021728516, 0.029815674, 0.04348755, 0.04537964, -0.030517578, -0.009269714, -0.011558533, 0.008361816, -0.0010795593, 0.030410767, 0.0073394775, 0.028182983, 0.047729492, 0.024673462, -0.00541687, -0.057006836, 0.008087158, -0.054351807, 0.0017185211, 0.010818481, -0.058532715, 0.0039978027, 0.051086426, -0.013504028, -0.0234375, -0.010444641, 0.044311523, 0.008628845, -0.0010223389, 0.000084638596, 0.038085938, -0.030334473, 0.018035889, 0.01876831, -0.026321411, -0.064819336, 0.016189575, -0.056518555, -0.0024089813, -0.06695557, 0.00076007843, 0.04937744, -0.082458496, 0.019927979, -0.0115737915, -0.0064735413, 0.0010261536, 0.027282715, 0.018859863, -0.0038986206, -0.052581787, -0.018798828, 0.016464233, -0.0068855286, 0.018585205, -0.04019165, 0.078063965, 0.015113831, -0.0066604614, 0.0072250366, 0.03488159, -0.017364502, -0.013900757, -0.020050049, -0.0036315918, 0.006500244, 0.018539429, 0.0025939941, -0.015129089, -0.026123047, -0.08453369, 0.0056648254, -0.023162842, 0.01461792, -0.008834839, -0.0036411285, -0.048797607, 0.012496948, -0.021270752, -0.03842163, 0.01687622, 0.038208008, 0.020370483, -0.006225586, 0.023773193, -0.04711914, 0.039916992, -0.045288086, -0.05456543, 0.006324768, -0.011856079, -0.012184143, -0.0012607574, -0.03414917, -0.047576904, 0.0030059814, 0.046295166, 0.047302246, 0.011413574, -0.036010742, 0.059906006, 0.00059080124, 0.029129028, -0.008239746, 0.0008735657, -0.01940918, -0.013412476, -0.029769897, -0.05239868, 0.0012760162, -0.009757996, -0.017227173, -0.045562744, 0.009674072, -0.0005340576, 0.015579224, 0.016433716, -0.03074646, 0.030715942, -0.032684326, -0.0206604, -0.02583313, -0.04623413, -0.0024642944, -0.011779785, 0.04119873, 0.0028743744, 0.07208252, 0.002603531, 0.018981934, 0.03753662, -0.03540039, 0.011276245, -0.035308838, -0.027618408, 0.02619934, 0.0134887695, 0.027313232, 0.0068893433, -0.0070724487, -0.046051025, 0.024871826, -0.04119873, -0.009773254, -0.0031833649, -0.031707764, -0.0109939575, -0.06072998, 0.015777588, 0.0045814514, 0.038970947, -0.0126953125, -0.018539429, 0.008743286, 0.0033435822, -0.049102783, 0.016326904, 0.010574341, -0.03668213, 0.012329102, 0.029510498, -0.013427734, -0.029434204, -0.016677856, 0.044799805, 0.019134521, 0.019714355, 0.003320694, -0.010505676, -0.022644043, -0.018798828, -0.08898926, -0.022964478, 0.047302246, 0.045684814, 0.018554688, 0.028945923, -0.015686035, -0.018585205, -0.02192688, -0.0055274963, -0.00007855892, 0.03427124, -0.019256592, -0.027862549, 0.0574646, -0.042755127, -0.018066406, 0.026992798, 0.044311523, -0.03768921, 0.0016717911, 0.028778076, 0.017105103, 0.0042800903, 0.047943115, -0.0057411194, 0.0012187958, -0.05090332, 0.010574341, -0.013252258, 0.0068092346, 0.027359009, 0.00843811, 0.023849487, 0.022247314, 0.0012702942, 0.0154800415, -0.037017822, -0.005683899, 0.026992798, -0.008628845, -0.010650635, 0.029663086, 0.018600464, 0.02557373, -0.0077400208, 0.021148682, 0.022659302, 0.045196533, -0.02722168, -0.035736084, 0.022583008, 0.050079346, -0.06768799, -0.048919678, -0.06732178, 0.005722046, 0.020812988, -0.009880066, -0.016967773, -0.0012283325, 0.028884888, -0.03414917, -0.013290405, -0.0005197525, 0.021057129, 0.0087509155, -0.027786255, -0.06359863, 0.011421204, -0.027801514, -0.05545044, -0.03604126, 0.025314331, -0.017486572, 0.04727173, -0.019012451, -0.005130768, 0.024002075, 0.028396606, 0.049621582, 0.0440979, -0.027053833, -0.07537842, -0.004180908, 0.0040283203, -0.04449463, 0.024246216, -0.048217773, -0.0059318542, -0.020736694, 0.04095459, -0.013420105, -0.018203735, -0.050201416, 0.0022182465, 0.002664566, 0.011428833, 0.029220581, 0.03286743, 0.01247406, 0.029754639, 0.014205933, 0.020751953, -0.041137695, -0.060272217, -0.0075302124, 0.04031372, -0.00025463104, -0.0009508133, 0.036743164, 0.03967285, -0.03250122, 0.014511108, 0.027893066, 0.03933716, 0.016845703, 0.013473511, 0.01309967, -0.018066406, -0.03857422, 0.033325195, -0.025543213, 0.043182373, 0.023040771, 0.043548584, -0.016052246, 0.005012512, 0.021957397, -0.001616478, 0.006000519, 0.022445679, 0.015609741, -0.09277344, -0.11431885, -0.03741455, 0.09112549, -0.012702942, -0.0017566681, 0.026260376, -0.027999878, 0.010238647, 0.074401855, 0.041992188, -0.0050468445, -0.010551453, -0.01725769, -0.004322052, -0.049804688, -0.07824707, 0.01007843, -0.012969971, 0.010322571, -0.031951904, -0.0012254715, -0.057159424, -0.04095459, -0.012077332, 0.024215698, 0.01852417, -0.023117065, 0.047332764, 0.101745605, 0.0011711121, 0.026062012, 0.00806427, -0.0016670227, 0.015144348, 0.036895752, 0.0016832352, 0.008361816, 0.021148682, -0.020370483, 0.00141716, -0.0026664734, 0.0067367554, -0.0135650635, -0.014381409, 0.01109314, -0.020385742, -0.036621094, 0.021774292, 0.0015077591, -0.04626465, 0.02986145, -0.026031494, 0.019622803, 0.040283203, -0.006298065, -0.006954193, 0.020843506, -0.05078125, -0.037139893, -0.008140564, -0.0690918, 0.017715454, -0.03378296, -0.05355835, -0.039489746, 0.022842407, 0.019943237, 0.016601562, -0.018478394, 0.003982544, -0.058929443, 0.0066719055, -0.0068206787, -0.020751953, 0.03152466, 0.0020008087, 0.0033416748, 0.028442383, 0.034484863, -0.02861023, 0.0048179626, -0.011756897, -0.028930664, -0.011886597, 0.0041236877, -0.0013580322, 0.021133423, 0.02848816, -0.048034668, 0.01651001, 0.035980225, 0.043182373, -0.025360107, -0.002691269, 0.042510986, -0.011734009, -0.023712158, 0.004863739, -0.01991272, -0.02470398, 0.0059013367, 0.0061683655, -0.026809692, 0.017791748, -0.020370483, -0.00034284592, 0.0010328293, -0.04650879, 0.018203735, 0.02407837, -0.013206482, -0.03527832, 0.008575439, 0.015525818, -0.049713135, 0.0059814453, -0.009963989, 0.07104492, -0.03201294, -0.023376465, -0.0043563843, 0.010177612, -0.0087890625, 0.059387207, -0.018066406, -0.02748108, -0.022506714, -0.033294678, -0.023040771, 0.0009045601, 0.011184692, -0.017547607, -0.019073486, -0.055389404, -0.00028538704, -0.013267517, -0.01058197, -0.023010254, 0.0056114197, -0.009788513, -0.046569824, 0.0423584, -0.010322571, -0.028182983, -0.02909851, 0.017547607, 0.05883789, 0.015823364, 0.028823853, -0.03692627, -0.032409668, 0.0021362305, 0.013252258, 0.031143188, -0.036102295, 0.017181396, -0.0009069443, -0.014816284, 0.0473938, 0.01373291, 0.0129776, 0.07171631, 0.04510498, -0.042297363, -0.015617371, -0.013084412, -0.03918457, 0.06347656, -0.049835205, 0.018051147, -0.034729004, -0.046325684, -0.058929443, -0.014656067, 0.051574707, 0.013168335, 0.009239197, -0.002292633, 0.00028419495, 0.0047187805, 0.020568848, 0.011505127, 0.034942627, 0.014167786, 0.020690918, 0.00015568733, -0.030303955, 0.019042969, 0.04647827, 0.002401352, -0.028656006, 0.009185791, -0.027404785, -0.0107421875, 0.04272461, 0.015388489, -0.017807007, 0.0031032562, -0.034301758, 0.03881836, 0.009025574, 0.06109619, 0.026885986, 0.010536194, 0.026824951, -0.0042877197, -0.023422241, 0.019134521, -0.044647217, 0.034362793, 0.04837036, -0.046020508, 0.028366089, -0.027053833, -0.040649414, -0.04296875, 0.00548172, 0.055511475, -0.015945435, -0.019073486, 0.0014457703, 0.050109863, -0.006248474, -0.01096344, -0.047332764, -0.012184143, 0.018203735, 0.024383545, -0.004589081, 0.002614975, 0.0234375, 0.0053901672, 0.008560181, 0.012214661, 0.010269165, 0.05709839, 0.004951477, 0.03692627, -0.048980713, 0.017318726, 0.02217102, -0.020095825, 0.018554688, 0.023651123, -0.034454346, 0.023208618, 0.03427124, 0.016464233, 0.008003235, 0.05923462, 0.02142334, 0.0058937073, -0.06817627, -0.03488159, 0.049591064, 0.022216797, -0.04660034, -0.02128601, 0.016342163, -0.019561768, 0.01576233, -0.02331543, 0.026062012, -0.04425049, 0.009002686, -0.02456665, 0.013671875, 0.019439697, -0.06088257, -0.03274536, -0.031188965, -0.047180176, -0.0055656433, -0.026611328, -0.015602112, -0.020401001, -0.022247314, 0.036010742, 0.0020427704, -0.0072250366, -0.0029525757, 0.003856659, -0.09283447, 0.034423828, -0.032684326, 0.06359863, -0.007171631, -0.01928711, -0.030578613, 0.012191772, 0.029037476, 0.0178833, -0.025894165, 0.0592041, -0.049041748, -0.030670166, 0.022720337, 0.010223389, -0.009124756, 0.019607544, -0.035583496, 0.018341064, -0.021697998, -0.006210327, 0.021957397, -0.04837036, 0.020584106, 0.013084412, -0.03604126, 0.05630493, 0.020553589, 0.0031585693, 0.0078048706, 0.026824951, -0.005039215, -0.001789093, 0.0039901733, 0.022735596, -0.013648987, -0.055725098, -0.0051116943, 0.010604858, -0.0021953583, -0.06112671, -0.07836914, 0.034240723, 0.07165527, -0.014572144, 0.04522705, 0.04510498, 0.013786316, 0.037231445, 0.015975952, 0.00082826614, -0.04550171, -0.03643799, -0.019317627, 0.042907715, 0.018066406, -0.007820129, -0.027420044, 0.02178955, -0.011878967, -0.022415161, 0.02746582, 0.026870728, 0.018005371, 0.029525757, 0.07171631, -0.040283203, -0.026321411, 0.0019369125, 0.052612305, -0.025283813, 0.020721436, -0.027267456, 0.017486572, 0.020339966, 0.0084991455, -0.024291992, -0.0026416779, 0.011680603, 0.016983032, 0.018966675, 0.03189087, -0.016296387, 0.016525269, 0.0053634644, -0.025619507, -0.020736694, -0.015686035, 0.03643799, -0.057434082, -0.0129776, -0.07849121, -0.05368042, -0.024932861, -0.054107666, 0.038726807, -0.0029735565, 0.02961731, 0.03213501, -0.0138168335, 0.0059432983, 0.020065308, 0.008705139, -0.016799927, -0.024291992, -0.04244995, 0.035095215, -0.0013742447 ], "summary": [ 0.046569824, 0.0052757263, -0.030441284, -0.028167725, 0.005290985, -0.038879395, -0.003238678, -0.020843506, -0.0049743652, 0.006893158, -0.028182983, 0.016479492, 0.023544312, -0.036865234, 0.04284668, -0.027832031, -0.024734497, 0.030059814, -0.014450073, -0.028686523, 0.002040863, -0.015716553, -0.033813477, 0.009628296, 0.035125732, -0.06774902, -0.025390625, 0.017044067, -0.0022830963, -0.008552551, 0.00844574, 0.037902832, 0.0071372986, -0.00054359436, 0.03894043, 0.0129776, -0.024871826, 0.011352539, 0.044708252, -0.013771057, -0.0053749084, 0.016738892, 0.07141113, -0.083740234, 0.009971619, 0.09124756, -0.08148193, -0.035339355, 0.02204895, 0.0103302, -0.005962372, 0.0030517578, -0.016342163, -0.0032997131, -0.003704071, -0.007713318, -0.02734375, -0.009651184, 0.02168274, 0.053741455, 0.011802673, -0.012428284, -0.016525269, -0.062927246, -0.038635254, -0.008995056, 0.009155273, -0.0076065063, 0.058654785, -0.017227173, 0.0018634796, 0.054107666, 0.020645142, -0.030578613, -0.01133728, 0.014427185, -0.010375977, -0.022872925, 0.054107666, -0.034210205, -0.06317139, -0.000108361244, -0.06173706, -0.037597656, -0.009391785, -0.010467529, -0.032836914, -0.003698349, -0.026016235, 0.011856079, -0.021255493, 0.004070282, -0.03540039, 0.06518555, 0.012710571, -0.0039138794, 0.0085372925, 0.02444458, -0.0022697449, -0.0024547577, -0.012336731, -0.013374329, -0.022369385, -0.009437561, 0.017440796, 0.008346558, -0.01638794, -0.03942871, 0.026687622, 0.012176514, -0.023513794, 0.012573242, -0.03164673, -0.016998291, -0.0096206665, 0.0064697266, -0.03643799, 0.030090332, -0.013305664, 0.024154663, -0.00049877167, 0.00072336197, 0.060394287, -0.03604126, 0.02508545, 0.022491455, -0.045135498, -0.031829834, -0.03237915, 0.022445679, -0.0013580322, 0.0012369156, -0.029052734, 0.033081055, -0.018661499, -0.00806427, 0.01966858, 0.048187256, 0.02482605, -0.023971558, 0.055847168, -0.040618896, -0.03942871, 0.05883789, 0.02508545, 0.009712219, 0.020492554, 0.01852417, 0.011955261, -0.014862061, -0.0090789795, 0.016815186, 0.062042236, -0.032989502, -0.02406311, -0.0814209, -0.033294678, -0.052703857, 0.031188965, -0.02961731, 0.021896362, 0.021087646, 0.043182373, 0.053466797, 0.032989502, -0.026290894, -0.015167236, -0.0127334595, 0.014518738, 0.002708435, 0.0061073303, 0.0023975372, -0.008522034, -0.015022278, 0.013282776, 0.0049324036, -0.013198853, 0.07397461, 0.0423584, -0.020019531, 0.010215759, -0.039367676, 0.092285156, -0.002210617, -0.051483154, 0.045288086, -0.015930176, 0.030197144, 0.05050659, -0.008872986, 0.011688232, -0.0030555725, 0.01386261, 0.0017995834, 0.008926392, -0.011253357, -0.024993896, 0.014274597, -0.010147095, -0.03225708, -0.00069999695, 0.018341064, 0.0025920868, 0.0051727295, -0.009025574, 0.001584053, -0.015991211, 0.022705078, -0.0103302, 0.040039062, 0.0069732666, -0.023147583, -0.008468628, 0.0077323914, 0.020950317, -0.06359863, 0.03137207, 0.0021972656, 0.008415222, 0.0027828217, -0.001619339, 0.007896423, -0.024261475, 0.029953003, -0.001115799, 0.0020599365, 0.010215759, 0.02796936, 0.04260254, 0.055419922, 0.030227661, -0.07019043, 0.020812988, 0.013671875, -0.029067993, -0.018936157, 0.0041770935, -0.04083252, 0.012893677, 0.038848877, 0.009941101, 0.008918762, -0.036468506, 0.004016876, -0.010131836, -0.04837036, -0.010307312, -0.00019335747, -0.03543091, -0.010482788, -0.005428314, 0.00013101101, 0.031982422, -0.03012085, -0.024841309, 0.05731201, -0.012069702, -0.019317627, -0.017303467, -0.006023407, 0.01651001, -0.0032749176, -0.012565613, 0.012878418, -0.061157227, -0.035339355, -0.032318115, -0.03314209, 0.013404846, -0.041870117, 0.025741577, -0.02609253, -0.009468079, -0.010559082, -0.030532837, -0.058044434, -0.023651123, 0.02760315, -0.0064964294, -0.043121338, -0.027954102, -0.035369873, -0.0042915344, -0.01209259, 0.030471802, 0.017684937, 0.01991272, -0.025772095, 0.025253296, 0.04421997, 0.055908203, 0.03201294, 0.011924744, 0.0023002625, 0.010765076, 0.000009179115, 0.0063095093, -0.0013780594, 0.011634827, -0.022247314, 0.018035889, 0.041168213, -0.028747559, 0.023605347, 0.025939941, 0.011520386, 0.037963867, -0.010002136, 0.010864258, 0.041107178, -0.043914795, 0.028533936, 0.016494751, 0.042663574, -0.04147339, -0.028579712, -0.040283203, 0.017120361, -0.04449463, -0.0047340393, 0.11779785, -0.023025513, 0.03878784, 0.0158844, -0.00015425682, -0.07647705, 0.045715332, -0.014762878, 0.0030708313, 0.0060424805, 0.018829346, -0.0074043274, -0.027954102, 0.0005669594, 0.012832642, 0.006149292, 0.017456055, -0.016952515, 0.02192688, 0.058288574, 0.056274414, 0.022079468, -0.024765015, -0.051086426, -0.02394104, -0.014427185, 0.00655365, -0.004714966, -0.09295654, -0.029663086, 0.059783936, -0.032165527, -0.041229248, -0.0037269592, -0.0072288513, 0.05908203, 0.03591919, 0.029785156, 0.060668945, -0.020828247, 0.045013428, 0.027191162, 0.005718231, -0.1282959, -0.009666443, -0.04324341, -0.02168274, -0.05130005, 0.023147583, 0.04156494, -0.013542175, 0.032592773, -0.013458252, -0.008003235, 0.0069122314, -0.009269714, 0.10998535, 0.015701294, -0.013397217, 0.07006836, 0.0035877228, 0.008735657, -0.017288208, -0.023925781, 0.016967773, 0.033416748, -0.025726318, 0.0025291443, -0.022567749, -0.0046081543, -0.030715942, 0.015007019, 0.05859375, -0.0030460358, 0.039123535, -0.0009012222, -0.03112793, -0.002035141, -0.036956787, -0.022109985, 0.010032654, 0.0072784424, 0.005504608, 0.0033054352, -0.019424438, 0.04699707, -0.009010315, -0.017715454, 0.010772705, 0.026306152, 0.010894775, -0.027923584, 0.008117676, -0.03741455, 0.0003888607, -0.022918701, 0.025878906, 0.018310547, -0.020050049, -0.04824829, 0.0037174225, 0.046966553, -0.03302002, -0.036895752, 0.049041748, 0.060699463, 0.0021781921, -0.038116455, 0.018661499, -0.0024757385, 0.028915405, -0.015098572, -0.007610321, -0.04345703, -0.025527954, -0.015029907, -0.037017822, 0.007797241, -0.026550293, -0.022567749, -0.08886719, -0.025802612, -0.009460449, 0.024765015, -0.0029029846, -0.015617371, -0.020202637, -0.09094238, -0.0024108887, -0.0016584396, -0.009841919, -0.010536194, 0.043121338, 0.04244995, -0.01828003, 0.078063965, -0.019897461, 0.023757935, 0.04840088, -0.016448975, 0.0032043457, -0.0057144165, -0.008392334, 0.012809753, 0.023788452, 0.045928955, 0.021133423, 0.025405884, -0.053253174, 0.0413208, 0.04135132, -0.09790039, -0.0014858246, -0.040130615, -0.018951416, -0.091674805, 0.036743164, 0.009407043, 0.04663086, -0.047424316, -0.0066986084, -0.00012105703, -0.024612427, 0.008804321, 0.032836914, -0.002243042, -0.0058670044, 0.0019302368, -0.0018959045, 0.011650085, 0.020965576, -0.006839752, 0.03753662, -0.0044822693, -0.02633667, -0.0070114136, -0.022247314, 0.11077881, -0.0074653625, -0.030029297, -0.0040893555, -0.035736084, 0.042236328, 0.022109985, -0.0031013489, 0.054748535, 0.008628845, -0.008041382, -0.015304565, -0.0670166, 0.010002136, -0.0592041, -0.049316406, 0.02470398, -0.028320312, -0.013725281, 0.004673004, 0.03262329, -0.03314209, -0.011543274, 0.045410156, 0.033721924, 0.0035800934, 0.016830444, -0.002500534, -0.030090332, 0.0034503937, -0.015991211, 0.011184692, -0.0029087067, 0.02394104, 0.03817749, 0.029830933, 0.043670654, -0.01499939, -0.04675293, -0.030761719, -0.013206482, 0.04208374, 0.030151367, -0.005760193, 0.019836426, 0.009681702, 0.057739258, -0.018188477, 0.00062417984, -0.014755249, 0.012832642, -0.030319214, -0.032440186, 0.012771606, 0.041870117, -0.021194458, -0.0569458, -0.005203247, -0.015930176, 0.02168274, -0.01576233, -0.000050783157, 0.01071167, 0.033721924, 0.028259277, -0.0037117004, -0.02243042, 0.027893066, 0.017059326, -0.054260254, -0.074645996, 0.053833008, -0.021713257, -0.074035645, -0.036254883, 0.019180298, -0.04071045, 0.028427124, -0.015350342, 0.010643005, 0.011528015, 0.004005432, -0.024932861, 0.03692627, -0.027572632, -0.030044556, -0.04611206, 0.0014419556, -0.00017368793, -0.00018978119, -0.02822876, -0.0062408447, -0.006542206, 0.021438599, 0.0015554428, -0.026947021, -0.060028076, -0.013473511, -0.005508423, -0.024902344, 0.053741455, 0.064575195, 0.0071372986, 0.029647827, 0.0053863525, 0.012176514, -0.0041770935, -0.04812622, -0.006626129, 0.00070381165, 0.029190063, -0.02796936, 0.0127334595, -0.010894775, -0.027267456, 0.036346436, -0.024002075, 0.02331543, 0.04525757, -0.030273438, -0.0052986145, 0.019546509, -0.0032672882, 0.0345459, -0.021026611, 0.01876831, 0.054107666, -0.010787964, 0.025161743, 0.054718018, 0.024108887, -0.035888672, -0.0075912476, -0.020751953, -0.012664795, -0.060546875, -0.029586792, 0.0024929047, 0.013153076, -0.018676758, -0.0079193115, -0.018295288, -0.056274414, 0.025741577, 0.04525757, 0.04333496, -0.029769897, 0.005340576, -0.0063934326, -0.007537842, -0.00045871735, 0.017715454, 0.018173218, -0.000048816204, -0.001162529, -0.041015625, -0.018035889, 0.027267456, -0.0037956238, -0.06137085, -0.0010261536, 0.0095825195, -0.0015172958, -0.042755127, 0.03552246, -0.012031555, 0.030715942, 0.03878784, 0.0069847107, -0.030349731, 0.015579224, -0.018173218, 0.021652222, -0.022720337, -0.05493164, 0.04537964, 0.006713867, 0.001821518, -0.013496399, 0.0067443848, -0.0013179779, -0.027832031, 0.0101623535, -0.00011718273, -0.00869751, -0.048553467, 0.033721924, -0.007385254, 0.059753418, 0.023605347, -0.021072388, -0.022399902, -0.0035552979, -0.031280518, -0.018295288, -0.010597229, -0.04421997, -0.0052223206, -0.04473877, -0.039764404, -0.005207062, -0.018859863, 0.015472412, 0.006702423, -0.002735138, 0.024307251, -0.020141602, -0.030715942, -0.0049819946, 0.015991211, -0.008987427, 0.015853882, 0.01689148, -0.031433105, -0.02734375, -0.016357422, 0.00995636, -0.021377563, -0.042114258, -0.034057617, 0.014060974, -0.0041389465, 0.021636963, 0.007572174, -0.015235901, 0.037475586, -0.008293152, 0.035186768, -0.028182983, 0.0037631989, 0.012413025, -0.0128479, -0.00009995699, 0.01197052, -0.039245605, -0.018066406, 0.003419876, 0.0075302124, -0.06149292, 0.020935059, 0.03262329, 0.02923584, -0.03463745, -0.06365967, -0.0011548996, 0.034301758, -0.0076179504, -0.0057907104, 0.015510559, 0.008338928, 0.010559082, 0.009239197, 0.008224487, 0.055267334, -0.00447464, -0.04638672, -0.03994751, 0.029464722, -0.041381836, -0.039367676, 0.003107071, -0.032440186, 0.014350891, -0.040039062, 0.0062294006, 0.012702942, 0.028656006, 0.011009216, 0.037628174, -0.046020508, -0.024719238, 0.002878189, -0.026855469, -0.022857666, 0.011657715, -0.0024528503, 0.007358551, 0.036102295, -0.011688232, -0.042999268, 0.010421753, 0.011001587, 0.06585693, 0.005458832, 0.06365967, -0.025848389, -0.039123535, 0.0027942657, 0.03451538, 0.03274536, 0.018203735, -0.0211792, -0.016036987, 0.007926941, 0.033203125, 0.0024852753, -0.014579773, 0.031585693, 0.023620605, -0.014877319, -0.012535095, -0.017623901, -0.018600464, 0.05999756, -0.0082092285, -0.054016113, -0.080322266, -0.07006836, -0.03326416, 0.0096206665, -0.0121536255, 0.01033783, 0.016433716, 0.009613037, -0.009315491, 0.0077323914, -0.031585693, 0.02104187, 0.017425537, 0.029556274, 0.008087158, -0.009521484, -0.022628784, 0.018753052, 0.037384033, 0.0009608269, 0.021102905, 0.0037784576, 0.002620697, 0.009536743, 0.00223732, -0.01687622, -0.045654297, 0.024597168, -0.03668213, 0.07159424, 0.03967285, 0.091796875, 0.0038394928, -0.019561768, 0.024749756, -0.01965332, -0.014350891, 0.060821533, -0.031173706, 0.009597778, 0.016845703, 0.009056091, -0.05178833, -0.0014181137, -0.013999939, -0.01889038, 0.018295288, 0.03945923, -0.026657104, -0.002363205, 0.028564453, 0.01033783, 0.007659912, -0.012413025, -0.038909912, -0.01638794, 0.0002104044, -0.017501831, -0.0035915375, 0.00093603134, 0.027252197, 0.005710602, 0.0335083, 0.038909912, 0.019439697, 0.033111572, 0.048583984, 0.045013428, -0.06976318, 0.046661377, 0.038513184, -0.013328552, 0.0054016113, 0.03955078, -0.031982422, 0.04940796, -0.037719727, 0.086242676, 0.08642578, 0.050994873, -0.054748535, 0.018325806, 0.09832764, -0.023651123, 0.061706543, -0.029785156, 0.010368347, -0.021133423, -0.0149383545, 0.005207062, 0.018035889, -0.015487671, 0.064208984, -0.03643799, 0.00075769424, -0.015945435, -0.041015625, -0.019729614, -0.005004883, 0.03778076, -0.08111572, -0.009498596, -0.009963989, -0.008361816, -0.023422241, -0.008903503, -0.04385376, 0.003227234, -0.010047913, -0.022598267, 0.0047836304, 0.012184143, -0.035736084, -0.014205933, -0.009750366, 0.04711914, -0.0069084167, -0.033935547, 0.032318115, -0.008514404, 0.03250122, -0.005744934, -0.038604736, 0.061676025, 0.01638794, -0.07757568, 0.024032593, 0.016189575, -0.024719238, -0.03652954, -0.01020813, -0.017044067, -0.028198242, -0.007247925, 0.050231934, -0.011276245, -0.008590698, 0.0021457672, -0.012413025, 0.053131104, 0.0032367706, 0.007118225, 0.034362793, 0.010681152, -0.007671356, -0.014564514, 0.015426636, 0.003408432, 0.0036888123, -0.03829956, -0.022338867, 0.026397705, 0.01939392, -0.024093628, -0.03225708, 0.038208008, 0.033843994, 0.014030457, -0.021820068, 0.039733887, 0.0118255615, -0.013595581, -0.0056266785, -0.005367279, -0.022323608, 0.0052871704, -0.016983032, 0.032562256, -0.0087890625, -0.023345947, -0.030654907, -0.010215759, -0.00021719933, -0.05130005, 0.044799805, 0.05078125, -0.007881165, 0.040893555, 0.06951904, -0.055358887, -0.025344849, 0.0042266846, 0.00274086, -0.0070228577, 0.018630981, -0.0141067505, 0.012214661, 0.002105713, 0.0390625, -0.005138397, 0.031311035, 0.0006184578, 0.011756897, 0.018035889, -0.010650635, -0.017349243, 0.01838684, 0.024353027, 0.010169983, -0.0010070801, 0.022155762, 0.0059432983, -0.051330566, -0.032714844, -0.046813965, -0.064941406, -0.060302734, -0.06939697, 0.039520264, -0.018127441, 0.007713318, 0.07171631, -0.0075416565, 0.015464783, 0.006679535, -0.0016641617, -0.023025513, 0.033477783, 0.008270264, 0.007896423, 0.02130127 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2011.12468v5
Nudge: Accelerating Overdue Pull Requests Towards Completion
Chandra Maddila, Sai Surya Upadrasta, Chetan Bansal, Nachiappan Nagappan, Georgios Gousios, Arie van Deursen
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PL
Pull requests are a key part of the collaborative software development and code review process today. However, pull requests can also slow down the software development process when the reviewer(s) or the author do not actively engage with the pull request. In this work, we design an end-to-end service, Nudge, for accelerating overdue pull requests towards completion by reminding the author or the reviewer(s) to engage with their overdue pull requests. First, we use models based on effort estimation and machine learning to predict the completion time for a given pull request. Second, we use activity detection to filter out pull requests that may be overdue, but for which sufficient action is taking place nonetheless. Lastly, we use actor identification to understand who the blocker of the pull request is and nudge the appropriate actor (author or reviewer(s)). The key novelty of Nudge is that it succeeds in reducing pull request resolution time, while ensuring that developers perceive the notifications sent as useful, at the scale of thousands of repositories. In a randomized trial on 147 repositories in use at Microsoft, Nudge was able to reduce pull request resolution time by 60% for 8,500 pull requests, when compared to overdue pull requests for which Nudge did not send a notification. Furthermore, developers receiving Nudge notifications resolved 73% of these notifications as positive. We observed similar results when scaling up the deployment of Nudge to 8,000 repositories at Microsoft, for which Nudge sent 210,000 notifications during a full year. This demonstrates Nudge's ability to scale to thousands of repositories. Lastly, our qualitative analysis of a selection of Nudge notifications indicates areas for future research, such as taking dependencies among pull requests and developer availability into account.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2011.12468v5
"2022-06-17T09:09:31"
"2020-11-25T01:22:29"
{ "title": [ 0.0005993843, -0.004722595, -0.07562256, -0.049438477, 0.007171631, -0.038879395, 0.015930176, 0.017868042, -0.023544312, 0.023513794, -0.02293396, 0.00089263916, 0.011497498, -0.04156494, -0.005958557, -0.016494751, 0.0034675598, 0.03366089, -0.023406982, -0.028442383, -0.021820068, -0.034210205, 0.0151901245, 0.024841309, 0.0017271042, 0.00856781, -0.052947998, -0.020629883, -0.014076233, -0.023132324, 0.005214691, 0.015899658, 0.017501831, 0.017349243, 0.0043525696, 0.033966064, -0.02027893, 0.026611328, 0.001086235, 0.017715454, 0.035339355, -0.015434265, -0.05407715, 0.015129089, -0.050964355, 0.014778137, -0.054260254, -0.0050697327, -0.0039043427, 0.049926758, 0.010101318, 0.011230469, -0.004638672, 0.04498291, -0.0024147034, -0.051483154, -0.011802673, -0.01184845, 0.03930664, 0.024978638, 0.002029419, -0.04437256, 0.05026245, -0.024978638, -0.03778076, -0.011665344, -0.02204895, 0.038879395, 0.07434082, -0.03982544, -0.041931152, 0.046691895, -0.004081726, 0.012756348, -0.037139893, -0.022750854, 0.030258179, 0.013679504, 0.03604126, 0.011276245, -0.011871338, -0.024475098, 0.030044556, -0.023773193, 0.0101623535, -0.0016746521, -0.015037537, -0.006465912, -0.027236938, -0.032562256, -0.019851685, 0.032104492, -0.033813477, 0.004497528, -0.009536743, -0.039367676, 0.00705719, 0.018341064, 0.017715454, -0.008621216, -0.06311035, 0.021606445, -0.05267334, -0.015510559, 0.0058135986, -0.013076782, -0.012260437, -0.01285553, 0.024490356, 0.053741455, -0.027954102, 0.048187256, 0.018463135, 0.006832123, 0.004486084, -0.027770996, -0.017669678, 0.009155273, 0.0014209747, 0.017349243, 0.028289795, 0.0017442703, 0.02281189, -0.00434494, 0.017440796, 0.0064353943, -0.057739258, -0.003534317, -0.026824951, 0.013267517, 0.006706238, 0.076660156, -0.09661865, -0.08123779, -0.07397461, 0.0385437, 0.022781372, 0.00957489, 0.011650085, 0.0064086914, -0.003004074, -0.020980835, 0.004627228, 0.009346008, -0.00541687, -0.014595032, 0.02507019, 0.010299683, -0.002653122, 0.012557983, -0.026931763, -0.013923645, 0.032226562, -0.018859863, -0.059417725, -0.031173706, -0.1237793, 0.006046295, 0.03567505, -0.0022830963, -0.010070801, -0.021118164, 0.003894806, 0.03024292, 0.020233154, 0.052215576, 0.015960693, 0.017211914, 0.0055122375, 0.062561035, -0.033203125, 0.010894775, 0.043151855, -0.019546509, -0.02067566, -0.00573349, 0.0385437, 0.049102783, 0.028244019, -0.035614014, -0.025054932, -0.029800415, 0.06463623, -0.010536194, -0.031707764, -0.009925842, -0.0074920654, -0.012840271, 0.019882202, 0.008010864, -0.012077332, 0.033294678, -0.04269409, -0.030471802, -0.04849243, -0.009384155, 0.014198303, 0.022262573, -0.011138916, 0.03048706, 0.0056877136, 0.011856079, -0.03353882, 0.02519226, -0.036010742, -0.028839111, -0.012908936, 0.014305115, -0.0211792, 0.061950684, 0.041259766, -0.003396988, -0.022445679, 0.0015001297, 0.0135269165, -0.061279297, -0.019042969, 0.010017395, -0.0131073, 0.0039138794, -0.025268555, -0.014823914, -0.010879517, 0.010879517, 0.034454346, 0.039093018, -0.009590149, 0.010559082, 0.06222534, 0.05731201, 0.03692627, -0.03463745, 0.048187256, 0.04953003, -0.002910614, -0.033996582, 0.02520752, -0.06384277, 0.027359009, 0.03186035, 0.014282227, -0.049468994, -0.010429382, 0.0057754517, 0.023880005, -0.0063934326, 0.0042686462, 0.009422302, 0.03805542, 0.015029907, 0.036193848, -0.009353638, 0.06774902, 0.023956299, 0.02519226, 0.041503906, 0.006587982, -0.025924683, -0.036621094, 0.007820129, 0.03164673, -0.0023994446, -0.046691895, 0.02381897, -0.0635376, 0.009391785, -0.014961243, 0.023956299, 0.01777649, -0.007282257, 0.03326416, -0.0016880035, 0.0082473755, 0.014251709, 0.013412476, -0.044677734, -0.031555176, 0.012039185, 0.0055885315, -0.04107666, -0.03253174, -0.011299133, 0.07269287, -0.00440979, 0.020706177, 0.008102417, 0.03930664, -0.056518555, -0.02734375, 0.015220642, 0.05078125, 0.040100098, -0.012573242, 0.013427734, 0.022445679, 0.006877899, 0.051513672, 0.06506348, -0.020629883, -0.004753113, -0.09484863, -0.011474609, 0.025726318, -0.048095703, 0.000641346, 0.01626587, 0.016418457, -0.0023212433, -0.018554688, 0.0104522705, -0.05279541, 0.035217285, 0.025924683, 0.03466797, -0.032684326, -0.06665039, -0.0079956055, -0.00014126301, -0.08654785, -0.09307861, 0.037017822, -0.046142578, 0.016952515, -0.020446777, -0.0025787354, -0.040100098, 0.015029907, -0.010093689, -0.026504517, -0.00001013279, 0.016723633, -0.00079250336, -0.080200195, 0.02281189, 0.027954102, 0.06915283, -0.002658844, 0.022247314, -0.040100098, -0.03439331, -0.04425049, -0.046905518, -0.016693115, -0.039398193, 0.009033203, -0.0501709, 0.0036640167, -0.021057129, 0.0056915283, 0.023849487, 0.0010824203, 0.00422287, -0.030014038, -0.035858154, 0.029373169, 0.03744507, 0.033721924, -0.008010864, 0.05609131, -0.023880005, 0.012199402, -0.006877899, -0.016235352, -0.014823914, 0.02709961, -0.052368164, -0.023269653, -0.010505676, 0.0126571655, 0.02319336, -0.024719238, -0.020401001, -0.0071144104, 0.00091695786, 0.004020691, -0.012939453, 0.030761719, -0.030715942, -0.0019273758, 0.016555786, 0.0076026917, 0.005191803, -0.0017118454, -0.021118164, 0.07714844, -0.011016846, -0.018920898, 0.061157227, 0.0015573502, -0.0060310364, -0.02798462, -0.019592285, -0.035125732, -0.0079956055, -0.012870789, 0.019592285, -0.036712646, -0.023483276, -0.0513916, 0.015075684, 0.05911255, -0.0019779205, -0.0413208, 0.050964355, -0.05706787, -0.004776001, 0.024856567, -0.01737976, 0.030212402, 0.043029785, -0.000022947788, -0.023956299, 0.0053749084, -0.03768921, 0.017166138, -0.030410767, -0.06896973, 0.026351929, -0.038330078, -0.02532959, 0.008155823, 0.00051784515, -0.023269653, -0.0026721954, -0.00491333, 0.040985107, 0.01737976, -0.00983429, -0.0021476746, 0.018112183, 0.015853882, -0.012107849, 0.011711121, -0.0070266724, -0.014175415, 0.010879517, 0.00051498413, 0.062683105, 0.04425049, -0.014198303, -0.032104492, -0.024612427, 0.0010652542, 0.02720642, 0.012054443, -0.01737976, -0.06008911, -0.039245605, 0.00705719, 0.012878418, 0.0061187744, -0.011199951, -0.010284424, -0.0064735413, -0.032165527, 0.03527832, 0.012710571, 0.029769897, -0.035461426, -0.01386261, 0.013839722, -0.014625549, -0.041778564, -0.010803223, 0.0039901733, 0.027786255, -0.03765869, 0.014213562, -0.037017822, -0.0058631897, -0.0069389343, 0.034942627, 0.024017334, -0.017593384, -0.006137848, -0.061187744, 0.0017662048, 0.019638062, -0.006313324, -0.033569336, 0.026016235, 0.015945435, 0.017715454, -0.053375244, -0.026153564, 0.02104187, -0.082336426, -0.033081055, 0.020080566, -0.042877197, -0.06921387, -0.038970947, 0.014633179, -0.042419434, -0.025741577, 0.02508545, -0.012245178, 0.02545166, 0.01626587, -0.06347656, -0.0076446533, 0.049316406, 0.011482239, -0.0044784546, 0.022521973, -0.008872986, -0.04232788, -0.018981934, 0.0118255615, 0.007259369, -0.004371643, -0.024246216, 0.005153656, 0.014671326, -0.020767212, 0.013961792, 0.017120361, 0.0043258667, -0.004421234, 0.01096344, 0.025558472, 0.030929565, -0.060028076, 0.038085938, 0.06756592, -0.0129470825, -0.097229004, 0.023452759, 0.014808655, -0.047302246, 0.015808105, -0.012176514, 0.03881836, 0.06414795, -0.018630981, 0.03161621, -0.027435303, 0.029403687, 0.02458191, -0.022369385, -0.03768921, -0.07434082, 0.004257202, 0.007709503, -0.019241333, 0.014968872, 0.0057640076, 0.07702637, -0.0030899048, 0.019897461, 0.0039520264, 0.009429932, -0.06762695, -0.013633728, -0.027053833, -0.026397705, -0.03515625, 0.036499023, -0.031433105, -0.003944397, 0.042236328, -0.0018606186, -0.047912598, -0.0017318726, -0.031173706, -0.0027618408, 0.014770508, -0.047729492, -0.002090454, 0.0032653809, -0.06958008, -0.035369873, -0.022918701, 0.0070762634, -0.007881165, -0.004760742, -0.01424408, 0.013328552, -0.002544403, 0.012306213, 0.011314392, 0.0052871704, -0.023406982, 0.010787964, -0.009284973, -0.016616821, -0.0181427, 0.012863159, -0.016494751, -0.032592773, 0.0010786057, -0.0064315796, -0.023239136, -0.040100098, 0.048065186, 0.01940918, 0.03451538, -0.001616478, 0.031921387, 0.034576416, -0.0038642883, -0.0029296875, -0.008583069, -0.024612427, 0.037597656, 0.020553589, 0.0368042, 0.019973755, 0.013870239, 0.022216797, 0.036865234, -0.022354126, -0.019180298, 0.043914795, 0.00081300735, -0.011390686, -0.0013160706, 0.05331421, 0.02104187, -0.01335144, 0.0158844, 0.012435913, 0.040649414, -0.03829956, 0.027816772, -0.009635925, -0.0062294006, -0.01134491, -0.027740479, 0.0026607513, -0.029342651, 0.003873825, -0.036254883, -0.04940796, 0.010910034, 0.056152344, -0.020187378, -0.01966858, -0.008430481, 0.045562744, -0.02128601, 0.020568848, -0.024536133, 0.048675537, 0.016906738, -0.0023822784, 0.0033111572, -0.034820557, -0.058624268, -0.021240234, -0.028121948, 0.019836426, -0.0022010803, 0.04977417, -0.043426514, -0.008369446, -0.010795593, 0.01424408, -0.0010948181, -0.0340271, 0.035461426, 0.08105469, -0.003967285, 0.033111572, 0.058807373, 0.03564453, 0.025726318, 0.02986145, 0.018951416, 0.018432617, -0.0026111603, -0.04055786, -0.004924774, 0.020584106, 0.021774292, -0.026138306, 0.029830933, 0.0012207031, -0.022781372, -0.0418396, 0.027572632, 0.03817749, 0.022094727, -0.008285522, -0.037597656, 0.020263672, -0.03479004, 0.01058197, 0.021118164, -0.057434082, -0.034423828, 0.005367279, -0.035217285, -0.036010742, 0.015167236, 0.000040769577, -0.019195557, 0.0259552, 0.037200928, -0.015602112, 0.016738892, 0.038024902, -0.019210815, 0.011360168, 0.012550354, 0.025634766, -0.020980835, 0.0039520264, -0.029296875, -0.0005040169, 0.02670288, 0.039276123, -0.042633057, 0.002105713, -0.08782959, -0.032226562, -0.043762207, -0.030166626, 0.0035820007, 0.07110596, -0.0028820038, -0.04550171, 0.0046806335, -0.010871887, 0.037628174, -0.018981934, -0.013130188, 0.016464233, -0.0071754456, -0.015975952, 0.028762817, 0.06085205, -0.03805542, 0.018829346, 0.03982544, -0.021530151, 0.0209198, 0.021728516, -0.0056114197, -0.010848999, -0.078125, 0.014213562, 0.02633667, 0.013946533, -0.019805908, 0.025146484, 0.021209717, 0.032073975, 0.015670776, 0.005054474, 0.0602417, -0.014007568, 0.025497437, -0.020858765, 0.017990112, -0.04788208, 0.018966675, 0.012123108, 0.029205322, -0.04638672, -0.044006348, -0.027008057, -0.00497818, 0.038513184, -0.00029492378, 0.042938232, -0.08685303, -0.055603027, -0.0024700165, -0.0050735474, -0.046844482, 0.019470215, -0.015899658, 0.00554657, 0.03250122, -0.0007753372, 0.01159668, 0.004501343, 0.024398804, -0.01423645, -0.02885437, -0.0029563904, -0.025604248, 0.0181427, -0.015083313, -0.0087890625, 0.06286621, 0.007987976, 0.0069122314, 0.044036865, -0.033843994, 0.033355713, 0.04663086, 0.0066070557, 0.048797607, 0.016418457, -0.011672974, 0.024719238, 0.026611328, -0.016433716, 0.024261475, -0.06817627, 0.027130127, -0.026657104, -0.014503479, -0.06829834, -0.0057373047, 0.038391113, 0.030883789, -0.0039634705, 0.0037002563, -0.011398315, 0.0047798157, 0.0043296814, 0.02420044, 0.035247803, -0.030975342, -0.025497437, 0.020965576, 0.0076446533, 0.003967285, 0.023727417, 0.003993988, 0.021255493, 0.027175903, -0.021575928, -0.006542206, 0.029006958, 0.023712158, -0.03591919, 0.006996155, -0.015823364, -0.021499634, -0.012016296, 0.0025978088, 0.05117798, 0.046539307, -0.027328491, 0.013069153, 0.007980347, 0.029129028, -0.053131104, 0.04763794, 0.08703613, -0.095214844, 0.023986816, -0.033996582, -0.04348755, -0.01676941, 0.031555176, 0.014350891, -0.037628174, -0.04019165, 0.036895752, 0.01374054, 0.038116455, -0.033966064, -0.04736328, -0.002380371, 0.06390381, 0.010604858, -0.030761719, -0.0126953125, 0.03387451, -0.0030288696, -0.011489868, -0.03945923, 0.0071640015, 0.004928589, -0.009689331, 0.030441284, 0.001203537, 0.0925293, -0.047821045, -0.054656982, 0.04046631, -0.009094238, -0.06329346, -0.03668213, 0.076293945, 0.045806885, 0.026473999, 0.0597229, 0.01247406, -0.026229858, -0.0072250366, -0.014831543, 0.022064209, 0.026763916, -0.0053215027, 0.0206604, -0.041992188, -0.03463745, 0.009735107, -0.026031494, 0.034057617, -0.005432129, 0.010498047, -0.027832031, 0.027801514, 0.047943115, -0.059631348, -0.060638428, 0.0055732727, -0.0055885315, -0.016738892, -0.0017814636, -0.044647217, -0.033325195, -0.029464722, 0.047821045, -0.014099121, -0.02355957, 0.011993408, -0.029800415, -0.03765869, -0.018478394, -0.01348114, -0.0010490417, -0.01637268, 0.015419006, 0.01902771, 0.0030021667, -0.026687622, -0.057922363, -0.016296387, -0.017486572, -0.022644043, -0.06604004, 0.03805542, -0.001291275, -0.018661499, -0.024841309, -0.016860962, 0.0024642944, -0.016189575, -0.029205322, 0.03010559, -0.032073975, 0.0017623901, 0.0048103333, -0.022750854, 0.030258179, 0.021270752, 0.007637024, 0.032928467, 0.021896362, 0.0018577576, -0.020599365, 0.0052108765, 0.009292603, 0.017425537, -0.03277588, 0.009361267, 0.026000977, 0.0736084, -0.023529053, -0.043914795, -0.0029945374, 0.022979736, -0.018508911, 0.035003662, 0.0049972534, 0.039123535, 0.052246094, 0.068359375, 0.024032593, -0.0914917, 0.0009994507, -0.040924072, -0.0018529892, -0.019851685, 0.0028381348, -0.0473938, 0.0025539398, 0.0015459061, 0.029083252, -0.011024475, -0.017425537, 0.009101868, -0.04248047, 0.023925781, -0.0035362244, 0.009178162, -0.021499634, 0.04031372, -0.010192871, 0.028747559, -0.010551453, 0.016723633, 0.020355225, 0.081726074, -0.00090265274, -0.012336731, -0.0057868958, 0.020645142, 0.00023257732, 0.05279541, -0.032989502, -0.0107803345, -0.00749588, 0.0053215027, -0.02458191, 0.0069847107, 0.033355713, 0.007911682, -0.01058197, 0.0736084, -0.030090332, -0.0011615753, -0.014556885, 0.017654419, -0.055511475, 0.033691406, -0.02720642, -0.027191162, 0.011749268, 0.027145386, 0.024337769, -0.0158844, -0.044433594, 0.00415802, 0.036315918, -0.0149002075 ], "summary": [ 0.0067253113, 0.00094890594, -0.04067993, -0.03994751, 0.004917145, -0.026779175, -0.00000667572, -0.00040984154, -0.011009216, 0.020355225, -0.03579712, 0.0048065186, -0.006576538, -0.025024414, 0.0023174286, -0.025314331, -0.009086609, 0.027511597, 0.00041627884, -0.03967285, 0.024795532, -0.04321289, 0.005367279, 0.016036987, -0.005886078, -0.009941101, 0.029907227, 0.008796692, -0.002960205, 0.0032691956, 0.012817383, -0.023513794, 0.012565613, 0.010040283, 0.020492554, 0.022766113, 0.021087646, -0.0031490326, 0.023468018, 0.018081665, 0.034973145, 0.006679535, 0.011039734, -0.012840271, -0.02911377, 0.023223877, -0.016464233, -0.017608643, 0.04208374, -0.0052108765, 0.011566162, 0.034973145, 0.0034484863, -0.017974854, -0.01852417, -0.00076293945, 0.00037956238, -0.008361816, 0.018234253, 0.02470398, -0.013549805, 0.004550934, 0.018096924, -0.020935059, -0.017166138, -0.008041382, -0.014305115, 0.009559631, 0.05819702, -0.01940918, -0.013572693, 0.032073975, 0.014816284, -0.03363037, -0.016448975, 0.021621704, -0.0039711, 0.008918762, 0.025405884, -0.0090789795, -0.021209717, 0.016860962, 0.040222168, -0.04815674, 0.009147644, -0.016952515, -0.028335571, -0.0043563843, -0.028015137, -0.000101566315, -0.015274048, 0.02027893, -0.060699463, 0.015991211, 0.030914307, -0.043029785, 0.015350342, 0.046081543, -0.010971069, -0.037384033, -0.008529663, -0.0020389557, -0.060150146, -0.011474609, -0.005420685, -0.006980896, -0.021911621, -0.013771057, 0.018051147, 0.035217285, -0.018661499, 0.0060920715, 0.006149292, 0.0018043518, -0.030563354, -0.01374054, -0.02420044, -0.0025501251, -0.013046265, -0.0042533875, 0.0154800415, 0.037902832, 0.0069007874, 0.010398865, 0.0079193115, -0.0002887249, -0.0129776, -0.02508545, -0.012435913, -0.0017786026, -0.014221191, 0.031311035, -0.018722534, -0.013458252, -0.02810669, 0.0016498566, 0.04168701, 0.042938232, 0.028533936, -0.005290985, 0.026351929, -0.008338928, -0.007396698, 0.023880005, 0.00088739395, -0.013381958, -0.017150879, 0.022354126, 0.050598145, 0.077941895, -0.05380249, -0.005214691, 0.062347412, -0.038909912, -0.036346436, -0.10839844, -0.05105591, -0.041931152, 0.05038452, -0.04333496, -0.033935547, -0.028564453, 0.019729614, 0.06781006, 0.029449463, 0.0625, 0.036224365, 0.009597778, 0.016311646, 0.044708252, -0.034729004, 0.0049819946, 0.046539307, -0.0039749146, -0.029571533, -0.012001038, 0.06137085, 0.06896973, 0.027557373, -0.052947998, -0.039916992, -0.035888672, 0.15063477, -0.08557129, -0.021896362, -0.0026168823, 0.017501831, -0.0029563904, -0.0107803345, 0.0025482178, 0.03668213, 0.031982422, -0.0141067505, -0.035949707, -0.030273438, 0.016586304, -0.0027828217, 0.031341553, -0.030471802, 0.025634766, 0.028060913, -0.0000011324883, 0.0076675415, -0.004535675, -0.033325195, -0.004005432, 0.0036258698, 0.0184021, -0.013381958, 0.04019165, 0.014450073, -0.013137817, -0.027801514, 0.024032593, 0.032073975, -0.013442993, 0.0015993118, -0.023651123, 0.017715454, -0.025009155, 0.016784668, 0.03213501, -0.0056915283, 0.025756836, -0.020584106, 0.022232056, -0.025024414, 0.03048706, 0.0073547363, 0.033599854, 0.019836426, -0.0052719116, 0.0524292, 0.08294678, 0.034698486, -0.014167786, 0.0647583, -0.099243164, 0.020187378, 0.02331543, 0.003019333, -0.012161255, -0.02331543, 0.028900146, -0.04510498, -0.038879395, -0.00012934208, 0.017227173, 0.002773285, -0.009819031, 0.029769897, -0.0116119385, 0.03930664, 0.001364708, 0.0345459, 0.008926392, -0.013343811, -0.050750732, 0.016235352, -0.012382507, 0.009803772, -0.06451416, -0.048187256, -0.013000488, -0.06945801, -0.011138916, 0.0043945312, 0.016647339, 0.020080566, -0.05871582, 0.013031006, 0.022964478, -0.013687134, 0.004333496, -0.0032157898, -0.06365967, -0.027801514, 0.023620605, 0.0008111, -0.029327393, -0.054473877, -0.0095825195, 0.03149414, -0.022094727, 0.011360168, 0.048095703, 0.024505615, -0.08416748, 0.029159546, 0.06085205, 0.05883789, 0.040496826, 0.005607605, 0.02381897, 0.0038490295, 0.0058631897, 0.028564453, 0.046875, -0.013465881, -0.008758545, -0.032592773, 0.010368347, 0.011238098, -0.059661865, 0.0045166016, -0.006248474, 0.0063667297, 0.02798462, -0.0051345825, -0.019195557, -0.022583008, 0.022888184, 0.026382446, 0.050323486, -0.02909851, -0.043914795, -0.008430481, 0.022476196, -0.08306885, -0.06677246, 0.081726074, -0.037475586, 0.043060303, 0.007434845, -0.0082473755, -0.07086182, 0.038085938, -0.0007843971, -0.025497437, -0.021911621, -0.04586792, -0.032440186, -0.047851562, 0.05441284, -0.0024662018, 0.0317688, 0.0077438354, 0.013450623, -0.025512695, 0.0010814667, 0.011146545, -0.0390625, 0.0042266846, -0.019958496, -0.034484863, -0.043945312, 0.021575928, -0.028686523, 0.022109985, 0.0031909943, 0.023376465, -0.0053253174, -0.02960205, -0.016204834, 0.0035552979, 0.075927734, 0.043273926, -0.008483887, 0.06222534, -0.042114258, 0.028198242, -0.0047187805, -0.0064926147, -0.013587952, -0.0008573532, -0.034820557, 0.0016241074, -0.0032215118, 0.04107666, 0.020767212, 0.044403076, 0.012245178, -0.01977539, 0.00060749054, 0.0024261475, -0.04598999, 0.060638428, -0.017822266, 0.003818512, 0.038208008, -0.014312744, -0.008285522, -0.0041275024, -0.035949707, 0.0803833, 0.00067329407, 0.008003235, 0.06341553, 0.012489319, -0.0070533752, -0.027664185, -0.00598526, 0.0007991791, -0.014419556, -0.025390625, -0.006385803, -0.017150879, -0.0041999817, -0.01197052, -0.0069389343, 0.036193848, 0.0023536682, -0.016845703, 0.02180481, -0.005680084, -0.012886047, 0.05709839, -0.00040864944, 0.011680603, -0.000104784966, 0.04071045, -0.013244629, 0.017486572, -0.004673004, 0.017089844, -0.055999756, -0.024459839, 0.021148682, -0.03933716, -0.023254395, 0.004585266, 0.021881104, -0.01424408, -0.011070251, 0.009887695, 0.007095337, -0.0032539368, -0.010231018, -0.04156494, 0.016098022, 0.01084137, -0.028427124, 0.009643555, 0.032287598, -0.036193848, 0.046783447, 0.004722595, 0.014762878, 0.051696777, -0.05883789, -0.040283203, -0.036315918, -0.016540527, -0.018325806, 0.0063285828, -0.017410278, -0.033569336, -0.035186768, -0.0039787292, 0.01727295, -0.017913818, -0.0038928986, 0.010353088, 0.019042969, -0.024917603, 0.04812622, 0.009162903, 0.018875122, -0.006729126, -0.019424438, 0.009544373, 0.005836487, -0.050842285, -0.024414062, 0.01979065, 0.052246094, -0.055419922, 0.021469116, -0.036590576, 0.013427734, 0.022705078, -0.016189575, 0.013870239, -0.013175964, -0.0007967949, -0.037475586, 0.019424438, -0.009101868, 0.027069092, -0.02470398, -0.009155273, 0.023864746, -0.02859497, -0.066833496, -0.023895264, -0.0028190613, -0.06088257, -0.049316406, 0.0052108765, -0.043518066, -0.06555176, -0.0069236755, 0.0006046295, -0.0236969, 0.006843567, 0.003862381, -0.012275696, 0.040985107, 0.015312195, -0.05404663, -0.017623901, 0.0184021, 0.038085938, 0.009880066, 0.008926392, 0.021133423, -0.01927185, -0.023330688, -0.011650085, -0.025802612, -0.01626587, -0.051513672, 0.030029297, -0.009407043, -0.0059165955, 0.02507019, 0.00472641, -0.0019836426, 0.010681152, -0.0019035339, 0.0385437, 0.079956055, -0.08947754, -0.010520935, 0.101257324, -0.0069236755, -0.099121094, 0.058380127, 0.0063819885, -0.010734558, 0.012908936, 0.0066566467, 0.014045715, 0.021957397, -0.003522873, -0.00573349, -0.033691406, 0.01763916, 0.053466797, 0.028427124, -0.04296875, -0.084350586, -0.0030727386, 0.049194336, -0.010986328, 0.001159668, 0.013801575, 0.03265381, 0.0023918152, 0.0041122437, 0.008003235, 0.008300781, -0.046447754, -0.022003174, 0.005821228, -0.019714355, -0.04260254, 0.0126953125, -0.011978149, 0.007396698, -0.0039482117, -0.015930176, -0.038146973, 0.03665161, -0.06124878, 0.018981934, -0.013519287, -0.04638672, -0.0033016205, -0.008972168, -0.027694702, -0.010055542, -0.019470215, -0.046295166, -0.00699234, -0.0048065186, -0.01966858, -0.00554657, -0.006706238, 0.017532349, 0.024230957, 0.030426025, -0.023529053, -0.0041389465, 0.0033283234, 0.005847931, -0.010009766, 0.030715942, -0.008491516, -0.017959595, -0.01902771, -0.01184845, -0.026229858, -0.050628662, 0.03869629, 0.036834717, 0.0054779053, -0.012214661, 0.007663727, 0.021026611, 0.011070251, -0.015151978, -0.005973816, -0.009307861, 0.050994873, 0.0049591064, 0.030181885, 0.034301758, -0.0132751465, -0.028381348, 0.022384644, -0.019317627, 0.009132385, 0.023071289, -0.016311646, -0.021896362, 0.038146973, 0.008216858, 0.056121826, 0.00022518635, 0.04321289, 0.026931763, 0.033477783, 0.024108887, 0.019927979, -0.01675415, -0.012001038, -0.026901245, -0.014556885, 0.011421204, -0.039855957, 0.0013046265, -0.0231781, -0.029678345, 0.0046920776, 0.024261475, -0.012580872, -0.010383606, -0.01751709, 0.008995056, -0.032714844, -0.026687622, -0.084228516, 0.082458496, 0.022705078, -0.021362305, 0.016220093, -0.025604248, -0.024230957, -0.041534424, 0.017196655, 0.024276733, 0.012229919, 0.024749756, -0.009483337, -0.0060539246, -0.016860962, 0.011291504, -0.008956909, -0.037506104, -0.031921387, 0.021194458, 0.0084991455, -0.012184143, 0.10498047, 0.0003502369, -0.045837402, -0.0003619194, -0.015945435, 0.032928467, -0.045013428, -0.066589355, -0.033966064, 0.0036354065, 0.0036144257, 0.000746727, 0.015449524, 0.021102905, -0.035064697, -0.01838684, 0.02218628, 0.047698975, 0.056274414, -0.047790527, -0.019989014, 0.018249512, -0.054595947, 0.03050232, 0.020111084, -0.01158905, -0.005493164, -0.013801575, 0.0002772808, -0.046875, -0.0042800903, 0.0035953522, 0.0049743652, 0.055877686, 0.015312195, -0.04156494, 0.027160645, 0.04928589, -0.04248047, 0.025894165, -0.028045654, 0.03656006, 0.010437012, 0.029586792, -0.032714844, 0.007980347, -0.0042533875, 0.017974854, 0.0052604675, 0.01890564, -0.09777832, -0.028503418, -0.048828125, -0.06970215, -0.027877808, 0.11785889, -0.009803772, -0.023956299, -0.0023555756, -0.0047302246, 0.04208374, -0.03439331, -0.042816162, 0.0008678436, -0.008705139, -0.027801514, 0.009567261, 0.043762207, -0.06060791, 0.003080368, 0.040008545, -0.012878418, 0.047302246, -0.008071899, 0.00018405914, 0.01902771, -0.051452637, 0.025360107, 0.025665283, -0.0040016174, 0.00932312, 0.0025520325, -0.0057868958, 0.059173584, -0.0025348663, -0.009895325, 0.007965088, 0.047210693, 0.03326416, 0.0044174194, 0.036743164, -0.01423645, -0.00579834, -0.016281128, 0.027786255, -0.024154663, -0.029418945, 0.0074920654, -0.00066900253, 0.011138916, -0.0025100708, 0.014854431, -0.06896973, -0.028442383, 0.03390503, -0.0035572052, -0.03866577, -0.013267517, -0.0034885406, 0.0074882507, 0.02684021, 0.032440186, 0.00070762634, 0.039276123, -0.0211792, -0.031204224, -0.023147583, 0.024169922, 0.028305054, 0.02746582, 0.0018987656, -0.0067367554, 0.031219482, 0.013259888, -0.0074386597, 0.011047363, 0.0028190613, 0.03439331, 0.049987793, -0.004837036, 0.007419586, -0.026977539, -0.006828308, 0.016281128, 0.0039863586, -0.020614624, 0.024856567, -0.0395813, 0.00957489, -0.006969452, -0.03152466, 0.019210815, -0.010932922, 0.029968262, -0.019302368, 0.010353088, -0.004825592, -0.034179688, 0.021575928, -0.04837036, 0.033203125, -0.028259277, -0.017807007, -0.024658203, 0.034729004, 0.034240723, -0.01159668, 0.014778137, -0.008430481, 0.042510986, 0.029312134, -0.024658203, -0.01914978, 0.017150879, 0.019577026, -0.027420044, 0.01512146, 0.0012998581, -0.026748657, -0.0043640137, 0.013687134, 0.018066406, 0.01701355, 0.06021118, -0.0073432922, -0.002412796, 0.016204834, -0.07196045, 0.03817749, 0.02267456, -0.023117065, -0.03643799, -0.034729004, -0.001285553, -0.0046920776, 0.03555298, 0.015159607, -0.028778076, 0.0033512115, -0.0027065277, 0.008712769, 0.010353088, -0.056243896, -0.050109863, 0.009132385, 0.08306885, 0.0020580292, -0.026184082, -0.07489014, 0.0073013306, -0.02357483, -0.02418518, -0.034301758, -0.014205933, 0.03186035, -0.061035156, 0.017791748, 0.02166748, 0.08508301, -0.039794922, -0.039031982, 0.010696411, 0.0018882751, -0.06488037, -0.033233643, 0.096069336, 0.048065186, 0.03262329, 0.06137085, -0.035125732, -0.0012187958, 0.040985107, 0.011657715, 0.008293152, 0.020477295, 0.011360168, -0.0021095276, -0.029174805, 0.0059776306, -0.017501831, -0.00023257732, -0.0107040405, -0.024414062, 0.007537842, -0.014541626, 0.0011577606, 0.021408081, -0.032318115, -0.030273438, -0.0073242188, 0.025482178, -0.0104599, -0.018875122, -0.052612305, -0.024536133, -0.0390625, 0.053344727, -0.0143966675, -0.018325806, -0.004512787, 0.002664566, -0.0041389465, -0.03778076, -0.02420044, 0.0155181885, -0.023376465, 0.0023880005, 0.015556335, 0.02494812, -0.040771484, -0.062072754, 0.0038700104, -0.005508423, 0.004085541, -0.09637451, 0.055847168, 0.031204224, -0.008323669, 0.0012922287, -0.045684814, -0.0027885437, -0.009498596, 0.009521484, -0.03414917, -0.028656006, 0.07220459, 0.014968872, -0.013290405, -0.019607544, 0.024505615, -0.007865906, 0.07348633, 0.018218994, -0.026748657, 0.0031356812, -0.0060768127, -0.0077590942, 0.020385742, -0.050964355, 0.037078857, -0.014526367, 0.05709839, 0.00080156326, 0.010070801, 0.00970459, 0.022994995, -0.009552002, 0.011482239, -0.027435303, 0.01838684, 0.06137085, 0.06878662, 0.02809143, -0.05984497, 0.022964478, -0.024520874, -0.0053596497, -0.042633057, -0.001449585, -0.062469482, -0.024612427, 0.0069770813, 0.00970459, 0.0003836155, -0.04144287, -0.0075187683, -0.022232056, -0.00034475327, 0.00025129318, 0.0129776, -0.0101623535, -0.019180298, 0.016952515, 0.02861023, -0.0015106201, 0.0026454926, -0.0012464523, 0.09515381, -0.044647217, 0.035247803, -0.049926758, -0.0051651, -0.014282227, 0.013893127, -0.03302002, 0.025283813, -0.0065727234, -0.016326904, -0.015975952, -0.037384033, 0.032806396, -0.013061523, -0.039611816, 0.111694336, -0.009262085, -0.048309326, -0.017944336, 0.020751953, -0.017211914, -0.012283325, 0.017150879, -0.030319214, 0.016708374, 0.032318115, 0.03555298, -0.020629883, 0.015327454, 0.056488037, 0.019042969, 0.0129776 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2012.01126v1
Pain Intensity Assessment in Sickle Cell Disease patients using Vital Signs during Hospital Visits
Swati Padhee, Amanuel Alambo, Tanvi Banerjee, Arvind Subramaniam, Daniel M. Abrams, Gary K. Nave Jr., Nirmish Shah
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.LG
Pain in sickle cell disease (SCD) is often associated with increased morbidity, mortality, and high healthcare costs. The standard method for predicting the absence, presence, and intensity of pain has long been self-report. However, medical providers struggle to manage patients based on subjective pain reports correctly and pain medications often lead to further difficulties in patient communication as they may cause sedation and sleepiness. Recent studies have shown that objective physiological measures can predict subjective self-reported pain scores for inpatient visits using machine learning (ML) techniques. In this study, we evaluate the generalizability of ML techniques to data collected from 50 patients over an extended period across three types of hospital visits (i.e., inpatient, outpatient and outpatient evaluation). We compare five classification algorithms for various pain intensity levels at both intra-individual (within each patient) and inter-individual (between patients) level. While all the tested classifiers perform much better than chance, a Decision Tree (DT) model performs best at predicting pain on an 11-point severity scale (from 0-10) with an accuracy of 0.728 at an inter-individual level and 0.653 at an intra-individual level. The accuracy of DT significantly improves to 0.941 on a 2-point rating scale (i.e., no/mild pain: 0-5, severe pain: 6-10) at an intra-individual level. Our experimental results demonstrate that ML techniques can provide an objective and quantitative evaluation of pain intensity levels for all three types of hospital visits.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2012.01126v1
"2020-11-24T15:25:29"
"2020-11-24T15:25:29"
{ "title": [ 0.012084961, -0.010269165, -0.009002686, -0.011413574, -0.017974854, 0.0027503967, 0.00957489, -0.041748047, -0.0109939575, 0.029052734, -0.011306763, 0.008407593, 0.006095886, -0.04296875, -0.005821228, 0.00869751, 0.027877808, 0.0035247803, 0.034576416, 0.00013899803, 0.022018433, 0.01914978, 0.047668457, 0.03930664, -0.022720337, -0.00028562546, -0.05206299, 0.023406982, -0.016296387, -0.012893677, -0.008506775, 0.0041389465, 0.026382446, 0.024002075, -0.041290283, -0.011062622, -0.03640747, 0.038909912, -0.016601562, 0.03111267, 0.004623413, -0.02041626, 0.02420044, -0.054382324, 0.00459671, 0.041748047, -0.040222168, -0.038513184, -0.007537842, 0.00019395351, 0.017028809, 0.0098724365, 0.026153564, 0.032470703, -0.015327454, -0.019256592, 0.008468628, -0.03756714, 0.060791016, -0.040740967, -0.021331787, -0.06427002, 0.05105591, 0.0030078888, -0.009506226, -0.011222839, -0.027923584, 0.023925781, 0.079956055, 0.01499176, -0.009254456, 0.027008057, 0.008613586, 0.03845215, -0.009170532, -0.040527344, 0.03881836, 0.029220581, 0.024902344, 0.0073432922, -0.0040893555, 0.0013389587, 0.030029297, -0.028961182, 0.011100769, 0.0065307617, -0.0090789795, -0.0059928894, -0.033233643, -0.030303955, -0.010734558, 0.029922485, -0.033111572, -0.016921997, -0.019439697, -0.03982544, -0.018371582, 0.014007568, 0.007843018, -0.011192322, -0.034423828, 0.015792847, -0.05038452, -0.006351471, -0.00088500977, 0.030532837, -0.00027155876, -0.025390625, -0.0013580322, 0.023162842, -0.02645874, 0.0027942657, -0.004211426, -0.022140503, -0.009605408, 0.021240234, -0.007904053, 0.008560181, 0.023284912, 0.039367676, -0.004562378, 0.0053367615, -0.018829346, 0.028839111, 0.0060806274, 0.017715454, 0.016464233, -0.009117126, -0.06222534, 0.002714157, 0.0038528442, 0.033691406, -0.03945923, -0.011100769, -0.03741455, 0.014457703, -0.0070114136, 0.008636475, -0.0090789795, -0.0155181885, 0.052246094, -0.022277832, 0.003534317, 0.009880066, 0.013595581, -0.0044517517, 0.02659607, 0.026901245, -0.007972717, -0.012741089, 0.0022830963, -0.012451172, 0.019485474, -0.013381958, -0.11419678, 0.015563965, -0.13989258, 0.04724121, -0.0038757324, 0.00920105, -0.008216858, 0.019241333, 0.032684326, 0.022476196, 0.038909912, -0.028366089, -0.016906738, 0.019073486, 0.02078247, 0.014297485, -0.0024051666, 0.027770996, 0.026397705, -0.018035889, -0.007385254, -0.008338928, 0.019195557, 0.03338623, -0.014083862, -0.028442383, 0.0036182404, -0.022003174, 0.0051231384, 0.021209717, -0.038635254, -0.017913818, -0.001701355, -0.019378662, 0.032287598, -0.0059127808, -0.0008215904, 0.03112793, -0.021484375, 0.01701355, -0.024154663, -0.02305603, -0.0055274963, 0.025848389, -0.016555786, -0.0309906, -0.025344849, 0.00020217896, -0.015220642, -0.013153076, -0.0073547363, -0.045013428, -0.0063705444, 0.029556274, 0.030960083, 0.011352539, 0.0013227463, 0.00491333, -0.00046563148, -0.056365967, -0.05709839, -0.01096344, 0.008888245, 0.015449524, -0.012710571, -0.0034770966, -0.020858765, -0.023803711, 0.0024986267, 0.033447266, -0.011184692, -0.017852783, -0.00054359436, -0.029769897, -0.00009280443, 0.010726929, 0.019500732, 0.016845703, 0.035888672, 0.04800415, -0.007106781, 0.02494812, 0.034606934, -0.0063972473, -0.007156372, 0.005138397, 0.019851685, -0.007904053, 0.004497528, 0.0048446655, 0.030532837, -0.015350342, 0.029571533, -0.0026798248, 0.011581421, -0.0021419525, 0.018432617, -0.020507812, 0.040252686, 0.02861023, 0.0028629303, 0.047607422, -0.0077667236, -0.0002834797, -0.024490356, 0.0129776, 0.013587952, 0.008201599, -0.005607605, 0.012023926, 0.013397217, 0.009010315, 0.022842407, 0.038146973, -0.0010814667, 0.03149414, -0.0038108826, -0.061340332, 0.0064697266, -0.0010900497, -0.03930664, -0.009361267, 0.019454956, 0.0064582825, -0.020462036, -0.04562378, -0.031204224, -0.0068206787, -0.0078125, -0.010139465, -0.011184692, -0.012786865, 0.035736084, 0.022079468, -0.037322998, -0.03378296, 0.010231018, 0.041229248, -0.011894226, 0.009315491, -0.011169434, -0.007499695, -0.0017709732, 0.038330078, -0.0048446655, -0.008575439, -0.0703125, 0.00217247, -0.010635376, -0.009628296, -0.0256958, 0.011314392, -0.038238525, 0.055023193, -0.0007443428, -0.0814209, 0.09387207, 0.101867676, 0.0178833, -0.01423645, -0.01927185, -0.034210205, -0.02053833, -0.0057678223, -0.056518555, 0.019683838, -0.0061149597, -0.052001953, 0.031982422, -0.008987427, -0.002811432, -0.016937256, -0.002603531, 0.013015747, -0.050811768, 0.029876709, 0.05407715, 0.006134033, -0.013061523, -0.00667572, 0.0126571655, 0.014770508, 0.010322571, -0.010032654, -0.012794495, 0.012649536, 0.018692017, -0.013809204, -0.008125305, -0.023254395, 0.03881836, -0.05215454, 0.016845703, -0.004749298, -0.033569336, 0.019607544, 0.0025024414, -0.014167786, -0.013328552, 0.016403198, 0.053771973, 0.02986145, -0.008918762, 0.024459839, 0.0357666, -0.007621765, 0.049621582, 0.03225708, 0.040527344, 0.03314209, -0.03111267, -0.095214844, -0.002904892, 0.023544312, 0.031982422, 0.014511108, -0.05041504, 0.0015954971, 0.001414299, 0.00057554245, 0.054901123, 0.0045547485, -0.023880005, -0.025360107, -0.023513794, -0.043060303, 0.017990112, -0.029830933, 0.025741577, -0.0110321045, 0.117126465, -0.012825012, -0.0026950836, 0.013664246, 0.044525146, 0.03152466, -0.034210205, -0.08404541, -0.020111084, -0.048828125, -0.0074310303, 0.007167816, 0.00969696, -0.0011491776, 0.00097084045, -0.025482178, 0.026016235, -0.0044784546, -0.012542725, 0.023239136, -0.048553467, 0.030227661, 0.004825592, -0.010284424, 0.012878418, 0.033691406, -0.015991211, 0.030334473, -0.04119873, 0.043395996, -0.017868042, -0.021362305, -0.08502197, 0.006996155, -0.021728516, 0.018737793, 0.043426514, -0.050689697, -0.014282227, 0.0029182434, 0.0026378632, 0.020828247, 0.02305603, 0.000056028366, -0.0048179626, -0.026504517, -0.0018453598, -0.027877808, -0.005493164, -0.05444336, -0.019454956, -0.009681702, -0.016815186, 0.05645752, -0.0038261414, 0.009727478, -0.016647339, 0.011192322, 0.020462036, 0.047302246, -0.0005068779, -0.020690918, -0.006500244, -0.013145447, -0.023483276, -0.030288696, -0.007205963, 0.02331543, -0.018112183, -0.0015764236, 0.0005373955, 0.02267456, 0.005180359, 0.030212402, -0.027359009, -0.04171753, -0.03189087, -0.034576416, -0.0027637482, -0.023529053, -0.016601562, -0.010437012, 0.031951904, -0.002729416, -0.05819702, 0.03451538, -0.033966064, 0.027435303, -0.012489319, -0.0062942505, 0.0015554428, 0.026428223, -0.020568848, 0.008811951, 0.008728027, 0.022201538, 0.034942627, 0.0065727234, -0.021606445, -0.061401367, -0.044708252, 0.019317627, -0.12231445, -0.025115967, 0.044311523, -0.042663574, -0.0011358261, -0.02305603, 0.029647827, -0.010688782, 0.014640808, -0.025772095, 0.028533936, -0.043273926, -0.036743164, -0.07904053, -0.07836914, 0.04864502, -0.04046631, 0.022155762, 0.015319824, 0.015167236, -0.019470215, -0.021896362, 0.015411377, 0.016021729, -0.026443481, -0.024597168, 0.008720398, 0.011634827, -0.0051574707, 0.00856781, 0.03164673, -0.03250122, 0.034362793, 0.009025574, 0.013793945, 0.0137786865, -0.013313293, 0.051116943, 0.018814087, -0.013160706, -0.037200928, -0.014144897, -0.011566162, -0.046051025, -0.011688232, -0.03604126, -0.018371582, 0.02281189, 0.06970215, 0.09020996, 0.03012085, 0.025512695, -0.028137207, -0.07684326, -0.0028362274, 0.022750854, 0.03918457, -0.0569458, 0.007286072, -0.009590149, -0.0008378029, 0.03439331, -0.022338867, -0.00730896, 0.0063476562, 0.0234375, -0.091430664, -0.052246094, -0.031188965, -0.0692749, -0.032104492, 0.033416748, 0.0017700195, -0.046905518, 0.04498291, 0.036193848, -0.083496094, -0.015327454, 0.03616333, -0.049224854, 0.05441284, -0.04019165, -0.0058631897, 0.005683899, -0.08514404, -0.017959595, -0.021484375, -0.0044517517, 0.045532227, -0.027297974, -0.025115967, -0.037902832, 0.031402588, 0.018463135, 0.024963379, 0.010437012, -0.016448975, -0.07397461, 0.0010375977, 0.019638062, -0.039398193, 0.048309326, -0.014175415, -0.008277893, -0.022415161, -0.007434845, 0.0008802414, -0.0009822845, -0.009544373, -0.040649414, 0.03427124, -0.025543213, 0.007598877, -0.0034236908, -0.013458252, 0.039978027, -0.0057411194, -0.030426025, 0.0039405823, 0.060394287, 0.033935547, 0.0015878677, -0.0018386841, 0.024719238, 0.021652222, -0.0079422, -0.027114868, -0.0013017654, -0.010147095, 0.012786865, 0.0003387928, 0.009819031, -0.06512451, -0.028747559, -0.02053833, -0.04458618, -0.00056028366, -0.07006836, 0.010627747, -0.018341064, 0.03302002, -0.02218628, -0.029022217, 0.03189087, -0.058288574, 0.030044556, -0.032196045, 0.027893066, 0.030426025, -0.022232056, -0.046142578, -0.0026016235, -0.013839722, 0.010467529, 0.04296875, 0.0041999817, -0.06008911, 0.022125244, -0.019561768, 0.02381897, 0.004211426, -0.0390625, -0.015434265, -0.0031089783, 0.03866577, 0.033721924, 0.008636475, -0.012542725, -0.049438477, 0.0044441223, -0.01586914, 0.02670288, -0.042144775, -0.02784729, 0.032714844, 0.02798462, 0.0031223297, 0.018234253, 0.0073547363, -0.013977051, 0.053955078, 0.023849487, 0.0013504028, -0.00020754337, 0.0062332153, -0.039245605, 0.043426514, 0.0033073425, 0.0032672882, 0.026870728, 0.0043182373, -0.023742676, -0.0026817322, -0.004436493, 0.029037476, 0.009269714, -0.012496948, -0.021102905, -0.022003174, 0.034484863, -0.005760193, -0.018966675, 0.004722595, -0.026885986, 0.0101623535, 0.07678223, -0.040130615, 0.039611816, 0.01751709, -0.03366089, -0.016937256, -0.07611084, 0.024169922, -0.0124053955, 0.033996582, -0.01953125, -0.0033130646, -0.041748047, 0.025863647, 0.03062439, -0.026321411, -0.0026187897, 0.019119263, 0.010612488, 0.022140503, 0.012077332, -0.06640625, -0.026535034, 0.09490967, 0.015434265, 0.035003662, 0.005718231, -0.01335144, -0.046813965, 0.0037899017, -0.070129395, -0.016418457, 0.05114746, 0.036132812, -0.0049972534, -0.0119018555, 0.03050232, -0.012641907, 0.0051460266, 0.014968872, -0.033599854, 0.039764404, -0.004207611, -0.032928467, -0.03967285, 0.021392822, 0.029022217, -0.0020370483, 0.011444092, -0.0010929108, -0.02734375, 0.024963379, -0.007980347, -0.035949707, 0.012229919, 0.025054932, 0.019241333, -0.027786255, -0.017288208, 0.05001831, -0.03741455, -0.076538086, -0.009414673, 0.016342163, 0.009407043, 0.060668945, -0.007194519, -0.064086914, -0.012825012, -0.035003662, -0.016784668, 0.026107788, 0.030532837, -0.0259552, 0.023117065, -0.040283203, 0.013282776, -0.009307861, -0.008239746, -0.037597656, 0.005554199, 0.0067481995, 0.038116455, 0.012229919, -0.009109497, 0.028396606, -0.099243164, 0.007972717, -0.020828247, 0.039764404, -0.034973145, 0.044799805, 0.0077209473, -0.025634766, 0.0047073364, 0.015655518, 0.0035991669, -0.028289795, 0.030944824, -0.015655518, 0.033294678, 0.04711914, 0.017166138, 0.039855957, 0.038238525, 0.016204834, 0.01979065, 0.025939941, -0.00018572807, -0.053985596, -0.059509277, -0.04168701, -0.0045547485, 0.014556885, -0.035980225, -0.020263672, 0.026672363, 0.08026123, -0.005710602, 0.02456665, 0.025772095, -0.018432617, 0.05731201, -0.024261475, 0.10430908, -0.0010490417, -0.033233643, 0.015640259, 0.0803833, -0.0024738312, 0.012741089, 0.033325195, -0.0045661926, -0.055786133, 0.00056886673, 0.024291992, -0.03463745, -0.0045547485, -0.007045746, 0.0016183853, -0.024246216, 0.027526855, 0.01133728, 0.03100586, 0.040496826, 0.040283203, 0.011955261, -0.026000977, 0.013771057, 0.00033044815, -0.01852417, 0.02609253, 0.060760498, -0.096069336, 0.076416016, 0.01473999, -0.03515625, -0.02986145, 0.091430664, -0.021118164, 0.016693115, 0.0063972473, 0.019622803, 0.004337311, 0.093811035, -0.014427185, -0.045013428, -0.0065956116, 0.028793335, -0.0031147003, -0.013542175, -0.01638794, 0.035186768, 0.046173096, 0.016098022, -0.022994995, 0.011604309, -0.04156494, 0.0020008087, 0.029251099, 0.04977417, -0.008590698, -0.043670654, -0.033996582, 0.009216309, -0.013847351, 0.005958557, -0.02960205, 0.03604126, 0.006198883, -0.0602417, 0.007129669, 0.0121536255, -0.011116028, -0.07537842, 0.023117065, -0.0025577545, 0.008934021, -0.005142212, -0.017105103, -0.020065308, -0.030639648, 0.0064430237, -0.031051636, 0.03918457, -0.055633545, -0.0073928833, -0.060821533, 0.04058838, -0.023406982, -0.02204895, -0.008895874, -0.06726074, -0.04498291, 0.01751709, -0.003129959, -0.027191162, -0.0070533752, -0.00856781, 0.009422302, 0.021896362, -0.010223389, -0.01701355, -0.012519836, -0.013771057, 0.0042915344, 0.00064373016, 0.042419434, 0.028518677, -0.016525269, -0.02456665, 0.0018529892, -0.009651184, 0.05041504, -0.00094270706, 0.024429321, -0.078186035, -0.013496399, -0.008659363, -0.0021266937, -0.01763916, -0.031677246, 0.057739258, -0.00374794, -0.020751953, -0.02684021, 0.006252289, -0.04373169, -0.0059547424, -0.009780884, -0.047943115, 0.015068054, 0.060455322, 0.009681702, -0.03375244, 0.048431396, -0.054351807, -0.06335449, -0.011329651, 0.010482788, 0.019638062, -0.030883789, -0.005279541, -0.0052223206, 0.0017461777, -0.050109863, -0.092041016, -0.009651184, 0.09057617, 0.0050811768, 0.02696228, -0.026260376, -0.03253174, 0.01197052, -0.003484726, 0.016571045, -0.005882263, -0.056518555, -0.05331421, 0.014198303, 0.0287323, -0.0077056885, -0.012771606, 0.07556152, 0.010848999, 0.019454956, -0.010437012, 0.005191803, 0.012428284, -0.02142334, 0.055236816, 0.0010814667, -0.008728027, 0.016357422, -0.012138367, 0.019165039, 0.03314209, -0.023956299, 0.018371582, -0.0043945312, 0.015655518, -0.030944824, 0.036956787, 0.011772156, 0.018997192, 0.011352539, 0.027633667, -0.0065193176, 0.041656494, 0.009689331, -0.033691406, -0.017440796, -0.059051514, 0.052947998, -0.04525757, -0.06304932, 0.025512695, -0.022537231, 0.028686523, -0.0010662079, 0.02420044, -0.033233643, 0.02494812, -0.022445679, -0.012481689, 0.014907837, 0.014221191, 0.025741577, -0.002735138, -0.025405884, 0.029937744, 0.017471313, -0.013046265 ], "summary": [ 0.020690918, -0.023345947, 0.025772095, -0.020446777, -0.037322998, 0.013305664, -0.023086548, -0.04034424, 0.0021419525, 0.014694214, 0.00013911724, 0.015914917, -0.027633667, -0.051086426, 0.005279541, -0.022857666, -0.016296387, 0.043518066, 0.031433105, -0.021316528, 0.010009766, -0.02722168, 0.015014648, 0.008857727, -0.0027675629, 0.007160187, -0.043060303, 0.026412964, 0.0021820068, 0.00592041, 0.00068855286, -0.007785797, 0.017166138, 0.006641388, -0.0234375, -0.0062675476, 0.0007843971, 0.011116028, 0.0028266907, -0.008239746, 0.022720337, -0.015838623, 0.07397461, -0.082092285, 0.03378296, 0.037719727, 0.005836487, -0.048217773, 0.027496338, -0.011817932, 0.006175995, 0.03387451, 0.0016813278, -0.030319214, -0.020812988, -0.009399414, 0.026428223, -0.0552063, 0.02178955, -0.0036239624, -0.003004074, -0.03555298, 0.02986145, -0.023162842, -0.004924774, -0.0025978088, 0.05065918, 0.010757446, 0.06994629, 0.004383087, -0.018554688, 0.061767578, -0.0004017353, 0.023223877, -0.026519775, -0.01953125, 0.054382324, -0.003955841, -0.01448822, 0.039886475, -0.006000519, 0.005504608, -0.02128601, -0.034942627, 0.024520874, 0.0057258606, -0.016967773, -0.016555786, -0.012374878, -0.038909912, -0.01576233, -0.04168701, -0.04373169, 0.031555176, 0.033111572, -0.041137695, -0.017730713, -0.025466919, 0.0129470825, 0.0115356445, -0.00340271, -0.008628845, -0.027557373, -0.0011253357, -0.0015096664, 0.04522705, -0.030593872, -0.07324219, -0.009864807, 0.022567749, 0.0029525757, -0.01927185, 0.0030975342, -0.0035324097, 0.006160736, 0.013832092, -0.0046081543, 0.04260254, -0.0021362305, 0.05029297, -0.013908386, 0.025115967, -0.059143066, 0.047332764, 0.0143585205, 0.037353516, 0.03475952, 0.007820129, -0.09423828, 0.051452637, 0.004798889, 0.032104492, -0.0016307831, -0.013450623, -0.050628662, -0.022491455, 0.018630981, -0.0057029724, -0.00881958, -0.028564453, 0.03692627, -0.007446289, -0.001162529, 0.0024089813, -0.0043563843, 0.0073623657, 0.0046691895, 0.008720398, 0.007347107, -0.020477295, -0.0074691772, -0.01727295, 0.059661865, -0.033172607, -0.13476562, -0.0064315796, -0.11871338, 0.03805542, -0.046813965, -0.03112793, 0.048858643, 0.006340027, 0.021865845, 0.03451538, 0.006198883, -0.015403748, -0.04977417, -0.010658264, 0.016403198, -0.007698059, 0.021850586, 0.056396484, 0.034942627, -0.014801025, 0.006175995, -0.029464722, -0.0042762756, 0.032165527, 0.022460938, -0.064086914, -0.039398193, -0.04309082, 0.04159546, 0.0013074875, -0.057800293, 0.013511658, 0.006816864, 0.04925537, 0.04321289, 0.0055885315, 0.028137207, -0.011001587, -0.015472412, -0.008117676, -0.0022506714, -0.019515991, -0.020248413, 0.0093688965, -0.025802612, -0.0052833557, 0.009925842, -0.0073547363, 0.007686615, -0.027175903, -0.028793335, -0.036987305, -0.004714966, 0.027938843, -0.008239746, 0.008491516, 0.015357971, -0.013031006, -0.018569946, 0.020324707, -0.020767212, -0.022460938, 0.0317688, 0.013305664, -0.010192871, -0.016586304, -0.0050849915, -0.0231781, -0.008872986, 0.058654785, -0.0035934448, 0.010620117, 0.0029182434, -0.0033664703, 0.009117126, 0.012336731, 0.02267456, -0.004501343, 0.025283813, 0.036743164, -0.0017118454, 0.008392334, 0.027297974, -0.052642822, 0.0052604675, 0.020980835, 0.02746582, 0.002029419, -0.007980347, -0.0058898926, 0.04421997, 0.026916504, 0.027572632, -0.014152527, -0.0035552979, -0.008964539, -0.0021457672, -0.005809784, 0.027755737, -0.015541077, 0.010391235, 0.039031982, -0.04638672, -0.015556335, 0.012634277, -0.014884949, 0.0039596558, 0.016281128, 0.022232056, 0.0073661804, 0.0513916, -0.007545471, 0.040222168, 0.03186035, 0.0022010803, -0.0022010803, -0.012130737, -0.06652832, 0.01763916, -0.0082473755, -0.0552063, -0.017028809, 0.012077332, 0.010528564, 0.015808105, -0.026855469, 0.0055160522, 0.036102295, -0.051849365, -0.010505676, -0.004470825, -0.012214661, -0.028213501, 0.045135498, -0.00440979, 0.01374054, 0.014152527, 0.043640137, -0.005252838, 0.036071777, -0.012466431, 0.0061569214, -0.0063934326, 0.036224365, 0.0003373623, -0.024215698, -0.025939941, 0.021377563, -0.031982422, 0.006412506, -0.017745972, 0.026855469, -0.016906738, 0.039764404, 0.005466461, -0.08886719, 0.06341553, 0.022964478, 0.026519775, 0.041534424, -0.034820557, -0.039886475, -0.026504517, 0.018051147, -0.050994873, 0.014450073, 0.064331055, -0.03262329, 0.037078857, -0.0021915436, 0.0051574707, -0.05130005, 0.03314209, 0.011024475, -0.042053223, 0.02331543, -0.0055618286, -0.015304565, -0.01083374, 0.033935547, -0.004558563, 0.016983032, 0.022781372, 0.024673462, 0.011199951, -0.0109939575, 0.028335571, 0.02468872, -0.023529053, 0.0073165894, -0.031219482, -0.032958984, 0.0284729, -0.012763977, -0.053741455, -0.008766174, 0.032470703, -0.00091791153, -0.048675537, 0.052642822, 0.016601562, 0.005065918, 0.041992188, 0.039611816, 0.0087890625, -0.0020999908, 0.05154419, 0.06555176, 0.06524658, 0.028045654, -0.12036133, -0.065979004, 0.050598145, 0.031677246, 0.0011968613, 0.0018796921, -0.025054932, 0.015068054, -0.031799316, -0.0044822693, 0.0020370483, 0.02557373, 0.060913086, -0.008102417, -0.046722412, 0.012893677, -0.008377075, -0.01889038, -0.006336212, -0.026138306, 0.09667969, -0.016952515, -0.027893066, 0.014724731, 0.03869629, 0.041625977, -0.034362793, -0.08068848, 0.016815186, -0.035980225, -0.008560181, 0.0035514832, 0.028579712, 0.03152466, 0.007408142, -0.033172607, -0.005622864, 0.0050964355, 0.006690979, -0.00043678284, -0.033569336, 0.035736084, -0.014053345, -0.0141067505, 0.020095825, 0.0020751953, 0.012046814, 0.0368042, -0.024658203, 0.051361084, -0.0077934265, -0.045440674, -0.034423828, 0.006996155, -0.017730713, 0.01272583, 0.015304565, 0.021957397, -0.03225708, -0.003168106, 0.0019760132, 0.002779007, -0.013710022, -0.012413025, -0.005290985, 0.01285553, -0.008865356, -0.00055503845, -0.005470276, -0.050079346, -0.03778076, 0.0031700134, -0.008026123, 0.061157227, -0.0069770813, -0.012435913, -0.028961182, -0.009277344, 0.0060577393, -0.0026493073, -0.0045700073, -0.0016088486, -0.002916336, -0.018600464, 0.020843506, -0.064819336, -0.010368347, 0.0052833557, 0.06915283, 0.01260376, 0.003145218, 0.030029297, 0.0022392273, 0.019042969, 0.061035156, -0.009056091, -0.007499695, -0.011482239, 0.005970001, 0.0019626617, 0.0065689087, -0.008415222, 0.04650879, -0.00957489, -0.047790527, 0.047729492, -0.02053833, -0.02293396, -0.021438599, -0.030166626, 0.022476196, -0.030136108, 0.011329651, 0.0038261414, 0.031311035, 0.0013484955, -0.011405945, 0.027877808, -0.072143555, -0.091552734, -0.092163086, 0.026382446, -0.1508789, -0.08959961, 0.016082764, 0.023620605, 0.024108887, -0.02519226, 0.0501709, -0.009887695, -0.006526947, 0.003627777, -0.0003376007, 0.034729004, -0.026641846, -0.03704834, -0.06402588, -0.005718231, -0.008056641, 0.020233154, -0.03765869, 0.06274414, 0.012519836, -0.020004272, -0.011871338, -0.07366943, -0.029876709, -0.071777344, 0.0028953552, 0.01902771, -0.015777588, 0.014465332, 0.020767212, 0.009117126, 0.01020813, -0.0055160522, 0.0038375854, 0.05670166, -0.0046806335, 0.023971558, -0.022506714, -0.009498596, -0.0234375, 0.0037174225, -0.012931824, -0.059509277, 0.0023002625, 0.011672974, 0.003622055, 0.053009033, 0.02458191, 0.057647705, 0.0013904572, -0.016540527, -0.030029297, -0.027816772, 0.0028762817, 0.025115967, 0.02633667, -0.020858765, -0.011512756, 0.006866455, -0.009376526, 0.01864624, -0.04119873, -0.026168823, 0.008018494, 0.02532959, -0.09674072, -0.048614502, 0.013809204, -0.06585693, -0.03466797, 0.022109985, 0.00070762634, -0.028884888, 0.012702942, 0.0044403076, -0.030456543, -0.0021533966, 0.0062217712, -0.011306763, 0.017578125, -0.027923584, -0.044281006, 0.009399414, -0.050109863, -0.00289917, -0.0044784546, -0.04248047, -0.003578186, -0.018127441, -0.040527344, -0.026565552, 0.008003235, 0.016921997, -0.007522583, -0.0041503906, -0.023239136, -0.12158203, 0.012023926, 0.047088623, -0.05114746, 0.03277588, -0.009536743, 0.011360168, -0.034851074, -0.008651733, -0.011444092, -0.046295166, -0.00894928, 0.01411438, -0.0035877228, 0.0042266846, -0.0033111572, 0.006526947, 0.009735107, 0.06329346, 0.020996094, 0.000093877316, -0.055023193, 0.07220459, 0.028213501, 0.03933716, 0.015838623, 0.038360596, -0.01826477, -0.028869629, -0.0015678406, 0.0027427673, 0.011009216, 0.00088214874, -0.0065193176, 0.010932922, -0.02468872, -0.02255249, -0.016784668, -0.03189087, -0.021652222, -0.03125, -0.0060043335, 0.0017442703, 0.02734375, 0.008796692, -0.031188965, 0.0055618286, -0.036224365, 0.002960205, -0.025619507, 0.046661377, 0.030197144, -0.04586792, -0.039215088, 0.004749298, -0.028900146, -0.050598145, 0.016403198, -0.011528015, -0.06439209, 0.0017538071, 0.0023155212, -0.0037765503, -0.016281128, -0.01878357, -0.009086609, 0.0060768127, 0.043792725, 0.0181427, 0.04208374, -0.057495117, -0.033721924, 0.004257202, 0.0071105957, 0.03945923, -0.04135132, -0.022216797, -0.0052490234, -0.0065345764, -0.031799316, -0.011138916, 0.017700195, -0.06726074, 0.0047416687, -0.0019054413, -0.050933838, 0.024047852, -0.03466797, -0.039520264, 0.031204224, -0.0154800415, -0.0012903214, 0.038726807, -0.046569824, -0.0024528503, -0.020431519, 0.028442383, 0.012832642, -0.023025513, -0.006565094, -0.04458618, 0.006549835, 0.03012085, -0.0062179565, -0.012260437, -0.013870239, -0.0076179504, 0.0020503998, 0.056549072, -0.026657104, 0.03451538, 0.010292053, -0.028884888, -0.0138168335, -0.052337646, -0.039642334, -0.00044369698, 0.029174805, -0.019729614, 0.03677368, -0.017227173, -0.015975952, -0.007286072, -0.0041885376, 0.004814148, 0.008232117, 0.0128479, -0.01574707, -0.010620117, -0.07543945, -0.014656067, 0.03062439, 0.007461548, 0.006252289, 0.0006093979, -0.008201599, 0.00040102005, 0.015655518, -0.020141602, 0.028671265, -0.004219055, 0.019744873, -0.002948761, 0.01864624, 0.02758789, -0.01928711, -0.035095215, 0.011238098, -0.031188965, 0.009292603, -0.005584717, -0.023544312, -0.016098022, 0.011047363, 0.050109863, 0.050842285, -0.029403687, 0.016845703, -0.03164673, 0.05895996, -0.005367279, 0.0060768127, -0.026641846, 0.00035214424, -0.007724762, -0.023239136, -0.0154800415, 0.054718018, -0.045440674, -0.06793213, -0.022750854, 0.025039673, 0.025299072, 0.046020508, -0.01725769, -0.06549072, 0.007633209, -0.028564453, 0.012260437, -0.000910759, -0.022735596, -0.008010864, -0.0062408447, 0.006126404, 0.0234375, 0.005683899, -0.03829956, -0.01007843, -0.0036506653, -0.005744934, 0.022323608, 0.039764404, -0.026031494, 0.031585693, -0.081604004, -0.023101807, -0.00573349, 0.03543091, -0.016723633, 0.018615723, -0.009162903, -0.016204834, 0.020324707, 0.0087509155, 0.007858276, -0.018096924, -0.0048065186, 0.0012044907, 0.021514893, 0.04824829, -0.02520752, 0.0015220642, 0.012786865, 0.038757324, 0.013198853, -0.021362305, 0.007217407, -0.01889038, -0.023422241, -0.04168701, -0.024246216, -0.015617371, 0.023422241, 0.0058517456, -0.008125305, 0.05670166, 0.0053215027, 0.022018433, 0.017532349, 0.003894806, 0.01008606, 0.008293152, 0.0770874, 0.015716553, -0.037231445, 0.048431396, 0.05419922, -0.021575928, 0.012924194, 0.031433105, 0.008041382, -0.0079193115, 0.010124207, 0.04751587, -0.022598267, -0.05029297, -0.0038223267, 0.05593872, -0.028137207, 0.025650024, 0.012886047, 0.018325806, 0.024490356, 0.02859497, 0.0259552, -0.0206604, 0.033294678, 0.021057129, -0.04119873, 0.04244995, 0.05419922, -0.08917236, 0.02671814, 0.018676758, -0.019851685, 0.036712646, 0.05810547, 0.002035141, -0.0036640167, -0.016326904, 0.0013685226, 0.015159607, 0.06463623, -0.006668091, -0.01914978, 0.012901306, 0.048309326, -0.019165039, 0.01701355, 0.008354187, 0.03781128, 0.039978027, 0.0236969, -0.0024280548, 0.0137786865, -0.033569336, 0.03591919, 0.03378296, -0.0006804466, -0.0057907104, 0.007663727, -0.016036987, 0.012626648, 0.012397766, 0.016967773, -0.0039596558, 0.024658203, 0.009757996, -0.009468079, 0.021774292, -0.006511688, -0.0045166016, -0.020645142, 0.0063934326, -0.008674622, 0.01889038, -0.011756897, -0.05126953, 0.0027065277, -0.009735107, -0.015235901, -0.005458832, 0.04257202, -0.06011963, -0.012359619, -0.042633057, 0.031051636, -0.062683105, 0.0047912598, -0.0009083748, -0.06451416, -0.021438599, 0.012184143, 0.011009216, -0.033081055, 0.00687027, -0.01525116, -0.01965332, 0.025344849, -0.006790161, 0.015197754, 0.007827759, -0.03942871, -0.0090789795, -0.014778137, 0.04949951, -0.008491516, -0.02168274, 0.0044822693, 0.018798828, -0.015296936, -0.0045394897, -0.012680054, 0.029388428, -0.0013341904, -0.03250122, 0.0059661865, 0.009559631, -0.02255249, -0.029205322, 0.010269165, 0.0056648254, -0.018615723, -0.00079870224, 0.0132751465, -0.0036849976, -0.01890564, -0.017593384, -0.02809143, 0.009468079, 0.008552551, 0.013534546, 0.008422852, 0.022232056, -0.014640808, -0.06866455, -0.006389618, -0.025375366, 0.00018107891, -0.051330566, -0.000009357929, -0.012214661, -0.009841919, -0.060455322, -0.009338379, 0.0005083084, 0.11315918, -0.00026607513, -0.035980225, -0.042144775, -0.04397583, 0.062469482, 0.010192871, 0.019180298, -0.0042495728, -0.09710693, -0.06939697, 0.057250977, -0.008552551, -0.023498535, -0.01651001, 0.06951904, -0.023208618, -0.026535034, 0.0017604828, 0.05319214, -0.0063438416, 0.010894775, 0.051513672, -0.038726807, -0.052825928, 0.07312012, -0.04876709, 0.017288208, 0.0022201538, -0.035583496, -0.023010254, -0.032714844, -0.015068054, -0.013252258, 0.06732178, -0.04800415, -0.025772095, 0.010009766, -0.0061912537, -0.028549194, 0.042419434, 0.030014038, -0.038604736, -0.018081665, -0.04800415, 0.07086182, -0.092041016, -0.07897949, 0.006362915, -0.025726318, 0.012969971, -0.0143966675, 0.029830933, -0.03125, 0.022384644, 0.0054359436, -0.017044067, 0.04043579, 0.003353119, 0.05114746, 0.0055732727, 0.019744873, 0.051818848, -0.0036849976, 0.013076782 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2012.07023v2
InferCode: Self-Supervised Learning of Code Representations by Predicting Subtrees
Nghi D. Q. Bui, Yijun Yu, Lingxiao Jiang
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PL
Building deep learning models on source code has found many successful software engineering applications, such as code search, code comment generation, bug detection, code migration, and so on. Current learning techniques, however, have a major drawback that these models are mostly trained on datasets labeled for particular downstream tasks, and code representations may not be suitable for other tasks. While some techniques produce representations from unlabeled code, they are far from satisfactory when applied to downstream tasks. Although certain techniques generate representations from unlabeled code when applied to downstream tasks they are far from satisfactory. This paper proposes InferCode to overcome the limitation by adapting the self-supervised learning mechanism to build source code model. The key novelty lies in training code representations by predicting automatically identified subtrees from the context of the ASTs. Subtrees in ASTs are treated with InferCode as the labels for training code representations without any human labeling effort or the overhead of expensive graph construction, and the trained representations are no longer tied to any specific downstream tasks or code units. We trained an InferCode model instance using the Tree-based CNN as the encoder of a large set of Java code and applied it to downstream unsupervised tasks such as code clustering, code clone detection, cross-language code search or reused under a transfer learning scheme to continue training the model weights for supervised tasks such as code classification and method name prediction. Compared to previous code learning techniques applied to the same downstream tasks, such as Code2Vec, Code2Seq, ASTNN, higher performance results are achieved using our pre-trained InferCode model with a significant margin for most tasks including those involving different programming languages.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2012.07023v2
"2020-12-15T16:37:23"
"2020-12-13T10:33:41"
{ "title": [ -0.029937744, -0.034088135, -0.04446411, -0.049468994, -0.017303467, -0.00655365, -0.033355713, 0.024505615, 0.0002593994, 0.034851074, -0.025726318, 0.011016846, -0.020645142, -0.014801025, -0.04147339, -0.0072135925, -0.0012693405, 0.042510986, -0.009933472, -0.031677246, -0.029876709, -0.031234741, 0.042022705, 0.026565552, 0.035705566, -0.047851562, -0.025726318, 0.02809143, -0.01928711, -0.037261963, -0.004463196, 0.006790161, 0.05239868, 0.020065308, -0.025375366, 0.017837524, -0.06726074, 0.016021729, -0.015449524, 0.016143799, 0.033599854, -0.0009331703, 0.0042762756, -0.06530762, -0.018218994, 0.028625488, -0.0418396, -0.009346008, -0.017654419, 0.0044403076, 0.019119263, 0.0317688, -0.007713318, 0.0138168335, 0.02708435, -0.015991211, -0.046966553, 0.0019893646, 0.033233643, 0.062805176, 0.021896362, -0.046051025, 0.02558899, -0.0127334595, -0.03363037, -0.024520874, -0.029525757, 0.019561768, 0.0692749, 0.008613586, -0.019851685, 0.024536133, 0.0008211136, -0.01184845, -0.08709717, 0.03048706, 0.061065674, 0.012565613, 0.026321411, -0.056121826, 0.023086548, -0.023895264, 0.0068473816, -0.027770996, 0.033294678, -0.03237915, -0.003479004, -0.01586914, -0.034210205, -0.0637207, -0.0070343018, 0.019973755, -0.038604736, -0.014778137, -0.020370483, -0.037261963, 0.0087509155, 0.049591064, 0.0071640015, -0.00047516823, -0.032836914, 0.01802063, -0.03942871, -0.027145386, 0.017684937, 0.03366089, -0.033477783, -0.05340576, 0.006752014, 0.02456665, -0.023529053, 0.007896423, 0.009529114, -0.007209778, -0.00071525574, 0.0118255615, -0.00818634, 0.016281128, 0.011131287, 0.018722534, -0.0071372986, -0.0013618469, -0.0075187683, -0.033416748, 0.052124023, 0.010719299, -0.031036377, -0.0025730133, 0.009780884, 0.0033092499, 0.0032787323, 0.0625, -0.111572266, -0.0949707, -0.07446289, 0.049346924, -0.008026123, 0.0039711, -0.01675415, 0.0057907104, 0.0011119843, -0.03010559, -0.0035877228, -0.008895874, -0.0016288757, 0.030853271, 0.046295166, -0.014152527, -0.03552246, -0.039031982, -0.044403076, -0.0012960434, 0.037109375, 0.0011005402, -0.03970337, -0.026626587, -0.088134766, -0.019805908, 0.016418457, 0.0001603365, 0.024780273, -0.013679504, -0.008712769, 0.021636963, 0.03302002, 0.0058250427, -0.014541626, 0.01096344, 0.0021629333, 0.03378296, -0.020904541, -0.00036644936, 0.014755249, -0.0057868958, -0.012664795, -0.0025615692, 0.024215698, -0.008605957, 0.02734375, -0.0015535355, 0.014205933, -0.01701355, 0.0017204285, 0.046661377, -0.066223145, -0.009674072, 0.009971619, 0.011207581, 0.027816772, 0.0038452148, 0.0072135925, 0.033050537, -0.039031982, -0.039398193, -0.0385437, -0.024261475, 0.032196045, 0.020111084, 0.002111435, 0.02760315, -0.051452637, 0.0019512177, -0.021133423, 0.023712158, 0.023101807, -0.030349731, -0.013916016, 0.022720337, -0.024795532, 0.031280518, 0.05822754, -0.0067710876, -0.038970947, 0.03692627, 0.00028681755, -0.04107666, 0.018447876, -0.014404297, 0.009552002, -0.028900146, 0.023971558, -0.010757446, 0.02154541, 0.04876709, -0.00041532516, -0.012062073, 0.009109497, -0.027938843, 0.030853271, 0.030914307, 0.057678223, -0.052001953, 0.036224365, 0.012687683, -0.025741577, -0.04260254, -0.047180176, -0.05166626, 0.0067634583, 0.057922363, 0.0017652512, -0.008506775, -0.019485474, 0.007003784, 0.09716797, 0.029968262, 0.011405945, -0.0043525696, 0.034057617, 0.036376953, 0.04928589, 0.02583313, 0.037719727, -0.018203735, 0.028518677, 0.052093506, -0.0046806335, -0.024765015, 0.010147095, 0.011634827, 0.0007805824, 0.01171875, -0.0067443848, 0.0044174194, -0.03149414, 0.028289795, -0.007835388, 0.02420044, -0.016235352, 0.025436401, 0.033050537, 0.021835327, 0.012176514, -0.00027179718, 0.042938232, -0.032318115, -0.014305115, -0.0007529259, 0.02520752, -0.052734375, -0.0029525757, 0.017288208, -0.0041236877, -0.011421204, 0.043823242, -0.012191772, -0.027236938, -0.015991211, -0.013069153, 0.013130188, 0.050689697, 0.052703857, 0.00025129318, 0.0135269165, 0.0035858154, 0.024353027, 0.086364746, 0.077697754, -0.043182373, 0.031280518, -0.043670654, 0.014907837, 0.008079529, -0.024734497, -0.0003426075, 0.028366089, 0.012535095, 0.02859497, -0.035980225, -0.0036239624, -0.0362854, -0.0051002502, 0.014839172, 0.002401352, -0.06341553, -0.061553955, -0.018157959, -0.031707764, -0.041931152, -0.033996582, 0.08099365, 0.0059318542, -0.025650024, 0.014663696, 0.010665894, -0.031402588, 0.004714966, -0.030715942, -0.020370483, 0.013053894, 0.02015686, 0.026550293, -0.049346924, 0.008132935, -0.017700195, 0.0026550293, -0.0026798248, -0.012664795, -0.021347046, 0.015823364, 0.023773193, -0.0045433044, 0.021240234, -0.04446411, -0.019805908, -0.07269287, 0.013694763, 0.015731812, -0.06262207, -0.023880005, 0.06542969, -0.017684937, -0.018630981, 0.017501831, 0.04232788, 0.00013422966, -0.0098724365, 0.04385376, 0.030731201, -0.013839722, 0.017990112, 0.019973755, 0.008407593, -0.049041748, -0.03591919, -0.047454834, 0.00032687187, 0.0044288635, -0.005947113, 0.06317139, -0.03555298, -0.019943237, -0.0435791, -0.015007019, 0.0059928894, 0.013442993, 0.028152466, -0.02154541, -0.057403564, -0.012016296, -0.0023498535, 0.010528564, -0.03201294, -0.015823364, 0.076049805, -0.006801605, -0.028869629, 0.03768921, 0.013900757, -0.0034217834, -0.018539429, 0.020141602, -0.048675537, 0.016342163, 0.031036377, 0.0019741058, -0.00415802, -0.0011310577, -0.122924805, -0.0073928833, 0.039855957, -0.009651184, -0.037902832, 0.030548096, -0.058166504, -0.0034637451, -0.0042304993, -0.027252197, 0.030258179, 0.051452637, 0.0027866364, 0.01499939, 0.032440186, -0.035064697, 0.007549286, -0.017852783, -0.11401367, 0.026733398, -0.017456055, -0.015640259, -0.0071487427, -0.024810791, -0.058380127, -0.007030487, -0.014213562, 0.021224976, 0.024017334, 0.013465881, 0.005065918, -0.0012283325, -0.0058059692, -0.036743164, -0.0059547424, 0.009422302, -0.016830444, 0.045532227, -0.004573822, 0.040252686, 0.03552246, -0.020599365, -0.024490356, -0.022857666, -0.008872986, 0.018035889, -0.014190674, -0.02281189, -0.012252808, 0.0028476715, -0.024627686, -0.0030498505, -0.036376953, 0.01109314, -0.013725281, 0.011291504, -0.013839722, 0.007827759, 0.039398193, 0.0011863708, -0.03463745, -0.000364542, 0.03955078, -0.0043144226, -0.06616211, -0.0068626404, 0.05053711, 0.0043792725, -0.014282227, -0.0048713684, 0.005996704, -0.0018196106, -0.0038394928, 0.010246277, -0.005344391, -0.008934021, -0.015625, -0.0005555153, 0.008117676, -0.007194519, 0.0067214966, -0.0149002075, 0.009918213, -0.0006866455, 0.004962921, -0.053100586, 0.00053977966, 0.0037784576, -0.103027344, -0.0073051453, 0.03289795, -0.012527466, -0.0087509155, -0.074035645, 0.041107178, -0.027801514, -0.02798462, 0.028717041, -0.026504517, -0.012535095, -0.0070877075, -0.07525635, -0.0053482056, 0.06689453, 0.00084257126, 0.011230469, 0.019256592, 0.022094727, -0.028427124, -0.030136108, 0.03186035, -0.023468018, 0.030731201, -0.027389526, -0.023406982, 0.03488159, -0.03387451, 0.009483337, 0.02407837, 0.01914978, -0.013381958, 0.011108398, 0.014892578, 0.0012378693, 0.001537323, 0.050323486, -0.01235199, 0.010887146, -0.060668945, -0.005962372, 0.017807007, -0.013580322, 0.0037612915, -0.0035037994, 0.01083374, 0.037902832, 0.00020110607, 0.03677368, -0.01524353, -0.0065345764, 0.040618896, -0.003435135, -0.022521973, -0.004699707, 0.0063705444, 0.019134521, -0.0034809113, 0.04800415, 0.0037326813, 0.05819702, -0.036590576, -0.027679443, 0.01058197, 0.033691406, -0.026641846, 0.002336502, -0.057373047, -0.02128601, -0.030776978, 0.014312744, -0.013160706, 0.04257202, 0.040649414, -0.04107666, -0.009132385, -0.0044670105, 0.023117065, -0.010002136, 0.02607727, -0.048919678, -0.038238525, 0.019454956, -0.054779053, -0.01473999, -0.008140564, -0.028320312, 0.020889282, -0.025314331, -0.05987549, 0.0049438477, 0.023269653, 0.11199951, 0.017929077, -0.0056114197, -0.09411621, 0.008262634, -0.001241684, -0.009643555, -0.00034213066, -0.019927979, 0.0006995201, -0.01713562, 0.007965088, -0.018722534, -0.007965088, -0.028717041, 0.026550293, -0.011070251, 0.048828125, -0.00881958, 0.03390503, 0.028167725, 0.0057525635, 0.032165527, 0.019577026, -0.031982422, -0.009094238, 0.043945312, 0.056854248, -0.0012664795, 0.034423828, 0.03427124, -0.0016031265, -0.024230957, -0.007499695, 0.02243042, 0.007446289, -0.028778076, 0.0050315857, 0.020309448, -0.045532227, -0.01638794, -0.0010089874, -0.009475708, 0.048614502, -0.04147339, 0.05142212, -0.0036354065, 0.02784729, 0.048950195, -0.00315094, 0.00299263, 0.009483337, 0.012786865, -0.08013916, -0.055786133, -0.007686615, 0.044189453, -0.02243042, 0.011451721, 0.02645874, -0.006668091, 0.026504517, 0.017837524, 0.009353638, -0.018005371, -0.019500732, -0.035858154, -0.0077285767, -0.016860962, -0.062408447, 0.023513794, 0.014259338, 0.016937256, -0.008056641, -0.012458801, -0.072631836, -0.00121212, -0.004714966, -0.019515991, 0.019256592, -0.083496094, 0.020019531, 0.06488037, 0.016311646, 0.017532349, -0.0064048767, 0.0059280396, 0.018737793, 0.041229248, -0.009780884, 0.026153564, 0.02909851, -0.04522705, 0.007671356, 0.0046310425, 0.023086548, 0.009109497, 0.010284424, 0.014175415, 0.00011998415, -0.05142212, 0.04031372, 0.028717041, -0.01838684, -0.0030879974, -0.038635254, 0.02532959, -0.016433716, 0.012825012, 0.004486084, -0.015594482, -0.019439697, -0.027938843, -0.018432617, -0.07147217, 0.0072135925, -0.031311035, -0.025390625, -0.057495117, 0.016036987, -0.017150879, 0.0015964508, -0.00025463104, 0.01260376, -0.029281616, -0.0046806335, 0.051727295, -0.015823364, 0.0395813, -0.02708435, -0.0019607544, 0.052886963, 0.019592285, -0.015487671, 0.0023479462, -0.029815674, -0.0501709, -0.07080078, -0.022201538, -0.01373291, 0.021972656, -0.00007903576, -0.018692017, 0.0053215027, -0.021743774, 0.018920898, 0.0012025833, -0.01687622, 0.041046143, 0.00020766258, -0.026046753, 0.008575439, 0.0044670105, -0.016845703, 0.013076782, 0.0110321045, -0.0038261414, 0.0010995865, -0.0039138794, 0.009284973, -0.02142334, -0.07421875, -0.0047454834, 0.01939392, 0.019699097, 0.02519226, 0.008758545, 0.028152466, 0.015960693, 0.006038666, 0.027496338, 0.06518555, -0.06756592, -0.011657715, 0.005329132, 0.017425537, -0.009605408, 0.038635254, -0.033447266, -0.023712158, -0.027557373, -0.044555664, -0.022583008, 0.01689148, 0.005619049, 0.012138367, 0.013221741, -0.052612305, 0.024871826, -0.022613525, -0.029006958, -0.031921387, 0.041625977, -0.004714966, -0.016174316, 0.014350891, -0.04437256, 0.0052757263, -0.016921997, 0.0184021, 0.012359619, -0.02255249, 0.007019043, -0.04156494, 0.012672424, -0.012664795, -0.035705566, 0.033996582, -0.009773254, 0.01084137, 0.037750244, -0.03643799, 0.0524292, 0.0016441345, 0.040893555, 0.017211914, -0.0061454773, 0.017150879, -0.0099105835, 0.0039634705, -0.038513184, 0.043670654, -0.04425049, 0.019683838, -0.06500244, -0.018051147, -0.07098389, 0.008995056, 0.021057129, 0.0061149597, 0.01751709, 0.013130188, 0.02456665, 0.019882202, 0.043182373, -0.0033988953, 0.039642334, 0.04159546, 0.03289795, -0.029403687, -0.0206604, 0.024047852, 0.040985107, 0.02658081, -0.00340271, 0.03652954, -0.02935791, 0.0045700073, 0.052459717, 0.021911621, -0.041015625, -0.015350342, -0.032226562, -0.008636475, -0.027267456, 0.0085372925, 0.054992676, 0.05041504, -0.014183044, 0.0048217773, 0.015914917, -0.035125732, -0.030517578, 0.0020446777, 0.025421143, -0.08294678, 0.024368286, -0.008049011, -0.007019043, -0.018951416, 0.010681152, 0.036468506, -0.05831909, -0.037719727, 0.030288696, 0.047180176, -0.013580322, -0.010604858, -0.032806396, 0.013969421, 0.018341064, 0.008514404, 0.007736206, 0.0078125, 0.014602661, 0.014221191, -0.008331299, -0.035339355, 0.014053345, 0.014533997, 0.021011353, 0.04458618, -0.030792236, 0.05621338, -0.0006752014, -0.037475586, 0.0070724487, 0.012786865, -0.093933105, -0.0068855286, 0.016937256, 0.05630493, 0.064575195, 0.08935547, 0.012611389, 0.005844116, 0.014076233, -0.05770874, 0.057373047, 0.03543091, -0.03024292, 0.022918701, -0.03665161, -0.041107178, 0.032928467, -0.033416748, 0.078125, -0.04272461, -0.0016460419, -0.028427124, 0.040985107, 0.012298584, -0.046417236, -0.020141602, -0.010093689, 0.0034713745, -0.017150879, -0.027114868, -0.0284729, -0.031219482, -0.025222778, 0.050445557, -0.0035209656, 0.0030918121, 0.004573822, -0.029174805, -0.05886841, 0.036254883, -0.018203735, 0.07574463, -0.017929077, -0.0035419464, 0.003894806, 0.000035703182, 0.0002617836, -0.05355835, -0.0385437, -0.00919342, 0.004219055, -0.029525757, -0.0039043427, -0.0029239655, -0.02798462, -0.030883789, -0.0345459, 0.0178833, -0.03491211, -0.011703491, 0.037017822, -0.04876709, 0.015701294, -0.0011787415, -0.032073975, 0.05783081, 0.02885437, -0.015174866, 0.026290894, -0.013290405, -0.0016593933, 0.0058403015, 0.04095459, 0.055541992, -0.015853882, -0.04095459, 0.013069153, 0.030471802, 0.053771973, -0.05999756, -0.023040771, 0.00013160706, 0.019439697, 0.005443573, 0.03579712, 0.014511108, -0.009498596, 0.036956787, -0.022460938, 0.005836487, -0.027877808, -0.056640625, -0.027038574, 0.048858643, 0.036346436, -0.020568848, -0.027130127, 0.04031372, -0.029205322, -0.010658264, -0.00894165, 0.010673523, -0.014587402, -0.002210617, -0.010345459, -0.030456543, -0.049926758, -0.044433594, 0.0109939575, 0.019866943, 0.060058594, -0.007965088, 0.012458801, 0.019805908, 0.107666016, -0.013511658, -0.040618896, 0.037078857, 0.023010254, 0.023254395, 0.022445679, -0.014221191, -0.02192688, -0.011268616, -0.00034284592, -0.011390686, 0.018493652, 0.016113281, -0.0340271, 0.015289307, -0.036346436, -0.029785156, -0.056121826, -0.027755737, 0.03237915, -0.04208374, 0.012969971, -0.030227661, -0.018844604, -0.0067481995, 0.034118652, 0.024749756, -0.036346436, -0.03439331, -0.011047363, 0.073913574, -0.011558533 ], "summary": [ -0.022567749, -0.06085205, -0.008399963, 0.0044059753, -0.07763672, 0.0019512177, -0.02809143, 0.01663208, 0.030197144, 0.027038574, -0.028839111, 0.0065231323, -0.015014648, -0.019989014, -0.007080078, -0.012992859, 0.006122589, 0.0317688, 0.01600647, -0.026306152, 0.006134033, -0.014518738, 0.005329132, -0.003129959, 0.022338867, -0.05795288, 0.021469116, 0.033935547, 0.024917603, 0.01158905, 0.010925293, -0.032073975, 0.035095215, -0.013954163, -0.0154418945, 0.0126953125, -0.033172607, -0.0004553795, -0.014434814, 0.019699097, 0.031234741, -0.0043907166, 0.073913574, -0.0569458, 0.017929077, 0.024093628, 0.01763916, -0.009849548, 0.008560181, -0.033477783, -0.008338928, 0.00207901, -0.023590088, 0.016525269, -0.009735107, 0.018630981, -0.05368042, 0.00031614304, 0.024932861, 0.043762207, 0.0065307617, -0.018127441, 0.015853882, -0.015380859, -0.0209198, -0.02067566, -0.008468628, -0.015449524, 0.05831909, 0.0060424805, 0.01524353, 0.024230957, 0.013221741, -0.038360596, -0.07067871, 0.025039673, 0.06286621, 0.0014600754, -0.019424438, -0.05255127, 0.016433716, 0.0011205673, 0.02482605, -0.046936035, 0.013557434, -0.051116943, -0.007965088, -0.010185242, -0.018478394, -0.0066986084, -0.010810852, 0.041412354, -0.06329346, 0.010948181, 0.020904541, -0.05871582, -0.03213501, 0.007587433, 0.009284973, 0.052337646, -0.017654419, -0.009338379, 0.028793335, -0.051635742, -0.00349617, 0.0440979, -0.027801514, -0.0670166, -0.002494812, 0.008277893, -0.015701294, -0.040893555, -0.024353027, -0.047668457, -0.008148193, 0.034698486, -0.0059127808, 0.021057129, 0.014190674, 0.0126953125, -0.031677246, 0.02468872, -0.0055160522, -0.007293701, 0.02923584, 0.03060913, 0.030792236, -0.03326416, 0.039276123, -0.016723633, -0.026275635, 0.035980225, 0.009056091, -0.026916504, -0.015457153, -0.002275467, -0.0069885254, 0.025604248, -0.0039711, -0.00084495544, 0.010070801, -0.0113220215, 0.0046043396, 0.02029419, 0.03302002, -0.013214111, 0.006198883, 0.029693604, 0.006942749, 0.0057640076, 0.011726379, 0.016723633, 0.035339355, -0.0256958, -0.009635925, -0.09667969, -0.019119263, -0.04925537, 0.054595947, -0.034484863, 0.007820129, -0.01071167, 0.0038471222, 0.025238037, -0.0019741058, 0.0026378632, 0.022857666, -0.009231567, 0.005092621, -0.01134491, -0.019958496, 0.0036563873, 0.045684814, -0.011047363, -0.011077881, 0.009887695, -0.021820068, 0.013496399, 0.021514893, 0.00015246868, 0.018478394, -0.022979736, 0.027191162, 0.024963379, -0.04269409, 0.01727295, -0.009155273, 0.027038574, 0.030944824, -0.007522583, 0.033325195, 0.00422287, -0.016220093, 0.013168335, -0.010093689, -0.05996704, 0.016189575, -0.019180298, -0.008361816, 0.014770508, -0.037841797, 0.004699707, -0.016967773, -0.00034284592, -0.0016241074, -0.016921997, 0.003047943, 0.021911621, -0.011054993, 0.0118255615, 0.02947998, -0.012237549, -0.02960205, 0.036132812, -0.012145996, -0.03414917, 0.015159607, -0.034698486, 0.033233643, -0.022964478, 0.038085938, 0.059539795, -0.004890442, 0.018875122, -0.032836914, -0.034484863, -0.0008673668, -0.0011281967, 0.02696228, 0.004940033, 0.072631836, -0.032165527, 0.054901123, 0.036102295, -0.035736084, -0.028549194, -0.030532837, -0.0692749, 0.005935669, 0.07434082, 0.024383545, 0.034698486, -0.021575928, -0.026977539, 0.10296631, 0.06085205, 0.018234253, -0.026000977, -0.019515991, -0.0028057098, 0.020401001, -0.0030956268, 0.021148682, -0.026550293, 0.011726379, 0.023132324, -0.04748535, -0.06665039, 0.050964355, -0.011871338, 0.00068998337, -0.035186768, 0.01763916, -0.02357483, 0.0262146, -0.03414917, 0.0131073, 0.00087976456, -0.048065186, -0.0076179504, 0.033721924, 0.047607422, -0.01108551, -0.00945282, 0.042785645, -0.05328369, -0.035614014, 0.014892578, 0.029708862, -0.01612854, 0.008720398, 0.021102905, -0.017410278, -0.024215698, 0.043518066, 0.019332886, -0.04147339, -0.01713562, 0.024856567, 0.07098389, 0.041809082, 0.06555176, -0.0037326813, 0.05899048, -0.030776978, 0.02998352, 0.024261475, 0.04763794, -0.031204224, 0.0039482117, 0.009765625, 0.031921387, -0.0064353943, -0.015487671, 0.014808655, -0.00030088425, 0.005130768, 0.0039749146, -0.00021123886, 0.010482788, -0.02482605, 0.026977539, 0.033996582, 0.11608887, -0.042816162, -0.051940918, -0.0077934265, 0.07385254, -0.012863159, -0.017593384, 0.081604004, 0.0061798096, 0.012573242, 0.031799316, 0.0034599304, -0.046203613, 0.041809082, -0.0206604, 0.022354126, -0.00020062923, 0.0026721954, 0.04055786, 0.008346558, 0.036224365, -0.011886597, -0.024276733, 0.0077209473, -0.039733887, 0.0023651123, 0.018981934, 0.04711914, 0.04071045, -0.0009918213, -0.031585693, -0.042297363, -0.04425049, 0.010955811, -0.0045928955, -0.017700195, -0.020385742, 0.053131104, -0.011138916, -0.018112183, 0.023147583, -0.024932861, 0.01878357, 0.025634766, -0.006877899, -0.00844574, -0.04827881, 0.010604858, 0.02468872, -0.010879517, -0.050323486, -0.017715454, -0.021865845, 0.0034122467, 0.009849548, 0.04067993, 0.058746338, -0.008705139, 0.040771484, -0.05340576, -0.011779785, 0.019546509, -0.015975952, 0.074401855, -0.00907135, -0.050872803, 0.028045654, 0.013916016, 0.026626587, -0.04425049, -0.002046585, 0.04336548, 0.011161804, -0.012611389, 0.05050659, 0.008880615, -0.0050811768, -0.010398865, 0.038635254, -0.022979736, -0.0067863464, 0.0335083, 0.0025043488, -0.007675171, 0.011947632, -0.055236816, -0.03201294, 0.058898926, 0.011169434, 0.006336212, 0.03074646, -0.009292603, 0.0065612793, 0.046020508, -0.0048561096, 0.0018672943, 0.012908936, 0.03665161, -0.060058594, 0.03253174, -0.0491333, 0.010101318, -0.009613037, -0.08227539, 0.014305115, -0.02305603, 0.004459381, -0.02897644, 0.05480957, -0.0262146, 0.0069732666, 0.00605011, 0.027755737, -0.006980896, -0.00026512146, -0.021377563, 0.019622803, -0.0073165894, -0.021759033, 0.0051879883, 0.035217285, -0.0021591187, 0.057006836, -0.012664795, -0.014190674, 0.019470215, -0.064086914, -0.010566711, -0.008415222, -0.008071899, 0.024520874, -0.011528015, -0.009109497, -0.0026855469, -0.012306213, -0.0017929077, 0.034698486, -0.045410156, -0.0042304993, 0.06225586, 0.032684326, -0.030349731, 0.00945282, 0.008758545, 0.015975952, 0.006877899, 0.008491516, 0.05206299, -0.00091695786, -0.01828003, -0.0053596497, 0.047943115, 0.031585693, -0.08673096, 0.022521973, -0.008674622, -0.0072746277, 0.054992676, -0.012512207, -0.030471802, -0.033325195, 0.0074043274, -0.03475952, 0.035308838, -0.0012712479, 0.03842163, -0.033294678, -0.024856567, 0.009811401, -0.028579712, -0.015220642, -0.0014352798, 0.01071167, -0.03463745, 0.0062828064, 0.04147339, 0.0018806458, 0.0032615662, -0.068237305, 0.061676025, -0.03164673, -0.00026774406, 0.03161621, -0.024215698, 0.058654785, 0.0011892319, -0.067993164, 0.033416748, -0.02116394, 0.005191803, 0.00762558, -0.022003174, 0.06329346, 0.016738892, -0.0060195923, 0.0031929016, -0.0690918, -0.0028820038, -0.058013916, 0.010253906, 0.0071983337, -0.026657104, -0.0151901245, 0.0029792786, 0.043029785, -0.036071777, 0.0066375732, 0.042816162, 0.033172607, -0.00049972534, 0.018005371, -0.025344849, 0.026809692, -0.027832031, -0.0047454834, 0.04119873, -0.00819397, -0.0045394897, 0.022247314, 0.013404846, 0.036132812, 0.004650116, -0.032409668, -0.03213501, -0.041656494, 0.011116028, 0.047027588, -0.03945923, -0.055145264, -0.01663208, 0.06628418, -0.024978638, 0.049621582, -0.03579712, 0.043029785, -0.06112671, 0.00806427, 0.009635925, 0.009277344, -0.032348633, -0.03555298, -0.02835083, 0.034606934, -0.015487671, 0.018341064, -0.003124237, 0.017349243, 0.015655518, -0.043762207, 0.011047363, -0.00028800964, -0.0030517578, 0.011985779, 0.000436306, -0.062072754, -0.06286621, 0.036132812, -0.03262329, -0.00031518936, -0.06817627, -0.07727051, -0.024612427, -0.017227173, -0.052703857, 0.021408081, 0.00044560432, 0.07019043, 0.028640747, -0.000341177, -0.091552734, -0.007701874, -0.029846191, 0.042510986, -0.027313232, 0.035888672, -0.010925293, 0.017410278, 0.0068130493, -0.0059280396, -0.015426636, -0.038269043, 0.00037527084, 0.031143188, 0.019973755, -0.009590149, 0.013122559, 0.009521484, 0.021759033, 0.0309906, 0.010757446, 0.0007047653, 0.00060129166, 0.032226562, 0.04647827, 0.01890564, 0.04586792, 0.022338867, -0.04034424, -0.03967285, -0.02015686, 0.038360596, -0.0075683594, -0.026672363, 0.01940918, -0.0069465637, 0.01486969, 0.0067596436, 0.025634766, -0.013214111, 0.017105103, 0.010986328, 0.010658264, 0.00630188, 0.025482178, 0.0062713623, -0.008094788, 0.0044288635, -0.010040283, -0.004600525, -0.07342529, -0.044403076, -0.014457703, 0.03656006, 0.0002746582, -0.006175995, 0.03439331, -0.03756714, 0.030456543, -0.03213501, -0.034820557, -0.024429321, -0.013252258, -0.011459351, -0.00028538704, 0.010513306, -0.036071777, -0.0078086853, 0.011909485, 0.017349243, 0.0070610046, -0.013458252, -0.0005502701, 0.0067100525, -0.033416748, -0.011817932, 0.039215088, -0.046813965, -0.05117798, 0.023208618, -0.018371582, -0.008796692, 0.028121948, -0.0053710938, -0.016647339, 0.027389526, -0.0418396, 0.017852783, 0.021011353, -0.064453125, 0.015808105, 0.008712769, 0.022247314, 0.010650635, 0.017730713, 0.021026611, 0.010299683, -0.0357666, 0.008644104, 0.018341064, 0.009307861, -0.02229309, -0.015914917, 0.026443481, -0.028503418, 0.01184082, -0.010047913, -0.0115737915, 0.016296387, 0.009277344, -0.025146484, -0.034729004, 0.01537323, -0.04888916, -0.01096344, -0.01576233, 0.016693115, -0.036956787, -0.013252258, 0.006942749, -0.007446289, -0.011581421, -0.061340332, 0.026794434, 0.01512146, 0.059661865, -0.011474609, 0.0067634583, 0.026351929, -0.011360168, -0.027038574, 0.0013237, -0.038909912, -0.022644043, -0.06976318, -0.032714844, -0.024337769, 0.06530762, 0.012275696, 0.007820129, 0.007003784, -0.029830933, 0.009475708, -0.01751709, -0.010520935, 0.04864502, -0.013717651, -0.050445557, -0.0037765503, -0.0061798096, -0.064697266, 0.0038108826, 0.03289795, -0.0074157715, -0.009239197, 0.04611206, 0.031951904, -0.036224365, -0.06677246, -0.012359619, 0.036254883, 0.006149292, 0.06365967, 0.019958496, 0.021896362, 0.02645874, 0.04763794, 0.05496216, 0.05731201, -0.032958984, 0.03729248, 0.028167725, 0.040252686, 0.024520874, 0.0103302, -0.02293396, 0.0121536255, -0.019882202, 0.010055542, 0.0073165894, 0.018722534, 0.0069618225, -0.02532959, 0.02633667, -0.008041382, 0.0143966675, -0.018829346, -0.038330078, -0.025726318, 0.029159546, -0.016571045, -0.030715942, 0.03878784, -0.040740967, -0.029403687, 0.032165527, 0.010429382, 0.02217102, -0.015640259, 0.05340576, -0.00071430206, 0.001950264, 0.006755829, -0.011558533, -0.0077285767, 0.0032596588, 0.014808655, 0.00944519, -0.022155762, 0.035003662, 0.012519836, -0.0027809143, -0.0037193298, -0.03967285, -0.017242432, -0.010437012, -0.03604126, -0.03164673, 0.060577393, -0.014923096, -0.031341553, -0.052764893, -0.046936035, -0.030883789, 0.014625549, 0.002872467, -0.057373047, 0.062683105, -0.021331787, 0.0059394836, 0.048034668, -0.027282715, 0.032684326, -0.03201294, 0.08856201, 0.022109985, -0.024261475, -0.022354126, 0.010055542, 0.040649414, 0.012886047, 0.023010254, 0.089416504, -0.027618408, 0.0065574646, 0.04598999, -0.016189575, -0.097473145, 0.043762207, -0.035980225, -0.024642944, -0.020004272, 0.017562866, 0.015594482, -0.0004286766, 0.008087158, 0.014770508, 0.01322937, -0.015090942, -0.024963379, 0.0101623535, 0.010795593, -0.07543945, 0.010307312, 0.021240234, -0.0055122375, -0.0036201477, 0.005054474, 0.040740967, -0.043518066, -0.004688263, -0.001666069, 0.016036987, -0.016342163, -0.03363037, -0.051574707, -0.013000488, -0.0033988953, -0.024765015, -0.011421204, -0.045196533, 0.0079193115, 0.009719849, 0.034179688, 0.0074882507, 0.025985718, 0.019866943, 0.06890869, 0.046813965, -0.046447754, 0.055755615, 0.009414673, -0.024627686, 0.019546509, 0.01689148, -0.040008545, 0.013832092, -0.006668091, 0.052734375, 0.09625244, 0.06896973, -0.035583496, 0.051818848, 0.07183838, -0.021530151, 0.071777344, 0.0018539429, -0.004585266, -0.02784729, -0.013328552, -0.0023117065, 0.009567261, -0.008506775, 0.06506348, -0.028213501, -0.0035934448, -0.02909851, 0.02658081, -0.042419434, -0.0075263977, 0.0027637482, -0.01550293, 0.023742676, -0.0057258606, -0.027389526, -0.038146973, -0.0385437, -0.03842163, 0.044525146, -0.020584106, 0.015022278, 0.039764404, -0.024337769, -0.04055786, 0.038360596, -0.0006313324, 0.082336426, -0.010536194, -0.016571045, 0.059326172, -0.009750366, 0.005367279, -0.050598145, -0.03289795, -0.0035037994, 0.03878784, -0.049346924, 0.010818481, 0.006996155, -0.036956787, -0.08135986, -0.04248047, -0.009864807, -0.042541504, 0.004146576, 0.028442383, -0.030761719, 0.063964844, 0.02003479, -0.01007843, 0.036193848, 0.00248909, -0.015113831, 0.042633057, -0.012832642, -0.024505615, 0.020050049, 0.033203125, 0.03201294, -0.01889038, -0.029876709, -0.010910034, 0.025344849, 0.044067383, -0.030395508, 0.006286621, 0.020446777, 0.017745972, 0.022369385, -0.037506104, -0.049560547, -0.043273926, 0.054748535, 0.011238098, 0.021987915, -0.016723633, 0.002149582, -0.010360718, 0.040374756, 0.00081682205, -0.029312134, -0.012649536, 0.015686035, -0.014312744, -0.023620605, 0.0011034012, -0.023895264, -0.027633667, 0.01083374, -0.015167236, -0.00021791458, -0.056671143, -0.04006958, 0.024017334, 0.013870239, 0.0368042, 0.01776123, 0.020629883, 0.024276733, 0.11010742, 0.008880615, -0.008338928, 0.0107421875, 0.0008006096, 0.02583313, 0.012565613, 0.018737793, -0.031951904, 0.0042037964, 0.013252258, -0.001033783, 0.027404785, 0.011619568, -0.030059814, -0.009994507, -0.036468506, -0.013092041, -0.0791626, -0.04522705, 0.03564453, -0.03982544, 0.0076141357, -0.012008667, -0.010101318, 0.010505676, 0.022140503, 0.009361267, -0.021377563, 0.049072266, 0.049682617, 0.017410278, 0.01777649 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2012.09812v2
ViNG: Learning Open-World Navigation with Visual Goals
Dhruv Shah, Benjamin Eysenbach, Gregory Kahn, Nicholas Rhinehart, Sergey Levine
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
We propose a learning-based navigation system for reaching visually indicated goals and demonstrate this system on a real mobile robot platform. Learning provides an appealing alternative to conventional methods for robotic navigation: instead of reasoning about environments in terms of geometry and maps, learning can enable a robot to learn about navigational affordances, understand what types of obstacles are traversable (e.g., tall grass) or not (e.g., walls), and generalize over patterns in the environment. However, unlike conventional planning algorithms, it is harder to change the goal for a learned policy during deployment. We propose a method for learning to navigate towards a goal image of the desired destination. By combining a learned policy with a topological graph constructed out of previously observed data, our system can determine how to reach this visually indicated goal even in the presence of variable appearance and lighting. Three key insights, waypoint proposal, graph pruning and negative mining, enable our method to learn to navigate in real-world environments using only offline data, a setting where prior methods struggle. We instantiate our method on a real outdoor ground robot and show that our system, which we call ViNG, outperforms previously-proposed methods for goal-conditioned reinforcement learning, including other methods that incorporate reinforcement learning and search. We also study how \sysName generalizes to unseen environments and evaluate its ability to adapt to such an environment with growing experience. Finally, we demonstrate ViNG on a number of real-world applications, such as last-mile delivery and warehouse inspection. We encourage the reader to visit the project website for videos of our experiments and demonstrations sites.google.com/view/ving-robot.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2012.09812v2
"2021-03-26T11:12:28"
"2020-12-17T18:22:32"
{ "title": [ -0.015617371, 0.0020599365, -0.022872925, -0.021835327, 0.0112838745, -0.01626587, 0.010437012, -0.023223877, -0.0025787354, 0.013496399, -0.02520752, 0.014411926, -0.04434204, -0.010856628, -0.032989502, -0.015380859, 0.0021400452, 0.0024681091, -0.03552246, -0.038513184, -0.018875122, -0.037353516, 0.03717041, 0.08508301, 0.021774292, 0.006313324, -0.12164307, 0.032318115, -0.06774902, -0.027755737, -0.024902344, 0.038116455, 0.035247803, 0.01348114, -0.0057792664, -0.018096924, -0.029129028, -0.0010738373, -0.010673523, 0.01210022, 0.026473999, -0.018432617, -0.06726074, -0.015945435, -0.0670166, 0.015960693, -0.048583984, -0.0035324097, -0.033172607, 0.05203247, 0.02468872, 0.026992798, -0.0037937164, 0.048675537, 0.021713257, -0.05215454, -0.004020691, -0.04586792, 0.04473877, 0.0574646, 0.020019531, -0.06738281, 0.016677856, -0.027572632, -0.032073975, -0.024490356, 0.008148193, 0.016662598, 0.05130005, 0.0059051514, -0.01739502, 0.03829956, -0.009742737, 0.030319214, -0.0362854, -0.016601562, 0.055541992, 0.033203125, 0.021133423, 0.0023937225, -0.0025310516, -0.012306213, -0.02609253, -0.03302002, 0.01838684, -0.04171753, -0.0052833557, -0.00907135, -0.044830322, -0.078063965, -0.009315491, 0.02180481, -0.051818848, -0.010910034, -0.032836914, -0.034088135, -0.023040771, 0.021713257, 0.012916565, 0.004108429, -0.010902405, 0.011962891, -0.020370483, -0.026916504, 0.009063721, 0.029586792, -0.005264282, -0.011642456, 0.01210022, 0.029754639, -0.024032593, 0.01965332, 0.025894165, 0.03137207, -0.021362305, -0.032226562, -0.021896362, 0.012588501, -0.0015363693, 0.02267456, -0.012672424, -0.0234375, 0.017318726, 0.018508911, 0.027801514, 0.013000488, -0.033447266, -0.0061149597, 0.0018644333, 0.017486572, 0.011245728, 0.046722412, -0.11053467, -0.09515381, -0.066223145, 0.048980713, -0.021636963, 0.015899658, -0.013374329, 0.004005432, 0.003376007, -0.0029392242, 0.039978027, -0.011123657, 0.017501831, 0.012557983, 0.05859375, -0.0003402233, -0.041259766, -0.04534912, 0.0021400452, 0.011772156, 0.0003876686, 0.0051116943, -0.027313232, -0.001789093, -0.11456299, 0.008026123, 0.037475586, 0.024002075, 0.025344849, 0.024154663, 0.016220093, -0.0090789795, 0.03439331, -0.04309082, -0.042999268, 0.010620117, 0.011871338, 0.053253174, -0.018066406, 0.029464722, -0.009223938, -0.016479492, -0.013298035, -0.020904541, 0.047088623, -0.023376465, 0.017333984, 0.04449463, 0.023376465, -0.008361816, 0.0039863586, 0.034088135, -0.052124023, -0.025344849, -0.008705139, -0.019607544, 0.053527832, 0.0067863464, -0.03387451, 0.018035889, -0.038970947, -0.035705566, -0.029327393, -0.008338928, 0.025299072, 0.018722534, 0.0051727295, 0.009056091, -0.0051078796, -0.019073486, -0.015197754, 0.006954193, -0.026504517, -0.02746582, -0.016189575, 0.01689148, -0.050720215, 0.06185913, 0.05581665, 0.014289856, -0.050201416, 0.0368042, 0.023452759, -0.06915283, 0.038482666, -0.0211792, -0.0034885406, -0.030715942, -0.004875183, 0.00046038628, 0.009376526, 0.065979004, 0.023757935, 0.01361084, -0.0010309219, -0.007835388, 0.037139893, 0.028137207, 0.038757324, -0.040252686, 0.017105103, 0.01713562, -0.018981934, -0.039398193, -0.035003662, -0.020492554, 0.022247314, 0.033111572, -0.007045746, -0.02558899, -0.02067566, 0.03253174, 0.03564453, -0.00095415115, -0.0021820068, 0.023757935, -0.01272583, 0.016845703, 0.057739258, 0.04776001, 0.034729004, 0.043548584, -0.012428284, 0.049468994, 0.008506775, 0.010040283, -0.023361206, 0.0011701584, 0.001657486, -0.0077171326, -0.0006709099, 0.0039978027, -0.08502197, 0.0010948181, -0.03390503, 0.00566864, 0.011428833, -0.023284912, 0.042938232, 0.03778076, 0.0075035095, -0.017868042, 0.030654907, -0.018035889, -0.020019531, 0.01826477, 0.043060303, -0.06201172, -0.01449585, -0.018829346, 0.050079346, -0.00409317, 0.036987305, 0.01436615, 0.026809692, -0.049041748, 0.0048713684, -0.023849487, 0.039398193, -0.0017004013, -0.009536743, 0.018997192, -0.003753662, -0.037231445, 0.054992676, 0.06903076, -0.021102905, 0.025650024, -0.054107666, 0.024047852, -0.008323669, -0.0076904297, 0.0015172958, 0.039367676, 0.031311035, 0.010765076, -0.016189575, 0.01524353, -0.03074646, -0.0012264252, 0.00069999695, -0.03286743, -0.05328369, -0.038909912, -0.012916565, -0.051971436, -0.06329346, -0.034484863, 0.047210693, -0.0141067505, 0.0031147003, 0.026016235, -0.0021953583, -0.028823853, 0.02909851, -0.025543213, -0.009925842, 0.040222168, 0.015144348, 0.03982544, -0.046905518, 0.0014076233, -0.013160706, 0.023605347, -0.01058197, -0.0463562, -0.041229248, 0.014709473, 0.0024051666, 0.005809784, 0.032806396, -0.06591797, -0.013153076, -0.076049805, 0.003376007, 0.012420654, -0.023925781, -0.02468872, 0.049102783, -0.017669678, -0.009757996, 0.022567749, 0.080200195, -0.044281006, -0.037017822, 0.04574585, 0.020629883, -0.0101623535, 0.023422241, 0.0017614365, -0.00046610832, -0.0446167, -0.0059509277, -0.028656006, -0.015838623, -0.014373779, 0.023239136, 0.060577393, -0.078125, 0.0073280334, -0.01159668, -0.004016876, 0.033996582, 0.025726318, -0.0014886856, -0.023101807, -0.01713562, -0.0025157928, 0.0049591064, 0.02809143, -0.05206299, -0.0023727417, 0.10083008, 0.01977539, 0.00050497055, 0.017807007, 0.03314209, -0.0020427704, -0.022125244, -0.029205322, -0.030548096, 0.02293396, 0.004863739, -0.015174866, 0.0031471252, 0.022949219, -0.1427002, -0.0015773773, -0.02243042, 0.030380249, -0.018722534, 0.021591187, -0.06585693, 0.009017944, -0.03475952, -0.050323486, 0.035095215, 0.058563232, 0.00024008751, 0.020248413, 0.008338928, -0.0058784485, -0.013771057, -0.0060195923, -0.080078125, 0.03237915, -0.04168701, -0.038879395, -0.0074272156, 0.0077400208, -0.038909912, -0.013717651, 0.025436401, 0.03591919, 0.031799316, -0.0047912598, 0.037506104, -0.001537323, 0.0077552795, -0.014533997, -0.01927185, -0.03338623, -0.042877197, -0.03274536, -0.0012235641, 0.046051025, 0.041992188, -0.01285553, -0.04953003, 0.008888245, -0.007926941, 0.028335571, 0.007610321, -0.031341553, 0.011329651, -0.016784668, -0.014183044, 0.009315491, -0.020202637, -0.0025749207, -0.03363037, 0.013114929, -0.021057129, 0.051208496, -0.00070858, 0.0020141602, 0.019195557, -0.047180176, -0.0053520203, -0.02507019, -0.06365967, 0.01071167, 0.01260376, 0.0048332214, 0.017837524, -0.03201294, -0.045898438, 0.023483276, -0.05340576, 0.021469116, 0.011329651, -0.0010280609, 0.0067710876, 0.0048332214, -0.017089844, 0.0023937225, -0.031402588, 0.011375427, 0.03881836, -0.01953125, 0.023971558, -0.025146484, 0.013687134, -0.0016155243, -0.10614014, 0.007205963, 0.021377563, 0.008590698, 0.005683899, -0.04751587, 0.030838013, -0.0053863525, -0.026168823, 0.013519287, -0.017807007, 0.012016296, 0.0181427, -0.057403564, -0.018630981, 0.06750488, -0.002948761, -0.010292053, 0.061584473, 0.0011053085, -0.014129639, -0.019714355, 0.010055542, 0.036071777, 0.032073975, 0.0019044876, -0.021087646, 0.057159424, -0.047668457, 0.024597168, 0.03201294, 0.040405273, -0.014717102, -0.003993988, -0.0231781, -0.015312195, -0.016647339, 0.057128906, 0.0049591064, 0.0052490234, -0.06097412, 0.046051025, 0.013282776, 0.0134887695, 0.009880066, -0.029724121, 0.014656067, 0.012260437, 0.015151978, 0.04260254, -0.009529114, -0.03829956, 0.025054932, 0.025772095, -0.012924194, -0.0067749023, 0.015792847, 0.03744507, -0.0028324127, -0.0056152344, -0.035461426, 0.01335144, -0.015045166, -0.013679504, -0.010414124, -0.004611969, -0.07019043, -0.028808594, -0.032470703, -0.037017822, 0.005771637, 0.0078125, -0.033203125, 0.0053863525, 0.019805908, -0.0131073, -0.028152466, 0.0124053955, 0.017684937, 0.013946533, -0.03451538, -0.07318115, 0.0042152405, 0.016494751, -0.06591797, -0.028503418, -0.014266968, -0.021057129, 0.02760315, -0.0178833, -0.021759033, 0.021484375, 0.029067993, 0.10180664, 0.044158936, 0.009902954, -0.068237305, 0.07098389, -0.029724121, -0.025299072, 0.03930664, 0.00096845627, -0.004722595, -0.049102783, 0.0040664673, -0.00065612793, -0.025314331, -0.020812988, 0.010017395, 0.008178711, 0.029571533, 0.008628845, 0.056365967, 0.023071289, 0.027420044, 0.0017166138, 0.016204834, -0.03665161, -0.01525116, -0.023605347, 0.02748108, 0.02923584, 0.010528564, 0.019454956, 0.016357422, 0.024673462, -0.0071983337, 0.0069274902, 0.0051841736, -0.010635376, -0.005130768, 0.03262329, -0.024673462, -0.022140503, 0.0031738281, -0.0030460358, 0.028396606, -0.020599365, 0.07055664, 0.0043029785, -0.015945435, 0.03842163, -0.0004377365, 0.015304565, 0.0016546249, -0.0024299622, -0.06512451, -0.09222412, -0.028747559, 0.07733154, -0.02432251, -0.018035889, 0.009284973, -0.0002734661, 0.047790527, 0.064941406, 0.06921387, -0.03488159, -0.027770996, -0.0006465912, -0.012207031, -0.024902344, -0.047332764, 0.0071411133, 0.0024757385, 0.009315491, -0.061920166, 0.024429321, -0.03250122, -0.019561768, -0.019119263, -0.00087833405, 0.010803223, -0.06298828, 0.007637024, 0.06738281, 0.019332886, 0.030227661, 0.030731201, 0.013374329, 0.0037345886, 0.047821045, -0.008964539, 0.052703857, 0.015075684, -0.018859863, 0.056152344, 0.026611328, 0.017456055, -0.022857666, -0.015792847, -0.023330688, -0.03062439, -0.0037765503, 0.029541016, -0.019973755, -0.03173828, 0.0066833496, -0.027542114, 0.0021743774, 0.013977051, 0.020111084, 0.005367279, -0.02394104, -0.024230957, -0.02142334, -0.015602112, -0.05041504, 0.011352539, -0.019439697, -0.005329132, -0.0791626, 0.0075416565, -0.054016113, 0.011734009, 0.0011358261, 0.015312195, -0.022354126, 0.008659363, 0.04559326, 0.018234253, -0.0006275177, -0.0096588135, 0.001291275, 0.022262573, 0.0231781, -0.0423584, -0.00831604, 0.0021514893, -0.044433594, -0.04473877, 0.009094238, 0.009002686, -0.0132369995, -0.015068054, -0.072143555, -0.0065994263, 0.008911133, 0.022644043, -0.010917664, -0.00818634, 0.016784668, 0.009536743, -0.017868042, 0.020812988, -0.004245758, -0.048065186, 0.029769897, 0.009506226, 0.036376953, 0.0362854, -0.017410278, 0.013244629, -0.0024051666, -0.030975342, 0.013717651, 0.030715942, 0.0046310425, -0.03427124, 0.00995636, 0.024734497, -0.0033302307, -0.005027771, -0.01675415, 0.054504395, -0.028182983, 0.039489746, 0.020736694, 0.013450623, -0.029373169, 0.013809204, -0.0052375793, 0.03225708, -0.052825928, -0.053863525, -0.032470703, -0.008171082, 0.024551392, -0.005279541, 0.0031852722, -0.020355225, 0.013557434, -0.025024414, -0.006526947, -0.030380249, 0.008956909, -0.009262085, -0.022750854, 0.010101318, 0.029174805, 0.02519226, -0.016540527, 0.021438599, -0.024795532, -0.01838684, 0.011100769, -0.02192688, 0.031341553, -0.015838623, -0.03112793, 0.032806396, 0.0044555664, -0.022918701, 0.015312195, -0.024978638, 0.06262207, 0.04095459, 0.049987793, 0.053009033, 0.011833191, 0.016189575, 0.016403198, 0.02229309, -0.028076172, 0.008216858, -0.042510986, -0.0024433136, -0.017913818, -0.014442444, -0.05493164, -0.009155273, 0.042755127, 0.006214142, 0.031188965, -0.0017347336, -0.0038051605, 0.02746582, 0.018539429, 0.029907227, 0.031341553, -0.019165039, -0.015312195, 0.0040626526, -0.008522034, 0.030639648, 0.047454834, 0.01902771, -0.014297485, -0.026824951, -0.01675415, 0.010147095, 0.015823364, 0.01260376, -0.010070801, -0.02319336, -0.025009155, 0.02633667, -0.0118255615, 0.016540527, 0.066345215, 0.042877197, -0.031082153, -0.011009216, 0.027252197, -0.0009355545, -0.036071777, 0.01713562, 0.030288696, -0.063964844, 0.013938904, -0.002840042, -0.017471313, -0.008995056, 0.035217285, 0.047943115, -0.05606079, -0.015449524, 0.046020508, 0.025222778, -0.013015747, -0.0107040405, -0.052001953, -0.024475098, 0.003446579, 0.01574707, -0.021072388, -0.012664795, 0.018829346, 0.008422852, -0.0011930466, -0.037139893, 0.029052734, 0.0025978088, 0.018157959, 0.034362793, -0.011062622, 0.05834961, 0.009025574, -0.033843994, 0.030654907, 0.014404297, -0.05871582, 0.0061912537, 0.02368164, 0.052001953, 0.024520874, 0.0473938, -0.018463135, -0.02722168, 0.007598877, -0.033294678, 0.032562256, 0.02861023, -0.03314209, 0.017532349, -0.03805542, -0.033172607, 0.02670288, -0.051757812, 0.02218628, -0.03756714, 0.0032920837, -0.020599365, 0.0023002625, 0.060516357, -0.061828613, -0.03729248, -0.027114868, -0.0008764267, 0.0049934387, -0.005207062, -0.020584106, 0.008735657, 0.02519226, 0.0076026917, 0.046722412, 0.00021588802, -0.012611389, -0.01663208, -0.06317139, -0.008216858, -0.043640137, 0.031188965, -0.00566864, -0.04699707, -0.04989624, 0.0070724487, 0.04196167, 0.027374268, -0.034057617, 0.02796936, -0.040130615, -0.021621704, -0.004673004, 0.0036125183, -0.012268066, 0.007648468, -0.0335083, 0.029800415, -0.022094727, 0.0069999695, 0.04611206, -0.041412354, -0.039886475, 0.010871887, -0.025527954, 0.046783447, 0.007030487, -0.010543823, 0.00013780594, 0.024291992, -0.033325195, -0.014823914, 0.014480591, 0.035736084, -0.006454468, -0.02897644, 0.013244629, 0.008132935, 0.026626587, -0.052825928, -0.032287598, 0.0028247833, 0.026977539, -0.0026664734, 0.049560547, 0.013648987, -0.0013599396, 0.025344849, 0.021743774, 0.013023376, -0.045440674, -0.043945312, -0.029876709, 0.035461426, 0.032348633, 0.00459671, -0.03555298, 0.019165039, -0.018569946, 0.02027893, -0.007545471, 0.011688232, 0.022155762, -0.010025024, 0.061523438, -0.021636963, 0.02772522, -0.044281006, 0.018157959, 0.0066108704, 0.04071045, -0.026412964, 0.025985718, -0.0015707016, 0.06738281, -0.026412964, -0.054260254, 0.031066895, 0.044952393, 0.0018453598, 0.048797607, -0.034698486, -0.022415161, -0.00894165, 0.02407837, 0.011207581, 0.022460938, 0.010520935, -0.0061836243, 0.027526855, -0.05404663, -0.037506104, 0.016799927, -0.025817871, 0.013893127, -0.04373169, 0.005153656, -0.019882202, -0.02079773, -0.010353088, 0.053466797, 0.0011434555, -0.042266846, -0.030166626, 0.036987305, 0.06890869, -0.0023517609 ], "summary": [ 0.029006958, -0.030136108, 0.02619934, -0.0029716492, -0.03491211, -0.022277832, 0.013343811, -0.01701355, -0.0019292831, 0.020370483, -0.042419434, 0.012046814, -0.046966553, -0.008277893, -0.027618408, -0.06121826, 0.041412354, 0.033935547, 0.03765869, -0.012176514, 0.010185242, 0.02217102, 0.0017051697, 0.111694336, 0.004737854, 0.036468506, -0.03857422, 0.010871887, -0.0062446594, 0.018249512, 0.014831543, -0.0385437, 0.018051147, -0.03253174, 0.051116943, -0.030273438, 0.02986145, -0.025527954, -0.0035648346, 0.0236969, 0.020507812, -0.014472961, 0.036102295, -0.041900635, -0.004673004, 0.016204834, -0.016326904, -0.042907715, -0.00015926361, 0.006904602, 0.005443573, 0.015365601, 0.007675171, 0.045043945, -0.016113281, -0.028320312, -0.03555298, -0.0491333, 0.04449463, 0.029953003, 0.011985779, -0.07470703, 0.01058197, -0.03201294, 0.012832642, -0.0002579689, 0.04763794, 0.0047416687, 0.01789856, 0.018081665, 0.016036987, 0.011741638, -0.015274048, 0.03643799, -0.034973145, -0.022262573, 0.06536865, 0.021774292, -0.02835083, 0.014823914, -0.023101807, 0.015136719, -0.03414917, -0.068725586, 0.024887085, -0.060150146, -0.007583618, 0.020874023, -0.04559326, -0.057037354, -0.030639648, 0.08496094, -0.097717285, -0.029159546, -0.01612854, -0.047180176, -0.02696228, -0.053344727, 0.051818848, 0.034240723, 0.025375366, -0.053833008, 0.05001831, -0.016677856, -0.0018749237, 0.035491943, 0.02192688, -0.014930725, 0.012580872, 0.0008368492, -0.01902771, 0.020446777, 0.025146484, 0.0085372925, -0.026779175, -0.014343262, -0.0021476746, -0.008163452, -0.011894226, -0.015930176, -0.012893677, 0.011436462, -0.028778076, 0.031341553, 0.0138168335, 0.0055274963, 0.007572174, 0.011444092, 0.05908203, 0.0057411194, -0.0010242462, 0.01033783, -0.047180176, -0.046203613, -0.045318604, 0.005168915, 0.007217407, 0.008468628, 0.032348633, -0.03805542, 0.03857422, -0.0074882507, 0.004486084, 0.046966553, -0.020111084, 0.02973938, 0.009712219, 0.010826111, -0.012779236, -0.017105103, -0.02911377, 0.006401062, -0.013885498, 0.0024166107, 0.019317627, -0.04547119, -0.05758667, -0.0053596497, 0.08105469, 0.014335632, 0.013557434, 0.013557434, 0.032073975, -0.038330078, -0.028411865, -0.04840088, -0.06021118, 0.00059890747, 0.0109939575, 0.029037476, 0.009101868, 0.035827637, -0.023101807, -0.0234375, 0.0024089813, -0.044708252, 0.008232117, 0.014854431, 0.017501831, 0.018585205, 0.017822266, -0.0049705505, 0.030700684, 0.014282227, 0.0018014908, -0.02558899, -0.011978149, -0.031066895, 0.049743652, 0.0059776306, -0.016036987, 0.011558533, -0.0076675415, 0.011642456, 0.0127334595, -0.033294678, -0.031280518, -0.01436615, -0.014442444, 0.004047394, 0.029693604, 0.013824463, 0.0029773712, 0.027770996, -0.02015686, 0.022766113, -0.0040130615, 0.011413574, -0.034057617, 0.022979736, 0.030273438, -0.045928955, -0.019561768, 0.010810852, 0.0017261505, -0.053527832, 0.05419922, -0.03756714, -0.0039634705, -0.06958008, -0.0045547485, 0.023071289, -0.03375244, 0.07684326, 0.00021076202, 0.026687622, -0.03161621, 0.029342651, 0.019058228, 0.028930664, 0.020736694, -0.0011873245, -0.0019779205, 0.04446411, -0.01373291, -0.031951904, -0.0262146, -0.052703857, 0.032104492, 0.04425049, 0.00737381, -0.0098724365, -0.033111572, 0.008605957, 0.0016899109, -0.02128601, -0.0090408325, 0.019165039, -0.07550049, -0.015434265, 0.01838684, 0.06304932, 0.018920898, 0.08355713, -0.033813477, 0.029449463, -0.0016870499, -0.0021190643, -0.0007596016, 0.0024585724, 0.008430481, -0.010650635, -0.028366089, 0.002960205, -0.05899048, -0.042755127, 0.0022296906, 0.005470276, 0.018676758, -0.084350586, 0.036254883, 0.079711914, -0.017654419, -0.057434082, -0.012519836, -0.034454346, -0.051086426, 0.052764893, 0.06500244, -0.050811768, -0.021881104, -0.030166626, 0.042877197, -0.0032405853, 0.0284729, 0.014533997, 0.06201172, 0.015625, -0.004421234, 0.0011615753, 0.036346436, 0.014266968, -0.0043258667, -0.006641388, -0.018493652, -0.029052734, -0.023849487, 0.071777344, -0.028335571, -0.004802704, -0.04699707, 0.00340271, -0.034851074, -0.0038204193, -0.00016343594, 0.012916565, 0.020523071, -0.02279663, -0.016418457, 0.024246216, -0.06903076, -0.019561768, 0.01335144, 0.035614014, -0.016052246, -0.007785797, -0.014854431, 0.036956787, -0.021942139, 0.0049858093, 0.017913818, 0.007801056, -0.0047302246, 0.07952881, 0.009468079, -0.02470398, 0.10571289, -0.010177612, -0.010894775, 0.012390137, -0.022842407, -0.0010843277, -0.004951477, 0.016479492, -0.021850586, -0.004901886, 0.024261475, -0.05960083, -0.010169983, 0.020004272, 0.052764893, 0.0048675537, 0.011505127, -0.0024204254, -0.043884277, -0.06585693, 0.01109314, -0.024719238, 0.03781128, -0.042633057, 0.05670166, 0.009155273, -0.018356323, 0.03665161, 0.034851074, -0.06768799, 0.018707275, 0.042053223, -0.028747559, -0.017578125, 0.04736328, 0.00856781, 0.0155181885, -0.05731201, -0.035339355, -0.029373169, -0.0052337646, -0.020812988, 0.0446167, 0.08001709, -0.03552246, 0.058898926, -0.019378662, -0.0064888, 0.0044174194, 0.011726379, 0.050933838, -0.018737793, 0.008171082, 0.025924683, 0.031280518, 0.045166016, -0.033050537, 0.0124053955, 0.08282471, 0.008621216, -0.0053634644, 0.0496521, 0.019607544, -0.0017108917, -0.027648926, -0.012893677, 0.00617218, -0.02468872, -0.030303955, -0.014022827, 0.0010471344, 0.03656006, -0.03463745, -0.0052490234, -0.059936523, 0.036346436, 0.0026378632, 0.00831604, 0.014381409, 0.010261536, 0.008880615, -0.050689697, 0.015052795, 0.04827881, 0.00049829483, -0.008094788, 0.02029419, -0.01525116, -0.0033988953, 0.010643005, 0.05227661, 0.015640259, -0.03640747, -0.033203125, 0.010139465, 0.061401367, -0.022125244, -0.021469116, -0.0126571655, -0.020492554, 0.034301758, 0.021652222, 0.003944397, 0.044769287, 0.0234375, -0.009780884, 0.010681152, -0.010025024, -0.08087158, -0.050354004, -0.007286072, 0.0037250519, 0.057800293, -0.05709839, -0.044555664, 0.015640259, 0.03164673, -0.018127441, -0.0028305054, -0.008361816, 0.052703857, -0.010688782, -0.018249512, -0.019638062, -0.010116577, 0.012008667, 0.036834717, 0.028533936, -0.012779236, 0.09399414, 0.013168335, 0.02470398, 0.07104492, -0.062561035, -0.04473877, -0.0063171387, -0.04788208, -0.0044517517, -0.0019931793, 0.013748169, 0.010177612, -0.01512146, -0.037872314, 0.016571045, -0.035339355, 0.017547607, 0.015655518, -0.002401352, -0.018798828, -0.005794525, 0.0463562, -0.019134521, 0.025970459, -0.040924072, -0.002500534, 0.012870789, -0.054779053, -0.0051078796, -0.01890564, 0.026031494, -0.055480957, -0.024215698, 0.010017395, 0.04159546, 0.02229309, -0.003458023, 0.045196533, 0.00705719, -0.017593384, 0.022369385, -0.013710022, 0.048736572, 0.03024292, -0.03845215, -0.02079773, 0.0027751923, 0.024963379, -0.022338867, 0.025543213, 0.002576828, 0.017181396, -0.0079193115, -0.0034618378, 0.03527832, 0.0018920898, -0.029006958, 0.03375244, 0.027374268, -0.017196655, 0.002588272, 0.060333252, 0.0262146, -0.011169434, -0.01600647, -0.0062942505, 0.019973755, -0.014091492, 0.025543213, 0.023880005, 0.014732361, -0.055847168, 0.050994873, -0.021240234, -0.0053367615, -0.022476196, 0.03741455, -0.022094727, -0.018829346, 0.048797607, -0.034973145, -0.023712158, -0.025650024, -0.0036239624, 0.0206604, -0.018341064, -0.045135498, 0.02168274, 0.026489258, 0.0007958412, -0.039123535, -0.032684326, -0.011833191, -0.060638428, 0.02355957, -0.018188477, -0.032409668, -0.08093262, -0.0423584, -0.0035476685, -0.004173279, 0.010025024, 0.011650085, -0.031677246, -0.027709961, -0.009521484, 0.029403687, -0.017913818, -0.002439499, 0.007385254, 0.033721924, -0.0463562, -0.05722046, -0.013519287, -0.0045280457, -0.06939697, -0.026763916, -0.032043457, -0.05493164, -0.010383606, -0.005378723, 0.0049438477, -0.0027484894, 0.07006836, 0.12390137, 0.028671265, 0.03466797, -0.066101074, -0.005870819, -0.02532959, -0.004711151, 0.025497437, -0.03652954, -0.024429321, -0.041625977, -0.021469116, 0.025985718, -0.025543213, -0.03503418, 0.007904053, 0.0007300377, 0.027389526, 0.052886963, 0.06903076, 0.02671814, -0.0060539246, 0.020401001, 0.011749268, -0.014381409, -0.017120361, 0.019821167, -0.0013828278, 0.0021362305, -0.011634827, -0.0062942505, 0.013282776, 0.023864746, -0.03189087, 0.0046043396, 0.0069465637, -0.06781006, -0.030212402, 0.039611816, 0.02709961, 0.0020198822, 0.037902832, 0.0037288666, 0.016494751, 0.029937744, 0.00957489, 0.053985596, -0.016296387, 0.039093018, -0.011199951, 0.0025424957, 0.015777588, -0.040527344, -0.085998535, -0.05230713, -0.066345215, 0.051635742, -0.022659302, -0.05291748, 0.014778137, -0.030960083, 0.061065674, -0.0032691956, 0.02671814, -0.06048584, -0.014198303, 0.010368347, -0.0138168335, 0.032928467, -0.0077781677, 0.0022621155, -0.010025024, -0.014953613, -0.03756714, -0.022460938, 0.022338867, -0.02079773, -0.039276123, 0.022842407, -0.016906738, -0.016296387, -0.05444336, -0.0043792725, -0.006565094, 0.005329132, 0.059539795, 0.015838623, -0.04901123, 0.030807495, -0.022445679, 0.053009033, -0.015510559, -0.0058135986, 0.10614014, 0.012275696, 0.010322571, -0.035491943, 0.0040130615, -0.036376953, -0.028747559, 0.007865906, 0.01386261, -0.035003662, -0.019058228, -0.021636963, -0.00039243698, 0.01737976, -0.014961243, 0.031066895, -0.009986877, -0.040222168, 0.0023403168, 0.00995636, -0.03289795, -0.039733887, -0.0007071495, -0.051483154, 0.037902832, -0.057037354, -0.00504303, -0.07269287, 0.025222778, 0.0020961761, 0.017074585, 0.0028915405, -0.0088272095, 0.018310547, 0.025466919, -0.0095825195, 0.03060913, 0.021621704, -0.0059013367, 0.0011968613, -0.03866577, 0.0010299683, -0.0019321442, -0.02658081, -0.070129395, -0.014602661, -0.03125, 0.014732361, -0.0077781677, -0.028503418, 0.015037537, -0.04522705, 0.0015516281, -0.015899658, 0.028961182, 0.013687134, -0.01739502, -0.06185913, 0.06512451, -0.022399902, -0.06378174, 0.034698486, 0.010124207, 0.052337646, 0.015388489, 0.018539429, 0.0287323, -0.00687027, -0.009269714, -0.014099121, 0.034698486, 0.009277344, 0.007369995, 0.027786255, 0.019699097, 0.026153564, -0.018798828, 0.010726929, -0.0017032623, -0.00014913082, 0.040802002, 0.050231934, 0.018035889, 0.011100769, 0.023773193, 0.0054397583, 0.040985107, -0.04626465, -0.02746582, -0.007381439, -0.062927246, 0.002943039, -0.04107666, -0.01864624, -0.0085372925, -0.037994385, 0.02168274, 0.005760193, -0.007724762, 0.039764404, 0.0030117035, -0.02229309, -0.03050232, 0.008285522, 0.036956787, -0.008918762, -0.006614685, -0.020263672, -0.019134521, 0.033935547, -0.03652954, 0.016159058, 0.0035533905, 0.00705719, 0.021850586, -0.013061523, 0.008171082, -0.00982666, -0.008369446, 0.018997192, 0.013618469, 0.03829956, 0.009597778, -0.007499695, 0.03729248, 0.0073165894, 0.010276794, -0.025115967, -0.013221741, -0.023513794, -0.062927246, -0.014228821, -0.037902832, -0.008728027, 0.010856628, 0.011726379, -0.03878784, 0.053497314, -0.013626099, -0.011749268, 0.08081055, -0.04385376, 0.070739746, -0.027023315, -0.022064209, -0.049865723, 0.025527954, 0.025817871, -0.009185791, 0.030456543, 0.028656006, 0.0021858215, 0.020874023, -0.002538681, 0.040161133, -0.024917603, -0.00034308434, -0.04663086, 0.0004775524, -0.04083252, -0.007381439, -0.009407043, 0.025741577, 0.013214111, 0.004890442, 0.02079773, -0.007217407, 0.019592285, -0.01826477, -0.031311035, -0.009315491, -0.0026416779, -0.036621094, 0.012451172, 0.005744934, -0.0062675476, 0.0104904175, 0.033599854, 0.04248047, -0.03036499, 0.010673523, 0.012878418, 0.00217247, -0.012321472, -0.011795044, -0.046325684, -0.04031372, -0.0010690689, -0.0001500845, -0.015274048, 0.0041160583, 0.019180298, 0.0121536255, -0.0028381348, -0.0011005402, 0.013221741, -0.012466431, 0.034484863, 0.033325195, -0.039611816, 0.04736328, 0.005268097, -0.018966675, 0.03302002, 0.007247925, -0.02923584, 0.0178833, 0.0029315948, 0.012687683, 0.0037155151, 0.038116455, -0.04067993, -0.00016283989, 0.013557434, 0.022201538, 0.018707275, -0.013542175, -0.0105896, -0.005947113, -0.0004696846, 0.017150879, 0.010505676, 0.006214142, -0.00031876564, -0.02748108, -0.021972656, -0.022491455, -0.0050621033, 0.0077667236, -0.023666382, -0.016830444, -0.072509766, 0.039520264, 0.006565094, -0.03781128, -0.07965088, 0.053771973, -0.011711121, -0.038360596, 0.043182373, 0.013305664, 0.0047569275, -0.020217896, 0.032287598, -0.025177002, 0.0021190643, 0.039031982, 0.036895752, -0.051635742, -0.02015686, 0.0016546249, 0.038024902, 0.012748718, -0.032684326, 0.053497314, -0.00076675415, 0.010406494, -0.036621094, -0.021987915, -0.018173218, 0.036376953, 0.0046157837, 0.04714966, -0.012023926, 0.044158936, 0.016235352, -0.010047913, -0.014671326, 0.019119263, -0.015258789, 0.016433716, -0.03277588, -0.01713562, 0.028167725, 0.0051612854, -0.0017633438, 0.013122559, 0.028305054, 0.026107788, -0.013755798, -0.004650116, -0.013389587, -0.0040016174, 0.007381439, -0.034698486, -0.03665161, 0.0009551048, 0.020812988, -0.008834839, 0.01625061, -0.038909912, -0.009742737, 0.055114746, 0.06915283, 0.035491943, -0.02796936, -0.014259338, -0.029220581, 0.0034370422, -0.0029697418, -0.010238647, -0.013252258, 0.008354187, -0.011795044, 0.0074043274, -0.031341553, 0.039794922, 0.012954712, -0.023284912, 0.055908203, -0.03765869, 0.018798828, -0.025924683, 0.0050697327, -0.0031013489, 0.04244995, -0.019226074, 0.024383545, 0.016921997, 0.054748535, 0.011550903, -0.026184082, -0.012649536, 0.016555786, 0.0019626617, 0.016174316, -0.009223938, -0.038909912, 0.005207062, 0.056396484, 0.009552002, 0.10406494, 0.010040283, 0.03894043, 0.03652954, -0.059295654, -0.0074920654, -0.011726379, 0.0029697418, -0.010383606, -0.03414917, 0.0032653809, 0.01474762, -0.032165527, 0.0007529259, 0.032196045, -0.0018148422, -0.055999756, 0.02305603, 0.024139404, 0.026107788, 0.01486969 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2012.13533v1
Reconfigurable Intelligent Surface Assisted Mobile Edge Computing with Heterogeneous Learning Tasks
Shanfeng Huang, Shuai Wang, Rui Wang, Miaowen Wen, Kaibin Huang
cs.IT, cs.AI, cs.LG, math.IT
The ever-growing popularity and rapid improving of artificial intelligence (AI) have raised rethinking on the evolution of wireless networks. Mobile edge computing (MEC) provides a natural platform for AI applications since it is with rich computation resources to train machine learning (ML) models, as well as low-latency access to the data generated by mobile and internet of things (IoT) devices. In this paper, we present an infrastructure to perform ML tasks at an MEC server with the assistance of a reconfigurable intelligent surface (RIS). In contrast to conventional communication systems where the principal criterions are to maximize the throughput, we aim at maximizing the learning performance. Specifically, we minimize the maximum learning error of all participating users by jointly optimizing transmit power of mobile users, beamforming vectors of the base station (BS), and the phase-shift matrix of the RIS. An alternating optimization (AO)-based framework is proposed to optimize the three terms iteratively, where a successive convex approximation (SCA)-based algorithm is developed to solve the power allocation problem, closed-form expressions of the beamforming vectors are derived, and an alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM)-based algorithm is designed together with an error level searching (ELS) framework to effectively solve the challenging nonconvex optimization problem of the phase-shift matrix. Simulation results demonstrate significant gains of deploying an RIS and validate the advantages of our proposed algorithms over various benchmarks. Lastly, a unified communication-training-inference platform is developed based on the CARLA platform and the SECOND network, and a use case (3D object detection in autonomous driving) for the proposed scheme is demonstrated on the developed platform.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2012.13533v1
"2020-12-25T07:08:50"
"2020-12-25T07:08:50"
{ "title": [ -0.064941406, 0.012397766, -0.05581665, -0.011413574, 0.011024475, -0.0033607483, -0.008514404, -0.005592346, -0.053009033, 0.026565552, -0.027389526, 0.034606934, -0.02357483, -0.013572693, 0.007686615, -0.017715454, -0.009223938, 0.006000519, -0.037719727, -0.037384033, 0.004383087, -0.03567505, 0.019088745, 0.038970947, 0.01133728, -0.04434204, -0.14245605, 0.018173218, -0.04257202, -0.042419434, -0.024383545, 0.07128906, 0.044525146, 0.05419922, -0.08917236, -0.021240234, -0.060760498, 0.03074646, -0.02355957, 0.031982422, 0.015541077, 0.025756836, -0.001906395, -0.043548584, -0.034088135, 0.0067710876, -0.042755127, 0.0020484924, 0.019943237, 0.02255249, 0.015655518, 0.033203125, -0.012313843, 0.051361084, 0.0066223145, -0.021224976, -0.016647339, -0.013053894, 0.026626587, 0.049224854, 0.014801025, -0.008483887, 0.0032482147, -0.016860962, -0.009178162, -0.008110046, 0.010169983, 0.021759033, 0.019058228, -0.020584106, -0.01373291, -0.0023727417, 0.014350891, 0.017242432, -0.04751587, -0.026748657, 0.070373535, 0.0063934326, 0.019744873, -0.014793396, -0.031143188, 0.015792847, -0.0061950684, -0.049713135, 0.039916992, -0.034362793, -0.025817871, 0.0026836395, -0.035461426, -0.03314209, 0.004825592, -0.03652954, -0.007575989, 0.03616333, 0.0014228821, -0.026626587, -0.03378296, -0.047607422, 0.047943115, -0.0074768066, 0.025756836, -0.024810791, -0.029449463, 0.0033416748, 0.007888794, 0.025375366, -0.016571045, -0.039367676, 0.00919342, 0.025512695, -0.018051147, 0.019424438, 0.018798828, 0.017089844, -0.024108887, -0.0011329651, 0.013336182, -0.017501831, -0.008071899, -0.0017280579, -0.024047852, -0.04385376, 0.032226562, 0.041503906, 0.043640137, 0.027496338, -0.030044556, 0.00068092346, -0.0037460327, -0.03265381, 0.004322052, 0.07946777, -0.07183838, -0.07055664, -0.06896973, 0.06011963, 0.011383057, -0.0077056885, 0.024841309, -0.015991211, 0.05831909, -0.01626587, -0.028625488, 0.054595947, 0.007827759, 0.007774353, 0.050842285, -0.0035934448, -0.030471802, -0.03640747, -0.006477356, 0.019836426, 0.010520935, -0.007724762, -0.015930176, 0.0022201538, -0.10095215, -0.012573242, 0.019363403, 0.021911621, 0.034057617, 0.03967285, 0.024276733, 0.06137085, 0.08911133, -0.05026245, -0.02116394, 0.021499634, 0.005580902, -0.0019683838, 0.0073242188, -0.020751953, -0.016693115, -0.0037670135, 0.004673004, 0.020690918, 0.06829834, 0.0004234314, 0.0077285767, -0.011459351, 0.008857727, -0.016403198, 0.014053345, 0.0181427, -0.035461426, -0.04006958, 0.0030345917, -0.015609741, 0.027801514, 0.008201599, -0.032165527, 0.012397766, -0.04333496, -0.044128418, -0.04208374, -0.015457153, 0.019836426, 0.018615723, -0.008705139, 0.033355713, -0.02532959, 0.001584053, -0.02748108, 0.0262146, -0.012390137, -0.038848877, 0.002412796, 0.0075531006, 0.04940796, 0.059936523, -0.012321472, 0.0059013367, -0.00084400177, -0.021743774, -0.017745972, -0.026931763, 0.025268555, -0.0059890747, -0.013702393, -0.034240723, -0.000998497, -0.033416748, 0.0032444, 0.05618286, 0.018447876, 0.032318115, -0.009414673, -0.007659912, 0.04748535, 0.032714844, 0.06890869, -0.042144775, 0.017105103, 0.016921997, -0.014045715, -0.0127334595, -0.026947021, 0.0021839142, 0.007686615, 0.016082764, -0.014930725, -0.056549072, -0.029678345, 0.024459839, 0.0069885254, -0.017028809, -0.0014753342, 0.0491333, 0.008094788, 0.023101807, 0.054534912, 0.027679443, 0.04901123, 0.050354004, -0.0055618286, 0.047821045, 0.0071258545, 0.020568848, -0.03366089, 0.00617218, 0.0071640015, 0.022964478, -0.0017461777, 0.016235352, -0.072143555, 0.016998291, -0.011566162, 0.01348114, -0.0024356842, 0.00573349, 0.04055786, 0.0048828125, -0.020767212, -0.024093628, 0.016052246, -0.03363037, -0.009460449, 0.03479004, -0.038208008, -0.07714844, -0.0149383545, -0.023406982, 0.008674622, -0.0041007996, 0.029953003, -0.024002075, 0.012748718, -0.007217407, 0.01247406, -0.0035705566, 0.055419922, 0.035705566, 0.011604309, -0.0013999939, 0.007083893, -0.0096206665, 0.053894043, 0.074645996, -0.030792236, 0.04547119, -0.07043457, 0.0028476715, -0.015670776, -0.00078201294, -0.0059165955, 0.04034424, 0.018371582, 0.014137268, -0.020767212, 0.008743286, -0.049072266, -0.014953613, 0.025009155, -0.03479004, -0.0256958, -0.05343628, -0.00043654442, -0.030685425, -0.043060303, -0.006450653, 0.08880615, -0.015792847, -0.012290955, 0.00116539, -0.007217407, -0.027297974, 0.0005517006, -0.037353516, -0.012168884, 0.013763428, 0.027420044, 0.018936157, -0.053985596, 0.008087158, 0.0053138733, 0.0069999695, -0.0019283295, -0.044036865, -0.017471313, 0.044189453, 0.035003662, 0.012199402, 0.028930664, -0.045684814, -0.0008125305, -0.06109619, -0.0096206665, 0.018432617, -0.045684814, -0.021240234, 0.0390625, -0.033111572, -0.034484863, 0.0016622543, 0.05117798, -0.041778564, -0.015571594, 0.020187378, 0.0010910034, -0.018707275, 0.03201294, 0.013404846, 0.017791748, -0.016555786, -0.005847931, -0.056518555, -0.005695343, -0.01083374, -0.023101807, 0.03488159, -0.020843506, -0.02017212, -0.0690918, -0.023422241, -0.011154175, 0.01637268, -0.007156372, -0.025238037, -0.01184082, -0.020553589, 0.020980835, 0.007835388, 0.015563965, -0.010681152, 0.047851562, -0.0060539246, -0.036895752, -0.029724121, 0.040252686, 0.013587952, -0.004875183, -0.027145386, -0.023757935, -0.001121521, 0.018371582, 0.014663696, -0.008979797, -0.013618469, -0.083984375, -0.014122009, 0.032440186, -0.011856079, -0.055664062, 0.04824829, -0.05456543, -0.0031433105, 0.03390503, -0.02368164, 0.019561768, 0.07434082, -0.014564514, 0.009208679, 0.01461792, -0.008506775, 0.004386902, -0.0096206665, -0.08380127, 0.03933716, -0.023651123, -0.036987305, -0.014442444, -0.006210327, -0.058044434, -0.018218994, -0.019073486, 0.06414795, 0.022033691, 0.013519287, 0.051239014, -0.010910034, 0.0063591003, -0.021194458, 0.01108551, 0.009048462, -0.04736328, 0.0048980713, -0.0048103333, 0.033721924, 0.0473938, -0.03555298, 0.009498596, 0.011680603, 0.016204834, 0.030258179, 0.01399231, -0.04019165, 0.0034599304, 0.014381409, -0.002904892, 0.004070282, -0.01725769, -0.009712219, -0.014694214, 0.0039253235, -0.026397705, 0.03265381, 0.019699097, 0.021697998, -0.03829956, -0.007663727, 0.02684021, -0.0124435425, -0.036865234, 0.021514893, 0.040405273, 0.010513306, 0.0062332153, 0.010246277, -0.010131836, 0.01737976, 0.004322052, -0.016021729, 0.01838684, -0.0054893494, 0.01739502, 0.03010559, -0.03842163, -0.003686905, -0.04699707, 0.004135132, 0.010848999, -0.005168915, -0.04156494, -0.01751709, 0.025039673, 0.0013837814, -0.078125, -0.007068634, 0.006095886, -0.026733398, -0.028945923, -0.060577393, 0.032226562, -0.019439697, -0.026535034, 0.0009536743, -0.016662598, -0.011932373, 0.019592285, -0.06555176, -0.015899658, 0.06341553, -0.009681702, -0.0026760101, 0.0016736984, -0.0030498505, 0.010848999, -0.030883789, 0.0178833, -0.018814087, 0.025390625, -0.022750854, -0.011749268, 0.060455322, -0.041412354, 0.022247314, 0.012786865, 0.012176514, -0.011024475, -0.002046585, 0.0014333725, 0.011634827, -0.07659912, 0.06561279, 0.04788208, -0.013633728, -0.1027832, 0.024963379, -0.0046958923, -0.02671814, 0.0071525574, -0.014045715, 0.02998352, 0.040863037, 0.00014722347, 0.04724121, 0.0046653748, -0.0065994263, 0.0013122559, -0.02583313, 0.009628296, 0.03842163, 0.047576904, -0.017669678, -0.023086548, 0.00969696, -0.032562256, 0.06976318, -0.025375366, -0.0038776398, 0.025939941, 0.018630981, -0.042114258, -0.026397705, -0.024337769, -0.045654297, -0.030929565, 0.019622803, -0.025344849, -0.005264282, 0.031036377, 0.0039596558, -0.05050659, 0.02079773, 0.045318604, -0.012969971, 0.015930176, -0.0491333, -0.025726318, 0.021347046, -0.08660889, -0.015777588, -0.05090332, -0.023910522, 0.020812988, 0.0023002625, 0.0059814453, 0.02331543, 0.028030396, 0.042053223, 0.0073165894, -0.0054397583, -0.01272583, 0.047851562, -0.021835327, -0.03149414, 0.03112793, 0.0045318604, 0.008285522, -0.015281677, 0.05215454, -0.04244995, -0.02166748, -0.04815674, 0.018341064, 0.009651184, 0.03277588, 0.008277893, 0.009529114, 0.020339966, 0.03793335, 0.025634766, 0.011802673, -0.038482666, -0.045166016, 0.008796692, 0.07489014, -0.045928955, 0.021453857, 0.016921997, 0.009963989, 0.049194336, -0.037475586, 0.02619934, -0.0112838745, -0.03173828, -0.056518555, 0.05834961, -0.0056915283, -0.035125732, 0.018676758, 0.0036830902, 0.028808594, -0.027908325, 0.053222656, -0.012237549, -0.005142212, 0.008529663, -0.007774353, 0.01637268, -0.030273438, 0.019241333, -0.06817627, -0.03704834, -0.020248413, 0.038604736, -0.042266846, -0.01374054, 0.022476196, -0.01386261, 0.046722412, 0.04284668, 0.06011963, -0.032409668, -0.023834229, -0.002023697, 0.002494812, -0.008026123, -0.02796936, 0.0039596558, -0.0019931793, 0.017974854, -0.052947998, -0.001625061, -0.023880005, -0.008148193, -0.0040740967, 0.008728027, 0.012001038, -0.06707764, -0.01184082, 0.027053833, 0.029251099, -0.012557983, 0.010093689, 0.013832092, 0.010932922, 0.046661377, 0.016296387, 0.020767212, 0.038024902, -0.04623413, 0.019302368, 0.00957489, 0.03164673, -0.03704834, 0.010826111, -0.012992859, -0.013397217, -0.048461914, 0.028686523, 0.03994751, -0.032592773, 0.007881165, -0.039642334, 0.022064209, 0.02720642, -0.011932373, 0.003791809, -0.047821045, -0.026657104, 0.01977539, -0.040924072, 0.0006494522, 0.028152466, -0.0027713776, -0.017623901, -0.07550049, -0.002483368, -0.01701355, 0.021820068, -0.01525116, 0.027557373, -0.04147339, 0.01638794, 0.029968262, -0.03567505, 0.010772705, 0.0011148453, 0.019638062, 0.027618408, 0.012672424, -0.0541687, -0.0059661865, -0.04888916, -0.036315918, -0.040100098, -0.017288208, 0.0070991516, 0.047576904, 0.006603241, 0.0062789917, 0.017852783, 0.0034770966, 0.0357666, 0.02281189, -0.020446777, 0.05505371, 0.007423401, 0.0072135925, 0.0006790161, 0.03805542, 0.009651184, -0.011993408, 0.0048713684, -0.027999878, 0.006187439, 0.0028305054, -0.0009946823, 0.009048462, -0.019546509, 0.0039711, 0.029312134, 0.010643005, 0.0000833869, 0.010635376, 0.02822876, 0.008598328, 0.0066566467, -0.005744934, 0.058776855, -0.026275635, -0.0047569275, -0.031951904, 0.013832092, -0.04385376, 0.041900635, -0.027511597, -0.015617371, -0.038360596, -0.044189453, -0.028503418, 0.0051841736, 0.033691406, 0.023391724, 0.05734253, -0.013542175, 0.015548706, 0.021377563, 0.0009841919, -0.05670166, -0.017486572, 0.016937256, 0.039398193, 0.017211914, 0.047088623, 0.008514404, -0.012535095, 0.023117065, -0.04006958, -0.004070282, -0.022766113, 0.029144287, 0.030029297, -0.04034424, -0.01737976, 0.026748657, 0.060394287, -0.05670166, 0.031585693, -0.01637268, 0.06756592, 0.053741455, -0.0014896393, 0.049072266, -0.0056991577, -0.011772156, 0.016479492, -0.012992859, -0.029647827, -0.017807007, -0.07702637, 0.0048179626, -0.056793213, 0.016052246, -0.042022705, 0.015991211, -0.020339966, 0.037750244, -0.012130737, 0.02557373, 0.024795532, 0.005821228, 0.03704834, -0.037628174, 0.070129395, -0.050109863, -0.008117676, -0.005153656, 0.026824951, 0.021347046, 0.0385437, -0.0158844, 0.03665161, -0.021575928, -0.014480591, 0.02722168, -0.025344849, 0.023498535, -0.02709961, -0.030731201, -0.031677246, 0.0357666, 0.008148193, 0.033355713, 0.037384033, 0.040130615, -0.013221741, -0.002325058, 0.0025291443, -0.0011901855, -0.032562256, 0.009925842, 0.05895996, -0.062286377, 0.024765015, -0.027694702, -0.02545166, 0.005596161, 0.01737976, 0.035858154, -0.0770874, -0.030578613, 0.010467529, 0.02772522, -0.015434265, 0.0010881424, -0.03781128, -0.0063476562, 0.053955078, 0.026031494, -0.029464722, -0.014633179, 0.036834717, 0.007671356, -0.0017728806, -0.025924683, 0.0075416565, 0.033081055, -0.009803772, 0.02520752, -0.0158844, 0.032226562, 0.009880066, -0.032287598, 0.038146973, 0.0013799667, -0.046844482, 0.017242432, 0.02720642, 0.11004639, 0.04248047, 0.053222656, -0.032989502, -0.03100586, 0.062561035, -0.013511658, 0.024856567, 0.022476196, -0.047912598, -0.012145996, -0.017364502, -0.019500732, -0.00077724457, -0.024429321, 0.028503418, -0.026184082, 0.0052757263, -0.024612427, -0.00009512901, 0.04647827, -0.06970215, -0.0068130493, -0.024551392, -0.043762207, -0.009315491, -0.0023612976, -0.0055351257, 0.0039596558, -0.0026073456, 0.009933472, 0.032989502, -0.00982666, 0.0028705597, -0.027191162, -0.03930664, -0.00018966198, -0.04953003, 0.039215088, -0.030838013, -0.0116119385, -0.020523071, 0.0037269592, -0.012588501, -0.023452759, -0.012107849, 0.0029754639, -0.0041923523, -0.018844604, 0.029891968, 0.029403687, -0.020019531, -0.00349617, -0.057403564, 0.021377563, -0.024307251, -0.00025439262, 0.040618896, -0.05734253, -0.020858765, 0.015838623, -0.052124023, 0.054595947, 0.02368164, -0.019836426, 0.0050582886, 0.029281616, -0.024124146, -0.030517578, -0.0034313202, 0.024215698, -0.013832092, -0.021575928, -0.014221191, 0.03717041, 0.022277832, -0.06994629, -0.046447754, -0.006137848, 0.05328369, -0.0036029816, 0.064453125, -0.001156807, 0.00055360794, 0.0007095337, 0.044952393, 0.013618469, -0.03781128, -0.019683838, -0.026855469, 0.0635376, 0.06298828, -0.020217896, -0.008110046, 0.042541504, 0.022323608, 0.015640259, 0.046813965, -0.02142334, 0.0068588257, -0.0022201538, 0.040740967, 0.007511139, -0.061798096, 0.017456055, 0.020584106, 0.0019006729, 0.03567505, -0.032714844, 0.003627777, -0.005340576, 0.015586853, -0.018493652, -0.060272217, 0.036254883, 0.017623901, -0.0021133423, 0.057861328, -0.005039215, -0.033111572, -0.014015198, 0.0014638901, 0.018859863, 0.008888245, 0.011047363, -0.0078048706, 0.03869629, -0.062316895, -0.048950195, 0.010620117, -0.025604248, 0.03363037, -0.052490234, 0.031463623, -0.037841797, -0.028152466, -0.009490967, 0.018341064, -0.007633209, -0.011367798, -0.041809082, -0.021011353, 0.030044556, -0.024169922 ], "summary": [ -0.08654785, -0.044311523, 0.010055542, 0.04559326, -0.085876465, 0.016708374, -0.01739502, -0.04168701, -0.021240234, 0.029312134, -0.052642822, 0.026382446, 0.0006275177, -0.018432617, 0.040863037, -0.036102295, -0.0034828186, -0.013298035, -0.015129089, -0.033233643, 0.007320404, -0.0345459, 0.01499176, 0.020263672, -0.0045166016, 0.011482239, -0.07867432, 0.00014066696, -0.012779236, -0.0015125275, -0.012313843, 0.02482605, 0.029266357, 0.040130615, -0.078552246, -0.006038666, -0.03491211, 0.018981934, -0.015213013, 0.042541504, 0.017929077, 0.01777649, 0.062438965, -0.03778076, 0.014411926, 0.014297485, -0.014091492, -0.036865234, 0.03955078, -0.01737976, -0.0036754608, 0.04421997, -0.016647339, 0.01171875, -0.0076141357, 0.03366089, -0.03314209, -0.05456543, 0.019332886, 0.060760498, 0.028427124, -0.017669678, 0.0015287399, -0.042541504, 0.010421753, -0.012893677, 0.060577393, 0.010467529, -0.028930664, -0.009971619, 0.04019165, -0.000936985, 0.025634766, -0.023147583, -0.025283813, -0.011268616, 0.06378174, -0.0051002502, -0.014167786, -0.028335571, -0.01398468, 0.027801514, 0.0042648315, -0.035888672, 0.00010818243, -0.03363037, -0.022323608, 0.008216858, -0.015716553, 0.01386261, -0.022720337, -0.013580322, -0.04144287, 0.03729248, 0.030456543, -0.016937256, -0.04888916, -0.074645996, 0.04711914, 0.03665161, 0.02255249, -0.051696777, 0.052764893, -0.020095825, -0.014595032, 0.042266846, -0.0076522827, -0.068359375, -0.026565552, 0.020111084, -0.0236969, -0.08081055, 0.00047898293, -0.022476196, -0.03503418, 0.042999268, 0.022476196, -0.018341064, -0.0073776245, 0.0034008026, -0.01651001, -0.007896423, -0.035247803, 0.04586792, 0.04269409, 0.003786087, 0.0016412735, 0.040893555, 0.009231567, -0.005844116, -0.010864258, 0.034942627, -0.033294678, -0.03643799, -0.05480957, 0.00032258034, 0.035980225, 0.0088272095, 0.0491333, -0.017440796, 0.07305908, -0.01638794, -0.06726074, 0.09106445, -0.028121948, 0.035217285, 0.032226562, -0.0032615662, -0.036376953, -0.038238525, -0.03363037, 0.032348633, 0.014831543, 0.0010375977, -0.0044136047, -0.027664185, -0.0082473755, -0.042999268, 0.025009155, -0.03274536, 0.037109375, 0.040008545, 0.034606934, 0.07678223, 0.049804688, -0.03543091, -0.019348145, -0.005947113, 0.015068054, -0.02243042, -0.00340271, -0.039276123, 0.0074691772, 0.010055542, 0.021865845, 0.02658081, 0.015083313, 0.0473938, -0.019882202, -0.041015625, -0.002002716, -0.042541504, 0.026443481, 0.009773254, -0.026306152, 0.038757324, -0.020217896, 0.032836914, 0.022033691, -0.0010442734, -0.0056381226, 0.009178162, -0.045410156, 0.047546387, -0.018585205, -0.0012359619, -0.03491211, 0.022079468, -0.04534912, -0.004272461, 0.03656006, -0.012527466, 0.004825592, -0.023025513, -0.066589355, -0.01777649, -0.021911621, 0.010169983, 0.031204224, 0.0029506683, -0.021575928, -0.053497314, 0.019577026, -0.002073288, -0.027191162, -0.00019705296, 0.014129639, -0.016616821, -0.025817871, -0.013435364, -0.04083252, -0.004814148, -0.056121826, 0.061920166, 0.0020618439, 0.023635864, -0.019851685, 0.010658264, 0.05960083, 0.033081055, 0.07757568, -0.05355835, -0.016952515, 0.022064209, -0.010971069, 0.0013418198, 0.004875183, -0.018173218, 0.02583313, 0.038238525, 0.0015678406, -0.02734375, -0.052093506, 0.024551392, -0.010414124, -0.047790527, -0.0115356445, 0.053222656, -0.0134887695, 0.002544403, 0.025665283, 0.00072956085, 0.038604736, -0.023147583, 0.007335663, 0.0034885406, -0.011924744, -0.014755249, 0.033813477, -0.017440796, 0.022109985, -0.012268066, -0.012054443, 0.00034928322, -0.011360168, 0.006160736, 0.011390686, 0.01360321, -0.022506714, 0.0063323975, 0.0413208, -0.006652832, 0.0018234253, -0.023803711, -0.05505371, -0.014312744, -0.009567261, 0.035858154, -0.012756348, -0.0440979, -0.018310547, -0.029678345, -0.044433594, -0.006690979, 0.033081055, 0.0126953125, 0.0072288513, 0.023117065, 0.003786087, 0.042236328, 0.07122803, 0.017333984, 0.0070114136, -0.022369385, -0.0055618286, -0.025619507, -0.019683838, 0.072631836, -0.013580322, -0.004764557, -0.07104492, 0.0041542053, -0.02909851, 0.0019521713, 0.0064048767, 0.016189575, 0.009292603, 0.033416748, 0.014282227, -0.01939392, -0.008331299, -0.022445679, 0.016281128, -0.019348145, -0.005882263, -0.033416748, -0.01927185, 0.00504303, -0.019363403, 0.040649414, 0.13134766, -0.001964569, 0.00058221817, 0.012664795, -0.018035889, -0.061431885, 0.04244995, -0.038146973, -0.00017666817, 0.029891968, -0.046417236, -0.0063323975, -0.03857422, 0.035247803, 0.0042686462, 0.020126343, 0.029907227, -0.07470703, 0.01979065, 0.03289795, 0.082336426, 0.029968262, -0.024658203, -0.0031909943, -0.034698486, -0.010070801, 0.01322937, -0.0032482147, -0.048461914, 0.0036468506, 0.019256592, -0.027526855, -0.016113281, 0.02722168, 0.008354187, -0.026046753, 0.020507812, 0.021896362, -0.033111572, -0.03564453, 0.024780273, 0.021942139, 0.0012664795, -0.04675293, -0.0009274483, -0.035980225, -0.007865906, -0.013000488, -0.002412796, 0.028442383, -0.018951416, -0.024810791, -0.028411865, 0.0072021484, 0.017715454, 0.03842163, 0.047668457, -0.0048065186, 0.018539429, 0.033691406, 0.026657104, -0.007217407, 0.024032593, -0.052947998, 0.080078125, -0.029647827, -0.0066986084, 0.0007891655, 0.064819336, 0.024536133, -0.015533447, -0.07562256, 0.009849548, -0.020309448, -0.02885437, -0.0024757385, -0.007598877, -0.010467529, -0.015853882, -0.0036258698, 0.020812988, 0.010803223, 0.0019216537, 0.0017538071, -0.011833191, 0.032348633, 0.031585693, -0.014335632, 0.0017280579, 0.035461426, 0.010009766, -0.0035190582, 0.013000488, -0.005832672, 0.0016946793, 0.0023651123, -0.0057907104, 0.014533997, 0.02305603, -0.038482666, -0.03488159, 0.050598145, -0.026733398, 0.0030136108, -0.014717102, 0.050323486, -0.006011963, 0.010482788, 0.01965332, 0.023117065, 0.010620117, -0.006603241, 0.023773193, 0.03326416, -0.059661865, 0.023071289, -0.002210617, -0.0013589859, 0.057769775, -0.07550049, 0.006996155, 0.0065307617, 0.05407715, 0.034423828, 0.044036865, -0.024414062, 0.012176514, 0.014564514, 0.015686035, -0.010673523, 0.005809784, -0.00749588, 0.02760315, 0.017593384, -0.009292603, 0.04360962, -0.005214691, 0.038360596, 0.053131104, -0.02859497, 0.0064888, -0.004737854, -0.050872803, 0.026062012, 0.055267334, 0.015617371, -0.035339355, 0.02885437, 0.012329102, -0.006717682, 0.061157227, -0.03149414, 0.008071899, -0.015991211, -0.00027227402, -0.0067443848, 0.022003174, 0.00003683567, -0.010276794, -0.037078857, -0.029388428, 0.017822266, -0.05419922, -0.017730713, -0.008964539, 0.005695343, -0.025299072, -0.021865845, -0.018417358, 0.011245728, 0.026687622, -0.0037155151, 0.022583008, 0.017730713, -0.0013799667, -0.03338623, -0.015350342, 0.051696777, 0.038146973, -0.047943115, 0.0113220215, 0.0036678314, 0.024963379, 0.006008148, -0.064208984, 0.041107178, 0.05984497, -0.006996155, 0.011795044, -0.047973633, 0.0052490234, -0.06414795, 0.02784729, 0.01625061, -0.010635376, 0.015510559, 0.004673004, 0.0053215027, -0.01828003, 0.009384155, 0.054718018, 0.05859375, -0.041412354, 0.0025482178, 0.04812622, -0.026748657, -0.04446411, 0.01537323, -0.028121948, -0.06390381, 0.02734375, 0.03765869, -0.011001587, 0.026885986, 0.0015258789, 0.016281128, -0.014785767, -0.017059326, -0.007549286, 0.0022773743, -0.0051460266, 0.007698059, 0.028366089, 0.017120361, -0.0007300377, 0.022766113, 0.006839752, 0.08734131, -0.01940918, 0.050933838, -0.0021800995, -0.018249512, -0.00995636, -0.026428223, -0.007865906, 0.030029297, -0.010551453, -0.003753662, -0.021118164, 0.009895325, 0.019058228, 0.016983032, -0.022125244, 0.004962921, -0.00073337555, 0.015701294, -0.01826477, -0.07556152, -0.046417236, 0.023422241, -0.03717041, -0.005706787, -0.043701172, -0.040100098, -0.022033691, -0.013191223, -0.010475159, 0.024383545, -0.013725281, -0.0005674362, 0.00008690357, 0.014259338, 0.0006661415, 0.018356323, 0.0019817352, -0.010650635, -0.01512146, 0.015991211, 0.004634857, 0.0026760101, 0.04058838, -0.04425049, -0.0065727234, -0.058410645, -0.000044882298, 0.019882202, 0.0035381317, 0.0047454834, -0.020004272, -0.00022625923, 0.04248047, 0.027359009, 0.012969971, -0.01838684, -0.043304443, -0.0045166016, 0.07476807, -0.054504395, 0.019256592, 0.0045776367, -0.0015850067, -0.009429932, -0.010391235, 0.03353882, -0.009063721, -0.029022217, -0.046905518, 0.057739258, 0.05923462, -0.041503906, 0.03604126, 0.01701355, -0.033966064, 0.050994873, 0.0005745888, 0.036712646, -0.018844604, 0.037017822, -0.011894226, -0.0018100739, 0.01663208, -0.011352539, -0.056427002, -0.07244873, -0.054992676, 0.083618164, -0.017364502, -0.04385376, -0.035339355, -0.029693604, 0.036743164, 0.004383087, 0.010047913, -0.03781128, -0.026260376, 0.007827759, -0.0054016113, -0.0058288574, -0.009391785, -0.023071289, 0.041503906, 0.03515625, 0.00724411, -0.017547607, 0.019363403, 0.0037727356, -0.0011463165, 0.0025730133, -0.016067505, -0.03466797, -0.05682373, -0.032928467, -0.01348114, -0.040496826, 0.019378662, -0.024551392, -0.03378296, 0.022598267, -0.035705566, 0.0056152344, -0.012580872, -0.057495117, 0.009048462, -0.007701874, 0.023254395, -0.024978638, 0.0026073456, -0.0044174194, -0.025619507, -0.021392822, -0.009269714, -0.009124756, 0.0043525696, 0.0368042, -0.028808594, 0.008766174, -0.014129639, -0.0023231506, -0.0035362244, 0.012069702, -0.010475159, 0.010574341, -0.0098724365, 0.016708374, -0.0026359558, -0.013420105, 0.0040359497, -0.013504028, -0.0023899078, -0.031341553, -0.0039100647, 0.01133728, 0.014411926, -0.005332947, 0.015914917, 0.0074386597, -0.011024475, -0.005264282, 0.01222229, -0.0017299652, -0.0059165955, 0.042633057, -0.03857422, -0.00868988, -0.06378174, -0.042297363, -0.061035156, -0.043914795, -0.0030670166, 0.082214355, 0.006591797, 0.004173279, 0.009864807, -0.007751465, 0.009376526, 0.0109939575, -0.024612427, 0.031021118, -0.017608643, -0.032714844, 0.015266418, 0.033813477, -0.005783081, -0.012626648, 0.012458801, -0.030883789, 0.009025574, 0.018936157, 0.008331299, 0.002286911, -0.019989014, -0.00075626373, 0.039245605, 0.0057868958, -0.0113220215, 0.004436493, -0.006866455, 0.007320404, 0.019378662, -0.029586792, 0.047332764, 0.038391113, 0.0052948, -0.008277893, 0.04269409, -0.036071777, -0.03451538, -0.025665283, 0.0012779236, -0.005012512, -0.049194336, 0.0035076141, -0.0023937225, 0.015151978, 0.047424316, 0.06964111, -0.0019245148, 0.0063552856, 0.03756714, 0.0036334991, -0.02305603, -0.027389526, 0.011276245, 0.051727295, 0.024291992, 0.046081543, 0.0050621033, 0.007160187, -0.006137848, -0.031021118, 0.0025310516, 0.0006685257, 0.036987305, 0.029724121, -0.030349731, 0.016983032, 0.04232788, 0.039764404, -0.015625, 0.038146973, 0.022232056, 0.024230957, 0.026229858, -0.029281616, 0.027557373, -0.0050849915, -0.033843994, -0.013031006, -0.009216309, -0.021865845, 0.018859863, -0.026763916, -0.06124878, -0.058166504, -0.037322998, -0.0061912537, 0.026245117, -0.047607422, -0.01449585, 0.021255493, 0.017333984, 0.051239014, 0.007297516, -0.01852417, -0.08874512, 0.0073928833, -0.0362854, -0.0055389404, -0.013122559, 0.0134887695, 0.009292603, 0.038238525, -0.010574341, 0.044036865, -0.0049819946, -0.0061912537, 0.025039673, -0.049835205, 0.015716553, -0.050079346, -0.012527466, -0.032104492, 0.05105591, 0.044189453, 0.056488037, -0.0035095215, 0.026229858, 0.008262634, 0.006778717, 0.0070991516, 0.031921387, -0.05908203, 0.056884766, 0.030059814, 0.00082731247, -0.014053345, -0.028289795, -0.024978638, 0.06036377, -0.0128479, 0.06149292, -0.09552002, -0.029159546, 0.009529114, 0.0011091232, -0.06958008, 0.015106201, -0.029678345, -0.022064209, 0.024734497, 0.01838684, -0.031143188, -0.017944336, 0.019180298, -0.0004544258, -0.0051879883, 0.0059051514, 0.012207031, 0.050994873, 0.0050697327, 0.02406311, -0.046081543, 0.033233643, 0.017593384, -0.017333984, 0.036315918, 0.014442444, -0.0074157715, 0.022201538, 0.0058288574, 0.10211182, 0.06903076, 0.019714355, -0.080444336, -0.011802673, 0.119140625, -0.005428314, 0.013206482, -0.0009851456, -0.028213501, -0.04208374, 0.014862061, 0.012229919, 0.0027580261, 0.011985779, 0.030975342, -0.008010864, -0.027420044, -0.06982422, 0.021102905, -0.015106201, -0.074279785, 0.035583496, -0.099121094, -0.048339844, 0.0035820007, 0.045013428, 0.004878998, 0.030715942, -0.029754639, -0.02482605, 0.019180298, -0.026443481, 0.028320312, 0.0013723373, -0.0056533813, -0.02949524, -0.022964478, 0.020446777, 0.0008921623, -0.04006958, -0.025787354, 0.035736084, 0.034576416, -0.021316528, -0.01486969, 0.051940918, 0.022872925, -0.054534912, 0.04156494, 0.044067383, -0.0053977966, -0.007419586, -0.006061554, 0.0051612854, -0.0033950806, 0.04837036, 0.020843506, 0.0012989044, -0.046203613, 0.013679504, -0.028396606, 0.0031280518, -0.043914795, -0.0018119812, 0.019882202, 0.03945923, -0.017044067, -0.054138184, -0.029220581, -0.02394104, 0.0036010742, -0.012786865, -0.023803711, -0.0001680851, 0.015838623, -0.033294678, -0.043151855, 0.01235199, 0.051361084, 0.01272583, -0.0051460266, -0.015106201, 0.018234253, 0.014511108, 0.03567505, 0.0078086853, -0.048950195, -0.015930176, 0.005756378, 0.07836914, 0.01838684, -0.022705078, -0.016540527, 0.033233643, 0.0017490387, -0.03100586, -0.012359619, 0.00034046173, -0.059570312, 0.009056091, -0.0155181885, -0.0135650635, -0.019378662, 0.039520264, 0.029785156, -0.010986328, 0.0072135925, 0.0036888123, -0.014732361, 0.006904602, 0.005443573, 0.022872925, -0.0020866394, 0.027328491, 0.028259277, 0.02053833, -0.018035889, 0.0035991669, -0.022125244, 0.0044822693, 0.023254395, 0.022903442, 0.05328369, 0.0057868958, -0.03829956, 0.03604126, -0.10131836, -0.045074463, -0.061676025, -0.036621094, -0.025680542, -0.05432129, 0.05026245, 0.019180298, -0.017669678, 0.00027632713, -0.014480591, -0.0036029816, 0.009796143, 0.017990112, -0.021896362, -0.023452759, 0.009483337 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2012.15081v14
Fairness-Oriented User Scheduling for Bursty Downlink Transmission Using Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning
Mingqi Yuan, Qi Cao, Man-on Pun, Yi Chen
cs.OS, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NI
In this work, we develop practical user scheduling algorithms for downlink bursty traffic with emphasis on user fairness. In contrast to the conventional scheduling algorithms that either equally divides the transmission time slots among users or maximizing some ratios without physcial meanings, we propose to use the 5%-tile user data rate (5TUDR) as the metric to evaluate user fairness. Since it is difficult to directly optimize 5TUDR, we first cast the problem into the stochastic game framework and subsequently propose a Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL)-based algorithm to perform distributed optimization on the resource block group (RBG) allocation. Furthermore, each MARL agent is designed to take information measured by network counters from multiple network layers (e.g. Channel Quality Indicator, Buffer size) as the input states while the RBG allocation as action with a proposed reward function designed to maximize 5TUDR. Extensive simulation is performed to show that the proposed MARL-based scheduler can achieve fair scheduling while maintaining good average network throughput as compared to conventional schedulers.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2012.15081v14
"2022-06-19T04:45:35"
"2020-12-30T08:41:51"
{ "title": [ 0.000729084, 0.031402588, -0.039031982, -0.00086688995, 0.041290283, -0.024383545, 0.03189087, -0.024307251, -0.009819031, 0.043762207, -0.013412476, 0.031585693, -0.0016098022, -0.028015137, -0.017364502, 0.00033664703, -0.020828247, 0.03717041, -0.01763916, -0.033843994, 0.011947632, -0.028030396, -0.06161499, 0.09448242, 0.012245178, 0.006832123, -0.12658691, 0.026779175, -0.015220642, -0.032836914, -0.018585205, 0.02456665, 0.03475952, -0.0049934387, -0.031188965, -0.026641846, -0.04486084, 0.017227173, -0.0067214966, -0.012649536, 0.028045654, 0.0048561096, -0.04574585, -0.00020098686, -0.019699097, -0.022720337, -0.01776123, -0.028381348, -0.014167786, 0.05908203, 0.035583496, 0.033233643, 0.019485474, 0.07122803, 0.03778076, -0.008110046, -0.030212402, -0.010406494, 0.05630493, 0.008659363, -0.0071907043, -0.059295654, 0.036865234, -0.035491943, -0.004863739, -0.022781372, 0.04574585, 0.027328491, 0.06109619, 0.009506226, -0.013259888, 0.032592773, 0.01612854, 0.011932373, -0.04916382, -0.03353882, 0.041992188, -0.020111084, 0.022857666, -0.024673462, 0.015617371, 0.011405945, -0.0072784424, -0.01574707, 0.034210205, -0.01209259, 0.005657196, -0.018798828, -0.04660034, 0.003189087, -0.027114868, 0.0597229, -0.014305115, 0.0027332306, -0.0063209534, -0.00472641, -0.018203735, 0.027191162, -0.01033783, -0.035461426, -0.053710938, 0.02130127, -0.093444824, -0.009483337, 0.0021381378, -0.031021118, 0.006843567, -0.007926941, 0.0154418945, 0.030258179, -0.049743652, 0.016525269, 0.04660034, 0.07409668, -0.040893555, -0.07104492, -0.0071907043, 0.005012512, -0.0154418945, 0.006111145, -0.011169434, -0.006626129, -0.016494751, -0.006790161, 0.051635742, 0.010131836, -0.01285553, 0.019058228, -0.035003662, 0.07318115, -0.0008831024, 0.0143966675, -0.055419922, -0.056640625, -0.061431885, -0.0093688965, -0.035125732, -0.040771484, -0.00724411, -0.0029525757, 0.01033783, -0.032440186, 0.004386902, 0.010047913, 0.04611206, 0.010543823, 0.045135498, -0.010070801, -0.014198303, -0.0042800903, -0.012512207, 0.06762695, 0.013687134, 0.0058631897, 0.027374268, -0.016296387, -0.048217773, -0.0209198, 0.049560547, -0.008522034, 0.020874023, 0.024719238, 0.034179688, 0.09765625, 0.07867432, -0.03390503, 0.022216797, 0.025146484, 0.006175995, 0.026748657, 0.014846802, 0.006011963, 0.008491516, -0.02746582, 0.0017671585, -0.009399414, 0.047302246, 0.020217896, 0.010467529, -0.051483154, -0.019210815, -0.028778076, 0.03829956, -0.007965088, -0.0289917, -0.042510986, -0.018814087, -0.022903442, 0.0519104, 0.0013504028, -0.009544373, -0.0033416748, -0.06463623, 0.0049858093, -0.011634827, 0.00024020672, -0.009513855, 0.0062408447, 0.0014104843, 0.006374359, -0.023391724, 0.023651123, -0.030654907, 0.010292053, -0.037750244, -0.028686523, -0.002439499, 0.029663086, 0.01499176, 0.033996582, 0.021347046, -0.006011963, -0.024017334, -0.032165527, -0.006374359, 0.0079956055, 0.008865356, -0.0031833649, 0.012184143, -0.014801025, 0.0003209114, 0.033843994, -0.008018494, 0.01108551, -0.01020813, -0.017349243, 0.020812988, -0.004722595, 0.025619507, 0.015045166, 0.067871094, -0.05291748, 0.022750854, 0.072265625, 0.0027446747, -0.015930176, -0.012039185, -0.0025959015, 0.04067993, -0.0014467239, -0.0062561035, -0.043182373, -0.0032253265, 0.06555176, 0.019821167, -0.018508911, 0.0009860992, 0.05407715, 0.0009098053, -0.0022468567, 0.035308838, 0.007926941, 0.031463623, -0.029891968, 0.007347107, 0.037841797, -0.00017440319, 0.010910034, -0.014823914, 0.0062408447, 0.015899658, 0.005077362, 0.012199402, -0.0022125244, -0.01184845, -0.003704071, -0.008880615, -0.0075187683, -0.022781372, 0.019485474, 0.02696228, -0.03741455, -0.0063171387, 0.0005173683, 0.012329102, -0.0053634644, -0.013130188, 0.013175964, -0.02218628, -0.037963867, -0.0023345947, 0.014060974, -0.0033302307, -0.024780273, 0.011123657, 0.020019531, 0.006134033, 0.01828003, 0.02822876, 0.003036499, 0.050872803, 0.022399902, -0.00014138222, 0.011878967, 0.0068588257, -0.011566162, -0.02960205, 0.09112549, -0.033843994, 0.031829834, -0.10626221, -0.0052108765, 0.020767212, -0.021377563, 0.014602661, 0.029266357, 0.025100708, 0.030914307, 0.020324707, 0.029968262, -0.040161133, 0.024765015, 0.006958008, -0.039276123, -0.04043579, -0.039031982, -0.030410767, -0.03213501, 0.0013875961, 0.030944824, 0.099121094, 0.011482239, 0.0040664673, -0.008041382, 0.0073928833, -0.047576904, -0.010879517, -0.026428223, -0.05908203, 0.035369873, 0.04953003, 0.044006348, -0.0143585205, 0.07543945, 0.015731812, 0.042022705, 0.0124053955, -0.00504303, -0.021606445, -0.03466797, -0.015731812, -0.01285553, -0.002664566, -0.013847351, -0.0056037903, -0.02961731, -0.018081665, -0.00021016598, 0.034729004, 0.027130127, -0.02368164, 0.01939392, -0.0546875, -0.010215759, 0.0395813, -0.009147644, 0.025650024, 0.052856445, 0.029052734, 0.014266968, 0.0473938, 0.025817871, 0.013420105, -0.078063965, -0.0058784485, -0.05441284, -0.016540527, -0.024520874, -0.027877808, 0.012184143, -0.042388916, -0.02532959, -0.0127334595, -0.022583008, 0.009384155, 0.03933716, 0.00015878677, -0.0061836243, -0.006378174, -0.016479492, -0.0052108765, 0.0009508133, -0.017425537, -0.0044555664, 0.04574585, -0.016357422, -0.059661865, -0.018722534, 0.0047683716, 0.020233154, -0.022735596, -0.031433105, 0.031707764, -0.01574707, 0.0028591156, 0.003921509, -0.019866943, 0.007911682, -0.061584473, -0.002714157, 0.01838684, 0.0071258545, -0.027435303, 0.029403687, -0.03164673, -0.013000488, 0.021194458, -0.029403687, 0.03152466, -0.020553589, 0.007820129, -0.0044670105, 0.0013475418, -0.02468872, 0.0009264946, -0.054138184, -0.019607544, 0.02468872, -0.015640259, -0.03781128, 0.01676941, -0.023422241, -0.003868103, -0.009864807, 0.02041626, 0.0062217712, 0.053619385, -0.039611816, 0.061584473, 0.017120361, 0.006580353, -0.017166138, -0.019699097, -0.021652222, -0.010055542, 0.025497437, 0.010917664, 0.017852783, 0.018310547, -0.0012931824, -0.040740967, -0.02027893, 0.02168274, 0.0149383545, 0.026748657, -0.045013428, -0.022659302, -0.02243042, 0.012001038, -0.041168213, -0.0058059692, -0.007232666, -0.018585205, 0.0022640228, -0.022766113, 0.064697266, 0.008262634, 0.021438599, -0.0059432983, 0.03286743, 0.039001465, -0.010810852, -0.0050468445, 0.015777588, 0.059509277, 0.004825592, -0.009742737, 0.0039367676, -0.019561768, 0.010375977, 0.043395996, -0.039520264, 0.0034713745, -0.016235352, 0.0005354881, -0.005973816, 0.0049819946, 0.013832092, -0.019729614, -0.03955078, 0.0078125, 0.025177002, -0.05126953, -0.05307007, -0.009925842, 0.004169464, -0.09918213, -0.03137207, 0.03479004, -0.002456665, 0.022384644, -0.030670166, 0.04244995, 0.02330017, -0.0007414818, 0.0061912537, 0.00045108795, -0.022644043, 0.025466919, -0.061035156, -0.03564453, 0.05795288, 0.00907135, -0.037231445, 0.029434204, 0.01979065, 0.032562256, -0.019592285, 0.0158844, 0.005001068, 0.07348633, -0.029159546, -0.004573822, 0.020248413, -0.013710022, -0.057006836, 0.049682617, 0.018753052, -0.047088623, 0.0062217712, 0.07080078, 0.070129395, -0.047607422, 0.0362854, 0.030639648, -0.043121338, -0.062927246, -0.037841797, 0.010643005, -0.047912598, -0.0056762695, -0.0005917549, 0.021728516, 0.045043945, 0.003227234, 0.034301758, -0.017547607, -0.014945984, 0.006385803, 0.009460449, -0.01763916, -0.005634308, 0.016693115, 0.016464233, -0.0038013458, 0.024749756, -0.01663208, 0.078308105, -0.056030273, 0.010955811, -0.0020103455, 0.016525269, 0.0084991455, 0.0044937134, -0.06439209, 0.023101807, -0.03265381, -0.0023174286, -0.036895752, 0.05657959, 0.027297974, -0.024307251, -0.05545044, 0.041931152, -0.014183044, -0.0017986298, -0.0034332275, -0.057678223, 0.027511597, 0.011367798, -0.056518555, -0.02178955, -0.06329346, -0.019317627, 0.0046958923, -0.0107803345, -0.0004878044, 0.05239868, 0.011604309, 0.014045715, 0.05810547, -0.041900635, -0.048950195, 0.05230713, -0.018920898, -0.032318115, -0.0009851456, -0.034423828, -0.013114929, -0.023513794, 0.05630493, -0.022964478, -0.007774353, -0.053955078, 0.03829956, -0.033569336, 0.0357666, 0.013702393, 0.035369873, 0.03427124, 0.035095215, 0.014915466, 0.02116394, -0.033935547, 0.015068054, 0.0050201416, 0.057678223, -0.0335083, 0.0019359589, 0.016174316, 0.045532227, 0.022872925, -0.01071167, 0.0041046143, 0.01360321, -0.011985779, -0.045318604, 0.053741455, 0.00472641, -0.017288208, 0.04083252, 0.028778076, 0.039001465, 0.017364502, 0.048736572, -0.004886627, 0.017227173, 0.053741455, 0.012374878, 0.03567505, 0.012023926, 0.009849548, -0.05871582, -0.03387451, -0.013175964, 0.021057129, -0.04714966, -0.017074585, -0.037902832, -0.029785156, 0.030731201, 0.008712769, 0.017700195, 0.010192871, -0.06530762, -0.011436462, 0.010818481, -0.018600464, -0.039154053, -0.035095215, 0.008003235, 0.039764404, -0.01348114, 0.043884277, -0.049865723, 0.03604126, 0.014427185, -0.017532349, -0.021209717, -0.047424316, 0.03189087, 0.0155181885, 0.008125305, -0.014381409, -0.0055503845, 0.016113281, -0.019210815, 0.05493164, -0.01739502, 0.042510986, 0.04345703, -0.05618286, 0.039367676, -0.02645874, 0.02458191, -0.011375427, 0.002023697, -0.0056610107, 0.024597168, -0.044921875, 0.024734497, 0.017623901, -0.03111267, 0.0002373457, -0.024230957, 0.01689148, 0.040802002, 0.029266357, 0.051483154, -0.047912598, -0.013092041, -0.01676941, 0.007762909, -0.047729492, 0.030227661, 0.05291748, -0.023712158, -0.05770874, 0.04156494, -0.041870117, 0.012237549, 0.00031232834, 0.007282257, -0.029220581, 0.016906738, 0.04333496, -0.031173706, -0.010429382, 0.00067281723, 0.022018433, 0.025161743, 0.009262085, -0.03225708, -0.0024261475, -0.023620605, -0.066467285, -0.08581543, 0.025375366, 0.013771057, 0.0012044907, -0.009567261, 0.019088745, -0.007888794, -0.003900528, 0.035491943, 0.004234314, -0.07495117, 0.021438599, 0.0046806335, 0.016784668, 0.02670288, 0.0184021, -0.026367188, 0.027069092, 0.03060913, 0.015579224, 0.012145996, -0.0012407303, -0.018585205, 0.024108887, -0.040985107, 0.022903442, 0.00374794, -0.005657196, -0.021987915, 0.023513794, 0.024154663, -0.023223877, 0.023712158, -0.004459381, 0.046844482, -0.031051636, -0.023254395, -0.022842407, -0.014335632, -0.034942627, 0.04748535, 0.02178955, -0.02078247, -0.031341553, -0.051971436, -0.01889038, 0.008720398, 0.048187256, 0.0059165955, 0.056915283, -0.06842041, -0.0395813, -0.022644043, -0.010803223, -0.025268555, 0.014137268, 0.002161026, -0.007221222, -0.011955261, -0.0061416626, 0.012382507, -0.03930664, 0.004711151, -0.0038528442, 0.024261475, -0.03427124, -0.025894165, 0.0039634705, 0.010955811, -0.013069153, 0.0050315857, -0.030731201, 0.0062446594, -0.0066719055, -0.061187744, 0.029327393, -0.0030555725, 0.010574341, -0.009246826, -0.0016431808, 0.0141067505, 0.0103302, 0.02482605, -0.026687622, 0.030426025, -0.072143555, -0.030334473, -0.079956055, -0.029464722, -0.07940674, 0.009246826, -0.0184021, 0.00422287, -0.011024475, -0.011779785, 0.044952393, 0.02432251, 0.00843811, -0.0748291, 0.017196655, -0.042633057, -0.008300781, -0.06011963, 0.054718018, 0.025634766, 0.016067505, 0.010414124, 0.015335083, 0.008560181, -0.059143066, 0.008979797, 0.021347046, 0.014053345, -0.017807007, -0.045715332, -0.027572632, 0.028213501, -0.004016876, 0.016906738, 0.04385376, 0.0143966675, 0.022521973, -0.024291992, 0.009391785, 0.03173828, -0.04336548, 0.05041504, 0.059295654, -0.07885742, 0.030197144, 0.0017442703, -0.010772705, 0.027038574, 0.016860962, 0.020812988, -0.08312988, -0.056762695, 0.03036499, 0.006702423, -0.0023593903, 0.032440186, -0.019470215, -0.012016296, 0.03250122, 0.033081055, -0.0059776306, 0.012527466, -0.010688782, 0.042297363, -0.017593384, 0.01878357, -0.018371582, 0.0259552, -0.05218506, 0.016571045, -0.05480957, 0.02557373, 0.032226562, -0.02078247, 0.023406982, 0.007896423, -0.010093689, 0.0041122437, -0.014144897, 0.08013916, 0.032440186, 0.03491211, -0.029174805, -0.045806885, 0.065979004, -0.024810791, -0.012504578, 0.013618469, -0.024749756, 0.010177612, -0.021835327, -0.028930664, 0.04119873, -0.013336182, 0.046783447, -0.021621704, -0.013320923, -0.017349243, -0.01737976, 0.031402588, -0.047821045, -0.0000121593475, -0.038604736, -0.013450623, 0.0015888214, 0.015167236, -0.014701843, -0.011505127, -0.007896423, 0.026306152, -0.0044555664, -0.025054932, -0.02420044, 0.023025513, -0.035491943, -0.025131226, -0.070129395, 0.026901245, -0.023239136, -0.014930725, -0.024917603, 0.001159668, 0.031677246, -0.008483887, -0.03253174, 0.01083374, -0.007671356, -0.00541687, -0.0013542175, 0.018157959, 0.0065727234, 0.034820557, 0.048431396, 0.017364502, -0.0023670197, 0.004863739, 0.019485474, 0.00048184395, -0.07421875, -0.016616821, -0.049468994, -0.012481689, -0.016418457, -0.0116119385, -0.036071777, 0.025848389, -0.06854248, -0.029281616, -0.007217407, 0.059265137, -0.014579773, -0.01626587, 0.0112838745, 0.030822754, 0.048980713, -0.014274597, -0.030212402, 0.010574341, 0.012992859, -0.02029419, 0.04663086, -0.010940552, -0.007083893, 0.05593872, 0.028930664, 0.032318115, -0.03479004, -0.04510498, 0.0011463165, 0.07543945, 0.032196045, -0.027053833, -0.030914307, 0.018249512, 0.0005888939, -0.012496948, 0.0073623657, 0.0077400208, -0.033813477, 0.004890442, 0.0024681091, -0.025497437, -0.039093018, -0.0034503937, 0.00340271, -0.014801025, 0.004180908, -0.0037517548, -0.002872467, -0.008560181, 0.024398804, -0.03265381, -0.018173218, 0.030929565, 0.03390503, -0.00349617, 0.004322052, -0.024368286, 0.028747559, 0.014305115, 0.01348114, -0.019180298, 0.009529114, 0.059448242, -0.041931152, -0.0042381287, -0.045532227, -0.07159424, 0.0029239655, -0.041412354, -0.0020751953, -0.034332275, 0.049926758, 0.025253296, 0.00856781, -0.0058670044, 0.0178833, 0.023345947, -0.018753052, -0.044708252, -0.064941406, 0.030914307, -0.028411865 ], "summary": [ 0.012931824, -0.0025482178, -0.024429321, 0.017532349, -0.0053100586, -0.037841797, 0.012878418, -0.025009155, -0.018508911, 0.025222778, -0.009613037, 0.02154541, -0.010040283, -0.03652954, 0.022033691, -0.016738892, 0.004043579, 0.014587402, -0.01537323, -0.035186768, -0.008018494, 0.0022506714, -0.06951904, 0.08660889, 0.024246216, 0.030822754, -0.07678223, 0.011291504, 0.006351471, -0.0026245117, 0.0043678284, 0.01940918, -0.012435913, 0.014953613, 0.009590149, -0.043518066, -0.019989014, 0.028823853, 0.024536133, -0.017196655, 0.023620605, 0.013801575, 0.0005540848, -0.000538826, -0.015151978, -0.008766174, 0.014228821, -0.034423828, -0.006198883, 0.06060791, 0.025543213, 0.016433716, 0.0073432922, 0.04208374, 0.008850098, 0.0020713806, -0.0345459, 0.0019931793, 0.03100586, 0.0039711, 0.0032577515, -0.02432251, 0.023284912, -0.0065841675, 0.024841309, 0.00074243546, 0.092285156, 0.016464233, 0.02583313, 0.033447266, 0.0031223297, 0.017181396, 0.015350342, 0.00015902519, -0.024978638, 0.0010185242, 0.013687134, -0.005455017, 0.00422287, -0.0055885315, 0.0071525574, 0.02331543, -0.013442993, -0.03250122, 0.028427124, 0.0015821457, -0.01626587, -0.024749756, -0.034484863, 0.03918457, -0.031341553, 0.06762695, -0.02079773, -0.0032463074, 0.02671814, -0.028945923, -0.0075645447, -0.007030487, -0.007133484, -0.039520264, -0.020126343, -0.0040359497, -0.06854248, -0.000109791756, -0.016921997, -0.033172607, 0.010429382, -0.0058250427, 0.0037212372, 0.029525757, -0.038330078, 0.0051231384, 0.048614502, 0.0592041, -0.06951904, -0.05441284, 0.003730774, -0.013282776, -0.0151901245, 0.0011081696, -0.031707764, 0.039215088, -0.027374268, -0.022842407, 0.01676941, -0.01727295, 0.01838684, -0.0026359558, -0.048736572, 0.05230713, -0.0015411377, 0.013206482, -0.03491211, 0.00076913834, -0.04574585, -0.03024292, -0.016067505, -0.062805176, -0.024032593, -0.011047363, 0.014183044, -0.020477295, -0.0071144104, -0.0014858246, 0.045776367, 0.04248047, 0.036987305, -0.018966675, 0.0073165894, 0.01550293, -0.022705078, 0.045166016, 0.010765076, 0.0020046234, 0.022506714, -0.018157959, -0.024902344, -0.0022125244, 0.033203125, 0.0032749176, 0.019714355, 0.022521973, 0.045684814, 0.11669922, 0.048675537, -0.008148193, 0.019454956, 0.0015220642, 0.007507324, 0.0041923523, 0.041809082, 0.013893127, 0.028579712, -0.023025513, -0.0045166016, -0.029327393, 0.05014038, 0.0637207, -0.021530151, -0.040740967, -0.015777588, -0.034454346, 0.04309082, -0.01979065, 0.008682251, -0.051757812, -0.010986328, -0.009773254, 0.04055786, 0.019210815, -0.009017944, -0.025360107, -0.024002075, 0.024368286, -0.0019035339, -0.033416748, -0.048797607, -0.019378662, -0.0075798035, 0.004333496, 0.0069274902, 0.027694702, -0.024154663, -0.010375977, -0.06854248, -0.0028247833, -0.017623901, 0.04611206, 0.0022010803, 0.012435913, 0.0005326271, -0.017669678, -0.006351471, -0.03201294, -0.007663727, -0.0010795593, 0.011756897, -0.023880005, 0.025268555, -0.044128418, 0.012382507, 0.030181885, -0.0077400208, 0.038879395, -0.0039482117, -0.033966064, 0.010536194, 0.007633209, 0.033325195, 0.005142212, 0.056854248, -0.046203613, 0.005542755, 0.08239746, 0.0054512024, -0.009483337, 0.021209717, -0.026367188, 0.043823242, 0.006095886, 0.019210815, -0.022506714, -0.019348145, 0.04171753, -0.0022621155, -0.041503906, 0.0027751923, 0.040649414, -0.009544373, 0.014282227, -0.016204834, -0.00021195412, 0.028381348, -0.06414795, 0.00774765, 0.04257202, -0.0037193298, 0.023727417, -0.017471313, 0.010902405, -0.0049819946, -0.0077438354, 0.017684937, -0.013587952, 0.026031494, -0.0038528442, 0.028182983, 0.0016927719, -0.019821167, 0.0038261414, 0.016723633, -0.049804688, -0.0076446533, -0.027435303, -0.0042495728, -0.0015125275, -0.023529053, 0.01676941, -0.015541077, -0.030914307, -0.008087158, -0.012954712, -0.05050659, -0.016220093, 0.030303955, 0.012756348, -0.0001322031, 0.022109985, 0.04257202, 0.03692627, 0.042541504, 0.025131226, -0.00374794, 0.0181427, 0.018478394, -0.020904541, -0.05480957, 0.051361084, -0.017456055, -0.00157547, -0.06286621, 0.0053520203, -0.005962372, -0.011306763, 0.022354126, 0.02218628, 0.024414062, 0.019210815, 0.038238525, 0.008262634, -0.012611389, 0.0075263977, 0.024658203, -0.0075302124, -0.025039673, -0.01927185, -0.04006958, 0.005821228, 0.01739502, 0.053009033, 0.08917236, 0.021469116, -0.0035095215, 0.011505127, 0.0009622574, -0.04498291, 0.021011353, -0.029907227, -0.08343506, 0.01940918, 0.006969452, -0.0031795502, -0.013198853, 0.112976074, 0.01537323, 0.031707764, 0.004299164, -0.026321411, -0.0076026917, -0.046661377, -0.01789856, 0.026519775, -0.015106201, -0.0135650635, -0.01675415, -0.0051460266, -0.008804321, 0.004207611, 0.06488037, 0.03881836, -0.057556152, 0.019195557, -0.048431396, -0.006454468, 0.010848999, 0.0055274963, 0.036376953, 0.0340271, 0.01689148, -0.01914978, 0.059173584, 0.03237915, 0.01651001, -0.07434082, -0.025436401, -0.03744507, 0.018753052, -0.050811768, -0.029388428, -0.0143966675, 0.0071640015, -0.039215088, 0.011360168, -0.016403198, -0.026809692, 0.017745972, 0.049957275, 0.009216309, 0.0184021, 0.02217102, 0.019439697, 0.008026123, -0.0014762878, -0.04006958, 0.035247803, -0.009407043, -0.012786865, -0.016479492, 0.031463623, 0.011352539, -0.010604858, -0.0121154785, 0.03326416, -0.03375244, -0.02204895, 0.011161804, 0.0023727417, -0.0030326843, 0.032836914, -0.013786316, 0.01171875, 0.021820068, -0.0013818741, -0.0006599426, 0.010414124, -0.02949524, 0.043029785, -0.01675415, 0.035705566, -0.030441284, 0.014389038, -0.034454346, 0.0077285767, -0.047210693, -0.023391724, -0.04135132, 0.05822754, 0.0065841675, -0.008666992, -0.025253296, 0.039642334, 0.009994507, 0.03967285, 0.015274048, 0.026321411, 0.015594482, 0.005302429, -0.05517578, 0.060638428, 0.06750488, 0.009498596, 0.017028809, -0.009635925, 0.019607544, -0.033447266, 0.019882202, -0.0068206787, -0.023498535, 0.031234741, -0.04901123, -0.03564453, -0.01626587, 0.0063934326, 0.010269165, 0.008026123, -0.018356323, -0.012680054, -0.03074646, 0.02798462, -0.028366089, -0.008163452, -0.019042969, 0.016662598, 0.018310547, -0.015304565, 0.06781006, -0.014022827, 0.03729248, 0.033111572, 0.025527954, 0.03378296, -0.003665924, 0.01838684, 0.026245117, 0.05117798, 0.03564453, -0.053894043, 0.0082092285, -0.03451538, 0.013442993, 0.039855957, -0.05105591, 0.011299133, -0.035308838, 0.019012451, -0.02960205, 0.026504517, 0.013389587, -0.019546509, -0.058166504, -0.020095825, 0.022247314, -0.03744507, -0.030151367, -0.005218506, 0.0066337585, -0.04373169, -0.020950317, 0.018554688, 0.05178833, 0.033996582, -0.0088272095, 0.05105591, 0.04776001, 0.0002039671, 0.028015137, -0.017684937, 0.06185913, 0.045013428, -0.023529053, -0.004070282, -0.0017385483, 0.0135269165, -0.051513672, -0.0025138855, 0.03225708, 0.037322998, 0.010757446, 0.0036563873, -0.024551392, 0.08129883, -0.03643799, -0.0050582886, -0.013389587, -0.011108398, -0.07324219, 0.05581665, 0.002855301, -0.043395996, 0.0020160675, 0.076049805, 0.10650635, -0.02973938, 0.01625061, 0.010856628, -0.04864502, -0.014678955, -0.023391724, 0.016281128, -0.032470703, 0.033447266, 0.007045746, 0.028564453, 0.037963867, -0.010391235, 0.0010375977, -0.018737793, -0.036132812, -0.039733887, 0.040161133, -0.029815674, -0.035308838, 0.0037269592, 0.030136108, -0.019515991, -0.017730713, -0.025375366, 0.035125732, -0.064086914, -0.0026378632, 0.006626129, 0.01751709, 0.0070228577, -0.008979797, -0.014823914, 0.059417725, -0.005092621, -0.032562256, -0.047973633, 0.07232666, -0.013320923, -0.028839111, -0.025894165, 0.025772095, -0.07556152, 0.026763916, -0.020263672, -0.03970337, 0.009597778, -0.008361816, -0.037902832, -0.023254395, -0.09564209, -0.06536865, -0.014328003, 0.013053894, -0.0051651, 0.055877686, -0.012542725, -0.024734497, 0.03869629, -0.040649414, -0.034729004, 0.010810852, -0.014945984, -0.013381958, 0.002204895, -0.03189087, -0.01436615, -0.01121521, 0.048614502, -0.015731812, -0.014877319, -0.04324341, 0.022155762, -0.01096344, 0.0006098747, 0.016860962, 0.042114258, 0.026184082, -0.0009822845, -0.012702942, 0.0023174286, -0.027664185, 0.036743164, -0.022644043, 0.012069702, -0.031707764, -0.003982544, -0.0038394928, 0.031097412, -0.024551392, 0.018371582, 0.018005371, 0.024932861, -0.035217285, -0.050933838, 0.0791626, 0.06750488, -0.014404297, 0.05419922, 0.043426514, 0.016967773, 0.046844482, -0.021774292, 0.031555176, 0.048339844, 0.024383545, -0.028060913, 0.01373291, 0.00083875656, -0.0059547424, -0.055541992, -0.0010070801, -0.027633667, 0.014549255, -0.050201416, -0.057373047, -0.035736084, -0.029708862, 0.0146484375, 0.0015001297, -0.0005340576, 0.02708435, -0.042755127, 0.0004553795, 0.015266418, -0.021377563, -0.032592773, -0.038726807, 0.013252258, 0.034332275, 0.037750244, 0.016159058, -0.026870728, 0.034240723, 0.027282715, -0.0033950806, -0.019256592, -0.0098724365, -0.0013275146, -0.00041770935, -0.020187378, -0.040802002, -0.010139465, -0.017456055, -0.030258179, 0.033233643, -0.040863037, -0.0021343231, 0.011955261, -0.040985107, 0.023803711, -0.0317688, 0.0059509277, -0.010864258, 0.00058555603, 0.003293991, -0.0017614365, -0.014472961, 0.009284973, 0.02418518, -0.02508545, -0.02909851, -0.0099487305, 0.016830444, 0.015670776, 0.04537964, 0.06738281, -0.018066406, 0.0031223297, -0.0236969, 0.028518677, -0.07110596, -0.018249512, 0.03866577, -0.011291504, -0.03741455, 0.013534546, -0.0049324036, 0.016601562, -0.008888245, 0.026260376, -0.016418457, 0.008140564, 0.023406982, 0.0031814575, -0.016326904, 0.037017822, 0.015655518, 0.009544373, 0.016036987, -0.012779236, 0.010566711, -0.038726807, -0.060516357, -0.091918945, 0.004184723, -0.003042221, 0.04083252, -0.0023555756, 0.043670654, 0.020568848, -0.022232056, 0.03543091, -0.005634308, -0.060302734, 0.010375977, -0.0035152435, -0.017440796, 0.03729248, 0.010902405, -0.06842041, 0.022155762, 0.040649414, 0.023529053, 0.0014638901, 0.025848389, 0.013023376, -0.00033426285, -0.0670166, 0.016281128, 0.010749817, 0.017318726, -0.007080078, 0.040161133, 0.0019035339, 0.02142334, -0.003572464, -0.008071899, -0.0019950867, 0.01197052, -0.02519226, 0.0042304993, 0.0008354187, -0.03164673, 0.040802002, 0.051208496, 0.0007686615, -0.021362305, -0.023391724, 0.020629883, -0.008842468, 0.013427734, -0.0002682209, 0.032318115, -0.08911133, -0.056365967, 0.0024337769, -0.015151978, -0.014862061, 0.0079193115, -0.0073432922, 0.020477295, 0.008880615, -0.014564514, 0.036895752, -0.019897461, -0.03225708, -0.05038452, 0.005065918, -0.040039062, -0.0071372986, 0.029907227, 0.0256958, 0.019378662, -0.00932312, -0.03390503, -0.01486969, -0.05960083, -0.059051514, 0.04660034, -0.0032691956, -0.035888672, -0.0345459, -0.0042037964, 0.022628784, -0.0015649796, 0.009017944, -0.018234253, 0.053588867, -0.0064468384, -0.06048584, -0.06304932, -0.049957275, -0.03503418, 0.039398193, -0.019195557, -0.01651001, 0.03201294, -0.0067634583, 0.030288696, -0.04260254, -0.05227661, -0.075683594, -0.004917145, -0.023971558, -0.016586304, -0.045715332, 0.059783936, 0.0065841675, 0.0287323, 0.020141602, 0.025344849, 0.024658203, -0.033813477, 0.029174805, -0.019958496, 0.0109939575, -0.031463623, -0.016845703, -0.026245117, 0.00055885315, -0.0016613007, 0.036621094, 0.01864624, -0.022369385, 0.07836914, -0.028259277, -0.0047416687, 0.06021118, -0.058624268, 0.0947876, 0.049957275, -0.026657104, 0.011199951, -0.015235901, -0.020874023, 0.042419434, -0.005466461, 0.05529785, -0.06488037, -0.05645752, 0.019500732, -0.0012245178, -0.01777649, 0.014770508, -0.016052246, 0.019546509, 0.038604736, -0.017059326, 0.01600647, -0.0062561035, -0.004348755, 0.04663086, -0.034423828, 0.028167725, -0.014091492, 0.010070801, -0.052947998, 0.006500244, -0.056610107, 0.01663208, 0.026260376, -0.014015198, 0.05480957, -0.0008468628, 0.014839172, 0.04385376, -0.02494812, 0.10040283, 0.042785645, 0.04748535, -0.050231934, -0.018676758, 0.08380127, 0.0063323975, -0.01701355, -0.028884888, -0.007621765, -0.0070266724, -0.012001038, 0.00020432472, 0.02003479, -0.003578186, 0.021743774, -0.031829834, 0.0063476562, -0.017578125, -0.006801605, -0.014945984, -0.032073975, 0.0016841888, -0.056518555, 0.008201599, 0.004562378, -0.00044441223, -0.03643799, 0.015914917, -0.02607727, -0.0005707741, 0.010070801, -0.039215088, -0.011642456, 0.040222168, -0.04953003, -0.04876709, -0.06100464, 0.0059814453, -0.03152466, -0.009353638, 0.006793976, -0.0018291473, 0.010620117, -0.024749756, -0.013427734, 0.0071029663, 0.0063705444, -0.0073394775, -0.0005249977, 0.0030593872, 0.0068588257, 0.064697266, 0.04309082, 0.033111572, 0.011878967, 0.022094727, 0.012435913, 0.012336731, -0.061065674, 0.0005450249, -0.019317627, -0.039367676, -0.058441162, 0.008155823, -0.042236328, 0.04196167, -0.049804688, -0.038970947, 0.001824379, 0.052459717, -0.011009216, -0.039093018, 0.0010051727, 0.0009889603, 0.025390625, 0.014465332, 0.019226074, 0.039794922, 0.00969696, -0.020202637, 0.014221191, -0.027801514, -0.012290955, 0.06793213, 0.04647827, 0.028503418, -0.018920898, -0.06781006, -0.036621094, 0.05279541, 0.0044174194, -0.01626587, -0.033843994, 0.034729004, 0.0006275177, -0.018112183, -0.028060913, 0.032806396, -0.0546875, 0.004737854, 0.00042295456, -0.025238037, -0.034179688, 0.0026245117, -0.008369446, -0.009223938, -0.014251709, -0.012519836, 0.004096985, -0.027770996, -0.013893127, -0.03463745, 0.010681152, -0.0010490417, 0.037597656, -0.009063721, -0.019302368, -0.036315918, 0.044433594, 0.037902832, -0.011749268, -0.009284973, 0.005115509, 0.06774902, -0.0670166, -0.021697998, -0.08093262, -0.053955078, -0.012886047, -0.03656006, -0.012588501, -0.007785797, 0.040039062, 0.06237793, -0.019210815, 0.022216797, -0.00699234, 0.022598267, 0.011581421, -0.0070228577, -0.04623413, -0.01625061, -0.00090932846 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2101.01669v3
A Survey of Community Detection Approaches: From Statistical Modeling to Deep Learning
Di Jin, Zhizhi Yu, Pengfei Jiao, Shirui Pan, Dongxiao He, Jia Wu, Philip S. Yu, Weixiong Zhang
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.LG, physics.soc-ph
Community detection, a fundamental task for network analysis, aims to partition a network into multiple sub-structures to help reveal their latent functions. Community detection has been extensively studied in and broadly applied to many real-world network problems. Classical approaches to community detection typically utilize probabilistic graphical models and adopt a variety of prior knowledge to infer community structures. As the problems that network methods try to solve and the network data to be analyzed become increasingly more sophisticated, new approaches have also been proposed and developed, particularly those that utilize deep learning and convert networked data into low dimensional representation. Despite all the recent advancement, there is still a lack of insightful understanding of the theoretical and methodological underpinning of community detection, which will be critically important for future development of the area of network analysis. In this paper, we develop and present a unified architecture of network community-finding methods to characterize the state-of-the-art of the field of community detection. Specifically, we provide a comprehensive review of the existing community detection methods and introduce a new taxonomy that divides the existing methods into two categories, namely probabilistic graphical model and deep learning. We then discuss in detail the main idea behind each method in the two categories. Furthermore, to promote future development of community detection, we release several benchmark datasets from several problem domains and highlight their applications to various network analysis tasks. We conclude with discussions of the challenges of the field and suggestions of possible directions for future research.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2101.01669v3
"2021-08-14T09:12:36"
"2021-01-03T02:32:45"
{ "title": [ 0.011993408, 0.011650085, -0.054473877, -0.036346436, 0.049743652, -0.029388428, -0.0014858246, -0.034362793, -0.0007610321, 0.012413025, -0.01524353, 0.024429321, -0.021087646, -0.015205383, -0.007843018, 0.008361816, -0.010314941, 0.034820557, 0.003282547, -0.02810669, -0.009918213, -0.04675293, 0.053222656, 0.01789856, 0.01852417, -0.042938232, -0.016662598, 0.010398865, -0.033935547, -0.023452759, -0.011123657, -0.0028133392, 0.040252686, 0.021881104, -0.020248413, 0.03527832, -0.049865723, 0.022994995, 0.012397766, -0.0032176971, 0.0064735413, 0.005004883, -0.004924774, -0.028686523, -0.026855469, 0.022872925, -0.066467285, -0.04296875, -0.011405945, 0.012458801, 0.007709503, 0.021987915, -0.03010559, -0.0053100586, 0.0234375, -0.026947021, -0.022262573, -0.010391235, 0.040374756, 0.05368042, -0.008918762, -0.06384277, 0.027511597, -0.030883789, -0.070373535, -0.012863159, -0.019195557, 0.027542114, 0.073913574, -0.033843994, -0.035217285, 0.036315918, 0.0024967194, 0.007980347, -0.065979004, -0.019973755, 0.049591064, -0.02458191, 0.021972656, -0.03378296, -0.041137695, -0.030517578, -0.031341553, -0.004497528, -0.008453369, -0.009788513, -0.03668213, -0.004245758, -0.019470215, -0.04663086, -0.002796173, -0.024093628, -0.010047913, 0.04714966, -0.01777649, -0.002193451, -0.0009174347, 0.06817627, -0.024261475, -0.028717041, -0.009971619, 0.016113281, -0.048065186, -0.022644043, 0.015068054, 0.0211792, -0.0362854, -0.047302246, 0.004459381, 0.04336548, -0.005908966, 0.0039978027, 0.008102417, 0.024642944, 0.012763977, -0.0026168823, -0.01725769, 0.0048599243, -0.007949829, 0.012313843, 0.008491516, -0.005748749, 0.0063476562, -0.0002951622, 0.005176544, -0.014579773, -0.03591919, -0.015182495, -0.017913818, 0.029647827, 0.025405884, 0.044952393, -0.12487793, -0.08355713, -0.06567383, 0.051727295, -0.013702393, -0.020614624, -0.00003349781, 0.010520935, 0.005344391, -0.042907715, -0.041259766, 0.0090408325, 0.030227661, 0.022537231, 0.070495605, -0.01689148, -0.048187256, -0.021087646, -0.026504517, 0.02255249, 0.06549072, 0.0022449493, -0.085876465, -0.0066604614, -0.10876465, -0.030761719, 0.002784729, -0.030380249, 0.04574585, -0.008644104, -0.031341553, 0.027709961, 0.04421997, 0.0030460358, -0.023223877, 0.020477295, 0.013160706, 0.028717041, -0.02760315, 0.04156494, 0.017364502, 0.017608643, 0.003780365, 0.001914978, 0.045410156, -0.00048279762, 0.029220581, 0.013618469, 0.027496338, -0.0048599243, 0.033996582, 0.050323486, -0.061767578, -0.016540527, 0.0074539185, -0.002653122, 0.046875, 0.0112838745, -0.028045654, 0.034179688, -0.04763794, -0.062072754, -0.056640625, -0.008575439, 0.046203613, 0.04446411, -0.00579834, 0.012123108, -0.018173218, -0.019699097, -0.022338867, -0.012771606, -0.011444092, -0.023284912, -0.008125305, 0.01914978, -0.001411438, 0.05340576, 0.044158936, 0.016784668, -0.02293396, -0.018356323, -0.005672455, -0.043395996, 0.02519226, -0.044799805, -0.0037631989, -0.010787964, -0.034942627, 0.018600464, -0.040405273, 0.030761719, 0.0071029663, -0.02645874, 0.014945984, -0.053833008, 0.017593384, 0.0046539307, 0.0847168, -0.024871826, 0.012954712, 0.013961792, 0.0019187927, -0.013328552, -0.0048561096, -0.014373779, 0.013252258, 0.010093689, 0.010528564, 0.0126571655, -0.019378662, 0.0008087158, 0.08892822, 0.007461548, 0.003490448, 0.005519867, 0.019348145, 0.03857422, 0.050201416, 0.05557251, 0.03933716, -0.0003824234, 0.0121536255, 0.06762695, 0.014770508, 0.020614624, -0.04257202, 0.029434204, -0.0067214966, 0.016357422, -0.01576233, 0.010169983, -0.043945312, -0.010910034, -0.0236969, -0.003250122, 0.018051147, -0.00034689903, 0.030059814, -0.010513306, 0.014678955, 0.021194458, 0.034851074, -0.0050201416, -0.034301758, -0.021728516, 0.021530151, -0.038909912, -0.01247406, 0.016326904, 0.022323608, -0.00029826164, 0.03213501, -0.0010690689, 0.00028181076, -0.033843994, -0.02848816, -0.027114868, 0.030776978, 0.051208496, -0.006790161, 0.009407043, -0.0029735565, 0.0047302246, 0.10003662, 0.08679199, -0.036071777, 0.058624268, -0.038024902, 0.023605347, 0.026687622, -0.03616333, 0.0010814667, 0.07147217, 0.016326904, 0.024963379, -0.025863647, -0.00409317, -0.035339355, -0.0015296936, -0.004787445, -0.05407715, -0.03375244, -0.04486084, -0.0015888214, -0.051513672, -0.050323486, -0.011100769, 0.081726074, -0.0022773743, -0.048614502, -0.0041885376, 0.0057792664, -0.023651123, -0.022064209, -0.045959473, -0.050567627, 0.03173828, 0.044036865, 0.014144897, -0.043182373, -0.01197052, -0.007133484, 0.015266418, -0.015159607, 0.008956909, -0.006877899, 0.004688263, 0.030914307, 0.0065841675, 0.01878357, -0.03604126, 0.0028533936, -0.036621094, 0.023880005, 0.039520264, -0.057037354, 0.015106201, 0.025772095, -0.03656006, -0.029037476, 0.008293152, 0.06793213, -0.023376465, -0.032348633, 0.015586853, 0.022705078, -0.04055786, 0.004283905, 0.013145447, -0.016326904, -0.057403564, -0.015090942, -0.028701782, -0.01398468, -0.025497437, -0.0020999908, 0.0703125, -0.07269287, -0.03527832, 0.015106201, 0.008811951, 0.008995056, 0.03149414, -0.01838684, -0.03326416, -0.013069153, -0.025268555, -0.021102905, -0.0067977905, 0.0012845993, 0.009605408, 0.10595703, 0.0021438599, -0.0032482147, 0.024749756, 0.041229248, 0.0010223389, -0.023956299, -0.014755249, -0.019836426, 0.016052246, 0.020355225, 0.015151978, 0.027542114, 0.0013341904, -0.105407715, -0.030700684, 0.027389526, -0.011039734, -0.01448822, 0.005847931, -0.05267334, 0.021224976, -0.025512695, -0.0031108856, 0.026901245, 0.06323242, 0.0067634583, 0.008323669, 0.004699707, -0.0047340393, -0.00035095215, -0.01965332, -0.06878662, 0.017608643, -0.009185791, -0.036895752, -0.008010864, -0.036621094, -0.04272461, 0.0007929802, -0.017730713, 0.01739502, 0.015838623, 0.020050049, 0.016693115, 0.0060653687, -0.009857178, -0.0054779053, -0.0075950623, -0.01158905, -0.02418518, -0.005393982, -0.008888245, 0.027313232, 0.021972656, -0.014312744, -0.04071045, -0.031311035, 0.021911621, 0.021316528, 0.016815186, -0.021881104, -0.0014295578, -0.009643555, -0.012382507, -0.0019187927, -0.047210693, 0.0065727234, -0.03036499, 0.019638062, -0.015777588, -0.019348145, 0.03363037, -0.004966736, -0.027832031, 0.009414673, 0.04788208, -0.008934021, -0.103149414, 0.014923096, 0.028961182, 0.029373169, -0.038391113, -0.0023326874, -0.024414062, -0.0025672913, -0.022659302, 0.018630981, 0.017303467, -0.0057525635, -0.009483337, 0.022033691, 0.0012168884, 0.0016899109, -0.03225708, -0.006603241, 0.004055023, 0.01146698, -0.00029802322, -0.06149292, 0.0013809204, -0.014045715, -0.10546875, -0.018066406, 0.0034065247, -0.02911377, -0.017333984, -0.052490234, 0.024841309, -0.013916016, -0.052856445, 0.018630981, -0.0135650635, -0.015411377, -0.026824951, -0.074157715, -0.019348145, 0.06976318, 0.03253174, 0.04034424, 0.014640808, 0.0047798157, -0.013008118, -0.044128418, -0.011665344, -0.009857178, 0.04800415, -0.0259552, 0.0010604858, 0.030761719, -0.028030396, 0.02909851, 0.0030155182, 0.0032234192, -0.01776123, 0.003314972, 0.038269043, 0.04345703, 0.0030822754, 0.032409668, -0.014778137, -0.012786865, -0.04849243, -0.0068359375, -0.0011730194, 0.012550354, 0.01914978, -0.021087646, 0.036102295, 0.013267517, 0.009384155, 0.06341553, -0.025497437, -0.0012407303, 0.033325195, -0.016311646, -0.010223389, -0.005054474, 0.011642456, 0.032287598, 0.0073776245, -0.01386261, -0.012931824, 0.010818481, -0.015670776, -0.049346924, 0.011802673, 0.027023315, -0.04727173, -0.009635925, -0.037231445, -0.050201416, -0.01928711, -0.0063934326, -0.021835327, 0.013221741, 0.0057907104, -0.016967773, -0.011955261, -0.010551453, 0.030776978, 0.011917114, 0.020233154, -0.034088135, 0.012840271, -0.01966858, -0.037902832, -0.024993896, -0.010826111, -0.019638062, 0.04083252, -0.005466461, -0.00182724, 0.0096206665, 0.023529053, 0.039367676, 0.024169922, -0.0036067963, -0.033935547, 0.010772705, -0.018661499, -0.009544373, 0.014053345, -0.00038528442, 0.00038671494, -0.0075035095, 0.015975952, -0.025421143, -0.018615723, -0.013969421, 0.016021729, -0.010307312, 0.041290283, -0.012283325, 0.04196167, 0.012992859, -0.00048828125, 0.0151901245, 0.022445679, -0.036254883, -0.048736572, 0.018051147, 0.0368042, -0.0058174133, 0.0137786865, 0.05545044, 0.016571045, -0.022872925, 0.02243042, 0.019348145, 0.03640747, 0.0020694733, 0.01651001, -0.0016403198, -0.03213501, -0.0362854, 0.010650635, 0.0051345825, 0.053894043, -0.030471802, 0.07080078, -0.030075073, 0.010421753, 0.03274536, -0.0056915283, -0.0032482147, -0.017990112, 0.014854431, -0.07922363, -0.08905029, -0.032836914, 0.08526611, -0.024749756, -0.00007611513, 0.01676941, 0.024169922, 0.023803711, 0.03768921, 0.021865845, 0.029190063, 0.009819031, 0.005382538, 0.026641846, -0.005012512, -0.053009033, -0.0036392212, -0.004852295, 0.010467529, -0.016342163, -0.0042877197, -0.08520508, -0.015182495, -0.0018987656, -0.005680084, -0.00037312508, -0.055267334, 0.0015163422, 0.04510498, 0.0038089752, 0.031173706, 0.019561768, 0.01335907, 0.002111435, 0.030410767, 0.0075302124, 0.032562256, 0.018157959, -0.07397461, -0.014793396, 0.0048332214, 0.030288696, 0.024856567, 0.014724731, 0.017028809, -0.010520935, -0.035980225, 0.044769287, 0.015602112, -0.020874023, 0.0057754517, -0.03933716, 0.0012397766, -0.021987915, 0.014259338, 0.020263672, -0.0067214966, 0.0036411285, 0.003156662, -0.0027980804, -0.055877686, -0.0071983337, 0.011108398, -0.01576233, -0.068481445, 0.024276733, -0.022979736, 0.0066223145, -0.01878357, 0.026992798, -0.03375244, 0.012741089, -0.0012493134, -0.06585693, 0.019470215, -0.02330017, 0.02418518, 0.037719727, 0.008338928, -0.024871826, 0.006969452, -0.041259766, -0.06604004, -0.07952881, -0.010429382, 0.0022525787, 0.023269653, 0.002532959, -0.017105103, 0.03024292, -0.0027370453, 0.025680542, 0.029785156, -0.022232056, 0.028427124, 0.021499634, 0.030059814, 0.0031852722, 0.007850647, -0.013671875, 0.0058631897, 0.014549255, -0.023864746, 0.02192688, -0.01121521, 0.004047394, -0.008384705, -0.07397461, 0.027038574, 0.0087890625, -0.0011701584, 0.015052795, 0.019699097, 0.039398193, 0.023727417, -0.009094238, 0.024612427, 0.058044434, -0.060150146, -0.01600647, 0.014892578, 0.01210022, -0.051116943, 0.020629883, -0.0030536652, 0.0042800903, -0.035491943, -0.0635376, -0.022918701, 0.020935059, 0.030212402, 0.03152466, 0.04559326, -0.042541504, 0.041503906, -0.041625977, -0.018615723, -0.010314941, 0.0143585205, 0.008087158, -0.04763794, 0.02116394, -0.008056641, -0.0067253113, -0.033233643, 0.034698486, 0.01146698, -0.012290955, -0.009300232, -0.021209717, 0.014183044, -0.036987305, -0.029571533, 0.05303955, 0.004722595, -0.004360199, 0.08129883, -0.026123047, 0.044006348, 0.01625061, 0.069885254, 0.05279541, 0.02381897, 0.041168213, -0.0058517456, 0.007194519, -0.041503906, 0.018951416, -0.031082153, -0.03050232, -0.07867432, -0.02961731, -0.07342529, 0.0030994415, 0.0077209473, 0.010421753, 0.02746582, 0.014579773, 0.019699097, 0.025009155, 0.060272217, 0.02078247, 0.064208984, 0.0067634583, 0.006187439, -0.003704071, -0.00995636, -0.0009531975, 0.041107178, -0.00012481213, -0.0047836304, -0.014198303, -0.0062828064, -0.007511139, 0.03237915, 0.012397766, -0.0028152466, 0.0058631897, -0.029678345, 0.062927246, -0.017044067, 0.060546875, 0.0769043, 0.035491943, 0.027664185, -0.06072998, -0.0016012192, -0.031402588, -0.02154541, -0.019363403, 0.01826477, -0.05996704, 0.0043754578, -0.04559326, -0.006298065, 0.0044822693, -0.0011062622, 0.048980713, -0.07904053, -0.061431885, 0.0064048767, 0.05307007, -0.004863739, 0.00027871132, -0.047058105, 0.01335907, 0.014045715, 0.016052246, -0.0006747246, -0.02166748, 0.019210815, 0.03491211, -0.035308838, -0.0126571655, 0.0032215118, 0.025924683, -0.02760315, 0.022888184, -0.032989502, 0.030075073, 0.02180481, -0.033477783, 0.016860962, 0.010505676, -0.05038452, 0.0036010742, 0.028900146, 0.03237915, 0.06304932, 0.068237305, 0.00061416626, -0.011726379, 0.0143585205, -0.07147217, 0.019302368, 0.057617188, -0.026489258, 0.017486572, -0.022476196, -0.027328491, 0.04510498, -0.00022423267, 0.043060303, -0.05770874, 0.01096344, 0.01335907, -0.012435913, 0.037017822, -0.037719727, -0.01889038, -0.0071792603, -0.021011353, -0.008094788, -0.028045654, -0.045135498, -0.023086548, -0.0016803741, 0.02053833, 0.0073051453, -0.020446777, -0.03488159, -0.009086609, -0.08300781, -0.023468018, -0.055023193, 0.021011353, -0.025146484, -0.007472992, -0.033172607, -0.0065612793, 0.0019207001, -0.0074272156, -0.014556885, -0.015068054, -0.060424805, -0.070739746, 0.03353882, 0.02822876, -0.025802612, -0.037994385, 0.0024337769, -0.019836426, -0.016677856, -0.023544312, 0.031585693, -0.04043579, -0.03869629, -0.022644043, -0.0028762817, 0.04144287, 0.036956787, -0.008026123, 0.011550903, 0.022964478, -0.025115967, -0.015060425, 0.0027885437, 0.02659607, -0.009315491, -0.032958984, 0.012229919, 0.027923584, 0.031402588, -0.059417725, -0.026428223, 0.0066947937, 0.020263672, 0.000248909, 0.03677368, 0.026916504, -0.027374268, 0.030761719, -0.0033912659, 0.01499939, -0.019104004, -0.04989624, -0.03475952, 0.033081055, 0.044067383, -0.00082969666, -0.023498535, 0.050201416, -0.008041382, 0.008972168, 0.031463623, -0.019073486, 0.025100708, 0.004863739, 0.017608643, -0.028793335, 0.0042762756, 0.0044670105, 0.012489319, -0.0013723373, 0.027008057, -0.013114929, -0.002216339, -0.023010254, 0.03930664, -0.00047969818, -0.08148193, 0.050079346, 0.043945312, 0.016403198, 0.036987305, -0.013336182, -0.036346436, 0.015617371, -0.014823914, -0.018188477, -0.006084442, 0.015258789, -0.030929565, 0.0042877197, -0.029403687, -0.020614624, -0.000497818, -0.0259552, 0.03857422, -0.01576233, -0.0006108284, -0.020629883, -0.013717651, -0.017959595, 0.015991211, 0.0048179626, -0.057403564, -0.00869751, 0.0036640167, 0.066711426, 0.0008444786 ], "summary": [ 0.054504395, 0.005153656, -0.030853271, 0.00049877167, 0.012496948, -0.03717041, -0.002439499, -0.03918457, 0.017562866, 0.0077171326, -0.035217285, 0.034118652, 0.012763977, -0.01524353, 0.046020508, 0.00843811, 0.0019836426, 0.009811401, 0.010307312, -0.018707275, 0.010803223, -0.017059326, 0.004070282, 0.021652222, -0.0051651, -0.024215698, 0.08843994, -0.0022583008, 0.012504578, 0.01600647, 0.014045715, -0.023834229, -0.0027275085, 0.049468994, -0.034698486, 0.015579224, -0.027801514, 0.029067993, 0.014778137, 0.0047721863, 0.025650024, 0.0040779114, 0.12780762, -0.029724121, 0.04244995, 0.045806885, -0.010192871, -0.06542969, 0.023162842, -0.014175415, -0.012275696, 0.008781433, -0.011711121, -0.052703857, -0.014335632, -0.020385742, 0.01826477, -0.011711121, 0.036376953, 0.01222229, -0.040222168, -0.021743774, 0.035003662, -0.058563232, -0.02305603, -0.018844604, 0.03970337, 0.016143799, 0.01600647, -0.023910522, 0.020095825, 0.030715942, 0.0031108856, -0.018218994, -0.045166016, -0.031585693, 0.04446411, -0.0440979, -0.014175415, -0.018127441, -0.056030273, 0.0010089874, -0.052246094, -0.02619934, -0.0069351196, 0.01071167, -0.02897644, -0.015068054, -0.0039787292, -0.0024547577, -0.017700195, -0.008148193, -0.016143799, 0.042175293, -0.0031738281, -0.015045166, 0.034729004, 0.03955078, -0.031585693, -0.035064697, -0.0017385483, -0.02897644, -0.0064811707, -0.014923096, -0.004383087, 0.019348145, -0.034942627, -0.042266846, 0.017150879, 0.050354004, 0.0075263977, -0.0024433136, -0.01927185, 0.0051651, -0.039520264, 0.012969971, -0.012969971, 0.009635925, -0.0071868896, 0.034729004, 0.0059318542, 0.03717041, -0.033691406, 0.0071411133, -0.004558563, 0.0023899078, 0.014480591, -0.013290405, -0.019577026, 0.03488159, 0.010566711, 0.0149383545, -0.047058105, -0.028259277, -0.052734375, -0.0034942627, 0.007461548, -0.0022068024, 0.014060974, -0.001241684, 0.038085938, -0.044769287, -0.06210327, 0.07598877, -0.0016422272, 0.025238037, 0.023849487, -0.0014266968, -0.02079773, -0.0052337646, -0.0118637085, 0.019729614, 0.04321289, -0.004673004, -0.062164307, -0.04550171, -0.009567261, -0.038879395, 0.004901886, -0.04736328, 0.036254883, -0.0027942657, -0.0027561188, 0.045043945, 0.017028809, 0.00044465065, -0.0068588257, -0.007041931, 0.011909485, -0.033477783, -0.042999268, 0.028808594, 0.033935547, -0.007972717, 0.0009365082, -0.0020561218, 0.0013179779, -0.013076782, -0.016204834, 0.08087158, 0.03189087, -0.034088135, -0.042388916, 0.03579712, -0.03543091, 0.0064315796, 0.007019043, 0.042999268, 0.0035171509, 0.016159058, 0.026565552, -0.0011043549, -0.031234741, -0.016113281, -0.022857666, 0.03540039, -0.007209778, 0.037231445, -0.010665894, 0.01020813, 0.011978149, 0.0036373138, 0.00020742416, -0.0052986145, -0.02999878, 0.00617218, -0.0046157837, 0.007850647, 0.048736572, 0.01928711, 0.00033950806, -0.019439697, 0.022354126, -0.04360962, -0.03479004, -0.005420685, 0.011978149, -0.113464355, -0.033081055, -0.064819336, -0.057617188, 0.0690918, -0.10070801, 0.030822754, 0.03302002, -0.027694702, 0.009429932, -0.020370483, 0.032409668, -0.0030918121, 0.015655518, 0.011009216, -0.008003235, 0.0035171509, 0.001411438, 0.01525116, 0.06100464, -0.037963867, 0.0027942657, 0.008239746, 0.028717041, 0.029846191, -0.052215576, -0.050445557, 0.038726807, -0.024490356, -0.0039901733, -0.010147095, -0.0072517395, 0.029830933, 0.008880615, 0.027740479, 0.018493652, -0.012893677, 0.027282715, 0.0234375, 0.017196655, 0.019683838, -0.046905518, 0.03845215, 0.0024490356, 0.046661377, -0.01902771, 0.0099487305, 0.007686615, -0.029632568, 0.0051002502, -0.0065574646, 0.03652954, -0.027359009, -0.0129776, -0.06414795, -0.008239746, 0.031188965, 0.01486969, 0.024017334, -0.036743164, -0.015792847, 0.007369995, 0.01550293, -0.01473999, 0.02897644, 0.0036411285, -0.021072388, 0.018737793, 0.039489746, -0.009231567, -0.05444336, -0.018630981, 0.029418945, 0.037322998, 0.060333252, -0.005836487, 0.025100708, -0.039855957, 0.0146484375, 0.042510986, 0.05239868, -0.02331543, 0.0064315796, 0.008148193, 0.026748657, -0.025527954, -0.015426636, 0.000016093254, 0.049987793, 0.007698059, -0.01234436, -0.0056877136, -0.013290405, -0.024871826, -0.0023059845, 0.0019168854, 0.018356323, -0.034332275, -0.040283203, -0.02482605, -0.0067634583, -0.048583984, -0.0016365051, 0.07287598, -0.014526367, -0.025039673, 0.00084495544, -0.017486572, -0.01927185, 0.0027313232, -0.036010742, -0.033233643, 0.005306244, -0.05532837, -0.026016235, -0.06726074, 0.038360596, -0.0008854866, 0.02633667, 0.022033691, -0.026641846, 0.012001038, 0.0093307495, 0.050842285, 0.019348145, -0.0016918182, -0.012481689, -0.0070762634, 0.021408081, 0.028533936, 0.0046157837, -0.04675293, 0.014022827, -0.012260437, -0.026550293, 0.0014696121, -0.003545761, 0.040496826, -0.007118225, -0.03656006, -0.019546509, 0.011054993, -0.052215576, 0.023712158, 0.028137207, 0.0149002075, -0.04864502, -0.03955078, -0.011917114, 0.034454346, -0.035217285, 0.019989014, 0.036193848, -0.023910522, -0.029449463, 0.02885437, 0.0074386597, 0.025741577, 0.001581192, 0.014259338, -0.023162842, 0.036895752, 0.027145386, -0.013954163, -0.0070266724, 0.045959473, 0.0345459, 0.068237305, 0.006450653, 0.0256958, 0.03842163, 0.035003662, -0.013282776, -0.015640259, -0.016418457, -0.026000977, -0.0037212372, 0.00869751, 0.0036792755, 0.06500244, 0.022125244, -0.024002075, -0.060058594, 0.023513794, 0.023742676, 0.030944824, 0.0001667738, -0.027557373, 0.017181396, -0.007019043, 0.009605408, 0.008804321, 0.05065918, 0.021133423, -0.027999878, 0.00037789345, 0.024108887, -0.013130188, 0.0035037994, 0.07324219, 0.025375366, -0.029418945, -0.06518555, 0.0075035095, 0.019226074, 0.030639648, -0.007472992, -0.018951416, 0.01184845, -0.032348633, 0.014877319, -0.021408081, 0.04425049, -0.024871826, 0.0211792, -0.008605957, -0.012763977, -0.0357666, -0.022369385, -0.007030487, -0.033233643, 0.028182983, -0.049468994, -0.019943237, -0.016967773, 0.046081543, 0.033325195, 0.023513794, 0.0063438416, 0.013656616, -0.0045814514, -0.0093688965, 0.014259338, -0.070007324, 0.027648926, 0.01914978, 0.027130127, -0.01309967, -0.058746338, -0.006629944, 0.005710602, -0.0079422, -0.00042772293, 0.051635742, 0.03375244, -0.08728027, -0.0116119385, 0.010421753, 0.03338623, -0.07659912, 0.023513794, -0.041381836, 0.008560181, 0.046417236, -0.008171082, -0.014038086, -0.042419434, 0.0046195984, -0.027420044, 0.057495117, -0.005962372, 0.027526855, -0.053527832, -0.06439209, 0.030044556, 0.01259613, -0.029388428, -0.018478394, 0.005542755, -0.024734497, -0.013015747, 0.0030879974, 0.0032749176, 0.016357422, -0.037231445, 0.02671814, -0.009140015, -0.029525757, -0.0048294067, -0.015197754, 0.09472656, -0.009460449, -0.08154297, 0.040161133, -0.032684326, 0.045135498, 0.044067383, -0.030090332, 0.04812622, 0.07598877, -0.014953613, -0.01309967, -0.034088135, 0.044952393, -0.07019043, 0.017623901, 0.014450073, -0.028335571, 0.015312195, -0.008041382, -0.029129028, -0.0056114197, 0.03753662, 0.079956055, 0.08093262, -0.0033187866, -0.012924194, -0.0011920929, 0.0010728836, -0.0055770874, 0.00141716, 0.0036354065, -0.005279541, 0.04345703, 0.020828247, 0.0036201477, 0.017150879, -0.030059814, -0.015434265, -0.03765869, -0.02822876, 0.0056762695, 0.04748535, -0.034210205, -0.053344727, -0.0070228577, 0.05041504, -0.024398804, -0.039764404, -0.062164307, -0.016342163, -0.011657715, -0.028915405, 0.020950317, 0.026565552, -0.06237793, -0.00932312, 0.027252197, -0.004425049, -0.022079468, -0.017944336, -0.042114258, 0.012825012, -0.021514893, 0.052215576, 0.020584106, -0.04119873, 0.048950195, 0.0075263977, 0.0055122375, -0.02330017, -0.052215576, -0.007865906, -0.037384033, -0.010566711, -0.0592041, -0.08898926, -0.03048706, 0.016937256, -0.0046577454, -0.00032949448, 0.029632568, 0.038146973, -0.005218506, 0.027755737, -0.014282227, -0.004798889, -0.017150879, 0.03463745, -0.04522705, 0.036376953, -0.013038635, 0.032958984, 0.009254456, -0.023513794, -0.0047187805, -0.00340271, 0.0008239746, -0.02619934, 0.01927185, -0.025115967, 0.03555298, -0.0011320114, -0.011795044, 0.018829346, 0.0028896332, -0.012458801, -0.015838623, 0.04244995, 0.030899048, -0.01966858, 0.019943237, 0.05001831, 0.0066986084, -0.074157715, 0.024627686, 0.026031494, 0.038391113, -0.008430481, 0.02243042, -0.015670776, 0.0042495728, -0.010253906, 0.010902405, 0.004470825, 0.013542175, 0.008758545, 0.0027675629, 0.012428284, 0.0008254051, 0.036499023, 0.0029563904, -0.0069618225, 0.034179688, -0.012069702, -0.046875, -0.077697754, -0.062438965, 0.05218506, 0.014572144, -0.030212402, 0.029174805, 0.016174316, 0.007091522, 0.013946533, 0.009170532, 0.037872314, 0.009101868, 0.0132369995, 0.039367676, 0.013160706, -0.026931763, -0.04989624, 0.009475708, 0.004096985, 0.018707275, -0.0022335052, -0.0030059814, 0.000059604645, -0.021270752, 0.00058555603, -0.0035171509, -0.010856628, -0.030960083, 0.032562256, -0.022766113, 0.0151901245, 0.064086914, -0.018508911, -0.023117065, 0.020935059, -0.033477783, 0.019348145, -0.0062828064, -0.08520508, -0.037322998, 0.0026569366, 0.016494751, 0.0011739731, 0.0028476715, 0.017501831, -0.035247803, -0.012916565, 0.019500732, 0.010467529, 0.024887085, -0.07714844, 0.018127441, 0.028869629, -0.037322998, 0.03378296, 0.027435303, 0.032836914, 0.04272461, 0.034606934, 0.045013428, 0.014755249, -0.019500732, 0.048095703, 0.007347107, -0.046051025, 0.034301758, -0.040649414, -0.0036506653, -0.0060272217, 0.024414062, 0.010848999, -0.04458618, -0.024459839, -0.055541992, 0.042236328, -0.009468079, 0.039093018, -0.012519836, -0.038879395, -0.048828125, -0.006336212, -0.031677246, -0.060943604, -0.09875488, -0.037628174, -0.020111084, 0.04940796, -0.017593384, 0.011230469, 0.035308838, -0.012382507, 0.016586304, 0.02935791, -0.040893555, 0.019348145, 0.007335663, 0.016448975, 0.007888794, -0.011871338, -0.037841797, -0.0010175705, 0.031677246, -0.044036865, 0.020996094, 0.0011844635, -0.011047363, -0.028533936, -0.039764404, 0.017074585, 0.019760132, -0.021438599, 0.06341553, 0.01586914, 0.022583008, 0.03829956, 0.0027008057, 0.044525146, 0.03793335, -0.036346436, 0.030014038, 0.012374878, 0.030288696, -0.03829956, -0.046722412, 0.024490356, 0.043945312, -0.013015747, -0.05206299, 0.017654419, 0.014694214, -0.003271103, 0.0496521, 0.07397461, -0.031921387, 0.015434265, -0.03829956, -0.025878906, -0.007724762, 0.018432617, -0.015029907, -0.030670166, 0.040802002, -0.030349731, -0.019699097, 0.027267456, 0.010421753, -0.026275635, -0.031311035, -0.0055885315, 0.03543091, 0.03262329, -0.016799927, 0.016021729, 0.01977539, 0.016860962, 0.01499939, -0.003522873, 0.018371582, 0.0362854, 0.036010742, 0.019851685, 0.0033607483, -0.02281189, 0.023376465, 0.012863159, -0.018188477, -0.03466797, 0.02279663, 0.014099121, -0.092041016, -0.06921387, -0.06329346, -0.004753113, 0.021820068, -0.044311523, -0.03768921, 0.056152344, -0.011169434, 0.010177612, 0.070739746, -0.0022735596, 0.053741455, -0.005405426, -0.04147339, -0.01638794, -0.033569336, 0.01008606, 0.0061416626, 0.03173828, 0.021118164, 0.0049934387, 0.016677856, -0.016418457, 0.0289917, 0.029312134, -0.026290894, -0.01777649, 0.054138184, -0.039245605, 0.056793213, 0.024017334, 0.041503906, 0.030273438, -0.013038635, 0.06173706, -0.06640625, -0.0014266968, 0.00592041, -0.02368164, -0.022537231, -0.03036499, 0.017807007, -0.046691895, -0.027145386, 0.025497437, 0.023025513, -0.030685425, 0.06359863, -0.07525635, -0.04058838, 0.020446777, 0.013511658, -0.0362854, 0.0046577454, -0.036834717, -0.014884949, -0.004627228, -0.01626587, 0.004421234, -0.023712158, -0.007091522, 0.004825592, -0.025115967, 0.00037956238, -0.017532349, 0.026031494, -0.047546387, 0.017044067, -0.00932312, 0.0107040405, 0.037475586, -0.006942749, 0.007217407, 0.026519775, 0.014320374, 0.028808594, 0.030700684, 0.03112793, 0.062927246, 0.04559326, -0.028579712, 0.013343811, 0.07672119, -0.024902344, -0.0056152344, 0.016036987, 0.008338928, -0.0062446594, -0.025222778, 0.01776123, 0.0026340485, 0.019500732, 0.051513672, -0.029159546, 0.0056037903, -0.012435913, -0.010185242, -0.03378296, -0.017684937, 0.019332886, -0.03857422, -0.016433716, 0.02015686, -0.014915466, -0.06427002, 0.039215088, -0.025238037, -0.047576904, 0.018081665, -0.015258789, 0.003376007, -0.0050354004, -0.04724121, 0.009223938, -0.0062294006, 0.049621582, 0.004676819, -0.030975342, 0.00920105, -0.008476257, 0.018112183, -0.0037498474, 0.008300781, -0.011642456, -0.026443481, -0.107910156, 0.06817627, 0.06573486, -0.02418518, -0.05392456, 0.10394287, -0.05166626, -0.0012187958, -0.02003479, 0.035247803, -0.005458832, -0.035827637, -0.020492554, 0.013885498, 0.029663086, 0.013046265, 0.015563965, 0.026657104, 0.039855957, -0.02911377, -0.007671356, -0.008903503, -0.011405945, 0.019897461, -0.014167786, 0.0050811768, 0.0072517395, 0.05279541, -0.02243042, 0.008087158, 0.012229919, 0.00831604, 0.018997192, -0.028442383, 0.007926941, -0.024993896, 0.010276794, -0.016403198, 0.0008378029, 0.0011959076, -0.019897461, -0.03262329, 0.052093506, 0.0011930466, -0.039489746, -0.0042037964, 0.047607422, -0.021118164, 0.011062622, 0.016479492, -0.03265381, 0.0020160675, -0.010093689, -0.021194458, -0.012954712, 0.004508972, 0.054382324, 0.02947998, -0.027328491, -0.018981934, -0.017364502, -0.028762817, -0.019607544, -0.05596924, 0.01058197, -0.012870789, -0.017105103, 0.004322052, 0.014678955, -0.003490448, 0.010040283, -0.034057617, 0.013198853, -0.013442993, -0.015838623, -0.0234375, 0.027893066, -0.007320404, -0.008468628, -0.012329102, 0.027175903, 0.016784668, -0.011543274, 0.048675537, -0.009162903, -0.009162903, -0.027938843, 0.008422852, 0.00831604, 0.020050049, -0.018295288, -0.052124023, 0.063964844, 0.068359375, 0.025543213, 0.038024902 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2101.02780v2
SHARKS: Smart Hacking Approaches for RisK Scanning in Internet-of-Things and Cyber-Physical Systems based on Machine Learning
Tanujay Saha, Najwa Aaraj, Neel Ajjarapu, Niraj K. Jha
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Cyber-physical systems (CPS) and Internet-of-Things (IoT) devices are increasingly being deployed across multiple functionalities, ranging from healthcare devices and wearables to critical infrastructures, e.g., nuclear power plants, autonomous vehicles, smart cities, and smart homes. These devices are inherently not secure across their comprehensive software, hardware, and network stacks, thus presenting a large attack surface that can be exploited by hackers. In this article, we present an innovative technique for detecting unknown system vulnerabilities, managing these vulnerabilities, and improving incident response when such vulnerabilities are exploited. The novelty of this approach lies in extracting intelligence from known real-world CPS/IoT attacks, representing them in the form of regular expressions, and employing machine learning (ML) techniques on this ensemble of regular expressions to generate new attack vectors and security vulnerabilities. Our results show that 10 new attack vectors and 122 new vulnerability exploits can be successfully generated that have the potential to exploit a CPS or an IoT ecosystem. The ML methodology achieves an accuracy of 97.4% and enables us to predict these attacks efficiently with an 87.2% reduction in the search space. We demonstrate the application of our method to the hacking of the in-vehicle network of a connected car. To defend against the known attacks and possible novel exploits, we discuss a defense-in-depth mechanism for various classes of attacks and the classification of data targeted by such attacks. This defense mechanism optimizes the cost of security measures based on the sensitivity of the protected resource, thus incentivizing its adoption in real-world CPS/IoT by cybersecurity practitioners.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2101.02780v2
"2022-10-19T22:02:25"
"2021-01-07T22:01:30"
{ "title": [ -0.021835327, 0.0000020861626, -0.017303467, 0.00856781, -0.004589081, -0.028884888, 0.018493652, -0.037353516, -0.06109619, 0.021392822, -0.023254395, 0.051605225, -0.014297485, -0.031280518, 0.00083589554, -0.030776978, -0.011177063, 0.01625061, 0.009674072, -0.030410767, 0.016799927, -0.044799805, 0.068847656, -0.016921997, 0.019210815, -0.011634827, -0.058532715, 0.0005354881, -0.003358841, -0.039398193, 0.004173279, 0.035705566, 0.023040771, 0.033325195, -0.033843994, 0.016159058, -0.035217285, 0.04498291, 0.008453369, 0.0025367737, 0.031082153, 0.0003182888, 0.019485474, 0.0041770935, -0.018447876, 0.038146973, -0.058380127, -0.016189575, 0.0011711121, 0.036895752, 0.0034236908, 0.017730713, 0.0020275116, 0.023773193, -0.008773804, -0.033691406, -0.025924683, -0.04425049, 0.031097412, 0.08135986, 0.0418396, -0.046081543, 0.005382538, -0.056152344, -0.013557434, -0.03289795, 0.0021247864, 0.033050537, 0.0413208, -0.0060157776, 0.021209717, 0.035003662, 0.019500732, 0.019332886, -0.052886963, -0.045440674, 0.06707764, -0.011161804, 0.023468018, -0.010826111, -0.020812988, -0.011764526, 0.020889282, -0.012710571, -0.0018577576, -0.008415222, -0.018417358, 0.0036582947, -0.02482605, -0.019332886, -0.018920898, -0.005695343, -0.005207062, 0.021713257, -0.02078247, -0.014060974, 0.01890564, 0.004169464, 0.022399902, -0.031799316, 0.0034694672, -0.0078125, -0.05065918, 0.006008148, 0.021087646, 0.05545044, -0.00819397, -0.0055656433, 0.015174866, -0.0071907043, -0.008132935, 0.0057678223, -0.0005135536, -0.022140503, -0.033233643, 0.0044441223, 0.007347107, -0.021331787, 0.029205322, -0.0031929016, -0.012802124, -0.033447266, 0.020202637, 0.05239868, 0.033599854, 0.02720642, -0.0284729, 0.012825012, -0.0070266724, -0.00046730042, -0.0206604, 0.053894043, -0.031433105, -0.066589355, -0.0625, 0.025253296, 0.011726379, 0.017791748, 0.016067505, -0.014961243, 0.049865723, -0.017944336, -0.02885437, 0.033294678, -0.028381348, -0.028778076, 0.02645874, 0.032958984, -0.0099105835, -0.008583069, -0.013832092, 0.02281189, 0.0047340393, 0.010566711, 0.002796173, 0.029129028, -0.06854248, 0.006690979, 0.003643036, 0.012840271, 0.057006836, 0.014045715, -0.009925842, 0.0496521, 0.052825928, -0.016067505, -0.00010514259, 0.025802612, -0.01134491, 0.02633667, -0.024597168, -0.0012607574, -0.015106201, -0.03363037, -0.0077285767, 0.00945282, -0.016113281, 0.0335083, 0.025497437, -0.039855957, -0.027526855, -0.04397583, 0.009361267, 0.019622803, -0.04397583, -0.014076233, 0.0015115738, 0.01713562, 0.0463562, -0.0041999817, -0.020980835, -0.00026988983, -0.032684326, -0.054779053, -0.01676941, 0.01878357, 0.015823364, 0.028060913, -0.0069351196, -0.011932373, -0.058624268, 0.020553589, -0.046539307, 0.046173096, 0.00088071823, -0.034240723, 0.01776123, 0.021697998, -0.03970337, 0.04345703, 0.046936035, -0.022369385, -0.01676941, -0.010040283, 0.01499176, -0.042510986, 0.04421997, 0.004497528, 0.0042800903, 0.002828598, -0.046936035, 0.0006275177, -0.021972656, 0.021255493, 0.02507019, 0.018661499, -0.012123108, -0.004432678, 0.07757568, 0.030548096, 0.045532227, -0.04675293, 0.061462402, 0.018112183, -0.021606445, -0.016326904, 0.011543274, -0.057403564, 0.015655518, 0.0597229, 0.02482605, -0.01902771, -0.008041382, 0.0018844604, 0.060516357, -0.070495605, -0.028747559, 0.023223877, 0.0071640015, 0.019073486, 0.0463562, 0.028503418, 0.05886841, 0.077819824, 0.0018568039, 0.03817749, -0.0043792725, 0.047454834, -0.048950195, 0.0024337769, 0.021942139, 0.02619934, -0.004558563, 0.012321472, -0.049713135, 0.00009858608, -0.006679535, 0.03857422, 0.015823364, -0.016159058, 0.030761719, -0.014160156, 0.009902954, 0.053466797, 0.014984131, 0.0051116943, -0.021652222, -0.026397705, 0.01574707, 0.00025749207, -0.016021729, -0.012031555, 0.0012655258, -0.0065231323, 0.023513794, -0.019348145, 0.011444092, -0.00030899048, -0.0335083, 0.0049324036, 0.049713135, 0.044647217, -0.008415222, -0.006038666, -0.012336731, 0.023651123, 0.035003662, 0.09197998, -0.03579712, 0.023773193, -0.07287598, -0.0031757355, 0.014656067, -0.032348633, 0.0069236755, 0.0024261475, 0.02130127, -0.008552551, -0.02607727, 0.010192871, -0.06530762, 0.00036120415, 0.017211914, -0.030426025, -0.012237549, -0.06011963, -0.021148682, -0.019134521, -0.040618896, 0.00881958, 0.047454834, -0.01411438, -0.030349731, -0.011268616, -0.022521973, -0.02204895, -0.027740479, -0.033935547, -0.05203247, 0.008377075, 0.015068054, -0.008239746, -0.031463623, 0.025024414, 0.004676819, 0.018798828, 0.0000104904175, -0.0045051575, -0.018112183, -0.016113281, -0.0065612793, -0.015136719, -0.012588501, -0.027877808, -0.016738892, -0.03768921, -0.005241394, 0.014129639, -0.012489319, -0.014083862, 0.044403076, -0.020584106, -0.013175964, 0.008407593, 0.040863037, -0.010810852, -0.025985718, 0.007896423, 0.013961792, -0.029006958, 0.04852295, 0.034179688, 0.03277588, -0.053588867, -0.04638672, -0.06750488, -0.008079529, -0.002866745, 0.012199402, 0.045562744, -0.06323242, 0.01159668, -0.06036377, -0.018356323, 0.0013971329, 0.036865234, -0.02760315, -0.055847168, 0.021774292, -0.028289795, -0.016159058, -0.039489746, 0.034332275, -0.013381958, 0.06359863, -0.016799927, -0.026779175, 0.0011835098, 0.008079529, 0.0013809204, -0.0073165894, -0.018554688, -0.038848877, -0.004043579, 0.039215088, 0.0011930466, -0.0052719116, 0.017349243, -0.098083496, -0.01134491, 0.012893677, 0.016235352, -0.030303955, 0.020767212, -0.064208984, -0.028381348, -0.0026779175, -0.022018433, 0.044067383, 0.06866455, 0.016921997, -0.055633545, 0.058807373, -0.05996704, 0.02078247, -0.008216858, -0.046173096, 0.024658203, -0.032928467, -0.02420044, 0.005683899, 0.0013132095, -0.016540527, -0.022750854, -0.011428833, 0.017807007, 0.049041748, 0.012313843, 0.006996155, -0.00065755844, 0.008514404, -0.032714844, 0.019073486, -0.039764404, -0.07507324, -0.03173828, -0.017028809, 0.05026245, 0.02420044, -0.00022339821, -0.031341553, -0.0057678223, -0.015052795, 0.0025348663, -0.0032596588, -0.055755615, -0.0109939575, -0.023544312, 0.005268097, 0.0026874542, 0.002538681, 0.0027809143, 0.023040771, -0.0004992485, -0.011222839, 0.0413208, -0.005657196, 0.037475586, -0.016281128, -0.015686035, 0.017181396, -0.01802063, -0.035888672, 0.012458801, -0.024642944, -0.018310547, 0.038238525, -0.00881958, -0.0043144226, -0.021881104, -0.051483154, 0.06677246, 0.020812988, 0.00092458725, 0.009216309, 0.030395508, -0.025894165, -0.020126343, -0.012062073, 0.014785767, -0.01146698, 0.014930725, 0.004966736, -0.04425049, -0.024261475, 0.029251099, -0.08862305, -0.051849365, 0.010681152, -0.070129395, -0.06439209, -0.06756592, 0.026901245, -0.0814209, -0.023544312, 0.01878357, 0.009094238, -0.05822754, -0.024810791, -0.082336426, -0.009338379, 0.064453125, -0.01637268, 0.03677368, 0.0019187927, 0.00198555, -0.0064048767, -0.009681702, -0.015792847, -0.019454956, 0.0340271, -0.027282715, 0.021575928, 0.060668945, -0.033355713, 0.029785156, 0.0015001297, 0.03768921, -0.026062012, 0.012161255, 0.015914917, 0.024993896, -0.06866455, 0.031463623, 0.054992676, -0.0012559891, -0.12286377, 0.02734375, 0.003118515, -0.06463623, 0.02116394, -0.007633209, 0.029251099, 0.070739746, 0.004108429, 0.06222534, -0.011665344, 0.018112183, -0.01449585, -0.04437256, -0.04675293, -0.010749817, 0.030883789, -0.020355225, -0.008476257, 0.026397705, -0.013969421, 0.059265137, -0.030380249, 0.004535675, -0.0016775131, -0.0027751923, -0.035705566, -0.030426025, -0.03060913, -0.011077881, -0.0034503937, 0.01259613, -0.020370483, -0.022750854, 0.048553467, -0.014526367, -0.038482666, -0.008285522, 0.031799316, -0.010482788, -0.0035572052, -0.06750488, -0.018005371, 0.002161026, -0.0501709, -0.04043579, 0.05038452, 0.041137695, -0.006149292, -0.043701172, -0.0023097992, 0.034942627, 0.029190063, 0.056518555, 0.03744507, -0.010955811, -0.053131104, 0.044128418, -0.032196045, 0.00026154518, 0.017684937, 0.0069465637, -0.008666992, -0.020858765, 0.019973755, -0.008705139, -0.0005068779, -0.006668091, 0.0017404556, -0.016601562, -0.00070858, -0.0124435425, 0.061828613, 0.0032463074, 0.01235199, 0.021484375, 0.010818481, -0.020187378, -0.0061302185, 0.03149414, 0.044525146, -0.0007381439, 0.05041504, 0.06021118, -0.010688782, 0.0072402954, -0.030059814, 0.032165527, -0.0096206665, -0.041107178, 0.0023975372, 0.044403076, 0.0073776245, -0.0473938, -0.0043296814, 0.03353882, 0.015792847, -0.033172607, 0.033355713, 0.0037708282, -0.0033893585, 0.002691269, -0.019363403, 0.013038635, -0.0011873245, 0.013595581, -0.03765869, -0.028335571, -0.014961243, 0.016204834, -0.015731812, -0.0020103455, -0.008331299, -0.016738892, 0.0074691772, 0.02709961, -0.0012083054, -0.02204895, 0.0019779205, -0.0015687943, -0.025161743, -0.013366699, -0.022842407, -0.044525146, -0.0025596619, 0.016830444, 0.0014276505, 0.0039100647, -0.04458618, 0.0066223145, 0.0042304993, 0.010536194, -0.015304565, -0.04827881, 0.007434845, 0.045959473, 0.004798889, -0.0033607483, -0.057739258, 0.0026569366, 0.043884277, 0.0335083, 0.001871109, -0.041229248, 0.0496521, -0.032928467, 0.010032654, 0.04055786, 0.03265381, -0.00076150894, 0.029510498, 0.019363403, -0.009613037, -0.035827637, 0.0017566681, 0.020492554, 0.014480591, 0.022491455, -0.03829956, 0.015159607, 0.0129852295, 0.005680084, 0.023391724, -0.039276123, -0.0046653748, 0.04107666, -0.02041626, 0.027709961, 0.0077552795, 0.009567261, -0.046966553, -0.064331055, 0.01134491, 0.011398315, -0.008354187, -0.029663086, 0.025360107, -0.048095703, 0.021087646, 0.02229309, -0.054840088, 0.00045871735, -0.00491333, 0.024612427, 0.014533997, 0.004470825, -0.052734375, -0.028747559, -0.00970459, -0.044036865, -0.058624268, -0.027786255, -0.0146865845, 0.012931824, -0.020065308, -0.018218994, 0.019515991, -0.0234375, 0.010498047, 0.029968262, -0.0149002075, 0.010116577, -0.008300781, -0.009185791, 0.025741577, 0.013000488, -0.0026760101, 0.01739502, 0.0025939941, 0.007347107, 0.040893555, -0.011253357, -0.0037765503, 0.010299683, -0.032562256, 0.016296387, 0.030273438, 0.020965576, -0.03451538, 0.018844604, 0.026443481, -0.0009622574, 0.002073288, -0.016616821, 0.06109619, -0.0032997131, 0.018325806, -0.031555176, 0.0077285767, -0.05227661, 0.047668457, -0.028060913, 0.009010315, -0.053344727, -0.07965088, -0.04147339, -0.007972717, 0.047729492, 0.03527832, 0.06689453, -0.06402588, -0.0016717911, -0.010635376, -0.0006814003, -0.035186768, 0.016540527, -0.009185791, 0.013404846, 0.00970459, 0.027389526, -0.020599365, -0.015655518, 0.022476196, 0.052581787, 0.007904053, 0.02168274, -0.06591797, -0.022872925, -0.025222778, 0.0054130554, 0.054779053, 0.009361267, -0.030181885, 0.02319336, -0.0134887695, 0.047180176, 0.032440186, 0.004573822, 0.04031372, 0.031173706, -0.009346008, 0.009635925, 0.02861023, -0.0037231445, -0.012580872, -0.058166504, -0.00466156, -0.025939941, -0.0072364807, -0.042877197, -0.0055160522, 0.027420044, 0.0446167, 0.0056877136, 0.015068054, 0.04385376, 0.015007019, 0.03616333, -0.013183594, 0.07287598, 0.0143585205, 0.0009994507, 0.030426025, -0.011894226, -0.001490593, 0.030975342, -0.0006146431, 0.03237915, -0.023651123, -0.015296936, -0.0054740906, 0.0054092407, 0.043792725, 0.002166748, -0.022781372, -0.0012578964, 0.0131073, -0.00066280365, -0.0006351471, 0.048217773, 0.0670166, -0.030471802, 0.010360718, 0.0037727356, -0.0036964417, 0.010597229, -0.017456055, 0.040802002, -0.036010742, 0.024765015, -0.011940002, -0.047454834, 0.0048103333, 0.050567627, 0.0030612946, -0.045013428, -0.00995636, 0.017471313, 0.01436615, 0.02180481, 0.049194336, -0.004940033, 0.0027637482, 0.035247803, 0.008644104, 0.0063819885, 0.017303467, 0.00894928, 0.044830322, -0.010345459, 0.010719299, -0.02935791, 0.034362793, -0.04055786, 0.020767212, -0.044921875, 0.042419434, -0.047912598, -0.052337646, 0.0028209686, 0.0079422, -0.06549072, -0.027053833, 0.043792725, 0.029830933, 0.07635498, 0.05899048, -0.0012769699, -0.0073127747, 0.062286377, -0.06036377, 0.01586914, 0.03111267, -0.026977539, 0.021224976, -0.021987915, -0.036071777, 0.038879395, -0.019088745, 0.09124756, -0.008621216, 0.015266418, -0.049346924, 0.028717041, -0.022750854, -0.04824829, 0.041229248, -0.026992798, -0.032562256, -0.02897644, -0.011619568, -0.017944336, -0.05316162, -0.04437256, 0.058654785, -0.029129028, 0.02029419, 0.037506104, -0.05682373, -0.043548584, 0.043029785, 0.004535675, 0.06518555, 0.0047302246, -0.01739502, 0.005306244, -0.0027122498, 0.0020370483, -0.05154419, -0.020263672, -0.022354126, 0.0019416809, -0.037841797, 0.01689148, 0.0026226044, -0.04083252, -0.039489746, -0.012191772, -0.010292053, -0.031082153, 0.037200928, 0.029006958, -0.030197144, -0.038146973, 0.01689148, -0.029342651, 0.02961731, -0.022903442, -0.0015878677, 0.021621704, 0.012962341, -0.01259613, -0.020339966, 0.017562866, 0.027893066, 0.0082473755, -0.053131104, -0.023651123, 0.0602417, 0.040863037, -0.024917603, 0.030273438, 0.034118652, 0.049621582, -0.008918762, 0.04827881, -0.030883789, 0.0045814514, 0.047424316, 0.1027832, 0.02545166, -0.07318115, -0.059539795, -0.032958984, 0.052337646, 0.043426514, -0.023025513, -0.015457153, 0.027770996, 0.004878998, 0.04171753, 0.0035572052, -0.048553467, 0.016296387, -0.02810669, 0.021652222, 0.022857666, -0.01789856, 0.013313293, 0.05303955, -0.014167786, 0.012817383, -0.0011920929, 0.012626648, 0.007259369, 0.019195557, 0.028762817, -0.031097412, 0.05343628, 0.040100098, 0.03866577, 0.056671143, -0.008506775, -0.03881836, -0.0036773682, 0.03488159, -0.0075263977, 0.053497314, 0.018707275, 0.033203125, 0.029312134, -0.03729248, -0.020401001, -0.020248413, -0.033172607, 0.027420044, -0.040283203, 0.007709503, -0.04260254, 0.010375977, 0.013313293, 0.021484375, 0.017211914, 0.013504028, -0.04373169, -0.05001831, 0.0146102905, -0.024047852 ], "summary": [ 0.027648926, -0.013252258, -0.0051116943, -0.004306793, -0.022354126, -0.027893066, -0.010055542, -0.03668213, -0.072265625, 0.010826111, -0.036956787, 0.03692627, -0.044525146, -0.021728516, 0.05078125, -0.061798096, -0.016952515, 0.035339355, 0.016799927, -0.017578125, 0.012489319, -0.009063721, 0.03302002, -0.0137786865, 0.00058317184, -0.009750366, -0.029663086, 0.022125244, -0.009429932, -0.002653122, -0.0019817352, 0.0135650635, 0.020462036, 0.031188965, -0.050079346, 0.012046814, -0.020904541, 0.027633667, -0.017944336, 0.03768921, 0.014892578, 0.022506714, 0.10620117, -0.022750854, 0.022705078, 0.044158936, -0.033050537, -0.047729492, 0.021987915, 0.0017547607, -0.0007185936, -0.02142334, 0.0049858093, -0.006828308, -0.032714844, -0.05441284, -0.02784729, 0.019943237, 0.016036987, 0.064086914, 0.024490356, 0.0036907196, -0.01335907, -0.06567383, -0.015296936, 0.009742737, 0.08685303, -0.0015573502, 0.033477783, -0.03186035, -0.0057373047, 0.048736572, 0.019226074, -0.036590576, -0.018798828, -0.0019512177, 0.023513794, -0.037017822, -0.004886627, -0.024978638, 0.005077362, 0.0070610046, 0.015960693, -0.023651123, 0.036193848, 0.024398804, -0.0066108704, -0.033081055, -0.016220093, -0.00007492304, -0.016677856, -0.020980835, -0.049591064, 0.061035156, 0.037841797, -0.03869629, 0.00995636, -0.023345947, 0.015991211, 0.0011634827, 0.024139404, -0.061828613, 0.030776978, -0.027236938, -0.0051460266, 0.08074951, 0.068237305, -0.0069503784, -0.022369385, -0.052246094, -0.01272583, 0.030227661, -0.038085938, -0.006664276, -0.049865723, 0.043640137, -0.004447937, -0.037902832, -0.01374054, -0.0030822754, -0.03479004, -0.008125305, -0.046569824, 0.026351929, 0.014282227, -0.0023040771, 0.010978699, 0.049072266, -0.0015363693, 0.010772705, -0.009521484, 0.00819397, 0.00010418892, 0.0004274845, -0.018615723, -0.010917664, 0.026504517, 0.028640747, 0.047546387, -0.044647217, 0.060302734, 0.004398346, -0.03564453, 0.055877686, -0.00093364716, 0.027770996, 0.013504028, 0.009712219, -0.0008983612, -0.0069465637, -0.020904541, -0.012550354, 0.030807495, 0.01058197, -0.017333984, 0.0005803108, 0.012321472, -0.01663208, -0.020599365, -0.046936035, 0.020629883, -0.008575439, -0.027145386, 0.028778076, 0.009002686, 0.009399414, 0.009315491, 0.021957397, 0.0044937134, 0.045959473, -0.009315491, -0.010284424, -0.028396606, -0.026855469, -0.0146484375, -0.009239197, -0.009101868, 0.027694702, 0.001203537, -0.016036987, 0.006072998, -0.032043457, 0.02923584, -0.0028572083, -0.031982422, 0.008972168, 0.010803223, 0.066223145, 0.023773193, 0.019073486, 0.02407837, -0.026870728, -0.028884888, 0.0065193176, -0.008758545, 0.010269165, 0.012863159, 0.026763916, -0.01499176, -0.02041626, 0.024108887, 0.019866943, -0.027175903, -0.01058197, -0.044921875, -0.0026607513, 0.002817154, 0.013580322, -0.05770874, 0.007003784, 0.018081665, -0.059631348, -0.0018014908, -0.005783081, 0.02305603, -0.015419006, 0.046081543, -0.006549835, 0.0084991455, -0.039886475, -0.019378662, 0.008132935, -0.02720642, 0.048614502, 0.026062012, 0.009132385, -0.019058228, 0.00040912628, 0.11566162, 0.0005788803, 0.05407715, -0.035980225, 0.04626465, 0.027526855, -0.011650085, -0.011352539, -0.011833191, -0.09790039, 0.011543274, 0.07159424, 0.011398315, 0.016204834, -0.048583984, -0.028625488, -0.032043457, -0.080078125, -0.025405884, 0.017074585, -0.013427734, 0.05239868, -0.022918701, 0.021896362, 0.012840271, -0.032226562, -0.0027332306, 0.031204224, 0.031677246, 0.03793335, -0.050445557, 0.018997192, 0.00869751, 0.0121154785, -0.020019531, 0.00047683716, 0.013763428, -0.034851074, 0.03010559, 0.04486084, 0.034729004, -0.060791016, -0.0036010742, -0.025726318, 0.011016846, 0.01638794, -0.018814087, -0.02154541, 0.009796143, -0.011550903, -0.0055389404, -0.0042533875, -0.026611328, -0.037719727, -0.05026245, -0.018508911, 0.053466797, -0.0013999939, -0.018218994, -0.0368042, 0.000119149685, 0.054718018, 0.042175293, 0.053649902, 0.005458832, 0.023208618, -0.017425537, 0.02015686, 0.0007443428, 0.051971436, 0.011482239, -0.014579773, -0.027145386, 0.022705078, -0.028381348, 0.022994995, 0.018676758, -0.0087890625, 0.019363403, 0.017074585, 0.01663208, 0.03842163, -0.055023193, 0.0340271, 0.018966675, 0.036865234, -0.042510986, -0.048797607, -0.03753662, 0.0154953, -0.03842163, 0.001115799, 0.035186768, -0.03491211, 0.023788452, 0.01007843, -0.025894165, -0.03829956, 0.031951904, -0.0021762848, -0.037078857, 0.033813477, -0.018035889, 0.0011148453, -0.016540527, 0.06335449, -0.010284424, 0.020004272, -0.00026655197, 0.039611816, -0.009559631, -0.018096924, -0.004764557, -0.03491211, -0.022521973, 0.0065727234, -0.057922363, 0.0020542145, -0.018722534, 0.013038635, -0.03250122, -0.029296875, 0.047546387, -0.030273438, 0.004043579, -0.028030396, 0.056152344, -0.048217773, -0.054107666, -0.008026123, 0.017181396, -0.057373047, 0.035369873, 0.050689697, 0.04525757, -0.0287323, -0.08459473, -0.04260254, 0.017623901, 0.035369873, -0.0071029663, 0.007843018, 0.0022563934, -0.009429932, -0.055999756, -0.007583618, -0.0071754456, 0.024368286, 0.044403076, -0.024520874, 0.0036334991, 0.014328003, -0.013168335, -0.007385254, -0.0140686035, -0.006313324, 0.07366943, -0.006072998, 0.0032520294, 0.0446167, 0.02281189, -0.0077667236, -0.015022278, -0.0041160583, -0.043029785, 0.00737381, -0.02267456, -0.0102005005, 0.029083252, -0.009757996, -0.04800415, -0.025375366, -0.006214142, 0.019958496, -0.005580902, -0.013305664, -0.0073013306, 0.026748657, 0.009681702, -0.017471313, 0.01537323, 0.026397705, 0.02229309, -0.05230713, 0.0231781, -0.039520264, 0.026016235, -0.01737976, 0.01966858, 0.013977051, 0.017211914, -0.040283203, -0.019241333, -0.005203247, 0.021453857, 0.0071868896, 0.0033473969, -0.009170532, 0.033081055, 0.001625061, -0.008834839, 0.04135132, 0.022369385, -0.011810303, -0.0024585724, 0.0073280334, -0.03552246, -0.034088135, -0.0025997162, -0.07006836, 0.06536865, -0.052093506, -0.0340271, 0.012611389, 0.032836914, 0.045166016, 0.01889038, -0.010482788, 0.004802704, -0.041503906, -0.0037975311, 0.0047416687, -0.010261536, 0.008636475, 0.02468872, 0.020706177, -0.011405945, 0.027999878, -0.053955078, -0.000064730644, 0.05895996, -0.013374329, 0.0075149536, 0.032470703, -0.07836914, -0.010070801, -0.019058228, -0.041748047, 0.05380249, 0.005607605, 0.009109497, -0.010192871, -0.03515625, 0.058563232, -0.023422241, -0.015777588, -0.022155762, 0.008621216, 0.019836426, -0.03060913, 0.08294678, 0.013122559, -0.06933594, 0.03665161, -0.05630493, -0.05117798, -0.023651123, 0.01285553, -0.04663086, -0.038970947, 0.004753113, -0.011940002, -0.0057258606, 0.010848999, 0.06378174, -0.03918457, 0.030715942, -0.029434204, -0.009292603, -0.0021686554, -0.03253174, -0.08294678, 0.007972717, 0.0154800415, 0.04437256, 0.051574707, -0.023452759, 0.030044556, 0.000600338, -0.015396118, -0.016494751, -0.03704834, -0.015052795, -0.059143066, 0.024871826, 0.027557373, -0.014183044, 0.05316162, -0.028289795, 0.078430176, -0.031585693, -0.017822266, 0.060638428, 0.05126953, -0.05050659, 0.006790161, 0.03189087, 0.013374329, -0.06878662, 0.013397217, -0.00029063225, -0.08483887, 0.027252197, 0.0009407997, 0.023803711, 0.089660645, -0.016662598, 0.06109619, 0.0030593872, -0.013824463, -0.010650635, -0.021972656, -0.028656006, 0.0027942657, 0.032928467, -0.007534027, -0.028945923, 0.044952393, -0.0418396, 0.06652832, -0.04458618, 0.033813477, 0.0015277863, -0.023422241, -0.02859497, -0.024978638, -0.008415222, 0.03918457, -0.013198853, 0.0078125, -0.0019779205, -0.011436462, 0.031951904, -0.044403076, 0.022354126, -0.003829956, 0.11175537, 0.011955261, -0.017562866, -0.12670898, -0.031188965, 0.024459839, -0.01802063, 0.017684937, 0.024047852, -0.0446167, 0.006538391, -0.055267334, 0.005622864, 0.033203125, 0.029907227, 0.04034424, 0.028915405, -0.0017557144, -0.02986145, 0.027420044, 0.011299133, -0.014343262, 0.01689148, 0.008346558, 0.015235901, 0.01360321, 0.0024471283, -0.031677246, -0.025405884, -0.01586914, 0.009178162, 0.001405716, 0.048187256, 0.0044555664, 0.027069092, 0.015289307, 0.008430481, -0.02268982, -0.011871338, -0.02458191, 0.04043579, -0.002494812, 0.03616333, -0.04321289, 0.03488159, 0.030197144, -0.026824951, -0.050079346, -0.01776123, 0.047698975, -0.005519867, -0.023788452, -0.06427002, 0.074157715, 0.03970337, -0.02784729, 0.027130127, 0.0014619827, 0.0033454895, 0.02104187, -0.036193848, 0.0042877197, 0.007133484, 0.03250122, -0.010749817, -0.00031590462, 0.04321289, -0.0039711, -0.03756714, -0.025314331, -0.028640747, 0.056549072, -0.026016235, -0.04244995, -0.040893555, -0.011619568, 0.0423584, -0.003894806, -0.030532837, -0.056610107, 0.0016670227, 0.00806427, -0.038513184, 0.007827759, -0.014320374, -0.012893677, -0.03878784, 0.016662598, 0.007881165, -0.007926941, -0.002571106, 0.003736496, 0.0069770813, 0.006374359, -0.014442444, -0.042755127, -0.04147339, -0.016525269, -0.026519775, -0.021438599, -0.0023880005, 0.019927979, -0.012496948, 0.04156494, -0.024002075, 0.0067863464, 0.019073486, -0.009902954, -0.009971619, -0.008590698, -0.00075626373, 0.023727417, 0.01789856, 0.0206604, -0.005832672, -0.017730713, -0.014862061, -0.058135986, -0.023895264, -0.012245178, 0.025466919, 0.033935547, -0.00056934357, -0.003030777, 0.0023059845, -0.0020065308, 0.0003476143, 0.040649414, -0.0060577393, 0.044036865, 0.021743774, 0.015777588, -0.0052719116, -0.027633667, -0.02748108, -0.014656067, 0.03692627, -0.011711121, 0.01651001, -0.018981934, -0.009521484, 0.034362793, -0.044067383, 0.028320312, -0.022338867, 0.031311035, 0.015464783, -0.0035896301, 0.013496399, 0.013168335, -0.087524414, -0.033599854, -0.07678223, -0.05014038, -0.029312134, 0.08807373, -0.027709961, -0.010292053, 0.04397583, -0.043823242, 0.0011034012, 0.04055786, -0.012069702, -0.013893127, -0.0050849915, -0.015808105, 0.00680542, -0.039794922, -0.0060157776, 0.005153656, 0.0026168823, -0.001209259, 0.015274048, 0.011512756, 0.012397766, -0.005672455, 0.010314941, -0.009178162, 0.03060913, -0.0043182373, -0.01675415, 0.02659607, 0.021026611, -0.0335083, 0.0440979, 0.00806427, 0.053527832, 0.009101868, -0.03817749, -0.023635864, 0.017044067, -0.0209198, 0.04623413, 0.018554688, -0.028198242, -0.024002075, -0.050628662, 0.0090789795, 0.0029067993, 0.013267517, 0.040283203, 0.04699707, -0.04763794, 0.013038635, 0.039886475, -0.039123535, -0.021514893, -0.027740479, 0.012748718, 0.036590576, 0.058898926, 0.0074501038, -0.009399414, -0.015159607, 0.021240234, 0.026138306, -0.016952515, 0.036102295, -0.008476257, -0.0009021759, -0.0028362274, 0.03643799, 0.054138184, -0.005470276, 0.04156494, 0.01977539, 0.010467529, -0.0027008057, 0.027114868, -0.025619507, -0.009376526, 0.0030231476, 0.016921997, -0.009757996, -0.036468506, -0.007411957, 0.04425049, -0.003047943, -0.074157715, -0.08135986, -0.062805176, -0.053009033, 0.0259552, -0.046203613, 0.023727417, 0.019470215, 0.022247314, 0.043701172, -0.018692017, -0.036102295, -0.057128906, 0.03488159, -0.019256592, -0.008598328, 0.015579224, 0.0007634163, -0.0009384155, 0.02482605, -0.0068130493, 0.022109985, 0.0019664764, 0.038726807, -0.03765869, 0.000023305416, -0.016983032, -0.048553467, 0.045074463, -0.008491516, 0.050842285, 0.025634766, 0.0070991516, 0.036132812, 0.029342651, 0.06591797, -0.04562378, 0.015914917, -0.00002026558, 0.037078857, -0.020935059, 0.030181885, -0.014152527, 0.0033226013, 0.01512146, -0.013648987, 0.011512756, 0.031280518, 0.0032024384, -0.0045700073, 0.031433105, -0.03829956, 0.02267456, 0.0036029816, -0.016220093, -0.021469116, -0.009056091, 0.008422852, -0.0152282715, 0.011489868, 0.023010254, 0.021774292, 0.010925293, -0.0030765533, 0.01259613, -0.005744934, 0.023895264, -0.0017995834, 0.017623901, -0.06008911, -0.046020508, -0.040527344, -0.023284912, -0.0044898987, -0.007583618, 0.053955078, -0.025009155, 0.08905029, 0.033569336, 0.06945801, 0.041168213, -0.021408081, 0.010185242, 0.05493164, -0.023468018, 0.020980835, 0.002023697, -0.013175964, -0.0357666, 0.0003221035, -0.0011224747, 0.008033752, 0.006778717, 0.046875, -0.008758545, -0.020019531, -0.06585693, 0.013511658, -0.029647827, -0.053527832, 0.051727295, -0.08465576, 0.0023841858, -0.021331787, 0.011100769, -0.0079193115, 0.015609741, -0.027908325, 0.011787415, 0.03152466, 0.006504059, 0.012886047, -0.029296875, 0.016998291, 0.052520752, 0.013496399, 0.09106445, 0.023147583, -0.0059318542, 0.015670776, -0.0028858185, -0.0017690659, -0.077697754, 0.003276825, -0.045532227, 0.015472412, -0.0056991577, -0.0034561157, -0.019241333, -0.021728516, 0.041503906, 0.022827148, 0.030654907, -0.0013570786, 0.030426025, 0.043670654, -0.026748657, -0.018356323, 0.0068473816, -0.038330078, 0.051727295, -0.006713867, 0.015686035, 0.0134887695, 0.030395508, 0.002790451, -0.030700684, 0.033599854, 0.011528015, 0.00032639503, -0.06713867, 0.0073623657, 0.032958984, 0.035980225, 0.008735657, 0.07299805, 0.06112671, 0.017501831, 0.004135132, -0.008621216, -0.042663574, -0.01676941, 0.056274414, 0.050964355, 0.024658203, -0.029373169, -0.03729248, 0.0030384064, 0.04425049, 0.0053901672, -0.025543213, -0.02935791, 0.016189575, -0.014862061, 0.0030555725, -0.028030396, -0.032440186, -0.030548096, -0.0049362183, -0.013206482, 0.00995636, 0.009407043, 0.036315918, 0.023620605, -0.011459351, 0.0049934387, -0.0063552856, -0.00995636, 0.000002861023, -0.015777588, 0.005470276, -0.04510498, -0.001376152, 0.0011701584, 0.006839752, 0.017288208, 0.0011978149, -0.039031982, -0.009010315, -0.0006737709, -0.0014543533, 0.0010404587, 0.014038086, 0.007820129, 0.01285553, -0.007549286, -0.011894226, -0.040283203, -0.030014038, 0.020309448, -0.019302368, 0.008110046, 0.026016235, 0.0014400482, 0.008544922, 0.026321411, -0.019302368, 0.037231445, -0.033996582, -0.025100708, -0.011413574, -0.02748108 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2101.04163v1
