article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
additive models @xcite provide an important family of models for semiparametric regression or classification . some reasons for the success of additive models are their increased flexibility when compared to linear or generalized linear models and their increased interpretability when compared to fully nonparametric models .
it is well - known that good estimators in additive models are in general less prone to the curse of high dimensionality than good estimators in fully nonparametric models .
many examples of such estimators belong to the large class of regularized kernel based methods over a reproducing kernel hilbert space @xmath0 , see e.g. @xcite . in the last years
many interesting results on learning rates of regularized kernel based models for additive models have been published when the focus is on sparsity and when the classical least squares loss function is used , see e.g. @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and the references therein . of course , the least squares loss function is differentiable and has many nice mathematical properties , but it is only locally lipschitz continuous and therefore regularized kernel based methods based on this loss function typically suffer on bad statistical robustness properties , even if the kernel is bounded .
this is in sharp contrast to kernel methods based on a lipschitz continuous loss function and on a bounded loss function , where results on upper bounds for the maxbias bias and on a bounded influence function are known , see e.g. @xcite for the general case and @xcite for additive models .
therefore , we will here consider the case of regularized kernel based methods based on a general convex and lipschitz continuous loss function , on a general kernel , and on the classical regularizing term @xmath1 for some @xmath2 which is a smoothness penalty but not a sparsity penalty , see e.g. @xcite .
such regularized kernel based methods are now often called support vector machines ( svms ) , although the notation was historically used for such methods based on the special hinge loss function and for special kernels only , we refer to @xcite . in this paper we address the open question , whether an svm with an additive kernel can provide a substantially better learning rate in high dimensions than an svm with a general kernel , say a classical gaussian rbf kernel , if the assumption of an additive model is satisfied .
our leading example covers learning rates for quantile regression based on the lipschitz continuous but non - differentiable pinball loss function , which is also called check function in the literature , see e.g. @xcite and @xcite for parametric quantile regression and @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite for kernel based quantile regression .
we will not address the question how to check whether the assumption of an additive model is satisfied because this would be a topic of a paper of its own .
of course , a practical approach might be to fit both models and compare their risks evaluated for test data .
for the same reason we will also not cover sparsity .
consistency of support vector machines generated by additive kernels for additive models was considered in @xcite . in this paper
we establish learning rates for these algorithms .
let us recall the framework with a complete separable metric space @xmath3 as the input space and a closed subset @xmath4 of @xmath5 as the output space .
a borel probability measure @xmath6 on @xmath7 is used to model the learning problem and an independent and identically distributed sample @xmath8 is drawn according to @xmath6 for learning .
a loss function @xmath9 is used to measure the quality of a prediction function @xmath10 by the local error @xmath11 .
_ throughout the paper we assume that @xmath12 is measurable , @xmath13 , convex with respect to the third variable , and uniformly lipschitz continuous satisfying @xmath14 with a finite constant @xmath15 .
_ support vector machines ( svms ) considered here are kernel - based regularization schemes in a reproducing kernel hilbert space ( rkhs ) @xmath0 generated by a mercer kernel @xmath16 . with a shifted loss function @xmath17 introduced for dealing
even with heavy - tailed distributions as @xmath18 , they take the form @xmath19 where for a general borel measure @xmath20 on @xmath21 , the function @xmath22 is defined by @xmath23 where @xmath24 is a regularization parameter .
the idea to shift a loss function has a long history , see e.g. @xcite in the context of m - estimators .
it was shown in @xcite that @xmath22 is also a minimizer of the following optimization problem involving the original loss function @xmath12 if a minimizer exists : @xmath25 the additive model we consider consists of the _ input space decomposition _
@xmath26 with each @xmath27 a complete separable metric space and a _ hypothesis space _
@xmath28 where @xmath29 is a set of functions @xmath30 each of which is also identified as a map @xmath31 from @xmath3 to @xmath5 .
hence the functions from @xmath32 take the additive form @xmath33 .
we mention , that there is strictly speaking a notational problem here , because in the previous formula each quantity @xmath34 is an element of the set @xmath35 which is a subset of the full input space @xmath36 , @xmath37 , whereas in the definition of sample @xmath8 each quantity @xmath38 is an element of the full input space @xmath36 , where @xmath39 .
because these notations will only be used in different places and because we do not expect any misunderstandings , we think this notation is easier and more intuitive than specifying these quantities with different symbols .
the additive kernel @xmath40 is defined in terms of mercer kernels @xmath41 on @xmath27 as @xmath42 it generates an rkhs @xmath0 which can be written in terms of the rkhs @xmath43 generated by @xmath41 on @xmath27 corresponding to the form ( [ additive ] ) as @xmath44 with norm given by @xmath45 the norm of @xmath46 satisfies @xmath47 to illustrate advantages of additive models , we provide two examples of comparing additive with product kernels .
the first example deals with gaussian rbf kernels .
all proofs will be given in section [ proofsection ] .
[ gaussadd ] let @xmath48 , @xmath49 $ ] and @xmath50 ^ 2.$ ] let @xmath51 and @xmath52.\ ] ] the additive kernel @xmath53 is given by @xmath54 furthermore , the product kernel @xmath55 is the standard gaussian kernel given by @xmath56 define a gaussian function @xmath57 on @xmath58 ^ 2 $ ] depending only on one variable by @xmath59 then @xmath60 but @xmath61 where @xmath62 denotes the rkhs generated by the standard gaussian rbf kernel @xmath63 .
the second example is about sobolev kernels .
[ sobolvadd ] let @xmath64 , @xmath65 $ ] and @xmath58^s.$ ] let @xmath66 : = \bigl\{u\in l_2([0,1 ] ) ; d^\alpha u \in l_2([0,1 ] ) \mbox{~for~all~}|\alpha|\le 1\bigr\}\ ] ] be the sobolev space consisting of all square integrable univariate functions whose derivative is also square integrable .
it is an rkhs with a mercer kernel @xmath67 defined on @xmath68 ^ 2 $ ] .
if we take all the mercer kernels @xmath69 to be @xmath67 , then @xmath70 $ ] for each @xmath71 .
the additive kernel @xmath72 is also a mercer kernel and defines an rkhs @xmath73\right\}.\ ] ] however , the multivariate sobolev space @xmath74^s)$ ] , consisting of all square integrable functions whose partial derivatives are all square integrable , contains discontinuous functions and is not an rkhs .
denote the marginal distribution of @xmath6 on @xmath27 as @xmath75 . under the assumption that @xmath76 for each @xmath71 and that @xmath43 is dense in @xmath29 in the @xmath77-metric , it was proved in @xcite that @xmath78 in probability as long as @xmath79 satisfies @xmath80 and @xmath81 .
the rest of the paper has the following structure .
section [ ratessection ] contains our main results on learning rates for svms based on additive kernels . learning rates for quantile regression
are treated as important special cases .
section [ comparisonsection ] contains a comparison of our results with other learning rates published recently .
section [ proofsection ] contains all the proofs and some results which can be interesting in their own .
in this paper we provide some learning rates for the support vector machines generated by additive kernels for additive models which helps improve the quantitative understanding presented in @xcite .
the rates are about asymptotic behaviors of the excess risk @xmath82 and take the form @xmath83 with @xmath84 .
they will be stated under three kinds of conditions involving the hypothesis space @xmath0 , the measure @xmath6 , the loss @xmath12 , and the choice of the regularization parameter @xmath85 .
the first condition is about the approximation ability of the hypothesis space @xmath0 .
since the output function @xmath19 is from the hypothesis space , the learning rates of the learning algorithm depend on the approximation ability of the hypothesis space @xmath0 with respect to the optimal risk @xmath86 measured by the following approximation error .
[ defapprox ] the approximation error of the triple @xmath87 is defined as @xmath88 to estimate the approximation error , we make an assumption about the minimizer of the risk @xmath89 for each @xmath90 , define the integral operator @xmath91 associated with the kernel @xmath41 by @xmath92 we mention that @xmath93 is a compact and positive operator on @xmath94 . hence we can find its normalized eigenpairs @xmath95 such that @xmath96 is an orthonormal basis of @xmath94 and @xmath97 as @xmath98 . fix @xmath99 .
then we can define the @xmath100-th power @xmath101 of @xmath93 by @xmath102 this is a positive and bounded operator and its range is well - defined .
the assumption @xmath103 means @xmath104 lies in this range .
[ assumption1 ] we assume @xmath105 and @xmath106 where for some @xmath107 and each @xmath108 , @xmath109 is a function of the form @xmath110 with some @xmath111 .
the case @xmath112 of assumption [ assumption1 ] means each @xmath113 lies in the rkhs @xmath43 .
a standard condition in the literature ( e.g. , @xcite ) for achieving decays of the form @xmath114 for the approximation error ( [ approxerrordef ] ) is @xmath115 with some @xmath116 . here
the operator @xmath117 is defined by @xmath118 in general , this can not be written in an additive form .
however , the hypothesis space ( [ additive ] ) takes an additive form @xmath119 .
so it is natural for us to impose an additive expression @xmath120 for the target function @xmath121 with the component functions @xmath113 satisfying the power condition @xmath110 .
the above natural assumption leads to a technical difficulty in estimating the approximation error : the function @xmath113 has no direct connection to the marginal distribution @xmath122 projected onto @xmath27 , hence existing methods in the literature ( e.g. , @xcite ) can not be applied directly .
note that on the product space @xmath123 , there is no natural probability measure projected from @xmath6 , and the risk on @xmath124 is not defined . our idea to overcome the difficulty is to introduce an intermediate function @xmath125 .
it may not minimize a risk ( which is not even defined ) .
however , it approximates the component function @xmath113 well .
when we add up such functions @xmath126 , we get a good approximation of the target function @xmath121 , and thereby a good estimate of the approximation error .
this is the first novelty of the paper .
[ approxerrorthm ] under assumption [ assumption1 ] , we have @xmath127 where @xmath128 is the constant given by @xmath129 the second condition for our learning rates is about the capacity of the hypothesis space measured by @xmath130-empirical covering numbers . let @xmath131 be a set of functions on @xmath21 and @xmath132 for every @xmath133 the * covering number of @xmath131 * with respect to the empirical metric @xmath134 , given by @xmath135 is defined as @xmath136 and the * @xmath130-empirical covering number * of @xmath137 is defined as @xmath138 [ assumption2 ] we assume @xmath139 and that for some @xmath140 , @xmath141 and every @xmath142 , the @xmath130-empirical covering number of the unit ball of @xmath43 satisfies @xmath143 the second novelty of this paper is to observe that the additive nature of the hypothesis space yields the following nice bound with a dimension - independent power exponent for the covering numbers of the balls of the hypothesis space @xmath0 , to be proved in section [ samplesection ] .
[ capacitythm ] under assumption [ assumption2 ] , for any @xmath144 and @xmath145 , we have @xmath146 the bound for the covering numbers stated in theorem [ capacitythm ] is special : the power @xmath147 is independent of the number @xmath148 of the components in the additive model .
it is well - known @xcite in the literature of function spaces that the covering numbers of balls of the sobolev space @xmath149 on the cube @xmath150^s$ ] of the euclidean space @xmath151 with regularity index @xmath152 has the following asymptotic behavior with @xmath153 : @xmath154 here the power @xmath155 depends linearly on the dimension @xmath148 .
similar dimension - dependent bounds for the covering numbers of the rkhss associated with gaussian rbf - kernels can be found in @xcite .
the special bound in theorem [ capacitythm ] demonstrates an advantage of the additive model in terms of capacity of the additive hypothesis space .
the third condition for our learning rates is about the noise level in the measure @xmath6 with respect to the hypothesis space . before stating the general condition
, we consider a special case for quantile regression , to illustrate our general results .
let @xmath156 be a quantile parameter .
the quantile regression function @xmath157 is defined by its value @xmath158 to be a @xmath159-quantile of @xmath160 , i.e. , a value @xmath161 satisfying @xmath162 the regularization scheme for quantile regression considered here takes the form ( [ algor ] ) with the loss function @xmath12 given by the pinball loss as @xmath163 a noise condition on @xmath6 for quantile regression is defined in @xcite as follows . to this end , let @xmath164 be a probability measure on @xmath165 and @xmath166 . then a real number @xmath167 is called @xmath159-quantile of @xmath164 , if and only if @xmath167 belongs to the set @xmath168\bigr ) \ge
\tau \mbox{~~and~~ } q\bigl([t , \infty)\bigr ) \ge 1-\tau\bigr\}\,.\ ] ] it is well - known that @xmath169 is a compact interval .
[ noisecond ] let @xmath166 . 1 .
a probability measure @xmath164 on @xmath165 is said to have a * @xmath159-quantile of type @xmath170 * , if there exist a @xmath159-quantile @xmath171 and a constant @xmath172 such that , for all @xmath173 $ ] , we have @xmath174 2 .
let @xmath175 $ ] .
we say that a probability measure @xmath20 on @xmath176 has a * @xmath159-quantile of @xmath177-average type @xmath170 * if the conditional probability measure @xmath178 has @xmath179-almost surely a @xmath159-quantile of type @xmath170 and the function @xmath180 where @xmath181 is the constant defined in part ( 1 ) , satisfies @xmath182 .
one can show that a distribution @xmath164 having a @xmath159-quantile of type @xmath170 has a unique @xmath159-quantile @xmath183 .
moreover , if @xmath164 has a lebesgue density @xmath184 then @xmath164 has a @xmath159-quantile of type @xmath170 if @xmath184 is bounded away from zero on @xmath185 $ ] since we can use @xmath186\}$ ] in ( [ tauquantileoftype2formula ] ) .
this assumption is general enough to cover many distributions used in parametric statistics such as gaussian , student s @xmath187 , and logistic distributions ( with @xmath188 ) , gamma and log - normal distributions ( with @xmath189 ) , and uniform and beta distributions ( with @xmath190 $ ] ) .
the following theorem , to be proved in section [ proofsection ] , gives a learning rate for the regularization scheme ( [ algor ] ) in the special case of quantile regression .
[ quantilethm ] suppose that @xmath191 almost surely for some constant @xmath192 , and that each kernel @xmath41 is @xmath193 with @xmath194 for some @xmath195 .
if assumption [ assumption1 ] holds with @xmath112 and @xmath6 has a @xmath159-quantile of @xmath177-average type @xmath170 for some @xmath196 $ ] , then by taking @xmath197 , for any @xmath198 and @xmath199 , with confidence at least @xmath200 we have @xmath201 where @xmath202 is a constant independent of @xmath203 and @xmath204 and @xmath205 please note that the exponent @xmath206 given by ( [ quantilerates2 ] ) for the learning rate in ( [ quantilerates ] ) is independent of the quantile level @xmath159 , of the number @xmath148 of additive components in @xmath207 , and of the dimensions @xmath208 and @xmath209 further note that @xmath210 , if @xmath211 , and @xmath212 if @xmath213 . because @xmath214 can be arbitrarily close to @xmath215 , the learning rate , which is independent of the dimension @xmath216 and given by theorem [ quantilethm ] , is close to @xmath217 for large values of @xmath177 and is close to @xmath218 or better , if @xmath211 . to state our general learning rates
, we need an assumption on a _ variance - expectation bound _ which is similar to definition [ noisecond ] in the special case of quantile regression .
[ assumption3 ] we assume that there exist an exponent @xmath219 $ ] and a positive constant @xmath220 such that @xmath221 assumption [ assumption3 ] always holds true for @xmath222 . if the triple @xmath223 satisfies some conditions , the exponent @xmath224 can be larger .
for example , when @xmath12 is the pinball loss ( [ pinloss ] ) and @xmath6 has a @xmath159-quantile of @xmath177-average type @xmath225 for some @xmath196 $ ] and @xmath226 as defined in @xcite , then @xmath227 .
[ mainratesthm ] suppose that @xmath228 is bounded by a constant @xmath229 almost surely . under assumptions [ assumption1 ] to [ assumption3 ] ,
if we take @xmath198 and @xmath230 for some @xmath231 , then for any @xmath232 , with confidence at least @xmath200 we have @xmath233 where @xmath234 is given by @xmath235 and @xmath202 is constant independent of @xmath203 or @xmath204 ( to be given explicitly in the proof ) .
we now add some theoretical and numerical comparisons on the goodness of our learning rates with those from the literature . as already mentioned in the introduction
, some reasons for the popularity of additive models are flexibility , increased interpretability , and ( often ) a reduced proneness of the curse of high dimensions .
hence it is important to check , whether the learning rate given in theorem [ mainratesthm ] under the assumption of an additive model favourably compares to ( essentially ) optimal learning rates without this assumption . in other words ,
we need to demonstrate that the main goal of this paper is achieved by theorem [ quantilethm ] and theorem [ mainratesthm ] , i.e. that an svm based on an additive kernel can provide a substantially better learning rate in high dimensions than an svm with a general kernel , say a classical gaussian rbf kernel , provided the assumption of an additive model is satisfied .
our learning rate in theorem [ quantilethm ] is new and optimal in the literature of svm for quantile regression .
most learning rates in the literature of svm for quantile regression are given for projected output functions @xmath236 , while it is well known that projections improve learning rates @xcite . here the projection operator @xmath237 is defined for any measurable function @xmath10 by @xmath238 sometimes this is called clipping .
such results are given in @xcite .
for example , under the assumptions that @xmath6 has a @xmath159-quantile of @xmath177-average type @xmath170 , the approximation error condition ( [ approxerrorb ] ) is satisfied for some @xmath239 , and that for some constants @xmath240 , the sequence of eigenvalues @xmath241 of the integral operator @xmath117 satisfies @xmath242 for every @xmath243 , it was shown in @xcite that with confidence at least @xmath200 , @xmath244 where @xmath245 here the parameter @xmath246 measures the capacity of the rkhs @xmath247 and it plays a similar role as half of the parameter @xmath147 in assumption 2 . for a @xmath193 kernel and @xmath112
, one can choose @xmath246 and @xmath147 to be arbitrarily small and the above power index @xmath248 can be taken as @xmath249 .
the learning rate in theorem [ quantilethm ] may be improved by relaxing assumption 1 to a sobolev smoothness condition for @xmath121 and a regularity condition for the marginal distribution @xmath250 .
for example , one may use a gaussian kernel @xmath251 depending on the sample size @xmath203 and @xcite achieve the approximation error condition ( [ approxerrorb ] ) for some @xmath252 .
this is done for quantile regression in @xcite .
since we are mainly interested in additive models , we shall not discuss such an extension .
[ gaussmore ] let @xmath48 , @xmath49 $ ] and @xmath50 ^ 2.$ ] let @xmath51 and the additive kernel @xmath72 be given by ( [ gaussaddform ] ) with @xmath253 in example [ gaussadd ] as @xmath52.\ ] ] if the function @xmath121 is given by ( [ gaussfcn ] ) , @xmath191 almost surely for some constant @xmath192 , and @xmath6 has a @xmath159-quantile of @xmath177-average type @xmath170 for some @xmath196 $ ] , then by taking @xmath197 , for any @xmath145 and @xmath199 , ( [ quantilerates ] ) holds with confidence at least @xmath200 . it is unknown whether the above learning rate can be derived by existing approaches in the literature ( e.g. @xcite ) even after projection .
note that the kernel in the above example is independent of the sample size .
it would be interesting to see whether there exists some @xmath99 such that the function @xmath57 defined by ( [ gaussfcn ] ) lies in the range of the operator @xmath254 .
the existence of such a positive index would lead to the approximation error condition ( [ approxerrorb ] ) , see @xcite . let us now add some numerical comparisons on the goodness of our learning rates given by theorem [ mainratesthm ] with those given by @xcite .
their corollary 4.12 gives ( essentially ) minmax optimal learning rates for ( clipped ) svms in the context of nonparametric quantile regression using one gaussian rbf kernel on the whole input space under appropriate smoothness assumptions of the target function .
let us consider the case that the distribution @xmath6 has a @xmath159-quantile of @xmath177-average type @xmath170 , where @xmath255 , and assume that both corollary 4.12 in @xcite and our theorem [ mainratesthm ] are applicable .
i.e. , we assume in particular that @xmath6 is a probability measure on @xmath256 $ ] and that the marginal distribution @xmath257 has a lebesgue density @xmath258 for some @xmath259 . furthermore , suppose that the optimal decision function @xmath260 has ( to make theorem [ mainratesthm ] applicable with @xmath261 $ ] ) the additive structure @xmath207 with each @xmath104 as stated in assumption [ assumption1 ] , where @xmath262 and @xmath263 , with minimal risk @xmath86 and additionally fulfills ( to make corollary 4.12 in @xcite applicable ) @xmath264 where @xmath265 $ ] and @xmath266 denotes a besov space with smoothness parameter @xmath267 .
the intuitive meaning of @xmath248 is , that increasing values of @xmath248 correspond to increased smoothness .
we refer to ( * ? ? ? * and p. 44 ) for details on besov spaces .
it is well - known that the besov space @xmath268 contains the sobolev space @xmath269 for @xmath270 , @xmath271 , and @xmath272 , and that @xmath273 .
we mention that if all @xmath41 are suitably chosen wendland kernels , their reproducing kernel hilbert spaces @xmath43 are sobolev spaces , see ( * ? ? ?
* thm . 10.35 , p. 160 ) .
furthermore , we use the same sequence of regularizing parameters as in ( * ? ? ?
4.9 , cor . 4.12 ) , i.e. , @xmath274 where @xmath275 , @xmath276 , @xmath277 $ ] , and @xmath278 is some user - defined positive constant independent of @xmath279 . for
reasons of simplicity , let us fix @xmath280 .
then ( * ? ? ?
4.12 ) gives learning rates for the risk of svms for @xmath159-quantile regression , if a single gaussian rbf - kernel on @xmath281 is used for @xmath159-quantile functions of @xmath177-average type @xmath170 with @xmath255 , which are of order @xmath282 hence the learning rate in theorem [ quantilethm ] is better than the one in ( * ? ? ?
4.12 ) in this situation , if @xmath283 provided the assumption of the additive model is valid .
table [ table1 ] lists the values of @xmath284 from ( [ explicitratescz2 ] ) for some finite values of the dimension @xmath216 , where @xmath285 .
all of these values of @xmath284 are positive with the exceptions if @xmath286 or @xmath287 .
this is in contrast to the corresponding exponent in the learning rate by ( * ? ?
* cor . 4.12 ) , because @xmath288 table [ table2 ] and figures [ figure1 ] to [ figure2 ] give additional information on the limit @xmath289 .
of course , higher values of the exponent indicates faster rates of convergence .
it is obvious , that an svm based on an additive kernel has a significantly faster rate of convergence in higher dimensions @xmath216 compared to svm based on a single gaussian rbf kernel defined on the whole input space , of course under the assumption that the additive model is valid .
the figures seem to indicate that our learning rate from theorem [ mainratesthm ] is probably not optimal for small dimensions . however , the main focus of the present paper is on high dimensions .
.[table1 ] the table lists the limits of the exponents @xmath290 from ( * ? ? ?
* cor . 4.12 ) and @xmath291 from theorem [ mainratesthm ] , respectively , if the regularizing parameter @xmath292 is chosen in an optimal manner for the nonparametric setup , i.e. @xmath293 , with @xmath294 for @xmath295 and @xmath296 .
recall that @xmath297 $ ] .
[ cols= " > , > , > , > " , ]
|
additive models play an important role in semiparametric statistics .
this paper gives learning rates for regularized kernel based methods for additive models .
these learning rates compare favourably in particular in high dimensions to recent results on optimal learning rates for purely nonparametric regularized kernel based quantile regression using the gaussian radial basis function kernel , provided the assumption of an additive model is valid .
additionally , a concrete example is presented to show that a gaussian function depending only on one variable lies in a reproducing kernel hilbert space generated by an additive gaussian kernel , but does not belong to the reproducing kernel hilbert space generated by the multivariate gaussian kernel of the same variance . *
key words and phrases . * additive model , kernel , quantile regression , semiparametric , rate of convergence , support vector machine .
|
the leptonic decays of a charged pseudoscalar meson @xmath7 are processes of the type @xmath8 , where @xmath9 , @xmath10 , or @xmath11 . because no strong interactions are present in the leptonic final state @xmath12 , such decays provide a clean way to probe the complex , strong interactions that bind the quark and antiquark within the initial - state meson . in these decays , strong interaction effects can be parametrized by a single quantity , @xmath13 , the pseudoscalar meson decay constant .
the leptonic decay rate can be measured by experiment , and the decay constant can be determined by the equation ( ignoring radiative corrections ) @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the fermi coupling constant , @xmath16 is the cabibbo - kobayashi - maskawa ( ckm ) matrix @xcite element , @xmath17 is the mass of the meson , and @xmath18 is the mass of the charged lepton .
the quantity @xmath13 describes the amplitude for the @xmath19 and @xmath20-quarks within the @xmath21 to have zero separation , a condition necessary for them to annihilate into the virtual @xmath22 boson that produces the @xmath12 pair .
the experimental determination of decay constants is one of the most important tests of calculations involving nonperturbative qcd .
such calculations have been performed using various models @xcite or using lattice qcd ( lqcd ) .
the latter is now generally considered to be the most reliable way to calculate the quantity .
knowledge of decay constants is important for describing several key processes , such as @xmath23 mixing , which depends on @xmath24 , a quantity that is also predicted by lqcd calculations .
experimental determination @xcite of @xmath24 with the leptonic decay of a @xmath25 meson is , however , very limited as the rate is highly suppressed due to the smallness of the magnitude of the relevant ckm matrix element @xmath26 .
the charm mesons , @xmath27 and @xmath28 , are better instruments to study the leptonic decays of heavy mesons since these decays are either less ckm suppressed or favored , _
i.e. _ , @xmath29 and @xmath30 are much larger than @xmath31 .
thus , the decay constants @xmath32 and @xmath33 determined from charm meson decays can be used to test and validate the necessary lqcd calculations applicable to the @xmath34-meson sector . among
the leptonic decays in the charm - quark sector , @xmath35 decays are more accessible since they are ckm favored .
furthermore , the large mass of the @xmath11 lepton removes the helicity suppression that is present in the decays to lighter leptons .
the existence of multiple neutrinos in the final state , however , makes measurement of this decay challenging .
physics beyond the standard model ( sm ) might also affect leptonic decays of charmed mesons .
depending on the non - sm features , the ratio of @xmath36 could be affected @xcite , as could the ratio @xcite @xmath37 .
any of the individual widths might be increased or decreased .
there is an indication of a discrepancy between the experimental determinations @xcite of @xmath33 and the most recent precision lqcd calculation @xcite .
this disagreement is particularly puzzling since the cleo - c determination @xcite of @xmath32 agrees well with the lqcd calculation @xcite of that quantity . some @xcite conjecture that this discrepancy may be explained by a charged higgs boson or a leptoquark . in this article
, we report an improved measurement of the absolute branching fraction of the leptonic decay @xmath0 ( charge - conjugate modes are implied ) , with @xmath1 , from which we determine the decay constant @xmath33 .
we use a data sample of @xmath38 events provided by the cornell electron storage ring ( cesr ) and collected by the cleo - c detector at the center - of - mass ( cm ) energy @xmath39 mev , near @xmath3 peak production @xcite .
the data sample consists of an integrated luminosity of @xmath40 @xmath41 containing @xmath42 @xmath3 pairs .
we have previously reported @xcite measurements of @xmath43 and @xmath0 with a subsample of these data . a companion article @xcite reports measurements of @xmath33 from @xmath43 and @xmath0 , with @xmath44 , using essentially the same data sample as the one used in this measurement .
the cleo - c detector @xcite is a general - purpose solenoidal detector with four concentric components utilized in this measurement : a small - radius six - layer stereo wire drift chamber , a 47-layer main drift chamber , a ring - imaging cherenkov ( rich ) detector , and an electromagnetic calorimeter consisting of 7800 csi(tl ) crystals .
the two drift chambers operate in a @xmath45 t magnetic field and provide charged particle tracking in a solid angle of @xmath46% of @xmath47 .
the chambers achieve a momentum resolution of @xmath48% at @xmath49 gev/@xmath50 .
the main drift chamber also provides specific - ionization ( @xmath51 ) measurements that discriminate between charged pions and kaons .
the rich detector covers approximately @xmath52% of @xmath47 and provides additional separation of pions and kaons at high momentum .
the photon energy resolution of the calorimeter is @xmath53% at @xmath54 gev and @xmath55% at @xmath56 mev .
electron identification is based on a likelihood variable that combines the information from the rich detector , @xmath51 , and the ratio of electromagnetic shower energy to track momentum ( @xmath57 ) .
we use a geant - based @xcite monte carlo ( mc ) simulation program to study efficiency of signal - event selection and background processes .
physics events are generated by evtgen @xcite , tuned with much improved knowledge of charm decays @xcite , and final - state radiation ( fsr ) is modeled by the photos @xcite program .
the modeling of initial - state radiation ( isr ) is based on cross sections for @xmath3 production at lower energies obtained from the cleo - c energy scan @xcite near the cm energy where we collect the sample .
the presence of two @xmath58 mesons in a @xmath3 event allows us to define a single - tag ( st ) sample in which a @xmath58 is reconstructed in a hadronic decay mode and a further double - tagged ( dt ) subsample in which an additional @xmath59 is required as a signature of @xmath60 decay , the @xmath59 being the daughter of the @xmath60 .
the @xmath61 reconstructed in the st sample can be either primary or secondary from @xmath62 ( or @xmath63 ) .
the st yield can be expressed as @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the produced number of @xmath3 pairs , @xmath66 is the branching fraction of hadronic modes used in the st sample , and @xmath67 is the st efficiency .
the @xmath68 counts the candidates , not events , and the factor of 2 comes from the sum of @xmath28 and @xmath61 tags .
our double - tag ( dt ) sample is formed from events with only a single charged track , identified as an @xmath69 , in addition to a st .
the yield can be expressed as @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the leptonic decay branching fraction , including the subbranching fraction of @xmath1 decay , @xmath72 is the efficiency of finding the st and the leptonic decay in the same event . from the st and dt yields we can obtain an absolute branching fraction of the leptonic decay @xmath71 , without needing to know the integrated luminosity or the produced number of @xmath3 pairs , @xmath73 where @xmath74 ( @xmath75 ) is the effective signal efficiency . because of the large solid angle acceptance with high segmentation of the cleo - c detector and the low multiplicity of the events with which we are concerned , @xmath76 , where @xmath77 is the leptonic decay efficiency .
hence , the ratio @xmath78 is insensitive to most systematic effects associated with the st , and the signal branching fraction @xmath71 obtained using this procedure is nearly independent of the efficiency of the tagging mode . to minimize systematic uncertainties , we tag using three two - body hadronic decay modes with only charged particles in the final state .
the three st modes and @xmath79 are shorthand labels for @xmath80 events within mass windows ( described below ) of the @xmath81 peak in @xmath82 and the @xmath83 peak in @xmath84 , respectively .
no attempt is made to separate these resonance components in the @xmath85 dalitz plot . ]
are @xmath86 , @xmath79 , and @xmath87 .
using these tag modes also helps to reduce the tag bias which would be caused by the correlation between the tag side and the signal side reconstruction if tag modes with high multiplicity and large background were used .
the effect of the tag bias @xmath88 can be expressed in terms of the signal efficiency @xmath74 defined by @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the st efficiency when the recoiling system is the signal leptonic decay with single @xmath59 in the other side of the tag .
as the general st efficiency @xmath67 , when the recoiling system is any possible @xmath91 decays , will be lower than the @xmath90 , sizable tag bias could be introduced if the multiplicity of the tag mode were high , or the tag mode were to include neutral particles in the final state . as shown in sec .
[ sec : results ] , this effect is negligible in our chosen clean tag modes .
the @xmath92 decay is reconstructed by combining oppositely charged tracks that originate from a common vertex and that have an invariant mass within @xmath93 mev of the nominal mass @xcite .
we require the resonance decay to satisfy the following mass windows around the nominal masses @xcite : @xmath94 ( @xmath95 mev ) and @xmath96 ( @xmath97 mev ) .
we require the momenta of charged particles to be @xmath56 mev or greater to suppress the slow pion background from @xmath98 decays ( through @xmath99 ) .
we identify a st by using the invariant mass of the tag @xmath100 and recoil mass against the tag @xmath101 .
the recoil mass is defined as @xmath102 where @xmath103 is the net four - momentum of the @xmath4 beam , taking the finite beam crossing angle into account ; @xmath104 is the four - momentum of the tag , with @xmath105 computed from @xmath106 and the nominal mass @xcite of the @xmath91 meson .
we require the recoil mass to be within @xmath107 mev of the @xmath108 mass @xcite .
this loose window allows both primary and secondary @xmath91 tags to be selected . to estimate the backgrounds in our st and dt yields from the wrong tag combinations ( incorrect combinations that , by chance , lie within the @xmath109 signal region ) , we use the tag invariant mass sidebands .
we define the signal region as @xmath110 mev @xmath111 mev , and the sideband regions as @xmath112 mev @xmath113 mev or @xmath114 mev @xmath115 mev , where @xmath116 is the difference between the tag mass and the nominal mass .
we fit the st @xmath109 distributions to the sum of double - gaussian signal function plus second - degree chebyshev polynomial background function to get the tag mass sideband scaling factor .
the invariant mass distributions of tag candidates for each tag mode are shown in fig .
[ fig : dm ] and the st yield and @xmath109 sideband scaling factor are summarized in table [ table : data - single ] .
we find @xmath117 summed over the three tag modes .
.[table : data - single ] summary of single - tag ( st ) yields , where @xmath118 is the yield in the st mass signal region , @xmath119 is the yield in the sideband region , @xmath120 is the sideband scaling factor , and @xmath68 is the scaled sideband - subtracted yield . [ cols="<,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] we considered six semileptonic decays , @xmath121 @xmath122 , @xmath123 , @xmath124 , @xmath125 , @xmath126 , and @xmath127 , as the major sources of background in the @xmath128 signal region .
the second dominates the nonpeaking background , and the fourth ( with @xmath129 ) dominates the peaking background .
uncertainty in the signal yield due to nonpeaking background ( @xmath130 ) is assessed by varying the semileptonic decay branching fractions by the precision with which they are known @xcite .
imperfect knowledge of @xmath131 gives rise to a systematic uncertainty in our estimate of the amount of peaking background in the signal region , which has an effect on our branching fraction measurement of @xmath132 .
we study differences in efficiency , data vs mc events , due to the extra energy requirement , extra track veto , and @xmath133 requirement , by using samples from data and mc events , in which _ both _ the @xmath134 and @xmath2 satisfy our tag requirements , i.e. , `` double - tag '' events .
we then apply each of the above - mentioned requirements and compare loss in efficiency of data vs mc events . in this way
we obtain a correction of @xmath135 for the extra energy requirement and systematic uncertainties on each of the three requirements of @xmath136 ( all equal , by chance ) .
the non-@xmath69 background in the signal @xmath69 candidate sample is negligible ( @xmath137 ) due to the low probability ( @xmath138 per track ) that hadrons ( @xmath139 or @xmath140 ) are misidentified as @xmath69 @xcite .
uncertainty in these backgrounds produces a @xmath141 uncertainty in the measurement of @xmath142 .
the secondary @xmath69 backgrounds from charge symmetric processes , such as @xmath143 dalitz decay ( @xmath144 ) and @xmath145 conversion ( @xmath146 ) , are assessed by measuring the wrong - sign signal electron in events with @xmath147 . the uncertainty in the measurement from this source
is estimated to be @xmath148 .
other possible sources of systematic uncertainty include @xmath68 ( @xmath137 ) , tag bias ( @xmath149 ) , tracking efficiency ( @xmath148 ) , @xmath59 identification efficiency ( @xmath150 ) , and fsr ( @xmath150 ) . combining all contributions in quadrature ,
the total systematic uncertainty in the branching fraction measurement is estimated to be @xmath151 .
in summary , using the sample of @xmath152 tagged @xmath28 decays with the cleo - c detector we obtain the absolute branching fraction of the leptonic decay @xmath153 through @xmath154 @xmath155 where the first uncertainty is statistical and the second is systematic .
this result supersedes our previous measurement @xcite of the same branching fraction , which used a subsample of data used in this work .
the decay constant @xmath33 can be computed using eq .
( [ eq : f ] ) with known values @xcite @xmath156 gev@xmath157 , @xmath158 mev , @xmath159 mev , and @xmath160 s. we assume @xmath161 and use the value @xmath162 given in ref .
we obtain @xmath163 combining with our other determination @xcite of @xmath164 mev with @xmath43 and @xmath0 ( @xmath165 ) decays , we obtain @xmath166 this result is derived from absolute branching fractions only and is the most precise determination of the @xmath91 leptonic decay constant to date . our combined result is larger than the recent lqcd calculation @xmath167 mev @xcite by @xmath168 standard deviations .
the difference between data and lqcd for @xmath33 could be due to physics beyond the sm @xcite , unlikely statistical fluctuations in the experimental measurements or the lqcd calculation , or systematic uncertainties that are not understood in the lqcd calculation or the experimental measurements . combining with our other determination @xcite of @xmath169 , via @xmath44
, we obtain @xmath170 using this with our measurement @xcite of @xmath171 , we obtain the branching fraction ratio @xmath172 this is consistent with @xmath173 , the value predicted by the sm with lepton universality , as given in eq .
( [ eq : f ] ) with known masses @xcite .
we gratefully acknowledge the effort of the cesr staff in providing us with excellent luminosity and running conditions .
d. cronin - hennessy and a. ryd thank the a.p . sloan foundation .
this work was supported by the national science foundation , the u.s .
department of energy , the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada , and the u.k .
science and technology facilities council . c. amsler
_ et al . _
( particle data group ) , phys .
b * 667 * , 1 ( 2008 ) .
k. ikado _ et al . _
( belle collaboration ) , phys .
lett . * 97 * , 251802 ( 2006 ) .
b. aubert _ et al .
_ ( babar collaboration ) , phys . rev .
d * 77 * , 011107 ( 2008 ) .
a. g. akeroyd and c. h. chen , phys .
d * 75 * , 075004 ( 2007 ) ; a. g. akeroyd , prog .
phys . * 111 * , 295 ( 2004 ) .
j. l. hewett , arxiv : hep - ph/9505246 .
w. s. hou , phys .
d * 48 * , 2342 ( 1993 ) .
e. follana , c. t. h. davies , g. p. lepage , and j. shigemitsu ( hpqcd collaboration ) , phys .
lett . *
100 * , 062002 ( 2008 ) .
b. i. eisenstein _ et al .
_ ( cleo collaboration ) , phys . rev .
d * 78 * , 052003 ( 2008 ) .
b. a. dobrescu and a. s. kronfeld , phys .
* 100 * , 241802 ( 2008 ) .
d. cronin - hennessy _ et al .
_ ( cleo collaboration ) , arxiv:0801.3418 .
m. artuso _ et al . _
( cleo collaboration ) , phys .
lett . * 99 * , 071802 ( 2007 ) .
k. m. ecklund _ et al . _
( cleo collaboration ) , phys . rev .
lett . * 100 * , 161801 ( 2008 ) .
j. p. alexander _ et al .
_ ( cleo collaboration ) , phys . rev .
d * 79 * , 052001 ( 2009 ) .
y. kubota _ et al .
_ ( cleo collaboration ) , nucl .
instrum .
a * 320 * , 66 ( 1992 ) .
d. peterson _
et al . _ ,
instrum .
methods phys .
, sec . a * 478 * , 142 ( 2002 ) . m. artuso _ et al . _ ,
nucl . instrum .
methods phys .
a * 502 * , 91 ( 2003 ) .
s. dobbs _ et al .
_ ( cleo collaboration ) , phys . rev .
d * 76 * , 112001 ( 2007 ) .
j. p. alexander _ et al .
_ ( cleo collaboration ) , phys . rev .
lett . * 100 * , 161804 ( 2008 ) .
e. barberio and z. was , comput .
. commun . * 79 * , 291 ( 1994 ) .
|
we have studied the leptonic decay @xmath0 , via the decay channel @xmath1 , using a sample of tagged @xmath2 decays collected near the @xmath3 peak production energy in @xmath4 collisions with the cleo - c detector .
we obtain @xmath5 and determine the decay constant @xmath6 mev , where the first uncertainties are statistical and the second are systematic .
|
the transport properties of nonlinear non - equilibrium dynamical systems are far from well - understood@xcite .
consider in particular so - called ratchet systems which are asymmetric periodic potentials where an ensemble of particles experience directed transport@xcite .
the origins of the interest in this lie in considerations about extracting useful work from unbiased noisy fluctuations as seems to happen in biological systems@xcite .
recently attention has been focused on the behavior of deterministic chaotic ratchets@xcite as well as hamiltonian ratchets@xcite .
chaotic systems are defined as those which are sensitively dependent on initial conditions . whether chaotic or not , the behavior of nonlinear systems including the transition from regular to chaotic behavior is in general sensitively dependent on the parameters of the system .
that is , the phase - space structure is usually relatively complicated , consisting of stability islands embedded in chaotic seas , for examples , or of simultaneously co - existing attractors .
this can change significantly as parameters change .
for example , stability islands can merge into each other , or break apart , and the chaotic sea itself may get pinched off or otherwise changed , or attractors can change symmetry or bifurcate .
this means that the transport properties can change dramatically as well .
a few years ago , mateos@xcite considered a specific ratchet model with a periodically forced underdamped particle .
he looked at an ensemble of particles , specifically the velocity for the particles , averaged over time and the entire ensemble .
he showed that this quantity , which is an intuitively reasonable definition of ` the current ' , could be either positive or negative depending on the amplitude @xmath0 of the periodic forcing for the system . at the same time , there exist ranges in @xmath0 where the trajectory of an individual particle displays chaotic dynamics .
mateos conjectured a connection between these two phenomena , specifically that the reversal of current direction was correlated with a bifurcation from chaotic to periodic behavior in the trajectory dynamics .
even though it is unlikely that such a result would be universally valid across all chaotic deterministic ratchets , it would still be extremely useful to have general heuristic rules such as this .
these organizing principles would allow some handle on characterizing the many different kinds of behavior that are possible in such systems .
a later investigation@xcite of the mateos conjecture by barbi and salerno , however , argued that it was not a valid rule even in the specific system considered by mateos .
they presented results showing that it was possible to have current reversals in the absence of bifurcations from periodic to chaotic behavior .
they proposed an alternative origin for the current reversal , suggesting it was related to the different stability properties of the rotating periodic orbits of the system .
these latter results seem fundamentally sensible . however , this paper based its arguments about currents on the behavior of a _ single _ particle as opposed to an ensemble .
this implicitly assumes that the dynamics of the system are ergodic .
this is not true in general for chaotic systems of the type being considered . in particular , there can be extreme dependence of the result on the statistics of the ensemble being considered .
this has been pointed out in earlier studies @xcite which laid out a detailed methodology for understanding transport properties in such a mixed regular and chaotic system . depending on specific parameter value , the particular system under consideration has multiple coexisting periodic or chaotic attractors or a mixture of both .
it is hence appropriate to understand how a probability ensemble might behave in such a system .
the details of the dependence on the ensemble are particularly relevant to the issue of the possible experimental validation of these results , since experiments are always conducted , by virtue of finite - precision , over finite time and finite ensembles .
it is therefore interesting to probe the results of barbi and salerno with regard to the details of the ensemble used , and more formally , to see how ergodicity alters our considerations about the current , as we do in this paper .
we report here on studies on the properties of the current in a chaotic deterministic ratchet , specifically the same system as considered by mateos@xcite and barbi and salerno@xcite .
we consider the impact of different kinds of ensembles of particles on the current and show that the current depends significantly on the details of the initial ensemble .
we also show that it is important to discard transients in quantifying the current .
this is one of the central messages of this paper : broad heuristics are rare in chaotic systems , and hence it is critical to understand the ensemble - dependence in any study of the transport properties of chaotic ratchets .
having established this , we then proceed to discuss the connection between the bifurcation diagram for individual particles and the behavior of the current .
we find that while we disagree with many of the details of barbi and salerno s results , the broader conclusion still holds .
that is , it is indeed possible to have current reversals in the absence of bifurcations from chaos to periodic behavior as well as bifurcations without any accompanying current reversals .
the result of our investigation is therefore that the transport properties of a chaotic ratchet are not as simple as the initial conjecture .
however , we do find evidence for a generalized version of mateos s conjecture .
that is , in general , bifurcations for trajectory dynamics as a function of system parameter seem to be associated with abrupt changes in the current .
depending on the specific value of the current , these abrupt changes may lead the net current to reverse direction , but not necessarily so .
we start below with a preparatory discussion necessary to understand the details of the connection between bifurcations and current reversal , where we discuss the potential and phase - space for single trajectories for this system , where we also define a bifurcation diagram for this system . in the next section ,
we discuss the subtleties of establishing a connection between the behavior of individual trajectories and of ensembles .
after this , we are able to compare details of specific trajectory bifurcation curves with current curves , and thus justify our broader statements above , after which we conclude .
the goal of these studies is to understand the behavior of general chaotic ratchets .
the approach taken here is that to discover heuristic rules we must consider specific systems in great detail before generalizing .
we choose the same @xmath1-dimensional ratchet considered previously by mateos@xcite , as well as barbi and salerno@xcite .
we consider an ensemble of particles moving in an asymmetric periodic potential , driven by a periodic time - dependent external force , where the force has a zero time - average .
there is no noise in the system , so it is completely deterministic , although there is damping .
the equations of motion for an individual trajectory for such a system are given in dimensionless variables by @xmath2 where the periodic asymmetric potential can be written in the form @xmath3 + \frac{1}{4 } \sin [ 4\pi ( x -x_0 ) ] \bigg ] .\ ] ] in this equation @xmath4 have been introduced for convenience such that one potential minimum exists at the origin with @xmath5 and the term @xmath6 .
( a ) classical phase space for the unperturbed system . for @xmath7 , @xmath8 ,
two chaotic attractors emerge with @xmath9 ( b ) @xmath10 ( c ) and a period four attractor consisting of the four centers of the circles with @xmath11.,title="fig:",width=302 ] the phase - space of the undamped undriven ratchet the system corresponding to the unperturbed potential @xmath12 looks like a series of asymmetric pendula .
that is , individual trajectories have one of following possible time - asymptotic behaviors : ( i ) inside the potential wells , trajectories and all their properties oscillate , leading to zero net transport . outside the wells , the trajectories either ( ii ) librate to the right or ( iii ) to the left , with corresponding net transport depending upon initial conditions .
there are also ( iv ) trajectories on the separatrices between the oscillating and librating orbits , moving between unstable fixed points in infinite time , as well as the unstable and stable fixed points themselves , all of which constitute a set of negligible measure . when damping is introduced via the @xmath13-dependent term in eq .
[ eq : dyn ] , it makes the stable fixed points the only attractors for the system .
when the driving is turned on , the phase - space becomes chaotic with the usual phenomena of intertwining separatrices and resulting homoclinic tangles .
the dynamics of individual trajectories in such a system are now very complicated in general and depend sensitively on the choice of parameters and initial conditions .
we show snapshots of the development of this kind of chaos in the set of poincar sections fig .
( [ figure1]b , c ) together with a period - four orbit represented by the center of the circles . a broad characterization of the dynamics of the problem as a function of a parameter ( @xmath14 or @xmath15 ) emerges in a bifurcation diagram
. this can be constructed in several different and essentially equivalent ways .
the relatively standard form that we use proceeds as follows : first choose the bifurcation parameter ( let us say @xmath0 ) and correspondingly choose fixed values of @xmath16 , and start with a given value for @xmath17 .
now iterate an initial condition , recording the value of the particle s position @xmath18 at times @xmath19 from its integrated trajectory ( sometimes we record @xmath20 .
this is done stroboscopically at discrete times @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 is an integer @xmath24 with @xmath25 the maximum number of observations made . of these , discard observations at times less than some cut - off time @xmath26 and plot the remaining points against @xmath27 .
it must be noted that discarding transient behavior is critical to get results which are independent of initial condition , and we shall emphasize this further below in the context of the net transport or current .
if the system has a fixed - point attractor then all of the data lie at one particular location @xmath28 . a periodic orbit with period @xmath29 ( that is , with period commensurate with the driving ) shows up with @xmath30 points occupying only @xmath31 different locations of @xmath32 for @xmath27 .
all other orbits , including periodic orbits of incommensurate period result in a simply - connected or multiply - connected dense set of points . for the next value @xmath33 , the last computed value of @xmath34 at @xmath35 are used as initial conditions , and previously , results are stored after cutoff and so on until @xmath36 .
that is , the bifurcation diagram is generated by sweeping the relevant parameter , in this case @xmath0 , from @xmath27 through some maximum value @xmath37 .
this procedure is intended to catch all coexisting attractors of the system with the specified parameter range .
note that several initial conditions are effectively used troughout the process , and a bifurcation diagram is not the behavior of a single trajectory .
we have made several plots , as a test , with different initial conditions and the diagrams obtained are identical .
we show several examples of this kind of bifurcation diagram below , where they are being compared with the corresponding behavior of the current .
having broadly understood the wide range of behavior for individual trajectories in this system , we now turn in the next section to a discussion of the non - equilibrium properties of a statistical ensemble of these trajectories , specifically the current for an ensemble .
the current @xmath38 for an ensemble in the system is defined in an intuitive manner by mateos@xcite as the time - average of the average velocity over an ensemble of initial conditions .
that is , an average over several initial conditions is performed at a given observation time @xmath39 to yield the average velocity over the particles @xmath40 this average velocity is then further time - averaged ; given the discrete time @xmath39 for observation this leads to a second sum @xmath41 where @xmath25 is the number of time - observations made . for this to be a relevant quantity to compare with bifurcation diagrams , @xmath38 should be independent of the quantities @xmath42 but still strongly dependent on @xmath43 .
a further parameter dependence that is being suppressed in the definition above is the shape and location of the ensemble being used .
that is , the transport properties of an ensemble in a chaotic system depend in general on the part of the phase - space being sampled .
it is therefore important to consider many different initial conditions to generate a current . the first straightforward result we show in fig .
( [ figure2 ] ) is that in the case of chaotic trajectories , a single trajectory easily displays behavior very different from that of many trajectories .
however , it turns out that in the regular regime , it is possible to use a single trajectory to get essentially the same result as obtained from many trajectories . further consider the bifurcation diagram in fig .
( [ figure3 ] ) where we superimpose the different curves resulting from varying the number of points in the initial ensemble .
first , the curve is significantly smoother as a function of @xmath0 for larger @xmath44 . even more relevant is the fact that the single trajectory data ( @xmath45 ) may show current reversals that do not exist in the large @xmath44 data .
current @xmath38 versus the number of trajectories @xmath44 for @xmath7 ; dashed lines correspond to a regular motion with @xmath46 while solid lines correspond to a chaotic motion with @xmath47 .
note that a single trajectory is sufficient for a regular motion while the convergence in the chaotic case is only obtained if the @xmath44 exceeds a certain threshold , @xmath48.,title="fig:",width=302 ] current @xmath38 versus @xmath0 for different set of trajectories @xmath44 ; @xmath45 ( circles ) , @xmath49 ( square ) and @xmath50 ( dashed lines ) . note that a single trajectory suffices in the regular regime where all the curves match . in the chaotic regime
, as @xmath44 increases , the curves converge towards the dashed one.,title="fig:",width=302 ] also , note that single - trajectory current values are typically significantly greater than ensemble averages .
this arises from the fact that an arbitrarily chosen ensemble has particles with idiosyncratic behaviors which often average out . as our result , with these ensembles we see typical @xmath51 for example , while barbi and salerno report currents about @xmath52 times greater .
however , it is not true that only a few trajectories dominate the dynamics completely , else there would not be a saturation of the current as a function of @xmath44 .
all this is clear in fig .
( [ figure3 ] ) .
we note that the * net * drift of an ensemble can be a lot closer to @xmath53 than the behavior of an individual trajectory
. it should also be clear that there is a dependence of the current on the location of the initial ensemble , this being particularly true for small @xmath44 , of course .
the location is defined by its centroid @xmath54 . for @xmath45 , it is trivially true that the initial location matters to the asymptotic value of the time - averaged velocity , given that this is a non - ergodic and chaotic system .
further , considering a gaussian ensemble , say , the width of the ensemble also affects the details of the current , and can show , for instance , illusory current reversal , as seen in figs .
( [ current - bifur1],[current - bifur2 ] ) for example .
notice also that in fig .
( [ current - bifur1 ] ) , at @xmath55 and @xmath56 , the deviations between the different ensembles is particularly pronounced .
these points are close to bifurcation points where some sort of symmetry breaking is clearly occuring , which underlines our emphasis on the relevance of specifying ensemble characteristics in the neighborhood of unstable behavior .
however , why these specific bifurcations should stand out among all the bifurcations in the parameter range shown is not entirely clear . to understand how to incorporate this knowledge into calculations of the current ,
therefore , consider the fact that if we look at the classical phase space for the hamiltonian or underdamped @xmath57 motion , we see the typical structure of stable islands embedded in a chaotic sea which have quite complicated behavior@xcite . in such a situation , the dynamics always depends on the location of the initial conditions .
however , we are not in the hamiltonian situation when the damping is turned on in this case , the phase - space consists in general of attractors .
that is , if transient behavior is discarded , the current is less likely to depend significantly on the location of the initial conditions or on the spread of the initial conditions . in particular , in the chaotic regime of a non - hamiltonian system , the initial ensemble needs to be chosen larger than a certain threshold to ensure convergence .
however , in the regular regime , it is not important to take a large ensemble and a single trajectory can suffice , as long as we take care to discard the transients .
that is to say , in the computation of currents , the definition of the current needs to be modified to : @xmath58 where @xmath59 is some empirically obtained cut - off such that we get a converged current ( for instance , in our calculations , we obtained converged results with @xmath60 ) . when this modified form is used , the convergence ( ensemble - independence ) is more rapid as a function of @xmath61 and the width of the intial conditions .
armed with this background , we are now finally in a position to compare bifurcation diagrams with the current , as we do in the next section .
our results are presented in the set of figures fig .
( [ figure5 ] ) fig .
( [ rev - nobifur ] ) , in each of which we plot both the ensemble current and the bifurcation diagram as a function of the parameter @xmath0 .
the main point of these numerical results can be distilled into a series of heuristic statements which we state below ; these are labelled with roman numerals . for @xmath7 and @xmath8 , we plot current ( upper ) with @xmath62 and bifurcation diagram ( lower ) versus @xmath0 .
note that there is a * single * current reversal while there are many bifurcations visible in the same parameter range.,title="fig:",width=302 ] consider fig .
( [ figure5 ] ) , which shows the parameter range @xmath63 chosen relatively arbitrarily . in this figure , we see several period - doubling bifurcations leading to order - chaos transitions , such as for example in the approximate ranges @xmath64 . however , there is only one instance of current - reversal , at @xmath65 .
note , however , that the current is not without structure it changes fairly dramatically as a function of parameter .
this point is made even more clearly in fig .
( [ figure6 ] ) where the current remains consistently below @xmath53 , and hence there are in fact , no current reversals at all .
note again , however , that the current has considerable structure , even while remaining negative
. for @xmath66 and @xmath8 , plotted are current ( upper ) and bifurcation diagram ( lower ) versus @xmath0 with @xmath62 .
notice the current stays consistently below @xmath53.,title="fig:",width=302 ] current and bifurcations versus @xmath0 . in ( a ) and ( b )
we show ensemble dependence , specifically in ( a ) the black curve is for an ensemble of trajectories starting centered at the stable fixed point @xmath67 with a root - mean - square gaussian width of @xmath68 , and the brown curve for trajectories starting from the unstable fixed point @xmath69 and of width @xmath68 . in ( b ) , all ensembles are centered at the stable fixed point , the black line for an ensemble of width @xmath68 , brown a width of @xmath70 and maroon with width @xmath71 .
( c ) is the comparison of the current @xmath38 without transients ( black ) and with transients ( brown ) along with the single - trajectory results in blue ( after barbi and salerno ) .
the initial conditions for the ensembles are centered at @xmath67 with a mean root square gaussian of width @xmath68 .
( d ) is the corresponding bifurcation diagram.,title="fig:",width=302 ] it is possible to find several examples of this at different parameters , leading to the negative conclusion , therefore , that * ( i ) not all bifurcations lead to current reversal*. however , we are searching for positive correlations , and at this point we have not precluded the more restricted statement that all current reversals are associated with bifurcations , which is in fact mateos conjecture .
we therefore now move onto comparing our results against the specific details of barbi and salerno s treatment of this conjecture . in particular , we look at their figs .
( 2,3a,3b ) , where they scan the parameter region @xmath72 .
the distinction between their results and ours is that we are using _
ensembles _ of particles , and are investigating the convergence of these results as a function of number of particles @xmath44 , the width of the ensemble in phase - space , as well as transience parameters @xmath73 . our data with larger @xmath44 yields different results in general , as we show in the recomputed versions of these figures , presented here in figs .
( [ current - bifur1],[current - bifur2 ] ) .
specifically , ( a ) the single - trajectory results are , not surprisingly , cleaner and can be more easily interpreted as part of transitions in the behavior of the stability properties of the periodic orbits .
the ensemble results on the other hand , even when converged , show statistical roughness .
( b ) the ensemble results are consistent with barbi and salerno in general , although disagreeing in several details .
for instance , ( c ) the bifurcation at @xmath74 has a much gentler impact on the ensemble current , which has been growing for a while , while the single - trajectory result changes abruptly . note , ( d ) the very interesting fact that the single - trajectory current completely misses the bifurcation - associated spike at @xmath75 .
further , ( e ) the barbi and salerno discussion of the behavior of the current in the range @xmath76 is seen to be flawed
our results are consistent with theirs , however , the current changes are seen to be consistent with bifurcations despite their statements to the contrary . on the other hand ( f ) , the ensemble current shows a case [ in fig .
( [ current - bifur2 ] ) , at @xmath77 of current reversal that does not seem to be associated with bifurcations .
in this spike , the current abruptly drops below @xmath53 and then rises above it again .
the single trajectory current completely ignores this particular effect , as can be seen .
the bifurcation diagram indicates that in this case the important transitions happen either before or after the spike .
all of this adds up to two statements : the first is a reiteration of the fact that there is significant information in the ensemble current that can not be obtained from the single - trajectory current .
the second is that the heuristic that arises from this is again a negative conclusion , that * ( ii ) not all current reversals are associated with bifurcations .
* where does this leave us in the search for ` positive ' results , that is , useful heuristics ?
one possible way of retaining the mateos conjecture is to weaken it , i.e. make it into the statement that * ( iii ) _ most _ current reversals are associated with bifurcations . * same as fig .
( [ current - bifur1 ] ) except for the range of @xmath0 considered.,title="fig:",width=302 ] for @xmath78 and @xmath8 , plotted are current ( upper ) and bifurcation diagram ( lower ) versus @xmath0 with @xmath62 .
note in particular in this figure that eyeball tests can be misleading .
we see reversals without bifurcations in ( a ) whereas the zoomed version ( c ) shows that there are windows of periodic and chaotic regimes .
this is further evidence that jumps in the current correspond in general to bifurcation.,title="fig:",width=302 ] for @xmath7 and @xmath79 , current ( upper ) and bifurcation diagram ( lower ) versus @xmath0.,title="fig:",width=302 ] however , a * different * rule of thumb , previously not proposed , emerges from our studies .
this generalizes mateos conjecture to say that * ( iv ) bifurcations correspond to sudden current changes ( spikes or jumps)*. note that this means these changes in current are not necessarily reversals of direction .
if this current jump or spike goes through zero , this coincides with a current reversal , making the mateos conjecture a special case .
the physical basis of this argument is the fact that ensembles of particles in chaotic systems _ can _ have net directed transport but the details of this behavior depends relatively sensitively on the system parameters .
this parameter dependence is greatly exaggerated at the bifurcation point , when the dynamics of the underlying single - particle system undergoes a transition a period - doubling transition , for example , or one from chaos to regular behavior .
scanning the relevant figures , we see that this is a very useful rule of thumb . for example
, it completely captures the behaviour of fig .
( [ figure6 ] ) which can not be understood as either an example of the mateos conjecture , or even a failure thereof . as such
, this rule significantly enhances our ability to characterize changes in the behavior of the current as a function of parameter .
a further example of where this modified conjecture helps us is in looking at a seeming negation of the mateos conjecture , that is , an example where we seem to see current - reversal without bifurcation , visible in fig .
( [ hidden - bifur ] ) .
the current - reversals in that scan of parameter space seem to happen inside the chaotic regime and seemingly independent of bifurcation . however , this turns out to be a ` hidden ' bifurcation when we zoom in on the chaotic regime , we see hidden periodic windows .
this is therefore consistent with our statement that sudden current changes are associated with bifurcations .
each of the transitions from periodic behavior to chaos and back provides opportunities for the current to spike .
however , in not all such cases can these hidden bifurcations be found .
we can see an example of this in fig .
( [ rev - nobifur ] ) .
the current is seen to move smoothly across @xmath80 with seemingly no corresponding bifurcations , even when we do a careful zoom on the data , as in fig .
( [ hidden - bifur ] ) .
however , arguably , although subjective , this change is close to the bifurcation point .
this result , that there are situations where the heuristics simply do not seem to apply , are part of the open questions associated with this problem , of course .
we note , however , that we have seen that these broad arguments hold when we vary other parameters as well ( figures not shown here ) . in conclusion ,
in this paper we have taken the approach that it is useful to find general rules of thumb ( even if not universally valid ) to understand the complicated behavior of non - equilibrium nonlinear statistical mechanical systems . in the case of chaotic deterministic ratchets
, we have shown that it is important to factor out issues of size , location , spread , and transience in computing the ` current ' due to an ensemble before we search for such rules , and that the dependence on ensemble characteristics is most critical near certain bifurcation points .
we have then argued that the following heuristic characteristics hold : bifurcations in single - trajectory behavior often corresponds to sudden spikes or jumps in the current for an ensemble in the same system .
current reversals are a special case of this
. however , not all spikes or jumps correspond to a bifurcation , nor vice versa .
the open question is clearly to figure out if the reason for when these rules are violated or are valid can be made more concrete .
a.k . gratefully acknowledges t. barsch and kamal p. singh for stimulating discussions , the reimar lst grant and financial support from the alexander von humboldt foundation in bonn . a.k.p .
is grateful to carleton college for the ` sit , wallin , and class of 1949 ' sabbatical fellowships , and to the mpipks for hosting him for a sabbatical visit , which led to this collaboration .
useful discussions with j .-
m . rost on preliminary results are also acknowledged .
p. hnggi and bartussek , in nonlinear physics of complex systems , lecture notes in physics vol .
476 , edited by j. parisi , s.c .
mueller , and w. zimmermann ( springer verlag , berlin , 1996 ) , pp.294 - 308 ; r.d .
asturmian , science * 276 * , 917 ( 1997 ) ; f. jlicher , a. ajdari , and j. prost , rev . mod .
phys . * 69 * , 1269 ( 1997 ) ; c. dring , nuovo cimento d*17 * , 685 ( 1995 ) s. flach , o. yevtushenko , and y. zolotaryuk , phys
. rev .
lett . * 84 * , 2358 ( 2000 ) ; o. yevtushenko , s. flach , y. zolotaryuk , and a. a. ovchinnikov , europhys .
lett . * 54 * , 141 ( 2001 ) ; s. denisov et al .
e * 66 * , 041104 ( 2002 )
|
in 84 , 258 ( 2000 ) , mateos conjectured that current reversal in a classical deterministic ratchet is associated with bifurcations from chaotic to periodic regimes .
this is based on the comparison of the current and the bifurcation diagram as a function of a given parameter for a periodic asymmetric potential .
barbi and salerno , in 62 , 1988 ( 2000 ) , have further investigated this claim and argue that , contrary to mateos claim , current reversals can occur also in the absence of bifurcations .
barbi and salerno s studies are based on the dynamics of one particle rather than the statistical mechanics of an ensemble of particles moving in the chaotic system .
the behavior of ensembles can be quite different , depending upon their characteristics , which leaves their results open to question . in this paper we present results from studies showing how the current depends on the details of the ensemble
used to generate it , as well as conditions for convergent behavior ( that is , independent of the details of the ensemble ) .
we are then able to present the converged current as a function of parameters , in the same system as mateos as well as barbi and salerno .
we show evidence for current reversal without bifurcation , as well as bifurcation without current reversal .
we conjecture that it is appropriate to correlate abrupt changes in the current with bifurcation , rather than current reversals , and show numerical evidence for our claims .
|
studies of laser beams propagating through turbulent atmospheres are important for many applications such as remote sensing , tracking , and long - distance optical communications .
howerver , fully coherent laser beams are very sensitive to fluctuations of the atmospheric refractive index .
the initially coherent laser beam acquires some properties of gaussian statistics in course of its propagation through the turbulence . as a result , the noise / signal ratio approaches unity for long - distance propagation .
( see , for example , refs.@xcite-@xcite ) .
this unfavourable effect limits the performance of communication channels . to mitigate this negative effect
the use of partially ( spatially ) coherent beams was proposed .
the coherent laser beam can be transformed into a partially coherent beam by means of a phase diffuser placed near the exit aperture .
this diffuser introduces an additional phase ( randomly varying in space and time ) to the wave front of the outgoing radiation .
statistical characteristics of the random phase determine the initial transverse coherence length of the beam .
it is shown in refs .
@xcite,@xcite that a considerable decrease in the noise / signal ratio can occur under following conditions : ( i ) the ratio of the initial transverse coherence length , @xmath0 , to the beam radius , @xmath1 , should be essentially smaller than unity ; and ( ii ) the characteristic time of phase variations , @xmath2 , should be much smaller than the integration time , @xmath3 , of the detector .
however , only limiting cases @xmath4 and @xmath5 have been considered in the literature .
( see , for example , refs .
@xcite,@xcite and ref .
@xcite , respectively ) .
it is evident that the inequality @xmath6 can be easily satisfied by choosing a detector with very long integration time . at the same time
, this kind of the detector can not distinguish different signals within the interval @xmath3 .
this means that the resolution of the receiving system might become too low for the case of large @xmath3 . on the other hand
, there is a technical restriction on phase diffusers : up to now their characteristic times , @xmath2 , are not smaller than @xmath7 . besides that , in some specific cases ( see , for example , ref .
@xcite ) , the spectral broadening of laser radiation due to the phase diffuser ( @xmath8 ) may become unacceptably high .
the factors mentioned above impose serious restrictions on the physical characteristics of phase diffusers which could be potentially useful for suppressing the intensity fluctuations .
an adequate choice of diffusers may be facilitated if we know in detail the effect of finite - time phase variation , introduced by them , on the photon statistics . in this case
, it is possible to control the performance of communication systems . in what follows , we will obtain theoretically the dependence of scintillation index on @xmath9 without any restrictions on the value of this ratio
this is the main purpose of our paper .
further analysis is based on the formalism developed in ref .
@xcite and modified here to understand the case of finite - time dynamics of the phase diffuser .
the detectors of the absorbed type do not sense the instantaneous intensity of electromagnetic waves @xmath10 .
they sense the intensity averaged over some finite interval @xmath3 i.e. @xmath11 usually , the averaging time @xmath3 ( the integration time of the detector ) is much smaller than the characteristic time of the turbulence variation , @xmath12 , ( @xmath13 ) .
therefore , the average value of the intensity can be obtained by further averaging of eq .
[ one ] over many measurements corresponding various realizations of the refractive - index configurations .
the scintillation index determining the mean - square fluctuations of the intensity is defined by @xmath14\bigg /\big
< \bar{i}\big > ^2=
\frac{\big < : \bar i(t ) ^2:\big>}{\big<\bar i \big>^2}-1,\ ] ] where the symbol @xmath15 indicates the normal ordering of the creation and annihilation operators which determine the intensity , @xmath10 .
( see more details in refs .
@xcite,@xcite ) . the brackets @xmath16 indicate quantum - mechanical and atmospheric averagings .
the intensity @xmath17 depends not only on @xmath18 , but also on the spatial variable @xmath19 . therefore , the detected intensity is the intensity @xmath20 averaged not only over @xmath18 as in eq .
[ one ] , but also over the detector aperture . for simplicity , we will restrict ourselves to calculations of the intensity correlations for coinciding spatial points that correspond to `` small '' detector aperture .
this simplification is quite reasonable for a long - distance propagation path of the beam . in the case of quasimonochromatic light
, we can choose @xmath20 in the form @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 are the creation and annihilation operators of photons with momentum @xmath24 .
they are given in the heisenberg representation .
@xmath25 is the volume of the system .
it follows from eqs .
[ two],[three ] that @xmath26 can be obtained if one knows the average @xmath27 it is a complex problem to obtain this value for arbitrary turbulence strengths and propagation distances .
nevertheless , the following qualitative reasoning can help to do this in the case of strong turbulence .
we have mentioned that the laser light acquires the properties of gaussian statistics in the course of its propagation through the turbulent atmosphere . as a result , in the limit of infinitely long propagation path , @xmath28 , only
diagonal " terms , i.e. terms with ( i ) @xmath29 or ( ii ) @xmath30 , @xmath31 contribute to the right part of eq . [ four ] . for large but still finite @xmath28
, there exist small ranges of @xmath32 in case ( i ) and @xmath33 , @xmath34 in case ( ii ) contributing into the sum in eq .
the presence of the mentioned regions is due to the two possible ways of correlating of four different waves ( see ref .
@xcite ) which enter the right hand side of eq .
[ four ] . as explained in ref .
@xcite , the characteristic sizes of regions ( i ) and ( ii ) depend on the atmospheric broadening of beam radii as @xmath35 , thus decreasing with increasing @xmath28 . in the case of long - distance propagation , @xmath36 is much smaller than the component of photon wave - vectors perpendicular to the @xmath28 axis .
the last quantity grows with @xmath28 as @xmath37 .
( see ref .
@xcite ) . for this reason ,
the overlapping of regions ( i ) and ( ii ) can be neglected . in this case
eq . [ four ] can be rewritten in the convenient form : @xmath38 @xmath39 where the value @xmath40 , confining summation over @xmath41 , is chosen to be greater than @xmath42 but much smaller than the characteristic transverse wave vector of the photons ; this is consistent with the above explanations .
the two terms in the right - hand side correspond to the two regions of four - wave correlations .
the quantity @xmath43 entering the right side of eq . [ five ] is the operator of photon density in phase space ( the photon distribution function in @xmath44 space ) .
it was used in refs . @xcite,@xcite and
@xcite for the description of photon propagation in turbulent atmospheres . by analogy
, we can define the two - time distribution function @xmath45 then eq . [ five ] can be rewritten in terms of the distribution functions as @xmath46 let us represent @xmath47 in the form @xmath48 .
we assume that @xmath49 , as explained in the text after eq.[one ] . in this case
the hamiltonian of photons in a turbulent atmosphere can be considered to be independent of time . as a result , both functions defined by eqs .
[ six ] and [ seven ] satisfy the same kinetic equation , i.e. @xmath50 @xmath51 where @xmath52 is the photon velocity , @xmath53 is a random force , caused by the turbulence .
this force is equal to @xmath54 , where @xmath55 is the frequency of laser radiation .
@xmath56 is the refractive index of the atmosphere .
the general solution of the equation for @xmath48 can be written in the form @xmath57 where @xmath58 @xmath59 the functions @xmath60 and @xmath61 obey the equations of motion @xmath62 with the boundary conditions @xmath63 .
the instant @xmath64 is equal to @xmath65 , where @xmath66 is the speed of light .
@xmath64 is the time of the exit of photons from the source .
this choice of @xmath64 makes it possible to neglect the influence of the turbulence on the initial values of operators @xmath67 ( their dependence on time is as in vacuum ) .
the term for @xmath68 can be obtained from eq . [ twelve ] by putting @xmath69 . substituting both distribution functions into eq .
[ eight ] , we obtain @xmath70 @xmath71 @xmath72:\big>,\ ] ] where @xmath73 and @xmath74 are solutions of eqs .
[ twelve ] with the initial conditions @xmath63 and @xmath75 , respectively .
the operators on the right side of eq . [ thirteen ] are related through matching conditions with the amplitudes of the exiting laser radiation ( see ref .
@xcite ) by the relation @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the operator of the laser field which is assumed to be a single - mode field and the subscript ( @xmath78 ) means perpendicular to the @xmath28-axis component .
the function @xmath79 describes the profile of the laser mode , which is assumed to be gaussian - type function [ @xmath80 .
@xmath1 desribes the initial radius of the beam . to account for the effect of the phase diffuser
, a factor @xmath81 or @xmath82 should be inserted into the integrand of eq . [ fourteen ] .
the quantity @xmath83 is the random phase introduced by the phase diffuser .
a similar consideration is applicable to each of four photon operators entering both terms in square brackets of eq .
[ thirteen ] .
it can be easily seen that the factor @xmath84},\ ] ] describing the effect of phase screen on the beam , enters implicitly the integrand of eq .
[ thirteen ] ( the indices @xmath78 are omitted here for the sake of brevity ) .
there are integrations over variables @xmath85 as shown in eq .
[ fourteen ] .
furthermore , the brackets @xmath16 , which indicate averaging over different realizations of the atmosperic inhomogeneities , also indicate averaging over different states of the phase diffuser .
as long as both types of averaging do not correlate , the factor ( [ fifteen ] ) entering eq .
[ thirteen ] must be averaged over different instants , @xmath64 . to begin with ,
let us consider the simplest case of two phase correlations @xmath86}\big > .\ ] ] it is evident that in the case @xmath87 , as shown schematically in fig .
1 , the factor ( [ sixteen ] ) is sizable if only points @xmath19 and @xmath88 are close to one another .
two curves correspond to different instants @xmath18 and @xmath89 . ] therefore , the term given by eq .
[ sixteen ] can be replaced by @xmath90 where @xmath91 is considered to be a gaussian random variable with the mean - square values given by @xmath92 ^ 2\rangle = \langle [ \frac { \partial \varphi ( { \bf r},t_0)}{\partial y}]^2\rangle = 2\lambda _ c^{-2}$ ] , where @xmath93 is the correlation length of phase fluctuations . ( see fig.1 ) . as we see , in this case the effect of phase fluctuations can be described by the schell model @xcite-@xcite,@xcite-@xcite . a somewhat more complex situation is for the average value of @xmath94 given by eq . [ fifteen ] .
there is an effective phase correlation not only in the case of coincident times , but also for differing times . for @xmath95 , two different sets of coordinates contribute considerably to phase correlations .
this can be described mathematically as @xmath96}\big > \approx \big < e^{i[\varphi ( { \bf r},t_0)-\varphi ( { \bf r^\prime},t_0)]}\big > \times\ ] ] @xmath97}\big > + \big < e^{i[\varphi ( { \bf r},t_0)-\varphi ( { \bf r^\prime _
1},t_0+\tau ) ] } \big > \big < e^{i[\varphi ( { \bf r_1},t_0+\tau ) -\varphi ( { \bf r^\prime } , t_0)]}\big > .\ ] ] repeating the arguments leading to eq .
[ seventeen ] , we represent the difference in the last term @xmath98 as @xmath99 then , considering the random functions @xmath100 and @xmath101 as independent gaussian variables , we obtain a simple expression for @xmath102 . it is given by @xmath103}+ e^{-\lambda _ c^{-2}[({\bf r - r^\prime}_1)^2+({\bf r^\prime -r_1})^2]-2\nu^2\tau ^2},\ ] ] where @xmath104 ^ 2\rangle = 2\nu^2 $ ] . as we see , the effect of the phase screen can be described by two parameters , @xmath93 and @xmath105 , which characterize the spatial and temporal coherence of the laser beam . in the limiting case , @xmath106 , the second term in eq .
[ twenty ] vanishes and the problem is reduced to the case considered in refs .
@xcite,@xcite . in the opposite case , @xmath107 , both terms in eq .
[ twenty ] are important .
this is shown in ref .
@xcite . in
what follows , we will see that these two limiting cases have physical interpretations where where @xmath108 ( slow detector ) and @xmath109 ( fast detector ) , respectively .
there is a specific realization of the diffuser in which a random phase distribution moves across the beam .
( this situation can be modeled by a rotating transparent disk with large diameter and varying thickness . )
the phase depends here on the only variable @xmath110 , i.e. @xmath111 where @xmath112 is the velocity of the drift .
then we have @xmath113}+e^{-\lambda _ c^{-2}[({\bf r - r^\prime_1+v}\tau)^2+({\bf r^\prime -r_1+v}\tau)^2]}.\ ] ] comparing eqs .
[ twenty ] and [ twtw ] , we see that the quantity , @xmath114 , stands for the characteristic parameter describing the efficiency of the phase diffuser .
the criterion of slow " detector requires @xmath115 .
qualitatively , the two scenarios of phase variations , given by eqs . [ twenty ] and [ twtw ] , affect in a similar way the intensity fluctuations . in what follows
, we consider the first of them as the simplest one .
( this is because the spatial and temporal variables in @xmath102 , given by eq . [
twenty ] , are separable . )
_ vs _ propagation distance @xmath28 in the case of `` slow '' detector : @xmath116 .
the parameter @xmath117 indicates different initial coherence length . in the absence of phase diffuser @xmath118 ( solid line ) .
@xmath119 is the conventional parameter describing a strength of the atmospheric turbulence . ]
substituting the expressions for operators given by eq .
[ fourteen ] with account for the phase factors @xmath120 and averaging over time as shown in eq .
[ one ] , we obtain @xmath121 @xmath122\bigg > , \ ] ] where the notation @xmath16 after sums indicates averaging over different realizations of the atmospheric refractive index .
the parameter @xmath123 describes the initial coherence length modified by the phase diffuser .
other notations are defined by following relations @xmath124
@xmath125 @xmath126 further calculations follow the scheme described in ref @xcite .
2 illustrates the effect of the phase diffuser on scintillations in the limit of a slow " detector ( @xmath127 ) .
we can see a considerable decrease in @xmath128 caused by the phase diffuser . at the same time , the effect of the phase screen on @xmath128 becomes weaker for finite values of @xmath129 .
moreover , comparing the two upper curves in fig .
3 , we see the opposite effect : slow phase variations ( @xmath130 ) result in increased scintillations .
there is a simple explanation for this phenomenon : the noise generated by the turbulence is complemented by the noise arising from the random phase screen .
the integration time of the detector , @xmath3 , is not sufficiently large for averaging phase variations generated by the diffuser .
the function , @xmath131 , has a very simple form in the two limits : ( i)@xmath132 , when @xmath133 ; and ( ii ) @xmath134 , when @xmath109 .
then , in case ( i ) and for small values of the initial coherence [ @xmath135 , the asymptotic term for the scintillation index ( @xmath136 ) is given by @xmath137 the right - hand side of eq .
[ twfo ] differs from analogous one in ref .
@xcite by the value @xmath138 that is much less than unity but , nevertheless , can be comparable or even greater than @xmath139 . in case ( ii )
, the asymptotic value of @xmath26 is close to unity , coinciding with the results of refs . @xcite and @xcite .
this agrees with well known behavior of the scintillation index to approach unity for any source distribution , provided the response time of the recording instrument is short compared with the source coherence time .
( see , for example , survey @xcite ) .
a similar tendency can be seen in both figs . 3 and 4 : the curves with the smallest @xmath129 , used for numerical calculations ( @xmath130 ) , are close to the curves without diffuser " in spite of the small initial coherence length [ @xmath140 .
it can also be seen that all curves approach their asymptotic values very slowly .
describing diffuser dynamics .
the solid curve is calculated for @xmath118 ( without diffuser ) .
other curves are for @xmath141 . ] . ]
it follows from our analysis that the scintillation index is very sensitive to the diffuser parameters , @xmath0 and @xmath142 , for long propagation paths .
on the other hand , the characteristics of the irradience such as beam radius , @xmath143 , and angle - of - arrival spread , @xmath144 , do not depend on the presence of the phase diffuser for large values of @xmath28 . to see this , the following analysis is useful .
the beam radius expressed in terms of the distribution function is given by @xmath145 straightforward calculations using eq .
[ ten ] with @xmath69 ( see ref .
@xcite ) result in the following explicit form : @xmath146 where @xmath147 and @xmath148 is the inner radius of turbulent eddies , which in our previous calculations was assumed to be equal @xmath149 m . as we see , the third term does not depend on the diffuser parameters and it dominates when @xmath150 .
a similar situation holds for the angle - of - arrival spread , @xmath144 .
( this physical quantity is of great importance for the performance of communication systems based on frequency encoded information @xcite . )
it is defined by the distribution function as @xmath151 simple calculations , which are very similar to those while obtaining @xmath152 , result in @xmath153 ^ 2=\frac 2{r_1 ^ 2q_0 ^ 2}+12tz-\frac { 4z^2}{q_0 ^ 4r^2}(r_1^{-2}+3tq_0 ^ 2z)^2.\ ] ] for long propagation paths ,
. [ twei ] reduces to @xmath154 , which like @xmath152 does not depend on the diffuser parameters .
as we see , for large distances @xmath28 , the quantities @xmath152 and @xmath144 do not depend on @xmath93 and @xmath105 .
this contrasts with the case of the scintillation index .
so pronounced differences can be explained by differences in the physical nature of these characteristics .
it follows from eq .
[ two ] that the functional , @xmath26 , is quadratic in the distribution function , @xmath155 .
hence , four - wave correlations determine the value of scintillation index .
the main effect of a phase diffuser on @xmath26 is to destroy correlations between waves exited at different times .
( see more explanations in ref .
this is achieved at sufficiently small parameters @xmath93 and @xmath156 .
in contrast , @xmath152 and @xmath144 depend on two wave - correlations , both waves being given at the same instant .
therefore , the values of @xmath152 and @xmath144 do not depend on the rate of phase variations [ @xmath105 does not enter the factor ( [ seventeen ] ) describing the effect of phase diffuser ] .
moreover , these quantities become independent of @xmath93 at long propagation paths because light scattering on atmospheric inhomogeneities prevails in this case .
the plots in figs .
3 anf 4 show that the finite - time effect is quite sizable even for very slow " detectors ( @xmath157 ) .
our paper makes it possible to estimate the actual utility of phase diffusers in several physical regimes .
we have analyzed the effects of a diffuser on scintillations for the case of large - amplitude phase fluctuations .
this specific case is very convenient for theoretial analysis because only two parameters are required to describe the effects of the diffuser .
phase fluctuations may occur independently in space as well as in time .
also , our formalism can be applied for the physical situation in which a spatially random phase distribution drifts across the beam .
[ twtw ] . )
our results show the importance of both parameters , @xmath93 and @xmath142 , on the ability of a phase diffuser to suppress scintillations .
this work was carried out under the auspices of the national nuclear security administration of the u.s .
department of energy at los alamos national laboratory under contract no .
de - ac52 - 06na25396 .
we thank onr for supporting this research .
|
the effect of a random phase diffuser on fluctuations of laser light ( scintillations ) is studied .
not only spatial but also temporal phase variations introduced by the phase diffuser are analyzed .
the explicit dependence of the scintillation index on finite - time phase variations is obtained for long propagation paths .
it is shown that for large amplitudes of phase fluctuations , a finite - time effect decreases the ability of phase diffuser to suppress the scintillations .
|
the so - called `` nucleon spin crisis '' raised by the european muon collaboration ( emc ) measurement in 1988 is one of the most outstanding findings in the field of hadron physics @xcite,@xcite .
the renaissance of the physics of high energy deep inelastic scatterings is greatly indebted to this epoch - making finding .
probably , one of the most outstanding progresses achieved recently in this field of physics is the discovery and the subsequent research of completely new observables called generalized parton distribution functions ( gpd ) .
it has been revealed that the gpds , which can be measured through the so - called deeply - virtual compton scatterings ( dvcs ) or the deeply - virtual meson productions ( dvmp ) , contain surprisingly richer information than the standard parton distribution functions @xcite@xcite .
roughly speaking , the gpds are generalization of ordinary parton distributions and the elastic form factors of the nucleon .
the gpds in the most general form are functions of three kinematical variables : the average longitudinal momentum fraction @xmath1 of the struck parton in the initial and final states , a skewdness parameter @xmath3 which measures the difference between two momentum fractions , and the four - momentum - transfer square @xmath4 of the initial and final nucleon . in the forward limit @xmath5 ,
some of the gpds reduce to the usual quark , antiquark and gluon distributions .
on the other hand , taking the @xmath0-th moment of the gpds with respect to the variable @xmath1 , one obtains the generalizations of the electromagnetic form factors of the nucleon , which are called the generalized form factors of the nucleon .
the complex nature of the gpds , i.e. the fact that they are functions of three variable , makes it quite difficult to grasp their full characteristics both experimentally and theoretically . from the theoretical viewpoint
, it may be practical to begin studies with the two limiting cases .
the one is the forward limit of zero momentum transfer .
we have mentioned that , in this limit , some of the gpds reduce to the ordinary parton distribution function depending on one variable @xmath1 .
however , it turns out that , even in this limit , there appear some completely new distribution functions , which can not be accessed by the ordinary inclusive deep - inelastic scattering measurements .
very interestingly , it was shown by ji that one of such distributions contains valuable information on the total angular momentum carried by the quark fields in the nucleon @xcite@xcite .
this information , combined with the known knowledge on the longitudinal quark polarization , makes it possible to determine the quark orbital angular momentum contribution to the total nucleon spin purely experimentally .
another relatively - easy - to - handle quantities are the generalized form factors of the nucleon @xcite,@xcite , which are given as the non - forward nucleon matrix elements of the spin-@xmath0 , twist - two quark and gluon operators .
since these latter quantities are given as the nucleon matrix elements of local operators , they can be objects of lattice qcd simulations .
( it should be compared with parton distributions .
the direct calculation of parton distributions is beyond the scope of lattice qcd simulations , since it needs to treat the nucleon matrix elements of quark bilinears , which are _ nonlocal in time_. ) in fact , two groups , the lhpc collaboration and the qcdsf collaboration independently investigated the generalized form factors of the nucleon , and gave several interesting predictions , which can in principle be tested by the measurement of gpds in the near future @xcite@xcite . although interesting , there is no _ a priori _ reason to believe that the predictions of these lattice simulations are realistic enough .
the reason is mainly that the above mentioned lattice simulation were carried out in the heavy pion regime around @xmath6 with neglect of the so - called disconnected diagrams .
our real world is rather close to the chiral limit with vanishing pion mass , and we know that , in this limit , the goldstone pion plays very important roles in some intrinsic properties of the nucleon .
the lattice simulation carried out in the heavy pion region is in danger of missing some important role of chiral dynamics . on the other hand ,
the chiral quark soliton model ( cqsm ) is an effective model of baryons , which maximally incorporates the chiral symmetry of qcd and its spontaneous breakdown @xcite,@xcite .
( see @xcite@xcite for early reviews . )
it was already applied to the physics of ordinary parton distribution functions with remarkable success @xcite@xcite . for instance , an indispensable role of pion - like quark - antiquark correlation was shown to be essential to understand the famous nmc measurement , which revealed the dominance of the @xmath7-quark over the @xmath8-quark inside the proton @xcite,@xcite,@xcite .
then , it would be interesting to see what predictions the cqsm would give for the quantities mentioned above .
now , the main purpose of the present study is to study the generalized form factors of the nucleon within the framework of the cqsm and compare its predictions with those of the lattice qcd simulations . of our particular interest here
is to see the change of final theoretical predictions against the variation of the pion mass .
such an analysis is expected to give some hints for judging the reliability of the lattice qcd predictions at the present level for the observables in question .
the plan of the paper is as follows . in sect.ii
, we shall briefly explain how to introduce the nonzero pion mass into the scheme of the cqsm with pauli - villars regularization . in sect.iii
, we derive the theoretical expressions for the generalized form factors of the nucleon .
sect.iv is devoted to the discussion of the results of the numerical calculations .
some concluding remarks are then given in sect.v .
we start with the basic effective lagrangian of the chiral quark soliton model in the chiral limit given as @xmath9 with @xmath10 which describes the effective quark fields , with a dynamically generated mass @xmath11 , strongly interacting with pions @xcite,@xcite .
since one of the main purposes of the present study is to see how the relevant observables depend on pion mass , we add to @xmath12 an explicit chiral symmetry breaking term @xmath13 given by @xcite @xmath14 .