On the Practicality of Differential Privacy in Federated Learning by Tuning Iteration Times
Yao Fu, Yipeng Zhou, Di Wu, Shui Yu, Yonggang Wen, Chao Li
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.DC, cs.LG
In spite that Federated Learning (FL) is well known for its privacy protection when training machine learning models among distributed clients collaboratively, recent studies have pointed out that the naive FL is susceptible to gradient leakage attacks. In the meanwhile, Differential Privacy (DP) emerges as a promising countermeasure to defend against gradient leakage attacks. However, the adoption of DP by clients in FL may significantly jeopardize the model accuracy. It is still an open problem to understand the practicality of DP from a theoretic perspective. In this paper, we make the first attempt to understand the practicality of DP in FL through tuning the number of conducted iterations. Based on the FedAvg algorithm, we formally derive the convergence rate with DP noises in FL. Then, we theoretically derive: 1) the conditions for the DP based FedAvg to converge as the number of global iterations (GI) approaches infinity; 2) the method to set the number of local iterations (LI) to minimize the negative influence of DP noises. By further substituting the Laplace and Gaussian mechanisms into the derived convergence rate respectively, we show that: 3) The DP based FedAvg with the Laplace mechanism cannot converge, but the divergence rate can be effectively prohibited by setting the number of LIs with our method; 4) The learning error of the DP based FedAvg with the Gaussian mechanism can converge to a constant number finally if we use a fixed number of LIs per GI. To verify our theoretical findings, we conduct extensive experiments using two real-world datasets. The results not only validate our analysis results, but also provide useful guidelines on how to optimize model accuracy when incorporating DP into FL
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2101.04163v1
"2021-01-11T19:43:12"
"2021-01-11T19:43:12"
{ "title": [ -0.019622803, 0.012069702, -0.06323242, -0.060272217, 0.03112793, -0.008308411, -0.0036582947, 0.0013818741, -0.026794434, 0.016326904, -0.044433594, 0.032684326, -0.014411926, 0.00217247, -0.014556885, -0.020385742, -0.00026106834, 0.019439697, 0.014549255, -0.021621704, -0.031066895, -0.028579712, 0.059295654, 0.0014286041, 0.054016113, -0.040924072, -0.10101318, 0.017822266, 0.0055274963, -0.01399231, 0.008277893, 0.0059280396, 0.0131073, 0.052978516, -0.012908936, 0.019989014, -0.03277588, 0.04498291, 0.025863647, 0.010826111, 0.012435913, -0.0015363693, -0.023239136, -0.016906738, -0.031341553, 0.013755798, -0.060638428, -0.030181885, -0.020828247, 0.09472656, 0.031021118, 0.03515625, -0.007095337, 0.08337402, 0.007713318, -0.04901123, -0.0012130737, -0.009376526, 0.064941406, 0.007446289, -0.016448975, -0.060546875, 0.032165527, -0.02734375, -0.018371582, -0.035339355, -0.0077781677, 0.02407837, 0.06335449, 0.015197754, 0.005466461, 0.027069092, 0.020935059, 0.007904053, -0.06173706, -0.012054443, 0.048553467, 0.003293991, 0.021972656, -0.044036865, -0.012489319, -0.017974854, -0.054107666, 0.0017957687, 0.01083374, 0.02079773, -0.013618469, -0.017364502, -0.006954193, 0.006000519, -0.002664566, -0.0029964447, 0.008384705, 0.058532715, -0.0046844482, -0.0095825195, -0.0011386871, 0.034851074, -0.013206482, -0.03060913, -0.0435791, 0.01121521, -0.06951904, -0.0028095245, -0.017578125, 0.0049819946, 0.006175995, -0.010536194, -0.008766174, 0.03152466, -0.019195557, 0.010131836, 0.016708374, 0.008476257, -0.005432129, -0.015274048, 0.0056877136, 0.0096588135, 0.0027599335, 0.005996704, 0.006767273, -0.0042495728, -0.009223938, 0.019226074, 0.04611206, 0.007587433, -0.021026611, -0.006832123, -0.034973145, 0.046936035, 0.013198853, 0.039001465, -0.08880615, -0.07873535, -0.06347656, 0.03250122, -0.014335632, -0.006801605, -0.013221741, 0.012001038, -0.00605011, -0.033050537, 0.0036449432, -0.00038051605, -0.013877869, 0.023544312, 0.058441162, -0.024368286, -0.06008911, -0.0519104, -0.033355713, 0.038116455, 0.02659607, 0.0066490173, -0.031402588, 0.0054969788, -0.06488037, -0.006614685, 0.011772156, -0.012550354, 0.014823914, -0.006511688, -0.008728027, 0.08465576, 0.10357666, 0.028137207, 0.018936157, 0.02268982, 0.0046310425, 0.06427002, 0.004459381, -0.02468872, -0.051818848, -0.009162903, -0.008224487, 0.011100769, 0.036315918, 0.0287323, 0.012413025, -0.046966553, -0.0062026978, -0.003194809, 0.013648987, 0.016952515, -0.059265137, -0.0036258698, 0.0055389404, 0.022918701, 0.033996582, 0.0031528473, -0.013954163, 0.03829956, -0.0362854, -0.033294678, -0.03503418, -0.0014562607, -0.015975952, 0.0073394775, -0.0052337646, 0.011100769, -0.02923584, 0.025802612, -0.04660034, 0.032409668, -0.024307251, -0.006046295, -0.012191772, 0.02848816, -0.028747559, 0.030517578, 0.050933838, -0.019592285, -0.019165039, 0.023483276, 0.015792847, -0.043945312, 0.013908386, -0.006099701, -0.013938904, -0.010269165, -0.02809143, 0.0047836304, -0.014709473, 0.025146484, 0.035125732, 0.015701294, -0.011749268, -0.011054993, 0.07086182, 0.012992859, 0.09887695, -0.027877808, -0.02658081, -0.02279663, 0.0013217926, -0.01789856, -0.015510559, -0.049560547, 0.026260376, 0.02168274, -0.005203247, -0.0104522705, -0.016693115, 0.021072388, 0.035308838, 0.022399902, 0.017440796, 0.0075531006, 0.0061798096, 0.017852783, 0.07775879, 0.024841309, 0.02116394, 0.004070282, 0.022628784, 0.04574585, -0.029052734, 0.011169434, -0.03540039, 0.015342712, -0.0009531975, 0.024627686, 0.033325195, 0.011779785, -0.079711914, -0.011016846, -0.032287598, -0.0072135925, 0.014511108, -0.009674072, 0.035308838, -0.035186768, 0.009651184, 0.0054092407, 0.0000035762787, -0.036743164, -0.0060272217, 0.009391785, 0.0017147064, -0.04800415, -0.019073486, 0.013908386, 0.011497498, -0.009613037, 0.0038795471, -0.010726929, 0.0027484894, -0.028808594, -0.012710571, 0.005874634, 0.059570312, 0.029571533, 0.0022354126, -0.0075912476, -0.001958847, -0.0020313263, 0.03427124, 0.068603516, -0.023071289, 0.014930725, -0.06414795, 0.0055885315, 0.013038635, -0.031402588, 0.0036087036, 0.020599365, -0.0034313202, -0.001704216, -0.03414917, 0.013473511, -0.06414795, 0.047027588, 0.005290985, -0.061462402, -0.037139893, -0.03540039, -0.008232117, -0.047027588, -0.03604126, 0.02746582, 0.07324219, -0.016479492, -0.020217896, -0.0178833, 0.0066566467, -0.03265381, -0.01739502, -0.032043457, -0.0004529953, 0.026184082, -0.032989502, 0.012580872, -0.08050537, 0.01574707, -0.006248474, 0.030059814, -0.010139465, 0.01108551, -0.020767212, 0.011405945, 0.006351471, -0.007789612, 0.037353516, -0.060913086, -0.03289795, -0.028442383, -0.027496338, 0.021194458, -0.030044556, -0.02130127, 0.042053223, -0.019073486, -0.026443481, -0.0095825195, 0.07086182, -0.033996582, -0.030410767, 0.02607727, 0.03616333, -0.019332886, 0.050476074, 0.021713257, 0.016525269, -0.090026855, -0.04977417, -0.048095703, -0.024475098, -0.013908386, 0.02784729, 0.07196045, -0.03845215, 0.021087646, -0.054870605, -0.007724762, 0.006134033, 0.00045347214, 0.036987305, -0.012748718, -0.032470703, 0.0040359497, -0.0149002075, 0.008903503, -0.038848877, 0.0032749176, 0.0395813, 0.01461792, -0.02330017, -0.0053138733, 0.021850586, -0.010215759, 0.015457153, 0.025283813, 0.030548096, -0.010978699, 0.02835083, 0.0063438416, -0.008216858, 0.009918213, -0.035064697, -0.013221741, 0.06781006, -0.02267456, -0.023956299, 0.0075263977, -0.035217285, -0.035339355, 0.034423828, -0.0073013306, 0.022659302, 0.009216309, 0.010116577, -0.011489868, 0.016998291, -0.023498535, 0.01159668, -0.07208252, -0.05908203, 0.041290283, -0.04046631, -0.053375244, -0.005168915, 0.02293396, -0.033843994, -0.024398804, -0.014076233, 0.05130005, 0.024383545, 0.0040779114, 0.03463745, 0.014503479, 0.008338928, -0.005607605, 0.00573349, -0.030136108, -0.072509766, -0.025650024, 0.003993988, 0.05303955, 0.034454346, -0.017456055, -0.059936523, -0.007194519, -0.0011453629, 0.026351929, 0.018997192, -0.044311523, -0.013267517, -0.03579712, -0.0061531067, 0.039794922, -0.024902344, -0.005340576, -0.01777649, 0.0028266907, -0.023590088, 0.02709961, 0.004009247, -0.005958557, -0.04663086, 0.02734375, 0.032806396, 0.026107788, -0.036621094, -0.017333984, 0.020095825, 0.002532959, 0.01210022, -0.014892578, -0.038970947, 0.030639648, -0.03555298, 0.0029850006, -0.006965637, -0.010047913, 0.012336731, 0.00016963482, -0.03137207, 0.03237915, -0.020446777, -0.0026874542, -0.03466797, 0.027435303, -0.056732178, -0.06854248, -0.014640808, 0.0046157837, -0.08850098, -0.031555176, 0.047973633, -0.06970215, -0.04309082, -0.08782959, 0.026229858, -0.049072266, -0.0077171326, 0.009429932, -0.013549805, 0.0032615662, -0.010795593, -0.09863281, 0.02772522, 0.0501709, 0.019592285, 0.048431396, 0.005493164, -0.0028362274, -0.026275635, -0.041107178, 0.0107803345, -0.024887085, 0.016342163, -0.029907227, 0.021774292, 0.0619812, -0.026550293, 0.021072388, 0.013946533, 0.03366089, -0.029953003, 0.003036499, 0.021514893, 0.051635742, -0.06842041, 0.053009033, 0.05984497, -0.04159546, -0.07556152, 0.0005578995, 0.009902954, -0.0060043335, 0.022262573, -0.006839752, 0.05230713, 0.037750244, -0.02116394, 0.042297363, -0.0045661926, -0.03366089, 0.03100586, 0.025177002, -0.010345459, -0.014015198, 0.02180481, 0.031707764, 0.012130737, -0.027328491, -0.011871338, 0.0110321045, -0.035827637, -0.024353027, -0.010604858, 0.007293701, -0.043670654, -0.013534546, -0.039001465, -0.039886475, -0.01260376, 0.027557373, -0.016998291, -0.012519836, 0.005088806, 0.02067566, -0.051757812, 0.013298035, 0.025283813, 0.00073337555, 0.018218994, -0.01914978, 0.020111084, 0.010169983, -0.033477783, -0.0124435425, 0.045318604, -0.00617218, 0.040618896, -0.055664062, -0.005306244, 0.029525757, 0.009086609, 0.004940033, 0.05078125, -0.047973633, -0.034973145, 0.005580902, -0.010910034, -0.023529053, 0.01828003, 0.0184021, -0.019638062, -0.035125732, 0.016998291, -0.020477295, -0.020980835, -0.051452637, 0.04083252, -0.0038166046, 0.036071777, 0.011314392, 0.04537964, 0.04559326, 0.013420105, 0.015716553, 0.016464233, -0.02911377, -0.015304565, 0.0020656586, 0.023529053, 0.027618408, 0.03704834, 0.057525635, -0.004886627, -0.03765869, 0.017501831, 0.019897461, 0.02760315, 0.004802704, 0.009796143, 0.0015439987, -0.008651733, -0.015899658, 0.01637268, 0.013870239, 0.05404663, -0.012184143, 0.057434082, -0.021591187, -0.030593872, 0.016342163, 0.010658264, 0.024002075, -0.0021362305, 0.019195557, -0.05895996, -0.033081055, -0.0042648315, 0.015312195, -0.035736084, -0.030700684, 0.012817383, 0.023452759, 0.03439331, 0.0038776398, -0.014091492, 0.014228821, -0.03982544, -0.01222229, -0.0056266785, -0.0033187866, -0.038513184, 0.010696411, -0.0011234283, 0.023391724, -0.027740479, 0.030441284, -0.036224365, 0.027755737, -0.03665161, -0.018661499, -0.0061302185, -0.072143555, -0.006214142, 0.015235901, 0.031555176, 0.013618469, 0.022949219, 0.016708374, 0.02658081, 0.026443481, 0.02798462, 0.004016876, 0.006175995, -0.008399963, -0.024978638, 0.0015544891, 0.046020508, -0.0066223145, 0.01285553, 0.010681152, -0.023361206, -0.056610107, 0.030899048, -0.017669678, -0.032440186, -0.038726807, -0.0025539398, 0.025756836, 0.043060303, 0.013084412, 0.019638062, -0.03125, -0.028259277, 0.01449585, -0.015151978, -0.0015258789, 0.03387451, 0.023849487, -0.02696228, -0.014907837, 0.04724121, -0.03604126, -0.0068092346, 0.015853882, 0.002418518, -0.016616821, 0.034851074, 0.0057296753, -0.060058594, -0.041870117, 0.007511139, 0.02507019, -0.00447464, 0.00022220612, -0.04272461, -0.0051345825, -0.037902832, -0.055877686, -0.0703125, -0.024719238, 0.008163452, 0.03366089, -0.015701294, 0.028518677, 0.009506226, -0.052490234, 0.014175415, 0.0003004074, -0.025665283, 0.022781372, -0.0015716553, 0.0021018982, -0.0074310303, 0.05847168, 0.016174316, -0.011543274, 0.0041999817, -0.059143066, 0.0340271, 0.0019006729, -0.005554199, 0.0005750656, -0.019256592, 0.009056091, 0.023391724, -0.008674622, -0.0072746277, 0.00869751, 0.033599854, 0.031707764, 0.00095176697, 0.0025997162, 0.060028076, -0.041809082, -0.042663574, -0.0088272095, -0.006614685, -0.040405273, 0.045440674, 0.009262085, -0.02015686, -0.03753662, -0.06896973, -0.047943115, -0.0032215118, 0.053619385, 0.027374268, 0.06896973, 0.005569458, 0.037902832, -0.03265381, -0.030349731, -0.042633057, 0.04397583, -0.004600525, -0.026641846, 0.024993896, -0.03427124, 0.003250122, -0.055023193, 0.035308838, 0.016860962, 0.017333984, -0.034973145, -0.041534424, -0.0019035339, -0.042297363, -0.0030021667, 0.035888672, 0.04296875, -0.02418518, 0.045318604, -0.02645874, 0.036071777, 0.020233154, 0.044403076, 0.019317627, 0.01033783, 0.012130737, 0.008834839, -0.0015592575, -0.030288696, 0.031677246, -0.04852295, 0.011367798, -0.053527832, -0.018966675, -0.11218262, 0.02355957, 0.015792847, 0.009788513, -0.0066871643, 0.008895874, 0.028823853, 0.02545166, 0.023757935, -0.039123535, 0.041534424, 0.0121154785, 0.0037994385, -0.026672363, 0.021728516, 0.0143966675, 0.03717041, 0.029190063, 0.01449585, 0.014602661, -0.032226562, 0.04095459, 0.01939392, -0.008262634, -0.013206482, 0.00033473969, -0.044830322, 0.013694763, -0.018341064, -0.011199951, 0.059387207, 0.040771484, 0.01109314, -0.024429321, 0.016220093, -0.0012226105, -0.040649414, 0.01776123, 0.014472961, -0.028457642, -0.00052022934, -0.047332764, -0.0011882782, 0.0010309219, 0.021636963, 0.022415161, -0.072753906, -0.03753662, 0.014144897, 0.028884888, 0.00504303, 0.0105896, -0.027786255, -0.017532349, 0.020019531, 0.0234375, 0.00048971176, 0.020645142, 0.00944519, 0.011756897, -0.036193848, -0.01474762, 0.00013494492, 0.031051636, -0.0340271, 0.026428223, -0.055511475, 0.025436401, -0.006450653, -0.034301758, 0.010795593, 0.010063171, -0.0340271, -0.015853882, 0.07763672, 0.047576904, 0.049865723, 0.072143555, 0.019454956, -0.009750366, 0.03591919, -0.050750732, 0.006668091, 0.04559326, -0.038879395, 0.01424408, -0.023757935, -0.027511597, 0.030685425, -0.026672363, 0.014976501, 0.0046806335, 0.04837036, -0.007270813, -0.011482239, 0.009925842, -0.04522705, 0.05368042, 0.017715454, -0.042388916, 0.0026397705, 0.037322998, -0.01171875, -0.008232117, -0.019515991, 0.0069465637, 0.0060310364, -0.014480591, -0.02381897, -0.010093689, -0.03475952, -0.003791809, -0.046661377, 0.018493652, 0.017044067, -0.008514404, -0.0124053955, -0.0029125214, 0.008018494, -0.019699097, -0.0037899017, -0.028121948, -0.03253174, -0.031433105, 0.00579834, 0.0030593872, -0.027435303, -0.03439331, 0.04324341, -0.004016876, -0.021591187, -0.026260376, 0.044830322, -0.037719727, -0.025039673, -0.0024738312, -0.029022217, 0.044677734, 0.026672363, -0.0048828125, 0.013542175, 0.019363403, -0.019729614, -0.0026378632, 0.014755249, 0.046844482, -0.013931274, -0.066345215, 0.027160645, 0.048553467, 0.055633545, -0.00793457, 0.035614014, 0.049224854, 0.010047913, -0.013549805, 0.06384277, 0.023040771, 0.018249512, -0.00010728836, 0.026641846, 0.006000519, -0.034851074, -0.020004272, -0.026321411, 0.051239014, 0.049713135, -0.019210815, -0.017364502, 0.022125244, 0.01789856, -0.0015583038, 0.035491943, -0.02998352, -0.000079751015, -0.0058135986, 0.009559631, -0.009284973, -0.003528595, 0.01979065, -0.026641846, 0.016906738, 0.035980225, -0.027053833, -0.011581421, -0.017532349, 0.033416748, -0.009902954, -0.024612427, 0.021499634, 0.016998291, 0.022598267, 0.040618896, -0.041778564, -0.010910034, -0.03744507, -0.010719299, 0.003829956, -0.0063476562, 0.02973938, -0.0064811707, 0.049041748, -0.049194336, -0.03857422, 0.013519287, -0.03466797, 0.02607727, -0.04562378, 0.04360962, -0.04925537, 0.010513306, -0.003206253, 0.013595581, 0.049041748, -0.032318115, -0.04699707, -0.1126709, 0.066223145, -0.020324707 ], "summary": [ 0.018218994, 0.019210815, -0.014198303, -0.014533997, 0.017471313, -0.020568848, 0.017562866, -0.029312134, -0.02861023, 0.015991211, -0.042633057, 0.03866577, -0.017929077, -0.0020332336, 0.009284973, -0.04763794, 0.0061912537, 0.02748108, 0.053833008, -0.015701294, -0.003074646, -0.0015211105, 0.036590576, 0.0070533752, 0.037353516, -0.025436401, -0.035461426, 0.015991211, 0.026565552, 0.013572693, 0.027420044, -0.010154724, -0.016342163, 0.06964111, -0.013122559, 0.0054130554, -0.023864746, 0.044921875, 0.030288696, 0.01638794, 0.0023555756, 0.013809204, 0.046539307, 0.013175964, -0.009925842, 0.008102417, -0.025939941, -0.045837402, 0.0028152466, 0.08258057, 0.0009422302, 0.02607727, -0.028778076, 0.111694336, -0.024627686, -0.05758667, -0.03778076, -0.01625061, 0.04272461, 0.05267334, 0.014656067, -0.042755127, -0.0012292862, -0.058135986, -0.009773254, -0.010665894, -0.008453369, 0.0057525635, 0.011245728, -0.0072898865, 0.01576233, 0.013122559, 0.044708252, -0.02279663, -0.017608643, -0.027755737, 0.03692627, -0.01838684, -0.0012693405, -0.020248413, 0.012023926, -0.013946533, -0.045196533, 0.0047302246, -0.0034942627, 0.019073486, -0.01424408, -0.01612854, 0.016494751, 0.015327454, 0.0027236938, 0.004283905, -0.016021729, 0.052947998, 0.008270264, -0.023605347, -0.004508972, 0.011741638, -0.00983429, -0.0042419434, -0.011634827, -0.025802612, 0.006336212, -0.024856567, -0.028823853, 0.019515991, 0.010223389, -0.02809143, -0.0154800415, 0.015731812, -0.02407837, -0.024887085, 0.0009098053, -0.03253174, -0.0019216537, 0.009529114, -0.0053977966, 0.036743164, 0.009933472, 0.011428833, 0.005493164, 0.029632568, -0.04815674, 0.033477783, 0.047576904, 0.04537964, 0.01184082, -0.009918213, -0.013259888, 0.021331787, -0.013809204, 0.023330688, -0.017349243, -0.018463135, -0.020050049, -0.0090408325, 0.0041999817, 0.017486572, 0.01876831, -0.0154953, 0.019378662, -0.026626587, 0.0078086853, 0.04498291, -0.022155762, 0.021514893, 0.02041626, 0.0032196045, -0.020599365, -0.041046143, 0.0070724487, 0.012252808, 0.02885437, 0.0013666153, -0.014007568, -0.018218994, 0.0014915466, -0.01109314, 0.00033640862, -0.027832031, 0.04284668, -0.016647339, -0.022018433, 0.103149414, 0.032104492, 0.046020508, 0.037200928, -0.00541687, 0.009552002, 0.041656494, 0.01979065, -0.012504578, -0.054840088, 0.0041618347, 0.0029850006, 0.002702713, 0.008850098, 0.030883789, 0.034118652, -0.031921387, -0.014411926, -0.015792847, 0.060150146, -0.0012636185, -0.019897461, 0.010375977, -0.010002136, 0.035308838, 0.024230957, 0.008026123, -0.0041885376, 0.005935669, -0.019683838, -0.02357483, -0.013252258, -0.0022621155, -0.014312744, 0.009017944, -0.0008916855, -0.02468872, 0.017913818, 0.02696228, -0.028015137, -0.0118637085, -0.06518555, 0.013870239, -0.015579224, 0.042297363, -0.053588867, 0.005748749, 0.04147339, -0.034820557, -0.029174805, 0.046783447, 0.019302368, -0.029571533, 0.010414124, -0.0036354065, 0.009246826, -0.020126343, -0.026412964, 0.028259277, -0.023132324, -0.01008606, 0.029403687, 0.006008148, -0.022033691, -0.00024580956, 0.05569458, 0.007896423, 0.06903076, -0.010879517, -0.034820557, -0.043670654, -0.047180176, -0.02772522, -0.035369873, -0.08758545, 0.029006958, 0.08831787, 0.016494751, 0.019943237, -0.031066895, -0.011306763, -0.01058197, -0.0082473755, 0.02734375, -0.030838013, -0.03387451, 0.008201599, 0.059173584, 0.0284729, -0.011138916, -0.032287598, 0.016311646, 0.02406311, -0.019332886, -0.014930725, -0.027297974, -0.0002734661, 0.01109314, -0.016448975, -0.011741638, 0.010276794, -0.07531738, -0.04446411, -0.0362854, -0.042877197, 0.026290894, -0.0473938, 0.023040771, -0.04360962, 0.00039982796, -0.023834229, -0.02734375, -0.07720947, -0.019210815, 0.0390625, 0.016189575, -0.0524292, -0.03552246, 0.017944336, -0.016723633, -0.028427124, -0.0053482056, -0.008399963, 0.0000769496, -0.03753662, 0.023925781, 0.05368042, 0.06390381, 0.034698486, 0.011108398, 0.0035648346, 0.0032844543, 0.001786232, -0.0014410019, 0.05947876, -0.016860962, -0.014625549, -0.030395508, 0.012367249, -0.0112838745, -0.025894165, 0.004058838, 0.013916016, -0.027572632, 0.005016327, 0.0037441254, 0.0022830963, -0.060699463, 0.03149414, 0.022445679, -0.010307312, -0.01802063, -0.021621704, -0.023727417, 0.01134491, -0.016052246, 0.07104492, 0.11071777, -0.009475708, 0.002790451, 0.011024475, -0.009925842, -0.049804688, 0.040161133, -0.033325195, -0.0034332275, -0.0073547363, -0.08679199, -0.049621582, -0.07550049, 0.034729004, -0.0043907166, 0.018127441, -0.00011438131, 0.027618408, 0.01084137, 0.01537323, 0.04849243, 0.0027008057, 0.016555786, -0.012382507, -0.097839355, 0.020950317, -0.016464233, -0.0032043457, -0.08081055, -0.03567505, 0.07208252, -0.021316528, -0.021362305, -0.010398865, 0.032592773, -0.008140564, -0.00818634, 0.015045166, 0.03253174, -0.048919678, 0.06549072, 0.02645874, 0.026000977, -0.10443115, -0.06628418, -0.021743774, -0.009712219, -0.02456665, 0.05770874, 0.05908203, -0.020996094, 0.058929443, -0.052703857, -0.0033569336, 0.021957397, -0.00299263, 0.10760498, -0.0055351257, -0.0096206665, 0.06536865, 0.00013554096, 0.016616821, -0.01864624, 0.003900528, 0.021621704, 0.0017318726, -0.0038166046, 0.00058078766, 0.04534912, 0.0010690689, 0.010307312, 0.005340576, 0.054748535, -0.033172607, -0.0031528473, -0.0043525696, 0.03137207, 0.03857422, 0.053588867, -0.03488159, 0.070251465, -0.017471313, -0.014389038, -0.0051879883, 0.019058228, -0.048950195, 0.066467285, 0.0017786026, 0.023361206, -0.039154053, 0.00674057, -0.024032593, 0.012466431, -0.045074463, -0.00018191338, -0.055877686, 0.030975342, 0.006084442, -0.009941101, -0.046844482, 0.008995056, 0.01776123, -0.001042366, -0.010650635, 0.020050049, 0.047088623, 0.004508972, -0.022583008, 0.018051147, 0.066467285, 0.03338623, -0.005519867, -0.0038852692, -0.0056991577, -0.082458496, -0.044525146, 0.011131287, 0.023849487, 0.06555176, -0.053710938, -0.08581543, 0.005634308, 0.017105103, -0.0015068054, 0.013298035, -0.015914917, 0.022735596, -0.059295654, 0.005718231, 0.04425049, -0.018112183, -0.001241684, 0.024383545, 0.014518738, -0.0184021, 0.019210815, -0.008415222, 0.017669678, 0.0021953583, 0.0178833, 0.009437561, 0.020828247, -0.017822266, -0.0118255615, 0.019561768, 0.028900146, -0.0043754578, 0.011390686, -0.040527344, 0.026107788, 0.01411438, -0.028671265, -0.030151367, -0.012184143, 0.023803711, -0.020019531, -0.015716553, 0.029525757, 0.0014867783, -0.005908966, -0.08459473, 0.04446411, -0.09063721, -0.037872314, -0.05758667, 0.017089844, -0.022598267, -0.026443481, 0.0056266785, 0.0029964447, -0.020721436, -0.020080566, 0.043670654, -0.027008057, 0.016052246, 0.01626587, -0.017990112, 0.050811768, -0.0030174255, -0.07849121, 0.064453125, -0.036743164, 0.009735107, 0.029678345, -0.05065918, 0.019500732, -0.015930176, -0.020019531, -0.01184845, -0.054840088, -0.023025513, -0.04901123, 0.04724121, 0.040802002, -0.026626587, 0.021850586, -0.014389038, 0.048919678, -0.0423584, -0.011390686, 0.03010559, 0.05480957, -0.037384033, -0.0023384094, 0.043792725, -0.015411377, -0.038879395, 0.031311035, 0.018936157, -0.010658264, 0.015457153, 0.021728516, 0.023956299, 0.04510498, -0.02696228, -0.037017822, -0.007335663, -0.036071777, 0.012748718, 0.053741455, -0.008903503, -0.011955261, 0.017868042, 0.03503418, 0.021453857, -0.030853271, -0.0034828186, -0.032714844, -0.039733887, -0.035827637, -0.0038547516, 0.005947113, -0.044067383, -0.025756836, 0.009422302, -0.006839752, 0.0033187866, 0.005996704, -0.0206604, -0.028533936, -0.012535095, 0.00617218, -0.015853882, 0.006702423, 0.0038032532, 0.024658203, -0.0029411316, -0.02507019, -0.018966675, 0.026550293, -0.029403687, 0.0042762756, 0.018600464, -0.080566406, 0.0057029724, -0.07232666, -0.00063610077, 0.020095825, 0.0035095215, -0.011543274, 0.024780273, -0.023117065, -0.030807495, -0.053985596, -0.034301758, -0.028442383, 0.055664062, -0.045043945, -0.030273438, -0.043701172, 0.018692017, 0.015487671, -0.007484436, -0.041900635, 0.015396118, -0.016906738, 0.029083252, 0.020248413, 0.04309082, 0.0259552, -0.014266968, 0.017913818, 0.019943237, -0.009246826, -0.0038852692, 0.01965332, -0.049926758, 0.050598145, 0.011077881, 0.03933716, -0.015838623, -0.051696777, 0.031951904, 0.008552551, 0.031799316, 0.007270813, 0.030075073, -0.023345947, 0.024124146, 0.010940552, 0.054382324, 0.019958496, 0.055755615, 0.048858643, 0.032806396, -0.011474609, -0.044799805, 0.024353027, 0.0082092285, 0.018615723, 0.01725769, -0.00026202202, -0.024612427, -0.013435364, 0.036193848, 0.018478394, -0.0042648315, -0.0058517456, -0.0011062622, 0.009902954, 0.029129028, -0.0074653625, -0.03805542, -0.0054969788, -0.040893555, 0.0014820099, -0.019851685, -0.027938843, -0.0014867783, -0.026000977, 0.027679443, 0.021469116, -0.010040283, 0.018173218, 0.017333984, 0.009674072, -0.045440674, -0.02394104, -0.0039405823, -0.057861328, -0.09863281, -0.043395996, 0.0011529922, -0.019256592, 0.07183838, 0.018203735, 0.033691406, 0.022018433, 0.025375366, 0.0070610046, -0.012329102, 0.010635376, -0.04034424, -0.01737976, 0.013763428, 0.0070648193, 0.00299263, 0.010902405, -0.019943237, -0.035461426, 0.0073242188, -0.03353882, -0.030700684, -0.047302246, 0.030136108, 0.05795288, 0.030929565, 0.0005016327, 0.009994507, -0.021530151, -0.027297974, 0.0053634644, -0.009635925, -0.0027370453, 0.034698486, 0.016403198, -0.0049324036, -0.0028362274, 0.035614014, -0.048706055, -0.003419876, 0.023834229, -0.0070381165, 0.0003914833, 0.0022735596, -0.011054993, -0.072143555, -0.02229309, 0.00843811, 0.046661377, -0.027359009, -0.027832031, -0.03326416, 0.0020999908, -0.031234741, -0.019470215, -0.042297363, -0.032226562, -0.010421753, 0.045715332, -0.02268982, 0.041900635, 0.018173218, -0.06665039, 0.015342712, -0.034088135, -0.017303467, -0.009719849, -0.025772095, -0.027023315, 0.0020923615, 0.020233154, -0.0009946823, -0.020095825, 0.003572464, -0.03677368, 0.03326416, 0.027023315, -0.006729126, 0.010444641, 0.008583069, -0.005958557, 0.030776978, -0.030548096, -0.020721436, 0.007572174, 0.013328552, -0.014076233, 0.008148193, -0.0076408386, 0.04336548, -0.01096344, -0.053222656, -0.023727417, 0.010574341, -0.055236816, -0.014030457, 0.025604248, -0.009269714, -0.0059547424, -0.030197144, -0.00945282, -0.012687683, 0.018325806, -0.00009846687, 0.034942627, 0.033203125, 0.027160645, -0.009315491, -0.033081055, -0.028121948, 0.034851074, -0.020553589, -0.026916504, 0.039978027, -0.03945923, 0.0037212372, -0.009155273, 0.0041389465, -0.0034675598, -0.0016908646, 0.017745972, -0.012435913, 0.015411377, -0.037353516, 0.04940796, 0.031097412, 0.044647217, -0.02168274, 0.011070251, 0.020065308, 0.024505615, 0.009407043, -0.034332275, -0.01966858, 0.00028967857, 0.010192871, 0.004131317, -0.028717041, -0.013656616, 0.060424805, -0.011177063, -0.046661377, -0.057739258, -0.058288574, -0.043395996, 0.02609253, -0.0035266876, -0.0019130707, 0.011238098, 0.0076408386, 0.026016235, 0.034484863, -0.033050537, -0.032226562, 0.001791954, -0.011672974, -0.0075569153, -0.023910522, -0.0039749146, 0.017242432, 0.044555664, 0.008369446, 0.017044067, 0.034698486, -0.01084137, 0.072265625, -0.054138184, -0.0066719055, -0.04321289, 0.010215759, -0.044189453, 0.025054932, 0.0075187683, -0.0035972595, 0.043884277, 0.00025987625, 0.08251953, -0.04928589, 0.021316528, 0.025817871, -0.026809692, 0.022109985, -0.0037822723, 0.014877319, -0.02671814, -0.0423584, -0.010826111, 0.025985718, 0.020187378, 0.044555664, -0.060577393, -0.026428223, 0.00060606, 0.005908966, -0.0146865845, 0.017166138, -0.029342651, 0.004901886, 0.039733887, 0.0011768341, 0.0009326935, 0.00365448, 0.000054061413, -0.014816284, -0.008506775, 0.0146865845, -0.008735657, 0.03753662, -0.020477295, 0.016448975, -0.03555298, 0.030838013, 0.015670776, -0.018325806, 0.009422302, 0.038909912, -0.012626648, 0.02268982, 0.09588623, 0.07873535, 0.07495117, 0.050872803, -0.015823364, -0.0012073517, 0.099121094, -0.03338623, 0.002609253, 0.030044556, -0.01108551, -0.030090332, 0.0009031296, 0.016052246, -0.009773254, 0.029174805, -0.023773193, 0.036743164, 0.061309814, -0.015434265, -0.032226562, -0.028869629, -0.036621094, 0.12475586, 0.0032901764, -0.015686035, 0.00831604, 0.035858154, -0.029815674, 0.019424438, -0.02923584, -0.0027503967, 0.012702942, -0.006626129, -0.0011291504, 0.009422302, 0.016784668, -0.007369995, -0.022125244, 0.030349731, 0.009597778, -0.035949707, 0.019638062, -0.013587952, 0.033447266, -0.030227661, -0.014060974, -0.04940796, 0.0103302, -0.019500732, -0.006324768, 0.0011339188, -0.028762817, -0.04345703, 0.048217773, -0.000018000603, -0.019226074, 0.022140503, 0.019363403, 0.0076675415, -0.02998352, 0.010559082, -0.02154541, 0.0020103455, -0.022521973, -0.00566864, 0.023910522, 0.0043563843, -0.033447266, 0.016143799, 0.027297974, 0.04724121, -0.020080566, -0.08514404, 0.026016235, 0.025939941, 0.06298828, 0.037841797, 0.06719971, 0.064086914, -0.03274536, -0.007972717, 0.03277588, 0.01890564, 0.024414062, -0.0014781952, 0.029037476, -0.007904053, -0.021881104, 0.007007599, -0.0016708374, 0.05496216, 0.017807007, -0.033416748, 0.012184143, 0.005607605, -0.0140686035, -0.0052108765, 0.010948181, -0.023605347, -0.0181427, -0.010215759, -0.014541626, -0.013633728, -0.008033752, 0.028915405, -0.02557373, 0.011787415, 0.0055885315, -0.007129669, -0.0068969727, -0.027069092, 0.03616333, 0.038024902, 0.016677856, -0.030288696, -0.01600647, 0.039123535, 0.021865845, -0.021026611, -0.039215088, 0.008712769, 0.006752014, 0.008811951, 0.015571594, 0.0031967163, -0.008544922, 0.0002065897, -0.05050659, -0.00762558, 0.0034751892, -0.030029297, 0.018707275, -0.042053223, 0.030548096, -0.032348633, 0.0016441345, 0.025970459, 0.016708374, 0.07836914, 0.020507812, -0.005065918, -0.06359863, 0.03503418, 0.0012397766 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2101.05555v2
Non-intrusive Surrogate Modeling for Parametrized Time-dependent PDEs using Convolutional Autoencoders
Stefanos Nikolopoulos, Ioannis Kalogeris, Vissarion Papadopoulos
math.NA, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NA
This work presents a non-intrusive surrogate modeling scheme based on machine learning technology for predictive modeling of complex systems, described by parametrized time-dependent PDEs. For these problems, typical finite element approaches involve the spatiotemporal discretization of the PDE and the solution of the corresponding linear system of equations at each time step. Instead, the proposed method utilizes a convolutional autoencoder in conjunction with a feed forward neural network to establish a low-cost and accurate mapping from the problem's parametric space to its solution space. For this purpose, time history response data are collected by solving the high-fidelity model via FEM for a reduced set of parameter values. Then, by applying the convolutional autoencoder to this data set, a low-dimensional representation of the high-dimensional solution matrices is provided by the encoder, while the reconstruction map is obtained by the decoder. Using the latent representation given by the encoder, a feed-forward neural network is efficiently trained to map points from the problem's parametric space to the compressed version of the respective solution matrices. This way, the encoded response of the system at new parameter values is given by the neural network, while the entire response is delivered by the decoder. This approach effectively bypasses the need to serially formulate and solve the system's governing equations at each time increment, thus resulting in a significant cost reduction and rendering the method ideal for problems requiring repeated model evaluations or 'real-time' computations. The elaborated methodology is demonstrated on the stochastic analysis of time-dependent PDEs solved with the Monte Carlo method, however, it can be straightforwardly applied to other similar-type problems, such as sensitivity analysis, design optimization, etc.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2101.05555v2
"2021-04-23T09:53:13"
"2021-01-14T11:34:58"
{ "title": [ 0.030273438, 0.003835678, -0.0037727356, -0.045654297, -0.0038394928, -0.0018815994, -0.027114868, -0.027709961, -0.03741455, 0.03829956, 0.031799316, -0.007118225, 0.017700195, -0.04650879, -0.001124382, 0.007255554, -0.0003504753, 0.02178955, -0.021972656, -0.031204224, -0.014541626, -0.048065186, 0.034851074, 0.039520264, -0.0006341934, -0.007896423, -0.08648682, 0.02609253, -0.023162842, -0.00020313263, -0.008522034, 0.005027771, 0.006450653, 0.046203613, 0.029647827, 0.029251099, -0.043914795, 0.066101074, 0.06085205, -0.01411438, 0.019485474, -0.0067367554, -0.0110321045, -0.058502197, -0.01524353, 0.032928467, -0.034576416, -0.022903442, -0.0041236877, 0.06097412, 0.0060653687, -0.043060303, -0.011558533, 0.050933838, -0.012374878, -0.040222168, -0.03488159, 0.000052332878, 0.036071777, 0.029312134, 0.015159607, -0.05206299, 0.035186768, 0.0124053955, -0.044525146, -0.013458252, -0.0345459, 0.018920898, 0.07141113, -0.003211975, -0.029953003, 0.019607544, 0.006187439, 0.013900757, -0.06463623, -0.014457703, 0.03829956, 0.009025574, 0.048950195, -0.049591064, 0.024398804, 0.011749268, 0.020339966, 0.015014648, -0.023513794, -0.0026016235, -0.017807007, -0.030212402, -0.011787415, -0.048980713, -0.008995056, -0.04647827, -0.01524353, 0.04647827, 0.004211426, -0.045074463, -0.013404846, -0.019760132, 0.0012617111, 0.025817871, -0.018814087, -0.010787964, 0.043701172, -0.03112793, 0.016082764, 0.0418396, -0.038970947, -0.06555176, 0.0051193237, 0.024673462, 0.011436462, -0.03253174, 0.039398193, -0.0028152466, 0.015411377, -0.021957397, 0.008613586, 0.045776367, 0.019073486, 0.012283325, 0.018630981, 0.019119263, 0.023025513, -0.043121338, 0.02243042, -0.01637268, -0.03878784, -0.01939392, 0.028213501, 0.026382446, -0.057128906, 0.030929565, -0.0038223267, -0.04058838, -0.020248413, 0.015510559, 0.012817383, -0.022598267, -0.02268982, 0.006290436, 0.008628845, -0.0541687, -0.04260254, -0.017730713, -0.0075531006, 0.032470703, 0.034057617, -0.0032596588, -0.033416748, -0.06677246, 0.0070114136, -0.0070533752, 0.051605225, 0.009536743, -0.093322754, 0.0046310425, -0.04888916, -0.026992798, -0.01902771, -0.049957275, 0.015808105, -0.03186035, -0.032440186, 0.049804688, 0.0501709, 0.022415161, 0.010803223, 0.015357971, 0.023025513, 0.104003906, -0.041992188, 0.007507324, 0.01473999, -0.0021629333, -0.020050049, 0.00831604, 0.017105103, -0.0020694733, 0.030731201, -0.02468872, 0.03326416, -0.00011920929, 0.03579712, 0.0418396, -0.024353027, -0.04837036, -0.023849487, -0.019546509, 0.07879639, 0.020431519, -0.08325195, -0.026611328, -0.04144287, -0.0231781, -0.051513672, -0.024597168, 0.040527344, 0.020980835, -0.0042762756, 0.024261475, -0.046813965, 0.004573822, -0.014923096, 0.06542969, 0.03564453, 0.019256592, -0.002603531, 0.010368347, -0.007270813, 0.04736328, 0.02583313, 0.0107803345, -0.024551392, -0.020935059, 0.0028686523, -0.020523071, 0.02796936, 0.0020599365, -0.025482178, 0.008522034, -0.04055786, -0.03652954, -0.006389618, 0.08178711, 0.0074882507, -0.019546509, 0.019683838, -0.03186035, 0.065979004, 0.012077332, 0.07299805, -0.04727173, -0.014320374, -0.02116394, -0.019485474, 0.017486572, -0.016220093, -0.025253296, -0.02015686, 0.01449585, 0.014480591, -0.0057411194, 0.0046958923, 0.027008057, 0.076293945, 0.019210815, 0.012680054, -0.0066947937, 0.0090408325, -0.010353088, 0.059906006, 0.008995056, 0.053955078, -0.020980835, 0.03579712, 0.05114746, 0.004005432, 0.022949219, -0.0046310425, 0.0025253296, 0.013061523, 0.023101807, -0.014564514, -0.0042800903, -0.018722534, -0.028213501, -0.01084137, 0.014564514, 0.0075263977, -0.03060913, 0.030670166, 0.012763977, 0.019805908, -0.008544922, -0.03515625, -0.014404297, -0.020339966, 0.019424438, 0.019180298, -0.027740479, 0.0063056946, 0.031097412, 0.072387695, -0.0076065063, 0.029663086, -0.00793457, 0.009849548, -0.0151901245, 0.026916504, 0.032806396, 0.06939697, 0.00034475327, -0.0018825531, -0.003686905, 0.0044403076, -0.021408081, 0.02949524, 0.07312012, -0.022659302, 0.01158905, -0.064575195, -0.008529663, 0.01612854, -0.052947998, 0.0025024414, 0.03591919, 0.0039520264, -0.01979065, -0.03463745, 0.008628845, -0.062683105, 0.007911682, -0.008384705, -0.00819397, -0.04284668, -0.050689697, 0.0042762756, -0.015563965, -0.020736694, -0.019302368, 0.05331421, -0.0031833649, -0.023880005, -0.0034770966, -0.00010615587, -0.027618408, -0.006626129, -0.030639648, -0.0069847107, -0.014572144, -0.018081665, -0.032989502, -0.070129395, -0.0034370422, -0.01701355, 0.013153076, -0.017181396, 0.02557373, -0.016159058, 0.021118164, 0.030471802, 0.0068740845, 0.037475586, -0.014015198, -0.0071640015, -0.02142334, 0.014198303, 0.010765076, -0.015007019, 0.018341064, 0.011695862, -0.011772156, -0.05090332, 0.014259338, 0.02571106, -0.0045433044, 0.036376953, 0.018615723, 0.017074585, -0.01448822, 0.032409668, 0.021087646, -0.0077590942, -0.043762207, 0.01134491, -0.059692383, -0.024505615, -0.02079773, -0.0013227463, 0.054260254, -0.055114746, 0.0054130554, -0.029937744, -0.016403198, 0.0035800934, 0.028656006, -0.0141067505, -0.037078857, 0.0012378693, -0.009857178, 0.03048706, 0.038024902, -0.048980713, 0.0020122528, 0.083618164, -0.022583008, 0.007472992, 0.043151855, 0.027114868, 0.0034599304, -0.031280518, -0.027435303, 0.0231781, -0.012321472, 0.007118225, -0.0141067505, -0.025650024, 0.013969421, -0.08477783, 0.010047913, 0.070007324, 0.0074310303, -0.024230957, 0.023757935, -0.053344727, 0.051483154, 0.029418945, 0.004180908, 0.020721436, -0.00045967102, -0.00077342987, -0.0143966675, 0.009483337, -0.057861328, 0.0184021, -0.05050659, -0.05178833, 0.01991272, -0.017303467, -0.04373169, -0.0071754456, -0.003572464, -0.040496826, -0.013069153, 0.020385742, 0.033935547, 0.039398193, -0.0070762634, 0.022537231, 0.008926392, 0.02458191, -0.029312134, -0.021728516, -0.017364502, 0.015563965, 0.012649536, -0.020645142, -0.013748169, -0.014640808, 0.005973816, 0.0020713806, -0.022247314, -0.031829834, 0.017486572, 0.008705139, -0.05206299, -0.018127441, 0.0070877075, 0.020065308, 0.006629944, -0.024139404, -0.019088745, 0.012969971, 0.01586914, -0.019805908, 0.023071289, 0.0010004044, 0.016586304, -0.035491943, -0.024169922, -0.009376526, -0.021652222, -0.036132812, -0.0067634583, 0.043518066, -0.021270752, 0.037322998, -0.02670288, -0.013786316, 0.0126571655, -0.055023193, 0.02293396, -0.0005455017, 0.010818481, 0.00051116943, 0.008735657, -0.02482605, 0.0017318726, -0.0048713684, 0.034973145, -0.016403198, 0.0025424957, -0.054382324, -0.082092285, 0.015319824, -0.023254395, -0.03793335, 0.007675171, 0.01889038, -0.046691895, 0.003314972, -0.034576416, 0.04043579, -0.0055389404, 0.010154724, -0.046875, -0.020446777, 0.0074691772, 0.0012922287, -0.05456543, -0.05899048, 0.06933594, 0.040802002, 0.015914917, -0.028503418, -0.01272583, 0.033081055, -0.025497437, -0.0023059845, -0.034362793, 0.05621338, -0.0362854, 0.007446289, 0.047546387, -0.015022278, -0.015365601, 0.06384277, 0.06384277, -0.026367188, -0.026779175, 0.01663208, 0.028335571, 0.0039863586, 0.0635376, -0.015106201, -0.021881104, -0.05441284, -0.0138549805, -0.025787354, 0.0046653748, 0.0103302, 0.015045166, 0.024963379, 0.0026435852, 0.027053833, -0.0012559891, -0.022476196, -0.014320374, 0.04159546, -0.010658264, -0.005508423, -0.0019874573, -0.0064468384, 0.030258179, 0.018157959, 0.043884277, 0.0335083, 0.05899048, -0.047698975, 0.013626099, -0.048675537, -0.0057296753, 0.034240723, 0.010978699, -0.06311035, 0.008804321, 0.008369446, -0.002714157, -0.010063171, 0.062561035, 0.0055160522, 0.021072388, -0.043182373, 0.0009689331, 0.023757935, 0.032989502, -0.06530762, -0.08380127, 0.0031719208, -0.022354126, -0.050598145, -0.047576904, 0.022079468, -0.011276245, 0.02229309, -0.011009216, -0.019104004, 0.020812988, 0.011978149, 0.051574707, 0.047180176, -0.03314209, -0.07733154, -0.025970459, -0.01876831, -0.033447266, 0.008995056, -0.0054779053, -0.028335571, -0.05557251, 0.0055999756, 0.010467529, -0.014549255, 0.025390625, 0.022109985, -0.02368164, 0.08685303, -0.03100586, 0.047912598, 0.003917694, 0.020935059, 0.00033640862, 0.0052833557, -0.032562256, -0.023742676, -0.009559631, 0.04067993, -0.016464233, -0.0064735413, 0.02835083, -0.00687027, -0.04434204, 0.04949951, -0.004627228, 0.03552246, 0.032196045, -0.02116394, 0.030319214, 0.026306152, 0.0014915466, 0.0418396, 0.0070381165, 0.053009033, 0.017333984, 0.025283813, -0.036834717, 0.02027893, 0.032318115, -0.009407043, -0.0050697327, 0.021697998, 0.011024475, -0.062316895, -0.09710693, 0.0017032623, 0.05911255, 0.011062622, 0.022918701, 0.027359009, -0.012908936, -0.010910034, 0.0546875, 0.041229248, 0.015930176, 0.0032749176, -0.03378296, 0.009338379, -0.018722534, -0.04421997, -0.0012321472, -0.003047943, -0.0013961792, -0.019607544, -0.007369995, -0.051696777, -0.0025253296, 0.0013341904, 0.003490448, 0.01727295, -0.043945312, 0.026123047, 0.07165527, -0.028869629, 0.0078125, 0.024047852, 0.017333984, 0.032928467, 0.044525146, 0.024795532, 0.00089788437, 0.021987915, 0.019943237, 0.006263733, -0.021408081, 0.0036296844, 0.043029785, -0.022018433, 0.015098572, 0.027694702, -0.028152466, 0.027282715, -0.004585266, -0.07434082, 0.044555664, -0.044158936, 0.010719299, 0.007369995, 0.014205933, 0.02545166, -0.04321289, 0.021408081, 0.023468018, -0.023071289, -0.05279541, 0.027526855, -0.027633667, -0.048339844, -0.008216858, 0.015434265, 0.0028419495, 0.0093307495, 0.008392334, 0.014518738, -0.042419434, 0.012062073, 0.0011320114, -0.05545044, 0.016143799, 0.019256592, 0.0395813, 0.03100586, -0.014022827, -0.037506104, -0.0064697266, -0.007835388, -0.03277588, -0.030090332, 0.02520752, 0.006477356, 0.0027751923, 0.010871887, 0.01977539, 0.006958008, -0.022079468, 0.012565613, 0.005428314, -0.008033752, 0.062683105, -0.0030345917, -0.0011587143, 0.021377563, -0.04586792, 0.0104522705, 0.017227173, 0.004524231, -0.070373535, 0.024887085, -0.009849548, 0.01638794, 0.035888672, -0.032714844, 0.018203735, 0.02357483, 0.009864807, -0.06384277, -0.0036201477, 0.010826111, -0.07067871, -0.040130615, -0.04901123, 0.038909912, -0.028259277, -0.03164673, -0.031433105, -0.010025024, -0.050933838, 0.034210205, -0.02798462, -0.03878784, -0.021987915, -0.024780273, 0.005252838, 0.0033512115, 0.005821228, 0.028121948, 0.04031372, -0.045898438, -0.024032593, -0.022720337, -0.0152282715, -0.031433105, 0.03640747, 0.00015747547, -0.03201294, -0.005142212, -0.033721924, -0.031433105, -0.0069389343, 0.017562866, 0.014518738, -0.0054359436, 0.03829956, -0.02923584, -0.014877319, -0.010017395, 0.029663086, 0.025299072, 0.0057868958, -0.021514893, 0.02331543, -0.04949951, 0.04269409, 0.011436462, 0.03274536, 0.03970337, 0.038848877, -0.012336731, -0.013290405, -0.010292053, -0.046539307, 0.04827881, -0.030593872, -0.022033691, -0.08795166, -0.058685303, -0.072387695, 0.0016365051, -0.02003479, -0.017547607, 0.05908203, -0.009414673, -0.008636475, 0.0069389343, 0.0076789856, 0.047973633, 0.028747559, 0.02935791, 0.01701355, 0.018112183, -0.03378296, 0.0069847107, 0.03543091, -0.015144348, 0.013664246, 0.005809784, -0.025543213, 0.0034294128, 0.017349243, 0.01739502, -0.040100098, -0.0073432922, -0.033691406, 0.014411926, -0.022659302, -0.0062828064, 0.07739258, 0.014579773, 0.0262146, -0.026321411, 0.013092041, 0.010238647, -0.011245728, 0.0030078888, 0.045166016, -0.037109375, 0.028244019, -0.009490967, -0.023483276, 0.010559082, 0.04083252, 0.034088135, -0.007858276, -0.031707764, 0.007843018, 0.049346924, 0.05810547, -0.010620117, -0.0418396, 0.005836487, 0.0418396, 0.017349243, -0.0072402954, -0.0017881393, 0.009063721, 0.033935547, 0.0004339218, 0.007457733, 0.020309448, 0.007686615, 0.020889282, 0.03137207, -0.05239868, 0.039276123, -0.008056641, -0.039886475, 0.008926392, 0.015563965, -0.07086182, -0.025497437, 0.035614014, 0.022476196, 0.028381348, 0.062805176, 0.01727295, 0.0004222393, 0.0020065308, -0.06304932, -0.027862549, 0.026535034, -0.027359009, -0.022491455, -0.0037155151, -0.03866577, 0.011909485, -0.034698486, 0.020706177, -0.059509277, 0.01171875, -0.03074646, 0.0036296844, 0.012237549, -0.039978027, -0.043640137, -0.0158844, -0.032073975, -0.002105713, -0.02758789, -0.020355225, -0.023025513, -0.010902405, 0.026321411, 0.024108887, 0.0039405823, 0.036956787, 0.005844116, -0.08502197, 0.000017523766, -0.038604736, 0.05923462, -0.047576904, -0.02720642, -0.04260254, 0.030151367, 0.02949524, -0.0017633438, -0.0132369995, 0.019592285, -0.023544312, -0.035217285, 0.040374756, 0.032592773, -0.009979248, -0.0236969, 0.027328491, -0.013092041, -0.01939392, 0.026321411, 0.03793335, -0.017303467, -0.05935669, 0.0041885376, -0.024353027, 0.041625977, -0.023025513, -0.026016235, 0.015007019, 0.02017212, -0.029373169, 0.011474609, 0.006717682, 0.012138367, -0.027191162, -0.03439331, 0.010368347, 0.021774292, 0.05166626, -0.028045654, -0.043518066, 0.002922058, -0.008232117, -0.006690979, 0.029205322, -0.0017356873, 0.030639648, 0.028396606, 0.064453125, 0.011772156, -0.06536865, 0.039611816, -0.005680084, 0.05517578, 0.0637207, -0.031097412, 0.03277588, 0.03326416, 0.024627686, -0.0135269165, 0.028900146, -0.050964355, 0.013000488, 0.013755798, 0.026901245, -0.0284729, 0.038604736, -0.010566711, -0.019119263, 0.021377563, 0.009712219, -0.0015640259, 0.012123108, -0.033416748, 0.06793213, -0.0011882782, 0.03567505, 0.004180908, 0.01424408, 0.036956787, -0.010856628, 0.0009446144, 0.019760132, -0.015174866, -0.017120361, -0.002374649, -0.030227661, 0.010307312, -0.0099487305, 0.008575439, -0.030578613, -0.024169922, -0.017089844, -0.027450562, 0.054901123, -0.0597229, 0.020004272, -0.033355713, -0.044647217, -0.0015087128, -0.01398468, 0.017990112, -0.00015091896, -0.057128906, -0.10357666, 0.0028858185, -0.031311035 ], "summary": [ 0.044036865, 0.0045280457, 0.056610107, 0.0070991516, -0.03277588, 0.0027656555, -0.02381897, -0.06384277, -0.026977539, 0.02557373, 0.006576538, 0.01574707, 0.01927185, -0.039093018, 0.03488159, -0.01751709, 0.0003004074, 0.013076782, 0.00014650822, -0.039886475, 0.019088745, -0.038635254, 0.021865845, 0.018798828, 0.019897461, 0.013542175, -0.06317139, 0.03302002, -0.0040779114, 0.02986145, 0.0027236938, -0.043426514, -0.015586853, 0.034210205, 0.012840271, 0.031219482, -0.02029419, 0.042541504, 0.035705566, 0.0061912537, 0.018417358, -0.015991211, 0.059387207, -0.05239868, 0.023376465, 0.042022705, -0.008888245, -0.033447266, 0.025802612, 0.053466797, 0.034942627, -0.0736084, 0.024459839, 0.039520264, -0.045074463, -0.04458618, -0.040527344, -0.007232666, 0.009155273, 0.061920166, 0.037322998, -0.004032135, -0.004470825, -0.013412476, -0.03439331, -0.008979797, -0.007926941, 0.0023536682, 0.049224854, -0.027496338, -0.01902771, 0.026916504, 0.001613617, -0.02017212, -0.048950195, 0.016326904, 0.011154175, -0.009727478, 0.006511688, -0.03137207, -0.014518738, 0.027023315, 0.031921387, -0.05279541, -0.010871887, -0.03152466, -0.033569336, 0.00063085556, -0.036987305, -0.026275635, -0.025939941, -0.032043457, -0.027786255, -0.0002465248, 0.021514893, -0.047607422, 0.0033187866, -0.03189087, 0.020248413, 0.04660034, 0.023910522, -0.037017822, 0.07312012, -0.032196045, 0.0022735596, 0.0736084, -0.021697998, -0.06958008, -0.0054244995, 0.0066108704, 0.011131287, -0.059387207, 0.015609741, -0.056427002, 0.008239746, 0.05734253, 0.041534424, 0.027496338, 0.017456055, 0.018508911, 0.029144287, 0.04711914, -0.031982422, -0.0036621094, 0.012710571, -0.00088739395, 0.0059165955, -0.017791748, 0.03704834, 0.0256958, -0.060058594, -0.00522995, 0.06384277, 0.019256592, 0.01826477, -0.030639648, 0.040039062, -0.020446777, -0.013885498, -0.005683899, 0.036956787, -0.030593872, -0.05923462, 0.019882202, -0.015510559, 0.023330688, 0.011451721, 0.008758545, -0.020111084, -0.04296875, -0.00944519, 0.015182495, 0.0340271, 0.010498047, -0.035614014, -0.012001038, 0.029541016, -0.030380249, 0.0039405823, -0.049804688, 0.04940796, -0.021881104, -0.032409668, 0.08337402, 0.030181885, 0.017837524, 0.028427124, 0.00712204, 0.01626587, 0.047607422, -0.015823364, -0.009300232, 0.009048462, -0.0017576218, -0.014305115, 0.018814087, -0.01576233, 0.0060653687, 0.0023174286, 0.011772156, 0.029937744, -0.015151978, 0.016815186, 0.03704834, 0.017181396, -0.032226562, -0.018356323, -0.004722595, 0.051330566, 0.019989014, -0.06762695, -0.022750854, -0.008651733, 0.0012550354, -0.018325806, -0.025161743, -0.0038547516, 0.015296936, -0.0056266785, -0.019165039, -0.03543091, 0.007171631, -0.021057129, 0.026992798, -0.023742676, 0.014930725, -0.013450623, 0.025863647, -0.028579712, 0.032714844, 0.020767212, -0.0031108856, -0.0044937134, -0.023971558, 0.0052375793, -0.02458191, 0.023330688, -0.028717041, -0.03552246, -0.02949524, -0.062286377, 0.011955261, -0.049621582, 0.09082031, 0.009521484, -0.01134491, 0.0039863586, -0.0021915436, 0.049041748, -0.005458832, 0.06549072, -0.026977539, -0.019470215, -0.0016288757, -0.023925781, 0.020599365, 0.0050468445, -0.012039185, -0.009796143, 0.013168335, 0.033477783, 0.013656616, 0.007980347, 0.028137207, 0.064575195, -0.0022392273, 0.019363403, -0.0077819824, 0.00083589554, -0.014549255, 0.04373169, -0.03366089, 0.046051025, -0.028793335, 0.04095459, 0.022079468, -0.009391785, 0.007820129, 0.029159546, -0.019851685, 0.010314941, -0.018859863, -0.0005736351, -0.007858276, 0.023071289, -0.009529114, 0.022781372, 0.023986816, -0.0031852722, -0.030960083, -0.0012054443, 0.006958008, 0.007698059, -0.044036865, -0.10095215, -0.0063095093, -0.029220581, 0.05505371, 0.02923584, -0.02720642, 0.010353088, 0.0074005127, 0.010360718, -0.003610611, 0.03463745, 0.022064209, 0.00957489, 0.014801025, 0.058563232, 0.08508301, 0.076660156, 0.024490356, 0.01260376, 0.02558899, -0.041870117, -0.0068359375, -0.022628784, 0.042541504, -0.014678955, -0.0067443848, -0.04763794, 0.022018433, 0.009178162, -0.04724121, 0.003993988, 0.043945312, 0.011039734, -0.017547607, -0.0027599335, 0.027557373, -0.06707764, -0.009460449, 0.019943237, 0.02418518, -0.02468872, -0.026489258, -0.01914978, 0.03515625, -0.007827759, 0.012336731, 0.06555176, -0.0037975311, 0.01133728, 0.03552246, -0.01878357, -0.038604736, 0.060272217, -0.007896423, 0.018692017, -0.018539429, -0.06188965, -0.034118652, -0.06463623, 0.030929565, -0.008018494, 0.010375977, 0.0065460205, -0.0026988983, 0.0017232895, 0.0019779205, 0.041107178, 0.023147583, 0.010009766, 0.006137848, -0.025024414, 0.003211975, 0.022888184, 0.022750854, -0.040802002, -0.02545166, 0.034820557, -0.04067993, -0.040618896, 0.039764404, -0.017105103, 0.03756714, 0.0597229, 0.023529053, 0.014373779, -0.022979736, 0.016784668, 0.024536133, -0.021347046, -0.05895996, 0.012763977, -0.03387451, -0.01991272, -0.022888184, 0.025100708, 0.049224854, -0.019256592, 0.046569824, -0.06549072, -0.024475098, -0.002325058, 0.010284424, 0.06768799, 0.005847931, 0.016830444, 0.039764404, 0.06298828, 0.04800415, -0.03277588, -0.033691406, 0.04901123, -0.013084412, 0.016174316, 0.054748535, 0.024124146, 0.0010213852, -0.012458801, 0.0018262863, 0.045562744, -0.02835083, -0.016067505, -0.02494812, 0.042297363, 0.05581665, -0.0041007996, -0.021530151, 0.04446411, 0.023468018, 0.0070533752, 0.008155823, -0.029678345, 0.05328369, 0.02154541, 0.009429932, 0.010002136, -0.037322998, 0.030807495, -0.04727173, 0.0284729, -0.07354736, 0.0317688, -0.0657959, 0.023651123, 0.0017032623, -0.004436493, -0.028198242, 0.00687027, 0.02519226, 0.0152282715, 0.0077667236, 0.021850586, 0.039367676, 0.02331543, -0.022613525, 0.014976501, 0.046722412, 0.046813965, -0.023132324, -0.01939392, 0.00674057, 0.007217407, 0.01576233, -0.010093689, -0.040985107, 0.024047852, -0.035369873, 0.028381348, 0.001572609, -0.030914307, 0.013534546, -0.0024337769, -0.02909851, 0.019851685, 0.0141067505, 0.016235352, 0.018127441, -0.0012636185, -0.017486572, 0.052001953, 0.034423828, -0.015541077, 0.015594482, -0.02015686, 0.033172607, -0.0047302246, -0.002746582, 0.03744507, -0.008453369, -0.036468506, 0.01574707, 0.005256653, -0.008323669, 0.011703491, -0.00028657913, -0.028915405, 0.020904541, -0.023635864, 0.01953125, -0.004142761, -0.008003235, -0.005432129, -0.006313324, 0.009307861, 0.012916565, -0.0032291412, -0.0006170273, -0.048309326, 0.017349243, -0.04675293, -0.049621582, 0.0025119781, -0.012237549, -0.013267517, 0.0037193298, 0.0010051727, -0.015083313, 0.01689148, -0.0018577576, 0.03378296, 0.005836487, 0.01210022, -0.030517578, -0.022918701, 0.07269287, -0.00037264824, -0.042755127, -0.023239136, -0.023101807, 0.020523071, 0.01272583, -0.05493164, 0.04763794, 0.084106445, 0.003856659, -0.006919861, -0.05480957, 0.039245605, -0.051696777, 0.018875122, 0.04824829, -0.026809692, -0.039398193, 0.059783936, 0.07147217, -0.048614502, -0.03793335, 0.03567505, 0.07489014, -0.021636963, 0.027877808, 0.008140564, -0.02003479, -0.03543091, 0.012542725, -0.031585693, 0.0069236755, 0.0026187897, 0.04776001, 0.013648987, -0.01209259, 0.023849487, -0.042419434, 0.0013389587, -0.031036377, 0.011245728, 0.005970001, 0.0028972626, -0.019638062, -0.011421204, 0.00982666, 0.011177063, 0.028259277, 0.022781372, 0.079711914, -0.08691406, 0.06695557, -0.031402588, -0.022201538, 0.0079956055, -0.016281128, -0.015960693, 0.040496826, 0.022613525, -0.013847351, -0.015213013, 0.042175293, 0.0065612793, 0.03387451, -0.03112793, 0.00090551376, 0.0044517517, 0.040527344, -0.08026123, -0.09051514, 0.0084991455, -0.011985779, -0.039611816, -0.04067993, 0.018737793, 0.0021743774, -0.016082764, -0.016616821, -0.034362793, 0.01777649, -0.007789612, 0.04611206, 0.051483154, -0.029708862, -0.09039307, -0.039093018, -0.038879395, 0.0037956238, 0.0068626404, 0.024978638, -0.030975342, -0.019744873, 0.017990112, -0.011459351, -0.01158905, -0.011810303, 0.0060806274, 0.010696411, 0.029144287, -0.049560547, -0.005268097, 0.0032539368, 0.009468079, 0.017730713, 0.0057640076, -0.018341064, -0.019866943, -0.006591797, 0.027832031, -0.02067566, -0.005218506, 0.006214142, -0.033477783, -0.061828613, 0.041046143, 0.015388489, 0.032714844, 0.011962891, -0.02633667, 0.024719238, 0.0541687, 0.009223938, 0.04852295, 0.001285553, 0.02571106, 0.029525757, -0.04046631, 0.01763916, 0.054138184, 0.045776367, -0.029388428, -0.020736694, 0.011077881, -0.029144287, -0.052764893, -0.09265137, -0.02470398, 0.06463623, 0.020507812, -0.017654419, 0.004886627, 0.00006508827, -0.018814087, 0.008995056, -0.015670776, -0.0024604797, 0.03277588, -0.04043579, -0.018051147, -0.0027179718, -0.0118255615, -0.0025119781, -0.02078247, -0.010231018, -0.0031929016, -0.025619507, 0.001206398, 0.0070533752, -0.013793945, 0.01309967, -0.000726223, -0.027542114, -0.027435303, 0.013435364, -0.018722534, -0.013679504, 0.04147339, -0.012863159, -0.00009608269, 0.03643799, -0.009963989, 0.01600647, 0.0004606247, 0.0010528564, 0.014511108, -0.034179688, 0.019042969, 0.026351929, 0.0071640015, 0.023773193, 0.04840088, -0.048431396, -0.005443573, 0.0054779053, -0.003730774, 0.0234375, -0.04031372, 0.023208618, 0.020401001, 0.0056152344, 0.0018520355, -0.03262329, 0.0029468536, 0.02394104, -0.010131836, -0.022994995, 0.015701294, -0.024856567, -0.046966553, 0.051879883, -0.02810669, 0.011528015, -0.011734009, 0.03845215, 0.017471313, 0.015068054, -0.026657104, -0.01977539, -0.036712646, 0.046661377, -0.0060272217, 0.014564514, 0.009521484, -0.011528015, -0.056610107, 0.009773254, -0.040985107, -0.029846191, -0.07043457, 0.015792847, 0.009536743, 0.045837402, -0.010246277, 0.04626465, 0.030654907, -0.05355835, 0.0062942505, 0.017700195, -0.02406311, 0.018920898, 0.0020637512, -0.014503479, 0.054534912, 0.0013055801, -0.026367188, 0.045776367, 0.023910522, -0.040527344, 0.04156494, -0.02178955, 0.005317688, 0.0231781, 0.02696228, 0.0048713684, 0.030441284, -0.008674622, -0.053527832, -0.024246216, -0.005970001, -0.059051514, -0.042114258, -0.06939697, 0.026901245, -0.014923096, -0.037994385, -0.049621582, 0.0013370514, -0.06384277, 0.00025486946, 0.016494751, -0.025878906, -0.01071167, -0.016662598, 0.012336731, -0.015174866, 0.008049011, 0.010383606, 0.035217285, -0.029266357, -0.053375244, 0.011787415, -0.026016235, -0.050964355, 0.02128601, -0.012878418, -0.030914307, 0.06750488, -0.01928711, -0.022979736, 0.014518738, 0.0025405884, 0.009742737, 0.007472992, 0.052368164, -0.02053833, -0.0018310547, 0.0009455681, 0.012184143, -0.0068244934, 0.022857666, -0.018539429, -0.0039138794, -0.00944519, 0.033325195, -0.011566162, 0.0022964478, 0.029800415, 0.04083252, -0.023239136, -0.023849487, -0.00522995, -0.034179688, 0.04675293, 0.019973755, -0.08850098, -0.07977295, -0.09698486, -0.027893066, -0.0012435913, -0.019729614, -0.023971558, 0.08728027, -0.02067566, 0.016525269, 0.029937744, -0.06903076, 0.01864624, -0.015571594, 0.051940918, 0.003698349, 0.006504059, -0.006526947, -0.013389587, 0.023132324, 0.016921997, 0.013442993, 0.01675415, 0.006904602, 0.027282715, -0.014381409, -0.021469116, -0.059265137, 0.04559326, -0.035217285, -0.00038266182, -0.015991211, -0.0021152496, 0.03555298, 0.003824234, 0.059448242, -0.016571045, 0.01612854, 0.019805908, -0.020950317, 0.04321289, 0.03277588, -0.009841919, 0.03378296, 0.011680603, -0.02659607, 0.03540039, 0.03213501, 0.027770996, -0.029144287, -0.0008010864, 0.016143799, 0.010353088, 0.0077705383, -0.009674072, -0.03164673, 0.01689148, 0.043060303, -0.0077667236, -0.003271103, -0.024017334, 0.018295288, -0.000025570393, -0.008544922, 0.0062332153, 0.02935791, 0.0102005005, 0.03378296, 0.028274536, -0.059448242, 0.028823853, 0.035827637, -0.017684937, 0.0033435822, 0.042663574, -0.03945923, 0.024215698, -0.005794525, 0.03466797, 0.058807373, 0.036346436, -0.031677246, 0.015113831, 0.06549072, -0.0309906, 0.0118255615, -0.055664062, -0.005680084, -0.057434082, 0.02230835, 0.029510498, -0.0048217773, 0.037109375, 0.0073890686, -0.045043945, -0.0076026917, -0.051818848, 0.037353516, -0.050842285, -0.025634766, -0.010223389, -0.06536865, -0.030899048, 0.008522034, 0.025375366, -0.01574707, -0.012962341, -0.026397705, 0.0025634766, -0.0052757263, 0.02116394, 0.047027588, 0.0006661415, -0.04437256, 0.007255554, 0.0009074211, 0.070251465, -0.027786255, -0.026107788, -0.0017738342, 0.02520752, 0.022140503, -0.023910522, -0.017730713, 0.020385742, -0.000626564, -0.042266846, 0.024734497, 0.029190063, -0.017669678, -0.027740479, -0.0033912659, 0.0049438477, -0.01876831, 0.014579773, 0.032470703, -0.010574341, -0.022583008, 0.000992775, -0.014030457, 0.0103302, -0.02734375, -0.006340027, 0.014152527, 0.022750854, -0.037719727, -0.034851074, -0.020401001, -0.034210205, 0.016494751, -0.043395996, -0.0037403107, 0.01121521, 0.06555176, -0.0046195984, -0.03326416, 0.014953613, -0.0357666, -0.00023007393, -0.0050354004, -0.015464783, 0.032409668, 0.015113831, 0.08087158, 0.009651184, -0.062042236, 0.0418396, 0.01121521, 0.0070152283, 0.033355713, -0.015113831, 0.028213501, 0.015975952, -0.0065612793, -0.02633667, 0.048431396, -0.053527832, -0.0073547363, 0.009170532, -0.0066184998, -0.016723633, 0.016143799, 0.01209259, -0.03756714, 0.014656067, -0.021942139, -0.012145996, 0.007320404, -0.045440674, -0.0010700226, 0.020996094, 0.08392334, -0.01953125, -0.021881104, 0.06500244, -0.05316162, 0.0027675629, 0.019073486, 0.006088257, -0.00881958, -0.0064468384, -0.02204895, 0.007381439, -0.017196655, -0.013259888, -0.02848816, -0.036376953, -0.033203125, -0.029434204, 0.044189453, -0.059295654, 0.022018433, -0.0023460388, -0.0017118454, 0.027008057, -0.02986145, 0.01977539, 0.03656006, -0.012359619, -0.08782959, -0.053985596, -0.006866455 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2101.10643v12
Causal inference for observational longitudinal studies using deep survival models
Jie Zhu, Blanca Gallego
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.QM
Causal inference for observational longitudinal studies often requires the accurate estimation of treatment effects on time-to-event outcomes in the presence of time-dependent patient history and time-dependent covariates. To tackle this longitudinal treatment effect estimation problem, we have developed a time-variant causal survival (TCS) model that uses the potential outcomes framework with an ensemble of recurrent subnetworks to estimate the difference in survival probabilities and its confidence interval over time as a function of time-dependent covariates and treatments. Using simulated survival datasets, the TCS model showed good causal effect estimation performance across scenarios of varying sample dimensions, event rates, confounding and overlapping. However, increasing the sample size was not effective in alleviating the adverse impact of a high level of confounding. In a large clinical cohort study, TCS identified the expected conditional average treatment effect and detected individual treatment effect heterogeneity over time. TCS provides an efficient way to estimate and update individualized treatment effects over time, in order to improve clinical decisions. The use of a propensity score layer and potential outcome subnetworks helps correcting for selection bias. However, the proposed model is limited in its ability to correct the bias from unmeasured confounding, and more extensive testing of TCS under extreme scenarios such as low overlapping and the presence of unmeasured confounders is desired and left for future work.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2101.10643v12
"2022-06-08T08:40:56"
"2021-01-26T09:15:49"
{ "title": [ 0.008018494, 0.0029315948, -0.03857422, -0.09484863, 0.023635864, -0.0025234222, -0.068847656, -0.015777588, 0.0043296814, 0.004512787, -0.0079956055, 0.029022217, -0.033477783, -0.04171753, 0.0019407272, 0.011528015, -0.00819397, 0.011703491, -0.022842407, -0.038085938, -0.015426636, -0.06604004, 0.05657959, 0.005508423, 0.022964478, -0.01007843, -0.046569824, 0.028457642, -0.05038452, -0.023590088, -0.00737381, -0.0070266724, 0.038330078, 0.041107178, -0.011787415, -0.0076179504, -0.05770874, 0.02394104, 0.0028133392, -0.0069236755, 0.004272461, -0.0074691772, 0.004295349, -0.04272461, -0.03427124, 0.035980225, -0.05960083, -0.034301758, -0.01309967, 0.03741455, 0.014213562, 0.03353882, -0.02709961, 0.06149292, 0.020431519, -0.010147095, -0.01586914, -0.028381348, 0.038757324, 0.06210327, 0.01537323, -0.062805176, 0.012382507, -0.030426025, -0.046051025, -0.026367188, -0.013885498, 0.04458618, 0.05014038, 0.000067174435, -0.012939453, 0.015342712, -0.026062012, 0.024719238, -0.0501709, -0.01184082, 0.05734253, -0.0028038025, 0.015266418, -0.0029525757, -0.010177612, -0.020050049, 0.0008277893, -0.015716553, -0.015464783, -0.048339844, -0.03149414, 0.01260376, -0.014373779, -0.053985596, -0.007713318, -0.029815674, -0.0046958923, 0.046051025, -0.013175964, -0.021606445, -0.018630981, 0.044403076, -0.020950317, -0.02520752, -0.039794922, 0.03277588, -0.06213379, -0.015991211, -0.009712219, 0.020050049, 0.0055389404, -0.007709503, -0.0073776245, 0.033050537, -0.017700195, 0.020706177, -0.021026611, -0.015075684, 0.021606445, 0.03439331, -0.018737793, 0.03186035, 0.013130188, 0.022247314, -0.029266357, -0.03161621, -0.014923096, 0.017044067, 0.011016846, -0.021514893, -0.027359009, 0.019485474, -0.056030273, 0.06451416, 0.009216309, 0.012550354, -0.10369873, -0.047912598, -0.03778076, 0.021972656, -0.024398804, -0.07330322, -0.03366089, 0.025787354, -0.0024642944, -0.036346436, 0.011634827, -0.01928711, 0.0005955696, -0.00064229965, 0.06726074, 0.004550934, -0.056884766, -0.018493652, -0.0057792664, 0.037139893, 0.06414795, 0.0013456345, -0.12927246, -0.004398346, -0.14111328, -0.015960693, -0.013710022, -0.028533936, 0.010681152, -0.023071289, -0.027923584, -0.008758545, 0.021118164, 0.018737793, -0.014709473, 0.023788452, 0.020370483, 0.049591064, -0.025253296, 0.020721436, 0.01335144, 0.016113281, -0.0031166077, 0.022247314, 0.019729614, 0.0012617111, 0.031433105, 0.0007209778, 0.014328003, -0.012908936, 0.020980835, 0.06188965, -0.047576904, -0.043518066, 0.0011577606, -0.010848999, 0.054779053, 0.023590088, -0.054382324, 0.014533997, -0.06542969, -0.04611206, -0.037139893, 0.00035977364, 0.04425049, 0.0309906, -0.006122589, 0.0058670044, 0.017929077, -0.013534546, -0.008621216, -0.021621704, -0.01852417, -0.027420044, -0.014404297, 0.0055503845, -0.024749756, 0.0491333, 0.05380249, -0.00013422966, -0.024291992, 0.011985779, -0.004966736, -0.07196045, 0.016494751, -0.03427124, -0.0126953125, -0.004764557, -0.020233154, -0.009223938, -0.008018494, 0.048187256, -0.009216309, -0.02999878, 0.031143188, -0.058624268, 0.024963379, -0.0010461807, 0.08569336, -0.0362854, -0.0076179504, -0.03729248, -0.046447754, -0.013000488, -0.014328003, 0.013626099, -0.0038928986, 0.031433105, -0.012580872, -0.010017395, -0.01928711, 0.04336548, 0.004047394, -0.011741638, -0.007610321, 0.033691406, -0.013954163, 0.005393982, 0.0748291, 0.031707764, 0.054840088, 0.016555786, 0.0052223206, 0.0602417, 0.017501831, 0.0141067505, -0.0015087128, 0.024887085, -0.0022182465, 0.033233643, -0.024017334, 0.018310547, -0.05279541, -0.01713562, -0.037261963, -0.00029969215, -0.005393982, -0.002571106, 0.038238525, -0.023834229, 0.00598526, -0.01007843, 0.029815674, 0.0012264252, -0.03753662, 0.009803772, 0.016540527, -0.052612305, -0.0074768066, 0.030227661, 0.05529785, -0.00038552284, 0.017242432, -0.02520752, 0.004699707, -0.02168274, 0.017303467, -0.004863739, 0.049102783, 0.008270264, -0.009140015, 0.013870239, 0.015022278, -0.03866577, 0.019119263, 0.06549072, -0.02381897, 0.033935547, -0.053497314, 0.025497437, 0.027694702, -0.009521484, 0.006679535, 0.054901123, 0.006729126, 0.019454956, -0.018478394, -0.023788452, -0.011268616, 0.025863647, 0.013305664, 0.024307251, -0.03289795, -0.04675293, 0.013313293, 0.0061531067, -0.0015363693, -0.015022278, 0.04473877, -0.02571106, -0.04751587, -0.020874023, -0.0012207031, -0.006198883, -0.02708435, -0.029159546, -0.010681152, 0.023773193, 0.06512451, 0.023544312, -0.046691895, -0.07470703, -0.0018911362, 0.00016105175, -0.008476257, 0.03540039, -0.015167236, -0.0019454956, 0.016830444, -0.05331421, 0.020446777, -0.025314331, 0.038909912, -0.059265137, 0.014350891, 0.038604736, -0.068725586, 0.024032593, 0.0019283295, -0.046295166, -0.035461426, -0.0046424866, 0.047698975, -0.023239136, -0.008583069, 0.02722168, 0.039031982, -0.030273438, 0.0016765594, -0.0067863464, -0.02468872, -0.05657959, 0.0101623535, -0.032196045, -0.034729004, -0.014373779, -0.018157959, 0.049804688, -0.07904053, -0.024795532, -0.029571533, 0.010765076, 0.028640747, 0.06542969, -0.014724731, -0.02935791, -0.025283813, -0.018814087, 0.0041046143, 0.012031555, -0.022827148, 0.009178162, 0.06982422, -0.0038814545, 0.00022053719, -0.011184692, 0.039001465, 0.015289307, -0.02268982, -0.033355713, -0.029846191, -0.0015306473, -0.00028276443, 0.03149414, 0.00068330765, -0.017684937, -0.07080078, -0.021636963, 0.041259766, -0.0046310425, -0.025985718, 0.017044067, -0.07116699, 0.01864624, -0.022598267, -0.00749588, 0.030059814, 0.057739258, -0.011276245, 0.04107666, -0.0022258759, 0.0006117821, 0.014259338, -0.017089844, -0.04083252, 0.034210205, -0.023284912, -0.06689453, 0.028640747, -0.04336548, -0.034057617, -0.01751709, 0.03074646, 0.037963867, 0.014167786, -0.016143799, 0.016189575, -0.03729248, -0.005466461, -0.026138306, -0.016113281, -0.011795044, 0.009712219, 0.021392822, -0.006378174, 0.039398193, -0.0037841797, 0.0072784424, -0.025985718, -0.027679443, 0.015380859, 0.04397583, 0.007411957, -0.016708374, -0.033721924, 0.006801605, 0.0011320114, -0.011688232, -0.021392822, -0.019805908, -0.019363403, 0.020858765, -0.02041626, 0.064208984, 0.053588867, 0.005241394, -0.027450562, 0.01663208, 0.01171875, -0.033081055, -0.03479004, 0.015617371, 0.05606079, -0.019699097, 0.016418457, -0.03149414, -0.0071754456, 0.015975952, -0.04425049, 0.02331543, -0.010177612, -0.009933472, -0.0008120537, 0.014450073, 0.0037384033, 0.0034236908, -0.0131073, 0.0038967133, 0.032989502, 0.00040555, 0.007041931, -0.06262207, -0.010650635, 0.016555786, -0.14160156, -0.02281189, 0.030395508, -0.060668945, -0.060272217, -0.06341553, 0.041870117, -0.06262207, -0.010848999, 0.018508911, -0.018997192, -0.016204834, -0.013801575, -0.06854248, -0.006252289, 0.07611084, 0.0121536255, 0.03152466, 0.0061035156, 0.0062446594, 0.023498535, -0.035583496, 0.0038433075, -0.01576233, 0.05871582, -0.020874023, 0.02079773, 0.03010559, -0.016525269, 0.010795593, 0.04815674, 0.03137207, -0.004837036, -0.012649536, 0.03326416, 0.008926392, 0.00843811, 0.030822754, 0.01739502, -0.02229309, -0.031280518, -0.010322571, -0.010826111, 0.010932922, 0.0003502369, -0.0036258698, 0.047454834, 0.013534546, 0.018356323, 0.019195557, -0.017944336, -0.033294678, 0.0045394897, -0.016433716, 0.0014410019, 0.046722412, 0.014968872, 0.026168823, 0.0013427734, -0.015686035, -0.019195557, 0.026657104, -0.0309906, -0.0075263977, 0.0004992485, 0.007926941, 0.009300232, -0.0065460205, -0.07788086, -0.038238525, 0.0030708313, 0.0008611679, -0.0011940002, 0.024505615, 0.0037326813, -0.017440796, -0.0124053955, 0.0015583038, 0.003238678, 0.006614685, 0.018630981, -0.012245178, 0.00843811, -0.024230957, -0.018692017, -0.03842163, -0.0054016113, -0.027557373, 0.041900635, -0.011985779, -0.0284729, 0.015930176, 0.009147644, 0.045928955, 0.0519104, 0.00027942657, -0.03881836, 0.00049066544, 0.0028324127, 0.008720398, 0.005531311, 0.009567261, 0.018188477, -0.022155762, -0.04824829, -0.018981934, -0.007865906, -0.014259338, 0.004058838, -0.025405884, 0.05947876, 0.011390686, 0.050750732, 0.0115737915, 0.007106781, 0.001291275, 0.016937256, -0.028793335, -0.033111572, 0.028671265, 0.02859497, 0.017929077, 0.0146865845, 0.017044067, 0.00048685074, -0.023513794, 0.022338867, 0.019317627, 0.023208618, -0.0151901245, -0.011138916, 0.032592773, 0.019485474, -0.010169983, 0.033294678, 0.02017212, 0.042938232, -0.014801025, 0.062438965, -0.01739502, 0.022994995, 0.012428284, -0.016601562, 0.015029907, -0.023391724, 0.026855469, -0.07092285, -0.095458984, -0.023086548, 0.07775879, -0.0090789795, -0.012702942, 0.019714355, 0.042114258, 0.017654419, 0.059020996, 0.051971436, -0.002040863, -0.006843567, -0.01663208, -0.001964569, -0.022750854, -0.059020996, 0.015838623, -0.004863739, 0.015525818, -0.025360107, -0.003955841, -0.068725586, 0.011657715, 0.022079468, -0.03842163, 0.028686523, -0.08666992, -0.009513855, 0.018951416, -0.015464783, 0.015960693, -0.00642395, 0.006778717, 0.030212402, 0.050964355, 0.0018692017, 0.022445679, 0.01675415, -0.021606445, -0.01084137, -0.007030487, 0.031097412, 0.028244019, -0.023803711, 0.0077552795, -0.016403198, -0.020584106, 0.020996094, 0.0017776489, 0.0012979507, 0.0050315857, -0.044189453, -0.019180298, 0.0014810562, 0.016708374, -0.0028305054, 0.008926392, -0.022125244, 0.019821167, -0.029647827, -0.020477295, 0.013694763, -0.023162842, -0.031402588, -0.014335632, 0.0057678223, -0.00021386147, 0.03326416, -0.00055885315, 0.00094509125, -0.028930664, 0.023483276, -0.0067443848, -0.05947876, 0.0087890625, 0.010215759, 0.029937744, 0.03857422, 0.014709473, -0.038848877, 0.008453369, -0.028762817, -0.05596924, -0.04196167, 0.029006958, 0.007736206, 0.0011854172, 0.0004837513, -0.009735107, 0.015235901, 0.008476257, 0.034423828, -0.0073776245, -0.015930176, 0.040161133, 0.0035820007, 0.000644207, -0.0016994476, -0.02204895, -0.005214691, -0.01373291, -0.007270813, -0.027160645, 0.019241333, 0.00034737587, 0.0066108704, -0.0070152283, -0.06149292, 0.015777588, 0.017669678, 0.017044067, -0.013961792, -0.017089844, 0.017471313, 0.0031223297, 0.002035141, -0.008506775, 0.080078125, -0.027114868, -0.022888184, 0.002614975, 0.0017623901, -0.03567505, 0.048309326, -0.0061798096, -0.031829834, -0.035186768, -0.058807373, -0.030731201, 0.0009331703, 0.02848816, -0.0041923523, 0.014846802, -0.0024471283, 0.034606934, -0.040405273, -0.01272583, 0.0154800415, 0.009162903, -0.006839752, -0.054351807, -0.0021438599, -0.019866943, 0.001698494, -0.04876709, 0.018478394, -0.014335632, 0.012268066, -0.022216797, 0.00079774857, 0.013282776, -0.006198883, -0.02507019, 0.054840088, -0.024017334, 0.0069236755, 0.036895752, -0.01626587, 0.014572144, 0.017303467, 0.08673096, 0.062286377, 0.043182373, 0.03186035, 0.008773804, 0.034820557, -0.033569336, 0.013473511, -0.007820129, -0.0043029785, -0.04333496, -0.018585205, -0.09185791, 0.04928589, 0.005973816, 0.017807007, 0.020706177, 0.001121521, -0.016601562, 0.0066986084, 0.055145264, 0.07232666, 0.055908203, 0.05441284, -0.008041382, 0.044067383, -0.018875122, -0.0023651123, 0.043945312, 0.005256653, -0.0105896, -0.008140564, -0.010353088, -0.010765076, 0.010322571, 0.014205933, -0.018569946, -0.0113220215, -0.03201294, 0.03125, -0.0044441223, 0.04510498, 0.0435791, 0.02053833, -0.005672455, 0.0059165955, -0.0024280548, -0.0017786026, -0.018310547, 0.023742676, 0.058502197, -0.07885742, 0.031707764, 0.0010080338, -0.028045654, -0.011253357, 0.03387451, 0.029434204, -0.06768799, -0.050323486, 0.021759033, 0.038024902, 0.015357971, 0.03994751, -0.03555298, 0.011077881, 0.031021118, -0.0017642975, 0.011741638, 0.016906738, 0.024642944, 0.03137207, -0.0069618225, -0.012191772, 0.012306213, 0.018966675, -0.00374794, 0.040130615, -0.028015137, 0.0062789917, 0.022064209, -0.02041626, 0.029418945, 0.019012451, -0.04852295, 0.0062789917, 0.010307312, 0.00598526, 0.025726318, 0.08306885, 0.038024902, 0.0033893585, -0.045562744, -0.041931152, 0.028579712, 0.032073975, -0.019577026, -0.010925293, -0.019363403, -0.042266846, 0.040374756, -0.028198242, 0.088012695, -0.068237305, -0.015319824, -0.0022659302, 0.0093688965, 0.021255493, -0.019302368, -0.026931763, -0.032928467, -0.022338867, -0.004951477, 0.005252838, -0.021835327, -0.046142578, 0.005504608, 0.03942871, 0.01083374, -0.023086548, -0.03366089, -0.013122559, -0.042541504, -0.0026283264, -0.02355957, 0.027114868, -0.007698059, -0.015670776, -0.053466797, 0.021743774, 0.0211792, -0.009666443, -0.018051147, 0.015777588, -0.0440979, -0.036712646, 0.032165527, 0.04196167, -0.016082764, -0.03186035, 0.014266968, -0.015083313, -0.01158905, -0.0018548965, 0.031188965, -0.03475952, -0.055511475, -0.016235352, -0.011764526, 0.049835205, 0.020355225, -0.011367798, 0.017593384, 0.030639648, -0.02078247, -0.027923584, -0.01448822, 0.011604309, -0.013763428, -0.06311035, 0.0055656433, 0.029434204, 0.0234375, -0.05517578, 0.008018494, 0.049438477, 0.044769287, -0.0023670197, 0.04437256, 0.008934021, -0.00573349, -0.0033187866, 0.04598999, 0.013130188, -0.028015137, -0.042510986, -0.030685425, 0.067871094, 0.041229248, -0.0006775856, -0.017181396, 0.04006958, -0.022506714, -0.014518738, 0.019744873, -0.009635925, -0.0009860992, 0.023086548, 0.04046631, -0.02168274, -0.0118255615, 0.01689148, -0.008979797, 0.0018320084, 0.034484863, -0.020370483, -0.0005335808, -0.014854431, 0.054351807, -0.0012617111, -0.004676819, 0.026306152, 0.0054130554, 0.05697632, 0.0017347336, 0.014602661, 0.0062026978, 0.028778076, -0.03338623, -0.0181427, -0.03237915, 0.05316162, -0.074157715, -0.041748047, -0.038970947, -0.031051636, 0.0357666, -0.027526855, 0.0501709, -0.029830933, 0.011207581, -0.042755127, -0.020141602, -0.017440796, 0.024963379, -0.023925781, -0.064575195, -0.0463562, 0.014533997, 0.06439209, -0.003660202 ], "summary": [ 0.036254883, -0.009063721, -0.011352539, -0.057495117, -0.026107788, -0.012809753, -0.058013916, -0.01902771, -0.015419006, 0.0072898865, -0.016540527, 0.023635864, -0.03125, -0.052001953, 0.036743164, -0.03515625, -0.019180298, 0.032440186, 0.0019416809, -0.028808594, 0.023162842, -0.039031982, -0.01838684, -0.017074585, 0.0029716492, 0.026824951, 0.0012483597, -0.0020503998, 0.005138397, -0.003332138, 0.022781372, -0.017456055, -0.044708252, 0.06732178, 0.0052375793, -0.03778076, 0.0010910034, 0.03189087, 0.023910522, 0.020996094, 0.020217896, -0.014808655, 0.08483887, -0.064697266, 0.029525757, 0.03289795, 0.036865234, -0.041015625, 0.030090332, -0.010734558, -0.026443481, -0.011749268, -0.012535095, 0.026321411, -0.037353516, -0.03866577, -0.044189453, 0.038513184, 0.014526367, 0.020004272, 0.0071258545, -0.010734558, 0.0027103424, -0.009864807, 0.0030536652, 0.008964539, -0.006324768, 0.008125305, 0.018218994, 0.026428223, -0.004585266, -0.013458252, 0.00043940544, -0.017700195, -0.050231934, -0.002368927, 0.044952393, -0.020874023, -0.0018558502, -0.026321411, -0.02406311, -0.013298035, 0.009567261, -0.030960083, -0.008926392, -0.024459839, -0.023834229, 0.0039405823, -0.00034856796, -0.009010315, -0.0063667297, -0.04901123, -0.02949524, 0.05807495, 0.025939941, -0.030548096, -0.0057373047, 0.000910759, -0.008041382, -0.057281494, -0.012466431, 0.0065956116, -0.081970215, 0.007461548, -0.033843994, 0.0262146, 0.05883789, 0.057403564, 0.0011405945, -0.001745224, -0.01890564, 0.024612427, -0.029296875, -0.022583008, -0.005794525, 0.029785156, -0.029434204, 0.02293396, -0.005138397, 0.020065308, -0.0076789856, 0.036071777, -0.026184082, 0.006565094, -0.03250122, -0.03857422, 0.008071899, -0.006500244, -0.041168213, 0.05041504, -0.017959595, -0.006801605, 0.024124146, 0.040496826, 0.011245728, -0.038726807, -0.0061569214, -0.04940796, -0.030181885, -0.0013513565, 0.021011353, -0.011352539, 0.012390137, -0.008796692, -0.00806427, -0.004688263, 0.033843994, 0.031311035, -0.029449463, -0.023345947, 0.017913818, 0.028259277, 0.052947998, -0.02458191, -0.1418457, -0.075683594, -0.07757568, -0.01399231, 0.016311646, -0.06561279, -0.030914307, -0.03491211, -0.020248413, -0.019836426, -0.042938232, 0.016311646, 0.04284668, 0.004486084, 0.024734497, 0.002614975, -0.0015621185, -0.001200676, 0.034118652, 0.01689148, 0.008552551, 0.028671265, -0.019241333, -0.01637268, 0.008720398, 0.018066406, 0.0028858185, -0.011169434, 0.01751709, 0.020217896, -0.02079773, -0.040863037, 0.00077199936, 0.020324707, 0.03555298, 0.028884888, -0.03665161, -0.012557983, -0.058288574, -0.0026817322, -0.018798828, 0.024032593, -0.005470276, 0.025512695, -0.020004272, -0.015586853, 0.07952881, -0.01184845, 0.0026359558, -0.0335083, -0.06402588, -0.01689148, -0.008178711, 0.013809204, -0.023529053, 0.022521973, 0.015296936, -0.02822876, 0.007221222, 0.005344391, -0.012794495, -0.03717041, -0.0042915344, -0.030288696, 0.0010681152, -0.028503418, 0.016052246, 0.011161804, -0.008926392, 0.025024414, -0.009933472, -0.023834229, 0.006160736, -0.015899658, 0.01979065, -0.019439697, 0.064697266, -0.0076141357, -0.05871582, -0.04928589, -0.06878662, 0.0010223389, -0.021499634, 0.035461426, 0.012458801, 0.01939392, 0.00055646896, -0.00022876263, -0.023788452, 0.016662598, -0.02507019, -0.022613525, -0.016571045, 0.027832031, -0.054107666, -0.053253174, 0.07928467, -0.0098724365, 0.03463745, 0.0025291443, 0.03149414, 0.015655518, 0.0053749084, 0.022125244, -0.011772156, 0.0026664734, 0.0019321442, 0.016281128, -0.015777588, -0.000600338, 0.04559326, -0.04537964, 0.011703491, -0.011306763, 0.00029110909, -0.043884277, 0.009300232, -0.050201416, -0.00004506111, -0.024871826, -0.023361206, 0.044036865, -0.021499634, 0.01676941, 0.03982544, -0.008956909, -0.019241333, 0.028671265, 0.013938904, -0.014854431, -0.01033783, -0.0063476562, 0.025283813, -0.0004415512, 0.022964478, 0.019241333, 0.049102783, -0.030380249, -0.03677368, 0.025115967, 0.014717102, -0.053619385, -0.071777344, 0.0138549805, 0.0064315796, -0.029006958, -0.052734375, 0.037078857, 0.004447937, 0.004623413, -0.0069007874, 0.032073975, -0.02243042, 0.012939453, 0.009277344, -0.047790527, 0.03375244, 0.03656006, 0.03237915, 0.12042236, -0.024749756, -0.04196167, 0.015266418, 0.06512451, 0.018173218, -0.02319336, 0.0335083, -0.021469116, -0.027648926, -0.026473999, -0.0068130493, 0.0073928833, -0.02583313, -0.01663208, 0.012664795, -0.009429932, 0.044189453, -0.016098022, -0.035247803, -0.060333252, 0.022125244, -0.017349243, 0.002576828, 0.07080078, -0.0037574768, -0.015426636, 0.009597778, -0.04159546, 0.0009365082, 0.0037937164, 0.017578125, -0.023727417, 0.0079574585, 0.012550354, -0.013725281, 0.00046634674, -0.022918701, -0.04257202, -0.032104492, 0.0013751984, 0.0066719055, -0.026275635, 0.04147339, 0.03692627, 0.026473999, -0.015296936, 0.019119263, 0.026397705, -0.0037574768, -0.027130127, -0.020751953, -0.031173706, 0.015670776, -0.013183594, -0.004558563, -0.009994507, -0.04055786, -0.006843567, -0.0026721954, 0.018249512, 0.03665161, 0.055633545, 0.026901245, -0.018081665, 0.02279663, 0.020950317, 0.012145996, 0.00037837029, -0.004787445, -0.022247314, 0.03765869, -0.0023212433, 0.013320923, 0.028305054, 0.013877869, 0.008460999, -0.02545166, -0.024124146, -0.015159607, -0.027877808, -0.012107849, 0.0010633469, 0.04006958, -0.014091492, 0.016281128, -0.034820557, -0.02482605, 0.018707275, 0.0012550354, -0.007083893, -0.019012451, -0.024993896, -0.020080566, -0.035247803, 0.012077332, -0.010940552, 0.008003235, -0.011909485, -0.0236969, 0.008934021, 0.011909485, -0.047821045, 0.08880615, 0.037078857, -0.06427002, -0.07861328, 0.035583496, 0.03982544, 0.025375366, -0.023468018, 0.0791626, 0.047943115, 0.0154418945, -0.057159424, 0.018295288, 0.0077285767, 0.06323242, -0.024917603, -0.004951477, -0.014228821, 0.010635376, 0.03692627, -0.025375366, -0.014167786, -0.04812622, 0.0020828247, 0.034423828, -0.017456055, 0.046539307, 0.03918457, 0.009559631, 0.04727173, -0.023162842, 0.04421997, 0.004310608, -0.011360168, -0.023391724, -0.010864258, 0.022384644, 0.03744507, -0.008155823, 0.08203125, 0.017486572, 0.011787415, 0.0030708313, -0.0107803345, -0.014762878, -0.01348114, -0.035858154, -0.007904053, 0.037261963, -0.0027198792, 0.014251709, -0.022720337, 0.012786865, -0.013641357, -0.030578613, 0.008926392, -0.02835083, -0.015068054, -0.011993408, -0.014511108, 0.03591919, 0.027526855, 0.018920898, -0.02470398, -0.0067710876, 0.021469116, 0.010269165, -0.041534424, -0.035308838, 0.0098724365, -0.074523926, -0.0519104, 0.04321289, -0.06561279, -0.053588867, -0.054504395, 0.042236328, -0.053375244, 0.015655518, 0.0039863586, -0.018966675, 0.016555786, -0.019119263, -0.066467285, 0.043701172, -0.008529663, 0.010765076, 0.046783447, -0.046569824, 0.032226562, 0.097961426, 0.017700195, 0.015312195, -0.026412964, 0.054382324, -0.019256592, 0.06567383, 0.022598267, 0.00793457, -0.03366089, 0.064331055, 0.036895752, -0.0067481995, -0.022659302, 0.035064697, 0.04458618, -0.0023555756, 0.028198242, 0.0013866425, -0.030029297, 0.006263733, -0.007472992, -0.005355835, 0.018630981, -0.029922485, 0.0345459, 0.017211914, 0.0031471252, 0.02557373, -0.062561035, -0.02053833, -0.064331055, -0.022567749, 0.027618408, -0.00806427, 0.036865234, -0.0032653809, 0.055877686, 0.004508972, 0.021438599, -0.025970459, 0.026550293, -0.018966675, 0.030776978, -0.031921387, -0.04043579, 0.008918762, -0.012756348, -0.02305603, 0.053955078, -0.0021800995, -0.012039185, -0.0016841888, 0.027740479, -0.025268555, 0.017669678, -0.0020122528, -0.008178711, -0.014732361, 0.017532349, 0.014923096, 0.020324707, -0.057922363, 0.0052871704, -0.015335083, -0.01777649, -0.0770874, -0.0625, -0.025054932, 0.009933472, -0.0259552, -0.010322571, 0.014389038, 0.020996094, 0.025253296, 0.016448975, -0.00071525574, -0.06994629, -0.007671356, 0.05255127, 0.00095558167, 0.024963379, 0.008628845, -0.013389587, -0.058441162, -0.0018520355, -0.029907227, -0.026046753, -0.005596161, -0.015670776, 0.03491211, 0.02671814, 0.05960083, 0.010307312, -0.020233154, -0.016662598, 0.0022354126, -0.019958496, 0.0127334595, 0.023223877, -0.024047852, 0.042755127, -0.017868042, 0.001414299, -0.013122559, -0.022201538, 0.01007843, -0.028121948, 0.00818634, 0.02935791, 0.00021576881, 0.011276245, 0.0848999, 0.021621704, 0.07550049, 0.013961792, 0.0181427, 0.056884766, -0.022140503, -0.016189575, 0.021270752, 0.030136108, -0.01285553, -0.004802704, 0.01449585, -0.0032520294, -0.042541504, -0.055511475, -0.0067863464, 0.053985596, -0.0184021, -0.03756714, -0.0135650635, 0.003921509, 0.00092458725, 0.011177063, 0.02482605, -0.020996094, 0.0010900497, -0.026275635, -0.006664276, 0.01234436, -0.011169434, -0.016296387, 0.0112838745, 0.001824379, 0.05819702, -0.02885437, -0.023452759, 0.012130737, -0.0033874512, -0.0064888, 0.007041931, -0.03463745, -0.049865723, -0.022018433, -0.039642334, -0.02911377, 0.034973145, -0.023117065, -0.0030536652, 0.051940918, -0.04156494, 0.011009216, 0.01071167, -0.004333496, 0.029052734, -0.0003080368, 0.043273926, 0.039611816, -0.019897461, -0.0025253296, 0.003868103, 0.011474609, -0.016555786, 0.007282257, 0.06304932, -0.041900635, -0.008155823, 0.03579712, 0.015777588, -0.041015625, -0.0030918121, 0.01727295, -0.019104004, -0.017807007, -0.008651733, -0.026321411, 0.009651184, -0.015686035, -0.036193848, 0.04425049, 0.014518738, 0.009033203, 0.005809784, 0.025726318, -0.016921997, -0.0050735474, -0.003786087, -0.030792236, -0.07849121, 0.032806396, 0.03829956, 0.033203125, 0.022659302, -0.013969421, -0.016601562, 0.0062294006, 0.00053691864, -0.026870728, -0.030792236, 0.038269043, 0.008468628, 0.013961792, 0.0036582947, -0.007282257, 0.043945312, -0.0062408447, 0.0256958, -0.016174316, -0.0033111572, 0.0155181885, 0.0012731552, -0.0003798008, 0.010612488, -0.027908325, -0.0006942749, -0.014205933, 0.011451721, -0.049316406, -0.0002822876, 0.0043754578, -0.008110046, -0.0057792664, -0.030303955, -0.0057907104, 0.017623901, 0.0013618469, -0.011131287, -0.025756836, -0.0058135986, -0.01977539, -0.008232117, -0.035858154, 0.039398193, -0.010124207, -0.05731201, -0.0064086914, 0.021530151, 0.0043258667, 0.036193848, -0.017288208, -0.054656982, 0.007068634, -0.025634766, 0.0010242462, -0.023925781, 0.0016756058, -0.026107788, -0.026351929, 0.023910522, 0.04385376, -0.028686523, -0.0040016174, 0.025421143, 0.019210815, 0.00081014633, 0.008270264, -0.041992188, -0.016067505, -0.0028591156, -0.026504517, 0.004016876, -0.017913818, 0.014122009, 0.008674622, 0.046661377, 0.014282227, 0.008377075, 0.0137786865, 0.023117065, -0.027755737, 0.018173218, -0.0093688965, 0.017959595, -0.0012683868, -0.018417358, 0.030960083, 0.013977051, 0.064331055, 0.03237915, -0.013725281, 0.074157715, -0.014892578, 0.028335571, 0.024871826, 0.014793396, -0.010314941, -0.006084442, -0.033294678, 0.110839844, -0.026535034, 0.016723633, -0.008903503, 0.017608643, -0.035614014, 0.026473999, -0.013687134, 0.06756592, 0.02420044, 0.069885254, -0.0050582886, 0.05407715, -0.015792847, -0.019165039, 0.037994385, 0.043518066, -0.028167725, 0.0006709099, -0.0037975311, 0.014801025, -0.0069007874, -0.0154800415, -0.043701172, 0.017959595, -0.04446411, -0.016098022, 0.019683838, 0.012817383, -0.023452759, -0.02897644, 0.045166016, 0.013511658, -0.00045514107, 0.044128418, 0.002960205, 0.03439331, 0.06713867, -0.0015192032, 0.0048599243, 0.008430481, -0.031143188, 0.03753662, 0.027694702, 0.030807495, -0.08538818, -0.037719727, 0.057373047, -0.0068092346, 0.00037145615, 0.032196045, -0.02003479, 0.015640259, 0.047424316, -0.010215759, 0.013923645, 0.024139404, 0.0126571655, -0.038635254, 0.031799316, -0.0011730194, 0.005558014, 0.05935669, 0.0051651, 0.035614014, -0.013000488, -0.014167786, 0.08251953, 0.0049858093, 0.019256592, 0.04812622, 0.009666443, 0.060668945, -0.05328369, 0.00002360344, -0.012466431, 0.051239014, 0.012611389, 0.00472641, -0.027832031, 0.012626648, -0.028808594, -0.020233154, -0.013160706, -0.02368164, 0.011116028, 0.02746582, 0.030517578, 0.001534462, 0.021377563, -0.0803833, -0.0031318665, -0.026794434, 0.016677856, -0.012634277, -0.015007019, -0.041015625, -0.06506348, -0.06311035, 0.01663208, 0.013755798, -0.011619568, -0.029174805, -0.022949219, 0.005065918, -0.005886078, -0.00881958, 0.014663696, 0.0017976761, -0.019042969, 0.012069702, 0.0003528595, 0.058685303, -0.010795593, -0.045928955, -0.010475159, 0.01537323, 0.022354126, 0.02444458, -0.027282715, 0.0680542, -0.0024642944, -0.04119873, -0.013023376, -0.02142334, -0.048339844, -0.039916992, 0.10168457, 0.003932953, -0.0046043396, -0.0019550323, 0.010673523, 0.0012426376, -0.028701782, -0.013999939, -0.045013428, -0.010650635, -0.020401001, -0.009521484, 0.03717041, 0.027420044, -0.006767273, -0.032165527, -0.0132751465, -0.03262329, 0.0014743805, -0.06097412, 0.008323669, 0.0020580292, 0.030654907, -0.02796936, 0.013900757, 0.050354004, 0.061798096, 0.006576538, -0.027389526, -0.021316528, -0.010498047, 0.009208679, 0.04272461, -0.0031108856, -0.013305664, -0.034057617, -0.036956787, 0.04727173, 0.021850586, -0.011329651, -0.015235901, 0.027069092, 0.0030212402, -0.025558472, 0.007106781, 0.05102539, -0.030670166, 0.008468628, 0.026657104, -0.030380249, -0.12005615, 0.028762817, -0.025634766, 0.0016412735, -0.012634277, -0.019180298, -0.011581421, -0.047302246, 0.0073242188, 0.030227661, 0.064086914, -0.04159546, -0.041107178, 0.045837402, -0.020736694, 0.027038574, 0.014808655, -0.016494751, -0.055664062, -0.012512207, -0.07122803, 0.091918945, -0.12249756, -0.055267334, -0.00028824806, -0.0025024414, 0.06347656, 0.008308411, 0.043273926, -0.039916992, -0.0019416809, -0.030929565, -0.052886963, 0.02027893, 0.026168823, 0.010772705, -0.015281677, 0.01247406, 0.048339844, 0.024612427, 0.008071899 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2102.02988v3
AutoPilot: Automating SoC Design Space Exploration for SWaP Constrained Autonomous UAVs
Srivatsan Krishnan, Zishen Wan, Kshitij Bhardwaj, Paul Whatmough, Aleksandra Faust, Sabrina Neuman, Gu-Yeon Wei, David Brooks, Vijay Janapa Reddi
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.AR, cs.LG
Building domain-specific accelerators for autonomous unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) is challenging due to a lack of systematic methodology for designing onboard compute. Balancing a computing system for a UAV requires considering both the cyber (e.g., sensor rate, compute performance) and physical (e.g., payload weight) characteristics that affect overall performance. Iterating over the many component choices results in a combinatorial explosion of the number of possible combinations: from 10s of thousands to billions, depending on implementation details. Manually selecting combinations of these components is tedious and expensive. To navigate the {cyber-physical design space} efficiently, we introduce \emph{AutoPilot}, a framework that automates full-system UAV co-design. AutoPilot uses Bayesian optimization to navigate a large design space and automatically select a combination of autonomy algorithm and hardware accelerator while considering the cross-product effect of other cyber and physical UAV components. We show that the AutoPilot methodology consistently outperforms general-purpose hardware selections like Xavier NX and Jetson TX2, as well as dedicated hardware accelerators built for autonomous UAVs, across a range of representative scenarios (three different UAV types and three deployment environments). Designs generated by AutoPilot increase the number of missions on average by up to 2.25x, 1.62x, and 1.43x for nano, micro, and mini-UAVs respectively over baselines. Our work demonstrates the need for holistic full-UAV co-design to achieve maximum overall UAV performance and the need for automated flows to simplify the design process for autonomous cyber-physical systems.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2102.02988v3
"2021-09-10T13:53:49"
"2021-02-05T03:50:54"
{ "title": [ -0.033721924, 0.001996994, -0.02798462, -0.008621216, 0.0112838745, -0.016799927, 0.00907135, -0.016235352, -0.04837036, 0.019836426, -0.049560547, 0.021102905, -0.03253174, -0.012413025, -0.011253357, -0.030410767, 0.0026760101, 0.006263733, -0.019882202, -0.022521973, -0.006462097, -0.02746582, 0.051971436, 0.044311523, 0.017623901, 0.006504059, -0.1315918, 0.020309448, -0.050628662, -0.042907715, -0.033203125, 0.06210327, 0.05899048, 0.016342163, -0.027816772, 0.04324341, -0.0015497208, 0.013496399, 0.0006070137, 0.022949219, 0.03149414, -0.014053345, -0.0069007874, -0.009864807, -0.016494751, 0.027252197, -0.042388916, -0.0029335022, -0.0025405884, 0.015655518, 0.02809143, 0.013198853, 0.01763916, 0.066345215, -0.0062217712, -0.032684326, -0.011627197, 0.02204895, 0.02772522, 0.073791504, 0.029327393, 0.002494812, -0.013938904, -0.025268555, -0.0039901733, -0.022781372, -0.023406982, 0.03552246, 0.058898926, 0.0021476746, -0.016601562, 0.019378662, 0.008522034, 0.02935791, -0.04675293, -0.039215088, 0.064086914, 0.0030879974, 0.030151367, 0.0042533875, -0.0017156601, -0.018081665, 0.018630981, -0.014152527, 0.015640259, -0.012290955, -0.012794495, 0.0014104843, -0.046295166, -0.008728027, -0.019577026, 0.035308838, -0.0067749023, -0.0042533875, -0.04800415, 0.0037612915, -0.025314331, -0.0184021, 0.03274536, 0.015670776, 0.040405273, -0.025421143, 0.031051636, -0.015792847, -0.0043563843, 0.0132369995, 0.007751465, 0.029434204, 0.028701782, 0.02670288, -0.028427124, 0.04156494, 0.020080566, 0.028579712, -0.030014038, -0.021072388, 0.000103890896, -0.009490967, -0.0121536255, -0.0033416748, -0.018081665, -0.023742676, 0.026977539, 0.00018751621, 0.046325684, 0.037200928, -0.03704834, -0.008239746, 0.005935669, -0.0020046234, 0.017578125, 0.043670654, -0.083496094, -0.07897949, -0.05947876, 0.04537964, -0.022644043, 0.010902405, -0.008003235, 0.019638062, 0.013320923, -0.030456543, 0.01902771, 0.013908386, 0.006412506, 0.016647339, 0.06549072, -0.0021152496, -0.04348755, -0.035980225, -0.019592285, 0.020095825, -0.008285522, 0.005832672, -0.0006246567, 0.011833191, -0.087524414, 0.0046844482, 0.028305054, 0.032073975, -0.0073013306, 0.008041382, 0.0014371872, 0.028060913, 0.04449463, 0.0062828064, 0.0055007935, 0.026763916, 0.008598328, 0.0184021, -0.019470215, 0.018981934, -0.0010910034, -0.016967773, -0.02470398, 0.004589081, 0.0070991516, -0.0033988953, 0.014183044, 0.0020618439, 0.00674057, -0.028137207, 0.00070238113, 0.02947998, -0.057922363, -0.025466919, 0.007522583, 0.0044822693, 0.030899048, 0.009216309, -0.0113220215, 0.02279663, -0.047851562, -0.027130127, -0.04525757, -0.005996704, 0.01727295, 0.020599365, -0.0129776, 0.039520264, -0.05340576, 0.003932953, -0.034454346, 0.01965332, -0.007217407, -0.055786133, 0.0061302185, 0.020462036, 0.018966675, 0.07495117, 0.022460938, 0.009765625, -0.043029785, 0.014266968, 0.0011367798, -0.0574646, 0.016738892, -0.007396698, 0.00035333633, -0.025909424, -0.014381409, 0.0056991577, -0.003862381, 0.032562256, 0.054107666, -0.0061683655, 0.0036449432, -0.043304443, 0.09448242, 0.002790451, 0.048919678, -0.010925293, 0.018295288, 0.014724731, -0.010650635, -0.002571106, -0.013771057, -0.003993988, 0.0044059753, 0.013694763, 0.0024433136, -0.02809143, -0.015991211, 0.027282715, 0.015464783, -0.038879395, 0.0059547424, 0.029052734, 0.008605957, 0.027557373, 0.045440674, 0.025039673, 0.04611206, 0.015602112, 0.0064468384, 0.05340576, 0.017868042, 0.028747559, -0.025161743, 0.0009417534, -0.0011014938, 0.024963379, 0.0007596016, 0.017578125, -0.03955078, 0.017791748, -0.0015916824, 0.033325195, -0.006801605, 0.007575989, 0.04019165, 0.026245117, -0.00006997585, -0.0036354065, -0.030731201, -0.031463623, 0.00015544891, 0.031921387, -0.017089844, -0.062683105, -0.012771606, -0.0073623657, 0.043670654, -0.008148193, 0.01335907, -0.000089108944, 0.03805542, -0.033966064, -0.0075149536, -0.014022827, 0.05001831, 0.012161255, -0.013801575, 0.02116394, -0.016311646, -0.017929077, 0.09472656, 0.08068848, -0.031433105, 0.051849365, -0.043762207, -0.0026798248, 0.009468079, -0.018829346, 0.0016098022, 0.01398468, 0.026626587, -0.012329102, -0.02923584, 0.058898926, -0.06878662, 0.02746582, 0.008865356, 0.013847351, -0.06854248, -0.06573486, -0.0069084167, -0.027130127, -0.024719238, 0.0027694702, 0.06793213, -0.03262329, -0.013435364, 0.013908386, -0.030471802, -0.032958984, 0.020736694, -0.027175903, -0.020187378, 0.019088745, 0.009117126, 0.0060691833, -0.051757812, 0.008293152, -0.012123108, 0.02696228, -0.021911621, 0.034942627, -0.030578613, -0.019180298, -0.0066986084, 0.0064315796, 0.008659363, -0.024002075, 0.018035889, -0.066223145, 0.017150879, 0.004371643, -0.007091522, 0.012756348, 0.016143799, -0.02218628, -0.026824951, 0.0036506653, 0.036865234, -0.05267334, -0.0025310516, 0.019561768, -0.013336182, -0.030654907, 0.009185791, 0.038360596, 0.0040626526, 0.004562378, -0.0013856888, -0.062347412, 0.0090789795, -0.014389038, -0.044036865, 0.0018138885, -0.06213379, -0.057403564, -0.018371582, -0.0079422, 0.008049011, 0.052246094, -0.011375427, -0.03201294, 0.016799927, -0.020904541, 0.011192322, 0.016662598, -0.0019416809, 0.00844574, 0.059936523, 0.011039734, -0.0065460205, 0.010009766, 0.036071777, -0.012023926, 0.00919342, 0.011985779, -0.06781006, 0.0074310303, 0.03793335, -0.011474609, -0.006225586, 0.02418518, -0.13720703, -0.0072402954, 0.03274536, -0.029525757, -0.037719727, -0.0078125, -0.013366699, -0.058776855, 0.017745972, -0.029281616, 0.03289795, 0.014434814, -0.0037822723, 0.013618469, 0.004524231, -0.03137207, -0.0048446655, -0.035369873, -0.07397461, 0.033233643, -0.03994751, -0.0440979, -0.0037384033, -0.005317688, -0.04598999, -0.014709473, -0.023651123, 0.023284912, 0.010108948, 0.011276245, -0.01928711, -0.01651001, -0.0024223328, -0.02583313, 0.0014247894, 0.023956299, -0.053710938, 0.042266846, 0.019363403, 0.047058105, 0.079589844, -0.035095215, -0.01586914, -0.0055770874, 0.010047913, 0.03149414, 0.015777588, -0.037200928, -0.02204895, -0.011940002, 0.00001835823, -0.016830444, 0.0107803345, 0.010223389, -0.006389618, -0.0054969788, -0.01537323, 0.040222168, 0.02949524, 0.00091934204, -0.015014648, -0.04800415, -0.023361206, -0.013206482, -0.07757568, -0.023223877, 0.0060539246, -0.023803711, -0.012062073, -0.017150879, -0.024002075, 0.014541626, -0.037872314, 0.074523926, 0.020431519, -0.0020160675, 0.0015611649, 0.006072998, -0.015052795, 0.024124146, -0.049713135, -0.013824463, 0.009529114, -0.012367249, 0.04598999, -0.014656067, 0.05090332, -0.005077362, -0.044799805, 0.020568848, 0.03555298, -0.05429077, -0.009857178, -0.05706787, 0.04611206, -0.03265381, 0.0017337799, -0.0110321045, 0.005657196, -0.08355713, 0.0019416809, -0.056762695, -0.056396484, 0.08605957, -0.0058555603, -0.022277832, 0.043701172, -0.008514404, -0.028503418, 0.008155823, 0.0262146, -0.005531311, 0.034454346, 0.007007599, -0.00035905838, 0.048095703, -0.03643799, 0.014907837, -0.0008840561, 0.007194519, -0.020004272, 0.0107040405, 0.010131836, -0.0027561188, -0.016098022, 0.052734375, 0.03137207, -0.005432129, -0.05831909, 0.016036987, -0.008804321, -0.027450562, 0.003873825, -0.02381897, -0.0051879883, 0.023391724, 0.050567627, 0.0725708, -0.0079422, 0.025680542, 0.024536133, -0.033233643, -0.023864746, -0.0050468445, 0.033843994, -0.0064849854, 0.008148193, 0.025131226, -0.006149292, 0.07965088, -0.03024292, 0.021194458, 0.0029392242, 0.009994507, -0.036346436, -0.020721436, -0.0791626, 0.014709473, -0.011009216, 0.017425537, -0.033721924, 0.012214661, 0.032592773, -0.018508911, -0.013954163, 0.0047798157, 0.094177246, -0.002368927, 0.02923584, -0.07006836, 0.010032654, 0.011672974, -0.07196045, -0.04031372, -0.019195557, 0.030151367, 0.011192322, -0.009635925, -0.0127334595, 0.037750244, 0.004940033, 0.04144287, 0.037994385, -0.012298584, -0.04071045, 0.053833008, -0.013313293, -0.014030457, 0.009841919, 0.022857666, -0.014198303, -0.03604126, 0.0069351196, -0.018661499, -0.008338928, -0.017562866, 0.0030574799, -0.01979065, 0.023162842, -0.010948181, 0.040771484, 0.022659302, 0.0071907043, -0.006641388, 0.0005068779, -0.043029785, 0.00056886673, -0.0041236877, 0.03741455, -0.05670166, 0.030593872, 0.037353516, -0.002796173, -0.020050049, -0.016677856, 0.037872314, 0.014694214, -0.032562256, -0.035095215, 0.036743164, -0.014694214, -0.0066223145, 0.0064353943, 0.0036792755, 0.026397705, -0.05178833, 0.093688965, -0.04257202, -0.05496216, 0.017166138, 0.02130127, -0.006576538, -0.008270264, 0.010826111, -0.06829834, -0.04434204, -0.029541016, 0.054595947, -0.05114746, -0.03793335, -0.009803772, 0.01423645, 0.02659607, 0.040985107, 0.017028809, 0.0027656555, -0.054351807, -0.004234314, -0.009605408, -0.058776855, -0.04336548, -0.00440979, -0.0048332214, 0.026824951, -0.001991272, 0.026870728, -0.056610107, 0.01133728, 0.0006570816, -0.017822266, 0.041748047, -0.09454346, -0.0124435425, 0.041503906, 0.014205933, 0.0010328293, 0.0075798035, 0.032958984, 0.038635254, 0.05557251, -0.007511139, 0.041168213, 0.03012085, 0.0078125, 0.0059509277, -0.022705078, 0.039489746, 0.019592285, 0.007686615, 0.016174316, 0.033325195, -0.080078125, 0.027191162, 0.015037537, -0.04248047, 0.039398193, -0.03366089, 0.045959473, -0.0016050339, -0.02420044, 0.021484375, -0.035186768, -0.021835327, -0.016845703, -0.007751465, -0.052459717, 0.006931305, 0.0057640076, 0.0043411255, -0.071899414, -0.028625488, -0.044525146, 0.019348145, 0.0012235641, 0.031066895, -0.0036773682, 0.05444336, 0.05053711, -0.007209778, -0.03390503, 0.002161026, -0.01247406, 0.034820557, 0.05441284, -0.026657104, 0.00014698505, -0.0015878677, -0.03387451, -0.03213501, -0.013771057, -0.01411438, 0.005874634, 0.00630188, 0.009498596, 0.007686615, -0.015319824, 0.03704834, -0.012641907, -0.026855469, 0.047180176, -0.0018148422, 0.00491333, 0.008728027, 0.038269043, 0.029037476, -0.001405716, -0.012702942, 0.0061073303, 0.025115967, -0.032684326, -0.028869629, 0.024032593, -0.06384277, 0.028671265, -0.00083732605, 0.012313843, -0.0011911392, -0.0058021545, 0.039245605, -0.04034424, 0.017028809, 0.0033874512, 0.072753906, -0.06707764, -0.030929565, 0.0022258759, 0.014854431, 0.009384155, 0.035186768, -0.0070610046, -0.021896362, -0.023132324, -0.053344727, -0.042907715, -0.012268066, 0.04446411, 0.0012617111, 0.042999268, -0.012481689, -0.012504578, -0.030654907, -0.020370483, -0.060577393, 0.010940552, -0.011528015, -0.009750366, 0.039154053, 0.0019226074, 0.016189575, -0.012496948, 0.018600464, 0.013175964, -0.0023269653, 0.017227173, -0.035949707, 0.01197052, -0.014663696, -0.013557434, 0.0047912598, 0.020187378, -0.02519226, 0.0121536255, -0.05834961, 0.05697632, -0.026351929, 0.024551392, 0.049438477, 0.022613525, -0.030548096, -0.011314392, -0.022338867, -0.053344727, -0.014251709, -0.057281494, -0.010536194, -0.04574585, -0.00072956085, -0.037384033, 0.013595581, -0.008598328, 0.039764404, 0.010154724, 0.02897644, 0.024520874, -0.0031108856, 0.041168213, -0.03704834, 0.06768799, 0.042053223, 0.004764557, 0.00730896, 0.016433716, 0.016174316, 0.02230835, 0.0030174255, 0.028717041, 0.0005645752, -0.022613525, 0.011726379, 0.01525116, 0.01550293, -0.020187378, -0.0107421875, -0.015686035, 0.029174805, -0.017364502, 0.0027866364, 0.0793457, 0.04650879, 0.0041770935, -0.03982544, 0.025527954, -0.012626648, -0.042297363, 0.0028629303, 0.02456665, -0.036224365, -0.0053482056, -0.041412354, -0.014884949, -0.005012512, 0.030975342, 0.02734375, -0.05053711, -0.020080566, 0.03756714, 0.022109985, -0.016189575, 0.006385803, -0.03277588, -0.0015277863, 0.037902832, 0.02861023, -0.011253357, -0.008529663, 0.0061569214, 0.027160645, -0.006149292, -0.036865234, 0.0077323914, 0.010719299, -0.02130127, 0.014823914, 0.03869629, 0.0001950264, 0.0051727295, -0.032165527, -0.010940552, 0.008644104, -0.0116119385, -0.01158905, 0.011100769, 0.05041504, 0.054992676, 0.054382324, 0.015510559, 0.001657486, 0.032318115, -0.053833008, 0.027297974, 0.05630493, -0.025634766, 0.0368042, -0.03137207, -0.026947021, 0.04244995, -0.012245178, 0.058288574, -0.035247803, 0.007904053, -0.019302368, 0.036987305, 0.017532349, -0.039398193, -0.04031372, -0.0013122559, 0.0029850006, -0.0047416687, -0.011894226, -0.02861023, -0.009414673, 0.014503479, 0.030380249, 0.03805542, 0.0018577576, 0.011711121, -0.029373169, -0.05307007, 0.02949524, -0.022247314, 0.051483154, -0.008964539, -0.012283325, 0.0038757324, -0.011444092, -0.025482178, -0.033294678, -0.0012111664, -0.029251099, -0.042785645, -0.008453369, 0.021072388, 0.03656006, 0.005870819, 0.08856201, -0.043029785, 0.050109863, -0.0051612854, -0.002954483, 0.035491943, -0.034332275, -0.041931152, 0.016693115, -0.044067383, 0.02468872, 0.009437561, -0.010116577, 0.019134521, 0.018203735, -0.025878906, -0.03201294, 0.015281677, 0.040924072, 0.0061836243, -0.027191162, 0.010398865, 0.026748657, 0.06933594, -0.025665283, -0.07519531, -0.007045746, -0.025619507, 0.00056123734, 0.060943604, 0.021591187, 0.030975342, -0.007045746, 0.027755737, -0.002670288, -0.0552063, -0.043823242, -0.027557373, 0.036346436, 0.04055786, -0.01235199, -0.022018433, 0.029830933, -0.018295288, 0.0037460327, 0.020751953, -0.022857666, 0.017837524, -0.005176544, 0.04345703, -0.021499634, 0.00041651726, 0.035980225, -0.00856781, 0.003774643, 0.03463745, -0.024353027, 0.0009241104, -0.005168915, 0.009635925, -0.010871887, -0.040649414, 0.036376953, 0.017181396, 0.017822266, 0.0418396, -0.0071372986, -0.033477783, -0.060821533, 0.025680542, 0.040039062, 0.025375366, -0.04812622, 0.01727295, 0.060333252, -0.040740967, -0.06488037, 0.0055274963, -0.023468018, 0.025741577, -0.01939392, 0.023773193, 0.023025513, -0.0317688, -0.008956909, 0.036468506, 0.024642944, 0.03555298, -0.08648682, -0.06121826, 0.033203125, -0.045135498 ], "summary": [ 0.0074424744, -0.012214661, -0.024871826, -0.009414673, -0.029418945, -0.026275635, -0.027023315, -0.01878357, -0.03933716, 0.020187378, -0.046051025, 0.024276733, 0.013557434, -0.010726929, 0.056671143, -0.04638672, 0.024673462, 0.007873535, -0.0014429092, -0.019165039, -0.00187397, -0.020095825, 0.018997192, 0.06185913, 0.0019044876, 0.06335449, -0.11047363, 0.047698975, -0.044799805, -0.0015544891, -0.021331787, 0.026931763, 0.027557373, 0.024276733, -0.03579712, 0.0357666, 0.026138306, 0.002878189, 0.012077332, 0.023162842, 0.040222168, -0.020248413, 0.049621582, -0.08282471, 0.015586853, 0.05142212, 0.018371582, 0.009017944, 0.01828003, -0.014625549, 0.000052511692, 0.024490356, -0.0013875961, 0.021728516, -0.012252808, 0.024932861, -0.032928467, 0.002811432, 0.025131226, 0.058807373, 0.019180298, -0.021972656, -0.00022161007, -0.050476074, 0.0077705383, -0.011703491, -0.024169922, 0.012374878, 0.050689697, 0.0045051575, -0.01878357, 0.0035152435, 0.023254395, 0.0011825562, -0.020019531, -0.01966858, 0.017715454, 0.0059661865, 0.020477295, -0.00021350384, -0.036132812, 0.0005235672, -0.023498535, -0.026275635, -0.009307861, -0.01676941, -0.0184021, 0.0055656433, -0.013420105, 0.025054932, -0.020614624, 0.026245117, -0.030883789, 0.031677246, -0.008476257, 0.0026378632, -0.035217285, -0.086364746, 0.05734253, 0.024902344, 0.08850098, -0.082336426, 0.09765625, -0.014289856, -0.0028324127, 0.062561035, 0.040893555, 0.060546875, 0.03366089, -0.014823914, -0.013946533, 0.028182983, -0.016418457, -0.01789856, -0.01737976, 0.016311646, -0.026977539, 0.02909851, -0.010795593, 0.009757996, 0.000477314, 0.022109985, -0.012031555, 0.05517578, 0.013755798, 0.047027588, 0.021224976, -0.036010742, 0.036895752, -0.04257202, -0.010108948, 0.049194336, -0.025650024, -0.038116455, -0.031036377, 0.008911133, -0.013381958, 0.022720337, 0.016601562, -0.015655518, 0.019439697, -0.023635864, -0.0038013458, 0.03567505, -0.010437012, 0.05218506, 0.035980225, -0.0231781, -0.021835327, -0.04046631, -0.026779175, -0.0065231323, -0.020202637, -0.01096344, 0.068359375, -0.02319336, 0.0005221367, -0.01663208, 0.036590576, 0.013320923, 0.0078086853, 0.008674622, 0.015914917, 0.039733887, 0.027114868, -0.008331299, 0.008880615, 0.013015747, 0.006969452, -0.01725769, -0.029678345, -0.023422241, -0.01574707, -0.02418518, -0.025680542, 0.025390625, 0.014778137, 0.03564453, -0.0074157715, -0.011871338, -0.0035152435, -0.035186768, 0.034362793, -0.0059547424, -0.04763794, 0.02859497, -0.014976501, 0.04272461, 0.039642334, -0.012046814, 0.026321411, -0.013023376, -0.018539429, 0.023208618, -0.026016235, -0.03237915, -0.0060157776, 0.0005373955, -0.016143799, 0.018478394, 0.004184723, -0.008010864, -0.0009069443, -0.010353088, -0.023773193, -0.019439697, 0.00223732, 0.01335144, -0.0027503967, 0.04067993, 0.012374878, -0.040374756, -0.007041931, 0.019012451, 0.027252197, -0.02432251, 0.022918701, -0.044708252, -0.019058228, -0.022537231, -0.030426025, 0.015686035, -0.05795288, 0.043945312, 0.07751465, -0.007663727, -0.011566162, -0.0184021, 0.15588379, -0.026763916, 0.05630493, -0.01701355, -0.0037460327, 0.013496399, -0.014228821, -0.0065994263, -0.0032463074, -0.022857666, 0.018814087, 0.04776001, 0.02041626, -0.015586853, -0.0067253113, 0.049224854, -0.03970337, -0.05834961, 0.006881714, 0.009315491, -0.017974854, -0.025238037, 0.020385742, -0.011268616, 0.042297363, -0.032073975, 0.00642395, 0.030426025, 0.007160187, -0.01826477, -0.01525116, 0.010787964, 0.010612488, 0.007472992, -0.012680054, 0.0181427, -0.0029830933, -0.02520752, 0.017028809, 0.022506714, 0.024047852, -0.04437256, 0.013954163, -0.025878906, -0.0069351196, -0.0033187866, -0.025878906, -0.08013916, 0.012535095, 0.015548706, -0.02709961, -0.045074463, -0.013793945, -0.023101807, 0.029281616, -0.010398865, 0.05444336, -0.0012283325, 0.026382446, -0.037963867, 0.018417358, 0.023971558, 0.041503906, 0.015701294, -0.007789612, 0.044006348, 0.015533447, -0.018035889, 0.062683105, 0.026473999, 0.012458801, -0.002204895, 0.0107803345, 0.022506714, -0.030288696, 0.03326416, 0.00712204, -0.035186768, -0.00030517578, 0.01083374, -0.004108429, -0.0065460205, -0.047607422, 0.017440796, 0.028778076, 0.0859375, -0.06604004, -0.047424316, -0.024963379, 0.034240723, -0.031341553, -0.04473877, 0.08081055, 0.041229248, 0.026046753, 0.0040359497, 0.012550354, -0.07421875, -0.0084991455, -0.026641846, 0.004398346, -0.003332138, -0.017364502, -0.016921997, -0.0096588135, 0.0012083054, 0.0034618378, -0.014251709, -0.0054893494, 0.016540527, -0.020309448, -0.040985107, 0.0041618347, -0.015686035, -0.00014042854, 0.022979736, 0.021408081, -0.04598999, 0.01675415, 0.015029907, 0.0064201355, 0.0042419434, 0.017242432, -0.038269043, -0.024215698, 0.051361084, 0.009254456, -0.027679443, 0.03074646, 0.017807007, -0.03479004, -0.04324341, -0.010444641, 0.019332886, -0.03161621, -0.016906738, 0.019821167, -0.022033691, 0.010879517, -0.014373779, -0.023880005, 0.0107040405, 0.012908936, -0.024261475, -0.06982422, -0.018585205, -0.023834229, 0.026367188, 0.05758667, -0.009414673, 0.024368286, 0.03289795, 0.014945984, 0.015350342, -0.025009155, -0.020446777, 0.06036377, 0.0041236877, 0.04840088, 0.029464722, 0.07495117, -0.020324707, 0.03778076, 0.0038204193, -0.011878967, -0.0039138794, -0.003583908, -0.029266357, -0.00223732, -0.017852783, -0.06756592, -0.017684937, 0.0075798035, -0.010246277, -0.0035572052, -0.029769897, 0.010131836, -0.038269043, 0.014160156, -0.022781372, 0.032348633, -0.019317627, -0.0030460358, -0.020690918, 0.009902954, -0.058654785, 0.0004107952, -0.027572632, 0.038269043, 0.008918762, -0.025909424, -0.027572632, 0.008605957, 0.027267456, -0.0055389404, -0.020141602, -0.008087158, -0.040252686, -0.012199402, -0.005962372, -0.027191162, 0.05731201, -0.014472961, 0.0022449493, -0.0017261505, 0.046173096, -0.044281006, 0.035125732, -0.009384155, -0.043884277, 0.06542969, -0.06896973, -0.00434494, -0.0064086914, -0.01612854, 0.05053711, -0.019088745, -0.0035934448, -0.03640747, -0.043670654, 0.03540039, -0.007686615, 0.005443573, -0.0032081604, 0.049346924, 0.01838684, -0.021362305, 0.060760498, -0.024429321, 0.003583908, 0.043121338, -0.043518066, -0.037872314, 0.003232956, -0.064086914, -0.036132812, 0.033416748, -0.020370483, -0.0435791, -0.0033416748, 0.00022399426, 0.019973755, 0.0020427704, 0.020568848, -0.0031051636, -0.010009766, 0.03250122, 0.017303467, -0.012481689, 0.023803711, -0.049224854, -0.007255554, -0.032714844, -0.0014095306, 0.083496094, -0.023788452, 0.018722534, 0.017852783, -0.029403687, -0.005050659, 0.032989502, 0.002374649, 0.023498535, -0.00058078766, 0.07092285, 0.018600464, 0.045410156, -0.049591064, -0.005268097, 0.010955811, 0.021011353, -0.038330078, -0.033477783, 0.009475708, 0.025238037, -0.01889038, -0.033050537, 0.016586304, 0.038635254, 0.021087646, -0.0060310364, -0.029663086, 0.033477783, -0.043060303, 0.0005402565, 0.027252197, -0.027694702, 0.016860962, -0.025299072, 0.00063180923, -0.020462036, 0.006374359, 0.007888794, 0.032470703, -0.046722412, 0.029800415, 0.056762695, -0.013290405, -0.06011963, 0.036987305, 0.006664276, -0.055145264, 0.023544312, 0.012718201, -0.008987427, 0.05114746, 0.010627747, 0.016021729, -0.021575928, -0.013648987, 0.029586792, 0.006752014, -0.01852417, -0.0051956177, 0.00012552738, 0.01651001, 0.0045166016, 0.021850586, 0.016525269, 0.08276367, -0.037322998, 0.03414917, 0.005115509, -0.005619049, 0.01499939, -0.009750366, -0.014335632, 0.035491943, 0.002746582, -0.013191223, -0.030883789, 0.07318115, 0.02520752, -0.024902344, 0.042510986, -0.04486084, 0.09472656, 0.019546509, -0.010559082, -0.09680176, -0.028900146, 0.009216309, -0.056762695, -0.016479492, -0.056365967, -0.028686523, -0.0066184998, 0.007347107, -0.01828003, 0.026428223, 0.00022137165, 0.053100586, 0.0007510185, 0.027740479, -0.031951904, 0.027008057, 0.017654419, 0.000497818, -0.032409668, 0.0076026917, -0.027252197, -0.014335632, -0.016235352, -0.0054779053, -0.015022278, -0.039520264, -0.00409317, -0.0019817352, -0.016113281, 0.024612427, 0.040863037, 0.0039253235, 0.017074585, -0.017471313, -0.0016469955, -0.028884888, 0.025390625, -0.036621094, 0.02394104, -0.013954163, 0.049194336, 0.055389404, -0.029754639, -0.060913086, 0.0045394897, 0.041168213, 0.028381348, -0.04220581, -0.0803833, 0.07116699, 0.05307007, -0.031402588, 0.010986328, -0.018081665, -0.042633057, 0.026016235, 0.05114746, -0.023406982, -0.069885254, 0.03527832, 0.0262146, -0.0054244995, 0.041870117, -0.0068855286, -0.064819336, -0.05859375, -0.056243896, 0.058502197, -0.013160706, -0.06774902, 0.01625061, -0.004211426, 0.019729614, 0.023483276, -0.0039901733, 0.015174866, -0.0071907043, 0.026260376, 0.023788452, -0.020370483, -0.008911133, 0.014556885, -0.022064209, -0.0025749207, -0.012878418, -0.02355957, 0.0006504059, 0.0007095337, 0.020187378, -0.009010315, 0.022277832, -0.059265137, -0.062561035, -0.02748108, -0.022735596, -0.030548096, 0.0524292, 0.00274086, 0.02255249, 0.03314209, -0.02330017, 0.038757324, -0.02104187, 0.015457153, -0.006839752, -0.006904602, 0.019622803, 0.036743164, -0.02645874, 0.019500732, -0.015625, -0.023513794, 0.010108948, 0.0055770874, -0.035064697, -0.010688782, 0.015472412, 0.05227661, 0.011512756, -0.022201538, 0.0024719238, -0.042999268, -0.049621582, -0.012214661, -0.0028266907, -0.03137207, 0.021636963, 0.020019531, 0.0077056885, -0.031311035, -0.056365967, -0.019515991, 0.04071045, 0.003080368, 0.041259766, 0.02178955, -0.011581421, 0.042175293, 0.015396118, -0.00022757053, -0.019119263, 0.0031852722, -0.020904541, 0.027282715, -0.012817383, -0.0005092621, -0.022537231, -0.005882263, -0.0029201508, -0.025878906, 0.0009765625, 0.049682617, 0.0026283264, 0.006324768, 0.025848389, -0.019622803, 0.024780273, -0.017608643, -0.018096924, 0.016571045, -0.009094238, -0.007724762, -0.02192688, 0.023620605, 0.0135269165, -0.020217896, -0.006603241, -0.009613037, 0.04107666, -0.021087646, -0.008895874, 0.033935547, -0.009002686, 0.0093307495, 0.026885986, 0.014129639, -0.027633667, 0.009056091, 0.017181396, -0.055603027, 0.031402588, -0.037353516, 0.035095215, 0.010688782, -0.033203125, -0.033721924, 0.025970459, -0.020126343, -0.02357483, -0.026428223, -0.03125, 0.005531311, -0.049804688, -0.010627747, -0.009422302, 0.018371582, 0.03050232, 0.052246094, 0.019897461, 0.026412964, 0.020431519, -0.044830322, -0.050628662, -0.027450562, -0.0036201477, 0.0009255409, 0.11236572, 0.0058135986, 0.0069618225, 0.023284912, 0.0075683594, -0.02029419, -0.031951904, 0.029327393, 0.008285522, 0.03845215, -0.008110046, 0.085876465, 0.011833191, 0.021331787, -0.0110321045, -0.052825928, 0.012046814, 0.0236969, 0.00042009354, -0.06774902, 0.008995056, -0.010681152, -0.06970215, -0.021118164, -0.06286621, -0.0440979, 0.009399414, -0.008415222, -0.050933838, -0.03213501, -0.036224365, -0.019058228, 0.049560547, -0.027328491, 0.017700195, 0.0009365082, 0.025863647, -0.0023097992, 0.013244629, -0.03161621, 0.0039138794, 0.027938843, 0.005279541, 0.008293152, -0.008262634, -0.023422241, -0.0037498474, 0.039367676, -0.0018167496, 0.01878357, 0.038360596, -0.0023288727, 0.02368164, -0.020309448, 0.0026760101, -0.031097412, 0.030426025, -0.0001758337, 0.0141067505, -0.0024318695, 0.021743774, 0.034240723, 0.003856659, 0.024017334, -0.0030231476, 0.01939392, 0.0029506683, -0.05444336, 0.05718994, 0.010818481, 0.011123657, -0.028839111, -0.054718018, -0.02293396, -0.030181885, -0.0033226013, 0.037231445, -0.040496826, -0.0102005005, 0.025482178, 0.021499634, -0.047729492, -0.010002136, -0.024169922, -0.045013428, -0.00819397, 0.02519226, -0.013977051, 0.014533997, -0.020065308, 0.02142334, 0.01889038, 0.007713318, -0.0007853508, 0.042053223, -0.006263733, 0.020553589, -0.020980835, -0.03503418, 0.039276123, -0.005405426, -0.014297485, 0.030807495, 0.034454346, 0.020263672, -0.012275696, 0.04232788, 0.0680542, 0.03845215, -0.0046691895, 0.046539307, 0.04812622, -0.040161133, 0.06561279, 0.021896362, -0.017028809, -0.03640747, 0.0044059753, 0.010391235, -0.010482788, 0.030822754, 0.03692627, -0.032440186, 0.0014572144, -0.04171753, 0.044433594, -0.04324341, -0.015960693, -0.014060974, -0.035614014, -0.01210022, -0.010261536, -0.03933716, -0.031585693, 0.0107421875, -0.052703857, -0.0074882507, 0.031219482, -0.027694702, -0.011993408, -0.025527954, -0.015625, 0.0046157837, -0.0013189316, 0.024108887, 0.0657959, -0.022018433, 0.0045204163, 0.040496826, 0.007904053, -0.06854248, -0.013977051, 0.003501892, -0.0026893616, -0.006351471, 0.025177002, 0.03111267, 0.016220093, 0.08734131, -0.04925537, 0.05722046, -0.002943039, 0.022201538, 0.03640747, -0.014266968, -0.04574585, 0.009963989, -0.0040359497, 0.04309082, 0.013717651, 0.0034656525, 0.022903442, 0.042022705, 0.0087509155, -0.032165527, 0.01727295, -0.006652832, 0.0027561188, -0.029968262, 0.022964478, 0.03164673, 0.061706543, 0.022659302, 0.01637268, 0.026138306, -0.09008789, -0.015609741, -0.0030460358, 0.03704834, 0.03390503, -0.0050811768, 0.034179688, -0.019607544, -0.052612305, -0.04623413, -0.035247803, 0.050048828, 0.016784668, -0.044006348, 0.025146484, 0.04425049, -0.04437256, -0.012672424, 0.013511658, -0.021987915, 0.004131317, 0.017669678, 0.028625488, -0.039093018, 0.045959473, 0.035064697, -0.015304565, 0.00422287, 0.015213013, -0.011177063, -0.0010662079, -0.01134491, 0.029403687, 0.022949219, -0.014907837, 0.0063934326, 0.002040863, 0.028182983, 0.012229919, 0.008705139, -0.033569336, -0.04107666, 0.03741455, 0.03756714, 0.038848877, -0.052978516, 0.03918457, 0.056915283, -0.016342163, -0.033569336, -0.006702423, -0.012176514, 0.012557983, 0.024887085, -0.005958557, 0.07885742, -0.048339844, 0.0033016205, 0.019638062, 0.036987305, 0.05621338, -0.037475586, -0.046173096, -0.0037822723, -0.038146973 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2102.03049v3
Benchmarking of eight recurrent neural network variants for breath phase and adventitious sound detection on a self-developed open-access lung sound database-HF_Lung_V1
Fu-Shun Hsu, Shang-Ran Huang, Chien-Wen Huang, Chao-Jung Huang, Yuan-Ren Cheng, Chun-Chieh Chen, Jack Hsiao, Chung-Wei Chen, Li-Chin Chen, Yen-Chun Lai, Bi-Fang Hsu, Nian-Jhen Lin, Wan-Lin Tsai, Yi-Lin Wu, Tzu-Ling Tseng, Ching-Ting Tseng, Yi-Tsun Chen, Feipei Lai
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS
A reliable, remote, and continuous real-time respiratory sound monitor with automated respiratory sound analysis ability is urgently required in many clinical scenarios-such as in monitoring disease progression of coronavirus disease 2019-to replace conventional auscultation with a handheld stethoscope. However, a robust computerized respiratory sound analysis algorithm has not yet been validated in practical applications. In this study, we developed a lung sound database (HF_Lung_V1) comprising 9,765 audio files of lung sounds (duration of 15 s each), 34,095 inhalation labels, 18,349 exhalation labels, 13,883 continuous adventitious sound (CAS) labels (comprising 8,457 wheeze labels, 686 stridor labels, and 4,740 rhonchi labels), and 15,606 discontinuous adventitious sound labels (all crackles). We conducted benchmark tests for long short-term memory (LSTM), gated recurrent unit (GRU), bidirectional LSTM (BiLSTM), bidirectional GRU (BiGRU), convolutional neural network (CNN)-LSTM, CNN-GRU, CNN-BiLSTM, and CNN-BiGRU models for breath phase detection and adventitious sound detection. We also conducted a performance comparison between the LSTM-based and GRU-based models, between unidirectional and bidirectional models, and between models with and without a CNN. The results revealed that these models exhibited adequate performance in lung sound analysis. The GRU-based models outperformed, in terms of F1 scores and areas under the receiver operating characteristic curves, the LSTM-based models in most of the defined tasks. Furthermore, all bidirectional models outperformed their unidirectional counterparts. Finally, the addition of a CNN improved the accuracy of lung sound analysis, especially in the CAS detection tasks.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2102.03049v3
"2022-07-12T09:04:06"
"2021-02-05T08:21:28"
{ "title": [ -0.0021152496, -0.009925842, -0.023452759, -0.031280518, -0.028686523, -0.0024681091, -0.06768799, -0.019805908, 0.016357422, 0.02859497, -0.019805908, 0.009208679, -0.047607422, -0.037322998, -0.017303467, -0.024398804, -0.0013723373, 0.03878784, 0.024642944, -0.007247925, 0.009788513, -0.004295349, 0.009841919, 0.0602417, 0.0064430237, 0.01335144, -0.01727295, 0.008865356, -0.030471802, -0.03286743, -0.0021800995, 0.032043457, 0.0073661804, 0.051727295, -0.027069092, -0.0068473816, -0.05380249, 0.05102539, 0.032409668, -0.035125732, 0.03137207, -0.013633728, 0.056732178, -0.043304443, 0.02230835, 0.026885986, -0.005996704, -0.037872314, -0.0155181885, 0.044006348, 0.030288696, -0.056762695, 0.032226562, 0.006881714, -0.000767231, -0.00642395, -0.013442993, 0.04916382, 0.02583313, -0.021987915, -0.03314209, 0.00014066696, 0.02456665, -0.0059547424, -0.047546387, 0.041107178, 0.049224854, -0.019577026, 0.07537842, -0.043945312, -0.076171875, 0.03527832, 0.007949829, -0.005519867, -0.028366089, -0.008926392, 0.052642822, 0.027267456, 0.028335571, -0.037017822, 0.0068588257, 0.009635925, -0.00096416473, 0.009513855, -0.021606445, -0.001701355, -0.017105103, -0.008003235, -0.021713257, -0.0121154785, -0.009864807, -0.029586792, -0.053741455, 0.046936035, 0.010772705, -0.035888672, -0.019363403, -0.021270752, 0.03439331, 0.0036945343, 0.04916382, -0.066589355, 0.029891968, -0.015090942, 0.001750946, 0.0017948151, -0.04626465, -0.0496521, 0.010147095, 0.011886597, -0.04058838, -0.03942871, 0.018981934, -0.05847168, 0.00020623207, 0.035888672, 0.035247803, 0.0046577454, 0.038391113, -0.02810669, 0.003921509, 0.003036499, 0.056549072, -0.0004901886, 0.01171875, 0.022857666, -0.027923584, -0.049591064, -0.07928467, 0.06994629, 0.056030273, 0.014091492, -0.105285645, -0.0032024384, -0.07476807, 0.0026550293, 0.034301758, 0.0335083, -0.001209259, -0.030593872, 0.017990112, -0.01108551, -0.037017822, 0.011856079, -0.005306244, 0.020217896, 0.011413574, -0.00013065338, 0.0012979507, -0.005180359, -0.03463745, 0.024520874, 0.051086426, -0.010627747, -0.07922363, -0.046844482, -0.076171875, 0.00806427, -0.007320404, -0.05279541, 0.055419922, -0.027389526, -0.038146973, 0.062438965, 0.0129470825, 0.019515991, 0.014205933, 0.009994507, 0.008872986, 0.016311646, 0.012992859, 0.036895752, 0.0519104, -0.0033931732, -0.0025634766, -0.0022296906, 0.018417358, 0.0076408386, 0.03036499, -0.030838013, 0.0065689087, -0.019378662, 0.026657104, -0.010604858, -0.037231445, -0.03677368, -0.016479492, -0.007446289, 0.07531738, 0.010505676, -0.013328552, -0.014923096, 0.05517578, 0.0067367554, -0.024124146, -0.03366089, -0.026626587, 0.023498535, -0.047607422, -0.013664246, -0.032104492, 0.015205383, -0.010749817, 0.014816284, -0.015975952, -0.010345459, -0.0056381226, 0.015930176, 0.021591187, 0.017745972, 0.013572693, 0.0069084167, -0.03213501, 0.011817932, -0.013618469, 0.008956909, -0.009262085, 0.001540184, -0.03213501, 0.019592285, -0.029708862, -0.023498535, -0.035064697, 0.021057129, 0.004299164, -0.00043225288, 0.016174316, -0.0037841797, 0.013450623, 0.047576904, -0.0020580292, -0.044006348, -0.015625, -0.031402588, -0.009635925, 0.0050582886, 0.0126571655, -0.03555298, 0.017684937, 0.031143188, 0.02619934, 0.010627747, -0.016937256, -0.005176544, 0.038513184, -0.0054016113, 0.015899658, -0.02204895, 0.013839722, 0.008995056, -0.008895874, 0.016479492, 0.030410767, 0.02885437, 0.025772095, 0.023376465, -0.035339355, -0.0067367554, 0.03137207, -0.031021118, 0.007949829, 0.009338379, 0.014312744, -0.007904053, 0.006980896, -0.028427124, 0.0025615692, -0.0066986084, -0.019821167, 0.013137817, 0.036865234, -0.04171753, 0.00554657, 0.0027770996, 0.02180481, -0.03427124, -0.025787354, 0.00030851364, 0.013832092, -0.009605408, -0.00573349, 0.010002136, 0.015090942, -0.0075531006, -0.0004708767, 0.036712646, 0.040863037, 0.028884888, -0.06384277, -0.023971558, -0.0047912598, 0.01763916, -0.0023994446, -0.038909912, 0.05340576, 0.0024471283, -0.06958008, 0.014144897, -0.0129776, -0.05456543, -0.044433594, 0.009765625, -0.020645142, -0.013618469, 0.0038204193, -0.0044822693, -0.016616821, -0.012512207, -0.018554688, -0.030227661, -0.022521973, 0.026916504, 0.0140686035, 0.036956787, -0.036132812, -0.049194336, -0.032440186, 0.018692017, -0.046905518, -0.015472412, -0.00039482117, -0.0018482208, 0.081726074, -0.04815674, 0.03692627, -0.05783081, -0.053100586, 0.020599365, 0.009460449, 0.008148193, 0.0016469955, 0.0002913475, -0.05886841, -0.0087890625, 0.020141602, 0.018203735, 0.00207901, 0.022323608, -0.021606445, -0.045166016, -0.012413025, 0.013320923, 0.005104065, -0.007621765, -0.050994873, 0.00084495544, -0.007297516, -0.022384644, 0.0059432983, 0.009010315, 0.0014400482, 0.03186035, 0.0035190582, 0.0031528473, 0.023391724, 0.024795532, -0.00074243546, 0.021438599, 0.032440186, -0.027679443, 0.016540527, 0.033935547, 0.0058174133, -0.03161621, -0.04397583, -0.040496826, 0.008422852, -0.0031967163, -0.03378296, 0.015304565, -0.056610107, -0.014694214, 0.0013980865, -0.0054092407, -0.012939453, 0.040374756, 0.0036811829, -0.052459717, -0.05114746, -0.007858276, -0.033813477, -0.0015935898, -0.034973145, 0.041381836, 0.060302734, -0.015975952, 0.008804321, -0.0077400208, 0.07537842, -0.0041046143, 0.029144287, -0.020553589, -0.00017511845, -0.018417358, 0.039001465, 0.029525757, -0.03878784, -0.030654907, -0.045410156, 0.005393982, 0.041992188, -0.027893066, -0.051696777, 0.016983032, -0.024383545, -0.02986145, 0.027450562, -0.030349731, 0.007511139, 0.0107421875, 0.030441284, -0.014968872, 0.021972656, 0.00039339066, 0.028869629, -0.068847656, -0.052001953, 0.0015773773, -0.0076293945, 0.014015198, 0.03427124, -0.029083252, 0.008476257, 0.02154541, 0.03692627, 0.0748291, 0.009963989, -0.023284912, 0.0074005127, 0.00032687187, 0.03466797, -0.017486572, -0.004673004, -0.025421143, -0.004722595, 0.055511475, -0.014228821, 0.02810669, -0.022003174, 0.010665894, 0.0035915375, 0.0073890686, 0.03286743, 0.0035362244, 0.009422302, -0.017333984, 0.020019531, 0.02709961, -0.0022678375, 0.014625549, -0.0287323, -0.014801025, -0.020721436, 0.034729004, -0.029403687, 0.053131104, -0.00315094, 0.03012085, 0.038726807, -0.043945312, -0.032989502, -0.034973145, -0.022705078, -0.0037384033, -0.025161743, 0.02961731, -0.0049095154, -0.0030269623, -0.024383545, 0.00096845627, -0.03213501, 0.027496338, 0.0013856888, -0.018218994, -0.021850586, -0.091308594, 0.012893677, 0.017211914, 0.036010742, -0.031173706, -0.06402588, 0.03540039, -0.06097412, 0.00057172775, -0.003829956, 0.015853882, 0.032043457, 0.0075798035, 0.025878906, -0.040374756, 0.04473877, -0.032806396, 0.036132812, -0.015945435, 0.008766174, -0.047851562, 0.00566864, 0.015060425, -0.021377563, -0.06958008, -0.027404785, 0.013893127, 0.01902771, 0.035217285, -0.040649414, -0.03289795, 0.0024032593, 0.024276733, 0.032043457, -0.013641357, 0.017227173, 0.011657715, 0.039489746, 0.04373169, -0.021118164, 0.043640137, 0.008506775, 0.06982422, -0.0073509216, -0.014480591, 0.047302246, 0.017929077, 0.03677368, 0.014129639, 0.0035476685, 0.004890442, -0.015258789, 0.0027236938, -0.0061035156, -0.010528564, -0.023773193, 0.02027893, 0.021759033, 0.017944336, 0.02645874, -0.032104492, -0.009918213, -0.043945312, -0.02394104, -0.02029419, -0.0049209595, 0.06732178, 0.03149414, 0.0055503845, 0.01222229, 0.006164551, 0.0115737915, 0.025314331, -0.0055885315, -0.018692017, -0.019104004, 0.008079529, -0.028945923, -0.049438477, -0.05996704, -0.07434082, -0.038604736, 0.015991211, 0.022125244, 0.013938904, -0.005176544, 0.0064888, 0.012084961, -0.034332275, 0.07006836, 0.02885437, -0.023788452, -0.06008911, -0.022384644, -0.026794434, -0.05883789, -0.017227173, -0.010353088, -0.035064697, 0.03564453, -0.009880066, -0.016555786, -0.019577026, 0.038330078, 0.032806396, 0.038635254, -0.026519775, -0.09790039, -0.11444092, -0.036132812, -0.0062065125, 0.018432617, 0.021438599, -0.0049552917, -0.0067596436, 0.009780884, -0.028640747, 0.01638794, -0.006088257, -0.050201416, -0.024032593, 0.025268555, -0.049987793, -0.024002075, -0.020462036, 0.0063819885, 0.009086609, 0.007709503, -0.0077056885, 0.02470398, -0.0014219284, -0.01209259, 0.049926758, 0.021270752, 0.057403564, -0.01449585, -0.08514404, 0.031799316, 0.020019531, 0.04559326, 0.007621765, -0.07470703, 0.032165527, 0.004940033, -0.0035896301, 0.003271103, -0.039398193, -0.0065574646, -0.036712646, 0.030288696, 0.011726379, -0.017700195, 0.05331421, 0.011817932, -0.01335907, 0.04067993, -0.02796936, -0.062469482, -0.06854248, -0.033355713, 0.07733154, -0.01751709, -0.0054512024, 0.00047302246, -0.025436401, -0.020065308, 0.008338928, 0.023544312, 0.03881836, -0.023071289, -0.008056641, 0.008140564, -0.011192322, -0.019104004, -0.02810669, -0.01953125, -0.0259552, 0.006137848, -0.017181396, -0.013893127, -0.01802063, -0.013664246, -0.0008068085, -0.009719849, -0.04360962, 0.03970337, 0.05090332, -0.011291504, 0.03173828, 0.045806885, 0.018463135, 0.011459351, 0.025375366, -0.00023043156, 0.0027122498, 0.010231018, 0.015281677, -0.023452759, 0.019058228, 0.021636963, -0.007259369, -0.018981934, 0.006942749, -0.040130615, 0.008811951, -0.012741089, -0.009895325, 0.07281494, -0.02053833, -0.029891968, 0.025863647, 0.0129470825, -0.024505615, 0.032836914, -0.035064697, 0.018508911, 0.015342712, -0.0070152283, -0.042236328, -0.00016665459, 0.006580353, -0.033447266, 0.029281616, 0.032806396, -0.015899658, -0.02633667, 0.018493652, -0.0043563843, -0.01121521, -0.0006670952, -0.041870117, -0.076416016, -0.011390686, 0.013038635, 0.04373169, -0.024963379, -0.040100098, -0.048461914, -0.02015686, 0.036224365, -0.027236938, -0.0064926147, 0.032592773, 0.006793976, -0.022705078, 0.026947021, -0.026016235, 0.0010051727, 0.003227234, 0.003572464, -0.014328003, -0.0076179504, 0.062683105, 0.009223938, 0.029037476, 0.0023593903, -0.011352539, 0.0149383545, -0.0053863525, 0.004676819, -0.061706543, 0.034210205, 0.015792847, 0.07098389, 0.016174316, -0.083740234, 0.018295288, 0.029769897, 0.03314209, -0.0015954971, -0.020965576, 0.012908936, -0.015296936, -0.022964478, -0.0068206787, 0.045166016, -0.03881836, -0.045715332, -0.049194336, -0.012939453, -0.040740967, 0.062347412, -0.016571045, -0.04547119, -0.017959595, -0.08392334, 0.0005736351, 0.019317627, 0.04244995, 0.047546387, 0.066345215, -0.06719971, -0.012016296, -0.06121826, 0.026016235, -0.019165039, -0.011772156, -0.05819702, -0.025375366, 0.036376953, 0.047821045, -0.0027217865, 0.0039711, 0.008956909, -0.008872986, -0.015945435, -0.026748657, 0.0105896, 0.03161621, -0.020233154, 0.03970337, 0.0054969788, 0.030975342, -0.002380371, 0.01574707, -0.018310547, 0.01499939, 0.03012085, 0.022216797, 0.02432251, -0.025009155, 0.014785767, 0.01977539, -0.01701355, -0.031433105, -0.009887695, -0.059509277, 0.0070495605, -0.0065612793, 0.022964478, -0.007865906, 0.031311035, -0.000045657158, 0.04284668, -0.0023956299, 0.01586914, 0.02178955, 0.006515503, 0.05053711, -0.013061523, 0.08917236, -0.009101868, 0.022705078, -0.022064209, -0.06817627, 0.029022217, 0.04736328, -0.0052719116, 0.0042648315, -0.010810852, 0.0049438477, -0.008361816, 0.0035438538, -0.0018663406, -0.017852783, 0.028656006, -0.0018253326, 0.010063171, 0.020690918, 0.004486084, 0.024597168, 0.018753052, 0.025863647, -0.014732361, 0.033691406, 0.025909424, 0.01576233, -0.008552551, 0.043914795, -0.016448975, 0.004547119, -0.026611328, -0.025619507, -0.017684937, 0.04675293, -0.004184723, -0.028564453, 0.03302002, -0.03062439, 0.007247925, 0.004306793, -0.0033035278, -0.024032593, -0.029769897, 0.009712219, 0.0036640167, -0.011764526, -0.015853882, 0.023544312, -0.01727295, 0.012458801, 0.007286072, 0.013198853, 0.04852295, 0.052337646, 0.03225708, -0.041503906, 0.07080078, -0.040740967, -0.047790527, 0.044281006, 0.004852295, -0.035369873, -0.018035889, 0.04776001, 0.028503418, -0.005584717, 0.035369873, -0.0069503784, -0.01159668, -0.019348145, 0.0043258667, 0.016952515, -0.034729004, -0.0063476562, -0.042297363, 0.012916565, 0.008102417, -0.020401001, 0.0138549805, 0.037322998, -0.04244995, -0.024169922, -0.040039062, 0.043151855, -0.04043579, -0.00028324127, -0.01878357, -0.029800415, 0.01713562, -0.025375366, -0.031555176, -0.008560181, -0.018661499, -0.043548584, 0.034057617, 0.016448975, -0.0033073425, 0.05065918, -0.0038261414, -0.016433716, -0.014541626, -0.008010864, 0.035003662, -0.038085938, -0.04437256, -0.028518677, -0.01828003, 0.049316406, 0.089660645, 0.0020484924, 0.05810547, -0.07739258, -0.08270264, 0.003704071, -0.007545471, -0.04916382, -0.062042236, 0.007835388, -0.010643005, -0.030197144, -0.008285522, 0.033050537, 0.011474609, -0.07141113, -0.015281677, -0.005821228, 0.02822876, -0.014427185, 0.0084991455, -0.034301758, 0.03286743, -0.0064735413, 0.017974854, 0.025115967, 0.056488037, -0.05227661, -0.029144287, 0.008583069, -0.014251709, 0.024154663, -0.056427002, -0.06689453, -0.012428284, 0.07208252, -0.027069092, 0.007331848, 0.0127334595, 0.012878418, 0.019973755, 0.033203125, -0.005054474, -0.034179688, -0.037261963, -0.018981934, 0.060333252, 0.03717041, -0.026611328, 0.012763977, 0.05014038, -0.020889282, 0.0007390976, 0.0055274963, -0.0008134842, 0.002325058, -0.0095825195, -0.004421234, -0.028656006, 0.019378662, -0.025314331, 0.008682251, 0.013015747, 0.004245758, -0.006263733, 0.020980835, -0.011077881, 0.070495605, 0.029296875, 0.014038086, 0.07702637, -0.015060425, 0.07989502, -0.03753662, 0.110961914, 0.0076789856, 0.012420654, -0.029174805, 0.008560181, -0.028625488, 0.020324707, -0.039642334, -0.015472412, -0.053466797, -0.028076172, -0.0010976791, -0.03010559, 0.017288208, -0.009788513, 0.0082473755, 0.031280518, 0.0032730103, 0.0065193176, -0.012519836, -0.004096985, -0.018081665, -0.0049934387, -0.08294678, -0.011962891, -0.0028247833 ], "summary": [ 0.018157959, 0.0015573502, -0.0069389343, -0.05645752, -0.02027893, 0.021469116, -0.059417725, -0.0340271, 0.017959595, 0.048339844, -0.016677856, -0.014282227, 0.003753662, -0.029159546, -0.02192688, -0.029205322, 0.0046577454, 0.00066423416, -0.0014476776, -0.022644043, 0.008674622, -0.019729614, -0.007194519, 0.05227661, 0.0178833, -0.012794495, -0.04006958, 0.031402588, -0.027618408, -0.0134887695, -0.0039596558, 0.048583984, 0.003709793, 0.08300781, -0.058166504, 0.0046424866, -0.041992188, 0.042877197, 0.021987915, -0.011047363, 0.042877197, -0.024353027, 0.10296631, -0.06982422, 0.019241333, 0.07348633, -0.0021877289, -0.041137695, 0.019104004, 0.011978149, 0.027755737, -0.01096344, 0.02772522, -0.034820557, -0.014083862, -0.0059547424, -0.049438477, 0.037231445, 0.004234314, 0.01914978, 0.009597778, 0.0019721985, 0.005432129, 0.0007314682, -0.045440674, 0.005794525, 0.03253174, -0.007534027, 0.036987305, -0.055023193, -0.028823853, 0.017822266, 0.025512695, -0.01474762, -0.03338623, -0.028747559, 0.04916382, 0.009880066, 0.028884888, -0.039276123, 0.08441162, 0.03805542, 0.036956787, 0.018554688, -0.023117065, -0.007259369, -0.0048828125, -0.03842163, -0.00617218, -0.016601562, -0.02178955, -0.029556274, -0.037963867, 0.048858643, 0.00970459, -0.033172607, -0.015220642, -0.036254883, 0.026779175, 0.008987427, 0.018432617, -0.04232788, 0.014602661, -0.0039749146, -0.008926392, 0.03829956, -0.04559326, -0.048461914, 0.010627747, 0.018295288, -0.010009766, -0.0635376, 0.0012578964, -0.10119629, 0.0045204163, 0.090026855, 0.07574463, 0.003479004, 0.07067871, -0.001739502, -0.010238647, -0.0054855347, 0.03665161, 0.022994995, 0.032196045, 0.04397583, -0.022201538, -0.033294678, -0.057281494, 0.05545044, 0.039855957, 0.00868988, -0.07147217, -0.0012483597, -0.060150146, -0.006717682, 0.054260254, 0.054595947, 0.031066895, -0.052490234, 0.04385376, 0.0019483566, -0.008888245, 0.05657959, 0.0075798035, 0.015655518, 0.032043457, 0.010040283, -0.011886597, -0.006626129, -0.0082092285, 0.04837036, 0.03829956, 0.0066070557, -0.0574646, -0.028717041, -0.028823853, -0.009780884, 0.0024814606, -0.03652954, 0.04373169, -0.016555786, -0.008552551, 0.039398193, -0.01979065, 0.012191772, -0.013557434, -0.0074920654, 0.0068092346, -0.042388916, 0.03439331, 0.026260376, 0.053863525, 0.015808105, 0.02909851, 0.0044288635, -0.023849487, 0.029830933, 0.0579834, -0.05606079, -0.027297974, -0.026016235, 0.062805176, -0.002937317, 0.0005159378, -0.05871582, 0.006336212, 0.050476074, 0.044891357, 0.037719727, -0.05307007, -0.05166626, 0.01676941, 0.00242424, -0.015174866, -0.025039673, -0.017913818, 0.008895874, -0.041625977, -0.0038452148, -0.030883789, 0.012886047, 0.0019378662, -0.013298035, -0.022598267, -0.003036499, -0.009147644, 0.03475952, -0.014144897, 0.009605408, 0.023864746, -0.03250122, -0.035125732, 0.017196655, -0.008026123, -0.023376465, 0.02192688, 0.014656067, -0.031951904, 0.014770508, -0.05441284, -0.017715454, -0.056549072, 0.045318604, -0.022460938, -0.025100708, 0.015838623, 0.003856659, -0.010810852, 0.030700684, -0.011177063, -0.061065674, -0.013114929, -0.0440979, -0.0019626617, 0.029541016, 0.05114746, -0.030212402, 0.0019607544, 0.0140686035, 0.019088745, 0.009284973, -0.045440674, 0.0039043427, 0.001540184, 0.0052757263, 0.014030457, -0.016937256, 0.00566864, 0.020065308, 0.0137786865, 0.0029239655, 0.00434494, -0.041107178, -0.004108429, 0.01979065, -0.02784729, 0.016098022, -0.0138168335, -0.041046143, 0.016098022, -0.042510986, -0.014373779, -0.023132324, 0.0134887695, -0.053649902, -0.0154800415, -0.029830933, 0.0050849915, -0.015777588, 0.014968872, -0.060028076, 0.0035171509, 0.042755127, 0.010604858, -0.010284424, -0.02218628, -0.00116539, 0.014678955, 0.018829346, 0.008590698, -0.014328003, -0.005306244, 0.003282547, 0.010864258, -0.022521973, 0.03479004, 0.06567383, -0.0062942505, 0.01259613, 0.018157959, 0.004497528, 0.0181427, -0.031402588, 0.03756714, -0.011985779, -0.004863739, 0.051513672, -0.0038776398, -0.009689331, -0.00793457, 0.014915466, -0.034179688, 0.018203735, 0.009361267, 0.018814087, 0.0033912659, -0.01209259, 0.01473999, -0.00504303, -0.0054473877, 0.05316162, 0.007572174, 0.056274414, -0.07122803, -0.0680542, -0.050689697, 0.0076293945, -0.045135498, 0.021881104, 0.011566162, -0.029525757, 0.024032593, -0.012680054, 0.0065193176, -0.037994385, 0.01399231, 0.0072517395, -0.00024461746, 0.022964478, 0.015823364, 0.03250122, -0.005607605, 0.01335144, 0.007331848, -0.004714966, 0.019073486, 0.03253174, 0.0044021606, -0.018096924, 0.041503906, 0.0027770996, 0.0026130676, 0.03326416, -0.074157715, 0.062042236, 0.0029830933, -0.005256653, 0.014320374, 0.0037899017, -0.018112183, -0.005466461, -0.008918762, 0.017562866, -0.009391785, 0.042510986, 0.0047836304, -0.02178955, 0.0072669983, -0.056518555, 0.021942139, 0.030578613, 0.0154953, -0.026138306, -0.03768921, -0.03982544, -0.0017175674, -0.0054969788, 0.0033779144, 0.030883789, -0.045074463, 0.016220093, -0.03881836, -0.008720398, -0.0096588135, 0.033447266, 0.02809143, -0.0040397644, -0.061584473, 0.012458801, 0.03062439, 0.01550293, 0.015029907, 0.018569946, 0.09527588, -0.005420685, 0.059936523, 0.06628418, 0.059936523, -0.01763916, -0.015304565, -0.01146698, -0.018157959, -0.010765076, 0.005214691, 0.023452759, -0.04119873, -0.043670654, -0.025787354, -0.01133728, 0.03869629, -0.010253906, -0.017150879, 0.0072364807, -0.013824463, -0.024154663, 0.03555298, -0.021835327, 0.022369385, 0.017593384, 0.003862381, -0.031677246, 0.019592285, -0.051513672, 0.011001587, -0.016937256, -0.018417358, 0.0037231445, -0.01083374, -0.0021800995, 0.008979797, -0.011169434, 0.010147095, 0.014205933, 0.04257202, 0.048065186, 0.0023097992, -0.026885986, -0.013496399, 0.00017404556, 0.02709961, -0.026626587, -0.0012369156, -0.06298828, 0.004486084, 0.04852295, -0.03326416, 0.076538086, -0.06060791, 0.0128479, -0.021224976, 0.0067977905, 0.01966858, 0.0054512024, 0.011650085, -0.030731201, 0.015556335, 0.015617371, -0.008773804, 0.030197144, -0.011207581, 0.00025820732, -0.03527832, 0.019439697, -0.037200928, 0.017105103, -0.028366089, 0.009338379, 0.06939697, -0.038848877, -0.040740967, -0.012275696, -0.02079773, -0.008834839, -0.011528015, 0.010826111, -0.044006348, 0.017303467, -0.02243042, 0.0017299652, 0.014442444, 0.047332764, 0.0074691772, -0.031433105, -0.014724731, -0.07293701, 0.029586792, 0.006542206, 0.03677368, -0.04168701, -0.06726074, 0.022415161, -0.06707764, -0.005344391, 0.012611389, 0.0016202927, 0.028579712, -0.0031700134, 0.013381958, -0.02519226, -0.01626587, -0.024017334, 0.03491211, -0.012298584, 0.007789612, -0.0066871643, -0.013008118, 0.06427002, -0.011444092, -0.07757568, -0.002368927, -0.02444458, 0.03552246, 0.02659607, -0.02558899, -0.012046814, 0.018707275, -0.0018367767, 0.014373779, -0.01626587, -0.014007568, -0.02444458, -0.013328552, 0.054901123, -0.04547119, 0.0057678223, 0.01574707, 0.055541992, -0.021377563, -0.0066490173, 0.028198242, 0.01727295, 0.052978516, 0.022247314, -0.0513916, 0.020050049, -0.009849548, -0.003791809, -0.011543274, -0.005756378, -0.015579224, 0.013664246, 0.004764557, 0.011886597, 0.02645874, -0.014144897, -0.027420044, 0.0035877228, 0.008834839, -0.028884888, -0.0132369995, 0.047790527, 0.03765869, 0.0039024353, 0.008850098, -0.011146545, -0.020614624, -0.0060157776, -0.03338623, 0.0012235641, -0.03111267, -0.021484375, -0.0135269165, -0.06173706, -0.034088135, -0.062469482, -0.00440979, -0.011749268, 0.012588501, 0.026550293, -0.0042648315, -0.007926941, -0.003168106, -0.012649536, 0.07519531, 0.0058555603, 0.0007209778, -0.04849243, -0.007621765, -0.032806396, -0.039520264, -0.03289795, -0.020111084, -0.036102295, -0.0041999817, 0.020584106, -0.0146102905, -0.01789856, 0.01940918, 0.020263672, 0.0098724365, -0.010139465, -0.06616211, -0.08380127, -0.019561768, -0.004917145, -0.017318726, 0.013793945, -0.024765015, -0.019134521, 0.017837524, -0.028701782, 0.0211792, 0.016677856, -0.047088623, -0.019058228, 0.015670776, -0.027618408, 0.004055023, -0.01109314, 0.020111084, 0.016983032, -0.001241684, -0.0047683716, 0.029434204, 0.0015907288, 0.01448822, 0.0635376, 0.017288208, 0.08215332, -0.035614014, -0.086364746, 0.022277832, 0.030532837, 0.042663574, 0.020446777, -0.05343628, 0.05230713, -0.0052757263, -0.011154175, -0.006942749, -0.026855469, 0.00036859512, -0.042541504, 0.021011353, -0.0037345886, 0.02053833, 0.068603516, 0.00063705444, -0.046020508, 0.033416748, -0.04046631, -0.057128906, -0.049316406, -0.018981934, 0.06390381, -0.01574707, 0.0039520264, -0.034057617, -0.06628418, -0.040405273, -0.0027713776, -0.031311035, 0.058380127, -0.02003479, -0.024627686, -0.007083893, -0.027114868, 0.005207062, -0.02897644, 0.052001953, -0.012359619, 0.004070282, -0.044128418, 0.00036215782, -0.037994385, -0.028121948, 0.011291504, 0.03845215, -0.026168823, -0.02079773, 0.064819336, -0.006259918, 0.023147583, 0.030044556, 0.0029029846, 0.0030822754, 0.033813477, -0.018463135, 0.016159058, 0.01247406, -0.046417236, -0.008918762, 0.02520752, 0.012580872, -0.008865356, 0.0039138794, 0.006378174, -0.019699097, -0.0025100708, -0.008255005, 0.0016565323, 0.0129776, 0.0037593842, -0.0103302, 0.052215576, 0.008453369, -0.032836914, 0.032318115, -0.013023376, -0.010375977, 0.0032405853, 0.0098724365, -0.037475586, -0.024032593, -0.0015850067, -0.034454346, 0.04034424, 0.0045318604, -0.012840271, -0.01109314, 0.024749756, -0.014930725, -0.0032024384, -0.013084412, -0.046813965, -0.08117676, -0.0025691986, -0.013031006, 0.017745972, -0.027648926, 0.005897522, -0.026473999, -0.016403198, 0.046295166, -0.038085938, -0.009490967, 0.02633667, 0.00522995, -0.038635254, 0.0115737915, -0.013717651, 0.026306152, -0.00085544586, 0.020812988, -0.015182495, -0.005722046, 0.041015625, 0.0038070679, 0.00869751, -0.0019159317, -0.026168823, 0.025909424, -0.014656067, 0.00016343594, -0.035095215, 0.020629883, 0.037902832, 0.07879639, 0.019226074, -0.055480957, 0.000049054623, 0.044830322, 0.032348633, -0.012390137, -0.018157959, 0.01423645, -0.029251099, -0.015945435, -0.0069503784, 0.032592773, -0.0284729, -0.06677246, -0.039245605, 0.01651001, -0.005393982, 0.05883789, -0.045043945, -0.0769043, 0.0067253113, -0.045959473, 0.027252197, 0.006198883, 0.0028762817, 0.043823242, 0.050964355, -0.037841797, -0.0038776398, -0.034729004, 0.010467529, -0.014915466, -0.010353088, -0.049072266, -0.04196167, 0.059295654, 0.047088623, -0.013290405, 0.039001465, -0.0007138252, 0.011978149, -0.039764404, 0.026046753, -0.00680542, 0.03074646, -0.05041504, 0.043426514, 0.028961182, 0.057037354, -0.002588272, 0.022491455, 0.029541016, 0.0072402954, 0.040222168, 0.00579834, 0.01424408, -0.027374268, 0.012054443, 0.013320923, -0.014541626, -0.027328491, -0.0032043457, -0.016021729, -0.0077171326, -0.01763916, 0.004585266, -0.0032634735, 0.08099365, -0.024337769, 0.00667572, 0.0552063, 0.011009216, 0.040283203, 0.010047913, 0.01626587, -0.023391724, 0.055664062, 0.033325195, 0.017669678, -0.022109985, -0.02154541, 0.0038909912, 0.03945923, 0.014671326, 0.011390686, 0.02218628, 0.006778717, -0.0047454834, 0.017791748, -0.033599854, -0.052337646, 0.06903076, -0.028839111, 0.022460938, 0.015060425, 0.030532837, 0.019332886, 0.009643555, 0.041870117, -0.022399902, 0.013473511, 0.035308838, -0.031463623, 0.047790527, 0.025390625, 0.0019016266, -0.00046944618, -0.021621704, -0.03189087, -0.050750732, 0.048309326, 0.0066184998, -0.01890564, 0.02960205, -0.009750366, -0.0019607544, -0.0024032593, 0.0181427, -0.017425537, -0.07147217, -0.007484436, 0.022598267, -0.007030487, 0.018081665, 0.008140564, 0.019119263, 0.010360718, 0.03427124, 0.0027313232, 0.014099121, 0.022827148, 0.029296875, -0.033843994, 0.03466797, -0.0137786865, -0.028305054, 0.01953125, 0.016281128, -0.0030708313, -0.007835388, 0.07684326, 0.0059776306, 0.047424316, 0.030792236, -0.042633057, 0.023086548, 0.035095215, -0.017547607, 0.0104904175, -0.04574585, -0.02128601, -0.04598999, 0.018127441, 0.030395508, -0.006702423, 0.016815186, 0.021438599, -0.062927246, -0.0023460388, -0.057373047, 0.06222534, -0.11102295, 0.008972168, 0.017318726, -0.036468506, 0.038391113, -0.022827148, -0.03640747, -0.028839111, 0.0015640259, -0.04321289, 0.032348633, 0.0034637451, -0.013885498, 0.01374054, -0.004283905, -0.013885498, -0.013519287, 0.0009832382, 0.03286743, 0.015914917, -0.035491943, -0.024154663, 0.017868042, 0.010971069, 0.04815674, -0.0019664764, 0.08734131, -0.0362854, -0.027252197, 0.0007162094, -0.0007472038, -0.038269043, -0.030883789, -0.030578613, 0.023803711, -0.04058838, -0.0032043457, 0.06762695, 0.0000577569, -0.03842163, -0.008728027, -0.0018405914, 0.04458618, -0.021438599, -0.012557983, -0.014640808, 0.025054932, -0.037261963, -0.01966858, 0.0024967194, 0.0259552, -0.04663086, -0.04046631, -0.0016078949, -0.001953125, 0.0037517548, -0.052825928, -0.014373779, 0.008613586, 0.06304932, -0.029052734, -0.05581665, 0.0026474, -0.0038394928, 0.04736328, 0.026382446, 0.0043525696, -0.041290283, -0.033233643, -0.022338867, 0.033569336, -0.00048208237, -0.030258179, 0.019073486, 0.050628662, -0.047546387, -0.007801056, 0.010932922, 0.016204834, -0.002937317, -0.022460938, -0.0027618408, -0.0368042, -0.037231445, -0.013633728, 0.0037059784, 0.001964569, 0.0017404556, -0.02027893, 0.016281128, -0.011520386, 0.022720337, 0.01777649, 0.05328369, 0.01537323, -0.035186768, 0.056610107, -0.06347656, 0.06549072, 0.031021118, 0.025253296, -0.03375244, -0.004524231, -0.016967773, 0.041046143, -0.060913086, -0.04425049, -0.042877197, 0.017227173, -0.03475952, -0.03491211, 0.040222168, 0.017349243, -0.04159546, 0.03967285, -0.02192688, 0.026153564, -0.016326904, 0.01008606, -0.009101868, 0.0057029724, -0.06451416, -0.013076782, 0.026489258 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2102.03502v4
MSPM: A Modularized and Scalable Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning-based System for Financial Portfolio Management
Zhenhan Huang, Fumihide Tanaka
q-fin.PM, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-fin.CP
Financial portfolio management (PM) is one of the most applicable problems in reinforcement learning (RL) owing to its sequential decision-making nature. However, existing RL-based approaches rarely focus on scalability or reusability to adapt to the ever-changing markets. These approaches are rigid and unscalable to accommodate the varying number of assets of portfolios and increasing need for heterogeneous data. Also, RL agents in the existing systems are ad-hoc trained and hardly reusable for different portfolios. To confront the above problems, a modular design is desired for the systems to be compatible with reusable asset-dedicated agents. In this paper, we propose a multi-agent RL-based system for PM (MSPM). MSPM involves two types of asynchronously-updated modules: Evolving Agent Module (EAM) and Strategic Agent Module (SAM). An EAM is an information-generating module with a DQN agent, and it receives heterogeneous data and generates signal-comprised information for a particular asset. An SAM is a decision-making module with a PPO agent for portfolio optimization, and it connects to EAMs to reallocate the assets in a portfolio. Trained EAMs can be connected to any SAM at will. With its modularized architecture, the multi-step condensation of volatile market information, and the reusable design of EAM, MSPM simultaneously addresses the two challenges in RL-based PM: scalability and reusability. Experiments on 8-year U.S. stock market data prove the effectiveness of MSPM in profit accumulation by its outperformance over five baselines in terms of accumulated rate of return (ARR), daily rate of return, and Sortino ratio. MSPM improves ARR by at least 186.5% compared to CRP, a widely-used PM strategy. To validate the indispensability of EAM, we back-test and compare MSPMs on four portfolios. EAM-enabled MSPMs improve ARR by at least 1341.8% compared to EAM-disabled MSPMs.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2102.03502v4
"2022-02-19T03:54:41"
"2021-02-06T04:04:57"
{ "title": [ -0.021194458, 0.011505127, -0.040618896, -0.01033783, 0.017028809, -0.021331787, 0.009811401, -0.019042969, -0.017318726, 0.021820068, -0.035186768, 0.015289307, -0.037750244, -0.01272583, -0.039916992, -0.04144287, -0.014526367, 0.028930664, -0.00022220612, -0.025421143, 0.00089788437, -0.045562744, 0.03845215, 0.025985718, 0.043060303, -0.009735107, -0.106933594, 0.0138549805, -0.021270752, -0.019515991, -0.0059165955, 0.013793945, 0.03479004, -0.015411377, 0.037475586, 0.04928589, -0.04812622, 0.026275635, 0.016662598, -0.01600647, 0.03265381, -0.02935791, 0.0033817291, 0.0158844, -0.014511108, 0.032043457, -0.04989624, -0.030319214, -0.037322998, 0.051727295, 0.03967285, 0.021026611, 0.017578125, 0.0637207, 0.015182495, -0.017303467, -0.04324341, -0.00970459, 0.048706055, 0.06506348, 0.027053833, -0.058624268, 0.010391235, -0.039642334, -0.045654297, -0.01638794, 0.00497818, -0.0050621033, 0.07318115, 0.0070762634, -0.0036907196, 0.03930664, -0.0036792755, 0.010070801, -0.04067993, -0.029083252, 0.0473938, -0.008682251, 0.030838013, -0.011024475, 0.00055503845, -0.017074585, -0.032440186, 0.0025920868, 0.001121521, -0.0128479, -0.014282227, -0.008529663, -0.045562744, -0.038116455, -0.014434814, 0.02293396, -0.027038574, -0.0039711, -0.032409668, -0.02331543, -0.03842163, 0.009185791, 0.004776001, 0.009803772, -0.033294678, 0.024246216, -0.040405273, -0.0052375793, -0.018615723, 0.009986877, 0.017852783, 0.023544312, -0.006290436, 0.019744873, -0.046844482, -0.0284729, 0.005874634, 0.011497498, -0.010658264, -0.02822876, -0.028152466, 0.018096924, 0.0053520203, 0.00085020065, 0.017715454, -0.0052452087, 0.019989014, -0.0038433075, 0.005809784, 0.0011825562, -0.05026245, -0.016601562, -0.004032135, 0.06335449, 0.014724731, 0.016601562, -0.09515381, -0.07110596, -0.055847168, 0.025466919, 0.0066490173, 0.027618408, -0.007843018, -0.012046814, 0.042022705, -0.026794434, -0.018508911, 0.03945923, 0.01965332, 0.0067367554, 0.05734253, -0.0068893433, -0.032440186, -0.035583496, -0.04434204, 0.046966553, -0.014381409, 0.0038166046, 0.012672424, 0.011291504, -0.096191406, 0.003271103, 0.041381836, 0.04876709, 0.029815674, 0.0017299652, -0.0054130554, 0.052459717, 0.072631836, -0.0038261414, 0.01739502, 0.0317688, 0.0035057068, 0.037872314, -0.007850647, -0.007091522, 0.0025863647, -0.024261475, -0.013923645, 0.007965088, 0.023986816, 0.012016296, 0.014724731, -0.027282715, 0.01524353, -0.020751953, 0.032684326, 0.03463745, -0.03970337, -0.06713867, 0.011016846, -0.033477783, 0.053649902, 0.0143585205, 0.002954483, -0.0014238358, -0.04397583, -0.05444336, -0.03213501, 0.037719727, -0.0075149536, 0.044311523, -0.011047363, 0.00021636486, -0.03677368, 0.019638062, -0.04324341, 0.032348633, -0.012710571, -0.031188965, -0.003484726, 0.015281677, -0.05996704, 0.033355713, 0.062316895, 0.01171875, -0.048828125, 0.0061836243, 0.014755249, -0.060028076, 0.032684326, -0.03213501, -0.0042495728, -0.041625977, -0.0061569214, 0.013442993, -0.013183594, 0.044403076, 0.016952515, 0.009979248, -0.016860962, -0.009757996, 0.013130188, 0.03024292, 0.016403198, 0.0009841919, -0.012413025, 0.0049095154, -0.020874023, -0.0446167, -0.026321411, -0.025375366, 0.03955078, 0.030776978, -0.014526367, -0.015045166, -0.015991211, 0.04449463, 0.040283203, -0.008674622, -0.0036449432, 0.04147339, 0.010414124, -0.004760742, 0.061035156, 0.014556885, 0.047302246, 0.042419434, 0.005207062, 0.036224365, -0.011276245, 0.00472641, -0.03866577, -0.00070238113, 0.013687134, -0.0088272095, -0.007545471, 0.0035705566, -0.031585693, 0.03933716, -0.006023407, 0.031173706, -0.005191803, 0.023269653, 0.03567505, -0.002855301, 0.009941101, 0.012519836, -0.0003271103, -0.022140503, -0.014442444, 0.0124435425, 0.033996582, -0.034820557, -0.010360718, 0.021362305, 0.037628174, -0.0065231323, 0.020462036, 0.03213501, 0.013977051, -0.025009155, -0.010848999, -0.035949707, 0.05303955, -0.030136108, -0.026519775, -0.026611328, 0.014411926, -0.043426514, 0.018737793, 0.07342529, -0.011978149, 0.013824463, -0.103759766, 0.005634308, 0.0184021, -0.027923584, 0.0020942688, 0.016174316, 0.029541016, -0.0036067963, -0.03970337, 0.0043258667, -0.04824829, 0.0116119385, 0.0015516281, -0.066101074, -0.022415161, -0.031921387, -0.018127441, -0.061431885, -0.060821533, 0.0005297661, 0.0635376, -0.02470398, -0.0178833, 0.0033912659, -0.012367249, -0.020751953, -0.003528595, -0.028717041, -0.0035419464, 0.019302368, -0.008178711, -0.0011949539, -0.08911133, -0.008331299, -0.00040197372, 0.031951904, -0.0041236877, 0.06555176, -0.0107040405, -0.015556335, 0.0040245056, -0.023452759, 0.0026493073, -0.008857727, 0.012496948, -0.047698975, -0.007762909, -0.0034999847, 0.031799316, 0.0048065186, 0.0064048767, 0.0020332336, -0.030258179, 0.028579712, 0.033599854, -0.0138549805, 0.02029419, 0.04525757, -0.0016317368, 0.0054893494, 0.029708862, 0.014129639, -0.017944336, -0.09979248, 0.019424438, -0.03842163, -0.007980347, -0.05065918, -0.009140015, 0.048797607, -0.07635498, 0.006122589, -0.023544312, -0.019683838, 0.000998497, 0.023345947, -0.008392334, -0.017364502, -0.022354126, -0.015899658, 0.00096845627, 0.0077285767, -0.019729614, 0.009109497, 0.048065186, 0.0048065186, -0.060913086, -0.008811951, -0.018508911, 0.010986328, -0.04675293, -0.025497437, -0.0256958, 0.013252258, 0.02281189, 0.0069618225, 0.0077819824, 0.0021858215, -0.10498047, -0.00356102, 0.042144775, -0.008682251, -0.032348633, 0.023620605, -0.0289917, 0.009170532, 0.011558533, -0.02128601, 0.042297363, 0.0024204254, 0.024642944, -0.022155762, 0.035705566, -0.05697632, 0.020401001, -0.056732178, -0.07244873, 0.034179688, -0.06854248, -0.013801575, 0.03491211, -0.03250122, -0.036499023, -0.027267456, -0.011566162, 0.047088623, 0.06274414, 0.026153564, 0.0178833, 0.002336502, 0.042816162, -0.04321289, -0.023086548, -0.036895752, -0.010215759, -0.00097227097, -0.01940918, 0.046844482, -0.01550293, 0.008758545, -0.060333252, -0.030807495, -0.019607544, 0.010971069, -0.01838684, -0.030014038, -0.023284912, -0.040771484, -0.015792847, -0.033233643, 0.0046806335, 0.013221741, 0.0014314651, 0.002161026, 0.0017318726, 0.009780884, -0.013549805, -0.009216309, -0.028381348, -0.023803711, 0.0007138252, -0.019515991, -0.021087646, -0.008415222, -0.0054855347, 0.03100586, 0.029205322, -0.020553589, -0.051330566, 0.035186768, -0.037139893, 0.0057907104, 0.031555176, -0.008766174, -0.011756897, -0.011940002, -0.0025577545, -0.0030097961, -0.011604309, -0.017501831, 0.019699097, 0.0036239624, -0.0262146, -0.055755615, -0.011550903, 0.0046539307, -0.113586426, -0.046722412, 0.015472412, -0.046936035, -0.012649536, -0.04458618, 0.025741577, -0.035064697, -0.032165527, -0.0056915283, -0.003627777, -0.04711914, 0.023986816, -0.029159546, -0.046569824, 0.09875488, 0.010261536, -0.022003174, 0.038391113, 0.037963867, -0.003786087, -0.04083252, -0.010139465, -0.008514404, 0.038391113, -0.033416748, 0.027816772, 0.05130005, -0.019622803, -0.009216309, 0.068359375, 0.044555664, -0.005241394, -0.0044784546, 0.030059814, 0.035095215, -0.028060913, 0.04055786, 0.033325195, -0.027236938, -0.04248047, -0.012390137, -0.012870789, -0.008117676, 0.01663208, 0.0030822754, 0.0036773682, 0.002319336, 0.021713257, 0.031921387, -0.0035476685, -0.016433716, 0.008666992, 0.0042648315, -0.015472412, 0.0034561157, 0.03665161, 0.010368347, 0.02029419, 0.036743164, -0.008422852, 0.05105591, -0.023651123, 0.01939392, -0.03390503, -0.013160706, -0.04660034, 0.003042221, -0.046142578, -0.046936035, -0.055023193, 0.02458191, -0.011642456, 0.032928467, 0.024398804, -0.008621216, -0.041168213, 0.024124146, 0.016357422, -0.0013999939, 0.0041046143, -0.042144775, 0.0068511963, -0.009185791, -0.07824707, -0.04763794, -0.0033054352, 0.01776123, 0.034179688, -0.011672974, -0.03945923, 0.023651123, 0.026016235, 0.079956055, 0.04699707, -0.00957489, -0.055114746, 0.02734375, -0.03842163, 0.010719299, 0.008361816, 0.016601562, -0.016189575, -0.004398346, 0.026657104, -0.012062073, -0.012237549, -0.047607422, 0.01235199, 0.008491516, 0.021484375, 0.003484726, 0.03475952, 0.024124146, 0.02520752, 0.037261963, 0.024429321, -0.020309448, -0.02520752, 0.010986328, 0.034820557, 0.015266418, 0.0099105835, 0.040985107, 0.01939392, -0.0035705566, 0.009666443, -0.005645752, 0.033233643, -0.012008667, -0.032684326, 0.051757812, -0.02722168, -0.03366089, -0.00699234, 0.0062026978, 0.009056091, -0.058135986, 0.049438477, -0.0071411133, -0.019943237, 0.035339355, -0.006587982, 0.006378174, 0.011665344, -0.0030021667, -0.048095703, -0.02394104, 0.0032157898, 0.014045715, -0.026947021, -0.010292053, -0.009513855, -0.00022315979, 0.02557373, 0.049987793, 0.036590576, -0.025222778, -0.0065612793, -0.016799927, -0.027191162, -0.03567505, -0.041229248, -0.029022217, 0.016830444, 0.03186035, -0.04446411, 0.056549072, -0.04324341, 0.00440979, -0.014213562, -0.006713867, 0.026519775, -0.07928467, -0.009414673, 0.035491943, 0.021896362, -0.007232666, 0.015914917, 0.018157959, 0.019958496, 0.045776367, 0.0066070557, 0.025482178, 0.026687622, -0.017364502, -0.007621765, 0.00819397, 0.045562744, -0.009750366, 0.0077667236, 0.0035533905, -0.012016296, -0.05493164, 0.031951904, -0.0037841797, -0.03842163, 0.02986145, -0.033813477, 0.013748169, 0.0047798157, 0.006713867, 0.024871826, -0.048339844, -0.06506348, -0.041870117, -0.012710571, -0.058807373, 0.021011353, 0.021057129, -0.022277832, -0.07989502, 0.014907837, -0.048309326, -0.008293152, -0.0057296753, 0.022720337, -0.026687622, -0.0042762756, 0.03213501, -0.035949707, 0.02659607, -0.02357483, 0.01335144, 0.037628174, 0.013542175, -0.062286377, -0.0134887695, -0.019454956, -0.04699707, -0.027389526, 0.026473999, 0.025512695, -0.015380859, -0.029922485, -0.019607544, -0.02458191, -0.032989502, 0.013412476, 0.01335144, -0.050445557, 0.012229919, 0.0037269592, 0.01966858, 0.015823364, -0.015823364, 0.005809784, 0.0031929016, -0.00052404404, -0.00027799606, 0.016174316, 0.0026950836, -0.019699097, 0.034301758, -0.042053223, 0.016525269, 0.017944336, -0.0047416687, -0.027999878, 0.0036010742, 0.034851074, -0.018997192, -0.0014429092, -0.004207611, 0.06732178, -0.055023193, -0.012832642, -0.018417358, -0.006828308, -0.029953003, 0.09307861, -0.0028190613, -0.015319824, -0.06341553, -0.068481445, -0.026733398, -0.0048561096, 0.025970459, 0.02078247, 0.031066895, -0.029724121, 0.02835083, -0.024383545, -0.019515991, -0.04586792, 0.012771606, 0.0070533752, -0.015197754, 0.034210205, -0.0020370483, 0.0090408325, 0.0012254715, 0.009567261, -0.00705719, -0.033050537, 0.026306152, -0.056610107, 0.026397705, -0.021499634, 0.005004883, 0.03677368, 0.0037174225, -0.02734375, 0.013786316, -0.0068588257, 0.04269409, 0.029708862, 0.061309814, 0.03338623, 0.013900757, 0.050994873, 0.008834839, 0.02078247, -0.02532959, 0.027648926, -0.056762695, -0.020462036, -0.09118652, -0.04309082, -0.069885254, 0.0014696121, -0.020568848, 0.026397705, 0.0115737915, -0.0010242462, 0.0015029907, -0.0016841888, 0.040740967, -0.0009908676, 0.054473877, 0.023117065, -0.01586914, 0.025848389, 0.047607422, 0.0055160522, 0.015975952, 0.0024662018, 0.031341553, -0.03289795, -0.019607544, 0.019058228, -0.00504303, 0.009246826, -0.01979065, -0.022872925, -0.041107178, 0.03717041, -0.019226074, 0.0026454926, 0.070007324, 0.068725586, -0.0007791519, -0.02861023, 0.024093628, -0.0014352798, -0.02053833, 0.03314209, 0.055664062, -0.09063721, 0.06414795, 0.016601562, -0.037109375, 0.0050315857, 0.009506226, 0.043640137, -0.083618164, -0.045776367, 0.041381836, 0.029403687, -0.0028419495, 0.050994873, -0.03466797, -0.01586914, -0.0037975311, 0.012588501, 0.00025892258, 0.033355713, 0.02470398, 0.026672363, -0.043304443, 0.0071792603, -0.014511108, 0.03857422, -0.07110596, 0.012062073, -0.047821045, 0.045959473, 0.009017944, -0.03540039, 0.007873535, 0.014549255, -0.05505371, -0.002790451, 0.012382507, 0.04336548, 0.07067871, 0.05596924, -0.010551453, -0.018478394, 0.060455322, -0.064575195, 0.013259888, 0.014503479, -0.027008057, 0.011627197, -0.02520752, -0.021057129, 0.03302002, -0.020645142, 0.036590576, -0.035949707, 0.043121338, -0.0013484955, -0.040100098, 0.05722046, -0.04888916, 0.010284424, 0.003955841, -0.05895996, 0.0077590942, 0.017059326, 0.0049591064, 0.014083862, -0.01826477, -0.0056419373, 0.022613525, -0.0018911362, -0.021850586, -0.011116028, -0.042938232, -0.011413574, -0.04309082, 0.025360107, -0.0014019012, -0.01084137, -0.016677856, 0.008430481, 0.00017642975, -0.0014362335, -0.039855957, 0.033721924, 0.004562378, -0.009941101, 0.017425537, 0.035308838, -0.0036067963, -0.009986877, 0.023345947, 0.014083862, -0.013977051, -0.04309082, 0.027404785, -0.01777649, -0.0635376, -0.036712646, -0.020401001, 0.012748718, 0.036071777, -0.00033402443, -0.037872314, 0.03616333, -0.018997192, -0.022827148, -0.00071144104, 0.034973145, -0.020065308, -0.03692627, 0.01739502, 0.036956787, 0.0748291, -0.008399963, -0.016967773, 0.0067634583, -0.01763916, -0.010749817, 0.062194824, 0.019592285, -0.009475708, -0.0006918907, 0.019165039, -0.00818634, -0.017654419, -0.009857178, -0.017837524, 0.033721924, 0.0541687, -0.020263672, -0.0013332367, 0.02998352, -0.0041542053, 0.013771057, 0.018188477, -0.016525269, 0.020874023, -0.008857727, 0.038391113, -0.020812988, -0.0018138885, -0.026519775, 0.031921387, -0.01600647, 0.015426636, -0.033203125, 0.030822754, 0.0090789795, 0.008926392, -0.048858643, 0.0002501011, 0.03579712, 0.027511597, 0.0101623535, 0.04168701, -0.022125244, 0.03414917, 0.00012493134, 0.021621704, -0.0068511963, 0.033203125, 0.0037250519, 0.007080078, 0.032196045, -0.042816162, -0.053131104, -0.0003900528, -0.03265381, 0.0345459, -0.07366943, 0.022003174, -0.036193848, -0.018341064, 0.0023860931, 0.046173096, 0.03781128, -0.025985718, -0.021820068, -0.0057373047, 0.057861328, -0.010002136 ], "summary": [ 0.0056915283, -0.009605408, 0.017074585, 0.0018701553, -0.04244995, 0.007381439, -0.024383545, -0.044921875, -0.042633057, 0.0124435425, -0.009735107, -0.007762909, -0.037384033, -0.029327393, 0.0078048706, -0.06695557, -0.00756073, 0.015213013, 0.02645874, -0.02911377, 0.00258255, -0.061309814, 0.046691895, -0.003435135, 0.022140503, -0.011878967, -0.06213379, 0.017623901, 0.011871338, 0.011917114, 0.006046295, -0.0016174316, 0.008125305, -0.015716553, 0.04534912, 0.0038394928, -0.008911133, -0.0079956055, 0.025558472, -0.02079773, 0.025497437, 0.000022053719, 0.06185913, -0.005104065, -0.010116577, 0.03378296, -0.016983032, -0.011787415, 0.006187439, 0.025268555, 0.0287323, 0.0034828186, 0.023590088, -0.014511108, -0.0068130493, 0.0016241074, -0.052703857, -0.034942627, 0.039031982, 0.064086914, 0.03930664, -0.03463745, -0.0059776306, -0.045928955, -0.019760132, 0.021820068, 0.070617676, -0.018325806, 0.024475098, -0.013015747, -0.0078086853, 0.015853882, 0.020706177, -0.02243042, 0.00093603134, -0.018096924, 0.017654419, -0.0051002502, 0.007820129, 0.0018157959, -0.004257202, 0.04815674, -0.055664062, -0.0016784668, -0.033233643, -0.0059432983, -0.039001465, -0.010597229, -0.043670654, 0.004146576, -0.032989502, 0.0357666, -0.057128906, -0.0012569427, -0.00010716915, -0.009529114, -0.04727173, -0.011421204, -0.015129089, 0.04522705, -0.004383087, -0.009918213, 0.030303955, -0.028396606, -0.050872803, 0.007461548, 0.041503906, 0.022109985, -0.038330078, 0.001461029, -0.049468994, -0.06915283, 0.01499939, -0.01234436, -0.0067253113, 0.008850098, 0.0041618347, 0.031341553, -0.009674072, 0.012489319, 0.0012836456, 0.004802704, 0.011192322, 0.025177002, 0.0063438416, 0.014137268, -0.030776978, -0.015090942, 0.0211792, 0.02658081, -0.009048462, -0.004135132, -0.03817749, 0.013702393, -0.0040130615, -0.006374359, -0.014091492, 0.019088745, -0.00083732605, -0.020568848, 0.056854248, -0.020431519, -0.023757935, 0.06530762, 0.024459839, 0.07501221, 0.021408081, -0.031021118, -0.020050049, -0.031082153, -0.035369873, 0.005970001, -0.0033111572, -0.0013332367, 0.030838013, -0.033050537, -0.044830322, 0.002084732, 0.07507324, 0.029083252, 0.05090332, 0.0012931824, -0.015510559, 0.051116943, 0.034698486, -0.028945923, 0.013038635, 0.015129089, 0.01927185, 0.023513794, 0.03414917, -0.017700195, 0.03137207, 0.01146698, 0.000093221664, 0.008659363, -0.0048599243, 0.035614014, 0.023605347, -0.034820557, 0.0006637573, -0.029190063, 0.05630493, -0.0020656586, -0.031188965, -0.02897644, -0.0028820038, 0.027542114, 0.04559326, 0.015670776, 0.022247314, -0.040100098, -0.042907715, 0.0099105835, -0.0034942627, 0.03366089, -0.04888916, 0.03894043, -0.0146865845, -0.04421997, 0.027526855, 0.015312195, -0.018249512, 0.011512756, -0.034362793, -0.021881104, -0.0041999817, 0.002670288, -0.059509277, 0.01134491, 0.045959473, 0.006164551, -0.054626465, 0.030670166, 0.019729614, -0.032165527, 0.010070801, -0.03857422, 0.0017080307, -0.042175293, 0.0028095245, 0.018798828, -0.035888672, 0.04953003, 0.0026798248, 0.0024719238, -0.030731201, 0.016342163, 0.020355225, 0.017166138, 0.020828247, 0.0074501038, -0.07763672, -0.032684326, -0.040161133, -0.03164673, -0.014183044, -0.017501831, 0.03930664, 0.026611328, -0.00007420778, 0.019378662, -0.03567505, 0.025482178, 0.03866577, -0.022109985, -0.018875122, 0.040252686, -0.029815674, -0.05795288, 0.038970947, 0.0025959015, 0.05203247, 0.024795532, 0.0058937073, 0.04522705, -0.014549255, 0.0076522827, -0.012313843, 0.009529114, -0.014732361, -0.02470398, 0.017471313, -0.024871826, 0.006263733, 0.017959595, 0.036895752, 0.029541016, -0.025497437, 0.004245758, 0.011001587, 0.0184021, 0.01574707, -0.007843018, -0.037078857, -0.023773193, 0.007949829, 0.0077552795, 0.015960693, -0.017181396, 0.018249512, 0.034301758, -0.017913818, -0.008346558, 0.039031982, 0.013664246, -0.0036506653, 0.037017822, 0.02357483, 0.017501831, 0.059417725, -0.046081543, -0.0022411346, -0.03656006, 0.024246216, -0.04537964, -0.01727295, 0.007572174, 0.011489868, -0.031066895, -0.04510498, 0.02810669, 0.01637268, -0.030349731, 0.0039100647, 0.004070282, 0.022079468, 0.0099487305, 0.0057411194, -0.0032863617, -0.025421143, -0.0019512177, 0.01550293, -0.045135498, 0.022262573, 0.004360199, -0.02998352, 0.0040130615, -0.034210205, 0.028167725, 0.10656738, -0.026870728, 0.0017185211, 0.031021118, -0.02128601, -0.05203247, 0.080444336, -0.014579773, -0.021255493, -0.033477783, -0.030349731, -0.06677246, -0.07208252, 0.015365601, 0.016067505, 0.020477295, 0.01676941, 0.077941895, 0.01525116, -0.022125244, 0.037384033, -0.0093307495, -0.017929077, 0.035125732, -0.025817871, -0.00022923946, 0.0067214966, -0.0049095154, 0.0657959, 0.0087509155, -0.018066406, 0.0075569153, -0.025314331, 0.059753418, -0.018066406, -0.0001347065, 0.055480957, 0.05819702, -0.02027893, -0.008026123, 0.014091492, -0.013771057, -0.041137695, -0.11871338, 0.0284729, 0.01737976, -0.002861023, -0.062805176, -0.00023806095, 0.042510986, -0.013946533, 0.025299072, -0.0030975342, -0.020370483, -0.041534424, -0.0024986267, 0.046325684, -0.005207062, 0.031707764, 0.03765869, 0.040863037, 0.026489258, 0.01058197, 0.0063323975, 0.038482666, -0.009635925, -0.062927246, 0.011642456, -0.01184082, 0.024963379, -0.054595947, -0.02331543, -0.007949829, -0.013847351, -0.010536194, -0.0019683838, -0.0096588135, -0.015014648, -0.034606934, -0.01675415, 0.041503906, 0.019332886, 0.0023670197, 0.028427124, -0.008735657, 0.038269043, 0.021759033, -0.0072631836, 0.035888672, -0.078125, 0.05480957, -0.02961731, 0.062347412, -0.065979004, -0.004184723, -0.05795288, -0.021560669, -0.0025310516, -0.065979004, 0.036224365, 0.058898926, -0.038635254, -0.026611328, -0.010467529, 0.037719727, 0.039245605, 0.039276123, -0.010765076, -0.00957489, 0.019958496, 0.054992676, -0.04385376, -0.00043559074, 0.0035076141, -0.0021743774, 0.03201294, -0.0126571655, 0.026138306, 0.010307312, -0.036224365, -0.030059814, -0.022613525, 0.0015201569, 0.009460449, -0.014854431, -0.006122589, -0.018554688, -0.014701843, -0.00078344345, -0.046539307, -0.0007510185, 0.01637268, 0.05795288, 0.0134887695, 0.0034561157, 0.030303955, -0.034729004, -0.0015115738, 0.040283203, -0.026519775, -0.03842163, -0.0049438477, -0.01423645, -0.025726318, 0.017318726, 0.037902832, -0.0138549805, -0.007160187, -0.02998352, 0.017044067, 0.0002503395, -0.026275635, 0.035003662, -0.03363037, -0.0087890625, -0.035186768, 0.052337646, -0.0008068085, 0.014801025, -0.066711426, -0.019485474, 0.0008020401, 0.0004594326, -0.055786133, -0.014190674, 0.004890442, -0.064941406, -0.030517578, 0.00068569183, -0.02154541, 0.012519836, -0.03378296, 0.02684021, -0.014465332, -0.02671814, -0.018066406, 0.01084137, -0.032928467, 0.03793335, 0.014427185, -0.06958008, 0.04711914, -0.015129089, -0.033447266, -0.040161133, 0.051330566, 0.05432129, -0.020050049, -0.020263672, -0.07208252, 0.05053711, -0.07043457, 0.06488037, 0.027053833, 0.0008254051, -0.01499939, 0.06604004, 0.054656982, -0.008911133, -0.02357483, 0.055389404, 0.062316895, -0.0049743652, 0.0009174347, 0.04257202, -0.02003479, -0.010498047, -0.022216797, -0.009681702, 0.0047454834, 0.022460938, 0.03479004, -0.02998352, -0.04449463, 0.040618896, -0.04345703, -0.01876831, -0.00055265427, -0.01424408, 0.0011587143, -0.040008545, -0.020385742, 0.047180176, 0.02319336, 0.006866455, 0.0184021, -0.033416748, 0.027191162, -0.036834717, 0.02029419, -0.019546509, -0.01914978, -0.016616821, -0.014465332, 0.029724121, -0.034729004, -0.025177002, -0.023040771, -0.021774292, 0.05645752, -0.00806427, -0.010978699, -0.011749268, 0.023071289, 0.037963867, 0.018539429, 0.008293152, -0.030929565, -0.015396118, -0.026123047, -0.045318604, -0.009147644, 0.027572632, -0.020431519, 0.01890564, -0.017578125, -0.044830322, 0.03353882, -0.010139465, 0.048919678, 0.03475952, 0.005710602, -0.05368042, 0.026977539, -0.03375244, 0.058135986, -0.008888245, 0.040130615, -0.005569458, 0.03012085, 0.021820068, -0.020370483, 0.004131317, -0.06060791, -0.017990112, 0.018432617, -0.025680542, 0.0020656586, 0.0082092285, 0.008720398, 0.034057617, 0.028182983, 0.023117065, -0.0019388199, -0.0082092285, -0.0071907043, 0.02923584, 0.045654297, -0.011978149, 0.02053833, -0.010971069, -0.020019531, 0.029693604, -0.020355225, 0.031188965, 0.0024051666, -0.021514893, 0.046813965, 0.012229919, -0.050720215, -0.010574341, 0.013832092, -0.028930664, -0.016937256, -0.004863739, 0.033599854, -0.014007568, 0.040496826, -0.023406982, -0.030380249, 0.015930176, -0.039215088, -0.020614624, 0.005657196, 0.00894928, 0.0026664734, -0.005504608, -0.022994995, -0.012763977, -0.00340271, 0.017807007, 0.02734375, -0.016571045, -0.026046753, 0.019042969, -0.00869751, -0.03390503, -0.018844604, -0.01247406, -0.031280518, 0.034240723, 0.023361206, -0.016784668, 0.009361267, 0.002960205, -0.01020813, -0.025390625, 0.0021877289, 0.009033203, -0.049713135, -0.084228516, -0.039886475, 0.015060425, -0.025115967, 0.029067993, 0.0026397705, 0.0047798157, 0.042633057, -0.0036144257, 0.005458832, 0.0062332153, -0.005039215, -0.052703857, -0.011444092, 0.05117798, -0.017349243, 0.0079193115, 0.018203735, -0.020065308, -0.046447754, 0.0041007996, -0.043792725, -0.015991211, 0.008735657, -0.0073242188, 0.0079422, -0.0062217712, 0.01965332, 0.035369873, -0.01259613, -0.047546387, -0.06976318, 0.027832031, -0.08227539, 0.0039482117, 0.029083252, 0.000872612, -0.02357483, -0.02973938, -0.03479004, 0.010772705, 0.016067505, 0.038482666, 0.014640808, -0.03591919, 0.036865234, 0.0058555603, 0.005115509, 0.005367279, 0.024368286, 0.004714966, -0.011627197, -0.04815674, -0.018096924, -0.0259552, -0.011405945, -0.0053367615, 0.022384644, 0.024642944, 0.0073661804, -0.03137207, 0.03237915, -0.00982666, -0.08404541, -0.0011882782, -0.015434265, -0.044677734, -0.008239746, 0.0031280518, -0.0018815994, -0.002861023, -0.07165527, -0.023635864, 0.006389618, -0.004425049, 0.02708435, 0.035095215, -0.012825012, -0.027404785, 0.046325684, 0.0066986084, 0.0066566467, 0.009933472, -0.024093628, -0.0016889572, -0.0031013489, 0.0038986206, 0.023956299, 0.007904053, -0.0054969788, 0.04220581, 0.0046958923, -0.036254883, -0.01625061, 0.020523071, 0.006778717, 0.07019043, 0.009429932, -0.039886475, -0.02458191, -0.04751587, 0.009742737, -0.010604858, -0.012382507, 0.05078125, 0.019317627, 0.0077438354, 0.025482178, 0.005634308, 0.0037631989, -0.024490356, 0.004878998, -0.011894226, -0.015670776, 0.02482605, 0.042297363, 0.0064926147, 0.037231445, 0.0061187744, -0.0013885498, -0.03353882, 0.028839111, -0.057250977, 0.035003662, -0.026428223, 0.04788208, 0.030075073, 0.043945312, -0.06933594, -0.034454346, 0.062194824, 0.051361084, 0.026046753, -0.013916016, -0.019622803, 0.02519226, 0.09008789, -0.006263733, -0.013160706, 0.0040664673, 0.041046143, -0.017288208, -0.0625, -0.08312988, -0.068725586, -0.023010254, 0.039611816, -0.06323242, -0.016433716, 0.013130188, -0.0066833496, -0.026992798, 0.0030403137, -0.0052375793, 0.0025234222, -0.00092077255, 0.03277588, -0.008361816, 0.006134033, 0.021774292, -0.00907135, 0.030914307, -0.00004029274, 0.024963379, -0.008018494, 0.026321411, 0.024871826, -0.062438965, 0.0030574799, -0.053955078, -0.002254486, -0.025772095, 0.026565552, -0.008979797, 0.020904541, 0.048339844, 0.009346008, 0.059387207, -0.043395996, 0.015258789, 0.01889038, -0.03842163, 0.05065918, 0.024932861, -0.020233154, 0.034210205, 0.025848389, -0.040283203, 0.030593872, -0.023651123, 0.09887695, -0.08984375, -0.024261475, 0.038726807, -0.001458168, -0.07836914, 0.021224976, -0.02999878, -0.0049095154, -0.010658264, -0.021362305, 0.013824463, -0.0065193176, 0.010848999, -0.017456055, -0.0011425018, -0.009742737, -0.015945435, 0.039764404, -0.02960205, 0.017333984, -0.029006958, 0.019622803, 0.004875183, -0.02015686, -0.0019702911, 0.023239136, 0.00020670891, 0.018035889, 0.013519287, 0.09674072, 0.09429932, 0.04232788, -0.055999756, 0.023147583, 0.12597656, -0.025054932, 0.024490356, -0.020431519, -0.008804321, -0.049804688, -0.007068634, 0.019134521, -0.022476196, -0.0071372986, 0.0064468384, -0.047210693, 0.045776367, 0.035491943, -0.089782715, 0.027740479, 0.026535034, -0.005695343, 0.014984131, -0.07550049, 0.022964478, 0.045654297, 0.0001784563, 0.011779785, -0.03753662, -0.02923584, -0.007247925, -0.022369385, 0.0048217773, 0.009536743, -0.034118652, -0.062927246, -0.016799927, -0.02279663, 0.0064430237, -0.031677246, 0.00724411, 0.016784668, 0.036590576, -0.0063667297, -0.04949951, 0.06567383, 0.032714844, -0.011947632, 0.024856567, 0.02935791, -0.013870239, -0.022369385, 0.036468506, 0.007972717, -0.0181427, -0.042877197, 0.014190674, 0.011413574, -0.056121826, -0.037597656, -0.008728027, -0.013870239, 0.029541016, -0.017868042, -0.059783936, 0.044830322, -0.034973145, -0.037017822, -0.010185242, 0.010093689, -0.058441162, -0.037109375, 0.018844604, 0.00982666, 0.04434204, 0.008377075, 0.03366089, 0.011894226, -0.016693115, -0.006072998, 0.02897644, 0.012031555, -0.0005364418, 0.01838684, 0.01802063, -0.008666992, -0.022399902, 0.041290283, 0.007270813, 0.010910034, 0.03515625, -0.02468872, 0.0181427, 0.022399902, -0.008117676, 0.011238098, -0.0008778572, -0.029281616, 0.00042653084, -0.009216309, 0.024749756, -0.014717102, 0.02722168, -0.0072135925, -0.029693604, -0.0030021667, -0.029464722, -0.030593872, 0.015701294, -0.04937744, -0.010368347, -0.049438477, 0.06854248, -0.018844604, -0.00198555, 0.007858276, 0.0009326935, -0.012496948, 0.062408447, 0.015380859, 0.020980835, 0.02670288, 0.011657715, -0.03527832, 0.045837402, 0.023452759, -0.040802002, -0.042419434, -0.027267456, -0.03640747, 0.022460938, -0.05154419, 0.021438599, 0.010314941, -0.020690918, 0.023132324, 0.036987305, 0.011245728, 0.019012451, 0.0134887695, 0.0014352798, -0.00023663044, 0.00737381 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2102.04062v3
An Update on a Progressively Expanded Database for Automated Lung Sound Analysis
Fu-Shun Hsu, Shang-Ran Huang, Chien-Wen Huang, Yuan-Ren Cheng, Chun-Chieh Chen, Jack Hsiao, Chung-Wei Chen, Feipei Lai
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS
Purpose: We previously established an open-access lung sound database, HF_Lung_V1, and developed deep learning models for inhalation, exhalation, continuous adventitious sound (CAS), and discontinuous adventitious sound (DAS) detection. The amount of data used for training contributes to model accuracy. Herein, we collected larger quantities of data to further improve model performance. Moreover, the issues of noisy labels and sound overlapping were explored. Methods: HF_Lung_V1 was expanded to HF_Lung_V2 with a 1.45x increase in the number of audio files. Convolutional neural network-bidirectional gated recurrent unit network models were trained separately using the HF_Lung_V1 (V1_Train) and HF_Lung_V2 (V2_Train) training sets and then tested using the HF_Lung_V1 (V1_Test) and HF_Lung_V2 (V2_Test) test sets, respectively. Segment and event detection performance was evaluated using the F1 scores. Label quality was assessed. Moreover, the overlap ratios between inhalation, exhalation, CAS, and DAS labels were computed. Results: The model trained using V2_Train exhibited improved F1 scores in inhalation, exhalation, and CAS detection on both V1_Test and V2_Test but not in DAS detection. Poor CAS detection was attributed to the quality of CAS labels. DAS detection was strongly influenced by the overlapping of DAS labels with inhalation and exhalation labels. Conclusion: Collecting greater quantities of lung sound data is vital for developing more accurate lung sound analysis models. To build real ground-truth labels, the labels must be reworked; this process is ongoing. Furthermore, a method for addressing the sound overlapping problem in DAS detection must be formulated.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2102.04062v3
"2021-09-29T06:11:41"
"2021-02-08T08:52:17"
{ "title": [ 0.0011663437, -0.00806427, -0.032165527, -0.099731445, 0.010864258, 0.0012750626, -0.054534912, 0.0016698837, -0.0073509216, 0.029510498, -0.027709961, 0.029510498, -0.005592346, -0.02053833, -0.025665283, -0.0016727448, 0.0061569214, 0.010902405, -0.02279663, -0.028945923, 0.006198883, -0.040161133, 0.023010254, 0.05895996, 0.012573242, 0.021728516, -0.057037354, 0.0021915436, -0.044769287, -0.057769775, -0.014549255, 0.050964355, 0.015823364, 0.074523926, -0.05343628, 0.032806396, -0.049072266, 0.059326172, 0.012283325, 0.005935669, 0.016647339, -0.011817932, 0.02017212, -0.025146484, -0.011177063, 0.030075073, -0.02949524, -0.010627747, -0.013305664, -0.0048713684, 0.020309448, 0.022064209, 0.03527832, 0.025314331, -0.00021362305, -0.024658203, -0.015426636, 0.049316406, 0.03842163, 0.00006979704, -0.0060272217, -0.00447464, 0.024963379, 0.0059165955, -0.04638672, -0.0023384094, 0.014343262, 0.020080566, 0.07623291, -0.03237915, -0.033111572, 0.030151367, -0.0027122498, 0.0033435822, -0.037384033, -0.0044059753, 0.04043579, 0.000117480755, 0.048980713, -0.02798462, 0.029541016, -0.015068054, 0.03982544, 0.0072784424, -0.0033855438, -0.0059165955, -0.0029830933, -0.014312744, -0.026290894, -0.05117798, -0.0055236816, -0.008003235, -0.016845703, -0.004207611, -0.033721924, -0.044311523, -0.011627197, 0.006652832, 0.0048065186, -0.005794525, -0.0039711, -0.00036859512, -0.013847351, -0.016494751, -0.006542206, 0.043304443, -0.021636963, -0.0703125, -0.02355957, 0.031677246, -0.016540527, -0.034851074, -0.00075626373, -0.0473938, -0.0014724731, 0.023269653, 0.012557983, -0.00038433075, 0.05090332, -0.036315918, 0.013511658, -0.002811432, 0.032836914, -0.007911682, 0.020629883, 0.02218628, -0.03869629, -0.052215576, -0.07128906, 0.060058594, 0.041992188, 0.020965576, -0.13305664, -0.058654785, -0.064208984, 0.02243042, 0.014030457, 0.0018758774, -0.028244019, 0.017425537, 0.017715454, -0.021469116, -0.00038719177, 0.014251709, -0.0063552856, -0.020141602, 0.05130005, 0.025863647, -0.047546387, -0.021987915, -0.02947998, 0.06878662, 0.04119873, 0.0045928955, -0.06652832, -0.018737793, -0.08319092, -0.025634766, 0.009178162, -0.022613525, 0.027053833, -0.008277893, -0.030029297, 0.019943237, 0.012489319, 0.023620605, 0.024475098, 0.021514893, 0.018508911, 0.027130127, 0.009796143, 0.029663086, 0.07244873, -0.013702393, -0.0074768066, -0.020248413, 0.029907227, 0.020965576, 0.033966064, -0.030944824, -0.022125244, -0.027328491, 0.028335571, -0.0063095093, -0.058441162, -0.041809082, 0.013572693, 0.011672974, 0.05432129, 0.009811401, -0.015838623, 0.011230469, -0.009017944, -0.028305054, -0.050048828, -0.022521973, 0.025543213, 0.0262146, -0.036865234, 0.02154541, -0.053894043, 0.018554688, -0.029830933, 0.04547119, 0.028381348, -0.022598267, 0.005683899, 0.0044441223, 0.021331787, 0.054901123, 0.015945435, -0.006652832, -0.016174316, 0.016433716, -0.011817932, -0.039276123, 0.014427185, 0.018997192, -0.01727295, 0.01537323, -0.058898926, -0.020523071, -0.022903442, 0.01878357, 0.009689331, 0.002002716, -0.008605957, -0.017791748, 0.0055999756, 0.02279663, 0.017974854, -0.0076828003, 0.0019521713, 0.016143799, -0.0040016174, -0.026382446, -0.007423401, -0.004547119, 0.029327393, -0.001200676, 0.00022006035, -0.018081665, -0.012245178, 0.021514893, 0.028778076, -0.0016641617, 0.025772095, 0.01889038, 0.016830444, 0.015411377, 0.047546387, -0.0045433044, 0.0335083, 0.0041160583, 0.010391235, 0.026550293, -0.017333984, -0.024597168, -0.00907135, -0.030426025, 0.0418396, -0.029022217, -0.047027588, 0.008483887, 0.0065994263, 0.0000025629997, 0.0071487427, 0.027526855, 0.0023059845, 0.02772522, 0.02053833, -0.03942871, 0.024215698, 0.038269043, -0.0039711, 0.020462036, -0.010925293, -0.014511108, 0.006336212, -0.002374649, -0.018737793, -0.01020813, 0.06173706, 0.004058838, -0.014602661, -0.024551392, 0.07537842, 0.023254395, -0.043426514, -0.054351807, 0.010437012, 0.034698486, 0.0028133392, -0.020401001, 0.02798462, 0.0045204163, 0.054351807, 0.056762695, -0.02748108, 0.030349731, -0.04385376, 0.0065574646, 0.02508545, -0.027923584, 0.0029506683, 0.027038574, 0.0061187744, 0.00932312, -0.014251709, -0.020462036, -0.018249512, 0.032348633, 0.0047187805, -0.0069389343, -0.064086914, -0.078063965, -0.055603027, -0.04107666, -0.07873535, 0.0072898865, 0.0143585205, -0.008415222, -0.016357422, -0.037475586, 0.014411926, -0.005558014, -0.06744385, -0.007881165, 0.01612854, 0.022781372, 0.022842407, 0.0032577515, -0.07196045, -0.049438477, 0.013900757, 0.012634277, -0.0077209473, 0.020858765, -0.031707764, -0.0027637482, 0.00642395, -0.012771606, 0.021835327, -0.0077438354, -0.0129852295, -0.038330078, 0.019515991, -0.0027008057, -0.026473999, 0.00217247, 0.02519226, -0.0073280334, -0.0079193115, -0.012138367, 0.051513672, 0.00019288063, -0.022338867, 0.0037975311, 0.018463135, -0.028808594, 0.052246094, 0.036102295, 0.039764404, -0.02545166, -0.04888916, -0.06628418, 0.00982666, -0.000066936016, -0.010475159, 0.044433594, -0.06506348, -0.034820557, -0.034210205, 0.011833191, 0.032165527, 0.02960205, -0.011039734, -0.03970337, -0.02432251, -0.02305603, 0.0032787323, 0.014587402, -0.037231445, 0.023742676, 0.09893799, 0.012901306, 0.041809082, 0.03253174, 0.018417358, -0.019866943, -0.035491943, -0.027328491, -0.010650635, -0.02607727, -0.0008459091, 0.018859863, -0.009384155, -0.008178711, -0.04284668, 0.022201538, 0.04663086, -0.005947113, -0.049987793, 0.021316528, -0.035064697, -0.02557373, 0.01890564, -0.019729614, 0.028549194, 0.031234741, -0.012802124, 0.040649414, -0.01033783, -0.0048065186, 0.00009715557, -0.04498291, -0.091796875, 0.03048706, -0.0015993118, -0.013244629, 0.015144348, -0.03366089, -0.018875122, 0.012260437, -0.02192688, 0.062042236, 0.018859863, 0.018844604, 0.005332947, -0.026046753, 0.00868988, -0.036865234, -0.01713562, -0.045318604, 0.012519836, 0.047180176, -0.026550293, 0.08514404, -0.051635742, 0.0368042, -0.006389618, 0.019165039, 0.013839722, 0.04537964, -0.020477295, -0.04043579, 0.018356323, 0.015052795, -0.010681152, 0.012275696, 0.0030384064, -0.0048675537, -0.039154053, -0.0009050369, -0.03451538, 0.020584106, 0.012031555, 0.028060913, -0.009819031, -0.02166748, 0.003616333, -0.040283203, -0.047668457, 0.007472992, -0.013679504, 0.02494812, -0.008781433, -0.0010061264, -0.012252808, -0.008125305, -0.018997192, 0.046905518, -0.0062713623, -0.029556274, 0.0008125305, -0.025238037, -0.008407593, -0.01020813, 0.018341064, -0.0073013306, -0.05657959, 0.024780273, -0.01285553, -0.038604736, -0.008407593, 0.013252258, -0.022369385, -0.008834839, 0.020141602, -0.04650879, -0.010734558, -0.041625977, 0.02923584, -0.04727173, -0.017807007, -0.00598526, -0.0041389465, -0.02810669, 0.0011997223, -0.08477783, -0.041229248, 0.08166504, 0.019622803, 0.008735657, 0.035888672, -0.018692017, -0.017288208, -0.022872925, 0.018814087, 0.03503418, 0.02758789, 0.017822266, -0.016067505, 0.053588867, -0.043304443, 0.018005371, 0.02406311, 0.011978149, -0.004638672, 0.008155823, 0.0073127747, -0.0042800903, 0.012771606, 0.06524658, -0.0149383545, -0.011352539, -0.043273926, 0.0033245087, -0.021072388, -0.0010328293, 0.009185791, 0.0024662018, 0.015808105, 0.00121212, 0.036254883, 0.029876709, -0.0046577454, 0.009353638, -0.019882202, -0.07104492, -0.008590698, 0.042938232, 0.0256958, -0.020355225, -0.0042533875, 0.0039863586, -0.03668213, 0.004169464, -0.0054130554, -0.028930664, -0.008277893, 0.0078048706, -0.022766113, -0.023269653, -0.06161499, -0.08251953, -0.05340576, 0.014930725, 0.0030899048, 0.04373169, 0.03286743, 0.026626587, -0.025299072, -0.03225708, 0.057373047, 0.009140015, 0.0071754456, -0.047088623, 0.016021729, -0.014541626, -0.045898438, -0.04800415, 0.0011730194, 0.031021118, 0.04019165, -0.00056409836, -0.04244995, -0.014373779, 0.009429932, 0.02017212, 0.04824829, -0.027252197, -0.084350586, -0.06112671, -0.050079346, -0.029037476, 0.028198242, 0.004016876, -0.025970459, -0.046325684, 0.021743774, -0.008514404, 0.0016307831, -0.008872986, 0.0027236938, -0.042175293, 0.06317139, -0.03543091, -0.006454468, 0.0072402954, 0.011528015, -0.01134491, -0.008010864, -0.03866577, 0.043304443, -0.03363037, 0.046051025, -0.03466797, 0.022247314, 0.06088257, 0.010955811, -0.05505371, 0.020980835, 0.016159058, 0.047058105, 0.0039138794, -0.049346924, 0.03652954, -0.06304932, -0.033081055, -0.028137207, -0.02619934, 0.025558472, -0.06451416, 0.0019321442, 0.008171082, 0.022491455, 0.038757324, -0.020050049, 0.015670776, -0.0014362335, 0.012580872, -0.055358887, -0.06237793, -0.0028877258, 0.06982422, -0.03250122, 0.0070343018, -0.012184143, 0.0038013458, -0.008590698, 0.023468018, 0.009063721, 0.058380127, -0.04071045, -0.005996704, 0.0041122437, -0.04724121, -0.045562744, -0.0075645447, 0.0014333725, 0.0023937225, 0.025924683, -0.013145447, -0.08129883, -0.018295288, -0.010360718, -0.022399902, 0.008491516, -0.0647583, 0.031829834, 0.057037354, 0.002073288, 0.027374268, -0.0149002075, 0.017745972, 0.060943604, 0.04019165, 0.011680603, 0.0042762756, 0.031707764, -0.001162529, -0.017929077, 0.0064811707, 0.028656006, -0.013687134, 0.015686035, 0.01222229, -0.0140686035, -0.048858643, 0.005443573, 0.036895752, 0.028900146, -0.00919342, -0.03878784, 0.04510498, 0.0075531006, -0.057006836, 0.031021118, -0.041748047, -0.025238037, 0.004459381, 0.008079529, -0.02810669, 0.013717651, 0.026565552, -0.02154541, 0.0032463074, 0.04953003, -0.020614624, -0.028213501, 0.026168823, 0.0009083748, -0.011634827, 0.037384033, 0.01247406, -0.07147217, -0.000022113323, -0.04147339, -0.0026760101, 0.020126343, 0.030776978, -0.051116943, -0.017822266, 0.026824951, -0.055389404, -0.045135498, 0.021484375, -0.00340271, -0.028533936, 0.008743286, -0.042816162, 0.0104599, 0.0011024475, 0.028579712, -0.004047394, -0.0035476685, 0.03933716, 0.01625061, 0.03768921, 0.012290955, 0.00052785873, 0.046966553, -0.0015916824, -0.0042381287, -0.041015625, 0.039398193, 0.019332886, 0.03366089, 0.0075263977, -0.059661865, 0.011039734, 0.016357422, -0.007888794, -0.042144775, -0.006717682, 0.018951416, -0.00012981892, -0.020355225, -0.01902771, 0.06994629, -0.0385437, -0.06732178, -0.019851685, -0.005596161, 0.014465332, 0.11315918, -0.026260376, -0.06744385, -0.039978027, -0.06390381, -0.02645874, -0.0008406639, 0.018234253, 0.038208008, 0.022506714, -0.038604736, 0.012687683, -0.06524658, -0.0043258667, -0.03149414, 0.012863159, -0.023880005, -0.009590149, 0.027191162, -0.0014591217, 0.01272583, -0.01876831, 0.010620117, -0.0052223206, -0.022537231, 0.009796143, -0.029556274, 0.018371582, -0.04043579, 0.0017910004, 0.024734497, 0.040863037, -0.05697632, 0.017745972, -0.02305603, 0.05834961, 0.022384644, 0.03555298, 0.020324707, -0.011405945, 0.030944824, -0.0002297163, -0.038726807, -0.037963867, 0.0031337738, -0.06341553, 0.030700684, -0.004623413, 0.0154418945, -0.048217773, -0.0067443848, 0.05090332, 0.042510986, -0.010398865, 0.008880615, 0.023468018, 0.0049819946, 0.0496521, 0.00032567978, 0.08294678, -0.015686035, -0.013084412, -0.017181396, 0.005760193, 0.032409668, 0.030548096, 0.012710571, 0.004676819, -0.012924194, -0.012763977, 0.0034561157, 0.0005979538, 0.010795593, -0.015274048, 0.018234253, -0.011878967, 0.044647217, -0.005039215, -0.0036010742, 0.07183838, 0.04788208, 0.022918701, -0.034698486, 0.026611328, 0.023925781, -0.028335571, 0.0034008026, 0.053741455, -0.058441162, -0.0009121895, -0.02923584, -0.029312134, -0.03744507, 0.06616211, -0.007713318, -0.021469116, -0.0015773773, 0.0043525696, 0.029006958, 0.031311035, 0.036956787, -0.027832031, -0.03353882, -0.010650635, 0.011772156, -0.013305664, 0.006839752, 0.016586304, 0.03994751, 0.0066070557, 0.003545761, 0.0019664764, 0.0030117035, -0.022415161, 0.022750854, -0.0014762878, 0.034057617, -0.04446411, -0.052947998, 0.01777649, -0.005592346, -0.022598267, -0.04373169, 0.0647583, -0.0118255615, -0.027359009, 0.04159546, 0.02746582, -0.027389526, -0.06573486, -0.007820129, -0.000108003616, 0.0024585724, -0.030456543, -0.016448975, -0.0071029663, -0.032196045, 0.022079468, -0.038635254, 0.0670166, -0.03665161, -0.022949219, -0.04751587, 0.056640625, -0.018432617, -0.019561768, -0.019805908, -0.028289795, -0.0043029785, -0.021148682, -0.018447876, -0.0072135925, -0.026763916, -0.028945923, 0.044281006, 0.0036258698, -0.013511658, 0.008766174, -0.01083374, -0.04550171, -0.0017766953, -0.025344849, 0.03744507, -0.029571533, -0.018096924, -0.034942627, -0.022354126, 0.023849487, 0.06573486, -0.0055999756, 0.033294678, -0.0770874, -0.010253906, -0.009979248, 0.015060425, -0.023742676, -0.033111572, -0.011268616, 0.019515991, -0.038024902, -0.002538681, 0.036071777, -0.03668213, -0.06237793, -0.00869751, -0.04083252, 0.028839111, 0.011810303, -0.016738892, -0.008155823, 0.020736694, -0.025253296, -0.01689148, -0.0026626587, 0.03768921, -0.028823853, -0.05102539, -0.00041937828, 0.028945923, 0.050964355, -0.04650879, -0.04156494, 0.026641846, 0.04748535, -0.02027893, 0.01876831, 0.0011758804, 0.003271103, 0.0124435425, 0.029327393, 0.012969971, -0.054534912, -0.030776978, -0.008628845, 0.05545044, 0.036956787, -0.023162842, 0.013175964, 0.04168701, -0.044128418, 0.012718201, -0.032104492, -0.021057129, 0.012023926, -0.02571106, 0.0077781677, -0.0034255981, 0.0024700165, -0.038757324, 0.012184143, 0.00084495544, 0.006500244, -0.02243042, 0.029571533, -0.01247406, 0.034362793, 0.02609253, 0.016418457, 0.028671265, -0.00037670135, 0.050628662, -0.024932861, 0.029464722, 0.0011978149, -0.0061416626, -0.013008118, 0.01335907, -0.015586853, 0.0158844, -0.029281616, 0.01260376, -0.04019165, -0.04486084, -0.0135650635, -0.038726807, 0.021499634, -0.007160187, 0.007659912, 0.0055885315, -0.0119018555, 0.016143799, 0.023483276, 0.042022705, -0.004749298, -0.056854248, -0.053466797, 0.02053833, -0.026641846 ], "summary": [ 0.025817871, 0.019439697, -0.036834717, -0.02861023, -0.0047836304, -0.017211914, -0.050354004, -0.04248047, 0.015007019, 0.022491455, -0.036102295, 0.0048103333, -0.0012187958, -0.027175903, -0.010887146, -0.02671814, -0.0011978149, 0.026916504, 0.015380859, -0.010406494, 0.013214111, -0.015296936, -0.0143585205, 0.025360107, 0.0012798309, -0.004005432, -0.0023097992, 0.02281189, -0.027542114, -0.01676941, 0.0036411285, 0.040863037, 0.010696411, 0.05517578, -0.05279541, -0.008598328, -0.05001831, 0.041046143, 0.018112183, -0.012184143, 0.040893555, -0.030288696, 0.12286377, -0.03967285, 0.034210205, 0.079833984, -0.00831604, -0.04525757, -0.0017023087, 0.0048217773, 0.014289856, 0.004764557, 0.0068244934, -0.0041503906, 0.0010137558, -0.002811432, -0.042999268, 0.039398193, 0.028671265, 0.009567261, -0.015655518, -0.024917603, 0.008522034, -0.026855469, -0.04336548, -0.0016498566, 0.061584473, -0.013824463, 0.047088623, -0.042022705, -0.006336212, 0.04196167, 0.0074539185, -0.01184845, -0.020401001, -0.020904541, 0.041046143, 0.013755798, 0.011169434, -0.019577026, 0.06567383, 0.016693115, 0.05267334, 0.037506104, -0.021026611, 0.01600647, 0.00083065033, -0.034973145, -0.020492554, 0.0053634644, -0.016830444, -0.021255493, -0.03314209, 0.054504395, 0.018585205, -0.0075569153, 0.0071640015, 0.020812988, -0.0070724487, -0.0057411194, 0.018997192, -0.037963867, 0.0178833, -0.020706177, 0.018035889, 0.025344849, -0.07110596, -0.08508301, 0.028625488, 0.029296875, -0.010917664, -0.0619812, -0.014122009, -0.07501221, -0.00071287155, 0.07562256, 0.045654297, -0.000477314, 0.03768921, -0.02017212, 0.01159668, 0.023391724, 0.0014486313, 0.048583984, 0.022338867, 0.052612305, 0.012466431, -0.047698975, -0.055511475, 0.034606934, 0.056884766, 0.011619568, -0.08721924, 0.012268066, -0.053710938, 0.002696991, 0.018188477, 0.015899658, -0.0021533966, -0.021621704, 0.04083252, -0.007881165, -0.010673523, 0.030776978, -0.017684937, 0.01876831, 0.027954102, 0.007701874, -0.023834229, -0.019561768, -0.026779175, 0.03765869, 0.089782715, -0.028671265, -0.111572266, -0.06121826, -0.047027588, -0.018157959, -0.032104492, -0.08770752, 0.0637207, -0.006134033, -0.0050468445, 0.085754395, 0.014160156, 0.0112838745, -0.011909485, -0.0035953522, 0.009643555, -0.03086853, 0.03842163, 0.024932861, 0.011940002, -0.013511658, 0.021469116, -0.02217102, 0.02558899, 0.040008545, 0.04196167, -0.03302002, -0.034118652, -0.038391113, 0.093811035, -0.04550171, -0.0029582977, -0.03543091, 0.008270264, 0.008621216, 0.037719727, 0.016113281, -0.003490448, -0.011375427, 0.021636963, -0.0055656433, -0.033355713, -0.023651123, -0.0000113248825, 0.017486572, -0.046203613, 0.012062073, -0.037353516, 0.020935059, -0.016860962, 0.019332886, 0.019042969, -0.006252289, 0.018600464, 0.0065460205, -0.039764404, 0.020904541, 0.031173706, -0.025268555, -0.036590576, 0.022735596, 0.0390625, 0.012794495, 0.0284729, 0.028457642, -0.020706177, 0.039794922, -0.034942627, -0.03805542, -0.04647827, 0.018157959, -0.015701294, -0.036865234, 0.011268616, -0.009857178, -0.02279663, 0.027191162, -0.016723633, -0.03503418, 0.009765625, -0.011512756, -0.016967773, 0.0076446533, 0.021438599, -0.034698486, -0.0012512207, 0.03668213, 0.013626099, 0.016571045, -0.03152466, 0.012535095, 0.025848389, -0.00674057, 0.010383606, -0.0036792755, -0.013442993, -0.006969452, 0.033325195, 0.012062073, 0.016464233, -0.0287323, 0.00541687, 0.01689148, -0.02532959, -0.06939697, 0.03665161, -0.036071777, 0.028411865, -0.048339844, -0.05480957, -0.0008420944, -0.017105103, -0.024368286, -0.011665344, -0.014503479, -0.019866943, 0.0068893433, 0.028533936, -0.03173828, 0.012001038, 0.021820068, -0.012535095, -0.012138367, -0.015563965, 0.0018615723, 0.014953613, -0.0025081635, 0.009567261, 0.0028209686, -0.004219055, -0.0033302307, 0.013313293, -0.0126571655, 0.022888184, 0.043640137, -0.047027588, -0.03753662, -0.028701782, 0.03970337, -0.00076818466, -0.0055351257, 0.057525635, -0.011962891, -0.003856659, 0.034454346, -0.0063667297, -0.013031006, -0.026687622, 0.013999939, -0.006412506, -0.009132385, -0.013328552, 0.021697998, 0.0042800903, -0.006465912, 0.00573349, -0.03253174, -0.008811951, 0.04385376, 0.018371582, 0.07836914, -0.06713867, -0.07489014, -0.053771973, 0.038757324, -0.0423584, 0.026000977, 0.06738281, -0.013641357, 0.027328491, -0.014572144, 0.012870789, -0.057403564, -0.008079529, -0.007789612, 0.03213501, -0.0035076141, 0.031585693, 0.019073486, -0.02734375, -0.03768921, 0.021499634, -0.0021324158, 0.023498535, -0.0090408325, -0.011329651, -0.029251099, 0.037750244, -0.042633057, -0.0010280609, 0.042510986, -0.037017822, -0.0011949539, 0.01902771, -0.008682251, -0.019973755, 0.0016498566, 0.0011100769, -0.008987427, -0.0026741028, 0.020080566, 0.0037956238, 0.065979004, 0.0064888, 0.0018253326, 0.017669678, -0.04864502, 0.034332275, 0.032104492, 0.013244629, -0.07269287, -0.04537964, -0.030670166, -0.007972717, -0.019607544, 0.0053138733, 0.048675537, -0.051727295, 0.012924194, 0.012145996, 0.002691269, -0.007247925, 0.025650024, -0.0046081543, -0.036865234, -0.020263672, 0.004787445, 0.0076179504, 0.0075950623, 0.0023002625, 0.028289795, 0.0914917, -0.015686035, 0.03643799, 0.042175293, 0.07385254, -0.019439697, 0.009239197, -0.0031108856, -0.0012693405, -0.01977539, 0.05609131, 0.03729248, -0.01247406, -0.010871887, -0.036102295, -0.025741577, -0.0039787292, 0.009132385, -0.010414124, -0.0052490234, -0.009819031, -0.018249512, 0.010055542, -0.027236938, 0.024597168, -0.023391724, 0.01902771, 0.0077781677, -0.00037002563, 0.0015144348, -0.0075683594, -0.044677734, 0.012512207, 0.013389587, -0.016677856, -0.013404846, 0.0057792664, 0.027435303, 0.0024662018, 0.0069732666, 0.014968872, 0.03253174, -0.0007185936, -0.01878357, 0.03250122, 0.010520935, 0.005290985, -0.0044784546, 0.004928589, -0.028427124, 0.010894775, 0.06768799, -0.012382507, 0.06213379, -0.023086548, -0.008308411, -0.050720215, 0.004047394, 0.017578125, 0.026046753, 0.010688782, -0.023406982, 0.022491455, -0.027877808, 0.006778717, 0.0013885498, -0.012626648, -0.024215698, 0.01008606, 0.025680542, -0.034606934, 0.049316406, -0.043273926, 0.0046577454, 0.027175903, -0.024612427, -0.018722534, -0.011993408, -0.03286743, -0.027862549, 0.007797241, 0.008743286, -0.038024902, -0.0066184998, -0.017440796, -0.00015163422, -0.00068187714, 0.047698975, -0.011054993, -0.040039062, -0.006416321, -0.078308105, 0.037384033, -0.009002686, 0.06713867, -0.028961182, -0.08441162, 0.039245605, -0.0287323, -0.016098022, 0.007080078, 0.013549805, 0.034179688, -0.009483337, 0.023361206, -0.035736084, 0.023742676, -0.04058838, 0.035125732, -0.026641846, -0.01373291, -0.024383545, -0.025497437, 0.045959473, -0.019210815, -0.08380127, 0.021743774, -0.026687622, 0.06329346, 0.043762207, -0.025314331, -0.012504578, -0.0031719208, 0.009056091, 0.027648926, 0.017745972, -0.026000977, -0.003780365, 0.0057792664, 0.039978027, -0.027694702, 0.029937744, 0.011817932, 0.09277344, -0.03164673, -0.030883789, 0.023834229, 0.026916504, 0.06365967, 0.028747559, -0.05831909, -0.012237549, 0.021514893, -0.010475159, -0.033843994, -0.0032920837, 0.019332886, 0.040039062, 0.004310608, -0.014984131, 0.027862549, -0.013061523, -0.04272461, -0.01977539, -0.024475098, -0.01675415, -0.033966064, 0.026687622, 0.03111267, 0.0073509216, -0.021438599, 0.05731201, -0.016998291, 0.0061569214, -0.018539429, -0.030731201, -0.014884949, 0.018859863, 0.0055122375, -0.024291992, -0.012863159, -0.034118652, -0.01158905, -0.005870819, 0.0082092285, 0.04586792, -0.018371582, 0.023269653, 0.015579224, -0.048095703, 0.038360596, 0.03805542, -0.036193848, -0.056640625, -0.029678345, -0.03744507, -0.047607422, -0.02420044, -0.04940796, -0.043823242, -0.0018978119, 0.02218628, -0.033477783, -0.003604889, -0.0010490417, 0.020401001, 0.03479004, -0.017593384, -0.089660645, -0.08807373, -0.053344727, -0.0026416779, 0.01121521, 0.0047721863, -0.018127441, -0.0020599365, 0.03579712, -0.027404785, 0.0076446533, -0.020629883, -0.031280518, -0.019638062, 0.028411865, 0.0065956116, 0.015853882, -0.0015268326, 0.0011825562, 0.01701355, 0.0047912598, -0.0048179626, -0.016189575, 0.012275696, 0.0028324127, 0.02279663, 0.026657104, 0.07598877, -0.012802124, -0.09448242, 0.033813477, 0.034484863, 0.054473877, -0.023773193, -0.036102295, 0.026062012, -0.022781372, -0.011917114, -0.0064468384, -0.025115967, 0.015281677, -0.040649414, 0.0024585724, 0.009170532, -0.008773804, 0.032226562, -0.014968872, -0.013519287, 0.02458191, -0.03289795, -0.057250977, -0.053527832, -0.02029419, 0.084228516, -0.023284912, -0.0317688, -0.035949707, -0.03125, 0.01234436, -0.009765625, 0.005874634, 0.025268555, -0.019821167, 0.00077724457, 0.016860962, -0.0040740967, 0.002368927, -0.024139404, 0.012374878, -0.0062217712, -0.015563965, -0.031677246, 0.028640747, -0.03717041, 0.00422287, 0.010765076, 0.02558899, -0.034088135, -0.01247406, 0.044128418, -0.011772156, -0.015159607, -0.0033607483, 0.0046691895, 0.0357666, -0.0030326843, 0.007663727, -0.03488159, -0.027130127, 0.0041236877, -0.022872925, 0.024291992, 0.004398346, 0.010093689, 0.012840271, 0.0085372925, -0.031921387, 0.020248413, -0.014854431, -0.039520264, 0.039916992, -0.030670166, 0.007873535, 0.035491943, 0.029922485, -0.014228821, 0.018676758, -0.024047852, -0.0018844604, 0.020645142, 0.0027484894, -0.0012645721, -0.00061511993, 0.020126343, -0.044189453, 0.00945282, 0.061798096, -0.017089844, -0.006679535, -0.00031900406, -0.0413208, -0.031921387, -0.011581421, 0.01033783, -0.050201416, -0.0027446747, -0.0044059753, 0.019485474, -0.0234375, -0.010375977, -0.050354004, -0.025177002, 0.062805176, -0.03643799, -0.018844604, 0.03665161, -0.0050468445, -0.058807373, 0.02053833, -0.009239197, 0.009811401, 0.02067566, 0.025817871, -0.037109375, -0.020599365, 0.05987549, -0.016067505, 0.002779007, -0.00000923872, -0.034210205, 0.02861023, -0.011894226, -0.0054512024, -0.057159424, 0.028259277, 0.020248413, 0.068359375, 0.027954102, -0.026733398, 0.008392334, 0.044769287, 0.010520935, -0.033813477, 0.013366699, 0.0033245087, -0.031311035, 0.010871887, -0.014038086, 0.029556274, 0.0026226044, -0.06713867, -0.03540039, 0.0061073303, -0.00037813187, 0.058532715, -0.04324341, -0.08795166, 0.0022964478, -0.0690918, 0.011360168, 0.014427185, 0.022949219, 0.04397583, 0.059570312, -0.023635864, 0.010032654, -0.044189453, 0.013496399, -0.003774643, -0.009140015, -0.035461426, -0.029708862, 0.022903442, 0.03265381, 0.008773804, 0.01234436, -0.011329651, -0.00020575523, -0.038024902, 0.009742737, 0.037902832, 0.024810791, -0.0262146, 0.040008545, 0.016662598, 0.029464722, -0.020263672, -0.01852417, 0.015838623, 0.03756714, 0.03918457, -0.016967773, 0.023239136, -0.015106201, 0.0047340393, -0.000248909, -0.054626465, -0.02810669, 0.016860962, -0.03744507, -0.0030536652, -0.021118164, -0.018096924, 0.0020885468, 0.013618469, 0.0036087036, -0.003124237, 0.052520752, 0.00749588, 0.036499023, -0.02142334, -0.0065727234, -0.02407837, 0.035736084, 0.035064697, 0.0040740967, 0.0056648254, -0.01626587, -0.012504578, 0.03225708, 0.032104492, -0.006351471, 0.049987793, -0.014221191, 0.013725281, 0.02355957, -0.0076408386, -0.029403687, 0.05569458, 0.0009965897, 0.052734375, 0.027877808, 0.019485474, 0.036254883, 0.0072402954, 0.019256592, -0.050811768, 0.016433716, 0.03778076, -0.0070877075, -0.0041542053, 0.040618896, -0.009994507, -0.025772095, -0.027801514, -0.011642456, -0.04336548, 0.044677734, -0.009140015, -0.032836914, 0.028366089, -0.04449463, 0.015258789, -0.005142212, -0.0014352798, -0.037475586, -0.06542969, -0.028381348, 0.0073661804, -0.016586304, -0.008163452, -0.0014209747, 0.0079574585, 0.04260254, 0.03668213, 0.021499634, 0.021697998, 0.06964111, 0.044525146, -0.039886475, 0.010734558, -0.025222778, -0.0287323, 0.019638062, 0.00054740906, 0.022476196, -0.014831543, 0.037261963, 0.022125244, 0.022201538, 0.032409668, -0.027145386, 0.0076446533, 0.018081665, 0.00248909, 0.02935791, -0.027832031, -0.016494751, -0.057647705, 0.020217896, 0.01940918, -0.00434494, 0.017410278, 0.039642334, -0.07611084, -0.010765076, -0.04107666, 0.05328369, -0.093444824, 0.019500732, -0.024307251, -0.022033691, 0.041259766, -0.014595032, -0.017044067, -0.054229736, -0.021606445, -0.037200928, 0.03805542, -0.01713562, -0.021453857, -0.007545471, 0.0049362183, -0.018173218, -0.036102295, 0.009963989, 0.013450623, 0.033966064, -0.038909912, 0.0017843246, -0.014160156, 0.03970337, 0.05441284, -0.015136719, 0.0519104, -0.051086426, -0.03286743, 0.0057029724, 0.0309906, -0.03262329, -0.08807373, 0.016067505, -0.0030956268, -0.047546387, -0.0004825592, 0.06781006, -0.016616821, -0.019332886, -0.00042271614, -0.021697998, 0.052947998, -0.009811401, -0.0074424744, -0.024261475, 0.028656006, -0.048553467, -0.014183044, 0.002696991, 0.037994385, -0.014640808, -0.03289795, 0.0021953583, -0.0068626404, 0.018417358, -0.043762207, -0.03237915, 0.006767273, 0.052581787, -0.014045715, -0.050323486, 0.012840271, -0.0029354095, 0.050567627, -0.00007915497, 0.00894165, -0.04159546, -0.054901123, 0.0038032532, 0.05255127, 0.029510498, -0.0345459, 0.041412354, 0.07293701, -0.06970215, -0.020004272, 0.01828003, -0.0066375732, -0.030288696, -0.00724411, -0.028366089, -0.026626587, -0.049926758, -0.033966064, 0.020385742, -0.012420654, -0.0009226799, -0.017242432, 0.026931763, -0.007068634, 0.038146973, -0.01727295, 0.016494751, 0.029037476, -0.018966675, 0.04486084, -0.06488037, 0.072021484, 0.0368042, 0.016159058, -0.016143799, -0.004917145, -0.01171875, 0.0340271, -0.01739502, -0.024841309, -0.031188965, -0.02355957, -0.0030937195, -0.03543091, 0.02494812, 0.004512787, 0.0010118484, 0.047088623, 0.0071754456, 0.0206604, 0.005176544, 0.008239746, -0.012626648, -0.016159058, -0.04776001, 0.008399963, 0.013298035 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2102.05960v1
Comparative Analysis of Machine Learning Approaches to Analyze and Predict the Covid-19 Outbreak
Muhammad Naeem, Jian Yu, Muhammad Aamir, Sajjad Ahmad Khan, Olayinka Adeleye, Zardad Khan
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG
Background. Forecasting the time of forthcoming pandemic reduces the impact of diseases by taking precautionary steps such as public health messaging and raising the consciousness of doctors. With the continuous and rapid increase in the cumulative incidence of COVID-19, statistical and outbreak prediction models including various machine learning (ML) models are being used by the research community to track and predict the trend of the epidemic, and also in developing appropriate strategies to combat and manage its spread. Methods. In this paper, we present a comparative analysis of various ML approaches including Support Vector Machine, Random Forest, K-Nearest Neighbor and Artificial Neural Network in predicting the COVID-19 outbreak in the epidemiological domain. We first apply the autoregressive distributed lag (ARDL) method to identify and model the short and long-run relationships of the time-series COVID-19 datasets. That is, we determine the lags between a response variable and its respective explanatory time series variables as independent variables. Then, the resulting significant variables concerning their lags are used in the regression model selected by the ARDL for predicting and forecasting the trend of the epidemic. Results. Statistical measures i.e., Root Mean Square Error (RMSE), Mean Absolute Error (MAE) and Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE) are used for model accuracy. The values of MAPE for the best selected models for confirmed, recovered and deaths cases are 0.407, 0.094 and 0.124 respectively, which falls under the category of highly accurate forecasts. In addition, we computed fifteen days ahead forecast for the daily deaths, recover, and confirm patients and the cases fluctuated across time in all aspects. Besides, the results reveal the advantages of ML algorithms for supporting decision making of evolving short term policies.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2102.05960v1
"2021-02-11T11:57:33"
"2021-02-11T11:57:33"
{ "title": [ 0.00010430813, 0.011779785, -0.047210693, -0.055480957, 0.01234436, -0.027450562, -0.013580322, 0.013442993, -0.06341553, 0.050598145, -0.027832031, 0.032318115, 0.0011892319, -0.019744873, 0.0021438599, -0.029144287, 0.013923645, 0.027938843, 0.0060577393, -0.023590088, -0.0018320084, -0.028640747, 0.030838013, 0.033477783, 0.048339844, -0.01751709, -0.054718018, -0.026397705, -0.017562866, -0.046203613, -0.0030097961, 0.04324341, 0.030792236, 0.015327454, -0.031158447, 0.02999878, -0.042114258, 0.027755737, -0.0028476715, -0.011558533, -0.0022411346, 0.011657715, 0.0032367706, -0.010002136, -0.012016296, -0.011436462, -0.044281006, -0.010765076, -0.0005173683, 0.05215454, 0.017105103, 0.016845703, 0.007911682, 0.020355225, 0.007282257, -0.03213501, -0.038116455, -0.0044136047, 0.024124146, 0.02796936, -0.006061554, -0.007575989, 0.031204224, 0.0004117489, -0.0236969, -0.03894043, -0.029708862, 0.017791748, 0.07550049, -0.0039405823, -0.013999939, 0.040100098, 0.010185242, 0.04043579, -0.06317139, -0.06732178, 0.06222534, -0.008407593, 0.017410278, 0.0026512146, -0.026351929, -0.01751709, 0.0050697327, -0.03353882, 0.0026798248, -0.020401001, -0.011909485, -0.009422302, 0.0052833557, -0.033294678, 0.0070228577, -0.010421753, -0.020904541, 0.054901123, -0.0064353943, -0.031585693, 0.010093689, 0.032104492, 0.006881714, -0.032043457, -0.04031372, 0.03137207, -0.103271484, 0.0015459061, 0.010910034, 0.05593872, 0.04168701, -0.005466461, -0.019454956, -0.01687622, -0.036468506, 0.0077705383, 0.03845215, -0.032806396, -0.0016717911, -0.005722046, 0.010253906, 0.04434204, 0.027435303, 0.010284424, 0.017669678, 0.0046806335, -0.0068206787, 0.0039596558, 0.027282715, -0.0027770996, -0.033050537, -0.016296387, -0.0020446777, 0.056640625, -0.028137207, 0.03302002, -0.10797119, -0.09527588, -0.046203613, 0.0061950684, 0.018585205, 0.00027775764, 0.0074424744, -0.0003437996, 0.029815674, -0.021270752, 0.0056114197, 0.048950195, -0.024734497, 0.002002716, 0.042999268, 0.005580902, -0.04925537, -0.038757324, -0.03857422, 0.011077881, 0.0054969788, 0.012809753, -0.046813965, 0.014953613, -0.078308105, -0.0018005371, 0.028137207, 0.012435913, 0.062561035, 0.016052246, -0.022445679, 0.034973145, 0.03479004, -0.009239197, -0.0036468506, 0.01701355, -0.0048294067, 0.016967773, -0.0014390945, 0.0149002075, 0.0050964355, -0.015472412, 0.0055389404, -0.026550293, -0.021972656, 0.01512146, 0.010429382, 0.0037517548, -0.014770508, -0.04458618, -0.04550171, 0.05480957, -0.037322998, -0.033721924, 0.016082764, -0.010673523, 0.028518677, 0.0033683777, -0.02482605, 0.007598877, -0.041992188, -0.022964478, -0.03527832, 0.0043258667, 0.021820068, 0.024642944, -0.0048332214, 0.00044226646, -0.08190918, 0.009521484, -0.043304443, 0.0435791, -0.010025024, -0.019561768, 0.0020217896, 0.023529053, -0.029724121, 0.07489014, 0.030853271, 0.030899048, -0.020614624, -0.027877808, 0.0001527071, -0.051879883, 0.0071983337, -0.0044136047, -0.014663696, -0.004184723, -0.03387451, 0.0064468384, -0.026031494, 0.03024292, 0.027557373, 0.01423645, 0.012496948, -0.009895325, 0.06896973, 0.009422302, 0.09741211, -0.03918457, 0.04220581, 0.012214661, -0.040985107, -0.00969696, 0.0030326843, 0.02218628, -0.0012931824, 0.021530151, 0.019515991, -0.015327454, -0.0029182434, 0.017181396, 0.08129883, 0.009918213, 0.011695862, 0.010169983, 0.0055122375, 0.009803772, 0.053894043, 0.025756836, 0.05218506, 0.070007324, 0.012863159, 0.061950684, -0.0099105835, 0.019546509, -0.04437256, 0.033935547, -0.017654419, 0.040802002, 0.0446167, -0.0065193176, -0.049346924, -0.0011482239, -0.03616333, 0.009635925, -0.00092601776, -0.011627197, 0.03164673, -0.020065308, -0.0006046295, 0.03366089, 0.004875183, -0.00274086, -0.04043579, 0.005809784, -0.0014047623, -0.006729126, 0.009757996, 0.037841797, 0.013504028, -0.000059604645, 0.0020179749, 0.007297516, 0.0059165955, -0.0021839142, -0.053619385, -0.01260376, 0.04675293, 0.035369873, -0.00007510185, -0.032287598, 0.04373169, 0.014701843, 0.061279297, 0.0904541, -0.035858154, 0.025177002, -0.06976318, 0.011634827, 0.0005707741, -0.020050049, 0.0075683594, 0.019363403, 0.017730713, -0.010543823, -0.04232788, -0.0017938614, -0.07678223, -0.009925842, 0.001115799, -0.024978638, -0.0011920929, -0.021697998, -0.014968872, -0.006454468, -0.052124023, 0.00038838387, 0.023605347, -0.009269714, 0.0067863464, -0.041107178, 0.016357422, -0.021728516, -0.031982422, -0.013801575, 0.0012407303, -0.0061187744, 0.023864746, -0.018630981, -0.061706543, -0.0046463013, 0.015167236, 0.03363037, -0.0027637482, 0.047027588, -0.0047798157, -0.036193848, 0.00046873093, 0.01965332, -0.0057144165, -0.026947021, -0.004257202, -0.009277344, -0.0030994415, 0.018844604, -0.031433105, -0.0048179626, 0.021270752, -0.008552551, -0.030380249, -0.0435791, 0.03677368, -0.038360596, -0.014137268, -0.0034809113, 0.042114258, -0.026565552, 0.049743652, 0.010498047, 0.014320374, -0.034851074, -0.017166138, -0.062042236, -0.008125305, -0.011787415, 0.0045814514, 0.013824463, -0.042510986, -0.016174316, 0.0066871643, 0.0024147034, 0.0075302124, 0.009925842, -0.055419922, -0.052459717, 0.022949219, -0.032073975, -0.016860962, -0.018554688, 0.025054932, -0.014923096, 0.05480957, 0.00089645386, -0.028305054, -0.003627777, 0.027008057, 0.0051651, -0.0029792786, 0.008453369, -0.016586304, 0.012908936, 0.018630981, 0.0014419556, -0.0131073, 0.025421143, -0.12084961, -0.0017023087, 0.007335663, -0.02293396, -0.018325806, 0.0022010803, -0.052337646, 0.047698975, -0.008628845, -0.00068950653, 0.015525818, 0.055480957, -0.018875122, 0.017364502, 0.0049476624, -0.0037822723, -0.0046463013, -0.019042969, -0.060913086, 0.030288696, -0.028656006, -0.006462097, 0.026245117, -0.042419434, -0.025283813, -0.00970459, -0.035705566, 0.038330078, 0.022445679, 0.03274536, 0.01876831, 0.005973816, -0.00038790703, -0.0289917, -0.012794495, -0.062194824, -0.059143066, -0.004180908, -0.035339355, 0.07684326, -0.024597168, 0.024139404, -0.032165527, 0.011482239, 0.0073547363, 0.027862549, 0.03756714, -0.055541992, 0.004776001, -0.032806396, -0.003030777, 0.016921997, 0.003396988, 0.006641388, -0.02923584, 0.013961792, -0.030136108, 0.016418457, -0.009597778, 0.018997192, 0.0024299622, -0.010398865, -0.0003633499, -0.031311035, -0.032714844, -0.009483337, -0.02368164, -0.016342163, 0.057922363, 0.0049095154, -0.0073013306, -0.017242432, -0.02178955, 0.038482666, 0.010314941, -0.000052690506, -0.019805908, -0.0061836243, -0.011138916, 0.013870239, -0.027496338, -0.0044441223, 0.009216309, -0.0053520203, -0.0090789795, -0.02507019, -0.008262634, 0.014122009, -0.09716797, -0.019821167, -0.0044403076, -0.04434204, -0.03250122, -0.027435303, 0.010360718, -0.030761719, -0.04421997, -0.0024681091, -0.016952515, 0.01852417, -0.012954712, -0.06842041, -0.043273926, 0.038635254, -0.004878998, 0.02079773, 0.0073013306, -0.0146865845, -0.009559631, -0.005531311, 0.053222656, 0.008926392, 0.02293396, 0.007003784, 0.015625, 0.048919678, -0.041870117, 0.018539429, 0.020812988, -0.008148193, -0.003074646, 0.028793335, -0.006565094, 0.02204895, -0.027709961, 0.047454834, 0.04537964, -0.011184692, -0.056030273, 0.023086548, 0.0011148453, -0.05203247, -0.014587402, -0.016952515, -0.009353638, 0.049438477, 0.02381897, 0.077697754, -0.036468506, 0.007873535, -0.0062713623, -0.035858154, -0.036315918, -0.030410767, 0.0012254715, 0.0013513565, -0.0017442703, 0.017120361, 0.005115509, 0.05682373, -0.00217247, -0.01701355, 0.01272583, 0.0335083, -0.020568848, -0.012992859, -0.06945801, -0.050109863, -0.03152466, 0.02218628, 0.0021743774, -0.011238098, 0.055145264, 0.015777588, -0.020996094, -0.029159546, 0.00019621849, -0.0033569336, 0.007987976, -0.050689697, -0.0058174133, -0.0012969971, -0.08648682, -0.04940796, -0.048675537, -0.014266968, -0.0050811768, -0.011558533, -0.01939392, 0.024383545, 0.008460999, 0.047210693, 0.03656006, -0.030136108, -0.045837402, -0.020065308, -0.013572693, -0.009147644, -0.018447876, 0.02758789, -0.021362305, -0.022506714, 0.019012451, -0.01902771, -0.009468079, -0.06317139, 0.0059776306, 0.00023972988, -0.0061950684, -0.004764557, 0.020889282, 0.009101868, 0.022827148, 0.022735596, 0.013839722, -0.029693604, -0.028930664, 0.008491516, 0.0657959, -0.01550293, 0.01789856, 0.05569458, 0.0131073, -0.017791748, -0.008407593, 0.013839722, 0.027786255, -0.0051078796, -0.013938904, 0.042022705, -0.006290436, -0.026260376, -0.014251709, 0.024139404, 0.0184021, -0.04864502, 0.03010559, -0.005329132, -0.005809784, 0.03161621, -0.0038776398, 0.0014371872, 0.0067253113, 0.008895874, -0.03451538, -0.045196533, -0.0013952255, 0.022888184, -0.031463623, -0.013847351, -0.027755737, -0.013725281, 0.012886047, 0.030853271, -0.0062789917, 0.0049324036, 0.024368286, -0.014122009, 0.0046195984, -0.030319214, -0.03982544, -0.010253906, -0.032440186, 0.010536194, -0.031402588, 0.02281189, -0.028915405, -0.004787445, -0.0032215118, 0.009811401, 0.019744873, -0.04748535, 0.015167236, 0.06628418, -0.019515991, 0.030075073, -0.060668945, 0.011917114, 0.03491211, 0.04119873, -0.011779785, -0.0053367615, 0.03930664, -0.011581421, -0.009170532, 0.004699707, 0.020370483, 0.007255554, 0.026672363, 0.014831543, -0.0037345886, -0.050109863, 0.020019531, 0.009643555, -0.0087890625, 0.02078247, -0.053710938, 0.030014038, -0.024841309, -0.014984131, -0.013252258, -0.044799805, -0.036254883, 0.040283203, -0.050720215, 0.02418518, 0.00008124113, -0.023773193, -0.051879883, -0.036956787, 0.032684326, 0.0051231384, -0.007183075, -0.015731812, 0.027877808, -0.04437256, 0.025924683, -0.0020313263, -0.09729004, 0.009849548, -0.012397766, 0.024597168, 0.0362854, 0.0049858093, -0.09240723, -0.014785767, -0.022567749, -0.07458496, -0.025238037, 0.037475586, 0.05618286, -0.009552002, -0.016220093, -0.0435791, -0.0066108704, -0.025558472, 0.0013446808, 0.044189453, -0.036254883, 0.03161621, -0.003917694, 0.008323669, 0.021270752, 0.047912598, 0.010276794, 0.008422852, 0.0008955002, -0.013366699, 0.02142334, 0.0000034570694, 0.0021877289, 0.0014619827, -0.07519531, 0.010231018, 0.008590698, 0.017425537, 0.0022888184, 0.023712158, 0.032470703, -0.012329102, 0.025177002, 0.039916992, 0.0993042, -0.064208984, -0.029052734, -0.02923584, -0.014160156, -0.07366943, 0.028244019, 0.033111572, -0.0027809143, -0.03414917, -0.010879517, -0.021911621, -0.00042414665, 0.015472412, -0.002565384, 0.04977417, -0.04031372, -0.02822876, -0.033966064, 0.007972717, 0.0042686462, 0.012512207, -0.011703491, 0.04034424, -0.019317627, 0.02609253, -0.003932953, -0.01158905, 0.03515625, 0.039886475, 0.006793976, 0.010955811, -0.042022705, -0.022232056, -0.04534912, -0.0095825195, 0.059173584, 0.02470398, -0.038513184, 0.025344849, -0.019348145, 0.064453125, 0.03942871, 0.05621338, 0.06738281, 0.027679443, 0.010681152, 0.009300232, 0.027374268, -0.021224976, 0.003271103, -0.040008545, 0.0020980835, -0.034484863, -0.014152527, -0.09118652, 0.01184082, 0.0124435425, 0.010978699, 0.0033988953, 0.021026611, -0.0008597374, -0.0016613007, 0.045318604, 0.015235901, 0.05911255, 0.0011529922, -0.001156807, -0.033416748, 0.0024051666, 0.021606445, 0.026992798, 0.01939392, 0.025360107, 0.0048599243, 0.02180481, -0.011512756, -0.013298035, 0.020614624, -0.020187378, 0.02017212, 0.005455017, -0.0064888, -0.030044556, -0.036895752, 0.06262207, 0.046844482, -0.041168213, -0.008888245, 0.04348755, 0.046936035, -0.00340271, 0.008605957, 0.053375244, -0.057891846, 0.025405884, -0.0030059814, -0.04449463, -0.02784729, 0.045013428, -0.0008006096, -0.018844604, -0.0072746277, 0.018188477, 0.01348114, 0.024917603, -0.014137268, -0.03668213, -0.015823364, 0.04055786, 0.01802063, -0.022155762, -0.0036697388, 0.020553589, 0.061645508, -0.036956787, -0.015716553, -0.009437561, -0.0024662018, -0.026977539, 0.023513794, -0.04095459, 0.043914795, -0.0127334595, -0.04034424, 0.022216797, -0.01184082, -0.014801025, -0.021697998, 0.031707764, 0.0184021, 0.00018370152, 0.05319214, 0.01449585, -0.01789856, -0.028289795, -0.024337769, 0.020629883, 0.05593872, -0.02104187, 0.049743652, -0.017974854, -0.018249512, 0.07659912, 0.018356323, 0.100097656, -0.0066566467, -0.035369873, -0.03048706, 0.042236328, 0.010231018, -0.03366089, -0.04949951, -0.019241333, -0.010284424, -0.025299072, -0.028884888, -0.01576233, -0.05166626, -0.03125, 0.054473877, -0.017028809, -0.0038547516, 0.022262573, -0.028915405, -0.047546387, 0.015808105, -0.012588501, 0.04574585, -0.013214111, -0.017562866, 0.005279541, -0.0070495605, -0.008514404, -0.008903503, -0.008918762, 0.008331299, -0.011360168, -0.013465881, 0.0019035339, 0.014015198, -0.028808594, -0.107910156, 0.027160645, -0.035858154, -0.046295166, -0.021118164, 0.0418396, 0.015182495, -0.093811035, -0.022781372, -0.028823853, 0.00008350611, -0.012313843, -0.0113220215, 0.0014467239, 0.025939941, 0.008674622, -0.011192322, 0.024642944, 0.04711914, -0.02999878, -0.031234741, -0.013366699, 0.026809692, 0.038238525, -0.06378174, -0.043395996, -0.012390137, 0.06530762, -0.013557434, 0.04800415, -0.007167816, 0.045532227, 0.006664276, 0.07543945, -0.00554657, -0.06982422, -0.06628418, -0.035003662, 0.042022705, 0.014167786, -0.024459839, -0.03164673, 0.027999878, -0.002023697, 0.020111084, 0.02784729, -0.006668091, 0.044403076, -0.0063056946, 0.051940918, -0.009597778, -0.038848877, 0.026794434, 0.06359863, -0.029373169, 0.013725281, -0.012878418, -0.0072898865, 0.019836426, 0.008598328, -0.016113281, -0.0791626, 0.056884766, 0.06341553, 0.007698059, 0.05239868, -0.013473511, -0.042022705, 0.00034308434, -0.0054092407, 0.011314392, 0.006565094, 0.009971619, -0.018951416, -0.0052604675, -0.02822876, -0.040161133, 0.013168335, -0.02519226, 0.024398804, -0.04373169, 0.015281677, -0.027267456, 0.00856781, 0.00060129166, 0.020736694, 0.020202637, -0.027999878, -0.037384033, -0.007434845, 0.047943115, -0.007385254 ], "summary": [ 0.014450073, -0.023956299, 0.003042221, -0.031707764, -0.038635254, -0.013801575, -0.013145447, 0.00085639954, -0.031433105, 0.033996582, -0.0037574768, 0.019241333, -0.019622803, -0.021530151, -0.004146576, -0.035461426, 0.0041275024, 0.0042762756, 0.03137207, -0.020690918, 0.028625488, -0.044128418, 0.04171753, 0.025268555, 0.052520752, -0.034423828, -0.057800293, 0.008972168, 0.02633667, 0.025650024, 0.019683838, -0.030273438, 0.019485474, 0.0030212402, 0.0051498413, -0.009086609, -0.0047302246, -0.006137848, 0.015548706, -0.015205383, 0.01360321, 0.0027217865, 0.13952637, -0.07269287, 0.031677246, 0.051818848, -0.012680054, -0.035583496, 0.008293152, 0.027679443, 0.0011711121, -0.015182495, 0.008911133, -0.038757324, -0.012199402, -0.033050537, -0.0064697266, 0.0016756058, -0.0053253174, 0.019317627, -0.0017156601, 0.035858154, -0.0018854141, -0.012466431, -0.035369873, 0.015602112, 0.008911133, -0.01386261, 0.08288574, -0.025390625, -0.017028809, 0.03878784, -0.0124435425, -0.022750854, -0.018600464, -0.02558899, 0.028518677, -0.031707764, -0.014701843, 0.00868988, 0.010978699, 0.024017334, -0.01927185, -0.031677246, -0.004348755, -0.011146545, -0.013175964, -0.02078247, -0.013938904, 0.00015187263, -0.024902344, -0.05404663, -0.008705139, 0.042907715, 0.032592773, -0.035736084, -0.031951904, 0.0032405853, 0.00035643578, -0.005619049, -0.038909912, 0.03552246, -0.10290527, 0.007621765, -0.033843994, 0.10015869, 0.06100464, -0.027297974, -0.056640625, -0.01751709, 0.008460999, -0.076293945, 0.010940552, -0.04473877, -0.03366089, 0.03503418, 0.016983032, -0.0032653809, 0.034576416, 0.014205933, -0.02508545, 0.020462036, -0.049865723, -0.026641846, 0.03213501, -0.018218994, -0.0014762878, 0.044036865, -0.009109497, 0.09893799, -0.005264282, -0.041809082, -0.05065918, -0.010604858, -0.041412354, -0.049713135, 0.030456543, 0.006843567, 0.044403076, -0.03164673, 0.039520264, 0.008934021, -0.008132935, 0.054473877, -0.018951416, -0.012794495, -0.0069732666, 0.028503418, 0.024429321, -0.024246216, 0.035736084, -0.032928467, 0.03201294, -0.028808594, -0.05657959, -0.068603516, -0.026855469, -0.021850586, 0.038269043, -0.043884277, -0.008224487, -0.026779175, 0.00894165, -0.0067634583, -0.017562866, 0.035186768, -0.007369995, -0.003479004, 0.006374359, -0.022323608, 0.02545166, 0.017120361, 0.016296387, 0.006690979, 0.030548096, 0.00012683868, -0.04144287, -0.0079956055, 0.01209259, 0.0017404556, 0.02394104, -0.01675415, -0.06323242, 0.0791626, -0.014564514, -0.0020542145, 0.0026493073, 0.016601562, 0.038330078, -0.0005226135, -0.0009074211, -0.025939941, 0.022735596, 0.019699097, 0.047546387, -0.04107666, -0.012878418, -0.024841309, 0.011886597, -0.04714966, -0.03744507, -0.029205322, -0.008216858, -0.00072288513, -0.064697266, -0.014533997, -0.019348145, 0.018341064, -0.052520752, 0.02519226, 0.030761719, -0.035583496, -0.036193848, 0.041778564, 0.026260376, -0.018112183, -0.0034542084, 0.0011310577, -0.02507019, 0.006538391, -0.04421997, 0.016067505, -0.03756714, 0.01083374, -0.03289795, -0.03414917, 0.023666382, -0.013175964, 0.031402588, -0.023864746, 0.097717285, -0.01789856, -0.046813965, 0.0146484375, 0.013198853, -0.0037670135, -0.009338379, -0.041168213, 0.03164673, -0.00017917156, 0.024002075, -0.02545166, -0.023483276, -0.0015659332, 0.020477295, 0.044769287, 0.041534424, -0.009941101, -0.025238037, -0.0024433136, 0.07165527, 0.016052246, 0.008262634, 0.046966553, 0.012397766, 0.009353638, -0.01965332, -0.013633728, -0.02204895, 0.03213501, -0.004535675, 0.0027542114, 0.0026817322, 0.002275467, -0.057922363, -0.027755737, -0.04940796, -0.013290405, 0.0178833, -0.066711426, 0.030853271, -0.0035705566, -0.002943039, -0.013313293, -0.05517578, -0.03262329, -0.015350342, 0.03704834, -0.0103302, -0.039764404, -0.0020713806, 0.028076172, -0.0090789795, -0.013320923, 0.002986908, -0.03036499, 0.0018558502, 0.019241333, 0.0005340576, 0.02696228, 0.021194458, 0.050231934, 0.009490967, 0.023529053, 0.003255844, -0.004962921, -0.033935547, 0.011634827, 0.007881165, -0.021362305, 0.0031604767, 0.0385437, -0.03753662, 0.03161621, -0.0016326904, 0.032989502, 0.015357971, -0.0058059692, 0.0027256012, -0.030059814, -0.022888184, -0.01828003, 0.0068588257, 0.036376953, -0.020980835, -0.03250122, -0.0035800934, 0.03869629, 0.012138367, 0.04196167, 0.0418396, -0.019165039, 0.014801025, 0.010124207, 0.004890442, -0.03643799, 0.012435913, -0.0033168793, -0.014442444, -0.024841309, 0.00003027916, -0.009788513, -0.011619568, 0.0592041, 0.01399231, 0.011253357, 0.011070251, 0.09051514, 0.016052246, -0.0368042, 0.011795044, -0.00028538704, -0.020645142, 0.0049591064, -0.04815674, 0.037872314, 0.009475708, 0.005859375, 0.007843018, 0.013267517, -0.014480591, -0.013458252, -0.05886841, -0.016921997, -0.019714355, 0.03466797, 0.06549072, -0.026138306, 0.028839111, -0.031921387, 0.046203613, 0.027130127, 0.013549805, -0.04559326, -0.041778564, -0.048553467, 0.035003662, -0.04940796, 0.0619812, 0.058624268, -0.04727173, 0.037231445, -0.003200531, 0.01914978, 0.047302246, -0.0056152344, 0.030395508, -0.0032157898, 0.014076233, 0.017929077, 0.030960083, 0.0011796951, 0.008171082, -0.036956787, 0.05807495, 0.0030002594, 0.04220581, 0.03805542, 0.061676025, -0.0074920654, 0.0055732727, 0.0042686462, 0.034942627, -0.012458801, 0.0236969, -0.027557373, -0.0032024384, 0.059448242, -0.062316895, -0.007129669, 0.034240723, 0.0017299652, 0.02456665, 0.00022149086, -0.015914917, 0.080566406, 0.0004911423, 0.023727417, 0.032714844, -0.004825592, -0.010551453, 0.021255493, -0.020309448, 0.003660202, -0.018692017, -0.014511108, 0.05630493, 0.0048332214, -0.013534546, -0.0340271, 0.053649902, -0.064208984, 0.03656006, 0.0072288513, -0.0005197525, 0.027053833, 0.024093628, 0.013465881, -0.020721436, 0.014328003, 0.028167725, -0.02229309, -0.013427734, -0.05029297, -0.03414917, -0.040405273, 0.0002373457, 0.037750244, 0.009506226, -0.025283813, -0.009552002, -0.012748718, 0.002527237, -0.007858276, 0.048736572, -0.038604736, -0.0011911392, 0.013114929, 0.035858154, 0.0033245087, -0.022094727, -0.012298584, 0.030441284, 0.036468506, -0.025238037, 0.023605347, -0.036621094, 0.0041656494, 0.056488037, 0.011558533, -0.00015413761, 0.018569946, -0.056671143, -0.018417358, -0.020080566, 0.0044898987, 0.04626465, 0.004180908, -0.026809692, 0.0039634705, -0.013465881, -0.002872467, -0.011474609, -0.02835083, -0.022888184, -0.013504028, 0.03982544, -0.008651733, 0.040924072, -0.030212402, -0.01436615, -0.004020691, 0.0010070801, -0.04486084, -0.024887085, 0.008720398, -0.09460449, -0.03375244, -0.012367249, 0.015808105, 0.005847931, -0.02998352, -0.00090408325, 0.039642334, -0.0541687, 0.024276733, -0.040161133, 0.11431885, 0.03213501, -0.05380249, 0.04159546, -0.022277832, 0.037231445, 0.009315491, -0.05203247, 0.039123535, 0.030731201, -0.010154724, -0.0051574707, -0.08276367, -0.0058059692, -0.051361084, 0.014427185, 0.039245605, -0.023391724, -0.021835327, 0.048706055, 0.041503906, -0.018600464, -0.008979797, 0.01890564, 0.059326172, 0.002626419, 0.013221741, 0.0049209595, -0.016616821, 0.0090408325, 0.003227234, -0.0050086975, -0.009803772, -0.015403748, 0.0030994415, -0.016998291, -0.009490967, 0.05923462, -0.0073623657, -0.005138397, -0.03152466, -0.0054740906, 0.026885986, -0.013595581, -0.033233643, 0.0063667297, 0.033294678, -0.015167236, 0.01777649, -0.0028648376, 0.05505371, -0.016418457, 0.026824951, -0.01335907, -0.0075187683, 0.004432678, -0.052093506, -0.0129852295, -0.021148682, 0.025466919, -0.008712769, 0.0113220215, -0.015434265, 0.020385742, 0.013389587, -0.037597656, -0.005886078, 0.040863037, 0.005420685, -0.027694702, -0.074035645, -0.014442444, 0.0021152496, -0.047210693, -0.025787354, -0.026779175, -0.025894165, -0.02079773, -0.009597778, 0.00082445145, 0.032714844, -0.011962891, -0.010696411, -0.02116394, -0.050476074, -0.006881714, -0.04244995, -0.002216339, 0.023284912, -0.0446167, 0.056488037, -0.028320312, -0.016235352, -0.005039215, -0.021072388, -0.012123108, 0.0032787323, -0.0012760162, 0.025985718, -0.0076522827, -0.020446777, 0.034362793, 0.0026779175, 0.03894043, 0.010765076, 0.0084991455, -0.012298584, -0.034118652, 0.013046265, 0.043823242, 0.007881165, -0.03289795, 0.03353882, 0.00793457, -0.03062439, 0.03466797, -0.008773804, 0.032287598, 0.008399963, 0.007987976, -0.010688782, 0.06719971, -0.007335663, 0.044708252, 0.015914917, 0.011177063, 0.025787354, -0.014778137, 0.04522705, 0.02130127, 0.05038452, -0.021240234, -0.010948181, 0.019058228, -0.022384644, -0.01689148, -0.013290405, 0.02204895, 0.031280518, -0.019195557, -0.016204834, -0.046539307, -0.009483337, -0.03250122, 0.025314331, -0.014976501, 0.0016202927, 0.020233154, -0.031280518, -0.04675293, -0.02368164, 0.0061836243, -0.00008201599, -0.0046691895, 0.0026493073, -0.032958984, -0.019058228, 0.034820557, 0.012886047, -0.046783447, 0.01876831, 0.006259918, 0.002128601, -0.060058594, 0.014518738, -0.0020332336, 0.008773804, 0.002916336, -0.006526947, -0.038635254, 0.022262573, -0.04425049, 0.044067383, -0.011680603, -0.024871826, 0.002948761, -0.04171753, 0.006511688, 0.018249512, 0.021652222, 0.009796143, 0.023864746, -0.04550171, 0.0040626526, -0.053344727, -0.052001953, -0.01449585, 0.0105896, 0.0064086914, -0.018707275, 0.02243042, -0.027557373, -0.008926392, -0.02267456, 0.046173096, -0.03781128, 0.0473938, -0.0024929047, -0.040863037, -0.03463745, 0.023864746, -0.005592346, -0.009346008, 0.0017538071, 0.022918701, 0.01499939, 0.0034160614, -0.0049705505, -0.006904602, -0.08782959, 0.019744873, -0.0020008087, 0.036743164, -0.0039901733, -0.010108948, -0.04837036, -0.005569458, -0.06970215, -0.034576416, -0.017623901, 0.055511475, 0.070373535, 0.029449463, -0.05291748, 0.031921387, 0.04522705, -0.07702637, 0.011604309, 0.027145386, -0.026290894, -0.038238525, -0.020996094, -0.02998352, 0.007419586, 0.021362305, 0.000097334385, 0.0032539368, -0.0037174225, -0.01512146, 0.053833008, -0.022064209, 0.013969421, 0.014251709, -0.042388916, 0.018829346, 0.025283813, -0.0038833618, -0.0016851425, -0.019088745, -0.0005226135, -0.034301758, 0.011421204, -0.00198555, 0.06488037, -0.027877808, -0.024719238, -0.021942139, 0.022491455, -0.05722046, -0.040008545, 0.01689148, -0.005252838, -0.011802673, -0.0033416748, 0.0064582825, 0.005432129, 0.003921509, -0.0046195984, 0.02331543, 0.022033691, 0.0013408661, 0.019424438, -0.00945282, 0.0048065186, 0.008720398, 0.016998291, 0.020324707, -0.020019531, 0.014801025, -0.026855469, 0.013648987, -0.00969696, 0.033843994, 0.01637268, 0.036132812, 0.0060539246, -0.028167725, -0.032104492, 0.0030097961, 0.033355713, 0.020812988, -0.0056991577, 0.041259766, 0.016952515, 0.024353027, 0.02180481, 0.01146698, 0.020401001, 0.0016345978, -0.013198853, -0.0018186569, -0.024261475, -0.032165527, 0.053894043, -0.008460999, 0.002111435, -0.056121826, -0.027572632, -0.023620605, 0.080200195, -0.06982422, -0.022079468, 0.025283813, -0.001707077, -0.034362793, 0.006084442, -0.02520752, 0.06500244, 0.012916565, 0.025527954, -0.004497528, 0.00015890598, -0.017440796, -0.0034866333, 0.0317688, 0.025909424, -0.009857178, -0.014724731, 0.034362793, 0.0072517395, -0.022460938, -0.061767578, -0.02420044, 0.07434082, -0.03756714, 0.012466431, -0.019073486, 0.009918213, 0.067993164, 0.02470398, 0.03475952, -0.036987305, 0.037994385, 0.061676025, 0.005130768, 0.004180908, 0.04434204, -0.010643005, -0.020706177, 0.013198853, -0.019363403, 0.03640747, 0.026824951, 0.04940796, -0.04699707, 0.013015747, -0.0071487427, 0.0031375885, -0.039398193, 0.007835388, -0.025772095, -0.050476074, 0.035583496, 0.0289917, -0.02281189, -0.011474609, -0.0037517548, 0.019363403, -0.03677368, 0.013557434, -0.0006327629, 0.008674622, -0.008880615, 0.014030457, -0.049072266, 0.01612854, 0.0109939575, -0.015159607, 0.010047913, 0.0056648254, -0.0031757355, -0.012542725, 0.05340576, 0.059631348, 0.030227661, 0.0647583, -0.040100098, 0.009117126, 0.028518677, 0.015472412, 0.026123047, -0.024261475, 0.006515503, -0.013130188, -0.016921997, 0.027816772, 0.030639648, 0.033172607, 0.029174805, -0.08166504, 0.0007548332, -0.050079346, 0.059265137, -0.08959961, -0.006504059, -0.0042762756, -0.045898438, -0.0446167, -0.0056266785, 0.023345947, 0.020324707, -0.035186768, -0.03164673, 0.03086853, -0.017471313, -0.017608643, 0.013511658, 0.011634827, -0.025680542, -0.03604126, -0.024337769, 0.025863647, 0.0032749176, 0.012023926, 0.06237793, 0.026031494, -0.030181885, -0.07122803, -0.033599854, 0.031097412, 0.059051514, -0.045959473, 0.022735596, 0.015197754, -0.037506104, -0.09863281, 0.0056533813, -0.039794922, -0.04232788, 0.039642334, 0.03363037, 0.013824463, -0.08099365, -0.0072021484, -0.007095337, 0.0070648193, -0.046051025, -0.012901306, 0.043548584, 0.013206482, 0.010719299, -0.0032806396, 0.003358841, -0.012794495, -0.019332886, -0.045288086, -0.00084638596, 0.039367676, 0.028198242, -0.018127441, 0.052856445, 0.04425049, 0.04046631, -0.052215576, -0.055267334, -0.003004074, 0.020309448, 0.08380127, 0.0791626, 0.010177612, -0.06335449, -0.023132324, -0.032409668, 0.047454834, 0.0014858246, -0.025360107, -0.01335144, 0.013435364, -0.02468872, -0.026138306, 0.020202637, 0.022766113, -0.016220093, 0.016815186, 0.009521484, -0.045013428, -0.04269409, 0.06112671, 0.042938232, -0.029190063, 0.026824951, -0.01966858, -0.028045654, 0.032989502, -0.01828003, 0.012748718, 0.015258789, 0.013076782, 0.012290955, 0.03677368, -0.032318115, 0.015548706, 0.010307312, -0.0017442703, -0.009521484, -0.0015907288, -0.0016546249, 0.038269043, -0.049438477, -0.0068130493, -0.054840088, -0.027450562, 0.032684326, -0.03640747, 0.030151367, -0.053863525, 0.018035889, -0.031463623, -0.0113220215, 0.02973938, -0.009346008, 0.051727295, -0.010292053, 0.029205322, -0.0056381226, 0.000248909, 0.015991211 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2102.07244v1
Resilient Machine Learning for Networked Cyber Physical Systems: A Survey for Machine Learning Security to Securing Machine Learning for CPS
Felix Olowononi, Danda B. Rawat, Chunmei Liu
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Cyber Physical Systems (CPS) are characterized by their ability to integrate the physical and information or cyber worlds. Their deployment in critical infrastructure have demonstrated a potential to transform the world. However, harnessing this potential is limited by their critical nature and the far reaching effects of cyber attacks on human, infrastructure and the environment. An attraction for cyber concerns in CPS rises from the process of sending information from sensors to actuators over the wireless communication medium, thereby widening the attack surface. Traditionally, CPS security has been investigated from the perspective of preventing intruders from gaining access to the system using cryptography and other access control techniques. Most research work have therefore focused on the detection of attacks in CPS. However, in a world of increasing adversaries, it is becoming more difficult to totally prevent CPS from adversarial attacks, hence the need to focus on making CPS resilient. Resilient CPS are designed to withstand disruptions and remain functional despite the operation of adversaries. One of the dominant methodologies explored for building resilient CPS is dependent on machine learning (ML) algorithms. However, rising from recent research in adversarial ML, we posit that ML algorithms for securing CPS must themselves be resilient. This paper is therefore aimed at comprehensively surveying the interactions between resilient CPS using ML and resilient ML when applied in CPS. The paper concludes with a number of research trends and promising future research directions. Furthermore, with this paper, readers can have a thorough understanding of recent advances on ML-based security and securing ML for CPS and countermeasures, as well as research trends in this active research area.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2102.07244v1
"2021-02-14T20:50:18"
"2021-02-14T20:50:18"
{ "title": [ -0.019378662, 0.0055999756, -0.030075073, -0.007369995, 0.0044555664, -0.031402588, 0.019897461, -0.026275635, -0.05783081, 0.029937744, -0.026275635, 0.020858765, -0.015731812, -0.024871826, -0.025985718, -0.03186035, -0.009674072, 0.02557373, -0.0006608963, -0.03274536, -0.012077332, -0.036834717, 0.04537964, 0.00831604, 0.0118255615, -0.011299133, -0.049560547, -0.0020065308, -0.018447876, -0.04171753, 0.0009870529, 0.018249512, 0.04647827, 0.025344849, -0.051330566, 0.015457153, -0.039398193, 0.034576416, -0.011497498, 0.01423645, 0.010131836, -0.0035362244, -0.005657196, -0.022766113, -0.02947998, 0.036499023, -0.06616211, -0.016159058, -0.03768921, 0.04751587, 0.031982422, -0.01878357, 0.022949219, 0.048675537, 0.011978149, -0.036010742, -0.044677734, -0.016326904, 0.02456665, 0.09484863, 0.039916992, -0.028381348, 0.004798889, -0.04876709, -0.02684021, -0.035369873, -0.008346558, 0.019226074, 0.058898926, -0.011795044, 0.013435364, 0.049041748, 0.026992798, 0.006511688, -0.041229248, -0.04248047, 0.05355835, 0.008842468, 0.032043457, -0.055236816, 0.0031929016, -0.011016846, 0.0020008087, -0.031951904, 0.02961731, -0.008964539, -0.0032024384, -0.00932312, -0.016464233, -0.02255249, -0.0016155243, -0.010032654, -0.014289856, 0.04437256, -0.006416321, -0.025665283, 0.0060768127, 0.03189087, -0.0073890686, -0.045196533, -0.01965332, 0.0027980804, -0.07342529, -0.018463135, 0.013809204, 0.0513916, 0.019882202, -0.020355225, -0.019729614, -0.005554199, -0.008285522, 0.010276794, -0.011398315, -0.0079956055, 0.010116577, 0.004966736, -0.019821167, 0.010475159, 0.002532959, 0.011795044, -0.022232056, -0.02810669, -0.023849487, 0.037261963, 0.021743774, -0.0009994507, -0.02935791, 0.03878784, -0.03302002, 0.04473877, 0.00043010712, 0.027435303, -0.061279297, -0.043945312, -0.037719727, 0.016540527, 0.011367798, 0.03125, 0.011779785, -0.013626099, 0.04876709, -0.012817383, 0.004142761, 0.059448242, -0.0132751465, 0.017745972, 0.035339355, -0.015083313, -0.049041748, -0.04144287, -0.021148682, -0.010520935, -0.003929138, 0.0211792, -0.0073928833, 0.024398804, -0.048858643, -0.016021729, 0.031829834, 0.0035686493, 0.054901123, -0.0006122589, -0.022872925, 0.04586792, 0.058288574, -0.0071258545, -0.008651733, 0.027160645, -0.003238678, 0.05630493, -0.012664795, 0.008117676, -0.014183044, -0.010414124, -0.0101623535, 0.002035141, 0.027999878, 0.023391724, 0.014503479, 0.002576828, -0.004135132, -0.026412964, 0.028030396, 0.0048294067, -0.02330017, -0.056030273, 0.016921997, 0.007949829, 0.045288086, 0.025817871, -0.044403076, 0.0019798279, -0.0423584, -0.042510986, -0.04534912, 0.005264282, 0.020706177, 0.035705566, -0.023254395, 0.037139893, -0.04071045, 0.026916504, -0.040771484, 0.014312744, -0.012023926, -0.021270752, 0.00868988, 0.025863647, -0.055114746, 0.049682617, 0.048065186, -0.015419006, -0.017333984, -0.025909424, 0.03086853, -0.047546387, -0.00020372868, -0.000834465, -0.009422302, -0.0027236938, -0.026489258, -0.008171082, 0.0044555664, 0.022369385, 0.0044136047, 0.027938843, -0.019714355, 0.0085372925, 0.07385254, 0.015434265, 0.12805176, -0.034362793, 0.033416748, 0.0143966675, -0.000024437904, -0.010520935, -0.006790161, -0.07800293, 0.0132751465, 0.04144287, 0.015083313, -0.013343811, 0.01448822, 0.012550354, 0.059936523, -0.03262329, -0.012687683, 0.012168884, 0.011047363, 0.028961182, 0.066467285, 0.0107803345, 0.03552246, 0.024276733, 0.019226074, 0.039154053, 0.015327454, 0.037017822, -0.033203125, 0.025909424, -0.021560669, 0.03933716, 0.034210205, 0.009490967, -0.05105591, 0.0075798035, -0.015571594, 0.026351929, 0.011985779, 0.0036334991, 0.017486572, -0.048309326, -0.0032749176, 0.05831909, 0.006713867, -0.014221191, -0.0048217773, -0.006954193, -0.0029392242, -0.012756348, -0.0014286041, 0.004432678, 0.0017385483, -0.0063476562, 0.027999878, -0.000056385994, 0.008529663, 0.0013446808, -0.03970337, -0.011116028, 0.046325684, 0.015914917, -0.004043579, -0.02229309, 0.005378723, -0.0067749023, 0.07635498, 0.10473633, -0.048553467, 0.028793335, -0.0670166, -0.01474762, -0.0154800415, -0.01802063, 0.005176544, 0.013473511, 0.03086853, 0.013427734, -0.018432617, 0.012817383, -0.07232666, -0.019607544, 0.012931824, 0.0035991669, -0.048675537, -0.048950195, -0.014968872, -0.021621704, -0.055389404, -0.030715942, 0.03475952, -0.020202637, 0.013153076, 0.004463196, 0.0077400208, -0.031433105, -0.0029735565, -0.0042381287, -0.02519226, 0.028961182, 0.002445221, 0.018508911, -0.0680542, -0.0051460266, -0.012756348, 0.03579712, -0.014274597, 0.056427002, -0.0138168335, -0.008415222, -0.0038471222, -0.025726318, -0.009567261, -0.030883789, -0.032714844, -0.021224976, -0.0047569275, 0.015281677, -0.023269653, -0.015106201, 0.046081543, -0.017959595, -0.022201538, -0.0013208389, 0.05291748, -0.04525757, -0.014083862, 0.016326904, 0.021377563, -0.018951416, 0.017440796, 0.027236938, 0.014884949, -0.0390625, -0.04916382, -0.041900635, -0.0029888153, 0.024414062, -0.0029640198, 0.038391113, -0.043945312, -0.012832642, -0.04724121, 0.0010185242, 0.008888245, 0.022628784, 0.010902405, -0.030319214, -0.006504059, -0.015029907, -0.018829346, -0.00970459, -0.009887695, -0.018417358, 0.062805176, 0.00039601326, -0.030853271, 0.020690918, 0.0061073303, -0.0054893494, -0.016418457, -0.0014362335, -0.034057617, 0.013763428, 0.017471313, 0.0004916191, 0.011390686, -0.020935059, -0.09436035, -0.01902771, 0.015419006, -0.0027999878, -0.034301758, 0.01890564, -0.044952393, -0.0014619827, 0.011734009, -0.02458191, 0.0138168335, 0.061187744, 0.006416321, -0.047973633, 0.028671265, -0.04763794, 0.046905518, -0.0513916, -0.07110596, 0.032409668, -0.025756836, -0.014389038, -0.004146576, -0.009101868, -0.04348755, -0.017532349, -0.014099121, 0.008506775, 0.056671143, 0.0024375916, 0.020614624, 0.028518677, 0.019607544, -0.023880005, 0.015487671, -0.0021343231, -0.053497314, -0.027374268, -0.022064209, 0.0076789856, 0.023880005, -0.031982422, -0.05340576, -0.00050497055, 0.019104004, 0.038116455, 0.03201294, -0.048614502, -0.0090408325, -0.060577393, -0.037200928, 0.01600647, -0.022949219, 0.01789856, -0.021636963, -0.00085783005, -0.010871887, -0.0010128021, -0.012283325, 0.007286072, -0.04510498, 0.049224854, 0.056549072, 0.018722534, -0.039123535, -0.0042419434, -0.0019416809, -0.013442993, 0.060424805, -0.00018155575, -0.024398804, 0.015106201, -0.031677246, 0.01727295, 0.0093307495, 0.0062217712, 0.00016736984, 0.041503906, -0.028442383, 0.00010359287, -0.02684021, 0.008293152, -0.04147339, 0.024734497, -0.06536865, -0.07727051, -0.03010559, 0.023468018, -0.087768555, -0.03805542, 0.026123047, -0.06124878, -0.05380249, -0.037841797, 0.01979065, -0.03338623, 0.0026779175, -0.010101318, -0.010437012, -0.027648926, -0.025314331, -0.08081055, -0.022460938, 0.042907715, 0.005191803, 0.038604736, 0.0017290115, 0.017150879, -0.019241333, -0.01725769, 0.02142334, -0.03375244, 0.000095427036, -0.026000977, 0.026275635, 0.05657959, -0.015838623, 0.043914795, 0.0021781921, 0.03250122, -0.009094238, -0.0033187866, 0.03326416, 0.034729004, -0.06732178, 0.023757935, 0.061706543, -0.011520386, -0.08947754, 0.018188477, 0.011047363, -0.0814209, 0.025665283, -0.023849487, 0.043701172, 0.09039307, -0.023986816, 0.10986328, -0.01184845, -0.012214661, 0.009422302, 0.0032787323, -0.026153564, -0.016204834, 0.021347046, 0.020248413, -0.019882202, 0.0074386597, -0.02229309, 0.04824829, -0.004776001, -0.018173218, 0.014884949, 0.017730713, -0.021362305, -0.00680542, -0.07110596, 0.010246277, -0.033416748, 0.023132324, -0.017410278, 0.013572693, 0.024719238, -0.0038700104, -0.03378296, 0.025985718, 0.05102539, -0.0042495728, 0.012290955, -0.052734375, -0.017074585, -0.0035953522, -0.050994873, -0.037200928, 0.015296936, -0.008842468, 0.013160706, -0.033691406, -0.005847931, 0.031433105, 0.021911621, 0.033843994, 0.046966553, -0.01638794, -0.027145386, 0.032318115, -0.008903503, -0.009277344, -0.009239197, 0.03125, -0.004081726, -0.016998291, -0.0008363724, -0.017791748, 0.005832672, -0.060943604, -0.0011739731, -0.017318726, 0.011566162, 0.011489868, 0.035308838, 0.016784668, 0.023788452, 0.0032196045, -0.0025539398, -0.035491943, -0.00056409836, 0.019012451, 0.05065918, -0.015686035, 0.05999756, 0.07495117, -0.014030457, -0.008781433, -0.02708435, 0.043395996, 0.019744873, -0.064208984, -0.011787415, 0.024017334, -0.02293396, -0.022537231, 0.012420654, 0.017913818, 0.049835205, -0.043670654, 0.04095459, -0.021194458, -0.0023326874, 0.03817749, 0.003408432, 0.0010824203, 0.022262573, 0.010177612, -0.051239014, -0.042419434, -0.0023822784, 0.05758667, -0.03503418, -0.010223389, -0.028137207, -0.020523071, 0.02557373, 0.028564453, -0.0037937164, -0.006603241, -0.008766174, -0.005268097, -0.008720398, -0.016784668, -0.034729004, -0.0011501312, -0.015716553, 0.019973755, 0.00573349, 0.000726223, -0.065979004, 0.0047416687, -0.0013952255, 0.00315094, 0.029159546, -0.050598145, -0.0001783371, 0.060180664, 0.0017089844, -0.0017719269, -0.017181396, 0.018951416, 0.04095459, 0.040222168, 0.008590698, 0.0074768066, 0.045684814, -0.028656006, -0.010246277, -0.009025574, 0.02130127, -0.004047394, 0.036010742, 0.014076233, -0.0029678345, -0.060821533, 0.02508545, -0.012229919, -0.028884888, 0.020462036, -0.035247803, 0.02003479, 0.019317627, -0.00085401535, 0.010185242, -0.048461914, -0.02027893, 0.037322998, -0.036865234, 0.026824951, 0.03164673, 0.0055122375, -0.024353027, -0.024490356, 0.036865234, -0.034210205, 0.014854431, 0.0028820038, -0.023162842, -0.03805542, 0.03186035, 0.0102005005, -0.09429932, 0.0075149536, -0.012290955, 0.028930664, 0.023788452, 0.023605347, -0.045898438, -0.014915466, -0.034362793, -0.06854248, -0.070739746, -0.0046424866, -0.0015163422, 0.01360321, -0.029129028, -0.009300232, -0.0040359497, -0.02319336, -0.00074243546, 0.034851074, -0.040618896, 0.017288208, -0.007205963, 0.0037670135, -0.008323669, 0.040985107, 0.0101623535, -0.010238647, 0.00422287, -0.02545166, 0.024276733, -0.005809784, -0.005443573, 0.020996094, -0.009140015, 0.004486084, 0.022384644, -0.00029325485, -0.026062012, 0.003118515, 0.02507019, -0.0015668869, 0.022994995, 0.012306213, 0.0871582, -0.0368042, -0.04537964, -0.05984497, -0.017471313, -0.055267334, 0.077819824, -0.014137268, -0.049987793, -0.042419434, -0.060058594, -0.025619507, 0.012329102, 0.025512695, 0.043518066, 0.035888672, -0.050720215, 0.019897461, -0.0063285828, -0.023117065, -0.03866577, 0.03604126, -0.008522034, -0.02218628, 0.028030396, -0.040893555, 0.0068092346, -0.03390503, 0.0368042, 0.038330078, -0.0035190582, 0.0036354065, -0.07489014, -0.020004272, -0.004310608, -0.0131073, 0.059539795, -0.013671875, -0.015686035, 0.02204895, -0.004085541, 0.044158936, 0.04425049, -0.0036468506, 0.044891357, 0.024215698, 0.020462036, -0.000073850155, -0.006587982, -0.008903503, 0.04067993, -0.037719727, -0.01525116, -0.0793457, -0.03857422, -0.1171875, 0.0011901855, 0.010314941, 0.04031372, -0.0107421875, 0.019607544, 0.012199402, -0.014137268, 0.04989624, -0.0024337769, 0.084228516, -0.014602661, -0.013824463, -0.008155823, 0.025787354, 0.017974854, 0.025024414, 0.015548706, 0.02204895, 0.016662598, -0.038970947, 0.0075187683, 0.036621094, 0.008399963, -0.011375427, 0.00004810095, -0.035888672, 0.008590698, -0.022598267, -0.002714157, 0.058532715, 0.047851562, 0.0030937195, -0.03161621, 0.010269165, 0.014602661, -0.0012989044, 0.0026454926, 0.05029297, -0.064208984, 0.030960083, 0.011543274, -0.029083252, -0.016952515, 0.032104492, 0.009353638, -0.028244019, -0.009933472, 0.00066804886, 0.038360596, 0.018630981, -0.010932922, -0.029052734, -0.03488159, 0.015945435, 0.022125244, -0.0037956238, 0.022201538, 0.0010490417, 0.050109863, -0.022705078, 0.016708374, 0.0018663406, 0.014961243, -0.01576233, 0.009048462, -0.056915283, 0.014953613, -0.04244995, -0.05581665, 0.0005354881, -0.0074539185, -0.04574585, -0.026687622, 0.032196045, 0.033935547, 0.04916382, 0.06384277, 0.017501831, -0.0039634705, 0.03250122, -0.038208008, 0.0032539368, 0.027664185, -0.03793335, 0.0076789856, -0.011177063, -0.037750244, 0.04067993, -0.038848877, 0.05203247, 0.0022068024, 0.024673462, -0.038024902, 0.04147339, 0.027893066, -0.089416504, -0.013801575, 0.00021183491, -0.010284424, -0.015266418, -0.003967285, -0.009315491, -0.012664795, -0.011131287, 0.029769897, 0.029006958, 0.0054359436, 0.023483276, -0.039367676, -0.040039062, 0.035125732, -0.01171875, 0.056793213, -0.00484848, -0.019515991, -0.0053863525, -0.00818634, 0.015670776, -0.024169922, -0.015510559, -0.043945312, 0.0000046491623, -0.014022827, 0.0018701553, 0.010910034, -0.02897644, -0.048553467, 0.010353088, -0.0067367554, -0.027679443, 0.012496948, 0.030731201, -0.025970459, -0.04083252, -0.0037021637, -0.03656006, 0.02734375, 0.012870789, -0.010375977, -0.028579712, 0.044555664, -0.028564453, -0.01637268, 0.010772705, 0.047027588, -0.015220642, -0.05517578, -0.0005917549, 0.028137207, 0.04864502, -0.027694702, -0.030715942, 0.025924683, 0.043884277, -0.013679504, 0.04043579, -0.0070762634, -0.0029735565, 0.007972717, 0.053619385, 0.0008111, -0.041259766, -0.05987549, -0.024032593, 0.05770874, 0.03652954, -0.01625061, -0.021606445, 0.02923584, 0.006515503, 0.006290436, 0.010543823, -0.02355957, 0.007358551, -0.007904053, 0.021133423, -0.0031604767, -0.0013771057, -0.012504578, 0.0035552979, 0.011817932, 0.034179688, -0.01626587, 0.008979797, -0.0015668869, 0.06298828, -0.0063705444, -0.018081665, 0.0284729, 0.021942139, 0.016418457, 0.05130005, -0.007881165, -0.02760315, -0.022033691, -0.0020866394, 0.010864258, -0.004058838, 0.023117065, -0.004917145, 0.021728516, -0.033813477, -0.0619812, -0.04421997, -0.054138184, 0.036834717, -0.04824829, 0.0287323, -0.020980835, -0.009002686, 0.0018758774, 0.02507019, 0.0015087128, 0.0065727234, -0.06945801, -0.041412354, 0.027770996, -0.036132812 ], "summary": [ 0.01675415, -0.0060691833, 0.0107803345, 0.02017212, -0.0335083, -0.023147583, 0.018157959, -0.059631348, -0.041290283, 0.03555298, -0.0071487427, 0.033691406, -0.021408081, -0.019866943, 0.01525116, -0.03768921, -0.014259338, 0.01637268, 0.026977539, -0.02748108, 0.0075950623, -0.024032593, 0.029022217, -0.036071777, 0.0052604675, -0.015670776, -0.03152466, 0.00497818, 0.009346008, -0.0051956177, -0.0018749237, 0.012832642, 0.03817749, 0.013694763, -0.049987793, -0.03289795, -0.028579712, 0.020751953, -0.024017334, 0.013969421, 0.015060425, -0.0012760162, 0.07531738, -0.03945923, 0.003227234, 0.064208984, -0.03387451, -0.0262146, 0.010177612, 0.04095459, -0.0020370483, -0.025421143, -0.005619049, 0.03314209, -0.015289307, -0.04534912, -0.022659302, -0.047576904, 0.0044059753, 0.083862305, 0.04522705, -0.0030727386, -0.008239746, -0.04751587, -0.0095825195, -0.014167786, 0.061065674, 0.02154541, 0.035186768, -0.010398865, -0.0021800995, 0.041503906, 0.0368042, -0.04748535, 0.012481689, 0.013389587, -0.003643036, -0.0027770996, 0.010894775, -0.02696228, 0.004928589, 0.021560669, 0.030029297, -0.045928955, 0.0146484375, -0.036621094, -0.014419556, -0.006088257, -0.0011196136, 0.008125305, -0.01586914, -0.00050640106, -0.021881104, 0.05328369, 0.01928711, -0.028076172, -0.0049095154, -0.0018396378, 0.016525269, 0.00052165985, 0.017684937, -0.0552063, -0.01121521, -0.022628784, -0.0065994263, 0.07684326, 0.044708252, 0.005958557, -0.006866455, -0.012565613, 0.01727295, -0.012138367, -0.016052246, -0.033416748, -0.02079773, 0.04269409, 0.0022125244, 0.0017032623, -0.0037117004, 0.0079574585, -0.04434204, -0.00308609, -0.04699707, 0.024627686, 0.020858765, -0.008277893, 0.01737976, 0.037200928, -0.00035119057, 0.04800415, 0.0042304993, -0.024871826, -0.015975952, 0.03591919, -0.0048599243, -0.02331543, 0.015327454, 0.00000923872, 0.06222534, -0.04763794, 0.06573486, 0.024658203, -0.017913818, 0.07208252, -0.023330688, 0.032287598, 0.0027866364, 0.0028896332, -0.016845703, -0.0262146, -0.0060806274, -0.044006348, 0.017532349, 0.008102417, 0.025421143, -0.0132751465, 0.020599365, -0.018478394, 0.0052871704, -0.030960083, 0.06982422, 0.00932312, -0.03942871, 0.06237793, 0.036895752, -0.023666382, -0.003080368, 0.013069153, 0.0001502037, 0.059631348, 0.005744934, -0.01109314, -0.059906006, -0.0019760132, -0.009567261, -0.014556885, 0.019592285, 0.028259277, 0.01424408, 0.005420685, -0.015792847, -0.034973145, 0.06173706, -0.027404785, 0.0077400208, -0.036376953, 0.010108948, 0.007575989, 0.026062012, 0.019226074, -0.031402588, -0.0076065063, -0.008934021, -0.023391724, -0.013252258, -0.016967773, 0.0009241104, 0.008483887, -0.024139404, 0.014198303, 0.026443481, 0.018203735, 0.008483887, -0.0107040405, 0.008544922, 0.004753113, 0.020370483, 0.01008606, -0.024383545, 0.009643555, 0.011909485, -0.046539307, 0.0088272095, -0.0059814453, 0.01727295, -0.007293701, 0.0066833496, -0.019210815, -0.014442444, -0.00630188, -0.043273926, 0.007221222, -0.044677734, 0.02973938, 0.02357483, 0.016326904, -0.029251099, 0.008224487, 0.10418701, -0.016159058, 0.11517334, -0.014404297, 0.019088745, 0.014450073, 0.015312195, -0.0014705658, 0.006340027, -0.12963867, 0.010940552, 0.056030273, 0.0143966675, 0.011856079, -0.014213562, 0.002325058, -0.025909424, -0.084350586, -0.007987976, 0.01675415, -0.00085783005, 0.018844604, 0.02809143, -0.008033752, 0.028305054, 0.011398315, 0.004108429, 0.033325195, 0.02331543, 0.022415161, -0.026809692, 0.04397583, -0.014816284, 0.03262329, 0.009544373, 0.009109497, -0.03277588, -0.037017822, -0.008117676, 0.001991272, 0.060791016, -0.055114746, -0.0053863525, -0.06347656, 0.011383057, 0.051727295, -0.016601562, -0.018203735, 0.013626099, -0.031707764, 0.004142761, 0.00642395, -0.0021095276, -0.033325195, -0.06732178, -0.012458801, 0.066589355, -0.00034499168, -0.015655518, 0.011276245, 0.004135132, 0.03604126, 0.068603516, -0.0096206665, -0.025939941, 0.0024261475, -0.02810669, -0.029449463, 0.018463135, 0.043945312, 0.004825592, -0.028137207, -0.0035190582, 0.012329102, -0.059509277, 0.025787354, 0.0051956177, 0.0126571655, 0.0008497238, 0.024353027, 0.020309448, -0.0036029816, -0.025817871, 0.032836914, 0.04269409, 0.03857422, -0.0026397705, -0.0211792, -0.013038635, 0.03704834, -0.024368286, -0.0093307495, 0.010322571, -0.036834717, 0.016052246, 0.026809692, -0.0209198, -0.019851685, 0.056915283, 0.006385803, -0.03878784, 0.016204834, -0.04421997, -0.026489258, -0.025787354, 0.047943115, -0.019622803, 0.014785767, -0.007045746, 0.07019043, 0.0011873245, -0.019470215, 0.00030946732, -0.01789856, -0.0129852295, 0.0018463135, -0.07165527, 0.0524292, -0.004459381, 0.021652222, -0.012748718, -0.006500244, 0.008071899, -0.02180481, -0.016860962, 0.022125244, 0.022247314, 0.007537842, -0.00092697144, -0.0021572113, -0.0031700134, -0.04638672, 0.0025787354, 0.008872986, -0.010978699, -0.02947998, -0.018676758, -0.00970459, 0.007293701, 0.0129852295, 0.014266968, 0.019744873, -0.025314331, -0.0104522705, -0.033843994, 0.0028820038, 0.030456543, 0.042633057, 0.050598145, -0.019760132, -0.0045661926, 0.011894226, 0.0041007996, -0.006465912, -0.0024433136, -0.0143585205, 0.0869751, -0.015037537, -0.022872925, 0.03829956, 0.0362854, 0.014518738, -0.020233154, -0.04385376, -0.030944824, -0.003162384, 0.005470276, 0.011413574, 0.005870819, -0.031158447, -0.041290283, -0.037475586, 0.02166748, 0.03161621, -0.013336182, 0.0029087067, -0.017471313, 0.029403687, 0.039031982, -0.019439697, 0.012886047, 0.04348755, 0.007610321, -0.064575195, 0.0055999756, -0.049926758, 0.021209717, -0.015380859, 0.026382446, 0.0047454834, 0.008918762, -0.026397705, -0.013389587, 0.018692017, 0.005897522, 0.0059394836, 0.0231781, -0.023422241, 0.042388916, -0.013725281, -0.0041160583, 0.046661377, 0.012901306, -0.013664246, 0.00969696, 0.015670776, -0.056640625, -0.06665039, -0.012290955, -0.07977295, 0.054229736, -0.07598877, -0.046295166, 0.025054932, 0.04046631, 0.0039520264, 0.044708252, -0.035369873, 0.044830322, -0.038726807, -0.011375427, 0.02027893, -0.016433716, 0.008811951, 0.017807007, 0.01828003, -0.013725281, 0.012260437, -0.04260254, -0.005214691, 0.024795532, 0.013656616, 0.027267456, 0.045776367, -0.071899414, -0.021270752, -0.01637268, -0.011360168, 0.035827637, -0.0028800964, -0.014472961, 0.0034751892, -0.029190063, 0.028686523, -0.023330688, -0.016708374, -0.00046777725, 0.011642456, 0.016433716, -0.026779175, 0.07330322, 0.009109497, -0.08404541, 0.042633057, -0.09814453, -0.06088257, -0.05215454, 0.025054932, -0.052612305, -0.036315918, 0.019561768, -0.0259552, -0.032806396, -0.012161255, 0.051757812, -0.01878357, 0.031143188, -0.005126953, -0.023727417, 0.024932861, -0.024414062, -0.0892334, 0.0143966675, -0.008628845, 0.06262207, 0.052459717, -0.0042266846, 0.028808594, -0.015182495, -0.0044555664, -0.0032653809, -0.042938232, -0.027542114, -0.04434204, 0.0541687, 0.032440186, 0.007156372, 0.036499023, 0.02420044, 0.051727295, 0.00033950806, -0.020843506, 0.075927734, 0.06298828, -0.05569458, -0.0028572083, 0.056732178, 0.009468079, -0.07269287, 0.021133423, 0.021575928, -0.08544922, 0.046722412, -0.021392822, 0.017913818, 0.10095215, -0.03375244, 0.064941406, -0.011634827, -0.014038086, -0.0060272217, -0.00011378527, -0.028320312, -0.021972656, 0.036376953, 0.017028809, -0.014053345, 0.021316528, -0.038909912, 0.046417236, -0.009605408, 0.022262573, 0.0032787323, -0.015144348, 0.0057296753, -0.019546509, -0.02519226, 0.030181885, -0.015701294, 0.0039043427, -0.0070266724, 0.037719727, 0.0020923615, -0.0048217773, 0.022537231, -0.004558563, 0.12805176, 0.015106201, 0.0034313202, -0.08959961, -0.04827881, -0.014213562, -0.039978027, 0.006752014, 0.0026454926, -0.029449463, -0.008613586, -0.011154175, -0.001241684, 0.028961182, 0.009841919, 0.043823242, -0.0073242188, 0.0003774166, -0.011962891, 0.045715332, 0.0020580292, 0.039215088, -0.019195557, 0.074035645, 0.003534317, 0.039794922, -0.0079956055, -0.041107178, 0.010917664, -0.026473999, -0.0024909973, -0.030517578, 0.0071105957, -0.009132385, 0.029922485, -0.0037651062, 0.009849548, -0.01638794, -0.002948761, -0.021469116, 0.026611328, -0.012252808, 0.008560181, -0.024246216, 0.04724121, 0.040008545, -0.023117065, -0.040527344, -0.0045166016, 0.05609131, 0.00056552887, -0.055358887, -0.033111572, 0.033081055, 0.021377563, 0.0015678406, 0.030914307, -0.0034637451, 0.023117065, 0.008300781, -0.018936157, 0.02961731, 0.0038986206, 0.06732178, 0.0018529892, -0.0014009476, 0.07354736, -0.015098572, -0.02885437, -0.015617371, -0.0026130676, 0.052886963, -0.032165527, -0.018432617, -0.05709839, -0.039093018, 0.0051994324, 0.015151978, -0.044555664, 0.02180481, 0.026855469, 0.016571045, -0.0012693405, -0.017120361, -0.026947021, -0.02355957, -0.06124878, -0.0011377335, 0.01335144, -0.0031852722, 0.004146576, -0.0127334595, 0.02027893, 0.03213501, -0.022720337, -0.025009155, -0.04360962, -0.021011353, -0.01247406, -0.03894043, 0.03262329, 0.010032654, -0.00655365, 0.03656006, -0.022033691, 0.029754639, -0.011924744, -0.007408142, -0.039978027, -0.037750244, -0.009284973, 0.033416748, 0.013755798, 0.024124146, 0.009361267, -0.021347046, -0.004627228, -0.021087646, -0.016677856, -0.003194809, 0.0033092499, 0.039367676, 0.017593384, -0.012321472, 0.010879517, 0.0031051636, -0.0231781, 0.028274536, 0.0030899048, 0.04626465, 0.01713562, 0.025344849, -0.009750366, -0.05078125, -0.014450073, -0.01977539, 0.035736084, -0.025222778, 0.0023002625, -0.020370483, -0.007007599, 0.02368164, -0.054901123, -0.0040779114, -0.016586304, 0.03555298, -0.017578125, -0.012680054, 0.003900528, 0.0033454895, -0.056427002, -0.038238525, -0.04949951, -0.04559326, -0.025558472, 0.06732178, -0.050750732, 0.029205322, 0.013427734, -0.03439331, -0.0066604614, 0.04574585, -0.0758667, -0.010353088, -0.003528595, -0.014129639, 0.0073394775, 0.03274536, -0.022216797, -0.0030651093, 0.011169434, 0.0014486313, 0.014091492, -0.007865906, -0.035339355, 0.058563232, 0.025436401, 0.0047454834, 0.002746582, -0.013290405, -0.027877808, -0.021148682, -0.0031375885, -0.038360596, 0.014717102, -0.0116119385, 0.04800415, -0.00932312, -0.033355713, -0.042510986, 0.0046577454, -0.046722412, 0.03540039, -0.012565613, -0.05267334, -0.014595032, -0.032470703, 0.021728516, 0.024230957, 0.007911682, 0.046142578, 0.047302246, -0.053619385, 0.010253906, 0.052856445, -0.04345703, -0.052520752, -0.012069702, 0.012306213, 0.04269409, 0.072021484, -0.01789856, 0.005680084, -0.006275177, 0.01550293, 0.010795593, -0.020233154, 0.015914917, -0.008766174, 0.007408142, 0.0026893616, 0.041229248, 0.041168213, -0.0027256012, 0.028015137, -0.00038003922, 0.029205322, 0.00982666, 0.0395813, -0.048736572, -0.008796692, 0.020568848, 0.029342651, 0.007259369, -0.005306244, 0.0046653748, 0.06774902, 0.0020503998, -0.08093262, -0.099853516, -0.09039307, -0.04055786, 0.02029419, -0.03793335, 0.010612488, 0.008460999, 0.016433716, 0.022109985, 0.010391235, 0.0042266846, -0.021743774, 0.029785156, -0.049102783, -0.037139893, 0.007621765, 0.023544312, 0.0026779175, 0.04147339, 0.0102005005, 0.0001885891, 0.029556274, -0.035583496, 0.009132385, 0.041290283, -0.018066406, -0.05038452, 0.02166748, -0.03930664, 0.047668457, 0.024963379, 0.036254883, 0.025817871, -0.005138397, 0.06829834, -0.050628662, 0.0048713684, 0.04260254, 0.0064468384, 0.012161255, 0.028549194, 0.009819031, -0.0047836304, 0.018478394, -0.023254395, 0.008705139, -0.0037498474, 0.031829834, -0.044311523, -0.022277832, -0.01777649, 0.030593872, -0.026397705, -0.008087158, -0.034484863, -0.0065078735, 0.007926941, -0.034484863, 0.0073280334, -0.007293701, 0.020324707, 0.035095215, -0.012817383, 0.030853271, -0.008407593, -0.00072288513, -0.027267456, 0.0038967133, -0.042175293, -0.028381348, -0.0637207, -0.031311035, -0.0023555756, -0.010551453, -0.0057640076, -0.025375366, 0.039276123, 0.06903076, 0.07879639, 0.07537842, -0.009254456, 0.019165039, 0.064086914, -0.01914978, 0.0005264282, 0.00028944016, -0.008781433, -0.015388489, -0.009796143, 0.0028438568, 0.0049743652, -0.008628845, 0.031341553, -0.003566742, 0.022369385, -0.04711914, 0.020706177, -0.04309082, -0.043395996, 0.027633667, -0.019546509, -0.003250122, 0.011062622, 0.025436401, -0.050476074, 0.019897461, -0.03137207, -0.03781128, -0.0034046173, -0.0012378693, 0.030593872, -0.02949524, -0.005279541, 0.007904053, 0.02128601, 0.054504395, 0.02696228, -0.020950317, 0.022018433, 0.011184692, 0.02381897, -0.06427002, -0.025558472, -0.0042495728, 0.019607544, -0.045074463, 0.010948181, 0.005088806, -0.018203735, 0.0090789795, 0.00554657, 0.0154800415, -0.0012578964, 0.042236328, 0.0059432983, -0.0056381226, -0.019699097, 0.004600525, -0.039215088, 0.0031661987, -0.022903442, 0.0007648468, -0.024017334, 0.04699707, -0.022216797, -0.003982544, 0.027786255, 0.03326416, -0.013710022, -0.079833984, 0.006767273, 0.008903503, 0.012046814, -0.012168884, 0.02003479, 0.041107178, 0.078186035, -0.00017356873, -0.012588501, -0.041107178, -0.010314941, 0.025939941, 0.06793213, 0.011009216, -0.033996582, -0.04486084, -0.017578125, 0.060058594, 0.005748749, -0.027877808, -0.014328003, 0.036468506, -0.017440796, 0.0059051514, -0.027404785, -0.012680054, -0.0077781677, -0.016021729, 0.010726929, -0.011734009, 0.02293396, 0.0026054382, -0.01763916, 0.007232666, 0.029525757, -0.011444092, 0.0048980713, -0.0053596497, 0.04019165, 0.0015878677, -0.020889282, 0.014503479, 0.019256592, 0.014015198, -0.004623413, 0.0021743774, -0.017822266, -0.029052734, 0.007461548, 0.013023376, 0.0053100586, 0.0027008057, 0.03302002, 0.04360962, -0.013130188, -0.009742737, -0.0892334, -0.036224365, 0.01713562, 0.0022735596, 0.00083589554, 0.01876831, 0.00819397, 0.005718231, -0.0012168884, -0.025848389, 0.014198303, -0.039794922, -0.07318115, -0.02671814, -0.008544922 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2102.09370v1
A Study on the Manifestation of Trust in Speech
Lara Gauder, Leonardo Pepino, Pablo Riera, Silvina Brussino, Jazmín Vidal, Agustín Gravano, Luciana Ferrer
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.LG
Research has shown that trust is an essential aspect of human-computer interaction directly determining the degree to which the person is willing to use a system. An automatic prediction of the level of trust that a user has on a certain system could be used to attempt to correct potential distrust by having the system take relevant actions like, for example, apologizing or explaining its decisions. In this work, we explore the feasibility of automatically detecting the level of trust that a user has on a virtual assistant (VA) based on their speech. We developed a novel protocol for collecting speech data from subjects induced to have different degrees of trust in the skills of a VA. The protocol consists of an interactive session where the subject is asked to respond to a series of factual questions with the help of a virtual assistant. In order to induce subjects to either trust or distrust the VA's skills, they are first informed that the VA was previously rated by other users as being either good or bad; subsequently, the VA answers the subjects' questions consistently to its alleged abilities. All interactions are speech-based, with subjects and VAs communicating verbally, which allows the recording of speech produced under different trust conditions. Using this protocol, we collected a speech corpus in Argentine Spanish. We show clear evidence that the protocol effectively succeeded in influencing subjects into the desired mental state of either trusting or distrusting the agent's skills, and present results of a perceptual study of the degree of trust performed by expert listeners. Finally, we found that the subject's speech can be used to detect which type of VA they were using, which could be considered a proxy for the user's trust toward the VA's abilities, with an accuracy up to 76%, compared to a random baseline of 50%.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2102.09370v1
"2021-02-09T13:08:54"
"2021-02-09T13:08:54"
{ "title": [ 0.026504517, 0.013664246, -0.078063965, -0.02947998, 0.0077781677, -0.06689453, 0.02999878, 0.033050537, -0.050231934, 0.060668945, -0.022003174, 0.008598328, 0.03793335, -0.03173828, 0.0099105835, -0.02809143, -0.018417358, 0.05316162, 0.030914307, -0.0028972626, 0.010253906, -0.009017944, -0.039093018, -0.10101318, 0.025924683, -0.027954102, 0.0053215027, -0.018417358, 0.050842285, 0.0066719055, 0.02293396, -0.008407593, 0.01878357, 0.01751709, -0.0209198, -0.04220581, -0.026138306, 0.021255493, -0.006679535, -0.0041046143, 0.014022827, -0.018814087, 0.025283813, 0.027450562, -0.02861023, -0.01121521, 0.028747559, -0.01914978, 0.017562866, -0.00944519, -0.027679443, 0.0048446655, -0.00554657, -0.036499023, -0.0209198, 0.0063323975, -0.04156494, 0.042053223, -0.0003771782, 0.008781433, 0.010124207, 0.03640747, 0.019363403, 0.021408081, 0.017181396, -0.02885437, -0.027877808, 0.02053833, 0.00078582764, 0.009216309, 0.021240234, -0.02331543, 0.009780884, 0.00026106834, -0.0038013458, 0.008583069, -0.02330017, 0.029373169, 0.014656067, -0.0045166016, -0.01626587, -0.03012085, 0.01449585, -0.037139893, 0.012496948, -0.021316528, -0.0009446144, 0.0128479, 0.011352539, -0.035186768, 0.00024867058, 0.11663818, -0.01448822, -0.0029525757, -0.05407715, -0.036468506, 0.05429077, 0.07702637, -0.02532959, -0.04800415, -0.07287598, 0.017578125, -0.07751465, -0.00034952164, -0.018585205, -0.002609253, 0.015792847, 0.032226562, 0.026733398, 0.0345459, -0.0395813, 0.054229736, 0.038513184, -0.024597168, -0.012664795, -0.00021505356, -0.01309967, 0.010879517, 0.008476257, 0.014915466, -0.0063819885, 0.05154419, 0.007911682, -0.032196045, 0.00049209595, 0.016448975, 0.012123108, -0.07550049, 0.007068634, 0.023895264, -0.015960693, 0.05822754, -0.115600586, -0.0847168, -0.052459717, 0.000025093555, -0.030197144, -0.009414673, -0.0079956055, -0.011962891, -0.00774765, 0.0026016235, 0.0826416, -0.015808105, -0.016189575, 0.024536133, 0.0289917, 0.028640747, 0.012260437, -0.05392456, -0.0026779175, -0.0015144348, -0.016906738, 0.01977539, 0.022766113, 0.026687622, -0.07470703, 0.031280518, 0.05480957, 0.07696533, 0.0028247833, 0.006668091, -0.009689331, 0.0524292, 0.018173218, -0.0113220215, 0.045318604, 0.035064697, 0.021774292, 0.05307007, 0.0132751465, -0.02519226, -0.03805542, -0.0040664673, -0.0078125, -0.012084961, -0.022018433, -0.00045514107, 0.029083252, -0.033172607, -0.031433105, -0.04748535, -0.020050049, 0.020080566, -0.01108551, -0.021652222, 0.026687622, 0.019241333, -0.012077332, 0.044525146, -0.017547607, 0.05670166, -0.030899048, -0.007484436, -0.012176514, 0.01373291, -0.022384644, 0.028259277, -0.016616821, -0.004043579, -0.011062622, -0.0017776489, 0.022903442, -0.021377563, -0.051086426, -0.0017175674, -0.018295288, 0.022003174, 0.059265137, 0.0138168335, 0.0022010803, -0.0317688, 0.013031006, -0.032989502, -0.058898926, -0.025283813, 0.007598877, -0.05026245, -0.0131073, -0.029129028, -0.013534546, 0.03036499, -0.065979004, 0.0010299683, -0.008430481, -0.00023412704, -0.010322571, -0.01449585, -0.005252838, 0.027359009, 0.016540527, -0.0034179688, 0.026916504, 0.010536194, -0.026153564, -0.015556335, 0.0020503998, -0.066101074, 0.009414673, 0.05215454, 0.015975952, -0.03918457, 0.005065918, 0.004798889, -0.0023384094, 0.008483887, 0.044891357, -0.023544312, 0.019897461, 0.022506714, 0.019348145, -0.02418518, 0.034698486, -0.017196655, 0.02822876, 0.04345703, -0.01335144, 0.036865234, -0.022644043, 0.02545166, -0.014663696, 0.018966675, 0.04168701, -0.026229858, -0.09161377, 0.051208496, -0.0440979, 0.016326904, 0.003414154, 0.034210205, 0.016021729, -0.034240723, 0.005847931, 0.020889282, -0.0012378693, -0.018356323, -0.061523438, 0.034057617, -0.010658264, 0.010650635, -0.03643799, -0.008491516, -0.029876709, 0.0062179565, -0.015716553, 0.08215332, 0.04446411, 0.018173218, 0.0021896362, 0.03677368, 0.04067993, 0.07598877, -0.00024461746, 0.036834717, 0.03652954, 0.03665161, -0.017929077, 0.006603241, -0.0074501038, -0.015640259, 0.015266418, 0.026748657, -0.017028809, 0.04724121, 0.025985718, 0.019729614, 0.041015625, 0.014442444, 0.0121536255, 0.008140564, -0.03540039, -0.0033226013, 0.024627686, -0.011856079, 0.032470703, -0.0017337799, -0.014381409, 0.022583008, -0.016189575, 0.015151978, -0.006088257, -0.010475159, -0.027160645, -0.03652954, -0.02166748, 0.0071792603, -0.03274536, -0.000068724155, -0.02079773, 0.009429932, 0.042236328, -0.033996582, -0.040527344, -0.08258057, 0.017242432, -0.00080633163, 0.02104187, -0.0019836426, 0.029220581, 0.015640259, 0.04547119, 0.022613525, -0.023132324, -0.022964478, 0.02104187, -0.032440186, -0.029830933, -0.001074791, 0.031097412, 0.0021705627, -0.004753113, 0.005970001, 0.026611328, -0.0023384094, 0.059051514, -0.03439331, -0.060180664, 0.048858643, 0.043762207, -0.0032730103, 0.029281616, 0.006351471, -0.0071525574, -0.022583008, -0.012306213, -0.046295166, -0.010406494, -0.0038776398, -0.0062828064, 0.0026073456, 0.003326416, -0.022064209, 0.0051078796, -0.003042221, -0.01965332, -0.004798889, 0.020263672, -0.04309082, -0.016342163, -0.02003479, -0.009223938, -0.040496826, 0.083984375, 0.0035514832, 0.07220459, 0.010917664, 0.0036582947, 0.00019025803, 0.06616211, 0.019577026, -0.0017700195, -0.044067383, -0.053344727, -0.018096924, 0.011100769, -0.0070152283, 0.019943237, 0.0012655258, -0.048309326, -0.0021915436, 0.027130127, -0.018692017, -0.003780365, 0.01197052, 0.0011396408, -0.011543274, 0.035583496, -0.014884949, 0.036010742, -0.018844604, -0.011711121, 0.04437256, 0.018081665, -0.0030174255, -0.032287598, -0.027175903, -0.033081055, 0.002418518, -0.05343628, 0.013885498, 0.02998352, -0.015281677, 0.000027418137, 0.01663208, 0.010673523, 0.027786255, 0.034576416, -0.0026226044, 0.005580902, -0.040802002, 0.0072135925, -0.047302246, 0.036071777, 0.018249512, -0.10095215, -0.00774765, 0.00063705444, 0.064941406, 0.10571289, -0.064453125, -0.051086426, 0.0032615662, -0.011512756, -0.043273926, -0.015914917, -0.017150879, 0.03668213, -0.018203735, -0.032928467, -0.00522995, -0.035308838, 0.019836426, 0.00957489, 0.032318115, -0.0005364418, -0.0007491112, 0.013771057, 0.038024902, 0.05178833, 0.026153564, 0.02508545, -0.0035953522, -0.06323242, 0.050811768, 0.0011711121, 0.019348145, 0.030014038, 0.035339355, 0.025466919, -0.013404846, 0.041259766, -0.026290894, -0.02809143, -0.008735657, 0.032928467, 0.034362793, -0.033081055, 0.00061798096, -0.024978638, -0.008712769, -0.0036354065, 0.0020923615, -0.014976501, -0.03378296, -0.024475098, -0.005115509, -0.059631348, -0.013214111, 0.025421143, -0.06329346, -0.01789856, -0.005329132, 0.02633667, -0.042053223, -0.0038776398, -0.04534912, -0.0068588257, -0.0025577545, 0.020065308, -0.064575195, -0.031021118, 0.042755127, -0.019729614, -0.0042533875, -0.008590698, -0.03488159, 0.0031318665, -0.017822266, 0.03161621, 0.050476074, -0.020706177, 0.008338928, 0.01210022, 0.0019741058, -0.010635376, 0.02911377, 0.020599365, -0.032409668, 0.028778076, 0.007637024, 0.09765625, 0.1071167, -0.019134521, 0.0178833, 0.0592041, -0.013114929, -0.0501709, -0.0065345764, -0.020324707, -0.031677246, 0.020690918, 0.0022087097, -0.027313232, 0.01197052, 0.022659302, 0.023590088, 0.0070724487, -0.014350891, 0.008857727, -0.010238647, -0.0026302338, -0.03111267, -0.032928467, 0.01133728, 0.010688782, -0.022216797, -0.025222778, 0.043060303, -0.015808105, 0.037628174, 0.0061149597, -0.0072631836, -0.060760498, 0.015380859, 0.002210617, -0.075683594, -0.087524414, 0.004096985, -0.034057617, 0.011917114, -0.0006403923, 0.005004883, -0.012046814, 0.012283325, 0.050750732, 0.016723633, 0.012313843, -0.04232788, -0.046020508, -0.050323486, -0.034820557, -0.000518322, 0.0011749268, 0.014564514, 0.0026283264, 0.010719299, -0.021408081, 0.018692017, 0.0019388199, 0.017532349, 0.0259552, 0.010040283, -0.011329651, 0.0154418945, -0.0023670197, 0.051605225, -0.017654419, 0.015419006, -0.0044021606, 0.018753052, -0.0014648438, -0.028244019, -0.0029335022, -0.012641907, 0.009506226, -0.016418457, 0.033233643, -0.03778076, 0.016784668, -0.0013208389, -0.017501831, -0.00793457, 0.009140015, -0.01739502, 0.053100586, 0.012886047, -0.052856445, 0.062927246, -0.012077332, 0.0090408325, 0.027542114, -0.029937744, -0.022323608, 0.032073975, -0.021972656, 0.029129028, 0.000415802, 0.0017795563, -0.010246277, -0.043426514, 0.03543091, -0.01171875, 0.03805542, 0.02708435, -0.015068054, -0.046905518, -0.014595032, -0.004085541, -0.0050849915, -0.0065956116, 0.0063171387, 0.005706787, -0.006164551, -0.015007019, 0.046569824, 0.00060749054, 0.005065918, 0.00365448, -0.010879517, 0.018188477, 0.010345459, 0.019973755, -0.014709473, -0.043182373, 0.032440186, -0.042114258, -0.03869629, -0.008880615, -0.030258179, -0.016082764, -0.0037784576, 0.009162903, 0.025741577, 0.00749588, 0.0005745888, -0.0046195984, -0.010643005, 0.008407593, -0.013442993, -0.029129028, 0.027130127, 0.05038452, -0.016036987, 0.03274536, -0.005924225, 0.042907715, -0.002456665, 0.020812988, -0.022079468, -0.006248474, -0.0048675537, -0.026123047, -0.032287598, -0.04748535, -0.020324707, -0.010475159, -0.0131073, 0.035614014, 0.010543823, -0.045684814, 0.0046310425, 0.01197052, 0.04714966, -0.024765015, -0.030227661, 0.027999878, 0.015945435, -0.0015792847, -0.012939453, -0.052612305, -0.006664276, 0.03186035, -0.062683105, -0.015182495, 0.0022277832, -0.05508423, -0.038391113, 0.010543823, 0.05053711, 0.031799316, 0.024551392, -0.0016155243, 0.0143585205, -0.014945984, 0.017791748, 0.014770508, -0.028930664, -0.003414154, -0.016952515, 0.018798828, 0.010147095, 0.016952515, 0.013771057, 0.0017499924, -0.008728027, 0.0036029816, 0.06137085, 0.04144287, 0.018615723, -0.0042037964, -0.025222778, -0.052764893, -0.032318115, -0.009986877, 0.008872986, 0.019454956, -0.05078125, -0.008384705, -0.03265381, -0.03692627, 0.018295288, 0.05493164, -0.005004883, -0.004131317, 0.023101807, -0.04147339, 0.056243896, 0.020095825, 0.004711151, -0.037475586, -0.05368042, 0.014526367, 0.014160156, -0.008087158, -0.009056091, 0.023620605, 0.005645752, -0.0039978027, 0.026626587, 0.008995056, 0.080444336, -0.016433716, -0.031585693, -0.024246216, 0.0041007996, -0.051635742, -0.036743164, 0.012046814, -0.0023002625, 0.0011043549, -0.05319214, -0.013549805, -0.005130768, 0.03945923, -0.031188965, 0.008384705, -0.036712646, -0.0116119385, 0.009681702, 0.016952515, -0.017471313, 0.04559326, -0.02607727, -0.03274536, -0.018096924, -0.0043258667, 0.01461792, 0.0036373138, -0.0129470825, 0.010925293, 0.00015306473, 0.018615723, -0.015182495, -0.008743286, -0.009597778, -0.018341064, 0.05496216, 0.011489868, 0.020202637, 0.027145386, 0.02720642, 0.025939941, -0.0018501282, 0.007904053, -0.026245117, -0.010437012, 0.04071045, 0.009513855, -0.025039673, -0.001159668, 0.006286621, -0.07537842, -0.025299072, -0.019470215, -0.0029945374, -0.03692627, -0.030059814, 0.027664185, 0.021759033, -0.009429932, 0.013343811, 0.046295166, -0.05419922, -0.01612854, -0.093444824, 0.037261963, 0.0124435425, -0.016784668, -0.030685425, -0.028900146, 0.0256958, 0.03515625, -0.0058021545, 0.029006958, -0.030258179, -0.0062828064, 0.04220581, -0.018371582, -0.023727417, 0.015541077, 0.037139893, -0.018600464, -0.046081543, 0.02017212, 0.0028743744, -0.0021877289, -0.043701172, -0.013671875, 0.032562256, -0.0025253296, 0.010467529, -0.030349731, -0.0062179565, 0.033477783, -0.059448242, 0.027908325, 0.03555298, -0.030136108, 0.03086853, 0.04736328, 0.04336548, -0.014549255, -0.0011291504, 0.04272461, -0.0056610107, 0.008598328, 0.006454468, -0.04928589, -0.0552063, -0.049346924, -0.02809143, -0.03616333, -0.055511475, 0.016281128, 0.031311035, -0.04727173, -0.03616333, -0.028274536, -0.044647217, -0.085632324, 0.009994507, 0.052978516, 0.052520752, -0.059143066, -0.036956787, 0.028823853, 0.012023926, -0.036193848, -0.0008659363, 0.049194336, -0.009361267, -0.013908386, 0.038726807, 0.017425537, -0.0018358231, -0.062683105, 0.008224487, -0.031234741, 0.03866577, 0.0010385513, 0.0060195923, -0.021881104, -0.000854969, 0.016036987, 0.03829956, 0.0013484955, 0.004714966, 0.022109985, -0.027572632, -0.0064201355, -0.027679443, -0.010910034, 0.022857666, -0.010765076, 0.00094890594, 0.036712646, 0.0501709, -0.050048828, 0.011512756, -0.0052108765, -0.042236328, 0.010070801, 0.03781128, 0.059783936, -0.03717041, -0.019546509, 0.04168701, 0.029144287, 0.09375, -0.008087158, -0.03579712, -0.045196533, 0.0209198, 0.037506104, 0.044799805, -0.012458801, 0.050567627, -0.051361084, -0.043426514, 0.030029297, 0.021438599, -0.016235352, -0.039398193, 0.029556274, -0.027023315, -0.005710602, 0.0012426376, 0.0107040405, 0.0041999817, -0.026733398, 0.002817154, -0.036865234, -0.04168701, -0.033325195, -0.029205322, 0.0501709, -0.0024337769, -0.0025234222, 0.021728516, 0.025619507, 0.024429321, 0.008934021, -0.0016365051, -0.031585693, -0.0020694733, -0.008956909, -0.07702637, -0.097839355, -0.02947998, 0.12438965, 0.011306763, -0.023742676, 0.042175293, 0.035736084, -0.068481445, -0.038024902, -0.031677246, -0.029434204, 0.029891968, 0.027496338, 0.002922058, 0.013633728, -0.026992798, 0.053710938, -0.00064086914, -0.03744507, 0.0061454773, -0.031021118, -0.029388428, 0.0064048767, -0.022140503, 0.016098022, -0.0051612854, 0.009544373, -0.06890869, 0.031036377, -0.002872467, -0.013496399, -0.0087890625, 0.044189453, -0.014274597, 0.052764893, -0.00032114983, -0.009292603, -0.00087976456, 0.02281189, 0.015899658, 0.017913818, 0.0062065125, -0.015213013, -0.04598999, -0.0062332153, 0.045043945, -0.008201599, -0.0070152283, -0.0070991516, 0.015281677, -0.019241333, -0.03387451, -0.06768799, -0.027770996, -0.003742218, -0.016235352, 0.033172607, 0.007896423, -0.0013513565, 0.00037550926, -0.03250122, -0.03173828, -0.049102783, -0.022964478, -0.011817932, -0.0061149597, 0.008720398 ], "summary": [ 0.0124053955, 0.0036640167, -0.036315918, 0.027511597, -0.0026493073, -0.04006958, 0.017166138, -0.027572632, 0.007408142, 0.011062622, -0.013084412, -0.021911621, 0.015037537, -0.051239014, 0.0059776306, -0.026672363, -0.028366089, 0.048675537, 0.0058784485, -0.029891968, 0.01600647, -0.035247803, -0.030456543, -0.093444824, 0.038726807, -0.028411865, 0.008529663, 0.013977051, 0.043823242, 0.04437256, 0.02116394, -0.07873535, -0.014556885, 0.036010742, -0.030380249, -0.061584473, -0.025909424, 0.032226562, 0.011924744, 0.0034503937, 0.038391113, -0.0022354126, 0.039398193, -0.019241333, -0.0050849915, 0.010787964, 0.014472961, -0.04437256, 0.029190063, 0.012741089, -0.016998291, 0.02027893, -0.017654419, -0.018508911, 0.004524231, 0.0046806335, -0.013557434, 0.0024909973, 0.003780365, 0.042053223, 0.006340027, 0.016113281, -0.00090551376, -0.028503418, -0.024536133, -0.0043563843, -0.016494751, -0.013046265, 0.009963989, -0.028518677, 0.024841309, -0.0037460327, -0.008834839, -0.016433716, -0.010658264, 0.029724121, -0.001657486, -0.007003784, 0.008354187, 0.008033752, 0.031433105, 0.0037937164, 0.043060303, -0.06161499, 0.025497437, -0.05380249, 0.01361084, 0.0035800934, -0.016952515, 0.024261475, -0.008293152, -0.012748718, 0.00087308884, 0.06185913, 0.018737793, -0.013244629, 0.014907837, 0.019607544, 0.0024337769, -0.021438599, -0.027664185, -0.0010108948, -0.045776367, -0.013191223, 0.02166748, 0.05014038, -0.02709961, -0.05810547, 0.018417358, 0.024154663, 0.0066223145, 0.008934021, -0.017486572, -0.008415222, -0.04309082, 0.034332275, -0.020904541, -0.03326416, -0.01776123, 0.008369446, -0.019866943, 0.022918701, -0.0016441345, 0.009513855, 0.031402588, 0.034698486, 0.016281128, -0.049926758, 0.008514404, 0.02658081, -0.009162903, 0.005580902, -0.06536865, -0.026046753, -0.04574585, 0.0008125305, -0.00050640106, 0.0017757416, 0.011123657, -0.03125, 0.0234375, 0.00299263, 0.027938843, 0.010429382, -0.0061912537, 0.0262146, 0.038085938, -0.0074043274, -0.028396606, -0.045684814, 0.015052795, -0.006198883, -0.031311035, 0.016067505, 0.027114868, 0.004383087, -0.05819702, 0.02217102, 0.061767578, 0.054229736, -0.0030841827, 0.011245728, 0.025314331, 0.043182373, 0.026046753, 0.010925293, 0.017791748, 0.021759033, 0.008773804, 0.017227173, 0.0087509155, -0.016555786, -0.01586914, 0.0013809204, -0.0053215027, -0.011886597, 0.03704834, 0.027435303, 0.01676941, -0.03567505, -0.032562256, -0.040222168, 0.07696533, -0.04550171, 0.0064697266, 0.014755249, 0.0072021484, 0.0011405945, -0.007522583, 0.009460449, -0.0115356445, 0.059814453, 0.012229919, -0.022415161, -0.021469116, -0.029388428, -0.005630493, 0.00093889236, -0.035064697, 0.02192688, 0.08087158, -0.018997192, 0.017211914, -0.0871582, -0.13537598, -0.0039367676, -0.027648926, 0.038848877, -0.0013408661, 0.011878967, 0.0093688965, -0.037872314, -0.025222778, 0.07208252, -0.014472961, -0.038391113, 0.050476074, -0.0006222725, 0.0041389465, -0.0047340393, -0.020446777, 0.019454956, -0.040283203, 0.028778076, -0.048980713, 0.026901245, -0.023468018, 0.03074646, 0.00030493736, 0.015052795, 0.06933594, -0.030899048, 0.046966553, 0.03878784, -0.0033245087, -0.006504059, 0.009849548, -0.07006836, 0.006038666, 0.042022705, 0.018112183, -0.034454346, 0.0012998581, 0.049682617, -0.05078125, -0.025299072, 0.039733887, 0.003704071, 0.0095825195, 0.026947021, -0.036834717, 0.00818634, 0.05114746, 0.021240234, 0.0026493073, 0.04547119, -0.02658081, -0.024963379, 0.016693115, -0.02166748, 0.004096985, -0.09240723, -0.010169983, -0.03729248, -0.08282471, -0.009506226, -0.05996704, -0.045043945, 0.004497528, -0.013008118, 0.004184723, -0.056793213, -0.017059326, -0.019348145, 0.026977539, -0.03717041, -0.06439209, 0.04537964, 0.019561768, -0.024536133, -0.02468872, -0.019577026, -0.0046195984, -0.010772705, 0.0053215027, 0.012382507, 0.02859497, -0.0084991455, -0.002922058, 0.060546875, 0.047912598, 0.059570312, 0.0071754456, 0.010902405, -0.027542114, 0.026611328, 0.0038490295, 0.007987976, 0.010940552, -0.029693604, -0.01940918, 0.025100708, -0.017791748, -0.0020065308, 0.014793396, 0.008232117, 0.0064582825, 0.04660034, 0.020599365, -0.024261475, 0.009933472, 0.028045654, 0.022445679, 0.011474609, -0.009468079, -0.04284668, -0.02722168, 0.0048179626, -0.062194824, -0.025680542, 0.090148926, -0.0052108765, 0.0043754578, 0.005218506, -0.00819397, -0.042907715, 0.0385437, -0.023620605, -0.009010315, 0.011451721, 0.02508545, 0.0069389343, -0.008079529, -0.017196655, -0.0026683807, -0.009162903, 0.00894165, -0.05102539, 0.011421204, -0.0010890961, 0.04611206, 0.0058937073, -0.01512146, -0.005050659, -0.05709839, -0.02003479, 0.015220642, -0.0032863617, 0.015220642, -0.031463623, 0.03857422, -0.025817871, 0.020523071, 0.027496338, 0.064331055, -0.030319214, -0.0552063, 0.047821045, 0.032684326, 0.0019550323, 0.07702637, 0.038513184, 0.03765869, -0.06286621, -0.058410645, -0.051696777, 0.020935059, -0.03744507, -0.013084412, 0.02520752, 0.021621704, 0.020370483, -0.039794922, -0.032592773, -0.06201172, 0.0023231506, 0.07684326, -0.019683838, -0.012237549, 0.029785156, 0.0041389465, 0.02368164, -0.007358551, 0.031433105, 0.06210327, 0.012321472, 0.05215454, 0.031555176, 0.033843994, -0.01852417, -0.0056152344, 0.0073165894, -0.017089844, -0.0019874573, 0.007911682, -0.009971619, 0.032806396, 0.0496521, -0.05618286, -0.024459839, 0.006843567, 0.00075006485, 0.0055007935, -0.0037288666, -0.00090169907, -0.007156372, 0.03186035, -0.021392822, 0.036956787, -0.01802063, 0.016143799, 0.0067253113, -0.0013017654, -0.0027179718, -0.0026302338, -0.045776367, -0.022659302, -0.002363205, 0.03668213, -0.021713257, -0.038024902, 0.029632568, -0.025650024, 0.0018386841, 0.018692017, 0.057739258, -0.003856659, -0.021743774, 0.015258789, -0.013748169, 0.0032596588, -0.022994995, 0.010765076, -0.013450623, -0.0713501, -0.024749756, -0.018737793, 0.017303467, 0.032226562, -0.05105591, -0.034973145, 0.009353638, -0.04586792, -0.024917603, -0.0020503998, -0.026046753, 0.031188965, -0.048950195, -0.06604004, -0.030410767, -0.03161621, 0.025634766, -0.016113281, 0.047729492, 0.016235352, 0.035980225, 0.013420105, 0.03933716, 0.06945801, -0.040649414, 0.014099121, -0.003850937, -0.066833496, 0.04257202, 0.023742676, 0.031799316, -0.027252197, 0.03643799, 0.0010089874, -0.01512146, 0.039123535, -0.023284912, -0.017578125, -0.039916992, 0.055847168, 0.0017566681, -0.015167236, -0.02029419, 0.009315491, -0.0031471252, -0.056793213, 0.028015137, -0.06530762, -0.062469482, -0.028213501, -0.012779236, -0.058502197, -0.039031982, -0.004295349, -0.055633545, 0.008850098, -0.0236969, 0.04437256, -0.057495117, -0.010398865, -0.04940796, -0.01663208, 0.0055618286, -0.006549835, -0.044708252, -0.011108398, 0.0082092285, 0.045318604, 0.032470703, -0.0057029724, 0.045196533, 0.011512756, 0.01121521, -0.00013577938, -0.048065186, -0.0034427643, -0.036987305, -0.0014257431, -0.0018892288, -0.019134521, -0.015991211, 0.044952393, -0.02507019, 0.0088272095, 0.010345459, 0.10424805, 0.111083984, -0.06994629, 0.0021381378, 0.080566406, -0.0049743652, -0.09362793, -0.008926392, -0.010864258, -0.022216797, 0.008850098, 0.03375244, -0.030456543, -0.010955811, 0.009025574, -0.007167816, -0.0064315796, -0.0071105957, 0.034698486, 0.02178955, -0.010032654, 0.0008096695, -0.000093102455, 0.018875122, 0.0014753342, -0.013618469, -0.042907715, 0.0030574799, -0.0015306473, 0.005130768, -0.015304565, -0.01209259, -0.03137207, -0.022781372, -0.019943237, -0.06817627, -0.045166016, 0.0016260147, 0.028289795, 0.01335144, 0.007183075, -0.010620117, 0.002954483, 0.009063721, 0.046844482, 0.018707275, -0.03930664, -0.08508301, -0.047302246, -0.013122559, -0.01360321, 0.006259918, -0.025421143, -0.05432129, -0.016937256, -0.020553589, -0.03955078, 0.012107849, 0.032348633, 0.092041016, 0.021606445, 0.03753662, -0.045806885, -0.0052757263, -0.032440186, 0.028945923, -0.0067329407, -0.011146545, -0.0038280487, 0.027923584, 0.041625977, -0.013038635, 0.0017623901, 0.020980835, 0.0044021606, -0.024810791, 0.019622803, -0.049316406, 0.024810791, -0.006198883, -0.026672363, 0.014419556, -0.0027065277, -0.005809784, 0.035980225, 0.048217773, -0.02218628, 0.037841797, -0.0062065125, 0.023086548, -0.0027046204, 0.0017557144, 0.012054443, -0.00749588, 0.0054397583, 0.024475098, -0.014503479, -0.0031166077, 0.034210205, 0.009544373, 0.05621338, 0.01525116, 0.050811768, 0.07409668, 0.016830444, 0.016967773, -0.0115737915, -0.01234436, -0.011497498, 0.022827148, -0.027648926, 0.012886047, -0.017318726, 0.00047516823, 0.038909912, 0.005508423, -0.01776123, 0.004924774, -0.04989624, -0.015602112, 0.0051116943, 0.0057907104, -0.03982544, 0.034698486, -0.01977539, 0.007144928, 0.01071167, -0.047576904, 0.0059432983, -0.026901245, -0.016159058, -0.00233078, 0.018234253, -0.0011281967, -0.0084991455, 0.020736694, -0.009559631, -0.022232056, 0.0033721924, -0.06982422, -0.060913086, -0.028396606, -0.028213501, -0.018081665, -0.0013742447, -0.0079956055, -0.007621765, 0.0016336441, -0.015960693, -0.016235352, -0.01864624, -0.028244019, 0.014892578, -0.017623901, 0.006778717, 0.033447266, -0.0024642944, 0.019622803, 0.008781433, -0.01889038, 0.018829346, 0.06323242, 0.034484863, -0.047943115, -0.013015747, 0.056732178, 0.034362793, -0.013374329, 0.012649536, -0.028915405, -0.008338928, -0.0317688, -0.017211914, -0.07714844, 0.018920898, -0.016799927, -0.043060303, 0.01386261, 0.005142212, -0.0043792725, -0.017730713, 0.01965332, 0.04019165, 0.022323608, -0.021835327, 0.038757324, -0.013870239, 0.058288574, -0.009407043, 0.014770508, 0.026565552, 0.005947113, 0.0018444061, 0.016845703, -0.006614685, -0.006099701, 0.008224487, -0.022979736, -0.01737976, 0.04827881, -0.010765076, -0.016479492, -0.004901886, -0.027282715, 0.016220093, -0.013504028, -0.0000603199, 0.005634308, -0.023330688, -0.027130127, 0.013763428, 0.015083313, -0.011802673, -0.009971619, 0.007926941, -0.04473877, 0.062438965, -0.0019798279, 0.03579712, -0.023742676, -0.00548172, 0.011604309, 0.04498291, 0.00036001205, -0.024047852, 0.029525757, 0.0071907043, -0.057159424, 0.030426025, -0.00048446655, 0.06317139, -0.023010254, -0.035858154, 0.0041503906, 0.012046814, -0.0015974045, 0.040405273, 0.031555176, -0.026641846, -0.008934021, -0.050598145, -0.0000410676, -0.01625061, 0.017303467, 0.036254883, 0.037200928, 0.018218994, 0.019256592, 0.02041626, 0.019180298, 0.027313232, -0.02670288, 0.012481689, 0.06185913, -0.04446411, 0.055145264, 0.007873535, 0.014602661, -0.013244629, -0.025009155, -0.023513794, 0.019363403, 0.016281128, 0.03427124, -0.004207611, -0.00056409836, 0.018829346, 0.0044441223, 0.011108398, 0.024658203, -0.0066452026, 0.031097412, 0.008293152, -0.0044555664, 0.0131073, -0.0031528473, 0.027404785, -0.005115509, -0.03591919, -0.014266968, 0.03994751, -0.031463623, -0.0033111572, -0.02305603, -0.013626099, 0.002981186, 0.029830933, 0.014663696, -0.009033203, 0.028060913, 0.009666443, 0.048217773, -0.011070251, -0.056671143, -0.06744385, -0.0029773712, 0.0184021, 0.007789612, -0.026367188, 0.02027893, -0.0039138794, 0.022232056, 0.0007710457, 0.033813477, -0.020202637, -0.007221222, 0.018707275, -0.014854431, -0.03250122, -0.013771057, 0.024658203, -0.03677368, 0.019897461, 0.010940552, 0.026809692, 0.03439331, 0.0042419434, 0.022521973, -0.0143966675, 0.0158844, -0.048858643, 0.034301758, -0.03164673, -0.014091492, -0.04006958, 0.05545044, 0.034606934, -0.025634766, 0.039916992, 0.035583496, 0.047088623, -0.038238525, 0.013015747, 0.0084991455, 0.008995056, -0.016983032, 0.0014162064, -0.055999756, -0.078430176, -0.059143066, -0.0018167496, -0.033325195, -0.024627686, 0.0071640015, 0.008262634, -0.036224365, -0.015838623, -0.011802673, 0.0075149536, -0.054351807, 0.017074585, -0.009300232, 0.00092697144, -0.023513794, -0.031311035, -0.008483887, 0.022857666, -0.023864746, -0.020462036, 0.05303955, 0.01878357, 0.018341064, 0.0131073, -0.028915405, -0.015007019, 0.012916565, -0.010520935, 0.001367569, -0.036621094, -0.024536133, -0.021591187, 0.00047016144, 0.00497818, 0.017593384, 0.00013518333, 0.040771484, -0.005268097, 0.023864746, -0.04034424, -0.009208679, -0.04638672, -0.028045654, 0.07910156, -0.046081543, -0.018997192, 0.040771484, 0.045074463, -0.06274414, 0.087402344, 0.011047363, -0.110961914, 0.04916382, 0.0057907104, 0.035949707, -0.0073280334, 0.0035648346, 0.015945435, 0.012901306, 0.06842041, -0.027038574, -0.049438477, -0.0047721863, 0.022079468, 0.027175903, -0.0025539398, -0.031433105, 0.05014038, 0.03366089, -0.054901123, 0.027130127, 0.040496826, -0.006137848, 0.025787354, -0.001991272, 0.000603199, -0.008270264, 0.061401367, 0.047729492, 0.035308838, -0.10180664, -0.0018806458, -0.010864258, -0.011520386, -0.08288574, 0.00016880035, 0.049804688, -0.011871338, 0.010681152, -0.011352539, 0.022949219, 0.00869751, 0.008354187, -0.027038574, -0.00579834, -0.011077881, 0.014846802, -0.027236938, -0.0061302185, 0.015670776, 0.039855957, 0.005367279, -0.05569458, -0.0042800903, -0.007369995, 0.021987915, -0.01928711, 0.0039596558, -0.015853882, 0.00472641, 0.026870728, 0.07116699, 0.0048713684, -0.052337646, 0.03768921, 0.010856628, -0.06536865, -0.014595032, -0.029556274, -0.010513306, -0.022491455, -0.007446289, 0.0064735413, -0.00033545494, 0.012664795, -0.021118164, -0.0023441315, -0.0024299622, -0.024871826, 0.006011963, 0.0054969788, -0.033203125, 0.025100708, -0.018066406, -0.025680542, 0.00077056885, -0.0070648193, 0.0061187744, 0.00315094, 0.018234253, -0.015388489, -0.031677246, -0.014442444, 0.031204224, 0.007171631, 0.017227173, -0.09350586, 0.010108948, -0.08831787, -0.022506714, -0.074401855, -0.020050049, -0.009819031, 0.023483276, 0.008407593, 0.061920166, -0.02381897, 0.020889282, 0.012908936, 0.013015747, 0.0093307495, -0.0052261353, 0.008255005, 0.021194458, -0.0022468567 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2103.02958v3
Serverless Data Science -- Are We There Yet? A Case Study of Model Serving
Yuncheng Wu, Tien Tuan Anh Dinh, Guoyu Hu, Meihui Zhang, Yeow Meng Chee, Beng Chin Ooi
cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.LG
Machine learning (ML) is an important part of modern data science applications. Data scientists today have to manage the end-to-end ML life cycle that includes both model training and model serving, the latter of which is essential, as it makes their works available to end-users. Systems of model serving require high performance, low cost, and ease of management. Cloud providers are already offering model serving choices, including managed services and self-rented servers. Recently, serverless computing, whose advantages include high elasticity and a fine-grained cost model, brings another option for model serving. Our goal in this paper is to examine the viability of serverless as a mainstream model serving platform. To this end, we first conduct a comprehensive evaluation of the performance and cost of serverless against other model serving systems on Amazon Web Service and Google Cloud Platform. We find that serverless outperforms many cloud-based alternatives. Further, there are settings under which it even achieves better performance than GPU-based systems. Next, we present the design space of serverless model serving, which comprises multiple dimensions, including cloud platforms, serving runtimes, and other function-specific parameters. For each dimension, we analyze the impact of different choices and provide suggestions for data scientists to better utilize serverless model serving. Finally, we discuss challenges and opportunities in building a more practical serverless model serving system.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.02958v3
"2022-03-01T15:53:39"
"2021-03-04T11:23:01"
{ "title": [ -0.0146102905, -0.009880066, -0.060302734, -0.07110596, 0.01626587, -0.01512146, -0.009422302, 0.009376526, 0.007926941, 0.03955078, -0.0124053955, -0.02053833, 0.020446777, -0.028518677, -0.042266846, 0.0074539185, 0.008369446, 0.021591187, -0.0029144287, -0.024002075, -0.00592041, -0.0035686493, 0.0146484375, 0.054534912, 0.02456665, -0.015159607, -0.082336426, -0.004131317, -0.015426636, -0.028060913, -0.002122879, 0.022583008, 0.02532959, 0.018737793, -0.007820129, 0.022583008, -0.026885986, 0.034851074, -0.0009407997, 0.0026817322, 0.0104522705, -0.0025596619, 0.00541687, -0.0036010742, -0.01600647, 0.0026741028, -0.05142212, -0.028930664, -0.026977539, 0.05215454, -0.004058838, 0.014526367, -0.017730713, 0.061706543, 0.019302368, -0.03274536, -0.015312195, -0.0056419373, 0.032073975, 0.025924683, -0.0046043396, -0.017837524, 0.032104492, -0.0104522705, -0.01902771, -0.034454346, -0.041046143, 0.016830444, 0.06591797, 0.024993896, 0.0070266724, 0.022720337, -0.0032367706, 0.040740967, -0.05517578, -0.014335632, 0.041900635, 0.028961182, 0.038269043, -0.010093689, 0.0152282715, -0.016296387, 0.040405273, -0.030761719, 0.02003479, -0.028823853, -0.0058021545, -0.013626099, -0.008216858, -0.02935791, -0.0059890747, 0.002746582, 0.012741089, 0.053527832, -0.012107849, -0.007335663, -0.01876831, 0.0059928894, 0.0017557144, -0.04736328, -0.03427124, 0.02229309, -0.07678223, 0.00049066544, 0.020553589, 0.0065231323, -0.019989014, -0.04119873, 0.012779236, 0.045715332, -0.030761719, 0.043792725, 0.018569946, 0.032318115, -0.0501709, -0.031433105, -0.017410278, -0.025665283, -0.00010848045, 0.028549194, 0.014122009, -0.010375977, 0.010574341, -0.013557434, 0.013214111, -0.007888794, -0.04724121, -0.010284424, -0.0033473969, 0.012672424, 0.004009247, 0.059051514, -0.09991455, -0.087524414, -0.06774902, 0.047729492, 0.008987427, -0.008811951, -0.0053138733, 0.00079870224, 0.015716553, -0.01725769, 0.019378662, 0.026733398, -0.010406494, -0.0143585205, 0.068481445, 0.0027046204, -0.06335449, -0.019241333, -0.040649414, 0.04425049, 0.031280518, -0.012290955, -0.061706543, 0.000092446804, -0.10272217, -0.0045318604, 0.0026988983, 0.004055023, 0.0154953, -0.000020682812, 0.0028057098, 0.017074585, 0.03466797, 0.005844116, -0.028518677, 0.012001038, -0.0035858154, 0.036071777, -0.018447876, -0.015670776, -0.0015554428, -0.014572144, -0.008232117, 0.019317627, 0.034362793, 0.0040740967, 0.012588501, -0.0124053955, -0.0031986237, -0.009506226, 0.014320374, 0.04196167, -0.047180176, 0.0031967163, 0.015205383, 0.03729248, 0.033233643, 0.010322571, -0.058258057, 0.01727295, -0.054748535, -0.048919678, -0.038635254, -0.003686905, 0.012374878, 0.02583313, -0.004512787, 0.008140564, -0.04925537, 0.03778076, -0.04776001, 0.04324341, 0.043640137, -0.034210205, 0.023925781, 0.013679504, -0.021377563, 0.062072754, 0.048034668, 0.026412964, -0.02607727, -0.0034751892, -0.0012750626, -0.06463623, 0.0040016174, -0.01776123, -0.013000488, -0.0029087067, -0.03555298, -0.002067566, -0.015975952, 0.02986145, -0.027053833, 0.0138549805, 0.0025291443, 0.011993408, 0.050445557, 0.040496826, 0.11407471, -0.07525635, 0.032318115, 0.016220093, -0.0064926147, -0.025421143, 0.0010709763, -0.030014038, 0.016677856, 0.03552246, -0.007156372, -0.02734375, -0.007423401, 0.044647217, -0.0046844482, -0.011154175, 0.01550293, 0.025299072, 0.025680542, 0.041809082, 0.046569824, 0.014984131, 0.05001831, 0.0146865845, 0.014984131, 0.05380249, 0.0016546249, 0.03253174, -0.014678955, 0.006706238, 0.002866745, 0.05215454, 0.033294678, 0.0121154785, -0.08392334, 0.036743164, -0.041900635, 0.008934021, -0.004108429, 0.022018433, 0.046173096, -0.018981934, 0.005432129, 0.004432678, -0.00057172775, -0.017410278, 0.005619049, 0.00063991547, -0.011474609, -0.03552246, -0.025238037, -0.02519226, 0.040863037, 0.0060043335, 0.021697998, -0.008560181, 0.0395813, -0.013557434, -0.012039185, -0.0158844, 0.04849243, 0.020584106, 0.008430481, 0.0010232925, -0.0027122498, -0.011329651, 0.10290527, 0.10253906, -0.059814453, 0.0579834, -0.061462402, -0.008995056, 0.02859497, -0.057128906, 0.000813961, 0.02848816, 0.02357483, -0.024978638, -0.03604126, 0.032043457, -0.08154297, 0.028121948, 0.021392822, -0.028213501, -0.012229919, -0.040039062, -0.019317627, -0.043518066, -0.07470703, -0.061187744, 0.064453125, 0.010223389, -0.021148682, -0.013969421, 0.010215759, -0.030883789, -0.021377563, -0.026443481, 0.002822876, 0.0085372925, 0.013648987, -0.006996155, -0.08215332, -0.034576416, 0.009292603, 0.033569336, -0.024154663, 0.0076560974, -0.035095215, -0.013259888, -0.03677368, -0.027755737, 0.012023926, -0.06567383, 0.010528564, -0.056243896, -0.024719238, 0.0118255615, 0.0034103394, -0.0064201355, 0.0206604, 0.0059509277, -0.0395813, 0.012069702, 0.051208496, -0.027053833, 0.011413574, 0.02180481, 0.019546509, -0.012969971, 0.01878357, 0.008781433, -0.012107849, -0.032348633, 0.011184692, -0.052124023, -0.022369385, -0.010627747, -0.01197052, 0.024963379, -0.023971558, -0.026626587, -0.054107666, -0.00459671, -0.007286072, 0.008857727, -0.012519836, -0.03253174, 0.016311646, -0.011016846, 0.02659607, 0.023880005, -0.009414673, -0.022583008, 0.06945801, 0.006614685, 0.0042686462, 0.044830322, 0.023101807, -0.021499634, -0.014122009, 0.024734497, -0.007724762, 0.0028934479, 0.008651733, 0.0037784576, -0.01687622, 0.00020766258, -0.078186035, 0.0104599, 0.06713867, -0.00043177605, -0.021835327, 0.024871826, -0.049865723, -0.032104492, 0.030975342, -0.003835678, 0.024673462, 0.003314972, 0.019470215, -0.028869629, 0.03894043, -0.07373047, 0.01626587, -0.0715332, -0.101379395, 0.027786255, -0.0078125, -0.023223877, -0.007511139, -0.019058228, -0.035980225, -0.011047363, -0.013214111, 0.04031372, 0.051879883, 0.03793335, 0.011749268, -0.028518677, 0.014175415, -0.058166504, -0.007621765, -0.03375244, -0.031799316, -0.0178833, -0.011207581, 0.056427002, 0.010803223, 0.0065231323, -0.02973938, 0.009727478, 0.024246216, 0.05041504, 0.006916046, -0.016479492, -0.006389618, -0.014007568, -0.017364502, 0.026168823, 0.0051994324, 0.0059890747, -0.012718201, 0.0003144741, -0.012817383, 0.0027046204, 0.013343811, 0.014297485, -0.03491211, -0.014274597, 0.0024909973, -0.01864624, -0.035369873, -0.018081665, 0.0048713684, -0.001496315, 0.024734497, 0.018661499, -0.035827637, 0.018157959, 0.003545761, 0.0011005402, 0.013641357, 0.004737854, -0.013633728, 0.022613525, -0.022262573, 0.0070266724, -0.039855957, 0.00063323975, -0.016403198, 0.018096924, -0.022018433, -0.055358887, -0.00010329485, 0.00248909, -0.07458496, -0.036315918, 0.009887695, -0.044158936, -0.032318115, -0.037322998, 0.03186035, -0.048034668, -0.018875122, 0.008468628, -0.016433716, 0.005584717, 0.0039367676, -0.06530762, -0.012619019, 0.06719971, -0.014694214, 0.0068740845, 0.036346436, 0.015304565, -0.010856628, -0.006134033, 0.035217285, 0.026107788, 0.028747559, -0.006248474, 0.020370483, 0.058807373, -0.029830933, 0.034606934, 0.026016235, -0.0007042885, -0.007461548, 0.015792847, 0.032714844, 0.016784668, -0.015777588, 0.03503418, 0.033111572, -0.028274536, -0.033996582, -0.0049819946, 0.012535095, -0.039093018, 0.013366699, -0.026565552, 0.032104492, 0.05596924, 0.008377075, 0.088134766, -0.012962341, 0.001950264, 0.01889038, -0.021560669, -0.015853882, -0.019332886, 0.022079468, -0.008842468, 0.010818481, 0.010032654, 0.017807007, 0.0619812, -0.024169922, 0.011505127, 0.0026245117, 0.013870239, -0.016555786, -0.01033783, -0.04348755, -0.02999878, -0.01777649, 0.016677856, -0.006729126, 0.012619019, -0.00091028214, 0.00066280365, -0.044891357, 0.022583008, -0.012329102, 0.009963989, 0.015258789, -0.028274536, 0.0067214966, -0.00009059906, -0.0647583, -0.04626465, 0.01739502, 0.00086164474, 0.027679443, -0.032470703, 0.004043579, 0.014892578, -0.0046920776, -0.03591919, 0.032470703, -0.038757324, -0.0022964478, -0.02734375, -0.0072746277, 0.0038776398, -0.035339355, 0.014961243, -0.019378662, -0.022369385, 0.001750946, -0.011650085, -0.032318115, -0.07458496, 0.04776001, -0.0007162094, 0.062438965, 0.034240723, 0.042022705, 0.038238525, -0.0017137527, 0.0020980835, 0.0001360178, -0.04031372, 0.017349243, -0.014190674, 0.06750488, -0.05392456, 0.028915405, 0.037902832, -0.0001783371, 0.0036087036, -0.030593872, 0.03048706, -0.012168884, -0.0236969, 0.031677246, -0.016571045, -0.029922485, -0.031799316, -0.001958847, 0.020462036, 0.050231934, -0.04309082, 0.03945923, -0.05923462, 0.0005674362, 0.012519836, -0.0027427673, 0.005783081, -0.008758545, 0.028686523, -0.037872314, -0.030303955, 0.012138367, 0.028579712, -0.025482178, -0.010139465, -0.0024757385, 0.037353516, 0.025680542, 0.04019165, 0.027648926, 0.009231567, -0.00617218, -0.016342163, -0.0008158684, -0.01838684, -0.040527344, 0.009353638, -0.012489319, 0.021072388, -0.012611389, -0.0068130493, -0.052703857, -0.015701294, -0.0082473755, 0.007621765, 0.031707764, -0.061401367, 0.029373169, 0.09307861, 0.014160156, 0.021820068, -0.00573349, 0.027893066, 0.025802612, 0.04043579, 0.008407593, 0.0234375, 0.04168701, -0.03942871, 0.00762558, 0.0015058517, 0.014663696, -0.002784729, 0.012321472, 0.004463196, -0.012023926, -0.035858154, 0.02973938, 0.027297974, 0.0115737915, 0.018615723, -0.063964844, 0.031433105, -0.022994995, -0.01184845, 0.0056648254, -0.048309326, -0.03967285, 0.01727295, -0.029174805, -0.0040740967, 0.027389526, 0.011390686, -0.035949707, -0.039642334, 0.04324341, -0.0033683777, 0.0026340485, -0.0015468597, 0.008262634, -0.036895752, 0.019226074, 0.014778137, -0.055541992, 0.004798889, -0.0016021729, 0.02986145, 0.03942871, -0.0031871796, -0.0065078735, 0.00381279, -0.0011339188, -0.085754395, -0.064208984, -0.026977539, -0.02003479, -0.0030384064, -0.018310547, -0.03326416, -0.007572174, 0.0036506653, 0.018356323, 0.033813477, -0.0440979, 0.01927185, 0.0029582977, 0.0069618225, 0.019592285, 0.037994385, 0.023269653, -0.0017290115, 0.009101868, -0.047088623, 0.012489319, 0.005958557, -0.013504028, -0.03866577, -0.059143066, -0.007083893, 0.02067566, -0.00009602308, -0.038635254, 0.037384033, 0.044525146, -0.011833191, 0.003004074, -0.008811951, 0.059020996, -0.030258179, -0.018234253, -0.028274536, 0.012031555, -0.036865234, 0.009857178, 0.012283325, 0.0071754456, -0.031036377, -0.04876709, -0.028778076, 0.00034165382, 0.035369873, 0.011428833, 0.062927246, -0.030075073, -0.0056114197, -0.010658264, 0.013587952, -0.016983032, 0.039398193, -0.002735138, 0.014076233, -0.036987305, 0.011459351, -0.002401352, -0.016738892, 0.04574585, 0.016464233, -0.02456665, 0.002632141, -0.048797607, 0.0061416626, -0.047058105, -0.023727417, 0.05429077, 0.052520752, -0.043273926, 0.05038452, -0.029891968, 0.060516357, 0.02748108, 0.040924072, 0.05807495, 0.029632568, 0.016662598, 0.005771637, 0.028045654, -0.014480591, -0.015167236, -0.043182373, -0.026885986, -0.04940796, -0.010787964, -0.076171875, 0.0019741058, 0.0020065308, -0.010093689, 0.037017822, -0.0018405914, -0.012298584, 0.010017395, 0.03677368, 0.05215454, 0.024505615, -0.0026359558, -0.014915466, 0.003921509, 0.019424438, 0.017791748, 0.02609253, -0.0008535385, 0.034118652, -0.0033054352, 0.008407593, -0.010955811, -0.0051727295, 0.0184021, -0.022445679, -0.000849247, -0.01864624, 0.015182495, -0.0289917, 0.011413574, 0.08947754, 0.0423584, 0.00016760826, -0.044006348, 0.003522873, 0.021896362, -0.024658203, 0.010009766, 0.06210327, -0.06726074, 0.01965332, -0.033477783, -0.03692627, 0.008331299, 0.037261963, 0.022277832, -0.043151855, -0.043304443, 0.020263672, 0.022033691, 0.03503418, -0.014320374, -0.04147339, -0.03552246, 0.011886597, 0.04574585, -0.038085938, -0.0110321045, -0.017593384, 0.034362793, -0.022918701, -0.05783081, 0.016647339, -0.022079468, 0.0009074211, 0.031066895, 0.031951904, 0.02973938, -0.024795532, -0.047912598, 0.017303467, -0.005619049, -0.042419434, -0.006603241, -0.005340576, 0.040985107, 0.03451538, 0.054016113, -0.0074920654, -0.013473511, 0.026016235, -0.015792847, 0.034576416, 0.062042236, -0.035247803, 0.034942627, -0.043029785, -0.060943604, 0.043640137, -0.072143555, 0.05166626, -0.022109985, 0.042541504, -0.012390137, 0.028549194, 0.03213501, -0.070495605, -0.035064697, 0.019638062, -0.015930176, -0.0076942444, 0.021591187, -0.019241333, -0.03213501, 0.0005879402, 0.040496826, 0.008079529, -0.010894775, -0.013175964, -0.027160645, -0.05343628, 0.018325806, -0.026306152, 0.03515625, -0.016662598, -0.0044670105, 0.0018701553, 0.003993988, -0.030059814, -0.009262085, -0.011566162, 0.015991211, -0.037841797, -0.06137085, 0.028793335, -0.0030708313, -0.018569946, -0.03555298, 0.01083374, -0.015579224, -0.004550934, -0.026062012, 0.036071777, -0.045318604, -0.021408081, 0.008155823, -0.044036865, 0.028839111, 0.023361206, -0.013137817, 0.006717682, 0.011871338, -0.03164673, -0.06738281, -0.0013341904, 0.02897644, 0.021087646, -0.042907715, -0.017211914, 0.04788208, 0.04751587, -0.05130005, -0.028060913, 0.020904541, 0.04058838, -0.011222839, 0.060943604, 0.02079773, 0.021865845, 0.0029945374, 0.02027893, 0.005683899, -0.054138184, -0.05117798, -0.028671265, 0.04449463, 0.047607422, -0.0131073, -0.018493652, 0.038970947, 0.02029419, 0.010948181, 0.022872925, -0.01449585, 0.0206604, -0.008987427, 0.033477783, 0.0025081635, -0.024887085, -0.020095825, 0.02973938, -0.008216858, 0.01637268, -0.009132385, 0.020507812, -0.0010738373, 0.051116943, -0.008682251, -0.09246826, 0.04837036, 0.060333252, -0.000037014484, 0.07489014, -0.03390503, -0.04751587, -0.0028953552, -0.011474609, -0.011566162, 0.00466156, 0.035125732, -0.011230469, 0.0067596436, -0.012619019, -0.040008545, -0.0070610046, -0.0368042, 0.032043457, -0.035369873, 0.010093689, -0.01939392, -0.022460938, -0.0053253174, -0.0007510185, -0.021026611, -0.03866577, -0.048858643, -0.039215088, 0.018173218, -0.017807007 ], "summary": [ 0.0037174225, -0.04107666, -0.0149002075, -0.015808105, -0.040008545, -0.019058228, -0.009506226, -0.004940033, 0.018936157, 0.017654419, -0.02861023, -0.0005865097, 0.011230469, -0.033050537, 0.01448822, -0.020385742, 0.005958557, 0.023773193, 0.019363403, -0.030456543, 0.025131226, -0.0032653809, -0.022949219, 0.05609131, 0.03173828, -0.01574707, -0.09484863, 0.032989502, 0.004878998, 0.038879395, 0.0079574585, -0.007873535, 0.010917664, 0.0006713867, 0.024841309, 0.013267517, 0.0033607483, 0.007068634, 0.00894928, 0.015975952, 0.015274048, -0.0016641617, 0.07904053, -0.04748535, 0.011192322, 0.025375366, -0.0029563904, -0.019454956, 0.013084412, 0.016357422, 0.006084442, 0.034820557, -0.005680084, 0.029190063, -0.0070724487, -0.0057296753, 0.0023841858, -0.0035495758, 0.014656067, -0.0029773712, -0.0022029877, 0.016235352, 0.01965332, 0.0058403015, 0.01222229, -0.023956299, -0.008926392, 0.0037498474, 0.030059814, 0.03869629, 0.044067383, 0.018508911, 0.020721436, -0.011016846, -0.02633667, 0.023880005, 0.0059318542, 0.016189575, 0.01083374, -0.01234436, 0.0069389343, -0.006160736, 0.030960083, -0.03414917, -0.008758545, -0.016418457, -0.016113281, -0.0046958923, 0.011650085, 0.0049324036, -0.009933472, -0.055419922, -0.015304565, 0.093811035, 0.041534424, -0.017242432, -0.035369873, -0.08850098, 0.022125244, -0.023727417, 0.028198242, -0.038208008, -0.0017271042, 0.019134521, -0.01550293, 0.06390381, -0.0011644363, -0.11236572, -0.035614014, 0.008720398, -0.0066070557, -0.045806885, 0.007129669, 0.012825012, -0.053833008, 0.006866455, 0.004432678, 0.0018005371, -0.008880615, 0.042510986, 0.004764557, 0.029785156, -0.003168106, -0.019989014, 0.014343262, -0.008705139, -0.021194458, -0.0048446655, -0.047210693, 0.009208679, 0.006713867, 0.038391113, -0.027435303, -0.007331848, -0.06512451, -0.0010061264, 0.022064209, -0.015686035, 0.04083252, -0.03567505, 0.050079346, 0.0051498413, -0.015579224, 0.04421997, 0.0013160706, -0.002506256, 0.039001465, 0.013954163, -0.029800415, 0.00096940994, -0.032318115, 0.061798096, 0.03805542, -0.0087890625, -0.027526855, -0.022491455, -0.022857666, -0.0038776398, 0.00082445145, -0.0063476562, 0.006832123, 0.0056991577, 0.047088623, 0.03353882, 0.014350891, -0.0062332153, -0.049041748, -0.018997192, 0.009971619, -0.046203613, -0.0017614365, 0.015914917, 0.01687622, 0.0020542145, 0.027893066, 0.02406311, 0.01612854, 0.009246826, 0.015899658, -0.04425049, -0.022949219, -0.031066895, 0.050231934, -0.011878967, -0.0033874512, 0.04724121, 0.003118515, 0.0690918, 0.030029297, 0.015602112, -0.07849121, -0.01802063, -0.013748169, 0.0019817352, 0.022964478, -0.013824463, -0.032409668, -0.010826111, -0.006088257, -0.024307251, 0.032104492, 0.035858154, -0.036865234, -0.009529114, -0.0065345764, -0.022201538, 0.03062439, 0.011161804, -0.032684326, 0.03125, 0.02142334, -0.0118637085, -0.013549805, 0.024536133, 0.026855469, -0.03591919, 0.016601562, -0.0060691833, 0.010902405, -0.0025615692, -0.0006122589, 0.0008792877, -0.019226074, 0.02368164, -0.070129395, 0.0027923584, 0.002691269, 0.046936035, 0.027755737, 0.035583496, 0.09039307, -0.0859375, -0.002002716, 0.031921387, -0.006034851, -0.02331543, 0.009254456, -0.0574646, 0.01209259, 0.040039062, 0.013618469, -0.0050468445, 0.0071372986, 0.049591064, -0.03643799, -0.014732361, 0.038085938, 0.012481689, -0.016860962, 0.01902771, 0.032470703, -0.0022697449, 0.008049011, -0.024780273, 0.0034275055, 0.033599854, 0.014984131, 0.028717041, 0.026641846, 0.01436615, -0.007484436, 0.08215332, 0.045959473, 0.018585205, -0.07897949, 0.017959595, -0.038116455, -0.01234436, 0.0019025803, -0.0079193115, 0.03793335, -0.037200928, -0.0058784485, 0.0025672913, -0.03942871, -0.0446167, 0.006275177, 0.019851685, -0.048034668, -0.027923584, -0.016021729, -0.027770996, -0.0030555725, -0.006855011, 0.034942627, -0.013160706, 0.020874023, 0.019470215, 0.0078086853, 0.03894043, 0.05114746, 0.032226562, -0.013153076, 0.027114868, -0.028564453, 0.0010480881, 0.076538086, 0.0715332, -0.035369873, 0.029632568, -0.0059013367, -0.0015153885, -0.009880066, -0.039276123, -0.0070533752, 0.043426514, 0.035369873, -0.040802002, -0.026641846, 0.04220581, -0.07824707, -0.011619568, 0.025863647, 0.0362854, -0.014663696, -0.021606445, -0.012641907, 0.017974854, -0.06896973, -0.05645752, 0.09307861, 0.011329651, 0.008361816, 0.004878998, 0.0022182465, -0.047332764, 0.037261963, -0.031585693, 0.012084961, -0.037078857, -0.02583313, -0.05596924, -0.05041504, -0.031799316, 0.0064201355, -0.0033130646, -0.0013217926, 0.022216797, -0.0036354065, -0.036193848, -0.018508911, -0.010795593, -0.0072669983, -0.0062294006, -0.03967285, -0.0018377304, -0.020568848, -0.012107849, -0.0034713745, -0.0006299019, 0.013442993, 0.0034599304, -0.06222534, 0.015991211, -0.03326416, 0.015304565, 0.086364746, 0.014770508, -0.007881165, -0.01889038, -0.0035076141, 0.0035247803, -0.03503418, -0.05203247, 0.019943237, -0.021118164, -0.0009889603, -0.019805908, 0.00018072128, 0.016082764, 0.033843994, 0.012924194, -0.088134766, -0.016525269, -0.02998352, 0.007659912, 0.095458984, 0.016204834, 0.00037550926, 0.057739258, 0.044311523, 0.027770996, -0.017684937, -0.05102539, 0.04537964, 0.039276123, 0.05999756, 0.050933838, 0.009124756, -0.03543091, -0.038879395, 0.04159546, 0.04333496, -0.008117676, 0.032043457, -0.022506714, -0.0018444061, 0.053649902, -0.0418396, -0.011558533, 0.039398193, 0.040740967, 0.023788452, 0.0005207062, -0.007133484, -0.006427765, 0.041992188, 0.0040740967, 0.009162903, -0.022720337, 0.059783936, -0.05770874, 0.06384277, -0.078552246, 0.01146698, -0.061920166, 0.020690918, 0.018341064, -0.0057754517, -0.03149414, -0.0076141357, 0.045043945, -0.008224487, -0.0060653687, 0.02998352, 0.031707764, 0.029434204, -0.0077438354, 0.007205963, 0.0011663437, 0.0287323, -0.04425049, -0.014953613, -0.029785156, -0.050079346, -0.020721436, 0.0058403015, 0.03829956, 0.01285553, -0.02619934, -0.010597229, 0.011024475, 0.062286377, 0.03567505, 0.016296387, 0.015594482, 0.016036987, 0.015655518, -0.007637024, 0.05255127, 0.0066184998, 0.009605408, 0.035339355, 0.028121948, -0.021102905, -0.0031166077, -0.035217285, 0.017562866, 0.022964478, -0.028808594, -0.003211975, 0.00080776215, -0.037597656, -0.012390137, 0.02784729, 0.054840088, -0.02670288, 0.028945923, -0.020355225, -0.0064735413, 0.038330078, -0.061309814, -0.0033569336, -0.006816864, -0.007019043, -0.018508911, 0.009529114, 0.0037517548, 0.0074157715, -0.017227173, -0.07672119, 0.041809082, -0.054992676, -0.044921875, -0.021347046, 0.012023926, -0.0118637085, -0.027374268, -0.007881165, 0.00674057, -0.025863647, 0.0032157898, 0.030883789, -0.022827148, -0.013664246, 0.032287598, -0.016403198, 0.08117676, 0.025161743, -0.05480957, 0.0035133362, -0.013031006, 0.015151978, 0.006084442, -0.032592773, 0.044403076, 0.03451538, -0.0078086853, -0.00017607212, -0.04043579, 0.025039673, -0.056762695, 0.0713501, 0.030075073, -0.018234253, 0.020141602, 0.019577026, 0.011909485, -0.001540184, 0.0069732666, 0.07269287, 0.06829834, -0.011558533, -0.011734009, 0.03036499, -0.027664185, 0.0042533875, -0.000998497, 0.001502037, -0.07458496, 0.022277832, -0.0052375793, 0.009376526, 0.07611084, -0.0056114197, 0.062164307, -0.021484375, -0.022094727, -0.008407593, 0.014427185, -0.028182983, -0.011695862, 0.027877808, 0.033233643, 0.008125305, -0.006942749, 0.029891968, 0.042755127, -0.018096924, 0.008644104, 0.0062332153, 0.0079422, 0.003894806, -0.022506714, 0.0018663406, -0.01991272, -0.025253296, 0.007583618, 0.009712219, 0.024536133, -0.035736084, -0.0317688, 0.0028858185, 0.05065918, -0.027053833, 0.037139893, -0.031402588, -0.049682617, -0.02609253, -0.008644104, -0.044952393, -0.007255554, -0.00021731853, -0.026138306, 0.016220093, -0.011161804, 0.021438599, 0.012039185, 0.0017175674, -0.05569458, -0.00091028214, -0.037597656, 0.018569946, -0.07763672, -0.0034561157, 0.02394104, -0.022857666, -0.016983032, -0.016906738, 0.01902771, 0.022598267, 0.0038547516, -0.037902832, -0.09655762, 0.029708862, 0.014183044, 0.0077171326, 0.053649902, 0.027679443, 0.023666382, 0.012367249, 0.007873535, 0.0037345886, -0.019958496, -0.003332138, -0.015335083, 0.061187744, -0.0597229, 0.026229858, 0.0357666, -0.006626129, -0.021392822, -0.019424438, 0.027740479, -0.0022258759, -0.021636963, 0.028259277, -0.011978149, 0.012329102, -0.038879395, 0.016799927, 0.017150879, 0.0048179626, 0.0418396, -0.0048179626, -0.02507019, -0.009185791, 0.029449463, 0.008628845, 0.00894165, 0.03152466, 0.004650116, -0.03149414, -0.017684937, 0.0059394836, 0.028396606, -0.0115737915, -0.013809204, -0.023086548, -0.007686615, -0.0031547546, 0.02128601, -0.0005197525, 0.005176544, 0.0154418945, -0.0085372925, -0.00856781, -0.018218994, -0.017929077, -0.010238647, 0.008346558, 0.0021514893, -0.018966675, -0.033966064, 0.028915405, -0.03656006, -0.0067749023, 0.006252289, 0.004711151, -0.05218506, -0.050628662, -0.00881958, 0.00003260374, -0.030960083, 0.01878357, 0.009002686, -0.021774292, 0.030151367, -0.025268555, 0.016616821, 0.0036239624, -0.03125, -0.00018179417, -0.017623901, 0.0052719116, 0.0015859604, 0.0018539429, 0.00566864, -0.000040709972, -0.011558533, -0.0028648376, -0.023223877, -0.0036334991, 0.0033302307, -0.015617371, 0.034576416, -0.023590088, -0.0066108704, -0.008857727, -0.014289856, -0.024963379, 0.027359009, -0.014801025, 0.003276825, 0.016311646, 0.0014448166, -0.040618896, -0.006248474, 0.01864624, -0.0005674362, -0.002904892, 0.0022087097, -0.0037593842, -0.024475098, -0.0044670105, -0.026382446, -0.0084991455, -0.023590088, 0.03729248, 0.03778076, -0.040649414, -0.03137207, -0.04650879, -0.017059326, -0.025665283, -0.074035645, -0.08868408, -0.029281616, 0.0004761219, 0.028823853, -0.043701172, 0.027954102, 0.00667572, -0.052612305, 0.0027885437, 0.034118652, -0.050750732, 0.0029029846, -0.003753662, -0.0043640137, 0.0061531067, 0.0040397644, 0.021133423, -0.0149002075, -0.011520386, -0.03945923, -0.009780884, 0.02458191, -0.032043457, -0.010322571, 0.005695343, -0.029144287, 0.027374268, -0.0090408325, -0.045288086, 0.016082764, 0.019683838, -0.057006836, 0.026062012, -0.023483276, 0.04083252, 0.007286072, -0.035736084, -0.043792725, 0.025665283, -0.055847168, -0.072021484, 0.00026226044, 0.0027236938, 0.005973816, -0.020355225, 0.022720337, -0.011978149, 0.005836487, 0.024917603, 0.055786133, 0.0060043335, -0.00053453445, 0.013534546, -0.017578125, -0.0093307495, 0.0057029724, -0.0054779053, 0.00094366074, 0.01423645, 0.005256653, 0.0049819946, 0.023101807, 0.0016202927, -0.019348145, -0.029891968, 0.0069503784, -0.009933472, 0.034423828, -0.044006348, 0.025527954, 0.036834717, 0.061798096, -0.029418945, 0.03186035, 0.039978027, 0.028289795, 0.025985718, -0.017227173, 0.02229309, 0.01234436, 0.008628845, -0.008117676, 0.0059280396, -0.0025749207, 0.015090942, -0.0051193237, -0.0927124, -0.07763672, -0.06500244, 0.0047302246, 0.021560669, -0.048950195, -0.07757568, 0.06713867, -0.030258179, -0.03869629, 0.06616211, -0.05126953, 0.08331299, -0.078308105, -0.0052757263, -0.039001465, 0.024993896, 0.043273926, -0.00078487396, 0.034729004, 0.0004143715, 0.026824951, 0.034240723, 0.018310547, 0.00037050247, -0.015144348, -0.009803772, -0.037750244, 0.03894043, -0.005104065, 0.009498596, -0.010627747, 0.0010461807, 0.06640625, 0.007926941, 0.03967285, -0.040802002, 0.016159058, 0.06201172, -0.02281189, 0.022827148, 0.035247803, -0.00881958, -0.040771484, -0.021987915, -0.016479492, 0.06921387, 0.023849487, 0.025436401, -0.04144287, -0.026565552, -0.018875122, 0.006954193, 0.018661499, -0.03567505, -0.039642334, -0.028823853, 0.021881104, 0.039489746, -0.035583496, -0.05328369, -0.04852295, 0.014091492, 0.01411438, -0.024230957, 0.0284729, 0.0055885315, 0.037017822, 0.032989502, 0.016723633, 0.018432617, 0.052703857, -0.010536194, 0.009063721, 0.03451538, -0.013931274, 0.04043579, -0.05545044, 0.08917236, 0.080200195, 0.03744507, -0.08270264, 0.019546509, 0.12670898, -0.01373291, 0.04876709, 0.030197144, 0.020767212, 0.016616821, -0.0335083, -0.012954712, 0.014198303, -0.010520935, 0.022155762, -0.001824379, 0.01625061, -0.024993896, -0.001953125, -0.007259369, -0.042633057, 0.030288696, -0.016952515, -0.00037550926, 0.02645874, 0.06506348, -0.0284729, -0.00541687, -0.0057258606, -0.004550934, -0.016342163, -0.017227173, -0.0002808571, -0.006000519, -0.01914978, -0.0019273758, -0.00020670891, 0.03842163, 0.0018796921, 0.015899658, 0.030548096, 0.029418945, -0.04269409, -0.036224365, -0.0058403015, 0.09069824, -0.013008118, -0.107910156, 0.071899414, 0.04345703, -0.01651001, -0.061706543, -0.0014762878, -0.040222168, -0.01361084, 0.024398804, 0.011512756, -0.03744507, 0.014411926, 0.03491211, -0.041229248, 0.020187378, 0.0102005005, 0.0031108856, 0.025665283, 0.016586304, -0.04034424, -0.046966553, -0.010513306, -0.00819397, 0.040527344, -0.052612305, 0.0021343231, 0.017700195, 0.046051025, 0.008781433, 0.012710571, 0.052703857, -0.0001834631, 0.00017559528, -0.020462036, -0.0052261353, 0.016113281, 0.008598328, 0.02696228, 0.007030487, -0.044525146, -0.021331787, -0.019989014, 0.07116699, 0.0055770874, -0.0390625, 0.011131287, 0.037139893, -0.007873535, 0.0028839111, 0.016647339, 0.016143799, -0.009559631, -0.016906738, 0.021820068, -0.018600464, -0.04058838, 0.0069274902, -0.0059394836, -0.0020980835, 0.0023078918, -0.0044288635, -0.0010185242, -0.009468079, 0.014968872, -0.005168915, -0.05508423, -0.006767273, 0.03704834, -0.014213562, 0.040618896, -0.036010742, -0.039611816, -0.0070152283, 0.0012283325, -0.0071640015, 0.02508545, 0.004283905, -0.0046653748, 0.007648468, -0.03778076, -0.021652222, -0.02558899, -0.029586792, 0.01713562, -0.011978149, 0.015403748, 0.023284912, 0.000091433525, 0.018936157, -0.031799316, 0.014709473, -0.013885498, 0.010047913, -0.04260254, -0.034820557, 0.016693115 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2103.13527v1
Improving Editorial Workflow and Metadata Quality at Springer Nature
Angelo A. Salatino, Francesco Osborne, Aliaksandr Birukou, Enrico Motta
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
Identifying the research topics that best describe the scope of a scientific publication is a crucial task for editors, in particular because the quality of these annotations determine how effectively users are able to discover the right content in online libraries. For this reason, Springer Nature, the world's largest academic book publisher, has traditionally entrusted this task to their most expert editors. These editors manually analyse all new books, possibly including hundreds of chapters, and produce a list of the most relevant topics. Hence, this process has traditionally been very expensive, time-consuming, and confined to a few senior editors. For these reasons, back in 2016 we developed Smart Topic Miner (STM), an ontology-driven application that assists the Springer Nature editorial team in annotating the volumes of all books covering conference proceedings in Computer Science. Since then STM has been regularly used by editors in Germany, China, Brazil, India, and Japan, for a total of about 800 volumes per year. Over the past three years the initial prototype has iteratively evolved in response to feedback from the users and evolving requirements. In this paper we present the most recent version of the tool and describe the evolution of the system over the years, the key lessons learnt, and the impact on the Springer Nature workflow. In particular, our solution has drastically reduced the time needed to annotate proceedings and significantly improved their discoverability, resulting in 9.3 million additional downloads. We also present a user study involving 9 editors, which yielded excellent results in term of usability, and report an evaluation of the new topic classifier used by STM, which outperforms previous versions in recall and F-measure.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.13527v1
"2021-03-24T23:23:59"
"2021-03-24T23:23:59"
{ "title": [ -0.047180176, -0.009178162, -0.057250977, -0.05130005, -0.009536743, -0.007888794, -0.048980713, 0.010925293, -0.01134491, 0.039520264, -0.0018177032, 0.0031929016, 0.025756836, -0.028320312, -0.030288696, 0.017623901, -0.01638794, 0.037750244, -0.0107421875, -0.024215698, -0.0044784546, -0.027709961, 0.025268555, -0.0236969, 0.012001038, -0.0053138733, -0.061676025, -0.004776001, -0.042999268, -0.050842285, -0.019012451, 0.04574585, 0.049926758, -0.012161255, 0.00066041946, 0.05001831, -0.025039673, 0.010719299, -0.012001038, 0.0061569214, 0.015586853, -0.009017944, -0.019607544, -0.023788452, -0.026855469, 0.035614014, -0.049987793, -0.014572144, -0.010231018, 0.028289795, -0.0008649826, 0.022781372, -0.011199951, 0.050567627, 0.015670776, -0.0050621033, -0.01209259, -0.030136108, 0.056488037, 0.035186768, -0.005821228, -0.04486084, 0.03277588, -0.0262146, -0.0009303093, -0.012535095, -0.034729004, 0.019927979, 0.03375244, 0.028335571, 0.011520386, -0.016708374, 0.01576233, -0.011138916, -0.02519226, 0.015388489, 0.02861023, 0.029464722, 0.031280518, -0.02468872, -0.019058228, -0.02960205, 0.02709961, -0.054626465, 0.03048706, -0.018875122, -0.0059509277, -0.01084137, -0.012649536, -0.044158936, -0.006881714, 0.008766174, -0.02468872, 0.031433105, -0.020080566, -0.034484863, 0.009010315, 0.038848877, 0.00047659874, -0.007461548, -0.024612427, 0.0017747879, -0.013053894, -0.027740479, 0.008644104, 0.004196167, -0.014099121, 0.015808105, 0.020462036, 0.043701172, -0.03488159, 0.03164673, 0.02381897, -0.013946533, 0.0129776, 0.017105103, 0.0023860931, 0.0066719055, 0.01612854, 0.004085541, 0.023803711, 0.0035476685, -0.0119018555, 0.0093688965, 0.0087890625, -0.006401062, -0.046295166, 0.019012451, -0.0033721924, -0.018981934, -0.0013160706, 0.05291748, -0.024780273, -0.055755615, -0.032562256, 0.033935547, -0.0069122314, 0.020980835, -0.02230835, 0.010414124, 0.008346558, 0.01171875, 0.03189087, 0.0045928955, -0.018341064, -0.00844574, 0.059020996, 0.007858276, -0.04309082, -0.013244629, -0.05886841, 0.043945312, 0.03466797, -0.03918457, -0.049041748, -0.0715332, -0.059173584, -0.060455322, 0.051635742, -0.055114746, 0.014892578, 0.019760132, 0.0011720657, 0.0034942627, 0.049621582, -0.030807495, 0.0028915405, 0.04019165, 0.005836487, 0.020629883, -0.005554199, -0.0033988953, -0.008491516, -0.030899048, -0.013694763, -0.0061187744, -0.0018262863, -0.00062417984, 0.01876831, 0.0072784424, 0.022018433, -0.017593384, -0.008987427, 0.054260254, -0.053131104, -0.06933594, 0.0070381165, -0.010223389, 0.05267334, 0.03213501, -0.042144775, 0.0024604797, -0.056610107, -0.046203613, 0.00019180775, -0.00041508675, 0.00869751, -0.0056114197, 0.023712158, 0.0034694672, -0.041168213, 0.02961731, -0.04849243, 0.031158447, -0.003419876, -0.020187378, -0.001830101, 0.024093628, -0.041900635, 0.06762695, 0.0440979, 0.027038574, -0.028762817, -0.028549194, 0.005645752, -0.053527832, 0.0010004044, -0.040008545, -0.021118164, -0.021850586, -0.05569458, 0.029373169, -0.058563232, 0.01927185, 0.04425049, 0.018051147, 0.0025959015, -0.0044441223, 0.06854248, 0.048950195, 0.024169922, -0.033599854, 0.035827637, 0.047576904, -0.011657715, -0.022628784, 0.0053520203, -0.023468018, 0.029434204, 0.01676941, -0.0055770874, -0.035614014, 0.007789612, 0.045654297, 0.039764404, 0.009780884, 0.02609253, 0.015281677, 0.04559326, 0.038146973, -0.0069847107, -0.00333786, 0.06121826, -0.010902405, 0.0038146973, 0.07458496, -0.0008125305, 0.0028038025, 0.009246826, -0.013397217, 0.017990112, 0.026123047, 0.009864807, -0.0017557144, -0.03286743, 0.0039520264, 0.0041160583, 0.03930664, 0.009246826, -0.009765625, 0.016830444, 0.01675415, 0.005832672, 0.01474762, -0.006942749, -0.027023315, -0.0035438538, -0.0008058548, -0.00818634, -0.030960083, -0.038360596, 0.011741638, 0.07342529, -0.00198555, -0.011642456, 0.011154175, 0.064208984, -0.03189087, -0.018981934, -0.04373169, 0.037750244, -0.005432129, -0.016571045, -0.009628296, 0.017318726, -0.035583496, 0.10998535, 0.062408447, -0.023361206, 0.0362854, -0.023132324, 0.007911682, 0.018310547, -0.019897461, 0.010093689, 0.05493164, 0.037719727, -0.009414673, -0.032836914, 0.024505615, -0.058258057, -0.001540184, 0.013626099, -0.055358887, -0.03677368, -0.045959473, -0.03778076, -0.045715332, -0.082336426, -0.02128601, 0.024032593, -0.033172607, -0.0028533936, -0.011184692, -0.0231781, -0.011985779, -0.0014648438, -0.011169434, -0.008377075, 0.0064888, -0.013473511, -0.009010315, -0.097473145, -0.0068855286, -0.00141716, 0.03793335, -0.026443481, 0.03970337, -0.039276123, -0.019470215, -0.04574585, -0.043060303, 0.016342163, -0.04711914, 0.052856445, -0.059173584, -0.0019330978, 0.0043563843, 0.02810669, 0.030654907, -0.03314209, 0.0056991577, -0.019104004, -0.0061149597, 0.060272217, -0.033416748, -0.008338928, 0.05078125, 0.040802002, -0.0014009476, 0.029067993, 0.022399902, 0.002576828, -0.013755798, -0.021469116, -0.044433594, 0.0050086975, -0.0079193115, -0.0012369156, 0.028305054, -0.008041382, -0.00995636, -0.040618896, -0.017028809, -0.008171082, -0.019561768, -0.051605225, -0.050445557, 0.0053749084, -0.040924072, 0.006214142, -0.007068634, 0.021377563, -0.0060424805, 0.032562256, 0.0026283264, -0.056671143, -0.014060974, 0.00014638901, 0.015899658, -0.009727478, 0.010055542, -0.029067993, -0.00944519, 0.012435913, 0.0069618225, -0.01878357, -0.011650085, -0.061645508, 0.01033783, 0.04864502, 0.0015897751, -0.019180298, 0.021316528, -0.06378174, 0.026397705, -0.014480591, -0.0029582977, 0.03643799, 0.028640747, -0.016296387, -0.0007543564, -0.016784668, -0.023361206, -0.0073280334, -0.020339966, -0.13293457, 0.021148682, -0.032043457, 0.02330017, -0.0035076141, 0.00566864, -0.043304443, 0.018127441, -0.011749268, 0.05569458, 0.023422241, 0.016159058, 0.0034751892, -0.014129639, 0.027496338, -0.03265381, 0.007282257, -0.027511597, -0.045074463, -0.009628296, -0.01826477, 0.07861328, 0.005874634, -0.008560181, -0.028396606, -0.0078048706, 0.010307312, 0.024536133, 0.004688263, -0.037109375, -0.007801056, -0.013725281, 0.030227661, 0.018173218, -0.008781433, -0.0008530617, 0.0158844, -0.0068473816, -0.03479004, -0.00021088123, 0.022277832, 0.01802063, -0.026153564, 0.008239746, 0.030075073, -0.0181427, -0.012329102, 0.01902771, -0.00756073, -0.055480957, 0.035308838, -0.01637268, -0.02166748, 0.002439499, -0.049072266, 0.099243164, 0.0051078796, -0.0048065186, 0.023590088, 0.017456055, -0.04321289, 0.0013389587, -0.028213501, 0.01725769, 0.0062065125, 0.0030136108, 0.011924744, -0.059539795, 0.010475159, 0.0026779175, -0.095703125, -0.036193848, 0.010139465, -0.051513672, -0.07318115, -0.02394104, -0.007873535, -0.021713257, -0.03466797, 0.024993896, -0.015548706, -0.000028014183, 0.0037384033, -0.08111572, -0.013198853, 0.06958008, 0.020523071, 0.022232056, 0.04031372, 0.006877899, -0.012969971, -0.02027893, 0.02180481, 0.003156662, 0.019454956, -0.008926392, -0.03375244, 0.012741089, -0.035491943, 0.028625488, -0.008773804, -0.06222534, 0.005771637, 0.023086548, 0.027359009, 0.027923584, -0.043884277, 0.045074463, 0.044952393, -0.0035057068, -0.0814209, 0.00932312, -0.007972717, -0.03111267, -0.0051574707, -0.028289795, 0.015106201, 0.026397705, 0.033325195, 0.078552246, -0.010421753, -0.029174805, -0.0077285767, -0.03543091, 0.012123108, -0.023040771, -0.022109985, 0.0025978088, -0.0011825562, -0.003030777, -0.019088745, 0.046722412, -0.004421234, -0.004131317, 0.012390137, 0.012237549, -0.020736694, 0.0132751465, -0.048919678, -0.05532837, -0.064453125, 0.017486572, -0.012939453, 0.051879883, 0.029708862, 0.007911682, -0.026733398, -0.0044021606, -0.00028562546, 0.022827148, -0.040008545, -0.06286621, 0.02067566, -0.014984131, -0.07861328, -0.059509277, -0.031463623, 0.016479492, 0.0059013367, -0.0013713837, 0.008636475, 0.007843018, 0.013702393, -0.012626648, 0.039001465, -0.0016765594, -0.0069847107, 0.0231781, -0.01436615, -0.007583618, -0.023269653, 0.020141602, -0.02104187, -0.022125244, 0.0035686493, -0.01637268, -0.043640137, -0.06060791, 0.047973633, -0.00031924248, 0.052734375, 0.06149292, 0.045135498, 0.041137695, 0.01574707, -0.015945435, -0.0017747879, -0.047790527, 0.0075035095, -0.018157959, 0.026672363, -0.006111145, 0.016708374, 0.03488159, -0.0023727417, -0.014167786, 0.018997192, 0.011260986, 0.041015625, -0.00687027, 0.032806396, -0.021591187, -0.071777344, -0.02583313, -0.007972717, -0.0039024353, 0.06100464, -0.04006958, 0.02142334, 0.0002617836, 0.024017334, 0.01902771, -0.016021729, 0.017196655, -0.01727295, 0.0045394897, -0.06842041, -0.046325684, -0.00053453445, 0.0519104, -0.031463623, -0.0031738281, 0.004436493, 0.0146102905, -0.0068206787, 0.053527832, 0.0030345917, 0.049224854, 0.031402588, 0.0068969727, 0.019714355, -0.0423584, -0.059570312, -0.0015106201, 0.00007855892, 0.025344849, 0.03515625, 0.006679535, -0.09313965, -0.0023784637, -0.015350342, -0.0010671616, 0.0022392273, -0.041046143, 0.025344849, 0.07556152, 0.0008673668, 0.029144287, -0.008071899, 0.016921997, 0.009384155, 0.04763794, -0.0069770813, 0.0015659332, 0.04925537, -0.05441284, 0.004070282, -0.0048599243, 0.018920898, -0.0040626526, 0.020874023, 0.0041770935, -0.0027198792, -0.05960083, 0.0051841736, 0.019042969, 0.043151855, -0.0019893646, -0.05001831, 0.018554688, 0.013061523, -0.006526947, 0.03387451, -0.009422302, -0.016220093, 0.015701294, -0.0029830933, -0.008659363, 0.0037326813, 0.019714355, -0.05239868, -0.016220093, 0.043518066, 0.019134521, 0.005458832, -0.009841919, 0.011978149, -0.039733887, 0.023239136, 0.018234253, -0.03326416, 0.012207031, 0.0046195984, 0.0015058517, 0.041137695, 0.032409668, -0.014389038, 0.0046043396, -0.02166748, -0.054992676, -0.025878906, 0.0030765533, -0.0039367676, 0.0127334595, -0.007331848, -0.046447754, -0.0050735474, -0.0004014969, 0.020843506, 0.00084638596, -0.030761719, 0.012901306, 0.005279541, -0.0013990402, 0.034576416, 0.03326416, -0.003604889, 0.028808594, 0.014549255, -0.007282257, 0.0036830902, 0.0158844, 0.0012683868, -0.04437256, -0.05706787, -0.0064849854, 0.012290955, -0.017669678, 0.018722534, 0.027755737, 0.038208008, 0.05215454, -0.0019817352, 0.027679443, 0.06878662, -0.052703857, -0.03050232, -0.03567505, -0.0046691895, -0.040405273, 0.07232666, 0.024169922, -0.010665894, -0.04724121, -0.024108887, -0.040100098, -0.0016126633, 0.010864258, -0.013061523, 0.0011234283, 0.0032444, 0.04034424, -0.055664062, -0.00031924248, -0.048461914, 0.05908203, -0.022155762, -0.0018930435, -0.018875122, -0.028869629, -0.025512695, -0.01322937, 0.04763794, 0.036102295, -0.0061798096, 0.046051025, -0.012451172, -0.023498535, -0.037719727, -0.0039596558, 0.02267456, 0.046447754, -0.054138184, 0.01411438, -0.029678345, 0.06756592, 0.022872925, 0.025222778, 0.0519104, 0.024642944, -0.013221741, -0.0021648407, -0.017074585, -0.021224976, -0.040863037, -0.03552246, 0.015327454, 0.0030612946, 0.018447876, -0.048187256, 0.01751709, 0.033569336, 0.019485474, -0.0064735413, 0.0049362183, -0.010414124, 0.006767273, 0.023895264, 0.04144287, 0.043548584, -0.034942627, -0.011787415, -0.0077285767, -0.03945923, 0.07788086, 0.04849243, -0.033294678, 0.018600464, -0.05496216, -0.0015439987, 0.013725281, -0.009292603, 0.0047683716, 0.025772095, -0.0051460266, -0.015258789, 0.061279297, 0.002483368, 0.046691895, 0.057128906, 0.035369873, 0.026870728, -0.046813965, -0.006713867, -0.0012073517, -0.025466919, 0.006526947, 0.037384033, -0.08483887, 0.026275635, -0.0051231384, -0.031341553, -0.017471313, 0.061157227, -0.0051231384, -0.043823242, -0.028198242, 0.024032593, 0.015594482, 0.028411865, 0.012191772, -0.016326904, -0.029632568, 0.012138367, 0.03677368, -0.011810303, 0.027664185, -0.008903503, 0.011360168, -0.0040130615, -0.041381836, 0.009780884, 0.0018405914, -0.018005371, 0.028396606, 0.0017433167, 0.045776367, -0.024749756, -0.05328369, 0.022003174, -0.0031719208, -0.04083252, -0.017822266, 0.025878906, 0.020690918, 0.0010852814, 0.051208496, 0.026535034, -0.019470215, -0.045013428, -0.017684937, 0.006801605, 0.0395813, -0.036468506, 0.028244019, -0.04916382, -0.043121338, 0.021774292, -0.07745361, 0.0335083, -0.037597656, -0.0000045895576, -0.035491943, 0.032928467, 0.034301758, -0.054382324, -0.041015625, -0.026321411, -0.037902832, 0.0032100677, 0.018096924, -0.018325806, -0.045166016, -0.022033691, 0.033172607, -0.03326416, -0.023239136, -0.0031547546, -0.022140503, -0.049835205, -0.010391235, -0.007896423, -0.0023384094, -0.008529663, -0.017150879, -0.009895325, -0.013893127, 0.002626419, 0.008804321, -0.0060272217, -0.035186768, -0.04748535, -0.040496826, 0.0041770935, -0.0014619827, -0.040100098, -0.029937744, -0.033233643, -0.007835388, -0.038238525, 0.0021324158, 0.011421204, -0.062408447, -0.021270752, 0.0051651, -0.040100098, 0.028961182, 0.037475586, -0.02230835, 0.0019798279, 0.0110321045, -0.014579773, -0.040039062, -0.0051994324, 0.02128601, -0.020736694, -0.02734375, 0.002412796, 0.012336731, 0.049743652, -0.06732178, -0.083984375, -0.008460999, 0.06036377, -0.023117065, 0.06530762, 0.00995636, 0.02961731, 0.026031494, 0.052124023, 0.012077332, -0.071777344, 0.008331299, -0.027664185, -0.028244019, 0.03326416, -0.0005235672, -0.0061798096, 0.036376953, 0.0063438416, 0.0178833, 0.010925293, -0.049621582, 0.017578125, -0.013587952, 0.009056091, 0.004020691, 0.0038909912, -0.039794922, 0.015571594, -0.008270264, -0.0048561096, -0.015350342, 0.026473999, -0.03640747, 0.026473999, -0.015640259, -0.074523926, 0.048950195, 0.056762695, -0.0058288574, 0.07458496, -0.012062073, -0.03363037, 0.008163452, -0.017807007, -0.03527832, -0.025756836, 0.06518555, -0.03100586, -0.03591919, 0.028579712, -0.052581787, 0.012611389, -0.030044556, 0.029693604, -0.02659607, 0.029251099, -0.026260376, -0.016906738, 0.0032444, 0.017593384, 0.01309967, -0.019638062, -0.043182373, -0.034423828, 0.020507812, -0.013877869 ], "summary": [ -0.015312195, -0.034698486, 0.013824463, -0.011131287, -0.0758667, 0.01763916, -0.077941895, -0.03756714, 0.045043945, 0.0005836487, 0.023483276, 0.009597778, -0.046722412, -0.04220581, -0.009521484, -0.009712219, -0.0141067505, 0.013259888, 0.003753662, -0.01876831, -0.0034275055, -0.036315918, 0.026062012, -0.1348877, 0.04586792, -0.0501709, 0.03262329, -0.012580872, 0.045654297, 0.026382446, 0.032104492, -0.041992188, 0.058563232, -0.04663086, -0.0026512146, 0.051574707, 0.019622803, -0.039520264, -0.015823364, 0.011802673, 0.038330078, -0.016143799, 0.019134521, -0.045440674, -0.027572632, 0.06201172, -0.025039673, -0.02003479, -0.0042419434, -0.042816162, -0.0047950745, 0.024627686, 0.010498047, -0.033813477, -0.003993988, 0.0234375, 0.006515503, -0.034729004, 0.014152527, 0.0052452087, 0.015220642, 0.0021324158, 0.011650085, 0.013290405, -0.002002716, 0.008094788, 0.074279785, 0.016616821, 0.016830444, -0.013793945, -0.0030002594, 0.018997192, 0.0077590942, -0.030563354, -0.023498535, 0.03161621, 0.0064811707, 0.01461792, 0.015686035, -0.017288208, -0.06732178, 0.001499176, -0.018554688, -0.09454346, 0.038330078, -0.038604736, -0.03314209, 0.02418518, -0.0021839142, -0.02519226, -0.0061187744, -0.0158844, -0.037750244, 0.025512695, 0.014305115, -0.04360962, -0.011459351, 0.023269653, 0.0042686462, 0.024902344, -0.00932312, -0.02017212, 0.0020999908, -0.029663086, 0.017944336, 0.022445679, -0.017700195, -0.009544373, 0.039215088, 0.028884888, -0.0027694702, 0.005844116, 0.006000519, -0.021118164, -0.019638062, 0.012039185, -0.006088257, 0.017593384, 0.022323608, 0.019515991, 0.0043411255, -0.0032081604, -0.0079422, -0.006351471, 0.008674622, -0.027160645, -0.05166626, 0.051971436, 0.035949707, -0.0060691833, 0.017700195, 0.018508911, -0.01876831, -0.0042381287, -0.03552246, 0.004196167, 0.01638794, 0.006286621, 0.007259369, -0.011520386, 0.033935547, -0.010131836, -0.007209778, 0.038513184, 0.04510498, -0.018676758, 0.0053901672, 0.026931763, 0.02633667, 0.060455322, -0.01826477, 0.0440979, 0.08227539, -0.057495117, -0.064331055, -0.123413086, -0.02381897, -0.06347656, 0.034301758, -0.082092285, 0.03878784, 0.026687622, 0.0010995865, -0.009292603, -0.026443481, -0.03793335, -0.019760132, -0.007408142, 0.014526367, -0.07098389, 0.053100586, 0.015899658, 0.023223877, -0.021102905, 0.015365601, -0.003232956, 0.0016365051, 0.026550293, 0.0013952255, -0.014587402, -0.0033798218, -0.030807495, 0.030273438, 0.010917664, 0.0050315857, -0.054016113, 0.0131073, -0.008033752, 0.028930664, 0.023468018, -0.03213501, 0.0050697327, -0.045654297, 0.011985779, -0.006088257, -0.0062828064, -0.0041885376, -0.0058135986, 0.00049734116, -0.029510498, 0.014915466, 0.022003174, -0.01071167, 0.002746582, -0.036132812, 0.01889038, -0.0066566467, 0.029159546, -0.028884888, 0.025268555, 0.016113281, -0.011543274, -0.041046143, 0.057617188, 0.0028820038, -0.049072266, 0.03463745, -0.051727295, 0.00034737587, -0.037719727, -0.012039185, 0.042999268, -0.041015625, 0.03765869, 0.04034424, 0.011238098, -0.011024475, 0.0077209473, 0.09741211, 0.025299072, 0.04421997, -0.027893066, 0.040222168, 0.030838013, -0.018417358, -0.003232956, -0.00141716, -0.0435791, 0.0206604, 0.045135498, 0.027816772, -0.0064430237, -0.0032215118, 0.0015687943, 0.024169922, 0.0023899078, 0.04156494, -0.022369385, -0.00409317, 0.0284729, -0.00063705444, 0.007904053, 0.019577026, -0.04699707, 0.005657196, 0.04650879, 0.0052833557, 0.009597778, -0.034484863, 0.0077819824, 0.0069122314, -0.02432251, -0.016601562, -0.0063972473, -0.003900528, -0.013916016, 0.040863037, 0.052124023, 0.04034424, -0.059295654, -0.01486969, 0.0158844, 0.00881958, 0.040863037, 0.015274048, -0.050048828, 0.014572144, -0.02810669, -0.007949829, -0.0015239716, -0.021652222, 0.00605011, 0.0060043335, -0.013748169, -0.008331299, -0.011749268, 0.022598267, 0.0017242432, -0.014122009, 0.0023288727, 0.014968872, 0.040618896, -0.015510559, 0.018371582, 0.015136719, -0.0059890747, 0.040771484, -0.02722168, 0.034820557, -0.0155181885, 0.037994385, 0.050628662, -0.0007777214, 0.01361084, 0.0236969, 0.013053894, 0.028442383, -0.013114929, -0.006755829, 0.027740479, -0.07989502, -0.01576233, 0.0029964447, 0.015586853, -0.040802002, -0.05203247, -0.02168274, -0.01448822, -0.07775879, -0.01727295, 0.09661865, -0.02116394, -0.004600525, 0.008552551, -0.031036377, -0.031143188, 0.039733887, -0.038391113, -0.0012769699, -0.01802063, -0.04525757, -0.038726807, -0.031463623, 0.040039062, -0.0030002594, 0.010559082, -0.0067710876, 0.01360321, -0.034942627, -0.020690918, -0.045684814, -0.015487671, 0.024963379, -0.039489746, 0.032043457, -0.03918457, -0.0048713684, 0.005382538, 0.019699097, 0.014297485, -0.029876709, 0.000093996525, -0.028961182, 0.031951904, 0.023651123, -0.007358551, 0.02394104, 0.016601562, 0.007659912, -0.03869629, 0.07043457, 0.017959595, 0.029449463, -0.04397583, -0.052490234, -0.03363037, 0.025650024, -0.04309082, 0.011123657, 0.029434204, 0.030151367, 0.026809692, -0.078430176, -0.025405884, -0.033355713, -0.014915466, 0.020858765, -0.03491211, 0.017242432, 0.011627197, -0.006752014, 0.008285522, 0.01411438, 0.0059013367, -0.005722046, 0.0015325546, -0.032714844, -0.02809143, 0.011329651, 0.00932312, 0.0048828125, -0.028823853, -0.029937744, -0.037078857, 0.038482666, -0.0038719177, 0.016723633, 0.06732178, -0.04498291, -0.032043457, 0.009796143, 0.03768921, -0.0090408325, 0.037475586, -0.047668457, 0.038726807, 0.0047950745, -0.018844604, 0.017089844, -0.03778076, 0.022323608, -0.0037784576, -0.012870789, 0.026489258, -0.004169464, -0.052703857, -0.045654297, -0.004283905, 0.0017652512, 0.0061950684, -0.040039062, 0.07574463, -0.038909912, 0.015960693, 0.03149414, 0.029312134, 0.013595581, -0.01448822, 0.015594482, 0.010345459, 0.00027441978, -0.013244629, 0.012031555, 0.014274597, -0.08380127, 0.05819702, 0.015655518, 0.038970947, 0.05923462, -0.07458496, -0.03778076, -0.012008667, -0.0039787292, -0.023147583, -0.023925781, 0.0060272217, -0.001080513, -0.013168335, 0.030090332, 0.0029582977, -0.0038089752, -0.0020618439, 0.058654785, 0.011474609, -0.021560669, -0.023239136, 0.023422241, 0.030670166, 0.07122803, -0.0053901672, 0.010299683, -0.016571045, -0.028457642, 0.037200928, -0.017288208, -0.018798828, -0.011756897, -0.012718201, -0.02708435, -0.013160706, -0.0368042, 0.066223145, 0.0015058517, -0.027908325, 0.036712646, 0.011054993, -0.0046920776, -0.0435791, 0.01838684, 0.018463135, -0.004463196, 0.00037002563, -0.0055503845, -0.06311035, -0.0005412102, -0.006752014, -0.07489014, -0.03186035, -0.0061149597, -0.0010948181, -0.022323608, 0.019973755, 0.025466919, 0.008682251, 0.016204834, -0.0042381287, 0.0079574585, 0.055633545, -0.016998291, -0.08618164, -0.017913818, -0.00076675415, -0.044647217, 0.022720337, -0.031707764, 0.025268555, 0.052764893, 0.0059318542, 0.0149383545, -0.023864746, 0.046020508, -0.027648926, -0.035949707, -0.033325195, -0.0053634644, 0.061187744, -0.0027942657, -0.061035156, 0.04724121, -0.00806427, 0.027191162, 0.04711914, -0.019622803, 0.01146698, 0.026046753, -0.0008416176, -0.034240723, 0.001958847, -0.0056037903, 0.023712158, 0.025039673, 0.0052986145, 0.030914307, -0.016235352, 0.01902771, -0.032684326, 0.0060043335, -0.064453125, -0.040863037, 0.040527344, 0.018432617, -0.038909912, -0.020141602, 0.0158844, -0.0064849854, -0.019058228, -0.044891357, -0.0056114197, -0.008903503, -0.014526367, -0.013313293, -0.01739502, -0.025756836, 0.00025343895, 0.023345947, -0.062316895, -0.054656982, 0.00053215027, 0.016601562, 0.024795532, -0.008613586, 0.012672424, -0.0023860931, -0.00983429, 0.04095459, 0.04937744, -0.07293701, -0.09051514, 0.021362305, 0.0103302, -0.040283203, -0.035186768, -0.0012168884, 0.012336731, -0.030426025, -0.0077667236, 0.013137817, 0.023666382, -0.009414673, -0.02822876, 0.03375244, -0.031707764, -0.01789856, -0.023025513, -0.025680542, 0.024917603, -0.0055503845, 0.032196045, -0.032806396, -0.016525269, 0.021713257, -0.007221222, -0.073791504, -0.11364746, 0.048431396, 0.061279297, 0.022033691, 0.089904785, 0.014053345, 0.040039062, 0.023391724, 0.01474762, 0.01600647, -0.007259369, -0.029006958, -0.004173279, -0.009902954, 0.022476196, 0.010688782, 0.05340576, -0.009468079, -0.064331055, 0.023376465, 0.019729614, 0.035095215, 0.010826111, 0.024658203, -0.005191803, -0.03164673, -0.030532837, 0.009269714, -0.016662598, 0.021118164, 0.020553589, -0.021087646, 0.005115509, 0.0105896, 0.0096206665, -0.02029419, -0.010124207, -0.010902405, -0.01550293, -0.081726074, -0.07330322, -0.03466797, 0.04660034, -0.002571106, -0.007144928, 0.05731201, -0.022369385, 0.015655518, 0.0064926147, -0.06628418, 0.01247406, 0.06384277, 0.00932312, 0.0072746277, 0.004737854, -0.014083862, -0.023101807, 0.03439331, 0.0021858215, -0.01158905, -0.026977539, -0.02784729, -0.015052795, -0.040161133, 0.030975342, -0.018447876, -0.019821167, -0.030426025, 0.01777649, 0.031021118, -0.02053833, -0.014823914, 0.007545471, -0.030197144, 0.04611206, -0.04940796, 0.0048103333, 0.03668213, -0.05227661, -0.0029067993, -0.019058228, -0.00028824806, 0.004398346, 0.019500732, 0.009460449, 0.003068924, -0.039520264, -0.024795532, -0.0051460266, 0.100097656, -0.0435791, -0.014328003, -0.0015211105, -0.005886078, 0.010856628, 0.04232788, 0.026641846, -0.0013313293, 0.004825592, 0.03866577, 0.013412476, -0.0042304993, 0.0793457, -0.023483276, 0.020721436, 0.0017967224, -0.02520752, 0.004512787, 0.011482239, 0.002254486, 0.008575439, -0.02218628, 0.0033683777, -0.0009775162, 0.02810669, 0.0044403076, -0.004261017, 0.005935669, 0.022766113, 0.030578613, 0.009880066, -0.040863037, -0.03277588, -0.025909424, -0.03579712, -0.04244995, 0.05770874, 0.004562378, 0.002948761, 0.029006958, -0.021987915, 0.031829834, -0.026611328, 0.0009689331, 0.005680084, -0.000106334686, 0.005039215, 0.042022705, -0.013679504, -0.06378174, 0.02154541, 0.031921387, -0.03765869, -0.002866745, 0.033355713, 0.041015625, -0.07989502, 0.009048462, -0.036712646, 0.050109863, -0.005420685, 0.062469482, 0.018005371, 0.019088745, 0.10461426, -0.035247803, 0.019897461, 0.009262085, -0.014442444, -0.023223877, -0.013954163, 0.018188477, -0.027053833, 0.015945435, 0.015914917, -0.011657715, -0.007926941, -0.060333252, -0.003774643, -0.018844604, 0.008079529, 0.028213501, 0.0021877289, 0.012901306, 0.06341553, -0.03744507, -0.011802673, -0.0023288727, 0.0057792664, -0.0028972626, 0.013153076, 0.035827637, -0.0014448166, -0.02633667, 0.048461914, 0.015068054, -0.032226562, -0.011817932, 0.011627197, 0.036315918, 0.023101807, -0.032348633, 0.0061416626, 0.01914978, 0.045684814, -0.0309906, 0.042510986, 0.03074646, 0.025985718, 0.02923584, 0.0031032562, 0.0067825317, 0.019577026, 0.026367188, 0.014389038, 0.007446289, -0.0040893555, -0.02368164, 0.018127441, -0.08673096, -0.012298584, -0.062805176, 0.010040283, -0.008796692, 0.012176514, -0.0018367767, 0.04321289, -0.0050354004, 0.012588501, 0.036132812, -0.04446411, 0.026504517, 0.001584053, -0.07672119, -0.01084137, -0.03652954, -0.040374756, 0.03302002, 0.04348755, -0.01411438, 0.012466431, -0.02281189, 0.03427124, 0.029205322, -0.03012085, -0.024261475, -0.041625977, 0.017623901, -0.033996582, 0.021377563, 0.034088135, 0.048675537, -0.019302368, 0.0027980804, 0.025054932, 0.0043144226, -0.022094727, 0.021270752, 0.010917664, -0.028427124, 0.020996094, -0.015525818, -0.03564453, 0.0077400208, -0.009307861, 0.016464233, 0.057922363, 0.028930664, -0.034942627, 0.018203735, -0.013832092, 0.0059127808, -0.021118164, -0.013755798, -0.037322998, 0.009506226, 0.005405426, -0.029129028, 0.03567505, 0.014663696, 0.033996582, -0.003982544, 0.016723633, 0.0012292862, 0.0004248619, 0.010231018, 0.0070533752, 0.022506714, -0.027923584, 0.015930176, 0.0028705597, -0.028045654, 0.020645142, 0.013404846, -0.008735657, 0.0062828064, -0.025482178, 0.015563965, 0.011070251, 0.025115967, -0.017059326, -0.0022716522, 0.020950317, -0.011642456, -0.015808105, -0.003835678, -0.012023926, -0.023071289, -0.024047852, 0.0060577393, -0.007041931, -0.06726074, -0.022094727, -0.051757812, -0.010719299, -0.05178833, 0.047332764, -0.056030273, -0.00573349, -0.019515991, -0.040985107, -0.08618164, 0.039489746, 0.023757935, -0.035736084, 0.010604858, -0.04650879, -0.04006958, -0.039794922, -0.020477295, -0.00869751, 0.014266968, 0.019973755, -0.03152466, -0.013710022, 0.013557434, -0.018569946, -0.016052246, 0.025787354, 0.021316528, -0.029052734, -0.048797607, 0.021224976, -0.019424438, -0.025054932, -0.05606079, 0.026504517, 0.011940002, -0.035369873, -0.0541687, -0.07739258, 0.004180908, -0.045166016, -0.0395813, 0.017288208, -0.030578613, 0.012329102, -0.0021915436, -0.0024642944, 0.016937256, 0.03152466, 0.0017356873, 0.026245117, 0.034179688, -0.030227661, -0.016311646, -0.030715942, -0.0073547363, 0.000664711, -0.007183075, -0.011436462, 0.0126953125, 0.016998291, -0.03894043, 0.031799316, 0.0015068054, 0.059570312, -0.015617371, 0.019836426, -0.05239868, 0.0013055801, 0.09320068, 0.066345215, 0.044006348, -0.055145264, 0.0037498474, -0.064697266, -0.0055770874, 0.0034484863, -0.0060691833, -0.016204834, 0.044433594, 0.0051612854, -0.031021118, -0.0060691833, -0.017822266, -0.042266846, 0.0049438477, -0.022125244, -0.026901245, -0.007129669, 0.005428314, -0.019165039, -0.004009247, -0.01966858, -0.005569458, -0.00033688545, -0.03869629, -0.0049705505, -0.0021514893, -0.022720337, 0.011138916, 0.031341553, 0.012397766, 0.0046463013, 0.0059776306, -0.00024676323, -0.007472992, -0.008033752, -0.0065689087, -0.030456543, 0.026321411, -0.045837402, -0.02468872, 0.02720642, 0.014663696, -0.04449463, -0.032714844, 0.04638672, -0.0069351196, -0.040008545, -0.00554657, -0.03265381, 0.015281677, 0.010101318, -0.0039749146, -0.01878357, -0.012290955, -0.070129395, -0.0031795502, -0.00009685755 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2103.14749v4
Pervasive Label Errors in Test Sets Destabilize Machine Learning Benchmarks
Curtis G. Northcutt, Anish Athalye, Jonas Mueller
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG
We identify label errors in the test sets of 10 of the most commonly-used computer vision, natural language, and audio datasets, and subsequently study the potential for these label errors to affect benchmark results. Errors in test sets are numerous and widespread: we estimate an average of at least 3.3% errors across the 10 datasets, where for example label errors comprise at least 6% of the ImageNet validation set. Putative label errors are identified using confident learning algorithms and then human-validated via crowdsourcing (51% of the algorithmically-flagged candidates are indeed erroneously labeled, on average across the datasets). Traditionally, machine learning practitioners choose which model to deploy based on test accuracy - our findings advise caution here, proposing that judging models over correctly labeled test sets may be more useful, especially for noisy real-world datasets. Surprisingly, we find that lower capacity models may be practically more useful than higher capacity models in real-world datasets with high proportions of erroneously labeled data. For example, on ImageNet with corrected labels: ResNet-18 outperforms ResNet-50 if the prevalence of originally mislabeled test examples increases by just 6%. On CIFAR-10 with corrected labels: VGG-11 outperforms VGG-19 if the prevalence of originally mislabeled test examples increases by just 5%. Test set errors across the 10 datasets can be viewed at https://labelerrors.com and all label errors can be reproduced by https://github.com/cleanlab/label-errors.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.14749v4
"2021-11-07T13:04:04"
"2021-03-26T21:54:36"
{ "title": [ -0.014854431, -0.0016021729, -0.016082764, -0.016098022, 0.0009536743, -0.024978638, 0.013137817, -0.021774292, -0.01991272, 0.0236969, -0.039276123, 0.026138306, -0.027954102, -0.009277344, -0.037719727, -0.017456055, -0.0061302185, 0.020889282, -0.015533447, -0.04156494, 0.0079574585, -0.042022705, 0.028533936, 0.04260254, 0.021697998, -0.00995636, -0.07696533, -0.011001587, -0.024551392, -0.05529785, -0.017562866, 0.044677734, 0.027069092, 0.050689697, -0.021438599, 0.050598145, -0.018066406, 0.045135498, 0.025039673, -0.0065689087, 0.023345947, -0.013183594, 0.00844574, -0.023971558, -0.015655518, 0.03213501, -0.055877686, -0.03942871, -0.0053596497, 0.040222168, 0.010650635, 0.01991272, -0.0029830933, 0.034942627, 0.01234436, -0.03491211, -0.024414062, -0.0029449463, 0.03793335, 0.06652832, 0.018188477, -0.036102295, 0.019515991, -0.035827637, -0.027801514, -0.028076172, -0.04083252, 0.018463135, 0.0914917, 0.012512207, -0.023406982, 0.0440979, -0.005458832, 0.0129852295, -0.026870728, -0.013008118, 0.054229736, 0.012077332, 0.008087158, -0.000027239323, 0.033569336, -0.026123047, 0.000057280064, 0.016601562, 0.013832092, 0.019317627, -0.0009822845, -0.032043457, -0.05239868, -0.0317688, -0.023208618, -0.048339844, -0.022338867, 0.002407074, -0.0124435425, -0.018463135, -0.001657486, 0.04473877, -0.012176514, -0.0340271, -0.03643799, 0.027160645, -0.085632324, -0.004020691, 0.0071144104, -0.0049972534, -0.011062622, -0.020950317, 0.011749268, 0.034240723, -0.04309082, 0.027374268, -0.015403748, -0.045074463, 0.0066108704, 0.030654907, -0.0078125, 0.0140686035, 0.02607727, 0.016555786, -0.0047073364, -0.010108948, -0.013557434, 0.018463135, 0.036193848, 0.023620605, -0.015411377, 0.007751465, -0.041656494, 0.024658203, -0.0014715195, 0.04888916, -0.06958008, -0.07928467, -0.055419922, 0.025787354, 0.011428833, 0.02053833, -0.020355225, 0.02746582, 0.009117126, -0.056884766, -0.005886078, 0.021514893, -0.0009889603, 0.026687622, 0.0637207, -0.020584106, -0.0496521, -0.05557251, -0.021209717, 0.004562378, 0.020614624, 0.008079529, -0.05130005, -0.001461029, -0.093811035, -0.0024433136, 0.009689331, -0.011138916, 0.033172607, -0.0029411316, 0.0023002625, 0.029174805, 0.044036865, 0.024169922, -0.027313232, 0.011474609, 0.000031352043, 0.019210815, -0.02507019, -0.0026435852, 0.016937256, -0.024856567, -0.021835327, 0.00831604, 0.02420044, 0.01197052, 0.010047913, -0.020736694, 0.00843811, -0.017684937, -0.0008625984, 0.03201294, -0.05203247, -0.047790527, 0.0051498413, -0.00031471252, 0.046905518, 0.009902954, -0.00907135, 0.0041236877, -0.06958008, -0.038085938, -0.038085938, -0.00061893463, -0.007160187, 0.011459351, -0.0149002075, 0.036315918, -0.021881104, 0.032165527, -0.051818848, 0.025878906, -0.037200928, -0.027786255, -0.008666992, 0.018112183, -0.061767578, 0.039764404, 0.04724121, -0.015556335, -0.02267456, 0.032562256, 0.02357483, -0.045074463, -0.0007696152, 0.0036258698, -0.01474762, -0.0067367554, -0.009963989, -0.023406982, 0.025466919, 0.05807495, -0.009651184, 0.01889038, -0.0023670197, 0.008300781, 0.024841309, 0.014587402, 0.11260986, -0.043518066, 0.05178833, 0.017410278, -0.0009860992, -0.032714844, -0.0020141602, -0.054779053, 0.015235901, 0.03390503, 0.002790451, -0.027557373, -0.004814148, 0.02154541, 0.043670654, 0.009254456, 0.018112183, 0.010635376, 0.028778076, 0.008766174, 0.014854431, 0.010528564, 0.05215454, 0.00111866, 0.019638062, 0.05429077, 0.0129852295, 0.022323608, -0.02079773, 0.020599365, -0.008018494, 0.051818848, 0.020370483, 0.01651001, -0.057800293, 0.0128479, -0.02192688, 0.009162903, 0.013389587, 0.013671875, 0.021316528, -0.05795288, 0.006679535, -0.0009303093, -0.0090408325, -0.017471313, -0.03314209, 0.031433105, 0.011459351, -0.03753662, -0.018157959, -0.02267456, 0.038909912, 0.0099105835, 0.011291504, 0.0036735535, 0.0496521, 0.005138397, -0.04748535, -0.045166016, 0.027679443, 0.038116455, 0.0026016235, -0.0042800903, 0.0034046173, -0.005268097, 0.091674805, 0.07330322, -0.036743164, 0.03744507, -0.041809082, 0.012542725, -0.013763428, -0.008590698, 0.011772156, 0.024520874, 0.040893555, -0.0005569458, -0.03201294, 0.02784729, -0.0657959, -0.013282776, 0.015853882, -0.017150879, -0.020187378, -0.056610107, -0.0035419464, -0.019195557, -0.0758667, -0.045959473, 0.07098389, 0.028625488, -0.00063610077, 0.013168335, 0.027618408, -0.041137695, 0.0082473755, -0.046936035, 0.009346008, 0.017562866, 0.03466797, 0.019836426, -0.06173706, -0.03805542, 0.0031490326, 0.010383606, -0.01914978, 0.03982544, -0.031311035, -0.025878906, -0.015563965, -0.026367188, 0.015052795, -0.019012451, -0.017089844, -0.028564453, -0.007637024, 0.010520935, -0.072631836, -0.0012845993, 0.031982422, -0.0234375, -0.005897522, 0.0063476562, 0.049926758, -0.025283813, -0.03164673, 0.017181396, 0.0048294067, -0.027786255, 0.018371582, 0.03213501, -0.0010986328, -0.036865234, -0.025894165, -0.05633545, 0.013206482, -0.016235352, 0.02520752, 0.05218506, 0.011756897, -0.0079193115, -0.066833496, -0.014793396, 0.0036563873, -0.029006958, -0.017944336, -0.044158936, 0.0038280487, -0.02406311, -0.011871338, -0.006072998, -0.000854969, -0.0019798279, 0.06439209, -0.0073623657, -0.038238525, 0.019073486, 0.0073051453, 0.01374054, -0.0129776, 0.0015678406, -0.004547119, 0.0064201355, 0.0041770935, 0.0024776459, -0.020187378, -0.0025787354, -0.084472656, 0.005630493, 0.058776855, -0.019607544, -0.03024292, 0.020828247, -0.060760498, 0.051574707, 0.0011100769, 0.002313614, 0.010757446, 0.036712646, 0.010971069, -0.005306244, 0.0038986206, -0.021057129, 0.023971558, -0.04953003, -0.10583496, 0.040740967, -0.046051025, -0.0067214966, -0.017593384, 0.023956299, -0.0715332, -0.024429321, -0.0031700134, 0.04107666, 0.04724121, 0.0031166077, 0.033355713, 0.0209198, 0.04724121, -0.013122559, 0.012687683, -0.013412476, -0.055511475, 0.014762878, 0.003490448, 0.070373535, 0.05517578, -0.024337769, -0.020187378, -0.013847351, -0.009819031, 0.031921387, -0.0022449493, -0.024856567, -0.015350342, -0.020690918, -0.0045051575, 0.028060913, -0.016326904, -0.0010948181, -0.017562866, 0.008705139, -0.022323608, 0.03942871, 0.012535095, 0.0072364807, -0.018615723, 0.004135132, 0.005344391, -0.016738892, -0.016616821, -0.0031356812, 0.011566162, -0.0002706051, 0.0037155151, -0.013092041, -0.043762207, 0.020477295, -0.039245605, 0.03189087, 0.015777588, 0.006008148, 0.0069274902, 0.011802673, -0.04748535, 0.027679443, -0.048706055, 0.017974854, -0.011878967, 0.025497437, -0.009803772, -0.07147217, -0.008132935, 0.016342163, -0.10211182, -0.06585693, 0.025299072, -0.033355713, -0.028381348, -0.053894043, 0.03552246, -0.03427124, -0.014259338, 0.009399414, -0.025772095, 0.03933716, 0.0015392303, -0.089660645, 0.018493652, 0.05154419, -0.007293701, 0.04562378, 0.024856567, -0.0027656555, -0.022232056, -0.012123108, 0.018753052, -0.011940002, 0.017745972, -0.013061523, 0.007583618, 0.045013428, -0.034820557, 0.052825928, -0.021865845, 0.001783371, -0.01007843, 0.014015198, 0.0043411255, 0.013679504, -0.029022217, 0.04373169, 0.0074539185, -0.0132369995, -0.0592041, 0.021881104, -0.020492554, -0.03869629, 0.015975952, 0.013618469, 0.020812988, 0.03164673, 0.002286911, 0.062438965, -0.01789856, 0.013648987, -0.003862381, -0.035614014, -0.039886475, -0.03050232, 0.042236328, -0.010238647, 0.00005185604, 0.014183044, 0.002954483, 0.039520264, 0.013267517, -0.016647339, -0.0027046204, 0.0064468384, -0.04107666, -0.028579712, -0.07421875, -0.004638672, -0.0032215118, 0.02192688, -0.011451721, -0.013473511, 0.026107788, -0.0048294067, -0.032287598, 0.008460999, 0.020355225, -0.004196167, -0.01235199, -0.05218506, -0.03753662, 0.0027809143, -0.06213379, -0.034698486, -0.0050697327, -0.008872986, 0.013069153, -0.014198303, -0.0017404556, 0.010795593, 0.017990112, 0.030395508, 0.019317627, -0.010368347, -0.03677368, 0.007434845, -0.023086548, -0.041870117, 0.021820068, -0.015312195, -0.024871826, -0.03552246, 0.031234741, -0.013969421, 0.000995636, -0.021606445, 0.01058197, -0.012779236, 0.03491211, -0.003627777, 0.045684814, 0.018157959, -0.002527237, 0.0052833557, 0.0028057098, -0.026824951, -0.006576538, 0.01977539, 0.006290436, 0.017562866, 0.031707764, 0.011817932, 0.01008606, -0.015258789, -0.039794922, 0.04727173, -0.008728027, -0.036865234, 0.002023697, 0.00005221367, -0.06109619, -0.027786255, -0.0064849854, -0.0035629272, 0.045440674, -0.046142578, 0.027832031, -0.013687134, 0.010185242, 0.03390503, -0.0008416176, 0.012931824, 0.00894928, 0.016220093, -0.066223145, -0.035858154, 0.005783081, 0.044677734, -0.038879395, -0.023498535, 0.011550903, 0.010253906, 0.023483276, 0.06976318, 0.059265137, -0.015960693, -0.009666443, 0.003484726, -0.0029506683, -0.031799316, -0.04208374, -0.0018997192, 0.00026845932, 0.012161255, -0.03967285, 0.011306763, -0.029220581, -0.026901245, -0.0022964478, -0.039764404, 0.032287598, -0.090026855, -0.01360321, 0.021820068, -0.010612488, 0.010551453, -0.0181427, 0.034942627, 0.046875, 0.05105591, 0.016983032, -0.012481689, 0.05670166, -0.020065308, 0.040893555, 0.0025138855, 0.029525757, 0.002790451, 0.023376465, 0.008956909, 0.013305664, -0.05984497, 0.025375366, 0.026672363, -0.0038795471, 0.018661499, -0.056396484, 0.020431519, 0.0063591003, -0.0025920868, -0.014320374, -0.036193848, -0.019836426, 0.02961731, -0.04977417, 0.00068950653, 0.030944824, -0.031951904, -0.027420044, -0.04083252, 0.02748108, -0.010292053, 0.018554688, -0.004055023, -0.0041999817, -0.03729248, 0.033813477, 0.039398193, -0.06945801, 0.0004339218, -0.028869629, -0.0013818741, 0.030517578, 0.03933716, -0.09906006, -0.0287323, 0.023757935, -0.03427124, -0.030670166, -0.0063667297, 0.017608643, -0.01373291, -0.010269165, -0.028839111, -0.0020656586, -0.008628845, 0.016357422, 0.011779785, -0.02078247, 0.029449463, 0.013282776, 0.018356323, 0.023986816, 0.033233643, 0.029296875, 0.010406494, -0.0062065125, -0.01134491, 0.018493652, -0.0011606216, 0.013023376, -0.01083374, -0.056488037, 0.0060157776, 0.016464233, 0.024414062, 0.0078048706, 0.03253174, 0.04336548, 0.030258179, 0.024261475, 0.031433105, 0.0791626, -0.04257202, -0.042816162, -0.025650024, 0.0069007874, -0.015304565, 0.08428955, -0.021377563, -0.045959473, -0.038269043, -0.0597229, -0.03164673, 0.00065755844, 0.0119018555, 0.013221741, 0.012580872, -0.041992188, 0.022857666, -0.023605347, -0.035888672, -0.042907715, 0.036132812, -0.013015747, -0.018936157, 0.029556274, -0.042633057, 0.0019626617, -0.03982544, 0.011436462, 0.038757324, 0.026550293, 0.001200676, -0.060516357, -0.018676758, -0.031433105, -0.015075684, 0.015098572, 0.043548584, -0.03805542, 0.029403687, -0.029769897, 0.054992676, 0.010803223, 0.014831543, 0.030288696, 0.013122559, 0.0013198853, -0.008804321, 0.0041236877, -0.025253296, -0.010391235, -0.056518555, 0.020812988, -0.03918457, 0.0051994324, -0.062561035, 0.030014038, 0.012260437, 0.055847168, -0.0039634705, 0.024627686, 0.016326904, -0.0022392273, 0.025634766, -0.023010254, 0.07092285, 0.01260376, -0.0070724487, 0.013664246, -0.006198883, 0.023956299, 0.035827637, -0.012413025, 0.025650024, 0.0073928833, -0.04284668, 0.027770996, 0.0090789795, 0.030258179, -0.015792847, -0.025619507, -0.032562256, 0.048858643, 0.008384705, 0.037200928, 0.048217773, 0.016479492, -0.0014743805, -0.036010742, -0.012039185, -0.013793945, -0.024002075, -0.0028018951, 0.038085938, -0.057617188, 0.022659302, -0.028656006, -0.027648926, 0.003982544, 0.051696777, 0.012741089, -0.04824829, -0.017959595, 0.020812988, 0.026290894, 0.028808594, 0.022262573, -0.018661499, -0.038269043, 0.021606445, 0.050750732, -0.027389526, 0.04135132, -0.0030899048, 0.0034732819, 0.0039405823, -0.027786255, 0.019699097, 0.028640747, 0.0012731552, 0.027252197, -0.031051636, 0.055541992, -0.04486084, -0.04852295, -0.0021209717, 0.0009431839, -0.07543945, -0.036743164, 0.06341553, 0.05230713, 0.0446167, 0.054260254, 0.0062789917, -0.01222229, 0.033477783, -0.034057617, 0.013000488, 0.0625, -0.01739502, 0.03643799, -0.04244995, -0.040771484, 0.03338623, -0.03237915, 0.067993164, -0.01411438, 0.019256592, -0.0435791, 0.030181885, 0.03074646, -0.08081055, 0.0046195984, -0.014877319, -0.038604736, 0.0040779114, -0.000024557114, -0.028823853, -0.0340271, -0.021759033, 0.017471313, -0.008476257, -0.017028809, 0.016052246, -0.027130127, -0.0793457, -0.028060913, -0.03640747, -0.0017194748, -0.020935059, -0.0018920898, -0.013725281, 0.015640259, -0.003025055, -0.030792236, -0.022903442, -0.024017334, -0.015899658, -0.051818848, -0.0024032593, -0.021057129, -0.042663574, -0.028930664, -0.055358887, 0.008514404, -0.03756714, -0.011695862, 0.034179688, -0.04727173, 0.0015773773, 0.007610321, -0.04916382, 0.04837036, 0.0446167, 0.0070991516, 0.012794495, 0.011520386, -0.009735107, -0.013496399, 0.0335083, 0.05380249, 0.003829956, -0.030090332, -0.005004883, 0.03314209, 0.0501709, -0.06500244, -0.033050537, 0.0005335808, 0.0155181885, -0.0075912476, 0.02571106, 0.0119018555, -0.011756897, 0.007865906, 0.016281128, -0.0019760132, -0.020980835, -0.062683105, -0.03314209, 0.04373169, 0.040222168, -0.014694214, -0.02178955, 0.03869629, -0.0115356445, -0.005722046, 0.033050537, -0.0038928986, 0.005558014, 0.012969971, 0.036224365, -0.0077667236, -0.04437256, -0.031921387, -0.007575989, 0.027664185, 0.022415161, -0.026641846, 0.016677856, -0.018875122, 0.061676025, 0.0045204163, -0.048217773, 0.034454346, 0.021759033, 0.021255493, 0.06329346, -0.00032639503, -0.05795288, -0.019546509, -0.016464233, -0.016921997, -0.015151978, 0.036376953, -0.03111267, 0.0057868958, 0.009529114, -0.040771484, 0.042907715, -0.018981934, 0.039398193, -0.0491333, 0.026290894, -0.052520752, -0.011947632, 0.0014734268, 0.031204224, 0.027801514, -0.02053833, -0.031311035, -0.051727295, 0.052978516, -0.023147583 ], "summary": [ -0.009857178, -0.0078048706, -0.017486572, 0.028366089, -0.011772156, -0.031188965, 0.017608643, -0.023544312, 0.031280518, 0.02229309, -0.044921875, 0.005630493, -0.030548096, -0.016555786, -0.042175293, -0.035247803, -0.014694214, 0.031463623, 0.0011920929, -0.027572632, 0.019760132, -0.039276123, -0.0031929016, -0.014266968, -0.001748085, -0.020904541, 0.0048332214, 0.021652222, -0.030349731, -0.012748718, -0.0048942566, 0.028625488, 0.01084137, 0.032836914, -0.011024475, 0.040008545, 0.060913086, -0.0037612915, 0.05227661, -0.0018062592, 0.043701172, -0.038024902, 0.14929199, -0.0725708, 0.06304932, 0.06274414, 0.041229248, -0.06750488, 0.00674057, 0.014961243, 0.030151367, 0.02960205, 0.025848389, -0.004673004, -0.006790161, -0.012298584, -0.018936157, -0.03302002, 0.02607727, 0.02784729, 0.006626129, -0.019332886, 0.0029659271, -0.026016235, -0.001619339, -0.017074585, 0.0059928894, -0.0030059814, 0.03564453, 0.017120361, 0.023849487, 0.025604248, -0.0057792664, -0.005420685, 0.001698494, 0.03692627, 0.004676819, 0.036865234, 0.00021624565, 0.017120361, 0.03253174, 0.004272461, -0.0107040405, 0.052215576, -0.036346436, 0.040496826, -0.00028777122, -0.04168701, -0.041900635, 0.011695862, -0.023330688, -0.04888916, -0.08416748, 0.044799805, 0.046722412, -0.009788513, 0.011947632, 0.022369385, -0.0025138855, -0.029418945, -0.011398315, -0.023910522, -0.05227661, 0.008720398, 0.047851562, -0.004108429, -0.061706543, -0.077819824, 0.059692383, 0.03640747, -0.021713257, 0.02658081, -0.029556274, -0.036590576, -0.023468018, 0.053863525, 0.002445221, -0.019485474, -0.0060310364, -0.006439209, -0.019714355, 0.021713257, -0.01828003, 0.00919342, 0.025436401, 0.03253174, 0.01499939, -0.0024662018, -0.044799805, 0.004562378, 0.0053749084, 0.024765015, -0.027404785, -0.008483887, -0.050567627, 0.0010271072, 0.018920898, 0.031799316, 0.018951416, -0.025009155, 0.03744507, -0.016342163, 0.0032310486, 0.027359009, 0.028305054, 0.04147339, 0.03161621, -0.012252808, -0.030303955, -0.07122803, 0.05505371, -0.05847168, 0.03225708, -0.016098022, 0.006126404, -0.06964111, -0.0027980804, -0.030441284, 0.026489258, -0.041900635, 0.06549072, -0.0048599243, 0.027664185, 0.0574646, 0.019454956, 0.012054443, -0.051116943, -0.020828247, 0.0020008087, -0.0075302124, -0.0099487305, -0.00006300211, 0.016998291, -0.027908325, -0.0028057098, -0.010978699, 0.0084991455, 0.0027217865, 0.009841919, 0.019836426, 0.012863159, -0.013298035, 0.02482605, 0.02078247, -0.005783081, -0.09527588, 0.0017776489, -0.0015583038, 0.06512451, 0.02017212, 0.00969696, -0.06976318, -0.034820557, -0.0132369995, -0.016555786, -0.008834839, -0.020690918, -0.007858276, -0.02645874, 0.0287323, 0.016433716, 0.016693115, -0.03643799, -0.005558014, -0.09301758, -0.018417358, -0.018203735, 0.023498535, -0.078125, 0.009361267, 0.03326416, -0.05908203, -0.03201294, 0.10839844, 0.053985596, -0.041259766, -0.0025920868, -0.0051651, -0.024856567, -0.023529053, 0.0033779144, -0.0010929108, 0.0029773712, 0.068237305, -0.021728516, 0.03781128, -0.016967773, 0.03439331, 0.0077781677, 0.020324707, 0.06378174, -0.034332275, 0.060791016, 0.044158936, -0.010032654, 0.0025177002, 0.016311646, -0.061950684, -0.0093307495, 0.045654297, 0.024780273, -0.014091492, -0.029937744, -0.022018433, 0.042053223, 0.029541016, 0.03503418, -0.03387451, 0.009346008, 0.031311035, -0.0035037994, 0.00082445145, 0.010002136, -0.044433594, -0.012672424, 0.037902832, -0.037628174, -0.034332275, 0.01171875, -0.022598267, 0.01689148, -0.027008057, -0.006313324, -0.0017080307, -0.020874023, -0.031982422, -0.014122009, -0.009796143, 0.009849548, -0.024505615, 0.012130737, -0.06726074, 0.0076293945, -0.009056091, -0.025253296, -0.011070251, -0.018493652, 0.030792236, 0.0000045895576, -0.026031494, -0.02822876, -0.031982422, -0.0053482056, -0.003818512, 0.007911682, 0.003742218, 0.04220581, 0.01247406, -0.07281494, -0.037841797, 0.006099701, 0.013542175, -0.023666382, -0.026184082, 0.013397217, -0.013793945, 0.073791504, 0.012306213, 0.008056641, 0.00072431564, 0.031677246, 0.031433105, -0.03173828, 0.026885986, 0.013534546, -0.0028057098, 0.046295166, 0.00025224686, -0.015510559, -0.0008034706, -0.041778564, -0.013954163, 0.017364502, 0.056732178, -0.05697632, -0.055999756, -0.039276123, 0.022506714, -0.08123779, -0.04324341, 0.023666382, 0.064819336, 0.009048462, 0.047698975, 0.04660034, -0.040771484, 0.040039062, -0.023101807, 0.04937744, 0.001036644, 0.013717651, 0.023117065, -0.0340271, -0.059509277, 0.010185242, -0.00699234, 0.017868042, 0.034332275, 0.0033092499, -0.022232056, 0.041809082, -0.051330566, -0.005317688, 0.017074585, -0.046875, 0.0068130493, 0.040100098, -0.012130737, -0.04043579, 0.005050659, 0.024490356, -0.016815186, -0.0060539246, 0.008895874, 0.0038166046, 0.0034255981, 0.011917114, -0.020309448, -0.02029419, -0.050231934, 0.0071907043, 0.042144775, -0.004512787, -0.03274536, -0.051483154, -0.03591919, 0.055755615, -0.03012085, 0.05722046, 0.060791016, 0.02722168, 0.012466431, -0.013977051, -0.0154953, -0.009506226, -0.057037354, 0.008285522, -0.042266846, 0.024887085, 0.002281189, -0.0006008148, -0.003572464, 0.033081055, 0.0115737915, 0.051330566, -0.01979065, -0.014862061, 0.0491333, 0.030975342, 0.005443573, 0.0022583008, 0.013000488, 0.023956299, -0.029037476, -0.027236938, -0.0074882507, 0.029251099, 0.0025100708, 0.019256592, -0.031707764, -0.013458252, -0.019973755, -0.0051078796, -0.019454956, -0.0022277832, 0.018753052, -0.006969452, -0.010108948, 0.00056028366, 0.016677856, 0.030975342, -0.026275635, 0.011177063, -0.008544922, 0.023712158, -0.050567627, -0.04421997, 0.014572144, -0.06390381, 0.030471802, -0.000749588, 0.091796875, -0.041656494, 0.0070266724, 0.016525269, 0.026763916, 0.018875122, -0.0062332153, 0.022003174, 0.028381348, 0.021453857, -0.0034809113, 0.0093688965, 0.0026226044, -0.08380127, 0.0035915375, 0.021392822, 0.038879395, 0.07470703, -0.061065674, -0.014533997, -0.03994751, -0.021133423, 0.016418457, 0.022827148, -0.0181427, -0.036712646, -0.016601562, 0.0099487305, 0.040496826, -0.021087646, 0.005821228, 0.016143799, 0.017913818, -0.033569336, -0.014251709, -0.013908386, 0.00605011, 0.011924744, -0.020629883, -0.022445679, -0.016708374, 0.01398468, -0.02784729, 0.0071029663, 0.035583496, -0.053771973, 0.0067367554, -0.029251099, -0.008850098, 0.017364502, 0.038391113, -0.016082764, -0.02999878, 0.038360596, -0.004020691, -0.018920898, -0.027374268, 0.03591919, 0.014419556, -0.028762817, 0.016021729, -0.008621216, -0.02078247, 0.00365448, 0.0137786865, -0.04321289, -0.041259766, 0.017822266, 0.024749756, 0.012901306, -0.015808105, 0.053222656, 0.00072050095, 0.0046539307, 0.018218994, -0.014678955, 0.02909851, -0.0021419525, -0.08605957, 0.02229309, -0.007820129, 0.037872314, 0.04360962, 0.009094238, 0.036071777, 0.014961243, 0.014793396, 0.0005540848, -0.031280518, 0.036376953, -0.042022705, 0.009178162, 0.0061531067, -0.02986145, 0.03640747, -0.04837036, -0.021453857, -0.022537231, 0.019836426, 0.03652954, 0.034362793, 0.009635925, 0.0046806335, 0.015823364, -0.012199402, 0.0149002075, 0.0016956329, -0.020217896, -0.0418396, -0.0036087036, 0.033569336, -0.010040283, 0.018615723, 0.030044556, 0.015792847, -0.04534912, -0.007858276, -0.043792725, -0.015594482, -0.055511475, -0.010345459, 0.046569824, 0.03125, -0.0012493134, -0.021560669, 0.028167725, 0.012756348, 0.028823853, -0.06488037, 0.031341553, 0.049041748, -0.004600525, -0.06048584, -0.0625, 0.055511475, 0.01739502, -0.01864624, -0.0012903214, 0.033996582, -0.012786865, -0.036834717, 0.007247925, 0.012268066, 0.01361084, 0.034179688, -0.06085205, -0.077697754, -0.012825012, -0.011070251, -0.029876709, -0.0025863647, 0.0075263977, -0.026382446, 0.016845703, -0.018493652, -0.0345459, 0.013946533, -0.011276245, 0.049957275, 0.018295288, 0.007751465, -0.06866455, -0.0059814453, 0.0011177063, -0.05203247, -0.00007712841, -0.05883789, -0.030136108, -0.035064697, 0.042114258, -0.009803772, -0.033477783, -0.013008118, 0.044006348, 0.028274536, 0.043701172, -0.0038032532, 0.032073975, 0.020431519, -0.0044670105, 0.0066375732, 0.012496948, 0.00089359283, 0.012886047, 0.031204224, -0.040130615, 0.06951904, 0.04434204, 0.022476196, -0.018157959, -0.02180481, -0.037841797, 0.045013428, -0.02659607, -0.06488037, 0.0012903214, -0.022720337, -0.032714844, -0.03375244, 0.0014486313, -0.013618469, 0.019805908, 0.025558472, -0.024261475, 0.012786865, 0.008003235, 0.050079346, -0.0049819946, -0.022476196, 0.052642822, -0.02748108, -0.053253174, -0.049621582, -0.021575928, 0.046722412, -0.0152282715, -0.027526855, -0.008163452, -0.02659607, -0.005771637, 0.019622803, 0.03857422, -0.00034594536, 0.0031433105, -0.014633179, -0.0007457733, 0.005092621, -0.022460938, -0.0077934265, 0.0011739731, -0.009216309, -0.00881958, -0.04345703, 0.027496338, -0.055023193, -0.0057792664, -0.0077285767, -0.0016679764, -0.032104492, -0.047332764, -0.0049324036, -0.025665283, -0.013549805, -0.019958496, -0.000030696392, 0.008613586, 0.0058631897, -0.015029907, -0.022857666, -0.0056381226, -0.031585693, 0.044952393, -0.013137817, 0.00440979, 0.03918457, 0.030059814, 0.0038604736, 0.03488159, -0.022628784, -0.00061416626, -0.015426636, -0.0039711, -0.05142212, 0.015655518, 0.03250122, 0.011116028, 0.0063476562, -0.012519836, 0.010002136, -0.0014543533, 0.01676941, -0.016418457, -0.005378723, -0.006214142, -0.017410278, -0.023406982, 0.0027256012, 0.0053749084, -0.0020523071, 0.0069618225, 0.012184143, 0.0034751892, 0.00037884712, 0.002735138, 0.008758545, -0.06604004, -0.026794434, -0.017547607, 0.016143799, -0.036071777, -0.025970459, -0.0635376, -0.016723633, 0.015525818, -0.010147095, -0.021270752, 0.00020849705, 0.010559082, -0.00048160553, -0.00027942657, -0.02558899, -0.013580322, -0.03414917, 0.020050049, -0.07434082, 0.016403198, 0.010116577, -0.012329102, -0.01335144, 0.0151901245, -0.030441284, -0.010818481, -0.0006656647, 0.009994507, -0.032470703, 0.007335663, 0.02255249, 0.04711914, -0.023361206, -0.031341553, -0.0036525726, 0.036499023, 0.025909424, 0.03933716, 0.04660034, 0.020690918, 0.081848145, 0.036956787, 0.04360962, 0.034484863, -0.0021705627, -0.016479492, -0.030456543, 0.009208679, -0.034606934, 0.038360596, -0.037078857, -0.022964478, -0.018371582, -0.0076904297, 0.013679504, 0.016220093, -0.005104065, -0.0066337585, 0.048583984, -0.028930664, -0.010238647, -0.033172607, -0.04168701, 0.0155181885, 0.024398804, -0.010345459, -0.03338623, 0.027374268, -0.05783081, -0.010772705, -0.0052833557, -0.004463196, 0.062408447, 0.005897522, 0.03277588, -0.070739746, -0.025344849, -0.02078247, 0.03756714, 0.039398193, 0.0046958923, -0.0132369995, -0.01927185, 0.023666382, 0.020874023, -0.054595947, -0.014022827, -0.03765869, -0.010269165, -0.002752304, -0.030670166, -0.011543274, -0.02949524, -0.038085938, -0.0057029724, -0.014961243, 0.011741638, -0.005882263, 0.015556335, 0.0435791, -0.0009274483, -0.00970459, 0.057922363, 0.01625061, 0.023651123, 0.014167786, -0.025543213, -0.01096344, 0.008460999, 0.0134887695, -0.015289307, 0.008865356, 0.0014648438, -0.016815186, 0.01914978, 0.0051651, 0.030380249, 0.017410278, -0.036346436, 0.044281006, -0.009101868, 0.017929077, -0.008743286, 0.0024776459, -0.026397705, 0.055145264, 0.05380249, 0.06695557, 0.0033245087, -0.04638672, 0.060943604, -0.03793335, -0.035186768, -0.011413574, -0.029296875, 0.010391235, -0.0004682541, -0.016098022, 0.008659363, -0.0211792, -0.0061950684, 0.061645508, 0.020431519, 0.023223877, -0.064819336, -0.011512756, -0.009101868, 0.0045166016, 0.0031108856, 0.017807007, -0.018157959, -0.057006836, 0.028762817, 0.054870605, -0.027908325, 0.052978516, 0.005531311, -0.014160156, 0.023422241, 0.006717682, 0.024536133, 0.02999878, 0.03277588, 0.0284729, -0.04437256, 0.037506104, -0.010604858, -0.02571106, 0.014518738, 0.016571045, -0.035369873, 0.003730774, 0.056274414, 0.041107178, 0.044799805, 0.038909912, -0.032196045, 0.0033721924, 0.064941406, -0.02255249, -0.007598877, 0.02532959, 0.013259888, -0.0009608269, -0.029937744, -0.01260376, 0.016983032, 0.013084412, 0.11187744, -0.022033691, -0.022323608, -0.055358887, 0.03643799, -0.041046143, -0.014381409, 0.0284729, -0.054656982, 0.015808105, 0.0020942688, -0.028686523, -0.07525635, -0.0044784546, -0.03756714, -0.00982666, -0.020462036, 0.0018558502, 0.048339844, -0.022705078, -0.052947998, -0.02670288, -0.0054740906, 0.0047035217, 0.016067505, -0.02017212, 0.005580902, 0.014503479, 0.010177612, -0.027420044, -0.009170532, -0.014816284, -0.0018396378, -0.050750732, -0.009963989, -0.01424408, -0.048065186, -0.058044434, 0.043182373, -0.02243042, -0.027069092, 0.04953003, 0.031463623, -0.054626465, 0.044403076, 0.030395508, -0.034606934, 0.079956055, 0.017471313, -0.0010061264, 0.039794922, 0.03491211, -0.029876709, -0.0010957718, -0.016693115, -0.014343262, 0.0082473755, -0.0012149811, -0.0022735596, 0.0050621033, 0.012817383, -0.039123535, -0.039916992, -0.00013041496, 0.008964539, 0.021347046, -0.0019626617, 0.0011177063, -0.008575439, -0.00592041, 0.0036754608, 0.00079107285, -0.014167786, -0.040740967, 0.015930176, 0.061798096, 0.027282715, -0.025024414, 0.019210815, 0.028213501, -0.050811768, -0.046569824, 0.047790527, 0.035186768, -0.048797607, 0.045898438, 0.0075950623, -0.051574707, -0.05758667, -0.024993896, -0.021148682, 0.019256592, -0.0025367737, -0.032073975, 0.03173828, -0.030258179, 0.0074501038, 0.020629883, -0.05014038, -0.026412964, 0.013954163, 0.0001232624, 0.01739502, -0.0043792725, -0.052856445, 0.004272461, -0.016571045, -0.004486084, -0.005695343, 0.05819702, -0.06048584, -0.026321411, -0.04324341, -0.034118652, 0.024017334, -0.016418457, 0.0099105835, -0.039001465, 0.033294678, -0.015655518, 0.015556335, 0.011650085, 0.004005432, 0.048980713, -0.044158936, 0.06161499, -0.010017395, 0.02041626, 0.031234741 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2104.02214v1
Intelligent Building Control Systems for Thermal Comfort and Energy-Efficiency: A Systematic Review of Artificial Intelligence-Assisted Techniques
Ghezlane Halhoul Merabet, Mohamed Essaaidi, Mohamed Ben Haddou, Basheer Qolomany, Junaid Qadir, Muhammad Anan, Ala Al-Fuqaha, Mohamed Riduan Abid, Driss Benhaddou
cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SY, eess.SY
Building operations represent a significant percentage of the total primary energy consumed in most countries due to the proliferation of Heating, Ventilation and Air-Conditioning (HVAC) installations in response to the growing demand for improved thermal comfort. Reducing the associated energy consumption while maintaining comfortable conditions in buildings are conflicting objectives and represent a typical optimization problem that requires intelligent system design. Over the last decade, different methodologies based on the Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques have been deployed to find the sweet spot between energy use in HVAC systems and suitable indoor comfort levels to the occupants. This paper performs a comprehensive and an in-depth systematic review of AI-based techniques used for building control systems by assessing the outputs of these techniques, and their implementations in the reviewed works, as well as investigating their abilities to improve the energy-efficiency, while maintaining thermal comfort conditions. This enables a holistic view of (1) the complexities of delivering thermal comfort to users inside buildings in an energy-efficient way, and (2) the associated bibliographic material to assist researchers and experts in the field in tackling such a challenge. Among the 20 AI tools developed for both energy consumption and comfort control, functions such as identification and recognition patterns, optimization, predictive control. Based on the findings of this work, the application of AI technology in building control is a promising area of research and still an ongoing, i.e., the performance of AI-based control is not yet completely satisfactory. This is mainly due in part to the fact that these algorithms usually need a large amount of high-quality real-world data, which is lacking in the building or, more precisely, the energy sector.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2104.02214v1
"2021-04-06T01:04:28"
"2021-04-06T01:04:28"
{ "title": [ -0.027267456, 0.0001269579, -0.016479492, -0.0074691772, 0.016830444, -0.016464233, 0.038360596, -0.0345459, -0.012123108, 0.039001465, -0.023635864, 0.026138306, 0.020828247, -0.025466919, -0.025024414, 0.015235901, 0.002357483, -0.010040283, -0.023483276, -0.04034424, 0.03579712, -0.057891846, 0.045013428, 0.068725586, 0.038970947, -0.05480957, -0.072143555, 0.014556885, -0.03781128, -0.042755127, -0.011367798, 0.028564453, 0.052001953, 0.0050964355, -0.025741577, 0.015731812, -0.037109375, 0.01335907, -0.013809204, 0.011451721, 0.020401001, -0.01763916, -0.051361084, 0.0099487305, -0.032318115, 0.009666443, -0.054229736, -0.020767212, -0.022888184, 0.0016317368, 0.03375244, -0.00724411, 0.025650024, -0.03137207, 0.0025558472, -0.019088745, 0.010887146, -0.023468018, 0.049591064, -0.007820129, -0.014442444, -0.05316162, 0.04827881, 0.008659363, -0.04776001, -0.016677856, 0.017303467, 0.029296875, 0.10760498, -0.03665161, -0.04864502, 0.07495117, 0.0020217896, 0.019332886, -0.040100098, 0.00020480156, 0.03503418, -0.0017814636, 0.044006348, -0.00806427, -0.0028762817, 0.008895874, -0.016143799, -0.02432251, -0.0016765594, -0.03503418, -0.015655518, -0.0020332336, -0.046539307, -0.05493164, -0.010292053, -0.007549286, -0.026000977, -0.013374329, -0.023651123, -0.041992188, -0.030654907, 0.0066871643, 0.004234314, -0.0023384094, -0.0064811707, 0.011634827, -0.030883789, -0.028930664, -0.0074539185, 0.048339844, 0.012130737, 0.004589081, -0.0052337646, 0.01210022, -0.015052795, -0.019973755, 0.0005207062, -0.0047798157, -0.007827759, 0.0074539185, 0.002527237, -0.008659363, 0.025360107, -0.0063095093, -0.029891968, -0.057128906, -0.0033016205, 0.051940918, 0.039886475, 0.024505615, -0.023864746, 0.024353027, 0.017547607, -0.0005412102, 0.0018444061, 0.028686523, -0.07244873, -0.059417725, -0.025482178, 0.050689697, 0.022064209, -0.008293152, 0.014221191, -0.006538391, 0.049041748, 0.0067634583, 0.0001538992, 0.045928955, 0.00573349, 0.006000519, 0.056915283, -0.0037269592, -0.05355835, -0.035583496, -0.019104004, 0.022338867, 0.030059814, -0.003293991, -0.03274536, -0.014801025, -0.0904541, -0.02998352, 0.028182983, -0.011009216, 0.022781372, 0.0096588135, 0.0006637573, 0.04220581, 0.07373047, -0.022583008, 0.007965088, 0.035705566, 0.011940002, 0.06518555, -0.010597229, -0.002494812, 0.0020542145, 0.0055160522, -0.01889038, 0.00982666, 0.035125732, 0.042877197, 0.019317627, -0.040008545, -0.018127441, -0.03717041, 0.0519104, 0.012962341, -0.035064697, -0.020874023, -0.0030555725, -0.030471802, 0.047454834, 0.0051231384, -0.06829834, 0.037963867, -0.037994385, -0.051605225, -0.053741455, -0.021408081, 0.03488159, 0.029678345, -0.014564514, 0.028457642, -0.015838623, -0.015113831, -0.022125244, 0.00069856644, 0.0116119385, -0.05215454, 0.0003566742, 0.011405945, -0.017654419, 0.05697632, 0.04248047, 0.015914917, -0.012611389, -0.016036987, 0.0143966675, -0.036224365, 0.030548096, 0.004211426, -0.006324768, -0.017486572, -0.02885437, -0.015541077, 0.0006995201, 0.052520752, 0.005332947, 0.013435364, -0.00605011, -0.021987915, 0.044677734, 0.016647339, 0.076660156, -0.014038086, 0.017944336, 0.03552246, 0.012886047, -0.015838623, -0.0037155151, -0.017807007, 0.013130188, 0.00018191338, -0.0026569366, -0.013771057, 0.01586914, 0.059814453, 0.005722046, -0.02607727, 0.002998352, 0.036193848, 0.011268616, 0.028823853, 0.050567627, 0.006904602, 0.05419922, 0.030899048, 0.0018930435, 0.042633057, -0.015838623, -0.013999939, -0.0072669983, -0.012626648, 0.016220093, 0.004512787, -0.0064849854, 0.01134491, -0.020111084, 0.028533936, -0.0006918907, 0.039978027, 0.008026123, 0.02798462, 0.017410278, -0.02243042, 0.0041236877, -0.0073051453, -0.014678955, -0.017684937, -0.021102905, 0.021316528, 0.013916016, -0.052246094, -0.019073486, -0.011207581, -0.012184143, -0.008544922, 0.040740967, 0.008804321, -0.007904053, -0.01826477, -0.009567261, -0.011734009, 0.05432129, 0.018188477, 0.0049095154, -0.024032593, 0.016448975, -0.012001038, 0.06335449, 0.10217285, -0.03933716, 0.047973633, -0.09100342, -0.0071983337, 0.01625061, -0.044952393, -0.008529663, 0.037872314, 0.006767273, 0.016952515, -0.028900146, 0.0052719116, -0.048339844, -0.015045166, 0.027267456, -0.04107666, 0.008781433, -0.005306244, -0.0013742447, -0.017425537, -0.019638062, 0.007270813, -0.006500244, 0.022964478, -0.05895996, 0.0090789795, 0.017349243, 0.018722534, -0.044433594, -0.017547607, -0.0049438477, 0.016967773, 0.07861328, 0.049194336, -0.024154663, -0.0025291443, 0.01727295, 0.012107849, -0.022583008, 0.029541016, -0.01776123, -0.008041382, -0.0066375732, 0.0013608932, 0.023132324, -0.025802612, 0.0042037964, -0.045776367, 0.009765625, 0.015586853, -0.015266418, -0.0032234192, 0.023239136, -0.020874023, -0.03744507, -0.011360168, 0.026351929, 0.006664276, 0.0014677048, -0.0068588257, 0.027679443, -0.035614014, 0.036743164, 0.00045728683, -0.016601562, -0.07287598, 0.0090408325, -0.03048706, -0.035491943, -0.028121948, -0.030700684, 0.014328003, -0.04559326, -0.030548096, -0.026535034, -0.016082764, -0.0029029846, 0.032318115, 0.025360107, 0.0047187805, -0.037139893, -0.0024356842, 0.016098022, 0.023468018, -0.043823242, 0.009757996, 0.10266113, 0.0025100708, 0.0026683807, 0.0026836395, 0.033813477, -0.0021476746, -0.021911621, -0.045318604, -0.022857666, 0.017959595, 0.035217285, -0.0021762848, -0.036590576, 0.019592285, -0.14904785, 0.008171082, 0.002811432, 0.005329132, -0.023330688, 0.013519287, -0.058502197, 0.02279663, -0.019561768, -0.037200928, 0.025924683, 0.096069336, -0.0060043335, -0.012664795, 0.0065193176, -0.023010254, 0.016677856, -0.0014886856, -0.103271484, 0.011444092, -0.01663208, -0.0126571655, -0.013328552, -0.005870819, -0.04309082, -0.0034046173, -0.03024292, 0.050079346, 0.04550171, 0.024093628, 0.0011491776, -0.025619507, 0.023086548, -0.044891357, -0.007949829, 0.0017795563, -0.044128418, 0.017059326, 0.013748169, 0.049682617, 0.04852295, -0.01965332, -0.031982422, 0.0063552856, 0.0016851425, 0.015533447, 0.0032215118, -0.048461914, 0.017044067, -0.0042877197, 0.011131287, 0.004360199, 0.018554688, 0.0014123917, 0.0005021095, -0.0014066696, -0.00818634, 0.04437256, 0.033050537, 0.029632568, 0.0016126633, -0.038726807, 0.012138367, -0.03692627, -0.05215454, 0.03857422, 0.0023708344, -0.019348145, 0.04711914, -0.028060913, -0.03479004, 0.015777588, -0.05331421, 0.0463562, 0.0035305023, 0.00003349781, 0.0006170273, 0.02168274, -0.018127441, 0.02027893, -0.036956787, -0.0027542114, 0.017623901, 0.001200676, -0.019485474, -0.06506348, 0.007297516, -0.0042915344, -0.12042236, -0.04260254, 0.021087646, -0.0143585205, 0.0049858093, -0.04864502, 0.04144287, -0.018630981, -0.007183075, 0.012397766, -0.014289856, -0.035705566, -0.020812988, -0.07183838, -0.025024414, 0.08807373, -0.007423401, 0.051879883, 0.026626587, -0.0035037994, -0.010353088, -0.040283203, -0.0026454926, -0.017791748, 0.030761719, -0.0051460266, -0.026687622, 0.046173096, -0.024230957, -0.0076675415, 0.03427124, 0.04269409, -0.038146973, -0.021987915, 0.014297485, 0.02154541, -0.03817749, 0.049224854, 0.023590088, -0.015777588, -0.059051514, 0.00868988, -0.028457642, -0.024093628, 0.025054932, 0.0072784424, 0.03253174, 0.018463135, -0.0027770996, 0.072631836, -0.009773254, 0.034210205, 0.049682617, -0.04550171, -0.01675415, 0.016693115, 0.042785645, 0.009933472, 0.008033752, 0.0018568039, -0.038726807, 0.027709961, -0.021240234, -0.0042915344, -0.0030326843, -0.003227234, -0.030410767, -0.028884888, -0.061767578, -0.058502197, -0.02470398, 0.0181427, 0.0033664703, 0.017822266, 0.042755127, 0.0017328262, -0.040618896, 0.01008606, 0.04437256, -0.019714355, 0.031402588, -0.058776855, 0.023376465, -0.014190674, -0.07885742, -0.04067993, -0.07519531, -0.0044898987, 0.011741638, 0.022827148, -0.02130127, 0.014350891, 0.018356323, 0.055419922, 0.0317688, 0.009468079, -0.027450562, 0.0635376, -0.01713562, -0.012550354, 0.017791748, 0.024017334, -0.0013942719, -0.010093689, 0.018539429, -0.029541016, 0.011688232, 0.013290405, 0.0023784637, -0.028167725, 0.030563354, -0.038909912, 0.03869629, 0.0020523071, 0.01335907, 0.027053833, 0.0077819824, -0.023376465, -0.036865234, 0.0340271, 0.048583984, -0.029678345, 0.025253296, 0.04196167, 0.0076446533, -0.025253296, 0.019485474, 0.016052246, 0.0413208, -0.01576233, -0.012237549, 0.0065727234, -0.024520874, -0.021408081, 0.027130127, -0.0007972717, 0.06500244, -0.015159607, 0.04095459, -0.01725769, 0.004840851, 0.012741089, -0.020355225, 0.01878357, -0.018615723, 0.016723633, -0.05029297, -0.020111084, 0.011009216, 0.020751953, -0.036468506, -0.0025482178, -0.02027893, 0.018325806, 0.0076065063, 0.026672363, 0.0044517517, 0.013710022, 0.0049858093, -0.011878967, -0.0054359436, -0.024291992, -0.02331543, 0.007156372, -0.0032806396, 0.01977539, -0.02218628, -0.014892578, -0.0602417, -0.021697998, 0.005455017, -0.015007019, 0.011230469, -0.09637451, -0.008514404, 0.017623901, 0.019119263, -0.010559082, -0.004337311, 0.00008392334, 0.02822876, 0.064941406, -0.01727295, 0.033111572, 0.03564453, -0.01864624, 0.009376526, 0.0051612854, 0.04446411, -0.000025331974, 0.013244629, 0.010688782, -0.01184845, -0.0569458, 0.023605347, 0.0155181885, 0.003019333, 0.02796936, -0.051757812, 0.0013475418, 0.017684937, 0.00001835823, 0.015701294, -0.01033783, -0.048095703, -0.028625488, 0.0006098747, -0.029693604, -0.010025024, 0.013885498, -0.028411865, -0.050323486, -0.008796692, -0.017242432, -0.012504578, -0.0015287399, 0.030654907, -0.019470215, 0.02532959, 0.027038574, -0.056121826, 0.01890564, -0.013427734, 0.021560669, 0.048858643, 0.013252258, -0.027282715, -0.0017719269, -0.006374359, -0.04977417, -0.042877197, 0.0082092285, -0.014572144, 0.019485474, -0.022521973, -0.017120361, -0.015365601, 0.0052108765, 0.009468079, 0.04827881, -0.050811768, 0.026855469, 0.0060424805, 0.0069465637, -0.0028629303, 0.025878906, 0.016784668, -0.008285522, -0.0007529259, -0.00705719, 0.02293396, -0.020584106, -0.03289795, 0.0029697418, -0.026473999, 0.014801025, 0.0015869141, -0.007205963, -0.027786255, 0.02078247, 0.031311035, -0.021057129, -0.003622055, 0.005432129, 0.07293701, -0.056884766, -0.05923462, -0.013130188, 0.0072135925, -0.018997192, 0.08087158, -0.03152466, -0.06878662, -0.03366089, -0.0501709, -0.030792236, 0.019226074, 0.060455322, 0.027420044, 0.0713501, -0.046691895, -0.010070801, -0.040161133, -0.0028953552, -0.013641357, 0.019088745, 0.0045433044, 0.032958984, -0.037750244, 0.0040740967, -0.017288208, -0.02154541, 0.022232056, 0.031036377, 0.005180359, 0.02180481, -0.06756592, -0.012680054, -0.049591064, -0.026107788, 0.020477295, 0.038391113, -0.042510986, 0.05645752, -0.018356323, 0.04650879, 0.00050735474, 0.0657959, 0.03744507, 0.014221191, 0.0005378723, -0.0032596588, 0.015106201, -0.04336548, 0.018997192, -0.083740234, -0.0020561218, -0.0637207, -0.0072364807, -0.04763794, -0.024917603, 0.020233154, 0.019088745, 0.018234253, 0.009529114, 0.04244995, -0.0017004013, 0.02583313, -0.040374756, 0.0368042, 0.0033245087, -0.018508911, -0.0064430237, 0.062683105, 0.009841919, 0.024993896, 0.02722168, 0.019363403, -0.037109375, -0.026626587, 0.010169983, -0.0028858185, 0.019134521, -0.028060913, -0.037628174, -0.046722412, 0.05105591, -0.004463196, 0.017822266, 0.06762695, 0.055847168, 0.01802063, -0.029022217, 0.012519836, 0.0015974045, -0.024261475, 0.007095337, 0.0519104, -0.07757568, 0.026184082, -0.016448975, -0.041625977, -0.04586792, 0.033203125, 0.026550293, -0.036132812, -0.013710022, 0.043182373, 0.034851074, 0.00023806095, 0.034454346, -0.04058838, -0.031433105, -0.0032176971, 0.015419006, -0.011779785, 0.0031394958, 0.02558899, 0.0569458, -0.014175415, 0.034576416, -0.021759033, 0.044006348, -0.056427002, 0.025024414, -0.080566406, -0.018508911, 0.007167816, -0.040924072, -0.012611389, 0.0026378632, -0.015625, -0.019546509, 0.010131836, 0.028076172, 0.05218506, 0.05606079, 0.0140686035, -0.015113831, 0.020446777, -0.05947876, 0.03793335, 0.047668457, -0.03250122, 0.01184845, -0.036346436, -0.041412354, 0.014289856, -0.050079346, 0.043884277, -0.046783447, -0.0062217712, -0.023849487, 0.018981934, 0.016418457, -0.053863525, -0.017501831, -0.043151855, -0.018234253, -0.013412476, 0.020736694, -0.0049362183, -0.0368042, 0.010551453, 0.03173828, 0.0067596436, 0.0143966675, 0.0116119385, -0.028320312, -0.057617188, 0.008728027, -0.012283325, 0.05166626, 0.0033874512, -0.004650116, -0.02458191, -0.008300781, -0.011230469, -0.025299072, -0.02609253, -0.029556274, -0.029251099, -0.029342651, 0.0037708282, 0.015304565, -0.024780273, 0.012916565, -0.0262146, 0.024734497, -0.014518738, -0.0011358261, 0.043884277, -0.027282715, -0.045166016, 0.005554199, -0.048675537, 0.030929565, -0.0015001297, -0.015205383, 0.009819031, 0.027572632, -0.023834229, -0.059783936, -0.029190063, -0.018814087, 0.0028972626, -0.031311035, -0.014694214, 0.033416748, 0.035095215, -0.05847168, -0.067993164, 0.010597229, 0.048034668, -0.009605408, 0.049346924, 0.028411865, 0.011367798, 0.004737854, 0.03918457, 0.0030288696, -0.04824829, -0.04815674, -0.021224976, 0.056610107, 0.055786133, -0.010635376, -0.01576233, 0.042144775, -0.009117126, 0.0051002502, 0.000046253204, -0.042907715, 0.013786316, -0.010101318, 0.016342163, 0.0016698837, 0.0063667297, 0.00036478043, 0.013420105, -0.01663208, 0.005584717, -0.0013885498, -0.000085771084, -0.01939392, 0.035736084, -0.008918762, -0.018478394, 0.043762207, 0.02166748, 0.017944336, 0.025299072, -0.012748718, -0.015945435, -0.011680603, 0.0003848076, -0.008514404, -0.008743286, 0.02204895, -0.008171082, 0.016418457, 0.0063438416, -0.03161621, -0.019897461, -0.053863525, 0.060333252, -0.020568848, -0.020614624, -0.0053482056, -0.023010254, 0.0011348724, 0.0146102905, -0.0025234222, -0.013946533, -0.043426514, -0.05404663, 0.027008057, -0.022918701 ], "summary": [ 0.01966858, -0.023773193, 0.034484863, 0.046142578, -0.026733398, -0.030563354, 0.06341553, -0.06854248, 0.01776123, 0.02168274, -0.02897644, 0.032958984, 0.050231934, -0.023757935, 0.042816162, 0.019638062, 0.012687683, -0.019226074, -0.02154541, -0.044433594, 0.0041885376, -0.04953003, 0.03338623, 0.087890625, 0.030685425, -0.05758667, -0.03475952, 0.031799316, 0.011436462, 0.010917664, 0.0067367554, -0.020187378, 0.015617371, 0.019683838, -0.024093628, 0.017547607, 0.014625549, -0.0009469986, 0.010383606, 0.01222229, 0.029769897, -0.013458252, 0.014671326, 0.01689148, 0.007255554, 0.004837036, 0.0054779053, -0.028320312, -0.0099487305, -0.04006958, 0.03314209, -0.06750488, 0.04916382, -0.06964111, -0.037384033, 0.0008969307, 0.05105591, -0.051849365, 0.026779175, -0.07501221, -0.042541504, -0.031204224, 0.085632324, 0.042541504, -0.04425049, -0.013717651, 0.0473938, 0.019683838, 0.07720947, -0.02859497, -0.027450562, 0.07348633, -0.0034656525, -0.012557983, 0.00008839369, 0.017333984, 0.011779785, -0.012664795, 0.00020515919, 0.01689148, 0.0020656586, 0.025665283, -0.034820557, -0.022567749, -0.02178955, -0.024841309, -0.011253357, -0.013069153, -0.036102295, -0.011871338, -0.03289795, -0.003479004, -0.043640137, 0.010017395, 0.015960693, -0.038360596, -0.012817383, -0.021057129, 0.025878906, 0.01309967, 0.009353638, -0.040252686, 0.023986816, -0.017364502, -0.022888184, 0.061706543, 0.022994995, 0.04598999, 0.009460449, 0.009010315, 0.0037460327, -0.04812622, -0.0013446808, -0.054229736, -0.019012451, 0.031982422, 0.016998291, -0.007217407, 0.026138306, -0.016540527, -0.06524658, -0.032562256, -0.010856628, 0.07318115, 0.02355957, 0.044281006, 0.024139404, 0.015312195, 0.029678345, 0.0099105835, -0.026062012, -0.00053167343, 0.005126953, -0.0010786057, -0.0101623535, -0.0030593872, 0.04647827, -0.01991272, 0.040649414, -0.040039062, 0.052093506, 0.017791748, 0.002790451, 0.059143066, 0.009719849, 0.007041931, 0.032592773, 0.0065231323, -0.01953125, -0.01071167, 0.012504578, -0.016098022, 0.028518677, -0.0262146, -0.02017212, -0.06921387, -0.019454956, -0.019897461, 0.0413208, -0.029464722, 0.016967773, 0.0057907104, -0.010902405, 0.06903076, 0.09210205, -0.028549194, 0.03543091, 0.028640747, 0.01134491, 0.0059661865, -0.010047913, -0.019454956, 0.000500679, -0.0013399124, -0.01928711, 0.02607727, -0.0033435822, 0.066101074, -0.01751709, -0.029678345, -0.003824234, -0.0519104, 0.037719727, 0.0019550323, 0.032043457, -0.03668213, -0.011146545, -0.03012085, 0.018753052, 0.0116119385, -0.03894043, 0.020736694, -0.01008606, -0.0178833, -0.04147339, 0.00009024143, -0.033966064, 0.033691406, -0.0423584, 0.024383545, 0.034606934, -0.041015625, 0.04046631, -0.048065186, -0.019439697, -0.023666382, -0.019851685, 0.017227173, -0.055480957, 0.013916016, 0.044006348, -0.017990112, -0.025756836, 0.014533997, 0.03491211, -0.0015506744, 0.037963867, -0.009849548, -0.009712219, -0.017868042, -0.023391724, -0.024871826, -0.040374756, 0.05996704, 0.0043678284, -0.012702942, -0.015571594, -0.029678345, 0.043151855, -0.015167236, 0.03744507, 0.025344849, 0.015159607, 0.064697266, 0.017868042, 0.013053894, 0.031341553, -0.05078125, 0.017349243, 0.0068206787, 0.014923096, 0.0021095276, 0.00793457, 0.06378174, -0.046203613, -0.06088257, 0.005542755, 0.02355957, 0.012863159, 0.054473877, 0.015388489, -0.0071640015, 0.00806427, 0.007019043, 0.016586304, 0.010322571, -0.02935791, -0.03994751, 0.0036067963, -0.000500679, 0.005004883, -0.010124207, -0.0066070557, -0.0004658699, 0.030578613, 0.0076179504, 0.026473999, 0.038909912, 0.0036354065, 0.0004105568, -0.0053710938, -0.033172607, -0.019073486, -0.014823914, -0.015419006, 0.005367279, -0.03768921, 0.020492554, 0.013870239, -0.01448822, -0.009063721, -0.012672424, -0.05142212, -0.01335907, 0.049804688, 0.03479004, -0.021835327, 0.005718231, 0.0021419525, 0.025970459, 0.061584473, 0.0098724365, 0.00548172, -0.009262085, 0.011383057, -0.0178833, -0.002746582, 0.069885254, -0.021102905, -0.001625061, -0.044647217, -0.007511139, -0.024520874, -0.029266357, -0.0043411255, 0.038085938, 0.013664246, 0.005718231, 0.007949829, 0.0032444, -0.050109863, 0.012641907, 0.012184143, 0.04611206, -0.019927979, -0.03024292, -0.01953125, 0.027755737, -0.024291992, -0.00016570091, -0.017089844, 0.020309448, -0.044189453, 0.017959595, -0.008743286, -0.0053253174, 0.025100708, -0.009590149, 0.015571594, 0.009773254, 0.05053711, 0.06341553, 0.037261963, 0.027236938, 0.0062675476, -0.0317688, -0.008529663, 0.053131104, -0.0023612976, -0.034301758, -0.01159668, 0.02809143, -0.011329651, 0.005542755, -0.034851074, 0.004310608, 0.027053833, -0.007888794, 0.0023937225, 0.015853882, -0.004386902, -0.028030396, -0.04458618, -0.014335632, -0.017181396, 0.0151901245, 0.032440186, -0.021560669, 0.015342712, -0.052825928, 0.036224365, -0.008483887, -0.034942627, -0.095458984, 0.038848877, -0.01146698, -0.01096344, -0.07513428, -0.010269165, 0.0017051697, -0.03387451, -0.003610611, 0.008552551, -0.024291992, -0.022033691, 0.033447266, 0.08911133, 0.032684326, 0.00068569183, 0.06008911, 0.043029785, 0.049346924, -0.033050537, 0.029037476, 0.08117676, -0.0116119385, 0.027404785, 0.027175903, 0.049804688, -0.0057373047, -0.0033283234, -0.037231445, 0.028945923, -0.001206398, 0.027038574, -0.017593384, -0.031311035, 0.043518066, -0.095458984, 0.006290436, -0.017166138, 0.0435791, 0.011665344, -0.009735107, -0.0284729, 0.0345459, -0.02229309, -0.04135132, 0.004371643, 0.080566406, -0.0043754578, -0.03463745, 0.022338867, -0.027374268, 0.01890564, 0.025894165, 0.013031006, 0.0066184998, -0.037231445, -0.013290405, 0.004852295, 0.057159424, 0.0074310303, 0.01374054, 0.0025539398, 0.046447754, 0.022735596, 0.013618469, -0.024398804, -0.02696228, 0.024475098, -0.043548584, -0.013160706, 0.05267334, -0.0132369995, 0.07952881, 0.026504517, -0.0035190582, 0.070495605, -0.053344727, -0.011169434, 0.015701294, 0.00055885315, -0.031066895, -0.0105896, -0.012207031, 0.04736328, 0.015396118, 0.012619019, 0.017196655, 0.037628174, -0.0012292862, 0.045135498, 0.007335663, -0.014015198, 0.023117065, -0.0079956055, 0.039489746, 0.05718994, -0.06774902, -0.020568848, -0.028198242, -0.030532837, 0.019500732, -0.00051021576, -0.037261963, 0.021636963, -0.026931763, -0.0368042, 0.028823853, -0.05456543, 0.051574707, -0.0076522827, -0.015205383, -0.00007760525, -0.04043579, 0.020217896, 0.009742737, 0.029708862, -0.025344849, -0.016204834, 0.017471313, -0.036254883, -0.02960205, 0.0013198853, -0.0004005432, -0.047424316, -0.04324341, 0.0155181885, 0.028076172, 0.046325684, -0.017120361, 0.067993164, -0.010810852, 0.008277893, -0.010536194, -0.041259766, 0.055419922, -0.0037250519, -0.0690918, 0.045928955, -0.02545166, 0.03137207, 0.0390625, -0.00054359436, 0.028808594, 0.056152344, -0.005466461, -0.011360168, 0.0104599, 0.020431519, -0.024414062, -0.0084991455, 0.0184021, -0.023620605, 0.00013589859, 0.04434204, 0.028961182, -0.0071868896, -0.015274048, 0.04107666, 0.046813965, -0.036254883, -0.0069999695, 0.066833496, -0.0042915344, -0.04562378, 0.02911377, -0.034942627, -0.053741455, 0.023757935, 0.039489746, 0.008453369, 0.041137695, -0.0076026917, 0.022109985, -0.0016593933, 0.03314209, 0.03010559, -0.018539429, -0.034454346, -0.0002834797, 0.036132812, 0.008132935, -0.02142334, 0.0036258698, -0.05203247, 0.022155762, -0.04031372, 0.0069351196, -0.0019798279, -0.0105896, -0.0025196075, -0.03668213, -0.025482178, -0.02835083, -0.020401001, 0.003074646, 0.024017334, 0.02861023, 0.015716553, 0.0015716553, -0.0075302124, -0.0040512085, 0.08856201, -0.013656616, 0.033081055, -0.06210327, -0.015563965, -0.013061523, -0.049468994, -0.023757935, -0.0892334, -0.036346436, -0.026687622, 0.018997192, -0.0043182373, 0.027038574, 0.023376465, 0.06585693, 0.008110046, 0.02128601, -0.029266357, 0.07055664, -0.019165039, 0.024475098, -0.026504517, 0.013542175, -0.007434845, 0.01739502, 0.031555176, -0.01852417, 0.0077323914, 0.03656006, -0.011131287, -0.02746582, 0.019241333, -0.056549072, 0.015426636, -0.025680542, 0.023223877, 0.019958496, -0.006855011, -0.015838623, -0.0027599335, 0.039154053, 0.05206299, -0.016403198, 0.027267456, 0.033172607, -0.01914978, -0.0814209, 0.03765869, 0.043182373, 0.037994385, -0.013450623, 0.01486969, -0.033599854, 0.039031982, 0.0052833557, 0.05545044, -0.0029716492, 0.036315918, 0.051086426, 0.0036773682, 0.012458801, -0.033355713, 0.046905518, -0.006336212, -0.008850098, 0.044311523, -0.025863647, -0.02961731, -0.00868988, -0.0019311905, 0.024993896, -0.01902771, -0.039031982, -0.06567383, -0.023208618, -0.0067100525, -0.020751953, -0.050689697, 0.031173706, -0.0066184998, -0.008842468, -0.0059165955, -0.011260986, -0.0028209686, -0.022384644, -0.028015137, 0.004470825, 0.008766174, -0.027786255, 0.03050232, -0.03488159, 0.005443573, 0.0011529922, 0.0063552856, -0.042663574, -0.058654785, -0.010902405, 0.0037212372, -0.034118652, 0.022338867, -0.013534546, 0.0053749084, 0.057647705, -0.046569824, 0.022415161, 0.0018615723, 0.03692627, -0.020324707, -0.0015487671, 0.01739502, -0.0057868958, -0.034118652, 0.012046814, -0.051971436, -0.006378174, -0.00058460236, 0.026351929, 0.002462387, 0.008117676, -0.024993896, 0.02709961, 0.013313293, 0.010032654, -0.009422302, -0.004524231, -0.03994751, -0.013534546, 0.018722534, -0.010139465, -0.015090942, 0.019256592, -0.0066184998, -0.03189087, -0.03552246, -0.02178955, -0.028564453, 0.00712204, 0.06439209, 0.028900146, -0.017150879, -0.017868042, -0.012687683, 0.011741638, -0.00274086, 0.02848816, -0.010421753, -0.011199951, -0.023483276, -0.00078725815, -0.02645874, -0.045013428, -0.028930664, -0.026245117, -0.0010156631, 0.06774902, -0.023376465, 0.03555298, 0.014457703, -0.008712769, 0.0154800415, 0.03338623, -0.070007324, 0.008926392, -0.004425049, -0.019897461, 0.010276794, 0.0032653809, -0.021392822, 0.0017719269, 0.015541077, 0.020568848, 0.015655518, -0.013847351, -0.03616333, -0.0017709732, -0.01424408, 0.013404846, 0.0033912659, 0.000021636486, 0.010353088, -0.012306213, 0.019515991, -0.025817871, 0.009757996, 0.0043563843, 0.06262207, -0.050689697, -0.0692749, -0.04663086, 0.004096985, -0.024963379, 0.042510986, -0.04675293, -0.07928467, 0.009284973, -0.04232788, -0.005077362, -0.015777588, 0.039886475, 0.040222168, 0.06616211, -0.0057792664, -0.02670288, -0.01235199, -0.001909256, 0.025497437, -0.0022029877, 0.015525818, 0.051696777, -0.006401062, 0.014137268, -0.016998291, 0.024291992, -0.006210327, 0.022155762, -0.004863739, 0.024627686, -0.03753662, -0.009780884, -0.033813477, 0.023651123, -0.0047721863, 0.06365967, -0.009780884, -0.0009059906, 0.0072631836, 0.029571533, 0.00087690353, 0.016616821, -0.0048179626, -0.010368347, 0.009925842, -0.0035858154, 0.028549194, -0.026870728, 0.039855957, -0.03945923, -0.030380249, -0.04031372, -0.044799805, 0.010551453, -0.0033607483, 0.0013990402, -0.038635254, 0.052520752, 0.0014486313, 0.05126953, 0.036010742, -0.02796936, -0.04107666, -0.02508545, -0.00022768974, -0.019042969, 0.006389618, 0.045684814, -0.017196655, 0.021316528, 0.027420044, 0.014205933, -0.015434265, -0.014007568, 0.029464722, -0.0034866333, -0.020141602, -0.07757568, -0.00447464, -0.06878662, 0.052581787, 0.010421753, 0.0149002075, 0.05545044, 0.024810791, 0.030578613, -0.03451538, 0.031082153, 0.026626587, -0.033599854, 0.035583496, 0.024673462, -0.050201416, 0.004699707, 0.011734009, -0.029037476, -0.029205322, 0.027130127, 0.06707764, -0.010520935, 0.022415161, 0.046203613, 0.012321472, -0.050567627, 0.0047721863, -0.03152466, -0.03704834, -0.0075416565, -0.019836426, 0.0011835098, -0.0039405823, 0.008224487, 0.023071289, 0.016815186, 0.099365234, -0.040100098, 0.08526611, -0.06036377, 0.0057640076, -0.09887695, -0.05041504, 0.002729416, -0.015853882, -0.024230957, 0.022994995, -0.007160187, 0.010284424, 0.0049476624, 0.024353027, 0.061279297, 0.028549194, -0.019592285, 0.012512207, 0.034820557, -0.045166016, 0.036132812, 0.0072746277, -0.00047636032, -0.0019254684, -0.015205383, 0.0011396408, -0.01991272, -0.0033512115, 0.003479004, -0.017791748, 0.0033569336, -0.03302002, 0.013549805, -0.039093018, -0.0064353943, 0.01826477, -0.058898926, -0.013931274, 0.006454468, 0.029449463, -0.030319214, 0.024169922, -0.015380859, -0.029693604, 0.0030536652, 0.013153076, 0.035308838, -0.023513794, -0.016189575, 0.015327454, 0.019210815, 0.06762695, 0.032318115, -0.02947998, -0.024642944, 0.019256592, -0.002029419, -0.030227661, -0.0031204224, 0.0032024384, -0.019241333, -0.035186768, 0.020385742, 0.01612854, -0.023284912, -0.0063667297, -0.012207031, 0.010391235, -0.0022583008, 0.0158844, 0.059661865, 0.029006958, -0.07696533, -0.0048599243, -0.033996582, 0.005317688, -0.037231445, 0.0023097992, 0.015609741, 0.035125732, -0.01084137, -0.042633057, -0.014259338, -0.028747559, 0.0138549805, -0.0025749207, -0.023086548, 0.008575439, 0.018127441, -0.050933838, -0.061309814, -0.022628784, 0.01461792, 0.019332886, 0.010253906, -0.0041389465, 0.014122009, -0.010093689, 0.024215698, -0.012832642, -0.013824463, -0.030166626, -0.0005145073, 0.081970215, 0.0134887695, -0.045928955, 0.02305603, 0.026550293, -0.045318604, -0.016159058, -0.0038967133, -0.035491943, -0.03805542, -0.01096344, -0.037597656, -0.019927979, 0.006641388, 0.030517578, 0.0085372925, -0.024475098, -0.029953003, 0.022140503, -0.015090942, -0.0345459, 0.0021419525, 0.0064468384, -0.013267517, 0.016830444, -0.0037117004, 0.020065308, -0.009895325, 0.033599854, -0.03050232, -0.02015686, -0.00085544586, -0.0206604, -0.014633179, 0.02482605, -0.006385803, 0.008911133, 0.0569458, -0.01852417, -0.043151855, -0.05215454, 0.04058838, 0.033966064, -0.013580322, 0.056274414, 0.02482605, 0.033111572, -0.024917603, -0.015052795, 0.048858643, -0.021347046, -0.03778076, -0.07269287, -0.010398865 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2104.04076v1
An artificial intelligence and Internet of things based automated irrigation system
Ömer Aydin, Cem Ali Kandemir, Umut Kiraç, Feriştah Dalkiliç
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.LG
It is not hard to see that the need for clean water is growing by considering the decrease of the water sources day by day in the world. Potable fresh water is also used for irrigation, so it should be planned to decrease freshwater wastage. With the development of technology and the availability of cheaper and more effective solutions, the efficiency of irrigation increased and the water loss can be reduced. In particular, Internet of things (IoT) devices has begun to be used in all areas. We can easily and precisely collect temperature, humidity and mineral values from the irrigation field with the IoT devices and sensors. Most of the operations and decisions about irrigation are carried out by people. For people, it is hard to have all the real-time data such as temperature, moisture and mineral levels in the decision-making process and make decisions by considering them. People usually make decisions with their experience. In this study, a wide range of information from the irrigation field was obtained by using IoT devices and sensors. Data collected from IoT devices and sensors sent via communication channels and stored on MongoDB. With the help of Weka software, the data was normalized and the normalized data was used as a learning set. As a result of the examinations, a decision tree (J48) algorithm with the highest accuracy was chosen and an artificial intelligence model was created. Decisions are used to manage operations such as starting, maintaining and stopping the irrigation. The accuracy of the decisions was evaluated and the irrigation system was tested with the results. There are options to manage, view the system remotely and manually and also see the system s decisions with the created mobile application.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2104.04076v1
"2021-04-01T21:05:26"
"2021-04-01T21:05:26"
{ "title": [ -0.0132369995, 0.013549805, -0.03756714, -0.030899048, 0.013023376, -0.022872925, 0.013427734, 0.0014925003, -0.015670776, 0.037109375, -0.05529785, 0.0059013367, 0.023071289, -0.019317627, -0.018844604, -0.017532349, 0.0022029877, 0.01713562, -0.015914917, -0.032470703, 0.023361206, -0.04067993, 0.008583069, 0.06768799, -0.013809204, 0.0052337646, -0.087524414, 0.001282692, -0.05596924, -0.042785645, -0.030395508, 0.057556152, 0.042175293, -0.006500244, -0.0054969788, 0.026107788, -0.039398193, 0.017349243, -0.008766174, 0.0056533813, 0.020095825, -0.004146576, -0.055877686, -0.0075149536, -0.05493164, 0.009880066, -0.056152344, -0.0017414093, -0.010932922, 0.054473877, 0.00003170967, -0.010551453, -0.014129639, 0.047821045, -0.0030231476, -0.04232788, 0.0046195984, -0.033355713, 0.043395996, -0.013694763, -0.025741577, -0.03778076, 0.0619812, 0.006477356, -0.013771057, -0.029678345, -0.00043535233, 0.03555298, 0.026870728, -0.013572693, 0.0074920654, 0.029449463, -0.006462097, 0.036590576, -0.036834717, -0.063964844, 0.048217773, 0.004711151, 0.037597656, 0.02104187, -0.019744873, -0.03314209, 0.012939453, -0.032043457, 0.0103302, -0.025100708, -0.016967773, 0.0034065247, -0.055725098, -0.05065918, -0.020019531, 0.009407043, -0.047546387, 0.0017595291, -0.02305603, -0.023635864, -0.0127334595, 0.02809143, 0.005836487, 0.0032901764, -0.026870728, 0.010009766, -0.021850586, -0.024032593, 0.011688232, 0.03692627, 0.020843506, -0.018310547, -0.0019817352, 0.005001068, -0.010597229, 0.0109939575, 0.02784729, 0.011497498, -0.041046143, -0.030578613, -0.011169434, -0.026062012, -0.0005841255, -0.0007405281, -0.018188477, -0.02281189, 0.011291504, 0.022354126, 0.009338379, 0.0009236336, -0.027267456, 0.014785767, 0.048095703, 0.008224487, -0.016204834, 0.06756592, -0.06311035, -0.09429932, -0.048980713, 0.031280518, 0.015960693, 0.019592285, -0.0070495605, 0.0026340485, 0.026382446, -0.025436401, -0.013450623, 0.042510986, -0.022384644, -0.00983429, 0.03189087, 0.007331848, -0.03012085, -0.040649414, -0.04119873, 0.00881958, 0.0098724365, 0.014724731, -0.015670776, 0.0049819946, -0.058746338, -0.021484375, 0.015853882, 0.005027771, 0.02960205, 0.0006251335, -0.020339966, -0.00031495094, 0.036987305, -0.0028057098, -0.028137207, 0.021713257, 0.006538391, 0.004180908, 0.0009455681, -0.003332138, 0.032043457, -0.022415161, -0.008071899, -0.0022621155, 0.021118164, 0.0052375793, 0.004878998, 0.000059366226, -0.005973816, -0.017532349, 0.010871887, 0.027404785, -0.046813965, -0.0054092407, -0.023513794, -0.002822876, 0.064819336, 0.0005207062, -0.07006836, 0.0059318542, -0.048431396, -0.027786255, -0.02746582, -0.0044441223, 0.0033359528, 0.025939941, -0.0078086853, 0.010635376, -0.08673096, 0.014404297, -0.0262146, 0.044952393, 0.04711914, -0.03778076, 0.011817932, 0.01725769, -0.015914917, 0.054626465, 0.0309906, -0.013389587, -0.01348114, -0.028930664, -0.013168335, -0.04598999, 0.005630493, -0.020111084, -0.020523071, -0.03527832, -0.032104492, -0.017456055, -0.012107849, 0.02822876, 0.0104522705, 0.025756836, -0.0038967133, -0.0013380051, 0.07281494, 0.03253174, 0.119262695, -0.037902832, 0.039123535, -0.0033016205, -0.035125732, -0.025314331, -0.03616333, -0.043121338, -0.0026435852, 0.047729492, 0.011199951, -0.037597656, 0.0104522705, 0.049957275, 0.0014066696, -0.036987305, 0.004875183, 0.029403687, 0.035003662, 0.020019531, 0.0317688, 0.014320374, 0.0769043, 0.020950317, -0.015266418, 0.08227539, -0.016281128, 0.030960083, -0.01927185, 0.009506226, 0.0011234283, 0.0019378662, 0.026397705, -0.017288208, -0.03515625, 0.036468506, -0.009918213, 0.029510498, -0.0340271, 0.03753662, 0.047180176, 0.018920898, -0.0032215118, -0.005973816, 0.000998497, -0.04083252, -0.009262085, 0.031036377, -0.012481689, -0.045776367, -0.006996155, -0.009681702, 0.02645874, 0.008964539, 0.01576233, 0.018875122, 0.034057617, 0.022338867, -0.027572632, -0.0011644363, 0.042175293, 0.054229736, 0.023605347, -0.010444641, 0.01651001, 0.016952515, 0.03591919, 0.09899902, -0.039611816, 0.02658081, -0.103881836, -0.021713257, 0.001791954, -0.04071045, 0.010025024, 0.00092458725, 0.010765076, 0.00712204, -0.016479492, 0.03817749, -0.090026855, 0.021484375, -0.00022757053, -0.024963379, -0.01940918, -0.03439331, -0.022903442, -0.027236938, -0.028884888, 0.008369446, 0.010940552, 0.010757446, -0.022094727, -0.02218628, 0.018615723, -0.013015747, -0.07183838, -0.005340576, -0.04763794, 0.012062073, 0.03567505, 0.012176514, -0.04244995, 0.049102783, 0.013656616, 0.027832031, -0.004085541, 0.018920898, -0.009063721, -0.02532959, 0.0039138794, -0.000603199, -0.0058059692, -0.021560669, 0.033294678, -0.043182373, -0.022064209, 0.013343811, -0.02432251, 0.007537842, 0.009208679, -0.008453369, -0.022094727, 0.016998291, 0.039489746, -0.08178711, -0.005634308, 0.005420685, -0.022216797, -0.029464722, 0.017059326, 0.030822754, -0.0010852814, -0.03378296, 0.012313843, -0.05999756, -0.020568848, 0.0101623535, -0.036010742, 0.007167816, -0.053466797, -0.055480957, -0.0076675415, 0.004180908, -0.012573242, 0.036102295, -0.0065574646, -0.0362854, -0.016540527, -0.025009155, 0.029724121, 0.029937744, -0.004173279, 0.008468628, 0.07879639, -0.0005173683, -0.008529663, 0.007736206, 0.057250977, 0.0056495667, -0.0044136047, -0.031158447, -0.047576904, 0.0018177032, 0.03842163, 0.017089844, -0.019927979, 0.014678955, -0.1194458, -0.0064430237, 0.0057640076, -0.0004234314, -0.023132324, 0.03527832, -0.059143066, 0.027923584, -0.008666992, -0.027404785, 0.018692017, 0.03552246, -0.015579224, 0.014579773, 0.005882263, -0.019714355, 0.012519836, -0.015686035, -0.08581543, 0.029769897, -0.003326416, -0.027526855, -0.031036377, 0.008369446, -0.040802002, -0.0069618225, -0.03466797, 0.038238525, 0.033813477, 0.037750244, -0.0017652512, -0.015777588, 0.0031986237, -0.037384033, 0.01210022, -0.036590576, -0.06021118, -0.038024902, -0.033111572, 0.056884766, 0.009651184, -0.0034809113, -0.012298584, 0.007396698, -0.031921387, 0.015792847, -0.005077362, -0.046783447, 0.0033245087, -0.026611328, -0.0018644333, -0.033325195, 0.018814087, 0.015174866, 0.028396606, -0.0068092346, -0.0052757263, 0.02923584, 0.01033783, 0.027770996, -0.01638794, -0.019592285, 0.015274048, -0.021011353, -0.046020508, 0.01449585, -0.0007300377, -0.01020813, 0.051940918, 0.0048332214, -0.008285522, 0.003332138, -0.022537231, 0.03289795, -0.006832123, -0.013175964, -0.0026988983, -0.015083313, -0.02456665, 0.0031394958, -0.0056037903, 0.0076675415, -0.04083252, 0.024215698, -0.05545044, -0.03366089, -0.027770996, 0.012481689, -0.0473938, -0.030471802, 0.022766113, -0.029312134, -0.048461914, -0.056518555, 0.02128601, -0.035888672, -0.016479492, 0.017562866, -0.0030136108, -0.023651123, 0.0013532639, -0.04473877, -0.070617676, 0.0803833, -0.016204834, -0.0048103333, 0.0071105957, 0.02885437, 0.0047073364, -0.004878998, 0.01159668, -0.02104187, 0.03062439, -0.029876709, -0.0082473755, 0.042236328, -0.035308838, 0.019958496, -0.010696411, 0.0134887695, -0.036834717, 0.019104004, 0.012298584, 0.0048179626, -0.032928467, 0.045806885, 0.051452637, -0.023422241, -0.07318115, 0.0047340393, -0.012542725, -0.008377075, 0.011955261, -0.019683838, 0.025314331, 0.015388489, 0.010276794, 0.040618896, -0.011489868, 0.015808105, 0.022598267, -0.05126953, -0.02243042, 0.004760742, 0.031585693, -0.01309967, -0.0049362183, 0.0058174133, -0.030441284, 0.0657959, -0.03942871, 0.012817383, 0.00856781, 0.0063056946, 0.0024261475, -0.020584106, -0.066711426, -0.007247925, 0.0019235611, 0.002708435, -0.02355957, 0.0050735474, 0.04559326, -0.013336182, -0.0592041, 0.027862549, 0.0030059814, -0.023345947, 0.019256592, -0.050567627, -0.01020813, -0.009559631, -0.101257324, -0.03842163, -0.02670288, 0.030380249, -0.010383606, 0.0016031265, -0.02041626, 0.03439331, 0.0121536255, 0.045166016, 0.062316895, 0.0013380051, -0.070739746, 0.08868408, -0.008300781, -0.015640259, -0.012939453, 0.025543213, -0.0036144257, -0.03253174, 0.0055656433, -0.022415161, -0.0034809113, -0.025634766, 0.026473999, -0.024383545, 0.04547119, -0.011192322, 0.039276123, 0.015327454, 0.01210022, 0.046783447, 0.0104904175, -0.030792236, -0.021362305, 0.023498535, 0.05709839, -0.022354126, -0.0044822693, 0.04321289, 0.02748108, 0.002527237, -0.015617371, 0.011169434, 0.012130737, -0.0013914108, -0.0076065063, 0.037139893, -0.009635925, -0.029907227, 0.013305664, 0.0038433075, 0.044555664, -0.019882202, 0.032836914, -0.02758789, -0.0063934326, -0.0037021637, -0.020309448, 0.010437012, -0.029556274, 0.027450562, -0.06359863, -0.011451721, -0.011360168, 0.03390503, -0.045196533, -0.0104599, -0.026550293, -0.0068206787, -0.0031852722, 0.03967285, -0.0340271, 0.008705139, 0.040740967, -0.0046539307, -0.006801605, -0.029205322, -0.02911377, -0.0046463013, -0.023666382, 0.014480591, -0.016448975, 0.017532349, -0.033813477, 0.0035762787, 0.012527466, 0.001824379, -0.00010955334, -0.054351807, 0.036193848, 0.04852295, -0.009277344, 0.011474609, 0.009666443, 0.01689148, 0.028671265, 0.060668945, -0.01725769, 0.046722412, 0.023880005, -0.041870117, 0.024032593, 0.014274597, 0.023330688, 0.038848877, 0.008628845, 0.0023155212, 0.011680603, -0.013015747, 0.021194458, 0.012008667, 0.018844604, 0.034851074, -0.048614502, 0.033050537, 0.012649536, -0.028549194, -0.0018119812, -0.032714844, -0.038757324, 0.024917603, -0.036376953, 0.00982666, -0.008361816, -0.012893677, -0.008049011, -0.04776001, 0.039642334, -0.0206604, -0.017990112, 0.004650116, 0.03479004, -0.005332947, 0.037017822, 0.0423584, -0.04058838, -0.023895264, 0.019042969, 0.029022217, 0.03564453, 0.009422302, -0.027694702, 0.007965088, -0.021591187, -0.049194336, -0.03338623, -0.0011758804, -0.0010766983, 0.019927979, -0.0009212494, -0.04940796, -0.017532349, 0.005203247, 0.017654419, 0.013008118, -0.024398804, 0.031951904, -0.01638794, -0.022918701, 0.0053100586, 0.03161621, 0.024291992, -0.01687622, 0.004425049, -0.05001831, 0.00630188, -0.009971619, -0.015541077, -0.008178711, -0.019470215, 0.0031967163, 0.01965332, 0.01689148, -0.024734497, 0.025299072, 0.032104492, -0.01878357, -0.004135132, 0.011642456, 0.07098389, -0.050628662, -0.07824707, -0.022964478, -0.019821167, -0.03289795, 0.072753906, -0.019134521, -0.08111572, -0.025985718, -0.039886475, -0.03366089, 0.011131287, 0.05331421, 0.013122559, 0.073791504, -0.05038452, -0.017623901, -0.025878906, 0.020507812, -0.011520386, 0.011253357, 0.010414124, 0.056365967, -0.041778564, -0.0006914139, -0.035888672, 0.021072388, 0.051971436, 0.033172607, -0.008163452, 0.023483276, -0.03753662, -0.0051841736, -0.03665161, -0.013519287, 0.052703857, 0.011795044, -0.010124207, 0.07055664, -0.040527344, 0.0491333, 0.010047913, 0.03265381, 0.054595947, 0.031021118, -0.007156372, -0.006549835, -0.011650085, -0.025497437, -0.026550293, -0.049713135, -0.04522705, -0.037841797, -0.012504578, -0.074645996, -0.029342651, 0.015304565, 0.019485474, 0.01966858, 0.0056762695, 0.0390625, -0.015930176, 0.03540039, -0.046875, 0.0501709, -0.025863647, -0.009094238, -0.01737976, -0.01737976, 0.031188965, 0.04019165, -0.0041275024, 0.022979736, -0.011329651, -0.011116028, 0.0071029663, -0.00044488907, 0.027786255, -0.026306152, -0.017288208, -0.01826477, 0.06210327, 0.009819031, 0.034454346, 0.062438965, 0.06890869, -0.053833008, -0.008430481, 0.016815186, 0.008552551, -0.026565552, 0.00078725815, 0.05429077, -0.06427002, 0.021911621, -0.03414917, -0.035308838, -0.027877808, 0.013008118, 0.027664185, -0.05307007, -0.026733398, 0.03353882, 0.024108887, -0.013244629, 0.02973938, -0.047302246, -0.02960205, -0.006881714, 0.013961792, -0.027786255, -0.015007019, 0.014320374, 0.054656982, 0.008110046, 0.022705078, -0.009773254, 0.028015137, -0.02897644, 0.022125244, -0.035186768, 0.019256592, -0.011039734, -0.05606079, 0.01979065, -0.006767273, -0.009117126, -0.02180481, 0.023162842, 0.0019607544, 0.03781128, 0.036834717, 0.02909851, -0.00982666, -0.024337769, -0.047698975, 0.019515991, 0.04763794, -0.017410278, 0.010955811, -0.030395508, -0.024307251, 0.011779785, 0.011512756, 0.05996704, -0.01109314, 0.0023860931, -0.023376465, 0.002046585, 0.026748657, -0.029891968, -0.015304565, -0.026306152, -0.001876831, -0.02545166, -0.020324707, -0.024032593, -0.010360718, -0.008865356, 0.03186035, 0.01399231, 0.016342163, 0.028320312, -0.055541992, -0.043762207, 0.023986816, 0.019592285, 0.03353882, 0.024459839, -0.004852295, 0.012184143, -0.002817154, -0.013587952, -0.049438477, -0.022384644, -0.03250122, -0.0019035339, -0.033813477, 0.0262146, 0.027511597, -0.018692017, -0.022201538, -0.007030487, -0.010025024, -0.017105103, -0.021347046, 0.001584053, -0.05618286, 0.0020599365, -0.0025024414, -0.04486084, 0.028625488, 0.049102783, -0.007160187, -0.0032157898, 0.045013428, -0.014251709, -0.03277588, -0.01586914, 0.005886078, -0.011146545, 0.0015172958, -0.04434204, 0.052337646, 0.02923584, -0.08258057, -0.06628418, -0.02571106, 0.058044434, -0.020004272, 0.058258057, -0.016830444, 0.0021362305, 0.044921875, 0.077819824, 0.014694214, -0.061523438, -0.0440979, -0.032684326, 0.030593872, 0.03186035, -0.017730713, -0.00920105, 0.03262329, -0.0054130554, 0.030395508, 0.010772705, -0.012840271, 0.024429321, -0.011131287, 0.037261963, -0.0046043396, -0.011131287, 0.00579834, 0.034088135, -0.010169983, 0.008621216, -0.02178955, 0.019454956, -0.0017566681, 0.023101807, -0.0007801056, -0.1104126, 0.08544922, 0.06976318, 0.0035877228, 0.075683594, -0.007423401, -0.06427002, -0.021133423, 0.01701355, 0.012161255, 0.019195557, 0.0017185211, 0.030059814, 0.02168274, -0.0034275055, -0.021514893, -0.049102783, -0.047821045, 0.053833008, -0.03778076, -0.007133484, -0.048309326, -0.022354126, 0.01701355, 0.000992775, 0.031036377, 0.0009946823, -0.045928955, -0.004447937, 0.02368164, -0.017654419 ], "summary": [ 0.0093307495, -0.00021135807, -0.020431519, -0.015350342, 0.009887695, -0.021331787, 0.018554688, -0.014953613, 0.03366089, 0.022094727, -0.058502197, 0.006401062, 0.021957397, -0.0050621033, -0.012878418, -0.030151367, -0.015388489, 0.041107178, 0.016296387, -0.0061950684, 0.009803772, -0.007698059, -0.060455322, 0.022872925, -0.014328003, 0.021102905, -0.0814209, 0.0143585205, -0.06500244, -0.010292053, -0.036346436, 0.051971436, 0.032348633, -0.027648926, 0.030334473, 0.03173828, 0.013046265, -0.014770508, -0.011405945, 0.030517578, 0.03262329, -0.009384155, -0.005126953, -0.05166626, 0.0032405853, -0.0079574585, 0.020309448, -0.035247803, 0.008140564, 0.030197144, -0.004245758, -0.0045814514, -0.0064582825, 0.012992859, -0.023361206, 0.0030441284, 0.05215454, -0.08459473, 0.023284912, -0.028533936, -0.025817871, -0.019119263, 0.052459717, 0.021331787, -0.027053833, 0.0010118484, 0.0814209, 0.0070114136, 0.017547607, -0.019515991, 0.012672424, 0.045959473, 0.001832962, 0.00023007393, -0.009521484, -0.03062439, 0.015274048, -0.026351929, 0.000069618225, 0.036895752, -0.021560669, -0.013366699, -0.0007133484, -0.055847168, 0.011398315, -0.04244995, -0.009086609, 0.010437012, -0.046020508, -0.016220093, -0.04171753, -0.019805908, -0.056030273, -0.0028247833, 0.015670776, -0.033172607, 0.011978149, -0.009307861, -0.0055160522, 0.0036029816, -0.015022278, -0.0151901245, -0.015472412, -0.013175964, -0.00011444092, 0.05026245, -0.0044517517, -0.035888672, 0.0065689087, 0.0009083748, -0.006252289, -0.03161621, -0.006652832, -0.02444458, -0.03488159, 0.02973938, 0.0042304993, -0.04257202, 0.004524231, -0.035888672, -0.018203735, -0.012519836, -0.019973755, 0.042663574, 0.02494812, 0.0069732666, -0.02571106, 0.041778564, 0.046936035, 0.026809692, -0.006679535, 0.009361267, -0.017623901, -0.02520752, -0.026809692, -0.0027618408, 0.05114746, 0.03274536, -0.0031166077, -0.018035889, 0.04067993, -0.0124435425, -0.03555298, 0.03225708, 0.029968262, 0.011230469, -0.0025691986, 0.013313293, 0.03062439, 0.022720337, -0.014984131, 0.0025291443, 0.035827637, -0.013870239, -0.03640747, -0.049804688, -0.01727295, -0.027053833, 0.025848389, -0.047576904, 0.041046143, 0.002702713, -0.0053367615, 0.041381836, 0.009483337, 0.000053584576, -0.02722168, 0.0039634705, 0.008682251, -0.043426514, 0.01651001, -0.0033855438, 0.030944824, -0.010940552, 0.0039100647, 0.010047913, -0.003501892, 0.0058555603, 0.011306763, -0.033081055, -0.015602112, -0.02708435, 0.0022468567, 0.01927185, 0.0101623535, 0.007926941, -0.03756714, 0.0069885254, 0.05126953, 0.008911133, -0.07165527, -0.021484375, 0.01399231, 0.03286743, 0.015625, -0.027770996, -0.058258057, 0.0023269653, -0.017959595, -0.057678223, -0.024459839, 0.0018815994, 0.009460449, 0.034820557, -0.018051147, 0.019058228, -0.01411438, 0.01828003, -0.059265137, -0.0007429123, 0.042663574, -0.019973755, -0.029541016, -0.0030384064, 0.017852783, 0.0023994446, 0.022583008, -0.021072388, 0.0014400482, -0.038909912, 0.0017976761, 0.013076782, -0.020141602, 0.040740967, -0.013618469, -0.014053345, 0.0009675026, -0.0014781952, 0.044891357, -0.013473511, 0.10131836, -0.0014314651, 0.039154053, 0.034973145, -0.015060425, -0.019577026, -0.0051193237, -0.09259033, 0.018417358, 0.053222656, 0.012931824, -0.021652222, -0.014053345, 0.04244995, -0.041259766, -0.0552063, -0.0055618286, 0.036346436, 0.01411438, 0.031799316, -0.0010566711, 0.007129669, 0.037078857, -0.021026611, -0.009269714, 0.05380249, -0.044677734, 0.0158844, 0.013038635, -0.005836487, -0.010917664, -0.028182983, 0.045837402, -0.034332275, -0.0027713776, 0.0054359436, -0.013221741, -0.007881165, -0.04046631, 0.0077323914, 0.033203125, 0.0009741783, -0.0033473969, -0.0209198, -0.007583618, -0.061798096, -0.008392334, 0.019134521, -0.00579834, -0.03933716, -0.00075769424, 0.0038967133, -0.027999878, 0.01637268, -0.0042419434, -0.012550354, 0.023086548, 0.054107666, 0.0004413128, 0.040374756, 0.04034424, 0.034606934, 0.0149002075, 0.0039520264, 0.018417358, 0.0061798096, -0.0066604614, 0.09283447, -0.040771484, 0.019332886, -0.03277588, -0.0017051697, 0.000385046, -0.03152466, 0.01979065, -0.028823853, 0.029769897, -0.011817932, -0.014595032, 0.04421997, -0.10437012, 0.0074806213, 0.0064926147, -0.018692017, -0.009521484, -0.005290985, -0.02659607, -0.002746582, 0.036254883, 0.06616211, -0.024337769, 0.0019931793, -0.014076233, 0.007827759, 0.007369995, 0.011772156, -0.009231567, 0.006626129, -0.057739258, 0.014129639, -0.03265381, 0.00088119507, -0.005836487, 0.111816406, -0.014228821, 0.0010128021, -0.009254456, 0.018737793, -0.027557373, -0.038330078, -0.03515625, -0.0019350052, -0.0026550293, -0.03173828, -0.0013809204, -0.022155762, -0.0070762634, 0.0045433044, -0.0057144165, 0.0093688965, -0.000875473, 0.0042266846, -0.022384644, 0.033966064, 0.0014047623, -0.031921387, 0.029129028, -0.021621704, -0.037750244, -0.057556152, 0.023910522, 0.019607544, -0.006942749, -0.03591919, -0.03463745, -0.012428284, -0.00017976761, 0.02079773, -0.018951416, -0.0077438354, -0.05886841, -0.008583069, 0.0023269653, -0.002363205, 0.0095825195, 0.0597229, 0.051330566, -0.017089844, -0.005126953, 0.020706177, -0.0054779053, 0.029464722, -0.012191772, 0.04434204, 0.07543945, -0.023910522, 0.01159668, 0.015853882, 0.09008789, 0.018447876, 0.021408081, -0.047454834, 0.024093628, -0.024856567, 0.032287598, -0.002817154, -0.008682251, 0.049591064, -0.042999268, -0.025756836, -0.018722534, -0.0022296906, -0.0107040405, -0.0020389557, -0.003353119, 0.0067329407, 0.001203537, -0.036590576, 0.030075073, -0.011184692, 0.0013484955, 0.0070266724, -0.008872986, 0.002565384, -0.013442993, -0.01676941, -0.019989014, 0.008934021, 0.018722534, -0.014907837, -0.039123535, 0.07299805, -0.027053833, 0.016342163, -0.017837524, 0.04107666, -0.013008118, 0.027404785, -0.04055786, -0.035491943, -0.008155823, -0.028625488, 0.022216797, -0.059448242, -0.06976318, -0.06964111, -0.01928711, 0.06713867, 0.0015439987, -0.022109985, -0.012069702, 0.008453369, -0.05834961, -0.02999878, -0.032073975, -0.035125732, 0.04309082, -0.016418457, 0.020614624, -0.09277344, 0.025726318, 0.0109939575, 0.1005249, 0.010292053, 0.030975342, 0.003868103, -0.024002075, 0.036224365, 0.055908203, -0.00819397, 0.009017944, -0.0074310303, -0.028778076, 0.029586792, 0.032287598, -0.00982666, 0.0496521, 0.017990112, 0.013664246, 0.001660347, 0.022247314, -0.01713562, -0.0019416809, -0.01977539, 0.009918213, -0.040283203, 0.009010315, 0.009437561, 0.0056495667, -0.021087646, -0.06707764, 0.03062439, -0.11608887, -0.007030487, -0.043151855, 0.004432678, -0.022628784, -0.019882202, 0.012832642, 0.010505676, 0.035186768, -0.027328491, 0.054473877, -0.013511658, 0.0016613007, -0.01348114, -0.004501343, 0.02255249, 0.01739502, -0.0021820068, -0.03237915, 0.030761719, -0.0017375946, -0.03302002, -0.046569824, 0.06463623, 0.04559326, -0.021148682, -0.036590576, -0.08087158, 0.023254395, -0.08654785, -0.009300232, 0.0063591003, -0.018371582, -0.009513855, 0.008872986, 0.009162903, -0.03338623, 0.0030899048, 0.056274414, 0.035614014, -0.019363403, -0.0040664673, 0.057891846, 0.018203735, -0.05810547, -0.007843018, 0.00039100647, 0.006225586, -0.014160156, 0.0034866333, -0.030151367, -0.0002529621, 0.048858643, 0.00006347895, -0.0011129379, -0.01222229, -0.005554199, -0.015113831, 0.013671875, 0.008956909, 0.0010929108, -0.015701294, -0.012260437, -0.010269165, -0.017822266, 0.034301758, -0.032470703, 0.013977051, 0.007713318, 0.00032949448, -0.0037555695, -0.04159546, -0.011619568, 0.012588501, 0.028671265, -0.024734497, -0.027908325, 0.018463135, 0.018234253, -0.008392334, -0.028625488, 0.017288208, 0.020858765, 0.004585266, -0.01600647, -0.076538086, -0.03765869, -0.014770508, -0.07678223, -0.012718201, -0.05709839, -0.034118652, -0.0064735413, 0.0058288574, -0.00096178055, 0.045715332, 0.0033836365, 0.03363037, 0.05456543, -0.013954163, -0.07122803, 0.052001953, 0.0015058517, 0.023529053, 0.00012922287, 0.012329102, 0.0059509277, 0.0059280396, -0.005783081, -0.019546509, -0.0070877075, -0.00579834, 0.011962891, -0.02911377, 0.029449463, -0.016967773, 0.02897644, 0.010604858, 0.033691406, 0.033966064, 0.009880066, -0.00844574, -0.045715332, 0.021377563, 0.045684814, 0.017349243, -0.01953125, -0.014762878, 0.011054993, 0.002029419, -0.0018100739, 0.0015792847, -0.020065308, 0.0034675598, -0.010139465, 0.02746582, 0.028244019, 0.0013856888, 0.03378296, 0.013679504, 0.018722534, 0.008926392, -0.0023880005, -0.013053894, -0.030792236, -0.0054130554, -0.010360718, 0.0017366409, -0.0000333786, 0.0033721924, -0.03869629, 0.022354126, -0.00058221817, -0.011230469, -0.025619507, -0.012336731, -0.03161621, -0.04751587, -0.0022335052, 0.014053345, -0.056427002, -0.00548172, 0.03515625, -0.006843567, -0.030563354, -0.0066719055, 0.0011520386, -0.015296936, 0.017028809, 0.002319336, -0.035705566, -0.009048462, 0.014167786, 0.008232117, 0.03869629, 0.048828125, -0.062561035, -0.014205933, -0.029663086, -0.049865723, -0.035369873, -0.03527832, 0.011695862, -0.027130127, -0.04586792, 0.03274536, -0.073791504, 0.04498291, -0.013793945, -0.023468018, -0.0059509277, 0.009666443, -0.0032539368, 0.056549072, 0.027740479, 0.0137786865, -0.007598877, 0.039123535, 0.018463135, 0.024246216, 0.006843567, -0.009262085, -0.010101318, 0.055633545, -0.0146484375, -0.021331787, 0.009407043, 0.0013246536, -0.014755249, 0.017852783, 0.021255493, 0.022583008, -0.010673523, 0.022750854, -0.00605011, -0.036254883, 0.0010309219, -0.051330566, -0.042297363, 0.027832031, 0.046417236, 0.034606934, -0.017822266, 0.047088623, 0.0060577393, -0.0036201477, 0.0038089752, 0.028244019, 0.008239746, -0.012939453, 0.0390625, 0.02456665, -0.039916992, -0.0017147064, -0.0011672974, 0.0035896301, -0.022827148, 0.052886963, 0.0048179626, -0.039855957, 0.046447754, 0.007663727, 0.022644043, 0.017807007, 0.020187378, 0.025009155, -0.026138306, -0.031555176, -0.014022827, 0.005039215, -0.0036964417, -0.019058228, 0.011734009, -0.068847656, -0.003042221, -0.007926941, 0.013595581, -0.056640625, -0.0118637085, -0.0058898926, 0.033172607, 0.027938843, -0.018692017, 0.016921997, 0.021743774, -0.04135132, 0.0032691956, -0.009346008, 0.03817749, -0.021911621, -0.087768555, -0.026641846, 0.026275635, 0.028625488, 0.046325684, -0.038482666, -0.107910156, 0.01108551, -0.02229309, 0.0011711121, -0.009742737, 0.034057617, 0.0062294006, 0.07543945, -0.009979248, -0.039520264, 0.025375366, 0.021713257, 0.020370483, -0.03982544, 0.030807495, 0.08331299, -0.010482788, 0.060302734, -0.033843994, 0.028503418, 0.041137695, 0.0021896362, -0.0076942444, 0.04724121, 0.039978027, 0.0066986084, -0.038391113, 0.023971558, 0.018096924, 0.037994385, 0.008102417, 0.060150146, -0.03805542, 0.012580872, 0.029312134, 0.03277588, 0.017913818, 0.008285522, 0.027236938, 0.017608643, -0.00025367737, -0.012504578, -0.010238647, -0.022598267, -0.07861328, -0.029190063, -0.039489746, 0.00026082993, -0.0093307495, 0.0009675026, -0.013153076, 0.09338379, -0.011474609, 0.06500244, 0.019348145, -0.032836914, 0.0009460449, 0.021881104, -0.02557373, -0.007331848, 0.0007009506, -0.011703491, 0.0056648254, 0.030456543, -0.012069702, 0.024597168, -0.020431519, 0.0061454773, 0.013748169, -0.0146484375, -0.019180298, -0.032806396, 0.023910522, -0.02432251, 0.08276367, 0.048675537, 0.08666992, 0.0031375885, -0.0016498566, -0.016983032, -0.0066184998, -0.016967773, -0.008155823, -0.058654785, 0.029190063, 0.024963379, -0.032409668, 0.018447876, -0.0146102905, -0.012817383, 0.017333984, 0.0040283203, 0.058135986, -0.070617676, -0.008178711, -0.00007367134, 0.015777588, -0.04949951, 0.030151367, -0.025177002, -0.022460938, 0.0018835068, -0.0010137558, -0.004459381, -0.014053345, -0.009231567, 0.011726379, -0.011619568, 0.05407715, -0.029556274, 0.055541992, -0.032287598, 0.009338379, -0.07434082, 0.029190063, 0.014457703, -0.02444458, 0.032165527, 0.0039253235, -0.0016708374, 0.0090789795, 0.01675415, -0.008163452, 0.028915405, 0.019622803, -0.0031833649, 0.0023059845, -0.0033187866, -0.03479004, -0.0082473755, 0.048797607, 0.015396118, -0.025222778, -0.011878967, 0.019195557, -0.02178955, 0.046936035, 0.014282227, -0.020324707, -0.021194458, -0.0069732666, -0.009803772, 0.0044021606, 0.02079773, -0.021362305, -0.04638672, 0.021209717, -0.011917114, 0.006881714, -0.015960693, -0.0056991577, -0.020858765, 0.026351929, 0.0052986145, 0.021987915, 0.02973938, -0.03704834, -0.010864258, 0.021453857, 0.040649414, 0.056152344, 0.06585693, 0.00027441978, 0.04019165, 0.009994507, -0.020889282, -0.08483887, -0.016098022, -0.0074768066, 0.03744507, -0.0881958, 0.060150146, 0.03564453, -0.016906738, -0.011436462, 0.03894043, -0.02583313, -0.00491333, 0.04220581, -0.03250122, -0.061279297, 0.043914795, 0.012374878, -0.027236938, 0.030807495, 0.037261963, 0.009788513, 0.012825012, 0.04547119, -0.00094366074, -0.07397461, -0.030136108, -0.05657959, 0.0043640137, -0.0121536255, -0.020324707, 0.017410278, -0.019165039, -0.058685303, 0.0066337585, 0.0017290115, 0.062683105, -0.007881165, 0.009269714, -0.077941895, 0.0009236336, 0.074035645, 0.14562988, 0.038482666, -0.059020996, -0.03213501, -0.044158936, 0.025817871, -0.009689331, -0.02709961, 0.00044870377, 0.047821045, -0.04055786, -0.014778137, 0.0051994324, 0.0002040863, -0.01373291, 0.0149002075, 0.0076141357, -0.02243042, -0.028518677, -0.005886078, -0.010566711, 0.0059280396, -0.0070533752, -0.021255493, 0.011451721, -0.024719238, -0.007987976, -0.026931763, -0.11627197, 0.068725586, 0.043151855, -0.0026226044, 0.023132324, 0.014076233, -0.047698975, 0.011947632, 0.015151978, -0.0031719208, 0.013374329, -0.0032539368, -0.014915466, -0.019836426, -0.030731201, 0.004432678, -0.045715332, -0.05609131, 0.055023193, 0.0021533966, -0.03463745, 0.016403198, -0.010658264, 0.009788513, -0.02861023, 0.0107421875, -0.03778076, 0.0035037994, 0.039733887, 0.0059165955, 0.024993896 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2104.06735v1
Enabling Machine Learning Algorithms for Credit Scoring -- Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) methods for clear understanding complex predictive models
Przemysław Biecek, Marcin Chlebus, Janusz Gajda, Alicja Gosiewska, Anna Kozak, Dominik Ogonowski, Jakub Sztachelski, Piotr Wojewnik
q-fin.RM, cs.AI, cs.LG
Rapid development of advanced modelling techniques gives an opportunity to develop tools that are more and more accurate. However as usually, everything comes with a price and in this case, the price to pay is to loose interpretability of a model while gaining on its accuracy and precision. For managers to control and effectively manage credit risk and for regulators to be convinced with model quality the price to pay is too high. In this paper, we show how to take credit scoring analytics in to the next level, namely we present comparison of various predictive models (logistic regression, logistic regression with weight of evidence transformations and modern artificial intelligence algorithms) and show that advanced tree based models give best results in prediction of client default. What is even more important and valuable we also show how to boost advanced models using techniques which allow to interpret them and made them more accessible for credit risk practitioners, resolving the crucial obstacle in widespread deployment of more complex, 'black box' models like random forests, gradient boosted or extreme gradient boosted trees. All this will be shown on the large dataset obtained from the Polish Credit Bureau to which all the banks and most of the lending companies in the country do report the credit files. In this paper the data from lending companies were used. The paper then compares state of the art best practices in credit risk modelling with new advanced modern statistical tools boosted by the latest developments in the field of interpretability and explainability of artificial intelligence algorithms. We believe that this is a valuable contribution when it comes to presentation of different modelling tools but what is even more important it is showing which methods might be used to get insight and understanding of AI methods in credit risk context.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2104.06735v1
"2021-04-14T09:44:04"
"2021-04-14T09:44:04"
{ "title": [ -0.008476257, -0.01638794, 0.010040283, -0.0012636185, -0.03161621, -0.004524231, 0.0068511963, -0.009361267, 0.015014648, 0.007881165, -0.051727295, -0.014549255, 0.017654419, -0.04916382, 0.008964539, -0.033813477, -0.012893677, 0.038604736, 0.0033721924, -0.034851074, 0.014152527, -0.045684814, 0.0044555664, 0.032043457, 0.014602661, 0.03805542, -0.028915405, -0.026275635, 0.037902832, 0.013038635, 0.010444641, -0.041900635, -0.014816284, 0.021240234, 0.015914917, 0.037963867, 0.011650085, 0.014503479, 0.04425049, -0.0052948, 0.012893677, -0.00831604, 0.010406494, -0.01058197, 0.015304565, -0.024169922, 0.018203735, -0.014816284, 0.037597656, 0.0047187805, 0.0073509216, 0.028961182, 0.007282257, 0.026367188, -0.011405945, 0.0025138855, -0.022918701, -0.05126953, 0.016616821, 0.020446777, 0.008506775, -0.010673523, 0.02670288, -0.021453857, -0.01739502, -0.043701172, -0.03466797, 0.020568848, 0.05770874, -0.0043640137, 0.008010864, 0.039520264, -0.020492554, -0.0009455681, -0.044769287, -0.03387451, 0.058776855, -0.024230957, -0.022506714, -0.00365448, -0.022781372, -0.026992798, 0.026885986, -0.03048706, 0.003376007, -0.0028266907, -0.012023926, 0.009628296, -0.03161621, -0.015335083, -0.030319214, -0.016403198, -0.038879395, 0.016220093, 0.0015239716, -0.023925781, 0.03286743, 0.038024902, -0.02017212, -0.04147339, 0.02029419, -0.024047852, -0.019592285, -0.008010864, -0.011672974, 0.055419922, 0.068481445, 0.07342529, 0.0006389618, -0.026809692, -0.019165039, 0.011528015, 0.04071045, 0.0031967163, -0.023239136, -0.0024662018, 0.011329651, 0.012756348, -0.010101318, 0.016311646, 0.008895874, -0.0043754578, 0.0289917, 0.025894165, 0.018356323, 0.015167236, -0.03366089, -0.004688263, 0.045654297, 0.038513184, 0.0046844482, 0.020462036, -0.079711914, -0.05230713, -0.06311035, -0.011474609, 0.030944824, -0.047576904, 0.0054397583, -0.010894775, 0.048706055, -0.00491333, 0.03744507, 0.049041748, -0.03781128, -0.020889282, 0.028121948, 0.039031982, -0.01007843, -0.06890869, 0.012123108, 0.009155273, -0.00957489, 0.021194458, -0.008460999, 0.037017822, -0.04724121, 0.027374268, 0.03062439, 0.028427124, 0.059509277, 0.013725281, -0.016571045, 0.02355957, 0.009033203, -0.025299072, -0.008323669, 0.0074005127, 0.010223389, -0.061706543, 0.045959473, -0.0317688, 0.018447876, -0.015365601, 0.010299683, 0.024154663, 0.008621216, -0.026473999, -0.021194458, 0.01625061, -0.0031986237, -0.038482666, -0.070495605, 0.035064697, -0.06427002, -0.00674057, 0.0038223267, 0.044708252, 0.03781128, 0.0096588135, 0.021987915, -0.022094727, -0.018600464, -0.031173706, -0.03060913, 0.009117126, -0.011558533, 0.01889038, -0.035308838, 0.0340271, -0.02281189, 0.04220581, -0.03741455, 0.009819031, -0.015808105, -0.029266357, 0.0035800934, 0.0385437, -0.026672363, 0.046051025, 0.036865234, 0.013511658, -0.022888184, -0.013252258, 0.009002686, -0.03250122, 0.0024223328, -0.061553955, -0.014427185, -0.058380127, -0.0079574585, 0.050079346, -0.032043457, 0.053771973, -0.012031555, 0.053955078, -0.021011353, 0.030227661, 0.020736694, 0.04663086, 0.049316406, -0.03086853, 0.0463562, -0.021911621, -0.057647705, -0.013542175, -0.015960693, -0.050720215, -0.001449585, 0.07623291, 0.028396606, -0.010681152, 0.009963989, -0.017730713, 0.064453125, 0.0010566711, 0.014877319, -0.038238525, 0.006866455, 0.02558899, 0.011543274, -0.021469116, 0.010505676, 0.04611206, -0.028533936, 0.021102905, -0.006996155, 0.025680542, -0.01423645, 0.027633667, -0.02154541, 0.058929443, 0.044067383, -0.004436493, -0.033355713, 0.045715332, 0.007205963, 0.04776001, -0.04095459, 0.00046610832, 0.036193848, 0.053741455, 0.00020098686, 0.01876831, -0.004852295, -0.017410278, -0.026657104, -0.0032958984, 0.015037537, -0.010871887, 0.031829834, 0.045043945, 0.03338623, 0.00061893463, 0.021621704, 0.02960205, 0.018585205, 0.0496521, -0.059326172, -0.01626587, 0.00059080124, 0.09472656, 0.027374268, -0.008041382, 0.011894226, 0.03375244, -0.030960083, 0.023605347, 0.0022621155, -0.01058197, -0.09613037, 0.013793945, 0.035308838, -0.035705566, 0.027511597, 0.0284729, 0.07067871, -0.007293701, 0.0016040802, 0.022964478, -0.040802002, -0.01687622, 0.013343811, 0.011306763, -0.023376465, -0.02619934, -0.029037476, 0.016204834, -0.04800415, -0.001203537, 0.04046631, 0.015136719, -0.013053894, -0.024734497, 0.00919342, -0.014007568, -0.033111572, -0.024810791, -0.01940918, 0.0129852295, -0.021316528, -0.022872925, -0.038635254, -0.021560669, -0.01939392, 0.000992775, -0.0010604858, 0.02204895, -0.019348145, -0.014709473, -0.0044059753, -0.0690918, 0.011421204, -0.012542725, 0.009086609, -0.039611816, 0.06149292, -0.008903503, -0.066345215, 0.015586853, 0.031188965, -0.031951904, -0.02897644, -0.008796692, 0.010253906, -0.04827881, 0.022277832, 0.031082153, 0.011940002, -0.02255249, 0.079956055, 0.03579712, 0.033050537, -0.113342285, -0.038085938, -0.04486084, -0.009101868, -0.0418396, -0.03173828, 0.001707077, -0.0146484375, -0.019378662, -0.020355225, -0.015602112, -0.02293396, 0.042785645, 0.014884949, -0.008277893, 0.00080251694, 0.0054092407, 0.0069847107, -0.0024223328, 0.020935059, -0.0067825317, -0.017242432, 0.008415222, -0.009712219, 0.012794495, -0.017303467, -0.0002567768, -0.031799316, 0.01928711, -0.048461914, 0.0029659271, 0.038848877, -0.0073242188, -0.0074005127, 0.034698486, -0.13098145, -0.00076913834, 0.0095825195, 0.010002136, -0.02180481, 0.020599365, -0.045562744, 0.027160645, -0.011985779, -0.012817383, 0.01625061, 0.06933594, 0.03555298, -0.0033016205, 0.055908203, -0.0060310364, 0.03765869, -0.023773193, -0.015640259, 0.01260376, -0.054748535, 0.007972717, 0.019241333, 0.033813477, -0.03543091, -0.031188965, -0.0023059845, 0.050048828, 0.00579834, -0.0064735413, 0.00484848, 0.033996582, 0.03010559, -0.0074882507, -0.020690918, -0.034179688, 0.020080566, 0.05581665, -0.01121521, 0.03012085, -0.017349243, 0.017822266, -0.006126404, -0.034179688, -0.0690918, 0.004119873, -0.032958984, -0.0041046143, -0.033996582, -0.035247803, -0.0060272217, -0.005607605, -0.0031108856, 0.010566711, 0.028259277, 0.026367188, -0.010231018, 0.03878784, 0.015136719, 0.037017822, 0.016586304, 0.020874023, -0.013122559, -0.009742737, 0.01084137, 0.0040397644, -0.01864624, 0.02557373, 0.03552246, 0.0035552979, -0.028244019, 0.006008148, -0.009765625, -0.013832092, 0.02418518, 0.020217896, -0.032470703, -0.054534912, 0.009986877, 0.03338623, 0.007167816, -0.027374268, 0.00016331673, 0.024765015, 0.026473999, -0.058044434, -0.044921875, 0.026794434, -0.08880615, -0.055541992, 0.01247406, -0.04421997, -0.021575928, -0.06311035, 0.038513184, -0.06713867, -0.021728516, 0.0018825531, -0.0058555603, 0.043640137, 0.0026626587, -0.03778076, -0.0115737915, -0.012168884, -0.023269653, 0.005153656, -0.026000977, 0.0043411255, 0.017974854, 0.0040397644, -0.005004883, -0.006702423, 0.016098022, -0.023239136, 0.027801514, 0.051361084, -0.033721924, 0.0010948181, 0.03164673, -0.012130737, -0.0054740906, 0.024490356, -0.0031394958, 0.052886963, -0.040222168, 0.009597778, 0.07092285, -0.049468994, -0.0056152344, 0.04095459, -0.023376465, -0.073913574, 0.006351471, 0.022262573, -0.013381958, 0.048950195, 0.03152466, 0.044799805, -0.024551392, 0.025970459, 0.012458801, -0.020706177, -0.037597656, 0.007965088, 0.016799927, 0.010246277, 0.0007343292, -0.013023376, -0.012023926, 0.03164673, -0.0012750626, 0.012519836, -0.013092041, -0.020446777, 0.026046753, -0.017105103, -0.007045746, -0.04815674, 0.0023422241, -0.0018110275, 0.0022907257, -0.0043258667, 0.035003662, 0.026916504, -0.0124053955, -0.048583984, 0.012878418, 0.026992798, -0.054473877, -0.062683105, 0.004940033, -0.026046753, -0.07659912, -0.06274414, -0.017669678, 0.013626099, -0.013023376, -0.011726379, -0.028274536, 0.0076828003, -0.0049819946, 0.0491333, 0.05227661, 0.014656067, -0.060577393, -0.0022850037, -0.005630493, 0.050811768, -0.03866577, 0.04647827, -0.009101868, 0.0058403015, 0.016952515, -0.011802673, -0.024459839, -0.07507324, -0.0047836304, 0.024612427, 0.0018978119, 0.044311523, 0.014007568, 0.007965088, 0.0004541874, 0.01209259, 0.017669678, -0.0287323, -0.013175964, -0.0020809174, 0.03149414, -0.050231934, 0.029724121, 0.059326172, 0.005302429, -0.013587952, 0.010467529, 0.0006594658, 0.038482666, -0.022277832, -0.005290985, 0.05029297, 0.02482605, -0.002122879, 0.01121521, -0.004322052, 0.0015563965, -0.07312012, -0.008361816, 0.012962341, -0.006088257, 0.023773193, 0.0011835098, 0.0066986084, 0.040771484, -0.0019054413, -0.002210617, 0.017227173, 0.04348755, -0.013031006, 0.0038776398, 0.010261536, -0.029434204, 0.011352539, 0.017578125, -0.00066518784, 0.03414917, -0.019317627, 0.002380371, -0.027160645, -0.00075674057, 0.029876709, -0.020965576, -0.039642334, -0.039154053, -0.0009126663, -0.03353882, 0.009460449, 0.018936157, -0.029266357, 0.0068969727, 0.002822876, 0.03152466, -0.013259888, -0.0063934326, 0.050750732, -0.05807495, 0.007331848, 0.0022525787, -0.0119018555, 0.042755127, 0.034698486, -0.008728027, -0.0027122498, 0.00086832047, 0.01008606, 0.012924194, 0.0005078316, 0.034210205, 0.01737976, -0.0062789917, 0.011749268, 0.019973755, -0.036712646, 0.024780273, 0.023101807, -0.007949829, 0.019729614, -0.033294678, 0.047088623, -0.015281677, -0.013366699, -0.030532837, -0.03387451, -0.05142212, 0.03475952, -0.050048828, 0.028213501, 0.050750732, -0.006385803, -0.016708374, -0.045898438, 0.009284973, -0.019744873, -0.015258789, -0.016464233, 0.031799316, -0.020370483, 0.02017212, -0.021255493, -0.066223145, 0.027374268, -0.0038394928, -0.0005002022, 0.015975952, 0.02468872, -0.084228516, -0.030349731, -0.070617676, -0.035339355, -0.026824951, 0.042114258, 0.04788208, 0.032836914, 0.00042152405, 0.029541016, -0.01979065, -0.041259766, -0.017059326, 0.028198242, -0.04837036, 0.052886963, -0.0017223358, 0.032165527, 0.0014886856, 0.021408081, 0.005466461, 0.0024967194, 0.0073051453, 0.00042319298, 0.02420044, -0.013313293, -0.024536133, -0.033233643, -0.05343628, -0.0057792664, 0.014411926, -0.0055160522, 0.020507812, 0.0045204163, 0.023208618, -0.028625488, 0.02734375, 0.039001465, 0.08758545, -0.062805176, -0.089904785, -0.045196533, -0.00084352493, -0.051330566, 0.013298035, 0.020401001, -0.06829834, 0.012763977, -0.008293152, 0.0052604675, -0.005405426, 0.04425049, 0.011383057, 0.08105469, -0.045928955, -0.09124756, -0.03866577, -0.017227173, -0.0017251968, 0.04937744, -0.028533936, -0.051574707, 0.0012283325, -0.022644043, -0.013442993, -0.0037498474, 0.011756897, 0.029647827, 0.013168335, 0.017715454, -0.036834717, -0.026184082, -0.046417236, 0.048065186, 0.050598145, 0.05053711, -0.05456543, -0.00036740303, 0.047454834, 0.05407715, 0.033966064, -0.006214142, 0.012130737, 0.031829834, 0.0211792, 0.0011196136, 0.011741638, 0.0016050339, 0.03189087, -0.029251099, 0.009895325, 0.020980835, -0.007873535, -0.057128906, -0.019302368, 0.082458496, -0.00522995, 0.027496338, 0.0075569153, -0.003643036, 0.02482605, 0.028808594, 0.024978638, 0.035827637, -0.019073486, -0.006629944, 0.0043411255, 0.021621704, -0.021148682, -0.0035896301, 0.0039711, 0.044677734, -0.009376526, -0.014671326, 0.047698975, -0.014022827, -0.004711151, -0.003419876, 0.0025119781, -0.027420044, -0.034729004, -0.038146973, -0.04019165, 0.04046631, 0.037506104, -0.041015625, 0.020050049, 0.044830322, 0.038116455, 0.004119873, 0.021820068, 0.05822754, -0.04446411, 0.031555176, 0.036102295, -0.0446167, 0.018936157, 0.0713501, 0.01133728, 0.0131073, 0.010726929, 0.026870728, 0.00056028366, 0.0368042, 0.013191223, -0.028289795, -0.016204834, 0.0007967949, -0.018951416, 0.0015888214, -0.005268097, 0.027755737, 0.044799805, 0.048797607, 0.08300781, -0.014015198, 0.06085205, -0.005218506, 0.03262329, -0.06890869, 0.027389526, -0.022766113, -0.027420044, 0.006000519, 0.012313843, -0.02760315, 0.016983032, -0.002204895, 0.03543091, 0.029006958, 0.0703125, -0.010772705, 0.02217102, 0.0062179565, 0.013343811, 0.05645752, 0.010932922, 0.01763916, 0.0030536652, -0.027999878, 0.003211975, 0.007537842, 0.020339966, 0.038848877, -0.0003695488, 0.04421997, -0.029571533, 0.014923096, -0.039764404, -0.03643799, 0.03161621, 0.009475708, 0.0005040169, 0.0038051605, 0.023712158, -0.0047454834, -0.020065308, -0.0054092407, 0.03414917, 0.011024475, 0.026382446, 0.030334473, -0.05569458, 0.015022278, 0.05340576, 0.04586792, 0.093688965, 0.0619812, -0.01927185, -0.001036644, 0.019302368, -0.0018758774, -0.00055122375, -0.008453369, 0.040527344, -0.0093688965, -0.030426025, 0.014343262, 0.024917603, -0.02835083, -0.077941895, 0.0062789917, -0.016571045, -0.031829834, 0.012878418, 0.026153564, 0.018371582, -0.060668945, -0.003376007, -0.03729248, -0.010116577, -0.014450073, 0.00504303, 0.016281128, 0.019561768, -0.0037879944, -0.03326416, 0.0048599243, 0.0036621094, -0.00712204, 0.014953613, -0.031951904, 0.02331543, 0.046661377, -0.047943115, -0.06933594, -0.017333984, -0.014724731, 0.011634827, 0.02230835, 0.008682251, 0.015792847, -0.025100708, 0.017105103, -0.005279541, -0.008796692, 0.02545166, 0.03869629, 0.005596161, 0.04598999, -0.017608643, 0.04296875, 0.020019531, -0.02885437, 0.017044067, 0.04333496, -0.007434845, 0.03945923, 0.0032844543, 0.04385376, -0.044769287, -0.019973755, 0.06707764, 0.0071105957, -0.019958496, 0.02520752, -0.033416748, -0.014213562, 0.006351471, -0.005428314, 0.015419006, -0.031234741, 0.01838684, 0.05078125, 0.010719299, 0.035980225, -0.01953125, -0.048431396, 0.014778137, 0.025390625, -0.0050582886, 0.028778076, -0.019638062, 0.026824951, -0.0017900467, -0.014595032, -0.061462402, -0.004863739, -0.026809692, 0.010772705, -0.05630493, 0.048034668, -0.022277832, 0.021255493, 0.032958984, 0.022018433, 0.033813477, 0.059448242, -0.047943115, -0.02796936, -0.013420105, -0.034698486 ], "summary": [ 0.041259766, -0.02998352, 0.07562256, -0.015113831, -0.05154419, 0.018310547, -0.0105896, -0.062683105, 0.056549072, 0.008071899, -0.06222534, -0.0110321045, 0.0019330978, -0.013252258, -0.023895264, -0.039733887, -0.01626587, 0.040924072, 0.019546509, -0.036071777, 0.022766113, -0.0703125, -0.011474609, 0.008216858, 0.036468506, -0.029754639, -0.027008057, 0.001704216, 0.05328369, 0.039611816, 0.008834839, -0.06317139, 0.014907837, -0.007709503, 0.016464233, 0.053771973, 0.0019664764, 0.0021266937, 0.021606445, -0.005592346, 0.037353516, -0.019744873, 0.07287598, 0.011169434, 0.030059814, 0.005302429, 0.015563965, -0.051605225, 0.022705078, -0.01914978, 0.018539429, 0.036315918, 0.011772156, 0.001203537, -0.02607727, -0.0029582977, -0.05493164, -0.011291504, 0.023010254, 0.08807373, 0.032226562, -0.006565094, -0.0093307495, -0.05001831, -0.006755829, -0.006591797, 0.024810791, 0.01965332, 0.09631348, 0.01499939, -0.022094727, 0.053619385, 0.0042304993, -0.013687134, -0.04321289, -0.022949219, 0.049591064, -0.011413574, -0.0035820007, -0.013259888, 0.02670288, -0.009025574, 0.0015678406, 0.007129669, -0.0075912476, 0.024353027, -0.008674622, -0.006187439, -0.0069007874, -0.02281189, -0.01499176, -0.008888245, -0.053863525, 0.0418396, 0.024276733, -0.019073486, -0.043273926, -0.013999939, 0.006061554, 0.015098572, 0.014282227, -0.010597229, -0.007583618, -0.020767212, -0.019927979, 0.081604004, 0.040161133, 0.013122559, -0.006259918, -0.012397766, 0.0043258667, -0.026382446, 0.013877869, 0.0132751465, -0.01625061, 0.025863647, 0.01158905, 0.015914917, -0.019363403, 0.041625977, -0.03201294, -0.019561768, 0.007019043, 0.019226074, 0.014175415, 0.0005669594, 0.0014801025, 0.0029697418, 0.022094727, 0.07318115, 0.007610321, -0.021697998, -0.04812622, 0.0018863678, -0.02746582, -0.029953003, 0.020736694, 0.0029392242, 0.004371643, 0.0032730103, 0.052825928, -0.018630981, -0.006702423, 0.05429077, 0.032989502, 0.003068924, 0.022354126, 0.025665283, 0.021530151, -0.04360962, 0.039031982, -0.019348145, 0.05142212, -0.008422852, -0.035064697, -0.03225708, -0.019256592, -0.019073486, -0.017242432, -0.03491211, 0.014472961, -0.018600464, -0.027954102, -0.0070495605, -0.030029297, 0.018051147, 0.0053863525, -0.0024471283, 0.012428284, -0.08532715, -0.0000046491623, 0.015686035, -0.004940033, -0.032165527, 0.015548706, 0.008018494, -0.031433105, 0.037017822, 0.016845703, -0.023284912, 0.015899658, -0.016082764, 0.028579712, 0.03656006, -0.035064697, 0.02456665, -0.026611328, 0.054107666, 0.056854248, 0.014793396, -0.041809082, -0.023910522, -0.009742737, -0.012611389, -0.00086069107, -0.009735107, -0.04446411, -0.029800415, -0.016830444, 0.011550903, -0.03265381, 0.006164551, -0.027374268, -0.0033473969, 0.015449524, -0.028656006, 0.011001587, 0.014862061, -0.04071045, 0.019805908, 0.047698975, 0.013198853, -0.078430176, 0.076660156, 0.011665344, -0.03503418, 0.03225708, -0.0435791, -0.008277893, -0.048919678, -0.025817871, 0.033081055, -0.041900635, 0.03237915, -0.047576904, 0.012916565, -0.011726379, 0.025253296, -0.003370285, 0.035949707, 0.046936035, -0.035980225, 0.006401062, -0.017120361, -0.028030396, -0.02949524, -0.01953125, -0.1237793, 0.01651001, 0.08905029, 0.03262329, 0.03161621, 0.0017604828, 0.009750366, 0.038482666, -0.020339966, 0.017684937, -0.010284424, 0.02015686, 0.03564453, -0.013893127, -0.0236969, 0.025878906, -0.025161743, -0.017868042, 0.050201416, -0.016540527, 0.008834839, -0.018218994, 0.018707275, -0.009796143, -0.0181427, 0.0026569366, -0.014945984, 0.013175964, -0.0030117035, 0.028213501, 0.034484863, 0.002023697, -0.038208008, 0.002401352, 0.02381897, -0.007820129, -0.019866943, -0.0013027191, 0.047088623, -0.028717041, 0.010894775, 0.0010662079, -0.017532349, 0.053100586, 0.06951904, 0.047088623, -0.007511139, 0.015655518, 0.034088135, 0.003047943, 0.039093018, -0.016342163, 0.02748108, 0.03955078, 0.020324707, -0.010276794, 0.004436493, -0.045410156, -0.0005931854, 0.00068473816, 0.045196533, 0.010543823, -0.00381279, -0.055664062, 0.02633667, 0.0012903214, -0.018096924, 0.001376152, 0.04574585, 0.05090332, -0.028060913, -0.011192322, -0.009155273, -0.027252197, -0.03265381, 0.027648926, 0.035125732, -0.012962341, -0.015007019, -0.0098724365, 0.040863037, 0.014221191, 0.045318604, 0.019973755, -0.03363037, -0.02519226, -0.0063209534, -0.030334473, 0.017593384, 0.0134887695, 0.0016527176, 0.0021820068, -0.017288208, 0.004901886, -0.03768921, -0.022476196, -0.023620605, -0.0018234253, -0.015327454, -0.0062408447, 0.028442383, 0.014785767, 0.018615723, 0.022415161, -0.010772705, -0.0039978027, -0.020050049, -0.042022705, -0.0068588257, 0.02558899, 0.0027484894, -0.04650879, -0.013305664, 0.031707764, -0.016143799, -0.039886475, 0.019195557, -0.037475586, -0.034576416, 0.06524658, -0.018203735, -0.0552063, -0.06329346, 0.05178833, 0.040161133, 0.021316528, -0.05065918, -0.05758667, -0.03213501, 0.031677246, -0.027679443, 0.001411438, 0.021759033, -0.039916992, 0.030166626, -0.03982544, -0.020080566, -0.0064353943, 0.024398804, 0.07849121, 0.013755798, -0.045410156, 0.04107666, 0.015449524, 0.034484863, -0.0034885406, 0.027679443, 0.0146102905, -0.0021705627, -0.021743774, 0.011108398, -0.0024776459, 0.015274048, -0.0044059753, 0.015045166, -0.05532837, -0.019470215, 0.03189087, 0.0088272095, 0.008956909, 0.045410156, -0.066223145, -0.033416748, 0.0038433075, -0.0033493042, -0.002111435, -0.0021343231, -0.038757324, 0.06121826, -0.039276123, -0.013290405, 0.037384033, 0.012283325, -0.004547119, 0.01398468, -0.006477356, -0.011871338, -0.012107849, 0.004009247, -0.011421204, -0.000018656254, 0.00045251846, -0.011947632, -0.018600464, 0.023605347, -0.023910522, 0.004886627, -0.01625061, 0.041229248, 0.0032176971, 0.02432251, 0.019577026, -0.005596161, -0.007888794, -0.018722534, -0.028076172, -0.07141113, -0.023010254, -0.04159546, -0.018127441, 0.02067566, -0.020935059, 0.0006790161, -0.04434204, -0.038085938, -0.057495117, 0.024215698, -0.0066947937, -0.015281677, -0.039031982, -0.04937744, -0.010971069, -0.016799927, 0.0053710938, 0.0015306473, 0.068603516, 0.02758789, -0.0015068054, 0.053344727, -0.007709503, 0.03173828, -0.007347107, -0.0035514832, -0.023742676, -0.03970337, 0.07531738, -0.012580872, 0.0009870529, 0.030639648, -0.058135986, 0.020553589, -0.03125, -0.0070724487, 0.018997192, 0.009414673, 0.022018433, 0.001033783, -0.041656494, -0.059448242, 0.037994385, 0.01524353, 0.04534912, -0.027252197, 0.004901886, 0.009384155, 0.05871582, -0.057678223, -0.022949219, 0.02166748, -0.0925293, -0.06549072, 0.01789856, 0.009605408, -0.031204224, 0.0022449493, 0.02960205, 0.027404785, 0.0262146, 0.0019378662, -0.03250122, 0.10296631, -0.004196167, -0.06329346, 0.03540039, -0.03955078, 0.031921387, 0.029571533, -0.0181427, 0.07714844, 0.05380249, -0.004940033, -0.028823853, -0.05517578, 0.029724121, -0.059814453, 0.029678345, 0.048065186, -0.021881104, 0.0039100647, 0.03704834, -0.008766174, -0.003129959, 0.018203735, 0.045898438, 0.07733154, -0.015625, -0.0033626556, 0.012535095, 0.0013942719, -0.031341553, 0.0011644363, -0.019104004, -0.03353882, 0.011657715, 0.037475586, -0.023269653, 0.022644043, 0.010910034, -0.015022278, -0.030654907, -0.015731812, 0.0065193176, 0.022628784, -0.03677368, -0.030807495, -0.001077652, 0.047424316, -0.005317688, 0.009056091, -0.0011548996, 0.045196533, -0.031799316, 0.02017212, -0.009033203, -0.000197649, 0.021881104, -0.02609253, -0.019607544, -0.0069885254, 0.0061035156, -0.014320374, -0.006439209, 0.032958984, 0.024505615, 0.021759033, 0.009475708, -0.04638672, 0.07635498, 0.012367249, -0.00010287762, -0.046936035, 0.0014209747, -0.0067443848, -0.08319092, -0.044525146, -0.047698975, -0.0071983337, -0.021896362, -0.009147644, -0.021377563, 0.022521973, 0.012367249, 0.040130615, 0.041503906, -0.019454956, -0.08087158, -0.02772522, -0.0014753342, 0.024841309, -0.024841309, 0.017120361, -0.009559631, 0.009292603, 0.014945984, -0.014091492, -0.014923096, -0.06958008, 0.00472641, -0.013183594, 0.012435913, 0.027404785, 0.00374794, 0.016967773, 0.048797607, 0.025299072, 0.024642944, 0.004623413, -0.049713135, 0.00806427, 0.0042648315, 0.07055664, 0.023452759, 0.049926758, -0.015113831, -0.037139893, 0.03945923, -0.0072669983, 0.054229736, -0.009170532, 0.012336731, -0.0025348663, -0.03338623, -0.030700684, -0.022354126, 0.0043525696, -0.0037288666, -0.0368042, -0.005821228, -0.011436462, -0.03427124, 0.0154418945, 0.0026798248, 0.0138168335, 0.035095215, 0.005592346, 0.012046814, 0.00008571148, 0.04434204, -0.02609253, 0.013374329, -0.005180359, -0.022857666, 0.0552063, 0.003484726, 0.0013389587, -0.007205963, 0.012763977, 0.014945984, -0.008132935, -0.0012521744, -0.0005245209, -0.023223877, -0.021087646, -0.012870789, -0.008384705, -0.016311646, -0.0036468506, 0.007762909, -0.017623901, 0.0017471313, -0.004295349, -0.012199402, -0.02420044, -0.032104492, -0.01600647, -0.02468872, -0.00869751, 0.022644043, 0.0036792755, 0.033935547, 0.019363403, -0.011444092, -0.016036987, -0.014274597, 0.024597168, 0.034973145, -0.009552002, 0.023269653, 0.01285553, 0.0039634705, -0.003900528, -0.008369446, -0.021408081, 0.0038852692, -0.007408142, 0.03894043, -0.007724762, -0.035217285, 0.01638794, -0.062805176, -0.0017957687, 0.0093688965, 0.047424316, -0.0049705505, 0.01876831, 0.02835083, 0.02418518, -0.02243042, 0.015792847, -0.027175903, -0.044769287, 0.0007452965, -0.009147644, -0.02609253, -0.014587402, 0.053649902, -0.003921509, -0.036346436, -0.02507019, -0.010826111, 0.0038909912, -0.025863647, 0.0088272095, -0.032348633, 0.0043029785, -0.012359619, -0.0020313263, -0.061431885, -0.021606445, -0.02180481, -0.037231445, -0.016723633, 0.08203125, 0.011955261, 0.046844482, 0.017120361, -0.04901123, -0.0039253235, 0.010192871, -0.004699707, 0.049438477, -0.01171875, -0.00667572, 0.023864746, 0.024627686, -0.04949951, 0.012062073, 0.025848389, 0.00037288666, -0.027297974, 0.013908386, 0.0004723072, -0.056732178, -0.0018310547, -0.022857666, 0.033050537, 0.021774292, 0.0056381226, 0.041534424, 0.021270752, -0.053894043, 0.06591797, 0.03010559, 0.06384277, -0.010826111, -0.07354736, -0.035125732, 0.016143799, -0.01260376, 0.035980225, -0.016174316, -0.073791504, 0.009651184, -0.012046814, -0.010681152, -0.01928711, 0.05319214, -0.011528015, 0.06573486, -0.011695862, -0.06274414, -0.044067383, -0.050994873, -0.022415161, 0.037963867, -0.031463623, -0.076049805, 0.038330078, -0.058746338, 0.0007715225, 0.0040016174, -0.0018072128, 0.03845215, -0.009399414, 0.04067993, -0.10418701, -0.01386261, -0.021408081, 0.06463623, 0.02368164, 0.045532227, -0.04333496, -0.019943237, 0.03286743, 0.027709961, 0.031173706, -0.04510498, -0.009010315, 0.012557983, 0.022247314, -0.010139465, -0.038085938, 0.00349617, 0.026275635, -0.0060310364, -0.04019165, -0.029693604, -0.034088135, -0.018585205, -0.000058352947, 0.019927979, -0.042877197, 0.04525757, -0.015617371, -0.01612854, 0.02293396, 0.00982666, 0.06518555, -0.0025234222, 0.026229858, 0.011192322, 0.011367798, -0.011009216, -0.030929565, 0.013641357, 0.006980896, 0.025390625, 0.020263672, -0.013671875, 0.031677246, 0.0048103333, -0.03543091, -0.06036377, 0.025344849, -0.056610107, 0.013755798, -0.013717651, 0.0039482117, 0.045135498, 0.033325195, 0.022949219, -0.0063819885, 0.022949219, 0.02230835, 0.0046424866, 0.024368286, 0.020217896, -0.038848877, 0.026626587, 0.018722534, -0.03225708, 0.048034668, 0.03768921, 0.034423828, -0.03353882, -0.024398804, 0.025024414, 0.011177063, 0.01499939, 0.022262573, -0.037841797, -0.019760132, 0.0018196106, -0.008544922, -0.008262634, -0.019180298, 0.0042419434, 0.013137817, 0.02557373, 0.069885254, -0.025894165, 0.07312012, -0.031097412, 0.022506714, -0.084350586, 0.0048561096, -0.017044067, -0.028320312, -0.011550903, 0.016204834, -0.038085938, 0.0014734268, 0.0015554428, 0.04864502, 0.07861328, 0.070617676, -0.0048103333, 0.04257202, 0.04763794, -0.011581421, 0.042236328, -0.03112793, 0.0070114136, -0.017440796, -0.011192322, 0.02355957, 0.0050964355, 0.011375427, 0.0034332275, -0.007129669, 0.026901245, -0.024154663, -0.020858765, -0.04434204, -0.011726379, 0.07891846, -0.024780273, 0.00289917, 0.01399231, 0.037506104, -0.052764893, -0.013168335, -0.01979065, 0.0006637573, -0.018569946, 0.019592285, 0.045837402, -0.029586792, -0.03466797, 0.02130127, 0.025131226, 0.061462402, 0.019256592, -0.03286743, 0.0049934387, 0.039886475, 0.0057792664, -0.014343262, -0.019348145, 0.05441284, 0.056121826, -0.08886719, 0.06347656, 0.049865723, -0.025741577, -0.043182373, 0.036865234, -0.029647827, -0.008514404, 0.040863037, 0.0044136047, -0.014533997, -0.04067993, 0.012359619, -0.023956299, -0.00086069107, 0.002878189, 0.03277588, 0.0031986237, 0.049804688, -0.0043678284, -0.03201294, 0.0001552105, -0.010147095, 0.006549835, -0.027420044, -0.0074157715, 0.024795532, 0.048431396, -0.00957489, -0.016159058, 0.04019165, -0.041259766, 0.026290894, -0.0181427, 0.0028820038, 0.018600464, -0.002254486, 0.0030498505, 0.005504608, -0.03842163, 0.018661499, -0.008857727, 0.060668945, 0.0087890625, -0.051818848, 0.040252686, 0.018829346, -0.028030396, -0.006263733, 0.026245117, 0.008575439, -0.005329132, 0.0023078918, 0.039489746, 0.0026474, -0.066345215, 0.042938232, 0.031799316, -0.02973938, -0.013664246, -0.006248474, -0.01940918, 0.008666992, -0.0074386597, 0.0046157837, -0.013435364, -0.041992188, 0.039093018, -0.008399963, 0.019500732, -0.04852295, -0.021743774, 0.0056266785, -0.01411438, -0.022262573, -0.03427124, 0.00522995, 0.0052452087, -0.012825012, 0.0056915283, -0.024398804, 0.038482666, -0.035705566, 0.043395996, -0.037109375, 0.0154800415, -0.035125732, 0.014060974, 0.036621094, 0.025604248, 0.06982422, 0.038726807, -0.012458801, 0.023101807, 0.006511688, -0.008338928 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2104.08336v2
Self-Supervised Graph Neural Networks for Improved Electroencephalographic Seizure Analysis
Siyi Tang, Jared A. Dunnmon, Khaled Saab, Xuan Zhang, Qianying Huang, Florian Dubost, Daniel L. Rubin, Christopher Lee-Messer
eess.SP, cs.AI, cs.LG
Automated seizure detection and classification from electroencephalography (EEG) can greatly improve seizure diagnosis and treatment. However, several modeling challenges remain unaddressed in prior automated seizure detection and classification studies: (1) representing non-Euclidean data structure in EEGs, (2) accurately classifying rare seizure types, and (3) lacking a quantitative interpretability approach to measure model ability to localize seizures. In this study, we address these challenges by (1) representing the spatiotemporal dependencies in EEGs using a graph neural network (GNN) and proposing two EEG graph structures that capture the electrode geometry or dynamic brain connectivity, (2) proposing a self-supervised pre-training method that predicts preprocessed signals for the next time period to further improve model performance, particularly on rare seizure types, and (3) proposing a quantitative model interpretability approach to assess a model's ability to localize seizures within EEGs. When evaluating our approach on seizure detection and classification on a large public dataset, we find that our GNN with self-supervised pre-training achieves 0.875 Area Under the Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve on seizure detection and 0.749 weighted F1-score on seizure classification, outperforming previous methods for both seizure detection and classification. Moreover, our self-supervised pre-training strategy significantly improves classification of rare seizure types. Furthermore, quantitative interpretability analysis shows that our GNN with self-supervised pre-training precisely localizes 25.4% focal seizures, a 21.9 point improvement over existing CNNs. Finally, by superimposing the identified seizure locations on both raw EEG signals and EEG graphs, our approach could provide clinicians with an intuitive visualization of localized seizure regions.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2104.08336v2
"2022-03-13T21:59:58"
"2021-04-16T20:32:10"