\label{eq : lsb}\ ] ] here the trace in ( [ eq : lsb ] ) is to be taken with respect to flavor indices .
the total model lagrangian is therefore given by @xmath15 naturally , one could have taken an alternative choice in which the explicit chiral - symmetry - breaking effect is introduced in the form of current quark mass term as @xmath16 .
we did not do so , because we do not know any consistent regularization of such effective lagrangian with finite current quark mass within the framework of the pauli - villars subtraction scheme , as explained in appendix of @xcite .
the effective action corresponding to the above lagrangian is given as @xmath17 = s_f [ u ] + s_m [ u ] , \label{eq : energsol}\ ] ] with @xmath18 = - \,i \,n_c \,\mbox{sp } \
, \ln ( i \not\!\partial - m u^{\gamma_5 } ) , \ ] ] and @xmath19 = \int \frac{1}{4 } \,f_{\pi}^2 \,m_{\pi}^2 \ , \mbox{tr}_f \ , [ u ( x ) + u^{\dagger } ( x ) - 2 ] \,d^4 x .\ ] ] here @xmath20 with @xmath21 and @xmath22 representing the trace of the dirac gamma matrices and the flavors ( isospins ) , respectively .
the fermion ( quark ) part of the above action contains ultra - violet divergences . to remove these divergences , we must introduce physical cutoffs . for the purpose of regularization , here we use the pauli - villars subtraction scheme . as explained in @xcite ,
we must eliminate not only the logarithmic divergence contained in @xmath23 $ ] but also the quadratic and logarithmic divergence contained in the equation of motion shown below .
to get rid of all these troublesome divergence , we need at least two subtraction terms .
the regularized action is thus defined as @xmath24 = s_f^{reg } [ u ] + s_m [ u ] , \ ] ] where @xmath25 = s_f [ u ] - \sum_{i = 1}^2 \,c_i \,s_f^{\lambda _ i } [ u ] .\ ] ] here @xmath26 is obtained from @xmath27 $ ] with @xmath11 replaced by the pauli - villars regulator mass @xmath28 .
these parameters are fixed as follows .
first , the quadratic and logarithmic divergence contained in the equation of motion ( or in the expression of the vacuum quark condensate ) can , respectively , removed if the subtraction constants satisfy the following two conditions : @xmath29 ( we recall that the condition which removes the logarithmic divergence in @xmath23 $ ] just coincides with the 1st of the above conditions . ) by solving the above equations for @xmath30 and @xmath31 , we obtain @xmath32 which constrains the values of @xmath30 and @xmath31 , once @xmath33 and @xmath34 are given . for determining @xmath33 and @xmath34
, we use two conditions @xmath35 and @xmath36 which amounts to reproducing the correct normalization of the pion kinetic term in the effective meson lagrangian and also the empirical value of the vacuum quark condensate . to derive soliton equation of motion , we must first write down a regularized expression for the static soliton energy . under the hedgehog ansatz @xmath37 for the background pion fields ,
it is obtained in the form : @xmath38 = e_f^{reg } [ f ( r ) ] + e_m [ f ( r ) ] , \ ] ] where the meson ( pion ) part is given by @xmath39 = - \,f_{\pi}^2 \,m_{\pi}^2 \int d^3 x \,[\cos f ( r ) - 1 ] , \ ] ] while the fermion ( quark ) part is given as @xmath40 = e_{val } + e_{v p}^{reg } , \label{eq : estatic}\ ] ] with @xmath41 here @xmath42 are the quark single - particle energies , given as the eigenvalues of the static dirac hamiltonian in the background pion fields : @xmath43 with @xmath44 , \label{eq : dirach}\ ] ] while @xmath45 denote energy eigenvalues of the vacuum hamiltonian given by ( [ eq : dirach ] ) with @xmath46 ( or @xmath47 ) . the particular state @xmath48 , which is a discrete bound - state orbital coming from the upper dirac continuum under the influence of the hedgehog mean field , is called the valence level .
the symbol @xmath49 in ( [ eq : regenerg ] ) denotes the summation over all the negative energy eigenstates of @xmath50 , i.e. the negative energy dirac continuum .
the soliton equation of motion is obtained from the stationary condition of @xmath51 $ ] with respect to the variation of the profile function @xmath52 : @xmath53 \nonumber \\ & = & 4 \pi r^2 \,\left\ { - \,m \,[s ( r ) \sin f ( r ) - p ( r ) \cos f ( r ) ] + f_{\pi}^2 m_{\pi}^2 \sin f ( r ) \right\ } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which gives @xmath54 here @xmath55 and @xmath56 are regularized scalar and pseudoscalar quark densities given as @xmath57 with @xmath58 while @xmath59 and @xmath60 are the corresponding densities evaluated with the regulator mass @xmath28 instead of the dynamical quark mass @xmath11 .
we also note that @xmath61 and @xmath62 . as usual
, a self - consistent soliton solution is obtained as follows with use of kahana and ripka s discretized momentum basis @xcite,@xcite .
first by assuming an appropriate ( though arbitrary ) soliton profile @xmath52 , the eigenvalue problem of the dirac hamiltonian is solved . using the resultant eigenfunctions and their associated eigenenergies
, one can calculate the regularized scalar and pseudoscalar densities @xmath55 and @xmath56 .
with use of these @xmath63 and @xmath64 , eq.([eq : profile ] ) can then be used to obtain a new soliton profile @xmath52 .
the whole procedure above is repeated with this new profile @xmath52 until the self - consistency is attained .
since the generalized form factors of the nucleon are given as moments of generalized parton distributions ( gpds ) , it is convenient to start with the theoretical expressions of the unpolarized gpds @xmath65 and @xmath66 within the cqsm . following the notation in @xcite,@xcite
, we introduce the quantities @xmath67 and @xmath68 here , the isoscalar and isovector combinations respectively correspond to the sum and the difference of the quark flavors @xmath69 and @xmath70 . the relation between these quantities and the generalized parton distribution functions @xmath71 and @xmath72
are obtained most conveniently in the so - called breit frame .
they are given by @xmath73 where @xmath74 these two independent combinations of @xmath65 and @xmath66 can be extracted through the spin projection of @xmath75 as @xmath76 where tr " denotes the trace over spin indices , while @xmath77 .
now , within the cqsm , it is possible to evaluate the right - hand side ( rhs ) of ( [ eq : hetrace ] ) and ( [ eq : emtrace ] ) .
since the answers are already given in several previous papers @xcite@xcite , we do not repeat the derivation . here
we comment only on the following general structure of the theoretical expressions for relevant observables in the cqsm .
the leading contribution just corresponds to the mean field prediction , which is independent of the collective rotational velocity @xmath78 of the hedgehog soliton .
the next - to - leading order term takes account of the linear response of the internal quark motion to the rotational motion as an external perturbation , and consequently it is proportional to @xmath78 .
it is known that the leading - order term contributes to the isoscalar combination of @xmath79 and to the isovector combination of @xmath80 , while the isoscalar part of @xmath79 and the isovector part of @xmath80 survived only at the next - to - leading order of @xmath78 ( or of @xmath81 ) .
the leading - order gpds are then given as @xmath82 here the symbol @xmath83 denotes the summation over the occupied ( the valence plus negative - energy dirac sea ) quark orbitals in the hedgehog mean field . on the other hand ,
the theoretical expressions for the isovector part of @xmath84 and the isoscalar part of @xmath85 , which survive at the next - to - leading order , are a little more complicated .
they are given as double sums over the single quark orbitals as @xmath86 \
, e^{i x m_n z^0 } \nonumber \\ & \ , & \hspace{30 mm } \times \ \langle n | \tau^a | m \rangle \langle m | \,\tau^a \,(1 + \gamma^0 \gamma^3 ) \ , e^{-i ( z^0/2 ) \hat{p}_3 } \ , e^{i { \mbox{\boldmath$\delta$ } } \cdot { \mbox{\boldmath$x$ } } } \,e^{-i ( z^0/2 ) \hat{p}_3 } | n \rangle .
\label{eq : gpdheiv}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath87 e^{i x m_n z^0 } \nonumber \\ & \ , & \hspace{25 mm } \times \ \langle n | \tau^b | m \rangle \langle m | \,(1 + \gamma^0 \gamma^3 ) \,e^{-i ( z^0/2 ) \hat{p}_3 } \ , \frac{\varepsilon^{3 a b }
\delta^a}{{\mbox{\boldmath$\delta$}}_{\perp}^2 } \ , e^{i { \mbox{\boldmath$\delta$ } } \cdot { \mbox{\boldmath$x$ } } } \,e^{-i ( z^0/2 ) \hat{p}_3 } | n \rangle .
\label{eq : gpdemiv}\end{aligned}\ ] ] these four expressions for the unpolarized gpds , i.e. ( [ eq : gpdheis ] ) @xmath88 ( [ eq : gpdemiv ] ) , are the basic starting equations for our present study of the generalized form factors of the nucleon within the cqsm .
there are infinite tower of generalized form factors , which are defined as the @xmath0-th moments of gpds . in the present study ,
we confine ourselves to the 1st and the 2nd moments , which respectively corresponds to the standard electromagnetic form factors of the nucleon and the so - called gravitational form factors .
we are especially interested in the second one , since they are believed to contain valuable information on the spin contents of the nucleon through ji s angular momentum sum rule @xcite,@xcite . for each isospin channel , the 1st and the 2nd moments of @xmath89 define the sachs - electric and gravito - electric form factors as @xmath90 and @xmath91 on the other hand , the 1st and the 2nd moments of @xmath92 respectively define the sachs - magnetic and gravito - magnetic form factors as @xmath93 and @xmath94 in the following , we shall explain how we can calculate the generalized form factors based on the theoretical expressions of corresponding gpds , by taking @xmath95 and @xmath96 as examples .
setting @xmath97 and integrating over @xmath98 in ( [ eq : gpdheis ] ) , we obtain @xmath99 putting this expression into ( [ eq : ge10def ] ) , we have @xmath100 it is easy to see that , using the generalized spherical symmetry of the hedgehog configuration , the term containing the factor @xmath101 identically vanishes , so that @xmath102 is reduced to a simple form as follows : @xmath103 aside from the factor @xmath104 , this is nothing but the known expression for the isoscalar sachs - electric form factor of the nucleon in the cqsm @xcite .
a less trivial example is @xmath96 , which is defined as the 2nd moment of @xmath105 . inserting ( [ eq : heis ] ) into ( [ eq : ge10def ] ) and carrying out the integration over @xmath1 ,
we obtain @xmath106 using the partial - wave expansion of @xmath107 , this can be written as @xmath108 this can further be divided into four pieces as @xmath109 where @xmath110 with @xmath111 to proceed further , we first notice that , by using the generalized spherical symmetry , @xmath112 survives only when @xmath113 , i.e. @xmath114 which leads to the result : @xmath115 to evaluate @xmath116 , we first note that @xmath117^{(\lambda ) } .\ ] ] here , the generalized spherical symmetry dictates that @xmath118 must be zero , so that the rhs of the above equation is effectively reduced to @xmath119^{(0 ) } .\ ] ] this then gives @xmath120^{(0 ) } \ , \phi_n ( { \mbox{\boldmath$x$ } } ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] owing to the identity @xmath121 we therefore find that @xmath122 next we investigate the third term @xmath123 . using @xmath124^{(\lambda ) }
\ \sim \ - \,\frac{1}{\sqrt{3 } } \,\delta_{l,1 } \,\delta_{m,0 } \ , [ y_1 ( \hat{x } ) \times \hat{{\mbox{\boldmath$p$ } } } ] ^{(0 ) } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] we obtain @xmath125^{(0 ) } \ , \phi_n ( { \mbox{\boldmath$x$ } } ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] this term vanishes by the same reason as @xmath116 does .
the last term @xmath126 is a little more complicated .
we first notice that @xmath127^{(\lambda)}_0 \nonumber \\ & \sim & \sum_{\lambda } \ , \langle 1 0 1 0 | \lambda 0 \rangle \ , \langle l m \lambda 0 | 00 \rangle \ , [ y_l ( \hat{x } ) \times [ { \mbox{\boldmath$\alpha$ } } \times \hat{{\mbox{\boldmath$p$ } } } ] ^{(\lambda ) } ] ^{(0 ) } \nonumber \\ & = & \delta_{m , 0 } \,\langle 1 0 1 0 | l 0 \rangle \
, \langle l 0 l 0 | 0 0 \rangle \ , [ y_l ( \hat{x } ) \times [ { \mbox{\boldmath$ \alpha$ } } \times \hat{{\mbox{\boldmath$p$ } } } ] ^{(l ) } ] ^{(0 ) } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which dictates that @xmath128 must be 0 or 2 . inserting the above expression into ( [ eq : m4 ] ) , and using the explicit values of clebsch - gordan coefficients
, @xmath126 becomes @xmath129^{(0 ) } \ , \phi_n ( { \mbox{\boldmath$x$ } } ) \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{\sqrt{4 \pi}}{\sqrt{6 } } \cdot \frac{n_c}{m_n } \int d^3 x \,\sum_{n \leq 0 } \,\phi_n^{\dagger } ( { \mbox{\boldmath$x$ } } ) \
, j_2 ( \delta_{\perp } x ) \ , [ y_2 ( \hat{x } ) \times [ { \mbox{\boldmath$\alpha$ } } \times \hat{{\mbox{\boldmath$p$ } } } ] ^{(2 ) } ] ^{(0 ) } \ , \phi_n ( { \mbox{\boldmath$x$ } } ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the identities @xmath130^{(0 ) } & = & -\frac{1}{\sqrt{3 } } { \mbox{\boldmath$\alpha$ } } \cdot \hat{{\mbox{\boldmath$p$ } } } , \\ \ , [ y_2 ( \hat{x } ) \times [ { \mbox{\boldmath$\alpha$ } } \times { \mbox{\boldmath$p$ } } ] ^{(2 ) } ] ^{(0 ) } & = & [ [ y_2 ( \hat{x } ) \times \hat{{\mbox{\boldmath$p$ } } } ] ^{(1 ) } \times { \mbox{\boldmath$\alpha$ } } ] ^{(0 ) } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath126 can also be written as @xmath131^{(1 ) } \times { \mbox{\boldmath$\alpha$ } } ] ^{(0 ) } \ , \phi_n ( { \mbox{\boldmath$x$ } } ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] collecting the answers for @xmath132 and @xmath126 , we finally obtain @xmath133^{(1 ) } \times { \mbox{\boldmath$\alpha$ } } ] ^{(0 ) } \,\phi_n ( { \mbox{\boldmath$x$ } } ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] up to now , we have obtained the theoretical expressions for the isoscalar combination of the generalized form factors @xmath95 and @xmath96 .
for notational convenience , we summarize these results in a little more compact forms as follows : @xmath134 and @xmath135^{(1 ) } \times { \mbox{\boldmath$\alpha$ } } ] ^{(0 ) } \ , | n \rangle \right\ } .
\label{eq : inthe20is}\end{aligned}\ ] ] as pointed out before , @xmath95 is @xmath104 times the isoscalar combination of standard sachs - electric form factor of the nucleon .
analogously , we may call @xmath96 the gravitoelectric form factor of the nucleon ( its quark part ) , since it is related to the nonforward nucleon matrix elements of the quark part of the qcd energy momentum tensor .
the other generalized form factors can be obtained in a similar way .
the isovector part of the generalized electric form factors survive only at the next - to - leading order of @xmath78 .
they are given as @xmath136 and @xmath137^{(1 ) } \times { \mbox{\boldmath$\alpha$ } } ] ^{(0 ) } \,{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$ } } \,|| n \rangle \right\ } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the isoscalar combination of the generalized magnetic form factors also survive only at the next - to - leading order of @xmath78 , so that they are given as double sums over the single - quark orbitals in the hedgehog mean field as @xmath138 and @xmath139 we recall that @xmath140 just coincides with the known expression of the isoscalar sachs - magnetic form factor of the nucleon in the cqsm @xcite . on the other hand , @xmath141
is sometimes called the gravitomagnetic form factor of the nucleon ( its isoscalar part ) , which we can evaluate within the qcsm based on the above theoretical expression .
finally , the leading - order contribution to the isovector part of the generalized magnetic form factors are given as @xmath142 and @xmath143 especially interesting to us are the values of the generalized form factors in the forward limit @xmath5 .
the consideration of this limit is also useful for verifying consistency of our theoretical analyses , since it leads to fundamental sum rules discussed below .
we first consider the forward limit of @xmath95 . from ( [ eq : inthe10is ] ) , we find that @xmath144 subtracting the corresponding vacuum contribution , this reduces to @xmath145 .
if we remember the relation @xmath146 the forward limit of ( [ eq : inthe10is ] ) just leads to the sum rule : @xmath147 which denotes that the sum of the @xmath69-quark and @xmath70-quark numbers in the proton is three .
next we turn to the forward limit of @xmath96 , which gives @xmath148 it is easy to see that , after regularization and vacuum subtraction , the first term of the rhs of the above equation reduces to the fermion ( quark ) part of the soliton energy , i.e. @xmath149 in ( [ eq : estatic ] ) .
it was proved in @xcite that , in the cqsm with vanishing pion mass , the following identity holds : @xmath150 in the case of finite pion mass , which we are handling , this identity does not hold . instead
, we can prove ( see appendix ) that @xmath151 that is , the second term in the parenthesis of rhs of eq.([eq : momsum ] ) just coincides with the pion part of the soliton energy ( or mass ) . since the sum of the quark and pion part
give the total soliton mass @xmath152 , we then find that @xmath153 in consideration of eq.([eq : inthe20is ] ) , this relation can also be expressed as @xmath154 which means that the total momentum fraction carried by quark fields ( the @xmath69- and @xmath70-quarks ) is just unity .
this is an expected result , since the cqsm contains quark fields only ( note that the pion is not an independent field of quarks ) , so that the total nucleon momentum should be saturated by the quark fields alone . taking the forward limit of @xmath155
, we are again led to a trivial sum rule , constrained by the conservation low .
in fact , we have @xmath156 thereby leading to @xmath157 which denotes that the difference of the @xmath69-quark and the @xmath70-quark numbers in the proton is just unity .
on the other hand , the forward limit of @xmath158 leads to the first nontrivial sum rule as @xmath159 since this quantity , which represents the difference of momentum fraction carried by the @xmath69-quark and the @xmath70-quark in the proton , is not constrained by any conservation law , its actual value can be estimated only numerically .
next we turn to the discussion of the forward limit of the generalized magnetic form factors .
first , the forward limit of @xmath140 gives @xmath160 which reproduces the known expression of the isoscalar magnetic moment of the nucleon in the cqsm @xcite . on the other hand ,
the forward limit of @xmath141 gives @xmath161 it was shown in @xcite that the rhs of the above equation is just unity , i.e. @xmath162 in consideration of ( [ eq : gm2nd ] ) , this identity can be recast into a little different form as @xmath163 \,d x .\end{aligned}\ ] ] assuming the familiar angular momentum sum rule due to ji @xmath164 \,d x = j^{u + d } , \ ] ] the above identity claims that @xmath165 which means that the nucleon spin is saturated by the quark fields alone .
this is again a reasonable result , because the cqsm is an effective quark model which contains no explicit gluon fields .
the derived identity ( [ eq : gm20ist0 ] ) has still another interpretation .
remembering the fact that @xmath141 consists of two parts as @xmath166 eq.([eq : gm20ist0 ] ) dictates that @xmath167 since it also holds that ( the momentum sum rule ) @xmath168 it immediately follows that @xmath169 which is interpreted as showing the absence of the _ net quark contribution to the anomalous gravitomagnetic moment of the nucleon_. finally , we investigate the forward limit of the isovector combination of the generalized magnetic form factors . from eq .
( [ eq : mgivform ] ) , we get @xmath170 which reproduces the known expression of the isovector magnetic form factor of the nucleon in the cqsm . on the other hand , letting @xmath5 in ( [ eq : mg2ivform ] ) , we have @xmath171 as shown in @xcite , this sum rule can be recast into the form : @xmath172 where @xmath173 consists of two parts as @xmath174 here , the first part is given as a proton matrix element of the _ free field expression _ for the isovector total angular momentum operator of quark fields as @xmath175 with @xmath176 \ , \psi ( { \mbox{\boldmath$x$ } } ) \,d^3 x \nonumber \\ & = & \hat{l}_f^{(i = 1 ) } + \frac{1}{2 } \,\hat{\sigma}^{(i = 1 ) } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] on the other hand ,
the second term is given as @xmath177 | n \rangle .\ ] ]
the model in the chiral limit contains two parameters , the weak pion decay constant @xmath178 and the dynamical quark mass @xmath11 . as usual , @xmath178 is fixed to its physical value , i.e. @xmath179 . for the mass parameter @xmath11 , there is some argument based on the instanton liquid picture of the qcd vacuum that it is not extremely far from @xmath180 @xcite .
the previous phenomenological analysis of various static baryon observables based on this model prefer a slightly larger value of @xmath11 between @xmath180 and @xmath181 @xcite@xcite . in the present analysis ,
we use the value @xmath182 . with this value of @xmath182 , we prepare self - consistent soliton solutions for seven values of @xmath183 , i.e. @xmath184 and @xmath185 , in order to see the pion mass dependence of the generalized form factors etc .
favorable physical predictions of the model will be obtained by using the value of @xmath182 and @xmath186 , since this set gives a self - consistent soliton solution close to the phenomenologically successful one obtained with @xmath187 and @xmath188 in the single - subtraction pauli - villars regularization scheme @xcite@xcite .
we first show in fig.[fig : profile ] the soliton profile functions @xmath52 obtained with several values of @xmath183 , i.e. @xmath189 , and @xmath185 .
one sees that the spatial size of the soliton profile becomes more and more compact as the pion mass increases . and
@xmath190 , and @xmath185.,width=340,height=264 ] we are now ready to show the theoretical predictions of the cqsm for the generalized form factors .
since the corresponding lattice predictions are given for the generalized form factors @xmath191 and @xmath192 , which are the generalization of the standard dirac and pauli form factors , we first write down the relations between these form factors and the generalized sachs - type factors , which we have calculated in the cqsm .
they are given by @xmath193 \,/\ , ( 1 + \tau ) , \\
a_{20}^{u + d } ( t ) & = & \left[\ , g_{e , 20}^{(i = 0 ) } ( t ) + \tau \ , g_{m , 20}^{(i = 0 ) } ( t ) \right ] \,/\ , ( 1 + \tau ) , \\
a_{10}^{u - d } ( t ) & = & \left[\ , g_{e , 10}^{(i = 1 ) } ( t ) + \tau \ , g_{m , 10}^{(i = 1 ) } ( t ) \right ] \,/\ , ( 1 + \tau ) , \\
a_{20}^{u - d } ( t ) & = & \left[\ , g_{e , 20}^{(i = 1 ) } ( t ) + \tau \ , g_{m , 20}^{(i = 1 ) } ( t ) \right ] \,/\ , ( 1 + \tau ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath194 \,/\ , ( 1 + \tau ) , \\ b_{20}^{u + d } ( t ) & = & \left[\ , g_{m , 10}^{(i = 0 ) } ( t ) - g_{e , 20}^{(i = 0 ) } ( t ) \right ] \,/\ , ( 1 + \tau ) , \\ b_{10}^{u - d } ( t ) & = & \left[\ , g_{m , 10}^{(i = 1 ) } ( t ) - g_{e , 10}^{(i = 1 ) } ( t ) \right ] \,/\ , ( 1 + \tau ) , \\
b_{20}^{u - d } ( t ) & = & \left[\ , g_{m , 20}^{(i = 1 ) } ( t ) - g_{e , 20}^{(i = 1 ) } ( t ) \right ] \,/\ , ( 1 + \tau ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath195 .
we recall that @xmath196 and @xmath197 are nothing but the standard dirac and pauli form factors of the nucleon : @xmath198 since the lattice simulations by the lhpc and qcdsf collaborations were carried out in the heavy pion region around @xmath199 and since the simulation in the small pion mass region is hard to perform , we think it interesting to investigate the pion mass dependence of the generalized form factors within the framework of the cqsm . for simplicity
, we shall show the pion mass dependence of the generalized form factors at the zero momentum transfer only .
we think it enough for our purpose because the generalized form factors at the zero momentum transfer contain the most important information for clarifying the underlying spin structure of the nucleon . at zero momentum transfer ,
the relations between the generalized dirac and pauli form factors and the generalized sachs - type form factors are simplified to become @xmath200 and @xmath201 and @xmath202 as functions of @xmath183 ( the filled diamonds ) , together with the corresponding lattice predictions . here
, the open triangles correspond to the predictions of the lhpc group @xcite , while the open squares to those of the qcdsf collaboration @xcite.,width=604,height=264 ] fig.[fig : a1020is ] shows the predictions of the cqsm for @xmath203 and @xmath202 as functions of @xmath183 , together with the corresponding lattice predictions . as for @xmath203 ,
the cqsm predictions and the lattice qcd predictions are both independent of @xmath183 and consistent with the constraint of the quark number sum rule : @xmath204 with high numerical precision . turning to @xmath202 ,
one finds a sizable difference between the predictions of the cqsm and of the lattice qcd .
the lattice qcd predicts that @xmath205 which means that only about @xmath206 of the total nucleon momentum is carried by the quark fields , while the rest is borne by the gluon fields . on the other hand , the cqsm predictions for the same quantity
is @xmath207 which means that the quark fields saturates the total nucleon momentum .
this may certainly be a limitation of an effective quark model , which contains no explicit gluon fields .
note , however , that the total quark momentum fraction @xmath202 is a scale dependent quantity .
the lattice result corresponds to the energy scale of @xmath208 @xcite , while the cqsm prediction should be taken as that of the model energy scale around @xmath209 @xcite .
we shall later make more meaningful comparison by taking care of the scale dependencies of relevant observables . and
@xmath210 as functions of @xmath183 , together with the corresponding lattice predictions @xcite,@xcite .
the meaning of the symbols are the same as in fig.[fig : a1020is].,width=604,height=264 ] next , in fig.[fig : a1020iv ] , we show the isovector combination of the generalized form factors @xmath211 and @xmath210 .
the meaning of the symbols are the same as in fig.[fig : a1020is ] . as for @xmath211 ,
both the cqsm and the lattice simulation reproduce the quark number sum rule @xmath212 with good prediction . turning to @xmath210
, one observes that the prediction of the cqsm shows somewhat peculiar dependence on the pion mass .
starting from a fairly small value in the chiral limit ( @xmath213 ) , it first increases as @xmath183 increases , but as @xmath183 further increases it begins to decrease , thereby showing a tendency to match the lattice prediction in the heavy pion region . very interestingly , letting put aside the absolute value , a similar @xmath183 dependence is also observed in the chiral extrapolation of the lattice prediction for the momentum fraction @xmath214 shown in fig.25 of @xcite .
physically , the quantity @xmath210 has a meaning of the difference of the momentum fractions carried by the @xmath69-quark and the @xmath70-quark .
the empirical value for it is @xmath215 @xcite .
one sees that the prediction of the cqsm in the chiral limit is not far from this empirical information , although more serious comparison must take account of the scale dependence of @xmath216 . and @xmath217 as functions of @xmath183 , together with the corresponding lattice predictions @xcite,@xcite .
the meaning of the symbols are the same as in fig.[fig : a1020is].,width=604,height=264 ] next , shown in fig.[fig : b1020is ] are the cqsm predictions for @xmath218 and @xmath217 .
the former quantity is related to the isoscalar combination of the nucleon anomalous magnetic moment as @xmath219 .
( we recall that its empirical value is @xmath220 . )
we find that this quantity is very sensitive to the variation of the pion mass .
it appears that the cqsm prediction @xmath221 corresponding to chiral limit underestimates the observation significantly .
however , the difference is exaggerated too much in this comparison . in fact
, if we carry out a comparison in the total isoscalar magnetic moment of the nucleon @xmath222 , the cqsm in the chiral limit gives @xmath223 in comparison with the observed value @xmath224 . to our knowledge ,
no theoretical predictions are given for this quantity by either of the lhpc or qcdsf collaborations .
the right panel of fig.4 shows the predictions for @xmath217 , which is sometimes called the isoscalar part of the nucleon anomalous gravitomagnetic moment , or alternatively the _ net quark contribution to the nucleon anomalous gravitomagnetic moment_. as already pointed out , the prediction of the cqsm for this quantity is exactly zero : i.e. @xmath169 the explicit numerical calculation also confirms it .
it should be recognized that the above result @xmath225 obtained in the cqsm is just a necessary consequence of the _ momentum sum rule _ and the _ total nucleon spin sum rule _
, both of which are saturated by the quark field only in the cqsm as @xmath226 and @xmath227 \ = \ \langle j \rangle^{u + d } \ = \
\frac{1}{2 } .\ ] ] in real qcd , the gluon also contributes to these sum rules , thereby leading to more general identities : @xmath228 + [ a_{20}^g ( 0 ) + b_{20}^g ( 0 ) ] = 1 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which constrains that only the sum of @xmath217 and @xmath229 is forced to vanish as @xmath230 ( while we neglect here the contributions of other quarks than the @xmath69- and @xmath70-quarks , it loses no generality in our discussion below .
in fact , to include them , we have only to replace the combination @xmath231 by @xmath232 . )
the above nontrivial identity claims that the net contributions of quark and gluon fields to the anomalous gravitomagnetic moment of the nucleon must be zero .
an interesting question is whether the quark and gluon contribution to the anomalous gravitomagnetic moment vanishes separately or they are both large with opposite sign .
a perturbative analysis based on a very simple toy model indicates the latter possibility @xcite . on the other hand
, a nonperturbative analysis within the framework of the lattice qcd indicates that the net quark contribution to the anomalous gravitomagnetic moment is small or nearly zero , @xmath233 @xcite,@xcite .
( to be more precise , we sees that the prediction of the lhpc collaboration for @xmath217 is slightly negative @xcite , while that of the qcdsf group is slightly positive @xcite . )
this strongly indicates a surprising possibility that the quark and gluon contribution to the anomalous gravitomagnetic moment of the nucleon may separately vanish .
worthy of special mention here is an interesting argument given by teryaev some years ago , claiming that the vanishing net quark contributions to the anomalous gravitomagnetic moment of the nucleon , violated in perturbation theory , is expected to be restored in full nonperturbative qcd due to the confinement @xcite,@xcite,@xcite . very interestingly ,
once it actually happens , it leads to a surprisingly simple result , i.e. the proportionality of the quark momentum and angular momentum fraction @xmath234 as advocated by teryaev @xcite,@xcite,@xcite .
a far reaching physical consequence resulting from this observation was extensively discussed in our recent report @xcite .
( see also the discussion at the end of this section . ) and @xmath235 as functions of @xmath183 , together with the corresponding lattice predictions @xcite,@xcite .
the meaning of the symbols are the same as in fig.[fig : a1020is].,width=604,height=264 ] next , we show in fig.[fig : b1020iv ] the predictions for the isovector case , i.e. @xmath236 and @xmath235 .
we recall first that the quantity @xmath236 represents the isovector combination of the nucleon anomalous magnetic moment @xmath237 , the empirical value of which is known to be @xmath238 .
one find that this quantity is extremely sensitive to the variation of the pion mass especially near @xmath239 .
this is only natural if one remembers the important role of the pion cloud in the isovector magnetic moment of the nucleon .
( one may notice that the prediction of the cqsm for @xmath240 underestimates a little its empirical value even in the chiral limit .
we recall , however , that , within the framework of the cqsm , there is an important @xmath241 correction or the 1st order rotational correction to some kind of isovector quantities like the isovector magnetic moment of the nucleon in question or the axial - vector coupling constant of the nucleon @xcite@xcite .
this next - to - leading correction in @xmath241 should also be taken into account in more advanced investigations . )
shown in the right panel of fig.[fig : b1020iv ] is the theoretical predictions for @xmath235 , the half of which can be interpreted as the difference of the total angular momentum carried by the @xmath69-quark and the @xmath70-quark fields according to ji s angular momentum sum rule @xcite .
the cqsm predicts fairly small value for this quantity , in contrast to the lattice predictions of sizable magnitude .
it seems that the pion mass dependence rescues this discrepancy only partially .
here we argue that , the reason why the cqsm ( in the chiral limit ) gives rather small prediction for this quantity is intimately connected with the characteristic @xmath1 dependence of the quantity @xmath242 , the forward limit of the isovector unpolarized spin - flip gpd of the nucleon . to show it
, we first recall that , within the theoretical frame work of the cqsm , @xmath236 as well as @xmath243 are calculated as difference of @xmath244 and @xmath245 and of @xmath246 and @xmath247 , respectively , as @xmath248 although the quantities of the rhs can be calculated directly without recourse to any distribution functions , they can also be evaluated as @xmath1-weighted integrals of the corresponding gpds as @xmath249 the distribution function @xmath242 has already been calculated within the cqsm in our recent paper @xcite . as shown there ,
the dirac sea contribution to this quantity has a sizably large peak around @xmath250 .
since this significant peak due to the deformed dirac - sea quarks is approximately symmetric with respect to the reflection @xmath251 , it hardly contributes to the second moment @xmath252 , whereas it gives a sizable contribution to the first moment @xmath253 .
the predicted significant peak of @xmath242 around @xmath250 can physically be interpreted as the effects of pion cloud .
it can be convinced in several ways .
first , we investigate how this behavior of @xmath242 changes as the pion mass is varied .
obtained with @xmath182 and @xmath239.,width=340,height=264 ] dependence of @xmath254.,width=604,height=264 ] shown in fig.[fig : eiv_pi0 ] and in fig.[fig : eiv_pi24 ] are the cqsm predictions for @xmath242 with several values of @xmath183 .
i.e. @xmath255 , and @xmath256 .
one clearly sees that the height of the peak around @xmath250 , due to the deformed dirac - sea quarks , decreases rapidly as @xmath183 increases .
this supports our interpretation of this peak as the effects of pion clouds . on the other hand
, one also observes that the magnitude of the valence quark contribution , peaked around @xmath257 , gradually increases as @xmath183 becomes large .
this behavior of @xmath242 turns out to cause a somewhat unexpected @xmath183 dependence of @xmath253 and @xmath252 . as a function of @xmath183 , the dirac sea contribution to
@xmath253 decreases fast , whereas the valence quark contribution to it increases slowly , so that the total @xmath253 becomes a decreasing function of @xmath183 . on the other hand ,
owing to the approximate odd - function nature of the dirac sea contribution to @xmath258 with respect to @xmath1 , it hardly contributes to @xmath259 independent of the pion mass , while the valence quark contribution to @xmath258 is an increasing function of @xmath183 , thereby leading to the result that the net @xmath259 is a increasing function of @xmath183 .
obtained with @xmath182 and @xmath239.,width=340,height=264 ] dependence of @xmath260.,width=604,height=264 ] we can give still another support to the above - mentioned interpretation of the contribution of the dirac - sea quarks . to see it ,
we first recall that the theoretical unpolarized distribution function @xmath261 appearing in the decomposition @xmath262 also has a sizable peak around @xmath250 due to the deformed dirac - sea quarks . as shown in fig.[fig : fiv_pi0 ] and in fig.[fig : fiv_pi24 ] , this peak is again a rapidly decreasing function of @xmath183 , supporting our interpretation of it as the effects of pion clouds . here
, we can say more .
we point out that this small-@xmath1 behavior of @xmath261 is just what is required by the famous nmc measurement @xcite . to confirm it ,
first remember that the distribution @xmath263 in the negative @xmath1 region should actually be interpreted as the distribution of antiquarks . to be explicit
, it holds that @xmath264 the large and positive value of @xmath261 in the negative @xmath1 region close to @xmath250 means that @xmath265 is negative , i.e. the dominance of the @xmath7-quark over the @xmath8-quark inside the proton , which has been established by the nmc measurement @xcite
. evolved to @xmath266 and @xmath267 in comparison with the hermes and nutev data at the corresponding energy scales @xcite,@xcite.,width=340,height=283 ] shown in fig.[fig : dbdu ] are the predictions of the cqsm for @xmath268 evolved to the high energy scales corresponding to the experimental observation @xcite .
( the theoretical predictions here were obtained with @xmath182 and @xmath269 . )
the model reproduces well the observed behavior of @xmath268 , although the magnitude of the flavor asymmetry in smaller @xmath1 region seems to be slightly overestimated .
it is a widely accepted fact that this flavor asymmetry of the sea quark distribution in the proton can physically be understood as the effects of pion cloud at least qualitatively @xcite@xcite .
this then supports our interpretation of the effects of the deformed dirac - sea quarks in @xmath242 and @xmath261 as the effects of pion clouds . .the
@xmath270 dependencies of @xmath271 , @xmath272 , and @xmath273 in the cqsm with @xmath182 .
[ tabivb20 ] [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
in this paper , we have investigated the generalized form factors of the nucleon , which will be extracted through near - future measurements of the generalized parton distribution functions , within the framework of the cqsm .
a particular emphasis is put on the pion mass dependence as well as the scale dependence of the model predictions , which we compare with the corresponding predictions of the lattice qcd by the lhpc and the qcdsf collaborations carried out in the heavy pion regime around @xmath199 .
the generalized form factors contain the ordinary electromagnetic form factors of the nucleon such as the dirac and pauli form factors of the proton and the neutron .
we have shown that the cqsm with good chiral symmetry reproduces well the general behaviors of the observed electromagnetic form factors , while the lattice simulations by the above two groups have a tendency to underestimate the electromagnetic sizes of the nucleon . undoubtedly , this can not be unrelated to the fact that the above two lattice simulations were performed with unrealistically heavy pion mass .
we have also tried to figure out the underlying spin contents of the nucleon through the analysis of the gravitoelectric and gravitomagnetic form factors of the nucleon , by taking care of the pion mass despondencies as well as of the scale dependencies of the relevant quantities . after taking account of the scale dependencies by means of the qcd evolution equations at the nlo in the @xmath274 scheme ,
the cqsm predicts , at @xmath275 , that @xmath276 , and @xmath277 , which means that the quark orbital angular momentum carries sizable amount of total nucleon spin even at such a relatively high energy scale .
it contradicts the conclusion of the lhpc and qcdsf collaborations indicating that the total orbital angular momentum of quarks is very small or consistent with zero .
it should be recognized , however , that the prediction of the cqsm for the total quark angular momentum is not extremely far from the corresponding lattice prediction @xmath278 at the same renormalization scale .
the cause of discrepancy can therefore be traced back to the lhpc and qcdsf lattice qcd predictions for the quark spin fraction @xmath279 around 0.6 , which contradicts not only the prediction of the cqsm but also the emc observation . as was shown in our recent paper @xcite , @xmath279 is such a quantity that is extremely sensitive to the variation of the pion mass , especially in the region close to the chiral limit .
more serious lattice qcd studies on the @xmath270-dependence of @xmath279 is highly desirable .
worthy of special mention is the fact that , once we accept a theoretical postulate @xmath280 , i.e , the absence of the net quark contribution to the anomalous gravitomagnetic moment of the nucleon , which is supported by both of the lhpc and qcdsf lattice simulations , we are necessarily led to a surprisingly simple relations , @xmath281 and @xmath282 , i.e. the proportionality of the linear and angular momentum fractions carried by the quarks and the gluons . using these relations , together with the existing empirical information for the unpolarized and the longitudinally polarized pdfs
, we can give _ model - independent predictions _ for the quark and gluon contents of the nucleon spin .
for instance , with combined use of the mrst2004 fit @xcite and the dns2005 fit @xcite , we obtain @xmath283 , @xmath284 , and @xmath285 at @xmath275 . since @xmath286 ( as well as @xmath287 ) is a rapidly decreasing function of the energy scale , while the scale dependence of @xmath279 is very weak
, we must conclude that the former is even more dominant over the latter at the scale below @xmath288 where any low energy models are supposed to hold .
the situation is a little more complicated in the flavor - nonsinglet ( or isovector ) channel , because @xmath289 , and also because the cqsm and the lattice qcd give fairly different predictions for @xmath271 . as compared with the lattice prediction for @xmath271 around @xmath290 , the predictions of the cqsm turns out to be around @xmath291 .
we have argued that the relatively small value of @xmath246 obtained in the cqsm is intimately connected with the small @xmath1 enhancement of the generalized parton distribution @xmath292 , which is dominated by the clouds of pionic @xmath293 excitation around @xmath294 .
( we recall that the 2nd moment of @xmath292 gives @xmath246 . )
unfortunately , such a @xmath1-dependent distribution as @xmath292 can not be accessed within the framework of lattice qcd .
still , the predicted small @xmath1 behavior of @xmath295 as well as of @xmath296 indicates again the importance of chiral dynamics in the nucleon structure function physics , which has not been fully accounted for in the lattice qcd simulation at the present level .
this work is supported in part by a grant - in - aid for scientific research for ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology , japan ( no . c-16540253 )
here we closely follow the proof of the momentum sum rule given in @xcite , by taking into account a necessary modification in the case of @xmath297 .
the starting point is the following expression for the soliton mass ( or the static soliton energy ) : @xmath298 \ - \ ( h \rightarrow h_0 ) \ + \
e_m , \ ] ] with @xmath299 \ = \ - \,f_\pi^2 \,m_\pi^2 \,\int \ , [ \cos f(r ) - 1 ] \,d^3 x .
\label{eq : emeson}\ ] ] the soliton mass must be stationary with respect to an arbitrary variation of the chiral field @xmath300 or equivalently the soliton profile @xmath52 , which lead to a saddle point equation : @xmath301 \ + \ \delta e_m \ = \ 0 .\ ] ] here we consider a particular ( dilatational ) variation of chiral field @xmath302 for infinitesimal @xmath3 , we have @xmath303 so that @xmath304 \ = \ \xi \ , ( [ x^k \partial_k , h ] - i \gamma^0 \gamma^k \partial_k ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] noting the identity @xmath305 ) \ =
\ \mbox{sp } ( [ h , \theta ( e_0 - h + i \varepsilon ) ] x^k \partial_k ) \ = \ 0 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] we therefore obtain a key identity @xmath306 = - \,\delta e_m .
\label{eq : keyid}\ ] ] now , by using ( [ eq : emeson ] ) together with the relations , @xmath307 we get @xmath308 here , taking account of the boundary condition @xmath309 we can manipulate as @xmath310 we thus find an important relation : @xmath311 putting this relation into ( [ eq : keyid ] ) , we have @xmath312 or @xmath313 if we evaluate the trace sum above by using the eigenstates of the static dirac hamiltonian @xmath50 as a complete set of basis , ( [ eq : traceap ] ) can also be written as @xmath314 which is the relation quoted in ( [ eq : alfp ] ) .
we point out that our result has a correct chiral limit , since @xmath315 as @xmath316 and therefore @xmath317 in conformity with the proof given in ref.@xcite .
|
with a special intention of clarifying the underlying spin contents of the nucleon , we investigate the generalized form factors of the nucleon , which are defined as the @xmath0-th @xmath1-moments of the generalized parton distribution functions , within the framework of the chiral quark soliton model .
a particular emphasis is put on the pion mass dependence of final predictions , which we shall compare with the predictions of lattice qcd simulations carried out in the so - called heavy pion region around @xmath2 .
we find that some observables are very sensitive to the variation of the pion mass .
it will be argued that the negligible importance of the quark orbital angular momentum indicated by the lhpc and qcdsf lattice collaborations might be true in the unrealistic heavy pion world , but it is not necessarily the case in our real world close to the chiral limit .
|
let @xmath1 . let @xmath2\longrightarrow [
0,\pi_{p , q}/2]$ ] be the integral @xmath3 where @xmath4 . the @xmath0-_sine functions _
, @xmath5 , $ ] are defined to be the inverses of @xmath6 , @xmath7\ ] ] extended to @xmath8 by the rules @xmath9 which make them periodic , continuous , odd with respect to 0 and even with respect to @xmath10 .
these are natural generalisations of the sine function , indeed @xmath11 and they are known to share a number of remarkable properties with their classical counterpart @xcite
. among these properties lies the fundamental question of completeness and linear independence of the family @xmath12 where @xmath13 .
this question has received some attention recently @xcite , with a particular emphasis on the case @xmath14 .
in the latter instance , @xmath15 is the set of eigenfunctions of the generalised eigenvalue problem for the one - dimensional @xmath16-laplacian subject to dirichlet boundary conditions @xcite , which is known to be of relevance in the theory of slow / fast diffusion processes , @xcite .
see also the related papers @xcite .
set @xmath17 , so that @xmath18 is a schauder basis of the banach space @xmath19 for all @xmath20 .
the family @xmath21 is also a schauder basis of @xmath22 if and only if the corresponding _ change of coordinates map _ , @xmath23 , extends to a linear homeomorphism of @xmath22 .
the fourier coefficients of @xmath24 associated to @xmath25 obey the relation @xmath26 for @xmath27 , let @xmath28 ( note that @xmath29 for @xmath30 ) and let @xmath31 be the linear isometry such that @xmath32 .
then @xmath33 so that the change of coordinates takes the form @xmath34 notions of `` nearness '' between bases of banach spaces are known to play a fundamental role in classical mathematical analysis , @xcite , @xcite or @xcite .
unfortunately , the expansion strongly suggests that @xmath21 is not globally `` near '' @xmath18 , e.g. in the krein - lyusternik or the paley - wiener sense , @xcite .
therefore classical arguments , such as those involving the paley - wiener stability theorem , are unlikely to be directly applicable in the present context .
in fact , more rudimentary methods can be invoked in order to examine the invertibility of the change of coordinates map . from it
follows that @xmath35 in @xcite it was claimed that the left side of held true for all @xmath36 where @xmath37 was determined to lie in the segment @xmath38 .
hence @xmath21 would be a schauder basis , whenever @xmath39 .
further developments in this respect were recently reported by bushell and edmunds @xcite .
these authors cleverly fixed a gap originally published in ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 5 ) and observed that , as the left side of ceases to hold true whenever @xmath40 the argument will break for @xmath14 near @xmath41 .
therefore , the basisness question for @xmath21 should be tackled by different means in the regime @xmath42 .
more recently @xcite , edmunds , gurka and lang , employed in order to show invertibility of @xmath43 for general pairs @xmath44 , as long as @xmath45 since is guaranteed whenever @xmath46 this allows @xmath47 for @xmath48
. however , note that a direct substitution of @xmath14 in , only leads to the sub - optimal condition @xmath49 . in section [ linearind ] below
we show that the family @xmath21 is @xmath50-_linearly independent _ for all @xmath1 , see theorem [ likernelandspan ] . in section [ ribap ]
we establish conditions ensuring that @xmath43 is a homeomorphism of @xmath51 in a neighbourhood of the region in the @xmath44-plane where @xmath52 see theorem [ inprovement ] and also corollary [ beyonda ] . for this purpose , in section [ criteria ] we find two further criteria which generalise in the hilbert space setting , see corollaries [ main_1 ] and [ main_2 ] . in this case , the _ riesz constant _ , @xmath53 characterises how @xmath21 deviates from being an orthonormal basis .
these new statements yield upper bounds for @xmath54 , which improve upon those obtained from the right side of , even when the latter is applicable .
the formulation of the alternatives to presented below relies crucially on work developed in section [ toep_s ] . from lemma [ multareshifts ]
we compute explicitly the wold decomposition of the isometries @xmath31 : they turn out to be shifts of infinite multiplicity
. hence we can extract from the expansion suitable components which are toeplitz operators of scalar type acting on appropriate hardy spaces . as the theory becomes quite technical for the case @xmath55 and all the estimates analogous to those reported below would involve a dependence on the parameter @xmath56
, we have chosen to restrict our attention with regards to these improvements only to the already interesting hilbert space setting .
section [ casep = q ] is concerned with particular details of the case of equal indices @xmath14 , and it involves results on both the general case @xmath20 and the specific case @xmath57 .
rather curiously , we have found another gap which renders incomplete the proof of invertibility of @xmath43 for @xmath58 originally published in @xcite .
see remark [ rem_gap ] .
moreover , the application of ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.5 ) only gets to a _
basisness threshold _ of @xmath59 , where @xmath60 is defined by the identity @xmath61 see also ( * ? ? ?
* remark 2.1 ) . in theorem [ fixingbbcdg ]
we show that @xmath21 is indeed a schauder basis of @xmath22 for @xmath62 where @xmath63 , see ( * ? ? ?
* problem 1 ) . as @xmath64 , basisness
is now guaranteed for all @xmath65 .
see figure [ impro_fig_p = q ] .
in section [ nume ] we report on our current knowledge of the different thresholds for invertibility of the change of coordinates map , both in the case of equal indices and otherwise . based on the new criteria found in section [ criteria ] , we formulate a general test of invertibility for @xmath43 which is amenable to analytical and numerical investigation .
this test involves finding sharp bounds on the first few coefficients @xmath66 .
see proposition [ beyond2 ] . for the case of equal indices
, this test indicates that @xmath21 is a riesz basis of @xmath51 for @xmath67 where @xmath68 .
all the numerical quantities reported in this paper are accurate up to the last digit shown , which is rounded to the nearest integer . in the appendix
we have included fully reproducible computer codes which can be employed to verify the calculations reported .
a family @xmath69 in a banach space is called @xmath50-linearly independent @xcite , if @xmath70 [ likernelandspan ] for all @xmath1 , the family @xmath21 is @xmath50-linearly independent in @xmath22 .
moreover , if the linear extension of the map @xmath23 is a bounded operator @xmath71 , then @xmath72 for the first assertion we show that @xmath73 .
let @xmath74 be such that @xmath75 where the series is convergent in the norm of @xmath22 .
then @xmath76 hence @xmath77 we show that all @xmath78 by means of a double induction argument .
suppose that @xmath79 .
we prove that all @xmath80 . indeed , clearly @xmath81 from with @xmath82 .
now assume inductively that @xmath29 for all @xmath83 . from for @xmath84
we get @xmath85 then @xmath80 for all @xmath86 . as this
would contradict the fact that @xmath87 , necessarily @xmath88 .
suppose now inductively that @xmath89 and @xmath90 .
we prove that again all @xmath80 .
firstly , @xmath81 from with @xmath91 , because @xmath92 secondly , assume by induction that @xmath29 for all @xmath93 . from for @xmath94
we get @xmath95 the latter equality is a consequence of the fact that , for @xmath96 with @xmath97 and @xmath98 , either @xmath99 ( indices for the @xmath100 ) or @xmath101 ( indices for the @xmath102 ) .
hence @xmath80 for all @xmath86 .
as this would again contradict the fact that @xmath87 , necessarily all @xmath103 so that @xmath104 .
the second assertion is shown as follows .
assume that @xmath105 .
if @xmath106 , then @xmath107 for all @xmath108 , so @xmath109 which in turns means that @xmath110 for all @xmath111 . on the other hand , if the latter holds true for @xmath112 , then @xmath113 for all @xmath114 , so @xmath115 , as required . therefore , @xmath21 is a riesz basis of @xmath51 if and only if @xmath105 and @xmath116 .
a simple example illustrates how a family of dilated periodic functions can break its property of being a riesz basis .
[ ex1 ] let @xmath117 $ ] .
take @xmath118 by virtue of lemma [ toep ] below , @xmath119 is a riesz basis of @xmath51 if and only if @xmath120 .
for @xmath121 we have an orthonormal set .
however it is not complete , as it clearly misses the infinite - dimensional subspace @xmath122 .
the fundamental decomposition of @xmath43 given in allows us to extract suitable components formed by toeplitz operators of scalar type , @xcite . in order to identify these components , we begin by determining the wold decomposition of the isometries @xmath31 , @xcite
. see remark [ diri ] .
[ multareshifts ] for all @xmath123 , @xmath124 is a shift of infinite multiplicity .
define @xmath125 then @xmath126 for @xmath127 , @xmath128 , and @xmath129 one - to - one and onto for all @xmath130 .
therefore indeed @xmath31 is a shift of multiplicity @xmath131 .
let @xmath132 .
the hardy spaces of functions in @xmath133 with values in the banach space @xmath134 are denoted below by @xmath135 .
let @xmath136 be a holomorphic function on @xmath137 and fix @xmath138 .
let @xmath139 let the corresponding toeplitz operator ( * ? ? ?
* ( 5 - 1 ) ) @xmath140 let @xmath141 by virtue of lemma [ multareshifts ] ( see ( * ? ? ? * and 5.2 ) ) , there exists an invertible isometry @xmath142 such that @xmath143 .
below we write @xmath144 [ generic_toep ] @xmath145 in is invertible if and only if @xmath146 .
moreover @xmath147 observe that @xmath148 is scalar analytic in the sense of @xcite .
since @xmath149 is holomorphic in @xmath137 , then @xmath150 and @xmath151 ( * ? ? ?
* theorem a(iii ) ) . if @xmath152 , then @xmath153 is also holomorphic in @xmath137 .
the scalar toeplitz operator @xmath154 is invertible if and only if @xmath146 .
moreover , @xcite , @xmath155 the matrix of @xmath148 has the block representation @xcite @xmath156 the matrix associated to @xmath154 has exactly the same scalar form , replacing @xmath157 by @xmath158 . then , @xmath148 is invertible if and only if @xmath154 is invertible , and @xmath159 hence @xmath160 [ pert ] let @xmath161 for @xmath145 as in . if @xmath162 , then @xmath43 is invertible .
moreover @xmath163 since @xmath145 is invertible , write @xmath164 .
if additionally @xmath165 , then @xmath166 [ diri ] it is possible to characterise the change of coordinates @xmath43 in terms of dirichlet series , and recover some of the results here and below directly from this characterisation .
see for example the insightful paper @xcite and the complete list of references provided in the addendum @xcite .
however , the full technology of dirichlet series is not needed in the present context .
a further development in this direction will be reported elsewhere .
a proof of can be achieved by applying corollary [ pert ] assuming that @xmath167 our next goal is to formulate concrete sufficient condition for the invertibility of @xmath43 and corresponding bounds on @xmath54 , which improve upon whenever @xmath57 . for this purpose
we apply corollary [ pert ] assuming that @xmath145 has now the three - term expansion @xmath168 let @xmath169 let @xmath170 see figure [ region ] .
optimal region of invertibility in lemma [ toep ] . in this picture
the horizontal axis is @xmath171 and the vertical axis is @xmath172.,height=377 ] [ toep ] let @xmath57 .
let @xmath173 .
the operator @xmath174 is invertible if and only if @xmath175 .
moreover @xmath176 let @xmath177 be associated with @xmath145 as in section [ toep_s ] .
the first assertion is a consequence of the following observation . if @xmath178 , then @xmath179 has roots @xmath180 conjugate with each other and @xmath181
if and only if @xmath182 . otherwise @xmath179 has two real roots .
if @xmath183 and @xmath184 , then the smallest in modulus root of @xmath179 would lie in @xmath137 if and only if @xmath185 .
if @xmath186 and @xmath187 , then the root of @xmath179 that is smallest in modulus would lie in @xmath137 if and only if @xmath188 .
for the second assertion , let @xmath175 and @xmath189 .
by virtue of the maximum principle on @xmath179 and @xmath190 , @xmath191 since @xmath192 then @xmath193 if and only if @xmath194 .
for @xmath195 , we get @xmath196 and @xmath197 . for @xmath198
, we get @xmath199 with the condition @xmath200 . by virtue of theorem
[ generic_toep ] , we obtain the claimed statement . since @xmath201 for all @xmath202 , then @xmath203 .
below we substitute @xmath204 and @xmath205 , then apply lemma [ toep ] appropriately in order to determine the invertibility of @xmath43 whenever pairs @xmath44 lie in different regions of the @xmath44-plane . for this purpose
we establish the following hierarchy between @xmath206 and @xmath207 for @xmath208 , whenever the latter are non - negative .
[ ajint ] for @xmath209 or @xmath210 , we have @xmath211 . firstly observe that @xmath212 is continuous , it increases for all @xmath213 and it vanishes at @xmath214 .
let @xmath209 .
set @xmath215 { \mathrm{d}}x \qquad \text{and } \\
i_1=\int_{\frac14}^{\frac12 } \sin_{p , q}(\pi_{p , q}x ) [ \sin(\pi x)-\sin(3\pi x ) ] { \mathrm{d}}x . \end{gathered}\ ] ] since @xmath216 then @xmath217 and @xmath218 .
as @xmath219 is odd with respect to @xmath220 and @xmath221 is increasing in the segment @xmath222 , then also @xmath223 .
hence @xmath224 ensuring the first statement of the lemma .
let @xmath210 .
a straightforward calculation shows that @xmath225 if and only if , either @xmath226 or @xmath227 .
thus , @xmath228 has exactly five zeros in the segment @xmath229 $ ] located at : @xmath230 set @xmath231 and @xmath232 { \mathrm{d}}x .\ ] ] then @xmath233 for @xmath234 and @xmath235 for @xmath236 . since @xmath237 for all @xmath238 , then @xmath239 hence @xmath240
the next two corollaries are consequences of corollary [ pert ] and lemma [ toep ] , and are among the main results of this paper .
[ main_1 ] @xmath241 let @xmath161 where @xmath242 the top on left side of and the fact that @xmath203 imply @xmath243 thus , the bottom on the left side of yields @xmath244 so indeed @xmath43 is invertible .
the estimate on the riesz constant is deduced from the triangle inequality . since @xmath203
, supersedes , only when the pair @xmath44 is such that @xmath245 . from this corollary
we see below that the change of coordinates is invertible in a neighbourhood of the threshold set by the condition .
see proposition [ beyond2 ] and figures [ impro_fig_p = q ] and [ th10ab ] .
[ main_2 ] @xmath246 the proof is similar to that of corollary [ main_1 ] .
we see below that corollary [ main_1 ] is slightly more useful than corollary [ main_2 ] in the context of the dilated @xmath0-sine functions
. however the latter is needed in the proof of the main theorem [ inprovement ] .
it is of course natural to ask what consequences can be derived from the other statement in lemma [ toep ] .
for @xmath247 we have @xmath248 . hence the same argument as in the proofs of corollaries [ main_1 ] and [ main_2 ] would reduce to , and
in this case there is no improvement .
our first goal in this section is to establish that the change of coordinates map associated to the family @xmath21 is invertible beyond the region of applicability of .
we begin by recalling a calculation which was performed in the proof of ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 4.1 ) and which will be invoked several times below .
let @xmath249 be the inverse function of @xmath250
. then @xmath251 indeed , integrating by parts twice and changing the variable of integration to @xmath252 yields @xmath253 ' \sin(j\pi x ) { \mathrm{d}}x \\ & = -\frac{2 \sqrt{2 } \pi_{p , q}}{j^2\pi^2 } \int_0 ^ 1 \sin \left ( \frac{j \pi}{\pi_{p , q } } a(t)\right ) { \mathrm{d}}t .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ inprovement ] let @xmath57 .
suppose that the pair @xmath254 is such that the following two conditions are satisfied 1 .
[ improa ] @xmath255 2 .
[ improc ] @xmath256 .
then there exists a neighbourhood @xmath257 , such that the change of coordinates @xmath43 is invertible for all @xmath258 . from the dominated convergence theorem
, it follows that each @xmath259 is a continuous function of the parameters @xmath16 and @xmath260 .
therefore , by virtue of and a further application of the dominated convergence theorem , also @xmath261 is continuous in the parameters @xmath16 and @xmath260 . here
@xmath262 can be any fixed set of indices , but below in this proof we only need to consider @xmath263 for the first possibility and @xmath264 for the second possibility .
write @xmath265 .
the hypothesis implies @xmath266 , because @xmath267 therefore @xmath268 for a suitable neighbourhood @xmath269 .
two possibilities are now in place .
note that @xmath271 is an immediate consequence of [ improa ] and [ improc ] . by continuity of all quantities involved ,
there exists a neighbourhood @xmath272 such that the left hand side and hence the right hand side of hold true for all @xmath273 .
substitute @xmath275 and @xmath276 .
if @xmath277 , then @xmath278 indeed , the conditions on @xmath171 and @xmath172 give @xmath279 as @xmath280 , @xmath281 thus @xmath282 which is .
hence @xmath283 thus , once again by continuity of all quantities involved , there exists a neighbourhood @xmath284 such that the left hand side and hence the right hand side of hold true for all @xmath285 .
the conclusion follows by defining either @xmath286 or @xmath287 .
we now examine other further consequences of the corollaries [ main_1 ] and [ main_2 ] .
[ impro_implicit ] any of the following conditions ensure the invertibility of the change of coordinates map @xmath288 . 1 . [ aimplicit ] ( @xmath20 ) : @xmath289 2
. [ bimplicit ] ( @xmath57 ) : @xmath290 , @xmath245 , @xmath291 and @xmath292 3 .
[ cimplicit ] ( @xmath57 ) : @xmath290 , @xmath245 , @xmath293 and @xmath294 from , it follows that @xmath295 hence the condition [ aimplicit ] implies that the hypothesis is satisfied .
by virtue of lemma [ ajint ] , it is guaranteed that @xmath296 in the settings of [ bimplicit ] or [ cimplicit ] . from
, it also follows that @xmath297 combining each one of these assertions with and , respectively , immediately leads to the claimed statement .
we recover ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 4.3 ) from the part [ aimplicit ] of this theorem by observing that for all @xmath1 , @xmath298 in fact , for @xmath299 , the better estimate @xmath300 ensures invertibility of @xmath43 for all @xmath20 whenever @xmath301 see figures [ th10ab ] and [ th10c ] .
we now consider in closer detail the particular case @xmath302 .
our analysis requires setting various sharp upper and lower bounds on the coefficients @xmath303 for @xmath304 .
this is our first goal .
employed to show bound [ a3l ] in lemma [ ajpositive ] . for reference
we also show @xmath305 , @xmath306 , @xmath307 and @xmath308 .
[ fig : interp ] , width=340 ] [ ajpositive ] 1 .
[ a3l ] @xmath309 for all @xmath310 2 .
[ a5l ] @xmath311 for all @xmath312 3 .
[ a7l ] @xmath313 for all @xmath312 4 .
[ a9l ] @xmath314 for all @xmath315 all the stated bounds are determined by integrating a suitable approximation of @xmath316 .
each one requires a different set of quadrature points , but the general structure of the arguments in all cases is similar . without further mention ,
below we repeatedly use the fact that in terms of hypergeometric functions , @xmath317.\ ] ] let @xmath318 for @xmath319 let @xmath320 see figure [ fig : interp ] . since @xmath321 and @xmath322 is an increasing function of @xmath323 , then @xmath324 according to ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 4.4 ) , @xmath316 increases as @xmath16 decreases for any fixed @xmath325 .
let @xmath16 be as in the hypothesis .
then @xmath326 and similarly @xmath327 by virtue of ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 3 ) the function @xmath322 is strictly concave for @xmath323 .
then , in fact , @xmath328 let @xmath329 since @xmath330 for @xmath331 and @xmath332 , @xmath333 note that @xmath334 set @xmath335 then @xmath336 and so @xmath337 also @xmath338
so @xmath339 let @xmath16 be as in the hypothesis .
then , similarly to the previous case [ a3l ] , @xmath340 set @xmath341 by strict concavity and , @xmath342 let @xmath343 then @xmath344 as claimed .
let @xmath16 be as in the hypothesis .
set @xmath345 then @xmath346 hence @xmath347 put @xmath348 then , @xmath349 let @xmath350 since @xmath351 is negative for @xmath352 and positive for @xmath353 , then @xmath354 .
hence @xmath355 note that @xmath356 let @xmath16 be as in the hypothesis .
set @xmath357 then @xmath358 hence @xmath347 put @xmath359 then , @xmath360 let @xmath361 then @xmath362 .
hence @xmath363 the next statement is a direct consequence of combining [ a3l ] and [ a9l ] from this lemma with theorem [ inprovement ] .
[ beyonda ] set @xmath57 and suppose that @xmath364 is such that @xmath365 there exists @xmath366 such that @xmath43 is invertible for all @xmath367 .
see figure [ impro_fig_p = q ] .
[ rem_gap ] in @xcite it was claimed that the hypothesis of held true whenever @xmath36 for a suitable @xmath368 .
the argument supporting this claim @xcite was separated into two cases : @xmath369 and @xmath370 . with our definition by a factor of @xmath371 .
note that the ground eigenfunction of the @xmath16-laplacian equation in @xcite is denoted by @xmath372 and it equals @xmath373 as defined above .
a key observation here is the @xmath16-pythagorean identity @xmath374 .
] of the fourier coefficients , in the latter case it was claimed that @xmath375 was bounded above by @xmath376 as it turns , there is a missing power 2 in the term @xmath377 for this claim to be true .
this corresponds to taking second derivatives of @xmath378 and it can be seen by applying the cauchy - schwartz inequality in .
the missing factor is crucial in the argument and renders the proof of ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1 ) incomplete in the latter case . in the paper
@xcite published a few years later , it was claimed that the hypothesis of held true for @xmath379 where @xmath60 is defined by .
it was then claimed that an approximated solution of was near @xmath380 .
an accurate numerical approximation of , based on analytical bounds on @xmath381 , give the correct digits @xmath382 .
therefore neither the results of @xcite nor those of @xcite include a complete proof of invertibility of the change of coordinates in a neighbourhood of @xmath383 . accurate numerical estimation of @xmath381 show that the identity is valid as long as @xmath384 , which improves slightly upon the value @xmath60 from @xcite .
however , as remarked in @xcite , the upper bound @xmath385 ensuring and hence the validity of theorem [ impro_implicit]-[aimplicit ] , is too crude for small values of @xmath16 . note for example that the correct regime is @xmath386 whereas @xmath387 as @xmath388 ( see appendix [ ap1 ] ) .
therefore , in order to determine invertibility of @xmath43 in the vicinity of @xmath389 , it is necessary to find sharper bounds for the first few terms @xmath375 , and employ directly .
this is the purpose of the next lemma .
see figure [ impro_fig_p = q ] .
[ ajbounds ] let @xmath312
. then 1 .
[ a1l ] @xmath390 2 .
[ a3u ] @xmath391 3 .
[ a5u ] @xmath392 4 .
[ a7u ] @xmath393 we proceed in a similar way as in the proof of lemma [ ajpositive ] .
let @xmath16 be as in the hypothesis
. set @xmath394 then @xmath395 and so @xmath347 let @xmath396 then , @xmath397 hence @xmath398 set @xmath399 then @xmath400 let @xmath401 then , @xmath402 and hence @xmath403 set @xmath404 and let @xmath405 then , @xmath406 , so @xmath407 set @xmath408 and @xmath409 then , @xmath406 and @xmath410 , so @xmath411 the following result fixes the proof of the claim made in ( * ? ? ?
* claim 2 ) and improves the threshold of invertibility determined in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.5 ) .
[ fixingbbcdg ] there exists @xmath412 , such that @xmath413\pi^2}{2\sqrt{2}\left ( \frac{\pi^2}{8}-1- \frac19-\frac{1}{25}-\frac{1}{49 } \right ) } \qquad \forall p\in\left(p_3 , \frac{6}{5}\right).\ ] ] the family @xmath21 is a schauder basis of @xmath414 for all @xmath415 and @xmath20 .
both sides of are continuous functions of the parameter @xmath416 .
the right hand side is bounded .
the left side is decreasing as @xmath16 increases and @xmath387 as @xmath388 . by virtue of lemma [ ajbounds ] , @xmath417 hence the first statement is ensured as a consequence of the intermediate value theorem . from
, it follows that @xmath418 for all @xmath419 .
lemma [ ajpositive ] guarantees positivity of @xmath207 for @xmath420 .
then , by re - arranging this inequality , the second statement becomes a direct consequence of .
a sharp numerical approximation of the solution of the equation with equality in gives @xmath421 .
see figure [ impro_fig_p = q ] .
if sharp bounds on the first few fourier coefficients @xmath259 are at hand , the approach employed above for the proof of theorem [ fixingbbcdg ] can also be combined with the criteria or . a natural question is whether this would lead to a positive answer to the question of invertibility for @xmath43 , whenever @xmath422 in the case of , we see below that this is indeed the case .
the key statement is summarised as follows .
[ beyond2 ] let @xmath57 and @xmath423 .
suppose that 1 .
@xmath290 , @xmath245 and @xmath424 for all other @xmath425 .
2 . @xmath426 . if @xmath427 then @xmath43 is invertible .
assume that the hypotheses are satisfied .
the combination of and gives @xmath428 then @xmath429 and so the conclusion follows from .
we now discuss the connection between the different statements established in the previous sections with those of the papers @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . for this purpose
we consider various accurate approximations of @xmath207 and @xmath430 .
these approximations are based on the next explicit formulae : @xmath431 and @xmath432 here @xmath433 is the incomplete beta function , @xmath434 is the beta function and @xmath435 is the gamma function .
moreover , by considering exactly the steps described in @xcite for the proof of ( * ? ? ?
* ( 4.15 ) ) , it follows that @xmath436{\mathrm{d}}x \\ & = \frac{\sqrt{2}}{\pi}\int_0 ^ 1 \log\left[\cot \left ( \frac{\pi}{4 } \
{ \mathcal{i}}\ !
\!\left(\frac1q,\frac{p-1}{p};x^q\right ) \right)\right ] { \mathrm{d}}x .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] .
the positions of @xmath37 , @xmath437 and the value of @xmath438 are set only for illustration purposes , as we are only certain that @xmath439 .
black indicates relevance to the general case @xmath20 while red indicates relevance for the case @xmath57 .
[ impro_fig_p = q],height=241 ] let us begin with the case of equal indices .
see figure [ impro_fig_p = q ] . as mentioned in the introduction , @xmath440 for @xmath41 .
the condition @xmath441 is fulfilled for all @xmath442 where @xmath443 .
the fourier coefficients @xmath444 for all @xmath445 whenever @xmath446 .
remarkably we need to get to @xmath447 , for a numerical verification of the conditions of proposition [ beyond2 ] allowing @xmath448 .
indeed we remark the following . 1 . for @xmath449 ,
the condition hold true only for @xmath450 where @xmath451 .
2 . for @xmath447
the condition does hold true for @xmath452 where @xmath68 .
this indicates that that the threshold for invertibility of @xmath43 in the hilbert space setting for @xmath14 is at least @xmath453 .
now we examine the general case .
the graphs shown in figures [ th10ab ] and [ th10c ] correspond to regions in the @xmath44-plane near @xmath454 .
curves on figure [ th10ab ] that are in red are relevant only to the hilbert space setting @xmath57 .
black curves pertain to @xmath20 .
figure [ th10ab]-_(a ) _ and a blowup shown in figure [ th10ab]-_(b ) _ , have two solid ( black ) lines .
one that shows the limit of applicability of theorem [ impro_implicit]-[aimplicit ] and one that shows the limit of applicability of the result of @xcite .
the dashed line indicates where occurs . to the left of that curve
is not applicable .
there are two filled regions of different colours in _ ( a ) _ , which indicate where @xmath455 and where @xmath456 for @xmath208 .
proposition [ beyond2 ] is not applicable in the union of these regions .
we also show the lines where @xmath457 and @xmath458 .
the latter forms part of the boundary of this union . the solid red line corresponding to the limit of applicability of theorem [ impro_implicit]-[bimplicit ] is also included in figure [ th10ab]-_(a)(d)_. to the right of that line , in the white area , we know that @xmath43 is invertible for @xmath57 . the blowup in figure [ th10ab]-_(b )
_ clearly shows the gap between theorem [ impro_implicit]-[aimplicit ] and theorem [ impro_implicit]-[bimplicit ] in this @xmath57 setting .
certainly @xmath459 is a point of intersection for all curves where @xmath29 for @xmath123 .
these curves are shown in figure [ th10ab]-_(c ) _ also for @xmath460 and @xmath461 . in this figure
, we also include the boundary of the region where @xmath455 and the region where @xmath456 now for @xmath462 .
note that the curves for @xmath463 and @xmath458 form part of the boundary of the latter . comparing _ ( a ) _ and _ ( c ) _ , the new line that cuts the @xmath16 axis at @xmath464 corresponds to the limit of where proposition [ beyond2 ] for @xmath465 is applicable ( for @xmath16 to the right of this line ) .
the gap between the two red lines ( case @xmath57 ) indicates that proposition [ beyond2 ] can significantly improve the threshold for basisness with respect to a direct application of theorem [ impro_implicit]-[bimplicit ] .
as we increase @xmath466 , the boundary of the corresponding region moves to the left , see the blowups in figure [ th10ab]-_(d ) _ and _ ( e)_. the two further curves in red located very close to the vertical axis , correspond to the precise value of the parameter @xmath466 where proposition [ beyond2 ] allows a proof of invertibility for the change of coordinates which includes the break made by . for @xmath467
the region does not include the dashed black line , for @xmath447 it does include this line .
the region shown in blue indicates a possible place where corollary [ main_1 ] may still apply , but further investigation in this respect is needed .
figure [ th10c ] concerns the statement of theorem [ impro_implicit]-[cimplicit ] .
the small wedge shown in green is the only place where the former is applicable .
as it turns , it appears that the conditions of corollary [ main_2 ] prevent it to be useful for determining invertibility of @xmath43 in a neighbourhood of @xmath454 .
however in the region shown in green , the upper bound on the riesz constant consequence of is sharper than that obtained from .
part of the difficulties for a proof of basisness for the family @xmath21 in the regime @xmath470 has to do the fact that the fourier coefficients of @xmath471 approach those of the function @xmath472 . in this appendix
we show that , indeed @xmath473 note that @xmath474 let @xmath475 be the ( unique ) value , such that @xmath476 then @xmath477 let @xmath478 be the line passing through the points @xmath479 and @xmath480 .
there exists a unique value @xmath481 such that @xmath482 this value is unique because of monotonicity of both sides of this equality , and it exists by bisection .
as all the functions involved are continuous in @xmath16 , then also @xmath483 is continuous in the parameter @xmath16 .
moreover , @xmath484 indeed , by clearing the equation defining @xmath483 , we get @xmath485 the right hand side , and thus the left hand side , approach 0 as @xmath388 .
then , one ( and hence both ) of the two terms multiplying on the left should approach 0 .
let @xmath486 be the polygon which has as vertices ( ordered clockwise ) @xmath487 as @xmath488 @xmath489\times\{0\ } ) \cup ( \{1\}\times [ 0,1])$ ] in hausdorff distance .
then the area of @xmath486 approaches 0 as @xmath388 .
moreover , @xmath486 covers the graph of @xmath490 for @xmath491 .
thus @xmath492 hence , there is a point @xmath493 on the graph of @xmath494 such that @xmath495 and @xmath496 the proof of is completed from the fact that , as @xmath494 is concave ( because its inverse function is convex ) , the piecewise linear interpolant of @xmath494 for the family of nodes @xmath497 has a graph below that of @xmath494 .
the following computer codes written in the open source languages octave and python can be used to verify any of the numerical estimations presented in this paper .
function for computing @xmath207 with 10-digits precision .
.... # -- function file : [ a , err , np]=apq(k , p , q ) # a is the kth fourier coefficient of the p , q sine function # err is the residual # np number of quadrature points # function [ a , err , np]=apq(k , p , q ) if mod(k,2)==0 , disp('error : k should be odd ' ) ; return ; end [ i , err , np]=quadcc(@(y ) cos(k*pi*betainc(y.^q,1/q,(p-1)/p)/2),0,1,1e-10 ) ; a = i*2*sqrt(2)/k / pi ; ....
function for computing @xmath498 with 10-digits precision .
.... # -- function file : [ s , err , np]=apqsum(k , p , q ) # s is the sum of the fourier coefficient of the p , q sine function # err is the residual # np number of quadrature points # function [ s , err , np]=apqsum(p , q ) [ i , err , np]=quadcc(@(y ) log(cot(pi*betainc(y.^q,1/q,(p-1)/p)/4)),0,1,1e-10 ) ; s = i*sqrt(2)/pi ; ....
function for computing @xmath207 with variable precision .
.... def a(k , p , q ) : " " " computes the kth fourier coefficient of the p , q sine function .
returns coefficient and residual .
> > > from sympy.mpmath import * > > > mp.dps = 25 ; mp.pretty = true > > > a(1,mpf(12)/11,mpf(12)/11 ) > > > ( 0.8877665848468607372062737 , 1.0e-59 ) " " " if isint(fraction(k,2 ) ) : apq=0 ; e=0 ; return apq , e f= lambda x : cos(k*pi*betainc(1/q,(p-1)/p,0,x**q , regularized = true)/2 ) ; ( i , e)=quad(f,[0,1],error = true , maxdegree=10 ) ; apq = i*2*sqrt(2)/k / pi ; return apq , e ....
function for computing @xmath498 with variable precision .
.... def suma(p , q ) : " " " computes the sum of the fourier coefficient of the p , q sine function . returns sum and residual .
> > > from sympy.mpmath import * > > > mp.dps = 25 ; mp.pretty = true > > > suma(mpf(12)/11,mpf(12)/11 ) > > > ( 1.48634943002852603038783 , 1.0e-56 ) " " " f= lambda x : log(cot(pi*betainc(1/q,(p-1)/p,0,x**q , regularized = true)/4 ) ) ; ( i , e)=quad(f,[0,1],error = true , maxdegree=10 ) ; sumapq = i*sqrt(2)/pi ; return sumapq , e ....
the authors wish to express their gratitude to paul binding who suggested this problem a few years back .
they are also kindly grateful with stefania marcantognini for her insightful comments during the preparation of this manuscript .
we acknowledge support by the british engineering and physical sciences research council ( ep / i00761x/1 ) , the research support fund of the edinburgh mathematical society and the instituto venezolano de investigaciones cientficas .
-plane where theorem [ impro_implicit]-[aimplicit ] and [ bimplicit ] , as well as proposition [ beyond2 ] ( with different values of @xmath466 ) apply . in all graphs
@xmath16 corresponds to the horizontal axis and @xmath260 to the vertical axis and the dotted line shows @xmath14 .
[ th10ab],title="fig:",height=226 ] -plane where theorem [ impro_implicit]-[aimplicit ] and [ bimplicit ] , as well as proposition [ beyond2 ] ( with different values of @xmath466 ) apply . in all graphs
@xmath16 corresponds to the horizontal axis and @xmath260 to the vertical axis and the dotted line shows @xmath14 .
[ th10ab],title="fig:",height=226 ] -plane where theorem [ impro_implicit]-[aimplicit ] and [ bimplicit ] , as well as proposition [ beyond2 ] ( with different values of @xmath466 ) apply . in all graphs
@xmath16 corresponds to the horizontal axis and @xmath260 to the vertical axis and the dotted line shows @xmath14 .
[ th10ab],title="fig:",height=226 ] -plane where theorem [ impro_implicit]-[aimplicit ] and [ bimplicit ] , as well as proposition [ beyond2 ] ( with different values of @xmath466 ) apply . in all graphs
@xmath16 corresponds to the horizontal axis and @xmath260 to the vertical axis and the dotted line shows @xmath14 .
[ th10ab],title="fig:",height=226 ] -plane where theorem [ impro_implicit]-[aimplicit ] and [ bimplicit ] , as well as proposition [ beyond2 ] ( with different values of @xmath466 ) apply . in all graphs
@xmath16 corresponds to the horizontal axis and @xmath260 to the vertical axis and the dotted line shows @xmath14 .
[ th10ab],title="fig:",height=226 ] -plane where theorem [ impro_implicit]-[aimplicit ] and [ bimplicit ] , as well as proposition [ beyond2 ] ( with different values of @xmath466 ) apply . in all graphs
@xmath16 corresponds to the horizontal axis and @xmath260 to the vertical axis and the dotted line shows @xmath14 .
[ th10ab],title="fig:",height=226 ] -plane where theorem [ impro_implicit]-[cimplicit ] applies .
even when we know @xmath43 is invertible in this region as a consequence of theorem [ impro_implicit]-[aimplicit ] , the upper bound on the riesz constant provided by improves upon that provided by ( case @xmath57 ) . in this graph
@xmath16 corresponds to the horizontal axis and @xmath260 to the vertical axis and the dotted line shows @xmath14 .
[ th10c],title="fig:",height=226 ] -plane where theorem [ impro_implicit]-[cimplicit ] applies .
even when we know @xmath43 is invertible in this region as a consequence of theorem [ impro_implicit]-[aimplicit ] , the upper bound on the riesz constant provided by improves upon that provided by ( case @xmath57 ) . in this graph
@xmath16 corresponds to the horizontal axis and @xmath260 to the vertical axis and the dotted line shows @xmath14 .
[ th10c],title="fig:",height=226 ]
|
we improve the currently known thresholds for basisness of the family of periodically dilated @xmath0-sine functions .
our findings rely on a beurling decomposition of the corresponding change of coordinates in terms of shift operators of infinite multiplicity .
we also determine refined bounds on the riesz constant associated to this family .
these results seal mathematical gaps in the existing literature on the subject .
|
the simulations we discuss here allowed us to obtain spectra of the shg response .
we employed comsol multiphysics software ( www.comsol.com ) in order to perform simulations of the linear optical response as described in ref .
@xcite . a unit cell containing a single sic pillar attached to the sic substrate
was constructed , with floquet boundary conditions along the @xmath30-axis and periodic boundary conditions along the @xmath31-axis , perpendicular to the plane of incidence .
a _ p_-polarized plane wave at frequency @xmath32 was launched towards the sic structure at an incident angle of 25@xmath33 .
originating from the _ p_-polarised light source , the electric field @xmath34 inside the sic pillar and substrate was recorded .
then , this electric field was translated into the nonlinear polarization @xmath16 , according to eq .
( 1 ) in the main manuscript . there , the following non - zero components of the nonlinear susceptibility were accounted for : @xmath14 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 . as a next step , @xmath16 in the pillar and the substrate
was regarded as the source of scattered electric field @xmath35 inside the unit cell .
the shg output was then obtained by integrating the power flow through a _
xy_-plane set above the substrate .
sweeping the fundamental frequency and taking the dispersion of both linear and nonlinear sic susceptibilities from refs.@xcite , we calculated several shg spectra for samples with various periodicity of the pillars .
we note that in these calculations , the input power density at fundamental frequency was kept constant , and the shg output power was normalized to the area of the _ xy_-plane @xmath36 . the results of the simulations presented in fig
. [ analysis ] in the main manuscript demonstrate a single pronounced peak corresponding to the excitation of the sphp monopole mode .
barnes , w. l. ; dereux , a. ; ebbesen , t. w. surface plasmon subwavelength optics . _
nature ( london ) _ * 2003 * , _ 424 _ , 824830 maier , s. a. _ plasmonics : fundamentals and applications _ ; springer : new york , 2007 schuller , j. a. ; barnard , e. s. ; cai , w. ; jun , y. c. ; white , j. s. ; brongersma , m. l. plasmonics for extreme light concentration and manipulation .
mater . _ * 2010 * , _ 9 _ , 193204 boriskina , s. v. ; ghasemi , h. ; chen , g. plasmonic materials for energy : from physics to applications .
_ mater . today _ * 2013 * , _ 16 _ , 375386 brongersma , m. l. ; halas , n. j. ; nordlander , p. plasmon - induced hot carrier science and technology . _
* 2015 * , _ 10 _ , 2534 kauranen , m. ; zayats , a. v. nonlinear plasmonics .
photon . _ * 2012 * , _ 6 _ , 737748 hentschel , m. ; utikal , t. ; metzger , b. ; giessen , h. ; lippitz , m. in _ progress in nonlinear nano - optics _ ; sabake , s. , lienau , c. , grunwald , r. , eds . ; springer international publishing : switzerland , 2015 ; chapter 9 , pp 153181 butet , j. ; brevet , p .- f .
; martin , o. j. f. optical second harmonic generation in plasmonic nanostructures : from fundamental principles to advanced applications .
_ acs nano _ * 2015 * , _ 9 _ , 1054510562 vahala , k. j. optical microcavities .
_ nature ( london ) _ * 2003 * , _ 424 _ , 839846 barnes , w. l. surface plasmon - polariton length scales : a route to sub - wavelength optics .
_ j. opt . a : pure appl
_ * 2006 * , _ 8 _ , s87s93 greffet , j .- j . ;
carminati , r. ; joulain , k. ; mulet , j .- p . ;
mainguy , s. ; chen , y. coherent emission of light by thermal sources .
_ nature ( london ) _ * 2002 * , _ 416 _ , 6164 hillenbrand , r. ; taubner , t. ; keilmann , f. phonon - enhanced light - matter interaction at the nanometre scale .
_ nature ( london ) _ * 2002 * , _ 418 _ , 159162 , b. ; korobkin , d. ; fietz , c. ; carole , d. ; ferro , g. ; shvets , g. critically coupled surface phonon - polariton excitation in silicon carbide .
expr . _ * 2007 * , _ 34 _ , 26672669 caldwell , j. d. ; glembocki , o. j. ; francescato , y. ; sharac , n. ; giannini , v. ; bezares , f. j. ; long , j. p. ; owrutsky , j. c. ; vurgaftman , i. ; tischler , j. g. ; wheeler , v. d. ; bassim , n. d. ; shirey , l. m. ; kasica , r. ; maier , s. a. low - loss , extreme subdiffraction photon confinement via silicon carbide localized surface phonon polariton resonators .
_ nano lett . _ * 2013 * , _ 13 _ , 36903697 chen , y. ; francescato , y. ; caldwell , j. d. ; giannini , v. ; ma , t. w. w. ; glembocki , o. j. ; bezares , f. j. ; taubner , t. ; kasica , r. ; hong , m. ; maier , s. a. spectral tuning of localized surface phonon polariton resonators for low - loss mid - ir applications .
_ acs photonics _ * 2014 * , _ 1 _ , 718724 caldwell , j. d. ; kretinin , a. v. ; chen , y. ; giannini , v. ; fogler , m. m. ; francescato , y. ; ellis , c. t. ; tischler , j. g. ; woods , c. r. ; giles , a. j. ; hong , m. ; watanabe , k. ; taniguchi , t. ; maier , s. a. ; novoselov , k. s. sub - diffractional volume - confined polaritons in the natural hyperbolic material hexagonal boron nitride .
commun . _ * 2014 * , _ 5 _ , 5221 dai , s. et al .
tunable phonon polaritons in atomically thin van der waals crystals of boron nitride .
_ science _ * 2014 * , _ 343 _ , 11251129 caldwell , j. d. ; vurgaftman , i. ; tischler , j. g. probing hyperbolic polaritons . _ nat .
photon . _ * 2015 * , _ 9 _ , 638640 li , p. ; lewin , m. ; kretinin , a. v. ; caldwell , j. d. ; novoselov , k. s. ; taniguchi , t. ; watanabe , k. ; gaussmann , f. ; taubner , t. hyperbolic phonon - polaritons in boron nitride for near - field optical imaging and focusing .
commun . _ * 2015 * , _ 6 _ , 7507 dai , s. ; ma , q. ; andersen , t. ; mcleod , a. s. ; fei , z. ; liu , m. k. ; wagner , m. ; watanabe , k. ; taniguchi , t. ; thiemens , m. ; keilmann , f. ; jarillo - herrero , p. ; fogler , m. m. ; basov , d. n. subdiffractional focusing and guiding of polaritonic rays in a natural hyperbolic material .
commun . _ * 2015 * , _ 6 _ , 6963 caldwell , j. d. ; lindsay , l. ; giannini , v. ; vurgaftman , i. ; reinecke , t. l. ; maier , s. a. ; glembocki , o. j. low - loss , infrared and terahertz nanophotonics using surface phonon polaritons .
_ nanophotonics _ * 2014 * , _ 4 _ , 4468 ferguson , b. ; zhang , x .- c .
materials for terahertz science and technology .
photon . _ * 2002 * , _ 1 _ , 2633 ulbricht , r. ; hendry , e. ; shan , j. ; heinz , t. f. ; bonn , m. carrier dynamics in semiconductors studied with time - resolved terahertz spectroscopy . _
_ * 2011 * , _ 83 _ , 543586 kampfrath , t. ; tanaka , k. ; nelson , k. a. resonant and nonresonant control over matter and light by intense terahertz transients .
photon . _ * 2013 * , _ 7 _ , 680690 schllkopf , w. ; gewinner , s. ; junkes , h. ; paarmann , a. ; von helden , g. ; bluem , h. ; todd , a. m. m. the new ir and thz fel facility at the fritz haber institute in berlin .
spie _ * 2015 * , _ 9512 _ , 95121l paarmann , a. ; razdolski , i. ; melnikov , a. ; gewinner , s. ; schllkopf , w. ; wolf , m. second harmonic generation spectroscopy in the reststrahl band of sic using an infrared free - electron laser .
lett . _ * 2015 * , _ 107 _ , 081101 , a. ; razdolski , i. ; gewinner , s. ; schoellkopf , w. ; wolf , m. effects of crystal anisotropy on optical phonon resonances in the mid - infrared second harmonic response of sic . *
2016 * , arxiv:1607.05207 [ condmat.mtrlsci ] carpetti , a. ; walsh , g. f. ; minissale , s. ; trevino , j. ; forestiere , c. ; miano , g. ; negro , l. d. multipolar second harmonic generation from planar arrays of au nanoparticles . _ opt . expr . _ * 2012 * , _ 20 _ , 1579715806 canfield , b. k. ; husu , h. ; laukkanen , j. ; bai , b. ; kuittinen , m. ; turunen , j. ; kauranen , m. local field asymmetry drives second - harmonic generation in noncentrosymmetric nanodimers .