{ "title": [ 0.0039253235, 0.010978699, -0.0066604614, -0.036956787, -0.002412796, -0.0046463013, -0.02520752, -0.026321411, -0.020462036, 0.0423584, 0.021377563, 0.014404297, 0.010192871, -0.046813965, -0.031433105, 0.018035889, 0.017547607, 0.01991272, 0.011444092, -0.017547607, -0.003030777, -0.009483337, 0.0513916, 0.0051727295, 0.037628174, -0.033477783, -0.06161499, 0.027633667, -0.0132751465, -0.015365601, 0.014671326, -0.0061683655, 0.038085938, 0.02444458, -0.020507812, 0.012489319, -0.043701172, 0.027114868, 0.0052871704, -0.005634308, 0.010269165, -0.023330688, 0.043823242, -0.03326416, 0.02154541, 0.016418457, -0.027511597, -0.04776001, -0.016967773, 0.023468018, 0.030319214, 0.012535095, 0.024673462, 0.013031006, 0.0011005402, -0.017410278, -0.042633057, -0.029312134, 0.032196045, 0.09259033, 0.03866577, -0.032348633, -0.0051651, -0.034698486, -0.031677246, -0.03024292, -0.0016450882, 0.016220093, 0.075683594, -0.014228821, -0.029159546, 0.043914795, 0.017181396, 0.024887085, -0.055511475, -0.038269043, 0.07208252, 0.005088806, 0.033691406, -0.02619934, 0.0052223206, -0.0052108765, -0.016082764, -0.026275635, 0.033966064, -0.0069847107, -0.0047569275, -0.018539429, -0.04763794, -0.06903076, -0.017227173, -0.046783447, -0.05218506, 0.015655518, -0.004497528, -0.035003662, -0.012420654, -0.024810791, -0.0077590942, -0.04800415, 0.016403198, 0.008674622, -0.0703125, 0.020507812, 0.035491943, 0.00969696, -0.0524292, -0.056793213, 0.010353088, 0.030929565, -0.013977051, 0.0058021545, 0.040618896, 0.01828003, -0.023269653, -0.0119018555, 0.025894165, 0.010261536, 0.01966858, 0.018249512, 0.012237549, -0.013900757, -0.027145386, 0.0335083, 0.02822876, -0.0007839203, -0.021621704, 0.025497437, -0.005470276, 0.0036716461, 0.008361816, 0.041259766, -0.083496094, -0.06628418, -0.071899414, 0.037139893, -0.018066406, -0.0020122528, -0.0016450882, -0.0031719208, 0.04827881, -0.022384644, -0.0022735596, 0.022201538, 0.020767212, -0.0022621155, 0.034484863, 0.011764526, -0.032165527, -0.031097412, 0.002943039, 0.0055160522, 0.005443573, -0.00011605024, -0.01210022, -0.02218628, -0.107543945, -0.029815674, 0.0513916, 0.014915466, 0.020706177, 0.020095825, 0.006641388, 0.04623413, 0.048797607, -0.02760315, -0.011550903, 0.026794434, 0.00038290024, -0.000749588, -0.019470215, 0.03829956, 0.046417236, -0.036895752, -0.017074585, -0.012008667, 0.013198853, -0.047912598, 0.014472961, 0.030212402, 0.008216858, -0.019851685, -0.043884277, 0.0501709, -0.0715332, -0.03579712, -0.012992859, -0.0029010773, 0.10571289, -0.001534462, -0.06359863, -0.030380249, -0.017745972, -0.016967773, -0.028244019, -0.011039734, -0.0031394958, 0.019561768, -0.012207031, 0.0042381287, -0.05166626, 0.011390686, -0.03363037, 0.03616333, 0.024642944, -0.05496216, 0.0065727234, -0.009025574, 0.03112793, 0.027740479, 0.022735596, 0.0056152344, -0.016998291, -0.027633667, -0.046447754, -0.049957275, 0.04046631, 0.022750854, 0.0055999756, -0.0309906, 0.014373779, -0.0055732727, 0.028198242, 0.048553467, 0.034362793, -0.015602112, 0.0060691833, -0.03741455, 0.03137207, 0.0181427, 0.027740479, -0.0043258667, 0.007232666, -0.00223732, 0.001657486, -0.013130188, -0.011482239, -0.01612854, 0.02394104, 0.0038166046, 0.011703491, -0.0013799667, -0.005168915, 0.012641907, 0.03781128, 0.003982544, 0.015792847, -0.011558533, 0.001004219, -0.009750366, 0.062927246, 0.016189575, 0.038879395, 0.0041618347, 0.042999268, 0.04220581, 0.009971619, 0.035705566, -0.04196167, 0.015022278, -0.0054130554, 0.04220581, 0.018310547, 0.017303467, -0.0051498413, -0.028305054, -0.021560669, -0.023147583, 0.010177612, 0.0053901672, 0.0115737915, -0.08642578, 0.03213501, -0.022537231, -0.06109619, 0.009391785, -0.010261536, 0.027832031, 0.020355225, -0.059387207, -0.01525116, 0.007144928, 0.0063591003, -0.0057754517, 0.042938232, 0.024520874, -0.0025787354, -0.03970337, -0.008895874, -0.016586304, 0.022445679, 0.028213501, 0.017593384, -0.014060974, 0.011985779, -0.011962891, 0.049957275, 0.022598267, -0.00077724457, 0.026062012, -0.047454834, 0.03604126, 0.0095825195, 0.004108429, 0.008781433, 0.05810547, 0.019210815, 0.005821228, -0.02684021, 0.030914307, -0.045562744, -0.0008368492, 0.0041618347, -0.007873535, -0.062194824, -0.0725708, -0.03643799, -0.03778076, -0.07672119, -0.027359009, 0.041290283, 0.01171875, -0.048614502, -0.015365601, -0.0088272095, 0.0013818741, -0.044677734, -0.020736694, -0.030792236, 0.023773193, 0.02935791, 0.002828598, -0.037872314, 0.0423584, 0.012512207, 0.01852417, -0.014160156, 0.032226562, -0.021835327, 0.029556274, -0.005279541, -0.0072021484, 0.024719238, -0.066833496, -0.025466919, -0.0074806213, -0.0024909973, 0.028930664, -0.049438477, -0.032562256, 0.04248047, -0.021743774, -0.034332275, 0.043670654, 0.039367676, -0.030822754, 0.014808655, 0.043762207, 0.007282257, 0.01235199, 0.0062446594, 0.057434082, 0.013046265, -0.057861328, -0.03375244, -0.067871094, -0.020355225, 0.011245728, 0.030960083, 0.052093506, -0.040252686, 0.00049734116, -0.032989502, 0.0018577576, 0.041168213, -0.019104004, 0.00919342, -0.03237915, -0.035827637, -0.016448975, -0.032226562, -0.010612488, -0.039154053, 0.0039749146, 0.09039307, 0.0015325546, -0.016067505, 0.013465881, 0.03036499, 0.016830444, -0.017059326, -0.016937256, 0.0075187683, -0.020065308, 0.021224976, 0.013633728, -0.030593872, -0.027359009, -0.070373535, -0.011001587, 0.049743652, -0.0035533905, -0.02468872, 0.021026611, -0.037322998, -0.012123108, 0.008590698, -0.014915466, 0.020355225, 0.076293945, -0.024139404, 0.007949829, -0.024612427, 0.024169922, 0.02168274, -0.016708374, -0.041870117, 0.024993896, -0.014289856, -0.05307007, 0.0070152283, -0.039764404, -0.034454346, -0.014839172, -0.0007867813, -0.016525269, 0.03475952, -0.006263733, 0.0088272095, 0.011726379, -0.0017328262, -0.01360321, 0.015434265, -0.025344849, -0.027511597, -0.00078105927, -0.031799316, 0.026611328, 0.008979797, -0.006374359, -0.049438477, -0.021652222, 0.02128601, 0.05126953, 0.009933472, -0.035186768, -0.028015137, -0.029800415, -0.0287323, 0.011802673, 0.0063591003, 0.013839722, -0.0134887695, 0.008636475, -0.02305603, 0.05029297, 0.0009217262, -0.0049819946, -0.008239746, -0.04144287, -0.013847351, -0.009895325, -0.07147217, 0.00086021423, 0.015029907, -0.0038032532, -0.01777649, -0.0023403168, -0.02720642, 0.012992859, -0.004207611, 0.025238037, -0.038482666, -0.018417358, 0.03918457, 0.050231934, -0.05493164, -0.011451721, -0.0017967224, 0.040740967, -0.023834229, 0.009162903, -0.0184021, -0.045684814, 0.0050849915, 0.004135132, -0.054504395, -0.015602112, 0.031173706, -0.03378296, -0.008285522, -0.06414795, 0.006515503, 0.0042381287, -0.034729004, 0.01802063, -0.0046081543, -0.009376526, -0.0043678284, -0.053771973, -0.033569336, 0.057617188, -0.020523071, 0.014297485, -0.005443573, 0.012741089, 0.016159058, -0.029281616, 0.01651001, -0.05606079, 0.046844482, -0.02053833, -0.01209259, 0.05053711, -0.04083252, 0.02229309, 0.013313293, -0.0006289482, -0.006095886, 0.018081665, 0.0059890747, 0.023834229, -0.032226562, 0.06817627, 0.0019435883, -0.02319336, -0.08135986, -0.017196655, 0.00019800663, -0.016433716, -0.001531601, -0.005001068, 0.0011529922, 0.026748657, 0.014320374, 0.036865234, 0.009719849, -0.04058838, 0.00024938583, -0.016159058, 0.009284973, 0.016296387, 0.0035800934, 0.004234314, 0.002521515, 0.012962341, -0.0079956055, 0.025543213, -0.044006348, -0.043304443, 0.021499634, 0.039855957, -0.022369385, -0.0178833, -0.07513428, -0.052215576, -0.02178955, 0.0032958984, -0.009780884, 0.03152466, 0.024871826, 0.0021018982, -0.035217285, 0.027755737, 0.023010254, -0.0020599365, -0.0209198, -0.06536865, -0.007221222, -0.025360107, -0.05505371, -0.035217285, -0.03326416, -0.017028809, 0.015914917, -0.005859375, -0.027648926, -0.0033569336, 0.033172607, 0.07110596, 0.058532715, -0.014984131, -0.07543945, -0.021377563, -0.009605408, -0.005794525, 0.0068244934, 0.019363403, -0.027404785, -0.04144287, -0.009788513, -0.0054092407, -0.0053749084, -0.033447266, -0.0049057007, -0.015022278, 0.02255249, -0.009971619, 0.008125305, 0.014671326, -0.0053215027, 0.043518066, 0.008888245, -0.026794434, -0.016433716, 0.035369873, 0.029846191, 0.015655518, 0.015129089, 0.059387207, 0.0052948, -0.011116028, 0.012969971, -0.0013360977, 0.03704834, 0.0030460358, 0.0018835068, 0.03036499, -0.07574463, -0.03970337, -0.014297485, -0.014152527, 0.035888672, -0.08654785, 0.066589355, 0.018295288, -0.023010254, 0.059295654, 0.0037231445, -0.0030822754, 0.001405716, -0.0069236755, -0.04989624, -0.04888916, -0.007545471, 0.047302246, -0.035888672, -0.016342163, -0.0067596436, 0.046173096, 0.03225708, 0.035583496, 0.0032215118, 0.0027179718, -0.037353516, -0.0013055801, 0.012954712, -0.041778564, -0.034729004, 0.0030708313, 0.018920898, -0.00070619583, -0.07006836, -0.0012493134, -0.026138306, -0.018295288, -0.01537323, 0.019424438, 0.010574341, -0.04953003, 0.02394104, 0.08306885, 0.014167786, 0.0006136894, -0.015838623, 0.020568848, 0.010917664, 0.03881836, 0.003156662, 0.016860962, 0.041870117, -0.041778564, 0.059326172, 0.013282776, 0.012054443, -0.027420044, 0.037872314, -0.016540527, 0.023147583, -0.052856445, 0.029327393, 0.008583069, 0.009231567, -0.005554199, -0.044311523, 0.027130127, -0.012588501, -0.027069092, 0.009887695, -0.046966553, -0.007583618, 0.0024223328, -0.03967285, -0.026885986, 0.020828247, -0.010551453, -0.022247314, -0.07739258, 0.019958496, -0.040802002, 0.0069122314, -0.022277832, 0.013442993, -0.042633057, 0.026245117, 0.052764893, -0.03552246, 0.030258179, -0.013061523, 0.014419556, 0.0592041, 0.017562866, -0.029632568, 0.0034332275, -0.017349243, -0.047851562, -0.059265137, -0.0039482117, -0.007156372, 0.0009036064, 0.02041626, -0.0074882507, -0.020355225, 0.007858276, 0.025466919, -0.03050232, -0.02218628, 0.054656982, 0.004589081, 0.0087509155, -0.0036907196, -0.011909485, 0.017700195, 0.004764557, -0.00617218, 0.0021514893, -0.0025939941, 0.03604126, 0.03074646, -0.03289795, -0.041015625, -0.01109314, 0.02027893, 0.00034499168, -0.028778076, 0.007041931, 0.028503418, -0.076538086, -0.008323669, -0.011856079, 0.064331055, -0.066711426, -0.06542969, -0.051971436, 0.0058631897, -0.026687622, 0.05886841, -0.028533936, -0.072143555, -0.009712219, -0.07659912, -0.038269043, 0.01725769, 0.05215454, 0.025772095, 0.038085938, -0.085754395, -0.010620117, -0.040374756, 0.0181427, -0.02508545, 0.012992859, -0.017471313, 0.008834839, -0.022644043, 0.02772522, 0.014976501, -0.046691895, 0.017913818, -0.012176514, 0.017166138, -0.035095215, -0.014038086, 0.0076904297, -0.02760315, -0.034088135, 0.005302429, 0.028503418, -0.020751953, 0.050048828, -0.048828125, 0.050048828, -0.005996704, 0.032196045, 0.019958496, 0.008552551, -0.00080013275, -0.008407593, -0.014724731, -0.04537964, 0.0023097992, -0.060546875, -0.00016355515, -0.06390381, 0.0013427734, -0.053253174, 0.01689148, 0.0003244877, 0.05886841, 0.019226074, 0.0031394958, 0.019866943, -0.008674622, 0.033203125, 0.025665283, 0.08087158, 0.029159546, 0.0075950623, -0.017944336, 0.034179688, 0.05508423, 0.029464722, 0.036315918, 0.012168884, -0.007965088, -0.02357483, 0.03475952, 0.020217896, -0.006603241, -0.0043678284, 0.006702423, -0.03060913, 0.049926758, 0.013572693, 0.031707764, 0.0034275055, 0.05935669, -0.04421997, 0.017028809, -0.00050640106, -0.010765076, -0.010299683, -0.024368286, 0.042053223, -0.103759766, 0.02116394, 0.011978149, -0.012893677, 0.030838013, 0.048217773, 0.023422241, -0.059417725, -0.0069618225, 0.0152282715, 0.023101807, -0.0017032623, 0.011230469, -0.03390503, 0.011199951, 0.018615723, 0.0051498413, 0.0031833649, 0.009559631, 0.04498291, 0.012779236, -0.029037476, -0.011390686, -0.016616821, 0.020996094, -0.057159424, 0.027511597, -0.02619934, 0.013938904, 0.011512756, -0.04083252, 0.008529663, 0.012397766, 0.0011129379, -0.020584106, 0.037078857, -0.0036144257, 0.01687622, 0.04727173, 0.029907227, -0.011260986, -0.03967285, -0.05557251, 0.010353088, 0.017410278, -0.031341553, 0.020217896, -0.031921387, -0.03152466, 0.02029419, -0.030136108, 0.050323486, -0.05117798, 0.008155823, -0.026779175, 0.021133423, 0.008277893, -0.03564453, -0.03378296, -0.014770508, -0.06427002, 0.01335907, 0.01361084, -0.018798828, 0.0006699562, -0.009384155, -0.04083252, 0.036132812, -0.0070991516, -0.016357422, -0.005088806, -0.0335083, 0.03488159, -0.026748657, 0.047607422, -0.016616821, -0.012489319, -0.016159058, -0.0015459061, -0.024276733, 0.013114929, 0.0052375793, 0.004787445, -0.057037354, -0.029388428, 0.0002104044, 0.021316528, -0.014816284, 0.0033435822, -0.027908325, 0.016159058, -0.017974854, -0.0058021545, 0.028579712, -0.030929565, -0.02720642, -0.0053596497, -0.042877197, 0.017364502, 0.013191223, -0.010444641, -0.00548172, 0.028213501, -0.038513184, 0.018066406, 0.009254456, 0.052093506, -0.015419006, -0.053497314, 0.010932922, 0.026824951, 0.036071777, -0.023452759, -0.010894775, 0.03643799, 0.019515991, -0.036499023, 0.01965332, 0.0098724365, -0.0052261353, 0.054138184, 0.025878906, 0.0074806213, -0.026031494, -0.10974121, -0.052886963, 0.06921387, 0.042053223, -0.006729126, -0.055511475, 0.053771973, 0.0029296875, -0.012199402, 0.021743774, -0.0131073, -0.0028934479, 0.0018539429, -0.0051651, -0.01373291, -0.06573486, 0.0048446655, -0.0013284683, 0.016311646, 0.04864502, -0.021987915, -0.004184723, -0.009124756, 0.024658203, -0.020904541, 0.0030574799, 0.024734497, 0.004837036, 0.02859497, -0.007774353, 0.0035438538, 0.017913818, -0.0026836395, -0.025238037, -0.006980896, -0.026916504, 0.06390381, -0.05001831, -0.0093307495, -0.047790527, -0.04107666, -0.020507812, -0.0446167, 0.05038452, -0.06359863, 0.011413574, -0.050445557, -0.010467529, 0.0026779175, 0.013877869, 0.03375244, 0.0033836365, -0.033599854, -0.059906006, 0.030563354, -0.012283325 ], "summary": [ 0.057250977, 0.052642822, 0.03717041, 0.020858765, 0.0018730164, -0.031433105, -0.0048294067, -0.10882568, 0.015327454, 0.022216797, 0.0020484924, -0.020309448, 0.019363403, -0.057281494, -0.0010070801, -0.00919342, 0.042999268, -0.00051116943, 0.049041748, -0.0047912598, -0.0073928833, 0.03390503, 0.042785645, 0.01309967, 0.020507812, -0.017105103, -0.0473938, 0.03878784, -0.003019333, 0.028625488, 0.013130188, -0.013427734, -0.0036773682, 0.008956909, 0.025726318, -0.03048706, 0.0035381317, 0.01600647, 0.016845703, 0.005771637, 0.0042419434, -0.014434814, 0.11456299, -0.0025749207, 0.02810669, 0.034118652, 0.011688232, -0.04928589, 0.016494751, 0.010070801, 0.016586304, -0.0005970001, 0.00059461594, -0.038391113, -0.023513794, -0.0022525787, -0.056365967, -0.03842163, 0.01914978, 0.12243652, 0.03378296, -0.020401001, -0.014656067, -0.08441162, -0.019607544, -0.00422287, 0.02671814, 0.003490448, 0.05569458, 0.00198555, -0.00642395, 0.031097412, 0.010246277, -0.007911682, -0.052215576, -0.0090789795, 0.049987793, 0.004421234, 0.007419586, -0.02708435, 0.03488159, -0.014556885, 0.028549194, -0.032806396, 0.029708862, -0.0046691895, 0.0035209656, -0.0079574585, -0.0040397644, -0.055358887, -0.017745972, -0.058563232, -0.07684326, 0.064697266, 0.026153564, -0.045776367, -0.039916992, -0.056854248, -0.017852783, -0.013717651, 0.020477295, -0.0065574646, -0.030395508, 0.024642944, 0.006385803, 0.02720642, -0.031799316, -0.048217773, 0.020980835, 0.016525269, -0.010131836, -0.019607544, -0.00069236755, -0.025039673, -0.035980225, 0.014976501, 0.01852417, -0.014541626, 0.003967285, -0.0023155212, 0.005218506, 0.025161743, -0.06439209, 0.05368042, -0.013549805, -0.01828003, 0.017089844, 0.021316528, -0.026367188, 0.049713135, 0.0059165955, 0.0074882507, -0.053100586, -0.021560669, -0.07525635, -0.010620117, 0.013977051, -0.0181427, 0.022323608, -0.04663086, 0.091430664, 0.013328552, 0.0024967194, 0.054748535, 0.0032634735, 0.006832123, 0.022399902, 0.014350891, 0.0022945404, -0.050628662, 0.042114258, 0.018585205, 0.008369446, 0.00995636, 0.008872986, -0.019180298, -0.023391724, -0.018005371, 0.037597656, 0.0002322197, 0.06237793, 0.007133484, -0.011016846, 0.020584106, -0.01713562, -0.02671814, -0.027893066, -0.0031585693, 0.014579773, -0.03744507, -0.0066184998, 0.07128906, 0.063964844, -0.021224976, 0.0074882507, -0.026550293, -0.02835083, -0.02355957, 0.014465332, 0.023010254, 0.0025310516, -0.024612427, -0.025283813, 0.033447266, -0.018157959, -0.06222534, 0.004940033, 0.017501831, 0.074523926, 0.02619934, -0.032318115, -0.066467285, -0.019104004, 0.014831543, 0.008308411, 0.015975952, -0.023910522, 0.014549255, -0.019897461, -0.023910522, -0.026519775, -0.007583618, 0.011764526, 0.012680054, 0.025680542, -0.040649414, 0.009841919, -0.003829956, 0.059539795, -0.022476196, -0.019485474, -0.013519287, 0.004585266, -0.0446167, -0.08496094, -0.029418945, 0.011978149, -0.014526367, -0.0015888214, -0.028244019, 0.021850586, 0.0014629364, -0.005554199, 0.028671265, 0.046142578, 0.023666382, -0.010192871, 0.004638672, 0.07775879, 0.029876709, 0.010879517, -0.021118164, 0.0065994263, -0.01574707, -0.013069153, 0.012252808, 0.035186768, -0.05581665, 0.023345947, 0.032836914, 0.028060913, 0.020935059, -0.007663727, -0.008666992, 0.056396484, 0.009849548, 0.023773193, -0.040802002, -0.01977539, -0.007385254, -0.020736694, 0.005065918, 0.035705566, -0.01864624, -0.0035991669, 0.045043945, 0.017425537, 0.005897522, 0.000562191, 0.024536133, -0.018920898, 0.029678345, -0.010749817, 0.008041382, 0.04348755, -0.04748535, -0.010025024, -0.03717041, 0.010559082, -0.024459839, -0.005332947, -0.107421875, 0.02507019, 0.014328003, -0.076171875, -0.015434265, -0.026031494, 0.026687622, 0.020950317, -0.005722046, -0.010177612, 0.0262146, -0.039245605, -0.023742676, 0.009101868, 0.020843506, -0.024917603, -0.026519775, 0.038970947, 0.035003662, 0.019943237, 0.052825928, 0.02696228, 0.009712219, 0.046813965, -0.0037403107, 0.015571594, -0.04434204, 0.033691406, -0.034118652, 0.041046143, 0.04598999, -0.03274536, 0.014144897, 0.004650116, 0.0284729, 0.0141067505, -0.004627228, 0.004962921, 0.024108887, -0.028717041, 0.0064811707, 0.023101807, 0.06970215, -0.05960083, -0.075805664, -0.04840088, 0.012542725, -0.04421997, -0.018676758, 0.050201416, 0.047790527, -0.0016117096, -0.012557983, 0.019241333, -0.033569336, -0.011367798, -0.010787964, -0.028762817, 0.0045928955, -0.008903503, -0.028213501, -0.011581421, 0.06402588, 0.011238098, 0.0037117004, 0.01612854, -0.02923584, -0.00248909, 0.0059394836, 0.038116455, 0.0446167, 0.010002136, -0.012870789, -0.04559326, 0.024673462, 0.007396698, 0.024780273, -0.079589844, -0.047180176, 0.05114746, -0.049804688, -0.044952393, 0.059051514, 0.00982666, -0.01889038, 0.05230713, 0.024856567, -0.0016584396, -0.01802063, 0.038146973, 0.038970947, 0.028030396, -0.07501221, -0.028671265, -0.0637207, -0.025848389, -0.0000821352, 0.031051636, 0.036132812, -0.051452637, 0.01184082, -0.035369873, 0.011482239, 0.04296875, 0.02027893, 0.043670654, -0.046417236, -0.016967773, 0.023406982, -0.023635864, 0.017715454, -0.018737793, 0.016342163, 0.06890869, -0.008583069, -0.012817383, 0.04296875, 0.014770508, 0.01197052, -0.028182983, -0.0039634705, 0.0021972656, -0.033416748, 0.015235901, 0.0060195923, -0.025405884, -0.008026123, -0.01890564, -0.0155181885, 0.0019836426, -0.0035247803, -0.013183594, -0.019943237, -0.007820129, -0.00818634, -0.0016775131, -0.026260376, 0.00024318695, 0.051849365, 0.022827148, -0.0028648376, 0.017562866, 0.024475098, 0.014892578, -0.016113281, 0.03125, 0.013130188, -0.03869629, -0.011253357, 0.01586914, 0.045562744, -0.052856445, -0.03552246, 0.011703491, -0.019210815, 0.0076942444, -0.02482605, 0.0021572113, 0.052581787, 0.0019798279, 0.0019140244, 0.015914917, -0.0011758804, -0.043182373, -0.00058460236, -0.025466919, -0.016571045, 0.01940918, -0.044830322, -0.00894165, -0.03414917, 0.005935669, 0.026611328, 0.00541687, -0.019638062, -0.03744507, 0.0082092285, -0.004814148, 0.013771057, 0.029541016, 0.006259918, 0.023712158, 0.013320923, -0.032165527, 0.0032691956, 0.0035953522, -0.00091695786, 0.08093262, -0.070251465, -0.059448242, -0.011940002, -0.05029297, -0.014678955, 0.007232666, 0.01399231, -0.039520264, 0.017608643, -0.0033035278, -0.009681702, 0.021194458, 0.028778076, -0.055114746, -0.0013170242, 0.02696228, 0.025009155, -0.022369385, -0.0040359497, 0.046691895, 0.0446167, -0.041107178, 0.011871338, -0.027282715, -0.04574585, -0.0011720657, 0.0048942566, -0.022079468, -0.022842407, 0.009803772, 0.010406494, -0.0077209473, -0.035583496, 0.012214661, 0.0038166046, -0.022506714, 0.03250122, -0.0031776428, 0.0836792, -0.023010254, -0.049804688, -0.036865234, -0.02355957, 0.0037899017, 0.018051147, -0.044677734, 0.047088623, 0.057617188, 0.0060310364, 0.012252808, -0.07165527, 0.041168213, -0.06628418, -0.031555176, 0.037506104, -0.04824829, 0.020904541, 0.00299263, -0.026992798, 0.0038986206, 0.02909851, 0.041503906, 0.076416016, -0.020446777, 0.03616333, 0.0019702911, -0.010971069, -0.05206299, -0.0067977905, 0.019332886, -0.027893066, -0.014694214, -0.002588272, -0.047088623, 0.032043457, 0.047088623, 0.017929077, 0.0015439987, -0.048797607, -0.027648926, 0.019699097, 0.004135132, 0.021255493, 0.0046310425, 0.028198242, -0.01713562, -0.021057129, -0.018997192, -0.018875122, -0.0036087036, -0.046295166, 0.020248413, 0.037139893, -0.040130615, -0.033691406, -0.011253357, -0.019683838, -0.0158844, 0.0018444061, -0.03289795, 0.010566711, -0.015075684, -0.040863037, 0.0002667904, 0.03475952, -0.048614502, 0.015655518, -0.048431396, -0.051452637, -0.04650879, -0.031143188, -0.046203613, -0.028915405, -0.048980713, -0.017929077, -0.033996582, 0.03274536, -0.018676758, -0.020309448, 0.026947021, 0.036193848, 0.035095215, 0.0020713806, -0.0748291, -0.079956055, -0.015022278, -0.0154953, -0.021820068, -0.025344849, -0.042053223, -0.03213501, 0.02178955, 0.00034952164, 0.0124053955, -0.015235901, -0.01789856, -0.033172607, 0.030090332, -0.0052261353, 0.013336182, -0.003042221, 0.012428284, 0.020080566, -0.0095825195, -0.0031471252, -0.013328552, 0.03387451, 0.00819397, 0.01020813, 0.011772156, 0.05822754, -0.012687683, -0.038604736, 0.025039673, -0.0070724487, 0.030792236, 0.022872925, 0.00014698505, 0.032043457, -0.021972656, -0.026901245, 0.021514893, -0.012260437, 0.013832092, -0.009101868, 0.034820557, 0.01576233, -0.001004219, 0.08770752, 0.0023269653, -0.032592773, 0.028900146, -0.0234375, -0.046173096, -0.029846191, -0.004722595, 0.026687622, -0.02973938, -0.023330688, -0.017456055, 0.010566711, 0.0022697449, 0.014945984, 0.008369446, 0.011932373, -0.0032405853, -0.011299133, 0.020141602, -0.0022888184, -0.0053520203, -0.01550293, 0.0259552, -0.025817871, -0.07543945, 0.017120361, 0.027893066, -0.012390137, 0.004142761, 0.046539307, 0.0020923615, -0.019592285, -0.019805908, 0.052978516, -0.008529663, -0.029769897, -0.024139404, 0.014381409, -0.022216797, 0.011459351, -0.024490356, -0.01625061, 0.0011425018, -0.029876709, 0.037475586, 0.0135650635, -0.0007276535, 0.021774292, -0.0040016174, -0.005634308, -0.0067481995, 0.002067566, 0.0018634796, 0.0018758774, 0.027938843, -0.046447754, -0.006351471, 0.038330078, -0.014801025, -0.010620117, 0.005050659, -0.020996094, 0.009925842, 0.010986328, -0.020462036, -0.005153656, 0.024169922, -0.008811951, 0.017196655, -0.082458496, -0.00073099136, -0.06518555, 0.026977539, -0.017822266, 0.017913818, -0.0048828125, -0.020065308, 0.021713257, -0.004348755, 0.0077552795, -0.002368927, 0.017715454, 0.0006942749, -0.012641907, 0.013473511, 0.009361267, -0.026107788, -0.044403076, -0.07696533, -0.0075569153, -0.043548584, 0.026489258, 0.017471313, 0.0423584, -0.010284424, -0.03012085, 0.011749268, -0.03213501, -0.03527832, 0.05606079, -0.012359619, -0.027267456, -0.013587952, -0.042510986, -0.04232788, 0.0051345825, 0.018218994, 0.006843567, -0.0072746277, 0.032989502, 0.028289795, -0.016464233, -0.026229858, -0.014984131, 0.028305054, 0.0020122528, -0.01626587, -0.016021729, 0.0054016113, -0.06335449, -0.012794495, -0.017715454, 0.05407715, -0.042816162, -0.057495117, -0.042510986, 0.030517578, -0.0066566467, 0.019546509, -0.029251099, -0.074523926, 0.019897461, -0.061798096, -0.0058288574, -0.004032135, 0.04095459, 0.018997192, 0.027435303, -0.065979004, -0.039764404, -0.028656006, 0.0008678436, 0.003730774, 0.0099487305, -0.017608643, 0.030197144, -0.024520874, 0.0012893677, -0.0016288757, -0.02973938, -0.027160645, -0.007335663, 0.044433594, -0.029693604, 0.01739502, -0.0031414032, -0.014717102, 0.04324341, 0.020080566, 0.03994751, -0.031204224, 0.0060310364, -0.018371582, 0.03842163, 0.012763977, -0.052520752, -0.04095459, -0.03262329, -0.010749817, -0.009155273, -0.03994751, -0.027770996, 0.031433105, -0.00075244904, -0.036376953, -0.06549072, -0.03817749, -0.02407837, 0.052703857, -0.030151367, -0.002166748, 0.031555176, -0.0072135925, 0.017913818, 0.041931152, -0.022735596, 0.03363037, 0.02810669, 0.05819702, 0.012687683, -0.021621704, 0.00006324053, 0.005970001, 0.030838013, 0.04638672, 0.0032730103, -0.0044288635, -0.0043907166, 0.054229736, -0.022216797, -0.020843506, -0.044769287, 0.025100708, -0.04534912, 0.020812988, 0.005947113, 0.032226562, 0.0062942505, 0.0058670044, -0.012069702, 0.0019340515, -0.0018606186, 0.0011253357, -0.00983429, -0.028656006, 0.0039100647, -0.014060974, -0.040405273, -0.008613586, 0.010726929, 0.046966553, 0.048583984, 0.041412354, -0.04550171, 0.015113831, 0.01928711, 0.0013933182, -0.021438599, 0.008743286, -0.030380249, -0.027526855, -0.02659607, -0.0050086975, 0.011352539, -0.002506256, -0.015945435, -0.015083313, -0.0035629272, -0.006000519, -0.001206398, 0.026062012, 0.0045394897, 0.020950317, -0.013885498, 0.004009247, 0.011276245, -0.020599365, 0.01550293, 0.033294678, 0.0016202927, 0.006336212, 0.06842041, -0.03161621, 0.022033691, 0.024169922, -0.028198242, 0.016860962, -0.005176544, -0.039489746, 0.013046265, -0.019943237, -0.010467529, -0.014030457, -0.0025863647, 0.0035190582, 0.028778076, 0.014045715, 0.04647827, -0.056427002, -0.008361816, -0.027297974, 0.021194458, -0.0725708, 0.018753052, -0.0007266998, -0.02973938, -0.022033691, 0.046905518, 0.05859375, 0.0034542084, 0.04284668, 0.025772095, -0.05795288, 0.07220459, 0.007549286, 0.019561768, -0.0087890625, -0.029174805, 0.031097412, 0.020339966, 0.0793457, 0.012138367, -0.024093628, 0.031188965, -0.033843994, -0.0076065063, 0.014289856, 0.018798828, 0.014297485, -0.03918457, -0.0635376, 0.039794922, 0.013908386, -0.028640747, 0.013023376, 0.0037841797, 0.00983429, -0.0033893585, 0.03161621, 0.026443481, -0.0077552795, -0.023651123, 0.0047302246, -0.042877197, 0.035858154, 0.0012340546, -0.008522034, -0.021148682, 0.017120361, -0.014785767, -0.013511658, 0.016159058, 0.026290894, -0.04421997, -0.050476074, 0.007255554, 0.02470398, 0.02532959, -0.009597778, 0.016143799, 0.042907715, -0.008201599, -0.0063285828, -0.018966675, -0.035217285, -0.0037879944, 0.07305908, 0.035827637, 0.018875122, -0.020141602, -0.076660156, -0.036499023, 0.05456543, 0.003730774, -0.011207581, -0.04574585, 0.019134521, -0.020248413, -0.04434204, 0.021560669, -0.00907135, -0.032958984, 0.021087646, -0.016952515, -0.03173828, -0.03366089, 0.03074646, -0.014770508, 0.007881165, 0.014129639, -0.012001038, -0.012145996, -0.027542114, -0.009208679, 0.006324768, 0.07873535, -0.025436401, -0.051513672, 0.06549072, -0.047058105, 0.043395996, 0.030334473, 0.04135132, -0.045318604, 0.0072021484, -0.05822754, 0.02394104, -0.06616211, -0.06414795, -0.08392334, -0.00995636, 0.0028743744, -0.016204834, 0.024658203, -0.040893555, 0.0006790161, -0.018936157, -0.03149414, 0.018981934, 0.020019531, -0.0026626587, 0.019088745, -0.008476257, -0.060821533, -0.0065994263, 0.005092621 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2104.08337v1
Identification of mental fatigue in language comprehension tasks based on EEG and deep learning
Chunhua Ye, Zhong Yin, Chenxi Wu, Xiayidai Abulaiti, Yixing Zhang, Zhenqi Sun, Jianhua Zhang
cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.SP
Mental fatigue increases the risk of operator error in language comprehension tasks. In order to prevent operator performance degradation, we used EEG signals to assess the mental fatigue of operators in human-computer systems. This study presents an experimental design for fatigue detection in language comprehension tasks. We obtained EEG signals from a 14-channel wireless EEG detector in 15 healthy participants. Each participant was given a cognitive test of a language comprehension task, in the form of multiple choice questions, in which pronoun references were selected between nominal and surrogate sentences. In this paper, the 2400 EEG fragments collected are divided into three data sets according to different utilization rates, namely 1200s data set with 50% utilization rate, 1500s data set with 62.5% utilization rate, and 1800s data set with 75% utilization rate. In the aspect of feature extraction, different EEG features were extracted, including time domain features, frequency domain features and entropy features, and the effects of different features and feature combinations on classification accuracy were explored. In terms of classification, we introduced the Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) method as the preferred method, It was compared with Least Squares Support Vector Machines(LSSVM),Support Vector Machines(SVM),Logistic Regression (LR), Random Forest(RF), Naive Bayes (NB), K-Nearest Neighbor (KNN) and Decision Tree(DT).According to the results, the classification accuracy of convolutional neural network (CNN) is higher than that of other classification methods. The classification results show that the classification accuracy of 1200S dataset is higher than the other two datasets. The combination of Frequency and entropy feature and CNN has the highest classification accuracy, which is 85.34%.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2104.08337v1
"2021-04-14T14:00:57"
"2021-04-14T14:00:57"
{ "title": [ -0.011230469, 0.025115967, -0.025375366, 0.00055503845, -0.008880615, -0.020080566, -0.03353882, -0.04864502, 0.005924225, 0.03692627, -0.025817871, -0.0357666, 0.023391724, -0.035186768, -0.05999756, -0.024505615, -0.0140686035, 0.057495117, 0.009712219, -0.036346436, 0.014892578, -0.031463623, 0.022705078, 0.031555176, 0.01033783, -0.03753662, -0.10424805, 0.028259277, -0.052947998, -0.039031982, -0.016921997, 0.0362854, 0.050476074, 0.017593384, -0.05795288, -0.023880005, -0.040924072, 0.019180298, -0.006980896, -0.0049057007, 0.02420044, -0.019989014, -0.017227173, -0.016540527, -0.023895264, 0.033294678, -0.049865723, -0.036193848, 0.0259552, 0.029754639, -0.0047950745, 0.027069092, -0.009757996, 0.0134887695, -0.004058838, -0.022705078, -0.039916992, -0.012916565, 0.027313232, 0.0725708, 0.021820068, -0.02758789, -0.00687027, -0.019607544, -0.030273438, -0.01335907, -0.03918457, 0.027313232, 0.07324219, 0.0052833557, -0.023849487, 0.028030396, 0.03555298, -0.0002270937, -0.04324341, -0.019989014, 0.026626587, 0.0060195923, 0.04751587, -0.04977417, -0.046447754, 0.0029449463, -0.03100586, -0.033172607, 0.016220093, -0.0317688, -0.036376953, -0.005760193, -0.05441284, -0.06451416, -0.016235352, -0.02798462, -0.036895752, -0.012916565, -0.00415802, -0.044128418, 0.0017290115, 0.030471802, -0.018463135, -0.031951904, -0.047332764, 0.046569824, -0.07904053, -0.012817383, 0.016921997, -0.001367569, -0.0496521, -0.048217773, 0.037597656, 0.045654297, -0.02079773, 0.015090942, 0.00011193752, -0.038208008, 0.00080776215, 0.039520264, 0.014076233, 0.02659607, 0.040496826, 0.036468506, -0.027862549, -0.012077332, -0.04248047, 0.021530151, 0.049346924, 0.013595581, -0.0044555664, 0.04486084, 0.008003235, 0.013977051, 0.0060539246, 0.039916992, -0.07171631, -0.054382324, -0.04623413, 0.03152466, -0.019348145, 0.013092041, -0.007160187, 0.004486084, -0.0041503906, -0.013969421, 0.0234375, -0.0075302124, 0.019592285, 0.023101807, 0.06402588, -0.007045746, -0.05050659, -0.042755127, -0.014968872, 0.01586914, 0.01940918, 0.0038757324, -0.0725708, 0.0025100708, -0.1451416, -0.0008254051, 0.025238037, 0.028518677, -0.0041618347, -0.00053071976, -0.019210815, 0.02192688, 0.04562378, 0.01058197, -0.017303467, 0.024795532, 0.0047836304, -0.014671326, -0.009849548, 0.023391724, 0.04071045, -0.029006958, -0.00806427, 0.012931824, 0.023468018, -0.0057678223, 0.009498596, -0.0054969788, 0.0074768066, -0.015716553, -0.00548172, 0.03237915, -0.04928589, -0.046569824, 0.0060920715, 0.008361816, 0.06726074, 0.016174316, -0.025283813, -0.012023926, -0.028686523, -0.033111572, -0.029006958, -0.04067993, 0.08068848, 0.0079193115, 0.014343262, 0.0064430237, -0.013664246, -0.013717651, -0.02015686, -0.028884888, -0.07867432, -0.049194336, -0.033172607, 0.011932373, 0.055877686, 0.019134521, 0.0054244995, 0.003458023, -0.015701294, -0.03277588, -0.069885254, -0.024673462, 0.03062439, -0.0011301041, 0.009933472, -0.013053894, 0.0008993149, 0.0034713745, 0.00409317, 0.034118652, 0.022094727, -0.004989624, 0.016921997, -0.041107178, 0.06427002, 0.008354187, 0.0949707, -0.031234741, 0.045562744, 0.035888672, -0.012367249, 0.00774765, 0.0024871826, -0.00020003319, -0.002210617, 0.00054216385, 0.0049934387, -0.0033740997, 0.010009766, 0.04547119, 0.025604248, -0.023406982, 0.005622864, 0.01234436, -0.011917114, 0.022094727, 0.005268097, 0.015007019, 0.039794922, 0.011062622, -0.041015625, 0.075927734, -0.007904053, -0.021652222, -0.007247925, -0.0069770813, 0.028823853, -0.016036987, -0.02104187, -0.0058517456, -0.066589355, 0.006465912, -0.032104492, -0.009254456, -0.0063552856, 0.0041046143, 0.018127441, -0.022094727, 0.029693604, 0.011253357, -0.048095703, -0.03100586, -0.025405884, 0.026138306, 0.01739502, -0.04638672, -0.038970947, 0.020492554, 0.0053138733, -0.01600647, -0.024627686, -0.016342163, 0.018539429, -0.04324341, 0.011009216, -0.0023498535, 0.015640259, 0.054107666, -0.0026283264, 0.028137207, 0.037353516, 0.002922058, 0.043548584, 0.027069092, 0.0002605915, 0.009185791, -0.03665161, 0.027893066, -0.018417358, 0.009490967, 0.0015468597, 0.057281494, -0.0072135925, 0.025115967, -0.019348145, 0.0047683716, -0.040130615, 0.0018844604, 0.0059127808, 0.009109497, -0.04547119, -0.05722046, -0.030273438, -0.0076293945, -0.049346924, -0.018081665, 0.052886963, -0.029891968, -0.04284668, -0.012290955, -0.019515991, 0.0024280548, -0.021438599, -0.026794434, 0.004310608, 0.031051636, 0.02494812, 0.013320923, -0.053131104, -0.037139893, -0.006214142, 0.01197052, 0.0087509155, -0.0049324036, -0.023864746, 0.0011692047, -0.004749298, -0.03314209, 0.0043182373, -0.024337769, -0.016036987, -0.016113281, 0.003967285, 0.01864624, -0.05709839, 0.005706787, 0.021850586, -0.02180481, -0.018508911, 0.020980835, 0.045806885, -0.0262146, -0.010246277, 0.024017334, 0.0020694733, -0.022827148, -0.0014066696, 0.021621704, -0.012107849, -0.030395508, 0.011581421, -0.036987305, -0.020523071, -0.0077819824, -0.0031528473, 0.046569824, -0.038146973, -0.011276245, -0.035827637, -0.0077323914, 0.01008606, 0.0141067505, -0.017318726, -0.030044556, -0.04333496, -0.03955078, -0.008117676, -0.0132369995, -0.015731812, -0.0019483566, 0.07751465, 0.016204834, -0.015388489, -0.029891968, 0.039520264, 0.01991272, -0.0036735535, -0.038024902, 0.010574341, 0.0037384033, 0.012870789, 0.010429382, -0.027404785, -0.045410156, -0.08843994, 0.0026664734, 0.0848999, 0.0071105957, -0.017700195, 0.047454834, -0.052978516, 0.012672424, 0.03527832, 0.002117157, 0.026229858, 0.057434082, -0.0035247803, 0.022720337, -0.015136719, 0.025924683, 0.011955261, -0.016067505, -0.09100342, 0.017227173, -0.006072998, -0.023605347, -0.00033974648, -0.043395996, -0.042633057, -0.007873535, 0.021255493, 0.061462402, 0.025314331, -0.030899048, 0.049591064, 0.0012083054, 0.01626587, -0.0020179749, 0.0036087036, -0.0033855438, 0.011268616, 0.022064209, -0.014884949, -0.0036811829, 0.007888794, -0.0070381165, 0.0008506775, -0.0072517395, 0.017959595, 0.01071167, 0.008087158, -0.04397583, 0.010551453, 0.030471802, 0.015182495, -0.0018186569, -0.008598328, -0.009414673, 0.008399963, 0.0066108704, -0.023529053, 0.04815674, 0.0093307495, 0.02583313, -0.011940002, -0.037200928, -0.013504028, -0.04812622, 0.011543274, 0.030761719, 0.03060913, -0.025054932, 0.01927185, -0.015037537, -0.045532227, 0.02128601, 0.006313324, -0.004169464, -0.009613037, 0.00033569336, 0.026565552, 0.027832031, -0.044799805, 0.00945282, -0.028930664, 0.035186768, -0.018615723, 0.011116028, -0.024871826, -0.05996704, -0.00983429, 0.006439209, -0.070251465, -0.019561768, 0.021057129, -0.036010742, -0.0103302, -0.05984497, 0.008590698, -0.007457733, -0.033203125, -0.003118515, -0.005268097, 0.0057640076, -0.017837524, -0.082214355, 0.0049858093, 0.055023193, -0.029708862, 0.048217773, 0.037994385, 0.006427765, -0.022369385, -0.035461426, 0.012336731, 0.015586853, 0.00070667267, -0.016281128, 0.016464233, 0.018127441, -0.018920898, 0.010643005, 0.014801025, -0.019546509, 0.0038871765, 0.014472961, 0.030410767, 0.037750244, -0.010215759, 0.05557251, -0.0057029724, -0.029190063, -0.043792725, -0.02067566, -0.018356323, -0.02949524, 0.036712646, -0.00020611286, 0.0044898987, 0.015686035, -0.00056505203, 0.074279785, 0.009735107, -0.0027008057, 0.0026988983, -0.031173706, -0.019546509, 0.0049743652, 0.036987305, -0.005596161, -0.0054244995, 0.025497437, -0.015136719, 0.06262207, -0.031173706, -0.019180298, 0.019897461, 0.043426514, -0.053985596, -0.012046814, -0.052825928, -0.07739258, -0.017105103, 0.0024414062, -0.008506775, 0.025436401, 0.032165527, -0.010528564, -0.012229919, 0.009254456, 0.08642578, 0.00712204, -0.046813965, -0.11590576, -0.017807007, -0.042755127, -0.040405273, -0.03955078, -0.07147217, -0.01133728, 0.004989624, 0.021377563, -0.03125, 0.009521484, 0.0071105957, 0.054473877, 0.04031372, -0.0054740906, -0.037353516, 0.03277588, -0.021499634, -0.019454956, 0.036010742, -0.02583313, -0.00016248226, 0.014457703, 0.023422241, -0.022567749, -0.004753113, -0.016174316, 0.018173218, -0.046173096, 0.0473938, 0.014778137, 0.064575195, 0.0059280396, 0.007587433, 0.031097412, 0.012763977, -0.03857422, -0.052612305, 0.03237915, 0.034698486, 0.0011358261, 0.0064888, 0.03363037, 0.027786255, -0.0021591187, 0.015838623, 0.012145996, 0.025482178, 0.00712204, -0.009361267, 0.044799805, -0.041107178, -0.049560547, -0.017318726, 0.0010499954, 0.017044067, -0.06958008, 0.05758667, -0.017349243, -0.024520874, 0.02230835, 0.0060768127, 0.012680054, 0.0054969788, 0.014793396, -0.056610107, -0.033477783, 0.003376007, 0.020614624, -0.025604248, 0.01852417, 0.022994995, 0.013504028, 0.025177002, 0.024734497, 0.010940552, 0.010917664, -0.014862061, -0.008644104, 0.01638794, -0.012924194, -0.04336548, 0.0001538992, -0.030975342, 0.00605011, -0.06817627, 0.0051956177, 0.008132935, -0.023254395, -0.028305054, -0.023498535, 0.011421204, -0.03793335, 0.025299072, 0.053588867, -0.024597168, 0.039978027, -0.010314941, 0.0076179504, 0.016571045, 0.0390625, 0.0043258667, 0.014678955, 0.045684814, -0.056427002, 0.0047912598, -0.010787964, 0.025421143, -0.0050354004, 0.012313843, 0.0017290115, 0.018417358, -0.06616211, 0.026763916, -0.052825928, -0.056365967, 0.03567505, -0.050750732, -0.023086548, -0.015281677, 0.021255493, 0.037872314, -0.027740479, 0.00818634, -0.014694214, -0.015151978, -0.05178833, 0.0012388229, -0.009147644, -0.023406982, -0.07293701, -0.006717682, -0.02532959, 0.029953003, -0.022766113, 0.016159058, -0.049804688, 0.013626099, 0.007911682, -0.0109939575, 0.016815186, 0.037017822, 0.0262146, 0.057800293, -0.008651733, -0.06628418, -0.00033259392, 0.014122009, -0.0021381378, -0.0065689087, 0.012565613, 0.0013904572, -0.012390137, -0.013137817, 0.010635376, -0.018096924, -0.0032291412, 0.023223877, -0.015022278, -0.045684814, 0.018066406, -0.0065345764, -0.0013074875, 0.0287323, -0.009735107, -0.020202637, 0.025024414, 0.004020691, 0.011192322, 0.033691406, -0.0072364807, 0.046051025, -0.07171631, -0.0635376, 0.0027885437, 0.027023315, 0.009742737, -0.016525269, 0.010498047, 0.035095215, -0.012245178, -0.023910522, -0.0022792816, 0.05227661, -0.06365967, -0.03994751, -0.024429321, 0.0098724365, -0.014305115, 0.062194824, -0.028656006, -0.061065674, -0.020629883, -0.064697266, -0.039642334, 0.0063972473, 0.040039062, 0.009941101, 0.035369873, -0.05065918, 0.015594482, -0.04611206, -0.0028057098, -0.015686035, -0.0013809204, -0.0058174133, -0.0072517395, 0.01121521, 0.014717102, -0.011016846, -0.0390625, 0.026123047, 0.004131317, 0.008270264, 0.009414673, -0.0023860931, -0.00566864, 0.0019283295, -0.023757935, 0.026687622, -0.023147583, -0.007583618, 0.010757446, -0.014373779, 0.047943115, 0.016448975, 0.025146484, 0.030441284, 0.0030555725, -0.027008057, 0.009002686, -0.0056152344, -0.039215088, -0.005458832, -0.058502197, 0.01259613, -0.06781006, 0.00957489, -0.057250977, 0.040130615, -0.016326904, 0.04373169, -0.010772705, 0.02078247, 0.025863647, -0.019134521, 0.01890564, -0.048950195, 0.052124023, -0.027191162, -0.014022827, 0.002292633, 0.016845703, 0.046813965, 0.026443481, -0.021469116, 0.04916382, -0.036132812, -0.018249512, 0.021606445, -0.0095825195, 0.011451721, -0.02432251, -0.022201538, -0.03753662, 0.014205933, -0.007751465, 0.007499695, 0.047210693, 0.073791504, -0.08862305, 0.0473938, 0.024383545, -0.020080566, -0.028305054, -0.008842468, 0.048980713, -0.10083008, 0.038513184, -0.007106781, -0.011077881, -0.040924072, 0.08148193, 0.006061554, -0.0061798096, 0.03439331, 0.013763428, 0.008285522, 0.025100708, 0.019073486, -0.050445557, -0.003660202, 0.036621094, 0.008621216, -0.031097412, -0.034423828, 0.04699707, 0.021224976, -0.013374329, -0.0032634735, -0.030227661, 0.031311035, -0.06323242, 0.030517578, -0.011550903, 0.019454956, -0.013870239, -0.035186768, -0.0138168335, 0.012321472, -0.02671814, -0.04196167, 0.048614502, 0.014709473, 0.018875122, 0.06048584, 0.015213013, -0.0047302246, -0.031402588, -0.028823853, 0.033355713, 0.037902832, -0.018692017, -0.009513855, -0.0047454834, -0.027908325, 0.032989502, -0.0069885254, 0.082092285, -0.06359863, 0.0036182404, -0.03286743, 0.027679443, 0.002023697, -0.03555298, -0.052612305, -0.004463196, -0.06762695, 0.005268097, 0.008666992, -0.034423828, -0.01979065, -0.010971069, -0.01739502, 0.012199402, -0.012054443, -0.005870819, -0.0020580292, -0.03842163, 0.016296387, -0.040893555, 0.04699707, -0.0496521, -0.006340027, -0.011505127, 0.024978638, -0.015617371, -0.03527832, -0.01625061, -0.0035896301, -0.013244629, -0.029022217, 0.014923096, 0.012901306, -0.008590698, 0.014434814, -0.023849487, 0.01360321, -0.016708374, -0.012680054, 0.022903442, -0.035186768, -0.030014038, -0.007095337, -0.045776367, 0.034301758, 0.043304443, -0.016677856, -0.0053215027, 0.011009216, -0.059936523, 0.007926941, 0.022903442, 0.0758667, -0.008522034, -0.020431519, -0.014595032, 0.023361206, 0.020187378, -0.059143066, -0.06286621, -0.0002605915, 0.057617188, -0.0060806274, 0.035583496, 0.006462097, 0.007827759, 0.0446167, 0.019210815, 0.0206604, -0.043884277, -0.034851074, 0.016113281, 0.070007324, 0.043304443, -0.0054893494, -0.029846191, 0.0027580261, -0.0016222, -0.017227173, 0.00039672852, -0.020095825, -0.010040283, 0.0024414062, 0.017486572, 0.01084137, -0.024353027, -0.029342651, -0.008842468, 0.015083313, 0.020935059, -0.01637268, 0.025482178, -0.021820068, 0.05947876, -0.041107178, -0.03326416, 0.06652832, 0.026733398, 0.029190063, 0.009216309, 0.03640747, 0.017623901, -0.00315094, -0.011528015, -0.0022621155, -0.017654419, 0.040161133, -0.042785645, -0.008163452, -0.04296875, -0.03656006, 0.00415802, -0.053344727, 0.048065186, 0.0007829666, 0.00843811, -0.010345459, 0.015686035, 0.0041275024, 0.003856659, 0.020095825, -0.008094788, -0.038085938, -0.04309082, 0.024673462, -0.012496948 ], "summary": [ 0.006214142, 0.010795593, -0.00010627508, 0.03277588, -0.020858765, -0.017654419, -0.015838623, -0.076293945, 0.04257202, 0.030532837, -0.03390503, -0.057159424, 0.024307251, -0.030700684, -0.039093018, -0.03930664, -0.010360718, 0.041046143, 0.006034851, -0.035827637, 0.005306244, -0.031921387, 0.0087890625, -0.030563354, 0.033721924, -0.04309082, -0.06008911, 0.024139404, -0.011993408, -0.002023697, 0.003643036, 0.037902832, 0.021530151, 0.023742676, -0.05368042, -0.015022278, -0.008422852, 0.008132935, 0.0034561157, -0.0067481995, 0.013633728, -0.005382538, 0.054748535, -0.021743774, -0.0034675598, 0.046813965, -0.019424438, -0.066589355, 0.046905518, -0.012832642, -0.0033416748, 0.025741577, -0.0026550293, -0.036376953, -0.022155762, 0.009475708, -0.06964111, -0.000057280064, 0.002313614, 0.08532715, 0.034606934, -0.0030174255, -0.01449585, -0.03753662, -0.013717651, 0.012825012, 0.01626587, 0.012359619, 0.015914917, -0.004852295, -0.0041999817, 0.0028648376, 0.01524353, -0.003206253, -0.042938232, -0.01676941, 0.020202637, -0.01838684, 0.028198242, -0.029083252, -0.000045120716, 0.01399231, -0.031158447, -0.026748657, 0.0021362305, -0.022659302, -0.015571594, -0.015853882, -0.027648926, -0.024017334, -0.009552002, -0.05316162, -0.044921875, 0.017700195, 0.049072266, -0.062561035, -0.018936157, -0.02444458, -0.004386902, -0.010276794, -0.017684937, 0.009147644, -0.04840088, -0.0015296936, 0.014465332, 0.01965332, -0.053466797, -0.07525635, 0.026794434, 0.030395508, -0.017456055, -0.021011353, -0.0088272095, -0.07159424, -0.014060974, 0.037139893, 0.019897461, 0.027389526, 0.04888916, 0.029724121, -0.019638062, 0.015975952, -0.079833984, 0.014251709, 0.036956787, 0.010864258, 0.011688232, 0.05718994, 0.023406982, 0.0029468536, -0.00548172, 0.014060974, -0.052886963, -0.0018949509, -0.033477783, -0.00026273727, 0.03125, -0.0030231476, 0.024780273, -0.022476196, 0.0491333, 0.0066452026, 0.009895325, 0.051452637, -0.009155273, 0.050323486, 0.01965332, -0.001958847, -0.00422287, -0.0569458, 0.010986328, -0.021972656, 0.030700684, 0.0031147003, -0.043518066, -0.027191162, -0.051757812, -0.010734558, 0.010574341, -0.0069351196, 0.011856079, -0.03289795, -0.028137207, 0.017578125, -0.018417358, 0.05456543, -0.02468872, 0.012931824, 0.0033569336, -0.06616211, 0.0069503784, 0.01335144, 0.04714966, -0.019378662, 0.011184692, 0.006164551, 0.012870789, 0.014556885, 0.004512787, -0.009811401, -0.0050086975, -0.036956787, 0.036834717, -0.016113281, -0.012763977, -0.046813965, 0.015220642, 0.027832031, 0.034362793, 0.020935059, 0.014907837, -0.03591919, -0.014213562, 0.017440796, 0.0023670197, -0.04296875, 0.007637024, -0.01411438, -0.004547119, 0.0006918907, 0.019165039, -0.022628784, -0.0022640228, -0.049621582, -0.10913086, -0.03604126, -0.03086853, 0.025146484, 0.04159546, 0.00655365, -0.010597229, -0.0072746277, -0.02015686, -0.0066719055, -0.0579834, -0.02746582, 0.022644043, 0.010292053, -0.0013666153, -0.019210815, 0.007549286, 0.016036987, -0.005077362, 0.037261963, 0.019088745, 0.006340027, 0.0063705444, 0.008285522, 0.07922363, -0.008972168, 0.09588623, -0.03970337, 0.021743774, 0.026733398, 0.0015707016, 0.022781372, 0.034942627, -0.05581665, 0.01776123, 0.02394104, 0.015838623, 0.018951416, -0.01737976, 0.012702942, 0.0055885315, -0.0049819946, 0.029785156, -0.013710022, -0.021850586, 0.04876709, -0.020095825, 0.044006348, 0.0090789795, -0.009727478, -0.04650879, 0.052642822, -0.03265381, -0.045196533, -0.0063705444, -0.019500732, 0.03933716, -0.05532837, -0.032836914, -0.01763916, 0.006008148, -0.027679443, -0.007972717, -0.020095825, -0.0018930435, -0.008361816, 0.010925293, -0.0552063, 0.027252197, 0.026565552, -0.05621338, -0.0340271, -0.03729248, 0.028289795, 0.032989502, -0.018218994, -0.022964478, 0.0059127808, -0.017288208, -0.026626587, 0.0025043488, -0.0045547485, 0.0031604767, -0.045532227, 0.046722412, 0.052856445, 0.030548096, 0.056365967, 0.02772522, 0.015396118, 0.050994873, 0.0019369125, 0.022094727, -0.0043563843, 0.009681702, -0.011184692, 0.0385437, 0.053985596, -0.021240234, 0.011100769, -0.00021672249, -0.002363205, -0.010887146, 0.0027542114, -0.0072402954, -0.026885986, -0.017059326, -0.0016412735, 0.028396606, 0.050598145, -0.03112793, -0.058410645, -0.042419434, 0.026947021, -0.056793213, -0.029373169, 0.05303955, -0.003189087, 0.00044226646, 0.02104187, -0.0027999878, -0.032958984, 0.030426025, -0.018829346, -0.015563965, 0.006713867, -0.01084137, 0.00061035156, 0.010665894, 0.01701355, -0.006225586, -0.010032654, 0.02532959, 0.007610321, 0.022109985, 0.0042381287, 0.033569336, 0.011222839, -0.018600464, 0.012077332, -0.046417236, -0.0013847351, 0.009376526, -0.005264282, -0.057556152, -0.0018386841, 0.02784729, -0.022735596, -0.030853271, 0.008628845, 0.016830444, -0.014793396, 0.028518677, 0.025115967, 0.0098724365, -0.025054932, 0.0001924038, 0.05883789, 0.016860962, -0.035308838, -0.041229248, -0.036132812, 0.02230835, 0.00030994415, 0.011817932, 0.041229248, 0.010475159, 0.0034217834, -0.03793335, -0.008483887, 0.0040130615, -0.002231598, 0.04071045, -0.028564453, -0.061676025, -0.0029125214, -0.011779785, -0.008224487, -0.028030396, -0.020370483, 0.032104492, 0.00843811, -0.00894165, 0.009140015, 0.034606934, 0.0058517456, 0.005874634, -0.00982666, 0.034454346, -0.013031006, -0.000105917454, 0.012077332, -0.026412964, -0.04425049, -0.018417358, -0.010551453, 0.040618896, 0.026184082, -0.0023345947, 0.033599854, -0.02508545, 0.013809204, 0.035247803, -0.001709938, 0.022781372, 0.064575195, -0.00028920174, -0.0008916855, 0.005332947, 0.026794434, 0.0073013306, -0.004047394, -0.04550171, -0.0011453629, -0.01600647, -0.002609253, -0.011444092, 0.0034275055, -0.042510986, 0.009361267, 0.02722168, 0.016159058, -0.0045814514, -0.05154419, 0.0519104, 0.069885254, 0.004535675, 0.036621094, -0.013771057, -0.032409668, -0.021011353, -0.01374054, -0.023529053, -0.041015625, 0.0018873215, -0.014785767, 0.015533447, -0.022354126, -0.001405716, -0.013771057, 0.0074310303, -0.036376953, 0.010276794, 0.03643799, 0.014984131, -0.0022125244, 0.0063056946, -0.0010280609, 0.07122803, 0.01651001, -0.008415222, -0.0006155968, -0.0015621185, 0.027175903, 0.071777344, -0.04876709, -0.036346436, -0.04095459, 0.04537964, 0.0051727295, 0.00705719, -0.027023315, 0.015808105, -0.003528595, -0.04425049, 0.025222778, 0.015533447, 0.0026569366, -0.0015411377, -0.0007648468, 0.0014066696, -0.008682251, -0.0019292831, -0.008956909, 0.016082764, 0.012619019, -0.068847656, 0.019088745, -0.07055664, -0.025619507, -0.0035362244, 0.0010890961, -0.0037994385, 0.006439209, 0.017227173, 0.021469116, 0.021072388, -0.014602661, 0.03262329, 0.019958496, 0.0039138794, 0.0009775162, -0.010627747, 0.08917236, -0.011116028, -0.06732178, 0.044433594, -0.030899048, 0.0074310303, 0.042297363, -0.021026611, 0.052337646, -0.014389038, -0.032348633, -0.023376465, -0.06347656, -0.036743164, -0.0826416, 0.03945923, 0.0007457733, -0.024002075, 0.015838623, -0.019699097, -0.026367188, -0.017303467, 0.009117126, 0.051879883, 0.07055664, -0.022216797, 0.018737793, -0.0036716461, 0.008850098, -0.058013916, -0.01398468, 0.006580353, -0.0524292, 0.016067505, -0.01713562, -0.022399902, 0.035247803, 0.0184021, 0.0569458, -0.002199173, -0.039489746, 0.018447876, 0.014961243, 0.0001335144, -0.00075149536, -0.00198555, 0.015914917, -0.023376465, 0.035369873, 0.008956909, 0.035186768, -0.0124053955, -0.04019165, 0.027526855, 0.061645508, -0.056121826, -0.03805542, -0.0022888184, -0.05014038, -0.00084114075, -0.0127334595, -0.015197754, 0.010070801, 0.01878357, -0.046783447, 0.029510498, 0.0050621033, 0.07409668, 0.028701782, -0.0569458, -0.12249756, -0.034820557, -0.049224854, -0.018188477, -0.018066406, -0.05328369, -0.023788452, -0.017242432, 0.04864502, -0.05090332, -0.0061531067, -0.014328003, 0.07977295, -0.008453369, 0.04699707, -0.035980225, 0.002943039, -0.0154953, -0.0121154785, 0.017700195, -0.04196167, 0.009712219, 0.01802063, 0.041046143, -0.022628784, -0.015838623, -0.00737381, 0.0017328262, 0.0121536255, 0.0149002075, -0.013465881, 0.033172607, 0.00011497736, -0.011047363, 0.03503418, 0.013511658, -0.019943237, -0.039855957, 0.042388916, -0.01940918, 0.02520752, 0.016159058, 0.027496338, -0.0011062622, 0.005748749, 0.0107421875, -0.0005950928, 0.012779236, -0.018600464, -0.03793335, 0.073913574, 0.010253906, -0.023162842, -0.004722595, -0.0078125, -0.0129852295, -0.041748047, 0.0256958, -0.027740479, -0.015060425, 0.04937744, 0.012901306, -0.014701843, 0.033935547, -0.016082764, -0.034179688, -0.013244629, 0.008934021, 0.011940002, -0.026351929, -0.016479492, -0.037902832, -0.02029419, 0.007270813, -0.01600647, -0.024383545, 0.011558533, -0.011581421, -0.019882202, 0.013633728, 0.0021362305, -0.0063209534, 0.01789856, -0.040618896, -0.010635376, -0.024856567, -0.03567505, 0.051635742, -0.015930176, -0.015144348, -0.005355835, 0.0047302246, -0.028564453, -0.028457642, 0.016555786, -0.044128418, -0.002527237, -0.013679504, -0.0014944077, -0.015151978, 0.019805908, -0.026916504, -0.010437012, 0.020843506, -0.060150146, 0.005519867, -0.02746582, -0.01398468, 0.033935547, -0.008262634, 0.02243042, 0.030670166, -0.03353882, -0.0066452026, -0.11608887, -0.033843994, 0.008232117, -0.0021018982, 0.0025482178, -0.020401001, 0.019760132, 0.04626465, -0.008277893, 0.0068359375, -0.0093688965, 0.014015198, -0.042053223, -0.022476196, -0.0013656616, 0.0025730133, -0.066467285, -0.025344849, -0.044036865, 0.026016235, -0.027557373, 0.015014648, -0.01713562, -0.019638062, 0.007949829, -0.040924072, 0.027893066, 0.008094788, 0.045654297, 0.012702942, -0.047576904, -0.054656982, 0.0053749084, 0.007659912, 0.010749817, -0.003376007, 0.020629883, 0.0049438477, -0.0024929047, 0.007408142, 0.02418518, 0.013908386, -0.029190063, 0.017715454, -0.02859497, -0.007522583, 0.02949524, 0.008178711, -0.010787964, 0.018066406, -0.033599854, -0.07287598, 0.035095215, 0.027236938, 0.05090332, 0.009719849, 0.008323669, 0.07080078, -0.12084961, -0.06365967, -0.012252808, 0.04196167, 0.04257202, 0.023788452, 0.016708374, 0.02885437, -0.030349731, -0.0028533936, 0.022216797, 0.053741455, -0.061309814, -0.043304443, -0.029647827, 0.03466797, -0.008972168, 0.03765869, -0.055267334, -0.05230713, -0.010925293, -0.06512451, -0.01184082, 0.0047454834, 0.031555176, 0.03390503, 0.05596924, -0.034576416, 0.008911133, -0.010826111, -0.0065078735, -0.0011205673, -0.0052108765, -0.024124146, -0.018569946, 0.039642334, 0.012870789, -0.012710571, 0.0101623535, 0.011451721, -0.013397217, -0.022201538, 0.039855957, 0.011642456, 0.014427185, 0.011817932, -0.0010519028, 0.009735107, -0.026351929, 0.013427734, -0.0016508102, -0.020706177, 0.026733398, 0.020553589, -0.02835083, -0.028747559, -0.054534912, -0.0088272095, 0.012466431, -0.023208618, -0.03149414, 0.023971558, -0.00945282, 0.0073013306, -0.035827637, -0.01890564, -0.00079774857, 0.059448242, -0.031463623, 0.019882202, 0.016418457, 0.024536133, 0.041259766, -0.010391235, -0.03540039, -0.06689453, 0.008255005, -0.029663086, -0.009414673, 0.008071899, 0.017578125, 0.043640137, 0.030563354, -0.030471802, 0.06488037, -0.013977051, -0.030227661, 0.07318115, -0.027923584, -0.027862549, -0.043762207, 0.01134491, -0.06542969, 0.012039185, 0.029953003, 0.02331543, -0.0061569214, 0.054229736, -0.058563232, 0.050048828, 0.019638062, 0.014045715, -0.04272461, 0.034088135, 0.03048706, -0.05657959, -0.0027008057, 0.009216309, -0.002861023, -0.02911377, 0.074645996, 0.022125244, 0.008995056, 0.081970215, 0.016830444, -0.015586853, -0.037384033, -0.008781433, -0.044799805, -0.028060913, 0.004119873, -0.017578125, -0.02217102, -0.04058838, 0.029144287, 0.0005941391, 0.024475098, 0.013015747, -0.0056991577, 0.04714966, 0.004043579, 0.027511597, -0.044891357, 0.021087646, -0.045715332, -0.02381897, -0.016708374, 0.019378662, -0.04727173, -0.024261475, 0.041534424, 0.04034424, 0.0703125, 0.07788086, -0.0027179718, 0.01524353, 0.0149383545, -0.024719238, 0.028030396, -0.029815674, -0.003610611, -0.04260254, 0.012954712, 0.010314941, 0.025177002, 0.020523071, 0.08392334, -0.075927734, -0.021530151, -0.055389404, 0.054748535, -0.076660156, 0.01083374, -0.05429077, -0.038208008, -0.064941406, 0.020233154, 0.032440186, -0.0231781, 0.026977539, -0.013954163, -0.07312012, 0.024841309, 0.0068130493, 0.049194336, -0.00491333, -0.02859497, 0.013969421, -0.020645142, 0.07006836, -0.061676025, -0.019348145, 0.005531311, 0.02508545, -0.01209259, -0.012550354, -0.016036987, 0.02319336, 0.00031542778, -0.02230835, -0.01727295, -0.022521973, -0.020980835, 0.039764404, 0.0028324127, 0.032928467, -0.007080078, 0.029724121, -0.0056991577, -0.006198883, -0.0008530617, 0.002002716, -0.014762878, -0.004798889, -0.0054397583, -0.005584717, -0.01525116, 0.02029419, -0.049194336, 0.008102417, 0.03604126, 0.06109619, -0.012413025, -0.04095459, 0.0028629303, -0.01651001, -0.004009247, -0.053710938, -0.021835327, 0.013534546, 0.08728027, 0.004573822, -0.015144348, 0.0048332214, 0.003484726, 0.042663574, 0.009605408, 0.006690979, -0.027053833, -0.018814087, 0.001086235, 0.07763672, 0.018661499, -0.03768921, -0.02355957, -0.002117157, -0.0082092285, -0.035217285, 0.00969696, 0.00074005127, -0.03677368, 0.0044517517, -0.018066406, -0.021987915, -0.0637207, -0.014289856, -0.033691406, 0.02128601, -0.004562378, -0.018600464, 0.010269165, -0.036193848, 0.02381897, -0.00049591064, 0.015113831, 0.007408142, -0.035949707, 0.051116943, -0.042175293, 0.06756592, 0.020004272, 0.006134033, -0.02468872, 0.014282227, -0.022476196, 0.02708435, -0.09265137, -0.040496826, -0.05392456, -0.02357483, -0.006614685, -0.037841797, 0.036224365, -0.0060768127, 0.0071105957, 0.027572632, -0.0036354065, 0.025054932, -0.008354187, 0.040130615, 0.0043029785, 0.013946533, -0.018508911, -0.0113220215, 0.02583313 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2104.08542v2
ScaleFreeCTR: MixCache-based Distributed Training System for CTR Models with Huge Embedding Table
Huifeng Guo, Wei Guo, Yong Gao, Ruiming Tang, Xiuqiang He, Wenzhi Liu
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.DC, cs.LG
Because of the superior feature representation ability of deep learning, various deep Click-Through Rate (CTR) models are deployed in the commercial systems by industrial companies. To achieve better performance, it is necessary to train the deep CTR models on huge volume of training data efficiently, which makes speeding up the training process an essential problem. Different from the models with dense training data, the training data for CTR models is usually high-dimensional and sparse. To transform the high-dimensional sparse input into low-dimensional dense real-value vectors, almost all deep CTR models adopt the embedding layer, which easily reaches hundreds of GB or even TB. Since a single GPU cannot afford to accommodate all the embedding parameters, when performing distributed training, it is not reasonable to conduct the data-parallelism only. Therefore, existing distributed training platforms for recommendation adopt model-parallelism. Specifically, they use CPU (Host) memory of servers to maintain and update the embedding parameters and utilize GPU worker to conduct forward and backward computations. Unfortunately, these platforms suffer from two bottlenecks: (1) the latency of pull \& push operations between Host and GPU; (2) parameters update and synchronization in the CPU servers. To address such bottlenecks, in this paper, we propose the ScaleFreeCTR: a MixCache-based distributed training system for CTR models. Specifically, in SFCTR, we also store huge embedding table in CPU but utilize GPU instead of CPU to conduct embedding synchronization efficiently. To reduce the latency of data transfer between both GPU-Host and GPU-GPU, the MixCache mechanism and Virtual Sparse Id operation are proposed. Comprehensive experiments and ablation studies are conducted to demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency of SFCTR.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2104.08542v2
"2021-05-11T14:11:46"
"2021-04-17T13:36:19"
{ "title": [ -0.04815674, -0.0023460388, -0.074401855, -0.049346924, -0.032928467, 0.005756378, -0.080078125, -0.0042495728, 0.0061912537, 0.025527954, -0.031280518, 0.008216858, 0.005168915, -0.038909912, -0.018951416, -0.011299133, 0.00712204, 0.036254883, -0.012916565, -0.020706177, -0.02822876, -0.017486572, -0.01449585, 0.03616333, -0.008544922, -0.00705719, -0.053527832, 0.00031900406, -0.021697998, -0.025161743, -0.0039711, 0.027740479, 0.029846191, 0.050994873, -0.057128906, -0.012786865, -0.058532715, 0.052734375, -0.015419006, 0.011604309, 0.036346436, -0.01285553, 0.045196533, -0.01927185, 0.0021953583, 0.024459839, -0.0317688, -0.043151855, -0.0013923645, 0.047454834, -0.032958984, 0.054260254, -0.05029297, 0.06210327, 0.03353882, 0.00806427, -0.0049095154, -0.022323608, 0.010421753, 0.04373169, 0.028015137, 0.0061073303, 0.0141067505, -0.021896362, 0.001572609, -0.027175903, 0.0019683838, 0.033203125, 0.0703125, 0.02468872, -0.029953003, 0.04840088, -0.0009331703, -0.015686035, -0.039642334, 0.01209259, 0.035217285, 0.008140564, 0.0023460388, -0.018508911, -0.00793457, 0.0039901733, -0.0032539368, -0.03427124, -0.014297485, -0.024932861, -0.032928467, 0.0047454834, 0.0043945312, -0.028900146, 0.003534317, -0.031402588, -0.02394104, 0.07531738, 0.0036411285, -0.031799316, 0.0017604828, 0.017684937, 0.012535095, -0.007648468, 0.012390137, -0.017654419, -0.011634827, -0.023971558, 0.019729614, 0.031341553, -0.04626465, -0.022201538, 0.046722412, 0.03842163, 0.015960693, -0.002002716, -0.026153564, -0.010368347, 0.061523438, -0.017974854, -0.06463623, 0.07879639, -0.013023376, 0.03930664, 0.004825592, 0.0067214966, 0.021591187, -0.004310608, 0.05529785, 0.05303955, -0.011444092, -0.024505615, -0.06774902, 0.024002075, 0.0066223145, 0.05154419, -0.04498291, -0.022460938, -0.030807495, 0.024108887, -0.007881165, 0.0021190643, -0.010643005, -0.009643555, -0.0057754517, -0.014923096, 0.008880615, -0.031982422, -0.033294678, 0.0357666, 0.06829834, -0.011299133, -0.07293701, -0.05392456, -0.042388916, 0.045196533, 0.011299133, 0.011169434, -0.035705566, -0.02407837, -0.051696777, -0.022018433, 0.019424438, -0.032989502, 0.051849365, -0.017456055, -0.051818848, 0.0032444, -0.003042221, 0.009376526, -0.0005493164, 0.013381958, 0.006439209, 0.063964844, -0.04220581, -0.021621704, -0.004135132, -0.0054779053, -0.0064201355, 0.029830933, 0.024612427, 0.0027065277, 0.023345947, -0.07873535, -0.028518677, -0.0024662018, 0.009933472, -0.0037956238, -0.036499023, -0.04724121, -0.0060424805, -0.029449463, 0.043640137, 0.0023994446, -0.029693604, 0.017990112, -0.015182495, 0.0034160614, -0.013290405, 0.0075263977, -0.012550354, 0.030090332, -0.015151978, -0.048065186, -0.013893127, 0.019592285, -0.029144287, 0.027328491, -0.03665161, -0.01512146, -0.009147644, 0.02935791, -0.005683899, 0.069885254, 0.023269653, -0.0016584396, -0.030014038, 0.004901886, 0.023040771, -0.028686523, 0.014038086, -0.024490356, -0.0037670135, -0.0152282715, -0.0033950806, 0.007987976, -0.00920105, 0.011528015, -0.028121948, 0.037506104, -0.01737976, 0.019042969, -0.005836487, 0.04562378, 0.027740479, -0.02822876, -0.008666992, 0.032836914, -0.00049877167, 0.0033912659, -0.013908386, -0.013046265, 0.011024475, 0.013259888, 0.008453369, -0.040039062, -0.017654419, 0.021133423, 0.024490356, 0.0027503967, 0.017913818, 0.013801575, -0.0008368492, -0.009010315, 0.07495117, -0.0048332214, 0.037597656, -0.015792847, -0.013763428, 0.028839111, -0.01626587, 0.0039749146, -0.013786316, -0.028060913, 0.020431519, -0.0030117035, -0.027252197, 0.01071167, -0.052520752, 0.016525269, -0.033599854, 0.014709473, 0.00907135, 0.0211792, 0.02798462, -0.044708252, 0.020339966, 0.021270752, -0.04058838, -0.019088745, -0.012290955, 0.013320923, 0.005088806, -0.02911377, -0.02633667, -0.014160156, 0.03918457, -0.0071792603, 0.015075684, 0.025497437, 0.03463745, -0.03982544, -0.030914307, -0.009414673, 0.02645874, 0.043792725, 0.0072288513, 0.012306213, 0.0040512085, -0.00069618225, 0.08532715, 0.056365967, -0.027542114, 0.01864624, -0.024856567, -0.004611969, 0.009346008, -0.03970337, 0.02279663, 0.01864624, 0.037231445, 0.0061073303, -0.020324707, 0.007003784, -0.06829834, -0.013465881, 0.015312195, 0.003074646, -0.044799805, -0.04824829, -0.022232056, -0.0025405884, -0.039398193, -0.026016235, 0.04788208, 0.037719727, 0.001329422, 0.01789856, 0.03652954, -0.04348755, 0.0115737915, -0.0317688, -0.0041275024, -0.010345459, 0.03086853, -0.008804321, -0.07165527, -0.036071777, 0.014167786, 0.0104599, -0.0018453598, 0.006542206, 0.009284973, 0.036346436, 0.028411865, 0.009887695, 0.0023670197, -0.048706055, -0.01826477, -0.065979004, -0.0007472038, -0.0066070557, -0.018569946, 0.012817383, 0.045837402, -0.0072517395, -0.013801575, 0.017318726, 0.03945923, -0.007774353, -0.0071029663, -0.006515503, 0.0017690659, -0.04458618, 0.035217285, 0.02027893, 0.0013828278, -0.06048584, -0.002040863, -0.060760498, -0.025512695, -0.037139893, -0.010124207, 0.053344727, -0.035461426, 0.030654907, -0.021575928, -0.036468506, -0.060516357, -0.012840271, 0.046295166, -0.0043563843, -0.05783081, 0.0022506714, 0.0053520203, -0.016586304, 0.018753052, -0.015419006, 0.07342529, 0.004764557, -0.0017290115, 0.021087646, 0.01751709, -0.013404846, -0.012107849, -0.019348145, -0.011642456, 0.011253357, -0.020599365, -0.0050964355, -0.020233154, -0.032043457, -0.061798096, 0.032043457, 0.020828247, -0.01878357, -0.03274536, -0.012962341, -0.010017395, -0.009613037, 0.02041626, -0.024307251, 0.012207031, 0.041412354, 0.0040283203, -0.0041885376, 0.030426025, -0.036010742, 0.042175293, -0.03704834, -0.06689453, 0.005710602, -0.043060303, 0.036743164, 0.012870789, 0.0131073, -0.04034424, 0.017547607, 0.037628174, 0.04333496, 0.022003174, -0.024169922, 0.022033691, -0.029159546, 0.022705078, -0.034179688, -0.016494751, -0.033355713, -0.025848389, -0.022232056, -0.010787964, -0.0054359436, 0.016021729, -0.016677856, -0.042633057, -0.03161621, -0.014953613, 0.012786865, -0.0071868896, -0.009429932, -0.037017822, -0.023086548, -0.010292053, 0.050689697, -0.027053833, 0.0211792, -0.021209717, 0.015777588, -0.0335083, -0.03213501, 0.0126953125, 0.040771484, 0.03314209, -0.023925781, 0.018859863, -0.03277588, -0.036865234, 0.051635742, 0.0027561188, 0.02281189, 0.042144775, 0.0073928833, -0.02281189, -0.0024414062, -0.035461426, -0.0054855347, 0.0024108887, 0.0140686035, -0.02243042, -0.027572632, 0.00687027, 0.04055786, -0.0028572083, -0.029342651, -0.0010204315, 0.017471313, -0.034820557, -0.05014038, -0.0069999695, 0.012260437, -0.05883789, -0.022018433, 0.023391724, 0.01184082, -0.03414917, -0.030914307, 0.034729004, 0.011634827, -0.011436462, 0.030334473, 0.0019817352, -0.0155181885, -0.010620117, -0.10296631, 0.01914978, 0.0423584, 0.037902832, 0.036895752, 0.008682251, -0.03527832, -0.010765076, -0.002008438, 0.024978638, 0.0073890686, 0.040374756, -0.0006518364, -0.027709961, 0.037139893, -0.02709961, 0.027038574, 0.03173828, -0.02078247, 0.009666443, 0.020706177, 0.04296875, 0.035888672, -0.044036865, 0.029174805, 0.043914795, 0.0103302, -0.09472656, 0.02961731, 0.0074424744, -0.023025513, 0.02394104, -0.01574707, -0.0072746277, 0.02897644, 0.035247803, 0.03930664, -0.039520264, -0.026657104, 0.0009646416, 0.0043411255, -0.023071289, -0.0032653809, 0.006511688, 0.05630493, -0.0015974045, -0.009559631, 0.010017395, 0.051849365, 0.0044937134, -0.014274597, 0.009208679, 0.034088135, -0.058654785, -0.02394104, -0.037597656, 0.0059127808, -0.019943237, 0.014884949, -0.00598526, 0.0049324036, 0.014656067, -0.011833191, -0.03967285, 0.016815186, -0.01852417, 0.0151901245, -0.038238525, -0.057800293, 0.038238525, -0.024398804, -0.06512451, -0.075805664, -0.011390686, 0.017456055, 0.001291275, 0.016830444, -0.011047363, -0.0029945374, 0.03579712, 0.04232788, 0.02507019, -0.009460449, -0.048980713, -0.050323486, -0.0075263977, -0.024932861, 0.020126343, 0.00944519, 0.002243042, -0.018173218, 0.009941101, -0.023422241, -0.018661499, -0.08972168, -0.010482788, 0.01285553, 0.04067993, 0.046142578, 0.001917839, 0.020614624, 0.024002075, -0.010002136, -0.010108948, -0.034576416, -0.00015175343, 0.0058784485, 0.050048828, -0.025161743, 0.009307861, 0.03793335, 0.028778076, -0.013870239, -0.013496399, 0.027130127, 0.0008711815, 0.021072388, 0.05105591, 0.0074157715, 0.008300781, -0.025222778, 0.040222168, 0.01411438, 0.025238037, 0.023223877, 0.027648926, -0.02003479, 0.030654907, 0.016738892, -0.012321472, 0.0049209595, 0.0099487305, 0.019073486, -0.06829834, -0.08483887, -0.03652954, 0.08465576, -0.020111084, -0.023330688, -0.039489746, -0.042541504, 0.026550293, 0.01777649, 0.0031013489, -0.05291748, 0.015457153, -0.017974854, -0.030639648, -0.00030469894, -0.06274414, -0.018554688, -0.015609741, 0.01802063, -0.03387451, 0.009666443, -0.036193848, -0.03237915, -0.025909424, 0.022583008, -0.0033493042, -0.0025367737, 0.03010559, 0.08062744, 0.006996155, 0.023330688, 0.024612427, 0.019744873, 0.040222168, 0.022399902, 0.04425049, -0.045898438, -0.00983429, 0.00045633316, 0.0065078735, -0.021911621, 0.0104522705, -0.007896423, 0.028213501, 0.0062713623, 0.026916504, -0.0725708, 0.010917664, -0.008628845, -0.014335632, 0.023864746, -0.042022705, 0.023513794, 0.035247803, -0.024215698, 0.00010198355, -0.009544373, -0.0362854, 0.000023722649, -0.028274536, -0.026382446, 0.012161255, -0.028076172, -0.04309082, -0.005844116, 0.014732361, 0.009605408, 0.017959595, -0.0008020401, 0.0059814453, -0.033416748, 0.012313843, 0.012298584, -0.026412964, 0.044311523, -0.013053894, -0.015563965, 0.032592773, 0.06311035, 0.003917694, -0.0027599335, -0.010612488, -0.047424316, -0.017547607, -0.03845215, -0.03933716, 0.038146973, 0.00009614229, -0.003200531, 0.034454346, -0.013244629, 0.037078857, 0.024765015, -0.018356323, 0.024261475, -0.02067566, -0.018234253, 0.01701355, -0.004184723, -0.0026760101, 0.012557983, -0.0020446777, -0.043395996, 0.009506226, -0.009925842, -0.029327393, 0.044830322, -0.009437561, 0.012191772, 0.024108887, -0.0033817291, -0.012908936, 0.044647217, 0.022140503, 0.015808105, -0.0013446808, 0.0013656616, 0.015136719, -0.0028438568, -0.021972656, -0.03237915, -0.009391785, -0.047973633, 0.057128906, -0.011375427, -0.014251709, -0.038604736, -0.09918213, -0.018920898, -0.012191772, 0.021438599, 0.024124146, -0.0074806213, -0.05078125, 0.026367188, 0.014884949, -0.01876831, -0.055145264, 0.018066406, -0.0065307617, -0.050994873, 0.06304932, -0.023849487, -0.0037956238, -0.0256958, 0.008140564, -0.0036621094, 0.012077332, -0.020324707, 0.0129470825, 0.010360718, -0.027496338, 0.024169922, 0.066833496, 0.010940552, -0.009788513, 0.05899048, 0.0034179688, 0.025131226, -0.00033259392, 0.017745972, 0.059051514, 0.035888672, -0.06817627, -0.013313293, 0.010177612, -0.02722168, 0.054992676, -0.047454834, 0.013290405, -0.037109375, -0.019989014, -0.08477783, 0.0036067963, 0.041046143, 0.0068969727, 0.037231445, -0.0029029846, 0.020446777, -0.009918213, -0.027908325, -0.015235901, 0.015258789, -0.009712219, 0.0053596497, -0.004272461, 0.027832031, 0.010032654, 0.026626587, -0.002105713, 0.018508911, 0.01928711, 0.004463196, -0.009414673, 0.014671326, 0.0061187744, -0.04574585, 0.03665161, -0.02267456, 0.0395813, 0.011650085, 0.04751587, 0.050994873, -0.0064964294, 0.026397705, -0.041107178, -0.01864624, 0.035980225, -0.044189453, 0.06173706, 0.10369873, -0.08843994, 0.035186768, -0.012184143, -0.051239014, 0.015365601, 0.021438599, 0.05706787, -0.03665161, -0.022445679, 0.0039100647, 0.033233643, 0.017669678, 0.0011529922, -0.04736328, -0.055541992, 0.021697998, 0.04611206, -0.032836914, 0.018127441, 0.00198555, 0.0047912598, 0.02720642, 0.00087213516, 0.027297974, 0.02003479, 0.051818848, 0.039642334, -0.04751587, 0.02708435, 0.02557373, -0.011871338, 0.0031204224, 0.05050659, -0.06488037, 0.035003662, -0.022125244, 0.08856201, 0.07476807, 0.08660889, 0.017959595, 0.022750854, 0.038238525, -0.048797607, 0.04071045, 0.045806885, -0.014724731, -0.0024929047, -0.02633667, -0.04434204, 0.0048713684, -0.068481445, 0.0082092285, -0.040161133, 0.025268555, -0.030929565, 0.007106781, 0.024765015, -0.064819336, -0.023345947, -0.011192322, -0.0748291, 0.01713562, -0.018615723, 0.023666382, 0.04055786, -0.016937256, 0.0022144318, 0.049957275, -0.0072898865, 0.03189087, -0.00415802, -0.07910156, 0.01789856, -0.030929565, 0.073913574, -0.046539307, -0.010299683, -0.0054893494, 0.01727295, 0.005657196, -0.011817932, -0.015792847, 0.037017822, -0.0154953, -0.06945801, 0.019500732, -0.00894165, -0.03894043, -0.03967285, 0.0046463013, -0.007545471, -0.02331543, -0.008293152, -0.00894165, -0.056549072, -0.0054397583, 0.009971619, -0.030044556, 0.030578613, 0.033813477, -0.014198303, 0.02558899, 0.013832092, -0.052520752, -0.010269165, -0.031402588, 0.0010080338, 0.0038795471, -0.049926758, 0.00056266785, 0.017242432, 0.034088135, -0.0124435425, -0.051879883, 0.04949951, 0.016967773, 0.0029659271, 0.04095459, 0.035339355, 0.0060539246, 0.012710571, -0.0065460205, 0.008781433, -0.03466797, -0.036621094, 0.0010433197, 0.029647827, 0.010940552, -0.01234436, -0.016174316, 0.036834717, -0.04248047, -0.015960693, 0.04928589, 0.023757935, 0.002632141, 0.022262573, 0.05218506, -0.050964355, -0.037322998, 0.018829346, -0.015007019, 0.009674072, 0.024276733, -0.025558472, 0.002243042, -0.014122009, 0.018463135, -0.057739258, 0.03918457, 0.022354126, 0.030075073, 0.008911133, -0.011665344, -0.017074585, 0.091552734, 0.010681152, -0.012893677, -0.01550293, -0.0018692017, -0.0143966675, -0.017547607, -0.011024475, -0.019729614, -0.045928955, -0.051513672, -0.05331421, 0.034210205, -0.045532227, 0.03665161, -0.00083589554, -0.019363403, 0.019439697, -0.03439331, 0.023971558, 0.0015268326, -0.0423584, -0.0960083, -0.013755798, -0.0072746277 ], "summary": [ -0.035461426, -0.006626129, -0.02607727, -0.016647339, -0.030578613, 0.0027980804, -0.032073975, -0.0043678284, 0.010025024, 0.0057144165, -0.049743652, -0.009529114, 0.00258255, -0.026535034, 0.010055542, -0.023040771, 0.004234314, 0.027450562, 0.008171082, -0.03967285, 0.01852417, -0.024627686, -0.020095825, 0.03768921, 0.010688782, -0.024139404, -0.03765869, 0.020492554, 0.0057640076, 0.011520386, 0.008102417, 0.011276245, 0.023498535, 0.044189453, -0.05831909, 0.0011062622, -0.03955078, 0.031951904, -0.011123657, 0.012207031, 0.042999268, -0.021606445, 0.040740967, -0.025619507, 0.004081726, 0.03942871, -0.011940002, -0.033843994, -0.0019512177, 0.050811768, 0.00030469894, 0.034423828, -0.014205933, 0.039794922, 0.033416748, 0.017715454, -0.015106201, -0.006252289, 0.0035762787, 0.050689697, 0.03152466, 0.035003662, -0.03265381, -0.028640747, 0.02520752, -0.031433105, 0.046539307, 0.026535034, 0.008811951, 0.027832031, 0.019348145, 0.026123047, -0.0063171387, 0.013046265, -0.028671265, -0.010749817, 0.021881104, 0.010948181, -0.0042266846, 0.011161804, -0.027145386, 0.018218994, -0.022918701, -0.04928589, -0.006149292, -0.034973145, -0.032714844, 0.008514404, -0.0034065247, -0.00070238113, 0.003042221, -0.041229248, -0.015037537, 0.055145264, 0.022399902, -0.045654297, -0.004447937, -0.027908325, 0.029403687, 0.029449463, 0.044830322, -0.06817627, 0.06286621, -0.033203125, -0.021224976, 0.035491943, -0.04159546, -0.06640625, 0.0069084167, 0.04727173, -0.00032162666, -0.079589844, -0.008560181, -0.009864807, -0.013206482, 0.0043296814, -0.02330017, 0.055480957, -0.0015916824, 0.05822754, 0.0051460266, 0.019088745, -0.014381409, 0.03286743, 0.019699097, 0.027236938, 0.018432617, -0.022201538, -0.0803833, 0.032440186, -0.0236969, 0.037841797, 0.033813477, 0.01008606, -0.020965576, -0.022781372, -0.005794525, 0.007572174, 0.017242432, -0.033691406, 0.047698975, -0.015853882, -0.01687622, 0.049743652, -0.005290985, 0.013923645, 0.028778076, 0.01838684, -0.035064697, -0.027862549, 0.0052375793, 0.023117065, 0.01878357, 0.002111435, -0.023956299, -0.034606934, -0.035888672, -0.02003479, 0.027175903, -0.029556274, 0.0597229, 0.01171875, -0.00944519, 0.09088135, 0.03656006, -0.008277893, 0.007911682, -0.0068855286, 0.0060577393, 0.018508911, 0.00248909, 0.008110046, 0.0018577576, -0.0077819824, -0.0014324188, -0.01676941, 0.020248413, -0.011459351, 0.045166016, -0.089904785, -0.07196045, -0.029205322, 0.049102783, -0.025390625, -0.008033752, 0.03640747, 0.015563965, 0.038238525, -0.0049743652, 0.00055646896, -0.024642944, 0.041778564, -0.0043296814, 0.013145447, -0.009635925, 0.014831543, -0.01550293, 0.038360596, -0.0129470825, -0.05996704, 0.017166138, 0.016601562, -0.0061569214, -0.028030396, -0.07269287, -0.016906738, -0.006401062, 0.0309906, -0.02319336, 0.03564453, 0.010467529, -0.026779175, -0.016983032, 0.017242432, 0.011260986, -0.046905518, 0.018630981, -0.044189453, 0.011734009, -0.03829956, -0.015640259, 0.037078857, -0.03213501, 0.041931152, -0.032592773, 0.026901245, -0.025939941, 0.04144287, -0.008674622, 0.038635254, 0.05001831, -0.051635742, 0.020126343, 0.032104492, -0.027023315, 0.011962891, 0.018417358, 0.017944336, -0.010375977, 0.014808655, 0.0014696121, -0.021102905, -0.04598999, 0.037597656, -0.003522873, 0.016662598, 0.01826477, 0.03237915, -0.019546509, -0.01084137, 0.039245605, -0.025619507, 0.018295288, -0.03869629, -0.011436462, 0.013206482, -0.0018730164, -0.0050239563, 0.0074386597, -0.016342163, 0.01171875, -0.008888245, -0.013114929, 0.0009317398, -0.06088257, 0.022735596, -0.025161743, -0.0057296753, 0.007648468, -0.006904602, 0.016815186, -0.047912598, 0.006919861, -0.013252258, -0.08911133, -0.0154953, -0.0044517517, 0.03479004, -0.018966675, -0.03692627, -0.0015697479, -0.004535675, -0.009391785, -0.0018854141, 0.026397705, 0.0056648254, 0.01399231, -0.013671875, 0.0054512024, 0.021972656, 0.022506714, 0.06732178, 0.03112793, 0.0178833, 0.010826111, 0.008743286, 0.036010742, 0.024642944, -0.014595032, 0.004043579, -0.016433716, 0.021606445, 0.006717682, -0.02658081, 0.007911682, 0.026992798, 0.041259766, -0.011741638, 0.006500244, 0.044830322, -0.059661865, -0.000109016895, 0.024276733, 0.04083252, -0.056640625, -0.040618896, -0.05380249, -0.0002424717, -0.081848145, -0.029418945, 0.11199951, 0.037628174, 0.014846802, 0.01878357, 0.015602112, -0.060913086, 0.044036865, -0.032836914, 0.007507324, -0.005756378, 0.030899048, 0.008872986, -0.004802704, 0.009918213, 0.017288208, 0.00065279007, 0.015029907, -0.016433716, 0.022064209, 0.037994385, 0.062683105, 0.02067566, 0.0032024384, -0.007286072, -0.030761719, -0.04144287, 0.003868103, 0.0024089813, -0.04849243, -0.0026550293, 0.036193848, -0.007987976, -0.012374878, 0.007785797, 0.008392334, 0.05834961, 0.026977539, -0.01361084, 0.039245605, -0.04824829, 0.004032135, 0.009788513, -0.019378662, -0.06384277, 0.02217102, -0.033477783, -0.020736694, -0.01939392, 0.017089844, 0.037872314, 0.020187378, 0.016799927, -0.00034928322, -0.031555176, -0.024810791, -0.028808594, 0.10760498, 0.026123047, -0.06060791, 0.04916382, 0.039001465, -0.010299683, 0.026672363, -0.0657959, 0.06451416, 0.014976501, -0.022857666, 0.017868042, 0.012168884, -0.010513306, -0.02267456, 0.00061941147, 0.013916016, -0.007888794, -0.02458191, -0.012046814, -0.027542114, -0.019470215, -0.0040283203, 0.007472992, 0.052886963, 0.032836914, -0.010566711, 0.008453369, 0.011940002, -0.041809082, 0.06866455, -0.020141602, -0.007369995, 0.015525818, 0.02178955, -0.024642944, 0.008888245, 0.0027103424, 0.021240234, -0.049560547, -0.001996994, -0.0017642975, -0.017211914, 0.007461548, -0.0077209473, 0.08526611, -0.0035438538, 0.036224365, 0.078063965, 0.04574585, 0.0118637085, -0.06842041, 0.022018433, 0.011474609, 0.041931152, -0.0138549805, -0.016052246, -0.013412476, -0.022857666, 0.012397766, 0.0076560974, 0.016845703, 0.022506714, -0.03881836, -0.07006836, -0.013702393, 0.039520264, 0.035095215, 0.030685425, -0.013191223, -0.033447266, -0.048675537, 0.005695343, 0.08862305, -0.0045166016, 0.004257202, 0.023666382, 0.034942627, -0.048583984, -0.027893066, -0.012817383, 0.04434204, 0.062927246, 0.0034618378, 0.028793335, -0.009788513, -0.022598267, 0.060455322, 0.01852417, 0.024291992, -0.003774643, 0.032440186, -0.028137207, 0.0062294006, 0.008621216, -0.028411865, 0.020202637, -0.015716553, -0.003068924, -0.07513428, 0.015235901, 0.041625977, 0.0012464523, -0.059051514, -0.047607422, 0.027450562, -0.022338867, -0.02468872, -0.0036907196, 0.012817383, -0.007713318, -0.018096924, 0.0006928444, 0.014404297, -0.030899048, -0.03074646, 0.01235199, -0.0017347336, -0.036468506, 0.032409668, -0.0034275055, 0.034057617, -0.0017118454, -0.0625, 0.0054626465, 0.002981186, 0.03677368, 0.006793976, -0.009498596, 0.00548172, 0.013671875, -0.007598877, 0.00491333, -0.00932312, 0.019729614, -0.03164673, 0.003967285, 0.01626587, -0.021560669, 0.008598328, 0.014984131, -0.023880005, -0.02218628, 0.016693115, 0.059509277, 0.06112671, -0.041900635, 0.020202637, 0.036712646, -0.010223389, -0.066711426, 0.006164551, 0.013717651, -0.033355713, 0.031311035, -0.00063323975, -0.0026721954, 0.030914307, 0.009750366, 0.01424408, -0.027893066, -0.043762207, 0.024536133, 0.028335571, -0.0040359497, -0.0095825195, -0.01436615, 0.0657959, -0.018478394, -0.012489319, -0.013710022, 0.017440796, -0.008087158, -0.027526855, -0.00045514107, 0.0098724365, -0.018066406, -0.04147339, -0.03164673, 0.061950684, 0.014289856, 0.0014276505, -0.012321472, 0.033813477, -0.0023612976, 0.0044517517, -0.003993988, 0.017211914, 0.00390625, 0.017410278, -0.014099121, -0.051635742, 0.017471313, -0.015411377, -0.038879395, -0.037139893, -0.037963867, -0.04699707, -0.027328491, 0.005378723, -0.0032024384, -0.000036656857, -0.0064353943, -0.0093307495, 0.012672424, -0.02482605, -0.025726318, -0.050872803, -0.023956299, -0.031402588, 0.017608643, 0.0049705505, -0.016098022, -0.04373169, 0.020721436, -0.02810669, -0.045562744, -0.10168457, 0.0026893616, 0.03414917, 0.0059547424, 0.082458496, 0.04940796, 0.022140503, 0.019958496, 0.01158905, -0.00907135, -0.01826477, 0.0018224716, 0.019882202, 0.030883789, 0.005748749, 0.030776978, 0.05923462, -0.009399414, -0.045562744, -0.03378296, 0.04751587, -0.007583618, 0.0008568764, 0.026046753, -0.013725281, 0.013435364, -0.011543274, 0.047790527, 0.0005955696, 0.026763916, 0.05142212, -0.00070762634, -0.01121521, 0.025100708, 0.012969971, -0.013931274, 0.019943237, 0.007286072, 0.008071899, -0.06549072, -0.081970215, -0.05593872, 0.06616211, -0.0016126633, -0.04309082, -0.020339966, -0.044036865, 0.005710602, -0.012084961, -0.04977417, -0.0151901245, 0.0124435425, -0.028884888, -0.04333496, -0.014053345, -0.03451538, -0.018432617, -0.030090332, -0.004737854, 0.009132385, -0.043304443, -0.00050258636, -0.04949951, -0.013458252, 0.03466797, -0.016906738, -0.014556885, -0.05267334, 0.0025691986, 0.009773254, -0.037231445, 0.039520264, 0.025100708, 0.034973145, 0.0065727234, 0.030075073, -0.03353882, -0.030380249, -0.0060272217, 0.01626587, -0.029846191, 0.005340576, -0.0019683838, 0.01966858, 0.0042800903, 0.018341064, -0.05722046, -0.013031006, -0.041748047, -0.0033340454, -0.009254456, -0.0015678406, -0.0020103455, 0.06011963, 0.02319336, -0.013000488, 0.012329102, -0.030731201, -0.020004272, -0.015022278, 0.0030994415, 0.0049858093, -0.022094727, -0.020751953, -0.0041389465, -0.014633179, -0.017044067, 0.016052246, 0.009605408, -0.010414124, -0.031204224, -0.009895325, 0.014427185, -0.03463745, 0.01902771, -0.008659363, -0.0010404587, -0.0016956329, 0.023880005, 0.024993896, 0.0017547607, -0.035064697, -0.044708252, -0.06921387, -0.06427002, -0.05908203, 0.062561035, -0.013786316, 0.021133423, 0.037597656, -0.011161804, 0.032440186, 0.0045700073, -0.041137695, 0.017959595, -0.014801025, -0.018295288, 0.033416748, -0.0124053955, -0.01576233, 0.020324707, -0.0034484863, -0.022720337, 0.017349243, 0.0030651093, -0.017059326, 0.031707764, -0.0058631897, 0.0049476624, 0.0259552, 0.013404846, -0.022964478, 0.010101318, 0.011100769, -0.022842407, 0.0055122375, -0.017166138, 0.031585693, 0.012207031, 0.005592346, -0.019683838, 0.03164673, -0.023498535, 0.006175995, -0.010871887, 0.008384705, -0.033355713, -0.08758545, -0.0070724487, -0.007785797, 0.018173218, 0.030426025, 0.005973816, -0.030899048, 0.028411865, 0.01222229, -0.029891968, -0.03817749, 0.015914917, -0.012718201, -0.015731812, 0.064697266, -0.012672424, -0.009536743, 0.014511108, 0.017807007, -0.02104187, -0.011833191, 0.014884949, 0.064941406, 0.033050537, -0.0034770966, 0.020477295, 0.056732178, 0.0023021698, -0.008781433, 0.0057525635, 0.042236328, 0.015838623, -0.011116028, 0.008460999, 0.034729004, 0.030853271, -0.016143799, -0.025360107, -0.0093307495, -0.026016235, 0.015701294, -0.016723633, -0.07373047, -0.053100586, -0.055664062, 0.00522995, 0.005004883, -0.018157959, -0.013008118, 0.06427002, 0.0057754517, 0.01876831, 0.0054626465, -0.06097412, -0.022521973, -0.019470215, 0.046020508, 0.0042419434, 0.0115737915, 0.04147339, -0.023239136, 0.022338867, -0.0033798218, 0.053222656, 0.03640747, -0.030273438, 0.014060974, 0.014266968, -0.0022296906, -0.045715332, 0.016235352, -0.047302246, 0.023208618, 0.012397766, 0.05291748, 0.0024681091, -0.02709961, 0.036834717, -0.020950317, -0.014030457, 0.080078125, -0.042419434, 0.078430176, 0.081970215, -0.025436401, 0.013710022, -0.0013742447, -0.043518066, 0.03375244, 0.011199951, 0.03753662, -0.04840088, -0.02368164, -0.00018310547, 0.012962341, -0.011764526, 0.01210022, -0.04272461, -0.026687622, 0.042785645, 0.01802063, -0.036590576, -0.029800415, 0.02015686, -0.011993408, 0.04095459, 0.009437561, 0.03540039, 0.022735596, 0.079711914, 0.044830322, -0.064331055, 0.014076233, 0.034973145, -0.011116028, 0.0025920868, 0.039642334, -0.026931763, 0.022888184, -0.00034856796, 0.091430664, 0.10430908, 0.06506348, -0.024108887, 0.03656006, 0.08648682, -0.038848877, 0.041625977, 0.03253174, -0.0061798096, -0.02784729, 0.0046043396, -0.003320694, 0.012519836, -0.013977051, 0.011642456, -0.061767578, 0.018005371, -0.011062622, -0.01876831, -0.018173218, -0.020187378, -0.00017225742, -0.022521973, -0.062561035, 0.021972656, 0.008140564, 0.019226074, 0.051757812, -0.01586914, -0.030197144, 0.039215088, -0.025314331, 0.02796936, 0.0016727448, -0.039245605, -0.019195557, -0.01121521, 0.036621094, -0.028579712, -0.00032663345, 0.031463623, 0.0146102905, -0.0079193115, -0.02494812, 0.0044822693, 0.047332764, -0.013412476, -0.06542969, 0.022201538, 0.0015974045, -0.038909912, -0.030227661, -0.041656494, 0.003917694, -0.028793335, -0.0022468567, 0.009346008, -0.02998352, -0.008773804, 0.0069389343, -0.026016235, -0.0040664673, 0.019836426, -0.008110046, 0.029678345, 0.020324707, -0.074279785, -0.006252289, -0.025650024, -0.007724762, 0.02067566, -0.04156494, -0.016143799, 0.0501709, 0.032592773, -0.011299133, 0.015045166, 0.061157227, 0.024215698, 0.017044067, -0.018508911, -0.0034732819, -0.0070495605, -0.01675415, 0.020950317, 0.011932373, -0.044128418, -0.03564453, -0.01576233, 0.062042236, -0.0055503845, -0.0206604, -0.025650024, 0.023483276, -0.00068855286, -0.014892578, 0.03668213, -0.0061073303, -0.013717651, 0.014839172, 0.04660034, -0.012527466, -0.038879395, 0.011314392, -0.040374756, 0.011756897, 0.013725281, -0.038726807, 0.004673004, -0.038024902, -0.012710571, -0.05307007, 0.059814453, -0.028182983, -0.019699097, 0.0010499954, -0.053649902, -0.026794434, 0.068481445, 0.029129028, -0.013305664, -0.016311646, -0.012809753, -0.0004901886, -0.029464722, -0.05130005, 0.012420654, -0.04156494, -0.03112793, -0.05508423, 0.04815674, -0.05984497, 0.021133423, 0.0023593903, -0.009437561, 0.031188965, -0.04309082, 0.007347107, 0.05657959, -0.032043457, -0.060760498, -0.061065674, -0.003622055 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2104.13190v1
Extending Isolation Forest for Anomaly Detection in Big Data via K-Means
Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Jimmy Huang, Vladan Smetana, Chris Stewart, Kees Pouw, Aijun An, Stephen Chan, Lei Liu
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Industrial Information Technology (IT) infrastructures are often vulnerable to cyberattacks. To ensure security to the computer systems in an industrial environment, it is required to build effective intrusion detection systems to monitor the cyber-physical systems (e.g., computer networks) in the industry for malicious activities. This paper aims to build such intrusion detection systems to protect the computer networks from cyberattacks. More specifically, we propose a novel unsupervised machine learning approach that combines the K-Means algorithm with the Isolation Forest for anomaly detection in industrial big data scenarios. Since our objective is to build the intrusion detection system for the big data scenario in the industrial domain, we utilize the Apache Spark framework to implement our proposed model which was trained in large network traffic data (about 123 million instances of network traffic) stored in Elasticsearch. Moreover, we evaluate our proposed model on the live streaming data and find that our proposed system can be used for real-time anomaly detection in the industrial setup. In addition, we address different challenges that we face while training our model on large datasets and explicitly describe how these issues were resolved. Based on our empirical evaluation in different use-cases for anomaly detection in real-world network traffic data, we observe that our proposed system is effective to detect anomalies in big data scenarios. Finally, we evaluate our proposed model on several academic datasets to compare with other models and find that it provides comparable performance with other state-of-the-art approaches.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2104.13190v1
"2021-04-27T16:21:48"
"2021-04-27T16:21:48"
{ "title": [ -0.009651184, -0.007205963, -0.04916382, -0.0592041, 0.016967773, -0.0059509277, -0.008934021, 0.007987976, -0.011932373, 0.018798828, -0.049835205, 0.029891968, -0.025970459, -0.0055503845, -0.040283203, -0.019515991, -0.00856781, 0.03265381, 0.0011949539, -0.023880005, 0.012718201, -0.04360962, 0.044189453, -0.0032081604, 0.039733887, 0.0002861023, -0.042053223, 0.0104599, -0.015640259, -0.019104004, -0.003572464, -0.018844604, 0.044128418, 0.036743164, -0.043914795, 0.0004708767, -0.07330322, 0.038330078, -0.0058288574, 0.013076782, 0.0072784424, -0.002363205, 0.010406494, -0.013671875, -0.0236969, 0.056518555, -0.08679199, -0.046173096, -0.014312744, 0.015060425, 0.027160645, 0.01776123, 0.0069007874, 0.022613525, 0.009468079, -0.032409668, -0.028900146, -0.01361084, 0.02658081, 0.053741455, 0.03314209, -0.041381836, 0.014579773, 0.0003809929, -0.046295166, -0.02331543, -0.0118255615, 0.02142334, 0.058898926, -0.023132324, -0.009918213, 0.039215088, -0.0025234222, 0.01651001, -0.051116943, -0.02229309, 0.05545044, -0.005958557, 0.013687134, -0.0055618286, -0.0074005127, -0.0259552, 0.007129669, -0.020431519, 0.026046753, -0.025604248, -0.021896362, -0.008476257, -0.028656006, -0.022888184, -0.010063171, -0.02218628, -0.0035877228, 0.037719727, 0.007331848, -0.005039215, 0.012817383, 0.047210693, -0.007888794, -0.034454346, 0.0062217712, -0.0012645721, -0.043670654, -0.01374054, 0.008331299, 0.000025451183, -0.012687683, -0.09667969, -0.020141602, 0.025665283, -0.04815674, 0.0021820068, 0.019073486, 0.022064209, -0.005924225, 0.004863739, 0.014205933, 0.010528564, 0.0018959045, 0.020614624, -0.011108398, -0.011566162, -0.0060195923, -0.029312134, 0.004234314, -0.0473938, -0.05859375, 0.038208008, -0.009178162, 0.00018441677, 0.027175903, 0.021011353, -0.10046387, -0.04525757, -0.041290283, 0.04147339, -0.0011453629, 0.0022697449, 0.010536194, -0.016143799, 0.026809692, -0.028793335, -0.024307251, 0.041107178, 0.032928467, 0.009407043, 0.05770874, -0.01348114, -0.03842163, -0.0009803772, -0.003255844, -0.0029697418, 0.03665161, 0.0007252693, -0.07122803, -0.008834839, -0.11419678, -0.009231567, 0.003288269, -0.00548172, -0.0045433044, -0.0031147003, 0.004234314, 0.0007801056, 0.024383545, 0.015327454, -0.0012102127, 0.01852417, 0.000644207, -0.013916016, -0.017211914, 0.022369385, -0.0024795532, -0.015548706, -0.009994507, -0.0031337738, 0.032928467, 0.0046958923, 0.020339966, -0.020874023, 0.005859375, -0.021911621, -0.0046463013, 0.05142212, -0.07446289, 0.019882202, 0.024230957, 0.033081055, 0.023590088, 0.0115356445, -0.03656006, 0.055725098, -0.06781006, -0.00630188, -0.012145996, -0.009864807, 0.013641357, 0.012512207, 0.005001068, -0.031280518, -0.020568848, 0.009689331, -0.045532227, 0.018218994, -0.008811951, -0.03515625, -0.0063056946, 0.015052795, -0.05609131, 0.05758667, 0.06286621, 0.02670288, -0.0703125, 0.04269409, 0.02243042, -0.055877686, 0.0178833, -0.033203125, -0.022323608, -0.009269714, -0.050109863, 0.020904541, -0.026275635, 0.035217285, -0.002407074, -0.0023174286, 0.0016374588, -0.036193848, 0.033111572, 0.008300781, 0.075927734, -0.03955078, 0.020736694, -0.015090942, -0.010734558, -0.021957397, -0.027374268, -0.024047852, 0.0011854172, 0.030654907, 0.010658264, -0.016296387, 0.00774765, 0.02078247, 0.044921875, -0.01675415, 0.020019531, 0.0028057098, 0.016494751, 0.028167725, 0.05053711, 0.043304443, 0.042114258, 0.023895264, 0.020767212, 0.052215576, -0.0022659302, 0.023971558, -0.060272217, 0.037109375, -0.014907837, 0.009963989, 0.0061683655, -0.00008255243, -0.044036865, 0.03488159, 0.0000121593475, 0.036193848, 0.0098724365, 0.020812988, 0.011512756, -0.030014038, 0.0118637085, 0.027954102, -0.014427185, -0.022735596, 0.0044784546, 0.00017094612, -0.008728027, -0.053771973, -0.016586304, 0.019500732, 0.02619934, -0.013679504, 0.02973938, -0.009338379, -0.007335663, -0.06591797, -0.0093688965, -0.0023460388, 0.055908203, 0.040740967, -0.00011861324, -0.005783081, -0.0013284683, 0.0027618408, 0.05456543, 0.05078125, -0.0053863525, 0.010864258, -0.048553467, 0.023788452, -0.018692017, 0.0068969727, 0.011810303, 0.013725281, 0.044799805, 0.027496338, -0.01260376, 0.008651733, -0.047668457, -0.007713318, 0.0027446747, -0.042419434, -0.020492554, -0.050476074, 0.0088272095, -0.04208374, -0.023834229, -0.007949829, 0.072021484, 0.009399414, -0.05307007, -0.011405945, 0.015098572, -0.009986877, -0.03967285, -0.048553467, -0.01878357, 0.027832031, 0.051727295, 0.0385437, -0.035827637, -0.0015611649, 0.007068634, 0.011993408, -0.022369385, 0.028747559, -0.020996094, 0.008590698, 0.0038490295, -0.024047852, 0.024169922, -0.042633057, -0.02444458, -0.04360962, -0.016159058, 0.017700195, -0.050598145, -0.026763916, 0.0635376, -0.02633667, -0.051879883, -0.017150879, 0.02810669, -0.008857727, 0.016677856, -0.0077171326, 0.006210327, -0.04714966, 0.03265381, 0.021530151, -0.0029792786, -0.056396484, -0.044647217, -0.026809692, -0.0009303093, -0.020874023, 0.022018433, 0.06591797, -0.0390625, -0.0013275146, -0.024520874, 0.0008969307, 0.036376953, -0.010025024, -0.0031166077, -0.023590088, -0.02696228, -0.02192688, -0.01676941, -0.0048179626, -0.023910522, -0.009757996, 0.10827637, -0.016403198, -0.0057754517, 0.030410767, 0.044433594, 0.015136719, -0.009986877, -0.024383545, -0.021484375, 0.016647339, 0.005569458, 0.0059661865, -0.00044751167, -0.0028591156, -0.09472656, -0.00082826614, 0.042175293, 0.008483887, -0.031555176, 0.02810669, -0.06463623, -0.0087890625, -0.0040359497, -0.011360168, 0.023788452, 0.06713867, -0.00699234, 0.013076782, 0.013435364, -0.015960693, 0.011352539, -0.021606445, -0.072631836, 0.026626587, -0.0340271, -0.05343628, -0.0107803345, 0.010910034, -0.029815674, -0.015472412, -0.035949707, 0.008514404, 0.027008057, 0.03427124, 0.016952515, -0.0015821457, -0.0072135925, -0.024658203, 0.026046753, -0.025314331, -0.06201172, -0.068115234, -0.027954102, 0.04788208, 0.01701355, -0.020126343, -0.012886047, -0.02293396, -0.0027942657, 0.041046143, 0.0259552, -0.045837402, -0.033416748, -0.011116028, 0.0115356445, 0.02859497, -0.026855469, -0.018051147, -0.005748749, 0.007259369, -0.033355713, 0.0049934387, 0.023025513, 0.0042915344, -0.036010742, -0.011100769, 0.021514893, -0.012573242, -0.07537842, 0.0013208389, 0.025375366, 0.0079574585, 0.017288208, 0.0035152435, -0.0077667236, 0.003572464, -0.0116119385, 0.006084442, -0.024490356, -0.016204834, 0.00037026405, 0.010307312, -0.00018405914, 0.0011730194, 0.01423645, -0.01966858, -0.014450073, 0.019165039, -0.028671265, -0.083496094, -0.016479492, -0.0021133423, -0.12463379, -0.048309326, 0.030059814, -0.025253296, 0.0021133423, -0.07385254, 0.021606445, 0.0038089752, -0.02293396, 0.00036978722, -0.013671875, 0.0007414818, -0.014503479, -0.07800293, -0.012199402, 0.062194824, -0.0019741058, 0.01939392, 0.005420685, 0.00894165, -0.020843506, -0.054260254, -0.0006160736, -0.046844482, 0.020004272, -0.037261963, -0.016616821, 0.04537964, -0.038330078, 0.044921875, -0.021530151, 0.023101807, -0.023590088, -0.007843018, 0.004131317, 0.0006804466, -0.01586914, 0.0440979, -0.0026512146, -0.014549255, -0.053497314, 0.0072021484, -0.011230469, -0.03643799, 0.0025615692, -0.013038635, 0.033416748, 0.040740967, 0.010734558, 0.09643555, -0.025772095, 0.019424438, 0.030303955, -0.044433594, -0.0056533813, 0.0073547363, 0.022964478, 0.008338928, 0.019073486, 0.01374054, 0.015174866, 0.03439331, -0.025497437, -0.021133423, -0.013336182, 0.01977539, -0.04309082, -0.025482178, -0.037628174, -0.046295166, -0.002155304, 0.008422852, -0.00730896, -0.035217285, 0.032073975, 0.008728027, -0.04736328, 0.005683899, 0.04031372, -0.005054474, 0.01751709, -0.04055786, -0.0059051514, 0.01663208, -0.04437256, -0.019744873, 0.006603241, -0.005470276, 0.022460938, -0.02798462, -0.0121154785, 0.010513306, 0.028961182, 0.054779053, 0.026245117, 0.0039367676, -0.03817749, 0.011260986, -0.025543213, -0.013519287, 0.03503418, -0.0035209656, 0.0024261475, -0.020446777, -0.000056266785, -0.014518738, -0.029205322, -0.03201294, 0.029647827, 0.011062622, 0.05105591, -0.0024528503, 0.027191162, 0.036895752, -0.007583618, 0.0029335022, 0.015296936, -0.05343628, 0.011306763, -0.005130768, 0.044555664, -0.044036865, 0.023925781, 0.030456543, 0.016479492, -0.03201294, 0.0002937317, 0.040985107, 0.01763916, -0.03050232, -0.0063056946, 0.01576233, -0.022598267, -0.039520264, 0.0049476624, 0.008796692, 0.037353516, -0.055511475, 0.03274536, -0.01184845, 0.00687027, 0.045013428, 0.0009007454, 0.005130768, 0.0075645447, 0.007797241, -0.05532837, -0.047668457, -0.018798828, 0.054138184, -0.03302002, -0.00957489, 0.0044670105, 0.03866577, 0.011512756, 0.04534912, 0.0073051453, 0.035217285, -0.023880005, 0.0028266907, 0.006362915, -0.044036865, -0.034973145, 0.025177002, 0.0062828064, 0.0053596497, -0.038757324, 0.0034236908, -0.054351807, -0.009613037, -0.01625061, 0.011505127, -0.021865845, -0.052124023, 0.0033035278, 0.015716553, 0.02154541, 0.014083862, -0.04550171, 0.03643799, 0.038146973, 0.030044556, 0.024917603, -0.01235199, 0.035369873, -0.029937744, -0.0026226044, 0.0031375885, 0.012428284, -0.012771606, 0.03488159, -0.0038375854, -0.012512207, -0.045776367, 0.03765869, 0.03213501, -0.005580902, 0.007926941, -0.06402588, 0.006324768, -0.030471802, 0.0073661804, 0.038909912, 0.02067566, -0.026428223, 0.0037879944, 0.034973145, -0.0075416565, -0.008285522, 0.05319214, -0.04727173, -0.041046143, -0.0073394775, 0.015823364, 0.010139465, -0.008506775, 0.032073975, -0.035736084, 0.0061683655, 0.039123535, -0.057434082, 0.014503479, -0.046966553, 0.00957489, 0.037628174, 0.013458252, 0.01940918, 0.012817383, -0.043273926, -0.06347656, -0.07147217, 0.0017595291, 0.0017681122, 0.030685425, -0.036346436, -0.016281128, 0.0069084167, -0.017944336, 0.012672424, 0.031097412, -0.048614502, 0.009101868, 0.010131836, 0.0043945312, -0.009399414, 0.050323486, 0.0059928894, -0.018661499, -0.013832092, -0.03451538, -0.0074806213, 0.00982666, -0.00094890594, -0.008026123, -0.08630371, 0.00349617, 0.009643555, 0.011787415, 0.0016183853, 0.027496338, 0.031036377, 0.011558533, 0.011070251, 0.019165039, 0.06451416, -0.04547119, -0.042633057, -0.025650024, 0.0059318542, -0.035308838, 0.06982422, -0.010787964, -0.032287598, -0.040740967, -0.03765869, -0.0209198, 0.02468872, 0.003353119, 0.008071899, 0.018173218, -0.003917694, 0.062438965, -0.03677368, -0.028533936, -0.035186768, 0.05230713, -0.0058517456, -0.059020996, 0.011978149, -0.045532227, 0.008056641, -0.05758667, 0.0078086853, -0.002998352, 0.031829834, 0.0023212433, -0.008728027, -0.0018253326, -0.03189087, -0.009269714, 0.04043579, 0.019607544, -0.0055885315, 0.0715332, -0.036712646, 0.02758789, -0.0020751953, 0.0395813, 0.015258789, -0.00007325411, 0.0039978027, 0.004966736, 0.010322571, -0.040985107, -0.033111572, -0.048919678, -0.042785645, -0.05404663, -0.019989014, -0.034729004, -0.00054359436, 0.0017538071, 0.0154418945, 0.030288696, 0.01689148, 0.018356323, 0.014984131, 0.047058105, 0.02130127, 0.06793213, 0.0033721924, -0.0015468597, 0.0052604675, 0.029510498, 0.0057296753, 0.024887085, -0.0040016174, 0.032470703, 0.022476196, -0.00623703, -0.023086548, 0.03744507, 0.017333984, -0.009880066, 0.010559082, -0.0104904175, 0.0058174133, -0.017303467, 0.012138367, 0.05480957, 0.025878906, 0.010047913, -0.027786255, 0.019744873, -0.0078125, -0.012786865, 0.028259277, 0.042755127, -0.06573486, 0.04550171, -0.009414673, -0.03149414, -0.006839752, 0.016906738, 0.033721924, -0.06750488, -0.055389404, 0.005241394, 0.044921875, 0.021102905, -0.0043525696, -0.032440186, -0.0037708282, -0.01763916, 0.0034675598, 0.03237915, 0.018051147, 0.014083862, 0.01499176, -0.026565552, -0.0069389343, -0.00434494, 0.047698975, -0.013549805, 0.033691406, -0.072631836, -0.0112838745, -0.040893555, -0.03326416, -0.031311035, 0.0036029816, -0.04006958, -0.04623413, 0.093933105, 0.029724121, 0.036865234, 0.04953003, 0.0073890686, -0.02684021, 0.020935059, -0.06958008, -0.0042304993, 0.053344727, -0.04159546, 0.012123108, -0.020431519, -0.040374756, 0.03338623, -0.040893555, 0.048950195, -0.06652832, 0.0055618286, -0.005432129, -0.0023651123, 0.037719727, -0.0390625, -0.018615723, -0.017288208, -0.017288208, 0.004951477, 0.034484863, -0.033203125, -0.03656006, 0.008262634, 0.01084137, 0.0064201355, -0.012908936, -0.027450562, -0.02268982, -0.046020508, -0.009307861, -0.032226562, 0.023849487, -0.016906738, -0.013061523, -0.041381836, 0.013053894, -0.004047394, 0.00365448, 0.0066184998, -0.010765076, -0.04800415, -0.06591797, 0.0395813, 0.029937744, -0.032928467, -0.064086914, 0.008987427, -0.026046753, -0.032592773, -0.0016183853, 0.02281189, -0.044128418, -0.0057754517, -0.0043678284, -0.03692627, 0.03552246, 0.03024292, 0.0025348663, -0.00554657, 0.026489258, -0.0035114288, -0.014129639, 0.031921387, 0.051971436, -0.017120361, -0.03756714, -0.0024433136, 0.06222534, 0.042236328, -0.026794434, 0.027893066, 0.03604126, -0.001294136, -0.0149383545, 0.082336426, -0.0022583008, -0.0077400208, 0.013877869, 0.073913574, 0.017410278, -0.041809082, -0.07556152, -0.04434204, 0.055908203, 0.05911255, 0.00015258789, -0.012168884, 0.06414795, 0.0068969727, -0.0071754456, 0.01197052, 0.012161255, 0.010894775, 0.006378174, 0.04812622, -0.016296387, -0.022979736, 0.019744873, 0.018951416, 0.002986908, 0.052520752, -0.036743164, -0.0006289482, 0.0052833557, 0.007926941, -0.036315918, -0.084350586, 0.051452637, 0.04336548, -0.0024814606, 0.030334473, -0.017990112, -0.013679504, 0.0011644363, -0.022232056, -0.00083065033, -0.0074501038, 0.0231781, -0.05496216, -0.013786316, -0.02659607, 0.00013315678, -0.054351807, -0.053253174, 0.075927734, -0.02885437, -0.023635864, -0.046783447, -0.025482178, -0.021835327, 0.04663086, -0.018661499, -0.049102783, -0.014633179, 0.0011663437, 0.06378174, -0.015625 ], "summary": [ -0.000020444393, -0.008743286, -0.030822754, -0.028686523, -0.0103302, -0.004798889, -0.023757935, 0.004688263, -0.021759033, 0.0074501038, -0.08251953, 0.023773193, -0.013320923, -0.0011148453, 0.042907715, -0.062561035, -0.017166138, 0.06317139, 0.04901123, -0.010238647, 0.027999878, -0.02645874, 0.0099487305, -0.026184082, -0.0022602081, 0.029632568, 0.017654419, 0.021636963, 0.016342163, 0.03643799, 0.012313843, -0.056610107, 0.017288208, 0.012023926, -0.012054443, 0.010917664, -0.022354126, 0.023376465, -0.009239197, 0.013534546, 0.023162842, 0.0051231384, 0.10272217, -0.045928955, 0.030075073, 0.062408447, -0.033081055, -0.062805176, -0.016098022, -0.018722534, 0.033477783, 0.011276245, 0.03161621, -0.016738892, 0.0009741783, 0.023742676, -0.05493164, 0.005882263, 0.019866943, 0.06970215, 0.031829834, -0.023498535, -0.0031337738, -0.036590576, -0.015182495, -0.01260376, 0.05130005, 0.0049552917, 0.007068634, -0.019729614, 0.038909912, 0.028625488, -0.0072288513, -0.013343811, -0.02861023, -0.020828247, 0.04763794, -0.031677246, -0.028015137, 0.00969696, -0.04421997, 0.018310547, 0.0045547485, -0.042510986, -0.013595581, -0.03881836, -0.035186768, 0.0077552795, -0.009544373, 0.015945435, -0.022323608, 0.02734375, -0.014251709, 0.041900635, 0.023544312, -0.012191772, 0.009986877, -0.0102005005, 0.0043678284, 0.0024814606, 0.02545166, -0.053222656, 0.036712646, -0.032989502, -0.011932373, 0.01763916, 0.023223877, -0.04837036, -0.024612427, -0.007633209, -0.04663086, -0.017745972, -0.004432678, -0.01966858, -0.040374756, 0.039215088, 0.025665283, -0.028884888, 0.012016296, -0.004245758, -0.011177063, 0.009086609, -0.029434204, 0.031677246, -0.0032653809, -0.015991211, -0.008522034, 0.027755737, -0.0056114197, -0.026931763, 0.0045547485, 0.023040771, -0.026260376, 0.02229309, -0.014381409, 0.016983032, 0.04534912, 0.04864502, 0.04776001, -0.04663086, 0.05154419, 0.003501892, -0.040161133, 0.06707764, -0.0019416809, -0.011695862, 0.015396118, 0.018463135, -0.001285553, 0.023788452, 0.012176514, 0.015312195, 0.02897644, 0.012039185, -0.046539307, -0.0055274963, -0.0026493073, -0.004798889, -0.001209259, -0.05316162, 0.025268555, 0.012939453, -0.0013122559, -0.0063934326, -0.010971069, -0.033111572, -0.0026245117, 0.0010204315, 0.00056886673, -0.04940796, -0.0038051605, 0.010032654, 0.0126953125, -0.035888672, -0.004184723, 0.0061912537, 0.0158844, 0.015556335, 0.0012435913, -0.007896423, -0.010185242, -0.047943115, -0.004764557, 0.0028839111, -0.015533447, 0.019241333, 0.0099105835, 0.052093506, 0.0056495667, 0.018539429, -0.021240234, 0.025848389, -0.024993896, 0.007850647, -0.0027446747, 0.003326416, -0.024291992, 0.021072388, -0.025238037, -0.026611328, 0.02067566, 0.01838684, -0.021087646, -0.004055023, -0.0209198, -0.0049438477, 0.008903503, 0.012046814, -0.049682617, 0.009819031, 0.023208618, -0.033294678, -0.0209198, 0.0064048767, 0.022476196, -0.024093628, 0.010231018, -0.057861328, -0.028121948, -0.014587402, -0.0440979, 0.04260254, -0.049713135, 0.027130127, -0.01537323, 0.02722168, -0.025390625, 0.020385742, 0.072021484, 0.021224976, 0.11315918, -0.05899048, 0.035736084, 0.030731201, -0.015625, -0.008590698, -0.008354187, -0.0748291, -0.013244629, 0.060638428, 0.018112183, 0.0025978088, -0.017105103, 0.0045547485, -0.022567749, -0.039398193, 0.010093689, 0.0017414093, -0.03137207, 0.018051147, 0.015029907, 0.028060913, 0.009674072, 0.016983032, -0.008384705, 0.025375366, 0.017623901, 0.053588867, -0.05960083, 0.023895264, -0.0055351257, 0.03652954, 0.007972717, 0.013420105, 0.031311035, -0.0060539246, 0.028182983, 0.03161621, 0.023895264, -0.005508423, -0.002822876, -0.070129395, 0.026947021, 0.024047852, -0.05419922, 0.0044898987, -0.008552551, -0.0061454773, 0.023468018, 0.008972168, -0.0050354004, 0.026519775, -0.035125732, -0.017471313, 0.026138306, 0.032104492, -0.027496338, -0.036346436, 0.023605347, 0.06341553, 0.057922363, 0.028411865, 0.0018348694, 0.00440979, -0.00017130375, 0.008834839, 0.019210815, 0.013015747, 0.039916992, -0.05307007, 0.0053977966, 0.025985718, -0.08831787, 0.062438965, 0.011550903, 0.0069465637, 0.018554688, 0.004638672, 0.0051727295, 0.019851685, -0.06689453, 0.003894806, 0.024017334, 0.015106201, -0.020462036, -0.03161621, -0.01991272, 0.028900146, -0.013847351, 0.0077285767, 0.04159546, -0.01889038, -0.05130005, -0.005836487, -0.021453857, 0.011146545, -0.010414124, -0.019897461, -0.022567749, 0.028320312, 0.02923584, 0.017669678, 0.0023384094, 0.04916382, 0.0118637085, 0.006954193, 0.009666443, 0.049102783, 0.025634766, 0.00033831596, 0.026306152, -0.008659363, -0.012298584, -0.00004261732, -0.039489746, -0.013412476, -0.010734558, 0.0093688965, -0.02935791, -0.018478394, 0.03778076, -0.026809692, -0.054504395, -0.01449585, 0.0019664764, -0.014793396, 0.03866577, -0.039031982, 0.0028133392, -0.053497314, 0.048797607, 0.03289795, 0.03781128, -0.03930664, -0.07836914, -0.026885986, 0.00920105, 0.026489258, 0.017929077, 0.03945923, -0.015266418, 0.007041931, -0.020126343, -0.0027179718, -0.014450073, 0.0023231506, 0.073913574, -0.003332138, -0.027832031, 0.034240723, -0.0043182373, 0.0018882751, 0.0058288574, -0.018737793, 0.08770752, -0.02218628, 0.0121154785, 0.03213501, 0.05239868, 0.00013399124, 0.008728027, -0.019851685, -0.015609741, -0.0076141357, -0.028030396, -0.005004883, 0.00014305115, -0.0043640137, -0.025863647, -0.018188477, -0.0206604, 0.035308838, -0.013137817, -0.009605408, -0.011978149, -0.008735657, 0.002779007, -0.029815674, 0.020492554, 0.017745972, 0.031982422, -0.031463623, 0.03967285, -0.018005371, -0.0009126663, -0.030731201, -0.020477295, 0.010818481, -0.0463562, 0.028686523, -0.0017499924, 0.07006836, -0.0024433136, 0.010925293, -0.010978699, -0.04095459, 0.010543823, 0.01436615, -0.027572632, 0.02796936, -0.015808105, -0.021194458, 0.011764526, -0.03213501, -0.07336426, -0.0680542, 0.0034694672, 0.029464722, 0.037506104, -0.040893555, 0.03479004, 0.0060653687, 0.025344849, 0.04840088, 0.041168213, -0.025253296, -0.0018320084, 0.020431519, 0.024612427, 0.032714844, -0.026428223, -0.023208618, 0.03781128, 0.026489258, -0.03390503, -0.0030975342, -0.027633667, 0.0345459, 0.010421753, -0.022705078, 0.018936157, -0.009307861, -0.052490234, 0.0025997162, 0.026550293, -0.013122559, -0.011016846, 0.031311035, 0.00036263466, -0.0033473969, 0.013587952, 0.015174866, -0.014450073, -0.03463745, -0.016677856, -0.01309967, 0.057525635, -0.02168274, 0.04333496, -0.048431396, -0.058685303, 0.03982544, -0.06262207, -0.07733154, -0.06616211, 0.019607544, -0.07775879, -0.057281494, 0.014274597, 0.018432617, 0.022232056, -0.010307312, 0.039978027, 0.036743164, 0.028121948, -0.015075684, -0.008430481, 0.07659912, -0.019226074, -0.077819824, 0.020507812, -0.034210205, 0.014297485, 0.046722412, -0.028060913, 0.0072021484, -0.0025310516, -0.021072388, -0.01008606, -0.039611816, 0.0053749084, -0.04727173, -0.01600647, 0.03579712, -0.043060303, 0.035888672, -0.030700684, 0.03994751, -0.028640747, -0.0010194778, 0.047302246, 0.07421875, -0.026290894, 0.0025119781, -0.0015773773, -0.009712219, -0.022094727, 0.008621216, -0.006767273, -0.0491333, 0.051696777, 0.031066895, 0.0035572052, 0.03479004, -0.029678345, 0.0112838745, -0.031555176, 0.021850586, 0.0006365776, -0.0062675476, -0.0625, -0.03552246, 0.052520752, 0.021118164, -0.02015686, 0.035247803, -0.002281189, 0.035186768, -0.0044441223, -0.023086548, 0.0049591064, 0.024658203, -0.010253906, -0.053985596, -0.015304565, 0.01033783, 0.014167786, -0.005329132, -0.009483337, -0.026779175, 0.003156662, 0.014457703, 0.000685215, -0.02104187, 0.029785156, 0.02748108, -0.027542114, -0.058410645, -0.049316406, 0.0047187805, -0.04852295, -0.005290985, 0.020965576, -0.017684937, 0.0039100647, -0.011383057, -0.016693115, 0.015350342, 0.028060913, 0.042938232, 0.009719849, 0.012062073, -0.03274536, -0.023925781, -0.018218994, -0.006351471, 0.0546875, -0.006576538, 0.001953125, -0.0064582825, -0.008300781, -0.010856628, -0.018157959, -0.02130127, 0.0038585663, 0.012207031, 0.022445679, -0.021408081, 0.019744873, 0.016067505, -0.048736572, -0.00027751923, -0.00009328127, -0.025405884, 0.085998535, 0.034118652, 0.017745972, -0.02973938, 0.042144775, 0.03414917, -0.023117065, -0.049560547, -0.009223938, 0.062194824, 0.011413574, -0.053100586, -0.041900635, 0.06311035, 0.025756836, -0.0062065125, 0.0004582405, -0.017028809, -0.00969696, -0.035949707, -0.039367676, 0.06390381, 0.030899048, 0.021850586, -0.015991211, 0.02746582, 0.019165039, 0.0012741089, -0.030044556, -0.0124053955, -0.022094727, 0.038635254, -0.02243042, -0.03857422, -0.03286743, -0.036712646, -0.018707275, 0.029800415, -0.003791809, 0.028030396, 0.023788452, 0.013145447, 0.0032424927, -0.017349243, 0.013145447, -0.027069092, -0.00957489, -0.0066108704, -0.029876709, -0.016098022, 0.04058838, -0.027313232, -0.019088745, 0.036254883, -0.028060913, 0.0028190613, -0.008262634, 0.038360596, -0.010536194, 0.0074653625, 0.031341553, 0.014587402, 0.0056037903, -0.003967285, 0.0046806335, -0.029800415, -0.030059814, 0.0049705505, 0.017562866, -0.0020160675, 0.004600525, -0.014450073, 0.008094788, -0.00066137314, -0.014953613, -0.01007843, -0.00026130676, -0.011123657, -0.03677368, -0.0013885498, 0.0060310364, 0.06161499, -0.021026611, -0.01826477, 0.010627747, -0.0069007874, -0.013702393, 0.028686523, 0.014289856, 0.011627197, 0.02368164, 0.027359009, -0.02255249, -0.034240723, 0.006793976, -0.0026893616, -0.00029468536, -0.010147095, 0.011260986, -0.015960693, -0.010574341, -0.0065460205, -0.09387207, 0.042938232, -0.03579712, 0.028701782, 0.0073051453, -0.015655518, 0.03289795, 0.015716553, -0.05319214, -0.074157715, -0.14318848, -0.06427002, -0.07287598, 0.09259033, -0.048095703, 0.02381897, 0.049804688, -0.050811768, 0.0012779236, 0.046569824, -0.030227661, -0.0064811707, -0.014343262, -0.048065186, 0.020812988, 0.012016296, -0.0033111572, -0.012702942, -0.009399414, -0.047210693, -0.02986145, -0.0016469955, -0.026855469, -0.041870117, -0.061706543, -0.0022220612, 0.005771637, 0.008140564, -0.011787415, 0.03363037, 0.012107849, -0.03250122, 0.035064697, -0.001821518, 0.033691406, 0.0058021545, -0.018371582, -0.005317688, 0.021102905, -0.008277893, 0.021362305, -0.017974854, -0.02571106, -0.016555786, -0.025527954, 0.018081665, 0.005443573, -0.0090408325, -0.00374794, 0.0027942657, 0.0045700073, 0.04171753, 0.04006958, -0.0335083, -0.054138184, -0.0016536713, 0.006706238, 0.029205322, 0.03845215, -0.0118255615, 0.0029792786, 0.0011825562, 0.029830933, -0.00868988, -0.02331543, 0.014274597, 0.0007958412, 0.02166748, -0.016082764, 0.019927979, 0.05343628, 0.0008621216, 0.015388489, 0.025253296, 0.0066604614, 0.0062065125, 0.011619568, -0.025924683, -0.008026123, -0.018173218, 0.010665894, 0.005344391, -0.017745972, -0.0121154785, 0.0030078888, 0.0008368492, -0.10284424, -0.05895996, -0.06323242, -0.0035858154, 0.016204834, -0.036895752, -0.0065727234, 0.04598999, -0.004924774, 0.008766174, 0.0064849854, -0.03894043, 0.0033016205, -0.001115799, 0.0014925003, -0.0065193176, -0.0028095245, -0.0029258728, -0.001964569, 0.036254883, 0.0055007935, 0.010185242, 0.012268066, -0.020965576, -0.005836487, 0.027069092, -0.0016994476, -0.044769287, 0.020553589, -0.03213501, 0.04421997, 0.016082764, 0.036132812, 0.0340271, -0.0004119873, 0.0043525696, -0.029220581, 0.008102417, 0.048706055, 0.018066406, 0.025390625, 0.04147339, -0.010314941, 0.009773254, 0.028656006, -0.02319336, -0.0074806213, 0.010040283, 0.023757935, -0.017181396, -0.009376526, -0.005771637, 0.025817871, 0.020309448, 0.017822266, -0.026855469, -0.016830444, -0.0440979, -0.028869629, 0.031402588, 0.0184021, 0.0014867783, -0.0116119385, -0.0038471222, 0.0579834, -0.01424408, 0.076416016, -0.0045204163, 0.026931763, -0.11541748, -0.0501709, -0.041229248, -0.01889038, -0.050567627, 0.031555176, 0.008361816, -0.03515625, 0.11779785, 0.04611206, 0.045135498, 0.04196167, -0.0140686035, 0.011138916, 0.05496216, -0.017044067, -0.00856781, -0.0035877228, -0.01108551, -0.050079346, 0.002292633, 0.009483337, 0.0035629272, -0.006099701, 0.026977539, -0.019851685, -0.021759033, -0.030670166, -0.001373291, -0.031463623, -0.020187378, 0.046569824, -0.049987793, -0.0013723373, 0.019378662, 0.038146973, -0.015808105, 0.011169434, -0.014503479, -0.022842407, 0.01524353, -0.023422241, 0.006706238, -0.007209778, 0.00081920624, -0.013000488, -0.0138168335, 0.03704834, -0.0135650635, -0.02319336, -0.011817932, -0.0001860857, 0.015930176, 0.0073432922, 0.018844604, 0.013847351, -0.014289856, -0.07208252, 0.057037354, 0.04260254, -0.019638062, -0.055664062, -0.0064582825, -0.022949219, -0.022506714, 0.013679504, 0.0440979, -0.03125, 0.0010318756, 0.011459351, -0.032440186, 0.040863037, -0.005935669, 0.026306152, -0.030517578, 0.051239014, 0.0011262894, -0.018554688, 0.027252197, 0.035858154, 0.0008611679, -0.07446289, 0.004386902, 0.066223145, 0.058380127, 0.03665161, 0.10656738, 0.09063721, 0.008895874, 0.016311646, 0.024597168, -0.039367676, -0.01828003, 0.006034851, 0.07940674, 0.03366089, -0.02204895, -0.07348633, -0.03488159, 0.08026123, 0.01424408, -0.028182983, -0.0012149811, 0.07763672, -0.013893127, 0.0029449463, 0.013694763, -0.012672424, -0.011405945, -0.007297516, -0.0015268326, -0.013877869, -0.03845215, 0.054260254, 0.0009813309, -0.02406311, -0.011802673, -0.03277588, -0.011947632, -0.023239136, -0.06713867, 0.014884949, -0.07556152, 0.048980713, 0.013847351, 0.021270752, -0.028137207, 0.037902832, -0.03970337, 0.016220093, -0.0041542053, -0.0014753342, -0.002298355, 0.01689148, -0.02571106, -0.041778564, -0.0079956055, 0.019348145, -0.12017822, -0.036987305, 0.01940918, -0.016815186, -0.009506226, -0.016494751, -0.0023002625, 0.016815186, 0.031829834, 0.0021820068, 0.0009570122, 0.022857666, 0.0006599426, 0.003709793, 0.0031833649 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2104.14633v1
Modelling Urban Dynamics with Multi-Modal Graph Convolutional Networks
Krittika D'Silva, Jordan Cambe, Anastasios Noulas, Cecilia Mascolo, Adam Waksman
physics.soc-ph, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI
Modelling the dynamics of urban venues is a challenging task as it is multifaceted in nature. Demand is a function of many complex and nonlinear features such as neighborhood composition, real-time events, and seasonality. Recent advances in Graph Convolutional Networks (GCNs) have had promising results as they build a graphical representation of a system and harness the potential of deep learning architectures. However, there has been limited work using GCNs in a temporal setting to model dynamic dependencies of the network. Further, within the context of urban environments, there has been no prior work using dynamic GCNs to support venue demand analysis and prediction. In this paper, we propose a novel deep learning framework which aims to better model the popularity and growth of urban venues. Using a longitudinal dataset from location technology platform Foursquare, we model individual venues and venue types across London and Paris. First, representing cities as connected networks of venues, we quantify their structure and note a strong community structure in these retail networks, an observation that highlights the interplay of cooperative and competitive forces that emerge in local ecosystems of retail businesses. Next, we present our deep learning architecture which integrates both spatial and topological features into a temporal model which predicts the demand of a venue at the subsequent time-step. Our experiments demonstrate that our model can learn spatio-temporal trends of venue demand and consistently outperform baseline models. Relative to state-of-the-art deep learning models, our model reduces the RSME by ~ 28% in London and ~ 13% in Paris. Our approach highlights the power of complex network measures and GCNs in building prediction models for urban environments. The model could have numerous applications within the retail sector to better model venue demand and growth.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2104.14633v1
"2021-04-29T20:00:47"
"2021-04-29T20:00:47"
{ "title": [ -0.0034255981, 0.00818634, -0.042663574, -0.0513916, 0.008216858, -0.015426636, -0.0496521, -0.0076065063, 0.0032234192, 0.029190063, -0.03652954, 0.014457703, -0.010917664, -0.015167236, -0.03741455, 0.001209259, 0.01777649, 0.009689331, -0.024627686, -0.02760315, -0.012145996, -0.018234253, 0.015029907, 0.09136963, 0.033233643, -0.06311035, -0.06488037, 0.02798462, -0.044891357, -0.051208496, -0.004699707, 0.03540039, 0.050109863, 0.025924683, -0.026184082, 0.023712158, -0.059326172, 0.017669678, 0.0028152466, 0.0149002075, 0.017196655, -0.009521484, -0.008773804, -0.03060913, -0.033111572, 0.030044556, -0.058746338, -0.011657715, -0.014862061, 0.044433594, 0.028076172, 0.026550293, 0.011383057, 0.016159058, 0.0028152466, -0.047454834, -0.0041542053, -0.04135132, 0.040283203, 0.05404663, 0.014694214, -0.045288086, 0.019317627, -0.030166626, -0.047424316, -0.0105896, -0.033203125, 0.015541077, 0.04626465, -0.04119873, -0.023880005, 0.020935059, -0.011276245, -0.0009794235, -0.03866577, -0.0011377335, 0.032562256, 0.010643005, 0.034362793, -0.018798828, 0.010932922, -0.009002686, -0.019760132, -0.0023918152, 0.011268616, -0.009109497, -0.010375977, -0.03677368, -0.05532837, -0.05090332, -0.014274597, -0.015823364, -0.034057617, 0.011413574, -0.014533997, -0.0146102905, -0.018341064, 0.014877319, -0.0040626526, -0.031951904, -0.006603241, 0.009597778, -0.025543213, -0.015701294, 0.02128601, 0.030059814, -0.008163452, -0.026733398, 0.0024852753, 0.018798828, -0.021484375, 0.024536133, 0.024856567, 0.023513794, -0.0053482056, -0.0015659332, 0.0055351257, 0.0005016327, -0.0020561218, 0.0052108765, -0.003452301, -0.013694763, -0.019607544, 0.018127441, 0.023849487, -0.0035743713, -0.01878357, 0.009628296, 0.0009937286, 0.010169983, 0.014251709, 0.053344727, -0.09881592, -0.09277344, -0.07977295, 0.055725098, -0.012435913, -0.012702942, -0.008476257, 0.02507019, 0.030838013, -0.048919678, -0.038146973, 0.03475952, -0.00012922287, 0.02722168, 0.050872803, -0.017028809, -0.0637207, -0.035736084, 0.0033226013, -0.016799927, 0.035308838, 0.00057315826, 0.004459381, -0.022399902, -0.030136108, -0.05987549, 0.0036754608, -0.03189087, 0.03375244, 0.0065841675, 0.0075302124, 0.039276123, 0.060272217, -0.026794434, -0.043823242, 0.01727295, 0.0035324097, 0.028244019, -0.023422241, 0.012565613, -0.008491516, 0.0027256012, 0.0026435852, 0.019134521, 0.037017822, -0.025482178, 0.0110321045, 0.05166626, 0.021270752, -0.01789856, -0.0058021545, 0.04019165, -0.0670166, -0.016586304, 0.0003170967, -0.003408432, 0.06173706, -0.004348755, -0.025375366, 0.01876831, -0.043304443, -0.018951416, -0.044952393, -0.031051636, 0.036468506, 0.02180481, -0.0051651, 0.019592285, 0.00018119812, -0.008407593, -0.016708374, 0.0116119385, -0.010940552, -0.038024902, -0.00010460615, 0.0034160614, -0.02670288, 0.052337646, 0.059661865, 0.037017822, -0.05090332, -0.021087646, 0.0014705658, -0.040222168, 0.033355713, -0.02494812, -0.022598267, -0.016418457, -0.04675293, -0.00088596344, -0.024627686, 0.06854248, 0.0070114136, -0.016281128, 0.021942139, -0.033111572, 0.024887085, 0.005191803, 0.06604004, -0.035949707, 0.0052223206, 0.0072250366, 0.007144928, -0.013694763, 0.015098572, -0.0066337585, 0.026153564, 0.014030457, -0.009681702, -0.012992859, -0.0046463013, 0.04663086, 0.022872925, 0.0061302185, 0.014312744, 0.015655518, 0.010978699, 0.0019741058, 0.07989502, 0.016143799, 0.046081543, 0.012039185, 0.012458801, 0.047576904, 0.0064468384, 0.016677856, -0.045776367, 0.007873535, 0.022109985, 0.037963867, -0.017425537, 0.023513794, -0.064331055, -0.020095825, -0.047576904, -0.009689331, 0.027511597, -0.015144348, 0.027679443, -0.024108887, 0.013542175, -0.015281677, -0.0102005005, 0.00033664703, -0.030197144, 0.014923096, 0.036834717, -0.058013916, 0.002822876, -0.0014371872, 0.03677368, -0.004272461, 0.06561279, -0.00007772446, 0.0022449493, -0.016036987, -0.010299683, -0.031433105, 0.03427124, 0.006072998, -0.0052375793, -0.0069847107, 0.015472412, -0.029937744, 0.072509766, 0.09899902, -0.037017822, 0.041778564, -0.03942871, 0.012329102, -0.0020561218, -0.014976501, -0.006881714, 0.050476074, 0.03302002, 0.0010719299, -0.041870117, -0.013465881, -0.021759033, 0.008155823, 0.0055656433, -0.0690918, -0.009643555, -0.031311035, -0.0040512085, -0.048706055, -0.034332275, 0.015541077, 0.042999268, 0.0065612793, -0.022109985, 0.00881958, 0.01928711, -0.019195557, 0.00060272217, -0.023880005, -0.028762817, 0.011749268, 0.029769897, 0.00907135, -0.047607422, 0.027770996, -0.0032367706, 0.039611816, -0.018493652, -0.0054397583, -0.019332886, 0.03842163, 0.034851074, -0.012168884, 0.027008057, -0.03265381, 0.012176514, -0.047027588, 0.017807007, 0.017669678, -0.02230835, 0.01713562, 0.012107849, -0.012611389, -0.024291992, -0.003786087, 0.05645752, -0.008560181, -0.012825012, 0.005344391, 0.018249512, -0.031921387, 0.001033783, 0.008758545, -0.024291992, -0.033477783, -0.00034236908, -0.027648926, 0.0013237, -0.017074585, 0.0006933212, 0.053955078, -0.03881836, -0.030593872, -0.015899658, -0.01802063, 0.018249512, 0.0061073303, -0.024963379, -0.044189453, -0.017547607, -0.027008057, -0.018447876, -0.0009098053, -0.017593384, 0.00623703, 0.10467529, -0.0014247894, 0.003145218, 0.01676941, 0.0496521, 0.0040359497, -0.027008057, -0.04788208, -0.05114746, 0.01574707, 0.03994751, 0.009208679, -0.002588272, 0.013916016, -0.14697266, -0.016998291, 0.035858154, 0.02822876, -0.02394104, 0.05355835, -0.07757568, 0.04537964, -0.02835083, -0.026611328, 0.04058838, 0.06719971, -0.016220093, 0.0010681152, -0.012290955, -0.023422241, -0.000028073788, -0.012771606, -0.029632568, 0.022506714, 0.0034885406, -0.087402344, -0.0069122314, -0.028900146, -0.033966064, -0.018417358, 0.026550293, 0.022506714, 0.03164673, -0.02381897, -0.0034561157, 0.018234253, 0.012069702, -0.026031494, 0.00004184246, -0.013458252, -0.034332275, 0.007144928, -0.00969696, 0.03604126, 0.012413025, -0.0077552795, -0.025756836, -0.015975952, 0.012702942, 0.032958984, 0.019058228, -0.042053223, 0.00881958, 0.013298035, -0.034606934, 0.01676941, -0.027557373, -0.0005364418, -0.04660034, 0.018600464, -0.012397766, 0.017486572, -0.00623703, 0.0074882507, -0.023803711, -0.023849487, 0.042022705, -0.016464233, -0.0949707, 0.013786316, 0.037231445, -0.0010910034, 0.00970459, -0.01864624, -0.04547119, 0.046966553, -0.026977539, -0.009353638, -0.0067367554, -0.029815674, 0.002746582, -0.015472412, -0.0023555756, -0.017105103, 0.01348114, 0.0032806396, 0.041870117, -0.018341064, -0.000998497, -0.021072388, 0.04019165, -0.005554199, -0.07836914, 0.00299263, 0.031585693, -0.014831543, -0.02029419, -0.035888672, 0.03475952, -0.008720398, -0.0138549805, 0.01953125, -0.013938904, -0.017211914, -0.00674057, -0.08190918, -0.015556335, 0.06506348, 0.02154541, 0.025726318, 0.03213501, 0.016113281, -0.0028419495, -0.020843506, -0.0039711, -0.0073432922, 0.062683105, -0.024932861, -0.027740479, 0.04925537, -0.04977417, 0.025726318, 0.010055542, 0.024536133, -0.025405884, 0.000060796738, 0.022705078, 0.01739502, 0.0039024353, 0.05630493, 0.0028972626, -0.016159058, -0.037231445, 0.0038490295, 0.0103302, 0.022583008, 0.00002092123, -0.017120361, 0.04916382, 0.01625061, -0.00969696, 0.026367188, -0.012313843, -0.007987976, 0.022262573, -0.021377563, 0.0011978149, 0.0129470825, 0.01525116, 0.005592346, -0.006275177, 0.026672363, 0.0056648254, 0.03555298, -0.049621582, -0.023788452, 0.011619568, 0.036865234, -0.026153564, -0.019699097, -0.054656982, -0.029327393, 0.010421753, 0.0034313202, -0.026733398, 0.012084961, 0.026123047, -0.021514893, -0.008644104, -0.00223732, 0.043151855, 0.004261017, -0.02128601, -0.07598877, 0.046844482, -0.01525116, -0.043914795, -0.045440674, -0.025924683, -0.0127334595, 0.03491211, 0.012214661, 0.005191803, 0.031143188, 0.011924744, 0.051727295, 0.064941406, -0.010955811, -0.052459717, 0.05718994, -0.013572693, -0.010620117, 0.019454956, 0.010276794, -0.0034637451, -0.04397583, -0.014053345, -0.0039253235, -0.0059890747, -0.0030879974, -0.007534027, -0.016098022, 0.017364502, -0.0009841919, 0.06463623, -0.001865387, 0.014465332, 0.014076233, 0.023040771, -0.04119873, -0.037322998, -0.0129852295, 0.025817871, -0.015777588, 0.013046265, 0.057006836, 0.01689148, -0.0066337585, 0.032958984, 0.004447937, 0.052612305, -0.020446777, 0.008392334, 0.023773193, -0.023239136, -0.03866577, -0.00056934357, 0.009414673, 0.045043945, -0.017196655, 0.048583984, -0.01979065, -0.013000488, 0.026016235, 0.00046396255, 0.015220642, 0.0071105957, 0.018112183, -0.05307007, -0.07989502, -0.02293396, 0.08258057, -0.03173828, -0.018478394, -0.010604858, 0.03439331, 0.022201538, 0.045959473, 0.030563354, -0.02859497, 0.017166138, -0.011665344, -0.012649536, -0.005592346, -0.041412354, 0.033477783, -0.021865845, 0.0104599, -0.011444092, -0.022735596, -0.05831909, 0.0035953522, 0.010757446, -0.0140686035, 0.029663086, -0.053771973, 0.054534912, 0.09844971, -0.012893677, 0.04776001, 0.02848816, 0.00069856644, 0.039794922, 0.024780273, 0.02798462, 0.023712158, 0.014549255, -0.04663086, 0.028152466, 0.019302368, 0.021774292, 0.005821228, 0.008071899, 0.012832642, -0.0009975433, -0.032348633, 0.025253296, -0.018035889, -0.02859497, 0.027664185, -0.041748047, 0.021118164, 0.007610321, -0.0096588135, 0.01612854, -0.0008664131, -0.027023315, 0.00017988682, -0.0011062622, -0.021743774, -0.0062294006, -0.008346558, -0.029006958, -0.06451416, 0.042541504, -0.023513794, -0.0066337585, -0.014480591, 0.0059127808, -0.045562744, 0.023834229, 0.008575439, -0.05770874, 0.010772705, 0.004081726, 0.022781372, 0.03829956, 0.017929077, -0.054779053, 0.0015325546, -0.01448822, -0.054351807, -0.076660156, -0.012046814, 0.002084732, 0.02204895, 0.0033893585, 0.0048599243, 0.0062789917, -0.011764526, 0.038726807, -0.015914917, -0.028213501, 0.02949524, 0.021255493, 0.03665161, -0.0060424805, -0.008262634, -0.017425537, 0.010154724, 0.026138306, -0.023590088, 0.02557373, -0.0050621033, 0.02508545, 0.006462097, -0.048828125, 0.012168884, 0.014770508, 0.026916504, -0.047698975, -0.010345459, 0.020874023, -0.049560547, -0.008384705, -0.024887085, 0.064941406, -0.040374756, 0.014778137, -0.012786865, 0.012489319, -0.06652832, 0.027816772, -0.009460449, 0.021560669, -0.05618286, -0.06121826, -0.026260376, 0.025665283, 0.036010742, 0.02720642, 0.06976318, -0.04547119, 0.009735107, -0.032226562, -0.002954483, -0.035308838, 0.036468506, 0.0018568039, 0.005001068, -0.028457642, -0.015464783, -0.029022217, 0.005672455, 0.0284729, 0.013122559, -0.033599854, 0.044281006, -0.030441284, 0.0053596497, -0.0058784485, -0.015090942, 0.05935669, -0.034301758, 0.0178833, 0.03781128, -0.016738892, 0.024856567, 0.021957397, 0.064331055, 0.055358887, 0.013931274, 0.023757935, 0.006664276, -0.0059776306, -0.043914795, 0.020202637, -0.039916992, -0.055541992, -0.08959961, -0.045043945, -0.08190918, -0.00093746185, -0.0090789795, -0.013572693, 0.058258057, -0.00605011, 0.021850586, -0.0014371872, 0.056640625, 0.023727417, 0.03768921, 0.0067634583, 0.0039596558, -0.007385254, 0.0025367737, 0.031921387, 0.038146973, 0.034088135, -0.017791748, -0.025299072, -0.020080566, 0.011909485, 0.043060303, -0.019714355, -0.020553589, 0.008758545, -0.053741455, 0.023849487, -0.022903442, 0.006290436, 0.061187744, 0.02204895, 0.050354004, -0.054595947, 0.00415802, 0.02444458, -0.033203125, 0.021026611, 0.059295654, -0.05670166, 0.008773804, -0.026382446, -0.02583313, -0.0058059692, -0.013046265, 0.05618286, -0.083984375, -0.073791504, 0.033843994, 0.0552063, -0.01448822, 0.007865906, -0.058898926, -0.016815186, -0.00048613548, 0.021697998, -0.01184082, -0.01676941, 0.02658081, 0.04031372, -0.0035133362, 0.022888184, 0.0135269165, 0.037017822, 0.013496399, 0.036346436, -0.06173706, 0.013114929, 0.014541626, -0.02986145, 0.008705139, 0.020889282, -0.036590576, 0.0059013367, 0.04284668, 0.029876709, 0.039764404, 0.06286621, 0.019744873, -0.011123657, -0.005001068, -0.05886841, 0.025100708, 0.022842407, -0.025878906, 0.002111435, -0.03656006, -0.036621094, 0.023651123, -0.027832031, 0.06274414, -0.04864502, 0.008331299, -0.027267456, 0.032806396, 0.015167236, -0.059143066, -0.017501831, -0.043426514, -0.035186768, 0.0042037964, -0.03186035, -0.0057373047, -0.016693115, 0.003982544, 0.042114258, 0.04171753, 0.0068855286, -0.018920898, -0.020065308, -0.06137085, 0.01134491, -0.04147339, 0.04095459, 0.0012607574, -0.017028809, -0.02947998, 0.007827759, 0.002708435, -0.0002297163, -0.019332886, 0.022216797, -0.052246094, 0.00022673607, -0.0104599, 0.010848999, -0.012489319, -0.02255249, -0.031982422, 0.017868042, -0.02507019, 0.004497528, 0.025222778, -0.0513916, -0.0340271, 0.009124756, -0.037963867, 0.033325195, 0.017990112, -0.004802704, 0.017562866, 0.037841797, -0.052093506, -0.0084991455, -0.018692017, 0.012825012, 0.020645142, -0.035858154, -0.004470825, 0.03274536, 0.026306152, -0.055267334, -0.029647827, 0.017852783, 0.052093506, -0.017456055, 0.054351807, 0.0033073425, 0.00020980835, 0.024429321, 0.062561035, 0.021911621, -0.044036865, -0.033569336, -0.017196655, 0.035827637, 0.051605225, -0.0034694672, 0.0026226044, 0.03741455, -0.014717102, 0.020690918, 0.007381439, -0.0053215027, 0.028717041, -0.012496948, 0.018234253, -0.025543213, -0.014343262, 0.024459839, 0.014137268, -0.011169434, 0.025009155, -0.02720642, -0.0104599, -0.007385254, 0.014564514, -0.024276733, -0.05645752, 0.042419434, 0.03527832, -0.0010576248, 0.01612854, -0.021392822, -0.017791748, 0.0020580292, -0.00026011467, -0.0068588257, 0.0059013367, 0.03152466, -0.02671814, 0.0050468445, -0.05239868, -0.03152466, 0.020858765, -0.015007019, 0.035369873, -0.07977295, 0.026046753, -0.052368164, -0.037902832, -0.019927979, 0.02331543, -0.027252197, -0.04296875, -0.030136108, -0.05331421, 0.049072266, -0.014823914 ], "summary": [ 0.022064209, -0.015419006, -0.0051574707, -0.038726807, -0.014907837, -0.020080566, -0.03488159, 0.0005578995, 0.032958984, 0.030288696, -0.04559326, -0.009796143, -0.015144348, -0.003660202, -0.03086853, -0.031158447, 0.04168701, -0.0236969, 0.0026779175, -0.024490356, 0.0041923523, -0.016540527, 0.013809204, 0.09338379, 0.02520752, -0.043792725, 0.036865234, 0.025787354, 0.010688782, 0.016738892, 0.026473999, -0.04510498, 0.011398315, 0.0054092407, 0.01675415, -0.050354004, -0.01625061, 0.0034885406, 0.0029506683, -0.0058021545, 0.009841919, -0.003288269, 0.051635742, -0.068847656, -0.0104599, 0.054870605, -0.018981934, -0.0045280457, 0.011314392, 0.0064048767, 0.0023555756, 0.02658081, 0.006816864, -0.031555176, -0.018539429, -0.024139404, 0.0044021606, -0.042755127, 0.031555176, 0.023666382, 0.013290405, -0.02708435, 0.031173706, -0.029571533, -0.084472656, -0.026794434, 0.020507812, -0.02168274, 0.05291748, -0.057281494, 0.015220642, 0.062805176, -0.011352539, -0.01309967, -0.03665161, -0.006603241, 0.031829834, -0.024276733, 0.01838684, -0.0051078796, 0.011497498, 0.022369385, -0.038330078, -0.016143799, -0.004711151, -0.022003174, -0.0077667236, -0.019744873, -0.022216797, -0.029464722, -0.021514893, -0.021072388, -0.06036377, 0.026367188, 0.02520752, -0.042297363, -0.004924774, -0.009895325, -0.02684021, -0.01486969, -0.002336502, 0.0035648346, -0.024154663, -0.008018494, 0.0008583069, 0.026977539, -0.020187378, -0.012908936, 0.009590149, 0.02420044, -0.0010948181, -0.023910522, 0.013267517, -0.011962891, -0.0126571655, 0.0051002502, -0.0067710876, 0.0066833496, -0.0010557175, -0.020050049, -0.044891357, -0.0035648346, -0.019317627, 0.053710938, 0.0048332214, 0.03363037, 0.03543091, -0.012054443, -0.0619812, 0.02268982, 0.002632141, 0.040100098, -0.04925537, -0.022583008, -0.060913086, 0.01033783, 0.008430481, -0.021347046, 0.015716553, -0.029129028, 0.0982666, -0.013656616, -0.072631836, 0.07348633, 0.04534912, 0.020874023, 0.025344849, 0.0033226013, -0.0135269165, -0.011360168, 0.03781128, -0.014732361, 0.053222656, -0.011451721, -0.026992798, -0.050994873, 0.020065308, -0.06866455, 0.004322052, -0.06378174, 0.016174316, -0.012321472, 0.008300781, 0.010559082, -0.0056533813, -0.0022010803, -0.021575928, -0.0002963543, 0.021514893, 0.022491455, -0.00005429983, -0.009513855, -0.012481689, 0.010421753, 0.008407593, 0.018814087, 0.03137207, 0.017608643, -0.00088977814, 0.029251099, 0.009231567, -0.033294678, 0.051239014, -0.014503479, -0.014579773, 0.026489258, -0.00258255, 0.05291748, 0.0023784637, -0.0060806274, -0.032287598, -0.0010910034, -0.04333496, -0.030548096, -0.013168335, 0.028701782, 0.026031494, 0.032043457, 0.011894226, -0.011657715, 0.019592285, -0.017501831, 0.02671814, -0.001750946, 0.0054626465, -0.008613586, -0.0041542053, -0.0051002502, -0.051513672, -0.0009531975, 0.049316406, 0.0044784546, -0.04876709, 0.0042037964, 0.0013093948, -0.01979065, 0.027740479, -0.013214111, -0.03189087, 0.01638794, -0.03881836, 0.023239136, -0.04925537, 0.06451416, 0.015716553, -0.033050537, 0.0048294067, -0.0074653625, 0.052612305, -0.005443573, 0.04888916, -0.015182495, 0.017227173, 0.009803772, -0.019973755, 0.016525269, 0.04626465, -0.008514404, -0.005569458, 0.023117065, -0.0007200241, 0.017547607, -0.016357422, 0.026657104, -0.0020828247, 0.009063721, 0.029205322, -0.00274086, -0.020217896, 0.030166626, 0.020324707, 0.04147339, 0.02268982, 0.030044556, -0.014923096, 0.041992188, 0.025009155, 0.019073486, 0.0023403168, 0.016098022, 0.0074882507, 0.051513672, -0.004524231, 0.017837524, -0.029144287, -0.040893555, -0.05670166, -0.03414917, 0.02053833, -0.01158905, 0.020645142, -0.081604004, -0.0028057098, -0.044067383, -0.051757812, 0.0056915283, -0.054351807, 0.050811768, 0.025299072, -0.03152466, -0.001613617, 0.008972168, -0.035491943, -0.009559631, 0.034301758, -0.014030457, -0.016021729, 0.03112793, 0.04626465, 0.062316895, 0.051757812, 0.016830444, -0.0020389557, 0.0082092285, 0.011993408, -0.019012451, 0.0138549805, 0.06384277, -0.028564453, 0.0032444, -0.013473511, 0.013015747, -0.02444458, -0.01902771, -0.0037765503, 0.034729004, 0.010665894, -0.017150879, -0.014518738, -0.010040283, -0.010482788, 0.012840271, 0.011070251, 0.025985718, -0.020080566, -0.004699707, -0.030578613, 0.02859497, 0.010322571, 0.043670654, 0.041778564, 0.025115967, 0.019973755, 0.0017356873, 0.012527466, -0.036895752, -0.013442993, -0.016967773, 0.027160645, 0.026382446, -0.009605408, 0.010879517, -0.02859497, 0.0038490295, -0.0025463104, -0.0025482178, 0.01121521, -0.019195557, 0.0022125244, 0.031555176, 0.048187256, -0.007858276, 0.01991272, -0.0034656525, -0.028961182, -0.0011339188, -0.010559082, 0.0038089752, 0.004447937, 0.012184143, 0.014274597, 0.0018587112, -0.014427185, 0.00097608566, 0.030670166, 0.04876709, -0.0016908646, 0.017044067, 0.05267334, -0.02545166, 0.0012598038, -0.007965088, -0.037322998, -0.06329346, 0.022201538, 0.018844604, -0.020721436, -0.015434265, -0.03314209, -0.005584717, 0.010749817, -0.04876709, 0.016235352, -0.018737793, -0.02229309, 0.01689148, 0.08087158, 0.0023460388, 0.0033245087, 0.064453125, -0.00484848, 0.02658081, -0.03161621, 0.022354126, 0.048187256, 0.019241333, 0.00207901, 0.017303467, 0.020477295, -0.022399902, -0.014328003, 0.013061523, -0.05609131, 0.013679504, 0.036621094, 0.01927185, 0.0016708374, -0.027450562, -0.10168457, -0.033050537, 0.055358887, 0.005592346, -0.010467529, 0.022872925, -0.045074463, 0.07196045, 0.017745972, -0.0027542114, 0.0040626526, 0.026550293, 0.043060303, -0.0579834, 0.019821167, -0.00969696, 0.030838013, -0.04159546, 0.061340332, 0.011833191, 0.005088806, -0.066223145, -0.00014078617, 0.056152344, -0.0013933182, -0.015609741, 0.041107178, 0.008796692, 0.01739502, -0.035125732, -0.009132385, 0.0129776, 0.020309448, -0.029815674, -0.0025558472, 0.051574707, -0.026824951, 0.055358887, 0.027618408, -0.027648926, 0.08239746, -0.06317139, -0.040405273, -0.0030841827, 0.05947876, 0.011001587, 0.020965576, -0.020309448, 0.029632568, 0.021057129, -0.024368286, -0.0038700104, -0.029388428, 0.012275696, 0.02381897, 0.02659607, -0.004940033, -0.00409317, -0.0020141602, 0.05432129, 0.062042236, -0.042419434, 0.04425049, -0.0154418945, -0.10571289, 0.07043457, 0.037139893, -0.0013551712, 0.011459351, 0.0061035156, -0.023361206, 0.02418518, 0.02909851, -0.042114258, -0.022277832, -0.045166016, -0.009986877, -0.10211182, 0.031402588, 0.01524353, 0.074279785, -0.04611206, 0.020904541, -0.006374359, 0.049560547, -0.024765015, 0.022247314, 0.010597229, -0.04522705, -0.01914978, 0.026809692, 0.0234375, -0.012664795, -0.014335632, 0.02708435, 0.022216797, 0.0011978149, 0.02619934, -0.009643555, 0.028930664, -0.03164673, -0.09222412, 0.017944336, -0.027114868, 0.034362793, 0.053833008, 0.005630493, 0.006072998, 0.02748108, 0.0065612793, -0.013916016, -0.004009247, 0.06298828, -0.03894043, 0.002029419, 0.0090408325, -0.02281189, 0.059295654, -0.017196655, 0.032287598, -0.0037727356, -0.01612854, 0.066345215, 0.0927124, -0.009757996, -0.0018320084, 0.011276245, -0.023956299, -0.009155273, -0.011650085, 0.001408577, -0.03640747, 0.02017212, 0.019760132, 0.004928589, 0.031707764, -0.021728516, -0.03024292, -0.0070228577, -0.008934021, -0.018844604, -0.03225708, -0.0032615662, -0.0008301735, 0.008880615, -0.0046577454, -0.023422241, 0.043945312, -0.0044021606, 0.04171753, -0.02168274, -0.028442383, 0.02067566, 0.0262146, -0.05722046, -0.054107666, 0.024642944, -0.06500244, 0.01725769, -0.0046310425, -0.019348145, -0.021728516, 0.0039520264, 0.00048208237, -0.014854431, 0.009132385, -0.021560669, 0.018173218, -0.0579834, -0.08215332, -0.0003569126, -0.023880005, -0.0052337646, -0.012687683, 0.0037288666, -0.03503418, -0.020095825, -0.0054016113, 0.010292053, 0.034820557, 0.009727478, -0.039001465, 0.030029297, -0.040527344, -0.017471313, -0.03024292, -0.00894165, 0.0027980804, 0.013282776, 0.018157959, -0.0025787354, -0.027832031, -0.02897644, 0.0025978088, -0.008178711, -0.031173706, -0.024780273, -0.016845703, -0.022659302, 0.035980225, 0.09283447, -0.0065689087, 0.05886841, -0.004070282, 0.0178833, 0.0001282692, -0.0362854, -0.057525635, 0.013923645, 0.016784668, -0.008888245, 0.03656006, -0.009162903, -0.05166626, 0.045440674, -0.012290955, 0.054779053, 0.00869751, 0.014266968, 0.009429932, 0.019180298, -0.02319336, 0.03475952, -0.0075950623, 0.02017212, 0.032348633, 0.02041626, -0.016296387, -0.015838623, 0.026306152, 0.009132385, -0.011711121, -0.0075645447, -0.00484848, -0.052947998, -0.06866455, -0.058563232, 0.05368042, -0.0011711121, -0.062286377, 0.0012617111, 0.028915405, -0.008377075, 0.049804688, 0.019973755, -0.022399902, 0.016464233, -0.017868042, -0.029891968, -0.01953125, -0.018615723, -0.010955811, 0.007835388, -0.0026016235, 0.0030517578, -0.028167725, 0.0018997192, -0.01852417, 0.0002270937, -0.0008511543, 0.014381409, -0.003824234, -0.029464722, 0.01776123, -0.061157227, 0.014877319, 0.06976318, -0.014762878, 0.015548706, 0.0115737915, -0.000213027, 0.0211792, -0.017227173, -0.0104522705, 0.050872803, 0.0058250427, 0.010368347, 0.0075187683, -0.030899048, -0.004486084, -0.022537231, 0.012062073, -0.0057411194, -0.022521973, -0.010543823, -0.013870239, -0.014442444, 0.01638794, 0.018066406, 0.013122559, 0.0031108856, 0.026473999, -0.0003721714, 0.032836914, 0.029403687, 0.03515625, -0.04562378, -0.001709938, -0.005004883, -0.097473145, 0.004852295, -0.040405273, -0.0102005005, -0.023147583, 0.0065841675, -0.048553467, -0.021865845, -0.010940552, 0.009460449, -0.0013980865, 0.054260254, 0.053009033, 0.008422852, -0.052581787, -0.06365967, 0.001616478, -0.057617188, -0.023880005, -0.056152344, -0.010574341, 0.022384644, 0.06964111, -0.005092621, 0.027130127, 0.04626465, -0.0046157837, 0.033966064, 0.009277344, -0.03930664, -0.0026931763, 0.0043144226, 0.009979248, 0.038970947, -0.021957397, 0.012817383, 0.0072364807, -0.009880066, -0.025222778, 0.033081055, 0.01876831, 0.022659302, 0.0003695488, -0.038513184, 0.013969421, 0.03277588, 0.005935669, -0.020965576, -0.013427734, 0.002462387, -0.028335571, 0.01373291, -0.0030498505, 0.054748535, -0.017349243, 0.014381409, -0.00868988, 0.031082153, -0.032226562, -0.03994751, -0.0181427, 0.0181427, -0.002521515, -0.02520752, 0.012496948, -0.0046043396, 0.0287323, -0.00056886673, 0.05456543, -0.06329346, -0.052246094, -0.054229736, -0.0045814514, 0.01184082, 0.021453857, -0.00762558, 0.0028076172, -0.022781372, -0.02658081, 0.0027446747, 0.0037250519, 0.018447876, -0.0011606216, -0.03756714, 0.0496521, 0.0031795502, 0.0037384033, 0.013450623, 0.029327393, 0.040496826, -0.035705566, 0.015838623, 0.00046753883, 0.007762909, 0.009712219, 0.0049552917, 0.012992859, 0.042175293, 0.05432129, 0.013267517, -0.010856628, 0.0032367706, -0.0056381226, 0.036743164, -0.013008118, -0.125, -0.12231445, -0.08898926, -0.012969971, 0.021621704, -0.08074951, -0.039031982, 0.07757568, -0.012184143, 0.029403687, 0.02357483, -0.02281189, 0.0340271, -0.011398315, 0.01576233, 0.009613037, -0.013343811, -0.025161743, -0.0041046143, 0.03161621, 0.050323486, -0.011886597, 0.0037250519, 0.013282776, 0.034942627, -0.0026893616, -0.048095703, -0.057006836, 0.04650879, -0.045135498, 0.012054443, -0.011444092, -0.018585205, 0.044525146, 0.006893158, 0.0362854, -0.028900146, 0.035858154, 0.082458496, -0.04510498, 0.05706787, 0.046936035, 0.017669678, -0.015586853, -0.0066719055, -0.0395813, 0.034362793, -0.04840088, 0.0637207, -0.081604004, -0.077697754, 0.004257202, 0.0340271, -0.029571533, 0.0071983337, -0.043884277, -0.058502197, 0.014198303, 0.0158844, -0.043945312, 0.0032176971, 0.020385742, 0.00030255318, 0.020828247, 0.040100098, 0.0014009476, 0.042999268, 0.0054397583, 0.033416748, -0.068359375, 0.018356323, 0.03253174, -0.012641907, 0.034973145, 0.031158447, -0.014007568, 0.030761719, 0.036193848, 0.050048828, 0.03414917, 0.026855469, -0.052215576, 0.0011072159, 0.05130005, -0.010032654, 0.029190063, 0.023284912, -0.008102417, -0.078063965, 0.016021729, -0.016067505, -0.02078247, 0.014656067, 0.066833496, -0.007736206, 0.029434204, -0.002527237, -0.036956787, 0.014549255, -0.011795044, 0.028808594, -0.02267456, -0.040252686, 0.010719299, -0.00011199713, -0.00756073, 0.016174316, -0.011245728, 0.007335663, 0.06008911, -0.010307312, 0.02180481, 0.006580353, 0.0045433044, -0.00818634, -0.011245728, 0.03515625, -0.0098724365, -0.031341553, 0.04119873, -0.003211975, 0.018981934, -0.028640747, -0.031463623, 0.035583496, 0.026107788, -0.049560547, -0.0034770966, 0.003326416, -0.03390503, -0.04083252, -0.0020561218, 0.0045547485, -0.035827637, -0.00043225288, 0.05142212, -0.020065308, -0.018127441, -0.0051879883, 0.0015172958, 0.040008545, -0.014022827, -0.0095825195, 0.043395996, 0.0026779175, -0.016906738, -0.011177063, -0.017669678, 0.0011739731, -0.005744934, -0.02798462, 0.005874634, -0.0055122375, 0.020965576, -0.03829956, -0.019348145, -0.007865906, 0.0491333, 0.0039367676, -0.012794495, -0.054382324, -0.020614624, 0.039001465, 0.07330322, 0.031433105, -0.035247803, -0.017700195, 0.016418457, 0.062927246, -0.0030269623, -0.03277588, -0.002565384, 0.017669678, -0.04598999, -0.0013380051, -0.020553589, 0.0030231476, -0.0028877258, -0.0018939972, 0.012680054, -0.0071792603, -0.02999878, 0.043914795, 0.010650635, -0.03137207, -0.008613586, -0.01939392, -0.016403198, -0.0058517456, -0.02330017, -0.029022217, 0.024841309, -0.010925293, 0.017181396, 0.0058937073, 0.011299133, 0.0021648407, 0.021987915, 0.018173218, 0.025741577, -0.023498535, 0.0340271, 0.042663574, 0.0131073, -0.009513855, -0.020904541, 0.008811951, -0.024169922, -0.057678223, 0.07165527, -0.045898438, -0.022613525, -0.032318115, -0.025299072, -0.0021877289, -0.00566864, -0.028274536, -0.04144287, 0.0020065308, -0.060302734, -0.0046577454, 0.018188477 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2105.00875v1
A Sensorless Control System for an Implantable Heart Pump using a Real-time Deep Convolutional Neural Network
Masoud Fetanat, Michael Stevens, Christopher Hayward, Nigel H. Lovell
eess.SY, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SY
Left ventricular assist devices (LVADs) are mechanical pumps, which can be used to support heart failure (HF) patients as bridge to transplant and destination therapy. To automatically adjust the LVAD speed, a physiological control system needs to be designed to respond to variations of patient hemodynamics across a variety of clinical scenarios. These control systems require pressure feedback signals from the cardiovascular system. However, there are no suitable long-term implantable sensors available. In this study, a novel real-time deep convolutional neural network (CNN) for estimation of preload based on the LVAD flow was proposed. A new sensorless adaptive physiological control system for an LVAD pump was developed using the full dynamic form of model free adaptive control (FFDL-MFAC) and the proposed preload estimator to maintain the patient conditions in safe physiological ranges. The CNN model for preload estimation was trained and evaluated through 10-fold cross validation on 100 different patient conditions and the proposed sensorless control system was assessed on a new testing set of 30 different patient conditions across six different patient scenarios. The proposed preload estimator was extremely accurate with a correlation coefficient of 0.97, root mean squared error of 0.84 mmHg, reproducibility coefficient of 1.56 mmHg, coefficient of variation of 14.44 %, and bias of 0.29 mmHg for the testing dataset. The results also indicate that the proposed sensorless physiological controller works similarly to the preload-based physiological control system for LVAD using measured preload to prevent ventricular suction and pulmonary congestion. This study shows that the LVADs can respond appropriately to changing patient states and physiological demands without the need for additional pressure or flow measurements.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2105.00875v1
"2021-04-30T05:12:09"
"2021-04-30T05:12:09"
{ "title": [ 0.0076675415, -0.0072517395, -0.013870239, -0.007232666, 0.013389587, -0.03656006, 0.022064209, -0.041900635, -0.02558899, 0.03616333, -0.026672363, -0.0029354095, 0.027832031, -0.027435303, -0.02848816, -0.015960693, -0.0022277832, 0.024108887, -0.0059509277, -0.023864746, 0.008361816, -0.029708862, 0.035217285, 0.1026001, 0.0004992485, -0.007171631, -0.10028076, 0.015266418, -0.058502197, -0.033996582, -0.012802124, 0.044769287, 0.024398804, 0.04248047, -0.027069092, -0.0060768127, -0.045074463, 0.047454834, 0.010536194, 0.0072402954, 0.021713257, -0.011871338, -0.010292053, -0.028640747, -0.032806396, 0.037750244, -0.06085205, -0.0178833, -0.010032654, 0.070495605, 0.013496399, -0.011207581, -0.026412964, 0.06262207, 0.014823914, -0.029647827, -0.025634766, -0.006965637, 0.042785645, 0.08947754, 0.010124207, -0.033966064, -0.014091492, -0.05380249, -0.036834717, -0.0069236755, -0.014152527, 0.014556885, 0.09814453, -0.0063056946, -0.042755127, 0.041107178, 0.021972656, 0.014694214, -0.048309326, -0.016113281, 0.044677734, 0.02722168, 0.034942627, -0.04144287, -0.007335663, -0.010269165, 0.020477295, -0.0206604, 0.020751953, -0.009468079, -0.012016296, -0.0027370453, -0.042907715, -0.06274414, -0.019454956, 0.012069702, -0.028823853, -0.031707764, -0.021835327, -0.046539307, -0.00030827522, -0.002811432, 0.013000488, 0.0072021484, 0.04095459, -0.024154663, 0.054504395, -0.029266357, 0.0154953, 0.031082153, -0.027786255, -0.060638428, 0.005458832, 0.010269165, -0.032836914, -0.0021820068, -0.00881958, -0.01889038, 0.0079193115, 0.00554657, -0.008171082, 0.006549835, 0.022064209, 0.0087890625, 0.00868988, -0.009399414, 0.02458191, -0.0113220215, 0.018707275, -0.013259888, -0.04736328, -0.019042969, 0.004299164, -0.0022888184, -0.034088135, 0.025360107, 0.0023155212, -0.030151367, -0.015304565, 0.03366089, -0.027679443, -0.0043144226, 0.004714966, -0.012237549, 0.025497437, 0.020080566, 0.015213013, 0.016937256, -0.007858276, 0.0012235641, 0.043395996, 0.01159668, -0.048431396, -0.03289795, -0.019348145, 0.014457703, 0.021759033, -0.006290436, -0.021911621, -0.015045166, -0.10821533, -0.009880066, 0.027877808, 0.017684937, 0.038208008, -0.00001835823, -0.0056877136, 0.022384644, 0.057769775, -0.023895264, -0.049621582, 0.025482178, 0.010414124, 0.014762878, -0.01638794, 0.024490356, 0.015655518, -0.012413025, 0.01663208, 0.012290955, 0.03149414, 0.0085372925, 0.031555176, -0.036895752, -0.009178162, -0.007484436, 0.022827148, 0.02406311, -0.04360962, -0.013710022, -0.0006542206, 0.023010254, 0.056671143, 0.021026611, -0.074523926, 0.0096588135, -0.015312195, -0.019851685, -0.05053711, -0.035003662, 0.036834717, 0.02482605, -0.019363403, 0.023712158, -0.05596924, 0.0158844, -0.029525757, 0.040649414, -0.0015764236, -0.0059432983, -0.018569946, 0.014808655, -0.025772095, 0.0340271, 0.041931152, -0.020767212, -0.0020885468, -0.014717102, -0.0093307495, -0.050933838, 0.026473999, -0.015380859, -0.03933716, -0.037322998, -0.037628174, -0.020095825, -0.013755798, 0.05718994, -0.0012235641, 0.0463562, -0.013137817, -0.0031642914, 0.05227661, 0.034179688, 0.092163086, -0.049682617, -0.0028419495, -0.015838623, -0.01751709, 0.011024475, 0.000644207, 0.02519226, -0.0020542145, -0.003648758, -0.0047416687, -0.010894775, -0.007270813, 0.055633545, 0.03274536, -0.006515503, 0.01033783, 0.03805542, 0.013549805, 0.034942627, 0.06335449, 0.033996582, 0.038269043, 0.040802002, 0.0072784424, 0.040283203, -0.012069702, -0.0049095154, -0.016677856, 0.005256653, -0.010375977, 0.01007843, 0.03125, 0.010276794, -0.05908203, 0.027191162, -0.0049057007, 0.027786255, -0.02268982, 0.030532837, 0.054870605, 0.0501709, 0.010871887, -0.015716553, -0.02407837, -0.015838623, -0.012023926, 0.017105103, -0.004802704, -0.036071777, -0.030136108, -0.02078247, 0.037261963, -0.007904053, 0.014190674, -0.031204224, 0.035125732, -0.040374756, 0.023788452, -0.004043579, 0.039764404, 0.002166748, -0.0062828064, -0.0021266937, 0.010353088, -0.031219482, 0.02671814, 0.049346924, -0.03274536, 0.027496338, -0.027450562, 0.017166138, -0.0006313324, -0.002336502, 0.00030946732, 0.0029525757, -0.023605347, 0.016311646, -0.017822266, 0.028259277, -0.066833496, 0.04800415, -0.011650085, 0.0029258728, -0.085632324, -0.09313965, -0.033691406, -0.047851562, -0.078186035, -0.016937256, 0.042663574, -0.017440796, -0.013496399, -0.0021095276, -0.000916481, -0.030685425, -0.021133423, -0.025802612, -0.044067383, 0.028167725, 0.08068848, 0.043304443, -0.005996704, 0.036956787, 0.017410278, 0.011047363, -0.0025520325, 0.03414917, -0.012763977, -0.006385803, -0.0044441223, 0.00365448, 0.0018482208, -0.029647827, -0.002319336, 0.00054740906, -0.014503479, 0.015106201, -0.026550293, 0.0026683807, 0.019073486, -0.044830322, -0.03881836, 0.0038928986, 0.016403198, -0.030929565, -0.0008292198, -0.011390686, -0.015792847, -0.020736694, 0.010444641, 0.026412964, -0.011459351, -0.044433594, 0.008178711, -0.060821533, -0.02571106, 0.0001887083, 0.0004477501, 0.04473877, -0.10064697, -0.0019760132, -0.0049705505, -0.018493652, 0.03729248, 0.05822754, 0.008140564, -0.009399414, -0.011856079, -0.0031318665, 0.029510498, 0.017944336, -0.035949707, -0.0042533875, 0.06555176, 0.013259888, 0.02029419, 0.0012664795, 0.044799805, -0.018035889, 0.007659912, -0.0067634583, 0.004497528, 0.0017232895, 0.033813477, -0.0023784637, 0.0068511963, 0.025146484, -0.10064697, -0.00705719, 0.080566406, 0.0061531067, -0.03717041, 0.042907715, -0.034118652, -0.0053100586, 0.05343628, -0.012359619, -0.0013713837, 0.06567383, -0.018997192, 0.018127441, -0.009590149, 0.0088272095, 0.035827637, -0.0362854, -0.113098145, 0.02835083, -0.023849487, -0.010467529, -0.013885498, -0.001953125, -0.06878662, -0.0051116943, -0.011474609, 0.038757324, 0.030075073, 0.007167816, 0.0036468506, -0.028289795, 0.013534546, -0.049468994, -0.010017395, -0.03326416, -0.0024795532, 0.033325195, -0.017700195, 0.06463623, -0.023971558, 0.015449524, -0.028060913, -0.011108398, 0.013938904, 0.04119873, 0.0012893677, -0.043121338, -0.008232117, 0.0027751923, -0.016403198, -0.022354126, 0.022155762, 0.004283905, 0.025360107, 0.0011577606, -0.00059366226, 0.03970337, 0.003358841, 0.00440979, 0.0047912598, -0.031188965, -0.014717102, -0.01777649, -0.052001953, 0.018600464, 0.009033203, 0.00078487396, 0.027664185, -0.008605957, -0.030670166, 0.017623901, -0.0034503937, 0.013328552, -0.01676941, -0.029647827, 0.019866943, -0.022003174, -0.008476257, -0.0062561035, 0.014205933, 0.0062294006, -0.023468018, 0.025772095, -0.048309326, -0.053344727, -0.0018129349, 0.00086069107, -0.050689697, -0.047546387, 0.030090332, -0.07458496, -0.014778137, -0.097351074, 0.031585693, -0.070129395, -0.035491943, -0.012184143, 0.007217407, -0.05670166, 0.0003745556, -0.05429077, -0.060760498, 0.06124878, 0.0102005005, 0.01008606, -0.019195557, 0.010597229, -0.007255554, -0.024520874, 0.027801514, -0.053344727, 0.022445679, -0.0074386597, 0.012367249, 0.06124878, -0.03817749, 0.004081726, 0.030426025, 0.05911255, -0.030380249, 0.0031375885, 0.05517578, 0.039154053, 0.0011844635, 0.043792725, -0.014328003, -0.011154175, -0.059814453, -0.02848816, -0.009094238, -0.004207611, 0.027160645, 0.000052154064, 0.057281494, 0.030914307, -0.003282547, 0.03152466, 0.008720398, 0.021972656, 0.027908325, -0.046051025, -0.023330688, 0.016555786, 0.052764893, -0.03125, 0.011550903, 0.023956299, -0.030471802, 0.009223938, -0.033111572, -0.0362854, -0.022232056, 0.015014648, -0.007850647, -0.031234741, -0.045196533, -0.046417236, 0.019332886, -0.032409668, -0.016311646, 0.020370483, 0.022857666, 0.0006084442, -0.03164673, 0.012306213, 0.020385742, -0.02003479, 0.033416748, -0.029403687, -0.03640747, -0.006259918, -0.05505371, -0.036987305, -0.0048217773, 0.02407837, 0.0020198822, -0.0062789917, 0.00012481213, 0.006175995, 0.044158936, 0.059814453, 0.038146973, 0.004184723, -0.05847168, 0.017486572, -0.036071777, -0.0026626587, -0.00086832047, 0.00069618225, -0.027435303, -0.02810669, 0.02166748, -0.004081726, -0.0024986267, 0.010292053, 0.0063819885, -0.029663086, 0.034423828, -0.03253174, 0.045196533, 0.0063591003, 0.005317688, 0.020355225, 0.0064201355, -0.041412354, -0.004169464, 0.014251709, 0.036132812, -0.027709961, 0.030853271, 0.030059814, 0.022766113, -0.017730713, 0.0030841827, 0.03918457, 0.01626587, -0.029296875, -0.020019531, 0.021514893, -0.013420105, -0.029632568, -0.0019874573, -0.010391235, 0.036071777, -0.044952393, 0.06274414, -0.038024902, -0.042907715, 0.023269653, 0.013069153, -0.0134887695, 0.0072250366, 0.007408142, -0.057891846, -0.060913086, -0.018096924, 0.06402588, -0.01927185, 0.007827759, -0.018951416, -0.015014648, 0.032989502, 0.027145386, 0.0137786865, 0.008888245, -0.01512146, 0.004890442, 0.008148193, -0.028289795, -0.052825928, 0.00026726723, 0.00699234, 0.021591187, 0.027816772, -0.027023315, -0.072509766, 0.0038166046, -0.004573822, -0.0026760101, 0.029129028, -0.064697266, -0.006259918, 0.038757324, 0.020370483, -0.0061531067, 0.026382446, 0.027633667, -0.02923584, 0.051330566, -0.021118164, 0.057647705, 0.034301758, -0.037231445, -0.016983032, -0.009048462, 0.0146102905, 0.012214661, 0.017425537, 0.0017910004, 0.012168884, -0.048919678, 0.023117065, 0.013214111, -0.028182983, 0.023040771, -0.033721924, 0.037719727, -0.004383087, -0.017181396, 0.012435913, -0.03817749, -0.017730713, 0.020706177, -0.033203125, -0.012611389, 0.012634277, -0.024551392, -0.03591919, -0.034057617, 0.012199402, -0.037261963, -0.029968262, 0.014831543, 0.024337769, -0.013977051, 0.006252289, -0.00081443787, -0.08898926, 0.019210815, 0.020431519, 0.049957275, 0.025543213, -0.025299072, -0.032409668, 0.001086235, 0.022766113, -0.013092041, -0.011123657, 0.028518677, -0.0026359558, -0.035614014, -0.0056381226, -0.033599854, -0.01727295, 0.020965576, 0.020477295, 0.019042969, -0.044433594, 0.034240723, -0.009994507, -0.011940002, 0.019515991, -0.00026392937, 0.046295166, -0.001452446, -0.021896362, -0.040527344, 0.016403198, -0.0070610046, -0.0019664764, -0.015777588, -0.021224976, 0.009208679, 0.01499939, -0.014984131, -0.010353088, -0.0036792755, 0.032989502, 0.00970459, -0.03741455, -0.021148682, 0.062347412, -0.05239868, -0.049102783, -0.031829834, 0.0016212463, -0.045288086, 0.06317139, -0.02809143, -0.048706055, -0.032470703, -0.03692627, -0.019073486, 0.019042969, 0.044708252, 0.007587433, 0.057037354, -0.1104126, -0.036193848, -0.056854248, 0.027557373, 0.000050604343, -0.011703491, -0.004760742, 0.023788452, -0.028778076, 0.039916992, -0.018630981, -0.010559082, 0.04269409, -0.0008621216, -0.02229309, 0.027175903, -0.00015437603, 0.007843018, -0.021347046, -0.033294678, 0.032989502, 0.01096344, -0.020874023, 0.052246094, -0.01424408, 0.050323486, 0.00022912025, 0.06524658, 0.058441162, 0.010597229, 0.0038833618, 0.0009937286, -0.01902771, -0.04019165, 0.0027236938, -0.060913086, -0.033294678, -0.055419922, -0.013626099, -0.04562378, -0.013511658, 0.0033340454, 0.03942871, 0.006084442, 0.020767212, 0.038726807, -0.008903503, 0.039489746, -0.04348755, 0.05718994, 0.004711151, -0.007724762, 0.0042648315, 0.031433105, 0.04348755, 0.027664185, -0.010108948, 0.05496216, -0.00005877018, -0.013839722, -0.0012817383, 0.005554199, 0.011528015, -0.030792236, -0.012916565, -0.024276733, 0.064331055, -0.004131317, 0.015213013, 0.07409668, 0.0635376, -0.011001587, -0.029541016, 0.031021118, 0.015220642, -0.023742676, 0.0022239685, 0.042907715, -0.04031372, 0.025222778, -0.027938843, -0.03427124, -0.005279541, 0.060150146, -0.0014791489, -0.037078857, -0.0023040771, 0.010444641, 0.024459839, 0.039245605, 0.011642456, -0.036346436, -0.0143585205, 0.026947021, 0.01777649, -0.018463135, -0.019485474, 0.02067566, 0.04547119, 0.011878967, 0.023605347, -0.011169434, 0.032043457, -0.029205322, 0.031951904, -0.030471802, -0.008033752, -0.0077171326, -0.032470703, -0.011978149, 0.014816284, -0.036376953, -0.015327454, 0.030014038, -0.0018339157, 0.009315491, 0.04876709, 0.04598999, -0.0018930435, -0.05441284, -0.04586792, 0.0061531067, 0.030288696, -0.042053223, -0.016082764, -0.018951416, -0.048736572, 0.0033245087, -0.027923584, 0.064819336, -0.033233643, -0.008613586, -0.04550171, 0.024795532, 0.010498047, -0.06439209, -0.0010929108, -0.05859375, 0.0038490295, -0.002008438, 0.019851685, -0.046325684, -0.014099121, 0.013206482, 0.00945282, 0.018814087, -0.0020961761, -0.008285522, -0.031982422, -0.057739258, 0.024032593, -0.0058784485, 0.050201416, 0.031341553, 0.0058670044, -0.025344849, -0.008003235, -0.02532959, -0.018707275, 0.022613525, -0.04269409, -0.07373047, -0.045288086, 0.0003476143, 0.002286911, -0.023071289, 0.011367798, 0.010025024, 0.0020751953, -0.008659363, -0.031280518, 0.029373169, -0.039916992, -0.019973755, -0.008583069, -0.029159546, 0.01386261, 0.02268982, -0.012176514, -0.00233078, 0.01928711, -0.021331787, -0.023361206, 0.0022888184, 0.051635742, -0.014572144, -0.047180176, 0.0028095245, 0.022583008, 0.018554688, -0.06048584, -0.023483276, 0.01977539, 0.07409668, 0.009979248, 0.020614624, -0.003446579, -0.008460999, 0.012016296, 0.021072388, 0.005168915, -0.042999268, -0.06341553, 0.01436615, 0.052124023, 0.045135498, -0.011444092, 0.013450623, 0.036376953, -0.04989624, 0.009391785, 0.001414299, -0.01852417, 0.021575928, -0.016799927, 0.009300232, -0.011482239, 0.0033283234, -0.023742676, -0.0043411255, 0.015792847, 0.030059814, -0.015792847, 0.03237915, -0.0056991577, 0.06933594, -0.0054740906, -0.049957275, 0.053497314, 0.0053863525, 0.030731201, 0.024536133, 0.018447876, -0.04006958, -0.016906738, -0.010017395, -0.018554688, -0.007896423, 0.035461426, -0.013183594, 0.012802124, -0.018585205, -0.027526855, -0.008605957, -0.04046631, 0.049346924, -0.011962891, 0.0071525574, -0.0016126633, -0.010551453, -0.013595581, -0.010925293, -0.003227234, -0.0055503845, -0.061767578, -0.09283447, -0.0055122375, -0.021011353 ], "summary": [ 0.024124146, -0.024032593, 0.027267456, -0.000518322, -0.024169922, -0.02268982, 0.01020813, -0.0501709, -0.026306152, 0.036010742, 0.015548706, 0.012756348, 0.0059280396, -0.028915405, -0.00065660477, -0.022460938, 0.0368042, -0.03250122, 0.01210022, -0.020095825, 0.009742737, -0.00033044815, 0.029556274, 0.09124756, -0.013114929, 0.035949707, -0.08947754, 0.05911255, -0.057891846, 0.0057411194, -0.012763977, 0.035583496, -0.00017523766, 0.039031982, -0.017303467, -0.035369873, -0.007926941, 0.032592773, 0.019134521, 0.0054893494, 0.029678345, -0.013771057, 0.054870605, -0.05770874, -0.0011329651, 0.04446411, 0.0028018951, -0.032043457, 0.0317688, 0.071777344, -0.0066337585, -0.025665283, -0.03189087, 0.026824951, -0.019836426, -0.04135132, -0.019897461, -0.0017299652, 0.024414062, 0.06829834, -0.017166138, 0.002981186, -0.009498596, -0.06878662, -0.03591919, -0.009223938, -0.024108887, 0.009231567, 0.10028076, -0.017593384, -0.051116943, 0.03805542, 0.01953125, -0.009529114, -0.010818481, -0.014572144, -0.007850647, -0.024383545, 0.012512207, -0.0068206787, 0.027816772, -0.011779785, 0.03967285, -0.017684937, 0.020492554, 0.00093126297, 0.0028381348, -0.002576828, -0.034057617, -0.04977417, -0.0345459, 0.006919861, -0.02760315, -0.023452759, -0.036621094, -0.027038574, -0.008338928, -0.066589355, 0.020614624, 0.029067993, 0.049438477, -0.0552063, 0.076660156, 0.0069351196, -0.013885498, 0.046936035, 0.0039863586, -0.041503906, -0.020370483, 0.007911682, -0.026535034, -0.023391724, -0.011421204, -0.045684814, -0.017318726, 0.038482666, 0.0059394836, 0.007156372, 0.018951416, -0.0029010773, 0.007843018, 0.046691895, 0.03945923, -0.022476196, -0.018432617, -0.008125305, 0.0013275146, -0.07104492, 0.007858276, 0.031051636, -0.03466797, -0.014404297, 0.045410156, 0.026947021, 0.013282776, -0.027130127, 0.021591187, 0.0050697327, 0.026565552, -0.008422852, 0.015022278, -0.0041885376, 0.0022678375, 0.015335083, -0.0413208, 0.02696228, 0.034851074, 0.009414673, -0.051605225, -0.06201172, -0.013946533, 0.025283813, 0.014976501, -0.016815186, 0.004261017, -0.02128601, -0.07513428, 0.017364502, 0.028518677, 0.033966064, 0.022338867, -0.0039787292, 0.010261536, 0.032958984, 0.0051879883, -0.0007891655, -0.012580872, 0.00072813034, 0.017593384, -0.0025119781, 0.028640747, 0.039794922, 0.0680542, -0.023757935, 0.0019140244, -0.016433716, -0.0104599, 0.029785156, 0.06463623, -0.084350586, -0.035736084, -0.01802063, 0.09643555, -0.010383606, 0.01689148, -0.023101807, 0.015808105, 0.040740967, 0.013969421, 0.031951904, -0.05267334, -0.008934021, 0.035095215, 0.0019721985, -0.010749817, -0.06512451, 0.028884888, -0.011329651, -0.014122009, 0.004142761, -0.01234436, -0.028823853, 0.011383057, -0.007789612, 0.0041542053, -0.026428223, 0.0056114197, 0.0051231384, 0.02722168, 0.02418518, -0.0031280518, -0.010757446, -0.0030212402, -0.027008057, -0.03515625, 0.007987976, -0.0043411255, -0.033050537, -0.039123535, -0.038879395, -0.03253174, -0.019210815, -0.03982544, 0.07244873, -0.019577026, 0.010154724, -0.008033752, 0.014511108, 0.068725586, -0.0259552, 0.13928223, -0.03656006, -0.010932922, -0.0038490295, -0.027664185, 0.0066604614, 0.03945923, 0.002784729, 0.011383057, 0.0064201355, -0.00073719025, -0.0039711, -0.020980835, 0.07623291, -0.021392822, 0.026382446, 0.021896362, 0.032043457, -0.0026054382, 0.052246094, 0.026794434, 0.021026611, 0.0007991791, 0.0138549805, 0.007293701, 0.027832031, -0.04534912, -0.054016113, 0.015350342, -0.029510498, 0.022506714, -0.023452759, -0.01083374, 0.008155823, -0.039093018, -0.002822876, -0.017715454, 0.0038394928, -0.025772095, -0.00020861626, 0.02999878, 0.022994995, 0.011192322, -0.028640747, -0.05734253, 0.0072364807, -0.018615723, 0.025283813, 0.0004963875, -0.02947998, -0.028152466, -0.034606934, -0.023376465, -0.012565613, 0.02609253, -0.052093506, 0.0087509155, -0.020599365, 0.0625, 0.039154053, 0.043762207, -0.0015258789, -0.012329102, 0.045196533, 0.012870789, -0.035491943, 0.0074386597, -0.0048446655, 0.013961792, -0.024902344, 0.035827637, 0.051727295, -0.03062439, 0.02418518, 0.0029239655, -0.019073486, -0.026855469, 0.02154541, 0.013748169, -0.022918701, 0.0001950264, 0.076660156, -0.022216797, 0.07745361, -0.103393555, -0.09259033, -0.03616333, -0.02796936, -0.05480957, -0.009185791, 0.078308105, -0.028121948, 0.0032234192, 0.026062012, -0.0131073, -0.055389404, 0.059814453, 0.0020980835, -0.026260376, -0.0015926361, 0.009017944, -0.009727478, -0.0056762695, 0.053222656, 0.012672424, 0.00806427, -0.0036678314, 0.07989502, -0.0011548996, -0.044555664, -0.018463135, 0.028411865, -0.0023822784, 0.022903442, -0.027252197, 0.017868042, -0.0071105957, 0.008605957, -0.00066804886, 0.005622864, -0.0056533813, -0.02935791, -0.060638428, 0.01259613, -0.015731812, -0.049987793, 0.04373169, -0.010543823, -0.061798096, -0.044891357, 0.022598267, -0.010025024, -0.006072998, -0.050231934, -0.000014603138, -0.030288696, -0.020492554, -0.0039901733, -0.0049095154, 0.051116943, -0.06958008, 0.01676941, -0.02319336, -0.009765625, 0.019805908, 0.07098389, 0.060272217, -0.020355225, 0.050048828, 0.046661377, 0.042114258, 0.032684326, -0.017105103, -0.0062332153, 0.085632324, 0.009712219, 0.057922363, 0.051361084, 0.035003662, -0.024459839, -0.02557373, -0.01676941, -0.0031490326, -0.030639648, 0.026367188, 0.008560181, 0.014259338, 0.06414795, -0.030456543, -0.026916504, 0.09918213, 0.012420654, -0.0087890625, 0.030899048, -0.017944336, 0.007217407, 0.06524658, 0.020355225, 0.003648758, 0.026138306, -0.0088272095, -0.00881958, -0.0055656433, -0.019073486, 0.013442993, -0.018341064, -0.041107178, -0.008377075, 0.024276733, 0.03363037, -0.021331787, 0.021560669, -0.04034424, 0.013000488, 0.054870605, 0.027282715, 0.037963867, -0.037322998, -0.00015854836, 0.01763916, 0.04345703, -0.035247803, -0.027633667, -0.03390503, 0.0036945343, 0.057800293, -0.020126343, 0.010383606, -0.032714844, 0.011474609, -0.058746338, -0.020477295, -0.009590149, 0.0014390945, -0.020111084, -0.033966064, -0.0016202927, -0.03845215, -0.003894806, -0.015701294, 0.011962891, -0.0042648315, 0.054107666, 0.021057129, -0.0011196136, 0.079589844, 0.012397766, 0.025421143, 0.04473877, -0.042541504, -0.032592773, -0.009559631, -0.023208618, -0.0026855469, -0.021316528, 0.044708252, -0.056915283, 0.04486084, -0.015975952, -0.024383545, 0.044128418, 0.033569336, -0.02973938, -0.034576416, 0.03161621, -0.040374756, 0.0031585693, -0.0011577606, 0.036621094, -0.0066223145, -0.03842163, 0.02659607, -0.044708252, -0.01776123, -0.017471313, 0.0070495605, -0.033081055, -0.03225708, 0.0014514923, -0.050842285, 0.0039138794, -0.054870605, 0.03741455, -0.052978516, -0.022262573, -0.033813477, 0.0051231384, -0.02607727, -0.021270752, -0.053985596, -0.033447266, -0.0076942444, 0.036376953, 0.041107178, -0.037902832, 0.008239746, 0.032958984, -0.017410278, 0.018005371, -0.02722168, -0.0025367737, -0.028656006, 0.011154175, 0.024642944, -0.027832031, -0.024612427, 0.020095825, 0.0579834, -0.045806885, -0.01864624, 0.068359375, 0.09375, 0.0033740997, 0.028320312, -0.014587402, -0.026641846, -0.021713257, -0.035827637, -0.013061523, -0.035461426, 0.013648987, 0.028839111, -0.009391785, 0.024398804, 0.030044556, -0.008239746, 0.019241333, 0.031707764, 0.022262573, -0.049682617, -0.010414124, 0.014251709, 0.028305054, -0.047668457, 0.005332947, -0.022521973, -0.042175293, -0.008323669, -0.038726807, -0.027572632, -0.012557983, 0.008934021, 0.015090942, -0.048095703, -0.014511108, -0.030593872, 0.019607544, -0.050598145, 0.006412506, 0.032928467, -0.013366699, -0.032928467, -0.01737976, 0.015312195, -0.021530151, 0.019073486, 0.013252258, -0.014091492, -0.011024475, -0.03439331, -0.005138397, -0.03237915, -0.003490448, -0.00573349, -0.026641846, 0.017990112, -0.003967285, 0.0044174194, 0.011131287, 0.026901245, 0.029663086, -0.0073661804, -0.04336548, -0.034820557, -0.011581421, 0.002117157, -0.012756348, 0.0016260147, -0.02432251, -0.01852417, 0.019012451, -0.017105103, -0.013664246, 0.017822266, 0.012252808, -0.0069274902, 0.01737976, -0.041625977, 0.03527832, 0.0047836304, -0.009635925, 0.033843994, 0.0055618286, -0.004928589, -0.020874023, 0.048675537, -0.02746582, 0.032836914, 0.005466461, 0.0068092346, 0.0027446747, 0.014465332, -0.010848999, -0.008506775, -0.008255005, -0.019592285, -0.051940918, 0.035369873, 0.029510498, 0.0054359436, 0.016921997, -0.04144287, 0.012718201, 0.016403198, 0.015548706, -0.02746582, -0.030899048, 0.039276123, 0.0101623535, -0.016021729, 0.03741455, -0.00881958, -0.048309326, -0.04373169, -0.030548096, 0.041107178, -0.017105103, -0.022949219, -0.015014648, -0.032958984, 0.0023345947, 0.022140503, -0.0041656494, 0.04827881, -0.031341553, 0.0018062592, 0.028656006, -0.03289795, -0.030731201, -0.018722534, -0.0026779175, 0.005882263, 0.0748291, -0.045837402, -0.019119263, -0.009300232, 0.020965576, 0.007286072, 0.017456055, -0.070251465, -0.05606079, -0.02027893, 0.014930725, -0.059448242, 0.036376953, 0.018997192, -0.048614502, 0.0340271, -0.040496826, 0.049621582, 0.000027477741, -0.02519226, -0.013183594, -0.03161621, 0.007003784, 0.006866455, -0.0028362274, 0.016159058, 0.002702713, -0.024154663, 0.011962891, -0.0051193237, -0.016815186, -0.015586853, -0.0043258667, 0.04232788, 0.016342163, -0.009666443, 0.015792847, -0.016860962, -0.017913818, 0.002128601, 0.003435135, -0.021499634, 0.0076141357, -0.007762909, 0.010467529, -0.0009784698, -0.007675171, -0.051361084, 0.0015220642, 0.016082764, 0.01701355, 0.02909851, -0.0146484375, -0.01927185, -0.02973938, -0.0025787354, 0.02999878, 0.038726807, -0.013160706, -0.044891357, -0.00756073, -0.01335144, -0.015045166, -0.010292053, 0.045959473, 0.048919678, 0.030059814, 0.002576828, -0.0262146, -0.029388428, -0.0068893433, -0.015541077, 0.00033950806, 0.012969971, -0.033966064, -0.005504608, -0.015312195, -0.024932861, 0.02684021, -0.03137207, -0.020553589, 0.013259888, 0.0035743713, -0.0152282715, 0.047546387, -0.020690918, 0.014961243, -0.015106201, 0.030441284, -0.0011720657, 0.03048706, -0.014144897, -0.04220581, 0.019088745, 0.019622803, -0.030822754, -0.012741089, -0.029464722, 0.026031494, -0.009552002, -0.08917236, -0.018157959, 0.025604248, -0.004005432, 0.027832031, -0.020370483, -0.06921387, 0.0038414001, 0.0012922287, 0.017105103, 0.004016876, 0.019683838, -0.0059814453, 0.06121826, -0.097595215, -0.06945801, -0.03173828, 0.025115967, -0.016647339, 0.002620697, -0.02041626, 0.0056762695, -0.0047454834, 0.025894165, -0.00617218, 0.014595032, 0.017745972, -0.027267456, -0.046661377, 0.0513916, 0.0390625, 0.032989502, -0.0020389557, -0.011436462, -0.03149414, 0.030166626, -0.04071045, 0.0030384064, -0.038482666, 0.055999756, 0.03439331, 0.017852783, 0.020614624, -0.040130615, -0.02609253, 0.015083313, -0.023712158, -0.040283203, 0.00053834915, -0.016693115, -0.03805542, -0.03152466, -0.01524353, 0.0014352798, 0.032684326, -0.013145447, -0.022537231, 0.009613037, 0.0011920929, 0.022735596, 0.03717041, 0.002948761, -0.029632568, -0.00018906593, 0.0019245148, -0.04034424, 0.026138306, 0.064208984, -0.00061941147, 0.019241333, 0.025482178, 0.02255249, -0.015113831, 0.015151978, -0.001832962, -0.011329651, -0.010047913, -0.030059814, 0.026428223, -0.027130127, 0.03894043, 0.0011911392, 0.027801514, 0.024475098, 0.03543091, 0.026550293, -0.011390686, 0.01838684, 0.027435303, -0.034973145, 0.050689697, 0.04663086, -0.02734375, 0.00029993057, -0.0066833496, -0.028533936, 0.004398346, 0.103881836, -0.0020122528, 0.013328552, 0.057403564, -0.014404297, -0.0033054352, 0.020355225, 0.016494751, -0.04711914, -0.026000977, -0.0070114136, -0.007774353, -0.0041503906, -0.033691406, 0.013557434, 0.04168701, -0.0032463074, 0.036468506, -0.034210205, 0.009338379, -0.06573486, 0.007396698, -0.021865845, -0.036865234, 0.03062439, -0.010154724, 0.0055885315, 0.024215698, 0.022918701, 0.013900757, -0.025436401, -0.01751709, 0.011352539, 0.054229736, 0.028533936, 0.028579712, -0.057556152, -0.006385803, 0.0012788773, -0.047973633, -0.021957397, -0.0597229, -0.008224487, 0.016479492, -0.050567627, -0.0006365776, -0.0037212372, -0.03793335, -0.0059432983, -0.044189453, 0.032806396, -0.06512451, -0.010772705, 0.03149414, -0.06719971, -0.01424408, 0.03265381, 0.040405273, -0.018295288, 0.049224854, 0.015792847, -0.04864502, 0.072631836, -0.0060920715, 0.023345947, -0.010223389, -0.01638794, -0.019180298, -0.00057029724, 0.019241333, -0.023635864, -0.022644043, 0.020431519, -0.017837524, 0.011360168, 0.008155823, -0.00072336197, -0.0073890686, -0.047210693, -0.028793335, -0.017959595, -0.01525116, -0.031982422, 0.011756897, -0.0021705627, 0.03161621, -0.017700195, -0.011817932, 0.042755127, -0.0041389465, -0.03567505, -0.014152527, -0.026229858, 0.012634277, -0.0074310303, -0.008338928, -0.0017061234, 0.0126953125, -0.032806396, -0.056793213, 0.0107803345, 0.015716553, 0.011070251, -0.017837524, -0.0017442703, -0.0017375946, 0.012359619, -0.047698975, -0.0023384094, 0.016677856, 0.04727173, -0.009597778, -0.051208496, -0.007106781, -0.04373169, 0.042022705, -0.0024547577, 0.0030078888, -0.011375427, -0.03665161, 0.000682354, 0.040405273, 0.012168884, -0.029556274, 0.018463135, 0.030792236, -0.05142212, -0.026824951, -0.0059280396, -0.028366089, -0.02357483, 0.002840042, -0.005695343, -0.0058288574, 0.012481689, 0.024993896, -0.027542114, 0.010978699, 0.015853882, -0.010627747, -0.014312744, -0.0006341934, 0.043640137, -0.009544373, 0.0075950623, 0.016830444, -0.03881836, 0.028564453, -0.032928467, 0.05215454, 0.00409317, 0.01184845, -0.0048561096, -0.011314392, -0.0073776245, 0.04776001, -0.04977417, -0.023880005, -0.00047779083, -0.0066490173, 0.004043579, -0.030853271, 0.03918457, 0.023254395, -0.017654419, 0.06237793, -0.014877319, 0.009117126, -0.0496521, -0.028533936, 0.026733398, -0.051849365, -0.07171631, -0.07366943, -0.007083893 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2105.03811v1
Click-Through Rate Prediction Using Graph Neural Networks and Online Learning
Farzaneh Rajabi, Jack Siyuan He
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Recommendation systems have been extensively studied by many literature in the past and are ubiquitous in online advertisement, shopping industry/e-commerce, query suggestions in search engines, and friend recommendation in social networks. Moreover, restaurant/music/product/movie/news/app recommendations are only a few of the applications of a recommender system. A small percent improvement on the CTR prediction accuracy has been mentioned to add millions of dollars of revenue to the advertisement industry. Click-Through-Rate (CTR) prediction is a special version of recommender system in which the goal is predicting whether or not a user is going to click on a recommended item. A content-based recommendation approach takes into account the past history of the user's behavior, i.e. the recommended products and the users reaction to them. So, a personalized model that recommends the right item to the right user at the right time is the key to building such a model. On the other hand, the so-called collaborative filtering approach incorporates the click history of the users who are very similar to a particular user, thereby helping the recommender to come up with a more confident prediction for that particular user by leveraging the wider knowledge of users who share their taste in a connected network of users. In this project, we are interested in building a CTR predictor using Graph Neural Networks complemented by an online learning algorithm that models such dynamic interactions. By framing the problem as a binary classification task, we have evaluated this system both on the offline models (GNN, Deep Factorization Machines) with test-AUC of 0.7417 and on the online learning model with test-AUC of 0.7585 using a sub-sampled version of Criteo public dataset consisting of 10,000 data points.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2105.03811v1
"2021-05-09T01:35:49"
"2021-05-09T01:35:49"
{ "title": [ -0.0014190674, 0.0010461807, -0.0129852295, -0.023788452, 0.0037002563, -0.008056641, -0.017730713, -0.029800415, -0.0027275085, 0.025177002, -0.017150879, 0.015945435, -0.033477783, -0.022827148, -0.025497437, -0.002506256, -0.015991211, 0.055511475, 0.015960693, -0.028793335, -0.009933472, -0.037261963, 0.039154053, 0.027664185, 0.021896362, -0.052520752, -0.0362854, 0.030792236, -0.014335632, -0.013809204, -0.008056641, -0.00070667267, 0.029724121, 0.0256958, 0.0055732727, 0.019226074, -0.045959473, 0.04736328, 0.033325195, -0.019973755, 0.005870819, 0.0030708313, -0.014923096, -0.058288574, -0.042053223, 0.052886963, -0.072509766, -0.012290955, -0.02053833, -0.0019388199, 0.008125305, 0.02407837, 0.013687134, -0.005256653, 0.006931305, -0.04486084, -0.045715332, 0.002916336, 0.04156494, 0.051605225, 0.0036849976, -0.028671265, -0.0015678406, -0.04321289, -0.047058105, -0.014274597, 0.01360321, 0.028030396, 0.071777344, -0.028427124, -0.02758789, 0.057159424, -0.015312195, 0.017120361, -0.055755615, 0.009536743, 0.061950684, 0.004047394, 0.026977539, 0.0009226799, -0.02394104, 0.003353119, -0.04840088, -0.034057617, 0.026794434, -0.011497498, -0.023635864, -0.023269653, -0.032714844, -0.06774902, -0.014678955, 0.017059326, -0.032989502, 0.0079574585, -0.022094727, -0.028152466, 0.008163452, 0.04901123, -0.013137817, -0.039245605, -0.01979065, 0.019073486, -0.08856201, -0.0033779144, 0.00907135, 0.0012283325, -0.015686035, -0.025619507, 0.02279663, 0.034729004, -0.007785797, 0.025924683, 0.02079773, 0.042785645, -0.020721436, -0.029907227, -0.011405945, 0.0015125275, -0.008506775, 0.021377563, -0.0076904297, -0.02330017, -0.008590698, 0.003627777, 0.023880005, 0.0038013458, -0.019332886, 0.017501831, -0.030838013, 0.072021484, 0.0025787354, 0.025863647, -0.10546875, -0.07165527, -0.08648682, 0.022598267, -0.013587952, 0.0056419373, -0.004348755, 0.028549194, -0.017745972, -0.049438477, 0.0021781921, -0.0044517517, 0.061553955, 0.007019043, 0.057006836, -0.0030269623, -0.03161621, -0.010612488, 0.029418945, 0.011428833, 0.061767578, -0.049224854, -0.05709839, -0.07141113, -0.12042236, -0.042663574, 0.030914307, -0.016677856, 0.026824951, -0.004119873, 0.0037784576, 0.012207031, 0.021255493, -0.011245728, -0.02760315, 0.018585205, 0.009414673, 0.048950195, -0.0005531311, -0.008399963, -0.013328552, -0.028701782, -0.009155273, 0.0018615723, 0.08026123, -0.003440857, 0.03161621, 0.0012693405, -0.00022852421, -0.013595581, 0.06665039, -0.007217407, -0.060028076, 0.019607544, -0.009521484, -0.013191223, 0.053710938, -0.013389587, -0.008232117, 0.036102295, -0.022003174, -0.049194336, -0.02684021, -0.024383545, 0.03253174, 0.013824463, 0.019760132, 0.0026779175, -0.035491943, -0.004814148, -0.03817749, 0.017211914, 0.0016765594, -0.035064697, -0.0023002625, 0.00680542, -0.010925293, 0.06286621, 0.046142578, 0.01360321, -0.027694702, 0.0056152344, 0.0057525635, -0.066345215, 0.0501709, 0.018569946, -0.007160187, 0.008422852, -0.037994385, 0.007686615, -0.022415161, 0.05130005, -0.0050239563, 0.006919861, 0.0028972626, -0.022399902, 0.0039100647, 0.04598999, 0.04006958, -0.049346924, 0.039520264, 0.023529053, 0.0024585724, -0.0046424866, 0.011451721, -0.022064209, 0.0033226013, 0.009742737, -0.0032196045, -0.02482605, -0.0115737915, 0.05859375, 0.013183594, 0.028213501, 0.03390503, 0.01171875, 0.009819031, 0.0071372986, 0.057891846, 0.05041504, 0.033935547, 0.014831543, 0.040283203, 0.07055664, -0.0011034012, 0.012496948, -0.019866943, 0.024368286, -0.000644207, 0.03491211, 0.018234253, 0.023971558, -0.049957275, -0.02330017, -0.04220581, -0.027359009, -0.003993988, 0.008590698, 0.036834717, -0.021057129, 0.0004169941, -0.026809692, 0.013267517, -0.031341553, -0.04034424, 0.022857666, 0.016143799, -0.06262207, -0.012550354, 0.0067481995, 0.045959473, -0.0059165955, 0.038513184, 0.02722168, 0.011787415, -0.014907837, 0.012573242, 0.0014781952, 0.04840088, 0.048034668, 0.008010864, 0.01335907, 0.0021476746, 0.008880615, 0.06561279, 0.048858643, -0.022338867, 0.036224365, -0.013587952, 0.018630981, -0.005393982, 0.0038833618, 0.0003273487, 0.06097412, -0.007949829, 0.02166748, -0.022338867, 0.011672974, -0.03942871, 0.015823364, -0.0025501251, -0.021575928, -0.06185913, -0.05480957, -0.03125, -0.056549072, -0.08337402, -0.044769287, 0.076416016, -0.05886841, -0.02041626, 0.00060749054, -0.030532837, -0.031311035, 0.008987427, -0.0154800415, -0.024490356, 0.026245117, 0.026672363, 0.01360321, -0.035949707, 0.03253174, -0.010406494, 0.009757996, -0.0054779053, -0.031021118, -0.02407837, 0.02104187, -0.0021076202, -0.001335144, 0.020233154, -0.050109863, -0.011383057, -0.03186035, 0.00043845177, 0.010482788, -0.033355713, -0.0072669983, 0.038116455, -0.009643555, -0.022125244, 0.02810669, 0.057037354, 0.021347046, -0.013885498, 0.041503906, 0.04534912, -0.003484726, 0.02432251, 0.026855469, 0.004306793, -0.0657959, 0.011016846, -0.06524658, -0.023239136, -0.038635254, 0.0054893494, 0.04135132, -0.026031494, -0.032562256, -0.024612427, 0.000323534, 0.02053833, 0.008880615, 0.038238525, -0.0075149536, -0.02507019, 0.0070724487, 0.015808105, 0.018981934, -0.04660034, -0.009643555, 0.06274414, 0.016967773, -0.0065345764, -0.0024795532, 0.010795593, -0.00086021423, -0.010360718, -0.0040130615, -0.02078247, 0.016204834, 0.02255249, 0.00030207634, 0.0012111664, -0.015563965, -0.113464355, -0.018966675, 0.036834717, 0.010513306, -0.0014162064, 0.013191223, -0.05078125, 0.03967285, -0.012741089, -0.010139465, 0.041381836, 0.08483887, 0.00013506413, 0.004058838, 0.0062217712, -0.007572174, -0.00035643578, -0.010986328, -0.04168701, 0.033111572, -0.0132751465, -0.058654785, 0.013191223, -0.034240723, -0.045776367, -0.02784729, 0.007888794, 0.06591797, 0.031707764, 0.000029027462, 0.019607544, -0.015899658, 0.0289917, -0.031402588, -0.007789612, -0.021911621, -0.019500732, 0.004924774, -0.014831543, 0.042541504, 0.0011529922, -0.0046539307, -0.053466797, -0.0061073303, -0.0012750626, 0.035217285, 0.008232117, -0.041870117, 0.0011692047, -0.054382324, -0.030273438, -0.018356323, -0.014335632, -0.006000519, -0.013954163, 0.021972656, -0.0071029663, 0.055633545, 0.00021195412, 0.0021800995, 0.0044174194, -0.023864746, 0.0126953125, -0.022766113, -0.048797607, 0.025680542, 0.013916016, 0.019607544, 0.04800415, -0.01512146, -0.021240234, 0.0072250366, -0.026519775, -0.037475586, 0.022918701, -0.029510498, 0.0021858215, -0.04763794, -0.0025081635, 0.008934021, 0.008918762, -0.017456055, 0.023452759, 0.006099701, 0.0058784485, -0.03567505, 0.006717682, 0.00025606155, -0.07647705, 0.0018968582, -0.004257202, -0.0061531067, -0.040771484, -0.028640747, 0.022399902, -0.04107666, -0.040405273, 0.02468872, -0.011024475, 0.004043579, -0.0016775131, -0.04928589, -0.015083313, 0.048095703, -0.0075035095, 0.007080078, 0.04168701, -0.023132324, 0.0010528564, -0.02748108, -0.006008148, -0.0016813278, 0.059143066, -0.010169983, -0.01146698, 0.043914795, -0.029571533, 0.0016613007, 0.030761719, 0.019058228, -0.0155181885, 0.0030078888, 0.024276733, 0.07775879, -0.05340576, 0.06903076, 0.005882263, -0.041656494, -0.07409668, -0.008636475, 0.0021247864, -0.020828247, 0.035858154, 0.00356102, 0.03274536, 0.036315918, -0.01977539, 0.03591919, -0.018630981, -0.035491943, 0.031707764, 0.013687134, 0.01826477, 0.009124756, -0.0049324036, 0.03086853, 0.03262329, 0.004737854, 0.035461426, 0.03289795, -0.014060974, -0.037261963, 0.0040512085, 0.0284729, 0.001991272, -0.033996582, -0.066223145, -0.050598145, 0.011856079, -0.008621216, -0.00078582764, 0.03665161, 0.043792725, -0.0040512085, -0.03427124, -0.0050086975, -0.0032577515, -0.018676758, 0.011253357, -0.052764893, 0.03262329, -0.02456665, -0.06689453, -0.044036865, 0.0004887581, 0.0024871826, 0.024841309, -0.0017642975, 0.0059394836, 0.018508911, 0.0146484375, 0.008560181, 0.019821167, -0.027679443, -0.03564453, 0.03665161, -0.003736496, -0.041046143, 0.040985107, -0.0009460449, 0.011489868, -0.03265381, 0.0057640076, -0.017974854, -0.029754639, -0.036315918, 0.028701782, -0.011268616, 0.017303467, 0.010673523, 0.055877686, 0.027359009, 0.018447876, 0.019073486, 0.009346008, -0.02331543, -0.012321472, 0.01737976, 0.062072754, 0.0053710938, 0.02104187, 0.03378296, 0.010040283, -0.017578125, 0.005718231, 0.018920898, 0.022354126, 0.0021591187, -0.021881104, 0.01928711, -0.010231018, 0.00793457, 0.031677246, -0.004020691, 0.05908203, -0.037506104, 0.037231445, 0.025726318, 0.01096344, 0.031555176, -0.021148682, 0.034057617, -0.0069618225, 0.004634857, -0.06878662, -0.032806396, 0.0021381378, 0.021881104, -0.04385376, 0.0035495758, -0.006214142, -0.008934021, 0.025482178, 0.049194336, 0.051879883, 0.016342163, -0.013954163, 0.0006842613, 0.01574707, -0.035308838, -0.02545166, 0.008865356, 0.0069885254, 0.0039863586, -0.017150879, -0.04953003, -0.05041504, -0.021911621, -0.034606934, 0.0030784607, 0.024002075, -0.046142578, 0.024353027, 0.09112549, 0.018966675, 0.032806396, 0.01977539, 0.017608643, -0.0054740906, 0.02897644, 0.012641907, 0.02029419, 0.014129639, -0.040130615, 0.062194824, 0.020858765, 0.0062408447, -0.017654419, 0.04043579, -0.005264282, 0.013183594, -0.03930664, 0.033203125, 0.029220581, 0.015151978, 0.0043945312, -0.049316406, 0.025283813, -0.027923584, -0.012901306, -0.002817154, -0.016525269, -0.01574707, 0.022949219, -0.04031372, -0.018737793, 0.031204224, -0.024841309, -0.04083252, -0.04446411, 0.01171875, -0.015541077, 0.014328003, -0.002922058, 0.009109497, -0.044189453, 0.009651184, 0.036743164, -0.023880005, 0.012504578, -0.0066986084, 0.01007843, 0.023071289, 0.0018949509, -0.053771973, -0.011528015, -0.0107421875, -0.056396484, -0.048553467, 0.02494812, 0.027542114, -0.010765076, 0.023208618, -0.037017822, 0.019561768, 0.006801605, 0.025405884, 0.0035514832, 0.010276794, 0.042419434, 0.006587982, 0.011039734, 0.024963379, 0.015296936, 0.018859863, 0.020202637, -0.0050468445, -0.014137268, 0.0096206665, 0.02911377, 0.02949524, -0.05508423, -0.03189087, -0.017791748, 0.03213501, -0.004016876, -0.0009174347, 0.024536133, 0.028198242, 0.015289307, -0.00932312, -0.00010818243, 0.03567505, -0.023269653, 0.00020992756, -0.04156494, 0.01309967, -0.06451416, 0.022369385, -0.017837524, 0.0090408325, -0.025512695, -0.066467285, -0.020614624, 0.03237915, 0.03955078, 0.059326172, 0.077941895, -0.096069336, -0.032989502, -0.034057617, -0.00083971024, -0.032318115, 0.024475098, 0.009185791, 0.010093689, -0.028884888, -0.0035858154, 0.02330017, -0.040283203, 0.022216797, 0.0026435852, -0.008857727, 0.0018348694, -0.05307007, 0.0067977905, -0.007083893, 0.012290955, 0.008918762, 0.015899658, -0.021209717, 0.015426636, -0.028427124, 0.044189453, 0.0016670227, 0.064208984, 0.054138184, 0.022979736, 0.00016570091, -0.007751465, 0.0023975372, -0.035217285, 0.018341064, -0.05819702, -0.013496399, -0.07019043, 0.0004131794, -0.08538818, 0.024597168, 0.00009119511, 0.018493652, 0.049926758, 0.00017130375, 0.013198853, -0.0009822845, 0.05218506, 0.034423828, 0.060821533, -0.0025138855, 0.01725769, 0.0026493073, -0.035827637, 0.02470398, 0.024734497, -0.030258179, 0.027664185, -0.021575928, -0.035247803, 0.041015625, 0.009681702, 0.006175995, 0.031311035, -0.0046577454, -0.028335571, 0.052825928, 0.01374054, 0.052093506, 0.017105103, -0.0011425018, 0.033355713, -0.027618408, -0.022735596, 0.041625977, -0.042297363, 0.021865845, 0.06402588, -0.06359863, 0.008834839, -0.017059326, -0.025924683, 0.006099701, 0.02784729, 0.030715942, -0.05355835, -0.016418457, 0.014587402, 0.028808594, 0.017288208, 0.015853882, -0.041107178, -0.016036987, -0.004058838, 0.014785767, -0.004585266, 0.016662598, 0.020980835, 0.05429077, -0.03491211, 0.033111572, 0.0121154785, 0.02178955, -0.011856079, 0.032714844, -0.09387207, 0.06976318, 0.018051147, -0.044433594, 0.03262329, 0.013206482, -0.06945801, 0.0026359558, 0.019973755, 0.05984497, 0.053649902, 0.065979004, 0.01423645, -0.01109314, -0.0018453598, -0.050476074, 0.04949951, 0.014839172, -0.014190674, 0.028060913, -0.0071868896, -0.03375244, 0.066833496, -0.017501831, 0.061523438, -0.036956787, 0.017349243, -0.025253296, -0.003107071, 0.02633667, -0.06274414, 0.010696411, -0.0340271, -0.018951416, -0.008270264, -0.026443481, -0.04736328, -0.022109985, -0.010147095, 0.032714844, 0.014633179, -0.019958496, -0.030059814, -0.0037822723, -0.05230713, -0.011314392, -0.036468506, 0.02810669, -0.0035190582, 0.011695862, 0.026779175, -0.00365448, -0.027862549, -0.051849365, -0.028625488, 0.023132324, 0.0028381348, -0.052368164, 0.005554199, 0.0058898926, -0.022872925, -0.017608643, -0.037750244, 0.0038146973, -0.02583313, -0.043640137, 0.037322998, -0.01777649, -0.06341553, -0.029449463, -0.02961731, 0.02444458, 0.027877808, -0.00969696, -0.018493652, 0.021820068, -0.03869629, -0.026062012, -0.0042533875, 0.03894043, -0.014152527, -0.027114868, -0.011512756, 0.060424805, 0.03024292, -0.052581787, -0.018692017, 0.022018433, 0.04812622, -0.008720398, 0.045898438, 0.049713135, 0.037231445, -0.016418457, 0.013008118, -0.0039405823, -0.06011963, -0.03173828, -0.030853271, 0.016189575, 0.029708862, -0.0009803772, -0.023391724, 0.026443481, 0.0058059692, -0.021240234, 0.0256958, 0.01876831, 0.00092458725, 0.019042969, 0.025253296, -0.024139404, -0.0423584, 0.009048462, 0.02519226, -0.009925842, 0.0154418945, 0.012199402, -0.005924225, -0.0054244995, 0.056854248, -0.019622803, -0.017852783, -0.015426636, 0.012260437, -0.012588501, 0.04928589, -0.043762207, -0.011390686, -0.00605011, -0.01184082, -0.024932861, 0.0021762848, 0.05706787, -0.035186768, -0.009635925, -0.0041656494, -0.016586304, -0.0030670166, -0.028167725, 0.06048584, -0.028549194, -0.032348633, -0.011581421, -0.046661377, -0.0060539246, 0.021987915, 0.023147583, -0.05984497, 0.008712769, -0.0006670952, 0.05886841, 0.0009822845 ], "summary": [ 0.03866577, 0.0046806335, 0.014709473, 0.00016975403, -0.012008667, -0.01272583, -0.0046958923, -0.053771973, 0.029220581, 0.011367798, -0.06225586, 0.029571533, -0.007858276, -0.011940002, -0.010414124, -0.038970947, -0.024154663, 0.06262207, 0.019134521, -0.020950317, 0.014579773, -0.041259766, -0.005695343, 0.0046691895, 0.013870239, -0.019546509, -0.008392334, 0.05307007, 0.021896362, 0.059417725, 0.012580872, -0.060668945, -0.018478394, 0.04208374, -0.0067367554, 0.021850586, -0.0020942688, 0.03955078, 0.036376953, -0.0034236908, 0.032806396, -0.024429321, 0.053497314, -0.043884277, 0.0041885376, 0.05355835, 0.0055007935, -0.038879395, 0.02029419, -0.03845215, -0.014419556, 0.025680542, -0.002670288, -0.047088623, -0.020339966, -0.025512695, -0.0418396, 0.031280518, 0.012680054, 0.014907837, 0.0078086853, -0.008666992, 0.013893127, 0.0051002502, -0.010261536, -0.003452301, 0.07696533, 0.009719849, 0.021835327, -0.030471802, -0.014671326, 0.046203613, -0.019378662, -0.0037841797, -0.038024902, 0.018661499, 0.02394104, -0.0045433044, 0.008522034, 0.0061416626, -0.024780273, 0.024780273, -0.0418396, -0.07067871, 0.0012140274, -0.041748047, -0.032287598, 0.004924774, -0.005077362, 0.0027065277, -0.0036029816, -0.018051147, -0.03152466, 0.07366943, 0.02381897, -0.0028839111, 0.061340332, 0.04296875, 0.0076026917, -0.03173828, -0.004802704, -0.030075073, -0.05517578, -0.009681702, 0.0068206787, 0.06335449, -0.009605408, 0.02130127, 0.04473877, 0.024780273, 0.030883789, -0.019210815, 0.0209198, 0.031051636, 0.0036239624, -0.014945984, -0.010185242, 0.05657959, -0.01461792, 0.08581543, -0.006198883, -0.0047912598, -0.01663208, -0.01676941, 0.030929565, -0.010978699, -0.03945923, 0.037078857, -0.052581787, 0.08843994, -0.014778137, -0.012519836, -0.014007568, 0.023849487, -0.028869629, -0.041107178, 0.014465332, 0.009719849, 0.015419006, -0.016937256, 0.035095215, -0.015129089, -0.0031547546, 0.041015625, 0.053466797, -0.021896362, 0.02470398, 0.045898438, 0.009529114, -0.0060043335, 0.06677246, 0.0018224716, 0.056549072, -0.027618408, -0.0395813, -0.0927124, -0.011428833, -0.05908203, 0.038269043, -0.049591064, 0.02810669, -0.018356323, -0.0035877228, 0.045013428, -0.0052261353, 0.015808105, 0.019332886, 0.008087158, 0.0033817291, -0.02130127, -0.002855301, -0.013534546, -0.019882202, -0.021987915, 0.0027809143, 0.033813477, 0.05935669, 0.01058197, 0.010986328, 0.034088135, -0.010025024, -0.03656006, 0.080200195, -0.039642334, -0.039520264, 0.06903076, -0.0014743805, 0.030029297, 0.008918762, -0.011817932, 0.025131226, 0.028442383, 0.0031661987, -0.024658203, -0.024429321, -0.033447266, 0.034332275, 0.02708435, -0.018569946, 0.008911133, 0.00005441904, 0.027770996, -0.022232056, -0.016174316, -0.08441162, 0.013633728, -0.02671814, 0.060272217, -0.001572609, 0.044921875, -0.002527237, -0.029220581, -0.015014648, 0.03656006, 0.013885498, -0.06329346, 0.019332886, -0.036193848, -0.024856567, -0.020584106, -0.050567627, 0.035125732, -0.05331421, 0.033935547, 0.008323669, 0.016494751, -0.026428223, 0.02696228, 0.01914978, 0.044677734, 0.0026130676, -0.023345947, 0.03878784, 0.056549072, -0.0015287399, -0.009010315, 0.019058228, -0.035125732, 0.013832092, 0.013214111, 0.030792236, -0.011146545, -0.015945435, 0.035125732, -0.00749588, -0.00012946129, 0.031097412, 0.01651001, 0.00031208992, 0.031051636, 0.024276733, 0.023880005, 0.016860962, 0.007259369, 0.034179688, 0.029815674, 0.0143585205, 0.027130127, -0.03717041, 0.015579224, -0.009918213, 0.016952515, 0.0041046143, 0.009437561, -0.06573486, 0.008613586, -0.018692017, -0.013877869, 0.016067505, -0.012168884, 0.017410278, -0.014137268, -0.013633728, -0.0146865845, 0.015197754, -0.056243896, -0.047332764, 0.044891357, 0.018310547, -0.031799316, 0.0063819885, 0.005130768, 0.041381836, -0.014785767, 0.04626465, -0.0034694672, 0.0036125183, -0.018417358, 0.029769897, 0.009025574, 0.00982666, 0.045318604, 0.0027503967, 0.040802002, -0.021743774, -0.008308411, -0.012641907, 0.0057907104, -0.007873535, -0.032440186, 0.02130127, 0.035705566, -0.03503418, 0.0045204163, -0.00065279007, 0.0703125, 0.033935547, -0.004085541, -0.0044517517, 0.0032043457, -0.028549194, -0.024383545, 0.029342651, 0.020980835, -0.015464783, -0.029266357, -0.028717041, 0.012863159, -0.081848145, -0.042053223, 0.10076904, -0.0137786865, 0.00881958, 0.008262634, -0.020202637, -0.055267334, 0.047576904, -0.009971619, -0.015426636, 0.005317688, -0.0052452087, -0.0076675415, -0.014785767, 0.060821533, -0.005634308, 0.01763916, 0.010475159, -0.027572632, 0.0047683716, 0.040893555, 0.038726807, 0.05053711, -0.0056762695, -0.05404663, -0.022399902, -0.0035152435, -0.020126343, -0.00066185, 0.008346558, -0.0025596619, 0.008384705, -0.006816864, 0.012077332, 0.0287323, 0.036834717, 0.0009613037, -0.023620605, 0.031951904, 0.037384033, -0.035003662, 0.055725098, 0.036712646, 0.022949219, -0.08502197, -0.025543213, -0.04373169, -0.0038719177, -0.05203247, 0.011375427, 0.028671265, -0.011360168, 0.018722534, -0.03942871, -0.002916336, -0.0056381226, 0.019821167, 0.1381836, 0.034820557, 0.024353027, 0.08483887, 0.040527344, 0.006626129, 0.012420654, -0.07904053, 0.0022354126, 0.03253174, 0.015945435, 0.021102905, 0.012001038, -0.024353027, 0.0059890747, 0.047576904, 0.019882202, 0.0064582825, 0.004627228, -0.027679443, 0.015563965, 0.009468079, -0.0647583, -0.012741089, -0.0072898865, 0.016693115, 0.01676941, -0.008476257, -0.017288208, 0.041412354, -0.0029621124, -0.007484436, -0.0006594658, 0.038726807, 0.041534424, -0.029449463, 0.01776123, -0.0051574707, 0.02684021, -0.041748047, 0.047821045, 0.00630188, -0.018417358, -0.026275635, 0.014663696, 0.037902832, -0.014778137, -0.008430481, 0.039031982, 0.041229248, -0.010749817, -0.05606079, 0.030685425, 0.019241333, 0.01574707, -0.011054993, -0.019317627, -0.06225586, -0.024261475, -0.025436401, -0.02418518, -0.009613037, -0.034240723, -0.009727478, -0.046661377, 0.015449524, -0.012634277, 0.033233643, 0.01374054, -0.03326416, 0.0049209595, -0.08123779, -0.046875, -0.033203125, -0.014923096, 0.01902771, -0.0028877258, 0.025161743, 0.0118255615, 0.029327393, -0.032562256, 0.017593384, 0.034484863, -0.014854431, -0.0060577393, 0.0012483597, 0.014717102, 0.012710571, 0.0049743652, -0.015449524, 0.057525635, 0.00043463707, -0.03213501, 0.032806396, -0.013748169, -0.017501831, -0.012512207, -0.042633057, -0.009033203, -0.05670166, 0.052520752, 0.005065918, 0.047180176, -0.051239014, -0.009788513, 0.01763916, -0.0013046265, -0.03656006, -0.040618896, 0.012557983, -0.049865723, -0.0011920929, -0.0059814453, -0.017242432, -0.028762817, -0.0030841827, 0.01007843, 0.0031967163, 0.008934021, -0.018539429, -0.018249512, 0.07458496, 0.0041503906, -0.042144775, -0.0029449463, -0.024856567, 0.0049743652, -0.016494751, -0.021362305, 0.012145996, 0.029220581, 0.018493652, 0.0033550262, -0.03717041, 0.036865234, -0.015029907, 0.01600647, 0.046539307, -0.019058228, -0.050933838, 0.045837402, 0.051818848, -0.055633545, -0.013679504, 0.06774902, 0.09753418, -0.056549072, 0.016036987, 0.041503906, -0.019165039, -0.058410645, -0.0074424744, -0.0018396378, -0.015472412, -0.01574707, 0.027618408, -0.020141602, 0.013519287, 0.03881836, -0.0362854, -0.023406982, -0.06555176, 0.019607544, 0.056427002, 0.008613586, -0.01234436, -0.01651001, 0.058532715, 0.023208618, -0.025863647, -0.007713318, -0.009170532, -0.024215698, -0.025100708, -0.0093688965, 0.0031738281, -0.028244019, -0.035095215, -0.01335907, -0.028762817, -0.0042495728, 0.0040283203, 0.011833191, 0.0058174133, 0.01927185, 0.021392822, -0.017990112, -0.024536133, 0.015350342, 0.009132385, -0.02217102, -0.054718018, 0.0158844, -0.03086853, -0.047790527, -0.024612427, -0.05078125, -0.07196045, -0.0042381287, 0.021118164, -0.02218628, 0.002199173, 0.004562378, 0.018630981, -0.022125244, -0.00819397, -0.01272583, -0.046203613, -0.0012483597, 0.0008983612, 0.021224976, -0.0061569214, 0.033050537, 0.0059318542, 0.014831543, -0.031402588, -0.053375244, -0.061431885, 0.0074005127, 0.010620117, 0.0033187866, 0.07873535, 0.08404541, 0.01802063, 0.030792236, 0.0015554428, 0.015716553, -0.0126571655, -0.016052246, -0.013809204, 0.023651123, 0.034942627, 0.01108551, 0.047973633, -0.010437012, -0.014205933, -0.025390625, 0.013809204, -0.0038013458, 0.006465912, 0.005317688, 0.003232956, 0.0519104, 0.009208679, 0.04348755, 0.0006465912, 0.010536194, 0.009391785, -0.009277344, 0.030258179, 0.045318604, 0.011253357, -0.026275635, 0.01146698, -0.02067566, -0.0059013367, -0.070495605, -0.014633179, -0.006542206, 0.0073165894, -0.019805908, -0.018600464, -0.003036499, -0.057037354, 0.026306152, 0.03262329, 0.028259277, 0.020874023, 0.012031555, 0.011100769, 0.031051636, -0.013671875, -0.0074310303, -0.012901306, -0.021560669, -0.019241333, 0.0030708313, -0.06665039, 0.04385376, -0.052642822, -0.03149414, 0.043670654, -0.017852783, -0.004470825, -0.034942627, 0.020141602, -0.005001068, -0.0132369995, 0.044921875, -0.006351471, -0.0155181885, 0.018630981, -0.021408081, 0.013420105, -0.014541626, -0.0082473755, 0.040374756, 0.001115799, -0.004508972, -0.0020599365, 0.02444458, -0.005355835, 0.0011634827, 0.0044784546, 0.005596161, 0.006839752, 0.004295349, -0.0209198, 0.0015115738, 0.04751587, 0.03164673, -0.02558899, -0.016235352, 0.01852417, -0.06036377, -0.043029785, -0.009750366, -0.04196167, -0.0030155182, -0.028686523, -0.02885437, 0.0050621033, -0.047027588, 0.0033931732, 0.023956299, 0.0068588257, 0.010261536, -0.0064468384, -0.032165527, 0.013374329, 0.027893066, 0.003824234, -0.014450073, -0.0019483566, -0.025039673, 0.013198853, -0.009010315, 0.0046081543, -0.013046265, -0.02961731, -0.0079574585, -0.014152527, -0.01940918, 0.030761719, 0.0119018555, -0.02796936, 0.051849365, -0.022033691, 0.010177612, 0.008804321, 0.033935547, 0.028900146, -0.012145996, -0.020751953, 0.03152466, 0.051086426, 0.027450562, -0.0047569275, -0.018035889, -0.026290894, 0.008163452, 0.015655518, 0.027069092, -0.034362793, -0.05706787, -0.008987427, 0.037322998, 0.039154053, 0.016677856, -0.011398315, -0.0018634796, 0.009643555, 0.009780884, -0.012908936, 0.036499023, -0.0056533813, -0.00983429, -0.0035991669, 0.011169434, -0.026107788, 0.013877869, 0.026611328, -0.008728027, -0.01864624, -0.060333252, 0.004699707, 0.020690918, 0.047790527, 0.009269714, 0.039245605, -0.07885742, -0.024291992, -0.005847931, 0.0057029724, -0.0019569397, 0.013061523, -0.0013895035, 0.012245178, -0.029769897, 0.01663208, -0.0041542053, 0.02255249, 0.009857178, -0.018112183, -0.026168823, 0.026504517, -0.01727295, 0.014907837, 0.019638062, 0.0619812, 0.046966553, -0.022659302, 0.034851074, -0.02861023, 0.010185242, -0.0030498505, -0.0019836426, 0.018707275, 0.048919678, 0.021911621, -0.01965332, -0.005874634, -0.020217896, -0.020217896, 0.041656494, -0.002866745, 0.00039744377, -0.021972656, -0.01638794, -0.04196167, 0.04473877, 0.010635376, -0.01335907, 0.101135254, -0.007499695, -0.00016665459, 0.00077295303, -0.041046143, 0.056884766, 0.012908936, 0.016082764, 0.02507019, -0.024017334, -0.050476074, 0.01852417, 0.033111572, -0.0014648438, 0.004463196, -0.018432617, -0.0017375946, -0.00037956238, -0.012413025, -0.0052108765, -0.006969452, 0.019226074, -0.029937744, 0.038879395, 0.028839111, 0.08026123, -0.01675415, -0.03363037, 0.038513184, -0.0050468445, -0.036224365, 0.013824463, -0.03945923, 0.029251099, 0.010604858, 0.000035583973, 0.0129470825, 0.0050621033, -0.028152466, 0.032470703, -0.044921875, 0.08746338, -0.09222412, -0.06323242, 0.040771484, 0.03668213, -0.03491211, -0.017654419, -0.048858643, -0.00028657913, 0.009391785, -0.0053482056, -0.020202637, -0.046936035, 0.011940002, 0.04147339, -0.019897461, 0.07141113, -0.018829346, 0.039154053, -0.04043579, 0.023513794, -0.10546875, 0.03353882, 0.01625061, -0.029296875, 0.031204224, 0.019744873, -0.041046143, 0.029220581, -0.029708862, 0.07519531, 0.08123779, 0.06201172, -0.046081543, 0.010375977, 0.059783936, -0.016296387, 0.06604004, -0.025314331, -0.025238037, -0.016311646, 0.019058228, 0.023712158, 0.022399902, -0.006046295, -0.027862549, 0.0038394928, 0.013656616, -0.030288696, -0.019760132, -0.0038795471, -0.028762817, 0.019500732, -0.03656006, -0.013954163, 0.0023956299, -0.02545166, -0.026473999, 0.026855469, -0.03439331, -0.018692017, 0.027801514, -0.014556885, 0.018859863, -0.0021362305, -0.036193848, 0.011390686, 0.006668091, 0.07507324, 0.0050811768, 0.0014152527, 0.06341553, 0.002298355, -0.03366089, -0.047668457, -0.027175903, 0.025817871, -0.0073280334, -0.044433594, -0.017578125, -0.015106201, -0.024261475, -0.029724121, -0.0011224747, 0.011520386, -0.0115737915, -0.009918213, 0.008514404, 0.00422287, -0.043395996, -0.015205383, -0.012916565, -0.023513794, 0.0018844604, 0.020004272, 0.008293152, 0.04675293, -0.0029945374, -0.061920166, -0.029129028, -0.042388916, 0.019058228, -0.020721436, -0.023757935, 0.043762207, 0.020767212, -0.0413208, 0.023712158, 0.032318115, 0.06774902, 0.010620117, -0.024536133, 0.03552246, -0.017242432, -0.04257202, 0.012939453, -0.018463135, -0.017089844, 0.016159058, -0.01096344, 0.018585205, 0.017425537, -0.020584106, -0.0048103333, 0.016708374, -0.00063467026, -0.045135498, 0.021591187, 0.040405273, -0.021881104, 0.02545166, 0.02293396, -0.05456543, -0.050750732, 0.047851562, -0.008758545, -0.000015854836, 0.005924225, 0.01033783, -0.024993896, -0.009284973, 0.033233643, 0.014183044, 0.050872803, -0.045715332, -0.018432617, 0.018447876, -0.02394104, -0.0015125275, 0.0070877075, 0.027923584, -0.02217102, -0.040222168, -0.029525757, 0.06088257, -0.05758667, -0.05807495, 0.023330688, -0.004634857, -0.07714844, -0.019760132, 0.040374756, 0.0014152527, -0.041931152, 0.038085938, -0.048461914, 0.013031006, -0.0054626465, -0.020324707, -0.042816162, 0.016342163, 0.02796936, -0.010917664, 0.022918701 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2105.08450v2
Implementation and Evaluation of a Multivariate Abstraction-Based, Interval-Based Dynamic Time-Warping Method as a Similarity Measure for Longitudinal Medical Records
Yuval Shahar, Matan Lion
cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SC, I.2.6
We extended dynamic time warping (DTW) into interval-based dynamic time warping (iDTW), including (A) interval-based representation (iRep): [1] abstracting raw, time-stamped data into interval-based abstractions, [2] comparison-period scoping, [3] partitioning abstract intervals into a given temporal granularity; (B) interval-based matching (iMatch): matching partitioned, abstract-concepts records, using a modified DTW. Using domain knowledge, we abstracted the raw data of medical records, for up to three concepts out of four or five relevant concepts, into two interval types: State abstractions (e.g. LOW, HIGH) and Gradient abstractions (e.g. INCREASING, DECREASING). We created all uni-dimensional (State or Gradient) or multi-dimensional (State and Gradient) abstraction combinations. Tasks: Classifying 161 oncology patients records as autologous or allogenic bone-marrow transplantation; classifying 125 hepatitis patients records as B or C hepatitis; predicting micro- or macro-albuminuria in the next year for 151 Type 2 diabetes patients. We used a k-Nearest-Neighbors majority, k = an odd number from 1 to SQRT(N), N = set size. 75,936 10-fold cross-validation experiments were performed: 33,600 (Oncology), 28,800 (Hepatitis), 13,536 (Diabetes). Measures: Area Under the Curve (AUC), optimal Youden's Index. Paired t-tests compared result vectors for equivalent configurations other than a tested variable, to determine a significant mean accuracy difference (P<0.05). Mean classification and prediction using abstractions was significantly better than using only raw time-stamped data. In each domain, at least one abstraction combination led to a significantly better mean performance than raw data. Increasing feature number and using Multi-dimensional abstractions enhanced performance. Unlike when using raw data, optimal mean performance was often reached with k=5, using abstractions.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2105.08450v2
"2021-08-26T10:59:13"
"2021-05-18T11:41:42"
{ "title": [ 0.0018911362, 0.019958496, -0.05014038, -0.057403564, 0.042022705, -0.01411438, -0.0035190582, -0.012786865, -0.013465881, 0.023239136, -0.006767273, 0.02041626, 0.0053710938, -0.0362854, -0.013504028, -0.010253906, 0.025787354, 0.03237915, 0.027618408, -0.016860962, -0.013290405, -0.015083313, 0.055725098, 0.049560547, 0.03161621, 0.021911621, -0.035064697, 0.022644043, -0.010749817, -0.011116028, 0.0071868896, -0.022094727, -0.0046577454, 0.04788208, -0.01374054, -0.03564453, -0.038635254, 0.044647217, -0.006298065, 0.029708862, 0.02204895, -0.018218994, 0.036376953, -0.06939697, -0.005092621, 0.06713867, -0.053619385, -0.008369446, -0.01725769, 0.026306152, 0.021652222, 0.012001038, 0.030975342, 0.0345459, 0.0020256042, -0.020202637, -0.029632568, 0.013893127, 0.03390503, -0.0018377304, -0.0005283356, -0.031921387, 0.022644043, 0.006465912, -0.022720337, -0.031951904, -0.0051498413, 0.026855469, 0.04977417, 0.009742737, -0.0035800934, 0.043701172, -0.005962372, -0.0113220215, -0.028259277, 0.031219482, 0.016296387, 0.023361206, 0.021453857, -0.017028809, -0.025756836, -0.03665161, 0.010955811, -0.037109375, 0.022659302, -0.020080566, -0.02835083, 0.014816284, -0.03152466, -0.05078125, -0.016464233, -0.010231018, -0.04626465, 0.0104904175, 0.0028705597, -0.04525757, -0.016052246, 0.018463135, -0.020812988, -0.04510498, -0.033599854, 0.02368164, -0.09631348, -0.009223938, -0.0011768341, 0.018829346, 0.024459839, 0.0015182495, 0.014160156, 0.002904892, -0.021011353, 0.068115234, 0.010002136, -0.015045166, -0.000813961, 0.019058228, 0.00894928, 0.012626648, 0.016860962, 0.013885498, -0.026443481, -0.009925842, -0.01184082, 0.008590698, 0.012908936, -0.024246216, -0.0206604, 0.007499695, -0.009407043, 0.049316406, -0.0011062622, 0.01902771, -0.07702637, -0.052703857, -0.04864502, 0.017349243, 0.023910522, -0.023101807, -0.023406982, -0.024353027, 0.010871887, 0.0113220215, -0.0040283203, -0.025344849, -0.004211426, 0.04736328, 0.031799316, -0.029129028, -0.03262329, -0.05154419, -0.010322571, -0.043121338, 0.033203125, -0.019714355, -0.070739746, -0.029006958, -0.10784912, 0.028884888, 0.0031013489, -0.0076675415, -0.015670776, -0.021697998, -0.011680603, -0.0024757385, 0.010665894, 0.019821167, -0.0041503906, 0.031036377, 0.023269653, 0.04348755, 0.0040245056, 0.002784729, -0.0053596497, 0.051757812, 0.032409668, 0.041259766, -0.007282257, -0.036193848, 0.03765869, 0.00061941147, -0.026321411, -0.0287323, -0.050598145, 0.027420044, -0.025924683, -0.019485474, 0.002796173, 0.027816772, 0.011177063, 0.013259888, -0.035858154, 0.030548096, -0.045043945, 0.0012111664, -0.018432617, 0.006549835, -0.023727417, 0.020721436, -0.030731201, -0.01737976, -0.0059547424, 0.030227661, -0.044067383, 0.03353882, -0.026062012, -0.009460449, -0.014877319, -0.00068187714, 0.0055732727, 0.03353882, 0.02482605, 0.0020828247, -0.047332764, 0.052215576, 0.0049743652, -0.048583984, 0.055908203, -0.020889282, 0.0050582886, -0.009429932, -0.034332275, 0.024963379, -0.03387451, 0.027664185, -0.04159546, -0.015838623, -0.0011043549, -0.028335571, -0.0027446747, 0.0000046491623, 0.07141113, -0.0059547424, -0.014472961, -0.051757812, -0.060424805, -0.0018777847, -0.039916992, -0.0131073, -0.006401062, 0.036987305, 0.0058937073, -0.00881958, 0.012306213, 0.056243896, -0.009361267, -0.004497528, 0.04360962, 0.0052223206, -0.03326416, 0.0068511963, 0.06008911, 0.033447266, 0.03805542, 0.023727417, -0.04473877, 0.060943604, 0.008476257, 0.023132324, -0.009513855, 0.01991272, -0.009727478, -0.015899658, -0.0045204163, -0.012237549, 0.02116394, -0.0079574585, 0.00982666, 0.019561768, -0.018951416, 0.0008459091, 0.031677246, -0.012397766, 0.029785156, -0.010101318, -0.062927246, 0.0043563843, 0.012779236, 0.011230469, 0.034942627, -0.030517578, -0.0140686035, 0.035614014, -0.0042381287, -0.019210815, -0.016738892, -0.028549194, 0.013130188, -0.00049066544, -0.00046253204, -0.0066566467, 0.013908386, 0.040283203, -0.0023784637, 0.01914978, 0.03857422, -0.020217896, -0.027694702, 0.038024902, -0.009552002, 0.03050232, -0.058410645, 0.043701172, 0.04522705, -0.012969971, 0.0017442703, 0.017608643, -0.0046043396, 0.014923096, -0.015464783, -0.044067383, 0.011405945, 0.03439331, 0.018981934, -0.009887695, 0.0019760132, -0.02407837, 0.006160736, -0.01826477, -0.061187744, -0.08721924, 0.0013208389, -0.05795288, -0.038116455, -0.02999878, -0.008018494, -0.0006952286, -0.033111572, -0.0154953, 0.023620605, 0.0033569336, 0.035583496, -0.0049972534, -0.070007324, -0.042114258, 0.02154541, 0.004421234, -0.006893158, 0.033996582, -0.017318726, -0.004886627, -0.017120361, 0.018463135, 0.002456665, -0.025863647, 0.005012512, -0.016204834, 0.03567505, 0.030807495, -0.05529785, 0.018218994, 0.011894226, -0.046722412, -0.0007047653, -0.0017261505, 0.055755615, -0.0046920776, -0.007835388, 0.06463623, 0.064697266, 0.006034851, 0.048065186, 0.026306152, 0.014228821, -0.016052246, -0.048095703, -0.061920166, 0.02079773, -0.01940918, -0.013328552, 0.0072631836, -0.061920166, -0.023666382, -0.051635742, 0.0006260872, 0.025512695, 0.036590576, 0.0057373047, -0.023147583, -0.036193848, -0.008224487, -0.008872986, 0.006038666, -0.021881104, 0.031204224, 0.07281494, 0.0104904175, 0.04458618, 0.03250122, 0.02571106, -0.028762817, -0.011833191, -0.031051636, -0.035247803, -0.03781128, 0.021453857, 0.022003174, 0.0056495667, 0.035736084, -0.044311523, -0.01574707, 0.050750732, 0.017959595, -0.011451721, 0.022079468, -0.06286621, 0.022506714, -0.004310608, -0.0017414093, 0.025024414, 0.06311035, -0.01979065, 0.033294678, -0.029129028, 0.04763794, -0.0017232895, -0.005645752, -0.060028076, 0.02293396, -0.0546875, -0.01586914, 0.050445557, -0.04043579, -0.013442993, -0.0012903214, -0.013198853, 0.0814209, 0.019958496, 0.0063972473, 0.03768921, -0.01612854, 0.032470703, -0.020187378, -0.0135650635, -0.09893799, 0.002292633, -0.042144775, -0.04159546, 0.03591919, -0.070251465, 0.03656006, 0.028717041, 0.014060974, 0.013389587, 0.03274536, -0.004447937, -0.0209198, -0.0030155182, 0.035247803, 0.003396988, 0.0045280457, -0.040374756, 0.005996704, -0.025985718, 0.011299133, -0.019622803, -0.029708862, 0.033477783, 0.02079773, -0.035186768, -0.0048103333, -0.0027580261, -0.028182983, 0.0033664703, -0.0007572174, 0.017608643, 0.026428223, -0.014770508, -0.0031318665, 0.010307312, -0.027908325, -0.014816284, 0.023773193, 0.043304443, 0.0043792725, -0.013893127, -0.002483368, 0.0262146, 0.024658203, -0.036865234, -0.030181885, 0.0014343262, 0.026138306, -0.06726074, -0.099853516, -0.055114746, 0.017074585, -0.13342285, -0.064208984, 0.03466797, -0.07141113, -0.031280518, -0.052520752, 0.01134491, -0.025238037, 0.000028312206, -0.009391785, -0.005970001, 0.026046753, -0.016723633, -0.09515381, -0.0064888, 0.0713501, 0.043548584, 0.068847656, -0.026260376, -0.010658264, 0.027694702, -0.01574707, 0.036621094, -0.03414917, 0.038269043, -0.0037250519, 0.053588867, 0.036224365, -0.008781433, 0.011009216, 0.010169983, 0.02619934, 0.00033855438, 0.007118225, 0.04019165, 0.026306152, -0.009536743, 0.053771973, -0.019256592, -0.008712769, -0.053955078, -0.031951904, -0.018356323, -0.009292603, 0.003501892, 0.0061912537, 0.015930176, -0.008049011, 0.04434204, 0.012825012, 0.0057373047, -0.02748108, 0.016021729, 0.008483887, 0.0044517517, 0.026168823, 0.0057754517, 0.0345459, 0.005580902, 0.0024375916, -0.0064315796, 0.049224854, -0.019348145, 0.0077667236, -0.024734497, 0.011985779, -0.025253296, -0.04034424, -0.052612305, 0.004173279, 0.0059890747, -0.002565384, 0.0027046204, -0.009803772, 0.013412476, 0.025283813, -0.078430176, 0.023284912, 0.0028266907, -0.01612854, 0.0340271, -0.012619019, 0.030426025, -0.021530151, -0.04937744, -0.040100098, -0.04547119, -0.0026626587, 0.049346924, 0.020965576, -0.0423584, -0.017410278, 0.038757324, 0.0635376, 0.051361084, -0.009925842, -0.06842041, -0.07110596, -0.0018033981, 0.0041885376, 0.006374359, 0.036254883, 0.000022292137, -0.0012483597, -0.0118637085, -0.028961182, -0.020950317, 0.008613586, -0.0074806213, -0.030792236, 0.036102295, -0.0011539459, 0.065979004, 0.011108398, 0.0028190613, -0.025482178, 0.006580353, -0.038513184, 0.014923096, -0.04144287, -0.00793457, -0.020645142, 0.007987976, 0.03579712, 0.020187378, -0.056121826, 0.020706177, 0.018630981, 0.04196167, 0.02960205, 0.044403076, -0.01737976, -0.026657104, -0.030761719, -0.0027542114, -0.003835678, 0.029067993, -0.025848389, 0.023468018, 0.05380249, 0.028915405, 0.03060913, -0.03262329, 0.01411438, -0.024765015, -0.006664276, -0.070007324, -0.07244873, -0.01966858, 0.076293945, -0.011436462, -0.026763916, 0.02104187, 0.023849487, 0.03366089, 0.02381897, 0.0132369995, 0.0063209534, -0.034942627, 0.02545166, 0.015220642, -0.02456665, -0.034240723, -0.035186768, 0.011955261, 0.020202637, -0.0022277832, 0.0018758774, -0.04345703, -0.014282227, -0.008232117, -0.050354004, 0.022964478, -0.05029297, 0.020950317, 0.037994385, -0.05166626, 0.049957275, -0.0076446533, 0.031341553, 0.049102783, 0.041503906, 0.035888672, -0.017166138, 0.017410278, 0.0013160706, 0.043151855, -0.009490967, 0.005592346, 0.004699707, 0.029663086, -0.011978149, 0.027053833, -0.038635254, 0.0073165894, 0.034301758, -0.0033245087, -0.004436493, -0.04623413, 0.033569336, -0.0054359436, -0.037841797, 0.058013916, -0.013710022, -0.012931824, -0.021347046, 0.0047416687, -0.0446167, 0.052734375, 0.047668457, -0.05319214, -0.06738281, -0.00497818, -0.008117676, 0.0062179565, -0.03475952, 0.016738892, -0.0435791, 0.052825928, 0.009483337, -0.068847656, -0.016693115, -0.010025024, 0.0013914108, 0.005630493, 0.028625488, -0.021270752, 0.00093746185, -0.009597778, -0.039916992, -0.029876709, 0.020355225, -0.0042762756, 0.025817871, -0.021453857, -0.008895874, -0.0138168335, -0.020477295, 0.02470398, -0.00014698505, -0.05670166, 0.017181396, -0.004611969, 0.009765625, -0.01499939, -0.016021729, 0.034973145, -0.028503418, -0.025253296, -0.073791504, 0.020965576, -0.0101623535, 0.016616821, -0.029327393, -0.058532715, -0.0027999878, 0.015792847, -0.00029850006, -0.017196655, 0.009857178, 0.013687134, 0.017456055, -0.045715332, -0.03466797, 0.021331787, -0.019973755, -0.0637207, -0.030014038, 0.029708862, -0.015991211, 0.025222778, -0.01399231, -0.05279541, 0.005214691, -0.033172607, -0.015975952, 0.0104522705, 0.022781372, -0.0121154785, 0.011390686, -0.062347412, -0.0060806274, -0.014587402, -0.019241333, -0.02772522, -0.0051460266, 0.019515991, 0.020233154, 0.01777649, -0.023529053, 0.019241333, -0.04864502, 0.020050049, -0.04421997, 0.0018615723, -0.020645142, 0.010803223, 0.017868042, -0.014884949, -0.0023765564, -0.0056114197, 0.01878357, -0.014328003, 0.027557373, -0.037719727, 0.044769287, 0.018737793, 0.01701355, 0.013946533, 0.01411438, 0.0014133453, 0.008544922, -0.005378723, -0.03729248, -0.03466797, -0.04360962, 0.0016546249, -0.04348755, 0.008529663, -0.040161133, 0.052886963, -0.008300781, 0.031921387, -0.008323669, -0.009109497, 0.023254395, 0.015838623, 0.004310608, -0.018188477, 0.046936035, 0.015701294, 0.015037537, -0.024291992, 0.018920898, -0.011192322, 0.011505127, -0.010505676, 0.03265381, 0.008918762, -0.0024414062, -0.017654419, 0.008811951, 0.01260376, -0.019836426, 0.024642944, -0.00844574, -0.0021800995, -0.006565094, 0.0033416748, 0.03643799, 0.011749268, 0.03366089, -0.01171875, 0.0011968613, 0.009414673, -0.004398346, -0.0049057007, 0.05618286, -0.07946777, 0.017913818, -0.005126953, -0.038360596, -0.026123047, 0.0069465637, 0.026992798, -0.087890625, -0.0463562, 0.015991211, 0.022415161, 0.0062217712, -0.02357483, -0.037353516, 0.014198303, 0.054718018, 0.012756348, 0.000890255, -0.0118255615, -0.003993988, 0.012794495, 0.041625977, 0.00034427643, 0.020324707, 0.026016235, 0.036132812, 0.031021118, -0.0027942657, -0.026062012, -0.029800415, -0.027252197, -0.007217407, -0.012382507, -0.0015382767, -0.03555298, 0.032043457, 0.011367798, 0.030212402, 0.045440674, 0.00472641, -0.0119018555, 0.013633728, -0.04827881, 0.0066108704, 0.006362915, -0.022262573, -0.031555176, 0.019805908, 0.0048942566, 0.011108398, 0.027069092, 0.011444092, -0.07952881, -0.017684937, -0.017608643, 0.04598999, 0.020339966, -0.024475098, -0.09661865, -0.011428833, -0.056274414, -0.0033473969, 0.018218994, 0.0070533752, -0.043029785, -0.018157959, 0.032440186, -0.007949829, -0.019851685, -0.016784668, -0.01210022, -0.02986145, 0.006526947, -0.017501831, 0.049865723, 0.0023345947, -0.01966858, -0.029571533, 0.00592041, 0.025222778, 0.05041504, 0.00071048737, 0.06652832, -0.06591797, 0.0012817383, -0.007019043, 0.006526947, -0.031829834, -0.04534912, -0.0011920929, 0.019882202, -0.03475952, -0.055145264, -0.010223389, -0.033691406, -0.00894928, -0.019729614, -0.04888916, -0.009590149, 0.04107666, 0.01084137, 0.019378662, -0.0009279251, 0.0028533936, -0.027572632, 0.012763977, 0.02810669, -0.008666992, -0.055999756, -0.008415222, 0.045166016, 0.050628662, 0.0027236938, -0.0061187744, 0.07397461, 0.01675415, -0.032318115, 0.083618164, -0.018920898, 0.034423828, 0.08630371, 0.091918945, 0.033325195, -0.076293945, -0.022613525, -0.019348145, 0.019439697, 0.029876709, 0.009963989, -0.033294678, 0.037719727, -0.005214691, -0.0154418945, 0.01235199, -0.034484863, -0.025344849, 0.02017212, -0.0013303757, 0.008590698, -0.028549194, 0.040985107, 0.013931274, -0.0002603531, 0.0048294067, -0.00459671, -0.006526947, -0.023468018, 0.010971069, -0.015579224, 0.077819824, 0.002281189, -0.019638062, 0.044525146, -0.039642334, 0.026885986, 0.06109619, -0.026443481, -0.018997192, 0.0011901855, -0.04119873, 0.05029297, -0.064208984, -0.0031032562, 0.004699707, -0.019317627, 0.055480957, -0.0053253174, 0.030075073, -0.026062012, 0.007797241, -0.019851685, -0.040893555, 0.0048179626, 0.021209717, 0.011367798, -0.023513794, -0.04244995, -0.042510986, 0.026550293, -0.023086548 ], "summary": [ 0.06506348, 0.016433716, -0.03970337, -0.04840088, 0.030349731, -0.034729004, -0.010467529, -0.0231781, 0.019104004, 0.01991272, -0.036987305, -0.00038290024, 0.01360321, -0.025787354, -0.025665283, -0.03744507, 0.023498535, 0.041748047, 0.06652832, -0.017501831, 0.008705139, -0.0030136108, 0.058380127, 0.0084991455, 0.024734497, 0.008453369, 0.0042648315, 0.0068740845, -0.005393982, 0.0030593872, 0.013427734, -0.0015878677, -0.027572632, 0.03274536, 0.018310547, -0.016067505, -0.018066406, 0.022476196, 0.031280518, -0.0034103394, 0.016159058, -0.028884888, 0.055664062, -0.062469482, -0.015159607, 0.06112671, -0.03466797, 0.00016355515, 0.00894928, 0.022033691, -0.011726379, 0.02217102, -0.0075302124, 0.031311035, 0.0034637451, -0.006652832, -0.060394287, -0.00053215027, 0.025024414, 0.00730896, 0.016540527, -0.043029785, 0.01687622, 0.006931305, -0.016586304, -0.045837402, 0.04916382, 0.041931152, 0.057037354, -0.019363403, -0.006893158, 0.081604004, -0.0112838745, -0.033294678, -0.02319336, 0.057891846, -0.0047035217, 0.01889038, 0.009536743, -0.013076782, -0.013793945, -0.037994385, 0.0390625, -0.029342651, 0.026657104, 0.014060974, -0.012184143, -0.0098724365, -0.017715454, -0.006095886, -0.010612488, -0.03491211, -0.052215576, 0.03616333, 0.042633057, -0.06112671, -0.006511688, -0.00026583672, -0.038848877, -0.006477356, 0.008560181, 0.00020325184, -0.027404785, -0.003917694, 0.025817871, 0.04385376, 0.010818481, 0.011505127, 0.029724121, 0.008644104, -0.01084137, 0.031097412, 0.00868988, -0.024230957, 0.00004464388, 0.012863159, -0.027770996, 0.03744507, 0.0031280518, 0.016036987, -0.0002863407, 0.021072388, -0.011917114, -0.009887695, 0.02407837, 0.008483887, -0.02859497, -0.007858276, -0.028762817, 0.03970337, -0.008460999, 0.023269653, -0.016708374, -0.019866943, -0.04864502, -0.007320404, 0.056671143, -0.029693604, -0.0011348724, -0.031677246, 0.036987305, 0.0025348663, -0.016113281, -0.003955841, -0.027908325, 0.08355713, 0.0024604797, -0.019958496, -0.010498047, -0.109558105, 0.03970337, -0.099243164, 0.040161133, -0.025726318, -0.060302734, -0.06524658, -0.07299805, 0.00806427, 0.026519775, -0.026016235, 0.029144287, -0.017547607, -0.038146973, 0.023483276, -0.009819031, 0.013954163, -0.009132385, 0.009811401, 0.029678345, 0.02003479, 0.03189087, -0.022399902, -0.0013475418, 0.016204834, 0.013977051, 0.017196655, -0.012069702, -0.05105591, 0.029708862, -0.010543823, -0.02923584, -0.022460938, -0.05267334, 0.031219482, -0.020401001, 0.021575928, 0.009124756, 0.03753662, 0.014663696, 0.0119018555, -0.009803772, 0.016677856, -0.031951904, 0.0020046234, 0.021728516, -0.0104904175, -0.038513184, -0.0023860931, -0.008811951, -0.047668457, 0.044769287, 0.047912598, -0.025939941, 0.021759033, -0.03982544, 0.037597656, -0.0072021484, 0.015335083, -0.009300232, 0.01687622, 0.005142212, -0.062683105, 0.0049819946, 0.034423828, -0.008171082, -0.057922363, 0.025512695, -0.04046631, -0.0115737915, -0.037841797, -0.0059814453, 0.026931763, -0.03265381, 0.046051025, -0.0017700195, -0.047576904, 0.023849487, -0.026611328, 0.052734375, -0.019546509, 0.064697266, -0.0178833, -0.03982544, -0.035980225, -0.0574646, -0.00856781, -0.027252197, 0.0044898987, 0.0088272095, 0.029159546, 0.005630493, 0.00497818, -0.02053833, 0.023345947, 0.013175964, -0.004211426, -0.004173279, 0.023117065, -0.03112793, 0.004055023, 0.037963867, 0.022033691, 0.024261475, 0.0002477169, -0.04510498, 0.04550171, -0.021316528, 0.028930664, -0.04598999, 0.019439697, -0.012191772, 0.008056641, 0.0026302338, -0.00856781, 0.055480957, -0.032104492, 0.032958984, 0.010887146, -0.012908936, -0.020553589, 0.0110321045, -0.035064697, 0.013313293, -0.034454346, -0.045776367, -0.025604248, 0.005264282, 0.023132324, 0.01953125, -0.038482666, -0.019500732, 0.024108887, 0.017715454, -0.019699097, 0.0052452087, -0.036224365, 0.012702942, -0.033813477, 0.027450562, 0.008651733, 0.01134491, 0.021881104, 0.016983032, 0.03366089, 0.024124146, -0.024902344, -0.07281494, 0.025115967, -0.0064086914, -0.012817383, -0.028701782, 0.050964355, 0.021194458, -0.013214111, 0.0001950264, -0.014968872, -0.01928711, 0.037078857, 0.019546509, -0.06536865, 0.039489746, 0.042999268, 0.031280518, 0.03186035, 0.014930725, -0.011528015, 0.0076789856, 0.037597656, -0.02027893, -0.025253296, 0.024124146, -0.020889282, -0.01638794, -0.022918701, -0.0044021606, -0.022781372, -0.03515625, -0.008781433, -0.02772522, 0.015327454, 0.0009293556, -0.007762909, -0.038909912, -0.017654419, -0.00024485588, 0.01689148, 0.0031204224, 0.034118652, -0.0047569275, -0.014526367, 0.0029182434, 0.032043457, 0.019195557, -0.0047302246, -0.031341553, 0.009719849, 0.0335083, -0.004550934, 0.013282776, 0.017929077, -0.018569946, -0.0065193176, -0.029159546, 0.036621094, 0.022079468, -0.020629883, 0.012969971, 0.08270264, 0.03604126, 0.011260986, 0.072753906, 0.04058838, 0.04434204, -0.074523926, -0.08520508, -0.056762695, 0.024429321, -0.023391724, -0.0047302246, 0.011108398, 0.014953613, 0.0038795471, -0.06713867, -0.018234253, -0.028762817, -0.015556335, 0.024017334, -0.017852783, -0.0435791, 0.00066947937, 0.015777588, 0.023895264, 0.0093688965, 0.03503418, 0.0803833, 0.009338379, 0.045166016, 0.03375244, 0.06640625, -0.011711121, 0.002368927, -0.035461426, 0.037506104, -0.025512695, -0.010238647, 0.007801056, -0.038208008, -0.011734009, -0.019760132, 0.0054740906, 0.05230713, 0.00655365, -0.005332947, 0.027954102, -0.021759033, 0.02748108, 0.025238037, -0.0073051453, 0.0211792, 0.02748108, 0.008842468, 0.006706238, -0.032287598, 0.037261963, -0.024139404, -0.01121521, 0.02960205, 0.004547119, 0.004924774, -0.036010742, 0.02204895, 0.0030288696, 0.0155181885, 0.016586304, -0.0037994385, 0.039245605, 0.008338928, 0.012512207, -0.009284973, -0.0045166016, 0.044799805, -0.037475586, -0.0107421875, -0.08392334, -0.017852783, -0.045288086, -0.04623413, 0.02722168, -0.067993164, 0.003414154, -0.021575928, -0.00111866, 0.022232056, 0.024673462, -0.0121536255, 0.0024108887, -0.011657715, -0.002784729, 0.048065186, 0.011581421, -0.045440674, -0.0046958923, 0.04284668, 0.007587433, -0.032318115, -0.02444458, 0.01335144, 0.018127441, 0.04638672, -0.039611816, -0.0713501, -0.015617371, 0.00374794, -0.01146698, 0.010063171, 0.009117126, 0.011512756, 0.014205933, -0.0031661987, 0.0000062584877, 0.010391235, 0.011367798, 0.032806396, 0.0047416687, -0.05230713, -0.025009155, 0.074645996, 0.016174316, -0.021240234, -0.07531738, 0.0038032532, 0.028305054, -0.043060303, -0.056121826, -0.035858154, 0.006629944, -0.08709717, -0.07714844, 0.010513306, 0.037353516, 0.017227173, -0.0036029816, 0.03857422, 0.009407043, -0.010887146, 0.019058228, -0.03338623, 0.061828613, -0.031433105, -0.097839355, 0.050109863, -0.0043525696, 0.062683105, 0.07501221, -0.08001709, 0.0022449493, 0.051605225, 0.011184692, 0.034942627, -0.0791626, 0.020065308, -0.016296387, 0.027496338, 0.010139465, -0.017608643, 0.004886627, -0.0026741028, 0.032348633, -0.047912598, -0.008895874, 0.035705566, 0.044555664, -0.0006990433, 0.016998291, -0.004623413, -0.032226562, 0.002368927, -0.011665344, -0.028778076, -0.024368286, 0.017227173, 0.020080566, 0.008895874, -0.006828308, 0.032348633, 0.015068054, 0.002248764, -0.049072266, 0.01612854, 0.03164673, 0.025802612, 0.025299072, -0.018310547, 0.037902832, -0.012329102, 0.034423828, -0.000579834, 0.0546875, -0.002149582, 0.005130768, 0.003753662, 0.017044067, -0.058563232, -0.04876709, -0.019607544, 0.068115234, 0.013397217, -0.00491333, -0.012741089, -0.018463135, 0.01235199, -0.016159058, -0.053253174, 0.045898438, -0.022232056, -0.0070762634, 0.012680054, -0.020126343, -0.0044174194, -0.030929565, -0.054901123, -0.027648926, -0.03265381, -0.026855469, -0.0041389465, 0.0021953583, -0.048675537, -0.0085372925, -0.01348114, 0.056518555, 0.0357666, 0.031097412, -0.059173584, -0.016708374, 0.03161621, 0.02305603, -0.0019054413, 0.019638062, 0.009475708, 0.016143799, -0.024917603, -0.027832031, -0.0031909943, 0.0026798248, -0.013824463, -0.01828003, 0.034942627, -0.0116119385, 0.03665161, -0.00069093704, -0.00032687187, 0.0008172989, 0.01121521, -0.013244629, -0.0063552856, 0.014678955, 0.00085163116, 0.0076560974, 0.003917694, 0.03050232, -0.024612427, -0.047851562, 0.00995636, 0.002046585, 0.023254395, 0.03540039, 0.03866577, 0.032836914, 0.014320374, -0.064208984, 0.00049734116, 0.0027694702, -0.016464233, 0.010871887, -0.0026435852, 0.02607727, 0.01524353, 0.0043640137, -0.045928955, 0.012191772, -0.014854431, -0.005207062, -0.028762817, -0.054534912, 0.0018434525, 0.03161621, 0.009277344, -0.01927185, -0.0071907043, 0.028701782, 0.026870728, 0.0055618286, -0.012031555, 0.0001552105, 0.026641846, 0.010787964, 0.010429382, 0.01651001, -0.011222839, -0.046966553, 0.028717041, 0.0076828003, -0.018859863, -0.0053367615, -0.002588272, -0.015090942, -0.0256958, -0.021011353, 0.002981186, -0.03768921, -0.041107178, 0.0063667297, -0.047454834, 0.04006958, 0.034454346, 0.0102005005, 0.0390625, 0.03186035, 0.005558014, -0.009864807, -0.011726379, 0.027496338, 0.051361084, -0.027801514, 0.024307251, -0.009178162, 0.0024490356, -0.011161804, 0.020385742, -0.045196533, -0.010307312, -0.04348755, -0.03640747, -0.012878418, 0.008323669, 0.048187256, 0.002872467, -0.02166748, 0.042175293, -0.01574707, -0.028549194, -0.031188965, 0.021499634, -0.0418396, 0.023330688, 0.026565552, -0.015823364, -0.0546875, -0.036621094, -0.036743164, 0.014282227, -0.020935059, 0.014160156, -0.02909851, 0.017837524, -0.005203247, -0.07727051, -0.0024986267, 0.035614014, 0.032196045, -0.0029659271, -0.025131226, -0.03857422, -0.0037631989, -0.040405273, -0.005619049, 0.024765015, 0.019592285, 0.02696228, 0.033477783, 0.0041275024, 0.010299683, 0.017288208, -0.03765869, 0.027450562, -0.034118652, -0.020690918, 0.017944336, -0.009895325, -0.01586914, 0.0017404556, -0.005794525, 0.02067566, -0.0056877136, -0.010734558, -0.051971436, 0.03552246, 0.00052690506, 0.031036377, -0.045166016, -0.070373535, -0.001077652, 0.021850586, 0.012466431, 0.04421997, 0.055755615, 0.018981934, 0.029205322, -0.011230469, 0.039916992, -0.0119018555, -0.012863159, -0.027191162, -0.014045715, 0.056640625, 0.03878784, 0.041931152, -0.052215576, -0.05316162, -0.0058784485, -0.005241394, 0.010414124, 0.0035686493, 0.023849487, -0.023483276, 0.039154053, -0.03439331, -0.020370483, -0.013183594, -0.020324707, -0.0440979, 0.008583069, -0.023284912, 0.00068616867, 0.050811768, 0.010513306, 0.0026836395, -0.018692017, 0.017532349, -0.015304565, -0.029266357, 0.044189453, 0.01210022, 0.011940002, -0.026275635, 0.037872314, 0.030578613, 0.024261475, -0.014205933, 0.005302429, 0.010414124, 0.02734375, -0.0090408325, -0.03338623, -0.035217285, -0.016967773, -0.023452759, -0.0021400452, -0.01890564, -0.022094727, -0.032440186, -0.016693115, -0.0017375946, 0.014205933, 0.012626648, -0.00091838837, 0.06402588, 0.0011777878, -0.03161621, 0.035858154, -0.0074653625, 0.018936157, 0.027770996, -0.040039062, -0.010284424, -0.008956909, 0.043060303, 0.0027065277, -0.027923584, 0.052520752, -0.020202637, -0.010505676, 0.020645142, 0.050750732, 0.0038414001, 0.031585693, -0.0053215027, -0.029052734, 0.009857178, -0.055603027, 0.033203125, -0.016067505, 0.049713135, 0.025009155, 0.014320374, 0.02078247, 0.028335571, 0.041625977, -0.026870728, 0.022018433, 0.04663086, -0.03186035, 0.036346436, 0.03479004, -0.036102295, 0.00061273575, 0.013809204, -0.02659607, 0.07421875, 0.011444092, 0.014312744, -0.074523926, -0.059173584, 0.015930176, 0.027313232, 0.052368164, -0.045440674, -0.036132812, -0.006198883, 0.02407837, -0.01763916, -0.0024547577, -0.0068511963, 0.014671326, -0.024856567, 0.046722412, 0.007972717, -0.005264282, 0.05722046, 0.021392822, 0.043182373, -0.036224365, 0.021560669, 0.010406494, -0.036346436, 0.009254456, 0.008552551, -0.005680084, -0.0057029724, 0.048675537, -0.013595581, 0.055114746, 0.060424805, -0.033081055, 0.027252197, 0.021209717, -0.01360321, -0.008506775, -0.009422302, -0.004245758, -0.049591064, 0.01335907, 0.020492554, -0.019714355, 0.04321289, -0.022857666, -0.07147217, -0.010398865, -0.013458252, 0.011413574, -0.020645142, 0.015312195, -0.051208496, -0.04736328, -0.06915283, 0.008354187, 0.03793335, -0.0118255615, -0.038360596, -0.042907715, 0.0026836395, -0.050750732, 0.0017223358, 0.035827637, -0.005504608, -0.046539307, -0.00869751, -0.014015198, 0.054016113, -0.001203537, -0.01902771, 0.0049934387, 0.020996094, 0.013450623, -0.013259888, -0.01701355, 0.05041504, -0.016342163, 0.014854431, -0.038879395, -0.020767212, -0.021820068, 0.0073890686, 0.09124756, 0.016906738, -0.0018157959, -0.028198242, -0.0021686554, 0.008270264, 0.06185913, -0.0010261536, -0.0126953125, -0.016723633, -0.012557983, 0.010650635, 0.006614685, 0.021514893, 0.021835327, -0.048065186, 0.0054626465, -0.024841309, -0.013023376, -0.04940796, -0.0048980713, 0.043640137, 0.039489746, -0.0018348694, 0.045562744, 0.0670166, 0.0317688, -0.010101318, 0.02444458, -0.03955078, -0.008872986, 0.06713867, 0.067993164, 0.02468872, -0.030410767, -0.031234741, -0.015991211, 0.0054855347, -0.008239746, -0.007171631, -0.049102783, 0.031799316, -0.010696411, -0.02406311, 0.014518738, 0.011306763, -0.03111267, 0.009513855, -0.026260376, -0.026611328, -0.07354736, 0.023361206, -0.028579712, -0.0070991516, -0.035705566, -0.0013370514, 0.00046038628, -0.06524658, -0.0065956116, -0.02720642, 0.076416016, -0.018447876, -0.038879395, 0.03161621, -0.056152344, 0.029953003, 0.07098389, -0.032562256, -0.042785645, 0.00642395, -0.05114746, 0.0637207, -0.09741211, -0.0007724762, -0.031585693, -0.018844604, 0.09350586, 0.010108948, 0.038024902, -0.0077056885, -0.019317627, 0.052612305, -0.07159424, 0.034118652, 0.000289917, 0.07537842, -0.0070724487, 0.022781372, -0.019714355, 0.011672974, 0.01473999 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2105.10488v4
Understanding the Performance of Knowledge Graph Embeddings in Drug Discovery
Stephen Bonner, Ian P Barrett, Cheng Ye, Rowan Swiers, Ola Engkvist, Charles Tapley Hoyt, William L Hamilton
q-bio.BM, cs.AI, cs.LG
Knowledge Graphs (KG) and associated Knowledge Graph Embedding (KGE) models have recently begun to be explored in the context of drug discovery and have the potential to assist in key challenges such as target identification. In the drug discovery domain, KGs can be employed as part of a process which can result in lab-based experiments being performed, or impact on other decisions, incurring significant time and financial costs and most importantly, ultimately influencing patient healthcare. For KGE models to have impact in this domain, a better understanding of not only of performance, but also the various factors which determine it, is required. In this study we investigate, over the course of many thousands of experiments, the predictive performance of five KGE models on two public drug discovery-oriented KGs. Our goal is not to focus on the best overall model or configuration, instead we take a deeper look at how performance can be affected by changes in the training setup, choice of hyperparameters, model parameter initialisation seed and different splits of the datasets. Our results highlight that these factors have significant impact on performance and can even affect the ranking of models. Indeed these factors should be reported along with model architectures to ensure complete reproducibility and fair comparisons of future work, and we argue this is critical for the acceptance of use, and impact of KGEs in a biomedical setting.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2105.10488v4
"2022-05-23T10:55:45"
"2021-05-17T11:39:54"
{ "title": [ -0.02935791, -0.014945984, -0.046813965, -0.048675537, -0.015144348, -0.0076293945, -0.04788208, 0.0107421875, -0.00756073, 0.016067505, -0.03475952, 0.014724731, -0.022979736, -0.010734558, -0.034484863, -0.015022278, -0.0007224083, 0.04611206, 0.011245728, -0.032287598, -0.0071029663, -0.032958984, 0.07128906, 0.036376953, 0.03552246, -0.06951904, -0.04309082, 0.020248413, -0.034423828, -0.058410645, -0.008506775, 0.024841309, 0.042907715, 0.029220581, -0.015029907, 0.024307251, -0.03866577, 0.014373779, 0.011222839, 0.003232956, 0.020202637, -0.013824463, 0.0234375, -0.051696777, -0.0061187744, 0.057495117, -0.061950684, -0.03564453, -0.020706177, 0.01675415, 0.02520752, 0.004711151, -0.0079193115, 0.03125, 0.012870789, -0.014320374, -0.022232056, -0.036254883, 0.038360596, 0.06427002, 0.03074646, -0.047302246, 0.011512756, -0.017684937, -0.03250122, -0.03781128, -0.0030994415, 0.035583496, 0.06335449, -0.016021729, -0.01789856, 0.048583984, 0.018478394, -0.004383087, -0.06488037, -0.016326904, 0.061279297, 0.0033798218, 0.01121521, -0.053131104, -0.026809692, -0.031051636, -0.04006958, 0.0023040771, -0.005458832, -0.00030517578, -0.016448975, -0.013183594, 0.002161026, -0.034362793, 0.011497498, -0.005809784, 0.013259888, 0.04473877, -0.01386261, -0.019515991, -0.019897461, -0.0077590942, 0.012191772, -0.025283813, 0.03024292, -0.0070877075, -0.015823364, -0.0045661926, 0.0043525696, 0.023422241, -0.011131287, -0.014755249, 0.00075531006, 0.02319336, -0.025054932, 0.0008378029, 0.007183075, -0.0060043335, 0.014190674, -0.00447464, -0.021881104, 0.036071777, 0.010826111, 0.0110321045, -0.0038414001, -0.01890564, -0.012435913, 0.016296387, 0.031097412, 0.010536194, -0.03366089, 0.015037537, -0.050872803, 0.036376953, 0.016418457, 0.04159546, -0.07519531, -0.0501709, -0.05947876, 0.045532227, -0.010025024, 0.020462036, -0.005645752, 0.016723633, -0.023529053, -0.029937744, 0.027648926, 0.0054244995, 0.0022907257, 0.013755798, 0.05291748, -0.01828003, -0.046020508, -0.041168213, -0.042144775, 0.038726807, 0.03793335, -0.03253174, -0.06463623, -0.029205322, -0.13684082, -0.012313843, 0.021606445, -0.002286911, 0.02758789, 0.019638062, -0.00051641464, 0.021499634, 0.03756714, -0.009017944, -0.03250122, 0.024917603, 0.005290985, 0.026626587, -0.03527832, 0.03100586, -0.0028305054, -0.029312134, -0.018066406, -0.008041382, 0.04714966, -0.024963379, 0.013633728, 0.009361267, 0.0037345886, -0.023635864, -0.006828308, 0.028411865, -0.06604004, -0.0019683838, 0.00029683113, -0.0063323975, 0.044525146, -0.014373779, -0.020202637, 0.041290283, -0.014678955, -0.060424805, -0.031402588, -0.028213501, 0.026931763, 0.006286621, 0.0011396408, 0.009429932, -0.04812622, -0.008552551, -0.020309448, 0.029891968, 0.021743774, -0.039886475, 0.005672455, -0.005970001, -0.0068206787, 0.06652832, 0.038513184, 0.029800415, -0.038330078, 0.0132369995, 0.0027236938, -0.03845215, 0.021575928, 0.013290405, 0.005622864, 0.008720398, 0.0036697388, -0.0062408447, 0.033996582, 0.02784729, 0.00390625, 0.0018138885, 0.008872986, -0.03704834, 0.007587433, 0.011878967, 0.04272461, -0.023727417, 0.021621704, -0.0057678223, -0.014274597, -0.020050049, -0.016418457, -0.018676758, -0.00025200844, 0.007068634, -0.00982666, -0.021514893, -0.020767212, 0.016098022, 0.05493164, 0.014427185, 0.0013513565, 0.015640259, 0.002084732, 0.057281494, 0.06188965, 0.03326416, 0.008834839, 0.004421234, -0.026290894, 0.060302734, 0.0128479, 0.03125, -0.021987915, 0.025772095, -0.015007019, 0.05065918, 0.034332275, 0.009536743, -0.038513184, -0.0063972473, -0.012611389, 0.016937256, 0.023345947, -0.018173218, 0.01576233, -0.006603241, 0.0069885254, 0.0011587143, 0.0024871826, -0.04574585, -0.022659302, 0.025817871, 0.0061950684, -0.052703857, -0.003929138, 0.029815674, 0.053222656, 0.0062942505, 0.024520874, 0.03616333, 0.00035071373, -0.020874023, -0.019500732, -0.028915405, 0.024765015, 0.05114746, -0.0009098053, 0.0012569427, 0.018814087, 0.006259918, 0.0793457, 0.06036377, -0.027389526, 0.05859375, -0.046325684, 0.035736084, 0.050048828, -0.03250122, 0.003929138, 0.04586792, 0.029418945, 0.010353088, -0.03302002, 0.008338928, -0.036865234, -0.01663208, 0.010902405, -0.029800415, -0.04650879, -0.058776855, -0.028030396, -0.05065918, -0.09851074, -0.05105591, 0.06585693, -0.009178162, -0.01977539, -0.010322571, 0.0124053955, -0.02268982, -0.01828003, -0.024795532, -0.017700195, 0.028549194, 0.010391235, -0.0026283264, -0.055603027, -0.020996094, -0.010154724, 0.0059776306, -0.018249512, 0.043548584, -0.015960693, 0.0069618225, 0.013214111, -0.02470398, 0.02027893, -0.040863037, 0.025634766, -0.06488037, 0.0146865845, 0.009140015, 0.008743286, 0.019195557, 0.0017461777, -0.005203247, -0.0077934265, 0.025299072, 0.08746338, -0.054718018, -0.042785645, 0.06530762, 0.05142212, 0.008979797, 0.026947021, 0.0440979, 0.020965576, -0.07556152, -0.059814453, -0.048980713, -0.005634308, -0.0051193237, 0.01612854, 0.058898926, -0.060302734, -0.009483337, -0.038391113, -0.0033245087, 0.032348633, 0.0126571655, 0.013954163, -0.022277832, -0.016204834, -0.00042176247, -0.0015859604, -0.0014190674, -0.009277344, -0.021759033, 0.076171875, 0.009017944, -0.0016613007, 0.025405884, 0.048431396, 0.009315491, 0.001332283, -0.0019226074, 0.016784668, 0.01222229, -0.0021362305, 0.008712769, -0.02154541, -0.012901306, -0.084106445, 0.009567261, 0.04446411, 0.004348755, -0.028656006, 0.028320312, -0.062286377, 0.008705139, -0.005935669, -0.023147583, 0.022964478, 0.050201416, 0.0054512024, 0.034088135, -0.010375977, 0.028274536, -0.004058838, -0.024536133, -0.07513428, 0.027328491, -0.006893158, -0.049102783, -0.015464783, -0.011894226, -0.054626465, -0.024353027, 0.00059604645, 0.024520874, 0.019683838, 0.0024356842, 0.0035324097, -0.005596161, -0.0047569275, -0.025985718, -0.022003174, -0.027572632, -0.012641907, 0.004398346, -0.03137207, 0.048431396, -0.020553589, 0.0011177063, -0.02116394, -0.016342163, 0.013122559, 0.031219482, -0.0019369125, -0.036254883, -0.01461792, 0.015098572, -0.011230469, 0.016281128, -0.005832672, -0.0066375732, -0.011154175, 0.011619568, -0.024017334, 0.042816162, 0.039123535, 0.0051841736, -0.039611816, -0.04348755, -0.004917145, -0.016571045, -0.096069336, -0.003194809, 0.016571045, 0.016311646, 0.0045661926, -0.013061523, -0.028396606, 0.012275696, -0.031982422, 0.016296387, 0.016708374, -0.015472412, -0.0069999695, 0.001496315, -0.0039138794, 0.011528015, -0.029785156, -0.025039673, 0.0031642914, 0.0040359497, -0.0011901855, -0.0925293, -0.002023697, -0.006259918, -0.13989258, -0.056793213, 0.020843506, -0.043945312, -0.022216797, -0.07324219, 0.026397705, -0.03552246, -0.03555298, 0.0046653748, -0.03086853, 0.037322998, 0.00052928925, -0.0836792, 0.012641907, 0.056884766, 0.016525269, 0.030975342, 0.046051025, -0.016204834, -0.0037937164, -0.0181427, 0.0209198, 0.006717682, 0.058410645, 0.008613586, -0.0046463013, 0.024475098, -0.016555786, 0.007789612, 0.02835083, -0.028869629, 0.009674072, 0.031143188, 0.042907715, 0.028274536, -0.03744507, 0.041229248, 0.03277588, -0.024887085, -0.061706543, -0.003578186, -0.002286911, 0.002708435, 0.0026874542, -0.025924683, 0.015716553, 0.014556885, 0.023391724, 0.06222534, -0.023971558, -0.034973145, 0.02949524, -0.005908966, 0.01965332, 0.0132751465, -0.0028839111, 0.027130127, 0.010360718, 0.014053345, -0.020751953, 0.027862549, -0.02748108, -0.026916504, -0.00818634, 0.015594482, -0.025115967, -0.021270752, -0.055145264, -0.026611328, -0.012710571, 0.016448975, -0.017425537, 0.01322937, 0.033447266, 0.005569458, -0.04034424, 0.0069122314, 0.048736572, -0.009765625, -0.006088257, -0.068359375, 0.04598999, -0.020645142, -0.054656982, -0.037872314, -0.024719238, -0.029190063, 0.059539795, 0.0033226013, -0.031280518, -0.007896423, 0.034576416, 0.08276367, 0.033325195, -0.00029039383, -0.041870117, 0.012016296, -0.021636963, -0.0050315857, 0.011329651, -0.0048332214, -0.00076913834, -0.012939453, 0.0010890961, -0.0135269165, -0.035369873, -0.058013916, 0.021713257, 0.006038666, 0.047668457, 0.03375244, 0.04849243, 0.032196045, 0.0014276505, 0.02960205, 0.0049819946, -0.018447876, -0.04434204, 0.030044556, 0.036010742, 0.016693115, 0.018341064, 0.06237793, 0.010215759, 0.016616821, 0.0017852783, -0.015945435, 0.035308838, -0.0065956116, -0.0026435852, 0.014022827, -0.045898438, -0.023651123, 0.003660202, 0.00843811, 0.060546875, -0.031677246, 0.052490234, -0.051452637, -0.010192871, 0.0035705566, -0.0077552795, 0.0069732666, -0.011146545, 0.018325806, -0.056640625, -0.06744385, -0.0035972595, 0.06994629, -0.022155762, 0.0050468445, -0.009254456, 0.020996094, 0.033569336, 0.050445557, 0.05859375, -0.02281189, -0.0079422, -0.00026345253, 0.007965088, -0.011154175, -0.045715332, 0.020339966, 0.015602112, 0.018692017, -0.029678345, -0.0012340546, -0.07989502, 0.00020086765, -0.008644104, -0.034729004, 0.045959473, -0.091674805, 0.022888184, 0.06750488, -0.0063438416, 0.029373169, -0.019256592, 0.03164673, 0.035003662, 0.030212402, 0.03048706, 0.004562378, 0.026412964, -0.04559326, 0.026000977, 0.016906738, 0.016479492, 0.005558014, 0.026260376, -0.0053215027, 0.008049011, -0.030639648, 0.026275635, 0.0039138794, 0.009239197, 0.00016593933, -0.048217773, 0.0055160522, 0.0033779144, 0.0022029877, -0.0029468536, -0.031051636, 0.014427185, 0.056152344, -0.028686523, 0.02935791, 0.045288086, 0.0033607483, -0.04019165, -0.07720947, -0.012062073, -0.024993896, 0.001748085, -0.011726379, 0.026153564, -0.045562744, 0.05041504, 0.023101807, -0.045898438, -0.0064315796, 0.012992859, 0.015602112, 0.05657959, 0.009979248, -0.017868042, 0.0027694702, -0.0022296906, -0.06298828, -0.033233643, -0.0029029846, -0.0016756058, 0.008613586, 0.003660202, -0.034698486, 0.0121154785, 0.0034370422, 0.030395508, -0.005897522, -0.006969452, 0.038726807, 0.0034637451, -0.0038814545, 0.018615723, 0.020233154, 0.010246277, 0.013694763, 0.00289917, -0.041625977, 0.046325684, -0.0036373138, 0.028640747, -0.012741089, -0.050323486, 0.0126953125, 0.025146484, 0.00894928, 0.029754639, 0.034423828, 0.035980225, 0.026931763, -0.0037403107, 0.038024902, 0.04663086, -0.05734253, -0.010292053, -0.015991211, 0.01890564, -0.039886475, 0.061462402, -0.00012552738, 0.0059013367, -0.051330566, -0.072631836, -0.036254883, 0.009262085, 0.021530151, 0.040740967, 0.020370483, -0.020706177, 0.06890869, -0.05117798, -0.015098572, -0.038635254, 0.026535034, -0.007461548, -0.021316528, 0.02041626, -0.004257202, 0.004562378, -0.033966064, 0.027862549, 0.02319336, 0.00894165, 0.0003168583, -0.044677734, -0.003698349, -0.030090332, -0.016815186, 0.0113220215, 0.053710938, -0.05517578, 0.022598267, -0.017410278, 0.05895996, 0.037475586, 0.07080078, 0.047821045, -0.00459671, 0.026428223, 0.024307251, 0.041778564, -0.03326416, 0.025527954, -0.03665161, 0.025161743, -0.04336548, 0.001613617, -0.09082031, 0.03781128, 0.024383545, 0.007835388, 0.042297363, -0.007621765, 0.0107040405, 0.00242424, 0.024642944, 0.04220581, 0.05404663, 0.0116119385, 0.013580322, 0.0015182495, -0.022415161, 0.0075950623, 0.028793335, -0.013717651, 0.024276733, -0.0049972534, -0.038726807, 0.003440857, 0.0357666, 0.006378174, -0.01889038, -0.0043907166, -0.03829956, 0.05404663, 0.015296936, 0.040008545, 0.032470703, 0.019821167, 0.0017585754, -0.017074585, -0.018081665, -0.0029239655, -0.026229858, 0.0090789795, 0.047607422, -0.06866455, 0.0134887695, -0.032470703, -0.013328552, 0.015304565, 0.023727417, 0.035827637, -0.06427002, -0.06591797, 0.033355713, 0.043304443, 0.021911621, -0.0073242188, -0.036865234, -0.000036776066, 0.01687622, 0.013809204, -0.0045051575, 0.006778717, 0.02772522, 0.03704834, 0.00035357475, -0.02658081, 0.0047187805, 0.019134521, -0.031982422, 0.02835083, 0.009765625, 0.031158447, -0.01838684, -0.042388916, 0.013130188, 0.007534027, -0.038970947, -0.019042969, 0.024917603, 0.015640259, 0.006160736, 0.049835205, 0.02748108, -0.010749817, -0.046173096, -0.03704834, 0.011528015, 0.06365967, -0.027359009, 0.026794434, -0.04135132, -0.04788208, 0.01675415, -0.06536865, 0.03366089, -0.03152466, -0.0042266846, -0.01209259, 0.017990112, 0.034576416, -0.043945312, -0.000071525574, -0.020996094, -0.06652832, 0.018432617, -0.012550354, -0.016647339, -0.0028247833, -0.022872925, -0.036132812, 0.02330017, -0.008018494, -0.028015137, -0.011894226, -0.057006836, 0.01184082, -0.03366089, 0.049560547, -0.037597656, -0.0017499924, -0.010688782, -0.015129089, -0.012680054, -0.0020637512, -0.009849548, -0.023345947, -0.0519104, -0.041107178, 0.023864746, 0.026229858, -0.014839172, -0.021972656, 0.04547119, -0.010925293, -0.011886597, 0.01499176, 0.010475159, -0.06365967, -0.0011024475, 0.004962921, -0.024673462, 0.03491211, 0.030914307, -0.038330078, 0.010070801, 0.012817383, -0.05029297, -0.0045394897, 0.0018815994, 0.02960205, -0.019317627, -0.04244995, 0.008384705, 0.047424316, 0.055480957, -0.03463745, -0.03338623, 0.020248413, 0.0021877289, -0.020355225, 0.055725098, 0.018600464, 0.0032310486, -0.0025024414, 0.020095825, -0.007423401, -0.03744507, -0.03552246, -0.02268982, 0.02217102, 0.0395813, -0.005180359, -0.009376526, 0.047424316, -0.026824951, -0.0058631897, 0.012390137, -0.015823364, 0.018188477, -0.011436462, 0.018814087, -0.012199402, -0.0064964294, 0.010101318, 0.031677246, -0.015213013, 0.026428223, -0.023498535, -0.008026123, 0.01184082, 0.0016536713, -0.04147339, -0.032043457, 0.023788452, 0.025527954, -0.002632141, 0.02809143, -0.026351929, 0.0041999817, 0.004989624, -0.006702423, -0.02897644, -0.010292053, 0.033813477, -0.012359619, -0.014091492, 0.026535034, -0.030395508, 0.009506226, -0.040008545, 0.04937744, -0.035491943, 0.009742737, -0.028060913, -0.017440796, 0.0024490356, 0.02835083, 0.045562744, -0.017242432, -0.026809692, -0.019195557, 0.048187256, -0.02394104 ], "summary": [ -0.028564453, -0.04550171, -0.02432251, 0.018066406, -0.093444824, -0.01096344, -0.06390381, 0.0023155212, 0.035827637, 0.036071777, -0.015388489, -0.011375427, 0.012367249, -0.026229858, -0.01737976, -0.01424408, 0.025634766, 0.06188965, 0.07110596, -0.008956909, 0.014945984, 0.0020256042, 0.049316406, 0.036956787, 0.03390503, -0.08483887, -0.018508911, 0.014335632, 0.00040650368, -0.0045166016, 0.003955841, 0.008605957, -0.0032405853, 0.046905518, -0.00356102, 0.002986908, 0.017532349, -0.0031604767, 0.031982422, 0.020187378, 0.04675293, -0.032318115, 0.14245605, -0.06518555, 0.058441162, 0.07019043, -0.0041618347, -0.05307007, -0.0018339157, 0.011268616, -0.0010118484, 0.008476257, -0.021560669, 0.0047035217, -0.0071983337, -0.008872986, -0.050598145, -0.01448822, 0.010955811, 0.059295654, 0.020904541, -0.023742676, -0.009742737, -0.039001465, -0.020431519, -0.016738892, 0.04751587, 0.020858765, 0.043762207, -0.023513794, -0.0070877075, 0.05404663, 0.015136719, -0.043395996, -0.03768921, 0.0047340393, 0.01965332, -0.008796692, -0.010734558, -0.032562256, -0.021057129, -0.01713562, -0.034423828, 0.0070762634, -0.029937744, 0.0024738312, -0.018218994, -0.01058197, 0.032318115, 0.02482605, 0.004753113, -0.00844574, 0.019744873, 0.09484863, 0.014511108, -0.016143799, -0.041900635, -0.07525635, 0.026947021, -0.03805542, 0.07183838, -0.0335083, -0.008255005, 0.024169922, -0.0021572113, 0.06842041, 0.01979065, 0.011413574, 0.0041542053, -0.012641907, 0.00010049343, -0.011917114, -0.007041931, -0.020935059, -0.0033473969, 0.031066895, -0.00014686584, 0.024429321, -0.016281128, 0.028686523, -0.0013313293, 0.030471802, -0.016159058, -0.03050232, -0.0010213852, -0.022460938, -0.008056641, -0.005050659, -0.0770874, 0.033691406, -0.0030174255, 0.018493652, 0.029022217, 0.024719238, -0.01889038, -0.00041294098, 0.005542755, 0.047821045, -0.0005145073, 0.021743774, -0.07312012, -0.034973145, 0.012397766, -0.025222778, -0.003408432, 0.040863037, 0.015319824, -0.0036354065, -0.006134033, -0.051452637, -0.0042915344, 0.0073928833, 0.056610107, -0.05593872, -0.047912598, -0.06530762, -0.09326172, -0.0015182495, 0.020385742, -0.0075531006, 0.0357666, 0.016098022, -0.0025024414, 0.038360596, 0.013938904, -0.016036987, -0.033813477, 0.0019102097, -0.0041503906, -0.018981934, -0.06677246, 0.016021729, -0.01939392, -0.05444336, -0.030090332, 0.006969452, 0.02607727, -0.02670288, 0.008354187, 0.032043457, 0.0012245178, -0.020217896, -0.00059986115, 0.0012998581, -0.010536194, 0.010444641, 0.010101318, 0.026184082, 0.008148193, 0.012046814, -0.02178955, 0.015289307, 0.026031494, -0.047027588, 0.026473999, -0.020980835, 0.0018129349, -0.009880066, 0.0028572083, -0.026885986, -0.010574341, -0.0062332153, -0.00048828125, 0.018493652, 0.0149002075, -0.020126343, 0.018249512, 0.012268066, -0.024429321, 0.042999268, 0.022964478, 0.025909424, -0.030822754, 0.022521973, 0.017562866, -0.032165527, 0.017974854, 0.0053749084, 0.027053833, -0.00043964386, 0.034942627, -0.0028076172, 0.018585205, 0.011711121, -0.051940918, 0.009353638, -0.0060539246, 0.007610321, -0.019592285, 0.020324707, 0.041656494, -0.03164673, 0.018005371, -0.0013513565, 0.0024871826, 0.03640747, 0.032562256, -0.03189087, -0.019226074, 0.006542206, 0.005771637, -0.022384644, -0.038269043, 0.022842407, 0.035186768, 0.007270813, 0.0024871826, 0.017425537, 0.010749817, 0.062469482, 0.015945435, -0.010673523, -0.012886047, -0.009963989, -0.037872314, 0.018081665, -0.0017547607, -0.023345947, 0.02658081, -0.0004775524, 0.02067566, 0.044311523, 0.004989624, 0.023956299, -0.015563965, -0.03488159, -0.002456665, -0.012062073, 0.01789856, -0.03604126, 0.0027828217, -0.04345703, -0.016067505, -0.0054359436, -0.015670776, -0.034973145, -0.015533447, 0.028411865, -0.002948761, -0.008888245, -0.012741089, 0.017089844, 0.032958984, -0.0028915405, 0.009521484, 0.05441284, 0.02708435, -0.00065660477, -0.008453369, -0.015930176, 0.0039863586, 0.02520752, -0.02067566, 0.022476196, -0.011871338, -0.010444641, 0.044891357, 0.007858276, -0.004146576, 0.0146484375, 0.029830933, 0.046569824, 0.025924683, -0.013046265, 0.002986908, 0.020462036, 0.009056091, -0.008682251, -0.015106201, -0.02128601, -0.01777649, -0.02999878, 0.028518677, 0.07659912, -0.035369873, -0.052001953, -0.03189087, 0.032226562, -0.06604004, -0.022567749, 0.08154297, 0.008384705, -0.008415222, -0.0037250519, 0.025009155, -0.041992188, -0.0005469322, -0.010421753, -0.0014600754, -0.007736206, -0.040405273, -0.054351807, -0.039642334, 0.011245728, -0.00087070465, -0.007789612, -0.0026512146, 0.09466553, 0.010574341, -0.0095825195, 0.0143585205, -0.06298828, 0.018508911, 0.012664795, -0.014778137, -0.038879395, 0.0067329407, -0.025726318, 0.059051514, 0.03390503, -0.020492554, 0.019500732, -0.0029964447, 0.042022705, 0.060546875, -0.049468994, -0.019546509, 0.072509766, 0.04324341, -0.0014505386, 0.003238678, 0.040130615, 0.008712769, -0.07080078, -0.042907715, -0.03866577, 0.011444092, -0.030899048, 0.047546387, 0.034179688, -0.017349243, 0.039764404, -0.052093506, -0.008918762, 0.029571533, 0.015350342, 0.06945801, -0.003227234, -0.0057640076, 0.039276123, -0.0052337646, -0.009422302, 0.022201538, -0.03717041, 0.060668945, -0.008895874, 0.0011520386, 0.05596924, 0.042053223, 0.013961792, 0.0074272156, -0.00021874905, 0.054504395, -0.015670776, -0.0138549805, -0.011627197, -0.018875122, 0.021224976, -0.011268616, 0.0021648407, 0.0335083, 0.024627686, 0.008804321, 0.018417358, -0.034057617, 0.059631348, -0.004081726, -0.011482239, 0.0041046143, 0.028564453, -0.0024108887, 0.01939392, -0.009300232, 0.041046143, -0.0059928894, -0.021728516, 0.015365601, 0.0152282715, -0.0070533752, -0.031677246, -0.013259888, 0.050079346, -0.04446411, -0.01802063, 0.023773193, 0.049316406, 0.012397766, -0.0104522705, -0.0067825317, 0.01486969, 0.03503418, -0.026229858, 0.00004374981, -0.032684326, -0.055023193, -0.021759033, -0.014694214, 0.013015747, 0.002319336, -0.052215576, -0.023391724, -0.029022217, 0.024765015, 0.022384644, -0.017593384, 0.011062622, -0.017196655, 0.007297516, 0.00047302246, 0.017471313, -0.008605957, -0.0019950867, 0.030685425, 0.035247803, -0.015205383, 0.050750732, 0.010467529, 0.012336731, 0.00022745132, -0.023147583, 0.0031814575, 0.013389587, -0.09259033, -0.025543213, 0.015701294, 0.0368042, 0.012870789, 0.0032997131, -0.0011911392, -0.0066833496, -0.0042800903, -0.020050049, -0.0007100105, -0.03829956, 0.015403748, -0.024627686, 0.018112183, -0.0042762756, 0.028045654, -0.028137207, -0.03591919, 0.025344849, 0.00026583672, -0.08972168, -0.052612305, 0.018127441, -0.11004639, -0.08154297, 0.0054626465, -0.037231445, -0.015716553, -0.046905518, 0.027175903, -0.026535034, -0.013244629, -0.022216797, -0.034576416, 0.12390137, 0.02230835, -0.081848145, 0.075683594, -0.03765869, 0.00025486946, 0.030227661, -0.0031833649, 0.0016374588, 0.05456543, 0.02822876, 0.00881958, -0.0058631897, 0.05630493, 0.000059962273, 0.0036792755, 0.002922058, -0.0048675537, 0.027359009, 0.025100708, -0.04699707, 0.035949707, 0.01675415, 0.0836792, 0.0670166, -0.034210205, -0.017684937, 0.0635376, 0.0051841736, -0.04916382, 0.006690979, 0.010284424, -0.00071525574, -0.026657104, -0.030715942, -0.016433716, 0.014656067, 0.05014038, 0.0012617111, -0.021881104, -0.04333496, 0.0008969307, 0.005077362, 0.014465332, 0.016464233, -0.015716553, 0.024520874, -0.021072388, -0.0132751465, -0.043701172, 0.0129470825, -0.026794434, -0.028244019, 0.026870728, 0.028930664, -0.03842163, -0.054595947, 0.014541626, 0.041412354, 0.015213013, -0.00016593933, -0.0041542053, -0.016220093, 0.006149292, -0.0027694702, 0.007545471, -0.0045661926, 0.023971558, 0.029266357, -0.074157715, -0.09851074, 0.022644043, -0.035858154, -0.04937744, -0.052825928, -0.07598877, -0.046020508, 0.004512787, 0.028289795, -0.042816162, -0.022750854, 0.01878357, 0.049468994, 0.004753113, 0.025863647, -0.013664246, -0.05795288, -0.02708435, 0.020370483, -0.009521484, -0.001282692, -0.030807495, 0.0017414093, 0.011383057, 0.0051841736, -0.033599854, -0.06726074, 0.015281677, 0.03201294, 0.0069122314, 0.026916504, 0.017547607, 0.020568848, 0.037384033, 0.0340271, 0.0065689087, 0.0032920837, -0.054473877, -0.0007662773, 0.027542114, 0.030471802, 0.01966858, 0.06149292, -0.0019369125, 0.0068206787, -0.004611969, -0.013183594, 0.030349731, -0.020401001, -0.008422852, -0.02545166, -0.001543045, -0.004436493, 0.015281677, -0.013153076, 0.018859863, 0.021484375, 0.0008392334, -0.023071289, -0.017303467, -0.00031876564, -0.012619019, 0.0045394897, 0.012031555, -0.0010099411, -0.029525757, -0.033691406, -0.0022525787, 0.037719727, 0.010101318, -0.018341064, -0.022735596, 0.00315094, 0.019165039, 0.026550293, 0.021133423, -0.027389526, -0.0012950897, -0.011962891, -0.009780884, -0.023147583, -0.012535095, 0.010864258, 0.009765625, 0.0045166016, -0.0073242188, -0.03152466, -0.005924225, -0.012367249, 0.0021190643, -0.040374756, 0.07318115, -0.06286621, -0.032043457, 0.027526855, -0.0597229, 0.011779785, 0.0067367554, 0.023895264, 0.031921387, 0.04510498, 0.013893127, -0.014587402, 0.019714355, -0.031585693, 0.059295654, -0.00497818, -0.0002567768, 0.032196045, 0.005355835, -0.006866455, 0.021362305, 0.011680603, -0.008895874, 0.022521973, 0.042541504, -0.030456543, -0.022369385, 0.033294678, 0.022735596, -0.008018494, -0.035980225, 0.025009155, 0.008583069, 0.08251953, -0.009132385, 0.097473145, 0.02911377, 0.0028591156, -0.040802002, -0.05178833, -0.022537231, -0.013938904, -0.0036830902, -0.014579773, 0.04196167, -0.019500732, -0.0011730194, -0.02456665, -0.02432251, 0.016296387, 0.032287598, 0.015823364, 0.013061523, -0.011421204, 0.0070266724, -0.005859375, 0.0068473816, -0.030685425, 0.0018968582, -0.029281616, -0.023590088, 0.029678345, 0.011436462, -0.03012085, 0.0056533813, -0.020233154, -0.0027179718, 0.011421204, -0.0022220612, 0.0491333, -0.022583008, -0.030044556, 0.02645874, 0.018051147, 0.009994507, -0.009429932, -0.0076942444, -0.0690918, 0.026489258, 0.0087890625, 0.027023315, -0.053955078, -0.01966858, -0.0034008026, 0.045043945, 0.0047302246, 0.04699707, 0.04812622, 0.009170532, 0.0006284714, 0.049102783, 0.053009033, 0.03665161, -0.011383057, -0.019088745, -0.018447876, 0.033416748, -0.013198853, 0.03286743, 0.005622864, 0.0016489029, -0.017852783, -0.026947021, 0.017105103, -0.0010519028, -0.006126404, 0.031463623, 0.0069999695, -0.010665894, 0.045013428, -0.01222229, -0.0158844, -0.03274536, 0.016784668, -0.02748108, -0.05053711, 0.066711426, 0.0021133423, -0.018035889, -0.00023365021, 0.0025959015, 0.021820068, 0.009407043, 0.0115356445, -0.0037117004, -0.00223732, -0.03781128, 0.059539795, -0.025390625, 0.09613037, -0.08135986, -0.031433105, -0.0059432983, 0.04498291, 0.06222534, 0.016464233, -0.0071640015, -0.04638672, 0.021331787, 0.038726807, 0.0118255615, -0.015174866, 0.032958984, 0.003967285, 0.003528595, -0.023132324, -0.027633667, -0.037200928, 0.077697754, -0.0067749023, -0.019332886, 0.06008911, -0.012016296, -0.032440186, -0.0011844635, -0.050323486, 0.09527588, 0.0048103333, 0.012138367, -0.0072669983, 0.00390625, -0.038024902, -0.009384155, 0.032806396, -0.017730713, 0.0335083, 0.037628174, -0.020843506, 0.039978027, 0.0050468445, -0.029022217, -0.05670166, 0.0418396, -0.043121338, 0.056884766, 0.0357666, 0.051757812, 0.0011062622, -0.039001465, 0.06011963, -0.02305603, -0.024459839, 0.051849365, -0.046844482, 0.05532837, 0.066467285, -0.06124878, -0.00472641, -0.0107040405, -0.030853271, 0.068237305, 0.04421997, 0.032409668, -0.027786255, -0.030563354, 0.018966675, 0.008850098, 0.014450073, -0.010696411, -0.050567627, -0.013397217, 0.023162842, -0.0063209534, -0.018798828, -0.028411865, 0.020050049, 0.040496826, 0.021392822, -0.0028820038, 0.007736206, -0.0030517578, 0.0031166077, 0.037322998, 0.006011963, 0.022659302, -0.02558899, -0.023788452, 0.017684937, 0.015640259, -0.002122879, 0.022613525, 0.020126343, 0.01928711, 0.010650635, 0.0440979, -0.007007599, 0.009994507, 0.0016679764, 0.010467529, -0.022216797, 0.009559631, -0.0015697479, 0.026947021, -0.036499023, -0.0034122467, 0.010772705, -0.03741455, -0.017852783, -0.048614502, 0.013496399, -0.0071144104, 0.0010843277, -0.019866943, -0.005126953, -0.0012483597, -0.039398193, -0.055511475, 0.039398193, 0.014701843, -0.046722412, 0.03692627, -0.03955078, -0.091796875, 0.008331299, 0.009147644, 0.011810303, -0.01574707, -0.031402588, 0.030181885, 0.008895874, 0.08081055, -0.010223389, -0.018676758, 0.011489868, -0.005973816, 0.0074691772, -0.030090332, -0.009727478, -0.0057754517, -0.014907837, -0.036499023, 0.01687622, 0.019836426, -0.021057129, -0.051513672, 0.07775879, -0.022644043, -0.0054855347, 0.021636963, 0.0030155182, -0.04486084, 0.02583313, 0.013702393, -0.0181427, 0.01335907, 0.009521484, -0.01838684, 0.017990112, 0.015304565, -0.03164673, 0.011421204, 0.0090408325, 0.007282257, -0.0070343018, -0.02670288, -0.0038967133, 0.02204895, 0.03338623, -0.00015187263, 0.009460449, 0.039215088, 0.012771606, 0.00932312, 0.03616333, -0.0024604797, -0.00060367584, -0.0018157959, 0.021377563, -0.018234253, 0.0056610107, 0.009231567, -0.0023384094, 0.016189575, 0.011711121, -0.021697998, 0.009086609, 0.03439331, -0.03062439, -0.0027484894, 0.027450562, -0.009407043, -0.0018730164, -0.015655518, -0.0018873215, -0.03201294, -0.018310547, 0.028396606, -0.02796936, -0.001786232, -0.043823242, 0.01007843, -0.023376465, -0.06829834, -0.008644104, -0.016937256, 0.048095703, -0.024795532, -0.011367798, 0.010620117, -0.025268555, -0.023010254, 0.023025513, 0.024368286, -0.005554199, -0.044128418, -0.012741089, 0.05822754, -0.010414124, -0.045928955, 0.046722412, 0.0019817352, -0.009063721, -0.015098572, 0.029174805, -0.008796692, 0.0027046204, 0.011436462, -0.016036987, 0.04144287, 0.017211914, 0.070373535, 0.0029792786, 0.04425049, 0.0072021484, 0.019836426, 0.009277344 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2105.13289v1
MTH-IDS: A Multi-Tiered Hybrid Intrusion Detection System for Internet of Vehicles
Li Yang, Abdallah Moubayed, Abdallah Shami
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NI, 68T01, I.2.6; C.2.0
Modern vehicles, including connected vehicles and autonomous vehicles, nowadays involve many electronic control units connected through intra-vehicle networks to implement various functionalities and perform actions. Modern vehicles are also connected to external networks through vehicle-to-everything technologies, enabling their communications with other vehicles, infrastructures, and smart devices. However, the improving functionality and connectivity of modern vehicles also increase their vulnerabilities to cyber-attacks targeting both intra-vehicle and external networks due to the large attack surfaces. To secure vehicular networks, many researchers have focused on developing intrusion detection systems (IDSs) that capitalize on machine learning methods to detect malicious cyber-attacks. In this paper, the vulnerabilities of intra-vehicle and external networks are discussed, and a multi-tiered hybrid IDS that incorporates a signature-based IDS and an anomaly-based IDS is proposed to detect both known and unknown attacks on vehicular networks. Experimental results illustrate that the proposed system can detect various types of known attacks with 99.99% accuracy on the CAN-intrusion-dataset representing the intra-vehicle network data and 99.88% accuracy on the CICIDS2017 dataset illustrating the external vehicular network data. For the zero-day attack detection, the proposed system achieves high F1-scores of 0.963 and 0.800 on the above two datasets, respectively. The average processing time of each data packet on a vehicle-level machine is less than 0.6 ms, which shows the feasibility of implementing the proposed system in real-time vehicle systems. This emphasizes the effectiveness and efficiency of the proposed IDS.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2105.13289v1
"2021-05-26T17:36:35"
"2021-05-26T17:36:35"
{ "title": [ -0.011299133, 0.005138397, -0.041503906, -0.042022705, 0.024978638, -0.01927185, 0.017333984, -0.0026779175, -0.051818848, 0.035614014, -0.04953003, 0.028182983, -0.008964539, -0.0016002655, -0.022903442, -0.027023315, -0.03540039, 0.021759033, -0.04336548, -0.041809082, 0.010856628, -0.06707764, 0.01626587, 0.028686523, 0.0065841675, 0.018066406, -0.06707764, 0.0059547424, -0.04031372, -0.038238525, -0.011497498, 0.03186035, 0.03665161, 0.046173096, -0.04171753, 0.041625977, -0.049468994, 0.04928589, 0.016189575, 0.0040359497, 0.018829346, 0.0019254684, 0.037963867, -0.0014810562, 0.011390686, 0.024124146, -0.05593872, -0.057250977, 0.0013818741, 0.03326416, 0.02027893, 0.019683838, -0.0066070557, 0.06982422, 0.0126571655, -0.01826477, -0.039764404, 0.014930725, 0.049987793, 0.07318115, 0.0340271, -0.039367676, -0.012397766, -0.04547119, -0.028869629, -0.014785767, 0.0463562, 0.010871887, 0.045288086, -0.025466919, -0.012878418, 0.04928589, 0.0069351196, 0.015533447, -0.039398193, -0.010658264, 0.039886475, -0.008811951, 0.027435303, -0.027740479, -0.0060920715, -0.008613586, -0.027450562, 0.011650085, 0.017990112, 0.00881958, -0.008232117, -0.017852783, -0.016311646, -0.02708435, -0.0033245087, -0.0035915375, 0.028823853, 0.013870239, -0.030761719, -0.002937317, -0.013183594, 0.011154175, 0.00032877922, -0.027511597, -0.009635925, 0.0107421875, -0.05218506, -0.01222229, 0.006832123, 0.029327393, 0.016967773, -0.02406311, -0.0028648376, -0.00013697147, -0.046325684, 0.052368164, 0.018249512, 0.030166626, -0.048553467, -0.02658081, 0.00049972534, -0.043914795, -0.004749298, -0.0018701553, 0.0077171326, -0.009803772, 0.012893677, -0.019470215, 0.020645142, -0.0113220215, -0.040405273, -0.0025863647, -0.0029697418, 0.006187439, -0.0031089783, 0.025421143, -0.033691406, -0.030578613, -0.034301758, 0.030838013, 0.015266418, 0.016738892, 0.012229919, -0.0010738373, 0.0357666, -0.02130127, -0.0033569336, 0.03765869, -0.024642944, -0.0015239716, 0.0552063, 0.005092621, -0.047698975, -0.045013428, -0.02784729, 0.026519775, 0.03475952, -0.00036668777, -0.072265625, -0.0038986206, -0.08270264, -0.023162842, -0.0018320084, -0.023605347, 0.026351929, -0.0018806458, -0.0056610107, 0.030838013, 0.06518555, 0.0017213821, 0.0021743774, 0.030090332, 0.0015792847, 0.021835327, -0.012481689, 0.0039520264, -0.011398315, -0.036895752, -0.012039185, -0.012634277, 0.040161133, 0.014602661, 0.007045746, -0.016860962, -0.010238647, -0.030166626, 0.03878784, -0.001748085, -0.08807373, 0.039093018, 0.011245728, 0.059936523, 0.030838013, -0.003414154, -0.010795593, 0.01890564, -0.049560547, 0.0019836426, -0.017578125, -0.0003848076, -0.00554657, 0.04034424, -0.015151978, -0.03466797, -0.032073975, 0.006832123, -0.026443481, 0.026687622, -0.0034217834, -0.036376953, -0.0020103455, 0.018005371, -0.019317627, 0.04626465, 0.04260254, 0.009796143, -0.051208496, 0.02947998, -0.009605408, -0.036499023, -0.004940033, -0.03668213, -0.0071525574, -0.01878357, -0.054626465, 0.028945923, -0.021316528, 0.007587433, -0.011802673, 0.062072754, -0.02482605, 0.031219482, 0.058166504, 0.05432129, 0.10345459, -0.07727051, 0.041107178, 0.023498535, -0.011367798, -0.04284668, -0.03591919, -0.048431396, 0.0340271, 0.031677246, -0.0021896362, -0.016921997, -0.020111084, 0.017593384, 0.0013084412, -0.079833984, -0.023223877, 0.04837036, -0.002544403, 0.019104004, 0.030761719, 0.015975952, 0.050811768, 0.024475098, 0.0063972473, 0.037597656, 0.012161255, 0.032318115, -0.06085205, 0.012825012, 0.018539429, 0.004081726, -0.017959595, 0.014022827, -0.026290894, 0.00844574, 0.01626587, 0.057159424, 0.015274048, -0.010276794, 0.01687622, 0.004917145, 0.0046920776, 0.027145386, 0.01637268, -0.029434204, 0.0023975372, -0.0110321045, -0.0003426075, -0.029708862, -0.041412354, -0.030181885, 0.0011081696, -0.011680603, 0.014030457, -0.016540527, 0.015075684, -0.058441162, -0.010093689, -0.005176544, 0.057769775, 0.034973145, 0.021362305, -0.018356323, -0.021438599, -0.007926941, 0.079589844, 0.074523926, -0.013320923, 0.039489746, -0.061431885, 0.014778137, 0.0048103333, -0.00013685226, 0.010314941, 0.005355835, 0.038024902, -0.0016489029, -0.027770996, 0.03729248, -0.08215332, 0.0071525574, 0.006134033, -0.03918457, -0.051574707, -0.050476074, -0.0234375, -0.05038452, -0.031982422, 0.0284729, 0.062042236, -0.026016235, -0.022445679, -0.018081665, -0.012924194, -0.01260376, -0.046081543, -0.03265381, -0.060394287, 0.041625977, 0.054504395, 0.019515991, -0.020050049, 0.0030708313, 0.0042266846, 0.02583313, -0.010559082, 0.016494751, -0.024734497, -0.013092041, -0.0041389465, 0.016189575, -0.010055542, -0.049713135, -0.02458191, -0.04449463, 0.0030899048, 0.0067367554, -0.08502197, -0.02293396, 0.061035156, -0.030227661, -0.007713318, -0.00944519, 0.076416016, -0.060028076, -0.058929443, 0.02357483, 0.017181396, -0.023254395, 0.049468994, 0.038848877, 0.03640747, -0.053955078, -0.084228516, -0.040924072, 0.008666992, 0.00818634, -0.009925842, 0.032714844, -0.061431885, -0.031677246, -0.026901245, -0.0019073486, 0.03817749, 0.028396606, -0.011009216, -0.025054932, -0.024520874, -0.024490356, 0.007797241, -0.00049734116, -0.0010633469, -0.011619568, 0.07183838, 0.015609741, 0.017364502, 0.017562866, 0.018203735, -0.026611328, -0.011077881, 0.0050621033, -0.013442993, 0.0065689087, 0.008575439, -0.017822266, -0.0022850037, 0.016021729, -0.097961426, 0.0030765533, 0.042175293, -0.004940033, -0.041656494, 0.022109985, -0.045196533, -0.0056266785, 0.012573242, -0.013366699, 0.013412476, 0.028793335, 0.014801025, 0.013824463, 0.021392822, -0.010574341, 0.013557434, -0.051361084, -0.08538818, 0.029449463, -0.037506104, -0.035491943, 0.0007534027, -0.0048103333, -0.047058105, -0.018508911, -0.032348633, 0.009475708, 0.026885986, 0.02330017, -0.010673523, 0.016723633, -0.01713562, -0.026138306, 0.018463135, -0.00843811, -0.036102295, -0.015258789, -0.019638062, 0.026306152, 0.018661499, -0.016220093, -0.017105103, -0.0028800964, 0.0135269165, 0.047607422, 0.015686035, -0.032592773, -0.0038585663, -0.01424408, -0.001950264, -0.0019407272, 0.010063171, -0.00774765, 0.005088806, 0.006008148, -0.0028095245, 0.06173706, -0.004337311, -0.008140564, -0.05618286, 0.0049858093, 0.032043457, 0.005065918, -0.05871582, -0.02848816, -0.013519287, 0.0037975311, 0.022064209, 0.009918213, -0.028305054, 0.0107421875, -0.015609741, 0.048034668, -0.007144928, -0.010437012, -0.0007214546, 0.041259766, -0.02154541, -0.018875122, 0.003616333, 0.013427734, -0.022094727, 0.025726318, -0.05807495, -0.05984497, -0.011428833, 0.0076179504, -0.08862305, -0.047302246, 0.0018138885, -0.018508911, -0.01689148, -0.02835083, 0.00076675415, 0.023162842, -0.023803711, 0.0010251999, 0.003440857, -0.02558899, -0.022415161, -0.083618164, -0.028442383, 0.06414795, -0.030227661, 0.037475586, 0.042297363, 0.0027103424, -0.0395813, -0.027511597, 0.020187378, 0.0028934479, 0.010314941, -0.00598526, -0.020706177, 0.024993896, -0.024597168, 0.011550903, 0.015022278, -0.0093307495, -0.012573242, 0.012771606, 0.014381409, 0.0110321045, -0.05029297, 0.048034668, 0.019119263, -0.011276245, -0.085876465, 0.012763977, -0.011383057, -0.040527344, 0.026412964, -0.02909851, 0.029846191, 0.047210693, -0.0014972687, 0.09588623, 0.007926941, 0.017669678, 0.001745224, -0.038635254, -0.015655518, 0.0015010834, 0.04840088, -0.021118164, -0.0069618225, 0.033843994, -0.017700195, 0.044311523, -0.015327454, -0.013046265, -0.0077552795, 0.01676941, -0.039398193, -0.0067977905, -0.06390381, -0.010429382, -0.04324341, 0.025634766, -0.010543823, 0.0020713806, 0.04650879, 0.00623703, -0.033966064, 0.0041275024, 0.10614014, -0.00045990944, 0.002986908, -0.091552734, -0.004135132, 0.014984131, -0.052978516, -0.029144287, -0.013442993, 0.006038666, 0.017501831, -0.0368042, -0.005382538, 0.0031051636, 0.03591919, 0.061065674, 0.0385437, 0.010192871, -0.029449463, 0.051239014, 0.012390137, -0.033416748, 0.015182495, 0.012390137, 0.011054993, -0.01637268, 0.010025024, -0.03427124, 0.0054130554, -0.03201294, 0.017364502, -0.017623901, 0.032165527, -0.030349731, 0.026687622, 0.006919861, 0.007358551, 0.0055236816, 0.018951416, -0.045166016, 0.009941101, -0.016098022, 0.02909851, -0.025497437, 0.0149002075, 0.01977539, 0.03225708, -0.01411438, -0.03137207, 0.032562256, -0.0141067505, -0.0037326813, -0.0418396, 0.06088257, 0.010681152, -0.024917603, 0.020721436, 0.020935059, 0.026901245, -0.02444458, 0.023345947, -0.03540039, 0.009994507, 0.015449524, -0.003944397, 0.0069351196, -0.011024475, 0.016021729, -0.0501709, -0.062164307, -0.013542175, 0.060455322, -0.039978027, -0.02267456, -0.01737976, 0.029846191, 0.019592285, 0.028915405, -0.0010643005, 0.016738892, -0.022018433, -0.0035324097, -0.00504303, -0.03479004, -0.034179688, -0.00623703, -0.0126571655, 0.010665894, -0.030197144, 0.031204224, -0.06933594, -0.0026626587, -0.023117065, 0.02418518, -0.01171875, -0.030288696, 0.038024902, 0.08288574, 0.020721436, 0.020095825, -0.017486572, 0.034454346, 0.044921875, 0.030853271, 0.02609253, 0.007896423, 0.031921387, -0.021072388, 0.038269043, 0.024627686, 0.027542114, -0.0058937073, 0.018371582, -0.0045204163, -0.012199402, -0.03817749, 0.025024414, 0.017669678, -0.029434204, 0.028167725, -0.04977417, 0.031402588, 0.0035095215, -0.007881165, 0.01134491, -0.029006958, -0.0078125, 0.024520874, -0.0126571655, 0.0178833, 0.021148682, 0.016189575, -0.06201172, -0.023284912, 0.011146545, 0.015945435, -0.007663727, -0.0028533936, 0.013473511, -0.035827637, 0.041748047, 0.021514893, -0.052520752, -0.012428284, 0.016189575, 0.033599854, 0.04168701, 0.018920898, -0.0047683716, 0.0104522705, -0.05480957, -0.045318604, -0.07324219, -0.0390625, -0.023208618, 0.054656982, -0.017166138, -0.043304443, -0.005432129, -0.0001449585, 0.015289307, 0.022033691, -0.023391724, 0.017196655, 0.007408142, -0.006542206, 0.022659302, 0.061523438, -0.0051727295, 0.0041885376, 0.018127441, -0.019134521, 0.029144287, -0.021057129, 0.0029945374, -0.0011091232, -0.048431396, 0.023864746, 0.020126343, 0.010948181, -0.04208374, 0.016571045, 0.032470703, -0.031188965, 0.03567505, -0.013580322, 0.07501221, -0.0051574707, -0.009613037, -0.018951416, 0.009727478, -0.040496826, 0.03466797, -0.0027446747, -0.0000654459, -0.044647217, -0.07244873, -0.039245605, 0.01260376, 0.038879395, 0.023605347, 0.045135498, -0.02017212, 0.03805542, -0.02758789, -0.0054855347, -0.04248047, 0.018569946, 0.0055389404, 0.018661499, -0.009864807, 0.00982666, 0.010749817, -0.0078125, 0.03375244, -0.01473999, -0.04437256, 0.024139404, -0.057403564, 0.024536133, -0.038604736, -0.018539429, 0.042938232, 0.015144348, -0.014732361, 0.04852295, -0.023651123, 0.036132812, 0.011665344, 0.048858643, 0.06781006, 0.027420044, -0.028701782, -0.008491516, -0.020706177, -0.044799805, 0.005302429, -0.05581665, -0.030044556, -0.045776367, -0.027633667, -0.06088257, -0.012542725, 0.018615723, 0.043640137, -0.0017347336, 0.016983032, 0.028671265, -0.015052795, 0.0362854, -0.042266846, 0.06137085, -0.0093307495, -0.0045547485, -0.004142761, 0.009521484, 0.030792236, 0.022079468, -0.004840851, 0.019683838, -0.01474762, -0.027542114, -0.013137817, 0.011360168, 0.03378296, -0.007972717, -0.024795532, -0.018417358, 0.037628174, 0.0068206787, 0.012451172, 0.051818848, 0.05935669, 0.013420105, -0.020355225, 0.012573242, -0.027877808, 0.011192322, -0.013885498, 0.030456543, -0.02760315, 0.029525757, -0.026107788, -0.015090942, -0.042663574, 0.026123047, 0.009544373, -0.056640625, -0.034729004, 0.023117065, 0.02357483, 0.0071754456, 0.0069618225, -0.028411865, -0.010177612, -0.020507812, 0.01084137, 0.011657715, 0.021591187, 0.011657715, 0.04055786, -0.014579773, -0.023147583, 0.01235199, -0.0051231384, 0.0052261353, 0.02923584, -0.007507324, -0.01940918, -0.008071899, -0.03652954, -0.011787415, 0.0070114136, -0.0052375793, -0.02458191, 0.024383545, 0.040008545, 0.020767212, 0.047729492, 0.004776001, -0.038635254, 0.014770508, -0.030166626, 0.0090789795, 0.036590576, -0.03427124, 0.013015747, -0.022476196, -0.032348633, 0.019256592, -0.05227661, 0.019104004, -0.011222839, -0.008308411, -0.040283203, 0.018844604, 0.035827637, -0.08514404, 0.043151855, -0.06506348, 0.014030457, -0.028640747, -0.014709473, -0.035705566, -0.022277832, -0.0051002502, 0.04940796, 0.0184021, -0.0009613037, -0.005706787, -0.023162842, -0.048339844, -0.012542725, -0.04336548, 0.010238647, -0.013519287, -0.01626587, -0.018432617, -0.009681702, -0.012794495, -0.0070343018, 0.013641357, -0.039001465, -0.032409668, -0.03829956, 0.027191162, 0.019195557, -0.008781433, 0.021133423, 0.046417236, 0.012435913, -0.0007352829, -0.033355713, 0.033447266, -0.038391113, -0.015106201, -0.017349243, -0.028381348, 0.0064430237, 0.022125244, 0.00856781, -0.015235901, 0.042938232, -0.014480591, -0.02217102, 0.038970947, 0.06982422, 0.0056877136, -0.05847168, 0.001786232, 0.060913086, 0.052764893, -0.016235352, 0.021148682, 0.041625977, 0.017791748, -0.002828598, 0.078552246, 0.022033691, 0.007774353, -0.02848816, 0.049468994, 0.013916016, -0.046295166, -0.07574463, -0.036590576, 0.05203247, 0.04626465, 0.005542755, -0.031402588, 0.060913086, -0.0063323975, -0.0015010834, -0.0018672943, -0.030136108, -0.008613586, -0.007068634, 0.015129089, 0.0018901825, 0.011787415, -0.005104065, 0.07116699, -0.02368164, 0.029815674, -0.03314209, 0.018692017, 0.024291992, -0.032684326, 0.014152527, -0.07147217, 0.046325684, 0.037963867, 0.0134887695, 0.034332275, -0.035339355, -0.04547119, -0.0031375885, -0.009010315, -0.011962891, 0.011306763, 0.03479004, -0.026687622, -0.012023926, -0.02470398, -0.03024292, -0.021209717, -0.04296875, 0.031173706, -0.036865234, 0.025314331, -0.034240723, 0.0014677048, -0.010658264, 0.031585693, 0.008705139, -0.015289307, -0.035339355, -0.01889038, 0.040100098, -0.02079773 ], "summary": [ 0.016403198, 0.005252838, -0.023544312, 0.0059051514, 0.019042969, -0.038513184, 0.034820557, -0.029434204, -0.032226562, 0.013801575, -0.07751465, 0.014633179, -0.020126343, -0.009010315, 0.031707764, -0.05947876, -0.016189575, 0.054229736, 0.0029010773, -0.022140503, 0.013214111, -0.028823853, -0.022445679, 0.008804321, -0.010749817, 0.007762909, -0.02078247, 0.03640747, -0.013130188, 0.0062713623, 0.0017194748, 0.00042533875, 0.0043411255, 0.045135498, -0.022613525, 0.02168274, -0.02772522, 0.040924072, 0.024978638, -0.008377075, 0.021957397, 0.002363205, 0.13232422, -0.0037784576, 0.03717041, 0.0473938, -0.007896423, -0.06512451, 0.00969696, 0.026748657, -0.015853882, 0.007221222, -0.028274536, 0.03668213, -0.0085372925, -0.010971069, -0.07727051, 0.013648987, 0.02331543, 0.08691406, 0.026016235, -0.022827148, -0.008361816, -0.07495117, -0.013092041, -0.0034713745, 0.0758667, 0.000026583672, 0.008033752, -0.018737793, 0.013320923, 0.038330078, 0.015960693, -0.03967285, -0.0073280334, 0.010536194, 0.005706787, -0.020553589, 0.00819397, -0.024749756, -0.027297974, 0.013633728, -0.007537842, -0.007423401, -0.016601562, -0.016342163, -0.028686523, -0.014083862, -0.02508545, 0.034179688, -0.025970459, -0.021087646, 0.0033359528, 0.043518066, 0.011932373, 0.0031337738, 0.016189575, -0.012184143, 0.019699097, 0.0011854172, 0.008834839, -0.06335449, 0.013290405, -0.027832031, 0.0063591003, 0.05593872, 0.032958984, -0.037139893, -0.015609741, -0.038330078, -0.031280518, 0.030578613, -0.006385803, -0.0049362183, -0.06756592, 0.024139404, 0.021499634, -0.055999756, -0.0024986267, -0.003112793, -0.009513855, 0.01701355, -0.033691406, 0.0018806458, 0.045410156, 0.015022278, 0.001405716, 0.01612854, 0.01965332, -0.0044174194, -0.024246216, 0.00026249886, 0.03652954, 0.018707275, 0.0024909973, -0.01701355, 0.048919678, 0.029281616, 0.039916992, -0.039367676, 0.066833496, 0.00081157684, -0.014205933, 0.06726074, -0.0262146, 0.025558472, 0.030258179, 0.010826111, -0.015777588, -0.05718994, 0.019439697, 0.016799927, 0.05239868, -0.022766113, -0.057037354, -0.038085938, -0.03149414, -0.024795532, 0.018463135, -0.045654297, 0.044067383, -0.0005955696, -0.004878998, 0.054992676, 0.036590576, -0.00932312, -0.0024528503, 0.009811401, -0.0021419525, 0.0028038025, -0.019638062, -0.010276794, -0.044525146, -0.02935791, -0.010269165, 0.0023326874, 0.013023376, 0.03994751, 0.0045928955, -0.041809082, -0.0119018555, -0.03314209, 0.058258057, -0.009269714, -0.07342529, 0.04208374, 0.0010786057, 0.08660889, 0.01586914, 0.0085372925, 0.027572632, -0.008483887, -0.023529053, 0.026107788, 0.022384644, 0.0068588257, -0.029464722, 0.02798462, -0.022872925, -0.064941406, 0.028030396, 0.009498596, -0.000117242336, -0.035125732, -0.047546387, -0.016204834, -0.0049743652, 0.03302002, -0.039398193, 0.0050086975, 0.016983032, -0.04550171, -0.00869751, 0.047058105, 0.029571533, 0.0047836304, -0.009780884, -0.051727295, -0.022262573, -0.0060272217, -0.055358887, 0.050872803, -0.05871582, 0.034118652, -0.01146698, 0.070617676, -0.049835205, 0.047912598, 0.08642578, 0.04586792, 0.09979248, -0.07366943, 0.008705139, 0.012428284, -0.025772095, -0.02458191, -0.02671814, -0.09246826, 0.03363037, 0.06628418, 0.008834839, 0.015037537, -0.0390625, 0.0038642883, -0.043640137, -0.080078125, -0.024917603, 0.029388428, -0.030944824, -0.006462097, 0.004371643, -0.008483887, 0.045959473, 0.013130188, 0.0052871704, 0.020339966, 0.006286621, 0.012191772, -0.064208984, 0.029251099, 0.012924194, -0.04788208, -0.029296875, -0.016860962, 0.01940918, -0.03152466, 0.05230713, 0.058441162, 0.037322998, -0.06124878, -0.014259338, 0.016723633, 0.0048217773, 0.0010824203, -0.01361084, -0.019180298, 0.003080368, 0.00045728683, -0.010467529, -0.011199951, -0.018722534, -0.018569946, -0.05014038, -0.002298355, 0.033355713, -0.008804321, -0.0030937195, 0.0004632473, -0.008033752, 0.03668213, 0.06488037, 0.01612854, 0.0024032593, -0.022644043, -0.0053596497, -0.0036697388, -0.0018482208, 0.040863037, 0.0046081543, -0.019317627, -0.004589081, 0.024673462, -0.037597656, 0.016418457, 0.010406494, -0.008079529, 0.030227661, 0.00894165, 0.010444641, -0.0014600754, -0.054626465, 0.0050811768, 0.011230469, -0.0027427673, -0.030548096, -0.039154053, -0.04043579, -0.011886597, -0.010894775, 0.02645874, 0.035247803, 0.011001587, -0.0059280396, -0.016021729, 0.007820129, -0.027954102, -0.018569946, -0.030792236, -0.022720337, 0.010292053, 0.012565613, -0.007709503, -0.00033950806, 0.0042266846, 0.0022220612, -0.018630981, 0.02293396, 0.0050849915, 0.014511108, 0.0036315918, 0.041625977, 0.021469116, -0.043762207, -0.021209717, -0.062347412, 0.013114929, -0.012130737, 0.015716553, -0.086120605, -0.028884888, 0.037841797, -0.037963867, -0.005947113, 0.0146102905, 0.048553467, -0.066223145, -0.0368042, 0.04714966, 0.004837036, -0.025756836, 0.055389404, 0.05279541, 0.05291748, -0.040924072, -0.116760254, -0.03277588, 0.047302246, 0.017944336, -0.026428223, 0.026535034, -0.050720215, -0.014518738, -0.00081157684, -0.002910614, -0.0041503906, 0.06719971, 0.024780273, -0.016662598, 0.012367249, -0.004020691, 0.003414154, -0.0087890625, 0.033569336, -0.012779236, 0.04373169, 0.011688232, 0.04559326, 0.016830444, 0.030578613, -0.03414917, -0.011871338, 0.013916016, 0.0034217834, -0.008071899, -0.013084412, -0.024124146, 0.018661499, 0.011398315, -0.03741455, -0.015304565, 0.013656616, 0.023147583, 0.00019860268, 0.005908966, -0.013366699, 0.050720215, 0.02671814, -0.015396118, 0.015548706, 0.01626587, 0.013839722, -0.016098022, -0.0042152405, 0.0069007874, -0.0028648376, -0.019760132, 0.058776855, 0.030517578, -0.028045654, -0.060546875, -0.019515991, 0.08129883, 0.018615723, -0.015068054, -0.019500732, -0.021697998, -0.0069351196, 0.010635376, -0.025772095, 0.057556152, -0.020263672, -0.006389618, 0.0013580322, -0.006385803, -0.023742676, -0.06689453, -0.023757935, -0.06378174, 0.024993896, -0.044067383, 0.0032577515, -0.01084137, 0.031951904, 0.047668457, 0.0289917, -0.011833191, -0.004257202, -0.016586304, 0.03805542, 0.0037441254, -0.0069351196, -0.027297974, 0.060028076, 0.03338623, -0.01739502, 0.08538818, -0.026275635, 0.013534546, 0.008804321, -0.031555176, -0.0036182404, -0.0077590942, -0.030059814, -0.022613525, -0.017654419, 0.008369446, 0.0060310364, 0.024124146, 0.02659607, -0.040649414, -0.00699234, 0.053833008, -0.009819031, -0.025482178, -0.010635376, 0.00541687, 0.03564453, -0.050445557, 0.07336426, 0.00072813034, -0.07098389, 0.041381836, -0.107666016, -0.015007019, -0.04171753, 0.023361206, -0.02557373, -0.0030117035, -0.03225708, 0.033569336, 0.013954163, 0.03100586, 0.00010496378, 0.035339355, -0.019058228, -0.00070381165, -0.003704071, 0.028518677, -0.04006958, -0.076049805, 0.0016393661, -0.02796936, 0.008705139, 0.05618286, 0.0010795593, 0.017318726, -0.012237549, -0.012161255, -0.0031166077, -0.023422241, -0.004776001, -0.030838013, -0.009422302, 0.016464233, -0.032806396, 0.032440186, -0.02961731, 0.02961731, -0.022750854, 0.0005583763, 0.057159424, 0.058807373, -0.035736084, 0.023468018, 0.009643555, 0.00983429, -0.06137085, 0.017333984, -0.022888184, -0.06161499, 0.038757324, 0.005378723, 0.0118255615, 0.05432129, -0.005619049, 0.059783936, -0.013725281, -0.0071792603, -0.013145447, 0.012306213, -0.0287323, -0.0058937073, 0.054595947, 0.015579224, -0.010261536, 0.019485474, -0.032958984, 0.045196533, -0.03677368, 0.034118652, -0.014350891, -0.03567505, 0.020339966, -0.020507812, -0.012969971, 0.024093628, -0.0029621124, -0.016082764, -0.0072517395, 0.017486572, 0.027450562, 0.008392334, -0.0005092621, -0.025421143, 0.12585449, 0.017929077, -0.015151978, -0.11883545, -0.05419922, 0.0012483597, -0.016204834, 0.011581421, 0.0075263977, -0.029403687, -0.01184082, -0.031143188, -0.0067443848, 0.022735596, 0.049468994, 0.06689453, 0.0076560974, 0.02243042, -0.047302246, 0.05255127, 0.034423828, -0.01890564, 0.0007033348, -0.030288696, 0.027770996, 0.011421204, -0.006511688, -0.023483276, -0.004547119, -0.020401001, 0.013832092, -0.018585205, 0.03970337, -0.019119263, 0.04663086, 0.0015220642, 0.0038471222, -0.0113220215, 0.0018882751, -0.019805908, 0.020385742, -0.0039978027, 0.004508972, 0.005470276, 0.01424408, -0.016845703, -0.011436462, -0.028884888, -0.028900146, 0.046844482, -0.039916992, -0.015106201, -0.06628418, 0.08532715, 0.05508423, -0.020126343, 0.031280518, 0.004573822, -0.016311646, 0.0024299622, -0.013137817, 0.006011963, -0.0023899078, 0.011505127, -0.008308411, -0.01146698, 0.0009236336, -0.0024414062, -0.025421143, -0.09802246, -0.004234314, 0.101745605, -0.006416321, -0.008956909, -0.054840088, -0.017578125, 0.0042877197, -0.015434265, -0.022369385, 0.056549072, -0.004261017, 0.0005917549, 0.014717102, 0.0048561096, 0.007843018, -0.028182983, -0.012252808, -0.010299683, 0.024932861, -0.0034179688, -0.0014762878, 0.008415222, -0.0023326874, 0.03994751, -0.0073547363, -0.013114929, -0.014282227, 0.03643799, -0.010131836, -0.012298584, 0.041625977, 0.014701843, 0.005393982, 0.008491516, -0.013946533, 0.00818634, -0.026641846, -0.009140015, 0.050354004, 0.013687134, 0.012756348, 0.011978149, 0.04071045, -0.01335907, 0.014892578, -0.008506775, -0.017028809, -0.021621704, -0.022094727, 0.008934021, -0.0107421875, 0.041992188, 0.008636475, -0.0041503906, 0.010910034, 0.026473999, 0.01889038, 0.039611816, 0.012039185, 0.03729248, 0.009864807, 0.03366089, -0.013893127, 0.024032593, -0.033569336, 0.0155181885, 0.019439697, 0.0053138733, 0.017791748, 0.0029563904, -0.009223938, 0.019760132, -0.013648987, -0.022323608, 0.0211792, 0.039520264, -0.006313324, -0.032714844, -0.008140564, -0.002002716, -0.018676758, -0.04107666, -0.055480957, -0.05545044, -0.04147339, 0.041046143, -0.021835327, -0.04937744, 0.030944824, -0.010467529, 0.00554657, 0.028076172, -0.015808105, -0.01247406, 0.0036010742, -0.025619507, 0.04147339, 0.03894043, -0.025299072, 0.012313843, 0.0259552, 0.0022659302, 0.0140686035, 0.0023078918, 0.011062622, -0.009902954, -0.0010375977, -0.0018262863, 0.026748657, 0.018157959, -0.031707764, 0.030090332, 0.010765076, -0.035247803, 0.031707764, -0.010826111, 0.020523071, 0.018173218, -0.0052375793, -0.01473999, 0.020248413, -0.016204834, 0.017791748, 0.0017786026, -0.00655365, -0.0015697479, -0.043640137, 0.017349243, 0.00033330917, 0.021621704, 0.041809082, 0.05432129, 0.0029792786, 0.03466797, 0.011581421, -0.016296387, -0.013244629, -0.0045814514, 0.021759033, 0.0440979, 0.00409317, 0.008903503, 0.009780884, 0.04232788, 0.03970337, -0.02444458, -0.080078125, 0.039215088, 0.0030498505, 0.035217285, 0.012435913, 0.040649414, 0.039794922, -0.018554688, 0.03363037, -0.013824463, 0.008796692, 0.007335663, -0.0014276505, 0.008285522, 0.033447266, -0.02406311, -0.05630493, -0.01676941, -0.08679199, -0.050598145, -0.017913818, -0.008262634, -0.099365234, -0.043640137, -0.050445557, 0.0209198, 0.0058555603, -0.03753662, 0.014297485, 0.019958496, 0.022720337, 0.054870605, 0.024047852, -0.003736496, -0.0690918, 0.019470215, -0.012260437, -0.0044822693, -0.02281189, 0.006832123, 0.0178833, 0.024749756, -0.014350891, 0.03378296, 0.005306244, -0.008506775, -0.004650116, 0.013244629, -0.000019311905, -0.032287598, 0.022277832, -0.018295288, 0.0027809143, 0.002216339, 0.007587433, 0.024337769, 0.020721436, 0.07397461, -0.020645142, 0.011138916, 0.023239136, 0.008453369, 0.0066108704, 0.024871826, 0.018722534, -0.011253357, -0.021896362, -0.008407593, -0.016647339, 0.010124207, 0.012123108, -0.026733398, -0.008796692, -0.007949829, 0.0056495667, -0.027816772, -0.03842163, -0.02494812, -0.0076026917, 0.010108948, -0.0077819824, 0.006877899, -0.0053482056, 0.0021476746, 0.013969421, 0.0005750656, 0.014915466, 0.012481689, 0.01209259, 0.027069092, 0.020111084, -0.034942627, -0.056549072, -0.046020508, -0.019821167, -0.0074539185, 0.0073394775, 0.03152466, -0.018585205, 0.06951904, 0.03918457, 0.042297363, 0.05734253, -0.013298035, -0.007888794, 0.03829956, -0.019882202, -0.020248413, -0.011199951, -0.027038574, -0.0496521, 0.0021190643, 0.00440979, -0.013626099, -0.01071167, 0.0137786865, 0.027786255, -0.05432129, -0.06518555, 0.037017822, -0.044067383, -0.032562256, 0.07879639, -0.09527588, 0.023880005, -0.022399902, -0.017791748, -0.026489258, -0.0036354065, -0.019302368, 0.04537964, 0.020141602, -0.016998291, 0.028671265, -0.02407837, -0.019805908, -0.033172607, -0.019821167, 0.0209198, 0.022567749, -0.03756714, -0.010414124, -0.007621765, -0.004322052, 0.002626419, 0.036468506, -0.010772705, -0.026611328, -0.044067383, 0.017608643, 0.015609741, -0.0017147064, 0.04876709, 0.048553467, 0.030166626, 0.008354187, -0.010444641, 0.044799805, -0.014083862, -0.02859497, -0.0075035095, -0.035614014, 0.014831543, -0.009780884, 0.017227173, -0.009567261, 0.031829834, 0.010795593, -0.034301758, 0.035491943, 0.02822876, -0.00198555, -0.032196045, -0.0014638901, 0.033843994, 0.032562256, -0.01121521, 0.070007324, 0.04058838, 0.027893066, 0.013191223, 0.037963867, 0.007549286, 0.016311646, -0.028167725, 0.020706177, 0.0066375732, -0.029800415, -0.043395996, -0.02355957, 0.073913574, 0.020568848, -0.033172607, 0.01576233, 0.060150146, -0.019119263, 0.006690979, -0.028442383, -0.006401062, -0.009712219, -0.0030269623, 0.045410156, -0.007522583, 0.018966675, 0.03942871, 0.03314209, -0.035095215, -0.003774643, -0.017501831, -0.013519287, -0.003353119, -0.06616211, -0.001964569, -0.020721436, -0.009422302, 0.009361267, 0.0004620552, 0.021636963, -0.011932373, -0.032073975, 0.007896423, -0.013809204, -0.0018520355, -0.004295349, 0.024337769, -0.03225708, -0.024093628, -0.022384644, -0.008621216, -0.040374756, 0.001616478, -0.000992775, -0.041992188, 0.018035889, -0.017990112, -0.026229858, -0.0041160583, 0.020187378, -0.011474609, 0.00094652176, 0.00019419193, -0.027999878, 0.012466431, 0.0020179749 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2106.00611v1
Deep Learning for EEG Seizure Detection in Preterm Infants
Alison OShea, Rehan Ahmed, Gordon Lightbody, Sean Mathieson, Elena Pavlidis, Rhodri Lloyd, Francesco Pisani, Willian Marnane, Geraldine Boylan, Andriy Temko
eess.SP, cs.AI, cs.LG
EEG is the gold standard for seizure detection in the newborn infant, but EEG interpretation in the preterm group is particularly challenging; trained experts are scarce and the task of interpreting EEG in real-time is arduous. Preterm infants are reported to have a higher incidence of seizures compared to term infants. Preterm EEG morphology differs from that of term infants, which implies that seizure detection algorithms trained on term EEG may not be appropriate. The task of developing preterm specific algorithms becomes extra-challenging given the limited amount of annotated preterm EEG data available. This paper explores novel deep learning (DL) architectures for the task of neonatal seizure detection in preterm infants. The study tests and compares several approaches to address the problem: training on data from full-term infants; training on data from preterm infants; training on age-specific preterm data and transfer learning. The system performance is assessed on a large database of continuous EEG recordings of 575h in duration. It is shown that the accuracy of a validated term-trained EEG seizure detection algorithm, based on a support vector machine classifier, when tested on preterm infants falls well short of the performance achieved for full-term infants. An AUC of 88.3% was obtained when tested on preterm EEG as compared to 96.6% obtained when tested on term EEG. When re-trained on preterm EEG, the performance marginally increases to 89.7%. An alternative DL approach shows a more stable trend when tested on the preterm cohort, starting with an AUC of 93.3% for the term-trained algorithm and reaching 95.0% by transfer learning from the term model using available preterm data.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2106.00611v1
"2021-05-28T14:03:56"
"2021-05-28T14:03:56"
{ "title": [ -0.0143966675, 0.024017334, -0.028518677, -0.018539429, 0.016433716, -0.019180298, -0.008422852, -0.036956787, 0.0039138794, 0.046569824, -0.042938232, 0.011543274, 0.043182373, -0.028564453, -0.03265381, -0.0072669983, 0.013214111, 0.013282776, 0.006904602, -0.016571045, 0.0027332306, -0.012397766, 0.072265625, 0.032073975, 0.03894043, -0.037597656, -0.09753418, 0.04107666, -0.03656006, -0.03277588, 0.0053749084, 0.032989502, 0.037261963, 0.015686035, -0.024871826, 0.0010404587, -0.04244995, 0.033111572, 0.0066490173, -0.013916016, 0.01586914, -0.024780273, -0.0020828247, -0.022109985, -0.0032100677, 0.035461426, -0.06378174, -0.054107666, -0.02659607, -0.0026016235, 0.038269043, -0.0022258759, 0.028335571, 0.008163452, 0.014183044, 0.0005478859, -0.031677246, -0.025375366, 0.047302246, 0.09851074, 0.029129028, -0.045654297, -0.0041542053, -0.060668945, -0.021072388, -0.028900146, -0.026550293, 0.022262573, 0.06512451, 0.008956909, -0.0020427704, 0.026626587, 0.01436615, 0.004245758, -0.07147217, -0.031921387, 0.06695557, 0.0021514893, 0.020568848, -0.041534424, -0.0023288727, -0.018051147, 0.010948181, -0.050109863, 0.037902832, -0.036834717, -0.0076675415, 0.0050582886, -0.055236816, -0.07043457, -0.019119263, -0.038269043, -0.06161499, 0.0072021484, 0.009086609, -0.0413208, -0.028320312, -0.003929138, -0.016983032, -0.032318115, -0.011489868, 0.03390503, -0.07745361, 0.0035381317, 0.016189575, -0.014579773, -0.03878784, -0.060821533, 0.014770508, 0.04220581, -0.04159546, 0.02998352, 0.01007843, -0.024917603, 0.0000962019, 0.016723633, 0.013755798, 0.00010108948, 0.034057617, -0.0005636215, -0.014450073, -0.034820557, 0.018035889, 0.033172607, 0.021652222, 0.0076293945, -0.020004272, -0.001373291, -0.0317688, 0.050323486, 0.01449585, 0.026641846, -0.092163086, -0.058502197, -0.066467285, 0.01876831, -0.02130127, 0.014831543, -0.0012903214, -0.022628784, 0.051330566, -0.016357422, -0.003479004, 0.04852295, -0.000075399876, -0.0026950836, 0.035705566, 0.0085372925, -0.03390503, -0.03414917, -0.009864807, 0.003648758, 0.023269653, -0.01020813, -0.046966553, 0.003917694, -0.11419678, -0.0007805824, 0.010040283, 0.018432617, 0.023147583, 0.002822876, 0.010536194, 0.041290283, 0.06109619, -0.007019043, -0.034179688, 0.02178955, 0.015838623, 0.015670776, -0.0033512115, 0.029830933, 0.035095215, -0.013931274, -0.0015182495, -0.008102417, 0.011940002, 0.010925293, 0.005367279, 0.020965576, 0.011482239, -0.027175903, -0.017166138, 0.04711914, -0.044921875, -0.058563232, 0.016098022, 0.0057640076, 0.059570312, 0.023468018, -0.042419434, -0.011856079, -0.052001953, -0.024597168, -0.025848389, 0.009117126, 0.005622864, 0.026611328, -0.0057296753, 0.0057907104, -0.041503906, -0.002817154, -0.005268097, -0.00040721893, 0.0009317398, -0.048583984, -0.0055274963, 0.0027866364, -0.000067055225, 0.028579712, 0.01701355, -0.0102005005, -0.005264282, -0.027069092, -0.01007843, -0.028808594, 0.010276794, 0.0022449493, -0.0014352798, -0.022155762, -0.01777649, -0.011306763, 0.015914917, 0.02532959, 0.044891357, 0.011528015, -0.0034255981, -0.025802612, 0.08270264, 0.016036987, 0.0680542, -0.002286911, 0.013687134, -0.03857422, -0.055999756, -0.011505127, -0.040161133, -0.013618469, 0.007751465, 0.03387451, 0.002746582, -0.010749817, -0.0017051697, 0.035491943, 0.04864502, -0.018447876, -0.000030338764, 0.016464233, 0.01197052, 0.032836914, 0.06677246, 0.010307312, 0.03475952, -0.0007414818, 0.023452759, 0.03414917, 0.010536194, 0.021469116, -0.0016756058, -0.005458832, -0.004802704, 0.01763916, 0.006214142, 0.012039185, -0.03857422, -0.013847351, -0.039215088, -0.01763916, -0.0058288574, 0.01525116, 0.022766113, -0.05130005, 0.014511108, -0.0025253296, -0.03186035, -0.01777649, -0.01159668, 0.025787354, -0.0014829636, -0.056488037, -0.008232117, 0.01776123, 0.021713257, -0.0069351196, 0.014755249, -0.0070533752, -0.0026359558, -0.021331787, 0.0018320084, -0.017456055, 0.016311646, 0.036834717, 0.0068740845, -0.002292633, 0.033569336, -0.0063171387, 0.028259277, 0.04421997, -0.025939941, 0.01713562, -0.046173096, 0.02456665, -0.00012075901, -0.00015687943, -0.0016746521, 0.028961182, -0.0024776459, 0.011192322, -0.018005371, 0.006072998, -0.027526855, 0.025314331, 0.000500679, 0.014266968, -0.068359375, -0.06665039, -0.03527832, -0.023132324, -0.067871094, -0.025146484, 0.023071289, 0.009506226, -0.009727478, -0.02545166, 0.0024414062, 0.0015668869, -0.052215576, -0.013618469, -0.014404297, 0.025924683, 0.0602417, 0.030075073, -0.04333496, -0.000936985, 0.019989014, 0.017349243, 0.0010662079, 0.03881836, -0.025283813, -0.015945435, 0.0006122589, 0.016845703, 0.02166748, -0.019638062, -0.028396606, -0.0046195984, 0.004257202, 0.027938843, -0.072021484, -0.010978699, 0.043914795, -0.036590576, -0.037139893, 0.004951477, 0.018798828, -0.00074768066, 0.026290894, -0.0028457642, -0.005508423, -0.011329651, 0.01058197, 0.02079773, 0.0023326874, -0.044830322, -0.010398865, -0.064331055, -0.033813477, 0.0022830963, -0.016647339, 0.034179688, -0.07562256, -0.021148682, -0.020370483, -0.009384155, 0.024368286, 0.033966064, 0.0038089752, -0.025741577, -0.04537964, -0.016784668, -0.0071868896, -0.0000333786, -0.033416748, -0.003440857, 0.06506348, 0.017349243, -0.028198242, -0.0073013306, 0.027572632, 0.0019569397, -0.012283325, -0.0033359528, -0.02458191, -0.0065078735, 0.029449463, 0.014152527, -0.012870789, -0.033172607, -0.074523926, -0.012573242, 0.08721924, -0.010055542, -0.020324707, 0.033081055, -0.062561035, 0.011306763, 0.018325806, 0.0076942444, 0.016708374, 0.072021484, -0.027114868, 0.00422287, -0.018188477, 0.0042152405, 0.027526855, -0.01676941, -0.08276367, 0.0335083, -0.039764404, -0.016311646, 0.017700195, -0.037475586, -0.043792725, -0.016983032, -0.012268066, 0.027023315, 0.013687134, -0.019042969, 0.040924072, 0.008102417, -0.0022697449, -0.00831604, -0.016098022, -0.034729004, 0.010505676, 0.01386261, -0.032287598, 0.030273438, -0.023223877, 0.014045715, -0.03744507, -0.0030937195, 0.020126343, 0.050811768, 0.010948181, -0.03930664, -0.025360107, -0.027740479, -0.029052734, 0.033325195, -0.0019664764, -0.0048675537, -0.034942627, 0.016326904, -0.024154663, 0.05770874, 0.006362915, 0.009346008, 0.009864807, -0.037872314, -0.008377075, -0.014480591, -0.056030273, 0.00749588, 0.004627228, -0.0036315918, 0.016052246, -0.0056419373, -0.032440186, 0.012802124, -0.009994507, 0.019973755, -0.02053833, -0.02609253, 0.041137695, 0.019729614, -0.046783447, -0.02229309, 0.012672424, 0.039794922, -0.019973755, 0.010658264, -0.054656982, -0.046203613, -0.007286072, 0.0011692047, -0.07989502, -0.040527344, 0.03640747, -0.06951904, -0.02482605, -0.08215332, 0.0110321045, -0.0181427, -0.030929565, 0.019210815, -0.0038909912, -0.037506104, -0.00040555, -0.042663574, -0.059295654, 0.06774902, -0.013244629, -0.0040016174, 0.015556335, 0.013046265, 0.006034851, -0.019821167, -0.0012264252, -0.011566162, 0.043884277, -0.025543213, -0.0058784485, 0.040649414, -0.034332275, 0.012268066, 0.011764526, 0.013870239, -0.011680603, 0.010688782, 0.018112183, 0.0048217773, -0.019805908, 0.0635376, 0.00945282, -0.019851685, -0.08099365, -0.03010559, -0.026504517, -0.021469116, 0.019561768, -0.015960693, 0.011154175, 0.020477295, 0.02482605, 0.08453369, 0.0031757355, -0.024032593, 0.0037975311, -0.0231781, -0.0001680851, 0.005783081, 0.00032019615, -0.0010070801, -0.01625061, 0.028503418, -0.015365601, 0.03845215, -0.031341553, -0.03967285, 0.02671814, 0.044708252, -0.012237549, -0.019088745, -0.06286621, -0.0385437, -0.01701355, -0.0022525787, -0.004470825, 0.02482605, 0.023666382, 0.0049552917, -0.027740479, 0.01007843, 0.021713257, -0.0036029816, -0.010818481, -0.056640625, -0.016098022, -0.012924194, -0.0569458, -0.037231445, -0.03604126, -0.01158905, 0.015838623, -0.026885986, -0.02671814, -0.006542206, 0.039398193, 0.058135986, 0.045837402, -0.012252808, -0.05630493, -0.03213501, -0.034576416, -0.009284973, 0.015960693, 0.008628845, -0.032592773, -0.03756714, 0.010177612, -0.005962372, 0.001499176, -0.0033836365, 0.014404297, -0.042907715, 0.054656982, -0.02279663, 0.02671814, 0.01335907, 0.027801514, 0.028793335, 0.016921997, -0.03378296, -0.05090332, 0.019821167, 0.034576416, -0.010795593, 0.011238098, 0.04333496, 0.02192688, -0.02268982, 0.017990112, 0.02720642, 0.041381836, -0.0076141357, -0.015670776, 0.024536133, -0.07556152, -0.034210205, -0.022827148, -0.016647339, 0.03463745, -0.070129395, 0.08001709, -0.025283813, -0.03289795, 0.045715332, 0.01939392, -0.016540527, 0.005504608, 0.0026397705, -0.08068848, -0.059173584, -0.030212402, 0.06915283, -0.042785645, -0.022216797, -0.0069999695, -0.002374649, 0.05038452, 0.023864746, -0.0010251999, 0.014816284, -0.041656494, 0.0015277863, 0.015342712, -0.039733887, -0.040161133, -0.009109497, -0.00022363663, 0.007698059, -0.055664062, 0.0104522705, -0.036712646, -0.023910522, -0.009056091, -0.00080156326, 0.026412964, -0.054382324, -0.0003027916, 0.05014038, 0.0029525757, -0.006095886, -0.0016775131, 0.02166748, -0.0026988983, 0.05859375, -0.0047302246, 0.034301758, 0.046936035, -0.052978516, 0.004863739, 0.0085372925, 0.052337646, -0.027648926, -0.025482178, 0.000828743, -0.033691406, -0.05621338, 0.02267456, -0.009483337, -0.026397705, 0.03955078, -0.049224854, 0.02607727, -0.0017662048, -0.023468018, 0.0028762817, -0.043029785, -0.021316528, 0.014892578, -0.05999756, -0.00844574, 0.044769287, -0.021911621, -0.031280518, -0.06185913, 0.015945435, -0.020339966, 0.006401062, -0.01612854, 0.026031494, -0.043518066, 0.022476196, 0.03186035, -0.01902771, -0.0069503784, -0.0043754578, 0.01586914, 0.03274536, 0.014289856, -0.031402588, 0.0022468567, 0.004459381, -0.049865723, -0.05569458, 0.020233154, -0.011581421, -0.035308838, 0.008361816, -0.035949707, -0.021240234, 0.009597778, 0.022415161, -0.035888672, -0.0062026978, 0.02885437, -0.0096588135, -0.0039405823, 0.015487671, 0.0005812645, -0.013893127, 0.015289307, 0.0061187744, 0.0023937225, -0.00083112717, 0.025558472, 0.033966064, -0.020339966, -0.0692749, -0.0034923553, 0.018203735, 0.021255493, -0.028762817, -0.01612854, 0.031707764, -0.06347656, 0.0045700073, -0.00006276369, 0.09283447, -0.0791626, -0.05770874, -0.0284729, -0.0030136108, -0.03479004, 0.046905518, -0.017684937, -0.064941406, -0.01637268, -0.08331299, -0.046325684, 0.016998291, 0.0597229, 0.014480591, 0.036193848, -0.05545044, 0.011489868, -0.03491211, 0.017944336, -0.022140503, -0.009544373, -0.014129639, 0.018692017, 0.0021400452, 0.029174805, 0.012763977, -0.050842285, 0.0035171509, 0.009002686, 0.033081055, -0.02470398, -0.013938904, -0.008003235, -0.030578613, -0.019577026, 0.04336548, 0.010566711, -0.0014886856, 0.050994873, -0.027999878, 0.033233643, 0.0053367615, 0.029052734, 0.03503418, 0.019851685, 0.007133484, -0.0074653625, 0.002008438, -0.03451538, -0.023239136, -0.05529785, -0.016464233, -0.05090332, -0.0074310303, -0.04232788, -0.018585205, 0.008705139, 0.050445557, 0.006866455, 0.017608643, 0.033569336, 0.0129852295, 0.029968262, -0.014526367, 0.06161499, 0.03652954, 0.003080368, -0.004425049, 0.02168274, 0.03439331, 0.029647827, 0.0051116943, 0.048858643, -0.007507324, -0.011383057, 0.0025520325, -0.004306793, 0.019058228, -0.0026359558, -0.0043029785, -0.020523071, 0.090026855, 0.01675415, 0.031799316, 0.06262207, 0.0690918, -0.057861328, -0.019119263, 0.022216797, 0.0033073425, 0.012710571, -0.02204895, 0.02758789, -0.025375366, 0.024642944, -0.011405945, -0.018859863, -0.023742676, 0.064331055, 0.00705719, -0.027893066, 0.025680542, 0.009361267, 0.008087158, -0.001964569, 0.020828247, -0.03375244, -0.020187378, 0.003566742, 0.022415161, -0.010604858, 0.008224487, 0.017684937, 0.006214142, -0.0029678345, -0.019515991, -0.0151901245, 0.034362793, -0.05581665, 0.021102905, 0.00073862076, 0.005558014, -0.0032844543, -0.04144287, 0.0065841675, 0.0027751923, -0.012161255, -0.012771606, 0.03918457, 0.0053520203, -0.002998352, 0.022766113, -0.0077400208, -0.03062439, -0.0064468384, -0.034332275, -0.0036067963, 0.057037354, -0.030288696, -0.0016832352, -0.015403748, -0.050476074, 0.020935059, -0.026626587, 0.072265625, -0.042541504, 0.020111084, -0.018585205, 0.0058898926, 0.017303467, -0.03656006, -0.022033691, 0.0031051636, -0.027038574, -0.0022964478, 0.025100708, -0.018066406, -0.03137207, 0.008285522, 0.016220093, 0.015777588, 0.0046424866, 0.0067367554, -0.018615723, -0.033996582, 0.039031982, -0.017120361, 0.07122803, -0.018600464, -0.014419556, -0.015411377, -0.018035889, 0.0046539307, 0.0066566467, 0.0038166046, -0.034362793, -0.05709839, -0.045776367, 0.037994385, 0.040252686, -0.02432251, -0.016967773, -0.0067825317, -0.011543274, -0.009017944, 0.0034828186, 0.04083252, -0.030151367, -0.06304932, -0.0007042885, -0.050476074, 0.037902832, 0.024642944, -0.012710571, -0.010002136, 0.026779175, -0.03149414, 0.023376465, 0.030578613, 0.07598877, -0.016174316, -0.06463623, 0.009536743, 0.038482666, 0.041412354, -0.012306213, -0.017105103, 0.041290283, 0.01727295, -0.011833191, 0.029281616, -0.016616821, -0.0014801025, 0.062683105, 0.02279663, 0.019638062, -0.04309082, -0.07354736, -0.049621582, 0.054351807, 0.028747559, -0.018234253, -0.03918457, 0.02961731, -0.0033187866, -0.009117126, 0.00034165382, -0.018173218, -0.00705719, -0.0007300377, 0.015220642, 0.00044441223, -0.017440796, 0.0028972626, 0.015625, 0.005104065, 0.04107666, -0.029022217, 0.0043525696, -0.0043907166, 0.034484863, -0.021087646, -0.014884949, 0.0637207, 0.012359619, 0.04537964, -0.0013141632, 0.028320312, 0.006996155, 0.0027122498, -0.025604248, -0.0031967163, -0.030319214, 0.052459717, -0.05834961, -0.015342712, -0.048217773, -0.0317688, 0.024017334, -0.02720642, 0.056243896, -0.030899048, 0.0021915436, -0.022216797, -0.019424438, -0.010421753, 0.019378662, -0.020935059, 0.00844574, -0.074523926, -0.09979248, 0.012336731, -0.025894165 ], "summary": [ -0.0077781677, 0.022216797, 0.0010700226, 0.03616333, -0.0048599243, -0.025009155, 0.0039749146, -0.072631836, 0.04248047, 0.025924683, -0.041656494, 0.015975952, 0.043121338, -0.031433105, -0.002111435, -0.011627197, 0.021331787, -0.001748085, 0.020202637, -0.014884949, -0.0015335083, 0.00141716, 0.06591797, 0.038238525, 0.031982422, -0.0044822693, -0.041046143, 0.037384033, 0.012817383, 0.033203125, 0.027404785, -0.02909851, 0.008026123, 0.013511658, 0.012390137, -0.0037612915, -0.009742737, 0.024383545, 0.020553589, 0.0014266968, 0.015899658, -0.01876831, 0.08935547, -0.0024642944, 0.028823853, 0.03845215, -0.016433716, -0.07409668, -0.026657104, -0.042144775, 0.03604126, -0.0211792, 0.04547119, -0.03366089, -0.00044608116, 0.036132812, -0.05117798, -0.033843994, 0.013900757, 0.12683105, 0.030166626, -0.00894928, -0.016494751, -0.07922363, -0.013465881, -0.012641907, -0.0053863525, 0.007583618, 0.038024902, 0.007171631, 0.0076179504, 0.019622803, 0.025848389, -0.005268097, -0.026397705, -0.036254883, 0.05734253, 0.016479492, -0.0074272156, -0.011695862, 0.0054016113, 0.008338928, 0.016937256, -0.05859375, 0.022598267, -0.041534424, -0.010688782, 0.009239197, -0.04510498, -0.06008911, -0.026428223, -0.035614014, -0.089782715, -0.0017175674, 0.014076233, -0.039123535, -0.032104492, -0.03112793, -0.017807007, -0.021987915, -0.015579224, 0.0110321045, -0.06384277, 0.016189575, -0.007171631, -0.030776978, -0.009712219, -0.039916992, 0.0026607513, 0.03729248, -0.052581787, 0.031158447, 0.0018663406, -0.06323242, -0.016662598, 0.060302734, 0.033721924, -0.009033203, 0.025848389, -0.009117126, -0.039733887, -0.0039405823, -0.011955261, 0.016494751, 0.014701843, 0.00409317, 0.031173706, -0.0057907104, -0.06512451, 0.030471802, 0.019561768, 0.017196655, -0.04928589, -0.014350891, -0.06842041, -0.009048462, 0.01499939, 0.0011329651, 0.0146865845, -0.0657959, 0.0871582, 0.008468628, -0.020950317, 0.059631348, -0.011390686, -0.0068511963, 0.007888794, 0.03378296, 0.016799927, -0.027938843, 0.025772095, -0.015701294, 0.028411865, -0.011001587, -0.021697998, -0.030075073, -0.05026245, 0.0027866364, 0.020217896, -0.0041122437, 0.02268982, -0.012687683, -0.007133484, 0.03668213, 0.011985779, 0.0063705444, -0.02456665, 0.0013027191, 0.019363403, -0.028778076, 0.016403198, 0.010597229, 0.06201172, -0.014274597, 0.0046806335, 0.00028800964, -0.039154053, 0.017944336, 0.029968262, -0.0028266907, -0.014564514, -0.03704834, 0.0011978149, 0.021911621, 0.0040893555, -0.08312988, 0.02029419, 0.0053596497, 0.01789856, 0.019454956, 0.012062073, -0.033569336, -0.019424438, 0.02293396, 0.000992775, 0.0020141602, -0.049804688, 0.0019369125, -0.029830933, -0.0132751465, -0.008972168, 0.003282547, 0.0098724365, -0.001953125, -0.00970459, -0.032928467, -0.0010404587, 0.014984131, -0.0074272156, -0.018997192, 0.0029392242, -0.03765869, -0.0042877197, -0.0010499954, -0.0067634583, 0.017623901, 0.016494751, -0.007843018, 0.019943237, -0.031173706, 0.019470215, -0.006160736, -0.0071411133, 0.0038204193, 0.040130615, 0.01084137, 0.008346558, -0.00019919872, 0.093933105, 0.012786865, 0.041259766, -0.008674622, -0.046936035, -0.06951904, -0.064086914, 0.008239746, -0.031585693, -0.045135498, 0.010246277, 0.046447754, 0.022109985, 0.009552002, -0.003818512, 0.047210693, 0.044403076, -0.03390503, -0.020431519, 0.018753052, -0.0096588135, 0.044006348, 0.024307251, 0.012420654, 0.016021729, -0.003118515, -0.0028305054, 0.026184082, 0.02947998, 0.009239197, 0.033172607, -0.015808105, -0.0006418228, 0.01285553, -0.031234741, 0.017089844, -0.015380859, -0.036132812, -0.043640137, -0.04888916, -0.0070762634, -0.015701294, 0.015449524, -0.07165527, 0.0024356842, -0.025421143, -0.07232666, 0.005996704, -0.020080566, 0.050323486, -0.0155181885, -0.043762207, -0.0051879883, 0.043762207, -0.0146865845, -0.029678345, -0.0054626465, -0.018493652, -0.015716553, -0.01940918, 0.024032593, 0.0110321045, 0.014854431, 0.03717041, 0.008277893, 0.016952515, 0.028793335, -0.011528015, -0.0048179626, -0.026916504, 0.017654419, -0.0496521, 0.02255249, 0.038879395, -0.017196655, 0.001335144, 0.008392334, -0.0075416565, -0.002811432, 0.0041046143, 0.001543045, -0.012336731, -0.02658081, 0.010345459, 0.0023326874, 0.09246826, -0.074035645, -0.07141113, -0.017929077, 0.010391235, -0.0309906, -0.026138306, -0.007534027, 0.030151367, 0.0018291473, -0.021774292, 0.013504028, 0.00881958, -0.03741455, -0.0031166077, -0.015396118, 0.0131073, 0.00844574, -0.012458801, -0.010421753, 0.008392334, 0.0074310303, -0.005382538, 0.013847351, 0.04446411, -0.004711151, -0.033813477, 0.005054474, 0.030151367, 0.009994507, 0.028625488, -0.06201172, 0.070739746, -0.012458801, 0.010543823, -0.09729004, -0.0031585693, 0.018478394, -0.0385437, -0.039398193, 0.031982422, -0.0020618439, -0.017318726, 0.045288086, -0.010017395, -0.025436401, -0.032958984, 0.032989502, 0.012107849, 0.022232056, -0.032928467, -0.060272217, -0.029815674, -0.0025081635, 0.0046539307, -0.025726318, 0.015792847, -0.055725098, -0.014831543, -0.006626129, 0.0007176399, -0.0008749962, 0.051239014, 0.06829834, -0.01928711, -0.036499023, 0.018966675, -0.01586914, 0.00046730042, -0.034362793, -0.0033912659, 0.025131226, 0.009498596, -0.045043945, 0.012565613, 0.022445679, 0.013580322, -0.0072250366, 0.016448975, 0.022781372, -0.021484375, 0.010177612, -0.001821518, 0.021057129, -0.01121521, -0.002822876, -0.037719727, 0.10723877, -0.015510559, 0.0018863678, 0.015419006, -0.012809753, -0.015686035, 0.054779053, 0.02659607, 0.012718201, 0.030944824, -0.016693115, 0.0076026917, -0.007419586, -0.0036239624, 0.023239136, -0.020446777, -0.003074646, 0.012954712, -0.020309448, 0.006252289, 0.0008006096, 0.023239136, -0.03060913, -0.0073776245, 0.010292053, 0.00078487396, 0.0010032654, -0.01939392, 0.035888672, 0.037109375, -0.0013370514, 0.000014960766, -0.017715454, -0.03540039, -0.010177612, 0.0006542206, -0.03677368, -0.03640747, -0.012863159, -0.010437012, -0.008590698, -0.010475159, 0.01576233, 0.02519226, 0.017501831, -0.015159607, -0.02420044, -0.0036964417, -0.01889038, 0.015380859, -0.025909424, -0.015022278, -0.0063934326, 0.036499023, -0.02166748, 0.090148926, 0.019332886, 0.0021514893, 0.06213379, -0.051757812, -0.045135498, 0.0036296844, -0.05847168, -0.024871826, 0.0010166168, 0.015586853, -0.033813477, 0.024917603, -0.019821167, -0.021194458, 0.026794434, 0.004245758, -0.015945435, -0.0463562, 0.06274414, 0.005340576, -0.018157959, -0.05517578, 0.055389404, 0.025848389, -0.045928955, 0.017593384, -0.08874512, -0.026245117, -0.026489258, 0.019927979, -0.04260254, -0.033325195, 0.024047852, -0.023391724, 0.005428314, -0.06286621, 0.012290955, 0.0060157776, -0.023864746, 0.018661499, 0.0010967255, 0.024246216, 0.00066661835, -0.015586853, -0.038024902, -0.023849487, 0.001326561, -0.0061950684, -0.023666382, 0.03805542, 0.0446167, -0.0033931732, -0.028396606, -0.049713135, 0.058898926, -0.062072754, -0.013214111, 0.021362305, -0.036376953, 0.033325195, -0.015220642, 0.018508911, -0.017105103, 0.00058221817, 0.030303955, 0.020095825, -0.0043563843, 0.036743164, -0.017425537, -0.005203247, -0.053466797, -0.027450562, -0.021453857, -0.023345947, 0.0057678223, -0.00081443787, -0.033172607, 0.00793457, 0.054351807, 0.04373169, 0.02027893, -0.04928589, -0.047576904, -0.0026874542, 0.019958496, 0.011871338, -0.009284973, -0.026168823, -0.019241333, 0.026504517, 0.013626099, 0.027435303, -0.03050232, -0.026168823, 0.02027893, 0.043060303, 0.004131317, -0.031402588, -0.036743164, 0.028244019, 0.018539429, -0.019302368, -0.02798462, 0.013580322, -0.000035643578, 0.0019626617, -0.02166748, 0.022155762, -0.040283203, 0.020324707, -0.023605347, -0.04144287, -0.060760498, -0.008132935, -0.031066895, -0.018981934, -0.05529785, -0.038909912, -0.043701172, 0.0025424957, -0.02519226, -0.00983429, 0.035949707, 0.061462402, 0.01878357, 0.011520386, -0.053100586, -0.08526611, -0.03137207, -0.021469116, 0.0062408447, -0.022140503, -0.04196167, -0.046417236, 0.020889282, 0.011787415, 0.014823914, 0.01663208, 0.004333496, -0.04724121, 0.0345459, -0.047546387, 0.026229858, 0.004055023, 0.03704834, 0.017669678, 0.012580872, 0.002626419, -0.08514404, 0.014022827, -0.007724762, 0.025817871, 0.011550903, 0.023788452, 0.021224976, -0.023040771, 0.00592041, 0.033416748, 0.031677246, -0.030761719, 0.004573822, 0.0051231384, -0.029418945, -0.04168701, -0.010169983, -0.021697998, -0.0149002075, -0.013320923, 0.07659912, 0.0038452148, -0.04776001, 0.047698975, 0.011680603, -0.023361206, 0.016159058, -0.013755798, -0.054534912, -0.04046631, -0.010902405, 0.055603027, -0.02519226, -0.011299133, -0.02999878, -0.052520752, 0.041229248, -0.018371582, -0.011207581, 0.0037212372, -0.032287598, 0.011138916, 0.03390503, 0.0030403137, 0.00038218498, -0.039154053, 0.020095825, -0.010040283, -0.036315918, 0.0023880005, -0.0048828125, -0.016281128, -0.013908386, 0.018096924, 0.017852783, -0.038848877, -0.076416016, -0.008125305, 0.011329651, -0.044677734, -0.017166138, 0.010154724, -0.039520264, 0.021102905, -0.028915405, 0.010627747, 0.015701294, -0.046844482, -0.0017900467, -0.008148193, 0.03945923, -0.011558533, -0.04849243, 0.018249512, -0.036712646, -0.025863647, -0.0017271042, -0.0541687, -0.00969696, 0.005138397, -0.0005030632, 0.04156494, -0.0023269653, -0.0046958923, -0.0049972534, -0.021087646, -0.013008118, 0.005001068, -0.03189087, -0.0001912117, 0.04095459, -0.021392822, -0.012260437, -0.03012085, 0.029663086, -0.03250122, 0.0132751465, -0.00052690506, 0.00680542, -0.018081665, -0.025466919, 0.025161743, 0.0146102905, 0.0026359558, 0.0069618225, 0.01939392, -0.0042533875, -0.029281616, 0.0033168793, 0.007419586, 0.001709938, -0.017944336, -0.00737381, 0.018707275, -0.01737976, -0.015106201, 0.020858765, -0.0061912537, 0.016937256, -0.014770508, 0.017578125, -0.046142578, 0.012817383, 0.021057129, -0.022903442, -0.026184082, 0.05618286, -0.021652222, -0.06173706, 0.042236328, 0.030776978, -0.0015554428, -0.003742218, 0.03463745, 0.048736572, -0.047210693, -0.06390381, 0.0012083054, 0.031463623, 0.029388428, -0.003118515, -0.025039673, 0.026519775, -0.075683594, 0.000021576881, 0.0073928833, 0.06591797, -0.07751465, -0.066345215, -0.032989502, 0.0140686035, -0.018035889, 0.008026123, 0.00078105927, -0.06286621, 0.013877869, -0.06732178, -0.022750854, -0.014381409, 0.046661377, -0.007080078, 0.021575928, -0.038513184, -0.011062622, -0.009513855, 0.024261475, -0.027572632, -0.02079773, -0.027450562, 0.010040283, 0.026611328, 0.03842163, 0.020263672, -0.022216797, -0.036987305, -0.01966858, 0.010917664, -0.012954712, 0.005001068, 0.018966675, -0.03237915, 0.03665161, 0.030334473, 0.034240723, 0.007461548, 0.023345947, -0.011512756, 0.0129470825, -0.006324768, -0.015930176, -0.019714355, -0.006881714, 0.013954163, -0.008987427, 0.004508972, -0.013381958, -0.034210205, -0.003824234, -0.061340332, -0.028961182, -0.023468018, 0.023361206, 0.00030088425, -0.016220093, 0.013313293, 0.022079468, 0.018417358, 0.033233643, 0.02217102, 0.00077295303, -0.024154663, 0.032318115, 0.05441284, -0.0042648315, 0.003458023, 0.026351929, -0.0042762756, 0.02458191, 0.039916992, 0.021606445, -0.011657715, 0.008766174, 0.009498596, -0.027542114, -0.004169464, -0.015365601, 0.02104187, -0.018127441, 0.09320068, 0.040283203, 0.052124023, 0.04940796, 0.04083252, -0.008651733, -0.031402588, 0.033233643, 0.010307312, 0.024261475, -0.035461426, -0.0053520203, -0.005718231, -0.011230469, 0.0061531067, 0.011077881, -0.011413574, 0.057891846, 0.018539429, -0.0019683838, 0.05911255, -0.031173706, -0.006465912, -0.03604126, -0.008255005, -0.034332275, 0.0012702942, 0.006011963, -0.013442993, 0.014083862, -0.017822266, -0.019226074, -0.010757446, 0.015266418, -0.01033783, -0.02696228, 0.03845215, -0.037872314, 0.011627197, 0.019241333, -0.0043563843, 0.012382507, -0.021072388, 0.012580872, 0.007865906, 0.0045547485, 0.03302002, 0.0068092346, 0.024414062, 0.005554199, -0.0019054413, -0.0690918, -0.022140503, 0.061340332, -0.012275696, -0.0044174194, 0.041534424, -0.021621704, -0.031555176, 0.0071029663, -0.015731812, 0.016662598, -0.009811401, 0.049316406, -0.04269409, 0.02482605, -0.014877319, 0.0023555756, -0.05493164, 0.010848999, -0.006942749, 0.017700195, -0.030410767, 0.015235901, 0.054840088, 0.00019013882, 0.018325806, -0.0149002075, -0.0289917, 0.0061950684, 0.013587952, 0.018630981, 0.0044021606, -0.018417358, 0.038482666, -0.009811401, 0.079833984, -0.016220093, -0.03387451, -0.005695343, -0.020614624, 0.009384155, 0.007965088, 0.039001465, -0.04336548, -0.058044434, -0.06933594, 0.046081543, 0.019180298, -0.036621094, -0.03253174, 0.026779175, -0.022537231, -0.013870239, 0.034820557, 0.04333496, -0.016830444, -0.050720215, 0.010620117, -0.04849243, 0.0692749, 0.014205933, -0.0032157898, -0.021331787, 0.03643799, -0.01902771, 0.035491943, 0.05581665, 0.079589844, -0.04208374, -0.09887695, 0.034332275, -0.010879517, 0.013336182, 0.035247803, 0.023803711, 0.07647705, -0.0049476624, -0.005645752, -0.035980225, -0.0256958, -0.017990112, 0.07922363, 0.0030765533, 0.016937256, -0.030380249, -0.06500244, -0.03817749, 0.03540039, 0.004737854, -0.022079468, -0.015853882, 0.035827637, -0.028747559, -0.034301758, -0.007133484, 0.008529663, -0.05105591, 0.01260376, -0.0066604614, -0.015914917, -0.034820557, 0.0009756088, -0.01651001, -0.0024471283, 0.014297485, -0.025527954, 0.012130737, -0.018707275, 0.0035152435, 0.006477356, 0.052215576, 0.012207031, -0.049316406, 0.068115234, -0.0657959, 0.06414795, 0.038513184, 0.031463623, -0.040771484, -0.00086307526, -0.06185913, 0.05429077, -0.10192871, -0.075927734, -0.018981934, 0.013626099, 0.011260986, 0.003955841, 0.02017212, 0.002943039, -0.011627197, 0.01335144, -0.03161621, 0.008544922, -0.0077819824, -0.031204224, 0.041748047, -0.04940796, -0.10321045, -0.041259766, -0.0017690659 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2106.13121v1
Real-time Spatio-temporal Event Detection on Geotagged Social Media
Yasmeen George, Shanika Karunasekera, Aaron Harwood, Kwan Hui Lim
cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.LG
A key challenge in mining social media data streams is to identify events which are actively discussed by a group of people in a specific local or global area. Such events are useful for early warning for accident, protest, election or breaking news. However, neither the list of events nor the resolution of both event time and space is fixed or known beforehand. In this work, we propose an online spatio-temporal event detection system using social media that is able to detect events at different time and space resolutions. First, to address the challenge related to the unknown spatial resolution of events, a quad-tree method is exploited in order to split the geographical space into multiscale regions based on the density of social media data. Then, a statistical unsupervised approach is performed that involves Poisson distribution and a smoothing method for highlighting regions with unexpected density of social posts. Further, event duration is precisely estimated by merging events happening in the same region at consecutive time intervals. A post processing stage is introduced to filter out events that are spam, fake or wrong. Finally, we incorporate simple semantics by using social media entities to assess the integrity, and accuracy of detected events. The proposed method is evaluated using different social media datasets: Twitter and Flickr for different cities: Melbourne, London, Paris and New York. To verify the effectiveness of the proposed method, we compare our results with two baseline algorithms based on fixed split of geographical space and clustering method. For performance evaluation, we manually compute recall and precision. We also propose a new quality measure named strength index, which automatically measures how accurate the reported event is.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2106.13121v1
"2021-06-23T07:14:03"
"2021-06-23T07:14:03"
{ "title": [ 0.04321289, 0.015434265, -0.003993988, -0.06896973, 0.043151855, -0.008361816, -0.004119873, -0.030883789, -0.0003476143, 0.03564453, -0.03414917, 0.026535034, -0.0034732819, -0.00033473969, -0.03555298, 0.004119873, 0.0044937134, 0.02746582, -0.008422852, -0.036254883, -0.003042221, -0.023742676, 0.045562744, 0.038848877, 0.041046143, -0.044311523, -0.026641846, -0.009086609, 0.003528595, -0.033050537, -0.00013780594, 0.0017261505, 0.046722412, 0.0574646, -0.0574646, 0.024627686, -0.049621582, 0.033325195, -0.01158905, 0.036468506, 0.002922058, 0.012306213, -0.010192871, 0.011993408, -0.043273926, 0.017959595, -0.07922363, -0.019119263, -0.056915283, 0.032043457, 0.02684021, 0.004673004, 0.0128479, 0.01802063, 0.020355225, -0.05154419, -0.04812622, 0.022415161, 0.032592773, 0.05307007, 0.031066895, -0.035461426, -0.00036859512, -0.01436615, -0.0463562, -0.0047302246, 0.01789856, 0.0047454834, 0.020553589, -0.037719727, 0.004673004, 0.017684937, -0.011444092, 0.0063819885, -0.031677246, 0.0012226105, 0.043273926, -0.003435135, 0.011123657, 0.0073509216, -0.026641846, -0.0079422, -0.00035715103, -0.03768921, 0.013893127, -0.0357666, -0.02178955, -0.010787964, -0.059631348, -0.08203125, -0.015090942, -0.022399902, -0.06939697, 0.0022525787, -0.012390137, -0.029220581, 0.007419586, 0.08508301, -0.02053833, -0.048309326, -0.03201294, 0.041778564, -0.12023926, -0.0058555603, 0.017288208, 0.030807495, -0.0138168335, -0.0074043274, 0.011558533, 0.025314331, -0.027297974, 0.01473999, 0.020568848, 0.021347046, -0.026031494, -0.0035572052, -0.003660202, -0.012290955, 0.0038471222, 0.012626648, 0.0028419495, -0.028778076, -0.010307312, 0.022064209, 0.0357666, -0.0034046173, -0.047058105, 0.025360107, 0.014541626, 0.02444458, 0.014404297, 0.039489746, -0.10626221, -0.101623535, -0.078308105, 0.04711914, 0.025527954, -0.04083252, -0.005542755, 0.021728516, 0.012283325, -0.029022217, -0.018112183, 0.018508911, 0.01838684, 0.0018873215, 0.057159424, 0.020568848, -0.060333252, -0.024215698, 0.0017471313, 0.014968872, 0.053619385, -0.039489746, -0.04562378, -0.046966553, -0.064819336, -0.057800293, 0.001329422, -0.037109375, 0.03491211, -0.007545471, 0.000831604, 0.007881165, 0.020828247, 0.0074806213, -0.03338623, -0.0013427734, 0.005378723, 0.013641357, -0.012626648, 0.017440796, 0.0010623932, -0.008560181, -0.00920105, -0.00043797493, 0.029174805, 0.0027713776, 0.024490356, 0.0137786865, -0.006942749, -0.018997192, 0.014198303, 0.03982544, -0.074035645, -0.00919342, 0.0066337585, 0.02494812, 0.053466797, 0.013938904, -0.017501831, 0.027679443, -0.0345459, -0.030761719, -0.024917603, -0.013435364, 0.013442993, 0.015991211, 0.0025043488, 0.0028648376, -0.036224365, 0.0016422272, -0.03942871, 0.013893127, 0.00012481213, -0.03012085, -0.0041542053, 0.02116394, 0.007331848, 0.05947876, 0.025283813, 0.016174316, -0.015045166, -0.023086548, 0.001373291, -0.026046753, 0.029464722, -0.015289307, -0.01676941, -0.0071372986, -0.058624268, 0.022277832, -0.03265381, 0.020111084, 0.037353516, -0.007789612, 0.014709473, -0.03387451, 0.07305908, 0.012008667, 0.06768799, -0.029510498, 0.015777588, -0.015235901, -0.019165039, -0.012519836, -0.028717041, -0.021347046, 0.010101318, 0.027114868, 0.0038414001, -0.017684937, -0.005748749, 0.034942627, 0.042114258, -0.031951904, 0.005378723, 0.034118652, 0.021194458, 0.034973145, 0.016983032, 0.007797241, 0.055603027, -0.00051546097, -0.02645874, 0.06958008, 0.005504608, 0.01235199, -0.052215576, 0.019836426, 0.00869751, 0.0030498505, -0.0035972595, 0.0010023117, -0.037017822, 0.009605408, -0.018829346, 0.0012483597, -0.0006804466, 0.020843506, 0.024124146, -0.029159546, 0.014129639, 0.008232117, -0.012573242, 0.0031089783, 0.0069847107, 0.009223938, 0.006893158, -0.044036865, -0.021621704, -0.003686905, -0.0038871765, -0.01512146, 0.030410767, -0.028930664, -0.00440979, -0.043426514, -0.00566864, -0.033233643, 0.03778076, 0.030029297, 0.002462387, -0.00032234192, 0.02720642, -0.022155762, 0.1083374, 0.07470703, -0.024765015, 0.047821045, -0.03930664, 0.016204834, -0.0057792664, 0.0068244934, 0.005962372, -0.0029335022, 0.020187378, 0.017471313, -0.03237915, 0.0012969971, -0.05819702, 0.018630981, 0.01625061, -0.06011963, -0.027908325, -0.0262146, 0.00030446053, -0.04498291, -0.07232666, -0.022659302, 0.05645752, -0.053253174, -0.01802063, -0.004146576, -0.03729248, -0.023895264, 0.012069702, -0.031433105, -0.053497314, 0.04486084, 0.04928589, 0.036865234, -0.009567261, 0.0069465637, -0.013717651, 0.015113831, -0.01335907, -0.007575989, -0.022521973, -0.0029907227, 0.006931305, -0.032928467, 0.010025024, -0.03552246, 0.0066070557, -0.039794922, 0.03515625, 0.026687622, -0.07019043, 0.0021705627, 0.025344849, -0.044799805, -0.019622803, 0.0073432922, 0.066833496, -0.021469116, -0.042297363, 0.02230835, 0.038360596, -0.025756836, -0.00041127205, 0.01802063, -0.016311646, -0.04800415, -0.007709503, -0.015510559, -0.012466431, -0.00058555603, 0.03237915, 0.06970215, -0.045684814, 0.002002716, -0.03050232, 0.004146576, 0.031463623, -0.008911133, -0.086242676, -0.06008911, -0.00554657, -0.0637207, -0.028121948, -0.040496826, 0.02243042, -0.012123108, 0.078308105, 0.009521484, -0.017364502, -0.012077332, 0.032836914, 0.0014104843, -0.015075684, -0.010017395, -0.06100464, 0.009170532, 0.01171875, -0.012825012, 0.017105103, 0.02078247, -0.11968994, -0.015899658, 0.009246826, 0.010597229, -0.0076675415, 0.013648987, -0.059783936, 0.003107071, -0.03048706, -0.01626587, 0.02468872, 0.027450562, -0.018325806, 0.025772095, -0.011558533, -0.015586853, 0.005558014, -0.02998352, -0.06561279, 0.034729004, -0.011360168, -0.06518555, -0.012321472, -0.04135132, -0.030471802, -0.012321472, 0.0011863708, 0.0317688, 0.024002075, -0.017181396, 0.011947632, 0.034118652, 0.009170532, -0.005718231, -0.0005931854, -0.005710602, -0.039276123, 0.007335663, -0.012611389, 0.036315918, 0.02760315, -0.022232056, -0.031433105, 0.0042304993, -0.010093689, 0.020370483, 0.0011234283, -0.031021118, 0.01852417, -0.017990112, -0.0041618347, 0.025634766, -0.013900757, 0.0011920929, -0.016540527, 0.00008583069, -0.01725769, -0.0209198, -0.0054893494, 0.008529663, -0.014625549, -0.017974854, 0.021087646, -0.021759033, -0.05496216, 0.017547607, 0.031051636, -0.008232117, 0.009521484, -0.00040602684, -0.012763977, 0.02470398, 0.009346008, -0.0036334991, -0.012413025, -0.029266357, 0.004837036, -0.006286621, 0.0050697327, 0.034362793, -0.032104492, -0.03237915, 0.018112183, 0.009757996, -0.020858765, -0.08709717, -0.018676758, -0.0041770935, -0.13256836, -0.028518677, 0.010696411, -0.038238525, -0.04953003, -0.034210205, 0.005378723, -0.0002834797, -0.032836914, 0.020141602, -0.008239746, -0.02734375, -0.006290436, -0.06085205, -0.047729492, 0.080200195, -0.010116577, 0.010749817, 0.022888184, -0.006000519, 0.004550934, -0.03591919, 0.019348145, 0.005382538, 0.039093018, -0.0061187744, -0.024169922, 0.043701172, -0.038085938, -0.0017709732, 0.055419922, -0.011146545, 0.002773285, 0.007545471, 0.027770996, 0.0390625, -0.023910522, 0.0680542, -0.0017623901, -0.021530151, -0.07043457, -0.0071792603, -0.0064086914, 0.0071144104, -0.008117676, -0.0395813, -0.0015335083, 0.0008187294, 0.046966553, 0.056549072, -0.0066223145, 0.008758545, 0.049957275, -0.0028839111, 0.002084732, -0.008003235, 0.017730713, 0.016159058, 0.0020332336, 0.03439331, -0.015220642, 0.027618408, -0.0049476624, -0.020965576, -0.020233154, 0.0026741028, -0.031204224, -0.023147583, -0.06958008, -0.014442444, -0.000041604042, 0.025756836, -0.022918701, -0.003944397, 0.028686523, 0.0029201508, -0.041137695, 0.014884949, 0.033691406, 0.00091457367, 0.011207581, -0.043823242, 0.003583908, -0.013763428, -0.06298828, -0.032318115, -0.021560669, 0.0017490387, 0.036865234, 0.0031204224, -0.0014219284, 0.027175903, 0.0132751465, 0.021652222, 0.0435791, -0.025680542, -0.041656494, 0.053497314, -0.012916565, -0.028640747, 0.019973755, 0.010253906, -0.01398468, -0.032958984, 0.0057678223, -0.018310547, -0.027374268, -0.033050537, 0.023376465, -0.02166748, 0.03869629, 0.034820557, 0.08050537, 0.018661499, -0.0011606216, 0.013961792, 0.024673462, -0.03692627, -0.018936157, 0.002117157, 0.017120361, -0.002937317, 0.018341064, 0.04055786, 0.005542755, 0.015052795, -0.010353088, -0.0065574646, 0.021133423, -0.0004169941, 0.019561768, 0.013793945, -0.032928467, -0.037872314, 0.004486084, 0.023910522, 0.05340576, -0.039489746, 0.0703125, -0.01966858, -0.019424438, 0.027664185, 0.007095337, -0.011116028, -0.026428223, 0.00090169907, -0.055389404, -0.05545044, -0.008651733, 0.044311523, -0.023483276, -0.009765625, -0.0030708313, 0.022583008, 0.022491455, 0.047912598, 0.041168213, 0.014823914, -0.010070801, -0.006801605, 0.0077590942, -0.021224976, -0.031234741, 0.018951416, 0.030914307, 0.021835327, -0.036102295, 0.008872986, -0.035339355, -0.005191803, -0.03741455, 0.004398346, -0.004837036, -0.047668457, 0.025466919, 0.07714844, 0.031707764, 0.051940918, -0.018569946, 0.010131836, 0.04864502, 0.042388916, 0.016586304, -0.00036478043, 0.039916992, -0.04852295, -0.025787354, 0.009208679, 0.024841309, 0.008766174, 0.0054397583, 0.026062012, -0.021774292, -0.032348633, 0.025115967, 0.001698494, -0.017684937, 0.028121948, -0.0524292, 0.0033874512, -0.004096985, 0.005504608, 0.021453857, -0.0038833618, -0.036376953, -0.022842407, 0.011421204, -0.026626587, -0.009590149, 0.026290894, -0.035247803, -0.045654297, 0.02557373, -0.024917603, -0.0006322861, -0.002073288, 0.006401062, -0.024139404, 0.026275635, 0.036621094, -0.031463623, 0.011108398, -0.013671875, 0.0068588257, 0.039764404, 0.03604126, -0.011268616, 0.0060806274, -0.02003479, -0.039520264, -0.08312988, -0.008659363, -0.0025424957, 0.02128601, -0.023971558, -0.034698486, -0.006336212, -0.006893158, 0.01751709, 0.0022296906, -0.026306152, 0.020568848, 0.0004618168, 0.0018968582, 0.013206482, 0.007621765, 0.020065308, -0.0003077984, -0.0062026978, -0.04953003, 0.014930725, 0.032104492, 0.044311523, -0.04159546, -0.08203125, -0.0023441315, 0.026306152, 0.013893127, -0.02458191, 0.017745972, 0.029556274, -0.01878357, -0.012771606, -0.012481689, 0.0345459, -0.03149414, 0.017288208, -0.022003174, -0.0025501251, -0.09222412, 0.015083313, 0.007965088, 0.032226562, -0.055145264, -0.048797607, -0.0287323, 0.011161804, 0.021591187, 0.0022354126, 0.026519775, -0.04611206, 0.015586853, -0.014663696, -0.010673523, -0.0340271, 0.032440186, 0.022033691, 0.038024902, -0.029373169, -0.01411438, -0.012626648, -0.009788513, 0.045288086, -0.00019812584, -0.016860962, 0.01108551, 0.012580872, 0.012313843, -0.025970459, -0.017654419, 0.057617188, -0.0018968582, -0.0017671585, 0.053100586, -0.009300232, 0.036590576, 0.01727295, 0.04031372, 0.051239014, 0.030807495, 0.010505676, -0.002412796, 0.015029907, -0.036346436, 0.0059051514, -0.06518555, -0.034820557, -0.06185913, -0.022109985, -0.06774902, -0.013954163, 0.0035991669, 0.01889038, -0.0032863617, 0.010276794, 0.0016708374, -0.0033111572, 0.053649902, -0.016311646, 0.038879395, -0.015419006, 0.025299072, -0.0317688, -0.03274536, 0.044830322, 0.03656006, -0.0067214966, 0.018630981, -0.0040779114, -0.007701874, 0.0006699562, 0.019180298, 0.022201538, 0.0009946823, 0.0051002502, -0.01940918, 0.026016235, -0.0072021484, 0.035980225, 0.025863647, 0.025619507, 0.020828247, -0.020828247, -0.013259888, 0.020401001, 0.002571106, -0.0069885254, 0.04611206, -0.02532959, -0.0029067993, -0.015792847, -0.022598267, 0.009597778, 0.0068740845, 0.038024902, -0.08984375, -0.04208374, 0.011245728, 0.038848877, -0.024505615, 0.026245117, -0.033813477, -0.023376465, -0.002418518, 0.023620605, -0.015716553, -0.020446777, 0.0038852692, 0.04638672, -0.025360107, -0.034606934, 0.021499634, -0.025848389, -0.0022087097, 0.037017822, -0.0068588257, 0.018997192, -0.0056419373, -0.032348633, 0.017150879, -0.003604889, -0.012962341, -0.021972656, 0.06604004, -0.002653122, -0.007534027, 0.039031982, 0.027145386, -0.029083252, -0.04348755, -0.043304443, -0.013725281, 0.03744507, -0.03616333, 0.0071144104, -0.029800415, -0.03060913, 0.019104004, -0.03237915, 0.020889282, -0.07550049, 0.013061523, -0.015975952, 0.010948181, 0.018737793, -0.047058105, -0.018188477, -0.028076172, -0.0035095215, -0.015853882, -0.022583008, -0.04989624, -0.04751587, -0.010566711, 0.037841797, -0.011207581, -0.0036525726, 0.008140564, -0.016967773, -0.06878662, -0.01713562, -0.045318604, 0.016464233, -0.03604126, -0.015571594, -0.014533997, 0.0041770935, -0.014541626, 0.010543823, 0.0049591064, -0.0027980804, -0.044891357, -0.033843994, 0.010116577, 0.013954163, -0.025558472, -0.058898926, 0.044128418, -0.01524353, -0.026519775, 0.0030536652, 0.05230713, -0.040161133, -0.06774902, -0.0069847107, -0.036834717, 0.03656006, 0.014770508, -0.000059127808, 0.0011425018, 0.048797607, -0.028640747, -0.041625977, -0.019577026, 0.0016880035, 0.0067825317, -0.024490356, -0.023757935, 0.036895752, 0.0049095154, -0.069885254, -0.039489746, 0.015342712, 0.06903076, -0.024612427, 0.036315918, 0.0015077591, -0.0062561035, 0.044769287, 0.033050537, 0.025527954, -0.052703857, -0.061309814, -0.042419434, 0.01398468, 0.039978027, 0.01940918, -0.045318604, 0.04159546, 0.0036525726, 0.008674622, 0.0039520264, -0.0155181885, 0.003145218, -0.003627777, 0.022247314, -0.0020866394, -0.029754639, -0.0031051636, 0.05114746, -0.006389618, 0.05029297, -0.022994995, 0.004699707, 0.009811401, 0.009796143, -0.014282227, -0.081970215, 0.04083252, 0.03024292, -0.0024147034, 0.04144287, 0.008079529, -0.036590576, -0.016998291, -0.035705566, -0.011222839, -0.035247803, 0.062927246, -0.09765625, -0.0010118484, -0.04598999, -0.017990112, 0.0357666, -0.038970947, 0.042419434, -0.04458618, 0.0000872612, -0.057373047, 0.015602112, -0.02935791, 0.027420044, -0.03817749, -0.052612305, -0.020553589, -0.03378296, 0.043945312, -0.008163452 ], "summary": [ 0.0927124, 0.03225708, 0.034454346, -0.021652222, 0.03186035, -0.013595581, 0.0041160583, -0.07196045, 0.024124146, 0.034332275, -0.046661377, 0.021377563, 0.01058197, -0.0014333725, -0.0101623535, -0.023834229, 0.006954193, 0.03869629, 0.013702393, -0.020507812, 0.005870819, -0.019104004, 0.0013790131, 0.018249512, 0.01399231, -0.0013895035, 0.064331055, -0.018112183, 0.04824829, 0.026504517, 0.019317627, -0.062561035, 0.0009303093, 0.0619812, -0.038757324, -0.006969452, -0.012954712, 0.03074646, -0.0076522827, 0.053985596, -0.0059432983, 0.022079468, 0.08557129, -0.0155181885, -0.001367569, 0.031707764, -0.040618896, -0.04647827, -0.02468872, 0.008872986, -0.004638672, -0.011428833, 0.004207611, -0.04333496, -0.0048980713, -0.038238525, -0.026916504, 0.03439331, 0.012954712, 0.039276123, 0.01108551, 0.0069007874, -0.0109939575, -0.041870117, -0.02583313, 0.026168823, 0.062805176, 0.002960205, -0.020812988, -0.06555176, -0.004310608, 0.009407043, -0.021072388, -0.0039367676, 0.013916016, 0.02609253, -0.0008621216, -0.00021755695, 0.006717682, 0.030456543, -0.044891357, 0.04159546, -0.0079956055, -0.066589355, 0.007534027, -0.043151855, -0.035369873, 0.0015296936, -0.021224976, -0.04626465, -0.0234375, -0.050964355, -0.08331299, 0.032989502, 0.02746582, -0.054351807, 0.047454834, 0.07159424, -0.024337769, -0.035369873, -0.03967285, 0.006401062, -0.08331299, -0.007461548, -0.00579834, 0.028793335, 0.008354187, -0.024154663, 0.0046920776, 0.02507019, -0.0074043274, -0.005897522, 0.009117126, -0.00945282, -0.041900635, 0.022018433, 0.020614624, -0.023468018, 0.00032377243, -0.0062789917, -0.0019626617, 0.006374359, -0.029296875, 0.048980713, 0.028305054, 0.02128601, -0.0076789856, 0.01424408, 0.007873535, -0.008415222, -0.018630981, 0.031204224, -0.03540039, -0.037353516, -0.056396484, 0.018692017, 0.047668457, -0.0027370453, 0.01725769, -0.014404297, 0.039001465, -0.020568848, -0.05303955, 0.034240723, 0.03173828, 0.014839172, 0.023025513, 0.013710022, -0.01020813, 0.011138916, -0.0023422241, 0.009048462, 0.07757568, -0.062927246, -0.02394104, -0.0914917, 0.022659302, -0.06719971, -0.0074920654, -0.07556152, 0.031951904, -0.02029419, -0.014221191, 0.03543091, -0.009208679, 0.021362305, -0.010620117, -0.011497498, 0.004928589, -0.05203247, 0.009437561, 0.014282227, 0.0012578964, -0.027450562, 0.005710602, 0.0016736984, -0.0015516281, 0.010879517, 0.014984131, 0.012496948, -0.0050697327, -0.031280518, 0.02935791, 0.015205383, -0.028305054, -0.006259918, 0.020828247, 0.035186768, 0.0024642944, 0.028457642, 0.023956299, 0.029022217, -0.012886047, -0.013595581, -0.00756073, 0.020812988, -0.020645142, 0.023712158, -0.007598877, -0.0262146, 0.033813477, 0.010368347, -0.035217285, -0.032592773, -0.08215332, -0.023895264, -0.0046577454, 0.04083252, -0.030960083, 0.028442383, 0.020217896, -0.007785797, -0.0030708313, -0.02204895, 0.033233643, -0.0031356812, 0.028045654, -0.088134766, -0.028320312, -0.027633667, -0.050994873, 0.057495117, -0.10601807, 0.014411926, 0.019744873, -0.024887085, 0.0031814575, -0.019973755, 0.054718018, -0.011749268, 0.07080078, 0.0041046143, 0.015838623, -0.000013589859, -0.026412964, -0.018249512, -0.0005507469, -0.04321289, 0.012908936, 0.04714966, 0.02960205, 0.050201416, -0.0031871796, 0.019042969, 0.011703491, -0.03967285, 0.018447876, 0.0010251999, -0.021118164, 0.04360962, -0.04208374, 0.019836426, 0.026107788, -0.01737976, -0.04562378, 0.06008911, 0.0012969971, 0.027893066, -0.046569824, 0.016098022, 0.00082063675, -0.015914917, 0.010116577, -0.011138916, 0.036743164, -0.017959595, 0.028869629, 0.009933472, 0.016311646, -0.0007748604, 0.01007843, -0.07702637, 0.014221191, -0.010108948, -0.05593872, 0.0040779114, -0.009773254, 0.030654907, 0.011947632, -0.02142334, -0.019485474, 0.016311646, -0.024291992, -0.017349243, 0.0077819824, -0.012290955, 0.00207901, -0.024810791, 0.0068740845, 0.017593384, 0.016830444, 0.036712646, -0.03616333, 0.05822754, -0.00066137314, -0.026763916, 0.02720642, 0.019882202, 0.011756897, -0.02859497, -0.0030403137, 0.032409668, -0.06530762, 0.06048584, 0.0055160522, -0.00055742264, -0.0062026978, 0.0046081543, -0.0015411377, -0.009803772, -0.026916504, 0.040924072, 0.02986145, -0.010154724, 0.00579834, -0.0062217712, 0.0049095154, 0.010284424, -0.024658203, -0.0058135986, 0.07104492, -0.05303955, 0.0045280457, -0.004425049, -0.045288086, -0.03829956, 0.029754639, -0.031066895, -0.04748535, 0.029327393, 0.0045280457, 0.028381348, 0.008140564, 0.059417725, -0.011444092, 0.0039863586, 0.0038928986, 0.026809692, 0.011222839, -0.02861023, -0.010467529, 0.0013513565, -0.03768921, -0.039215088, -0.0061569214, 0.02696228, 0.020996094, 0.037506104, -0.056793213, 0.018539429, -0.017608643, -0.051208496, -0.010879517, 0.024612427, 0.031677246, 0.019821167, -0.010284424, 0.018081665, 0.04324341, -0.026901245, 0.0056648254, -0.0032482147, -0.023529053, -0.062042236, -0.0056533813, 0.011459351, -0.012054443, -0.027572632, 0.044952393, 0.031677246, 0.03137207, 0.019454956, -0.04446411, -0.0016269684, 0.013801575, -0.028182983, -0.02571106, -0.055114746, 0.032989502, -0.022491455, -0.024642944, -0.030685425, 0.050689697, 0.018157959, 0.07696533, 0.003929138, 0.021850586, 0.039764404, 0.014785767, -0.01210022, -0.047668457, -0.023849487, -0.05166626, -0.027648926, -0.008926392, 0.00059986115, 0.0073165894, 0.017303467, -0.017913818, -0.030181885, -0.02949524, 0.038024902, 0.029693604, -0.022247314, -0.025985718, 0.025512695, -0.028930664, -0.015914917, 0.017456055, -0.042877197, 0.0031013489, -0.012123108, -0.019165039, -0.000626564, 0.018463135, -0.05267334, 0.023773193, 0.015037537, -0.0019330978, -0.04309082, -0.0057373047, 0.0006761551, 0.0067977905, -0.009796143, 0.019958496, 0.013397217, -0.006679535, -0.02911377, -0.015068054, 0.054473877, 0.0005373955, 0.0017366409, 0.018859863, -0.012901306, -0.07562256, -0.028671265, -0.016738892, -0.016479492, 0.041168213, -0.06137085, -0.0064964294, -0.0010318756, -0.00056552887, 0.033081055, -0.021987915, 0.011566162, 0.014328003, -0.015930176, 0.017501831, 0.057647705, -0.038391113, -0.000091552734, 0.028045654, 0.017044067, -0.03289795, -0.07043457, -0.061706543, 0.029800415, 0.03967285, -0.024642944, 0.035491943, -0.00065755844, -0.066223145, 0.035369873, 0.030044556, 0.016921997, -0.033966064, 0.029693604, 0.0076065063, 0.0011882782, 0.05404663, -0.028549194, -0.048461914, -0.04232788, 0.022155762, -0.035614014, 0.030731201, 0.02619934, 0.019561768, -0.054718018, 0.00066900253, 0.012496948, -0.05239868, -0.0814209, -0.03286743, 0.0033874512, -0.10266113, -0.031463623, 0.011650085, 0.010940552, 0.0072402954, -0.013679504, 0.03866577, 0.02810669, -0.008666992, 0.0051116943, -0.0052986145, 0.0473938, -0.009468079, -0.062561035, 0.0010280609, -0.0064888, -0.020401001, 0.038146973, -0.023620605, 0.010353088, 0.042877197, -0.0016269684, -0.0014982224, -0.027648926, 0.028152466, -0.041229248, -0.0053863525, 0.019714355, -0.026107788, 0.0008869171, -0.0052452087, -0.025283813, -0.0152282715, 0.0129776, 0.08111572, 0.070129395, -0.023284912, 0.026763916, 0.0075912476, -0.0070877075, -0.050476074, -0.034484863, -0.0021648407, -0.024627686, 0.0025177002, -0.013114929, -0.052764893, 0.012901306, 0.051849365, 0.019851685, -0.02128601, -0.018051147, 0.041900635, 0.05239868, 0.008964539, -0.01637268, -0.008895874, 0.055786133, -0.0025253296, 0.007865906, -0.029037476, 0.009986877, 0.024765015, -0.0060768127, -0.01776123, -0.014808655, -0.041107178, -0.05102539, -0.025772095, 0.011428833, -0.016860962, 0.013221741, 0.0047721863, -0.004535675, -0.030303955, -0.026412964, 0.00039815903, 0.035308838, -0.0054740906, 0.0491333, -0.053527832, -0.076293945, -0.048461914, 0.015945435, -0.03253174, -0.018692017, -0.05001831, -0.021347046, -0.026916504, -0.0016508102, 0.015617371, 0.013427734, 0.018341064, -0.004917145, 0.021850586, -0.006832123, -0.022384644, -0.015281677, -0.01499176, 0.010406494, 0.047210693, 0.027526855, 0.0055007935, -0.013656616, -0.02772522, -0.0048713684, -0.026855469, -0.036956787, -0.009490967, -0.021347046, -0.0042877197, 0.049102783, 0.066833496, 0.006576538, -0.007419586, -0.009803772, 0.0056648254, -0.015838623, 0.02986145, -0.0052757263, -0.009376526, 0.032196045, 0.0051612854, 0.02015686, -0.027053833, -0.007537842, 0.0006098747, -0.0049934387, 0.016021729, -0.001739502, 0.05404663, 0.0016374588, 0.0012769699, -0.026519775, 0.034729004, 0.028869629, 0.03173828, 0.05178833, 0.006187439, -0.009346008, -0.0036411285, 0.013198853, 0.006275177, -0.0209198, -0.008552551, -0.008323669, -0.031066895, -0.04159546, -0.00020110607, 0.038757324, -0.002462387, -0.022445679, -0.029586792, 0.009338379, 0.00070238113, 0.0112838745, -0.016159058, 0.024612427, -0.004650116, 0.003929138, 0.0021400452, -0.030410767, -0.0042648315, -0.00856781, 0.050231934, 0.01612854, -0.027389526, -0.014160156, 0.031799316, 0.005569458, -0.053710938, 0.01625061, -0.028503418, -0.012771606, -0.025009155, 0.01889038, 0.0062294006, 0.04949951, -0.022644043, -0.02633667, 0.028961182, -0.0049743652, -0.01109314, -0.02746582, -0.0012235641, -0.06008911, -0.057250977, 0.011520386, 0.018218994, 0.033721924, 0.031951904, 0.0317688, -0.021347046, -0.014663696, -0.02508545, -0.03781128, 0.041107178, -0.01008606, -0.020843506, 0.01133728, -0.047424316, 0.0033054352, 0.024429321, 0.04284668, -0.02319336, -0.01612854, 0.04144287, -0.013755798, -0.03475952, 0.029754639, -0.019165039, -0.000058472157, -0.0040626526, -0.02331543, 0.010627747, 0.0010709763, 0.0151901245, 0.008422852, -0.032348633, 0.022460938, -0.0040245056, 0.040039062, -0.018493652, 0.0012731552, 0.0085372925, 0.018295288, 0.003458023, 0.005340576, -0.020858765, -0.013320923, -0.0473938, -0.0079574585, -0.009124756, 0.03918457, -0.013313293, 0.0034999847, 0.028945923, -0.050628662, 0.016296387, -0.036224365, -0.005367279, -0.01448822, -0.02458191, -0.028930664, 0.025650024, -0.06329346, 0.027755737, 0.0028190613, -0.039733887, -0.052246094, -0.00051403046, 0.060943604, 0.07116699, -0.081970215, -0.07727051, -0.0146484375, 0.04736328, 0.0385437, 0.0011959076, 0.034423828, 0.020584106, -0.034057617, -0.018234253, -0.005432129, 0.02079773, -0.021896362, 0.042053223, -0.024246216, 0.014533997, -0.107421875, -0.055664062, 0.024765015, 0.078125, -0.021469116, -0.030090332, 0.015357971, 0.0072631836, 0.0090408325, -0.0071525574, 0.017791748, 0.005241394, 0.02520752, -0.020980835, -0.018188477, -0.00093078613, 0.04537964, 0.024276733, 0.061798096, -0.043121338, -0.05557251, -0.015838623, 0.019943237, 0.020202637, -0.014030457, -0.029052734, 0.033477783, 0.054626465, 0.012809753, -0.011932373, 0.020996094, 0.04486084, 0.013450623, 0.017852783, 0.038116455, 0.016113281, 0.0075531006, -0.0007658005, -0.0003745556, 0.03515625, 0.005897522, -0.033966064, -0.012519836, -0.02230835, -0.042510986, -0.011299133, -0.033721924, -0.093322754, -0.052368164, -0.048095703, -0.0017910004, -0.002336502, -0.038146973, 0.01259613, 0.011276245, 0.0026798248, 0.018676758, -0.017929077, -0.01776123, -0.050689697, 0.011833191, -0.0463562, -0.008773804, -0.021057129, -0.016448975, 0.037506104, 0.03692627, -0.02067566, 0.020568848, 0.008613586, 0.0022773743, 0.010444641, 0.0027618408, -0.002790451, 0.011543274, 0.039733887, 0.0002040863, 0.042663574, -0.00037622452, 0.03488159, 0.035064697, -0.03540039, 0.06210327, -0.04888916, -0.006828308, 0.06341553, 0.009284973, 0.0070533752, 0.059570312, -0.009819031, -0.022598267, 0.009002686, -0.034606934, 0.043151855, -0.02859497, 0.074401855, -0.06384277, -0.013664246, -0.013870239, 0.024795532, -0.06213379, 0.032043457, -0.037139893, -0.00680542, 0.000111699104, -0.010795593, 0.0022830963, -0.061676025, -0.009857178, 0.025268555, -0.011421204, -0.016860962, 0.005077362, -0.027664185, -0.009971619, 0.03125, -0.0069465637, 0.007858276, -0.014038086, -0.017959595, 0.018371582, 0.016479492, -0.00027108192, 0.00078964233, 0.06060791, 0.014678955, -0.022094727, 0.01777649, -0.028030396, -0.02003479, 0.010444641, 0.011070251, -0.03414917, -0.017700195, -0.019607544, -0.04522705, 0.01084137, 0.021575928, 0.00019991398, 0.030929565, 0.015151978, -0.059265137, 0.016204834, -0.013320923, 0.00029826164, -0.03439331, -0.006690979, -0.02154541, -0.028167725, 0.00084781647, 0.0030765533, -0.011489868, -0.062561035, -0.015991211, -0.027160645, -0.008056641, -0.014434814, -0.008377075, 0.038635254, -0.010734558, -0.073913574, -0.026916504, -0.024154663, 0.013259888, 0.0030345917, -0.02468872, 0.015449524, 0.008636475, -0.026168823, -0.0053749084, 0.0021400452, 0.021270752, -0.006038666, -0.034301758, -0.0021038055, -0.0059280396, -0.027130127, -0.07775879, 0.033050537, -0.0066452026, -0.023208618, 0.011856079, 0.02748108, -0.0143966675, -0.0725708, -0.010803223, -0.028900146, 0.0020637512, -0.017730713, -0.005645752, -0.023849487, 0.054107666, -0.0368042, -0.030380249, -0.047027588, -0.031921387, -0.014060974, -0.014274597, -0.020996094, 0.028244019, 0.005180359, -0.033325195, 0.018096924, 0.028442383, 0.07348633, -0.008323669, -0.0011844635, -0.036132812, 0.0045204163, 0.071777344, 0.07299805, 0.030532837, -0.045318604, -0.04928589, -0.032806396, 0.029449463, 0.006996155, -0.0085372925, -0.020904541, 0.045684814, -0.034118652, -0.0052604675, -0.0018415451, -0.011550903, -0.018249512, -0.0096206665, 0.014450073, 0.004383087, -0.06323242, 0.011100769, 0.0154953, -0.009063721, 0.019943237, -0.030395508, -0.0014801025, -0.004600525, -0.043914795, 0.015052795, -0.0025939941, -0.0009050369, -0.0027160645, 0.025482178, -0.027420044, 0.047698975, -0.021026611, -0.010597229, -0.042999268, -0.00091457367, -0.05050659, 0.04525757, -0.13439941, -0.03994751, -0.029327393, 0.026229858, 0.05203247, -0.02243042, 0.0513916, -0.020935059, -0.037109375, -0.026138306, 0.004863739, -0.012321472, -0.0019683838, -0.03942871, -0.049682617, 0.017623901, 0.021697998, 0.008361816, 0.025863647 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2107.02358v1
Impact of On-Chip Interconnect on In-Memory Acceleration of Deep Neural Networks
Gokul Krishnan, Sumit K. Mandal, Chaitali Chakrabarti, Jae-sun Seo, Umit Y. Ogras, Yu Cao
cs.AR, cs.AI, cs.LG
With the widespread use of Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), machine learning algorithms have evolved in two diverse directions -- one with ever-increasing connection density for better accuracy and the other with more compact sizing for energy efficiency. The increase in connection density increases on-chip data movement, which makes efficient on-chip communication a critical function of the DNN accelerator. The contribution of this work is threefold. First, we illustrate that the point-to-point (P2P)-based interconnect is incapable of handling a high volume of on-chip data movement for DNNs. Second, we evaluate P2P and network-on-chip (NoC) interconnect (with a regular topology such as a mesh) for SRAM- and ReRAM-based in-memory computing (IMC) architectures for a range of DNNs. This analysis shows the necessity for the optimal interconnect choice for an IMC DNN accelerator. Finally, we perform an experimental evaluation for different DNNs to empirically obtain the performance of the IMC architecture with both NoC-tree and NoC-mesh. We conclude that, at the tile level, NoC-tree is appropriate for compact DNNs employed at the edge, and NoC-mesh is necessary to accelerate DNNs with high connection density. Furthermore, we propose a technique to determine the optimal choice of interconnect for any given DNN. In this technique, we use analytical models of NoC to evaluate end-to-end communication latency of any given DNN. We demonstrate that the interconnect optimization in the IMC architecture results in up to 6$\times$ improvement in energy-delay-area product for VGG-19 inference compared to the state-of-the-art ReRAM-based IMC architectures.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2107.02358v1
"2021-07-06T02:44:00"
"2021-07-06T02:44:00"
{ "title": [ -0.017807007, -0.0073051453, -0.04446411, -0.026824951, 0.017425537, -0.034057617, 0.024765015, 0.015350342, -0.0026474, 0.035308838, -0.022994995, -0.009216309, 0.00819397, -0.025772095, -0.04547119, -0.008110046, 0.008659363, 0.014595032, -0.0046081543, -0.02279663, 0.0064926147, -0.018463135, 0.032165527, 0.043518066, 0.029876709, -0.050476074, -0.08679199, 0.013580322, -0.042999268, -0.058532715, -0.013450623, 0.062469482, 0.04953003, 0.018371582, -0.03829956, 0.009513855, -0.061523438, 0.031585693, -0.0036582947, -0.011520386, 0.010795593, 0.0087509155, 0.002155304, -0.043823242, 0.0048675537, 0.030853271, -0.062286377, -0.024353027, -0.023010254, -0.0026779175, 0.03375244, 0.04046631, 0.033233643, 0.038909912, 0.00040125847, -0.019851685, -0.04156494, 0.007598877, 0.035064697, 0.07940674, 0.03173828, -0.026062012, -0.0018053055, -0.036834717, -0.010322571, -0.015083313, 0.0045776367, 0.017990112, 0.041015625, 0.00015187263, -0.014640808, 0.0048065186, -0.011856079, 0.011192322, -0.042785645, -0.009155273, 0.059753418, 0.016448975, 0.019119263, -0.016479492, -0.011352539, -0.03152466, -0.00077676773, -0.022659302, 0.030685425, -0.01146698, -0.021255493, -0.0070877075, -0.045288086, -0.03970337, -0.01184082, -0.019546509, -0.009796143, -0.010665894, -0.03451538, -0.015029907, -0.03729248, -0.009498596, 0.01878357, 0.031097412, -0.00037312508, -0.0031871796, 0.008171082, -0.031188965, 0.028701782, 0.005882263, -0.023620605, -0.054626465, 0.024459839, 0.019515991, -0.03564453, 0.0501709, 0.005569458, -0.012390137, -0.02432251, 0.0029563904, 0.012496948, 0.0027217865, 0.017196655, 0.015899658, -0.0104522705, -0.040893555, 0.008979797, 0.01651001, 0.041534424, 0.025543213, -0.037475586, 0.0206604, -0.04324341, 0.018325806, 0.011199951, 0.038116455, -0.092041016, -0.07128906, -0.06567383, 0.03289795, 0.026397705, 0.015167236, 0.009750366, -0.0026302338, 0.061279297, -0.034118652, -0.0340271, 0.05822754, 0.0032997131, 0.014053345, 0.06652832, -0.003396988, -0.04220581, -0.05291748, -0.014984131, 0.0126571655, -0.009803772, 0.0047187805, -0.012039185, 0.008644104, -0.09887695, -0.011993408, 0.013404846, 0.022506714, 0.016555786, 0.0390625, 0.013916016, 0.037902832, 0.049926758, -0.019180298, 0.00137043, 0.022033691, 0.013763428, 0.0158844, 0.0028266907, 0.004802704, 0.007385254, -0.032226562, -0.014480591, 0.00090026855, 0.026153564, -0.0032520294, 0.018951416, -0.013999939, 0.005012512, -0.028625488, 0.0072669983, 0.043945312, -0.06890869, 0.011734009, 0.009895325, 0.031173706, 0.041870117, 0.0022773743, -0.040893555, 0.041412354, -0.026763916, -0.039611816, -0.049682617, -0.00894165, 0.033599854, 0.016479492, -0.00006425381, 0.04458618, -0.046966553, 0.006958008, -0.027297974, 0.020828247, -0.0236969, -0.031234741, -0.013244629, 0.012542725, -0.0009665489, 0.051086426, 0.014175415, -0.0017719269, -0.013511658, 0.009124756, -0.012229919, -0.035339355, 0.0007405281, 0.009216309, 0.0047836304, -0.00894165, 0.012878418, -0.019744873, 0.030151367, 0.025421143, 0.016403198, 0.0022392273, -0.0029888153, -0.032348633, 0.032165527, 0.017028809, 0.068115234, -0.02230835, 0.018920898, 0.016342163, -0.0073280334, -0.016571045, -0.008514404, -0.016555786, 0.016906738, 0.0234375, 0.0029239655, -0.056274414, -0.02104187, 0.0039901733, 0.046051025, -0.004085541, 0.006439209, 0.014183044, 0.01210022, -0.011268616, 0.05618286, -0.012550354, 0.06567383, -0.012313843, 0.043060303, 0.034118652, 0.0236969, 0.043304443, -0.026763916, -0.0015106201, -0.00037264824, 0.057556152, 0.016647339, 0.026626587, -0.06512451, 0.013626099, -0.029449463, -0.00094366074, -0.02281189, 0.014152527, 0.060577393, -0.014129639, 0.0054969788, -0.042297363, -0.051757812, -0.037963867, -0.004722595, 0.037078857, -0.0046577454, -0.075683594, -0.019165039, -0.026443481, 0.022720337, 0.0021266937, 0.029800415, -0.040130615, 0.030288696, 0.0011644363, -0.024108887, -0.013679504, 0.043395996, 0.038757324, 0.009056091, -0.0050849915, 0.008621216, 0.010055542, 0.068237305, 0.0814209, -0.031173706, 0.03137207, -0.076416016, 0.000849247, -0.0033226013, -0.021652222, 0.002407074, 0.037017822, 0.02029419, -0.00995636, -0.027633667, 0.017578125, -0.05493164, 0.0018186569, 0.008712769, -0.0058555603, -0.041900635, -0.048461914, -0.013671875, -0.042633057, -0.06585693, -0.041625977, 0.059631348, -0.017166138, -0.018356323, -0.01663208, -0.0096588135, -0.008666992, -0.021774292, -0.025054932, -0.0028381348, 0.028762817, 0.05090332, 0.027450562, -0.039520264, -0.016036987, 0.012329102, 0.011009216, -0.009819031, 0.027526855, -0.02432251, 0.007873535, 0.022354126, -0.00044202805, 0.0046691895, -0.027191162, 0.009140015, -0.015426636, -0.00440979, 0.035217285, -0.070129395, -0.0006966591, 0.029251099, -0.035003662, -0.02671814, 0.001461029, 0.03189087, 0.006855011, 0.008666992, 0.021881104, 0.020843506, -0.023529053, 0.0015544891, -0.0010852814, -0.029800415, -0.028442383, 0.017684937, -0.032043457, -0.011238098, -0.021636963, -0.027145386, 0.016860962, -0.04034424, -0.03074646, -0.015792847, -0.013786316, 0.006652832, 0.010505676, 0.027359009, -0.016235352, -0.032440186, -0.0057792664, 0.004085541, -0.00340271, -0.0059318542, -0.025558472, 0.07495117, 0.0002617836, -0.02609253, -0.011543274, 0.036254883, 0.0073776245, 0.01235199, 0.008850098, -0.01637268, 0.0074272156, 0.013374329, -0.005645752, 0.0012292862, -0.020584106, -0.08477783, -0.012718201, 0.10998535, -0.017059326, -0.04534912, 0.042663574, -0.06341553, 0.012176514, 0.03970337, 0.017211914, 0.020095825, 0.027832031, -0.02281189, 0.02809143, -0.009048462, -0.009819031, 0.00008356571, -0.035705566, -0.12512207, 0.022521973, -0.016937256, -0.016952515, -0.028900146, 0.013656616, -0.06390381, 0.002866745, -0.0033245087, 0.038330078, 0.02798462, -0.008575439, 0.004009247, 0.0007381439, 0.010620117, -0.023132324, -0.004180908, 0.0074920654, -0.01676941, 0.04498291, -0.0071411133, 0.04083252, 0.03289795, -0.011123657, -0.027694702, 0.0035877228, 0.018966675, 0.046417236, 0.009780884, -0.04159546, -0.011619568, -0.023254395, 0.0061302185, 0.01927185, -0.008361816, -0.00667572, -0.0060310364, 0.004600525, -0.031585693, 0.03366089, 0.03552246, 0.0181427, -0.012741089, -0.020889282, 0.015808105, -0.018218994, -0.045928955, 0.024658203, 0.016662598, 0.018081665, -0.008125305, -0.009407043, -0.06402588, 0.0440979, -0.021530151, 0.008560181, 0.026382446, -0.02923584, 0.008453369, -0.019363403, -0.01626587, -0.0014886856, -0.032470703, -0.03527832, -0.01436615, 0.009025574, -0.0077819824, -0.021713257, 0.029541016, -0.010604858, -0.038269043, -0.014801025, 0.02078247, -0.027160645, -0.011680603, -0.050598145, 0.01777649, 0.00029063225, -0.035339355, 0.029785156, -0.013961792, -0.017410278, -0.0032367706, -0.060028076, -0.023880005, 0.074523926, -0.013618469, 0.01776123, 0.027908325, 0.007461548, -0.020462036, -0.019515991, 0.0065345764, -0.009536743, 0.024795532, -0.005531311, -0.014541626, 0.032348633, -0.042022705, 0.026550293, 0.0062942505, -0.006008148, -0.00919342, 0.007522583, 0.020950317, 0.019638062, -0.046539307, 0.073791504, 0.013580322, -0.026733398, -0.07849121, -0.020095825, -0.007850647, -0.03955078, 0.009513855, -0.026611328, 0.032409668, 0.04537964, 0.008605957, 0.08123779, -0.017990112, 0.041748047, 0.028457642, -0.06561279, -0.041748047, -0.007873535, 0.046203613, -0.014152527, -0.0110321045, 0.04333496, -0.027328491, 0.0635376, -0.03262329, -0.012649536, 0.020599365, 0.0074310303, 0.0043754578, -0.027709961, -0.08959961, 0.018676758, 0.007949829, -0.0032234192, -0.017150879, 0.044952393, 0.032104492, 0.0002156496, -0.02684021, 0.0049743652, 0.052825928, -0.017654419, 0.022277832, -0.055480957, 0.0012960434, 0.005596161, -0.059051514, -0.036254883, 0.0129852295, -0.0030212402, 0.029525757, -0.039794922, -0.01776123, 0.0143585205, 0.017120361, 0.05444336, 0.032714844, -0.012969971, -0.04623413, 0.032928467, -0.0051956177, -0.03387451, 0.0039711, 0.021499634, -0.018966675, -0.041259766, 0.00504303, -0.02130127, 0.009223938, -0.046203613, 0.00087690353, -0.013549805, 0.020828247, -0.021499634, 0.012321472, 0.0066490173, -0.0010166168, 0.008346558, 0.0052948, -0.030441284, 0.011886597, 0.007575989, 0.045806885, -0.035003662, 0.040039062, 0.05239868, -0.0029239655, -0.02798462, 0.0014925003, 0.03845215, 0.033813477, -0.050964355, -0.036987305, 0.022567749, -0.02218628, -0.019226074, 0.010528564, -0.008033752, 0.047088623, -0.021438599, 0.06011963, -0.049102783, -0.030151367, -0.0012559891, 0.008201599, 0.020370483, -0.024856567, 0.02558899, -0.078308105, -0.09472656, -0.029266357, 0.06768799, -0.016921997, -0.0011501312, 0.03616333, 0.020553589, -0.002456665, 0.048828125, 0.01386261, 0.027267456, 0.013366699, -0.011459351, 0.0104904175, -0.019226074, -0.04095459, 0.0016803741, -0.031677246, 0.02029419, -0.048980713, 0.015235901, -0.044311523, -0.010047913, -0.01776123, -0.014411926, 0.0042800903, -0.051879883, 0.0048675537, 0.042388916, 0.008766174, 0.023529053, 0.03967285, 0.013534546, 0.023727417, 0.052856445, -0.017044067, 0.05218506, 0.032196045, -0.046966553, 0.03652954, 0.005924225, 0.030792236, -0.0012741089, 0.00919342, 0.0067214966, 0.0019683838, -0.03289795, 0.023391724, 0.0009665489, -0.019058228, 0.0340271, -0.056793213, 0.025970459, 0.005519867, -0.019073486, -0.0056152344, -0.03677368, -0.010032654, 0.062408447, -0.044708252, 0.032928467, 0.008201599, -0.022994995, -0.034729004, -0.05368042, -0.005382538, -0.009185791, 0.020843506, -0.015342712, -0.0010137558, -0.045654297, 0.02267456, 0.040527344, -0.03036499, -0.009651184, -0.015113831, 0.015823364, 0.03161621, 0.020843506, -0.037139893, 0.0019521713, 0.0010004044, -0.04788208, -0.061187744, -0.0045433044, -0.018600464, -0.010040283, -0.0010185242, -0.029022217, -0.011154175, -0.009208679, 0.012496948, 0.003540039, -0.017486572, 0.035583496, 0.0068244934, 0.014656067, 0.009376526, 0.0340271, 0.022521973, -0.006374359, 0.0027446747, -0.035827637, 0.004512787, -0.0043640137, -0.0019464493, -0.0023765564, -0.08502197, 0.016555786, 0.0029621124, 0.02432251, 0.006454468, -0.0051956177, 0.037506104, -0.013458252, 0.013137817, 0.013343811, 0.093688965, -0.05807495, -0.0072898865, -0.010017395, 0.00667572, -0.03074646, 0.016403198, -0.019866943, 0.02166748, -0.033111572, -0.06640625, -0.045288086, 0.00409317, 0.05267334, 0.01499939, 0.056030273, -0.037628174, 0.0061454773, -0.027938843, -0.029006958, -0.059661865, 0.011421204, -0.010414124, -0.009788513, 0.052734375, -0.014884949, 0.0051727295, 0.010093689, 0.0345459, -0.0055274963, -0.03668213, 0.021865845, -0.020217896, 0.02041626, -0.030075073, -0.008598328, 0.014579773, 0.01966858, -0.036895752, 0.012321472, -0.046051025, 0.05432129, -0.0039901733, 0.057037354, 0.064697266, 0.0037212372, -0.011520386, -0.003921509, -0.009559631, -0.039916992, 0.0027828217, -0.05154419, -0.017608643, -0.064697266, -0.016296387, -0.039855957, -0.008102417, 0.00012946129, 0.0473938, -0.018325806, 0.021453857, 0.012580872, 0.0011014938, 0.029815674, -0.041534424, 0.051940918, 0.07080078, 0.031951904, -0.012557983, 0.006877899, 0.017440796, 0.0206604, -0.008598328, 0.037231445, 0.027633667, -0.025863647, -0.0010566711, 0.02571106, 0.02961731, -0.019515991, -0.023834229, -0.005847931, 0.06402588, 0.021453857, 0.050842285, 0.037109375, 0.015457153, -0.008148193, -0.021438599, -0.016189575, 0.038360596, -0.04611206, 0.03817749, 0.0680542, -0.046844482, 0.005821228, -0.034362793, -0.0317688, -0.036865234, 0.055419922, 0.008201599, -0.026229858, 0.0033874512, 0.011962891, 0.021331787, -0.0068206787, 0.00094366074, -0.028167725, 0.007434845, 0.06530762, 0.035064697, -0.006149292, -0.0059394836, 0.015083313, 0.038909912, 0.014144897, -0.0046844482, 0.008094788, 0.017166138, 0.008178711, 0.026916504, -0.03793335, 0.046569824, 0.020629883, -0.03010559, 0.028015137, 0.014579773, -0.03289795, -0.012046814, 0.039520264, 0.053222656, 0.031158447, 0.059326172, 0.024093628, -0.008483887, 0.02053833, -0.03503418, 0.02947998, 0.048858643, -0.041625977, 0.026062012, -0.012718201, -0.014984131, 0.032318115, -0.014808655, 0.040893555, -0.041748047, 0.016845703, -0.009902954, 0.009384155, 0.024795532, -0.03164673, -0.027420044, 0.0047073364, -0.030426025, 0.005050659, 0.029205322, -0.0029773712, -0.021224976, -0.0026111603, 0.03503418, 0.0008158684, 0.009819031, 0.018325806, -0.02619934, -0.05645752, 0.05822754, -0.024612427, 0.078430176, -0.034088135, -0.011024475, 0.0060920715, -0.0016202927, -0.03756714, -0.044189453, -0.013214111, -0.019439697, -0.00566864, -0.029525757, 0.0023937225, -0.006793976, -0.03918457, 0.0049819946, -0.09869385, 0.0395813, -0.02973938, -0.03491211, 0.055633545, -0.02859497, -0.033081055, 0.0010251999, -0.041259766, 0.038726807, 0.040924072, -0.004962921, 0.009429932, 0.017852783, -0.033996582, -0.007446289, 0.03326416, 0.06100464, 0.0017261505, -0.01914978, -0.0052719116, 0.05911255, 0.06982422, -0.051696777, -0.020080566, -0.0049362183, 0.03994751, -0.0074882507, 0.04611206, 0.025497437, 0.035003662, 0.0009255409, 0.04336548, -0.00024747849, -0.06262207, -0.028503418, -0.023040771, 0.042236328, 0.038757324, -0.017959595, -0.0070991516, 0.020965576, -0.021835327, 0.004673004, 0.011276245, 0.0024871826, 0.0138168335, -0.004623413, 0.03677368, -0.014266968, -0.016601562, -0.010444641, -0.013435364, 0.017593384, 0.029434204, -0.040618896, 0.021453857, -0.011856079, 0.031204224, -0.003929138, -0.052978516, 0.0345459, 0.040924072, 0.012832642, 0.024978638, -0.044006348, -0.04724121, -0.0078125, -0.006187439, -0.007835388, -0.0041007996, 0.024780273, -0.012168884, -0.006629944, 0.009246826, -0.066467285, 0.07086182, -0.023254395, 0.042053223, -0.05630493, 0.038391113, -0.041137695, -0.012123108, -0.017440796, 0.007904053, -0.00085163116, 0.018081665, -0.07659912, -0.07928467, 0.03189087, -0.038391113 ], "summary": [ 0.004962921, -0.02130127, 0.00491333, -0.003419876, -0.03213501, -0.020904541, 0.009483337, -0.022994995, -0.006893158, 0.012390137, -0.021316528, -0.0042762756, 0.017929077, -0.042388916, 0.022445679, -0.032348633, 0.010910034, -0.012512207, 0.00033450127, -0.03717041, 0.005882263, -0.0259552, 0.033599854, 0.029220581, 0.014839172, -0.040405273, -0.04168701, -0.0014486313, -0.0067214966, -0.006038666, 0.0010271072, 0.03845215, 0.02407837, 0.013252258, -0.021072388, -0.029434204, -0.031341553, 0.023254395, 0.006996155, -0.004016876, 0.03338623, 0.005065918, 0.099731445, -0.047058105, 0.035461426, 0.047607422, 0.0010204315, -0.028625488, 0.023162842, -0.047943115, 0.029144287, 0.015312195, 0.040802002, -0.032714844, -0.022247314, 0.024520874, -0.056274414, 0.015419006, -0.0051193237, 0.06213379, 0.05596924, 0.036865234, -0.02128601, -0.019088745, 0.024734497, -0.013786316, 0.061706543, 0.015571594, 0.00046730042, 0.017959595, 0.016921997, 0.024093628, 0.016815186, -0.016525269, -0.030059814, 0.026672363, 0.031188965, 0.022613525, 0.004749298, -0.042144775, -0.016357422, -0.00046038628, 0.007041931, -0.044921875, -0.012702942, -0.04525757, -0.019638062, 0.025482178, -0.016143799, 0.000890255, -0.024047852, 0.022216797, -0.01676941, -0.005886078, -0.029586792, -0.013031006, -0.06072998, -0.07293701, 0.03250122, 0.064086914, 0.04888916, -0.059814453, 0.08581543, -0.03930664, 0.017547607, 0.003025055, -0.045654297, -0.055633545, 0.03930664, 0.03604126, -0.019439697, 0.038085938, -0.009147644, -0.023254395, -0.02999878, 0.010932922, 0.0096206665, -0.01751709, -0.009498596, -0.022262573, -0.022583008, -0.01878357, 0.005657196, 0.028625488, 0.010429382, 0.012420654, -0.016052246, 0.020843506, -0.03845215, 0.010292053, -0.0118255615, 0.022857666, 0.0058135986, -0.013198853, -0.055877686, -0.022399902, 0.02848816, -0.008201599, 0.01612854, -0.023406982, 0.08300781, -0.032592773, -0.07373047, 0.08178711, 0.0048599243, 0.033294678, 0.04272461, -0.0007343292, -0.036499023, -0.04159546, 0.005584717, 0.0079193115, 0.00023460388, 0.0018815994, -0.020935059, -0.016403198, -0.044921875, 0.0031814575, 0.009300232, 0.016967773, 0.044677734, 0.026153564, 0.014411926, 0.078125, 0.054901123, -0.02999878, -0.020141602, -0.00054454803, 0.009986877, 0.022155762, 0.01828003, 0.017440796, -0.0010986328, -0.019042969, 0.005176544, -0.024917603, -0.010482788, 0.0065078735, 0.013839722, -0.034851074, -0.010467529, -0.03869629, 0.00051784515, 0.027252197, -0.053833008, 0.06542969, 0.0029582977, 0.043884277, 0.018463135, -0.014411926, 0.022979736, 0.035736084, -0.009651184, -0.024932861, -0.021759033, 0.018615723, -0.004711151, 0.017150879, -0.011383057, 0.020492554, -0.019012451, 0.005077362, 0.0001821518, 0.008232117, -0.072631836, 0.01184082, -0.020736694, 0.01663208, 0.0013122559, 0.00041031837, -0.0071487427, -0.049468994, 0.013145447, 0.0061531067, -0.017181396, -0.010551453, -0.000374794, 0.0012197495, 0.014450073, 0.0012578964, 0.0140686035, -0.018493652, 0.0017995834, 0.027191162, 0.017669678, 0.0040512085, -0.011489868, 0.015945435, 0.0552063, 0.03387451, 0.015457153, -0.030807495, 0.011398315, 0.024734497, -0.027374268, -0.004676819, 0.031829834, -0.009788513, 0.020370483, 0.032043457, 0.014381409, -0.019439697, -0.025741577, 0.014205933, 0.010475159, -0.030410767, -0.0059509277, 0.008590698, -0.010986328, -0.03552246, 0.038757324, -0.013893127, 0.05368042, -0.018615723, 0.024215698, 0.023712158, 0.026473999, 0.019973755, 0.021484375, 0.02368164, -0.009902954, 0.060699463, 0.02973938, 0.030532837, -0.010467529, -0.027938843, -0.020019531, -0.0093688965, -0.017715454, -0.0068969727, 0.033172607, -0.017486572, -0.0029411316, -0.028533936, -0.048431396, -0.03744507, -0.011474609, 0.03488159, -0.029769897, -0.043670654, -0.020050049, -0.004753113, -0.024291992, -0.0045394897, 0.016525269, 0.0016174316, 0.002090454, 0.014434814, 0.009994507, 0.04788208, 0.0541687, 0.025863647, -0.0110321045, 0.019500732, 0.026229858, -0.0034008026, -0.0031375885, 0.06274414, -0.0126953125, -0.0072364807, 0.00067281723, 0.009399414, -0.028060913, 0.0043296814, -0.006160736, 0.05291748, -0.0048675537, -0.021118164, -0.0031337738, 0.004016876, -0.02835083, -0.0027103424, 0.015594482, 0.012336731, -0.030944824, -0.02897644, -0.033447266, 0.009925842, -0.046844482, 0.03869629, 0.08068848, -0.0025119781, 0.0048217773, -0.01512146, -0.011566162, -0.03201294, -0.021438599, -0.027618408, -0.021575928, 0.015235901, -0.017562866, 0.017089844, -0.02519226, 0.071777344, 0.0040664673, 0.028121948, 0.020339966, -0.02470398, -0.0017900467, -0.0025424957, 0.06060791, 0.048461914, -0.013320923, -0.017166138, -0.025421143, 0.016952515, 0.02708435, 0.000685215, -0.06097412, 0.02166748, 0.010696411, -0.027832031, -0.024169922, 0.039733887, 0.012084961, 0.0256958, 0.045806885, 0.052001953, 0.016143799, -0.026672363, 0.024490356, 0.01537323, -0.00983429, -0.03994751, -0.014953613, -0.03237915, 0.008728027, -0.022583008, -0.026290894, 0.0058937073, 0.0023727417, -0.02154541, 0.0001462698, -0.015991211, -0.0211792, 0.0034694672, 0.07867432, -0.003396988, -0.014671326, 0.043304443, 0.021102905, 0.015792847, -0.0115356445, -0.021331787, 0.0758667, -0.010772705, 0.014961243, -0.024246216, 0.07952881, 0.022277832, 0.014442444, -0.046936035, 0.060272217, -0.019104004, -0.014007568, -0.0256958, 0.03201294, 0.0007119179, 0.022003174, -0.036376953, 0.09063721, 0.024734497, -0.014152527, 0.041992188, -0.0076675415, 0.0019683838, 0.08294678, 0.007980347, -0.0010509491, 0.056915283, -0.025436401, 0.023284912, -0.009552002, 0.020141602, 0.0053977966, -0.010940552, -0.015777588, 0.002216339, 0.013381958, -0.0259552, -0.03781128, 0.06390381, -0.038238525, -0.0087509155, 0.0054855347, -0.003540039, -0.0032043457, -0.010734558, -0.044403076, 0.03878784, 0.0014324188, -0.012359619, -0.0082473755, 0.028686523, -0.05130005, 0.026672363, -0.004234314, -0.03717041, 0.06555176, -0.059295654, -0.08843994, -0.023971558, 0.0473938, 0.014678955, 0.03375244, -0.015563965, -0.011116028, -0.057525635, 0.033203125, 0.01259613, -0.006515503, -0.0064926147, 0.04055786, 0.020248413, -0.021026611, 0.045013428, 0.026535034, 0.03765869, 0.040496826, -0.016418457, 0.014877319, -0.0063438416, -0.025527954, 0.036834717, 0.008270264, 0.052642822, -0.04046631, 0.020721436, -0.045898438, 0.027496338, 0.015525818, -0.03744507, 0.047821045, -0.03555298, -0.013801575, -0.08685303, 0.036712646, -0.004760742, 0.02545166, -0.06903076, -0.039245605, 0.02166748, -0.004459381, -0.008300781, 0.048095703, -0.0067634583, 0.012168884, -0.02279663, -0.0021686554, 0.040863037, 0.008041382, -0.0019388199, 0.049743652, 0.0027866364, -0.018875122, 0.027313232, -0.004009247, 0.06561279, 0.0137786865, -0.05368042, -0.02645874, -0.015731812, 0.0011692047, -0.010551453, -0.006023407, 0.03338623, 0.011566162, -0.0105896, -0.0058174133, -0.039916992, 0.02999878, -0.054107666, -0.008232117, -0.0049858093, -0.010467529, 0.014022827, 0.029418945, -0.026977539, 0.02142334, 0.014755249, 0.047821045, 0.043426514, -0.031433105, 0.040863037, 0.01234436, -0.01725769, -0.06072998, -0.028869629, -0.00067949295, -0.049865723, 0.02507019, 0.01537323, 0.013168335, 0.060943604, -0.008377075, 0.008621216, -0.021240234, -0.007171631, 0.033813477, 0.014099121, -0.024291992, -0.010192871, 0.003227234, 0.017089844, -0.01612854, -0.017440796, -0.029846191, 0.050750732, -0.07897949, 0.01159668, 0.026992798, 0.0008459091, 0.016021729, -0.047302246, -0.035217285, 0.056396484, 0.05230713, -0.04876709, -0.018508911, 0.07006836, 0.020767212, 0.009117126, 0.0042381287, -0.008872986, 0.057739258, -0.0039901733, 0.010803223, -0.0519104, -0.048431396, -0.022781372, -0.047821045, -0.0044555664, 0.0051116943, -0.032470703, 0.011253357, -0.01084137, -0.00730896, 0.004333496, 0.031402588, 0.03213501, 0.036834717, -0.012077332, -0.056732178, -0.05407715, 0.017868042, -0.00088214874, -0.014335632, 0.03805542, -0.009963989, -0.024337769, -0.02947998, -0.020980835, 0.021270752, -0.014099121, -0.032592773, 0.0012807846, -0.015991211, -0.03503418, -0.0029144287, -0.016616821, 0.013130188, 0.014839172, 0.011169434, -0.019699097, 0.034362793, 0.0058555603, 0.031951904, -0.003042221, 0.06677246, 0.04937744, -0.032684326, -0.07525635, 0.005191803, 0.062469482, 0.01586914, -0.07086182, -0.059295654, 0.024414062, 0.013931274, -0.030258179, 0.022247314, -0.0075531006, 0.008132935, 0.06451416, 0.04711914, -0.010910034, -0.039611816, 0.013641357, 0.012535095, -0.0072250366, 0.010948181, -0.015129089, -0.067871094, -0.12097168, -0.0546875, 0.11248779, -0.0011997223, -0.041381836, 0.008918762, 0.00712204, -0.011482239, 0.030334473, 0.0031108856, 0.009376526, 0.011528015, -0.011047363, -0.00085020065, -0.009246826, -0.015174866, 0.0028095245, -0.02229309, 0.01612854, 0.012290955, -0.005935669, -0.020568848, 0.012664795, -0.018920898, 0.00072050095, -0.016799927, -0.035095215, -0.039794922, -0.0048828125, -0.00018584728, 0.0034103394, 0.04421997, -0.024475098, -0.045440674, 0.014015198, -0.0748291, 0.064697266, -0.018600464, -0.07873535, 0.0129776, 0.02406311, 0.0335083, -0.015449524, -0.017593384, 0.013656616, -0.05154419, 0.008682251, -0.007713318, -0.0016994476, -0.0002629757, 0.0071907043, -0.0059509277, 0.054351807, 0.024337769, -0.016494751, -0.028457642, 0.00056886673, -0.0079574585, 0.054626465, -0.022735596, 0.045715332, 0.00031924248, -0.021255493, 0.00030565262, -0.05267334, 0.020706177, -0.05718994, -0.010414124, 0.0027828217, 0.0061187744, -0.006931305, -0.021514893, 0.016723633, -0.0039482117, -0.017547607, -0.013595581, 0.018981934, -0.03427124, -0.0056648254, -0.03967285, -0.0037269592, -0.008125305, -0.035339355, -0.072509766, -0.031921387, -0.021377563, 0.026733398, -0.007408142, -0.010902405, 0.020324707, -0.026031494, 0.0134887695, -0.009414673, -0.005168915, 0.0026950836, 0.0031490326, 0.009963989, 0.016998291, -0.00349617, -0.023162842, 0.014717102, 0.013442993, -0.022415161, -0.0072250366, -0.026184082, -0.015335083, -0.03488159, -0.07910156, 0.018615723, 0.007686615, 0.02558899, 0.012886047, 0.0048446655, 0.004837036, 0.023132324, 0.03225708, -0.00025963783, 0.06933594, 0.006340027, -0.001452446, -0.011039734, 0.035247803, -0.049102783, -0.08087158, 0.0019741058, 0.039245605, 0.012397766, -0.030258179, -0.0057029724, -0.012084961, 0.029220581, 0.0017728806, 0.039733887, -0.02154541, -0.008956909, -0.0021858215, -0.03817749, -0.023529053, -0.0072631836, -0.0068740845, 0.007129669, 0.0803833, -0.02142334, 0.005756378, 0.049743652, 0.00856781, -0.025970459, -0.05404663, 0.030731201, 0.0023670197, 0.053344727, -0.0045051575, 0.011390686, 0.0008773804, 0.007904053, -0.020065308, -0.01235199, -0.010971069, 0.031402588, 0.015975952, 0.0368042, 0.027450562, -0.0038375854, 0.009590149, 0.004348755, -0.003004074, -0.019851685, 0.054779053, -0.03036499, -0.057373047, -0.06768799, -0.05303955, -0.00970459, -0.009407043, -0.01474762, 0.0048599243, 0.028533936, 0.017196655, 0.03463745, 0.019958496, -0.006450653, -0.025299072, 0.021987915, 0.08666992, 0.011795044, -0.0062065125, 0.0546875, -0.032806396, 0.005821228, 0.0048599243, 0.050598145, 0.024642944, -0.014602661, 0.0038108826, -0.008087158, 0.0138168335, -0.021621704, 0.0025596619, -0.00944519, 0.07977295, 0.04937744, 0.06365967, 0.008850098, -0.003944397, 0.0028457642, -0.0053100586, 0.0038833618, 0.051818848, -0.048095703, 0.055999756, 0.038024902, -0.008140564, -0.032836914, -0.04434204, -0.0029582977, -0.006580353, 0.022872925, 0.0345459, -0.02545166, 0.021133423, -0.00061655045, 0.014434814, -0.045684814, -0.051727295, -0.047576904, 0.022766113, 0.07574463, -0.024002075, -0.009857178, -0.085754395, 0.022659302, 0.001865387, -0.018798828, -0.0017681122, 0.022750854, 0.03692627, 0.039276123, 0.022537231, -0.079833984, 0.03555298, 0.025161743, -0.020721436, 0.032348633, 0.019897461, -0.015457153, 0.026443481, 0.023895264, 0.06402588, 0.06817627, 0.034332275, -0.039215088, 0.024642944, 0.08026123, -0.00724411, 0.015686035, 0.023651123, -0.009101868, -0.034179688, 0.008049011, 0.007583618, -0.017410278, 0.041778564, 0.049316406, -0.042419434, 0.0028247833, -0.016677856, -0.014511108, -0.035095215, 0.020904541, 0.0034866333, -0.028656006, -0.042999268, 0.0072288513, 0.028060913, -0.014930725, 0.00061893463, -0.024612427, 0.012298584, -0.00044465065, -0.027160645, 0.011489868, 0.0017347336, -0.013374329, 0.039123535, -0.020736694, 0.08709717, -0.04269409, -0.019104004, 0.025436401, 0.010673523, 0.0064888, -0.05218506, -0.0206604, 0.014823914, 0.0069885254, -0.03564453, 0.00048542023, 0.019119263, -0.022949219, 0.04095459, -0.07080078, 0.04660034, -0.022583008, -0.0134887695, 0.046325684, 0.011154175, -0.04296875, 0.0036144257, -0.019439697, 0.0137786865, -0.0059547424, -0.0030765533, 0.016296387, 0.018371582, -0.02003479, -0.006111145, 0.0013532639, -0.0055618286, -0.03010559, 0.026107788, -0.040039062, 0.057006836, 0.038513184, -0.05810547, -0.007419586, -0.004512787, 0.01739502, 0.015342712, 0.015960693, 0.017242432, 0.0395813, -0.027526855, 0.031951904, -0.011444092, -0.055023193, -0.005207062, 0.013198853, 0.061584473, -0.029144287, -0.03918457, -0.012191772, -0.020935059, -0.06286621, -0.02204895, 0.003408432, 0.0034122467, -0.021499634, 0.022781372, 0.036376953, -0.015731812, 0.0032920837, 0.010566711, -0.060699463, 0.029907227, 0.006000519, -0.04864502, 0.01852417, -0.034332275, -0.013267517, 0.017913818, 0.0007314682, -0.008743286, 0.026901245, 0.020507812, -0.004261017, -0.046020508, -0.030059814, 0.022659302, 0.019973755, -0.021347046, 0.056396484, 0.031143188, -0.036468506, -0.032318115, -0.0340271, -0.05493164, 0.044433594, -0.019897461, -0.0023384094, -0.047729492, 0.050048828, 0.016342163, -0.01701355, 0.00059223175, -0.0016183853, -0.020248413, -0.0028419495, -0.015426636, -0.030029297, 0.0047454834, -0.004020691 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2107.02689v3
A Model-Driven Approach to Machine Learning and Software Modeling for the IoT
Armin Moin, Moharram Challenger, Atta Badii, Stephan Günnemann
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.LG
Models are used in both Software Engineering (SE) and Artificial Intelligence (AI). SE models may specify the architecture at different levels of abstraction and for addressing different concerns at various stages of the software development life-cycle, from early conceptualization and design, to verification, implementation, testing and evolution. However, AI models may provide smart capabilities, such as prediction and decision-making support. For instance, in Machine Learning (ML), which is currently the most popular sub-discipline of AI, mathematical models may learn useful patterns in the observed data and can become capable of making predictions. The goal of this work is to create synergy by bringing models in the said communities together and proposing a holistic approach to model-driven software development for intelligent systems that require ML. We illustrate how software models can become capable of creating and dealing with ML models in a seamless manner. The main focus is on the domain of the Internet of Things (IoT), where both ML and model-driven SE play a key role. In the context of the need to take a Cyber-Physical System-of-Systems perspective of the targeted architecture, an integrated design environment for both SE and ML sub-systems would best support the optimization and overall efficiency of the implementation of the resulting system. In particular, we implement the proposed approach, called ML-Quadrat, based on ThingML, and validate it using a case study from the IoT domain, as well as through an empirical user evaluation. It transpires that the proposed approach is not only feasible, but may also contribute to the performance leap of software development for smart Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS) which are connected to the IoT, as well as an enhanced user experience of the practitioners who use the proposed modeling solution.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2107.02689v3
"2021-11-23T15:21:05"
"2021-07-06T15:50:50"
{ "title": [ -0.041046143, -0.015701294, -0.044647217, -0.035369873, 0.0077171326, -0.013427734, -0.019348145, 0.0023479462, -0.024734497, 0.031311035, -0.024993896, -0.006038666, 0.00705719, -0.02305603, -0.030807495, -0.004459381, -0.012359619, 0.023742676, -0.017654419, -0.035980225, 0.01058197, -0.04208374, 0.052490234, 0.033447266, 0.024139404, -0.012458801, -0.0836792, 0.022842407, -0.0491333, -0.040649414, -0.021347046, 0.037322998, 0.04284668, 0.021972656, -0.035186768, 0.034240723, -0.014633179, 0.022827148, -0.00630188, 0.015235901, 0.037353516, -0.0104904175, -0.008720398, -0.009483337, -0.02557373, 0.025650024, -0.04815674, -0.018005371, -0.01449585, 0.024093628, 0.024993896, 0.035064697, 0.0022068024, 0.01625061, 0.009811401, -0.031433105, 0.0062828064, -0.025146484, 0.030914307, 0.050689697, 0.0010385513, -0.023086548, 0.018371582, -0.017486572, -0.015205383, -0.039123535, -0.007987976, 0.018692017, 0.0791626, 0.010726929, -0.014419556, 0.045898438, -0.00072193146, 0.022277832, -0.055999756, -0.0262146, 0.07269287, 0.011177063, 0.016494751, -0.018066406, 0.017669678, -0.0070266724, 0.024368286, -0.011360168, 0.025146484, -0.011695862, 0.00057315826, -0.013206482, -0.038238525, -0.05355835, -0.0071792603, -0.007797241, -0.01826477, 0.017822266, -0.007896423, -0.013961792, -0.026779175, 0.003967285, 0.025650024, -0.021408081, -0.017150879, 0.020858765, -0.06414795, -0.010513306, 0.014198303, 0.04800415, -0.0060424805, -0.022003174, 0.0028686523, 0.021652222, -0.019210815, -0.0011405945, 0.012199402, 0.00083971024, -0.022323608, -0.005584717, -0.00919342, -0.009086609, 0.014389038, 0.011581421, -0.017166138, -0.034179688, -0.0073242188, 0.0016508102, 0.032562256, -0.0014314651, -0.022033691, 0.01864624, 0.012046814, 0.010925293, 0.00680542, 0.05581665, -0.10681152, -0.09851074, -0.06762695, 0.044006348, 0.0010480881, -0.0056495667, 0.0030593872, 0.005039215, 0.027572632, -0.020980835, -0.0067863464, 0.024765015, 0.014480591, 0.012931824, 0.05279541, -0.012184143, -0.04547119, -0.032348633, -0.036315918, 0.0060272217, 0.0028686523, 0.011955261, -0.015930176, 0.026367188, -0.08532715, -0.008460999, 0.00907135, 0.01687622, 0.025924683, 0.0088272095, -0.0006222725, 0.022277832, 0.045806885, -0.0071868896, -0.0024280548, 0.021774292, -0.004798889, 0.032714844, -0.02746582, 0.0037002563, 0.01083374, -0.015304565, -0.011726379, 0.0070114136, 0.028884888, 0.025970459, 0.01676941, -0.020065308, -0.013023376, -0.02357483, 0.03213501, 0.02053833, -0.07086182, -0.0054130554, 0.010055542, 0.029052734, 0.052856445, -0.0014982224, -0.046936035, 0.012916565, -0.051605225, -0.04498291, -0.049987793, -0.013679504, 0.038970947, 0.044647217, -0.0079193115, 0.023880005, -0.04876709, 0.012229919, -0.038391113, 0.024169922, -0.0079193115, -0.028152466, -0.0016927719, 0.020431519, -0.033233643, 0.05496216, 0.05340576, 0.019729614, -0.035339355, 0.0022087097, 0.0061302185, -0.05429077, 0.013977051, -0.010292053, -0.012870789, -0.035064697, -0.024612427, -0.01878357, 0.007873535, 0.059265137, 0.028030396, 0.019714355, -0.0048179626, -0.008285522, 0.07287598, 0.02822876, 0.066223145, -0.070373535, 0.032836914, 0.0069389343, -0.013893127, -0.03591919, -0.017868042, -0.02204895, 0.014427185, 0.032684326, -0.013084412, -0.011047363, 0.0019350052, 0.061462402, 0.036193848, 0.001376152, 0.0029182434, 0.035736084, 0.025466919, 0.04159546, 0.0637207, 0.019073486, 0.04623413, 0.0006008148, -0.0008339882, 0.055480957, 0.0070991516, 0.020751953, -0.035858154, 0.030792236, 0.006790161, 0.009925842, -0.01007843, 0.0031147003, -0.06390381, 0.03375244, -0.020996094, 0.025802612, -0.002696991, 0.018981934, 0.037994385, 0.008262634, -0.0018148422, 0.0064926147, -0.004096985, -0.007133484, -0.00027394295, 0.01914978, -0.015068054, -0.05065918, -0.015563965, -0.0105896, 0.020828247, 0.0060768127, 0.0060043335, -0.010635376, 0.019683838, -0.0181427, 0.00082969666, -0.002981186, 0.055847168, 0.031341553, 0.006298065, 0.017654419, -0.017868042, -0.0063476562, 0.0927124, 0.095214844, -0.043670654, 0.03756714, -0.07519531, -0.008743286, 0.009376526, -0.030258179, -0.0048446655, 0.018295288, 0.015266418, 0.0008530617, -0.04067993, 0.029586792, -0.072753906, 0.0178833, 0.020019531, -0.008430481, -0.036102295, -0.05923462, -0.0049934387, -0.025665283, -0.03475952, -0.0026416779, 0.061950684, -0.0059928894, 0.00071048737, 0.0073394775, 0.010025024, -0.030441284, -0.006965637, -0.021957397, -0.028671265, 0.031951904, 0.027069092, 0.03652954, -0.05154419, 0.020217896, -0.014884949, 0.03778076, -0.015060425, 0.0107421875, -0.017608643, 0.00440979, 0.012756348, -0.018798828, 0.017852783, -0.03692627, -0.0128479, -0.07788086, -0.0013074875, 0.008308411, -0.02708435, -0.012756348, 0.053649902, -0.004470825, -0.047729492, -0.0058135986, 0.04989624, -0.050811768, -0.010879517, 0.027160645, 0.037078857, -0.009437561, 0.023391724, 0.033325195, 0.0057678223, -0.029953003, -0.031341553, -0.051483154, 0.003572464, -0.00724411, -0.0104522705, 0.042938232, -0.053741455, -0.022232056, -0.033081055, -0.0063209534, -0.00051259995, 0.034454346, 0.0018434525, -0.023986816, -0.026290894, -0.015945435, 0.011978149, 0.01461792, -0.029205322, -0.012840271, 0.093933105, 0.012184143, 0.01209259, 0.03314209, 0.036071777, -0.008659363, -0.017547607, -0.0121154785, -0.036621094, 0.017608643, 0.039733887, 0.012382507, -0.005252838, 0.02003479, -0.12658691, -0.019989014, 0.053985596, 0.00756073, -0.023162842, 0.017059326, -0.062805176, 0.015731812, 0.0035419464, 0.0017499924, 0.02267456, 0.05050659, 0.016937256, 0.0018138885, 0.044433594, -0.05105591, 0.024810791, -0.04336548, -0.097351074, 0.047546387, -0.04373169, -0.050933838, -0.003900528, -0.024383545, -0.026855469, -0.022003174, -0.015625, 0.021499634, 0.048675537, 0.03643799, 0.007598877, -0.015022278, 0.0046043396, -0.04006958, -0.006980896, -0.009803772, -0.05532837, 0.016311646, 0.012367249, 0.076049805, 0.044952393, -0.011924744, -0.012741089, -0.0034160614, -0.0056610107, 0.03479004, -0.000019907951, -0.042419434, -0.008468628, -0.010948181, -0.0076675415, -0.0259552, 0.005329132, -0.00081014633, 0.022644043, 0.0015821457, 0.011077881, 0.04071045, 0.023895264, -0.0057754517, -0.021835327, -0.015464783, 0.012268066, -0.006046295, -0.07470703, -0.011001587, 0.04071045, -0.008171082, 0.011634827, 0.0026721954, -0.028656006, 0.032684326, 0.0020942688, 0.0010652542, 0.013504028, 0.0009860992, -0.014022827, 0.026672363, -0.01386261, -0.011497498, -0.0049209595, 0.021469116, -0.00066661835, 0.010513306, -0.032409668, -0.06298828, -0.0055503845, 0.014472961, -0.13720703, -0.053588867, 0.01725769, -0.03930664, -0.02986145, -0.060516357, 0.035461426, -0.048980713, -0.017486572, -0.0017557144, -0.020812988, -0.03152466, -0.0054969788, -0.06530762, -0.02960205, 0.0871582, -0.0096206665, 0.01612854, 0.0047836304, 0.00907135, 0.0037269592, -0.041656494, 0.010482788, -0.020721436, 0.02470398, -0.04006958, -0.014770508, 0.048828125, -0.025222778, 0.029541016, 0.015899658, 0.033966064, -0.016418457, -0.005531311, 0.018844604, 0.003227234, -0.028640747, 0.040802002, 0.024917603, -0.028411865, -0.051086426, 0.009780884, 0.0041503906, -0.022857666, 0.003921509, -0.005695343, 0.025222778, 0.040252686, 0.012969971, 0.05215454, 0.00033211708, -0.0045051575, 0.0040397644, -0.04348755, -0.010856628, 0.021896362, 0.013710022, -0.030578613, -0.018951416, 0.034332275, -0.021408081, 0.06542969, -0.050598145, -0.0124053955, 0.015510559, 0.030471802, -0.041870117, -0.018127441, -0.05444336, -0.03564453, -0.018035889, 0.020507812, -0.02708435, 0.006137848, 0.034088135, -0.017303467, -0.025680542, 0.013046265, 0.027374268, 0.0012025833, -0.00447464, -0.061462402, 0.022979736, -0.0075683594, -0.06274414, -0.046844482, -0.030151367, 0.013877869, 0.02532959, 0.007751465, -0.029144287, 0.026901245, -0.0076942444, 0.03744507, 0.05493164, -0.015129089, -0.048706055, 0.03314209, 0.0031661987, -0.012199402, -0.018341064, 0.026779175, -0.0073890686, -0.035614014, -0.014083862, -0.020935059, 0.0007610321, -0.021255493, 0.013534546, -0.008522034, 0.025405884, -0.031402588, 0.03967285, 0.009460449, -0.005470276, 0.013145447, -0.0009775162, -0.03100586, -0.0015878677, 0.009384155, 0.07879639, -0.050842285, 0.037719727, 0.027435303, 0.004611969, 0.010154724, -0.028137207, 0.028945923, -0.0048980713, -0.033813477, 0.01058197, 0.01626587, -0.041625977, -0.044433594, -0.0063705444, 0.036895752, 0.04574585, -0.050689697, 0.064331055, -0.04840088, 0.0058021545, 0.004627228, -0.006160736, 0.016998291, -0.016952515, 0.036071777, -0.074035645, -0.03555298, -0.014678955, 0.04736328, -0.05142212, -0.0048217773, -0.021240234, -0.020751953, 0.02861023, 0.025772095, 0.039642334, -0.008308411, -0.016540527, -0.014190674, -0.0053710938, -0.008506775, -0.034423828, 0.010902405, -0.00038814545, 0.02609253, -0.01889038, 0.0012168884, -0.06341553, 0.013847351, 0.00579834, 0.005191803, -0.0032234192, -0.064697266, 0.027511597, 0.053894043, 0.014175415, 0.010421753, -0.010116577, 0.0039863586, 0.04598999, 0.04953003, 0.0036888123, 0.033599854, 0.033111572, -0.0096588135, 0.004886627, 0.005607605, 0.03286743, -0.024047852, 0.017807007, 0.010513306, -0.01424408, -0.062927246, 0.03552246, 0.029525757, -0.019836426, 0.01586914, -0.03857422, 0.029541016, 0.0034751892, 0.0051193237, 0.002412796, -0.03414917, -0.025604248, 0.00730896, -0.014701843, -0.0049705505, 0.0002863407, -0.0045433044, -0.023223877, -0.06958008, 0.015090942, -0.024215698, 0.0088272095, -0.016983032, 0.021209717, -0.040222168, 0.0317688, 0.020080566, -0.03704834, 0.017791748, -0.0024681091, 0.014160156, 0.05883789, 0.028747559, -0.030807495, 0.0076065063, -0.035064697, -0.076049805, -0.075683594, -0.02192688, -0.001452446, 0.023254395, 0.002822876, -0.022476196, -0.0049858093, -0.0043640137, 0.010803223, 0.02168274, -0.030578613, 0.04510498, -0.0035648346, -0.008071899, 0.0052833557, 0.017532349, 0.045806885, -0.010467529, -0.00957489, -0.04006958, 0.0284729, -0.018096924, -0.020019531, 0.015991211, -0.041625977, 0.017456055, 0.023651123, 0.011650085, -0.033294678, 0.015853882, 0.04336548, -0.0072746277, 0.004421234, 0.0042533875, 0.07312012, -0.041259766, -0.022399902, 0.0011501312, 0.0077438354, -0.01159668, 0.066223145, -0.018539429, -0.026184082, -0.04449463, -0.0446167, -0.027679443, 0.011878967, 0.031219482, 0.023788452, 0.06732178, -0.06185913, -0.010322571, -0.016464233, -0.0071105957, -0.020339966, 0.012367249, 0.00078105927, 0.00059366226, -0.0061149597, 0.019683838, 0.000073611736, -0.019180298, 0.033111572, 0.02986145, -0.017303467, 0.02394104, -0.05218506, 0.00038814545, -0.030227661, -0.028213501, 0.056884766, 0.017578125, -0.017028809, 0.053100586, -0.042877197, 0.05307007, 0.024475098, 0.03933716, 0.037475586, 0.014381409, 0.023666382, 0.0041122437, 0.015136719, -0.027526855, -0.010612488, -0.036102295, -0.03765869, -0.05645752, -0.019607544, -0.068603516, -0.0004041195, 0.0019359589, 0.0025939941, 0.046020508, 0.0048179626, 0.020950317, -0.008163452, 0.027145386, 0.007675171, 0.043792725, 0.023269653, 0.01335144, 0.015586853, -0.01586914, 0.00078868866, 0.025680542, 0.0071258545, 0.013427734, -0.00045704842, 0.018569946, -0.002204895, -0.003982544, 0.008338928, -0.034057617, 0.014984131, -0.021743774, 0.04208374, -0.014701843, 0.015014648, 0.08282471, 0.06262207, -0.0109939575, -0.026687622, 0.014892578, -0.010231018, -0.011039734, -0.0003554821, 0.028381348, -0.056549072, 0.024276733, -0.018096924, -0.017211914, 0.003835678, 0.04260254, 0.0023708344, -0.03656006, -0.017089844, 0.00031924248, 0.036956787, 0.025650024, 0.009902954, -0.03427124, 0.004032135, 0.043518066, 0.042022705, -0.028198242, 0.0010633469, 0.009300232, 0.03463745, -0.023254395, -0.025054932, 0.01020813, 0.025817871, -0.01586914, 0.023010254, -0.045928955, 0.0138168335, 0.00007265806, -0.03543091, 0.014183044, -0.006755829, -0.02859497, -0.0051116943, 0.041870117, 0.068847656, 0.056365967, 0.05593872, -0.023345947, -0.038208008, 0.059570312, -0.046722412, 0.037750244, 0.030593872, -0.04071045, 0.017440796, -0.044036865, -0.038513184, 0.03164673, -0.048980713, 0.060272217, -0.043518066, 0.012802124, -0.026779175, 0.045532227, 0.022888184, -0.068725586, -0.024475098, -0.02078247, -0.028015137, -0.02532959, -0.006904602, -0.0072250366, -0.027786255, -0.010986328, 0.027679443, 0.0007457733, 0.00066280365, 0.0044059753, -0.04397583, -0.049591064, 0.03765869, -0.01499176, 0.048736572, -0.020736694, 0.0035591125, 0.0045204163, -0.014320374, -0.026000977, -0.048095703, -0.015640259, -0.048187256, -0.0015306473, -0.045684814, 0.01965332, 0.009544373, -0.0211792, -0.02519226, -0.0022525787, -0.007785797, -0.013824463, -0.008377075, 0.045043945, -0.057922363, -0.012084961, 0.0066184998, -0.040802002, 0.04437256, 0.013504028, -0.0021629333, 0.019302368, 0.025436401, -0.014289856, -0.025146484, -0.00029277802, 0.020858765, 0.0051956177, -0.05859375, -0.00072813034, 0.04034424, 0.05770874, -0.04598999, -0.031433105, 0.018157959, 0.016586304, -0.0037250519, 0.06317139, 0.0012025833, 0.012863159, 0.018356323, 0.05633545, 0.012519836, -0.061767578, -0.05618286, -0.023834229, 0.05206299, 0.060394287, -0.009513855, -0.0146102905, 0.04837036, 0.0014600754, 0.007980347, 0.028930664, -0.03414917, 0.009101868, 0.0011405945, 0.02432251, -0.000446558, -0.016113281, 0.0020046234, 0.0090789795, -0.0002567768, 0.031829834, -0.014251709, -0.0023956299, -0.00217247, 0.05831909, -0.0032043457, -0.061553955, 0.053344727, 0.025253296, 0.034423828, 0.033843994, -0.016464233, -0.036743164, -0.014953613, -0.008682251, 0.009513855, 0.0055122375, 0.010917664, -0.03237915, 0.01638794, -0.048706055, -0.028274536, -0.05795288, -0.050231934, 0.039764404, -0.018615723, -0.011268616, -0.019699097, -0.0036697388, -0.003780365, 0.013793945, 0.016723633, -0.009796143, -0.049621582, -0.03729248, 0.047027588, -0.020080566 ], "summary": [ -0.01777649, -0.01725769, 0.003452301, 0.015625, -0.0340271, -0.0060043335, -0.007881165, -0.030670166, 0.007232666, 0.038513184, -0.02229309, -0.0118255615, 0.050628662, -0.033477783, 0.00069093704, -0.027130127, -0.017852783, 0.024856567, 0.027572632, -0.023330688, 0.04095459, -0.015548706, 0.013542175, -0.02923584, 0.015930176, -0.028121948, -0.083618164, 0.0039253235, -0.017150879, -0.013290405, -0.005016327, 0.028778076, 0.03463745, -0.0064315796, -0.022857666, 0.03778076, 0.021759033, -0.015068054, -0.033599854, 0.05130005, 0.030975342, -0.007972717, 0.074523926, -0.04827881, 0.015777588, 0.04537964, 0.001789093, -0.012275696, 0.0023345947, -0.0040359497, 0.013870239, 0.0099487305, 0.021575928, -0.015396118, -0.037353516, -0.03463745, -0.015655518, -0.024230957, 0.002193451, 0.047180176, 0.02192688, 0.003124237, 0.0051116943, -0.015853882, -0.0035953522, -0.015899658, 0.015716553, 0.020690918, 0.047668457, 0.014221191, -0.011489868, 0.035614014, 0.017196655, -0.051605225, -0.00774765, 0.019485474, 0.03353882, 0.00076675415, -0.02406311, -0.019256592, -0.0043525696, 0.04421997, -0.00674057, -0.032836914, -0.014198303, -0.03869629, -0.01525116, -0.003232956, -0.009017944, 0.0010967255, -0.02609253, 0.011299133, -0.051483154, 0.048065186, 0.036499023, -0.02671814, -0.031188965, -0.042022705, 0.028518677, 0.014373779, 0.015274048, -0.033691406, 0.004333496, -0.0052604675, 0.009750366, 0.08758545, 0.012809753, 0.014595032, -0.008300781, 0.0036182404, 0.004798889, -0.06695557, -0.024642944, -0.04647827, -0.03262329, 0.039794922, -0.01159668, -0.024993896, 0.0016803741, 0.004749298, -0.028121948, -0.007045746, -0.019805908, 0.04714966, 0.040649414, 0.029190063, 0.024368286, -0.0076522827, 0.018600464, -0.04156494, 0.0099105835, 0.04083252, -0.023788452, 0.0051879883, -0.019805908, 0.023880005, 0.02758789, 0.010002136, 0.025421143, -0.022399902, 0.041046143, 0.01411438, -0.011169434, 0.031051636, -0.009231567, 0.03778076, 0.016296387, -0.0036773682, -0.017913818, -0.008705139, -0.03643799, -0.025482178, -0.00036215782, -0.03302002, 0.03363037, -0.020599365, -0.045776367, 0.0141067505, 0.035858154, 0.02279663, -0.011329651, 0.023101807, 0.045776367, 0.017715454, 0.012840271, -0.0027828217, -0.007003784, -0.023986816, 0.01121521, 0.02494812, 0.012962341, 0.014633179, -0.02809143, -0.008178711, 0.012199402, -0.014434814, 0.028198242, 0.04510498, -0.016418457, -0.02507019, -0.026412964, -0.037353516, 0.03552246, -0.018005371, -0.034454346, -0.003955841, -0.01763916, 0.021713257, 0.078063965, 0.006706238, -0.02041626, -0.034484863, -0.011390686, -0.02305603, 0.017532349, -0.031829834, -0.010124207, -0.02381897, -0.0022621155, 0.029281616, -0.014945984, -0.023345947, -0.013092041, -0.011260986, -0.022521973, -0.02444458, -0.0031089783, 0.01600647, -0.029663086, 0.016540527, 0.024780273, -0.019577026, -0.016586304, -0.009338379, 0.013282776, -0.025314331, 0.025436401, -0.047210693, -0.013977051, -0.028778076, -0.037322998, 0.036865234, -0.042663574, 0.050628662, -0.008163452, 0.030654907, -0.025375366, 0.028549194, 0.082092285, 0.04055786, 0.06915283, -0.06329346, 0.008552551, -0.009300232, -0.0088272095, 0.006286621, -0.0060272217, -0.10046387, 0.008010864, 0.053619385, 0.021148682, 0.0002887249, -0.011734009, 0.009086609, 0.012870789, -0.00045204163, 0.018600464, 0.00869751, -0.002861023, 0.027893066, 0.024002075, 0.016311646, 0.0074691772, -0.019012451, -0.011383057, 0.024429321, 0.014122009, -0.017364502, 0.023910522, -0.01550293, 0.040008545, -0.028381348, -0.080444336, 0.01550293, -0.021209717, -0.013267517, 0.019592285, 0.03353882, 0.027526855, -0.039733887, 0.010284424, 0.014076233, -0.0012254715, 0.01826477, -0.064208984, -0.02571106, 0.0126571655, 0.020584106, -0.028274536, -0.033599854, 0.0043411255, -0.015113831, -0.018997192, 0.0015001297, 0.026855469, 0.010955811, 0.00016105175, 0.026351929, 0.037231445, 0.05166626, 0.068603516, -0.0056152344, -0.023147583, 0.04559326, -0.0362854, -0.039031982, 0.038391113, 0.05581665, -0.0047454834, 0.020080566, -0.033477783, 0.022201538, 0.009414673, -0.014381409, 0.001964569, 0.0012025833, 0.016036987, -0.031585693, -0.02331543, 0.031555176, -0.04144287, 0.035125732, 0.045837402, 0.031143188, 0.037750244, -0.0076179504, 0.0062675476, 0.07537842, 0.022277832, 0.0317688, 0.05203247, 0.030639648, 0.0115356445, 0.04333496, 0.02545166, -0.061767578, 0.042236328, -0.0058174133, -0.02947998, 0.016311646, -0.013389587, -0.0019273758, -0.010002136, 0.0368042, -0.016952515, -0.00000834465, -0.007347107, 0.026351929, -0.0057640076, -0.02420044, 0.012878418, -0.00047183037, 0.0049591064, 0.0023994446, -0.0259552, -0.052703857, 0.016418457, -0.01096344, 0.007724762, -0.00040221214, 0.01878357, 0.00484848, -0.052459717, 0.025985718, 0.005622864, -0.042907715, 0.038330078, 0.042541504, 0.012512207, -0.009681702, 0.0074386597, 0.027252197, -0.016815186, -0.023605347, -0.0035877228, -0.028533936, 0.034362793, -0.026000977, -0.00035881996, 0.0032176971, -0.008010864, 0.0040740967, -0.082092285, -0.011413574, 0.013557434, 0.040985107, 0.07006836, 0.024841309, -0.021957397, 0.029922485, 0.03955078, 0.022857666, -0.020309448, -0.022094727, 0.08856201, 0.003189087, 0.028045654, 0.044403076, 0.052490234, 0.008522034, 0.0027160645, -0.024993896, -0.0074653625, -0.01184845, 0.01322937, -0.004360199, -0.06161499, 0.032928467, -0.08544922, -0.008705139, 0.06088257, 0.026489258, 0.0335083, 0.018173218, -0.05886841, 0.0748291, -0.009307861, 0.017745972, 0.019821167, -0.031158447, 0.017532349, -0.036621094, 0.011802673, -0.07104492, 0.009963989, -0.043029785, 0.001958847, 0.01953125, -0.023071289, -0.028686523, 0.0033874512, 0.046905518, 0.016693115, 0.014091492, -0.013153076, -0.043182373, 0.04650879, 0.034973145, -0.009376526, -0.0013017654, -0.010467529, -0.03466797, 0.0017814636, 0.018936157, -0.038726807, 0.05328369, 0.02609253, -0.0016975403, 0.06201172, -0.06311035, 0.0129470825, -0.014045715, 0.031051636, 0.018478394, 0.016830444, -0.012771606, -0.0063209534, 0.04550171, 0.012817383, -0.019363403, 0.01838684, -0.00084733963, 0.02230835, -0.0024547577, -0.01235199, 0.035858154, -0.012481689, 0.0036029816, 0.027160645, -0.000562191, 0.030914307, 0.05380249, -0.114868164, -0.0335083, 0.037902832, -0.01234436, -0.004447937, -0.0015926361, -0.030975342, 0.037384033, 0.0104522705, -0.027572632, -0.006664276, -0.01184082, -0.010383606, 0.043701172, 0.019302368, -0.052215576, 0.056030273, 0.02142334, -0.025650024, 0.021133423, -0.04196167, -0.044891357, -0.02015686, 0.008453369, -0.06512451, -0.04522705, -0.014785767, 0.010177612, -0.024353027, 0.028656006, 0.024429321, 0.021392822, 0.02218628, -0.018936157, -0.018554688, 0.0463562, 0.022064209, -0.046539307, 0.045043945, 0.0070495605, -0.011405945, 0.00919342, -0.030288696, 0.05810547, 0.06451416, -0.019302368, -0.0015478134, -0.043182373, 0.019851685, -0.080444336, 0.007320404, 0.012283325, -0.010765076, 0.0023765564, 0.025360107, 0.03866577, -0.007369995, -0.0131073, 0.03086853, 0.044311523, -0.024887085, -0.0022010803, 0.040527344, -0.0073432922, -0.016098022, 0.039642334, 0.0059776306, -0.048614502, 0.006500244, 0.0101623535, -0.0038070679, 0.04840088, 0.017059326, 0.021896362, 0.008666992, -0.03253174, -0.03805542, -0.01828003, -0.020965576, -0.032470703, -0.016494751, -0.016067505, -0.024978638, 0.06878662, 0.013458252, 0.09320068, -0.024917603, 0.016845703, 0.019088745, 0.029510498, 0.000936985, -0.036193848, -0.0064201355, -0.004634857, 0.0051116943, -0.009613037, -0.005332947, 0.02178955, 0.0004696846, -0.014450073, 0.030029297, -0.017745972, 0.10595703, 0.02960205, -0.0055770874, -0.08508301, 0.024597168, -0.0058021545, -0.02571106, -0.03717041, -0.058013916, 0.0008702278, -0.025009155, 0.010520935, -0.005645752, 0.035827637, 0.0039520264, 0.015258789, 0.008666992, -0.012580872, -0.015380859, 0.033355713, 0.016571045, 0.039642334, -0.06896973, 0.068237305, -0.0037651062, 0.013664246, -0.0112838745, -0.011795044, 0.013534546, -0.042419434, -0.016036987, -0.013969421, -0.027114868, -0.0015153885, 0.034332275, -0.012619019, 0.0022716522, 0.0046691895, -0.004447937, -0.027236938, 0.008659363, -0.0077056885, 0.062683105, -0.06982422, 0.0056762695, -0.02532959, -0.039001465, -0.012756348, -0.015541077, 0.021347046, -0.035369873, -0.014381409, 0.050567627, -0.023483276, -0.0031223297, -0.016159058, 0.02645874, 0.009521484, 0.02609253, 0.030181885, 0.015975952, -0.051239014, 0.010627747, -0.011543274, -0.025787354, 0.011642456, -0.024978638, 0.024536133, -0.030670166, -0.011421204, 0.015670776, 0.027114868, -0.0158844, -0.008041382, -0.050048828, -0.042633057, -0.019897461, -0.0037593842, -0.040649414, 0.000667572, 0.0748291, -0.016067505, -0.020553589, 0.014297485, -0.013648987, -0.043792725, -0.00844574, 0.018661499, 0.022476196, -0.0058784485, 0.008934021, 0.0051574707, 0.004421234, 0.020187378, -0.019897461, -0.0043792725, -0.019546509, 0.0055770874, -0.024719238, -0.009117126, 0.030517578, -0.050231934, 0.005050659, 0.042419434, -0.051971436, 0.028259277, 0.00034284592, -0.0041160583, -0.016983032, -0.014717102, 0.0058555603, 0.005592346, 0.032836914, 0.019607544, 0.003326416, -0.030426025, 0.00034046173, 0.013893127, 0.0005893707, -0.025543213, 0.004425049, 0.041992188, 0.017852783, 0.016784668, 0.018936157, -0.02305603, -0.04940796, -0.035705566, 0.013542175, -0.02960205, 0.004634857, 0.02746582, 0.0018348694, -0.041625977, -0.023025513, -0.03161621, 0.0385437, -0.008964539, 0.025894165, -0.0041160583, -0.03982544, 0.03817749, -0.0099105835, 0.043701172, -0.00831604, 0.005432129, 0.007129669, 0.010253906, 0.024505615, 0.034240723, -0.07080078, -0.03161621, -0.078430176, -0.0826416, -0.048095703, 0.11468506, -0.0095825195, 0.0028934479, 0.027145386, -0.029159546, -0.0037574768, 0.045013428, -0.038726807, 0.0073776245, -0.026641846, -0.053497314, -0.014930725, 0.0018424988, -0.0065307617, -0.014541626, -0.012413025, -0.020690918, 0.024932861, -0.026855469, -0.038635254, 0.019561768, -0.009376526, 0.0036563873, 0.016357422, -0.010269165, -0.034332275, 0.0008225441, 0.012268066, -0.043395996, 0.01109314, -0.0287323, 0.04345703, -0.007873535, -0.011100769, -0.052825928, 0.014099121, -0.035064697, 0.0015535355, -0.026153564, -0.02078247, -0.0050735474, -0.0435791, -0.0008225441, -0.014823914, 0.02659607, 0.037109375, 0.04284668, -0.053375244, -0.03390503, 0.028274536, -0.0035266876, -0.039978027, -0.02885437, 0.004360199, 0.015411377, 0.055389404, 0.06109619, -0.028900146, 0.030563354, 0.005886078, 0.03942871, -0.012893677, 0.05053711, -0.0026950836, -0.012916565, -0.0082092285, 0.0011692047, 0.039520264, 0.018249512, -0.00039672852, 0.013252258, 0.032562256, 0.026489258, -0.004486084, -0.048095703, -0.011650085, 0.03012085, 0.027435303, -0.027633667, -0.032348633, -0.008102417, 0.035980225, 0.019546509, -0.0625, -0.030685425, -0.053497314, -0.033935547, 0.04257202, -0.014030457, -0.008262634, 0.057556152, -0.0045928955, -0.0029277802, -0.012069702, -0.045928955, 0.026290894, -0.002090454, 0.026733398, 0.010124207, 0.016937256, 0.0005774498, -0.0284729, 0.020004272, 0.00021123886, 0.026916504, 0.028518677, 0.024505615, 0.005886078, -0.01512146, -0.020721436, -0.06976318, 0.043823242, -0.029754639, 0.04550171, -0.0031261444, 0.027389526, 0.06958008, -0.010360718, 0.083496094, -0.07159424, 0.010673523, 0.008872986, -0.00579834, -0.0046081543, -0.005619049, 0.009155273, -0.011688232, -0.01751709, -0.016693115, 0.027877808, 0.0015249252, 0.048736572, -0.031051636, -0.0024433136, -0.014167786, 0.022659302, -0.015571594, 0.00033283234, -0.023086548, 0.022460938, 0.042907715, -0.012878418, 0.0070533752, -0.014862061, -0.007408142, 0.002708435, -0.0087509155, -0.0079422, -0.014022827, 0.015419006, 0.007293701, 0.025817871, -0.042663574, -0.03515625, -0.021621704, -0.004211426, 0.0038223267, -0.0023021698, 0.016189575, 0.015235901, 0.055511475, 0.11590576, 0.074645996, 0.02935791, -0.088378906, -0.0049438477, 0.14941406, -0.01638794, 0.028335571, -0.032592773, -0.005218506, -0.021606445, -0.013191223, 0.018829346, -0.0072402954, 0.001660347, 0.0049552917, -0.0362854, 0.0029468536, -0.05105591, 0.036743164, -0.057739258, -0.021835327, 0.037475586, -0.08074951, -0.029418945, 0.008155823, 0.032836914, -0.022567749, 0.0082092285, -0.014930725, -0.024047852, 0.00068712234, 0.022018433, 0.01411438, -0.05267334, 0.011947632, 0.07409668, 0.04373169, 0.119506836, 0.05343628, -0.008544922, 0.017837524, 0.013679504, -0.02720642, -0.063964844, -0.006919861, 0.013885498, 0.008071899, -0.054595947, 0.02279663, -0.004852295, -0.029525757, -0.022338867, 0.025543213, -0.009063721, -0.0152282715, 0.038085938, 0.03213501, -0.02178955, 0.005744934, 0.039123535, -0.058166504, 0.040496826, -0.021347046, 0.026901245, 0.025360107, 0.03491211, -0.007457733, -0.032592773, 0.0044059753, -0.014732361, 0.0158844, -0.06524658, -0.0055160522, -0.006668091, 0.011962891, -0.016433716, -0.036834717, 0.053985596, 0.026992798, 0.006126404, -0.00059223175, -0.052642822, -0.010261536, 0.04421997, 0.08404541, 0.016418457, -0.035064697, -0.004180908, -0.02420044, 0.054504395, 0.00090551376, -0.030670166, -0.011741638, 0.02281189, -0.0025310516, -0.015380859, 0.050811768, -0.05722046, -0.015975952, 0.017364502, -0.030593872, -0.027404785, 0.0027828217, 0.046325684, -0.030670166, -0.0029830933, -0.00089883804, -0.013465881, -0.01838684, -0.03479004, -0.008224487, 0.010803223, 0.008895874, 0.015289307, -0.0015258789, 0.03643799, 0.017059326, 0.0015277863, -0.02835083, -0.011734009, 0.024017334, 0.0006303787, 0.011764526, 0.0020713806, 0.009147644, 0.03100586, -0.025436401, 0.009025574, -0.08129883, -0.04586792, 0.0335083, 0.014007568, -0.037261963, 0.0446167, -0.009681702, 0.015808105, -0.0030899048, 0.00076675415, -0.0010442734, -0.0009241104, -0.010383606, -0.019989014, 0.0068626404 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2107.03019v3
SelfCF: A Simple Framework for Self-supervised Collaborative Filtering
Xin Zhou, Aixin Sun, Yong Liu, Jie Zhang, Chunyan Miao
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Collaborative filtering (CF) is widely used to learn informative latent representations of users and items from observed interactions. Existing CF-based methods commonly adopt negative sampling to discriminate different items. Training with negative sampling on large datasets is computationally expensive. Further, negative items should be carefully sampled under the defined distribution, in order to avoid selecting an observed positive item in the training dataset. Unavoidably, some negative items sampled from the training dataset could be positive in the test set. In this paper, we propose a self-supervised collaborative filtering framework (SelfCF), that is specially designed for recommender scenario with implicit feedback. The proposed SelfCF framework simplifies the Siamese networks and can be easily applied to existing deep-learning based CF models, which we refer to as backbone networks. The main idea of SelfCF is to augment the output embeddings generated by backbone networks, because it is infeasible to augment raw input of user/item ids. We propose and study three output perturbation techniques that can be applied to different types of backbone networks including both traditional CF models and graph-based models. The framework enables learning informative representations of users and items without negative samples, and is agnostic to the encapsulated backbones. We conduct comprehensive experiments on four datasets to show that our framework may achieve even better recommendation accuracy than the encapsulated supervised counterpart with a 2$\times$--4$\times$ faster training speed. We also show that SelfCF can boost up the accuracy by up to 17.79% on average, compared with a self-supervised framework BUIR.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2107.03019v3
"2023-04-30T09:47:26"
"2021-07-07T05:21:12"
{ "title": [ 0.0070648193, 0.00712204, -0.038391113, -0.044281006, 0.026565552, -0.01852417, 0.0027275085, -0.014083862, -0.010070801, 0.021469116, -0.010604858, 0.02520752, -0.041931152, -0.013557434, -0.04232788, -0.0043640137, -0.01676941, 0.035827637, -0.031982422, -0.032562256, 0.00084400177, -0.054870605, 0.02456665, 0.027053833, 0.03265381, -0.03656006, -0.047058105, 0.030593872, -0.030212402, -0.018432617, -0.0015897751, -0.013824463, 0.012825012, 0.053131104, -0.008964539, 0.02583313, -0.061065674, 0.032226562, 0.020202637, 0.002626419, 0.039886475, -0.00894928, -0.038208008, -0.0050354004, -0.045288086, 0.021438599, -0.03652954, -0.008712769, -0.025497437, 0.009239197, 0.027191162, 0.024627686, 0.005279541, 0.00038838387, 0.020217896, -0.022125244, -0.029541016, 0.008117676, 0.05316162, 0.028778076, 0.0107421875, -0.0670166, 0.021514893, -0.0018081665, -0.044891357, -0.032165527, -0.0045814514, 0.021270752, 0.068237305, -0.009727478, -0.026748657, 0.03466797, 0.017166138, 0.016113281, -0.054901123, -0.020721436, 0.07092285, 0.011505127, 0.032409668, -0.026229858, -0.025772095, -0.015296936, -0.040130615, -0.024505615, 0.02720642, -0.011199951, -0.014465332, -0.014717102, -0.019607544, -0.053710938, 0.0008044243, -0.028579712, -0.012794495, 0.0256958, -0.014755249, -0.024917603, 0.022628784, 0.072021484, 0.0031852722, -0.03100586, -0.024917603, 0.032592773, -0.072021484, -0.02067566, 0.006111145, 0.020721436, -0.04067993, -0.013244629, 0.020370483, 0.04156494, -0.018035889, 0.010528564, 0.036376953, 0.057617188, -0.036895752, -0.035369873, 0.0088272095, 0.0025119781, -0.007019043, 0.027755737, 0.003862381, -0.025344849, 0.022384644, 0.009117126, 0.02720642, 0.0004799366, -0.043792725, -0.005218506, -0.013168335, 0.022994995, 0.0013856888, 0.04849243, -0.08880615, -0.074279785, -0.060943604, 0.039886475, -0.016525269, 0.006095886, -0.007850647, 0.0053520203, 0.01763916, -0.010597229, 0.0042266846, 0.03591919, -0.0069999695, -0.006126404, 0.04916382, 0.0038013458, -0.04095459, -0.027816772, -0.029647827, 0.016067505, 0.042816162, -0.0129470825, -0.04071045, -0.02217102, -0.1048584, -0.03805542, 0.027877808, -0.01020813, 0.01928711, 0.00045967102, 0.012260437, 0.05050659, 0.05947876, 0.0044517517, -0.015838623, 0.0256958, 0.0040130615, 0.010902405, -0.008728027, 0.014572144, 0.01197052, -0.017288208, -0.0039901733, -0.0062942505, 0.056365967, 0.016433716, 0.013427734, 0.007080078, 0.0066108704, -0.033813477, 0.040374756, 0.015014648, -0.062561035, -0.02079773, 0.0055656433, -0.0048942566, 0.051818848, 0.009796143, -0.050750732, 0.023498535, -0.06756592, -0.03857422, -0.068847656, -0.012870789, 0.037872314, 0.04699707, -0.00340271, 0.033233643, -0.02331543, -0.0016889572, -0.031799316, 0.0017309189, -0.025909424, -0.02760315, -0.023483276, 0.0317688, -0.031066895, 0.052001953, 0.05307007, 0.010643005, -0.047424316, 0.013267517, 0.0028190613, -0.062042236, 0.0067100525, -0.008987427, -0.021820068, -0.016357422, -0.03845215, -0.018539429, -0.022125244, 0.038757324, 0.02041626, 0.0020599365, 0.0025749207, -0.016647339, 0.036132812, 0.024963379, 0.043273926, -0.029006958, 0.03717041, 0.027770996, -0.006210327, -0.04458618, -0.01701355, -0.017562866, 0.023712158, 0.021972656, 0.001206398, -0.0041656494, 0.0031795502, 0.051849365, 0.07470703, -0.0211792, 0.0039100647, 0.029510498, 0.032562256, 0.0362854, 0.028518677, -0.0012292862, 0.041809082, 0.0020446777, 0.016937256, 0.046936035, 0.004878998, 0.025772095, -0.04309082, 0.018203735, -0.009284973, 0.024642944, 0.026229858, 0.007160187, -0.07788086, 0.024047852, -0.026153564, 0.012504578, 0.01928711, 0.0132751465, 0.019058228, -0.007003784, 0.014381409, -0.0045051575, 0.03378296, -0.057495117, -0.0067253113, 0.00046348572, 0.020553589, -0.069885254, -0.012184143, -0.027374268, 0.023391724, -0.00068569183, 0.041992188, -0.015594482, 0.020996094, -0.0141067505, -0.0071411133, -0.019104004, 0.03894043, 0.030136108, 0.00315094, 0.0012845993, 0.011528015, -0.007980347, 0.08544922, 0.04837036, -0.0029792786, 0.018920898, -0.03829956, 0.03302002, 0.0105896, -0.0107040405, -0.0060691833, 0.040618896, 0.031463623, 0.0022697449, -0.03503418, 0.018722534, -0.061309814, -0.022918701, 0.0071868896, -0.045806885, -0.05230713, -0.050964355, -0.021972656, -0.060302734, -0.0826416, -0.029418945, 0.11199951, -0.011619568, -0.027572632, 0.010215759, -0.01675415, -0.03479004, 0.0031967163, -0.034942627, -0.028259277, 0.03527832, 0.019866943, 0.03149414, -0.057006836, 0.025360107, -0.004878998, 0.029464722, -0.0184021, -0.0042419434, -0.025344849, 0.027297974, 0.010917664, -0.01676941, 0.025772095, -0.05807495, 0.014137268, -0.050231934, 0.01878357, 0.030227661, -0.026519775, -0.014907837, 0.020309448, -0.027633667, -0.01890564, 0.024963379, 0.06262207, -0.006755829, -0.032196045, 0.024963379, 0.041931152, -0.017028809, 0.031143188, 0.0053253174, 0.0044670105, -0.06262207, -0.02848816, -0.03173828, -0.026397705, -0.013763428, -0.011238098, 0.056274414, -0.054534912, -0.021194458, -0.042022705, -0.012649536, 0.0021591187, 0.023880005, -0.0030231476, -0.03164673, 0.0024528503, -0.015945435, -0.02557373, 0.0028381348, -0.0368042, -0.0021896362, 0.07067871, 0.026000977, 0.0011119843, 0.015388489, 0.023330688, -0.009338379, -0.010665894, 0.004020691, -0.039001465, 0.005706787, 0.042236328, 0.010421753, -0.0029792786, 0.017089844, -0.11138916, -0.015510559, 0.019165039, 0.000006377697, -0.032470703, 0.00083732605, -0.054351807, -0.0385437, -0.022949219, -0.039367676, 0.027191162, 0.022460938, 0.006198883, 0.0020103455, -0.011634827, -0.017288208, 0.0020103455, -0.049621582, -0.086364746, 0.029968262, -0.018630981, -0.05090332, -0.021408081, 0.006828308, -0.03668213, -0.0016441345, 0.0017814636, 0.051452637, 0.017578125, -0.0011339188, 0.025405884, -0.019882202, -0.0027370453, -0.034576416, 0.007621765, -0.038238525, -0.046020508, -0.018356323, -0.016464233, 0.07598877, 0.0009264946, -0.008178711, -0.039855957, -0.017028809, -0.011421204, 0.05609131, -0.0014724731, -0.027557373, -0.027557373, -0.029205322, -0.022857666, -0.016448975, 0.018447876, 0.013999939, -0.03149414, -0.0054244995, -0.0053100586, 0.011665344, -0.012023926, 0.00005108118, -0.026229858, -0.014328003, 0.013748169, -0.012939453, -0.055786133, 0.001080513, 0.029632568, -0.006542206, 0.03466797, -0.020874023, -0.029663086, 0.035827637, -0.027236938, -0.0035552979, -0.01096344, -0.0034675598, 0.0018911362, 0.024475098, -0.017547607, 0.019012451, -0.034088135, -0.008255005, 0.019851685, -0.010879517, -0.009132385, -0.06616211, -0.00044584274, -0.015045166, -0.12017822, -0.024047852, 0.0061683655, -0.04397583, -0.045776367, -0.05303955, 0.010879517, -0.019378662, -0.043273926, 0.009857178, -0.011642456, -0.0077590942, -0.0012607574, -0.072387695, -0.02229309, 0.06976318, -0.036743164, 0.022094727, 0.042236328, 0.009384155, 0.009597778, -0.017196655, 0.021881104, -0.018539429, 0.05996704, -0.011146545, -0.0029964447, 0.07086182, -0.03466797, -0.0024280548, 0.03967285, 0.018569946, -0.008850098, 0.0055122375, 0.009880066, 0.04788208, -0.04776001, 0.04852295, 0.029464722, -0.017974854, -0.07672119, 0.018341064, 0.005760193, -0.021560669, 0.0035552979, -0.020248413, 0.00919342, 0.031982422, 0.008377075, 0.066833496, -0.002986908, -0.020812988, 0.027389526, -0.008087158, 0.0013856888, -0.01247406, 0.0042533875, 0.02432251, 0.008865356, -0.003534317, -0.02130127, 0.015068054, -0.024551392, -0.03555298, -0.0025501251, 0.006565094, -0.010482788, 0.023849487, -0.046173096, -0.06738281, -0.06463623, 0.014656067, 0.0088272095, 0.04321289, 0.02961731, -0.010688782, -0.024871826, 0.008079529, 0.026535034, 0.0055999756, -0.0064888, -0.060943604, -0.013076782, -0.020706177, -0.040222168, -0.016738892, -0.0074501038, -0.023086548, 0.03289795, -0.008399963, -0.025787354, 0.014724731, 0.024627686, 0.046447754, 0.015411377, -0.03439331, -0.026138306, -0.02961731, -0.0014858246, -0.033294678, 0.0206604, -0.0023841858, 0.003522873, -0.027908325, 0.011924744, -0.039276123, -0.021987915, -0.066467285, 0.01651001, -0.013847351, 0.021057129, 0.062042236, 0.064819336, 0.037322998, 0.020935059, 0.014297485, 0.016326904, -0.020812988, -0.019088745, 0.0024414062, 0.03277588, 0.025177002, 0.022781372, 0.057403564, -0.002412796, -0.004917145, 0.017074585, 0.0074424744, 0.02633667, 0.0040397644, -0.022888184, 0.03717041, -0.02218628, -0.030441284, 0.00072431564, 0.0078125, 0.045288086, -0.0597229, 0.043182373, 0.0069465637, 0.020874023, 0.022766113, -0.017120361, 0.029403687, -0.026229858, 0.023544312, -0.066101074, -0.050628662, -0.010665894, 0.027175903, -0.03201294, 0.0034046173, 0.021377563, 0.02885437, 0.037628174, 0.04675293, 0.024993896, 0.0129776, -0.02217102, 0.00289917, 0.018447876, -0.04244995, -0.027801514, 0.03451538, 0.0079422, -0.011856079, -0.03189087, -0.058532715, -0.05178833, -0.033569336, -0.0011987686, 0.005886078, 0.00831604, -0.06707764, 0.017913818, 0.059539795, 0.023208618, 0.0041656494, 0.019592285, 0.014480591, 0.028625488, 0.034362793, 0.02420044, 0.033294678, 0.009475708, -0.042999268, 0.04360962, -0.003572464, -0.0039863586, -0.016479492, 0.025726318, -0.008110046, 0.0028839111, -0.038208008, 0.04043579, 0.015281677, -0.01965332, -0.013679504, -0.037841797, -0.0051460266, 0.030258179, 0.040283203, 0.018432617, -0.036254883, -0.04168701, -0.04159546, -0.01386261, -0.070617676, 0.013793945, -0.009605408, -0.042419434, -0.044067383, 0.025375366, -0.017089844, -0.008720398, 0.010246277, 0.020492554, -0.015945435, 0.024917603, 0.028656006, -0.020431519, 0.0104599, -0.032165527, -0.0022392273, 0.034240723, 0.04486084, -0.017211914, 0.006298065, -0.039642334, -0.057556152, -0.06072998, 0.0060424805, 0.002943039, 0.017745972, -0.010009766, -0.03286743, -0.006137848, 0.0024356842, 0.024276733, 0.0053482056, -0.04055786, 0.019226074, 0.018417358, 0.022903442, -0.021011353, 0.056610107, 0.013549805, -0.0051116943, 0.0016546249, -0.02407837, 0.03515625, 0.0069847107, 0.049438477, -0.018127441, -0.05117798, 0.002023697, 0.030700684, 0.0023479462, 0.0018882751, 0.02230835, 0.033050537, 0.027236938, -0.012031555, 0.0048217773, 0.048217773, -0.042419434, -0.041900635, -0.027130127, 0.011665344, -0.035980225, 0.036834717, -0.025863647, -0.03857422, -0.038909912, -0.060577393, -0.02810669, 0.012908936, 0.025680542, 0.0317688, 0.0073623657, -0.05154419, 0.026000977, -0.046295166, -0.00983429, -0.029403687, 0.04168701, 0.00054836273, 0.016357422, -0.034851074, -0.016357422, -0.01386261, -0.030899048, 0.037231445, 0.012992859, -0.00762558, 0.01586914, -0.02192688, 0.013931274, -0.030303955, -0.010322571, 0.034576416, 0.024963379, -0.01838684, 0.047302246, -0.04083252, 0.047454834, 0.03262329, 0.054107666, 0.05050659, 0.008720398, -0.00045704842, 0.007118225, 0.017852783, -0.044891357, 0.020263672, -0.074157715, 0.045959473, -0.038085938, 0.0042800903, -0.062927246, 0.0011548996, 0.039154053, 0.026031494, 0.03010559, 0.005569458, 0.017181396, 0.0026493073, 0.025848389, 0.010520935, 0.04925537, 0.009849548, 0.020690918, -0.04067993, -0.015899658, 0.034240723, 0.027038574, -0.002954483, 0.017227173, -0.019088745, -0.031799316, 0.0043029785, 0.029663086, 0.01033783, -0.008705139, -0.017028809, -0.036254883, 0.041992188, -0.007987976, 0.03756714, 0.043823242, 0.048095703, 0.0047569275, -0.021408081, -0.0032138824, -0.011444092, -0.017166138, -0.0050468445, 0.03652954, -0.051483154, 0.0071792603, -0.013938904, -0.017227173, 0.019454956, 0.000083088875, 0.046417236, -0.07470703, -0.07946777, 0.0395813, 0.051208496, -0.0043296814, -0.010040283, -0.037506104, -0.014198303, 0.0076904297, 0.032714844, -0.014770508, -0.0050849915, 0.008430481, 0.037841797, -0.029129028, -0.0127334595, 0.0073051453, 0.012191772, -0.030639648, 0.031219482, -0.049041748, 0.022506714, -0.005458832, -0.047973633, -0.012176514, 0.026245117, -0.05279541, -0.016845703, 0.022125244, 0.059570312, 0.056640625, 0.069885254, 0.012367249, -0.0009560585, 0.006893158, -0.05621338, 0.04147339, 0.029144287, -0.050994873, 0.03753662, -0.03665161, -0.025772095, 0.02017212, -0.07800293, -0.014472961, -0.029708862, 0.0032138824, -0.012077332, -0.0036640167, 0.037994385, -0.04473877, 0.008628845, -0.00819397, -0.0101623535, -0.017089844, -0.006160736, -0.017333984, -0.027755737, -0.012619019, 0.018356323, 0.014892578, -0.021362305, -0.026824951, -0.003900528, -0.04736328, 0.010482788, -0.03845215, 0.040008545, -0.033721924, -0.017196655, 0.0030822754, -0.023971558, 0.02003479, -0.016204834, -0.03062439, -0.008560181, -0.012512207, -0.037139893, 0.004295349, 0.018295288, -0.026367188, -0.052642822, 0.021652222, -0.0052261353, -0.025009155, -0.0007548332, 0.023544312, -0.05340576, -0.03414917, -0.004135132, -0.04486084, 0.029251099, 0.035736084, -0.01486969, 0.010223389, 0.00027799606, -0.0033245087, -0.033477783, 0.014854431, 0.028793335, -0.0068740845, -0.033721924, 0.008026123, 0.020477295, 0.024795532, -0.0758667, -0.03086853, -0.010688782, 0.027557373, 0.002565384, 0.055236816, 0.02168274, -0.029220581, 0.0006752014, -0.01197052, 0.0029678345, -0.0068473816, -0.057037354, -0.025787354, 0.04537964, 0.0647583, -0.010002136, -0.021255493, 0.058502197, 0.006263733, -0.009933472, 0.0012617111, 0.0066452026, -0.009307861, -0.003929138, 0.013641357, -0.023620605, -0.053466797, -0.024337769, 0.005783081, 0.006706238, 0.04727173, -0.024459839, 0.0053253174, -0.001420021, 0.05758667, -0.0065574646, -0.056152344, 0.04156494, -0.0025424957, 0.023284912, 0.026138306, 0.018112183, -0.03439331, 0.00046801567, -0.01109314, -0.008285522, -0.008514404, 0.023849487, -0.049682617, -0.0047416687, -0.025436401, -0.038238525, -0.06414795, -0.04928589, 0.027435303, -0.051452637, 0.0035419464, -0.030288696, -0.023086548, -0.00756073, 0.020385742, -0.025894165, -0.02923584, -0.03152466, -0.011352539, 0.031799316, -0.011642456 ], "summary": [ 0.064819336, -0.009254456, -0.010879517, -0.040863037, -0.016906738, -0.030227661, -0.018066406, -0.01713562, 0.0039901733, 0.016799927, -0.045715332, 0.037719727, -0.04446411, -0.013641357, -0.0061683655, -0.026321411, -0.017333984, 0.03277588, -0.008125305, -0.02217102, 0.011436462, -0.04663086, -0.0178833, -0.009666443, 0.005645752, -0.018188477, -0.022659302, 0.026947021, 0.0036582947, 0.03488159, 0.0063209534, -0.024719238, -0.021865845, 0.08691406, -0.0826416, -0.056854248, -0.066345215, 0.04537964, -0.0068511963, 0.03186035, 0.043426514, -0.0069236755, 0.02178955, -0.003982544, -0.024978638, 0.030151367, 0.010025024, -0.0234375, -0.0025863647, 0.025222778, 0.0043640137, -0.0115356445, -0.0037937164, -0.007003784, -0.0065574646, -0.015541077, -0.056427002, 0.019546509, 0.036621094, 0.035064697, -0.0003271103, -0.045654297, 0.014816284, -0.020889282, -0.036102295, -0.0052375793, 0.046417236, -0.02418518, 0.060302734, -0.022827148, -0.010826111, 0.047546387, 0.024459839, -0.0037174225, -0.051086426, 0.0005264282, 0.05999756, 0.032287598, 0.009689331, -0.036224365, -0.07116699, 0.004096985, -0.09954834, -0.04458618, 0.0005030632, -0.009010315, -0.025253296, 0.0033187866, 0.0027675629, -0.00006252527, -0.0055236816, -0.03466797, -0.010139465, 0.06768799, 0.010444641, -0.008918762, 0.06225586, 0.05819702, 0.0028686523, -0.04147339, 0.02130127, -0.045684814, -0.008682251, -0.019989014, 0.0002323389, 0.026779175, -0.040527344, -0.019241333, 0.034057617, 0.03756714, 0.007221222, -0.0063552856, 0.06188965, 0.024032593, -0.05206299, -0.019424438, 0.04244995, 0.012664795, -0.0059051514, 0.02986145, -0.023651123, 0.015701294, 0.019317627, 0.025985718, 0.0050697327, 0.008125305, 0.03955078, -0.041137695, -0.02659607, 0.008201599, -0.039276123, 0.021987915, 0.046722412, 0.041503906, -0.0072631836, -0.020095825, 0.011650085, 0.023162842, 0.014755249, -0.021820068, 0.06652832, 0.0027561188, -0.017196655, 0.06378174, -0.019317627, 0.00680542, 0.008110046, 0.010856628, 0.011787415, -0.018127441, -0.018341064, 0.002254486, 0.034210205, -0.008171082, -0.01486969, -0.04840088, -0.006427765, -0.05960083, 0.034576416, -0.04647827, 0.0206604, -0.023757935, 0.00233078, 0.06542969, 0.02368164, 0.034729004, 0.0011558533, 0.012870789, 0.0007238388, -0.03466797, -0.009674072, 0.017074585, 0.020233154, -0.026428223, 0.0006146431, 0.006916046, 0.024749756, 0.026168823, -0.0033035278, 0.046447754, 0.008674622, -0.031799316, 0.06414795, -0.022979736, -0.01864624, -0.018218994, -0.0116119385, -0.008514404, 0.057647705, 0.010681152, -0.002298355, -0.012573242, -0.033996582, 0.001200676, -0.051574707, -0.017288208, 0.012062073, 0.020568848, -0.017578125, 0.03805542, 0.010437012, 0.004207611, 0.00037932396, -0.036254883, -0.08258057, -0.016082764, -0.028305054, 0.0385437, -0.019317627, 0.020843506, 0.031585693, -0.009422302, -0.04699707, 0.015991211, -0.0035820007, -0.04434204, 0.021591187, -0.05795288, -0.007850647, -0.035003662, -0.020217896, 0.047576904, -0.045288086, 0.061828613, 0.023986816, -0.010543823, -0.0043029785, 0.011711121, 0.018447876, 0.013496399, 0.0076026917, 0.0064315796, 0.019760132, 0.002445221, -0.029464722, -0.0005440712, 0.01914978, -0.015403748, 0.007095337, 0.036499023, 0.004219055, 0.02406311, -0.035888672, 0.022766113, 0.048339844, 0.038024902, 0.017410278, 0.012023926, 0.015571594, 0.019989014, -0.033599854, -0.02659607, 0.04525757, -0.035186768, 0.022491455, 0.033050537, -0.011360168, 0.0044822693, -0.0209198, 0.00674057, -0.0041007996, 0.0026187897, 0.032562256, -0.0072288513, -0.011062622, -0.058746338, 0.004699707, -0.0060806274, 0.04562378, -0.06762695, -0.0026721954, -0.027069092, -0.0038051605, -0.0155181885, 0.015396118, -0.059539795, -0.0054016113, 0.013801575, 0.018341064, -0.031677246, 0.0024089813, -0.000446558, -0.0036239624, -0.011276245, 0.033416748, -0.017822266, 0.008522034, -0.00869751, 0.03225708, 0.037261963, 0.036987305, 0.014465332, -0.0033607483, 0.03463745, -0.009010315, -0.018371582, 0.016143799, -0.007045746, 0.007484436, -0.045684814, 0.007320404, 0.039367676, -0.015655518, -0.008430481, 0.014381409, 0.042236328, 0.055755615, -0.0053710938, 0.012039185, 0.018630981, -0.014862061, -0.0063285828, 0.009521484, 0.011764526, -0.04925537, -0.05834961, -0.049224854, -0.0050239563, -0.0703125, 0.00020647049, 0.107421875, 0.011100769, -0.03137207, 0.037872314, -0.010887146, -0.04272461, 0.03845215, -0.017303467, -0.002981186, -0.0064582825, -0.034454346, -0.018356323, -0.03894043, 0.05996704, 0.009895325, 0.0014324188, 0.004749298, -0.017532349, 0.008163452, 0.031433105, 0.03970337, -0.023803711, -0.0041999817, -0.04611206, 0.013702393, -0.035888672, -0.007785797, 0.02508545, 0.02381897, -0.022949219, -0.0051574707, -0.021194458, -0.011672974, 0.029281616, 0.021194458, 0.03543091, 0.0043754578, 0.011238098, 0.046844482, -0.026306152, -0.009307861, 0.028884888, -0.007965088, -0.09295654, -0.008338928, -0.02760315, -0.05026245, 0.009780884, 0.012207031, 0.04373169, -0.019424438, 0.025665283, -0.03277588, -0.0079422, -0.0026893616, 0.003484726, 0.11590576, -0.0039482117, 0.005306244, 0.055236816, -0.015914917, 0.018951416, -0.055145264, -0.031341553, 0.04534912, -0.0059814453, 0.013999939, 0.045806885, 0.04156494, 0.004272461, 0.007873535, 0.014045715, -0.026992798, -0.030807495, 0.052215576, 0.029907227, 0.0056266785, 0.02798462, 0.0030956268, -0.0569458, 0.050201416, -0.00674057, 0.0025730133, -0.013381958, -0.0010471344, -0.042755127, 0.0385437, 0.00004643202, 0.0075416565, -0.0066223145, 0.053741455, -0.05883789, 0.043792725, -0.050445557, 0.042541504, -0.05517578, 0.048950195, 0.014923096, 0.0013904572, -0.060424805, -0.031951904, 0.09674072, -0.0069236755, -0.018417358, 0.031463623, 0.07537842, -0.04095459, -0.041107178, 0.03451538, 0.021911621, 0.009185791, 0.0035324097, 0.005504608, -0.030776978, -0.05279541, -0.04067993, -0.018035889, -0.005832672, 0.011199951, -0.046203613, -0.044189453, -0.019866943, -0.022781372, 0.04724121, 0.013946533, -0.021316528, -0.03692627, -0.07342529, -0.011474609, 0.012535095, -0.011230469, 0.01838684, 0.01524353, 0.03289795, -0.013191223, 0.0152282715, -0.05355835, 0.009735107, 0.018737793, -0.03338623, 0.0035362244, 0.012794495, -0.045959473, -0.0135650635, 0.022155762, -0.00040888786, 0.024734497, -0.023361206, -0.035705566, 0.04446411, -0.0052337646, -0.03656006, -0.05596924, -0.0034885406, -0.01663208, -0.009666443, 0.025115967, 0.029266357, 0.016098022, -0.031982422, -0.04159546, 0.027069092, -0.019210815, -0.040649414, -0.007980347, 0.0016384125, -0.031982422, -0.026382446, 0.0031528473, -0.040252686, -0.027908325, -0.07147217, 0.0062446594, -0.0074768066, -0.03378296, -0.0016841888, -0.026153564, 0.07739258, 0.030456543, -0.042663574, 0.032958984, -0.026901245, -0.014976501, 0.014274597, -0.012512207, 0.049072266, 0.03894043, 0.03930664, 0.011619568, -0.07019043, 0.07171631, -0.03677368, 0.022628784, 0.06390381, -0.02822876, 0.0019254684, 0.025375366, 0.025985718, -0.010505676, 0.0039711, 0.07733154, 0.087402344, -0.043670654, 0.011581421, 0.031829834, -0.005683899, -0.053466797, -0.009437561, -0.016555786, -0.040863037, 0.00043320656, 0.035858154, -0.0069503784, 0.033325195, 0.007949829, -0.018859863, -0.01586914, -0.052764893, -0.005455017, 0.015701294, -0.007713318, -0.033325195, -0.025482178, 0.026412964, 0.010307312, -0.025878906, -0.027389526, -0.0056762695, -0.041137695, -0.010101318, -0.007896423, -0.009727478, -0.0003054142, 0.02609253, 0.0071792603, -0.020385742, -0.07067871, 0.0076904297, 0.0069847107, 0.059692383, 0.019470215, 0.023880005, -0.015136719, -0.027236938, 0.0041236877, 0.0029354095, -0.018585205, -0.048614502, -0.031341553, -0.013923645, -0.02218628, -0.022949219, -0.042999268, -0.058258057, -0.034698486, -0.0044937134, -0.016998291, 0.0069084167, 0.020980835, 0.0010900497, -0.024536133, -0.03717041, -0.0021457672, -0.11254883, 0.0051231384, -0.006816864, 0.009475708, 0.01876831, 0.029876709, -0.003967285, -0.011741638, -0.03286743, -0.040527344, -0.09063721, 0.011436462, 0.012176514, -0.002910614, 0.08807373, 0.04852295, 0.029281616, 0.029556274, -0.017974854, 0.00067806244, 0.0003106594, 0.024047852, -0.011161804, 0.018218994, 0.06335449, 0.010131836, 0.031082153, -0.00057315826, -0.027740479, 0.02178955, 0.013160706, 0.017181396, -0.0054244995, -0.03756714, 0.036254883, 0.033172607, -0.0030822754, 0.017730713, -0.02204895, 0.0057258606, -0.027053833, 0.013839722, 0.0077209473, 0.0043640137, 0.031982422, 0.007385254, -0.0070991516, 0.018844604, -0.014701843, -0.024047852, -0.014297485, 0.0090408325, 0.016403198, 0.0026760101, -0.018035889, 0.009010315, 0.022155762, 0.0060691833, 0.02583313, -0.018066406, 0.023864746, -0.003921509, 0.010856628, 0.018127441, -0.03326416, 0.00081062317, -0.00030565262, 0.015777588, -0.019317627, 0.028167725, -0.09240723, 0.0110321045, -0.024795532, -0.016036987, 0.018005371, 0.0076408386, -0.033111572, -0.0657959, -0.016815186, -0.00059986115, -0.046875, 0.08831787, -0.03503418, -0.01737976, 0.02809143, -0.02684021, 0.039093018, -0.027359009, -0.03677368, 0.036743164, -0.016067505, -0.015182495, 0.027267456, 0.037353516, -0.0025043488, 0.03427124, -0.023117065, 0.013168335, -0.0051231384, 0.0007343292, -0.07116699, 0.031311035, 0.020690918, 0.048706055, 0.030212402, 0.01739502, 0.00356102, -0.053253174, -0.06384277, 0.014533997, -0.060668945, -0.018661499, -0.0076942444, -0.013206482, 0.004234314, 0.0357666, -0.04449463, -0.024871826, 0.041381836, 0.005935669, 0.035125732, -0.022491455, -0.014083862, -0.03161621, 0.024154663, -0.024765015, 0.011413574, -0.03463745, 0.025421143, -0.02998352, 0.0064964294, -0.044555664, -0.024917603, -0.04473877, -0.0088272095, 0.0035743713, 0.042999268, -0.0152282715, 0.00035953522, 0.022277832, -0.04437256, 0.012001038, -0.00699234, -0.020645142, -0.0005965233, 0.019302368, 0.023239136, -0.011169434, 0.034332275, 0.0019664764, -0.0071754456, 0.015586853, -0.014923096, 0.04043579, 0.02128601, 0.027694702, 0.0029563904, -0.014778137, -0.00390625, 0.03152466, -0.005622864, 0.022964478, 0.025344849, 0.009895325, 0.025253296, 0.027282715, 0.016830444, 0.03564453, 0.002204895, -0.0206604, -0.027801514, 0.03717041, -0.037200928, -0.04083252, -0.01398468, -0.0039978027, -0.004589081, -0.04449463, 0.014717102, -0.0074882507, 0.028366089, 0.021484375, 0.020812988, -0.05734253, 0.0007266998, -0.025100708, -0.0011014938, 0.015159607, 0.030166626, -0.0073509216, 0.018157959, -0.036376953, -0.03274536, -0.0065612793, -0.017196655, 0.020233154, -0.0011587143, 0.0013875961, 0.021560669, 0.0056648254, 0.010910034, 0.0064582825, 0.05899048, 0.019500732, -0.0040512085, 0.03012085, -0.006210327, -0.024597168, 0.010848999, 0.03074646, 0.020629883, 0.013320923, -0.029159546, -0.010253906, 0.023910522, 0.0013933182, -0.034698486, 0.056671143, -0.05709839, 0.05053711, -0.033416748, -0.0035476685, -0.029006958, 0.030395508, 0.021499634, -0.018615723, 0.040863037, -0.00843811, -0.009880066, 0.035095215, -0.058410645, 0.0129776, -0.0124053955, 0.014640808, 0.011695862, -0.017120361, -0.036346436, 0.028289795, 0.048461914, 0.00730896, 0.009086609, 0.019638062, -0.014823914, 0.013008118, 0.0075302124, 0.0022220612, -0.016464233, 0.029067993, -0.02520752, 0.011116028, 0.019500732, 0.03842163, 0.004306793, 0.00042963028, 0.04852295, -0.018859863, -0.0028324127, 0.034240723, -0.013114929, -0.0063972473, 0.000084877014, 0.031097412, -0.03149414, 0.009475708, -0.007736206, 0.046661377, -0.05569458, 0.07904053, -0.0993042, -0.08129883, 0.03213501, 0.033203125, -0.040039062, -0.022628784, -0.04071045, -0.043914795, 0.0074768066, 0.017303467, -0.034423828, -0.020904541, -0.008590698, 0.0047454834, -0.013053894, 0.019302368, -0.0059280396, 0.03265381, -0.003282547, 0.035736084, -0.07885742, 0.03527832, 0.02154541, -0.033813477, 0.0015945435, 0.04348755, -0.04550171, 0.025634766, -0.024459839, 0.101989746, 0.07672119, 0.073913574, -0.021881104, 0.02067566, 0.05114746, -0.011016846, 0.04473877, -0.02015686, -0.031234741, -0.029647827, -0.0067214966, 0.015434265, -0.034179688, -0.05783081, -0.049926758, -0.009475708, -0.0118637085, -0.023864746, -0.004650116, -0.023468018, -0.010688782, 0.021484375, -0.061187744, 0.013130188, 0.0012235641, -0.003627777, -0.04220581, 0.0065345764, -0.004180908, 0.003665924, 0.038970947, -0.04244995, -0.0034255981, 0.010925293, 0.003145218, 0.0004427433, -0.0052719116, 0.033172607, -0.010673523, -0.03805542, 0.029251099, -0.027435303, 0.044555664, -0.032348633, -0.044647217, -0.007347107, 0.01675415, -0.017700195, -0.0016412735, 0.030838013, -0.0067596436, -0.040618896, 0.049316406, -0.0003504753, -0.014953613, 0.030563354, -0.003250122, -0.0019569397, -0.054626465, 0.002002716, -0.04901123, -0.017089844, -0.0030994415, -0.0010166168, -0.00007426739, 0.028945923, 0.0032176971, -0.041381836, 0.0004506111, -0.0057754517, -0.010955811, -0.015014648, 0.00983429, -0.002702713, 0.0118255615, -0.064941406, 0.016433716, -0.009788513, 0.040527344, 0.008728027, -0.014892578, 0.005706787, -0.038635254, 0.00182724, -0.02381897, -0.005622864, 0.030441284, -0.0059928894, 0.002779007, 0.056732178, 0.03189087, -0.037139893, -0.0015220642, 0.040039062, 0.0062332153, -0.025558472, 0.026229858, 0.02041626, -0.04031372, 0.0054473877, -0.0149002075, -0.04559326, -0.061187744, 0.016983032, -0.021896362, 0.007926941, 0.028778076, -0.021072388, 0.00006663799, -0.015037537, 0.027496338, -0.007347107, 0.022735596, -0.015914917, -0.037902832, 0.024993896, -0.033569336, 0.033996582, -0.0030212402, 0.0473938, -0.00003707409, -0.011856079, -0.0018262863, 0.020095825, -0.044006348, -0.048828125, -0.015304565, -0.030563354, -0.06964111, -0.016799927, 0.0073242188, -0.043060303, 0.012023926, 0.039886475, -0.052490234, 0.023117065, -0.012954712, -0.025527954, 0.022476196, 0.022354126, 0.0030117035, -0.04107666, 0.009109497 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2107.09996v2
MarsExplorer: Exploration of Unknown Terrains via Deep Reinforcement Learning and Procedurally Generated Environments
Dimitrios I. Koutras, Athanasios Ch. Kapoutsis, Angelos A. Amanatiadis, Elias B. Kosmatopoulos
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
This paper is an initial endeavor to bridge the gap between powerful Deep Reinforcement Learning methodologies and the problem of exploration/coverage of unknown terrains. Within this scope, MarsExplorer, an openai-gym compatible environment tailored to exploration/coverage of unknown areas, is presented. MarsExplorer translates the original robotics problem into a Reinforcement Learning setup that various off-the-shelf algorithms can tackle. Any learned policy can be straightforwardly applied to a robotic platform without an elaborate simulation model of the robot's dynamics to apply a different learning/adaptation phase. One of its core features is the controllable multi-dimensional procedural generation of terrains, which is the key for producing policies with strong generalization capabilities. Four different state-of-the-art RL algorithms (A3C, PPO, Rainbow, and SAC) are trained on the MarsExplorer environment, and a proper evaluation of their results compared to the average human-level performance is reported. In the follow-up experimental analysis, the effect of the multi-dimensional difficulty setting on the learning capabilities of the best-performing algorithm (PPO) is analyzed. A milestone result is the generation of an exploration policy that follows the Hilbert curve without providing this information to the environment or rewarding directly or indirectly Hilbert-curve-like trajectories. The experimental analysis is concluded by evaluating PPO learned policy algorithm side-by-side with frontier-based exploration strategies. A study on the performance curves revealed that PPO-based policy was capable of performing adaptive-to-the-unknown-terrain sweeping without leaving expensive-to-revisit areas uncovered, underlying the capability of RL-based methodologies to tackle exploration tasks efficiently. The source code can be found at: https://github.com/dimikout3/MarsExplorer.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2107.09996v2
"2021-11-06T22:56:12"
"2021-07-21T10:29:39"
{ "title": [ -0.027435303, -0.011550903, -0.030197144, 0.016662598, -0.020431519, -0.031311035, 0.0018615723, -0.032928467, -0.024658203, 0.007171631, -0.029663086, 0.014656067, -0.046783447, -0.03363037, -0.002494812, -0.029678345, 0.003490448, 0.029388428, -0.016571045, -0.044311523, 0.0006928444, -0.05041504, 0.017974854, 0.10290527, -0.00017535686, 0.04724121, -0.10601807, 0.03778076, -0.056549072, -0.027374268, -0.031829834, 0.030670166, 0.018218994, 0.004623413, 0.0052375793, 0.0076828003, -0.038391113, 0.026885986, 0.01008606, -0.020004272, 0.007724762, -0.0077934265, -0.04019165, -0.022567749, -0.038238525, 0.013038635, -0.049957275, -0.019210815, -0.019851685, 0.08721924, 0.017974854, 0.035003662, 0.0015916824, 0.07476807, 0.019714355, -0.03378296, -0.010246277, -0.030273438, 0.043029785, 0.0236969, 0.0041160583, -0.0574646, 0.03353882, -0.012969971, -0.012283325, -0.028060913, 0.020996094, 0.031280518, 0.019500732, 0.0074882507, 0.008071899, 0.03277588, 0.00051403046, -0.002111435, -0.0446167, -0.0059509277, 0.037017822, 0.017486572, 0.029678345, -0.023956299, -0.0003221035, -0.034210205, 0.016464233, -0.049957275, 0.023483276, -0.04159546, -0.0051994324, -0.00032138824, -0.057922363, -0.051879883, -0.011077881, -0.022521973, -0.042175293, 0.0064697266, -0.021224976, -0.028137207, -0.03274536, -0.028015137, 0.0178833, 0.0040283203, 0.0076942444, 0.0074920654, -0.008453369, -0.007633209, 0.0010347366, 0.025024414, -0.0023536682, -0.030731201, 0.0024280548, 0.022598267, -0.022445679, 0.017288208, 0.042633057, 0.014602661, -0.0049324036, -0.054870605, -0.026931763, 0.048675537, 0.016540527, 0.02684021, -0.015686035, -0.03213501, 0.038726807, -0.011238098, 0.045440674, 0.024017334, -0.053375244, -0.0090408325, -0.012504578, 0.036254883, 0.0043258667, 0.07299805, -0.10498047, -0.11248779, -0.091918945, 0.05722046, 0.029052734, 0.019424438, 0.00434494, -0.02758789, 0.031951904, 0.018875122, 0.011520386, 0.0006160736, 0.028640747, -0.0093688965, 0.05319214, 0.008621216, -0.025497437, -0.010719299, -0.009170532, 0.032318115, -0.0077934265, 0.015777588, 0.022125244, -0.005218506, -0.053771973, -0.011955261, 0.0473938, 0.011367798, 0.032928467, 0.021209717, 0.015731812, 0.030548096, 0.057891846, -0.033233643, -0.029815674, 0.0129776, 0.011871338, 0.04159546, -0.004776001, 0.026672363, 0.00090551376, -0.01838684, -0.0023899078, -0.017166138, 0.038024902, 0.022766113, 0.0073394775, 0.0055389404, 0.010658264, -0.020584106, 0.022384644, 0.033813477, -0.018920898, -0.024429321, -0.00919342, -0.037353516, 0.036987305, -0.004688263, -0.045654297, 0.026916504, -0.024719238, -0.043121338, -0.031707764, -0.0020427704, 0.027664185, 0.03427124, -0.0031719208, 0.012176514, -0.045898438, -0.015167236, -0.020843506, 0.04324341, 0.03277588, -0.05819702, 0.019226074, 0.0059165955, -0.03793335, 0.067993164, 0.044677734, 0.007827759, -0.027313232, -0.012336731, 0.016082764, -0.057281494, 0.02494812, -0.027297974, -0.011642456, -0.012901306, -0.013999939, 0.018936157, -0.003458023, 0.044799805, 0.039886475, 0.03277588, -0.017868042, -0.012016296, 0.05090332, 0.026245117, 0.04550171, -0.015113831, 0.038970947, 0.025497437, -0.02192688, -0.01878357, 0.008293152, -0.016921997, 0.0073013306, 0.03062439, 0.008232117, 0.0037574768, -0.00390625, 0.0119018555, 0.11816406, 0.036499023, 0.009017944, 0.010673523, 0.017028809, 0.039215088, 0.024963379, 0.055023193, 0.058410645, 0.09063721, -0.0066108704, 0.06555176, -0.018814087, 0.015792847, -0.0046806335, -0.014213562, -0.0060157776, 0.008102417, 0.012214661, -0.002073288, -0.08013916, 0.0362854, -0.020431519, 0.019317627, 0.00548172, 0.021636963, 0.043273926, 0.007385254, 0.004558563, 0.009941101, 0.0064849854, -0.006385803, -0.028686523, 0.004169464, 0.04510498, -0.027938843, 0.005039215, 0.0034275055, 0.039276123, -0.0041389465, 0.023223877, 0.008659363, 0.021621704, -0.026473999, -0.04660034, -0.017227173, 0.035827637, 0.018508911, -0.020050049, 0.007926941, -0.013145447, -0.0135269165, 0.030532837, 0.06689453, -0.021591187, 0.001996994, -0.079711914, -0.010986328, -0.009895325, -0.02217102, 0.020370483, 0.021133423, 0.053985596, 0.0071983337, -0.008422852, 0.04638672, -0.07519531, -0.001531601, -0.00047969818, -0.038238525, -0.023773193, -0.050994873, -0.0067214966, -0.037109375, -0.04953003, 0.0013742447, 0.08874512, -0.034301758, -0.008140564, -0.029281616, -0.026168823, -0.027008057, -0.019226074, -0.033325195, 0.00844574, 0.0048675537, -0.010955811, -0.0012683868, -0.06414795, -0.0010204315, -0.00002527237, 0.025039673, -0.005332947, 0.012825012, -0.02520752, -0.024795532, -0.008232117, -0.03591919, 0.023345947, -0.0115737915, -0.008590698, -0.047424316, -0.020965576, 0.0010709763, 0.008850098, -0.009757996, 0.027572632, -0.0059432983, -0.024337769, 0.015716553, 0.028457642, -0.02268982, 0.007381439, 0.037078857, -0.00044369698, -0.0063591003, -0.009513855, -0.008422852, -0.028427124, -0.00066804886, 0.033721924, -0.03744507, -0.0107803345, -0.012245178, 0.0015630722, 0.04486084, -0.041992188, -0.0020713806, -0.04055786, -0.017822266, -0.009895325, 0.01247406, 0.0019664764, -0.025787354, -0.041046143, -0.012214661, 0.0010814667, 0.017929077, -0.0067100525, 0.013946533, 0.09094238, 0.00223732, -0.014213562, -0.0050964355, 0.050109863, 0.007724762, -0.01424408, -0.051635742, -0.0037498474, 0.02470398, 0.026275635, -0.018707275, -0.02218628, 0.029785156, -0.15563965, 0.016494751, 0.0053482056, 0.0052337646, -0.02507019, 0.0046081543, -0.035888672, -0.020874023, -0.0129776, -0.027023315, 0.018859863, 0.03201294, 0.012298584, -0.024993896, 0.033843994, -0.04547119, 0.03665161, -0.029876709, -0.059692383, 0.013595581, 0.0010948181, -0.042419434, -0.037841797, 0.04611206, -0.049102783, -0.0043678284, -0.005214691, 0.041290283, 0.029769897, 0.0093688965, 0.01701355, 0.014877319, 0.01713562, -0.014823914, 0.007736206, 0.00086450577, -0.031097412, 0.008796692, -0.012336731, 0.056365967, 0.029556274, -0.013404846, -0.0071868896, 0.024963379, 0.020217896, 0.04333496, 0.009941101, -0.020385742, 0.020202637, 0.005050659, -0.01512146, -0.0064430237, -0.014373779, -0.0022201538, -0.03286743, -0.0042419434, -0.014839172, 0.043426514, -0.010772705, 0.014572144, -0.0065345764, -0.01991272, 0.008270264, -0.030090332, -0.018493652, 0.013320923, -0.0051498413, -0.013450623, 0.032196045, -0.025390625, -0.04660034, 0.021194458, -0.056274414, 0.045135498, 0.022018433, -0.02041626, -0.013404846, -0.03817749, 0.017288208, -0.0021457672, -0.009750366, -0.03717041, 0.018203735, -0.0034637451, -0.012786865, -0.019302368, -0.0025920868, 0.009498596, -0.07672119, -0.017227173, 0.005420685, 0.0116119385, -0.00667572, -0.028747559, 0.02116394, -0.009750366, -0.035369873, 0.011230469, -0.0053215027, 0.011146545, 0.0048332214, -0.053863525, -0.046905518, 0.06210327, 0.006626129, -0.008049011, 0.05380249, -0.033325195, -0.03793335, 0.018417358, 0.013961792, 0.0524292, 0.034606934, 0.027999878, 0.03189087, 0.06665039, -0.03677368, -0.0056037903, 0.0234375, 0.06976318, -0.039855957, 0.0028839111, -0.012458801, 0.008583069, -0.028137207, 0.048339844, 0.018066406, -0.0009975433, -0.061828613, 0.04534912, -0.022216797, -0.014251709, 0.0065727234, 0.009681702, -0.0005226135, 0.010192871, 0.024002075, 0.026443481, -0.010902405, -0.032989502, -0.007659912, 0.019104004, -0.012649536, -0.010040283, 0.008041382, 0.019104004, -0.013114929, 0.046020508, -0.0028495789, 0.058685303, -0.036834717, 0.019104004, -0.017196655, 0.007865906, -0.048431396, -0.013397217, -0.053344727, -0.015823364, -0.009300232, 0.009979248, -0.024459839, -0.0014476776, 0.01348114, -0.0287323, -0.018249512, 0.01725769, 0.03152466, 0.011688232, -0.047027588, -0.079833984, 0.01953125, -0.027709961, -0.0703125, -0.06036377, -0.043792725, -0.005054474, -0.013595581, 0.015670776, -0.04119873, 0.0154418945, 0.031707764, 0.11437988, 0.020690918, 0.015899658, -0.06616211, 0.025177002, -0.032196045, -0.056518555, 0.023040771, -0.012390137, -0.015350342, -0.06213379, 0.02746582, -0.00932312, -0.029312134, -0.025039673, 0.026626587, -0.0013589859, 0.06341553, -0.0031719208, 0.030395508, 0.01940918, 0.036071777, -0.0015583038, 0.0008125305, -0.03567505, -0.008132935, -0.021942139, 0.050811768, -0.011238098, 0.03024292, -0.010299683, 0.027709961, 0.007030487, -0.040405273, 0.061676025, -0.04071045, -0.04135132, -0.0031986237, 0.0073432922, -0.008735657, -0.012786865, 0.008529663, 0.014007568, 0.031188965, -0.031829834, 0.05911255, -0.018096924, -0.006439209, 0.00248909, -0.008003235, 0.0055999756, -0.028869629, 0.008514404, -0.054016113, -0.08074951, -0.026260376, 0.05496216, -0.0073051453, -0.033843994, 0.010261536, 0.023651123, 0.023117065, 0.043792725, 0.033447266, -0.023544312, -0.023544312, -0.010643005, -0.025756836, -0.037841797, -0.06652832, -0.016921997, -0.035003662, 0.014633179, -0.027496338, 0.058380127, -0.047454834, 0.0038375854, 0.0076675415, -0.01991272, 0.020217896, -0.0748291, 0.007217407, 0.0340271, -0.023986816, 0.023025513, 0.027404785, 0.040283203, 0.037109375, 0.03488159, 0.017410278, -0.006011963, 0.025146484, -0.019317627, 0.045440674, -0.00868988, 0.028396606, -0.0012769699, 0.0045661926, -0.0016508102, 0.013191223, -0.048675537, 0.020141602, -0.010093689, -0.0037784576, 0.012283325, -0.024978638, 0.014678955, 0.019958496, 0.007785797, 0.0231781, -0.023132324, -0.033355713, -0.0151901245, -0.005836487, -0.038085938, 0.005466461, 0.00027871132, 0.00086450577, -0.06915283, 0.00072050095, -0.039855957, 0.008399963, -0.009765625, 0.023712158, -0.022750854, 0.03829956, 0.03375244, 0.0340271, -0.019958496, 0.019210815, -0.018112183, 0.02835083, 0.043884277, -0.032104492, 0.0015239716, 0.0042800903, -0.036743164, -0.029754639, 0.0027503967, -0.016082764, -0.0064735413, 0.010566711, -0.030944824, 0.0029640198, -0.007411957, 0.01525116, 0.004558563, 0.00038576126, 0.03427124, 0.0059165955, 0.00699234, 0.038269043, 0.0059776306, -0.010307312, 0.019058228, 0.011383057, 0.011360168, 0.03591919, -0.030075073, -0.014137268, 0.009208679, -0.013084412, 0.029205322, 0.031433105, 0.004589081, -0.020446777, -0.0049476624, 0.022399902, -0.019042969, -0.00073719025, -0.011932373, 0.06112671, -0.040222168, 0.036499023, -0.018737793, -0.012245178, -0.050750732, 0.06463623, -0.00969696, 0.021697998, -0.06713867, -0.05050659, -0.02696228, 0.0066566467, 0.02961731, 0.0032901764, 0.027740479, 0.022613525, 0.047698975, -0.039276123, 0.009254456, -0.03515625, -0.0059661865, -0.027038574, -0.029846191, 0.05722046, 0.02519226, 0.016204834, -0.0413208, 0.021697998, 0.020324707, 0.0024528503, 0.020935059, -0.05557251, -0.00617218, -0.03933716, -0.027145386, 0.04095459, 0.018447876, -0.030395508, 0.0501709, -0.023162842, 0.06414795, -0.0104522705, 0.054626465, 0.05105591, 0.02041626, 0.020202637, -0.0070114136, -0.019699097, -0.040527344, 0.026687622, -0.056121826, 0.019363403, -0.028182983, -0.02104187, -0.062316895, -0.013343811, 0.03994751, 0.016662598, 0.047973633, 0.005619049, -0.0124053955, -0.00039863586, 0.015220642, 0.04434204, 0.038482666, -0.011192322, -0.0070648193, 0.0076942444, -0.0035915375, 0.02330017, 0.036834717, 0.0045433044, 0.013938904, 0.0002861023, -0.004173279, 0.009178162, 0.026443481, -0.003200531, -0.046936035, 0.0007929802, -0.031677246, 0.03652954, -0.0011940002, -0.00047135353, 0.07080078, 0.039031982, -0.012908936, -0.013496399, 0.026367188, -0.025146484, -0.018051147, -0.0047683716, 0.021347046, -0.041778564, 0.05001831, -0.018463135, -0.028366089, 0.0020370483, 0.02558899, 0.026947021, -0.0519104, -0.01852417, 0.025634766, 0.016342163, 0.0021629333, 0.0009703636, -0.045776367, -0.03555298, 0.013008118, 0.027938843, -0.023239136, 0.02746582, 0.026824951, 0.015533447, 0.00009292364, -0.0032291412, 0.008239746, 0.037475586, -0.008071899, 0.02331543, -0.010688782, 0.047943115, -0.007080078, -0.030197144, 0.019454956, 0.011474609, -0.06378174, -0.0033950806, 0.0042266846, 0.021514893, 0.005092621, 0.039642334, 0.0007648468, -0.02116394, -0.019592285, -0.015930176, 0.018630981, 0.037078857, -0.024124146, 0.009414673, -0.023635864, -0.037261963, 0.031158447, -0.03137207, 0.06719971, -0.025054932, 0.0158844, -0.01600647, -0.005756378, 0.073913574, -0.051574707, -0.046020508, -0.0109939575, 0.0090789795, 0.011550903, 0.015655518, -0.013374329, 0.017669678, 0.043670654, 0.02230835, 0.0546875, -0.022018433, 0.006843567, -0.011444092, -0.093811035, -0.01838684, -0.033294678, 0.010063171, -0.0018367767, -0.013313293, -0.020599365, -0.00093078613, 0.0069847107, -0.02178955, -0.025604248, 0.0032539368, -0.026367188, -0.024017334, 0.02973938, 0.034454346, -0.00060510635, 0.0027198792, -0.032928467, 0.014968872, -0.024459839, 0.0006928444, 0.025802612, -0.030715942, -0.032165527, -0.00466156, -0.017990112, 0.04663086, 0.018035889, -0.016952515, 0.010627747, 0.002576828, -0.02456665, -0.0016126633, 0.009170532, 0.05105591, -0.007663727, -0.022338867, -0.012901306, 0.03326416, 0.043945312, -0.040893555, -0.051239014, 0.0037441254, 0.014274597, -0.03970337, 0.05529785, 0.0057792664, 0.02281189, 0.06021118, 0.091796875, 0.010139465, -0.07366943, -0.04815674, -0.0071411133, 0.052886963, 0.021255493, -0.00605011, -0.023086548, 0.013572693, -0.018066406, 0.03186035, 0.012451172, -0.031555176, 0.028152466, -0.014144897, 0.05456543, -0.0019083023, 0.022415161, -0.028167725, 0.037109375, -0.0062408447, 0.033111572, -0.010978699, 0.019699097, 0.017105103, 0.054656982, -0.034973145, -0.03274536, 0.04284668, 0.0418396, 0.0047798157, 0.040924072, -0.018753052, -0.006462097, -0.010803223, 0.020370483, 0.0050697327, 0.024291992, 0.024475098, -0.0026226044, 0.020690918, -0.037322998, -0.05505371, 0.03845215, -0.04071045, 0.035980225, -0.03125, 0.029434204, -0.024459839, 0.032165527, 0.001115799, 0.029052734, -0.025756836, -0.015396118, -0.052337646, 0.012641907, 0.021850586, -0.021759033 ], "summary": [ -0.014266968, -0.016479492, 0.006542206, 0.04989624, -0.047027588, -0.022460938, 0.00919342, -0.036193848, -0.032836914, -0.015640259, -0.034332275, 0.013595581, -0.057617188, -0.038238525, 0.028320312, -0.07312012, 0.005836487, 0.012840271, 0.010383606, -0.041503906, 0.035949707, -0.04449463, 0.0021533966, 0.10101318, 0.0055122375, 0.037353516, -0.093811035, 0.046875, -0.02758789, -0.0020866394, -0.010749817, 0.0231781, 0.0035057068, -0.002084732, 0.020477295, -0.025024414, -0.026260376, 0.020065308, 0.015975952, -0.01689148, -0.008842468, 0.018112183, 0.00096702576, -0.05633545, -0.026504517, 0.014801025, -0.034057617, -0.016677856, -0.004306793, 0.083984375, 0.012962341, 0.01965332, -0.019317627, 0.06616211, 0.021820068, -0.016174316, -0.0078086853, -0.055877686, 0.025863647, 0.028945923, 0.021133423, -0.015510559, 0.004753113, -0.0050811768, -0.006942749, -0.019805908, 0.04135132, 0.01272583, -0.022750854, -0.039031982, 0.014427185, 0.016418457, 0.027664185, 0.013870239, -0.030334473, -0.05822754, 0.05505371, -0.0054779053, -0.0099487305, 0.00042414665, 0.0017137527, -0.007144928, -0.009376526, -0.04675293, -0.0023269653, -0.04083252, -0.0053863525, 0.009986877, -0.06347656, -0.023071289, -0.026016235, -0.005542755, -0.07055664, -0.014312744, 0.0026245117, -0.016479492, -0.02960205, -0.06500244, 0.0077056885, 0.01197052, 0.07495117, -0.061340332, 0.084106445, -0.009223938, -0.012634277, 0.024337769, 0.029373169, -0.027374268, -0.023727417, 0.0069084167, -0.027557373, -0.005001068, 0.030715942, -0.024276733, -0.018417358, -0.023880005, 0.00026750565, 0.04626465, 0.022994995, -0.009925842, -0.022964478, -0.00007355213, 0.023361206, 0.006378174, 0.029769897, 0.026016235, 0.0015468597, -0.020309448, 0.019805908, 0.0138168335, 0.007156372, 0.056365967, -0.05529785, -0.06402588, -0.07165527, 0.008110046, 0.05545044, -0.0019779205, 0.022583008, -0.037750244, 0.026992798, 0.0052719116, -0.0015172958, 0.020370483, 0.045776367, 0.028503418, 0.032684326, 0.0064086914, -0.0009174347, -0.018447876, -0.0077781677, 0.02659607, -0.0063438416, 0.017410278, 0.07348633, -0.025680542, 0.026046753, -0.0154418945, 0.04333496, -0.005176544, 0.03881836, 0.015457153, 0.030426025, 0.07385254, 0.03048706, -0.027648926, 0.0023479462, -0.0027980804, 0.008811951, 0.014633179, 0.020004272, 0.04522705, -0.015686035, -0.012649536, 0.01108551, -0.03945923, 0.007423401, 0.04763794, 0.0087509155, -0.047729492, -0.005718231, -0.045318604, 0.05090332, 0.0141067505, 0.03463745, -0.060913086, -0.01007843, -0.043121338, 0.006828308, 0.019927979, -0.043518066, 0.00995636, -0.008834839, 0.0060310364, 0.002456665, 0.011833191, -0.013183594, 0.026245117, -0.014060974, -0.04776001, 0.026901245, -0.011360168, -0.014305115, 0.021118164, -0.017822266, -0.01838684, 0.0014390945, -0.0024166107, -0.04196167, 0.03955078, 0.028213501, -0.012908936, -0.029144287, 0.009941101, 0.027954102, -0.023956299, 0.028030396, -0.028305054, 0.02357483, -0.030014038, 0.00844574, 0.025268555, -0.019592285, 0.011451721, 0.02041626, 0.023773193, -0.03842163, 0.016967773, 0.049804688, 0.0116119385, 0.050689697, 0.0035438538, -0.0030784607, 0.0060539246, -0.021011353, -0.01007843, 0.022109985, -0.038208008, 0.023132324, 0.034332275, 0.014411926, 0.041931152, -0.030960083, 0.009727478, 0.1038208, 0.043151855, -0.0023612976, 0.012428284, -0.04156494, -0.0010576248, 0.008628845, 0.03375244, 0.024902344, 0.02885437, -0.026916504, 0.053833008, -0.022125244, -0.029129028, 0.028564453, -0.02911377, 0.020935059, -0.014511108, -0.0209198, 0.015716553, -0.08642578, 0.02470398, -0.0005531311, 0.012557983, -0.0043258667, -0.021713257, 0.029052734, 0.0657959, -0.012641907, -0.0069236755, 0.0021457672, 0.012825012, -0.045898438, 0.02494812, 0.029006958, 0.002708435, 0.006439209, -0.015625, -0.040252686, -0.008079529, 0.04663086, 0.015464783, -0.009536743, 0.01309967, -0.012931824, 0.04714966, 0.04711914, 0.022735596, 0.005870819, 0.00004887581, -0.006668091, -0.00008529425, 0.0015678406, 0.018417358, 0.013595581, -0.039886475, -0.027114868, 0.02041626, -0.04269409, -0.0104599, 0.017181396, -0.0121536255, 0.0513916, 0.011505127, 0.023483276, 0.012901306, -0.040985107, 0.0027561188, 0.011474609, 0.0113220215, -0.018371582, -0.019088745, -0.0021362305, 0.021713257, 0.0013513565, 0.047607422, 0.11730957, -0.057556152, 0.006839752, -0.00944519, -0.054382324, -0.05239868, 0.039855957, -0.017684937, 0.003047943, -0.0045661926, -0.05239868, -0.047790527, -0.07098389, -0.0231781, 0.005844116, 0.01928711, -0.000014901161, 0.03479004, -0.0062026978, -0.026306152, 0.007041931, -0.017211914, 0.026672363, 0.018173218, -0.027908325, -0.01889038, -0.0178833, -0.016067505, 0.017166138, -0.0076904297, 0.010116577, 0.0040512085, -0.016784668, 0.036132812, -0.02330017, -0.018814087, 0.032592773, 0.005115509, -0.046142578, -0.03704834, 0.01953125, -0.0035572052, -0.022567749, -0.029144287, 0.02279663, -0.020324707, -0.004962921, -0.03289795, 0.007972717, 0.06359863, -0.0131073, 0.054779053, -0.064575195, -0.030288696, -0.046325684, 0.025924683, 0.058380127, -0.018829346, 0.0005412102, 0.026870728, 0.0006418228, 0.0044822693, -0.006095886, -0.007987976, 0.10583496, 0.00818634, 0.010345459, -0.012321472, 0.07122803, 0.005455017, 0.0016489029, -0.047088623, 0.055358887, -0.012672424, 0.00554657, -0.016845703, -0.014434814, 0.031204224, -0.05532837, 0.005847931, -0.03390503, 0.036499023, 0.0066452026, 0.0062179565, -0.01737976, 0.008110046, -0.030792236, -0.023742676, 0.013130188, 0.022323608, 0.026046753, -0.057037354, 0.05319214, -0.06414795, 0.009536743, -0.014541626, 0.016815186, -0.0019283295, 0.0051841736, -0.031433105, -0.037353516, 0.06274414, -0.030044556, -0.0040626526, -0.015434265, 0.0063438416, 0.014053345, 0.023803711, -0.010932922, 0.03387451, 0.012626648, -0.01222229, 0.026931763, 0.030685425, -0.05029297, 0.025787354, 0.0059013367, 0.03262329, 0.058013916, -0.06958008, -0.029876709, 0.012382507, 0.009231567, 0.02381897, 0.0154418945, -0.037506104, 0.013328552, -0.028244019, -0.020446777, -0.025283813, -0.021133423, 0.016052246, 0.033355713, 0.01626587, 0.01235199, 0.05041504, -0.05142212, 0.03677368, 0.028640747, -0.01751709, -0.0178833, -0.03781128, 0.037078857, 0.0011634827, 0.01676941, 0.012619019, -0.011421204, -0.008529663, -0.03933716, 0.009094238, -0.013267517, 0.0017004013, 0.012672424, -0.046905518, 0.020584106, -0.070129395, 0.04159546, -0.013084412, 0.03918457, -0.05255127, -0.0028953552, 0.011917114, -0.017807007, -0.00024175644, -0.011375427, 0.018310547, -0.054382324, -0.030838013, 0.004787445, 0.055603027, 0.040252686, -0.010406494, 0.034606934, 0.01864624, -0.020706177, 0.02609253, -0.008987427, 0.05130005, 0.014137268, -0.036987305, -0.0033988953, 0.009048462, 0.045410156, 0.0073547363, -0.002319336, 0.011978149, 0.028305054, 0.027648926, 0.015548706, 0.0101623535, 0.049102783, -0.0033092499, 0.068115234, 0.041381836, -0.0075416565, 0.011451721, 0.008361816, 0.081604004, -0.04537964, -0.021530151, 0.009002686, 0.014381409, -0.025268555, 0.005531311, 0.04425049, 0.0012302399, -0.041137695, 0.048461914, -0.023147583, -0.033203125, 0.016647339, 0.0309906, -0.020690918, -0.003993988, 0.026123047, -0.0021247864, -0.00093364716, -0.06378174, -0.0016546249, 0.05444336, -0.0069236755, -0.010765076, -0.010559082, 0.048461914, -0.037963867, 0.03479004, -0.048980713, 0.03390503, -0.04083252, 0.01084137, -0.0033435822, 0.005039215, -0.06323242, -0.050964355, 0.0064697266, 0.018585205, 0.009315491, -0.014846802, -0.031982422, 0.010124207, -0.0048675537, -0.019302368, 0.020751953, 0.008712769, 0.05029297, 0.044311523, -0.05355835, -0.090148926, -0.0010061264, -0.04067993, -0.049957275, -0.03817749, -0.055419922, -0.030532837, -0.042663574, 0.023498535, -0.04437256, 0.015174866, 0.011894226, 0.08807373, 0.021347046, 0.033203125, -0.05609131, 0.034942627, -0.037994385, -0.017593384, 0.023223877, -0.004760742, -0.023788452, -0.03390503, 0.04019165, -0.0068626404, -0.052001953, -0.057861328, 0.016052246, 0.0052719116, 0.044403076, 0.066467285, 0.04815674, 0.029296875, 0.028671265, -0.023864746, 0.000395298, -0.025146484, 0.027740479, -0.05255127, 0.029464722, -0.014892578, 0.030456543, 0.0005993843, 0.011917114, 0.009498596, -0.04232788, 0.043670654, -0.038208008, -0.058654785, -0.003578186, 0.01737976, 0.020935059, -0.009559631, 0.017654419, 0.012702942, 0.0056419373, -0.0016345978, 0.013710022, 0.018997192, 0.004562378, -0.0104599, -0.03643799, 0.0027275085, -0.041107178, -0.0072364807, -0.05041504, -0.07165527, -0.019958496, 0.05670166, -0.003042221, -0.04940796, 0.007926941, 0.0096588135, 0.030914307, -0.0017671585, 0.0066833496, -0.062438965, -0.014587402, -0.023742676, -0.040252686, 0.014678955, -0.052490234, -0.037261963, -0.023727417, 0.032958984, -0.0037441254, 0.064331055, 0.008132935, 0.019439697, 0.01890564, -0.03086853, 0.0023555756, -0.054901123, -0.048797607, -0.02947998, -0.02406311, -0.021896362, 0.05557251, 0.002773285, -0.021484375, 0.03289795, -0.016555786, 0.027832031, -0.003768921, -0.028015137, 0.020233154, -0.017364502, 0.01802063, -0.020233154, -0.00730896, -0.001750946, -0.01499176, -0.024002075, -0.0070648193, -0.05316162, 0.018676758, -0.027420044, 0.006038666, 0.002035141, 0.020248413, 0.02923584, 0.018539429, -0.018371582, -0.035827637, -0.028457642, 0.006225586, -0.03942871, -0.0023975372, 0.0045776367, 0.009819031, -0.045074463, -0.024658203, -0.05810547, 0.013206482, 0.00081062317, 0.0066833496, 0.000007390976, 0.023345947, -0.02017212, 0.006629944, -0.026763916, 0.058746338, 0.009902954, -0.009803772, 0.011306763, -0.0017709732, 0.0019292831, -0.012756348, -0.02027893, -0.04559326, -0.01360321, -0.023712158, 0.02947998, -0.0034484863, 0.010604858, 0.022460938, -0.064453125, 0.009750366, -0.01838684, 0.017700195, -0.000790596, -0.008071899, -0.028961182, 0.038330078, -0.016357422, -0.05493164, 0.023468018, 0.024017334, 0.024368286, 0.038116455, -0.01979065, 0.0034255981, 0.024810791, 0.007911682, 0.023071289, 0.01828003, -0.00006300211, 0.04437256, 0.010559082, 0.018203735, 0.035614014, 0.0039405823, 0.006072998, 0.020309448, -0.0054779053, 0.03479004, -0.026916504, 0.00097608566, -0.025756836, 0.08343506, -0.04397583, 0.010574341, -0.05911255, -0.030517578, -0.018844604, -0.034088135, 0.005344391, -0.0119018555, -0.001200676, 0.070251465, 0.037506104, -0.025161743, -0.013290405, -0.025344849, -0.0021209717, -0.028579712, -0.020141602, 0.075927734, 0.017608643, 0.019088745, -0.026733398, -0.0030899048, 0.025939941, 0.0181427, 0.017150879, -0.046936035, -0.0016918182, -0.036987305, 0.011001587, 0.014724731, 0.031951904, -0.03756714, 0.014022827, 0.004272461, 0.045562744, -0.0423584, 0.020568848, -0.030181885, -0.02368164, 0.02798462, -0.015960693, -0.04522705, -0.04660034, 0.023071289, -0.04534912, -0.03540039, -0.04385376, -0.04107666, -0.0011959076, -0.008422852, -0.0031871796, -0.014442444, 0.05734253, 0.0032138824, -0.03237915, 0.010131836, -0.0014286041, 0.068603516, 0.020935059, -0.011123657, -0.012435913, 0.0011501312, -0.014816284, 0.014198303, 0.045684814, 0.009223938, 0.010856628, 0.013328552, 0.0022468567, 0.019073486, -0.0044136047, -0.03250122, -0.06173706, 0.036315918, -0.03869629, 0.03930664, 0.014770508, 0.029449463, 0.041137695, 0.016540527, 0.0054244995, -0.015945435, 0.020584106, 0.0022792816, -0.013305664, 0.026611328, -0.00065135956, 0.009681702, 0.04296875, 0.007980347, -0.0335083, 0.023529053, 0.020828247, 0.031951904, -0.038238525, -0.00070142746, 0.01953125, 0.0046958923, -0.015670776, 0.021865845, -0.03237915, -0.06512451, -0.020446777, 0.012084961, -0.029876709, 0.029052734, 0.027175903, 0.003458023, -0.007331848, 0.021347046, -0.015686035, 0.051208496, -0.021408081, 0.02810669, -0.04788208, 0.046203613, 0.012245178, -0.010726929, 0.013916016, 0.014671326, -0.04345703, 0.03793335, -0.027862549, 0.03010559, 0.0035476685, 0.030929565, -0.015457153, 0.011489868, 0.005836487, 0.018356323, 0.02130127, 0.018112183, -0.00046348572, -0.026138306, -0.00907135, -0.012268066, -0.0135269165, -0.009857178, 0.03427124, -0.03286743, 0.023269653, -0.0036087036, -0.0158844, 0.027816772, -0.024536133, -0.066467285, -0.012519836, 0.04345703, 0.020111084, 0.017562866, -0.05166626, 0.04397583, 0.042755127, -0.01826477, 0.06225586, -0.041046143, 0.0032196045, 0.011260986, -0.072021484, -0.04949951, -0.04522705, 0.00021600723, 0.005054474, -0.0024471283, 0.017959595, 0.008987427, -0.009590149, -0.052490234, -0.01676941, 0.0068893433, 0.0046157837, -0.009414673, 0.008041382, 0.019607544, 0.0044670105, 0.032409668, -0.01889038, 0.030960083, -0.013366699, -0.0062561035, 0.012763977, -0.0055122375, -0.027450562, -0.016342163, 0.017578125, 0.009796143, 0.007843018, -0.027160645, 0.03286743, -0.02394104, -0.04321289, 0.008682251, 0.015075684, 0.025161743, -0.028366089, 0.005256653, -0.03515625, 0.05117798, 0.043792725, -0.022705078, 0.042236328, 0.025314331, -0.0066871643, -0.038360596, 0.036346436, -0.02748108, 0.035369873, 0.08959961, 0.14318848, 0.029708862, -0.08703613, -0.043060303, 0.0050621033, 0.015083313, 0.007385254, -0.0011081696, -0.015045166, 0.038604736, -0.03012085, -0.00067186356, 0.0073661804, -0.006263733, -0.00894928, -0.0049209595, 0.0178833, -0.024002075, -0.0038414001, -0.016296387, 0.02015686, -0.02305603, -0.028869629, 0.0025730133, 0.0063667297, -0.02230835, 0.013580322, -0.029037476, 0.03353882, 0.019577026, -0.0072288513, 0.032928467, -0.036346436, 0.022567749, 0.030166626, 0.010421753, 0.025222778, 0.030776978, 0.034820557, -0.021102905, 0.0050964355, -0.0065689087, -0.014404297, -0.05404663, 0.05709839, -0.05316162, 0.03451538, -0.00283432, 0.026397705, 0.059814453, 0.04269409, 0.014259338, 0.0072288513, -0.026794434, -0.00063848495, 0.012901306, 0.030090332, -0.017349243, 0.0058937073 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2107.10332v9
Machine Learning Characterization of Cancer Patients-Derived Extracellular Vesicles using Vibrational Spectroscopies
Abicumaran Uthamacumaran, Samir Elouatik, Mohamed Abdouh, Michael Berteau-Rainville, Zu-hua Gao, Goffredo Arena
q-bio.OT, cs.AI, cs.LG, physics.bio-ph
The early detection of cancer is a challenging problem in medicine. The blood sera of cancer patients are enriched with heterogeneous secretory lipid bound extracellular vesicles (EVs), which present a complex repertoire of information and biomarkers, representing their cell of origin, that are being currently studied in the field of liquid biopsy and cancer screening. Vibrational spectroscopies provide non-invasive approaches for the assessment of structural and biophysical properties in complex biological samples. In this pilot study, multiple Raman spectroscopy measurements were performed on the EVs extracted from the blood sera of 9 patients consisting of four different cancer subtypes (colorectal cancer, hepatocellular carcinoma, breast cancer and pancreatic cancer) and five healthy patients (controls). FTIR (Fourier Transform Infrared) spectroscopy measurements were performed as a complementary approach to Raman analysis, on two of the four cancer subtypes. The AdaBoost Random Forest Classifier, Decision Trees, and Support Vector Machines (SVM) distinguished the baseline corrected Raman spectra of cancer EVs from those of healthy controls (18 spectra) with a classification accuracy of above 90 percent when reduced to a spectral frequency range of 1800 to 1940 inverse cm and subjected to a 50:50 training: testing split. FTIR classification accuracy on 14 spectra showed an 80 percent classification accuracy. Our findings demonstrate that basic machine learning algorithms are powerful applied intelligence tools to distinguish the complex vibrational spectra of cancer patient EVs from those of healthy patients. These experimental methods hold promise as valid and efficient liquid biopsy for artificial intelligence-assisted early cancer screening.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2107.10332v9
"2022-02-14T04:18:47"
"2021-07-21T19:56:33"
{ "title": [ 0.0044517517, -0.0052986145, -0.012496948, -0.053497314, -0.0063209534, -0.004058838, -0.036346436, -0.025054932, -0.013618469, 0.020553589, -0.029800415, 0.00008249283, -0.025024414, -0.0076408386, -0.038757324, -0.030303955, 0.009086609, 0.04751587, 0.03286743, 0.00021791458, -0.0053482056, 0.015930176, 0.049072266, -0.010505676, -0.016952515, 0.022521973, -0.058258057, -0.013442993, -0.038330078, -0.04135132, -0.016235352, 0.027526855, 0.013931274, 0.054595947, -0.054718018, -0.030288696, -0.055725098, 0.05606079, -0.0030288696, -0.003616333, -0.0015125275, 0.003944397, 0.046020508, -0.032958984, -0.013946533, 0.04675293, -0.059753418, -0.045532227, 0.0042152405, 0.03878784, 0.007030487, 0.0010662079, -0.00012242794, 0.02456665, -0.00049495697, -0.040527344, -0.019241333, -0.018753052, 0.054107666, 0.04208374, -0.003211975, -0.044769287, 0.022781372, -0.04034424, -0.028121948, -0.020874023, -0.0178833, 0.01576233, -0.03491211, -0.018951416, 0.036712646, -0.01398468, -0.015029907, -0.017852783, -0.031341553, 0.041503906, 0.046844482, 0.033966064, -0.001786232, -0.014503479, 0.0016908646, -0.02456665, 0.039001465, -0.00017499924, -0.02027893, -0.012886047, -0.015296936, 0.008216858, 0.011276245, -0.016799927, 0.0014333725, 0.017166138, 0.00630188, 0.049346924, -0.04336548, 0.0031757355, -0.044189453, -0.015586853, 0.014984131, 0.013069153, 0.0054969788, -0.010002136, 0.027023315, -0.018554688, 0.011756897, 0.02330017, -0.0037975311, -0.06359863, -0.011787415, 0.015960693, -0.028045654, -0.018249512, 0.0070343018, 0.0010700226, 0.027694702, 0.001950264, -0.0073394775, 0.03414917, 0.010818481, 0.018966675, 0.005241394, -0.010574341, 0.0043754578, -0.0066490173, 0.00749588, -0.003791809, -0.042633057, 0.010513306, -0.058807373, 0.0670166, 0.024261475, 0.02822876, -0.064697266, -0.053131104, -0.063964844, 0.009933472, 0.014175415, -0.016448975, 0.0031223297, -0.010574341, 0.036315918, -0.020385742, -0.0021343231, 0.025802612, -0.004131317, 0.035827637, 0.05303955, -0.00806427, -0.030532837, -0.028930664, -0.07897949, 0.039367676, 0.053741455, -0.040618896, -0.092041016, -0.027435303, -0.09765625, -0.015159607, -0.015777588, -0.020141602, 0.028503418, 0.0008530617, -0.0340271, 0.032958984, 0.05105591, -0.0021877289, 0.009231567, 0.04675293, 0.0070991516, 0.013046265, 0.0034751892, -0.0023479462, 0.015304565, -0.032104492, -0.027252197, -0.009765625, 0.03845215, -0.00712204, -0.0048713684, -0.007194519, 0.008857727, -0.025405884, -0.035614014, 0.038482666, -0.061065674, 0.006477356, 0.0010671616, 0.047454834, 0.045410156, 0.01071167, -0.02696228, 0.0007596016, -0.004119873, -0.05126953, -0.047210693, -0.004447937, 0.03817749, 0.041229248, -0.013313293, 0.023239136, -0.0181427, -0.012878418, -0.0010728836, 0.0056037903, 0.0012083054, -0.049591064, 0.0052719116, 0.0027675629, 0.010719299, 0.057159424, 0.021606445, 0.015731812, -0.012954712, -0.026641846, -0.023025513, -0.032073975, 0.016464233, -0.0045318604, -0.03982544, -0.011528015, -0.045288086, -0.03265381, -0.021453857, 0.051940918, 0.0011339188, 0.002128601, 0.02319336, -0.036499023, 0.076049805, 0.015007019, 0.11419678, -0.043029785, 0.03164673, -0.018859863, -0.004940033, 0.02331543, 0.017456055, -0.03866577, 0.003276825, 0.018478394, 0.010406494, 0.0107803345, 0.008522034, 0.026504517, 0.10626221, 0.062438965, 0.019454956, -0.0032577515, 0.007411957, 0.036621094, 0.028915405, 0.028503418, 0.035186768, -0.02973938, 0.0154418945, 0.06768799, -0.01259613, 0.012008667, -0.006462097, 0.02229309, -0.0045814514, 0.10882568, 0.04724121, 0.041992188, -0.055664062, 0.029403687, -0.0074653625, 0.021377563, 0.0008568764, 0.018341064, 0.018997192, -0.013008118, -0.007083893, 0.009597778, 0.044433594, -0.031341553, -0.035888672, 0.002111435, 0.023147583, -0.028564453, 0.0019369125, 0.039001465, 0.035308838, -0.014266968, 0.021560669, -0.042236328, 0.0016021729, -0.014389038, -0.024536133, -0.017471313, 0.027923584, 0.027938843, -0.017684937, -0.005378723, 0.022384644, -0.015777588, 0.03982544, 0.074523926, -0.03677368, 0.0069274902, -0.07098389, -0.009216309, -0.001543045, -0.038330078, -0.0066871643, 0.05407715, 0.008140564, -0.0023765564, -0.02079773, -0.008796692, -0.012390137, 0.017150879, -0.0018224716, -0.06100464, -0.03274536, -0.033569336, -0.060546875, -0.06402588, -0.1159668, -0.049591064, 0.057617188, -0.01966858, 0.017303467, -0.00957489, 0.014320374, -0.051330566, -0.010360718, -0.0029621124, -0.0045394897, -0.010719299, 0.028656006, -0.013160706, -0.038116455, -0.004272461, 0.013710022, -0.01007843, -0.007663727, -0.024002075, -0.036102295, -0.009605408, -0.021148682, -0.0044021606, 0.016082764, -0.044158936, -0.007183075, -0.03894043, -0.0022144318, -0.0037631989, -0.0055274963, 0.0015897751, 0.03378296, -0.0112838745, 0.009216309, 0.023849487, 0.045837402, -0.046020508, -0.019897461, 0.07775879, 0.020935059, 0.031021118, 0.035308838, 0.02204895, 0.018722534, -0.016326904, -0.041412354, -0.0569458, -0.0052948, 0.000047564507, -0.0063705444, 0.037200928, -0.041015625, -0.014556885, -0.0006504059, -0.0015249252, 0.016723633, 0.012886047, -0.03945923, -0.04031372, -0.022918701, -0.039520264, 0.018707275, -0.01625061, 0.01071167, -0.012748718, 0.06097412, 0.00881958, -0.024246216, 0.028747559, -0.023788452, 0.0018501282, -0.06695557, -0.01878357, 0.02784729, -0.004459381, 0.022491455, 0.0042877197, -0.02041626, 0.014816284, -0.064941406, -0.00072717667, -0.0011405945, -0.0014219284, -0.02217102, -0.0040779114, -0.06542969, -0.0032405853, -0.059661865, -0.008934021, 0.009414673, 0.08502197, -0.01612854, 0.014129639, 0.0289917, -0.004837036, 0.022338867, -0.004398346, -0.06008911, 0.011726379, 0.012741089, -0.04788208, -0.048614502, 0.023803711, -0.041778564, -0.010238647, -0.01889038, -0.0072898865, 0.064941406, 0.018997192, 0.015945435, 0.038330078, 0.029388428, -0.010932922, -0.009346008, -0.029266357, -0.028839111, -0.025497437, -0.031051636, 0.031341553, -0.0033187866, -0.0008072853, -0.013656616, 0.015144348, 0.036376953, 0.017364502, 0.0070343018, -0.0357666, 0.020401001, 0.02670288, -0.018875122, -0.0019521713, 0.0032444, 0.023712158, -0.01374054, -0.014060974, -0.019592285, -0.043151855, 0.021011353, 0.008483887, -0.02545166, -0.01285553, 0.00038433075, -0.00687027, -0.04864502, 0.0046081543, -0.004840851, -0.016235352, 0.0925293, -0.018203735, -0.008514404, 0.021255493, -0.028686523, -0.001121521, 0.00042819977, -0.006629944, 0.033691406, 0.03314209, -0.042541504, -0.018325806, -0.018539429, 0.0073432922, -0.029647827, 0.012786865, -0.06945801, -0.034210205, 0.019119263, -0.013336182, -0.04574585, -0.016677856, 0.021118164, -0.09838867, -0.09124756, -0.05807495, 0.00818634, -0.056030273, -0.016342163, 0.005176544, 0.015319824, -0.05960083, -0.0049476624, -0.054595947, -0.07232666, 0.07385254, -0.027770996, 0.01499176, 0.02355957, 0.007736206, 0.013496399, -0.025360107, -0.0043525696, -0.0025310516, 0.03878784, -0.025100708, 0.0064086914, 0.022705078, -0.028198242, -0.0071868896, 0.032409668, -0.041656494, 0.015625, 0.016296387, 0.0259552, -0.0020771027, 0.01322937, 0.04397583, 0.0024909973, 0.0020828247, -0.03894043, -0.027160645, -0.0052833557, -0.01838684, -0.014007568, 0.0035438538, 0.012046814, 0.0423584, 0.02104187, 0.023849487, -0.00374794, 0.0064697266, -0.012504578, -0.035247803, -0.019729614, 0.03567505, 0.053833008, -0.0026435852, -0.008071899, 0.025177002, -0.029556274, 0.042785645, -0.0028591156, -0.022125244, 0.003993988, 0.019897461, -0.026641846, -0.036590576, -0.03161621, -0.090148926, -0.02116394, 0.0032043457, 0.012077332, 0.00223732, 0.020355225, 0.013137817, -0.031555176, -0.00983429, 0.049804688, 0.0115737915, -0.01914978, -0.06524658, 0.016708374, -0.024719238, -0.047454834, -0.05166626, 0.02758789, 0.032806396, 0.021255493, -0.0011672974, -0.020263672, -0.011230469, 0.038208008, 0.049621582, 0.020126343, 0.007297516, -0.027160645, -0.04336548, -0.02305603, -0.02545166, -0.015655518, 0.011894226, -0.030273438, -0.054656982, 0.0027942657, -0.0034217834, -0.04660034, -0.03463745, 0.041748047, -0.0029029846, 0.045837402, 0.040039062, 0.06137085, 0.04940796, 0.039733887, 0.04815674, 0.023086548, -0.005874634, -0.08453369, 0.03652954, 0.04119873, 0.033996582, 0.02947998, 0.04901123, 0.005519867, -0.04196167, 0.013397217, 0.044769287, 0.042877197, -0.032348633, -0.030639648, 0.0206604, -0.008682251, -0.009750366, 0.013572693, -0.00025248528, 0.045166016, -0.043518066, 0.008399963, -0.0013246536, 0.001121521, 0.0018672943, -0.01512146, 0.022537231, -0.001285553, 0.013038635, -0.05859375, -0.035949707, 0.004825592, 0.04284668, -0.019943237, 0.0033950806, -0.003063202, -0.011993408, 0.02809143, -0.0115356445, -0.020523071, -0.004699707, -0.030395508, -0.01927185, -0.013267517, -0.008796692, -0.0390625, 0.012321472, 0.011772156, 0.021331787, 0.010154724, -0.02607727, -0.06896973, -0.026062012, 0.027069092, -0.0073890686, -0.012252808, -0.05368042, 0.04119873, 0.020889282, -0.034301758, 0.007987976, -0.03564453, -0.009635925, 0.0960083, 0.020202637, 0.027862549, -0.032196045, 0.03213501, -0.0107040405, -0.013999939, 0.0050315857, 0.02935791, 0.025146484, 0.026672363, 0.017959595, 0.0016698837, -0.033843994, 0.035186768, 0.057373047, 0.031585693, -0.0013065338, -0.032165527, 0.030715942, -0.0039138794, -0.017715454, 0.018005371, -0.024398804, 0.009490967, 0.054534912, -0.011650085, 0.018234253, 0.0340271, 0.027313232, -0.062408447, -0.06665039, 0.023880005, 0.011360168, -0.023162842, -0.033294678, 0.02532959, -0.055358887, 0.039886475, -0.002527237, -0.05899048, -0.023147583, 0.00077056885, 0.021255493, -0.0027637482, 0.02960205, -0.039093018, -0.026535034, 0.015258789, -0.056793213, -0.003993988, 0.03933716, 0.012001038, -0.018753052, -0.00945282, -0.042175293, -0.032958984, -0.005718231, 0.005153656, 0.013587952, -0.028305054, 0.023361206, 0.009414673, 0.01713562, 0.0049858093, -0.0014152527, 0.0115356445, 0.0032234192, -0.0048446655, -0.0036258698, 0.010864258, -0.020523071, 0.015388489, -0.021392822, -0.04937744, 0.01423645, -0.00065279007, 0.030258179, 0.003660202, 0.025634766, 0.017303467, 0.07330322, -0.008338928, 0.014152527, 0.047180176, -0.026626587, -0.026245117, -0.034423828, 0.021408081, -0.031158447, 0.031463623, -0.019348145, -0.02116394, -0.012283325, -0.048736572, -0.024978638, 0.020950317, 0.03353882, 0.033813477, 0.057373047, 0.00021374226, 0.024932861, -0.028533936, 0.012588501, -0.036254883, 0.04321289, -0.008590698, -0.011184692, -0.013572693, -0.012542725, 0.0418396, -0.059326172, 0.025039673, -0.011764526, 0.00497818, -0.029891968, -0.023590088, 0.009117126, -0.010292053, -0.006000519, 0.029693604, 0.00015234947, -0.03060913, 0.03010559, 0.0041503906, 0.035095215, 0.009460449, 0.04574585, 0.04257202, 0.0010185242, -0.010406494, 0.00043678284, -0.01802063, -0.04345703, -0.007637024, -0.05886841, 0.00605011, -0.037353516, -0.007949829, -0.0501709, 0.006214142, 0.024398804, 0.019119263, 0.030822754, -0.009590149, 0.045806885, 0.006549835, 0.0574646, -0.04034424, 0.06317139, -0.037994385, -0.02041626, -0.008239746, 0.018753052, 0.0047950745, 0.01852417, 0.014251709, 0.014839172, -0.016555786, 0.008590698, -0.0026474, 0.0061416626, 0.008834839, 0.010948181, 0.012207031, -0.0007491112, 0.02192688, -0.0022335052, 0.007701874, 0.052520752, 0.047546387, -0.032592773, 0.002380371, 0.025360107, -0.002029419, -0.0071983337, -0.0045318604, 0.026519775, -0.046539307, 0.029144287, -0.0062713623, -0.024261475, -0.035736084, 0.043640137, 0.020935059, 0.0046043396, -0.008560181, 0.029266357, 0.019042969, 0.026229858, -0.0046577454, -0.02508545, 0.032104492, 0.057647705, 0.006210327, 0.0038852692, 0.0034713745, 0.034851074, 0.037597656, 0.017456055, -0.05166626, 0.02822876, -0.028030396, 0.0041007996, 0.02709961, 0.057891846, -0.00036740303, 0.00023078918, -0.043518066, 0.01977539, -0.011070251, 0.016036987, -0.00198555, 0.012275696, 0.042510986, -0.009017944, 0.050048828, -0.013374329, -0.030776978, -0.0074691772, 0.010215759, 0.00447464, 0.035339355, -0.032318115, 0.0026741028, 0.0154418945, -0.031555176, 0.04650879, -0.016494751, 0.06604004, -0.04425049, 0.029083252, 0.003255844, -0.018997192, 0.052490234, -0.04626465, -0.03778076, 0.004589081, 0.018234253, -0.016708374, 0.019454956, -0.028442383, -0.06817627, -0.0048675537, 0.090026855, -0.0049552917, -0.028076172, -0.0048980713, 0.00050735474, -0.047821045, -0.0067977905, -0.030197144, 0.031158447, -0.02784729, -0.0121536255, -0.029022217, 0.012611389, 0.018661499, -0.012413025, -0.026031494, -0.0054740906, -0.009918213, -0.0036773682, -0.008010864, -0.00083494186, -0.035095215, -0.04598999, 0.07714844, -0.01158905, -0.02243042, -0.056549072, 0.04296875, -0.0022697449, -0.046325684, -0.031677246, -0.03213501, -0.0026779175, 0.01626587, -0.007091522, 0.0289917, 0.022262573, -0.010421753, 0.012062073, 0.008720398, 0.021972656, -0.013435364, -0.023422241, -0.018844604, 0.05307007, 0.057678223, -0.026901245, -0.040771484, 0.017456055, -0.001534462, -0.01713562, 0.04473877, -0.001991272, -0.0050964355, 0.036224365, 0.0362854, -0.0010061264, -0.019165039, -0.017044067, -0.003786087, 0.060516357, 0.044189453, -0.02809143, -0.0056152344, 0.0047454834, 0.004890442, -0.016616821, -0.024765015, -0.026657104, -0.031707764, -0.018417358, -0.039978027, -0.021835327, 0.0072784424, 0.026229858, 0.026123047, -0.009918213, 0.009223938, -0.017303467, -0.008918762, 0.004016876, 0.018676758, -0.00085639954, -0.001613617, 0.006679535, 0.03277588, 0.0104522705, 0.051940918, -0.03640747, -0.045166016, 0.00029039383, -0.009590149, -0.02470398, -0.013252258, 0.10021973, -0.08666992, -0.021881104, -0.039855957, -0.020996094, -0.060394287, -0.009994507, 0.009895325, -0.055908203, 0.018249512, -0.038208008, -0.029205322, 0.00036907196, 0.014671326, -0.0005583763, -0.04837036, -0.040649414, -0.025299072, 0.030548096, -0.023071289 ], "summary": [ 0.033416748, 0.0016431808, 0.031463623, -0.016983032, -0.0289917, 0.0011281967, -0.033355713, -0.045440674, 0.022888184, 0.012191772, -0.041290283, -0.0019302368, -0.012084961, -0.036499023, 0.0023174286, -0.01574707, 0.011833191, 0.0501709, 0.07354736, 0.008674622, -0.000702858, 0.017791748, 0.055847168, -0.0070991516, -0.010978699, 0.036743164, -0.011077881, -0.0029773712, -0.01084137, 0.0028209686, -0.009086609, -0.005973816, -0.012741089, 0.084228516, -0.067871094, -0.0058021545, -0.029876709, 0.05593872, -0.0036029816, 0.026901245, 0.0104904175, 0.008354187, 0.10205078, -0.04647827, 0.031951904, 0.049743652, -0.026428223, -0.064208984, 0.025299072, 0.045532227, 0.0057144165, 0.008598328, -0.0037937164, -0.010375977, -0.01838684, -0.0385437, -0.017532349, -0.04336548, 0.018676758, 0.037231445, 0.015113831, -0.026733398, 0.01902771, -0.033599854, -0.053344727, 0.0020503998, 0.032958984, -0.016906738, -0.043121338, -0.045013428, 0.035705566, 0.009376526, -0.003030777, -0.036590576, -0.009841919, 0.057891846, 0.007499695, 0.038391113, 0.0042762756, -0.01436615, 0.0029201508, 0.01713562, 0.01940918, -0.0057525635, -0.035583496, -0.025604248, -0.018188477, -0.0014867783, -0.015609741, 0.018997192, -0.03161621, -0.010665894, -0.0053520203, 0.044799805, 0.008293152, -0.009895325, -0.02520752, -0.06390381, 0.029647827, 0.007843018, 0.052612305, -0.048706055, 0.056854248, -0.0128479, -0.022140503, 0.04034424, 0.015258789, -0.038208008, -0.021743774, 0.00459671, -0.0024490356, -0.05340576, 0.011421204, -0.052612305, 0.027236938, 0.029678345, 0.018707275, 0.0418396, 0.033081055, 0.008758545, 0.010826111, 0.026657104, -0.047576904, 0.006362915, -0.009017944, -0.0030174255, -0.005859375, 0.008148193, -0.07476807, 0.085876465, 0.00957489, -0.00029611588, -0.022399902, 0.004142761, -0.036132812, -0.026779175, 0.01838684, -0.013977051, 0.011199951, -0.030776978, 0.07281494, -0.03591919, -0.037902832, 0.083984375, -0.022872925, 0.04940796, 0.034332275, -0.015144348, -0.03225708, -0.024490356, -0.07757568, 0.031707764, 0.07409668, -0.050811768, -0.111816406, -0.04940796, -0.07678223, 0.0003798008, -0.028884888, -0.043121338, 0.010101318, -0.004322052, -0.031097412, 0.042175293, 0.037872314, 0.014038086, 0.03866577, 0.026626587, -0.00061416626, -0.107543945, 0.012710571, 0.0026683807, 0.03491211, -0.03668213, -0.0016899109, -0.0027599335, 0.02746582, 0.0053596497, -0.0026836395, -0.0013914108, -0.020553589, -0.049041748, 0.004184723, -0.00068569183, -0.00598526, 0.038604736, -0.025299072, 0.04586792, 0.03668213, 0.009986877, -0.058044434, -0.0022659302, 0.0418396, -0.060150146, -0.026977539, -0.014915466, 0.04067993, 0.038635254, -0.012649536, 0.003616333, 0.00970459, -0.031555176, 0.010620117, -0.032470703, -0.022521973, -0.060760498, 0.011138916, 0.008575439, 0.031951904, 0.024932861, -0.0052986145, -0.008155823, 0.014274597, -0.037506104, -0.041259766, -0.008377075, 0.011161804, -0.032806396, -0.036468506, -0.051513672, -0.030517578, -0.03189087, -0.045776367, 0.07489014, -0.016693115, -0.00995636, 0.014083862, -0.0009646416, 0.06652832, -0.015197754, 0.121520996, -0.020751953, 0.025527954, 0.019927979, 0.002729416, 0.027664185, 0.06298828, -0.04522705, 0.012245178, 0.023147583, 0.026397705, 0.018325806, -0.0135269165, -0.003873825, 0.08605957, 0.047058105, 0.028198242, -0.027816772, -0.029418945, 0.018295288, -0.0065574646, 0.03543091, 0.034576416, -0.0012369156, 0.00018584728, 0.046295166, -0.010070801, 0.012825012, 0.001291275, 0.03302002, -0.011360168, 0.10858154, 0.0501709, 0.03982544, -0.011444092, -0.024765015, 0.012893677, 0.0056152344, 0.004306793, -0.041503906, 0.01398468, 0.012779236, 0.00050640106, 0.006454468, -0.0048980713, -0.005027771, -0.029754639, -0.0047035217, 0.016860962, 0.0021896362, 0.007068634, 0.030670166, 0.012359619, -0.0098724365, 0.0057907104, -0.018615723, 0.000702858, -0.0021400452, -0.0027770996, 0.0022068024, 0.026657104, -0.006198883, -0.037200928, 0.026321411, 0.009559631, -0.042938232, 0.016830444, 0.060455322, -0.0012693405, -0.02204895, -0.036499023, -0.0059890747, -0.048614502, 0.0051193237, -0.00598526, 0.031311035, 0.004173279, 0.0021362305, 0.011711121, -0.05645752, 0.062438965, 0.044006348, 0.012275696, -0.03253174, 0.0003466606, -0.024246216, -0.033203125, -0.012031555, -0.07873535, -0.025619507, 0.067871094, -0.009277344, -0.0054130554, -0.015541077, -0.006286621, -0.034851074, -0.0035495758, -0.005622864, -0.0105896, -0.011352539, -0.00018072128, -0.0072288513, 0.005466461, 0.043029785, 0.0020771027, -0.031036377, 0.007369995, -0.03338623, 0.005126953, 0.015220642, 0.008018494, 0.035186768, 0.0026760101, -0.02619934, -0.01008606, -0.056671143, -0.014808655, -0.007881165, 0.019348145, -0.014976501, 0.028518677, -0.002527237, -0.024353027, 0.047790527, 0.04034424, -0.056274414, 0.007369995, 0.082214355, 0.0059814453, 0.015312195, 0.045135498, 0.036834717, 0.029403687, -0.00017273426, -0.05130005, -0.06304932, 0.019012451, -0.014831543, 0.017608643, 0.03552246, -0.023742676, 0.035827637, -0.03753662, -0.014274597, 0.009719849, 0.005996704, -0.0076065063, -0.008026123, -0.020095825, -0.018493652, 0.018005371, -0.017807007, 0.026062012, -0.026779175, 0.04119873, 0.008003235, 0.00037837029, 0.053619385, -0.02192688, -0.009521484, -0.05279541, 0.007789612, 0.023727417, -0.023971558, 0.0052452087, 0.026107788, -0.036376953, 0.0033931732, -0.0058403015, -0.013534546, -0.07366943, 0.04510498, 0.022644043, -0.027053833, -0.016998291, 0.0050315857, -0.06329346, -0.0317688, 0.007904053, 0.08001709, -0.025665283, 0.019515991, 0.006855011, 0.017349243, 0.0048675537, 0.023635864, 0.001124382, -0.00016140938, 0.023880005, -0.035614014, -0.04397583, 0.09320068, -0.03466797, -0.007835388, -0.007972717, -0.0066986084, 0.031585693, 0.011054993, 0.0020828247, 0.055114746, 0.03062439, -0.0015697479, 0.0038604736, -0.023513794, -0.055633545, -0.041809082, -0.039611816, -0.010231018, 0.015899658, -0.046051025, 0.018051147, 0.023849487, 0.0126571655, 0.021133423, -0.014259338, 0.0038967133, 0.03161621, 0.020629883, -0.015487671, -0.039398193, -0.017288208, 0.009536743, 0.01966858, 0.02557373, -0.004676819, 0.028549194, 0.0054893494, 0.013015747, 0.018295288, -0.009628296, -0.021377563, -0.008605957, 0.0018062592, -0.0073776245, 0.019302368, -0.011169434, 0.070739746, -0.005657196, -0.006511688, 0.030853271, 0.00067329407, -0.04071045, -0.02986145, -0.03488159, 0.048095703, -0.0019874573, -0.01902771, -0.0317688, 0.032104492, -0.0024547577, -0.05041504, 0.013832092, -0.038269043, -0.0069351196, -0.0010566711, 0.003124237, -0.016479492, -0.019454956, 0.015701294, -0.029769897, -0.04876709, -0.042541504, 0.035614014, -0.03781128, -0.010757446, 0.027908325, -0.006942749, -0.031921387, -0.01184082, -0.052642822, -0.024765015, 0.0071144104, -0.015563965, 0.007534027, 0.0012292862, 0.06896973, 0.03289795, -0.021408081, -0.041137695, -0.05593872, 0.011421204, -0.07562256, 0.016189575, 0.01008606, -0.018325806, -0.01838684, 0.022033691, -0.014404297, -0.011138916, 0.0010652542, 0.030548096, 0.01133728, 0.023666382, 0.017166138, -0.013748169, 0.016525269, -0.022323608, -0.009468079, -0.010734558, -0.01146698, 0.0041160583, 0.03665161, -0.005710602, 0.02053833, 0.00843811, -0.017990112, -0.017837524, -0.00712204, 0.0056266785, -0.0035514832, -0.003376007, 0.022262573, 0.018661499, 0.025650024, -0.0118255615, 0.019592285, -0.017028809, 0.027664185, -0.028259277, -0.02532959, 0.018371582, 0.037200928, -0.00029039383, -0.04220581, -0.016647339, -0.041046143, -0.00869751, 0.008049011, 0.029663086, -0.017623901, 0.0056915283, 0.03704834, -0.024459839, -0.0066947937, 0.035888672, 0.00630188, -0.004261017, -0.036254883, 0.0068473816, -0.0076560974, -0.025360107, -0.030212402, -0.0018148422, -0.014091492, -0.017074585, -0.015930176, -0.01676941, -0.009765625, 0.016220093, 0.027572632, 0.018829346, 0.030136108, -0.01864624, -0.044677734, -0.022399902, 0.018539429, 0.0057640076, -0.011184692, -0.036315918, -0.011703491, -0.00022494793, -0.005542755, -0.040802002, -0.039794922, 0.0079422, 0.02746582, -0.009788513, 0.02229309, 0.046661377, 0.02015686, 0.064331055, 0.068725586, 0.031341553, 0.014060974, -0.11328125, 0.019989014, 0.02368164, 0.053497314, 0.023986816, 0.0072517395, 0.002368927, -0.029800415, -0.0022659302, 0.040039062, 0.017440796, -0.054351807, -0.05014038, 0.019805908, 0.012893677, -0.009994507, 0.014541626, -0.012619019, 0.0040664673, 0.011383057, -0.0061454773, 0.013656616, 0.015281677, 0.0046691895, -0.02746582, 0.00724411, -0.007820129, 0.007144928, -0.028259277, -0.03704834, 0.011672974, 0.047698975, -0.0001745224, -0.015792847, -0.0057640076, 0.019088745, 0.027420044, -0.03881836, -0.053588867, -0.007381439, -0.033081055, -0.008972168, -0.012634277, -0.004371643, 0.004524231, 0.017593384, 0.011985779, -0.016738892, 0.0017614365, -0.0769043, -0.010169983, -0.054595947, 0.0345459, 0.029312134, -0.037597656, -0.030258179, -0.0069503784, -0.015396118, -0.037200928, -0.035308838, 0.00061130524, -0.025146484, 0.024719238, 0.006439209, 0.010787964, -0.053619385, 0.013999939, -0.04345703, -0.032836914, -0.020492554, 0.03152466, 0.03982544, -0.008399963, 0.025421143, -0.0022678375, -0.015792847, 0.0043029785, 0.031433105, 0.06347656, -0.029632568, -0.024047852, 0.019348145, -0.013496399, -0.017837524, 0.038635254, 0.0025920868, 0.041290283, 0.052246094, 0.016052246, 0.032470703, 0.0077819824, 0.05178833, -0.03366089, -0.050231934, -0.02734375, 0.0065193176, -0.034973145, -0.010482788, 0.058135986, -0.0013923645, 0.0026474, -0.033233643, -0.047546387, -0.022750854, 0.02255249, 0.027008057, -0.025253296, -0.017593384, -0.019683838, -0.015640259, 0.012565613, -0.03164673, 0.012420654, 0.058898926, 0.022064209, -0.01600647, -0.028762817, -0.035003662, -0.011108398, -0.015220642, 0.02017212, -0.02722168, -0.030166626, -0.017990112, 0.0075263977, 0.004337311, -0.011375427, -0.0027160645, 0.003967285, -0.018753052, -0.007774353, 0.011009216, 0.007270813, -0.014251709, 0.001200676, -0.010650635, -0.048828125, 0.01612854, 0.012962341, 0.034332275, 0.02230835, 0.032836914, 0.011795044, 0.06756592, -0.03060913, 0.006931305, 0.023635864, -0.014755249, -0.082458496, -0.029510498, 0.026535034, -0.011100769, -0.0012512207, -0.006362915, -0.06463623, 0.026916504, -0.064208984, 0.010269165, -0.005554199, 0.022888184, 0.04849243, 0.055603027, 0.022277832, 0.028152466, -0.014160156, -0.009277344, -0.013931274, -0.002811432, 0.0074768066, 0.04864502, 0.011054993, -0.01550293, 0.027496338, -0.067871094, 0.009346008, 0.0013942719, 0.021957397, -0.002445221, 0.006023407, -0.00017595291, -0.009742737, 0.027908325, 0.018356323, 0.03213501, -0.01272583, 0.010116577, 0.02861023, 0.021652222, 0.004562378, -0.034301758, 0.005466461, -0.007801056, -0.05758667, -0.023803711, -0.07092285, -0.04348755, -0.02520752, -0.013427734, -0.028564453, -0.011749268, -0.011459351, 0.034820557, 0.045043945, -0.011772156, -0.0087509155, 0.0501709, -0.002231598, 0.036254883, 0.0034618378, 0.00079870224, -0.02885437, 0.028579712, -0.05722046, -0.018081665, -0.034606934, -0.00089359283, 0.03060913, 0.033081055, 0.021697998, 0.019897461, -0.015151978, 0.0028839111, -0.02684021, 0.015296936, -0.005340576, -0.031143188, 0.011444092, -0.013069153, 0.04067993, 0.020401001, 0.036499023, 0.009811401, 0.015899658, 0.018127441, -0.009941101, 0.007221222, -0.0016736984, -0.021392822, 0.013504028, -0.012367249, -0.02420044, 0.007575989, 0.008354187, -0.011489868, -0.02357483, 0.040985107, 0.0048446655, -0.0023498535, 0.021865845, -0.0034866333, 0.0037899017, 0.0051956177, 0.018829346, -0.028182983, 0.035217285, 0.0357666, -0.036743164, 0.030929565, 0.003211975, 0.051605225, 0.002532959, 0.033599854, -0.04937744, 0.007209778, -0.018203735, -0.011192322, 0.019805908, 0.0713501, -0.024658203, 0.008094788, -0.01789856, 0.008293152, 0.024765015, 0.027908325, 0.011779785, 0.05999756, 0.052581787, 0.009513855, 0.06304932, -0.017196655, -0.02760315, 0.03363037, 0.012863159, -0.029220581, 0.026367188, -0.012458801, -0.008911133, 0.014076233, -0.0006842613, 0.048065186, 0.028213501, 0.08062744, -0.0066108704, 0.020812988, -0.0079956055, -0.028167725, -0.023742676, -0.018218994, 0.06222534, -0.030700684, 0.023086548, -0.007659912, 0.024215698, -0.03591919, -0.06021118, -0.029251099, 0.042175293, -0.029769897, -0.048675537, -0.02017212, 0.042266846, -0.0061912537, -0.03894043, -0.035461426, 0.016555786, -0.0057640076, -0.020507812, 0.0006990433, 0.009407043, 0.003692627, 0.0039482117, -0.0023059845, 0.02861023, -0.020050049, -0.016983032, 0.0077934265, 0.03967285, -0.029953003, -0.050811768, 0.122680664, -0.022979736, -0.007648468, -0.030471802, 0.034851074, 0.02319336, -0.061767578, -0.02722168, -0.015563965, -0.021591187, -0.0178833, 0.0068511963, 0.04953003, 0.015403748, -0.007575989, 0.02319336, 0.023452759, 0.013595581, -0.0078048706, -0.033447266, -0.009384155, 0.020645142, 0.032562256, -0.021560669, -0.03817749, 0.01625061, 0.009819031, -0.014923096, -0.0006995201, -0.014587402, -0.0211792, 0.04031372, 0.023529053, -0.0061683655, 0.013214111, -0.0067825317, 0.0053863525, 0.06903076, 0.008758545, -0.038970947, -0.007820129, 0.0030956268, -0.02748108, -0.020095825, -0.0051727295, -0.033203125, -0.05999756, -0.01209259, -0.055267334, -0.015823364, -0.05206299, 0.05392456, 0.027252197, -0.039855957, -0.037353516, -0.0030384064, -0.026123047, -0.02973938, -0.03994751, 0.032104492, 0.036132812, -0.018600464, -0.006412506, 0.04724121, -0.034606934, 0.021835327, -0.028808594, 0.020370483, -0.031555176, -0.02079773, -0.031082153, 0.11730957, -0.111328125, -0.057434082, -0.05645752, 0.019592285, -0.0637207, -0.0037441254, 0.021743774, -0.0041885376, -0.01499176, -0.0060157776, -0.015731812, 0.010597229, 0.013938904, 0.0024757385, -0.0335083, 0.018493652, -0.025558472, 0.0074806213, 0.005962372 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2107.12433v1