_ nano lett . _ * 2007 * , _ 7 _ , 12511255 raether , h. _ surface plasmons on smooth and rough surfaces and on gratings _ ; springer - verlag : berlin , 1988 agarwal , g. s. ; jha , s. s. surface - enhanced second - harmonic generation at a metallic grating . _
b _ * 1982 * , _ 26 _ , 482 coutaz , j. experimental study of second - harmonic generation from silver gratings of various groove depths . _ j. opt
b _ * 1987 * , _ 4 _ , 105106 quail , j. c. ; simon , h. j. second - harmonic generation from a silver grating with surface plasmons .
b _ * 1988 * , _ 5 _ , 325329 razdolski , i. ; parchenko , s. ; stupakiewicz , a. ; semin , s. ; stognij , a. ; maziewski , a. ; kirilyuk , a. ; rasing , t. second - harmonic generation from a magnetic buried interface enhanced by an interplay of surface plasma resonances . _ acs phot . _
* 2015 * , _ 2 _ , 2026 gubbin , c. r. ; martini , f. ; politi , a. ; maier , s. a. ; de liberato , s. strong and coherent coupling between localized and propagating phonon polaritons .
_ * 2016 * , _ 116 _ , 246402 shan , j. ; dadap , j. ; stiopkin , i. ; reider , g. ; heinz , t. experimental study of optical second - harmonic scattering from spherical nanoparticles .
b _ * 2006 * , _ 73 _ , 023819 kujala , s. ; canfield , b. k. ; kauranen , m. ; svirko , y. ; turunen , j. phonon - enhanced light - matter interaction at the nanometre scale . _ phys .
_ * 2007 * , _ 98 _ , 167403 bachelier , g. ; butet , j. ; russier - antoine , i. ; jonin , c. ; benichou , e. ; brevet , p .- f .
origin of optical second - harmonic generation in spherical gold nanoparticles : local surface and nonlocal bulk contributions .
b _ * 2010 * , _ 82 _ , 235403 butet , j. ; bachelier , g. ; russier - antoine , i. ; jonin , c. ; benichou , e. ; brevet , p .- f . interference between selected dipoles and octupoles in the optical second - harmonic generation from spherical gold nanoparticles . _ phys .
lett . _ * 2010 * , _ 105 _ , 077401 razdolski , i. ; gheorghe , d. g. ; melander , e. ; hjrvarsson , b. ; patoka , p. ; kimel , a. v. ; kirilyuk , a. ; papaioannou , e. t. ; rasing , t. nonlocal nonlinear magneto - optical response of a magnetoplasmonic crystal .
b _ * 2013 * , _ 88 _ , 075436 kruk , s. ; weismann , m. ; bykov , a. y. ; mamonov , e. a. ; kolmychek , i. a. ; murzina , t. ; panoiu , n. c. ; neshev , d. n. ; kivshar , y. s. enhanced magnetic second - harmonic generation from resonant metasurfaces
. _ acs photonics _ * 2015 * , _ 2 _ , 10071012 hille , a. ; moeferdt , m. ; wolff , c. ; matyssek , c. ; rodriguez - oliveros , r. ; prohm , c. ; niegemann , j. ; grafstrom , s. ; eng , l. m. ; ; busch , k. second harmonic generation from metal nano - particle resonators : numerical analysis on the basis of the hydrodynamic drude model .
_ j. phys .
c _ * 2016 * , _ 120 _ , 11631169 bluet , j. ; chourou , k. ; anikin , m. ; madar , r. weak phonon modes observation using infrared reflectivity for 4h , 6h and 15r polytypes .
eng . _ * 1999 * , _ b6162 _ , 212216 patrick , l. infrared absorption in sic polytypes . _ phys .
rev . _ * 1967 * , _ 167 _ , 809813 feldman , d. w. ; parker , jr . , j. h. ; choyke , w. j. ; patrick , l. phonon dispersion curves by raman scattering in sic , polytypes 3c , 4h , 6h , 15r , and 21r . _
rev . _ * 1968 * , _ 173 _ , 787793 engelbrecht , f. ; helbig , r. effect of crystal anisotropy on the infrared reflectivity of 6h sic .
b _ * 1993 * , _ 48 _ , 1569815707 metzger , b. ; gui , l. ; fuchs , j. ; floess , d. ; hentschel , m. ; giessen , h. strong enhancement of second harmonic emission by plasmonic resonances at the second harmonic wavelength .
_ nano lett . _ * 2015 * , _ 15 _ , 39173922 husu , h. ; canfield , b. k. ; laukkanen , j. ; bai , b. ; kuittinen , m. ; turunen , j. ; kauranen , m. local - field effects in the nonlinear optical response of metamaterials .
_ metamaterials _ * 2008 * , _ 2 _ , 155168 palomba , s. ; novotny , l. nonlinear excitation of surface plasmon polaritons by four - wave mixing .
lett . _ * 2008 * , _ 101 _ , 056802 carpetti , a. ; forestiere , c. ; negro , l. d. ; miano , g. full - wave analytical solution of second - harmonic generation in metal nanospheres .
_ plasmonics _ * 2014 * , _ 9 _ , 151166 razdolski , i. ; makarov , d. ; schmidt , o. g. ; kirilyuk , a. ; rasing , t. ; temnov , v. v. nonlinear surface magnetoplasmonics in kretschmann multilayers .
_ acs photonics _ * 2016 * , _ 3 _ , 179183 dai , s. et al .
graphene on hexagonal boron nitride as a tunable hyperbolic metamaterial .
nano . _ * 2015 * , _ 10 _ , 682687 caldwell , j. d. ; vurgaftman , i. ; tischler , j. g. ; glembocki , o. j. ; owrutsky , j. c. ; reinecke , t. l. atomic - scale photonic hybrids for mid - infrared and terahertz nanophotonics .
nano . _ * 2015 * , _ 11 _ , 915
|
we report on strong enhancement of mid - infrared second harmonic generation ( shg ) from sic nanopillars due to the resonant excitation of localized surface phonon - polaritons within the reststrahlen band .
the magnitude of the shg peak at the monopole mode experiences a strong dependence on the resonant frequency beyond that described by the field localization degree and the dispersion of linear and nonlinear - optical sic properties . comparing the results for the identical nanostructures made of 4h and 6h sic polytypes
, we demonstrate the interplay of localized surface phonon polaritons with zone - folded weak phonon modes of the anisotropic crystal . tuning the monopole mode in and out of the region where the zone - folded phonon is excited in 6h - sic , we observe a prominent increase of the already monopole - enhanced shg output when
the two modes are coupled . envisioning this interplay as one of the showcase features of mid - infrared nonlinear nanophononics , we discuss its prospects for the effective engineering of nonlinear - optical materials with desired properties in the infrared spectral range .
light localization in sub - wavelength volumes is a core of modern nanophotonics .
conventional methods of achieving strong confinement of the electromagnetic fields extensively utilize unique properties of surface plasmons .
a remarkable variety of objects and materials supporting these excitations ensures the key role of plasmonics in a broad range of applications @xcite .
apart from unparalleled sensitivity of plasmonic structures to the optical properties of the environment , strong light localization facilitates nonlinear - optical effects @xcite .
owing to the spectral tunability of the localized plasmon resonances and their sizeable nonlinearity , metallic nanostructures of different shapes and sizes have earned their place in nonlinear photonics . despite obvious advantages of plasmon - based nanophotonics , metallic nanoobjects exhibit significant optical losses , which lower the quality factor of the localized surface plasmon modes .
fast plasmon damping ( typically on the order of 10 fs ) due to ohmic losses @xcite thus inhibits nonlinear - optical conversion .
an alternative , promising metal - free approach has been suggested , utilizing polar dielectrics such as sic @xcite or bn @xcite for high - quality light confinement in the mid - infrared ( ir ) . in these materials ,
the subdiffractional confinement of electromagnetic radiation relies upon surface phonon polaritons ( sphp ) in the reststrahlen band : the electric polarization is created due to coherent oscillations of the ions instead of the electron or hole densities . due to the significantly longer scattering times associated with optical phonons
as compared to surface plasmons , the lifetimes of sphps tend to be on the order of picoseconds , much longer than their plasmonic counterparts @xcite .
in addition , due to energies associated with optical phonons , sphps with typical frequencies within the mid - ir ( @xmath0 ) to the thz domain hold high promise for spectroscopic and nanophotonic applications @xcite . in this letter
, we undertake a first step towards the largely unexplored domain of mid - ir nonlinear nanophononics .
we study the nonlinear - optical response of localized sphps using nanostructures made of different polytypes of sic . using free electron laser ( fel ) radiation in the mid - ir spectral range @xcite
, we probe second harmonic generation from rectangular arrays of sub - diffractional , cylindrical sic nanopillars .
the shg yield in the reststrahlen band of sic demonstrates prominent enhancement at the wavelengths associated with the excitation of the sphp eigenmodes of the pillars . depending on both the size and the spatial periodicity of the pillars ,
the shg - probed eigenmode exhibits a spectral shift accompanied with strong variations of the shg intensity . analyzing different sic polytypes
, we demonstrate the interplay of the localized sphps with the zone - folded optical phonon modes .
we further conclude that strong coupling of the two modes allows for a significant additional modulation of the sphp - enhanced shg output .
the schematic of our experimental approach is outlined in fig .
[ general],a .
we employed a non - collinear shg configuration discussed elsewhere @xcite to perform spectroscopic shg measurements on square arrays of 1 @xmath1m - tall 4h - sic and 6h - sic pillars with the main axis of the arrays in the _ xz _ plane of incidence .
the fundamental radiation incident at 28 and 62 degrees with respect to the normal to the sample surface was focused onto the sample with a peak fluence on the order of 10 mj/@xmath2 .
both 4h and 6h - sic samples were c - cut so that the _ c_-axis of the crystals was parallel to the surface normal .
typical shg and linear reflectivity spectra collected using the fel radiation for the two incident polarisations are presented in fig .
[ general],b - e .
there , the respective spectra of the bare substrate are shown for comparison .
for _ p_-polarised fundamental radiation ( fig .
[ general],d ) , the shg response features two pronounced peaks located at the zone - center frequencies of transverse and longitudinal optical phonons in sic @xcite , around 797 @xmath3 and 965 @xmath3 , respectively . the corresponding shg spectrum from the nanopillars demonstrate a much stronger shg signal at around 900 @xmath3 . due to the absence of this peak in the shg spectrum
when the fundamental radiation is _
s_-polarised , we attribute this shg feature to the excitation of the monopole sphp mode in the nanopillars @xcite . in general ,
the outgoing shg field @xmath4 is related to the incident electromagnetic fields @xmath5 via the so - called local field factors @xmath6 : @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the nonlinear polarisation and @xmath9 is the nonlinear susceptibility tensor .
the excitation of the sphp monopole mode leads to strong localization of the _ z_-projection of the fundamental electric field @xmath10 ( normal to the surface plane ) and thus a resonant enhancement of @xmath11 .
the latter results in a pronounced increase of the shg output when the fundamental radiation is _ p_-polarised .
however , the sphp dipole modes observed in the range of 920960 @xmath3 rely on the resonant enhancement of the in - plane electric fields described by the local field factors @xmath12 and thus can be excited with both _
p_- and _ s_-polarised fundamental radiation .
the total shg response is given by a vector sum of the terms on the right hand side of eq .
( 1 ) originating from various tensor components of the nonlinear susceptibility @xmath13 .
as the strength of @xmath14 is the largest in this spectral range @xcite , the sphp monopole mode , with an enhancement of @xmath11 , naturally results in a higher shg output than the dipole modes .
the results of the systematic studies of the shg response of various arrays of nanopillars are summarized in fig .
[ shifts ] for the 4h - sic ( a , c ) and 6h - sic ( b , d ) samples .
the panels ( a - b ) illustrate the evolution of the shg spectra upon varying pillar diameter @xmath15 .
it is seen that upon decreasing @xmath15 , the sphp monopole - driven shg peak exhibits a clear redshift .
remarkably , while the sphp monopole mode shifts in the range of about 890 - 910 @xmath3 , the shg enhancement factor associated with the excitation of the sphp monopole mode varies strongly with @xmath15 .
the panels ( c - d ) offer a zoom - in into the evolution of the sphp monopole mode - driven shg for a large variety of nanopillar arrays , indicating that the variations of the shg enhancement are observed for both 4h and 6h samples .
the dependences of the sphp monopole - driven shg output on the spectral position of the sphp monopole mode for the two sic polytypes are shown in fig .
[ analysis],a with open symbols .
= 1200 , 1100 and 1000 nm , respectively .
, scaledwidth=47.0% ] the strong dispersion in the sic reststrahlen band suggests that the observed spectral dependence of the shg enhancement could be captured in numerical simulations .
we calculated shg response using both linear and nonlinear sic dispersion@xcite , the results of the simulation of the linear optical response@xcite , and nonlinear polarization @xmath16 from eq .
( 1 ) spatially integrated over the sic volume , with the following non - zero components of the nonlinear susceptibility : @xmath14 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
the resultant shg spectra simulated with comsol multiphysics software ( www.comsol.com ) are shown in fig .
[ analysis],b with full symbols .
it is seen that the steep experimental dependence can not be quantitatively described within the simple model used in the calculations , which yields only a moderate increase of the shg output when the sphp monopole mode frequency is decreased .
we note the work of carpetti _
et al_. @xcite where the authors thoroughly examined plasmon - induced shg enhancement from arrays of au nanoparticles as a function of the inter - particle distance @xmath19 . in the regime of @xmath20 ( as it is in our case ) , the dependence of the shg output on @xmath19 was explained in terms of the changing filling factor ( and thus the associated number of active nanoemitters ) .
for very small inter - particle gaps ( @xmath21 ) , a modulation of the shg output has been attributed to the modification of the electromagnetic field localization in the gaps @xcite .
further , a large mismatch between the spatial period of the nanopillars @xmath22 and the resonant light wavelength @xmath23 rules out the excitation of propagating surface polaritons @xcite which are known to enhance the shg output @xcite .
since all these effects are included in our simulations , we conclude that the origin of the observed shg enhancement is unrelated to the periodicity of the array .
an alternative scenario for the observed trend could invoke modifications of the non - local shg contribution enhanced by a regular array structure .
the importance of the non - local shg was already demonstrated in a number of subwavelength - separated plasmonic nanoobjects @xcite .
the amplitude and phase of this non - local shg source depends on the electric field distribution , i.e. on both the pillar size @xmath15 and the periodicity @xmath24 .
as such , the interference conditions between the shg sources vary for different samples , thus resulting in a strong modification of the shg output .
further , the apparent difference in the shape of the resonant shg output for the 4h and 6h samples ( see fig . [ shifts ] ) is related to the anisotropic nature of sic .
the hexagonal sic polytypes are known to exhibit zone - folded weak modes in the reststrahlen region @xcite originating from particular stacking of the atomic layers along the _
c_-axis of the crystal @xcite .
these weakly ir - active zone - folded modes can be visualised in the reflectivity measurements at oblique incidence @xcite .
although zone - folded modes exist in both 4h and 6h polytypes , different stacking of the sic atomic layers is responsible for them having different frequencies , as illustrated in fig .
[ analysis],c - d .
the additional periodicity in the crystal results in folding of the large brillouin zone thus modifying the phonon dispersion and making the excitation of phonons with non - zero wavevectors ( @xmath25 ) possible .
it is seen in fig .
[ analysis],d that the zone - folded mode in the 6h - sic polytype with the reduced wavevector @xmath26 @xmath27 can be excited in the range of @xmath28 @xmath3 which is close to the typical monopole sphp resonant frequency of the sic nanopillars discussed above .
in particular , the interaction of the sphp and zone - folded mode which shifted the apparent spectral positions of the monopole sphp eigenmode in the linear response @xcite , is seen responsible for the complex structure of the resonant shg output in our experiments ( fig .
[ shifts],d ) .
the weak ir activity of the zone - folded modes is related to the large negative dielectric permittivity of sic in the reststrahlen band . as such , the out - of - plane component of the electromagnetic field @xmath10 remains small which inhibits the coupling of incident light to the zone - folded phonon mode .
however , the excitation of the sphp monopole mode in the nanopillars drives a strong increase of @xmath10 , which facilitates the sphp monopole interaction with the zone - folded phonon ( fig .
[ analysis],c ) .
figure [ analysis],a illustrates the effect of the zone - folded mode on the observed shg output .
the open red squares ( 4h ) and blue circles ( 6h ) depict the shg intensity obtained at the sphp monopole ( resonant ) frequencies , and the dashed lines illustrate a clear correlation between the maximum shg output and the spectral position of the sphp monopole peak .
similar trends are observed for the 4h and 6h - sic samples as long as the sphp monopole and the zone - folded mode are well - separated .
when these two resonances start to overlap , an additional enhancement of the shg output produced at the sphp monopole resonance in 6h - sic samples is observed .
moreover , the dependence of the shg signal at the frequency of the zone - folded mode @xmath29 @xmath3 ( green triangles ) exhibits a much faster increase when the two resonances are brought together ( dotted line ) , indicating an efficient interplay between the sphp monopole and the zone - folded mode .
we note that the interaction of the localized sphp eigenmodes and the intrinsic excitations of the medium is a unique fingerprint of mid - ir nanophononics . indeed
, surface plasmon excitations in metals rely on the free electron gas , which is essentially isotropic . as such , the shg output of plasmonic nanostructures is ( i ) largely determined by the metal of choice , usually au , ( ii ) exhibits only weak spectral dependence @xcite and ( iii ) is limited by robust phase relations in the likely case of multiple shg sources @xcite . on the contrary , the flexibility of the sphps is provided by the coupling of the surface phonon polariton excitations to the intrinsic bulk phonon modes . the latter can be engineered by designing artificial metamaterials based on hybrid multilayer structures @xcite , thus allowing for an effective control of their optical properties . to summarize ,
we have observed shg output enhancement associated with the excitation of the sphp eigenmodes in an array of nanopillars grown from sic of different polytypes .
the strongest shg output is associated with the excitation of the monopole sphp mode characterized by strong localization of the normal to surface projection of the electric field @xmath10 .
the spectral positions of the shg peaks shift according to the geometric parameters of the nanophononic structures .
we found a strong dependence of the magnitude of the shg enhancement on the resonant frequency .
this experimentally observed dependence can not be quantitatively described by simply taking into account the sub - diffractional field localization and the dispersion of the linear and nonlinear optical properties of sic .
further , we discuss the interplay of the sphps and the intrinsic crystalline anisotropy for an efficient nonlinear - optical conversion . this mechanism is supported by the shg spectral measurements on the 6h - sic nanopillars where excitation of the sphp monopole mode interacting with the weak zone - folded phonon resulted in an additional enhancement of the shg output .
the presence of intrinsic resonances strongly alters the phase relations in their vicinity , providing a natural way for optimizing the shg response in a relatively narrow spectral range .
our findings demonstrate high potential of mid - ir nonlinear nanophononics as a novel and promising platform for nonlinear optics and illustrate the rich opportunities it provides for efficient control over nonlinear - optical response .
the authors thank g. kichin and a. kirilyuk ( radboud university nijmegen ) for stimulating discussions .
s.a.m . acknowledges the office of naval research , the royal society , and the lee - lucas chair in physics . a.j.g . acknowledges financial support from the nrc / nrl postdoctoral fellowship program .
funding for j.d.c . was provided by the office of naval research through the naval research laboratory s nanoscience institute .
|
with significant research efforts being directed to the development of neurocomputers based on the functionalities of the brain , a seismic shift is expected in the domain of computing based on the traditional von - neumann model .
the @xmath0 @xcite , @xmath1 @xcite and the ibm @xmath2 @xcite are instances of recent flagship neuromorphic projects that aim to develop brain - inspired computing platforms suitable for recognition ( image , video , speech ) , classification and mining problems . while boolean computation is based on the sequential fetch , decode and execute cycles , such neuromorphic computing architectures are massively parallel and event - driven and are potentially appealing for pattern recognition tasks and cortical brain simulations
to that end , researchers have proposed various nanoelectronic devices where the underlying device physics offer a mapping to the neuronal and synaptic operations performed in the brain . the main motivation behind the usage of such non - von neumann post - cmos technologies as neural and synaptic devices stems from the fact that the significant mismatch between the cmos transistors and the underlying neuroscience mechanisms result in significant area and energy overhead for a corresponding hardware implementation .
a very popular instance is the simulation of a cat s brain on ibm s blue gene supercomputer where the power consumption was reported to be of the order of a few @xmath3 @xcite .
while the power required to simulate the human brain will rise significantly as we proceed along the hierarchy in the animal kingdom , actual power consumption in the mammalian brain is just a few tens of watts . in a neuromorphic computing platform
, synapses form the pathways between neurons and their strength modulate the magnitude of the signal transmitted between the neurons .
the exact mechanisms that underlie the `` learning '' or `` plasticity '' of such synaptic connections are still under debate .
meanwhile , researchers have attempted to mimic several plasticity measurements observed in biological synapses in nanoelectronic devices like phase change memories @xcite , @xmath4 memristors @xcite and spintronic devices @xcite , etc .
however , majority of the research have focused on non - volatile plasticity changes of the synapse in response to the spiking patterns of the neurons it connects corresponding to long - term plasticity @xcite and the volatility of human memory has been largely ignored . as a matter of fact , neuroscience studies performed in @xcite have demonstrated that synapses exhibit an inherent learning ability where they undergo volatile plasticity changes and ultimately undergo long - term plasticity conditionally based on the frequency of the incoming action potentials .
such volatile or meta - stable synaptic plasticity mechanisms can lead to neuromorphic architectures where the synaptic memory can adapt itself to a changing environment since sections of the memory that have been not receiving frequent stimulus can be now erased and utilized to memorize more frequent information .
hence , it is necessary to include such volatile memory transition functionalities in a neuromorphic chip in order to leverage from the computational power that such meta - stable synaptic plasticity mechanisms has to offer .
[ drawing1 ] ( a ) demonstrates the biological process involved in such volatile synaptic plasticity changes . during the transmission of each action potential from the pre - neuron to the post - neuron through the synapse , an influx of ionic species like
@xmath5 and @xmath6 causes the release of neurotransmitters from the pre- to the post - neuron .
this results in temporary strengthening of the synaptic strength .
however , in absence of the action potential , the ionic species concentration settles down to its equilibrium value and the synapse strength diminishes . this phenomenon is termed as short - term plasticity ( stp ) @xcite . however ,
if the action potentials occur frequently , the concentration of the ions do not get enough time to settle down to the equilibrium concentration and this buildup of concentration eventually results in long - term strengthening of the synaptic junction .
this phenomenon is termed as long - term potentiation ( ltp ) . while stp is a meta - stable state and lasts for a very small time duration
, ltp is a stable synaptic state which can last for hours , days or even years @xcite .
a similar discussion is valid for the case where there is a long - term reduction in synaptic strength with frequent stimulus and then the phenomenon is referred to as long - term depression ( ltd ) .
such stp and ltp mechanisms have been often correlated to the short - term memory ( stm ) and long - term memory ( ltm ) models proposed by atkinson and shiffrin @xcite ( fig .
[ drawing1](b ) ) .
this psychological model partitions the human memory into an stm and an ltm . on the arrival of an input stimulus , information is first stored in the stm . however , upon frequent rehearsal , information gets transferred to the ltm . while the `` forgetting '' phenomena occurs at a fast rate in the stm , information can be stored for a much longer duration in the ltm . in order to mimic such volatile synaptic plasticity mechanisms , a nanoelectronic device is required that is able to undergo meta - stable resistance transitions depending on the frequency of the input and also transition to a long - term stable resistance state on frequent stimulations .
hence a competition between synaptic memory reinforcement or strengthening and memory loss is a crucial requirement for such nanoelectronic synapses . in the next section
, we will describe the mapping of the magnetization dynamics of a nanomagnet to such volatile synaptic plasticity mechanisms observed in the brain .
let us first describe the device structure and principle of operation of an mtj @xcite as shown in fig .
[ drawing2](a ) .
the device consists of two ferromagnetic layers separated by a tunneling oxide barrier ( tb ) .
the magnetization of one of the layers is magnetically `` pinned '' and hence it is termed as the `` pinned '' layer ( pl ) .
the magnetization of the other layer , denoted as the `` free layer '' ( fl ) , can be manipulated by an incoming spin current @xmath7 .
the mtj structure exhibits two extreme stable conductive states the low conductive `` anti - parallel '' orientation ( ap ) , where pl and fl magnetizations are oppositely directed and the high conductive `` parallel '' orientation ( p ) , where the magnetization of the two layers are in the same direction .
let us consider that the initial state of the mtj synapse is in the low conductive ap state .
considering the input stimulus ( current ) to flow from terminal t2 to terminal t1 , electrons will flow from terminal t1 to t2 and get spin - polarized by the pl of the mtj .
subsequently , these spin - polarized electrons will try to orient the fl of the mtj `` parallel '' to the pl .
it is worth noting here that the spin - polarization of incoming electrons in the mtj is analogous to the release of neurotransmitters in a biological synapse .
the stp and ltp mechanisms exhibited in the mtj due to the spin - polarization of the incoming electrons can be explained by the energy profile of the fl of the mtj .
let the angle between the fl magnetization , @xmath8 , and the pl magnetization , @xmath9 , be denoted by @xmath10 .
the fl energy as a function of @xmath10 has been shown in fig .
[ drawing2](a ) where the two energy minima points ( @xmath11 and @xmath12 ) are separated by the energy barrier , @xmath13 . during the transition from the ap state to the p state , the fl has to transition from @xmath12 to @xmath11 . upon the receipt of an input stimulus , the fl magnetization proceeds `` uphill '' along the energy profile ( from initial point 1 to point 2 in fig .
[ drawing2](a ) ) .
however , since point 2 is a meta - stable state , it starts going `` downhill '' to point 1 , once the stimulus is removed .
if the input stimulus is not frequent enough , the fl will try to stabilize back to the ap state after each stimulus .
however , if the stimulus is frequent , the fl will not get sufficient time to reach point 1 and ultimately will be able to overcome the energy barrier ( point 3 in fig .
[ drawing2](a ) ) .
it is worth noting here , that on crossing the energy barrier at @xmath14 , it becomes progressively difficult for the mtj to exhibit stp and switch back to the initial ap state .
this is in agreement with the psychological model of human memory where it becomes progressively difficult for the memory to `` forget '' information during transition from stm to ltm .
hence , once it has crossed the energy barrier , it starts transitioning from the stp to the ltp state ( point 4 in fig .
[ drawing2](a ) ) .
the stability of the mtj in the ltp state is dictated by the magnitude of the energy barrier .
the lifetime of the ltp state is exponentially related to the energy barrier @xcite .
for instance , for an energy barrier of @xmath15 used in this work , the ltp lifetime is @xmath16 hours while the lifetime can be extended to around @xmath17 years by engineering a barrier height of @xmath18 .
the lifetime can be varied by varying the energy barrier , or equivalently , volume of the mtj .
the stp - ltp behavior of the mtj can be also explained from the magnetization dynamics of the fl described by landau - lifshitz - gilbert ( llg ) equation with additional term to account for the spin momentum torque according to slonczewski @xcite , @xmath19 where , @xmath20 is the unit vector of fl magnetization , @xmath21 is the gyromagnetic ratio for electron , @xmath22 is gilberts damping ratio , @xmath23 is the effective magnetic field including the shape anisotropy field for elliptic disks calculated using @xcite , @xmath24 is the number of spins in free layer of volume @xmath25 ( @xmath26 is saturation magnetization and @xmath27 is bohr magneton ) , and @xmath28 is the spin current generated by the input stimulus @xmath29 ( @xmath30 is the spin - polarization efficiency of the pl ) . thermal noise is included by an additional thermal field @xcite , @xmath31 , where @xmath32 is a gaussian distribution with zero mean and unit standard deviation , @xmath33 is boltzmann constant , @xmath34 is the temperature and @xmath35 is the simulation time step .
equation [ llg ] can be reformulated by simple algebraic manipulations as , @xmath36 hence , in the presence of an input stimulus the magnetization of the fl starts changing due to integration of the input . however , in the absence of the input , it starts leaking back due to the first two terms in the rhs of the above equation .
it is worth noting here that , like traditional semiconductor memories , magnitude and duration of the input stimulus will definitely have an impact on the stp - ltp transition of the synapse .
however , frequency of the input is a critical factor in this scenario . even though the total flux through the device is same ,
the synapse will conditionally change its state if the frequency of the input is high .
we verified that this functionality is exhibited in mtjs by performing llg simulations ( including thermal noise ) .
the conductance of the mtj as a function of @xmath10 can be described by , @xmath37 where , @xmath38 ( @xmath39 ) is the mtj conductance in the p ( ap ) orientation respectively . as shown in fig .
[ drawing2](b ) , the mtj conductance undergoes meta - stable transitions ( stp ) and is not able to undergo ltp when the time interval of the input pulses is large ( @xmath40 ) .
however , on frequent stimulations with time interval as @xmath41 , the device undergoes ltp transition incrementally .
[ drawing2](b ) and ( c ) illustrates the competition between memory reinforcement and memory decay in an mtj structure that is crucial to implement stp and ltp in the synapse .
we demonstrate simulation results to verify the stp and ltp mechanisms in an mtj synapse depending on the time interval between stimulations .
the device simulation parameters were obtained from experimental measurements @xcite and have been shown in table i. [ table ] table i. device simulation parameters [ cols="^,^ " , ] + the mtj was subjected to 10 stimulations , each stimulation being a current pulse of magnitude @xmath42 and @xmath43 in duration . as shown in fig .
[ drawing3 ] , the probability of ltp transition and average device conductance at the end of each stimulation increases with decrease in the time interval between the stimulations .
the dependence on stimulation time interval can be further characterized by measurements corresponding to paired - pulse facilitation ( ppf : synaptic plasticity increase when a second stimulus follows a previous similar stimulus ) and post - tetanic potentiation ( ptp : progressive synaptic plasticity increment when a large number of such stimuli are received successively ) @xcite .
[ drawing4 ] depicts such ppf ( after 2nd stimulus ) and ptp ( after 10th stimulus ) measurements for the mtj synapse with variation in the stimulation interval .
the measurements closely resemble measurements performed in frog neuromuscular junctions @xcite where ppf measurements revealed that there was a small synaptic conductivity increase when the stimulation rate was frequent enough while ptp measurements indicated ltp transition on frequent stimulations with a fast decay in synaptic conductivity on decrement in the stimulation rate .
hence , stimulation rate indeed plays a critical role in the mtj synapse to determine the probability of ltp transition .
the psychological model of stm and ltm utilizing such mtj synapses was further explored in a @xmath44 memory array .
the array was stimulated by a binary image of the purdue university logo where a set of 5 pulses ( each of magnitude @xmath45 and @xmath46 in duration ) was applied for each on pixel .
the snapshots of the conductance values of the memory array after each stimulus have been shown for two different stimulation intervals of @xmath47 and @xmath48 respectively .
while the memory array attempts to remember the displayed image right after stimulation , it fails to transition to ltm for the case @xmath49 and the information is eventually lost @xmath50 after stimulation .
however , information gets transferred to ltm progressively for @xmath51 .
it is worth noting here , that the same amount of flux is transmitted through the mtj in both cases .
the simulation not only provides a visual depiction of the temporal evolution of a large array of mtj conductances as a function of stimulus but also provides inspiration for the realization of adaptive neuromorphic systems exploiting the concepts of stm and ltm .
readers interested in the practical implementation of such arrays of spintronic devices are referred to ref .
the contributions of this work over state - of - the - art approaches may be summarized as follows .
this is the first theoretical demonstration of stp and ltp mechanisms in an mtj synapse .
we demonstrated the mapping of neurotransmitter release in a biological synapse to the spin polarization of electrons in an mtj and performed extensive simulations to illustrate the impact of stimulus frequency on the ltp probability in such an mtj structure .
there have been recent proposals of other emerging devices that can exhibit such stp - ltp mechanisms like @xmath52 synapses @xcite and @xmath53 memristors @xcite .
however , it is worth noting here , that input stimulus magnitudes are usually in the range of volts ( 1.3v in @xcite and 80mv in @xcite ) and stimulus durations are of the order of a few msecs ( 1ms in @xcite and 0.5s in @xcite ) .
in contrast , similar mechanisms can be exhibited in mtj synapses at much lower energy consumption ( by stimulus magnitudes of a few hundred @xmath54 and duration of a few @xmath55 ) .
we believe that this work will stimulate proof - of - concept experiments to realize such mtj synapses that can potentially pave the way for future ultra - low power intelligent neuromorphic systems capable of adaptive learning .
the work was supported in part by , center for spintronic materials , interfaces , and novel architectures ( c - spin ) , a marco and darpa sponsored starnet center , by the semiconductor research corporation , the national science foundation , intel corporation and by the national security science and engineering faculty fellowship .
j. schemmel , j. fieres , and k. meier , in _ neural networks , 2008 .
ijcnn 2008.(ieee world congress on computational intelligence ) .
ieee international joint conference on_.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emieee , 2008 , pp .
431438 .
b. l. jackson , b. rajendran , g. s. corrado , m. breitwisch , g. w. burr , r. cheek , k. gopalakrishnan , s. raoux , c. t. rettner , a. padilla _
et al . _ , `` nanoscale electronic synapses using phase change devices , '' _ acm journal on emerging technologies in computing systems ( jetc ) _ , vol . 9 , no . 2 , p. 12
, 2013 .
m. n. baibich , j. m. broto , a. fert , f. n. van dau , f. petroff , p. etienne , g. creuzet , a. friederich , and j. chazelas , `` giant magnetoresistance of ( 001 ) fe/(001 ) cr magnetic superlattices , '' _ physical review letters _ ,
61 , no .
21 , p. 2472
, 1988 .
g. binasch , p. grnberg , f. saurenbach , and w. zinn , `` enhanced magnetoresistance in layered magnetic structures with antiferromagnetic interlayer exchange , '' _ physical review b _ , vol .
39 , no . 7 , p. 4828
, 1989 .
w. scholz , t. schrefl , and j. fidler , `` micromagnetic simulation of thermally activated switching in fine particles , '' _ journal of magnetism and magnetic materials _ , vol .
233 , no . 3 , pp .
296304 , 2001 .
pai , l. liu , y. li , h. tseng , d. ralph , and r. buhrman , `` spin transfer torque devices utilizing the giant spin hall effect of tungsten , '' _ applied physics letters _ , vol .
101 , no . 12 , p. 122404
, 2012 .
h. noguchi , k. ikegami , k. kushida , k. abe , s. itai , s. takaya , n. shimomura , j. ito , a. kawasumi , h. hara _
et al . _ , in _ solid - state circuits conference-(isscc ) , 2015 ieee international_.1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emieee , 2015 , pp .
t. ohno , t. hasegawa , t. tsuruoka , k. terabe , j. k. gimzewski , and m. aono , `` short - term plasticity and long - term potentiation mimicked in single inorganic synapses , '' _ nature materials _ , vol .
10 , no . 8 , pp . 591595 , 2011 .
r. yang , k. terabe , y. yao , t. tsuruoka , t. hasegawa , j. k. gimzewski , and m. aono , `` synaptic plasticity and memory functions achieved in a wo3- x - based nanoionics device by using the principle of atomic switch operation , '' _ nanotechnology _ , vol .
24 , no .
38 , p. 384003
|
synaptic memory is considered to be the main element responsible for learning and cognition in humans .
although traditionally non - volatile long - term plasticity changes have been implemented in nanoelectronic synapses for neuromorphic applications , recent studies in neuroscience have revealed that biological synapses undergo meta - stable volatile strengthening followed by a long - term strengthening provided that the frequency of the input stimulus is sufficiently high .
such `` memory strengthening '' and `` memory decay '' functionalities can potentially lead to adaptive neuromorphic architectures . in this paper , we demonstrate the close resemblance of the magnetization dynamics of a magnetic tunnel junction ( mtj ) to short - term plasticity and long - term potentiation observed in biological synapses . we illustrate that , in addition to the magnitude and duration of the input stimulus , frequency of the stimulus plays a critical role in determining long - term potentiation of the mtj .
such mtj synaptic memory arrays can be utilized to create compact , ultra - fast and low power intelligent neural systems .
|
the segmentation process as a whole can be thought of as consisting of two tasks : recognition and delineation .
recognition is to determine roughly `` where '' the object is and to distinguish it from other object - like entities .
although delineation is the final step for defining the spatial extent of the object region / boundary in the image , an efficient recognition strategy is a key for successful delineation . in this study ,
a novel , general method is introduced for object recognition to assist in segmentation ( delineation ) tasks .
it exploits the pose relationship that can be encoded , via the concept of ball scale ( b - scale ) @xcite , between the binary training objects and their associated images . as an alternative to the manual methods based on initial placement of the models by an expert @xcite in the literature ,
model based methods can be employed for recognition .
for example , in @xcite , the position of an organ model ( such as liver ) is estimated by its histogram . in @xcite ,
generalized hough transform is succesfully extended to incorporate variability of shape for 2d segmentation problem .
atlas based methods are also used to define initial position for a shape model . in @xcite
, affine registration is performed to align the data into an atlas to determine the initial position for a shape model of the knee cartilage .
similarly , a popular particle filtering algorithm is used to detect the starting pose of models for both single and multi - object cases @xcite . however , due to the large search space and numerous local minimas in most of these studies , conducting a global search on the entire image is not a feasible approach . in this paper
, we investigate an approach of automatically recognizing objects in 3d images without performing elaborate searches or optimization .
the proposed method consists of the following key ideas and components : * 1 .
model building : * after aligning image data from all @xmath0 subjects in the training set into a common coordinate system via 7-parameter affine registration , the live - wire algorithm @xcite is used to segment @xmath1 different objects from @xmath0 subjects .
segmented objects are used for the automatic extraction of landmarks in a slice - by - slice manner @xcite . from the landmark information for all objects ,
a model assembly @xmath2 is constructed .
b - scale encoding : * the b - scale value at every voxel in an image helps to understand `` objectness '' of a given image without doing explicit segmentation . for each voxel ,
the radius of the largest ball of homogeneous intensity is weighted by the intensity value of that particular voxel in order to incorporate appearance ( texture ) information into the object information ( called intensity weighted b - scale : @xmath3 ) so that a model of the correlations between shape and texture can be built . a simple and proper way of thresholding the b - scale image yields a few largest balls remaining in the image .
these are used for the construction of the relationship between the segmented training objects and the corresponding images .
the resulting images have a strong relationship with the actual delineated objects .
relationship between @xmath2 and @xmath3 : * a principal component @xmath4 system is built via pca for the segmented objects in each image , and their mean @xmath5 system , denoted @xmath6 , is found over all training images .
@xmath6 has an origin and three @xmath5 axes .
similarly the mean @xmath5 system , denoted @xmath7 , for intensity weighted b - scale images @xmath8 is found .
finally the transformation @xmath9 that maps @xmath7 to @xmath6 is found .
given an image @xmath10 to be segmented , the main idea here is to use @xmath9 to facilitate a quick placement of @xmath2 in @xmath10 with a proper pose as indicated in step 4 below . *
hierarchical recognition : * for a given image @xmath10 , @xmath3 is obtained and its @xmath5 system , denoted @xmath11 is computed subsequently . assuming the relationship of @xmath11 to @xmath6 to be the same as of @xmath7 to @xmath6 , and assuming that @xmath6 offers the proper pose of @xmath2 in the training images , we use transformation @xmath9 and @xmath11 to determine the pose of @xmath2 in @xmath10 .
this level of recognition is called coarse recognition . further refinement of the recognition can be done using the skin boundary object in the image with the requirement that a major portion of @xmath2 should lie inside the body region delimited by the skin boundary . moreover
, a little search inside the skin boundary can be done for the fine tuning , however , since offered coarse recognition method gives high recognition rates , there is no need to do any elaborate searches .
we will focus on the fine tuning of coarse recognition for future study .
the finest level of recognition requires the actual delineation algorithm itself , which is a hybrid method in our case and called gc - asm ( synergistic integration of graph - cut and active shape model ) .
this delineation algorithm is presented in a companion paper submitted to this symposium @xcite .
a convenient way of achieving incorporation of prior information automatically in computing systems is to create and use a flexible _ model _ to encode information such as the expected _ size _ , _ shape _ , _ appearance _ , and _ position _ of objects in an image @xcite . among such information ,
_ shape _ and _ appearance _ are two complementary but closely related attributes of biological structures in images , and hence they are often used to create statistical models . in particular , shape has been used both in high and low level image analysis tasks extensively , and it has been demonstrated that shape models ( such as active shape models ( asms ) ) can be quite powerful in compensating for misleading information due to noise , poor resolution , clutter , and occlusion in the images @xcite .
therefore , we use asm @xcite to estimate population statistics from a set of examples ( training set ) . in order to guarantee 3d point correspondences required by asm
, we build our statistical shape models combining semi - automatic methods : ( 1 ) manually selected anatomically correspondent slices by an expert , and ( 2 ) semi - automatic way of specifying key points on the shapes starting from the same anatomical locations .
once step ( 1 ) is accomplished , the remaining problem turns into a problem of establishing point correspondence in 2d shapes , which is easily solved .
it is extremely significant to choose correct correspondences so that a good representation of the modelled object results .
although landmark correspondence is usually established manually by experts , it is time - consuming , prone to errors , and restricted to only 2d objects @xcite .
because of these limitations , a semi - automatic landmark tagging method , _ equal space landmarking _ , is used to establish correspondence between landmarks of each sample shape in our experiments .
although this method is proposed for 2d objects , and equally spacing a fixed number of points for 3d objects is much more difficult , we use equal space landmarking technique in pseudo-3d manner where 3d object is annotated slice by slice .
let @xmath12 be a single shape and assume that its finite dimensional representation after the landmarking consisting of @xmath13 landmark points with positions @xmath14 , where @xmath15 are cartesian coordinates of the @xmath16 point on the shape @xmath17 .
equal space landmark tagging for points @xmath18 for @xmath19 on shape boundaries ( contours ) starts by selecting an initial point on each shape sample in training set and equally space a fixed number of points on each boundary automatically @xcite . selecting the starting point
has been done manually by annotating the same anatomical point for each shape in the training set .
figure [ img : landmarking_abd ] shows annotated landmarks for five different objects ( skin , liver , right kidney , left kidney , spleen ) in a ct slice of the abdominal region .
note that different number of landmarks are used for different objects considering their size . [ cols="^ " , ]
\(1 ) the b - scale image of a given image captures object morphometric information without requiring explicit segmentation .
b - scales constitute fundamental units of an image in terms of largest homogeneous balls situated at every voxel in the image .
the b - scale concept has been previously used in object delineation , filtering and registration .
our results suggest that their ability to capture object geography in conjunction with shape models may be useful in quick and simple yet accurate object recognition strategies .
( 2 ) the presented method is general and does not depend on exploiting the peculiar characteristics of the application situation .
( 3 ) the specificity of recognition increases dramatically as the number of objects in the model increases .
( 4 ) we emphasize that both modeling and testing procedures are carried out on the ct data sets that are part of the clinical pet / ct data routinely acquired in our hospital .
the ct data set are thus of relatively poor ( spatial and contrast ) resolution compared to other ct - alone studies with or without contrast .
we expect better performance if higher resolution ct data are employed in modeling or testing .
this paper is published in spie medical imaging conference - 2010 .
falcao , a.x . ,
udupa , j.k . ,
samarasekera , s. , sharma , s. , hirsch , b.e . , and lotufo , r.a . , 1998
user - steered image segmentation paradigms : live wire and live lane . graph .
models image process .
60 ( 4 ) , pp .
233260 .
kokkinos , i. , maragos , p. , 2009 .
synergy between object recognition and image segmentation using the expectation - maximization algorithm .
ieee transactions on pattern analysis and machine intelligience , vol.31 ( 8) , pp.14861501 .
brejl , m. , sonka , m. , 2000 .
object localization and border detection criteria design in edge - based image segmentation : automated learning from examples .
ieee transactions on medical imaging , vol.19 ( 10 ) , pp.973985 .
fripp , j. , crozier , s. , warfield , s.k . ,
ourselin , s. , 2005 .
automatic initialisation of 3d deformable models for cartilage segmentation . in proceedings of digital image computing : techniques and applications , pp .
|
this paper investigates , using prior shape models and the concept of ball scale ( b - scale ) , ways of automatically recognizing objects in 3d images without performing elaborate searches or optimization .
that is , the goal is to place the model in a single shot close to the right pose ( position , orientation , and scale ) in a given image so that the model boundaries fall in the close vicinity of object boundaries in the image .
this is achieved via the following set of key ideas : ( a ) a semi - automatic way of constructing a multi - object shape model assembly .
( b ) a novel strategy of encoding , via b - scale , the pose relationship between objects in the training images and their intensity patterns captured in b - scale images . ( c )
a hierarchical mechanism of positioning the model , in a one - shot way , in a given image from a knowledge of the learnt pose relationship and the b - scale image of the given image to be segmented .
the evaluation results on a set of 20 routine clinical abdominal female and male ct data sets indicate the following : ( 1 ) incorporating a large number of objects improves the recognition accuracy dramatically .
( 2 ) the recognition algorithm can be thought as a hierarchical framework such that quick replacement of the model assembly is defined as coarse recognition and delineation itself is known as finest recognition .
( 3 ) scale yields useful information about the relationship between the model assembly and any given image such that the recognition results in a placement of the model close to the actual pose without doing any elaborate searches or optimization . ( 4 ) effective object recognition can make delineation most accurate .
|
one surprising result that has come out of the more than 200 extrasolar planet discoveries to date is the wide range of eccentricities observed . unlike our own solar system
, many of the extrasolar planets which are not tidally locked to their host stars have moderate eccentricities ( @xmath1 ) , and 15 planets have high eccentricities ( @xmath0 ) .
these observations have spawned several theories as to the origin of highly eccentric extrasolar planets .
one such method , planet - planet scattering , occurs when multiple jovian planets form several astronomical units ( au ) from the host star and then interact , leaving one in an eccentric orbit and often ejecting the other @xcite .
this method has been proposed to explain the architecture of the @xmath2 and planetary system @xcite , which contains a hot jupiter as well as two jovian planets in moderately eccentric orbits .
@xcite suggested a merger scenario in which inner protoplanets perturb each other and merge to form a single massive , eccentric planet with @xmath3 and @xmath4 au .
interactions with stellar companions are another possible way to boost a planet s eccentricity .
of the 15 stars hosting a planet with @xmath0 , six are also known to possess stellar - mass companions in wide binary orbits : hd 3651 @xcite , hd 20782 @xcite , hd 80606 , hd 89744 @xcite , 16 cyg b , and hd 222582 @xcite .
if the inclination angle between the planetary orbit and a stellar companion is large , the kozai mechanism @xcite can induce large - amplitude oscillations in the eccentricity of the planet ( e.g. malmberg et al .
these oscillations can be damped by general relativistic effects and by interaction with other planets , and hence are most effective in systems with a single planet in an orbit @xmath51 au from the host star @xcite .
the kozai mechanism has been suggested to explain the high eccentricity of 16 cyg bb @xcite and hd 80606b @xcite .
@xcite found the inclination of 16 cyg b orbiting the system barycenter to lie between 100 and 160 degrees , where 90 degrees is an edge - on orientation .
however , it is the difference in inclination between the orbital planes of the planetary and stellar companion that is critical in determining the importance of the kozai mechanism , and the inclination of the planet s orbit is generally not known for non - transiting systems . of the 192 known planetary systems , 23 ( 12% )
are multi - planet systems .
recent discoveries of additional objects in systems known to host at least one planet @xcite suggest that multiple - planet systems are common .
of particular interest are systems which host a jovian planet and a low - mass `` hot neptune , '' e.g. 55 cnc ( = hd 75732 ) , gj 876 , @xmath6 arae ( = hd 160691 ) , gl 777a ( = hd 190360 ) . motivated by the discoveries of hot neptunes in known planetary systems , we have undertaken an intensive survey of selected single - planet systems to search for additional low - mass companions .
three of the planetary systems discussed in this paper ( hd 3651 , hd 80606 , hd 89744 ) are part of this campaign .
the excellent radial - velocity precision of the high resolution spectrograph on the hobby - eberly telescope ( het ) , combined with queue - scheduling , allow us to time the observations in such a way as to minimize phase gaps in the orbit of the known planet , and also to act quickly on potential new planet candidates .
the use of the het in this manner is discussed further in @xcite with regard to the discovery of hd 37605b . in this work
, we aim to combine observational limits on additional planets in known planetary systems with dynamical constraints obtained by n - body simulations .
the observations address the question : what additional planets are ( or are not ) in these systems ?
the dynamical simulations can answer the question : where are additional planets possible ?
section 2 describes the observations and the test particle simulations for six highly eccentric planetary systems : hd 3651 , hd 37605 , hd 45350 , hd 80606 , hd 89744 , and 16
cyg b. we have chosen these systems based on two criteria : ( 1 ) each hosts a planet with @xmath0 , and ( 2 ) each has been observed by the planet search programs at mcdonald observatory . in 3 , we present and discuss the results of the updated orbital fits , dynamical simulations , and detection limit computations .
five of the six stars considered in this work have been observed with the mcdonald observatory 9.2 m hobby - eberly telescope ( het ) using its high resolution spectrograph ( hrs ) @xcite .
a full description of the het planet search program is given in @xcite .
for 16 cyg b , observations from mcdonald observatory were obtained only with the 2.7 m harlan j. smith ( hjs ) telescope ; the long - term planet search program on this telescope is described in @xcite .
all available published data on these systems were combined with our data from mcdonald observatory in the orbit fitting procedures . to place constraints on the architecture of planetary systems , we would like to know where additional objects can remain in stable orbits in the presence of the known planet(s ) .
we performed test particle simulations using swifthal / swift.html . ]
@xcite to investigate the dynamical possibility of additional low - mass planets in each of the six systems considered here .
low - mass planets can be treated as test particles since the exchange of angular momentum with jovian planets is small .
we chose the regularized mixed - variable symplectic integrator ( rmvs3 ) version of swift for its ability to handle close approaches between massless , non - interacting test particles and planets .
particles are removed if they are ( 1 ) closer than 1 hill radius to the planet , ( 2 ) closer than 0.05 au to the star , or ( 3 ) farther than 10 au from the star .
since the purpose of these simulations is to determine the regions in which additional planets could remain in stable orbits , we set this outer boundary because the current repository of radial - velocity data can not detect objects at such distances .
the test particle simulations were set up following the methods used in @xcite , with the exception that only initially circular orbits are considered in this work . for each planetary system ,
test particles were placed in initially circular orbits spaced every 0.002 au in the region between 0.05 - 2.0 au .
we have chosen to focus on this region because the duration of our high - precision het data is currently only 2 - 4 years for the objects in this study .
the test particles were coplanar with the existing planet , which had the effect of confining the simulation to two dimensions .
input physical parameters for the known planet in each system were obtained from our keplerian orbit fits described in 3.1 , and from recent literature for 16 cyg b @xcite and hd 45350 @xcite .
the planetary masses were taken to be their minimum values ( sin @xmath7 ) .
the systems were integrated for @xmath8 yr , following @xcite and allowing completion of the computations in a reasonable time .
we observed that nearly all of the test - particle removals occurred within the first @xmath9 yr ; after this time , the simulations had essentially stabilized to their final configurations .
we present updated keplerian orbital solutions for hd 3651b , hd 37605b , hd 80606b , and hd 89744b in table 1 .
a summary of the data used in our analysis is given in table 2 , and the het radial velocities are given in tables 3 - 6 .
the velocity uncertainties given for the het data represent internal errors only , and do not include any external sources of error such as stellar `` jitter . ''
the parameters for the remaining two planets , hd 45350b and 16 cyg bb , are taken from @xcite and @xcite , respectively .
radial velocity measurements from the het are given for hd 45350 in @xcite , and velocities for 16 cyg b from the hjs telescope are given in @xcite .
as in @xcite , all available published data were combined with those from mcdonald , and the known planet in each system was fit with a keplerian orbit using gaussfit @xcite , allowing the velocity offset between each data set to be a free parameter .
examination of the residuals to our keplerian orbit fits revealed no evidence for additional objects in any of the six systems in this study .
the saturn - mass ( m sin @xmath10 ) planet hd 3651b was discovered by @xcite using observations from lick and keck .
we fit these data , which were updated in @xcite , in combination with observations from the hjs and het at mcdonald observatory .
the het data , which consist of multiple exposures per visit , were binned using the inverse - variance weighted mean value of the velocities in each visit .
the standard error of the mean was added in quadrature to the weighted rms about the mean velocity to generate the error bar of each binned point ( n=29 ) .
the rms about the combined fit for each dataset is : lick & keck6.6 , het9.4 , hjs12.2 .
the fitted orbital parameters for hd 3651b are of comparable precision to those reported in @xcite , and agree within 2@xmath11 .
the recent discovery of a t dwarf companion to hd 3651 @xcite prompts an interesting exercise : can the radial - velocity trend due to this object be detected in the residuals after removing the planet ?
we detect a slope of @xmath12 yr@xmath13 , indicating that we are indeed able to discern a trend which is possibly due to the binary companion .
however , the reduced @xmath14 of the orbital solution is not significantly improved by the inclusion of a linear trend ( @xmath15=0.18 ) .
the parameters given in table 1 were obtained from the fit which did not include a trend .
we present 23 new het observations for hd 37605 obtained since its announcement by @xcite .
the data now span a total of 1065 days .
the best fit is obtained by including an acceleration of @xmath16 yr@xmath13 , indicating a distant orbiting body .
such a finding would lend support to the hypothesis that very eccentric single - planet systems originate by interactions within a wide binary system .
the shortest period that this outer companion could have and still remain consistent with the observed acceleration and its uncertainty over the timespan of the observations is about 40 yr , assuming a circular orbit .
this object would then have a minimum mass in the brown dwarf range
. the planet orbiting hd 80606 , first announced by @xcite , is the most eccentric extrasolar planet known , with @xmath17 ( table 1 ) .
we have fit the coralie data in combination with the keck data given in @xcite and 23 observations from het .
the extreme velocity variations induced by this planet greatly increase the sensitivity of orbit fits to the weighting of individual measurements . since the uncertainties of the het velocities given in tables 3 - 6 represent internal errors only , we experimented with adding 1 - 7 of radial - velocity `` jitter '' in quadrature before fitting the data for hd 80606 .
for all of these jitter values , the fitted parameters remained the same within their uncertainties .
table 1 gives the parameters derived from a fit which added 3.5 of jitter @xcite to the het data .
the rms about the combined fit is : coralie18.7 , het7.5 , keck5.6 .
@xcite noted that the eccentricity @xmath18 and the argument of periastron @xmath19 had to be held fixed in their fit to the keck data alone .
however , the large number of measurements included in this work allowed gaussfit to converge with all parameters free . for hd 89744b , we combine data from the het with 6 measurements from the hjs telescope and lick data from @xcite .
the het data were binned in the same manner as for hd 3651 , resulting in n=33 independent visits .
the rms about the combined fit for each dataset is : lick17.1 , het10.7 , hjs9.5 . as with hd 3651b ,
our derived parameters agree with those of @xcite within 2@xmath11 .
the scatter about our fit remains large , most likely due to the star s early spectral type ( f7v ) , which hinders precision radial - velocity measurements due to the smaller number of spectral lines .
for example , the f7v star hd 221287 was recently found to host a planet @xcite ; despite the superb instrumental precision of the harps spectrograph , that orbital solution has a residual rms of 8.5 .
the results of the dynamical simulations are shown in figures 1 - 3 .
the survival time of the test particles is plotted against their initial semimajor axis .
as shown in figure 1 , the short - period planets hd 3651 and hd 37605 sweep clean the region inside of about 0.5 au . in both of these systems , however , a small number of test particles remained in low - eccentricity orbits near the known planet s apastron distance , near the 1:2 mean - motion resonance ( mmr ) . in the hd 3651 system , particles remained stable beyond about 0.6 au , which is not surprising given the low mass of the planet . for hd 37605 ,
two distinct strips of stability are seen in fig . 1 , corresponding to the 1:2 and 1:3 mmrs .
the eccentricity of the test particles in the region of the 1:2 mmr oscillated between 0.00 and 0.06 .
particles in 1:3 mmr oscillated in eccentricity with a larger range , up to @xmath20 , which is expected due to secular forcing . as with hd 3651 , the region beyond about 0.8 au
was essentially unaffected by the planet .
figure 2 shows the results for the hd 45350 and hd 80606 systems .
the long period ( 963.6 days ) and relatively large mass ( m sin @xmath21=1.8 ) of hd 45350b restricted stable orbits to the innermost 0.2 au .
these test particles oscillated in eccentricity up to @xmath22 .
the 4 planet orbiting hd 80606 removed all test particles to a distance of about 1.5 au , and only beyond 1.75 au did test particles remain in stable orbits for the duration of the simulation ( @xmath8 yr ) .
a region of instability is evident at 1.9 au due to the 8:1 mmr .
figure 3 shows that hd 89744b eliminated all test particles except for a narrow region near the 8:3 resonance .
for the 16 cyg b system , only particles inside of about 0.3 au remained stable , leaving open the possibility of short - period planets .
the surviving particles oscillated in eccentricity up to @xmath23 , but these simulations treat the star as a point mass , and hence tidal damping of the eccentricity is not included
. our results are consistent with those of @xcite , who investigated dynamical stability in extrasolar planetary systems and found that no test particles survived in the habitable zones of the hd 80606 , hd 89744 , and 16 cyg b systems .
three of these systems ( hd 3651 , hd 80606 , hd 89744 ) were monitored intensely with the het as part of a larger effort to search for low - mass , short period planets .
no evidence was found for any such objects in these or any of the six systems in this work .
we then asked what limits can be set on additional planets using the high - precision het data we have obtained .
the procedure for determining companion limits was identical to the method described in @xcite , except that in this work , the best - fit keplerian orbit for the known planet ( see 3.1 ) was removed before performing the limits computations . in this way
, we determined the radial - velocity amplitude @xmath24 for which 99% of planets would have been detected in the residuals .
the eccentricity of the injected test signals was chosen to be the mean eccentricity of the surviving particles from the simulations described in 3.2 . only the regions in which test particles survived were considered in these limits computations .
the results of these computations were highly varied , reflecting the differing observing strategies employed for these six objects .
in particular , hd 3651 , hd 80606 , and hd 89744 were monitored intensely with the het as part of a search for short - period objects , whereas hd 37605 and hd 45350 were only observed sporadically after the known planet orbits were defined and published @xcite , and 16 cyg b has only been observed with the hjs telescope at a frequency of at most once per month .
the companion limits are shown in figures 4 - 6 ; planets with masses above the solid line can be ruled out by the data with 99% confidence .
not surprisingly , the tightest limits were obtained for hd 3651 ( figure 4 ) , which had a total of 195 measurements , including 29 independent het visits .
for periods less than about 1 year , we can exclude planets with m sin @xmath21 2 neptune masses .
similar results were obtained for 16 cyg b ( n=161 ) , where the limits approach a neptune mass ( figure 6 ) .
since the detection limits generally improve with the addition of more data and with higher - quality data , we can define a quantity to measure the goodness of the limits .
a simple choice would be @xmath25 , where @xmath26 is the total number of observations , and @xmath27 is the mean uncertainty of the radial - velocity measurements .
the values of @xmath26 and @xmath27 are given in table 2 . in the hd 45350 system , the results of the dynamical simulations complement those of the detection limit determinations .
very tight limits are obtained in close orbits ( @xmath280.2 au ) . in this region ,
test particles were stable ( fig . 2 ) and our observations can exclude planets with m sin _ i _ between about 1 and 4 neptune masses .
similar results were obtained for the 16 cyg b system , in which test particles remained stable inward of @xmath29 0.3 au . in that region ,
planets of 1 - 3 neptune masses can be excluded by our limits determinations ( fig .
6 ) . in most of the limits determinations
, there are multiple `` blind spots '' evident where the periodogram method failed to significantly recover the injected signals .
typically this occurs at certain trial periods for which the phase coverage of the observational data is poor , and often at the 1-month and 1-year windows . for none of hd 37605 ( fig . 4 ) , hd 80606 ( fig . 5 ) , or hd 89744 ( fig .
6 ) could additional companions be ruled out below about 0.7 , and for most orbital periods tested , the limits were substantially worse .
one possible explanation for this result is that the sampling of the observations was poorly distributed in phase for many of the injected test signals , making significant recovery by the periodogram method difficult .
this is evidenced by the `` jagged '' regions in the plots .
also , the intrinsic scatter for those three systems was too large to permit tight limits determination .
this is certainly reasonable for the f7 star hd 89744 .
the three systems with the best limits ( hd 3651 , hd 45350 , and 16 cyg b ) also had the lowest rms scatter about their orbital solutions ( mean=@xmath30 ; table 1 ) .
in contrast , the mean rms for the remaining three systems was @xmath31 .
additional factors such as a paucity of data ( hd 37605 ) and short time baselines ( hd 80606 , hd 89744 ) made the determination of useful companion limits challenging for some of the planetary systems in this study .
we have shown that for a sample of six highly eccentric extrasolar planetary systems , there is no evidence for additional planets .
test particle simulations show that there are regions detectable by current surveys ( i.e. for @xmath32 au ) where additional objects can exist . for hd 3651 and hd 37605
, we find that protected resonances are also present .
combining these simulations with detection limits computed using new high - precision het data combined with all available published data is particularly effective for the hd 3651 and hd 45350 systems .
additional short - period planets can be ruled out down to a few neptune masses in the dynamically stable regions in these systems .
this material is based upon work supported by the national aeronautics and space administration under grant nos .
nng04g141 g and nng05g107 g issued through the terrestrial planet finder foundation science program .
we are grateful to the het tac for their generous allocation of telescope time for this project .
we also would like to thank barbara mcarthur for her assistance with gaussfit software .
we thank the referee , greg laughlin , for his careful review of this manuscript .
this research has made use of nasa s astrophysics data system ( ads ) , and the simbad database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france .
the hobby - eberly telescope ( het ) is a joint project of the university of texas at austin , the pennsylvania state university , stanford university , ludwig - maximilians - universit " at mnchen , and georg - august - universit " at g " ottingen the het is named in honor of its principal benefactors , william p. hobby and robert e. eberly .
lllllllll hd 3651 b & 62.197@xmath330.012 & 53932.2@xmath330.4 & 0.630@xmath330.046 & 250.7@xmath336.3 & 15.6@xmath331.1 & 0.20@xmath330.01 & 0.280@xmath330.006 & 7.1 + hd 37605 b & 55.027@xmath330.009 & 52992.8@xmath330.1 & 0.677@xmath330.009 & 218.4@xmath331.7 & 201.5@xmath333.9 & 2.39@xmath330.12 & 0.263@xmath330.006 & 13.0 + hd 45350 b & 963.6@xmath333.4 & 51825.3@xmath337.1 & 0.778@xmath330.009 & 343.4@xmath332.3 & 58.0@xmath331.7 & 1.79@xmath330.14 & 1.92@xmath330.07 & 9.1 + hd 80606 b & 111.428@xmath330.002 & 53421.928@xmath330.004 & 0.933@xmath330.001 & 300.4@xmath330.3 & 470.2@xmath332.5 & 4.10@xmath330.12 & 0.460@xmath330.007 & 13.5 + hd 89744 b & 256.78@xmath330.05 & 53816.1@xmath330.3 & 0.689@xmath330.006 & 194.1@xmath330.6 & 263.2@xmath333.9 & 7.92@xmath330.23 & 0.91@xmath330.01 & 14.4 + 16 cyg b b & 799.5@xmath330.6 & 50539.3@xmath331.6 & 0.689@xmath330.011 & 83.4@xmath332.1 & 51.2@xmath331.1 & 1.68@xmath330.07 & 1.68@xmath330.03 & 10.6 + lllll hd 3651 & 163 & 3.4 & & @xcite + hd 3651 & 3 & 6.1 & & hjs + hd 3651 & 29 & 2.1 & & het + hd 3651 ( total ) & 195 & 3.2 & 7083 & + hd 37605 ( total ) & 43 & 2.9 & 1065 & het + hd 45350 & 38 & 2.8 & & @xcite + hd 45350 & 28 & 4.2 & & het + hd 45350 & 47 & 8.9 & & hjs + hd 45350 ( total ) & 113 & 5.7 & 2265 & + hd 80606 & 61 & 13.7 & & @xcite + hd 80606 & 46 & 5.1 & & @xcite + hd 80606 & 23 & 2.5 & & het + hd 80606 ( total ) & 130 & 8.7 & 2893 & + hd 89744 & 50 & 11.2 & & @xcite + hd 89744 & 33 & 3.2 & & het + hd 89744 & 6 & 9.4 & & hjs + hd 89744 ( total ) & 89 & 8.1 & 2687 & + 16 cyg b & 95 & 6.3 & & @xcite + 16 cyg b & 29 & 19.7 & & hjs phase ii + 16 cyg b & 37 & 7.4 & & hjs phase iii + 16 cyg b ( total ) & 161 & 9.0 & 6950 & + lrr [ tbl-3 ] 53581.87326 & -19.1 & 2.9 + 53581.87586 & -19.4 & 2.7 + 53581.87846 & -20.7 & 2.7 + 53600.79669 & -11.5 & 2.4 + 53600.79860 & -15.5 & 3.0 + 53600.80050 & -22.8 & 2.9 + 53604.79166 & -15.8 & 1.9 + 53604.79356 & -18.8 & 2.1 + 53604.79548 & -21.3 & 2.1 + 53606.78169 & -19.3 & 1.8 + 53606.78360 & -14.8 & 2.1 + 53606.78551 & -24.0 & 1.8 + 53608.77236 & -18.8 & 1.9 + 53608.77426 & -18.0 & 1.9 + 53608.77617 & -18.8 & 1.8 + 53615.96280 & -28.0 & 2.6 + 53615.96471 & -31.9 & 2.4 + 53615.96662 & -37.8 & 2.5 + 53628.74050 & -6.8 & 2.2 + 53628.74240 & -14.5 & 2.4 + 53628.74431 & -5.5 & 2.2 + 53669.61012 & -18.2 & 2.1 + 53669.61203 & -19.2 & 2.2 + 53669.61394 & -17.7 & 2.4 + 53678.78954 & -10.6 & 2.4 + 53678.79141 & -8.6 & 2.3 + 53678.79332 & -2.3 & 2.1 + 53682.78423 & -15.4 & 2.2 + 53682.78609 & -15.0 & 2.3 + 53682.78801 & -11.9 & 2.3 + 53687.77684 & 11.3 & 2.2 + 53687.77875 & 8.7 & 2.2 + 53687.78066 & 15.9 & 2.2 + 53691.75967 & 9.6 & 2.2 + 53691.76158 & 20.3 & 2.1 + 53691.76349 & 15.9 & 2.0 + 53696.75837 & 16.1 & 1.8 + 53696.76028 & 18.6 & 1.8 + 53696.76220 & 20.0 & 2.0 + 53694.75275 & 18.0 & 1.9 + 53694.75466 & 15.1 & 2.0 + 53694.75656 & 17.8 & 2.0 + 53955.83401 & -0.5 & 1.9 + 53955.83593 & -1.2 & 2.0 + 53955.83785 & 1.3 & 1.9 + 53956.82850 & 0.4 & 2.0 + 53956.83046 & -1.0 & 2.0 + 53956.83236 & -5.4 & 2.2 + 53957.82201 & -2.1 & 2.0 + 53957.82392 & -1.3 & 2.0 + 53957.82583 & -3.6 & 2.0 + 53973.80721 & 9.8 & 7.3 + 53973.81020 & 3.5 & 2.3 + 53973.81200 & -3.5 & 2.0 + 53976.78393 & -10.4 & 2.4 + 53976.78586 & -5.4 & 2.1 + 53976.78778 & -6.7 & 2.3 + 53978.97197 & -3.8 & 2.6 + 53985.95886 & -9.0 & 2.3 + 53985.96079 & 4.3 & 3.3 + 53987.95335 & -8.3 & 2.2 + 53987.95527 & -8.0 & 2.2 + 53987.95719 & -12.0 & 2.3 + 53989.73817 & -13.2 & 2.2 + 53989.74009 & -13.2 & 2.1 + 53989.74203 & -18.6 & 2.1 + 54003.70719 & 2.0 & 2.2 + 54003.70915 & 4.7 & 2.4 + 54005.68297 & 7.0 & 2.5 + 54005.68488 & 11.1 & 2.0 + 54005.68690 & 10.2 & 2.1 + 54056.77919 & -7.5 & 2.2 + 54056.78110 & -11.5 & 2.1 + 54056.78302 & -9.6 & 2.3 + 54062.55119 & 20.1 & 1.8 + 54062.55312 & 21.9 & 2.0 + 54062.55505 & 20.9 & 2.0 + 54064.54710 & 12.8 & 2.0 + 54064.54902 & 16.7 & 2.1 + 54064.55094 & 16.6 & 2.1 + 54130.55316 & 19.1 & 2.4 + 54130.55508 & 16.9 & 2.5 + 54130.55701 & 17.6 & 2.5 + lrr [ tbl-4 ] 53002.67151 & 487.6 & 3.8 + 53003.68525 & 495.5 & 3.0 + 53006.66205 & 496.2 & 3.0 + 53008.66407 & 501.3 & 2.9 + 53010.80477 & 499.8 & 2.9 + 53013.79399 & 482.1 & 2.6 + 53042.72797 & 269.7 & 2.8 + 53061.66756 & 489.0 & 2.6 + 53065.64684 & 479.0 & 2.8 + 53071.64383 & 463.8 & 2.6 + 53073.63819 & 460.4 & 2.6 + 53082.62372 & 422.8 & 2.5 + 53083.59536 & 422.2 & 2.8 + 53088.59378 & 418.6 & 4.0 + 53089.59576 & 379.1 & 2.2 + 53092.59799 & 343.7 & 2.5 + 53094.58658 & 323.2 & 2.4 + 53095.58642 & 302.1 & 2.4 + 53096.58744 & 302.1 & 3.2 + 53098.57625 & 193.8 & 2.7 + 53264.95137 & 164.9 & 3.0 + 53265.94744 & 112.9 & 3.0 + 53266.94598 & 113.2 & 3.7 + 53266.95948 & 74.6 & 3.6 + 53266.97396 & 119.2 & 8.0 + 53283.92241 & 471.6 & 2.7 + 53318.81927 & 213.3 & 3.0 + 53335.92181 & 496.9 & 2.6 + 53338.90602 & 493.9 & 2.6 + 53377.81941 & 109.1 & 2.7 + 53378.81189 & 214.6 & 2.7 + 53379.80225 & 338.3 & 2.6 + 53381.64429 & 436.1 & 2.7 + 53384.64654 & 482.9 & 2.8 + 53724.85584 & 468.2 & 2.6 + 53731.69723 & 435.4 & 2.7 + 53738.67472 & 404.3 & 2.6 + 53743.81020 & 400.5 & 2.6 + 53748.64724 & 348.4 & 2.7 + 54039.85015 & 272.5 & 3.1 + 54054.96457 & 437.4 & 2.7 + 54055.95279 & 422.0 & 2.9 + 54067.76282 & 376.4 & 2.6 + lrr [ tbl-5 ] 53346.88103 & -20.8 & 3.0 + 53358.02089 & -49.5 & 2.7 + 53359.82400 & -60.4 & 3.0 + 53361.02985 & -64.7 & 2.5 + 53365.03079 & -77.4 & 2.4 + 53373.98282 & -88.4 & 3.0 + 53377.80112 & -105.5 & 2.4 + 53379.75230 & -109.3 & 2.7 + 53389.74170 & -115.3 & 2.5 + 53391.74400 & -129.4 & 2.4 + 53395.72763 & -146.4 & 2.3 + 53399.72518 & -158.4 & 2.5 + 53401.72497 & -174.7 & 2.7 + 53414.67819 & -219.8 & 3.0 + 53421.85529 & 261.0 & 2.2 + 53423.86650 & 322.1 & 2.0 + 53424.85231 & 245.9 & 2.1 + 53432.87120 & 87.5 & 1.9 + 53433.60628 & 70.0 & 2.1 + 53446.79322 & 4.5 & 1.9 + 54161.85400 & -109.5 & 2.8 + 54166.83797 & -119.3 & 2.4 + 54186.76189 & -184.2 & 2.3 + lrr [ tbl-6 ] 53709.89685 & -184.5 & 2.3 + 53723.85188 & -238.6 & 2.2 + 53723.85367 & -238.2 & 2.5 + 53723.85546 & -227.7 & 2.3 + 53727.84394 & -238.9 & 2.5 + 53727.84573 & -244.9 & 2.4 + 53727.84752 & -242.9 & 2.6 + 53736.81887 & -257.6 & 2.5 + 53736.82100 & -248.2 & 2.9 + 53736.82315 & -253.4 & 2.4 + 53738.03261 & -246.7 & 2.8 + 53738.03441 & -243.3 & 2.4 + 53738.03620 & -236.0 & 2.5 + 53738.80860 & -240.5 & 2.6 + 53738.81040 & -258.9 & 2.4 + 53738.81219 & -249.3 & 2.5 + 53734.81795 & -242.8 & 2.6 + 53734.81973 & -243.9 & 2.8 + 53734.82152 & -248.5 & 2.4 + 53742.79119 & -252.0 & 2.8 + 53742.79299 & -257.2 & 2.8 + 53742.79479 & -239.7 & 2.8 + 53751.78199 & -257.4 & 2.9 + 53751.78378 & -263.1 & 2.5 + 53751.78558 & -268.0 & 2.3 + 53753.78155 & -273.1 & 2.5 + 53753.78381 & -278.7 & 2.5 + 53753.78607 & -266.4 & 2.4 + 53755.76038 & -286.6 & 2.3 + 53755.76218 & -266.5 & 2.6 + 53755.76397 & -274.9 & 2.7 + 53746.81506 & -257.1 & 1.9 + 53746.81778 & -250.9 & 2.1 + 53746.82051 & -245.2 & 2.3 + 53757.77002 & -277.6 & 2.4 + 53757.77181 & -280.3 & 2.4 + 53757.77360 & -288.7 & 2.2 + 53797.64609 & -439.8 & 3.1 + 53797.64834 & -462.6 & 2.8 + 53797.65059 & -452.5 & 2.9 + 53809.62428 & -658.6 & 2.4 + 53809.62700 & -658.8 & 2.5 + 53809.62972 & -659.2 & 2.3 + 53837.76359 & -304.3 & 3.0 + 53837.76670 & -324.0 & 2.9 + 53837.78731 & -308.6 & 2.7 + 53837.79077 & -285.2 & 2.6 + 53866.69987 & -215.9 & 1.7 + 53866.70329 & -228.3 & 1.7 + 53866.70670 & -220.4 & 1.8 + 53868.68349 & -251.6 & 3.8 + 53868.68562 & -208.6 & 2.9 + 53868.68777 & -247.4 & 9.7 + 53875.66956 & -215.7 & 1.6 + 53883.65565 & -213.8 & 1.8 + 53883.65837 & -209.2 & 1.7 + 53883.66109 & -200.4 & 1.7 + 53890.63776 & -203.4 & 1.7 + 53890.63954 & -202.6 & 1.9 + 53890.64134 & -203.2 & 1.9 + 53893.62959 & -193.8 & 2.0 + 53893.63139 & -189.3 & 1.9 + 53893.63318 & -189.7 & 1.8 + 54047.94811 & -375.2 & 4.8 + 54047.94991 & -353.2 & 4.5 + 54047.95172 & -362.6 & 4.4 + 54050.96248 & -415.0 & 2.6 + 54050.96453 & -423.0 & 2.5 + 54050.96657 & -420.1 & 2.4 + 54052.96488 & -426.8 & 2.3 + 54052.96762 & -437.1 & 2.5 + 54052.97035 & -447.6 & 2.5 + 54056.94606 & -468.0 & 3.0 + 54056.94786 & -466.4 & 2.6 + 54056.94964 & -479.4 & 2.8 + 54063.92981 & -599.1 & 2.1 + 54063.93166 & -594.8 & 2.3 + 54063.93348 & -592.3 & 2.4 + 54073.91213 & -685.8 & 2.8 + 54073.91476 & -688.7 & 2.9 + 54073.91739 & -704.4 & 2.7 + 54122.01039 & -220.8 & 2.5 + 54122.01243 & -219.1 & 2.6 + 54122.01447 & -218.4 & 2.8 + 54129.74214 & -215.7 & 2.6 + 54129.74491 & -224.4 & 3.0 + 54129.74768 & -223.7 & 3.1 + 54160.65850 & -189.5 & 3.2 + 54160.66031 & -181.8 & 2.7 + 54160.66212 & -204.8 & 3.2 + 54163.66458 & -213.9 & 3.1 + 54163.66643 & -200.8 & 2.9 + 54163.66828 & -208.0 & 3.2 + 54165.88148 & -208.5 & 2.7 +
|
long time coverage and high radial velocity precision have allowed for the discovery of additional objects in known planetary systems .
many of the extrasolar planets detected have highly eccentric orbits , which raises the question of how likely those systems are to host additional planets .
we investigate six systems which contain a very eccentric ( @xmath0 ) planet : hd 3651 , hd 37605 , hd 45350 , hd 80606 , hd 89744 , and 16
cyg b. we present updated radial - velocity observations and orbital solutions , search for additional planets , and perform test particle simulations to find regions of dynamical stability .
the dynamical simulations show that short - period planets could exist in the hd 45350 and 16 cyg b systems , and we use the observational data to set tight detection limits , which rule out additional planets down to a few neptune masses in the hd 3651 , hd 45350 , and 16 cyg b systems .
|
biological aggregations such as fish schools , bird flocks , bacterial colonies , and insect swarms @xcite have characteristic morphologies governed by the group members interactions with each other and with their environment .
the _ endogenous _ interactions , _
i.e. _ , those between individuals , often involve organisms reacting to each other in an attractive or repulsive manner @xcite when they sense each other either directly by sound , sight , smell or touch , or indirectly via chemicals , vibrations , or other signals .
a typical modeling strategy is to treat each individual as a moving particle whose velocity is influenced by social ( interparticle ) attractive and repulsive forces @xcite . in contrast , the _ exogenous _ forces describe an individual s reaction to the environment , for instance a response to gravity , wind , a chemical source , a light source , a food source , or a predator .
the superposition of endogenous and exogenous forces can lead to characteristic swarm shapes ; these equilibrium solutions are the subject of our present study .
more specifically , our motivation is rooted in our previous modeling study of the swarming desert locust _
schistocerca gregaria _ @xcite . in some parameter regimes of our model (
presented momentarily ) , locusts self - organize into swarms with a peculiar morphology , namely a bubble - like shape containing a dense group of locusts on the ground and a flying group of locusts overhead ; see figure [ fig : locust](bc ) .
the two are separated by an unoccupied gap . with wind
, the swarm migrates with a rolling motion .
locusts at the front of the swarm fly downwards and land on the ground .
locusts on the ground , when overtaken by the flying swarm , take off and rejoin the flying group ; see figure [ fig : locust](cd ) .
the presence of an unoccupied gap and the rolling motion are found in real locust swarms @xcite . as we will show throughout this paper , features of swarms such as dense concentrations and disconnected components ( that is , the presence of gaps ) arise as properties of equilibria in a general model of swarming .
the model of @xcite is [ eq : locusts ] @xmath1 which describes @xmath2 interacting locusts with positions @xmath3 .
the direction of locust swarm migration is strongly correlated with the direction of the wind @xcite and has little macroscopic motion in the transverse direction , so the model is two - dimensional , _
i.e. _ , @xmath4 where the @xmath5 coordinate is aligned with the main current of the wind and @xmath6 is a vertical coordinate . as the velocity of each insect is simply a function of position ,
the model neglects inertial forces .
this so - called kinematic assumption is common in swarming models , and we discuss it further in section [ sec : discretemodel ] .
the first term on the right - hand side of ( [ eq : locusts ] ) describes endogenous forces ; @xmath7 measures the force that locust @xmath8 exerts on locust @xmath9 .
the first term of @xmath7 describes attraction , which operates with strength @xmath10 over a length scale @xmath11 and is necessary for aggregation .
the second term is repulsive , and operates more strongly and over a shorter length scale in order to prevent collisions .
time and space are scaled so that the repulsive strength and length scale are unity .
the second term on the right - hand side of ( [ eq : locusts ] ) describes gravity , acting downwards with strength @xmath12 .
the last term describes advection of locusts in the direction of the wind with speed @xmath13 .
furthermore , the model assumes a flat impenetrable ground . since locusts rest and feed while grounded , their motion in that state is negligible compared to their motion in the air .
thus we add to ( [ eq : locusts ] ) the stipulation that grounded locusts whose vertical velocity is computed to be negative under ( [ eq : locusts ] ) remain stationary .
as mentioned above , for some parameters , ( [ eq : locusts ] ) forms a bubble - like shape .
this can occur even in the absence of wind , that is , when @xmath14 ; see figure [ fig : locust](b ) .
the bubble is crucial , for it allows the swarm to roll in the presence of wind . as discussed in @xcite , states which lack a bubble in the absence of wind do not migrate in the presence of wind .
conditions for bubble formation , even in the equilibrium state arising in the windless model , have not been determined ; we will investigate this problem .
some swarming models adopt a discrete approach as in our locust example above because of the ready connection to biological observations .
a further advantage is that simulation of discrete systems is straightforward , requiring only the integration of ordinary differential equations .
however , since biological swarms contain many individuals , the resulting high - dimensional systems of differential equations can be difficult or impossible to analyze .
furthermore , for especially large systems , computation , though straightforward , may become a bottleneck .
continuum models are more amenable to analysis .
one well - studied continuum model is that of @xcite , a partial integrodifferential equation model for a swarm population density @xmath15 in one spatial dimension : @xmath16 the density @xmath17 obeys a conservation equation , and @xmath18 is the velocity field , which is determined via convolution with the antisymmetric pairwise endogenous force @xmath19 , the one - dimensional analog of a social force like the one in ( [ eq : locusts ] ) .
the general model ( [ eq : introeq ] ) displays at least three solution types as identified in @xcite .
populations may concentrate to a point , reach a finite steady state , or spread . in @xcite , we identified conditions on the social interaction force @xmath19 for each behavior to occur .
these conditions map out a `` phase diagram '' dividing parameter space into regions associated with each behavior .
similar phase diagrams arise in a dynamic particle model @xcite and its continuum analog @xcite .
models that break the antisymmetry of @xmath19 ( creating an asymmetric response of organisms to each other ) display more complicated phenomena , including traveling swarms @xcite .
many studies have sought conditions under which the population concentrates to a point mass . in a one - dimensional domain ,
collapse occurs when the force @xmath19 is finite and attractive at short distances @xcite .
the analogous condition in higher dimensions also leads to collapse @xcite .
one may also consider the case when the velocity includes an additional term describing an exogenous force , @xmath20 in this case , equilibrium solutions consisting of sums of point - masses can be linearly and nonlinearly stable , even for social forces @xmath19 that are repulsive at short distances @xcite .
these results naturally lead to the question of whether a solution can be continued past the time at which a mass concentrates . early work on a particular generalization of ( [ eq : introeq ] )
suggests the answer is yes @xcite . for ( [ eq : introeq ] ) itself in arbitrary dimension
, there is an existence theory beyond the time of concentration @xcite .
some of the concentration solutions mentioned above are equilibrium solutions
. however , there may be classical equilibria as well .
for most purely attractive @xmath19 , the only classical steady states are constant in space , as shown via a variational formulation of the steady state problem @xcite
. however , these solutions are non - biological , as they contain infinite mass . there
do exist attractive - repulsive @xmath19 which give rise to compactly - supported classical steady states of finite mass .
for instance , in simulations of ( [ eq : introeq ] ) , we found classical steady state solutions consisting of compactly supported swarms with jump discontinuities at the edges of the support @xcite . in our current work , we will find equilibria that contain both classical and nonclassical components .
many of the results reviewed above were obtained by exploiting the underlying gradient flow structure of ( [ eq : introeq2 ] ) .
there exists an energy functional @xmath21 = \frac{1}{2 } \int_\mathbb{r } \int_\mathbb{r } \rho(x ) \rho(y ) q(x - y)\,dx\,dy + \int_\mathbb{r } f(x)\rho(x)\,dx,\ ] ] which is minimized under the dynamics .
this energy can be interpreted as the continuum analog of the summed pairwise energy of the corresponding discrete ( particle ) model @xcite .
we will also exploit this energy to find equilibrium solutions and study their stability . in this paper
, we focus on equilibria of swarms and ask the following questions : * what sorts of density distributions do swarming systems make ? are they classical or nonclassical ? * how are the final density distributions reached affected by endogenous interactions , exogenous forces , boundaries , and the interplay of these ? *
how well can discrete and continuum swarming systems approximate each other ? to answer these questions , we formulate a general mathematical framework for discrete , interacting swarm members in one spatial dimension , also subject to exogenous forces .
we then derive an analogous continuum model and use variational methods to seek minimizers of its energy .
this process involves solution of a fredholm integral equation for the density .
for some choices of endogenous forces , we are able to find exact solutions . perhaps surprisingly , they are not always classical . in particular , they can involve @xmath0-function concentrations of mass at the domain boundary .
the rest of this paper is organized as follows . in section
[ sec : formulation ] , we create the mathematical framework for our study , and derive conditions for a particular density distribution to be an equilibrium solution , and to be stable to various classes of perturbations . in sections [ sec : repulsive ] and [ sec : morse ] ,
we demonstrate different types of swarm equilibria via examples . in section
[ sec : repulsive ] , we focus on purely repulsive endogenous interactions .
we consider a bounded domain with no exogenous forces , a half - line subject to gravitational forces , and an unbounded domain subject to a quadratic exogenous potential , modeling attraction to a light , chemical , or nutrient source .
for all three situations , we find exact solutions for swarm equilibria .
for the first two examples , these equilibria consist of a density distribution that is classical in the interior of the domain , but contains @xmath0-functions at the boundaries . for the third example , the equilibrium is compactly supported with the density dropping discontinuously to zero at the edge of the support .
for all three examples , we compare analytical solutions from the continuum framework to equilibria obtained from numerical simulation of the underlying discrete system . the two agree closely even for small numbers of discrete swarm members .
section [ sec : morse ] is similar to section [ sec : repulsive ] , but we now consider the more complicated case of endogenous interactions that are repulsive on short length scales and attractive over longer ones ; such forces are typical for swarming biological organisms . in section [ sec : locust - ground ] , we revisit locust swarms , focusing on their bubble - like morphology as described above , and on the significance of dimensionality . in a one - dimensional model corresponding to a vertical slice of a wide locust swarm under the influence of social interactions and gravity ,
energy minimizers can reproduce concentrations of locusts on the ground and a group of locusts above the ground , but there can not be a separation between the two groups
. however , a quasi - two - dimensional model accounting for the influence of the swarm s horizontal extent does , in contrast , have minimizers which qualitatively correspond to the biological bubble - like swarms .
consider @xmath2 identical interacting particles ( swarm members ) in one spatial dimension with positions @xmath22 .
assume that motion is governed by newton s law , so that acceleration is proportional to the sum of the drag and motive forces .
we will focus on the case where the acceleration is negligible and the drag force is proportional to the velocity .
this assumption is appropriate when drag forces dominate momentum , commonly known in fluid dynamics as the low reynolds number or stokes flow regime . in the swarming literature , the resulting models , which are first - order in time , are known as _
kinematic models have been used in numerous studies of swarming and collective behavior , including @xcite ) .
we now introduce a general model with both endogenous and exogenous forces , as with the locust model ( [ eq : locusts ] ) .
the endogenous forces act between individuals and might include social attraction and repulsion ; see @xcite for a discussion . for simplicity , we assume that the endogenous forces act in an additive , pairwise manner .
we also assume that the forces are symmetric , that is , the force induced by particle @xmath9 on particle @xmath8 is the opposite of that induced by particle @xmath8 on particle @xmath9 .
exogenous forces might include gravity , wind , and taxis towards light or nutrients .
the governing equations take the form [ eq : discretesystem ] @xmath23 eventually we will examine the governing equations for a continuum limit of the discrete problem . to this end , we have introduced a _ social mass _ @xmath24 which scales the strength of the endogenous forces so as to remain bounded for @xmath25 .