The Graph Neural Networking Challenge: A Worldwide Competition for Education in AI/ML for Networks
José Suárez-Varela, Miquel Ferriol-Galmés, Albert López, Paul Almasan, Guillermo Bernárdez, David Pujol-Perich, Krzysztof Rusek, Loïck Bonniot, Christoph Neumann, François Schnitzler, François Taïani, Martin Happ, Christian Maier, Jia Lei Du, Matthias Herlich, Peter Dorfinger, Nick Vincent Hainke, Stefan Venz, Johannes Wegener, Henrike Wissing, Bo Wu, Shihan Xiao, Pere Barlet-Ros, Albert Cabellos-Aparicio
cs.NI, cs.AI, cs.GL, cs.LG
During the last decade, Machine Learning (ML) has increasingly become a hot topic in the field of Computer Networks and is expected to be gradually adopted for a plethora of control, monitoring and management tasks in real-world deployments. This poses the need to count on new generations of students, researchers and practitioners with a solid background in ML applied to networks. During 2020, the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) has organized the "ITU AI/ML in 5G challenge'', an open global competition that has introduced to a broad audience some of the current main challenges in ML for networks. This large-scale initiative has gathered 23 different challenges proposed by network operators, equipment manufacturers and academia, and has attracted a total of 1300+ participants from 60+ countries. This paper narrates our experience organizing one of the proposed challenges: the "Graph Neural Networking Challenge 2020''. We describe the problem presented to participants, the tools and resources provided, some organization aspects and participation statistics, an outline of the top-3 awarded solutions, and a summary with some lessons learned during all this journey. As a result, this challenge leaves a curated set of educational resources openly available to anyone interested in the topic.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2107.12433v1
"2021-07-26T18:52:00"
"2021-07-26T18:52:00"
{ "title": [ -0.034118652, -0.016830444, -0.038024902, -0.01576233, 0.006587982, -0.0061187744, -0.0024604797, -0.0126953125, -0.009033203, 0.00970459, -0.010978699, 0.017227173, -0.01210022, -0.03552246, 0.00031375885, 0.0066566467, 0.0017280579, 0.020309448, -0.029907227, -0.0340271, -0.011886597, -0.03894043, 0.043640137, 0.052001953, 0.042114258, -0.03829956, -0.062438965, 0.015975952, -0.038757324, -0.032196045, -0.002817154, 0.031173706, 0.04067993, 0.031585693, -0.018875122, 0.02407837, -0.054534912, 0.030380249, 0.0034217834, 0.0076141357, 0.015304565, -0.005718231, -0.017440796, -0.024307251, -0.031433105, 0.012870789, -0.0657959, -0.013381958, -0.019195557, 0.055847168, 0.028518677, 0.027526855, -0.01235199, 0.06060791, 0.019195557, -0.029541016, -0.027923584, -0.02470398, 0.027694702, 0.06536865, 0.02468872, -0.02859497, 0.010566711, -0.027816772, -0.040740967, -0.015777588, -0.021087646, 0.018295288, 0.08355713, -0.005493164, -0.0440979, 0.03656006, -0.009246826, 0.036895752, -0.049194336, -0.034240723, 0.068481445, 0.02204895, 0.027877808, -0.007713318, -0.012794495, -0.0115356445, -0.039794922, -0.014877319, 0.009017944, -0.016647339, -0.011955261, -0.008155823, -0.030914307, -0.0513916, -0.0077552795, -0.015457153, -0.023330688, 0.014816284, -0.024337769, -0.011177063, -0.007972717, 0.006385803, 0.015365601, -0.02053833, -0.0032157898, 0.007896423, -0.050567627, -0.00049209595, 0.027191162, 0.031555176, -0.032318115, -0.010658264, 0.009979248, 0.038726807, -0.017730713, 0.011543274, 0.008430481, 0.0025157928, -0.014328003, -0.007980347, -0.016937256, 0.0068473816, 0.019760132, 0.010353088, -0.010604858, -0.035888672, 0.0027065277, 0.010887146, 0.044433594, 0.02180481, -0.042907715, 0.020385742, -0.0003299713, 0.014343262, 0.017593384, 0.040374756, -0.11138916, -0.068359375, -0.05645752, 0.048736572, -0.0020103455, 0.022521973, -0.0023517609, 0.021408081, 0.020874023, -0.042388916, -0.024520874, 0.029251099, -0.0010900497, 0.02218628, 0.06173706, -0.0129776, -0.056243896, -0.059417725, -0.0074501038, 0.017715454, 0.024719238, -0.004501343, -0.03152466, -0.0028572083, -0.12213135, -0.016204834, 0.026763916, 0.021865845, 0.028701782, 0.024047852, 0.016052246, 0.025558472, 0.07287598, -0.036071777, -0.03161621, 0.021972656, -0.010429382, 0.013076782, -0.0137786865, 0.018753052, 0.0007586479, -0.02217102, -0.010658264, -0.0015907288, 0.024795532, -0.016036987, 0.02142334, 0.023742676, 0.0073013306, -0.022628784, -0.009887695, 0.045318604, -0.045410156, -0.038360596, -0.0031547546, -0.051818848, 0.067993164, -0.007850647, -0.031158447, 0.026473999, -0.029586792, -0.037200928, -0.05810547, -0.029876709, 0.03744507, 0.036102295, -0.012954712, 0.035339355, -0.06036377, 0.01789856, -0.05014038, 0.02658081, -0.0030918121, -0.024047852, 0.0013999939, 0.031280518, -0.018325806, 0.054016113, 0.04949951, 0.018356323, -0.021911621, -0.023010254, -0.0022029877, -0.052368164, 0.020309448, -0.018081665, -0.011856079, -0.026794434, -0.027938843, 0.0022468567, 0.004299164, 0.058532715, 0.0082473755, -0.0072288513, -0.0046691895, -0.02722168, 0.022598267, 0.016036987, 0.06274414, -0.025421143, 0.0070648193, 0.0259552, 0.015686035, -0.015235901, 0.023132324, -0.011978149, 0.02418518, 0.00005197525, 0.00447464, -0.034942627, -0.00089788437, 0.03314209, 0.038146973, -0.006137848, 0.008834839, 0.008132935, 0.008049011, 0.006340027, 0.06958008, 0.042419434, 0.051849365, 0.023239136, 0.02178955, 0.05029297, 0.018234253, 0.037902832, -0.037322998, 0.017547607, 0.0043029785, 0.041046143, 0.00091457367, 0.025756836, -0.06286621, 0.0029296875, -0.04849243, -0.008613586, 0.0051994324, 0.017745972, 0.038879395, -0.038085938, 0.014144897, -0.008033752, -0.018417358, -0.0042762756, -0.0124053955, 0.012763977, 0.015571594, -0.051818848, -0.01612854, -0.0016746521, 0.046691895, 0.005138397, 0.042053223, -0.0051193237, 0.021072388, -0.037078857, -0.017303467, -0.035217285, 0.042785645, 0.023742676, 0.01008606, -0.018630981, 0.0038051605, -0.009963989, 0.06719971, 0.08074951, -0.02645874, 0.030776978, -0.07489014, 0.016296387, 0.012130737, -0.025466919, 0.005153656, 0.026290894, 0.028305054, 0.010902405, -0.036834717, 0.0025119781, -0.04537964, 0.012779236, 0.013900757, -0.054260254, -0.03338623, -0.05328369, -0.019165039, -0.057037354, -0.06567383, -0.00907135, 0.07720947, -0.0061531067, -0.024917603, 0.0022563934, 0.0005517006, -0.011726379, -0.023101807, -0.03353882, -0.01876831, 0.01473999, 0.015617371, 0.0017385483, -0.06945801, 0.01247406, -0.002254486, 0.030319214, -0.024642944, -0.0026226044, -0.020858765, 0.0107040405, 0.010147095, 0.003944397, 0.029891968, -0.05227661, 0.011642456, -0.05126953, 0.010292053, 0.014480591, -0.038391113, 0.0032844543, 0.020889282, -0.018539429, -0.026000977, 0.02104187, 0.06628418, -0.013320923, -0.02722168, 0.034240723, 0.026885986, -0.020645142, 0.009735107, 0.020080566, -0.0043907166, -0.028717041, -0.016571045, -0.036987305, -0.009132385, -0.009292603, -0.001698494, 0.043304443, -0.023361206, -0.027740479, -0.024337769, -0.0070533752, 0.005519867, 0.009963989, -0.009216309, -0.031555176, -0.039733887, -0.02909851, -0.0041770935, 0.011184692, -0.025115967, -0.008758545, 0.089904785, -0.0118255615, -0.041870117, 0.0063095093, 0.032836914, 0.021514893, -0.016723633, -0.043182373, -0.0023822784, 0.00969696, 0.0010118484, 0.016983032, -0.020965576, -0.018798828, -0.09094238, -0.00522995, 0.066223145, 0.0074043274, -0.025741577, 0.029205322, -0.06695557, 0.015731812, 0.009246826, -0.005821228, 0.036224365, 0.07720947, -0.009788513, 0.009941101, 0.0004825592, -0.0015802383, 0.009399414, -0.022415161, -0.054260254, 0.031219482, -0.03189087, -0.052124023, -0.0051651, 0.007381439, -0.04498291, -0.020095825, -0.0028495789, 0.031982422, 0.030914307, 0.017196655, 0.011451721, 0.0043563843, 0.014282227, -0.02355957, -0.0079422, -0.01473999, -0.031051636, -0.016357422, -0.002149582, 0.030014038, 0.048065186, -0.016784668, -0.036712646, -0.015777588, 0.02520752, 0.05227661, 0.027740479, -0.033447266, -0.0154953, -0.027175903, -0.02281189, 0.0158844, -0.018661499, 0.0019950867, -0.036590576, 0.004512787, -0.025024414, 0.019851685, 0.012832642, 0.004081726, -0.040527344, -0.02230835, 0.013465881, -0.019989014, -0.07171631, -0.011695862, 0.028869629, 0.016433716, 0.0067367554, -0.00932312, -0.04006958, 0.03274536, -0.03152466, -0.004886627, 0.0050621033, -0.012199402, 0.008087158, 0.013046265, -0.03967285, 0.0003774166, -0.030090332, 0.020767212, 0.003232956, -0.0014505386, -0.014030457, -0.056243896, 0.006385803, -0.0003771782, -0.09649658, -0.025909424, 0.019638062, -0.024093628, -0.011436462, -0.06530762, 0.03338623, -0.01928711, -0.028045654, 0.005683899, -0.028869629, 0.0211792, 0.004951477, -0.057617188, 0.010398865, 0.0597229, -0.0004351139, 0.0051651, 0.036254883, 0.0063438416, -0.0061454773, -0.016677856, 0.006641388, -0.013450623, 0.04776001, -0.012054443, -0.010223389, 0.046051025, -0.034484863, 0.019058228, 0.007369995, 0.0063171387, -0.023040771, 0.0053863525, 0.019744873, 0.029388428, -0.045074463, 0.047821045, 0.011528015, -0.0119018555, -0.07696533, 0.010009766, 0.008255005, 0.0004339218, 0.04031372, 0.0013504028, 0.03552246, 0.021560669, -0.027191162, 0.033935547, -0.018249512, -0.01828003, 0.022094727, 0.0022640228, -0.023239136, -0.008003235, 0.02029419, 0.018875122, -0.009185791, 0.030532837, -0.013633728, 0.037139893, -0.032470703, -0.030426025, 0.015792847, 0.023452759, -0.024154663, -0.008995056, -0.066711426, -0.005004883, -0.02229309, 0.0054740906, -0.013702393, 0.029571533, 0.04458618, -0.021591187, -0.038024902, 0.00919342, 0.02406311, -0.015670776, 0.008216858, -0.052581787, 0.0011911392, -0.01701355, -0.062805176, -0.04385376, -0.01209259, -0.012573242, 0.025939941, 0.0049552917, -0.0026016235, 0.021469116, 0.014656067, 0.04663086, 0.031402588, -0.017089844, -0.044067383, 0.035949707, 0.00440979, -0.044830322, 0.013435364, 0.0015058517, 0.0002720356, -0.054626465, -0.015617371, -0.019546509, -0.0033798218, -0.033416748, -0.0005097389, 0.0071372986, 0.009590149, -0.022521973, 0.029418945, 0.006839752, 0.0070152283, 0.031951904, 0.016998291, -0.02822876, -0.03781128, 0.02758789, 0.04598999, -0.00983429, 0.024169922, 0.071899414, 0.0045547485, 0.0038337708, -0.0051956177, 0.011634827, 0.03149414, -0.02444458, -0.0064735413, 0.020492554, -0.062347412, -0.027801514, -0.0048675537, -0.005344391, 0.054870605, -0.05886841, 0.059051514, -0.004989624, -0.011711121, 0.022857666, -0.0069770813, 0.008628845, -0.01222229, 0.010856628, -0.06933594, -0.07897949, -0.033843994, 0.08258057, -0.030136108, -0.009796143, -0.002796173, 0.010025024, 0.013389587, 0.043945312, 0.040222168, -0.009407043, -0.0026550293, -0.0206604, -0.00497818, -0.020462036, -0.031433105, 0.011360168, 0.0041542053, 0.00762558, -0.04107666, -0.016998291, -0.04824829, -0.032928467, -0.00869751, -0.005962372, 0.019577026, -0.05847168, 0.024215698, 0.101135254, -0.0020256042, 0.045532227, -0.0076789856, 0.008171082, 0.008377075, 0.026275635, 0.0017843246, 0.023376465, 0.033416748, -0.067993164, 0.027511597, 0.008926392, 0.033599854, -0.0018224716, 0.016342163, 0.014297485, 0.001627922, -0.058532715, 0.02658081, 0.0075149536, -0.0025959015, 0.015899658, -0.051452637, 0.017440796, -0.007106781, -0.0065307617, -0.0032424927, -0.044952393, -0.031082153, 0.021316528, -0.036865234, -0.008232117, 0.024749756, -0.019592285, -0.032562256, -0.059814453, 0.026229858, 0.00035476685, 0.0050086975, -0.020553589, 0.017913818, -0.041503906, 0.018203735, 0.031097412, -0.049468994, 0.023361206, -0.010658264, 0.011756897, 0.05041504, 0.017456055, -0.039611816, -0.007095337, -0.002254486, -0.06060791, -0.0703125, -0.011810303, -0.00774765, -0.012008667, 0.0044517517, -0.028945923, -0.002336502, 0.0046577454, 0.029632568, -0.0025138855, -0.022216797, 0.02293396, 0.018676758, 0.025665283, 0.000053822994, 0.017181396, 0.0017566681, 0.0045166016, 0.014602661, -0.021865845, 0.0109939575, -0.003583908, -0.0035591125, -0.0033416748, -0.053863525, 0.011054993, 0.021881104, 0.011756897, 0.013015747, 0.047912598, 0.05178833, 0.02255249, 0.01133728, 0.035247803, 0.07183838, -0.057281494, 0.0033893585, -0.020568848, 0.011329651, -0.045562744, 0.05960083, -0.018447876, 0.004371643, -0.058624268, -0.08721924, -0.036193848, 0.010856628, 0.052124023, 0.046661377, 0.055999756, -0.071777344, 0.015617371, -0.048675537, -0.0015153885, -0.040802002, 0.025268555, -0.020111084, -0.013267517, 0.017440796, 0.0029201508, 0.0057678223, -0.0236969, 0.029693604, -0.015533447, -0.02557373, 0.0028133392, -0.014549255, 0.034057617, -0.034851074, -0.0362854, 0.042297363, 0.012962341, -0.02015686, 0.049713135, -0.033813477, 0.05960083, 0.008857727, 0.064697266, 0.048583984, -0.005088806, 0.010345459, -0.0042037964, -0.0020160675, -0.04623413, 0.030960083, -0.04864502, -0.0016231537, -0.08154297, -0.021560669, -0.079956055, 0.012535095, 0.0020656586, 0.025482178, 0.037750244, 0.01524353, 0.033721924, 0.010063171, 0.053649902, 0.0068130493, 0.06793213, -0.0064926147, 0.009025574, -0.005908966, 0.0053482056, 0.021591187, 0.030136108, 0.004638672, 0.025970459, -0.00094890594, -0.024993896, 0.00667572, 0.025115967, 0.010696411, -0.015899658, -0.0023994446, -0.034057617, 0.037506104, -0.021621704, 0.017364502, 0.06903076, 0.06072998, 0.0025463104, -0.029800415, 0.014602661, 0.0045051575, -0.03475952, 0.013336182, 0.056365967, -0.06951904, 0.0103302, -0.027450562, -0.03186035, 0.0018892288, 0.028015137, 0.043823242, -0.07409668, -0.024612427, 0.015991211, 0.036590576, -0.03363037, 0.0020885468, -0.03918457, 0.014915466, 0.037200928, 0.02458191, -0.016860962, -0.018005371, 0.022598267, 0.052642822, -0.028030396, 0.0050849915, 0.0043792725, 0.019958496, -0.008644104, 0.021606445, -0.057495117, 0.03451538, 0.013069153, -0.04260254, 0.019561768, 0.017608643, -0.054504395, 0.0018939972, 0.026611328, 0.06518555, 0.048431396, 0.07635498, 0.01109314, -0.021484375, 0.008842468, -0.042999268, 0.01927185, 0.023208618, -0.03869629, 0.027374268, -0.024856567, -0.029571533, 0.03842163, -0.038269043, 0.06188965, -0.016937256, 0.018188477, -0.022964478, 0.031799316, 0.017822266, -0.08282471, 0.0067710876, -0.014144897, -0.030654907, -0.0055770874, -0.011207581, -0.022827148, 0.009490967, -0.0070266724, -0.004096985, 0.031341553, 0.0033874512, -0.01864624, -0.025283813, -0.04598999, 0.018005371, -0.029006958, 0.05279541, -0.023590088, -0.0034122467, -0.012016296, -0.0047683716, -0.011703491, -0.016326904, -0.034057617, 0.015670776, -0.032073975, -0.03564453, 0.010437012, 0.021011353, -0.022537231, -0.04650879, -0.055480957, 0.006023407, -0.031204224, 0.0262146, 0.037139893, -0.040496826, -0.035064697, 0.012580872, -0.043792725, 0.043640137, 0.003200531, -0.008010864, -0.011199951, 0.034362793, -0.041809082, -0.011985779, -0.0070343018, 0.04147339, -0.00831604, -0.02255249, -0.012992859, 0.03805542, 0.053741455, -0.0619812, -0.045776367, 0.004863739, 0.032684326, -0.004924774, 0.035247803, 0.011436462, -0.021972656, 0.013580322, 0.026870728, 0.010482788, -0.021331787, -0.047821045, -0.032806396, 0.045562744, 0.05203247, -0.014785767, -0.0023899078, 0.049987793, -0.00774765, 0.0051612854, 0.02468872, -0.0011463165, 0.018508911, -0.004333496, 0.021057129, -0.022125244, -0.013290405, -0.016845703, 0.018051147, -0.011039734, 0.033966064, -0.02468872, 0.012466431, 0.001288414, 0.043151855, 0.004131317, -0.061920166, 0.04925537, 0.035736084, 0.019577026, 0.05166626, -0.043151855, -0.048553467, 0.006351471, -0.01473999, -0.018875122, -0.01776123, 0.04095459, -0.042388916, -0.007598877, -0.02166748, -0.02859497, -0.023651123, -0.03878784, 0.056396484, -0.048583984, -0.0072250366, -0.039093018, -0.019577026, -0.0023880005, 0.012687683, 0.008041382, -0.020706177, -0.039733887, -0.015586853, 0.039154053, -0.006454468 ], "summary": [ -0.012413025, -0.039489746, -0.016586304, 0.022994995, -0.050750732, -0.019592285, 0.007408142, -0.013641357, -0.022872925, -0.012069702, -0.011581421, 0.048828125, -0.0056152344, -0.048339844, 0.080566406, -0.015335083, -0.0009813309, 0.0007443428, -0.03237915, -0.04043579, 0.0019931793, -0.035736084, -0.02330017, 0.061279297, 0.036071777, -0.036834717, -0.060913086, 0.02180481, -0.026473999, 0.001209259, 0.0018205643, 0.033813477, 0.041290283, -0.012069702, 0.0026245117, 0.0022468567, -0.0052833557, -0.011314392, 0.0050201416, -0.0006532669, 0.035003662, 0.011352539, 0.1116333, -0.027435303, 0.033355713, 0.009811401, 0.011909485, -0.05480957, 0.013191223, 0.012397766, 0.012573242, 0.046020508, -0.0074005127, 0.013916016, -0.013595581, 0.009490967, -0.028945923, -0.023101807, 0.012420654, 0.015007019, 0.022109985, -0.013671875, 0.014404297, 0.004501343, 0.012199402, -0.0016374588, 0.06124878, 0.015205383, 0.06097412, 0.0256958, -0.02331543, 0.03390503, 0.035339355, 0.0017442703, -0.012184143, -0.038513184, 0.052093506, 0.00018835068, -0.0027694702, -0.0038433075, 0.005821228, 0.038269043, -0.027816772, -0.016799927, -0.0135269165, 0.00086164474, -0.010681152, -0.029830933, -0.027542114, -0.0028076172, -0.030288696, 0.028808594, -0.06137085, 0.023208618, 0.02078247, -0.00491333, -0.021316528, -0.024261475, 0.024230957, -0.012062073, 0.0009775162, -0.021194458, -0.049346924, -0.002248764, -0.01512146, 0.06689453, -0.00055742264, -0.04208374, -0.01890564, 0.0042419434, -0.010482788, -0.05557251, 0.019729614, -0.0054855347, -0.03466797, -0.0048103333, -0.008399963, 0.0103302, 0.005153656, 0.028198242, -0.06097412, -0.020904541, -0.03668213, 0.032714844, 0.06274414, 0.02835083, 0.030227661, 0.048675537, -0.003030777, 0.015808105, 0.009140015, 0.022750854, -0.051361084, -0.019546509, -0.06616211, 0.007701874, 0.017242432, 0.002855301, 0.026565552, 0.0011577606, 0.057861328, -0.029708862, -0.044891357, 0.079711914, -0.011146545, 0.025924683, 0.02192688, -0.010505676, -0.022827148, -0.010726929, 0.007965088, 0.0032138824, 0.014984131, -0.003458023, 0.0067977905, 0.001074791, -0.016952515, 0.007671356, -0.0095825195, 0.013442993, 0.0211792, 0.019638062, 0.06567383, 0.08648682, 0.083862305, -0.028274536, -0.04220581, 0.0018558502, -0.0055007935, -0.038970947, -0.020141602, 0.034820557, 0.036499023, -0.016082764, -0.0002206564, -0.019927979, 0.0006260872, 0.026260376, -0.023330688, 0.015182495, 0.016815186, -0.051849365, -0.028503418, 0.030960083, -0.009437561, -0.035217285, -0.016296387, 0.004020691, 0.055664062, 0.0058135986, -0.0143966675, -0.019439697, 0.002216339, -0.037597656, -0.009628296, -0.0011644363, 0.016082764, 0.020690918, -0.0012893677, 0.0017528534, -0.024993896, -0.0032653809, -0.0072250366, -0.0034675598, -0.015449524, -0.01272583, 0.006149292, 0.006790161, -0.023239136, -0.0052986145, 0.022094727, -0.03604126, -0.020050049, 0.00459671, -0.0007581711, -0.010139465, 0.015960693, -0.013053894, 0.0021858215, -0.030975342, -0.017654419, 0.0063438416, -0.024932861, 0.038330078, -0.02848816, -0.000054836273, -0.030319214, 0.01159668, 0.030654907, -0.0005559921, 0.07684326, 0.002609253, -0.03036499, 0.012374878, 0.023590088, 0.016983032, 0.056427002, -0.08013916, 0.031463623, 0.007385254, 0.027511597, 0.027877808, 0.005382538, 0.031677246, -0.014953613, -0.04812622, 0.028945923, 0.0034046173, -0.00046229362, 0.00058174133, 0.027664185, -0.0053710938, 0.03164673, 0.017456055, 0.023925781, 0.01537323, 0.032348633, 0.06549072, -0.015274048, 0.0024223328, 0.002035141, 0.040039062, 0.0050201416, 0.0059280396, -0.01638794, -0.0024299622, -0.017410278, -0.015556335, 0.00630188, -0.004272461, 0.015930176, -0.055358887, 0.008857727, 0.020568848, -0.017150879, 0.031951904, 0.008506775, -0.01927185, -0.0093307495, -0.0013561249, -0.0049858093, -0.022628784, -0.045135498, -0.010597229, 0.05596924, 0.0003142357, -0.0020580292, 0.0015516281, 0.00037431717, 0.01638794, 0.045196533, 0.041137695, 0.0050582886, -0.015899658, 0.0034618378, -0.00283432, -0.007865906, 0.033966064, 0.005306244, -0.015853882, -0.039123535, 0.022613525, -0.020828247, 0.0005788803, 0.0061035156, 0.056884766, 0.022033691, 0.0011854172, 0.00667572, 0.014823914, -0.034240723, -0.011123657, 0.00058698654, -0.0031852722, -0.045654297, -0.033843994, -0.02053833, -0.015029907, -0.017791748, 0.046936035, 0.10345459, 0.020645142, 0.006828308, 0.040527344, -0.0061569214, -0.05206299, 0.0647583, -0.03753662, -0.033203125, -0.025054932, -0.041168213, -0.04437256, -0.044708252, 0.07110596, 0.014465332, 0.016937256, 0.0018968582, -0.0030326843, 0.00617218, -0.023406982, 0.02432251, 0.044189453, -0.0045433044, 0.001461029, -0.02217102, -0.027816772, 0.009216309, -0.016418457, -0.02746582, -0.0054130554, 0.019165039, -0.011634827, 0.004425049, 0.009529114, 0.030441284, -0.012008667, -0.027282715, 0.0020141602, -0.004928589, -0.036254883, 0.025772095, 0.04437256, 0.035888672, -0.01626587, -0.061157227, -0.04144287, 0.03640747, -0.0005645752, -0.030136108, -0.0001924038, -0.026107788, -0.030410767, 0.003917694, -0.008087158, -0.007587433, 0.037322998, 0.051940918, -0.0031833649, -0.0036697388, 0.031051636, 0.012329102, 0.021240234, -0.009674072, -0.025848389, 0.06915283, -0.032440186, -0.022399902, 0.009101868, 0.053588867, 0.022979736, 0.018157959, -0.05770874, 0.017456055, -0.009414673, -0.03842163, -0.019439697, -0.01348114, 0.0096588135, -0.020217896, -0.0032405853, 0.028396606, 0.034332275, 0.0023403168, 0.004798889, -0.014709473, -0.004085541, 0.035949707, -0.0107803345, 0.026046753, 0.07940674, 0.0070533752, 0.0006928444, 0.009742737, 0.002407074, 0.009635925, 0.014549255, 0.004245758, 0.023223877, -0.077819824, -0.028167725, 0.0143585205, 0.09777832, 0.01322937, -0.00048279762, 0.013763428, 0.011940002, 0.016296387, -0.008842468, 0.0074424744, 0.042663574, -0.00072288513, -0.0134887695, -0.016494751, 0.00026106834, -0.044799805, 0.0039100647, 0.021011353, -0.039245605, 0.05923462, -0.060058594, -0.025680542, -0.0012025833, 0.030044556, 0.029312134, 0.03778076, -0.0418396, -0.0066833496, -0.036590576, -0.0043144226, 0.034423828, -0.013153076, 0.002462387, 0.0067481995, 0.029403687, -0.018981934, 0.014076233, -0.026824951, 0.007129669, 0.05557251, -0.027145386, 0.0058021545, 0.009124756, -0.03967285, -0.005126953, 0.02305603, 0.043426514, -0.049072266, 0.025772095, -0.044708252, 0.008552551, 0.043823242, -0.055389404, -0.033569336, -0.04348755, 0.007297516, -0.036224365, 0.015525818, -0.025985718, 0.060760498, -0.013885498, -0.066467285, 0.040283203, -0.07519531, -0.05557251, -0.010276794, 0.0071754456, -0.036010742, -0.04473877, 0.008346558, 0.014183044, 0.024047852, -0.053222656, 0.025558472, 0.007537842, -0.015037537, 0.012413025, -0.033966064, 0.12109375, 0.0501709, -0.044006348, 0.08123779, -0.0289917, 0.03982544, -0.02003479, 0.023620605, 0.054840088, 0.022750854, 0.024719238, -0.016082764, -0.030181885, 0.045013428, -0.043029785, -0.018936157, 0.00756073, -0.02633667, 0.02796936, -0.03930664, 0.0022850037, -0.025741577, 0.0038318634, 0.06488037, 0.06298828, -0.024032593, 0.00818634, 0.03439331, -0.019546509, -0.038879395, -0.01399231, 0.01977539, -0.03475952, 0.028884888, 0.030899048, 0.023391724, 0.044006348, -0.04550171, -0.023742676, -0.01638794, -0.018951416, -0.006477356, 0.02015686, -0.027740479, -0.005443573, 0.02835083, 0.03060913, -0.035095215, 0.019088745, -0.018417358, 0.03567505, -0.049591064, -0.005340576, 0.03137207, 0.024108887, -0.012458801, -0.021347046, 0.016403198, 0.0072517395, -0.0236969, -0.0020542145, -0.016830444, 0.030654907, 0.0077590942, -0.02772522, -0.0048980713, 0.018295288, 0.021392822, 0.022155762, -0.048858643, -0.09197998, 0.0036087036, -0.03552246, -0.046173096, -0.040802002, -0.020385742, -0.046875, 0.0037517548, -0.007007599, -0.022567749, 0.023468018, -0.0031833649, 0.020812988, -0.006965637, -0.017532349, -0.025100708, 0.032989502, 0.018966675, -0.015655518, -0.012031555, -0.0022144318, 0.0033931732, -0.0088272095, 0.0009994507, -0.017837524, -0.00073194504, -0.05480957, -0.0021209717, 0.024108887, -0.026794434, -0.0017528534, -0.004512787, -0.0032405853, 0.03579712, 0.02796936, 0.010681152, -0.010345459, -0.033111572, 0.028045654, 0.06121826, -0.0065231323, -0.0058898926, 0.0010204315, 0.025100708, 0.003446579, -0.0044059753, 0.00869751, -0.01197052, -0.0023021698, 0.013694763, 0.0063476562, -0.025497437, -0.028320312, 0.0000795722, -0.0022068024, 0.0043258667, 0.021728516, 0.02507019, 0.040161133, -0.028381348, 0.009277344, -0.011054993, 0.039276123, -0.000102341175, 0.010101318, -0.061340332, -0.04486084, -0.039916992, 0.055023193, -0.025024414, -0.04977417, -0.012634277, -0.023635864, -0.002506256, 0.018630981, 0.012588501, 0.014663696, 0.010322571, 0.0027618408, -0.0016002655, -0.015167236, -0.026275635, -0.009963989, 0.0037269592, -0.0031871796, -0.021148682, -0.022476196, 0.028366089, -0.035339355, -0.0039405823, 0.006160736, -0.00091791153, -0.03567505, -0.021133423, 0.033996582, -0.0076446533, -0.0052490234, -0.006542206, 0.009513855, -0.020233154, 0.026153564, -0.03527832, 0.024810791, -0.004753113, -0.04714966, 0.009429932, 0.008094788, 0.042419434, -0.020980835, 0.021438599, 0.010406494, -0.009605408, -0.037902832, 0.020233154, 0.015029907, -0.04333496, -0.026885986, -0.0037059784, 0.04019165, -0.068237305, 0.0021247864, -0.017425537, -0.006313324, 0.011001587, 0.0519104, -0.0007619858, 0.048095703, 0.005619049, -0.005470276, -0.05987549, -0.030654907, 0.01146698, 0.034301758, -0.026107788, -0.031982422, 0.041290283, -0.03262329, -0.015716553, -0.007904053, 0.017593384, 0.00088119507, 0.023986816, 0.01083374, -0.02053833, -0.0013933182, -0.025558472, -0.0061149597, -0.030929565, -0.05166626, -0.07873535, -0.049957275, -0.03414917, 0.07385254, -0.0155181885, 0.033111572, 0.036712646, -0.056854248, 0.01876831, 0.011932373, -0.020263672, 0.01209259, 0.0013208389, 0.004550934, 0.006126404, -0.01876831, -0.009933472, 0.0068130493, 0.0075683594, 0.040985107, -0.01737976, 0.025680542, -0.035949707, -0.008491516, 0.0234375, -0.024093628, 0.020263672, -0.008262634, 0.06347656, 0.014297485, 0.030975342, 0.06878662, 0.0029468536, 0.040985107, 0.056243896, -0.040161133, 0.015174866, -0.04815674, 0.03253174, -0.06365967, -0.014335632, -0.048461914, -0.011497498, -0.0012588501, -0.06274414, -0.0015506744, -0.01234436, 0.030593872, 0.03479004, 0.025604248, -0.033996582, 0.026382446, 0.01171875, -0.042236328, -0.018341064, -0.005596161, 0.000100791454, 0.009269714, 0.061767578, -0.024856567, 0.0075149536, 0.012145996, 0.0066833496, -0.03652954, -0.03375244, 0.0045280457, -0.004386902, 0.037994385, 0.021209717, -0.016342163, -0.008117676, -0.014083862, 0.043792725, 0.005317688, -0.008216858, 0.008407593, 0.020065308, -0.038635254, -0.014595032, -0.07373047, -0.039978027, 0.011650085, 0.0010786057, -0.032104492, 0.08673096, 0.0008587837, -0.03857422, -0.07305908, -0.070251465, -0.039611816, 0.03781128, -0.022369385, -0.009002686, 0.0713501, 0.0012397766, 0.034240723, 0.050872803, -0.028427124, 0.019424438, 0.012062073, -0.056671143, -0.015052795, -0.045532227, 0.012634277, 0.02835083, 0.031433105, -0.0071907043, 0.03756714, 0.05090332, -0.05114746, 0.022323608, 0.020507812, -0.00050354004, -0.02330017, 0.01940918, -0.019424438, -0.0008773804, -0.00084781647, 0.01184845, 0.03265381, 0.009490967, 0.040039062, -0.01914978, 0.019958496, 0.048553467, -0.03881836, 0.061340332, 0.037200928, -0.026916504, -0.0137786865, 0.0007343292, -0.02494812, 0.053253174, -0.012771606, 0.052246094, -0.08618164, -0.027618408, 0.0115356445, 0.01638794, -0.043884277, 0.0015001297, -0.0057296753, 0.027923584, 0.03945923, -0.030639648, 0.02418518, -0.019302368, -0.03289795, 0.03048706, -0.024658203, 0.03375244, 0.008110046, 0.020645142, 0.0007162094, 0.011558533, -0.06933594, 0.0032424927, 0.011413574, -0.023971558, 0.01574707, 0.010543823, -0.008514404, 0.012565613, 0.010818481, 0.06591797, 0.039520264, 0.024856567, -0.06854248, 0.0055656433, 0.07885742, -0.013214111, 0.012031555, 0.008903503, 0.012741089, 0.016494751, -0.029510498, 0.019729614, 0.008918762, 0.04598999, 0.036346436, 0.016296387, 0.014007568, -0.05557251, 0.021270752, -0.046051025, -0.06726074, 0.06982422, -0.043823242, -0.032592773, 0.021484375, 0.032226562, -0.00016534328, 0.04006958, -0.0032577515, -0.015487671, 0.0345459, -0.0021476746, 0.018569946, 0.0071105957, -0.0010204315, 0.022369385, -0.033111572, 0.07556152, -0.02684021, -0.022003174, 0.035369873, -0.0079193115, 0.018081665, -0.02798462, -0.047180176, 0.048980713, 0.058776855, -0.07885742, 0.041748047, 0.02772522, -0.037078857, -0.089416504, -0.059509277, -0.008415222, -0.032409668, 0.051849365, 0.033416748, -0.014060974, -0.035614014, 0.016159058, -0.023605347, 0.023269653, -0.054840088, 0.03125, -0.007019043, 0.05810547, 0.013710022, 0.0017156601, 0.011306763, 0.015731812, -0.0033817291, -0.010284424, -0.00013875961, -0.014778137, 0.029190063, -0.04864502, -0.06750488, -0.024993896, 0.06347656, 0.030776978, -0.01977539, -0.057495117, -0.034332275, 0.031707764, 0.05706787, 0.014465332, -0.0000192523, -0.013999939, 0.0037002563, 0.113464355, 0.010169983, -0.058502197, 0.0072631836, 0.0035305023, -0.010734558, -0.018066406, -0.003868103, 0.031051636, -0.042938232, 0.002450943, -0.014350891, -0.030578613, -0.059692383, 0.0098724365, 0.030166626, -0.030853271, -0.017745972, -0.0074768066, 0.004108429, -0.012954712, -0.029006958, 0.03451538, -0.02822876, -0.008407593, 0.015899658, 0.013259888, 0.009170532, -0.004295349, -0.054595947, 0.00756073, -0.004005432, 0.00869751, 0.004627228, 0.012184143, -0.05883789, -0.010322571, -0.07232666, -0.011764526, -0.079956055, -0.040893555, 0.013717651, -0.012916565, 0.013847351, 0.022979736, 0.027130127, 0.018966675, -0.010299683, 0.020721436, 0.0011444092, 0.009986877, -0.041290283, -0.010879517, 0.013725281 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2107.12838v2
Graph Autoencoders for Embedding Learning in Brain Networks and Major Depressive Disorder Identification
Fuad Noman, Chee-Ming Ting, Hakmook Kang, Raphael C. -W. Phan, Brian D. Boyd, Warren D. Taylor, Hernando Ombao
q-bio.NC, cs.AI, cs.LG
Brain functional connectivity (FC) reveals biomarkers for identification of various neuropsychiatric disorders. Recent application of deep neural networks (DNNs) to connectome-based classification mostly relies on traditional convolutional neural networks using input connectivity matrices on a regular Euclidean grid. We propose a graph deep learning framework to incorporate the non-Euclidean information about graph structure for classifying functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI)-derived brain networks in major depressive disorder (MDD). We design a novel graph autoencoder (GAE) architecture based on the graph convolutional networks (GCNs) to embed the topological structure and node content of large-sized fMRI networks into low-dimensional latent representations. In network construction, we employ the Ledoit-Wolf (LDW) shrinkage method to estimate the high-dimensional FC metrics efficiently from fMRI data. We consider both supervised and unsupervised approaches for the graph embedding learning. The learned embeddings are then used as feature inputs for a deep fully-connected neural network (FCNN) to discriminate MDD from healthy controls. Evaluated on two resting-state fMRI (rs-fMRI) MDD datasets, results show that the proposed GAE-FCNN model significantly outperforms several state-of-the-art methods for brain connectome classification, achieving the best accuracy using the LDW-FC edges as node features. The graph embeddings of fMRI FC networks learned by the GAE also reveal apparent group differences between MDD and HC. Our new framework demonstrates feasibility of learning graph embeddings on brain networks to provide discriminative information for diagnosis of brain disorders.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2107.12838v2
"2022-06-02T13:34:00"
"2021-07-27T14:12:39"
{ "title": [ 0.004310608, 0.002418518, -0.022994995, -0.034332275, 0.003921509, -0.014160156, -0.030303955, -0.022232056, -0.005153656, 0.023773193, 0.015625, 0.0033302307, 0.012718201, -0.048736572, -0.01461792, 0.013336182, 0.00036740303, 0.026763916, 0.002292633, -0.043151855, -0.01701355, -0.036987305, 0.07891846, 0.01689148, 0.029724121, -0.027175903, -0.093811035, 0.034332275, -0.030059814, -0.01828003, -0.007255554, -0.0029850006, 0.028045654, 0.03164673, 0.0043907166, -0.0024642944, -0.051239014, 0.028808594, 0.025817871, -0.021743774, 0.008644104, -0.022094727, -0.00041770935, -0.052001953, -0.0006284714, 0.034942627, -0.04711914, -0.043121338, -0.00712204, 0.024765015, 0.013832092, 0.049438477, -0.016174316, 0.029037476, 0.0121154785, -0.024017334, -0.024017334, -0.022964478, 0.03878784, 0.05770874, 0.014228821, -0.04626465, 0.014892578, -0.03213501, -0.027374268, -0.017059326, -0.028259277, 0.024368286, 0.06768799, -0.011802673, -0.029220581, 0.017089844, 0.0031318665, 0.028533936, -0.093322754, -0.023254395, 0.0859375, 0.027038574, 0.026519775, -0.04244995, 0.008361816, 0.009796143, -0.02330017, -0.012634277, 0.035827637, -0.0088272095, -0.013069153, -0.02748108, -0.029876709, -0.028671265, -0.0035476685, -0.02557373, 0.007297516, 0.027297974, -0.012588501, -0.028305054, -0.021194458, 0.011566162, -0.009712219, -0.010215759, -0.024475098, 0.01979065, -0.039123535, -0.017196655, 0.01638794, -0.0070724487, -0.041503906, -0.04348755, 0.013473511, 0.05029297, -0.03112793, 0.023834229, 0.01701355, -0.012107849, 0.0021381378, -0.0050086975, -0.0034484863, 0.049987793, 0.025238037, 0.04248047, -0.00932312, -0.022644043, -0.0116119385, 0.020736694, 0.02607727, -0.010215759, -0.02796936, 0.025436401, -0.03817749, 0.011306763, 0.002811432, 0.06359863, -0.06359863, -0.084350586, -0.070617676, 0.043762207, -0.02772522, 0.0045394897, -0.03353882, 0.034698486, -0.010925293, -0.045043945, 0.0110321045, -0.010665894, 0.011146545, 0.031555176, 0.04232788, -0.015838623, -0.04812622, -0.035461426, -0.013473511, 0.0017337799, 0.02822876, 0.009590149, -0.048217773, 0.0074806213, -0.09893799, -0.012840271, -0.0049591064, -0.0062828064, 0.041168213, 0.012565613, -0.010421753, 0.054656982, 0.06359863, -0.016784668, -0.02848816, 0.018829346, 0.014091492, 0.023788452, 0.0019779205, 0.01939392, 0.029434204, 0.011924744, -0.009750366, 0.02041626, 0.015312195, -0.033447266, 0.020065308, 0.02734375, 0.014770508, -0.009132385, -0.022659302, 0.057678223, -0.048583984, -0.005470276, -0.0036010742, -0.0050582886, 0.057769775, -0.013519287, -0.040374756, 0.028656006, -0.02067566, -0.07434082, -0.040222168, -0.004005432, 0.04458618, 0.0079193115, 0.008079529, 0.02381897, -0.005168915, -0.0024375916, -0.036376953, 0.024032593, -0.009887695, -0.03778076, 0.005886078, -0.0058517456, 0.0019626617, 0.054382324, 0.032470703, 0.0075531006, -0.015823364, -0.021224976, -0.008850098, -0.046051025, 0.026443481, -0.016235352, -0.01499176, -0.009544373, -0.037261963, 0.011856079, -0.017288208, 0.03463745, 0.035339355, -0.028213501, 0.017822266, -0.05557251, 0.027893066, -0.00061798096, 0.03048706, -0.008872986, 0.015113831, -0.013381958, -0.0019626617, -0.008781433, -0.007881165, -0.03363037, 0.018325806, 0.0126571655, 0.00056791306, -0.038970947, -0.019073486, 0.0060157776, 0.0670166, 0.0010299683, -0.009048462, 0.015792847, -0.005016327, 0.020492554, 0.05102539, 0.028945923, 0.010948181, -0.014572144, 0.0037021637, 0.045562744, -0.018249512, 0.014915466, -0.030578613, 0.0065574646, 0.0050315857, 0.027053833, 0.012718201, 0.0003976822, -0.022003174, -0.032470703, -0.025405884, -0.008613586, 0.0020828247, -0.006702423, 0.038482666, -0.017120361, 0.022583008, -0.014945984, -0.022155762, -0.015777588, -0.023727417, 0.03048706, 0.005191803, -0.060028076, -0.014587402, -0.0045928955, 0.031143188, 0.0015897751, 0.042236328, -0.0057907104, 0.004764557, -0.025360107, -0.021820068, -0.024047852, 0.025787354, 0.06390381, 0.009895325, 0.0037250519, 0.029052734, 0.007129669, 0.06390381, 0.064086914, -0.01739502, 0.03036499, -0.07501221, 0.015007019, -0.006160736, -0.020935059, -0.0066566467, 0.05319214, 0.00090646744, 0.013092041, -0.02357483, 0.007534027, -0.026367188, 0.017211914, 0.008514404, -0.013046265, -0.047851562, -0.060516357, -0.013656616, -0.030059814, -0.06854248, -0.0440979, 0.055358887, 0.005924225, -0.033843994, -0.012710571, 0.0022144318, -0.008972168, -0.026885986, -0.03253174, -0.018112183, 0.021957397, 0.010292053, -0.01576233, -0.055755615, -0.005619049, -0.00034499168, 0.018981934, -0.010612488, 0.0040397644, -0.007972717, 0.022460938, 0.0287323, 0.014076233, 0.034454346, -0.041778564, 0.0093307495, -0.032196045, -0.000477314, 0.025390625, -0.013687134, 0.008682251, -0.0059432983, -0.012199402, -0.026626587, 0.020996094, 0.037902832, -0.00995636, 0.0024318695, 0.0340271, 0.009117126, -0.020202637, 0.013015747, 0.03866577, 0.00057554245, -0.054107666, -0.014289856, -0.05545044, -0.011810303, 0.0008325577, 0.02229309, 0.0703125, -0.03878784, 0.0016756058, -0.026046753, -0.013420105, 0.0036716461, -0.010192871, 0.0119018555, -0.011520386, -0.028320312, -0.006126404, 0.0079193115, 0.01309967, -0.017852783, -0.0018815994, 0.1005249, -0.0066719055, -0.032409668, -0.0054969788, 0.043792725, 0.023590088, -0.008171082, -0.026885986, -0.039276123, 0.0042381287, 0.025527954, 0.01739502, -0.022964478, 0.0039596558, -0.11645508, -0.01373291, 0.08648682, 0.001821518, -0.028396606, 0.042388916, -0.060913086, 0.011108398, 0.03286743, -0.014411926, 0.043304443, 0.06262207, -0.0027637482, 0.028121948, -0.0074691772, 0.026519775, -0.0018463135, -0.013671875, -0.06097412, 0.038330078, -0.04446411, -0.06149292, 0.0026435852, -0.02029419, -0.040161133, -0.025894165, 0.023605347, 0.05596924, 0.0126571655, -0.014160156, -0.002462387, 0.0019283295, 0.027557373, -0.017501831, -0.015312195, -0.0362854, -0.025253296, -0.019958496, 0.00025749207, 0.030334473, 0.027816772, -0.0045814514, -0.023239136, -0.012908936, 0.02456665, 0.03817749, 0.009246826, -0.03161621, -0.0030097961, 0.0046920776, -0.026550293, 0.028366089, -0.03274536, 0.016067505, -0.027160645, 0.017990112, -0.021453857, -0.008995056, 0.0064697266, 0.0051994324, -0.05331421, -0.026535034, 0.004348755, -0.031311035, -0.012062073, -0.0061073303, 0.03062439, -0.022415161, 0.0036678314, -0.029312134, -0.027770996, 0.023117065, -0.042419434, 0.03375244, -0.0107421875, -0.024215698, 0.005153656, -0.0043640137, -0.0178833, 0.008239746, 0.0020885468, 0.003124237, -0.022857666, 0.010612488, -0.013221741, -0.06188965, -0.009399414, 0.00055503845, -0.10046387, -0.04144287, 0.01776123, -0.06591797, -0.0357666, -0.053741455, 0.02130127, -0.04434204, -0.029205322, 0.009773254, -0.020812988, 0.017120361, -0.017822266, -0.08465576, 0.0015945435, 0.04525757, 0.024963379, 0.035369873, 0.021087646, 0.0011758804, 0.0029888153, -0.014167786, 0.00491333, -0.021209717, 0.052490234, -0.0075645447, 0.008964539, 0.0385437, -0.024673462, 0.0121536255, 0.038024902, 0.006919861, 0.0004925728, 0.014808655, 0.02947998, 0.022720337, -0.022140503, 0.056671143, 0.015991211, -0.030792236, -0.050323486, -0.028182983, 0.005443573, 0.01083374, 0.017700195, -0.006034851, 0.010978699, 0.0033187866, 0.014801025, 0.034484863, -0.0033302307, -0.010368347, 0.015472412, -0.016677856, -0.013687134, 0.031402588, 0.038238525, 0.005115509, -0.0105896, 0.0019550323, -0.003944397, 0.029510498, -0.03729248, -0.046447754, 0.03488159, 0.051116943, -0.0463562, -0.010910034, -0.037628174, -0.06286621, -0.026016235, 0.01991272, -0.038085938, 0.028167725, 0.009780884, 0.032226562, -0.047210693, 0.008216858, 0.040100098, 0.010803223, -0.013633728, -0.04840088, 0.033935547, -0.02267456, -0.047821045, -0.046569824, 0.002193451, -0.015487671, 0.042541504, -0.005908966, -0.03302002, 0.018249512, 0.014167786, 0.08496094, 0.04574585, -0.01398468, -0.066223145, 0.02960205, 0.00035858154, -0.038482666, 0.009315491, 0.01473999, 0.004085541, -0.032073975, -0.011054993, -0.03503418, -0.023468018, -0.044036865, 0.0033931732, 0.009841919, 0.043029785, 0.027557373, 0.029754639, 0.021591187, -0.01675415, 0.023391724, 0.0060691833, -0.031982422, -0.032592773, 0.03414917, 0.018569946, -0.02607727, 0.04623413, 0.06970215, -0.0055274963, -0.028686523, 0.023147583, 0.005203247, 0.052581787, -0.02444458, 0.0026130676, 0.046142578, -0.052886963, -0.03048706, 0.0103302, 0.00002002716, 0.046691895, -0.05343628, 0.07720947, -0.019821167, -0.030029297, 0.03753662, 0.008369446, 0.007408142, 0.0042419434, 0.017501831, -0.09008789, -0.072631836, -0.03074646, 0.07885742, -0.027862549, -0.0068092346, 0.026290894, 0.011268616, 0.028915405, 0.030883789, 0.023971558, -0.003112793, -0.037261963, -0.011398315, 0.008094788, -0.014129639, -0.049835205, 0.016906738, 0.03010559, 0.00082302094, -0.05682373, -0.020843506, -0.056152344, -0.036743164, -0.01826477, -0.023391724, 0.022583008, -0.07080078, 0.019363403, 0.056671143, -0.004283905, 0.033691406, 0.002357483, 0.0051116943, 0.029922485, 0.023269653, 0.018753052, 0.010818481, 0.0109939575, -0.04949951, 0.074401855, 0.015617371, 0.028244019, -0.009056091, 0.008743286, -0.01789856, 0.008308411, -0.038024902, 0.011657715, -0.03817749, -0.000243783, 0.021820068, -0.05166626, -0.014602661, 0.0009098053, -0.008430481, -0.008735657, -0.026107788, -0.017669678, 0.029144287, -0.045776367, 0.018615723, 0.008865356, -0.028442383, -0.014884949, -0.06451416, 0.011802673, -0.029144287, 0.02268982, -0.013397217, 0.009407043, -0.030776978, 0.040985107, 0.01890564, -0.05102539, 0.009422302, 0.026977539, 0.032714844, 0.050048828, -0.011604309, -0.048461914, -0.0031700134, -0.019210815, -0.060180664, -0.068603516, 0.005924225, 0.0030498505, 0.0042877197, 0.0103302, -0.018814087, -0.004486084, 0.0031604767, 0.030288696, -0.008354187, -0.0052948, 0.043762207, -0.0071868896, -0.01637268, 0.012016296, -0.021484375, 0.009666443, 0.011741638, -0.0025634766, -0.03652954, 0.029083252, 0.011352539, 0.042236328, -0.018478394, -0.05596924, 0.003293991, 0.027709961, 0.022033691, -0.007423401, 0.038757324, 0.041748047, -0.013748169, -0.0040359497, 0.024642944, 0.04437256, -0.054534912, -0.017929077, 0.005393982, 0.0234375, -0.017471313, 0.047546387, -0.0079956055, -0.025772095, -0.034057617, -0.08782959, -0.04324341, 0.0135269165, 0.058013916, 0.05621338, 0.052093506, -0.04449463, 0.031402588, -0.03994751, -0.0029525757, -0.030944824, 0.041931152, -0.0054244995, -0.016540527, -0.01424408, -0.010818481, 0.010810852, -0.026138306, 0.032714844, -0.0071144104, -0.01209259, -0.022354126, -0.035888672, 0.010635376, -0.0052452087, -0.024917603, 0.04397583, -0.01927185, 0.008636475, 0.031829834, -0.022735596, 0.035705566, 0.03265381, 0.068481445, 0.0513916, 0.009887695, 0.00806427, 0.0067634583, -0.006755829, -0.04925537, 0.03353882, -0.06323242, 0.021911621, -0.06768799, -0.0070152283, -0.07556152, 0.03164673, -0.00049829483, 0.01965332, 0.038238525, 0.007083893, 0.016418457, 0.00043058395, 0.03353882, 0.027618408, 0.05529785, 0.0045318604, 0.0141067505, -0.011383057, 0.013015747, 0.021072388, 0.028305054, 0.023284912, 0.010101318, 0.0019283295, -0.01902771, 0.013290405, 0.024429321, 0.009338379, -0.032562256, -0.0044174194, -0.026229858, 0.0054740906, -0.023101807, 0.0013113022, 0.0362854, 0.046051025, -0.020263672, 0.017807007, 0.0054626465, -0.04071045, -0.029510498, -0.025680542, 0.018569946, -0.082092285, 0.019836426, -0.017120361, -0.003627777, 0.019683838, 0.020950317, 0.038146973, -0.07904053, -0.037475586, 0.01461792, 0.04272461, 0.0051345825, 0.014099121, -0.035064697, -0.011474609, 0.00869751, 0.024597168, -0.00034213066, 0.015487671, 0.011550903, 0.044952393, -0.022766113, 0.0076446533, -0.0065841675, 0.015930176, -0.03665161, 0.032562256, -0.041534424, 0.013130188, 0.004650116, -0.03842163, -0.019439697, 0.029434204, -0.047180176, -0.019882202, 0.028244019, 0.016906738, 0.07745361, 0.09637451, 0.020736694, 0.015098572, 0.0051231384, -0.051757812, 0.038848877, 0.038513184, -0.024887085, 0.008552551, -0.042144775, -0.050567627, 0.007904053, -0.044677734, 0.054656982, -0.026535034, 0.013031006, -0.017440796, 0.010856628, 0.03652954, -0.055755615, -0.025177002, 0.0048561096, -0.061706543, 0.0016508102, -0.024765015, -0.00932312, 0.0055770874, -0.021255493, -0.005508423, 0.036132812, 0.0014047623, -0.007160187, -0.017242432, -0.060760498, 0.017745972, -0.03515625, 0.046203613, -0.009101868, -0.026184082, -0.022384644, -0.009971619, 0.020584106, 0.018463135, -0.028320312, 0.044952393, -0.052764893, -0.031097412, 0.011230469, 0.017410278, -0.0131073, -0.010543823, -0.021621704, 0.009719849, -0.027923584, -0.026489258, 0.03463745, -0.029525757, -0.050750732, -0.012687683, -0.0362854, 0.024902344, 0.02720642, 0.0048103333, 0.014877319, 0.01586914, -0.014923096, 0.004951477, 0.014274597, 0.035125732, 0.00073862076, -0.015640259, -0.017868042, 0.057373047, 0.060028076, -0.053741455, -0.010391235, 0.0121154785, 0.018203735, -0.015052795, 0.024276733, -0.0014600754, -0.02330017, 0.032592773, 0.010124207, 0.016113281, -0.016677856, -0.043640137, -0.042999268, 0.0635376, 0.042755127, -0.0095825195, -0.032348633, 0.03652954, 0.021728516, 0.02180481, 0.023361206, -0.022903442, 0.040222168, -0.01083374, 0.0256958, -0.004081726, -0.0034427643, 0.020095825, 0.0061950684, 0.020355225, 0.07019043, -0.036193848, -0.010536194, 0.017059326, 0.036376953, -0.006427765, -0.0059394836, 0.030441284, 0.014984131, 0.042785645, 0.00034165382, -0.0095825195, -0.000749588, 0.0032730103, -0.034057617, -0.01663208, -0.05041504, 0.056274414, -0.067871094, -0.0155181885, -0.026260376, -0.022857666, 0.014701843, -0.029144287, 0.060577393, -0.070617676, 0.011619568, -0.077941895, -0.012260437, -0.004688263, 0.019439697, 0.030578613, -0.017410278, -0.02607727, -0.03414917, 0.034332275, -0.0067100525 ], "summary": [ 0.013397217, -0.0067367554, -0.003932953, 0.009643555, -0.046661377, -0.02331543, -0.027801514, -0.03878784, -0.008872986, 0.026138306, 0.027313232, -0.013786316, 0.023544312, -0.06774902, 0.01727295, 0.0034751892, 0.014953613, 0.036987305, 0.051361084, -0.022384644, -0.007965088, -0.0048713684, 0.07336426, -0.033203125, 0.0181427, -0.028900146, -0.008758545, 0.048217773, -0.000626564, 0.020996094, 0.018051147, -0.0262146, -0.0016946793, 0.041107178, -0.010620117, -0.010879517, -0.03060913, 0.026855469, 0.013412476, -0.011833191, 0.021072388, -0.0037555695, 0.07287598, -0.046325684, 0.017227173, 0.042510986, -0.01776123, -0.047973633, 0.0076675415, 0.02848816, -0.008598328, 0.011833191, -0.035247803, -0.023147583, -0.003955841, -0.014335632, -0.03250122, -0.037597656, 0.014404297, 0.07501221, 0.027191162, -0.01474762, -0.012840271, -0.056365967, 0.0064201355, -0.0061683655, 0.008613586, 0.027709961, 0.017913818, 0.0053634644, -0.015113831, 0.0051231384, 0.011512756, -0.014503479, -0.072265625, 0.013847351, 0.014678955, 0.00033783913, 0.03112793, -0.04043579, 0.016494751, 0.048583984, -0.017150879, -0.009498596, 0.0065612793, 0.010238647, -0.017791748, -0.035003662, 0.0011129379, 0.01876831, -0.01222229, -0.025222778, -0.03768921, 0.08557129, 0.03390503, -0.027023315, -0.014175415, -0.049468994, 0.019241333, 0.023727417, 0.025115967, -0.048950195, 0.039611816, -0.012252808, 0.0028438568, -0.023849487, -0.03262329, -0.060150146, 0.011161804, 0.048217773, -0.03286743, 0.029785156, 0.011672974, -0.049224854, 0.017868042, 0.031677246, 0.020965576, 0.04559326, 0.023040771, 0.027114868, -0.0284729, 0.00724411, -0.024490356, 0.036010742, 0.018493652, -0.0015735626, 0.0021762848, 0.031982422, -0.058746338, 0.026687622, -0.012199402, 0.02935791, 0.025238037, -0.012908936, -0.039001465, -0.021331787, -0.04446411, 0.0044898987, -0.00945282, 0.010574341, 0.029678345, -0.039733887, -0.0008072853, 0.045288086, -0.025985718, 0.050964355, 0.012840271, 0.006290436, -0.03491211, -0.090270996, 0.021362305, -0.028305054, 0.045928955, 0.0052719116, -0.03878784, -0.02482605, -0.017227173, -0.029785156, 0.004142761, -0.04510498, 0.06762695, 0.012702942, -0.0060157776, 0.080200195, 0.05456543, -0.029373169, -0.03289795, 0.0035858154, 0.0028629303, 0.0049552917, 0.014015198, -0.0022220612, 0.0017347336, -0.006263733, -0.0073776245, -0.0009121895, 0.0009098053, -0.015144348, 0.0028324127, 0.07446289, 0.040222168, -0.023864746, -0.010322571, 0.034454346, -0.0033569336, -0.0022697449, 0.009414673, 0.039611816, 0.022277832, 0.0074157715, -0.014503479, -0.0107421875, 0.020599365, -0.033233643, -0.027114868, -0.006023407, 0.03942871, 0.022857666, -0.01966858, 0.002298355, 0.03488159, -0.010803223, 0.007549286, 0.0008029938, -0.03338623, -0.0050315857, -0.01020813, 0.00040531158, 0.03137207, 0.0047187805, -0.011108398, -0.013916016, 0.010787964, -0.05291748, -0.04800415, -0.02116394, 0.01826477, -0.05682373, -0.02279663, -0.06414795, -0.018341064, 0.029449463, -0.039154053, 0.04901123, 0.048065186, -0.018234253, 0.012832642, -0.0284729, 0.05307007, 0.0059280396, -0.011444092, -0.009048462, -0.0020751953, -0.021316528, -0.010353088, 0.023147583, 0.05709839, -0.028182983, 0.021240234, 0.0262146, 0.021316528, -0.009559631, -0.02482605, -0.01272583, 0.044158936, 0.0068359375, 0.002456665, -0.015586853, -0.018035889, 0.033325195, 0.0066452026, 0.020507812, -0.0064582825, -0.02619934, 0.003332138, 0.03125, 0.0006480217, -0.029205322, -0.0014295578, -0.002286911, 0.018127441, 0.009742737, -0.04156494, 0.01676941, 0.018554688, -0.03729248, 0.0070648193, -0.0058174133, 0.01436615, -0.037475586, -0.0010538101, -0.03717041, -0.0016183853, -0.020111084, -0.032073975, -0.04345703, -0.024276733, 0.039031982, 0.016204834, -0.024398804, -0.014427185, -0.006801605, -0.010055542, -0.00982666, 0.03173828, 0.018096924, -0.0027484894, -0.011436462, 0.022842407, 0.04788208, 0.028182983, 0.07647705, 0.01826477, 0.039916992, 0.046875, 0.017669678, -0.015365601, 0.00041246414, 0.012802124, -0.022232056, -0.01675415, 0.043914795, -0.017044067, 0.0016450882, -0.00623703, 0.0680542, -0.0068244934, -0.00025701523, 0.004508972, -0.0045318604, 0.016494751, 0.013999939, -0.005718231, 0.045532227, -0.061065674, -0.073913574, -0.053955078, 0.0037841797, -0.08282471, -0.0335083, 0.052093506, 0.026763916, -0.023513794, 0.0012350082, 0.00466156, -0.026107788, -0.0041770935, -0.012573242, -0.022644043, 0.003276825, -0.0423584, -0.03277588, -0.03744507, 0.03942871, -0.001578331, 0.015960693, 0.016540527, -0.02204895, 0.019500732, 0.02456665, 0.07531738, 0.046295166, 0.010246277, 0.0039634705, -0.020568848, -0.00008106232, -0.009147644, 0.0044288635, 0.0034618378, -0.013648987, 0.0040740967, -0.013793945, -0.020950317, 0.03616333, -0.018539429, 0.006816864, 0.04611206, 0.029708862, 0.00034213066, -0.018081665, -0.005420685, 0.037902832, 0.003282547, -0.07006836, -0.03643799, -0.025421143, -0.01625061, 0.027633667, 0.07055664, 0.062469482, 0.009712219, 0.04171753, -0.053009033, -0.0049476624, 0.003414154, -0.045410156, 0.09899902, 0.0077056885, -0.025909424, 0.05239868, 0.031066895, 0.039978027, -0.017425537, 0.00598526, 0.085510254, -0.029846191, -0.034820557, 0.027023315, 0.03842163, 0.033172607, -0.011802673, -0.026275635, 0.009239197, -0.023132324, 0.010726929, 0.028213501, -0.02670288, -0.007621765, -0.020706177, -0.02532959, 0.081726074, 0.005844116, -0.010047913, 0.023010254, -0.002784729, 0.016418457, 0.06738281, 0.0000821352, 0.0064849854, 0.06439209, -0.014297485, 0.021850586, -0.026931763, 0.06341553, 0.004924774, -0.005832672, 0.022583008, 0.02897644, -0.052337646, -0.051116943, 0.008026123, 0.029754639, -0.0064697266, -0.02128601, 0.0446167, 0.046417236, 0.0011014938, -0.03817749, 0.01574707, 0.015777588, 0.037139893, -0.0059776306, -0.013336182, -0.000746727, -0.021102905, -0.02217102, -0.013534546, -0.066345215, 0.044128418, -0.051239014, -0.002702713, -0.0075187683, 0.033081055, 0.006137848, 0.035217285, -0.033447266, 0.010887146, 0.015792847, -0.0029182434, 0.048828125, -0.033172607, 0.014122009, 0.02116394, 0.021224976, -0.03729248, -0.020065308, -0.0024051666, 0.030334473, 0.0052490234, -0.021774292, 0.005432129, -0.027923584, 0.031707764, 0.01071167, 0.027313232, 0.00018119812, -0.023803711, 0.011451721, -0.007896423, 0.0043144226, 0.023162842, -0.0011835098, -0.026794434, -0.025527954, 0.012420654, -0.028198242, 0.008735657, 0.023468018, 0.017501831, -0.0046691895, -0.060028076, 0.03186035, -0.05441284, -0.021484375, -0.03213501, 0.014724731, -0.02998352, -0.036956787, 0.015113831, 0.007987976, 0.007068634, -0.021942139, 0.044799805, -0.02230835, -0.012046814, 0.0025482178, -0.018920898, 0.12030029, -0.013404846, -0.09307861, 0.053894043, -0.050476074, 0.02709961, 0.058441162, -0.024841309, 0.03488159, 0.036712646, 0.025680542, 0.006511688, -0.04373169, 0.044708252, -0.031188965, 0.00818634, 0.032562256, -0.035858154, 0.0284729, 0.0033493042, 0.019424438, -0.0039787292, 0.0046157837, 0.04763794, 0.04095459, -0.02053833, 0.018600464, 0.025009155, -0.004787445, -0.031585693, -0.017974854, 0.040283203, 0.002708435, 0.022705078, 0.006214142, -0.013374329, 0.021194458, 0.0037021637, -0.02571106, -0.0046424866, -0.04058838, -0.029037476, 0.015701294, 0.0018348694, 0.037017822, 0.020141602, 0.009727478, -0.03112793, -0.0030918121, 0.0014867783, 0.031204224, -0.050201416, -0.054779053, 0.065979004, 0.0670166, -0.064453125, -0.019805908, 0.027908325, -0.06762695, -0.013221741, -0.007091522, -0.03289795, -0.011764526, -0.015563965, 0.05493164, -0.012123108, -0.009811401, 0.013206482, 0.0138549805, -0.010284424, -0.019683838, 0.030700684, -0.04296875, -0.005504608, -0.0357666, 0.020858765, -0.019042969, -0.015525818, -0.010543823, -0.020599365, 0.016296387, 0.014839172, 0.03857422, 0.015853882, -0.008392334, -0.04522705, -0.0335083, 0.020828247, -0.02986145, -0.0040512085, 0.007232666, 0.0065994263, -0.028671265, -0.013061523, -0.02760315, -0.019515991, -0.08129883, -0.025421143, 0.040283203, 0.020233154, 0.05987549, -0.0019721985, 0.007003784, -0.017700195, 0.03729248, 0.019363403, -0.0049858093, -0.024734497, 0.03933716, -0.0060577393, -0.01309967, 0.0345459, 0.057800293, -0.03466797, -0.05279541, 0.025772095, 0.005771637, 0.0602417, -0.03326416, -0.019378662, 0.033569336, -0.015777588, 0.0064964294, 0.009803772, -0.030273438, 0.010307312, -0.04244995, 0.03378296, -0.01235199, -0.01838684, 0.048309326, 0.015388489, -0.0018815994, 0.032409668, -0.00042009354, -0.054901123, -0.099121094, -0.030014038, 0.112854004, -0.000012755394, -0.025527954, 0.022827148, 0.044006348, 0.025756836, 0.0012893677, -0.002866745, -0.008338928, -0.042663574, 0.0019111633, 0.0030002594, 0.0028972626, -0.01725769, 0.002746582, 0.0569458, 0.0017747879, -0.03060913, -0.056518555, 0.0022449493, -0.0390625, -0.0043296814, -0.008796692, -0.010894775, -0.041503906, -0.008094788, 0.015068054, -0.03881836, 0.007030487, 0.050933838, 0.010093689, -0.009963989, 0.002620697, -0.0015172958, -0.0076560974, -0.009880066, -0.053894043, 0.072509766, 0.004169464, 0.01701355, -0.00642395, 0.009048462, -0.0065841675, 0.020431519, -0.021514893, -0.041015625, -0.06689453, 0.038635254, 0.0065689087, -0.027297974, -0.018508911, 0.04800415, 0.019821167, -0.014007568, 0.057006836, -0.0137786865, 0.0140686035, 0.006706238, 0.05429077, -0.036071777, -0.014862061, 0.0143585205, -0.06756592, 0.003293991, -0.06536865, 0.0077705383, -0.011688232, 0.02571106, 0.013893127, -0.014099121, -0.018875122, -0.030014038, 0.03289795, 0.033721924, 0.045043945, 0.010299683, -0.058135986, -0.024414062, 0.00086545944, -0.033447266, -0.06762695, -0.06048584, 0.014137268, 0.0011167526, 0.01676941, 0.01727295, -0.008293152, 0.012619019, -0.0075569153, 0.018325806, -0.009780884, 0.00027656555, 0.031402588, -0.0025157928, 0.005344391, 0.00969696, -0.06939697, 0.010856628, -0.0062217712, -0.008201599, -0.017959595, 0.016311646, 0.061340332, 0.05847168, 0.013595581, -0.022140503, -0.0039634705, 0.044433594, 0.018188477, 0.021240234, 0.030441284, 0.018432617, -0.021347046, 0.004085541, 0.025894165, 0.025421143, -0.0357666, -0.013847351, 0.010063171, 0.045074463, -0.0012216568, -0.030548096, -0.00995636, -0.017852783, 0.011932373, -0.09814453, -0.0018539429, -0.0036506653, 0.04067993, 0.047607422, 0.035247803, -0.056884766, 0.0043411255, -0.03048706, 0.0017156601, -0.0014019012, 0.033081055, -0.03289795, -0.04486084, -0.012504578, -0.0049324036, -0.01448822, 0.0045661926, 0.0043640137, -0.01586914, -0.008178711, -0.0013990402, 0.032348633, 0.012138367, 0.0047073364, 0.023223877, 0.0013494492, -0.010528564, -0.0028190613, -0.040924072, 0.009666443, 0.03253174, 0.0038166046, 0.049835205, 0.014724731, 0.008529663, 0.04144287, -0.0021514893, -0.04324341, -0.036376953, 0.01600647, 0.002008438, -0.0005555153, -0.020950317, -0.024002075, -0.012992859, 0.09112549, -0.015113831, -0.02659607, 0.06561279, -0.009666443, 0.03375244, 0.022445679, -0.024856567, 0.0073013306, -0.0070266724, 0.007091522, 0.005508423, -0.0027580261, 0.0031929016, -0.008773804, 0.026855469, 0.038208008, 0.0017538071, 0.0128479, -0.020950317, 0.03845215, 0.02104187, -0.017822266, -0.046295166, 0.030776978, -0.050842285, -0.019210815, -0.0042533875, 0.0067481995, 0.0042648315, 0.0011196136, -0.0146484375, 0.04248047, 0.008995056, -0.00041508675, -0.014556885, 0.0035152435, -0.0129776, -0.009002686, -0.0018072128, 0.012130737, 0.0014104843, 0.05911255, -0.0030784607, 0.054229736, -0.08123779, -0.037872314, 0.04360962, 0.02861023, -0.023086548, 0.001821518, -0.038726807, 0.0013313293, 0.019134521, -0.016281128, 0.005054474, -0.027999878, 0.00390625, 0.0019235611, 0.018585205, 0.0019550323, -0.0029468536, 0.012359619, 0.009223938, 0.031311035, -0.018615723, -0.013038635, 0.024917603, -0.009307861, -0.0028953552, 0.030456543, 0.0184021, 0.03616333, 0.013710022, 0.0038776398, 0.07525635, 0.07733154, -0.01977539, 0.048217773, 0.028579712, -0.0076141357, 0.012054443, -0.028015137, -0.009223938, -0.03564453, -0.0036888123, -0.00013780594, -0.008911133, -0.021240234, 0.04812622, -0.034729004, 0.025283813, -0.0066375732, -0.025634766, -0.035339355, 0.0009741783, 0.03262329, -0.021621704, -0.06762695, 0.02180481, 0.001917839, -0.013031006, 0.030456543, -0.023452759, -0.043792725, 0.035064697, 0.0058135986, 0.004005432, -0.003238678, -0.031463623, 0.034698486, -0.006095886, 0.07196045, -0.001868248, -0.052368164, -0.008293152, -0.03100586, 0.04095459, 0.060577393, -0.00047254562, 0.06555176, -0.07330322, -0.03894043, 0.00072431564, -0.00070858, -0.018005371, -0.018447876, 0.022613525, 0.0033493042, -0.01789856, 0.01449585, -0.0003812313, -0.004245758, -0.02116394, -0.0063095093, -0.0030345917, 0.007987976, 0.0006260872, 0.008743286, 0.012268066, 0.022109985, -0.0067100525, 0.0051002502, 0.01977539, 0.020767212, -0.012924194, 0.017669678, -0.03744507, 0.06604004, 0.07208252, -0.012283325, 0.016159058, 0.021530151, -0.018844604, 0.0068893433, -0.02458191, 0.0022449493, -0.021835327, 0.016799927, -0.025634766, 0.0018024445, 0.0155181885, -0.052459717, -0.06365967, 0.05795288, -0.03829956, -0.012168884, -0.0725708, 0.0029315948, 0.007896423, 0.014884949, 0.017791748, -0.025360107, 0.014045715, -0.005844116, 0.014762878, -0.0016727448, -0.00055503845, 0.08270264, -0.020050049, 0.014526367, 0.029190063, -0.016784668, -0.036834717, -0.014411926, 0.005744934, -0.015792847, 0.06866455, -0.0066070557, -0.016433716, 0.053955078, -0.04446411, 0.002872467, 0.051330566, 0.0335083, -0.026977539, -0.007621765, -0.035064697, 0.063964844, -0.09210205, -0.046173096, -0.076293945, 0.023666382, -0.010002136, -0.027542114, 0.0597229, -0.054138184, -0.0131073, -0.06982422, 0.00025105476, 0.0053215027, -0.009628296, -0.018493652, -0.023620605, 0.02961731, -0.01751709, -0.03265381, 0.03201294 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2108.01440v2
Adaptively Optimize Content Recommendation Using Multi Armed Bandit Algorithms in E-commerce
Ding Xiang, Becky West, Jiaqi Wang, Xiquan Cui, Jinzhou Huang
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG
E-commerce sites strive to provide users the most timely relevant information in order to reduce shopping frictions and increase customer satisfaction. Multi armed bandit models (MAB) as a type of adaptive optimization algorithms provide possible approaches for such purposes. In this paper, we analyze using three classic MAB algorithms, epsilon-greedy, Thompson sampling (TS), and upper confidence bound 1 (UCB1) for dynamic content recommendations, and walk through the process of developing these algorithms internally to solve a real world e-commerce use case. First, we analyze the three MAB algorithms using simulated purchasing datasets with non-stationary reward distributions to simulate the possible time-varying customer preferences, where the traffic allocation dynamics and the accumulative rewards of different algorithms are studied. Second, we compare the accumulative rewards of the three MAB algorithms with more than 1,000 trials using actual historical A/B test datasets. We find that the larger difference between the success rates of competing recommendations the more accumulative rewards the MAB algorithms can achieve. In addition, we find that TS shows the highest average accumulative rewards under different testing scenarios. Third, we develop a batch-updated MAB algorithm to overcome the delayed reward issue in e-commerce and enable an online content optimization on our App homepage. For a state-of-the-art comparison, a real A/B test among our batch-updated MAB algorithm, a third-party MAB solution, and the default business logic are conducted. The result shows that our batch-updated MAB algorithm outperforms the counterparts and achieves 6.13% relative click-through rate (CTR) increase and 16.1% relative conversion rate (CVR) increase compared to the default experience, and 2.9% relative CTR increase and 1.4% relative CVR increase compared to the external MAB service.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2108.01440v2
"2021-08-19T20:07:27"
"2021-07-30T21:03:38"
{ "title": [ -0.00466156, -0.007194519, -0.024429321, -0.017120361, 0.01335144, -0.02532959, 0.029434204, -0.011665344, -0.030899048, 0.029632568, -0.026885986, 0.027954102, -0.0075950623, -0.009635925, -0.013687134, -0.010887146, -0.0032405853, 0.031463623, -0.021438599, -0.03314209, -0.00031924248, -0.041046143, 0.009712219, 0.0574646, 0.041503906, -0.038848877, -0.03253174, 0.00020802021, 0.0064888, -0.015625, 0.008338928, -0.019744873, 0.047943115, 0.010772705, -0.008544922, 0.038635254, -0.059020996, 0.02418518, 0.0011043549, 0.010246277, 0.021316528, -0.008621216, -0.039123535, -0.013748169, -0.03741455, 0.024887085, -0.05041504, -0.012519836, -0.015808105, 0.00466156, 0.026611328, -0.002199173, 0.019760132, 0.00333786, 0.0013084412, -0.033081055, -0.010848999, -0.022842407, 0.044036865, 0.028808594, 0.0071411133, -0.03302002, 0.0132751465, -0.0034255981, -0.0418396, -0.021774292, 0.030319214, 0.008056641, 0.033721924, -0.002986908, 0.0010261536, 0.039489746, 0.006778717, 0.02722168, -0.046325684, -0.029083252, 0.07421875, 0.01651001, 0.014556885, 0.0004911423, -0.017913818, 0.0064315796, -0.012794495, -0.071899414, 0.060577393, -0.034942627, -0.01499939, 0.0021305084, -0.0340271, -0.04611206, -0.009094238, -0.0025615692, -0.019226074, 0.0031757355, -0.018341064, -0.032806396, 0.0010290146, 0.07171631, 0.000667572, -0.024978638, -0.032928467, 0.031799316, -0.08026123, -0.012290955, 0.022064209, 0.0023975372, -0.01902771, -0.0104904175, 0.040863037, 0.027526855, -0.02166748, 0.040496826, 0.04345703, 0.045715332, -0.016693115, -0.04849243, 0.009284973, 0.012458801, -0.012359619, 0.016967773, 0.0018291473, -0.014434814, 0.01625061, -0.04486084, 0.02279663, -0.021011353, -0.057159424, 0.026107788, -0.011253357, 0.042907715, 0.010673523, 0.037963867, -0.09124756, -0.076416016, -0.07092285, 0.030685425, -0.026123047, 0.024490356, 0.005218506, -0.008522034, 0.019851685, -0.036621094, 0.016983032, 0.04711914, 0.037200928, -0.039031982, 0.038848877, 0.026168823, -0.012969971, 0.019515991, 0.010429382, 0.01411438, 0.045898438, -0.02128601, -0.026794434, -0.02267456, -0.07684326, -0.027191162, 0.006965637, -0.016311646, -0.013656616, 0.001168251, 0.030380249, 0.012504578, 0.046020508, -0.0043907166, -0.010055542, 0.027175903, 0.0039520264, 0.030456543, -0.026290894, 0.011260986, 0.029510498, -0.005718231, -0.013046265, 0.021575928, 0.056427002, 0.03265381, 0.015930176, -0.020431519, 0.0026054382, -0.021438599, 0.086120605, -0.01373291, -0.0758667, -0.01109314, 0.009521484, 0.018463135, 0.045135498, -0.0032901764, -0.0036678314, 0.004081726, -0.048461914, -0.05697632, -0.033447266, 0.005264282, 0.030563354, 0.030685425, -0.0020771027, 0.006904602, -0.026885986, 0.002937317, -0.01890564, 0.005756378, -0.002002716, -0.036590576, -0.003162384, 0.01991272, -0.045562744, 0.052764893, 0.05429077, 0.02468872, -0.05960083, 0.032287598, 0.020309448, -0.047790527, 0.015136719, 0.0012607574, -0.0004749298, 0.016204834, -0.015701294, -0.020645142, -0.007293701, 0.01902771, 0.039764404, -0.018356323, 0.0065231323, -0.017425537, 0.0463562, 0.022842407, 0.028182983, -0.017730713, 0.050842285, 0.0440979, -0.0023994446, -0.02305603, 0.0023975372, -0.018875122, 0.017486572, 0.012428284, 0.0005335808, -0.00894165, 0.01386261, 0.06329346, 0.03543091, -0.040252686, -0.00081300735, 0.03881836, 0.03527832, 0.03427124, 0.0032482147, 0.01374054, 0.06726074, 0.037750244, 0.0073890686, 0.06549072, 0.0012483597, 0.042907715, -0.05291748, 0.043701172, -0.024139404, 0.038391113, 0.052978516, 0.0088272095, -0.066345215, 0.044311523, -0.0076179504, 0.022476196, 0.016036987, 0.014160156, 0.016738892, -0.020080566, 0.0024318695, 0.012672424, 0.024032593, -0.02796936, -0.01902771, 0.008216858, 0.010658264, -0.048950195, 0.0002501011, 0.017562866, 0.04559326, -0.000012755394, 0.017913818, 0.014091492, 0.019317627, 0.005443573, -0.024124146, -0.040924072, 0.038391113, 0.015701294, -0.0045318604, -0.012275696, -0.017913818, -0.015777588, 0.06048584, 0.07659912, -0.01776123, 0.041900635, -0.03930664, 0.018539429, -0.009277344, 0.0016756058, 0.0031738281, 0.05105591, 0.023101807, 0.014503479, -0.019744873, 0.022842407, -0.05419922, 0.007041931, 0.01914978, -0.050994873, -0.0105896, -0.020095825, -0.007083893, -0.038085938, -0.066589355, -0.038024902, 0.09667969, -0.03829956, -0.020843506, -0.013893127, -0.018615723, -0.036590576, 0.011497498, -0.027404785, 0.0032405853, 0.017913818, 0.002571106, 0.013656616, -0.062927246, -0.002779007, 0.0061912537, 0.027389526, -0.015945435, -0.0026607513, -0.022109985, 0.0036678314, -0.013534546, 0.009124756, 0.0035858154, -0.07409668, 0.019699097, -0.060791016, -0.00014793873, 0.0038089752, -0.0134887695, 0.007621765, 0.021606445, -0.016799927, -0.032592773, 0.02293396, 0.050994873, -0.020736694, 0.008934021, 0.05114746, 0.020645142, -0.0010585785, 0.04119873, 0.013771057, 0.0012359619, -0.043273926, 0.015975952, -0.06390381, -0.009216309, -0.030975342, -0.0021972656, 0.054748535, -0.0473938, -0.007637024, -0.035705566, -0.008354187, -0.0071754456, 0.023162842, 0.03375244, -0.016998291, 0.030349731, 0.012802124, 0.0016002655, 0.015457153, -0.047424316, -0.008842468, 0.040008545, 0.017288208, -0.014343262, 0.005256653, 0.00655365, -0.008255005, -0.020431519, 0.014099121, -0.01838684, -0.00075912476, 0.01826477, -0.013198853, -0.02267456, 0.044158936, -0.10211182, -0.0037059784, 0.03869629, -0.017593384, -0.04156494, 0.018676758, -0.03060913, -0.02368164, 0.029144287, -0.026870728, 0.016189575, 0.022354126, 0.019378662, 0.0045051575, 0.034118652, -0.0057029724, 0.014305115, -0.055236816, -0.057128906, 0.025115967, -0.00504303, -0.053344727, -0.008476257, -0.009941101, -0.0309906, -0.007007599, 0.012649536, 0.04611206, 0.039276123, -0.017532349, 0.042053223, -0.004924774, 0.017440796, -0.027435303, 0.0035266876, -0.045532227, -0.044769287, -0.037628174, -0.019943237, 0.07373047, 0.01084137, 0.0035533905, -0.08325195, -0.01939392, 0.0025596619, 0.018371582, 0.00806427, -0.03390503, -0.01953125, -0.06500244, -0.008674622, -0.010215759, -0.011940002, 0.0053482056, -0.021240234, -0.009140015, -0.011154175, 0.024230957, -0.011566162, -0.0011615753, -0.029129028, -0.014549255, 0.0049591064, -0.012199402, -0.011413574, -0.012786865, 0.022369385, -0.009254456, 0.038970947, -0.023040771, -0.031433105, 0.027160645, -0.030593872, 0.010421753, 0.015205383, -0.01512146, 0.002943039, 0.0014448166, -0.005256653, 0.011291504, -0.017440796, -0.019866943, 0.032806396, 0.004711151, 0.032287598, -0.062927246, -0.0003554821, -0.0064926147, -0.10876465, -0.04434204, 0.006843567, -0.038909912, -0.058288574, -0.038635254, -0.0022506714, -0.006942749, -0.0335083, 0.021743774, 0.0032691956, -0.030792236, 0.005886078, -0.057769775, -0.027389526, 0.08258057, -0.02609253, 0.004501343, 0.03353882, -0.0036029816, -0.003982544, -0.026031494, 0.028549194, -0.010147095, 0.05029297, 0.0020103455, -0.000093996525, 0.022918701, -0.02116394, -0.027404785, 0.036621094, -0.009414673, -0.013786316, 0.012931824, 0.017486572, 0.04071045, -0.044799805, 0.036346436, 0.03881836, -0.040161133, -0.043151855, -0.00030636787, -0.008377075, -0.025024414, -0.011711121, -0.009811401, -0.0033359528, 0.0135269165, 0.031097412, 0.03942871, -0.0043640137, -0.029220581, 0.0006494522, 0.018875122, -0.0037631989, -0.040893555, -0.0102005005, 0.020950317, -0.0030765533, -0.005428314, -0.07098389, 0.005504608, 0.028717041, -0.039794922, -0.010437012, 0.0037651062, -0.06640625, -0.034851074, -0.039794922, -0.06628418, -0.029815674, 0.022216797, -0.007698059, 0.012290955, 0.038146973, -0.002462387, -0.047088623, 0.024383545, 0.058807373, -0.012184143, -0.0011291504, -0.06463623, 0.011642456, -0.01902771, -0.06286621, -0.043823242, -0.039489746, -0.03338623, 0.007457733, -0.002286911, -0.033691406, 0.00299263, 0.022735596, 0.046142578, 0.029525757, -0.019760132, -0.030807495, -0.0050468445, -0.028137207, -0.048736572, 0.043945312, -0.0151901245, -0.009216309, -0.025314331, 0.0748291, -0.03024292, -0.03475952, -0.076293945, 0.029373169, -0.0018548965, 0.016403198, 0.06347656, 0.06933594, 0.037902832, 0.0062332153, 0.015930176, 0.019897461, -0.046142578, -0.005126953, -0.015136719, 0.04336548, -0.0340271, 0.021072388, 0.049468994, -0.007484436, 0.00086069107, 0.0067710876, 0.007007599, 0.012008667, 0.017364502, -0.036590576, 0.04724121, 0.0021133423, -0.016571045, 0.012931824, 0.006717682, 0.032958984, -0.041748047, 0.02961731, -0.016418457, 0.027572632, 0.03201294, -0.0099487305, 0.014533997, -0.0064582825, 0.008903503, -0.04901123, -0.027954102, 0.02168274, 0.020111084, -0.03729248, 0.009719849, -0.00003260374, 0.014205933, 0.04421997, 0.04135132, 0.01158905, -0.00065898895, -0.019485474, 0.019165039, 0.0047721863, -0.045654297, -0.042785645, 0.016418457, -0.019073486, 0.009536743, -0.08074951, 0.03265381, -0.01285553, -0.026535034, -0.011940002, -0.014633179, 0.0067977905, -0.07672119, 0.022659302, 0.04434204, 0.022827148, 0.019058228, -0.034423828, 0.011268616, 0.009513855, 0.032409668, 0.0065956116, 0.0079574585, 0.02998352, -0.045043945, 0.07055664, 0.021835327, 0.02180481, 0.0013618469, 0.035888672, -0.014221191, 0.014022827, -0.025863647, 0.038757324, 0.018478394, -0.008285522, -0.010314941, -0.035980225, 0.019104004, 0.00894928, -0.0011892319, 0.034576416, -0.034301758, -0.012001038, -0.015640259, -0.014175415, -0.04345703, 0.012138367, 0.014923096, -0.025131226, -0.07116699, -0.007133484, -0.025970459, 0.00699234, -0.008377075, 0.026931763, -0.030319214, 0.03363037, 0.04510498, -0.064575195, 0.005683899, -0.015625, 0.022109985, 0.038635254, 0.014251709, -0.06726074, -0.016281128, -0.055633545, -0.052368164, -0.029174805, -0.001250267, 0.044036865, 0.04006958, -0.019134521, -0.057891846, -0.00217247, 0.0034179688, 0.038757324, -0.0030536652, -0.007858276, 0.015319824, 0.0023155212, -0.006225586, 0.0062675476, 0.05682373, -0.023406982, 0.0044937134, 0.02859497, -0.0446167, 0.02973938, 0.000685215, 0.018188477, -0.02708435, -0.047302246, -0.00060510635, 0.030029297, -0.0025997162, 0.0181427, 0.014793396, 0.017364502, 0.040283203, 0.023406982, 0.008972168, 0.068237305, -0.024642944, -0.016235352, -0.021987915, -0.011558533, -0.055389404, 0.058502197, -0.016693115, -0.017837524, -0.053710938, -0.040527344, -0.026809692, -0.005542755, 0.018371582, 0.0132751465, 0.00061941147, -0.046569824, 0.0041542053, -0.026733398, 0.006210327, -0.04714966, 0.037750244, 0.00869751, 0.00027012825, -0.035949707, 0.0032672882, 0.012954712, -0.03201294, 0.010269165, -0.016143799, 0.0017213821, -0.009147644, -0.05114746, 0.020065308, -0.026626587, -0.002779007, 0.007160187, 0.025299072, -0.034423828, 0.006767273, -0.054626465, 0.059020996, 0.018997192, 0.031204224, 0.03479004, 0.0463562, 0.01902771, 0.0024414062, 0.026916504, -0.014289856, 0.033294678, -0.070129395, -0.0033512115, -0.04876709, -0.02142334, -0.09210205, -0.012008667, 0.032226562, 0.025161743, 0.008430481, 0.015205383, 0.011947632, 0.02859497, 0.048675537, 0.004764557, 0.062561035, 0.0037384033, 0.0055236816, -0.0022010803, -0.04550171, 0.03503418, 0.04574585, -0.029296875, 0.016815186, -0.043304443, -0.008476257, -0.021133423, 0.008834839, 0.015426636, 0.0035247803, -0.016693115, -0.019241333, 0.029525757, -0.0061416626, 0.029388428, 0.047668457, 0.030075073, -0.017059326, -0.006855011, 0.010513306, 0.030807495, -0.03137207, 0.025421143, 0.032989502, -0.0048561096, 0.007949829, -0.02772522, -0.025299072, 0.012794495, -0.006526947, 0.050079346, -0.07513428, -0.08862305, 0.024765015, 0.04562378, 0.021026611, 0.034240723, -0.027618408, -0.014785767, -0.0046920776, 0.01171875, 0.005718231, 0.007358551, 0.023422241, 0.04046631, -0.024398804, 0.01939392, 0.0037612915, 0.032348633, -0.02722168, 0.02279663, -0.076416016, 0.03353882, -0.010719299, -0.04824829, 0.00308609, -0.00020384789, -0.044769287, -0.016799927, 0.024124146, 0.078125, 0.08239746, 0.053649902, -0.024032593, -0.019744873, 0.064941406, -0.058410645, 0.028869629, 0.04788208, -0.006454468, 0.055511475, -0.05328369, -0.0473938, 0.041809082, -0.07385254, 0.0546875, -0.013038635, 0.017227173, -0.019546509, -0.015525818, 0.03488159, -0.06008911, 0.030532837, -0.01574707, -0.040161133, -0.004016876, -0.014656067, -0.017608643, -0.016723633, -0.025939941, 0.0155181885, 0.0063476562, -0.025680542, -0.015960693, 0.009902954, -0.0357666, -0.038604736, -0.06500244, 0.010978699, -0.06109619, -0.022949219, 0.011428833, -0.0046157837, 0.0075416565, -0.047668457, -0.0473938, -0.024871826, 0.021102905, -0.037139893, 0.015930176, 0.019470215, -0.010772705, -0.025970459, 0.04324341, -0.015975952, -0.019897461, -0.033294678, 0.02104187, -0.02029419, -0.056854248, -0.01914978, -0.037506104, 0.010292053, 0.028152466, -0.010635376, -0.016693115, 0.040130615, -0.02520752, -0.03225708, 0.00012075901, 0.02267456, -0.015426636, -0.028747559, -0.021743774, 0.066711426, 0.047851562, -0.037597656, -0.028457642, 0.02330017, 0.02458191, -0.014465332, 0.06213379, 0.01725769, -0.003665924, 0.0043182373, 0.042938232, 0.007030487, -0.03326416, -0.024551392, -0.010925293, 0.023651123, 0.05645752, -0.0007376671, -0.003200531, 0.038482666, -0.009819031, -0.018859863, 0.019226074, -0.0074691772, -0.021942139, 0.0030651093, 0.0046691895, -0.030639648, -0.015930176, 0.0055236816, 0.0124053955, -0.009132385, 0.023956299, 0.002090454, 0.0024261475, -0.0039405823, 0.036346436, -0.03363037, -0.030776978, 0.040008545, 0.025375366, 0.013298035, 0.04949951, -0.0046844482, -0.0062065125, -0.018875122, 0.0012588501, 0.0001296997, 0.012275696, 0.032714844, -0.02128601, 0.010559082, -0.01852417, -0.04736328, -0.016113281, -0.027954102, 0.016342163, -0.038604736, 0.0060272217, -0.0012750626, -0.03390503, 0.0018444061, 0.0206604, 0.015205383, -0.044311523, -0.020812988, -0.0065231323, 0.05633545, -0.014793396 ], "summary": [ 0.048065186, -0.027709961, 0.01864624, -0.009140015, -0.02609253, -0.031082153, 0.02835083, -0.024414062, -0.009223938, 0.04724121, -0.006713867, 0.018249512, 0.030227661, -0.017471313, 0.017318726, -0.008621216, 0.0024414062, 0.04034424, 0.0151901245, -0.024002075, -0.0010166168, -0.006477356, -0.020507812, 0.06451416, 0.03262329, -0.04055786, 0.0030975342, 0.004837036, 0.02029419, 0.013328552, 0.019699097, -0.0038986206, 0.009712219, 0.011024475, 0.0066871643, 0.032287598, 0.011894226, 0.0033340454, -0.004776001, 0.030670166, 0.034088135, -0.013542175, 0.01007843, -0.04486084, 0.00002604723, 0.02406311, 0.017547607, -0.019943237, 0.0056419373, -0.027648926, 0.0015821457, -0.014831543, 0.015274048, -0.01953125, -0.028442383, -0.03878784, -0.029067993, -0.042633057, 0.020858765, 0.05026245, 0.027511597, -0.022506714, -0.0033740997, -0.026031494, -0.014678955, -0.0006518364, 0.09161377, -0.001209259, -0.0012865067, -0.00034046173, 0.01725769, 0.026657104, 0.0042037964, -0.02658081, -0.030258179, 0.025619507, 0.023895264, 0.0010356903, 0.0014514923, -0.013557434, -0.025268555, 0.03704834, -0.009628296, -0.08831787, 0.03768921, -0.04095459, -0.021011353, 0.005558014, -0.051757812, -0.02027893, -0.034698486, -0.00894928, -0.048980713, -0.000726223, -0.004802704, -0.00881958, 0.054870605, 0.08868408, -0.025390625, -0.025009155, 0.0048294067, -0.032165527, -0.024383545, -0.027938843, 0.00031161308, 0.013381958, -0.0011320114, -0.0056266785, 0.015159607, 0.002161026, -0.016708374, 0.011993408, 0.04953003, 0.037506104, -0.03225708, -0.064086914, -0.012908936, 0.03366089, -0.01864624, 0.010185242, 0.012687683, 0.0231781, 0.026733398, 0.0036067963, 0.011924744, 0.019729614, -0.029266357, -0.025466919, -0.00054216385, 0.045440674, -0.008911133, -0.004749298, -0.02255249, 0.00982666, -0.021240234, -0.023544312, -0.01374054, 0.004825592, 0.0072898865, -0.009811401, 0.012542725, -0.032073975, 0.0065307617, 0.012191772, 0.05328369, -0.03050232, 0.0014209747, 0.050201416, 0.041809082, 0.038909912, 0.02609253, -0.0009727478, 0.08251953, -0.057434082, -0.050994873, -0.095581055, -0.05239868, -0.019760132, 0.03375244, -0.04574585, 0.010887146, -0.018707275, 0.029022217, 0.05432129, 0.0079422, 0.023101807, -0.00472641, -0.014572144, 0.01687622, 0.030929565, 0.012519836, -0.021606445, 0.042053223, -0.0055351257, -0.015914917, 0.009613037, 0.032104492, 0.06768799, 0.016067505, -0.041656494, -0.018585205, -0.036071777, 0.12902832, -0.051208496, -0.0619812, 0.02217102, -0.01309967, 0.08270264, 0.04498291, 0.019256592, -0.012924194, -0.04724121, -0.048461914, -0.023757935, 0.0049438477, 0.025466919, 0.0017948151, 0.020904541, 0.0058517456, -0.045776367, -0.00014472008, 0.0069847107, -0.0012369156, -0.0085372925, 0.010551453, -0.011962891, 0.012756348, 0.013259888, -0.05026245, 0.046569824, 0.028457642, -0.003211975, -0.054840088, 0.088134766, 0.046875, -0.07940674, 0.013946533, -0.011024475, 0.008522034, -0.00019574165, -0.00868988, 0.0007009506, -0.025817871, 0.03704834, 0.021240234, -0.036712646, 0.0046157837, 0.002248764, 0.053894043, 0.025726318, 0.007369995, -0.02708435, -0.014305115, 0.026123047, 0.0044937134, -0.020095825, 0.0029907227, -0.09020996, 0.04135132, 0.04309082, 0.021072388, 0.0039596558, -0.012252808, 0.03527832, 0.01763916, -0.03982544, 0.0024852753, 0.025634766, -0.011329651, 0.022735596, 0.0026130676, 0.0077438354, 0.032165527, -0.01235199, -0.008773804, 0.043762207, -0.03050232, 0.0317688, -0.05923462, 0.027359009, -0.022720337, -0.004650116, 0.03970337, -0.021408081, -0.024520874, 0.004169464, 0.013259888, 0.019088745, 0.02130127, -0.0256958, 0.00029301643, -0.010894775, -0.0019893646, 0.004295349, -0.018539429, -0.041625977, -0.019561768, 0.023071289, -0.01838684, -0.031188965, 0.000872612, 0.014877319, 0.018066406, -0.004863739, 0.033691406, 0.026168823, 0.009666443, 0.020050049, -0.02128601, -0.006187439, 0.014793396, 0.027282715, -0.028411865, 0.042785645, -0.034973145, -0.016143799, -0.013038635, 0.026351929, 0.00522995, -0.013793945, 0.018051147, 0.03817749, -0.029541016, 0.0012044907, -0.00080251694, 0.062194824, 0.017974854, -0.0007596016, 0.0066986084, 0.0007338524, -0.015792847, 0.0070610046, 0.036010742, 0.017807007, 0.010520935, -0.010353088, -0.024642944, 0.029129028, -0.06915283, -0.03604126, 0.053222656, -0.038330078, 0.020980835, 0.010406494, -0.012214661, -0.05508423, 0.082336426, -0.00920105, 0.020812988, 0.0019407272, -0.041229248, -0.0035514832, -0.04888916, 0.053619385, 0.0069503784, 0.025726318, 0.0048675537, -0.023025513, -0.0027542114, 0.008636475, 0.03326416, 0.04815674, 0.014854431, -0.027572632, -0.041900635, 0.011146545, 0.0028572083, -0.017425537, 0.008850098, 0.02279663, 0.00081682205, 0.011772156, -0.023651123, 0.06298828, 0.018661499, 0.00116539, 0.048706055, 0.08081055, 0.015701294, -0.006843567, 0.05895996, 0.020019531, 0.019927979, -0.06149292, 0.000787735, -0.054504395, 0.029922485, -0.060394287, 0.032470703, 0.026794434, 0.006980896, 0.0033740997, -0.020523071, -0.0029773712, -0.0048294067, -0.00730896, 0.11212158, 0.012176514, 0.020309448, 0.06707764, 0.014213562, 0.02432251, -0.028213501, -0.019683838, 0.070373535, 0.016540527, -0.015930176, 0.008216858, 0.0143966675, 0.011947632, -0.014625549, -0.0043029785, 0.013061523, -0.010261536, 0.011528015, -0.012138367, -0.026657104, 0.0043029785, -0.035339355, -0.008972168, 0.003030777, -0.006706238, 0.009124756, -0.015419006, -0.013877869, 0.02633667, -0.0012750626, -0.0059814453, 0.007827759, -0.029785156, 0.035827637, -0.004550934, 0.02519226, 0.0025787354, 0.008552551, -0.06304932, 0.013519287, 0.005470276, -0.002105713, -0.00070238113, 0.010032654, 0.011161804, -0.006690979, 0.0065689087, 0.02079773, 0.05331421, 0.010910034, -0.014587402, 0.04425049, -0.010635376, 0.021133423, -0.015991211, 0.010620117, -0.0625, -0.067993164, -0.07702637, -0.03414917, 0.041137695, -0.00076675415, -0.026382446, -0.093811035, -0.016586304, -0.004337311, -0.010955811, 0.0059814453, -0.03527832, -0.010810852, -0.08905029, 0.004211426, -0.03829956, -0.00063705444, 0.009529114, 0.046813965, 0.012130737, 0.005176544, 0.031585693, -0.033325195, 0.007949829, 0.05731201, -0.02255249, -0.026992798, -0.0059280396, -0.009475708, -0.0017166138, 0.050445557, -0.002357483, 0.007873535, 0.010749817, -0.011398315, 0.00598526, 0.033233643, -0.045013428, 0.0181427, -0.0368042, -0.018554688, -0.07330322, 0.051330566, 0.016677856, 0.03994751, -0.06866455, 0.0079574585, 0.0054397583, 0.09265137, -0.04006958, -0.02810669, 0.01007843, -0.05819702, -0.044891357, 0.003566742, -0.01335144, -0.056243896, -0.015586853, -0.004058838, 0.020614624, -0.012062073, 0.028961182, -0.0010604858, 0.023361206, 0.008308411, -0.037750244, -0.03869629, 0.0062026978, 0.012794495, -0.019973755, -0.032287598, 0.03933716, 0.0036754608, -0.018432617, 0.019104004, -0.06750488, -0.013938904, -0.048675537, 0.0054473877, 0.0010204315, -0.008468628, -0.034057617, 0.050994873, -0.02810669, 0.0077667236, 0.010826111, 0.058258057, 0.07305908, -0.039611816, -0.023498535, 0.0546875, -0.009132385, -0.04034424, 0.02015686, -0.011634827, -0.014671326, -0.018844604, 0.04272461, -0.015731812, 0.0025367737, 0.04309082, -0.039886475, -0.027404785, -0.04244995, -0.0014734268, 0.04562378, -0.02218628, -0.044403076, -0.021499634, 0.051940918, 0.008262634, -0.016830444, -0.044281006, 0.0137786865, -0.0067634583, 0.008728027, -0.018325806, -0.018234253, -0.032440186, -0.04714966, 0.010627747, 0.007270813, 0.0036563873, -0.023117065, -0.014587402, 0.023162842, 0.006549835, 0.01852417, -0.023788452, -0.0032577515, 0.042999268, 0.013534546, -0.0070228577, -0.04537964, 0.05432129, -0.048736572, -0.03704834, -0.0647583, -0.038482666, -0.03250122, -0.021377563, 0.0050086975, -0.0011100769, 0.013595581, 0.0231781, 0.00819397, 0.0032596588, -0.017944336, -0.010299683, -0.008201599, -0.013534546, -0.032287598, 0.042999268, -0.043518066, -0.0061073303, -0.013046265, 0.07647705, -0.012931824, -0.041290283, -0.06640625, 0.00920105, -0.0059890747, 0.018127441, 0.07922363, 0.07110596, 0.030075073, 0.0034008026, 0.019104004, 0.012489319, -0.019805908, 0.002023697, 0.0037498474, 0.024002075, -0.0007367134, 0.0013313293, 0.021606445, -0.0078125, -0.0024681091, 0.0023994446, 0.010635376, -0.0011024475, 0.0146102905, -0.029205322, 0.03894043, 0.09710693, -0.011787415, 0.04611206, 0.024612427, 0.0013875961, 0.029937744, -0.036468506, 0.031341553, 0.07714844, 0.04244995, -0.039916992, -0.019851685, -0.0029087067, -0.027450562, -0.03262329, -0.019744873, -0.003189087, 0.0070114136, -0.018463135, -0.028747559, -0.007129669, -0.0026664734, 0.034301758, 0.028274536, 0.018859863, -0.009376526, -0.0023117065, 0.018737793, 0.0020446777, -0.02619934, -0.014968872, -0.0064697266, -0.01927185, 0.008659363, -0.0140686035, 0.0034732819, 0.022857666, -0.016571045, -0.020187378, -0.02822876, -0.004611969, -0.0680542, -0.02758789, -0.008842468, -0.024139404, 0.01763916, -0.020004272, -0.014343262, 0.0071144104, 0.017578125, -0.0020389557, -0.02305603, -0.0059661865, -0.014328003, 0.043884277, 0.02949524, 0.009536743, 0.022720337, 0.004802704, -0.01058197, -0.008934021, 0.039031982, 0.017059326, 0.030166626, -0.019424438, -0.018753052, -0.0039520264, 0.07171631, 0.014801025, -0.038391113, 0.01789856, 0.034973145, -0.016555786, -0.02305603, 0.018005371, -0.015098572, -0.01109314, 0.010375977, -0.0066337585, -0.022735596, -0.045166016, -0.0020942688, 0.03768921, -0.0024280548, 0.00642395, -0.0234375, 0.0007777214, 0.020706177, -0.0390625, -0.00869751, 0.0017728806, 0.024368286, -0.014778137, -0.006286621, -0.075927734, -0.011291504, -0.05996704, 0.0060195923, 0.0056419373, -0.0017843246, 0.044128418, 0.041107178, -0.0038318634, -0.025253296, 0.04159546, -0.021102905, 0.029342651, -0.004737854, 0.02293396, 0.007843018, -0.0035820007, -0.019088745, 0.021270752, 0.013000488, -0.0069618225, 0.014533997, 0.003610611, -0.040802002, 0.015823364, -0.0028972626, 0.008079529, -0.017120361, -0.062347412, -0.00034308434, 0.014694214, 0.020401001, 0.011428833, -0.019592285, -0.001964569, 0.049224854, -0.0104522705, -0.028244019, 0.030258179, 0.0025672913, -0.014579773, -0.002418518, 0.029800415, -0.015327454, 0.0236969, -0.009719849, -0.0138549805, -0.011924744, -0.03414917, 0.004501343, -0.02217102, 0.024414062, 0.005645752, 0.012382507, -0.06011963, -0.05001831, 0.035461426, 0.0057373047, -0.03878784, 0.000113368034, 0.011314392, 0.04522705, -0.012763977, 0.03616333, 0.015342712, 0.0075149536, -0.02130127, -0.02041626, -0.008544922, 0.003730774, -0.041503906, 0.022384644, -0.0023651123, 0.04623413, -0.009635925, 0.022644043, -0.04458618, -0.060455322, -0.028274536, 0.056396484, -0.0019569397, -0.024627686, -0.009666443, 0.054382324, 0.027938843, -0.012939453, 0.021392822, -0.0033817291, 0.05822754, -0.02432251, -0.020355225, -0.039398193, -0.052520752, -0.04336548, 0.028701782, -0.006378174, 0.0029258728, 0.031402588, 0.01939392, -0.011070251, 0.024749756, 0.0039520264, 0.02947998, 0.039093018, 0.018707275, -0.0038414001, 0.013885498, -0.0435791, 0.0000067949295, 0.043029785, -0.009880066, 0.0065078735, -0.06982422, 0.0071372986, 0.015686035, -0.035247803, -0.0061683655, -0.010513306, 0.007160187, -0.037841797, 0.023803711, 0.029052734, 0.06542969, 0.016860962, -0.02432251, 0.03881836, -0.003704071, -0.008262634, 0.060150146, -0.055023193, 0.06689453, 0.03012085, 0.020828247, -0.04473877, -0.026229858, -0.013977051, 0.014045715, -0.028442383, 0.059326172, -0.05895996, -0.05670166, 0.008071899, 0.030288696, 0.0004761219, 0.023406982, -0.023925781, -0.026870728, 0.019226074, 0.0045776367, 0.0016326904, 0.017990112, 0.036193848, 0.007572174, 0.026550293, 0.060180664, -0.019729614, 0.06842041, -0.020629883, 0.028289795, -0.072509766, 0.0262146, 0.033111572, -0.026779175, 0.025512695, 0.024673462, 0.009307861, 0.028305054, -0.002822876, 0.08380127, 0.10559082, 0.024490356, -0.07141113, 0.016296387, 0.1104126, -0.026794434, 0.07324219, 0.0024795532, 0.012954712, 0.024734497, -0.016601562, -0.0029563904, 0.038024902, -0.033294678, 0.03012085, 0.0104904175, 0.021987915, -0.023040771, -0.049041748, 0.019332886, -0.028549194, 0.054718018, -0.03451538, 0.0068855286, -0.015701294, 0.01637268, -0.042938232, 0.008590698, -0.04763794, -0.010398865, -0.008758545, -0.054534912, -0.012420654, 0.026016235, -0.057525635, -0.06921387, -0.06286621, -0.017349243, -0.006832123, -0.034240723, 0.07122803, -0.032440186, 0.004890442, -0.07055664, -0.044189453, -0.01751709, 0.033294678, -0.050964355, 0.030273438, 0.014190674, -0.008468628, 0.010322571, 0.014663696, 0.004432678, 0.0009832382, -0.05480957, -0.0010967255, -0.0003683567, -0.070251465, -0.03967285, -0.019104004, -0.0141067505, 0.04675293, 0.014183044, 0.005783081, 0.050872803, -0.02178955, -0.032836914, -0.024642944, -0.02330017, 0.013618469, -0.037139893, -0.020202637, 0.034179688, 0.033691406, -0.012916565, -0.0068626404, 0.04537964, 0.021377563, 0.00258255, 0.017715454, 0.023101807, -0.010116577, -0.017105103, 0.044433594, -0.009902954, -0.014373779, 0.002998352, 0.022872925, 0.034210205, -0.00060749054, -0.018753052, -0.00085401535, 0.004673004, -0.050750732, -0.058135986, -0.019607544, 0.026321411, -0.07165527, 0.016403198, -0.0042381287, -0.034851074, -0.0051498413, 0.028198242, 0.009269714, -0.021575928, -0.0154953, 0.0068893433, -0.012176514, -0.010986328, -0.0018968582, -0.012832642, 0.043518066, -0.004020691, 0.011444092, 0.029266357, -0.0021343231, -0.0033302307, 0.018936157, -0.0010766983, 0.023422241, 0.008232117, 0.0184021, 0.024337769, -0.024749756, -0.00819397, -0.0070648193, -0.020996094, -0.024597168, -0.024383545, 0.021865845, 0.010528564, -0.019424438, 0.05407715, -0.027511597, 0.011520386, 0.00844574, 0.012161255, -0.027938843, 0.013557434, -0.015289307, 0.00497818, 0.018615723 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2108.02037v1
The MIT Supercloud Dataset
Siddharth Samsi, Matthew L Weiss, David Bestor, Baolin Li, Michael Jones, Albert Reuther, Daniel Edelman, William Arcand, Chansup Byun, John Holodnack, Matthew Hubbell, Jeremy Kepner, Anna Klein, Joseph McDonald, Adam Michaleas, Peter Michaleas, Lauren Milechin, Julia Mullen, Charles Yee, Benjamin Price, Andrew Prout, Antonio Rosa, Allan Vanterpool, Lindsey McEvoy, Anson Cheng, Devesh Tiwari, Vijay Gadepally
cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.LG
Artificial intelligence (AI) and Machine learning (ML) workloads are an increasingly larger share of the compute workloads in traditional High-Performance Computing (HPC) centers and commercial cloud systems. This has led to changes in deployment approaches of HPC clusters and the commercial cloud, as well as a new focus on approaches to optimized resource usage, allocations and deployment of new AI frame- works, and capabilities such as Jupyter notebooks to enable rapid prototyping and deployment. With these changes, there is a need to better understand cluster/datacenter operations with the goal of developing improved scheduling policies, identifying inefficiencies in resource utilization, energy/power consumption, failure prediction, and identifying policy violations. In this paper we introduce the MIT Supercloud Dataset which aims to foster innovative AI/ML approaches to the analysis of large scale HPC and datacenter/cloud operations. We provide detailed monitoring logs from the MIT Supercloud system, which include CPU and GPU usage by jobs, memory usage, file system logs, and physical monitoring data. This paper discusses the details of the dataset, collection methodology, data availability, and discusses potential challenge problems being developed using this data. Datasets and future challenge announcements will be available via https://dcc.mit.edu.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2108.02037v1
"2021-08-04T13:06:17"
"2021-08-04T13:06:17"
{ "title": [ 0.00957489, 0.006587982, -0.07470703, -0.07519531, 0.002275467, -0.027740479, -0.048461914, 0.009094238, 0.0010576248, 0.04425049, -0.0072135925, -0.009819031, 0.013618469, -0.051849365, 0.0014715195, 0.017868042, 0.032196045, -0.010810852, -0.0015935898, -0.010017395, -0.042144775, 0.00592041, 0.02861023, 0.02406311, -0.005214691, -0.031555176, -0.06222534, -0.011962891, -0.015350342, -0.04425049, -0.002084732, 0.07006836, 0.0113220215, 0.036071777, -0.015151978, 0.030029297, -0.014259338, 0.035308838, 0.024154663, 0.0048599243, 0.028137207, 0.013175964, 0.069885254, -0.023101807, -0.0027103424, -0.011482239, -0.000033795834, -0.012283325, -0.00522995, 0.0032730103, -0.02204895, 0.01247406, -0.03427124, 0.07366943, 0.0046195984, -0.0048942566, -0.02279663, 0.024139404, 0.029418945, -0.032470703, -0.044158936, -0.032043457, 0.08074951, 0.012741089, -0.028015137, -0.010032654, -0.013061523, 0.010971069, 0.05307007, -0.021133423, -0.03366089, 0.0060272217, -0.016235352, -0.00894165, -0.036468506, -0.020843506, 0.03994751, 0.009101868, -0.004272461, 0.004032135, -0.026855469, -0.03616333, -0.006629944, -0.020004272, 0.0026855469, 0.016113281, -0.011817932, -0.006752014, -0.020309448, -0.016784668, -0.008369446, 0.009231567, -0.019805908, 0.044799805, -0.014564514, -0.005832672, -0.0020141602, 0.031829834, 0.01184082, -0.031707764, -0.040222168, 0.004211426, -0.05810547, -0.0039138794, 0.024551392, 0.022415161, -0.017593384, -0.034606934, 0.02281189, 0.040222168, 0.00024485588, 0.04473877, -0.010391235, 0.012634277, -0.013313293, -0.009262085, -0.029006958, -0.0015602112, -0.027954102, 0.0029850006, 0.014465332, 0.009254456, 0.01651001, -0.026733398, 0.028274536, 0.013244629, -0.03338623, -0.025726318, -0.035705566, 0.017684937, -0.0036735535, 0.07885742, -0.101623535, -0.082092285, -0.081848145, 0.024307251, -0.004951477, -0.027038574, -0.0068511963, 0.0072746277, 0.022521973, -0.035705566, -0.028884888, 0.033081055, -0.002986908, 0.036895752, 0.045837402, -0.019180298, -0.040100098, -0.04525757, -0.018005371, -0.0016479492, 0.0031833649, 0.01725769, -0.053955078, 0.023071289, -0.06274414, -0.003490448, 0.021377563, 0.0072135925, 0.052459717, -0.015174866, -0.02684021, 0.06616211, 0.056365967, 0.016082764, 0.003583908, 0.026641846, -0.0077400208, 0.02217102, -0.025024414, -0.013435364, 0.044525146, -0.055755615, -0.015419006, -0.0030727386, -0.005332947, -0.019165039, 0.028289795, 0.012710571, -0.0062065125, -0.02670288, -0.0541687, 0.0362854, -0.02772522, -0.0635376, 0.0033073425, -0.012535095, 0.023345947, 0.032348633, -0.018218994, 0.026641846, -0.023849487, -0.032958984, -0.035247803, 0.02053833, 0.02861023, 0.05496216, -0.005138397, -0.0064468384, -0.02128601, 0.03643799, -0.022415161, 0.02078247, 0.014595032, -0.012550354, 0.012298584, 0.011238098, -0.0069503784, 0.06317139, 0.03250122, 0.011665344, -0.017028809, -0.029891968, -0.006336212, -0.05819702, -0.03338623, -0.03881836, -0.029800415, 0.00064754486, -0.013092041, -0.012161255, -0.012908936, 0.029510498, 0.019699097, 0.0574646, -0.01159668, 0.011459351, 0.06616211, 0.026916504, 0.08166504, -0.03591919, 0.043060303, -0.002450943, -0.027938843, -0.016082764, 0.022735596, -0.032043457, 0.0022220612, 0.045806885, 0.016418457, 0.002588272, -0.0068130493, 0.024154663, 0.07098389, 0.00447464, 0.017562866, 0.010482788, 0.04434204, 0.05731201, 0.01739502, 0.022445679, 0.054260254, 0.026565552, -0.0034122467, 0.070007324, 0.01486969, -0.007949829, -0.0014877319, 0.0317688, 0.0050849915, 0.0736084, 0.005836487, 0.03363037, -0.05706787, -0.0046577454, -0.03173828, 0.021942139, -0.00079488754, -0.012268066, 0.026000977, -0.00010037422, 0.012382507, -0.018569946, 0.023910522, -0.041870117, -0.020843506, 0.01259613, 0.005470276, -0.04449463, -0.028625488, -0.012519836, 0.06530762, 0.015113831, 0.0030765533, -0.012550354, 0.054748535, 0.015014648, -0.038238525, 0.005859375, 0.039978027, 0.070617676, 0.022628784, 0.021774292, 0.0002309084, 0.03793335, 0.080200195, 0.037475586, -0.012481689, 0.00086069107, -0.04675293, -0.00018322468, 0.008102417, -0.02015686, 0.02078247, 0.03253174, 0.042419434, -0.0025043488, -0.007949829, 0.017608643, -0.05126953, 0.01600647, 0.006504059, -0.02444458, -0.03390503, -0.055114746, -0.037963867, -0.002040863, -0.083618164, -0.011497498, 0.099975586, 0.008369446, -0.026763916, -0.06604004, 0.011154175, -0.03414917, -0.06750488, -0.035980225, 0.0061569214, -0.0055885315, -0.028289795, -0.031402588, -0.09411621, -0.020889282, 0.008338928, 0.035888672, -0.003993988, -0.00041365623, -0.018981934, -0.0008406639, 0.0077590942, 0.017501831, 0.0032482147, -0.04421997, 0.026809692, -0.030426025, -0.026016235, -0.00015342236, -0.009315491, 0.005870819, 0.013504028, -0.0010118484, -0.009284973, -0.0024490356, 0.03463745, -0.030761719, 0.006778717, -0.0056114197, 0.024917603, -0.03515625, -0.009147644, 0.0048980713, -0.012687683, -0.003145218, 0.0065574646, -0.04736328, -0.00008428097, 0.018539429, -0.019332886, 0.021774292, -0.03062439, -0.009841919, -0.015960693, -0.0055656433, -0.06890869, 0.01449585, -0.01423645, -0.045440674, -0.03567505, -0.020477295, 0.021377563, -0.0043411255, 0.033569336, -0.015510559, 0.06915283, -0.016326904, 0.00014281273, 0.046783447, 0.035736084, 0.009231567, -0.040008545, -0.032409668, -0.031677246, 0.00012457371, -0.00063991547, -0.01625061, 0.005405426, 0.0027370453, -0.083862305, 0.0119018555, 0.018493652, -0.017562866, -0.025604248, 0.0035991669, -0.02029419, -0.015350342, 0.017654419, -0.022018433, 0.02809143, 0.031585693, 0.019454956, 0.004497528, 0.073913574, -0.060821533, 0.027252197, -0.033111572, -0.029373169, 0.030838013, 0.0036334991, -0.022888184, -0.003929138, -0.011756897, -0.03704834, -0.022262573, -0.0018405914, 0.057373047, 0.009552002, 0.0231781, 0.0034713745, -0.020126343, 0.024124146, -0.039215088, -0.029083252, -0.026412964, -0.0055618286, 0.0070762634, 0.0013208389, 0.04901123, 0.03375244, 0.006416321, -0.028701782, -0.010848999, 0.00472641, 0.02810669, -0.001332283, -0.013114929, -0.0019760132, -0.024642944, 0.012290955, 0.0680542, -0.04272461, -0.006011963, -0.015113831, 0.009780884, -0.043029785, 0.010444641, 0.011856079, 0.061035156, -0.017974854, 0.009986877, 0.049468994, -0.006439209, -0.058807373, 0.013442993, -0.009986877, 0.0021591187, 0.002248764, 0.011253357, -0.0039711, -0.0022182465, -0.02079773, 0.033599854, -0.0021858215, -0.018432617, -0.011238098, -0.04043579, -0.0074882507, -0.00048542023, 0.007980347, -0.015098572, -0.02507019, 0.012756348, -0.046203613, -0.02520752, 0.0064926147, 0.008506775, -0.027557373, -0.006385803, 0.031829834, -0.01991272, -0.04864502, -0.03036499, 0.026535034, -0.008651733, 0.013259888, -0.0055885315, 0.0061187744, -0.018936157, -0.0052452087, -0.09063721, -0.022994995, 0.024749756, 0.03100586, 0.026428223, 0.005130768, -0.0024147034, 0.0053901672, -0.03918457, 0.026138306, 0.0060539246, 0.034606934, -0.053222656, 0.016571045, -0.014709473, 0.00031924248, 0.046173096, 0.003955841, -0.006416321, 0.02116394, 0.01133728, 0.055603027, 0.06341553, -0.06378174, 0.037353516, 0.06286621, -0.019592285, -0.087890625, 0.0023536682, 0.010002136, -0.042510986, 0.014694214, 0.0053215027, 0.04220581, 0.057556152, -0.02909851, 0.010597229, -0.006904602, -0.0029067993, 0.010192871, 0.0011844635, -0.0029201508, -0.030731201, -0.015640259, -0.028457642, -0.0076293945, 0.021087646, 0.033416748, 0.07159424, -0.0546875, 0.003993988, 0.02255249, 0.031707764, -0.0036525726, 0.004131317, -0.036743164, -0.009414673, -0.030395508, 0.002811432, -0.021957397, 0.008094788, 0.019927979, -0.008491516, -0.037261963, -0.021484375, -0.024765015, 0.014373779, -0.0019893646, -0.049468994, -0.0006504059, -0.020812988, -0.05517578, -0.042236328, 0.059417725, 0.030471802, 0.013160706, -0.015014648, -0.0051612854, 0.027877808, 0.012130737, 0.0034294128, 0.021652222, -0.024719238, -0.032043457, 0.00894165, -0.012130737, 0.049560547, -0.017333984, 0.0030994415, -0.010673523, -0.003025055, -0.0037708282, 0.0038146973, -0.027420044, -0.055511475, 0.01802063, 0.023666382, 0.05331421, 0.045288086, 0.013969421, 0.023895264, 0.027709961, -0.01687622, -0.00090932846, -0.03289795, -0.0129470825, -0.013923645, 0.017807007, 0.02494812, 0.034240723, 0.039489746, 0.0463562, -0.05001831, -0.02609253, 0.07305908, 0.0013074875, -0.02305603, 0.0057373047, 0.04248047, 0.02267456, -0.01626587, 0.0037517548, -0.01928711, 0.018417358, -0.03756714, 0.02746582, -0.030700684, 0.0004210472, -0.006832123, 0.009140015, -0.024398804, 0.00045371056, 0.0146102905, -0.052215576, -0.041290283, -0.018661499, 0.09222412, -0.04067993, -0.041412354, -0.035003662, 0.018569946, 0.011985779, 0.03942871, 0.0022735596, -0.030578613, 0.010177612, -0.022857666, -0.030960083, -0.009109497, -0.064941406, 0.008094788, -0.02079773, 0.030761719, 0.048614502, -0.015403748, -0.017456055, -0.023406982, -0.007297516, 0.019378662, 0.007621765, -0.02897644, -0.009979248, 0.043273926, 0.020462036, -0.016326904, 0.00012254715, -0.021942139, 0.04257202, 0.031951904, -0.0072021484, 0.000395298, 0.006210327, 0.0036830902, -0.018753052, 0.0042419434, 0.012535095, -0.0066986084, -0.004764557, 0.018173218, -0.011772156, -0.044036865, 0.012420654, 0.022613525, -0.01663208, 0.020767212, -0.04336548, 0.05886841, -0.041534424, -0.020187378, 0.021224976, -0.018447876, -0.033935547, 0.011016846, 0.001364708, -0.009590149, 0.015655518, 0.0058288574, -0.005844116, -0.03793335, 0.091308594, -0.013977051, 0.0044670105, -0.008628845, 0.0040016174, -0.01902771, 0.030029297, 0.00042796135, -0.04208374, 0.020446777, 0.0155181885, 0.020065308, 0.041381836, 0.015151978, -0.04550171, -0.020965576, -0.024307251, -0.051452637, -0.039794922, -0.032043457, 0.0005931854, 0.018417358, -0.02734375, -0.057037354, -0.005504608, -0.006336212, 0.03375244, -0.016693115, -0.029205322, -0.024459839, -0.013580322, -0.011154175, -0.0015153885, 0.019699097, 0.02229309, -0.0025844574, 0.0107803345, -0.055480957, -0.0043144226, -0.0043144226, 0.0053138733, -0.014945984, -0.087402344, 0.019119263, 0.0178833, 0.068359375, -0.024536133, 0.03302002, 0.03942871, 0.016281128, 0.017456055, 0.025024414, 0.10064697, -0.04257202, 0.023010254, -0.032409668, -0.013259888, -0.083862305, 0.032806396, 0.03390503, 0.04522705, -0.05114746, -0.054473877, -0.037872314, -0.026397705, 0.03439331, -0.018753052, 0.024658203, -0.020355225, 0.004562378, -0.032562256, 0.0073890686, 0.0016365051, 0.051330566, -0.03463745, -0.0077552795, -0.0041885376, -0.01361084, -0.013809204, -0.03286743, 0.03591919, 0.04486084, -0.0060577393, 0.033416748, -0.013809204, -0.026504517, -0.042022705, 0.028457642, 0.07684326, 0.04776001, -0.013145447, 0.038116455, -0.025375366, 0.052459717, 0.043670654, 0.031799316, 0.039764404, -0.014251709, -0.024673462, 0.019714355, 0.0032787323, -0.010101318, 0.016784668, -0.021881104, 0.0031108856, -0.010353088, -0.029373169, -0.09173584, -0.015640259, 0.044555664, 0.018997192, -0.009216309, 0.014137268, -0.009056091, -0.0082473755, 0.0076141357, -0.01260376, 0.04675293, -0.02670288, -0.01914978, 0.009094238, 0.0013856888, -0.03213501, 0.008087158, 0.009651184, 0.024856567, -0.011749268, 0.00831604, 0.020935059, 0.0012960434, 0.018508911, -0.018997192, 0.015388489, -0.020339966, 0.006629944, -0.008377075, 0.03744507, 0.047424316, 0.022994995, -0.082092285, 0.011749268, 0.0073280334, 0.027633667, -0.035736084, 0.028884888, 0.07647705, -0.07574463, 0.02810669, -0.016296387, -0.029052734, 0.02027893, -0.015304565, 0.044891357, -0.037200928, -0.020385742, -0.023635864, 0.023345947, 0.006088257, -0.033172607, -0.0287323, -0.022766113, 0.019622803, -0.0047340393, -0.01802063, 0.008384705, 0.02973938, -0.0011930466, 0.027008057, -0.008888245, 0.0059661865, 0.024856567, 0.034820557, 0.04348755, -0.04336548, 0.09710693, -0.021636963, -0.05493164, 0.04095459, 0.006477356, -0.06085205, 0.023788452, -0.0023059845, 0.07385254, 0.022033691, 0.040893555, -0.0014781952, -0.045410156, 0.018615723, -0.005191803, 0.029190063, 0.028152466, -0.0090789795, 0.027374268, -0.051574707, -0.03338623, 0.00025343895, -0.034606934, 0.053649902, -0.03062439, 0.030136108, -0.03805542, 0.016708374, 0.012832642, -0.045043945, -0.0079422, -0.025497437, 0.017074585, 0.0058021545, 0.0073623657, -0.03744507, -0.028762817, -0.023788452, 0.053222656, 0.0024642944, -0.014930725, 0.054351807, -0.03765869, -0.08691406, 0.041229248, -0.006160736, 0.050201416, -0.0418396, -0.0059509277, -0.021865845, 0.017700195, 0.0059776306, -0.010826111, -0.006828308, 0.017364502, -0.043945312, -0.00081062317, 0.02041626, 0.005832672, -0.003490448, -0.035705566, -0.004348755, 0.0025749207, -0.027557373, -0.0019721985, 0.01876831, -0.019195557, -0.03869629, 0.0140686035, -0.031829834, 0.022842407, 0.0035324097, -0.03314209, -0.008720398, 0.009292603, -0.0030918121, -0.052490234, -0.013824463, 0.013183594, -0.002298355, -0.024993896, -0.03010559, 0.032470703, 0.05493164, -0.02758789, -0.009925842, 0.031311035, 0.06890869, 0.014381409, 0.071777344, -0.0047340393, 0.02961731, 0.01386261, 0.038970947, 0.008972168, -0.025344849, 0.011810303, 0.009971619, 0.029953003, 0.0051231384, -0.044555664, 0.013366699, 0.006919861, -0.022109985, 0.016082764, 0.02142334, 0.0023937225, 0.010894775, -0.0068473816, 0.039855957, -0.03677368, -0.0137786865, 0.0018968582, 0.0012836456, -0.004337311, 0.008628845, -0.039489746, 0.013694763, -0.037078857, -0.0019073486, 0.01626587, -0.046447754, 0.033203125, 0.0357666, 0.009628296, 0.0395813, -0.0016775131, -0.05142212, -0.024978638, 0.006969452, 0.01777649, 0.005897522, -0.008651733, 0.00434494, 0.03225708, -0.015281677, -0.02911377, -0.035003662, -0.031463623, 0.02923584, -0.07910156, 0.058380127, -0.034698486, -0.016235352, 0.014320374, -0.058135986, -0.016021729, -0.004322052, -0.053344727, -0.0703125, -0.037628174, 0.008270264 ], "summary": [ -0.010185242, -0.03564453, -0.032073975, -0.035980225, -0.015556335, -0.01084137, -0.0011911392, 0.021026611, -0.009460449, 0.0090408325, -0.023452759, 0.0048980713, -0.013267517, -0.033966064, 0.023727417, -0.04095459, 0.01713562, -0.05432129, -0.013694763, -0.03012085, 0.010719299, -0.014389038, 0.006755829, 0.043670654, 0.026885986, -0.08117676, -0.06726074, 0.04360962, -0.0052604675, 0.02659607, 0.012817383, 0.016418457, 0.0043563843, 0.031829834, -0.011947632, 0.034942627, -0.001502037, 0.022781372, 0.027679443, 0.017196655, 0.01020813, 0.017730713, 0.13977051, -0.06365967, 0.050231934, 0.026565552, -0.005592346, -0.059661865, 0.00907135, -0.017471313, 0.014335632, 0.02583313, 0.00957489, -0.012176514, -0.015487671, 0.02079773, -0.011306763, 0.031829834, 0.028778076, -0.064086914, -0.027175903, 0.0019664764, 0.03881836, 0.047180176, -0.03933716, -0.015388489, 0.03250122, 0.013763428, 0.034423828, -0.032989502, 0.003604889, 0.04321289, 0.014076233, -0.0014181137, -0.009765625, -0.04107666, 0.04473877, -0.012359619, -0.012557983, 0.022155762, -0.018875122, -0.036956787, 0.0022792816, 0.003578186, -0.019088745, 0.026672363, -0.021362305, -0.00945282, 0.008911133, 0.013244629, -0.016082764, -0.011802673, 0.00008094311, 0.057800293, 0.0013771057, -0.012283325, -0.04434204, -0.03515625, 0.012519836, -0.017410278, 0.016845703, -0.035583496, -0.015449524, 0.0031700134, 0.009819031, 0.05758667, -0.042053223, -0.04147339, 0.02835083, 0.02998352, 0.02178955, -0.046081543, 0.014320374, -0.00724411, -0.030517578, 0.029434204, 0.005050659, 0.017608643, -0.011680603, 0.05227661, -0.002368927, 0.0395813, -0.030395508, 0.01524353, 0.040222168, 0.034118652, 0.024810791, -0.023620605, -0.05014038, 0.047729492, 0.008056641, -0.005241394, -0.031234741, -0.00074863434, -0.049102783, -0.013717651, 0.01979065, -0.02003479, 0.016967773, 0.027542114, 0.03829956, -0.0317688, -0.047943115, 0.05343628, -0.0023059845, 0.024475098, 0.013145447, -0.011054993, -0.009963989, -0.007144928, 0.024002075, -0.04888916, 0.027755737, 0.026290894, -0.06964111, 0.014411926, -0.022979736, 0.0063438416, -0.0345459, -0.021957397, 0.003189087, -0.0005173683, 0.032165527, 0.06762695, 0.04800415, 0.006187439, -0.008102417, 0.0024032593, 0.009918213, -0.11767578, 0.021102905, -0.01411438, 0.045959473, -0.049987793, 0.008125305, -0.002231598, 0.024810791, -0.021911621, 0.0010738373, -0.01991272, -0.02168274, -0.032989502, -0.018447876, 0.003921509, 0.007865906, -0.011123657, 0.014228821, -0.0034713745, 0.018997192, 0.014625549, -0.0064430237, 0.020599365, -0.017410278, 0.012313843, 0.00015473366, -0.0059394836, -0.033966064, 0.012771606, -0.013832092, -0.015914917, 0.04019165, 0.021392822, -0.03274536, -0.02684021, -0.08300781, -0.005859375, -0.023452759, 0.035095215, -0.062347412, 0.026123047, 0.04147339, -0.00920105, -0.031280518, 0.0059928894, 0.028762817, -0.027069092, -0.029403687, -0.014282227, 0.005382538, 0.0047187805, -0.01499176, 0.0016899109, -0.029708862, -0.016082764, -0.03036499, 0.038909912, -0.02708435, 0.025344849, 0.029571533, 0.024307251, 0.07739258, -0.028503418, 0.04248047, 0.04135132, -0.017944336, -0.011703491, 0.030166626, -0.048095703, -0.0109939575, 0.031082153, 0.021575928, -0.005458832, 0.00006747246, 0.040374756, -0.0029087067, -0.0007519722, 0.036010742, 0.02003479, -0.0016965866, 0.03640747, -0.0048179626, 0.028366089, 0.025314331, 0.050628662, -0.01171875, 0.025741577, 0.0008568764, -0.059143066, 0.02267456, 0.022109985, 0.027816772, 0.062683105, -0.010108948, 0.04333496, -0.03778076, 0.032073975, -0.014831543, 0.010231018, -0.004337311, -0.0022239685, 0.018997192, -0.023040771, -0.0054244995, -0.008918762, -0.05090332, 0.006252289, -0.0028514862, 0.008560181, -0.010864258, -0.028579712, -0.0049934387, -0.016082764, -0.027877808, -0.007457733, 0.044006348, -0.048309326, -0.024093628, -0.001294136, -0.019195557, 0.06323242, 0.05239868, 0.07324219, 0.006439209, -0.0041007996, 0.01928711, 0.040618896, 0.060913086, 0.0335083, -0.004837036, 0.0047073364, -0.0062942505, 0.013252258, -0.03955078, 0.005783081, 0.014320374, 0.030776978, 0.039001465, 0.00390625, 0.018569946, 0.020324707, -0.02722168, 0.018081665, -0.0032367706, 0.056671143, -0.05996704, -0.060516357, -0.016082764, 0.0073432922, -0.05859375, -0.014007568, 0.10437012, -0.0049591064, -0.027267456, -0.04156494, -0.02017212, -0.011001587, -0.016845703, -0.040039062, 0.015411377, -0.0065307617, -0.06567383, -0.024597168, -0.03189087, 0.024490356, -0.011184692, -0.0051345825, -0.013519287, 0.037322998, 0.0028953552, -0.028045654, -0.01499939, 0.013511658, -0.008041382, -0.010398865, -0.008666992, -0.01272583, -0.010803223, 0.00046873093, -0.005706787, 0.012962341, -0.01386261, 0.008918762, -0.023788452, 0.015914917, -0.010017395, 0.022918701, 0.04058838, -0.03086853, -0.015960693, -0.05142212, 0.009391785, 0.0009188652, -0.039276123, -0.0501709, 0.026519775, -0.02368164, -0.016357422, -0.03112793, 0.009727478, 0.007068634, 0.038604736, 0.01626587, -0.052124023, -0.02973938, -0.037109375, -0.01197052, 0.030944824, -0.005153656, 0.013038635, 0.02645874, 0.033813477, 0.019607544, -0.008056641, -0.01739502, 0.08087158, -0.021316528, -0.022964478, -0.015312195, 0.047210693, 0.029418945, -0.0037956238, -0.051940918, 0.028320312, -0.0134887695, -0.027359009, -0.01424408, -0.030441284, -0.02128601, -0.021530151, -0.002401352, 0.00381279, 0.04574585, -0.0014066696, -0.0054855347, -0.018630981, 0.026565552, 0.011222839, -0.010574341, -0.0017490387, 0.045410156, 0.0184021, -0.048858643, 0.011505127, -0.024505615, 0.029449463, -0.037750244, -0.033416748, 0.024017334, -0.045776367, -0.0013980865, -0.010421753, 0.058685303, -0.019821167, 0.00058174133, 0.01663208, 0.06237793, 0.001824379, 0.022338867, -0.0090789795, -0.018188477, 0.0236969, -0.033477783, -0.00680542, -0.012054443, -0.049560547, 0.015449524, 0.025802612, 0.05041504, 0.046173096, -0.02456665, -0.030929565, 0.002796173, 0.028045654, -0.000014781952, 0.015434265, -0.020965576, 0.028259277, -0.017150879, 0.052490234, 0.039154053, 0.0025615692, -0.016342163, 0.015701294, 0.015686035, -0.04272461, 0.0018787384, 0.017196655, 0.04510498, -0.013557434, 0.0065460205, 0.040161133, -0.0022640228, -0.023483276, 0.017547607, 0.0027103424, 0.03338623, -0.04083252, 0.029571533, -0.018554688, -0.0067443848, 0.023361206, 0.0071487427, 0.00064849854, -0.029907227, -0.0099105835, -0.04144287, 0.03137207, -0.006286621, 0.03353882, -0.0519104, -0.060791016, 0.03253174, -0.04751587, -0.029663086, -0.008773804, -0.0005507469, -0.021713257, -0.05041504, -0.006401062, 0.0020370483, -0.010025024, -0.0063819885, 0.022628784, 0.019302368, 0.0060043335, 0.00021088123, -0.01133728, 0.0715332, -0.004840851, -0.083862305, 0.03704834, -0.020523071, 0.034240723, 0.041168213, -0.021316528, 0.059906006, 0.043670654, -0.048553467, -0.017105103, -0.006164551, -0.006275177, -0.078430176, -0.027709961, -0.012550354, -0.01838684, 0.05239868, -0.032409668, -0.022735596, -0.0027770996, -0.0027923584, 0.05102539, 0.06048584, -0.052215576, 0.012084961, 0.042053223, -0.01348114, -0.06213379, 0.004600525, -0.01374054, -0.054473877, 0.041412354, 0.039154053, 0.027145386, 0.042053223, -0.045410156, -0.0076179504, -0.03186035, -0.010055542, -0.04837036, -0.019485474, -0.043762207, -0.033843994, 0.03439331, 0.010017395, -0.029586792, 0.032928467, -0.0043640137, 0.080566406, -0.074401855, 0.03111267, 0.010826111, 0.011360168, -0.013969421, -0.032714844, -0.020614624, -0.008659363, -0.018661499, 0.0041007996, -0.00894928, -0.0048446655, -0.008407593, 0.014137268, 0.0042381287, -0.008575439, 0.061645508, 0.034057617, -0.011581421, -0.06188965, -0.035705566, 0.0038414001, -0.044952393, -0.0031337738, 0.033813477, -0.0007276535, -0.013435364, -0.020339966, 0.0118255615, 0.014953613, 0.009384155, -0.002998352, 0.000582695, -0.006351471, 0.004020691, 0.0006580353, -0.025604248, 0.060699463, -0.03164673, -0.0118255615, -0.030944824, 0.04244995, 0.039215088, 0.0013170242, -0.025436401, -0.022521973, 0.01083374, 0.029678345, -0.007701874, -0.0060691833, 0.021224976, 0.0038719177, 0.043701172, -0.0124053955, -0.007160187, -0.023880005, 0.0104599, -0.027893066, 0.022399902, -0.0038337708, 0.055480957, 0.06878662, -0.017410278, -0.08984375, 0.0058021545, 0.058654785, 0.026779175, -0.032684326, -0.013420105, 0.04248047, 0.05758667, -0.003025055, 0.017608643, 0.031173706, -0.013206482, -0.008598328, -0.0026283264, 0.025878906, 0.040374756, 0.030334473, -0.0046081543, 0.014144897, 0.00059747696, -0.002796173, -0.037506104, -0.09197998, -0.031982422, 0.109436035, -0.016281128, -0.027709961, -0.04147339, -0.0062179565, 0.007583618, 0.002620697, -0.039794922, -0.002565384, -0.0033340454, -0.004558563, -0.032836914, -0.02798462, -0.011497498, -0.016723633, -0.048797607, 0.0022258759, -0.011146545, -0.018951416, 0.035858154, -0.012962341, 0.015014648, 0.0020065308, -0.020126343, -0.035705566, -0.05886841, -0.02810669, -0.019729614, -0.032318115, 0.006538391, -0.019210815, 0.0041885376, 0.021469116, -0.023971558, -0.0049324036, -0.013519287, -0.0031738281, -0.034729004, -0.016662598, 0.018569946, 0.04019165, -0.050720215, 0.045959473, -0.033203125, -0.00459671, 0.011619568, 0.029464722, -0.01625061, -0.011680603, -0.017074585, 0.04534912, -0.03768921, 0.009025574, -0.0015954971, 0.010604858, -0.038909912, 0.012054443, 0.03427124, 0.02104187, -0.0052757263, 0.02909851, -0.01638794, -0.033111572, 0.057678223, -0.053741455, -0.022598267, 0.0073165894, -0.029785156, -0.015838623, -0.03253174, 0.035186768, -0.00071287155, 0.01121521, -0.04345703, -0.006198883, -0.023956299, 0.018829346, 0.0013856888, 0.003730774, -0.06994629, -0.05291748, -0.107177734, -0.07678223, -0.035247803, 0.101379395, -0.061676025, 0.014038086, -0.00029063225, -0.046844482, 0.003435135, 0.01966858, -0.05178833, -0.02557373, -0.014671326, -0.026321411, 0.020431519, -0.0206604, -0.007881165, 0.0048942566, -0.022201538, 0.0007967949, 0.016220093, 0.0054855347, 0.011817932, -0.03781128, -0.031677246, -0.0063552856, 0.029327393, 0.016494751, 0.02609253, -0.03543091, 0.028396606, -0.040740967, -0.004043579, 0.0004711151, 0.093566895, -0.064086914, -0.018829346, -0.011367798, 0.031036377, -0.0099487305, 0.03277588, -0.020355225, -0.025466919, -0.012260437, -0.038970947, 0.010345459, -0.031585693, -0.007293701, 0.0066490173, -0.0053367615, 0.0047683716, 0.022506714, 0.030090332, -0.059143066, -0.054138184, -0.0069732666, 0.0008845329, 0.017349243, 0.07232666, -0.019927979, 0.015289307, -0.009407043, 0.01184082, -0.002199173, -0.016067505, 0.027069092, -0.010612488, 0.008232117, -0.023651123, 0.023925781, 0.017684937, 0.050750732, -0.023147583, 0.01084137, 0.0003926754, 0.03302002, 0.036224365, -0.036193848, -0.0019931793, -0.014343262, -0.0058631897, -0.008033752, 0.0027713776, -0.0067481995, 0.025115967, -0.027038574, -0.06964111, -0.080200195, -0.0647583, -0.003572464, -0.0206604, -0.0335083, -0.04434204, 0.047912598, -0.009819031, -0.015533447, 0.051940918, -0.04043579, 0.027557373, -0.049682617, -0.019546509, -0.035339355, -0.0031032562, 0.024917603, -0.008018494, 0.031036377, 0.023117065, 0.004787445, 0.037750244, -0.009147644, 0.00283432, -0.020858765, 0.039398193, -0.037506104, -0.007987976, -0.016723633, 0.032287598, 0.01713562, 0.02658081, 0.024261475, 0.019241333, -0.029174805, 0.0033779144, 0.027938843, 0.03955078, -0.0110321045, 0.0395813, 0.044769287, -0.013015747, 0.024246216, 0.0048446655, -0.043060303, 0.009941101, 0.039398193, 0.030395508, -0.02154541, 0.039154053, -0.024978638, 0.00046992302, -0.029220581, -0.035614014, -0.026657104, -0.011131287, 0.056915283, 0.013076782, -0.02079773, -0.014953613, 0.009986877, -0.0005083084, -0.014717102, 0.012680054, -0.006351471, 0.042266846, 0.011489868, 0.030685425, -0.07006836, 0.0073127747, 0.011787415, -0.02368164, 0.009254456, 0.011566162, 0.02255249, -0.0025291443, 0.017486572, 0.0357666, 0.022064209, 0.019241333, -0.056243896, 0.0008678436, 0.037231445, -0.014724731, 0.018218994, 0.015548706, 0.010147095, -0.012435913, -0.035186768, 0.0031337738, -0.012680054, -0.004737854, 0.037200928, -0.036102295, 0.013214111, -0.01763916, 0.010978699, -0.029953003, -0.016082764, 0.020858765, -0.020736694, -0.010688782, 0.019760132, 0.04449463, -0.0063476562, 0.033447266, -0.0070533752, -0.017501831, 0.01210022, -0.03074646, 0.01398468, 0.00066518784, -0.031829834, -0.0289917, -0.030441284, 0.032958984, -0.038360596, 0.0037975311, -0.014266968, 0.07965088, -0.026657104, -0.047821045, 0.0037670135, 0.07446289, 0.02418518, -0.029907227, 0.019119263, 0.015716553, -0.020019531, -0.04953003, -0.0602417, 0.0033626556, -0.041534424, 0.010292053, 0.02168274, -0.0060157776, -0.028656006, 0.009597778, -0.028244019, 0.001364708, -0.004020691, -0.005191803, -0.05404663, 0.06463623, -0.04525757, -0.04284668, -0.027038574, 0.007259369, -0.025177002, -0.047546387, -0.0026359558, 0.013542175, 0.046203613, -0.002243042, -0.004470825, 0.04623413, 0.013519287, 0.010917664, -0.002922058, -0.06060791, -0.011314392, 0.06970215, 0.087768555, 0.046417236, -0.048583984, -0.017089844, -0.03527832, 0.053588867, 0.0033912659, -0.03555298, 0.0038776398, 0.03768921, -0.022079468, 0.0052604675, -0.014060974, 0.0149383545, -0.02494812, -0.030700684, -0.01977539, -0.017089844, -0.068725586, 0.027267456, -0.027450562, 0.0035953522, 0.014846802, -0.022476196, -0.0032577515, -0.032592773, -0.00730896, 0.025466919, -0.061645508, 0.0112838745, 0.05316162, -0.0032978058, 0.014328003, -0.03161621, -0.051116943, -0.02279663, -0.0054244995, 0.008956909, 0.016784668, -0.00047135353, -0.020568848, 0.004032135, 0.0079193115, -0.027114868, -0.0446167, -0.053833008, 0.0017356873, -0.056518555, 0.031204224, -0.025863647, 0.03744507, 0.027038574, -0.033416748, -0.035247803, 0.004047394, -0.02420044, 0.0063056946, -0.059143066, -0.0015459061 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2108.03150v1
Attainment Regions in Feature-Parameter Space for High-Level Debugging in Autonomous Robots
Simón C. Smith, Subramanian Ramamoorthy
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
Understanding a controller's performance in different scenarios is crucial for robots that are going to be deployed in safety-critical tasks. If we do not have a model of the dynamics of the world, which is often the case in complex domains, we may need to approximate a performance function of the robot based on its interaction with the environment. Such a performance function gives us insights into the behaviour of the robot, allowing us to fine-tune the controller with manual interventions. In high-dimensionality systems, where the actionstate space is large, fine-tuning a controller is non-trivial. To overcome this problem, we propose a performance function whose domain is defined by external features and parameters of the controller. Attainment regions are defined over such a domain defined by feature-parameter pairs, and serve the purpose of enabling prediction of successful execution of the task. The use of the feature-parameter space -in contrast to the action-state space- allows us to adapt, explain and finetune the controller over a simpler (i.e., lower dimensional space). When the robot successfully executes the task, we use the attainment regions to gain insights into the limits of the controller, and its robustness. When the robot fails to execute the task, we use the regions to debug the controller and find adaptive and counterfactual changes to the solutions. Another advantage of this approach is that we can generalise through the use of Gaussian processes regression of the performance function in the high-dimensional space. To test our approach, we demonstrate learning an approximation to the performance function in simulation, with a mobile robot traversing different terrain conditions. Then, with a sample-efficient method, we propagate the attainment regions to a physical robot in a similar environment.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2108.03150v1
"2021-08-06T14:45:57"
"2021-08-06T14:45:57"
{ "title": [ -0.02520752, -0.0049438477, -0.018371582, -0.038482666, -0.004547119, 0.005508423, -0.033325195, -0.023712158, 0.010856628, 0.009178162, -0.0017986298, -0.0069236755, -0.016906738, -0.030578613, -0.022918701, -0.0028152466, 0.007335663, 0.018249512, -0.0005683899, -0.018875122, 0.008529663, -0.022720337, 0.013839722, 0.06573486, 0.017959595, 0.019836426, -0.091918945, -0.0010032654, -0.022094727, -0.029663086, -0.021331787, 0.014770508, 0.025924683, 0.022583008, 0.0067367554, 0.025131226, -0.003955841, 0.01007843, 0.010917664, 0.021270752, 0.030563354, -0.024536133, 0.00013697147, -0.02470398, -0.023162842, 0.025558472, -0.030792236, -0.012748718, 0.008399963, 0.0026378632, -0.0047302246, 0.0317688, -0.005908966, 0.03930664, -0.004749298, -0.030548096, -0.026672363, -0.031082153, 0.058380127, 0.0713501, 0.007896423, -0.06500244, 0.0030288696, -0.058013916, 0.032440186, 0.015342712, 0.00447464, 0.024124146, 0.04309082, 0.037109375, -0.038208008, -0.018493652, -0.015914917, 0.061340332, -0.0067329407, -0.027404785, 0.03286743, 0.022033691, 0.03643799, 0.033111572, 0.007411957, -0.041778564, 0.01222229, 0.03805542, -0.027755737, 0.005680084, 0.0054969788, -0.002603531, -0.026611328, -0.07672119, -0.0049972534, 0.0068588257, -0.044281006, -0.016616821, -0.046875, -0.05316162, -0.020690918, -0.011650085, 0.020263672, -0.0060424805, 0.054595947, -0.036193848, 0.017745972, -0.018630981, 0.0033569336, 0.0031604767, -0.00074625015, -0.01966858, 0.017974854, 0.022338867, -0.041992188, 0.041229248, 0.010009766, -0.018508911, -0.0211792, 0.010093689, 0.021743774, -0.017578125, 0.03744507, -0.026779175, -0.014465332, -0.009963989, 0.00504303, 0.037475586, -0.0026416779, 0.008285522, -0.032806396, -0.00844574, 0.014678955, 0.020507812, -0.0032863617, 0.048339844, -0.076416016, -0.09515381, -0.057922363, 0.03286743, 0.016326904, -0.007083893, -0.010047913, -0.010612488, 0.0042915344, -0.0044136047, 0.032714844, -0.013427734, -0.056549072, 0.008483887, 0.040618896, 0.017745972, -0.05657959, -0.070251465, -0.027023315, 0.02507019, 0.0027999878, -0.014762878, 0.026290894, -0.034942627, -0.042541504, -0.03677368, 0.056671143, -0.010284424, -0.007434845, 0.02218628, -0.006538391, -0.048583984, -0.0033607483, -0.02458191, 0.0016412735, 0.028915405, 0.004085541, 0.036315918, 0.0032463074, 0.010421753, -0.008460999, -0.030731201, -0.01448822, -0.0066337585, -0.002248764, 0.021072388, 0.022125244, -0.029251099, 0.031051636, -0.006275177, -0.0034484863, 0.04660034, -0.07269287, -0.012054443, -0.022384644, -0.008857727, 0.07293701, -0.0024929047, -0.015014648, 0.002521515, -0.036346436, -0.026229858, -0.028823853, -0.020599365, 0.017822266, -0.00070619583, -0.015510559, 0.030715942, -0.02961731, 0.023330688, -0.025772095, 0.015052795, -0.011138916, -0.049713135, 0.0020599365, 0.01449585, 0.008674622, 0.061401367, 0.02558899, 0.009750366, -0.028945923, 0.014144897, -0.0072250366, -0.060791016, 0.01335144, -0.006427765, -0.0021038055, -0.022628784, -0.016448975, 0.0007686615, -0.013412476, 0.015731812, 0.030838013, 0.025543213, 0.009216309, -0.018585205, 0.09832764, 0.03857422, 0.058502197, -0.08117676, 0.02558899, 0.012207031, -0.0052604675, -0.0022964478, -0.02130127, 0.0030403137, -0.007408142, 0.0087890625, 0.0057792664, -0.028656006, -0.003435135, 0.008010864, 0.047088623, -0.010177612, -0.0012273788, 0.010818481, -0.02331543, -0.014228821, 0.058624268, 0.006175995, 0.042388916, 0.011741638, -0.010604858, 0.047027588, 0.0065841675, -0.0104522705, -0.03414917, 0.011550903, 0.016693115, -0.007171631, -0.03665161, 0.003332138, -0.044189453, 0.03353882, -0.00033020973, 0.039001465, -0.011444092, 0.019439697, 0.03552246, 0.023239136, -0.020462036, -0.0006814003, -0.031021118, -0.033721924, -0.028213501, 0.048065186, -0.02015686, -0.055999756, -0.011856079, 0.0072517395, 0.07269287, -0.008628845, -0.019195557, 0.008323669, 0.050933838, -0.036590576, 0.0042152405, 0.0072669983, 0.068603516, -0.012664795, -0.008224487, -0.004005432, -0.0051994324, -0.037750244, 0.066833496, 0.095703125, -0.040161133, 0.0670166, -0.05871582, 0.0006093979, 0.024871826, -0.001162529, 0.014389038, 0.023147583, 0.013717651, 0.031921387, -0.0032520294, 0.05807495, -0.08026123, -0.006187439, 0.009208679, -0.0026550293, -0.034423828, -0.064819336, 0.008453369, -0.01524353, -0.06561279, -0.056915283, 0.04220581, -0.058776855, 0.014839172, 0.021255493, -0.03387451, -0.044128418, 0.03326416, -0.011146545, -0.0178833, 0.014518738, 0.03274536, 0.020080566, -0.03286743, 0.008781433, -0.0013284683, -0.0010824203, -0.02835083, 0.020370483, -0.035186768, -0.01751709, -0.027069092, -0.052215576, 0.02015686, -0.035827637, -0.015655518, -0.03881836, 0.0064048767, 0.007888794, -0.010665894, -0.01235199, 0.03829956, -0.030517578, -0.03265381, -0.0030937195, 0.030441284, -0.06665039, 0.015960693, 0.05255127, 0.00087308884, -0.0051574707, 0.027191162, 0.00049829483, 0.0010604858, -0.006214142, -0.006538391, -0.025466919, 0.006690979, -0.022827148, 0.027328491, 0.0079956055, -0.02015686, 0.0029125214, -0.030319214, -0.012496948, 0.02923584, -0.011657715, -0.0055389404, -0.02407837, -0.032226562, -0.022415161, 0.004623413, 0.018554688, -0.017929077, 0.041229248, 0.08782959, 0.015594482, 0.029571533, 0.050323486, 0.024414062, -0.01424408, -0.025878906, -0.013519287, -0.014411926, -0.0014457703, 0.024597168, -0.010231018, -0.010864258, -0.007820129, -0.082214355, -0.0063285828, 0.020980835, 0.01499939, -0.034088135, 0.022079468, -0.043914795, -0.020492554, -0.023849487, -0.027069092, 0.01939392, 0.01965332, 0.0041389465, -0.0010070801, 0.033721924, -0.045715332, 0.007843018, -0.034423828, -0.08935547, 0.04525757, -0.0435791, -0.03567505, -0.009498596, 0.002822876, -0.03656006, -0.012329102, -0.040893555, 0.043304443, 0.009651184, 0.025299072, -0.017410278, -0.014778137, 0.0035076141, -0.03475952, 0.012306213, 0.0075912476, -0.050079346, 0.017410278, 0.012763977, 0.06390381, 0.066711426, -0.019241333, 0.011657715, 0.012123108, -0.0008687973, -0.003982544, 0.0038375854, -0.04714966, 0.017974854, 0.036956787, -0.037109375, -0.022766113, -0.026626587, 0.023071289, -0.062194824, 0.0079574585, -0.011054993, 0.054382324, -0.010826111, 0.02305603, -0.01751709, -0.0524292, -0.0087509155, -0.030334473, -0.053466797, 0.008346558, 0.024459839, 0.0051460266, -0.026779175, -0.011436462, -0.021072388, 0.011474609, 0.009353638, 0.031280518, -0.000101566315, -0.013381958, -0.005264282, 0.019226074, -0.010543823, -0.008422852, 0.018173218, 0.023803711, 0.008674622, -0.0017137527, 0.026062012, -0.051361084, 0.0045776367, 0.009254456, -0.08679199, 0.0075416565, 0.011230469, 0.011978149, 0.0231781, -0.025222778, 0.026412964, 0.011650085, -0.021713257, -0.030563354, -0.0067367554, -0.02709961, -0.0033092499, -0.056549072, -0.0053749084, 0.06222534, -0.0005350113, 0.035858154, 0.049194336, 0.01687622, -0.0234375, 0.0070533752, 0.005420685, -0.011024475, 0.026046753, -0.015403748, 0.020629883, 0.020629883, -0.015731812, 0.06689453, 0.0016107559, 0.014289856, 0.013664246, -0.0014677048, -0.042785645, -0.00111866, -0.0309906, 0.046447754, 0.020858765, 0.024887085, -0.08258057, 0.07495117, -0.011642456, -0.0008177757, 0.023162842, -0.021255493, -0.018615723, -0.011978149, 0.041534424, 0.037841797, 0.015991211, 0.0057640076, 0.021057129, -0.015037537, -0.011436462, -0.00868988, 0.025802612, 0.0059890747, 0.036315918, -0.0006814003, 0.0040512085, 0.038482666, 0.019882202, -0.008407593, -0.010261536, 0.0021018982, -0.02532959, -0.017288208, -0.04953003, -0.010009766, 0.0068969727, 0.007472992, -0.032562256, 0.019195557, 0.022018433, 0.0077705383, -0.042419434, 0.016464233, 0.028335571, 0.008071899, -0.01625061, -0.064575195, 0.028457642, -0.0051612854, -0.050567627, -0.04611206, -0.010658264, 0.036590576, 0.019485474, 0.014221191, -0.028305054, 0.0028934479, 0.032806396, 0.0927124, 0.061950684, 0.023010254, -0.05807495, 0.05215454, -0.010597229, -0.019683838, 0.016784668, -0.013114929, -0.004058838, -0.007980347, 0.028060913, -0.009536743, -0.004055023, 0.025680542, 0.024642944, -0.059295654, 0.06781006, -0.031188965, 0.054779053, 0.01096344, -0.022735596, 0.008811951, 0.0043563843, -0.06109619, 0.030563354, -0.008277893, 0.022064209, -0.06677246, 0.016021729, 0.00088500977, 0.002292633, -0.03086853, 0.0076141357, 0.05114746, -0.0023479462, -0.014564514, 0.011329651, 0.0006914139, -0.031677246, -0.03778076, 0.007858276, 0.0051078796, 0.043182373, -0.0038089752, 0.070739746, 0.020401001, -0.024002075, 0.014701843, 0.0032806396, 0.007873535, -0.017822266, -0.0018634796, -0.06274414, -0.081604004, -0.019317627, 0.08721924, -0.023071289, -0.0155181885, 0.011047363, 0.02671814, 0.015281677, 0.061340332, 0.09326172, 0.015037537, -0.023513794, -0.0053749084, 0.019729614, -0.030075073, -0.052246094, 0.017913818, -0.018692017, 0.021240234, -0.021621704, 0.038269043, -0.053222656, 0.010421753, -0.010215759, -0.0031986237, 0.0012750626, -0.07043457, -0.00083208084, 0.03604126, 0.014823914, 0.017288208, 0.0029792786, 0.039794922, 0.019180298, 0.01889038, 0.015960693, 0.0077819824, 0.025970459, -0.035858154, 0.041748047, 0.014884949, 0.019073486, -0.00014424324, 0.056610107, -0.009399414, 0.021759033, -0.045806885, 0.004272461, 0.024291992, 0.0357666, -0.018585205, -0.04083252, 0.009056091, 0.0033245087, 0.024337769, 0.018554688, -0.0077400208, -0.045013428, -0.0262146, 0.015266418, -0.032196045, -0.012329102, 0.009887695, -0.004043579, -0.08959961, -0.0390625, -0.054016113, 0.018981934, -0.0071029663, 0.029037476, -0.0262146, 0.03466797, 0.051971436, 0.011329651, 0.006877899, -0.00032877922, -0.011024475, 0.054473877, 0.062927246, -0.011993408, -0.0026760101, 0.02670288, -0.025741577, -0.036895752, -0.015975952, -0.021316528, -0.010437012, -0.027938843, -0.056732178, -0.027435303, -0.040405273, -0.0033626556, -0.020202637, -0.002111435, 0.004234314, -0.002614975, -0.017211914, -0.0003528595, 0.044403076, 0.03967285, -0.008255005, -0.028503418, 0.007030487, 0.02796936, -0.0063209534, -0.0010070801, 0.014076233, -0.026229858, 0.0044822693, 0.018814087, -0.0014190674, 0.010643005, 0.021362305, 0.03286743, 0.0074272156, 0.0034313202, 0.0020389557, 0.04107666, -0.020263672, 0.00034809113, -0.013320923, 0.011138916, 0.0012197495, 0.080200195, -0.038269043, -0.03289795, -0.039031982, -0.041046143, -0.03842163, -0.012191772, 0.04525757, 0.015136719, 0.044708252, -0.017547607, -0.021194458, -0.07470703, -0.012588501, -0.020965576, 0.0069084167, -0.017974854, -0.03591919, 0.05343628, -0.004261017, 0.046661377, -0.039489746, -0.019958496, -0.006298065, 0.029052734, -0.008705139, -0.06774902, 0.00056886673, -0.02331543, -0.022399902, 0.00033640862, 0.018325806, -0.015037537, 0.04397583, -0.08392334, 0.051483154, 0.0057678223, 0.009788513, 0.06689453, 0.035614014, -0.044830322, -0.013664246, -0.00042700768, -0.03729248, -0.034240723, -0.08105469, -0.013023376, -0.0335083, 0.00274086, -0.019989014, -0.028717041, 0.023834229, 0.0034236908, 0.011451721, -0.007637024, -0.007423401, 0.005332947, -0.00932312, -0.031036377, 0.023376465, 0.039733887, 0.009498596, 0.0057373047, -0.016998291, 0.01676941, 0.03286743, 0.008430481, 0.003227234, -0.013595581, -0.0052337646, -0.019378662, 0.012649536, 0.029006958, -0.019821167, 0.000103116035, -0.013145447, 0.029342651, -0.0013866425, 0.020431519, 0.04095459, 0.020492554, 0.0032615662, -0.017807007, -0.002374649, -0.06555176, -0.019805908, -0.02053833, -0.0076141357, -0.07421875, 0.011627197, -0.015350342, 0.0045280457, -0.033599854, 0.06976318, 0.002632141, -0.033996582, 0.04196167, 0.03286743, 0.0027980804, -0.019317627, 0.02696228, -0.017745972, -0.031433105, -0.003698349, 0.034423828, 0.0024814606, 0.027694702, 0.0137786865, 0.0031833649, 0.023834229, -0.02142334, 0.012512207, 0.037200928, 0.004508972, 0.018432617, -0.01235199, 0.053771973, -0.0619812, -0.037628174, 0.008453369, -0.027694702, -0.018249512, -0.06488037, 0.090270996, 0.027557373, 0.051452637, 0.07733154, 0.014305115, 0.005054474, 0.026275635, -0.039611816, 0.03616333, 0.032409668, -0.022872925, 0.012054443, -0.0098724365, -0.018356323, 0.061187744, -0.03677368, 0.04272461, -0.046844482, 0.004070282, -0.04360962, 0.0440979, 0.0057754517, -0.038269043, -0.049957275, -0.009338379, 0.0022621155, 0.019729614, 0.028701782, -0.00504303, 0.010879517, 0.04425049, 0.015434265, 0.08337402, 0.023803711, 0.02748108, -0.05419922, -0.021057129, 0.024215698, 0.043182373, 0.045135498, -0.0047340393, -0.021148682, -0.044799805, 0.015220642, -0.0034713745, -0.014312744, -0.01360321, 0.0005159378, -0.04675293, -0.011787415, -0.02470398, -0.005458832, -0.027252197, 0.048828125, -0.078552246, 0.055541992, -0.034179688, -0.014175415, -0.0072784424, -0.015029907, -0.024261475, 0.001458168, -0.035491943, -0.024002075, 0.020507812, -0.0035991669, 0.045715332, -0.0038719177, -0.035217285, 0.013153076, 0.026657104, 0.05618286, -0.0026626587, -0.02041626, -0.0005888939, 0.053466797, 0.050598145, -0.026824951, -0.035705566, 0.016082764, -0.015960693, -0.009239197, 0.0574646, -0.018295288, 0.0085372925, 0.032562256, 0.061706543, 0.000831604, -0.048736572, -0.028366089, -0.023986816, 0.008758545, 0.043273926, -0.003408432, -0.014595032, 0.022094727, -0.014839172, 0.031555176, 0.019561768, -0.000054597855, 0.034179688, -0.018218994, 0.06719971, -0.01675415, 0.018615723, -0.036346436, -0.028778076, 0.03894043, 0.041259766, -0.025772095, 0.030136108, -0.015823364, 0.064086914, -0.037200928, 0.01158905, 0.003921509, 0.011489868, 0.0035533905, 0.05441284, -0.024993896, 0.00793457, -0.017333984, 0.0050201416, 0.003484726, 0.0017604828, 0.0042152405, -0.0062332153, -0.012207031, -0.006752014, -0.04611206, 0.066711426, -0.030319214, 0.040527344, -0.013671875, 0.008613586, -0.0028305054, 0.00047683716, 0.0018787384, 0.022338867, 0.039764404, -0.009033203, -0.023635864, 0.047302246, 0.04647827, -0.007255554 ], "summary": [ 0.031066895, -0.021972656, 0.03591919, 0.0010766983, -0.03390503, -0.015670776, -0.013023376, -0.031677246, -0.018722534, 0.006942749, -0.025375366, 0.0073661804, -0.021820068, -0.023468018, 0.013381958, -0.046081543, 0.011352539, 0.029571533, 0.025238037, -0.01977539, -0.016708374, -0.011016846, 0.033447266, 0.0574646, 0.039886475, -0.018508911, -0.079711914, 0.029083252, 0.008476257, 0.014053345, 0.010520935, -0.019592285, -0.01285553, 0.003063202, 0.045166016, -0.012756348, 0.013000488, -0.00019443035, 0.014945984, 0.016067505, 0.013710022, -0.012184143, 0.033294678, -0.05822754, -0.010406494, 0.034729004, -0.015792847, -0.016647339, 0.022476196, 0.00894165, 0.0053100586, 0.033447266, -0.010276794, 0.053771973, -0.021606445, -0.03375244, -0.044769287, -0.004890442, 0.04751587, 0.0914917, 0.011405945, -0.053619385, -0.022857666, -0.107421875, 0.0062332153, -0.008590698, 0.017166138, 0.018493652, 0.02067566, -0.010391235, -0.012390137, 0.0038337708, -0.019256592, 0.038604736, -0.01108551, -0.025787354, 0.013793945, -0.004322052, 0.0096206665, 0.04244995, -0.010185242, -0.01574707, 0.0072784424, 0.0017242432, -0.02381897, 0.008308411, -0.0021038055, 0.0050086975, -0.0001937151, -0.033691406, -0.012062073, -0.0029144287, -0.0209198, 0.0046653748, -0.0138549805, -0.035949707, -0.010070801, -0.08105469, 0.05847168, 0.0025634766, 0.07849121, -0.06829834, 0.050689697, 0.012718201, -0.0027637482, 0.04248047, 0.047027588, 0.0001449585, 0.007648468, -0.011199951, -0.028762817, 0.024551392, -0.008773804, -0.016967773, -0.038360596, 0.03201294, 0.00894165, -0.016799927, -0.004383087, -0.011528015, -0.0047836304, 0.01991272, -0.008087158, 0.012969971, -0.001657486, 0.02217102, -0.0022296906, -0.025527954, 0.05166626, 0.022399902, -0.02848816, 0.01663208, -0.014892578, -0.053100586, -0.045288086, -0.018432617, 0.039886475, -0.001660347, 0.0028362274, -0.02949524, 0.0016489029, 0.021911621, 0.01083374, -0.015533447, -0.036102295, 0.008674622, 0.030731201, 0.0317688, -0.0368042, -0.05908203, 0.028320312, -0.0018672943, 0.00059843063, 0.0004515648, 0.024383545, -0.029907227, -0.052734375, 0.00021028519, 0.048431396, 0.02796936, 0.046051025, 0.027664185, -0.004550934, 0.037994385, 0.004611969, -0.04055786, -0.010055542, 0.01008606, -0.00003182888, 0.008377075, 0.017303467, -0.008560181, -0.08001709, -0.008468628, 0.01979065, 0.010124207, -0.019241333, 0.0152282715, 0.012611389, -0.020202637, 0.02558899, -0.011520386, 0.0026073456, 0.044067383, 0.04425049, -0.07598877, -0.009521484, -0.05621338, 0.030441284, 0.025970459, -0.031204224, 0.005344391, -0.030349731, -0.00299263, 0.0006136894, 0.02142334, -0.03665161, 0.009223938, -0.016921997, -0.029678345, 0.044677734, -0.0026340485, 0.011619568, -0.0031356812, -0.04159546, -0.027542114, 0.010765076, 0.0011882782, -0.009979248, 0.051940918, 0.008857727, -0.0041542053, 0.0013570786, -0.009147644, 0.014251709, -0.02281189, 0.03250122, -0.02859497, -0.012008667, -0.01939392, -0.044891357, 0.018798828, -0.075805664, 0.017990112, 0.019607544, -0.016830444, 0.00844574, -0.0039901733, 0.10076904, -0.0023880005, 0.09655762, -0.04800415, 0.028244019, 0.03942871, -0.0043678284, 0.009643555, 0.012786865, -0.02330017, 0.009986877, 0.023910522, 0.00881958, -0.026260376, -0.018096924, 0.06161499, -0.03842163, -0.04272461, -0.01134491, 0.04751587, -0.029464722, 0.0035438538, 0.027511597, 0.009216309, 0.016326904, -0.045654297, -0.015777588, 0.039398193, 0.026016235, -0.00075387955, -0.0019359589, 0.017974854, -0.001247406, 0.021270752, -0.018814087, 0.021728516, -0.023651123, 0.010314941, 0.0016593933, 0.0046539307, -0.008506775, -0.0038471222, 0.008041382, -0.020980835, -0.018814087, -0.03567505, -0.036621094, -0.03189087, -0.017807007, 0.039733887, 0.012329102, -0.05038452, 0.0043144226, 0.03189087, 0.0070610046, -0.0048332214, -0.009162903, 0.022872925, 0.011375427, 0.034973145, 0.088378906, 0.083984375, 0.08306885, 0.0050582886, -0.009178162, 0.047454834, 0.024017334, -0.03225708, 0.05871582, 0.057495117, -0.026931763, 0.016738892, -0.017288208, 0.013282776, -0.0010595322, -0.0017499924, 0.027023315, 0.009674072, 0.041503906, 0.01852417, 0.0053100586, 0.02142334, -0.06933594, -0.04135132, 0.0132751465, 0.032104492, -0.021224976, -0.028244019, 0.018127441, 0.01676941, -0.03540039, -0.045959473, 0.06738281, -0.04034424, 0.03668213, 0.015655518, -0.025131226, -0.06286621, 0.047851562, 0.00019276142, 0.0050201416, 0.021209717, -0.029754639, 0.0030593872, -0.036346436, -0.012779236, -0.016647339, 0.0028648376, -0.01727295, 0.0770874, -0.0023059845, -0.03741455, -0.026397705, -0.03353882, 0.004173279, -0.0066871643, -0.025848389, -0.068603516, -0.0073432922, 0.00023806095, 0.041931152, -0.025100708, 0.047180176, -0.0056266785, -0.035003662, 0.032226562, -0.0027885437, -0.020263672, 0.027145386, 0.043762207, -0.003616333, -0.018814087, 0.0068206787, 0.013771057, -0.02949524, -0.057678223, 0.009643555, -0.01612854, -0.019042969, -0.036346436, 0.045654297, 0.047790527, -0.062438965, 0.052703857, -0.0657959, 0.004928589, 0.045013428, 0.033325195, 0.037750244, -0.028701782, 0.007194519, 0.016098022, 0.020217896, 0.02180481, -0.023376465, 0.0020008087, 0.07775879, 0.012062073, 0.021362305, 0.054504395, 0.018051147, -0.0060195923, -0.0362854, -0.020523071, 0.016586304, -0.030166626, -0.024810791, 0.0048713684, -0.0033435822, -0.024276733, 0.007118225, -0.015151978, 0.005012512, 0.044036865, -0.0023880005, 0.026107788, -0.016067505, 0.05090332, -0.003376007, -0.014503479, 0.008529663, 0.023223877, 0.016357422, -0.05996704, 0.043426514, -0.08746338, 0.023971558, -0.03010559, 0.04714966, 0.03189087, -0.04977417, -0.08746338, -0.00655365, 0.046966553, 0.019500732, -0.028533936, 0.020904541, 0.007987976, 0.0069618225, -0.004501343, -0.05441284, -0.014778137, 0.024749756, -0.059417725, 0.020324707, 0.023651123, -0.07928467, 0.03579712, -0.00060749054, 0.030090332, 0.07904053, -0.059509277, -0.039245605, -0.009887695, -0.012496948, -0.016738892, -0.0154953, -0.014541626, 0.023651123, -0.020202637, 0.0101623535, -0.023986816, -0.026062012, -0.0031013489, -0.011703491, 0.022964478, -0.018966675, 0.09741211, -0.043701172, 0.038726807, 0.07305908, -0.06567383, -0.042114258, -0.03253174, -0.026901245, 0.022415161, -0.014854431, -0.0035190582, 0.013168335, 0.0317688, 0.011489868, -0.022567749, 0.01953125, 0.028320312, -0.015640259, -0.024551392, -0.032104492, -0.035339355, 0.05999756, 0.0020179749, 0.07318115, -0.04397583, 0.007671356, -0.0033245087, -0.020843506, -0.007865906, 0.0006213188, 0.002544403, -0.063964844, -0.0032577515, 0.007171631, 0.028533936, 0.048858643, 0.0050239563, 0.045410156, 0.04559326, -0.0016202927, -0.039215088, -0.0065078735, 0.016571045, -0.0062713623, -0.061950684, 0.0107421875, -0.00630188, 0.059783936, 0.041809082, 0.01461792, 0.017456055, -0.0026340485, 0.028137207, -0.0012493134, -0.022018433, 0.000992775, -0.030929565, 0.07348633, 0.046203613, -0.0076026917, 0.034454346, 0.006881714, 0.101257324, -0.042541504, -0.05203247, 0.024505615, 0.036499023, -0.037139893, 0.014793396, 0.05178833, 0.007888794, -0.060760498, 0.040740967, 0.002620697, 0.003238678, 0.014808655, 0.01600647, -0.045898438, -0.008979797, 0.04119873, -0.022079468, 0.01977539, 0.022018433, 0.02166748, -0.0058174133, -0.016403198, -0.01360321, 0.022247314, 0.003955841, 0.014411926, 0.03152466, 0.026626587, 0.059387207, -0.006149292, 0.010757446, -0.0025539398, -0.008483887, -0.001750946, -0.031707764, -0.041534424, 0.03137207, -0.0045394897, 0.017501831, 0.0052490234, -0.020019531, -0.009391785, -0.005382538, -0.02822876, 0.02885437, -0.032318115, 0.028778076, -0.056640625, -0.07287598, -0.0061683655, -0.011314392, -0.039916992, -0.041412354, -0.043762207, -0.022720337, -0.01966858, 0.017852783, -0.036621094, -0.012771606, 0.023223877, 0.083862305, 0.018722534, 0.031799316, -0.059661865, -0.058807373, -0.011772156, 0.015357971, -0.0005402565, 0.0010786057, -0.00068473816, 0.011039734, 0.022613525, -0.022537231, -0.023910522, 0.03564453, -0.00048065186, -0.0390625, 0.04449463, -0.000082194805, 0.08520508, 0.003660202, -0.0128479, 0.024612427, 0.011505127, -0.031402588, -0.005344391, 0.014221191, 0.0007071495, -0.051116943, 0.013114929, -0.01448822, 0.0061531067, -0.0071525574, -0.0050735474, 0.033477783, 0.0029907227, -0.047332764, 0.0034294128, 0.00969696, 0.022369385, -0.0066719055, 0.019058228, 0.011634827, 0.012290955, 0.015792847, -0.0033950806, -0.0023536682, -0.007904053, 0.030761719, 0.0066375732, -0.006679535, 0.021209717, -0.023788452, -0.050323486, -0.088378906, -0.038757324, 0.07635498, 0.0059051514, -0.034851074, 0.007534027, 0.03466797, 0.02003479, 0.025253296, 0.03781128, -0.039001465, 0.0032253265, -0.024978638, -0.00075387955, 0.019104004, -0.022262573, 0.011550903, -0.015945435, 0.015342712, -0.0074920654, 0.008285522, 0.0021820068, 0.03302002, 0.0016584396, -0.011703491, 0.021987915, -0.040527344, -0.06088257, 0.0035114288, -0.04171753, -0.0074539185, 0.009246826, 0.015296936, 0.037628174, 0.011245728, 0.008483887, 0.0023593903, -0.0062065125, -0.014671326, 0.030212402, 0.0030403137, -0.005844116, 0.04321289, 0.06237793, 0.0011415482, 0.029449463, -0.015174866, 0.0073127747, -0.005836487, 0.034729004, -0.060150146, 0.0022735596, 0.021331787, -0.0071907043, 0.015151978, 0.0029582977, -0.006134033, -0.059539795, -0.02508545, 0.008148193, -0.018859863, -0.02835083, -0.015602112, -0.0007686615, -0.06359863, -0.024795532, -0.042388916, 0.021606445, -0.025161743, 0.017532349, -0.022506714, 0.006877899, -0.0143966675, 0.0076522827, 0.027359009, 0.02357483, 0.0039596558, 0.016845703, 0.03704834, -0.043121338, -0.005256653, -0.015342712, -0.010757446, -0.019714355, 0.021026611, 0.0036087036, 0.00491333, -0.016052246, 0.019882202, -0.0066184998, -0.06524658, -0.007282257, -0.027542114, -0.020385742, 0.008880615, -0.0076179504, -0.011398315, 0.03375244, 0.0110321045, 0.033172607, 0.009254456, -0.029190063, 0.017242432, 0.04522705, -0.0022468567, 0.0060424805, 0.018692017, 0.022201538, -0.008766174, 0.031921387, -0.007873535, 0.0038604736, 0.017944336, 0.022323608, -0.029876709, 0.040252686, 0.007904053, 0.04397583, -0.004650116, 0.009407043, -0.0054626465, 0.026504517, 0.0047416687, 0.06112671, -0.0413208, -0.0033721924, -0.030395508, 0.0031909943, -0.014945984, -0.02255249, 0.043701172, -0.029663086, 0.052947998, 0.016555786, -0.033447266, 0.005138397, -0.023620605, 0.0035305023, 0.008010864, -0.002746582, -0.05105591, 0.055114746, -0.0022201538, 0.037750244, -0.03262329, -0.009460449, -0.0028266907, 0.019104004, 0.0074386597, -0.05569458, 0.0008854866, 0.0064048767, 0.015899658, -0.00011563301, -0.009819031, -0.0015649796, -0.022598267, -0.027572632, 0.037597656, 0.012634277, -0.023529053, -0.00415802, 0.0050811768, -0.0016384125, 0.00012409687, 0.04736328, -0.0042419434, 0.01423645, -0.053771973, -0.037475586, -0.041290283, -0.037628174, 0.0008940697, -0.018676758, 0.010101318, -0.062042236, 0.060943604, -0.038604736, -0.018127441, 0.037109375, -0.052215576, 0.057861328, -0.03390503, 0.03955078, -0.0037059784, -0.01058197, -0.032562256, 0.026062012, 0.04260254, 0.0025348663, 0.029251099, -0.0065307617, -0.0077705383, 0.03012085, -0.02003479, 0.0026664734, -0.009231567, 0.018661499, -0.01939392, 0.032104492, 0.0051193237, 0.049041748, 0.025100708, -0.00095558167, 0.03527832, -0.02557373, 0.012649536, 0.022064209, -0.035949707, 0.05130005, 0.032592773, -0.03463745, 0.010635376, 0.026672363, -0.031677246, -0.003929138, 0.08190918, -0.0046958923, 0.004070282, 0.053955078, 0.008056641, -0.013114929, 0.003112793, 0.027938843, -0.0041885376, -0.045959473, -0.02394104, 0.005126953, 0.027389526, 0.068237305, -0.0038967133, -0.0058670044, 0.01914978, 0.023513794, 0.0031261444, 0.04067993, 0.008903503, 0.020385742, -0.056030273, 0.024612427, -0.031707764, -0.034820557, 0.008071899, -0.009506226, -0.009651184, -0.017150879, 0.027709961, 0.021835327, 0.014328003, 0.015670776, -0.01411438, 0.0009393692, 0.0158844, -0.0008716583, 0.004245758, 0.029953003, -0.0076904297, 0.01361084, 0.0074539185, -0.00021219254, 0.027175903, -0.014701843, 0.0030879974, -0.048950195, -0.0000834465, -0.027801514, 0.014167786, -0.023071289, -0.010879517, -0.025680542, -0.056549072, 0.012542725, 0.05014038, 0.0892334, -0.021224976, 0.06921387, 0.042907715, -0.07543945, 0.08074951, 0.038024902, 0.07470703, -0.047607422, -0.012367249, 0.011306763, 0.038269043, 0.04937744, -0.009742737, -0.031158447, -0.02784729, 0.028961182, 0.007007599, -0.010383606, -0.008804321, 0.04434204, -0.023727417, -0.04083252, -0.011154175, -0.006591797, -0.021697998, 0.05407715, -0.007972717, 0.03112793, 0.004676819, -0.010726929, 0.020263672, 0.02835083, -0.026382446, 0.00053834915, 0.009857178, -0.033294678, -0.028411865, 0.01461792, -0.0024871826, -0.0021705627, -0.018157959, -0.068725586, 0.014793396, 0.011817932, 0.028045654, -0.03552246, 0.01234436, 0.020812988, 0.04067993, 0.0032196045, 0.020690918, 0.015151978, -0.030929565, -0.010002136, 0.0023155212, -0.028579712, -0.006210327, 0.008956909, 0.060668945, -0.004016876, -0.02519226, -0.05807495, -0.001578331, 0.03164673, 0.015731812, -0.016464233, -0.004676819, 0.031799316, -0.03213501, 0.0008907318, -0.020645142, 0.019302368, 0.0018396378, -0.028869629, 0.0011529922, -0.013793945, -0.044891357, -0.017211914, -0.025543213, 0.0143585205, -0.0019397736, 0.011146545, 0.0047836304, -0.025344849, 0.07751465, -0.012329102, 0.09185791, -0.029449463, -0.03012085, 0.040985107, -0.043121338, -0.0019454956, 0.053527832, 0.009025574, 0.026443481, 0.007183075, 0.031234741, 0.0011768341, 0.010673523, 0.01033783, -0.04751587, -0.036865234, 0.08721924, -0.028198242, 0.016906738, 0.014144897, 0.009010315, 0.06945801, 0.010429382, 0.026062012, -0.016967773, 0.04260254, 0.02116394, 0.013313293, 0.0039711, -0.022506714, 0.023208618 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2108.07879v1
Edge AI without Compromise: Efficient, Versatile and Accurate Neurocomputing in Resistive Random-Access Memory
Weier Wan, Rajkumar Kubendran, Clemens Schaefer, S. Burc Eryilmaz, Wenqiang Zhang, Dabin Wu, Stephen Deiss, Priyanka Raina, He Qian, Bin Gao, Siddharth Joshi, Huaqiang Wu, H. -S. Philip Wong, Gert Cauwenberghs
cs.AR, cs.AI, cs.ET, cs.LG
Realizing today's cloud-level artificial intelligence functionalities directly on devices distributed at the edge of the internet calls for edge hardware capable of processing multiple modalities of sensory data (e.g. video, audio) at unprecedented energy-efficiency. AI hardware architectures today cannot meet the demand due to a fundamental "memory wall": data movement between separate compute and memory units consumes large energy and incurs long latency. Resistive random-access memory (RRAM) based compute-in-memory (CIM) architectures promise to bring orders of magnitude energy-efficiency improvement by performing computation directly within memory. However, conventional approaches to CIM hardware design limit its functional flexibility necessary for processing diverse AI workloads, and must overcome hardware imperfections that degrade inference accuracy. Such trade-offs between efficiency, versatility and accuracy cannot be addressed by isolated improvements on any single level of the design. By co-optimizing across all hierarchies of the design from algorithms and architecture to circuits and devices, we present NeuRRAM - the first multimodal edge AI chip using RRAM CIM to simultaneously deliver a high degree of versatility for diverse model architectures, record energy-efficiency $5\times$ - $8\times$ better than prior art across various computational bit-precisions, and inference accuracy comparable to software models with 4-bit weights on all measured standard AI benchmarks including accuracy of 99.0% on MNIST and 85.7% on CIFAR-10 image classification, 84.7% accuracy on Google speech command recognition, and a 70% reduction in image reconstruction error on a Bayesian image recovery task. This work paves a way towards building highly efficient and reconfigurable edge AI hardware platforms for the more demanding and heterogeneous AI applications of the future.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2108.07879v1
"2021-08-17T21:08:51"
"2021-08-17T21:08:51"
{ "title": [ -0.03173828, -0.017745972, -0.016403198, -0.024871826, -0.006313324, -0.01625061, 0.014724731, -0.018157959, -0.003490448, 0.036193848, -0.017486572, 0.006164551, 0.0010213852, -0.027450562, -0.045135498, -0.0028591156, -0.013305664, 0.033813477, -0.016525269, -0.028442383, -0.016525269, -0.040405273, 0.05026245, 0.027832031, 0.016067505, -0.028762817, -0.07891846, -0.013587952, -0.026626587, -0.045013428, -0.019042969, 0.032928467, 0.038482666, 0.01499176, -0.0079193115, 0.013626099, -0.047943115, 0.026046753, 0.008972168, -0.009521484, 0.0127334595, 0.00121212, -0.024810791, -0.019332886, -0.03366089, 0.007446289, -0.050445557, 0.00094366074, 0.005329132, 0.020370483, 0.01626587, 0.046661377, -0.004322052, 0.035736084, 0.009925842, -0.0069084167, -0.026977539, 0.00073862076, 0.033233643, 0.070251465, 0.015548706, -0.034423828, 0.014266968, -0.031402588, -0.02859497, -0.02267456, -0.014625549, 0.037719727, 0.04849243, -0.0027980804, -0.006603241, 0.024276733, 0.0026474, 0.0019235611, -0.06628418, -0.009170532, 0.042938232, 0.001209259, 0.042755127, -0.0340271, -0.013946533, -0.017028809, 0.029022217, -0.027633667, -0.0041542053, -0.039398193, -0.0284729, 0.0059814453, -0.046295166, -0.044525146, -0.0093688965, -0.02722168, -0.023864746, -0.000644207, -0.01361084, -0.02609253, -0.016845703, -0.020492554, 0.022567749, 0.0034370422, 0.0102005005, -0.0040626526, 0.002380371, -0.011634827, 0.029510498, 0.020462036, -0.030822754, -0.04006958, 0.030319214, 0.025848389, -0.015716553, 0.022033691, 0.029708862, -0.008262634, -0.014480591, 0.000187397, 0.01965332, 0.013069153, 0.022247314, 0.032440186, -0.007297516, -0.045837402, 0.03265381, 0.014533997, 0.045806885, 0.02897644, -0.05569458, -0.0030841827, -0.007762909, 0.021911621, -0.008796692, 0.05203247, -0.07684326, -0.104003906, -0.074523926, 0.03765869, 0.008926392, 0.026565552, 0.0054626465, 0.0066452026, 0.05807495, -0.033081055, -0.034973145, 0.055511475, -0.010643005, 0.004173279, 0.057525635, -0.003124237, -0.040649414, -0.026351929, -0.028335571, -0.0035076141, -0.0034637451, 0.011238098, -0.018493652, 0.023269653, -0.12298584, 0.014259338, 0.019378662, 0.04550171, 0.052093506, 0.025405884, -0.008117676, 0.028121948, 0.054260254, -0.021270752, -0.03353882, 0.025390625, 0.00015926361, 0.009254456, -0.0099105835, -0.0035820007, -0.010429382, -0.021087646, -0.0027809143, 0.017074585, 0.023071289, -0.010658264, 0.021224976, 0.0057907104, 0.0049591064, -0.02217102, -0.008834839, 0.06530762, -0.05697632, 0.004760742, -0.0075912476, 0.0050621033, 0.062347412, -0.0030612946, -0.040740967, 0.014785767, -0.015213013, -0.05819702, -0.027359009, -0.020706177, 0.013633728, 0.009460449, -0.00831604, 0.034698486, -0.03717041, 0.0010137558, -0.042938232, 0.016189575, -0.023376465, -0.048675537, -0.009048462, 0.023208618, -0.02758789, 0.07171631, 0.03942871, 0.026901245, -0.02571106, -0.020263672, -0.0011816025, -0.04675293, 0.02557373, 0.0022830963, -0.014259338, -0.006793976, -0.018478394, -0.01448822, 0.01133728, 0.050994873, 0.023757935, 0.024032593, -0.0010814667, -0.023529053, 0.050689697, 0.03387451, 0.06976318, -0.040863037, 0.03878784, 0.045288086, -0.0016231537, -0.02720642, -0.01864624, -0.02079773, 0.014831543, 0.018127441, 0.015686035, -0.040618896, -0.006008148, -0.009056091, 0.062072754, -0.030639648, 0.0033664703, -0.0023174286, 0.03942871, 0.018859863, 0.06518555, 0.00046873093, 0.05633545, 0.020004272, 0.03137207, 0.04336548, 0.010375977, 0.02180481, -0.019348145, 0.011375427, -0.0039100647, 0.05255127, 0.01852417, 0.021102905, -0.052246094, 0.030838013, -0.0061836243, 0.018569946, -0.007194519, 0.011268616, 0.0463562, -0.029220581, 0.013710022, -0.015731812, -0.029251099, -0.022094727, -0.019622803, 0.020858765, 0.021774292, -0.05935669, -0.010856628, -0.00084495544, 0.04031372, 0.0033187866, 0.007709503, -0.016906738, 0.027053833, -0.008056641, -0.009750366, -0.00274086, 0.05923462, 0.019256592, 0.0050201416, -0.0037517548, -0.003211975, -0.006790161, 0.053131104, 0.07208252, -0.033721924, 0.03741455, -0.061035156, 0.011482239, 0.017318726, -0.039978027, 0.005760193, 0.0044021606, 0.0026187897, 0.012504578, -0.024932861, 0.005054474, -0.06878662, -0.017333984, 0.0137786865, -0.03543091, -0.0024223328, -0.03640747, -0.0048217773, -0.034332275, -0.053649902, -0.0178833, 0.056488037, 0.0005645752, -0.020248413, -0.03024292, 0.000025689602, -0.007949829, -0.041625977, -0.03253174, 0.026565552, 0.032073975, 0.036102295, 0.03375244, -0.041259766, -0.028778076, 0.0030937195, 0.0058174133, -0.013641357, 0.017364502, -0.03010559, -0.016937256, -0.005683899, -0.013626099, 0.0048332214, -0.038146973, 0.01083374, -0.046417236, 0.0057144165, 0.014556885, -0.05026245, 0.0038070679, 0.03869629, -0.02079773, -0.030670166, 0.029815674, 0.046569824, 0.00057792664, 0.00983429, 0.044311523, 0.026245117, -0.005176544, 0.03302002, -0.002500534, 0.004043579, -0.053771973, 0.011619568, -0.044769287, -0.030654907, -0.013473511, 0.0010633469, 0.04940796, -0.042999268, 0.006504059, -0.05783081, -0.021499634, -0.003211975, 0.0040779114, -0.0056877136, -0.02748108, -0.0395813, -0.024169922, -0.0050315857, 0.0068130493, 0.012458801, 0.0035934448, 0.07775879, -0.01449585, -0.03692627, 0.006088257, 0.026733398, 0.010147095, -0.006832123, -0.01802063, -0.017105103, -0.0021820068, 0.005115509, 0.00982666, -0.012840271, -0.027359009, -0.07562256, 0.00039052963, 0.06707764, -0.009384155, -0.04257202, 0.017562866, -0.060699463, 0.014450073, 0.0019817352, 0.0036525726, 0.021621704, 0.06185913, -0.0028381348, 0.0029716492, 0.028259277, -0.028823853, 0.023117065, -0.019058228, -0.13232422, 0.027572632, 0.0023384094, -0.023468018, -0.030792236, -0.01826477, -0.062561035, 0.011917114, -0.04144287, 0.029174805, 0.038513184, 0.039154053, 0.015426636, -0.010192871, 0.009963989, -0.03189087, -0.0028476715, -0.011116028, -0.020019531, -0.011199951, -0.025299072, 0.013511658, 0.012321472, -0.005531311, -0.0048675537, -0.00038409233, 0.018920898, 0.043792725, -0.00058841705, -0.022720337, 0.0009994507, 0.0048561096, -0.027511597, -0.030853271, 0.0019426346, 0.007270813, -0.014274597, 0.014884949, -0.005569458, 0.030929565, 0.02999878, 0.028640747, -0.029174805, -0.019836426, -0.0015993118, -0.035339355, -0.023345947, 0.010658264, 0.025054932, 0.009361267, 0.010505676, -0.004535675, -0.030456543, 0.032073975, -0.015144348, 0.0051879883, 0.029083252, -0.009689331, -0.022354126, -0.0032577515, -0.0073051453, -0.0010433197, -0.034698486, -0.020965576, 0.009773254, -0.011932373, -0.02029419, -0.015991211, 0.021377563, -0.0038490295, -0.068359375, -0.022903442, -0.002040863, -0.028137207, -0.025299072, -0.038909912, 0.023849487, -0.021713257, -0.032196045, -0.0040512085, -0.010299683, -0.026351929, 0.0042877197, -0.047332764, -0.0309906, 0.07531738, -0.025466919, 0.012313843, 0.023040771, -0.0011835098, -0.0019006729, 0.002571106, 0.010314941, 0.004421234, 0.045318604, 0.0033893585, 0.00945282, 0.044555664, -0.031982422, 0.007865906, 0.035736084, 0.020126343, -0.015197754, 0.0009446144, 0.0069770813, 0.03805542, -0.071777344, 0.061462402, 0.040161133, -0.019165039, -0.1048584, 0.0061531067, -0.0027923584, -0.05316162, 0.021072388, -0.028900146, 0.013824463, 0.035064697, 0.008155823, 0.07501221, -0.004085541, 0.012756348, 0.027008057, -0.040496826, -0.0025081635, 0.03086853, 0.028869629, -0.025283813, 0.0037975311, 0.0059432983, 0.0042800903, 0.046417236, -0.019927979, -0.023208618, 0.0009627342, 0.007911682, -0.033050537, -0.021255493, -0.05606079, -0.018096924, 0.0014629364, 0.0079193115, -0.019989014, 0.0074768066, 0.030303955, -0.0079574585, -0.025726318, -0.00541687, 0.03414917, -0.0043792725, 0.0069007874, -0.04244995, 0.0021324158, -0.0074882507, -0.06463623, -0.04373169, 0.008743286, 0.002943039, 0.006969452, -0.013916016, -0.029815674, 0.021499634, 0.0034103394, 0.07928467, 0.033843994, -0.012420654, -0.05947876, 0.020446777, -0.019577026, -0.03704834, 0.008300781, 0.013809204, -0.023849487, -0.061645508, 0.002544403, -0.007217407, -0.001709938, -0.05569458, 0.019607544, 0.0073509216, 0.039916992, -0.008613586, 0.0025901794, 0.015686035, 0.018249512, 0.0074768066, 0.0010814667, -0.040924072, -0.03652954, -0.003921509, 0.061065674, -0.04272461, 0.03250122, 0.044677734, 0.0039978027, -0.01574707, 0.0025539398, 0.053344727, 0.03652954, -0.046417236, -0.017578125, 0.021270752, -0.03945923, -0.039794922, -0.005302429, 0.004863739, 0.037719727, -0.04925537, 0.03503418, -0.0395813, -0.004020691, 0.013801575, -0.011764526, 0.005832672, -0.016540527, 0.021057129, -0.05606079, -0.09106445, -0.041778564, 0.074401855, -0.021057129, -0.0015926361, 0.011001587, 0.023742676, 0.02658081, 0.03866577, 0.019851685, -0.033172607, 0.0024471283, -0.023269653, -0.023223877, -0.01222229, -0.040618896, 0.000023663044, 0.0013589859, 0.023498535, -0.049072266, 0.016036987, -0.04623413, -0.00084495544, 0.0072250366, 0.010108948, 0.0031471252, -0.06573486, 0.018356323, 0.0625, 0.020233154, 0.005420685, 0.035980225, 0.017990112, 0.025100708, 0.038391113, 0.009765625, 0.025421143, 0.019592285, -0.021957397, 0.014625549, 0.012954712, 0.036834717, 0.022521973, 0.020828247, 0.012397766, -0.0035743713, -0.038879395, 0.009902954, 0.008132935, 0.020889282, 0.046051025, -0.06945801, -0.005836487, 0.014442444, -0.009231567, 0.0031814575, -0.048858643, -0.0154953, 0.039764404, -0.03805542, 0.0001475811, 0.025894165, -0.017501831, -0.015960693, -0.066467285, 0.0067443848, -0.0074386597, 0.0132751465, -0.011276245, 0.020690918, -0.041748047, 0.03753662, 0.02357483, -0.06463623, -0.022247314, -0.007835388, 0.00762558, 0.032592773, 0.03111267, -0.03652954, 0.0022468567, -0.023376465, -0.044708252, -0.039642334, -0.0019493103, -0.0019130707, 0.012573242, 0.004058838, -0.0005297661, 0.004272461, -0.019973755, 0.007221222, 0.010307312, -0.008857727, 0.045715332, 0.0047721863, 0.002035141, 0.019058228, 0.08154297, -0.0184021, -0.0004029274, 0.023925781, -0.025009155, 0.014167786, -0.0087509155, -0.0010719299, -0.0104522705, -0.07281494, 0.016204834, 0.03074646, 0.024398804, -0.004211426, -0.011505127, 0.030776978, -0.019439697, 0.006008148, -0.0020980835, 0.0859375, -0.057250977, -0.005130768, -0.03640747, -0.011238098, -0.072265625, 0.04360962, 0.027709961, 0.005657196, -0.0513916, -0.042755127, -0.03173828, -0.0029697418, 0.038909912, 0.024002075, 0.054992676, -0.06359863, -0.026000977, -0.022506714, -0.007637024, -0.05041504, 0.008491516, -0.004070282, 0.015266418, 0.019592285, 0.015472412, -0.009277344, -0.022781372, 0.02168274, -0.00092983246, -0.0024356842, 0.012741089, 0.00070667267, 0.0008649826, -0.046447754, -0.012268066, 0.042053223, 0.04663086, -0.05441284, 0.0413208, -0.021377563, 0.06262207, 0.035003662, 0.026870728, 0.07348633, 0.01890564, -0.008743286, -0.0025959015, -0.007472992, -0.034576416, -0.0058403015, -0.05029297, -0.010879517, -0.051208496, -0.0085372925, -0.03189087, 0.0031757355, 0.00762558, 0.06097412, -0.01838684, 0.039978027, 0.02230835, -0.012763977, 0.061553955, -0.04196167, 0.09210205, 0.012954712, 0.002861023, 0.007396698, 0.009422302, 0.013641357, 0.023071289, -0.0007324219, 0.044036865, 0.0012559891, -0.014198303, 0.026275635, -0.0037269592, 0.015640259, -0.03741455, -0.028366089, -0.02935791, 0.06341553, 0.023849487, 0.045410156, 0.025939941, 0.056121826, -0.028213501, 0.007633209, -0.015930176, -0.0003964901, -0.0126953125, 0.0038108826, 0.057922363, -0.050567627, 0.035705566, -0.015075684, -0.04916382, -0.046722412, 0.022491455, 0.02532959, -0.04989624, -0.035461426, 0.029907227, 0.03503418, 0.0018501282, 0.011711121, -0.036376953, -0.0043258667, 0.049102783, 0.025390625, -0.015457153, 0.00050354004, 0.032989502, 0.016296387, -0.0066604614, -0.011581421, -0.0008735657, 0.04977417, -0.018005371, 0.02168274, -0.04815674, 0.06317139, 0.00022637844, -0.03845215, 0.03656006, 0.00024700165, -0.05593872, -0.007972717, 0.040008545, 0.0491333, 0.02810669, 0.071899414, 0.013824463, -0.020690918, 0.008293152, -0.028778076, 0.018661499, 0.03866577, -0.040649414, 0.028503418, -0.029052734, -0.035369873, 0.030075073, -0.04824829, 0.06298828, -0.03253174, 0.0050811768, -0.028381348, 0.042633057, 0.017318726, -0.030303955, -0.01776123, -0.019195557, -0.028671265, -0.017700195, 0.021911621, 0.015853882, -0.0152282715, -0.0038375854, 0.03036499, 0.015068054, -0.0066604614, 0.0037784576, -0.033477783, -0.054260254, 0.0012044907, -0.018005371, 0.017578125, -0.011260986, -0.008590698, 0.009315491, -0.0000150203705, -0.015945435, -0.036590576, -0.02458191, 0.006439209, -0.0037956238, -0.019821167, 0.027069092, 0.028640747, -0.015449524, 0.02078247, -0.10461426, 0.04043579, -0.031066895, 0.020019531, 0.048675537, -0.032989502, -0.045928955, 0.02192688, -0.05154419, 0.050079346, 0.014831543, 0.00052785873, -0.004787445, 0.03665161, -0.024841309, -0.0059661865, 0.012321472, 0.060546875, -0.008285522, -0.031707764, -0.020889282, 0.067871094, 0.0513916, -0.05630493, -0.033416748, 0.006641388, 0.033050537, -0.018341064, 0.061920166, 0.0037403107, 0.027999878, 0.009590149, 0.05999756, 0.00630188, -0.072387695, -0.025054932, -0.035614014, 0.037872314, 0.049743652, -0.0146865845, -0.02067566, 0.02619934, 0.004989624, 0.013076782, 0.011833191, -0.008163452, 0.008163452, -0.01902771, 0.011878967, -0.008544922, -0.025390625, -0.01651001, -0.0010766983, 0.010017395, 0.035003662, -0.04144287, 0.025131226, -0.010032654, 0.040863037, 0.010353088, -0.05001831, 0.070251465, 0.049346924, 0.016357422, 0.02520752, -0.023483276, -0.04107666, -0.021713257, -0.0101623535, -0.009498596, -0.008270264, 0.041656494, -0.019165039, 0.016677856, -0.0032463074, -0.064819336, 0.027389526, -0.03579712, 0.018615723, -0.053588867, 0.046295166, -0.05142212, 0.002243042, -0.007045746, 0.028823853, 0.033477783, 0.008911133, -0.05517578, -0.044403076, 0.038116455, -0.029800415 ], "summary": [ -0.016220093, -0.018447876, 0.0104904175, -0.010108948, -0.03074646, 0.0027675629, 0.0008330345, -0.011352539, 0.02684021, 0.012954712, -0.068359375, 0.011764526, 0.012145996, -0.01020813, 0.0055389404, -0.0158844, -0.0037288666, 0.009422302, -0.007621765, -0.028823853, 0.0036315918, -0.034362793, 0.013908386, -0.005367279, 0.028244019, -0.028366089, -0.04864502, 0.008361816, 0.021469116, 0.007171631, 0.005382538, 0.01058197, 0.044677734, 0.00065612793, -0.024017334, 0.004459381, -0.039489746, 0.004924774, -0.0008621216, -0.0021209717, 0.018341064, 0.0021953583, 0.026535034, -0.08026123, 0.0068588257, 0.015853882, -0.0011339188, -0.018035889, 0.0340271, -0.028198242, 0.0073394775, 0.023880005, 0.016311646, -0.05029297, -0.022949219, -0.0055007935, -0.04043579, -0.0022296906, 0.0038070679, 0.042053223, 0.017089844, 0.0058670044, 0.0016031265, -0.016677856, 0.023101807, -0.023422241, 0.045715332, 0.016967773, 0.0067863464, -0.0017776489, 0.010269165, 0.01928711, 0.010185242, -0.062927246, 0.0032482147, 0.046173096, 0.0069084167, 0.004837036, -0.012481689, -0.013153076, -0.03353882, 0.016113281, 0.025421143, -0.049835205, -0.004081726, -0.041931152, -0.03213501, 0.013175964, -0.06274414, -0.0070228577, -0.038330078, -0.023849487, -0.07952881, 0.015281677, 0.02619934, -0.009384155, -0.026351929, -0.076049805, 0.06933594, 0.037078857, 0.032287598, -0.072631836, 0.07965088, -0.004863739, 0.01096344, 0.00818634, -0.018600464, -0.06817627, 0.021240234, 0.02835083, -0.026245117, 0.038330078, 0.0016937256, -0.06100464, -0.024810791, 0.05895996, 0.05529785, 0.011672974, 0.025466919, 0.032989502, -0.012939453, -0.01210022, 0.009559631, 0.07336426, 0.029083252, 0.06707764, 0.016296387, -0.033996582, 0.021514893, 0.013580322, -0.002286911, 0.029129028, 0.0011529922, -0.054534912, -0.06365967, -0.019577026, 0.024520874, 0.007904053, 0.0069999695, -0.031341553, 0.10675049, -0.0012102127, -0.05407715, 0.07446289, 0.0012950897, 0.051635742, 0.025161743, -0.025726318, -0.005695343, -0.02999878, -0.007144928, -0.049560547, -0.004508972, -0.010879517, 0.008552551, -0.00049877167, -0.055145264, 0.01449585, 0.01701355, 0.042877197, 0.06695557, 0.029907227, 0.015594482, 0.0970459, 0.052581787, -0.026290894, -0.02671814, -0.005924225, 0.022598267, -0.018753052, -0.019317627, -0.030960083, 0.017288208, -0.0039978027, -0.0023727417, 0.028717041, 0.029281616, -0.0071907043, -0.005970001, 0.035583496, -0.0064888, -0.03262329, 0.0034713745, 0.008117676, -0.022201538, 0.01852417, -0.002128601, 0.05596924, 0.035736084, 0.021057129, -0.016082764, -0.010353088, -0.0009570122, -0.001748085, -0.047546387, -0.030380249, -0.004032135, 0.018844604, -0.050354004, 0.03262329, 0.066467285, -0.005718231, -0.026062012, -0.025177002, -0.09576416, -0.040222168, -0.006801605, 0.0028877258, -0.033081055, 0.025360107, 0.018341064, -0.008743286, -0.027252197, 0.01184082, -0.0021457672, -0.043395996, 0.0073127747, 0.020599365, -0.01411438, -0.0022621155, -0.027374268, -0.018920898, -0.013473511, 0.061401367, 0.023895264, 0.0056266785, -0.021362305, -0.001953125, 0.06323242, 0.007347107, 0.043945312, -0.002714157, 0.023086548, 0.045318604, -0.00029468536, -0.005279541, 0.0000538826, -0.054534912, 0.015136719, 0.044799805, 0.026000977, 0.001004219, -0.04714966, -0.025161743, 0.020721436, -0.0357666, -0.0035800934, 0.002450943, 0.045440674, 0.011558533, 0.015281677, -0.053741455, 0.050445557, -0.01210022, 0.029037476, 0.006374359, 0.034942627, 0.05316162, -0.017852783, 0.010269165, 0.0023021698, 0.049682617, -0.008171082, 0.038726807, -0.046905518, 0.007499695, 0.007850647, 0.021011353, -0.009346008, -0.029464722, 0.03668213, 0.034240723, 0.002483368, -0.035003662, -0.032440186, -0.03463745, -0.027755737, 0.032958984, 0.014060974, -0.046173096, -0.0072288513, -0.030761719, -0.039489746, -0.0009403229, 0.032440186, -0.017654419, 0.008972168, 0.040802002, -0.007007599, 0.03265381, 0.0473938, 0.024307251, -0.012001038, 0.007030487, -0.023422241, -0.010620117, 0.026107788, 0.038024902, -0.00095176697, 0.0014438629, -0.019378662, 0.021652222, -0.014198303, -0.0032863617, 0.0016641617, -0.016067505, -0.0018749237, 0.0073890686, 0.006477356, -0.009422302, -0.04324341, 0.0052833557, 0.010673523, 0.00029850006, 0.0014181137, -0.01953125, 0.0017700195, 0.018218994, -0.042053223, -0.008918762, 0.03842163, 0.02545166, 0.0025939941, 0.005580902, 0.009437561, -0.029815674, 0.018157959, -0.034240723, 0.03451538, 0.0061149597, 0.0020446777, 0.018814087, 0.004878998, -0.0051879883, 0.019058228, -0.022537231, 0.018371582, -0.019607544, 0.0119018555, -0.0073928833, 0.040893555, 0.009361267, -0.024795532, -0.014427185, -0.059265137, 0.017547607, 0.026519775, -0.010261536, -0.0395813, 0.014465332, 0.013389587, -0.012107849, -0.023773193, 0.0016241074, 0.0070648193, 0.0032348633, 0.034362793, 0.015686035, 0.012832642, -0.037261963, -0.0020561218, -0.012191772, -0.033172607, -0.045837402, 0.033172607, -0.0079193115, -0.015853882, -0.032989502, 0.00030231476, 0.026504517, 0.05102539, 0.013938904, -0.06378174, -0.0385437, -0.043273926, -0.024505615, 0.07183838, -0.00504303, -0.009376526, 0.05166626, 0.029769897, 0.022354126, 0.013366699, -0.016998291, 0.055755615, -0.009590149, 0.037109375, 0.024963379, 0.05014038, -0.0047798157, 0.0026016235, -0.018035889, 0.016098022, -0.023544312, -0.013412476, 0.0052223206, -0.021896362, -0.011909485, -0.0127334595, -0.011421204, 0.027633667, 0.0073165894, -0.031173706, 0.009277344, -0.006855011, 0.030960083, 0.030258179, -0.021377563, 0.008773804, 0.026824951, -0.024536133, -0.0053634644, -0.012863159, -0.024459839, 0.005996704, 0.0025978088, -0.04458618, 0.0013132095, 0.027679443, -0.005420685, -0.06500244, 0.08483887, -0.064208984, 0.012313843, -0.019973755, 0.038635254, 0.02154541, 0.03668213, 0.0055732727, -0.00579834, 0.01890564, -0.040618896, 0.020935059, 0.055267334, -0.022521973, 0.036132812, -0.019363403, -0.064819336, 0.0496521, -0.07287598, -0.050720215, -0.0043792725, 0.038513184, 0.01739502, 0.007575989, -0.01096344, -0.0115356445, -0.014007568, -0.012008667, -0.01687622, -0.0024356842, 0.0032215118, 0.046783447, 0.03466797, -0.0005645752, 0.061523438, 0.007904053, 0.037322998, 0.006881714, -0.013328552, -0.0206604, -0.020248413, 0.024856567, 0.0039711, 0.021499634, 0.03918457, -0.06982422, 0.016937256, -0.04534912, 0.016571045, 0.01361084, 0.0002732277, 0.04864502, -0.02519226, -0.016540527, -0.08166504, 0.020217896, -0.003118515, 0.022857666, -0.054656982, -0.017120361, 0.005756378, -0.035003662, 0.011695862, 0.038726807, -0.018127441, -0.00047779083, 0.006099701, -0.004070282, -0.0036945343, -0.0010690689, -0.03314209, 0.039886475, -0.020706177, -0.018981934, -0.0021476746, 0.006175995, -0.0056114197, 0.028640747, -0.014961243, -0.012275696, 0.010467529, -0.051635742, -0.018585205, -0.048553467, 0.044830322, 0.052581787, 0.001493454, 0.005596161, -0.07220459, 0.050872803, -0.055603027, 0.018920898, 0.0021705627, -0.01235199, 0.018722534, 0.022399902, -0.0043907166, 0.0033092499, -0.0057907104, 0.062561035, 0.058288574, -0.0335083, 0.014228821, 0.041107178, -0.0178833, -0.04034424, -0.018234253, -0.040405273, -0.064697266, 0.021316528, 0.04333496, 0.00009268522, 0.03668213, 0.0020389557, 0.021362305, -0.023223877, 0.007572174, -0.0060577393, -0.050872803, -0.010368347, 0.054107666, 0.037139893, -0.00198555, -0.019500732, 0.02003479, -0.0046157837, 0.06304932, 0.009895325, -0.00806427, 0.024963379, 0.0028705597, -0.037231445, -0.05883789, -0.02722168, 0.03164673, 0.024963379, -0.0011672974, -0.028656006, 0.0014228821, -0.0061950684, -0.036468506, 0.042999268, -0.004245758, 0.059295654, 0.03314209, -0.0072135925, -0.06201172, -0.024856567, 0.00084257126, -0.06274414, -0.006679535, 0.0009121895, -0.03491211, -0.015434265, -0.033081055, -0.023330688, 0.03515625, 0.00039815903, 0.051208496, 0.019607544, 0.014694214, -0.050872803, 0.020767212, 0.0059051514, -0.010955811, 0.0115737915, -0.004634857, -0.010177612, -0.033966064, -0.006351471, -0.004776001, -0.014518738, -0.036346436, 0.0057411194, 0.016418457, 0.0009832382, 0.00737381, 0.013084412, 0.0067329407, 0.018630981, 0.0037574768, 0.0049476624, -0.012825012, -0.026245117, -0.005207062, 0.020629883, -0.01687622, 0.021377563, 0.028915405, 0.0051994324, -0.05722046, 0.022384644, 0.036346436, 0.024993896, -0.029388428, -0.033477783, 0.040924072, 0.015945435, -0.035491943, 0.019470215, -0.00005763769, -0.003271103, 0.034057617, -0.016799927, -0.013206482, 0.0044670105, 0.020492554, -0.009101868, 0.017288208, 0.022064209, 0.0030975342, -0.06878662, -0.08880615, -0.045196533, 0.05557251, 0.013679504, -0.024795532, 0.04574585, 0.003206253, 0.014045715, -0.0057792664, -0.04449463, -0.026565552, 0.044158936, -0.0026454926, -0.014976501, 0.043395996, -0.005355835, -0.0024356842, -0.005794525, 0.007621765, 0.0033016205, -0.038208008, 0.010185242, -0.011665344, -0.021957397, 0.010658264, -0.0065574646, -0.031677246, -0.051208496, 0.0012559891, -0.00047302246, -0.014923096, 0.064941406, -0.042816162, -0.020431519, -0.01008606, -0.030654907, 0.009918213, -0.037841797, -0.06628418, -0.041931152, -0.023132324, 0.019317627, 0.013771057, -0.013832092, 0.036499023, -0.015701294, -0.036315918, -0.005050659, -0.0059814453, 0.017822266, -0.012184143, -0.007904053, 0.0102005005, 0.014060974, 0.0074424744, 0.004875183, 0.004924774, -0.0013465881, 0.026977539, -0.00554657, 0.00995636, 0.004814148, 0.01852417, 0.04574585, 0.009002686, -0.052764893, -0.031555176, 0.06201172, 0.017105103, -0.018066406, 0.0043029785, 0.002878189, 0.0047302246, -0.039642334, -0.016342163, 0.005504608, 0.019302368, -0.021743774, 0.009925842, -0.04159546, -0.00605011, -0.046203613, -0.031951904, -0.06390381, -0.020812988, 0.012825012, 0.051635742, 0.019424438, 0.0019493103, 0.014472961, -0.0124053955, 0.023132324, -0.039794922, 0.014976501, 0.029174805, 0.0020370483, 0.016418457, 0.031280518, 0.04135132, 0.03817749, -0.011543274, -0.0052604675, -0.044647217, -0.011222839, -0.024032593, 0.003025055, -0.0068244934, -0.044281006, -0.0006284714, 0.020889282, 0.043640137, 0.005756378, -0.054260254, 0.004310608, -0.035949707, 0.0104904175, -0.024398804, 0.09136963, -0.025314331, 0.020767212, -0.04058838, 0.0007138252, -0.08068848, -0.009750366, 0.005065918, 0.03353882, -0.02658081, -0.045043945, -0.01259613, -0.044555664, 0.011802673, 0.025222778, 0.029418945, -0.011306763, -0.018997192, 0.066101074, -0.03994751, -0.017807007, -0.02027893, 0.02835083, 0.039886475, 0.06951904, 0.015655518, -0.01675415, 0.01499176, 0.021209717, -0.026016235, -0.0048561096, 0.023406982, 0.07080078, 0.022766113, -0.03793335, 0.053619385, 0.01360321, 0.07470703, -0.030380249, -0.007801056, 0.03152466, 0.01876831, 0.029006958, -0.026184082, 0.01991272, 0.001499176, -0.0012311935, -0.00920105, -0.04788208, -0.017089844, -0.01096344, -0.01878357, -0.05758667, -0.030044556, -0.022232056, 0.034240723, 0.03439331, -0.027557373, 0.01373291, 0.0034542084, 0.02406311, 0.030075073, -0.012969971, -0.011329651, -0.0826416, 0.028701782, 0.03491211, 0.004501343, 0.027450562, 0.0082092285, -0.01991272, 0.021652222, -0.01876831, 0.06768799, 0.046783447, 0.0129776, 0.01876831, -0.019241333, 0.0049972534, -0.07122803, 0.014694214, -0.0211792, 0.07824707, 0.05923462, 0.09698486, -0.0057144165, -0.01991272, -0.002275467, -0.0028438568, -0.019683838, 0.03387451, -0.017410278, 0.04309082, 0.038726807, 0.019378662, 0.018936157, -0.00046396255, -0.05432129, 0.024124146, -0.0024986267, 0.047729492, -0.046783447, -0.03845215, 0.034729004, 0.023620605, -0.033966064, 0.011627197, -0.029251099, -0.013244629, 0.0647583, 0.027114868, -0.038848877, -0.04498291, 0.007911682, -0.011672974, 0.042816162, 0.0063667297, 0.015914917, 0.051483154, 0.022521973, 0.027648926, -0.022750854, 0.0574646, 0.0061416626, -0.014579773, 0.04119873, 0.009422302, -0.032073975, 0.030593872, 0.057769775, 0.10333252, 0.056854248, 0.04324341, -0.037963867, 0.010955811, 0.090270996, -0.0051879883, 0.009246826, 0.05130005, 0.012382507, -0.039215088, -0.026687622, -0.0014095306, -0.049194336, 0.029190063, 0.029693604, -0.031219482, 0.027542114, -0.03970337, 0.026062012, -0.051574707, -0.027359009, 0.043518066, -0.023757935, -0.06781006, 0.027648926, 0.0793457, -0.01234436, -0.010383606, -0.021347046, -0.0154418945, -0.013130188, -0.010009766, 0.03652954, -0.025405884, 0.0047454834, -0.0102005005, 0.004436493, 0.013000488, 0.003704071, -0.014595032, 0.028900146, 0.016113281, -0.010879517, -0.042755127, -0.0011520386, 0.018692017, -0.010322571, -0.0054893494, -0.0054092407, 0.011390686, -0.015388489, 0.003522873, -0.09436035, 0.042266846, -0.038360596, 0.02192688, 0.05670166, -0.011413574, -0.01574707, 0.0231781, -0.008659363, 0.05529785, -0.014289856, 0.013587952, -0.034454346, 0.06628418, -0.045806885, -0.0056877136, 0.011299133, 0.05029297, -0.019699097, -0.017837524, -0.008857727, 0.025939941, 0.03186035, -0.023422241, -0.03262329, 0.014694214, 0.016494751, -0.019882202, -0.021987915, 0.04348755, 0.06652832, 0.0019483566, 0.039764404, -0.011177063, -0.10180664, 0.0073623657, -0.0022125244, 0.01309967, 0.01109314, -0.008491516, -0.009292603, 0.024276733, -0.029006958, -0.018554688, 0.002702713, -0.00037884712, -0.043640137, -0.007843018, -0.027801514, -0.036102295, -0.028533936, 0.044952393, -0.011734009, 0.00065231323, 0.014755249, -0.030426025, 0.0031871796, -0.0158844, -0.033325195, 0.0143585205, -0.06225586, 0.011756897, 0.03161621, 0.0048179626, -0.015022278, -0.011146545, -0.061157227, -0.035369873, -0.0036945343, 0.008529663, -0.012832642, 0.0039100647, -0.046569824, 0.0099105835, -0.009796143, -0.055389404, 0.0030784607, -0.024414062, -0.017608643, -0.049926758, 0.04840088, -0.00044059753, -0.0069007874, 0.0026454926, 0.04095459, 0.031402588, 0.03579712, -0.0068588257, -0.035949707, 0.010231018, -0.016799927 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2108.09187v3
Quantization Backdoors to Deep Learning Commercial Frameworks
Hua Ma, Huming Qiu, Yansong Gao, Zhi Zhang, Alsharif Abuadbba, Minhui Xue, Anmin Fu, Zhang Jiliang, Said Al-Sarawi, Derek Abbott
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Currently, there is a burgeoning demand for deploying deep learning (DL) models on ubiquitous edge Internet of Things (IoT) devices attributed to their low latency and high privacy preservation. However, DL models are often large in size and require large-scale computation, which prevents them from being placed directly onto IoT devices, where resources are constrained and 32-bit floating-point (float-32) operations are unavailable. Commercial framework (i.e., a set of toolkits) empowered model quantization is a pragmatic solution that enables DL deployment on mobile devices and embedded systems by effortlessly post-quantizing a large high-precision model (e.g., float-32) into a small low-precision model (e.g., int-8) while retaining the model inference accuracy. However, their usability might be threatened by security vulnerabilities. This work reveals that the standard quantization toolkits can be abused to activate a backdoor. We demonstrate that a full-precision backdoored model which does not have any backdoor effect in the presence of a trigger -- as the backdoor is dormant -- can be activated by the default i) TensorFlow-Lite (TFLite) quantization, the only product-ready quantization framework to date, and ii) the beta released PyTorch Mobile framework. When each of the float-32 models is converted into an int-8 format model through the standard TFLite or Pytorch Mobile framework's post-training quantization, the backdoor is activated in the quantized model, which shows a stable attack success rate close to 100% upon inputs with the trigger, while it behaves normally upon non-trigger inputs. This work highlights that a stealthy security threat occurs when an end user utilizes the on-device post-training model quantization frameworks, informing security researchers of cross-platform overhaul of DL models post quantization even if these models pass front-end backdoor inspections.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2108.09187v3
"2023-04-27T06:08:27"
"2021-08-20T14:08:23"
{ "title": [ -0.022476196, 0.021530151, -0.02607727, -0.004917145, -0.007850647, -0.031188965, -0.007472992, -0.04208374, -0.0446167, 0.053253174, 0.006034851, -0.0018377304, -0.015007019, -0.037963867, -0.02545166, -0.0045318604, 0.022644043, 0.0048217773, 0.0041160583, -0.018722534, -0.017868042, -0.0042686462, 0.056518555, 0.016799927, 0.009239197, -0.031555176, -0.03878784, 0.0047836304, -0.0016012192, -0.030792236, 0.007858276, 0.020080566, 0.044403076, 0.04711914, -0.036621094, 0.044525146, -0.06738281, 0.05227661, 0.009086609, -0.031311035, -0.008758545, 0.024459839, -0.002544403, -0.00894928, -0.038482666, 0.012641907, -0.06536865, 0.0015563965, -0.017990112, 0.025360107, 0.012481689, 0.018249512, -0.004497528, 0.07598877, 0.010307312, -0.030853271, -0.014755249, -0.01083374, 0.033599854, 0.07531738, 0.0028972626, -0.032348633, 0.018051147, -0.06085205, -0.00072336197, -0.030212402, -0.04196167, 0.037872314, 0.04046631, 0.01108551, -0.0018548965, 0.0010633469, 0.0096206665, -0.012786865, -0.027999878, -0.030899048, 0.04647827, 0.019256592, 0.012886047, -0.022369385, 0.0017900467, -0.05316162, -0.027175903, -0.011985779, 0.028442383, 0.009681702, -0.006839752, -0.009681702, -0.013618469, -0.032684326, -0.007583618, -0.003452301, -0.010566711, 0.024246216, -0.01612854, -0.01953125, -0.015281677, 0.0096588135, 0.029708862, -0.0105896, -0.023376465, -0.0069351196, -0.021102905, -0.017669678, 0.020828247, 0.012046814, -0.007972717, -0.013053894, 0.018234253, 0.028686523, -0.0211792, 0.04425049, -0.020324707, -0.024520874, -0.0053138733, 0.004310608, -0.017211914, -0.00008833408, 0.019165039, 0.0065078735, 0.0068130493, -0.018371582, 0.03439331, 0.0053482056, 0.036468506, 0.022399902, -0.054351807, -0.0048675537, -0.010925293, 0.033813477, -0.014129639, 0.04425049, -0.11456299, -0.07800293, -0.057006836, 0.016799927, 0.002653122, -0.004337311, -0.010772705, 0.00076293945, 0.01965332, -0.04748535, -0.014640808, 0.04562378, -0.03805542, 0.011436462, 0.052093506, -0.006427765, -0.052978516, -0.057525635, -0.050689697, 0.0023040771, 0.0037975311, 0.029006958, -0.03250122, 0.035125732, -0.04827881, -0.017074585, 0.016052246, 0.0013799667, 0.03363037, 0.0015573502, -0.016357422, 0.047027588, 0.06713867, 0.002521515, 0.018539429, 0.030288696, -0.005756378, 0.05130005, -0.016418457, -0.0057525635, -0.026138306, -0.029678345, -0.019058228, -0.004196167, 0.0009946823, 0.059906006, 0.014663696, 0.0013284683, 0.019485474, -0.025619507, 0.04736328, 0.03881836, -0.041229248, -0.034820557, -0.0013341904, 0.018814087, 0.041046143, 0.030014038, -0.03692627, -0.006290436, -0.060943604, -0.0070724487, -0.07269287, 0.016189575, 0.031311035, 0.056671143, -0.020141602, 0.024154663, -0.050842285, 0.04196167, -0.04321289, 0.015670776, 0.011123657, -0.009277344, 0.00039052963, 0.023117065, -0.07116699, 0.07336426, 0.06903076, 0.015625, -0.026901245, -0.021743774, 0.023864746, -0.06304932, -0.023025513, -0.021774292, -0.007850647, -0.01940918, -0.011260986, -0.0018596649, 0.0066986084, 0.0357666, 0.007194519, 0.041809082, -0.009399414, 0.0027446747, 0.068237305, 0.033294678, 0.113220215, -0.05029297, 0.009208679, -0.0013933182, -0.04534912, -0.026168823, -0.009483337, 0.012138367, 0.027526855, 0.04458618, 0.009414673, -0.03491211, -0.00071668625, 0.0090408325, 0.073791504, 0.030914307, 0.014381409, -0.01398468, 0.035827637, 0.03591919, 0.037506104, 0.009895325, 0.053649902, -0.0051651, 0.013626099, 0.064453125, 0.004722595, 0.028152466, -0.027908325, 0.011108398, -0.013320923, 0.03677368, 0.023635864, 0.017929077, -0.03741455, -0.009155273, -0.030014038, 0.0048103333, -0.018356323, 0.00856781, 0.03338623, -0.03765869, 0.0023822784, -0.029403687, 0.014213562, -0.04425049, -0.018035889, 0.018432617, 0.029418945, -0.06048584, -0.0069351196, -0.011497498, 0.037902832, 0.01625061, 0.026229858, -0.034057617, 0.03225708, 0.01776123, -0.055541992, -0.033325195, 0.037994385, 0.039367676, 0.008041382, -0.004020691, -0.0037288666, 0.008613586, 0.03527832, 0.062042236, -0.041381836, 0.018417358, -0.047058105, 0.014511108, 0.015319824, -0.018661499, 0.005859375, 0.047027588, 0.032684326, -0.022857666, -0.025268555, 0.03869629, -0.06161499, 0.023620605, -0.008148193, -0.024536133, -0.061950684, -0.06933594, -0.046173096, -0.04864502, -0.0947876, -0.024597168, 0.07385254, 0.019989014, -0.010665894, -0.03060913, 0.018981934, -0.051116943, -0.025146484, -0.022033691, -0.0146102905, 0.025787354, 0.025970459, 0.01701355, -0.04547119, -0.047424316, 0.0079422, 0.02268982, 0.010925293, 0.007835388, -0.009864807, -0.03387451, 0.019836426, -0.03274536, -0.003856659, -0.0017232895, -0.004425049, -0.03173828, 0.00024294853, -0.008003235, -0.025405884, 0.00078964233, 0.033050537, -0.0138168335, -0.035736084, -0.025848389, 0.013221741, -0.00046277046, 0.021881104, -0.028884888, 0.027130127, -0.03945923, 0.033050537, 0.005016327, 0.0040283203, -0.050628662, -0.00541687, -0.052764893, -0.013938904, -0.006843567, 0.01828003, 0.06317139, -0.066711426, -0.00013518333, -0.010322571, 0.023330688, 0.028015137, 0.020324707, -0.03253174, -0.06341553, -0.0039367676, -0.02734375, 0.008033752, 0.03048706, -0.008087158, 0.03277588, 0.045715332, -0.026809692, -0.052978516, 0.010536194, 0.022659302, 0.021652222, 0.0003452301, -0.0065612793, -0.013183594, 0.0053253174, 0.040863037, 0.010658264, -0.022247314, -0.0053596497, -0.09552002, -0.005722046, 0.054534912, -0.0026187897, -0.02810669, 0.026397705, -0.049560547, -0.028244019, 0.02973938, -0.017333984, 0.012901306, 0.066345215, -0.0010433197, -0.025253296, 0.030654907, -0.035491943, 0.04916382, -0.036102295, -0.08898926, 0.023452759, -0.0060424805, 0.002664566, -0.0015830994, -0.006816864, -0.02217102, 0.0020446777, -0.0211792, 0.022705078, 0.018829346, 0.0045814514, 0.045166016, 0.020980835, 0.014137268, -0.0023994446, -0.0057029724, -0.0004916191, -0.01449585, 0.01109314, -0.033233643, 0.020904541, 0.012298584, -0.003873825, -0.033081055, -0.010543823, 0.012138367, 0.024810791, 0.0151901245, -0.031021118, -0.014389038, -0.033172607, 0.019317627, 0.01084137, -0.0059394836, -0.010566711, -0.035003662, -0.00793457, -0.04864502, 0.046813965, -0.004009247, 0.020477295, -0.010398865, 0.021850586, 0.026565552, -0.0050964355, -0.021514893, 0.00041794777, 0.020385742, -0.010925293, 0.031311035, -0.001958847, -0.013038635, 0.013336182, -0.01071167, -0.0129470825, -0.02142334, -0.022064209, 0.025268555, -0.022415161, -0.039978027, 0.030929565, -0.029846191, -0.0009794235, -0.003993988, 0.0061531067, 0.0040130615, -0.026290894, -0.0065307617, 0.027404785, -0.051239014, -0.010444641, 0.026000977, -0.052581787, -0.043518066, -0.06524658, 0.027328491, -0.06768799, -0.02885437, 0.0062446594, -0.014297485, -0.0015506744, -0.008850098, -0.07067871, -0.030975342, 0.051483154, -0.015701294, 0.0131073, 0.009864807, -0.016464233, -0.036468506, -0.018875122, 0.030853271, -0.03074646, 0.030944824, -0.027633667, -0.006752014, 0.023880005, -0.028915405, 0.029647827, 0.015701294, 0.0079422, 0.007358551, -0.00040125847, 0.011581421, 0.026504517, -0.03945923, 0.053527832, 0.03970337, -0.022918701, -0.08514404, -0.00028586388, -0.015533447, -0.04699707, 0.007507324, -0.01713562, 0.03616333, 0.045074463, 0.0023498535, 0.07910156, -0.014083862, 0.013725281, 0.02810669, -0.019332886, -0.04156494, -0.04916382, 0.010894775, -0.004753113, -0.01398468, 0.0015439987, 0.00037932396, 0.035217285, -0.0017347336, -0.04034424, 0.03152466, 0.03375244, -0.0071258545, -0.009353638, -0.044647217, 0.0070762634, 0.0045204163, 0.0067977905, -0.023864746, -0.0027828217, 0.025421143, -0.0005235672, -0.020965576, -0.0060195923, 0.034576416, 0.0025672913, 0.003440857, -0.056427002, 0.014015198, -0.018829346, -0.060333252, -0.045318604, 0.023117065, -0.0048065186, 0.031311035, -0.025970459, -0.027450562, 0.014022827, 0.010749817, 0.040924072, 0.028381348, 0.012878418, -0.029769897, 0.018432617, -0.018127441, -0.025741577, 0.0076446533, -0.0077590942, -0.0059509277, -0.052520752, -0.018508911, -0.008666992, -0.0040779114, -0.0357666, 0.036346436, 0.001914978, 0.024917603, -0.015235901, 0.03378296, 0.02659607, 0.029296875, 0.0032653809, 0.0049819946, -0.021392822, -0.015296936, 0.019470215, 0.051879883, 0.014465332, 0.026473999, 0.072265625, 0.011169434, -0.029724121, -0.032104492, 0.031463623, 0.019989014, -0.00044727325, 0.046569824, -0.018951416, -0.05355835, -0.0071372986, 0.013076782, -0.019195557, 0.06616211, -0.047027588, 0.031234741, -0.027893066, 0.027297974, 0.024215698, -0.0021533966, 0.012619019, -0.008743286, 0.027908325, -0.040985107, -0.022644043, 0.002822876, 0.03616333, -0.021759033, -0.019897461, -0.00025868416, 0.03768921, 0.004623413, 0.043548584, 0.035888672, 0.024459839, 0.0070724487, -0.0075302124, 0.028030396, -0.016906738, -0.04324341, -0.016708374, -0.024429321, 0.012954712, -0.011352539, 0.018493652, -0.03817749, -0.022033691, -0.0053977966, 0.012298584, 0.031036377, -0.047180176, 0.004135132, 0.07244873, -0.00083494186, 0.008514404, 0.011634827, -0.02355957, 0.049743652, 0.03152466, -0.009635925, 0.007270813, 0.036834717, -0.041259766, 0.042938232, 0.022354126, 0.041168213, -0.008399963, 0.01574707, 0.0023326874, 0.00080919266, -0.04269409, 0.028060913, 0.037017822, 0.001625061, 0.030136108, -0.054107666, 0.038024902, 0.0065193176, -0.0113220215, 0.013191223, -0.06427002, -0.02368164, 0.031066895, -0.046844482, -0.0048103333, 0.044036865, 0.011383057, -0.005569458, -0.05142212, 0.061584473, -0.01789856, 0.05609131, -0.020126343, -0.033996582, -0.04574585, 0.03414917, 0.028121948, -0.07122803, -0.0018930435, -0.026885986, 0.018722534, 0.028930664, 0.032470703, -0.046875, -0.0015649796, 0.0014390945, -0.075683594, -0.052581787, -0.012184143, -0.009628296, -0.0034389496, -0.013717651, -0.0368042, 0.0026817322, -0.0056533813, 0.016937256, -0.0061149597, -0.029846191, 0.003030777, -0.00064992905, -0.006954193, -0.010032654, 0.062561035, -0.0034561157, 0.005744934, 0.016662598, -0.00026488304, 0.010261536, 0.00073194504, 0.0068626404, -0.032440186, -0.023422241, 0.0006828308, 0.026123047, 0.017822266, 0.023651123, 0.020248413, 0.04650879, -0.0016889572, -0.00843811, 0.043426514, 0.0637207, -0.064697266, -0.014060974, -0.0070648193, -0.0008430481, -0.01852417, 0.051696777, -0.0056152344, -0.016479492, -0.038085938, -0.072021484, -0.037719727, 0.013320923, 0.045196533, 0.011131287, 0.051757812, -0.020935059, 0.015022278, -0.03555298, 0.0021591187, -0.010673523, 0.040649414, -0.03643799, -0.027053833, 0.009902954, -0.00831604, -0.020736694, -0.022140503, 0.04119873, 0.056396484, 0.010948181, 0.0007019043, -0.044433594, -0.02458191, -0.02720642, -0.00548172, 0.028152466, 0.019546509, -0.02885437, 0.0034446716, -0.028152466, 0.064208984, 0.021987915, 0.04748535, 0.03878784, 0.005088806, 0.012557983, -0.005847931, -0.0059280396, -0.02772522, 0.011726379, -0.044799805, -0.0090408325, -0.047180176, -0.01411438, -0.103637695, 0.009506226, 0.008628845, 0.049041748, 0.0030937195, 0.016830444, 0.018814087, -0.02029419, 0.018341064, -0.031280518, 0.06890869, 0.051635742, 0.006679535, 0.019363403, -0.039489746, -0.0014038086, 0.034851074, 0.008163452, 0.01737976, 0.051513672, -0.021270752, 0.023071289, 0.013343811, 0.025238037, -0.013809204, -0.00504303, -0.0032253265, 0.013122559, -0.026992798, 0.01133728, 0.06964111, 0.0317688, -0.011550903, -0.037322998, -0.0014829636, 0.014198303, -0.050811768, 0.033325195, 0.05419922, -0.070495605, 0.038024902, -0.020996094, -0.04309082, -0.016845703, 0.017150879, 0.020767212, -0.009391785, -0.014533997, 0.006095886, 0.028564453, 0.032287598, 0.016082764, -0.028579712, -0.020904541, 0.039733887, 0.02357483, -0.023803711, 0.014579773, 0.018737793, 0.028701782, -0.002199173, 0.0017538071, 0.013465881, 0.0138549805, 0.011459351, 0.018951416, -0.034698486, 0.060028076, -0.0056915283, -0.0446167, 0.045013428, 0.01210022, -0.03591919, 0.006713867, 0.040008545, 0.04446411, 0.050323486, 0.06237793, 0.0061950684, -0.017059326, 0.03274536, -0.013725281, 0.04928589, 0.03253174, -0.043060303, 0.009666443, -0.00013613701, -0.015563965, 0.050476074, -0.0052948, 0.08270264, -0.0011510849, 0.037353516, -0.02142334, 0.0027618408, 0.03237915, -0.059509277, -0.007575989, -0.0022945404, 0.02267456, -0.018432617, -0.010414124, -0.04321289, -0.027832031, -0.0109939575, 0.057525635, 0.010246277, 0.005706787, 0.043884277, -0.046905518, -0.032714844, 0.026931763, -0.0068855286, 0.056884766, -0.03137207, -0.029006958, -0.023330688, -0.008178711, 0.033966064, -0.013313293, -0.024353027, -0.023208618, -0.033599854, -0.007789612, 0.013504028, 0.0075912476, -0.027999878, -0.03265381, -0.015388489, 0.0052490234, -0.027252197, 0.024414062, 0.038238525, -0.029159546, -0.034210205, 0.014801025, -0.03817749, 0.048034668, 0.012252808, -0.012916565, 0.02330017, 0.0072746277, -0.008407593, -0.0011663437, 0.03149414, 0.061401367, 0.0035114288, -0.053863525, -0.00027608871, 0.038604736, 0.055664062, -0.036132812, -0.011421204, 0.008331299, 0.032104492, -0.004272461, 0.040252686, 0.01727295, 0.0033493042, -0.017745972, 0.039215088, -0.014450073, -0.017044067, -0.040649414, -0.014137268, 0.06726074, 0.028381348, -0.017349243, -0.027282715, 0.000374794, 0.020126343, 0.0055999756, 0.024093628, -0.012916565, 0.008010864, 0.0035915375, 0.04034424, -0.0057868958, -0.028778076, -0.008331299, 0.020370483, -0.0039978027, 0.034729004, -0.011657715, 0.008422852, 0.011741638, 0.07989502, -0.036254883, -0.06738281, 0.060302734, 0.037994385, -0.0038909912, 0.058776855, 0.0071487427, -0.026412964, -0.008033752, 0.018630981, -0.008300781, 0.02897644, 0.028762817, 0.017059326, 0.018432617, -0.02142334, -0.060272217, -0.015266418, -0.030166626, 0.03918457, -0.05230713, 0.028396606, -0.028884888, -0.0070381165, -0.0068969727, 0.0115737915, -0.040863037, -0.015281677, -0.08135986, -0.049224854, 0.01939392, -0.020553589 ], "summary": [ -0.022094727, 0.01348114, -0.031463623, 0.034057617, -0.026062012, -0.028457642, -0.020248413, -0.053131104, -0.05496216, 0.03152466, 0.019607544, 0.024108887, -0.01953125, -0.03390503, 0.0119018555, -0.017150879, 0.010025024, 0.0015993118, 0.012184143, -0.028289795, 0.03353882, -0.0024929047, 0.018066406, -0.00844574, 0.004009247, -0.009117126, -0.018539429, 0.004547119, 0.003490448, 0.00062942505, 0.018554688, -0.00026369095, 0.049987793, 0.040924072, -0.0597229, 0.008010864, -0.062469482, 0.04144287, -0.0048980713, -0.016082764, 0.031463623, -0.0024261475, 0.05480957, -0.019485474, -0.008766174, 0.039367676, -0.002904892, -0.020309448, 0.04446411, 0.012359619, -0.0031642914, 0.023361206, -0.021591187, 0.017303467, -0.019454956, -0.016998291, -0.03363037, -0.032165527, 0.020080566, 0.11444092, 0.04486084, -0.01600647, -0.03062439, -0.09448242, 0.03729248, -0.0184021, -0.0047569275, 0.039794922, 0.03652954, 0.028686523, 0.0031757355, 0.0013494492, 0.023864746, -0.035247803, -0.018844604, 0.020019531, 0.04864502, 0.039123535, -0.014770508, -0.02720642, 0.025039673, -0.036468506, -0.016525269, 0.0012283325, 0.029052734, 0.02243042, 0.004257202, -0.026351929, 0.013160706, 0.012390137, 0.002664566, 0.0020484924, 0.015449524, 0.043762207, 0.002658844, -0.020462036, -0.040252686, -0.04840088, 0.03213501, 0.021087646, 0.037872314, -0.04043579, 0.0259552, -0.007675171, -0.0041122437, 0.06323242, 0.011192322, -0.016998291, -0.005279541, -0.005382538, -0.0069122314, -0.008636475, -0.04055786, -0.058258057, -0.0022907257, 0.03164673, -0.02659607, 0.0052337646, 0.02067566, -0.03289795, -0.008392334, 0.0068473816, 0.03591919, 0.003704071, 0.037384033, 0.040924072, 0.004863739, -0.037963867, 0.028167725, 0.010665894, 0.0007138252, 0.021850586, -0.079589844, -0.048461914, -0.055114746, 0.003047943, 0.011238098, 0.0016498566, 0.021194458, -0.01360321, 0.036254883, -0.029891968, -0.0113220215, 0.048095703, 0.010528564, 0.06329346, 0.038513184, -0.025756836, -0.01348114, -0.036621094, -0.014945984, 0.009590149, 0.033203125, 0.018569946, -0.026641846, -0.002632141, 0.01777649, -0.023330688, -0.02230835, -0.04876709, 0.036376953, 0.01083374, -0.0016441345, 0.06585693, 0.022338867, -0.0129852295, 0.024810791, 0.0066566467, 0.017974854, 0.057769775, 0.010261536, -0.031951904, -0.0087890625, -0.0026664734, -0.019485474, -0.004623413, -0.028457642, 0.08483887, 0.021987915, -0.072631836, -0.011726379, -0.03555298, 0.101989746, -0.008735657, 0.005329132, -0.03781128, -0.006362915, 0.023895264, 0.042297363, 0.027267456, -0.059295654, -0.034057617, -0.0446167, 0.043640137, -0.035736084, -0.011451721, -0.016113281, 0.019363403, -0.028518677, -0.012802124, 0.009399414, 0.042785645, -0.044555664, -0.0066833496, -0.06903076, 0.030838013, -0.011253357, 0.03363037, -0.050598145, 0.028060913, 0.030212402, 0.004825592, -0.0463562, 0.008399963, 0.034820557, 0.00868988, 0.0035915375, 0.0049209595, 0.007881165, -0.02357483, -0.012062073, -0.00057792664, -0.02116394, 0.02331543, -0.009971619, 0.01322937, -0.0059127808, 0.009033203, 0.07556152, 0.016021729, 0.10253906, -0.05303955, -0.025299072, -0.04348755, -0.049621582, -0.015052795, -0.019119263, -0.06311035, 0.024932861, 0.07336426, 0.014389038, -0.003622055, -0.049713135, -0.030853271, 0.041381836, 0.014434814, 0.005405426, -0.0051193237, 0.020950317, 0.030899048, -0.020706177, -0.040985107, 0.036834717, -0.06732178, -0.015838623, 0.03729248, -0.0048675537, -0.002527237, -0.020095825, -0.012466431, 0.03427124, 0.006416321, -0.03591919, 0.017791748, 0.0015745163, -0.071777344, 0.001294136, -0.008399963, 0.013343811, -0.058258057, 0.016601562, -0.02432251, 0.007133484, -0.029174805, -0.013755798, -0.058410645, -0.008102417, 0.011169434, 0.015396118, -0.04336548, -0.0071525574, -0.021560669, -0.010261536, -0.00088500977, 0.039978027, -0.021469116, 0.014175415, 0.02772522, 0.0023288727, 0.039031982, 0.041290283, 0.04550171, 0.024932861, 0.009498596, -0.008026123, 0.013404846, 0.011802673, 0.016326904, 0.0011749268, -0.0007171631, -0.008094788, 0.032806396, 0.0033435822, -0.0019741058, 0.008834839, 0.02949524, 0.06604004, -0.047821045, -0.01461792, 0.03149414, -0.047424316, 0.025924683, 0.030151367, 0.03543091, -0.024734497, -0.0491333, -0.029129028, 0.04248047, -0.028945923, 0.03817749, 0.09527588, 0.001291275, 0.037506104, -0.015792847, 0.005832672, -0.07208252, -0.0007123947, -0.01449585, -0.03161621, 0.036895752, 0.03253174, 0.03564453, 0.01259613, 0.0039482117, 0.006832123, -0.00097227097, 0.0060768127, 0.012413025, -0.010322571, -0.007446289, 0.036315918, -0.05331421, 0.013191223, 0.032226562, -0.053741455, 0.0045776367, -0.0017690659, 0.0036334991, -0.037109375, -0.007911682, 0.03366089, -0.01763916, -0.015838623, -0.024139404, 0.0019483566, 0.019012451, -0.0062217712, -0.036102295, 0.005207062, -0.072265625, 0.010818481, 0.02973938, 0.0027503967, -0.02003479, -0.03942871, -0.02696228, -0.0002989769, 0.023788452, 0.033416748, 0.0357666, 0.0013818741, 0.029937744, -0.08441162, -0.00027632713, 0.029067993, 0.021224976, 0.04522705, -0.028137207, -0.007247925, 0.009979248, 0.005207062, 0.024597168, -0.017211914, 0.015640259, 0.06842041, -0.016021729, -0.009666443, -0.018035889, 0.08087158, 0.02229309, 0.038879395, -0.014877319, -0.015853882, -0.023208618, 0.037963867, 0.005508423, -0.009292603, -0.0022144318, -0.04650879, -0.043121338, 0.037078857, -0.020843506, -0.014556885, -0.0012512207, 0.015312195, -0.01763916, 0.066711426, -0.012001038, 0.008987427, 0.024429321, 0.02267456, -0.045806885, 0.02961731, -0.045715332, 0.032073975, -0.03161621, 0.016448975, 0.0016803741, 0.02633667, -0.04345703, -0.017349243, 0.03390503, 0.00687027, 0.018417358, -0.010604858, 0.00029420853, 0.023223877, 0.0069351196, 0.008644104, 0.041656494, 0.018356323, -0.014678955, 0.026290894, 0.03010559, -0.063964844, 0.012962341, 0.003856659, 0.010971069, 0.0703125, -0.07342529, -0.040802002, 0.00095939636, 0.018600464, 0.026657104, 0.020233154, -0.01751709, -0.019424438, -0.030334473, 0.047729492, -0.017303467, 0.015205383, -0.032196045, 0.05230713, 0.014053345, -0.014137268, 0.10797119, -0.02960205, 0.02178955, 0.06402588, 0.004966736, 0.015022278, 0.013786316, -0.044708252, 0.019882202, 0.050750732, 0.008872986, -0.010856628, 0.010070801, -0.025238037, 0.03729248, 0.030822754, -0.05505371, -0.0054359436, -0.010520935, 0.023147583, 0.002603531, -0.008705139, -0.010864258, 0.0037975311, 0.005760193, -0.06518555, 0.04107666, -0.025039673, -0.038848877, -0.036346436, 0.024139404, -0.038208008, -0.038513184, 0.026290894, 0.026794434, 0.017654419, -0.0435791, 0.06100464, -0.030471802, -0.0028247833, 0.024887085, -0.015464783, 0.057617188, 0.0038795471, -0.06738281, 0.044555664, -0.007385254, -0.020401001, 0.02659607, -0.034240723, 0.024520874, 0.0051231384, -0.008255005, 0.011985779, -0.06512451, 0.0005083084, -0.04650879, -0.0071907043, -0.006313324, -0.013595581, 0.04663086, -0.01826477, 0.0064086914, 0.0005555153, 0.0025310516, 0.014564514, 0.041870117, -0.02180481, 0.015235901, 0.024154663, -0.02394104, -0.036071777, 0.02468872, 0.009231567, -0.02861023, 0.012886047, 0.004005432, 0.0060768127, 0.030075073, 0.01512146, 0.015716553, 0.008293152, 0.0035076141, 0.001543045, 0.0012159348, -0.017623901, -0.020721436, 0.010383606, 0.005962372, -0.022598267, 0.03050232, -0.020889282, 0.045837402, -0.01828003, 0.004890442, -0.01235199, -0.011184692, -0.004173279, -0.0592041, -0.062561035, 0.113342285, 0.032287598, -0.0012350082, -0.011222839, -0.013008118, 0.030303955, -0.009384155, -0.009399414, 0.01576233, 0.051696777, 0.017425537, -0.037994385, -0.10131836, 0.014587402, -0.01979065, -0.01876831, -0.027908325, 0.0078048706, 0.0030288696, 0.010604858, -0.020401001, 0.0021476746, 0.032836914, 0.0015792847, -0.017211914, 0.013053894, 0.0044136047, -0.009925842, 0.027008057, 0.020477295, -0.027160645, 0.008659363, -0.017745972, 0.024475098, -0.009094238, -0.017288208, -0.013908386, 0.012817383, -0.031341553, 0.00869751, -0.016021729, 0.02407837, -0.046417236, -0.01838684, 0.008102417, 0.01499176, 0.008972168, 0.0008172989, 0.008270264, 0.01322937, 0.016235352, 0.025924683, 0.05130005, 0.0010643005, 0.025772095, 0.014877319, 0.016052246, -0.040863037, 0.018341064, -0.03387451, -0.005821228, 0.009269714, -0.02218628, 0.033599854, -0.0061950684, 0.03744507, 0.028198242, 0.023712158, 0.049316406, 0.015655518, -0.026672363, 0.013931274, -0.006099701, -0.00969696, 0.027435303, -0.0068359375, 0.025177002, -0.038146973, -0.027526855, 0.009109497, 0.04397583, -0.024215698, -0.024963379, -0.019821167, -0.016326904, 0.017745972, 0.046813965, 0.027618408, -0.03149414, 0.0317688, 0.013046265, 0.0013418198, -0.0063667297, -0.016235352, -0.017837524, -0.012969971, 0.012878418, 0.040771484, -0.014297485, -0.023590088, 0.009460449, -0.01576233, 0.039276123, -0.029724121, -0.03945923, -0.07727051, -0.025497437, 0.033325195, -0.058380127, 0.034820557, -0.027435303, 0.022506714, 0.026367188, -0.02456665, -0.0019187927, 0.00050878525, -0.018676758, 0.035949707, -0.004676819, 0.0072631836, 0.00308609, -0.010848999, -0.00094795227, -0.018936157, -0.008125305, 0.00390625, -0.025619507, -0.03024292, -0.00047135353, 0.011207581, 0.05303955, 0.023651123, -0.010375977, -0.0074806213, 0.021453857, -0.020629883, 0.00932312, -0.009803772, 0.037384033, 0.010948181, 0.014968872, 0.018463135, 0.004634857, 0.009819031, -0.03378296, 0.068359375, 0.010559082, -0.04598999, -0.013221741, -0.036621094, 0.015068054, -0.018630981, 0.024032593, -0.049957275, -0.0021800995, -0.014205933, 0.02420044, -0.03656006, 0.0017318726, -0.041168213, -0.048065186, -0.09118652, -0.059265137, -0.028259277, 0.08203125, -0.0043296814, 0.010757446, 0.039367676, -0.0008893013, 0.0236969, -0.009017944, -0.027511597, -0.005405426, -0.0050811768, -0.010047913, -0.00037765503, 0.021636963, 0.009231567, -0.006500244, 0.0011529922, -0.03161621, 0.026428223, -0.00705719, -0.0059127808, 0.0134887695, -0.0032844543, 0.008262634, 0.018615723, -0.002609253, 0.019363403, 0.024932861, 0.017318726, 0.0054016113, -0.00040245056, 0.0154800415, 0.008682251, -0.0051116943, -0.003276825, 0.0022563934, 0.04147339, 0.01838684, 0.003232956, -0.029525757, -0.006263733, -0.0077590942, -0.029403687, 0.002653122, 0.0096588135, 0.020004272, 0.024215698, 0.06842041, -0.018630981, 0.0029029846, 0.018722534, -0.012214661, -0.0072250366, 0.0011367798, 0.00036644936, 0.015594482, 0.016830444, 0.013374329, -0.025527954, 0.007030487, 0.015975952, 0.0042304993, -0.007865906, -0.0073928833, 0.038757324, 0.0016441345, -0.04248047, 0.054534912, 0.033599854, 0.045196533, -0.018554688, -0.017913818, 0.029052734, 0.02230835, 0.03741455, 0.017166138, 0.012107849, 0.0059547424, 0.036071777, 0.0019102097, -0.04727173, -0.0040740967, 0.024002075, -0.004306793, -0.07232666, -0.061157227, -0.053588867, -0.030014038, 0.006462097, -0.037384033, 0.011695862, 0.03567505, 0.014816284, 0.045318604, -0.010261536, -0.050109863, -0.041503906, 0.0022716522, 0.07019043, 0.014915466, 0.032165527, -0.06439209, 0.011291504, 0.053497314, -0.011703491, 0.0059165955, 0.057678223, 0.013900757, -0.0018205643, -0.011459351, -0.0054130554, -0.05456543, 0.04046631, 0.008094788, 0.03149414, 0.0011796951, 0.016815186, 0.04385376, 0.00019967556, 0.023971558, -0.030181885, 0.013214111, 0.018798828, -0.028427124, 0.032714844, 0.020767212, -0.042114258, 0.018630981, -0.0061798096, -0.016052246, 0.00472641, 0.029968262, -0.0042915344, -0.024551392, -0.0033798218, -0.026473999, 0.01739502, 0.037841797, -0.017044067, -0.048309326, -0.029632568, 0.029266357, 0.025009155, -0.04876709, -0.03817749, 0.017562866, -0.043640137, -0.0030536652, -0.02949524, 0.007381439, 0.050109863, 0.016662598, 0.022659302, -0.026870728, 0.046905518, 0.040527344, -0.008529663, 0.01121521, 0.045562744, -0.04458618, 0.041381836, 0.050079346, 0.06512451, 0.081726074, 0.052581787, -0.025909424, 0.01348114, 0.08850098, -0.030685425, 0.007045746, -0.0043029785, -0.0068588257, -0.03390503, -0.0065612793, 0.0059280396, 0.009971619, 0.0051002502, 0.04257202, -0.009971619, 0.028884888, -0.029067993, -0.036010742, -0.011680603, -0.035980225, 0.08068848, -0.035827637, 0.029312134, -0.0067100525, 0.017791748, -0.03765869, 0.0062561035, 0.0014543533, 0.037872314, 0.018554688, 0.009895325, 0.05206299, -0.032348633, -0.026901245, 0.028213501, 0.02015686, 0.061645508, -0.0023860931, -0.010124207, 0.016204834, -0.010719299, 0.0073013306, -0.053588867, 0.007293701, -0.06903076, 0.0012655258, -0.030654907, 0.011100769, -0.008346558, -0.035095215, -0.05340576, -0.028823853, 0.000040769577, -0.047668457, 0.054107666, 0.07019043, -0.03173828, -0.03250122, 0.052246094, -0.060699463, 0.073913574, -0.027175903, 0.017456055, 0.05230713, 0.002166748, 0.01146698, -0.015151978, 0.038513184, -0.0029029846, 0.019073486, -0.073913574, -0.0059890747, 0.006511688, 0.021942139, -0.0025806427, 0.0063972473, 0.07141113, 0.056030273, -0.000562191, -0.04248047, -0.00749588, -0.015838623, 0.015640259, 0.05368042, 0.0016393661, -0.051818848, -0.050964355, -0.017959595, 0.07354736, 0.0015382767, -0.019424438, -0.039794922, 0.018707275, 0.03652954, 0.0110321045, 0.029464722, -0.026977539, 0.0033473969, 0.000056803226, 0.029968262, 0.006122589, -0.03829956, 0.030731201, -0.048095703, 0.016281128, 0.025741577, -0.04434204, 0.00484848, -0.02772522, 0.0040016174, -0.0597229, -0.023361206, 0.046875, 0.009971619, 0.006175995, -0.026565552, 0.024597168, 0.044006348, 0.0060806274, 0.011054993, 0.010604858, 0.04534912, 0.011619568, -0.05029297, -0.014808655, -0.04748535, -0.051513672, 0.00091362, -0.057525635, 0.033111572, -0.023956299, 0.030899048, 0.028335571, 0.017074585, -0.0056266785, 0.024169922, -0.035095215, 0.011627197, -0.024490356, -0.037231445, -0.0099487305, -0.0075912476 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2110.05188v2
A Theory of Tournament Representations
Arun Rajkumar, Vishnu Veerathu, Abdul Bakey Mir
cs.GT, cs.AI, cs.LG
Real world tournaments are almost always intransitive. Recent works have noted that parametric models which assume $d$ dimensional node representations can effectively model intransitive tournaments. However, nothing is known about the structure of the class of tournaments that arise out of any fixed $d$ dimensional representations. In this work, we develop a novel theory for understanding parametric tournament representations. Our first contribution is to structurally characterize the class of tournaments that arise out of $d$ dimensional representations. We do this by showing that these tournament classes have forbidden configurations which must necessarily be union of flip classes, a novel way to partition the set of all tournaments. We further characterise rank $2$ tournaments completely by showing that the associated forbidden flip class contains just $2$ tournaments. Specifically, we show that the rank $2$ tournaments are equivalent to locally-transitive tournaments. This insight allows us to show that the minimum feedback arc set problem on this tournament class can be solved using the standard Quicksort procedure. For a general rank $d$ tournament class, we show that the flip class associated with a coned-doubly regular tournament of size $\mathcal{O}(\sqrt{d})$ must be a forbidden configuration. To answer a dual question, using a celebrated result of \cite{forster}, we show a lower bound of $\mathcal{O}(\sqrt{n})$ on the minimum dimension needed to represent all tournaments on $n$ nodes. For any given tournament, we show a novel upper bound on the smallest representation dimension that depends on the least size of the number of unique nodes in any feedback arc set of the flip class associated with a tournament. We show how our results also shed light on upper bound of sign-rank of matrices.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2110.05188v2
"2021-10-12T07:34:00"
"2021-10-06T09:08:00"
{ "title": [ 0.026168823, 0.0059280396, -0.005710602, -0.09350586, 0.027923584, 0.0020103455, -0.016845703, -0.00566864, 0.022583008, 0.038970947, -0.012008667, 0.0022335052, -0.00061035156, -0.022750854, -0.05154419, 0.027053833, -0.0051651, -0.0062217712, -0.055511475, -0.04284668, -0.044799805, -0.037384033, 0.021514893, 0.04324341, 0.056854248, -0.030578613, 0.016784668, -0.0055656433, 0.016860962, -0.023880005, 0.012062073, -0.037078857, 0.055236816, -0.003250122, 0.02116394, 0.008758545, -0.029373169, -0.00076007843, -0.008369446, 0.009994507, -0.019683838, 0.0032444, -0.057495117, -0.068359375, -0.080566406, 0.039642334, -0.071777344, 0.005935669, -0.04940796, 0.087524414, 0.012901306, 0.018173218, -0.0020618439, 0.055999756, 0.027359009, -0.04699707, -0.021652222, -0.003572464, 0.0075645447, 0.06359863, 0.031921387, -0.013618469, 0.00957489, -0.003955841, -0.05355835, -0.0051002502, 0.0049362183, 0.031921387, 0.06628418, -0.031433105, -0.039642334, 0.0184021, 0.025665283, 0.004383087, -0.030410767, -0.007827759, 0.050872803, 0.024871826, 0.021865845, -0.012573242, 0.020462036, -0.019363403, -0.005180359, -0.0024204254, -0.013114929, -0.033172607, -0.0038719177, -0.0028362274, -0.005138397, -0.01222229, -0.005794525, 0.032958984, 0.037902832, 0.009231567, -0.0335083, 0.001786232, -0.011543274, 0.019638062, -0.0082473755, -0.011070251, -0.013389587, 0.0058135986, -0.013938904, -0.013442993, -0.013557434, 0.018432617, 0.0056648254, -0.0184021, -0.0027770996, 0.043640137, -0.016738892, 0.034729004, 0.018722534, 0.026275635, 0.043884277, -0.002708435, -0.026229858, 0.07128906, -0.004245758, 0.0703125, -0.012054443, -0.037200928, 0.027694702, -0.049804688, 0.026916504, -0.0032215118, -0.06311035, -0.0061950684, -0.013320923, 0.029067993, -0.0058135986, 0.022613525, -0.059143066, -0.04071045, -0.022766113, 0.024734497, 0.0013208389, -0.05279541, -0.0061454773, 0.012214661, 0.0045280457, -0.024414062, 0.019866943, -0.019958496, -0.06378174, 0.01600647, 0.064453125, -0.010368347, -0.060333252, -0.05154419, -0.055114746, -0.00024306774, 0.014915466, 0.036224365, -0.016845703, 0.012939453, -0.06665039, -0.015716553, 0.021087646, 0.02671814, 0.0056037903, 0.0008506775, 0.0014066696, 0.009506226, 0.04232788, 0.013397217, -0.01713562, 0.035125732, -0.0029659271, 0.027770996, 0.015510559, 0.0129852295, -0.009628296, 0.0065994263, -0.00026774406, 0.012191772, 0.023468018, -0.026565552, 0.037597656, 0.0053367615, 0.038360596, 0.012878418, -0.004547119, 0.070007324, -0.05532837, -0.01158905, -0.013008118, -0.047668457, 0.017486572, 0.0011196136, -0.023162842, 0.06774902, -0.044891357, -0.022888184, -0.021102905, -0.033843994, 0.030014038, 0.02319336, 0.013008118, 0.0061149597, -0.0052986145, -0.013793945, -0.009140015, -0.017471313, 0.0017728806, -0.03567505, -0.0034446716, 0.014183044, -0.040222168, 0.040893555, 0.073913574, 0.00248909, -0.045196533, 0.04156494, 0.008880615, -0.055145264, 0.010688782, 0.021759033, 0.000667572, 0.013969421, -0.025558472, -0.02772522, -0.00894928, 0.0513916, -0.007522583, 0.010925293, 0.006126404, -0.021575928, 0.05227661, 0.027496338, 0.08190918, -0.042388916, 0.022491455, 0.002023697, 0.012580872, 0.019760132, -0.0029964447, -0.017089844, -0.017990112, 0.018310547, -0.006389618, -0.014923096, -0.013122559, 0.027572632, 0.0340271, 0.035736084, 0.027023315, 0.0031414032, 0.03414917, 0.004558563, 0.064453125, -0.013648987, 0.060516357, -0.046325684, 0.027374268, 0.06707764, 0.012084961, 0.026748657, -0.007820129, 0.042419434, -0.019073486, 0.051849365, 0.01436615, 0.021087646, -0.012283325, -0.012908936, -0.020492554, 0.010948181, 0.010040283, 0.026931763, 0.011985779, -0.06762695, 0.009536743, -0.03012085, 0.011253357, 0.015487671, -0.039031982, 0.010902405, 0.019134521, -0.059387207, -0.03164673, 0.0088272095, 0.013916016, 0.0010614395, 0.0037822723, -0.028823853, 0.016967773, -0.0048294067, -0.008171082, -0.012649536, 0.045166016, 0.02986145, -0.00041866302, 0.0060577393, -0.00013828278, 0.011131287, 0.02130127, 0.05899048, -0.013587952, 0.029434204, -0.03591919, 0.025314331, 0.023986816, -0.01424408, -0.014877319, 0.055908203, 0.00806427, 0.00033020973, -0.033233643, 0.0038719177, -0.054870605, 0.0002322197, 0.0021896362, -0.0073623657, -0.010154724, -0.03491211, 0.018463135, -0.022003174, 0.0084991455, 0.035308838, 0.03277588, -0.005973816, -0.052490234, 0.013702393, 0.004398346, -0.0141067505, -0.026428223, -0.038391113, -0.074523926, 0.020706177, 0.053100586, 0.017562866, -0.03189087, 0.0019235611, 0.016784668, 0.03164673, 0.0055236816, 0.003835678, -0.011123657, -0.001613617, 0.033172607, 0.024414062, 0.015823364, -0.028030396, 0.0065345764, -0.057769775, 0.0055999756, 0.009384155, -0.032592773, 0.013465881, 0.02986145, -0.020126343, -0.032592773, 0.004207611, 0.08074951, 0.0090408325, -0.045074463, 0.04849243, 0.080444336, -0.019836426, 0.035003662, -0.009849548, 0.0016746521, -0.0262146, -0.01979065, -0.04940796, -0.021148682, -0.007030487, -0.01637268, 0.05142212, -0.0259552, -0.043518066, -0.018936157, -0.008148193, -0.009246826, 0.015510559, -0.010917664, -0.026779175, -0.032165527, -0.026657104, -0.0039901733, 0.013008118, -0.021911621, 0.0034179688, 0.02935791, 0.0033054352, -0.049957275, 0.0017852783, 0.0345459, 0.032958984, 0.023361206, 0.008590698, 0.031585693, -0.027191162, -0.027069092, -0.0050315857, 0.00058603287, -0.026382446, -0.009521484, 0.011421204, 0.039093018, -0.03100586, -0.036071777, 0.021850586, -0.07550049, 0.035614014, -0.0008955002, -0.022872925, 0.04083252, 0.05050659, -0.02432251, 0.051361084, -0.0026168823, -0.028060913, -0.0009059906, -0.018951416, -0.049072266, 0.027236938, -0.04156494, -0.03540039, 0.02960205, -0.03768921, -0.027496338, -0.0017757416, -0.035217285, 0.028701782, 0.02658081, 0.030166626, 0.004131317, 0.006313324, -0.0020179749, -0.007160187, 0.004611969, 0.03390503, -0.015327454, 0.02154541, -0.01335907, 0.012962341, 0.037261963, -0.031219482, 0.0016613007, -0.027114868, -0.0074424744, 0.044647217, -0.012718201, -0.012313843, -0.0206604, 0.0030994415, -0.0362854, 0.006286621, -0.0435791, 0.025985718, -0.061431885, 0.018341064, -0.00041151047, -0.01890564, 0.029373169, -0.002040863, -0.040863037, 0.007457733, 0.02784729, 0.0014858246, -0.09051514, -0.025299072, 0.02784729, 0.021118164, -0.02746582, -0.018081665, -0.006290436, -0.00022339821, -0.021896362, 0.0051841736, 0.016052246, 0.025756836, -0.021240234, 0.0012674332, -0.047607422, 0.068481445, -0.07739258, -0.008117676, 0.05218506, -0.007293701, 0.036468506, -0.06750488, 0.035949707, -0.009773254, -0.11968994, -0.023162842, -0.001616478, 0.01676941, -0.035186768, -0.015419006, -0.026763916, 0.047851562, -0.048034668, 0.016723633, -0.013809204, -0.06616211, -0.010108948, -0.06964111, -0.030929565, 0.07006836, -0.014228821, -0.0014009476, 0.03189087, -0.043151855, -0.035064697, -0.028564453, 0.01979065, 0.045684814, 0.016464233, 0.0045661926, -0.042633057, -0.00035381317, -0.033081055, 0.017440796, 0.0022087097, -0.00724411, -0.008743286, 0.015716553, 0.018630981, -0.014778137, 0.03869629, 0.04510498, 0.005596161, -0.0035095215, -0.028366089, 0.0076789856, -0.020690918, -0.043640137, 0.012504578, -0.0025253296, -0.00003272295, 0.02104187, 0.023147583, 0.064086914, 0.0015516281, -0.030654907, 0.036712646, 0.019348145, -0.0014419556, 0.015655518, -0.002796173, 0.03491211, -0.012588501, 0.011924744, -0.0018634796, 0.029800415, 0.014427185, -0.03427124, 0.006855011, 0.019760132, -0.03869629, 0.02406311, -0.043151855, -0.05722046, -0.0513916, 0.021102905, -0.022018433, 0.02116394, 0.018173218, -0.009811401, -0.03262329, -0.009506226, -0.05407715, -0.0065612793, 0.01928711, -0.015716553, -0.02418518, -0.002243042, -0.030258179, -0.01448822, 0.042266846, -0.01008606, 0.016616821, -0.039611816, -0.009757996, 0.010131836, 0.042388916, 0.041534424, 0.007701874, -0.012283325, -0.028259277, 0.030776978, 0.008506775, -0.04083252, 0.008361816, -0.0014762878, -0.018661499, -0.046966553, 0.0146865845, -0.026550293, -0.012252808, -0.050933838, 0.022201538, -0.021118164, 0.052124023, 0.030319214, 0.015113831, 0.029510498, 0.005710602, -0.0066833496, 0.010253906, -0.03677368, -0.0029411316, -0.004878998, 0.06008911, -0.013290405, -0.038757324, 0.028518677, 0.043518066, 0.011627197, 0.020751953, -0.025146484, 0.019927979, 0.05316162, 0.017242432, 0.001367569, -0.06756592, -0.054718018, -0.03543091, -0.010429382, 0.022399902, -0.07849121, 0.0435791, -0.0057144165, 0.0019798279, 0.01184845, -0.029663086, 0.018051147, -0.007499695, 0.02243042, -0.057678223, -0.080078125, -0.025360107, 0.07287598, -0.03567505, -0.0102005005, 0.0054626465, 0.030975342, 0.024154663, 0.05239868, 0.047027588, -0.019714355, 0.030578613, -0.012634277, -0.008033752, -0.0052719116, -0.059143066, 0.036590576, 0.013572693, 0.020980835, -0.04449463, 0.0029907227, -0.058044434, -0.0042152405, -0.008705139, 0.025161743, -0.022201538, -0.066589355, 0.022109985, 0.033691406, 0.0060539246, 0.023147583, -0.01348114, -0.004875183, 0.052612305, 0.048614502, 0.0034675598, 0.028259277, 0.023269653, -0.038024902, -0.016983032, 0.009811401, 0.008705139, -0.004272461, 0.041107178, 0.017288208, -0.0099487305, -0.014533997, 0.008857727, -0.0016479492, -0.0042533875, 0.03378296, -0.04840088, 0.018112183, 0.021835327, -0.019561768, 0.025421143, -0.026107788, -0.055725098, -0.029052734, 0.004753113, -0.061187744, 0.017532349, 0.020553589, -0.062805176, -0.060577393, 0.042022705, 0.02330017, 0.008735657, -0.03591919, 0.011352539, -0.07836914, 0.009185791, 0.03894043, -0.04800415, 0.010948181, -0.017822266, 0.021148682, 0.05117798, -0.005493164, -0.012664795, -0.0061302185, 0.0068893433, -0.06323242, 0.00044727325, 0.02268982, 0.013069153, -0.020248413, -0.0211792, -0.04232788, 0.0046577454, 0.008773804, 0.02796936, -0.0046691895, -0.023803711, 0.030471802, -0.012840271, -0.030151367, -0.005508423, 0.042022705, -0.01626587, -0.0012016296, -0.0017290115, -0.010673523, 0.012702942, -0.03466797, -0.0206604, 0.011909485, -0.039154053, 0.019088745, 0.0060691833, 0.014343262, 0.0059165955, 0.036254883, 0.01890564, 0.027816772, 0.008453369, 0.013122559, 0.047912598, -0.0138168335, 0.010063171, 0.022583008, 0.009162903, 0.02230835, 0.10638428, -0.040924072, -0.014709473, -0.060668945, -0.035186768, -0.032470703, -0.0104522705, 0.045684814, 0.0077552795, 0.037750244, -0.056121826, -0.048339844, -0.0071640015, -0.037719727, -0.034729004, 0.008331299, -0.007949829, -0.06341553, 0.06738281, 0.00504303, 0.016174316, -0.041503906, 0.015106201, 0.011993408, 0.01689148, -0.017333984, -0.027557373, -0.009506226, -0.002199173, -0.0385437, 0.07196045, -0.02468872, -0.00024533272, 0.052764893, -0.05117798, 0.0385437, 0.020263672, 0.03201294, 0.034179688, 0.016494751, 0.024002075, 0.009109497, 0.02204895, -0.018432617, 0.024673462, -0.025253296, -0.011581421, -0.044006348, -0.0035476685, -0.08831787, -0.0041122437, 0.045715332, -0.002155304, -0.005836487, -0.004337311, 0.0033340454, -0.007129669, 0.016357422, -0.017211914, 0.039367676, -0.018814087, 0.004020691, -0.010627747, -0.02810669, 0.03186035, 0.062561035, 0.0178833, -0.028335571, 0.022750854, -0.054138184, -0.0059051514, 0.052368164, 0.017288208, -0.03375244, -0.026672363, -0.04296875, 0.0024299622, -0.013076782, 0.026351929, 0.04168701, 0.041900635, -0.005680084, -0.0011405945, 0.002380371, -0.0028266907, -0.036499023, 0.005088806, 0.030166626, -0.04647827, 0.0025939941, -0.017440796, 0.0018539429, -0.026016235, -0.011108398, 0.058929443, -0.05871582, -0.07299805, 0.010536194, 0.06652832, 0.0018539429, 0.053253174, -0.04058838, 0.0020179749, -0.029220581, -0.013519287, 0.044799805, 0.0317688, 0.00028586388, 0.04736328, -0.019454956, -0.027572632, 0.0059509277, -0.023330688, -0.03753662, 0.010719299, 0.008216858, 0.007980347, 0.02835083, -0.039215088, 0.0070266724, 0.014282227, -0.064941406, 0.01777649, -0.043518066, 0.017807007, 0.04736328, 0.06604004, 0.009773254, 0.0044441223, -0.010620117, -0.044006348, 0.039031982, 0.004081726, -0.030929565, 0.013015747, -0.035217285, -0.02305603, 0.044769287, -0.033111572, 0.030670166, -0.020095825, -0.000729084, -0.025039673, 0.018051147, 0.009552002, -0.03488159, 0.017105103, -0.0178833, -0.019836426, 0.00067710876, 0.025161743, -0.037902832, -0.00856781, -0.012641907, -0.00012719631, 0.012542725, -0.023162842, -0.020599365, -0.019256592, -0.043548584, -0.019515991, -0.0231781, 0.021514893, -0.0103302, -0.011169434, -0.004676819, 0.007156372, -0.00932312, -0.047424316, -0.05307007, 0.024520874, -0.015670776, -0.031204224, 0.022994995, 0.018295288, 0.00092983246, 0.033233643, -0.054016113, 0.029968262, -0.010673523, 0.021835327, -0.0012454987, -0.06323242, -0.021575928, 0.010635376, -0.026031494, 0.03765869, 0.02281189, -0.004360199, -0.0050201416, 0.033477783, -0.043273926, -0.047088623, -0.0071258545, 0.03781128, -0.015144348, -0.04071045, 0.01663208, 0.008880615, 0.009521484, -0.05722046, -0.05734253, 0.022232056, 0.030517578, 0.018112183, 0.050689697, 0.03189087, -0.024261475, -0.014877319, -0.06744385, -0.016830444, 0.0017356873, -0.04949951, -0.04031372, 0.009422302, 0.04360962, -0.01550293, -0.0059661865, 0.05596924, -0.012191772, 0.001707077, 0.000014841557, -0.010559082, -0.020721436, -0.0087890625, -0.023101807, -0.021087646, -0.0158844, -0.043121338, 0.021743774, -0.016784668, 0.0062675476, -0.0061912537, 0.013442993, -0.022720337, 0.038757324, -0.041992188, -0.049346924, 0.03515625, 0.04815674, -0.0135650635, 0.044891357, -0.03945923, 0.010406494, -0.007259369, 0.010673523, 0.008422852, 0.004814148, 0.0047187805, -0.02796936, -0.0016565323, -0.011520386, -0.06738281, 0.015914917, -0.040008545, 0.008728027, -0.050354004, 0.032318115, -0.008239746, -0.015563965, -0.013504028, 0.004421234, 0.002084732, -0.042999268, -0.0770874, -0.0440979, 0.043060303, -0.018722534 ], "summary": [ 0.012290955, -0.017440796, 0.042053223, -0.0103302, -0.031829834, 0.015007019, -0.023483276, -0.0345459, -0.0026664734, 0.034454346, -0.06744385, 0.008506775, 0.03250122, 0.011634827, 0.001964569, -0.024383545, 0.01713562, -0.011787415, -0.022018433, -0.036102295, -0.0107803345, -0.016052246, -0.006969452, 0.08270264, -0.0026111603, 0.037322998, 0.072631836, -0.016403198, 0.02027893, 0.0011854172, 0.023956299, -0.044952393, 0.02130127, -0.008926392, 0.023025513, 0.007209778, -0.014060974, 0.009796143, 0.008369446, -0.0040779114, -0.012779236, -0.00566864, 0.03289795, -0.07763672, -0.023071289, 0.048980713, -0.013114929, 0.02671814, -0.020202637, 0.054382324, -0.014976501, 0.040161133, -0.011169434, 0.010734558, 0.010391235, -0.054473877, -0.013923645, -0.023956299, -0.016311646, 0.08685303, 0.044158936, 0.04336548, -0.017929077, -0.0077705383, -0.011810303, 0.0007824898, -0.0010175705, -0.0023040771, 0.10070801, 0.010826111, -0.02281189, 0.018569946, 0.037994385, -0.031585693, -0.011581421, 0.038482666, 0.009391785, 0.045532227, 0.019622803, -0.03894043, 0.009109497, 0.049346924, 0.006023407, -0.019119263, -0.004348755, -0.0076522827, -0.02267456, -0.011581421, 0.0030727386, 0.051849365, -0.0011644363, 0.0039138794, -0.00043988228, 0.06774902, 0.02418518, 0.008956909, 0.018539429, 0.00983429, -0.0014781952, -0.012458801, -0.006011963, -0.033569336, 0.01928711, -0.018936157, -0.0036716461, -0.018218994, -0.021591187, -0.057006836, 0.026290894, 0.03881836, -0.025177002, 0.018203735, 0.017456055, 0.025482178, 0.0044403076, -0.041748047, -0.04840088, 0.103515625, -0.023635864, 0.07965088, -0.011779785, 0.015914917, 0.006290436, -0.049957275, 0.0058555603, -0.013442993, -0.0034599304, -0.017868042, -0.02545166, 0.0021076202, -0.010414124, 0.033599854, 0.0017337799, 0.013572693, -0.016860962, 0.003873825, 0.053710938, -0.014289856, 0.0030956268, 0.0076408386, 0.009170532, -0.025283813, -0.0016212463, -0.00056028366, -0.032714844, 0.056396484, 0.047668457, -0.020080566, -0.030166626, -0.05090332, -0.06341553, 0.0051651, 0.01612854, 0.022872925, -0.014846802, -0.040008545, 0.00969696, -0.03744507, 0.01473999, -0.02810669, 0.006122589, 0.0058135986, 0.007926941, 0.011505127, -0.0087890625, -0.0077056885, -0.018615723, -0.008811951, 0.010597229, 0.030273438, 0.026763916, -0.0024414062, -0.017593384, -0.0021953583, 0.004142761, -0.0016393661, -0.026824951, -0.044281006, 0.016647339, 0.026184082, 0.03918457, -0.009239197, -0.04711914, 0.059906006, -0.028869629, 0.008590698, -0.0070228577, -0.02192688, 0.009689331, -0.0026607513, 0.0026378632, 0.045532227, -0.041168213, 0.015975952, -0.015899658, 0.0049476624, -0.010658264, 0.017852783, -0.0038166046, -0.035491943, 0.007297516, 0.01663208, 0.0005559921, -0.020233154, 0.0087509155, -0.014389038, 0.015167236, 0.025161743, 0.007080078, 0.015151978, 0.032989502, -0.017486572, -0.036346436, 0.050476074, -0.011459351, -0.030090332, -0.0074157715, -0.009841919, -0.017608643, -0.021636963, -0.002588272, -0.031921387, -0.020935059, 0.06149292, -0.010269165, -0.0024642944, -0.0035381317, 0.0057144165, 0.062072754, 0.009605408, 0.064697266, -0.015068054, -0.016098022, 0.0034809113, 0.026260376, 0.025604248, 0.045684814, -0.07476807, 0.0146865845, 0.008705139, -0.01828003, -0.005859375, -0.04296875, 0.052825928, 0.0118255615, 0.03173828, 0.014320374, 0.048583984, -0.0030994415, -0.007133484, 0.05831909, -0.015289307, 0.028900146, -0.021408081, 0.03286743, 0.01953125, -0.015625, 0.012962341, 0.0135650635, 0.030181885, -0.015579224, 0.12207031, 0.07977295, 0.020370483, 0.025177002, -0.044647217, 0.0066604614, -0.012077332, 0.024719238, -0.0046653748, -0.022460938, -0.13024902, 0.020507812, -0.06854248, -0.031921387, -0.01727295, -0.01626587, 0.013763428, 0.035736084, -0.050201416, -0.005672455, 0.016021729, 0.0025405884, 0.005279541, 0.00042247772, -0.0014228821, 0.018707275, 0.0317688, 0.040222168, 0.07092285, 0.035064697, 0.07269287, 0.022842407, 0.023849487, 0.0040893555, 0.031707764, -0.032196045, 0.0053138733, 0.017837524, -0.025405884, -0.027297974, 0.038604736, -0.001332283, -0.013839722, 0.010848999, -0.02406311, 0.02029419, -0.013366699, -0.019927979, -0.016098022, -0.043823242, 0.007549286, 0.026123047, 0.05215454, 0.01247406, -0.029876709, 0.019943237, 0.04248047, 0.053131104, 0.051574707, 0.10217285, 0.045776367, -0.023620605, 0.036376953, 0.00434494, -0.051208496, 0.025543213, -0.04437256, -0.049224854, 0.011260986, -0.020126343, -0.0064926147, -0.023757935, 0.02835083, -0.008590698, 0.022521973, 0.014907837, -0.037841797, 0.0027198792, -0.019546509, 0.02267456, 0.05267334, -0.02168274, -0.013313293, 0.0026626587, -0.018310547, 0.018463135, -0.0033283234, -0.04055786, 0.012817383, 0.007663727, -0.027755737, -0.006629944, 0.006664276, 0.034698486, 0.058929443, -0.01663208, 0.030914307, 0.059387207, -0.022369385, 0.035461426, 0.018432617, 0.022842407, -0.053375244, -0.08428955, -0.033325195, 0.010223389, 0.0079574585, 0.001326561, 0.0046539307, 0.013870239, -0.037078857, -0.0095825195, -0.0017690659, 0.011581421, -0.0029010773, 0.052886963, -0.023422241, -0.018081665, 0.025024414, -0.021453857, -0.00048041344, 0.0030708313, 0.007408142, 0.009277344, 0.039093018, -0.020584106, 0.0055236816, 0.0068206787, -0.016555786, 0.015388489, 0.04751587, 0.06628418, -0.060302734, -0.043701172, 0.006286621, -0.020446777, -0.023590088, 0.101379395, 0.0090408325, 0.023880005, -0.027282715, 0.0052490234, -0.013893127, -0.04095459, 0.034088135, -0.01890564, 0.0013580322, 0.032928467, 0.033172607, 0.0056495667, -0.030319214, 0.011528015, -0.043701172, -0.015487671, 0.011001587, 0.009117126, 0.027023315, -0.06274414, -0.022659302, 0.039123535, 0.03668213, -0.02671814, -0.023208618, -0.055480957, -0.018051147, -0.014732361, 0.051513672, -0.07574463, 0.056396484, -0.006565094, -0.0050086975, 0.012763977, 0.05429077, -0.04534912, 0.014701843, -0.0068206787, -0.048950195, 0.05996704, -0.07244873, -0.010345459, -0.00044631958, 0.02709961, 0.06518555, 0.021224976, -0.0003836155, 0.000080645084, -0.03152466, -0.0574646, 0.01838684, -0.061584473, 0.03353882, -0.06378174, 0.04156494, -0.010017395, -0.03515625, -0.019638062, 0.0009841919, 0.036712646, -0.009750366, -0.035095215, 0.016830444, -0.041046143, -0.020599365, -0.00066041946, 0.023361206, -0.0390625, 0.013771057, -0.004470825, -0.015403748, 0.019104004, 0.0138168335, -0.006790161, 0.00894928, -0.025726318, -0.046905518, 0.022216797, 0.04751587, -0.009567261, -0.046081543, 0.031021118, 0.005332947, 0.04724121, -0.04748535, 0.022583008, -0.007873535, -0.07720947, -0.030410767, -0.014656067, 0.078430176, 0.028915405, 0.018981934, -0.0038585663, 0.068847656, -0.01687622, 0.0022354126, -0.010612488, 0.04724121, -0.03616333, -0.08111572, -0.027801514, 0.0031375885, -0.0066070557, 0.028015137, -0.005870819, 0.0018672943, 0.030471802, 0.019241333, -0.0047187805, 0.0077400208, 0.026977539, -0.025146484, 0.007637024, -0.0021305084, -0.014091492, -0.010818481, 0.0076789856, 0.010902405, -0.022598267, -0.0013780594, 0.014808655, 0.03778076, 0.013763428, 0.04055786, -0.002532959, -0.0013628006, -0.019195557, 0.0012922287, -0.0368042, -0.009727478, 0.020767212, 0.02130127, 0.017028809, 0.018951416, 0.013084412, 0.0009493828, -0.006362915, -0.02897644, -0.0015115738, 0.034210205, -0.023635864, -0.0072288513, 0.02494812, 0.027374268, -0.004360199, -0.032592773, -0.05102539, -0.032196045, 0.013877869, -0.02180481, -0.005859375, -0.0012216568, -0.10913086, -0.0021305084, 0.0057258606, -0.025390625, -0.07550049, 0.03125, -0.04043579, -0.003124237, -0.031173706, 0.041046143, -0.05255127, 0.006111145, -0.11639404, 0.015289307, 0.019714355, 0.03338623, -0.039733887, -0.018569946, -0.038208008, -0.0076408386, 0.030166626, -0.013084412, 0.019744873, -0.039764404, -0.019577026, -0.0072250366, 0.010795593, 0.026870728, 0.0082473755, 0.031036377, -0.0067100525, 0.0040016174, -0.04751587, 0.020904541, 0.009986877, 0.0036449432, -0.012374878, 0.020217896, 0.0546875, -0.020690918, -0.013366699, -0.046844482, -0.02696228, -0.010421753, 0.015701294, 0.01927185, 0.01991272, 0.0096588135, -0.027740479, 0.0039520264, 0.021652222, -0.016693115, 0.010345459, 0.0006122589, -0.026885986, -0.02003479, -0.017211914, 0.0077934265, -0.023254395, -0.010444641, 0.032836914, -0.0149002075, 0.024368286, 0.030426025, 0.011329651, -0.016113281, -0.046569824, -0.030838013, -0.008232117, -0.012680054, -0.00573349, -0.023498535, -0.009140015, 0.00076007843, 0.012023926, 0.024993896, -0.016693115, -0.013687134, 0.018432617, -0.0038108826, -0.031021118, -0.0703125, -0.006286621, 0.046569824, 0.0052871704, -0.0014667511, -0.008331299, 0.012870789, 0.024093628, 0.043060303, 0.025726318, -0.082336426, 0.010902405, -0.030166626, -0.044921875, -0.016555786, -0.017562866, -0.0048217773, 0.022537231, 0.012901306, 0.0070343018, -0.020935059, -0.0074882507, -0.001282692, -0.015823364, 0.039276123, 0.006965637, -0.02519226, -0.048309326, 0.014160156, 0.003250122, -0.0340271, -0.011505127, -0.013038635, 0.03479004, 0.039215088, -0.011909485, 0.008811951, 0.022125244, -0.01626587, -0.018539429, 0.014930725, 0.037963867, 0.036193848, -0.02708435, 0.020248413, -0.0418396, 0.020248413, -0.007091522, 0.01449585, 0.033843994, -0.016464233, -0.015083313, 0.03781128, 0.008605957, -0.015449524, 0.020324707, 0.0037498474, 0.016326904, -0.0037136078, 0.009025574, -0.0357666, -0.017425537, 0.0025901794, -0.021713257, -0.060546875, -0.019332886, -0.027786255, 0.028305054, -0.039794922, 0.0126953125, -0.05682373, 0.0017614365, 0.014968872, -0.0056114197, -0.00793457, 0.054748535, 0.03024292, 0.028152466, -0.04397583, -0.023071289, -0.005168915, 0.014434814, 0.0013818741, 0.009300232, -0.010101318, -0.012130737, 0.020019531, -0.024887085, -0.008422852, 0.04724121, 0.004085541, 0.02268982, 0.014930725, -0.031677246, 0.00018632412, -0.036224365, -0.026565552, -0.013198853, -0.0019817352, -0.0024681091, -0.014099121, 0.007144928, -0.083740234, 0.017730713, -0.02305603, -0.013893127, 0.029296875, -0.037200928, 0.020187378, 0.009590149, -0.018005371, 0.014579773, 0.016159058, 0.006916046, 0.003627777, 0.0059051514, 0.0064926147, 0.03866577, -0.024642944, 0.01953125, -0.007499695, 0.011245728, -0.013801575, 0.05819702, 0.009613037, 0.022720337, -0.051239014, -0.01828003, -0.0034732819, -0.0049057007, 0.044067383, 0.010627747, 0.06793213, -0.021530151, -0.054870605, -0.015853882, -0.06365967, -0.034973145, -0.006259918, -0.015548706, -0.02168274, 0.10992432, -0.03189087, 0.011993408, -0.049957275, -0.015556335, 0.008285522, 0.04043579, -0.019714355, 0.0071487427, -0.005794525, 0.011199951, 0.0066871643, 0.03857422, -0.029693604, 0.019256592, 0.011459351, -0.025848389, 0.014213562, 0.03540039, 0.04208374, 0.008865356, -0.015266418, 0.024673462, 0.026443481, 0.030593872, -0.013381958, -0.0030841827, -0.027542114, -0.048736572, -0.020690918, -0.018920898, 0.0008211136, 0.009384155, 0.017364502, -0.024368286, 0.014770508, -0.0056877136, 0.017196655, 0.053588867, -0.0357666, -0.027191162, -0.017868042, -0.008476257, -0.0024490356, -0.027435303, -0.04144287, 0.054382324, 0.06317139, 0.015914917, -0.017456055, 0.072753906, -0.057434082, -0.015586853, 0.040893555, 0.018798828, -0.068603516, -0.010910034, -0.027755737, -0.033966064, -0.008605957, -0.02130127, 0.029403687, -0.00598526, 0.076538086, -0.044189453, 0.01335907, -0.002784729, -0.03353882, 0.021377563, -0.0058898926, 0.028930664, 0.008674622, -0.007835388, -0.015472412, 0.028167725, -0.04449463, 0.057373047, -0.056884766, -0.05795288, 0.008049011, 0.028808594, -0.0104904175, 0.007549286, -0.029449463, 0.004798889, -0.038879395, -0.037078857, 0.050750732, 0.023361206, -0.0078048706, 0.05606079, -0.0024986267, -0.0053634644, 0.01096344, -0.060272217, -0.015930176, -0.00166893, 0.029083252, 0.024642944, 0.029647827, -0.019927979, 0.01625061, 0.016281128, -0.021835327, 0.02279663, -0.030899048, 0.06689453, 0.07513428, 0.054656982, -0.018295288, 0.023483276, 0.08508301, -0.021652222, 0.016143799, 0.032989502, 0.029953003, 0.0031871796, -0.037353516, -0.01663208, 0.026565552, 0.0184021, 0.0546875, -0.02355957, 0.013671875, -0.020126343, 0.01285553, -0.05291748, 0.013214111, 0.041534424, -0.006980896, -0.023788452, 0.027893066, 0.032318115, -0.06188965, 0.02420044, 0.0003671646, -0.032318115, 0.030548096, -0.01876831, -0.002817154, -0.020004272, 0.035125732, -0.012207031, 0.017959595, 0.03640747, -0.0024642944, -0.010177612, 0.038391113, 0.009613037, -0.0021839142, -0.041900635, -0.06161499, 0.06915283, 0.03161621, -0.039916992, 0.03778076, 0.036102295, 0.0046539307, 0.050109863, -0.026657104, 0.028274536, -0.016281128, 0.0070724487, -0.015487671, -0.036590576, 0.05987549, 0.012908936, -0.005619049, 0.013153076, 0.021759033, 0.0056495667, -0.0026855469, 0.040496826, -0.033691406, -0.044921875, -0.02848816, -0.012420654, 0.008888245, -0.026000977, -0.022583008, -0.001625061, 0.005508423, -0.036712646, -0.034576416, 0.0335083, 0.02355957, 0.056732178, -0.00868988, 0.0034542084, 0.0011415482, -0.031066895, -0.06500244, -0.025131226, 0.02331543, -0.01725769, -0.045074463, 0.013076782, 0.009155273, -0.0317688, 0.0070495605, 0.018676758, -0.01576233, 0.004096985, -0.0039024353, -0.023544312, -0.03729248, -0.015914917, -0.057250977, -0.004714966, -0.07714844, 0.015052795, -0.027999878, 0.0121536255, -0.0013999939, -0.033294678, -0.0011816025, -0.030670166, -0.0357666, -0.057006836, 0.03677368, -0.038208008, 0.031463623, -0.03881836, -0.0012712479, -0.060821533, 0.05758667, 0.0029888153, -0.007575989, 0.014785767, -0.031311035, -0.01626587, -0.003704071, -0.023101807, -0.019012451, -0.029190063, 0.00052785873, -0.012794495, 0.00283432, -0.05709839, 0.020706177, 0.004131317, -0.050048828, 0.025527954, -0.008796692, 0.021499634, 0.0067825317, -0.006362915, -0.017166138, -0.014930725, 0.010520935 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2110.06996v2
A Novel Clustering-Based Algorithm for Continuous and Non-invasive Cuff-Less Blood Pressure Estimation
Ali Farki, Reza Baradaran Kazemzadeh, Elham Akhondzadeh Noughabi
physics.med-ph, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.SP
Extensive research has been performed on continuous, non-invasive, cuffless blood pressure (BP) measurement using artificial intelligence algorithms. This approach involves extracting certain features from physiological signals like ECG, PPG, ICG, BCG, etc. as independent variables and extracting features from Arterial Blood Pressure (ABP) signals as dependent variables, and then using machine learning algorithms to develop a blood pressure estimation model based on these data. The greatest challenge of this field is the insufficient accuracy of estimation models. This paper proposes a novel blood pressure estimation method with a clustering step for accuracy improvement. The proposed method involves extracting Pulse Transit Time (PTT), PPG Intensity Ratio (PIR), and Heart Rate (HR) features from Electrocardiogram (ECG) and Photoplethysmogram (PPG) signals as the inputs of clustering and regression, extracting Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) and Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) features from ABP signals as dependent variables, and finally developing regression models by applying Gradient Boosting Regression (GBR), Random Forest Regression (RFR), and Multilayer Perceptron Regression (MLP) on each cluster. The method was implemented using the MIMICII dataset with the silhouette criterion used to determine the optimal number of clusters. The results showed that because of the inconsistency, high dispersion, and multi-trend behavior of the extracted features vectors, the accuracy can be significantly improved by running a clustering algorithm and then developing a regression model on each cluster, and finally weighted averaging of the results based on the error of each cluster. When implemented with 5 clusters and GBR, this approach yielded an MAE of 2.56 for SBP estimates and 2.23 for DBP estimates, which were significantly better than the best results without clustering (DBP: 6.27, SBP: 6.36).