@xmath26 is the total social mass of the ensemble .
( [ eq : vee ] ) defines the velocity rule ; @xmath27 is the endogenous velocity one particle induces on another , and @xmath28 is the exogenous velocity . from our assumption of symmetry of endogenous forces , @xmath19 is odd and in most realistic situations is discontinuous at the origin .
each force , @xmath28 and @xmath19 , can be written as the gradient of a potential under the relatively minor assumption of integrability .
as pointed out in @xcite , most of the specific models for mutual interaction forces proposed in the literature satisfy this requirement .
many exogenous forces including gravity and common forms of chemotaxis do so as well . under this assumption , we rewrite ( [ eq : discretesystem ] ) as a gradient flow , @xmath29 where the potential @xmath30 is [ eq : discrete_gradient ] @xmath31 the double sum describes the endogenous forces and the single sum describes the exogenous forces . also , @xmath32 is the mutual interaction potential , which is even , and @xmath33 is the exogenous potential .
the flow described by ( [ eq : discretegradient1 ] ) will evolve towards minimizers of the energy @xmath30 . up to now
, we have defined the problem on @xmath34 . in order to confine the problem to a particular domain @xmath35
, one may use the artifice of letting the exogenous potential @xmath33 tend to infinity on the complement of @xmath35 . while this discrete model is convenient from a modeling and simulation standpoint , it is difficult to analyze . presently , we will derive a continuum analog of ( [ eq : discretesystem ] ) .
this continuum model will allow us to derive equilibrium solutions and determine their stability via the calculus of variations and integral equation methods . to derive a continuum model , we begin by describing our evolving ensemble of discrete particles with a density function @xmath15 equal to a sum of @xmath0-functions .
( for brevity , we suppress the @xmath36 dependence of @xmath17 in the following discussion . )
our approach here is similar to @xcite .
these @xmath0-functions have strength @xmath24 and are located at the positions of the particles : @xmath37 the total mass is @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the domain of the problem . using ( [ eq : deltafuncs ] ) , we write the discrete velocity @xmath40 in terms of a continuum velocity @xmath41 .
that is , we require @xmath42 where @xmath43 by conservation of mass , the density obeys @xmath44 with no mass flux at the boundary .
we now introduce an energy functional @xmath45 $ ] which is analogous to the discrete potential @xmath30 in ( [ eq : generic_potential ] ) : @xmath46 = \frac{1}{2 } \int_{{\omega}}\int_{{\omega}}\rho(x ) \rho(y ) q(x - y)\,dx\,dy + \int_{{\omega}}f(x)\rho(x)\,dx.\ ] ] this expression follows from the discrete potential , @xmath21 = m { { \cal{w}}}(x_1,\ldots , x_n),\ ] ] remembering the @xmath0-function definition of the density ( [ eq : deltafuncs ] ) .
the rate of energy dissipation is @xmath47}{dt } = - \int_\omega \rho(x ) \left\{v(x)\right\}^2\,dx,\ ] ] where we assume that there is no mass flux at the boundary of @xmath35 .
a consequence of this boundary condition is that under some conditions , mass may concentrate at the boundary of the domain , and we will later see this manifest . since energy is dissipated , we conclude that stable equilibria correspond to minimizers of @xmath48 .
imagine now that the energy ( [ eq : continuum_energy ] ) is defined for _ any _ density distribution @xmath17 , not just ensembles of @xmath0-functions .
we will find minimizers for the continuous energy ( [ eq : continuum_energy ] ) and show that they approximate solutions to the discrete problem in the limit of large @xmath2 . to establish a correspondence between the two frameworks , consider a continuous distribution @xmath49 with total mass @xmath26 .
define the cumulative density function @xmath50 where the dummy coordinate @xmath51 is taken to the left of the support of @xmath49 .
we seek a discrete approximation of @xmath2 @xmath0-functions , @xmath52 the associated cumulative density function @xmath53 is @xmath54 & x = x_i,\quad i = 1,\ldots , n \\ i m & x_i < x < x_{i+1 } , \quad i = 1,\ldots , n-1\\ m & x > x_n , \end{cases}\ ] ] where we have used the convention that integrating up to a @xmath0-function yields half the mass of integrating through it .
to establish our correspondence , we require that @xmath55 , which in turn determines the particle positions @xmath22 . as @xmath25 for fixed @xmath26 , this step function @xmath53 converges uniformly to @xmath56 .
the correspondence goes in the opposite direction as well .
we can begin with an ensemble of @xmath0-functions @xmath57 placed at the positions of discrete swarm members , as shown in figure [ fig : delta_schematic](a ) .
we can find the corresponding cumulative density @xmath53 via ( [ eq : psid ] ) and interpolate to construct the continuum cumulative density @xmath56 .
the functions @xmath53 and @xmath56 are shown as the dotted red step function and the blue curve , respectively , in figure [ fig : delta_schematic](b ) .
we may then differentiate to find an approximation @xmath49 , as shown in figure [ fig : delta_schematic](c ) .
we use this correspondence in sections [ sec : repulsive ] through [ sec : locust - ground ] to compare analytical results for the continuum system ( [ eq : pde ] ) with numerical simulations of the discrete system ( [ eq : discretesystem ] ) .
we close this subsection by reiterating why we have made a correspondence between the discrete and continuum systems .
we use the continuous framework to find equilibrium solutions analytically via variational and integral equation methods .
the correspondence above allows a direct comparison to numerical simulation of the discrete system .
we use a variational calculation to determine conditions for a density distribution to be a minimizer of @xmath48 .
our starting point is the energy functional ( [ eq : continuum_energy ] ) subject to the mass constraint ( [ eq : mass_constraint ] ) .
let @xmath58 here @xmath59 is an equilibrium solution of mass @xmath26 and @xmath60 is a small perturbation of zero mass , so we have @xmath61 inspired by biological observations of swarms , we focus on equilibria with finite extent and take the support of @xmath59 to be a finite subset of the domain @xmath35 .
we refer to the support of @xmath59 as @xmath62 .
this assumption , combined with the fact that the density is nonnegative , restricts the perturbation @xmath63 to be nonnegative on @xmath64 , the complement of @xmath62 .
we write @xmath65 = w[{{\bar \rho } } ] + \epsilon w_1[{{\bar \rho}},{{\tilde \rho } } ] + \epsilon^2 w_2[{{\tilde \rho}},{{\tilde \rho}}],\ ] ] where @xmath66 and @xmath67 are the first and second variations respectively .
this expression is exact because @xmath48 is quadratic in @xmath17 ( see eq .
[ eq : continuum_energy ] ) .
we analyze these variations to determine necessary and sufficient conditions for a candidate solution @xmath59 to be a minimizer of @xmath48 .
our strategy is to consider two classes of perturbations @xmath63 .
first , we consider perturbations whose support lies in @xmath62 . in order for @xmath59 to be extremal
, @xmath66 must vanish . for it to be a minimizer
, @xmath67 must be positive .
since ( [ eq : expand_w ] ) is exact , @xmath68 guarantees that @xmath59 is both a local and global minimum with respect to this first class of perturbations .
the second class of perturbations we consider ( of which the first class is a subset ) consists of perturbations on the entire domain @xmath39 . as mentioned above
, these perturbations must be nonnegative in @xmath64 in order to maintain positivity of @xmath17 . a necessary condition for @xmath59 to be a local minimizer
is that @xmath69 for this class of perturbations .
if in addition @xmath67 remains positive for this larger class of perturbations , then @xmath59 is a global minimizer as well .
we derive the first variation @xmath66 by substituting ( [ eq : expand_rho ] ) into ( [ eq : expand_w ] ) and expanding to first order in @xmath70 , which yields @xmath71 = \int_\omega { { \tilde \rho}}\left [ \int_\omega q(x - y ) { { \bar \rho}}(y)\,dy+f(x ) \right ] \,dx .\ ] ] consider the first class of perturbations , whose support lies in @xmath62 . as the perturbation @xmath63 is arbitrary and of zero mass , for the first variation @xmath66 to vanish , it must be true that @xmath72 the same result can be found by a lagrange multiplier argument including the constant mass as a constraint .
the multiplier @xmath73 has a physical interpretation ; it is the energy per unit mass an additional test mass would feel due to the exogenous potential and the interaction with @xmath59 . thus far
, we have shown that a necessary condition for @xmath59 to be an equilibrium solution is that it satisfies the fredholm integral equation of the first kind for the nonnegative density @xmath59 , @xmath74 = \lambda - f(x ) , \quad { \cal i}[{{\bar \rho}}(x ) ] \equiv \int_{{\omega_{{{\bar \rho}}}}}q(x - y ) { { \bar \rho}}(y)\,dy , \label{eq : fie}\ ] ] as well as the mass constraint ( [ eq : mass1 ] ) . in order for @xmath59 to be a minimizer with respect to the first class of perturbations
, the second variation must be positive . substituting ( [ eq : expand_rho ] ) into ( [ eq : expand_w ] ) yields @xmath75 = \int_{{\omega_{{{\bar \rho}}}}}\int_{{{\omega_{{{\bar \rho } } } } } } q(x - y ) { { \tilde \rho}}(x ) { { \tilde \rho}}(y)\,dx\,dy.\ ] ] the sign of @xmath67 can be assessed in a number of ways .
we first derive a sufficient condition on the fourier transform of @xmath32 for @xmath67 to be nonnegative for the first class of perturbations .
define the fourier transform @xmath76 then we have @xmath77 & = & \int_{{\omega_{{{\bar \rho}}}}}\int_{{{\omega_{{{\bar \rho } } } } } } q(x - y ) { { \tilde \rho}}(x ) { { \tilde \rho}}(y)\,dx\,dy,\\ & = & \int_{-\infty}^{\infty } \int_{-\infty}^{\infty } q(x - y ) { { \tilde \rho}}(x ) { { \tilde \rho}}(y)\,dx\,dy , \\ & = & \int_{-\infty}^{\infty } { { \tilde \rho}}(x ) \left [ q(x ) * { { \tilde \rho}}(x ) \right]\,dx , \\ & = & \frac{1}{2\pi } \int_{-\infty}^{\infty } | \widehat{{{\tilde \rho}}}(k)|^2 \widehat{q}(k)~dk.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we have used the fact that @xmath63 is compactly supported to extend the range of integration to infinity .
we have also used the convolution theorem , parseval s theorem , and the fact that @xmath63 is real .
we see , then , that @xmath78 is a sufficient condition for @xmath68 ( assuming a nontrivial perturbation ) .
as shown in @xcite , this condition is actually equivalent to that for the linear stability of a constant density state in the absence of exogenous forces .
a necessary and sufficient condition for @xmath68 for the first class of perturbations comes from considering the spectrum of @xmath79 in @xmath62 .
note that ( [ eq : second_variation ] ) may be written as @xmath80 = \int_{{\omega_{{{\bar \rho}}}}}{\cal i}[{{\tilde \rho}}]{{\tilde \rho}}(x)\ , dx \equiv \langle { { \tilde \rho } } , { \cal i}[{{\tilde \rho } } ] \rangle,\ ] ] where the angle brackets denote the usual @xmath81 inner product on @xmath62 . if the eigenvalues of the integral operator @xmath79 are positive , then @xmath68 ( again assuming a nontrivial perturbation ) .
we now turn to the second class of perturbations , which have support in @xmath39 and which are positive in @xmath64 . to analyze these perturbations ,
we extend the definition of the constant @xmath73 to a function @xmath82 that is defined over all of @xmath35 .
we set @xmath83 trivially from ( [ eq : lagrange ] ) , @xmath84 for @xmath85 .
we now rewrite the first variation as @xmath86 = \int_{{\omega}}{{\tilde \rho}}(x ) \lambda(x)\,dx,\ ] ] directly from ( [ eq : first_variation ] ) . remembering that @xmath87 in @xmath64 and that @xmath63 has zero mass in @xmath39 , we see that a necessary and sufficient condition for @xmath69 is @xmath88 in @xmath64 , that is @xmath89 physically
, this guarantees that a parcel of mass transported from @xmath62 to its complement increases the total energy .
if we wish for @xmath59 to be a minimizer with respect to the second class of perturbations , it suffices for @xmath68 ( for example , by having @xmath78 ) .
however , this condition is not necessary .
the necessary condition is that @xmath90 + w_2[{{\tilde \rho}},{{\tilde \rho } } ] > 0 $ ] for nontrivial perturbations , which follows from ( [ eq : expand_w ] ) being exact . to summarize
, we have obtained the following results : * equilibrium solutions @xmath59 satisfy the fredholm integral equation ( [ eq : fie ] ) and the mass constraint ( [ eq : mass1 ] ) . * the solution @xmath59 is a local and global minimizer with respect to the first class of perturbations ( those with support in @xmath62 ) if @xmath67 in ( [ eq : second_variation ] ) is positive .
* the solution @xmath59 is a local minimizer with respect to the second ( more general zero - mass ) class of perturbations if @xmath59 satisfies ( [ eq : stable ] ) .
if in addition @xmath67 is positive for these perturbations , then @xmath59 is a global minimizer as well . in practice
, we solve the integral equation ( [ eq : fie ] ) to find candidate solutions .
then , we compute @xmath82 to determine whether @xmath59 is a local minimizer .
finally , when possible , we show the positivity of @xmath67 to guarantee that @xmath59 is a global minimizer .
as the continuum limit replaces individual particles with a density , we need to make sure the continuum problem inherits a physical interpretation for the underlying problem .
if we think about perturbing an equilibrium configuration , we note that mass can not `` tunnel '' between disjoint components of the solution . as such
we define the concept of a multi - component swarm equilibrium .
suppose the swarm s support can be divided into a set of @xmath24 disjoint , closed , connected components @xmath91 , that is @xmath92 we define a swarm equilibrium as a configuration in which each individual swarm component is in equilibrium , @xmath93 we can still define @xmath82 in @xmath39 @xmath94 + f(x ) = \int_{{\omega_{{{\bar \rho}}}}}q(x - y ) { { \bar \rho}}(y)~dy + f(x),\ ] ] but now @xmath95 in @xmath96 .
we can now define a swarm minimizer .
we say a swarm equilibrium is a swarm minimizer if @xmath97 for some neighborhood of each component @xmath96 of the swarm . in practice
this means that the swarm is an energy minimizer for infinitesimal redistributions of mass in the neighborhood of each component .
this might also be called a lagrangian minimizer in the sense that the equilibrium is a minimizer with respect to infinitesimal lagrangian deformations of the distributions .
it is crucial to note that even if a solution @xmath59 is a global minimizer , other multi - component swarm minimizers may still exist .
these solutions are local minimizers and consequently a global minimizer may not be a global attractor under the dynamics of ( [ eq : pde ] ) .
in this section we discuss the minimization problem formulated in section [ sec : formulation ] .
it is helpful for expository purposes to make a concrete choice for the interaction potential @xmath32 . as previously mentioned , in many physical , chemical , and biological applications , the pairwise potential @xmath32 is symmetric
. additionally , repulsion dominates at short distances ( to prevent collisions ) and the interaction strength approaches zero for very long distances .
a common choice for @xmath32 is the morse potential with parameters chosen to describe long - range attraction and short - range repulsion @xcite . for the remainder of this section
, we consider a simpler example where @xmath32 is the laplace distribution @xmath98 which represents repulsion with strength decaying exponentially in space . when there is no exogenous potential , @xmath99 , and when the domain is infinite , _
e.g. _ , @xmath100 , the swarm will spread without bound .
the solutions asymptotically approach the barenblatt solution to the porous medium equation as shown in @xcite .
however , when the domain @xmath39 is bounded or when there is a well in the exogenous potential , bounded swarms are observed both analytically and numerically , as we will show .
figure [ fig : repulsion_schematic ] shows solutions @xmath101 for three cases : a bounded domain with no exogenous potential , a gravitational potential on a semi - infinite domain , and a quadratic potential well on an infinite domain . in each case , a bounded swarm solution is observed but the solutions are not necessarily continuous and can even contain @xmath0-function concentrations at the boundaries .
we discuss these three example cases in detail later in this section .
first , we will formulate the minimization problem for the case of the laplace potential .
we will attempt to solve the problem classically ; when the solution has compact support contained within the domain we find solutions that are continuous within the support and may have jump discontinuities at the boundary of the support .
however , when the boundary of the support coincides with the boundary of the domain , the classical solution may break down and it is necessary to include a distributional component in the solution .
we also formulate explicit conditions for the solutions to be global minimizers .
we then apply these results to the three examples mentioned above .
recall that for @xmath59 to be a steady solution , it must satisfy the integral equation ( [ eq : fie ] ) subject to the mass constraint ( [ eq : mass1 ] ) . for @xmath101 to be a local minimizer , it must also satisfy ( [ eq : stable ] ) , @xmath102 finally , recall that for a solution @xmath59 to be a global minimizer , the second variation ( [ eq : second_variation ] ) must be positive .
we saw that if @xmath78 , this is guaranteed . for ( [ eq : laplace ] ) , @xmath103 and
so for the remainder of this section , we are able to ignore the issue of @xmath67 .
any local minimizer that we find will be a global minimizer .
additionally , for the remainder of this section , we restrict our attention to cases where the support of the solution @xmath62 is a single interval in @xmath39 ; in other words , the minimizing solution has a connected support .
the reason that we are able to make this restriction follows from the notion of swarm minimization , discussed above .
in fact , we can show that there are no multi - component swarm minimizers for the laplace potential as long as the exogenous potential @xmath104 is convex , that is , @xmath105 on @xmath39 . to see this ,
assume we have a swarm minimizer with a at least two disjoint components .
consider @xmath82 in the gap between two components so that @xmath106 .
we differentiate @xmath82 twice to obtain @xmath107 note that @xmath108 as @xmath109 in @xmath64 .
@xmath105 by assumption .
consequently , @xmath110 in @xmath64 and so @xmath82 is convex upwards in the gap . also , @xmath111 at the endpoints of the gap .
we conclude from the convexity that @xmath82 must be less than @xmath112 near one of the endpoints .
this violates the condition of swarm minimization from the previous section , and hence the solution is not a swarm minimizer . since swarm minimization is a necessary condition for global minimization , we now , as discussed , restrict attention to single - component solutions
. for concreteness , assume the support of the solution @xmath59 is @xmath113 $ ] .
we transform the integral equation ( [ eq : fie ] ) for @xmath59 into a differential equation by noting that @xmath114 is the green s function of the differential operator @xmath115 , so that @xmath116 , where @xmath117 is the dirac @xmath0-function . applying @xmath118 to both sides of ( [ eq : fie ] ) yields the dirac @xmath0-function under the integral .
integration and the sifting property of the @xmath0 function lead to @xmath119 = \frac{\lambda}{2}-\frac{1}{2}\left [ f- f''(x ) \right ] \quad { \rm in } \ { { \omega_{{{\bar \rho}}}}}. \label{eq : fie - sol}\ ] ] equation ( [ eq : fie - sol ] ) is a necessary condition on a solution @xmath120 but not sufficient .
in fact , to verify the candidate solution ( [ eq : fie - sol ] ) , we must substitute back into the governing integral equation ( [ eq : fie ] ) .
we find @xmath121 & \equiv & \int_\omega e^{-|x - y| } \left \
{ \frac{\lambda}{2}-\frac{1}{2}\left [ f(y)- f''(y ) \right ] \right \ } dy , \\ & = & \lambda - f(x ) + \frac{e^{\alpha - x}}{2}[f(\alpha)-f'(\alpha)-\lambda ] \\ & & \mbox { } + \frac{e^{x-\beta}}{2}[f(\beta)+f'(\beta)-\lambda ] , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the terms other than @xmath122 must vanish for ( [ eq : fie - sol ] ) to be a solution .
these error terms are spanned by @xmath123 which is the null space of @xmath124 .
the constraint that these terms must vanish leads to the conditions @xmath125 for a given @xmath104 , both these conditions will only be satisfied for particular choices of @xmath126 and @xmath127 .
the allowed @xmath126 and @xmath127 then specify @xmath73 which in turn determines the mass @xmath26 through ( [ eq : mass1 ] ) . as we discuss below , the solution derived here is sometimes , but not always , a true minimizer of the energy @xmath48 .
what we have presented above is the classical view of the solution of ( [ eq : fie ] ) .
the difficulty with this calculation is that we expect on physical grounds that for every mass @xmath26 and interval @xmath128 there should be a minimizer .
it is easy to see that if @xmath33 and @xmath32 are bounded from below , the energy @xmath48 is bounded from below also .
let @xmath129 then directly from ( [ eq : continuum_energy ] ) , @xmath130 since @xmath48 is bounded from below , solutions to the minimization problem exist in the space of measure valued functions @xcite .
sometimes these solutions are not classical ; when there is finite attraction at small distances , mass can concentrate in a @xmath0-function @xcite . for the more biologically relevant case of repulsion at short scales , in free space and in the absence of an external potential ,
solutions are classical for all time @xcite .
we now show that ( under sufficient hypotheses ) a @xmath0-function can not occur in the interior of @xmath62 . though we have restricted ourselves ( above ) to considering the laplace potential ( [ eq : laplace ] ) ,
this is true more generally .
in fact , suppose that at a point @xmath51 in the interior of @xmath39 , * the exogenous potential @xmath104 is twice - differentiable in a neighborhood of @xmath51 , * @xmath114 is twice - differentiable for @xmath131 , * @xmath114 has nonzero repulsion at short distances , that is , @xmath132 then a minimizer does not contain a @xmath0-function at @xmath133 .
to see this , we will compare the energy of a density containing a @xmath0-function at @xmath133 to one where the @xmath0-function has been replaced by a narrow , unit mass top - hat distribution @xmath134 , @xmath135 and show that the energy is reduced by @xmath136 .
consider a candidate distribution with a @xmath0-function of mass @xmath24 at @xmath51 , @xmath137 .
define the change of energy @xmath138 - w[{{\bar \rho}}_0 + m \delta(x - x_0)].\ ] ] by direct calculation using ( [ eq : continuum_energy ] ) , @xmath139 \,dx\,dy \nonumber \\ & & \mbox{}+ m \int_{{\omega}}f(x ) \left[\delta_\varepsilon(x - x_0 ) - \delta ( x - x_0 ) \right]\,dx .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that near @xmath140 , @xmath141 and @xmath142 . expanding to @xmath143 , only the first term of ( [ eq : nodeltas ] )
persists , yielding @xmath144 for @xmath145 , corresponding to nonzero repulsion at short distances , @xmath146 , indicating that the energy is reduced by replacing the @xmath0-function with a narrow top - hat .
we conclude that @xmath0-functions may not occur in the interior of @xmath39 under the assumed conditions .
however , the above reasoning breaks down for @xmath0-functions on the domain boundary , where they may not be replaced by a narrow , symmetric top - hat distribution . based on the result above
, we introduce a candidate solution @xmath147 where @xmath148 and @xmath149 are to be determined . the classical solution @xmath150 is supplemented with @xmath0-functions at the boundary of @xmath62 .
we will show , in agreement with the calculation above , that @xmath148 and @xmath149 must vanish unless the boundary of the support , @xmath62 , coincides with the boundary of the domain , @xmath39 .
we verify the new candidate solution ( [ eq : fie - sol2 ] ) by substituting back into the governing equation ( [ eq : fie ] ) .
we find @xmath151 & \equiv & \int_\omega e^{-|x - y| } \left \ { { \bar \rho(y ) } + a \delta(y-\alpha ) + b\delta(y-\beta ) \right \}\,dy , \\ & = & \lambda - f(x ) + \frac{e^{\alpha - x}}{2}[2a+f(\alpha)-f'(\alpha)-\lambda ] \\ & & \mbox{}+\frac{e^{x-\beta}}{2}[2b+f(\beta)+f'(\beta)-\lambda ] , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the terms other than @xmath122 must vanish for ( [ eq : fie - sol2 ] ) to be a solution .
this constraint leads to the following conditions on @xmath148 and @xmath149 , the coefficients of the nonclassical parts of the solution : @xmath152 because @xmath73 is undetermined as of yet , we can find a solution for any mass @xmath26 .
substituting the solution @xmath101 into the mass constraint ( [ eq : mass1 ] ) yields @xmath153,\\ & = & \lambda \left ( 1 + \frac{(\beta -\alpha)}{2 } \right ) -\frac{1}{2 } \left [ f(\alpha)+f(\beta)+ \int_{{\omega_{{{\bar \rho}}}}}f(x)\,dx \right ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] solving for @xmath73 in terms of @xmath26 yields @xmath154 we ve shown that for any @xmath113 $ ] and any mass @xmath26 we can find a solution to ( [ eq : fie ] ) with @xmath101 smooth in the interior and with a concentration at the endpoints .
however , we havent yet addressed the issue of @xmath101 being non - negative , nor have we considered whether it is a minimizer .
we next consider whether the extremal solution @xmath59 is a minimizer , which involves the study of ( [ eq : stable2 ] ) .
we present a differential operator method that allows us to compute @xmath82 and deduce sufficient conditions for @xmath59 to be a minimizer .
we start by factoring the differential operator @xmath155 where @xmath156 . applying these operators to the interaction potential @xmath32
, we see that @xmath157 substituting @xmath59 in ( [ eq : fie - sol2 ] ) into our definition of @xmath82 in ( [ eq : stable2 ] ) yields @xmath158 now consider applying @xmath159 to ( [ eq : one ] ) at a point @xmath5 in @xmath62 .
we see that @xmath160 = { \mathcal{d}^- } [ \lambda],\ ] ] where we ve used the fact that @xmath161 in @xmath62 .
if we let @xmath162 and let @xmath6 decrease to zero , the integral term vanishes and @xmath163 solving for @xmath148 yields the first half of ( [ eq : ab ] ) .
a similar argument near @xmath164 yields the value of @xmath149 .
assuming @xmath126 does not coincide with an endpoint of @xmath39 , we now consider the region @xmath165 , which is to the left of the support @xmath62 . again , applying @xmath159 to ( [ eq : fie ] ) simplifies the equation ; we can check that both the integral term and the contribution from the @xmath0-functions are annihilated by this operator , from which we deduce that @xmath166 = 0 \qquad \rightarrow \qquad f(x)-
\lambda(x ) = ce^x,\ ] ] where @xmath167 is an unknown constant .
a quick check shows that if @xmath104 is continuous , then @xmath82 is continuous at the endpoints of @xmath62 so that @xmath168 .
this in turn determines @xmath167 , yielding @xmath169e^{x-\alpha } \qquad { \rm for } \quad x \leq \alpha.\ ] ] a similar argument near @xmath164 yields @xmath170e^{\beta -x } \qquad { \rm for } \quad x \geq \beta.\ ] ] as discussed in section [ sec : minimizers ] , for @xmath101 to be a minimizer we wish for @xmath88 for @xmath171 and @xmath172 .
a little algebra shows that this is equivalent to [ eq : mincon ] @xmath173 if @xmath126 and @xmath127 are both strictly inside @xmath39 , then ( [ eq : mincon ] ) constitutes sufficient conditions for the extremal solution @xmath59 to be a global minimizer ( recalling that @xmath68 ) . we may also derive a necessary condition at the endpoints of the support from ( [ eq : mincon ] ) .
as @xmath5 increases to @xmath126 , we may apply lhpital s rule and this equation becomes equivalent to the condition @xmath174 , as expected .
a similar calculation letting @xmath5 decrease to @xmath127 implies that @xmath175 .
however , since @xmath59 is a density , we are looking for positive solutions . hence
, either @xmath176 or @xmath126 coincides with the left endpoint of @xmath39 .
similarly , either @xmath177 or @xmath127 coincides with the right edge of @xmath39 .
this is consistent with the result ( [ eq : nodeltas2 ] ) which showed that @xmath0-functions can not occur in the interior of @xmath39 . in summary
, we come to two conclusions : * a globally minimizing solution @xmath59 contains a @xmath0-function only if a boundary of the support of the solution coincides with a boundary of the domain . * a globally minimizing solution @xmath59 must satisfy ( [ eq : mincon ] ) .
we now consider three concrete examples for @xmath39 and @xmath104 .
we model a one - dimensional biological swarm with repulsive social interactions described by the laplace potential .
we begin with the simplest possible case , namely no exogenous potential , @xmath178 and a finite domain which for convenience we take to be the symmetric interval @xmath179 $ ] .
as @xmath180 we know from ( [ eq : singlecomponent ] ) that the minimizing solution has a connected support , _
i.e. _ , it is a single component .
we will see that the minimizing solution has an equipartition of mass between @xmath0-functions at the boundaries of the domain and a constant solution in the interior , as shown schematically in figure [ fig : repulsion_schematic](a ) .
we now proceed with calculating the solution . from ( [ eq : fie - sol ] ) , we find that @xmath181 the nonclassical solution is @xmath182 eq .
( [ eq : mform ] ) gives @xmath73 as @xmath183 eq . ( [ eq : ab ] ) specifies @xmath148 and @xmath149 as @xmath184 since @xmath185 , it follows that @xmath186 and @xmath66 vanishes according to ( [ eq : w1lambda ] ) .
therefore , the solution is a global minimizer . the solution @xmath101 is shown schematically in figure [ fig : repulsion_schematic](a ) .
figure [ fig : repulsion_numerics](a ) compares analytical and numerical results for an example case where we take the total mass to be @xmath187 and the finite domain to be @xmath188 $ ] with @xmath189 .
cross - hatched boxes indicate the boundary of the domain .
the solid line is the classical solution @xmath59 .
dots correspond to the numerically - obtained equilibrium of the discrete system ( [ eq : discretesystem ] ) with @xmath190 swarm members .
the density at each lagrangian grid point is estimated using the correspondence discussed in section ( [ sec : contmodel ] ) and pictured in figure [ fig : delta_schematic ] .
each `` lollipop '' at the domain boundary corresponds to a @xmath0-function of mass @xmath191 in the analytical solution , and simultaneously to a superposition of @xmath192 swarm members in the numerical simulation .
hence , we see excellent agreement between the continuum minimizer and the numerical equilibrium even for this relatively small number @xmath190 of lagrangian points .
we now consider repulsive social interactions and an exogenous gravitational potential .
the spatial coordinate @xmath193 describes the elevation above ground .
consequently , @xmath39 is the semi - infinite interval @xmath194 . then @xmath195 with @xmath196 , shown in figure [ fig : repulsion_schematic](f ) . as @xmath180 we know from ( [ eq : singlecomponent ] ) that the minimizing solution has a connected support , _
i.e. _ , it is a single component .
moreover , translating this component downward decreases the exogenous energy while leaving the endogenous energy unchanged .
thus , the support of the solution must be @xmath197 $ ] , potentially with @xmath198 .
in fact , we will see that there are two possible solution types depending on @xmath12 . for strong enough values of @xmath12
, @xmath127 indeed equals zero , and the mass accumulates on the ground @xmath140 , as shown schematically in figure [ fig : repulsion_schematic](d ) . for weaker @xmath12
, the mass is partitioned between a @xmath0-function on the ground and a classical solution for @xmath131 , as shown in figure [ fig : repulsion_schematic](e ) .
we now proceed with calculating the solution . from ( [ eq : fie - sol ] ) , we find that @xmath199 the nonclassical solution is @xmath200 eq .
( [ eq : mform ] ) gives @xmath73 as @xmath201 eq . ( [ eq : ab ] ) specifies @xmath148 and @xmath149 as @xmath202 for @xmath59 to be a global minimizer , it must be true that @xmath177 as shown in section [ sec : funcmin ] .
solving , we find that @xmath203 . for @xmath204 , we see that @xmath205 in which case the minimizing solution is @xmath206 it follows directly that @xmath207 .
figure [ fig : repulsion_schematic](e ) shows a schematic drawing of this solution .
we still must consider the condition ( [ eq : minconb ] ) . to see it is satisfied , first note that @xmath208 .
then ( [ eq : minconb ] ) becomes @xmath209 we note that by lhpital s rule that equality is obtained as @xmath210 . to show the inequality holds for @xmath211
let @xmath212 and @xmath213 ( so @xmath214 ) . the inequality becomes @xmath215 we can interpret the left - hand side as the slope of a chord connecting the points @xmath216 and @xmath217 .
consequently , if the function @xmath218 is concave upward , the slope of the chord will be increasing as @xmath219 increases away from @xmath220 , and the inequality will hold . recalling that @xmath221 ,
we compute @xmath222^{\prime \prime } = g / s$ ] which is positive , and hence the solution is globally stable . for @xmath223
our previous calculation naively implies @xmath224 .
since @xmath127 can not be negative , the minimizer in this case is a @xmath0-function at the origin , namely @xmath225 , shown in figure [ fig : repulsion_schematic](d ) . in this case ,
@xmath226 from ( [ eq : gravitylambda ] ) and @xmath227 from ( [ eq : lambdaright ] ) .
it follows that @xmath228 the first inequality follows from a taylor expansion .
the second follows from our assumption @xmath229 . since @xmath88 the solution is a global minimizer . in summary
, there are two cases . when @xmath223 , the globally stable minimizer is a @xmath0-function at the origin . when @xmath230 there is a globally stable minimizer consisting of a @xmath0-function at the origin which is the left - hand endpoint of a compactly - supported classical swarm .
the two cases are shown schematically in figures [ fig : repulsion_schematic](de ) .
figure [ fig : repulsion_numerics](b ) compares analytical and numerical results for the latter ( @xmath230 ) case with @xmath187 and @xmath231 .
we use @xmath190 swarm members for the numerical simulation . the numerical ( dots ) and analytical ( line ) @xmath232 agree , as does the nonclassical part of the solution , pictured as the `` lollipop '' which represents a superposition of @xmath233 swarm members in the numerical simulation having total mass @xmath234 , and simultaneously a @xmath0-function of mass @xmath235 in the analytical solution .
we now consider the infinite domain @xmath100 with a quadratic exogenous potential well , pictured in figure [ fig : repulsion_schematic](c ) .
this choice of a quadratic well is representative of a generic potential minimum , as might occur due to a chemoattractant , food source , or light source .
thus @xmath236 where @xmath237 controls the strength of the potential .
as @xmath238 we know from ( [ eq : singlecomponent ] ) that the minimizing solution is a single component .
we take the support of the solution to be @xmath113 $ ] .
we will find that the compactly supported density is classical and has an inverted parabolic shape , shown in figure [ fig : repulsion_schematic](b ) .
our calculation proceeds as follows .
we know from section [ sec : funcmin ] that because @xmath126 and @xmath127 are assumed to be finite , @xmath239 and so the solution is classical . from ( [ eq : fie - sol ] ) , we find that @xmath240 and , from ( [ eq : ab ] ) , @xmath241 eliminating @xmath73 from these equations and recalling that @xmath242 , it follows that @xmath243 .
hence , the solution is symmetric around the center of the potential . for convenience ,
we now define @xmath244 .
( [ eq : mform ] ) gives @xmath73 in terms of the mass @xmath26 as @xmath245 however , from the second half of ( [ eq : abquad ] ) we know that @xmath246 equating these two expressions for @xmath73 yields that @xmath247 note that @xmath248 increases monotonically from @xmath249 with increasing @xmath26 . finally , writing the solution @xmath59 in terms of @xmath26 , we have @xmath250 & |x| \leq \left(\frac{3m}{2\gamma } + 1\right)^{1/3 } - 1 \\ 0 & |x| > \left(\frac{3m}{2\gamma } + 1\right)^{1/3 } - 1 . \end{cases}\ ] ] it follows directly that @xmath207 , and that there is a discontinuity at the edge of the support .
we now must show that the candidate @xmath59 is a global minimizer , which is done by demonstrating ( [ eq : mincon ] ) . by the same argumentation used for the right endpoint in section [ sec : grav ]
, it suffices to show that @xmath218 is concave up for @xmath251 which follows directly from algebra .
hence , the solution is a global minimizer . the solution @xmath59 is shown schematically in figure [ fig : repulsion_schematic](b ) .
figure [ fig : repulsion_numerics](b ) compares analytical and numerical results for the case with @xmath187 and @xmath252 , with @xmath253 swarm members used for the numerical solution .
the numerical ( dots ) and analytical ( line ) @xmath59 agree closely .
in many physical , chemical , and biological applications , the pairwise potential @xmath32 is isotropic , with a repulsion dominating at short distance and the interaction strength approaching zero for very long distances .
a common choice for @xmath32 is the morse potential @xmath254 with appropriately chosen parameters . here
, @xmath5 is the distance between particles , @xmath255 is the characteristic length scale of attraction , and @xmath256 is the characteristic velocity induced by attraction . we have scaled the characteristic repulsive strength and length scale to be unity . in this section we are concerned with the solution of ( [ eq : mass1 ] ) and ( [ eq : fie ] ) with @xmath32 given by ( [ eq : morse ] ) .
the morse potential has been studied extensively and has become a canonical model for attractive - repulsive interactions @xcite .
a key characteristic of the potential ( [ eq : morse ] ) is whether or not the parameters @xmath257 are chosen to be in the _ h - stable _ or the _ catastrophic _ regime ; see @xcite for a review .
consider ( [ eq : discretesystem ] ) with @xmath178 .
if the parameters @xmath257 are chosen in the h - stable regime @xmath258 , then as the number of particles @xmath2 increases , the density distribution of particles approaches a constant , as does the energy per particle .
stated differently , the particles form a crystalline lattice where the nearest - neighbor distance is approximately equal for all particles ( excluding edge effects ) . as more individuals
are added to the group , the inter - organism spacing is preserved and the group grows to cover a larger spatial region . if the parameters are chosen outside of the h - stable regime , _
i.e. _ , @xmath259 , the system is catastrophic . in this case
, the energy per particle is unbounded as @xmath260 , and particles pack together more and more closely as n increases .
our work in @xcite classifies the asymptotic behaviors of the continuum problem ( [ eq : pde ] ) with morse - type interactions in the absence of an external potential , @xmath99 , and on the real line . in the h - stable regime , the continuum model displays spreading density profiles , while in the catastrophic regime , it forms compactly - supported steady states .
the distinction between catastrophic and h - stable is related to the fourier transform of the potential @xmath114 . note that ( [ eq : morse ] ) has fourier transform [ eq : qhatmorse ] @xmath261}{(1+{k}^{2})(1+(kl)^2)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the condition for h - stability is equivalent to @xmath262 . in this case ,
@xmath78 for all @xmath263 , and from section [ sec : minimizers ] , this is sufficient for @xmath68 , or equivalently , linear stability of constant density states . in the catastrophic case , @xmath264
intuitively , in the catastrophic case , the constant density state is unstable to long wave perturbations .
the system is attracted to states of finite extent shorter than the length scale of the instability . in the h - stable case ,
the constant density state is stable to perturbations , and initial density profiles spread evenly to become flat .
we will now study minimizers for the case of morse - type interactions , and will see qualitatively different solutions for the catastrophic and h - stable cases .
we follow the procedure used in section [ sec : repulsive ] , namely we first look for a classical solution on the interior of @xmath265 $ ] and then allow for @xmath0-functions at the boundaries . once again , we will see that minimizers contain @xmath0-functions only when the boundary of the support , @xmath62 , coincides with the boundary of the domain , @xmath39 . for convenience , define the differential operators @xmath266 and @xmath267 , and apply @xmath268 to ( [ eq : fie ] ) to obtain @xmath269 , \quad x \in { { \omega_{{{\bar \rho } } } } } , \label{eq : morselocal}\ ] ] where @xmath270 thus , we guess @xmath271 the full solution to the problem is obtained by substituting ( [ eq : morseansatz ] ) into ( [ eq : mass1 ] ) and ( [ eq : fie ] ) which yields @xmath272 where @xmath84 in @xmath62 .
we begin by considering the amplitudes @xmath148 and @xmath149 of the distributional component of the solution .
we factor the differential operators @xmath273 where @xmath274 and @xmath275 where @xmath276 .
note that @xmath277 h(x - y),\ ] ] where @xmath248 is the heaviside function .
now we apply @xmath278 to ( [ eq : morseintegraleq ] ) at a point @xmath5 in @xmath62 , which yields @xmath279 { { { { { \bar \rho}}_*}}}(y)\,dy & & \\
\mbox{}+a { \mathcal{p}^-}{\mathcal{q}^-}q(x-\alpha ) = { \mathcal{p}^-}{\mathcal{q}^-}\ { \lambda -f(x)\}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking the limit @xmath280 yields @xmath281 where we have used the fact that @xmath282 .
a similar calculation using the operators @xmath283 and focusing near @xmath164 yields that @xmath284 eqs .
( [ eq : morseboundary1 ] ) and ( [ eq : morseboundary2 ] ) relate the amplitudes of the @xmath0-functions at the boundaries to the value of the classical solution @xmath232 there .
further solution of the problem requires @xmath104 to be specified . in the case where @xmath285 , solving ( [ eq : morselocal ] ) for @xmath286 and solving ( [ eq : morseboundary1 ] ) and ( [ eq : morseboundary2 ] ) for @xmath148 and @xmath149 yields an equilibrium solution .
one must check that the solution is non - negative and then consider the solutions stability to determine if it is a local or global minimizer . in the case where @xmath62 is contained in the interior of @xmath39 , we know that @xmath287 as discussed in section [ sec : absence ] .
we consider this case below .
suppose @xmath62 is contained in the interior of @xmath39
. then @xmath287 . following section [ sec : funcmin ]
, we try to determine when @xmath88 in @xmath35 and when @xmath68 , which constitute necessary and sufficient conditions for @xmath59 to be a global minimizer .
we apply @xmath278 to ( [ eq : morseintegraleq ] ) at a point @xmath165 . the integral term and the terms arising from the @xmath0 functions vanish .
the equation is simply @xmath288 .
we write the solution as @xmath289 the two constants @xmath290 are determined as follows . from ( [ eq : morseintegraleq ] ) , @xmath82 is a continuous function , and thus @xmath291 we derive a jump condition on the derivative to get another equation for @xmath290 .
we differentiate ( [ eq : morseintegraleq ] ) and determine that @xmath292 is continuous . however , since @xmath84 for @xmath85 , @xmath293 . substituting this result into the derivative of ( [ eq : lambdamorse ] ) and letting @xmath5 increase to @xmath294
, we find @xmath295 the solution to ( [ eq : lambdacontinuity ] ) and ( [ eq : lambdaprime ] ) is [ eq : kvals ] @xmath296 now that @xmath82 is known near @xmath297 we can compute when @xmath88 , at least near the left side of @xmath62 .
taylor expanding @xmath82 around @xmath297 , we find @xmath298 the quadratic term in ( [ eq : lambdatayl ] ) has coefficient @xmath299 where the second line comes from substituting ( [ eq : morseboundary1 ] ) with @xmath176 and noting that the classical part of the solution @xmath300 must be nonnegative since it is a density . furthermore , since we expect @xmath301 ( this can be shown a posteriori ) , we have that the quadratic term in ( [ eq : lambdatayl ] ) is positive .
a similar analysis holds near the boundary @xmath164 .
therefore , @xmath302 for @xmath5 in a neighborhood outside of @xmath62 . stated differently , the solution ( [ eq : morseansatz ] ) is a swarm minimizer , that is , it is stable with respect to infinitesimal redistributions of mass . the domain @xmath62 is determined through the relations ( [ eq : morseboundary1 ] ) and ( [ eq : morseboundary2 ] ) , which , when @xmath239 , become [ eq : bcs ] @xmath303 in the following subsections , we will consider the solution of the continuum system ( [ eq : fie ] ) and ( [ eq : mass1 ] ) with no external potential , @xmath99 . we consider two cases for the morse interaction potential ( [ eq : morse ] ) : first , the catastrophic case on @xmath100 , for which the above calculation applies , and second , for the h - stable case on a finite domain , in which case @xmath304 and there are @xmath0-concentrations at the boundary .
exact solutions for cases with an exogenous potential , @xmath305 can be straightforwardly derived , though the algebra is even more cumbersome and the results unenlightening . in this case , @xmath99 in ( [ eq : fie ] ) and @xmath306 in ( [ eq : morse ] ) so that @xmath307 in ( [ eq : morselocal ] ) .
the solution to ( [ eq : morselocal ] ) is @xmath308 where @xmath309 in the absence of an external potential , the solution is translationally invariant .
consequently , we may choose the support to be an interval @xmath310 $ ] which is symmetric around the origin .
hence , by symmetry , @xmath311 . while the solution ( [ eq : freespacerhobar ] ) satisfies the ordinary differential equation ( [ eq : morselocal ] ) , substituting into the integral equation ( [ eq : fie ] ) and the mass constraint ( [ eq : mass1 ] ) will determine the constants @xmath167 , @xmath73 and @xmath248 .
the integral operator produces modes spanned by @xmath312 . from these modes
follow two homogeneous equations for @xmath167 and @xmath73 which simplify to @xmath313c - \frac{1}{{{g}}l^2 -1}\lambda & = & 0 , \label{eq : catastrophiceig1 } \\ \frac{2}{1+\mu^2 l^2}\left [ \cos ( \mu h ) - \mu l \sin ( \mu h ) \right]c - \frac{1}{{{g}}l^2 -1}\lambda & = & 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for these equations to have a nontrivial solution for @xmath167 and @xmath73 the determinant of the coefficient matrix must vanish , which yields a condition specifying @xmath248 , @xmath314 the mass constraint ( [ eq : mass1 ] ) yields @xmath315 solving ( [ eq : catastrophiceig1 ] ) and ( [ eq : catastrophicmass ] ) for @xmath167 and @xmath73 yields the full solution for the coefficients in ( [ eq : freespacerhobar ] ) and the half - width @xmath248 of the solution , @xmath316 } \left\ { \frac{{{g}}l-1}{\sqrt{(1-{{g}})({{g}}l^2 - 1 ) } } \right\ } , \\ c & = & \frac{m}{2(h+l+1 ) } \frac{\sqrt{{{g}}}(l^2 - 1)}{l(1-{{g } } ) } , \\
\lambda & = & \frac{m(1-{{g}}l^2)}{h + l+1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as we have shown in section [ sec : morsenonclass ] , this solution is a swarm minimizer .
in fact , the solution is also a local minimizer . to see this
, note that from ( [ eq : lambdamorse ] ) and ( [ eq : kvals ] ) that @xmath317 & |x| \geq h. \end{cases}\ ] ] since @xmath318 , we see that @xmath319 for @xmath320 , ensuring that the solution is a local minimizer . while we suspect that @xmath232 is a global minimizer , this is not immediately apparent because @xmath321 in ( [ eq : qhatmorse ] ) has mixed sign in this catastrophic case , and hence @xmath67 is of indeterminate sign . to establish that @xmath232 is a global minimizer
one might study the quantity @xmath322 but we leave this analysis as an open problem . figure [ fig : morse_numerics](a ) compares analytical and numerical results for an example case with total mass @xmath187 and interaction potential parameters @xmath323 and @xmath324 .
the solid line is the compactly supported analytical solution @xmath59 .
dots correspond to the numerically - obtained equilibrium of the discrete system ( [ eq : discretesystem ] ) with @xmath190 swarm members .
as described in @xcite , the asymptotic behavior of ( [ eq : pde ] ) for the h - stable case is a spreading self - similar solution that approaches the well - known barenblatt solution of the porous medium equation .
hence , there is no equilibrium solution for the h - stable case on an unbounded domain ( one can verify this by considering the analogous problem to that of the previous section and showing explicitly that there is no solution ) . here , we assume a bounded domain @xmath188 $ ] . as before , @xmath99 in ( [ eq : fie ] ) but now @xmath258 in ( [ eq : morse ] ) so that @xmath325 in ( [ eq : morselocal ] ) .
the classical solution to ( [ eq : morselocal ] ) is @xmath326 where @xmath327 we will again invoke symmetry to assume @xmath311 .
the minimizer will be the classical solution together with @xmath0-functions on the boundary , @xmath328 again by symmetry , @xmath329 .
consequently , the solution can be written as @xmath330.\ ] ] substituting into the integral equation ( [ eq : fie ] ) and the mass constraint ( [ eq : mass1 ] ) will determine the constants @xmath167 , @xmath73 and @xmath148 .
the integral operator produces modes spanned by @xmath312 .
this produces two homogeneous , linear equations for @xmath167 , @xmath148 and @xmath73 .
the mass constraint ( [ eq : mass1 ] ) produces an inhomogeneous one , namely an equation linear in @xmath167 , @xmath148 , and @xmath73 for the mass .
we have the three dimensional linear system @xmath331 the solution is [ eq : hstablesoln ] @xmath332}{2\phi } , \\ c & = & -\frac{{{\tilde \mu}}m ( 1-{{\tilde \mu}}^2 ) ( 1-{{\tilde \mu}}^2 l^2)}{\phi } , \\
\lambda & = & \frac{m { { \tilde \mu}}(1-{{g}}l^2)\left [ ( 1+{{\tilde \mu}})(1+{{\tilde \mu}}l ) + ( 1-{{\tilde \mu}})(1-{{\tilde \mu}}l ) \right]}{\phi},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where for convenience we have defined @xmath333 for this h - stable case , @xmath78 which ensures that @xmath68 for nontrivial perturbations .
this guarantees that the solution above is a global minimizer . in the limit of large domain size @xmath334 ,
the analytical solution simplifies substantially . to leading order ,
the expressions ( [ eq : hstablesoln ] ) become @xmath335 note that @xmath336 is exponentially small except in a boundary layer near each edge of @xmath39 , and therefore the solution is nearly constant in the interior of @xmath39 .
figure [ fig : morse_numerics](b ) compares analytical and numerical results for an example case with a relatively small value of @xmath334 .
we take total mass @xmath187 and set the domain half - width to be @xmath189 . the interaction potential parameters @xmath323 and @xmath324 .
the solid line is the classical solution @xmath232 .
dots correspond to the numerically - obtained equilibrium of the discrete system ( [ eq : discretesystem ] ) with @xmath190 swarm members .
each `` lollipop '' at the domain boundary corresponds to a @xmath0-function of mass @xmath191 in the analytical solution , and simultaneously to a superposition of @xmath192 swarm members in the numerical simulation .
we now return to the locust swarm model of @xcite , discussed also in section [ sec : intro ] .
recall that locust swarms are observed to have a concentration of individuals on the ground , a gap or `` bubble '' where the density of individuals is near zero , and a sharply delineated swarm of flying individuals .
this behavior is reproduced in the model ( [ eq : locusts ] ) ; see figure [ fig : locust](b ) .
in fact , figure [ fig : locust](c ) shows that the bubble is present even when the wind in the model is turned off , and only endogenous interactions and gravity are present . to better understand the structure of the swarm , we consider the analogous continuum problem . to further simplify the model , we note that the vertical structure of the swarm appears to depend only weakly on the horizontal direction , and thus we will construct a _ quasi - two - dimensional _ model in which the horizontal structure is assumed uniform . in particular , we will make a comparison between a one - dimensional and a quasi - two - dimensional model . both models
take the form of the energy minimization problem ( [ eq : fie ] ) on a semi - infinite domain , with an exogenous potential @xmath337 describing gravity .
the models differ in the choice of the endogenous potential @xmath32 , which is chosen to describe either one - dimensional or quasi - two - dimensional repulsion .
the one - dimensional model is precisely that which we considered in section [ sec : grav ] .
there we saw that minimizers of the one - dimensional model can reproduce the concentrations of locusts on the ground and a group of individuals above the ground , but there can not be a separation between the grounded and airborne groups .
we will show below that for the quasi - two - dimensional model , this is not the case , and indeed , some minimizers have a gap between the two groups .
as mentioned , the one - dimensional and quasi - two - dimensional models incorporate only endogenous repulsion .
however , the behavior we describe herein does not change for the more biologically realistic situation when attraction is present .
we consider the repulsion - only case in order to seek the minimal mechanism responsible for the appearance of the gap .
we consider a swarm in two dimensions , with spatial coordinate @xmath338 .
we will eventually confine the vertical coordinate @xmath339 to be nonnegative , since it describes the elevation above the ground at @xmath340 .
we assume the swarm to be uniform in the horizontal direction @xmath341 , so that @xmath342 .
we construct a quasi - two - dimensional interaction potential , @xmath343 letting @xmath344 and @xmath345 , this yields @xmath346 it is straightforward to show that the two - dimensional energy per unit horizontal length is given by @xmath347 = \frac{1}{2 } \int_{{\omega}}\int_{{\omega}}\rho(x_1 ) \rho(y_1 ) q_{2d}(x_1-y_1)\,dx_1\,dy_1 + \int_{{\omega}}f(x_1)\rho(x_1)\,dx_1,\ ] ] where the exogenous force is @xmath348 and the domain @xmath39 is the half - line @xmath349 .
this is exactly analogous to the one - dimensional problem ( [ eq : continuum_energy ] ) , but with particles interacting according to the quasi - two - dimensional endogenous potential .
similarly , the corresponding dynamical equations are simply ( [ eq : cont_velocity ] ) and ( [ eq : pde ] ) but with endogenous force @xmath350 . for the laplace potential ( [ eq : laplace ] ) , the quasi - two - dimensional potential is @xmath351 this integral can be manipulated for ease of calculation , @xmath352 where ( [ eq : q2db ] ) comes from symmetry , ( [ eq : q2dc ] ) comes from letting @xmath353 , ( [ eq : q2dd ] ) comes from letting @xmath354 , and ( [ eq : q2de ] ) comes from the trigonometric substitution @xmath355 . from an asymptotic expansion of ( [ eq : q2dd ] )
, we find that for small @xmath356 , @xmath357 whereas for large @xmath356 , @xmath358.\ ] ] in our numerical study , it is important to have an efficient method of computing values of @xmath359 . in practice ,
we use ( [ eq : smallz ] ) for small @xmath356 , ( [ eq : largez ] ) for large @xmath356 , and for intermediate values of @xmath356 we interpolate from a lookup table pre - computed using ( [ eq : q2de ] ) .
the potential @xmath360 is shown in figure [ fig : q2d ] .
note that @xmath360 is horizontal at @xmath361 , and monotonically decreasing in @xmath356 .
the negative of the slope @xmath362 reaches a maximum of @xmath363 the quantity @xmath364 plays a key role in our analysis of minimizers below .
the fourier transform of @xmath360 can be evaluated exactly using the integral definition ( [ eq : q2dc ] ) and interchanging the order of integration of @xmath6 and @xmath365 to obtain @xmath366 which we note is positive , so local minimizers are global minimizers per the discussion in section [ sec : minimizers ] .
we model a quasi - two - dimensional biological swarm with repulsive social interactions of laplace type and subject to an exogenous gravitational potential , @xmath221 .
the spatial coordinate @xmath193 describes the elevation above ground .
consequently , @xmath39 is the semi - infinite interval @xmath194 . from section [ sec : grav ] , recall that for the one - dimensional model
, @xmath367 is a minimizer for some @xmath26 , corresponding to all swarm members pinned by gravity to the ground .
we consider this same solution as a candidate minimizer for the quasi - two - dimensional problem . in this case
, @xmath59 above is actually a minimizer for any mass @xmath26 . to see this
, we can compute @xmath82 , @xmath368 since @xmath369 , @xmath370 increases away from the origin and hence @xmath59 is at least a swarm minimizer . in fact , if @xmath371 , @xmath101 is a global minimizer because @xmath372 which guarantees that @xmath82 is strictly increasing for @xmath373 as shown in figure [ fig : lambda](a ) . because it is strictly increasing , @xmath374 for @xmath131 .
given this fact , and additionally , since @xmath68 as previously shown , @xmath59 is a global minimizer .
this means that if an infinitesimal amount of mass is added anywhere in the system , it will descend to the origin .
consequently , we believe this solution is the global attractor ( though we have not proven this ) . note that while the condition @xmath375 is sufficient for @xmath59 to be a global minimizer , it is not necessary . as alluded above ,
it is not necessary that @xmath376 be strictly increasing , only that @xmath377 for @xmath131 .
this is the case for for @xmath378 , where @xmath379 .
figure [ fig : lambda](b ) shows a case when @xmath380 .
although @xmath377 for @xmath131 , @xmath82 has a local minimum .
in this situation , although the solution with the mass concentrated at the origin is a global minimizer , it is _ not _ a global attractor .
we will see that a small amount of mass added near the local minimum of @xmath82 will create a swarm minimizer , which is dynamically stable to perturbations .
figure [ fig : lambda](c ) shows the critical case when @xmath381 . in this case
the local minimum of @xmath82 at @xmath382 satisfies @xmath383 and @xmath384 .
figure [ fig : lambda](d ) shows the case when @xmath385 and now @xmath386 in the neighborhood of the minimum . in this case
the solution with the mass concentrated at the origin is only a swarm minimizer ; the energy of the system can be reduced by transporting some of the mass at the origin to the neighborhood of the local minimum . when @xmath387 it is possible to construct a continuum of swarm minimizers .
we have conducted a range of simulations for varying @xmath26 and have measured two basic properties of the solutions .
we set @xmath388 and use @xmath389 in all simulations of the discrete system .
initially , all the swarm members are high above the ground and we evolve the simulation to equilibrium . figure [ fig : quasi2dnumerics](a ) measures the mass on the ground as a percentage of the total swarm mass .
the horizontal blue line indicates ( schematically ) that for @xmath390 , the equilibrium consists of all mass concentrated at the origin ; as discussed above , this state is the global minimizer and ( we believe ) the global attractor . as mass
is increased through @xmath391 , the equilibrium is a swarm minimizer consisting of a classical swarm in the air separated from the origin , and some mass concentrated on the ground . as @xmath26 increases , the proportion of mass located on the ground decreases monotonically .
figure [ fig : quasi2dnumerics](b ) visualizes the support of the airborne swarm , which exists only for @xmath392 ; the lower and upper data represent the coordinates of the bottom and top of the swarm , respectively . as mass
is increased , the span of the swarm increases monotonically . as established above , when @xmath392 , swarm minimizers exist with two components .
in fact , there is a continuum of swarm minimizers with different proportions of mass in the air and on the ground .
which minimizer is obtained in simulation depends on initial conditions .
figure [ fig : lambda2 ] shows two such minimizers for @xmath388 and @xmath393 , and the associated values of @xmath82 ( each obtained from a different initial condition ) . recalling that for a swarm minimizer , each connected component of the swarm ,
@xmath73 is constant , we define @xmath394 for the grounded component and @xmath395 for the airborne component . in figure [ fig : lambda2](ab ) , @xmath396 of the mass is contained in the grounded component . in this case , @xmath397 indicating that the total energy could be reduced by transporting swarm members from the air to the ground .
in contrast , in figure [ fig : lambda2](cd ) , @xmath398 of the mass is contained in the grounded component . in this case , @xmath399 indicating that the total energy could be reduced by transporting swarm members from the ground to the air .
note that by continuity , we believe a state exists where @xmath400 , which would correspond to a global minimizer .
however , this state is clearly not a global attractor and hence will not necessarily be achieved in simulation .
we ve demonstrated that for @xmath401 one can construct a continuum of swarm minimizers with a gap between grounded and airborne components , and that for @xmath402 these solutions can have a lower energy than the state with the density concentrated solely on the ground .
by contrast with the one - dimensional system of section [ sec : grav ] in which no gap is observed , these gap states appear to be the generic configuration for sufficiently large mass in the quasi - two - dimensional system . we conclude that dimensionality is crucial element for the formation of the bubble - like shape of real locust swarms .
in this paper we deeveloped a framework for studying equilibrium solutions for swarming problems .
we related the discrete swarming problem to an associated continuum model .
this continuum model has an energy formulation which enables analysis equilibrium solutions and their stability .
we derived conditions for an equilibrium solution to be a local minimizer , a global minimizer , and/or a swarm minimizer , that is , stable to infinitesimal lagrangian deformations of the mass .
we found many examples of compactly supported equilibrium solutions , which may be discontinuous at the boundary of the support .
in addition , when a boundary of the support coincides with the domain boundary , a minimizer may contain a @xmath0-concentration there .
for the case of exogenous repulsion modeled by the laplace potential , we computed three example equilibria . on a bounded domain ,
the minimizer is a constant density profile with @xmath0-functions at each end . on a half - line with an exogenous gravitational potential ,
the minimizer is a compactly supported linear density profile with a @xmath0-function at the origin . in free space with an exogenous quadratic potential ,
the minimizer is a compactly supported inverted parabola with jump discontinuities at the endpoints .
each of the aforementioned solutions is also a global minimizer . to extend the results above
, we also found analytical solutions for exogenous attractive - repulsive forces , modeled with the morse potential . in the case that the social force was in the catastrophic statistical mechanical regime
, we found a compactly supported solution whose support is independent of the total population mass .
this means that within the modeling assumptions , swarms become denser with increasing mass . for the case of an h - stable social force
, there is no equilibrium solution on an infinite domain . on a finite domain
, mass is partitioned between a classical solution in the interior and @xmath0-concentrations on the boundary .
we recall that for the locust model of @xcite ( see figure [ fig : locust ] ) a concentration of locusts occurs on the ground , with a seemingly classical component above , separated by a gap .
none of the one - dimensional solutions ( for the laplace and morse potentials ) discussed above contain a gap , that is , multiple swarm components that are spatially disconnected , suggesting that this configuration is intrinsically two - dimensional . to study this configuration , we computed a quasi - two - dimensional potential corresponding to a horizontally uniform swarm .
we demonstrated numerically that for a wide range of parameters , there exists a continuous family of swarm minimizers that consist of a concentration on the ground and a disconnected , classical component in the air , reminiscent of our earlier numerical studies of a discrete locust swarm model .
we believe that the analytical solutions we found provide a sampling of the rich tapestry of equilibrium solutions that manifest in the general model we have considered , and in nature .
we hope that these solutions will inspire further analysis and guide future modeling efforts .
cmt acknowledges support from the nsf through grants dms-0740484 and dms-1009633 .
ajb gratefully acknowledges the support from the nsf through grants dms-0807347 and dms-0730630 , and the hospitality of robert kohn and the courant institute of mathematical sciences .
we both wish to thank the institute for mathematics and its applications where portions of this work were completed . , _ optimal transportation , dissipative pde s and functional inequalities _ , in optimal transportation and applications ( martina franca , 2001 ) , vol .
1813 of lecture notes in math . ,
springer , berlin , 2003 , pp .
|
we study equilibrium configurations of swarming biological organisms subject to exogenous and pairwise endogenous forces . beginning with a discrete dynamical model
, we derive a variational description of the corresponding continuum population density .
equilibrium solutions are extrema of an energy functional , and satisfy a fredholm integral equation .
we find conditions for the extrema to be local minimizers , global minimizers , and minimizers with respect to infinitesimal lagrangian displacements of mass .
in one spatial dimension , for a variety of exogenous forces , endogenous forces , and domain configurations , we find exact analytical expressions for the equilibria .
these agree closely with numerical simulations of the underlying discrete model.the exact solutions provide a sampling of the wide variety of equilibrium configurations possible within our general swarm modeling framework .
the equilibria typically are compactly supported and may contain @xmath0-concentrations or jump discontinuities at the edge of the support .
we apply our methods to a model of locust swarms , which are observed in nature to consist of a concentrated population on the ground separated from an airborne group .
our model can reproduce this configuration ; quasi - two - dimensionality of the model plays a critical role . swarm , equilibrium , aggregation , integrodifferential equation , variational model , energy , minimizer , locust
|
studies of charm decays are pursued for several different reasons .
first of all , there is the possibility of directly observing new physics beyond the standard model ( sm ) , since the effects of cp violation due to sm processes is highly suppressed allowing new physics contributions to be more easily seen than in @xmath8 decays where the sm processes typically have large effects @xcite . @xmath1
mixing also is interesting because it could come from either sm or new physics ( np ) processes , and could teach us interesting lessons .
another important reason for detailed charm studies is that most @xmath8 s , @xmath999% , decay into charm , so knowledge about charm decays is particularly useful for @xmath8 decay studies .
especially interesting are absolute branching ratios , resonant substructures in multi - body decays , phases on dalitz plots , etc .. other heavier objects such as top quarks decay into @xmath8 quarks and higgs particles may decay with large rates to @xmath10 , again making charm studies important .
furthermore , charm can teach us a great deal about strong interactions , especially decay constants and final state interactions .
charm has been studied at @xmath11 colliders at threshold , first by the mark iii collaboration and more recently by bes and cleo - c , at higher @xmath11 energies , and at fixed target and hadron collider experiments @xcite .
the detection techniques are rather different at threshold than in other experiments .
the @xmath12 resonance decays into @xmath13 ; the world average cross - section is 3.72@xmath140.09 nb for @xmath15 production and 2.82@xmath140.09 nb for @xmath16 production @xcite .
@xmath5 production is studied at 4170 mev , where the cross - section for @xmath17+@xmath18 is @xmath91 nb @xcite . the underlying light quark
continuum " background is about 14 nb .
the relatively large cross - sections , relatively large branching ratios and sufficient luminosities , allow experiments to fully reconstruct one @xmath19 as a tag . "
since the charge and flavor of the tag is then uniquely determined , the rest of the event can be examined for characteristics of the other known " particle . to measure absolute branching ratios , for example at the @xmath12 , the rest of the event is fully reconstructed , as well as the tag . at the @xmath12 @xmath19 meson final states are reconstructed by first evaluating the difference in the energy , @xmath20 , of the decay products with the beam energy . candidates with @xmath20 consistent with zero are selected and then the @xmath19 beam - constrained mass is evaluated , @xmath21 where @xmath22 runs over all the final state particles .
examples of single and double reconstruction are presented in fig .
[ cleo - double](a ) that shows the @xmath23 distribution for a @xmath24 or @xmath25 final states .
these single tags " show a large signal and a very small background .
[ cleo - double](b ) shows a double " tag sample where both @xmath3 and @xmath26 candidates in the same event are reconstructed .
distributions for candidates from either @xmath24 or @xmath25 modes .
( b ) the @xmath27 distribution for candidates for candidates from @xmath24 and @xmath25 modes .
the solid curves are a fits to the signals plus the backgrounds , that are indicated by the dashed shapes .
the signals are asymmetric due to radiation of the electron beams.,title="fig:",width=302 ] distributions for candidates from either @xmath24 or @xmath25 modes .
( b ) the @xmath27 distribution for candidates for candidates from @xmath24 and @xmath25 modes .
the solid curves are a fits to the signals plus the backgrounds , that are indicated by the dashed shapes .
the signals are asymmetric due to radiation of the electron beams.,title="fig:",width=294 ] other experiments make use of the both the approximately picosecond lifetimes of charm to identify detached vertices , and the decay @xmath28 , which also serves as a flavor tag in the case of @xmath29 transitions .
in charm meson decays , usually a single branching ratio sets the scale for determinations of most other rates , that are measured relative to it . for @xmath2 and @xmath3
these modes are @xmath30 and @xmath31 , respectively .
cleo - c , on the other hand uses a different technique where the branching ratios of several modes are determined simultaneously and all absolutely .
consider an ensemble of modes @xmath22 , that are both singly reconstructed and also doubly reconstructed , where all combinations of modes may be used .
i denote the number of observed single tag charmed particles as @xmath32 , anti - charmed particles as @xmath33 , and double tags as @xmath34 .
they are related to the number of @xmath13 events ( either charged or neutral ) through their branching ratios @xmath35 as @xmath36 where @xmath37 and @xmath38 are the reconstruction efficiencies in single and double tag events for each mode .
( in practice the differences in each mode between single and double tag events are small , and @xmath39 . ) solving these equations we find @xmath40 cleo - c has recently updated their absolute branching ratio measurements using a 281 pb@xmath41 data sample , an approximately 5 times larger data sample than used by them for their previous publication @xcite .
the new preliminary results are shown in table [ tab : dbr ] @xcite .
( in this table when two errors follow a number , the first error is statistical and the second systematic ; this will be true for all results quoted in this paper unless specifically indicated . )
the absolute branching fractions for charm mesons have been measured with unprecedented accuracy .
combining the pdg values with the preliminary cleo - c results for @xmath2 and @xmath3 decays , and using the cleo - c results for @xmath5 , i find @xmath42 cleo - c does not quote a branching ratio for @xmath43 mode because of interferences on the dalitz plot .
the @xmath44 or the @xmath45 modes should be used for normalization .
since most of the @xmath46 decay modes have been measured as ratios to the @xmath47 mode , i extract an effective branching ratio @xmath48 these rates can be used for many purposes . for example , adding up the number of charm quarks produced in each @xmath49 meson decay at the @xmath50 resonance by summing the @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath5 , charmed baryon and twice the charmonium yields gives a rate of 1.09@xmath140.04 , where the largest error comes from the @xmath2 yield .
there is no definitive evidence for @xmath52 mixing .
the best limits yet are @xmath53% and @xmath54 both at 95% c. l. the limit on @xmath55 of about 8% is just beginning to probe an interesting range .
there are two hints that mixing may be soon found .
belle finds consistency with no mixing at 3.9% c. l. in wrong - sign @xmath30 decays and babar finds consistency with no mixing at 4.5% c. l. in wrong sign @xmath56 decays , thus making further searches more interesting .
there have not been any observations of cp or t violation .
this work was supported by the national science foundation under grant # 0553004 .
i thank m. artuso , d. asner , r. faccini , s. malvezzi , n. menaa , p. onysi , r. sia and s. stroiney for interesting discussions and providing data and plots used in this review .
m. artuso , charm decays within the standard model and beyond , " in _ proc . of the xxii int .
symp . on lepton &
photon interactions at high energies _ , ed .
r. brenner , c. p. de los heros , and j. rathsman , world scientific , singapore ( 2006 ) [ hep - ex/0510052 .
s. malvezzi ,
@xmath19-meson dalitz fit from focus , " prepared for 7th conference on intersections between particle and nuclear physics ( cipanp 2000 ) , quebec city , quebec , canada , 22 - 28 may 2000 . published in aip conf
. proc . * 549 * , 569 ( 2002 ) .
the @xmath57 modes include @xmath58 , @xmath59 , and @xmath60 , that sum to 4.3@xmath140.44 times @xmath61 .
the @xmath62 modes include the analgous modes to those for the @xmath57 and , inaddition , feeddown from the @xmath57 modes ; they sum to 9.93@xmath140.95 times @xmath61 .
a. petrov , charm physics : theoretical review , " invited talk at flavor physics and cp violation ( fpcp 2003 ) , paris , france , 3 - 6 jun 2003 ; published in econf c030603 : mec05 ( 2003 ) http://www.slac.stanford.edu / econf / c030603/. r. godang _
_ ( cleo ) , phys.rev . lett . * 84 * , 5038 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ex/0001060 ]
. j. m. link _ et al .
_ ( focus ) , phys .
b * 618 * , 23 ( 2005 ) hep - ex/0412034 ] .
k. abe _ et al . _
( belle ) , phys .
lett . * 94 * , 071801 ( 2005 ) hep - ex/0408125 ] .
b. aubert _ et al .
_ ( babar ) , phys . rev
. lett . * 91 * , 171801 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ex/0304007 ] .
e. m. aitala _
et al . _
( e791 ) , phys .
83 * , 32 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ex/9903012 ] .
j. link _ et al .
_ ( focus ) , phys . lett .
b * 485 * , 62 ( 2000 ) .
( cleo ) , phys .
d * 65 * , 092001 ( 2002 ) .
et al . _ ( belle ) , phys .
lett . * 88 * , 162001 ( 2002 ) .
_ , meaurement of the @xmath52 lifetime difference using @xmath63 decays , " submitted to lepton - photon conference [ belle - conf-347 ] ( 2003 ) . c. cawlfield
_ et al . _ ( cleo ) , phys .
d * 71 * , 077101 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ex/0502012 ] .
b. aubert _ et al .
_ ( babar ) , phys . rev .
d * 70 * , 091102 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ex/0408066 ] .
u. bitenc _
et al . _ ( belle ) , phys . rev .
* d72 * , 071101 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ex/0507020 ] .
d. m. asner _
et al . _ ( cleo ) , phys . rev .
d * 72 * , 012001 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ex/0503045 ] .
as usual it takes two interfering amplitudes to generate an asymmetry , so no direct sm cp asymmetries can arise in pure cabibbo allowed or doubly - cabibbo suppressed decays .
see ref .
@xcite p. 258 .
asymmetries in singly - cabibbo suppressed decays are very small , on the order of @xmath64 in the sm .
x. c. tian _ et al . _
( belle ) , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 231801 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ex/0507071 ] .
d. cronin - hennessy _ et al .
_ ( cleo ) , phys .
d * 72 * , 031102 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ex/0503052 ] .
s. kopp _ et al .
_ ( cleo ) , phys . rev .
d * 63 * , 092001 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ex/0011065 ] .
|
i discuss new results on absolute branching ratios of charm mesons into specific exclusive final states , cabibbo suppressed decay rates , inclusive decays to @xmath0 mesons , limits on @xmath1 mixing , cp violation and t violation .
preliminary results from cleo - c now dominate the world average absolute branching fractions . for the most important normalization modes involving @xmath2 and @xmath3 , the averages are @xmath4 for the @xmath5 cleo - c measures @xmath6 . using this rate , i derive an effective branching ratio @xmath7 , that is appropriate for use in extracting other branching fractions that have often been measured relative to this mode .
this number is compared with other determinations .
|
quantum - mechanical fluctuations during an early epoch of inflation provide a plausible mechanism to generate the energy - density perturbations responsible for observed cosmological structure . while it has been known for quite some time that inflation is consistent with open spatial hypersurfaces ( gott 1982 ; guth & weinberg 1983 ) , attention was initially focussed on models in which there are a very large number of @xmath17-foldings during inflation , resulting in almost exactly flat spatial hypersurfaces for the observable part of the present universe ( guth 1981 ; also see kazanas 1980 ; sato 1981a , b ) .
this was , perhaps , inevitable because of strong theoretical prejudice towards flat spatial hypersurfaces and their resulting simplicity .
however , to get a very large number of @xmath17-foldings during inflation it seems necessary that the inflation model have a small dimensionless parameter ( j. r. gott , private communication 1994 ; banks et al .
1995 ) , which would require an explanation .
attempts to reconcile these favoured " flat spatial hypersurfaces with observational measures of a low value for the clustered - mass density parameter @xmath1 have concentrated on models in which one postulates the presence of a cosmological constant @xmath18 ( peebles 1984 ) . in the simplest flat-@xmath18 model one assumes a scale - invariant ( harrison 1970 ; peebles & yu 1970 ; zeldovich 1972 ) primordial power spectrum for gaussian adiabatic energy - density perturbations .
such a spectrum is generated by quantum - mechanical fluctuations during an early epoch of inflation in a spatially - flat model , provided that the inflaton potential is reasonably flat ( fischler , ratra , & susskind 1985 , and references therein ) .
it has been demonstrated that these models are indeed consistent with current observational constraints ( e.g. , stompor , grski , & banday 1995 ; ostriker & steinhardt 1995 ; ratra & sugiyama 1995 ; liddle et al .
1996b ; ganga , ratra , & sugiyama 1996b , hereafter grs ) .
an alternative , more popular of late , is to accept that the spatial hypersurfaces are not flat . in this case , the radius of curvature for the open spatial sections introduces a new length scale ( in addition to the hubble length ) , which requires a generalization of the usual flat - space scale - invariant spectrum ( ratra & peebles 1994 , hereafter rp94 ) .
such a spectrum is generated by quantum - mechanical fluctuations during an epoch of inflation in an open - bubble model ( rp94 ; ratra & peebles 1995 , hereafter rp95 ; bucher et al . 1995 , hereafter bgt ; lyth & woszczyna 1995 ; yamamoto et al .
1995 , hereafter yst ) , provided that the inflaton potential inside the bubble is reasonably flat .
such gaussian adiabatic open - bubble inflation models have also been shown to be consistent with current observational constraints ( rp94 ; kamionkowski et al .
1994 ; grski et al .
1995 , hereafter grsb ; liddle et al . 1996a , hereafter llrv ; ratra et al .
1995 ; grs ) .
inflation theory by itself is unable to predict the normalization amplitude for the energy - density perturbations .
currently , the least controversial and most robust method for the normalization of a cosmological model is to fix the amplitude of the model - predicted large - scale cmb spatial anisotropy by comparing it to the observed cmb anisotropy discovered by the @xmath0-dmr experiment ( smoot et al .
1992 ) . previously , specific open cold dark matter ( cdm ) models have been examined in light of the @xmath0-dmr two - year results ( bennett et al .
grsb investigated the cmb anisotropy angular spectra predicted by the open - bubble inflation model ( rp94 ) , and compared large - scale structure predictions of this dmr - normalized model to observational data .
cayn et al .
( 1996 ) performed a related analysis for the open model with a flat - space scale - invariant spectrum ( wilson 1983 , hereafter w83 ) , and yamamoto & bunn ( 1996 , hereafter yb ) examined the effect of additional sources of quantum fluctuations ( bgt ; yst ) in the open - bubble inflation model . in this paper
, we study the observational predictions for a number of open cdm models .
in particular , we employ the power spectrum estimation technique devised by grski ( 1994 ) for incomplete sky coverage to normalize the open models using the @xmath0-dmr four - year data ( bennett 1996 ) .
in @xmath19 we provide an overview of open - bubble inflation cosmogonies .
in @xmath20 we detail the various dmr data sets used in the analyses here , discuss the various open models we consider , and present the dmr estimate of the cmb rms quadrupole anisotropy amplitude @xmath21 as a function of @xmath1 for these open models . in @xmath22
we detail the computation of several cosmographic and large - scale structure statistics for the dmr - normalized open models .
these statistics are confronted by various current observational constraints in @xmath23 .
our results are summarized in @xmath24 .
the simplest open inflation model is that in which a single open - inflation bubble nucleates in a ( possibly ) spatially - flat , inflating spacetime ( gott 1982 ; guth & weinberg 1983 ) . in this model ,
the first epoch of inflation smooths away any preexisting spatial inhomogeneities , while simultaneously generating quantum - mechanical zero - point fluctuations .
then , in a tunnelling event , an open - inflation bubble nucleates , and for a small enough nucleation probability the observable universe lies inside a single open - inflation bubble . fluctuations of relevance to the late - time universe can be generated via three different quantum mechanical mechanisms : ( 1 ) they can be generated in the first epoch of inflation ; ( 2 ) they can be generated during the tunnelling event ( thus resulting in a slightly inhomogeneous initial hypersurface inside the bubble , or a slightly non - spherical bubble ) ; and ( 3 ) they can be generated inside the bubble .
the tunneling amplitude is largest for the most symmetrical solution ( and deviations from symmetry lead to an exponential suppression ) , so it has usually been assumed that the nucleation process ( mechanism [ 2 ] ) does not lead to the generation of significant inhomogeneities .
quantum - mechanical fluctuations generated during evolution inside the bubble ( rp95 ) are significant . assuming that the energy - density difference between the two epochs of inflation is negligible ( and so the bubble wall is not significant )
, one may estimate the contribution to the perturbation spectrum after bubble nucleation from quantum - mechanical fluctuations during the first epoch of inflation ( bgt ; yst ) . as discussed by bucher & turok ( 1995 , hereafter bt ) ( also see yst ; yb ) , the observable predictions of these simple open - bubble inflation models are almost completely insensitive to the details of the first epoch of inflation , for the observationally - viable range of @xmath1 .
this is because the fluctuations generated during this epoch affect only the smallest wavenumber part of the energy - density perturbation power spectrum , which can not contribute significantly to observable quantities because of the spatial curvature length
cutoff " in an open universe ( e.g. , w83 ; kamionkowski & spergel 1994 ; rp95 ) .
inclusion of such fluctuations in the calculations alter the predictions for the present value of the rms linear mass fluctuations averaged over an @xmath25 mpc sphere , @xmath26 $ ] , by @xmath27 ( which is comparable to our computational accuracy ) . besides the open - bubble inflation model spectra , a variety of alternatives have also been considered .
predictions for the usual flat - space scale - invariant spectrum in an open model have been examined ( w83 ; abbott & schaefer 1986 ; gouda , sugiyama , & sasaki 1991 ; sugiyama & gouda 1992 ; kamionkowski & spergel 1994 ; sugiyama & silk 1994 ; cayn et al .
the possibility that the standard formulation of quantum mechanics is incorrect in an open universe , and that allowance must be made for non - square - integrable basis functions has been investigated ( lyth & woszczyna 1995 ) , and other spectra have also been considered ( e.g. , w83 ; abbott & schaefer 1986 ; kamionkowski & spergel 1994 ) .
these spectra , being inconsistent with either standard quantum mechanics or the length scale set by spatial curvature , are of historical interest .
more recently , the open - bubble inflation scenario has been further elaborated on .
yst have considered a very specific model for the nucleation of the open bubble in a spatially - flat de sitter spacetime , and demonstrated a possible additional contribution from a non - square - integrable basis function which depends on the form of the potential , and on the assumed form of the quantum state prior to bubble nucleation . however , since the non - square - integrable basis function contributes only on the very largest scales , the spatial curvature cutoff " in an open universe makes almost all of the model predictions insensitive to this basis function , for the observationally - viable range of @xmath1 ( yst ; yb ) .
for example , at @xmath28 its effect is to change @xmath26 $ ] by @xmath29 . an additional possible effect determined for the specific model of an open - inflation bubble nucleating in a spatially - flat de sitter
spacetime is that fluctuations of the bubble wall behave like a non - square - integrable basis function ( hamazaki et al .
1996 ; garriga 1996 ; garca - bellido 1996 ; yamamoto , sasaki , & tanaka 1996 ) . while there are models in which these bubble - wall fluctuations are completely insignificant ( garriga 1996 ; yamamoto et al .
1996 ) , there is as yet no computation that accounts for both the bubble - wall fluctuations as well as those generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( which are always present ) , so it is not yet known if bubble - wall fluctuations can give rise to an observationally significant effect .
finally , again in this very specific model , the effects of a finite bubble size at nucleation seem to alter the zero bubble size predictions only by a very small amount ( yamamoto et al .
1996 ; cohn 1996 ) . while there is no guarantee that there is a spatially - flat de sitter spacetime prior to bubble nucleation
, these computations do illustrate the important point that the spatial curvature length cutoff " in an open universe ( e.g. , rp95 ) does seem to ensure that what happens prior to bubble nucleation does not significantly affect the observable predictions for observationally - viable single - field open - bubble inflation models .
it is indeed reassuring that accounting only for the quantum mechanical fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp94 ) seems to be essentially all that is required to make observational predictions for the single - field open - bubble inflation models .
that is , the observational predictions of the open - bubble inflation scenario seem to be as robust as those for the spatially - flat inflation scenario .
in this paper , we utilize the dmr four - year 53 and 90 ghz sky maps in both galactic and ecliptic coordinates .
we thus quantify explicitly the expected small shifts in the inferred normalization amplitudes due to the small differences between the galactic- and ecliptic - coordinate maps .
the maps are coadded using inverse - noise - variance weights derived in each coordinate system .
the least sensitive 31 ghz maps have been omitted from the analysis , since their contribution is minimal under such a weighting scheme .
the dominant source of emission in the dmr maps is due to the galactic plane .
we are unable to model this contribution to the sky temperature to sufficient accuracy to enable its subtraction , thus we excise all pixels where the galactic - plane signal dominates the cmb .
the geometry of the cut has been determined by using the dirbe 140 @xmath30 m map as a tracer of the strongest emission , as described completely in banday ( 1996a ) .
all pixels with galactic latitude @xmath31 20@xmath32@xmath33 are removed , together with regions towards scorpius - ophiucus and taurus - orion .
there are 3881 surviving pixels in galactic coordinates and 3890 in ecliptic .
this extended ( four - year data ) galactic plane cut has provided the biggest impact on the analysis of the dmr data ( see grski et al .
1996 , hereafter g96 ) .
the extent to which residual high - latitude galactic emission can modify our results has been quantified in two ways . since the spatial morphology of galactic synchrotron
, free - free and dust emission seems to be well described by a steeply falling power spectrum ( @xmath34 kogut 1996a , g96 ) , the cosmological signal is predominantly compromised on the largest angular scales . as a simple test of galactic contamination
, we perform all computations both including and excluding the observed sky quadrupole . a more detailed approach ( g96 )
notes that a large fraction of the galactic signal can be accounted for by using the dirbe 140 @xmath30 m sky map ( reach 1995 ) as a template for free - free and dust emission , and the 408 mhz all - sky radio survey ( haslam 1981 ) to describe synchrotron emission .
a correlation analysis yields coupling coefficients for the two templates at each of the dmr frequencies .
we have repeated our model analysis after correcting the coadded sky maps by the galactic templates scaled by the coefficients derived in g96 . in particular , we adopt those values derived under the assumption that the cmb anisotropy is well - described by an @xmath35 = 1 power law model with normalization amplitude @xmath21 @xmath36 18 @xmath30k and coupling coefficient amplitudes .
in fact , we have investigated this for a sub - sample of the models considered here in which we varied @xmath1 but fixed @xmath2 and @xmath10 .
no statistically significant changes were found in the derived values of either @xmath21 or the coupling coefficients . ] .
one might make criticisms of either technique : excluding information from an analysis , in this case the quadrupole components , can obviously weaken any conclusions simply because statistical uncertainties will grow ; at the same time , it is not clear whether the galactic corrections applied are completely adequate .
we believe that , given these uncertainties , our analysis is the most complete and conservative one that is possible . the power spectrum analysis technique developed by grski ( 1994 ) is implemented .
orthogonal basis functions for the fourier decomposition of the sky maps are constructed which specifically include both pixelization effects and the galactic cut .
( these are linear combinations of the usual spherical harmonics with multipole @xmath37 . )
the functions are coordinate system dependent . a likelihood analysis is then performed as described in grski ( 1994 ) .
we consider four open model energy - density perturbation power spectra : ( 1 ) the open - bubble inflation model spectrum , accounting only for fluctuations that are generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp94 ) ; ( 2 ) the open - bubble inflation model spectrum , now also accounting for the fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation ( bgt ; yst ) ; ( 3 ) the open - bubble inflation model spectrum , now also accounting for both the usual fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation and a contribution from a non - square - integrable basis function ( yst ) ; and , ( 4 ) an open model with a flat - space scale - invariant spectrum ( w83 ) . in all cases
we have ignored the possibility of tilt or primordial gravity waves , since it is unlikely that they can have a significant effect in viable open models . with the eigenvalue of the spatial scalar laplacian being @xmath38 , where @xmath39 is the radial coordinate spatial wavenumber , the gauge - invariant fractional energy - density perturbation power spectrum of type ( 1 ) above is @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the transfer function and @xmath42 is the normalization amplitude ) generalize the primordial part of the spectrum of eq .
( 1 ) by multiplying it with @xmath43 . as yet , only the specific @xmath44 generalized spectrum ( i.e. , eq .
[ 1 ] ) is known to be a prediction of an open - bubble inflation model and therefore consistent with the presence of spatial curvature .
it is premature to draw conclusions about open cosmogony on the basis of the @xmath45 version of the spectrum considered by bw . ] . in the simplest example , perturbations generated in the first epoch of inflation introduce an additional multiplicative factor , @xmath46 , on the right hand side of eq .
( 1 ) . for a discussion of the effects of the non - square - integrable basis function see yst and yb .
the energy - density power spectrum of type ( 4 ) above is @xmath47 and in this case one can also consider , e.g. , @xmath48 ( w83 ) , but because of the spatial curvature cutoff " in an open model the predictions are essentially indistinguishable . at
small @xmath49 the asymptotic expressions are @xmath50 ( type 1 ) , @xmath51 ( type 2 ) , and @xmath52 ( type 4 ) .
conventionally , the cmb fractional temperature perturbation , @xmath53 , is expressed as a function of angular position , @xmath54 , on the sky via the spherical harmonic decomposition , @xmath55 the cmb spatial anisotropy in a gaussian model can then be characterized by the angular perturbation spectrum @xmath56 , defined in terms of the ensemble average , @xmath57 the @xmath56 s used here were computed using two independent boltzmann transfer codes developed by ns ( e.g. , sugiyama 1995 ) and rs ( e.g. , stompor 1994 ) .
some illustrative comparisons are shown in fig .
we emphasize that the excellent agreement between the @xmath56 s computed using the two codes is mostly a reflection of the currently achievable numerical accuracy .
currently , the major likely additional , unaccounted for , source of uncertainty is that due to the uncertainty in the modelling of various physical effects .
the computations here assume a standard recombination thermal history , and ignore the possibility of early reionization .
the simplest open models ( with the least possible number of free parameters ) have yet to be ruled out by observational data ( grsb ; ratra et al .
1995 ; grs ; this paper ) , so there is insufficient motivation to expand the model - parameter space by including the effect of early reionization , tilt or gravity waves values determined from the dmr data here ( assuming no early reionization ) are unlikely to be very significantly affected by early reionization . however , since structure forms earlier in an open model , other effects of early reionization might be more significant in an open model .
while it is possible to heuristically account for such effects , an accurate quantitative estimate must await a better understanding of structure formation . ] .
for the @xmath58 of types ( 1 ) , ( 2 ) , and ( 4 ) above , we have evaluated the cmb anisotropy angular spectra for a range of @xmath1 spanning the interval between 0.1 and 1.0 , for a variety of values of @xmath2 ( the hubble parameter @xmath59 ) and the baryonic - mass density parameter @xmath10 .
the values of @xmath2 were selected to cover the lower part of the range of ages consistent with current requirements ( @xmath60 10.5 gyr , 12 gyr , or 13.5 gyr , with @xmath2 as a function of @xmath1 computed accordingly ; see , for example , jimenez et al .
1996 ; chaboyer et al .
the values of @xmath10 were chosen to be consistent with current standard nucleosynthesis requirements ( @xmath61 0.0055 , 0.0125 , or 0.0205 ; e.g. , copi , schramm , & turner 1995 ; sarkar 1996 ) . to render the problem tractable ,
@xmath56 s were determined for the central values of @xmath62 and @xmath63 , and for the two combinations of these parameters which most perturb the @xmath56 s from those computed at the central values ( i.e. , for the smallest @xmath62 we used the smallest @xmath63 , and for the largest @xmath62 we used the largest @xmath63 ) .
specific parameter values are given in columns ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) of tables 16 , and representative anisotropy spectra can be seen in figs . 2 and 3 .
we therefore improve on our earlier analysis of the dmr two - year data ( grsb ) by considering a suitably broader range in the ( @xmath10 , @xmath2 ) parameter space .
the cmb anisotropy spectra for @xmath58 of type ( 3 ) above were computed for a range of @xmath1 spanning the interval between 0.1 and 0.9 , for @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
specific parameter values are given in columns ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) of table 7 , and these spectra are shown in fig .
4 . in fig .
5 we compare the various spectra considered here . the differences in the low-@xmath66 shapes of the @xmath56 s in the various models ( figs .
25 ) are a consequence of three effects : ( 1 ) the shape of the energy - density perturbation power spectrum at low wavenumber ; ( 2 ) the exponential suppression at the spatial curvature scale in an open model ; and ( 3 ) the interplay between the usual " ( fiducial cdm ) sachs - wolfe term and the integrated " sachs - wolfe ( hereafter sw ) term in the expression for the cmb spatial anisotropy . the relative importance of these effects is determined by the value of @xmath1 , and leads to the non - monotonic behaviour of the large - scale @xmath56 s as a function of @xmath1 seen in figs .
more precisely , the contributions to the cmb anisotropy angular spectrum from the usual " and integrated " sw terms have a different @xmath66-dependence as well as a relative amplitude that is both @xmath1 and @xmath58 dependent . on very large angular scales ( small @xmath66 s ) , the dominant contribution to the usual " sw term comes from a higher redshift ( when the length scales are smaller ) than does the dominant contribution to the integrated " sw term ( hu & sugiyama 1994 , 1995 ) . as a result , in an open model on very large angular scales , the usual "
sw term is cut off more sharply by the spatial curvature length scale than is the integrated " sw term ( hu & sugiyama 1994 ) , i.e. , on very large angular scales in an open model the usual " sw term has a larger ( positive ) effective index @xmath35 than the integrated " sw term . on slightly smaller angular scales
the integrated " sw term is damped ( i.e. , it has a negative effective index @xmath35 ) while the usual " sw term plateaus ( hu & sugiyama 1994 ) . as a consequence , going from the largest to slightly smaller angular scales , the
usual " term rises steeply and then flattens , while the integrated " term rises less steeply and then drops ( i.e. , it has a peak ) .
the change in shape , as a function of @xmath66 , of these two terms is both @xmath1 and @xmath58 dependent .
these are the two dominant effects at @xmath67 ; at higher @xmath66 other effects come into play .
more specifically , for @xmath68 the curvature length scale cutoff and the precise large - scale form of the @xmath58 considered here are relatively unimportant the cmb anisotropy angular spectrum is quite similar to that for @xmath69 , and the dominant contribution is the usual " sw term . for a @xmath58 that does not diverge at low wavenumber , as with the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum in an open model , for @xmath70 the exponential cutoff " at the spatial curvature length dominates , and the lowest-@xmath66 @xmath56 s are suppressed ( figs . 3 and 5 ) . for this @xmath58 ,
as @xmath1 is reduced , the usual " term continues to be important on the largest angular scales down to @xmath28 .
as @xmath1 is reduced below @xmath71 the integrated " term starts to dominate on the largest angular scales , and as @xmath1 is further reduced the integrated " term also starts to dominate on smaller angular scales . from fig .
3(a ) one will notice that the integrated " sw term peak " first makes an appearance at @xmath72 the central line in the plot at @xmath73 and that as @xmath1 is further reduced ( in descending order along the curves shown ) the integrated " term peak " moves to smaller angular scales .
the @xmath74 case is where the integrated " term peaks at @xmath75 , and the damping of this term on smaller angular scales ( @xmath76 ) is compensated for by the steep rise of the usual " sw term the two terms are of roughly equal magnitude at @xmath77 and these effects result in the almost exactly scale - invariant spectrum at @xmath9 ( this case is more scale - invariant than fiducial cdm ) .
a discussion of some of these features of the cmb anisotropy angular spectrum in the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model is given in cayn et al .
( 1996 ) .
open - bubble inflation models have a @xmath58 that diverges at low wavenumber ( rp95 ; note that no physical quantity diverges ) , and this increases the low-@xmath66 @xmath56 s ( figs . 2 and 5 ) relative to those of the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( figs . 3 and 5 ) .
the @xmath56 s for low @xmath1 models increase more than the higher @xmath1 ones , since , for a fixed wavenumber - dependence of @xmath58 , the divergence is more prominent at lower @xmath1 ( rp94 ) .
the non - square - integrable basis function ( yst ) contributes even more power on large angular scales , and so , at low-@xmath66 , the @xmath56 s of fig .
4 are slightly larger than those of fig .
2 ( also see fig . 5 ) . again
, spectra at lower values of @xmath1 are more significantly influenced . as is clear from figs . 2 and 5 , in an open - bubble inflation model
, quantum - mechanical zero - point fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation scarcely affect the @xmath56 s , although at the very lowest values of @xmath1 the very lowest order @xmath56 coefficients are slightly modified .
the effect is concentrated in this region of the parameter space since the fluctuations in the first inflation epoch only contribute to , and increase , the lowest wavenumber part of @xmath58 . in simple open - bubble inflation models ,
the precise value of this small effect is dependent on the model assumed for the first epoch of inflation ( bt ) .
since the dmr data is most sensitive to multipole moments with @xmath78 810 , one expects the effect at @xmath78 23 to be almost completely negligible ( bt ; also see yst ; yb ) . figs .
35 show that both the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model , and the contribution from the non - square - integrable mode , do lead to significantly different @xmath56 s ( compared to those of fig .
the results of the dmr likelihood analyses are summarized in figs . 621 and tables 17 and 13 .
two representative sets of likelihood functions @xmath79 are shown in figs . 6 and 7 .
figure 6 shows those derived from the ecliptic - frame sky maps , ignoring the correction for faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission , and excluding the quadrupole moment from the analysis .
figure 7 shows the likelihood functions derived from the galactic - frame sky maps , accounting for the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction , and including the quadrupole moment in the analysis .
together , these two data sets span the maximum range of normalizations inferred from our analysis ( the former providing the highest , and the latter the lowest @xmath21 ) .
tables 17 give the @xmath21 central values and 1-@xmath80 and 2-@xmath80 ranges for spectra of type ( 1 ) , ( 3 ) , and ( 4 ) above , computed from the appropriate posterior probability density distribution function assuming a uniform prior . each line in tables 17 lists these values at a given @xmath1 for the 8 possible combinations of : ( 1 ) galactic- or ecliptic - coordinate map ; ( 2 ) faint high - latitude galactic foreground emission correction accounted for or ignored ; and , ( 3 ) quadrupole included ( @xmath81 ) or excluded ( @xmath82 ) value of varying cosmological parameters like @xmath10 .
since they do not quote derived @xmath21 values for this model we are not able to compare to their results . ] .
the corresponding ridge lines of maximum likelihood @xmath21 value as a function of @xmath1 are shown in figs .
810 for some of the cosmological - parameter values considered here .
although we have computed these values for spectra of type ( 2 ) above ( i.e. , those accounting for perturbations generated in the first epoch of inflation ) we record only a subset of them in column ( 4 ) of table 13 . these should be compared to columns ( 2 ) and ( 6 ) of table 13 , which show the maximal 2-@xmath80 @xmath21 range for spectra of types ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) .
while the differences in @xmath21 between spectra ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) [ cols . ( 2 ) and ( 4 ) of table 13 ] are not totally insignificant , more importantly the differences between the @xmath26 $ ] values for the three spectra [ cols .
( 3 ) , ( 5 ) , and ( 7 ) of table 13 ] are observationally insignificant .
the entries in tables 16 illustrate the shift in the inferred normalization amplitudes due to changes in @xmath2 and @xmath10 .
these shifts are larger for models with a larger @xmath1 , since these models have cmb anisotropy spectra that rise somewhat more rapidly towards large @xmath66 , so in these cases the dmr data is sensitive to somewhat smaller angular scales where the effects of varying @xmath2 and @xmath63 are more prominent .
figure 11 shows the effects that varying @xmath62 and @xmath63 have on some of the ridge lines of maximum likelihood @xmath21 as a function of @xmath1 , and fig .
13 illustrates the effects on some of the conditional ( fixed @xmath1 slice ) likelihood densities for @xmath83 on the whole , for the cmb anisotropy spectra considered here , shifts in @xmath2 and @xmath84 have only a small effect on the inferred normalization amplitude .
the normalization amplitude is somewhat more sensitive to the differences between the galactic- and ecliptic - coordinate sky maps , to the foreground high - latitude galactic emission treatment , and to the inclusion or exclusion of the @xmath85 moment .
for the purpose of normalizing models , we choose for our 2-@xmath80 c.l .
bounds values from the likelihood fits that span the maximal range in the @xmath21 normalizations .
specifically , for the lower 2-@xmath80 bound we adopt the value determined from the analysis of the galactic - coordinate maps accounting for the high - latitude galactic emission correction and including the @xmath85 moment in the analysis , and for the upper 2-@xmath80 value that determined from the analysis of the ecliptic - coordinate maps ignoring the galactic emission correction and excluding the @xmath85 moment from the analysis .
these values are recorded in columns ( 5 ) and ( 8) of tables 912 , and columns ( 2 ) , ( 4 ) , and ( 6 ) of table 13 ) were used in the likelihood analyses of the various model spectra , and different interpolation methods were used in the determination of the @xmath21 values , there are small ( but insignificant ) differences in the quoted @xmath21 values for some identical models in these tables . ] .
figure 12 compares the ridge lines of maximum likelihood @xmath21 value , as a function of @xmath1 , for the four different cmb anisotropy angular spectra considered here , and fig .
14 compares some of the conditional ( fixed @xmath1 slice ) likelihood densities for @xmath21 for these four cmb anisotropy angular spectra .
approximate fitting formulae may be derived to describe the above two extreme 2-@xmath80 limits . for the open - bubble inflation model ( rp94 ; bgt ; yst ) , not including a contribution from a non - square - integrable basis function , we have @xmath86 , \eqno(5)\ ] ] which is good to better than @xmath87 for all values of @xmath1 ( and to better than @xmath88 over the observationally - viable range of @xmath89 ) .
for those models including a contribution from the non - square - integrable basis function ( yst ) , we have @xmath90 , \eqno(6)\ ] ] mostly good to better than @xmath88 .
the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model fitting formula is @xmath91 , \eqno(7)\ ] ] generally good to better than @xmath92 , except near @xmath93 and @xmath94 where the deviations are larger .
further details about these fitting formulae may be found in stompor ( 1996 ) .
the approximate fitting formulae ( 5)(7 ) provide a convenient , portable normalization of the open models .
it is important , however , to note that they have been derived using the @xmath21 values determined for a given @xmath2 and @xmath10 , and hence do not account for the additional uncertainty ( which could be as large as @xmath88 ) due to allowed variations in these parameters .
we emphasize that in our analysis here we make use of the actual @xmath21 values derived from the likelihood analyses , not these fitting formulae .
figures 15 and 16 show projected likelihood densities for @xmath1 , for some of the models and dmr data sets considered here .
note that the general features of the projected likelihood densities for the open - bubble inflation model only accounting for the fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( spectrum [ 1 ] above ) , are consistent with those derived from the dmr two - year data ( grsb , fig .
3 ) . however , since we only compute down to @xmath95 here , only the rise to the prominent peak at very low @xmath1 ( grsb ) is seen .
bw show in the middle left - hand panel of their fig .
11 ( presumably ) the projected likelihood density for @xmath1 for the same open - bubble inflation model , the general features of which are consistent with those derived here .
figures 1721 show marginal likelihood densities for @xmath1 , for some of the models and dmr data sets considered here . for the open - bubble inflation model accounting only for the fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp94 ) ,
the dmr two - year data galactic - frame ( quadrupole moment excluded and included ) marginal likelihoods are shown in fig . 3 of grsb , and are in general concord with those shown in fig .
17 here ( although , again , only the rise to the prominent low-@xmath1 peak is seen here ) .
note that now , especially for the quadrupole excluded case , the peaks and troughs are more prominent ( although still not greatly statistically significant ) .
furthermore , comparing the solid line of fig .
17(b ) here to the heavy dotted line of fig . 3 of grsb ,
one notices that the intermediate @xmath1 peak is now at @xmath96 , instead of at @xmath97 for the dmr two - year data .
( since bw chose not to compute for the case when the quadrupole moment is excluded from the analysis , they presumably did not notice the peak at @xmath98 in the marginalized likelihood density for the open - bubble inflation model see fig .
17 . ) for the open - bubble inflation model now also accounting for both the fluctuations generated in the first spatially - flat epoch of inflation ( bgt ; yst ) , and those from the non - square - integrable basis function ( yst ) , the dmr two - year data ecliptic - frame quadrupole - included marginal likelihood ( shown as the solid line in fig . 3 of yb ) is in general agreement with the dot - dashed line of fig .
however , yb did not compute for the case where the quadrupole moment was excluded from the analysis and so did not find the peak at @xmath99 in fig .
19 . given the shapes of the marginal likelihoods in figs .
1721 , it is not at all clear if it is meaningful to derive limits on @xmath1 without making use of other ( prior ) information . as an example , it is not at all clear what to use for the integration range in @xmath1 .
focussing on fig .
21(a ) ( which is similar to the other quadrupole excluded cases ) , the only conclusion seems to be that @xmath9 is the value most consistent with the dmr data ( at least amongst those models with @xmath14 some of the models have another peak at @xmath100 , grsb ) . however , when the quadrupole moment is included in the analysis ( as in fig .
21b ) , the open - bubble inflation model peaks are at @xmath12 ( at least in the range @xmath14 , grsb ) , while the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model peak is at @xmath11 . at the 95% c.l .
no value of @xmath1 over the range considered , 0.11 , is excluded .
( the yb and bw claims of a lower limit on @xmath1 from the dmr data alone are , at the very least , premature . )
the @xmath58 ( e.g. , eqs . [ 1 ] and [ 2 ] ) were determined from a numerical integration of the linear perturbation theory equations of motion .
as before , the computations were performed with two independent numerical codes .
for some of the model - parameter values considered here the results of the two computations were compared and found to be in excellent agreement .
illustrative examples of the comparisons are shown in fig .
again , we emphasize that the excellent agreement is mostly a reflection of the currently available numerical accuracy , and the most likely additional , unaccounted for , source of uncertainty is that due to the uncertainty in the modelling of various physical effects .
table 8 list the @xmath58 normalization amplitudes @xmath42 ( e.g. , eqs . [ 1 ] and [ 2 ] ) when @xmath101k .
examples of the power spectra normalized to @xmath21 derived from the mean of the dmr four - year data analysis extreme upper and lower 2-@xmath80 limits discussed above are shown in figs .
one will notice , from fig .
23(e ) , the good agreement between the open - bubble inflation spectra . when normalized to the two extreme 2-@xmath80 @xmath21 limits ( e.g. , cols . [ 5 ] and [ 8 ] of table 10 ) , the @xmath58 normalization factor ( eq . [ 1 ] and table 8) for the open - bubble inflation model ( rp94 ; bgt ; yst ) , may be summarized by , for the lower 2-@xmath80 limit , @xmath102 , \eqno(8)\ ] ] and for the upper 2-@xmath80 limit , @xmath103 .
\eqno(9)\ ] ] these fits are good to @xmath104 for @xmath14 .
note however that they are derived using the @xmath21 values determined for given @xmath62 and @xmath63 and hence do not account for the additional uncertainty introduced by allowed variations in these parameters ( which could affect the power spectrum normalization amplitude by as much as @xmath105 ) . from fig .
23(e ) , and given the uncertainties , we see that the fitting formulae of eqs .
( 8) and ( 9 ) provide an adequate summary for all the open - bubble inflation model spectra . the extreme @xmath106-@xmath80 @xmath58 normalization factor ( eq .
[ 2 ] and table 8) for the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( w83 ) may be summarized by , for the lower 2-@xmath80 limit , @xmath107 , \eqno(10)\ ] ] and for the upper 2-@xmath80 limit , @xmath108 .
\eqno(11)\ ] ] these fits are good to better than @xmath88 for @xmath109 ; again , they are derived from @xmath21 values determined at given @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
given the uncertainties involved in the normalization procedure ( born of both statistical and other arguments ) it is not yet possible to quote a unique dmr normalization amplitude ( g96 ) .
as a central " value for the @xmath58 normalization factor , we currently advocate the mean of eqs .
( 8) and ( 9 ) or eqs . ( 10 ) and ( 11 ) as required .
we emphasize , however , that it is incorrect to draw conclusions about model viability based solely on this central " value . in conjunction with numerically determined transfer functions ,
the fits of eqs .
( 8)(11 ) allow for a determination of @xmath26 $ ] , accurate to a few percent . here
the mean square linear mass fluctuation averaged over a sphere of coordinate radius @xmath110 is @xmath111 ^ 2\right\rangle & = & { 2 \over \pi^2 \left[{\rm sinh } ( \bar\chi)\ , { \rm cosh}(\bar\chi ) - \bar\chi\right]^2 } \nonumber \\ { \ } & { \ } & \times \int^\infty_0 { dk \over ( 1 + k^2)^2 } \left[{\rm cosh}(\bar\chi)\ , { \rm sin}(k\bar\chi ) - k\ , { \rm sinh}(\bar\chi ) \ , { \rm cos}(k\bar\chi ) \right]^2 p(k ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which , on small scales , reduces to the usual flat - space expression @xmath112 \int^\infty_0 dk\ , k^2 p(k ) \left[{\rm sin}(k\bar\chi ) - k\bar\chi \ , { \rm cos}(k\bar\chi ) \right]^2/(k\bar\chi)^6 $ ] .
if instead use is made of the bardeen et al .
( 1986 , hereafter bbks ) analytic fit to the transfer function using the parameterization of eq .
( 13 ) below ( sugiyama 1995 ) and numerically determined values for @xmath42 , the resultant @xmath113 $ ] values are accurate to better than @xmath87 ( except for large baryon - fraction , @xmath114 , models where the error could be as large as @xmath115 ) .
use of the analytic fits of eqs .
( 8)(11 ) for @xmath42 ( instead of the numerically determined values ) slightly increases the error , while use of the bbks transfer function fit parameterized by an earlier version of eq .
( 13 ) below , @xmath116 $ ] , results in @xmath26 $ ] values that could be off by as much as @xmath117 .
nevertheless , as has been demonstrated by llrv , the approximate analytic fit to the transfer function greatly simplifies the computation and allows for rapid demarcation of the favoured part of cosmological - parameter space .
numerical values for some cosmographic and large - scale structure statistics for the models considered here are recorded in tables 915 .
we emphasize that when comparing to observational data we make use of numerically - determined large - scale structure predictions , not those derived using an approximate analytic fitting formula .
tables 912 give the predictions for the open - bubble inflation model accounting only for the perturbations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp94 ) , and for the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( w83 ) .
each of these tables corresponds to a different pair of @xmath118 values .
the first two columns in these tables record @xmath1 and @xmath2 , and the third column is the cosmological baryonic - matter fraction @xmath119 .
the fourth column gives the value of the matter power spectrum scaling parameter ( sugiyama 1995 ) , @xmath120 which is used to parameterize approximate analytic fits to the power spectra derived from numerical integration of the perturbation equations .
the quantities listed in columns ( 1)(4 ) of these tables are sensitive only to the global parameters of the cosmological model .
columns ( 5 ) and ( 8) of tables 912 give the dmr data 2-@xmath80 range of @xmath21 that is used to normalize the perturbations in the models considered here . the numerical values in table 12 are for @xmath121 gyr , @xmath122 .
we did not analyze the dmr data using @xmath56 s for these models , and in this case the perturbations are normalized to the @xmath21 values from the @xmath123 gyr , @xmath124 analyses .
( as discussed above , shifts in @xmath2 and @xmath63 do not greatly alter the inferred normalization amplitude . ) columns ( 6 ) and ( 9 ) of tables 912 give the 2-@xmath80 range of @xmath125 $ ] .
these were determined using the @xmath58 derived from numerical integration of the perturbation equations .
for about two dozen cases , these rms mass fluctuations determined using the two independent numerical integration codes were compared and found to be in excellent agreement .
( at fixed @xmath21 , they differ by @xmath126 depending on model - parameter values , with the typical difference being @xmath127 .
we again emphasize that this is mostly a reflection of currently achievable numerical accuracy . ) .
to usually better than @xmath128 accuracy , for @xmath129 , the 2-@xmath80 @xmath130 $ ] entries of columns ( 6 ) and ( 9 ) of tables 912 may be summarized by the fitting formulae listed in table 14 .
these fitting formulae are more accurate than expressions for @xmath26 $ ] derived at the same cosmological - parameter values using an analytic approximation to the transfer function and the normalization of eqs .
( 8)(11 ) . for open models ,
as discussed below , it proves most convenient to characterize the peculiar velocity perturbation by the parameter @xmath131 where @xmath132 is the linear bias factor for @xmath133 galaxies ( e.g. , peacock & dodds 1994 ) .
the 2-@xmath80 range of @xmath134 are listed in columns ( 7 ) and ( 10 ) of tables 912 .
table 13 compares the @xmath113 $ ] values for spectra of types ( 1)(3 ) above .
clearly , there is no significant observational difference between the predictions for the different spectra . in what follows , for the open - bubble inflation model we concentrate on the type ( 1 ) spectrum above .
again , the ranges in tables 914 are those determined from the maximal 2-@xmath80 @xmath21 range . table 15 lists central dmr - normalized " values for @xmath130 $ ] , defined as the mean of the maximal @xmath1352-@xmath80 entries of tables 912 .
( the mean of the @xmath1352-@xmath80 fitting formulae of table 14 may be used to interpolate between the entries of table 15 . )
we again emphasize that it is incorrect to draw conclusions about model viability based solely on these central " values for the purpose of constraining model - parameter values by , e.g. , comparing numerical simulation results to observational data one must make use of computations at a few different values of the normalization selected to span the @xmath1352-@xmath80 ranges of tables 912 .
the dmr likelihoods do not meaningfully exclude any part of the ( @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath63 ) parameter space for the models considered here . in this section
we combine current observational constraints on global cosmological parameters with the dmr - normalized model predictions to place constraints on the range of allowed model - parameter values .
it is important to bear in mind that some measures of observational cosmology remain uncertain thus our analysis here must be viewed as tentative and subject to revision as the observational situation approaches equilibrium . to constrain our model - parameter values
we have employed the most robust of the current observational constraints .
tables 912 list some observational predictions for the models considered here , and the boldface entries are those that are inconsistent with current observational data at the 2-@xmath80 significance level . for each cosmographic or large - scale parameter ,
we have generally chosen to use constraints from a single set of observations or from a single analysis .
we generally use the most recent analyses since we assume that they incorporate a better understanding of the uncertainties , especially those due to systematics .
the specific constraints we use are summarized below , where we compare them to those derived from other analyses .
the model predictions depend on the age of the universe @xmath62 . to reconcile the models with the high measured values of the hubble parameter @xmath2 , we have chosen to focus on @xmath60 10.5 , 12 , and 13.5 gyr , which are near the lower end of the ages now under discussion .
for instance , jimenez et al .
( 1996 ) find that the oldest globular clusters have ages @xmath136 gyr ( also see salaris , deglinnocenti , & weiss 1996 ; renzini et al .
1996 ) , and that it is very unlikely that the oldest clusters are younger than 9.7 gyr .
the value of @xmath1 is another input parameter for our computations . as summarized by peebles ( 1993 , @xmath137 ) , on scales @xmath138 mpc a variety of different observational measurements indicate that @xmath1 is low .
for instance , virial analyses of x - ray cluster data indicates @xmath139 , with a 2-@xmath80 range : @xmath140 ( carlberg et al .
1996 we have added their 1-@xmath80 statistical and systematic uncertainties in quadrature and doubled to get the 2-@xmath80 uncertainty ) . in a cdm model in which structure forms at a relatively high redshift ( as is observed ) , these local estimates of @xmath1 do constrain the global value of @xmath1 ( since , in this case , it is inconceivable that the pressureless cdm is much more homogeneously distributed than is the observed baryonic mass ) .
we hence adopt a 2-@xmath80 upper limit of @xmath141 to constrain the cdm models we consider here .
( this large upper limit allows for the possibility that the models might be moderately biased . ) the boldface entries in column ( 1 ) of tables 912 indicates those @xmath1 values inconsistent with this constraint .
column ( 2 ) of tables 912 gives the value of the hubble parameter @xmath2 that corresponds to the chosen values of @xmath1 and @xmath62 .
current observational data favours a larger @xmath2 ( e.g. , kennicutt , freedman , & mould 1995 ; baum et al . 1995 ; van den bergh 1995 ; sandage et al .
1996 ; ruiz - lapuente 1996 ; riess , press , & kirshner 1996 ; but also see schaefer 1996 ; branch et al .
for the purpose of our analysis here we adopt the @xmath142 value @xmath143 ( 1-@xmath80 uncertainty , tanvir et al .
1995 ) ; doubling the uncertainty , the 2-@xmath80 range is @xmath144 .
the bold face entries in column ( 2 ) of tables 912 indicates those model - parameter values which predict an @xmath2 inconsistent with this range .
comparison of the standard nucleosynthesis theoretical predictions for the primordial light element abundances to what is determined by extrapolation of the observed abundances to primordial values leads to constraints on @xmath63 .
it has usually been argued that @xmath145he and @xmath146li allow for the most straightforward extrapolation from the locally observed abundances to the primordial values ( e.g. , dar 1995 ; fields & olive 1996 ; fields et al .
1996 , hereafter fkot ) .
the observed @xmath145he and @xmath146li abundances then suggest @xmath147 , and a conservative assessment of the uncertainties indicate a 2-@xmath80 range : @xmath148 ( fkot ; also see copi et al .
1995 ; sarkar 1996 ) .
observational constraints on the primordial deuterium ( d ) abundance should , in principle , allow for a tightening of the allowed @xmath63 range .
there are now a number of different estimates of the primordial d abundance , and since the field is still in its infancy it is , perhaps , not surprising that the different estimates are somewhat discrepant .
songaila et al .
( 1994 ) , carswell et al .
( 1994 ) , and rugers & hogan ( 1996a , b ) use observations of three high - redshift absorption clouds to argue for a high primordial d abundance and so a low @xmath63 .
tytler , fan , & burles ( 1996 ) and burles & tytler ( 1996 ) study two absorption clouds and argue for a low primordial d abundance and so a high @xmath63 .
carswell et al . ( 1996 ) and wampler et al . ( 1996 ) examine other absorption clouds , but are not able to strongly constrain @xmath63 . while the error bars on @xmath63
determined from these d abundance observations are somewhat asymmetric , to use these results to qualitatively pick the @xmath63 values we wish to examine we assume that the errors are gaussian ( and where needed add all uncertainties in quadrature to get the 2-@xmath80 uncertainties ) .
the large d abundance observations suggest @xmath149 with a 2-@xmath80 range : @xmath150 ( rugers & hogan 1996a ) .
when these large d abundances are combined with the observed @xmath145he and @xmath146li abundances , they indicate @xmath151 , with a 2-@xmath80 range : @xmath152 ( fkot ) .
the large d abundances are consistent with the standard interpretation of the @xmath145he and @xmath146li abundances , and with the standard model of particle physics ( with three massless neutrino species ) ; they do , however , seem to require a modification in galactic chemical evolution models to be consistent with local determinations of the d and @xmath153he abundances ( e.g. , fkot ; cardall & fuller 1996 ) .
the low d abundance observations favour @xmath154 with a 2-@xmath80 range : @xmath155 ( burles & tytler 1996 ) .
the low d abundance observations seem to be more easily accommodated in modifications of the standard model of particle physics , i.e. , they are difficult to reconcile with exactly three massless neutrino species ; alternatively they might indicate a gross , as yet unaccounted for , uncertainty in the observed @xmath145he abundance ( burles & tytler 1996 ; cardall & fuller 1996 ) .
the low d abundance is approximately consistent with locally - observed d abundances , but probably requires some modification in the usual galactic chemical evolution model for @xmath146li ( burles & tytler 1996 ; cardall & fuller 1996 ) . to accommodate the range of @xmath63 now under discussion
, we compute model predictions for @xmath124 ( table 9 ) , 0.007 ( table 12 ) , 0.0125 ( table 10 ) , and 0.0205 ( table 11 ) .
we shall find that this uncertainty in @xmath63 precludes determination of robust constraints on model - parameter values .
fortunately , recent improvements in observational capabilities should eventually lead to a tightening of the constraints on @xmath63 , and so allow for tighter constraints on the other cosmological parameters .
column ( 3 ) of tables 912 give the cosmological baryonic - mass fraction for the models we consider here .
the cluster baryonic - mass fraction is the sum of the cluster galactic - mass and gas - mass fractions . assuming that the white et al .
( 1993 ) 1-@xmath80 uncertainties on the cluster total , galactic , and gas masses are gaussian and adding them in quadrature , we find for the 2-@xmath80 range of the cluster baryonic - mass fraction : @xmath156 elbaz , arnaud , & bhringer ( 1995 ) , white & fabian ( 1995 ) , david , jones , & forman ( 1995 ) , markevitch et al .
( 1996 ) , and buote & canizares ( 1996 ) find similar ( or larger ) gas - mass fractions .
note that elbaz et al .
( 1995 ) and white & fabian ( 1995 ) find that the gas - mass error bars are somewhat asymmetric ; this non - gaussianity is ignored here . assuming that the cluster baryonic - mass fraction is an unbiased estimate of the cosmological baryonic - mass fraction , we may use eq .
( 15 ) to constrain the cosmological parameters .
the boldface entries in column ( 3 ) of tables 9 - 12 indicates those model - parameter values which predict a cosmological baryonic - mass fraction inconsistent with the range of eq . ( 15 ) .
viana & liddle ( 1996 , hereafter vl ) have reanalyzed the combined galaxy @xmath58 data of peacock & dodds ( 1994 ) , ignoring some of the smaller scale data where nonlinear effects might be somewhat larger than previously suspected .
using an analytic approximation to the @xmath58 , they estimate that the scaling parameter ( eq . [ 13 ] ) in the exponent of eq .
( 13 ) , so the numerical values of their constraint on @xmath157 should be reduced slightly .
we ignore this small effect here . ]
@xmath158 , with a 2-@xmath80 range , @xmath159 this estimate is consistent with earlier ones than eq .
( 16 ) this is one reason why llrv favour a higher @xmath1 for the open - bubble inflation model than do grsb . ] .
it might be of interest to determine whether the wiggles in @xmath58 due to the pressure in the photon - baryon fluid , see figs .
23 , can significantly affect the determination of @xmath157 , especially in large @xmath119 models .
( these wiggles are not well described by the analytic approximation to @xmath58 . ) the boldface entries in column ( 4 ) of tables 912 indicates those model - parameter values which predict a scaling parameter value inconsistent with the range of eq .
( 16 ) . to determine the value of the linear bias parameter @xmath160 , @xmath161 where @xmath162 is the rms fractional perturbation in galaxy number
, we adopt the apm value ( maddox , efstathiou , & sutherland 1996 ) of @xmath163 = 0.96 $ ] , with 2-@xmath80 range : @xmath164 where we have added the uncertainty due to the assumed cosmological model and due to the assumed evolution in quadrature with the statistical 1-@xmath80 uncertainty ( maddox et al .
1996 , eq . [ 43 ] ) , and doubled to get the 2-@xmath80 uncertainty . the range of eq .
( 18 ) is consistent with that determined from eqs .
( 7.33 ) and ( 7.73 ) of peebles ( 1993 ) . the local abundance of rich clusters , as a function of their x - ray temperature , provides a tight constraint on @xmath113 $ ] .
eke , cole , & frenk ( 1996 , hereafter ecf ) ( and s. cole , private communication 1996 ) find for the open model at 2-@xmath80 : @xmath165 where we have assumed that the ecf uncertainties are gaussian , and that in general it depends weakly on the value of @xmath157 ( and so on the value of @xmath2 and @xmath10 ) see fig .
13 of ecf . in our preliminary analysis here
we ignore this mild dependence on @xmath2 and @xmath10 .
also note that the constraint of eq .
( 19 ) is approximately that required for consistency with the observed cluster correlation function . ]
. the constraints of eq .
( 19 ) are consistent with , but more restrictive than , those derived by vl = 0.60 $ ] for fiducial cdm , which is at the @xmath1662-@xmath80 limit of eq .
( as discussed in ecf , this is because vl normalize to the cluster temperature function at 7 kev , where there is a rise in the temperature function . )
this is one reason why llrv favour a higher value of @xmath1 for the open - bubble inflation model than did grsb . ] .
this is because ecf use observational data over a larger range in x - ray temperature to constrain @xmath167 , and also use n - body computations at @xmath168 0.3 and 1 to calibrate the press - schechter model ( which is used in their determination of the constraints ) .
furthermore , ecf also make use of hydrodynamical simulations of a handful of individual clusters in the fiducial cdm model ( @xmath69 ) to calibrate the relation between the gas temperature and the cluster mass , and then use this calibrated relation for the computations at all values of @xmath1 .
the initial conditions for all the simulations were set using the analytical approximation to @xmath58 , so again it might be of interest to see whether the wiggles in the numerically integrated @xmath58 could significantly affect the determination of the constraints of eq .
kitayama & suto ( 1996 ) use x - ray cluster data , and a method that allows for the fact that clusters need not have formed at the redshift at which they are observed , to directly constrain the value of @xmath1 for cdm cosmogonies normalized by the dmr two - year data .
their conclusions are in resonable accord with what would be found by using eq .
( 19 ) ( derived assuming that observed clusters are at their redshifts of formation ) .
however , kitayama & suto ( 1996 ) note that evolution from the redshift of formation to the redshift of observation can affect the conclusions , so a more careful comparison of these two results is warranted . the boldface entries in columns ( 6 ) and ( 9 ) of tables 912 indicate those model - parameter values whose predictions are inconsistent with the constraints of eq .
( 19 ) ( 1-@xmath80 ) uncertainty of eq .
( 19 ) , approximate analyses based on using the analytic bbks approximation to the transfer function should make use of the more accurate parameterization of eq .
( 13 ) ( rather than that with @xmath169 in the exponent ) , as this gives @xmath26 $ ] to better than @xmath87 in the observationally viable part of parameter space ( provided use is made of the numerically determined values of @xmath42 ) . ] . from large - scale peculiar velocity observational data zaroubi et al .
( 1996 ) estimate @xmath26 = ( 0.85 \pm 0.2)\omega_0{}^{-0.6}$ ] ( 2-@xmath80 )
. it might be significant that the large - scale peculiar velocity observational data constraint is somewhat discordant with ( higher than ) the cluster temperature function constraint .
since @xmath170 is less sensitive to smaller length scales ( compared to @xmath26 $ ] ) , observational constraints on @xmath170 are more reliably contrasted with the linear theory predictions . however , since @xmath170 is sensitive to larger length scales , the observational constraints on @xmath170 are significantly less restrictive than the @xmath171 ( 1-@xmath80 ) constraints of eq .
( 19 ) , and so we do not record the predicted values of @xmath170 here .
observational constraints on the mass power spectrum determined from large - scale peculiar velocity observations provide another constraint on the mass fluctuations .
kolatt & dekel ( 1995 ) find at the 1-@xmath80 level @xmath172 where the 1-@xmath80 uncertainty also accounts for sample variance ( t. kolatt , private communication 1996 ) . since the uncertainties associated with the constraint of eq .
( 19 ) are more restrictive than those associated with the constraint of eq .
( 20 ) , we do not tabulate predictions for this quantity here .
however , comparison may be made to the predicted linear theory mass power spectra of figs .
23 , bearing in mind the @xmath173 ( 2-@xmath80 ) uncertainty of eq .
( 20 ) ( the uncertainty is approximately gaussian , t. kolatt , private communication 1996),-@xmath80 , significance level , eq . ( 20 ) provides a strong upper limit on @xmath174 , especially at larger @xmath1 because of the @xmath1 dependence . ] and the uncertainty in the dmr normalization ( not shown in figs .
23 ) . columns ( 7 ) and ( 10 ) of tables 912 give the dmr - normalized model predictions for @xmath134 ( eq . [ 14 ] ) .
cole , fisher , & weinberg ( 1995 ) measure the anisotropy of the redshift space power spectrum of the @xmath133 1.2 jy survey and conclude @xmath175 with a 2-@xmath80 c.l .
range : @xmath176 where we have doubled the error bars of eq .
( 5.1 ) of cole et al .
( 1995 ) to get the 2-@xmath80 range .
cole et al .
( 1995 , table 1 ) compare the estimate of eq .
( 21 ) to other estimates of @xmath134 , and at 2-@xmath80 all estimates of @xmath134 are consistent . it should be noted that the model predictions of @xmath134 ( eq .
[ 14 ] ) in tables 912 assume that for @xmath133 galaxies @xmath163 = 1/1.3 $ ] holds exactly , i.e. , they ignore the uncertainty in the rms fractional perturbation in @xmath133 galaxy number , which is presumably of the order of that in eq . ( 18 ) . as the constraints from the deduced @xmath134 values , eq .
( 21 ) , are not yet as restrictive as those from other large - scale structure measures , we do not pursue this issue in our analysis here .
the boldface entries in columns ( 7 ) and ( 10 ) of tables 912 indicate those model - parameter values whose predictions are inconsistent with the constraints of eq .
( 21 ) . the boldface entries in tables
912 summarize the current constraints imposed by the observational data discussed in the previous section on the model - parameter values for the open - bubble inflation model ( spectra of type [ 1 ] above ) , and for the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( type [ 4 ] above ) .
the current observational constraints on the models are not dissimilar , but this is mostly a reflection of the uncertainty on the constraints themselves since the model predictions are fairly different . in the following discussion of the preferred part of model - parameter space
we focus on the open - bubble inflation model ( rp94 ) .
note from table 13 that the large - scale structure predictions of the open - bubble inflation model do not depend on perturbations generated in the first epoch of inflation ( bgt ; yst ) , and also do not depend significantly on the contribution from the non - square - integrable basis function ( yst ) .
table 9 corresponds to the part of parameter space with maximized " small - scale power in matter fluctuations .
this is accomplished by picking a low @xmath123 gyr ( and so large @xmath2 ) , and by picking a low @xmath124 ( this is the lower 2-@xmath80 limit from standard nucleosynthesis and the observed @xmath145he , @xmath146li , and high d abundances , fkot ) .
the tightest constraints on the model - parameter values come from the matter power spectrum observational data constraints on the shape parameter @xmath157 ( table 9 , col .
[ 4 ] ) , and from the cluster x - ray temperature function observational data constraints on @xmath26 $ ] ( col .
note that for @xmath177 the predicted upper 2-@xmath80 value of @xmath113 = 0.69 $ ] , while ecf conclude that at 2-@xmath80 the observational data requires that this be at least 0.74 , so an @xmath177 case fails this test .
the constraints on @xmath134 ( col .
[ 7 ] ) are not as restrictive as those on @xmath113 $ ] . for these values of @xmath62 and @xmath178 the cosmological baryonic - mass fraction at @xmath177
is predicted to be 0.033 ( col . [ 3 ] ) , while at 2-@xmath80 white et al .
( 1993 ) require that this be at least 0.039 ( at @xmath179 ) , so again this @xmath177 model just fails this test .
given the observational uncertainties , it might be possible to make minor adjustments to model - parameter values so that an @xmath180 model with @xmath181 gyr and @xmath182 is just consistent with the observational data .
however , it is clear that current observational data do not favour an open model with @xmath183 the observed cluster @xmath184 $ ] favours a larger @xmath1 while the observed cluster baryonic - mass fraction favours a smaller @xmath1 , and so are in conflict .
table 10 gives the predictions for the @xmath121 gyr , @xmath185 models .
this value of @xmath63 is consistent with the 2-@xmath80 range determined from standard nucleosynthesis and the observed @xmath145he and @xmath146li abundances : @xmath148 ( fkot , also see copi et al .
1995 ; sarkar 1996 ) .
it is , however , somewhat difficult to reconcile @xmath8 with the 2-@xmath80 range derived from the observed @xmath145he , @xmath146li , and current high d abundances @xmath152 ( fkot ) , or with that from the current observed low d abundances @xmath186 ( burles & tytler 1996 ) . in any case , the observed d abundances are still under discussion , and must be viewed as preliminary . in this case , open - bubble inflation models with @xmath187 are consistent with the observational constraints .
the current central observational data values for @xmath157 and @xmath134 favour @xmath74 , while that for the cluster baryonic - mass fraction prefers @xmath188 , and that for @xmath130 $ ] favours @xmath189 , so in this case the agreement between predictions and observational data is fairly impressive ( although the tanvir et al .
1995 central @xmath2 value favours @xmath190 ) .
note that in this case models with @xmath191 are quite inconsistent with the data .
table 11 gives the predictions for @xmath192 gyr , @xmath193 models .
this baryonic - mass density value is consistent with that determined from the current observed low d abundances , but is difficult to reconcile with the current standard nucleosynthesis interpretation of the observed @xmath145he and @xmath146li abundances ( cardall & fuller 1996 ) .
the larger value of @xmath63 ( and smaller value of @xmath2 ) has now lowered small - scale power in mass fluctuations somewhat significantly , opening up the allowed @xmath1 range to larger values .
models with @xmath194 are consistent with the observational data , although the higher @xmath1 part of the range is starting to conflict with what is determined from the small - scale dynamical estimates , and the models do require a somewhat low @xmath2 ( but not yet inconsistently so at the 2-@xmath80 significance level while the tanvir et al .
1995 central @xmath2 value requires @xmath100 , at 2-@xmath80 the @xmath2 constraint only requires @xmath195 ) .
the central observational values for @xmath157 , the cluster baryonic - mass fraction , @xmath26 $ ] , and @xmath134 favour @xmath97 , so the agreement with observational data is fairly impressive , and could even be improved by reducing @xmath62 a little to raise @xmath2 .
table 12 gives the predictions for another part of model - parameter space .
here we show @xmath122 models ( at @xmath121 gyr ) , consistent with the central value of @xmath63 determined from standard nucleosynthesis using the observed @xmath145he , @xmath146li , and high d abundances ( fkot ) .
the larger value of @xmath63 ( compared to table 9 ) eases the cluster baryonic - mass fraction constraint , which now requires only @xmath196 .
the increase in @xmath63 also decreases the mass fluctuation amplitude , making it more difficult to argue for @xmath177 ; however , models with @xmath197 seem to be consistent with the observational constraints when @xmath4 and @xmath198 gyr .
it is interesting that in this case the central observational data values we consider for @xmath157 , for @xmath26 $ ] , and for @xmath134 prefer @xmath9 ; however , that for the cluster baryonic - mass fraction ( as well as that for @xmath2 ) favours @xmath190 ( although at 2-@xmath80 the cluster baryonic - mass fraction constraint only requires @xmath196 ) . hence , while @xmath199 open - bubble inflation models with @xmath200 and @xmath198 gyr are quite consistent with the observational constraints , in this case the agreement between predictions and observations is not spectacular .
note that in this case models with @xmath201 are quite inconsistent with the observational data . in summary ,
open - bubble inflation models based on the cdm picture ( rp94 ; bgt ; yst ) are reasonably consistent with current observational data provided @xmath202 .
the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( w83 ) is also reasonably compatible with current observational constraints for a similar range of @xmath1 .
the uncertainty in current estimates of @xmath63 is one of the major reasons why such a large range in @xmath1 is consistent with current observational constraints
. our previous analysis of the dmr two - year data led us to conclude that only those open - bubble inflation models near the lower end of the above range ( @xmath203 ) were consistent with the majority of observations ( grsb ) .
the increase in the allowed range to higher @xmath1 values @xmath204 can be ascribed to a number of small effects .
specifically , these are : ( 1 ) the slight downward shift in the central value of the dmr four - year normalization relative to the two - year one ( g96 ) ; ( 2 ) use of the full 2-@xmath80 range of normalizations allowed by the dmr data analysis ( instead of the 1-@xmath80 range allowed by the galactic - frame quadrupole - excluded dmr two - year data set used previously ) ; ( 3 ) use of the 2-@xmath80 range of the small - scale dynamical estimates of @xmath1 instead of the 1-@xmath80 range used in our earlier analysis ; ( 4 ) we consider a range of @xmath63 values here ( in grsb we focussed on @xmath8 ) ; and ( 5 ) we consider a range of @xmath62 values here ( in grsb we concentrated on @xmath121 gyr ) .
we emphasize , however , that the part of parameter space with @xmath205 is only favoured if @xmath63 is large ( @xmath206 ) , @xmath2 is low @xmath207 ) , and the small - scale dynamical estimates of @xmath1 turn out to be biased somewhat low .
the observational results we have used to constrain model - parameter values in the previous sections are the most robust currently available .
in addition , there are several other observational results which we do not consider to be as robust , and any conclusions drawn from these should be treated with due caution . in this section
we summarize several of the more tentative constraints from more recent observations . in our analysis of the dmr two - year data normalized models , we compared model predictions for the rms value of the smoothed peculiar velocity field to results from the analysis of observational data ( bertschinger et al .
we do not do so again here since , given the uncertainties , the conclusions drawn in grsb are not significantly modified .
in particular , comparison of the appropriate quantities implies that we can treat the old 1-@xmath80 upper limits essentially as 2-@xmath80 upper limits for the four - year analysis . in grsb
we used @xmath134 determined by nusser & davis ( 1994 ) , @xmath208 ( 2-@xmath80 ) , to constrain the allowed range of models to @xmath209 . here
we use the cole et al .
( 1995 ) estimate , @xmath210 ( 2-@xmath80 ) , which , for the models of table 10 , requires @xmath211 .
this value is just slightly below the lower limit ( @xmath212 ) derived from the bertschinger et al .
( 1990 ) results in grsb .
we hence conclude that the large - scale flow results of bertschinger et al .
( 1990 ) indicates a lower 2-@xmath80 limit on @xmath1 that is about @xmath213 higher than that suggested by the redshift - space distortion analysis of cole et al .
( 1995).$ ] . ]
we however strongly emphasize that the central value of the large - scale flow results of bertschinger et al .
( 1990 ) does favour a significantly larger value of @xmath1 than the rest of the data we have considered here . furthermore , as discussed in detail in grsb , there is some uncertainty in how to properly interpret large - scale velocity data in the open models , particularly given the large sample variance associated with the measurement of a single bulk velocity ( bond 1996 , also see llrv ) .
a more careful analysis , as well as more observational data , is undoubtedly needed before it will be possible to robustly conclude that the large - scale velocity data does indeed force one to consider significantly larger values of @xmath1 than is favoured by the rest of the observational constraints ( and hence rules out the models considered here ) .
it might be significant that on comparing the mass power spectrum deduced from a refined set of peculiar velocity observations to the galaxy power spectrum determined from the apm survey , kolatt & dekel ( 1995 ) estimate that for the optically - selected apm galaxies @xmath214 with a 2-@xmath80 range , @xmath215 ( note that it has been argued that systematic uncertainties preclude a believable determination of @xmath134 from a comparison of the observed large - scale peculiar velocity field to the @xmath133 1.2 jy galaxy distribution , davis , nusser , & willick 1996 . )
this range is consistent with other estimates now under discussion .
the stromlo - apm comparison of loveday et al .
( 1996 ) indicates @xmath216 , with a 2-@xmath80 upper limit of 0.75 , while baugh ( 1996 ) concludes that @xmath217 ( 2-@xmath80 ) , and ratcliffe et al .
( 1996 ) argue for @xmath218 . using the apm range for @xmath163 $ ] ,
( 18 ) , the kolatt & dekel ( 1995 ) estimate of @xmath219 , eq .
( 22 ) , may be converted to an estimate of @xmath167 , and at 2-@xmath80 , @xmath220 it is interesting that at @xmath69 the lower part of this range is consistent with that determined from the cluster x - ray temperature function data , eq . ( 19 ) , although at lower @xmath1 eq .
( 23 ) indicates a larger value then does eq .
( 19 ) because of the steeper rise to low @xmath1 .
zaroubi et al .
( 1996 ) have constrained model - parameter values by comparing large - scale flow observations to that predicted in the dmr two - year data normalized open - bubble inflation model .
they conclude that the open - bubble inflation model provides a good description of the large - scale flow observations if , at 2-@xmath80 , @xmath221 from table 12 we see that an open - bubble inflation model with @xmath222 and @xmath223 provides a good fit to all the observational data considered in @xmath224 . for @xmath223 zaroubi et al .
( 1996 ) conclude that at 2-@xmath80 @xmath225 ( eq . [ 24 ] ) , just above our value of @xmath222 . since the zaroubi et al .
( 1996 ) analysis does not account for the uncertainty in the dmr normalization ( t. kolatt , private communication 1996 ) , it is still unclear if the constraints from the large - scale flow observations are in conflict with those determined from the other data considered here ( and so rule out the open - bubble inflation model )
. it might also be significant that on somewhat smaller length scales there is support for a smaller value of @xmath1 from large - scale velocity field data ( shaya , peebles , & tully 1995 ) .
the cluster peculiar velocity function provides an alternate mechanism for probing the peculiar velocity field ( e.g. , croft & efstathiou 1994 ; moscardini et al .
1995 ; bahcall & oh 1996 ) .
bahcall & oh ( 1996 ) conclude that current observational data is well - described by an @xmath177 flat-@xmath18 model with @xmath226 and @xmath227 = 0.67 $ ] .
this normalization is somewhat smaller than that indicated by the dmr data ( e.g. , ratra & sugiyama 1995 ) .
while bahcall & oh ( 1996 ) did not compare the cluster peculiar velocity function data to the predictions of the open - bubble inflation model , approximate estimates indicate that this data is consistent with the open - bubble inflation model predictions for the range of @xmath1 favoured by the other data we consider in @xmath228 see the @xmath26 $ ] values for the allowed models in tables 912 .
bahcall & oh ( 1996 ) also note that it is difficult , if not impossible , to reconcile the cluster peculiar velocity observations with what is predicted in high density models like fiducial cdm and mdm . at fixed @xmath113 $ ] ,
low - density cosmogonies form structure earlier than high density ones .
thus observations of structure at high redshift may be used to constrain the matter density . as benchmarks
, we note that scaling from the results of the numerical simulations of cen & ostriker ( 1993 ) , in a open model with @xmath229 = 0.8 $ ] galaxy formation peaks at a redshift @xmath230 when @xmath231 and at @xmath232 when @xmath72 .
thus the open - bubble inflation model is not in conflict with observational indications that the giant elliptical luminosity function at @xmath233 is similar to that at the present ( e.g. , lilly et al .
1995 ; glazebrook et al . 1995 ; i m et al .
1996 ) , nor is it in conflict with observational evidence for massive galactic disks at @xmath233 ( vogt et al .
these models can also accommodate observational evidence of massive star - forming galaxies at @xmath234 ( cowie , hu , & songaila 1995 ) , as well as the significant peak at @xmath235 in the number of galaxies as a function of ( photometric ) redshift found in the hubble deep field ( gwyn & hartwick 1996 ) , and it is not inconceivable that objects like the @xmath236 protogalaxy " candidate ( yee et al .
1996 ; ellingson et al .
1996 ) can be produced in these models .
it is , however , at present unclear whether the open - bubble inflation model can accommodate a substantial population of massive star - forming galaxies at @xmath237 ( steidel et al .
1996 ; giavalisco , steidel , & macchetto 1996 ) , and if there are many more examples of massive damped lyman@xmath238 systems like the one at @xmath239 ( e.g. , lu et al .
1996 ; wampler et al . 1996 ; fontana et al .
1996 ) , then , depending on the masses , these might be a serious problem for the open - bubble inflation model .
on the other hand , the recent discovery of galaxy groups at @xmath240 ( e.g. , francis et al . 1996 ; pascarelle et al . 1996 ) probably do not pose a serious threat for the open - bubble inflation model , while massive clusters at @xmath241 ( e.g. , luppino & gioia 1995 ; pell et al .
1996 ) can easily be accommodated in the model .
it should be noted that in adiabatic @xmath69 models normalized to fit the present small - scale observations , e.g. , fiducial cdm ( with a normalization inconsistent with that from the dmr ) , or mdm , or tilted cdm ( without a cosmological constant ) , it is quite difficult , if not impossible , to accommodate the above observational indications of early structure formation ( e.g. , ma & bertschinger 1994 ; ostriker & cen 1996 ) . with the recent improvements in observational capabilities , neoclassical cosmological tests hold great promise for constraining the world model .
it might be significant that current constraints from these tests are consistent with that region of the open - bubble inflation model parameter space that is favoured by the large - scale structure constraints .
these tests include the @xmath142 elliptical galaxy number counts test ( driver et al . 1996 ) , an early application of the apparent magnitude - redshift test using type ia supernovae ( perlmutter et al . 1996 ) , as well as analyses of the rate of gravitational lensing of quasars by foreground galaxies ( e.g. , torres & waga 1996 ; kochanek 1996 ) .
it should be noted that these tests are also consistent with @xmath69 models , and plausibly with a time - variable cosmological constant " dominated spatially - flat model ( e.g. , ratra & quillen 1992 ; torres & waga 1996 ) , but they do put pressure on the flat-@xmath18 cdm model .
smaller - scale cmb spatial anisotropy measurements will eventually significantly constrain the allowed range of model - parameter values . fig .
24 compares the 1-@xmath80 range of cmb spatial anisotropy predictions for a few representative open - bubble inflation ( as well as flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open ) models to available cmb spatial anisotropy observational data . from a preliminary comparison of the predictions of dmr two - year data
normalized open - bubble inflation models to available cmb anisotropy observational data , ratra et al .
( 1995 ) concluded that the range of parameter space for the open - bubble inflation model that was favoured by the other observational data was also consistent with the small - scale cmb anisotropy data .
this result was quantified by grs , who also considered open - bubble inflation models normalized to the @xmath1351-@xmath80 values of the dmr two - year data ( and hence considered open - bubble inflation models normalized at close to the dmr four - year data value , see figs . 5 and 6 of grs ) .
grs discovered that ( given the uncertainties associated with the smaller - scale measurements ) the 1-@xmath80 uncertainty in the value of the dmr normalization precludes determination of robust constraints on model - parameter values , although the range of model - parameter space for the open - bubble inflation model favoured by the analysis here was found to be consistent with the smaller - scale cmb anisotropy observations , and @xmath93 open - bubble inflation models were not favoured by the smaller - scale cmb anisotropy observational data ( grs , figs
. 5 and 6 ) . is favoured , but even at 1-@xmath80 @xmath242 is allowed this broad range is consistent with the conclusion of grs that it is not yet possible to meaningfully constrain cosmological - parameter values from the cmb anisotropy data alone .
note also that hancock et al .
( 1996b ) do not consider the effects of the systematic shifts between the various dmr data sets , and also exclude a number of data points , e.g. , the four msam points and the max3 mup point ( which is consistent with the recent max5 mup result , lim et al . 1996 ) , which do not disfavour a lower value of @xmath1 for the open - bubble inflation model ( ratra et al .
1995 ; grs ) . ] a detailed analysis of the ucsb south pole 1994 cmb anisotropy data ( gundersen et al .
1995 ) by ganga et al .
( 1996a ) reaches a similar conclusion : at 1-@xmath80 ( assuming a gaussian marginal probability distribution ) the data favours open - bubble inflation models with @xmath243 , while at 2-@xmath80 the ucsb south pole 1994 data is consistent with the predictions of the open - bubble , flat-@xmath18 , and fiducial cdm inflation models .
we have compared the dmr 53 and 90 ghz sky maps to a variety of open model cmb anisotropy angular spectra in order to infer the normalization of these open cosmogonical models .
our analysis explicitly quantifies the small shifts in the inferred normalization amplitudes due to : ( 1 ) the small differences between the galactic- and ecliptic - coordinate sky maps ; ( 2 ) the inclusion or exclusion of the @xmath85 moment in the analysis ; and , ( 3 ) the faint high - latitude galactic emission treatment .
we have defined a maximal 2-@xmath80 uncertainty range based on the extremal solutions of the normalization fits , and a maximal 1-@xmath80 uncertainty range may be defined in a similar manner . for this
maximal 1-@xmath80 @xmath21 range the fractional 1-@xmath80 uncertainty , at fixed @xmath10 and @xmath2 ( but depending on the assumed cmb anisotropy angular spectrum and model - parameter values ) , ranges between @xmath244 and @xmath245 ( statistical and systematic ) uncertainty of bw ( footnote 4 , also see bunn , liddle , & white 1996 ) , @xmath246 , is smaller than the dmr four - year data 1-@xmath80 uncertainty estimated in , e.g. , g96 , wright et al .
( 1996 ) , and here .
this is because we explicitly estimate the effect of all known systematic uncertainties for each assumed cmb anisotropy angular spectrum , and account for them , in the most conservative manner possible , as small shifts .
( in particular : we do not just account for the small systematic difference between the galactic- and ecliptic - frame maps ; we do not assume that any of the small systematic differences lead to model - independent systematic shifts in the inferred @xmath21 values ; and we do not add the systematic shifts in quadrature with the statistical uncertainty . )
since our accounting of the uncertainties is the most conservative possible , our conclusions about model - viability are the most robust possible . ] .
( compare this to the @xmath247 , 1-@xmath80 , uncertainty of eq .
[ 19 ] . ) since part of this uncertainty is due to the small systematic shifts , the maximal 2-@xmath80 fractional uncertainty is smaller than twice the maximal 1-@xmath80 fractional uncertainty .
for the largest possible 2-@xmath80 @xmath21 range defined above , the fractional uncertainty varies between @xmath248 and @xmath249 .
note that this accounts for intrinsic noise , cosmic variance , and effects ( 1)(3 ) above .
other systematic effects , e.g. , the calibration uncertainty ( kogut et al .
1996b ) , or the beamwidth uncertainty ( wright et al . 1994 ) , are much smaller than the effects we have accounted for here .
it has also been shown that there is negligible non - cmb contribution to the dmr data sets from known extragalactic astrophysical foregrounds ( banday et al .
1996b ) .
by analyzing the dmr maps using cmb anisotropy spectra at fixed @xmath1 but different @xmath2 and @xmath10 , we have also explicitly quantified the small shifts in the inferred normalization amplitude due to shifts in @xmath2 and @xmath10 .
although these shifts do depend on the value of @xmath1 and the assumed model power spectrum , given the other uncertainties , it is reasonable to ignore these small shifts when normalizing the models considered in this work .
we have analyzed the open - bubble inflation model , accounting only for the fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp94 ) , including the effects of the fluctuations generated in the first epoch of spatially - flat inflation ( bgt ; yst ) , and finally accounting for the contribution from a non - square - integrable basis function ( yst ) . for observationally viable open - bubble models ,
the observable predictions do not depend significantly on the latter two sources of anisotropy .
the observable predictions of the open - bubble inflation scenario seem to be robust it seems that only those fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble need to be accounted for .
as discussed in the introduction , a variety of more specific realizations of the open - bubble inflation scenario have recently come under scrutiny .
these are based on specific assumptions about the vacuum state prior to open - bubble nucleation . in these specific realizations of the open - bubble inflation scenario
there are a number of additional mechanisms for stress - energy perturbation generation ( in addition to those in the models considered here ) , including those that come from fluctuations in the bubble wall , as well as effects associated with the nucleation of a nonzero size bubble .
while current analyses suggest that such effects also do not add a significant amount to the fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble , it is important to continue to pursue such investigations both to more carefully examine the robustness of the open - bubble inflation scenario predictions , as well as to try to find a reasonable particle physics based realization of the open - bubble inflation scenario . as has been previously noted for other cmb anisotropy angular spectra ( g96 ) , the various different dmr data sets lead to slightly different @xmath21 normalization amplitudes , but well within the statistical uncertainty .
this total range is slightly reduced if one considers results from analyses either ignoring or including the quadrupole moment .
the dmr data alone can not be used to constrain @xmath1 over range @xmath14 in a statistically meaningful fashion for the open models considered here .
it is , however , reasonable to conclude that when the quadrupole moment is excluded from the analysis , the @xmath9 model cmb anisotropy spectral shape is most consistent with the dmr data , while the quadrupole - included analysis favours @xmath12 ( for the open - bubble inflation model in the range @xmath250 ) .
current cosmographic observations , in conjunction with current large - scale structure observations compared to the predictions of the dmr - normalized open - bubble inflation model derived here , favour @xmath202 .
the large allowed range is partially a consequence of the current uncertainty in @xmath10 .
this range is consistent with the value weakly favoured ( @xmath9 ) by a quadrupole - excluded analysis of the dmr data alone .
it might also be significant that mild bias is indicated both by the need to reconcile these larger values of @xmath1 with what is determined from small - scale dynamical estimates , as well as to reconcile the smaller dmr - normalized @xmath251 $ ] values ( for this favoured range of @xmath1 ) with the larger observed galaxy number fluctuations ( e.g. , eq . [ 18 ] ) . in common with the low - density flat-@xmath18 cdm model
, we have established that in the low - density open - bubble cdm model one may adjust the value of @xmath1 to accommodate a large fraction of present observational constraints . for a broad class of these models , with adiabatic gaussian initial energy - density perturbations , this focuses attention on values of @xmath1 that are larger than the range of values for @xmath10 inferred from the observed light - element abundances in conjunction with standard nucleosynthesis theory . whether this additional cdm is nonbaryonic , or is simply baryonic material that does not take part in standard nucleosynthesis , remains a major outstanding puzzle for these models .
we acknowledge the efforts of those contributing to the @xmath0-dmr .
@xmath0 is supported by the office of space sciences of nasa headquarters .
we also acknowledge the advice and assistance of c. baugh , s. cole , j. garriga , t. kolatt , c. park , l. piccirillo , g. rocha , g. tucker , d. weinberg , and k. yamamoto .
rs is supported in part by a pparc grant and kbn grant 2p30401607 .
1.fractional differences , @xmath253 , between the cmb spatial anisotropy multipole coefficients @xmath56 computed using the two boltzmann transfer codes ( and normalized to agree at @xmath254 ) .
heavy type is for the open - bubble inflation model spectrum accounting only for perturbations that are generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( type [ 1 ] spectra above ) , and light type is for the open - bubble inflation model spectrum now also accounting for perturbations generated in the first epoch of inflation ( type [ 2 ] spectra ) .
solid lines are for @xmath255 and dashed lines are for @xmath256 .
these are for @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
note that @xmath257 .
2.(a ) cmb anisotropy multipole coefficients for the open - bubble inflation model , accounting only for fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp94 , solid lines ) , and also accounting for fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation ( bgt ; yst , dotted lines these overlap the solid lines , except at the lowest @xmath1 and smallest @xmath66 ) , for @xmath258 0.1 , 0.2 , 0.25 , 0.3 , 0.35 , 0.4 , 0.45 , 0.5 , 0.6 , 0.8 , and 1.0 , in ascending order .
these are for @xmath121 gyr and @xmath8 .
the coefficients are normalized relative to the @xmath259 amplitude , and different values of @xmath1 are offset from each other to aid visualization . in ( b )
are the set of cmb anisotropy spectra for the open - bubble inflation model , accounting only for fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp94 ) , with @xmath255 and @xmath256 for the three different pairs of values ( @xmath62 , @xmath63 ) : ( @xmath260 gyr , @xmath261 ) , ( @xmath262 gyr , @xmath263 ) , and ( @xmath264 gyr , @xmath265 ) .
spectra in the two sets are normalized to have the same @xmath259 , and @xmath63 increases in ascending order on the right axis .
3.cmb spatial anisotropy
multipole coefficients for the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( w83 ) .
conventions and parameter values are as in the caption of fig .
2 ( although only one set of spectra are shown in fig . 3a ) . fig .
4.cmb spatial anisotropy multipole coefficients for the open - bubble inflation spectrum , also accounting for both fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation and that corresponding to a non - square - integrable basis function ( yst , solid lines ) , and ignoring both these fluctuations ( rp94 , dotted lines ) .
they are , in ascending order , for @xmath258 0.1 to 0.9 in steps of 0.1 , with @xmath64 and @xmath65 , normalized relative to the @xmath259 amplitude , and different values of @xmath1 are offset from each other to aid visualization .
5.cmb spatial anisotropy multipole coefficients , as a function of @xmath66 , for the various spectra considered in this paper , at @xmath255 and @xmath266 ( vertically offset ) .
light solid and heavy solid lines show the open - bubble inflation cases accounting for ( type [ 2 ] spectra above ) and ignoring ( type [ 1 ] spectra , at @xmath256 these completely overlap the type [ 2 ] spectra ) fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation . dashed lines show the open - bubble inflation models , now also accounting for the contribution from the non - square - integrable basis function ( type [ 3 ] spectra ) .
dotted lines show the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model spectra ( type [ 4 ] spectra ) .
all spectra are for @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
6.likelihood functions @xmath79 ( arbitrarily normalized to unity at the highest peak at @xmath74 ) derived from a simultaneous analysis of the dmr 53 and 90 ghz ecliptic - frame data , ignoring the correction for faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission , and excluding the quadrupole moment from the analysis .
these are for the @xmath64 , @xmath65 models .
panel ( a ) is for the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( w83 ) , ( b ) is for the open - bubble inflation model accounting only for perturbations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp94 ) , and ( c ) is for the open - bubble inflation model now also accounting for both the fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation and those corresponding to a non - square - integrable basis function ( yst ) .
7.likelihood functions @xmath79 ( arbitrarily normalized to unity at the highest peak near either @xmath93 or @xmath267 ) , derived from a simultaneous analysis of the dmr 53 and 90 ghz galactic - frame data , accounting for the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction , and including the quadrupole moment in the analysis .
conventions and parameter values are as for fig .
6 . fig .
8.ridge lines of the maximum likelihood @xmath21 value as a function of @xmath1 , for the open - bubble inflation model accounting only for fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( type [ 1 ] spectra ) , for the eight different dmr data sets considered here , and for @xmath121 gyr , @xmath8 .
heavy lines correspond to the case when the quadrupole moment is excluded from the analysis , while light lines account for the quadrupole moment .
these are for the ecliptic - frame sky maps , accounting for ( dashed lines ) and ignoring ( solid lines ) the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction , and for the galactic - frame maps , accounting for ( dot - dashed lines ) and ignoring ( dotted lines ) this galactic emission correction .
the general features of this figure are consistent with that derived from the dmr two - year data ( grsb , fig .
2 ) . fig .
9.ridge lines of the maximum likelihood @xmath21 value as a function of @xmath1 , for the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( type [ 4 ] spectra ) , for the eight different dmr data sets , and for @xmath121 gyr , @xmath8 .
heavy lines correspond to the ecliptic - frame analyses , while light lines are from the galactic - frame analyses . these are for the cases ignoring the faint high - latitude foreground galactic - emission correction , and either including ( dotted lines ) or excluding ( solid lines ) the quadrupole moment ; and accounting for this galactic emission correction , and either including ( dot - dashed lines ) or excluding ( dashed lines ) the quadrupole moment .
the general features of this figure are roughly consistent with that derived from the dmr two - year data ( cayn et al .
1996 , fig .
3 ) . fig .
10.ridge lines of the maximum likelihood @xmath21 value as a function of @xmath1 , for the open - bubble inflation model now also accounting for both the fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation ( bgt ; yst ) and those from a non - square - integrable basis function ( yst ) , for the eight different dmr data sets considered here , and for @xmath64 , @xmath65 .
heavy lines correspond to the cases where the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction is ignored , while light lines account for this galactic emission correction .
these are from the ecliptic frame analyses , accounting for ( dotted lines ) or ignoring ( solid lines ) the quadrupole moment ; and from the galactic - frame analyses , accounting for ( dot - dashed lines ) or ignoring ( dashed lines ) the quadrupole moment .
the general features of this figure are consistent with that derived from the dmr two - year data ( yb , fig .
2 ) . fig .
11.ridge lines of the maximum likelihood @xmath21 value as a function of @xmath1 , for the two extreme dmr data sets , and two different cmb anisotropy angular spectra , showing the effects of varying @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
heavy lines are for @xmath192 gyr and @xmath268 , while light lines are for @xmath123 gyr and @xmath124 .
two of the four pairs of lines are for the open - bubble inflation model accounting only for fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( type [ 1 ] spectra ) , either from the ecliptic - frame analysis without the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction and ignoring the quadrupole moment in the analysis ( solid lines ) , or from the galactic - frame analysis accounting for this galactic emission correction and including the quadrupole moment in the analysis ( dotted lines ) .
the other two of the four pairs of lines are for the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( type [ 4 ] spectra ) , either from the ecliptic - frame analysis without the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction and ignoring the quadrupole moment in the analysis ( dashed lines ) , or from the galactic - frame analysis accounting for this galactic emission correction and including the quadrupole moment in the analysis ( dot - dashed lines ) . given the other uncertainties , the effects of varying @xmath62 and @xmath63 are fairly negligible . fig .
12.ridge lines of the maximum likelihood @xmath21 value as a function of @xmath1 , for the two extreme dmr data sets , for the four cmb anisotropy angular spectra models considered here , and for @xmath64 , @xmath65 .
heavy lines are from the ecliptic - frame sky maps ignoring the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction and excluding the quadrupole moment from the analysis , while light lines are from the galactic - frame sky maps accounting for this galactic emission correction and including the quadrupole moment in the analysis .
solid , dotted , and dashed lines show the open - bubble inflation cases , accounting only for the fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( type [ 1 ] spectra , solid lines ) , also accounting for the fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation ( type [ 2 ] spectra , dotted lines these overlap the solid lines except for @xmath269 and @xmath12 ) , and finally also accounting for the fluctuations corresponding to the non - square - integrable basis function ( type [ 3 ] spectra , dashed lines ) .
dot - dashed lines correspond to the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( type [ 4 ] spectra ) .
13.conditional likelihood densities for @xmath21 , derived from @xmath79 ( which are normalized to be unity at the peak , for each dmr data set , cmb anisotropy angular spectrum , and set of model - parameter values ) .
panel ( a ) is for the open - bubble inflation model accounting only for fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( type [ 1 ] spectra ) , while panel ( b ) is for the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( type [ 4 ] spectra ) .
the heavy lines are for @xmath255 , while the light lines are for @xmath256 .
two of the four pairs of lines in each panel correspond to the results from the analysis of the galactic - frame maps accounting for the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction and with the quadrupole moment included in the analysis , either for @xmath123 gyr and @xmath124 ( dot - dashed lines ) , or for @xmath192 gyr and @xmath268 ( dashed lines ) .
the other two pairs of lines in each panel correspond to the results from the analysis of the ecliptic - frame maps ignoring this galactic emission correction and with the quadrupole moment excluded from the analysis , either for @xmath123 gyr and @xmath124 ( dotted lines ) , or for @xmath192 gyr and @xmath268 ( solid lines ) .
given the other uncertainties , the effects of varying @xmath62 and @xmath63 are fairly negligible .
14.conditional likelihood densities for @xmath21 normalized as in the caption for fig . 13 .
panel ( a ) is from the analysis of the ecliptic - frame maps ignoring the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction and excluding the quadrupole moment from the analysis , while panel ( b ) is from the analysis of the galactic - frame maps accounting for this galactic emission correction and including the quadrupole moment in the analysis .
these are for @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
the heavy lines are for @xmath255 and the light lines are for @xmath256
. there are eight lines ( four pairs ) in each panel , although in each panel two pairs almost identically overlap .
solid , dotted , and dashed lines show the open - bubble inflation cases , accounting only for the fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( type [ 1 ] spectra , solid lines ) , also accounting for the fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation ( type [ 2 ] spectra , dotted lines these almost identically overlap the solid lines ) , and finally also accounting for the fluctuations corresponding to the non - square - integrable basis function ( type [ 3 ] spectra , dashed lines ) .
dot - dashed lines correspond to the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( type [ 4 ] spectra ) .
15.projected likelihood densities for @xmath1 derived from @xmath79 ( normalized as in the caption of fig .
panel ( a ) is for the open - bubble inflation model accounting only for the fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( type [ 1 ] spectra ) , and panel ( b ) is for the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( type [ 4 ] spectra ) .
two of the curves in each panel correspond to the results from the analysis of the galactic - frame maps accounting for the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction and with the quadrupole moment included in the analysis , for @xmath123 gyr and @xmath124 ( dot - dashed lines ) and for @xmath192 gyr and @xmath268 ( dashed lines ) .
the other two curves in each panel are from the analysis of the ecliptic - frame maps ignoring the galactic emission correction and excluding the quadrupole moment from the analysis , for @xmath123 gyr and @xmath124 ( dotted lines ) and for @xmath192 gyr and @xmath268 ( solid lines ) .
16.projected likelihood densities for @xmath1 derived from @xmath79 ( normalized as in the caption of fig .
panel ( a ) is from the analysis of the ecliptic - frame sky maps ignoring the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction and excluding the quadrupole moment from the analysis .
panel ( b ) is from the analysis of the galactic - frame sky maps accounting for this galactic emission correction and including the quadrupole moment in the analysis .
there are four curves in each panel , although in each panel two of them almost overlap .
solid , dotted , and dashed lines show the open - bubble inflation cases , accounting only for the fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( type [ 1 ] spectra , solid lines ) , also accounting for the fluctuations generated in the first epoch of spatially - flat inflation ( type [ 2 ] spectra , dotted lines these almost exactly overlap the solid lines ) , and finally also accounting for the fluctuations corresponding to the non - square - integrable basis function ( type [ 3 ] spectra , dashed lines ) .
dot - dashed lines correspond to the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( type [ 4 ] spectra ) .
these are for @xmath64 and @xmath270 .
17.marginal likelihood densities [ @xmath271 for @xmath1 , normalized to unity at the peak , for the open - bubble inflation model accounting only for fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp94 ) , for the eight different dmr data sets , and for @xmath121 gyr , @xmath8 .
panel ( a ) is from the ecliptic - frame analyses , and panel ( b ) is from the galactic - frame analyses .
two of the four lines in each panel are from the analysis without the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction , either accounting for ( dot - dashed lines ) or ignoring ( solid lines ) the quadrupole moment .
the other two lines in each panel are from the analysis with this galactic emission correction , either accounting for ( dotted lines ) or ignoring ( dashed lines ) the quadrupole moment .
19.marginal likelihood densities for @xmath1 , for the open - bubble inflation model now also accounting for both the fluctuations generated in the first spatially - flat epoch of inflation and those that correspond to the non - square - integrable basis function ( yst ) , computed for @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
conventions are as in the caption of fig .
20.marginal likelihood densities for @xmath1 ( normalized as in the caption of fig .
panel ( a ) is for the open - bubble inflation model accounting only for the fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp94 ) , while panel ( b ) is for the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( w83 ) .
two of the lines in each panel are the results from the analysis of the galactic - frame data sets accounting for the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction and with the quadrupole moment included in the analysis , for @xmath123 gyr and @xmath124 ( dot - dashed lines ) , and for @xmath192 gyr and @xmath268 ( dashed lines ) .
the other two lines in each panel are the results from the analysis of the ecliptic - frame data sets ignoring this galactic emission correction and with the quadrupole moment excluded from the analysis , for @xmath272 gyr and @xmath124 ( dotted lines ) , and for @xmath273 gyr and @xmath268 ( solid lines ) .
21.marginal likelihood densities for @xmath1 ( normalized as in the caption of fig .
17 ) , computed for @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
panel ( a ) is from the analysis of the ecliptic - frame sky maps ignoring the faint high - latitude foreground galactic emission correction and excluding the quadrupole moment from the analysis .
panel ( b ) is from the analysis of the galactic - frame sky maps accounting for this galactic emission correction and including the quadrupole moment in the analysis .
there are four lines in each panel , although in each panel two of the lines almost overlap .
solid , dotted , and dashed curves are the open - bubble inflation cases , accounting only for the fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp94 , solid lines ) , also accounting for the fluctuations generated in the first epoch of spatially - flat inflation ( bgt ; yst , dotted lines these almost identically overlap the solid lines ) , and finally also accounting for the fluctuations corresponding to the non - square - integrable basis function ( yst , dashed lines ) .
dot - dashed curves correspond to the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( w83 ) .
22.fractional differences , @xmath274 , as a function of wavenumber @xmath49 , between the energy - density perturbation power spectra @xmath58 computed using the two independent numerical integration codes ( and normalized to give the same @xmath21 ) .
the heavy curves are for the open - bubble inflation model spectrum accounting only for fluctuations that are generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( type [ 1 ] spectra ) , and the light curves are for the open - bubble inflation model spectrum now also accounting for fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation ( type [ 2 ] spectra ) .
these are for @xmath255 ( solid lines ) and @xmath256 ( dashed lines ) , with @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
23.fractional energy - density perturbation power spectra @xmath58 as a function of wavenumber @xmath49 .
these are normalized to the mean of the extreme upper and lower 2-@xmath80 @xmath21 values ( as discussed in 3.3 ) .
panels ( a)(d ) correspond to the four different sets of ( @xmath62 , @xmath84 ) of tables 912 , and each panel shows power spectra for three different models at six values of @xmath1 .
solid lines show the open - bubble inflation model @xmath58 accounting only for fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp95 ) ; dotted lines are for the open - bubble inflation model now also accounting for fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation ( bgt ; yst ) ; and , dashed lines are for the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( w83 ) . starting near the center of the lower horizontal axis , and
moving counterclockwise , the spectra shown correspond to @xmath258 0.1 , 0.2 , 0.3 , 0.45 , 0.6 , and 1 .
note that at @xmath69 all three model spectra are identical and so overlap ; also note that at a given @xmath1 the open - bubble inflation model @xmath58 accounting for the fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation ( bgt ; yst , dotted lines ) essentially overlap those where this source of fluctuations is ignored ( rp95 , solid lines ) .
panel ( a ) corresponds to @xmath123 gyr and @xmath124 , ( b ) to @xmath121 gyr and @xmath275 , ( c ) to @xmath192 gyr and @xmath276 , and ( d ) to @xmath121 gyr and @xmath122 ( normalized using the results of the dmr analysis of the @xmath123 gyr , @xmath277 models ) .
panel ( e ) shows the three @xmath64 , @xmath65 open - bubble inflation spectra of table 13 at five different values of @xmath1 .
the spectra are for the open - bubble inflation model accounting only for fluctuations generated during the evolution inside the bubble ( rp95 , solid lines ) , also accounting for fluctuations generated in the first epoch of inflation ( bgt ; yst , dotted lines ) , and also accounting for the contribution from the non - square - integrable basis function ( yst , dashed lines ) .
starting near the center of the lower horizontal axis and moving counterclockwise , the models correspond to @xmath258 0.1 , 0.2 , 0.3 , 0.5 , and 0.9 .
note that at a given @xmath1 the three spectra essentially overlap , especially for observationally - viable values of @xmath212 .
the solid triangles represent the redshift - space da costa et al .
( 1994 ) ssrs2 + cfa2 ( @xmath278 mpc depth ) optical galaxies data ( and were very kindly provided to us by c. park ) .
the solid squares represent the [ @xmath279 weighting ] redshift - space results of the tadros & efstathiou ( 1995 ) analysis of the @xmath133 qdot and 1.2 jy infrared galaxy data .
the hollow pentagons represent the real - space results of the baugh & efstathiou ( 1993 ) analysis of the apm optical galaxy data ( and were very kindly provided to us by c. baugh ) .
it should be noted that the plotted model mass ( not galaxy ) power spectra do not account for any bias of galaxies with respect to mass . they also do not account for nonlinear or redshift - space - distortion ( when relevant ) corrections nor for the survey window functions .
it should also be noted that the observational data error bars are determined under the assumption of a specific cosmological model and a specific evolution scenario , i.e. , they do not necessarily account for these additional sources of uncertainty ( e.g. , gaztaaga 1995 ) .
we emphasize that , because of the different assumptions , the different observed galaxy power spectra shown on the plots are defined somewhat differently and so can not be directly quantitatively compared to each other .
24.cmb anisotropy bandtemperature predictions and observational results , as a function of multipole @xmath66 , to @xmath280 .
the four pairs of wavy curves ( in different linestyles ) demarcating the boundaries of the four partially overlapping wavy hatched regions ( hatched with straight lines in different linestyles ) in panel ( a ) are dmr - normalized open - bubble inflation model ( rp94 ) predictions for what would be seen by a series of ideal , kronecker - delta window - function , experiments ( see ratra et al .
1995 for details ) .
panel ( b ) shows dmr - normalized cmb anisotropy spectra with the same cosmological parameters for the flat - space scale - invariant spectrum open model ( w83 ) .
the model - parameter values are : @xmath177 , @xmath281 , @xmath282 , @xmath283 gyr ( dot - dashed lines ) ; @xmath72 , @xmath284 , @xmath8 , @xmath285 gyr ( solid lines ) ; @xmath256 , @xmath286 , @xmath287 , @xmath288 gyr ( dashed lines ) ; and , @xmath69 , @xmath289 , @xmath8 , @xmath290 gyr ( dotted lines ) for more details on these models see ratra et al .
( 1995 ) . for each pair of model - prediction demarcation curves ,
the lower one is normalized to the lower 1-@xmath80 @xmath21 value determined from the analysis of the galactic - coordinate maps accounting for the high - latitude galactic emission correction and including the @xmath291 moment in the analysis , and the upper one is normalized to the upper 1-@xmath80 @xmath21 value determined from the analysis of the ecliptic - coordinate maps ignoring the galactic emission correction and excluding the @xmath85 moment from the analysis . amongst the open - bubble inflation models of panel ( a ) , the @xmath72 model is close to what is favoured by the analysis of table 10 , and the @xmath256 model is close to that preferred from the analysis of table 11 .
the @xmath177 model is on the edge of the allowed region from the analysis of table 12 , and the @xmath69 fiducial cdm model is incompatible with cosmographic and large - scale structure observations .
a large fraction of the smaller - scale observational data in these plots are tabulated in ratra et al .
( 1995 ) and ratra & sugiyama ( 1995 ) . note that , as discussed in these papers , some of the data points are from reanalyses of the observational data .
there are 69 detections and 22 2-@xmath80 upper limits shown .
since most of the smaller - scale data points are derived assuming a flat bandpower cmb anisotropy angular spectrum , which is more accurate for narrower ( in @xmath66 ) window functions , we have shown the observational results from the narrowest windows available .
the data shown are from the dmr galactic frame maps ignoring the galactic emission correction ( grski 1996 , open octagons with @xmath292 ) ; from firs ( ganga et al .
1994 , as analyzed by bond 1995 , solid pentagon ) ; tenerife ( hancock et al .
1996a , open five - point star ) ; bartol ( piccirillo et al . 1996 , solid diamond , note that atmospheric contamination may be an issue ) ; sk93 , individual - chop sk94 ka and q , and individual - chop sk95 cap and ring ( netterfield et al .
1996 , open squares ) ; sp94 ka and q ( gundersen et al .
1995 , the points plotted here are from the flat bandpower analysis of ganga et al . 1996a , solid circles ) ; bam 2-beam ( tucker et al . 1996 , at @xmath293 with @xmath294 spanning 16 to 92 , and accounting for the @xmath295 calibration uncertainty , open circle ) ; python - g , -l , and -s ( e.g. , platt et al . 1996 , open six - point stars ) ; argo ( e.g. , masi et al .
1996 , both the hercules and aries+taurus scans are shown note that the aries+taurus scan has a larger calibration uncertainty of @xmath296 , solid squares ) ; max3 , individual - channel max4 , and max5 ( e.g. , tanaka et al . 1996 , including the max5 mup 2-@xmath80 upper limit @xmath297k at @xmath298 , lim et al .
1996 , open hexagons ) ; msam92 and msam94 ( e.g. , inman et al .
1996 , open diamonds ) ; wdh13 and wdi , ii ( e.g. , griffin et al . 1996 , open pentagons ) ; and cat ( scott et al . 1996 cat1 at @xmath299 with @xmath294 spanning 351 to 471 , and cat2 at @xmath300 with @xmath294 spanning 565 to 710 , both accounting for calibration uncertainty of @xmath301 , solid hexagons ) .
detections have vertical 1-@xmath80 error bars .
solid inverted triangles inserted inside the appropriate symbols correspond to nondetections , and are placed at the upper 2-@xmath80 limits .
vertical error bars are not shown for non - detections . as discussed in ratra et al .
( 1995 ) , all @xmath302 ( vertical ) error bars also account for the calibration uncertainty ( but in an approximate manner , except for the sp94 ka and q results from ganga et al .
1996a see ganga et al .
1996a for a discussion of this issue ) .
the observational data points are placed at the @xmath66-value at which the corresponding window function is most sensitive ( this ignores the fact that the sensitivity of the experiment is also dependent on the assumed form of the sky - anisotropy signal , and so gives a somewhat misleading impression of the multipoles to which the experiment is sensitive see ganga et al .