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2110.06996v2
"2021-12-27T14:18:17"
"2021-10-13T19:16:10"
{ "title": [ -0.0046691895, 0.00054359436, -0.025787354, -0.02609253, 0.009605408, -0.015716553, 0.026489258, -0.01927185, -0.026565552, 0.040039062, 0.03894043, 0.010566711, 0.005630493, -0.041748047, -0.038848877, 0.028457642, 0.028121948, 0.0025310516, 0.0056152344, -0.023086548, 0.028259277, -0.02607727, 0.008659363, 0.13244629, -0.0005578995, 0.012466431, -0.074645996, 0.007850647, -0.04727173, -0.016662598, -0.026473999, 0.035095215, -0.003145218, 0.050689697, -0.019165039, 0.015617371, -0.06604004, 0.06124878, 0.031188965, -0.0009407997, 0.023284912, -0.02178955, -0.026062012, 0.010406494, -0.030288696, 0.050933838, -0.05960083, -0.025650024, -0.023223877, -0.023666382, 0.0027332306, -0.0063552856, 0.0051651, 0.020080566, -0.008506775, -0.032318115, -0.0016927719, -0.015602112, 0.032440186, 0.029144287, 0.0058898926, -0.004142761, 0.0077705383, -0.025421143, -0.032226562, -0.0038433075, -0.018356323, 0.016494751, 0.06591797, -0.010131836, -0.027694702, 0.03579712, -0.0127334595, 0.015182495, -0.041229248, 0.008964539, 0.005882263, -0.014389038, 0.04675293, -0.015167236, 0.0059051514, -0.032073975, 0.026168823, -0.018859863, 0.015014648, 0.000050842762, -0.0004606247, -0.012214661, -0.043060303, -0.053710938, -0.024169922, -0.02507019, -0.024368286, -0.009635925, -0.024658203, -0.02758789, -0.013191223, 0.02999878, -0.008834839, -0.027450562, 0.014839172, 0.010925293, -0.045318604, -0.014320374, 0.035247803, 0.046875, -0.03793335, -0.06298828, 0.025894165, 0.002538681, -0.0038375854, 0.00014805794, 0.011062622, -0.0028095245, -0.018753052, 0.011375427, 0.0070228577, -0.02330017, 0.016418457, -0.01676941, -0.015670776, -0.014091492, -0.015296936, 0.011367798, 0.017089844, -0.010696411, 0.0025043488, -0.0035419464, -0.034484863, 0.014511108, -0.015464783, 0.017425537, -0.012130737, -0.010520935, -0.021621704, 0.025009155, -0.00674057, -0.005710602, -0.014595032, -0.0067367554, 0.03692627, -0.02255249, -0.016967773, 0.0284729, 0.0046920776, 0.0047035217, 0.05154419, -0.0056610107, -0.06573486, -0.030166626, -0.0058937073, 0.043792725, 0.042541504, -0.023773193, -0.087768555, -0.02809143, -0.125, -0.0075035095, 0.0051651, -0.017745972, 0.008407593, -0.01133728, -0.025650024, -0.02407837, 0.019042969, -0.00051403046, -0.004169464, 0.036010742, 0.024505615, 0.007381439, 0.010353088, 0.013572693, 0.057403564, 0.01689148, 0.0070762634, 0.011306763, 0.033813477, -0.0038871765, 0.035827637, -0.025970459, -0.015930176, -0.0058631897, 0.029846191, 0.015579224, -0.064697266, -0.03543091, 0.020751953, 0.056396484, 0.033843994, 0.025558472, -0.046813965, -0.0044784546, -0.055725098, -0.020309448, -0.03564453, -0.02319336, 0.010932922, 0.018508911, -0.0046463013, 0.0070343018, -0.08703613, 0.0042648315, -0.016784668, 0.053253174, 0.07733154, -0.033416748, 0.017684937, 0.00818634, -0.012527466, 0.030593872, 0.038726807, 0.0105896, -0.014297485, -0.036346436, -0.012176514, -0.04324341, 0.045562744, -0.045806885, -0.027877808, -0.04510498, -0.03488159, 0.016815186, -0.040283203, 0.07775879, 0.013961792, -0.008987427, 0.0013542175, -0.040985107, 0.038208008, -0.018615723, 0.06744385, 0.0209198, -0.0135269165, -0.008293152, -0.009727478, -0.0043792725, -0.024978638, 0.053619385, -0.0076789856, -0.0085372925, 0.0022411346, 0.008903503, -0.027938843, 0.017944336, 0.024993896, -0.0044937134, 0.0058898926, 0.019760132, 0.0021572113, 0.0020942688, 0.06561279, 0.021820068, 0.03491211, 0.059936523, -0.00029325485, 0.04348755, 0.0057373047, 0.045562744, -0.04534912, 0.011245728, -0.008331299, -0.0046539307, 0.012184143, -0.0015325546, -0.008605957, 0.011520386, 0.012565613, 0.017150879, -0.00881958, 0.0151901245, 0.017364502, -0.014183044, 0.01109314, -0.038391113, -0.03829956, -0.021713257, -0.028808594, 0.032470703, 0.027862549, -0.053741455, -0.038604736, 0.0032100677, 0.013252258, -0.017807007, 0.0076446533, -0.009590149, 0.0056114197, -0.037078857, -0.0058021545, -0.0143585205, 0.045715332, 0.018920898, 0.019760132, -0.040130615, 0.016723633, -0.01512146, -0.01260376, 0.043792725, -0.0064048767, 0.027908325, -0.05807495, 0.033050537, 0.011116028, 0.0076828003, -0.0044784546, 0.009773254, -0.006790161, 0.019317627, -0.01927185, -0.029174805, -0.01713562, 0.048583984, -0.0029830933, -0.06347656, -0.039489746, -0.04727173, -0.029754639, -0.051696777, -0.058532715, 0.013511658, 0.021972656, -0.0043411255, -0.06506348, 0.009559631, -0.00831604, 0.011276245, -0.027069092, -0.02229309, 0.00024068356, 0.0146865845, 0.04751587, 0.033081055, -0.04083252, 0.014221191, 0.011520386, 0.012863159, -0.02835083, 0.0042877197, -0.025131226, 0.006587982, -0.038604736, 0.008728027, 0.017852783, -0.058441162, 0.0076065063, -0.036865234, -0.029083252, 0.026229858, -0.06939697, -0.033569336, 0.058288574, -0.042022705, -0.027954102, -0.02558899, 0.024673462, 0.026504517, 0.0032806396, 0.01737976, 0.035125732, -0.01158905, 0.045166016, 0.025054932, 0.011413574, -0.014076233, 0.0126571655, -0.07104492, -0.02935791, -0.02470398, 0.046875, 0.05618286, -0.08282471, 0.020477295, -0.031097412, 0.016983032, 0.042175293, 0.020080566, -0.0116119385, -0.024658203, 0.0050582886, -0.009567261, 0.018707275, 0.0031108856, -0.0044670105, 0.0043144226, 0.110839844, 0.01109314, 0.064697266, 0.005432129, 0.07342529, -0.0037460327, -0.0025539398, -0.03753662, -0.013946533, -0.018554688, -0.0051727295, 0.017547607, -0.019454956, -0.06124878, -0.030441284, -0.0011768341, 0.044403076, 0.00016713142, -0.032409668, 0.03842163, -0.035583496, 0.019165039, 0.025100708, -0.013076782, 0.024353027, 0.07092285, -0.015640259, 0.00630188, -0.006122589, -0.019927979, 0.0060806274, -0.010978699, -0.08288574, 0.021514893, -0.030853271, -0.037902832, 0.013313293, -0.024414062, -0.018463135, -0.004966736, -0.037994385, 0.067871094, 0.03967285, 0.045074463, 0.008392334, -0.043304443, 0.015808105, -0.053588867, -0.011421204, -0.06964111, 0.003534317, -0.020843506, -0.037139893, 0.06707764, -0.038238525, 0.033050537, -0.0090789795, 0.0046806335, 0.02192688, 0.07305908, 0.004005432, -0.023468018, -0.013977051, 0.003686905, -0.0041389465, -0.009880066, 0.0064888, 0.009208679, 0.014595032, 0.0048828125, 0.004497528, -0.0029468536, 0.02357483, 0.0070152283, -0.026062012, -0.025131226, -0.010398865, -0.02381897, -0.04345703, -0.012062073, -0.0031013489, 0.03074646, -0.01574707, 0.00983429, -0.03894043, -0.000010848045, -0.008232117, 0.012008667, -0.0056762695, 0.025146484, -0.00642395, 0.022659302, -0.012283325, 0.03982544, -0.05230713, -0.0065689087, -0.024230957, 0.021896362, -0.015975952, -0.091918945, -0.050476074, 0.01586914, -0.10479736, -0.0647583, 0.034973145, -0.04144287, 0.009208679, -0.06689453, 0.03262329, -0.00687027, -0.01826477, -0.007209778, -0.0069351196, -0.0046920776, 0.0031433105, -0.08514404, -0.0005245209, 0.062164307, -0.036010742, 0.028686523, -0.009216309, 0.0008511543, 0.014961243, -0.022140503, 0.0053749084, -0.06500244, 0.05895996, -0.01524353, 0.025939941, 0.06173706, -0.011138916, 0.022903442, 0.03375244, 0.025009155, -0.0011901855, 0.0074043274, 0.037109375, 0.03765869, 0.0024662018, 0.03942871, -0.007724762, -0.027023315, -0.04147339, -0.022583008, -0.02078247, -0.023788452, 0.03363037, 0.024963379, 0.04727173, 0.035064697, -0.014884949, 0.018722534, -0.0037021637, 0.029632568, 0.022247314, -0.050964355, 0.0020141602, 0.012527466, 0.025314331, -0.0054626465, 0.012588501, -0.02507019, -0.01977539, 0.00092840195, -0.0287323, -0.04071045, -0.0031166077, 0.021652222, -0.02330017, -0.018463135, -0.061462402, 0.039031982, -0.010414124, -0.0042037964, -0.022598267, 0.02923584, -0.0039978027, 0.03640747, -0.05621338, 0.011543274, -0.023345947, -0.0035762787, 0.032165527, 0.012825012, 0.012107849, -0.006690979, -0.072021484, -0.028793335, 0.0037155151, 0.0027179718, 0.05923462, -0.016586304, -0.01676941, -0.004146576, 0.04852295, 0.04168701, 0.045532227, -0.016067505, -0.056549072, -0.046661377, -0.018554688, -0.0047340393, 0.027511597, 0.014778137, -0.02798462, -0.01399231, 0.010787964, -0.016998291, 0.010620117, 0.00774765, 0.021652222, -0.049041748, 0.06463623, -0.053497314, -0.0050315857, 0.0028381348, -0.0005836487, 0.04397583, 0.023284912, -0.019882202, -0.06304932, 0.030334473, 0.017791748, -0.0031051636, -0.0058288574, 0.040008545, 0.020828247, -0.00015735626, 0.025527954, -0.00674057, 0.040527344, 0.01474762, 0.010757446, 0.0005311966, -0.049438477, -0.038513184, 0.00059080124, -0.01626587, 0.03302002, -0.035980225, 0.011222839, 0.03262329, 0.0057296753, 0.017791748, -0.016433716, 0.027572632, -0.0050354004, 0.0069618225, -0.060394287, -0.02520752, 0.0107803345, 0.032104492, -0.03878784, -0.008872986, -0.013061523, 0.04034424, 0.041900635, 0.009811401, -0.0033836365, 0.0413208, -0.047821045, 0.017807007, 0.027938843, -0.026138306, -0.034210205, 0.017456055, 0.014755249, 0.007583618, -0.01675415, -0.011810303, -0.06317139, 0.00086688995, -0.020111084, 0.011428833, 0.025375366, -0.051208496, -0.031341553, 0.018737793, 0.022003174, -0.032928467, -0.010299683, 0.012451172, 0.028076172, 0.021697998, 0.028656006, 0.019882202, 0.024261475, -0.04006958, 0.005012512, 0.011367798, 0.013656616, 0.008087158, 0.034210205, -0.013626099, 0.00008010864, -0.023834229, 0.035949707, 0.042236328, 0.0037212372, -0.04147339, -0.02017212, 0.018951416, -0.0076408386, -0.011428833, 0.035949707, -0.022033691, 0.0010604858, 0.033172607, 0.0056495667, 0.002494812, -0.0023078918, 0.036590576, -0.0008368492, -0.05996704, -0.04333496, -0.03616333, -0.011955261, 0.00021743774, 0.06414795, -0.0042381287, 0.008560181, 0.01687622, -0.07659912, -0.007217407, 0.005092621, 0.034240723, 0.022094727, -0.027160645, -0.036224365, -0.0158844, -0.014801025, -0.017929077, 0.018936157, 0.056488037, 0.040924072, -0.0069847107, -0.01096344, -0.04852295, -0.0054893494, 0.011787415, 0.023757935, 0.014541626, -0.022644043, 0.02420044, 0.020095825, 0.032196045, 0.005630493, -0.0046463013, 0.053710938, -0.0058937073, -0.009986877, -0.040618896, 0.034820557, -0.014289856, 0.012313843, -0.043701172, -0.047729492, -0.0063285828, 0.014480591, -0.01953125, -0.0385437, 0.01625061, 0.046051025, -0.033935547, -0.04949951, -0.03704834, 0.024368286, -0.045715332, -0.07476807, -0.029174805, -0.009735107, -0.0181427, 0.079711914, 0.038604736, -0.053955078, -0.026794434, -0.038879395, -0.029953003, 0.013320923, 0.032287598, -0.01953125, -0.0010948181, -0.072143555, 0.017120361, 0.0005159378, -0.0010595322, -0.049682617, 0.03338623, 0.017562866, 0.009857178, -0.038238525, 0.011154175, 0.0435791, -0.055358887, 0.022109985, -0.03793335, -0.008811951, -0.021377563, -0.038269043, 0.012107849, -0.04336548, -0.012527466, 0.02015686, 0.029785156, -0.02458191, 0.06085205, -0.018554688, 0.033599854, 0.024108887, 0.02607727, 0.027420044, 0.018096924, 0.007858276, -0.0015230179, -0.0078048706, -0.036071777, -0.04888916, -0.050689697, -0.032073975, -0.04360962, -0.007129669, -0.027648926, 0.011009216, 0.0022277832, 0.041046143, -0.0036449432, 0.008171082, 0.03579712, -0.007335663, 0.038604736, -0.022033691, 0.084350586, -0.016906738, -0.028167725, -0.022140503, 0.044036865, 0.033569336, 0.021865845, -0.000002026558, 0.032196045, -0.022354126, 0.0075187683, -0.027633667, -0.017608643, 0.04248047, -0.019622803, -0.0059890747, 0.003129959, 0.04864502, -0.0077934265, 0.023513794, 0.064941406, 0.02519226, 0.010147095, -0.036590576, 0.022460938, -0.00040197372, -0.011856079, 0.0146865845, 0.056915283, -0.09472656, 0.049743652, -0.013397217, -0.039916992, 0.039855957, 0.06726074, -0.009635925, -0.06793213, -0.02859497, 0.017242432, 0.012329102, 0.03173828, -0.03930664, -0.02911377, 0.007850647, 0.02798462, 0.025161743, -0.0025291443, -0.012031555, 0.013496399, 0.04019165, -0.03817749, 0.019363403, -0.0057144165, 0.025115967, -0.054748535, 0.02180481, -0.050750732, 0.011558533, -0.037597656, -0.045013428, 0.00141716, -0.013725281, -0.039123535, -0.023925781, 0.029937744, -0.016082764, 0.0012378693, 0.053833008, 0.03741455, 0.006164551, -0.024398804, -0.017486572, -0.012634277, 0.01007843, -0.042938232, -0.012710571, -0.017868042, -0.03555298, 0.00091791153, -0.062469482, 0.00007420778, -0.027420044, -0.0065231323, -0.0345459, 0.03955078, 0.024139404, -0.05630493, -0.028564453, -0.015548706, -0.0124435425, -0.0037021637, 0.007461548, -0.011810303, -0.017944336, 0.010437012, 0.043762207, 0.031219482, 0.020339966, 0.0008864403, -0.01789856, -0.0018634796, -0.0069236755, -0.00027298927, 0.039245605, 0.009933472, -0.013832092, -0.025161743, -0.013771057, 0.016433716, 0.013221741, -0.0032672882, -0.015655518, -0.0637207, -0.056518555, -0.0045928955, -0.012557983, -0.036895752, -0.0052375793, 0.01890564, 0.0065231323, -0.016525269, -0.049194336, 0.027191162, -0.014434814, -0.07141113, -0.022567749, -0.045410156, -0.003419876, 0.02330017, -0.010498047, -0.010253906, 0.018295288, -0.013900757, -0.058624268, -0.0057411194, 0.012565613, -0.019439697, -0.051208496, 0.025375366, 0.0131073, 0.026184082, -0.045013428, -0.016235352, 0.00504303, 0.05166626, -0.02166748, 0.032470703, 0.00032019615, -0.008514404, 0.023803711, 0.025024414, 0.011260986, -0.027526855, -0.06439209, -0.035705566, 0.023971558, 0.034576416, 0.009086609, -0.026412964, 0.04272461, 0.0038986206, -0.016723633, 0.025100708, -0.01826477, 0.0050621033, 0.011764526, -0.00020301342, -0.018417358, -0.056854248, -0.04550171, 0.009376526, 0.023727417, -0.014602661, 0.006958008, 0.03289795, -0.027694702, 0.031219482, -0.03479004, -0.055908203, 0.0625, 0.019439697, 0.016448975, 0.009895325, 0.025619507, 0.0054092407, -0.043823242, -0.020187378, 0.027313232, -0.023727417, 0.022476196, -0.042266846, 0.04135132, -0.058380127, -0.026885986, -0.040496826, -0.0496521, 0.052215576, 0.0014438629, 0.00038051605, -0.0158844, -0.009101868, -0.009857178, 0.021408081, -0.016143799, -0.029510498, -0.028411865, -0.007610321, 0.03262329, -0.016723633 ], "summary": [ 0.008323669, 0.0008716583, 0.029342651, -0.0031833649, -0.013000488, 0.0025501251, 0.009346008, -0.04788208, -0.0024051666, 0.020645142, 0.0087890625, -0.01651001, 0.02003479, -0.059692383, -0.011276245, -0.0041770935, 0.029937744, -0.021835327, 0.020629883, -0.023910522, 0.03857422, -0.009414673, 0.0029029846, 0.11218262, 0.01939392, 0.014694214, -0.025878906, -0.00687027, 0.017654419, 0.030319214, 0.0020389557, -0.006893158, -0.021530151, 0.05154419, -0.009918213, -0.01789856, -0.03567505, 0.041931152, 0.045684814, -0.02017212, 0.016235352, 0.0055351257, 0.060760498, 0.0041046143, -0.00075244904, 0.044281006, -0.0395813, -0.057373047, -0.0048332214, -0.022598267, -0.001209259, -0.019195557, 0.0019159317, -0.015335083, -0.01777649, -0.013893127, 0.0021533966, 0.021713257, 0.0023975372, 0.032073975, -0.019729614, 0.03152466, 0.011276245, -0.050445557, -0.037139893, 0.0041656494, 0.004901886, 0.0029678345, 0.03817749, -0.024765015, -0.0021781921, 0.031341553, -0.013549805, 0.018157959, -0.032714844, 0.016830444, 0.0051193237, 0.0008010864, 0.029388428, -0.001329422, 0.013191223, -0.01864624, 0.01902771, -0.013343811, 0.010856628, 0.008071899, -0.00029921532, -0.01953125, -0.043121338, -0.02331543, -0.040039062, -0.06951904, -0.06756592, 0.041900635, 0.039733887, -0.032806396, -0.032196045, -0.013282776, -0.0054893494, 0.012268066, 0.009017944, -0.009971619, -0.012321472, -0.014228821, 0.017547607, 0.07745361, -0.018554688, -0.059265137, 0.0027217865, -0.021087646, 0.00831604, -0.041656494, -0.011886597, -0.033996582, -0.018676758, 0.056518555, 0.023025513, -0.01071167, 0.017532349, 0.007797241, -0.0015201569, 0.027160645, -0.038360596, 0.019485474, -0.015556335, -0.023498535, 0.014801025, -0.0012493134, -0.043426514, 0.022491455, -0.023590088, -0.018188477, 0.01008606, 0.03555298, -0.008766174, -0.023086548, 0.009208679, -0.006629944, -0.014450073, -0.039093018, 0.060668945, 0.004032135, -0.010437012, 0.03390503, 0.0016727448, -0.016418457, 0.021896362, 0.026031494, -0.024017334, -0.02532959, 0.026260376, 0.025222778, 0.026016235, -0.018920898, -0.044830322, -0.047546387, -0.052856445, 0.0023536682, 0.011329651, -0.027267456, 0.0284729, -0.021087646, -0.026489258, 0.004398346, -0.026168823, 0.012626648, -0.0018796921, 0.010566711, 0.0098724365, -0.06185913, 0.0012550354, -0.00029683113, 0.057678223, 0.003534317, 0.009727478, 0.022537231, -0.0018959045, -0.015701294, 0.05267334, -0.030883789, -0.030548096, -0.031082153, 0.044036865, -0.0087890625, -0.028686523, 0.026977539, 0.017837524, 0.10028076, 0.0069084167, 0.036071777, -0.06085205, -0.017868042, -0.058898926, 0.01676941, 0.013305664, -0.00869751, 0.00048327446, 0.00065135956, 0.0035572052, -0.034301758, -0.07623291, 0.019546509, -0.0017938614, 0.040100098, 0.044555664, 0.0026302338, 0.011268616, 0.021530151, -0.028533936, 0.004261017, 0.012649536, -0.03616333, 0.0035133362, -0.035003662, -0.016708374, -0.02015686, 0.010475159, -0.08935547, -0.04598999, -0.06414795, -0.037506104, 0.049987793, -0.07110596, 0.061309814, -0.027191162, -0.019500732, 0.004940033, -0.02178955, 0.014175415, -0.0076141357, 0.052215576, 0.0072364807, -0.014633179, 0.009651184, -0.020858765, -0.0046806335, 0.0034942627, 0.023406982, -0.0024642944, 0.0072631836, 0.018569946, 0.027053833, -0.02381897, 0.00390625, 0.006969452, -0.03515625, 0.004371643, 0.0035095215, -0.01725769, 0.0513916, 0.013175964, 0.043395996, 0.002401352, 0.02696228, -0.016967773, 0.017745972, 0.008308411, 0.03491211, -0.0423584, 0.01739502, -0.027053833, -0.02911377, -0.017654419, -0.017166138, 0.02381897, 0.012954712, 0.020706177, 0.031707764, -0.022033691, -0.005996704, 0.01675415, 0.026473999, 0.008491516, -0.04623413, -0.091674805, -0.04437256, -0.010513306, 0.056793213, 0.016662598, -0.07354736, -0.011917114, 0.016189575, -0.0024375916, -0.010192871, 0.01838684, -0.027557373, -0.008842468, -0.00440979, 0.028259277, 0.016189575, 0.026916504, 0.032104492, -0.0014076233, 0.008888245, 0.03427124, -0.020248413, -0.030456543, 0.0020771027, 0.020019531, -0.022247314, -0.026992798, 0.0362854, -0.01940918, 0.012870789, 0.0018310547, -0.010604858, -0.044647217, 0.045898438, 0.013938904, -0.046173096, -0.0055503845, 0.05645752, -0.002210617, -0.021011353, -0.03277588, -0.047698975, -0.035186768, -0.035736084, -0.032928467, 0.014862061, 0.037078857, -0.018569946, -0.045440674, 0.02659607, -0.01360321, -0.013442993, 0.033203125, -0.02029419, 0.008430481, 0.0032806396, -0.017623901, 0.022506714, -0.01864624, 0.07244873, -0.007965088, 0.022628784, -0.0012807846, 0.0256958, 0.01876831, 0.00894928, -0.0023059845, 0.049835205, -0.009536743, -0.03100586, -0.051208496, -0.003686905, -0.009208679, -0.00029683113, -0.05529785, -0.027862549, 0.048339844, -0.030960083, -0.07299805, -0.01576233, -0.034210205, 0.028167725, 0.08026123, -0.0006699562, 0.016647339, -0.038635254, 0.054504395, 0.027496338, 0.023376465, -0.057891846, -0.036071777, -0.05734253, -0.024871826, -0.017745972, 0.07159424, 0.049346924, -0.070617676, 0.05392456, 0.0012626648, 0.018325806, 0.075805664, -0.0022258759, 0.06994629, 0.003370285, 0.0077056885, 0.04888916, 0.026763916, 0.0031738281, 0.019821167, -0.0074653625, 0.094055176, -0.003627777, 0.06738281, 0.019195557, 0.09008789, -0.0034294128, -0.00025558472, -0.039245605, -0.008354187, -0.021560669, 0.010154724, 0.03817749, -0.03717041, -0.056152344, -0.0004518032, -0.015571594, 0.049224854, 0.003112793, -0.013031006, 0.024368286, -0.006290436, 0.04034424, 0.046203613, -0.006504059, 0.015701294, 0.043426514, 0.010604858, -0.00566864, -0.0012350082, -0.007774353, 0.007019043, -0.015136719, 0.0023727417, 0.0104522705, -0.02458191, -0.01939392, 0.023986816, 0.010292053, 0.010665894, 0.00642395, -0.011146545, 0.053527832, 0.024032593, 0.019638062, 0.010231018, -0.005718231, 0.029541016, -0.03793335, -0.029830933, -0.08514404, 0.030639648, 0.00045990944, -0.028930664, 0.038208008, -0.05593872, 0.025390625, 0.008552551, -0.0022525787, 0.025894165, 0.067871094, 0.025680542, -0.008430481, -0.016525269, -0.0009598732, 0.02166748, -0.023147583, -0.0075035095, 0.010154724, 0.05508423, 0.026809692, -0.0044136047, -0.012718201, 0.0090408325, 0.031402588, 0.044677734, -0.021011353, -0.035369873, -0.018157959, 0.002275467, -0.0006637573, 0.025772095, 0.012420654, -0.027069092, 0.047454834, 0.0066719055, -0.008529663, 0.052520752, -0.003414154, -0.015640259, -0.0032196045, -0.03111267, -0.03353882, 0.043518066, 0.04928589, 0.003490448, -0.06365967, -0.05154419, 0.03567505, -0.050354004, -0.08685303, -0.05911255, 0.016601562, -0.09692383, -0.09234619, 0.026351929, -0.019454956, 0.037841797, -0.048797607, 0.05569458, 0.00737381, 0.0032863617, -0.026123047, -0.02796936, 0.10632324, 0.01259613, -0.050994873, 0.017684937, -0.045532227, 0.009063721, 0.017410278, -0.043670654, 0.052337646, 0.04156494, -0.017089844, -0.022140503, -0.10632324, 0.021499634, -0.074279785, -0.015464783, 0.013885498, -0.02822876, 0.024154663, 0.013259888, 0.0070877075, -0.0029239655, 0.017440796, 0.06768799, 0.055786133, 0.017715454, -0.0056152344, -0.018936157, -0.0076675415, 0.004398346, -0.026321411, -0.009086609, -0.022247314, 0.041931152, 0.072143555, 0.018875122, 0.012084961, -0.017227173, -0.07293701, -0.023452759, -0.005962372, 0.013931274, -0.014289856, 0.0063476562, 0.048706055, 0.0066719055, 0.019500732, -0.0022125244, -0.047332764, -0.009346008, 0.011581421, -0.060760498, -0.014259338, 0.0026168823, 0.024124146, -0.012367249, -0.021820068, -0.004634857, 0.040893555, 0.0072021484, -0.029907227, -0.007575989, 0.016189575, -0.03277588, 0.011505127, -0.028778076, 0.026275635, -0.04660034, 0.013145447, 0.022750854, 0.030670166, 0.008010864, -0.0184021, -0.018661499, -0.011795044, 0.032928467, -0.0025177002, 0.027816772, -0.018234253, -0.033111572, -0.015548706, 0.019088745, 0.024261475, 0.00894165, 0.009895325, -0.036987305, -0.091430664, -0.018035889, 0.01576233, 0.009529114, -0.01725769, -0.027267456, -0.004421234, 0.0209198, -0.013549805, 0.02027893, 0.0048217773, -0.014205933, -0.0309906, 0.028198242, -0.058441162, -0.0045700073, -0.00315094, -0.0056533813, 0.02796936, 0.023101807, -0.023391724, -0.06585693, 0.0023441315, -0.039367676, 0.004333496, -0.0066833496, 0.031433105, -0.016586304, 0.0038661957, 0.0007972717, -0.01626587, 0.020553589, 0.0149383545, 0.027618408, -0.0024261475, -0.011062622, -0.0317688, 0.0030651093, 0.017623901, 0.016021729, -0.0072288513, -0.00012218952, 0.038085938, 0.035491943, 0.026916504, -0.017501831, -0.0029659271, -0.017654419, -0.018554688, -0.010864258, -0.00894928, 0.022949219, 0.015602112, -0.019012451, -0.032470703, -0.03604126, 0.053253174, 0.0051193237, -0.021102905, -0.027160645, 0.040924072, -0.01309967, 0.0058250427, 0.016677856, 0.014892578, -0.03338623, 0.009147644, -0.030715942, -0.011054993, 0.009132385, -0.038116455, -0.0009393692, -0.020858765, -0.0049552917, 0.008735657, 0.006000519, -0.047912598, -0.08850098, -0.031143188, 0.011230469, -0.06744385, 0.011001587, -0.001786232, 0.023910522, 0.014892578, -0.0035629272, 0.02658081, -0.013534546, 0.016296387, 0.018753052, 0.01776123, 0.03173828, -0.013458252, -0.000030577183, -0.01676941, -0.04425049, 0.005279541, -0.0022277832, -0.0023670197, 0.020736694, -0.012046814, -0.011604309, 0.025848389, -0.0013418198, 0.0018377304, 0.02229309, 0.036987305, 0.01953125, 0.023101807, 0.03149414, 0.03112793, -0.028320312, 0.0107040405, 0.01777649, -0.03161621, -0.051086426, -0.03036499, 0.011184692, 0.0012369156, 0.050231934, 0.006046295, -0.007827759, -0.019607544, -0.110839844, 0.017196655, 0.012298584, 0.03753662, -0.015838623, -0.041809082, -0.027267456, -0.003780365, -0.041015625, 0.0024967194, 0.048553467, 0.05908203, 0.041656494, 0.013824463, -0.0075683594, -0.024627686, 0.041992188, -0.007549286, 0.018997192, -0.00003540516, -0.0035858154, 0.013450623, 0.016052246, 0.028671265, 0.0021457672, -0.066101074, 0.04562378, -0.004360199, -0.025405884, -0.0075531006, 0.010101318, -0.015007019, 0.025283813, -0.08239746, -0.01663208, -0.014518738, 0.04269409, -0.008682251, -0.03074646, 0.0033512115, 0.017227173, -0.043884277, -0.028533936, -0.017532349, 0.024627686, -0.016845703, -0.07904053, -0.0079193115, 0.012252808, 0.018173218, 0.06781006, 0.015281677, -0.06488037, -0.011932373, -0.008956909, 0.010627747, 0.006828308, 0.0027370453, -0.02456665, 0.025039673, -0.055419922, -0.029556274, -0.02519226, 0.0009832382, 0.014663696, 0.02319336, -0.003955841, -0.007408142, -0.05227661, 0.0011806488, 0.06817627, -0.037322998, -0.012641907, -0.07055664, -0.039794922, -0.009681702, -0.016571045, 0.036987305, 0.0012207031, 0.007610321, 0.016021729, 0.0005683899, 0.014144897, 0.030197144, -0.022644043, 0.02796936, 0.016601562, -0.03253174, 0.0023155212, 0.012084961, -0.021835327, -0.014030457, -0.015235901, -0.021148682, -0.010391235, -0.0030555725, -0.03778076, -0.03677368, -0.027832031, 0.0116119385, 0.042938232, -0.02330017, 0.030822754, 0.014778137, 0.0068511963, 0.05834961, -0.015357971, -0.024032593, -0.058135986, 0.04827881, -0.0074539185, -0.011009216, -0.013885498, 0.03668213, 0.022735596, 0.029006958, 0.019546509, 0.020965576, -0.02507019, 0.04159546, -0.003929138, -0.041503906, -0.02796936, -0.037628174, 0.035980225, -0.022842407, 0.038513184, -0.024978638, 0.032989502, 0.06488037, 0.013648987, 0.013916016, -0.025848389, 0.027511597, 0.01953125, 0.0050811768, 0.011787415, 0.047546387, -0.039276123, 0.027877808, 0.020980835, -0.032165527, 0.026062012, 0.085632324, -0.010185242, -0.0058250427, 0.03062439, -0.020050049, -0.0023021698, 0.022994995, -0.010147095, -0.014587402, 0.002811432, 0.008987427, -0.016860962, 0.022903442, 0.007904053, 0.0014877319, 0.027526855, -0.020492554, 0.042144775, -0.015022278, 0.034606934, -0.031234741, 0.022827148, -0.060424805, -0.034423828, -0.03161621, -0.009529114, -0.014022827, 0.0062942505, 0.014350891, -0.03250122, 0.05102539, 0.028381348, 0.011695862, 0.05834961, 0.002943039, 0.009231567, 0.025604248, 0.017868042, -0.008636475, -0.032348633, -0.012756348, -0.03579712, -0.00012338161, 0.03289795, -0.031799316, -0.011665344, -0.033996582, -0.036102295, -0.006965637, -0.03213501, 0.035827637, -0.048919678, -0.018936157, 0.005470276, -0.0357666, -0.020767212, 0.0058174133, 0.033233643, -0.025604248, 0.023239136, -0.022216797, -0.025604248, 0.007675171, 0.011810303, 0.036865234, -0.009178162, 0.006565094, -0.027862549, -0.011001587, 0.02041626, 0.014961243, -0.026733398, -0.024368286, 0.022781372, 0.012748718, -0.019897461, 0.009292603, -0.0019664764, -0.03250122, -0.09454346, 0.0140686035, -0.010444641, -0.04034424, -0.044311523, 0.039276123, -0.02128601, -0.0057868958, -0.028060913, 0.036895752, 0.037994385, -0.09429932, -0.05105591, 0.0067749023, -0.026367188, -0.02734375, 0.0019340515, -0.0011873245, 0.03579712, -0.0030822754, -0.03540039, -0.01411438, -0.02017212, -0.037353516, -0.0625, 0.0078086853, 0.0071907043, 0.0067825317, -0.02104187, 0.020309448, 0.045837402, 0.041259766, -0.006439209, -0.019561768, -0.025741577, -0.020217896, 0.050598145, 0.026138306, 0.0068855286, -0.025161743, -0.04876709, -0.04598999, 0.041809082, -0.021911621, -0.0099105835, -0.034851074, 0.023101807, -0.022735596, -0.01939392, 0.03805542, 0.011924744, 0.0032157898, 0.0113220215, -0.0051574707, -0.034423828, -0.088378906, -0.04156494, -0.016189575, 0.021484375, -0.015686035, -0.005142212, 0.022277832, -0.032989502, 0.04147339, -0.013717651, 0.00440979, 0.021835327, -0.022903442, 0.038482666, -0.014968872, 0.0519104, 0.016036987, -0.0029315948, -0.05496216, 0.005970001, -0.07141113, 0.0435791, -0.05227661, -0.027557373, -0.04324341, -0.003967285, -0.044403076, -0.031585693, 0.02961731, 0.01902771, -0.007663727, 0.02178955, -0.020980835, 0.010787964, 0.020080566, -0.015686035, -0.007873535, 0.014297485, 0.009979248, 0.0084991455, 0.014633179 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2110.09714v2
Black-box Adversarial Attacks on Commercial Speech Platforms with Minimal Information
Baolin Zheng, Peipei Jiang, Qian Wang, Qi Li, Chao Shen, Cong Wang, Yunjie Ge, Qingyang Teng, Shenyi Zhang
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
Adversarial attacks against commercial black-box speech platforms, including cloud speech APIs and voice control devices, have received little attention until recent years. The current "black-box" attacks all heavily rely on the knowledge of prediction/confidence scores to craft effective adversarial examples, which can be intuitively defended by service providers without returning these messages. In this paper, we propose two novel adversarial attacks in more practical and rigorous scenarios. For commercial cloud speech APIs, we propose Occam, a decision-only black-box adversarial attack, where only final decisions are available to the adversary. In Occam, we formulate the decision-only AE generation as a discontinuous large-scale global optimization problem, and solve it by adaptively decomposing this complicated problem into a set of sub-problems and cooperatively optimizing each one. Our Occam is a one-size-fits-all approach, which achieves 100% success rates of attacks with an average SNR of 14.23dB, on a wide range of popular speech and speaker recognition APIs, including Google, Alibaba, Microsoft, Tencent, iFlytek, and Jingdong, outperforming the state-of-the-art black-box attacks. For commercial voice control devices, we propose NI-Occam, the first non-interactive physical adversarial attack, where the adversary does not need to query the oracle and has no access to its internal information and training data. We combine adversarial attacks with model inversion attacks, and thus generate the physically-effective audio AEs with high transferability without any interaction with target devices. Our experimental results show that NI-Occam can successfully fool Apple Siri, Microsoft Cortana, Google Assistant, iFlytek and Amazon Echo with an average SRoA of 52% and SNR of 9.65dB, shedding light on non-interactive physical attacks against voice control devices.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2110.09714v2
"2021-11-30T07:46:54"
"2021-10-19T03:36:35"
{ "title": [ 0.010559082, 0.0046424866, -0.035736084, -0.069885254, 0.027374268, -0.012374878, -0.023742676, -0.003921509, -0.047180176, 0.04348755, 0.012702942, 0.03781128, -0.021194458, -0.0140686035, -0.033966064, -0.0049934387, -0.009819031, 0.045928955, -0.005470276, -0.035125732, 0.008354187, -0.04852295, 0.028961182, 0.012519836, 0.026855469, -0.0713501, -0.0023288727, -0.00894165, 0.0064353943, -0.03466797, -0.00091695786, 0.0018367767, 0.034851074, 0.05343628, -0.032409668, 0.024047852, -0.06237793, 0.054351807, 0.017105103, -0.005302429, 0.01751709, -0.0037574768, -0.0011444092, 0.013053894, -0.018493652, 0.021621704, -0.058776855, -0.041534424, -0.029449463, 0.056396484, 0.021820068, 0.0395813, 0.0014228821, 0.045806885, 0.016860962, -0.048858643, -0.03466797, 0.0029354095, 0.037261963, 0.079589844, 0.03793335, -0.05770874, -0.0010414124, -0.040618896, -0.02331543, -0.010986328, -0.000062704086, 0.018249512, 0.038879395, -0.010887146, -0.0002322197, 0.010482788, 0.03060913, -0.009086609, -0.039093018, -0.012214661, 0.023223877, -0.002691269, 0.042297363, -0.037750244, -0.0060310364, -0.009124756, -0.0067596436, -0.024353027, 0.03161621, -0.008598328, -0.019546509, -0.012199402, -0.04776001, -0.047180176, -0.011047363, -0.014816284, 0.0041923523, -0.022842407, -0.028549194, -0.033111572, -0.0036087036, 0.035491943, -0.005126953, -0.027236938, -0.026306152, 0.03353882, -0.056884766, -0.01285553, 0.016693115, 0.028381348, -0.0030269623, -0.02204895, 0.0096206665, 0.01399231, -0.04043579, 0.03060913, 0.015525818, -0.004009247, -0.014381409, 0.015975952, 0.006210327, 0.00084781647, 0.015533447, 0.029129028, -0.004638672, -0.02029419, 0.03994751, -0.015823364, 0.02949524, 0.0064697266, -0.05407715, -0.020523071, -0.0052261353, 0.041412354, -0.0059394836, 0.052703857, -0.084350586, -0.09844971, -0.06695557, 0.033172607, -0.024002075, 0.008201599, 0.0068969727, -0.00075769424, -0.0071792603, -0.044891357, 0.0041999817, 0.025421143, -0.004558563, -0.004760742, 0.059448242, 0.0021629333, -0.043395996, -0.021728516, -0.037322998, 0.009635925, 0.020553589, 0.023254395, -0.020767212, 0.0022411346, -0.0418396, -0.03579712, 0.00141716, -0.029159546, 0.026306152, 0.0012607574, -0.0045394897, 0.0446167, 0.052520752, 0.006034851, -0.016662598, 0.02458191, 0.010932922, 0.019378662, -0.007583618, 0.016357422, -0.010299683, 0.011520386, -0.006286621, 0.0074424744, 0.023727417, 0.031982422, 0.028945923, -0.025756836, 0.0036563873, -0.033172607, 0.05166626, 0.014801025, -0.08166504, 0.01889038, 0.0050201416, 0.031707764, 0.03616333, -0.003042221, 0.0093307495, 0.03286743, -0.038085938, -0.038085938, -0.030288696, -0.012649536, 0.013534546, 0.023284912, -0.0073051453, 0.02444458, -0.010185242, 0.0104522705, -0.045715332, -0.0067214966, -0.032073975, -0.031188965, -0.02305603, 0.024749756, -0.053100586, 0.02758789, 0.07531738, 0.0131073, -0.056610107, 0.020401001, -0.0020866394, -0.042022705, 0.019821167, 0.01473999, -0.0090789795, -0.020324707, -0.036712646, -0.010055542, 0.003967285, 0.035736084, 0.03237915, 0.01020813, 0.015701294, -0.028289795, 0.093444824, 0.022033691, 0.0793457, -0.057281494, 0.05783081, 0.052612305, 0.001045227, -0.032165527, -0.029373169, -0.036956787, -0.0011663437, 0.033325195, 0.003850937, -0.03100586, -0.006095886, 0.009269714, 0.024139404, -0.043029785, 0.0024814606, 0.026367188, 0.028442383, 0.034576416, 0.046722412, 0.008094788, 0.03237915, 0.001625061, 0.020721436, 0.036193848, 0.017974854, 0.038909912, -0.035491943, 0.005847931, -0.006626129, 0.021743774, -0.004886627, 0.013557434, -0.047973633, 0.008049011, -0.026443481, 0.006336212, 0.020401001, 0.01448822, 0.011314392, -0.07281494, 0.0076560974, 0.010986328, 0.027877808, -0.018447876, -0.027053833, 0.01259613, 0.01197052, -0.0357666, -0.011306763, 0.0037498474, 0.028884888, -0.008720398, -0.00040078163, -0.005958557, 0.027786255, -0.012794495, -0.017227173, -0.021331787, 0.041168213, 0.05441284, -0.0011510849, 0.0071754456, 0.014289856, -0.0027656555, 0.058624268, 0.042877197, -0.016571045, 0.027999878, -0.03390503, 0.041503906, 0.022064209, -0.004508972, 0.0012340546, 0.021957397, 0.00724411, 0.01687622, -0.033447266, 0.0050468445, -0.050323486, 0.0071105957, -0.011543274, -0.046325684, -0.064208984, -0.068725586, -0.035369873, -0.062805176, -0.07867432, 0.021087646, 0.09857178, -0.033843994, -0.0058517456, -0.009765625, -0.023223877, -0.043701172, 0.008285522, -0.032318115, 0.0026817322, 0.032440186, 0.05331421, 0.028442383, -0.050689697, -0.03366089, 0.005718231, 0.016952515, -0.0054092407, 0.012786865, -0.01398468, -0.00034332275, 0.021636963, -0.037261963, -0.012672424, -0.011360168, 0.018844604, -0.0385437, -0.0049972534, 0.034057617, -0.040222168, 0.0071792603, 0.014213562, -0.03152466, -0.0060157776, -0.022994995, 0.045318604, 0.00831604, -0.037353516, -0.010169983, 0.02406311, -0.03289795, 0.03050232, 0.040130615, 0.023117065, -0.039031982, -0.05130005, -0.049041748, 0.008033752, 0.0017652512, 0.003932953, 0.058776855, -0.03692627, 0.0020122528, -0.06311035, -0.02355957, 0.0037193298, 0.0064086914, -0.03161621, -0.053253174, -0.0023860931, -0.034606934, -0.029785156, -0.012207031, -0.0107421875, 0.027404785, 0.09472656, 0.0019483566, -0.040405273, -0.0058288574, 0.026351929, 0.015289307, -0.004573822, -0.021957397, -0.04119873, 0.008926392, 0.017211914, 0.0048446655, 0.010932922, -0.00674057, -0.08911133, -0.015281677, 0.040771484, -0.0052337646, -0.028839111, 0.02142334, -0.055114746, -0.019546509, 0.011924744, -0.025741577, 0.017364502, 0.035217285, 0.017120361, -0.0067329407, 0.02268982, -0.030044556, 0.010757446, -0.03817749, -0.07086182, 0.027038574, 0.022842407, -0.059906006, -0.046661377, -0.01637268, -0.05621338, -0.013259888, -0.028640747, 0.050750732, 0.01448822, 0.010391235, 0.017471313, -0.01676941, 0.001127243, -0.026657104, -0.01499939, -0.02734375, -0.026123047, 0.015037537, 0.0077285767, 0.047790527, 0.036346436, -0.0058784485, -0.036132812, -0.023788452, -0.02444458, 0.04876709, -0.0056877136, -0.030838013, -0.033447266, -0.043762207, -0.0209198, 0.013748169, 0.0004272461, -0.008415222, -0.026565552, 0.0096206665, -0.013183594, 0.06933594, -0.010643005, 0.01411438, -0.020874023, -0.016952515, 0.0069999695, -0.031311035, -0.027374268, 0.0016202927, 0.03515625, -0.012313843, 0.021652222, -0.0126953125, -0.018630981, 0.020523071, -0.0004644394, -0.0076522827, -0.00187397, -0.008354187, 0.003435135, -0.020309448, -0.022750854, 0.033843994, -0.037200928, -0.005367279, -0.010154724, -0.0022659302, 0.017044067, -0.04824829, 0.011367798, 0.008865356, -0.068481445, -0.006965637, 0.01638794, -0.06542969, -0.052215576, -0.03451538, 0.024673462, -0.038635254, -0.012512207, -0.020492554, -0.012435913, -0.03100586, -0.016662598, -0.09033203, -0.016677856, 0.076171875, 0.003129959, 0.032409668, 0.04626465, -0.014389038, -0.037841797, -0.029953003, 0.0028419495, -0.0018062592, 0.015426636, -0.004436493, -0.0069351196, 0.03729248, -0.029067993, 0.017807007, 0.029220581, 0.033294678, -0.0032672882, -0.010124207, 0.043121338, 0.04058838, -0.028076172, 0.058624268, 0.0009441376, -0.018859863, -0.06945801, -0.02949524, 0.004878998, -0.018218994, -0.0004963875, -0.033233643, 0.029449463, 0.037872314, 0.009712219, 0.070617676, -0.023956299, -0.006629944, 0.042419434, 0.004009247, -0.029052734, -0.03829956, 0.015945435, 0.03262329, -0.000223279, 0.010887146, -0.012382507, 0.026367188, -0.009429932, -0.037719727, 0.012802124, 0.028137207, -0.031982422, -0.013450623, -0.057800293, -0.021560669, -0.024414062, 0.00422287, -0.015052795, 0.040863037, 0.033325195, 0.0021896362, -0.020614624, -0.004711151, 0.056793213, -0.005329132, 0.019058228, -0.048797607, -0.010421753, -0.002193451, -0.056274414, -0.019622803, 0.019256592, -0.011756897, 0.028671265, -0.0287323, 0.0045661926, 0.026992798, 0.025466919, 0.025436401, 0.050079346, -0.027877808, -0.030075073, 0.028411865, -0.027450562, -0.036346436, 0.028259277, -0.00667572, -0.003484726, -0.012901306, 0.0519104, -0.044403076, -0.016067505, -0.010910034, 0.052734375, -0.035583496, 0.06744385, -0.018966675, 0.04547119, 0.024612427, 0.00015819073, 0.0005517006, 0.018188477, -0.04046631, 0.0068969727, -0.017532349, 0.013549805, -0.034729004, 0.01146698, 0.06921387, -0.004333496, -0.006061554, 0.0014896393, -0.0065956116, 0.022003174, 0.032348633, -0.0011529922, 0.013618469, -0.0602417, -0.03817749, 0.0017576218, 0.008926392, 0.054992676, -0.05895996, 0.03253174, -0.057403564, -0.009597778, 0.03845215, 0.013145447, 0.015419006, 0.01991272, 0.012359619, -0.039855957, -0.016296387, 0.031921387, 0.01184845, -0.024841309, 0.017196655, -0.020721436, -0.016799927, 0.020446777, 0.052825928, 0.0234375, 0.017959595, -0.003479004, -0.0074272156, 0.0017557144, -0.029724121, -0.041046143, -0.010894775, -0.006843567, 0.0058174133, -0.044830322, 0.031219482, -0.04852295, -0.013305664, -0.0054512024, -0.011978149, 0.014633179, -0.06463623, 0.019897461, 0.061065674, 0.0028762817, 0.036956787, -0.00034594536, 0.006111145, 0.004257202, 0.076660156, -0.021408081, 0.028320312, 0.060028076, -0.04562378, 0.027389526, -0.0012311935, 0.029129028, 0.0151901245, 0.010665894, 0.01876831, 0.013381958, -0.056671143, 0.017074585, 0.040161133, 0.014450073, 0.03286743, -0.06402588, 0.022216797, 0.020553589, -0.027069092, -0.00012099743, -0.02848816, -0.010398865, 0.031402588, -0.033599854, -0.0075149536, 0.010002136, -0.03050232, -0.044525146, -0.027801514, 0.0030899048, -0.005355835, 0.02482605, -0.0033874512, -0.0051879883, -0.03930664, 0.030471802, 0.022354126, -0.046875, -0.02748108, -0.024230957, 0.014625549, 0.017807007, 0.021530151, -0.0413208, -0.010246277, -0.019485474, -0.02973938, -0.023254395, 0.013786316, 0.019363403, 0.010482788, -0.017303467, -0.04711914, 0.009292603, -0.006008148, 0.01852417, 0.029891968, -0.012283325, 0.019683838, 0.0017604828, 0.009048462, 0.01600647, 0.026321411, 0.030471802, 0.002002716, -0.012916565, -0.04940796, 0.018218994, 0.006641388, 0.017227173, -0.023208618, -0.045440674, -0.002040863, 0.026245117, 0.0079574585, -0.01499176, 0.022369385, 0.039916992, -0.028518677, 0.014793396, 0.013343811, 0.05834961, -0.04977417, -0.01713562, 0.0010871887, -0.0026798248, -0.014427185, 0.07116699, -0.0072784424, -0.021987915, -0.058624268, -0.047058105, -0.031921387, 0.007873535, 0.017059326, 0.023162842, 0.037506104, -0.00894165, 0.03744507, -0.03756714, -0.0154953, -0.021453857, 0.023284912, -0.0063285828, 0.0038795471, 0.00141716, -0.005844116, 0.0010709763, -0.0418396, 0.006752014, 0.004108429, 0.0069084167, -0.0047416687, -0.028671265, 0.018249512, -0.031555176, -0.033599854, 0.04925537, 0.013122559, -0.026687622, 0.037078857, -0.0006260872, 0.04852295, 0.030685425, 0.051757812, 0.03564453, 0.0031280518, 0.029663086, 0.012413025, -0.004589081, -0.03515625, 0.023651123, -0.047668457, -0.016738892, -0.080078125, -0.024902344, -0.09820557, 0.026779175, -0.012138367, 0.03768921, -0.0002746582, 0.018188477, 0.04168701, -0.0068473816, 0.045715332, -0.06335449, 0.059783936, 0.021194458, 0.01737976, -0.008743286, -0.034301758, 0.035736084, 0.030578613, -0.027832031, 0.035308838, -0.024963379, -0.0072784424, 0.0065574646, 0.0030841827, 0.019226074, -0.01600647, -0.018692017, -0.031066895, 0.04736328, 0.010643005, 0.043060303, 0.047729492, 0.036346436, 0.0107421875, -0.025115967, -0.001543045, -0.030151367, -0.03161621, -0.005432129, 0.035064697, -0.052825928, 0.02519226, -0.020111084, -0.018920898, -0.021499634, 0.022369385, 0.02545166, -0.05706787, -0.042938232, 0.043121338, 0.04525757, 0.0036334991, 0.010665894, -0.045013428, -0.04977417, -0.022781372, 0.04144287, -0.03286743, -0.00349617, -0.0005059242, 0.04562378, -0.03967285, -0.012825012, -0.0129852295, -0.0023727417, -0.046173096, 0.012519836, -0.016616821, 0.02809143, -0.0099105835, -0.02684021, -0.010932922, 0.0146102905, -0.046447754, -0.036895752, 0.04058838, 0.04876709, 0.03366089, 0.064208984, 0.015670776, -0.027542114, 0.02255249, -0.034942627, 0.014450073, 0.05706787, -0.013313293, 0.020523071, -0.034973145, -0.044677734, 0.043395996, -0.024917603, 0.09613037, -0.016952515, -0.00041508675, -0.036712646, 0.00333786, 0.035736084, -0.058441162, 0.028015137, -0.028396606, 0.025558472, -0.025756836, -0.011795044, -0.030654907, -0.055511475, -0.012672424, 0.062072754, -0.00062036514, 0.0049209595, 0.0032691956, -0.014457703, -0.039733887, 0.011833191, -0.031951904, 0.045959473, -0.030441284, -0.018615723, -0.03378296, 0.015258789, 0.021224976, -0.004058838, -0.019363403, -0.01008606, -0.026733398, -0.054718018, 0.025344849, 0.013366699, -0.021652222, 0.013442993, -0.027893066, 0.012817383, -0.018585205, 0.017852783, 0.041625977, -0.025039673, -0.079833984, -0.007183075, -0.02192688, 0.03314209, -0.0011377335, -0.012817383, 0.024887085, 0.01600647, -0.027618408, 0.024261475, 0.02911377, 0.06933594, -0.014053345, -0.059509277, 0.013908386, 0.029342651, 0.036346436, -0.049041748, -0.032836914, 0.020339966, 0.034942627, -0.01020813, 0.009742737, 0.0061683655, -0.0043907166, 0.01927185, 0.027359009, 0.009338379, -0.05142212, -0.041992188, -0.021469116, 0.06317139, 0.03378296, -0.011505127, -0.01864624, 0.016052246, -0.011566162, -0.0012359619, -0.01663208, -0.01058197, 0.0036525726, -0.0066947937, 0.033203125, -0.0065727234, 0.003168106, -0.040985107, 0.03704834, -0.0019416809, 0.0395813, -0.016815186, 0.021316528, 0.012077332, 0.029541016, -0.036346436, -0.08685303, 0.02935791, 0.045776367, -0.021621704, 0.05496216, -0.050445557, -0.026000977, -0.007896423, 0.015052795, -0.0069732666, 0.020614624, 0.003276825, -0.0077934265, 0.019058228, -0.028671265, -0.060150146, -0.043670654, -0.039154053, 0.04067993, -0.027633667, 0.021453857, -0.009979248, 0.001329422, -0.0096206665, 0.030258179, 0.0021591187, -0.008590698, -0.07885742, -0.025375366, 0.056396484, -0.039398193 ], "summary": [ 0.007686615, -0.0049057007, -0.005054474, -0.017349243, -0.014694214, -0.004257202, -0.039398193, -0.037963867, -0.05404663, 0.030715942, 0.005718231, 0.025482178, 0.006000519, -0.033569336, 0.033172607, -0.02279663, -0.017700195, 0.005332947, -0.030471802, -0.042999268, 0.003967285, -0.03189087, -0.029785156, -0.042266846, 0.012329102, -0.059326172, 0.046447754, -0.012763977, 0.020584106, 0.0015115738, 0.017562866, -0.008003235, 0.022079468, 0.0149383545, -0.019363403, -0.027709961, -0.047973633, 0.02961731, 0.012809753, -0.01008606, 0.027694702, -0.001876831, 0.017700195, -0.019042969, 0.0016832352, -0.010681152, 0.015235901, -0.03945923, 0.030273438, 0.010681152, 0.004055023, 0.01335907, 0.003894806, -0.012062073, -0.009796143, 0.010398865, -0.053619385, 0.029663086, 0.0206604, 0.046966553, 0.013771057, -0.025497437, -0.004878998, -0.039520264, 0.006591797, -0.001502037, 0.044433594, 0.011009216, 0.031066895, -0.0073509216, -0.018096924, 0.02180481, 0.03515625, -0.06112671, -0.020401001, 0.036071777, 0.010681152, 0.012107849, 0.021118164, -0.056732178, 0.008728027, 0.036590576, 0.008857727, -0.06414795, 0.045288086, -0.027130127, -0.014419556, -0.024017334, -0.038024902, -0.0022945404, -0.029296875, -0.054840088, -0.006378174, 0.01828003, 0.007331848, -0.042633057, -0.01020813, -0.018722534, 0.03933716, 0.003501892, 0.009880066, -0.034240723, 0.011726379, -0.023498535, -0.00566864, 0.062072754, 0.02166748, -0.035095215, -0.018341064, -0.02331543, -0.026779175, 0.007091522, -0.028717041, -0.032928467, -0.006664276, 0.05630493, -0.00067043304, 0.022277832, 0.007713318, 0.0062942505, -0.010238647, 0.0052986145, 0.016708374, 0.056610107, 0.02935791, 0.057037354, 0.0023078918, -0.02960205, -0.011734009, 0.010925293, -0.009147644, 0.023803711, 0.00065755844, -0.009880066, -0.019332886, -0.002773285, -0.0038166046, -0.00070762634, 0.021408081, -0.029708862, 0.049468994, -0.019424438, -0.009277344, 0.033477783, -0.0126571655, 0.045532227, 0.027557373, -0.0132369995, -0.016525269, -0.047088623, -0.019454956, -0.016983032, 0.008087158, 0.031280518, 0.017181396, -0.00075244904, 0.035461426, -0.017578125, -0.0032978058, -0.034332275, 0.040527344, -0.010437012, -0.017150879, 0.097961426, 0.06976318, 0.016052246, 0.0028514862, 0.036590576, 0.0019741058, 0.030838013, -0.028320312, 0.015342712, 0.005428314, 0.004386902, -0.0054779053, -0.00038862228, -0.021453857, 0.04119873, 0.04425049, -0.004638672, 0.019989014, -0.033691406, 0.06304932, 0.0022411346, -0.045410156, 0.04534912, -0.00003772974, 0.07092285, -0.0044403076, 0.008735657, 0.039489746, 0.025909424, 0.012008667, -0.016082764, -0.01486969, -0.038360596, 0.0036773682, -0.0038013458, -0.029159546, 0.032318115, 0.046325684, 0.02709961, -0.026611328, -0.0262146, -0.07519531, 0.0023345947, -0.010406494, 0.026535034, -0.030700684, 0.024383545, 0.037017822, -0.02229309, -0.055389404, 0.07574463, 0.027435303, -0.05343628, 0.0019073486, 0.008506775, 0.0102005005, -0.0053100586, 0.006008148, 0.00699234, -0.003282547, 0.015281677, 0.028839111, 0.010276794, -0.0008392334, 0.01184082, 0.11553955, 0.010879517, 0.07043457, -0.034698486, 0.038482666, 0.054229736, -0.01576233, -0.03643799, -0.032928467, -0.068847656, 0.0158844, 0.056121826, 0.027694702, -0.018493652, -0.02708435, -0.0075531006, -0.017211914, -0.037139893, 0.013420105, -0.008361816, -0.04043579, -0.007621765, 0.021865845, 0.025787354, 0.008758545, -0.02607727, 0.0045204163, 0.021972656, 0.0005955696, -0.011482239, -0.0008368492, -0.00566864, 0.0044403076, -0.027679443, -0.03253174, -0.0017738342, -0.0034389496, -0.05847168, -0.019485474, -0.025863647, 0.032836914, -0.038879395, 0.012619019, -0.08483887, 0.006465912, 0.02218628, 0.01966858, -0.015899658, -0.03765869, 0.011131287, 0.02897644, 0.0022716522, 0.010726929, 0.026290894, 0.0099105835, -0.00042128563, 0.019195557, 0.0002937317, 0.018096924, 0.031311035, -0.007286072, 0.053649902, 0.040252686, 0.08001709, 0.051239014, -0.0031280518, -0.036987305, 0.037628174, -0.034118652, -0.008049011, 0.032409668, -0.03237915, -0.03717041, 0.059783936, -0.005340576, 0.021484375, -0.0023002625, -0.016204834, -0.005367279, 0.011428833, -0.0024261475, -0.024505615, -0.018951416, 0.025314331, -0.006011963, 0.0181427, -0.051330566, -0.058898926, -0.030899048, -0.0061035156, -0.05581665, -0.006374359, 0.10455322, -0.020492554, 0.03604126, 0.026550293, -0.020431519, -0.080200195, 0.06994629, -0.01576233, 0.016723633, 0.042663574, 0.04135132, 0.05001831, 0.0034427643, -0.019088745, -0.002494812, -0.007545471, 0.030273438, -0.040924072, 0.0019798279, 0.0058250427, 0.05154419, -0.03274536, -0.029830933, -0.005466461, -0.023483276, 0.002735138, -0.02809143, 0.016326904, -0.02355957, -0.01626587, 0.014221191, -0.021224976, 0.00056934357, 0.0058670044, 0.01663208, 0.007144928, -0.013801575, 0.0022850037, 0.025604248, -0.03414917, 0.079589844, 0.0385437, 0.059692383, -0.0074691772, -0.09313965, -0.04989624, 0.049041748, 0.011657715, 0.019515991, 0.044677734, -0.049194336, 0.029006958, -0.018447876, -0.014045715, 0.0045776367, 0.020355225, 0.06921387, -0.040161133, -0.011077881, 0.031951904, -0.061767578, -0.013130188, -0.013679504, 0.05105591, 0.068237305, 0.0056266785, 0.010643005, 0.021911621, 0.031707764, -0.00920105, -0.008094788, -0.00894165, -0.024551392, -0.011749268, 0.030395508, 0.019805908, -0.00233078, 0.018417358, -0.028366089, -0.03616333, 0.030548096, 0.010620117, -0.02746582, 0.01171875, -0.0002425909, -0.016662598, 0.056793213, -0.026611328, 0.000916481, -0.030532837, 0.01828003, -0.031082153, 0.0058250427, -0.04324341, 0.008575439, -0.04019165, 0.016235352, 0.010612488, 0.010559082, -0.039276123, -0.03918457, 0.07098389, -0.017425537, 0.017333984, -0.0014791489, 0.031082153, -0.004459381, -0.007041931, -0.015899658, 0.016311646, 0.007835388, -0.020599365, -0.02784729, 0.009399414, 0.002937317, 0.027511597, 0.026031494, -0.0037784576, 0.06414795, -0.04144287, -0.024169922, -0.016799927, -0.017608643, 0.0041885376, -0.012680054, -0.014251709, -0.015167236, -0.029953003, -0.04522705, 0.03036499, -0.016235352, -0.004589081, -0.017562866, 0.04034424, -0.028701782, 0.11993408, -0.022201538, 0.0113220215, 0.05142212, -0.02961731, -0.036956787, -0.010398865, 0.007205963, -0.010482788, 0.04562378, -0.022613525, 0.015419006, 0.019256592, 0.010017395, -0.008399963, 0.042175293, -0.013038635, -0.026168823, -0.028320312, 0.005619049, -0.0463562, 0.020263672, 0.039001465, -0.0029296875, -0.0317688, -0.029769897, -0.0063056946, -0.008293152, -0.0012922287, 0.02659607, 0.006088257, -0.020523071, 0.015609741, 0.0017089844, -0.03265381, 0.017608643, -0.005748749, 0.059387207, -0.05529785, 0.026687622, -0.054016113, -0.019973755, 0.03353882, -0.018432617, -0.066345215, 0.026885986, -0.026504517, 0.013916016, 0.038269043, -0.036346436, 0.020141602, 0.021820068, -0.01902771, -0.021896362, -0.050872803, 0.0035648346, -0.064086914, 0.035003662, -0.006843567, -0.009254456, 0.020736694, 0.0029945374, 0.06982422, -0.016845703, -0.032348633, 0.0602417, 0.028411865, -0.00009047985, 0.0015668869, 0.012809753, 0.005874634, -0.028289795, -0.017608643, 0.021469116, -0.06695557, 0.04333496, -0.008872986, -0.012481689, 0.06640625, -0.015579224, 0.0519104, -0.032806396, -0.01890564, 0.050354004, 0.0132369995, -0.007572174, -0.018951416, -0.004589081, 0.058532715, -0.0158844, 0.03677368, -0.035369873, 0.04724121, -0.03189087, 0.029342651, -0.005710602, -0.0039634705, -0.039916992, -0.0418396, -0.027999878, 0.03050232, 0.0033340454, -0.01234436, -0.015098572, 0.017150879, 0.013504028, 0.001627922, 0.019378662, -0.030319214, 0.08734131, 0.005645752, 0.021713257, -0.05996704, -0.020401001, 0.008102417, -0.041656494, -0.005973816, 0.07458496, -0.0135269165, 0.00440979, -0.072143555, 0.011459351, 0.02720642, 0.0033073425, -0.015419006, 0.023864746, -0.012367249, -0.02255249, -0.02986145, -0.010482788, -0.012176514, 0.038726807, -0.042053223, 0.011054993, 0.010726929, 0.020401001, -0.013671875, -0.022903442, -0.019134521, 0.010444641, -0.0034599304, 0.03086853, 0.018814087, 0.03289795, 0.016052246, 0.025360107, -0.022705078, -0.002292633, -0.0071105957, 0.040863037, -0.021133423, -0.004463196, 0.029693604, -0.02545166, 0.0105896, -0.018707275, -0.024520874, 0.047546387, -0.0087509155, 0.04046631, 0.0016679764, -0.028793335, 0.011604309, 0.010498047, -0.0020217896, 0.02217102, -0.008766174, 0.030517578, 0.018508911, -0.026763916, -0.030654907, 0.0019817352, 0.01725769, 0.018157959, 0.02494812, 0.042114258, 0.013504028, -0.0026779175, 0.0023269653, 0.03112793, -0.00053834915, -0.0013513565, -0.00819397, -0.04525757, -0.021392822, 0.007286072, -0.015853882, -0.05822754, -0.008415222, 0.008003235, -0.018035889, -0.014625549, 0.024475098, -0.0149002075, -0.04336548, -0.036315918, -0.02357483, -0.007549286, 0.005504608, -0.019515991, -0.015388489, -0.008895874, 0.024551392, -0.019805908, -0.026901245, -0.04925537, -0.028747559, 0.008605957, -0.03237915, 0.018493652, 0.008407593, -0.021774292, 0.046844482, -0.045715332, 0.035491943, 0.011871338, -0.03717041, 0.020874023, -0.02659607, -0.0049324036, 0.026687622, -0.00970459, 0.019256592, 0.002149582, -0.0065689087, 0.015579224, 0.021514893, 0.028823853, -0.025390625, -0.009788513, 0.04135132, -0.023040771, -0.0060539246, -0.012771606, 0.016677856, -0.014953613, 0.032928467, 0.014434814, 0.0262146, -0.028411865, -0.0040283203, 0.012489319, 0.044006348, -0.008705139, -0.021560669, 0.06970215, 0.015541077, -0.029556274, 0.0011863708, -0.040252686, 0.008728027, -0.012252808, -0.008682251, -0.015686035, 0.031433105, -0.032348633, -0.021438599, -0.013336182, -0.0009937286, -0.014411926, -0.008407593, 0.0062217712, 0.007255554, -0.0068511963, 0.0317688, 0.026535034, -0.001745224, 0.03189087, 0.011459351, 0.036010742, -0.01335907, -0.011444092, 0.04638672, -0.0070152283, -0.015037537, 0.024536133, -0.024734497, 0.011627197, 0.0073127747, -0.005256653, -0.047210693, 0.044189453, -0.030563354, -0.008087158, -0.055480957, 0.010940552, -0.020477295, 0.03427124, -0.02822876, -0.039642334, -0.0055618286, 0.00894928, -0.064819336, 0.04446411, -0.025497437, 0.07684326, 0.000995636, -0.046539307, 0.0126953125, 0.021240234, 0.027191162, 0.039093018, 0.017150879, -0.043792725, -0.022842407, -0.022201538, -0.009376526, -0.0037956238, 0.025115967, -0.015686035, 0.047943115, -0.001045227, -0.00869751, -0.020523071, -0.002653122, -0.01084137, 0.0028305054, -0.0021762848, 0.045562744, 0.008796692, -0.0021457672, 0.006629944, -0.037384033, 0.016906738, 0.012756348, 0.000008702278, 0.026794434, 0.005405426, 0.003944397, -0.046569824, 0.008033752, 0.048339844, 0.03955078, -0.014976501, 0.04586792, 0.013809204, 0.015319824, 0.051116943, -0.026550293, -0.040374756, -0.042022705, 0.046203613, 0.018569946, -0.03286743, -0.014701843, 0.014030457, 0.008781433, -0.08081055, -0.06048584, -0.05480957, -0.01285553, 0.050048828, -0.042022705, 0.036743164, 0.01663208, 0.023910522, 0.06524658, -0.0055274963, -0.011528015, -0.08001709, 0.056793213, 0.03756714, 0.019485474, 0.014671326, 0.0064201355, -0.017456055, 0.014419556, -0.051727295, 0.071899414, -0.023071289, 0.0059051514, 0.018966675, -0.022201538, -0.013786316, -0.021209717, 0.008895874, -0.023147583, 0.033447266, 0.03466797, 0.043884277, 0.011665344, 0.010597229, 0.0078125, 0.0011129379, 0.003358841, -0.0063591003, 0.0011835098, -0.019134521, 0.0015821457, -0.0025806427, 0.0014619827, -0.009056091, -0.021957397, -0.0011692047, 0.039123535, 0.036132812, -0.020462036, 0.009597778, 0.022415161, 0.0059661865, -0.01146698, 0.004257202, -0.026260376, -0.06756592, -0.015411377, 0.027282715, -0.035095215, -0.0059432983, -0.025909424, -0.007675171, -0.00907135, 0.010803223, 0.0070495605, 0.035736084, -0.021331787, 0.025772095, -0.07122803, 0.027648926, -0.0007944107, -0.016311646, 0.03338623, 0.017868042, 0.01373291, -0.003967285, 0.10601807, 0.08709717, 0.04611206, 0.04006958, -0.039794922, -0.004425049, 0.08874512, -0.0076065063, 0.033355713, 0.028533936, 0.010360718, -0.019897461, 0.00071907043, -0.0076789856, 0.03918457, 0.026184082, 0.09259033, -0.0012464523, -0.03062439, -0.053833008, 0.012283325, -0.043395996, -0.022216797, 0.06317139, -0.07196045, 0.0501709, -0.007457733, 0.027648926, -0.04901123, -0.025741577, -0.027389526, 0.021560669, -0.021499634, -0.012313843, 0.014144897, -0.008171082, 0.010040283, 0.017288208, 0.008583069, 0.04840088, 0.006916046, -0.021957397, -0.015029907, 0.041503906, 0.010292053, -0.049102783, -0.010543823, 0.010368347, 0.001701355, -0.0715332, 0.046722412, 0.026550293, -0.0029010773, 0.037017822, -0.031234741, 0.017974854, -0.009361267, 0.04953003, 0.045166016, 0.009147644, -0.049621582, 0.016052246, -0.010635376, 0.012207031, -0.054016113, -0.018188477, 0.055541992, -0.021148682, -0.011306763, 0.053710938, 0.057373047, 0.07672119, -0.034820557, -0.059936523, 0.027389526, 0.008453369, 0.031921387, -0.010620117, 0.011016846, 0.0126571655, 0.046203613, -0.019348145, -0.024383545, -0.013694763, -0.0046920776, 0.04937744, 0.054779053, 0.0070877075, -0.053955078, -0.03302002, -0.003824234, 0.053955078, -0.0046806335, -0.042236328, 0.00020289421, 0.01108551, -0.041809082, -0.0017242432, -0.038116455, -0.013931274, -0.019104004, -0.005065918, 0.024093628, 0.019470215, 0.044036865, -0.020874023, -0.004787445, -0.0006079674, -0.006877899, -0.02029419, 0.033966064, -0.030319214, -0.0209198, -0.012916565, -0.050842285, 0.017288208, 0.017730713, 0.0008234978, -0.00806427, -0.0012836456, -0.016082764, -0.007091522, 0.018554688, 0.034454346, 0.046844482, -0.045837402, 0.004798889, 0.024383545, -0.06750488, -0.047088623, -0.08581543, -0.041656494, 0.010360718, 0.019927979, 0.017120361, 0.07305908, -0.004940033, 0.028320312, 0.020706177, 0.019622803, 0.06726074, -0.078552246, -0.0065574646, -0.016067505, -0.05154419 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2110.13423v2
Towards More Generalizable One-shot Visual Imitation Learning
Zhao Mandi, Fangchen Liu, Kimin Lee, Pieter Abbeel
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
A general-purpose robot should be able to master a wide range of tasks and quickly learn a novel one by leveraging past experiences. One-shot imitation learning (OSIL) approaches this goal by training an agent with (pairs of) expert demonstrations, such that at test time, it can directly execute a new task from just one demonstration. However, so far this framework has been limited to training on many variations of one task, and testing on other unseen but similar variations of the same task. In this work, we push for a higher level of generalization ability by investigating a more ambitious multi-task setup. We introduce a diverse suite of vision-based robot manipulation tasks, consisting of 7 tasks, a total of 61 variations, and a continuum of instances within each variation. For consistency and comparison purposes, we first train and evaluate single-task agents (as done in prior few-shot imitation work). We then study the multi-task setting, where multi-task training is followed by (i) one-shot imitation on variations within the training tasks, (ii) one-shot imitation on new tasks, and (iii) fine-tuning on new tasks. Prior state-of-the-art, while performing well within some single tasks, struggles in these harder multi-task settings. To address these limitations, we propose MOSAIC (Multi-task One-Shot Imitation with self-Attention and Contrastive learning), which integrates a self-attention model architecture and a temporal contrastive module to enable better task disambiguation and more robust representation learning. Our experiments show that MOSAIC outperforms prior state of the art in learning efficiency, final performance, and learns a multi-task policy with promising generalization ability via fine-tuning on novel tasks.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2110.13423v2
"2022-02-08T06:17:45"
"2021-10-26T05:49:46"
{ "title": [ 0.010856628, 0.00434494, -0.006385803, -0.03488159, 0.008934021, -0.0071907043, 0.0022258759, -0.017318726, -0.0045280457, 0.022247314, -0.037384033, 0.026473999, -0.026824951, -0.006477356, -0.033081055, -0.0062217712, -0.0029125214, 0.025375366, -0.034484863, -0.040740967, -0.011352539, -0.048309326, 0.025543213, 0.06976318, 0.0395813, -0.02998352, -0.10235596, 0.029693604, -0.038482666, -0.02204895, -0.0096588135, 0.022537231, 0.035064697, 0.03353882, -0.019851685, 0.01335144, -0.053375244, 0.028961182, 0.01235199, -0.0011444092, 0.010307312, -0.016326904, -0.036315918, -0.03363037, -0.040924072, 0.023025513, -0.043823242, -0.014801025, -0.019577026, 0.038848877, 0.024505615, 0.042663574, -0.013618469, 0.048309326, 0.028381348, -0.021255493, -0.03265381, -0.021377563, 0.04989624, 0.08666992, 0.026123047, -0.060699463, 0.007320404, -0.054901123, -0.031677246, -0.0395813, -0.041534424, 0.028793335, 0.07165527, 0.017333984, -0.0067367554, 0.026306152, -0.002910614, -0.00023639202, -0.04953003, 0.010246277, 0.0602417, 0.037963867, 0.0140686035, -0.03050232, -0.0012836456, -0.03274536, 0.00007927418, -0.025009155, 0.01914978, -0.029052734, -0.01033783, -0.0012931824, -0.043273926, -0.04220581, -0.019973755, -0.010101318, -0.017089844, 0.005241394, -0.033203125, -0.011726379, -0.02532959, 0.031707764, 0.010169983, -0.01612854, -0.0064735413, 0.010276794, -0.040649414, -0.01133728, 0.017089844, -0.005908966, -0.00819397, -0.036621094, 0.013999939, 0.029037476, -0.04928589, 0.064453125, 0.0154953, 0.020584106, -0.013412476, 0.013465881, -0.014625549, 0.022338867, -0.0015459061, 0.064575195, 0.011741638, -0.01159668, 0.051208496, 0.010978699, 0.015213013, 0.020904541, -0.049041748, -0.051849365, 0.0028953552, -0.018218994, -0.0063171387, 0.05496216, -0.030395508, -0.056427002, -0.034484863, 0.040649414, -0.0073165894, -0.0052261353, -0.015319824, 0.027130127, -0.019515991, -0.03265381, 0.013771057, -0.022247314, 0.018447876, 0.013397217, 0.052490234, -0.010879517, -0.021011353, -0.045440674, -0.029144287, 0.031707764, -0.009841919, 0.005756378, -0.002910614, -0.013748169, -0.11260986, -0.0061073303, 0.06225586, 0.041381836, 0.01184082, 0.024932861, 0.018478394, 0.0473938, 0.08190918, -0.039794922, 0.017868042, 0.03326416, 0.017089844, 0.060943604, -0.02444458, 0.0038051605, 0.000060021877, -0.0037784576, -0.015777588, 0.0032653809, 0.021697998, 0.00082683563, 0.03955078, -0.029373169, 0.0013275146, -0.02420044, 0.05029297, 0.015563965, -0.028366089, -0.05722046, 0.0010147095, -0.045928955, 0.052764893, 0.014457703, -0.054351807, 0.016693115, -0.06732178, -0.023162842, -0.031799316, 0.018920898, 0.012237549, 0.042999268, 0.0020503998, -0.004562378, -0.025009155, -0.022201538, -0.0035190582, -0.008560181, -0.020339966, -0.03378296, -0.018035889, 0.0211792, -0.043670654, 0.046203613, 0.05218506, -0.002275467, -0.027572632, 0.021987915, 0.011260986, -0.06567383, 0.035888672, -0.0020809174, -0.0010585785, -0.018463135, -0.02319336, 0.0011634827, -0.0059394836, 0.043823242, 0.019454956, 0.0013160706, -0.008407593, -0.026473999, -0.008239746, 0.021591187, 0.023956299, -0.017822266, -0.018356323, -0.017059326, -0.016036987, -0.04446411, -0.03616333, -0.026565552, 0.048339844, 0.0357666, -0.0055160522, -0.012557983, -0.0018253326, 0.04019165, 0.06518555, 0.024642944, 0.0022182465, 0.025863647, 0.0137786865, 0.025527954, 0.05178833, 0.018707275, 0.039031982, -0.0071105957, 0.014213562, 0.05065918, 0.006412506, 0.042785645, -0.039520264, 0.0035991669, -0.014976501, 0.033355713, 0.03741455, 0.0057411194, -0.054901123, -0.0030765533, -0.027572632, -0.0005631447, 0.0073051453, 0.0038013458, 0.030303955, -0.032287598, -0.00082969666, -0.018478394, 0.016296387, -0.024551392, -0.030197144, 0.028823853, 0.02947998, -0.060516357, -0.0012130737, -0.0052452087, 0.043273926, -0.0011577606, 0.0357666, -0.0077285767, 0.0068588257, -0.032714844, -0.010055542, -0.024612427, 0.048095703, 0.0093307495, 0.00070524216, -0.013343811, 0.0065460205, -0.024353027, 0.06567383, 0.06774902, -0.02670288, 0.027359009, -0.025131226, 0.017929077, -0.023666382, -0.0031280518, -0.012489319, 0.012619019, -0.004764557, 0.037719727, -0.030975342, -0.014770508, -0.029785156, 0.0063056946, -0.0018825531, 0.0031814575, -0.051727295, -0.05041504, 0.003025055, -0.025436401, -0.029342651, -0.01574707, 0.07659912, -0.022766113, -0.021636963, -0.007446289, -0.008934021, -0.016494751, -0.013557434, -0.0423584, -0.007030487, 0.041778564, 0.051574707, 0.047058105, -0.038970947, -0.037902832, -0.003320694, -0.0012655258, -0.011169434, 0.0045318604, -0.009422302, 0.020263672, 0.043151855, 0.0056495667, 0.02746582, -0.040130615, 0.017227173, -0.07891846, -0.0040664673, 0.009529114, -0.07104492, -0.0039367676, 0.0501709, -0.018539429, -0.014060974, 0.024963379, 0.06390381, 0.0052375793, -0.020721436, 0.042785645, 0.050872803, -0.0010061264, 0.031799316, 0.012878418, 0.0025291443, -0.06573486, -0.0016031265, -0.055389404, -0.0154953, -0.024963379, -0.00093126297, 0.059020996, -0.066223145, 0.0015802383, -0.04788208, -0.0047340393, 0.019073486, 0.047210693, -0.0032653809, -0.031707764, -0.021438599, -0.0032997131, -0.02154541, 0.01713562, -0.043945312, 0.023040771, 0.099121094, 0.011413574, 0.005016327, 0.031173706, 0.031707764, -0.0115737915, -0.01977539, -0.011512756, -0.041137695, -0.0019025803, 0.034301758, 0.00088596344, -0.013977051, -0.006969452, -0.1274414, -0.016433716, -0.014816284, 0.021743774, -0.022125244, 0.01399231, -0.043792725, -0.022949219, -0.020690918, -0.054595947, 0.009864807, 0.060394287, 0.00592041, -0.015327454, 0.006046295, -0.023910522, 0.025924683, -0.02885437, -0.0713501, 0.040618896, -0.080322266, -0.03994751, 0.022781372, -0.023406982, -0.030395508, -0.017166138, 0.0010957718, 0.035064697, 0.026672363, 0.023803711, -0.006034851, -0.02407837, 0.009346008, -0.039001465, -0.01360321, -0.044067383, -0.037017822, -0.022125244, -0.025604248, 0.059783936, 0.0040664673, -0.00009942055, -0.033843994, 0.0061798096, 0.014259338, 0.038208008, 0.007843018, -0.028121948, 0.0043563843, -0.0019683838, -0.022506714, -0.019882202, -0.0231781, -0.009887695, -0.049102783, 0.01763916, -0.012786865, 0.08251953, 0.011367798, 0.017669678, 0.0071792603, -0.050720215, 0.013397217, -0.03186035, -0.07720947, 0.018096924, 0.024993896, 0.00116539, 0.01033783, -0.038208008, -0.05419922, 0.04220581, -0.03692627, -0.005214691, 0.007083893, -0.00077676773, -0.0041389465, 0.002313614, -0.0075263977, 0.004798889, -0.019332886, 0.004787445, -0.00017809868, -0.0038394928, 0.0006599426, -0.03741455, 0.016693115, -0.006843567, -0.07775879, -0.0022792816, 0.031021118, -0.018463135, -0.008392334, -0.050689697, 0.035888672, -0.01965332, -0.021713257, 0.017730713, -0.00028777122, -0.029312134, 0.016677856, -0.04727173, -0.042907715, 0.07196045, -0.020065308, -0.017578125, 0.041290283, -0.014472961, -0.03704834, -0.012954712, 0.028274536, -0.015899658, 0.045318604, 0.017364502, -0.003627777, 0.062438965, -0.042907715, 0.022247314, 0.017303467, 0.021148682, -0.016601562, -0.004714966, 0.0047340393, -0.0034122467, -0.0036506653, 0.054748535, -0.0010347366, -0.006263733, -0.041534424, 0.011436462, -0.013793945, -0.0054016113, 0.027862549, 0.012046814, 0.003522873, -0.0033035278, 0.003791809, 0.043182373, -0.041259766, -0.015014648, 0.06921387, 0.027435303, -0.031021118, -0.014625549, 0.010147095, 0.06414795, 0.0019798279, 0.019760132, -0.014762878, 0.02029419, 0.013336182, -0.03149414, -0.0061912537, 0.008674622, -0.014221191, -0.008422852, -0.06616211, -0.030471802, -0.024719238, -0.0031166077, -0.009376526, 0.045043945, 0.029266357, -0.010765076, -0.035614014, 0.022521973, 0.010520935, 0.0042152405, -0.005142212, -0.052947998, -0.009048462, -0.012367249, -0.05029297, -0.010322571, -0.0055236816, -0.027572632, 0.04336548, -0.019897461, -0.041290283, 0.0026569366, 0.030899048, 0.117492676, 0.043273926, 0.005554199, -0.082214355, 0.013458252, -0.039001465, -0.018356323, 0.0209198, -0.03475952, -0.019104004, -0.009170532, 0.054382324, -0.013832092, -0.023849487, -0.026168823, 0.02482605, -0.0124053955, 0.05569458, 0.022720337, 0.060333252, 0.031555176, -0.004512787, 0.019927979, 0.023117065, -0.027038574, -0.008140564, 0.012481689, 0.011665344, 0.02432251, 0.012771606, 0.016540527, 0.0042266846, -0.005455017, 0.009437561, 0.013633728, 0.01727295, -0.0011138916, 0.031677246, -0.011238098, -0.06744385, -0.022216797, 0.0036449432, -0.013259888, 0.049346924, -0.04208374, 0.0670166, 0.003900528, -0.015640259, 0.034698486, -0.0077400208, 0.0011548996, -0.018554688, -0.00052165985, -0.067871094, -0.080200195, -0.018554688, 0.06640625, -0.03475952, -0.0023021698, -0.007820129, -0.006629944, 0.031219482, 0.048187256, 0.035705566, 0.004459381, -0.02468872, -0.0022392273, 0.005264282, -0.015174866, -0.041900635, 0.015449524, 0.008079529, 0.011993408, -0.069885254, 0.028259277, -0.037750244, -0.0012254715, -0.035186768, -0.016036987, 0.02204895, -0.049621582, 0.03137207, 0.09051514, -0.0002863407, 0.052978516, 0.025756836, 0.027938843, -0.013397217, 0.021820068, 0.013542175, 0.03616333, -0.0020179749, -0.012413025, 0.017852783, 0.005592346, 0.010299683, 0.00048470497, 0.0067253113, 0.008110046, -0.0011644363, -0.029312134, 0.029022217, -0.0050582886, -0.03829956, 0.020233154, -0.04095459, 0.022033691, 0.010940552, 0.006095886, 0.0124435425, -0.044677734, -0.041656494, -0.02671814, -0.022201538, -0.0670166, 0.03878784, -0.029373169, -0.038513184, -0.045532227, 0.021255493, -0.019119263, 0.0017318726, 0.0012321472, -0.006122589, -0.0440979, 0.01424408, 0.041168213, -0.06866455, 0.017227173, 0.010314941, 0.027191162, 0.046966553, -0.012123108, -0.0317688, -0.0050086975, -0.0005068779, -0.047943115, -0.033111572, 0.025436401, 0.006259918, -0.005382538, 0.0015916824, -0.039398193, -0.0012550354, 0.015029907, 0.021820068, -0.0016679764, -0.017807007, 0.044067383, 0.006336212, -0.0000962019, 0.018493652, -0.014419556, -0.022460938, 0.012573242, 0.009208679, -0.012580872, 0.039215088, -0.009811401, 0.002773285, 0.040649414, -0.021392822, 0.019805908, 0.012321472, -0.0029315948, -0.015731812, 0.022888184, 0.030075073, -0.008666992, 0.021087646, 0.01436615, 0.06652832, -0.017456055, -0.0039043427, -0.018920898, 0.001964569, -0.033721924, 0.06536865, -0.016311646, -0.014282227, -0.050872803, -0.05279541, -0.014671326, 0.027542114, 0.025238037, 0.0024261475, 0.008529663, -0.06878662, -0.0055351257, -0.03137207, -0.010391235, -0.032470703, 0.021652222, -0.0010108948, -0.020385742, -0.014846802, -0.010795593, -0.010910034, -0.013847351, 0.024810791, 0.0018520355, 0.0078125, 0.0044288635, -0.006641388, 0.010566711, -0.008651733, -0.0146102905, 0.020385742, -0.0017290115, -0.013046265, 0.015823364, -0.042053223, 0.057525635, 0.015113831, 0.049865723, 0.051483154, 0.009178162, -0.00095558167, 0.0061416626, 0.021835327, -0.047668457, 0.022598267, -0.054870605, -0.012001038, -0.06890869, -0.028808594, -0.064575195, -0.0059280396, 0.0011053085, 0.02180481, 0.03665161, 0.0005903244, 0.0063972473, -0.0022354126, 0.021987915, 0.016738892, 0.031158447, -0.0018291473, 0.010887146, -0.024780273, -0.0473938, 0.052856445, 0.04324341, -0.005596161, 0.004524231, 0.006668091, -0.017593384, -0.017822266, 0.025527954, 0.035095215, -0.021530151, -0.034210205, -0.01033783, 0.02784729, -0.015281677, 0.002363205, 0.06567383, 0.044891357, 0.0062675476, -0.028961182, 0.015449524, 0.016708374, -0.018981934, 0.009124756, 0.03253174, -0.041381836, 0.026947021, 0.0015850067, -0.02520752, -0.020217896, 0.05419922, 0.004131317, -0.051361084, -0.022857666, 0.032592773, 0.025558472, 0.017044067, 0.015640259, -0.043792725, -0.03060913, -0.015022278, 0.039123535, -0.0002708435, 0.022918701, 0.0005555153, 0.029953003, -0.024520874, -0.010139465, -0.006587982, 0.023635864, -0.04864502, 0.023849487, -0.014984131, 0.05331421, 0.032196045, -0.028808594, 0.024658203, 0.019012451, -0.06011963, 0.008300781, 0.0015687943, 0.06616211, 0.055603027, 0.06365967, -0.018753052, -0.020965576, 0.031555176, -0.050323486, 0.03741455, 0.022094727, -0.031204224, -0.006252289, -0.013534546, -0.018096924, 0.016921997, -0.023544312, 0.049804688, -0.026535034, -0.009521484, -0.0075645447, -0.010940552, 0.07281494, -0.04827881, -0.027435303, -0.033599854, -0.0009822845, 0.00080013275, 0.034301758, -0.02330017, -0.02394104, 0.021591187, 0.015083313, 0.027938843, 0.012390137, -0.0016260147, -0.027297974, -0.04776001, 0.04135132, -0.018066406, 0.06677246, -0.018417358, -0.024627686, -0.0362854, 0.028045654, 0.010826111, -0.020553589, -0.025039673, 0.029159546, -0.019805908, -0.022888184, 0.0016012192, 0.027435303, -0.010566711, 0.0001629591, -0.05090332, 0.019256592, -0.03164673, 0.01864624, 0.038635254, -0.03338623, -0.054016113, -0.0017089844, -0.0044555664, 0.04171753, 0.013023376, -0.010482788, -0.004333496, 0.033569336, -0.03375244, -0.0025348663, 0.013183594, 0.034179688, -0.008934021, -0.0491333, 0.021102905, 0.0124053955, 0.042236328, -0.04534912, -0.053833008, 0.0037651062, 0.0077056885, -0.0074043274, 0.05847168, 0.0010681152, -0.015487671, 0.024642944, 0.024047852, 0.020065308, -0.02861023, -0.020935059, -0.016296387, 0.036254883, 0.045318604, -0.0004529953, -0.024520874, 0.020004272, -0.016952515, -0.017089844, -0.016204834, 0.02116394, 0.005962372, 0.0065345764, 0.06237793, -0.031951904, -0.0020160675, -0.030654907, 0.045654297, -0.0085372925, 0.036468506, -0.010955811, 0.0074157715, 0.018035889, 0.04928589, -0.01373291, -0.058776855, 0.03768921, 0.026428223, 0.016723633, 0.032196045, -0.016403198, -0.038879395, -0.018356323, 0.002254486, 0.012786865, 0.022476196, 0.020324707, -0.023345947, 0.03326416, -0.08355713, -0.059387207, -0.0013275146, -0.025253296, 0.015319824, -0.03591919, 0.02658081, 0.005592346, -0.021530151, -0.018951416, 0.025253296, 0.020553589, -0.035736084, -0.029251099, -0.04977417, 0.050628662, -0.010787964 ], "summary": [ 0.057678223, -0.021347046, 0.027175903, -0.02456665, -0.035827637, -0.0017328262, -0.010192871, -0.020111084, -0.044555664, 0.043518066, -0.014427185, 0.025817871, -0.00043821335, -0.02003479, 0.030395508, -0.032684326, 0.022277832, -0.0075531006, -0.019454956, -0.02558899, -0.013404846, -0.025863647, 0.005645752, 0.043823242, 0.056793213, -0.042419434, -0.12445068, 0.030349731, 0.0047836304, 0.021087646, 0.014923096, 0.014198303, 0.03955078, -0.018630981, 0.006336212, -0.010559082, -0.019165039, -0.0009021759, 0.005180359, 0.008651733, 0.036621094, -0.012557983, 0.029159546, -0.043426514, -0.018692017, 0.03805542, -0.0074882507, -0.0015945435, -0.007896423, 0.031463623, 0.015380859, -0.0073394775, -0.0051994324, 0.030151367, 0.0023727417, -0.003894806, -0.050201416, -0.0002462864, 0.041900635, 0.07727051, -0.0012903214, -0.050750732, -0.0040626526, -0.076293945, 0.006965637, -0.020629883, -0.0034770966, 0.03112793, 0.0103302, 0.00027775764, 0.027435303, 0.0035438538, 0.017684937, -0.01247406, -0.03591919, 0.0052871704, 0.021133423, 0.011528015, 0.015853882, -0.021972656, -0.025741577, -0.0124053955, -0.011604309, -0.044708252, -0.0025482178, -0.042053223, -0.02128601, 0.01285553, -0.029953003, -0.0020427704, -0.03378296, 0.0211792, -0.028045654, 0.009963989, -0.006942749, -0.024108887, -0.014404297, -0.040100098, 0.033996582, 0.011695862, 0.048919678, -0.042938232, 0.03970337, -0.014030457, -0.0020885468, 0.02104187, 0.04663086, -0.03845215, -0.0008382797, -0.025787354, -0.050354004, 0.05496216, 0.008926392, -0.007369995, -0.030197144, 0.002105713, -0.022628784, 0.015007019, 0.00094747543, -0.006954193, -0.024108887, 0.019561768, 0.03970337, 0.03253174, -0.010925293, 0.026275635, 0.013114929, -0.050598145, 0.0340271, -0.048950195, -0.030639648, 0.06500244, 0.0713501, -0.013534546, -0.03012085, 0.010070801, 0.044830322, 0.016204834, 0.005393982, -0.0064468384, -0.0038967133, -0.014877319, -0.021209717, 0.011817932, -0.020767212, 0.036102295, 0.03149414, -0.00062179565, -0.02279663, -0.035980225, -0.03161621, 0.02571106, -0.019607544, -0.022155762, 0.053985596, -0.07287598, -0.048706055, 0.0035171509, 0.10131836, 0.03540039, 0.007949829, 0.036468506, 0.047027588, 0.038482666, 0.034454346, -0.048706055, 0.0047302246, 0.011680603, 0.0048294067, -0.0070381165, -0.01424408, 0.036834717, 0.026443481, -0.02798462, -0.012069702, -0.034210205, -0.018707275, 0.020080566, 0.023544312, -0.033050537, -0.015434265, -0.020599365, 0.044891357, -0.0022258759, -0.012008667, -0.04812622, -0.011619568, -0.022872925, 0.04699707, 0.0067329407, 0.01626587, 0.0058784485, -0.03842163, 0.005012512, -0.018417358, 0.035888672, -0.034301758, 0.03488159, -0.027557373, -0.018814087, 0.0009822845, -0.008323669, -0.00283432, -0.01713562, -0.04156494, -0.01838684, -0.010437012, 0.02633667, -0.043029785, 0.033203125, 0.027297974, -0.023162842, -0.0067329407, 0.00006592274, -0.009933472, -0.09918213, 0.045806885, -0.018920898, 0.014266968, -0.041992188, 0.026229858, 0.023071289, -0.015457153, 0.04699707, 0.030181885, 0.007129669, -0.031463623, 0.0014543533, 0.01701355, 0.01914978, 0.0035495758, -0.00036907196, -0.023162842, 0.017456055, -0.016830444, -0.02810669, 0.012634277, -0.049438477, 0.055541992, 0.035949707, -0.0019321442, -0.00705719, -0.028808594, 0.04168701, 0.027664185, 0.031066895, -0.0008292198, 0.034851074, -0.008659363, 0.01675415, 0.0033187866, 0.010726929, 0.02911377, -0.02355957, -0.011543274, 0.033172607, 0.0129470825, -0.019195557, -0.012825012, 0.020004272, 0.006298065, -0.007019043, -0.026184082, 0.016494751, -0.027862549, 0.008773804, -0.007221222, 0.005832672, -0.0069732666, -0.0011749268, 0.024673462, 0.010025024, -0.010284424, -0.027648926, 0.0077934265, -0.05126953, -0.048095703, 0.04095459, 0.03253174, -0.041900635, 0.018447876, 0.0035934448, 0.011428833, 0.0056419373, 0.040161133, -0.0046920776, 0.016067505, 0.028244019, 0.028198242, 0.014091492, 0.060668945, -0.035949707, -0.042755127, 0.025177002, -0.0008444786, -0.06402588, -0.024795532, 0.036254883, -0.012252808, -0.015136719, 0.029769897, 0.03164673, -0.06750488, 0.057128906, 0.0126571655, -0.04498291, 0.019607544, 0.028366089, 0.005065918, -0.010681152, -0.02418518, 0.009681702, 0.045166016, 0.08673096, -0.0071907043, -0.039031982, 0.03427124, 0.07208252, 0.010566711, 0.01209259, 0.0769043, -0.030075073, 0.026260376, 0.017181396, -0.022994995, -0.06298828, 0.062469482, -0.010360718, 0.06036377, 0.011878967, -0.030090332, 0.021743774, -0.057922363, -0.009544373, -0.00035429, -0.0107803345, 0.021652222, -0.017974854, 0.02029419, 0.02079773, 0.085754395, -0.006816864, 0.0045814514, 0.013771057, 0.0009765625, -0.04916382, -0.0289917, -0.008712769, -0.023651123, -0.015914917, 0.01979065, 0.0050201416, -0.012878418, 0.020141602, 0.021896362, -0.034729004, 0.005344391, 0.0078125, 0.0029335022, -0.023468018, 0.06524658, -0.0006599426, 0.008506775, -0.08343506, -0.0049057007, -0.042785645, -0.0317688, -0.045684814, 0.047424316, 0.056152344, 0.018676758, 0.08630371, -0.078186035, -0.028900146, -0.02470398, -0.025741577, 0.06762695, -0.0055007935, 0.0034866333, 0.030776978, 0.035125732, 0.0309906, -0.009605408, -0.006614685, 0.08666992, 0.009925842, -0.0021305084, 0.055603027, 0.0067749023, -0.018814087, -0.03378296, 0.0046653748, -0.027557373, -0.030014038, 0.016174316, 0.014533997, -0.008987427, -0.012008667, -0.02947998, -0.032714844, -0.04269409, 0.038391113, 0.023468018, 0.0014801025, 0.0033550262, 0.0068740845, -0.0046806335, -0.04107666, -0.0041046143, 0.012649536, 0.06262207, -0.05621338, 0.05859375, -0.036346436, 0.032714844, -0.053100586, 0.020309448, -0.0012540817, -0.047088623, -0.014892578, 0.040985107, 0.01914978, 0.016540527, 0.009635925, -0.011291504, 0.034606934, -0.02986145, 0.022247314, -0.037506104, -0.01550293, -0.012649536, -0.032928467, -0.00042414665, -0.0063934326, -0.06604004, -0.0058631897, -0.011428833, 0.031280518, 0.024307251, -0.050811768, -0.011161804, 0.011650085, 0.010902405, 0.0070533752, -0.010772705, -0.004299164, 0.040618896, -0.0021743774, -0.05493164, -0.009223938, -0.043151855, 0.0066184998, -0.011627197, 0.04208374, 0.007369995, 0.08874512, -0.039642334, 0.03668213, 0.07092285, -0.05697632, -0.0018577576, -0.030273438, -0.031402588, 0.032989502, 0.027740479, 0.017227173, -0.029174805, -0.01121521, -0.020217896, 0.021911621, 0.005153656, -0.01008606, -0.027694702, -0.011558533, 0.0056877136, -0.016967773, 0.032562256, 0.019989014, 0.012008667, -0.022872925, -0.04348755, 0.015945435, -0.019836426, -0.042419434, -0.017105103, 0.010192871, -0.043304443, -0.036834717, 0.007873535, 0.02154541, 0.035491943, -0.03488159, 0.052642822, -0.029663086, -0.020736694, 0.01259613, -0.008483887, 0.039215088, 0.0345459, -0.030639648, 0.00762558, -0.0184021, -0.0143585205, -0.0335083, 0.009864807, 0.02204895, 0.04522705, 0.036621094, 0.00957489, -0.019851685, 0.053009033, -0.014457703, 0.011177063, 0.036987305, -0.04260254, 0.008544922, -0.026672363, 0.014274597, -0.0496521, 0.0073928833, -0.007911682, 0.008171082, 0.00055217743, 0.023132324, 0.014556885, 0.013648987, -0.028457642, 0.048461914, -0.020385742, -0.01159668, 0.053894043, 0.03390503, -0.00088596344, -0.01108551, -0.0048675537, -0.0011367798, -0.049804688, 0.0087890625, 0.057250977, 0.020477295, -0.044433594, -0.038360596, 0.005607605, 0.062042236, -0.027542114, 0.017196655, -0.03010559, 0.0259552, -0.0016231537, 0.008880615, 0.012672424, 0.006626129, -0.0112838745, -0.02267456, -0.004585266, 0.019958496, 0.00566864, -0.013801575, -0.018630981, 0.0149383545, 0.0017538071, 0.018463135, -0.0062446594, -0.010421753, 0.00554657, 0.041656494, -0.047027588, -0.06604004, -0.031799316, -0.01020813, -0.04196167, -0.012588501, -0.059539795, -0.05596924, -0.018096924, 0.019805908, -0.06762695, 0.01586914, 0.012664795, 0.123413086, 0.028945923, 0.03363037, -0.09564209, 0.016494751, -0.048339844, -0.0068855286, 0.029418945, -0.054382324, -0.010475159, 0.028274536, 0.071777344, -0.0057258606, -0.027923584, -0.03842163, 0.004131317, -0.022842407, 0.038269043, 0.06530762, 0.07293701, 0.02734375, -0.011817932, 0.014183044, -0.006664276, -0.015113831, 0.015930176, 0.024810791, -0.0034332275, 0.015792847, -0.008232117, -0.017654419, 0.011856079, 0.0041275024, -0.015258789, -0.004131317, -0.017700195, -0.008682251, 0.012168884, 0.00592041, -0.019821167, -0.03857422, 0.0124435425, -0.006668091, -0.006828308, 0.024291992, 0.02784729, 0.025985718, -0.0008583069, 0.021347046, -0.011932373, -0.0072364807, -0.011146545, -0.012245178, -0.05429077, -0.06536865, -0.030456543, 0.07836914, -0.0137786865, -0.020401001, -0.036621094, -0.04336548, 0.029525757, 0.0029830933, -0.0066566467, -0.03164673, -0.0071640015, 0.0011816025, -0.00970459, 0.003227234, -0.018753052, -0.027389526, 0.026351929, 0.0178833, 0.002500534, 0.0034255981, 0.020980835, 0.007980347, -0.03543091, -0.0061073303, 0.012191772, -0.020690918, -0.029922485, 0.040374756, -0.011016846, 0.021377563, 0.071777344, 0.007865906, -0.05316162, 0.022460938, -0.03250122, 0.049591064, -0.029144287, -0.036132812, 0.0066833496, -0.021820068, -0.014007568, 0.051727295, 0.02268982, 0.015235901, 0.022521973, -0.0033073425, 0.008888245, 0.020202637, 0.029724121, -0.02178955, -0.011169434, 0.0062446594, 0.008880615, 0.032409668, 0.019683838, -0.035614014, -0.044921875, -0.05041504, -0.020446777, -0.118652344, 0.011230469, -0.040527344, -0.022720337, 0.0025806427, 0.019836426, -0.02748108, -0.013679504, 0.016281128, -0.021392822, -0.0077285767, -0.010650635, 0.010292053, -0.050720215, -0.0024166107, 0.04788208, 0.053253174, -0.006511688, -0.05593872, -0.031311035, 0.0006375313, 0.008766174, -0.0004775524, -0.019592285, -0.010543823, -0.0137786865, 0.03387451, 0.0011806488, -0.0128479, -0.00856781, -0.03213501, 0.0014667511, -0.020706177, -0.01991272, 0.040893555, -0.0052375793, -0.040985107, 0.04309082, -0.035491943, -0.04385376, 0.034851074, 0.011291504, 0.052459717, 0.035614014, -0.017913818, 0.007534027, 0.025375366, 0.014221191, 0.0065460205, 0.029937744, -0.0005674362, -0.002401352, 0.046966553, 0.0289917, -0.025863647, -0.00083208084, 0.010597229, 0.007663727, -0.007671356, 0.009063721, -0.03060913, 0.011833191, -0.031082153, 0.054901123, -0.023468018, -0.023284912, -0.029327393, -0.031921387, 0.012321472, 0.020996094, 0.010498047, -0.0019359589, -0.006362915, -0.0063819885, 0.026809692, 0.020324707, -0.02784729, -0.011512756, -0.016616821, 0.00541687, 0.009979248, 0.048217773, 0.0029563904, -0.03375244, 0.0491333, -0.0025749207, 0.009315491, -0.0069274902, 0.023132324, -0.004180908, 0.011268616, 0.001080513, 0.032592773, -0.024673462, -0.009460449, -0.007843018, -0.059173584, -0.017959595, 0.045959473, 0.008583069, -0.005970001, -0.050109863, -0.05368042, 0.026489258, 0.010604858, 0.023971558, -0.016174316, 0.0027675629, -0.027328491, -0.05227661, -0.041992188, -0.04257202, -0.004901886, -0.002784729, -0.0178833, -0.008384705, 0.046203613, -0.0024051666, -0.027557373, 0.025100708, -0.03552246, 0.07409668, 0.00045919418, 0.010971069, -0.0012273788, -0.011428833, -0.053253174, 0.031585693, 0.05303955, 0.00894165, 0.012626648, 0.011291504, 0.017700195, -0.0074310303, 0.0029525757, -0.025222778, -0.06542969, 0.024963379, -0.023666382, 0.029571533, 0.0038642883, 0.0385437, 0.03125, 0.031143188, -0.008415222, -0.0032100677, 0.03277588, 0.04333496, 0.011024475, 0.004463196, 0.015434265, 0.010093689, -0.0045280457, 0.032043457, -0.017059326, 0.011749268, 0.026489258, 0.023025513, -0.02798462, 0.021835327, 0.005176544, 0.0026779175, -0.0050697327, 0.02923584, -0.025360107, -0.03390503, -0.0211792, -0.029403687, 0.013404846, 0.022644043, 0.018371582, 0.017181396, -0.033233643, 0.015319824, -0.04714966, 0.030197144, -0.107055664, 0.010139465, 0.006515503, 0.064941406, 0.028289795, -0.0061302185, 0.046051025, 0.03515625, -0.05545044, 0.029724121, 0.0546875, 0.0869751, 0.0647583, 0.032318115, -0.06738281, -0.0050621033, 0.10534668, -0.0029735565, 0.028564453, -0.0012674332, -0.0064353943, -0.03604126, -0.0211792, -0.00762558, -0.019088745, -0.015975952, 0.035491943, -0.03100586, 0.0075683594, -0.026428223, -0.0040779114, 0.008148193, -0.031951904, -0.0096588135, -0.066711426, -0.0037250519, 0.023712158, 0.06512451, -0.029891968, 0.035247803, 0.013442993, -0.050231934, 0.027282715, -0.012527466, 0.020874023, -0.012123108, -0.03314209, 0.0020580292, 0.008918762, 0.038391113, 0.014862061, 0.00039672852, 0.0037498474, 0.047454834, -0.016601562, -0.04421997, -0.01638794, 0.060913086, 0.01586914, 0.029373169, -0.04714966, -0.016418457, -0.017333984, 0.05218506, -0.025009155, 0.05886841, -0.022994995, 0.00944519, 0.032684326, 0.00054359436, -0.034088135, -0.00038933754, -0.000115573406, 0.014183044, -0.029556274, -0.009765625, 0.024963379, 0.01398468, -0.03765869, -0.010551453, -0.009391785, 0.0146484375, -0.003578186, -0.03656006, 0.0023517609, 0.00434494, 0.0446167, -0.02229309, 0.00349617, 0.012611389, 0.011581421, -0.011520386, 0.03074646, -0.026794434, 0.011962891, 0.072509766, 0.06604004, 0.027542114, -0.053741455, 0.0058937073, 0.02784729, 0.0028266907, 0.034118652, -0.009429932, 0.010353088, 0.034118652, -0.036315918, -0.012786865, 0.02229309, 0.044830322, 0.008460999, 0.020965576, 0.062561035, -0.058807373, -0.029907227, 0.018066406, 0.02067566, -0.014907837, 0.010871887, -0.03387451, 0.000047564507, 0.004299164, -0.033050537, 0.008041382, 0.007980347, 0.0050849915, 0.008850098, 0.020462036, -0.03527832, 0.013572693, -0.012367249, -0.017913818, 0.024749756, 0.030166626, 0.03994751, -0.013343811, -0.008522034, 0.023742676, -0.0881958, -0.031173706, -0.010673523, -0.008644104, -0.0032520294, -0.022537231, 0.02508545, 0.042938232, -0.029891968, 0.021331787, -0.00944519, 0.06591797, 0.008354187, 0.022262573, 0.027114868, -0.00081920624, 0.010665894 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2110.15032v6
OneFlow: Redesign the Distributed Deep Learning Framework from Scratch
Jinhui Yuan, Xinqi Li, Cheng Cheng, Juncheng Liu, Ran Guo, Shenghang Cai, Chi Yao, Fei Yang, Xiaodong Yi, Chuan Wu, Haoran Zhang, Jie Zhao
cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.LG
Deep learning frameworks such as TensorFlow and PyTorch provide a productive interface for expressing and training a deep neural network (DNN) model on a single device or using data parallelism. Still, they may not be flexible or efficient enough in training emerging large models on distributed devices, which require more sophisticated parallelism beyond data parallelism. Plugins or wrappers have been developed to strengthen these frameworks for model or pipeline parallelism, but they complicate the usage and implementation of distributed deep learning. Aiming at a simple, neat redesign of distributed deep learning frameworks for various parallelism paradigms, we present OneFlow, a novel distributed training framework based on an SBP (split, broadcast and partial-value) abstraction and the actor model. SBP enables much easier programming of data parallelism and model parallelism than existing frameworks, and the actor model provides a succinct runtime mechanism to manage the complex dependencies imposed by resource constraints, data movement and computation in distributed deep learning. We demonstrate the general applicability and efficiency of OneFlow for training various large DNN models with case studies and extensive experiments. The results show that OneFlow outperforms many well-known customized libraries built on top of the state-of-the-art frameworks. The code of OneFlow is available at: https://github.com/Oneflow-Inc/oneflow.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2110.15032v6
"2022-04-19T11:57:54"
"2021-10-28T11:32:14"
{ "title": [ -0.031555176, -0.014167786, -0.054504395, -0.06781006, 0.012252808, -0.003660202, -0.026916504, 0.0026016235, -0.008056641, 0.021850586, -0.0064468384, 0.0008664131, -0.0032520294, -0.024612427, -0.031311035, 0.005493164, 0.0039520264, 0.02458191, -0.0155181885, -0.02670288, -0.025039673, -0.01876831, 0.04119873, 0.057373047, 0.032562256, -0.03479004, -0.09301758, 0.023147583, -0.058624268, -0.047851562, -0.009666443, 0.049682617, 0.041107178, 0.01939392, -0.024887085, -0.005290985, -0.051208496, 0.020141602, -0.011405945, -0.003250122, 0.03314209, -0.011199951, -0.01939392, -0.028640747, -0.025772095, 0.015914917, -0.0592041, -0.018173218, -0.010437012, 0.06274414, 0.021652222, 0.028533936, -0.021209717, 0.05105591, 0.021057129, -0.031707764, -0.004383087, -0.024093628, 0.04840088, 0.044830322, 0.0073890686, -0.05328369, 0.025054932, -0.02809143, -0.036254883, -0.021408081, -0.012016296, 0.03274536, 0.064941406, -0.0014572144, -0.027374268, 0.02545166, 0.003036499, 0.016784668, -0.044128418, -0.02722168, 0.056121826, 0.018035889, 0.031982422, -0.024902344, 0.010314941, -0.046539307, -0.0101623535, -0.008934021, 0.017456055, -0.0043258667, -0.008071899, -0.011642456, -0.043548584, -0.0234375, -0.016098022, -0.017700195, 0.0029678345, 0.010688782, -0.010238647, -0.0051879883, -0.027862549, -0.0015649796, 0.019485474, 0.002193451, -0.008529663, 0.008163452, -0.01802063, -0.0105896, 0.01374054, 0.011947632, -0.03201294, -0.03994751, 0.00082683563, 0.04925537, -0.032104492, 0.016052246, 0.0049438477, 0.0063667297, -0.002325058, -0.01133728, -0.017852783, 0.009773254, 0.006198883, 0.025009155, 0.009902954, -0.03074646, 0.017745972, 0.0418396, 0.03414917, 0.019134521, -0.057159424, 0.00083112717, -0.036865234, 0.012924194, 0.0046539307, 0.05557251, -0.0869751, -0.080566406, -0.060760498, 0.052642822, 0.0012540817, 0.028335571, 0.007068634, 0.00687027, 0.022583008, -0.031173706, -0.020446777, 0.035858154, -0.032684326, 0.000028789043, 0.06994629, -0.0030555725, -0.06781006, -0.053985596, -0.035064697, 0.0340271, 0.019622803, 0.004623413, -0.033233643, 0.013786316, -0.09698486, -0.016983032, 0.002922058, 0.013534546, 0.031234741, 0.012176514, 0.0026054382, 0.05090332, 0.086242676, -0.00932312, -0.007713318, 0.02305603, 0.0005607605, 0.033569336, -0.04019165, 0.01777649, 0.04824829, -0.018096924, -0.026748657, -0.0014133453, 0.02407837, 0.032073975, 0.019638062, -0.012619019, 0.007183075, -0.031707764, 0.023208618, 0.05178833, -0.04333496, -0.011329651, 0.0043678284, -0.018218994, 0.035369873, -0.0017414093, -0.037963867, 0.039398193, -0.057403564, -0.040130615, -0.056793213, -0.0053482056, 0.029678345, 0.035888672, -0.0010299683, 0.016296387, -0.03955078, -0.0022621155, -0.041748047, 0.026062012, -0.01965332, -0.021972656, -0.015319824, 0.02142334, -0.05114746, 0.049804688, 0.060943604, 0.016555786, -0.035125732, -0.0067367554, 0.013916016, -0.06298828, 0.011489868, -0.026016235, -0.007534027, -0.020202637, -0.014930725, 0.017669678, 0.006454468, 0.044403076, 0.020233154, 0.01008606, -0.012382507, -0.019592285, 0.032440186, 0.020736694, 0.07476807, -0.029815674, 0.026031494, 0.0128479, -0.005794525, -0.031585693, 0.027618408, -0.019927979, 0.03427124, 0.022842407, 0.006385803, -0.033050537, -0.01133728, 0.009506226, 0.0579834, 0.00333786, 0.01701355, 0.004840851, 0.022583008, 0.0034122467, 0.03074646, 0.014823914, 0.062927246, -0.022918701, 0.026977539, 0.056121826, 0.0049819946, 0.020111084, -0.030212402, 0.0152282715, -0.0020618439, 0.04135132, 0.0055503845, 0.026565552, -0.07598877, 0.022842407, -0.04333496, 0.008125305, 0.0057754517, 0.021194458, 0.04852295, -0.02734375, 0.0015926361, -0.0055122375, 0.00044703484, -0.014503479, -0.006969452, 0.010650635, -0.012817383, -0.055358887, -0.020904541, -0.006958008, 0.040802002, 0.013679504, 0.018218994, -0.005252838, 0.021896362, -0.028945923, -0.01449585, -0.016281128, 0.047058105, 0.038879395, 0.0101623535, -0.00061130524, -0.001162529, -0.0041503906, 0.07348633, 0.10015869, -0.041412354, 0.04537964, -0.05633545, 0.0124053955, 0.014854431, -0.0317688, -0.0044174194, 0.033966064, 0.029144287, -0.0025672913, -0.039611816, 0.0069274902, -0.05569458, 0.0034332275, 0.0062294006, -0.019943237, -0.05001831, -0.07086182, -0.011772156, -0.05718994, -0.066223145, -0.020263672, 0.08673096, -0.021514893, 0.0023422241, -0.032714844, -0.0064048767, -0.034606934, -0.017913818, -0.029678345, -0.0024490356, 0.03543091, 0.025466919, 0.038116455, -0.059631348, -0.007408142, -0.00096797943, 0.034210205, -0.012008667, 0.01902771, -0.011886597, 0.001367569, 0.039276123, 0.0055274963, 0.014816284, -0.036132812, 0.0031814575, -0.06347656, 0.017288208, 0.01612854, -0.05114746, -0.0073280334, 0.044891357, -0.028411865, -0.03894043, 0.0018815994, 0.045562744, -0.01638794, -0.0062026978, 0.013702393, 0.030914307, -0.026916504, 0.007575989, 0.006134033, -0.017471313, -0.051208496, 0.009635925, -0.04272461, -0.011306763, -0.02104187, -0.00573349, 0.051727295, -0.06262207, -0.009010315, -0.033569336, -0.010620117, 0.0055160522, 0.025939941, -0.014381409, -0.041015625, -0.03918457, -0.023483276, -0.007858276, 0.011100769, -0.009796143, 0.00028443336, 0.05517578, -0.002243042, -0.039611816, -0.013435364, 0.038330078, 0.009063721, 0.00995636, -0.008979797, -0.013298035, 0.00920105, 0.014251709, 0.009117126, -0.015266418, -0.014350891, -0.09295654, -0.0022354126, 0.07989502, -0.0025539398, -0.041809082, 0.034820557, -0.06359863, -0.0061798096, 0.028564453, -0.015823364, 0.016281128, 0.056762695, -0.0033874512, -0.003107071, 0.0012788773, -0.02973938, 0.027282715, -0.048217773, -0.11633301, 0.026672363, -0.042938232, -0.0070991516, -0.010910034, 0.011314392, -0.046325684, 0.016693115, -0.0004968643, 0.04849243, 0.019760132, 0.015274048, 0.024642944, -0.0025577545, 0.0037345886, -0.0231781, -0.018630981, -0.022399902, -0.022201538, -0.01374054, -0.01158905, 0.03640747, 0.022277832, -0.0046539307, -0.043304443, -0.009803772, 0.027664185, 0.04034424, 0.02418518, -0.035217285, -0.008636475, -0.024124146, 0.010643005, 0.02583313, -0.01727295, -0.015586853, -0.029846191, 0.0025024414, -0.030593872, 0.017181396, 0.020233154, 0.02368164, -0.03527832, -0.02947998, 0.033355713, -0.033172607, -0.056732178, 0.016357422, 0.036254883, 0.014373779, -0.014167786, -0.0015029907, -0.04989624, 0.041534424, -0.0077171326, -0.007369995, 0.009849548, -0.010635376, -0.0044441223, 0.0008916855, -0.012008667, 0.00944519, -0.02619934, -0.005378723, -0.018676758, 0.00242424, -0.024108887, -0.039123535, 0.0047073364, -0.004463196, -0.07122803, -0.035186768, 0.019989014, -0.044799805, -0.028320312, -0.07128906, 0.025390625, -0.012062073, -0.029510498, 0.016601562, -0.0211792, 0.006477356, 0.0021400452, -0.07006836, -0.0026283264, 0.07861328, -0.0067863464, -0.010482788, 0.03225708, 0.00806427, -0.023132324, -0.03375244, -0.0015544891, 0.0017461777, 0.02784729, -0.026763916, -0.00497818, 0.03060913, -0.035125732, 0.03640747, -0.009727478, 0.011199951, -0.023117065, 0.0082092285, 0.03466797, 0.015388489, -0.05407715, 0.04296875, 0.03152466, -0.006790161, -0.09399414, 0.01537323, 0.010398865, -0.016494751, 0.020553589, -0.009971619, 0.044067383, 0.041931152, -0.014404297, 0.066467285, -0.015068054, 0.0035953522, 0.033996582, -0.03427124, -0.012702942, -0.0022239685, 0.026565552, -0.009231567, -0.017990112, 0.038726807, -0.007095337, 0.021957397, 0.001912117, -0.035888672, 0.017333984, 0.02923584, -0.010009766, -0.008468628, -0.06524658, -0.017181396, -0.014564514, -0.008102417, -0.005317688, 0.025100708, 0.02607727, -0.020874023, -0.027267456, 0.004814148, 0.02796936, -0.0019083023, 0.007911682, -0.038848877, -0.0036792755, 0.006702423, -0.049865723, -0.036865234, 0.0007491112, -0.021728516, 0.01651001, -0.014846802, -0.01864624, 0.026168823, 0.010894775, 0.055603027, 0.056915283, -0.023468018, -0.0713501, -0.001115799, -0.0004940033, -0.015411377, -0.0003786087, 0.005256653, 0.0034561157, -0.03552246, -0.0051727295, -0.022521973, -0.011039734, -0.05126953, 0.020889282, 0.0023670197, 0.03753662, 0.000069856644, 0.024490356, 0.023025513, 0.009674072, 0.010864258, 0.004310608, -0.036193848, -0.03466797, 0.0019273758, 0.03427124, -0.007282257, 0.026641846, 0.055389404, 0.014526367, -0.0039863586, -0.0071411133, 0.027450562, 0.012313843, -0.019714355, 0.012016296, 0.004863739, -0.05166626, -0.039215088, -0.0073242188, 0.008491516, 0.050750732, -0.04107666, 0.057617188, -0.014755249, -0.0074157715, 0.011932373, -0.012504578, 0.019165039, -0.018218994, 0.030960083, -0.066467285, -0.076416016, -0.03866577, 0.055511475, -0.019073486, -0.019607544, 0.016113281, 0.03112793, 0.012435913, 0.048553467, 0.025161743, -0.0012435913, 0.004005432, -0.018035889, -0.017074585, -0.029724121, -0.036315918, 0.012901306, -0.010147095, 0.02532959, -0.036010742, 0.002632141, -0.0602417, -0.015625, -0.006580353, -0.021057129, 0.014587402, -0.07287598, 0.0050468445, 0.06616211, -0.00094652176, 0.039215088, 0.020126343, 0.014839172, 0.0033493042, 0.04232788, 0.0012378693, 0.040893555, 0.01725769, -0.054840088, -0.00630188, 0.013954163, 0.052947998, -0.010910034, -0.0065841675, 0.016174316, -0.03164673, -0.051513672, 0.03778076, 0.010787964, -0.03781128, 0.010871887, -0.042663574, 0.017532349, 0.0041999817, 0.014015198, 0.0063667297, -0.035949707, -0.03543091, -0.007774353, -0.037200928, -0.035888672, 0.04534912, -0.015525818, -0.029846191, -0.034332275, 0.04550171, -0.0063934326, 0.0071029663, 0.003753662, -0.01235199, -0.030654907, 0.010505676, 0.0030956268, -0.06744385, 0.009963989, -0.015945435, 0.024002075, 0.034423828, 0.0070610046, -0.03475952, 0.005504608, -0.0234375, -0.050842285, -0.05340576, -0.0040397644, 0.0018701553, -0.0010480881, -0.007888794, -0.04547119, -0.011070251, 0.0028629303, 0.021240234, -0.006465912, -0.031951904, 0.026153564, 0.01676941, 0.022827148, 0.0076026917, 0.0181427, -0.021362305, 0.020706177, 0.022750854, -0.010559082, 0.032958984, -0.008003235, 0.0031433105, -0.0026779175, -0.0635376, 0.023483276, 0.01663208, 0.014587402, -0.013320923, 0.008621216, 0.047790527, -0.00554657, -0.013824463, 0.011947632, 0.06738281, -0.05895996, -0.00059747696, -0.017288208, 0.014190674, -0.042633057, 0.028579712, -0.020141602, 0.005001068, -0.041992188, -0.053863525, -0.029647827, 0.011505127, 0.026290894, 0.017440796, 0.039764404, -0.04260254, 0.030227661, -0.023361206, -0.017242432, -0.027832031, 0.012031555, -0.003692627, -0.009162903, 0.022109985, 0.003572464, -0.022842407, -0.018661499, 0.046661377, 0.024810791, -0.019683838, 0.031982422, -0.012260437, 0.0079193115, -0.027496338, -0.0054397583, 0.042053223, 0.016143799, -0.017456055, 0.01725769, -0.02848816, 0.05557251, 0.03201294, 0.036224365, 0.055786133, -0.007843018, 0.00036621094, 0.0051193237, 0.0033607483, -0.036956787, 0.036346436, -0.034240723, 0.0009937286, -0.055541992, -0.0335083, -0.064208984, 0.015838623, 0.013412476, 0.030059814, 0.014854431, 0.011856079, 0.00415802, -0.021621704, 0.0446167, 0.010139465, 0.06021118, 0.0154800415, 0.00014472008, 0.011184692, -0.0069465637, 0.029220581, 0.04348755, 0.007156372, 0.00573349, 0.0124435425, -0.014007568, 0.0009727478, 0.026794434, 0.020523071, -0.02923584, -0.007041931, -0.02053833, 0.03439331, -0.016311646, 0.035888672, 0.0748291, 0.05810547, -0.025787354, -0.012039185, -0.0011844635, 0.008483887, -0.022109985, 0.011680603, 0.04269409, -0.05319214, -0.0011606216, -0.020019531, -0.022415161, -0.017852783, 0.013671875, 0.04660034, -0.064941406, -0.033081055, 0.013252258, 0.040527344, -0.013519287, -0.013404846, -0.04309082, 0.0019454956, 0.03668213, 0.03503418, -0.020874023, 0.006465912, 0.0059165955, 0.038330078, -0.02394104, -0.015090942, -0.005039215, 0.020324707, -0.03213501, 0.022384644, -0.03857422, 0.04296875, -0.010986328, -0.040527344, 0.015235901, 0.0079574585, -0.070495605, -0.011802673, 0.05001831, 0.04940796, 0.015144348, 0.051849365, -0.0076789856, -0.030883789, 0.008232117, -0.030136108, 0.011489868, 0.035186768, -0.0395813, -0.0054512024, -0.029571533, -0.036010742, 0.014190674, -0.033813477, 0.051574707, -0.037109375, 0.02243042, -0.013870239, 0.02545166, 0.031097412, -0.06652832, -0.01852417, 0.0044898987, -0.013160706, -0.011795044, 0.022979736, -0.023422241, -0.036010742, -0.00907135, 0.033447266, -0.0073890686, -0.0076026917, -0.014907837, -0.021606445, -0.058776855, 0.016204834, -0.04663086, 0.042510986, -0.032958984, -0.0075302124, -0.033081055, -0.0028572083, -0.008529663, -0.0049705505, -0.0062942505, 0.004108429, -0.047332764, -0.048797607, 0.025772095, 0.022201538, -0.020462036, -0.026245117, -0.06323242, 0.005012512, -0.030471802, 0.0008764267, 0.056610107, -0.055023193, -0.020141602, 0.014053345, -0.030838013, 0.066101074, 0.025115967, 0.0063934326, 0.002313614, 0.022781372, -0.016067505, -0.012016296, 0.012779236, 0.05392456, 0.0056877136, -0.04928589, -0.0025424957, 0.04058838, 0.055358887, -0.051574707, -0.037872314, 0.017196655, 0.02583313, 0.0053634644, 0.066345215, 0.010169983, 0.00032138824, -0.006500244, 0.05319214, 0.009963989, -0.049682617, -0.055419922, -0.032287598, 0.04660034, 0.043029785, -0.0029449463, -0.033325195, 0.04864502, -0.006790161, 0.0021839142, 0.00945282, 0.007858276, 0.011856079, -0.0017967224, 0.03289795, -0.025024414, -0.0058021545, -0.044677734, 0.016906738, 0.008865356, 0.04248047, -0.03414917, 0.027694702, 0.009292603, 0.07336426, 0.007007599, -0.07867432, 0.050109863, 0.041046143, 0.019683838, 0.046447754, -0.04031372, -0.053710938, -0.016036987, -0.015960693, -0.014923096, -0.0064430237, 0.024932861, -0.034240723, 0.020523071, -0.026565552, -0.054992676, -0.025894165, -0.044158936, 0.036987305, -0.049438477, 0.031799316, -0.035888672, -0.009178162, -0.01651001, 0.017166138, -0.0021572113, -0.029891968, -0.04864502, -0.029586792, 0.047851562, -0.016326904 ], "summary": [ -0.0034675598, -0.028381348, -0.03491211, -0.06866455, -0.04714966, 0.008918762, -0.0758667, 0.018615723, -0.003063202, 0.00699234, 0.0110321045, -0.0026111603, -0.014259338, -0.04446411, 0.02029419, -0.0018148422, 0.008201599, -0.016799927, -0.0138549805, -0.02406311, 0.013343811, -0.008842468, -0.01058197, 0.045776367, -0.0027065277, -0.029403687, -0.05090332, 0.049682617, -0.03930664, 0.006916046, 0.009086609, 0.012046814, 0.01159668, 0.008575439, -0.025436401, -0.083984375, -0.03765869, 0.019760132, -0.013435364, -0.010398865, 0.037597656, -0.008293152, 0.02810669, -0.030166626, -0.0055999756, 0.020721436, -0.010917664, -0.032562256, 0.027648926, 0.035186768, 0.0075416565, 0.0029315948, -0.016326904, 0.027648926, -0.009117126, 0.027236938, -0.043182373, -0.017990112, 0.030380249, 0.021026611, -0.0001835823, -0.029815674, 0.007080078, -0.03942871, -0.020339966, -0.02027893, -0.014289856, 0.00032186508, 0.080566406, 0.0053215027, -0.00749588, 0.05343628, 0.010017395, 0.020935059, -0.0055770874, -0.019226074, 0.053985596, 0.045959473, -0.0004453659, 0.025421143, -0.008628845, -0.041656494, -0.03152466, -0.021362305, -0.010284424, -0.008522034, -0.00724411, 0.0047340393, -0.03567505, 0.046569824, -0.026473999, 0.013435364, 0.000026166439, 0.046173096, 0.013717651, 0.007129669, -0.0793457, -0.08929443, 0.026779175, 0.05227661, 0.038024902, -0.04574585, 0.07849121, -0.028762817, -0.029586792, 0.0012168884, 0.0029258728, -0.057525635, -0.043792725, 0.022644043, -0.038391113, -0.061676025, -0.017120361, -0.017745972, -0.02268982, -0.0234375, -0.045166016, 0.0138549805, 0.008392334, -0.029693604, 0.0014886856, 0.01285553, 0.037506104, 0.03894043, -0.005142212, 0.017211914, -0.006248474, -0.048309326, -0.0039482117, -0.002521515, -0.010238647, 0.030014038, -0.0082473755, -0.007881165, -0.035949707, 0.010345459, 0.022491455, 0.041503906, 0.023742676, -0.0014066696, 0.050109863, -0.040893555, -0.05432129, 0.08227539, -0.010627747, 0.017593384, 0.021148682, -0.0046920776, -0.014533997, -0.02671814, -0.03189087, 0.039093018, 0.017181396, -0.0009584427, 0.0006213188, -0.014175415, 0.021347046, -0.02848816, -0.020004272, -0.022567749, 0.06640625, 0.018203735, 0.030151367, 0.107299805, 0.06341553, -0.019042969, -0.001241684, -0.005191803, 0.014289856, -0.010345459, -0.03463745, 0.024139404, 0.07495117, 0.0022144318, -0.0035972595, 0.0121536255, -0.049438477, 0.061676025, 0.018096924, -0.03274536, 0.01914978, -0.031021118, 0.03326416, 0.040130615, -0.009094238, 0.01322937, -0.011703491, -0.029937744, 0.017440796, -0.011657715, -0.0019264221, 0.041229248, -0.019897461, 0.019958496, -0.02355957, 0.011795044, 0.008018494, 0.035217285, -0.0076828003, -0.037506104, 0.0029468536, 0.02418518, -0.01626587, 0.02658081, -0.051086426, 0.032989502, -0.016662598, 0.02168274, -0.03933716, 0.016082764, 0.033569336, 0.008682251, -0.033813477, -0.030197144, -0.002248764, -0.042541504, 0.022766113, -0.022567749, -0.002998352, -0.039764404, 0.008041382, 0.02330017, -0.00045394897, 0.058746338, -0.020202637, 0.0063476562, -0.03427124, 0.013725281, -0.018432617, 0.0030059814, 0.018173218, 0.019927979, 0.01449585, 0.014389038, -0.014945984, 0.0020542145, 0.06719971, -0.024383545, 0.018447876, 0.026290894, 0.011528015, 0.0082473755, -0.031402588, -0.0049591064, 0.00020730495, 0.027191162, 0.03475952, -0.027252197, -0.015777588, -0.045837402, -0.017807007, -0.031188965, 0.03665161, -0.03781128, 0.0059013367, 0.028274536, -0.01399231, 0.0026607513, -0.01991272, 0.021377563, 0.006668091, 0.029205322, 0.01272583, 0.004207611, -0.051971436, -0.012107849, -0.043060303, -0.030960083, 0.009216309, -0.010871887, 0.028884888, -0.08227539, -0.013519287, -0.007865906, -0.05050659, -0.016723633, -0.0129852295, 0.035339355, -0.029129028, -0.020812988, -0.022735596, -0.021728516, 0.016830444, 0.0030384064, 0.010269165, 0.026138306, 0.039093018, 0.014282227, 0.022659302, 0.036865234, 0.042510986, 0.045562744, 0.02204895, 0.019805908, -0.012321472, 0.0044937134, 0.03793335, 0.042816162, -0.018920898, 0.0047035217, 0.04736328, 0.029342651, -0.043945312, 0.033203125, 0.0072898865, -0.0033512115, 0.034454346, -0.006149292, 0.0000628829, -0.000497818, -0.0335083, -0.001537323, 0.0022029877, 0.040100098, -0.06304932, -0.047821045, -0.024612427, 0.0012397766, -0.028411865, 0.025802612, 0.101867676, -0.013023376, 0.04071045, -0.0047950745, -0.019805908, -0.076660156, 0.03024292, -0.02255249, -0.015426636, 0.026107788, 0.0073661804, 0.011871338, -0.014572144, 0.042510986, -0.0034294128, -0.008560181, 0.028579712, -0.0042419434, 0.033355713, 0.039001465, 0.09234619, -0.0096588135, -0.021911621, 0.014717102, -0.018508911, -0.045166016, 0.040374756, 0.002948761, 0.011116028, 0.005836487, 0.017303467, -0.030090332, -0.01852417, -0.0067634583, 0.009590149, -0.003993988, 0.02104187, -0.027862549, 0.014457703, -0.05053711, -0.00076818466, 0.014198303, -0.023391724, -0.047851562, 0.029159546, -0.035064697, -0.007183075, -0.028076172, 0.017044067, 0.04244995, -0.04208374, 0.034698486, -0.048095703, -0.0016212463, 0.0022563934, 0.027496338, 0.0993042, -0.010917664, -0.059295654, 0.0519104, -0.016525269, 0.018554688, -0.0309906, 0.025756836, 0.015655518, 0.008705139, -0.017715454, -0.02645874, 0.022094727, 0.017166138, 0.012161255, -0.011222839, 0.056915283, -0.01727295, 0.0056114197, -0.0050621033, -0.037139893, -0.026275635, -0.010513306, -0.014892578, 0.11254883, -0.035247803, -0.03967285, 0.031921387, -0.0043563843, -0.0016584396, 0.09777832, -0.009155273, -0.0024299622, 0.008125305, -0.0015087128, -0.024414062, 0.010063171, -0.03338623, 0.021102905, -0.04260254, -0.023910522, 0.000081181526, -0.046813965, 0.025512695, 0.0018444061, 0.06768799, 0.006038666, 0.035461426, -0.0026416779, 0.0435791, 0.01689148, 0.0041007996, 0.0317688, 0.055023193, 0.02053833, 0.0045051575, -0.0063972473, -0.010398865, -0.025527954, 0.0005378723, -0.0060920715, 0.00076675415, 0.013374329, -0.025863647, -0.004169464, -0.012123108, 0.03262329, 0.04714966, 0.019500732, 0.00017142296, -0.028823853, 0.0022907257, 0.02204895, 0.021057129, -0.028930664, 0.003944397, 0.018035889, 0.015197754, -0.023208618, -0.0073661804, 0.0095825195, 0.0541687, 0.0073127747, -0.039367676, 0.0418396, -0.03466797, -0.03829956, 0.04559326, 0.024414062, 0.06695557, -0.06463623, 0.033294678, -0.052520752, 0.019882202, 0.032104492, -0.050750732, 0.009597778, -0.017318726, -0.011878967, -0.02482605, 0.04345703, -0.006580353, 0.026290894, -0.059783936, -0.07727051, 0.04034424, -0.06652832, -0.026016235, -0.021133423, 0.008300781, 0.0021877289, -0.044433594, 0.01109314, 0.033691406, 0.02909851, -0.018127441, 0.041107178, 0.004627228, -0.018615723, 0.009498596, -0.029281616, 0.117126465, 0.008125305, -0.060913086, 0.040252686, -0.025299072, 0.023803711, 0.0004003048, -0.030731201, 0.041412354, 0.036956787, -0.0060195923, -0.022354126, -0.032928467, 0.016784668, -0.06567383, 0.015281677, 0.023742676, -0.024612427, 0.01612854, -0.024169922, 0.0335083, -0.043304443, -0.0030212402, 0.055389404, 0.051605225, -0.053741455, 0.02255249, 0.018844604, 0.009254456, -0.07421875, 0.017425537, 0.0048217773, -0.017211914, 0.015007019, 0.027542114, 0.031280518, 0.036499023, -0.0049476624, -0.000013053417, -0.023651123, -0.010597229, 0.04006958, 0.008552551, -0.0023002625, 0.009223938, 0.005836487, 0.03640747, -0.02885437, 0.014961243, -0.032440186, -0.011169434, 0.007797241, -0.03778076, -0.004383087, -0.0020256042, 0.01586914, -0.041259766, -0.034210205, 0.021331787, 0.019104004, -0.0345459, -0.010757446, 0.061920166, 0.0028896332, -0.007144928, -0.0036373138, 0.0028457642, -0.012634277, 0.013000488, -0.025466919, -0.046691895, -0.039642334, 0.011489868, -0.03756714, -0.029968262, -0.06518555, -0.06756592, -0.038391113, 0.021362305, -0.01940918, -0.0018062592, 0.005092621, 0.027954102, 0.0597229, -0.012145996, -0.06222534, -0.07183838, 0.019561768, 0.022888184, -0.015533447, 0.009277344, 0.020431519, 0.010116577, -0.02330017, -0.009162903, -0.00894928, -0.09008789, 0.002904892, 0.0049057007, -0.016036987, 0.027801514, -0.0012836456, 0.013465881, 0.011383057, -0.003982544, -0.006412506, -0.003194809, 0.0131073, 0.0104904175, -0.00008350611, 0.02999878, 0.0036373138, 0.024505615, -0.0003774166, -0.012138367, -0.022628784, 0.016174316, -0.012901306, -0.015342712, 0.009864807, -0.014808655, 0.013511658, -0.039093018, -0.0028095245, 0.016616821, -0.011962891, 0.0024032593, 0.0146484375, -0.0008239746, -0.013053894, -0.0021877289, -0.0054473877, 0.041625977, 0.005264282, 0.01828003, -0.050689697, -0.08251953, -0.053771973, 0.08123779, -0.00058841705, -0.043060303, 0.01386261, -0.0017843246, -0.0015707016, 0.020950317, 0.009109497, -0.008583069, 0.040740967, -0.0033397675, -0.010345459, 0.011993408, 0.0007505417, -0.0004863739, -0.0058517456, 0.0026054382, -0.05029297, -0.02331543, 0.031982422, -0.02520752, -0.019088745, -0.04623413, 0.005760193, -0.044006348, -0.038513184, 0.01713562, -0.051849365, 0.027008057, 0.0713501, -0.044891357, -0.030761719, 0.0076446533, -0.026504517, 0.022720337, -0.030944824, -0.06695557, -0.0019168854, -0.001996994, 0.039794922, 0.008621216, -0.0513916, 0.013648987, -0.046539307, 0.0061035156, 0.01826477, -0.0006227493, -0.0446167, -0.014549255, -0.0021419525, 0.022155762, -0.015609741, 0.039611816, -0.0035381317, -0.014633179, -0.012123108, -0.015113831, -0.012382507, -0.023956299, 0.016967773, -0.016143799, -0.02848816, -0.021484375, 0.06750488, -0.021408081, 0.014205933, 0.007904053, -0.05090332, -0.028549194, -0.040863037, -0.03189087, -0.031707764, 0.029251099, -0.0018129349, 0.03274536, -0.024291992, -0.02722168, -0.034851074, -0.018432617, -0.03387451, -0.024505615, -0.06719971, -0.026016235, -0.01423645, 0.056732178, -0.015144348, -0.029968262, 0.0103302, -0.028930664, 0.011947632, -0.020584106, -0.0062217712, 0.0019016266, 0.0029029846, 0.0076293945, 0.010772705, -0.024017334, -0.05001831, 0.0155181885, 0.032928467, 0.0051612854, 0.06097412, -0.012817383, 0.00724411, 0.00041007996, -0.03955078, 0.019073486, 0.027236938, 0.00042128563, 0.0032634735, 0.018157959, 0.021148682, -0.030349731, -0.0056419373, -0.003522873, 0.012809753, 0.00080537796, 0.013870239, -0.022338867, 0.02746582, -0.048828125, -0.048187256, -0.0017328262, 0.025054932, -0.010864258, -0.059020996, 0.01386261, 0.0036735535, 0.02494812, 0.027023315, 0.029251099, -0.0446167, 0.019226074, 0.008857727, -0.037261963, -0.0019016266, -0.010215759, -0.007797241, -0.020812988, 0.06561279, -0.00970459, -0.016677856, 0.0025615692, 0.022827148, 0.0064353943, -0.02911377, 0.034851074, 0.022720337, 0.00945282, -0.007507324, 0.028564453, 0.012359619, 0.004463196, -0.011001587, -0.0109939575, -0.005897522, 0.029647827, 0.028381348, 0.002117157, 0.015434265, -0.028076172, -0.00868988, -0.00019466877, -0.03111267, -0.028442383, 0.051971436, 0.0070877075, -0.057037354, -0.07220459, -0.072021484, -0.033081055, 0.0107040405, -0.020965576, -0.0069503784, 0.06573486, -0.019363403, -0.0018444061, -0.008026123, -0.03149414, 0.034057617, 0.011306763, 0.009979248, -0.0032978058, 0.011734009, -0.04034424, 0.023849487, 0.06628418, -0.004463196, -0.004055023, 0.04425049, 0.00025343895, 0.019363403, -0.00548172, 0.0077819824, -0.060546875, 0.020492554, -0.016845703, 0.030227661, 0.0126571655, 0.033966064, 0.006416321, 0.049102783, -0.030059814, 0.023895264, 0.017990112, 0.07269287, -0.014175415, 0.037322998, 0.0077590942, 0.00504303, -0.047943115, 0.013366699, -0.0053749084, -0.015182495, 0.018630981, 0.030410767, -0.042877197, 0.013160706, 0.0010433197, 0.007598877, 0.0041656494, -0.034179688, -0.05029297, -0.043823242, 0.010955811, 0.02178955, -0.027923584, -0.009628296, -0.0006866455, 0.01828003, -0.0072746277, 0.004814148, -0.013046265, 0.024017334, -0.02319336, 0.02330017, -0.035949707, 0.017547607, 0.023834229, -0.0079422, 0.011787415, 0.024795532, -0.025772095, 0.033477783, -0.016143799, 0.08123779, 0.044311523, 0.036102295, -0.04260254, 0.00014579296, 0.08679199, -0.0056991577, -0.0029754639, 0.006038666, 0.0035266876, -0.06530762, -0.029129028, -0.0037460327, -0.058044434, -0.010719299, -0.011772156, -0.011978149, 0.01499939, -0.03652954, 0.029022217, -0.03439331, -0.05581665, 0.024887085, -0.01889038, -0.041168213, 0.028930664, 0.05960083, -0.013175964, -0.01361084, -0.04333496, -0.009254456, -0.039642334, 0.004306793, 0.0074882507, 0.0043640137, -0.019805908, 0.018218994, -0.0046157837, 0.06390381, -0.024002075, -0.0031433105, 0.013031006, -0.006385803, 0.00076436996, -0.022399902, 0.011154175, 0.012367249, -0.025115967, -0.06951904, 0.029571533, 0.019943237, -0.030792236, -0.061462402, -0.06689453, -0.008483887, -0.04156494, 0.015426636, 0.061798096, -0.012466431, -0.013267517, 0.020706177, -0.0009007454, 0.04458618, -0.0158844, 0.02192688, -0.019927979, 0.051849365, -0.012336731, 0.004737854, 0.014175415, 0.032104492, -0.025268555, -0.037750244, -0.023086548, 0.02053833, 0.04257202, 0.0016098022, -0.04043579, 0.05505371, -0.004360199, 0.016830444, 0.026153564, -0.017944336, 0.0052871704, -0.0104599, 0.08905029, 0.009246826, -0.03363037, -0.073913574, -0.039794922, 0.07470703, -0.029678345, -0.018234253, -0.06085205, 0.02305603, -0.0042037964, -0.017929077, 0.019973755, 0.031555176, -0.013427734, 0.012382507, 0.02217102, -0.054595947, -0.009933472, -0.034454346, -0.016464233, 0.033599854, 0.052703857, -0.018417358, 0.027801514, 0.014785767, 0.09240723, 0.0063552856, 0.0047569275, -0.018005371, 0.018234253, 0.022994995, -0.02758789, -0.021453857, -0.010185242, 0.006416321, -0.021133423, -0.00983429, -0.0009326935, 0.024475098, -0.039276123, -0.03387451, -0.017349243, -0.015098572, -0.058654785, -0.0368042, 0.015594482, -0.05114746, 0.029663086, -0.02003479, -0.0043144226, -0.015174866, 0.009170532, -0.05557251, -0.03060913, 0.006160736, 0.004432678, -0.006626129, -0.000052571297 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2111.00765v3
Validate on Sim, Detect on Real -- Model Selection for Domain Randomization
Gal Leibovich, Guy Jacob, Shadi Endrawis, Gal Novik, Aviv Tamar
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.LG
A practical approach to learning robot skills, often termed sim2real, is to train control policies in simulation and then deploy them on a real robot. Popular techniques to improve the sim2real transfer build on domain randomization (DR) -- training the policy on a diverse set of randomly generated domains with the hope of better generalization to the real world. Due to the large number of hyper-parameters in both the policy learning and DR algorithms, one often ends up with a large number of trained policies, where choosing the best policy among them demands costly evaluation on the real robot. In this work we ask - can we rank the policies without running them in the real world? Our main idea is that a predefined set of real world data can be used to evaluate all policies, using out-of-distribution detection (OOD) techniques. In a sense, this approach can be seen as a `unit test' to evaluate policies before any real world execution. However, we find that by itself, the OOD score can be inaccurate and very sensitive to the particular OOD method. Our main contribution is a simple-yet-effective policy score that combines OOD with an evaluation in simulation. We show that our score - VSDR - can significantly improve the accuracy of policy ranking without requiring additional real world data. We evaluate the effectiveness of VSDR on sim2real transfer in a robotic grasping task with image inputs. We extensively evaluate different DR parameters and OOD methods, and show that VSDR improves policy selection across the board. More importantly, our method achieves significantly better ranking, and uses significantly less data compared to baselines. Project website is available at https://sites.google.com/view/vsdr/home.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2111.00765v3
"2022-03-01T12:52:22"
"2021-11-01T08:34:59"
{ "title": [ -0.0059928894, 0.01486969, -0.05090332, -0.03665161, -0.015296936, -0.024963379, -0.0423584, -0.019042969, -0.08605957, 0.011779785, 0.008476257, 0.034057617, -0.021987915, -0.047607422, 0.032073975, -0.039154053, -0.013977051, 0.028701782, -0.02458191, -0.049468994, 0.017044067, -0.06518555, -0.004055023, 0.0647583, 0.019256592, 0.02029419, -0.055908203, 0.0068244934, -0.02809143, -0.03616333, 0.00667572, 0.03744507, 0.0000056028366, 0.017501831, 0.01802063, 0.10534668, 0.007221222, 0.03643799, 0.044769287, 0.0124053955, 0.03567505, -0.019134521, -0.009460449, -0.0066337585, -0.0034427643, -0.018234253, 0.024093628, -0.010154724, -0.0090789795, 0.054473877, -0.013824463, 0.0046958923, -0.009803772, 0.025924683, 0.0034313202, -0.048339844, -0.053009033, 0.023376465, 0.029006958, 0.035308838, 0.0017137527, -0.023239136, 0.008934021, -0.04425049, 0.019989014, -0.035583496, -0.072753906, 0.03265381, 0.04647827, 0.04650879, 0.020553589, -0.01725769, 0.0057296753, 0.022918701, -0.041168213, -0.021575928, 0.042419434, 0.023117065, 0.008842468, 0.00038290024, -0.018341064, -0.026245117, 0.006626129, 0.0028514862, -0.042266846, -0.0062789917, -0.013534546, 0.010940552, 0.017227173, -0.041931152, 0.0014295578, 0.03781128, -0.014564514, 0.04522705, -0.029220581, -0.029312134, 0.05581665, 0.042144775, 0.029708862, -0.04043579, -0.015144348, -0.006816864, -0.09631348, 0.010131836, 0.01499939, -0.006210327, -0.015541077, -0.027175903, 0.015945435, 0.020858765, -0.036224365, 0.026260376, -0.019073486, -0.0025310516, -0.002796173, -0.03363037, -0.05496216, 0.013801575, -0.013145447, -0.034454346, 0.028900146, 0.039978027, 0.048950195, -0.0031032562, -0.0025520325, 0.013648987, -0.02696228, -0.057403564, -0.006111145, 0.032348633, -0.0068740845, 0.07421875, -0.066833496, -0.09472656, -0.07293701, 0.009429932, 0.026733398, 0.043518066, 0.027145386, -0.050811768, 0.06112671, 0.015701294, 0.016464233, 0.038085938, -0.037353516, 0.033843994, 0.04336548, -0.031097412, -0.04071045, -0.041015625, -0.09301758, 0.02003479, -0.005996704, -0.0045547485, 0.008628845, 0.02394104, -0.05645752, 0.009109497, 0.028320312, 0.017318726, 0.07287598, 0.0045661926, -0.019561768, 0.0039482117, -0.010017395, -0.010368347, -0.025009155, 0.0065841675, 0.003025055, 0.048553467, -0.015068054, -0.04296875, 0.0008406639, 0.010726929, -0.013404846, 0.039520264, 0.00074386597, 0.024276733, 0.025650024, 0.013366699, 0.009521484, -0.008850098, 0.03765869, 0.015213013, -0.0050811768, -0.07720947, -0.02255249, -0.05734253, 0.06896973, 0.008674622, -0.025131226, -0.018157959, -0.06451416, -0.02394104, -0.008331299, 0.017715454, 0.006072998, 0.009628296, 0.0017738342, 0.00061273575, -0.026321411, 0.0030670166, -0.0055274963, 0.03567505, 0.037109375, -0.032226562, 0.029403687, -0.004749298, 0.028930664, 0.03579712, -0.0028057098, -0.021072388, -0.0029029846, -0.008361816, -0.042266846, -0.068115234, 0.030731201, -0.03756714, -0.013305664, -0.027679443, -0.022064209, 0.03527832, -0.041748047, 0.040740967, 0.017318726, 0.02658081, -0.0033073425, 0.009880066, 0.062194824, 0.03652954, 0.07269287, -0.039764404, -0.005268097, 0.027297974, -0.02458191, -0.020935059, -0.008323669, -0.015777588, 0.027130127, 0.03829956, 0.0236969, 0.0071754456, 0.019683838, 0.045684814, 0.016952515, -0.025436401, 0.012931824, 0.006164551, 0.016143799, 0.025222778, 0.0031833649, 0.014419556, 0.034362793, 0.05505371, 0.027938843, 0.045166016, -0.0007843971, 0.03479004, -0.036590576, 0.010948181, -0.0010166168, 0.059692383, 0.024230957, 0.004890442, -0.031982422, 0.023330688, -0.026382446, 0.015014648, -0.044708252, 0.045043945, 0.047058105, -0.029830933, 0.0027542114, 0.06311035, 0.00061941147, -0.027450562, -0.043304443, 0.0016050339, 0.018066406, -0.002571106, 0.000787735, -0.00030469894, 0.040039062, 0.007255554, 0.023498535, 0.0099487305, 0.031280518, 0.004459381, -0.017410278, 0.006641388, 0.036499023, 0.035064697, -0.0029659271, 0.013633728, 0.047607422, 0.00045609474, 0.040863037, 0.05331421, -0.02960205, 0.029281616, -0.083496094, 0.00504303, 0.0309906, -0.017044067, 0.033721924, -0.00491333, 0.05429077, -0.013069153, -0.011878967, -0.0007157326, -0.049468994, -0.018371582, 0.016677856, -0.035247803, 0.022216797, 0.003047943, 0.0050239563, -0.0072631836, -0.01966858, -0.013626099, 0.059173584, 0.013183594, -0.021224976, -0.030151367, 0.0035114288, -0.012680054, -0.040985107, -0.039245605, 0.016220093, -0.043060303, 0.021636963, -0.04876709, -0.054595947, -0.03878784, 0.016586304, -0.018844604, 0.0026302338, -0.0012264252, -0.0007586479, -0.023513794, 0.028289795, -0.0043907166, -0.018814087, 0.000033557415, -0.012420654, -0.023422241, -0.011734009, 0.022109985, -0.0149383545, -0.011734009, 0.022537231, -0.033294678, 0.003742218, 0.0018291473, 0.06341553, -0.09423828, -0.040161133, 0.07092285, 0.011779785, -0.009429932, 0.07507324, 0.018875122, 0.032592773, -0.048828125, -0.03970337, -0.0758667, -0.040771484, -0.015235901, 0.0102005005, 0.017562866, -0.05480957, 0.022384644, -0.03137207, -0.0039367676, -0.007774353, 0.026535034, -0.04562378, -0.06365967, -0.030593872, -0.039276123, -0.023254395, -0.030700684, 0.014389038, 0.001742363, 0.059936523, 0.0024700165, -0.008659363, 0.021713257, 0.022323608, -0.010253906, 0.0032043457, 0.017623901, -0.024124146, -0.0036411285, 0.015174866, 0.001405716, 0.0067481995, 0.0079193115, -0.084472656, 0.00548172, -0.007888794, -0.04815674, -0.02658081, -0.014587402, -0.034057617, 0.017440796, 0.005004883, -0.009933472, 0.018081665, -0.009925842, 0.012207031, -0.007949829, 0.04663086, -0.045532227, 0.027954102, -0.06304932, -0.05279541, 0.014755249, -0.01374054, 0.001326561, 0.010978699, -0.00655365, -0.019577026, -0.00687027, -0.016052246, -0.0015239716, 0.012184143, 0.011756897, -0.005756378, -0.00497818, -0.018676758, -0.025680542, 0.007888794, -0.018127441, -0.01247406, 0.00060749054, -0.01574707, 0.022445679, -0.003238678, 0.017700195, -0.03677368, -0.013122559, 0.0041885376, 0.014801025, -0.031311035, 0.0052261353, 0.0072021484, -0.010513306, 0.020492554, -0.00015974045, 0.004211426, -0.015434265, 0.0071525574, 0.017654419, -0.033355713, 0.11999512, 0.011062622, 0.020904541, 0.027694702, 0.0030059814, -0.018295288, -0.025161743, -0.010231018, 0.00076293945, -0.023498535, -0.026535034, 0.036254883, 0.0056114197, -0.017059326, -0.0034656525, -0.029693604, 0.06137085, 0.023468018, 0.014877319, -0.006454468, -0.0067481995, -0.023345947, 0.038879395, -0.05130005, -0.003955841, 0.011459351, 0.009391785, -0.0019550323, -0.031433105, -0.024093628, 0.027572632, -0.09240723, -0.05496216, 0.013793945, -0.018951416, -0.03527832, -0.022628784, 0.023208618, -0.026367188, -0.010444641, 0.004486084, 0.01058197, -0.025787354, -0.0033931732, -0.028793335, -0.043640137, 0.008255005, -0.00919342, 0.01626587, 0.006462097, -0.010505676, -0.030975342, -0.00856781, 0.018981934, -0.0078086853, 0.009727478, -0.014678955, 0.04067993, 0.018936157, 0.0054016113, 0.04071045, 0.03390503, -0.0024299622, 0.027770996, 0.0024337769, 0.054992676, 0.041656494, -0.045562744, 0.018920898, 0.06756592, -0.021942139, -0.09075928, -0.018051147, -0.007217407, -0.06378174, -0.00504303, -0.02406311, -0.016571045, 0.039276123, 0.030593872, 0.06842041, -0.0069503784, 0.0053901672, -0.043701172, -0.015235901, -0.02973938, -0.042907715, 0.0047035217, -0.008728027, -0.0065078735, -0.0042266846, 0.011947632, 0.03479004, 0.016845703, -0.0423584, 0.027175903, 0.051483154, -0.043640137, -0.015686035, -0.026473999, 0.0074310303, -0.039886475, 0.025283813, -0.0129776, -0.005466461, 0.00907135, 0.031280518, -0.028808594, -0.024032593, 0.022033691, 0.041046143, -0.058410645, -0.055664062, 0.028335571, -0.03074646, -0.0703125, -0.048461914, -0.013298035, 0.02204895, 0.027938843, 0.023986816, -0.0064697266, 0.038085938, 0.024917603, 0.025665283, 0.030944824, -0.023712158, -0.057006836, -0.0067710876, -0.004486084, -0.025527954, -0.021896362, 0.027175903, -0.03479004, -0.074279785, -0.0041999817, 0.0051841736, -0.018081665, -0.0023612976, 0.02885437, -0.025802612, 0.05429077, -0.02394104, 0.056854248, 0.0032787323, 0.006454468, -0.01146698, -0.0062332153, -0.03515625, 0.013954163, -0.02116394, 0.040222168, -0.01651001, 0.0026550293, 0.011009216, 0.005748749, -0.017852783, -0.019302368, 0.013893127, -0.018707275, 0.0067825317, 0.00932312, 0.028015137, 0.016189575, 0.008277893, 0.03579712, 0.019042969, 0.035339355, -0.035064697, -0.0064430237, -0.03225708, 0.0046958923, 0.007972717, -0.004219055, -0.0034275055, 0.024353027, 0.008522034, -0.0054130554, 0.008636475, 0.025604248, -0.019042969, -0.0103302, -0.0017156601, -0.02420044, -0.0076522827, 0.0049819946, 0.020874023, 0.036376953, -0.0158844, 0.0017871857, -0.0016517639, -0.009094238, -0.0021781921, -0.040802002, 0.008682251, -0.01612854, -0.0005173683, 0.042388916, -0.026489258, -0.053833008, -0.010757446, 0.000893116, 0.033813477, 0.0071105957, -0.01701355, -0.0036087036, 0.05380249, -0.0015640259, -0.0057792664, 0.009460449, -0.0034370422, 0.0758667, 0.015380859, 0.023635864, -0.031280518, 0.013893127, -0.017715454, -0.014350891, 0.015380859, 0.043273926, -0.015319824, 0.011550903, 0.013145447, -0.035217285, -0.057250977, 0.013954163, 0.02532959, -0.037475586, 0.0121154785, -0.038848877, 0.03955078, -0.0030403137, -0.012809753, -0.012557983, -0.036376953, -0.035583496, 0.037017822, -0.038726807, 0.017364502, -0.0077934265, -0.037261963, -0.03781128, -0.058441162, 0.048187256, 0.0027256012, -0.0037708282, -0.019866943, 0.010009766, -0.040985107, -0.002954483, 0.01473999, -0.09118652, 0.03543091, 0.013290405, 0.035186768, 0.037994385, -0.019897461, -0.031402588, -0.0018062592, 0.022735596, -0.026290894, -0.008399963, 0.019607544, -0.018005371, 0.004146576, -0.0077323914, -0.027832031, -0.022979736, -0.027236938, -0.00007009506, 0.018249512, -0.0418396, 0.05316162, 0.00699234, 0.014442444, 0.014297485, 0.043304443, -0.020553589, -0.003250122, 0.04550171, -0.042114258, 0.011703491, -0.008163452, -0.032287598, 0.03540039, -0.03363037, 0.003944397, 0.009262085, -0.012008667, -0.0010347366, 0.02381897, 0.016662598, 0.017166138, 0.0014476776, 0.0021305084, 0.052886963, -0.008018494, -0.06222534, -0.02279663, -0.002916336, -0.030731201, 0.05206299, 0.034851074, -0.055419922, -0.009468079, -0.0064849854, -0.008666992, 0.029312134, 0.037231445, -0.0074653625, 0.05041504, -0.081604004, -0.043762207, -0.014602661, 0.0063705444, -0.026367188, 0.045715332, -0.017105103, -0.0041618347, -0.0051956177, 0.0029716492, -0.0012378693, 0.0070610046, 0.010696411, 0.036987305, 0.0047950745, 0.0077781677, -0.07946777, -0.015899658, -0.04144287, -0.011482239, 0.058441162, 0.029800415, -0.048980713, 0.026229858, -0.004169464, 0.05807495, 0.02911377, -0.001789093, 0.040527344, 0.054229736, -0.0066108704, 0.013496399, 0.05001831, 0.0008125305, 0.015899658, -0.036621094, 0.01713562, 0.0073776245, -0.0051956177, -0.08325195, -0.04949951, 0.078552246, 0.03652954, -0.021148682, 0.024856567, 0.0062026978, -0.0118255615, 0.015655518, -0.022354126, 0.07745361, 0.042022705, 0.0067329407, 0.029434204, -0.04660034, -0.028762817, 0.03527832, 0.015235901, 0.0033245087, 0.0124053955, -0.008766174, 0.037384033, -0.0012874603, -0.022277832, -0.0079422, 0.03955078, -0.01675415, -0.026824951, -0.022232056, 0.023742676, 0.022140503, -0.04977417, 0.0054969788, -0.00045013428, -0.022216797, 0.02381897, -0.03555298, 0.031311035, 0.057434082, -0.07495117, 0.04724121, 0.003774643, -0.04901123, 0.01184845, 0.072387695, 0.0076904297, 0.008926392, 0.020019531, -0.004508972, -0.0032978058, 0.04083252, 0.05581665, -0.016662598, -0.03186035, 0.0009508133, 0.012779236, 0.0028190613, 0.053527832, 0.005092621, 0.014381409, -0.040405273, -0.03579712, -0.00009518862, -0.018676758, 0.010543823, 0.008995056, -0.016418457, 0.08166504, 0.010009766, -0.020721436, 0.037353516, 0.016464233, -0.04425049, 0.025405884, 0.028076172, 0.0496521, 0.023910522, 0.059173584, -0.007587433, -0.025512695, -0.00035357475, -0.0013084412, 0.02456665, 0.05557251, -0.01335144, 0.009300232, -0.023422241, -0.03213501, 0.03353882, -0.0008406639, 0.060272217, -0.0010213852, -0.01953125, -0.039398193, -0.004634857, 0.0044937134, -0.012145996, 0.0048179626, -0.048034668, -0.019638062, -0.0131073, 0.00440979, -0.0011491776, -0.01902771, -0.005203247, 0.037384033, 0.028167725, 0.009841919, 0.047607422, -0.0287323, -0.08190918, 0.046325684, -0.005367279, 0.0579834, -0.015174866, -0.02067566, 0.01725769, -0.010925293, -0.0027866364, -0.022964478, -0.023269653, -0.033081055, 0.0028629303, -0.031204224, 0.019714355, 0.019638062, -0.008987427, -0.054626465, 0.07281494, -0.02708435, -0.02381897, -0.009155273, 0.023757935, -0.015319824, -0.049591064, -0.006816864, -0.030532837, 0.02178955, 0.006881714, 0.00001335144, 0.012458801, 0.021392822, -0.006439209, -0.017745972, 0.022750854, 0.032592773, -0.005027771, -0.015579224, -0.03387451, 0.022857666, 0.04058838, -0.031829834, -0.09265137, 0.010856628, 0.021942139, -0.004272461, -0.011184692, 0.031829834, 0.03540039, 0.009597778, 0.043670654, 0.010032654, -0.06298828, -0.038726807, -0.00042772293, 0.06604004, 0.02079773, -0.028747559, -0.024307251, 0.009559631, 0.004722595, 0.0014982224, 0.033477783, -0.021713257, 0.025421143, 0.021072388, 0.06530762, 0.0050315857, 0.012168884, 0.02720642, -0.0029144287, -0.021728516, -0.036346436, 0.0046424866, 0.0071525574, -0.04724121, 0.017669678, 0.059295654, 0.014930725, -0.006252289, 0.010978699, 0.05770874, -0.009681702, 0.012634277, -0.032562256, 0.007282257, -0.014228821, 0.0041275024, 0.00856781, -0.0051116943, -0.024978638, -0.0010280609, -0.08050537, -0.02406311, -0.004924774, -0.02331543, 0.023834229, -0.0143585205, 0.007675171, 0.022232056, -0.036224365, 0.026153564, -0.008369446, 0.010154724, 0.0071487427, -0.040222168, -0.013137817, -0.011955261, -0.008033752 ], "summary": [ 0.049560547, -0.0068855286, 0.023071289, -0.0025024414, -0.0076942444, -0.02281189, 0.032348633, -0.032714844, -0.08282471, -0.020111084, 0.016036987, 0.048309326, -0.06072998, -0.053344727, 0.066467285, -0.05026245, 0.009544373, 0.028884888, 0.02168274, -0.029632568, 0.005367279, -0.006263733, 0.013694763, 0.04977417, 0.040771484, -0.03225708, -0.10522461, 0.021697998, 0.0060539246, 0.001786232, 0.014602661, 0.02897644, 0.022857666, -0.012619019, 0.03427124, 0.0066108704, 0.01625061, -0.0032920837, 0.011291504, 0.021575928, 0.0317688, -0.01739502, 0.0362854, -0.033813477, -0.007293701, 0.030380249, -0.0021820068, -0.0018930435, 0.0234375, 0.071777344, 0.010444641, 0.053741455, -0.012283325, 0.05960083, 0.013122559, 0.0058174133, -0.052642822, -0.020370483, 0.030410767, 0.09289551, 0.03945923, -0.024261475, -0.025131226, -0.06222534, 0.003545761, 0.008514404, -0.02571106, 0.0034389496, 0.014167786, 0.012840271, 0.015060425, -0.033447266, 0.021652222, -0.010620117, 0.0051231384, 0.0069084167, 0.013702393, 0.03741455, -0.002292633, -0.000044107437, -0.03933716, -0.022460938, -0.0013141632, -0.013130188, -0.013267517, -0.0035076141, -0.025009155, 0.0040130615, -0.02267456, -0.022872925, -0.022506714, 0.01687622, -0.044921875, 0.0038700104, -0.01424408, -0.03225708, 0.0059661865, -0.030395508, 0.052642822, -0.009132385, 0.046325684, -0.05895996, 0.0065078735, 0.0034999847, -0.0063285828, 0.03729248, 0.014717102, -0.032073975, -0.003414154, -0.012290955, -0.033569336, 0.020584106, 0.005290985, 0.01235199, -0.031921387, -0.024551392, -0.026412964, 0.01071167, -0.00793457, -0.034973145, 0.014282227, 0.033050537, 0.040008545, 0.041748047, 0.01737976, 0.0637207, -0.010627747, -0.07122803, 0.04119873, 0.0082092285, -0.006454468, 0.03010559, 0.0054626465, -0.028869629, -0.03149414, 0.0010280609, 0.029220581, -0.016098022, 0.01574707, -0.017837524, 0.040496826, 0.0075531006, -0.019180298, 0.03161621, -0.012550354, 0.044647217, 0.03656006, -0.012001038, -0.036621094, -0.059661865, -0.019378662, 0.028701782, -0.015510559, -0.0103302, 0.022949219, -0.057037354, -0.051727295, 0.0007724762, 0.08618164, 0.017990112, 0.049621582, 0.016342163, 0.0069770813, 0.051940918, 0.016693115, -0.030822754, -0.0033626556, 0.018157959, 0.0077209473, 0.051696777, -0.024551392, -0.014190674, -0.017501831, -0.022262573, -0.025650024, -0.0035896301, -0.012069702, 0.013847351, 0.055419922, -0.041107178, -0.014213562, -0.0029258728, 0.08239746, -0.00041031837, 0.03665161, -0.06506348, -0.020095825, -0.06756592, 0.031677246, 0.021102905, -0.05392456, 0.022857666, -0.057250977, 0.0071105957, -0.009422302, 0.017959595, -0.0151901245, 0.026931763, -0.008735657, -0.018600464, -0.008682251, -0.028427124, -0.0016841888, 0.006511688, -0.010421753, -0.03189087, 0.005771637, 0.006614685, -0.05102539, 0.046081543, 0.034698486, 0.0038967133, -0.05441284, 0.08850098, 0.067871094, -0.0061531067, 0.023544312, -0.015640259, -0.015327454, -0.03781128, 0.010383606, -0.023071289, -0.023162842, 0.07171631, -0.02357483, -0.011405945, -0.0043792725, 0.007217407, 0.053741455, 0.008232117, 0.10662842, -0.052978516, -0.03640747, 0.032196045, -0.0047416687, -0.03463745, -0.02468872, -0.06185913, 0.049560547, 0.03439331, 0.011650085, -0.0006608963, -0.013504028, 0.04006958, -0.008049011, -0.037902832, 0.0017137527, 0.011177063, -0.049957275, -0.05053711, 0.024871826, 0.01197052, 0.040222168, 0.006893158, 0.0067634583, 0.045928955, -0.023757935, -0.05102539, -0.020187378, 0.013549805, 0.01828003, -0.039123535, -0.024337769, -0.0074043274, -0.049102783, -0.017593384, -0.011001587, -0.009742737, -0.0028648376, -0.035980225, 0.029418945, 0.019882202, 0.0059165955, -0.017791748, -0.022415161, -0.014663696, -0.045288086, 0.030029297, 0.06732178, -0.02029419, 0.0031032562, 0.022033691, 0.026138306, -0.026382446, 0.043426514, 0.018341064, -0.010444641, -0.04019165, 0.017410278, 0.029418945, 0.05090332, 0.020645142, 0.00035119057, 0.021453857, -0.010658264, -0.010063171, 0.03793335, 0.070007324, -0.035186768, 0.017333984, -0.066223145, -0.0023269653, -0.001578331, -0.042236328, 0.026123047, -0.04421997, 0.043914795, 0.04348755, 0.022155762, -0.016998291, -0.03668213, -0.0030536652, 0.026901245, 0.038970947, -0.0055007935, -0.027023315, 0.00868988, 0.029876709, -0.020950317, -0.010856628, 0.06524658, 0.02822876, 0.011795044, 0.027297974, 0.0069885254, -0.043914795, 0.03781128, -0.015289307, 0.020477295, -0.005695343, -0.013427734, -0.026992798, -0.038970947, -0.019836426, -0.0016212463, -0.013244629, 0.008522034, -0.0038108826, 0.0087890625, -0.0020179749, 0.05935669, 0.016662598, 0.013214111, 0.028274536, -0.015289307, -0.031585693, -0.0033054352, -0.007019043, -0.02230835, -0.023330688, 0.02798462, -0.021759033, -0.050628662, 0.0077552795, -0.028335571, -0.0025157928, 0.05847168, 0.010070801, -0.014137268, -0.031021118, 0.04437256, 0.05331421, 0.031280518, -0.09320068, -0.045013428, -0.04473877, -0.0037956238, -0.03161621, 0.02192688, 0.06616211, -0.028930664, 0.08911133, -0.11883545, -0.0289917, -0.014984131, 0.04336548, 0.056396484, -0.028793335, 0.0025863647, 0.028869629, 0.015174866, 0.013824463, -0.0317688, -0.0074310303, 0.026412964, 0.012641907, 0.0103302, 0.054901123, 0.012580872, -0.023727417, 0.0033302307, 0.042388916, 0.020324707, -0.04309082, 0.0006275177, 0.00014543533, 0.007873535, 0.029800415, 0.016906738, -0.028533936, 0.0042266846, 0.0049972534, -0.0040016174, -0.0051574707, -0.013259888, 0.0014867783, 0.0018444061, -0.027374268, 0.017837524, -0.03668213, 0.04776001, -0.026657104, 0.051757812, -0.064331055, 0.00440979, -0.05645752, 0.04147339, 0.008628845, 0.0008239746, -0.031799316, 0.005519867, 0.029556274, -0.0057029724, -0.014038086, -0.009849548, -0.00045228004, 0.0017595291, 0.014831543, 0.014709473, -0.003786087, -0.011268616, -0.029922485, -0.009117126, -0.017410278, -0.05709839, -0.0013771057, 0.020141602, 0.04827881, 0.049865723, -0.029174805, -0.06951904, -0.02784729, -0.04083252, -0.014259338, -0.0003402233, -0.025924683, -0.012275696, -0.059509277, -0.014839172, -0.035491943, 0.001086235, -0.00011122227, 0.04763794, 0.03164673, 0.0079956055, 0.10534668, 0.012931824, 0.022109985, 0.06402588, -0.031799316, -0.032287598, -0.013160706, -0.023147583, 0.00793457, -0.014350891, 0.018203735, 0.01687622, 0.0056648254, -0.030059814, 0.0046577454, -0.013061523, 0.027359009, 0.0012788773, -0.020843506, -0.014518738, -0.0440979, 0.056030273, 0.013267517, 0.033935547, -0.04852295, -0.01663208, 0.010131836, -0.036376953, -0.038330078, -0.0069732666, 0.005332947, -0.068237305, -0.041412354, 0.015853882, 0.043273926, 0.036346436, -0.014129639, 0.028076172, 0.035705566, -0.011955261, -0.01121521, -0.0071411133, 0.04714966, 0.017044067, -0.03527832, -0.04321289, 0.021240234, 0.028625488, -0.02166748, 0.06213379, 0.019226074, -0.010612488, 0.01939392, 0.010017395, -0.0021324158, 0.04220581, -0.02168274, 0.050231934, 0.03677368, -0.009567261, 0.012413025, 0.027191162, 0.07104492, -0.037231445, -0.027038574, 0.051757812, 0.04397583, -0.054351807, 0.0093307495, 0.06964111, 0.0006875992, -0.08496094, 0.022094727, -0.01763916, -0.009925842, 0.036468506, 0.010353088, -0.04006958, -0.02949524, 0.027755737, 0.008056641, -0.02885437, -0.019882202, 0.013534546, 0.022750854, -0.02973938, -0.047973633, -0.00084877014, 0.048095703, 0.0025558472, -0.03451538, -0.019424438, -0.006790161, -0.025772095, -0.019989014, -0.005088806, 0.004558563, -0.047210693, -0.027114868, -0.01461792, 0.005493164, -0.024765015, 0.017959595, -0.013328552, 0.005405426, -0.015594482, 0.014541626, -0.013259888, 0.015960693, -0.00422287, 0.054473877, -0.07696533, -0.07550049, -0.01737976, -0.0039024353, -0.04083252, -0.01878357, -0.025375366, -0.0064353943, -0.021835327, -0.0033740997, -0.0289917, -0.0015077591, 0.01574707, 0.0960083, 0.03857422, 0.04699707, -0.064453125, 0.019989014, -0.009140015, 0.019897461, 0.009170532, 0.036621094, 0.0019035339, 0.0055122375, 0.004890442, -0.03161621, -0.01802063, 0.0010271072, -0.010253906, -0.0055389404, 0.013549805, 0.033172607, 0.091674805, 0.006752014, 0.006690979, 0.032318115, -0.0019321442, -0.010101318, -0.026565552, 0.02885437, 0.026779175, 0.009422302, 0.011497498, -0.009132385, 0.016540527, -0.016204834, -0.020462036, 0.048797607, -0.009361267, -0.0362854, -0.03463745, 0.02545166, 0.0013065338, 0.03439331, 0.034057617, -0.020141602, 0.023452759, -0.007572174, 0.0137786865, 0.0579834, -0.0077819824, 0.0211792, -0.024429321, -0.006877899, -0.026855469, -0.03717041, -0.044433594, -0.029800415, 0.00919342, 0.044525146, -0.033203125, -0.029891968, -0.061920166, -0.036346436, 0.02684021, 0.0065193176, -0.00032782555, -0.046325684, -0.015449524, -0.0138549805, -0.017944336, 0.0050964355, -0.034576416, -0.0048942566, 0.0073127747, 0.013313293, 0.029922485, -0.0035934448, -0.030456543, 0.0112838745, -0.008743286, 0.003036499, 0.015098572, -0.034606934, -0.05529785, 0.011100769, -0.0018749237, -0.02798462, 0.0013360977, -0.0075531006, -0.0052261353, 0.010101318, -0.0059814453, -0.02456665, -0.012023926, -0.026916504, 0.00089263916, 0.0072364807, 0.0076675415, -0.0036563873, 0.021881104, 0.0032215118, -0.011230469, -0.023727417, 0.011604309, -0.06439209, -0.037261963, -0.03994751, 0.016098022, 0.011924744, -0.001496315, 0.033996582, -0.0004911423, -0.008270264, -0.025177002, -0.019607544, -0.0087890625, -0.056549072, -0.020507812, -0.04473877, -0.013427734, -0.04425049, -0.0044403076, -0.015823364, -0.002439499, -0.008430481, 0.04598999, 0.006298065, -0.023666382, 0.03741455, 0.024246216, -0.00315094, 0.044006348, 0.020858765, 0.006526947, -0.024627686, -0.021530151, -0.0073242188, 0.0022888184, -0.014183044, -0.020690918, -0.0019779205, -0.02331543, 0.021591187, -0.010314941, -0.020812988, -0.018844604, -0.047668457, 0.005455017, -0.052337646, -0.016281128, -0.011489868, -0.024749756, -0.057250977, 0.029769897, -0.03173828, -0.042266846, 0.018295288, 0.010559082, 0.013496399, 0.007232666, 0.015357971, -0.016799927, 0.06008911, 0.017364502, -0.011268616, 0.0317688, -0.020065308, 0.0234375, 0.03050232, 0.015930176, 0.037353516, 0.00052928925, 0.0102005005, 0.0073509216, 0.012069702, 0.012702942, 0.017501831, 0.02078247, 0.016693115, 0.091796875, 0.012535095, -0.007904053, -0.049194336, 0.0036468506, 0.011802673, 0.006000519, -0.011390686, -0.037384033, 0.0049057007, -0.012870789, -0.0022621155, 0.049804688, -0.039367676, -0.0395813, -0.006427765, 0.0076828003, 0.02835083, 0.07208252, 0.004447937, 0.033721924, -0.009796143, -0.010559082, -0.01663208, -0.00059890747, 0.006980896, -0.021820068, 0.016143799, -0.017089844, 0.016983032, 0.008628845, 0.016921997, -0.03543091, -0.0063323975, -0.0007491112, 0.045684814, 0.020248413, 0.005329132, -0.0138549805, -0.019042969, 0.021652222, 0.013069153, 0.0025367737, -0.017242432, 0.00036287308, -0.011795044, -0.07904053, -0.011329651, -0.05734253, -0.0151901245, -0.06524658, 0.038238525, -0.030670166, 0.06738281, -0.0082473755, 0.012825012, 0.01272583, -0.052764893, 0.014732361, -0.011169434, 0.0032730103, 0.003768921, -0.035217285, -0.025253296, 0.019165039, 0.035217285, -0.0009946823, 0.027648926, 0.0065956116, -0.0058784485, 0.013870239, 0.021972656, -0.05456543, -0.01928711, 0.057128906, -0.035095215, 0.04675293, 0.016174316, 0.044036865, 0.023529053, 0.0057868958, 0.006454468, -0.015113831, 0.017471313, -0.0124053955, -0.031555176, 0.028686523, 0.03488159, -0.08709717, 0.049560547, 0.030334473, -0.02986145, -0.0034828186, 0.05014038, 0.018356323, -0.005214691, 0.012908936, -0.020706177, 0.0069236755, 0.010444641, 0.02078247, -0.024719238, -0.043426514, 0.0058937073, 0.021469116, -0.028305054, 0.0134887695, 0.007965088, -0.00032305717, -0.054718018, 0.0034599304, -0.014816284, 0.021835327, -0.040863037, 0.015602112, -0.074645996, 0.026321411, 0.05041504, -0.007980347, 0.05038452, 0.018630981, 0.0047340393, 0.053741455, -0.0357666, 0.061523438, 0.05206299, 0.052612305, -0.022155762, 0.0035629272, 0.070373535, -0.008972168, 0.017166138, -0.009521484, -0.017471313, -0.01424408, -0.0066833496, 0.014335632, 0.014434814, 0.023284912, 0.023895264, -0.0541687, 0.05456543, -0.01008606, -0.01096344, -0.033111572, -0.017288208, 0.004512787, -0.0053977966, 0.023590088, 0.035858154, 0.04824829, -0.012969971, 0.030166626, 0.0317688, -0.012901306, 0.059051514, 0.0074806213, 0.006111145, 0.0013942719, 0.005569458, 0.036895752, 0.0036182404, 0.09075928, -0.020980835, -0.01637268, 0.016937256, 0.021057129, -0.0031776428, -0.03543091, -0.024154663, 0.0546875, 0.015129089, -0.088256836, 0.040863037, 0.01737976, -0.0038795471, 0.066589355, -0.017608643, 0.02558899, 0.011940002, 0.020935059, 0.01890564, 0.009979248, -0.042419434, -0.0020313263, -0.014038086, -0.008880615, -0.038330078, -0.014785767, 0.04727173, 0.009490967, -0.037475586, 0.02859497, 0.014793396, 0.03277588, -0.009002686, -0.012672424, 0.0072631836, 0.016647339, 0.040283203, -0.006511688, 0.0051956177, 0.010398865, -0.028152466, -0.034576416, 0.00687027, -0.010421753, 0.011291504, 0.022567749, 0.083618164, 0.008926392, -0.054016113, 0.0028476715, 0.011627197, 0.041778564, 0.0065689087, -0.024932861, -0.013420105, -0.0060424805, -0.016647339, -0.04095459, 0.026031494, -0.00044488907, -0.035003662, 0.025024414, 0.0026016235, -0.0074157715, -0.060028076, 0.033325195, 0.0017156601, -0.01222229, 0.007030487, -0.010269165, -0.019927979, -0.012504578, 0.009468079, 0.009552002, 0.010353088, 0.007068634, -0.003692627, 0.032928467, -0.023605347, 0.012527466, -0.0042304993, 0.030563354, -0.008659363, -0.005870819, -0.00041007996, 0.03515625, -0.021881104, -0.018493652, -0.040863037, -0.020507812, -0.036743164, -0.024047852, 0.019546509, 0.0028476715, -0.0027999878, 0.06591797, -0.031829834, 0.022003174, -0.018966675, 0.03604126, -0.003622055, 0.0055274963, 0.023025513, -0.0039138794, 0.016464233 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2111.01705v1
AI Ethics Statements -- Analysis and lessons learnt from NeurIPS Broader Impact Statements
Carolyn Ashurst, Emmie Hine, Paul Sedille, Alexis Carlier
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.LG
Ethics statements have been proposed as a mechanism to increase transparency and promote reflection on the societal impacts of published research. In 2020, the machine learning (ML) conference NeurIPS broke new ground by requiring that all papers include a broader impact statement. This requirement was removed in 2021, in favour of a checklist approach. The 2020 statements therefore provide a unique opportunity to learn from the broader impact experiment: to investigate the benefits and challenges of this and similar governance mechanisms, as well as providing an insight into how ML researchers think about the societal impacts of their own work. Such learning is needed as NeurIPS and other venues continue to question and adapt their policies. To enable this, we have created a dataset containing the impact statements from all NeurIPS 2020 papers, along with additional information such as affiliation type, location and subject area, and a simple visualisation tool for exploration. We also provide an initial quantitative analysis of the dataset, covering representation, engagement, common themes, and willingness to discuss potential harms alongside benefits. We investigate how these vary by geography, affiliation type and subject area. Drawing on these findings, we discuss the potential benefits and negative outcomes of ethics statement requirements, and their possible causes and associated challenges. These lead us to several lessons to be learnt from the 2020 requirement: (i) the importance of creating the right incentives, (ii) the need for clear expectations and guidance, and (iii) the importance of transparency and constructive deliberation. We encourage other researchers to use our dataset to provide additional analysis, to further our understanding of how researchers responded to this requirement, and to investigate the benefits and challenges of this and related mechanisms.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2111.01705v1
"2021-11-02T16:17:12"
"2021-11-02T16:17:12"
{ "title": [ -0.0056152344, 0.0044021606, -0.032806396, -0.007648468, -0.016983032, -0.022735596, 0.016418457, 0.009590149, -0.015007019, 0.008148193, -0.058563232, -0.0060653687, 0.034942627, -0.037261963, 0.010826111, -0.041046143, 0.00554657, 0.038757324, 0.036132812, -0.01109314, -0.012672424, -0.0012731552, 0.01802063, -0.011451721, 0.02458191, 0.0037593842, -0.050231934, 0.00035738945, -0.036834717, -0.043945312, -0.0017147064, 0.06149292, -0.0044517517, 0.018615723, 0.013175964, 0.03869629, 0.021087646, 0.011680603, 0.017913818, 0.037506104, 0.008255005, 0.0003376007, 0.038848877, -0.048553467, 0.010261536, 0.006793976, -0.0029640198, -0.013877869, -0.0031490326, 0.024154663, 0.031036377, -0.0049819946, 0.027496338, 0.05215454, -0.0031814575, 0.0037441254, -0.06488037, 0.0077819824, 0.036865234, -0.0017490387, -0.014717102, -0.04208374, 0.04736328, -0.013206482, 0.0066871643, -0.028961182, -0.050689697, 0.011444092, 0.022903442, 0.045532227, 0.016998291, -0.03466797, -0.0096588135, 0.037353516, -0.054626465, -0.06536865, 0.02432251, -0.021408081, 0.024017334, 0.020355225, 0.00223732, -0.01109314, -0.0087509155, -0.06976318, 0.023956299, -0.06188965, 0.0058631897, 0.012298584, 0.0015459061, 0.014732361, -0.00598526, 0.06173706, 0.00073099136, 0.02923584, -0.04043579, -0.01876831, -0.01727295, 0.035186768, -0.005794525, -0.014434814, -0.05593872, 0.012878418, -0.047973633, -0.017807007, 0.009796143, 0.017608643, 0.028152466, -0.010749817, -0.0037403107, 0.0020217896, -0.03488159, 0.04437256, 0.032592773, -0.01928711, 0.00579834, -0.024658203, -0.0018930435, 0.038238525, 0.004055023, -0.000992775, -0.002254486, 0.010658264, 0.043762207, 0.03604126, 0.014907837, 0.033325195, 0.0005812645, -0.0670166, 0.02772522, 0.03326416, -0.0032901764, 0.03439331, -0.08874512, -0.061431885, -0.04901123, -0.009178162, 0.011512756, 0.024215698, 0.0008749962, -0.011177063, 0.03237915, 0.011108398, 0.0126571655, 0.045013428, -0.02078247, 0.020568848, 0.026123047, 0.0063667297, -0.006099701, -0.025787354, -0.02684021, -0.010032654, -0.00083112717, 0.0015954971, -0.002691269, -0.04296875, -0.048980713, -0.0045700073, 0.07861328, 0.0072021484, 0.03918457, 0.020111084, 0.027008057, 0.010643005, 0.032165527, -0.046844482, -0.060913086, 0.0231781, 0.005970001, 0.04626465, 0.0029697418, -0.028457642, -0.025924683, -0.011062622, -0.024871826, -0.0045814514, -0.050994873, -0.028549194, -0.001247406, -0.0037765503, 0.00944519, -0.022750854, -0.11016846, 0.09326172, -0.01890564, -0.017623901, 0.009742737, 0.021102905, 0.023208618, 0.017929077, -0.020690918, 0.004386902, -0.0053977966, 0.0063705444, -0.053497314, -0.015701294, -0.020828247, 0.03768921, -0.029205322, -0.016983032, -0.043121338, 0.047851562, -0.041809082, 0.055725098, 0.00055122375, 0.014633179, 0.017349243, 0.008079529, -0.016571045, 0.037841797, 0.025787354, 0.006340027, 0.00067710876, -0.04638672, -0.012916565, -0.036315918, 0.003704071, -0.066467285, -0.009567261, -0.044036865, 0.010147095, 0.032409668, -0.011672974, 0.077819824, 0.0048065186, 0.0256958, 0.0016326904, -0.0072288513, 0.05041504, 0.031951904, 0.068115234, -0.024963379, 0.027877808, 0.05847168, -0.014045715, -0.00025749207, 0.022781372, -0.013725281, 0.009803772, 0.019592285, 0.020980835, 0.003604889, -0.0007777214, 0.0068206787, 0.042510986, -0.016906738, 0.029556274, -0.013267517, 0.00015342236, -0.043060303, -0.020812988, -0.016113281, 0.07867432, 0.0029315948, 0.011787415, 0.053375244, -0.010848999, -0.022140503, -0.024963379, 0.04067993, 0.013877869, 0.03378296, 0.015602112, 0.023757935, -0.06677246, 0.004146576, -0.0154800415, 0.024963379, -0.031921387, -0.024139404, 0.053771973, 0.056427002, 0.009819031, 0.030014038, 0.03149414, -0.036468506, -0.0033893585, -0.011405945, -0.0032920837, -0.016067505, -0.0016708374, 0.01675415, 0.028442383, 0.0034179688, 0.0030937195, 0.023498535, 0.042266846, -0.004447937, -0.054229736, -0.03100586, 0.0054855347, 0.038024902, -0.01966858, -0.0079574585, 0.011993408, 0.004108429, 0.049804688, 0.071777344, -0.019042969, 0.013969421, -0.09832764, -0.0044403076, 0.01966858, -0.02330017, 0.016433716, 0.00019967556, 0.026473999, -0.01612854, -0.014022827, 0.0064468384, -0.07269287, -0.018722534, 0.0065689087, 0.025924683, -0.045013428, -0.06100464, -0.012794495, 0.015167236, -0.06549072, -0.025756836, 0.03741455, 0.013473511, 0.025436401, -0.061065674, 0.01701355, -0.045318604, -0.05331421, -0.0040626526, -0.0006055832, -0.021774292, 0.012817383, -0.051361084, -0.08642578, -0.049987793, 0.038909912, 0.042388916, 0.014831543, 0.062408447, -0.00026535988, -0.0657959, -0.025253296, 0.0022659302, -0.049438477, -0.027740479, -0.018676758, -0.015991211, -0.012023926, -0.0032958984, 0.0061454773, 0.011497498, 0.010658264, 0.018692017, 0.0016889572, -0.021224976, 0.049194336, -0.0657959, -0.010177612, 0.034973145, 0.021896362, -0.028900146, 0.04623413, 0.0062942505, 0.026321411, -0.042816162, -0.03552246, -0.04559326, -0.010627747, 0.00018703938, 0.011123657, 0.018875122, -0.021881104, -0.0039367676, -0.0011358261, -0.009895325, -0.010154724, -0.0051956177, -0.0006299019, -0.02558899, -0.013076782, -0.010185242, 0.004634857, -0.033294678, 0.066589355, -0.035369873, 0.019012451, -0.0032196045, -0.034423828, -0.008544922, 0.0053749084, 0.030380249, -0.025054932, -0.026733398, -0.0061569214, -0.02330017, 0.01687622, 0.0070762634, -0.011650085, 0.013908386, -0.028717041, -0.005886078, 0.022537231, -0.024383545, -0.025497437, -0.0012178421, -0.053588867, 0.0028572083, -0.0063667297, -0.017791748, 0.016860962, 0.043884277, -0.02130127, 0.029190063, 0.025817871, -0.008125305, 0.005214691, -0.011131287, -0.06756592, 0.019363403, -0.048217773, 0.03326416, -0.00012397766, 0.055511475, -0.05831909, -0.020568848, -0.032958984, -0.010734558, 0.0006546974, 0.020217896, -0.05102539, 0.002855301, -0.009643555, -0.04611206, -0.0059928894, -0.015991211, -0.018112183, -0.0030956268, -0.0093688965, 0.023757935, 0.016098022, -0.00983429, -0.03555298, -0.010879517, 0.016082764, 0.006591797, 0.03765869, -0.029769897, -0.012298584, -0.024810791, -0.029464722, 0.01675415, -0.03942871, 0.021865845, -0.051330566, 0.023040771, -0.03463745, 0.013946533, 0.025131226, 0.070495605, -0.014762878, 0.03366089, 0.029403687, -0.025558472, 0.03692627, 0.023483276, -0.03643799, -0.0065727234, 0.03363037, 0.02407837, -0.014892578, -0.012008667, -0.0044670105, 0.023284912, -0.007865906, -0.01084137, 0.0093688965, -0.05319214, -0.019561768, 0.026275635, 0.011955261, -0.007858276, -0.011116028, 0.005809784, 0.056854248, -0.035308838, -0.03463745, 0.030944824, -0.06781006, -0.0032024384, -0.00013434887, -0.08416748, -0.05810547, -0.020690918, 0.036193848, -0.110839844, -0.007385254, -0.023590088, -0.006629944, 0.02268982, 0.017227173, -0.027694702, -0.042877197, -0.0067596436, -0.024368286, -0.019012451, 0.022735596, 0.039489746, 0.01701355, -0.000893116, 0.0066452026, 0.037719727, 0.018447876, -0.027313232, -0.020202637, 0.03765869, -0.039367676, 0.03640747, -0.0020275116, -0.017913818, 0.0045051575, 0.022918701, 0.027786255, 0.05596924, -0.055725098, 0.017745972, 0.07531738, -0.0076141357, -0.085632324, 0.043304443, -0.028167725, -0.07678223, -0.013420105, 0.026947021, -0.0056991577, 0.032348633, 0.03274536, 0.043792725, -0.034942627, -0.01448822, 0.0058403015, 0.0121154785, -0.015808105, -0.019454956, -0.012771606, 0.04257202, -0.009628296, 0.011894226, 0.02406311, 0.072631836, 0.017227173, -0.017913818, 0.03717041, 0.043823242, -0.03744507, -0.010139465, 0.007347107, -0.048339844, -0.04916382, 0.013397217, 0.01739502, -0.005935669, 0.04244995, 0.013809204, -0.027832031, -0.02709961, 0.004245758, -0.013389587, 0.039794922, -0.033172607, -0.018356323, 0.0070495605, -0.06945801, -0.033477783, -0.007423401, 0.016021729, 0.0090408325, -0.01020813, -0.0068969727, 0.020523071, 0.022064209, 0.03161621, 0.004016876, 0.0065841675, -0.009902954, 0.028457642, 0.012145996, -0.008666992, 0.012428284, 0.0110321045, 0.008995056, -0.012886047, -0.012840271, -0.021743774, -0.031234741, -0.066833496, 0.023391724, 0.045410156, 0.03387451, 0.007751465, -0.03933716, 0.021316528, 0.014274597, -0.016143799, -0.0026988983, -0.029312134, 0.031234741, -0.015640259, 0.003967285, 0.015541077, 0.046295166, 0.013679504, 0.018981934, -0.05380249, -0.00085783005, 0.060302734, 0.0005502701, -0.041107178, 0.037994385, -0.005142212, 0.0009665489, -0.022979736, -0.00077581406, 0.023742676, 0.0115356445, -0.039489746, 0.04244995, -0.04901123, -0.021408081, 0.015586853, 0.00983429, -0.005432129, 0.015563965, -0.0025787354, 0.020706177, -0.006877899, 0.032684326, -0.018600464, 0.014518738, -0.022460938, -0.00434494, 0.07171631, -0.024047852, 0.029754639, 0.00630188, -0.03717041, 0.023788452, -0.060058594, -0.058624268, -0.020950317, -0.042022705, -0.03274536, -0.029327393, 0.012588501, -0.026229858, 0.06274414, 0.020584106, -0.019577026, -0.039245605, -0.036743164, 0.05822754, -0.026519775, -0.0069389343, 0.07647705, -0.048919678, 0.070129395, 0.020370483, -0.008201599, 0.0103302, 0.026367188, -0.026535034, 0.005619049, 0.0033130646, -0.007965088, -0.0211792, -0.009994507, 0.015174866, 0.03378296, 0.034454346, 0.026260376, 0.006877899, -0.046173096, -0.010032654, -0.012367249, 0.05441284, -0.04006958, -0.015281677, 0.038024902, 0.0008568764, -0.03152466, -0.0013618469, -0.054595947, -0.044006348, 0.023483276, -0.046081543, 0.0036067963, 0.009017944, -0.021270752, -0.013427734, -0.014091492, 0.03955078, -0.010871887, 0.00050354004, 0.0028152466, 0.01878357, -0.0043907166, 0.037841797, 0.010284424, -0.06298828, -0.0042648315, 0.018432617, 0.007293701, 0.032226562, 0.026824951, -0.03463745, -0.005722046, 0.022445679, -0.012428284, -0.02909851, -0.012214661, -0.031158447, -0.00032544136, -0.011016846, -0.042663574, -0.04675293, -0.039855957, 0.0042037964, -0.062042236, -0.022567749, -0.0050468445, 0.0013980865, 0.038208008, 0.006881714, 0.02468872, 0.068481445, -0.030044556, -0.025253296, -0.034118652, 0.016784668, 0.0044021606, -0.030883789, -0.011703491, -0.060943604, -0.0037384033, 0.0027923584, -0.019485474, 0.008224487, 0.03817749, 0.024780273, 0.037109375, 0.025878906, 0.026931763, 0.07531738, -0.033721924, -0.071777344, -0.0049057007, 0.0073242188, -0.029632568, 0.005203247, 0.031555176, -0.03933716, 0.0008702278, -0.025024414, -0.008041382, 0.01574707, 0.02798462, -0.006515503, 0.033599854, -0.040649414, -0.016998291, -0.02168274, 0.013000488, 0.0028190613, 0.014228821, -0.029205322, -0.010551453, 0.016220093, 0.017990112, 0.0017557144, -0.025802612, 0.0390625, 0.0030021667, 0.0038986206, 0.0005326271, 0.043029785, -0.0013465881, -0.0112838745, -0.009552002, 0.057525635, -0.0076446533, 0.0057678223, 0.03010559, -0.03048706, 0.028533936, 0.009422302, -0.007881165, 0.01864624, 0.02671814, 0.0078048706, -0.0013179779, -0.01966858, -0.007888794, -0.0007519722, -0.028701782, 0.023269653, 0.036621094, 0.009277344, -0.07128906, -0.015327454, 0.07910156, 0.039794922, -0.032958984, 0.025238037, -0.012817383, -0.015174866, 0.0107803345, -0.009399414, 0.06726074, -0.012619019, -0.020950317, 0.015960693, 0.01108551, -0.012130737, 0.0043640137, -0.00071048737, 0.04989624, -0.00016200542, 0.008674622, 0.048553467, -0.050598145, 0.0024852753, -0.03125, 0.010749817, -0.026657104, -0.016815186, -0.013244629, -0.01625061, 0.041137695, 0.036132812, -0.02658081, 0.01966858, 0.022460938, -0.02722168, -0.030181885, 0.024139404, 0.013694763, -0.05621338, 0.06201172, -0.0073623657, -0.049468994, 0.00030112267, 0.070251465, 0.034973145, 0.009941101, 0.022537231, 0.029510498, 0.0030822754, 0.008613586, 0.02116394, -0.029403687, -0.029174805, 0.031707764, 0.012718201, -0.018356323, 0.0124053955, 0.016677856, 0.017532349, 0.03277588, -0.0053977966, -0.023757935, 0.01134491, -0.0038452148, 0.03817749, 0.014205933, 0.066711426, -0.046020508, -0.04498291, 0.049957275, -0.025268555, -0.020736694, 0.002149582, -0.010192871, 0.00957489, -0.011947632, 0.051818848, 0.0063438416, -0.012245178, -0.03237915, 0.021865845, 0.017303467, 0.01360321, -0.016052246, -0.010322571, -0.00019145012, 0.0039634705, 0.022460938, 0.034179688, 0.04827881, 0.02267456, 0.020843506, -0.01184082, -0.038391113, 0.024932861, -0.022506714, -0.008094788, -0.01939392, 0.025009155, 0.0051727295, 0.005531311, -0.03552246, -0.014251709, 0.007408142, 0.032440186, 0.026901245, 0.03741455, 0.044067383, -0.059631348, -0.013504028, 0.074279785, 0.070495605, 0.10272217, 0.046722412, -0.0028629303, -0.007896423, 0.018966675, 0.0027446747, -0.027999878, -0.016830444, 0.029205322, -0.021606445, -0.024047852, 0.017120361, 0.0045928955, -0.018249512, -0.059539795, 0.022949219, -0.014091492, -0.01977539, 0.0284729, 0.024780273, 0.010810852, -0.08337402, 0.007637024, -0.041137695, -0.008293152, -0.037841797, -0.005596161, -0.012664795, 0.024368286, -0.0030784607, -0.034606934, 0.016204834, 0.044158936, -0.01222229, -0.013084412, -0.01763916, 0.0073890686, 0.056671143, -0.064575195, -0.11810303, 0.0051231384, 0.07122803, -0.011726379, 0.044799805, 0.005836487, 0.06100464, -0.007980347, 0.066101074, -0.0039749146, -0.0657959, 0.02166748, 0.018341064, 0.021942139, 0.0126953125, -0.02658081, 0.025375366, -0.0138168335, -0.031982422, 0.018661499, 0.05117798, -0.025680542, 0.027389526, -0.009170532, 0.027954102, -0.033447266, -0.009346008, 0.0038642883, 0.029266357, -0.020507812, -0.0038528442, -0.0026683807, 0.00894165, -0.004573822, 0.0541687, 0.00484848, -0.053771973, 0.014190674, 0.035827637, 0.009376526, 0.06402588, -0.002817154, -0.041046143, -0.0021705627, -0.0033512115, 0.012001038, -0.009521484, -0.0030670166, -0.0084991455, -0.009803772, -0.038238525, -0.0491333, 0.03488159, -0.01663208, 0.028564453, -0.04510498, 0.026107788, -0.0043754578, 0.00090169907, 0.021148682, 0.03353882, -0.0029144287, 0.032806396, -0.025253296, 0.03491211, -0.008781433, -0.016921997 ], "summary": [ 0.017654419, -0.018188477, -0.039642334, -0.02432251, -0.004016876, -0.030975342, 0.014297485, 0.014846802, 0.008666992, -0.017196655, -0.050750732, 0.028244019, 8.34465e-7, -0.024902344, 0.020828247, -0.028411865, -0.0013179779, 0.03439331, 0.038848877, -0.021316528, 0.026657104, -0.0077934265, 0.011436462, -0.04638672, 0.039733887, -0.074279785, -0.0076789856, 0.041168213, -0.020950317, -0.0005698204, -0.000043272972, 0.03753662, 0.04144287, 0.008216858, -0.016479492, 0.06225586, 0.051757812, -0.025939941, 0.0002143383, 0.056793213, 0.04888916, -0.034454346, 0.03390503, -0.052246094, -0.0033073425, 0.032043457, 0.010749817, -0.013587952, 0.006099701, 0.03201294, 0.0357666, 0.008071899, 0.011329651, -0.008155823, -0.0031051636, 0.0016889572, -0.037261963, 0.0018835068, 0.026977539, 0.044433594, -0.003862381, -0.01499176, -0.009567261, -0.04937744, 0.020812988, 0.008552551, 0.019836426, 0.013214111, 0.0063438416, 0.023971558, -0.0001000762, -0.014518738, 0.001824379, -0.023117065, -0.039642334, 0.011367798, -0.0025291443, -0.03475952, 0.0126953125, -0.011436462, -0.014755249, -0.003921509, -0.012741089, -0.024276733, -0.015266418, -0.024124146, -0.009437561, -0.0035800934, 0.0113220215, 0.05267334, -0.0041999817, -0.00048089027, 0.031982422, 0.078308105, 0.021575928, -0.013153076, -0.047302246, 0.027236938, -0.030822754, 0.0051956177, -0.040802002, 0.024047852, -0.035858154, -0.025222778, -0.007801056, 0.054718018, 0.010505676, -0.035491943, -0.01222229, -0.00093460083, -0.010192871, -0.0074501038, 0.022888184, -0.011726379, -0.031433105, 0.025604248, 0.027496338, -0.009513855, 0.009063721, 0.036865234, 0.003288269, 0.025512695, 0.0007710457, 0.02470398, 0.034118652, 0.04373169, -0.0012693405, -0.035095215, -0.00932312, 0.04144287, 0.02609253, -0.012626648, -0.061065674, 0.0048828125, -0.028366089, -0.024047852, 0.016693115, 0.004547119, -0.008430481, 0.029251099, -0.0025463104, -0.034088135, -0.008529663, 0.021865845, 0.02279663, 0.014175415, 0.007537842, 0.005897522, 0.011451721, 0.008682251, -0.004875183, 0.002450943, 0.033416748, -0.017913818, -0.06188965, -0.08886719, -0.071899414, -0.019836426, 0.0569458, -0.04888916, 0.02835083, 0.024246216, 0.031234741, 0.020141602, 0.031707764, -0.043182373, -0.051849365, 0.011482239, 0.0018692017, 0.002614975, -0.0005540848, 0.020111084, -0.02029419, 0.0073280334, 0.010871887, -0.012062073, -0.047607422, -0.008346558, -0.0036087036, 0.016830444, 0.016693115, -0.0206604, -0.068603516, 0.07019043, 0.007881165, -0.012825012, 0.013641357, 0.048950195, 0.025543213, 0.03225708, -0.048461914, -0.014587402, -0.0032024384, -0.011764526, -0.025756836, -0.03665161, -0.036071777, -0.0071754456, -0.036743164, 0.022949219, 0.027740479, 0.01701355, -0.028289795, -0.0032424927, -0.06695557, -0.0030002594, -0.0028495789, 0.01499176, -0.08135986, 0.007106781, 0.043792725, -0.019088745, -0.041503906, 0.054992676, 0.032470703, -0.018005371, 0.02168274, -0.019989014, -0.0036678314, -0.03857422, 0.011276245, 0.010681152, -0.009628296, 0.066711426, 0.003835678, -0.004386902, -0.0004632473, -0.010040283, 0.07891846, 0.0027503967, 0.08050537, -0.011650085, 0.044189453, 0.062072754, 0.011871338, 0.0138168335, 0.025772095, -0.06286621, 0.0033054352, 0.029373169, 0.022888184, 0.0129776, -0.021697998, 0.0010738373, 0.012641907, -0.025787354, 0.0061187744, -0.008544922, -0.015563965, -0.044799805, 0.0049858093, -0.025421143, 0.07086182, -0.033416748, -0.00667572, 0.053009033, -0.010971069, -0.02796936, 0.018600464, 0.0021076202, 0.012573242, -0.0055732727, -0.015068054, 0.012886047, -0.055633545, -0.040924072, 0.0033302307, 0.0055618286, 0.017196655, -0.064331055, 0.028060913, 0.03100586, 0.012886047, 0.03567505, 0.011329651, 0.0095825195, 0.033447266, -0.029220581, -0.019729614, 0.018478394, -0.0446167, -0.088012695, -0.015640259, 0.011566162, 0.045806885, -0.016403198, 0.051330566, -0.004585266, -0.021087646, -0.015052795, 0.021636963, 0.0014066696, -0.02482605, 0.00233078, 0.012374878, -0.031677246, 0.025421143, -0.0041503906, 0.0067329407, -0.00674057, -0.0289917, 0.04360962, 0.027801514, -0.022109985, 0.024551392, 0.021881104, 0.049316406, 0.020843506, 0.008918762, -0.00019836426, -0.033996582, -0.039398193, -0.0013847351, 0.0024490356, -0.048614502, -0.046142578, -0.028381348, -0.001578331, -0.058654785, 0.021118164, 0.08856201, -0.004043579, 0.035003662, -0.016830444, 0.010215759, -0.066711426, -0.009437561, -0.025299072, -0.013374329, -0.011604309, -0.008705139, -0.045013428, -0.055114746, -0.037353516, 0.012672424, 0.022476196, 0.0043640137, 0.059326172, -0.006416321, -0.070739746, -0.0010919571, -0.009742737, -0.020828247, 0.018722534, -0.047576904, 0.002210617, -0.0068626404, 0.00036358833, 0.038848877, 0.015159607, -0.008041382, 0.016174316, -0.005924225, 0.00069379807, 0.020904541, -0.023590088, 0.013168335, -0.00083875656, -0.024383545, -0.04147339, 0.0435791, -0.0032253265, 0.006095886, -0.046417236, -0.051513672, -0.0105896, -0.007396698, -0.0012292862, 0.035705566, 0.03451538, 0.020736694, 0.023925781, -0.03704834, -0.009552002, 0.012496948, -0.014404297, 0.057434082, 0.0038776398, 0.01234436, 0.038482666, 0.013954163, -0.002046585, 0.024383545, -0.045288086, 0.034210205, -0.0031394958, -0.032226562, -0.0064582825, 0.02178955, 0.030426025, -0.02331543, -0.041656494, 0.07458496, -0.055633545, -0.010986328, 0.015571594, -0.019729614, -0.0026416779, 0.081848145, -0.022003174, 0.03503418, -0.011047363, -0.024398804, 0.004055023, -0.043029785, 0.041992188, -0.020370483, -0.0020370483, 0.019561768, 0.04425049, -0.010238647, 0.012062073, -0.0066490173, 0.010604858, -0.006629944, 0.0030174255, -0.06744385, 0.0069274902, -0.056243896, 0.015640259, -0.011672974, 0.064453125, -0.056152344, -0.018554688, -0.021453857, -0.023635864, -0.0158844, 0.020095825, -0.06896973, 0.028778076, -0.012802124, -0.019226074, -0.013870239, 0.003255844, -0.024169922, 0.012138367, 0.013595581, -0.019943237, 0.030471802, -0.03994751, -0.01109314, 0.018692017, 0.055664062, 0.016311646, 0.07141113, -0.047424316, 0.02192688, -0.010429382, 0.020446777, 0.0418396, -0.03024292, 0.008575439, 0.01600647, 0.0154800415, -0.033325195, -0.040893555, 0.023086548, 0.039733887, 0.028060913, 0.014671326, 0.02355957, -0.0104904175, 0.028076172, 0.02798462, 0.0077285767, 0.026611328, 0.004966736, 0.021072388, 0.015686035, -0.021377563, 0.035705566, -0.010269165, -0.040649414, -0.012527466, 0.035308838, -0.0071258545, -0.012031555, 0.0082473755, 0.021621704, -0.0029315948, -0.02281189, 0.026733398, 0.044036865, -0.07910156, -0.03616333, 0.015945435, -0.07495117, -0.056854248, 0.0023231506, -0.060638428, -0.03302002, -0.033111572, 0.0513916, -0.08795166, -0.007423401, -0.013671875, -0.017318726, 0.052368164, 0.021652222, -0.04788208, 0.009628296, -0.021118164, 0.0055007935, -0.020050049, 0.0024814606, 0.06744385, 0.07537842, 0.0045661926, -0.009338379, 0.010292053, 0.03781128, -0.044158936, 0.0001937151, 0.01524353, -0.016555786, 0.03741455, -0.01713562, 0.011856079, -0.023361206, -0.017852783, 0.043121338, 0.066833496, -0.04675293, -0.00024175644, 0.068237305, -0.007774353, -0.066345215, 0.03225708, -0.042999268, -0.039093018, -0.009796143, 0.050933838, -0.032470703, -0.010635376, 0.037872314, -0.008293152, -0.052246094, -0.030380249, 0.014251709, 0.031234741, -0.03414917, -0.018661499, 0.0035171509, 0.08135986, 0.0010528564, -0.0041656494, 0.013946533, 0.014945984, 0.0074501038, -0.03878784, 0.018875122, 0.024047852, -0.019638062, 0.0011043549, 0.029830933, -0.03201294, -0.04675293, -0.0040893555, 0.0038967133, 0.04925537, 0.015144348, 0.031585693, -0.019546509, -0.034484863, 0.058013916, 0.017868042, -0.006752014, -0.050598145, 0.011489868, 0.0007882118, -0.05505371, -0.02861023, 0.003145218, 0.01676941, -0.0063095093, -0.016937256, 0.015930176, 0.03894043, -0.01335907, -0.022994995, -0.0069999695, 0.00064086914, 0.0034484863, 0.05090332, 0.0074157715, -0.0056991577, 0.018096924, -0.019866943, 0.012130737, 0.011260986, 0.021820068, -0.04248047, -0.027999878, -0.08325195, 0.016418457, 0.025100708, 0.02279663, 0.05041504, -0.010810852, 0.020706177, 0.017623901, 0.020629883, 0.01159668, 0.00006234646, -0.009483337, 0.021347046, -0.018981934, 0.045135498, 0.047912598, 0.03842163, -0.02619934, -0.053741455, -0.0033893585, 0.04522705, -0.0132369995, -0.028686523, 0.041015625, -0.013900757, -0.01727295, -0.039916992, -0.010650635, 0.004299164, 0.009185791, -0.00053453445, 0.0035591125, 0.029541016, -0.041137695, 0.01928711, -0.006259918, 0.020446777, 0.018234253, -0.017654419, -0.0066871643, -0.03488159, 0.027359009, 0.026412964, 0.013748169, -0.041992188, -0.01424408, 0.09387207, -0.024978638, 0.030807495, -0.008605957, -0.028335571, 0.015312195, -0.060424805, -0.06896973, -0.040222168, -0.04324341, -0.01675415, -0.041137695, 0.0066986084, -0.046081543, 0.05239868, 0.039855957, -0.013038635, -0.027542114, -0.06225586, 0.017227173, -0.05038452, -0.052093506, -0.0067596436, -0.06414795, 0.049621582, 0.006000519, 0.018951416, -0.012367249, 0.030914307, -0.023162842, 0.02670288, -0.0113220215, 0.008544922, -0.059661865, -0.03375244, -0.0027275085, 0.07598877, 0.0073890686, 0.041412354, 0.009010315, -0.024093628, -0.019348145, -0.05630493, 0.029205322, -0.046783447, 0.011695862, 0.0076065063, 0.022018433, 0.006225586, 0.000041246414, -0.0008068085, -0.00289917, 0.028289795, -0.0003707409, 0.0047721863, -0.028961182, -0.02116394, -0.04449463, 0.030975342, -0.006542206, 0.0073776245, 0.021270752, 0.0073623657, -0.009941101, -0.004421234, 0.034057617, -0.005847931, -0.028060913, -0.030319214, -0.004753113, 0.0007958412, -0.039245605, 0.04837036, 0.0008049011, 0.0129852295, 0.004016876, -0.0050964355, -0.049591064, -0.029815674, -0.054992676, 0.035980225, -0.024597168, 0.01852417, 0.017166138, -0.046081543, 0.032409668, -0.032684326, -0.019470215, -0.014953613, 0.0042037964, 0.03555298, -0.00037503242, 0.0014076233, 0.040405273, -0.021652222, -0.026931763, -0.031555176, 0.0087890625, 0.013542175, -0.011962891, -0.046417236, -0.04562378, -0.01676941, 0.010055542, -0.030319214, 0.035491943, 0.0057678223, -0.0021381378, 0.09136963, 0.024307251, 0.0107803345, 0.0390625, 0.017715454, -0.036743164, 0.009147644, 0.030136108, 0.028900146, 0.03050232, -0.004295349, -0.049346924, -0.0072746277, -0.002773285, 0.013694763, 0.03515625, -0.021316528, 0.017105103, 0.03265381, 0.03692627, 0.058563232, 0.026123047, -0.03149414, 0.009101868, -0.032073975, 0.0132751465, 0.007259369, 0.05606079, -0.00009471178, -0.020828247, -0.0041618347, 0.024871826, -0.017227173, 0.008468628, 0.003047943, 0.06414795, 0.02571106, -0.0015859604, -0.012496948, 0.043273926, -0.005393982, 0.007610321, 0.02671814, 0.021469116, 0.012130737, 0.01776123, 0.00969696, 0.012901306, -0.0046577454, 0.03024292, -0.0062217712, -0.06188965, -0.02027893, 0.011192322, -0.015350342, -0.017242432, -0.01864624, -0.03010559, -0.00655365, 0.02142334, 0.016555786, -0.008491516, 0.02758789, 0.00088119507, -0.013069153, 0.030578613, -0.02407837, 0.06304932, 0.0033416748, -0.0010213852, -0.03527832, 0.042053223, 0.0151901245, -0.014183044, 0.023498535, -0.01335907, 0.048980713, -0.0048561096, 0.007820129, 0.055114746, -0.041931152, -0.029632568, -0.0859375, 0.026382446, -0.05331421, 0.000095665455, 0.002494812, 0.018951416, 0.025177002, 0.012023926, 0.049316406, -0.013969421, 0.0016679764, -0.03643799, 0.0027675629, -0.016983032, -0.0463562, 0.014884949, 0.017318726, 0.006664276, -0.019454956, 0.044769287, 0.053955078, 0.047607422, -0.03692627, -0.010528564, 0.017089844, 0.00944519, -0.025405884, -0.015068054, -0.02217102, -0.028305054, 0.038024902, 0.016601562, -0.024871826, 0.008964539, 0.002483368, 0.008911133, 0.019210815, -0.0018281937, -0.008972168, 0.019927979, 0.012001038, 0.03677368, -0.010658264, 0.06585693, -0.020111084, -0.034423828, 0.04714966, -0.014717102, -0.042816162, 0.0055503845, 0.014213562, 0.022277832, 0.03262329, 0.085998535, -0.00052165985, 0.02520752, 0.0069770813, 0.017959595, 0.016021729, 0.015533447, 0.020141602, -0.010902405, -0.006462097, 0.013450623, 0.004020691, 0.060424805, 0.034210205, -0.029159546, 0.0143585205, 0.014205933, -0.054656982, -0.002609253, 0.016906738, 0.057922363, -0.036590576, 0.041809082, 0.014282227, 0.06896973, -0.032073975, 0.027572632, 0.036895752, -0.007736206, 0.027313232, 0.016983032, 0.006629944, -0.021606445, 0.013595581, 0.00831604, 0.04171753, 0.0647583, 0.0473938, -0.006046295, 0.012641907, 0.027709961, 0.004638672, -0.06878662, -0.02709961, 0.015052795, 0.02003479, -0.06173706, 0.02885437, 0.021026611, -0.019470215, -0.05340576, -0.018035889, -0.017333984, -0.023117065, 0.0541687, 0.010375977, -0.011253357, 0.014266968, 0.03591919, -0.059661865, -0.010292053, -0.0541687, 0.02281189, -0.02684021, 0.041656494, -0.013511658, -0.027526855, 0.028686523, 0.04083252, -0.0014467239, -0.055725098, 0.0015897751, 0.0066490173, 0.020736694, -0.02822876, -0.047851562, 0.05026245, 0.04949951, -0.023895264, 0.018447876, 0.006626129, 0.056610107, 0.023925781, 0.07623291, 0.0017786026, -0.068847656, 0.023773193, 0.014526367, 0.045532227, 0.002910614, -0.03515625, 0.02734375, 0.007648468, -0.04849243, -0.02670288, 0.061187744, 0.007789612, -0.021835327, 0.012283325, -0.020843506, -0.05807495, -0.07519531, 0.0055160522, -0.007419586, -0.004890442, -0.009506226, -0.007583618, 0.0074310303, -0.028656006, -0.0015172958, -0.0011720657, -0.048614502, -0.037200928, 0.018249512, -0.010147095, 0.048095703, -0.03277588, -0.05218506, 0.013404846, -0.033966064, 0.0030574799, -0.043121338, 0.029464722, -0.07635498, -0.045898438, -0.023956299, -0.035827637, 0.023254395, -0.008598328, 0.013961792, -0.022918701, 0.022979736, 0.025909424, 0.011451721, 0.019317627, 0.043792725, 0.019866943, 0.037384033, 0.0076179504, -0.007873535, -0.00642395, -0.007083893 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2111.07265v2
Linear, or Non-Linear, That is the Question!
Taeyong Kong, Taeri Kim, Jinsung Jeon, Jeongwhan Choi, Yeon-Chang Lee, Noseong Park, Sang-Wook Kim
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.LG
There were fierce debates on whether the non-linear embedding propagation of GCNs is appropriate to GCN-based recommender systems. It was recently found that the linear embedding propagation shows better accuracy than the non-linear embedding propagation. Since this phenomenon was discovered especially in recommender systems, it is required that we carefully analyze the linearity and non-linearity issue. In this work, therefore, we revisit the issues of i) which of the linear or non-linear propagation is better and ii) which factors of users/items decide the linearity/non-linearity of the embedding propagation. We propose a novel Hybrid Method of Linear and non-linEar collaborative filTering method (HMLET, pronounced as Hamlet). In our design, there exist both linear and non-linear propagation steps, when processing each user or item node, and our gating module chooses one of them, which results in a hybrid model of the linear and non-linear GCN-based collaborative filtering (CF). The proposed model yields the best accuracy in three public benchmark datasets. Moreover, we classify users/items into the following three classes depending on our gating modules' selections: Full-Non-Linearity (FNL), Partial-Non-Linearity (PNL), and Full-Linearity (FL). We found that there exist strong correlations between nodes' centrality and their class membership, i.e., important user/item nodes exhibit more preferences towards the non-linearity during the propagation steps. To our knowledge, we are the first who design a hybrid method and report the correlation between the graph centrality and the linearity/non-linearity of nodes. All HMLET codes and datasets are available at: https://github.com/qbxlvnf11/HMLET.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2111.07265v2
"2021-12-24T02:48:23"
"2021-11-14T07:56:10"
{ "title": [ -0.014587402, -0.013664246, -0.025146484, -0.0017900467, -0.01838684, -0.010665894, 0.033111572, 0.002670288, -0.028305054, -0.016494751, -0.03274536, 0.018005371, -0.072387695, -0.04699707, 0.019317627, -0.05130005, -0.0028629303, -0.016540527, -0.017913818, -0.0154800415, -0.019927979, -0.03491211, 0.054473877, 0.016418457, 0.055419922, 0.05569458, -0.08843994, -0.0050697327, 0.0026187897, 0.009727478, 0.014572144, -0.022247314, 0.0028648376, 0.0049934387, 0.052886963, 0.013916016, -0.010307312, 0.030532837, 0.05532837, -0.030136108, 0.03643799, -0.009811401, -0.078430176, 0.018005371, -0.0914917, -0.026672363, 0.005306244, 0.018539429, 0.025527954, 0.034240723, -0.0057296753, 0.016815186, -0.003643036, 0.0028057098, 0.0007214546, -0.020080566, 0.00749588, -0.02192688, 0.028671265, -0.01966858, 0.0013523102, -0.032073975, 0.049926758, 0.010681152, -0.016082764, -0.039916992, -0.01638794, 0.044799805, 0.056793213, 0.010429382, -0.010215759, 0.030334473, 0.0013113022, -0.014923096, -0.02532959, 0.01777649, -0.011054993, 0.015579224, 0.029296875, -0.01991272, -0.039001465, 0.051971436, 0.0018262863, -0.014793396, -0.022109985, -0.011238098, -0.05923462, -0.005302429, 0.025253296, -0.0847168, 0.00095653534, 0.017196655, 0.0031528473, 0.017913818, -0.06652832, -0.023513794, -0.010910034, -0.050567627, -0.02859497, -0.02015686, 0.0068588257, -0.016586304, 0.009384155, 0.010169983, -0.008171082, 0.026977539, 0.015716553, -0.0050201416, 0.031021118, 0.036254883, -0.0005531311, 0.109802246, 0.026397705, -0.0033092499, 0.007881165, -0.055603027, -0.053527832, 0.06781006, 0.012519836, 0.009902954, -0.010803223, -0.0018205643, 0.047210693, -0.073913574, -0.0058059692, -0.030654907, -0.030303955, -0.010009766, -0.015541077, 0.024810791, 0.026504517, 0.064331055, -0.13452148, -0.0736084, -0.075683594, 0.020187378, 0.011169434, -0.036956787, -0.00028395653, 0.0015153885, 0.012779236, -0.027938843, 0.026367188, 0.015792847, -0.014793396, 0.00907135, 0.024276733, 0.0030593872, -0.00020837784, -0.037475586, 0.00737381, -0.022140503, 0.020263672, -0.0016040802, -0.007106781, 0.02255249, -0.06225586, 0.03829956, -0.004550934, 0.036376953, 0.016494751, 0.01259613, 0.013084412, -0.022613525, 0.015640259, -0.043518066, -0.0090789795, 0.026367188, 0.017044067, 0.045288086, -0.021987915, -0.0079422, 0.040771484, 0.021728516, -0.002609253, 0.033172607, 0.008682251, -0.06524658, 0.00075626373, 0.04824829, 0.00894928, -0.006061554, -0.09088135, 0.0927124, 0.0209198, -0.040130615, 0.016677856, -0.005771637, 0.011482239, 0.02255249, -0.02355957, -0.009208679, 0.0004246235, -0.012641907, -0.031921387, -0.06567383, 0.022949219, -0.04147339, -0.034210205, 0.08770752, -0.011123657, -0.009590149, 0.011795044, 0.019622803, 0.014183044, 0.000998497, -0.011436462, 0.006664276, 0.014564514, 0.03527832, -0.00819397, -0.033233643, -0.0044822693, 0.005264282, 0.0034656525, -0.0013656616, 0.009155273, -0.048919678, -0.0046577454, -0.014343262, 0.0018911362, 0.044769287, -0.03012085, 0.019500732, 0.021591187, 0.0036716461, 0.011131287, -0.009544373, 0.085632324, 0.011726379, 0.10076904, -0.007331848, -0.031082153, 0.041412354, -0.007358551, -0.009223938, 0.049926758, 0.030181885, 0.029586792, -0.028518677, -0.011451721, 0.004085541, -0.019119263, 0.019851685, -0.0041770935, 0.047332764, 0.04345703, 0.013061523, 0.0050697327, -0.008323669, 0.024353027, -0.0023040771, 0.047180176, 0.04940796, 0.033477783, 0.04751587, 0.02986145, 0.05166626, -0.011856079, 0.020736694, -0.024108887, 0.023498535, -0.008621216, 0.012382507, -0.059661865, -0.02357483, -0.018493652, 0.019439697, 0.04034424, -0.02154541, 0.0069885254, -0.0259552, 0.010246277, 0.026641846, 0.0063171387, 0.018325806, -0.04663086, 0.004207611, 0.020446777, 0.011817932, -0.0033912659, 0.028427124, 0.012832642, -0.016235352, 0.030456543, -0.007835388, -0.009124756, -0.017944336, -0.036590576, 0.020736694, 0.041900635, 0.011444092, -0.014205933, 0.015235901, -0.018173218, 0.014625549, 0.02760315, 0.056396484, 0.009597778, 0.010314941, -0.073791504, 0.011871338, 0.0073127747, -0.022735596, 0.019592285, 0.053375244, 0.023254395, -0.000036537647, 0.01222229, 0.03945923, -0.06341553, -0.00831604, -0.023040771, -0.034851074, -0.0015954971, -0.023223877, -0.020324707, 0.000644207, 0.0040130615, 0.011138916, 0.0053749084, -0.007835388, -0.040527344, 0.019622803, -0.0146484375, -0.0053367615, 0.014465332, -0.02067566, -0.011886597, -0.02809143, 0.035858154, -0.04550171, -0.04788208, 0.009086609, 0.039367676, 0.015098572, -0.0053749084, 0.03253174, -0.015792847, -0.007270813, -0.019927979, -0.046142578, 0.024337769, -0.022354126, 0.0011463165, 0.0076942444, -0.014381409, 0.017303467, -0.0340271, 0.01612854, -0.0030822754, -0.029464722, -0.0118255615, 0.009422302, 0.035491943, -0.037963867, -0.0066604614, 0.010971069, 0.02255249, -0.03982544, 0.016479492, -0.033172607, -0.013542175, 0.0077667236, 0.0052223206, -0.01965332, -0.015052795, 0.0154953, -0.022399902, 0.001496315, -0.024291992, -0.046325684, -0.0053901672, 0.016845703, -0.004875183, 0.033691406, -0.07159424, -0.089904785, 0.05142212, -0.03062439, -0.060394287, -0.0030574799, 0.003753662, 0.063964844, 0.0791626, -0.03640747, -0.032226562, -0.0004067421, 0.043884277, 0.051513672, -0.027938843, -0.077941895, -0.03942871, -0.043548584, 0.0006957054, 0.026535034, -0.05239868, -0.038879395, -0.012283325, 0.00434494, -0.016143799, 0.0012817383, -0.003364563, 0.00920105, -0.022109985, 0.049713135, -0.00059223175, -0.015136719, -0.0003976822, 0.030151367, -0.030136108, 0.0011262894, -0.019515991, -0.032836914, 0.029418945, -0.038513184, -0.013771057, -0.024353027, 0.008422852, 0.026031494, 0.005519867, -0.027404785, -0.015579224, 0.016784668, -0.046569824, -0.02192688, 0.030410767, 0.055725098, -0.06500244, -0.01802063, -0.0058937073, -0.06573486, -0.050964355, -0.071899414, -0.020401001, 0.0068626404, -0.0015745163, 0.03564453, -0.026733398, 0.041046143, -0.04562378, -0.008140564, 0.00050354004, 0.024765015, -0.042144775, 0.026489258, -0.011459351, -0.056427002, 0.022766113, 0.022338867, -0.026916504, 0.0034885406, 0.00598526, 0.024917603, -0.039642334, -0.0035209656, 0.02079773, 0.009674072, 0.04144287, 0.014328003, 0.013427734, 0.013145447, -0.076538086, 0.015258789, 0.0004646778, 0.005718231, 0.014717102, 0.011802673, -0.009796143, -0.005844116, -0.014892578, 0.018157959, 0.023880005, 0.011009216, 0.022598267, 0.04345703, -0.033935547, -0.016113281, -0.045837402, 0.010978699, 0.0025119781, 0.022369385, -0.047668457, -0.01247406, -0.037475586, 0.0012102127, -0.06689453, -0.01889038, -0.01928711, -0.06707764, -0.030731201, -0.016845703, 0.0071411133, -0.053833008, -0.010925293, -0.029754639, -0.0041542053, -0.025543213, -0.0048103333, -0.036590576, -0.028656006, 0.007534027, -0.012054443, 0.018310547, 0.07873535, 0.0035305023, -0.017669678, -0.030273438, -0.0010652542, 0.07116699, -0.012649536, -0.04208374, -0.008720398, -0.01663208, -0.0022850037, -0.0013837814, 0.0259552, -0.0099105835, -0.0070266724, 0.0072250366, -0.012489319, 0.009857178, 0.02319336, 0.044891357, -0.016952515, 0.015182495, -0.026000977, 0.05230713, 0.010620117, -0.009284973, 0.002368927, -0.020980835, -0.015808105, 0.0020580292, 0.021270752, 0.0060577393, 0.0126953125, 0.008804321, -0.008384705, -0.0256958, -0.0020599365, -0.022644043, 0.0046920776, -0.036254883, -0.008255005, -0.014282227, -0.0007915497, 0.0519104, 0.00083732605, 0.015777588, 0.014831543, 0.016113281, -0.02848816, 0.024124146, 0.03375244, -0.04031372, -0.03704834, -0.018341064, -0.031982422, 0.007751465, -0.016952515, -0.020736694, -0.020492554, 0.022781372, 0.06237793, -0.0005021095, 0.032562256, -0.0206604, -0.015853882, -0.017150879, -0.072387695, -0.048736572, -0.014907837, 0.016082764, -0.044891357, 0.018569946, -0.0104522705, 0.00894165, 0.012504578, 0.012863159, 0.0017347336, -0.015899658, -0.033172607, -0.03074646, 0.011177063, -0.066711426, 0.041381836, -0.0015230179, 0.007209778, -0.054718018, 0.030181885, -0.0703125, -0.034820557, 0.011543274, 0.06137085, 0.011444092, 0.07672119, -0.068359375, -0.033477783, 0.018218994, 0.012229919, 0.0077552795, -0.0018062592, -0.014961243, -0.020050049, 0.032165527, 0.043945312, -0.009239197, -0.01033783, -0.0056152344, 0.03970337, -0.059814453, -0.006175995, 0.061645508, -0.008026123, 0.0096206665, 0.06210327, -0.02722168, -0.05895996, -0.054107666, -0.0074005127, 0.0027675629, 0.016098022, 0.02330017, 0.0075950623, -0.01524353, 0.048339844, -0.0032844543, -0.014671326, 0.022598267, -0.014472961, 0.01499176, -0.020812988, -0.03741455, 0.038848877, 0.04611206, -0.029327393, -0.0017671585, 0.0048561096, 0.037017822, -0.031829834, 0.048614502, 0.030014038, -0.0020580292, 0.014419556, -0.03439331, -0.01171875, -0.023406982, -0.050811768, 0.038208008, -0.030136108, 0.01374054, -0.010681152, 0.025619507, -0.0028877258, 0.0090408325, -0.022613525, 0.025924683, 0.008781433, -0.008026123, -0.03503418, 0.02998352, -0.026275635, 0.008872986, 0.02079773, 0.01398468, 0.06185913, 0.018753052, 0.015960693, -0.007358551, -0.005680084, -0.00044107437, -0.05343628, 0.008262634, 0.04095459, 0.0065994263, 0.018432617, 0.021621704, -0.018112183, -0.05126953, 0.020385742, -0.01058197, -0.03338623, -0.0016641617, -0.02331543, 0.027236938, -0.04675293, 0.005218506, -0.003255844, -0.031402588, -0.008918762, 0.03488159, -0.03250122, 0.029632568, 0.051239014, 0.0009727478, 0.028274536, -0.06286621, 0.05029297, -0.06518555, 0.0010690689, 0.005748749, 0.0068092346, -0.015655518, -0.0006980896, -0.030303955, 0.016647339, -0.008476257, 0.02861023, 0.02331543, 0.026550293, 0.0002603531, -0.06982422, -0.029418945, -0.0105896, 0.024246216, 0.066223145, 0.027740479, 0.047302246, 0.0020046234, -0.008804321, -0.027297974, 0.0082092285, -0.0357666, 0.0031871796, 0.011650085, -0.0021209717, 0.029052734, 0.022445679, 0.03186035, 0.0095825195, 0.061950684, -0.0046310425, 0.0035743713, 0.014404297, -0.042236328, 0.044158936, -0.03744507, -0.014221191, -0.021484375, 0.033569336, -0.0040245056, 0.02456665, -0.0048332214, -0.07513428, 0.018493652, 0.006790161, -0.055847168, -0.03845215, -0.049682617, -0.009170532, 0.01927185, -0.024475098, 0.0016431808, -0.016464233, -0.0137786865, -0.004634857, 0.00003939867, -0.043792725, 0.008544922, -0.038482666, -0.021469116, -0.016952515, 0.03491211, -0.00088119507, 0.046813965, -0.013320923, -0.00945282, 0.024887085, 0.014228821, 0.040039062, 0.018051147, 0.01701355, -0.011314392, -0.03933716, 0.011070251, -0.035247803, 0.0011129379, 0.044525146, 0.049926758, -0.0236969, 0.018707275, -0.072631836, -0.029586792, 0.009613037, -0.006629944, -0.021636963, -0.0029144287, 0.014038086, -0.011764526, -0.06506348, 0.047210693, 0.05038452, 0.028808594, -0.0069885254, 0.020385742, 0.06665039, 0.037994385, 0.082458496, 0.020553589, 0.015068054, -0.031921387, 0.008728027, 0.018539429, -0.002275467, 0.0178833, -0.05065918, 0.04989624, 0.04562378, 0.03845215, 0.014442444, 0.0118255615, -0.003660202, 0.070617676, 0.02609253, 0.06921387, 0.04473877, -0.00097084045, -0.018676758, -0.019485474, 0.0077667236, 0.026687622, 0.032409668, -0.008987427, -0.0043144226, -0.049835205, -0.012619019, 0.034454346, 0.019104004, 0.04345703, 0.012817383, 0.007610321, -0.037231445, -0.00070762634, 0.010368347, -0.0062561035, 0.0023403168, 0.022079468, 0.020706177, 0.0041160583, 0.07183838, -0.022567749, 0.056549072, 0.0524292, -0.013092041, 0.00497818, 0.042907715, -0.03363037, 0.034576416, 0.031173706, 0.030227661, 0.02305603, -0.014190674, -0.044403076, 0.032318115, 0.08001709, 0.053100586, -0.007129669, -0.027389526, -0.01687622, -0.009048462, 0.028656006, 0.00039339066, -0.0060272217, 0.0063705444, -0.010940552, -0.012268066, -0.0017604828, -0.0044898987, -0.025970459, -0.0001732111, 0.025985718, 0.011924744, -0.008201599, -0.0259552, 0.03945923, 0.007083893, -0.007637024, 0.021072388, -0.0020809174, 0.00415802, 0.021652222, 0.055023193, 0.0121154785, 0.01651001, -0.040222168, -0.013587952, 0.02027893, 0.062286377, 0.00066137314, 0.030975342, -0.03527832, -0.0435791, 0.023269653, -0.027786255, 0.05218506, -0.023086548, 0.013801575, -0.02532959, 0.01386261, -0.015312195, -0.041992188, -0.0027637482, -0.0014028549, -0.004360199, -0.008468628, 0.024917603, -0.01134491, 0.0037765503, -0.038391113, 0.021652222, -0.00032138824, 0.008049011, 0.013999939, -0.025375366, -0.033416748, -0.008094788, -0.014587402, 0.037597656, 0.0058555603, -0.01020813, -0.005306244, 0.0009121895, 0.000015676022, 0.02468872, -0.0069084167, 0.02633667, -0.048431396, 0.0113220215, 0.018920898, 0.0073776245, -0.026947021, -0.047302246, 0.025314331, 0.005256653, -0.024612427, 0.029846191, -0.04321289, 0.012687683, -0.10119629, -0.0013790131, -0.04071045, -0.057617188, -0.016204834, -0.0127334595, 0.049987793, 0.0035762787, 0.037261963, -0.010093689, 0.020019531, -0.018615723, -0.013519287, -0.038604736, 0.0017776489, -0.03616333, -0.013977051, -0.055145264, -0.026123047, -0.0007739067, 0.093322754, 0.019683838, 0.02557373, -0.028366089, 0.016494751, 0.030838013, 0.041534424, 0.0070266724, -0.04486084, 0.072021484, 0.022857666, -0.01184845, 0.0048294067, -0.014457703, 0.0010280609, -0.012390137, -0.0015850067, -0.00093221664, -0.0032310486, -0.0035800934, -0.010772705, -0.008041382, 0.03302002, -0.017166138, -0.039215088, -0.06536865, -0.031280518, 0.034576416, 0.012374878, -0.000890255, 0.038726807, -0.018829346, 0.07891846, 0.036987305, 0.009185791, -0.051879883, 0.02557373, 0.009170532, -0.007484436, -0.038269043, -0.024383545, 0.01360321, -0.0013074875, -0.000854969, 0.022705078, 0.018051147, 0.042541504, -0.002243042, -0.030334473, 0.0043182373, -0.01889038, 0.0035743713, 0.04953003, -0.03048706, -0.0016231537, -0.007762909, -0.044769287, -0.011383057, 0.01600647, -0.0019369125, -0.054016113, 0.0085372925, -0.0063934326, 0.033843994, 0.0116119385 ], "summary": [ 0.018966675, -0.0021381378, 0.010856628, 0.013664246, -0.029403687, -0.01927185, -0.0025482178, -0.04837036, -0.0637207, 0.028839111, 0.00023639202, 0.026443481, 0.046081543, -0.03756714, 0.0440979, -0.016159058, -0.044647217, 0.02180481, -0.026306152, -0.05770874, 0.02558899, -0.09063721, 0.021728516, -0.012763977, 0.003616333, -0.022506714, 0.013244629, -0.0038585663, 0.030715942, 0.018356323, 0.01058197, -0.016571045, 0.018661499, 0.035461426, -0.0519104, -0.03213501, -0.02456665, 0.00037646294, -0.01083374, -0.01235199, 0.016403198, -0.00031232834, 0.03668213, -0.0099105835, -0.006576538, -0.004501343, 0.013442993, -0.021820068, 0.011909485, 0.009849548, 0.0040512085, 0.011360168, 0.0035305023, -0.005554199, -0.0032978058, -0.008094788, -0.04159546, -0.026351929, 0.015617371, 0.053253174, 0.038635254, -0.034942627, 0.010574341, -0.0056877136, -0.0011758804, 0.0065994263, 0.040893555, 0.022079468, 0.029129028, -0.020111084, -0.020263672, 0.00982666, 0.02015686, 0.0010061264, -0.057800293, 0.038146973, -0.0012254715, 0.04559326, 0.04562378, -0.040527344, -0.03894043, 0.03555298, -0.10089111, -0.055847168, 0.010375977, -0.020614624, -0.025482178, 0.0048942566, 0.00667572, -0.020843506, -0.007610321, -0.027755737, -0.013015747, 0.037109375, -0.0073776245, -0.027648926, 0.036956787, 0.03375244, 0.029830933, 0.008354187, -0.00969696, -0.026123047, -0.014266968, -0.03414917, -0.0012159348, 0.031341553, -0.015975952, -0.020050049, 0.01725769, 0.02558899, -0.012718201, 0.031707764, 0.032348633, 0.015327454, -0.0015039444, -0.046691895, -0.029663086, 0.091430664, 0.0006275177, 0.05630493, -0.0059776306, 0.01058197, -0.022140503, 0.013313293, 0.019485474, 0.0023918152, -0.0028133392, 0.021850586, -0.030181885, 0.00075387955, -0.0041007996, 0.04837036, -0.032073975, -0.0071525574, -0.05532837, 0.0027160645, -0.04034424, -0.007129669, -0.0035133362, 0.023162842, 0.030273438, -0.03363037, 0.029525757, 0.06286621, 0.015068054, 0.021484375, 0.018127441, 0.01373291, 0.00919342, -0.033721924, 0.042114258, -0.019317627, 0.060791016, -0.05596924, -0.02809143, -0.10040283, -0.059539795, -0.027435303, 0.025848389, -0.040893555, -0.0054740906, -0.021987915, 0.01890564, 0.053131104, 0.015670776, 0.026687622, -0.009689331, 0.0073051453, 0.010055542, 0.045532227, -0.014335632, -0.0021076202, 0.010292053, -0.02218628, -0.01914978, -0.009475708, 0.044952393, 0.033325195, -0.005756378, 0.042144775, 0.010696411, -0.028656006, 0.06976318, -0.0413208, -0.05041504, 0.025680542, 0.018356323, 0.07678223, 0.020584106, 0.006942749, 0.033691406, -0.004623413, 0.02418518, -0.0074424744, -0.004306793, -0.035827637, -0.034088135, -0.013801575, -0.0141067505, 0.008338928, -0.014045715, -0.035949707, 0.024139404, -0.03010559, -0.03805542, -0.008102417, -0.009681702, 0.037353516, -0.05001831, 0.007835388, 0.025177002, -0.00730896, -0.025344849, -0.009429932, -0.0027484894, 0.011146545, 0.008178711, -0.004928589, 0.016708374, -0.012268066, -0.0079422, 0.027694702, -0.017120361, -0.007858276, 0.017730713, 0.049987793, -0.027709961, 0.03857422, 0.05911255, 0.03363037, 0.04623413, -0.011932373, -0.0013198853, 0.03756714, -0.026550293, -0.030029297, 0.027496338, -0.004047394, 0.0579834, 0.013580322, 0.01612854, 0.026062012, -0.008491516, 0.010612488, 0.010848999, -0.037506104, 0.018447876, 0.015174866, -0.013748169, 0.0029411316, 0.010826111, 0.0068473816, 0.03933716, 0.023910522, 0.024139404, 0.020065308, 0.0026245117, 0.03225708, -0.01663208, 0.0124435425, -0.01222229, 0.040924072, 0.03201294, 0.010093689, -0.028533936, -0.06951904, -0.0051956177, -0.011436462, 0.035858154, -0.06866455, -0.003944397, -0.0121154785, -0.00166893, -0.015136719, -0.017059326, -0.05203247, -0.055908203, 0.02645874, 0.031463623, -0.034973145, -0.012107849, 0.0037326813, -0.0066604614, -0.019378662, 0.040649414, 0.009498596, 0.0102005005, -0.029052734, -0.0054893494, 0.054840088, 0.028182983, 0.08428955, 0.036010742, 0.0070152283, 0.025238037, 0.044708252, -0.022750854, 0.010139465, 0.01146698, -0.037506104, -0.03475952, 0.0385437, -0.04046631, 0.009689331, -0.012504578, 0.07183838, 0.021484375, -0.036010742, -0.031188965, -0.02720642, 0.008102417, -0.018417358, 0.0033740997, 0.014389038, -0.05303955, -0.051483154, -0.04019165, -0.0126953125, -0.03817749, 0.018692017, 0.06689453, 0.008300781, 0.027542114, 0.015457153, 0.008148193, -0.04928589, 0.025161743, -0.0071907043, -0.060333252, 0.014564514, -0.051849365, -0.052246094, -0.037200928, 0.048187256, -0.01348114, 0.024353027, -0.011314392, -0.054534912, -0.011756897, 0.04248047, 0.014976501, 0.030212402, 0.03555298, -0.07244873, -0.05908203, 0.007598877, -0.016418457, -0.0003838539, -0.03942871, -0.010147095, 0.027496338, 0.0061302185, -0.009605408, 0.030273438, 0.030197144, 0.024719238, 0.0051231384, 0.04272461, 0.042419434, -0.01737976, 0.02961731, 0.020080566, 0.0035381317, -0.053771973, -0.040100098, -0.02015686, -0.01852417, 0.0021686554, 0.0012598038, 0.00497818, 0.014419556, 0.01725769, -0.055908203, -0.017074585, -0.027816772, 0.0077819824, 0.06640625, -0.009597778, 0.03543091, 0.046783447, -0.008514404, 0.023590088, -0.00061941147, 0.010467529, 0.10974121, -0.017532349, -0.011817932, 0.0016222, 0.091552734, 0.032806396, 0.028503418, -0.061584473, -0.020401001, -0.029022217, -0.010627747, 0.02532959, -0.027893066, -0.05645752, 0.029800415, -0.021453857, 0.00774765, 0.020202637, -0.0021514893, 0.026641846, -0.041625977, 0.058410645, 0.008422852, 0.0053520203, 0.010826111, 0.024932861, 0.035095215, -0.004337311, 0.017471313, 0.012191772, 0.003440857, -0.041015625, 0.046875, 0.010818481, -0.011405945, -0.045288086, 0.010177612, 0.030044556, -0.015716553, -0.014091492, 0.0035209656, 0.017868042, -0.017868042, -0.021347046, -0.045166016, 0.05432129, 0.021224976, -0.013542175, -0.0008625984, -0.055389404, -0.05343628, -0.05871582, -0.0138549805, 0.03741455, 0.02394104, -0.025848389, -0.110839844, -0.034118652, 0.024429321, 0.026565552, 0.008712769, 0.0060539246, -0.040649414, -0.09564209, 0.017425537, 0.0491333, -0.025253296, 0.0087890625, 0.013839722, 0.00333786, -0.043670654, -0.009178162, -0.005607605, -0.0020637512, 0.020004272, -0.028076172, -0.025650024, 0.029464722, -0.054473877, -0.031921387, 0.04714966, 0.0074386597, -0.014709473, 0.01689148, -0.024642944, 0.01977539, 0.05041504, -0.06854248, -0.0012292862, -0.0019950867, -0.016571045, 0.0043640137, 0.021697998, 0.011695862, -0.022506714, -0.03805542, -0.04537964, 0.03237915, -0.061767578, -0.049865723, -0.049438477, 0.015731812, -0.05709839, -0.021026611, -0.022445679, -0.020904541, -0.04550171, -0.017105103, -0.025283813, 0.018997192, -0.02861023, 0.011962891, -0.009483337, 0.048950195, 0.01953125, -0.05215454, 0.019256592, -0.000330925, -0.030044556, 0.016418457, -0.008178711, 0.05569458, 0.015350342, -0.00041913986, 0.0014276505, -0.040252686, 0.00003105402, -0.033691406, 0.037719727, -0.0110321045, 0.020599365, 0.025299072, 0.05291748, 0.0015573502, 0.028869629, -0.015090942, 0.058532715, 0.07696533, -0.055725098, 0.0079956055, 0.044189453, -0.010925293, -0.064086914, -0.002243042, 0.023498535, 0.049224854, 0.02558899, -0.006816864, 0.04083252, 0.00919342, -0.01209259, -0.043548584, -0.017715454, -0.030136108, -0.0055503845, 0.0011234283, -0.00073862076, 0.01461792, -0.014053345, 0.0052108765, -0.01928711, -0.0052375793, -0.02696228, 0.006313324, -0.026107788, -0.031707764, 0.014755249, 0.024368286, -0.006340027, -0.009719849, 0.004310608, -0.017974854, -0.021057129, -0.009605408, -0.0062828064, 0.033050537, -0.008735657, 0.046417236, -0.055236816, 0.00066947937, -0.006664276, 0.0095825195, -0.020446777, -0.03164673, 0.019378662, -0.05050659, -0.038482666, -0.03262329, -0.02798462, -0.050201416, 0.018493652, 0.010498047, -0.016418457, -0.0044517517, 0.0051727295, -0.0014829636, -0.0103302, 0.009307861, -0.013252258, -0.05053711, 0.013702393, -0.004058838, 0.0029716492, 0.028503418, 0.02293396, -0.0003232956, -0.0053138733, -0.035980225, -0.022109985, -0.05493164, 0.0006890297, -0.014793396, 0.0647583, 0.047790527, 0.038879395, 0.026641846, 0.0056037903, 0.018569946, 0.0074501038, 0.0016307831, -0.044006348, 0.02670288, -0.014450073, 0.040100098, 0.022262573, 0.03286743, 0.006313324, -0.025238037, 0.00016617775, 0.025146484, 0.022064209, -0.020401001, -0.0036315918, 0.0013208389, 0.020370483, -0.03918457, 0.028869629, -0.0023765564, 0.025283813, 0.064453125, -0.031951904, -0.025878906, 0.04937744, 0.025436401, 0.002248764, -0.0012655258, 0.037750244, -0.011131287, -0.042297363, -0.037231445, -0.0059928894, 0.059417725, -0.007888794, -0.020385742, -0.017791748, -0.00869751, -0.00022268295, 0.049591064, 0.009719849, 0.00983429, 0.0038204193, 0.002494812, 0.0058670044, -0.058013916, -0.005504608, 0.019622803, -0.0030117035, -0.0043640137, 0.030319214, -0.070739746, -0.006828308, -0.012664795, -0.0021381378, 0.011184692, -0.010910034, -0.03527832, -0.061279297, -0.046020508, 0.011642456, -0.034210205, 0.03479004, -0.006893158, -0.009880066, -0.0030002594, -0.020050049, 0.016555786, -0.027008057, -0.04144287, 0.0440979, 0.006210327, -0.011024475, 0.009765625, 0.059570312, -0.008880615, 0.006160736, -0.023025513, 0.024261475, -0.021316528, -0.009674072, -0.034088135, 0.005630493, 0.017837524, -0.008102417, 0.030563354, 0.011192322, 0.0027618408, -0.033172607, -0.0473938, 0.016906738, -0.053100586, 0.014770508, 0.015586853, 0.019165039, -0.02558899, 0.017150879, -0.08880615, -0.013946533, 0.028030396, 0.019485474, 0.023635864, -0.02444458, -0.0042762756, -0.049926758, 0.013847351, -0.0072784424, 0.031341553, -0.024719238, -0.005722046, -0.026657104, 0.0014753342, -0.087524414, -0.020645142, 0.0003156662, 0.03137207, 0.0368042, 0.06762695, 0.012931824, 0.010299683, -0.0034332275, -0.034179688, 0.017700195, -0.024017334, -0.019989014, 0.029037476, -0.0074424744, -0.013397217, -0.027618408, 0.03010559, -0.008125305, -0.015670776, 0.0031337738, -0.014518738, 0.035308838, 0.013641357, 0.020477295, 0.023529053, -0.049926758, 0.0053901672, 0.033081055, 0.013877869, 0.0005259514, 0.07281494, 0.028625488, -0.027267456, 0.0015039444, 0.026153564, -0.021606445, -0.020263672, -0.0473938, -0.02281189, 0.024215698, -0.02368164, -0.00920105, 0.0061073303, -0.030166626, -0.0014886856, -0.05532837, 0.002746582, -0.0047340393, 0.035858154, 0.029052734, 0.04840088, -0.07531738, -0.032592773, -0.02760315, 0.00060510635, -0.013687134, 0.04864502, -0.0026893616, 0.02583313, -0.031402588, -0.032714844, -0.03579712, 0.018569946, 0.037994385, 0.022247314, -0.0050315857, 0.060028076, -0.007949829, -0.01486969, -0.022644043, 0.045196533, 0.0033512115, 0.021347046, 0.021469116, 0.0031375885, -0.04849243, 0.006099701, 0.019927979, 0.027664185, 0.0025596619, -0.006916046, 0.02494812, 0.019592285, 0.0149383545, -0.0070648193, 0.022079468, -0.038879395, -0.016708374, -0.016464233, -0.014724731, 0.0020809174, -0.0005068779, 0.021652222, -0.002292633, 0.03390503, 0.009567261, 0.007545471, 0.02709961, -0.036743164, 0.043060303, 0.011306763, 0.0211792, 0.02355957, -0.026565552, 0.0071411133, -0.0014572144, 0.016357422, -0.030853271, 0.07208252, 0.00033211708, -0.010391235, -0.018096924, 0.027038574, -0.008049011, 0.014457703, 0.03756714, -0.0043754578, 0.0035533905, 0.009597778, 0.026794434, 0.01448822, -0.031585693, 0.047668457, -0.017166138, -0.0069885254, 0.03878784, -0.040863037, 0.047088623, 0.03274536, 0.0126571655, -0.00699234, -0.025482178, -0.03540039, 0.04949951, -0.010185242, 0.054534912, -0.101989746, -0.0647583, 0.039733887, 0.016952515, -0.019119263, 0.038513184, -0.014877319, -0.011985779, 0.00010710955, 0.014266968, 0.0135269165, -0.008583069, -0.031402588, 0.07696533, 0.030975342, 0.04525757, 0.0041923523, -0.002412796, -0.0051727295, 0.01828003, -0.014785767, -0.029464722, 0.0440979, -0.0076560974, 0.011665344, 0.026443481, 0.01676941, 0.04562378, -0.06604004, 0.06347656, 0.09082031, 0.035888672, -0.06347656, 0.014434814, 0.10723877, -0.026565552, 0.062408447, -0.026397705, -0.025894165, -0.0071907043, -0.012916565, 0.004562378, -0.0025291443, -0.06756592, -0.02519226, -0.018798828, 0.046569824, -0.02217102, -0.013244629, -0.0597229, 0.013259888, 0.08276367, -0.022644043, -0.034301758, 0.012451172, -0.018493652, -0.008430481, 0.022094727, -0.014099121, 0.011886597, 0.043182373, -0.0073127747, 0.021820068, -0.0068130493, 0.043701172, -0.01651001, -0.013183594, 0.041778564, -0.04196167, -0.031555176, 0.03439331, -0.0031394958, 0.022598267, -0.037628174, -0.040863037, -0.001964569, 0.027328491, -0.028259277, -0.02355957, -0.034851074, -0.043182373, -0.028167725, 0.06994629, 0.012329102, -0.020080566, -0.0008330345, -0.017105103, 0.024108887, -0.04888916, -0.011924744, 0.0011844635, -0.074279785, -0.032073975, -0.02357483, 0.074157715, -0.0141067505, 0.0013256073, -0.029037476, -0.027069092, -0.049682617, -0.008850098, -0.019256592, -0.016677856, 0.017593384, 0.021148682, -0.046051025, -0.0058784485, 0.028869629, 0.050750732, 0.021118164, 0.000872612, -0.024108887, -0.0769043, -0.006591797, -0.029373169, -0.004207611, 0.047027588, 0.008636475, -0.0044136047, -0.022109985, -0.02053833, -0.0009946823, -0.040649414, -0.02142334, -0.000705719, -0.020401001, 0.011680603, -0.022506714, -0.020065308, -0.0015125275, -0.01739502, 0.0014419556, -0.032226562, -0.00087213516, -0.020812988, -0.0015115738, -0.017456055, -0.02407837, 0.003627777, -0.041656494, -0.010658264, 0.01146698, 0.01234436, 0.008232117, -0.013748169, 0.044891357, -0.019866943, 0.0071411133, 0.00969696, 0.043273926, -0.01713562, -0.0070266724, -0.039794922, 0.0055007935, -0.04196167, -0.05670166, -0.0002322197, -0.026382446, -0.059326172, -0.024856567, 0.017349243, -0.034210205, 0.01777649, 0.030929565, -0.033111572, 0.0007324219, 0.011543274, 0.00466156, -0.04736328, 0.018722534, -0.013282776, 0.017318726, 0.016189575 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2111.11157v1
NTD: Non-Transferability Enabled Backdoor Detection
Yinshan Li, Hua Ma, Zhi Zhang, Yansong Gao, Alsharif Abuadbba, Anmin Fu, Yifeng Zheng, Said F. Al-Sarawi, Derek Abbott
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.LG
A backdoor deep learning (DL) model behaves normally upon clean inputs but misbehaves upon trigger inputs as the backdoor attacker desires, posing severe consequences to DL model deployments. State-of-the-art defenses are either limited to specific backdoor attacks (source-agnostic attacks) or non-user-friendly in that machine learning (ML) expertise or expensive computing resources are required. This work observes that all existing backdoor attacks have an inevitable intrinsic weakness, non-transferability, that is, a trigger input hijacks a backdoored model but cannot be effective to another model that has not been implanted with the same backdoor. With this key observation, we propose non-transferability enabled backdoor detection (NTD) to identify trigger inputs for a model-under-test (MUT) during run-time.Specifically, NTD allows a potentially backdoored MUT to predict a class for an input. In the meantime, NTD leverages a feature extractor (FE) to extract feature vectors for the input and a group of samples randomly picked from its predicted class, and then compares similarity between the input and the samples in the FE's latent space. If the similarity is low, the input is an adversarial trigger input; otherwise, benign. The FE is a free pre-trained model privately reserved from open platforms. As the FE and MUT are from different sources, the attacker is very unlikely to insert the same backdoor into both of them. Because of non-transferability, a trigger effect that does work on the MUT cannot be transferred to the FE, making NTD effective against different types of backdoor attacks. We evaluate NTD on three popular customized tasks such as face recognition, traffic sign recognition and general animal classification, results of which affirm that NDT has high effectiveness (low false acceptance rate) and usability (low false rejection rate) with low detection latency.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2111.11157v1
"2021-11-22T12:48:19"
"2021-11-22T12:48:19"
{ "title": [ -0.012886047, 0.016403198, -0.022476196, -0.025909424, -0.02154541, -0.0074386597, -0.011856079, -0.03164673, -0.049713135, 0.022109985, 0.01826477, 0.013084412, 0.002286911, -0.05078125, 0.015419006, 0.001004219, -0.004432678, 0.022979736, 0.0022830963, -0.017807007, -0.020324707, -0.02130127, 0.030273438, -0.02355957, 0.010169983, -0.016967773, -0.02029419, -0.03286743, 0.028625488, -0.022506714, 0.014015198, 0.0062332153, 0.012062073, 0.056365967, -0.034423828, 0.024230957, -0.06298828, 0.0703125, 0.016601562, -0.01687622, -0.0025959015, 0.007144928, 0.013961792, -0.022247314, -0.01612854, 0.024749756, -0.058410645, -0.030883789, 0.007217407, 0.05834961, -0.010139465, 0.0032844543, -0.025314331, 0.08618164, -0.0031337738, -0.06561279, -0.032714844, 0.035308838, 0.02772522, 0.039215088, 0.008483887, -0.0152282715, 0.00819397, -0.036010742, 0.025634766, -0.04147339, 0.012107849, 0.06561279, 0.01663208, 0.043792725, 0.019470215, -0.013679504, -0.0025730133, -0.0038871765, -0.04147339, 0.005935669, 0.009864807, 0.01638794, 0.030181885, -0.018417358, -0.0602417, -0.056671143, -0.04208374, -0.012664795, 0.0143585205, 0.02130127, -0.020935059, 0.011184692, -0.025680542, 0.0024490356, -0.01979065, 0.03463745, 0.02508545, 0.015975952, -0.05545044, 0.023010254, -0.013198853, 0.014450073, -0.0015029907, -0.0039711, -0.06982422, 0.027053833, -0.047912598, -0.01902771, 0.040863037, 0.016967773, -0.0058174133, -0.026062012, 0.010932922, 0.016021729, -0.052124023, 0.021743774, 0.010726929, 0.015396118, -0.018157959, -0.0067710876, 0.004863739, -0.025390625, -0.013404846, -0.009277344, 0.013122559, -0.0088272095, 0.027709961, 0.0004837513, 0.033050537, 0.023040771, -0.03756714, -0.016906738, -0.013038635, 0.012771606, -0.01171875, 0.07232666, -0.034820557, -0.08178711, -0.072021484, 0.018997192, -0.006023407, 0.00094652176, 0.0027008057, -0.027069092, 0.049743652, -0.024307251, -0.008262634, 0.05810547, -0.019699097, -0.02041626, 0.054382324, 0.032836914, -0.022033691, -0.05682373, -0.005428314, 0.03665161, 0.007671356, 0.018112183, -0.036346436, 0.031066895, -0.087402344, 0.010536194, 0.025909424, 0.02015686, 0.045318604, 0.01687622, -0.025787354, 0.018981934, 0.037200928, -0.014038086, 0.022384644, 0.03604126, 0.008178711, 0.042297363, -0.020492554, -0.03262329, -0.02267456, -0.040130615, -0.016021729, 0.010398865, 0.010734558, 0.058807373, 0.009025574, -0.024093628, 0.017074585, -0.03527832, 0.023834229, 0.035186768, -0.047027588, -0.00017178059, 0.011856079, 0.03704834, 0.013336182, 0.015625, -0.0042152405, 0.013153076, -0.031234741, -0.0023765564, -0.06085205, -0.028457642, 0.008636475, 0.024154663, -0.018859863, 0.028121948, -0.023757935, 0.023391724, -0.03250122, 0.05316162, 0.023132324, -0.015159607, 0.005153656, 0.008377075, 0.007598877, 0.055236816, 0.037261963, 0.020523071, -0.034118652, -0.01876831, -0.012077332, -0.027786255, -0.036712646, -0.029937744, -0.006877899, 0.0005893707, -0.013465881, 0.0134887695, -0.009712219, 0.000025808811, 0.055419922, 0.028396606, 0.008102417, -0.0076942444, 0.1348877, 0.04260254, 0.09509277, -0.064819336, -0.016464233, -0.008216858, -0.029388428, -0.023284912, -0.03543091, -0.060333252, 0.023345947, 0.06573486, 0.015686035, -0.049804688, -0.011077881, -0.0049819946, 0.06530762, -0.0073509216, 0.008781433, 0.0105896, 0.015464783, -0.0025691986, -0.0019512177, 0.004234314, 0.06402588, 0.024749756, 0.014770508, 0.06262207, -0.008903503, 0.06506348, -0.02748108, -0.005115509, 0.0051078796, 0.068847656, 0.010848999, 0.024108887, 0.0036468506, -0.03540039, -0.017608643, -0.012001038, -0.022583008, 0.013114929, 0.039276123, -0.049072266, 0.011932373, 0.014297485, 0.047790527, -0.028137207, -0.0075035095, -0.020584106, 0.047546387, -0.025802612, -0.028808594, 0.011817932, 0.05718994, -0.015197754, 0.01789856, 0.021987915, 0.026947021, -0.047088623, -0.0418396, -0.00046682358, 0.054656982, 0.037994385, -0.015640259, 0.010940552, -0.008003235, 0.00868988, 0.03744507, 0.05859375, -0.03665161, 0.02229309, -0.07501221, 0.0036792755, 0.03845215, -0.014015198, 0.014221191, 0.01612854, 0.059906006, -0.034423828, -0.03793335, 0.033294678, -0.11791992, -0.044647217, -0.0063552856, -0.043670654, -0.041290283, -0.050750732, -0.041992188, -0.051940918, -0.06665039, 0.0031032562, 0.025543213, -0.0014915466, -0.012649536, -0.015197754, 0.0060195923, -0.011474609, -0.021911621, -0.008636475, -0.055389404, 0.006679535, 0.029266357, 0.003704071, -0.026977539, 0.011978149, 0.020477295, 0.01977539, 0.009742737, -0.029418945, -0.018432617, -0.024383545, -0.011123657, 0.034118652, -0.021697998, -0.05886841, 0.0019874573, -0.031402588, -0.0062408447, 0.008911133, -0.099487305, -0.02168274, 0.066711426, -0.042755127, -0.009338379, -0.050048828, 0.06591797, -0.03930664, -0.04650879, 0.016723633, 0.055633545, -0.013427734, 0.07122803, 0.010643005, 0.056549072, -0.033599854, -0.0574646, -0.06945801, -0.023101807, 0.0035915375, 0.017425537, 0.033355713, -0.045074463, 0.009506226, -0.04196167, 0.009780884, -0.0030937195, 0.014251709, -0.026489258, -0.054107666, -0.026794434, -0.027359009, 0.0048065186, -0.017333984, 0.028640747, -0.014587402, 0.036010742, 0.013793945, -0.0073509216, 0.028884888, -0.018997192, -0.028213501, -0.030395508, 0.0033340454, -0.045135498, -0.00340271, 0.028579712, 0.0088272095, 0.03125, -0.0033111572, -0.06878662, -0.020324707, 0.054870605, -0.025787354, -0.043670654, 0.009162903, -0.029006958, -0.068847656, 0.030456543, -0.02281189, 0.028366089, 0.06652832, -0.006210327, 0.010620117, 0.073913574, -0.058746338, 0.043029785, -0.03161621, -0.036071777, 0.012557983, -0.025436401, -0.031707764, 0.0051612854, 0.007484436, -0.03793335, -0.01876831, -0.038391113, 0.0054855347, 0.03186035, 0.019104004, 0.022201538, 0.03503418, 0.009552002, 0.0010681152, 0.011436462, -0.008338928, -0.017837524, -0.008460999, -0.02432251, 0.034576416, 0.031082153, -0.0074272156, 0.0014247894, -0.0028152466, 0.011909485, 0.045532227, 0.013542175, -0.016342163, -0.019577026, -0.0006737709, 0.009902954, -0.020385742, -0.011245728, 0.006214142, -0.0096206665, 0.0020122528, -0.018371582, 0.047668457, 0.023742676, 0.020141602, -0.021484375, -0.003276825, -0.003332138, -0.008071899, -0.015838623, -0.02015686, -0.026870728, 0.010986328, 0.020721436, -0.0016746521, -0.036834717, 0.015777588, -0.044769287, 0.029144287, -0.021835327, -0.018997192, 0.025314331, -0.039001465, -0.028549194, 0.029190063, -0.019180298, -0.01374054, 0.023254395, 0.016647339, -0.02355957, -0.047180176, -0.0055389404, 0.020080566, -0.08148193, -0.03665161, 0.016815186, -0.03250122, -0.057403564, -0.04034424, 0.034851074, -0.06317139, -0.015731812, 0.01586914, 0.0109939575, -0.0040016174, -0.019058228, -0.095825195, -0.018753052, 0.032226562, -0.033172607, 0.035736084, 0.009750366, -0.004802704, -0.052246094, -0.00598526, 0.0061950684, -0.016448975, 0.0018491745, -0.027114868, 0.018569946, 0.0335083, -0.017440796, 0.022033691, 0.03451538, -0.0043678284, 0.013671875, 0.011550903, 0.01675415, 0.022979736, -0.042175293, 0.04434204, 0.051330566, -0.016174316, -0.08294678, 0.024276733, -0.011169434, -0.070373535, 0.018325806, 0.0077400208, 0.021148682, 0.056884766, -0.0060806274, 0.04058838, -0.016525269, 0.022781372, 0.024368286, -0.02078247, -0.04751587, -0.053497314, 0.011962891, 0.0084991455, -0.022521973, -0.0051727295, -0.05065918, -0.00079870224, 0.01210022, -0.0026340485, -0.012779236, -0.015213013, -0.07635498, -0.013267517, -0.007751465, 0.016937256, -0.0135269165, 0.0055351257, -0.05899048, -0.015594482, 0.03564453, 0.005710602, -0.014625549, -0.015037537, 0.034973145, -0.013908386, 0.023132324, -0.047729492, 0.0059776306, -0.018218994, -0.060424805, -0.051116943, 0.028518677, 0.057403564, 0.0072746277, -0.015007019, -0.021591187, 0.012634277, 0.025817871, 0.028259277, 0.011856079, -0.011985779, -0.025543213, 0.024246216, -0.008613586, -0.016967773, 0.003227234, 0.010025024, -0.0121536255, -0.02909851, -0.0038032532, -0.009216309, -0.011924744, -0.024658203, 0.028442383, -0.0011014938, 0.070129395, -0.021972656, 0.00592041, 0.015312195, 0.008705139, 0.0061683655, 0.0010614395, -0.04611206, 0.0054016113, 0.013702393, 0.03353882, -0.032226562, 0.0129470825, 0.022460938, 0.033081055, -0.0060310364, -0.003238678, 0.03375244, 0.0017290115, -0.014556885, 0.0027656555, 0.03527832, -0.0004439354, -0.019546509, 0.02218628, 0.016906738, 0.034210205, -0.025283813, -0.015060425, -0.015541077, 0.027282715, 0.020080566, -0.021560669, 0.03491211, 0.01826477, 0.02809143, -0.048797607, -0.028121948, 0.013221741, 0.028625488, -0.01914978, -0.004573822, -0.014877319, -0.0032749176, -0.014183044, 0.040649414, 0.041229248, 0.020523071, 0.03427124, -0.013626099, 0.02720642, 0.0087890625, -0.04748535, -0.009605408, -0.009124756, 0.01109314, 0.06689453, -0.006931305, -0.105163574, 0.015914917, -0.008148193, 0.03970337, 0.015579224, -0.050048828, -0.010368347, 0.06188965, 0.056488037, -0.029418945, 0.032592773, 0.017333984, 0.064331055, 0.015434265, 0.020736694, 0.013786316, -0.016098022, -0.006134033, -0.004043579, 0.0035209656, 0.026275635, -0.02532959, 0.03491211, 0.0050468445, -0.008964539, -0.06317139, 0.023025513, 0.047698975, 0.0048980713, 0.053497314, -0.07305908, 0.03845215, 0.0040397644, -0.028289795, 0.0178833, -0.03503418, -0.04425049, 0.02482605, -0.020950317, 0.0006957054, 0.004753113, 0.010375977, -0.036987305, -0.012054443, 0.042053223, 0.0019683838, 0.010223389, 0.010017395, 0.009338379, -0.012916565, 0.018707275, 0.021759033, -0.013679504, -0.011428833, 0.022460938, 0.027618408, 0.031982422, -0.009262085, -0.032409668, -0.005344391, -0.018463135, -0.045196533, -0.049560547, -0.025024414, -0.024734497, 0.022338867, -0.038726807, -0.019485474, 0.013679504, -0.031341553, 0.0059890747, 0.020889282, -0.028549194, -0.007972717, -0.007106781, -0.0023822784, 0.028839111, 0.058532715, -0.015449524, 0.007259369, 0.027679443, -0.030273438, 0.0050201416, -0.01838684, -0.044281006, -0.043121338, -0.053100586, 0.008865356, 0.016098022, 0.0025997162, -0.021347046, 0.050720215, 0.021728516, 0.022628784, 0.03479004, 0.012252808, 0.06866455, -0.004131317, -0.022598267, 0.0011987686, 0.02998352, -0.0005078316, 0.02822876, -0.02909851, -0.020019531, -0.018478394, -0.081726074, -0.033843994, -0.009918213, 0.033111572, 0.002506256, -0.013092041, -0.0073776245, 0.05026245, 0.0051841736, 0.008338928, -0.03237915, 0.045196533, -0.022994995, -0.0077667236, -0.022735596, 0.009719849, 0.013084412, -0.042419434, 0.03555298, 0.014030457, -0.0062408447, 0.009918213, -0.011856079, -0.002357483, -0.034240723, 0.004184723, 0.006126404, 0.039978027, -0.024353027, 0.024230957, -0.034423828, 0.053100586, 0.033294678, 0.049804688, 0.07397461, 0.013687134, -0.036956787, 0.018829346, -0.032836914, -0.04006958, 0.0037117004, -0.04336548, 0.017333984, -0.0045776367, -0.002922058, -0.08331299, -0.0027389526, 0.050079346, 0.029067993, -0.026977539, 0.018554688, 0.024230957, -0.035186768, -0.0030097961, -0.048431396, 0.052764893, -0.0024223328, -0.019760132, 0.0036010742, 0.00522995, 0.010696411, 0.019851685, 0.009117126, 0.017074585, 0.01763916, -0.006362915, -0.010955811, 0.01436615, 0.028945923, -0.024536133, 0.0076942444, -0.0025501251, -0.010894775, 0.007472992, -0.004432678, 0.04248047, 0.040222168, -0.0025691986, 0.0029144287, -0.00012993813, -0.011940002, -0.013008118, 0.003929138, 0.05722046, -0.07086182, 0.05630493, -0.018417358, -0.039978027, -0.031982422, 0.033172607, 0.009025574, -0.02432251, -0.007335663, 0.027053833, 0.012939453, 0.028945923, 0.016906738, -0.030258179, 0.00944519, 0.026504517, -0.011497498, 0.028549194, 0.0038528442, -0.002029419, 0.038269043, 0.03173828, 0.022155762, -0.018554688, 0.036346436, -0.04147339, 0.0129852295, 0.017669678, 0.056518555, -0.004337311, -0.044433594, 0.04949951, 0.014404297, -0.022262573, -0.014328003, 0.050689697, 0.02532959, -0.0043945312, 0.050598145, 0.044036865, -0.023529053, -0.02809143, -0.0003950596, -0.0044021606, 0.045959473, -0.027862549, 0.012878418, -0.024765015, -0.046081543, 0.028305054, -0.04333496, 0.06677246, 0.007408142, 0.03125, -0.023773193, -0.029663086, 0.034362793, -0.036102295, 0.03390503, -0.013847351, 0.015823364, -0.026260376, -0.0029506683, -0.017837524, -0.027374268, -0.01146698, 0.061431885, 0.019821167, 0.0002939701, 0.029541016, -0.039001465, -0.04034424, 0.037200928, -0.0029830933, 0.059814453, 0.015029907, -0.009895325, -0.014930725, -0.004585266, 0.008514404, -0.0047035217, 0.0075263977, -0.022079468, -0.06329346, -0.0040626526, -0.0018606186, -0.005355835, -0.04006958, -0.047058105, 0.03439331, 0.015075684, -0.033081055, -0.020828247, 0.008285522, -0.010971069, -0.041015625, -0.005340576, -0.030883789, 0.0062446594, 0.02015686, 0.021881104, 0.035339355, -0.0002105236, 0.02557373, 0.015342712, 0.061767578, 0.06347656, 0.039733887, -0.0368042, 0.009315491, 0.03149414, 0.0770874, -0.010818481, -0.001452446, -0.009048462, 0.019134521, 0.00020182133, 0.07525635, 0.020843506, 0.017425537, -0.014709473, 0.03048706, 0.00333786, -0.030258179, -0.020462036, -0.030395508, 0.017547607, 0.015808105, -0.005252838, -0.041778564, 0.01914978, 0.026031494, 0.014518738, 0.016616821, -0.027648926, 0.005821228, 0.0026111603, 0.04989624, 0.00894928, -0.023880005, -0.032592773, 0.068481445, -0.028121948, 0.00033593178, -0.0037231445, 0.03375244, 0.007598877, 0.02180481, 0.011947632, -0.04788208, 0.018615723, 0.04095459, -0.0011882782, 0.033721924, -0.03793335, -0.022918701, -0.004207611, 0.0044898987, 0.0005249977, 0.0050468445, 0.010650635, 0.016525269, -0.0025806427, -0.003255844, 0.0015439987, -0.023208618, -0.012649536, 0.047576904, -0.0035190582, 0.00007933378, -0.010826111, -0.027359009, 0.011329651, 0.014289856, 0.019958496, -0.01890564, -0.035705566, 0.025238037, 0.029953003, 0.0031585693 ], "summary": [ 0.049682617, 0.002609253, 0.030593872, -0.002445221, -0.013885498, -0.025268555, 0.011634827, -0.06323242, -0.0362854, -0.0044555664, -0.0030708313, 0.005088806, -0.007396698, -0.046905518, 0.037963867, -0.023391724, -0.008354187, 0.008415222, 0.005794525, -0.025100708, 0.00566864, -0.011398315, 0.017105103, -0.043823242, 0.02357483, -0.030822754, -0.009002686, 0.009643555, 0.03805542, 0.020690918, 0.037384033, -0.028961182, -0.0024223328, 0.07244873, -0.04336548, 0.008834839, -0.060394287, 0.05770874, 0.02458191, -0.029769897, 0.024795532, -0.015823364, 0.051330566, 0.0059013367, -0.0014543533, 0.033721924, -0.016067505, -0.040100098, 0.027038574, 0.06237793, -0.022583008, 0.019882202, -0.05758667, 0.044677734, -0.0011129379, -0.04144287, -0.08148193, 0.03781128, 0.021835327, 0.11401367, 0.04284668, -0.015975952, -0.046905518, -0.08288574, 0.03918457, -0.03353882, 0.028640747, 0.037261963, 0.009132385, 0.036346436, 0.029769897, 0.006477356, 0.01939392, -0.068603516, -0.022064209, 0.06112671, 0.010772705, 0.012168884, 0.005592346, -0.045288086, -0.033355713, 0.0052833557, -0.09173584, -0.029434204, 0.012840271, 0.004623413, -0.023635864, -0.013412476, -0.04864502, 0.03353882, -0.025131226, -0.012870789, -0.027038574, 0.038116455, 0.013084412, -0.00048971176, -0.023147583, -0.036987305, 0.016952515, 0.007247925, 0.016098022, -0.036743164, 0.029083252, -0.017471313, -0.0019893646, 0.03564453, 0.000767231, -0.04208374, -0.02758789, -0.0007724762, -0.039764404, -0.031158447, -0.00007802248, -0.035369873, -0.0056495667, 0.035583496, 0.018814087, 0.021194458, 0.011672974, 0.017944336, 0.011062622, 0.014373779, 0.022460938, 0.01398468, 0.026046753, 0.03125, -0.001373291, -0.04537964, 0.0035934448, -0.001200676, -0.053619385, 0.04244995, 0.042755127, -0.017028809, -0.020599365, -0.013008118, 0.014892578, 0.021408081, 0.02142334, -0.0014162064, 0.02166748, -0.04559326, -0.01939392, 0.05621338, -0.03164673, 0.034698486, 0.036224365, 0.008911133, -0.029418945, -0.068237305, 0.02583313, -0.027175903, 0.02279663, 0.0053367615, -0.011558533, -0.020904541, -0.016204834, -0.017364502, 0.030578613, -0.023208618, 0.02960205, 0.012489319, -0.0009250641, 0.06088257, 0.024459839, -0.0031032562, 0.003129959, 0.015792847, 0.020050049, 0.05105591, 0.006263733, -0.028457642, -0.024230957, 0.015220642, -0.002456665, 0.00894165, 0.027801514, 0.07678223, 0.0060424805, -0.032226562, -0.0025787354, -0.041229248, 0.094177246, -0.031951904, -0.03527832, 0.017608643, -0.0038661957, 0.04638672, 0.03778076, 0.013084412, -0.014129639, -0.009017944, -0.024383545, 0.035980225, -0.045684814, -0.025360107, -0.0090789795, 0.016967773, -0.040893555, 0.013061523, 0.045135498, 0.017105103, -0.014709473, -0.03918457, -0.06817627, -0.009063721, -0.017807007, 0.025985718, -0.039031982, 0.0059127808, 0.041168213, 0.0071144104, -0.055480957, 0.04095459, 0.027450562, 0.03378296, 0.0035533905, -0.011306763, 0.009338379, -0.008010864, -0.014846802, -0.003238678, -0.026901245, 0.012290955, 0.013580322, 0.021316528, -0.014137268, 0.007205963, 0.09942627, 0.022445679, 0.09436035, -0.07556152, -0.023864746, -0.019332886, -0.046081543, -0.028182983, -0.05065918, -0.0736084, 0.011489868, 0.07293701, 0.03201294, -0.0079956055, -0.04815674, -0.035614014, 0.05581665, -0.0031471252, -0.0010251999, -0.015075684, -0.0209198, 0.005947113, -0.024017334, -0.005218506, 0.030563354, -0.050689697, -0.01828003, 0.06414795, 0.005092621, 0.012245178, 0.0017328262, -0.005264282, 0.0058288574, -0.010543823, -0.027069092, 0.012702942, 0.03491211, -0.062438965, -0.0020980835, -0.03074646, -0.015556335, -0.025497437, 0.022705078, -0.07147217, 0.019180298, -0.021118164, -0.007575989, -0.014289856, -0.00623703, -0.010269165, 0.0524292, -0.019088745, -0.024780273, -0.0017824173, 0.0018539429, -0.013397217, 0.024154663, 0.010406494, 0.012123108, -0.032196045, 0.024520874, 0.061431885, 0.0501709, 0.054748535, 0.0055122375, 0.02470398, 0.0018577576, 0.012062073, 0.009155273, 0.01739502, -0.005393982, -0.010559082, -0.03149414, 0.030899048, 0.016281128, -0.021469116, 0.013931274, 0.00047421455, 0.03050232, 0.0098724365, -0.012252808, 0.016235352, -0.08996582, -0.043762207, 0.025238037, 0.016113281, -0.02809143, -0.03250122, -0.030014038, 0.032470703, -0.04373169, 0.01083374, 0.056854248, -0.0021896362, 0.021728516, -0.019058228, -0.0008049011, -0.031097412, -0.0025997162, -0.006511688, -0.026779175, 0.028137207, 0.03277588, 0.037353516, 0.008918762, 0.010787964, 0.013725281, 0.005630493, 0.005493164, 0.0030822754, -0.0055007935, -0.02394104, 0.01033783, 0.022491455, -0.016540527, -0.023849487, -0.06768799, 0.0057792664, 0.0076065063, -0.0036029816, -0.07128906, -0.022644043, 0.06549072, -0.028076172, -0.018081665, -0.064453125, -0.0011501312, 0.029876709, 0.006866455, -0.029449463, 0.04647827, -0.062927246, 0.051727295, 0.039764404, 0.037506104, -0.08380127, -0.07128906, -0.03866577, -0.020324707, 0.0014867783, 0.043029785, 0.061279297, -0.0003607273, 0.04663086, -0.09698486, -0.011482239, -0.00014925003, 0.008888245, 0.036499023, -0.025543213, -0.007896423, 0.013381958, 0.012954712, -0.0047073364, 0.020187378, -0.028717041, 0.055419922, 0.011306763, -0.014259338, 0.010192871, 0.03439331, -0.014854431, 0.0008945465, 0.014541626, -0.039245605, -0.027404785, 0.034820557, 0.02406311, -0.0028591156, -0.0017089844, -0.03302002, -0.03189087, 0.045013428, -0.0062065125, -0.03652954, 0.00258255, 0.010765076, -0.033813477, 0.05657959, -0.015899658, 0.01676941, 0.020187378, 0.035949707, -0.04864502, 0.05255127, -0.07751465, 0.026916504, -0.023391724, 0.053222656, 0.021911621, -0.002866745, -0.09466553, -0.020599365, 0.058441162, 0.010299683, -0.02557373, 0.00025892258, -0.030792236, -0.00004976988, -0.028121948, 0.022994995, 0.07080078, 0.000051617622, 0.03805542, -0.0118255615, 0.018615723, -0.018081665, 0.026382446, 0.019424438, -0.009475708, 0.060638428, -0.045776367, -0.019302368, -0.008621216, -0.029022217, 0.00036931038, -0.0030117035, -0.028900146, -0.006942749, -0.01663208, 0.038238525, -0.013221741, -0.002319336, -0.022201538, 0.06945801, 0.022537231, -0.017166138, 0.0859375, -0.010093689, 0.022354126, 0.052459717, -0.025558472, -0.014183044, 0.0061531067, -0.014625549, 0.0045700073, -0.010620117, -0.004924774, 0.026519775, 0.015510559, -0.015174866, 0.010314941, -0.003189087, 0.0010404587, -0.034973145, -0.023422241, -0.009483337, -0.020629883, 0.03201294, -0.010726929, 0.05001831, -0.012741089, -0.03994751, 0.034729004, -0.022750854, -0.056427002, -0.039642334, 0.015563965, -0.059143066, -0.035217285, 0.013702393, -0.009513855, -0.020370483, -0.039886475, 0.03778076, -0.038238525, 0.009887695, 0.021453857, -0.0071792603, 0.07208252, -0.0473938, -0.08355713, 0.013259888, -0.03527832, 0.020324707, 0.07635498, -0.0014371872, 0.041259766, -0.018859863, 0.012825012, -0.0052337646, -0.06365967, -0.0029735565, -0.05331421, -0.021270752, 0.020309448, -0.026184082, 0.02909851, 0.012794495, 0.020690918, 0.008224487, -0.024536133, 0.021942139, 0.050842285, -0.011634827, 0.011436462, 0.013160706, -0.012802124, -0.02973938, 0.014404297, -0.0152282715, -0.06185913, 0.058135986, 0.043182373, 0.018920898, 0.041412354, -0.03930664, 0.012138367, -0.042419434, -0.0007677078, 0.03213501, 0.020507812, -0.04284668, -0.04736328, 0.0060691833, 0.052215576, -0.023132324, 0.006046295, -0.060760498, -0.017120361, -0.018981934, -0.026657104, -0.01008606, -0.011001587, -0.037902832, -0.041046143, -0.0050849915, 0.04574585, 0.0032653809, 0.0004749298, -0.021560669, -0.024032593, 0.01878357, -0.01096344, -0.0025634766, 0.0011959076, 0.022949219, 0.01550293, -0.010978699, -0.068115234, 0.011619568, -0.011520386, -0.027313232, -0.0126571655, 0.023452759, 0.002161026, -0.0061302185, -0.025939941, -0.010749817, 0.044769287, -0.0033569336, 0.026947021, 0.031158447, -0.013702393, -0.061065674, 0.027832031, -0.026351929, -0.005619049, 0.018569946, 0.00048589706, -0.03414917, -0.029754639, 0.013046265, -0.006061554, -0.03567505, -0.042877197, 0.04812622, 0.03338623, 0.055023193, -0.011787415, 0.0039901733, 0.02609253, 0.0003399849, 0.011909485, 0.012763977, -0.013374329, 0.004688263, 0.019348145, -0.04171753, 0.05508423, -0.0017166138, 0.035125732, -0.011650085, -0.012298584, -0.007926941, 0.0072898865, 0.006778717, -0.0024471283, 0.0033359528, 0.017456055, 0.040863037, -0.013626099, 0.039794922, 0.027282715, 0.016616821, 0.0134887695, 0.009254456, -0.009155273, 0.024047852, 0.03253174, 0.0043754578, 0.018371582, 0.019638062, 0.0132369995, -0.037322998, -0.056884766, 0.0008416176, 0.051239014, -0.008895874, 0.0030612946, -0.032806396, -0.04562378, 0.0016794205, 0.014572144, -0.0019817352, 0.0051193237, 0.041931152, -0.0031223297, 0.005542755, 0.018936157, -0.022521973, 0.016708374, -0.031188965, 0.006515503, 0.055664062, -0.04156494, -0.046722412, -0.0037269592, -0.033172607, 0.03866577, 0.00730896, -0.029815674, -0.08239746, 0.005554199, 0.03427124, -0.04763794, 0.027297974, 0.018249512, 0.03741455, 0.019363403, -0.004699707, 0.01159668, -0.008148193, 0.032287598, 0.021896362, -0.014915466, 0.002544403, 0.016616821, 0.043426514, 0.0074272156, 0.024261475, -0.054840088, 0.00091457367, -0.0025730133, -0.027313232, 0.03024292, -0.034606934, 0.0076179504, -0.011741638, 0.022064209, 0.0039634705, -0.025756836, 0.017807007, 0.041168213, -0.017166138, 0.009925842, 0.011657715, -0.009056091, -0.009552002, 0.03881836, 0.022842407, -0.008163452, 0.0385437, 0.019134521, -0.04260254, -0.016998291, -0.010063171, 0.007751465, -0.048095703, 0.009613037, 0.023025513, 0.045806885, 0.0054130554, -0.032104492, -0.06689453, -0.020690918, -0.0070381165, -0.046783447, -0.050354004, -0.03390503, -0.018493652, 0.039154053, -0.014251709, 0.04144287, 0.04248047, -0.051208496, 0.0077285767, -0.00095176697, -0.025726318, 0.0032539368, -0.01687622, -0.03640747, -0.000016152859, -0.01586914, -0.010765076, -0.006877899, -0.0043411255, -0.022201538, 0.031082153, -0.0060157776, 0.020401001, -0.03793335, -0.005519867, -0.008323669, 0.04473877, -0.005077362, -0.02822876, 0.006023407, -0.0024871826, -0.01361084, 0.04650879, -0.0012016296, 0.059783936, 0.02810669, -0.015625, -0.00258255, 0.037384033, 0.009017944, 0.028442383, -0.027877808, -0.017944336, -0.011955261, -0.044433594, 0.012145996, 0.004650116, -0.0057411194, 0.018035889, -0.0044937134, -0.0012836456, 0.035461426, 0.018814087, -0.016708374, -0.009757996, 0.0070152283, -0.0041236877, 0.014556885, 0.028701782, 0.0019426346, -0.0040893555, 0.016662598, 0.024291992, -0.011497498, -0.035308838, 0.01146698, 0.013420105, 0.016021729, -0.023635864, 0.024841309, 0.015403748, 0.03366089, 0.00198555, 0.009651184, 0.015556335, 0.029678345, 0.02532959, 0.046661377, 0.031066895, -0.03173828, -0.0051612854, 0.015258789, -0.053131104, -0.040618896, 0.013572693, 0.00024580956, -0.033996582, -0.0050735474, -0.037506104, -0.021636963, 0.0038051605, 0.030319214, 0.025497437, 0.001964569, 0.022140503, 0.024307251, -0.012397766, -0.054626465, -0.045562744, 0.013549805, 0.030578613, 0.0023097992, 0.017044067, -0.045318604, 0.01725769, 0.04248047, -0.0017910004, 0.009407043, 0.05038452, -0.0050811768, 0.027770996, 0.003332138, -0.02078247, -0.05895996, 0.027114868, -0.024261475, 0.008865356, 0.0079193115, 0.042236328, 0.01651001, 0.006008148, 0.046569824, -0.025772095, -0.007797241, 0.019470215, 0.011672974, -0.019256592, 0.015274048, -0.00969696, -0.008399963, 0.021331787, -0.0073394775, -0.013290405, 0.03933716, 0.013999939, -0.016738892, 0.0038986206, 0.01374054, 0.002199173, 0.005065918, 0.014381409, -0.027755737, 0.01940918, 0.00995636, -0.048919678, 0.021987915, -0.0037002563, 0.026153564, -0.018127441, 0.01939392, 0.014945984, -0.016036987, 0.07171631, -0.02835083, 0.025787354, -0.019821167, 0.020004272, 0.010116577, -0.009857178, -0.004928589, 0.048065186, -0.043121338, 0.044921875, 0.042877197, 0.07696533, 0.05078125, 0.08062744, -0.01727295, 0.022705078, 0.036621094, 0.021530151, 0.01322937, -0.0048713684, -0.0121536255, -0.04257202, 0.0064849854, 0.008895874, 0.015541077, 0.034118652, 0.08416748, 0.024856567, 0.02420044, -0.01675415, -0.0814209, 0.022125244, -0.0340271, 0.107177734, -0.053985596, 0.01979065, -0.015129089, 0.023803711, -0.0032100677, -0.013412476, -0.01763916, 0.038879395, 0.003982544, 0.0021762848, 0.04663086, 0.006088257, -0.031341553, -0.004173279, -0.010543823, 0.040618896, 0.0045928955, -0.021591187, 0.008842468, 0.014976501, 0.011695862, -0.0385437, 0.010803223, -0.03778076, -0.010101318, -0.055755615, 0.024414062, 0.0007457733, -0.039031982, -0.043640137, -0.024841309, -0.003742218, -0.038360596, 0.05102539, 0.027755737, -0.0011825562, -0.042388916, 0.013015747, -0.012557983, 0.0060577393, -0.037902832, 0.010536194, 0.074401855, -0.028045654, -0.008888245, 0.021530151, 0.06414795, 0.059753418, 0.04348755, -0.05368042, 0.013771057, 0.01411438, 0.052825928, -0.003955841, 0.025299072, 0.026290894, 0.017227173, 0.0158844, 0.040130615, -0.019927979, 0.01109314, -0.003660202, 0.049560547, 0.0028057098, -0.034820557, -0.05014038, 0.0042800903, 0.036010742, -0.00077438354, -0.008354187, -0.05682373, 0.005519867, 0.009086609, -0.008857727, 0.021972656, -0.015533447, -0.021362305, 0.012008667, 0.015342712, 0.0012588501, -0.03970337, 0.019256592, 0.051879883, -0.026763916, 0.0035686493, -0.00027799606, -0.0019359589, 0.01890564, -0.00046563148, -0.0009121895, -0.005279541, -0.0076026917, -0.0033740997, 0.009315491, -0.017349243, 0.0037193298, -0.0063285828, 0.016296387, -0.006576538, -0.0027637482, 0.008636475, 0.01184845, -0.033081055, -0.029434204, -0.029052734, -0.014282227, -0.05731201, -0.04611206, 0.043518066, 0.033447266, -0.01576233, 0.05496216, 0.008911133, 0.025665283, 0.037506104, 0.05444336, 0.023101807, 0.0002746582, 0.008613586, 0.032684326, 0.00466156 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2111.12210v7
From Kepler to Newton: Explainable AI for Science
Zelong Li, Jianchao Ji, Yongfeng Zhang
cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SC
The Observation--Hypothesis--Prediction--Experimentation loop paradigm for scientific research has been practiced by researchers for years towards scientific discoveries. However, with data explosion in both mega-scale and milli-scale scientific research, it has been sometimes very difficult to manually analyze the data and propose new hypotheses to drive the cycle for scientific discovery. In this paper, we discuss the role of Explainable AI in scientific discovery process by demonstrating an Explainable AI-based paradigm for science discovery. The key is to use Explainable AI to help derive data or model interpretations, hypotheses, as well as scientific discoveries or insights. We show how computational and data-intensive methodology -- together with experimental and theoretical methodology -- can be seamlessly integrated for scientific research. To demonstrate the AI-based science discovery process, and to pay our respect to some of the greatest minds in human history, we show how Kepler's laws of planetary motion and Newton's law of universal gravitation can be rediscovered by (Explainable) AI based on Tycho Brahe's astronomical observation data, whose works were leading the scientific revolution in the 16-17th century. This work also highlights the important role of Explainable AI (as compared to Blackbox AI) in science discovery to help humans prevent or better prepare for the possible technological singularity that may happen in the future, since science is not only about the know how, but also the know why. Presentation of the work is available at https://slideslive.com/38986142/from-kepler-to-newton-explainable-ai-for-science-discovery.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2111.12210v7
"2023-01-23T17:58:01"
"2021-11-24T00:45:27"
{ "title": [ -0.042022705, -0.0104522705, -0.01663208, -0.03253174, -0.005039215, 0.01096344, 0.0012893677, -0.022918701, -0.000518322, 0.025634766, -0.011886597, 0.011199951, 0.00010228157, -0.017578125, -0.041168213, 0.0075416565, 0.009086609, 0.024505615, -0.007068634, -0.021957397, -0.01737976, -0.017196655, 0.059265137, 0.036987305, 0.020462036, -0.028717041, -0.046295166, 0.010826111, -0.03756714, -0.037139893, -0.016189575, 0.01725769, 0.028182983, 0.010269165, 0.013000488, 0.021987915, -0.021865845, 0.017333984, 0.012817383, 0.005542755, -0.0037956238, 0.0056877136, -0.026031494, -0.03262329, -0.040527344, 0.01335144, -0.06945801, -0.0070343018, -0.020599365, 0.06854248, 0.017959595, 0.008422852, -0.0121154785, 0.05331421, 0.016555786, -0.027664185, 0.0025806427, -0.03552246, 0.032806396, 0.031402588, 0.003824234, -0.042388916, 0.039886475, -0.010726929, -0.045074463, -0.019424438, -0.012542725, 0.028411865, 0.06793213, -0.00043201447, -0.01966858, 0.029052734, -0.005443573, 0.00793457, -0.030532837, -0.022720337, 0.052703857, 0.020355225, 0.021224976, -0.017623901, 0.014312744, -0.029830933, 0.022888184, -0.00957489, -0.0070533752, -0.023757935, -0.009498596, -0.0009393692, -0.052368164, -0.047821045, -0.009284973, -0.02734375, -0.042755127, 0.037353516, -0.007701874, -0.0021781921, -0.028182983, -0.013458252, 0.005821228, -0.0009069443, -0.0055770874, 0.012329102, -0.005065918, -0.00907135, 0.023223877, 0.053741455, -0.012939453, -0.021987915, 0.0033340454, 0.02142334, -0.011054993, -0.0051460266, 0.034942627, -0.012435913, 0.011459351, -0.01084137, -0.008117676, 0.04925537, 0.0211792, 0.04901123, 0.00054740906, -0.045074463, 0.016952515, 0.0054397583, 0.021835327, -0.011779785, -0.08654785, 0.016693115, 0.007160187, 0.020477295, -0.012306213, 0.03866577, -0.078125, -0.08538818, -0.0524292, 0.04055786, -0.008628845, 0.011528015, -0.014045715, 0.029968262, 0.0016174316, -0.036376953, 0.015449524, 0.01399231, -0.02758789, -0.022964478, 0.054626465, 0.020767212, -0.032104492, -0.036376953, -0.026641846, 0.038024902, 0.027496338, -0.0002822876, -0.053253174, 0.013031006, -0.11364746, -0.0070114136, 0.016342163, 0.012809753, 0.01739502, 0.014808655, -0.017623901, -0.005142212, 0.052368164, -0.02684021, -0.0047073364, 0.029449463, 0.0075645447, 0.021896362, 0.0093307495, 0.012397766, -0.02142334, -0.0066871643, -0.0024051666, -0.016311646, 0.030075073, -0.01574707, 0.0075531006, 0.010032654, 0.0082473755, -0.020889282, -0.030685425, 0.07141113, -0.04248047, -0.031677246, -0.004299164, -0.025146484, 0.041412354, 0.0033817291, -0.04788208, 0.033294678, -0.052856445, -0.042053223, -0.041381836, -0.005683899, 0.03479004, 0.039855957, -0.0025520325, 0.02192688, -0.040161133, 0.009246826, -0.037719727, 0.024475098, -0.006980896, -0.011482239, -0.012771606, 0.0368042, -0.029418945, 0.07421875, 0.052947998, 0.032104492, -0.046417236, 0.010658264, 0.012992859, -0.06512451, 0.017303467, -0.012359619, -0.01991272, -0.029052734, -0.04171753, 0.00024914742, -0.008842468, 0.035736084, -0.0006842613, 0.016204834, -0.0003824234, -0.015808105, 0.045288086, 0.04321289, 0.07751465, -0.062316895, 0.06072998, 0.034088135, -0.01739502, -0.018066406, -0.006187439, -0.009300232, 0.003030777, 0.02722168, 0.0015459061, -0.02508545, 0.004852295, 0.027938843, 0.046844482, -0.0056266785, 0.016067505, 0.0074882507, 0.018569946, 0.011260986, 0.05783081, 0.012680054, 0.070007324, 0.005077362, -0.019577026, 0.07019043, 0.013015747, 0.014472961, -0.018493652, 0.025375366, -0.0012626648, 0.034240723, 0.0056915283, 0.020385742, -0.0713501, 0.03451538, -0.040893555, 0.005744934, -0.0029411316, 0.02293396, 0.045074463, -0.03338623, 0.0012245178, -0.013397217, -0.011886597, -0.023406982, -0.0055732727, 0.0113220215, 0.006198883, -0.064086914, 0.007434845, 0.0006957054, 0.04562378, 0.008659363, 0.030654907, -0.015296936, 0.025665283, 0.014221191, -0.015159607, -0.014373779, 0.042175293, 0.041870117, 0.031433105, -0.015083313, 0.021392822, -0.0012493134, 0.06542969, 0.090270996, -0.023452759, 0.02949524, -0.08166504, 0.0043296814, 0.028762817, -0.03466797, 0.0018720627, 0.0073165894, -0.0015745163, 0.015007019, -0.03060913, 0.0066566467, -0.073913574, 0.019195557, 0.006538391, -0.0368042, -0.014213562, -0.043273926, -0.008087158, -0.039367676, -0.056640625, -0.024002075, 0.08520508, -0.0061683655, -0.006706238, -0.02142334, 0.00043940544, -0.028900146, -0.01651001, -0.03265381, -0.028411865, 0.022445679, 0.032104492, 0.006839752, -0.051696777, 0.006324768, 0.001405716, 0.029220581, -0.028747559, 0.016204834, -0.036132812, 0.010505676, -0.014175415, -0.012542725, 0.031677246, -0.06976318, 0.008323669, -0.03857422, 0.019363403, 0.014183044, -0.024353027, 0.007255554, 0.019851685, -0.016525269, -0.034454346, 0.010055542, 0.056488037, -0.04724121, -0.0036697388, 0.044952393, 0.034698486, -0.013977051, 0.022888184, -0.0011577606, -0.0063591003, -0.03805542, 0.002576828, -0.0345459, -0.023361206, -0.0037136078, -0.012428284, 0.025894165, -0.06100464, -0.0060539246, -0.03866577, -0.00724411, 0.00080156326, 0.028396606, -0.03427124, -0.04586792, -0.035247803, -0.028167725, -0.009063721, 0.025772095, -0.0154800415, 0.02619934, 0.083862305, 0.005004883, -0.027267456, 0.0015707016, 0.024505615, 0.01222229, -0.029327393, -0.027114868, -0.016525269, 0.0023670197, -0.004070282, -0.0069274902, -0.015548706, 0.0020332336, -0.107299805, 0.015731812, 0.031158447, 0.028869629, -0.02798462, 0.0390625, -0.07562256, 0.013702393, -0.027236938, -0.014434814, 0.017425537, 0.049865723, -0.009094238, 0.009643555, 0.016479492, -0.038513184, 0.014434814, -0.023880005, -0.10760498, 0.020751953, -0.012023926, -0.029663086, -0.028579712, 0.008552551, -0.06665039, -0.016174316, 0.0052948, 0.046325684, 0.037139893, -0.002960205, 0.036102295, -0.023605347, -0.0005970001, -0.017303467, -0.01586914, -0.023544312, -0.018295288, 0.010375977, -0.0035877228, 0.0670166, 0.019424438, 0.006538391, -0.027160645, -0.024520874, -0.018035889, 0.028076172, -0.0039634705, -0.031219482, -0.025161743, -0.0049934387, -0.016448975, -0.010536194, 0.0034427643, -0.0031013489, -0.021713257, 0.0018749237, -0.008705139, 0.036865234, 0.0036239624, 0.0076179504, -0.025894165, -0.007575989, 0.015007019, -0.018936157, -0.056488037, -0.0026493073, 0.014984131, -0.017028809, 0.06112671, -0.017959595, -0.023223877, 0.027008057, -0.048431396, 0.01171875, 0.013694763, -0.0024166107, 0.008506775, 0.023162842, -0.04458618, 0.00019299984, -0.035461426, 0.051116943, 0.00012552738, 0.003501892, -0.024993896, -0.06390381, -0.005870819, 0.005744934, -0.11328125, -0.034179688, 0.004760742, -0.027526855, -0.032928467, -0.054382324, 0.028320312, -0.03375244, -0.033813477, 0.026184082, -0.023086548, 0.018005371, 0.004333496, -0.047851562, -0.0181427, 0.07110596, -0.0035324097, 0.007873535, 0.023025513, -0.011672974, -0.02204895, -0.022460938, 0.024429321, 0.01260376, 0.03302002, 0.005683899, -0.015930176, 0.0440979, -0.046051025, 0.03894043, 0.012176514, 0.014266968, -0.0079574585, 0.005302429, -0.007904053, 0.01247406, -0.028839111, 0.044891357, 0.032989502, -0.021026611, -0.046813965, 0.037078857, -0.007801056, -0.023040771, 0.031036377, 0.0071754456, 0.0029792786, 0.0056762695, 0.013839722, 0.04675293, -0.028747559, -0.01663208, 0.04812622, 0.0062942505, -0.016601562, -0.00055885315, 0.0209198, 0.04763794, 0.0061454773, 0.026306152, 0.004337311, 0.039154053, -0.025985718, -0.0032577515, -0.014076233, -0.0020256042, -0.0049438477, -0.000177145, -0.06274414, -0.025299072, -0.03567505, 0.0043525696, 0.0070648193, 0.03262329, 0.02508545, -0.014831543, -0.026245117, 0.008850098, 0.006679535, 0.009109497, -0.012687683, -0.059509277, 0.020614624, -0.023666382, -0.07220459, -0.058441162, -0.009902954, 0.0087890625, 0.022735596, 0.008300781, -0.0082092285, 0.025344849, 0.0067214966, 0.039855957, 0.06555176, -0.021652222, -0.06335449, 0.029769897, -0.03729248, -0.0027484894, 0.009727478, -0.005420685, -0.012840271, -0.03414917, 0.014953613, -0.002286911, -0.018936157, -0.04675293, 0.017074585, -0.0071983337, 0.060943604, 0.015640259, 0.027923584, 0.021697998, 0.0082473755, -0.00289917, 0.0044136047, -0.037597656, 0.0026798248, 0.00023198128, 0.0635376, -0.027114868, 0.02670288, 0.032440186, 0.013206482, -0.017913818, 0.0014362335, 0.03137207, 0.02658081, -0.055541992, 0.008049011, 0.0071640015, -0.043060303, -0.0035171509, 0.0077209473, 0.012771606, 0.068359375, -0.070251465, 0.043304443, -0.009376526, 0.008453369, 0.00078868866, -0.014945984, 0.030044556, -0.023361206, 0.027862549, -0.06378174, -0.1083374, -0.039276123, 0.08862305, -0.013931274, -0.017791748, 0.007801056, 0.018707275, 0.015457153, 0.050964355, 0.03086853, 0.009788513, 0.027069092, -0.005012512, -0.003604889, -0.02204895, -0.042266846, 0.0044822693, -0.003856659, 0.024291992, -0.040496826, 0.032684326, -0.057769775, 0.017089844, 0.004611969, -0.022094727, 0.052947998, -0.07836914, 0.00944519, 0.09100342, -0.009529114, 0.03451538, -0.0051879883, 0.016723633, 0.013618469, 0.045837402, -0.0052108765, 0.026000977, 0.029556274, -0.033294678, -0.023773193, 0.0050811768, 0.04107666, 0.025512695, 0.011329651, 0.025665283, -0.014564514, -0.045654297, 0.019042969, 0.022323608, 0.009788513, 0.02444458, -0.06774902, 0.015670776, -0.009384155, -0.0013694763, 0.009941101, -0.015991211, -0.05038452, 0.009902954, -0.0140686035, -0.0039978027, 0.025054932, 0.0047416687, -0.014389038, -0.061706543, 0.03050232, -0.009727478, 0.0056762695, -0.011627197, 0.025253296, -0.0236969, 0.02229309, 0.027313232, -0.05368042, 0.0014600754, -0.016036987, -0.00015830994, 0.04058838, 0.023773193, -0.035888672, 0.0020885468, -0.0063591003, -0.06439209, -0.028015137, 0.0126571655, 0.008956909, -0.0029277802, 0.00013411045, -0.042388916, -0.033843994, 0.044769287, 0.023254395, 0.0006980896, -0.063964844, 0.037506104, 0.0048103333, 0.014427185, -0.008911133, 0.03125, 0.006351471, -0.008323669, 0.009170532, -0.035705566, 0.009185791, -0.006038666, -0.016998291, -0.00034999847, -0.04547119, 0.0031604767, 0.012535095, 0.011528015, 0.0009417534, 0.015281677, 0.03970337, -0.006061554, 0.005634308, 0.022659302, 0.08984375, -0.05987549, -0.029083252, -0.031921387, -0.012161255, -0.051116943, 0.044158936, 0.025680542, -0.016220093, -0.034454346, -0.0519104, -0.02772522, -0.0008497238, 0.027175903, 0.027236938, 0.03286743, -0.04714966, -0.016326904, -0.045898438, 0.008148193, -0.014350891, 0.023376465, -0.006248474, 0.00024938583, -0.009086609, 0.0005373955, -0.016433716, -0.00970459, 0.032196045, 0.03567505, -0.0013523102, 0.03677368, -0.048919678, -0.0090408325, -0.0357666, -0.014854431, 0.05758667, 0.025848389, -0.03756714, 0.052581787, -0.036621094, 0.0635376, 0.02709961, 0.04168701, 0.048583984, 0.03125, 0.027191162, -0.012229919, 0.02458191, -0.021942139, 0.0016393661, -0.06262207, -0.02949524, -0.05618286, -0.021591187, -0.05621338, -0.044433594, 0.027236938, 0.0078086853, 0.014984131, 0.005207062, 0.0019702911, 0.003250122, 0.050201416, 0.022827148, 0.05215454, -0.02305603, 0.003004074, -0.011665344, -0.01802063, 0.018035889, 0.029129028, -0.014976501, 0.037261963, -0.033050537, -0.013687134, 0.008003235, 0.015487671, 0.012840271, -0.02027893, -0.019943237, -0.03387451, 0.050598145, -0.010505676, 0.017364502, 0.07019043, 0.07519531, -0.022476196, -0.017181396, 0.018371582, -0.018600464, -0.0028934479, -0.027130127, 0.03466797, -0.05368042, 0.027832031, -0.012619019, -0.03955078, -0.030441284, 0.04711914, 0.028045654, -0.029327393, -0.006000519, 0.015716553, 0.036346436, 0.009056091, -0.013404846, -0.042236328, -0.023666382, 0.017120361, 0.030075073, -0.018966675, 0.00484848, 0.014160156, 0.040130615, -0.023208618, -0.031677246, 0.008201599, 0.0025978088, -0.038238525, 0.018203735, -0.007843018, 0.01727295, -0.015701294, -0.03591919, 0.016159058, -0.00233078, -0.025680542, -0.017410278, 0.047668457, 0.017333984, 0.010276794, 0.04260254, -0.017089844, -0.032348633, -0.016464233, -0.030593872, 0.0446167, 0.053649902, -0.027053833, 0.018844604, -0.0395813, -0.03640747, 0.041503906, -0.026779175, 0.071777344, -0.04244995, 0.020950317, -0.020584106, 0.030975342, 0.022521973, -0.052734375, -0.01876831, -0.00014829636, -0.0035266876, -0.013725281, 0.0046653748, -0.008888245, -0.023971558, 0.020950317, 0.04046631, 0.026779175, 0.009483337, 0.0095825195, -0.04626465, -0.045959473, 0.01133728, -0.0104522705, 0.04522705, -0.020019531, -0.00459671, -0.026428223, 0.020507812, -0.007785797, -0.00034308434, -0.012184143, 0.011520386, -0.04849243, -0.027877808, 0.010055542, 0.007472992, -0.019821167, 0.0181427, -0.062927246, 0.026046753, -0.01638794, 0.003004074, 0.026153564, -0.030593872, -0.04837036, 0.0044517517, -0.03050232, 0.02822876, 0.020721436, -0.024215698, 0.006084442, 0.025894165, -0.028808594, -0.02381897, -0.015899658, 0.01612854, -0.012924194, -0.030197144, -0.023498535, 0.037353516, 0.037872314, -0.061920166, -0.06390381, 0.013214111, 0.043823242, -0.0007381439, 0.07531738, 0.006713867, 0.009757996, 0.020767212, 0.018295288, 0.008583069, -0.041809082, -0.0008301735, -0.021987915, 0.018295288, 0.049865723, -0.01210022, -0.0084991455, 0.023345947, -0.019500732, 0.019927979, 0.014122009, -0.016540527, 0.020645142, -0.0032596588, 0.0335083, -0.014541626, -0.019973755, -0.023101807, -0.020141602, 0.011550903, 0.03616333, -0.022415161, 0.009742737, -0.01890564, 0.09710693, 0.0033569336, -0.066589355, 0.054260254, 0.05645752, 0.015625, 0.05041504, -0.02470398, -0.04711914, -0.0022354126, 0.008125305, -0.0003478527, 0.017059326, 0.014846802, -0.007774353, 0.01285553, -0.050994873, -0.042053223, 0.008956909, -0.030395508, 0.052124023, -0.038482666, 0.007381439, -0.026565552, -0.007751465, 0.00762558, 0.026229858, 0.030319214, -0.0027313232, -0.06488037, -0.049468994, 0.037841797, -0.02986145 ], "summary": [ -0.052886963, -0.017990112, -0.0028438568, 0.017501831, -0.031677246, -0.0052490234, 0.037597656, 0.005443573, 0.016845703, 0.035461426, -0.01625061, -0.0051116943, 0.0158844, -0.018722534, -0.021209717, -0.02281189, 0.017700195, 0.021911621, 0.053955078, -0.012298584, 0.008384705, 0.010688782, 0.045135498, -0.011962891, 0.0016126633, -0.015701294, 0.0023536682, 0.0234375, 0.021972656, 0.03778076, 0.014579773, -0.06008911, 0.0107421875, -0.026443481, 0.026016235, 0.011268616, 0.029037476, -0.0074539185, 0.006465912, 0.0124053955, 0.010681152, -0.009902954, 0.0725708, -0.043304443, 0.012802124, 0.023880005, -0.00756073, -0.018630981, 0.023147583, 0.037078857, 0.0079956055, -0.024673462, -0.005504608, 0.007904053, -0.012466431, -0.0038261414, 0.011024475, -0.01890564, 0.010353088, -0.026245117, -0.013343811, 0.0022144318, 0.042419434, 0.02557373, -0.009307861, 0.0033130646, 0.034820557, 0.014045715, 0.005344391, -0.022460938, -0.0036964417, 0.012313843, -0.011505127, -0.010292053, -0.0009946823, -0.023757935, 0.042388916, 0.00024163723, -0.026351929, 0.0056762695, 0.011512756, -0.023971558, 0.027450562, -0.011428833, -0.0234375, -0.011413574, -0.010726929, 0.012489319, -0.06311035, 0.0042152405, -0.045043945, -0.097839355, -0.047058105, 0.05380249, 0.038330078, 0.0051498413, -0.05996704, -0.08276367, -0.0011510849, 0.032348633, 0.013595581, -0.019805908, 0.027740479, -0.0027580261, 0.013160706, 0.044830322, 0.009727478, -0.011871338, -0.01864624, -0.025115967, -0.01727295, -0.036834717, 0.033050537, -0.017227173, 0.0071372986, 0.020004272, -0.00035262108, 0.06817627, 0.00818634, 0.08630371, -0.00970459, -0.018508911, -0.040008545, 0.025268555, 0.03414917, -0.012702942, -0.05029297, 0.060760498, 0.016784668, 0.029464722, -0.025924683, 0.010192871, 0.0395813, 0.0051231384, -0.016860962, -0.01197052, 0.0154953, -0.0050811768, 0.018157959, 0.010635376, 0.0206604, -0.029403687, 0.031433105, 0.03152466, 0.020507812, -0.012390137, 0.021133423, 0.026473999, 0.027923584, -0.009063721, 0.0043144226, 0.03262329, 0.047943115, -0.011756897, -0.03286743, -0.02104187, -0.06298828, 0.0060577393, 0.0044136047, 0.0048179626, -0.003944397, 0.00762558, -0.011878967, 0.0116119385, 0.008781433, -0.0012998581, 0.007419586, 0.003194809, 0.00856781, -0.0690918, 0.048339844, 0.027374268, -0.049926758, -0.050628662, 0.017593384, -0.035827637, 0.025817871, -0.02078247, -0.03793335, 0.07312012, 0.03479004, -0.03338623, -0.06439209, 0.05001831, 0.012252808, 0.002960205, -0.00011616945, -0.010406494, 0.01121521, 0.011390686, -0.007167816, 0.019607544, -0.030197144, -0.0056648254, 0.014770508, 0.005996704, -0.023086548, 0.01626587, -0.0036373138, -0.0030441284, 0.024597168, 0.034362793, -0.042419434, -0.008399963, -0.082336426, 0.019897461, -0.027496338, 0.04147339, 0.006374359, 0.03277588, 0.017974854, 0.012954712, -0.019760132, -0.030792236, 0.0021896362, -0.007904053, 0.02720642, -0.013244629, -0.004234314, -0.0009126663, 0.0034294128, 0.030532837, -0.010322571, 0.029724121, 0.0012149811, 0.008033752, -0.0040740967, -0.00044441223, 0.04473877, 0.048980713, 0.039520264, -0.058624268, 0.03692627, 0.008705139, -0.03729248, 0.007297516, -0.01133728, -0.054107666, -0.009315491, 0.04940796, 0.024780273, -0.0027828217, -0.016952515, -0.010238647, -0.0007572174, -0.032714844, 0.029403687, -0.003004074, -0.021453857, 0.008003235, 0.032562256, -0.0051879883, 0.021377563, -0.009460449, -0.05355835, 0.03881836, 0.022659302, -0.0007123947, 0.007610321, 0.018096924, 0.010215759, 0.011184692, -0.0418396, 0.0181427, -0.031173706, 0.010139465, -0.011360168, -0.0002539158, -0.006175995, 0.00050258636, 0.030273438, -0.0028247833, -0.004924774, 0.026824951, -0.044525146, 0.01612854, -0.019317627, 0.011299133, 0.00970459, 0.0050735474, 0.0011501312, 0.0016117096, 0.002286911, -0.012771606, 0.050354004, 0.008583069, 0.004585266, 0.01675415, 0.026809692, 0.07196045, 0.05630493, 0.07299805, 0.054901123, 0.006565094, 0.029022217, 0.026428223, -0.048065186, 0.010559082, 0.013687134, -0.031341553, -0.03805542, 0.025863647, -0.006008148, -0.0044136047, 0.00969696, -0.00029683113, 0.0032081604, -0.0032749176, -0.002576828, 0.01802063, -0.066467285, 0.027999878, 0.0035114288, 0.0418396, -0.03173828, -0.047058105, -0.004550934, 0.014923096, -0.025878906, -0.014823914, 0.11730957, -0.04711914, 0.038757324, -0.01991272, -0.029632568, -0.05697632, 0.04168701, -0.02003479, -0.022766113, 0.016189575, -0.03237915, 0.006439209, -0.029205322, 0.055511475, -0.0035495758, 0.0073509216, -0.011398315, 0.025299072, -0.016967773, 0.025634766, 0.0044174194, 0.001964569, 0.011695862, -0.043762207, -0.0390625, 0.008766174, 0.0181427, -0.006088257, 0.024353027, 0.02619934, -0.025726318, 0.0068244934, -0.01260376, 0.024139404, 0.034973145, -0.06524658, 0.003982544, 0.07299805, 0.012069702, -0.014060974, 0.01625061, 0.005065918, -0.029953003, -0.09637451, 0.013175964, 0.001742363, -0.019439697, -0.04336548, 0.0060424805, 0.023544312, -0.031799316, 0.016326904, -0.052612305, -0.003774643, 0.01625061, 0.034179688, 0.03366089, -0.003534317, -0.033966064, 0.026504517, 0.008453369, 0.05239868, -0.02293396, 0.06530762, 0.079711914, -0.0256958, -0.036712646, 0.035369873, 0.011604309, 0.01802063, -0.017074585, -0.03237915, 0.03829956, -0.026550293, 0.0051574707, -0.025421143, 0.01838684, 0.044311523, -0.031921387, -0.0236969, 0.00037050247, 0.034820557, -0.008659363, 0.025512695, -0.03250122, 0.0067634583, -0.021392822, -0.026901245, 0.0154418945, -0.017089844, 0.024414062, 0.0016994476, 0.0025863647, -0.012504578, -0.004371643, -0.031829834, -0.022705078, -0.0012378693, 0.026733398, -0.017044067, -0.039916992, 0.06085205, -0.05718994, -0.019714355, 0.040924072, 0.034088135, 0.008285522, -0.03704834, 0.036621094, 0.00055122375, 0.008956909, -0.006668091, -0.02494812, 0.006023407, -0.02960205, 0.06652832, 0.010292053, 0.023086548, 0.03878784, -0.04434204, -0.00063562393, -0.03265381, -0.046966553, -0.017837524, -0.021072388, -0.030075073, -0.015052795, 0.010871887, 0.0067634583, 0.018829346, 0.039276123, -0.008804321, 0.0135269165, -0.0030174255, -0.026901245, 0.014183044, -0.021194458, 0.02293396, 0.041503906, -0.030700684, 0.0012817383, -0.0149002075, -0.045013428, 0.018493652, -0.016479492, -0.029754639, 0.08190918, -0.0011177063, -0.021591187, 0.009269714, -0.02949524, 0.0037403107, 0.023284912, -0.012054443, 0.010177612, 0.017837524, -0.008201599, -0.0077819824, -0.013008118, 0.020568848, -0.026351929, 0.028381348, 0.004886627, -0.04006958, -0.02420044, -0.0014638901, -0.060821533, -0.050109863, -0.01222229, -0.0018177032, 0.0005683899, -0.055999756, 0.028839111, -0.027709961, -0.052215576, 0.043273926, -0.029525757, 0.10668945, 0.035858154, -0.04385376, 0.044708252, -0.039642334, 0.029632568, 0.000770092, -0.007610321, -0.0006890297, 0.0033607483, 0.0066184998, 0.017654419, 0.023803711, 0.017593384, 0.01184845, 0.043151855, 0.017837524, -0.02709961, 0.03277588, 0.0044174194, 0.01109314, -0.0033035278, -0.00030970573, 0.026062012, 0.028869629, -0.016921997, -0.022125244, 0.06402588, -0.004573822, -0.008743286, 0.039886475, -0.031082153, 0.005756378, 0.009292603, 0.051086426, -0.034118652, -0.04309082, 0.033691406, -0.021972656, -0.04232788, -0.057006836, 0.037200928, 0.091430664, -0.018218994, -0.010826111, 0.015304565, 0.117614746, 0.028182983, -0.02015686, 0.0017900467, 0.008552551, -0.060913086, 0.04623413, -0.050628662, -0.05343628, 0.01322937, -0.040924072, 0.005290985, -0.023864746, -0.0064582825, -0.01914978, 0.02619934, 0.017349243, -0.038848877, -0.016540527, 0.021102905, 0.009849548, 0.037353516, 0.03781128, -0.041412354, -0.055114746, 0.018615723, -0.06365967, -0.07141113, -0.048583984, -0.013092041, -0.007461548, 0.0025253296, 0.02406311, -0.013175964, 0.020828247, -0.012420654, 0.024124146, 0.037902832, 0.032073975, -0.040863037, 0.04168701, -0.06378174, 0.095458984, -0.037994385, 0.011505127, -0.039154053, 0.041534424, 0.020187378, 0.026519775, -0.04296875, -0.044067383, 0.012916565, 0.013885498, 0.040618896, 0.032073975, 0.04034424, 0.013465881, 0.0027980804, -0.033203125, 0.00060272217, -0.027328491, 0.036987305, -0.038604736, 0.031433105, -0.058044434, 0.04333496, 0.0035972595, -0.036102295, -0.037078857, -0.01878357, 0.05697632, -0.007965088, -0.103637695, -0.013946533, 0.013183594, 0.030563354, 0.035949707, 0.06036377, 0.022094727, 0.05126953, 0.023895264, -0.010520935, 0.00073337555, 0.011543274, 0.016830444, -0.024246216, 0.024124146, 0.0013780594, 0.00048685074, -0.07318115, -0.12658691, -0.06958008, 0.10473633, 0.0004963875, -0.04623413, -0.012145996, -0.028305054, -0.005340576, 0.01461792, 0.018737793, -0.01574707, 0.043640137, -0.012458801, 0.004055023, 0.031707764, -0.035705566, -0.03933716, -0.0625, 0.0061149597, -0.05218506, 0.05697632, 0.016220093, 0.021102905, -0.006340027, -0.006164551, 0.02760315, -0.0059814453, -0.02116394, 0.05682373, -0.015411377, 0.021118164, 0.036132812, -0.0013694763, -0.029800415, 0.024520874, -0.031097412, 0.010101318, -0.018951416, 0.013008118, -0.037200928, -0.02067566, 0.032165527, 0.027267456, -0.04525757, 0.024993896, -0.041503906, -0.02760315, 0.0037384033, 0.0070533752, 0.057525635, -0.0317688, -0.03250122, -0.013038635, -0.023986816, 0.050323486, -0.031173706, 0.038238525, -0.033996582, 0.044158936, 0.0024738312, 0.07519531, -0.010261536, 0.007385254, 0.013053894, -0.012046814, -0.03237915, -0.034301758, 0.043884277, 0.006084442, 0.005378723, 0.025527954, 0.0011758804, -0.020996094, -0.028945923, -0.006374359, 0.022354126, 0.015312195, -0.0113220215, -0.00043725967, 0.021148682, 0.004737854, -0.015434265, -0.014205933, 0.021621704, 0.004863739, -0.015655518, 0.028427124, 0.0011110306, -0.013694763, -0.032440186, 0.037750244, 0.012069702, -0.0040130615, -0.082336426, 0.036590576, 0.0066719055, 0.0113220215, 0.004753113, 0.06689453, 0.018692017, -0.010002136, 0.010925293, -0.05166626, -0.0017738342, -0.00843811, -0.006500244, -0.035614014, -0.05267334, -0.002210617, 0.015777588, 0.01852417, 0.032104492, -0.0073509216, 0.013145447, -0.010192871, 0.019012451, 0.012420654, 0.0770874, -0.048797607, -0.044067383, -0.043548584, 0.0053520203, -0.0524292, -0.016433716, 0.026168823, -0.01259613, 0.010276794, -0.031158447, 0.010856628, -0.014060974, -0.020080566, 0.0036678314, -0.011619568, 0.0128479, -0.0049591064, -0.039398193, 0.017044067, 0.013015747, 0.024429321, -0.0043945312, -0.024658203, 0.0020008087, 0.031143188, -0.050109863, 0.029418945, 0.012649536, 0.04840088, 0.008453369, 0.041046143, 0.0009627342, -0.014785767, -0.029953003, 0.005870819, 0.010429382, 0.050354004, -0.032928467, 0.015602112, 0.052246094, 0.02949524, 0.008628845, -0.0013637543, -0.012886047, 0.012908936, 0.04385376, -0.014923096, 0.035186768, -0.013717651, 0.015182495, -0.057037354, -0.05493164, -0.078552246, -0.051330566, -0.008857727, -0.011528015, -0.016403198, -0.062286377, 0.052734375, -0.027709961, -0.035217285, 0.061065674, -0.02557373, 0.09954834, -0.020706177, -0.0592041, -0.010421753, -0.01424408, -0.03829956, 0.001996994, 0.038757324, -0.018936157, 0.022964478, -0.034118652, 0.006465912, 0.0423584, -0.043640137, 0.020980835, -0.009086609, -0.012001038, -0.024017334, 0.028671265, 0.009666443, 0.0066337585, 0.040283203, 0.030151367, -0.0025615692, -0.013847351, 0.044921875, 0.0031223297, 0.025405884, -0.05029297, 0.0060653687, 0.027755737, -0.018112183, 0.0018424988, -0.026870728, -0.0099105835, 0.056365967, 0.038879395, 0.0023994446, 0.039398193, 0.02331543, 0.0039634705, -0.023727417, -0.058532715, -0.04837036, -0.0362854, 0.013648987, 0.0015192032, -0.0256958, -0.019973755, 0.0036754608, 0.0093688965, 0.0023765564, -0.021362305, -0.017105103, 0.008384705, -0.03878784, 0.0062294006, 0.023864746, -0.032196045, 0.0033912659, -0.0060157776, 0.007675171, 0.02154541, 0.037994385, -0.0051574707, 0.07867432, -0.004600525, -0.03982544, -0.006259918, -0.05795288, -0.0075569153, 0.012794495, 0.011566162, 0.011711121, 0.051452637, 0.005958557, -0.012382507, -0.0058174133, -0.0093688965, 0.015075684, 0.041503906, 0.03564453, -0.050323486, -0.003850937, -0.010726929, 0.01725769, -0.049560547, 0.019866943, -0.014701843, -0.0031719208, 0.025878906, 0.00016379356, 0.025726318, -0.03491211, 0.02456665, 0.017303467, -0.0068359375, 0.033477783, 0.02670288, 0.013870239, -0.034973145, 0.02357483, -0.010269165, -0.008850098, 0.07183838, 0.052459717, -0.008605957, 0.0023918152, 0.028869629, -0.01928711, -0.025115967, -0.008369446, 0.037963867, -0.0057868958, -0.02609253, 0.03945923, 0.049102783, -0.0035324097, 0.01776123, -0.04437256, 0.032562256, -0.01411438, 0.036590576, 0.0019607544, 0.013290405, 0.016525269, 0.011123657, -0.022094727, -0.01751709, -0.025360107, -0.019760132, 0.006099701, 0.044952393, -0.04940796, -0.02180481, -0.038330078, -0.017730713, -0.0069007874, -0.014770508, -0.039398193, 0.032714844, 0.011604309, -0.039154053, -0.047180176, 0.035614014, 0.044952393, 0.02659607, 0.047729492, -0.032104492, 0.026916504, 0.0115737915, 0.048339844, 0.0064315796, -0.03363037, 0.04925537, 0.015823364, -0.02645874, 0.008300781, 0.0067634583, -0.009407043, 0.0004541874, -0.04046631, -0.015548706, -0.0032539368, -0.013198853, -0.033355713, 0.009750366, -0.025802612, -0.0368042, -0.006500244, 0.04421997, -0.043548584, 0.012748718, -0.003232956, -0.0043945312, -0.028244019, -0.042785645, 0.0362854, 0.032592773, 0.030639648, -0.035827637, -0.0055503845, 0.032806396, -0.04663086, -0.002937317, -0.030212402, 0.01802063, 0.0020885468, -0.008811951, 0.008773804, 0.014183044, 0.011131287, -0.014137268, -0.01852417, -0.026779175, -0.040985107, -0.04156494, 0.055480957, -0.027404785, -0.016021729, -0.0053215027, -0.012260437, 0.023651123, 0.0209198, 0.015914917, 0.008087158, -0.03668213, -0.020446777, -0.010375977, -0.018676758 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2111.15013v1
DeepCQ+: Robust and Scalable Routing with Multi-Agent Deep Reinforcement Learning for Highly Dynamic Networks
Saeed Kaviani, Bo Ryu, Ejaz Ahmed, Kevin Larson, Anh Le, Alex Yahja, Jae H. Kim
cs.NI, cs.AI, cs.LG
Highly dynamic mobile ad-hoc networks (MANETs) remain as one of the most challenging environments to develop and deploy robust, efficient, and scalable routing protocols. In this paper, we present DeepCQ+ routing protocol which, in a novel manner integrates emerging multi-agent deep reinforcement learning (MADRL) techniques into existing Q-learning-based routing protocols and their variants and achieves persistently higher performance across a wide range of topology and mobility configurations. While keeping the overall protocol structure of the Q-learning-based routing protocols, DeepCQ+ replaces statically configured parameterized thresholds and hand-written rules with carefully designed MADRL agents such that no configuration of such parameters is required a priori. Extensive simulation shows that DeepCQ+ yields significantly increased end-to-end throughput with lower overhead and no apparent degradation of end-to-end delays (hop counts) compared to its Q-learning based counterparts. Qualitatively, and perhaps more significantly, DeepCQ+ maintains remarkably similar performance gains under many scenarios that it was not trained for in terms of network sizes, mobility conditions, and traffic dynamics. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first successful application of the MADRL framework for the MANET routing problem that demonstrates a high degree of scalability and robustness even under environments that are outside the trained range of scenarios. This implies that our MARL-based DeepCQ+ design solution significantly improves the performance of Q-learning based CQ+ baseline approach for comparison and increases its practicality and explainability because the real-world MANET environment will likely vary outside the trained range of MANET scenarios. Additional techniques to further increase the gains in performance and scalability are discussed.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2111.15013v1
"2021-11-29T23:05:49"
"2021-11-29T23:05:49"
{ "title": [ -0.033355713, 0.00078487396, -0.048706055, -0.012916565, 0.01727295, -0.009544373, -0.014022827, -0.014701843, -0.013549805, 0.017120361, -0.026306152, 0.031143188, -0.03704834, -0.022109985, -0.017349243, -0.0134887695, -0.010047913, 0.005622864, -0.025970459, -0.045440674, 0.009788513, -0.06121826, 0.026687622, 0.103027344, 0.010528564, -0.016494751, -0.075927734, 0.02407837, -0.05593872, -0.03982544, -0.02609253, 0.030258179, 0.044891357, 0.006011963, -0.0317688, -0.017471313, -0.06225586, 0.015525818, -0.015426636, -0.0067100525, 0.025238037, -0.013145447, 0.00844574, -0.03829956, -0.007133484, 0.023635864, -0.0579834, -0.024871826, -0.013534546, 0.074645996, 0.037750244, 0.038879395, 0.0034561157, 0.081726074, 0.029251099, -0.02218628, -0.02142334, -0.03213501, 0.040008545, 0.04824829, 0.023269653, -0.06530762, 0.027893066, -0.0082092285, -0.047332764, -0.043029785, 0.04156494, 0.018554688, 0.06390381, -0.009895325, -0.007144928, 0.06518555, -0.002664566, 0.020935059, -0.0435791, -0.036987305, 0.047576904, -0.010383606, 0.027130127, -0.00894928, -0.011833191, -0.0075645447, -0.004070282, -0.021499634, 0.00995636, -0.032714844, -0.016998291, -0.016494751, -0.05859375, -0.05291748, -0.013374329, -0.018356323, -0.031311035, 0.0076942444, -0.0132751465, -0.023605347, -0.01965332, 0.030654907, -0.0062713623, 0.007534027, 0.00049352646, -0.0028686523, 0.0016040802, -0.03665161, -0.0044517517, -0.00052785873, -0.010009766, -0.011672974, 0.010757446, 0.04171753, -0.026779175, 0.030792236, 0.014533997, 0.034484863, -0.01689148, -0.027572632, -0.018447876, 0.01146698, -0.0014238358, 0.03125, 0.0004374981, -0.013534546, 0.008728027, 0.0025100708, 0.04397583, 0.034454346, -0.036468506, -0.016998291, -0.0016927719, 0.023071289, 0.015274048, 0.040039062, -0.09741211, -0.07739258, -0.06970215, 0.049072266, -0.00712204, 0.012718201, 0.015197754, -0.014579773, 0.029205322, -0.029403687, -0.021224976, 0.045288086, 0.023132324, 0.0042495728, 0.05645752, -0.0011863708, -0.051239014, -0.01474762, -0.027069092, 0.042266846, 0.017562866, 0.005821228, -0.015174866, 0.010406494, -0.08465576, -0.016174316, 0.013023376, 0.011581421, 0.029693604, 0.016235352, 0.012992859, 0.033355713, 0.06903076, -0.030838013, -0.037109375, 0.01486969, -0.005004883, 0.047058105, -0.029754639, 0.016815186, -0.019897461, -0.028778076, -0.0017127991, -0.0072746277, 0.028533936, 0.006549835, 0.0149002075, -0.029159546, -0.004085541, -0.022979736, 0.012825012, 0.044555664, -0.04486084, -0.034240723, 0.011802673, -0.014930725, 0.04019165, 0.0099105835, -0.019195557, 0.023162842, -0.07684326, -0.024887085, -0.0552063, 0.0031967163, 0.040222168, 0.03842163, -0.0121536255, 0.026535034, -0.052612305, 0.017913818, -0.032196045, 0.03756714, 0.013877869, -0.02217102, 0.0046844482, 0.014083862, -0.013427734, 0.054718018, 0.047790527, 0.012527466, -0.03062439, -0.0038166046, -0.012298584, -0.043121338, 0.0076293945, -0.029632568, -0.014656067, 0.001742363, -0.02911377, 0.022827148, -0.016708374, 0.036254883, -0.0019416809, 0.009117126, -0.0008792877, -0.011192322, 0.012023926, 0.021438599, 0.060394287, -0.029953003, 0.013557434, 0.018096924, -0.0077552795, -0.03866577, -0.0036125183, -0.02229309, 0.022872925, 0.020492554, -0.0014810562, -0.040893555, -0.014541626, 0.03152466, 0.02128601, -0.03744507, -0.013397217, 0.03137207, 0.009857178, 0.019012451, 0.060516357, 0.017974854, 0.051513672, 0.024032593, 0.0178833, 0.029876709, 0.013328552, 0.009506226, -0.01965332, 0.024932861, -0.0019779205, 0.038879395, 0.0026073456, 0.021987915, -0.06112671, 0.022766113, -0.01626587, 0.026855469, 0.011810303, 0.0104599, 0.03378296, -0.0066986084, 0.013366699, 0.032836914, 0.010269165, -0.011871338, -0.013084412, -0.006980896, 0.016067505, -0.023361206, -0.008148193, -0.0076141357, 0.039520264, 0.0021572113, 0.027664185, -0.012519836, 0.018112183, -0.02003479, 0.0070343018, -0.01625061, 0.03793335, 0.01889038, 0.0025501251, -0.0012245178, 0.017288208, -0.027236938, 0.06585693, 0.097351074, -0.025283813, 0.037994385, -0.07672119, 0.00217247, 0.014877319, -0.03173828, 0.0007991791, 0.02973938, 0.027145386, 0.021118164, -0.013648987, -0.006038666, -0.040924072, 0.00094127655, 0.0040245056, -0.036132812, -0.03414917, -0.03866577, -0.015686035, -0.04284668, -0.02822876, 0.020446777, 0.09063721, -0.012710571, 0.003145218, -0.00687027, -0.0016155243, -0.03778076, -0.01537323, -0.027236938, -0.027435303, 0.0289917, 0.023239136, 0.017654419, -0.059448242, 0.0058555603, -0.0074157715, 0.033447266, -0.0020446777, 0.0368042, -0.019317627, -0.023849487, 0.016830444, -0.046447754, -0.000107586384, -0.0072898865, 0.013771057, -0.051696777, 0.010536194, 0.008796692, -0.02507019, 0.017669678, 0.013076782, -0.0107040405, -0.046966553, 0.006542206, 0.053009033, -0.033691406, -0.008377075, 0.052612305, 0.036987305, 0.0026855469, -0.006210327, 0.004966736, -0.03164673, -0.07659912, 0.01586914, -0.01838684, -0.024765015, -0.006576538, 0.0015907288, 0.04623413, -0.058776855, -0.012123108, -0.012107849, -0.008872986, 0.022460938, 0.02571106, -0.012168884, -0.020050049, -0.0064468384, -0.0069732666, 0.0073394775, 0.025466919, -0.011276245, 0.0048828125, 0.07293701, 0.0036468506, -0.047973633, -0.019317627, 0.022018433, 0.010040283, -0.009925842, -0.029708862, -0.010253906, 0.014091492, 0.0072631836, -0.0040359497, 0.012573242, -0.0027542114, -0.09649658, -0.015792847, 0.059295654, 0.0064201355, -0.028457642, 0.035186768, -0.057495117, -0.02709961, 0.018615723, -0.007896423, 0.027526855, 0.028182983, 0.014465332, -0.00072431564, 0.004550934, -0.027618408, 0.023391724, -0.042266846, -0.029464722, 0.03756714, -0.042266846, -0.06793213, -0.0054626465, -0.0002593994, -0.042541504, -0.034362793, 0.006038666, 0.023651123, 0.034698486, -0.0075798035, 0.026824951, 0.0124053955, 0.0027103424, -0.02217102, -0.0055122375, -0.002691269, -0.037902832, -0.021911621, -0.006149292, 0.028717041, 0.040222168, -0.015640259, -0.06585693, -0.0362854, 0.0014476776, 0.035858154, 0.03286743, -0.053375244, -0.0362854, -0.06463623, -0.011581421, -0.036346436, -0.015159607, -0.011428833, -0.026397705, 0.016296387, -0.0093307495, 0.078063965, 0.0057411194, 0.0011920929, -0.017120361, -0.008552551, 0.028381348, -0.024856567, -0.059173584, 0.021148682, 0.04888916, 0.009552002, -0.0029239655, -0.021850586, -0.06555176, 0.057281494, -0.016036987, -0.0071792603, 0.02532959, -0.02268982, -0.014427185, -0.014083862, 0.016052246, -0.019424438, 0.013595581, -0.02822876, 0.013046265, -0.0038833618, -0.02017212, -0.0119018555, 0.018875122, -0.0057525635, -0.07885742, -0.008651733, 0.02368164, -0.010429382, -0.009902954, -0.03677368, 0.022918701, -0.022033691, -0.034118652, 0.014579773, -0.027633667, 0.0027446747, 0.0149002075, -0.051818848, -0.025756836, 0.057250977, 0.009025574, -0.00374794, 0.042388916, 0.018218994, 0.0026226044, -0.02609253, 0.0058898926, 0.008178711, 0.050476074, -0.02204895, -0.015396118, 0.032989502, -0.030654907, -0.003545761, 0.037841797, 0.037261963, -0.03164673, -0.010116577, 0.039245605, 0.031555176, -0.030731201, 0.03012085, 0.031402588, -0.019454956, -0.057281494, -0.00030303, 0.011810303, -0.00012141466, 0.02897644, 0.0036258698, 0.039978027, 0.019485474, -0.018066406, 0.035308838, -0.02128601, 0.006023407, 0.03050232, -0.016677856, -0.014221191, -0.0107040405, 0.015945435, -0.0060195923, 0.0044517517, 0.028213501, -0.012313843, 0.048614502, -0.060455322, 0.009002686, -0.0032043457, 0.008865356, -0.027923584, -0.0093688965, -0.061706543, 0.002691269, -0.012741089, 0.000685215, -0.03451538, 0.031280518, 0.040527344, 0.018432617, -0.025009155, -0.012252808, 0.06555176, -0.0005297661, -0.01272583, -0.06335449, 0.0055770874, -0.016662598, -0.048919678, -0.041229248, -0.003419876, -0.006904602, 0.015380859, -0.014884949, -0.03125, 0.029006958, 0.03189087, 0.10064697, 0.026046753, 0.0044441223, -0.049926758, 0.050109863, -0.023529053, -0.021896362, 0.014305115, -0.016586304, -0.0072288513, -0.021438599, 0.021697998, -0.012878418, -0.0088272095, -0.035736084, 0.017211914, -0.0021953583, 0.025268555, 0.008644104, 0.066711426, 0.03137207, 0.037872314, 0.015457153, 0.01902771, -0.026367188, -0.039398193, -0.0034217834, 0.061157227, -0.023712158, 0.020935059, 0.04776001, 0.025985718, 0.0048828125, -0.012557983, 0.01927185, 0.017105103, -0.031280518, -0.026138306, 0.03677368, -0.013046265, -0.029266357, 0.02178955, 0.015792847, 0.032562256, -0.011329651, 0.06378174, -0.019363403, -0.0076675415, 0.028289795, -0.006072998, 0.0009007454, -0.018600464, 0.010696411, -0.05392456, -0.06994629, -0.020980835, 0.05718994, -0.01802063, -0.0023727417, -0.0087890625, 0.020141602, 0.041992188, 0.0501709, 0.055541992, -0.031402588, -0.025909424, -0.0088272095, -0.0021190643, -0.027740479, -0.05480957, -0.030059814, -0.0019798279, 0.026977539, -0.033203125, 0.051574707, -0.06817627, 0.00793457, 0.0046577454, -0.019180298, 0.023544312, -0.062927246, 0.021972656, 0.06921387, -0.010269165, 0.028015137, 0.022125244, 0.02166748, -0.0054779053, 0.045959473, 0.001912117, 0.034362793, 0.045074463, -0.08026123, 0.034454346, -0.003479004, 0.033416748, -0.0051193237, 0.007686615, 0.005706787, 0.0076789856, -0.060394287, 0.038970947, 0.022735596, -0.02230835, 0.015022278, -0.04647827, 0.0073661804, -0.0004389286, 0.031829834, 0.017105103, -0.03213501, -0.028747559, -0.0014438629, -0.015823364, -0.025497437, -0.00060272217, 0.0016469955, -0.017242432, -0.05834961, 0.01953125, -0.057128906, 0.00039672852, 0.006996155, -0.00699234, -0.035095215, 0.023773193, 0.038909912, -0.015701294, 0.012397766, -0.007270813, 0.013671875, 0.05154419, 0.02458191, -0.064086914, -0.012260437, 0.002412796, -0.045654297, -0.06262207, -0.004272461, 0.0027942657, -0.011329651, -0.013412476, 0.003112793, 0.01134491, -0.005130768, 0.03781128, 0.0028572083, -0.05026245, 0.021697998, 0.010124207, 0.013870239, 0.0044517517, -0.00035071373, -0.02720642, 0.01586914, 0.018600464, 0.006454468, 0.03100586, -0.010299683, 0.00077056885, 0.012207031, -0.06713867, 0.03164673, 0.019546509, 0.0064926147, -0.0022678375, 0.019561768, 0.03717041, 0.0032310486, -0.00012862682, 0.015319824, 0.062286377, -0.050933838, 0.033996582, -0.015045166, 0.0022735596, -0.05117798, 0.04397583, -0.03189087, 0.020141602, -0.070495605, -0.06414795, -0.032989502, 0.0030879974, 0.037139893, 0.018707275, 0.035858154, -0.068115234, 0.009666443, -0.027893066, -0.006454468, -0.025558472, 0.019592285, 0.0015697479, -0.00015306473, -0.01675415, 0.0024585724, -0.00434494, -0.015220642, 0.024169922, 0.021362305, -0.008079529, 0.014015198, -0.04031372, -0.00034976006, -0.0035209656, -0.011436462, 0.045440674, -0.029067993, 0.008514404, 0.014556885, -0.0345459, 0.023513794, 0.011070251, 0.065979004, 0.061340332, 0.019592285, 0.024459839, -0.0019893646, 0.000364542, -0.04220581, 0.054779053, -0.060668945, -0.020202637, -0.09136963, -0.04425049, -0.07556152, -0.0034980774, -0.013748169, 0.035125732, 0.01776123, 0.0059394836, 0.040985107, -0.0030288696, 0.04348755, -0.04421997, 0.06137085, 0.023239136, 0.011047363, -0.008369446, 0.025512695, 0.018814087, 0.020568848, 0.0045394897, 0.020935059, 0.004211426, -0.033111572, -0.0027923584, 0.030563354, 0.0027046204, -0.011398315, -0.021697998, -0.03265381, 0.047943115, -0.01335907, 0.03010559, 0.07952881, 0.041290283, 0.0138168335, -0.039916992, 0.011177063, 0.010406494, -0.054382324, 0.044677734, 0.041015625, -0.052093506, 0.019256592, -0.021911621, -0.016494751, 0.0043563843, 0.013450623, 0.0357666, -0.08319092, -0.06463623, 0.04196167, 0.038208008, -0.00868988, 0.02557373, -0.045928955, -0.034423828, 0.006374359, 0.05218506, -0.018203735, -0.006038666, -0.015655518, 0.04815674, -0.038269043, 0.0071487427, 0.0003080368, 0.017578125, -0.017074585, 0.02507019, -0.06524658, 0.052459717, 0.025283813, -0.03326416, 0.027816772, 0.015731812, -0.062072754, -0.008239746, -0.0070114136, 0.018188477, 0.03564453, 0.046722412, 0.012191772, -0.018005371, -0.011566162, -0.059051514, 0.019332886, 0.0345459, -0.03515625, 0.012176514, -0.027770996, -0.042419434, 0.043518066, -0.04071045, 0.062438965, -0.0385437, 0.0037899017, -0.023452759, 0.02407837, 0.03302002, -0.06298828, -0.012435913, -0.03366089, -0.025604248, 0.0009264946, 0.010040283, -0.0021457672, 0.0044784546, 0.009025574, 0.019561768, 0.039215088, -0.017166138, -0.029174805, -0.007972717, -0.07861328, -0.026763916, -0.05883789, 0.012176514, -0.01234436, -0.009170532, -0.0049095154, -0.0016345978, -0.0024547577, -0.025848389, -0.024154663, 0.0058517456, 0.0072021484, -0.012390137, 0.011657715, 0.020187378, -0.0017843246, 0.009147644, 0.017333984, 0.019683838, -0.009391785, -0.0073623657, 0.026351929, -0.030838013, -0.047943115, -0.022079468, -0.017486572, 0.043060303, 0.03640747, -0.020523071, 0.0062828064, 0.018737793, -0.04486084, 0.009132385, -0.0018014908, 0.04925537, -0.011886597, -0.033569336, -0.009880066, 0.053222656, 0.055786133, -0.03656006, -0.0047187805, 0.021255493, 0.015419006, -0.020812988, 0.05368042, 0.016937256, -0.021270752, 0.010971069, 0.039031982, 0.015335083, -0.02999878, -0.046051025, -0.045196533, 0.05419922, 0.03955078, -0.008514404, -0.033233643, 0.039245605, 0.0017709732, 0.0022449493, 0.0023040771, -0.017440796, 0.010215759, -0.011940002, 0.04248047, -0.00018012524, 0.018447876, -0.010147095, 0.03366089, -0.014373779, 0.02583313, -0.014625549, -0.0030899048, 0.018096924, 0.034851074, -0.040405273, -0.043182373, 0.045074463, 0.044158936, 0.0040359497, 0.05419922, -0.0446167, -0.018432617, 0.012184143, 0.010650635, -0.025238037, 0.018157959, 0.033691406, -0.010108948, 0.0035171509, -0.034301758, -0.04168701, 0.023498535, -0.04425049, 0.04159546, -0.038482666, 0.014450073, -0.025619507, -0.010665894, -0.0076408386, 0.036712646, -0.018875122, -0.033233643, -0.03967285, 0.0027770996, 0.055633545, -0.010009766 ], "summary": [ 0.009269714, -0.009902954, -0.010643005, 0.035888672, -0.019973755, -0.036254883, 0.008659363, -0.016983032, -0.014404297, 0.00049972534, -0.0102005005, 0.023025513, -0.036895752, -0.03527832, 0.020141602, -0.027038574, 0.0024051666, -0.015312195, -0.0088272095, -0.040618896, 0.025756836, -0.029876709, -0.022323608, 0.09112549, -0.0184021, 0.011329651, -0.0010623932, 0.0014562607, -0.047668457, -0.03152466, -0.01121521, 0.0357666, -0.0012369156, 0.029708862, -0.03881836, -0.07659912, -0.058135986, 0.029266357, -0.013511658, -0.0032844543, 0.0040016174, 0.008918762, 0.05041504, -0.051452637, 0.0028152466, 0.029403687, -0.03982544, -0.037597656, 0.0028800964, 0.030334473, 0.039398193, 0.016921997, 0.03137207, 0.061309814, -0.013290405, -0.0023021698, -0.018737793, -0.047180176, 0.021484375, 0.059387207, 0.017456055, -0.025650024, 0.008430481, -0.023971558, -0.027236938, -0.023345947, 0.08203125, 0.005302429, 0.010002136, -0.020446777, 0.026351929, 0.03817749, 0.003156662, 0.008712769, -0.00945282, -0.022613525, 0.02041626, -0.0032310486, 0.0017642975, 0.01701355, -0.019836426, 0.017333984, 0.027191162, -0.04034424, -0.022232056, -0.05569458, -0.0149002075, 0.0020637512, -0.072631836, -0.008415222, -0.040924072, -0.00040745735, -0.07305908, 0.0035362244, 0.01991272, -0.017608643, -0.011245728, -0.05203247, 0.043273926, 0.050933838, 0.041290283, -0.06591797, 0.08428955, -0.03741455, -0.039276123, -0.015289307, 0.019577026, 0.00020444393, -0.0041046143, 0.03289795, -0.035949707, -0.012298584, -0.0031356812, 0.017440796, -0.013938904, -0.00409317, -0.047546387, 0.039001465, -0.007358551, 0.04071045, -0.016647339, 0.02319336, 0.028518677, -0.0006160736, 0.029968262, 0.051239014, -0.006843567, -0.052764893, 0.01374054, -0.00014078617, -0.006706238, 0.03338623, -0.017700195, -0.015960693, -0.04434204, 0.0090408325, 0.035064697, 0.010215759, -0.0007266998, -0.013961792, 0.021942139, -0.011405945, -0.044525146, 0.024932861, 0.017242432, 0.037322998, 0.020690918, -0.005317688, -0.0076026917, -0.013374329, -0.0357666, 0.029876709, 0.013381958, 0.002943039, -0.023513794, -0.012039185, -0.03793335, 0.00084400177, 0.025939941, -0.012832642, 0.020339966, 0.018539429, 0.03262329, 0.05480957, 0.051849365, -0.030014038, -0.038238525, 0.0006890297, 0.0074424744, 0.0067100525, 0.016647339, 0.00969696, -0.019882202, -0.025482178, 0.021759033, -0.0124435425, 0.018218994, 0.060455322, 0.014320374, -0.0569458, -0.013504028, -0.034820557, 0.06161499, 0.003364563, -0.012428284, -0.017059326, 0.015838623, 0.025680542, 0.019210815, 0.014732361, 0.01096344, -0.024612427, -0.037475586, 0.016784668, -0.031234741, -0.013397217, 0.010345459, 0.0064201355, -0.028152466, 0.013290405, -0.023727417, 0.04055786, -0.0028495789, 0.03515625, -0.0008826256, 0.04208374, -0.016418457, 0.02168274, 0.020812988, 0.03616333, -0.0005764961, -0.012802124, -0.0055656433, -0.04360962, -0.0390625, -0.049743652, 0.00831604, -0.032440186, 0.0066070557, 0.009391785, 0.0068740845, 0.023666382, -0.020645142, 0.0132751465, -0.013587952, 0.017822266, -0.016479492, 0.022888184, 0.008811951, 0.033813477, 0.012924194, -0.014907837, -0.032806396, 0.02029419, -0.02418518, -0.03878784, 0.0053367615, -0.06604004, 0.046142578, 0.046417236, 0.014167786, -0.01158905, -0.03616333, -0.0021953583, 0.0074005127, -0.024642944, -0.01852417, 0.011108398, -0.025634766, -0.01461792, 0.018203735, 0.0016078949, 0.043029785, 0.011894226, -0.0036468506, 0.03479004, 0.020690918, -0.014045715, -0.0068893433, 0.04067993, -0.007648468, 0.00919342, -0.017181396, -0.0018014908, -0.047851562, 0.001124382, 0.015792847, 0.018157959, 0.023468018, -0.042877197, 0.013343811, 0.030151367, -0.0052223206, 0.015640259, 0.014305115, -0.01940918, -0.026870728, -0.008018494, -0.006690979, -0.005935669, -0.026290894, -0.038635254, -0.01133728, -0.000688076, 0.015541077, 0.00031399727, 0.02822876, -0.00073337555, 0.029403687, 0.07281494, 0.06112671, 0.042633057, 0.03564453, 0.0035114288, -0.021377563, 0.002445221, -0.021102905, 0.070007324, -0.010643005, 0.018936157, -0.049072266, 0.0036334991, -0.0033607483, -0.0036563873, 0.011238098, 0.0524292, 0.0446167, 0.014923096, 0.034423828, -0.0059280396, 0.02027893, 0.020339966, 0.009536743, 0.031433105, -0.011482239, -0.011749268, -0.010009766, 0.03540039, 0.05770874, 0.097595215, 0.075683594, 0.004962921, 0.010948181, -0.0059165955, 0.0119018555, -0.04348755, 0.0025119781, -0.010902405, 0.014724731, 0.01737976, -0.01436615, -0.005680084, -0.052215576, -0.031219482, 0.00031971931, -0.00081682205, 0.03164673, 0.0006327629, 0.009056091, -0.011650085, 0.056121826, -0.07147217, -0.022720337, 0.05911255, -0.010627747, -0.021224976, 0.014587402, -0.004840851, 0.040618896, 0.02293396, -0.021118164, 0.006465912, -0.0385437, 0.033325195, 0.035339355, -0.051116943, 0.011062622, 0.05834961, 0.017150879, -0.010414124, 0.02911377, 0.0036067963, -0.031021118, -0.10736084, 0.029327393, -0.014060974, -0.040802002, -0.045684814, 0.014320374, 0.025466919, -0.03527832, 0.00023257732, -0.025482178, -0.003921509, 0.034362793, 0.037994385, 0.04852295, 0.013900757, 0.057373047, 0.060546875, 0.05496216, 0.045196533, 0.007637024, -0.0035324097, 0.01838684, 0.0002863407, -0.05331421, -0.0057640076, 0.0058135986, 0.015007019, -0.0040283203, -0.014480591, 0.0040016174, -0.009605408, -0.003648758, 0.0007162094, 0.022994995, -0.024291992, -0.007369995, -0.035125732, 0.040496826, 0.032196045, 0.009719849, 0.008659363, -0.0012607574, -0.06100464, 0.03616333, -0.0051956177, -0.0022888184, -0.004333496, 0.035095215, -0.034057617, 0.016815186, -0.025482178, 0.019378662, -0.040802002, 0.06567383, 0.018447876, -0.05419922, -0.04284668, 0.027236938, 0.036193848, -0.011238098, -0.038604736, 0.0034599304, 0.0008134842, 0.0011529922, -0.030014038, 0.008224487, 0.07891846, 0.0032577515, 0.029174805, 0.020965576, 0.027862549, -0.06573486, -0.033355713, -9.536743e-7, -0.016860962, 0.07727051, -0.074157715, -0.05404663, -0.026260376, -0.0027885437, 0.04107666, 0.04849243, -0.040527344, -0.060302734, -0.06359863, 0.027053833, -0.05206299, 0.008598328, -0.020950317, 0.05709839, 0.024658203, -0.005138397, 0.10424805, -0.0030956268, 0.008346558, 0.03503418, 0.01689148, 0.0072669983, 0.017349243, -0.0012845993, 0.017578125, 0.047851562, 0.020629883, -0.0032787323, 0.005455017, -0.040649414, 0.03805542, 0.03024292, -0.05670166, 0.0074005127, -0.028442383, 0.011627197, -0.028274536, 0.031219482, -0.023513794, 0.049682617, -0.03982544, -0.017608643, 0.017181396, -0.09173584, 0.0042037964, -0.020645142, 0.0054779053, -0.02784729, -0.0002644062, 0.015464783, 0.06640625, 0.053131104, 0.0037021637, 0.047454834, 0.008171082, -0.0206604, 0.015556335, -0.020462036, 0.09625244, 0.02355957, -0.025787354, -0.012924194, -0.025741577, 0.02619934, -0.008453369, -0.0024433136, 0.043304443, 0.030685425, 0.007434845, -0.0021572113, -0.004005432, 0.03262329, -0.03363037, 0.026916504, 0.0068359375, 0.00223732, 0.003610611, 0.04660034, 0.05279541, -0.020843506, -0.013511658, 0.058563232, 0.037200928, -0.0102005005, 0.0007162094, 0.031280518, -0.01184845, -0.027496338, -0.0037841797, -0.010658264, -0.017929077, 0.035949707, 0.03326416, -0.0012178421, -0.0031204224, 0.0020713806, -0.011474609, -0.015174866, -0.008659363, -0.025497437, -0.009803772, 0.008476257, -0.032562256, -0.015960693, -0.008895874, -0.0121154785, -0.025878906, -0.024658203, 0.05734253, -0.062683105, 0.040283203, 0.012489319, -0.009033203, -0.030593872, -0.023635864, -0.0027198792, 0.04220581, 0.009757996, -0.019683838, -0.041259766, 0.008270264, 0.029006958, 0.04244995, 0.02268982, -0.04446411, 0.06726074, 0.020874023, -0.059814453, -0.09375, 0.0018901825, -0.036315918, -0.020523071, -0.0090408325, -0.023040771, -0.05682373, 0.01751709, -0.007675171, -0.011688232, -0.0066070557, 0.04031372, 0.049865723, -0.008094788, 0.040405273, -0.008392334, 0.0020122528, 0.0040130615, 0.013694763, -0.01638794, 0.019561768, 0.0059051514, 0.011360168, -0.004337311, -0.016983032, -0.021896362, -0.050354004, -0.009727478, 0.0016708374, -0.02508545, 0.050354004, 0.07659912, 0.016418457, 0.039794922, 0.014511108, 0.010627747, 0.006095886, -0.036956787, 0.014320374, 0.038208008, 0.015930176, 0.0095825195, 0.006137848, 0.026229858, -0.024215698, -0.0072669983, 0.029541016, -0.003522873, -0.03555298, -0.015029907, 0.034088135, 0.039642334, -0.03866577, 0.05090332, 0.007095337, 0.0006146431, 0.0715332, 0.027069092, 0.01763916, -0.013076782, 0.020309448, -0.024612427, -0.030776978, -0.035064697, -0.018249512, -0.039245605, -0.08502197, -0.047821045, 0.095581055, 0.00046396255, -0.034088135, -0.014221191, 0.022415161, 0.038116455, 0.019165039, 0.040161133, -0.04788208, -0.05114746, -0.01902771, -0.018676758, -0.025283813, -0.0435791, -0.07385254, 0.020233154, 0.038482666, 0.02268982, 0.072021484, -0.013336182, 0.028244019, 0.013519287, -0.015457153, 0.0072250366, -0.034576416, -0.020736694, 0.0055732727, -0.04736328, -0.01939392, 0.03741455, -0.025848389, -0.049682617, 0.0025558472, -0.02557373, 0.00856781, -0.027832031, -0.044921875, 0.012954712, -0.0362854, 0.02532959, -0.020812988, -0.0024261475, 0.012870789, -0.007282257, -0.052124023, 0.026947021, 0.013969421, -0.018600464, -0.0077552795, -0.008613586, 0.01953125, -0.009674072, 0.025146484, 0.0087509155, 0.009712219, -0.004211426, 0.005996704, 0.0124053955, -0.004386902, -0.019302368, -0.0057144165, 0.017044067, -0.06689453, 0.018798828, -0.060455322, -0.002199173, 0.0057258606, 0.019836426, 0.000101566315, -0.019927979, 0.041534424, 0.037475586, 0.029876709, -0.018127441, 0.00054216385, 0.016845703, 0.025222778, -0.04574585, -0.01109314, 0.025604248, -0.008285522, -0.028167725, -0.031677246, -0.03201294, 0.0027580261, -0.009025574, 0.030822754, 0.042999268, -0.020141602, 0.025848389, 0.0015974045, -0.046081543, -0.0020008087, -0.008560181, -0.025787354, -0.0007853508, -0.024993896, -0.06121826, -0.0037574768, 0.021530151, 0.03186035, 0.03717041, 0.0010881424, 0.009231567, 0.030960083, -0.045898438, 0.028060913, 0.019348145, 0.0025043488, 0.047668457, 0.026794434, 0.02305603, 0.07672119, -0.013626099, 0.023239136, 0.004878998, -0.009925842, 0.056884766, -0.013793945, 0.0096206665, -0.058746338, 0.008056641, -0.015007019, 0.04446411, -0.04522705, -0.068237305, 0.010635376, -0.022003174, 0.009475708, 0.029327393, -0.0050239563, -0.04119873, 0.026107788, -0.0035171509, -0.020462036, -0.021881104, -0.02885437, -0.015304565, 0.0071258545, 0.07232666, 0.026153564, 0.0042419434, 0.006576538, -0.009414673, 0.016448975, 0.0077552795, 0.020950317, -0.02848816, -0.010482788, 0.009475708, 0.021316528, 0.00070858, -0.015586853, -0.002735138, -0.01878357, -0.018234253, 0.020874023, -0.016952515, 0.03363037, 0.052947998, 0.03366089, -0.013839722, -0.015777588, -0.024505615, -0.042999268, 0.047546387, -0.021575928, -0.033996582, -0.05343628, -0.041107178, -0.028182983, 0.015823364, -0.024154663, 0.017105103, 0.051086426, 0.00223732, 0.02178955, -0.03527832, 0.0011816025, -0.021987915, 0.04776001, 0.030410767, 0.0044288635, -0.016921997, 0.014968872, -0.00092601776, 0.021255493, 0.019058228, 0.044647217, -0.011978149, 0.021499634, -0.014175415, -0.01473999, -0.013595581, -0.08081055, 0.0071983337, -0.041046143, 0.03845215, 0.0027656555, 0.045196533, 0.054107666, 0.002614975, 0.07293701, -0.049957275, 0.018432617, 0.037841797, -0.052825928, 0.059265137, -0.00028014183, 0.028213501, -0.009841919, -0.022994995, -0.019882202, 0.056030273, 0.01360321, 0.03265381, -0.060058594, -0.046295166, 0.033355713, 0.012084961, -0.011802673, 0.0030670166, -0.050354004, -0.055236816, -0.013832092, 0.016693115, -0.018295288, -0.03363037, -0.014915466, 0.018585205, -0.04928589, -0.00983429, 0.017288208, -0.029754639, 0.009727478, 0.028396606, -0.057281494, 0.045959473, 0.043914795, -0.013648987, 0.046295166, 0.015174866, -0.037200928, 0.030975342, -0.060638428, 0.013328552, 0.064819336, 0.02607727, -0.031051636, 0.0140686035, 0.048828125, -0.03503418, 0.030410767, -0.018814087, -0.02357483, -0.05340576, -0.003627777, -0.011413574, -0.017700195, -0.024398804, 0.013977051, -0.039978027, 0.008781433, -0.019210815, 0.020080566, -0.040252686, -0.016052246, 0.00459671, -0.040771484, -0.018981934, 0.021484375, 0.033966064, -0.026351929, 0.035614014, 0.00089883804, -0.031799316, 0.022384644, -0.051483154, -0.027664185, 0.013931274, -0.021514893, -0.082458496, -0.01763916, -0.031951904, 0.012672424, -0.007896423, 0.036621094, -0.011924744, 0.007156372, -0.056762695, -0.018432617, -0.017837524, 0.0423584, -0.008956909, 0.015914917, 0.04711914, 0.008705139, 0.03643799, 0.050750732, 0.018569946, 0.007698059, 0.015899658, -0.004535675, -0.010650635, -0.05871582, -0.0134887695, -0.0048675537, 0.00088739395, 0.008934021, -0.018661499, 0.038757324, 0.0126571655, -0.02128601, 0.0037326813, -0.0015878677, 0.0070877075, -0.011154175, -0.011894226, -0.017745972, 0.01966858, 0.01084137, -0.036193848, -0.0030574799, 0.009811401, 0.054840088, -0.024169922, -0.04144287, -0.011199951, 0.0057144165, 0.038024902, 0.054840088, 0.020385742, -0.046569824, -0.039855957, -0.032836914, 0.06665039, -0.028533936, -0.012390137, -0.06604004, 0.0037345886, -0.016571045, -0.014701843, -0.023620605, -0.00025558472, -0.014640808, -0.0013904572, 0.021484375, 0.003189087, 0.013664246, 0.0236969, 0.010292053, 0.005252838, 0.03866577, -0.006034851, -0.008483887, 0.03604126, 0.04296875, -0.066223145, 0.025604248, 0.035095215, 0.008430481, -0.0014429092, -0.022964478, 0.012214661, 0.06591797, 0.03274536, 0.03253174, -0.020996094, 0.05569458, 0.026611328, 0.022476196, -0.00969696, -0.061676025, 0.0012388229, 0.0029907227, -0.0035266876, -0.007572174, -0.04776001, 0.019363403, -0.015853882, -0.017578125, 0.00806427, 0.03967285, -0.024383545, -0.02458191, 0.012878418, 0.04046631, 0.02482605, 0.00667572 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2112.00646v2
Reliability Assessment and Safety Arguments for Machine Learning Components in System Assurance
Yi Dong, Wei Huang, Vibhav Bharti, Victoria Cox, Alec Banks, Sen Wang, Xingyu Zhao, Sven Schewe, Xiaowei Huang
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO
The increasing use of Machine Learning (ML) components embedded in autonomous systems -- so-called Learning-Enabled Systems (LESs) -- has resulted in the pressing need to assure their functional safety. As for traditional functional safety, the emerging consensus within both, industry and academia, is to use assurance cases for this purpose. Typically assurance cases support claims of reliability in support of safety, and can be viewed as a structured way of organising arguments and evidence generated from safety analysis and reliability modelling activities. While such assurance activities are traditionally guided by consensus-based standards developed from vast engineering experience, LESs pose new challenges in safety-critical application due to the characteristics and design of ML models. In this article, we first present an overall assurance framework for LESs with an emphasis on quantitative aspects, e.g., breaking down system-level safety targets to component-level requirements and supporting claims stated in reliability metrics. We then introduce a novel model-agnostic Reliability Assessment Model (RAM) for ML classifiers that utilises the operational profile and robustness verification evidence. We discuss the model assumptions and the inherent challenges of assessing ML reliability uncovered by our RAM and propose solutions to practical use. Probabilistic safety argument templates at the lower ML component-level are also developed based on the RAM. Finally, to evaluate and demonstrate our methods, we not only conduct experiments on synthetic/benchmark datasets but also scope our methods with case studies on simulated Autonomous Underwater Vehicles and physical Unmanned Ground Vehicles.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2112.00646v2