1996a for a discussion of this issue ) . excluding the dmr points at @xmath303 , the horizontal lines on the observational data points represent the @xmath66-space width of the corresponding window function ( again ignoring the form of the sky - anisotropy signal ) .
note that from an analysis of a large fraction of the data ( corresponding to detections of cmb anisotropy ) shown in these figures , grs ( figs . 5 and 6 ) conclude that all the models shown in panel ( a ) , including the fiducial cdm one , are consistent with the cmb anisotropy data .
|
cut - sky orthogonal mode analyses of the @xmath0-dmr 53 and 90 ghz sky maps are used to determine the normalization of a variety of open cosmogonical models based on the cold dark matter scenario . to constrain the allowed cosmological - parameter range for these open cosmogonies , the predictions of the dmr - normalized models
are compared to various observational measures of cosmography and large - scale structure , viz . : the age of the universe ; small - scale dynamical estimates of the clustered - mass density parameter @xmath1 ; constraints on the hubble parameter @xmath2 , the x - ray cluster baryonic - mass fraction @xmath3 , and the matter power spectrum shape parameter ; estimates of the mass perturbation amplitude ; and constraints on the large - scale peculiar velocity field .
the open - bubble inflation model ( ratra & peebles 1994 ; bucher , goldhaber , & turok 1995 ; yamamoto , sasaki , & tanaka 1995 ) is consistent with current determinations of the 95% confidence level ( c.l . )
range of these observational constraints .
more specifically , for a range of @xmath2 , the model is reasonably consistent with recent high - redshift estimates of the deuterium abundance which suggest @xmath4 , provided @xmath5 ; recent high - redshift estimates of the deuterium abundance which suggest @xmath6 favour @xmath7 , while the old nucleosynthesis value @xmath8 requires @xmath9 .
small shifts in the inferred @xmath0-dmr normalization amplitudes due to : ( 1 ) the small differences between the galactic- and ecliptic - coordinate sky maps , ( 2 ) the inclusion or exclusion of the quadrupole moment in the analysis , ( 3 ) the faint high - latitude galactic emission treatment , and , ( 4 ) the dependence of the theoretical cosmic microwave background anisotropy angular spectral shape on the value of @xmath2 and @xmath10 , are explicitly quantified .
the dmr data alone do not possess sufficient discriminative power to prefer any values for @xmath1 , @xmath2 , or @xmath10 at the 95% c.l .
for the models considered . at a lower c.l . , and when the quadrupole moment is included in the analysis , the dmr data are most consistent with either @xmath11 or @xmath12 ( depending on the model considered ) . however , when the quadrupole moment is excluded from the analysis , the dmr data are most consistent with @xmath13 in all open models considered ( with @xmath14 ) , including the open - bubble inflation model .
earlier claims ( yamamoto & bunn 1996 ; bunn & white 1996 ) that the dmr data require a 95% c.l .
lower bound on @xmath1 ( @xmath15 ) are not supported by our ( complete ) analysis of the four - year data : the dmr data alone can not be used to meaningfully constrain @xmath1 . #
10= 0.00em0 - 0 0.03em0 - 0 0.00em.04em0 - 0 0.03em.04em0 - 00 # 1;#2;#3;#4;#5 # 1 # 2 , # 3 , # 4 , # 5 # 1;#2;#3 # 1 # 2 , # 3 # 1;#2;#3 # 1 # 2 , # 3 # 1@xmath16 mit - ctp-2548 , kuns 1399 0.5 cm august 1996
|
formation and bose - einstein condensation ( bec ) of molecules @xcite have recently been achieved based on ultracold atoms with magnetically - tuned feshbach resonances @xcite . in these experiments ,
feshbach coupling is induced by tuning a foreign molecular state near the scattering continuum , which allows for an efficient transfer of colliding atoms into molecules .
this method works for virtually all alkali atoms , and can create ultracold molecules from various sources including bose condensates @xcite , degenerate fermi gases @xcite , or normal thermal gases @xcite .
feshbach molecules have special and unique properties .
they typically populate only one weakly - bound quantum state , and the bound state can strongly couple to the scattering continuum via feshbach resonance .
we may ask the following question : should feshbach molecules rather be considered as molecules in a specific rovibrational state or as pairs of scattering atoms near the continuum ?
this distinction is particularly crucial in the studies of the bec to bcs ( bardeen - cooper - schrieffer state ) crossover in degenerate fermi gases , which call for a clarification of the quantum nature of the feshbach molecules @xcite .
molecular states near feshbach resonances have been recently investigated based on sophisticated and complete two - body or many - body theory @xcite and multi - channel scattering calculations @xcite .
all works suggest that the feshbach molecule is generally a coherent mixture of the foreign molecule in the closed channel and long - range atom pair in the open scattering channel . near resonances with large resonance widths ,
the molecules can be well approximated as pairs in the open channel . for narrow resonances , as suggested by numerical calculation @xcite , the closed channel dominates and a short - range molecule picture is appropriate . in this paper
, we use a simple two - channel model to describe two interacting atoms near a feshbach resonance ( sec .
ii ) . to account for the finite interaction range of real atoms ,
we introduce a spherical box potential , which allows us to analytically calculate the molecular bound state in different regimes and their threshold behavior ( sec .
iii and sec .
iv ) . finally , we apply our model to feshbach molecules in recent fermi gas experiments and to characterize the associated feshbach resonances ( sec .
we model the interaction of two identical , ultracold atoms with mass @xmath0 based on an open channel @xmath1 that supports the scattering continuum and a closed channel @xmath2 that supports the foreign bound state .
the wave function of the atoms is generally expressed as @xmath3 , where @xmath4 and @xmath5 are the amplitudes in the open and closed channels , respectively , and @xmath6 is the inter - atomic separation .
we assume the interaction @xmath7 is described by a spherical box potential with an interaction range of @xmath8 , see fig .
( 1 ) . for @xmath9 ,
the potential energy of the open channel is 0 and the closed channel @xmath10 . for @xmath11 , the open ( closed ) channel
has an attractive potential of @xmath12 @xmath13 , and a coupling term @xmath14 between the channels .
the wave function satisfies the schrdinger equation : @xmath15 .
a bound state with energy @xmath16 relative to the scattering continuum is supported by the closed channel.,width=211 ] the solution of the above equation for zero scattering energy @xmath17 can be expressed as : @xmath18 where the scattering length @xmath19 and @xmath20 are constants , @xmath21 are the
eigen wave numbers " for @xmath11 associated with the eigen states @xmath22 .
based on the boundary conditions @xmath23 and @xmath24 , we get @xmath25 the latter equation shows how in general , each channel contributes to the scattering length . in cold atom systems ,
feshbach resonances are , in most cases , induced by hyperfine interactions or spin - spin interactions .
both interactions are many orders of magnitude weaker than the relevant short range exchange potential .
it is an excellent approximation to assume @xmath26 and @xmath27 .
hence , we have @xmath28 , @xmath29 and @xmath30 . in this limit ,
the closed channel contribution is significant only when the foreign state is close to the continuum , in which case the last term in eq .
( 7 ) diverges .
given the energy of the closed channel state as @xmath31 and @xmath32 , the boundary condition @xmath33 allows us to expand the last term in eq .
( 7 ) as @xmath34 . here
@xmath35 characterizes the feshbach coupling strength . to the same order of expansion , the middle term in eq .
( 7 ) is a constant across the resonance and can be identified as @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is the background scattering length .
equation ( 7 ) reduces to @xmath38
experimentally , the relative energy between the continuum and the bare state can be adjusted linearly by a magnetic field @xmath39-induced zeeman shift @xmath40 , where @xmath41 and @xmath42 is the magnetic moment of the open(closed ) channel .
replacing @xmath16 by @xmath43 , we can rewrite eq .
( 8) in terms of the magnetic field as @xmath44 where the resonance width @xmath45 and the resonance position @xmath46 are given by @xmath47 several interesting features are shown here .
first of all , we find the resonance width is proportional to both the feshbach coupling @xmath48 and the background scattering properties @xmath49 .
the latter dependence is due to the fact that the scattering amplitude at short range is proportional to the scattering length .
a larger short range scattering amplitude leads to a stronger coupling to the closed channel .
secondly and importantly , the resonance position is offset by exactly @xmath45 relative to the crossing of the bare state and the continuum , @xmath50 , see eq . ( 11 ) . for a positive scattering length @xmath51 ,
this shift is negative @xmath52 .
this feature leads to the renormalization " of the feshbach resonance location discussed in ref .
@xcite . to understand the origin of the resonance shift
, we should return to eq .
the divergence of the scattering length occurs when the open channel contribution ( middle term ) is exactly canceled by the closed channel one ( last term ) . for systems with large background scattering lengths @xmath53 and strong feshbach couplings @xmath48 , this cancelation can occur even when the bare state is far away from the continuum .
a large resonance shift then results .
now we turn to the binding energy of the molecules . assuming a bound eigen state @xmath54 exists near the continuum at @xmath55 , where @xmath56 is the binding energy , we can determine @xmath57 by following essentially the same calculation as eq .
( 1)-(7 ) .
the equivalence of eq .
( 7 ) gives @xmath58 where @xmath59 .
assuming @xmath28 and the bound states in both channels are close to the continuum , namely , @xmath53 and @xmath60 , we can expand the two terms on the right side of eq .
( 12 ) to leading order as @xmath36 and @xmath61 , respectively .
equation ( 12 ) then reduces to @xmath62 this result shows the evolution of the eigen state near the resonance .
similar result is obtained in ref .
@xcite based on a contact potential .
we can immediately see that in the absence of the feshbach coupling @xmath63 , the solutions of eq .
( 13 ) are @xmath64 and @xmath65 ( for @xmath51 ) , which exactly correspond to the bare bound states in the closed channel and the open channel ( for @xmath51 ) , respectively . in the presence of the feshbach coupling @xmath66 , eq .
( 13 ) suggests an avoided level crossing "- like energy structure , see fig .
( 2 ) , which also illustrates the resonance position shifts .
the level crossing , however , is not hyperbolic as it is in a two - level system . in particular , at small binding energies , the bound state energy approaches the continuum quadratically , see fig .
( 2 ) inset . far below the continuum ,
the bound state approaches the bare state in the closed channel . , solid lines ) .
we assume ( a ) @xmath67 and @xmath68 and ( b ) @xmath69 and @xmath68 , where @xmath70 can be any relevant length scale .
arrows mark the offset resonance positions .
insets show the threshold behavior of the bound state.,width=268 ] to better quantify the role of the open and closed channel , we can write the wave function of the eigen state as @xmath71 and , with our approximations , @xmath72 satisfies @xmath73 and the mixing angle @xmath74 is defined below .
we show in eq .
( 15 ) that the eigen state generally occupies both the closed channel and open channel .
we can introduce a mixing amplitude @xmath75 as the amplitude in the closed channel @xmath76 the mixing fraction @xmath77 can be evaluated by a direct integration of the closed channel wave function . alternatively , noticing that the mixing also leads to a dependence of the eigen state on the bare state , we can also derive @xmath77 from the dependence of @xmath57 on @xmath16 , or from the magnetic moment of the feshbach molecule @xmath78 .
all methods lead to the same result @xmath79
despite the seemingly complex equations shown in previous sections , the feshbach molecules are simple and universal near the scattering continuum .
expanding eq .
( 13 ) with small @xmath57 and using eq .
( 9)-(11 ) , we find the binding energy of the feshbach molecules has a simple dependence on the scattering length and increases quadratically in magnetic field near the resonance , namely ,
@xmath80 where @xmath81 . equation ( 20 ) shows identical dependence on scattering length and interaction range as of single channel molecules in the threshold regime @xcite .
furthermore , taking the limit @xmath82 in eq .
( 14 ) and ( 19 ) , we find the molecular wave function here is purely in the open channel .
its spatial extent is determined by quantum uncertainty , @xmath83 , and can be much larger than the interaction range @xmath84 . in this limit ,
the feshbach molecules are identical to long - range atom pairs in a single open channel . by expanding eq .
( 19 ) at small @xmath85 and using eq .
( 13 ) , we find the closed channel fraction can be expressed as @xmath86 where @xmath87 . from eq .
( 22 ) , we see that @xmath88 provides the leading order estimation of the closed channel admixture . when @xmath89 or @xmath90 ( this condition applies when @xmath91 ) , the feshbach molecule is purely in the open channel .
as expected , the threshold regime is wider for resonances with larger @xmath48 and @xmath92 .
we can further determine the
open channel - dominated " regime by setting @xmath93 in eq .
( 19 ) . for resonances with small @xmath94
, this condition corresponds to @xmath95 , which , in terms of magnetic field , maps to only a small fraction of @xmath96 near the resonance @xmath46 . for resonances with large @xmath97 , the open channel dominates when @xmath98 , which covers the full resonance width when @xmath99 , and covers the entire upper branch of the bound state when @xmath100 .
based on the range of the single channel regime , we suggest the broad(narrow ) resonances be defined as those with @xmath97 ( @xmath101 ) . within the width of the feshbach resonance , the molecules associated with a broad ( narrow ) resonance are better described as long range pairs in the open channel ( short range molecules in the closed channel ) .
we note that this definition is purely based on two - body physics .
.parameters of the @xmath102li and @xmath103k feshbach resonances .
interaction range @xmath8 is derived from ref .
@xcite , see text .
feshbach coupling @xmath48 is derived from eq .
@xmath104 is bohr radius and @xmath105 is bohr magneton . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ table1 ] ( dotted lines ) and mixing fractions @xmath77 ( solid lines ) of the molecules near the @xmath102li and @xmath103k feshbach resonances .
the curves are calculated from eq .
( 13 ) , eq .
( 19 ) and the parameters in table 1 .
binding energies from multi - channel calculation @xcite ( dashed lines ) , from jila group measurement @xcite ( open square ) and the mixing fractions measurement from rice group @xcite ( open circles ) are shown for comparison .
the shaded areas indicate the typical bec - bcs crossover regimes , @xmath106.,width=268 ] finally , we apply our model to the @xmath102li@xmath107 and @xmath103k@xmath107 feshbach molecules created in recent bec - bcs experiments @xcite .
these molecules are stable near the resonance and both the molecular binding energies and the scattering lengths have been well measured and studied @xcite . to model the interaction of atoms , we adopt @xmath46 , @xmath45 , @xmath108 and @xmath109 from recent measurements and numerical calculations . to account for the finite range of the atomic interaction , which at low temperatures is determined by the van der waals potential of @xmath110 , we choose the interaction range @xmath8 in our model to be the mean scattering length @xmath111 defined in ref .
this choice ensures the same behavior of the scattering length in the threshold regime @xcite .
all parameters are given in table i. in fig .
( 3 ) , we show the calculated binding energy @xmath57 and the mixing fraction @xmath77 of the feshbach molecules for the two @xmath102li resonances and one @xmath103k resonance .
the results agree very well with the multi - channel calculation @xcite and the measurements on molecular binding energy @xcite , magnetic moment @xcite and mixing fraction @xcite .
both the li resonance at 834 g and the k resonance are broad with @xmath112 and @xmath113 , respectively .
the open channel - dominated regimes of @xmath114 210 mhz for the 834 g li resonance is also larger than the fermi energy of @xmath115 20 khz in the experiments.(here the fermi wave number is @xmath116 . ) for the k resonance , the full upper branch of the molecular state is open channel dominated with mixing fractions less than @xmath117 .
therefore , we conclude the open channel description of these feshbach molecules in the crossover regime to be a good approximation . for the narrower li resonance at @xmath118543 g , we obtain @xmath119 and @xmath120 31 hz @xmath121 20 khz .
this indicates an extremely narrow open channel regime of less than 50 @xmath109 g near the resonance , where the gas parameter is still over @xmath122 .
crossover experiments based on these feshbach molecules can not be described by open channel atom pairs and may lead to qualitatively different physics .
we attribute the large difference between the two li resonances to their different couplings @xmath48 and very different background scattering length @xmath37 , see table i. in the above discussions , we note that fermi energy @xmath123 is an external parameter which depends on the density of the sample . whether the molecules in the crossover regime can be described by single channel strongly depends on the density .
the @xmath124 parameter , however , provides a better and independent measure to classify feshbach resonances .
we find that the two feshbach resonances in @xmath102li are the two extremes of broad and narrow resonances with @xmath112 and @xmath125 . in summary , the two - channel model provides a simple picture to understand the molecular state near the feshbach resonances .
the analytic results of the molecular binding energy and mixing fraction on @xmath102li and @xmath103k agree with the measurements and other sophisticated calculations very well . based on the threshold behavior of the bound state
, we suggest a dimensionless parameter to assess the broadness " of the feshbach resonance .
we thank p.s .
julienne and n. nygaard for stimulating discussions and r. grimm s lithium and cesium groups in innsbruck for the support during our visit .
the author is partially supported by the lise - meitner program of the austrian science fund ( fwf ) .
s. jochim , m. bartenstein , a. altmeyer , g. hendl , s. riedl , c. chin , j. hecker denschlag and r. grimm , science * 302 * , 2101 ( 2003 ) ; m. greiner , c.a .
regal , d.s .
jin , nature * 426 * , 537 ( 2003 ) ; m. zwierlein , c.a .
stan , c.h .
schunck , s.m.f .
raupach , s. gupta , z. hadzibabic , and w. ketterle , phys .
91 * , 250401 ( 2003 ) .
j. herbig , t. kraemer , m. mark , t. weber , c. chin , h .- c .
ngerl , and r. grimm , science * 301 * , 1510 ( 2003 ) ; s. drr , t. volz , a. marte , and g. rempe phys . rev .
* 92 * , 020406 ( 2004 ) ; k. xu , t. mukaiyama , j.r .
abo - shaeer , j.k .
chin , d. miller , and w. ketterle , phys . rev
. lett . * 91 * , 210402 ( 2003 ) .
b. marcelis , e.g.m .
van kempen , b.j .
verhaar , and s.j.j.m.f .
kokkelmans , phys .
a * 70 * , 012701 ( 2004 ) ; s.j.j.m.f .
kokkelmans , j.n .
milstein , m.l .
chiofalo , r. walser , and m.j .
holland , phys .
a * 65 * , 053617 ( 2002 ) .
|
we present a two - channel model to describe the quantum state of two atoms with finite - range interaction near a feshbach resonance .
this model provides a simple picture to analytically derive the wave function and the binding energy of the molecular bound state .
the results agree excellently with the measurements and multichannel calculations . for small binding energies ,
the system enters a threshold regime in which the feshbach molecules are identical to long range atom pairs in single channel . according to their threshold behavior
, we find feshbach resonances can be classified into two types .
|
the study of supernovae ( sne ) has greatly advanced in the last few years .
intensive and highly automated monitoring of nearby galaxies ( e.g. , li et al .
1996 ; treffers et al .
1997 ; filippenko et al .
2001 ; dimai 2001 ; qiu & hu 2001 ) , wide - field , moderately deep surveys ( e.g. , reiss et al . 1998 ; gal - yam & maoz 1999 , 2002 ; hardin et al . 2000 ; schaefer 2000 ) , and cosmology - oriented , deep , high - redshift sn search projects ( perlmutter et al . 1997 ; schmidt et al .
1998 ) now combine to yield hundreds of new sn discoveries each year .
ambitious programs that are currently planned or underway [ e.g. , the nearby supernova factory aldering et al .
2001 ; the supernova / acceleration probe ( snap )
perlmutter et al . 2000 ; automated sn detections in sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) data vanden berk et al .
2001 ; miknaitis et al .
2001b ; see also @xmath9 promise to increase these numbers by at least an order of magnitude .
sne are heterogeneous events , empirically classified into many subtypes , with the main classification criteria based on spectral properties .
briefly , sne of type ii show hydrogen lines in their spectra while sne of type i do not .
each of these types is further divided into subtypes , the commonly used ones including ia , ib , and ic , as well as ii - p , ii - l , iin , and iib .
see filippenko ( 1997 ) for a thorough review and @xmath10 for more details .
it is widely accepted that sne ia are produced from the thermonuclear disruption of a white dwarf at or near the chandrasekhar limit , while all other types of sne ( ib , ic , and ii ) result from the core collapse of massive stars . while understanding sne , their properties , and their underlying physics is of great interest , sne are also useful tools in the study of various other important problems .
sne ia are excellent distance indicators , and their hubble diagram has been used to determine the local value of the hubble constant ( e.g. , parodi et al .
2000 , and references therein ) .
the extension of the hubble diagram to higher redshifts ( @xmath11 ) probes the geometry and matter - energy content of the universe ( e.g. , goobar & perlmutter 1995 ) .
two independent groups using large samples of high-@xmath12 sne ia presented a strong case for a current acceleration of the universe ( riess et al .
1998 ; perlmutter et al . 1999
; see filippenko 2001 for a summary ) , consistent with a nonzero cosmological constant , @xmath13 .
subsequent work ( riess et al . 2001 ) based on a single sn ia at @xmath14 possibly shows the transition from matter - dominated deceleration to @xmath13-dominated acceleration at @xmath15 .
sne ii - p can also be used as primary distance estimators through the expanding photosphere method ( epm ; kirshner & kwan 1974 ; schmidt , kirshner , & eastman 1992 ; schmidt et al .
1994 ) , as was most recently demonstrated by hamuy et al .
( 2001 ) and leonard et al .
( 2002a , b ) .
leonard et al . ( 2002a ; see also hflich et al . 2001 ) suggest that distances good to @xmath16% ( @xmath17 ) may be possible for sne ii - p by simply measuring the mean plateau visual magnitude , obviating the need for a complete epm analysis unless a more accurate distance is desired .
hamuy & pinto ( 2002 ) refine this technique , showing that a measurement of the plateau magnitude and the ejecta expansion velocity potentially yields a considerably smaller uncertainty in the derived distance .
sn rates as a function of redshift probe the star - formation history of the universe , the physical mechanisms leading to sne ia , and the cosmological parameters ( jorgensen et al .
1997 ; sadat et al . 1998 ; ruiz - lapuente & canal 1998 ; madau , della valle , & panagia 1998 ; yungelson & livio 2000 ) .
sn rates are also important for understanding the chemical enrichment and energetics of the interstellar medium ( e.g. , matteucci & greggio 1986 ) and the intracluster medium ( e.g. , brighenti & mathews 1998 , 2001 ; lowenstein 2000 ; gal - yam , maoz , & sharon 2002 ) .
once discovered , the study of a particular sn , and its use as a tool for any of the applications above , is almost always based on spectroscopic verification and classification .
the information extracted from sn spectra usually includes ( but is not limited to ) the sn type , redshift , and age ( relative to the dates of explosion or peak brightness ) .
spectroscopic followup may not always be possible or practical .
sne , especially at high redshift , may be too faint for spectroscopy , even with the largest , 10-m - class telescopes currently available .
spectroscopy is also not practical if large numbers ( hundreds or thousands ) of sne are detected within a relatively short time , as is expected to happen in the case of the sdss southern strip ( miknaitis et al .
2001b ; see also @xmath18 ) .
finally , spectroscopy is impossible for sne discovered in archival data ( gal - yam & maoz 2000 ; riess et al . 2001 ; gal - yam et al .
2002 ) , which have long faded by the time they are found .
the discovery of sne in archival data is expected to become frequent as high - quality astronomical databases become larger and more accessible , especially with the development of projects such as astrovirtel ( http://www.stecf.org/astrovirtel ) and the national virtual observatory ( brunner , djorgovski , & szalay 2001 ) .
the goal of the present work is to facilitate the scientific exploitation of sne for which no spectroscopic observations exist .
the obvious alternative for spectroscopy is multi - color broadband photometry .
the potential utility of such an approach is demonstrated , in principle , by the use of the `` photometric redshift '' method to infer the redshift and type of galaxies and quasars that are too faint or too numerous to observe spectroscopically ( e.g. , weymann et al .
1999 ; richards et al . 2001 ) . applying a similar method
to sne is not straightforward since , unlike galaxies , the spectra of sne vary strongly with type , redshift , and time . while photometric approaches to the study of faint sne have been discussed before ( dahln & fransson 1999 ; sullivan et al .
2000 ; riess et al . 2001 ) , no general treatment has been presented thus far . in a recent paper , dahln & goobar ( 2002 , hereafter dg2002 )
tackle the issue of sn classification for the case of deep , cosmology - oriented , high-@xmath12 sn searches .
their treatment relies heavily on the particular observational setup used by these programs i.e. , the comparison of images obtained @xmath194 weeks apart , designed to detect sne before , or at , peak brightness . as these authors show , this setup is strongly biased toward the discovery of sne ia .
the main theme of dg2002 is the selection of the high-@xmath12 sne ia from an observed sample , using photometry of the host galaxies and the sne themselves . for the particular observational setup
they consider , dg2002 also wish to minimize the contamination of the sample by non - ia sne . to do this
, they use the models of dahln & fransson ( 1999 ) and demonstrate their ability to reject most non - ia sne based on their colors and lower brightness . however , the models used for the population of non - ia sne are based on many parameters and assumptions , such as the ultraviolet ( uv ) spectra , peak brightness , light curves , and relative fractions of non - ia sne , that are not precisely known even in the local universe , let alone at high redshift .
while dg2002 seek only to identify high-@xmath12 sne ia detected by a particular observational setup , we present general methods that apply to all the major sn subtypes and can be used for a wide range of sn surveys , including searches that are similar to those described by dg2002 .
classification of sne using broadband colors is such a complex problem that , as we show below , a full solution ( i.e. , deriving sn type , redshift , and age from a few broadband colors ) is probably impossible .
however we will argue here that the problem may be simplified .
type , redshift , and age need not all be determined simultaneously .
most sne are associated with host galaxies that are readily detectable .
one can therefore infer the redshift of the sn from that of the host , derived either from spectroscopy ( that may be obtained long after the sn has faded ) or using a photometric redshift .
in fact , for sne that are detected in well - studied parts of the sky , the redshift information often already exists .
gal - yam et al .
( 2002 ) recently demonstrated this with sne they discovered in archival _
hubble space telescope ( hst ) _ images of well - studied galaxy - cluster fields .
five of the six apparent sne they found ( and all of those clearly associated with a host ) had redshift information in the literature .
for the majority of sne , the redshift can thus be obtained from observations of the host , and treated as a known parameter . in the absence of a spectrum , the sn age
may sometimes be revealed by measuring the photometric light curve of the event .
admittedly , such followup may still pose a problem for faint or very numerous events , and is generally not possible for archival sne ( see riess et al .
2001 for an exception ) .
however , for many of the scientific uses of sne ( e.g. , the derivation of sn rates ) , the age of each event is immaterial .
determination of the type of a sn is crucial for most of the applications discussed above .
the sn type can be securely determined only from observations of the active sn itself .
while some information can be gleaned from the host ( e.g. , elliptical galaxies are known to contain only sne ia ) , this information is limited and such reasoning may not hold at high redshifts .
we therefore concentrate our efforts on using multi - color broadband photometry to classify sne .
since we want to constrain the type of a sn with an arbitrary ( but known ) redshift , it is not simple to utilize broadband photometry ; k - corrections for sne of all types , and at all ages , are currently unknown . instead , we have compiled a large spectral database of nearby , well - observed sne .
these spectra are used to calculate synthetic broadband colors for various sn types through a given filter set at a given redshift .
the temporal coverage of our compilation allows us to draw paths in color space which show the time evolution of each sn type . inspecting the resulting diagrams
, one can then look for regions which are either populated by a single type of sn , or that are avoided by various sn types .
the observed photometric colors of a candidate sn with a known redshift can then be plotted on the relevant diagrams , and constraints on its type and age may be drawn .
as we show in @xmath20 , the type of a sn can sometimes be uniquely determined .
when this is not the case , the type may still be deduced by supplementing the color information with other available data on the sn , such as constraints on its brightness , and information ( even if very limited ) on its variability ( e.g. , whether its flux is rising or declining ) .
our sn classification method is based on colors , determined by the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) of each event . by definition
, such a method can differentiate only between sn subtypes with unique spectral characteristics .
hypothetically , two sne with very different photometric properties ( e.g. , light curves , peak magnitudes ) , but having similar seds at all ages , would not be distinguished by our method .
the sn classification scheme we adopt needs , therefore , to rely only on spectral properties .
fortunately , the common classification of sne ( see filippenko 1997 for a review ) is mostly based on their spectra , with one notable exception which we discuss below .
it is customary to divide the sn population into two main subgroups : type ii sne , which show prominent hydrogen lines in their spectra , and type i sne , which do not ( minkowski 1941 ) .
type i sne are further divided into type ia whose spectra are characterized by a deep absorption trough around @xmath21 , attributed to blueshifted si ii @xmath226347 , 6371 lines , type ib that show prominent he i lines , and type ic that lack both si ii and he i ( e.g. , matheson et al .
2001 , and references therein ) .
type ii sne are divided ( e.g. , barbon , ciatti , & rosino 1979 ; doggett & branch 1985 ) into two subclasses according to their light - curve shape : sne ii - p show a pronounced plateau during the first @xmath23 d of their evolution , and sne ii - l decline in a linear fashion in a magnitude vs. time plot , similar to sne i. further studies ( e.g. , filippenko 1997 ) show that sne ii - p have characteristic spectra , with the h@xmath24 line showing a p - cygni profile . on the other hand , sne ii - l have not been well characterized spectroscopically , and the best spectroscopically studied events ( sne 1979c and 1980k ) are considered to be photometrically peculiar ( `` overluminous '' ; miller & branch 1990 ) relative to other sne ii - l . during the 1990s ,
the focus in studies of sne ii shifted from photometry to spectroscopy .
two new subtypes have emerged .
sne iin show narrow h@xmath24 emission ( e.g. , schlegel 1990 ; filippenko 1997 , and references therein ) , and sne iib are transition objects that first appear as relatively normal sne ii , but evolve to resemble sne ib ( filippenko 1988 ; filippenko , matheson , & ho 1993 ; matheson et al .
2001 , and references therein ) . for our study ,
only sn subtypes with well - defined spectral properties are meaningful .
we therefore consider henceforth only sne ii - p , iin , and iib as subtypes of the sn ii population .
sne iin and iib are probably a large fraction of the sn population that was previously classified as type ii - l based only on their light - curve shape ( approximately half of the sn ii population , e.g. , cappellaro et al .
reviewing the latest spectral databases available to us , we estimate that most of the sne ii discovered by current surveys belong to the spectroscopically defined subtypes ii - p , iin , and iib ( see below ) .
sne are a veritable zoo , with many peculiar and even unique events , from luminous hypernovae ( e.g. , sn 1998bw galama et al .
1998 ; patat et al . 2001 ; sn 1997cy germany et al .
2000 ; turatto et al . 2000 ; sn 1997ef iwamoto et al .
2000 ; matheson et al . 2001 ) to faint sn 1987a - like events ( e.g. , arnett et al . 1989 , and references therein ) , and sn `` impostors '' ( e.g. , filippenko et al . 1995a ; van dyk et al . 2000 , and references therein ) .
currently , we limit our discussion to sn types that are not extremely rare , and are well - defined and well - characterized spectroscopically . assuming that the sne reported in the iau circulars are representative of the sn population that is discovered by current programs
, we estimate that , collectively , the well - defined subtypes we consider ( ia , ib , ic , ii - p , iin , and iib ) constitute at least 83% , and probably more , of the entire population .
for instance , we consider all the sne that were discovered during the year 2000 and whose type was either reported in iau circulars , or alternatively could be constrained by data available to us . among 110 such events ,
there were 54 type ia , 5 type ib , 5 type ic , 8 type iin , one type iib , two peculiar sne ia , one peculiar sn ib , and 34 events which were reported just as `` type ii . ''
using available spectra or data reported in the iau circulars , we learn that of the latter 34 events , 18 show a p - cygni profile in h@xmath24 , typical of sne ii - p , 13 events may or may not belong to the ii - p , iin , or iib subtypes , and 3 events are definitely not ii - p , iin , or iib events .
hence 91 events ( 83% ) belong to our spectroscopically defined sn sample ( types ia , ib , ic , ii - p , iin , and iib ) , 13 events ( 12% ) may or may not be of these types , and just 6 events ( 5% ) are known to be of types not included in our database .
it is therefore likely that analysis based on our database will be relevant to the large majority of sne discovered by current programs .
this is probably also true for future programs that will use similar search methods .
we are aware that a large population of intrinsically faint sne ( e.g. , sn 1987a - like ) may be underrepresented in current sn statistics .
analysis of future surveys that will be sensitive to such events may require their inclusion in the spectral database .
the core of our classification algorithm is the spectral database : a compilation of optical spectra of nearby sne .
most of the these spectra were obtained with the shane 3-m reflector at lick observatory .
the typical resolution is better than @xmath25 ( full width at half maximum ) , and the majority of the data used cover the range 320010000 . some spectra with narrower coverage ( approximately 40008000 ) are also used .
all spectra were either obtained at the parallactic angle ( filippenko 1982 ) , or calibrated by simultaneous photometry , to ensure that spectral shape distortions due to wavelength - dependent atmospheric refraction are not significant .
telluric lines were removed , generally through division by the spectrum of a featureless star . according to the galactic coordinates of the observed sn
, the spectra were corrected for galactic reddening , using the maps of schlegel , finkbeiner , & davis ( 1998 ) and the extinction curve of cardelli , clayton , & mathis ( 1989 ) .
the working edition of the database was constructed in the following manner . for each of the well - defined sn subtypes mentioned above ,
we have selected a prototype .
the main criterion was the availability of spectra with wide wavelength coverage and multiple epochs .
in addition , a few complementary spectra of other events were included in order to verify consistency and fill gaps in the temporal evolution , when needed .
table 1 lists the sne whose spectra constitute our database , with the prototypical event for each subtype listed first .
we have specifically avoided events that were known to either suffer considerable extinction , or to be otherwise peculiar . for sne
ia , peculiar ( overluminous , sn 1991t - like , or underluminous , sn 1991bg - like ) events are rather well characterized , and may be quite common , at least in low - redshift environments ( li et al .
our main database includes only spectra of normal sne ia , but we examine the effects of peculiar sne ia in @xmath26 below .
all spectra were de - redshifted according to the host - galaxy redshift taken from the ned database .
after redshifting the spectra again to a chosen redshift ( see below ) , the telluric features were re - applied before deriving synthetic colors . using our spectral database , we calculate the synthetic colors of sne at a chosen redshift through the johnson - cousins @xmath4 ( johnson 1965 ; cousins 1976 ;
see moro & munari 2000 for details ) , bessell @xmath27 ( bessell & brett 1988 ) , and sdss @xmath6 ( fukugita et al .
1996 ; stoughton et al .
2002 ) filter systems .
if a filter s bandpass is not fully covered by a sn spectrum , the flux in the missing spectral region is extrapolated linearly using the median value of the spectrum .
each calculated magnitude that includes such an extrapolation is assigned an error equal to the amount of flux in the extrapolated part of the spectrum , thus providing a conservative error estimate .
the resulting synthetic photometry is then displayed on color - color diagrams .
note that in all the plots we present , the ordinate and abscissa are composed of colors consisting of adjacent bands ( e.g. , @xmath28 vs. @xmath29 , @xmath29 vs. @xmath1 etc . ) .
since most of the spectra in our database have a wide wavelength range , error bars will hence generally appear only on one axis . in the following section we present such diagrams , discuss their use in the classification of sne discovered by various programs , and derive a few general rules .
note that the choice of colors that gives the best sn type differentiation , apart from the obvious dependence on the filter system used , also depends on redshift . for optimal results , for each sn ( having a known redshift and some observed colors )
one needs to search for color - color diagrams that give the maximum information content .
obvious space limitations allow us to present below just a few representative examples of such plots .
similar plots for arbitrary values of @xmath12 may be obtained from our website ( http://wise-obs.tau.ac.il/$\sim$dovip/typing ) .
in figure 1 , we compare our data on sne ia to template colors of normal sne ia compiled by leibundgut ( 1988 ) .
one can see that our calculated colors follow the expected path in color space , with a small scatter ( @xmath30 mag ) , consistent with the previously measured dispersion in sne ia colors ( e.g. , tripp 1998 ; phillips et al . 1999 , and references therein ) .
since our spectral database includes spectra of sn 1994d , which was somewhat bluer at early times than average sne ia ( richmond et al .
1995 ) , our treatment covers an even wider variety in the colors of early sne ia . from this plot
, we can estimate the expected width of color - color paths for normal sne ia to be @xmath300.3 mag .
note that sne ia follow a complex curve in color space , with a distinct turn - around point @xmath16 d after peak brightness .
the underlying spectral evolution is nontrivial .
like most sne , the continuum slope of early sne ia is very blue , and becomes redder as the sn grows older .
this process is dominant during the first weeks of sn ia evolution , but is later countered by the emergence of strong emission lines in the blue part of the spectrum ( restframe 40005500 ) .
the line - dominated spectrum results in unique colors for late - time ( @xmath31 d ) sne ia ( e.g. , figure 3 , below ) . in figure 2 our results for sne ii
- p are plotted against the observed photometry of the recent , well - observed sn 1999em .
it can be clearly seen that the results agree perfectly up to around 70 d past maximum brightness , where a bifurcation appears in our calculated color path .
our spectral data for sne ii - p is based on three different events ( sne 1992h , 1999em , and 2001x ) .
the three points that have considerably lower @xmath28 values ( at 110 , 127 , and 165 d ) have all been calculated from the spectra of sn 2001x , which up to that age was consistent with the other sne ii - p used .
this demonstrates the well - known variety of late - type spectra of sne ii ( filippenko 1997 ) . in subsequent plots ,
we retain both branches of `` old '' sne ii - p ( with the one derived from spectra of sn 2001x marked , when significantly different , in a darker shade ) , and treat the color space bounded by them as a possible location for such sne .
contrary to sne ia , the color path of sne ii - p is quite smooth .
the underlying spectral evolution is driven mostly by the change in the continuum slope , from very blue at early ages , growing redder with time ( e.g. , filippenko 1997 ) .
late - time ( @xmath31 d ) spectra become increasingly dominated by strong and broad emission lines , especially h@xmath24 , that give sne ii - p their distinct late - time colors ( see , e.g. , fig .
3 , below ) . in figure 3 ( top panel )
, we show the color paths of all types of sne at zero redshift in @xmath28 vs. @xmath29 .
one sees that many sne before maximum light are blue , with @xmath32 mag . while most young sne ii have @xmath33 mag , young sne ia have bluer @xmath29 colors ( @xmath34 mag ) but redder @xmath28 colors , around @xmath35 mag .
it is also evident that old ( @xmath36 d ) sne ia have unique colors ( @xmath37 mag , @xmath38 mag ) , as do some of the sne ii - p ( ages 19100 d ) which have the reddest colors of all sne . the arrow shows the reddening effect corresponding to @xmath39 mag of extinction , assuming the galactic reddening curve of cardelli et al .
one can see that the unique colors of young ( @xmath40 d ) and very old ( @xmath31 d ) sne ia can not be masked even by significant reddening in their host .
furthermore , we note that high extinction values are rare for sne ia . for example , only 3 among 49 sne ia ( @xmath41 ) studied by the cfa and caln / tololo programs , and presented in riess et al .
( 1999 ) , have @xmath42 mag .
conversely , because reddening works only in one direction , some candidates with appropriate observed colors can be uniquely determined to be sne ia
. however , the center of the diagram is populated by sne of all types . for example , a zero - redshift sn , of unknown type , with colors of @xmath43 mag , @xmath44 mag , would be impossible to classify based on these colors only .
but the middle panel of figure 3 shows that if one examines an additional color , such as @xmath1 , this degeneracy can be partly lifted .
for the same @xmath45 mag , there is a spread in @xmath1 that can shed some light on the sn type .
a value of @xmath46 mag would favor a type ia classification , while a positive value would suggest one of the core - collapse types .
addition of an @xmath2 measurement ( fig .
3 , bottom panel ) would narrow the options even further , since in this color , at this redshift , different types have distinct values , from the bluest sne ia to the reddest types ( ib , ic , and ii - p ) . looking at the reddening vectors in the middle and bottom panels of figure 3 , we again note that only heavy extinction ( @xmath47 mag ) can move sne ia into color regions populated by core - collapse sne . before we proceed , we briefly comment on the effects of host - galaxy contamination .
since our approach assumes the redshift of a given sn is a known parameter , and this is commonly available through the observation of the host galaxy , some data on the galaxy should exist .
it should therefore generally be possible to subtract the galaxy s light from the sn photometry . to study the effect of non - subtraction of host - galaxy light , or imperfect subtraction , we parameterize the amount of the contaminating galactic flux , at a given epoch , by the ratio @xmath48 where @xmath49 and @xmath50 are the mean flux of the host galaxy and sn spectra , respectively , calculated over the wavelength range of the spectrum of the sn .
we consider contamination as negligible , when it is not likely to make one type of sn look like another .
first , we find that for all types of sne and hosts , when @xmath51 the effect of contamination is indeed negligible . for young sne ia , the worst - case scenario would be the contamination by a red elliptical host that could make them look like redder core - collapse sne . when observed in restframe blue colors ( e.g. , @xmath52 ) , this effect becomes significant only when @xmath53 , but if red bands ( e.g. , @xmath54 ) are used , contaminated sne ia attain colors similar to those of the core - collapse population already at @xmath55 .
the opposite effect ( i.e. , of bluer host galaxies on red core - collapse sne ) is much weaker , so contamination by spiral hosts is unlikely to mix core - collapse sne with young sne ia . only heavy contamination ( @xmath56 ) by a very blue , star - forming host galaxy can make a red sn ii - p appear similar to a bluer sn ia on a @xmath52 color - color diagram . in redder bands ( e.g. , @xmath54 ) ,
even this extreme case causes negligible shifts in color .
we conclude that if the host galaxy light has been subtracted , at least roughly , from the measured sn photometry , residual contamination has no significant implication . a large contribution from an underlying host
( e.g. , with a flux similar to that of the sn itself ) that has not been removed may mask blue sne ia as core - collapse events , but is unlikely to make red core - collapse events appear as sne ia . in the discussion below
, we therefore neglect contamination of the sn photometry by light from the underlying host galaxy . with increasing redshift , the available spectral information shifts to longer - wavelength filters .
the top panel of figure 4 demonstrates how well sne ia can be differentiated from other types at @xmath57 on a @xmath1 vs. @xmath2 diagram . on the @xmath2 axis
the only sne with negative values are sne ia .
they are also the only type with @xmath1 color greater than 0.6 mag while @xmath2 is smaller than 0.3 mag . during most of the temporal evolution of sne ia ,
their distinction from other types is practically unaffected by host galaxy dust reddening , as can be seen from the vector plotted ( the reddening is calculated in the sn rest frame ) .
the middle panel of figure 4 shows a similar diagram computed at @xmath58 .
classification is obviously more difficult .
still , sne ii - p ( including `` sn 2001x - like , '' see @xmath59 ) at ages above 100 d have @xmath2 values higher than sne of other types ( at all ages ) .
close to peak flux , sne ia have @xmath1 colors of a few tenths of a magnitude bluer than other types , and again , this distinction is not sensitive to reddening . even where all types seem to mingle , at @xmath60 mag and @xmath61 mag , sne ia and ii - p have @xmath1 values that are 0.2 mag higher than other types . should one of these types be rendered unlikely by other data , such as a sn that is too bright to be a sn ii - p , the classification can become unique or nearly so .
for example , sne ii - p can be unambiguously identified by their light curves ; no other sn type has a roughly constant @xmath54 brightness over such a long period . in principle , two @xmath62-band ( restframe ) observations separated by , say , 30 d can unambiguously identify a sn ii - p . at redshifts
higher than 0.6 , the @xmath62 band samples the restframe uv , not covered by our spectral database .
thus , only one color ( @xmath2 ) remains in the johnson - cousins system .
the sdss filter system has 3 filters ( @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and @xmath12 ) in the approximate range covered by the @xmath65 and @xmath66 filters , but extending farther into the red by @xmath67 . using this system
, we can extend our analysis to higher redshifts .
this is demonstrated in the bottom panel of figure 4 for sne at @xmath7 .
again , late - time sne ii - p are significantly redder than other types ( @xmath68 mag and @xmath69 mag ) , while early - time sne ia are significantly bluer ( @xmath70 mag and @xmath71 mag ) , and remain so even in the presence of significant reddening by dust . at later times
( over two months ) , sne ia escape from the vicinity of other types and reach @xmath72 values above 1.2 mag .
sne iin at this redshift appear to be isolated from other types .
as we move even farther up the redshift scale the use of infrared ( ir ) filters is required . between @xmath73 and @xmath74 ,
classification would require a combination of optical and ir photometry .
figure 5 ( top panel ) shows that at @xmath75 , sne ia have distinct blue colors ( @xmath76 mag and @xmath77 mag ) at almost all ages , sne ii - p develop very red @xmath78 colors ( @xmath79 mag ) two months after peak , while sne ib and ic are the only ones that have @xmath80 colors that are redder than @xmath81 mag .
as before , these distinctions are hardly affected by extinction . between @xmath82 and 2.5 our spectra shift into the region covered by the bessell @xmath27 filters .
in the bottom panel of figure 5 ( @xmath83 ) , one can see that sne ia have generally lower @xmath80 colors ( @xmath84 mag ) , except between ages of one to two months , shared perhaps by very early type iin , ii - p , and ic events .
sne ib and ic are the only objects to have both @xmath80 and @xmath85 above unity .
the use of synthetic colors , calculated from spectra of local sne , to classify high-@xmath12 events , assumes that sn spectra do not evolve strongly with redshift .
the similarity , to a first approximation , between the spectra of distant sne ia and their local counterparts has been demonstrated ( riess et al . 1998 ; coil et al . 2000 ) .
however , for all other types of sne , high - quality spectra of distant ( @xmath86 ) events are largely unavailable .
since we use synthetic broadband colors , only significant evolution in either the spectral slope or strong emission or absorption features will influence our classification method . nevertheless , this is a caveat that must be addressed once spectra of distant core - collapse sne become available .
we now examine the colors of peculiar sne ia and their implication for our classification method . following the same approach used earlier , we have compiled spectra of the most extreme varieties of peculiar sne ia : overluminous ( sn 1991t - like ; e.g. , filippenko et al .
1992a ) and underluminous ( sn 1991bg - like ; e.g. , filippenko et al .
1992b ) objects , as well as spectra of sn 2000cx , a unique sn ia that may be considered a subtype of its own ( li et al .
table 2 provides observational details for these objects . inspecting figure 6 ( top panel ) ,
which shows the @xmath28 vs. @xmath29 colors of the various sn ia subtypes at zero redshift , we see that , although the paths of peculiar sne ia in color space are different from those of `` normal '' sne ia , they populate the same general region . on the other hand , in the middle panel of figure 6 , showing @xmath1 vs. @xmath2 colors at zero redshift , one can see that underluminous sne ia have significantly larger @xmath2 values ( by 0.20.6 mag ) than those of all other sne ia , and are therefore liable to mix with the redder core - collapse population .
this is illustrated in the bottom panel of the same figure , where indeed , underluminous sne ia at early ages ( prior to @xmath87 d ) can not be distinguished from core - collapse sne .
later in their evolution , these events acquire unique colors ( @xmath88 mag , @xmath89 mag ) that are different from all other types of sne . as sn 1991t - like and sn 2000cx - like events are almost always bluer than `` normal '' sne ia , they are generally easier to distinguish from core - collapse sne , and pose no special problem in our analysis .
sne ia of the underluminous , redder , sn 1991bg - like variety are hard to distinguish from core - collapse sne at early ages , and may be lost in color - based classification .
this problem is quite limited at low redshift , where underluminous sne ia are rare ( @xmath90% of the sn ia population ; li et al .
2001a ) , and may be totally negligible at higher redshifts where , empirically , sn 1991bg - like events have not been found at all ( li et al .
2001a ) .
high - redshift sn search programs that focus on finding sne ia for use as distance indicators encounter the problem of sample contamination by other sn types , especially a luminous variety of sne ic ( riess et al .
1998 ; clocchiatti et al . 2000 ) .
the problem is two - fold .
first , unwanted non - ia sne take up precious telescope resources for followup spectroscopy .
second , when only low signal - to - noise ratio spectra of faint , high-@xmath12 events are available , luminous sne ic may masquerade as sne ia .
the latter problem is acute at high @xmath12 , since at these redshifts the sn ia hallmark ( the si ii @xmath91 trough ) is shifted out of the optical range , and sne ic spectra lack the telltale h or he lines that distinguish sne ii and sne ib , respectively .
spectra with high signal - to - noise ratios can provide definitive classifications ( coil et al .
2000 ) , but these are time - consuming to obtain .
> from figure 7 , one sees that color information may help , at least partially , to alleviate this problem .
we confirm and quantify the well known `` rule of thumb '' ( e.g. , riess et al .
2001 ) : sne ic are red compared to sne ia at a similar redshift .
one can see that , for sne at ages that are relevant for high-@xmath12 search programs , designed to discover sne near peak brightness , sne ia are typically 0.5 mag bluer in @xmath72 than sne ic , well above the typical effects of reddening . while it is true that rising ( pre - maximum ) sne ic have colors similar to those of older ( @xmath92 weeks past maximum ) sne ia , even the most basic variability information ( e.g. , whether the object is rising or declining ) breaks this degeneracy .
figure 7 also illustrates the fact that most of the information at this redshift can be obtained from the @xmath72 color alone , and the inclusion of @xmath12-band information does not appear to be cost - effective .
sn 2001fg was the third sn reported from sdss data .
this event was discovered on 15 october 2001 ut by vanden berk et al .
( 2001 ) with @xmath93 , @xmath94 , and @xmath95 mag . inspecting the color - color diagram calculated for the appropriate redshift ( @xmath96 , see below ) , one can see ( fig .
8) that the type and approximate age of the sn candidate can be deduced .
the diagram clearly indicates this is a sn ia , around one month old .
followup spectra by filippenko & chornock ( 2001 ) using the keck ii 10-m telescope reveal that the object is indeed a sn ia , at @xmath96 .
the spectrum is similar to those of sne ia about two months past maximum brightness .
this age , at the time of the spectral observation ( 18 november ut ) , implies an age around one month past maximum brightness at discovery , confirming our diagnosis .
a fully `` blind '' application would have , of course , required an independent photometric or spectroscopic redshift for the sn host galaxy .
the method presented here can become significantly more powerful when more observational data become available .
faint , high-@xmath12 sne are usually observed at optical wavelengths ( i.e. , @xmath62 , @xmath65 , or @xmath66 bands ) . in order to use these bands for classification , knowledge of the restframe uv spectrum
is required .
currently , uv spectra are available for only a handful of objects , while methods like those discussed here require multi - epoch coverage of several objects for each sn subtype .
further characteristics of the various sn types , most notably the absolute peak magnitudes and their scatter for every sn type , the typical light curves , and the relative rates of the different types , would also be useful . with such data in hand , one could use the limiting magnitude of a survey to calculate , for each sn type , at what epochs it is bright enough to be observed , thus removing some degeneracy in the classification .
a further enhancement could be introduced to deal with the regions in color space that are populated by several different sn types . using the typical light curves and known peak magnitudes for all types , and the relative rates
, one could calculate the amount of time a sn of a certain type spends within a region and deduce the likelihood that an observed event belongs to a particular type .
as already mentioned in @xmath97 , work along these lines has been presented by dg2002 , who replace missing observational data with rough estimates or models .
sne are generally discovered by their variability .
however , the tools developed in this paper may enable one to detect sne by their colors alone .
indeed , such methods have recently been discussed for the detection of another kind of transient phenomenon gamma - ray burst afterglows ( rhoads 2001 ) .
multi - color wide - field surveys ( e.g. , becker et al .
2001 ; jannuzi et al . 2001 ; sdss york et al .
2000 ) that are either planned or already underway may be used to discover large numbers of sne using similar methods . to illustrate this point , we plot in figure 9 the locations of sne of all types at @xmath98 , together with a polygon within which fall the vast majority of stars , asteroids , cataclysmic variables , cepheids , and quasars , as discussed by krisciunas , margon , & szkody ( 1998 ) .
except for late - time sne ic , all sne have lower @xmath99 values and higher @xmath72 values than these objects .
similar results are obtained for the sn population at @xmath100 00.3 , the redshifts of sne probed by the sdss .
this demonstrates the feasibility of color selection of sne , a method which may emerge as an invaluable resource when applied to upcoming , large data sets .
an exciting application of the methods presented in this paper would be the study of sne discovered in the sdss southern strip . during the months of september to november , when the primary target of the sdss , the north galactic pole , is not visible , the sdss telescope observes parts of the sky near the south galactic pole .
the so called `` south equatorial strip '' is a patch of sky that will be imaged repeatedly during the 5-year planned operations of the survey . according to the sdss website ( http://www.sdss.org/documents/5yearbaseline.pdf ) , this 270 square degree area will be imaged @xmath101 times during the 5-year period , or about 4 times each fall , on average . assuming that this sampling enables the discovery of all sne that occur during the @xmath19 months this strip is imaged each year , for five years , the total surveyed area is @xmath102 deg@xmath103-months , or 337.5 deg@xmath103-years .
pain et al .
( 1996 ) have measured a sn ia rate of 34 per year per square degree in the magnitude range @xmath104 , and the limiting magnitude of the sdss images in this band is given as @xmath105 mag .
we would then expect some 2300 sne ia each year or a total of over 11,000 sne ia in this strip .
the numbers of sne of all types ( not just ia ) will undoubtedly be even larger .
miknaitis et al .
( 2001b ) report that a systematic search for sne in these data is underway , and the first sne have already been reported ( miknaitis et al . 2001a ; rest , miceli , & covarrubias 2001 ; miknaitis & krisciunas 2001 ) .
this huge expected dataset , which may contain an order of magnitude more events than all previously known sne , all with five - band photometry and possibly some variability information , offers an unprecedented resource for sn studies . as an example , sn rates , based on thousands of events , can be computed as a function of sn type , host - galaxy morphology , and redshift .
however , it is clear that obtaining spectra for thousands of faint sne each fall is not feasible .
photometric classification could therefore be a valuable option . the sdss supplies five - band information , along with ready - made tools for the derivation of photometric redshifts for all host galaxies , and spectral identification for part of the brighter ones .
this makes our approach of using the sn photometry for classification , assuming that the redshift is known , even more appropriate .
since no followup is required , such an analysis need not be done in real time in principle , it may even be carried out long after the project is complete , and all the data are publicly available . in summary , we have presented a method for the classification of sne , using multi - color broadband photometry .
we have shown that the type of a sn may be uniquely determined in some cases . even when this is not the case , constraints on the type may still be drawn .
in particular , sne ia may be distinguished from core - collapse sne during long periods in their evolution , for most of the redshifts and filter combinations studied .
finally , we have demonstrated the application of our method to a recently discovered sn from the sdss , and we have shown how this technique may become a valuable tool for the analysis of the large sn samples expected to emerge from this and other programs that are already active or will begin soon .
this work proves that spectroscopic followup is not always a prerequisite for sne to be a valuable scientific resource , and lays the foundations for the exploitation of large sn samples for which such followup may not be possible .
we thank the many people in a.v.f.s group at the university of california , berkeley ( especially a. j. barth , r. chornock , l. c. ho , and j. c. shields ) who , over the years , helped obtain and calibrate the spectra that constitute much of the dataset used in this study .
we are grateful to a. fassia , m. hamuy , and y. qiu for supplying us with digital copies of their spectra of sn 1998s , 1999ee , and 1996cb , respectively .
b. leibundgut generously provided help with sn light curves , and we thank d. branch , e. o. ofek , g. richards , and o. shemmer for useful suggestions .
we acknowledge the assistance of the staffs of various observatories ( especially lick ) where the data were taken . this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
d. m. acknowledges support by the israel science foundation the jack adler foundation for space research , grant 63/01 - 1 .
a.v.f . is grateful for the financial support of nsf grants ast9417213 and ast9987438 , as well as of the guggenheim foundation .
aldering , g. , supernova cosmology project collaboration , & nearby supernova factory collaboration .
2001 , baas , 199.67.01 arnett , w. d. , bahcall , j. n. , kirshner , r. p. , & woosley , s. e. 1989 , araa , 27 , 629 barbon , r. , ciatti , f. , & rosino , l. 1979 , a&a , 72 , 287 becker , a. , et al .
2001 , baas , 199.1101.14 ; see also http://dls.bell-labs.com/team.html bessell , m. s. , & brett , j. m. 1988 , , 100 , 1134 brighenti , f. , & mathews , w. g. 1998 , apj , 515 , 542 brighenti , f. , & mathews , w. g. 2001 , apj , 553 , 103 brunner , r. j. , djorgovski , s. g. , & szalay , a. s. 2001 , eds .
, virtual observatories of the future ( san francisco : asp , conf . ser .
225 ) cappellaro , e. , et al .
1997 , a&a , 322 , 431 cardelli , j. a. , clayton , g. c. , & mathis , j. s. 1989 , apj , 345 , 245 clocchiatti , a. , et al .
2000 , , 529 , 661 coil , a. l. , et al . 2000 ,
apj , 544 , l111 cousins , a. w. j. 1976 ; see moro & munari 2000 for details dahln , t. , & fransson , c. 1999 , a&a , 350 , 349 dahln , t. , & goobar , a. 2002 , pasp , 114 , 284 ( dg2002 ) dimai , a. 2001 , iau circ .
7719 doggett , j. b. , & branch , d. 1985 , aj , 90 , 2303 fassia , a. , et al .
2001 , mnras , 325 , 907 filippenko , a. v. 1982 , pasp , 94 , 715 filippenko , a. v. 1988 , aj , 96 , 1941 filippenko , a. v. 1997 , ara&a , 35 , 309 filippenko , a. v. 2001 , pasp , 113 , 1441 filippenko , a. v. , barth , a. j. , bower , g. c. , ho , l. c. , stringfellow , g. c. , goodrich , r. w. , & porter , a. c. 1995a , aj , 110 , 2261 [ erratum : 112 , 806 ( 1996 ) ] filippenko , a. v. , & chornock , r. 2001 , iau circ .
7754 filippenko , a. v. , li , w. d. , treffers , r. r. , & modjaz , m. 2001 , in small - telescope astronomy on global scales , ed .
w. p. chen , c. lemme , & b. paczyski ( san francisco : asp , conf .
246 ) , 121 filippenko , a. v. , matheson , t. , & ho , l. c. 1993 , apj , 415 , l103 filippenko , a. v. , et al .
1992a , apj , 384 , l15 filippenko , a. v. , et al .
1992b , aj , 104 , 1543 filippenko , a. v. , et al . 1995b , apj , 450 , l11 fukugita , m. , ichikawa , t. , gunn , j. e. , doi , m. , shimasaku , k. , & schneider , d. p. 1996
, , 111 , 1748 galama , t. j. , et al .
1998 , nature , 395 , 670 gal - yam , a. , & maoz , d. 1999 , in `` cosmic explosions , '' ed .
s. s. holt & w. w. zhang ( new york : aip ) , p. 107
gal - yam , a. , & maoz , d. 2000 , iau circ .
7405 gal - yam , a. , & maoz , d. 2002 , in preparation gal - yam , a. , maoz , d. , & sharon , k. 2002 , mnras , in press , astro - ph/0109089 gal - yam , a. , & shemmer , o. 2001 , iau circ .
7602 ; see http://wise-obs.tau.ac.il/$\sim$avishay/local.html germany , l. m. , reiss , d. j. , sadler , e. m. , schmidt , b. p. , & stubbs , c. w. 2000 , , 533 , 320 goobar , a. , & perlmutter , s. 1995 , apj , 450 , 14 hamuy , m. , & pinto , p. a. 2002 , apjl , 566 , l63 hamuy , m. , et al .
2001 , apj , 558 , 615 hamuy , m. , et al .
2002 , aj , in press , astro - ph/0203491 hardin , d. , et al .
2000 , iau circ .
7406 hflich , p. , straniero , o. , limongi , m. , dominguez , i. , & chieffi , a. 2001 , in rev .
mexicana astron .
10 , the seventh texas - mexico conference on astrophysics : flows , blows , and glows , ed .
w. lee & s. torres - peimbert ( mexico , df : inst . astron . ,
unam ) , 157 iwamoto , k. , et al .
2000 , apj , 534 , 660 jannuzi , b. , et al . 2001
; see http://www.noao.edu/noao/noaodeep johnson , h. l. 1965 ; see moro & munari 2000 for details jorgensen , h. e. , lipunov , v. m. , panchenko , i. e. , postnov , k. a. , & prokhorov , m. e. 1997 , , 486 , 110 kirshner , r. p. , & kwan , j. 1974 , apj , 193 , 27 krisciunas , k. , margon , b. , & szkody , p. 1998 , pasp , 110 , 1342 leibundgut , b. 1988 , ph.d .
thesis , university of basel leonard , d. c. , filippenko , a. v. , barth , a. j. , & matheson , t. 2000 , apj , 536 , 239 leonard , d. c. , et al .
2002a , pasp , 114 , 35 leonard , d. c. , et al .
2002b , aj , submitted li , w. , filippenko , a. v. , treffers , r. r. , riess , a. g. , hu , j. , & qiu , y. 2001a , , 546 , 734 li , w. , et al .
1996 , iau circ .
6379 li , w. , et al . 2001b , pasp , 113 , 1178 loewenstein , m. 2000 , apj , 532 , 17 madau , p. , della valle , m. , & panagia , n. 1998 , mnras , 297 , l17 matheson , t. , filippenko , a. v. , li , w. , leonard , d. c. , & shields , j. c. 2001 , aj , 121 , 1648 matteucci , f. , & greggio , l. 1986 , , 154 , 279 miknaitis , g. , & krisciunas , k. 2001 , iau circ .
7778 miknaitis , g. , miceli , a. , stubbs , c. , covarrubias , r. , & lawton , b. 2001a , iau circ .
7731 miknaitis , g. , rest , a. , stubbs , c. , stoughton , c. , & sdss collaboration .
2001b , baas , 199.84.04 miller , d. l. , & branch , d. 1990 , aj , 100 , 530 minkowski , r. 1941 , pasp , 53 , 224 moro , d. , & munari , u. 2000 , a&as , 147 , 361 pain , r. , et al .
1996 , , 473 , 356 parodi , b. r. , saha , a. , sandage , a. , & tammann , g. a. 2000 , apj , 540 , 634 patat , f. , et al .
2001 , apj , 555 , 900 perlmutter , s. , et al .
1997 , apj , 483 , 565 perlmutter , s. , et al .
1999 , apj , 517 , 565 perlmutter , s. , & snap collaboration .
2000 , baas , 197.61.01 phillips , m. m. , lira , p. , suntzeff , n. b. , schommer , r. a. , hamuy , m. , & maza , j. 1999 , , 118 , 1766 qiu , y. , & hu , j. y. 2001 , iau circ .
7753 qiu , y. , li , w. , qiao , q. , & hu , j. 1999 , aj , 117 , 736 reiss , d. , germany , l. m. , schmidt , b. p. , & stubbs , c. w. 1998 , aj , 115 , 26 rest , a. , miceli , a. , & covarrubias , r. 2001 , iau circ .
7740 rhoads , j. e. 2001 , apj , 557 , 943 richards , g. t. , et al .
2001 , , 122 , 1151 richmond , m. w. et al .
1995 , , 109 , 2121 .
riess , a. g. , et al .
1998 , aj , 116 , 1009 riess , a. g. , et al .
1999 , aj , 117 , 707 riess , a. g. , et al .
2001 , apj , 560 , 49 ruiz - lapuente , p. , & canal , r. 1998 , apj , 497 , l57 sadat , r. , blanchard , a. , guiderdoni , b. , & silk , j. 1998 , a&a , 331 , l69 schaefer , b. e. 2000 , iau circ .
7387 schlegel , d. j. , finkbeiner , d. p. , & davis , m. 1998 , apj , 500 , 525 schlegel , e. m. 1990 , mnras , 244 , 269 schmidt , b. p. , kirshner , r. p. , & eastman , r. g. 1992 , apj , 395 , 366 schmidt , b. p. , et al .
1994 , , 432 , 42 schmidt , b. p. , et al .
1998 , apj , 507 , 46 stoughton , c. , et al .
2002 , , 123 , 485 sullivan , m. , ellis , r. , nugent , p. , smail , i. , & madau , p. 2000 , , 319 , 549 treffers , r. r. , peng , c. y. , filippenko , a. v. , & richmond , m. w. 1997 , iau circ .
6627 tripp , r. 1998 , , 331 , 815 turatto , m. , et al .
2000 , apj , 534 , 57 vanden berk , d. e. , et al .
2001 , baas , 199.84.05 van dyk , s. d. , peng , c. y. , king , j. y. , filippenko , a. v. , treffers , r. r. , li , w. , & richmond , m. w. 2000 , pasp , 112 , 1532 weymann , r. j. , storrie - lombardi , l. j. , sawicki , m. , & brunner , r. 1999 , eds . ,
photometric redshifts and high - redshift galaxies ( san francisco : asp ) york , d. g. , et al .
2000 , aj , 120 , 1579 yungelson , l. , & livio , m. 2000 , apj , 528 , 108 clccc ia & 1994d & 22 & 0.0015 & 1,9 + & 1987l & 2 & 0.0074 & 1 + & 1995d & 4 & 0.0066 & 9 + & 1999dk & 5 & 0.0150 & 9 + & 1999ee & 12 & 0.0114 & 10 + ib & 1984l & 12 & 0.0051 & 1,9 + & 1991ar & 1 & 0.0152 & 2 + & 1998dt & 2 & 0.0150 & 2 + & 1999di & 1 & 0.0164 & 2 + & 1999dn & 3 & 0.0093 & 2 + ic & 1994i & 14 & 0.0015 & 1,3 + & 1990u & 8 & 0.0079 & 2 + & 1990b & 4 & 0.0075 & 2 + ii - p & 1999em & 27 & 0.0024 & 4 + & 1992h & 13 & 0.0060 & 1,9 + & 2001x & 12 & 0.0049 & 6,9 + iin & 1998s & 13 & 0.0030 & 5,7 + & 1994y & 1 & 0.0080 & 1 + & 1994ak & 1 & 0.0085 & 1 + iib & 1993j & 12 & 0 & 1 + & 1996cb & 3 & 0.0024 & 8 + total & & 172 & & + clccc 1991t - like & 1991 t & 12 & 0.0058 & 1,5 + & 1998es & 7 & 0.0106 & 5 + 1991bg - like & 1991bg & 5 & 0.0035 & 2,5 + & 1998bp & 2 & 0.0104 & 5 + & 1998de & 3 & 0.0166 & 5 + & 1999da & 4 & 0.0127 & 5 + 2000cx - like & 2000cx & 23 & 0.0079 & 3,4 + total & & 56 & & +
|
large numbers of supernovae ( sne ) have been discovered in recent years , and many more will be found in the near future . once discovered , further study of a sn and its possible use as an astronomical tool ( e.g. , as a distance estimator ) require knowledge of the sn type .
current classification methods rely almost solely on the analysis of sn spectra to determine their type .
however , spectroscopy may not be possible or practical when sne are faint , numerous , or discovered in archival studies .
we present a classification method for sne based on the comparison of their observed colors with synthetic ones , calculated from a large database of multi - epoch optical spectra of nearby events .
we discuss the capabilities and limitations of this method .
for example , type ia sne at redshifts @xmath0 can be distinguished from most other sn types during the first few weeks of their evolution , based on @xmath1 vs. @xmath2 colors .
type ii - p sne have distinct ( very red ) colors at late ( @xmath3 d ) stages .
broadband photometry through standard johnson - cousins @xmath4 filters can be useful to classify sne out to @xmath5 .
the use of sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) @xmath6 filters allows the extension of our classification method to even higher redshifts ( @xmath7 ) , and the use of infrared bands , to @xmath8 .
we demonstrate the application of this method to a recently discovered sn from the sdss .
finally , we outline the observational data required to further improve the sensitivity of the method , and discuss prospects for its use on future sn samples .
community access to the tools developed is provided by a dedicated website .
|
the time varying stern - gerlach , sg , interaction of a relativistic fermion with an e.m .
wave has been proposed to separate beams of particles with opposite spin states corresponding to different energies@xcite .
we will show how spin polarized particle will exchange energy with the electromagnetic field of an rf resonator .
let us denote with @xmath1 the coordinates of a particle in the laboratory , and with @xmath2 the coordinates in the particle rest frame , prf . in the latter the sg force that represents the action of an inhomogeneous magnetic field on a particle endowed with a magnetic moment @xmath3 is f_sg = (^ * b ) = x ( ^ * b ) + y ( ^ * b ) + z ( ^ * b ) [ fsg ] with = ge2 m s [ mu ] .
here @xmath4 is the elementary charge with @xmath5 for protons and positrons , @xmath6 , and @xmath7 for antiprotons and electrons , @xmath8 , making @xmath9 and @xmath10 either parallel or antiparallel to each other , respectively .
@xmath11 is the rest mass of the particle , @xmath12 the gyromagnetic ratio and @xmath13 the anomaly defined as a = g-22 = \ { ll 1.793 ( g=5.586 ) & p,|p + + 1.160 10 ^ -3 & e^ .. [ anomalies ] notice that in eq.([fsg ] ) we have defined the magnetic moment as @xmath14 in the rest frame , rather than as @xmath15 . in the rest frame the quantum vector @xmath10 , or spin , has modulus @xmath16 and its component parallel to the magnetic field lines can only take the following values s_m=(-s , -s+1, .... ,s-1 , s ) , [ s_main ] where @xmath17 is the reduced planck s constant . combining eqs.([mu ] ) and ( [ s_main ] ) we obtain for the magnetic moment in the prf = ||=g|e|4 m = \ { l 1.41 10 ^ -26 jt^-1 + + 9.28 10 ^ -24 jt^-1 .. [ mumod ] for a particle traveling along the axis @xmath18 , the lorentz transformations of the differential operators and of the force yield \
{ lll x = x & y = y & z = ( z + c t ) + + f_= 1f _ & f_= f _ & ( f_z = f_z ) [ dz ] .. [ ftransf]the force ( [ fsg ] ) is boosted to the laboratory system as f_sg = 1 x ( ^ * b ) + 1 y ( ^ * b ) + z ( ^ * b ) .
[ f - sg ] because of the lorentz transformation of the fields@xcite @xmath19 and @xmath20 \ { l e = ( e + cb ) - ^2 + 1(e ) + + b = ( b - ce )
- ^2 + 1(b ) .. [ br ] the energy in the rest frame @xmath21 becomes ( ^ * b ) = ^*_x ( b_x + ce_y ) + ^*_y ( b_y - ce_x ) + ^*_zb_z
. [ magen ] combining eqs.([magen ] ) and ( [ f - sg ] ) , by virtue of eq.([dz ] ) , after some algebra we can finally obtain the sg force components in the laboratory frame : \ { l f_x = ^*_x(b_xx + c e_yx ) + ^*_y(b_yx - c e_xx ) + 1^*_zb_zx + + f_y = ^*_x(b_xy + c e_yy ) + ^*_y(b_yy - c e_xy ) + 1^*_zb_zy + + f_z = ^*_xc_zx + ^*_yc_zy + ^*_zc_zz , .
[ fsgz ] with \ { l c_zx = ^2 + + c_zy = ^2 + + c_zz = ( b_zz + c b_zt ) .. [ czz ] these results can also be obtained from the quantum relativistic theory of the spin-@xmath0 charged particle@xcite .
let us introduce the dirac hamiltonian h = e+ c(p - ea ) + _ 0 mc^2 [ ham1 ] having made use of the dirac s matrices = ( ) , _ 0 = ( ) , = _ 0 = ( ) , [ mat - d ] where @xmath22 is a vector whose components are the pauli s matrices _ x = ( ) , _ y = ( ) , _ z = ( ) , [ mat - p ] @xmath23 is the @xmath24 identity matrix , @xmath25 the null matrix and having chosen the @xmath26-axis parallel to the main magnetic field . a standard
derivation leads to the non relativistic expression of the hamiltonian exhibiting the sg interaction with the `` normal '' magnetic moment = e+ ( p - ea)^2 - ( b ) [ hamp ] which coincides with the pauli equation and is valid in the prf . to complete the derivation
we must add the contribution from the anomalous magnetic moment to the sg energy term in the previous equation , with a factor @xmath27 , yielding - b = - ^ * b ^ * = g .
[ sgenergy ] in order to obtain the @xmath28-component of the sg force in the laboratory frame along the direction of motion of the particle , we must boost the whole pauli term of eq.([hamp ] ) by using the unitary operator @xmath29 in the hilbert space@xcite , which expresses the lorentz transformation u^-1 u = g(_0b ) [ hilb ] that can be written in terms of the equivalent transformation in the @xmath30 spinor space s = = + ( ) [ str ] with = , u = = = , u = (= ) .
[ defs ] from eqs.([hilb ] ) and ( [ str ] ) , due to the algebraic structure of the @xmath31 and @xmath32 matrices , we obtain in the laboratory frame the three components of the sg force \ { lll s^-1 ( _ 0 _ x ) s & = & _ 0 _ x + s^-1 ( _ 0 _ y ) s & = & _ 0 _ y + s^-1 ( _ 0 _ z ) s & = & ( _ 0 _ z ) + i_0_5 . ,
[ evxyz ] with _ 5 = _ x_y_z_0 = i ( ) .
[ g5 ] from eqs.([evxyz ] ) we can deduce the expectation values of the sg force in the laboratory system with a defined spin -along the @xmath26-axis in our case- via the expectation values of the pauli matrices and of the pauli interaction term of the proper force f_z = _ 0_y^2^*. [ fz4 ] in our case only the second of eqs.([evxyz ] ) gives a non vanishing result , while both the first and third produce a null contribution to the force , because of the orthogonality of the two spin states @xmath33 and the properties of the @xmath32 matrices .
let us consider the standing waves built up inside a rectangular radio - frequency resonator , tuned to a generic te mode@xcite .
resonator dimensions are : width @xmath13 , height @xmath34 and length @xmath35 , as shown in fig.[fig : box ] . on the cavity axis , which coincides with the beam axis , the electric and magnetic fields are@xcite @xmath36 \\ \\
b_x & = & - { b_0\over k_c^2 } \left({m\pi\over a}\right ) \left({p\pi\over d}\right ) \sin\left({m\pi x\over a}\right ) \cos\left({n\pi y\over b}\right ) \cos\left({p\pi z\over d}\right ) \cos\,\omega t \\ \\ b_y & = & - { b_0\over k_c^2 } \left({n\pi\over b}\right ) \left({p\pi\over d}\right ) \cos\left({m\pi x\over a}\right ) \sin\left({n\pi y\over b}\right ) \cos\left({p\pi z\over d}\right ) \cos\,\omega t \\ \\ b_z & = & b_0
\cos\left({m\pi x\over a}\right ) \cos\left({n\pi y\over b}\right ) \sin\left({p\pi z\over d}\right ) \cos\,\omega t \end{array}\ ] ] where @xmath37 is the rf peak magnetic field , @xmath11 , @xmath38 and @xmath39 are integer mode indeces , and k_c = .
[ kc ] the angular frequency of the e.m .
wave from the rf generator is = _
= 2c _ = c. [ omegen ] in contrast with an open waveguide , in a bounded cavity we can define a phase velocity @xmath40 and a cavity wavelength @xmath41 , as typical of any e.m . in a refractive media , according to the relations = _ = dp .
[ rphv ] and _ = _ ph_. [ cav - wl ] it is also = _ c = _ = notice that @xmath42 can take any value , even larger than one , since it is freely dependent on the cavity geometrical parameters .
moreover , combining eqs.([omegen ] ) and ( [ rphv ] ) we obtain d = p _ _ = p _ [ cav - length ] which describes the connection between the cavity length @xmath35 and the wavelengths , as shown in fig.[fig : edge ] . for simplicity , let s choose the transverse electric mode @xmath43 , so eqs.([omegen ] ) and ( [ rphv ] ) reduce respectively to = _
= c = _ c _ = [ ombetap ] or , setting the mode index @xmath44 , = _
= c = _ c _ = , [ ombeta1 ] which are the quantities pertaining to the preferred @xmath45 mode whose non zero field components on the cavity axis are \ { l b_y(z , t ) = - b_0 ( ) t + + e_x(z , t ) = -b_0 ( ) t .. [ byex ] it is important to emphasize that in all the field components met so far there is a clear separation between spatial and temporal contributions , as typical of standing waves .
besides , the boundary conditions of the electric and magnetic fields of the e.m . dictate the shape of the spatial component which , in turn , oscillates in time with the frequency @xmath46 . then , at the cavity entrance and exit the field components ( [ byex ] ) become on axis \ {
l b_y(0,t ) = -b_0 t + + e_x(0,t ) = 0 .. [ edge - in ] and \ { l b_y(d , t )
= -b_0 t = b_0 t + + e_x(d , t ) = -t = 0 .. [ edge - out ] where @xmath47 is a generic time .
the null values of @xmath48 at the cavity ends confirm a typical pattern of the transverse electric mode .
from eq.([fz4 ] ) , after some algebra , we obtain tha a charged fermion which crosses a radio - frequency resonator , tuned on the te@xmath49 mode , acquires ( or loses ) an energy amount when interacts with the field component in the `` body '' of the cavity shown in fig . [
fig : edge]@xcite ( u ) _ = _ 0^df_z dz = _
0^d^*c_zydz = ^2 ^ 2 b_0^ * ( 1 + ) [ du - x ] still assuming that the spin is not precessing .
however , since the cavity can not be completely enclosed but must have apertures at both ends to allow the particle bean to pass through and consequently will have fringe fields , in order to calculate the full sg interaction it is necessary to deal with the interaction with these fields .
this is discussed right below . in order to fulfill the boundary conditions ( [ edge - in ] ) and ( [ edge - out ] ) , a cavity tuned in its @xmath45 mode must be exactly filled by either an even or an odd number of cavity dependent half wave - lengths , eq.([cav - wl ] ) , as illustrated in figs .
[ fig : edge ] and [ fig : edges ] .
consider now a bunch of particles crossing the cavity in synchronism with the rf field .
this requires that the bunch centre of mass that enters the cavity at the instant @xmath50 and would leave the cavity at @xmath51 , at magnetic field values , respectively b_y(0,0 ) = -b_0 b_y(d , _ ) = b_0 [ in - out ] the field values at both ends fade rapidly to zero over a small distance @xmath52 just outside the cavity ( see figures . )
we may consider these fringe fields as small - valued functions in the @xmath53-plane , since the time @xmath54 necessary for a particle to proceed through this distances can be very small in comparison with @xmath55 , depending of course by the size of the beam channel , or \
{ llllll _ & = & -b_0g(z ) & & g(-)=0 , & g(0)=1 + + _ & = & b_0h(z ) & & h(d)=1 , & h(d+)=0 .. [ edge - flds ] under these conditions , a relativistic fermion with its spin directed along the @xmath26-axis and traversing the cavity will experience a sg force parallel to the @xmath28-axis ( direction of motion ) , see eq.([fsgz ] ) f_z = ^ * c_zy [ fz ] where @xmath56 is given by the second of the set of eqs.([czz ] ) . for the moment
we assume that the spin will conserve its orientation during traversal the electric field @xmath48 and its derivatives in this equation are almost constantly zero , because of the boundary conditions on the walls of the cavity and at the extreme points @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
furthermore , the function@xmath59 is almost zero along the fringe segments because of its proportionality to @xmath60 , with @xmath47 equal to the @xmath54 mentioned before .
consequently we have c_zy ^2 , [ redczy ] and for the entire fringe field \ { lll _ & = & -b_0^*^2 ( ) + + _ & = & b_0^*^2 ( ) .. [ edge - forces ] making use of eqs .
( [ redczy ] ) and ( [ edge - forces ] ) , the energy increments @xmath61_{\m in}$ ] and @xmath61_{\m out}$ ] related to the fringe fields are easily evaluated since the integrals @xmath62 and @xmath63 only depend upon the extreme points ( [ edge - flds ] ) and do not depend on the curve that connects them .
in fact @xmath64 becomes an exact differential .
then we obtain for the energy exchange at both edges ( u ) _
= ( u ) _ = - b_0^*^2 .
[ cav - en ] the total energy exchange at the edges is therefore ( u ) _
= ( u ) _ + ( u ) _
= - 2b_0^*^2 .
[ ff - en ] by adding the fringe contributions ( [ ff - en ] ) to the cavity body crossing contribution ( [ du - x ] ) seen before , obtain ( u ) _
= ( u ) _ + ( u)_x = -^2 b_0^ * f ( _ , ) [ du - tot ] with f ( _ , ) = . [ beta - beta ] for ultra relativistic particles ( @xmath65 ) eq .
( [ du - tot ] ) reduces to ( u ) _
-^2 b_0^ * ( 1- _ ) .
[ du - ur1 ] this last result deserves a few comments .
in fact , if we set _ = 2 d = _ = _ [ b2 ] the total energy contribution ( [ du - ur1 ] ) vanishes , implying a full cancellation of the effect . on the other hand if we set _
= _ [ b3 ] the total energy contribution ( [ du - ur1 ] ) becomes ( u ) _
-2 ^ 2 b_0^ * [ du - ur2 ] as deduced from eq.([cav - length ] ) . in table
i we gather values calculated from eq.([beta - beta ] ) for non - relativistic and ultra - relativistic particles for , either @xmath66 or @xmath67 at two proton energies . each @xmath42 is accompanied by the corresponding ratio cavity - length over cavity - height .
* table i : * @xmath68 [ cols="^,^,^ " , ] furthermore , if we consider two contiguous cavities , there will be a gradient between the positive @xmath69 at the end of the first cavity and a negative @xmath69 at the beginning of the second cavity , as shown in fig .
[ fig : cavx ] . in this case
we may consider the magnetic field at the interface as linearly dependent on @xmath28 , that is _
[ gradx ] reiterating what done before , obtain rcl _ & = & -2b_0 + + f_z & = & -2b_0^*^2 + + ( u ) _
= ( u ) _ & = & _ -^f_z dz = -2b_0^ * ^2 = -2b_0^*^2 which means that , for @xmath70 cavities , we shall have as final result for ultra relativistic particles ( u ) _ = n(u ) _ - ( n-1)(u ) _ - ( u ) _ = \ { ll 0 & _ ph = 2 + + b_0^*^2 & _ ph = 3 .. [ full - end ] conversely , if @xmath42 is even , particles with their spin pointing always in the same direction can not exchange energy with the standing wave of a te resonator .
a spin rotator@xcite can align the particle magnetic moments either parallel or anti - parallel to the directions of the magnetic field gradients , thus allowing the desired energy interaction .
this situation would be similar to what happens in a multi - stage tandem van de graaff , where the ions are repetitively accelerated by the same electrostatic field , becoming alternatively negative , via an addition of electrons , or positive , via electron stripping .
unfortunately , the field integral ( @xmath71 tm , for @xmath72 ) for attaining a spin rotation is so large that this solution is unpractical .
instead , the example of @xmath42 equal to an odd number seems much more suitable since does not require cumbersome magnets , but only longer cavities ( compare eqs .
( [ b2 ] ) and ( [ b3 ] ) ) .
in fact , the magnetic moments are ( de)accelerated by the field tails at the cavity ends , while do nt change their energy when crossing the cavities .
this situation resembles the wideroe linac where the charged particles are accelerated by the electric fields between two contiguous drift tubes , but do nt change their energy while crossing the tubes themselves .
on the basis of the previous estimates , we feel ready to propose the time varying sg interaction as a method for attaining a spin state separation of an unpolarized beam of , say ( anti)protons , since the energy of particles with opposite spin orientations will differ and beams in the two states can be separated . in a first stage of the study of a sensible practical design ,
we intend to proceed with numerical simulations . as a first step ,
we intend to verify the correctness of eqs.([du - tot ] ) and ( [ beta - beta ] ) setting once @xmath66 and then @xmath67 , in a cavity where the field line pattern can be realistically controlled . beyond the verification of the present theory ,
there is also the aim of studying the effects generated by the spin precession inside the cavity , that we did not yet address in this note .
next , we shall consider a spin splitter scheme based on the lattice of an existing or planned ( anti)proton ring endowed with an array of splitting cavities .
the principal aim of the latter implementations is to check the mixing effect@xcite@xcite of the longitudinal phase - plane filamentation , i.e. the actual foe which could frustrate the entire spin splitting process .
first , we want to thank waldo mackay , who has participated on so many discussions on the whole idea but who was regrettably prevented by numerous commitments from participate to the editing of the present note .
we thank renzo parodi for his help for us to better understand the subtleties of the standing waves building up .
thanks are also due to chris tschalaer for fruitful discussions on the role of the fringe fields .
m. conte , m. ferro , g. gemme , w.w .
mackay , r. parodi , m. pusterla : the stern - gerlach interaction between a traveling particle and a time varying magnetic field , infn / tc-00/03 , 22 marzo 2000 .
( http : xxx.lanl.gov / listphysics/0003 , preprint 0003069 ) p. cameron , m. conte , a. luccio , w.w .
mackay , m. palazzi and m. pusterla : the relativistic stern - gerlach interaction and quantum mechanics implications , proceedings of the spin2002 symposium , 9 - 14 september 2002 , brookhaven , eds .
makdisi , a.u .
luccio and w.w .
mackay , aip conference proceedings 675 ( 2003 ) p. 786 .
j.d.jackson , _ classical elecrodynamics _ , john wiley & sons inc .
, new york 1975 r.p .
feynman , _ quantum electrodynamics _
benjamin inc .
, new york 1961 .
s. ramo , j.r .
whinnery and t. van duzer , _ fields and waves in communication electronics _ , john wiley and & sons , new york , 1965 .
m.conte,a.u.luccio,w.w.mackay and m.pusterla _ stern gerlach force on a precessing magnetic moment _ proc .
pac07 , albuquerque , nm ( 2007 ) , p.3729 m. conte , w.w .
mackay and r. parodi : an overview of the longitudinal stern - gerlach effect , bnl-52541 , uc-414 , november 17 1997 .
m. palazzi : ph.d thesis , genoa university , june 6 2003 .
|
the general expression of the stern - gerlach force is deduced for a relativistic charged spin-@xmath0 particle which travels inside a time varying magnetic field .
this result was obtained either by means of two lorentz boosts or starting from dirac s equation .
then , the utilization of this interaction for attaining the spin states separation is reconsidered in a new example using a new radio - frequency arrangement .
|
excitons in semiconductors have been the subject of many experimental and theoretical investigations of bose condensation .
low - energy exciton - exciton interactions are characterized by the exciton - exciton scattering length , @xmath5 , which determines the thermodynamics of a low density gas and is crucial for modeling the thermalization time of a dilute exciton gas . despite its importance
, the exciton - exciton scattering length is an elusive quantity , being difficult to measure experimentally or to estimate theoretically .
as is well - known in atomic physics , scattering lengths can be extremely sensitive to the details of the interactions between particles .
in particular , the existence of a weakly bound or nearly bound state causes the scatter length to become quite large .
therefore , _ a priori _ one should suspect that exciton - exciton scattering may be a very material dependent property of semiconductors .
reliable theoretical predictions of exciton - exciton scatting lengths require both a very accurate hamiltonian for the semiconductor , and an accurate solution to the ( four - particle ) scattering problem . in this paper
we provide an essentially exact solution to exciton - exciton scattering for a commonly used single - band effective mass hamiltonian .
this solution allows us to study three important questions : ( 1 ) how sensitive is the scattering length to the mass ratio @xmath6 , ( 2 ) how does the scattering length depend on spin states ( singlet or triplet ) of the scattering excitons , and ( 3 ) to what degree can inter - exciton exchange of electrons or holes cause excitons to scatter into different spin states ?
this calculations also serve as a benchmark for the single band limit of more complicated scattering hamiltonians . one experimental method for measuring the exciton scattering cross section is to look at line width broadening of the recombination spectra in a gas of excitons
. collisions between excitons increase the line width , causing the line width to depend on the exciton - exciton scattering rate , @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the density and @xmath9 is a typical exciton velocity .
extracting cross sections from a line width requires that ( 1 ) the density and velocity distribution are known , and ( 2 ) elastic scattering is the fastest process . as discussed below , @xmath10 is a good material for comparison to the model studied in this work .
et al._@xcite have performed such experiments on @xmath10 and have found a line width broadening that suggests an upper bound of @xmath11 on the scattering length .
although our simulations do not exactly model @xmath10 , we will compare our results to this value .
theoretical approaches to this problem start with the effective mass approximation , in which the system under consideration consists of two electrons , labeled @xmath12 and @xmath13 , and two holes , labeled @xmath14 and @xmath15 .
the hamiltonian is @xmath16 where @xmath17 . the hamiltonian has symmetry under exchange of electrons and exchange of holes , so eigenstates may be denoted by two exchange quantum numbers .
the s - wave states are symmetric under exchange of excitons ; a condition which is satisfied by states @xmath18 and @xmath19 , where the @xmath20 signs refer to ( anti)symmetry under exchange of electrons and holes , respectively .
although this hamiltonian is a well - accepted model for exciton - exciton scattering , we should point out a few of its deficiencies . for small excitons , such as those in @xmath10 , that have radii not much larger than the lattice spacing , non - parabolic terms in the kinetic energy and other corrections to the potential energy may be necessary . for many semiconductors , such as si and ge ,
the valence band is a mixture of three bands and can not be described by a single parabolic band . in the case of @xmath10 ,
the valence band is the parabolic spin - orbit split off band , and there are fewer complications .
interband exchange ( virtual electron - hole recombination ) is an important effect that has been neglected , and could be modeled by an additional spin - dependent potential term .
this hamiltonian also describes a family of scattering processes for other particles , including hydrogen - hydrogen , positronium - positronium , and muonium - muonium scattering .
the equal mass case is at an extreme ( positronium scattering ) , where the born - oppenheimer approximation is the least applicable .
there have been several theoretical estimates of exciton - exciton scattering for bulk systems@xcite and quantum wells@xcite as well as calculations on biexciton - biexciton scattering,@xcite only the bulk , elastic scattering calculations@xcite are directly comparable to the results of this paper , but the techniques presented here could be generalized to the other scattering problems .
also , the results presented here provide a benchmark for evaluating the approximations used in other theoretical treatments , and could lend insight into the reliability of the approximations in more complicated situations .
one standard theoretical approach is diagrammatic perturbation theory , as presented in the work of keldysh and kolsov@xcite and haug and hanamura.@xcite they estimate the exciton - exciton scattering matrix as arising from a single term , @xmath21 , where @xmath22 represents a state of two noninteracting excitons with momentum @xmath23 and @xmath24 and @xmath25 is the inter - exciton coulomb interaction .
this method gives an estimate of @xmath26 ( independent of the mass ratio ) , where @xmath27 is the exciton radius , but it is an uncontrolled approximation which may have limited validity in the low energy limit
. one serious drawback of the method is that it does not include effects of the biexciton in the scattering .
as we show later , biexciton vibrational states cause strong dependence of the scattering length on the mass ratio @xmath6 , which is not captured by the low order perturbation theory .
a second common approach was developed by elkomoss and munchy,@xcite and uses an effective exciton - exciton potential defined by @xmath28 , where @xmath29 is the wavefunction for two free excitons a distance @xmath30 apart .
the effective potential @xmath31 arises from the hartree term and is used in a two - particle central - field calculation .
while an exciton - exciton scattering pseudo - potential would be a very useful tool , this approximate form has some serious drawbacks . among its deficiencies
are a lack of correlation , no van der waals attraction , a failure to reproduce biexciton states , and a vanishing interaction potential for @xmath32 .
the cross sections calculated by this method are small and lack qualitative agreement with the results of the present work .
some insight into exciton - exciton scattering can be gained by considering the bound states , biexcitons . since the number of bound states , @xmath33 , enters in the phase shift at zero energy , @xmath34 , it is necessary that a good computation method for low energy scattering be able accurately calculate biexciton binding energies.@xcite for the mass ratios considered ( and far beyond , including deuterium ) the biexcitons can not bind in the @xmath19 states , so biexcitons in rotational @xmath35 states always have @xmath18 wavefunctions .
detailed theoretical descriptions of biexcitons can be found in ref .
the equal mass case was shown to have a bound biexciton by hyllerass and ore using a variational argument,@xcite and a better variational estimate of the binding energy was given by brinkman , rice and bell,@xcite who found @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is the exciton binding energy . however , because of the importance of correlation energy , the latter variational treatment was missing _
half _ of the biexciton binding energy , as shown by diffusion monte carlo ( dmc ) calculations,@xcite which find @xmath38 .
dmc is a quantum monte carlo ( qmc ) method that uses a random walk to project out the ground state wavefunction from a variational wavefunction , in order to stochastically sample the exact ground state energy .
the success of dmc for calculating biexciton energies has been a motivation for its use in the present scattering calculations .
the @xmath30-matrix approach to scattering is to examine the standing waves of the system .
as shown by carlson , pandharipande , and wiringa@xcite and alhassid and koonin,@xcite by fixing nodes in the standing waves the scattering problem may be cast as a stationary state problem suitable for qmc methods . for an elastic scattering process
, we label the distance between the products by @xmath30 , and the reduced mass of the products by @xmath39 . in exciton - exciton scattering
there is a subtlety in the definition of r due to inter - exciton exchange , which we will address below in our discussion of the exciton - exciton scattering wavefunctions . nonetheless , for large separation @xmath30
, the relative motion of the products is free - particle like , so the many - body wavefunction depends on @xmath30 as @xmath40 , \label{asymptoticform}\ ] ] where @xmath41 is the relative angular momentum , @xmath42 is the scattering momentum , and @xmath43 is the phase shift . if we constrain the wavefunction to have a node at a large exciton separation @xmath44 , we find a discrete energy spectrum @xmath45 , which may be computed by ground state or excited state methods , such as dmc .
each choice of @xmath44 gives a spectrum of states @xmath46 , with energies @xmath47 that determine values of @xmath43 , @xmath48 where @xmath49 .
the scattering matrix elements are determined by the phase shifts , @xmath50 - 1.\ ] ] carlson has also proposed fixing the logarithmic derivative of the wavefunction at the boundary instead of setting wavefunction to zero , @xcite @xmath51 were @xmath52 is the normal to the boundary surface , at a fixed radius @xmath53 , and @xmath54 parameterizes the boundary condition .
this formulation has the advantage of separating the choice of simulation size @xmath53 ( subject to @xmath53 lying in the asymptotic region ) , from the sampling of energy , which is handled by varying @xmath54 , and is particularly well suited for finding the scattering length .
the application to vmc calculations is straight - forward , but preserving the boundary condition in dmc calculations requires a method of images .
@xcite the results presented here do not use the logarithmic - derivative boundary condition .
the use of excited states @xmath55 is necessary when there is a bound state and , more generally , when the scattering state being studied has its first node before the asymptotic region is reached .
we use a qmc method to calculate excited states developed by ceperley and bernu,@xcite to adapt vmc and dmc methods for a hilbert space of several low energy wavefunctions .
a set of @xmath56 trial wavefunctions is chosen , @xmath57 . the generalized eigenvalue equation to be solved is,@xcite @xmath58d_{k\beta}(t)=0 , \label{eq : eigen}\ ] ] where @xmath59 is the @xmath60 eigenvector with eigenvalue @xmath61 and the matrices @xmath62 and @xmath63 are the overlap and hamiltonian matrices in our trial basis , given by @xmath64 the parameter
@xmath65 is the projection time .
the eigenvalues @xmath61 are energy eigenvalues @xmath66 within the hilbert space spanned by the projected trial functions @xmath67 , and approach the exact energy eigenvalues in the limit of large @xmath65 .
the matrices @xmath62 and @xmath63 are sampled with random walks , using a guiding function @xmath68 which must be positive everywhere .
the guiding function must have significant overlap with all basis functions , and should be optimized to decrease the variance of the sampled matrices . at each step
@xmath69 in the random walk , the coordinates @xmath70 of the particles are updated using @xmath71 where @xmath72 is a normally distributed random variate with zero mean and unit variance and @xmath73 is the time step . in the limit of small
@xmath73 , eq . ( [ scat_step_eq ] ) describes a process for sampling @xmath74 .
the matrix element of @xmath75 is estimated by integrating the local energy of the guiding function , @xmath76 , along the random walk , @xmath77}.\ ] ] the estimators for matrices @xmath62 and @xmath63 are @xmath78 where @xmath79 and @xmath80 are the local energies of the trial basis states . , at large exciton - exciton separation .
the asymptotic form of the @xmath81-wave scattering states are symmetric ( @xmath18 ) or antisymmetric ( @xmath19 ) combinations of these configurations .
this symmetric / antisymmetric form is used for the trial wavefunctions @xmath82 and @xmath83 , using @xmath84 and @xmath85 from eq .
( [ trial_ex_scat_psi_eq ] ) . ]
we now discuss the form for the exciton scattering functions @xmath86 and @xmath87 . as mentioned before
, inter - exciton exchange of particles complicates the definition of exciton - exciton separation .
there are two configurations for well - separated excitons , as shown in fig .
[ configfig ] .
configuration i has the electrons and hole paired as @xmath88 , @xmath89 ; and configuration ii as @xmath90 , @xmath91 .
we choose wavefunctions @xmath92 and @xmath93 to represent these states , @xmath94 where @xmath95 , and parameters in the function @xmath96 are variational .
these wavefunctions represent two excitons in a relative s - wave state .
since these are not eigenstates of the exchange operator for electrons @xmath97 or holes , @xmath98 , we take linear combinations of the two for our trial wavefunctions , @xmath99 and @xmath100 . for large separation of excitons ,
the exponential factors prohibit both configurations from simultaneously contributing to the wavefunction .
thus , a node can be approximated in the scattering wavefunction by simply requiring that @xmath101 be zero for all @xmath102 .
the error introduced by this approximation is of order @xmath103 , and is another limit on the use of small values for @xmath44 .
since we only do calculations for low energy scattering , large @xmath44 , the lack of a well - defined exciton - exciton separation distance for short distances does not matter . of the dmc states relative to the vmc states as a function of dmc projection time @xmath65 ,
for basis states @xmath104 .
the eigenvalue equation is given by eqs .
( [ eq : eigen])([eq : hmat ] ) , where the hamiltonian and overlap matrices have been sampled using eqs .
( [ eq : overlapest ] ) and ( [ eq : hmatest ] ) . ]
this method for calculating scattering properties is very sensitive to the energy spectra @xmath105 . to get accurate energies ,
we do not try to construct and optimize elaborate variational wavefunctions , but rather use dmc to project the energy from trial wavefunctions of the form given in eq .
( [ trial_ex_scat_psi_eq ] ) .
the coefficients @xmath106 , @xmath107 , @xmath108 , and @xmath109 are chosen to obey the cusp conditions on the wavefunction for small particle separations .
the s - wave envelope functions @xmath101 are taken as solutions to an empirical exciton - exciton scattering potentials , @xmath110 where @xmath111 and @xmath112 have been self - consistently fit to approximate the energy spectrum of the four particle scattering states .
we take the guiding function @xmath68 to have the same form as the @xmath82 wavefunctions with @xmath113^{1/2}$ ] .
the parameters @xmath114 are chosen to bias sampling towards the collision : @xmath115 for @xmath18 states and @xmath116 for @xmath19 states to check for convergence of the energies in dmc , we plot the energy difference , @xmath117 , as a function of projection time in fig .
[ evstfig ] .
we see convergence after a projection time of 3 @xmath118 . , for ( a ) symmetric @xmath18 states , and ( b ) antisymmetric @xmath19 states , with @xmath119 . the lowest energy curve in ( a ) is the biexciton with binding energy @xmath120 . these functions @xmath121 determine the phase shifts @xmath122 and @xmath123 , by the relationship in eq .
( [ kfrome ] ) . ]
we thus find two energy spectra for each value of @xmath44 , as shown in figs .
[ evsrnfig](a ) and [ evsrnfig](b ) .
the spectra for the symmetric states @xmath18 , show a clearly bound biexciton state , as seen in fig .
[ evsrnfig](a ) .
the antisymmetric states @xmath19 , as shown in fig .
[ evsrnfig](b ) , have no bound state .
the binding energy of the biexciton is @xmath124 , in agreement with other ground state calculations , and is insensitive to the position of the node @xmath125 because it is localized .
in contrast , the delocalized scattering states are quite sensitive to @xmath125 , and their dependence on @xmath125 is a measure of the elastic scattering matrix elements . for the two @xmath35-wave scattering states , for @xmath119 , calculate using eq .
( [ kfrome ] ) and the data from fig .
[ evsrnfig ] . ]
.coefficients for polynomomial fit to the low energy part of the phase shift functions for the case @xmath119 . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ scattab ] the collision of two excitons with well defined initial and final spin states can be determined by decomposing the scattering events into the two channels , @xmath126 and @xmath127 . using the change of basis matrix ( table [ spbasistab ] ) , we find @xmath128 , where the coefficients @xmath129 and @xmath130 for all non - zero s - wave scattering processes are given in table [ scattab ] .
the s - wave scattering cross sections are given by @xmath131 , where there is a factor of two enhancement due to the identical particle statistics .
the spin - dependent cross sections take the form , @xmath132 , \label{eq : cs}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath133 , @xmath134 , and @xmath135 depend on the initial and final spin states and are tabulated in table [ scattab ] .
the scattering lengths @xmath5 are given by @xmath136 , where the derivatives of the phase shifts are determined from the linear coefficients in table [ phasecoeftab ] . ) , for exciton - exciton scattering with @xmath119 , for the processes : ( a ) singlet - singlet @xmath137 singlet - singlet , ( b ) triplet - triplet @xmath137 triplet - triplet for total spin @xmath138 ( dashed line ) and @xmath139 ( solid line ) , ( c ) triplet - singlet @xmath137 triplet - singlet with @xmath140 , and ( d ) triplet - triplet @xmath137 singlet - singlet and singlet - singlet @xmath137 triplet - triplet , both with @xmath140 . ]
the calculated spin - dependent scattering lengths for the case @xmath119 are presented in the last column of table [ scattab ] .
these are the low - energy limit the cross - sections shown in fig .
[ cs1fig ] . in fig .
[ cs1fig ] we have plotted the s - wave scattering cross sections versus scattering momentum for the case @xmath119 and all non - zero spin configurations . fig .
[ cs1fig](a ) shows scattering of two singlet - excitons .
scattering of two triplet - excitons is shown in fig .
[ cs1fig](b ) , where the solid line represents the spin aligned @xmath141 state , and the dashed line represents the @xmath142 state .
the @xmath142 state scatters particularly strong because it has a large contribution from the @xmath143 channel , which is enhanced by the weakly bound biexciton .
triplet - excitons in a relative @xmath144 state are spatially antisymmetric and thus have no s - wave scattering .
we show s - wave scattering of triplet - excitons from singlet - excitons in fig .
[ cs1fig](c ) .
this state has two distinguishable excitons , and can scatter by both s - wave and p - wave processes . as can be seen in table [ scattab ] , the only contribution to the cross section is from the weaker @xmath145 channel .
the coefficient for s - wave scattering is particularly small because only half the scattering process is symmetric ( s - wave ) , and there is an additional factor of one - half which cancels the identical particle factor .
there is also an triplet- to singlet - exciton conversion cross section given in fig .
[ cs1fig](d ) .
although this is an inelastic process in experimental situations , it conserves energy according to our model hamiltonian because we do not have an explicit interband spin coupling .
the conversion of two triplet - excitons to two singlet - excitons can be understood as an inter - exciton exchange of a pair of electrons ( or holes ) .
since the spins of the individual excitons do not correspond to symmetries of the hamiltonian , they need not remain constant during scattering .
this conversion process is a physical consequence of the two inequivalent scattering channels @xmath143 and @xmath145 .
this effect has been reported in experimental@xcite and theoretical@xcite work on exciton scattering in quantum wells . and @xmath146 as a function of the electron - hole mass ratio .
the divergence in @xmath147 near @xmath148 is due to the appearance of second bound biexciton state .
solid lines are a guide to the eye . ] the dependence of the cross sections on mass may be numerically studied by our methods . in fig .
[ avmfig ] we show our calculated @xmath147 and @xmath146 as a function of mass ratio , @xmath149 .
we find that the scattering length is remarkably insensitive to the mass ratio for @xmath150 ( corresponding to a wide range of semiconductors ) , but then diverges near @xmath151 .
this feature is lost in previously published theoretical treatments of exciton - exciton scattering .
the divergence in @xmath147 near @xmath148 is due to the acquisition of a biexciton vibrational state . for @xmath119
the biexciton has no bound excited states , while a @xmath152 molecule has 15 bound vibrational states .
our calculations have shown the first of these appears near @xmath148 , with dramatic effects on the scattering length .
the @xmath146 curve is relatively featureless because there are are no bound antisymmetric states in this range .
we interpret the upward drift of @xmath146 for larger mass ratios as a systematic error due to difficulties in projecting states in excitonic systems with very different electron and hole masses .
the heavy particle determines the projection time @xmath153 while the light particle determines the diffusion time step @xmath73 .
the difficulty in handling large mass ratios make the method ( as presented here ) complementary to calculations that use the born - oppenheimer approximation .
it is important to realize that similar relationships must exist between the scattering length and other material parameters , such as the luttinger - kohn parameters describing realistic hole states , external strain , and spin - orbit coupling , to name a few .
theoretical studies of such effects will need similar high - accuracy scattering calculations , but applied to more accurate hamiltonians , and are an area for future research .
to summarize , we have shown that there are several significant elastic scattering processes for excitons , and have given numerically exact values for a widely used theoretical model .
we find strong triplet - triplet and singlet - singlet scattering , with weaker triplet - singlet scattering and triplet - triplet to singlet - singlet conversion processes .
scattering is relatively insensitive to the mass ratio for @xmath154 , but becomes very sensitive and actually diverges near @xmath155 .
dmc has been found be a good tool for this four - particle excited state calculation , since the detection of weakly bound states requires very accurate evaluation of the correlation energy .
this computational approach should be extended in many ways .
the extension to higher angular momentum states would give important corrections at higher scattering energies .
application to biexciton - biexciton scattering are possible , but would be a bit more difficult because the scattering wavefunction would then have to describe eight interacting particles .
most importantly , the method should be adapted to better hamiltonians so that the sensitivity of the scattering length to material properties for a wide range of materials can be studied .
this approach should be quite useful for quantum well problems , which have similarities to the bulk problem study here , but have many more experimental parameters that can affect exciton - exciton interaction .
we would like to thank k. ohara and j. carlson for useful discussions .
this work was supported by nsf grant no .
dmr 98 - 02373 , computer resources at ncsa , and the department of physics at the university of illinois urbana - champaign .
for example , the location of the scattering length divergence at @xmath156 , reported later in this article , is extremely sensitive to an accurate treatment of correlation energy , since it relies on the appearance of a second , weakly bound biexciton state at that mass ratio .
|
we calculate cross sections for low energy elastic exciton - exciton scattering within the effective mass approximation .
unlike previous theoretical approaches , we give a complete , non - perturbative treatment of the four - particle scattering problem .
diffusion monte carlo is used to calculate the essentially exact energies of scattering states , from which phase shifts are determined . for the case of equal - mass electrons and holes , which is equivalent to positronium - positronium scattering ,
we find @xmath0 for scattering of singlet - excitons and @xmath1 for triplet - excitons , where @xmath2 is the excitonic radius .
the spin dependence of the cross sections arises from the spatial exchange symmetry of the scattering wavefunctions . a significant triplet - triplet to singlet - singlet scattering process is found , which is similar to reported effects in recent experiments and theory for excitons in quantum wells .
we also show that the scattering length can change sign and diverge for some values of the mass ratio @xmath3/@xmath4 , an effect not seen in previous perturbative treatments .
|
inflation generically predicts a primordial spectrum of density perturbations which is almost precisely gaussian @xcite . in recent years
the small non - gaussian component @xcite has emerged as an important observable @xcite , and will be measured with good precision by the _
planck surveyor _ satellite @xcite . in the near future ,
as observational data become more plentiful , it will be important to understand the non - gaussian signal expected in a wide variety of models , and to anticipate what conclusions can be drawn about early - universe physics from a prospective detection of primordial non - gaussianity . in this paper
, we present a novel method for calculating the primordial non - gaussianity produced by super - horizon evolution in two - field models of inflation .
our method is based on the real - space distribution of inflationary field values on a flat hypersurface , which can be thought of as a probability density function whose evolution is determined by a form of the collisionless boltzmann equation . using a cumulant representation @xcite to expand our density function around an exact gaussian
, we derive ordinary differential equations which evolve the moments of this distribution .
further , we show how these moments are related to observable quantities , such as the dimensionless bispectrum measured by @xmath1 @xcite .
we present numerical results which show that this method gives good agreement with other techniques .
it is not necessary to make any assumptions about the inflationary model beyond requiring a canonical kinetic term and applying the slow - roll approximation .
while there are already numerous methods for computing the super - horizon contribution to @xmath1 , including the widely used @xmath0 formalism , we believe the one reported here has a number of advantages .
first , this new technique is ideally suited to unraveling the various contributions to @xmath1 .
this is because we follow the moments of the inflaton distribution directly , which makes it straightforward to identify large contributions to the skewness or other moments .
the evolution equation for each moment is simple and possesses clearly identifiable source terms , which are related to the properties of the inflationary flow on field space .
this offers a clear separation between two key sources of primordial non - gaussianity .
one of these is the intrinsic non - linearity associated with evolution of the probability density function between successive flat hypersurfaces ; the other is a gauge transformation from field fluctuations to the curvature peturbation , @xmath2 .
it would be difficult or impossible to observe this split within the context of other calculational schemes , such as the conventional @xmath0 formalism .
a second advantage of our method is connected with the computational cost of numerical implementation .
analytic formulas for @xmath1 are known in certain cases , mostly in the context of the @xmath0 framework , but only for very specific choices of the potential @xcite or hubble rate @xcite .
these formulas become increasingly cumbersome as the number of fields increases , or if one studies higher moments @xcite . in the future , it seems clear that studies of complex models with many fields will increasingly rely on numerical methods .
the numerical @xmath0 framework requires the solution to a number of ordinary differential equations which scales exponentially with the number of fields .
since some models include hundreds of fields , this may present a significant obstacle @xcite .
moreover , the @xmath0 formalism depends crucially on a numerical integration algorithm with low noise properties , since finite differences must be extracted between perturbatively different initial conditions after @xmath3 e - folds of evolution .
thus , the background equations must be solved to great accuracy , since any small error has considerable scope to propagate . in this paper
we ultimately solve our equations numerically to determine the evolution of moments in specific models .
our method requires the solution to a number of differential equations which scales at most polynomially ( or in certain cases perhaps even linearly ) with the number of fields .
it does not rely on extracting finite differences , and therefore is much less susceptible to numerical noise .
these advantages may be shared with other schemes , such as the numerical method recently employed by lehners & renaux - petel @xcite .
a third advantage , to which we hope to return in a future publication , is that our formalism yields explicit evolution equations with source terms . from an analysis of these source terms , we hope that it will be possible to identify those physical features of specific models which lead to the production of large non - gaussianities .
this paper is organized as follows . in [ sec : computing_fnl ] , we show how the non - gaussian parameter @xmath1 can be computed in our framework .
the calculation remains in real space throughout ( as opposed to fourier space ) , which modifies the relationship between @xmath1 and the multi - point functions of the inflaton field .
our expression for @xmath1 shows a clean separation between different contributions to non - gaussianity , especially between the intrinsic nonlinearity of the field evolution and the gauge transformation between comoving and flat hypersurfaces . in [ sec : transport ] , we introduce our model for the distribution of inflaton field values , which is a moment expansion " around a purely gaussian distribution .
we derive the equations which govern the evolution of the moments of this distribution in the one- and two - field cases . in [ sec : numerics ] , we present a comparison of our new technique and those already in the literature . we compute @xmath1 numerically in several two - field models , and find excellent agreement between techniques .
we conclude in [ s : conclusions ] . throughout this paper
, we use units in which @xmath4 , and the reduced planck mass @xmath5 is set to unity .
in this section , we introduce our new method for computing the non - gaussianity parameter @xmath1 .
this method requires three main ingredients : a formula for the curvature perturbation , @xmath2 , in terms of the field values on a spatially flat hypersurface ; expressions for the derivatives of the number of e - foldings , @xmath6 , as a function of field values at horizon exit ; and a prescription for evolving the field distribution from horizon exit to the time when we require the statistical properties of @xmath2 .
the first two ingredients are given in eqs .
and , found at the end of [ ss : sep_universe ] and [ sec : derivative - n ] respectively .
the final ingredient is discussed in [ sec : transport ] . once it became clear that non - linearities of the microwave background anisotropies could be detected by the wmap and _ planck _ survey satellites @xcite , many authors studied higher - order correlations of the curvature perturbation . in early work , direct calculations of a correlation function were matched to the known limit of local non - gaussianity @xcite .
this method works well if isocurvature modes are absent , so that the curvature perturbation is constant after horizon exit . in the more realistic situation that isocurvature modes cause evolution on superhorizon scales , all correlation functions become time dependent .
various formalisms have been employed to describe this evolution .
lyth & rodrguez @xcite extended the @xmath0 method @xcite beyond linear order .
this method is simple and well - suited to analytical calculation .
rigopoulos , shellard and van tent @xcite worked with a gradient expansion , rewriting the field equations in langevin form .
the noise term was used as a proxy for setting initial conditions at horizon crossing .
a similar ` exact ' gradient formalism was written down by langlois & vernizzi @xcite . in its perturbative form
, this approach has been used by lehners & renaux - petel to obtain numerical results @xcite .
another numerical scheme has been introduced by huston & malik @xcite .
what properties do we require of a successful prediction ? consider a typical observer , drawn at random from an ensemble of realizations of inflation . in any of the formalisms
discussed above , we aim to estimate the statistical properties of the curvature perturbation which would be measured by such an observer .
some realizations may yield statistical properties which are quite different from the ensemble average , but these large excursions are uninteresting unless anthropic arguments are in play .
next we introduce a collection of comparably - sized spacetime volumes whose mutual scatter is destined to dominate the microwave background anisotropy on a given scale .
neglecting spatial gradients , each spacetime volume will follow a trajectory in field space which is slightly displaced from its neighbors .
the scatter between trajectories is determined by initial conditions set at horizon exit , which are determined by promoting the vacuum fluctuation to a classical perturbation .
a correct prediction is a function of the trajectories followed by every volume in the collection , taken as a whole .
one never makes a prediction for a single trajectory .
each spacetime volume follows a trajectory , which we label with its position @xmath7 at some fixed time , to be made precise below . throughout this paper ,
superscript ` @xmath8 ' denotes evaluation on a spatially flat hypersurface .
consider the evolution of some quantity of interest , @xmath9 , which is a function of trajectory .
if we know the distribution @xmath10 we can study statistical properties of @xmath9 such as the @xmath11 moment @xmath12 , @xmath13^m , \ ] ] where we have introduced the ensemble average of @xmath9 , @xmath14 in eqs . , @xmath7 stands for a collection of any number of fields .
it is the @xmath12 which are observable quantities .
. defines what we will call the exact separate universe picture .
it is often convenient to expand @xmath15 as a power series in the field values centered on a fiducial trajectory , labelled ` fid , ' @xmath16 when eq .
is used to evaluate the @xmath12 , we refer to the ` perturbative ' separate universe picture .
if all terms in the power series are retained , these two versions of the calculation are formally equivalent . in unfavorable cases , however , convergence may occur slowly or not at all .
this possibility was discussed in refs .
although our calculation is formally perturbative , it is not directly equivalent to eq . .
we briefly discuss the relation of our calculation to conventional perturbation theory in
[ s : conclusions ] . by definition , the curvature perturbation @xmath2 measures local fluctuations in expansion history ( expressed in e - folds @xmath6 ) , calculated on a comoving hypersurface . in many models , the curvature perturbation is synthesized by superhorizon physics , which reprocesses a set of gaussian fluctuations generated at horizon exit . in a single - field model
, only one gaussian fluctuation can be present , which we label @xmath17 . neglecting spatial gradients , the total curvature perturbation
must then be a function of @xmath17 alone . for @xmath18
, this can be well - approximated by @xmath19 where @xmath1 is independent of spatial position .
defines the so - called `` local '' form of non - gaussianity .
it applies only when quantum interference effects can be neglected , making @xmath2 a well - defined object rather than a superposition of operators @xcite .
if this condition is satisfied , spatial correlations of @xmath2 may be extracted and it follows that @xmath1 can be estimated using the rule @xmath20 where we have recalled that @xmath2 is nearly gaussian , or equivalently that @xmath21 . with @xmath1 spatially independent , eq . strictly applies only in single - field inflation . in this case
one can accurately determine @xmath1 by applying eq . to a single trajectory with fixed initial conditions , as in the method of lehners & renaux - petel @xcite .
where more than one field is present , @xmath1 may vary in space because it depends on the isocurvature modes . in this case
one must determine @xmath1 statistically on a bundle of adjacent trajectories which sample the local distribution of isocurvature modes .
is then indispensible .
following maldacena @xcite , and later lyth & rodrguez @xcite , we adopt eq . as our definition of @xmath1 , whatever its origin . in real space , the coefficient @xmath22 in eq .
depends on the convention @xmath23 .
more generally , this follows from the definition of @xmath12 , eq . .
in fourier space , either prescription is automatically enforced after dropping disconnected contributions , again leading to eq . . to proceed , we require estimates of the correlation functions @xmath24 and @xmath25 .
we first describe the conventional approach , in which ` @xmath8 ' denotes a flat hypersurface at a fixed initial time .
the quantity @xmath26 denotes the number of e - foldings between this initial slice and a final comoving hypersurface , where @xmath27 indexes the species of light scalar fields .
the local variation in expansion can be written in the fiducial picture as @xmath28 where @xmath29 .
subject to the condition that the relevant scales are all outside the horizon , we are free to choose the initial time set by the hypersurface ` @xmath8'at our convenience . in the conventional approach , ` @xmath8 ' is taken to lie a few e - folds after our collection of spacetime volumes passes outside the causal horizon @xcite .
this choice has many virtues .
first , we need to know statistical properties of the field fluctuations @xmath30 only around the time of horizon crossing , where they can be computed without the appearance of large logarithms @xcite .
second , as a consequence of the slow - roll approximation , the @xmath31 are uncorrelated at this time , leading to algebraic simplifications .
finally , the @xmath0 formula subsumes a gauge transformation from the field variables @xmath30 to the observational variable @xmath2 . using eqs . , and
, one finds that @xmath1 can be written to a good approximation @xcite @xmath32 where @xmath33 and for simplicity we have dropped the ` @xmath8 ' which indicates time of evaluation .
a similar definition applies for @xmath34 .
. is accurate up to small intrinsic non - gaussianities present in the field fluctuations at horizon exit . as a means of predicting @xmath1
it is pleasingly compact , and straightforward to evaluate in many models .
unfortunately , it also obscures the physics which determines @xmath35 . for this reason it is hard to infer , from eq . alone , those classes of models in which @xmath35 is always large or small .
is dynamically allowed .
see , for example , refs .
@xcite . ]
our strategy is quite different .
we choose ` @xmath8 ' to lie around the time when we require the statistical properties of @xmath2 .
the role of the @xmath0 formula , eq . , is then to encode _ only _ the gauge transformation between the @xmath36 and @xmath2 . in
[ sec : derivative - n ] below , we show how the appropriate gauge transformation is computed using the @xmath0 formula . in the present section
we restrict our attention to determining a formula for @xmath1 under the assumption that the distribution of field values on ` @xmath8 ' is known . in [ sec : transport ] , we will supply the required prescription to evolve the distribution of field values between horizon exit and ` @xmath8 ' .
although the @xmath31 are independent random variables at horizon exit , correlations can be induced by subsequent evolution .
one must therefore allow for off - diagonal terms in the two - point function .
remembering that we are working with a collection of spacetime volumes in real space , smoothed on some characteristic scale , we write @xmath37 @xmath38 does not vary in space , but it may be a function of the scale which characterizes our ensemble of spacetime volumes . in all but the simplest models it will vary in time .
it is also necessary to account for intrinsic non - linearities among the @xmath31 , which are small at horizon crossing but may grow . we define @xmath39 likewise , @xmath40 should be regarded as a function of time and scale .
the permutation symmetries of an expectation value such as guarantee that , for example , @xmath41 .
when written explicitly , we place the indices of symbols such as @xmath42 in numerical order . neglecting a small ( @xmath43 ) intrinsic four - point correlation , it follows that @xmath44 now we specialize to a two - field model , parametrized by fields @xmath45 and @xmath46 . using eqs .
, and , it follows that the two - point function of @xmath2 satisfies @xmath47 the three - point function can be written @xmath48 where we have identified two separate contributions , labelled ` 1 ' and ` 2 ' .
the ` 1 ' term includes all contributions involving _ intrinsic _ non - linearities , those which arise from non - gaussian correlations among the field fluctuations , @xmath49 the ` 2 ' term encodes non - linearities arising directly from the gauge transformation to @xmath2 @xmath50 after use of eq . ,
can be used to extract the non - linearity parameter @xmath1 .
this decomposes likewise into two contributions @xmath51 , which we shall discuss in more detail in
[ sec : numerics ] . to compute @xmath1 in concrete models ,
we require expressions for the derivatives @xmath52 and @xmath34 . for generic initial and final times , these are difficult to obtain .
lyth & rodrguez @xcite used direct integration , which is effective for quadratic potentials and constant slow - roll parameters .
vernizzi & wands @xcite obtained expressions in a two - field model with an arbitrary sum - separable potential by introducing gaussian normal coordinates on the space of trajectories .
their approach was generalized to many fields by battefeld & easther @xcite .
product - separable potentials can be accommodated using the same technique @xcite .
an alternative technique has been proposed by yokoyama _
_ @xcite .
a considerable simplification occurs in the present case , because we only require the derivative evaluated between flat and comoving hypersurfaces which coincide in the unperturbed universe . for any species @xmath27 , and
to leading order in the slow - roll approximation , the number of e - folds @xmath6 between the flat hypersurface ` @xmath8 ' and a comoving hypersurface ` @xmath53 ' satisfies @xmath54 where @xmath55 and @xmath56 are the field values evaluated on ` @xmath8 ' and ` @xmath53 , ' respectively . under an infinitesimal shift of @xmath57
, we deduce that @xmath52 obeys @xmath58 note that this applies for an arbitrary @xmath59 , which need not factorize into a sum or product of potentials for the individual species @xmath27 . in principle a contribution from variation of the integrand is present , which spoils a nave attempt to generalize the method of refs .
@xcite to an arbitrary potential .
this contribution vanishes in virtue of our supposition that ` @xmath8 ' and ` @xmath53 ' are infinitesimally separated . to compute @xmath60 it is helpful to introduce a quantity @xmath61 , which in the sum - separable case coincides with the conserved quantity of vernizzi & wands @xcite . for our specific choice of a two - field model , this takes the form @xmath62 where the integrals are evaluated on a single spatial hypersurface . in an @xmath63-field model , one would obtain @xmath64 conserved quantities which label the isocurvature fields .
the construction of these quantities is discussed in refs .
@xcite . for sum - separable potentials one can show using the equations of motion that @xmath61 is conserved under time evolution to leading order in slow - roll .
it is not conserved for general potentials , but the variation can be neglected for infinitesimally separated hypersurfaces . under a change of trajectory ,
@xmath61 varies according to the rules @xmath65 and @xmath66 the comoving hypersurface ` @xmath53 ' is defined by @xmath67 we are assuming that the slow - roll approximation applies , so that the kinetic energy may be neglected in comparison with the potential @xmath59 .
therefore on ` @xmath53 ' we have @xmath68 combining eqs . , and we obtain expressions for @xmath60 , namely @xmath69 where we have defined @xmath70 eqs .
can alternatively be derived without use of @xmath61 by comparing eq . with the formulas of ref .
@xcite , which were derived using conventional perturbation theory .
applying , we obtain @xmath71 to proceed , we require the second derivatives of @xmath6 .
these can be obtained directly from , after use of eqs .
. we find @xmath72^\star \cos^2 \theta + 2 \left ( \frac{v}{v_{,1 } } \right)^{\star 2 } \cos^2 \theta \\
\hspace{-6 mm } \mbox { } \times \left [ \frac{v_{,11}}{v } \sin^2 \theta - \frac{v_{,1 } v_{,12}}{v v_{,2 } } \sin^4 \theta - \left ( \frac{v_{,11}}{v } - \frac{v_{,22}}{v } + \frac{v_{,2 } v_{,12}}{v v_{,1 } } \right ) \cos^2 \theta \sin^2 \theta \right]^c .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] an analogous expression for @xmath73 can be obtained after the simultaneous exchange @xmath74 .
the mixed derivative satisfies @xmath75^c \\ \hspace{-6 mm } \mbox { } + \cos^2 \theta \left ( \frac{v_{,2}}{v_{,1 } } - \frac{v v_{,12}}{v_{,1}^2 } \right)^c . \end{aligned}\ ] ] now that the calculation is complete , we can drop the superscripts ` @xmath8 ' and ` @xmath53 , ' since any background quantity is the same on either hypersurface .
once this is done it can be verified that ( despite appearances ) eq .
is invariant under the exchange @xmath76 .
in this section we return to the problem of evolution between horizon exit and the time of observation , and supply the prescription which connects the distribution of field values at these two times .
we begin by discussing the single - field system , which lacks the technical complexity of the two - field case , yet still exhibits certain interesting features which recur there . among these features
are the subtle difference between motion of the statistical mean and the background field value , and the hierarchy of moment evolution equations .
moreover , the structure of the moment mixing equations is similar to that which obtains in the two - field case .
for this reason , the one - field scenario provides an instructive example of the techniques we wish to employ .
recall that we work in real space with a collection of comparably sized spacetime volumes , each with a slightly different expansion history , and the scatter in these histories determines the microwave background anisotropy on a given angular scale . within each volume
the smoothed background field @xmath77 takes a uniform value described by a density function @xmath78 , where in this section we are dropping the superscript ` @xmath8 ' denoting evaluation of spatially flat hypersurfaces .
our ultimate goal is to calculate the reduced bispectrum , @xmath1 , which describes the third moment of @xmath78 . in the language of probability
this is the skewness , which we denote @xmath42 .
a gaussian distribution has skewness zero , and inflation usually predicts that the skew is small .
for this reason , rather than seek a distribution with non - zero third moment , as proposed in ref .
@xcite , we will introduce higher moments as perturbative corrections to the gaussian .
such a procedure is known as a _
cumulant expansion_. the construction of cumulant expansions is a classical problem in probability theory .
we seek a distribution with centroid @xmath79 , variance @xmath80 , and skew @xmath42 , with all higher moments determined by @xmath81 and @xmath42 alone .
a distribution with suitable properties is @xmath82 , \ ] ] where @xmath83\ ] ] is a pure gaussian and @xmath84 denotes the @xmath85 hermite polynomial , for which there are multiple normalization conventions .
we choose to normalize so that @xmath86 which implies that the leading term of @xmath87 is @xmath88 .
this is sometimes called the `` probabilist s convention . ''
we define expectation values @xmath89 by the usual rule , @xmath90 the probability density function in eq .
has the properties , and do not depend on the approximation that @xmath42 is small .
however , for large @xmath42 the density function may become negative for some values of @xmath77 .
it then ceases to be a probability density in the strict sense .
this does not present a problem in practice , since we are interested in distributions which are approximately gaussian , and for which @xmath42 will typically be small . moreover , our principal use of eq .
is as a formal tool to extract evolution equations for each moment .
for this reason we will not worry whether @xmath78 defines an honest probability density function in the strict mathematical sense . ]
@xmath91 the moments @xmath79 , @xmath81 , and @xmath42 may be time - dependent , so evolution of the probability density in time can be accommodated by finding evolution equations for these quantities .
the density function given in eq .
is well - known and has been applied in many situations .
it is a solution to the problem of approximating a nearly - gaussian distribution whose moments are known .
( [ e : p1d ] ) is in fact the first two terms of the _ gram charlier ` a ' series _ , also sometimes called the _
hermite series_. in recent years it has found multiple applications to cosmology , of which our method is closest to that of taylor & watts @xcite .
other applications are discussed in refs .
@xcite . for a review of the `
a ' series and related nearly - gaussian probability distributions from an astrophysical perspective , see @xcite . in this paper
, we will refer to eq . and its natural generalization to higher moments as the `` moment expansion . '' in the slow - roll approximation
, the field in each spacetime volume obeys a simple equation of motion @xmath92 where @xmath6 records the number of e - foldings of expansion .
we refer to @xmath93 as the velocity field .
expanding @xmath94 about the instantaneous centroid @xmath79 gives @xmath95 where @xmath96 the value of @xmath79 evolves with time , so each expansion coefficient is time - dependent .
hence , we do not assume that the velocity field is _ globally _ well - described by a quadratic taylor expansion , but merely that it is well - described as such in the neighborhood of the instantaneous centroid .
we expand the velocity field to second order , although in principle this expansion could be carried to arbitrary order .
it remains to specify how the probability density evolves in time .
conservation of probability leads to the transport equation @xmath97 eq .
can also be understood as the limit of a chapman
kolmogorov process as the size of each hop goes to zero .
it is well known for example , from the study of starobinsky s diffusion equation which forms the basis of the stochastic approach to inflation @xcite that the choice of time variable in this equation is significant , with different choices corresponding to the selection of a temporal gauge .
we have chosen to use the e - folding time , @xmath6 , which means that we are evolving the distribution on hypersurfaces of uniform expansion .
these are the spatially flat hypersurfaces whose field perturbations enter the @xmath0 formulas described in [ sec : computing_fnl ] . in principle , eq .
can be solved directly . in practice
it is simpler to extract equations for the moments of @xmath98 , giving evolution equations for @xmath79 , @xmath81 and @xmath42 . to achieve this , one need only resolve eq
. into a hermite series of the form @xmath99 the hermite polynomials are linearly independent , and application of the orthogonality condition shows that the @xmath100 must all vanish .
this leads to a hierarchy of equations @xmath101 , which we refer to as the moment hierarchy . at the top of the hierarchy ,
the equation @xmath102 is empty and expresses conservation of probability .
the first non - trivial equation requires @xmath103 and yields an evolution equation for the centroid @xmath79 , @xmath104 the first term on the right - hand side drives the centroid along the velocity field , as one would anticipate based on the background equation of motion , eq . .
however , the second term shows that the centroid is also influenced as the wings of the probability distribution probe the nearby velocity field .
this influence is not captured by the background equation of motion .
if we are in a situation with @xmath105 , then the wings of the density function will be moving faster than the center .
hence , the velocity of the centroid will be larger than one might expect by restricting attention to @xmath79 .
accordingly , the mean fluctuation value is not following a solution to the background equations of motion .
evolution equations for the variance @xmath80 and skew @xmath42 are obtained after enforcing @xmath106 , yielding @xmath107 in both equations , the first term on the right - hand sides describes how @xmath81 and @xmath42 scale as the density function expands or contracts in response to the velocity field .
these terms force @xmath80 and @xmath42 to scale in proportion to the velocity field . specifically ,
if we temporarily drop the second terms in each equation above , one finds that @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
this precisely matches our expectation for the scaling of these quantities .
hence , these terms account for the jacobians associated with infinitesimal transformations induced by the flow @xmath93 . for applications to inflationary non - gaussianity ,
the second terms in and are more relevant .
these terms describe how each moment is sourced by higher moments and the interaction of the density function with the velocity field . in the example
above , if we are in a situation where @xmath105 , the tails of the density function are moving faster than the core .
this means that one tail is shrinking and the other is extending , skewing the probability density .
the opposite occurs when @xmath110 .
these effects are measured by the second term in .
hence , by expanding our pdf to the third moment , and our velocity field to quadratic order , we are able to construct a set of evolution equations which include the leading - order source terms for each moment . there is little conceptually new as we move from one field to two .
the new features are mostly technical in nature .
our primary challenge is a generalization of the moment expansion to two fields , allowing for the possibility of correlation between the fields . with this done ,
we can write down evolution equations whose structure is very similar to those found in the single - field case . the two - field system is described by a two - dimensional velocity field @xmath111 , defined by @xmath112 where again we are using the number of e - folds @xmath6 as the time variable .
the index @xmath27 takes values in @xmath113 . while we think it is likely that our equations generalize to any number of fields , we have only explicitly constructed them for a two - field system . as will become clear below , certain steps in this construction apply only for two fields , and
hence we make no claims at present concerning examples with three or more fields .
the two - dimensional transport equation is @xmath114 = 0 .\ ] ] here and in the following we have returned to our convention that repeated species indices are summed . as in the single - field case , we construct a probability distribution which is nearly gaussian , but has a small non - zero skewness .
that gives @xmath115 where @xmath116 is a pure gaussian distribution , defined by @xmath117 .\ ] ] in this equation , @xmath118 defines the center of the distribution and @xmath119 describes the covariance between the fields .
we adopt a conventional parametrization in terms of variances @xmath120 and a correlation coefficient @xmath121 , @xmath122 the matrix @xmath81 defines two - point correlations of the fields , @xmath123 all skewnesses are encoded in @xmath124 . before defining this explicitly ,
it is helpful to pause and notice a complication inherent in eqs . which was not present in the single - field case . to extract a hierarchy of moment evolution equations from the transport equation , eq .
, we made the expansion given in and argued that orthogonality of the hermite polynomials implied the hierarchy @xmath101 .
however , hermite polynomials of the form @xmath125 $ ] are _ not _ orthogonal under the gaussian measure of eq . .
following an expansion analogous to eq .
the moment hierarchy would comprise linear combinations of the coefficients .
the problem is essentially an algebraic question of gram
schmidt orthogonalization . to avoid this problem
it is convenient to diagonalize the covariance matrix @xmath119 , introducing new variables @xmath126 and @xmath127 for which eq .
factorizes into the product of two measures under which the polynomials @xmath128 and @xmath129 are separately orthogonal .
the necessary redefinitions are @xmath130\ ] ] and @xmath131 .\ ] ] a simple expression for @xmath116 can be given in terms of @xmath126 and @xmath127 , @xmath132 we now define the non - gaussian factor , which encodes the skewnesses , to be @xmath133 in these variables we find @xmath134 , but @xmath135 .
in addition , we have @xmath136 in order for eq .
to be useful , it is necessary to express the skewnesses associated with the physical variables @xmath137 in terms of @xmath126 and @xmath127 . by definition ,
these satisfy @xmath138 after substituting for the definition of these quantities inside the expectation values in eq .
we arrive at the relations @xmath139 the moments @xmath118 , @xmath38 and @xmath40 are time - dependent , but for clarity we will usually suppress this in our notation .
next we must extract the moment hierarchy , which governs evolution of @xmath118 , @xmath140 , @xmath121 and @xmath40 .
we expand the velocity field in a neighborhood of the instantaneous centroid @xmath118 according to @xmath141 where we have defined @xmath142 as in the single - field case , these coefficients are functions of time and vary with the motion of the centroid .
the expansion can be pursued to higher order if desired .
our construction of @xmath126 and @xmath127 implies that the two - field transport equation can be arranged as a double gauss hermite expansion , @xmath143 = p_g \sum_{m , n \ge 0 } c_{mn } h_m(x ) h_n(y ) = 0 .\ ] ] because the hermite polynomials are orthogonal in the measure defined by @xmath116 , we deduce the moment hierarchy @xmath144 we define the rank " @xmath145 of each coefficient @xmath146 by @xmath147 .
we terminated the velocity field expansion at quadratic order , and our probability distribution included only the first three moments .
it follows that only @xmath146 with rank five or less are nonzero .
if we followed the velocity field to higher order , or included higher terms in the moment expansion , we would obtain non - trivial higher - rank coefficients .
inclusion of additional coefficients requires no qualitative modification of our analysis and can be incorporated in the scheme we describe below . a useful feature of the expansion in eq .
is that the rank-@xmath145 coefficients give evolution equations for the order-@xmath145 moments . written explicitly in components ,
the expressions that result from are quite cumbersome .
however , when written as field - space covariant expressions they can be expressed in a surprisingly compact form .
: : the rank-0 coefficient @xmath148 is identically zero .
this expresses the fact that the total probability is conserved as the distribution evolves . : : the rank-1 coefficients @xmath149 and @xmath150 give evolution equations for the centroid @xmath118 .
these equations can be written in the form @xmath151 we remind the reader that here and below , terms like @xmath152 , @xmath153 and @xmath154 represent the velocity field and its derivatives evaluated at the centroid @xmath118 .
the first term in expresses the non - anomalous motion of the centroid , which coincides with the background velocity field of eq . .
the second term describes how the wings of the probability distribution sample the velocity field at nearby points .
narrow probability distributions have small components of @xmath119 and hence are only sensitive to the local value of @xmath155 .
broad probability distributions have large components of @xmath119 and are therefore more sensitive to the velocity field far from the centroid . : : the rank-2 coefficients @xmath156 , @xmath157 and @xmath158 give evolution equations for the variances @xmath120 and the correlation @xmath121 .
these can conveniently be packaged as evolution equations for the matrix @xmath119 @xmath159 this equation describes the stretching and rotation of @xmath119 as it is transported by the velocity field .
it includes a sensitivity to the wings of the probability distribution , in a manner analogous to the similar term appearing in .
hence the skew @xmath40 acts as a source for the correlation matrix .
: : the rank-3 coefficients @xmath160 , @xmath161 , @xmath162 and @xmath163 describe evolution of the moments @xmath40 .
these are @xmath164 the first term describes how the moments flow into each other as the velocity field rotates and shears the @xmath165 coordinate frame relative to the @xmath137 coordinate frame .
the second term describes sourcing of non - gaussianity from inhomogeneities in the velocity field and the overall spread of the probability distribution .
some higher - rank coefficients in our case , those of ranks four and five are also nonzero , but do not give any new evolution equations .
these coefficients measure the error " introduced by truncating the moment expansion .
if we had included higher cumulants , these higher - rank coefficients would have given evolution equations for the higher moments of the probability distribution .
in general , all moments of the density function will mix so it is always necessary to terminate our expansion at a predetermined order both in cumulants and powers of the field fluctuation .
the order we have chosen is sufficient to generate evolution equations containing both the leading - order behavior of the moments namely , the first terms in eqs . , and and the leading corrections , given by the latter terms in these equations .
at this point we put our new method into practice .
we study two models for which the non - gaussian signal is already known , using the standard @xmath0 formula . for each case
we employ our method and compare it with results obtained using @xmath0 . to ensure a fair comparison , we solve numerically in both cases .
our new method employs the slow - roll approximation , as described above .
therefore , when using the @xmath0 approach we produce results both with and without slow - roll simplifications .
first consider double quadratic inflation , which was studied by rigopoulos , shellard & van tent @xcite and later by vernizzi & wands @xcite .
the potential is @xmath166 we use the initial conditions chosen in ref .
@xcite , where @xmath167 , and the fiducial trajectory has coordinates @xmath168 and @xmath169 .
we plot the evolution of @xmath1 in fig .
[ fig1 ] , which also shows the prediction of the standard @xmath0 formula ( with and without employing slow roll simplifications ) .
we implement the @xmath0 algorithm using a finite difference method to calculate the derivatives of @xmath6 .
a similar technique was used in ref .
this model yields a very modest non - gaussian signal , below unity even at its peak .
if inflation ends away from the spike then @xmath1 is practically negligible .
shows that the method of moment transport allows us to separate contributions to @xmath1 from the intrinsic non - gaussianity of the field fluctuations , and non - linearities of the gauge transformation to @xmath2 . as explained in
[ ss : sep_universe ] , we denote the former @xmath170 and the latter @xmath171 , and plot them separately in fig .
[ fig2 ] . inspection of this figure clearly shows that @xmath1 is determined by a cancellation between two much larger components .
its final shape and magnitude are exquisitely sensitive to their relative phase .
initially , the magnitudes of @xmath170 and @xmath171 grow , but their sum remains small .
the peak in fig .
[ fig1 ] arises from the peak of @xmath171 , which is incompletely cancelled by @xmath170 .
it is remarkable that @xmath170 initially evolves in exact opposition to the gauge transformation , to which it is not obviously connected . in the double quadratic model
, @xmath1 is always small .
however , it has recently been shown by byrnes _
_ that a large non - gaussian signal can be generated even when slow - roll is a good approximation @xcite
. the conditions for this to occur are incompletely understood , but apparently require a specific choice of potential and strong tuning of initial conditions . in figs .
[ fig3][fig4 ] we show the evolution of @xmath1 in a model with the potential @xmath172 which corresponds to example a of ref .
* 5 ) when we choose @xmath173 and initial conditions @xmath174 , @xmath175 .
it is clear that the agreement is exact . in this model , @xmath1 is overwhelmingly dominated by the contribution from the second - order gauge transformation , @xmath171 , as shown in fig .
[ fig4 ] .
this conclusion applies equally to the other large-@xmath1 examples discussed in refs .
@xcite , although we make no claim that this is a general phenomenon . in conclusion , figs .
[ fig1 ] and [ fig3 ] show excellent agreement between our new method and the outcome of the numerical @xmath0 formula .
these figures also compare the moment transport method and @xmath0 without the slow - roll approximation .
we conclude that the slow - roll estimate remains broadly accurate throughout the entire evolution .
non - linearities are now routinely extracted from all - sky observations of the microwave background anisotropy .
our purpose in this paper has been to propose a new technique with which to predict the observable signal .
present data already give interesting constraints on the skewness parameter @xmath1 , and over the next several years we expect that the _ planck _ survey satellite will make these constraints very stringent . it is even possible that higher - order moments , such as the kurtosis parameter @xmath176 @xcite will become better constrained @xcite . to meet the need of the observational community for comparison with theory , reliable estimates of these non - linear quantities will be necessary for various models of early - universe physics .
a survey of the literature suggests that the ` conventional ' @xmath0 method , originally introduced by lyth & rodrguez , remains the method of choice for analytical study of non - gaussianity . in comparison ,
our proposed moment transport method exhibits several clear differences .
first , the conventional method functions best when we base the @xmath0 expansion on a flat hypersurface immediately after horizon exit . in our method , we make the opposite choice and move the flat hypersurface as close as possible to the time of observation . after this , the role of the @xmath0 formula is to provide no more than the non - linear gauge transformation between field fluctuations and the curvature perturbation .
we substitute the method of moment transport to evolve the distribution of field fluctuations between horizon exit and observation .
second , in integrating the transport equation one uses an expansion of the velocity field such as the one given in eqs .
. this expansion is refreshed at each step of integration , so the result is related to conventional perturbative calculations in a very similar way to renormalization - group improved perturbation theory @xcite . in this interpretation ,
derivatives of @xmath111 play the role of couplings . at a given order , @xmath177 , in the moment hierarchy
, the equations for lower - order moments function as renormalization group equations for the couplings at level-@xmath177 , resumming potentially large terms before they spoil perturbation theory .
this property is shared with any formalism such as @xmath0 which is non - perturbative in time evolution , but may be an advantage in comparison with perturbative methods .
we also note that although @xmath0 is non - perturbative as a point of principle , practical implementations are frequently perturbative .
for example , the method of vernizzi & wands @xcite and battefeld & easther @xcite depends on the existence of quantities which are conserved only to leading order in @xmath178 , and can lose accuracy after @xmath179 e - foldings .
numerical calculations confirm that our method gives results in excellent agreement with existing techniques . as a by - product of our analysis
, we note that the large non - gaussianities which have recently been observed in sum- and product - separable potentials @xcite are dominated by non - linearities from the second - order part of the gauge transformation from @xmath180 to @xmath2 .
the contribution from intrinsic non - linearities of the field fluctuations , measured by the skewnesses @xmath40 , is negligible . in such cases
one can obtain a useful formula for @xmath1 by approximating the field distribution as an exact gaussian .
the non - gaussianity produced in such cases arises from a distortion of comoving hypersurfaces with respect to adjacent spatially flat hypersurfaces .
our new method joins many well - established techniques for estimating non - gaussian properties of the curvature perturbation . in our experience , these techniques give comparable estimates of @xmath1 , but they do not exactly agree .
each method invokes different assumptions , such as the neglect of gradients or the degree to which time dependence can be accommodated .
the mutual scatter between different methods can be attributed to the theory error inherent in any estimate of @xmath1 .
the comparison presented in
[ sec : numerics ] shows that while all of these methods slightly disagree , the moment transport method gives good agreement with other established methods .
dm is supported by the cambridge centre for theoretical cosmology ( ctc ) .
ds is funded by stfc .
dw acknowledges support from the ctc .
we would like to thank chris byrnes , jim lidsey and karim malik for helpful conversations .
10 t. falk , r. rangarajan , and m. srednicki , _ the angular dependence of the three - point correlation function of the cosmic microwave background radiation as predicted by inflationary cosmologies _ , _ astrophys .
j. _ * 403 * ( 1993 ) l1 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/9208001 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9208001 ] ] .
a. gangui , f. lucchin , s. matarrese , and s. mollerach , _ the three - point correlation function of the cosmic microwave background in inflationary models _ , _ astrophys . j. _ * 430 * ( 1994 ) 447457 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/9312033 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9312033 ] ] .
t. pyne and s. m. carroll , _ higher - order gravitational perturbations of the cosmic microwave background _
* d53 * ( 1996 ) 29202929 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/9510041 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9510041 ] ] .
v. acquaviva , n. bartolo , s. matarrese , and a. riotto , _ second - order cosmological perturbations from inflation _ , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b667 * ( 2003 ) 119148 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/0209156 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0209156 ] ] .
e. komatsu and d. n. spergel , _
acoustic signatures in the primary microwave background bispectrum _ , _ phys .
* d63 * ( 2001 ) 063002 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/0005036 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0005036 ] ] .
f. r. bouchet and r. juszkiewicz , _ perturbation theory confronts observations : implications for the ` initial ' conditions and @xmath181 _ , http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/9312007 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9312007 ] .
p. fosalba , e. gaztanaga , and e. elizalde , _ gravitational evolution of the large - scale density distribution : the edgeworth & gamma expansions _ , http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/9910308 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9910308 ] .
m. sasaki and e. d. stewart , _ a general analytic formula for the spectral index of the density perturbations produced during inflation _ , _ prog .
* 95 * ( 1996 ) 7178 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/9507001 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9507001 ] ] .
g. i. rigopoulos , e. p. s. shellard , and b. j. w. van tent , _ non - linear perturbations in multiple - field inflation _
rev . _ * d73 * ( 2006 ) 083521 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/0504508 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0504508 ] ] .
h. r. s. cogollo , y. rodrguez , and c. a. valenzuela - toledo , _ on the issue of the @xmath2 series convergence and loop corrections in the generation of observable primordial non - gaussianity in slow - roll inflation .
part i : the bispectrum _ , _ jcap _ * 0808 * ( 2008 ) 029 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/0806.1546[arxiv:0806.1546 ] ] .
y. rodrguez and c. a. valenzuela - toledo , _ on the issue of the @xmath2 series convergence and loop corrections in the generation of observable primordial non - gaussianity in slow - roll inflation .
part ii : the trispectrum _ , http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/0811.4092 [ arxiv:0811.4092 ] .
choi , l. m. h. hall , and c. van de bruck , _ spectral running and non - gaussianity from slow - roll inflation in generalised two - field models _ , _ jcap _ * 0702 * ( 2007 ) 029 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/0701247 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0701247 ] ] . c. gordon , d. wands , b. a. bassett , and r. maartens , _ adiabatic and entropy perturbations from inflation _ , _ phys .
_ * d63 * ( 2001 ) 023506 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/0009131 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0009131 ] ] .
s. matarrese , l. verde , and r. jimenez , _ the abundance of high - redshift objects as a probe of non- gaussian initial conditions _ , _ astrophys
. j. _ * 541 * ( 2000 ) 10 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/0001366 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0001366 ] ] .
l. amendola , _ the dependence of cosmological parameters estimated from the microwave background on non - gaussianity _ , _ astrophys
. j. _ * 569 * ( 2002 ) 595599 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/0107527 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0107527 ] ] .
m. loverde , a. miller , s. shandera , and l. verde , _ effects of scale - dependent non - gaussianity on cosmological structures _ , _ jcap _ * 0804 * ( 2008 ) 014 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/0711.4126 [ arxiv:0711.4126 ] ] .
d. seery and j. c. hidalgo , _ non - gaussian corrections to the probability distribution of the curvature perturbation from inflation _ , _ jcap _ * 0607 * ( 2006 ) 008 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/0604579 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0604579 ] ] .
s. blinnikov and r. moessner , _
expansions for nearly gaussian distributions _ , _ astron .
* 130 * ( 1998 ) 193205 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/9711239 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9711239 ] ] .
g. i. rigopoulos , e. p. s. shellard , and b. j. w. van tent , _ quantitative bispectra from multifield inflation _
rev . _ * d76 * ( 2007 ) 083512 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/0511041 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0511041 ] ] .
m. sasaki , j. valiviita , and d. wands , _ non - gaussianity of the primordial perturbation in the curvaton model _ , _ phys .
rev . _ * d74 * ( 2006 ) 103003 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/0607627 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0607627 ] ] .
|
we present a novel method for calculating the primordial non - gaussianity produced by super - horizon evolution during inflation .
our method evolves the distribution of coarse - grained inflationary field values using a transport equation .
we present simple evolution equations for the moments of this distribution , such as the variance and skewness .
this method possesses some advantages over existing techniques . among them
, it cleanly separates multiple sources of primordial non - gaussianity , and is computationally efficient when compared with popular alternatives , such as the @xmath0 framework .
we adduce numerical calculations demonstrating that our new method offers good agreement with those already in the literature .
we focus on two fields and the @xmath1 parameter , but we expect our method will generalize to multiple scalar fields and to moments of arbitrarily high order .
we present our expressions in a field - space covariant form which we postulate to be valid for any number of fields .
* keywords * : inflation , cosmological perturbation theory , physics of the early universe , quantum field theory in curved spacetime .
|
for fixed integers @xmath0 and @xmath1 , we consider the admissible sequences of @xmath2 lattice paths in a colored @xmath3 square given in @xcite . each admissible sequence of paths can be associated with a partition @xmath10 of @xmath4 . in section
[ paths ] , we show that the number of self - conjugate admissible sequences of paths associated with @xmath10 is equal to the number of standard young tableaux of shape @xmath10 , and thus can be calculated using the hook length formula .
we extend this result to include the non - self - conjugate admissible sequences of paths and show that the number of all such admissible sequences of paths is equal to the sum of squares of the number of standard young tableaux of partitions of @xmath4 with height less than or equal to @xmath11 . using the rsk correspondence in @xcite ,
it is shown in ( @xcite , corollary 7.23.12 ) that the sum of squares of the number of standard young tableaux of partitions of @xmath4 with height less than or equal to @xmath11 is equal to the number of @xmath6-avoiding permutations of @xmath7 . in section [ multiplicities ]
, we apply our results to the representation theory of the affine kac - moody algebra @xmath8 .
let @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 denote the simple roots , simple coroots , and fundamental weights respectively .
note that @xmath15
. for @xmath16 , set @xmath17 and @xmath18 . as shown in @xcite , @xmath19
are maximal dominant weights of the irreducible @xmath8-module @xmath9 .
we show that the multiplicity of the weight @xmath19 in @xmath9 is the number of @xmath6-avoiding permutations of @xmath7 , which proves conjecture 4.13 in @xcite .
for fixed integers @xmath0 and @xmath1 , consider the @xmath3 square containing @xmath20 unit boxes in the fourth quadrant so that the top left corner of the square is at the origin .
we assign color @xmath21 to a box if its upper left corner has coordinates @xmath22 .
this gives the following @xmath3 colored square @xmath23 : a lattice path @xmath25 on @xmath23 is a path joining the lower left corner @xmath26 to the upper right corner @xmath27 moving unit lengths up or right . for two lattice paths @xmath28 on @xmath23
we say that @xmath29 if the boxes above @xmath30 are also above @xmath25 .
now , we draw @xmath2 lattice paths , @xmath31 on @xmath23 such that @xmath32 . for integers
@xmath33 , where @xmath34 , @xmath35 , we define @xmath36 to be the number of @xmath37-colored boxes between @xmath38 and @xmath39 .
we define @xmath40 to be the number of @xmath37-colored boxes below @xmath41 and @xmath42 to be the number of @xmath37-colored boxes above @xmath43 .
denote by @xmath49 the set of all admissible sequences of @xmath2 paths .
notice that there are @xmath4 0-colored boxes in @xmath23 and hence for any admissible sequence of paths , @xmath50 .
in addition , it follows from definition [ pathsdef](2 ) that @xmath51 for any admissible sequence of paths .
thus , we can and do associate an admissible sequence of paths @xmath44 on @xmath23 with a partition @xmath52 of @xmath4 . in this case , we say that this admissible sequence of paths is of type @xmath10 and often draw @xmath10 as a young diagram .
figure [ adseq](a ) is an element of @xmath53 , where @xmath54 and @xmath55 are shown in figures [ adseq](b ) , [ adseq](c ) , and [ adseq](d ) , respectively .
notice that this admissible sequence of paths is of type @xmath56 .
|
for @xmath0 and @xmath1 , we consider certain admissible sequences of @xmath2 lattice paths in a colored @xmath3 square .
we show that the number of such admissible sequences of lattice paths is given by the sum of squares of the number of standard young tableaux of partitions of @xmath4 with height @xmath5 , which is also the number of @xmath6-avoiding permutations of @xmath7 .
finally , we apply this result to the representation theory of the affine lie algebra @xmath8 and show that this quantity gives the multiplicity of certain maximal dominant weights in the irreducible module @xmath9 .
|
the lep experiments at the resonance of @xmath1-boson have tested the standard model ( sm ) at quantum level , measuring the @xmath1-decay into fermion pairs with an accuracy of one part in ten thousands .
the good agreement of the lep data with the sm predictions have severely constrained the behavior of new physics at the @xmath1-pole .
taking these achievements into account one can imagine that the physics of @xmath1-boson will again play the central role in the frontier of particle physics if the next generation @xmath1 factory comes true with the generated @xmath1 events several orders of magnitude higher than that of the lep .
this factory can be realized in the gigaz option of the international linear collider ( ilc)@xcite .
the ilc is a proposed electron - positron collider with tunable energy ranging from @xmath12 to @xmath13 and polarized beams in its first phase , and the gigaz option corresponds to its operation on top of the resonance of @xmath1 boson by adding a bypass to its main beam line .
given the high luminosity , @xmath14 , and the cross section at the resonance of @xmath1 boson , @xmath15 , about @xmath16 @xmath1 events can be generated in an operational year of @xmath17 of gigaz , which implies that the expected sensitivity to the branching ratio of @xmath1-decay can be improved from @xmath18 at the lep to @xmath19 at the gigaz@xcite . in light of this , the @xmath1-boson properties , especially its exotic or rare decays which are widely believed to be sensitive to new physics , should be investigated comprehensively to evaluate their potential in probing new physics . among the rare @xmath1-decays , the flavor changing ( fc ) processes were most extensively studied to explore the flavor texture in new physics @xcite , and it was found that , although these processes are severely suppressed in the sm , their branching ratios in new physics models can be greatly enhanced to @xmath19 for lepton flavor violation decays @xcite and @xmath20 for quark flavor violation decays @xcite . besides the fc processes
, the @xmath1-decay into light higgs boson(s ) is another type of rare process that was widely studied , e.g. the decay @xmath21 ( @xmath22 ) with the particle @xmath0 denoting a light higgs boson was studied in @xcite , the decay @xmath23 was studied in the two higgs doublet model ( 2hdm)@xcite and the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm)@xcite , and the decay @xmath4 was studied in a model independent way @xcite , in 2hdm@xcite and also in mssm@xcite .
these studies indicate that , in contrast with the kinematic forbidden of these decays in the sm , the rates of these decays can be as large as @xmath18 in new physics models , which lie within the expected sensitivity of the gigaz . in this work ,
we extend the previous studies of these decays to some new models and investigate these decays altogether .
we are motivated by some recent studies on the singlet extension of the mssm , such as the next - to - minimal supersymmetric standard model ( nmssm ) @xcite and the nearly minimal supersymmetric standard model ( nmssm ) @xcite , where a light cp - odd higgs boson @xmath0 with singlet - dominant component may naturally arise from the spontaneous breaking of some approximate global symmetry like @xmath24 or peccei - quuin symmetry @xcite .
these non - minimal supersymmetric models can not only avoid the @xmath25-problem , but also alleviate the little hierarchy by having such a light higgs boson @xmath0 @xcite .
we are also motivated by that , with the latest experiments , the properties of the light higgs boson are more stringently constrained than before .
so it is worth updating the previous studies .
so far there is no model - independent lower bound on the lightest higgs boson mass . in the sm
, it must be heavier than @xmath26 gev , obtained from the null observation of the higgs boson at lep experiments .
however , due to the more complex structure of the higgs sector in the extensions of the sm , this lower bound can be significantly relaxed according to recent studies , e.g. , for the cp - odd higgs boson @xmath0 we have @xmath27 gev in the nmssm @xcite , @xmath28 gev in the nmssm @xcite , and @xmath29 gev in the lepton - specific 2hdm ( l2hdm ) @xcite . with such a light cp - odd higgs boson , the z - decay into one or more
@xmath0 is open up . noting that the decay @xmath30 is forbidden due to bose symmetry , we in this work study the rare @xmath1-decays @xmath6 ( @xmath22 ) , @xmath31 and @xmath4 in a comparative way for four models , namely the type - ii 2hdm@xcite , the l2hdm @xcite , the nmssm and the nmssm . in our study
, we examine carefully the constraints on the light @xmath0 from many latest experimental results .
this work is organized as follows . in sec .
ii we briefly describe the four new physics models . in sec .
iii we present the calculations of the rare @xmath1-decays . in sec .
iv we list the constraints on the four new physics models . in sec .
v we show the numerical results for the branching ratios of the rare @xmath1-decays in various models . finally , the conclusion is given in sec .
as the most economical way , the sm utilizes one higgs doublet to break the electroweak symmetry . as a result ,
the sm predicts only one physical higgs boson with its properties totally determined by two free parameters . in new physics models ,
the higgs sector is usually extended by adding higgs doublets and/or singlets , and consequently , more physical higgs bosons are predicted along with more free parameters involved in .
the general 2hdm contains two @xmath32 doublet higgs fields @xmath33 and @xmath34 , and with the assumption of cp - conserving , its scalar potential can be parameterized as@xcite : @xmath35,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath36 ( @xmath37 ) are free dimensionless parameters , and @xmath38 ( @xmath39 ) are the parameters with mass dimension . after the electroweak symmetry breaking , the spectrum of this higgs sector includes three massless goldstone modes , which become the longitudinal modes of @xmath40 and @xmath1 bosons , and five massive physical states : two cp - even higgs bosons @xmath41 and @xmath42 , one neutral cp - odd higgs particle @xmath0 and a pair of charged higgs bosons @xmath43 . noting the constraint @xmath44 with @xmath45 and @xmath46 denoting the vacuum expectation values ( vev ) of @xmath33 and @xmath34 respectively , we choose @xmath47 as the input parameters with @xmath48 , and @xmath49 being the mixing angle that diagonalizes the mass matrix of the cp - even higgs fields .
the difference between the type - ii 2hdm and the l2hdm comes from the yukawa coupling of the higgs bosons to quark / lepton . in the type - ii 2hdm
, one higgs doublet @xmath34 generates the masses of up - type quarks and the other doublet @xmath33 generates the masses of down - type quarks and charged leptons ; while in the l2hdm one higgs doublet @xmath33 couples only to leptons and the other doublet @xmath34 couples only to quarks .
so the yukawa interactions of @xmath0 to fermions in these two models are given by @xcite @xmath50 with @xmath51 denoting generation index .
obviously , in the type - ii 2hdm the @xmath52 coupling and the @xmath53 coupling can be simultaneously enhanced by @xmath54 , while in the l2hdm only the @xmath53 coupling is enhanced by @xmath55 .
the structures of the nmssm and the nmssm are described by their superpotentials and corresponding soft - breaking terms , which are given by @xcite @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the superpotential of the mssm without the @xmath25 term , @xmath58 and @xmath59 are higgs doublet and singlet superfields with @xmath60 and @xmath61 being their scalar component respectively , @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 are soft breaking parameters , and @xmath68 and @xmath69 are coefficients of the higgs self interactions . with the superpotentials and the soft - breaking terms
, one can get the higgs potentials of the nmssm and the nmssm respectively . like the 2hdm ,
the higgs bosons with same cp property will mix and the mass eigenstates are obtained by diagonalizing the corresponding mass matrices : @xmath70 where the fields on the right hands of the equations are component fields of @xmath71 , @xmath72 and @xmath61 defined by @xmath73 @xmath74 and @xmath75 are respectively the cp - even and cp - odd neutral higgs bosons , @xmath76 and @xmath77 are goldstone bosons eaten by @xmath1 and @xmath78 , and @xmath79 is the charged higgs boson .
so both the nmssm and nmssm predict three cp - even higgs bosons , two cp - odd higgs bosons and one pair of charged higgs bosons . in general , the lighter cp - odd higgs @xmath0 in these model is the mixture of the singlet field @xmath80 and the doublet field combination , @xmath81 , i.e. @xmath82 and its couplings to down - type quarks are then proportional to @xmath83 .
so for singlet dominated @xmath0 , @xmath84 is small and the couplings are suppressed . as a comparison
, the interactions of @xmath0 with the squarks are given by@xcite @xmath85 i.e. the interaction does not vanish when @xmath86 approaches zero . just like the 2hdm where we use the vevs of the higgs fields as fundamental parameters , we choose @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath66 and @xmath89 as input parameters for the nmssm@xcite and @xmath68 , @xmath54 , @xmath88 , @xmath65 , @xmath90 and @xmath91 as input parameters for the nmssm@xcite .
about the nmssm and the nmssm , three points should be noted .
the first is for the two models , there is no explicit @xmath92term , and the effective @xmath25 parameter ( @xmath93 ) is generated when the scalar component of @xmath59 develops a vev .
the second is , the nmssm is actually same as the nmssm with @xmath94@xcite , because the tadpole terms @xmath95 and its soft breaking term @xmath96 in the nmssm do not induce any interactions , except for the tree - level higgs boson masses and the minimization conditions . and
the last is despite of the similarities , the nmssm has its own peculiarity , which comes from its neutralino sector .
in the basis @xmath97 , its neutralino mass matrix is given by @xcite @xmath98 where @xmath99 and @xmath100 are @xmath101 and @xmath102 gaugino masses respectively , @xmath103 , @xmath104 , @xmath105 and @xmath106 .
after diagonalizing this matrix one can get the mass eigenstate of the lightest neutralino @xmath107 with mass taking the following form @xcite @xmath108 this expression implies that @xmath107 must be lighter than about @xmath109 gev for @xmath110 ( from lower bound on chargnio mass ) and @xmath111 ( perturbativity bound ) . like the other supersymmetric models , @xmath107 as the lightest sparticle acts as the dark matter in the universe , but due to its singlino - dominated nature , it is difficult to annihilate sufficiently to get the correct density in the current universe .
so the relic density of @xmath107 plays a crucial way in selecting the model parameters .
for example , as shown in @xcite , for @xmath112 , there is no way to get the correct relic density , and for the other cases , @xmath107 mainly annihilates by exchanging @xmath1 boson for @xmath113 , or by exchanging a light cp - odd higgs boson @xmath0 with mass satisfying the relation @xmath114 for @xmath115 . for the annihilation , @xmath54 and @xmath25
are required to be less than 10 and @xmath116 respectively because through eq.([mass - exp ] ) a large @xmath87 or @xmath25 will suppress @xmath117 to make the annihilation more difficult .
the properties of the lightest cp - odd higgs boson @xmath0 , such as its mass and couplings , are also limited tightly since @xmath0 plays an important role in @xmath107 annihilation .
the phenomenology of the nmssm is also rather special , and this was discussed in detail in @xcite .
in the type - ii 2hdm , l2hdm , nmssm and nmssm , the rare @xmath1-decays @xmath118 ( @xmath22 ) , @xmath3 and @xmath4 may proceed by the feynman diagrams shown in fig.[fig1 ] , fig.[fig2 ] and fig.[fig3 ] respectively . for these diagrams , the intermediate state @xmath119 represents all possible cp - even higgs bosons in the corresponding model , i.e. @xmath41 and @xmath42 in type - ii 2hdm and l2hdm and @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath120 in nmssm and nmssm . in order to take into account the possible resonance effects of @xmath119 in fig.[fig1](c ) for @xmath2 and fig.[fig3 ] ( a ) for @xmath11 , we have calculated all the decay modes of @xmath119 and properly included the width effect in its propagator . as to the decay @xmath121 , two points should be noted .
one is , unlike the decays @xmath6 and @xmath11 , this process proceeds only through loops mediated by quarks / leptons in the type - ii 2hdm and l2hdm , and additionally by sparticles in the nmssm and nmssm .
so in most cases its rate should be much smaller than the other two .
the other is due to cp - invariance , loops mediated by squarks / sleptons give no contribution to the decay@xcite . in actual calculation , this is reflected by the fact that the coupling coefficient of @xmath122 differs from that of @xmath123 by a minus sign ( see eq.([asqsq ] ) ) , and as a result , the squark - mediated contributions to @xmath121 are completely canceled out . with regard to the rare decay @xmath11 , we have more explanations . in the lowest order , this decay proceeds by the diagram shown in fig.[fig3 ] ( a ) , and hence one may think that , as a rough estimate , it is enough to only consider the contributions from fig.[fig3](a ) . however , we note that in some cases of the type - ii 2hdm and l2hdm , due to the cancelation of the contributions from different @xmath119 in fig.[fig3 ] ( a ) and also due to the potentially largeness of @xmath124 couplings ( i.e. larger than the electroweak scale @xmath125 ) , the radiative correction from the higgs - mediated loops may dominate over the tree level contribution even when the tree level prediction of the rate , @xmath126 , exceeds @xmath20 . on the other hand
, we find the contribution from quark / lepton - mediated loops can be safely neglected if @xmath127 in the type - ii 2hdm and the l2hdm . in the nmssm and the nmssm , besides the corrections from the higgs- and quark / lepton - mediated loops , loops involving sparticles such as squarks , charginos and neutralinos can also contribute to the decay .
we numerically checked that the contributions from squarks and charginos can be safely neglected if @xmath127 .
we also calculated part of potentially large neutralino correction ( note that there are totally about @xmath128 diagrams for such correction ! ) and found they can be neglected too . since considering all the radiative corrections
will make our numerical calculation rather slow , we only include the most important correction , namely that from higgs - mediated loops , in presenting our results for the four models .
one can intuitively understand the relative smallness of the sparticle contribution to @xmath11 as follows .
first consider the squark contribution which is induced by the @xmath129 interaction ( @xmath130 denotes the squark in chirality state ) and the @xmath131 interaction through box diagrams . because the @xmath132 interaction conserves the chirality of the squarks while the @xmath133 interaction violates the chirality , to get non - zero contribution to @xmath11 from the squark loops , at least four chiral flippings are needed , with three of them provided by @xmath131 interaction and the rest provided by the left - right squark mixing .
this means that , if one calculates the amplitude in the chirality basis with the mass insertion method , the amplitude is suppressed by the mixing factor @xmath134 with @xmath135 being the off diagonal element in squark mass matrix .
next consider the chargino / neutralino contributions . since for a light @xmath0 , its doublet component , parameterized by @xmath84 in eq.([mixing ] ) ,
is usually small , the couplings of @xmath0 with the sparticles will never be tremendously large@xcite .
so the chargino / neutralino contributions are not important too . in our calculation of the decays
, we work in the mass eigenstates of sparticles instead of in the chirality basis .
for the type - ii 2hdm and the l2hdm , we consider the following constraints @xcite : * theoretical constraints on @xmath136 from perturbativity , unitarity and requirements that the scalar potential is finit at large field values and contains no flat directions @xcite , which imply that @xmath137 * the constraints from the lep search for neutral higgs bosons . we compute the signals from the higgs - strahlung production @xmath138 ( @xmath139 ) with @xmath140 @xcite and from the associated production @xmath141 with @xmath142 @xcite , and compare them with the corresponding lep data which have been inputted into our code .
we also consider the constraints from @xmath138 by looking for a peak of @xmath143 recoil mass distribution of @xmath1-boson @xcite and the constraint of @xmath144 mev when @xmath145 @xcite .
+ these constraints limit the quantities such as @xmath146 \times br ( h_i \to \bar{b } b ) $ ] on the @xmath147 plane with the the subscript @xmath148 denoting the coupling coefficient of the @xmath149 interaction .
they also impose a model - dependent lower bound on @xmath150 , e.g. , @xmath151 for the type - ii 2hdm ( from our scan results ) , @xmath152 for the l2hdm@xcite , and @xmath153 for the nmssm @xcite .
these bounds are significantly lower than that of the sm , i.e. @xmath154 , partially because in new physics models , unconventional decay modes of @xmath155 such as @xmath156 are open up . as to the nmssm , another specific reason for allowing a significantly lighter cp -
even higgs boson is that the boson may be singlet - dominated in this model .
+ with regard to the lightest cp - odd higgs boson @xmath0 , we checked that there is no lower bound on its mass so long as the @xmath157 interaction is weak or @xmath155 is sufficiently heavy . * the constraints from the lep search for a light higgs boson via the yukawa process @xmath158 with @xmath22 and @xmath61 denoting a scalar @xcite .
these constraints can limit the @xmath159 coupling versus @xmath160 in new physics models . * the constraints from the cleo - iii limit on @xmath161 and the latest babar limits on @xmath162 .
these constraints will put very tight constraints on the @xmath163 coupling for @xmath164 . in our analysis , we use the results of fig.8 in the second paper of @xcite to excluded the unfavored points . * the constraints from @xmath165 couplings .
since the higgs sector can give sizable higher order corrections to @xmath165 couplings , we calculate them to one loop level and require the corrected @xmath165 couplings to lie within the @xmath166 range of their fitted value .
the sm predictions for the couplings at @xmath1-pole are given by @xmath167 and @xmath168 @xcite , and the fitted values are given by @xmath169 and @xmath170 , respectively@xcite .
we adopt the formula in @xcite to the 2hdm in our calculation . * the constraints from @xmath171 leptonic decay .
we require the new physics correction to the branching ratio @xmath172 to be in the range of @xmath173 @xcite .
we use the formula in @xcite in our calculation . + about the constraints ( 5 ) and ( 6 ) , two points should be noted .
one is all higgs bosons are involved in the constraints by entering the self energy of @xmath171 lepton , the @xmath174 vertex correction or the @xmath175 vertex correction , and also the box diagrams for @xmath176@xcite .
since the yukawa couplings of the higgs bosons to @xmath171 lepton get enhanced by @xmath54 and so do the corrections , @xmath54 must be upper bounded for given spectrum of the higgs sector . generally speaking , the lighter @xmath0 is , the more tightly @xmath54 is limited@xcite .
the other point is in the type - ii 2hdm , @xmath177 , b - physics observables as well as @xmath178 decays discussed above can constraint the model in a tighter way than the constraints ( 5 ) and ( 6 ) since the yukawa couplings of @xmath171 lepton and @xmath179 quark are simultaneously enhanced by @xmath54 .
but for the l2hdm , because only the yukawa couplings of @xmath171 lepton get enhanced ( see eq.[yukawa ] ) , the constraints ( 5 ) and ( 6 ) are more important in limiting @xmath54 .
* indirect constraints from the precision electroweak observables such as @xmath180 , @xmath181 and @xmath182 , or their combinations @xmath183 @xcite .
we require @xmath184 to be compatible with the lep / sld data at @xmath185 confidence level@xcite .
we also require new physics prediction of @xmath186 is within the @xmath187 range of its experimental value .
the latest results for @xmath188 are @xmath189 ( measured value ) and @xmath190 ( sm prediction ) for @xmath191 gev @xcite . in our code , we adopt the formula for these observables presented in @xcite to the type - ii 2hdm and the l2hdm respectively .
+ in calculating @xmath180 , @xmath181 and @xmath182 , we note that these observables get dominant contributions from the self energies of the gauge bosons @xmath1 , @xmath192 and @xmath193 .
since there is no @xmath194 coupling or @xmath195 coupling , @xmath0 must be associated with the other higgs bosons to contribute to the self energies .
so by the uv convergence of these quantities , one can infer that , for the case of a light @xmath0 and @xmath196 , these quantities depend on the spectrum of the higgs sector in a way like @xmath197 at leading order , which implies that a light @xmath0 can still survive the constraints from the precision electroweak observables given the splitting between @xmath150 and @xmath198 is moderate@xcite . * the constraints from b physics observables such as the branching ratios for @xmath199 , @xmath200 and @xmath201 , and the mass differences @xmath202 and @xmath203 .
we require their theoretical predications to agree with the corresponding experimental values at @xmath187 level . + in the type - ii 2hdm and the l2hdm , only the charged higgs boson contributes to these observables by loops , so one can expect that @xmath198 versus @xmath54 is to be limited .
combined analysis of the limits in the type - ii 2hdm has been done by the ckmfitter group , and the lower bound of @xmath204 as a function of @xmath87 was given in fig.11 of @xcite .
this analysis indicates that @xmath198 must be heavier than @xmath205 at @xmath185 c.l .
regardless the value of @xmath54 . in this work
, we use the results of fig.11 in @xcite to exclude the unfavored points . as for
the l2hdm , b physics actually can not put any constraints@xcite because in this model the couplings of the charged higgs boson to quarks are proportional to @xmath206 and in the case of large @xmath54 which we are interested in , they are suppressed . in our analysis of the l2hdm , we impose the lep bound on @xmath198 , i.e. @xmath207@xcite . * the constraints from the muon anomalous magnetic moment @xmath208 .
now both the theoretical prediction and the experimental measured value of @xmath208 have reached a remarkable precision , but a significant deviation still exists : @xmath209 @xcite . in the 2hdm , @xmath208 gets additional contributions from the one - loop diagrams induced by the higgs bosons and also from the two - loop barr - zee diagrams mediated by @xmath0 and @xmath155@xcite .
if the higgs bosons are much heavier than @xmath25 lepton mass , the contributions from the barr - zee diagrams are more important , and to efficiently alleviate the discrepancy of @xmath208 , one needs a light @xmath0 along with its enhanced couplings to @xmath25 lepton and also to heavy fermions such as bottom quark and @xmath171 lepton to push up the effects of the barr - zee diagram@xcite .
the cp - even higgs bosons are usually preferred to be heavy since their contributions to @xmath208 are negative .
+ in the type - ii 2hdm , because @xmath54 is tightly constrained by the process @xmath210 at the lep@xcite and the @xmath178 decay@xcite , the barr - zee diagram contribution is insufficient to enhance @xmath208 to @xmath187 range around its measured value@xcite .
so in our analysis , we require the type - ii 2hdm to explain @xmath208 at @xmath211 level .
while for the l2hdm , @xmath54 is less constrained compared with the type - ii 2hdm , and the barr - zee diagram involving the @xmath171-loop is capable to push up greatly the theoretical prediction of @xmath208@xcite .
therefore , we require the l2hdm to explain the discrepancy at @xmath187 level .
+ unlike the other constraints discussed above , the @xmath208 constraint will put a two - sided bound on @xmath54 since on the one hand , it needs a large @xmath54 to enhance the barr - zee contribution , but on the other hand , too large @xmath54 will result in an unacceptable large @xmath208 . *
since this paper concentrates on a light @xmath0 , the decay @xmath212 is open up with a possible large decay width .
we require the width of any higgs boson to be smaller than its mass to avoid a too fat higgs boson@xcite .
we checked that for the scenario characterized by @xmath213 , the coefficient of @xmath214 interaction is usually larger than the electroweak scale @xmath125 , and consequently a large decay width is resulted .
for the nmssm and nmssm , the above constraints become more complicated because in these models , not only more higgs bosons are involved in , but also sparticles enter the constraints .
so it is not easy to understand some of the constraints intuitively .
take the process @xmath199 as an example . in the supersymmetric models , besides the charged higgs contribution , chargino loops , gluino loops as well as neutralino loops also contribute to the process@xcite , and depending on the susy parameters , any of these contributions may become dominated over or be canceled by other contributions . as a result , although the charged higgs affects the process in the same way as that in the type - ii 2hdm , charged higgs as light as @xmath215 is still allowed even for @xmath216@xcite . since among the constraints
, @xmath208 is rather peculiar in that it needs new physics to explain the discrepancy between @xmath217 and @xmath218 , we discuss more about its dependence on susy parameters . in the nmssm and the nmssm
, @xmath208 receives contributions from higgs loops and neutralino / chargino loops . for the higgs contribution , it is quite similar to that of the type - ii 2hdm except that more higgs bosons are involved in@xcite . for the neutralino / chargino contribution , in the light bino limit ( i.e.
@xmath219 ) , it can be approximated by@xcite @xmath220 for @xmath221 with @xmath222 being smuon mass . so combining the two contributions together
, one can learn that a light @xmath0 along with large @xmath54 and/or light smuon with moderate @xmath87 are favored to dilute the discrepancy . because more parameters are involved in the constraints on the supersymmetric models , we consider following additional constraints to further limit their parameters : * direct bounds on sparticle masses from the lep1 , the lep2 and the tevatron experiments @xcite . * the lep1 bound on invisible z decay @xmath223 ; the lep2 bound on neutralino production @xmath224 and @xmath225@xcite .