"2022-10-14T15:01:18"
"2021-11-30T14:39:22"
{ "title": [ -0.011367798, -0.0009508133, -0.03668213, -0.05380249, -0.00013530254, -0.023910522, 0.0050621033, 0.00052404404, -0.049224854, 0.016464233, -0.03491211, 0.007858276, -0.021087646, -0.038269043, 0.004562378, -0.026275635, -0.0017681122, 0.00806427, -0.02519226, -0.034820557, -0.0041389465, -0.033203125, 0.040649414, 0.035491943, 0.04498291, -0.021240234, -0.07745361, 0.01574707, -0.02720642, -0.042907715, -0.008010864, 0.016098022, 0.024887085, 0.0065841675, -0.008224487, 0.005634308, -0.02154541, 0.021255493, 0.008377075, 0.009796143, 0.008636475, 0.004501343, 0.058288574, -0.037017822, 0.0050354004, 0.03567505, -0.07348633, -0.053100586, -0.0154953, 0.03186035, 0.029693604, 0.02406311, 0.019088745, 0.05532837, 0.01512146, -0.019607544, -0.046203613, -0.026412964, 0.04031372, 0.0814209, 0.031799316, -0.039855957, 0.010246277, -0.026977539, -0.026046753, -0.04421997, -0.0048980713, 0.02468872, 0.050048828, -0.0040016174, 0.013031006, 0.034484863, 0.013793945, 0.022384644, -0.041656494, -0.031585693, 0.06500244, 0.01864624, 0.024871826, -0.023239136, 0.004009247, 0.010673523, 0.012252808, -0.0063667297, 0.009811401, -0.011230469, -0.002067566, -0.016921997, -0.034423828, -0.054748535, -0.007633209, -0.00007802248, -0.015640259, -0.008300781, -0.016036987, -0.042907715, -0.0021514893, 0.023483276, 0.006362915, -0.016860962, -0.03201294, 0.015579224, -0.051239014, -0.017593384, 0.017150879, 0.06781006, 0.017440796, -0.026870728, -0.025466919, -0.0017738342, -0.015792847, -0.016555786, -0.007293701, -0.049957275, 0.020095825, 0.039886475, 0.009292603, 0.012680054, 0.042175293, 0.004611969, -0.01210022, -0.020614624, -0.016845703, 0.03201294, 0.017578125, -0.011878967, -0.028839111, 0.015991211, -0.017684937, 0.042785645, 0.00856781, 0.033233643, -0.10845947, -0.091552734, -0.059814453, 0.025390625, -0.012466431, -0.0050697327, -0.008804321, 0.002943039, 0.034118652, -0.022506714, 0.017059326, 0.036376953, 0.008483887, 0.011482239, 0.05633545, 0.01033783, -0.055999756, -0.04827881, -0.009178162, 0.020446777, -0.0068626404, 0.019927979, -0.025421143, 0.006641388, -0.111450195, -0.0023078918, 0.06173706, 0.018814087, 0.027297974, 0.0073928833, -0.013450623, 0.028060913, 0.05731201, -0.0075645447, 0.015075684, 0.017044067, 0.0031204224, 0.033294678, -0.0028915405, -0.021133423, -0.0019464493, -0.0017137527, -0.007789612, 0.023986816, 0.012809753, 0.034118652, 0.021118164, -0.010757446, 0.008506775, -0.018600464, 0.039001465, 0.0236969, -0.06750488, -0.03729248, 0.010231018, 0.010879517, 0.06774902, 0.0060539246, -0.012039185, 0.0025539398, -0.050567627, -0.027679443, -0.042907715, -0.010185242, 0.027450562, 0.037261963, -0.01864624, 0.03289795, -0.02507019, 0.0045394897, -0.030029297, 0.00056028366, -0.008590698, -0.05154419, 0.0015611649, 0.008972168, -0.04135132, 0.08013916, 0.045684814, -0.00060510635, -0.035583496, 0.01499176, 0.032714844, -0.059051514, 0.004989624, -0.03866577, -0.010177612, -0.039031982, -0.018951416, 0.011375427, -0.010612488, 0.031143188, 0.0020942688, 0.017791748, -0.020553589, -0.01789856, 0.050750732, 0.0071868896, 0.10998535, -0.032836914, 0.045288086, 0.033843994, 0.005584717, -0.025909424, -0.016571045, -0.049713135, 0.0093307495, 0.0345459, 0.01197052, -0.0036182404, 0.015319824, 0.021011353, 0.030380249, -0.02760315, 0.0060539246, -0.001906395, -0.010887146, 0.011253357, 0.08251953, 0.03668213, 0.04336548, 0.05532837, -0.0045318604, 0.049591064, 0.0013628006, 0.02041626, -0.027404785, 0.016036987, -0.0062332153, 0.013137817, 0.012397766, 0.0019416809, -0.026306152, 0.018600464, -0.012191772, 0.027542114, -0.0041275024, 0.025466919, 0.018600464, -0.042633057, -0.004043579, 0.036132812, -0.018920898, 0.005054474, -0.017730713, 0.02532959, -0.0036754608, -0.023788452, 0.0002439022, -0.0016031265, 0.050842285, 0.0035648346, 0.023513794, -0.010070801, 0.026672363, -0.014778137, -0.025054932, -0.024856567, 0.06451416, 0.00869751, -0.0006093979, -0.0050239563, 0.00086402893, -0.020263672, 0.04019165, 0.08630371, -0.033416748, 0.010314941, -0.07598877, -0.0034732819, -0.006008148, -0.017410278, -0.0008845329, 0.051757812, 0.029205322, -0.0004246235, -0.03652954, 0.013641357, -0.060546875, -0.019866943, 0.020858765, -0.025360107, -0.0061454773, -0.016967773, -0.011749268, -0.017181396, -0.018249512, 0.0024356842, 0.07330322, -0.00056266785, -0.015457153, -0.006702423, 0.004722595, -0.039489746, -0.013648987, -0.023254395, -0.047454834, 0.030944824, 0.026229858, 0.0077400208, -0.056427002, -0.0047035217, 0.00045394897, 0.047332764, -0.021057129, 0.032073975, -0.028457642, -0.027160645, -0.024963379, -0.017791748, 0.0018453598, -0.03945923, -0.03302002, -0.049621582, -0.019088745, 0.008560181, -0.0099487305, -0.040863037, 0.070007324, -0.01727295, -0.022247314, 0.0012044907, 0.037994385, -0.048919678, -0.01096344, 0.030319214, 0.016815186, -0.008796692, 0.022125244, 0.038970947, 0.0033130646, -0.0619812, -0.015144348, -0.074157715, -0.011207581, -0.0050811768, -0.022872925, 0.015975952, -0.023162842, -0.02545166, -0.06323242, -0.011940002, -0.008972168, 0.029953003, -0.010902405, -0.026245117, -0.0018262863, -0.018951416, 0.00016510487, 0.0031547546, -0.028030396, -0.0068969727, 0.06573486, 0.0015249252, -0.03024292, 0.00894165, 0.013801575, 0.002796173, -0.014183044, -0.0101623535, -0.012031555, -0.0014314651, 0.011268616, -0.0018796921, -0.023773193, -0.0030574799, -0.09710693, 0.0028438568, 0.0124053955, 0.002708435, -0.019165039, 0.008140564, -0.05682373, -0.005908966, -0.012992859, -0.014457703, 0.014175415, 0.009719849, -0.004005432, 0.014518738, 0.0023326874, -0.029006958, 0.028915405, -0.072143555, -0.08959961, 0.02798462, -0.028808594, -0.006160736, -0.00072956085, -0.016586304, -0.033599854, -0.009437561, -0.0071105957, 0.030456543, 0.06536865, 0.017242432, 0.03677368, 0.0020923615, 0.026290894, -0.028671265, 0.0042152405, -0.00617218, -0.03829956, 0.01638794, -0.005138397, 0.05038452, 0.030197144, -0.00818634, -0.035583496, 0.013282776, 0.01751709, 0.041229248, 0.015945435, -0.047546387, 0.00010341406, -0.037353516, 0.002040863, -0.00080776215, 0.0021457672, 0.001499176, -0.007080078, -0.0035037994, -0.011177063, 0.02116394, 0.015716553, 0.024414062, -0.038238525, -0.0036640167, 0.03656006, -0.007637024, -0.05871582, 0.0010328293, 0.0064926147, -0.015823364, 0.02810669, 0.0009274483, -0.015914917, 0.015808105, -0.007987976, 0.025558472, 0.0029792786, -0.00089359283, -0.017318726, 0.03591919, -0.010978699, -0.0035629272, -0.0026779175, 0.020812988, -0.016830444, 0.008842468, -0.043518066, -0.06781006, -0.004070282, 0.0135650635, -0.09899902, -0.016647339, 0.015701294, -0.035308838, -0.037139893, -0.043029785, 0.021881104, -0.035827637, -0.014160156, 0.015129089, -0.028076172, -0.012039185, -0.0124435425, -0.077941895, -0.0067329407, 0.061340332, 0.008674622, 0.024902344, 0.03491211, 0.02255249, -0.012718201, -0.032989502, 0.00024676323, -0.027389526, 0.013183594, -0.03491211, 0.008766174, 0.047851562, -0.032348633, 0.04525757, -0.011451721, 0.038146973, -0.023773193, -0.00056266785, 0.040618896, 0.040222168, -0.063964844, 0.040161133, 0.058624268, -0.021133423, -0.10687256, 0.008399963, -0.016448975, -0.053222656, 0.02607727, 0.013839722, 0.014564514, 0.034820557, 0.02003479, 0.07800293, 0.0124435425, 0.011924744, -0.006717682, -0.047027588, -0.026321411, 0.002500534, 0.02935791, -0.023513794, -0.012031555, 0.026733398, -0.0362854, 0.046569824, -0.012359619, -0.021636963, 0.011856079, 0.02432251, -0.005077362, -0.030395508, -0.07305908, -0.0049362183, 0.016601562, -0.0058059692, -0.024276733, 0.013542175, 0.040893555, -0.017654419, -0.041625977, 0.023971558, 0.015060425, -0.0026302338, -0.017181396, -0.08068848, 0.02267456, -0.017303467, -0.05596924, -0.03543091, 0.00066804886, 0.016448975, 0.026290894, -0.011154175, -0.035247803, 0.0073547363, 0.021392822, 0.058898926, 0.02748108, 0.0066223145, -0.015060425, 0.02519226, -0.019058228, -0.016311646, 0.02079773, 0.005809784, 0.00091838837, -0.036956787, 0.012199402, -0.02015686, -0.0039749146, -0.008529663, 0.020599365, -0.02961731, 0.05105591, -0.023071289, 0.024810791, 0.025100708, -0.002691269, 0.030578613, 0.008865356, -0.025222778, -0.0059394836, 0.060577393, 0.059906006, -0.013519287, 0.045959473, 0.035095215, -0.00080919266, 0.010025024, -0.029342651, 0.04647827, -0.010688782, -0.04083252, -0.03086853, 0.054534912, -0.022415161, -0.025634766, -0.0074920654, 0.007335663, 0.030899048, -0.080322266, 0.043304443, -0.04272461, -0.024002075, -0.004573822, 0.01184845, 0.015609741, -0.0056648254, 0.025558472, -0.06616211, -0.051483154, -0.031829834, 0.04525757, -0.038238525, -0.034942627, 0.004016876, 0.0149002075, 0.01586914, 0.02432251, -0.004261017, 0.025390625, -0.02671814, -0.0021629333, 0.00013756752, -0.036315918, -0.058929443, 0.009483337, -0.023513794, 0.02217102, 0.00005966425, 0.00617218, -0.06384277, 0.000172019, 0.0119018555, -0.002483368, -0.0045700073, -0.08093262, 0.008728027, 0.017807007, -0.007472992, 0.007282257, -0.045776367, 0.00058221817, 0.061157227, 0.024169922, 0.0035743713, 0.0043525696, 0.028839111, -0.0056037903, -0.008216858, -0.0023784637, 0.037628174, -0.0126953125, 0.021087646, 0.030441284, -0.008239746, -0.06854248, 0.02204895, 0.020492554, -0.0007362366, 0.020065308, -0.057037354, 0.029022217, -0.033599854, 0.00021481514, 0.013076782, -0.033416748, -0.044189453, 0.004852295, -0.02268982, -0.005542755, 0.00036978722, -0.00137043, -0.027420044, -0.028625488, 0.015182495, -0.016174316, -0.008560181, 0.010070801, 0.028259277, -0.019302368, 0.016983032, 0.040893555, -0.032104492, -0.0009317398, -0.03503418, 0.009857178, 0.03515625, 0.027267456, -0.09307861, -0.025817871, 0.017105103, -0.07281494, -0.07861328, -0.012382507, 0.013664246, -0.016021729, -0.02494812, -0.012718201, -0.02027893, -0.028121948, 0.00071287155, 0.018234253, -0.049621582, 0.0236969, -0.00088882446, -0.010253906, 0.015281677, 0.026535034, 0.021835327, 0.003145218, -0.015449524, -0.016464233, 0.02709961, -0.012886047, -0.01737976, 0.0044937134, -0.016174316, -0.0035381317, 0.021713257, -0.0030956268, -0.03567505, 0.00011497736, 0.03326416, -0.049865723, 0.02178955, 0.0099487305, 0.10522461, -0.06201172, -0.042144775, -0.028533936, 0.0047454834, -0.014602661, 0.075683594, -0.03024292, -0.05117798, -0.04019165, -0.05014038, -0.031341553, 0.014038086, 0.026611328, 0.0054359436, 0.035339355, -0.03829956, 0.014640808, -0.026016235, -0.026733398, -0.04333496, 0.013252258, -0.0032157898, 0.0064430237, 0.036743164, -0.020309448, -0.010864258, -0.028320312, 0.028259277, 0.034301758, 0.004096985, 0.010734558, -0.043395996, -0.006385803, -0.010002136, -0.0057411194, 0.018081665, 0.019989014, -0.030136108, 0.002166748, -0.040802002, 0.057647705, 0.011260986, 0.00030994415, 0.03781128, 0.03149414, 0.010681152, -0.01335907, -0.0016469955, -0.013328552, 0.02911377, -0.053863525, -0.0022411346, -0.06365967, -0.021377563, -0.097229004, 0.012207031, 0.014373779, 0.0075569153, 0.0069274902, -0.005065918, 0.029708862, 0.005115509, 0.020568848, -0.030914307, 0.037109375, 0.011764526, -0.016799927, 0.010269165, 0.05392456, 0.00018501282, 0.017364502, 0.027282715, 0.029663086, -0.0025672913, -0.01991272, 0.009361267, 0.0140686035, 0.012641907, -0.02229309, 0.0016851425, -0.030441284, 0.047302246, 0.0010938644, 0.02218628, 0.05114746, 0.035461426, 0.0047454834, -0.02708435, 0.0047035217, -0.0016746521, -0.012794495, 0.010009766, 0.048858643, -0.0748291, 0.030258179, -0.0023345947, -0.021011353, 0.010108948, 0.05456543, 0.020858765, -0.032836914, 0.008003235, 0.026535034, 0.029647827, -0.0009870529, 0.011428833, -0.034057617, -0.005622864, 0.022918701, 0.012107849, -0.020477295, -0.010719299, 0.032470703, 0.043640137, -0.0050315857, -0.0057373047, 0.0011959076, 0.037506104, -0.026947021, 0.030090332, -0.043701172, 0.0038585663, -0.037109375, -0.039093018, -0.020004272, 0.010604858, -0.040283203, -0.03869629, 0.03149414, 0.007736206, 0.023529053, 0.038879395, 0.005130768, -0.029556274, 0.010360718, -0.041381836, 0.028793335, 0.01991272, -0.032073975, 0.026016235, -0.014091492, -0.028198242, 0.061279297, -0.0051994324, 0.101623535, -0.02128601, 0.009552002, -0.046691895, 0.024215698, 0.0017137527, -0.06262207, 0.022460938, -0.04699707, 0.017364502, -0.021606445, -0.004688263, -0.040618896, -0.048736572, 0.0007162094, 0.05630493, 0.0022029877, 0.011802673, 0.026367188, -0.047332764, -0.04776001, 0.032165527, -0.016281128, 0.047851562, -0.02684021, -0.0026130676, 0.0032920837, 0.016418457, -0.014129639, -0.038482666, -0.031707764, -0.0050697327, 0.017089844, -0.03842163, 0.03173828, 0.03463745, -0.011253357, 0.0028018951, 0.02758789, -0.008483887, -0.010215759, 0.004383087, 0.040527344, -0.027359009, -0.018753052, 0.003036499, -0.032226562, 0.03253174, 0.0037231445, -0.006160736, 0.01776123, 0.006942749, 0.014472961, -0.035247803, 0.02798462, 0.033843994, -0.0031833649, -0.044952393, -0.009216309, 0.027862549, 0.053863525, -0.029418945, -0.06222534, 0.017700195, -0.0013875961, -0.029190063, 0.03945923, 0.015617371, -0.0029735565, 0.01171875, 0.047607422, 0.00097608566, -0.038238525, -0.061706543, -0.012710571, 0.07739258, 0.060791016, -0.037750244, 0.0029067993, 0.03640747, -0.00982666, 0.015060425, -0.00111866, -0.019714355, -0.0015287399, -0.016082764, 0.01689148, 0.011436462, -0.024169922, -0.012008667, 0.005809784, 0.0013484955, 0.025146484, -0.0007548332, 0.012199402, -0.0069503784, 0.06762695, 0.03225708, -0.030410767, 0.0418396, 0.024154663, 0.052612305, 0.03717041, -0.0184021, -0.06536865, -0.03237915, 0.013000488, 0.014572144, 0.015159607, 0.016860962, -0.03778076, 0.019134521, -0.048187256, -0.05847168, -0.0064811707, -0.04840088, 0.03781128, -0.03479004, 0.013214111, -0.017730713, 0.0085372925, 0.009605408, 0.029159546, 0.038391113, 0.0038089752, -0.05996704, -0.015563965, 0.043945312, -0.0362854 ], "summary": [ 0.012687683, -0.018356323, -0.029525757, -0.014251709, -0.012565613, -0.036865234, 0.0058670044, -0.0055122375, -0.05697632, 0.0011310577, -0.029769897, 0.025939941, -0.02999878, -0.015319824, 0.04031372, -0.050048828, -0.011489868, -0.011665344, -0.022079468, -0.04852295, 0.012168884, -0.0552063, 0.013938904, -0.0078125, 0.049438477, -0.029022217, -0.07055664, 0.037506104, 0.023956299, 0.022521973, 0.010696411, -0.0079422, -0.0038433075, 0.01763916, 0.0104599, -0.018539429, 0.016036987, -0.0005888939, 0.012786865, 0.029190063, 0.046966553, -0.035461426, 0.10852051, -0.044189453, 0.029251099, 0.0637207, 0.003993988, -0.043426514, 0.026428223, 0.024597168, 0.011383057, 0.031463623, -0.0152282715, 0.01979065, -0.026855469, -0.0015115738, -0.054534912, -0.032073975, -0.0008735657, 0.09887695, 0.061401367, 0.00021862984, -0.02607727, -0.03451538, 0.005756378, -0.011390686, 0.012756348, 0.00076150894, 0.055603027, 0.045074463, 0.0061798096, 0.016296387, 0.025512695, -0.012290955, -0.011276245, -0.025390625, 0.059692383, 0.002746582, -0.027572632, -0.014907837, 0.022964478, -0.0027313232, -0.03186035, -0.0013437271, -0.0154953, -0.0065460205, 0.005558014, -0.016555786, 0.0037574768, -0.00047135353, -0.015899658, 0.025970459, -0.011184692, 0.016403198, 0.0042686462, -0.019378662, 0.0034370422, -0.04373169, 0.03265381, -0.005004883, 0.031341553, -0.046813965, 0.030731201, -0.0044288635, -0.004398346, 0.09020996, 0.058929443, -0.041290283, -0.03567505, -0.040802002, -0.023391724, 0.012832642, -0.012374878, -0.07977295, 0.029464722, 0.0692749, 0.0009899139, 0.03463745, 0.015617371, 0.0066108704, -0.028427124, -0.0043144226, -0.003955841, 0.04714966, 0.0017709732, 0.012939453, 0.0061912537, -0.028823853, 0.020507812, 0.025924683, 0.0036182404, 0.031829834, -0.06738281, -0.073913574, -0.070495605, -0.009498596, 0.009773254, 0.004497528, 0.013031006, -0.031066895, 0.0418396, 0.0048179626, 0.007205963, 0.03866577, -0.0061302185, 0.05126953, 0.03414917, 0.008682251, -0.041778564, -0.06842041, 0.032104492, -0.025985718, 0.028930664, -0.021499634, -0.033203125, -0.05380249, -0.0793457, 0.0034427643, 0.031143188, -0.011604309, 0.017471313, 0.024230957, 0.027542114, 0.032684326, 0.014862061, -0.04650879, -0.010093689, -0.015792847, 0.0029525757, -0.0067977905, 0.028884888, -0.043914795, -0.05480957, -0.004180908, 0.00080251694, 0.0090789795, -0.006175995, 0.06427002, 0.0027599335, -0.017745972, 0.0058174133, -0.029251099, 0.061157227, -0.010009766, -0.011260986, -0.046966553, 0.0027923584, 0.017807007, 0.05090332, 0.026138306, -0.017791748, -0.039031982, -0.030731201, -0.0005259514, -0.013763428, -0.021316528, -0.015838623, 0.01096344, -0.021728516, 0.0116119385, 0.022750854, 0.0045814514, -0.023361206, -0.042388916, -0.089416504, -0.02168274, -0.016403198, 0.025405884, -0.046936035, 0.06323242, 0.054840088, 0.0070228577, -0.0569458, 0.061828613, 0.053466797, -0.062194824, 0.022384644, -0.046875, -0.0029640198, -0.026916504, 0.015960693, 0.025482178, -0.031707764, 0.018188477, -0.036254883, -0.007160187, -0.034088135, -0.001206398, 0.0423584, -0.017166138, 0.119384766, -0.02432251, 0.014053345, 0.030044556, 0.003572464, -0.023864746, -0.042297363, -0.103515625, 0.011909485, 0.070739746, 0.022109985, 0.032043457, -0.008155823, 0.03213501, -0.0039405823, -0.02810669, 0.015045166, 0.013542175, -0.06732178, -0.042877197, 0.062072754, 0.00970459, 0.031158447, 0.06878662, -0.018936157, 0.012565613, -0.021575928, 0.003622055, -0.028579712, 0.02545166, 0.005718231, -0.018585205, -0.003868103, -0.00944519, -0.014801025, -0.054779053, 0.0016803741, 0.01158905, 0.01852417, -0.0546875, 0.020019531, -0.0054244995, 0.0032730103, 0.0141067505, -0.04324341, -0.005332947, -0.024124146, 0.029220581, -0.010673523, -0.018051147, -0.024032593, -0.05810547, 0.014389038, 0.0027103424, 0.058044434, -0.011398315, 0.02798462, -0.015312195, -0.015571594, 0.0043945312, 0.046020508, -0.0059127808, -0.027053833, 0.0093688965, -0.025756836, -0.035247803, -0.023956299, 0.038726807, -0.0073928833, -0.009597778, -0.007247925, 0.026412964, -0.025543213, -0.0015802383, -0.008399963, 0.046691895, 0.032592773, -0.022277832, -0.020599365, -0.00497818, -0.040039062, -0.016433716, 0.024108887, 0.041290283, -0.007785797, -0.0181427, 0.020965576, 0.044525146, 0.045288086, 0.033355713, 0.12573242, 0.050720215, 0.029632568, 0.024658203, 0.023513794, -0.08996582, 0.05429077, -0.023803711, -0.053710938, 0.008453369, -0.021987915, -0.018447876, -0.029403687, 0.066833496, 0.00223732, 0.035888672, -0.0020828247, 0.045043945, -0.007774353, -0.037078857, 0.020553589, -0.04321289, -0.014549255, 0.025161743, -0.073791504, 0.0158844, -0.0032043457, -0.004169464, 0.03375244, -0.02748108, 0.036346436, -0.02178955, -0.026916504, 0.022659302, 0.019851685, -0.048187256, 0.0027828217, 0.024490356, -0.02003479, -0.035461426, -0.006717682, 0.045776367, -0.0043640137, -0.031829834, -0.030792236, -0.0317688, 0.026016235, -0.006427765, -0.005455017, -0.0006418228, 0.036712646, 0.013137817, -0.10650635, -0.025909424, -0.045135498, 0.021713257, 0.038635254, -0.009170532, 0.013160706, 0.018859863, -0.0027580261, 0.011306763, -0.022125244, -0.017974854, 0.0423584, 0.002954483, -0.0044288635, 0.042907715, 0.032287598, -0.0023288727, 0.008918762, 0.003868103, 0.015563965, -0.044189453, 0.023208618, 0.0009675026, -0.018325806, 0.019973755, -0.020614624, -0.02645874, 0.039001465, 0.023880005, 0.020309448, -0.016494751, -0.013061523, -0.02142334, 0.004611969, -0.001004219, 0.0015449524, -0.032165527, 0.016677856, -0.0032215118, 0.01285553, -0.04550171, 0.016036987, -0.059814453, -0.024536133, 0.014450073, -0.05810547, 0.0027637482, 0.0052337646, 0.04736328, -0.015838623, -0.0121154785, 0.0050239563, 0.02758789, 0.021759033, 0.012016296, 0.0022830963, 0.001531601, 0.017059326, -0.026870728, 0.009735107, 0.0074310303, -0.06793213, 0.016189575, 0.0006284714, 0.007598877, 0.05319214, -0.044281006, -0.008468628, 0.0046157837, 0.036956787, 0.0067100525, 0.039520264, -0.028564453, 0.018554688, 0.0131073, 0.00055503845, -0.011291504, -0.008995056, 0.0038642883, 0.015205383, 0.029281616, -0.010246277, 0.071899414, 0.004295349, 0.033447266, 0.016342163, -0.036712646, 0.0024909973, -0.002090454, -0.045135498, -0.006149292, -0.00289917, 0.021591187, -0.02279663, 0.023956299, 0.006504059, -0.010520935, 0.006664276, 0.0075263977, -0.018203735, -0.005180359, -0.021087646, 0.03274536, 0.029449463, -0.03253174, 0.06744385, 0.023040771, -0.027069092, 0.007511139, -0.019439697, -0.010246277, -0.010910034, 0.011306763, -0.046173096, -0.009880066, 0.019073486, -0.0039100647, -0.027023315, -0.041625977, 0.04257202, -0.013252258, 0.00756073, 0.02709961, -0.015296936, 0.019073486, 0.014328003, -0.078430176, 0.04244995, 0.023406982, 0.01524353, 0.018585205, -0.00017023087, 0.053497314, 0.009277344, -0.0020656586, -0.014091492, -0.06201172, -0.0075416565, -0.05831909, 0.033935547, 0.03427124, -0.015235901, 0.050323486, -0.011520386, 0.021026611, -0.010856628, 0.004722595, 0.055725098, 0.045806885, -0.023803711, 0.013977051, 0.032165527, -0.006629944, -0.06213379, 0.0029563904, -0.015327454, -0.056610107, 0.015220642, 0.02796936, -0.023590088, 0.03616333, 0.029434204, 0.020263672, -0.008270264, 0.0060806274, -0.014854431, -0.024459839, -0.023086548, -0.017745972, 0.032348633, -0.0011377335, -0.01474762, 0.03579712, -0.020812988, 0.03186035, -0.01184845, -0.035308838, 0.016326904, 0.016067505, 0.023895264, -0.013504028, -0.0017595291, 0.044036865, 0.013198853, -0.03475952, 0.0036144257, 0.057403564, -0.0059318542, -0.020080566, 0.013587952, 0.0030002594, 0.061553955, 0.039276123, -0.037628174, -0.085510254, 0.009635925, -0.017364502, -0.029144287, -0.021087646, -0.033233643, -0.018371582, -0.0031814575, 0.013763428, -0.011474609, 0.015220642, 0.0015087128, 0.008407593, 0.014320374, 0.020858765, -0.0046844482, 0.018920898, 0.007511139, 0.007762909, 0.01713562, 0.0042533875, 0.015342712, 0.00043296814, -0.010681152, -0.016967773, -0.015274048, -0.013404846, -0.021087646, -0.011711121, 0.008323669, 0.031433105, 0.057769775, 0.0032291412, 0.0013341904, 0.027450562, 0.0055160522, -0.004108429, 0.032318115, 0.031433105, 0.03945923, 0.014251709, 0.04916382, 0.020370483, -0.032806396, -0.011306763, -0.015914917, 0.042755127, -0.02571106, -0.05444336, -0.027282715, 0.053497314, 0.033966064, 0.0056991577, 0.016693115, 0.003332138, -0.010650635, -0.033935547, 0.044799805, -0.0064468384, -0.027633667, 0.019882202, 0.002445221, -0.006702423, -0.0074005127, -0.012863159, -0.04623413, -0.06896973, -0.042419434, 0.08862305, -0.010444641, -0.06970215, -0.012626648, 0.05432129, 0.014755249, 0.0043258667, -0.046813965, 0.021652222, -0.057495117, -0.0027770996, -0.020324707, -0.054992676, -0.032562256, 0.0047950745, -0.028244019, 0.025375366, 0.027633667, -0.0057373047, -0.0035820007, 0.03817749, 0.031463623, 0.016967773, -0.016677856, -0.039916992, -0.01979065, -0.013961792, -0.027709961, -0.01638794, -0.021591187, -0.016540527, 0.009185791, -0.0047950745, -0.006729126, -0.013618469, -0.009819031, -0.034606934, -0.04144287, -0.0068969727, 0.006099701, 0.008285522, 0.018966675, 0.024978638, -0.030761719, -0.033172607, -0.014816284, -0.035339355, 0.017700195, -0.030731201, -0.0037193298, 0.01966858, -0.008804321, 0.02331543, -0.00067567825, 0.03024292, -0.025756836, -0.0013275146, 0.022491455, 0.0023899078, -0.036376953, 0.0028057098, 0.00043320656, -0.010040283, -0.028182983, -0.018707275, 0.04208374, 0.01966858, 0.0071907043, -0.00086402893, -0.02444458, 0.02633667, 0.037597656, -0.00919342, -0.0070762634, 0.00248909, -0.017211914, 0.015129089, -0.0793457, -0.010345459, -0.009628296, -0.032562256, -0.083618164, -0.050689697, -0.0027217865, 0.043518066, -0.018218994, 0.0016298294, 0.0071868896, -0.052856445, -0.011795044, 0.021621704, -0.026672363, 0.022003174, -0.016403198, -0.027893066, 0.027252197, -0.0390625, 0.018127441, 0.0020713806, -0.026626587, -0.009719849, 0.045715332, -0.014709473, -0.018234253, 0.00844574, 0.034851074, -0.01424408, 0.03527832, -0.039245605, -0.02420044, -0.022613525, -0.013687134, -0.041900635, 0.041381836, -0.031677246, 0.04675293, 0.021774292, -0.01272583, -0.027786255, 0.03414917, -0.007167816, 0.038208008, -0.033843994, -0.021270752, -0.021774292, -0.024917603, -0.015701294, -0.014533997, 0.036468506, -0.0005774498, 0.046813965, -0.0141067505, -0.027191162, -0.0026397705, -0.040802002, -0.015975952, -0.00033426285, -0.015823364, -0.017593384, 0.07141113, -0.0098724365, -0.012306213, -0.016906738, 0.017944336, 0.00043439865, 0.00033164024, 0.028701782, 0.016601562, -0.0016031265, -0.014732361, 0.016235352, 0.012275696, 0.03237915, -0.019104004, -0.040771484, 0.020492554, 0.051849365, 0.008796692, -0.082336426, -0.01235199, 0.050323486, 0.010658264, -0.030197144, -0.018981934, 0.01550293, 0.017074585, 0.0022659302, -0.03152466, -0.024002075, -0.03277588, -0.02406311, 0.055023193, -0.0029830933, -0.041870117, 0.03262329, -0.014953613, 0.01586914, 0.015670776, -0.06365967, -0.030593872, -0.034362793, -0.000031530857, -0.011581421, 0.0058250427, 0.005645752, -0.007709503, 0.03137207, 0.0040359497, 0.026687622, 0.03918457, 0.0008544922, 0.04321289, -0.026641846, -0.023254395, -0.08099365, 0.038146973, -0.04159546, 0.04537964, 0.0234375, 0.037719727, 0.0501709, -0.015960693, 0.03112793, -0.04058838, 0.012878418, -0.01727295, 0.009651184, -0.009994507, 0.0028038025, -0.028411865, -0.008033752, 0.004886627, -0.006587982, 0.034210205, 0.07330322, 0.02418518, -0.022857666, 0.08251953, -0.017410278, -0.017150879, -0.06524658, -0.03866577, -0.04473877, -0.021331787, 0.016342163, 0.015106201, -0.028762817, -0.030273438, 0.011985779, 0.014579773, 0.018615723, -0.035308838, 0.005832672, -0.0013151169, -0.012832642, 0.01838684, 0.033172607, -0.017028809, -0.01499939, -0.017715454, 0.009628296, -0.0032806396, 0.010269165, 0.005554199, 0.00020134449, 0.040496826, 0.062805176, 0.034057617, -0.031280518, 0.010665894, 0.07952881, -0.029220581, 0.009468079, -0.04168701, 0.0024318695, 0.00737381, -0.018692017, 0.0126571655, 0.020568848, -0.010681152, 0.046020508, 0.00869751, 0.0073547363, -0.068359375, 0.030288696, -0.06903076, -0.03289795, 0.09112549, -0.07745361, -0.0016851425, 0.025039673, 0.043060303, -0.05380249, -0.006374359, 0.0026283264, -0.01260376, -0.010307312, -0.0016174316, 0.0340271, -0.021774292, -0.039123535, 0.0413208, 0.022857666, 0.06896973, -0.015930176, -0.013061523, 0.04348755, 0.003944397, -0.018829346, -0.05102539, -0.027572632, 0.0048103333, 0.014091492, -0.057403564, 0.018997192, 0.019729614, -0.011764526, 0.038879395, 0.031921387, 0.0063438416, 0.005252838, 0.041992188, 0.021759033, -0.0158844, -0.025177002, 0.015312195, -0.016067505, 0.03326416, -0.01626587, 0.034088135, -0.0042915344, 0.011779785, 0.027740479, -0.04940796, 0.04272461, 0.014411926, 0.022033691, -0.022613525, 0.0044898987, 0.008224487, 0.05267334, -0.01222229, -0.040740967, 0.0015449524, -0.01890564, -0.020477295, -0.02268982, -0.016159058, -0.016220093, 0.05166626, 0.043701172, -0.0042419434, -0.018188477, -0.014373779, -0.011566162, 0.08239746, 0.009101868, -0.055236816, 0.014160156, 0.003124237, -0.013916016, 0.0022029877, -0.013511658, -0.005584717, -0.01713562, -0.014411926, 0.020996094, 0.009963989, -0.017333984, -0.00017988682, -0.0065841675, 0.0036506653, -0.0103302, 0.018661499, 0.001373291, -0.028182983, 0.040924072, 0.024368286, -0.0014801025, -0.00617218, -0.010131836, 0.04510498, -0.0062217712, 0.005695343, -0.042816162, -0.06518555, 0.024978638, 0.045166016, 0.028808594, -0.02671814, -0.011428833, 0.05596924, -0.08154297, -0.016738892, 0.019439697, -0.0036354065, 0.008308411, 0.004650116, 0.006214142, 0.04083252, -0.019104004, 0.02796936, 0.00233078, 0.01927185, 0.028717041, 0.001625061, -0.00894928, -0.016464233, -0.003396988 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2112.02752v1
End-to-end Adaptive Distributed Training on PaddlePaddle
Yulong Ao, Zhihua Wu, Dianhai Yu, Weibao Gong, Zhiqing Kui, Minxu Zhang, Zilingfeng Ye, Liang Shen, Yanjun Ma, Tian Wu, Haifeng Wang, Wei Zeng, Chao Yang
cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.LG
Distributed training has become a pervasive and effective approach for training a large neural network (NN) model with processing massive data. However, it is very challenging to satisfy requirements from various NN models, diverse computing resources, and their dynamic changes during a training job. In this study, we design our distributed training framework in a systematic end-to-end view to provide the built-in adaptive ability for different scenarios, especially for industrial applications and production environments, by fully considering resource allocation, model partition, task placement, and distributed execution. Based on the unified distributed graph and the unified cluster object, our adaptive framework is equipped with a global cost model and a global planner, which can enable arbitrary parallelism, resource-aware placement, multi-mode execution, fault-tolerant, and elastic distributed training. The experiments demonstrate that our framework can satisfy various requirements from the diversity of applications and the heterogeneity of resources with highly competitive performance. The ERNIE language model with 260 billion parameters is efficiently trained on thousands of AI processors with 91.7% weak scalability. The throughput of the model from the recommender system by employing the heterogeneous pipeline asynchronous execution can be increased up to 2.1 times and 3.3 times that of the GPU-only and CPU-only training respectively. Moreover, the fault-tolerant and elastic distributed training have been successfully applied to the online industrial applications, which give a reduction of 34.49% in the number of failed long-term training jobs and an increase of 33.91% for the global scheduling efficiency in the production environment.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2112.02752v1
"2021-12-06T03:00:32"
"2021-12-06T03:00:32"
{ "title": [ -0.037384033, 0.0062065125, -0.034729004, -0.035980225, 0.011314392, 0.0009832382, -0.015525818, -0.015022278, -0.018356323, 0.043395996, -0.0019836426, 0.005077362, 0.008331299, -0.0181427, -0.016235352, 0.017471313, -0.007583618, 0.014144897, -0.024642944, -0.045135498, -0.05126953, -0.047302246, 0.03967285, 0.04522705, 0.012809753, -0.019424438, -0.115478516, 0.0016908646, -0.037719727, -0.03161621, -0.018859863, 0.034973145, 0.046447754, 0.002620697, -0.033081055, -0.030288696, -0.03768921, 0.01222229, -0.040985107, 0.03074646, 0.01889038, -0.0017461777, -0.011154175, -0.008155823, -0.03375244, 0.008850098, -0.050689697, -0.009719849, -0.024810791, 0.06689453, 0.016738892, 0.023391724, -0.0074691772, 0.060516357, 0.02130127, -0.030548096, -0.029556274, -0.030166626, 0.041809082, 0.06518555, 0.00856781, -0.0473938, 0.014320374, -0.03753662, -0.020111084, -0.0016708374, -0.018844604, 0.031219482, 0.07104492, -0.0058517456, -0.051635742, 0.036956787, 0.012283325, 0.003168106, -0.03213501, -0.059539795, 0.07598877, 0.009254456, 0.0063438416, 0.0001835823, -0.005115509, -0.017028809, -0.0001155138, -0.03225708, -0.0043411255, -0.027557373, -0.003622055, 0.0016078949, -0.023849487, -0.06286621, -0.0015439987, -0.027359009, -0.036621094, 0.05557251, -0.005607605, -0.019515991, -0.09008789, -0.025131226, -0.0002206564, 0.011695862, -0.030059814, 0.0146865845, -0.023010254, -0.020629883, 0.0023460388, -0.014503479, -0.022857666, -0.0340271, 0.0012102127, 0.05593872, -0.031021118, 0.005584717, -0.0037822723, 0.0065689087, -0.008804321, -0.039398193, -0.037078857, 0.015434265, 0.003358841, 0.0039367676, 0.0056152344, -0.017822266, 0.024597168, -0.01940918, 0.021347046, -0.023269653, -0.048339844, 0.0052757263, 0.012687683, -0.01687622, -0.0055122375, 0.08203125, -0.09851074, -0.105529785, -0.07373047, 0.050354004, 0.010543823, -0.008216858, 0.0045928955, -0.0021247864, 0.0049591064, -0.015472412, 0.02079773, -0.010955811, -0.010070801, 0.0012207031, 0.053833008, 0.013458252, -0.055114746, -0.03616333, -0.022094727, 0.021255493, 0.016494751, -0.0047035217, -0.008354187, 0.0038967133, -0.055419922, -0.014144897, 0.0056037903, 0.013710022, 0.03189087, 0.01108551, -0.022872925, 0.019699097, 0.04550171, -0.008255005, -0.014907837, 0.023025513, -0.008674622, 0.07904053, -0.02961731, 0.009155273, 0.01083374, -0.010154724, -0.009750366, -0.0023078918, 0.010101318, 0.05996704, 0.03390503, -0.077941895, -0.0062217712, -0.0119018555, 0.06842041, 0.022125244, -0.013923645, -0.047210693, 0.014633179, -0.02507019, 0.018341064, 0.01222229, -0.028900146, 0.02947998, -0.04626465, -0.021774292, -0.035095215, 0.013305664, 0.015640259, 0.03793335, -0.0035858154, 0.013923645, -0.08087158, 0.0025749207, -0.045440674, 0.035614014, -0.029586792, -0.030914307, -0.014823914, 0.027877808, 0.017822266, 0.04434204, 0.023895264, 0.0022888184, -0.017318726, -0.02645874, -0.031219482, -0.03387451, -0.00038862228, -0.007045746, -0.00843811, 0.005455017, -0.0259552, -0.0026550293, -0.019012451, -0.0021591187, 0.014411926, -0.00052785873, -0.013122559, -0.017410278, 0.014122009, 0.026870728, 0.05456543, -0.014404297, 0.021026611, 0.010139465, -0.02017212, -0.010856628, -0.0034561157, -0.018249512, 0.02218628, 0.019989014, -0.011764526, -0.055511475, -0.038604736, 0.02696228, -0.007610321, -0.02986145, -0.007881165, 0.031280518, 0.020462036, -0.00982666, 0.03564453, -0.013305664, 0.06201172, 0.0005569458, 0.000436306, 0.059448242, -0.00073719025, 0.02748108, -0.035095215, 0.015045166, -0.0049438477, 0.023864746, 0.021316528, 0.011306763, -0.0579834, -0.01184845, -0.022476196, -0.0015134811, 0.0028362274, 0.010620117, 0.028839111, -0.03744507, 0.004550934, 0.013648987, 0.018051147, -0.016952515, -0.008422852, -0.0026779175, -0.0034236908, -0.035064697, -0.026260376, -0.017974854, 0.060302734, 0.00017523766, 0.022476196, 0.0026569366, 0.0519104, -0.034484863, -0.016586304, -0.03591919, 0.03982544, 0.0059928894, 0.005142212, -0.0075569153, 0.014053345, -0.029953003, 0.07293701, 0.10028076, -0.051116943, 0.03842163, -0.06085205, -0.017791748, 0.01109314, -0.051452637, -0.005432129, 0.01689148, 0.0031757355, 0.006500244, -0.033294678, -0.012825012, -0.03869629, 0.004299164, 0.0023403168, -0.002418518, -0.07635498, -0.068847656, -0.015617371, -0.04534912, -0.05859375, -0.033294678, 0.067993164, -0.020736694, -0.017654419, -0.001709938, -0.011703491, -0.043701172, 0.0011959076, -0.019424438, -0.021072388, 0.026062012, 0.026809692, 0.015579224, -0.06781006, -0.029571533, 0.009269714, 0.023071289, -0.0009493828, -0.033294678, -0.015625, 0.037872314, 0.035827637, 0.024291992, 0.016082764, -0.055511475, -0.0023651123, -0.051208496, -0.01914978, 0.022018433, -0.025039673, -0.014251709, 0.049316406, -0.031799316, -0.024093628, 0.024795532, 0.041046143, -0.05343628, -0.022338867, 0.024551392, -0.0055999756, -0.019958496, 0.053619385, 0.004386902, 0.017105103, -0.05230713, 0.015579224, -0.06518555, -0.018127441, -0.022964478, -0.0074806213, 0.031677246, -0.04623413, -0.021606445, -0.026107788, -0.003129959, 0.0043907166, 0.014793396, -0.0013570786, -0.036346436, -0.015716553, -0.013435364, 0.0038528442, 0.008399963, 0.012130737, 0.0116119385, 0.022155762, 0.010040283, -0.017349243, -0.014266968, 0.02255249, -0.006465912, -0.0040016174, -0.008628845, -0.027954102, 0.009147644, 0.012336731, 0.009422302, -0.0056266785, -0.019866943, -0.089904785, -0.014541626, 0.059906006, -0.012428284, -0.045684814, 0.03894043, -0.027862549, -0.00008034706, 0.058502197, -0.027313232, 0.014854431, 0.07849121, -0.0058555603, -0.0023975372, 0.026824951, -0.029922485, 0.032348633, -0.028686523, -0.1005249, 0.019851685, -0.022857666, 0.020645142, 0.0066337585, -0.03225708, -0.04751587, 0.00043201447, 0.022613525, 0.042297363, 0.042297363, 0.0011253357, -0.0020389557, -0.022644043, 0.012756348, -0.030944824, 0.0031318665, 0.007873535, -0.04437256, -0.011734009, -0.015731812, 0.006008148, 0.047576904, -0.026855469, -0.05117798, -0.032318115, -0.0056648254, 0.024108887, -0.0023784637, -0.02973938, -0.04055786, -0.03062439, 0.019958496, 0.025314331, -0.019302368, -0.008140564, -0.017440796, 0.0020580292, -0.03375244, 0.036224365, -0.0008363724, 0.023773193, 0.0027751923, -0.011650085, 0.03842163, -0.015640259, -0.06994629, 0.033325195, 0.027999878, 0.02607727, -0.01449585, 0.0029296875, -0.020095825, 0.0050468445, -0.004562378, 0.013977051, 0.024002075, -0.021987915, 0.017150879, 0.0121536255, -0.019958496, -0.01676941, -0.027893066, 0.005302429, -0.022140503, 0.03189087, -0.08831787, -0.03552246, -0.024627686, 0.01398468, -0.05734253, -0.018951416, 0.008972168, -0.005065918, -0.041259766, -0.037902832, 0.018966675, -0.0006175041, -0.0211792, 0.018432617, -0.0031394958, -0.023468018, -0.0028820038, -0.07312012, 0.008720398, 0.055114746, 0.015129089, 0.028640747, 0.019073486, -0.00856781, -0.011016846, -0.021331787, 0.015014648, 0.009933472, 0.0096588135, -0.010658264, 0.024414062, 0.03060913, -0.026901245, 0.0104904175, 0.01902771, 0.025115967, -0.018676758, 0.011619568, 0.040130615, 0.027923584, -0.032928467, 0.0413208, 0.04034424, -0.018737793, -0.06137085, -0.008514404, -0.0069618225, -0.03640747, 0.022537231, -0.008155823, 0.020843506, 0.034606934, 0.002029419, 0.052459717, -0.01789856, -0.041381836, 0.029251099, 0.019821167, -0.01739502, -0.014953613, 0.012306213, 0.039886475, -0.017547607, -0.00046515465, -0.000538826, 0.04586792, 0.0035419464, -0.04348755, 0.0345459, 0.047698975, -0.01260376, 0.0012435913, -0.060821533, -0.025665283, -0.0074691772, 0.0061798096, -0.023910522, 0.015235901, 0.0074653625, -0.035491943, -0.05029297, 0.064208984, -0.057678223, 0.011741638, -0.029876709, -0.04949951, -0.025726318, 0.007598877, -0.056396484, -0.02720642, -0.008384705, -0.030807495, 0.010055542, -0.020812988, -0.006412506, 0.012367249, 0.043060303, 0.038208008, 0.06021118, -0.0473938, -0.070373535, -0.050201416, 0.008834839, -0.017913818, 0.02128601, -0.005168915, 0.017456055, -0.01133728, 0.01071167, -0.024459839, -0.014892578, -0.0680542, 0.047973633, -0.00522995, 0.05001831, 0.0059127808, 0.019699097, 0.032348633, -0.007610321, 0.015541077, 0.00006043911, -0.048736572, 0.026000977, 0.012756348, 0.06713867, -0.044036865, 0.006210327, 0.01374054, 0.01473999, -0.010910034, -0.0034065247, 0.028808594, 0.006790161, 0.0059127808, 0.0056152344, 0.024902344, -0.037872314, -0.030059814, 0.014419556, -0.008102417, 0.05105591, -0.013305664, 0.057434082, 0.009300232, -0.032043457, 0.021499634, -0.008956909, 0.014183044, -0.004711151, 0.01473999, -0.0362854, -0.05645752, -0.0070228577, 0.04647827, -0.034240723, 0.0039711, -0.03543091, 0.0035362244, 0.021453857, 0.033843994, 0.036834717, -0.024139404, 0.005344391, -0.023513794, -0.017044067, -0.0032100677, -0.03363037, -0.0011901855, 0.0440979, 0.051483154, -0.040863037, 0.048797607, -0.022506714, 0.025680542, -0.022155762, -0.026870728, 0.041259766, -0.054473877, -0.017547607, 0.059753418, -0.00070619583, 0.014846802, 0.004878998, 0.007129669, 0.0055389404, 0.043884277, -0.0027618408, 0.03125, 0.027069092, -0.063964844, -0.00040626526, 0.013549805, 0.004383087, -0.014457703, 0.022232056, -0.0023937225, -0.012878418, -0.02507019, 0.026275635, 0.04473877, -0.0020198822, 0.014083862, -0.055725098, 0.022323608, 0.018188477, 0.0016336441, 0.0107803345, -0.084350586, -0.025802612, -0.014259338, -0.050476074, -0.06585693, 0.06866455, -0.011779785, -0.0015277863, -0.05517578, 0.026947021, -0.055633545, 0.010719299, 0.009971619, 0.012901306, -0.0063705444, -0.0018520355, 0.0064315796, -0.04244995, 0.026473999, -0.014213562, 0.022766113, 0.031188965, 0.02168274, 0.014953613, 0.010215759, -0.010925293, -0.056488037, -0.01008606, -0.021224976, -0.004508972, 0.021118164, 0.000015854836, -0.045440674, -0.02116394, 0.00982666, 0.027862549, -0.023040771, -0.030303955, 0.025543213, 0.0013961792, -0.0042915344, 0.021728516, 0.01247406, 0.0096206665, 0.0034656525, 0.008041382, -0.042388916, 0.00844574, 0.027938843, -0.0050086975, 0.02949524, -0.045654297, 0.017303467, 0.026977539, 0.008529663, -0.0036811829, 0.028366089, 0.032714844, -0.006549835, -0.031051636, 0.009811401, 0.032165527, -0.035888672, 0.000374794, -0.042907715, -0.012268066, -0.060058594, 0.046661377, -0.013397217, -0.009742737, -0.037597656, -0.06585693, -0.041778564, 0.0012331009, 0.051239014, 0.005256653, 0.057006836, -0.043060303, -0.0029640198, 0.014732361, 0.0078086853, -0.040100098, -0.00957489, -0.005874634, -0.027252197, 0.031143188, 0.045959473, -0.010917664, -0.006011963, 0.01399231, -0.01651001, 0.0045928955, -0.020904541, -0.016464233, 0.023330688, -0.022247314, 0.00036644936, 0.034423828, 0.02281189, 0.011146545, 0.049468994, -0.06323242, 0.038848877, 0.032196045, 0.024719238, 0.026123047, -0.0076446533, 0.010520935, 0.016738892, 0.009429932, -0.024520874, 0.0068473816, -0.045013428, -0.004535675, -0.02078247, -0.005104065, -0.08148193, 0.005355835, 0.03225708, 0.021224976, 0.034484863, 0.01171875, 0.025299072, -0.016082764, 0.02935791, -0.018661499, 0.04916382, -0.06323242, -0.01966858, 0.011352539, -0.008331299, 0.034088135, 0.042022705, -0.014419556, 0.011352539, 0.00554657, -0.0096206665, -0.014656067, 0.02909851, 0.020355225, -0.024734497, 0.00011700392, -0.018356323, 0.015792847, 0.0009255409, 0.03817749, 0.021316528, 0.041381836, 0.0037841797, 0.002407074, -0.013664246, 0.040252686, -0.03112793, 0.035247803, 0.07696533, -0.0703125, 0.016983032, -0.008628845, -0.019607544, -0.008148193, -0.0023078918, 0.036865234, -0.047332764, -0.016860962, -0.013641357, 0.045928955, -0.010925293, 0.01448822, -0.033691406, -0.0491333, 0.0056610107, 0.048217773, -0.017486572, 0.033966064, -0.0026512146, 0.031188965, -0.011817932, 0.006942749, -0.0023403168, 0.037231445, -0.018936157, 0.03439331, -0.06124878, 0.04812622, 0.02230835, -0.026901245, 0.025466919, 0.021438599, -0.057769775, 0.01737976, -0.0026054382, 0.08569336, 0.027282715, 0.064208984, -0.01953125, -0.035888672, 0.026275635, -0.015563965, 0.04385376, 0.008712769, -0.041137695, -0.017623901, -0.033721924, -0.036315918, -0.0037250519, -0.032318115, 0.013618469, -0.016281128, 0.052001953, -0.028213501, 0.018951416, 0.020263672, -0.07800293, -0.005531311, 0.011482239, -0.08508301, 0.008049011, -0.0053482056, -0.00920105, -0.004951477, -0.02357483, 0.025253296, 0.018798828, -0.022613525, -0.0018978119, -0.0032196045, -0.057769775, -0.0012807846, -0.06262207, 0.026016235, -0.02734375, -0.0206604, 0.0021915436, -0.015144348, 0.0016822815, -0.009498596, -0.018951416, 0.0011081696, -0.00074863434, -0.052642822, 0.020751953, -0.0039634705, -0.01360321, -0.0002579689, -0.026809692, 0.0075531006, -0.014518738, -0.049194336, 0.041107178, -0.030639648, -0.030944824, -0.01499176, -0.0345459, 0.024734497, 0.023208618, -0.023010254, -0.013931274, 0.032165527, -0.03869629, -0.0044174194, 0.005241394, 0.056762695, -0.03250122, -0.046051025, 0.0013256073, 0.035217285, 0.0256958, -0.041503906, 0.010505676, 0.035705566, 0.05267334, -0.00869751, 0.05432129, 0.018234253, -0.0049324036, -0.008781433, 0.031799316, 0.0024471283, -0.039367676, -0.05895996, -0.019226074, 0.05215454, 0.037353516, -0.008430481, -0.022888184, 0.043151855, 0.0018987656, -0.012687683, 0.0435791, 0.0115737915, 0.00070238113, 0.013267517, 0.030792236, -0.0335083, -0.015335083, -0.055114746, 0.010375977, 0.0068473816, 0.034301758, -0.0019931793, 0.02281189, -0.008361816, 0.08666992, -0.022445679, -0.0000046491623, 0.025405884, 0.028259277, 0.022537231, 0.032562256, -0.030288696, 0.0051345825, -0.037902832, 0.0032024384, 0.019104004, 0.019699097, 0.014259338, -0.014717102, 0.0446167, -0.06112671, -0.042877197, -0.05343628, -0.035827637, 0.013534546, -0.07220459, 0.01940918, -0.032928467, -0.04336548, -0.008964539, -0.017913818, 0.011451721, -0.029296875, -0.05102539, -0.0037002563, 0.024032593, -0.00466156 ], "summary": [ -0.01826477, -0.015960693, -0.03970337, -0.028579712, -0.026382446, -0.013298035, -0.03338623, 0.013008118, -0.0055503845, 0.019134521, -0.024917603, -0.0072021484, -0.0104904175, -0.033996582, 0.045166016, -0.03869629, -0.020721436, 0.027893066, -0.009513855, -0.04486084, 0.010726929, -0.05456543, -0.014411926, 0.0020637512, 0.0435791, -0.052337646, -0.06542969, 0.013282776, 0.0049934387, 0.007797241, 0.019638062, 0.015686035, 0.019683838, 0.0021438599, -0.029083252, -0.08068848, -0.01676941, 0.000869751, -0.029129028, 0.027908325, 0.03869629, -0.01663208, 0.06414795, -0.014450073, 0.013381958, 0.0395813, -0.004371643, -0.0368042, 0.020401001, 0.008972168, 0.013557434, 0.025985718, 0.0064964294, -0.030563354, -0.013839722, 0.01247406, -0.024429321, -0.010864258, 0.0368042, 0.054534912, -0.0061073303, -0.017105103, -0.016815186, -0.05239868, -0.0077400208, -0.013114929, 0.038482666, -0.009521484, 0.042938232, 0.018829346, 0.0049362183, 0.04534912, 0.023330688, -0.02746582, -0.0062294006, -0.031829834, 0.041870117, -0.030685425, -0.02130127, -0.002029419, -0.02532959, 0.015411377, -0.018432617, -0.046936035, -0.0119018555, -0.048828125, -0.014839172, 0.018005371, -0.038970947, 0.015731812, -0.02658081, -0.017852783, -0.051239014, 0.027175903, 0.04144287, -0.03656006, -0.040618896, -0.054534912, -0.00957489, 0.037475586, 0.03277588, -0.048553467, 0.07684326, -0.016799927, -0.030914307, 0.0026454926, -0.00016772747, -0.055877686, -0.028045654, 0.028564453, -0.024612427, -0.0715332, -0.013671875, -0.016113281, -0.026535034, -0.018966675, -0.029220581, 0.013076782, 0.0034160614, -0.006164551, 0.0050849915, 0.028625488, -0.014259338, 0.02720642, 0.01210022, 0.009109497, 0.0009899139, -0.005958557, 0.0385437, -0.038635254, -0.019561768, 0.062072754, -0.046295166, -0.039642334, -0.035186768, 0.011489868, 0.010528564, 0.022201538, 0.011405945, -0.017745972, 0.043884277, -0.02456665, -0.029388428, 0.049468994, 0.005580902, 0.014801025, 0.04598999, 0.0043144226, -0.046661377, -0.013549805, -0.002506256, 0.05697632, 0.025283813, -0.017288208, -0.005306244, -0.035491943, -0.006591797, -0.019927979, 0.015281677, -0.01751709, 0.0048675537, 0.033477783, 0.070373535, 0.018722534, 0.017745972, -0.046813965, -0.008506775, -0.017562866, 0.0061302185, 0.0031738281, -0.023117065, 0.01386261, 0.029693604, -0.010772705, 0.0011854172, 0.00062942505, -0.03173828, 0.07122803, 0.006046295, -0.078308105, -0.018569946, -0.042053223, 0.05105591, -0.0074768066, 0.011024475, -0.053527832, -0.01071167, -0.021774292, 0.035583496, 0.020050049, -0.000072956085, -0.016311646, -0.040802002, 0.029663086, -0.022903442, 0.032684326, -0.043914795, 0.040374756, -0.027526855, -0.022460938, 0.014053345, -0.008583069, -0.00504303, -0.02015686, -0.07409668, -0.0231781, -0.01197052, 0.01676941, 0.0019435883, 0.014434814, -0.0006122589, -0.028427124, 0.007827759, -0.014297485, -0.030212402, -0.035980225, -0.0011043549, -0.046173096, 0.0028266907, -0.024871826, 0.0001360178, 0.048553467, -0.025421143, 0.031799316, -0.03012085, -0.0071258545, -0.024047852, 0.018920898, 0.00730896, -0.0006175041, 0.10180664, -0.038482666, -0.0027313232, 0.06329346, 0.012641907, -0.012046814, 0.022064209, -0.04888916, 0.037384033, 0.025756836, -0.007827759, -0.026290894, -0.047058105, 0.04043579, -0.042388916, -0.0022201538, 0.010643005, 0.022247314, -0.039642334, -0.029067993, 0.05203247, -0.015991211, 0.013031006, -0.051727295, -0.006790161, 0.012863159, 0.007293701, -0.009254456, 0.004295349, 0.009002686, -0.002565384, -0.0059509277, -0.012634277, 0.007633209, -0.03643799, -0.014602661, -0.03540039, -0.03048706, -0.0028820038, -0.001247406, 0.036132812, -0.05331421, 0.0026836395, -0.034240723, -0.08319092, 0.009864807, -0.022109985, 0.051208496, 0.002462387, -0.02708435, -0.024780273, -0.0016117096, -0.032470703, -0.020385742, -0.004924774, 0.02255249, 0.015335083, -0.01838684, 0.028671265, 0.026809692, 0.048309326, -0.0045661926, 0.00806427, 0.0037975311, 0.015258789, -0.03265381, 0.013824463, 0.042297363, -0.017990112, -0.03274536, 0.0019130707, 0.0022239685, -0.054901123, -0.0002937317, 0.01259613, 0.008804321, 0.029342651, -0.0050239563, -0.006679535, 0.02659607, -0.07476807, -0.017105103, 0.030899048, 0.07141113, -0.048309326, -0.03189087, -0.01473999, 0.040130615, -0.0008392334, 0.00071048737, 0.046539307, 0.009300232, 0.011962891, 0.008110046, 0.010124207, -0.023025513, 0.015655518, -0.012435913, 0.03173828, 0.025238037, 0.011489868, 0.016204834, -0.031311035, -0.020080566, -0.00040769577, -0.014137268, 0.021957397, -0.022369385, 0.028625488, 0.02609253, 0.070251465, 0.007949829, -0.009086609, -0.0065078735, -0.015792847, -0.03439331, 0.019363403, 0.01033783, -0.039367676, 0.005771637, 0.011756897, -0.055511475, -0.023254395, 0.05130005, -0.0058631897, -0.010498047, 0.029266357, -0.0035953522, -0.014640808, -0.030395508, 0.052520752, -0.0017461777, 0.024520874, -0.03164673, 0.0151901245, -0.053741455, -0.009963989, -0.022994995, -0.01612854, 0.025161743, -0.0067367554, -0.010635376, -0.020706177, -0.013114929, -0.036224365, 0.012023926, 0.12359619, 0.0211792, -0.035339355, 0.07623291, 0.020385742, 0.027297974, -0.013328552, -0.019363403, 0.023544312, -0.0051956177, -0.0029582977, 0.0022583008, 0.032440186, -0.0012798309, 0.003479004, -0.015686035, 0.03656006, -0.022781372, -0.021331787, 0.01586914, -0.046325684, -0.007663727, 0.003850937, -0.0067481995, 0.064575195, 0.024246216, -0.021011353, 0.024673462, -0.013595581, 0.021331787, 0.058624268, -0.0158844, 0.0023517609, 0.014266968, 0.027511597, -0.0068588257, 0.036224365, -0.014831543, 0.0077056885, -0.05316162, -0.019454956, 0.0060806274, -0.030563354, 0.034088135, -0.0030841827, 0.058929443, -0.044403076, 0.0052948, 0.048431396, 0.07659912, 0.0074768066, -0.030166626, 0.017440796, -0.011985779, 0.015068054, -0.03161621, 0.001294136, 0.037628174, -0.07092285, -0.009376526, 0.006965637, -0.01222229, 0.07989502, -0.08251953, -0.0061302185, 0.009643555, -0.0018043518, 0.022628784, 0.0039482117, -0.028213501, 0.012374878, -0.022918701, 0.026062012, 0.060699463, 0.012077332, -0.008460999, 0.03152466, 0.019012451, -0.03466797, -0.008102417, -0.032928467, 0.05065918, 0.055999756, -0.059753418, 0.008918762, -0.036712646, -0.051330566, 0.041137695, 0.032440186, 0.038146973, -0.0395813, 0.012298584, -0.029556274, 0.013885498, 0.02279663, -0.02558899, 0.02947998, -0.03253174, -0.021026611, -0.03805542, 0.05697632, -0.0071640015, 0.033966064, -0.07397461, -0.06976318, 0.044281006, -0.04916382, -0.053771973, -0.030197144, 0.0019426346, -0.028167725, -0.03857422, -0.0037708282, 0.06695557, 0.019546509, -0.0048179626, 0.04812622, 0.020996094, -0.009979248, 0.01777649, -0.023605347, 0.12121582, 0.028167725, -0.054504395, 0.037261963, -0.035217285, 0.03704834, 0.017730713, -0.035064697, 0.02861023, 0.037475586, 0.0066719055, 0.01651001, -0.061706543, 0.037506104, -0.04156494, 0.025482178, 0.016845703, -0.018920898, 0.0077552795, 0.021255493, 0.008255005, 0.003419876, 0.0005021095, 0.062561035, 0.082458496, -0.060150146, 0.02456665, 0.028640747, -0.022079468, -0.0569458, -0.011062622, 0.0073432922, -0.0006532669, 0.038970947, 0.014701843, 0.000849247, 0.004852295, -0.014678955, -0.023757935, -0.02168274, 0.012863159, 0.01146698, 0.015411377, -0.039886475, -0.006046295, 0.03753662, 0.048431396, -0.018676758, -0.021194458, -0.022460938, 0.009033203, -0.006793976, -0.038482666, 0.009788513, 0.008087158, -0.0155181885, -0.025146484, -0.0018482208, -0.030410767, -0.01689148, 0.0064315796, -0.008995056, 0.022247314, -0.005203247, -0.008979797, 0.010108948, 0.01260376, 0.0043258667, 0.031036377, -0.040924072, -0.053497314, -0.0002937317, 0.007068634, -0.028198242, -0.018966675, -0.036193848, -0.052978516, -0.012664795, 0.005355835, -0.019897461, 0.005695343, 0.024490356, 0.0284729, 0.01574707, -0.013092041, -0.032928467, -0.074279785, -0.010650635, 0.0018320084, 0.0066223145, -0.0029277802, 0.00026202202, 0.0044670105, 0.00969696, -0.029129028, -0.025054932, -0.08465576, 0.0074920654, 0.025131226, -0.005455017, 0.049835205, 0.03930664, 0.017578125, 0.005744934, -0.009933472, -0.016220093, -0.013824463, 0.048614502, -0.00028657913, 0.05545044, -0.02557373, -0.009819031, -0.004459381, -0.0064201355, -0.027954102, 0.016616821, 0.017837524, -0.004180908, -0.0051498413, -0.019439697, 0.028121948, -0.0031604767, -0.019805908, 0.019515991, -0.008735657, 0.013725281, 0.007041931, 0.013076782, 0.011077881, -0.035827637, -0.009490967, -0.022109985, 0.013061523, -0.016052246, -0.0022087097, -0.027038574, -0.059051514, -0.028533936, 0.05480957, -0.0090789795, -0.033935547, -0.041931152, -0.01953125, 0.017700195, 0.012168884, 0.0012378693, -0.05343628, 0.015899658, -0.019348145, -0.030426025, 0.017227173, 0.0044898987, -0.014060974, -0.003358841, 0.01158905, -0.0473938, -0.022872925, 0.051452637, -0.02508545, -0.029632568, -0.0010414124, 0.020935059, -0.01802063, -0.061462402, 0.041412354, 0.0036354065, 0.000667572, 0.03970337, -0.018981934, -0.027923584, 0.0030345917, -0.01399231, -0.0076522827, -0.02279663, -0.058624268, 0.005584717, -0.0026931763, 0.0034179688, -0.0126953125, -0.002035141, -0.0058898926, -0.020385742, -0.006198883, -0.0062294006, -0.018341064, -0.0021076202, -0.015655518, -0.009315491, 0.030929565, -0.020843506, 0.01008606, -0.0013628006, -0.052886963, -0.014099121, -0.0129852295, -0.024719238, -0.041290283, 0.050231934, -0.012008667, 0.01586914, -0.026321411, 0.018341064, -0.072021484, -0.0014667511, 0.03375244, -0.0014257431, 0.026931763, -0.03744507, -0.011497498, -0.078552246, 0.050994873, -0.017974854, 0.028564453, -0.00033926964, -0.016677856, 0.008354187, 0.0073013306, -0.04446411, -0.068237305, -0.09484863, -0.03842163, -0.009170532, 0.07183838, -0.0141067505, 0.012062073, -0.0234375, -0.038330078, 0.0028877258, -0.022521973, -0.034698486, 0.025314331, -0.027160645, -0.04724121, 0.023376465, -0.0015640259, -0.019515991, 0.0061416626, 0.00058460236, -0.03515625, 0.019638062, 0.0146865845, 0.015945435, -0.021514893, -0.029388428, -0.007270813, 0.033355713, 0.011260986, 0.0056610107, 0.024795532, 0.010894775, -0.016174316, 0.01499939, 0.006477356, 0.015380859, 0.010231018, -0.0044021606, -0.045562744, 0.018951416, -0.05496216, 0.01675415, -0.029251099, -0.0068206787, -0.024505615, -0.07354736, -0.013183594, -0.023590088, 0.032287598, 0.032318115, 0.04534912, 0.0011301041, -0.0033607483, 0.016479492, -0.008491516, -0.03842163, -0.0019683838, -0.009567261, -0.0010604858, 0.033203125, 0.03161621, -0.01701355, 0.023376465, 0.027313232, -0.0027885437, -0.013465881, 0.016235352, 0.0045661926, 0.029342651, 0.004234314, 0.0069274902, 0.01600647, 0.0042037964, 0.02003479, 0.024505615, -0.017471313, 0.011291504, 0.03289795, 0.0054969788, 0.012664795, -0.030929565, 0.001865387, 0.014533997, -0.06414795, -0.04071045, 0.028945923, 0.01838684, -0.0758667, -0.06262207, -0.066833496, -0.03829956, 0.032318115, -0.0395813, 0.028366089, 0.042022705, 0.008728027, 0.006679535, 0.0041503906, -0.045288086, -0.014060974, 0.022521973, 0.0057373047, 0.0005455017, 0.004886627, 0.017227173, -0.01222229, 0.038024902, -0.003921509, 0.034851074, 0.044189453, 0.00063467026, 0.010620117, 0.01725769, -0.006401062, -0.03817749, 0.046966553, -0.029449463, 0.031082153, 0.02458191, 0.050933838, 0.01576233, 0.013786316, 0.024612427, -0.015571594, 0.0020580292, 0.066223145, -0.037628174, 0.07635498, 0.056030273, 0.0023059845, -0.0072250366, -0.0033550262, -0.02619934, 0.04788208, 0.017791748, 0.025939941, -0.044036865, 0.016326904, -0.05178833, 0.019104004, -0.02545166, -0.018936157, -0.033813477, -0.044403076, 0.023162842, 0.031921387, -0.03955078, 0.002313614, 0.01373291, -0.014091492, 0.03152466, 0.032958984, 0.013381958, 0.08337402, 0.042541504, 0.031234741, -0.101135254, -0.0010852814, 0.0093307495, -0.0032787323, 0.008239746, 0.025939941, 0.011924744, 0.01776123, 0.05105591, 0.11639404, 0.076660156, 0.054016113, -0.035705566, 0.014411926, 0.09240723, -0.025299072, 0.04763794, 0.0048980713, -0.0030021667, -0.044403076, 0.00004094839, 0.0071258545, -0.007911682, 0.01209259, 0.022491455, -0.005340576, 0.009254456, -0.051849365, 0.013374329, -0.03111267, -0.04345703, 0.06512451, -0.04888916, -0.052520752, 0.014862061, 0.040740967, 0.024871826, 0.016204834, -0.030288696, -0.029647827, -0.0006175041, -0.0027656555, 0.018951416, -0.0008597374, -0.018478394, -0.013549805, -0.027252197, 0.04800415, -0.014129639, 0.00055360794, 0.03010559, -0.0012369156, -0.010505676, -0.023391724, -0.0074424744, 0.016418457, 0.0042877197, -0.049743652, 0.025100708, 0.021408081, -0.025482178, -0.04925537, -0.022460938, -0.012954712, -0.029296875, 0.021942139, 0.043395996, -0.016921997, -0.023040771, 0.025344849, -0.035888672, 0.04135132, -0.0056533813, 0.011962891, -0.0013999939, 0.031280518, -0.021377563, -0.008575439, 0.005592346, 0.011543274, -0.0050468445, -0.064575195, 0.015159607, 0.012832642, 0.038269043, 0.0102005005, 0.044830322, 0.048034668, 0.024917603, -0.0012807846, 0.004032135, 0.028961182, -0.008666992, -0.031311035, 0.008979797, -0.009231567, -0.005378723, -0.02468872, -0.014656067, 0.04586792, 0.010169983, -0.018798828, -0.008094788, 0.056915283, -0.018417358, -0.038146973, 0.06756592, -0.017623901, -0.060668945, 0.032348633, 0.002292633, -0.012481689, -0.061706543, -0.024124146, -0.04751587, 0.035491943, 0.026901245, -0.012786865, 0.017654419, -0.02734375, 0.081726074, -0.04321289, 0.03265381, 0.027435303, 0.0065345764, 0.034210205, -0.041534424, 0.01625061, 0.045440674, -0.006576538, 0.002532959, 0.0071907043, 0.021026611, 0.019439697, -0.028152466, 0.009849548, -0.03463745, -0.0143966675, -0.03338623, -0.026763916, 0.001707077, -0.0690918, 0.02017212, -0.011528015, -0.017196655, 0.013954163, -0.007331848, 0.032989502, 0.021743774, 0.017471313, -0.016098022, -0.018753052, -0.0019226074 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2112.03235v2
Simulation Intelligence: Towards a New Generation of Scientific Methods
Alexander Lavin, David Krakauer, Hector Zenil, Justin Gottschlich, Tim Mattson, Johann Brehmer, Anima Anandkumar, Sanjay Choudry, Kamil Rocki, Atılım Güneş Baydin, Carina Prunkl, Brooks Paige, Olexandr Isayev, Erik Peterson, Peter L. McMahon, Jakob Macke, Kyle Cranmer, Jiaxin Zhang, Haruko Wainwright, Adi Hanuka, Manuela Veloso, Samuel Assefa, Stephan Zheng, Avi Pfeffer
cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.LG, cs.MS
The original "Seven Motifs" set forth a roadmap of essential methods for the field of scientific computing, where a motif is an algorithmic method that captures a pattern of computation and data movement. We present the "Nine Motifs of Simulation Intelligence", a roadmap for the development and integration of the essential algorithms necessary for a merger of scientific computing, scientific simulation, and artificial intelligence. We call this merger simulation intelligence (SI), for short. We argue the motifs of simulation intelligence are interconnected and interdependent, much like the components within the layers of an operating system. Using this metaphor, we explore the nature of each layer of the simulation intelligence operating system stack (SI-stack) and the motifs therein: (1) Multi-physics and multi-scale modeling; (2) Surrogate modeling and emulation; (3) Simulation-based inference; (4) Causal modeling and inference; (5) Agent-based modeling; (6) Probabilistic programming; (7) Differentiable programming; (8) Open-ended optimization; (9) Machine programming. We believe coordinated efforts between motifs offers immense opportunity to accelerate scientific discovery, from solving inverse problems in synthetic biology and climate science, to directing nuclear energy experiments and predicting emergent behavior in socioeconomic settings. We elaborate on each layer of the SI-stack, detailing the state-of-art methods, presenting examples to highlight challenges and opportunities, and advocating for specific ways to advance the motifs and the synergies from their combinations. Advancing and integrating these technologies can enable a robust and efficient hypothesis-simulation-analysis type of scientific method, which we introduce with several use-cases for human-machine teaming and automated science.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2112.03235v2
"2022-11-27T07:20:27"
"2021-12-06T18:45:31"
{ "title": [ -0.027740479, -0.0027751923, -0.020690918, -0.03213501, 0.018920898, 0.0025920868, 0.0020828247, -0.029083252, -0.0001821518, 0.031585693, 0.0061149597, 0.021255493, -0.023498535, -0.02748108, -0.04714966, 0.012039185, -0.004184723, 0.01701355, -0.03164673, -0.04345703, -0.011161804, -0.05316162, 0.048675537, 0.044952393, 0.049987793, -0.034942627, -0.08691406, 0.023239136, -0.040283203, -0.027160645, -0.024398804, 0.023422241, 0.049041748, 0.028747559, -0.012557983, 0.017944336, -0.047302246, 0.017303467, -0.020187378, 0.03250122, -0.0055274963, 0.0019874573, -0.013183594, -0.03552246, -0.044006348, 0.009117126, -0.07196045, -0.012489319, -0.041290283, 0.041259766, 0.037078857, 0.010864258, -0.001613617, 0.041809082, 0.022659302, -0.015525818, -0.022613525, -0.008354187, 0.03555298, 0.048065186, 0.0146102905, -0.040802002, 0.025360107, 0.001876831, -0.047546387, -0.013954163, -0.023086548, 0.02494812, 0.07434082, 0.0025997162, -0.023361206, 0.020843506, -0.0070877075, 0.022155762, -0.041656494, -0.028671265, 0.06958008, -0.0000039339066, 0.012825012, -0.009346008, -0.00016736984, -0.035491943, 0.011810303, 0.0071372986, -0.015991211, -0.018676758, -0.013633728, -0.0024929047, -0.036621094, -0.040100098, -0.009811401, 0.0059814453, -0.01512146, 0.012008667, -0.031951904, 0.0009264946, -0.03857422, 0.0073890686, 0.015579224, -0.00032186508, -0.0008544922, 0.007408142, -0.03161621, -0.013153076, 0.0011138916, 0.0670166, -0.0020484924, -0.021118164, -0.016906738, 0.02041626, 0.0070343018, -0.018692017, 0.01461792, -0.0042495728, 0.01826477, 0.0021476746, -0.0019798279, 0.013214111, 0.02218628, -0.004470825, 0.004966736, -0.017181396, 0.018341064, 0.00030088425, 0.024856567, 0.008529663, -0.05319214, -0.025390625, -0.0051345825, 0.010726929, -0.005050659, 0.019866943, -0.07067871, -0.05734253, -0.03942871, 0.04348755, 0.02508545, -0.015899658, 0.0016851425, -0.004501343, 0.018539429, 0.00006681681, 0.005935669, 0.00340271, -0.011436462, 0.0019445419, 0.06298828, -0.0075569153, -0.048858643, -0.0031356812, -0.055786133, 0.027008057, 0.0423584, -0.0102005005, -0.074279785, -0.0026550293, -0.1361084, -0.001912117, 0.0090408325, 0.0036029816, 0.004146576, 0.0005707741, -0.014076233, -0.0037651062, 0.050750732, 0.0030612946, -0.028442383, 0.029037476, 0.007926941, 0.060302734, -0.012008667, 0.00094509125, -0.034973145, -0.0044898987, -0.013084412, 0.0088272095, 0.049346924, -0.0039138794, 0.021942139, -0.0027770996, 0.0028591156, -0.0059661865, 0.011222839, 0.05419922, -0.0440979, -0.034179688, -0.014144897, -0.035827637, 0.05734253, 0.013366699, -0.059539795, 0.023147583, -0.064331055, -0.027053833, -0.026809692, -0.014007568, 0.015068054, 0.017715454, 0.002325058, -0.002407074, -0.041046143, -0.0032348633, -0.034088135, 0.021759033, 0.018630981, -0.033081055, -0.0025978088, 0.022094727, -0.034088135, 0.047302246, 0.061553955, 0.02394104, -0.04147339, 0.027755737, 0.0043525696, -0.052093506, 0.022521973, -0.030212402, -0.0068893433, -0.0181427, -0.023971558, 0.009086609, -0.016647339, 0.045684814, -0.02230835, 0.005378723, 0.014312744, -0.021484375, 0.06567383, 0.015235901, 0.1161499, -0.051239014, 0.016494751, 0.009475708, -0.0032215118, -0.014846802, -0.016540527, -0.015510559, 0.009811401, 0.020721436, 0.009002686, -0.0005187988, -0.008735657, 0.0015697479, 0.041381836, -0.011169434, 0.019485474, -0.004699707, 0.012619019, -0.008201599, 0.050720215, 0.008132935, 0.08917236, 0.026275635, -0.011116028, 0.063964844, -0.01687622, -0.008979797, 0.0011034012, 0.01525116, 0.011306763, 0.004901886, -0.0009765625, 0.0071754456, -0.053863525, 0.016189575, -0.029525757, 0.017120361, 0.0119018555, 0.015609741, 0.03805542, -0.031951904, 0.0101623535, -0.025177002, -0.04147339, 0.012023926, -0.00073575974, 0.027160645, 0.004562378, -0.068115234, -0.015205383, 0.027557373, 0.0054473877, -0.0025424957, 0.0047569275, -0.017608643, -0.004337311, -0.018234253, -0.00067329407, -0.019622803, 0.052856445, 0.017700195, -0.0052108765, -0.0028839111, -0.020111084, -0.019638062, 0.06555176, 0.10467529, -0.034820557, 0.05987549, -0.06982422, 0.0075569153, 0.048034668, -0.052612305, 0.00033926964, 0.009010315, 0.005054474, 0.043273926, -0.022354126, -0.004928589, -0.036621094, 0.0289917, 0.0155181885, -0.08959961, 0.02810669, -0.012023926, 0.014907837, -0.032409668, 0.010848999, 0.04107666, 0.031066895, 0.0066947937, -0.054229736, -0.024475098, 0.005744934, 0.01524353, -0.05432129, -0.02998352, -0.03314209, 0.011161804, 0.04776001, -0.0024585724, -0.05215454, -0.03579712, -0.004085541, 0.0064468384, -0.021194458, 0.028793335, -0.020370483, 0.008117676, 0.015899658, -0.00009304285, 0.032226562, -0.038085938, 0.020477295, -0.0680542, -0.0054092407, 0.025405884, -0.03866577, 0.0010166168, 0.025253296, -0.013290405, -0.04663086, 0.021438599, 0.057891846, -0.031829834, 0.009361267, 0.05102539, 0.03186035, -0.026733398, 0.042266846, -0.018615723, -0.013694763, -0.036315918, 0.011047363, -0.04525757, -0.015701294, -0.042877197, -0.01966858, 0.048583984, -0.05255127, -0.019485474, -0.05001831, -0.023666382, -0.021774292, 0.03289795, 0.004058838, -0.009689331, -0.03668213, -0.010658264, 0.004432678, 0.020309448, -0.044708252, -0.0006532669, 0.12438965, -0.016418457, -0.022491455, -0.010276794, 0.060028076, 0.036712646, -0.020523071, -0.05831909, -0.029006958, -0.0032577515, -0.002620697, 0.016799927, -0.013450623, -0.02331543, -0.07891846, 0.000869751, 0.009490967, 0.0032157898, -0.034820557, 0.012001038, -0.05706787, 0.024353027, -0.024108887, -0.019302368, 0.032196045, 0.036315918, -0.0073242188, 0.012672424, 0.0026569366, -0.037506104, 0.010757446, -0.027496338, -0.109680176, 0.012390137, -0.017089844, -0.02168274, -0.011962891, -0.006008148, -0.046813965, 0.004119873, 0.008430481, 0.043914795, 0.048614502, 0.0070991516, 0.028930664, -0.012489319, 0.028930664, -0.026687622, -0.012184143, -0.027816772, -0.014915466, -0.014083862, -0.013938904, 0.048919678, -0.0046081543, 0.0030708313, -0.020477295, -0.015129089, -0.019515991, 0.012619019, 0.0037078857, -0.048309326, 0.0016288757, 0.008865356, 0.0058021545, -0.009902954, -0.012802124, -0.0016222, 0.0025997162, 0.005680084, -0.005870819, 0.011459351, 0.026168823, 0.017578125, -0.038085938, -0.0052490234, 0.04260254, -0.031433105, -0.0597229, 0.011131287, 0.019943237, -0.00044846535, 0.049438477, -0.01612854, -0.023010254, 0.012023926, -0.045898438, 0.014030457, 0.020751953, 0.010353088, -0.04724121, 0.030410767, 0.004917145, 0.004257202, -0.011978149, 0.019958496, 0.0082473755, 0.005874634, -0.033477783, -0.070739746, -0.015022278, 0.011764526, -0.13586426, -0.03201294, -0.005130768, -0.01499939, -0.05291748, -0.019012451, 0.004760742, -0.0004992485, -0.023223877, 0.018615723, -0.030014038, -0.001912117, -0.009086609, -0.04333496, -0.01576233, 0.057678223, -0.00010663271, 0.020263672, 0.017684937, -0.009384155, -0.026519775, -0.041229248, 0.014183044, -0.013214111, 0.018661499, -0.010971069, -0.026824951, 0.050048828, -0.033081055, 0.02468872, 0.01159668, 0.021148682, -0.031066895, -0.0026950836, 0.02357483, 0.020019531, -0.038024902, 0.03503418, 0.04345703, 0.0009455681, -0.08001709, 0.02003479, -0.02204895, -0.027938843, 0.02178955, 0.008056641, -0.006084442, 0.0018758774, 0.026138306, 0.060272217, -0.017791748, 0.012313843, 0.04748535, -0.019042969, -0.015930176, 0.000053048134, 0.026290894, 0.025360107, 0.0062675476, 0.020019531, -0.013114929, 0.047698975, -0.017593384, -0.0107421875, -0.0049438477, 0.011787415, -0.025131226, -0.003917694, -0.06112671, -0.03237915, -0.026992798, 0.0040512085, 0.0019874573, 0.02168274, 0.024246216, -0.027191162, -0.017288208, 0.012306213, 0.05166626, 0.011932373, -0.01020813, -0.05960083, 0.020004272, -0.006290436, -0.046691895, -0.041625977, 0.000043153763, -0.012260437, 0.012016296, -0.021011353, -0.035003662, -0.000055849552, 0.013977051, 0.07305908, 0.06817627, 0.0068206787, -0.07067871, -0.0021038055, -0.024108887, -0.008529663, 0.010223389, 0.0023326874, -0.017990112, -0.021530151, 0.015701294, -0.008079529, 0.0067634583, 0.0015621185, 0.023071289, -0.026138306, 0.062805176, -0.024017334, 0.039855957, 0.013114929, 0.0036029816, 0.029129028, 0.023834229, -0.039886475, -0.048828125, 0.017242432, 0.05307007, -0.033325195, 0.004295349, 0.02204895, 0.027114868, 0.02381897, -0.010665894, -0.00011432171, 0.0048294067, -0.022888184, -0.017211914, 0.012428284, -0.042236328, -0.023803711, -0.0010080338, -0.002872467, 0.048706055, -0.045806885, 0.08734131, -0.03164673, 0.0049057007, 0.0090408325, -0.02015686, 0.01399231, -0.029830933, 0.020401001, -0.06945801, -0.054748535, -0.015670776, 0.06311035, -0.04537964, -0.0050735474, -0.0026760101, 0.01777649, 0.02420044, 0.03427124, 0.02079773, -0.0060539246, 0.021835327, -0.008666992, -0.0054244995, -0.010803223, -0.061523438, 0.012054443, -0.01727295, 0.034606934, -0.056610107, 0.038208008, -0.07501221, 0.0036411285, 0.012535095, -0.016342163, 0.01890564, -0.05899048, 0.035858154, 0.08544922, -0.021881104, 0.04272461, 0.003282547, 0.0075187683, 0.038024902, 0.051605225, 0.010871887, 0.03048706, 0.021148682, -0.027908325, -0.03262329, 0.0001502037, 0.041259766, 0.002325058, 0.02293396, 0.020217896, -0.02128601, -0.05343628, 0.032073975, 0.013725281, -0.008377075, 0.012535095, -0.05419922, -0.0014305115, 0.0007457733, 0.0154800415, 0.023162842, 0.011909485, -0.05947876, -0.021133423, 0.027114868, -0.039886475, 0.014381409, 0.032958984, -0.018493652, -0.06933594, -0.004283905, -0.0035820007, 0.022964478, -0.02029419, 0.02078247, -0.03491211, 0.0017232895, 0.035614014, -0.045837402, 0.03048706, -0.049621582, -0.013618469, 0.03866577, 0.052520752, -0.00039625168, 0.007381439, 0.0014781952, -0.05822754, -0.030273438, -0.014808655, -0.021560669, 0.009994507, -0.020217896, -0.04425049, -0.010795593, 0.033111572, 0.03567505, 0.015335083, -0.053619385, 0.02130127, 0.004169464, -0.007701874, -0.0018234253, 0.02659607, -0.024749756, -0.00074481964, 0.013519287, -0.024673462, 0.022079468, -0.028289795, -0.018936157, -0.0049819946, -0.044006348, 0.013702393, 0.006996155, 0.013702393, -0.011680603, 0.009521484, 0.027053833, 0.006515503, -0.011276245, -0.010810852, 0.05038452, -0.03741455, -0.03463745, -0.0033397675, -0.01184845, -0.02897644, 0.051239014, 0.008834839, -0.032714844, -0.03466797, -0.031066895, -0.029296875, 0.012275696, 0.02619934, 0.011390686, 0.053710938, -0.009262085, 0.0027809143, -0.0066604614, -0.018920898, -0.031982422, -0.0040359497, 0.012321472, -0.009651184, 0.030349731, 0.01033783, -0.014450073, -0.012031555, 0.024032593, 0.013755798, -0.006084442, 0.025100708, -0.041931152, 0.005256653, -0.036987305, -0.027618408, 0.042785645, 0.03164673, -0.05328369, 0.05279541, -0.035186768, 0.070739746, 0.02394104, 0.052459717, 0.041809082, 0.016052246, 0.022872925, -0.0053215027, 0.005821228, -0.032684326, 0.022201538, -0.031829834, -0.017211914, -0.05340576, -0.030029297, -0.05682373, -0.028442383, 0.039733887, -0.0025787354, -0.00029039383, 0.0073623657, 0.008255005, -0.006263733, 0.029678345, -0.007347107, 0.032287598, 0.0062713623, -0.011260986, 0.0037269592, 0.028503418, 0.010414124, 0.038116455, 0.004962921, 0.00856781, -0.0058898926, 0.0053749084, -0.00655365, 0.007904053, 0.0035877228, -0.034454346, -0.0077209473, -0.03326416, 0.055664062, 0.00084781647, 0.027328491, 0.07733154, 0.0769043, 0.025146484, -0.02432251, 0.0064048767, 0.0014123917, -0.01890564, 0.019454956, 0.06378174, -0.07287598, 0.03781128, -0.004184723, -0.037963867, -0.035461426, 0.041290283, 0.021957397, -0.04699707, -0.02947998, 0.007297516, 0.040222168, 0.016159058, 0.012535095, -0.0423584, -0.008232117, 0.01991272, 0.048736572, -0.0051994324, 0.0234375, 0.0023994446, 0.027709961, -0.02784729, -0.033233643, 0.000024735928, 0.0118255615, -0.03149414, 0.024002075, -0.008644104, -0.017303467, 0.0110321045, -0.026245117, 0.021209717, -0.0048217773, -0.036499023, 0.008087158, -0.0055160522, 0.053833008, 0.03677368, 0.06939697, 0.011116028, -0.029144287, 0.012008667, -0.039031982, 0.036224365, 0.031921387, -0.02255249, 0.029403687, -0.0287323, -0.029953003, 0.04699707, -0.027801514, 0.064575195, -0.04360962, 0.0065193176, -0.0031929016, 0.022338867, 0.05606079, -0.06567383, -0.029541016, -0.0061187744, -0.013999939, -0.007972717, 0.0209198, -0.019882202, -0.029586792, 0.019470215, 0.032073975, 0.02999878, -0.0069389343, -0.007904053, -0.031143188, -0.086120605, 0.0012207031, -0.009025574, 0.028503418, -0.018920898, -0.01499176, -0.030426025, 0.019165039, -0.0045318604, -0.007881165, -0.026412964, 0.016937256, -0.018569946, -0.038085938, 0.019836426, 0.02822876, -0.012107849, 0.01574707, -0.01361084, 0.015808105, -0.007320404, 0.0010261536, 0.041412354, -0.039093018, -0.066223145, -0.0045051575, -0.01651001, 0.0345459, 0.00579834, -0.017227173, 0.006916046, 0.038482666, -0.04586792, -0.044830322, -0.023925781, 0.009429932, -0.02508545, -0.06311035, 0.007160187, 0.015014648, 0.014122009, -0.04244995, -0.058410645, 0.031585693, 0.015205383, -0.015991211, 0.051452637, 0.02432251, 0.005130768, 0.032104492, 0.032592773, 0.015281677, -0.060333252, -0.052215576, -0.04031372, 0.042053223, 0.051239014, 0.0001552105, -0.039123535, 0.041900635, -0.015129089, 0.0005002022, -0.0009303093, -0.0050582886, -0.001039505, 0.011680603, 0.03729248, -0.0072898865, -0.004009247, 0.008201599, -0.018676758, -0.010070801, -0.0014381409, -0.01600647, -0.0023593903, -0.051239014, 0.03857422, -0.013343811, -0.042633057, 0.045928955, 0.052124023, 0.019470215, 0.03274536, -0.048309326, -0.01158905, 0.004634857, -0.015213013, -0.009628296, 0.003004074, 0.02734375, -0.015571594, -0.008094788, -0.0027942657, -0.04724121, 0.00749588, -0.039489746, 0.048431396, -0.01739502, 0.008987427, 0.002254486, -0.016647339, -0.003967285, 0.017822266, -0.0014467239, -0.011444092, -0.0769043, -0.02760315, 0.035186768, -0.028030396 ], "summary": [ 0.017791748, -0.0096206665, 0.016693115, -0.016571045, -0.028259277, 0.0019607544, 0.0070533752, -0.016921997, -0.015129089, 0.041137695, -0.0090789795, 0.029953003, 0.007949829, -0.017990112, 0.011260986, 0.002357483, -0.0055999756, -0.002199173, -0.018600464, -0.037597656, 0.023529053, -0.04019165, 0.016952515, 0.05895996, 0.017105103, -0.035827637, -0.023284912, 0.02709961, -0.0038490295, 0.01737976, -0.0012083054, -0.0025234222, 0.029296875, 0.017211914, -0.03225708, 0.016677856, -0.0040130615, -0.002450943, -0.025680542, 0.040924072, 0.010231018, -0.01285553, 0.08276367, -0.033813477, 0.027557373, 0.04156494, -0.028366089, -0.03515625, 0.0039367676, 0.007965088, 0.04437256, -0.04827881, 0.03567505, 0.0064086914, -0.02748108, -0.0008006096, -0.015823364, 0.014717102, 0.013114929, 0.021560669, 0.008232117, 0.021957397, 0.0027179718, 0.003955841, 0.01537323, -0.007774353, 0.0024490356, 0.020980835, 0.016784668, 0.048828125, 0.027526855, -0.0028476715, -0.005596161, -0.036834717, 0.051940918, 0.019226074, -0.014549255, 0.023010254, 0.007358551, 0.029510498, -0.025772095, -0.028900146, -0.0009646416, -0.047454834, -0.0009918213, -0.027511597, -0.015792847, 0.023284912, -0.0046539307, 0.01689148, -0.018432617, -0.010604858, 0.010284424, 0.031234741, -0.004386902, -0.020523071, -0.032470703, -0.058135986, 0.00995636, 0.034454346, 0.029678345, -0.040039062, 0.057769775, -0.022018433, -0.011642456, 0.06451416, -0.012802124, 0.009284973, -0.007987976, 0.016464233, 0.012275696, -0.09295654, 0.022644043, -0.01600647, -0.035705566, -0.02885437, -0.025665283, 0.03668213, 0.008781433, 0.01789856, -0.020935059, 0.015548706, -0.03656006, 0.047576904, 0.0020885468, 0.0021915436, 0.021881104, 0.003156662, -0.00869751, 0.0045204163, 0.0015163422, 0.030731201, 0.003768921, -0.004699707, -0.05899048, -0.005897522, 0.07714844, 0.012687683, -0.00617218, -0.0063056946, 0.06506348, 0.0129470825, -0.031402588, 0.04724121, -0.018859863, 0.022628784, 0.020431519, -0.000626564, -0.010978699, -0.015823364, -0.03010559, 0.005645752, 0.018829346, -0.03112793, -0.058929443, -0.022003174, -0.107788086, 0.037902832, 0.019363403, 0.027313232, -0.009262085, 0.0014743805, 0.029388428, 0.05050659, 0.021316528, 0.019683838, 0.028015137, -0.014846802, 0.0038719177, -0.0060195923, 0.01939392, 0.006149292, 0.0053977966, -0.016021729, -0.006198883, -0.01285553, 0.036071777, -0.032226562, -0.019683838, 0.072021484, 0.029037476, -0.00995636, -0.01586914, 0.016311646, -0.028884888, 0.05895996, -0.010955811, 0.046325684, 0.027404785, 0.008255005, -0.016448975, 0.02619934, -0.048675537, 0.0030231476, -0.0062217712, 0.025268555, -0.026885986, 0.013000488, -0.0039024353, -0.010627747, -0.0014657974, 0.03640747, -0.033447266, 0.005268097, -0.020187378, -0.0071144104, 0.010025024, 0.032318115, -0.030792236, 0.020217896, 0.018356323, -0.030273438, -0.028030396, 0.02796936, 0.04296875, 0.0054092407, 0.022598267, -0.067871094, 0.012901306, -0.051818848, -0.0035877228, 0.054992676, -0.041168213, 0.02243042, -0.0010995865, -0.027770996, 0.0052757263, -0.008468628, 0.072021484, 0.00623703, 0.076538086, -0.034423828, 0.0060806274, -0.0036716461, -0.045684814, 0.020568848, 0.019760132, -0.008392334, -0.014526367, 0.039367676, 0.014343262, 0.038604736, -0.06463623, -0.0713501, 0.03744507, -0.016418457, -0.0011339188, -0.018753052, 0.027694702, 0.03173828, 0.025680542, -0.02911377, 0.019180298, -0.009750366, 0.011421204, 0.0007457733, -0.017822266, -0.023788452, -0.02960205, 0.011100769, 0.028640747, -0.009819031, -0.027618408, 0.012962341, -0.030090332, -0.001247406, -0.02708435, -0.014320374, -0.03427124, -0.008277893, 0.052825928, 0.02027893, -0.012832642, -0.02722168, -0.036010742, -0.024871826, -0.029403687, 0.04333496, -0.003276825, -0.033996582, 0.01612854, 0.054992676, -0.024612427, -0.02609253, -0.00642395, -0.012680054, -0.022445679, 0.018096924, 0.032470703, 0.032562256, 0.05331421, 0.023376465, -0.011367798, 0.037139893, -0.044647217, -0.008583069, 0.009712219, 0.06109619, -0.007522583, -0.016708374, -0.07751465, -0.006893158, -0.0063819885, -0.052093506, 0.002401352, 0.030914307, 0.031082153, -0.01763916, -0.005142212, 0.0011425018, -0.0072631836, 0.014152527, 0.023330688, -0.021484375, 0.036956787, 0.0069084167, -0.0061073303, 0.028396606, -0.0014190674, 0.026062012, 0.0769043, 0.021774292, -0.05432129, -0.020828247, -0.015235901, -0.0009880066, -0.025650024, -0.046569824, -0.01890564, -0.026947021, -0.05670166, -0.06304932, -0.07196045, -0.00011062622, -0.0062828064, 0.013023376, -0.0047721863, -0.029785156, -0.0037899017, 0.015022278, 0.03866577, 0.03955078, 0.0013141632, -0.027908325, 0.015975952, -0.035217285, 0.007106781, -0.0020198822, -0.02758789, 0.019577026, -0.012329102, -0.0052719116, -0.04812622, 0.024383545, 0.005718231, 0.004722595, 0.053955078, 0.057373047, 0.039154053, 0.0031547546, 0.0069503784, -0.007385254, -0.04638672, -0.05227661, 0.035095215, -0.0005645752, -0.011146545, -0.052703857, 0.017959595, 0.02949524, -0.03717041, 0.009567261, -0.012802124, 0.0031528473, 0.01108551, 0.022918701, 0.091552734, 0.013633728, -0.026153564, 0.049346924, 0.019042969, 0.050445557, -0.04815674, -0.00026583672, 0.09680176, -0.026107788, 0.008735657, 0.03439331, 0.04147339, 0.021636963, -0.052124023, -0.06536865, -0.010276794, -0.02671814, 0.006603241, 0.017608643, 0.0045280457, -0.029220581, 0.006793976, -0.03918457, 0.021896362, 0.02357483, 0.017471313, 0.001373291, 0.001329422, -0.018081665, 0.021133423, -0.01348114, 0.025482178, -0.000102221966, -0.008483887, -0.014541626, 0.013114929, -0.052093506, 0.004558563, -0.0037498474, -0.022888184, 0.0017156601, -0.009613037, -0.00843811, 0.014251709, -0.0039749146, -0.011352539, 0.001950264, 0.008666992, 0.00166893, 0.008117676, -0.004470825, -0.03930664, 0.049102783, 0.02520752, -0.0060806274, -0.004966736, -0.013153076, -0.016036987, 0.033935547, -0.03189087, -0.010574341, -0.015945435, -0.02961731, 0.0028495789, 0.015510559, 0.020721436, 0.012138367, -0.0005450249, -0.001906395, 0.03717041, 0.01512146, 0.022903442, 0.028442383, -0.0041122437, 0.012168884, 0.016021729, 0.008682251, -0.030838013, -0.04083252, 0.02029419, 0.026672363, 0.029464722, -0.0037784576, 0.022216797, -0.0020618439, -0.04574585, 0.018798828, -0.055908203, 0.035980225, 0.0036582947, -0.007663727, -0.055603027, -0.0093307495, -0.051696777, 0.048309326, -0.011772156, -0.007167816, -0.06317139, -0.04385376, 0.07147217, 0.020889282, 0.044189453, -0.049743652, 0.0062217712, 0.01626587, -0.0137786865, -0.030471802, -0.038116455, 0.024856567, -0.095581055, -0.068481445, -0.0015945435, -0.031555176, -0.02053833, -0.03186035, 0.006248474, -0.0090408325, -0.017730713, -0.0037498474, -0.014533997, 0.074401855, 0.0335083, -0.019104004, -0.014961243, -0.013465881, 0.009269714, -0.043548584, -0.012420654, 0.035125732, 0.011070251, 0.017333984, -0.010612488, -0.04449463, 0.009109497, -0.04724121, -0.03262329, 0.002773285, -0.03164673, 0.038208008, -0.012664795, 0.006629944, -0.0029258728, -0.009429932, 0.033996582, 0.056243896, -0.026748657, -0.012687683, 0.04348755, -0.003320694, -0.039215088, 0.03527832, -0.056243896, -0.028961182, 0.039520264, 0.073791504, 0.0026378632, -0.01727295, 0.0016212463, -0.022460938, -0.025741577, -0.026687622, 0.04348755, 0.050964355, -0.00919342, -0.003850937, -0.0049858093, 0.06976318, -0.012397766, 0.052001953, 0.004173279, 0.08392334, -0.015945435, 0.035339355, 0.0134887695, 0.0099105835, 0.0013771057, 0.008560181, -0.0005373955, -0.039367676, -0.06304932, -0.004863739, 0.017242432, 0.02949524, -0.010192871, 0.026138306, 0.016937256, -0.015419006, 0.1262207, 0.027648926, -0.012374878, -0.06726074, -0.055541992, 0.0058250427, -0.044006348, 0.006778717, -0.046905518, -0.053894043, -0.0149002075, -0.012931824, -0.029953003, -0.016983032, 0.017868042, 0.059143066, 0.03540039, 0.0625, -0.018341064, -0.0071868896, -0.023071289, 0.054595947, -0.02947998, 0.045166016, -0.0025196075, 0.013092041, -0.010482788, -0.010879517, -0.031707764, -0.040283203, 0.029006958, 0.0078086853, 0.028244019, 0.027191162, 0.046936035, 0.018722534, 0.009986877, -0.0042533875, 0.0027389526, -0.013320923, 0.032196045, -0.008979797, 0.025756836, -0.011306763, 0.015838623, 0.025100708, -0.029525757, -0.034729004, 0.012870789, 0.011627197, -0.01586914, 0.021820068, -0.031280518, 0.005077362, 0.0017061234, 0.019042969, 0.030807495, -0.020263672, 0.039367676, 0.024978638, 0.018066406, 0.018936157, 0.0028266907, -0.03793335, -0.04107666, 0.018737793, -0.06463623, -0.00024580956, -0.08099365, -0.07470703, -0.06713867, 0.085876465, -0.023468018, -0.07220459, -0.0057029724, -0.00390625, -0.006931305, 0.019515991, 0.023101807, -0.035308838, 0.06542969, -0.007369995, 0.0031871796, 0.044189453, -0.032409668, -0.026107788, -0.00894928, 0.0051345825, -0.0033740997, -0.0009880066, -0.0028877258, -0.030685425, -0.023239136, 0.017120361, 0.045410156, 0.010879517, 0.00042533875, 0.11645508, -0.023864746, 0.033325195, 0.023971558, -0.015167236, 0.013977051, 0.015159607, -0.023895264, -0.003326416, -0.0041046143, -0.011909485, -0.036621094, -0.014709473, 0.021011353, 0.00022757053, -0.008766174, 0.017822266, -0.02116394, -0.026443481, -0.0033035278, 0.015930176, 0.089782715, -0.010848999, -0.0446167, 0.037628174, -0.018600464, -0.017333984, 0.010406494, 0.05178833, -0.062927246, -0.06210327, 0.042419434, -0.049316406, -0.03201294, 0.017074585, 0.050201416, -0.040740967, 0.004962921, -0.08685303, 0.012832642, 0.004096985, 0.010971069, 0.024765015, -0.022201538, -0.01184845, -0.050109863, 0.027542114, -0.012748718, 0.0064468384, 0.0042686462, 0.0050811768, 0.07775879, 0.016098022, -0.019088745, 0.001909256, 0.02885437, -0.036956787, -0.052368164, 0.068725586, -0.0335083, -0.013023376, -0.052520752, -0.0066490173, 0.003326416, -0.028076172, -0.079956055, -0.0028877258, -0.000688076, -0.019866943, 0.008369446, 0.015327454, -0.033111572, 0.003162384, 0.0096588135, -0.0056991577, -0.004878998, -0.043670654, -0.06744385, 0.009155273, -0.0033493042, 0.003604889, 0.007484436, 0.0070724487, -0.015312195, -0.022994995, 0.014907837, -0.0104904175, -0.013839722, -0.015037537, 0.062316895, -0.037750244, -0.0357666, -0.043762207, 0.013381958, -0.055511475, 0.014595032, 0.0028743744, -0.02330017, -0.0088272095, -0.017990112, 0.0029354095, -0.004131317, 0.009101868, 0.04373169, 0.06762695, 0.015853882, 0.0035209656, 0.032989502, -0.024871826, -0.049072266, -0.006477356, -0.012451172, -0.009689331, 0.07598877, 0.020187378, -0.037719727, 0.09265137, 0.006427765, -0.01828003, -0.044006348, 0.060516357, -0.00049209595, 0.030181885, -0.037902832, 0.0385437, 0.049560547, 0.056518555, -0.040283203, 0.03640747, 0.031585693, 0.03805542, 0.021209717, 0.005508423, 0.01386261, 0.00061035156, 0.029067993, -0.0087509155, -0.016799927, -0.018585205, -0.04147339, -0.019699097, -0.05215454, -0.015281677, -0.016174316, 0.036895752, -0.0005092621, -0.002729416, -0.06384277, 0.026031494, -0.0030593872, -0.008323669, 0.043945312, -0.014625549, -0.006778717, -0.03137207, -0.019638062, 0.006454468, -0.03741455, -0.02494812, 0.00015890598, 0.031951904, 0.011367798, 0.012207031, 0.0096206665, 0.0012817383, 0.041229248, -0.03665161, -0.01399231, -0.021057129, 0.016952515, -0.023803711, 0.037628174, 0.035095215, 0.06072998, -0.0027103424, 0.00844574, 0.025817871, -0.015319824, 0.0053596497, 0.037597656, 0.01776123, 0.012138367, -0.0011138916, 0.034698486, -0.004207611, 0.0079574585, -0.03793335, -0.04058838, -0.0052948, 0.024765015, -0.022232056, 0.011604309, -0.008628845, 0.005332947, -0.029800415, -0.023223877, -0.01789856, 0.012496948, 0.042663574, -0.007850647, 0.01878357, 0.03152466, 0.01448822, 0.036132812, 0.008010864, 0.008773804, -0.033203125, 0.026565552, -0.05731201, 0.026062012, 0.010101318, -0.028396606, -0.0050201416, -0.0066490173, -0.007133484, 0.020599365, 0.0033493042, 0.014022827, 0.027618408, 0.09008789, 0.05795288, 0.07885742, -0.025177002, 0.0206604, 0.068603516, 0.013916016, 0.05114746, -0.0019254684, 0.011550903, 0.018463135, -0.03527832, -0.0031166077, 0.013114929, -0.022888184, 0.041015625, -0.059509277, 0.011222839, -0.011222839, 0.00881958, 0.009086609, -0.019943237, -0.061920166, -0.014129639, -0.00020551682, -0.009536743, 0.016738892, -0.035217285, 0.01651001, -0.029541016, -0.016479492, -0.011817932, -0.023422241, 0.013587952, 0.0030708313, -0.05621338, 0.011245728, -0.008918762, 0.05114746, -0.0059432983, -0.015098572, 0.024932861, 0.03161621, -0.0014276505, -0.052642822, -0.022964478, 0.05026245, 0.035461426, -0.06726074, 0.032318115, 0.01335144, -0.02407837, -0.019302368, -0.0138168335, 0.009017944, -0.012298584, -0.027267456, 0.025161743, 0.02178955, -0.0075798035, -0.012008667, 0.017868042, -0.035980225, -0.028640747, 0.013114929, -0.004283905, 0.040405273, -0.030944824, -0.03289795, 0.0009422302, 0.016204834, -0.004486084, -0.009315491, -0.020401001, -0.009841919, 0.034484863, -0.029800415, -0.09454346, -0.011161804, -0.016983032, -0.029937744, -0.004108429, -0.012458801, 0.008918762, 0.055511475, 0.031188965, 0.0060577393, -0.030960083, -0.060150146, -0.032714844, 0.054473877, -0.0031833649, -0.015808105, -0.0541687, 0.018753052, -0.0012731552, 0.0011358261, 0.03161621, -0.013908386, -0.018066406, 0.0029582977, -0.0036239624, -0.011314392, -0.021896362, 0.056762695, -0.0024356842, -0.01309967, -0.009422302, -0.035491943, -0.0178833, -0.02394104, -0.06112671, 0.020950317, 0.006996155, -0.0140686035, 0.017562866, 0.03491211, -0.048828125, -0.008102417, -0.01537323, -0.012786865, 0.018096924, 0.0034923553, 0.009437561, 0.0011405945, 0.02178955, 0.017486572, -0.030593872, -0.024963379, 0.025039673, -0.036834717, 0.036346436, 0.011016846, 0.015670776, 0.006855011, 0.035339355, 0.020858765, 0.009284973, -0.052581787, 0.026000977, -0.0552063, -0.024749756, -0.04345703, -0.02885437 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2112.04552v1
PATO: Producibility-Aware Topology Optimization using Deep Learning for Metal Additive Manufacturing
Naresh S. Iyer, Amir M. Mirzendehdel, Sathyanarayanan Raghavan, Yang Jiao, Erva Ulu, Morad Behandish, Saigopal Nelaturi, Dean M. Robinson
cs.CE, cs.AI, cs.LG
In this paper, we propose PATO-a producibility-aware topology optimization (TO) framework to help efficiently explore the design space of components fabricated using metal additive manufacturing (AM), while ensuring manufacturability with respect to cracking. Specifically, parts fabricated through Laser Powder Bed Fusion are prone to defects such as warpage or cracking due to high residual stress values generated from the steep thermal gradients produced during the build process. Maturing the design for such parts and planning their fabrication can span months to years, often involving multiple handoffs between design and manufacturing engineers. PATO is based on the a priori discovery of crack-free designs, so that the optimized part can be built defect-free at the outset. To ensure that the design is crack free during optimization, producibility is explicitly encoded within the standard formulation of TO, using a crack index. Multiple crack indices are explored and using experimental validation, maximum shear strain index (MSSI) is shown to be an accurate crack index. Simulating the build process is a coupled, multi-physics computation and incorporating it in the TO loop can be computationally prohibitive. We leverage the current advances in deep convolutional neural networks and present a high-fidelity surrogate model based on an Attention-based U-Net architecture to predict the MSSI values as a spatially varying field over the part's domain. Further, we employ automatic differentiation to directly compute the gradient of maximum MSSI with respect to the input design variables and augment it with the performance-based sensitivity field to optimize the design while considering the trade-off between weight, manufacturability, and functionality. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method through benchmark studies in 3D as well as experimental validation.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2112.04552v1
"2021-12-08T19:52:24"
"2021-12-08T19:52:24"
{ "title": [ -0.028305054, 0.006706238, -0.04711914, -0.015991211, 0.0059509277, -0.019836426, -0.014930725, -0.0077667236, -0.008102417, 0.02331543, 0.023071289, 0.0146484375, -0.0065574646, -0.043518066, 0.007534027, 0.018249512, 0.018630981, 0.009277344, -0.0068206787, -0.022140503, 0.005832672, -0.01675415, 0.045074463, 0.06585693, 0.010574341, -0.023834229, -0.047668457, 0.0022068024, -0.059814453, -0.053588867, -0.007663727, 0.06008911, 0.046783447, -0.028518677, 0.01940918, -0.0016870499, -0.031219482, -0.0155181885, 0.0014038086, 0.0069122314, 0.020004272, -0.0071525574, -0.04559326, -0.0021190643, -0.0362854, -0.009109497, -0.032562256, -0.01096344, -0.013748169, 0.055419922, 0.027252197, -0.029846191, 0.031158447, 0.031173706, -0.0073509216, -0.05557251, -0.02709961, -0.010322571, 0.040985107, 0.06915283, 0.029434204, -0.032348633, -0.011734009, -0.054229736, -0.028671265, -0.021453857, 0.0135269165, 0.022598267, 0.0713501, -0.0067596436, -0.022476196, 0.044952393, 0.012901306, 0.02734375, -0.058380127, -0.050933838, 0.061767578, 0.0064201355, 0.04168701, -0.02104187, -0.028015137, 0.03289795, -0.023452759, -0.06750488, 0.027786255, -0.04650879, -0.017654419, -0.005340576, -0.017044067, -0.048065186, -0.002313614, 0.0017995834, 0.0029392242, 0.02015686, -0.023605347, -0.02822876, -0.027252197, -0.03189087, 0.014968872, 0.039215088, 0.03894043, -0.012527466, 0.06982422, -0.047729492, 0.015579224, 0.026535034, -0.02633667, -0.0071258545, 0.054992676, 0.025283813, 0.0019950867, 0.004108429, -0.008979797, -0.012893677, 0.053344727, 0.024932861, -0.028808594, 0.056396484, 0.017791748, 0.022827148, -0.016464233, -0.054229736, 0.027938843, 0.039367676, 0.012054443, -0.0029258728, -0.03741455, 0.0335083, -0.054992676, 0.004688263, 0.013870239, 0.06262207, -0.03552246, -0.035858154, -0.049316406, 0.048431396, -0.0042419434, 0.055633545, -0.019119263, -0.016677856, 0.0062065125, 0.0074539185, 0.021560669, -0.00022804737, 0.005420685, 0.028152466, 0.05142212, -0.018539429, -0.04876709, -0.045654297, -0.032562256, 0.027038574, 0.003419876, -0.011207581, 0.012046814, -0.033721924, -0.071899414, -0.015090942, 0.06335449, 0.009811401, -0.00289917, 0.023162842, 0.028076172, -0.016311646, 0.025543213, -0.028503418, -0.031280518, 0.011146545, 0.024551392, 0.05340576, -0.003944397, 0.004108429, -0.026031494, -0.029129028, -0.014312744, 0.015380859, 0.04559326, 0.0060424805, 0.013893127, -0.03845215, -0.015914917, -0.023590088, 0.021652222, 0.0010414124, -0.0635376, -0.018753052, 0.015960693, 0.014404297, 0.028533936, 0.00881958, -0.00031018257, 0.031951904, -0.06744385, -0.035095215, -0.057800293, 0.0029201508, 0.062683105, 0.03942871, -0.0023403168, 0.034454346, -0.05239868, -0.005355835, -0.02128601, 0.054626465, -0.022903442, -0.019180298, -0.020095825, 0.0012302399, -0.033813477, 0.04345703, 0.05114746, -0.00029611588, -0.015838623, -0.011054993, 0.0053710938, -0.04284668, 0.03225708, -0.027023315, -0.00869751, -0.034088135, -0.04458618, 0.031799316, -0.035858154, 0.027999878, 0.0051231384, 0.008056641, 0.0066871643, -0.017074585, 0.034484863, 0.01727295, 0.0446167, -0.0088272095, -0.018341064, 0.026519775, 0.011329651, 0.0012292862, 0.036743164, 0.030349731, 0.008621216, -0.019927979, -0.0035095215, -0.029220581, -0.009178162, 0.031951904, 0.04940796, 0.023849487, 0.012535095, 0.02508545, -0.002571106, 0.041229248, 0.044158936, 0.03375244, 0.011726379, 0.02078247, 0.023330688, 0.018493652, -0.018676758, 0.019485474, -0.025177002, 0.0035114288, -0.012710571, 0.050933838, 0.050964355, 0.0032730103, -0.02218628, -0.009613037, -0.0040397644, 0.011947632, -0.016326904, 0.005504608, 0.03756714, 0.0103302, 0.0013809204, -0.032684326, -0.034729004, -0.04196167, -0.028137207, 0.049865723, -0.012664795, -0.05734253, -0.014091492, -0.016815186, 0.07714844, 0.0051956177, 0.024490356, 0.011985779, 0.064819336, -0.018295288, 0.006401062, 0.016479492, 0.06390381, 0.003835678, 0.004497528, -0.018966675, 0.02772522, -0.020339966, 0.070739746, 0.057281494, -0.012420654, 0.021697998, -0.067993164, 0.011993408, -0.0035152435, -0.012199402, -0.00058221817, 0.041809082, 0.014122009, 0.011497498, -0.022354126, 0.036010742, -0.09643555, -0.028045654, 0.010574341, 0.0016479492, -0.022537231, -0.032409668, 0.0064849854, 0.0087509155, 0.01625061, 0.032196045, 0.05987549, -0.03302002, -0.01751709, -0.004348755, -0.013587952, -0.015106201, -0.018157959, -0.028900146, 0.017028809, 0.04348755, 0.021011353, 0.044555664, -0.051727295, -0.02885437, -0.02355957, -0.0017604828, -0.025878906, 0.023925781, -0.027938843, -0.003189087, -0.033050537, -0.023910522, 0.018112183, -0.049743652, 0.01914978, -0.041015625, -0.0012598038, 0.0018119812, -0.02053833, 0.015960693, 0.013809204, -0.012016296, -0.0032253265, 0.0001039505, 0.048309326, 0.055236816, -0.014343262, 0.022735596, 0.05130005, -0.025939941, 0.0146102905, 0.011764526, -0.011390686, 0.020767212, -0.033111572, -0.02911377, 0.015777588, 0.012687683, -0.0027923584, 0.04220581, -0.045959473, -0.0087509155, -0.022354126, -0.0035476685, 0.022979736, 0.014190674, 0.040161133, -0.00459671, -0.031280518, -0.0028076172, 0.017364502, 0.02708435, -0.04336548, 0.010353088, 0.09875488, 0.020950317, 0.017913818, 0.018966675, 0.029708862, -0.02067566, -0.0026397705, -0.008888245, 0.02607727, -0.007980347, -0.0030899048, -0.006877899, -0.023880005, 0.020645142, -0.052642822, 0.0096588135, -0.018173218, 0.024658203, -0.004753113, 0.013290405, -0.05529785, 0.020599365, -0.0496521, -0.023330688, 0.023208618, 0.06173706, 0.00076818466, -0.0002373457, -0.014572144, 0.027145386, 0.0087890625, -0.02911377, -0.034423828, 0.031677246, -0.004764557, -0.05596924, -0.015686035, 0.015197754, -0.051940918, -0.041503906, -0.0178833, 0.04458618, 0.033477783, 0.006919861, 0.013870239, -0.026138306, 0.00504303, -0.048309326, 0.000009655952, 0.0017213821, -0.023834229, 0.02557373, 0.004764557, 0.055664062, 0.04827881, -0.0158844, -0.059417725, 0.0017347336, -0.008682251, 0.015350342, -0.0011405945, -0.036865234, 0.001534462, -0.037322998, 0.016448975, -0.007194519, -0.026306152, -0.019454956, 0.017837524, 0.0041885376, -0.020980835, 0.040222168, 0.00016641617, 0.038208008, 0.021270752, -0.0056114197, 0.030960083, -0.04269409, -0.048675537, 0.075683594, 0.021743774, 0.016860962, -0.018295288, -0.027175903, -0.051879883, 0.032196045, -0.0362854, 0.029800415, 0.013870239, 0.018234253, -0.017562866, -0.0005226135, -0.001200676, 0.026275635, -0.032318115, -0.027633667, -0.007019043, -0.0036506653, 0.038909912, -0.04159546, 0.021987915, 0.009407043, -0.05947876, 0.0051460266, 0.014778137, -0.04058838, -0.026947021, -0.039245605, 0.0079574585, -0.045776367, -0.025650024, 0.016937256, -0.008430481, 0.008636475, 0.022598267, -0.045562744, -0.040039062, 0.055755615, 0.002588272, 0.004146576, 0.032287598, -0.0079574585, 0.000330925, -0.010604858, -0.015144348, 0.0005097389, 0.050689697, -0.008140564, -0.018539429, 0.044891357, -0.01727295, 0.009162903, 0.05230713, 0.057403564, -0.011421204, -0.015136719, -0.010444641, 0.041229248, -0.066223145, 0.05026245, 0.04559326, 0.011024475, -0.11077881, 0.047332764, -0.0067481995, 0.014015198, 0.019943237, 0.0028076172, 0.0063476562, -0.01626587, 0.03286743, 0.020599365, -0.010055542, 0.01399231, 0.006351471, -0.07733154, -0.019592285, 0.0049057007, 0.0112838745, -0.030731201, -0.010406494, 0.0010080338, -0.030929565, 0.03414917, -0.014183044, -0.018127441, -0.010025024, 0.007461548, -0.05734253, -0.04727173, -0.041168213, -0.045898438, 0.008331299, 0.005012512, -0.024719238, -0.016098022, 0.03793335, -0.003326416, -0.057128906, 0.030914307, 0.00016236305, -0.014526367, -0.017913818, -0.067993164, 0.01285553, -0.009536743, -0.042419434, -0.023483276, 0.020843506, 0.011405945, 0.02809143, -0.022033691, 0.008460999, 0.024032593, 0.017486572, -0.013023376, 0.025177002, -0.025985718, -0.006351471, 0.026535034, -0.025283813, -0.033294678, 0.015823364, 0.021575928, -0.023757935, -0.044036865, 0.012504578, -0.0082092285, -0.008338928, -0.05923462, 0.00007998943, 0.0032215118, 0.03729248, 0.01247406, 0.0037250519, 0.015640259, 0.015098572, 0.0033950806, -0.0003607273, -0.03942871, 0.008377075, -0.0005030632, 0.04095459, -0.034851074, 0.03933716, 0.060180664, -0.008331299, -0.065979004, 0.0340271, 0.04663086, 0.05722046, -0.037017822, 0.0019893646, -0.00009089708, -0.048675537, -0.009727478, 0.0017385483, -0.0112838745, 0.046661377, -0.05697632, 0.052703857, -0.006706238, -0.019699097, -0.0073890686, -0.020065308, 0.00982666, -0.017852783, 0.012062073, -0.052520752, -0.088378906, -0.028411865, 0.070739746, -0.0027980804, -0.025344849, 0.006767273, 0.055725098, 0.0020885468, 0.043182373, 0.028533936, 0.014183044, -0.013755798, 0.0018844604, 0.011276245, -0.03366089, -0.058624268, -0.011650085, -0.036743164, 0.006565094, 0.04373169, -0.05001831, -0.09106445, -0.012542725, -0.03451538, -0.01473999, 0.062316895, -0.04623413, 0.009757996, 0.10675049, -0.023773193, 0.052368164, 0.016113281, 0.021408081, 0.0065994263, 0.035858154, -0.0063095093, 0.0070533752, 0.034301758, -0.032836914, 0.018997192, 0.009086609, 0.025314331, -0.019699097, -0.011390686, -0.0028972626, -0.03463745, -0.01890564, 0.024215698, -0.010231018, -0.00067949295, 0.007850647, -0.031143188, 0.0071258545, 0.018737793, 0.0055389404, -0.0033683777, -0.04473877, -0.013938904, 0.030059814, -0.047698975, -0.005252838, 0.032592773, -0.02835083, -0.024917603, -0.05645752, -0.020248413, -0.022003174, 0.0053863525, -0.0068473816, 0.04147339, -0.021347046, 0.018920898, 0.0016927719, -0.020645142, -0.017501831, 0.021026611, -0.0005760193, 0.032989502, 0.011329651, -0.05380249, 0.006462097, -0.037017822, -0.044128418, -0.06616211, 0.0041122437, 0.0056037903, 0.02418518, -0.011390686, 0.009605408, 0.034454346, -0.02947998, 0.01763916, 0.045898438, -0.021881104, 0.025894165, 0.015113831, 0.030181885, 0.019500732, -0.017730713, 0.014694214, 0.013923645, -0.016052246, 0.0068473816, 0.016067505, 0.018035889, -0.0025405884, 0.00089263916, -0.010192871, -0.013832092, 0.033081055, -0.019363403, -0.040100098, -0.0014343262, 0.025299072, -0.052459717, -0.011169434, -0.030380249, 0.07165527, -0.07421875, -0.051452637, -0.028823853, -0.0036449432, -0.05895996, 0.018356323, -0.01146698, -0.036956787, -0.025894165, -0.044006348, -0.02986145, 0.0020580292, 0.023162842, 0.008972168, 0.023895264, -0.048736572, -0.0015220642, -0.07739258, 0.023345947, -0.035369873, 0.0022144318, -0.027496338, -0.025405884, 0.010101318, 0.03845215, -0.002035141, -0.027496338, -0.007019043, 0.048309326, 0.025253296, 0.037200928, -0.0826416, -0.020828247, -0.01751709, 0.014328003, 0.043182373, 0.011047363, -0.0064926147, 0.02456665, 0.0051345825, 0.01725769, 0.00077295303, 0.020751953, 0.06304932, 0.031021118, -0.044769287, -0.014709473, -0.013641357, -0.044128418, 0.0037593842, -0.052734375, -0.013336182, -0.048614502, -0.03277588, -0.031921387, -0.019851685, 0.03817749, 0.013801575, 0.02192688, -0.005874634, 0.015731812, 0.016204834, 0.01436615, -0.0015411377, 0.025741577, 0.046783447, -0.011268616, 0.027572632, 0.04043579, 0.013290405, 0.023803711, 0.008010864, 0.005455017, 0.013000488, -0.021530151, -0.013549805, 0.027679443, 0.018661499, 0.0073928833, -0.003074646, -0.008728027, 0.090026855, 0.031402588, 0.048614502, 0.05810547, 0.017471313, -0.008453369, -0.044525146, 0.007293701, 0.00056886673, -0.021438599, 0.00019538403, 0.018936157, 0.0050354004, -0.00044035912, -0.04348755, -0.028198242, 0.034729004, 0.0018548965, 0.059509277, -0.06518555, -0.04650879, 0.038085938, 0.026535034, -0.009292603, -0.018051147, -0.041290283, -0.012634277, 0.015838623, 0.020523071, -0.017532349, -0.015899658, 0.019454956, 0.042022705, 0.0073242188, 0.013076782, 0.0013484955, -0.0032348633, -0.010612488, 0.03540039, -0.04989624, 0.019515991, -0.006729126, -0.041259766, -0.00869751, 0.01134491, -0.039215088, -0.024841309, 0.019546509, 0.042266846, 0.08544922, 0.074523926, 0.0062294006, 0.017105103, 0.04336548, -0.056396484, 0.055145264, 0.030639648, -0.022613525, 0.0068092346, -0.01399231, -0.041259766, 0.03869629, -0.045440674, 0.07006836, -0.030059814, 0.010192871, -0.022354126, 0.015449524, 0.011985779, -0.050842285, -0.009651184, -0.021652222, 0.011695862, -0.022949219, -0.02279663, -0.045074463, -0.03277588, -0.014381409, 0.043884277, 0.0027065277, 0.0028915405, 0.005130768, -0.0014009476, -0.05505371, 0.005958557, -0.028778076, 0.034973145, -0.018493652, -0.0060272217, -0.0087509155, -0.018753052, 0.008682251, -0.03778076, -0.021743774, -0.046295166, -0.019546509, -0.055511475, 0.01322937, 0.0023860931, -0.02468872, 0.008140564, -0.041168213, 0.0155181885, -0.028198242, -0.016281128, 0.0340271, -0.0524292, -0.0012769699, -0.005607605, -0.017715454, 0.025299072, 0.03237915, 0.010429382, 0.0129776, 0.0064582825, 0.013000488, -0.007129669, 0.015365601, 0.029342651, -0.012397766, -0.02748108, 0.013420105, 0.013252258, 0.03753662, -0.048034668, -0.029083252, -0.010177612, 0.024734497, 0.01121521, 0.044769287, 0.009841919, -0.00013196468, -0.045166016, 0.031677246, -0.0013341904, -0.019638062, -0.0090408325, 0.026306152, 0.012931824, 0.039642334, 0.0015115738, 0.0045204163, 0.021774292, -0.059661865, 0.0104599, -0.009498596, -0.0017232895, 0.015609741, -0.04034424, 0.017044067, -0.024551392, 0.0054473877, 0.0018548965, -0.041809082, 0.00066423416, -0.027023315, -0.014282227, 0.015022278, -0.059265137, 0.03164673, 0.023269653, -0.0463562, 0.008026123, 0.03048706, 0.016677856, 0.07531738, -0.032958984, -0.08148193, -0.018325806, 0.0031108856, -0.015625, -0.011405945, 0.024902344, 0.0138549805, 0.0010633469, -0.008651733, -0.06750488, 0.003873825, -0.05050659, 0.037322998, -0.050842285, 0.014022827, -0.019500732, -0.019241333, 0.0134887695, 0.051330566, 0.034606934, 0.011672974, -0.053863525, -0.03149414, 0.04324341, -0.044158936 ], "summary": [ -0.007369995, -0.005744934, -0.01096344, -0.014312744, -0.033477783, -0.006416321, -0.04144287, -0.01876831, 0.02229309, 0.011543274, 0.020523071, -0.005455017, -0.011383057, -0.04928589, 0.0073890686, -0.010940552, 0.020706177, 0.0075950623, 0.00078344345, -0.012031555, -0.0011959076, -0.02267456, 0.019134521, 0.049194336, 0.008728027, 0.017837524, -0.06286621, -0.0032424927, -0.028274536, -0.009048462, -0.0013484955, 0.038757324, 0.020736694, -0.0071372986, 0.017974854, 0.02142334, 0.011520386, -0.030685425, 0.018981934, 0.014183044, 0.029129028, -0.013946533, -0.022857666, 0.0016174316, -0.013465881, -0.04373169, 0.04437256, -0.015731812, 0.032043457, 0.013694763, 0.0047683716, -0.04196167, 0.017532349, -0.054534912, -0.03652954, -0.04345703, -0.050567627, 0.015075684, 0.007411957, 0.09588623, 0.0413208, 0.013641357, -0.04135132, -0.061462402, 0.013763428, 0.013626099, 0.046875, 0.02015686, 0.037384033, 0.0068130493, -0.024002075, 0.011375427, 0.022583008, 0.0076560974, -0.027236938, -0.03314209, 0.044525146, 0.0211792, 0.028823853, -0.028411865, -0.044006348, 0.04324341, -0.0256958, -0.079956055, 0.03567505, -0.036743164, -0.038269043, 0.0016498566, 0.013076782, 0.002248764, -0.016204834, 0.033050537, 0.029968262, 0.010978699, -0.024749756, -0.01007843, -0.029953003, -0.0289917, 0.03866577, 0.07733154, 0.061065674, -0.05215454, 0.14099121, -0.06210327, 0.0073509216, 0.05343628, -0.002603531, -0.0053977966, 0.03262329, -0.0037250519, 0.014259338, 0.002773285, -0.027786255, -0.07159424, 0.045135498, 0.054351807, -0.016601562, 0.047546387, 0.02507019, -0.0015983582, -0.027862549, -0.02217102, 0.020736694, -0.0019989014, -0.004924774, -0.034423828, -0.025115967, 0.027053833, -0.02418518, -0.022506714, -0.018798828, 0.041107178, 0.028213501, 0.020492554, -0.008293152, -0.0028533936, -0.009506226, 0.0287323, -0.009544373, -0.017684937, -0.009506226, 0.008285522, 0.022277832, -0.002319336, -0.044189453, 0.034973145, 0.019638062, -0.011352539, -0.020507812, -0.04434204, -0.06750488, 0.037322998, 0.029434204, -0.017990112, -0.017974854, -0.064208984, -0.05102539, -0.01448822, 0.06121826, -0.0046157837, 0.0044174194, 0.017929077, 0.056671143, 0.050750732, 0.024307251, -0.014915466, -0.023239136, -0.010398865, 0.018875122, 0.06225586, -0.019622803, -0.01991272, -0.048706055, 0.00025320053, -0.016052246, 0.025924683, 0.019729614, 0.014091492, 0.008399963, -0.021499634, -0.020492554, -0.029067993, 0.06451416, -0.024856567, -0.011749268, -0.021636963, 0.00869751, 0.01272583, -0.0037765503, 0.02130127, 0.023742676, 0.013435364, -0.023925781, -0.044952393, -0.06304932, 0.010978699, 0.039642334, 0.045776367, -0.0262146, 0.047698975, -0.037719727, 0.01260376, -0.0087509155, 0.017822266, -0.030685425, -0.0052337646, -0.019882202, 0.036132812, -0.024276733, 0.03427124, 0.027877808, -0.0031013489, -0.03137207, 0.008087158, 0.0054397583, -0.0017595291, 0.009765625, -0.028381348, -0.004951477, -0.0262146, -0.03552246, 0.025619507, -0.05758667, 0.021774292, 0.007949829, 0.014862061, -0.0058898926, 0.008125305, 0.053955078, 0.016937256, 0.03894043, -0.03378296, -0.015289307, 0.018203735, -0.008476257, 0.018463135, 0.039276123, 0.012123108, 0.0007195473, 0.0036907196, 0.006248474, -0.005290985, -0.02178955, 0.04397583, 0.056793213, 0.01876831, -0.00028562546, 0.03741455, -0.0004968643, 0.035980225, -0.0046920776, 0.014564514, 0.01209259, 0.002538681, 0.01008606, 0.015899658, -0.048675537, -0.02557373, -0.026779175, 0.035217285, 0.0005736351, 0.051483154, 0.041625977, -0.001868248, 0.022369385, -0.019119263, 0.008964539, 0.0087509155, -0.034484863, 0.0017004013, 0.032409668, 0.014221191, 0.0036067963, -0.031188965, -0.096069336, -0.04083252, -0.021911621, 0.058624268, -0.007369995, -0.03994751, -0.028808594, -0.04095459, 0.019577026, -0.008911133, 0.04724121, 0.027664185, 0.04321289, -0.03277588, 0.024047852, 0.047210693, 0.058441162, 0.0056991577, 0.0005264282, -0.010627747, 0.04244995, -0.023223877, 0.025894165, 0.008110046, 0.016540527, -0.013999939, -0.0019493103, 0.03753662, -0.0124053955, -0.008087158, 0.0023593903, 0.062286377, 0.004722595, -0.015037537, -0.0004696846, 0.00006580353, -0.0022506714, 0.022109985, 0.019515991, 0.04837036, 0.010818481, -0.013191223, 0.015296936, 0.052703857, 0.056030273, 0.06286621, 0.060302734, -0.024810791, 0.0050354004, 0.024124146, -0.017669678, -0.034210205, 0.043640137, -0.018310547, -0.023529053, 0.021575928, -0.0023994446, -0.026824951, -0.015380859, -0.0053253174, -0.0058631897, -0.008018494, -0.0028057098, 0.0005226135, -0.0006170273, 0.0132369995, -0.015075684, 0.054534912, 0.005996704, -0.048034668, 0.024307251, -0.016418457, 0.01776123, 0.010414124, -0.023391724, 0.011444092, 0.017501831, -0.027740479, 0.004951477, 0.009216309, 0.023910522, 0.04776001, -0.01586914, 0.0030231476, 0.038909912, -0.047180176, -0.029937744, 0.03201294, -0.03149414, 0.028961182, -0.021575928, -0.013092041, 0.02671814, 0.021057129, 0.019729614, 0.05633545, 0.042541504, 0.024353027, -0.049560547, -0.02053833, -0.047180176, -0.033599854, 0.086364746, 0.01776123, 0.022613525, 0.045288086, 0.045837402, 0.044708252, -0.007904053, -0.011260986, 0.10809326, 0.011772156, 0.011360168, 0.036224365, 0.024871826, -0.004600525, -0.037719727, -0.038513184, 0.04006958, -0.04046631, -0.019332886, -0.0035858154, 0.0033798218, 0.041931152, 0.024719238, -0.025772095, -0.041900635, 0.038085938, 0.019424438, -0.007534027, -0.011413574, -0.017288208, -0.034851074, -0.029571533, 0.033996582, 0.03390503, 0.01134491, -0.0006289482, 0.010047913, 0.020889282, -0.022338867, -0.00064468384, 0.03390503, -0.0012025833, 0.023330688, -0.043151855, -0.023635864, 0.029510498, -0.015991211, -0.025146484, 0.010795593, 0.052764893, 0.019241333, 0.0068130493, -0.0005159378, -0.041015625, 0.0368042, -0.062561035, 0.002872467, 0.015304565, -0.00970459, 0.040985107, -0.0056915283, -0.012451172, 0.050964355, -0.041656494, -0.03353882, -0.0003478527, 0.00074386597, 0.0158844, 0.011436462, -0.016174316, -0.0053482056, -0.02671814, 0.051452637, -0.031341553, -0.020980835, -0.013961792, 0.050689697, 0.0126953125, -0.027679443, 0.040039062, 0.005016327, 0.050689697, 0.07470703, -0.004863739, 0.02482605, -0.026779175, -0.03604126, 0.054504395, -0.019348145, 0.040374756, -0.06323242, 0.00024747849, -0.044830322, 0.0018053055, -0.027252197, 0.04827881, -0.023117065, 0.018951416, -0.022872925, -0.010643005, 0.018615723, 0.051879883, -0.005455017, -0.0206604, -0.011497498, 0.006916046, 0.07318115, -0.02748108, 0.003446579, 0.016845703, -0.030456543, -0.01991272, 0.00064086914, -0.0077438354, -0.018234253, -0.021759033, 0.010871887, -0.050872803, -0.022979736, 0.013336182, 0.002986908, 0.013046265, 0.007446289, -0.022750854, -0.018295288, -0.02558899, -0.032989502, -0.0038452148, 0.0035972595, 0.031158447, 0.034210205, -0.007347107, -0.010932922, -0.032073975, 0.04284668, -0.055511475, 0.02973938, 0.04498291, -0.00907135, 0.009124756, 0.053771973, 0.017059326, 0.013725281, -0.009246826, 0.008300781, 0.0390625, -0.047943115, 0.024765015, 0.062438965, 0.027526855, -0.10089111, 0.05102539, -0.020904541, 0.020889282, 0.024719238, 0.029205322, -0.04446411, -0.055236816, 0.04849243, -0.031982422, -0.019226074, 0.034118652, 0.023330688, -0.06463623, -0.0064735413, 0.014160156, 0.010437012, -0.029266357, 0.0029697418, -0.03213501, -0.016296387, 0.024932861, -0.02204895, 0.010940552, -0.016479492, -0.018707275, -0.052246094, -0.04849243, -0.012672424, 0.035064697, 0.024429321, -0.013870239, -0.04876709, -0.014572144, -0.007217407, -0.02255249, -0.029220581, 0.04675293, 0.027053833, 0.028060913, -0.037597656, -0.07824707, 0.03491211, -0.030899048, -0.03353882, -0.016418457, -0.00009852648, -0.017913818, 0.028900146, -0.005794525, 0.013061523, 0.009590149, -0.018035889, -0.06286621, -0.011802673, 0.00018775463, 0.041046143, -0.011505127, -0.0029182434, -0.014801025, 0.023620605, -0.0090408325, -0.009529114, -0.03677368, -0.009544373, 0.005306244, -0.03262329, -0.03213501, 0.0059318542, 0.025527954, 0.031799316, -0.006164551, 0.0022010803, 0.013595581, -0.013420105, -0.0101623535, 0.005592346, -0.023025513, 0.01928711, -0.003692627, 0.010185242, -0.009757996, 0.028381348, 0.012931824, -0.027282715, -0.064086914, 0.030456543, 0.042877197, 0.029724121, -0.05050659, -0.03137207, 0.032196045, 0.0034160614, -0.016937256, 0.0055770874, -0.027694702, 0.0031166077, -0.006832123, 0.018737793, 0.03604126, -0.046813965, -0.012664795, -0.022842407, -0.00198555, -0.0053215027, -0.01285553, -0.024749756, -0.05697632, -0.022399902, 0.058746338, -0.0033245087, -0.053619385, -0.012802124, 0.042877197, -0.0022449493, 0.012191772, -0.012001038, 0.052581787, -0.0064201355, 0.014656067, 0.034576416, -0.027832031, -0.008338928, -0.00907135, -0.03982544, -0.0119018555, 0.057281494, -0.064331055, -0.04248047, -0.015266418, -0.029296875, 0.0012865067, 0.051727295, -0.03137207, -0.046905518, 0.054534912, -0.013061523, 0.018676758, 0.038848877, -0.007835388, 0.02067566, 0.043914795, -0.013755798, -0.0079422, 0.010383606, -0.009933472, 0.014564514, -0.018951416, -0.009162903, -0.012069702, 0.021865845, 0.0067214966, -0.018737793, -0.01033783, -0.0040626526, -0.022064209, 0.04055786, -0.00856781, -0.011398315, 0.030410767, -0.008529663, -0.020324707, -0.015777588, -0.024871826, -0.030822754, -0.0021343231, -0.032958984, -0.043640137, 0.0053482056, -0.041107178, -0.021469116, -0.03894043, -0.07696533, -0.0026397705, 0.031707764, -0.019577026, 0.052215576, -0.017333984, -0.004699707, -0.0072135925, 0.024124146, -0.01889038, 0.014305115, -0.011390686, -0.011329651, 0.029632568, -0.038482666, 0.0033359528, -0.009765625, -0.03302002, -0.050811768, -0.022964478, -0.020736694, 0.029891968, -0.017166138, 0.032562256, 0.068725586, -0.040161133, 0.017852783, 0.043518066, -0.005393982, 0.0057792664, 0.01474762, 0.025360107, 0.029327393, -0.068847656, 0.0037326813, 0.012565613, -0.021438599, 0.029266357, 0.0059013367, 0.021499634, 0.016220093, 0.001168251, 0.009010315, -0.033081055, 0.045196533, 0.0013284683, -0.021820068, 0.008956909, 0.009292603, -0.074157715, 0.004589081, -0.021026611, 0.02243042, -0.021774292, -0.08215332, 0.0064582825, 0.021606445, -0.014442444, -0.01940918, -0.009124756, -0.06536865, 0.014663696, -0.010215759, 0.010810852, -0.002292633, -0.012954712, -0.013572693, -0.005142212, -0.042236328, -0.025299072, -0.009239197, 0.004611969, -0.009033203, -0.015037537, -0.008079529, 0.011276245, 0.02658081, 0.033843994, -0.0033836365, -0.008529663, -0.00843811, 0.050476074, 0.01725769, 0.02961731, -0.07659912, -0.010375977, -0.010635376, 0.05496216, 0.050750732, 0.0044021606, -0.017074585, -0.01071167, 0.023376465, 0.019104004, -0.0038452148, -0.0014724731, 0.025909424, 0.036743164, -0.029876709, -0.017700195, 0.01234436, -0.028533936, -0.009086609, -0.013954163, -0.02619934, 0.0037574768, -0.032836914, 0.017120361, 0.022262573, 0.02217102, 0.0021591187, 0.01991272, 0.008964539, -0.0048294067, -0.0021457672, -0.021224976, -0.008735657, 0.004989624, 0.07086182, -0.034851074, 0.03744507, 0.049713135, -0.013420105, 0.02897644, 0.023284912, -0.011016846, 0.02859497, -0.019042969, 0.01007843, 0.020385742, -0.0034828186, -0.028137207, 0.020111084, -0.029953003, 0.08703613, 0.049835205, 0.06506348, 0.030578613, -0.016281128, 0.06500244, -0.06744385, -0.009208679, 0.007472992, -0.01977539, 0.015289307, -0.0048294067, 0.038726807, -0.014930725, -0.018920898, -0.037506104, 0.075805664, -0.023849487, 0.07989502, -0.06463623, -0.04083252, 0.013710022, 0.018844604, -0.019897461, -0.046691895, -0.043701172, -0.00466156, 0.018966675, 0.0040512085, -0.00187397, -0.023986816, 0.01838684, 0.015838623, 0.023117065, 0.040893555, -0.0045928955, 0.029541016, -0.016235352, 0.024353027, -0.051971436, 0.0012331009, -0.041259766, -0.0357666, 0.0000063180923, -0.009643555, -0.00016129017, -0.010475159, -0.0045814514, 0.07543945, 0.078308105, 0.047790527, -0.03074646, 0.013771057, 0.119140625, -0.033721924, 0.02444458, -0.022613525, 0.0061683655, -0.020523071, -0.013786316, 0.013069153, -0.004432678, -0.007835388, 0.026763916, -0.022140503, -0.0016012192, -0.03881836, 0.03338623, -0.03842163, -0.04168701, -0.0026378632, -0.053741455, 0.008033752, -0.021560669, -0.02609253, -0.05227661, -0.019165039, -0.04067993, 0.029296875, -0.00022757053, 0.009605408, 0.033996582, -0.013404846, -0.045776367, -0.0059127808, 0.002828598, 0.04849243, -0.0002834797, -0.026443481, -0.011985779, 0.025436401, 0.0132369995, -0.08123779, -0.015945435, -0.01838684, 0.017227173, 0.00094795227, -0.004348755, -0.0067825317, -0.011070251, 0.030822754, 0.015090942, 0.03074646, -0.0104599, -0.0069274902, 0.00091695786, -0.01360321, 0.03643799, -0.007598877, 0.004951477, -0.016342163, -0.0016059875, 0.025161743, 0.0440979, 0.016021729, 0.041168213, -0.02709961, 0.012565613, -0.01864624, 0.010566711, 0.00009793043, -0.0011692047, 0.0075912476, 0.023025513, -0.017807007, 0.002286911, 0.004005432, -0.019760132, 0.017944336, 0.03302002, 0.016098022, 0.023880005, -0.034698486, 0.028900146, -0.010513306, -0.02104187, 0.046936035, 0.028793335, -0.02835083, 0.023986816, -0.015396118, 0.013206482, 0.0039711, -0.03729248, 0.016860962, -0.022903442, 0.023712158, -0.004383087, -0.053771973, -0.014678955, -0.022216797, -0.0013914108, 0.04031372, -0.06149292, -0.014221191, -0.07043457, -0.004055023, -0.0029506683, -0.09539795, -0.044433594, 0.08081055, 0.05001831, -0.048339844, -0.028915405, 0.060058594, 0.013519287, 0.0078086853, -0.08337402, -0.027267456, -0.013427734, 0.0096588135, -0.0317688, -0.02859497, 0.0071525574, -0.019714355, 0.04232788, -0.05596924, 0.038238525, -0.036895752, 0.04244995, -0.021942139, -0.004558563, 0.04083252, -0.035736084, 0.019927979, 0.04638672, 0.017120361, 0.043548584, -0.02671814, -0.03781128, 0.00712204, -0.021865845 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2112.06292v1
Gamifying optimization: a Wasserstein distance-based analysis of human search
Antonio Candelieri, Andrea Ponti, Francesco Archetti
math.OC, cs.AI, cs.LG, 62F15,, G.3; I.2.0
The main objective of this paper is to outline a theoretical framework to characterise humans' decision-making strategies under uncertainty, in particular active learning in a black-box optimization task and trading-off between information gathering (exploration) and reward seeking (exploitation). Humans' decisions making according to these two objectives can be modelled in terms of Pareto rationality. If a decision set contains a Pareto efficient strategy, a rational decision maker should always select the dominant strategy over its dominated alternatives. A distance from the Pareto frontier determines whether a choice is Pareto rational. To collect data about humans' strategies we have used a gaming application that shows the game field, with previous decisions and observations, as well as the score obtained. The key element in this paper is the representation of behavioural patterns of human learners as a discrete probability distribution. This maps the problem of the characterization of humans' behaviour into a space whose elements are probability distributions structured by a distance between histograms, namely the Wasserstein distance (WST). The distributional analysis gives new insights about human search strategies and their deviations from Pareto rationality. Since the uncertainty is one of the two objectives defining the Pareto frontier, the analysis has been performed for three different uncertainty quantification measures to identify which better explains the Pareto compliant behavioural patterns. Beside the analysis of individual patterns WST has also enabled a global analysis computing the barycenters and WST k-means clustering. A further analysis has been performed by a decision tree to relate non-Paretian behaviour, characterized by exasperated exploitation, to the dynamics of the evolution of the reward seeking process.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2112.06292v1
"2021-12-12T18:23:46"
"2021-12-12T18:23:46"
{ "title": [ 0.018859863, 0.009925842, 0.009376526, 0.02079773, 0.008529663, -0.031921387, 0.008171082, -0.070495605, -0.043151855, 0.03567505, 0.029174805, 0.011054993, -0.025970459, -0.015930176, -0.027832031, -0.009841919, 0.0009126663, -0.0041923523, -0.018630981, -0.0385437, -0.018600464, -0.03488159, 0.013198853, 0.04547119, 0.030929565, -0.0042648315, -0.039215088, -0.014656067, -0.0146865845, -0.035125732, 0.0008845329, 0.013870239, 0.05999756, -0.016220093, 0.018676758, 0.012557983, -0.034942627, -0.0010251999, -0.042816162, 0.046905518, 0.019012451, -0.018325806, -0.06964111, -0.0019159317, -0.059692383, -0.012748718, -0.003189087, 0.013160706, -0.012458801, 0.042633057, 0.021530151, 0.037353516, 0.021377563, 0.0079574585, 0.021621704, -0.013656616, 0.010360718, -0.042510986, 0.038879395, 0.02355957, 0.0071487427, -0.037261963, 0.024246216, -0.007675171, -0.038116455, -0.0072746277, 0.001619339, 0.017364502, 0.03475952, -0.0151901245, -0.023742676, 0.010597229, -0.0068893433, 0.014930725, -0.030090332, -0.02420044, 0.052001953, 0.0042533875, 0.019561768, 0.0014572144, -0.03112793, -0.038726807, -0.016693115, -0.068481445, 0.05456543, -0.015327454, -0.015090942, 0.007297516, -0.036254883, -0.046905518, -0.008651733, -0.0069618225, -0.009437561, 0.0062217712, -0.023330688, -0.018081665, -0.011383057, 0.053771973, 0.0006198883, -0.028549194, -0.040100098, 0.021896362, -0.06896973, -0.023529053, -0.0031719208, 0.013954163, -0.0051727295, -0.021484375, 0.00806427, 0.02142334, -0.021408081, -0.010688782, -0.00072717667, 0.032592773, -0.015945435, -0.024993896, -0.027267456, 0.012336731, -0.01651001, 0.03640747, 0.0040626526, -0.02558899, 0.053833008, -0.0033359528, 0.04031372, 0.018630981, -0.06762695, 0.009498596, -0.02848816, 0.032928467, -0.002986908, 0.033477783, -0.07092285, -0.051361084, -0.047607422, 0.02861023, -0.009353638, -0.019180298, 0.0052337646, 0.016464233, 0.0048179626, -0.03640747, 0.012802124, 0.006832123, 0.038024902, 0.015213013, 0.06933594, -0.014724731, -0.0440979, 0.018341064, -0.024612427, 0.057250977, 0.017471313, 0.010269165, -0.058929443, 0.007259369, -0.13513184, 0.02911377, 0.012001038, 0.0052337646, -0.001953125, 0.006286621, 0.015365601, 0.020492554, 0.05126953, -0.023727417, -0.016738892, 0.043060303, 0.0045051575, 0.0513916, -0.002779007, 0.023651123, -0.059387207, -0.019714355, -0.0021095276, -0.011993408, 0.0368042, 0.0046424866, 0.028305054, 0.00687027, 0.011253357, -0.0038909912, 0.06137085, 0.00075674057, -0.06829834, 0.00024342537, -0.015792847, -0.004501343, 0.053100586, -0.004348755, -0.054992676, 0.04748535, -0.0385437, -0.04815674, -0.058624268, -0.028823853, 0.031921387, 0.003698349, -0.006549835, 0.054779053, 0.0014066696, -0.0074005127, -0.021591187, 0.013008118, -0.03591919, -0.02909851, -0.022750854, 0.0104904175, -0.06124878, 0.035247803, 0.050231934, 0.014076233, -0.046051025, 0.024291992, 0.034851074, -0.020614624, 0.031219482, 0.0029468536, -0.006969452, -0.015525818, -0.019210815, -0.013397217, -0.01928711, 0.047912598, -0.0047683716, -0.008735657, 0.017349243, -0.014518738, 0.060791016, 0.014465332, 0.08557129, -0.04107666, 0.01184845, 0.025039673, 0.0054016113, -0.014213562, 0.02017212, -0.014808655, 0.032073975, 0.0008211136, 0.0039405823, 0.012504578, -0.0021305084, 0.04421997, 0.04510498, -0.02142334, 0.0031356812, 0.011016846, 0.014976501, 0.05001831, 0.05218506, 0.027420044, 0.038085938, 0.013145447, -0.020553589, 0.07757568, -0.014633179, 0.013137817, -0.0051727295, 0.017684937, -0.0044136047, -0.009017944, 0.034088135, -0.01071167, -0.06100464, 0.013626099, -0.035247803, -0.0057373047, 0.012588501, 0.0045051575, 0.03250122, -0.020019531, 0.023269653, -0.0046157837, 0.014099121, -0.053710938, -0.010856628, 0.02029419, 0.017105103, -0.066467285, -0.01449585, 0.011581421, 0.03894043, -0.0008778572, -0.006164551, -0.0002412796, 0.035247803, 0.0026474, 0.008056641, -0.003932953, 0.038238525, -0.00006955862, -0.035308838, 0.02319336, -0.008483887, -0.026901245, 0.006942749, 0.10571289, -0.057159424, 0.04046631, -0.060821533, 0.005420685, 0.021377563, -0.024642944, -0.0000988245, 0.019515991, 0.017745972, 0.029281616, -0.016906738, 0.0004992485, -0.021331787, 0.023910522, 0.01991272, -0.032196045, -0.011161804, -0.034240723, -0.012023926, -0.029632568, -0.091918945, -0.094177246, 0.01878357, -0.030456543, -0.037384033, 0.013313293, -0.017532349, -0.0016078949, -0.0027618408, -0.028656006, 0.009468079, 0.013938904, 0.010673523, 0.014953613, -0.07287598, 0.028686523, -0.000875473, 0.028411865, -0.024017334, 0.010276794, -0.029663086, 0.012001038, -0.021102905, 0.02293396, 0.03564453, -0.040863037, -0.008781433, -0.029525757, -0.0014781952, 0.02229309, 0.015136719, -0.008041382, 0.010871887, -0.03164673, -0.030258179, 0.001704216, 0.07397461, -0.017288208, -0.0031585693, 0.062164307, 0.077819824, 0.014839172, 0.023895264, 0.017974854, 0.009391785, -0.0118255615, -0.024551392, -0.05807495, -0.01448822, 0.020233154, 0.022827148, 0.052825928, -0.046295166, -0.041229248, -0.0084991455, 0.020904541, 0.041046143, 0.021362305, 0.013313293, -0.027954102, 0.00434494, 0.0023860931, -0.011497498, 0.01776123, -0.032348633, 0.035827637, 0.09588623, 0.006378174, 0.012458801, 0.0051193237, 0.0446167, 0.019805908, 0.0031089783, -0.027236938, -0.002986908, 0.0035171509, 0.020339966, -0.0087509155, -0.03503418, 0.0038337708, -0.09869385, 0.01550293, 0.04196167, 0.0151901245, -0.0060768127, 0.031311035, -0.07336426, 0.0635376, -0.004180908, -0.002910614, 0.029342651, 0.0519104, -0.032440186, -0.012313843, -0.01158905, -0.03149414, 0.024154663, -0.021118164, -0.07110596, 0.033477783, -0.020828247, -0.05429077, -0.0053596497, -0.0020885468, -0.041625977, -0.012374878, 0.0021343231, 0.040374756, 0.05456543, 0.012123108, 0.020751953, 0.011894226, 0.03668213, -0.010513306, -0.014808655, -0.034240723, -0.03314209, -0.0040397644, -0.026016235, 0.072387695, 0.0005979538, 0.006210327, -0.04727173, -0.0053977966, -0.02041626, 0.019699097, -0.026168823, -0.013916016, 0.0030460358, -0.025604248, -0.0017557144, 0.0053253174, -0.006126404, -0.008453369, -0.025680542, 0.002696991, -0.034484863, 0.03463745, 0.015563965, 0.00034546852, -0.015609741, 0.006454468, 0.004550934, 0.002614975, -0.04675293, -0.0001705885, -0.02154541, 0.011543274, 0.032043457, -0.030426025, -0.05319214, 0.022323608, -0.043823242, 0.030334473, 0.026138306, 0.009346008, -0.0079193115, -0.0043563843, -0.0023231506, 0.016738892, -0.030258179, -0.013092041, 0.020706177, -0.0020866394, 0.022827148, -0.044158936, -0.038391113, 0.021911621, -0.099121094, 0.0035991669, -0.000026345253, -0.0098724365, -0.01902771, -0.018829346, 0.029464722, -0.03579712, -0.026657104, -0.007598877, -0.0060653687, 0.029266357, -0.0039863586, -0.050872803, -0.031799316, 0.04751587, -0.050720215, -0.0009331703, 0.031051636, 0.012039185, -0.015823364, -0.023666382, 0.0050621033, -0.036102295, 0.033203125, -0.020462036, -0.027557373, 0.027130127, -0.027389526, 0.038024902, 0.005104065, 0.012702942, -0.009773254, -0.0039901733, 0.008140564, 0.04763794, -0.02722168, 0.05026245, 0.019226074, 0.015731812, -0.079956055, 0.031082153, 0.0046539307, -0.024032593, -0.016616821, -0.015472412, 0.023132324, 0.037719727, 0.022644043, 0.029647827, -0.015930176, -0.033691406, 0.029312134, 0.0206604, -0.009162903, -0.013168335, -0.005554199, 0.03717041, 0.007434845, -0.03375244, -0.042541504, -0.004951477, 0.024841309, -0.048431396, -0.0021190643, 0.0072135925, -0.07128906, -0.025939941, -0.04095459, -0.0066833496, -0.014633179, 0.021820068, -0.039001465, 0.011688232, 0.033355713, -0.0056419373, -0.04397583, 0.014816284, 0.029266357, -0.0093307495, -0.022262573, -0.07598877, 0.016113281, -0.009666443, -0.051574707, -0.042236328, 0.0070533752, -0.002653122, 0.04284668, -0.023483276, -0.030181885, 0.019714355, 0.018829346, 0.042266846, 0.018417358, -0.029037476, -0.03488159, 0.008171082, -0.041809082, -0.04168701, 0.046020508, -0.039733887, -0.007282257, -0.012031555, 0.0725708, -0.023590088, -0.018569946, -0.024810791, 0.029190063, -0.02758789, 0.04196167, 0.014595032, 0.046844482, 0.03866577, -0.008613586, 0.00983429, 0.008201599, -0.034729004, -0.008728027, -0.011161804, 0.019424438, -0.018371582, -0.011047363, -0.008811951, 0.019866943, 0.003025055, -0.0036640167, 0.01235199, -0.010818481, 0.025619507, -0.026351929, 0.02923584, -0.040649414, -0.011779785, -0.0011863708, -0.012832642, 0.024337769, -0.05303955, 0.09338379, -0.028167725, -0.024124146, 0.026306152, 0.0005197525, -0.005252838, -0.019165039, 0.0011615753, -0.080078125, -0.03250122, -0.021606445, 0.049346924, -0.05795288, -0.043304443, -0.013885498, 0.00067710876, 0.026138306, 0.053375244, -0.00035309792, -0.025146484, 0.0020389557, 0.010261536, -0.025054932, -0.03677368, -0.0579834, 0.014350891, 0.022140503, 0.031463623, -0.11553955, 0.06097412, 0.013893127, -0.032104492, -0.008682251, -0.016403198, 0.024017334, -0.057281494, 0.0014238358, 0.036346436, -0.009757996, 0.020599365, 0.0049819946, 0.032165527, 0.042419434, 0.016418457, 0.04208374, -0.031234741, 0.004798889, -0.013389587, 0.0423584, 0.0046310425, 0.004535675, -0.012802124, 0.029708862, -0.017288208, 0.014427185, -0.0287323, 0.027709961, 0.02394104, 0.013168335, 0.012001038, -0.035858154, 0.017364502, 0.053466797, -0.008651733, 0.03778076, -0.01184082, -0.03741455, -0.042114258, 0.008346558, -0.057434082, 0.018753052, 0.030670166, -0.0090789795, -0.12158203, 0.0020694733, -0.040374756, 0.010421753, -0.03439331, 0.025421143, -0.037872314, 0.035369873, 0.020355225, -0.026138306, -0.011131287, -0.00047254562, 0.019104004, 0.03173828, 0.022476196, -0.021072388, 0.0014972687, -0.0082092285, -0.04534912, -0.054901123, -0.007835388, -0.017913818, 0.021331787, -0.0066947937, -0.053527832, 0.00050115585, 0.040802002, 0.033935547, 0.03253174, -0.030303955, 0.027404785, 0.009986877, 0.0050468445, -0.0025596619, -0.009605408, -0.0178833, 0.016067505, 0.013084412, 0.042785645, 0.0034694672, 0.029907227, 0.0055885315, -0.025802612, -0.04748535, -0.01309967, 0.018981934, -0.011184692, -0.0008392334, 0.021820068, 0.030822754, 0.03765869, -0.017807007, 0.0006933212, 0.040496826, -0.033355713, 0.026046753, 0.008911133, 0.01108551, -0.028961182, 0.029632568, 0.008583069, 0.029724121, -0.041748047, -0.059417725, -0.03414917, -0.0032138824, 0.029525757, 0.015579224, 0.023880005, -0.039916992, -0.009735107, 0.006416321, -0.009796143, -0.041137695, -0.019470215, 0.0184021, -0.026275635, 0.05303955, 0.036590576, 0.019836426, -0.035003662, -0.018249512, -0.011489868, 0.01083374, 0.0115737915, -0.01398468, 0.0058021545, -0.016998291, -0.030914307, 0.011184692, 0.018341064, -0.044769287, 0.028076172, -0.042022705, 0.057617188, 0.045440674, 0.04788208, -0.001411438, -0.0032367706, 0.055114746, 0.035583496, 0.023162842, -0.012260437, 0.019866943, -0.042510986, 0.00573349, -0.02331543, -0.014801025, -0.08074951, 0.04168701, 0.017166138, 0.032165527, 0.03564453, 0.0040245056, 0.0362854, 0.010467529, 0.008895874, -0.023025513, 0.058441162, 0.002866745, -0.009529114, 0.03225708, -0.00067567825, 0.011138916, 0.034454346, -0.011039734, 0.012138367, 0.026657104, -0.04055786, -0.001282692, 0.023391724, 0.03353882, -0.0062065125, -0.009490967, -0.006286621, 0.008796692, -0.037475586, 0.05178833, 0.06451416, -0.014587402, 0.010292053, -0.029541016, -0.009155273, 0.009918213, -0.03414917, 0.020065308, 0.0287323, -0.049438477, 0.024017334, -0.015808105, -0.027450562, -0.016830444, 0.03274536, 0.032196045, -0.054016113, -0.00064373016, 0.0051193237, 0.025741577, -0.0067749023, 0.004371643, -0.051208496, 0.012763977, 0.004627228, -0.001958847, 0.0010404587, -0.03918457, -0.0010375977, 0.028411865, 0.001832962, -0.011474609, -0.0022411346, 0.006187439, -0.013282776, 0.026367188, -0.0044441223, 0.042999268, 0.002368927, -0.034210205, 0.022384644, 0.0104522705, -0.057495117, 0.01423645, -0.0074386597, 0.07623291, 0.06726074, 0.06958008, -0.00085401535, -0.009979248, 0.032196045, -0.045135498, 0.018081665, 0.049041748, 0.0061454773, 0.056518555, -0.049194336, -0.044647217, 0.047729492, -0.036376953, 0.03378296, -0.01171875, -0.010940552, -0.016067505, -0.013214111, 0.08532715, -0.054840088, -0.018035889, -0.023361206, -0.041778564, 0.014862061, 0.0049362183, -0.010520935, -0.010322571, -0.00074100494, 0.024337769, 0.03213501, -0.026062012, -0.009140015, 0.003982544, -0.07861328, 0.0015525818, -0.053222656, 0.05130005, -0.047790527, -0.028411865, -0.026794434, 0.011886597, 0.030685425, -0.0016412735, -0.052734375, 0.04397583, 0.008895874, -0.047698975, 0.03665161, 0.031051636, -0.011177063, 0.002603531, 0.036987305, -0.006778717, -0.007335663, -0.04776001, 0.017196655, -0.008644104, -0.08502197, -0.037841797, -0.021820068, -0.0149383545, 0.02218628, -0.0010271072, -0.009979248, 0.01473999, -0.02696228, -0.05709839, 0.0009741783, 0.010070801, -0.010910034, -0.03164673, 0.009429932, 0.028259277, 0.01878357, -0.032562256, -0.04107666, 0.007575989, 0.008720398, 0.00856781, 0.014289856, -0.025604248, -0.018447876, 0.038482666, 0.018463135, 0.018295288, -0.03829956, -0.05532837, 0.0079956055, 0.051757812, 0.01876831, -0.0022354126, -0.03161621, -0.0041656494, -0.030227661, 0.0024147034, 0.019485474, -0.019515991, 0.0038585663, 0.012878418, 0.05593872, 0.004383087, -0.007701874, -0.03894043, 0.02545166, -0.0074920654, -0.011154175, 0.007358551, 0.021759033, -0.02758789, 0.03942871, -0.032836914, 0.008766174, 0.0025730133, 0.027770996, 0.015808105, 0.036376953, -0.024780273, 0.012641907, 0.024276733, 0.02960205, -0.013198853, 0.040039062, 0.021194458, 0.006187439, -0.008880615, -0.031036377, -0.04486084, -0.025222778, -0.044830322, 0.021453857, 0.0018758774, 0.015655518, 0.014701843, 0.0055007935, -0.0113220215, 0.018676758, 0.049346924, -0.06085205, -0.023361206, -0.02368164, 0.07196045, -0.0058174133 ], "summary": [ 0.034210205, 0.01940918, 0.046661377, 0.09240723, -0.029876709, -0.043426514, 0.046844482, -0.09680176, -0.015083313, 0.026367188, -0.010826111, -0.0009803772, -0.015274048, -0.023330688, -0.014961243, -0.032165527, -0.012428284, 0.05065918, 0.04916382, -0.019363403, 0.007003784, -0.022155762, -0.009719849, -0.011123657, 0.034454346, 0.00020980835, -0.060028076, 0.025375366, 0.010528564, 0.011764526, 0.005558014, -0.00308609, 0.03111267, -0.03250122, 0.04333496, 0.028198242, 0.02658081, -0.021774292, -0.0126571655, 0.028884888, 0.009811401, -0.02243042, 0.03451538, -0.033325195, -0.018997192, 0.053649902, -0.017608643, 0.00015819073, 0.030822754, 0.0006532669, 0.0031757355, -0.027511597, 0.02798462, -0.034851074, -0.027664185, -0.02532959, 0.0008096695, -0.06707764, 0.018493652, 0.04788208, 0.022140503, -0.015319824, 0.006000519, -0.028778076, -0.02078247, 0.01309967, 0.03475952, 0.0018186569, 0.023284912, -0.019302368, -0.0064430237, 0.013809204, 0.03213501, 0.009552002, -0.036712646, -0.07232666, 0.05529785, -0.00806427, 0.02067566, -0.006778717, -0.017562866, -0.039916992, 0.0047035217, -0.04815674, -0.0020008087, -0.029922485, -0.01763916, 0.019821167, -0.029754639, -0.0053596497, -0.030685425, 0.04119873, 0.009231567, -0.037597656, -0.048614502, -0.007926941, -0.0051841736, -0.009567261, -0.008430481, -0.030136108, -0.01889038, 0.019119263, -0.049713135, 0.0027179718, -0.02458191, 0.012084961, 0.044891357, -0.055877686, -0.028427124, -0.017333984, -0.0473938, 0.023086548, 0.020050049, -0.015716553, -0.01789856, -0.00054073334, -0.0003490448, 0.037200928, 0.009185791, 0.031341553, 0.013313293, 0.035339355, 0.003376007, 0.012191772, -0.0104599, 0.006629944, -0.01525116, -0.034423828, 0.013793945, 0.011329651, -0.006412506, 0.029815674, -0.02909851, -0.020507812, -0.039001465, -0.0052833557, 0.013717651, -0.03237915, -0.00043725967, -0.009239197, 0.048187256, -0.029815674, -0.0033302307, 0.038146973, 0.06335449, 0.014305115, 0.017333984, -0.0030155182, 0.026412964, 0.05078125, 0.0049934387, -0.010765076, 0.04458618, -0.016647339, -0.06329346, -0.021102905, -0.076660156, 0.020980835, -0.0035533905, -0.02178955, -0.024642944, -0.0107040405, 0.005176544, 0.038879395, -0.0007100105, 0.007369995, 0.036621094, 0.021621704, 0.005821228, 0.016479492, -0.018539429, -0.01209259, -0.057281494, 0.000025093555, -0.006778717, 0.022583008, 0.045013428, 0.0042152405, -0.034118652, 0.023147583, 0.018371582, -0.030410767, -0.022506714, -0.00315094, -0.0054473877, -0.020523071, 0.0053634644, 0.012008667, 0.022613525, 0.035369873, -0.018859863, 0.032287598, 0.021820068, 0.01247406, 0.016403198, -0.040740967, -0.016860962, -0.016693115, -0.01486969, -0.03086853, 0.014129639, 0.0036354065, -0.005241394, -0.004032135, -0.072265625, 0.007209778, -0.026870728, 0.03173828, -0.06585693, 0.019058228, 0.041137695, 0.025619507, -0.041503906, -0.010108948, 0.020874023, 0.004337311, 0.031433105, -0.022979736, -0.0023479462, -0.040374756, -0.026641846, 0.00945282, -0.06817627, 0.028930664, -0.009033203, -0.005138397, -0.007843018, 0.010368347, 0.06347656, 0.012771606, 0.06976318, -0.035125732, 0.02947998, 0.034576416, -0.03363037, -0.010169983, 0.020645142, -0.009147644, 0.0077438354, 0.029693604, 0.032073975, 0.014411926, -0.013496399, 0.016906738, 0.029373169, -0.028930664, -0.0062408447, 0.004901886, -0.03930664, 0.011428833, -0.004760742, 0.024490356, 0.047210693, 0.030410767, -0.050720215, 0.058807373, -0.064453125, -0.029953003, 0.014663696, -0.0049743652, -0.013008118, -0.008026123, 0.05822754, -0.011070251, -0.026138306, -0.030441284, -0.012741089, -0.020904541, 0.026870728, -0.0413208, 0.010940552, -0.013618469, 0.022644043, -0.02470398, -0.02279663, -0.06878662, -0.01108551, 0.02722168, 0.021606445, -0.055725098, 0.027801514, 0.037902832, 0.028808594, -0.0043029785, 0.031463623, 0.01940918, 0.00642395, 0.0184021, 0.0050315857, 0.0284729, 0.038085938, 0.016799927, -0.004878998, -0.0031280518, 0.0073890686, -0.013870239, -0.070007324, 0.02305603, 0.003932953, -0.033172607, -0.0038795471, 0.038482666, -0.010818481, 0.0068969727, 0.020065308, -0.007873535, 0.035583496, 0.03643799, 0.010749817, 0.004337311, -0.042999268, -0.014717102, 0.017700195, 0.0035915375, 0.0362854, 0.009613037, 0.03869629, 0.036254883, 0.047851562, 0.05255127, 0.060546875, -0.016052246, 0.011001587, -0.033477783, -0.0035705566, -0.03829956, -0.025253296, -0.013893127, -0.044036865, -0.012229919, 0.015419006, -0.01687622, -0.002696991, 0.05810547, 0.020339966, -0.003929138, -0.02178955, 0.055145264, -0.016433716, -0.0012435913, -0.05041504, 0.00034236908, 0.0079193115, -0.049987793, -0.03793335, -0.004863739, -0.02217102, -0.00097227097, 0.03225708, -0.010932922, 0.0022258759, 0.0054244995, -0.032958984, 0.010231018, 0.0010509491, 0.008018494, 0.046905518, 0.05834961, 0.017242432, 0.0065727234, 0.06384277, 0.026275635, 0.02557373, -0.07116699, -0.036743164, -0.045928955, 0.007575989, -0.039215088, 0.047698975, 0.02508545, -0.050689697, 0.052368164, -0.048431396, 0.020446777, 0.03894043, 0.036102295, 0.059539795, -0.01574707, 0.008956909, 0.036315918, -0.010597229, 0.04159546, -0.03555298, 0.020141602, 0.064819336, 0.006614685, -0.004020691, -0.061065674, 0.07519531, 0.04309082, 0.028915405, -0.048309326, -0.028366089, -0.020446777, -0.033691406, -0.0021247864, 0.02229309, -0.023544312, 0.008842468, -0.018463135, 0.023788452, 0.015510559, -0.008758545, 0.050628662, -0.03201294, 0.036590576, 0.012481689, -0.019485474, 0.015419006, 0.015144348, -0.026565552, -0.051086426, -0.021224976, -0.046936035, 0.0013198853, -0.007545471, 0.05569458, 0.0053749084, 0.03237915, -0.06097412, -0.009971619, 0.0053901672, -0.0070724487, -0.01878357, -0.04156494, 0.0340271, -0.0015335083, 0.033416748, 0.011436462, 0.02154541, 0.024383545, -0.015808105, -0.017364502, -0.03817749, -0.041900635, -0.027420044, -0.023620605, 0.024917603, 0.011711121, -0.025878906, -0.04421997, -0.005432129, -0.029769897, 0.008285522, -0.011329651, -0.010322571, 0.008087158, -0.06640625, -0.004787445, -0.05807495, 0.010932922, 0.022125244, 0.037384033, 0.0049552917, -0.000048458576, -0.0071372986, -0.015701294, 0.02784729, 0.043395996, -0.060302734, -0.03817749, -0.028366089, -0.0026454926, 0.00029802322, 0.00088596344, -0.038726807, 0.075683594, 0.0011091232, 0.02067566, -0.006904602, -0.036193848, 0.018493652, 0.0019283295, 0.00762558, -0.008216858, -0.017288208, 0.024429321, 0.017120361, -0.008117676, -0.02418518, 0.017623901, -0.014778137, -0.019439697, -0.01020813, 0.0058403015, 0.0033893585, -0.0602417, 0.008430481, -0.016647339, 0.008720398, 0.041168213, -0.009536743, 0.040649414, -0.04547119, -0.058654785, -0.0069084167, -0.018707275, 0.0635376, 0.018218994, -0.035186768, 0.034484863, -0.01890564, 0.028045654, -0.021850586, -0.032196045, 0.01977539, 0.04623413, -0.001036644, 0.0075035095, -0.04458618, 0.023529053, -0.024169922, 0.028671265, 0.021514893, -0.0093307495, -0.005142212, 0.0021896362, -0.006175995, -0.009475708, 0.0008330345, 0.026428223, 0.064331055, -0.022506714, 0.029647827, 0.017852783, 0.026428223, -0.057525635, 0.026489258, -0.050872803, -0.015930176, -0.020996094, 0.049682617, -0.043914795, -0.022125244, 0.05886841, -0.014183044, -0.03857422, -0.054138184, -0.012001038, 0.05050659, -0.019073486, -0.04071045, -0.027313232, 0.061920166, -0.015174866, 0.0053710938, -0.042663574, 0.006175995, -0.011421204, -0.030532837, 0.02407837, 0.026535034, -0.08935547, -0.024032593, 0.007888794, 0.02078247, -0.051330566, 0.015686035, -0.020751953, -0.000344038, -0.009246826, 0.023544312, -0.0043640137, -0.0023918152, 0.023727417, 0.030944824, -0.037597656, -0.033050537, -0.034606934, -0.00046253204, -0.027496338, -0.010368347, -0.011489868, -0.03488159, -0.0020942688, -0.03503418, -0.046539307, -0.0016527176, 0.038330078, 0.101623535, 0.0129776, 0.043029785, -0.040161133, 0.006099701, -0.06604004, 0.04031372, 0.03781128, -0.030151367, -0.032165527, 0.035858154, 0.08508301, 0.0049095154, -0.0113220215, -0.020889282, -0.003534317, -0.03677368, 0.047088623, 0.03668213, 0.03918457, 0.020401001, -0.0032653809, 0.005405426, -0.011627197, -0.018066406, 0.014266968, 0.0028514862, 0.03062439, -0.03314209, -0.014816284, 0.0045318604, -0.004425049, -0.021057129, 0.009666443, -0.009971619, 0.0021820068, 0.020629883, -0.048217773, 0.046569824, -0.016738892, 0.0178833, 0.04071045, -0.033813477, 0.023773193, 0.007774353, 0.022232056, -0.011260986, -0.017333984, 0.05227661, 0.0035152435, -0.008110046, 0.026260376, -0.013557434, -0.044952393, 0.0027389526, 0.0059394836, 0.019210815, -0.040649414, -0.030792236, -0.033447266, -0.0036582947, -0.00036406517, -0.0064353943, -0.015899658, -0.050872803, 0.007865906, -0.04586792, -0.04333496, -0.0002629757, -0.031341553, -0.01676941, -0.03729248, 0.01146698, -0.07446289, 0.058135986, 0.077697754, -0.024932861, 0.003074646, -0.010604858, -0.008361816, -0.057495117, -0.041809082, -0.044891357, -0.03375244, -0.010696411, -0.006385803, 0.00365448, 0.0027561188, 0.011642456, 0.007129669, -0.04534912, -0.008522034, 0.007843018, 0.041107178, -0.010658264, 0.019699097, -0.007041931, 0.016479492, -0.007007599, 0.007911682, -0.034179688, 0.010734558, -0.03817749, 0.00084400177, -0.04837036, 0.02355957, 0.04385376, 0.011123657, -0.014450073, 0.068359375, 0.013473511, -0.0036811829, -0.0206604, 0.049987793, -0.06060791, -0.01071167, 0.04498291, 0.006164551, -0.16259766, -0.022262573, -0.052490234, 0.0211792, -0.061035156, 0.019882202, -0.0637207, -0.012039185, 0.02420044, 0.0069389343, 0.016937256, 0.021560669, 0.020370483, 0.022994995, -0.013572693, -0.027236938, 0.0014629364, -0.03652954, -0.0058059692, -0.03930664, -0.0256958, -0.012168884, 0.074401855, -0.020187378, 0.016815186, 0.01826477, -0.020019531, 0.02293396, 0.010749817, -0.03375244, 0.008483887, 0.004436493, -0.011177063, 0.010047913, 0.06677246, -0.03173828, 0.012672424, 0.007106781, 0.06451416, 0.007850647, 0.038238525, 0.020721436, -0.033172607, -0.026184082, -0.022537231, 0.024673462, -0.029510498, 0.0009508133, -0.0020389557, 0.022140503, 0.011680603, -0.02180481, -0.016784668, 0.023788452, -0.013114929, 0.034301758, -0.019699097, 0.028015137, -0.016708374, 0.04663086, -0.0046539307, 0.02357483, -0.031555176, -0.021987915, -0.008102417, -0.041931152, 0.01184845, -0.044403076, -0.030181885, 0.04321289, 0.012481689, 0.012268066, -0.009056091, -0.02381897, -0.0055236816, 0.00076436996, -0.010261536, 0.04840088, 0.03427124, 0.058380127, -0.020202637, -0.024780273, -0.019165039, -0.0056419373, 0.0058059692, -0.03564453, 0.019622803, 0.0006699562, 0.02078247, 0.007068634, -0.0107040405, 0.013160706, -0.00793457, -0.038879395, 0.014038086, 0.036712646, -0.0072402954, -0.06793213, -0.030410767, 0.094055176, 0.024398804, -0.013435364, -0.002981186, -0.0066070557, -0.030471802, -0.040374756, -0.033325195, -0.01927185, 0.008934021, 0.04525757, -0.02670288, -0.034698486, 0.08087158, -0.0030918121, 0.027648926, 0.047210693, -0.016525269, 0.028015137, -0.0107803345, -0.003873825, -0.022445679, -0.0008921623, 0.011947632, 0.017211914, 0.040374756, 0.010643005, 0.01574707, -0.024398804, -0.0034999847, 0.029403687, -0.038513184, -0.035125732, 0.010398865, 0.04034424, -0.026763916, 0.045288086, 0.011734009, 0.035003662, 0.025405884, -0.0146865845, 0.05014038, -0.042175293, 0.011909485, 0.029220581, -0.026107788, 0.03793335, -0.006565094, 0.04675293, 0.00010788441, -0.004989624, -0.033416748, 0.042053223, 0.030715942, 0.03857422, 0.006778717, -0.0058403015, -0.0135650635, 0.0206604, 0.027328491, 0.007980347, -0.028640747, 0.0026435852, -0.009124756, -0.028778076, 0.03439331, 0.0011739731, -0.0078125, -0.009628296, -0.0030555725, 0.016204834, -0.027542114, 0.05795288, -0.025878906, 0.030715942, -0.0690918, 0.07269287, -0.023986816, -0.03439331, 0.021331787, 0.012786865, -0.06915283, 0.00415802, -0.018844604, 0.081970215, 0.039154053, 0.062164307, -0.02911377, -0.0062675476, 0.04864502, 0.009315491, -0.010124207, 0.015350342, 0.012367249, -0.004989624, -0.010627747, 0.0062789917, 0.02458191, 0.046173096, 0.05645752, -0.047943115, -0.022659302, -0.01448822, 0.0064315796, -0.020126343, 0.030151367, -0.029205322, -0.036834717, -0.0031967163, 0.018234253, 0.029464722, -0.06149292, 0.014190674, 0.00061416626, -0.037628174, 0.025772095, -0.015144348, 0.019546509, -0.00018334389, -0.03390503, -0.013877869, -0.029464722, 0.045928955, -0.011116028, -0.017913818, -0.0013599396, 0.03074646, 0.020019531, -0.015419006, -0.0463562, 0.08703613, 0.046875, -0.011367798, 0.014434814, 0.027770996, -0.0009851456, 0.038604736, 0.06335449, 0.010147095, -0.0066490173, -0.030349731, 0.026855469, 0.0102005005, -0.050628662, -0.014320374, -0.038909912, -0.008934021, 0.009864807, 0.0022563934, 0.00730896, 0.021865845, -0.008377075, -0.019088745, 0.003791809, -0.003314972, -0.024459839, -0.04144287, 0.00056886673, 0.019119263, 0.014907837, -0.009666443, 0.0067367554, 0.030456543, 0.004295349, 0.021621704, -0.006828308, -0.04949951, 0.00096178055, 0.03704834, 0.04473877, 0.019866943, -0.023620605, -0.04425049, -0.016647339, 0.0071372986, -0.03894043, -0.0014677048, -0.06097412, -0.013214111, -0.02748108, -0.00056791306, -0.007358551, 0.03579712, 0.0014419556, -0.003736496, 0.03668213, -0.03933716, -0.010307312, -0.060516357, -0.051483154, 0.013877869, -0.053833008, -0.006866455, 0.02494812, -0.0859375, -0.010360718, -0.016693115, 0.047454834, -0.017074585, -0.017700195, 0.036376953, 0.011108398, 0.028305054, 0.011947632, 0.027526855, 0.019989014, 0.01902771, 0.037597656, 0.0010051727, 0.03265381, -0.010093689, -0.049591064, -0.024398804, 0.038604736, -0.027557373, 0.038208008, -0.027236938, 0.011512756, 0.00749588, -0.022399902, 0.014228821, 0.027267456, 0.06335449, -0.05697632, 0.05493164, 0.046295166, 0.04232788, 0.033447266 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2112.06651v2
Accoustate: Auto-annotation of IMU-generated Activity Signatures under Smart Infrastructure
Soumyajit Chatterjee, Arun Singh, Bivas Mitra, Sandip Chakraborty
eess.SP, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
Human activities within smart infrastructures generate a vast amount of IMU data from the wearables worn by individuals. Many existing studies rely on such sensory data for human activity recognition (HAR); however, one of the major bottlenecks is their reliance on pre-annotated or labeled data. Manual human-driven annotations are neither scalable nor efficient, whereas existing auto-annotation techniques heavily depend on video signatures. Still, video-based auto-annotation needs high computation resources and has privacy concerns when the data from a personal space, like a smart-home, is transferred to the cloud. This paper exploits the acoustic signatures generated from human activities to label the wearables' IMU data at the edge, thus mitigating resource requirement and data privacy concerns. We utilize acoustic-based pre-trained HAR models for cross-modal labeling of the IMU data even when two individuals perform simultaneous but different activities under the same environmental context. We observe that non-overlapping acoustic gaps exist with a high probability during the simultaneous activities performed by two individuals in the environment's acoustic context, which helps us resolve the overlapping activity signatures to label them individually. A principled evaluation of the proposed approach on two real-life in-house datasets further augmented to create a dual occupant setup, shows that the framework can correctly annotate a significant volume of unlabeled IMU data from both individuals with an accuracy of $\mathbf{82.59\%}$ ($\mathbf{\pm 17.94\%}$) and $\mathbf{98.32\%}$ ($\mathbf{\pm 3.68\%}$), respectively, for a workshop and a kitchen environment.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2112.06651v2
"2022-08-02T15:02:22"
"2021-12-08T13:57:43"
{ "title": [ -0.006504059, 0.0025959015, -0.03555298, -0.03265381, 0.01852417, -0.015541077, -0.006340027, -0.03717041, -0.017150879, 0.035369873, -0.004146576, 0.01586914, -0.014404297, -0.029174805, -0.033294678, 0.0034694672, -0.010070801, -0.0050697327, -0.030807495, -0.03552246, 0.009925842, -0.047698975, 0.044433594, 0.044281006, 0.029434204, -0.030929565, -0.08013916, 0.030899048, -0.018035889, -0.009231567, 0.0010929108, 0.025756836, 0.030029297, 0.047821045, -0.049591064, -0.009170532, -0.04550171, 0.03869629, -0.0107421875, 0.026321411, 0.034454346, -0.0045661926, 0.020095825, -0.038238525, -0.0057868958, 0.03387451, -0.02798462, -0.017333984, -0.014160156, 0.011131287, 0.025436401, 0.030410767, 0.009544373, 0.016540527, 0.0104522705, -0.01725769, -0.06878662, 0.011871338, 0.025238037, 0.07159424, 0.054656982, -0.041168213, 0.0060272217, -0.013595581, -0.02720642, -0.019729614, 0.015411377, 0.032592773, 0.027252197, -0.022460938, -0.012687683, 0.03060913, -0.0051574707, 0.023117065, -0.053710938, -0.015899658, 0.050109863, 0.006816864, 0.026916504, -0.006855011, 0.040771484, 0.00806427, 0.018615723, -0.031311035, 0.035339355, -0.03289795, 0.012382507, -0.019897461, -0.021911621, -0.022872925, -0.012413025, -0.0041885376, 0.012634277, 0.02671814, -0.02192688, -0.009353638, -0.027648926, 0.03189087, -0.0053863525, -0.0077667236, -0.02508545, 0.016159058, -0.052734375, -0.025619507, -0.0008921623, 0.06262207, -0.00995636, -0.028305054, -0.0028038025, 0.011207581, 0.0064849854, -0.01461792, 0.02748108, 0.03527832, -0.046142578, -0.026046753, -0.0021533966, -0.035827637, -0.013786316, -0.003768921, -0.019165039, -0.021743774, 0.023834229, 0.026229858, 0.023132324, 0.008323669, -0.012191772, -0.018966675, 0.0034675598, -0.014762878, 0.011245728, 0.053375244, -0.08654785, -0.057037354, -0.053375244, 0.054504395, -0.011619568, -0.029449463, -0.009811401, 0.01927185, 0.025527954, -0.041534424, -0.03668213, 0.034942627, 0.004333496, 0.0052986145, 0.04559326, 0.00006818771, -0.02722168, -0.017318726, -0.0066871643, 0.0072402954, 0.01953125, -0.0039711, -0.011238098, 0.018005371, -0.08251953, -0.009811401, 0.0030574799, 0.000374794, 0.039916992, -0.0010490417, -0.028533936, 0.0368042, 0.041381836, 0.0014133453, 0.004348755, 0.02130127, 0.00605011, 0.057159424, -0.001364708, 0.00680542, 0.0033473969, -0.0054512024, -0.0026454926, 0.0031433105, 0.049987793, -0.013404846, 0.041809082, -0.015975952, -0.007881165, -0.0066337585, 0.061798096, 0.003396988, -0.07171631, -0.009498596, 0.0112838745, 0.041046143, 0.04248047, 0.0119018555, -0.022369385, 0.0149383545, -0.042175293, -0.016189575, -0.028335571, -0.0113220215, 0.0041007996, 0.023345947, -0.023757935, 0.009262085, 0.011154175, 0.0062332153, -0.031311035, 0.017745972, -0.033966064, -0.03805542, -0.008384705, 0.0016613007, -0.0019931793, 0.04864502, 0.0309906, 0.016677856, -0.023025513, -0.049224854, -0.008743286, -0.022506714, 0.01008606, -0.024856567, -0.018417358, -0.022399902, -0.03579712, -0.012245178, -0.01574707, 0.034576416, 0.017608643, 0.00504303, -0.009544373, -0.0060653687, 0.06762695, 0.01386261, 0.08557129, -0.026885986, 0.005252838, -0.0023441315, -0.012916565, -0.028457642, -0.040893555, -0.063964844, 0.037841797, 0.041107178, -0.0054397583, -0.03643799, -0.013343811, 0.05316162, -0.014541626, -0.048553467, 0.002483368, 0.043182373, 0.024108887, 0.042144775, 0.014297485, 0.0068588257, 0.057281494, -0.025177002, 0.006427765, 0.052337646, -0.017410278, 0.011566162, -0.015167236, 0.00046634674, 0.036468506, -0.0011386871, -0.022018433, 0.00088071823, -0.075805664, 0.011123657, -0.015159607, 0.023849487, -0.0034446716, 0.011024475, 0.033447266, 0.027359009, 0.0064468384, 0.032714844, 0.028503418, -0.01953125, -0.021560669, -0.0022182465, -0.007888794, -0.024780273, -0.04144287, -0.0340271, -0.020462036, -0.0129470825, 0.042938232, -0.021499634, 0.000562191, -0.022766113, -0.05645752, -0.0184021, 0.04324341, 0.05090332, 0.00060224533, -0.012039185, -0.015510559, 0.015792847, 0.055023193, 0.040405273, -0.017532349, 0.026611328, -0.04849243, 0.0055160522, 0.010650635, -0.012680054, -0.010650635, 0.016220093, -0.012817383, 0.007217407, -0.021148682, -0.016311646, -0.015556335, 0.059661865, 0.027572632, -0.016830444, -0.024353027, -0.05001831, -0.01474762, -0.010437012, -0.061157227, -0.030654907, 0.06542969, -0.026290894, 0.007709503, 0.002122879, -0.010169983, -0.052093506, -0.0058288574, -0.025177002, -0.070373535, 0.032104492, 0.019515991, 0.006843567, -0.03866577, 0.049865723, -0.00945282, 0.03427124, -0.009239197, -0.024551392, -0.03253174, 0.003288269, 0.0032653809, 0.0042648315, 0.015945435, -0.040100098, -0.007286072, -0.06707764, -0.000034987926, 0.01637268, -0.041412354, -0.0007276535, 0.02558899, -0.029052734, -0.04360962, 0.0069007874, 0.06060791, -0.029144287, -0.024597168, 0.045440674, 0.029800415, -0.0013589859, 0.06439209, 0.036193848, 0.039855957, -0.06100464, -0.05227661, -0.062469482, -0.0053520203, -0.026275635, -0.047790527, 0.03591919, -0.057647705, -0.028503418, -0.020812988, -0.028869629, -0.030853271, 0.052703857, -0.020004272, -0.040863037, -0.015701294, -0.037750244, -0.008285522, -0.003211975, -0.016586304, 0.0016012192, 0.09906006, -0.012260437, 0.013397217, 0.0095825195, 0.0690918, 0.0055007935, 0.0038414001, -0.055114746, -0.075683594, 0.0138549805, 0.033172607, 0.0015935898, 0.0018529892, 0.025863647, -0.13500977, -0.019561768, 0.05505371, 0.008796692, -0.025405884, 0.018081665, -0.03866577, -0.04864502, 0.016098022, -0.009536743, 0.031463623, 0.05609131, 0.008430481, 0.014709473, 0.011352539, -0.014129639, 0.013465881, -0.031066895, -0.052215576, 0.038879395, -0.051849365, -0.03729248, -0.0027542114, -0.014442444, -0.0206604, -0.007396698, 0.0062789917, 0.042755127, 0.039520264, 0.005420685, 0.015960693, -0.035858154, 0.0039482117, -0.048034668, 0.006259918, 0.010787964, -0.054351807, 0.018600464, 0.0052223206, 0.020126343, 0.053588867, -0.025970459, -0.020751953, 0.002313614, 0.015235901, 0.02041626, 0.03173828, -0.04727173, 0.008644104, 0.0059890747, 0.0019817352, -0.006008148, -0.012054443, -0.0054397583, 0.030273438, 0.01259613, 0.007358551, 0.017440796, 0.00869751, 0.018066406, -0.02192688, -0.03363037, 0.02229309, -0.01965332, -0.054107666, -0.0026111603, 0.0017623901, -0.013015747, 0.0067481995, -0.014930725, -0.021102905, 0.007335663, -0.034423828, 0.05770874, -0.013755798, -0.03805542, 0.0060424805, -0.01625061, 0.010566711, -0.028671265, 0.040863037, -0.016159058, 0.0011072159, 0.008079529, -0.064697266, -0.05090332, 0.008552551, -0.010063171, -0.08380127, -0.018600464, 0.020324707, -0.028167725, -0.024368286, -0.060546875, 0.034942627, -0.041412354, -0.021102905, 0.017120361, -0.005722046, -0.011154175, -0.017913818, -0.07940674, 0.0011663437, 0.051849365, 0.028015137, 0.046295166, 0.023620605, 0.013587952, -0.0063934326, -0.025253296, 0.0013971329, -0.028213501, 0.03378296, -0.017578125, 0.00095176697, 0.041931152, -0.02998352, 0.03302002, 0.0069618225, 0.015945435, -0.011001587, 0.003358841, 0.046173096, 0.017105103, 0.003396988, 0.03878784, -0.0075531006, -0.013450623, -0.036712646, 0.0009303093, 0.009857178, 0.020828247, 0.02281189, -0.008659363, 0.028137207, 0.013534546, 0.010902405, 0.025650024, 0.00041913986, 0.020614624, 0.029785156, -0.04135132, -0.01436615, 0.016937256, 0.05618286, -0.012275696, -0.007881165, 0.032043457, 0.006843567, 0.06329346, -0.037628174, 0.0029144287, 0.0031337738, 0.010002136, -0.025039673, -0.0004940033, -0.04006958, -0.052978516, -0.029205322, 0.016952515, -0.015281677, 0.01335907, 0.024230957, -0.032409668, -0.029464722, 0.034820557, 0.070617676, 0.0017347336, 0.014434814, -0.059143066, 0.042633057, -0.01663208, -0.04812622, -0.026885986, -0.016403198, -0.0259552, 0.050567627, -0.0038890839, -0.007865906, 0.03475952, 0.014533997, 0.030471802, 0.056732178, -0.02355957, -0.06890869, 0.05380249, -0.011077881, -0.016784668, 0.032409668, 0.022949219, 0.0118255615, -0.024398804, 0.02406311, -0.026412964, 0.015129089, 0.02154541, 0.0058631897, -0.03515625, 0.041290283, -0.024154663, 0.060058594, -0.012062073, -0.00019645691, 0.010871887, 0.011505127, -0.038635254, 0.011779785, 0.019332886, 0.05218506, -0.041778564, 0.033691406, 0.053588867, -0.0050354004, 0.0071487427, -0.029754639, 0.009529114, -0.006706238, 0.0063476562, -0.025848389, 0.050079346, -0.00957489, -0.036132812, 0.014732361, 0.01574707, 0.03656006, -0.006462097, 0.095825195, -0.03817749, -0.019012451, 0.04284668, 0.028671265, -0.0149383545, -0.007637024, 0.008239746, -0.06842041, -0.034332275, -0.018508911, 0.019561768, -0.033996582, -0.01789856, 0.036315918, 0.042053223, 0.01222229, 0.030441284, -0.0024757385, -0.0029182434, -0.016235352, -0.009513855, -0.019180298, -0.036102295, -0.031280518, 0.025039673, 0.004837036, 0.00554657, 0.01940918, -0.01084137, -0.06903076, 0.004085541, -0.015991211, -0.029785156, -0.013809204, -0.06591797, 0.023406982, 0.039794922, -0.016326904, 0.04547119, -0.035858154, 0.041412354, 0.030059814, 0.05114746, 0.011276245, -0.0016298294, 0.043548584, -0.0019874573, 0.0031833649, 0.015052795, 0.037261963, 0.01600647, -0.025772095, 0.017974854, -0.024795532, -0.016281128, 0.014762878, 0.019729614, 0.015312195, -0.01586914, -0.02947998, 0.0007839203, 0.024627686, 0.010231018, 0.030227661, 0.011550903, -0.044647217, -0.028427124, 0.03543091, 0.0006213188, 0.0008339882, 0.064331055, -0.01586914, -0.05130005, 0.0024757385, -0.060546875, -0.014755249, 0.009567261, 0.03527832, 0.008583069, 0.019104004, 0.025161743, -0.037109375, 0.029785156, -0.0032157898, 0.007881165, 0.047851562, 0.037017822, -0.026992798, 0.0043411255, -0.014877319, -0.046295166, -0.08929443, -0.05279541, -0.041992188, 0.0395813, 0.002067566, -0.047729492, 0.0074806213, 0.0033740997, 0.008285522, 0.025848389, -0.0072364807, 0.042297363, 0.004798889, 0.016586304, 0.0036029816, 0.010787964, 0.04537964, -0.004497528, -0.010482788, -0.003932953, 0.04034424, 0.020935059, 0.021743774, 0.013580322, -0.062683105, 0.019882202, 0.025878906, 0.0076904297, -0.03463745, 0.019805908, 0.022491455, -0.012619019, -0.024734497, -0.016967773, 0.033813477, -0.024154663, -0.013923645, 0.0077552795, 0.035888672, 0.0152282715, 0.034057617, -0.044433594, -0.029571533, -0.018127441, -0.052093506, -0.03982544, 0.012336731, 0.06677246, 0.025634766, 0.07800293, -0.06976318, -0.039794922, 0.0009965897, -0.0063323975, 0.0004734993, 0.007572174, 0.03225708, 0.044921875, -0.042388916, 0.0034732819, 0.004470825, -0.011833191, 0.04031372, -0.0138168335, -0.022125244, 0.0068092346, -0.0015087128, 0.018829346, -0.031204224, -0.0070877075, 0.012512207, 0.027542114, -0.028839111, 0.03756714, -0.030593872, 0.054626465, 0.011711121, 0.053619385, 0.04498291, 0.011428833, 0.0061683655, 0.011207581, 0.0059814453, -0.033050537, -0.011314392, -0.050842285, -0.030731201, -0.028518677, -0.007801056, -0.04425049, -0.017059326, 0.015808105, 0.028671265, -0.0014619827, 0.021881104, 0.03945923, -0.022888184, 0.008117676, -0.08123779, 0.031677246, 0.00045609474, 0.017791748, -0.008491516, -0.013427734, 0.028579712, 0.034057617, 0.006290436, 0.01007843, -0.021575928, -0.005569458, 0.00032758713, -0.00598526, 0.032043457, -0.03353882, -0.010398865, -0.02305603, 0.034942627, -0.0011434555, 0.040985107, 0.05621338, 0.035064697, 0.000048160553, -0.021728516, 0.005191803, -0.05444336, -0.026016235, -0.0079956055, 0.018554688, -0.08947754, 0.039093018, -0.027877808, -0.001326561, -0.0023651123, 0.01361084, 0.039276123, -0.08203125, -0.01574707, 0.0055885315, 0.026260376, -0.030593872, 0.019592285, -0.031311035, 0.0003809929, -0.006187439, -0.0069770813, 0.0073013306, -0.014289856, 0.001917839, 0.031921387, -0.013885498, -0.009056091, -0.018188477, 0.02494812, -0.061035156, 0.018951416, -0.0020523071, 0.028030396, -0.02444458, -0.040802002, 0.022766113, -0.00944519, -0.015609741, -0.027893066, 0.08880615, 0.01486969, -0.003686905, 0.024261475, -0.003686905, -0.036254883, -0.030838013, -0.0413208, 0.029754639, -0.009216309, -0.046875, -0.028259277, -0.025512695, -0.033355713, -0.013908386, -0.038085938, 0.031188965, -0.06359863, 0.018692017, -0.025741577, 0.03781128, 0.013313293, -0.05987549, -0.07495117, 0.007911682, -0.0008702278, -0.022018433, -0.039520264, -0.01939392, -0.035888672, 0.014663696, 0.07678223, 0.043121338, -0.0009756088, 0.012893677, -0.021438599, -0.070617676, -0.020996094, -0.034454346, 0.027328491, -0.007926941, -0.027694702, -0.012367249, -0.03353882, 0.024139404, -0.013191223, -0.008277893, -0.059631348, -0.034606934, -0.05456543, 0.017822266, 0.00598526, -0.02178955, -0.0010766983, -0.028076172, 0.0038928986, -0.020553589, -0.017044067, 0.036956787, -0.049438477, -0.026641846, -0.003376007, -0.034240723, 0.053771973, 0.03237915, 0.0023784637, -0.01525116, 0.027633667, -0.014190674, -0.04724121, -0.0020561218, 0.033325195, 0.01260376, -0.036071777, -0.0019607544, 0.037078857, 0.024856567, -0.0446167, -0.015060425, 0.027420044, 0.040802002, 0.0022907257, 0.06945801, -0.007598877, 0.031921387, 0.033599854, 0.058532715, 0.015655518, -0.074279785, -0.049346924, -0.028961182, 0.05053711, 0.046905518, 0.0018501282, -0.029266357, 0.029876709, 0.020263672, 0.029647827, 0.012710571, -0.0340271, 0.015670776, -0.016937256, 0.028366089, 0.0025691986, 0.011177063, -0.035736084, 0.013694763, 0.00907135, 0.019729614, -0.0032787323, 0.030212402, -0.014976501, 0.043029785, 0.01398468, -0.031707764, 0.012954712, 0.026290894, 0.03253174, 0.037384033, -0.0075683594, -0.04345703, -0.0065841675, -0.001408577, -0.0028629303, 0.021255493, 0.0064086914, -0.023986816, 0.012123108, -0.0881958, 0.00579834, -0.046142578, -0.019897461, 0.024536133, -0.013374329, -0.015609741, -0.000017404556, -0.04776001, -0.017501831, 0.002916336, -0.040039062, -0.0104522705, -0.051452637, -0.066223145, 0.011894226, -0.023330688 ], "summary": [ 0.013031006, 0.009239197, -0.0028896332, -0.023391724, -0.01939392, -0.008605957, -0.0395813, -0.050964355, -0.02909851, 0.04473877, -0.014808655, 0.014328003, 0.019989014, -0.026916504, 0.015556335, -0.0146484375, 0.0065231323, 0.023254395, 0.022888184, -0.018920898, 0.0034294128, -0.0035934448, 0.02217102, 0.026412964, 0.0003504753, -0.013923645, -0.05859375, 0.015670776, 0.007282257, 0.014465332, 0.009376526, -0.0012426376, -0.0040130615, 0.06536865, -0.054901123, -0.019302368, -0.062927246, 0.04159546, 0.025497437, -0.012542725, 0.03149414, -0.0053520203, 0.059906006, 0.023147583, -0.0058555603, 0.027145386, 0.008163452, -0.027023315, 0.008216858, -0.005470276, 0.0025367737, 0.0262146, -0.0010414124, -0.036193848, -0.012756348, 0.002670288, -0.03793335, 0.0056152344, 0.019866943, 0.06109619, 0.016189575, 0.006904602, 0.0019416809, -0.034118652, -0.00248909, -0.013412476, 0.05166626, 0.00434494, 0.0005912781, -0.022583008, 0.01852417, 0.018432617, 0.009063721, -0.011619568, -0.026290894, 0.022705078, 0.032348633, 0.025558472, -0.0059814453, -0.023498535, 0.02923584, 0.011772156, 0.064453125, -0.03704834, -0.008995056, -0.05404663, -0.0024585724, 0.0040359497, 0.0007095337, 0.025878906, -0.003320694, -0.017410278, -0.031829834, 0.0791626, 0.033355713, -0.0071372986, -0.0043258667, -0.00019085407, 0.009017944, -0.024795532, -0.035980225, -0.015602112, -0.041046143, -0.007904053, -0.0025177002, 0.021209717, -0.023086548, -0.031799316, 0.030303955, 0.02178955, -0.017211914, 0.031311035, -0.004421234, -0.0345459, -0.04260254, 0.04156494, 0.023422241, -0.021026611, 0.012191772, -0.008018494, -0.022125244, 0.004550934, -0.027404785, 0.07183838, 0.0181427, 0.03543091, 0.034301758, -0.015655518, 0.010322571, -0.017471313, -0.017242432, 0.035583496, -0.027053833, -0.012763977, -0.020690918, 0.011581421, 0.026031494, -0.00067424774, -0.0052490234, 0.009460449, 0.06915283, -0.044952393, -0.06555176, 0.0703125, -0.021911621, 0.041778564, 0.018798828, -0.017288208, -0.018585205, -0.019836426, -0.0026779175, -0.014640808, 0.029556274, -0.0079193115, 0.021896362, -0.02822876, 0.0013055801, -0.034423828, 0.011245728, -0.020065308, 0.044067383, 0.0065689087, -0.007881165, 0.057159424, 0.03845215, -0.007472992, 0.0026512146, 0.011405945, 0.014823914, 0.031311035, -0.013313293, -0.01424408, 0.039031982, 0.018661499, -0.0054359436, 0.010543823, 0.025802612, -0.0040283203, 0.0113220215, -0.0040740967, -0.038513184, -0.043029785, 0.029190063, -0.035461426, -0.009208679, -0.02407837, 0.005958557, 0.016937256, 0.012962341, 0.015853882, -0.021911621, 0.010353088, -0.022140503, -0.00051164627, -0.03286743, -0.021011353, 0.0033130646, 0.0042686462, -0.03753662, 0.031799316, 0.06555176, -0.0029506683, -0.023391724, -0.017532349, -0.09954834, -0.021835327, -0.01828003, -0.00023198128, -0.02935791, 0.015548706, 0.016937256, -0.012237549, -0.013336182, -0.04284668, 0.0022296906, -0.0090789795, -0.015899658, 0.0141067505, -0.022323608, 0.030670166, -0.023391724, -0.045776367, -0.020721436, 0.044128418, 0.011650085, -0.0048217773, -0.018432617, 0.0067253113, 0.03375244, 0.0027236938, 0.050994873, -0.011054993, 0.006099701, -0.008811951, -0.009063721, -0.009391785, 0.01777649, -0.055664062, 0.02470398, 0.044067383, -0.0119018555, -0.0051651, -0.03488159, 0.0803833, -0.016174316, -0.021316528, 0.00046110153, 0.05303955, -0.022506714, 0.037719727, -0.0023288727, 0.006259918, 0.015975952, -0.023422241, -0.021835327, 0.027679443, -0.029449463, -0.012397766, -0.023895264, -0.005836487, 0.022720337, -0.022003174, -0.0036621094, -0.018798828, -0.076293945, -0.02911377, -0.026443481, -0.023986816, 0.013198853, -0.037841797, 0.031097412, 0.004272461, -0.005241394, 0.019195557, 0.0107421875, -0.06011963, -0.0054740906, 0.0047683716, -0.014625549, -0.02142334, -0.014198303, -0.013122559, -0.030883789, -0.009490967, 0.031341553, -0.008598328, 0.008857727, 0.007671356, -0.026733398, 0.01864624, 0.019378662, 0.057769775, 0.008972168, -0.011581421, 0.0006246567, 0.020248413, 0.024246216, 0.005340576, 0.010017395, -0.02684021, -0.022247314, 0.012252808, -0.025466919, -0.008132935, -0.0069999695, -0.01512146, -0.021133423, 0.019927979, 0.026245117, -0.025726318, 0.03363037, 0.10412598, 0.031158447, 0.03677368, -0.009544373, -0.028686523, -0.009239197, 0.03994751, -0.02720642, -0.008201599, 0.0569458, -0.007434845, 0.06188965, 0.024291992, 0.014350891, -0.066101074, 0.060455322, -0.008140564, 0.0053863525, 0.0039405823, -0.0018596649, 0.043151855, -0.007789612, 0.06854248, 0.00057029724, 0.00069379807, -0.0047454834, -0.03488159, 0.0044517517, 0.027740479, 0.03857422, -0.006134033, 0.0040893555, -0.019821167, -0.037139893, -0.010421753, -0.005443573, 0.014984131, -0.06781006, -0.034698486, 0.044036865, -0.040863037, -0.009819031, 0.015731812, 0.03591919, -0.00957489, -0.0127334595, 0.05783081, 0.043426514, -0.0067100525, 0.08306885, 0.0262146, 0.034301758, -0.0826416, -0.040863037, -0.048614502, 0.005996704, -0.046142578, -0.012779236, 0.04727173, -0.023132324, 0.02557373, -0.060638428, -0.018493652, -0.050567627, 0.0592041, -0.0031547546, -0.041290283, 0.010231018, -0.0013046265, -0.015090942, -0.017990112, 0.0368042, 0.003709793, 0.089660645, 0.012145996, 0.064819336, 0.03729248, 0.06311035, -0.025497437, -0.02067566, -0.014053345, -0.07562256, -0.0013151169, 0.053985596, 0.011489868, 0.0051231384, 0.0042419434, -0.09893799, -0.038879395, 0.049682617, 0.022232056, 0.0033187866, 0.007926941, -0.0036888123, -0.036102295, 0.052368164, -0.0059318542, 0.027267456, 0.05859375, 0.012290955, -0.033599854, -0.010986328, -0.011978149, -0.012641907, 0.026657104, 0.021316528, 0.025100708, -0.025222778, -0.039398193, 0.0033607483, 0.050598145, -0.012542725, -0.024490356, 0.0068969727, 0.06008911, -0.018554688, -0.010032654, -0.013671875, 0.009010315, 0.009460449, -0.028320312, 0.020584106, 0.0079956055, -0.07556152, 0.024887085, -0.00059461594, 0.013572693, 0.06097412, -0.061340332, -0.024734497, 0.0024051666, 0.004219055, 0.009559631, 0.021148682, -0.04776001, 0.0181427, -0.015281677, -0.009284973, 0.048583984, -0.03692627, 0.0007300377, -0.0027542114, 0.036895752, -0.024246216, 0.004005432, 0.008308411, 0.05996704, 0.037902832, -0.06225586, 0.018096924, -0.033081055, -0.05316162, 0.03338623, -0.008201599, -0.0037117004, 0.006450653, -0.010437012, -0.025985718, 0.019592285, -0.03616333, 0.022109985, -0.023162842, -0.04534912, 0.030883789, -0.03768921, 0.011833191, -0.0027046204, 0.04296875, -0.017456055, -0.042510986, 0.019454956, -0.070617676, -0.021591187, 0.01335907, -0.012763977, -0.02027893, -0.011566162, 0.028503418, -0.043670654, -0.011398315, -0.05404663, 0.06982422, -0.079833984, -0.006755829, 0.0060577393, -0.0075035095, 0.0541687, -0.01020813, -0.057403564, -0.021148682, -0.013442993, 0.043823242, 0.03717041, -0.038970947, 0.024658203, 0.04711914, -0.005264282, 0.0073776245, -0.062072754, 0.019958496, -0.050231934, 0.025970459, 0.008850098, -0.019241333, 0.015220642, 0.0019226074, -0.0035476685, -0.008476257, -0.010437012, 0.049591064, 0.047546387, 0.010955811, 0.021774292, -0.012016296, -0.009437561, -0.011199951, -0.015563965, -0.023635864, -0.0011701584, 0.031555176, 0.06463623, 0.02848816, -0.0041122437, -0.008056641, -0.049621582, -0.01574707, -0.005443573, -0.040283203, -0.027404785, -0.02027893, 0.039154053, 0.057739258, -0.0045661926, -0.014450073, -0.0045318604, -0.018692017, 0.029953003, -0.04244995, -0.009254456, 0.01914978, 0.018707275, -0.04324341, -0.036315918, -0.010147095, 0.009941101, -0.03326416, 0.018127441, -0.015777588, 0.0032367706, -0.044433594, -0.002527237, -0.017364502, 0.02444458, 0.049194336, 0.025360107, -0.027908325, -0.039733887, 0.0284729, -0.015808105, -0.025741577, -0.007080078, -0.011756897, -0.06298828, 0.04876709, -0.015991211, -0.0152282715, 0.020629883, 0.0146484375, 0.042541504, 0.040283203, 0.00033330917, -0.06222534, -0.022247314, -0.040100098, -0.009918213, 0.028060913, -0.021377563, -0.0028953552, 0.0037174225, 0.058166504, -0.027160645, 0.019943237, 0.0014810562, -0.036346436, -0.036743164, 0.017944336, 0.01423645, 0.053833008, -0.010826111, 0.016937256, -0.0002784729, 0.0070991516, -0.02696228, -0.0026397705, -0.037628174, 0.017242432, -0.023269653, 0.03756714, 0.041107178, -0.047943115, -0.060302734, -0.0024871826, 0.038085938, 0.017288208, -0.01222229, -0.003921509, 0.008338928, -0.0019006729, -0.040405273, 0.009391785, -0.0070724487, 0.01171875, 0.04699707, 0.022109985, 0.0043754578, -0.0017986298, 0.03366089, 0.016357422, -0.006816864, 0.012794495, -0.0078125, -0.06185913, -0.026123047, -0.012527466, 0.046539307, -0.033325195, -0.03866577, -0.020645142, -0.0079574585, 0.039245605, -0.0042648315, 0.013465881, -0.034240723, -0.026931763, 0.004776001, -0.004573822, -0.014282227, -0.0075912476, -0.009147644, -0.024002075, -0.016906738, 0.010543823, -0.054382324, 0.014335632, -0.031433105, -0.037475586, 0.026443481, -0.010231018, -0.029464722, -0.0569458, 0.0014257431, 0.023666382, 0.0017814636, -0.00945282, -0.0007634163, 0.03225708, 0.011878967, 0.01083374, -0.043670654, -0.0005645752, 0.004348755, 0.023132324, 0.029418945, 0.021591187, 0.033325195, -0.045013428, 0.005844116, -0.04812622, 0.026901245, -0.0016441345, -0.03768921, -0.004886627, -0.047088623, 0.028656006, 0.019363403, 0.030914307, 0.019882202, 0.051330566, 0.04324341, -0.053985596, -0.07122803, 0.079711914, -0.04107666, -0.018829346, 0.07421875, 0.004825592, -0.044036865, -0.05630493, -0.044708252, -0.008010864, 0.0024757385, 0.04562378, 0.011077881, -0.015472412, 0.023162842, 0.021774292, 0.041107178, 0.0056495667, -0.0059661865, 0.018432617, 0.02268982, -0.05645752, 0.005722046, 0.011352539, -0.05783081, -0.097961426, -0.054901123, -0.04638672, 0.047821045, 0.0047683716, -0.051086426, 0.03491211, 0.013755798, 0.031036377, -0.021194458, 0.020050049, -0.000024557114, -0.0062789917, -0.023086548, -0.022064209, -0.0050697327, 0.028182983, -0.029159546, -0.020477295, -0.014945984, 0.03503418, 0.032562256, 0.051483154, -0.013710022, -0.05529785, 0.009529114, 0.028656006, 0.014083862, -0.03778076, 0.052368164, 0.026153564, -0.02720642, -0.018875122, -0.013038635, 0.0011663437, 0.0033340454, -0.016540527, 0.0077590942, 0.061676025, 0.0010519028, -0.008995056, -0.05819702, -0.025802612, 0.0126571655, 0.011024475, 0.0016946793, 0.006263733, 0.020233154, -0.03704834, 0.027633667, -0.05267334, -0.06112671, 0.014373779, 0.019134521, -0.0070991516, -0.019927979, 0.004219055, 0.0513916, -0.02355957, 0.038757324, -0.012207031, -0.014892578, 0.029815674, 0.0044898987, -0.00009638071, 0.017852783, 0.042114258, 0.0056648254, -0.013442993, 0.022628784, 0.031982422, 0.011306763, -0.023117065, -0.0023345947, 0.0026950836, 0.039031982, 0.032928467, 0.006134033, 0.008293152, -0.02923584, -0.0071029663, 0.014663696, -0.01739502, -0.03353882, -0.032196045, 0.002571106, -0.029022217, 0.017669678, -0.0105896, -0.021148682, 0.042816162, 0.008415222, -0.024917603, 0.064819336, 0.003435135, 0.06982422, -0.019470215, -0.07354736, -0.09277344, -0.032440186, 0.015617371, 0.01576233, 0.0040397644, -0.022460938, -0.023498535, 0.036315918, 0.026977539, 0.0017461777, 0.041625977, -0.008834839, 0.020736694, -0.013671875, 0.028045654, -0.060760498, 0.015510559, -0.010612488, 0.020645142, 0.008766174, 0.039093018, 0.025161743, -0.014892578, 0.033721924, -0.009269714, 0.0036754608, -0.041290283, -0.00907135, -0.004211426, -0.015403748, -0.034118652, 0.03717041, 0.00077056885, -0.0019664764, 0.024627686, 0.026306152, 0.056396484, -0.05429077, 0.025970459, -0.0011882782, -0.0020618439, -0.06744385, 0.018585205, -0.0385437, -0.019729614, -0.008430481, -0.021881104, -0.0053863525, -0.040222168, 0.008399963, 0.0051116943, -0.010131836, 0.02798462, -0.00957489, 0.04159546, -0.030685425, 0.020935059, -0.0289917, 0.05078125, 0.031311035, -0.027389526, 0.07006836, 0.009063721, 0.018157959, 0.029388428, 0.0552063, 0.042877197, 0.030838013, 0.03161621, -0.040649414, -0.0048179626, 0.050872803, -0.014282227, 0.026565552, -0.041259766, -0.02708435, -0.05758667, 0.0036697388, 0.039123535, -0.025482178, 0.0025196075, -0.0046195984, -0.047943115, -0.018753052, -0.04525757, 0.064086914, -0.04425049, -0.025909424, -0.0501709, -0.033050537, -0.017944336, 0.0059776306, -0.008987427, -0.026535034, -0.003063202, -0.025909424, -0.001906395, 0.01550293, -0.008399963, 0.042022705, -0.00242424, -0.050354004, -0.028198242, -0.016326904, 0.02128601, 0.042266846, -0.042388916, -0.02180481, -0.008674622, 0.039916992, -0.009895325, 0.004005432, -0.029754639, -0.044647217, -0.047821045, 0.017196655, 0.00655365, -0.015991211, -0.027145386, -0.010421753, 0.0059394836, -0.027374268, -0.016418457, 0.052124023, -0.026748657, -0.008758545, -0.0014181137, -0.0259552, 0.06088257, 0.010864258, 0.016815186, -0.031402588, 0.051483154, -0.001572609, -0.08581543, -0.023834229, -0.025680542, 0.025497437, -0.019134521, -0.0073432922, 0.0128479, 0.0039367676, -0.03378296, 0.00440979, 0.029968262, 0.07373047, -0.0042915344, 0.016906738, -0.012649536, 0.003627777, 0.0022029877, 0.06854248, 0.0070877075, -0.02998352, -0.00036525726, 0.017944336, 0.06793213, 0.027435303, -0.042785645, 0.025177002, 0.020599365, -0.022033691, -0.007003784, 0.011177063, -0.00076436996, -0.020721436, -0.0015659332, 0.010345459, 0.007446289, -0.057922363, -0.031143188, -0.033081055, 0.003622055, -0.047180176, -0.0017204285, 0.023254395, -0.07110596, 0.0011348724, 0.040527344, -0.041900635, -0.006881714, -0.00674057, 0.044311523, -0.0085372925, 0.03640747, -0.07873535, -0.01108551, -0.0033416748, 0.0119018555, 0.022628784, 0.014442444, -0.04360962, 0.013465881, -0.10888672, 0.008331299, -0.08459473, -0.031982422, 0.024795532, -0.011497498, -0.016204834, 0.013938904, -0.03250122, 0.0066184998, 0.028793335, -0.022994995, -0.012649536, -0.00010865927, -0.080566406, -0.000044941902, -0.00058078766 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2112.08211v1
TrialGraph: Machine Intelligence Enabled Insight from Graph Modelling of Clinical Trials
Christopher Yacoumatos, Stefano Bragaglia, Anshul Kanakia, Nils Svangård, Jonathan Mangion, Claire Donoghue, Jim Weatherall, Faisal M. Khan, Khader Shameer
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.QM, 68Q04, 05Cxx, J.3.1; I.2.0; I.5.1; I.7; H.3
A major impediment to successful drug development is the complexity, cost, and scale of clinical trials. The detailed internal structure of clinical trial data can make conventional optimization difficult to achieve. Recent advances in machine learning, specifically graph-structured data analysis, have the potential to enable significant progress in improving the clinical trial design. TrialGraph seeks to apply these methodologies to produce a proof-of-concept framework for developing models which can aid drug development and benefit patients. In this work, we first introduce a curated clinical trial data set compiled from the CT.gov, AACT and TrialTrove databases (n=1191 trials; representing one million patients) and describe the conversion of this data to graph-structured formats. We then detail the mathematical basis and implementation of a selection of graph machine learning algorithms, which typically use standard machine classifiers on graph data embedded in a low-dimensional feature space. We trained these models to predict side effect information for a clinical trial given information on the disease, existing medical conditions, and treatment. The MetaPath2Vec algorithm performed exceptionally well, with standard Logistic Regression, Decision Tree, Random Forest, Support Vector, and Neural Network classifiers exhibiting typical ROC-AUC scores of 0.85, 0.68, 0.86, 0.80, and 0.77, respectively. Remarkably, the best performing classifiers could only produce typical ROC-AUC scores of 0.70 when trained on equivalent array-structured data. Our work demonstrates that graph modelling can significantly improve prediction accuracy on appropriate datasets. Successive versions of the project that refine modelling assumptions and incorporate more data types can produce excellent predictors with real-world applications in drug development.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2112.08211v1
"2021-12-15T15:36:57"
"2021-12-15T15:36:57"
{ "title": [ -0.055114746, -0.017501831, -0.05343628, -0.037872314, -0.025222778, -0.0024433136, -0.04562378, -0.0041770935, -0.012550354, 0.023010254, -0.014541626, 0.01436615, -0.018005371, -0.032440186, -0.043029785, -0.0064315796, -0.014419556, 0.033721924, -0.016983032, -0.037872314, -0.011833191, -0.04660034, 0.039764404, 0.06213379, 0.02861023, -0.014717102, -0.060913086, 0.008850098, -0.035125732, -0.038604736, -0.023468018, 0.022720337, 0.033416748, 0.016143799, 0.0054397583, 0.050079346, -0.026062012, 0.024429321, 0.006755829, 0.006801605, 0.017318726, -0.019485474, 0.020492554, -0.038909912, -0.02029419, 0.034118652, -0.0501709, -0.022354126, -0.027053833, 0.023834229, 0.021621704, 0.031051636, 0.0061912537, 0.037017822, 0.014656067, -0.009231567, -0.0025024414, -0.02178955, 0.030548096, 0.013961792, 0.020446777, -0.047790527, 0.02772522, 0.004787445, -0.043151855, -0.026382446, -0.04272461, 0.027252197, 0.07684326, 0.0059814453, -0.017623901, 0.03503418, 0.0002655983, 0.014945984, -0.03778076, -0.022415161, 0.052124023, 0.003627777, 0.022842407, -0.016830444, -0.015365601, -0.035583496, -0.029327393, 0.00881958, -0.024353027, -0.00137043, -0.012390137, -0.006893158, -0.028289795, -0.045776367, -0.0058784485, -0.018585205, 0.0028896332, 0.020111084, -0.011550903, -0.034057617, -0.019500732, 0.0066566467, 0.0138549805, -0.026657104, 0.007293701, 0.0096588135, -0.062683105, 0.0038852692, 0.009025574, 0.050201416, -0.0018024445, -0.008361816, -0.0030441284, 0.021270752, -0.014915466, 0.017120361, 0.0013246536, 0.023849487, -0.004108429, -0.013748169, -0.022216797, 0.027694702, -0.014785767, 0.049072266, 0.010818481, -0.01687622, 0.011238098, 0.013038635, 0.027038574, 0.0063819885, -0.04324341, 0.004940033, -0.052612305, 0.048706055, 0.006259918, 0.024047852, -0.074645996, -0.055267334, -0.04522705, 0.019104004, 0.0033950806, -0.015335083, -0.00919342, 0.020523071, 0.00187397, -0.0047340393, 0.020507812, -0.013191223, -0.018814087, -0.0014801025, 0.055114746, 0.00036263466, -0.06359863, -0.03591919, -0.043884277, 0.031555176, 0.018798828, -0.0025081635, -0.07165527, 0.0012111664, -0.11151123, -0.0026931763, 0.006713867, 0.003967285, 0.010818481, 0.029754639, 0.031677246, -0.0053749084, 0.03616333, -0.036132812, -0.025360107, 0.021087646, 0.0036029816, 0.017349243, -0.011360168, 0.033111572, 0.029037476, -0.016189575, -0.010032654, -0.0011758804, 0.03253174, -0.0071411133, 0.0076065063, 0.0073394775, -0.010047913, -0.027130127, -0.009727478, 0.037963867, -0.047210693, -0.015365601, -0.0034637451, -0.013168335, 0.045135498, 0.004989624, -0.034973145, 0.028121948, -0.031402588, -0.022567749, -0.023666382, -0.0287323, 0.023651123, 0.025009155, -0.009857178, -0.012687683, 0.0071868896, 0.010505676, -0.034973145, 0.012863159, -0.010192871, -0.050628662, -0.0044059753, 0.0016002655, -0.049835205, 0.044281006, 0.06561279, 0.016021729, -0.03213501, 0.012130737, 0.0045776367, -0.05331421, 0.0317688, -0.006450653, -0.009635925, -0.021728516, -0.015464783, 0.0040245056, 0.0037193298, 0.056518555, 0.034362793, 0.0014810562, 0.008148193, -0.04840088, 0.041809082, 0.0039711, 0.07092285, -0.0040626526, 0.022018433, 0.0072250366, -0.008682251, -0.012313843, 0.022064209, -0.0045318604, 0.0021896362, 0.0068588257, -0.0074920654, -0.009742737, 0.00819397, 0.029953003, 0.05871582, 0.018936157, 0.017440796, -0.00056266785, 0.016525269, 0.02709961, 0.060577393, 0.03050232, 0.04776001, 0.045776367, 0.0066566467, 0.056274414, -0.017150879, 0.00491333, -0.0126571655, 0.01713562, 0.0019989014, 0.05029297, 0.023345947, 0.016860962, -0.03692627, 0.016525269, -0.022949219, 0.022857666, 0.01058197, 0.0075416565, 0.02166748, -0.045043945, 0.016113281, 0.014450073, -0.014625549, 0.006023407, -0.021743774, 0.013420105, 0.015975952, -0.038970947, -0.0101623535, 0.022491455, 0.0657959, -0.005771637, 0.010032654, 0.0088272095, 0.014823914, -0.031951904, -0.042236328, -0.034606934, 0.028686523, 0.021438599, -0.0067100525, -0.016418457, 0.008758545, -0.0035858154, 0.04171753, 0.08148193, -0.027069092, 0.025802612, -0.08416748, 0.0009841919, 0.009719849, -0.0146102905, 0.0064353943, 0.040618896, 0.015129089, 0.026168823, -0.026870728, -0.00087451935, -0.025894165, -0.0012950897, 0.01878357, -0.019439697, -0.005836487, -0.04284668, -0.0146102905, -0.03338623, -0.061645508, -0.03479004, 0.06665039, -0.024383545, -0.061584473, -0.021987915, -0.006511688, 0.0037155151, -0.036315918, -0.034088135, -0.02281189, 0.002450943, 0.037475586, -0.015716553, -0.048095703, -0.0036029816, 0.017120361, 0.018508911, -0.025161743, 0.03479004, -0.026397705, 0.010475159, -0.0077667236, 0.012016296, 0.016052246, -0.057250977, 0.031585693, -0.060394287, 0.010871887, 0.017227173, -0.043151855, 0.016235352, 0.0031490326, -0.021896362, -0.017242432, 0.03439331, 0.07208252, -0.050476074, -0.015029907, 0.06958008, 0.039093018, 0.009109497, 0.03100586, 0.026412964, 0.021942139, -0.050354004, -0.030410767, -0.078063965, -0.00021779537, -0.025878906, 0.043395996, 0.05593872, -0.045074463, 0.0070114136, -0.01209259, -0.001914978, 0.03933716, -0.020523071, -0.005264282, -0.023452759, -0.011390686, -0.007701874, 0.004131317, 0.0017642975, -0.009231567, -0.006462097, 0.09991455, -0.0059928894, 0.0046081543, 0.016662598, 0.05026245, 0.01637268, -0.009880066, -0.048339844, -0.029785156, -0.0031929016, -0.0184021, 0.01852417, 0.003276825, -0.009147644, -0.059692383, 0.0006990433, 0.06640625, -0.0076789856, -0.046722412, 0.036499023, -0.081848145, -0.0023841858, -0.005180359, -0.011138916, 0.046295166, 0.06347656, -0.008888245, 0.026412964, -0.010765076, 0.007587433, -0.023925781, 0.005039215, -0.08544922, 0.03125, -0.03933716, -0.02130127, 0.018463135, -0.020614624, -0.042755127, 0.005340576, -0.0063476562, 0.03756714, 0.04031372, 0.019363403, 0.01209259, -0.019485474, 0.016082764, -0.038269043, 0.00021588802, -0.029205322, -0.019180298, 0.017959595, -0.013023376, 0.06555176, -0.0031471252, 0.007843018, -0.035186768, -0.0039043427, 0.01789856, 0.029830933, -0.012756348, -0.025894165, 0.0006098747, -0.0041923523, -0.023727417, 0.0032157898, -0.014045715, -0.0048980713, -0.03253174, 0.01687622, -0.016174316, 0.0748291, 0.043945312, 0.018600464, -0.02684021, -0.014892578, 0.014228821, -0.022125244, -0.08111572, 0.018081665, 0.032989502, 0.0073509216, 0.0038547516, 0.00087308884, -0.031143188, 0.022766113, 0.0023841858, -0.0053863525, -0.008338928, -0.012237549, -0.010643005, 0.008705139, 0.0012674332, 0.0087890625, -0.015335083, -0.0057754517, 0.010421753, 0.01373291, 0.044189453, -0.08203125, -0.026062012, 0.007888794, -0.13952637, -0.068237305, 0.028518677, -0.038757324, -0.035064697, -0.049591064, 0.0345459, -0.04800415, -0.028625488, 0.009101868, -0.007987976, 0.0024528503, -0.008010864, -0.08453369, -0.0099487305, 0.07611084, -0.016616821, 0.02885437, 0.030273438, -0.010292053, 0.01776123, -0.004234314, 0.005683899, 0.00667572, 0.05960083, 0.0023403168, -0.003578186, 0.03604126, -0.02583313, 0.0029010773, 0.0357666, -0.000395298, -0.0131073, 0.017700195, 0.0501709, 0.047973633, -0.04800415, 0.039093018, 0.04788208, -0.030563354, -0.081726074, 0.0059165955, 0.01007843, -0.01058197, 0.014572144, -0.0063171387, 0.00094795227, 0.022247314, 0.0104599, 0.028381348, -0.01878357, -0.049804688, 0.020553589, 0.011390686, 0.012001038, 0.014213562, -0.0005683899, 0.031311035, 0.015464783, 0.010925293, -0.0115737915, 0.014503479, 0.015777588, -0.034942627, -0.01777649, 0.010665894, -0.022201538, -0.019485474, -0.072021484, -0.027999878, -0.006893158, 0.016693115, -0.0022735596, 0.022277832, 0.036224365, -0.006511688, -0.031082153, 0.013938904, 0.011680603, 0.0045051575, -0.00894928, -0.046325684, 0.05340576, -0.040008545, -0.043762207, -0.06384277, -0.017990112, 0.0043182373, 0.04244995, 0.026229858, -0.015533447, 0.010055542, 0.019515991, 0.03741455, 0.040405273, -0.013397217, -0.045196533, 0.0030078888, -0.0135650635, -0.005542755, -0.012145996, 0.005832672, -0.011482239, -0.03652954, -0.024856567, -0.0023784637, -0.03729248, -0.039794922, 0.0155181885, 0.0064926147, 0.052093506, 0.022018433, 0.041992188, 0.030258179, -0.019836426, 0.011154175, -0.007232666, -0.031402588, 0.004322052, 0.038604736, 0.034057617, 0.00011354685, 0.032104492, 0.06384277, 0.0044898987, 0.016357422, -0.023330688, -0.0029888153, 0.02053833, -0.01398468, 0.013824463, -0.0071907043, -0.04638672, -0.03253174, -0.0010461807, 0.006942749, 0.049682617, -0.031021118, 0.054626465, -0.03149414, -0.0039787292, 0.0138168335, -0.017120361, 0.008071899, -0.015945435, 0.007663727, -0.03918457, -0.064575195, -0.0076293945, 0.058410645, -0.016494751, -0.019424438, -0.015068054, 0.04650879, 0.021133423, 0.03970337, 0.028778076, -0.006175995, 0.016998291, -0.0016183853, 0.0010051727, -0.00051498413, -0.04345703, 0.024398804, 0.0054626465, 0.009223938, 0.003583908, -0.026367188, -0.08312988, -0.012962341, -0.019973755, -0.034118652, 0.056030273, -0.06390381, 0.029251099, 0.10418701, -0.021728516, 0.05432129, -0.024459839, 0.023620605, 0.042114258, 0.032440186, 0.014480591, -0.00026130676, 0.020431519, -0.042175293, 0.014274597, 0.01701355, 0.04168701, -0.015045166, 0.009536743, 0.013038635, -0.018310547, -0.037139893, 0.019851685, 0.033050537, 0.03665161, -0.008239746, -0.049102783, 0.026504517, -0.00089502335, -0.029373169, 0.0041885376, -0.055755615, -0.012504578, 0.04815674, -0.035888672, 0.011375427, 0.038879395, 0.0018720627, -0.02381897, -0.02998352, -0.0067710876, -0.0039405823, 0.0011091232, 0.004486084, 0.037963867, -0.009437561, 0.022232056, 0.03845215, -0.055389404, 0.023086548, -0.006904602, 0.012054443, 0.0637207, 0.019943237, -0.023834229, 0.0016956329, -0.0072784424, -0.06915283, -0.0513916, -0.019088745, -0.028213501, 0.023880005, 0.009292603, -0.033294678, -0.00045895576, 0.016052246, 0.03173828, -0.011108398, -0.01789856, 0.04196167, 0.004802704, 0.019073486, -0.00063323975, 0.028671265, 0.0435791, -0.005241394, -0.014335632, -0.04598999, 0.034942627, -0.00023794174, 0.00076436996, -0.013961792, -0.028167725, 0.006126404, 0.025115967, -0.005836487, 0.014312744, 0.03579712, 0.044128418, 0.054656982, -0.020645142, 0.03100586, 0.058898926, -0.04928589, -0.05770874, -0.04324341, 0.012969971, -0.049346924, 0.0637207, 0.009895325, -0.03982544, -0.028701782, -0.05734253, -0.04446411, -0.008644104, 0.0289917, 0.03137207, 0.03756714, -0.020339966, 0.0043411255, -0.03253174, -0.016738892, -0.03515625, 0.018630981, -0.0032901764, -0.011657715, 0.02960205, 0.013702393, 0.0041122437, -0.0062789917, 0.022994995, -0.010185242, -0.014564514, 0.0038700104, -0.036499023, 0.025314331, -0.03616333, -0.016433716, 0.026443481, 0.045166016, -0.06427002, 0.019515991, -0.018997192, 0.05532837, 0.029296875, 0.061035156, 0.048736572, 0.026153564, 0.03463745, 0.0012025833, 0.017303467, -0.029769897, 0.0068626404, -0.04321289, 0.013214111, -0.054656982, 0.011619568, -0.08117676, 0.05090332, 0.0068969727, 0.034973145, 0.03982544, 0.012435913, 0.030670166, -0.012825012, 0.03756714, 0.007144928, 0.08532715, 0.008163452, -0.0017738342, 0.0026721954, 0.0060539246, 0.018096924, 0.018753052, 0.0076560974, 0.01626587, -0.022903442, -0.010673523, 0.008338928, 0.011383057, 0.009552002, -0.020812988, 0.002319336, -0.03704834, 0.01071167, -0.024810791, 0.021743774, 0.040985107, 0.033935547, 0.00687027, -0.0069274902, -0.014076233, 0.00013637543, -0.02557373, 0.00010615587, 0.06933594, -0.099487305, 0.015701294, -0.016662598, -0.026153564, 0.037322998, 0.014266968, 0.043945312, -0.06951904, -0.057922363, 0.031555176, 0.043701172, 0.0027999878, 0.011672974, -0.030334473, -0.011154175, 0.022277832, 0.02458191, -0.0042419434, 0.019866943, -0.004753113, 0.02368164, 0.0009493828, -0.024459839, 0.0007119179, 0.020217896, -0.031555176, 0.033935547, 0.0042648315, 0.037109375, 0.004634857, -0.038116455, 0.03778076, 0.0028038025, -0.028015137, -0.009735107, 0.030029297, 0.016082764, 0.008041382, 0.079956055, 0.043304443, -0.017532349, -0.044647217, -0.034088135, -0.013977051, 0.031433105, -0.03564453, 0.013832092, -0.034301758, -0.045288086, 0.034973145, -0.03945923, 0.05633545, -0.060760498, 0.00920105, -0.017105103, 0.02999878, 0.02394104, -0.045043945, -0.01612854, -0.022781372, -0.049102783, 0.0041999817, 0.0112838745, -0.031951904, -0.015609741, -0.011924744, -0.02053833, 0.001156807, -0.0065689087, -0.017730713, -0.021606445, -0.0574646, 0.01008606, -0.012542725, 0.04446411, -0.031021118, 0.0070724487, -0.027435303, 0.014122009, -0.0015153885, -0.019088745, -0.043884277, 0.04849243, -0.010299683, -0.055999756, 0.027053833, 0.024765015, -0.02684021, -0.047180176, 0.001124382, -0.013435364, -0.024765015, -0.01574707, 0.044158936, -0.034484863, -0.0552063, -0.018127441, -0.032928467, 0.046203613, 0.0015640259, -0.011421204, 0.011360168, 0.023986816, -0.038757324, -0.028945923, -0.018951416, 0.014862061, -0.011390686, -0.05291748, 0.0063095093, 0.036010742, 0.039733887, -0.038024902, -0.05142212, 0.020599365, 0.010261536, -0.021240234, 0.046020508, 0.009902954, -0.001490593, 0.017364502, 0.03753662, 0.007911682, -0.0390625, -0.05923462, -0.047576904, 0.046173096, 0.034606934, 0.0006637573, -0.03945923, 0.035888672, -0.007255554, -0.0003745556, 0.028839111, -0.016342163, 0.011985779, -0.0011529922, 0.022964478, -0.010246277, -0.047332764, 0.04135132, 0.041259766, -0.037750244, 0.024139404, -0.026779175, -0.013328552, 0.0047950745, -0.014335632, -0.010772705, -0.013633728, 0.035217285, 0.01448822, 0.024429321, 0.018173218, -0.019882202, -0.012802124, 0.014694214, -0.024856567, -0.032928467, -0.03012085, 0.06903076, -0.043762207, -0.021591187, -0.011665344, -0.013954163, 0.00055360794, -0.019134521, 0.064331055, -0.04135132, -0.01210022, -0.06347656, -0.02746582, 0.010307312, 0.03149414, 0.024963379, -0.0061531067, -0.047576904, -0.0119018555, 0.03125, -0.019363403 ], "summary": [ -0.03857422, -0.03994751, -0.023773193, -0.026687622, -0.078125, 0.007549286, -0.08477783, 0.006755829, -0.016052246, 0.005935669, -0.012931824, 0.024032593, -0.084106445, -0.031173706, 0.008369446, -0.049346924, -0.01701355, 0.035003662, 0.000052690506, -0.04510498, -0.0154418945, -0.05319214, 0.01586914, 0.05255127, -0.0146102905, -0.034576416, 0.010765076, -0.010246277, -0.011100769, -0.0042877197, -0.01007843, 0.02319336, 0.0077400208, 0.04019165, 0.000054836273, 0.08099365, 0.043395996, 0.00869751, 0.035858154, 0.027694702, 0.0014657974, -0.010177612, 0.16271973, -0.0993042, 0.06524658, 0.042877197, 0.007858276, -0.05444336, -0.02293396, -0.00060606, 0.01146698, 0.013877869, 0.0115356445, -0.0027580261, -0.0027580261, 0.0021095276, -0.0034503937, -0.052093506, -0.01663208, 0.041259766, 0.038269043, 0.017532349, -0.0016155243, 0.0068206787, -0.008308411, -0.023269653, -0.02243042, 0.016189575, 0.041168213, 0.0028190613, 0.0072364807, 0.027801514, 0.008895874, -0.03390503, -0.0064582825, 0.024002075, 0.008117676, 0.006832123, -0.014350891, -0.013015747, -0.03845215, -0.012748718, -0.053497314, 0.008979797, -0.022201538, 0.030029297, -0.023483276, 0.00012743473, 0.007965088, -0.021118164, -0.004650116, -0.014793396, -0.018966675, 0.038330078, 0.02607727, -0.0635376, -0.018569946, -0.06088257, 0.019226074, -0.0087890625, 0.0574646, -0.048675537, 0.010147095, 0.0075416565, -0.0019683838, 0.0670166, 0.00856781, -0.026626587, -0.013046265, -0.0006494522, 0.009048462, -0.036499023, -0.025436401, 0.014953613, -0.025054932, 0.006290436, -0.03326416, 0.01020813, -0.030075073, 0.02166748, 0.03161621, 0.061431885, -0.03161621, -0.012413025, 0.01637268, 0.029678345, -0.0050697327, -0.03286743, -0.06488037, 0.09100342, 0.008926392, -0.024368286, -0.019821167, 0.012191772, -0.039245605, -0.03213501, 0.025024414, -0.008621216, 0.0052986145, 0.009727478, -0.013084412, -0.0034751892, 0.017837524, 0.004337311, 0.01335144, 0.00077724457, 0.0074653625, 0.011047363, -0.006801605, 0.008369446, -0.026641846, 0.027557373, 0.033355713, -0.0110321045, -0.047607422, -0.019241333, -0.040618896, -0.0030994415, -0.008285522, -0.026138306, 0.03616333, 0.031555176, 0.0418396, 0.007972717, 0.008506775, -0.054748535, -0.054504395, -0.0071640015, -0.0010881424, -0.04824829, -0.009124756, 0.059783936, 0.023727417, -0.062164307, -0.011650085, -0.036132812, 0.009147644, -0.013656616, 0.0025310516, -0.0018253326, -0.020370483, -0.043518066, -0.016204834, -0.0014400482, -0.019836426, 0.012367249, 0.0078086853, -0.002494812, 0.016021729, 0.00013005733, -0.008575439, 0.02368164, 0.039154053, 0.00466156, -0.016815186, -0.054748535, 0.014457703, 0.008705139, -0.028930664, -0.0074386597, 0.03086853, -0.007896423, -0.006839752, -0.018249512, -0.022338867, -0.05065918, 0.001912117, -0.0021762848, -0.05819702, 0.017852783, 0.045776367, -0.019561768, -0.036376953, 0.07147217, 0.038024902, -0.023162842, 0.049041748, 0.011123657, -0.0015096664, -0.031188965, 0.01940918, 0.011314392, 0.010238647, 0.06738281, 0.034729004, 0.00907135, -0.015365601, -0.011558533, 0.032928467, -0.009338379, 0.041778564, 0.024215698, -0.0027256012, -0.018249512, -0.018554688, 0.0119018555, 0.028381348, -0.030288696, -0.010154724, 0.023849487, 0.021377563, 0.011741638, -0.008270264, 0.0052337646, 0.057556152, 0.023391724, 0.016342163, -0.016342163, -0.017822266, 0.03643799, 0.021591187, 0.043151855, 0.008613586, 0.030395508, -0.019760132, 0.05291748, -0.02067566, -0.00667572, 0.010810852, 0.009208679, -0.006000519, 0.04901123, 0.018066406, 0.008934021, -0.024459839, -0.020263672, -0.018188477, -0.0050468445, 0.011138916, -0.026412964, 0.0009012222, -0.035614014, -0.015068054, -0.02041626, -0.033843994, 0.036865234, -0.04776001, 0.052978516, 0.005455017, -0.020004272, -0.012306213, 0.02859497, 0.048706055, -0.013183594, 0.0022029877, 0.05090332, 0.026428223, -0.026031494, 0.025054932, 0.011650085, 0.027557373, -0.017868042, -0.034118652, 0.025054932, 0.009971619, -0.030914307, 0.000726223, 0.05114746, -0.013290405, -0.0024852753, -0.020614624, 0.004146576, -0.021896362, 0.0033130646, -0.006378174, 0.039916992, 0.022399902, -0.00022351742, -0.016098022, -0.040802002, 0.016479492, -0.016357422, 0.019805908, 0.037506104, -0.0045280457, -0.01789856, -0.01448822, 0.015823364, -0.054626465, -0.056121826, 0.07128906, -0.012191772, -0.053771973, -0.006877899, -0.013946533, -0.011779785, 0.016677856, -0.026153564, -0.021255493, -0.020874023, -0.010681152, -0.060791016, -0.020248413, 0.046020508, 0.009353638, -0.0016880035, 0.00031852722, 0.039916992, -0.018707275, -0.0054130554, -0.016159058, 0.040161133, 0.004184723, -0.037078857, -0.0018920898, -0.023803711, 0.02848816, -0.014282227, 0.01374054, 0.021865845, -0.018951416, -0.01586914, -0.023376465, 0.06536865, 0.041900635, -0.027908325, 0.02279663, 0.09539795, 0.035247803, 0.03390503, 0.01940918, 0.053649902, 0.03793335, -0.06298828, -0.070251465, -0.04827881, 0.037506104, -0.027069092, 0.061920166, 0.06085205, -0.0037193298, 0.046783447, -0.033355713, -0.008583069, 0.014282227, -0.016494751, 0.07354736, 0.003709793, 0.019470215, 0.055023193, 0.007843018, -0.010635376, -0.012908936, -0.058685303, 0.056274414, -0.0038814545, 0.014625549, 0.05041504, 0.024871826, 0.0036373138, -0.013656616, -0.008796692, -0.002462387, -0.01184082, -0.010795593, -0.012275696, 0.005256653, 0.029663086, -0.035491943, -0.016830444, 0.02545166, 0.0004184246, 0.015052795, -0.0058288574, -0.0146102905, 0.0048828125, 0.005344391, -0.010475159, 0.047668457, 0.013977051, 0.033966064, 0.009017944, 0.0035915375, 0.027404785, -0.03692627, -0.01663208, 0.015296936, 0.018753052, -0.016967773, -0.01689148, 0.027572632, 0.018951416, -0.011993408, 0.0102005005, 0.0034046173, -0.013549805, 0.010116577, 0.013008118, -0.017990112, 0.025634766, 0.0040893555, -0.018692017, 0.015975952, -0.011688232, -0.024291992, 0.01864624, -0.030899048, 0.016983032, -0.01373291, -0.037109375, -0.0026817322, -0.0014181137, 0.030227661, 0.028198242, 0.0023155212, -0.017288208, 0.00026345253, 0.00073337555, -0.018630981, -0.01727295, -0.015403748, 0.00088500977, -0.0030059814, 0.041809082, -0.0032539368, 0.10443115, 0.011131287, 0.024932861, 0.032806396, -0.0026054382, 0.0009255409, -0.0072021484, -0.025497437, 0.011131287, -0.00365448, 0.05026245, -0.046203613, 0.025985718, -0.021942139, -0.0071640015, 0.023208618, 0.0027618408, 0.008491516, -0.031066895, -0.0079574585, -0.037261963, 0.03189087, -0.012489319, 0.023895264, -0.024993896, -0.039855957, 0.037200928, 0.041046143, -0.1005249, -0.068237305, 0.021774292, -0.109375, -0.07775879, 0.03970337, -0.0023155212, -0.015655518, -0.050964355, 0.055389404, -0.037475586, -0.004623413, 0.028930664, -0.011505127, 0.07446289, -0.01651001, -0.061187744, 0.0032920837, -0.022079468, -0.02909851, 0.01928711, -0.028335571, 0.0077209473, 0.08935547, 0.03729248, -0.022323608, -0.03942871, 0.08514404, -0.02255249, 0.015586853, 0.046447754, -0.024658203, -0.036071777, 0.05291748, 0.015716553, -0.015014648, -0.0020332336, 0.053649902, 0.09411621, -0.03050232, 0.0035705566, 0.030349731, -0.030212402, -0.031677246, 0.000052034855, 0.0033721924, 0.0040626526, 0.003704071, 0.012580872, -0.017547607, 0.00086927414, 0.0357666, -0.031829834, -0.027114868, -0.09881592, -0.027938843, 0.038269043, -0.0019016266, -0.0008454323, -0.024108887, 0.059661865, 0.011871338, -0.001200676, -0.0058517456, 0.0043754578, -0.0028762817, -0.008598328, -0.030288696, -0.0022239685, -0.01335144, -0.03250122, -0.01763916, 0.023010254, 0.021697998, -0.0036849976, -0.011444092, 0.0109939575, -0.01928711, -0.0031661987, -0.006023407, 0.017593384, -0.024887085, 0.025161743, -0.05038452, -0.058013916, 0.05078125, -0.04940796, -0.023010254, -0.040771484, -0.049194336, -0.06323242, 0.007030487, 0.020553589, -0.02432251, -0.0075912476, 0.008987427, 0.02243042, 0.010009766, -0.025009155, -0.03366089, -0.0892334, -0.01676941, 0.019851685, -0.03765869, 0.011497498, -0.017501831, -0.0061912537, -0.006996155, -0.0062179565, -0.03704834, -0.054016113, -0.003900528, 0.012382507, 0.028320312, 0.06390381, 0.05041504, 0.020965576, -0.0076026917, 0.0131073, -0.00035905838, -0.0036945343, 0.0079193115, 0.049621582, 0.0008802414, 0.050354004, 0.031677246, 0.08270264, -0.021759033, -0.030975342, 0.006641388, 0.002506256, 0.055358887, -0.040008545, 0.010826111, -0.0054016113, 0.007068634, -0.013168335, 0.026031494, -0.01939392, 0.011062622, 0.039978027, 0.0016403198, -0.017959595, -0.028625488, 0.013412476, -0.007045746, -0.012641907, 0.016723633, -0.01676941, -0.00089788437, -0.042114258, 0.011978149, 0.021499634, 0.018814087, -0.013656616, -0.0206604, 0.04598999, 0.027679443, 0.0143966675, 0.015945435, -0.041137695, 0.016342163, -0.0010490417, -0.008026123, 0.03137207, -0.011924744, 0.028869629, 0.00054979324, -0.0021743774, 0.014007568, -0.055725098, -0.0048065186, -0.0009775162, -0.016601562, -0.015342712, 0.03427124, -0.034423828, -0.027832031, 0.04159546, -0.03857422, 0.024246216, -0.0041122437, 0.0101623535, 0.019073486, 0.02722168, 0.003238678, -0.021820068, -0.0033473969, -0.022964478, 0.034118652, 0.0068206787, 0.02923584, -0.012489319, -0.014884949, 0.0044174194, -0.0026226044, -0.02230835, 0.0038909912, 0.023757935, 0.042633057, -0.04159546, -0.024307251, 0.024353027, -0.02067566, 0.0079574585, -0.0335083, -0.03555298, 0.026062012, 0.077697754, -0.037628174, 0.038330078, 0.03842163, -0.03475952, -0.0020008087, -0.012954712, -0.008346558, -0.03652954, 0.006351471, 0.014923096, 0.011444092, 0.006839752, -0.030853271, -0.008605957, -0.019134521, 0.0090408325, 0.02357483, 0.027694702, 0.009552002, -0.02709961, -0.03149414, -0.0023536682, -0.018753052, -0.043670654, -0.051361084, -0.013717651, -0.019607544, 0.044799805, 0.0025157928, -0.013969421, 0.013038635, -0.014091492, 0.016448975, -0.046569824, -0.009628296, 0.015312195, -0.0073280334, -0.016357422, 0.004463196, -0.00088357925, 0.028366089, -0.00012254715, -0.024459839, -0.028625488, 0.04248047, -0.0052223206, 0.017501831, -0.03152466, 0.020431519, -0.008857727, 0.042175293, 0.0010890961, 0.03161621, 0.03375244, 0.022491455, -0.006214142, 0.01499176, 0.027404785, 0.024536133, -0.0057296753, -0.0748291, -0.05807495, 0.01134491, -0.0597229, 0.033813477, 0.03741455, -0.039794922, 0.0039634705, -0.05871582, 0.0040397644, -0.02067566, 0.0132751465, 0.029693604, 0.02935791, -0.019699097, -0.0053901672, -0.025497437, -0.02619934, -0.03060913, 0.0072135925, -0.023986816, -0.031280518, 0.056030273, -0.016067505, 0.01084137, 0.003730774, -0.007774353, -0.021728516, -0.025375366, 0.016662598, 0.004634857, 0.030975342, -0.013572693, 0.05633545, 0.0024528503, 0.04699707, -0.051971436, -0.035949707, 0.010269165, 0.02017212, 0.045318604, 0.045928955, 0.027236938, -0.012512207, 0.007095337, 0.013648987, -0.0052948, -0.022735596, -0.024597168, -0.013946533, 0.010940552, -0.019058228, 0.008728027, -0.0234375, 0.082092285, -0.019012451, -0.0023727417, 0.076538086, 0.0048332214, -0.0034255981, -0.010116577, -0.03338623, 0.04095459, 0.015129089, 0.0015039444, -0.00356102, 0.02558899, -0.0008497238, -0.020492554, 0.02017212, 0.009674072, 0.025039673, -0.008804321, 0.007335663, 0.04849243, -0.016464233, -0.033172607, -0.017974854, 0.04711914, -0.04876709, 0.011886597, 0.017654419, 0.052978516, -0.029205322, -0.026565552, 0.06359863, -0.01449585, -0.021987915, 0.028579712, -0.017456055, 0.006298065, 0.03302002, -0.030654907, -0.004398346, -0.009880066, -0.01108551, 0.08148193, -0.036102295, 0.064331055, -0.08190918, -0.05053711, 0.016677856, 0.02229309, -0.0395813, -0.008934021, -0.033325195, -0.021652222, 0.033050537, -0.0016222, -0.0028057098, -0.0014600754, 0.0052375793, -0.0027999878, 0.020355225, 0.0052490234, -0.0007710457, 0.023071289, 0.0102005005, 0.040740967, -0.009262085, 0.053100586, 0.03201294, -0.016448975, 0.053741455, 0.014015198, -0.0009765625, 0.024856567, 0.024719238, -0.00166893, 0.026367188, 0.058441162, 0.017974854, 0.006587982, -0.0140686035, -0.008323669, -0.050109863, 0.021240234, -0.0017261505, 0.023956299, -0.01828003, 0.0017566681, 0.041931152, -0.008377075, 0.033233643, -0.027511597, 0.023284912, -0.0256958, 0.027313232, -0.057128906, -0.025100708, 0.056274414, -0.028778076, -0.044555664, 0.02935791, 0.018310547, -0.034240723, 0.018157959, -0.029281616, -0.05065918, 0.008239746, -0.0040893555, -0.007949829, 0.0044898987, -0.013961792, -0.012519836, -0.0079193115, 0.031280518, 0.011917114, -0.007820129, -0.01687622, 0.056396484, 0.0029239655, -0.030395508, -0.028701782, 0.07647705, 0.008979797, -0.053344727, 0.036102295, 0.03463745, -0.012969971, -0.052520752, 0.050964355, -0.021865845, -0.0132369995, -0.004436493, 0.036590576, -0.0028495789, -0.0016756058, -0.008201599, -0.025878906, 0.02709961, -0.02268982, 0.014579773, 0.03250122, 0.044067383, -0.015975952, -0.021469116, -0.0127334595, -0.012527466, 0.006996155, -0.03704834, -0.0026397705, 0.045440674, 0.048614502, 0.0072402954, 0.028457642, 0.038970947, -0.024612427, -0.025390625, -0.018585205, -0.00655365, -0.006095886, 0.038604736, 0.040008545, -0.0003824234, -0.021331787, -0.044128418, -0.03918457, 0.043029785, -0.0047187805, -0.033843994, -0.012962341, 0.03717041, -0.02458191, -0.004890442, 0.0060768127, 0.015342712, -0.023666382, -0.008728027, 0.00017213821, -0.032989502, -0.05053711, 0.05328369, 0.0385437, -0.032989502, 0.009849548, -0.02029419, -0.014526367, 0.012306213, -0.025268555, -0.028396606, 0.057556152, -0.047332764, -0.027755737, 0.009963989, -0.03024292, -0.022415161, 0.035308838, 0.03878784, -0.02268982, -0.04107666, -0.036834717, 0.07684326, -0.051879883, -0.06359863, 0.022979736, 0.019882202, -0.07910156, -0.006023407, 0.027648926, -0.016784668, -0.02243042, -0.0096206665, -0.03543091, 0.045166016, -0.024963379, 0.08135986, 0.025466919, 0.007774353, -0.03189087, -0.018600464, 0.003742218 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2112.12591v5
Black-Box Testing of Deep Neural Networks Through Test Case Diversity
Zohreh Aghababaeyan, Manel Abdellatif, Lionel Briand, Ramesh S, Mojtaba Bagherzadeh
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.LG
Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) have been extensively used in many areas including image processing, medical diagnostics, and autonomous driving. However, DNNs can exhibit erroneous behaviours that may lead to critical errors, especially when used in safety-critical systems. Inspired by testing techniques for traditional software systems, researchers have proposed neuron coverage criteria, as an analogy to source code coverage, to guide the testing of DNN models. Despite very active research on DNN coverage, several recent studies have questioned the usefulness of such criteria in guiding DNN testing. Further, from a practical standpoint, these criteria are white-box as they require access to the internals or training data of DNN models, which is in many contexts not feasible or convenient. In this paper, we investigate black-box input diversity metrics as an alternative to white-box coverage criteria. To this end, we first select and adapt three diversity metrics and study, in a controlled manner, their capacity to measure actual diversity in input sets. We then analyse their statistical association with fault detection using four datasets and five DNN models. We further compare diversity with state-of-the-art white-box coverage criteria. Our experiments show that relying on the diversity of image features embedded in test input sets is a more reliable indicator than coverage criteria to effectively guide the testing of DNNs. Indeed, we found that one of our selected black-box diversity metrics far outperforms existing coverage criteria in terms of fault-revealing capability and computational time. Results also confirm the suspicions that state-of-the-art coverage metrics are not adequate to guide the construction of test input sets to detect as many faults as possible with natural inputs.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2112.12591v5
"2023-02-06T19:02:57"
"2021-12-20T20:12:53"
{ "title": [ -0.002407074, 0.005622864, -0.04067993, -0.0597229, 0.033935547, -0.021118164, -0.017486572, -0.008392334, -0.0007982254, 0.019607544, -0.032989502, 0.015525818, -0.020812988, -0.0059814453, -0.047058105, -0.0021133423, -0.010101318, 0.019470215, -0.01625061, -0.033172607, 0.0021705627, -0.031204224, 0.037353516, 0.032196045, 0.05117798, -0.051605225, -0.095947266, 0.02571106, -0.036102295, -0.040527344, -0.0032672882, 0.042236328, 0.032165527, 0.060302734, -0.036346436, 0.03463745, -0.03314209, 0.040771484, 0.020492554, -0.0022258759, 0.023803711, -0.011978149, 0.0026359558, -0.034118652, -0.0034542084, 0.0014467239, -0.027114868, -0.040802002, -0.03326416, 0.03289795, 0.03074646, 0.022521973, -0.008575439, 0.059814453, 0.028030396, -0.01612854, -0.014503479, -0.0154953, 0.050048828, 0.06951904, 0.022369385, -0.049713135, 0.0023403168, -0.04928589, -0.022872925, -0.016937256, 0.005207062, 0.013877869, 0.07946777, -0.0018625259, -0.033355713, 0.040039062, 0.009635925, 0.0029335022, -0.041015625, -0.022979736, 0.048217773, 0.0077438354, 0.029296875, -0.029953003, 0.009628296, -0.03463745, -0.013793945, 0.0060577393, 0.012802124, -0.00025820732, -0.00592041, -0.015899658, -0.04385376, -0.06060791, -0.0075187683, -0.03125, -0.044189453, 0.0005450249, 0.000073075294, -0.037322998, -0.03942871, -0.0010185242, -0.0045547485, -0.006454468, 0.0017557144, -0.0011930466, 0.0053634644, -0.020950317, 0.01902771, -0.0149383545, -0.02571106, -0.058044434, 0.0041923523, 0.031982422, -0.061706543, 0.035827637, -0.0049591064, -0.03439331, 0.017578125, 0.029281616, -0.0127334595, 0.02720642, 0.03552246, 0.029724121, -0.014190674, -0.05734253, 0.041046143, -0.00080919266, 0.034332275, 0.014625549, -0.050720215, -0.0071411133, -0.00447464, 0.03366089, -0.008613586, 0.04135132, -0.08380127, -0.08782959, -0.057495117, 0.029937744, -0.0073280334, 0.003522873, 0.0027484894, -0.000187397, 0.015541077, -0.032409668, -0.008163452, 0.021011353, -0.01725769, 0.031433105, 0.06512451, -0.014854431, -0.068115234, -0.06677246, -0.0231781, -0.0032634735, 0.006336212, 0.0014467239, -0.019119263, 0.008850098, -0.09173584, -0.0023899078, 0.015853882, 0.018737793, 0.020858765, 0.013824463, 0.010147095, 0.034088135, 0.062683105, -0.017700195, -0.017623901, 0.022399902, 0.010360718, 0.013824463, -0.037719727, 0.020843506, 0.010284424, -0.017562866, -0.020614624, 0.011459351, 0.026412964, 0.030593872, 0.015319824, -0.010269165, 0.016983032, -0.015167236, 0.03741455, 0.022125244, -0.06958008, -0.01574707, 0.0047721863, 0.009963989, 0.050079346, -0.0030574799, -0.0018129349, 0.012756348, -0.04940796, -0.036499023, -0.029144287, -0.001244545, -0.006549835, 0.013572693, -0.0028839111, 0.019821167, -0.045440674, -0.012207031, -0.027862549, -0.0010309219, -0.01272583, -0.042388916, -0.016815186, 0.017318726, -0.058044434, 0.03982544, 0.060913086, 0.007396698, -0.046173096, 0.035369873, 0.017059326, -0.056274414, 0.02067566, -0.009788513, -0.006340027, -0.027954102, -0.01689148, 0.019454956, 0.01171875, 0.044006348, 0.007709503, 0.016952515, -0.0019607544, -0.010688782, 0.06298828, 0.017120361, 0.09680176, -0.07171631, 0.017593384, 0.015640259, 0.00881958, -0.02027893, -0.00579834, -0.028289795, 0.012237549, 0.023651123, 0.010429382, -0.0011177063, -0.009300232, -0.0058174133, 0.06994629, 0.00034594536, 0.003932953, -0.0014896393, 0.004386902, 0.009544373, 0.029190063, 0.018981934, 0.044647217, -0.0061149597, 0.00006186962, 0.041534424, 0.008552551, 0.025283813, 0.004348755, 0.00014841557, -0.0065956116, 0.022506714, 0.016723633, 0.0006546974, -0.04345703, -0.0003387928, -0.030014038, 0.00079107285, 0.011817932, 0.018676758, 0.026046753, -0.07006836, -0.0004901886, 0.01826477, 0.019866943, 0.009254456, -0.018753052, 0.0035953522, 0.014595032, -0.027877808, -0.0019893646, 0.002696991, 0.042510986, 0.0022201538, 0.013832092, -0.015213013, 0.0126953125, -0.035217285, -0.019454956, -0.000058054924, 0.061828613, 0.020843506, 0.0113220215, -0.011199951, -0.0021381378, -0.010215759, 0.035095215, 0.083862305, -0.034240723, 0.030654907, -0.07373047, 0.026977539, 0.012809753, -0.012046814, -0.0017223358, 0.041107178, 0.0039863586, 0.011360168, -0.030563354, 0.018722534, -0.054016113, 0.00020956993, 0.01008606, -0.016799927, -0.039154053, -0.044799805, 0.005382538, -0.032684326, -0.03894043, -0.00894165, 0.10784912, 0.009109497, -0.00793457, -0.017074585, 0.010192871, -0.036712646, -0.027908325, -0.04550171, -0.015220642, 0.008804321, 0.0491333, 0.012779236, -0.044769287, -0.02507019, -0.0030670166, 0.013008118, -0.0057373047, 0.0390625, -0.018814087, -0.0088272095, 0.012176514, -0.013511658, 0.009414673, -0.02760315, -0.00157547, -0.037017822, 0.00032687187, 0.022460938, -0.054260254, -0.0043296814, 0.036071777, -0.038330078, -0.03857422, 0.0011405945, 0.041503906, -0.002073288, -0.007843018, 0.017959595, 0.025909424, -0.02633667, 0.02418518, 0.011047363, 0.0011234283, -0.025680542, -0.025131226, -0.04876709, 0.013572693, -0.020431519, 0.012489319, 0.05307007, -0.01939392, -0.0059928894, -0.051605225, -0.02041626, 0.014709473, -0.00969696, -0.0046844482, -0.022537231, -0.023880005, -0.017578125, -0.010322571, 0.013008118, -0.0206604, 0.015182495, 0.05569458, 0.0050735474, -0.03173828, 0.009414673, 0.023330688, 0.010864258, -0.0011997223, 0.012184143, -0.017990112, 0.0073509216, 0.023040771, -0.0013408661, -0.008575439, -0.018707275, -0.10089111, -0.016540527, 0.062927246, -0.0071029663, -0.023529053, 0.007850647, -0.049438477, -0.020339966, 0.010002136, -0.0030136108, 0.0030765533, 0.038757324, 0.01991272, -0.02557373, 0.004512787, -0.03817749, 0.035858154, -0.051849365, -0.11608887, 0.024459839, -0.030517578, 0.00088214874, -0.026397705, 0.014923096, -0.071777344, -0.00390625, 0.010025024, 0.0592041, 0.03463745, 0.0064964294, 0.04446411, -0.026931763, 0.033813477, -0.035461426, -0.009254456, -0.009475708, -0.03125, 0.03338623, 0.0015325546, 0.048431396, 0.03805542, -0.014564514, -0.004722595, -0.0028896332, 0.000010073185, 0.036956787, 0.02810669, -0.04925537, -0.0059127808, -0.00919342, -0.0033283234, 0.02331543, -0.013458252, -0.0152282715, -0.011856079, 0.011077881, -0.02798462, 0.06323242, 0.016342163, 0.007156372, -0.0020561218, -0.039916992, -0.0020198822, -0.032592773, -0.037475586, 0.012748718, 0.042266846, 0.016525269, -0.0052223206, -0.025527954, -0.061401367, 0.051574707, -0.01737976, -0.022155762, 0.014503479, -0.0129852295, 0.0052337646, -0.009811401, -0.015014648, 0.009963989, -0.018798828, 0.0070533752, -0.018722534, 0.011482239, -0.042541504, -0.024124146, 0.016082764, 0.0018558502, -0.0574646, 0.001493454, 0.03793335, -0.011367798, -0.00674057, -0.052001953, 0.051116943, -0.0099487305, -0.0058937073, 0.013313293, -0.02494812, 0.024917603, -0.017852783, -0.07281494, 0.0038871765, 0.06890869, 0.00032949448, 0.041809082, 0.02609253, -0.004802704, -0.048034668, -0.036499023, 0.0135650635, -0.028335571, 0.01146698, -0.012840271, -0.011726379, 0.025802612, -0.037902832, 0.052886963, -0.037353516, 0.019165039, -0.03729248, -0.0017728806, 0.026916504, 0.012992859, -0.018539429, 0.057556152, 0.002752304, -0.019989014, -0.06768799, -0.01838684, 0.001619339, -0.020996094, 0.009765625, -0.020233154, 0.037231445, 0.044311523, -0.0062217712, 0.086364746, -0.020812988, -0.016494751, 0.02279663, -0.011207581, -0.019073486, -0.023162842, 0.008476257, 0.0036201477, 0.010116577, 0.018234253, -0.004776001, 0.031951904, -0.04425049, -0.02835083, 0.008468628, 0.024017334, -0.04953003, -0.023895264, -0.046936035, -0.0016956329, 0.012931824, 0.00541687, -0.034484863, 0.012527466, 0.02078247, -0.023269653, -0.022766113, 0.015586853, 0.030731201, -0.0064086914, 0.016921997, -0.041015625, -0.006290436, -0.0036830902, -0.047851562, -0.026397705, 0.024475098, 0.008010864, 0.03579712, -0.024505615, -0.009178162, 0.016540527, 0.015556335, 0.054870605, 0.03414917, -0.016067505, -0.048828125, 0.025512695, -0.009536743, -0.020263672, 0.013198853, 0.016220093, -0.0009355545, -0.014602661, 0.019546509, -0.035247803, -0.015144348, -0.01210022, 0.027389526, -0.016342163, 0.045196533, -0.027420044, 0.027313232, 0.015167236, -0.017791748, 0.015014648, 0.016586304, -0.037078857, 0.010383606, 0.021408081, 0.026184082, -0.018051147, 0.039886475, 0.036621094, 0.0029659271, -0.011154175, -0.026870728, 0.04336548, -0.0001231432, -0.034820557, 0.006160736, 0.021255493, -0.042785645, -0.018600464, 0.01272583, 0.014099121, 0.057525635, -0.044677734, 0.06616211, -0.044433594, -0.024276733, 0.01689148, 0.012763977, 0.00504303, -0.01625061, 0.018173218, -0.080078125, -0.07281494, -0.031143188, 0.0541687, -0.033447266, -0.017440796, 0.017456055, 0.013381958, 0.016815186, 0.04864502, 0.048034668, -0.013786316, 0.008338928, -0.019470215, -0.014266968, -0.018005371, -0.053833008, 0.00207901, -0.022766113, 0.018692017, -0.072143555, 0.037841797, -0.029067993, -0.02330017, 0.008918762, -0.011138916, 0.00015282631, -0.07525635, 0.012886047, 0.030944824, -0.0016269684, 0.027069092, 0.016464233, 0.008148193, 0.030593872, 0.049987793, 0.011756897, 0.01939392, 0.03778076, -0.04336548, 0.024841309, -0.0021514893, 0.051239014, 0.009269714, -0.008354187, 0.01713562, 0.00018084049, -0.056549072, 0.02168274, 0.021713257, 0.004558563, 0.04309082, -0.067871094, -0.000033199787, 0.010276794, 0.007663727, 0.014656067, -0.022125244, 0.010215759, 0.038635254, -0.022415161, 0.0026416779, 0.017501831, -0.008430481, -0.030090332, -0.052093506, -0.011947632, -0.012001038, 0.03564453, -0.010307312, -0.009468079, -0.05392456, 0.04119873, 0.0036964417, -0.06982422, -0.028884888, -0.00013136864, 0.018722534, 0.015701294, 0.020996094, -0.072021484, -0.012496948, 0.016738892, -0.026824951, -0.045654297, -0.008804321, 0.007598877, -0.008682251, -0.0107040405, -0.033721924, -0.008705139, -0.008964539, 0.011383057, -0.0026988983, -0.030883789, 0.02658081, 0.014457703, 0.020980835, 0.006340027, 0.016967773, 0.028076172, 0.0056266785, -0.008277893, -0.007385254, 0.008712769, -0.0065689087, 0.0079956055, -0.0052223206, -0.053253174, 0.007511139, 0.017456055, 0.025924683, 0.0040245056, 0.01966858, 0.04071045, -0.012626648, 0.019134521, 0.022277832, 0.078063965, -0.054840088, -0.021484375, 0.012931824, 0.0017232895, 0.018829346, 0.07904053, -0.026535034, -0.026611328, -0.041168213, -0.065979004, -0.03781128, 0.010017395, 0.05657959, 0.032287598, 0.061431885, -0.037475586, 0.025390625, -0.05831909, -0.024795532, -0.034179688, 0.008155823, -0.031082153, -0.05657959, 0.05697632, -0.008049011, -0.0022621155, -0.018859863, 0.02357483, 0.027145386, -0.0026683807, 0.03451538, -0.050811768, -0.004295349, -0.009651184, -0.03817749, 0.016616821, 0.0049438477, -0.019317627, 0.016143799, -0.017929077, 0.058380127, 0.000323534, 0.036895752, 0.026504517, 0.007007599, 0.021942139, -0.0052757263, 0.0020694733, -0.024276733, 0.0030670166, -0.046844482, -0.011482239, -0.06640625, -0.009300232, -0.05871582, 0.013656616, -0.007007599, 0.033569336, 0.013191223, 0.015419006, 0.008659363, 0.0010223389, 0.05709839, -0.008865356, 0.06536865, 0.045776367, 0.022003174, -0.0016202927, -0.024337769, 0.027267456, 0.029708862, -0.016098022, 0.042755127, 0.023101807, -0.04660034, 0.011489868, 0.031188965, 0.025177002, -0.022964478, -0.025665283, -0.03201294, 0.06854248, 0.012931824, 0.055480957, 0.05316162, 0.025497437, 0.014038086, -0.03439331, -0.009536743, -0.012886047, -0.0063438416, -0.0009212494, 0.033966064, -0.049560547, 0.021728516, -0.012916565, -0.021881104, -0.0032634735, 0.0513916, 0.014884949, -0.03012085, -0.0041885376, 0.019241333, 0.030548096, 0.011764526, 0.000009834766, -0.039398193, -0.0018415451, 0.041290283, 0.03488159, -0.008026123, -0.002779007, 0.009109497, 0.019332886, -0.009315491, -0.013793945, 0.008651733, 0.048095703, -0.015945435, 0.024429321, -0.033447266, 0.027267456, 0.001461029, -0.018859863, -0.007472992, 0.020568848, -0.059631348, -0.013801575, 0.052947998, 0.067871094, 0.05496216, 0.064819336, 0.0082092285, -0.029266357, 0.047424316, -0.054351807, 0.024047852, 0.035858154, -0.029708862, 0.021820068, -0.027114868, -0.025268555, 0.049468994, -0.0043792725, 0.09411621, -0.025146484, 0.001996994, -0.035736084, 0.014892578, 0.022491455, -0.056121826, 0.020706177, -0.04989624, 0.007820129, -0.007972717, 0.0037403107, -0.012458801, -0.03186035, 0.011222839, 0.041778564, 0.026672363, 0.0069007874, -0.004211426, -0.035491943, -0.057434082, 0.03604126, -0.030593872, 0.068237305, -0.010757446, -0.010627747, -0.0070533752, 0.0048980713, -0.010215759, -0.019866943, -0.017288208, -0.01701355, -0.022827148, -0.057037354, 0.01512146, 0.013824463, -0.03225708, -0.027648926, -0.07873535, 0.005115509, -0.03668213, -0.008354187, 0.045715332, -0.037231445, -0.027572632, 0.0115356445, -0.025268555, 0.048828125, 0.035705566, 0.005214691, 0.019256592, 0.008865356, 0.0010166168, 0.024856567, 0.05456543, 0.07373047, -0.012382507, -0.04510498, 0.012565613, 0.038726807, 0.06225586, -0.037261963, -0.06921387, 0.018218994, -0.0209198, -0.009986877, 0.05508423, -0.006965637, 0.0041160583, 0.032684326, 0.06323242, 0.020446777, -0.055786133, -0.044677734, -0.030273438, 0.07208252, 0.033966064, -0.024551392, -0.01637268, 0.011314392, -0.018203735, -0.0010652542, 0.016693115, 0.0014915466, 0.004337311, 0.002254486, 0.026229858, -0.011245728, -0.013534546, -0.025299072, 0.05441284, -0.013084412, 0.03387451, -0.0016880035, 0.001537323, 0.02709961, 0.072631836, -0.01134491, -0.04031372, 0.020492554, 0.029067993, 0.018829346, 0.0317688, -0.039123535, -0.037963867, -0.016082764, -0.02229309, -0.023468018, -0.018203735, 0.053466797, -0.03967285, 0.0021152496, -0.017700195, -0.042999268, 0.023254395, -0.027160645, 0.04559326, -0.027359009, 0.0016231537, -0.018371582, -0.012557983, -0.007980347, 0.009933472, 0.030090332, -0.02532959, -0.037597656, -0.011978149, 0.046020508, -0.010803223 ], "summary": [ 0.05331421, 0.018615723, -0.013900757, -0.006931305, 0.014671326, -0.0395813, 0.0036735535, -0.048706055, -0.01902771, 0.00004386902, -0.03604126, 0.0029087067, -0.017959595, -0.023406982, 0.009674072, -0.04019165, -0.015808105, 0.001704216, -0.008384705, -0.04135132, 0.023544312, -0.043273926, -0.0067214966, -0.012435913, 0.03213501, -0.036499023, -0.067993164, 0.009841919, -0.021942139, -0.008453369, -0.00016510487, 0.047790527, -0.014373779, 0.02998352, 0.038848877, 0.026565552, 0.027786255, 0.021820068, 0.04525757, 0.010505676, 0.027038574, -0.01184082, 0.116882324, -0.059173584, 0.059020996, -0.0013589859, 0.038970947, -0.071899414, 0.018814087, 0.007709503, -0.0060768127, 0.01335144, -0.016342163, 0.015571594, -0.004901886, 0.009414673, -0.04336548, -0.029037476, 0.039093018, 0.09234619, 0.021087646, -0.037231445, -0.012245178, -0.078430176, -0.011894226, -0.005756378, 0.020904541, -0.0067749023, 0.01838684, -0.001709938, 0.023391724, 0.01335144, 0.0093688965, -0.041931152, -0.0011091232, 0.006259918, 0.011512756, -0.0077171326, -0.00970459, -0.015930176, 0.019699097, -0.01058197, 0.018539429, -0.0073776245, -0.026565552, -0.023132324, -0.0077705383, -0.005432129, -0.019729614, -0.027542114, -0.008056641, -0.020523071, -0.07836914, 0.036621094, 0.044830322, -0.06048584, -0.020248413, -0.012168884, -0.014923096, 0.015419006, 0.019561768, -0.025100708, 0.050445557, -0.036376953, 0.010749817, -0.022064209, -0.058654785, -0.064331055, 0.033477783, 0.04699707, -0.04196167, -0.0042266846, -0.016113281, -0.072753906, 0.0053863525, 0.052246094, 0.015617371, 0.0051193237, 0.026611328, -0.00793457, -0.033721924, -0.01007843, 0.025299072, 0.0119018555, 0.012557983, 0.016036987, -0.01084137, -0.013450623, -0.0087890625, 0.014038086, -0.003774643, 0.028167725, -0.02268982, -0.01991272, -0.045806885, -0.01134491, 0.02696228, -0.00141716, 0.019058228, -0.04989624, 0.03012085, 0.02116394, -0.0030536652, 0.00831604, -0.041503906, 0.017089844, 0.027954102, 0.0060157776, -0.032714844, -0.06915283, 0.0005106926, -0.0074920654, 0.019729614, -0.0031604767, 0.0023670197, -0.01083374, -0.0043525696, -0.011047363, -0.011169434, 0.0021419525, 0.03149414, 0.03338623, 0.026779175, 0.03086853, -0.0001052022, -0.055389404, -0.00983429, -0.0010004044, 0.002735138, -0.024749756, -0.01159668, 0.019866943, -0.029815674, 0.00007146597, 0.017349243, 0.004611969, 0.0077781677, 0.06506348, -0.0034065247, -0.015731812, 0.011009216, -0.035888672, 0.06512451, 0.0057640076, -0.05895996, 0.03173828, -0.011772156, 0.048858643, 0.05230713, -0.0079422, 0.036468506, -0.01335907, -0.018966675, -0.013458252, -0.015029907, 0.007045746, -0.042816162, -0.0038776398, -0.03253174, 0.016479492, 0.04006958, -0.0068969727, -0.01083374, -0.04324341, -0.09869385, -0.015792847, -0.02154541, 0.0146484375, -0.033599854, -0.00068855286, 0.022369385, -0.029327393, -0.03463745, 0.047027588, -0.0076065063, -0.023132324, 0.06878662, -0.029464722, 0.0018310547, -0.025802612, -0.0051078796, 0.05331421, -0.0362854, 0.055725098, 0.013763428, 0.011314392, 0.0051460266, -0.002670288, 0.08453369, 0.007461548, 0.07446289, -0.058258057, 0.01247406, 0.05142212, 0.027175903, -0.000289917, 0.037078857, -0.064941406, 0.035980225, 0.021972656, 0.04425049, 0.053741455, 0.012008667, -0.0057868958, 0.031036377, -0.008056641, 0.029632568, -0.053253174, -0.011268616, 0.011962891, -0.014091492, -0.01928711, 0.039733887, -0.06939697, -0.039093018, 0.051635742, -0.014801025, 0.01020813, 0.0418396, -0.03640747, -0.011169434, -0.011268616, 0.024871826, -0.014297485, 0.010429382, -0.053131104, 0.006164551, -0.008483887, 0.026611328, -0.033294678, -0.0045928955, -0.051849365, -0.0054130554, 0.01890564, 0.021652222, 0.022460938, -0.02508545, -0.0045280457, 0.014144897, 0.009887695, 0.0052871704, 0.0034122467, 0.011062622, -0.011436462, 0.025985718, -0.00592041, 0.00856781, -0.007987976, 0.043273926, 0.07183838, 0.09185791, -0.02508545, 0.017303467, -0.008903503, -0.019851685, -0.026626587, -0.00818634, 0.04196167, -0.009147644, -0.00015711784, 0.0039367676, 0.037231445, -0.006137848, -0.0006322861, 0.015350342, 0.03579712, 0.0206604, 0.011230469, 0.012542725, 0.019866943, -0.057495117, -0.024261475, 0.029174805, 0.014434814, -0.0061950684, -0.020645142, -0.0115356445, 0.04812622, -0.0018615723, 0.024749756, 0.09875488, 0.031555176, 0.015930176, -0.0036697388, 0.015266418, -0.062683105, -0.00078487396, -0.032318115, -0.03439331, 0.009292603, -0.020736694, -0.012519836, -0.040100098, 0.0335083, 0.0020065308, 0.02709961, 0.009483337, 0.028030396, 0.019454956, -0.006214142, 0.051940918, -0.0021591187, -0.016738892, 0.009315491, -0.00982666, -0.013053894, 0.037353516, -0.003616333, -0.05142212, 0.021835327, 0.02053833, -0.045440674, -0.051696777, -0.0012874603, -0.02571106, -0.006843567, 0.0692749, 0.0038204193, -0.0044822693, -0.026504517, 0.030441284, 0.024612427, 0.0027427673, -0.03656006, -0.035217285, -0.03930664, 0.010322571, -0.0048713684, 0.018539429, 0.018081665, -0.0107421875, 0.031799316, -0.04333496, -0.019897461, -0.0022563934, -0.009002686, 0.041656494, -0.019577026, -0.0023880005, 0.007297516, -0.017486572, -0.0059394836, 0.008712769, 0.010520935, 0.026153564, 0.0069274902, -0.0025100708, 0.04660034, 0.014541626, 0.0011930466, -0.013175964, 0.02029419, 0.05328369, -0.020065308, 0.014373779, 0.02381897, -0.061798096, -0.056365967, -0.011627197, -0.0010719299, 0.05606079, 0.0013237, 0.028320312, -0.021392822, 0.00028324127, -0.028121948, 0.013114929, 0.01626587, -0.010971069, 0.035217285, -0.009292603, -0.023147583, -0.0008583069, -0.038757324, 0.040222168, -0.024307251, -0.007865906, 0.013343811, -0.044921875, -0.020095825, -0.0134887695, 0.07019043, -0.03881836, -0.017471313, 0.014175415, 0.053253174, 0.007797241, 0.0016956329, 0.007598877, 0.0018939972, 0.030670166, -0.02166748, -0.00806427, 0.01626587, -0.02218628, 0.0418396, -0.013336182, -0.018951416, 0.023773193, -0.04473877, -0.024658203, 0.0001180768, 0.031829834, 0.026611328, 0.04208374, -0.031158447, -0.0002092123, -0.016693115, 0.002626419, 0.021377563, 0.030761719, -0.010658264, 0.030303955, 0.01676941, -0.024429321, 0.06781006, -0.021194458, 0.023361206, 0.005039215, -0.0592041, -0.011695862, -0.0340271, 0.0090789795, -0.021560669, 0.009140015, 0.01713562, -0.048919678, 0.0055618286, -0.027999878, 0.011039734, -0.00052547455, 0.010887146, -0.020431519, -0.009086609, 0.011177063, -0.034210205, 0.0054855347, 0.01108551, 0.019180298, 0.00021719933, -0.039794922, 0.004650116, -0.023712158, 0.006549835, 0.03375244, 0.0096588135, 0.008354187, 0.0017490387, 0.04046631, 0.052612305, 0.014526367, -0.004432678, 0.07550049, 0.019744873, 0.029251099, 0.017791748, -0.02041626, 0.07006836, -0.035308838, -0.10015869, 0.047607422, -0.03982544, 0.040740967, 0.07293701, -0.03225708, 0.04220581, 0.011184692, -0.025177002, 0.005592346, -0.055908203, -0.00090932846, -0.050872803, -0.0054893494, 0.008972168, -0.03552246, 0.072265625, -0.079833984, 0.02746582, -0.040863037, -0.0047340393, 0.05114746, 0.029067993, -0.019210815, 0.009780884, 0.02230835, 0.01638794, -0.06311035, 0.0062179565, 0.018722534, -0.050598145, 0.005306244, -0.007068634, -0.014503479, 0.06890869, 0.016601562, 0.053863525, -0.0053863525, -0.045562744, -0.022369385, 0.027114868, -0.009010315, -0.015930176, -0.0019369125, 0.021148682, -0.03186035, -0.006679535, -0.059417725, -0.017120361, -0.051940918, -0.06518555, 0.019851685, 0.036010742, -0.047851562, -0.06384277, -0.007671356, -0.010612488, 0.016815186, -0.008514404, -0.0023670197, -0.008323669, -0.026519775, -0.02645874, 0.041625977, -0.0045280457, 0.045135498, 0.033813477, -0.033355713, -0.054656982, -0.03048706, 0.0019817352, -0.016555786, -0.015716553, 0.017593384, -0.018844604, -0.030899048, -0.044525146, -0.0128479, 0.012535095, 0.00019550323, 0.039215088, 0.021835327, 0.016235352, -0.046966553, 0.013687134, -0.038330078, -0.019439697, 0.024932861, -0.014465332, -0.02609253, -0.017120361, 0.040222168, -0.021072388, -0.022064209, 0.035217285, 0.004009247, -0.000026762486, 0.02633667, -0.0345459, 0.03527832, -0.0023727417, 0.009407043, 0.0028533936, 0.002090454, -0.010032654, 0.007827759, 0.0006155968, -0.0038108826, 0.019821167, 0.037841797, 0.021362305, 0.00013744831, -0.042510986, 0.0004851818, 0.05050659, 0.002904892, -0.05621338, 0.0030822754, 0.0076141357, 0.015823364, 0.012496948, 0.034301758, 0.0037841797, 0.020004272, 0.0021266937, 0.05230713, -0.0063438416, -0.04864502, 0.0041618347, 0.0075569153, -0.0018539429, -0.020736694, 0.00055933, -0.07080078, -0.06982422, -0.054779053, 0.075683594, -0.03692627, -0.06567383, 0.0107803345, 0.009277344, 0.0016908646, 0.036743164, 0.018554688, -0.024230957, 0.0022563934, -0.004398346, -0.0076026917, -0.020690918, -0.026916504, -0.040252686, -0.033966064, -0.0018234253, 0.009727478, 0.0066375732, 0.010101318, -0.0019874573, 0.0050086975, -0.009811401, -0.0013065338, -0.05065918, -0.026611328, 0.006038666, -0.034576416, 0.021270752, 0.020004272, 0.0036563873, -0.0012083054, 0.016571045, -0.007774353, -0.021636963, 0.0063934326, -0.07836914, 0.0008125305, -0.022247314, 0.008735657, 0.030593872, -0.017211914, 0.026931763, -0.0024280548, -0.025939941, -0.009101868, -0.010498047, 0.01979065, 0.0231781, -0.034179688, 0.016952515, -0.015686035, 0.0006427765, 0.0056915283, -0.015426636, 0.0079422, 0.022949219, -0.0129470825, -0.014770508, 0.008163452, -0.010795593, -0.010368347, -0.059265137, -0.049072266, -0.0009908676, 0.06112671, -0.035339355, 0.011734009, -0.044281006, -0.0084991455, -0.0345459, -0.05041504, 0.0022563934, 0.01576233, 0.03286743, -0.024658203, -0.01966858, -0.03869629, 0.00029492378, 0.04083252, -0.0143585205, -0.064941406, -0.03616333, -0.040527344, 0.01701355, -0.01084137, -0.020599365, 0.007511139, -0.044281006, 0.0027332306, -0.026321411, -0.007083893, 0.0018587112, 0.0075912476, 0.0044441223, 0.029449463, -0.017593384, 0.009216309, 0.0073509216, 0.0002644062, 0.005844116, -0.031982422, 0.010185242, -0.013473511, -0.03201294, -0.07543945, 0.0067596436, -0.0073394775, -0.0064430237, 0.054473877, 0.0256958, 0.022247314, 0.009544373, 0.038513184, 0.031280518, 0.059417725, -0.022354126, -0.039154053, 0.004638672, 0.035186768, 0.031143188, 0.03982544, -0.044677734, -0.0357666, -0.004802704, -0.05899048, -0.010284424, 0.0045776367, 0.05718994, 0.05126953, 0.09222412, -0.017822266, 0.01033783, -0.027450562, -0.031433105, -0.014190674, 0.016906738, -0.035308838, -0.039367676, 0.06518555, -0.03579712, -0.019256592, 0.0003643036, 0.02456665, 0.041229248, 0.0032844543, 0.057678223, -0.01638794, -0.017349243, 0.013290405, -0.00084400177, -0.012252808, -0.0070152283, -0.009757996, -0.030578613, 0.0061683655, 0.04006958, -0.0093688965, -0.044189453, -0.023788452, -0.027786255, -0.005001068, -0.012535095, -0.053527832, -0.009391785, 0.0047950745, -0.0008635521, -0.05697632, -0.03652954, -0.030395508, -0.0007972717, 0.025054932, -0.01939392, 0.008926392, 0.0077667236, 0.018341064, -0.005092621, 0.009361267, -0.01576233, 0.004283905, 0.024963379, 0.03652954, 0.0025367737, 0.021316528, -0.03491211, 0.013641357, 0.037078857, -0.01878357, 0.037963867, 0.031204224, -0.043914795, 0.016601562, 0.029830933, -0.008796692, -0.047668457, 0.01737976, -0.037872314, 0.07739258, 0.05819702, 0.062438965, 0.007724762, -0.0061149597, 0.07965088, -0.04888916, -0.010345459, 0.016662598, -0.00598526, 0.012939453, 0.016403198, -0.0046577454, -0.017684937, -0.0154953, -0.016052246, 0.030441284, 0.08441162, 0.001707077, 0.006187439, 0.04244995, -0.0008068085, -0.009979248, 0.015792847, -0.0211792, -0.041748047, 0.014732361, 0.020843506, -0.038330078, 0.011520386, -0.050933838, 0.013069153, -0.017440796, 0.01876831, 0.017150879, 0.01272583, 0.07659912, 0.0077323914, 0.023529053, -0.037322998, 0.010688782, -0.0023841858, -0.02508545, 0.013160706, 0.012420654, -0.0057258606, -0.00023686886, 0.036865234, 0.055908203, 0.064697266, 0.03152466, -0.038970947, -0.00047969818, 0.08081055, -0.023452759, 0.013938904, 0.002986908, 0.00040769577, 0.0008354187, -0.006801605, 0.0038146973, 0.033416748, 0.019424438, 0.09063721, -0.017608643, 0.008804321, -0.032928467, -0.024658203, -0.026870728, 0.0057029724, 0.06640625, -0.059753418, 0.0390625, -0.004878998, 0.00022029877, -0.042236328, -0.017807007, 0.009750366, 0.012748718, 0.03289795, 0.018676758, 0.03656006, -0.03286743, -0.04537964, 0.06817627, 0.016708374, 0.101623535, 0.005859375, -0.0060310364, 0.018554688, 0.001707077, -0.0040893555, 0.002527237, 0.0032367706, 0.017333984, -0.023498535, -0.072265625, 0.01071167, 0.00012683868, -0.03781128, -0.01676941, -0.07312012, 0.018981934, -0.033477783, 0.027374268, 0.032714844, -0.013305664, -0.023513794, 0.022018433, -0.049438477, 0.04446411, 0.0038337708, 0.024627686, -0.028381348, 0.018936157, 0.013786316, 0.016571045, 0.06896973, 0.06317139, -0.024414062, -0.029724121, -0.018615723, 0.028549194, 0.030670166, -0.0259552, -0.06329346, 0.033843994, -0.004119873, 0.0085372925, 0.013496399, -0.0446167, -0.0017547607, 0.038604736, 0.0769043, 0.019943237, -0.03765869, -0.020736694, -0.0074310303, 0.06817627, -0.008468628, -0.02949524, -0.03543091, -0.010498047, -0.012214661, -0.011489868, 0.03793335, 0.0034446716, -0.004322052, 0.016113281, 0.037109375, -0.017211914, -0.04953003, -0.0061149597, 0.027786255, -0.009674072, 0.0032978058, 0.010864258, -0.0016031265, 0.01802063, 0.054626465, -0.008155823, 0.036102295, -0.036193848, -0.021453857, 0.027450562, 0.00017654896, -0.0012903214, -0.0031776428, 0.0032176971, -0.0096588135, 0.0028476715, -0.0018815994, 0.03463745, -0.049072266, -0.022399902, -0.036010742, -0.04840088, 0.015625, -0.03527832, 0.03466797, -0.001285553, 0.013183594, 0.067993164, -0.027740479, 0.017242432, -0.013801575, 0.0211792, -0.010124207, 0.012825012, 0.038879395, 0.0033931732, 0.019042969 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2112.13210v1
Explainable Artificial Intelligence for Pharmacovigilance: What Features Are Important When Predicting Adverse Outcomes?
Isaac Ronald Ward, Ling Wang, Juan lu, Mohammed Bennamoun, Girish Dwivedi, Frank M Sanfilippo
q-bio.QM, cs.AI, cs.LG
Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) has been identified as a viable method for determining the importance of features when making predictions using Machine Learning (ML) models. In this study, we created models that take an individual's health information (e.g. their drug history and comorbidities) as inputs, and predict the probability that the individual will have an Acute Coronary Syndrome (ACS) adverse outcome. Using XAI, we quantified the contribution that specific drugs had on these ACS predictions, thus creating an XAI-based technique for pharmacovigilance monitoring, using ACS as an example of the adverse outcome to detect. Individuals aged over 65 who were supplied Musculo-skeletal system (anatomical therapeutic chemical (ATC) class M) or Cardiovascular system (ATC class C) drugs between 1993 and 2009 were identified, and their drug histories, comorbidities, and other key features were extracted from linked Western Australian datasets. Multiple ML models were trained to predict if these individuals would have an ACS related adverse outcome (i.e., death or hospitalisation with a discharge diagnosis of ACS), and a variety of ML and XAI techniques were used to calculate which features -- specifically which drugs -- led to these predictions. The drug dispensing features for rofecoxib and celecoxib were found to have a greater than zero contribution to ACS related adverse outcome predictions (on average), and it was found that ACS related adverse outcomes can be predicted with 72% accuracy. Furthermore, the XAI libraries LIME and SHAP were found to successfully identify both important and unimportant features, with SHAP slightly outperforming LIME. ML models trained on linked administrative health datasets in tandem with XAI algorithms can successfully quantify feature importance, and with further development, could potentially be used as pharmacovigilance monitoring techniques.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2112.13210v1
"2021-12-25T09:00:08"
"2021-12-25T09:00:08"
{ "title": [ -0.022735596, -0.0034255981, -0.030273438, -0.0657959, -0.009849548, -0.0021629333, -0.035369873, 0.018173218, -0.03353882, 0.0099487305, -0.017868042, -0.0058021545, -0.0071029663, -0.041503906, -0.0017461777, -0.03289795, 0.0026111603, 0.020217896, 0.025726318, -0.025985718, -0.0074653625, -0.017288208, 0.059906006, 0.015731812, 0.019165039, -0.00737381, -0.04144287, -0.013961792, -0.019683838, -0.038635254, -0.0005207062, 0.025878906, -0.023361206, 0.027816772, 0.016342163, -0.02394104, -0.0037670135, 0.039520264, 0.033966064, -0.008811951, -0.0044021606, -0.0009365082, 0.07122803, -0.0647583, 0.026000977, 0.033966064, -0.044525146, -0.028198242, 0.00012683868, -0.02142334, 0.0057258606, 0.00806427, 0.02809143, -0.0011224747, -0.0152282715, -0.018676758, -0.046020508, -0.026672363, 0.03729248, 0.008995056, -0.004837036, -0.053588867, 0.041290283, -0.005241394, -0.024627686, -0.027572632, -0.034576416, 0.027328491, 0.03479004, 0.0017185211, 0.00793457, 0.010894775, 0.0046463013, -0.00023341179, -0.036102295, -0.026931763, 0.026016235, 0.011146545, 0.01663208, -0.02519226, -0.04360962, -0.037994385, -0.033691406, -0.032714844, 0.021713257, -0.0016126633, -0.010444641, 0.010246277, -0.040008545, -0.057556152, -0.01524353, -0.024658203, -0.0569458, 0.016220093, -0.0049972534, -0.041656494, -0.016403198, -0.0073051453, 0.0060310364, -0.016403198, 0.007583618, -0.012680054, -0.029052734, -0.009552002, 0.005710602, 0.048217773, 0.024520874, -0.0055274963, -0.0105896, -0.0023212433, -0.025146484, -0.00054073334, 0.003686905, -0.029525757, 0.0045318604, 0.015159607, -0.012992859, 0.028808594, 0.028869629, 0.016464233, 0.028884888, 0.013114929, 0.007888794, -0.000117599964, 0.017074585, -0.0076522827, -0.05407715, 0.0038261414, -0.02935791, 0.09307861, 0.0068206787, 0.0209198, -0.062927246, -0.061523438, -0.06976318, -0.0029087067, 0.027160645, 0.009635925, -0.0132751465, 0.016403198, 0.026916504, -0.012069702, 0.04058838, 0.04309082, -0.032806396, -0.027877808, 0.032287598, 0.040252686, -0.030670166, -0.06628418, -0.017654419, 0.045166016, 0.012367249, -0.0033226013, -0.043426514, 0.027404785, -0.09442139, 0.032989502, 0.0068130493, 0.013999939, 0.031921387, 0.032592773, 0.022415161, 0.006210327, 0.029022217, -0.043518066, -0.020065308, 0.017929077, 0.017730713, 0.016281128, 0.032806396, -0.004207611, -0.026000977, 0.00025248528, 0.0154800415, 0.006214142, 0.01889038, 0.00077056885, -0.0047950745, -0.008163452, -0.014419556, -0.04071045, -0.005443573, 0.011512756, -0.06341553, 0.005039215, -0.018447876, 0.0016174316, 0.062561035, -0.011688232, -0.0109939575, 0.006324768, -0.021453857, -0.044158936, -0.052581787, -0.0012254715, 0.021957397, 0.02432251, -0.0284729, 0.030654907, -0.0059776306, 0.018096924, -0.0178833, 0.007648468, -0.013504028, -0.028564453, 0.008834839, 0.0051574707, -0.016036987, 0.06762695, 0.029205322, 0.0050239563, -0.02923584, 0.028457642, 0.013946533, -0.07208252, 0.008453369, -0.022079468, -0.013877869, -0.032836914, -0.013580322, 0.010528564, -0.005191803, 0.02859497, 0.006336212, 0.013694763, 0.013999939, -0.011932373, 0.05645752, 0.007789612, 0.11419678, -0.022842407, 0.042663574, -0.03439331, -0.061767578, -0.0060043335, -0.0006046295, -0.034179688, -0.013931274, 0.05178833, -0.0017900467, -0.027023315, -0.0034217834, 0.033081055, 0.04837036, 0.031173706, 0.012756348, 0.011177063, 0.00060606, 0.0098724365, 0.062194824, -0.012207031, 0.04385376, 0.046936035, -0.01663208, 0.0524292, -0.019836426, -0.0032749176, -0.03540039, 0.027801514, -0.0110321045, 0.07696533, 0.050689697, 0.006855011, -0.02911377, 0.013114929, -0.016494751, 0.012191772, -0.02128601, 0.006008148, 0.031707764, -0.00002759695, -0.003364563, 0.018997192, -0.003604889, -0.032989502, -0.0023326874, -0.0024261475, -0.007545471, -0.020858765, 0.021316528, 0.033416748, 0.05130005, -0.008415222, 0.015335083, 0.039123535, 0.022964478, 0.005455017, -0.019439697, 0.01626587, 0.038238525, 0.018371582, 0.01335907, -0.024887085, 0.062469482, -0.0011367798, 0.02758789, 0.07537842, -0.021377563, 0.013435364, -0.10095215, -0.008384705, -0.008041382, -0.008087158, 0.0023231506, 0.031585693, 0.020965576, 0.012557983, -0.019424438, 0.007789612, -0.06060791, -0.030548096, 0.014076233, -0.004081726, -0.016937256, -0.01966858, -0.026443481, 0.007446289, -0.044677734, -0.012992859, -0.0052452087, 0.040252686, -0.017211914, -0.007797241, 0.02394104, -0.0031585693, -0.040893555, -0.0028934479, -0.010261536, 0.009979248, 0.046569824, -0.01335907, -0.061279297, -0.014137268, 0.011398315, 0.018493652, -0.015319824, 0.06878662, -0.023635864, -0.01675415, -0.025299072, -0.057037354, -0.007926941, -0.033599854, 0.0107040405, -0.03942871, -0.009170532, 0.0009198189, -0.014465332, 0.005882263, 0.01902771, 0.0027198792, -0.014457703, -0.020431519, 0.061187744, -0.06567383, -0.018371582, 0.041534424, 0.05682373, 0.00017368793, 0.04196167, 0.024642944, 0.017028809, -0.07318115, -0.009712219, -0.052581787, -0.02130127, -0.01651001, 0.015670776, 0.009185791, -0.050750732, -0.013633728, -0.02734375, 0.0023040771, 0.037231445, 0.040222168, -0.027191162, -0.020996094, 0.0019264221, -0.018463135, 0.006893158, -0.022521973, 0.035308838, -0.0060272217, 0.051574707, 0.0010442734, -0.030014038, -0.0006933212, 0.009162903, 0.017303467, -0.017181396, -0.019104004, -0.012260437, -0.008575439, 0.008605957, -0.0077781677, -0.014816284, 0.025558472, -0.08911133, 0.012077332, 0.029281616, 0.0049972534, -0.01651001, 0.02607727, -0.059906006, 0.018096924, -0.020553589, -0.012741089, 0.02243042, 0.028213501, -0.0070114136, 0.04208374, -0.0010623932, 0.023971558, -0.014144897, -0.021514893, -0.08251953, 0.020629883, -0.034851074, 0.01020813, 0.018539429, 0.006439209, -0.0496521, -0.015342712, -0.0064353943, 0.05178833, 0.03677368, 0.0025634766, -0.0009851456, -0.00932312, 0.027801514, -0.03363037, -0.023422241, -0.05822754, -0.012962341, 0.00699234, -0.034179688, 0.05203247, -0.03112793, 0.027389526, -0.026504517, -0.034240723, -0.0016860962, 0.035583496, 0.003326416, -0.022918701, -0.055877686, -0.01259613, -0.04449463, -0.012023926, 0.0023708344, 0.016662598, -0.032043457, 0.0206604, -0.014343262, 0.05050659, -0.00374794, 0.051879883, 0.032043457, -0.021530151, 0.00039815903, -0.040008545, -0.030288696, 0.03955078, -0.041656494, 0.0066184998, 0.040130615, -0.007686615, -0.021820068, -0.00023794174, -0.038482666, 0.043518066, -0.014190674, -0.020950317, -0.000875473, -0.03414917, 0.008872986, -0.007911682, 0.043304443, -0.00932312, 0.028320312, 0.01449585, -0.0027675629, -0.09527588, -0.04949951, 0.01838684, -0.16711426, -0.074645996, 0.0018930435, -0.08325195, -0.049194336, -0.05996704, 0.00076150894, -0.06915283, -0.041168213, -0.008613586, -0.011009216, 0.044128418, -0.027770996, -0.087890625, -0.029968262, 0.02986145, -0.020187378, 0.048339844, 0.0014591217, -0.008323669, 0.008056641, -0.0127334595, 0.01158905, -0.004840851, 0.038848877, -0.014579773, -0.033111572, 0.018157959, -0.029067993, 0.027572632, 0.01852417, -0.035888672, 0.014678955, 0.035583496, 0.0004169941, 0.024291992, -0.04824829, 0.03579712, 0.06173706, -0.018859863, -0.048553467, 0.043121338, -0.020706177, -0.05050659, -0.0018825531, 0.0184021, -0.013084412, 0.026748657, 0.040985107, 0.029418945, 0.0030879974, 0.019882202, 0.0012407303, -0.04046631, -0.024429321, -0.017745972, 0.02809143, -0.025650024, 0.0022830963, 0.011932373, -0.00094652176, 0.026504517, 0.019042969, -0.031402588, -0.0012340546, 0.025131226, -0.010971069, -0.018295288, -0.030670166, -0.027770996, -0.018417358, 0.0015411377, 0.015625, -0.00020754337, 0.02279663, 0.014549255, -0.01928711, -0.009742737, 0.03213501, 0.0032520294, -0.01725769, -0.055999756, -0.003894806, -0.02557373, -0.05267334, -0.047546387, -0.015609741, 0.009155273, -0.0062408447, -0.011192322, -0.06185913, -0.016418457, 0.018249512, 0.08154297, 0.02456665, 0.031463623, -0.047210693, -0.030532837, -0.04449463, -0.006137848, 0.022155762, 0.02217102, -0.015357971, -0.034088135, 0.012756348, -0.015060425, -0.033416748, -0.030838013, 0.033416748, 0.0074272156, 0.020141602, 0.020584106, 0.050628662, 0.01979065, 0.0058784485, 0.0129852295, 0.008728027, -0.028961182, -0.00242424, 0.00566864, 0.009521484, -0.006980896, -0.0037231445, 0.021133423, 0.018096924, 0.0026435852, 0.0013046265, 0.0011711121, 0.025222778, -0.0034542084, 0.0009012222, 0.009414673, -0.032073975, 0.001364708, 0.017150879, 0.010482788, 0.054534912, -0.070007324, 0.018249512, -0.041046143, 0.004219055, 0.024261475, 0.007472992, -0.0012187958, 0.027648926, 0.0042648315, 0.0017251968, -0.027252197, 0.019882202, -0.002588272, 0.0118637085, 0.002872467, -0.023666382, 0.0231781, 0.012779236, 0.022369385, 0.027267456, 0.012878418, 0.0019378662, -0.0036506653, 0.01776123, -0.022323608, -0.009742737, -0.019012451, -0.007335663, 0.006706238, -0.009376526, -0.003358841, -0.02394104, -0.012084961, -0.02319336, -0.014808655, 0.023223877, -0.06604004, 0.0023441315, 0.060058594, 0.0020198822, 0.039367676, -0.02772522, 0.025482178, 0.014930725, 0.015792847, -0.008888245, 0.0056037903, 0.00023365021, -0.011291504, 0.009033203, 0.0121154785, 0.02482605, 0.019821167, 0.008094788, 0.003967285, -0.004085541, -0.021133423, 0.010421753, 0.009994507, 0.03414917, 0.0037765503, -0.0491333, 0.010444641, 0.012214661, -0.0036945343, -0.024475098, -0.051513672, -0.04171753, 0.0513916, -0.05569458, 0.05014038, 0.018295288, -0.045562744, -0.0345459, -0.064819336, 0.0368042, -0.023910522, -0.015945435, -0.019195557, 0.036193848, -0.040222168, 0.006980896, 0.01927185, -0.022277832, 0.0063476562, -0.004398346, 0.00003093481, 0.032836914, 0.02999878, -0.052124023, -0.013328552, -0.007083893, -0.044128418, -0.02154541, 0.040802002, 0.019638062, -0.00459671, -0.028335571, -0.019989014, -0.02897644, -0.019744873, -0.0062065125, 0.004627228, -0.064453125, 0.010192871, -0.011512756, 0.021865845, 0.005771637, 0.0027256012, 0.036468506, -0.00043153763, -0.00894928, -0.05102539, 0.04284668, 0.007575989, 0.0067749023, -0.016174316, -0.005214691, -0.015609741, 0.024047852, -0.026779175, -0.0050354004, 0.000259161, 0.03274536, -0.0513916, 0.025360107, 0.022277832, 0.115600586, -0.07147217, -0.062561035, -0.052093506, -0.013969421, -0.047821045, 0.06298828, 0.009216309, -0.06573486, -0.018081665, -0.043548584, -0.018325806, -0.01171875, 0.024169922, 0.017913818, 0.054504395, -0.04953003, -0.058380127, -0.052490234, -0.009529114, -0.014526367, 0.026184082, -0.020095825, -0.011421204, 0.016845703, -0.011695862, -0.0028457642, -0.015945435, 0.027404785, 0.021072388, 0.01651001, 0.009880066, -0.006679535, -0.0054626465, -0.05883789, 0.055664062, 0.05493164, 0.07788086, -0.056549072, 0.030517578, -0.011245728, 0.04800415, 0.040527344, -0.0071983337, 0.045440674, 0.05203247, 0.009651184, -0.006511688, 0.01461792, 0.00030303, 0.03173828, -0.07684326, 0.05014038, -0.010032654, 0.016403198, -0.06921387, -0.00084352493, 0.0579834, 0.025436401, 0.019302368, 0.012565613, 0.001906395, -0.009605408, 0.04220581, 0.015914917, 0.076049805, 0.00034189224, -0.0033359528, 0.01159668, -0.012298584, -0.009864807, 0.0065231323, -0.0073890686, 0.048187256, 0.004447937, -0.021972656, 0.01247406, -0.011924744, 0.013648987, -0.017791748, 0.0033626556, -0.021835327, 0.03161621, -0.0044784546, -0.0042419434, 0.045318604, 0.039031982, -0.015174866, -0.0039253235, 0.006351471, 0.034088135, 0.008148193, -0.027938843, 0.050201416, -0.03604126, 0.01411438, 0.0063285828, -0.04067993, -0.019760132, 0.03189087, 0.022628784, -0.005832672, -0.0046920776, 0.043029785, 0.01499939, 0.022537231, 0.012939453, -0.034179688, -0.04232788, -0.024230957, -0.00048184395, -0.006259918, 0.009841919, 0.021240234, 0.02494812, 0.029846191, -0.012672424, -0.020553589, 0.035186768, -0.0385437, 0.03579712, 0.008796692, 0.04626465, -0.05355835, -0.04434204, 0.0028629303, 0.0021762848, -0.02178955, -0.050323486, 0.07946777, -0.018417358, -0.06201172, 0.034057617, 0.009918213, -0.010932922, -0.07476807, 0.018539429, -0.00091934204, 0.0703125, -0.011177063, 0.023040771, -0.033721924, -0.03488159, 0.027801514, -0.026229858, 0.047576904, -0.005859375, -0.01361084, -0.026168823, 0.01512146, -0.0011005402, -0.023864746, -0.0034599304, -0.03567505, 0.012611389, -0.012138367, 0.029006958, -0.006099701, -0.01737976, -0.007205963, 0.02192688, -0.005153656, 0.01776123, 0.025009155, -0.03503418, -0.020431519, 0.018081665, 0.0014324188, 0.05609131, -0.000992775, 0.0041389465, -0.002401352, 0.012031555, -0.0075187683, -0.012527466, -0.016174316, 0.039276123, -0.018203735, -0.024734497, 0.0039863586, 0.011360168, -0.031341553, -0.058532715, 0.082336426, -0.009841919, -0.01802063, 0.021911621, 0.018371582, 0.0023880005, -0.06976318, -0.0071372986, -0.018814087, -0.0050315857, -0.012184143, -0.014373779, -0.022781372, 0.03503418, -0.039489746, -0.023498535, 0.0016536713, 0.031677246, -0.030212402, -0.039276123, -0.005619049, 0.009605408, 0.033691406, -0.044158936, -0.11773682, -0.013175964, 0.050811768, -0.014633179, 0.06304932, 0.0012540817, 0.029708862, -0.00013494492, 0.02507019, -0.007865906, -0.027053833, -0.039642334, -0.023483276, 0.03543091, 0.03857422, -0.015777588, -0.0038223267, 0.021499634, -0.016784668, -0.009628296, 0.032287598, 0.013031006, 0.015602112, 0.016998291, 0.022521973, -0.033996582, -0.045135498, -0.0055122375, 0.03289795, -0.008293152, 0.03353882, -0.0018520355, 0.015197754, 0.026977539, 0.075927734, -0.022476196, -0.0056991577, 0.00749588, 0.028167725, -0.0015306473, 0.067871094, -0.012634277, -0.015029907, -0.0026931763, -0.007785797, -0.007007599, -0.0009498596, 0.03062439, -0.058135986, -0.008880615, -0.032226562, -0.03543091, -0.01398468, -0.024627686, 0.04776001, -0.012756348, -0.00045728683, -0.011634827, -0.0063285828, 0.035583496, 0.05935669, 0.053222656, 0.06652832, -0.06317139, -0.016693115, 0.028640747, -0.053222656 ], "summary": [ -0.031555176, -0.021499634, -0.02583313, -0.032226562, -0.030563354, 0.001832962, -0.07421875, 0.009002686, -0.0043258667, 0.016830444, 0.011665344, 0.009178162, -0.017349243, -0.045196533, -0.024612427, -0.0259552, 0.0029506683, 0.025985718, 0.030578613, -0.026885986, 0.009101868, -0.01889038, 0.030593872, 0.05419922, -0.019561768, -0.017837524, 0.01600647, 0.009544373, -0.025558472, -0.024353027, -0.011871338, 0.026321411, -0.009376526, 0.04763794, -0.018325806, -0.0029563904, 0.019042969, 0.013458252, 0.014923096, 0.017715454, 0.020996094, -0.00077438354, 0.1373291, -0.042388916, 0.043121338, 0.062469482, -0.020690918, -0.057006836, 0.043884277, 0.009391785, -0.0287323, -0.0068244934, -0.02810669, -0.03060913, -0.025115967, -0.03074646, -0.05038452, 0.044158936, 0.0063591003, 0.055541992, 0.019058228, 0.015571594, -0.022460938, -0.018753052, -0.016815186, -0.024032593, 0.011184692, 0.02041626, 0.008277893, -0.012641907, 0.0236969, 0.028793335, -0.00062417984, -0.017471313, -0.018585205, -0.0055503845, 0.04837036, 0.013671875, -0.024276733, 0.0045394897, -0.025268555, 0.004486084, -0.05831909, -0.007587433, -0.0002424717, 0.015182495, -0.013969421, -0.023529053, -0.040527344, -0.037017822, -0.022994995, -0.037261963, -0.061584473, 0.014343262, 0.020858765, -0.04638672, 0.00598526, 0.0112838745, -0.011680603, 0.000579834, 0.041290283, -0.04208374, 0.020568848, -0.017623901, -0.016296387, 0.09472656, 0.04916382, -0.014266968, -0.037261963, -0.020629883, 0.000032186508, -0.07873535, 0.014907837, -0.011749268, -0.01625061, 0.00086545944, 0.019958496, 0.010528564, 0.0023155212, 0.0022792816, 0.02041626, 0.030548096, -0.0178833, 0.011543274, -0.016204834, -0.018722534, -0.019317627, 0.0036525726, -0.06451416, 0.047027588, -0.016235352, -0.021255493, 0.02255249, 0.05770874, 0.0038318634, -0.029693604, 0.049438477, -0.0073394775, 0.021270752, -0.00894165, 0.052703857, 0.0077438354, 0.0053977966, 0.053375244, -0.011802673, -0.022476196, -0.00074005127, 0.05947876, -0.000032544136, -0.04812622, 0.032165527, 0.009521484, 0.04248047, -0.01864624, -0.09375, -0.0039787292, -0.097717285, 0.028381348, -0.015991211, -0.011161804, 0.052368164, 0.022018433, 0.013122559, -0.020935059, -0.023208618, -0.033691406, -0.08929443, -0.0019493103, 0.010810852, -0.023284912, 0.018539429, -0.009765625, 0.0052452087, -0.025756836, -0.0016183853, -0.0013694763, 0.0016756058, 0.039093018, 0.008857727, -0.061920166, -0.00374794, -0.03677368, 0.046691895, 0.0076522827, -0.03540039, 0.022323608, -0.014160156, 0.014038086, 0.048919678, -0.01084137, 0.021392822, -0.011940002, 0.015792847, -0.028457642, -0.006313324, -0.05154419, -0.0126953125, -0.02128601, -0.023239136, 0.034118652, 0.009353638, -0.004917145, 0.026229858, -0.025741577, -0.003692627, -0.015853882, 0.007472992, 0.013687134, -0.0519104, 0.04434204, 0.042236328, 0.01373291, -0.06210327, 0.05795288, 0.042663574, -0.01928711, -0.004169464, -0.016708374, -0.006324768, -0.026885986, -0.031463623, 0.04714966, -0.029663086, 0.012962341, -0.043670654, 0.017211914, -0.006084442, 0.0126571655, -0.009857178, 0.01398468, 0.079833984, -0.012672424, -0.0042877197, -0.026504517, -0.053131104, -0.011306763, -0.026168823, -0.045135498, -0.0020179749, 0.05596924, -0.003025055, -0.022567749, -0.025299072, 0.01499939, 0.023620605, 0.03024292, 0.018051147, -0.0004556179, -0.03857422, 0.006099701, 0.058898926, 0.021469116, 0.030914307, 0.050048828, -0.030426025, 0.041412354, -0.03540039, -0.05307007, 0.021514893, 0.005016327, 0.007408142, 0.055480957, 0.008575439, 0.028945923, 0.0069503784, -0.021530151, 0.007411957, 0.01348114, -0.03527832, -0.026550293, 0.027435303, 0.040252686, -0.00504303, 0.010131836, -0.022109985, -0.023345947, 0.00289917, 0.0041618347, 0.0057411194, -0.018325806, -0.0019760132, 0.0018548965, -0.017028809, -0.0026855469, 0.020751953, -0.031829834, 0.004852295, 0.055541992, 0.021713257, 0.04385376, 0.037384033, 0.030685425, 0.014709473, -0.00097322464, 0.04156494, 0.005142212, -0.025161743, 0.038635254, 0.004043579, 0.00037026405, -0.066833496, 0.026367188, 0.02168274, -0.018753052, 0.010925293, 0.03363037, 0.03161621, -0.005897522, 0.0030918121, -0.032165527, 0.040130615, 0.016952515, 0.016494751, 0.08087158, -0.049987793, -0.048553467, -0.0181427, 0.020828247, -0.051757812, -0.026947021, 0.07495117, 0.020751953, -0.015686035, 0.009025574, 0.018081665, -0.050109863, 0.010055542, -0.014923096, -0.06896973, 0.025299072, 0.05380249, 0.008148193, 0.017684937, 0.04525757, 0.011260986, 0.0116119385, -0.0149383545, 0.10308838, -0.015792847, -0.0072364807, -0.02456665, -0.029632568, -0.0021648407, -0.028381348, 0.02470398, -0.06567383, 0.0259552, -0.018478394, -0.0021362305, 0.039886475, -0.005531311, 0.0057678223, -0.04977417, 0.0030136108, 0.031311035, -0.006717682, 0.019470215, 0.04135132, 0.066711426, 0.002067566, 0.04550171, 0.054626465, 0.036743164, -0.08215332, -0.04953003, -0.05508423, 0.034606934, -0.049438477, 0.012138367, -0.0011463165, -0.044830322, 0.0038166046, -0.028640747, 0.0018968582, 0.016281128, 0.031921387, 0.04348755, 0.007572174, 0.0095825195, 0.024780273, 0.04473877, -0.009414673, 0.045654297, -0.04827881, 0.049346924, 0.012931824, -0.0048179626, 0.015419006, 0.009811401, -0.0069274902, -0.02394104, -0.0067749023, -0.028945923, -0.010505676, 0.012107849, -0.004917145, -0.0037822723, 0.010215759, -0.082336426, -0.013153076, 0.027267456, 0.019165039, -0.019485474, 0.042999268, -0.049468994, 0.028442383, -0.010437012, -0.021560669, 0.020339966, 0.037902832, 0.01727295, 0.028182983, -0.0018863678, 0.037322998, -0.002904892, -0.023147583, -0.042510986, -0.014053345, -0.016174316, 0.03579712, 0.014320374, 0.026428223, -0.022598267, 0.029830933, 0.007881165, 0.030593872, -0.008224487, -0.004634857, -0.024169922, -0.039031982, -0.0077934265, -0.035186768, -0.013252258, -0.031219482, -0.011329651, 0.030197144, -0.028076172, 0.017745972, -0.028839111, -0.0036945343, -0.016113281, -0.026367188, -0.01852417, 0.021072388, -0.035217285, 0.0067710876, -0.034973145, -0.00032687187, -0.01449585, -0.03186035, -0.012390137, 0.010803223, 0.02809143, 0.042755127, 0.009399414, 0.0446167, 0.0030536652, 0.02911377, 0.064941406, -0.024353027, -0.021377563, -0.016967773, -0.035095215, 0.017440796, 0.021499634, 0.0076942444, -0.03062439, 0.017593384, 0.00061655045, -0.020080566, 0.022003174, 0.008171082, -0.020019531, 0.0048332214, -0.06286621, -0.011856079, 0.06518555, 0.011367798, 0.05114746, -0.035858154, 0.010383606, 0.025131226, -0.025161743, -0.08404541, -0.05734253, 0.022506714, -0.14489746, -0.10699463, -0.007801056, -0.03842163, -0.022232056, -0.03942871, 0.0009241104, -0.008491516, -0.025985718, -0.0039367676, -0.015609741, 0.0637207, -0.041992188, -0.0836792, 0.035736084, -0.045684814, -0.0362854, 0.07659912, -0.054351807, 0.02319336, 0.043182373, 0.011810303, 0.0017547607, -0.04159546, 0.014968872, -0.020767212, 0.015548706, -0.009605408, -0.0023002625, -0.0031108856, 0.050201416, -0.020217896, 0.019515991, 0.019165039, 0.035614014, 0.053985596, 0.0036716461, 0.006126404, 0.012901306, -0.034454346, 0.010848999, 0.016647339, -0.015159607, -0.044708252, -0.004272461, 0.044921875, -0.00484848, 0.021102905, 0.031982422, -0.02027893, -0.013343811, -0.011024475, -0.00932312, -0.0057868958, -0.032318115, 0.021270752, 0.05984497, 0.0063591003, -0.022506714, 0.034362793, -0.013259888, 0.01625061, 0.02218628, -0.050109863, 0.008232117, 0.032196045, -0.019699097, -0.05847168, -0.008331299, 0.024765015, 0.03729248, -0.025680542, 0.0072898865, -0.015609741, -0.006881714, -0.012916565, -0.013679504, 0.012664795, 0.014350891, 0.021316528, -0.04650879, -0.059448242, 0.01737976, -0.0045928955, -0.03552246, -0.037750244, 0.043701172, 0.011451721, 0.009857178, -0.03463745, -0.048980713, -0.017990112, -0.005004883, 0.06149292, 0.04840088, 0.03945923, -0.06274414, -0.054382324, -0.0065994263, 0.033203125, -0.028015137, 0.012687683, -0.0026721954, 0.0098724365, 0.003250122, -0.00957489, -0.037231445, -0.05203247, 0.029678345, 0.048309326, 0.008674622, 0.023635864, 0.025558472, 0.021499634, 0.0031871796, 0.042388916, 0.04611206, -0.0132369995, -0.07470703, 0.012664795, -0.050628662, 0.043395996, -0.005844116, 0.024139404, 0.0014009476, -0.004295349, 0.02394104, -0.024154663, 0.012931824, 0.017303467, -0.04333496, 0.03729248, 0.03845215, 0.00088882446, 0.014221191, -0.013320923, 0.0034542084, -0.025634766, -0.012939453, 0.006011963, 0.02204895, 0.02015686, -0.021972656, -0.0032806396, 0.0042266846, -0.0079193115, -0.00034713745, 0.01687622, 0.05090332, -0.030166626, 0.008766174, 0.040161133, -0.043304443, -0.050598145, -0.0001835823, 0.013633728, -0.010894775, 0.026382446, 0.013664246, -0.0005221367, 0.0005836487, -0.013015747, -0.0021343231, -0.0006942749, 0.019683838, 0.010940552, 0.022277832, -0.04547119, -0.007160187, -0.025894165, -0.014480591, 0.017288208, 0.011398315, -0.031982422, -0.029434204, 0.038970947, -0.00005275011, -0.0021514893, -0.013183594, 0.013076782, 0.043670654, 0.022399902, -0.015457153, 0.006034851, -0.00097322464, -0.00046730042, 0.009231567, 0.010826111, 0.019622803, 0.018554688, -0.025756836, -0.0010318756, -0.020629883, 0.01927185, -0.012008667, -0.020431519, 0.024536133, 0.0004887581, -0.022705078, 0.0043182373, 0.0073394775, 0.013252258, -0.014671326, -0.009765625, -0.03253174, 0.015716553, -0.011787415, 0.01360321, 0.03302002, -0.017791748, -0.0039043427, -0.04324341, -0.018112183, -0.04260254, 0.009529114, -0.014831543, 0.01449585, -0.029144287, -0.012550354, 0.0072746277, -0.041015625, 0.02645874, -0.0211792, 0.010276794, 0.018035889, 0.011634827, -0.053955078, -0.0070152283, -0.026275635, -0.033477783, -0.04043579, 0.0050201416, 0.0033874512, 0.024597168, -0.018753052, -0.004463196, -0.0021343231, -0.016616821, 0.014808655, -0.013717651, -0.028030396, 0.017196655, -0.0026435852, -0.0017118454, 0.017486572, -0.0019464493, 0.0022468567, 0.00041222572, -0.0124053955, -0.0178833, 0.050201416, -0.021347046, 0.011444092, 0.0032405853, 0.046142578, -0.000053048134, 0.028381348, -0.021911621, -0.013893127, -0.047943115, -0.003189087, -0.07446289, 0.013511658, -0.008346558, 0.08319092, -0.049682617, -0.11773682, -0.05142212, 0.010246277, -0.01713562, 0.032562256, -0.013442993, -0.11645508, 0.028381348, -0.0027427673, 0.0064888, 0.006500244, -0.0025482178, 0.020889282, 0.07977295, 0.024642944, -0.0078125, 0.0068893433, -0.03012085, -0.010864258, 0.02053833, -0.012649536, -0.035125732, 0.04071045, -0.012321472, 0.008903503, -0.0008172989, -0.0074539185, -0.03137207, -0.012054443, 0.0045547485, 0.055236816, 0.020889282, -0.05581665, 0.046203613, 0.03741455, 0.07537842, -0.07879639, 0.0029850006, 0.027999878, 0.05480957, -0.0041122437, -0.029464722, -0.009490967, 0.019714355, -0.008392334, -0.023788452, -0.0014982224, -0.009376526, 0.02330017, -0.03387451, 0.018051147, 0.002286911, -0.0052375793, -0.005207062, 0.019470215, 0.032165527, -0.020095825, 0.04449463, 0.01626587, 0.022705078, -0.012794495, -0.0028800964, -0.05355835, 0.014564514, -0.016036987, -0.0005569458, 0.0209198, -0.021850586, -0.01423645, 0.023452759, -0.0004901886, 0.018707275, -0.008583069, 0.0135269165, 0.03540039, -0.04232788, -0.0070114136, -0.030426025, 0.019561768, -0.034240723, 0.05130005, 0.01171875, 0.042633057, 0.030761719, 0.00079107285, 0.0011720657, -0.01927185, 0.0021324158, 0.025543213, -0.006034851, 0.002008438, 0.01838684, 0.017349243, 0.006263733, 0.010131836, -0.016357422, 0.057250977, 0.0126571655, 0.033172607, -0.052764893, -0.044158936, 0.04751587, 0.012275696, -0.01184082, 0.010124207, -0.02798462, -0.059143066, -0.028274536, 0.0035820007, 0.004432678, 0.028656006, 0.0030975342, 0.03010559, 0.06976318, 0.017868042, -0.015396118, 0.018966675, 0.009025574, 0.0546875, 0.008934021, 0.025024414, -0.0012254715, -0.02796936, 0.03363037, -0.015449524, 0.0053138733, 0.006828308, 0.02078247, -0.002653122, -0.03503418, 0.038208008, -0.019424438, 0.00605011, -0.04171753, 0.034088135, 0.001953125, -0.009475708, 0.007461548, -0.008987427, -0.017700195, 0.0066108704, -0.015556335, -0.011726379, 0.01399231, -0.030044556, 0.011123657, -0.03579712, 0.040374756, -0.049621582, -0.019058228, 0.010597229, -0.056427002, 0.010879517, -0.008110046, 0.035583496, -0.02720642, -0.023590088, -0.02180481, 0.018432617, -0.015411377, -0.025115967, -0.00058603287, 0.0032634735, -0.01586914, -0.0713501, -0.027191162, -0.012130737, -0.0059890747, -0.010169983, 0.009979248, 0.04119873, -0.0014886856, -0.034729004, -0.02444458, 0.052093506, 0.042938232, -0.033477783, -0.022155762, -0.02003479, -0.0390625, -0.01134491, 0.07269287, 0.0031528473, 0.0017108917, 0.023773193, 0.03366089, 0.019226074, -0.048614502, 0.002128601, -0.021514893, -0.016067505, -0.04171753, 0.0003414154, 0.021972656, 0.02507019, -0.014930725, -0.052825928, -0.0026168823, -0.012229919, -0.0104599, -0.05392456, -0.017349243, 0.017044067, 0.019088745, -0.013999939, -0.034301758, 0.048950195, 0.043548584, 0.01537323, 0.0103302, -0.010810852, -0.0129470825, 0.0028743744, 0.0034942627, -0.0018663406, -0.010322571, -0.06390381, -0.003982544, 0.041656494, -0.011306763, -0.019638062, -0.023727417, 0.013427734, -0.04257202, -0.019622803, 0.004085541, 0.068725586, -0.004055023, 0.0036582947, 0.017532349, -0.062408447, -0.04827881, 0.03942871, -0.03656006, 0.009735107, 0.033416748, -0.048217773, -0.0031471252, -0.0028972626, -0.007232666, -0.008003235, 0.021942139, -0.0039482117, -0.010047913, 0.020401001, 0.0014629364, 0.020401001, -0.009094238, 0.035217285, -0.04473877, -0.018188477, -0.022903442, 0.05050659, -0.09466553, -0.07702637, 0.000279665, -0.05532837, -0.012069702, -0.040863037, 0.02041626, -0.008705139, 0.030349731, 0.039367676, 0.0055274963, 0.038879395, 0.02760315, 0.06317139, 0.033721924, -0.01335144, 0.0045280457, 0.007171631, -0.014770508 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2201.01249v1
ExAID: A Multimodal Explanation Framework for Computer-Aided Diagnosis of Skin Lesions
Adriano Lucieri, Muhammad Naseer Bajwa, Stephan Alexander Braun, Muhammad Imran Malik, Andreas Dengel, Sheraz Ahmed
cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.IV
One principal impediment in the successful deployment of AI-based Computer-Aided Diagnosis (CAD) systems in clinical workflows is their lack of transparent decision making. Although commonly used eXplainable AI methods provide some insight into opaque algorithms, such explanations are usually convoluted and not readily comprehensible except by highly trained experts. The explanation of decisions regarding the malignancy of skin lesions from dermoscopic images demands particular clarity, as the underlying medical problem definition is itself ambiguous. This work presents ExAID (Explainable AI for Dermatology), a novel framework for biomedical image analysis, providing multi-modal concept-based explanations consisting of easy-to-understand textual explanations supplemented by visual maps justifying the predictions. ExAID relies on Concept Activation Vectors to map human concepts to those learnt by arbitrary Deep Learning models in latent space, and Concept Localization Maps to highlight concepts in the input space. This identification of relevant concepts is then used to construct fine-grained textual explanations supplemented by concept-wise location information to provide comprehensive and coherent multi-modal explanations. All information is comprehensively presented in a diagnostic interface for use in clinical routines. An educational mode provides dataset-level explanation statistics and tools for data and model exploration to aid medical research and education. Through rigorous quantitative and qualitative evaluation of ExAID, we show the utility of multi-modal explanations for CAD-assisted scenarios even in case of wrong predictions. We believe that ExAID will provide dermatologists an effective screening tool that they both understand and trust. Moreover, it will be the basis for similar applications in other biomedical imaging fields.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2201.01249v1
"2022-01-04T17:11:28"
"2022-01-04T17:11:28"
{ "title": [ -0.021713257, -0.01448822, -0.045562744, -0.06781006, -0.0005993843, -0.00078964233, -0.03387451, 0.016952515, 0.008415222, 0.0069084167, -0.010375977, 0.0058403015, -0.0012493134, -0.042633057, -0.007030487, 0.0008664131, 0.013023376, 0.0005412102, -0.00566864, -0.024215698, -0.0019102097, -0.020614624, 0.06463623, 0.04550171, -0.02368164, -0.013450623, -0.026062012, 0.013755798, -0.0670166, -0.068237305, -0.01777649, 0.041168213, 0.027328491, 0.057373047, -0.057861328, -0.01448822, -0.054840088, 0.038970947, 0.0073928833, 0.0015182495, 0.003446579, -0.008323669, 0.031066895, -0.027496338, -0.02142334, 0.068725586, -0.091918945, -0.033813477, -0.0018444061, 0.03010559, 0.024780273, 0.017364502, 0.014976501, 0.028427124, -0.00046944618, -0.022979736, -0.013366699, -0.029663086, 0.047332764, 0.018630981, 0.019683838, -0.05670166, 0.01071167, -0.002029419, -0.03527832, -0.0076789856, 0.008003235, 0.016998291, 0.056762695, -0.01158905, -0.019897461, 0.030883789, -0.012016296, -0.010322571, -0.045562744, 0.05227661, 0.028060913, 0.011100769, 0.02357483, -0.025222778, 0.005695343, -0.0074424744, -0.009101868, -0.007411957, 0.007965088, -0.012458801, -0.0006914139, -0.01687622, -0.029388428, -0.05380249, -0.0017223358, -0.012702942, -0.044769287, 0.013381958, -0.011909485, -0.03665161, -0.008460999, 0.0015802383, 0.006919861, -0.03262329, 0.011634827, 0.0037517548, -0.027282715, -0.0056648254, -0.020492554, 0.035247803, 0.020599365, 0.01965332, -0.0034675598, 0.015449524, -0.037017822, 0.014007568, 0.039642334, -0.01020813, 0.0054092407, -0.012298584, 0.013870239, 0.040863037, 0.03161621, -0.0005726814, 0.0039711, -0.02810669, -0.005680084, 0.03338623, 0.0024166107, -0.014801025, -0.041534424, 0.028701782, -0.016235352, 0.022735596, 0.014732361, 0.050811768, -0.07122803, -0.06524658, -0.07141113, 0.049987793, -0.03274536, -0.0062026978, -0.015930176, 0.0038833618, 0.016204834, -0.0184021, 0.016586304, 0.00054979324, -0.000705719, -0.00038909912, 0.049346924, 0.02420044, -0.048583984, -0.05621338, 0.033813477, -0.00034546852, 0.015350342, 0.0053710938, -0.043792725, 0.005882263, -0.10107422, -0.0023498535, 0.0036411285, 0.011405945, 0.032836914, 0.013168335, 0.01210022, -0.011253357, 0.004055023, -0.0146102905, -0.043914795, 0.010696411, 0.016143799, 0.018371582, -0.0024814606, -0.009254456, -0.002483368, -0.013969421, -0.012237549, 0.008964539, 0.05102539, -0.010421753, 0.0012273788, -0.010871887, -0.009803772, -0.015335083, -0.0043754578, 0.01751709, -0.06628418, -0.016067505, -0.001115799, 0.013504028, 0.046539307, -0.0019931793, -0.04168701, 0.01600647, -0.02305603, 0.0062065125, -0.046691895, -0.037384033, -0.008369446, 0.027511597, -0.03302002, 0.012245178, -0.023590088, 0.02003479, -0.044708252, 0.026901245, -0.018203735, -0.030532837, -0.00056791306, 0.0038642883, -0.0048446655, 0.04537964, 0.037353516, 0.027648926, -0.046325684, -0.0011606216, -0.019363403, -0.052215576, 0.00868988, -0.007347107, -0.029006958, -0.05340576, -0.03591919, -0.010177612, -0.0019741058, 0.06719971, 0.020690918, 0.006958008, 0.020965576, -0.020141602, 0.027908325, 0.041137695, -0.0009703636, -0.04711914, 0.025680542, 0.0051078796, -0.00038433075, -0.0052490234, 0.02168274, -0.020507812, 0.0058174133, 0.0064048767, -0.007232666, -0.0073509216, -0.017807007, -0.0053215027, 0.09539795, 0.06738281, 0.030456543, -0.005657196, -0.003276825, -0.016555786, 0.036712646, 0.012252808, 0.051452637, 0.019180298, -0.018081665, 0.05178833, 0.020111084, 0.023849487, -0.0423584, 0.007041931, 0.01737976, 0.027740479, -0.01651001, 0.029708862, -0.07476807, 0.0046653748, -0.047027588, -0.029891968, 0.0026721954, 0.014854431, 0.028533936, -0.06585693, 0.012275696, -0.0082473755, 0.0121536255, 0.01525116, -0.026062012, 0.0013427734, 0.0206604, -0.027236938, 0.0006914139, 0.0059165955, 0.047332764, -0.0064964294, 0.03982544, 0.014175415, 0.023117065, -0.0060310364, -0.05307007, 0.0052452087, 0.04006958, 0.050872803, 0.023269653, -0.032470703, 0.004638672, 0.02619934, 0.055023193, 0.074523926, -0.025360107, 0.040100098, -0.08093262, 0.0055885315, 0.015304565, -0.024414062, -0.0013465881, 0.015296936, 0.0039596558, 0.019210815, -0.02619934, -0.0101623535, -0.022445679, 0.03164673, 0.006008148, 0.007083893, -0.062286377, -0.072143555, -0.029815674, -0.031097412, -0.075805664, -0.03048706, 0.031188965, -0.0209198, -0.014015198, 0.01776123, 0.0029907227, -0.0129852295, -0.00044679642, -0.009216309, -0.029205322, 0.0041160583, 0.027893066, 0.00093364716, -0.046173096, 0.012176514, 0.0073432922, 0.01890564, -0.011352539, -0.010864258, -0.01902771, 0.024536133, 0.017501831, -0.034729004, 0.028640747, -0.023620605, -0.0070533752, -0.023239136, 0.014518738, 0.016723633, -0.07043457, -0.026824951, 0.0569458, -0.03375244, -0.026000977, 0.004547119, 0.025878906, 0.0014753342, 0.025924683, 0.025497437, 0.018127441, -0.014633179, 0.031585693, 0.030181885, 0.029434204, 0.0033607483, -0.044067383, -0.06463623, -0.00856781, 0.01259613, -0.015197754, 0.03756714, -0.046295166, -0.020477295, -0.015205383, -0.0053634644, 0.021118164, 0.007091522, -0.036743164, -0.042907715, -0.00024795532, -0.020446777, -0.002872467, 0.0014457703, -0.003358841, 0.035949707, 0.07232666, 0.011764526, 0.023162842, 0.02545166, 0.031982422, 0.0035114288, -0.015434265, -0.018676758, 0.0030784607, -0.00024795532, 0.01449585, -0.012123108, -0.031829834, 0.022018433, -0.10107422, 0.01576233, -0.055633545, 0.036224365, -0.0231781, 0.010902405, -0.081604004, 0.0062408447, -0.07220459, -0.051116943, 0.028656006, 0.076660156, -0.02078247, 0.0362854, -0.015083313, 0.036590576, -0.017425537, -0.0006480217, -0.119628906, 0.012336731, -0.008010864, -0.017654419, -0.018615723, -0.0063323975, -0.0803833, -0.017944336, -0.015197754, 0.07434082, 0.015419006, 0.0074768066, 0.03225708, -0.028121948, 0.006881714, -0.013221741, -0.02319336, -0.047821045, -0.026504517, -0.009216309, -0.012306213, 0.04675293, 0.0019702911, 0.0036716461, 0.03640747, 0.008590698, -0.00944519, 0.0395813, -0.02357483, -0.022628784, 0.008659363, 0.054138184, -0.05722046, -0.042755127, -0.019989014, 0.025604248, -0.017745972, 0.0124053955, 0.019515991, 0.013435364, -0.009773254, 0.02709961, -0.05230713, -0.03466797, 0.007827759, -0.04751587, -0.031173706, -0.0041160583, 0.024642944, 0.017990112, 0.03012085, -0.023788452, -0.029785156, 0.028411865, -0.041168213, -0.0048446655, -0.0036678314, -0.008964539, 0.044708252, 0.011268616, -0.05883789, 0.027633667, -0.043273926, 0.03201294, -0.0010766983, 0.007385254, -0.019866943, -0.07928467, 0.000187397, -0.002506256, -0.093811035, -0.035064697, 0.040863037, -0.05291748, -0.020507812, -0.092285156, 0.036834717, -0.042907715, -0.030319214, 0.013206482, 0.0026397705, -0.012809753, 0.0015211105, -0.076049805, -0.023330688, 0.084350586, 0.0024929047, 0.03152466, 0.0418396, -0.012336731, -0.044647217, -0.04019165, 0.024612427, -0.006023407, 0.0047836304, 0.0015468597, -0.019485474, 0.014434814, -0.01838684, 0.021438599, 0.026885986, -0.009819031, 0.017303467, 0.007896423, -0.021057129, -0.016540527, 0.0206604, 0.052764893, -0.025161743, -0.0231781, -0.01360321, 0.023742676, -0.017715454, -0.032226562, 0.01727295, 0.0013113022, 0.010467529, 0.023483276, 0.01625061, 0.05770874, -0.0069847107, -0.020309448, 0.025909424, -0.005050659, 0.009033203, 0.029205322, 0.012374878, 0.034698486, 0.0077590942, 0.041656494, -0.007587433, 0.034423828, -0.011047363, -0.025024414, -0.0088272095, 0.016662598, -0.045684814, -0.022979736, -0.051971436, -0.006881714, -0.034210205, 0.011390686, -0.0014762878, 0.023406982, 0.014259338, 0.022506714, -0.010513306, -0.014907837, 0.018615723, 0.017532349, -0.017837524, -0.061553955, 0.0044403076, -0.009819031, -0.05178833, -0.038360596, -0.03894043, 0.02468872, 0.012321472, -0.005378723, -0.029800415, -0.013076782, 0.0259552, 0.06939697, 0.058563232, 0.020828247, -0.045837402, 0.028167725, -0.023513794, -0.025466919, 0.03677368, 0.011993408, -0.001502037, -0.0062294006, 0.022918701, -0.029830933, -0.028549194, -0.03543091, 0.021240234, 0.017044067, 0.017578125, 0.02029419, 0.03366089, 0.023040771, 0.0043296814, 0.01826477, 0.0019683838, -0.036193848, -0.008804321, -0.005153656, 0.053588867, -0.051727295, -0.017944336, 0.0056877136, 0.025527954, 0.018676758, 0.031280518, -0.02218628, 0.02281189, 0.035095215, -0.008522034, 0.007583618, -0.016418457, -0.020645142, 0.012321472, 0.015357971, 0.047302246, -0.035736084, 0.0206604, 0.0049209595, 0.011238098, -0.020370483, -0.033233643, 0.050354004, -0.0262146, 0.028579712, -0.008476257, -0.023925781, 0.021072388, 0.018341064, -0.023239136, -0.01260376, -0.01878357, 0.07519531, -0.0032482147, 0.028366089, 0.019622803, 0.042633057, -0.011238098, 0.0028457642, 0.007610321, -0.04763794, -0.016586304, 0.021438599, 0.0021324158, -0.0035476685, -0.04598999, -0.047454834, -0.050445557, -0.031082153, -0.019989014, -0.03717041, 0.04055786, -0.06323242, 0.02961731, 0.0859375, -0.044921875, 0.046569824, 0.013130188, 0.010887146, 0.047332764, 0.045166016, 0.012313843, 0.0024375916, 0.03024292, -0.022659302, 0.008758545, 0.0029640198, 0.009338379, 0.023803711, 0.001830101, 0.0067329407, -0.0012235641, -0.015686035, 0.02734375, 0.029586792, 0.033447266, -0.026626587, -0.032836914, 0.030960083, 0.0051727295, -0.023254395, 0.016983032, -0.066589355, -0.0035591125, 0.0121154785, -0.04699707, -0.022506714, 0.07501221, -0.010406494, -0.0770874, -0.08312988, -0.007850647, 0.028839111, -0.008712769, -0.04812622, 0.03778076, -0.072021484, 0.034484863, 0.007888794, -0.053833008, 0.011253357, 0.005104065, -0.0066986084, 0.03640747, 0.031341553, -0.024490356, 0.002292633, -0.04598999, -0.03353882, -0.024490356, -0.00024437904, 0.011749268, 0.03982544, -0.004463196, -0.057403564, -0.04135132, 0.012229919, 0.020095825, -0.021255493, -0.031051636, 0.034729004, 0.0071029663, 0.022903442, -0.0075035095, 0.022460938, -0.0028800964, 0.0026569366, 0.02482605, -0.050842285, 0.027328491, -0.018951416, 0.007843018, 0.0018730164, -0.05419922, 0.0032138824, 0.010246277, 0.003276825, 0.007549286, -0.006515503, 0.03579712, 0.009857178, 0.0031585693, 0.0042266846, 0.06567383, -0.042388916, -0.06210327, -0.0029735565, 0.0124053955, 0.010971069, 0.070739746, -0.016723633, -0.06060791, -0.018630981, -0.05807495, -0.033294678, 0.010826111, 0.025405884, 0.013160706, 0.009124756, -0.026901245, 0.016464233, -0.03656006, -0.010818481, -0.043273926, -0.0028438568, -0.00983429, -0.012283325, 0.03869629, 0.027862549, 0.012313843, -0.045928955, 0.00016212463, -0.007457733, 0.033111572, 0.0066566467, -0.020004272, 0.00035190582, -0.055541992, -0.02645874, 0.028701782, 0.054748535, -0.057739258, 0.05456543, 0.0078086853, 0.05718994, 0.01576233, 0.03363037, 0.034088135, 0.03012085, 0.014350891, -0.0010728836, -0.015464783, -0.036712646, 0.049682617, -0.04449463, 0.014671326, -0.04598999, -0.028930664, -0.07067871, 0.00844574, 0.030883789, 0.031402588, -0.005138397, -0.00082731247, 0.00044178963, 0.0036830902, 0.019729614, 0.015655518, 0.044006348, 0.012168884, -0.016540527, 0.018051147, 0.02319336, 0.010063171, 0.023712158, 0.028549194, -0.0040359497, -0.06549072, -0.008575439, 0.017730713, -0.001168251, -0.004760742, -0.0047950745, -0.0027160645, -0.0340271, 0.03479004, 0.00039958954, 0.0151901245, 0.06616211, 0.007160187, 0.07702637, -0.060638428, -0.008369446, -0.022781372, -0.016464233, -0.011482239, 0.024230957, -0.049682617, 0.035705566, -0.01966858, -0.022460938, -0.0034332275, 0.039276123, 0.031677246, -0.050567627, 0.020248413, 0.024291992, 0.013168335, -0.019485474, 0.012451172, -0.023864746, -0.0014266968, 0.008087158, 0.023422241, 0.008911133, 0.033935547, 0.03086853, -0.0059928894, 0.04159546, -0.035308838, 0.011909485, 0.029296875, -0.020202637, 0.02645874, 0.04812622, -0.007633209, -0.025024414, -0.033355713, -0.017242432, 0.016830444, -0.01537323, -0.03704834, 0.07623291, 0.036071777, -0.0020599365, 0.062194824, 0.001832962, -0.012138367, -0.017105103, -0.009635925, 0.0023975372, 0.03439331, -0.03414917, -0.0362854, -0.017242432, -0.0395813, 0.0016765594, -0.0046920776, 0.051086426, -0.04058838, 0.0027427673, -0.039520264, 0.02986145, 0.0034065247, -0.041778564, 0.015068054, -0.013748169, -0.023071289, -0.004386902, 0.0060272217, -0.030685425, -0.0011758804, -0.015151978, -0.0044021606, 0.012039185, 0.032196045, 0.023391724, -0.045166016, -0.020736694, 0.05114746, 0.011070251, 0.076538086, 0.0016479492, -0.018859863, -0.02619934, 0.0032615662, 0.028274536, 0.0040893555, -0.035614014, 0.024673462, -0.014595032, -0.03527832, 0.010284424, 0.016830444, -0.026565552, -0.05456543, 0.031951904, -0.0022850037, -0.022720337, -0.0014438629, -0.0063552856, -0.045318604, -0.012420654, -0.00025343895, -0.026168823, 0.005466461, 0.024246216, 0.005973816, 0.013824463, 0.033813477, -0.0012340546, -0.023513794, 0.0054016113, 0.002439499, 0.0056610107, -0.040527344, 0.010253906, 0.018814087, 0.042053223, -0.032226562, -0.107421875, 0.0132369995, 0.004623413, -0.03692627, 0.034698486, 0.0073928833, 0.010284424, 0.045318604, 0.04385376, 0.011886597, -0.050842285, -0.024917603, -0.021728516, 0.0119018555, 0.03866577, 0.0065956116, -0.020843506, 0.02671814, -0.013412476, 0.0033054352, 0.0023059845, 0.024475098, 0.015975952, 0.009246826, 0.048309326, -0.02293396, -0.025497437, -0.018447876, 0.038330078, -0.012832642, 0.03994751, -0.022979736, 0.009727478, 0.011657715, 0.023208618, -0.029312134, -0.06347656, 0.052642822, 0.048919678, -0.007183075, 0.026977539, -0.019424438, 0.002445221, -0.008422852, -0.012619019, -0.0055274963, -0.013153076, 0.06097412, -0.049194336, -0.010955811, -0.0541687, -0.03338623, 0.023361206, -0.021987915, 0.044067383, -0.057739258, 0.010185242, -0.061065674, -0.000103890896, -0.001578331, 0.026992798, 0.026748657, -0.031799316, -0.013175964, -0.023925781, 0.044647217, -0.020050049 ], "summary": [ 0.0141067505, -0.02381897, -0.0059928894, -0.05960083, -0.018218994, 0.0011367798, -0.041900635, 0.01322937, 0.031158447, -0.012878418, -0.029556274, 0.0020713806, 0.00077342987, -0.04711914, 0.030181885, -0.021011353, 0.01663208, -0.00073480606, 0.017364502, -0.022994995, -0.0013589859, -0.010536194, 0.052001953, 0.017868042, -0.043060303, 0.026901245, -0.015159607, -0.0014476776, -0.03125, -0.016204834, -0.022583008, 0.021987915, -0.021438599, 0.041992188, -0.0073013306, -0.024108887, -0.01361084, 0.04425049, 0.031463623, 0.013877869, -0.0058403015, 0.0063667297, 0.066711426, -0.03149414, -0.010147095, 0.07348633, -0.060028076, -0.04006958, 0.030014038, 0.06225586, 0.009918213, -0.025146484, -0.00818634, 0.031433105, -0.035247803, -0.043945312, -0.016189575, -0.052215576, 0.030395508, 0.06021118, 0.013008118, -0.040740967, -0.0103302, -0.04449463, -0.0076446533, -0.00017356873, 0.018493652, 0.020980835, 0.011833191, -0.028640747, 0.0075302124, 0.012619019, 0.0039482117, -0.06335449, -0.03756714, 0.080566406, 0.028869629, 0.031311035, -0.020111084, -0.044036865, -0.0022583008, -0.015625, -0.017211914, -0.002576828, -0.004463196, 0.0033798218, -0.00944519, -0.015487671, -0.0063285828, -0.008399963, -0.015655518, -0.010650635, -0.049438477, 0.066833496, 0.021026611, -0.022857666, -0.0181427, -0.038482666, 0.029815674, 0.013679504, 0.042541504, -0.057617188, 0.050872803, -0.017868042, -0.035949707, 0.029800415, 0.06530762, -0.007904053, -0.04345703, -0.010360718, -0.041656494, -0.02407837, 0.012359619, -0.04824829, 0.011199951, 0.019485474, 0.01184082, 0.053619385, 0.026809692, 0.019088745, -0.0018987656, -0.01171875, 0.009033203, 0.10455322, -0.0065231323, 0.027908325, -0.006996155, -0.01737976, 0.014793396, 0.015014648, 0.005508423, 0.012466431, -0.010414124, -0.022949219, -0.042266846, -0.005882263, -0.027633667, -0.01247406, -0.013511658, 0.006111145, 0.034820557, -0.040252686, -0.004924774, 0.048217773, -0.035614014, -0.01586914, 0.009963989, 0.04421997, -0.0074424744, -0.05432129, 0.048950195, -0.019866943, 0.027282715, 0.0051956177, -0.026306152, 0.014175415, -0.037017822, 0.011772156, -0.01701355, 0.026641846, 0.064941406, 0.010795593, -0.024597168, 0.0044555664, -0.0047912598, -0.043548584, -0.02420044, 0.0074424744, 0.012718201, -0.0129776, 0.018569946, -0.024414062, -0.058563232, -0.02027893, 0.004261017, 0.0020046234, 0.03152466, 0.015151978, -0.0068588257, -0.041290283, -0.027145386, -0.03475952, -0.004371643, 0.008590698, -0.014129639, -0.017410278, -0.018493652, 0.013557434, 0.060760498, 0.01663208, -0.0435791, -0.02961731, -0.008346558, -0.009216309, -0.0104599, -0.013397217, -0.031311035, 0.0031642914, -0.022537231, 0.007297516, 0.038024902, 0.0047798157, -0.01991272, 0.0036182404, -0.018310547, -0.005016327, 0.0021362305, -0.0076789856, -0.0043411255, 0.04623413, 0.029815674, 0.02168274, -0.06695557, 0.03994751, 0.0050735474, -0.039215088, 0.016067505, -0.024642944, -0.030914307, -0.07434082, -0.019866943, 0.017593384, -0.03781128, 0.07299805, 0.050689697, 0.05239868, -0.018798828, 0.016693115, 0.08355713, 0.056549072, 0.009262085, -0.05090332, 0.00080633163, -0.0132369995, -0.01184845, 0.014442444, 0.039245605, -0.057525635, 0.0049552917, 0.03353882, 0.010902405, 0.004146576, -0.049987793, -0.03692627, 0.10546875, 0.06689453, 0.0046195984, -0.012779236, -0.05368042, -0.031173706, 0.0141067505, 0.0075149536, 0.045043945, -0.01020813, -0.02784729, 0.053863525, 0.005092621, -0.001663208, -0.019699097, 0.005306244, -0.0053482056, 0.00005608797, -0.004837036, 0.0048332214, -0.05984497, -0.02532959, -0.0390625, -0.044525146, -0.008911133, -0.018096924, 0.035339355, -0.040985107, -0.0049552917, 0.0025539398, -0.012664795, -0.0026779175, -0.022613525, 0.00248909, -0.00020587444, -0.009849548, 0.013076782, 0.0124435425, 0.030761719, -0.0057640076, 0.026611328, 0.021316528, 0.038604736, 0.024414062, -0.06210327, 0.037017822, 0.043670654, 0.06616211, 0.027542114, -0.03543091, 0.01222229, 0.04031372, -0.026870728, 0.03564453, 0.011695862, -0.019454956, -0.055419922, 0.017227173, -0.03845215, 0.011932373, 0.005634308, 0.033813477, 0.010734558, -0.0005493164, -0.0032615662, -0.0023765564, -0.018936157, 0.008666992, -0.014160156, 0.05380249, -0.07867432, -0.0715332, -0.035339355, -0.006061554, -0.061706543, 0.0067749023, 0.066589355, -0.010910034, 0.009651184, 0.020477295, 0.004573822, -0.044311523, 0.056488037, -0.01071167, -0.0028820038, -0.015625, -0.029907227, -0.048461914, -0.029571533, 0.014274597, 0.0064849854, -0.011108398, 0.0025901794, -0.019485474, -0.006008148, 0.017837524, 0.046905518, -0.013046265, 0.030334473, 0.008003235, -0.044433594, -0.015357971, 0.034210205, -0.003320694, -0.02279663, -0.02104187, 0.048583984, -0.027389526, -0.06329346, 0.024215698, -0.029342651, -0.00843811, 0.082214355, 0.037017822, -0.009979248, -0.026519775, 0.038024902, 0.03225708, 0.03074646, -0.026443481, -0.04345703, -0.042877197, 0.006149292, 0.008895874, -0.013153076, 0.0104599, -0.02798462, 0.006462097, -0.00061273575, -0.010269165, -0.0045280457, 0.011413574, 0.050567627, -0.011878967, 0.0046424866, 0.05038452, 0.002664566, 0.023086548, 0.015098572, 0.02859497, 0.013679504, -0.0018062592, -0.010498047, 0.031707764, 0.024841309, 0.005393982, -0.002790451, 0.0093688965, 0.019424438, -0.021530151, 0.029342651, 0.012283325, -0.04284668, 0.047790527, -0.053955078, -0.01374054, -0.06567383, 0.057006836, 0.018829346, 0.0026988983, -0.047790527, 0.0071983337, -0.04727173, -0.031951904, 0.031982422, 0.081726074, -0.0064849854, 0.019729614, -0.016098022, 0.04333496, -0.025405884, 0.028778076, -0.055541992, 0.0058517456, 0.007797241, 0.0032463074, -0.04232788, 0.064453125, -0.06463623, -0.010147095, -0.016738892, 0.07287598, -0.028671265, 0.017700195, 0.025100708, -0.040740967, -0.0033187866, -0.025863647, -0.029159546, -0.04800415, -0.015510559, -0.008979797, -0.019515991, -0.015655518, -0.0046463013, -0.015350342, 0.018829346, -0.0042037964, -0.013961792, 0.017700195, -0.030288696, 0.0053138733, 0.017715454, 0.02482605, -0.03451538, -0.039093018, -0.017074585, 0.011734009, 0.004425049, 0.027786255, -0.0022220612, 0.038238525, 0.025512695, 0.02571106, 0.000016868114, -0.026535034, -0.012588501, -0.017074585, -0.026184082, -0.008331299, 0.012016296, 0.041015625, 0.026397705, -0.012969971, -0.043426514, 0.01574707, -0.020401001, -0.049713135, -0.016281128, -0.014030457, 0.023986816, -0.00422287, -0.02607727, 0.01235199, -0.011268616, 0.012214661, -0.007633209, 0.017578125, -0.0036258698, -0.075683594, -0.03463745, 0.012840271, -0.076171875, -0.064086914, 0.022354126, -0.03842163, -0.0039634705, -0.08300781, 0.033691406, -0.018096924, -0.01701355, 0.0038928986, -0.01159668, 0.0357666, 0.0069236755, -0.055145264, 0.005809784, -0.00793457, 0.03656006, 0.018859863, -0.027709961, 0.007106781, 0.0007209778, -0.002626419, -0.007774353, -0.030776978, 0.009559631, -0.018707275, 0.038024902, -0.003835678, -0.014221191, -0.013381958, 0.043670654, -0.050354004, 0.022460938, 0.021148682, -0.008552551, 0.022964478, 0.015625, 0.018218994, 0.00038838387, -0.03225708, 0.034362793, 0.02558899, -0.035339355, -0.03918457, 0.039855957, 0.06085205, 0.0005607605, 0.008460999, -0.00079107285, -0.00806427, -0.01399231, -0.028564453, -0.0025119781, 0.01725769, -0.002532959, 0.011154175, 0.026748657, 0.0423584, -0.005508423, 0.03744507, -0.01374054, 0.017044067, -0.013542175, -0.0054397583, -0.016845703, -0.009346008, -0.018920898, -0.011505127, 0.004501343, 0.01612854, -0.0151901245, -0.010124207, -0.003982544, 0.026275635, 0.015823364, 0.02406311, -0.0023155212, -0.036224365, 0.0002770424, 0.027618408, -0.04260254, -0.06793213, -0.010650635, -0.02116394, -0.0074272156, -0.026275635, -0.013931274, 0.022567749, -0.037628174, -0.0065460205, -0.019348145, 0.011421204, -0.0056610107, 0.033416748, 0.060760498, 0.029159546, -0.040802002, 0.02746582, -0.037963867, 0.0017404556, 0.022842407, -0.016342163, -0.0155181885, 0.0011787415, 0.04046631, -0.014404297, -0.048950195, -0.095458984, 0.030212402, 0.054473877, -0.015235901, 0.07183838, 0.012687683, 0.038238525, 0.0061531067, 0.030654907, 0.008056641, -0.010543823, -0.045806885, 0.02796936, 0.03918457, -0.034179688, -0.040649414, -0.019500732, 0.02229309, 0.01083374, 0.056793213, -0.038909912, 0.02494812, 0.025909424, -0.02368164, 0.01626587, 0.04324341, 0.021438599, 0.03314209, 0.008880615, 0.023513794, -0.00039100647, -0.03060913, 0.03265381, -0.018051147, -0.018173218, -0.03466797, 0.031463623, -0.005756378, 0.009376526, -0.0023536682, -0.07043457, 0.010856628, 0.04660034, 0.011253357, -0.01826477, -0.0071144104, 0.038513184, -0.019546509, 0.0020618439, 0.0013418198, 0.034362793, 0.019851685, -0.0061187744, 0.010856628, -0.0057640076, -0.000538826, 0.009544373, 0.015731812, 0.0055389404, -0.0032520294, -0.07745361, 0.014373779, -0.044281006, 0.0015077591, -0.038085938, 0.051116943, -0.040771484, -0.024414062, 0.061553955, -0.07537842, 0.033233643, 0.045074463, 0.013214111, 0.012672424, 0.03152466, -0.0028095245, -0.0018463135, 0.0009965897, -0.0044021606, -0.020523071, 0.0007891655, 0.009223938, 0.06616211, -0.014663696, 0.024398804, -0.02784729, 0.024368286, -0.010246277, -0.026565552, 0.04473877, -0.039916992, -0.000103116035, 0.03704834, 0.035186768, -0.012817383, 0.0015506744, -0.05316162, 0.0066337585, 0.015151978, -0.03390503, -0.0146865845, 0.076660156, 0.006996155, -0.04650879, -0.06738281, -0.01020813, 0.026046753, -0.016082764, -0.039489746, 0.042785645, -0.033233643, 0.019378662, -0.025161743, -0.068359375, -0.01071167, 0.026565552, 0.018737793, -0.014419556, 0.025848389, -0.028869629, -0.0033855438, -0.05392456, -0.024353027, -0.045043945, -0.027877808, -0.010253906, 0.083618164, -0.0082473755, -0.0076789856, -0.03729248, 0.019058228, 0.029083252, -0.06677246, -0.06890869, 0.010025024, 0.027008057, 0.045166016, -0.012489319, 0.040222168, -0.052825928, -0.0043563843, 0.076171875, -0.07537842, 0.036956787, -0.01071167, -0.006477356, 0.00818634, -0.02381897, 0.013328552, 0.007583618, -0.023971558, 0.032348633, -0.03189087, 0.007686615, 0.03387451, -0.015510559, -0.0027484894, 0.048736572, -0.04510498, -0.074645996, -0.0021514893, 0.028045654, 0.010261536, 0.038757324, -0.025527954, -0.07550049, 0.016235352, -0.019714355, 0.011734009, -0.0026817322, -0.0015573502, 0.020614624, 0.03100586, 0.030838013, 0.023422241, -0.016555786, 0.0034275055, -0.018035889, -0.013595581, -0.030288696, -0.02810669, 0.054473877, 0.037841797, -0.0070610046, -0.0209198, -0.007663727, 0.005771637, 0.043548584, 0.015960693, 0.006801605, -0.011375427, -0.063964844, 0.022628784, 0.028823853, 0.08728027, -0.074401855, 0.024520874, 0.049682617, 0.06124878, 0.0034046173, -0.006023407, 0.007911682, 0.004108429, -0.0034389496, -0.019012451, -0.0032596588, -0.025268555, 0.05355835, 0.014717102, -0.014656067, -0.009117126, -0.04510498, -0.018753052, 0.017288208, 0.042144775, -0.014503479, 0.014411926, -0.0104522705, -0.016555786, 0.008415222, -0.0309906, 0.01953125, -0.003791809, 0.023452759, -0.015174866, 0.03704834, 0.019561768, -0.042816162, 0.013839722, 0.024154663, 0.012931824, -0.037078857, -0.00856781, 0.032684326, -0.013908386, -0.02017212, -0.013832092, 0.011367798, -0.026428223, 0.059143066, 0.008163452, 0.0440979, 0.02810669, -0.010093689, 0.06921387, -0.057525635, -0.017608643, 0.029129028, 0.012397766, -0.03201294, -0.004714966, 0.014122009, -0.039367676, 0.013282776, -0.0010957718, 0.017288208, 0.016952515, 0.030838013, -0.031097412, 0.0067253113, 0.010635376, 0.008552551, -0.018356323, -0.004558563, -0.016693115, 0.00982666, 0.008346558, -0.03338623, 0.040985107, 0.047668457, 0.03857422, -0.039031982, 0.062316895, -0.013114929, -0.0010118484, 0.049713135, -0.0019950867, 0.02406311, 0.04208374, -0.042175293, -0.006504059, -0.02116394, -0.015686035, 0.013923645, 0.028305054, -0.020706177, 0.064453125, 0.026870728, -0.010467529, 0.062683105, -0.034362793, 0.017196655, -0.013389587, 0.034240723, 0.03970337, -0.022354126, -0.011497498, -0.06732178, 0.013847351, 0.013397217, -0.020431519, 0.024215698, 0.016952515, -0.008758545, -0.0013093948, -0.019744873, 0.015625, -0.04748535, -0.0011205673, 0.041137695, -0.018737793, 0.020111084, 0.008338928, 0.032409668, -0.033477783, -0.011955261, -0.008094788, 0.027450562, 0.011802673, 0.026290894, 0.021438599, -0.034240723, 0.049743652, 0.015266418, 0.026779175, 0.064819336, 0.013282776, -0.042663574, -0.021942139, 0.016113281, 0.042297363, 0.019989014, -0.026794434, 0.08404541, 0.012825012, -0.033447266, 0.020126343, 0.021652222, -0.03286743, -0.082092285, 0.04345703, -0.011405945, -0.027618408, 0.0047798157, 0.002298355, -0.0034217834, 0.010292053, 0.007671356, -0.019943237, 0.00060510635, 0.011451721, 0.017471313, -0.000012397766, 0.053955078, 0.0015134811, -0.041107178, -0.008705139, -0.016738892, 0.007835388, -0.04849243, 0.003665924, 0.0033950806, 0.04095459, 0.011878967, -0.07232666, 0.030838013, -0.004917145, -0.011230469, 0.035369873, -0.028320312, 0.016586304, 0.06762695, 0.0552063, 0.028427124, -0.046661377, -0.007698059, -0.0040016174, 0.009757996, -0.0014476776, -0.011779785, 0.011459351, 0.020050049, -0.061309814, -0.017700195, -0.010536194, 0.056610107, -0.020233154, 0.012031555, 0.025527954, -0.04272461, -0.056274414, 0.029708862, 0.0132751465, -0.019592285, -0.000641346, -0.02494812, -0.00036740303, -0.014709473, -0.02760315, -0.043640137, -0.06982422, 0.018478394, 0.02748108, -0.02909851, -0.007736206, -0.003967285, -0.007183075, -0.0063056946, -0.012199402, -0.015625, -0.01727295, 0.052947998, -0.029205322, -0.023254395, -0.0022220612, -0.03189087, 0.019622803, -0.0048103333, 0.017105103, -0.04272461, 0.022277832, -0.0044403076, -0.0029525757, 0.024963379, 0.027526855, 0.02053833, 0.016342163, 0.02330017, -0.04333496, -0.011764526, -0.012374878 ] }