* dark matter constraints from the wmap relic density 0.0975 @xmath226 0.1213 @xcite .
note that among the above constraints , the constraint ( 2 ) on higgs sector and the constraint ( c ) on neutralino sector are very important . this is because in the supersymmetric models , the sm - like higgs is upper bounded by about @xmath227 at tree level and by about @xmath228 at loop level , and that the relic density restricts the lsp annihilation cross section in a certain narrow range . in our analysis of the nmssm , we calculate the constraints ( 3 ) and ( 5 - 7 ) by ourselves and utilize the code nmssmtools @xcite to implement the rest constraints .
we also extend nmssmtools to the nmssm to implement the constraints .
for the extension , the most difficult thing we faced is how to adapt the code micromegas@xcite to the nmssm case .
we solve this problem by noting the following facts : * as we mentioned before , the nmssm is actually same as the nmssm with the trilinear singlet term setting to zero .
so we can utilize the model file of the nmssm as the input of the micromegas and set @xmath229 . * since in the nmssm , the lsp is too light to annihilate into higgs pairs , there is no need to reconstruct the effective higgs potential to calculate precisely the annihilation channel @xmath230 with @xmath61 denoting any of higgs bosons@xcite .
we thank the authors of the nmssmtools for helpful discussion on this issue when we finish such extension@xcite .
with the above constraints , we perform four independent random scans over the parameter space of the type - ii 2hdm , the l2hdm , the nmssm and the nmssm respectively .
we vary the parameters in following ranges : @xmath231 for the type - ii 2hdm , @xmath232 for the l2hdm , @xmath233 for the nmssm , and @xmath234 for the nmssm . in performing the scans , we note that for the nmssm and the nmssm , some constraints also rely on the gaugino masses and the soft breaking parameters in the squark sector and the slepton sector .
since these parameters affect little on the properties of @xmath0 , we fix them to reduce the number of free parameters in our scan . for the squark sector
, we adopt the @xmath235 scenario which assumes that the soft mass parameters for the third generation squarks are degenerate : @xmath236 800 gev , and that the trilinear couplings of the third generation squarks are also degenerate , @xmath237 with @xmath238 . for the slepton sector , we assume all the soft - breaking masses and trilinear parameters to be 100 gev .
this setting is necessary for the nmssm since this model is difficult to explain the muon anomalous moment at @xmath239 level for heavy sleptons@xcite .
finally , we assume the grand unification relation @xmath240 for the gaugino masses with @xmath241 being fine structure constants of the different gauge group . with large number of random points in the scans ,
we finally get about @xmath242 , @xmath243 , @xmath244 and @xmath242 samples for the type - ii 2hdm , the l2hdm , the nmssm and the nmssm respectively which survive the constraints and satisfy @xmath245 . analyzing the properties of the @xmath0 indicates that for most of the surviving points in the nmssm and the nmssm , its dominant component is the singlet field ( numerically speaking , @xmath246 ) so that its couplings to the sm fermions are suppressed@xcite .
our analysis also indicates that the main decay products of @xmath0 are @xmath247 for the l2hdm@xcite , @xmath248 ( dominant ) and @xmath247 ( subdominant ) for the type - ii 2hdm , the nmssm and the nmssm , and in some rare cases , neutralino pairs in the nmssm@xcite . in fig.[fig4 ]
, we project the surviving samples on the @xmath249 plane .
this figure shows that the allowed range of @xmath54 is from @xmath250 to @xmath251 in the type - ii 2hdm , and from @xmath252 to @xmath253 in the l2hdm .
just as we introduced before , the lower bounds of @xmath254 come from the fact that we require the models to explain the muon anomalous moment , while the upper bound is due to we have imposed the constraint from the lep process @xmath255 , which have limited the upper reach of the @xmath256 coupling for light @xmath61 @xcite(for the dependence of @xmath256 coupling on @xmath54 , see sec .
this figure also indicates that for the nmssm and the nmssm , @xmath54 is upper bounded by @xmath257 .
for the nmssm , this is because large @xmath87 can suppress the dark matter mass to make its annihilation difficult ( see @xcite and also sec .
ii ) , but for the nmssm , this is because we choose a light slepton mass so that large @xmath54 can enhance @xmath208 too significantly to be experimentally unacceptable .
we checked that for the slepton mass as heavy as @xmath258 , @xmath259 is still allowed for the nmssm . in fig.[fig5 ] and fig.[fig6 ] , we show the branching ratios of @xmath260 and @xmath261 respectively .
fig.[fig5 ] indicates , among the four models , the type - ii 2hdm predicts the largest ratio for @xmath260 with its value varying from @xmath262 to @xmath263 .
the underlying reason is in the type - ii 2hdm , the @xmath264 coupling is enhanced by @xmath54 ( see fig.[fig4 ] ) , while in the other three model , the coupling is suppressed either by @xmath265 or by the singlet component of the @xmath0 .
fig.[fig6 ] shows that the l2hdm predicts the largest rate for @xmath266 with its value reaching @xmath5 in optimum case , and for the other three models , the ratio of @xmath261 is at least about one order smaller than that of @xmath267 .
this feature can be easily understood from the @xmath268 coupling introduced in sect .
we emphasize that , if the nature prefers a light @xmath0 , @xmath260 and/or @xmath269 in the type - ii 2hdm and the l2hdm will be observable at the gigaz . then by the rates of the two decays
, one can determine whether the type - ii 2hdm or the l2hdm is the right theory .
on the other hand , if both decays are observed with small rates or fail to be observed , the singlet extensions of the mssm are favored . in fig.[fig7
] , we show the rate of @xmath3 as the function of @xmath270 .
this figure indicates that the branching ratio of @xmath121 can reach @xmath271 , @xmath272 , @xmath273 and @xmath274 for the optimal cases of the type - ii 2hdm , the l2hdm , the nmssm and the nmssm respectively , which implies that the decay @xmath121 will never be observable at the gigaz if the studied model is chosen by nature .
the reason for the smallness is , as we pointed out before , that the decay @xmath121 proceeds only at loop level . comparing the optimum cases of the type - ii 2hdm , the nmssm and the nmssm shown in fig.5 - 7
, one may find that the relation @xmath275 holds for any of the decays .
this is because the decays are all induced by the yukawa couplings with similar structure for the models . in the supersymmetric models ,
the large singlet component of the light @xmath0 is to suppress the yukawa couplings , and the @xmath0 in the nmssm has more singlet component than that in the nmssm .
next we consider the decay @xmath11 , which , unlike the above decays , depends on the higgs self interactions . in fig.[fig8 ] we plot its rate as a function of @xmath270 and this figure indicates that the @xmath276 may be the largest among the ratios of the exotic @xmath1 decays , reaching @xmath277 in the optimum cases of the type - ii 2hdm , the l2hdm and the nmssm .
the underlying reason is , in some cases , the intermediate state @xmath119 in fig.[fig3 ] ( a ) may be on - shell .
in fact , we find this is one of the main differences between the nmssm and the nmssm , that is , in the nmssm , @xmath119 in fig.[fig3 ] ( a ) may be on - shell ( corresponds to the points with large @xmath278 ) while in the nmssm , this seems impossible .
so we conclude that the decay @xmath11 may serve as an alternative channel to test new physics models , especially it may be used to distinguish the nmssm from the nmssm if the supersymmetry is found at the lhc and the @xmath11 is observed at the gigaz with large rate .
before we end our discussion , we note that in the nmssm , the higgs boson @xmath0 may be lighter than @xmath279 without conflicting with low energy data from @xmath178 decays and the other observables ( see fig.[fig4]-[fig8 ] ) . in this case , @xmath0 is axion - like as pointed out in @xcite .
we checked that , among the rare @xmath1 decays discussed in this paper , the largest branching ratio comes from @xmath280 which can reach @xmath281 . since in this case , the decay product of @xmath0 is highly collinear muon pair , detecting the decay @xmath280 may need some knowledge about detectors , which is beyond our discussion .
in this paper , we studied the rare @xmath1-decays @xmath2 ( @xmath7 ) , @xmath282 and @xmath4 in the type - ii 2hdm , lepton - specific 2hdm , nmssm and nmssm , which predict a light cp - odd higgs boson @xmath0 . in the parameter space allowed by current experiments , the branching ratio can be as large as @xmath5 for @xmath118 , @xmath8 for @xmath3 and @xmath9 for @xmath4 , which implies that the decays @xmath2 and @xmath283 may be accessible at the gigaz option .
since different models predict different size of branching ratios , these decays can be used to distinguish different model through the measurement of these rare decays .
this work was supported in part by hastit under grant no .
2009hastit004 , by the national natural science foundation of china ( nnsfc ) under grant nos . 10821504 , 10725526 , 10635030 , 10775039 , 11075045 and by the project of knowledge innovation program ( pkip ) of chinese academy of sciences under grant no .
. for some reviews , see , e.g. , m. a. perez , g. tavares - velasco and j. j. toscano , int .
j. mod .
a * 19 * , 159 ( 2004 ) ; j. m. yang , arxiv:1006.2594 .
j. i. illana , m. masip , 67 , 035004 ( 2003 ) ; j. cao , z. xiong , j. m. yang , 32 , 245 ( 2004 ) .
d. atwood _
et al_. , 66 , 093005 ( 2002 ) . j. kalinowski , and s. pokorski , 219 , 116 ( 1989 ) ; a. djouadi , p. m. zerwas and j. zunft , 259 , 175 ( 1991 ) ; a. djouadi , j. kalinowski , and p. m. zerwas , z. phys .
c * 54 * , 255 ( 1992 ) .
m. krawczyk , _ et al .
_ , 19 , 463 ( 2001 ) ; 8 , 495 ( 1999 )
. j. f. gunion , g. gamberini and s. f. novaes , 38 , 3481 ( 1988 ) ; thomas j. weiler and tzu - chiang yuan , 318 , 337 ( 1989 ) ; a. djouadi , _ et al .
_ , 1 , 163 ( 1998)[hep - ph/9701342 ] .
d. chang and w. y. keung , phys .
lett . * 77 * , 3732 ( 1996 ) .
e. keith and e. ma , 57 , 2017 ( 1998 ) ; m. a. perez , g. tavares - velasco and j. j. toscano , int .
j. mod.phys .
a * 19 * , 159 ( 2004 ) .
f. larios , g. tavares - velasco and c. p. yuan , 64 , 055004 ( 2001 ) ; 66 , 075006 ( 2002 ) .
a. djouadi , _ et al .
_ , 10 , 27 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9903229 ]
. for a detailed introduction of the nmssm , see f. franke and h. fraas , int .
j. mod .
a * 12 * ( 1997 ) 479 ; for a recent review of the nmssm , see for example , u. ellwanger , c. hugonie , and a. m. teixeira , arxiv : 0910.1785 .
see , e.g. , j. r. ellis , j. f. gunion , h. e. haber , l. roszkowski and f. zwirner , phys . rev .
d * 39 * ( 1989 ) 844 ; m. drees , int .
j. mod .
phys . a * 4 * ( 1989 ) 3635 ; u. ellwanger , m. rausch de traubenberg and c. a. savoy , phys .
b * 315 * ( 1993 ) 331 ; nucl .
b * 492 * ( 1997 ) 21 ; d.j .
miller , r. nevzorov , p.m. zerwas , 681 , 3 ( 2004 ) . c. panagiotakopoulos , k. tamvakis , 446 , 224 ( 1999 ) ; 469 , 145 ( 1999 ) ; c. panagiotakopoulos , a. pilaftsis , 63 , 055003 ( 2001 ) ; a. dedes , _ et al . _ , 63 , 055009 ( 2001 ) ; a. menon , _ et al . _ , 70 , 035005 ( 2004 ) ; v. barger , _ et al .
_ , 630 , 85 ( 2005 ) .
c. balazs , _ et al .
_ , 0706 , 066 ( 2007 ) . b. a. dobrescu , k. t. matchev , 0009 , 031 ( 2000 ) ; a. arhrib , k. cheung , t. j. hou , k. w. song , hep - ph/0611211 ; 0703 , 073 ( 2007 ) ; x. g. he , j. tandean , and g. valencia , 98 , 081802 ( 2007 ) ; 0806 , 002 ( 2008 ) ; f. domingo _ et al_. , 0901 , 061 ( 2009 ) ; gudrun hiller , 70 , 034018 ( 2004 ) ; r. dermisek , and john f. gunion , 75 , 075019 ( 2007 ) ; 79 , 055014 ( 2009 ) ; 81 , 055001 ( 2010 ) ; r. dermisek , john f. gunion , and b. mcelrath , 76 , 051105 ( 2007 ) ; z. heng , _ et al_. , 77 , 095012 ( 2008 ) ; a. belyaev _
et al_. , 81 , 075021 ( 2010 ) ; d.
das and u. ellwanger , arxiv:1007.1151 [ hep - ph ] . s. andreas , o. lebedev , s. ramos - sanchez and a. ringwald , arxiv:1005.3978 [ hep - ph ] .
j. f. gunion , jhep * 0908 * , 032 ( 2009 ) ; r. dermisek and j. f. gunion , phys . rev .
d * 81 * , 075003 ( 2010 ) .
r. dermisek and j. f. gunion , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 041801 ( 2005 ) ; phys .
d * 73 * , 111701 ( 2006 ) .
j. cao , h. e. logan , j. m. yang , 79 , 091701 ( 2009 ) .
j. cao , p. wan , l. wu , j. m. yang , 80 , 071701 ( 2009 ) . j. f. gunion and h. e. haber , 67 , 075019 ( 2003 ) .
r. m. barnett , _ et al .
_ , phys .
b * 136 * , 191 ( 1984 ) ; r. m. barnett , g. senjanovic and d. wyler , phys .
d * 30 * , 1529 ( 1984 ) ; y. grossman , nucl .
b * 426 * , 355 ( 1994 ) .
h. s. goh , l. j. hall and p. kumar , jhep * 0905 * , 097 ( 2009 ) ; a. g. akeroyd and w. j. stirling , nucl .
b * 447 * , 3 ( 1995 ) ; a. g. akeroyd , phys .
b * 377 * , 95 ( 1996 ) ; h. e. logan and d. maclennan , phys . rev .
d * 79 * , 115022 ( 2009 ) ; m. aoki , _ et al .
_ , arxiv:0902.4665 [ hep - ph ]
. v. barger , p. langacker , h. s. lee and g. shaughnessy , phys .
d * 73 * , 115010 ( 2006 ) .
s. hesselbach , _ et .
_ , arxiv:0810.0511v2 [ hep - ph ] .
de vivie and p. janot [ aleph collaboration ] , pa13 - 027 contribution to the international conference on high energy physics , warsaw , poland , 2531 july 1996 ; j.
kurowska , o. grajek and p. zalewski [ delphi collaboration ] , cern - open-99 - 385 .
[ aleph collaboration and delphi collaboration and l3 collaboration ] , phys .
rept . * 427 * , 257 ( 2006 ) .
j. cao and j. m. yang , jhep * 0812 * , 006 ( 2008 ) .
m. krawczyk and d. temes , eur .
j. c * 44 * , 435 ( 2005 ) .
g. altarelli and r. barbieri , 253 , 161 ( 1991 ) ; m. e. peskin , t. takeuchi , 46 , 381 ( 1992 ) . c. amsler , _ et al .
_ , ( particle data group ) , 667 , 1 ( 2008 ) .
o. deschamps , s. descotes - genon , s. monteil , v. niess , s. tjampens and v. tisserand , arxiv:0907.5135 [ hep - ph ] .
s. su and b. thomas , phys .
d * 79 * , 095014 ( 2009 ) .
g. abbiendi , _ et al .
_ , eur . phys .
j. c * 32 * , 453 ( 2004 ) .
m. davier , _ et al .
_ , 66 , 1 ( 2010 ) .
k. cheung , _ et al .
_ , phys .
d * 64 * , 111301 ( 2001 ) .
k. cheung and o. c. w. kong , phys .
d * 68 * , 053003 ( 2003 ) .
t. besmer , c. greub , t.hurth , 609 , 359 ( 2001 ) ; f. borzumati , _ et al .
_ , 62 , 075005(2000 )
. j. cao , k. i. hikasa , w. wang , j. m. yang and l. x. yu , phys .
d * 82 * , 051701 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1006.4811 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. f. gunion , _ et .
d * 73 * , 015011 ( 2006 ) .
martin and j. d. wells , phys .
d * 64 * , 035003 ( 2001 ) .
j. abdallah _ et al .
_ , eur .
j. c * 31 * , 421 ( 2004 ) ; g. abbiendi _ et al .
_ , eur .
j. c * 35 * , 1 ( 2004 ) .
j. dunkley _ et al .
_ [ wmap collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. suppl .
* 180 * , 306 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0803.0586 [ astro - ph ] ] .
u. ellwanger _
et al . _ , 02 , 066 ( 2005 ) .
g. belanger , f. boudjema , a. pukhov and a. semenov , comput .
commun . * 174 * , 577 ( 2006 ) ; comput .
phys . commun .
* 176 * , 367 ( 2007 ) .
g. belanger , f. boudjema , c. hugonie , a. pukhov and a. semenov , jcap * 0509 * , 001 ( 2005 ) .
|
various new physics models predict a light cp - odd higgs boson ( labeled as @xmath0 ) and open up new decay modes for @xmath1-boson , such as @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 , which could be explored at the gigaz option of the ilc . in this work
we investigate these rare decays in several new physics models , namely the type - ii two higgs doublet model ( type - ii 2hdm ) , the lepton - specific two higgs doublet model ( l2hdm ) , the nearly minimal supersymetric standard model ( nmssm ) and the next - to - minimal supersymmetric standard model ( nmssm ) .
we find that in the parameter space allowed by current experiments , the branching ratios can reach @xmath5 for @xmath6 ( @xmath7 ) , @xmath8 for @xmath3 and @xmath9 for @xmath4 , which implies that the decays @xmath10 and @xmath11 may be accessible at the gigaz option .
moreover , since different models predict different patterns of the branching ratios , the measurement of these rare decays at the gigaz may be utilized to distinguish the models .
|
it is well known that the classical magnetoresistance ( mr ) in metals or semiconductors with a closed free electron fermi surface increases quadratically with increasing magnetic field @xmath2 for @xmath3 and saturates when @xmath4 . here
@xmath5 is the zero - magnetic - field mobility .
hence , the extraordinarily high and linear mr ( lmr ) , which breaks this familiar rule , has been gaining much attention as soon as its discovery . in the past decade
, this unexpected lmr has been reported in silver chalcogenide,@xcite indium antimonide,@xcite silicon,@xcite mnas - gaas composite material,@xcite and graphene.@xcite kapitza s linear law@xcite indicates that the metal shows a magnetoresistance linear in perpendicular magnetic field when it has an open fermi surface and a mean free path longer than the electronic larmor radius .
recently , another two models , irrespective of the open fermi surface , have been constructed to provide possible mechanisms for the lmr phenomenon .
abrikosov suggested a quantum - limit origin of lmr for the homogenous system with a gapless linear energy spectrum.@xcite his model requires that landau levels are well formed and the carrier concentration is small that all electrons occupy only the lowest landau band .
alternatively , parish and littlewood developed a classical model without involving linear spectrum.@xcite ignoring the concrete microscopic mechanism , they attributed this unusual mr to the mobility fluctuations in a strongly inhomogenous system .
topological insulators@xcite ( tis ) are novel materials with a full energy gap in bulk , while there are gapless surface states . due to its unique band structure with only one helical dirac cone and linear energy dispersion,@xcite the surface states of the ti bi@xmath0se@xmath1 become an excellent platform for the study of quantum - limit lmr .
the recent experiment in this flat surface system , however , reported that a large positive mr , which becomes very linear above a characteristic field of @xmath6@xmath7@xmath8 t , was observed even in an opposite situation where the carrier sheet density is high that electrons occupy more than one landau levels.@xcite moreover , they found that raising temperature to room temperature almost has no influence on the observed lmr .
it is striking that this observation is in conflict with abrikosov s model and also with the classical parish - littlewood model .
so far a reliable theoretical scheme capable of explaining this novel experiment has still been lacking . in this paper
, we generalize the balance - equation approach@xcite to a system modeling the surface states of a three - dimensional ti to investigate the two - dimensional magnetotransport in it .
we find that a positive , nonsaturating and dominantly linear magnetoresistance can appear within quite wide magnetic - field range in the ti surface state having a positive and finite effective g - factor .
this linear magnetoresistance shows up in the system of high carrier concentration and low mobility when electrons are in extended states and spread over many smeared landau levels , and persists up to room temperature , providing a possible mechanism for the recently observed linear magnetoresistance in topological insulator bi@xmath0se@xmath1 nanoribbons.@xcite
we consider the surface state of a bi@xmath0se@xmath1-type large bulk gap ti in the @xmath9-@xmath10 plane under the influence of a uniform magnetic field @xmath11 applied along the @xmath12 direction.@xcite following the experimental observation,@xcite we assume that the fermi energy locates in the gap of the bulk band and above the dirac point , i.e. the surface carriers are electrons .
further , the separations of the fermi energy from the bottom of bulk band and dirac point are much larger than the highest temperature ( @xmath13 ) considered in this work .
hence , the contribution from the bulk band to the magnetotransport is negligible .
these electrons , scattered by randomly distributed impurities and by phonons , are driven by a uniform in - plane electric field @xmath14 in the topological surface .
the hamiltonian of this many - electron and phonon system consists of an electron part @xmath15 , a phonon part @xmath16 , and electron - impurity and electron - phonon interactions @xmath17 and @xmath18 : @xmath19 here , the electron hamiltonian is taken in the form @xmath20 , \ ] ] in which @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 and @xmath24 , stand , respectively , for the canonical momentum , coordinate , momentum and spin operators of the @xmath25th electron having charge @xmath26 , @xmath27 is the vector potential of the perpendicular magnetic field @xmath28 in the landau gauge , @xmath29 is the fermi velocity , @xmath30 is the effective g - factor of the surface electron , and @xmath31 is the bohr magneton with @xmath32 the free electron mass .
the sum index @xmath25 in eq.([helectron ] ) goes over all electrons of total number @xmath33 in the surface state of unit area . in the frame work of balance equation approach,@xcite the two - dimensional center - of - mass ( c.m . )
momentum and coordinate @xmath34 and @xmath35 , and the relative - electron momenta and coordinates @xmath36 and @xmath37 are introduced to write the hamiltonian @xmath15 into the sum of a single - particle c.m .
part @xmath38 and a many - particle relative - electron part @xmath39 : @xmath40 , with @xmath41.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this , @xmath42 is the canonical momentum of the center - of - mass and @xmath43 is the canonical momentum for the @xmath25th relative electron . here
we have also introduced c.m .
spin operators @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
the commutation relations between the c.m .
spin operators @xmath46 and @xmath47 and the spin operators @xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath50 of the @xmath25th electron are of order of @xmath51 : @xmath52= n^{-1}2\,{\rm i}\,\varepsilon_{\beta_1\beta_2\beta_3}\sigma_j^{\beta_3}$ ] with @xmath53 .
therefore , for a macroscopic large @xmath33 system , the c.m .
part @xmath38 actually commutes with the relative - electron part @xmath54 in the hamiltonian , i.e. the c.m .
motion and the relative motion of electrons are truly separated from each other .
the couplings between the two emerge only through the electron
impurity and electron phonon interactions .
furthermore , the electric field @xmath55 shows up only in @xmath38 . and , in view of @xmath56={\rm i}\delta_{\alpha \beta}(\delta_{ij}-1/n)\simeq { \rm i}\delta_{\alpha\beta}\delta_{ij}$ ] , i.e. the relative - electron momenta and coordinates can be treated as canonical conjugate variables , the relative - motion part @xmath54 is just the hamiltonian of @xmath33 electrons in the surface state of ti in the magnetic field without the presence of the electric field . in terms of the c.m .
coordinate @xmath57 and the relative electron density operator @xmath58 , the electron impurity and electron phonon interactions can be written as@xcite @xmath59 here @xmath60 and @xmath61 are respectively the impurity potential ( an impurity at randomly distributed position @xmath62 ) and electron phonon coupling matrix element in the plane - wave representation , and @xmath63 with @xmath64 and @xmath65 being the creation and annihilation operators for a phonon of wavevector @xmath66 in branch @xmath67 having frequency @xmath68 .
velocity ( operator ) @xmath69 is the time variation of its coordinate : @xmath70= v_{\rm f}(\sigma_{\rm c}^y\ , \hat{i}-\sigma_{\rm c}^x\ , \hat{j})$ ] . to derive a force - balance equation for steady state transport we consider the heisenberg equation for the rate of change of the c.m .
canonical momentum @xmath71 : @xmath72= - n e({\bm v}\times { \bm b})- n e{\bm e}+{\bm { f}}_{\rm i}+{\bm { f}}_{\rm p},\ ] ] in which the frictional forces @xmath73 and @xmath74 share the same expressions as given in ref .. the statistical average of the operator equation can be determined to linear order in the electron
impurity and electron phonon interactions @xmath17 and @xmath18 with the initial density matrix @xmath75 at temperature @xmath76 when the in - plane electric field @xmath77 is not strong . for steady - transport states we have @xmath78 ,
leading to a force - balance equation of the form @xmath79 here @xmath80 , the statistically averaged velocity of the moving center - of - mass , is identified as the average rate of change of its position , i.e. the drift velocity of the electron system driven by the electric field @xmath77 , and @xmath81 and @xmath82 are frictional forces experienced by the center - of - mass due to impurity and phonon scatterings : @xmath83,\label{fp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in which @xmath84 is the bose distribution function , @xmath85 , and @xmath86 stands for the imaginary part of the fourier spectrum of the relative - electron density correlation function defined by @xmath87\big\rangle_{0},\ ] ] where @xmath88 and @xmath89 denotes the statistical averaging over the initial density matrix @xmath90.@xcite the force - balance equation describes the steady - state two - dimensional magnetotransport in the surface state of a ti .
note that the frictional forces @xmath81 and @xmath82 are in the opposite direction of the drift velocity @xmath91 and their magnitudes are functions of @xmath92 only . with the drift velocity @xmath93 in the @xmath9 direction , the force - balance equation eq .
yields a transverse resistivity @xmath94 , and a longitudinal resistivity @xmath95 .
the linear one is in the form @xmath96
for calculating the electron density correlation function @xmath97 we proceed in the landau representation.@xcite the landau levels of the single - particle hamiltonian @xmath98 of the relative - electron system in the absence of electric field are composed of a positive `` @xmath99 '' and a negative `` @xmath100 '' branch@xcite @xmath101 with @xmath102 and @xmath103 , and a zero ( @xmath104 ) level @xmath105 the corresponding landau wave functions are @xmath106 and @xmath107 for @xmath108 ; and @xmath109 for @xmath104 . here
@xmath110 is the wavevector of the system along @xmath9 direction ; @xmath111 with @xmath112 ; and @xmath113 is the harmonic oscillator eigenfunction with @xmath114 being the hermite polynomial , @xmath115 , and @xmath116 .
each landau level contains @xmath117 electron states for system of unit surface area . the positive branch @xmath118 and the @xmath104 level @xmath119 of the above energy spectra are indeed quite close to those of the surface states in the bulk gap of bi@xmath0se@xmath1-family materials derived from microscopic band calculation.@xcite the landau levels are broadened due to impurity , phonon and electron - electron scatterings .
we model the imaginary part of the retarded green s function , or the density - of - states , of the broadened landau level @xmath120 ( written for `` + ' ' -branch and @xmath104 levels ) , using a gaussian - type form:@xcite @xmath121,\ ] ] with a half - width @xmath122 of the form:@xcite @xmath123^{1/2}$ ] . here
@xmath124 is the single - particle lifetime and @xmath125 is the cyclotron frequency of linear - energy - dispersion system with @xmath126 being the zero - temperature fermi level . using a semi - empirical parameter @xmath127 to relate @xmath124 with the transport scattering time @xmath128 , and expressing @xmath129 with the zero - field mobility @xmath5 at finite temperature,@xcite we can write the landau - level broadening as @xmath130^{1/2}.\ ] ] in the present study we consider the case of @xmath120-doping ,
i.e. the fermi level is high enough above the energy zero of the dirac cone in the range of `` + ' ' -branch levels and the states of `` @xmath100''-branch levels are completely filled , that they are irrelevant to electron transport .
special attention has to be paid to the @xmath104 level , since , depending on the direction of exchange potential the effective g - factor of a ti surface state , @xmath30 , can be positive , zero or negative.@xcite the sign and magnitude of the effective g - factor determines how many states of the zero level should be included in or excluded from the available states for electron occupation in the case of @xmath120-doping at a magnetic field .
( i ) if @xmath131 , the @xmath104 level center is exactly at @xmath132 and the system is electron - hole symmetric .
the total number of negative energy states ( including the states of the lower half of the @xmath104 level and states of the
@xmath100"-branch levels ) and that of positive energy states ( including the states of the upper half of the @xmath104 level and states of the @xmath99"-branch levels ) do not change when changing magnetic field .
therefore , the lower - half negative energy states of this level are always filled and the upper - half positive - energy states of it are available for the occupation of particles which are counted as electrons participating in transport in the case of @xmath120-doping .
( ii ) for a finite positive @xmath133 , the @xmath104 level @xmath134 moves downward to negative energy and its distance to the nearest
@xmath100"-branch level is @xmath135 closer than to the nearest
+ " -branch level at finite magnetic field strength @xmath2 .
this is equivalent to the opening of an increasingly enlarged ( with increasing @xmath2 ) energy gap between the + " -branch states and the states of the zero - level and the
@xmath100"-branch levels .
the opening of a sufficient energy gap implies that with increasing magnetic field the states in the
+ " -branch levels would no longer shrink into the zero - level , and thus the @xmath104 level should be completely excluded from the conduction band , i.e. only particles occupying the + " -branch states are counted as electrons participating in transport in the case of @xmath120-doping , when the magnetic field @xmath2 gets larger than a certain value ( depending on the magnitude of @xmath30 ) .
( iii ) for a finite negative @xmath136 , the @xmath104 level @xmath134 moves upward to positive energy and an increasingly enlarged energy gap will be opened between the states of the zero - level and the + " -branch and the states of
@xmath100"-branch levels , and particles occupying the @xmath104 level and + " -branch states are electrons participating in transport when the magnetic field @xmath2 gets larger than a certain value . as a result ,
the experimentally accessible sheet density @xmath33 of electrons participating in transport is related to the fermi energy @xmath137 by the following equation valid at finite @xmath30 for the magnetic field @xmath2 larger than a certain value : @xmath138 in which @xmath139 + 1\}^{-1}$ ] is the fermi distribution function at temperature @xmath76 and the summation index @xmath120 goes over @xmath140 for @xmath133 , or @xmath141 for @xmath136 . in the case of @xmath131 , @xmath142\ ] ]
valid for arbitrary magnetic field , in which @xmath143 .
the imaginary part of relative - electron density correlation function in the presence of a magnetic field , @xmath86 , can be expressed in the landau representation as@xcite @xmath144 in which the transform factor @xmath145 ^ 2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath146 , @xmath147 , @xmath148 , and @xmath149 being associated laguerre polynomials .
the landau - representation correlation function @xmath150 in eq.([piqw ] ) can be constructed with the imaginary part of the retarded green s function @xmath151 , or the density - of - states , of the @xmath120th landau level as@xcite @xmath152\nonumber\\ & \hspace{1.2cm}\times{\rm im}g_n(\epsilon+\omega){\rm im}g_{n'}(\epsilon).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the summation indices @xmath120 and @xmath153 in eq.([piqw ] ) are taken over @xmath140 for @xmath133 , or @xmath154 for @xmath136 . in the case of @xmath131 , eq.([piqw ] ) still works and the summation indices @xmath120 and @xmath153 go over @xmath154 but with @xmath155 replaced by @xmath156 in eq.([p2nn ] ) .
numerical calculations are performed for the magnetoresistivity @xmath157 of surface state in a uniform ti bi@xmath0se@xmath1 . at zero temperature
the elastic scattering contributing to the resistivity is modeled by a coulomb potential due to charged impurities:@xcite @xmath158 with @xmath159 being the impurity density , which is determined by the zero - magnetic - field mobility @xmath5 . at temperatures higher than @xmath160,@xcite phonon scatterings
play increasingly important role and the dominant inelastic contribution comes from optical phonons . for this polar material , the scattering by optical phonons via the deformation potential can be neglected .
hence , we take account of inelastic scattering from optical phonons via frhlich coupling : @xmath161 . in the numerical calculation we use the following parameters:@xcite fermi velocity @xmath162 , static dielectric constant @xmath163 , optical dielectric constant @xmath164 , and phonon energy @xmath165 .
the broadening parameter is taken to be @xmath166 . as a function of the magnetic field @xmath2 having different effective g - factors : @xmath167 and @xmath168 for a ti surface system with electron sheet density @xmath169 in the cases of zero - magnetic - field mobility @xmath170 ( a ) and @xmath171 ( b ) .
several integer - number positions of filling factor @xmath172 are marked in ( b).,scaledwidth=40.0% ] fig.[diffg ] shows the calculated magnetoresistivity @xmath157 versus the magnetic field strength @xmath2 for a ti surface system with electron sheet density @xmath169 but having different effective g - factors : @xmath167 and @xmath168 for two values of zero - magnetic - field mobility @xmath170 and @xmath171 , representing different degree of landau - level broadening . in the case without zeeman splitting ( @xmath131 ) the resistivity @xmath157 exhibits almost no change with changing magnetic field up to 10 t , except the shubnikov - de haas ( sdh ) oscillation showing up in the case of @xmath171 . this kind of magnetoresistance behavior was indeed seen experimentally in the electron - hole symmetrical massless system of single - layer graphene.@xcite in the case of a positive g - factor , @xmath173 , the magnetoresistivity increases linearly with increasing magnetic field ; while for a negative g - factor , @xmath174 , the magnetoresistivity decreases linearly with increasing magnetic field .
is shown as a function of the magnetic field @xmath2 for different values of zero - magnetic - field mobility : ( a ) @xmath175 , ( b ) @xmath176 , ( c ) @xmath177 , ( d ) @xmath178 , ( e ) @xmath179 , and ( f ) @xmath180 .
the inset of ( a ) illustrates the same for a larger magnetic - field range @xmath181 .
the filling factor @xmath182 is plotted versus the magnetic field in ( f ) ; and several integer - number positions of @xmath182 are also marked in ( d ) and ( e ) . here the surface electron density @xmath169 and the lattice temperature @xmath183.,scaledwidth=47.0% ] in the following we will give more detailed examination on the linearly increasing magnetoresistance in the positive @xmath30 case .
fig.[rhob ] shows the calculated resistivity @xmath157 versus the magnetic field strength @xmath2 at lattice temperature @xmath183 for system of carrier sheet density @xmath169 and @xmath173 , having different zero - field mobility @xmath184 and @xmath180 .
all resistivity curves for mobility @xmath185 exhibit clear linearity in the magnetic - field range and appear no tendency of saturation at the highest field shown in the figure .
especially , for the case @xmath170 , the linear behavior extends even up to the magnetic field of @xmath186 , as illustrated in the inset of fig.[rhob](a ) .
this feature contradicts the classical mr which saturates at sufficiently large magnetic field @xmath187 .
note that here we only present the calculated @xmath157 for magnetic field @xmath2 larger than @xmath188 t , for which a sufficient energy gap @xmath135 is assumed to open that with further increase of the magnetic field the states in the `` + ' ' -branch levels no longer shrink into the zero level and thus it should be excluded from the conduction band .
this is of course not true for very weak magnetic field . when @xmath189 the energy gap @xmath190 , the situation becomes similar to the case of @xmath131
: the whole upper half of the zero - level states are available to electron occupation and we should have a flat resistivity @xmath157 when changing magnetic field .
with increasing @xmath2 the portion of the zero - level states available to conduction electrons decreases until the magnetic field reaches @xmath191 . as a result
the resistivity @xmath157 should exhibit a crossover from a flat changing at small @xmath2 to positively linear increasing at @xmath192 .
this is just the behavior observed in the ti bi@xmath0se@xmath1.@xcite note that in the case of @xmath170 , the broadened landau - level widths are always larger than the neighboring level interval : @xmath193 , which requires @xmath194 ^ 2 $ ] , even for the lowest landau level @xmath195 , i.e. the whole landau - level spectrum is smeared . with increasing the zero - field mobility the magnitude of resistivity @xmath157 decreases , and
when the broadened landau - level width becomes smaller than the neighboring level interval , @xmath196 , a weak sdh oscillation begin to occur around the linearly - dependent average value of @xmath157 at higher portion of the magnetic field range , as seen in fig.[rhob](c ) , ( d ) and ( e ) for @xmath197 and @xmath198 . on the other hand , in the case of large mobility , e.g. @xmath199 , where the broadened landau - level widths @xmath200 are much smaller than the neighboring level interval even for level index @xmath120 as large as @xmath201 , the magnetoresistivity shows pronounced sdh oscillation and the linear - dependent behavior disappears , before the appearance of quantum hall effect,@xcite as shown in fig.[rhob](f ) .
abrikosov s model for the lmr requires the applied magnetic field large enough to reach the quantum limit at which all the carriers are within the lowest landau level,@xcite while it is obvious that more than one landau levels are occupied in the experimental samples in the field range in which the linear and non - saturating magnetoresistivity was observed.@xcite for the given electron surface density @xmath202 , the number of occupied landau levels , or the filling factor @xmath172 , at different magnetic fields is shown in fig.[rhob](f ) , as well as in the fig.[rhob](d ) and ( e ) , where the integer - number positions of @xmath203 , i.e. filling up to entire @xmath182 landau levels , coincide with the minima of the density - of - states or the dips of sdh oscillation .
this is in contrast with @xmath131 case , where the integer number of @xmath203 , which implies a filling up to the center position of the @xmath182th landau levels , locates at a peak of sdh oscillation , as shown in fig.[diffg]b .
the observed sdh oscillations in the bi@xmath0se@xmath1 nanoribbon exhibiting nonsaturating surface lmr in the experiment@xcite favor the former case : a finite positive effective @xmath133 . is plotted as a function of the surface electron density @xmath33 at magnetic field @xmath204 : ( a ) at different values of zero - field mobility @xmath5 , and ( b ) at different values of zero - field conductivity @xmath205.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] at various lattice temperatures . here
the zero - magnetic - field mobility at zero temperature is @xmath206.,scaledwidth=35.0% ] next , we examine the density - dependence of the linear magnetoresistivity . to compare with abrikosov s quantum magnetoresistance which suggests a @xmath207 behavior,@xcite
we show the calculated @xmath208 for above lmr versus the carrier sheet density @xmath33 in fig.[rhon ] at fixed magnetic field @xmath209 t .
the mobility is taken respectively to be @xmath210 and @xmath211m@xmath212/vs to make the resistivity in the lmr regime .
a clearly linear dependence of @xmath213 on the surface density @xmath33 is seen in all cases , indicating that this non - saturating linear resistivity is almost inversely proportional to the carrier density . in the figure
we also show @xmath208 versus @xmath33 under the condition of different given conductivity @xmath214 and @xmath215 . in this case
the half - width @xmath216 is independent of surface density .
the linear dependence still holds , indicating that this linear behavior is not sensitive to the modest @xmath33-dependence of landau level broadening @xmath216 as long as the system is in the overlapped landau level regime . from the above discussion
, it is obvious that lmr shows up in the system having overlapped landau levels and the separation of landau levels makes the mr departure from the linear increase . at high temperature , the thermal energy would smear the level separation and phonon scatterings further broaden landau levels .
hence , it is believed that this lmr will be robust against raising temperature .
this is indeed the case as seen in fig.[rhot ] , where we plot the calculated magnetoresistivity @xmath157 for the above system with zero - temperature linear mobility @xmath217m@xmath212/vs versus the magnetic field at different lattice temperatures .
we can see that raising temperature to room temperature has little effect on the linearity of mr .
due to the decreased mobility at higher temperature from phonon scattering , the weak sdh oscillation on the linear background tends to vanish .
these features are in good agreement with the experimental report.@xcite
in summary , we have studied the two - dimensional magnetotransport in the flat surface of a three - dimensional ti , which arises from the surface states with a wavevector - linear energy dispersion and a finite , positive zeeman splitting within the bulk energy gap .
when the level broadening is comparable to or larger than the landau - level separation and the conduction electrons spread over many landau levels , a positive , dominantly linear and non - saturating magnetoresistance appears within a quite wide range of magnetic field and persists up to room temperature .
this remarkable lmr provides a possible mechanism for the recently observed linear magnetoresistance in topological insulator bi@xmath0se@xmath1 nanoribbons.@xcite in contrast to quantum hall effect which appears in the case of well formed landau levels and to abrikosov s quantum magnetotransport,@xcite which is limited to the extreme quantum limit that all electrons coalesce into the lowest landau level , the discussed lmr is a phenomena of pure classical two - dimensional magnetotransport in a system having linear - energy - dispersion , appearing in the regime of overlapped landau levels , irrespective of its showing up in relatively high magnetic field range .
furthermore , the present scheme deals with spatially uniform case without invoking the mobility fluctuation in a strongly inhomogeneous system , which is required in the classical parish and littlewood model to produce a lmr.@xcite the appearance of this significant positive - increasing linear magnetoresistance depends on the existence of a positive and sizable effective g - factor . if the zeeman energy splitting is quite small the resistivity @xmath157 would exhibit little change with changing magnetic field . in the case of a negative and sizable effective g - factor
the magnetoresistivity would decrease linearly with increasing magnetic field .
therefore , the behavior of the longitudinal resistivity versus magnetic field may provide a useful way for judging the direction and the size of the effective zeeman energy splitting in ti surface states .
this work was supported by the national science foundation of china ( grant no .
11104002 ) , the national basic research program of china ( grant no .
2012cb927403 ) and by the program for science&technology innovation talents in universities of henan province ( grant no .
2012hastit029 ) .
|
a positive , non - saturating and dominantly linear magnetoresistance is demonstrated to occur in the surface state of a topological insulator having a wavevector - linear energy dispersion together with a finite positive zeeman energy splitting .
this linear magnetoresistance shows up within quite wide magnetic - field range in a spatially homogenous system of high carrier density and low mobility in which the conduction electrons are in extended states and spread over many smeared landau levels , and is robust against increasing temperature , in agreement with recent experimental findings in bi@xmath0se@xmath1 nanoribbons .
|
a magnitude limited complete census of variable stars in nearby dwarf galaxies allows important contributions to the star formation history of these systems . measurements of some variable stars can supply improved distance determinations for the host galaxies , others will provide important constraints for the population analysis .
different classes of variables can further improve the understanding of the star formation history of these system , functioning as tracers of star formation during different epochs .
we expect the data set of our long term monitoring program to be especially well suited to study the contents of red long - period variables and to re - investigate the paucity of cepheids with @xmath1 days as reported by sandage & carlson ( 1985 ) .
we selected a sample of six local group dwarf irregular galaxies which are visible with the 0.8 m telescope of our institute at mt .
the names and additional data from the literature compilation by mateo ( 1998 ) are shown in table 1 .
.names , variable star counts , absolute @xmath2-band brightness in mag , and current distance estimation in kpc for the dwarf galaxies observed in our project .
the data are taken from the literature compilation by mateo ( 1995 ) .
for leo a the data are from the work of dolphin et .
al ( 2002 ) and from this work . [ cols="<,<,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] @xmath3 this work the observations so far were carried out in @xmath4 and @xmath2-band , sparsely sampling a three year period starting with test observations in 1999 .
this part of the data set should be sensitive for long period variable stars with periods up to @xmath5 days .
additional observations in @xmath4 , @xmath2 and @xmath6-band were obtained during 3 observing campaigns at the 1.23 m telescope on calar alto densely sampling three two week long periods .
these observations should provide a ground for a search for variable stars with shorter periods ranging from @xmath7 days up to @xmath8 days .
the acquired data were bias subtracted , flat - fielded and cosmic ray rejected .
then , the images from one night were astrometrically aligned to a common reference frame and combined with individual weights proportional to their @xmath9 . for each epoch , consisting of all the stacked images of a single night , a difference image against a common deep reference frame was created using an implementation ( gssl & riffeser , 2002 , 2003 ) of the alard algorithm ( alard & lupton , 1998 ) .
finally , these difference images were convolved with a stellar psf . to extract lightcurves from the reduced data ,
first all pixels deviating significantly ( @xmath10 ) from the reference image in a minimum number of epochs @xmath11 were flagged , utilizing the complete per - pixel error propagation of our data reduction pipeline .
then , using these coordinates as input , values and associated errors are read from the difference images and the lightcurve data are assembled . to search for periodic signals in the extracted difference fluxes , a lomb ( 1976 ) algorithm using the interpretation from scargle ( 1982 )
is applied .
the photometric calibration was conducted using the hst data published by schulte - ladbeck et al .
for the galaxies leo a , and ugca 92 , we have a very good monitoring and a large fraction of the data passed already the pipeline .
the leo a data set serves as test case : a total of 26 variable star candidates were detected . among them
, we identified 16 secure long period variables ( typical average values @xmath12 , and @xmath13 period [ days ] @xmath14 ) , and we have 8 further candidates for lpvs .
in addition we were able to identify two good candidates for @xmath0 cephei stars with best fitting periods of 6.4 and 1.69 days .
the later candidate was previously described by dolphin et al .
( 2002 ) as c2-v58 with a period of 1.4 days . the dolphin et al .
period solution fails in deriving a reliable lightcurve with our data , yet , applying our period value to their data set yields reasonable results .
the phase convolved lightcurves for the two @xmath0 cephei variables are shown in figure 1 .
the color magnitude diagram shown in the left panel of figure 2 is based upon the hst data published by tolstoy et al .
( 1996 ) and schulte - ladbeck et al . flagged by bigger symbols
are those variables from our sample that lie inside the hst field of view , two @xmath0 cephei variables in the instability strip ( crosses ) and the candidates for long term variability ( triangles ) in the regime of the red giants .
tolstoy et al .
( 1996 ) based on ground - based data found a distance modulus for leo a of 24.2 and a resulting distance of 690 kpc ( see also schulte - ladbeck et al . ) .
this result got further support by the search for short periodic variables with the wiyn telescope within 3 consecutive days in dec . 2000 ( dolphin et al .
our data complement this dataset for longer periods .
the right hand panel of figure 2 shows the period - luminosity ( pl ) relation of the smc shifted to the distance determined by tolstoy et al .
the short period variables measured by dolphin coincide with the shown pl relation .
the overplotted values for the two cepheids from our survey ( crosses ) support this relation also in the regime of longer periods .
we presented preliminary results for our survey for variable stars in a sample of irregular local group dwarf galaxies . for the leo a dwarf galaxy , the best analysed case so far
, we already identified a total of 26 candidates for variability , 16 of these as long period variables and 2 @xmath0 cephei stars .
we compared the later with the period - luminosity relation and the short period variables discussed by dolphin et al .
we found , that our cepheids fully support their findings and the resulting distance estimate for leo a. this result is further in good agreement with the trgb distance ( tolstoy et al .
, schulte - ladbeck et al . ) .
the location of the lpvs in the color - magnitude diagram indicate that most of them are early asymptotic giant branch stars .
while a complete census of these intermediate age stars is missing for most of the local group members , a proper statistic of their appearance can guide the reconstruction of the star formation history at the age of several gyr by - passing the age metalicity degeneracy inherent to color magnitude diagram studies .
we like to thank drs .
i. drozdovsky , c. maraston , r.e .
schulte - ladbeck , and e. tolstoy for helpful discussion .
we acknowledge the support of the calar alto and wendelstein staff .
j. fliri and a. riffeser carried out some of our observations .
the project is supported by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft grant ho 1812/3 - 1 and ho 1812/3 - 2 .
alard , c. & lupton , r. h. , , 503 , 325 dolphin , a. e. et al .
2002 , , 123 , 3154 gssl c. a. & riffeser a. 2002 , , 381 , 1095 gssl , c. a. & riffeser , a. 2003 , asp conf .
295 , 229 lomb n. r. 1976 , , 39 , 447 mateo m. l. 1998 , , 36 , 435 sandage , a. & carlson , g. 1985 , , 90 , 1464 scargle j. d. 1982 , , 263 , 835 schulte - ladbeck r. et al .
2002 , , 124 , 896 tolstoy e. et al .
1996 , , 116 , 1244
|
dwarf galaxies in the local group provide a unique astrophysical laboratory . despite their proximity some of these systems still lack a reliable distance determination as well as studies of their stellar content and star formation history .
we present first results of our survey of variable stars in a sample of six local group dwarf irregular galaxies . taking the leo a dwarf galaxy as an example we describe observational strategies and data reduction .
we discuss the lightcurves of two newly found @xmath0 cephei stars and place them into the context of a previously derived p - l relation .
finally we discuss the lpv content of leo a.
|
in 1957 g.a . askaryan pointed out that ionisation and cavitation along a track of an ionising particle through a liquid leads to hydrodynamic radiation @xcite . in the 1960s , 1970s and 1980s ,
theoretical and experimental studies have been performed on the hydrodynamic radiation of beams and particles traversing dense media @xcite .
the interest in characterising the properties of the acoustic radiation was , among other reasons , lead by the idea that the effect can be utilised to detect ultra - high energy ( @xmath1 ) cosmic , i.e. astrophysical neutrinos , in dense media like water , ice and salt .
in the 1970s this idea was discussed within the dumand optical neutrino detector project @xcite and has been studied in connection with cherenkov neutrino detector projects since .
the detection of such neutrinos is considerably more challenging than the search for high - energy neutrinos ( @xmath2 ) as currently pursued by under - ice and under - water cherenkov neutrino telescopes @xcite . due to
the low expected fluxes , detector sizes exceeding 100km@xmath3 are needed @xcite .
however , the properties of the acoustic method allow for sparsely instrumented arrays with @xmath4100 sensors / km@xmath3 . to study the feasibility of a detection method based on acoustic signals it is necessary to understand the properties of the sound generation by comparing measurements and simulations based on theoretical models .
according to the so - called thermo - acoustic model @xcite , the energy deposition of particles traversing liquids leads to a local heating of the medium which can be regarded as instantaneous with respect to the hydrodynamic time scales .
due to the temperature change the medium expands or contracts according to its bulk volume expansion coefficient @xmath5 .
the accelerated motion of the heated medium generates an ultrasonic pulse whose temporal signature is bipolar and which propagates in the volume .
coherent superposition of the elementary sound waves , produced over the cylindrical volume of the energy deposition , leads to a propagation within a flat disk - like volume in the direction perpendicular to the axis of the particle shower . in this study ,
the hydrodynamic signal generation by two types of beams , interacting with a water target , was investigated : pulsed protons and a pulsed laser , mimicking the formation of a hadronic cascade from a neutrino interaction under laboratory conditions .
with respect to the aforementioned experimental studies of the thermo - acoustic model , the work presented here can make use of previously unavailable advanced tools such as geant4 @xcite for the simulation of proton - induced hadronic showers in water .
good agreement was found in the comparison of the measured signal properties with the simulation results , providing confidence to apply similar simulation methods in the context of acoustic detection of ultra - high energy neutrinos . a puzzling feature observed in previous studies
a non - vanishing signal amplitude at a temperature of 4@xmath6c , where for water at its highest density no thermo - acoustic signal should be present was investigated in detail .
such a residual signal was also observed for the proton beam experiment described in this article , but not for the laser beam , indicating that the formation of this signal is related to the charge or the mass of the protons .
in the following , the thermo - acoustic model @xcite is derived from basic assumptions , using a hydrodynamic approach .
basis is the momentum conservation , i.e. , the euler equation @xmath7 for mass density @xmath8 , velocity vector field of the medium @xmath9 and momentum - density tensor @xmath10 including the pressure @xmath11 @xcite . equation ( [ eq_euler ] ) can be derived from momentum conservation . in the derivation , energy dissipation resulting from processes such as internal friction or heat transfer are neglected .
motions described by the euler equation hence are adiabatic .
taking the three partial derivatives of eq .
( [ eq_euler ] ) with respect to @xmath12 and using for the density the continuity equation @xmath13 a non - linear wave equation can be derived : @xmath14 to solve this equation , the problem is approached in two separated spatial regions : firstly , a region @xmath15 ( _ ` beam ' _ ) , where the energy is deposited in the beam interactions with the fluid and thus the wave excited in a non - equilibrium process ; and secondly , a hydrodynamic ( _ ` acoustic ' _ ) region @xmath16 , where the acoustic wave propagates through the medium and where linear hydrodynamics in local equilibrium can be assumed .
this splitting can be reflected by the momentum density tensor , rewriting it as @xmath17 in local equilibrium the changes in mass density are given by @xmath18 with the bulk volume expansion coefficient @xmath19 , the energy deposition @xmath20 , the adiabatic speed of sound @xmath21 in the medium and the specific heat @xmath22 . in the acoustic regime , where @xmath23 , the momentum density tensor can be expressed as @xmath24 ( using eqs.([eq_densitytensor ] ) and ( [ eq_density_change ] ) ) , where we assume an adiabatic density change with pressure . the non - linear kinetic term @xmath25 entering @xmath26 according to eq .
( [ eq_densitytensor ] ) can be neglected for small deviations @xmath27 from the static density @xmath28 and small pressure differences @xmath29 from the static pressure @xmath30 @xcite . in the region
b , where non - equilibrium deposition occur , one may make the _ ansatz _ @xmath31 with the direction @xmath32 of the beam which breaks the isotropy of the energy - momentum tensor and describes with the parameter @xmath33 in an effective way the momentum transfer on the fluid .
although in non - equilibirum we apply eq .
( [ eq_density_change ] ) with the energy deposition density @xmath34 of the beam .
then , with the additional energy - momentum tensor due to the beam @xmath35 the wave equation ( [ eq_wave_base ] ) reads @xmath36 the general solution for the wave equation can be written using a green function approach as @xmath37 \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] with the components of the unit vector @xmath38 and the retarded time @xmath39 .
for the last conversion , partial integration and the total derivative @xmath40 have been used repeatedly . note that @xmath41 for @xmath42 , so that the integration is carried out over the volume of the energy deposition region @xmath15 .
assuming an energy deposition without momentum transfer to the medium , the kinetic term in the _ ansatz _ ( [ eq : ansatz ] ) can be neglected ( @xmath43 ) yielding @xmath44 for a thermo - acoustic wave generated solely by heating of the medium .
the signal amplitude @xmath45 can be shown to be proportional to the dimensionless quantity @xmath46 when solving eq .
( [ eq_pressure ] ) for the case of an instantaneous energy deposition . equation ( [ eq_pressure ] ) is equivalent to the results obtained from the approaches presented in @xcite .
the derivation pursued above , however , uses a different approach starting with the euler equation and an anisotropic energy - momentum tensor , yielding a more general expression in eq .
( [ eq : pressure - approx ] ) . only if assuming an isotropic energy deposition one arrives at the expression for the pressure deviation @xmath45 given in eq .
( [ eq_pressure ] ) .
note that the validation of the last assumption @xmath43 being a good approximation would require a detailed knowledge of the momentum transfer from the beam to the medium .
taking it into account would result in an additional dipol term @xmath47 in eq .
( [ eq_pressure ] ) which may become the dominant contribution to wave generation if @xmath48 close to 4.0@xmath49c .
however , for @xmath43 the pressure field resulting from a beam interaction in a medium is determined by the spatial and temporal distribution of the energy deposition density @xmath50 alone .
the amplitude of the resulting acoustic wave is governed by the thermodynamic properties @xmath21 , @xmath51 and @xmath5 , the latter three depending primarily on the temperature of the medium .
a controlled variation of these parameters in the conducted laboratory experiments and a study of the resulting pressure signals therefore allows for a precise test of the thermo - acoustic model .
simulations based on the thermo - acoustic model , as performed to interpret the results of the experiments described in the next section , will be discussed in sec .
[ sec_simulation ] .
note that the energy deposition density @xmath50 and its temporal evolution for the proton and laser beam interactions discussed in this paper are quite different from those expected for the interaction of ultra - high energy neutrinos .
however , if a simulation starting from basic principles allows for a good reproduction of the experimental results , it is reasonable to assume that these simulation methods are transferable to neutrino interactions , as they are governed by the same underlying physical processes .
the experiments presented in this paper were performed with a pulsed infrared nd : yag laser facility ( @xmath52 ) located at the erlangen centre for astroparticle physics ( ecap ) of the university of erlangen , and the pulsed @xmath53 proton beam of the `` gustaf werner cyclotron '' at the `` theodor svedberg laboratory '' in uppsala , sweden .
the beam properties allow for a compact experimental setup . in both cases ,
the beams were dumped into a dedicated @xmath54 water tank , where the acoustic field was measured with several position - adjustable acoustic sensors ( see fig .
[ fig_test_setup ] ) .
the sensors ( also called hydrophones ) could be positioned within the tank with absolute uncertainties below 1 cm .
the temperature of the water could be varied between @xmath55 and @xmath56 with a precision of @xmath57 .
the temperature was brought to a particular value by first cooling the water with ice ; subsequently the whole water volume was heated to the desired temperature in a controlled , gradual procedure .
once the water temperature had been established , at least 10min remained for measurements until the water volume heated up by @xmath57 through heat transfer from the environment .
this time span was sufficient for all measurements conducted at water temperatures below the ambient temperature .
the explored range of spill energies for the proton beam was from @xmath58 to @xmath59 , the beam diameter was approximately @xmath60 and the spill time @xmath61 . for @xmath62 protons , the energy deposition in the water along the beam axis ( @xmath63-axis , beam entry into the water at @xmath64 ) is relatively uniform up to @xmath65 ending in the prominent bragg - peak at @xmath66 ( see fig .
[ fig_energy_deposition_z ] ) . to adjust the spill energy ,
the number of protons per bunch was varied .
the total charge of a bunch was calibrated with two independent methods ( faraday cups and scintillation counters ) , leading to an uncertainty on the order of 15% , with some higher values for low spill energies . to obtain the beam intensity and profile for the proton interactions in the water tank , the distance of about 1.2 m that the beam was travelling from the exit of the beam pipe through air and its entering into the water tank were included in the geant4 simulation . for the laser experiment , the pulse energy was adjusted between @xmath67 and @xmath68 and calibrated using a commercial power meter .
the beam had a diameter of approximately @xmath69 mm and the pulse length was fixed at @xmath70 . for the infrared light used , the laser energy density deposited along the beam axis has an exponential decrease with an absorption length of @xmath71 ( see fig . [ fig_energy_deposition_z ] ) .
for both beam types the lateral energy deposition profile was gaussian ( the aforementioned beam diameters are the @xmath72 s of the profiles ) .
the two experiments allow to explore different spatial and temporal distributions of the energy deposition as well as two different mechanisms of energy transfer into the medium . for both beams
, energy is deposited via excitation , in addition the medium is ionised in the case of the proton beam . , width=294 ] for the signal recording , sensors based on the piezo - electric effect @xcite were used .
a full characterisation of these sensors had been performed prior to the experiments .
they are linear in amplitude response , the frequency response is flat starting from a few khz up to the main resonance at @xmath73 with a sensitivity of @xmath74 ( @xmath40.02v / pa ) .
the main resonance is more sensitive by @xmath45@xmath75 and sensitivity drops rapidly at higher frequencies ; at 90khz , the sensitivity has dropped by 20db .
the absolute uncertainty in the determination of the sensitivity is at a level of 2db in the frequency range of interest . above 90khz
the uncertainty exceeds 5db . to calculate the response of the sensors to an external pressure pulse
a parametrised fit of an equivalent circuit model as described in @xcite was used .
the sensitivity dependence on temperature was measured and the relative decrease was found to be less than @xmath76 ( or about 0.13db ) per @xmath77 . for every set of fixed experimental parameters ( temperature , energy , sensor position , etc . )
the signals of 1000 beam pulses were recorded with a digital oscilloscope at a sampling rate in excess of @xmath78 .
this rate is sufficient for the signals with spectral components up to 100khz , where the sensitivity of the sensors is negligibly small .
these individual pulses were averaged to reduce background and environmental noise in the analysis , thereby obtaining a very high statistical precision .
figure [ fig_signals ] shows typical signals measured in the proton and the laser experiment , respectively , using the same sensors and experimental setup .
the general shapes of the two signals differ : a typical signal for the proton beam shows a bipolar signature , the one for the laser deviates from such a generic form .
the laser signal has high frequency components up to several mhz due to the high energy deposition density at the point of beam entry and the almost instantaneous energy deposition compared to the @xmath79s pulse of the proton beam ; therefore the resonance of the sensor is excited causing a ringing in the measured signal .
the spatial distribution of the energy density @xmath50 deposited by the laser leads to the two separate signals : the first originates in the beam area at the same @xmath63-region as the sensor placement ( _ ` direct signal ' _ ) , the second from the beam entry , a point of discontinuity where most of the energy is deposed ( _ ` beam entry signal ' _ ) .
the signal of the proton beam is deteriorated with respect to an ideal bipolar signal .
three main contributions to this distortion can be discerned : the recorded signal starts before the expected onset of the acoustic signal ( 55.2@xmath79s for the given position , see fig .
[ fig_signals ] , given by the sonic path length ) ; reflections of the acoustic wave on the beam entry window overlay the original wave starting in the first rare - faction peak ; and finally there are frequency components of the signal exciting a resonant response of the sensor , slightly changing the signal shape and causing ringing . the first point was studied and found to be consistent with an electric charge effect in the sensors caused by the proton beam .
its starting time was always coincident with the beam pulse entry into the water , even for sensor distances of up to 1 m , hinting at an electromagnetic origin of the distorting signal .
the shape of this non - acoustic signal is consistent with the integrated time - profile of the beam pulse with a subsequent exponential decay .
this deformation of the main signal is considered a systematic uncertainty on the signal properties and treated as such in the analysis . for the most part
, its shape was fitted and subtracted from the signal . in order to minimise the impact of the signal deformation caused by
the described effects on the analysis of the recorded signals , robust characteristics were used : the peak - to - peak amplitude and the signal length from maximum to minimum of the signal . for the laser experiment
these features were extracted for the direct signals only .
= 10 cm and @xmath63=20 cm and are shown within the same time interval .
the dash - dotted line in the upper graph indicates the charge effect described in the text .
[ fig_signals ] , width=264 ]
for an in - depth validation of the thermo - acoustic model , comparisons of the signal properties with simulation results based on the model are essential . to this end , a simulation of the expected signals was developed .
it is based on the thermo - acoustic model using a numeric solution of eq .
( [ eq_pressure ] ) .
the input parameters to the simulation were either measured at the experiments , i.e. medium temperature and beam profiles , or simulated , i.e. the energy deposition of the protons ( using geant4 ) .
the thermodynamic parameters bulk volume expansion coefficient , heat capacity and speed of sound were derived from the measured water temperature using standard parametrisations .
tap water quality was assumed .
a series of simulations was conducted , where the input parameters were varied individually in the range given by the experiment , including uncertainties .
especially the spatial and temporal beam profile have a substantial impact on amplitude , duration and shape of the signal .
simulated signals and the respective sensor response corresponding to the measured signals of fig .
[ fig_signals ] are shown in fig.[fig_signals_sim ] . to minimise systematic effects from the setup caused e.g. by reflections on the surfaces
, the sensor response was convoluted onto the simulated signals , rather than deconvoluted from the measured ones .
thus in the analysis voltage rather than pressure signals are compared . .
the corresponding dashed - lined signals mark the simulated signals after convolution with the sensor response . for better comparability ,
the signal maxima were normalised to 1 .
[ fig_signals_sim ] , width=264 ] the shapes of the simulated pulses are altered by the sensor response , especially the high - frequency components above the resonant frequency of the sensor . in the case of the laser pulse ,
mostly the resonance of the sensor is excited , leading to a strong ringing . for the proton beam ,
the primarily bipolar shape is again prominent , whereas the laser pulse is segmented into the two parts described above .
the direct pulse of the laser experiment exhibits a bipolar shape as well , albeit less symmetric than for the proton beam .
figure [ fig_systematics ] exemplifies the dependency of the signal amplitude on the input parameters of the simulation : water temperature , pulse energy , beam profile in @xmath80 and @xmath81 , pulse length and the position of the sensor . as nominal positions of the sensor @xmath82 m , @xmath83 m , and @xmath84 m
were used .
all parameters were varied by @xmath85 around the value of the best agreement with measurement , i.e. the values used for the simulations of the signals shown in fig .
[ fig_signals_sim ] .
some of the characteristics of thermo - acoustic sound generation are observable . as discussed in sec .
[ sec_model ] , the dependence on temperature enters through the factor @xmath46 ( where the dependence on the speed of sound is negligible ) and is roughly linear in the range investigated for this study .
the dependence on energy is strictly linear .
the dependency on the beam pulse parameters is diverse .
it is governed by the integral in eq.([eq_pressure ] ) and therefore depends on both the spatial and the temporal beam profiles and the interaction of the particles with the water . for a given point in space and time
, the elementary waves produced in the volume of energy deposition may interfere constructively or destructively depending on the beam properties .
accordingly , the length of the laser pulse has no influence on the amplitude , as with 9ns it is much shorter than the transit time of the acoustic signal through the energy deposition area . for the several ten @xmath79s long proton spill , the spill time is comparable to the transit time .
thus the acoustic signal shows a strong dependence on the spill time .
the dependence on the radial coordinate @xmath86 w.r.t .
the beam axis @xmath86 follows roughly the expected 1/@xmath87 and @xmath88 fall - off of a cylindric source in the near and the far field , respectively .
the @xmath81-position was varied between @xmath892 and 2 cm , as the signals were recorded within the @xmath90-plane .
the resulting change in amplitude is below 1% .
the @xmath63-dependency for the laser experiment follows the exponential fall - off expected from the light absorption .
the one for the proton experiment shows the only non - strictly monotonic behaviour due to the form of the energy deposition with the prominent bragg peak . using these dependencies the systematic uncertainties of the model
were obtained using the experimental uncertainties of the various parameters .
the main uncertainty for the proton beam is given by the temporal profile of the pulse , which was simplified to a gaussian profile for this chapter ( however not for the rest of this work ) .
for the laser beam experiment this parameter influences the signal amplitude only on a one percent level . the second main influence on
the amplitude is the sensor position along the beam axis ( @xmath63-direction ) .
table [ tab_systematics ] gives the parameters and their uncertainties ( @xmath91 ) used for the simulation of the signals .
the resulting systematic uncertainties in the amplitude ( @xmath92 ) are given as well .
the combined uncertainties are @xmath93 for the proton signal and @xmath94 for the laser signal , respectively . .beam
parameters used for the simulated signals in fig .
[ fig_signals_sim ] with their associated experimental uncertainties ( @xmath91 ) and resulting uncertainty in signal amplitude ( @xmath92 ) .
the pulse length of the laser is set to a value much higher than in the experiment , to save calculation time .
the resulting uncertainty in the signal amplitude is below @xmath95 [ cols="<,^,^,^,^ " , ]
in the following , the results obtained in the comparison of experiment and simulation are presented .
figure [ fig_proton_sim_meas ] shows a comparison between simulated and measured signals for the proton beam experiment at different sensor positions . for better visibility only the main part of the signals ( first bipolar part )
is plotted .
the input parameters of the simulation were varied within the experimental uncertainties until the best agreement with the measured signal in amplitude and duration was obtained for the reference point at @xmath80=0.40 m and @xmath63=0.11 m . for this optimisation ,
a simple procedure of adjusting the parameters manually and scanning the resulting agreement visually was found to be sufficient .
the other signals were simulated with the same parameter set , only the sensor positions were changed .
the signal shapes differ for different @xmath63-positions due to the geometry of the energy deposition profile described in sec .
[ sec_setup ] with cylindric form in the @xmath96-plane and almost flat energy density in @xmath63-direction up to the bragg peak at @xmath63=0.22 m . due to this geometry an almost cylindrical wave
is excited in the medium , with coherent emission perpendicular to the beam axis . in the region
@xmath97 m the signals are of bipolar shape . along the beam axis
( @xmath98 m , @xmath99 m ) the main part of the observed signal originates from the bragg peak as a nearly spheric source and no clear bipolar shape evolves .
the agreement between simulation and measurement is good for all positions .
not only amplitude and duration match ( see also the following sections ) but also the signal shape is reproduced to a very high degree .
the small discrepancies , primarily in the rare - faction part of the bipolar pulse , have contributions stemming from a non - ideal sensor calibration and reflections on the tank surfaces .
however , a significant part of the discrepancies may lie in the beam pulse modelling or even the thermo - acoustic model itself .
the prominent feature of the energy deposition of the laser beam is at the beam entry into the medium .
overall , the geometry of this deposition is mainly a cylindric one with rotational symmetry around the @xmath63-axis , as for the proton beam , with coherent emission perpendicular to the beam axis ( direct signal ) .
the signal from the discontinuity at the beam entry is emitted almost as from a point source ( beam entry signal ) .
in contrast to the proton beam , the shapes of signals at different positions along the @xmath63-axis do not vary much , only the relative timing between the two signal components varies . therefore , fig .
[ fig_laser_sim_meas ] shows only signals for a @xmath63-position in the middle of the water tank . here , both signal parts are well described by the simulation .
the beam entry part of each signal is less well reproduced in the simulation due to its high frequency components where the sensor calibration is less well understood .
+ m for different sensor positions along @xmath80 ( reference at @xmath100 m ) . for more details
[ fig_laser_sim_meas ] , width=325 ] to compare the characteristics of the signals in simulation and measurement in the following studies , their amplitudes and the point in time of the recording of the signal maximum were further studied . for the laser signal ,
the direct signal part is considered only .
equation ( [ eq_pressure ] ) yields as velocity of propagation for the thermo - acoustic signal the speed of sound in the medium , here water . to verify the hydrodynamic origin of the measured
signals the variation of the arrival times for different sensor positions perpendicular to the beam axis were analysed .
figure [ fig_time_vs_distance ] shows the measured data and a linear fit for each beam type .
the data is compatible with an acoustic sound propagation in water , as the fits yield a speed of sound compatible with pure water at the temperature used . for the proton beam @xmath101 ( @xmath102 )
was obtained for a water temperature of @xmath103c , where literature @xcite gives for pure water at normal pressure @xmath104 which is in complete agreement . for the laser measurements the water temperature of @xmath105c and thus the speed of sound were significantly higher ,
the observed @xmath106 ( @xmath107 ) is again in perfect agreement with the theoretical value of @xmath108 .
the offset between proton and laser beam data in fig .
[ fig_time_vs_distance ] is due to a differing delay time in between trigger time and arrival time of the different beams in the water and is irrelevant for the calculation of the speed of sound .
position ) .
the straight lines represent linear fits to the data points yielding @xmath109 and @xmath110 for the proton and laser beam , respectively .
[ fig_time_vs_distance ] , width=325 ] the durations of the complete , unclipped signals vary with sensor positions mainly due to reflections , which were not simulated and can therefore not be compared .
the comparison of simulated and measured signals for different sensor positions within the water tank , excluding the parts of the signals dominated by reflections , was shown in fig .
[ fig_proton_sim_meas ] .
the good agreement between model and measurement also manifests itself in the development of the signal amplitude with distance of sensors from the beam axis , shown in fig .
[ fig_amp_vs_x_protons ] . to minimise systematic effects from reflections ,
only the amplitude of the leading maximum is analysed .
though there are sizeable deviations , the overall shape of the curve is reproduced .
the behaviour is again different for the two @xmath63-positions .
the development at @xmath111 m follows the one expected from a cylindric source with a @xmath112 behaviour in the near field up to @xmath4@xmath113 m and a @xmath88 behaviour in the far field beyond that distance . at the smallest measured distances , the simulated behaviour deviates from the measured one .
presumably this is due to simplifications made in the derivation of the model in sec .
[ sec_model ] . at @xmath114
m the amplitude falls off more uniformly , this is again a combination of the point - like emission characteristic of the bragg peak interfering with the cylindric emission at @xmath115 m . ) for the proton beam experiment .
points mark the measured amplitudes for two different @xmath63-positions and the lines the respective simulation results .
[ fig_amp_vs_x_protons ] , width=325 ] the behaviour for the laser experiment is not as well reproduced by the simulation ( see fig . [ fig_amp_vs_x_laser ] ) .
this is again attributed to the high - frequent signal components of the laser , where minor uncertainties in the simulation may result in big changes of the signal amplitude .
especially the overlap of the direct with the beam entry window signal distort the signal shape . at distances exceeding 0.5
m the two signal parts can not be distinguished . ) for the laser beam experiment .
points mark the measured amplitudes at @xmath116 m and the line the simulation result .
[ fig_amp_vs_x_laser ] , width=325 ] assuming otherwise unchanged settings , the energy deposition density @xmath50 scales linearly with total deposited energy .
thus the spill energy can be written as a pre - factor in eq .
( [ eq_pressure ] ) effecting the pressure and thus signal amplitude linearly . as shown in fig .
[ fig_amplitude_vs_energy ] this behaviour was observed in the experiments yielding a zero - crossing of the pulse energy at @xmath117mpa for the proton beam and @xmath118mpa for the laser beam .
both values are consistent with zero .
the slope of the line depends on the energy deposition and the sensor positioning along the beam axis and can therefore not be compared for the two beams .
as expected from the model , the signal duration and signal shape showed no significant dependence on energy .
m. there is a ten percent systematic uncertainty in the absolute determination of the pulse energy .
the lines represent linear fits to the data points yielding a zero - crossing of the amplitude compatible with no energy in a pulse .
the insert shows the data for the proton beam.[fig_amplitude_vs_energy ] , width=325 ] the main feature of the thermo - acoustic model is its dependence on the temperature of the medium .
figure [ fig_temp_laser ] shows the temperature dependence of the signal peak - to - peak amplitude for the laser beam , where a positive ( negative ) sign denotes a leading positive ( negative ) peak of the signal .
the two data sets shown in the figure were recorded by two sensors simultaneously , which were positioned at @xmath119 perpendicular to the beam axis and at @xmath120 and @xmath121 along the beam axis , respectively . in the case of the proton beam setup , which will be discussed below , these hydrophone positions correspond roughly to the @xmath63-position of the bragg - peak and a @xmath63-position half way between the bragg - peak and the beam entry into the water , respectively . for comparability ,
the same positions and the same sensors were chosen for the laser and proton beam experiments . at @xmath122 .
the insert shows a blow - up of the region around @xmath123c where the sign of the amplitude changes .
[ fig_temp_laser],width=325 ] the laser beam signal shown in fig .
[ fig_temp_laser ] changes its polarity around @xmath124 , as expected from the thermo - acoustic model .
the theoretical expectation for the signal amplitude , which is proportional to @xmath125 and vanishes at @xmath126 for the given temperature and pressure , is fitted to the experimental data . in the fit , an overall scaling factor and a shift in temperature ( for the experimental uncertainty in the temperature measurement ) were left free as fit parameters .
the fit yielded a zero - crossing of the amplitude at @xmath127 , where the error is dominated by the systematic uncertainty in the temperature setting .
c , fitted with the model expectation as described in the text .
a systematic deviation from the model expectation as the amplitude changes its sign is clearly visible .
the amplitudes were normalised to @xmath128 at @xmath122 .
[ temp_amp_protons_uncorr ] , width=325 ] . to allow for an easy comparison of the signal shapes , a point in time at the onset of the acoustic signals
was chosen as zero time and for all signal amplitudes the corresponding offset was added or subtracted to yield a zero amplitude at that time . [ temp_comp_signals ] , width=325 ] analysing the proton data in the same fashion resulted in a fit that deviated from the model expectation , and a zero - crossing significantly different from @xmath129 at @xmath130 , see fig .
[ temp_amp_protons_uncorr ] .
the data strongly indicate the presence of a systematic effect near the zero - crossing of the signal amplitude . to understand this effect ,
the signal shapes near the temperature of @xmath129 were investigated ( fig . [ temp_comp_signals ] ) .
a non - vanishing signal is clearly observable at @xmath129 and the signal inverts its polarity between @xmath129 and @xmath131 . in view of the results from the laser beam measurements and the obvious systematic nature of the deviation from the model visible in fig .
[ temp_amp_protons_uncorr ] , we subtracted the residual signal at @xmath129 , which has an amplitude of @xmath132 of the @xmath122 signal , from all signals .
thus a non - temperature dependent effect in addition to the thermo - acoustic signal was assumed .
the resulting amplitudes shown in fig .
[ fig_temp_proton ] are well described by the model prediction .
c was subtracted at every temperature .
the amplitudes were afterwards normalised to @xmath128 at @xmath122 .
the insert shows a blow - up of the region around @xmath123c where the sign of the amplitude changes .
[ fig_temp_proton ] , width=325 ] the production mechanism of the underlying signal at @xmath133 , which was only observed in the proton experiment , could not be unambiguously determined with the performed measurements . from the model point of view , the main simplification for the derivation of eq .
( [ eq_pressure ] ) was to neglect all non - isotropic terms and momentum transfer to the medium in the momentum density tensor @xmath134 by setting @xmath43 in eq .
( [ eq : ansatz ] ) . as discussed in sec .
[ sec_model ] , dipole radiation could contribute significantly near the disappearance of the volume expansion coefficient for the case @xmath135 .
also other non - thermo - acoustic signal production mechanism have been discussed in the literature which could give rise to an almost temperature independent signal , see e.g.@xcite .
the obvious difference to the laser experiment are the charges involved both from the protons themselves and the ionisation of the water which could lead to an interaction with the polar water molecules .
another difference are the massive protons compared to massless photons .
residual signals at @xmath133 were found in previous works as well @xcite , as will be discussed in more detail in sec .
[ subsec : comparison ] . for clarification
further experiments are needed either with ionising neutral particles ( e.g. synchrotron radiation ) or with charged particles ( e.g. protons , @xmath136-particles ) with more sensors positioned around the bragg - peak . with such experiments it might be possible to distinguish between the effect of ionisation in the water and of net charge introduced by charged particles . with the analysis that has been described above , the signal production according to the thermo - acoustic model could be unambiguously confirmed .
while the model has been confirmed in previous experiments , the simulations presented in this work constitute a new level of precision .
the most puzzling feature , a residual signal at 4@xmath6c that was also observed in previous experiments , was investigated with high precision by scanning the relevant temperature region in steps of @xmath137c .
the observed shift of the zero - crossing of the amplitude towards values higher than 4@xmath6c , caused by a leading rarefaction non - thermal residual signal at 4@xmath6c , is in qualitative agreement with @xcite . in @xcite , a residual signal at @xmath123c
was also reported . since in that work
the zero - crossing of the amplitude is observed at @xmath138c , i.e.a higher value than the expected @xmath123c , it can be assumed that the corresponding residual signal has a leading rarefaction . in @xcite
, a residual signal is found at @xmath139c , however with a leading compression rather than rarefaction .
the authors conclude that this may lead to a signal disappearance point _ below _ the expected value , in contrast to @xcite and the work presented in this article . for the measurements with a laser beam reported in @xcite ,
a residual signal was also observed at @xmath123c , albeit with a leading compression and a subsequent reduction of the temperature of the zero - crossing of the signal amplitude to about @xmath140c .
this observation is in contrast to the laser experiment presented in this article . in conclusion ,
the works of all authors discussed here indicate a non - thermal residual signal for proton beams , albeit with varying results concerning the size of the effect and the shape of the underlying non - thermal signal .
the results for the laser beam reported in @xcite differ from those described in the article at hands .
it should be pointed out , however , that in @xcite and @xcite results are reported by the same authors for proton and for laser beams , respectively .
a comparison of these two publications shows that a different behaviour near the temperature of @xmath123c was observed for the two types of beams .
hence , to the best of our knowledge , there are currently no results in contradiction with the notion of different non - thermal effects in the interaction of proton vs. laser beams with water .
the available data does not allow for a more detailed analysis of the correlation between experimental conditions and the temperature of the zero - crossing of the signal amplitude .
efforts to detect neutrinos at ultra - high energies are at the frontier of research in the field of astroparticle physics .
neutrinos are the only viable messengers at ultra - high energies beyond the local universe , i.e. distances well beyond several tens of megaparsecs .
if successful , the investigation of these elusive particles will not only enhance the understanding of their own nature , but also provide important complementary information on the astrophysical phenomena and the environments that accelerate particles to such extreme energies . for acoustic particle detection , not only
the technical aspects such as optimal design and detector layout are subject of research . but
also the underlying physics processes
the formation of hadronic cascades resulting from neutrino interactions in dense media have never been observed directly in detector experiments at these energies .
producing ever more reliable extrapolation of reaction properties to ultra - high energies is an ongoing effort . with advancements in the simulations of cascades forming in water and improvements of detector simulation tools , the discrepancy between cascade parameters from independent simulations
decreased : recent studies differ only slightly @xcite .
at the same time it is necessary to gain a solid understanding of the sound signals generated from the energy depositions by particle cascades . for this purpose ,
laboratory measurements are required .
this work , together with others @xcite has established the validity of the thermo - acoustic model with uncertainties at the @xmath141 level .
the input to a model as discussed in this article is an energy deposition in water as it is also produced by a cascade that evolves from a neutrino interaction . in comparison with the uncertainty in the thermo - acoustic model ,
uncertainties due to the simulations of hadronic cascades and cascade - to - cascade variations are large @xcite , dominating the challenge to detect and identify sound signals resulting from neutrino interactions .
it can hence be concluded that the current level of precision in modelling sound signals in the context of the thermo - acoustic model is fully sufficient for the understanding of acoustic neutrino signatures .
the latter is necessary to improve the selection efficiency and background rejection for neutrino detection algorithms in potential future acoustic neutrino detectors .
several experiments have been conducted @xcite to understand the acoustic background at the sites of potential future large - scale acoustic neutrino telescopes in sea water , fresh water and ice .
the combination of simulation efforts , laboratory measurements and studies with in - situ test arrays will allow for a conclusion of the feasibility of acoustic neutrino detection .
we have demonstrated that the sound generation mechanism of intense pulsed beams is well described by the thermo - acoustic model . in
almost all aspects investigated , the signal properties are consistent with the model .
the biggest uncertainties of the experiments are on the 10@xmath0 level .
one discrepancy is the non - vanishing signal at 4@xmath49c for the proton beam experiment , which can be described with an additional non - temperature dependent signal with a @xmath132 contribution to the amplitude at 15@xmath49c .
the model allows for calculations of the characteristics of sound pulses generated in the interaction of high energy particles in water with the input of the energy deposition of the resulting cascade . a possible application of this technique would be the detection of neutrinos with energies @xmath142
this work was supported by the german ministry for education and research ( bmbf ) by grants 05cn2we1/2 , 05cn5we1/7 and 05a08we1 .
parts of the measurements were performed at the `` theodor svedberg laboratory '' in uppsala , sweden .
the authors wish to thank all involved personnel and especially the acoustics groups of desy zeuthen and of uppsala university for their support .
|
the generation of hydrodynamic radiation in interactions of pulsed proton and laser beams with matter is explored .
the beams were directed into a water target and the resulting acoustic signals were recorded with pressure sensitive sensors .
measurements were performed with varying pulse energies , sensor positions , beam diameters and temperatures .
the obtained data are matched by simulation results based on the thermo - acoustic model with uncertainties at a level of 10@xmath0 .
the results imply that the primary mechanism for sound generation by the energy deposition of particles propagating in water is the local heating of the medium .
the heating results in a fast expansion or contraction and a pressure pulse of bipolar shape is emitted into the surrounding medium .
an interesting , widely discussed application of this effect could be the detection of ultra - high energetic cosmic neutrinos in future large - scale acoustic neutrino detectors .
for this application a validation of the sound generation mechanism to high accuracy , as achieved with the experiments discussed in this article , is of high importance .
cosmic neutrinos , acoustic neutrino detection , thermo - acoustic model , ultra - high energy cosmic rays , beam interaction
|
the epoch of reionization signified the appearance of the first stars and galaxies within the first billion years after the big bang , and the transformation of the intergalactic medium ( igm ) from opaque to transparent . despite recent progress , however , it is not yet fully understood .
it is now well established that reionization is completed by @xmath14 thanks to observations of the ly@xmath15 forest ( e.g. @xcite ) , and that the universe was substantially ionized around redshift @xmath4 when its age was less than 600 myr , based on the electron scattering optical depth measured by planck @xcite .
however , there is still substantial uncertainty regarding the sources of reionization .
can galaxies form with sufficient efficiency at such early times to provide enough reionizing photons ( e.g. @xcite ) , or is the process possibly driven by other classes of objects such as agn @xcite ?
observationally , recent progress in near - ir detector technology has dramatically advanced our ability to search for galaxies during this epoch . following the installation of the wide field camera 3 ( wfc3 ) on the _ hubble space telescope _ ( _ hst _ ) , a continuously growing sample of galaxy candidates at @xmath16 is accumulating thanks to a variety of surveys . these range from small - area ultradeep observations such as the hubble ultra - deep field ( hudf , @xcite ) , to shallower , larger - area searches for @xmath17 galaxies either in legacy fields such as the cosmic assembly near - infrared deep extragalactic legacy survey ( candels ; @xcite ) , or taking advantage of random - pointing opportunities like in the brightest of reionizing galaxies ( borg ) survey ( go 11700 , 12572 , 13767 ; pi trenti ) . overall , a sample approaching 1000 galaxy candidates at @xmath18 is known today @xcite , and we are beginning to identify the first galaxy candidates from the first 500 million years ( @xmath19 ; @xcite ) .
these observations provide solid constraints on the galaxy luminosity function ( lf ) out to @xmath4 , which appears to be overall well described by a @xcite form , @xmath20 , as at lower redshift @xcite . however , other studies suggest that bright galaxy formation might not be suppressed as strongly at @xmath16 , and either a single power law @xcite or a double power law @xcite fit to the bright end of the lf has been explored .
this change in the shape of the bright end is in turn connected theoretically to the physics of star formation in the most overdense and early forming environments where the brightest and rarest galaxies are expected to live @xcite .
a departure from a schechter form could indicate a lower efficiency of feedback processes at early times , which in turn would imply an increase in the production of ionizing photons by galaxies .
additionally , at @xmath21 , the observed number density of bright galaxies is affected by magnification bias @xcite , and this bias can cause the lf to take on a power - law shape at the bright end .
currently , the samples at @xmath22 are still too small to draw any conclusion on which scenario is realized , since only a handful of @xmath23 candidates are known .
in addition to constraining the shape of the lf , the brightest high-@xmath24 candidates identified by _ hst _ observations are also ideal targets for follow - up observations to infer stellar population properties such as ages and stellar masses @xcite , ionization state of the igm @xcite , and spectroscopic redshift . for the latter , confirmation of photometric candidates relies typically on detection of a lyman break in the galaxy continuum , ( e.g. , @xcite ) and/or of emission lines , primarily lyman-@xmath15 ( e.g. @xcite ) or other uv lines such as ciii ] or civ @xcite .
spectroscopic follow - up for sources at @xmath25 is extremely challenging , with only limits on line emission resulting from most observations .
yet , the brightest targets show significant promise of detection based on the latest series of follow - ups which led to spectroscopic confirmation out to @xmath26 @xcite , with several other ly@xmath15 detections at @xmath25 @xcite . with the goal of complementing the discovery of the rarest and most luminous sources in the epoch of reionization from legacy fields such as candels ,
the brightest of reionizing galaxies survey ( borg , see @xcite ) has been carrying out pure - parallel , random pointing observations with wfc3 since 2010 .
borg identified a large sample ( @xmath27 ) of @xmath4 @xmath28-band dropouts with @xmath17 ( @xcite ; see also @xcite ) .
this represents a catalog of galaxies that is not affected by large scale structure bias ( sample or `` cosmic '' variance ; see @xcite ) , which is especially severe for rare sources sitting in massive dark matter halos ( @xmath29 ) , as inferred from clustering measurements at @xmath18 @xcite .
follow - up spectroscopy of the borg dropouts with keck and vlt has provided evidence for an increase of the igm neutrality at @xmath4 compared to @xmath30 @xcite .
currently , a new campaign of observations is ongoing , with a revised filter - set optimized for the new frontier of redshift detection at @xmath23 ( borg[z9 - 10 ] ; go 13767 , pi trenti ) .
initial results from @xmath31 of the dataset ( @xmath32 arcmin@xmath5 ) led to the identification of two candidates at @xmath3 @xcite with @xmath33 , which are similar in luminosity to the spectroscopically confirmed @xmath26 source reported by @xcite , but significantly brighter than the six @xmath34-dropouts with @xmath35 identified in the goods / candels fields from a comparable area @xcite .
these recent developments indicate that it might be possible for a small number of ultra - bright sources ( @xmath36 ) to be present as early as 500 myr after the big bang .
thus , they prompted us to systematically analyze the borg archival data from observations in the previous cycles , which cover @xmath37 arcmin@xmath5 , to search for bright @xmath3 candidates and constrain their number density .
this paper presents the results of this search , and is organized as follows : section [ section2 ] briefly introduces the borg dataset .
section [ section3 ] discusses our selection criteria for @xmath3 sources ( @xmath38-band dropouts ) , with results presented in section [ section4 ] . in section [ lfsection ]
, we determine the galaxy uv luminosity function at @xmath39 , and compare with previous determinations .
section [ sec : conclusions ] summarizes and concludes . throughout the paper we use the @xcite cosmology : @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
all magnitudes are quoted in the ab system @xcite .
we use data acquired as part of the brightest of reionizing galaxies ( borg[z8 ] ) survey , which consists of core borg pointings ( go 11700 , 12572 , 12905 ) , augmented by other pure parallel archival data ( go 11702 , pi yan , @xcite ) and cos gto coordinated parallel observations .
for an in - depth description of the survey , we refer the reader to @xcite . here
, we use the 2014 ( dr3 ) public release of the data , which consists of 71 independent pointings covering a total area of @xmath43350 arcmin@xmath5 .
all fields were imaged using the wfc3/ir filters f098 m , f125w and f160w , and in the optical @xmath44 band , using either the wfc3 f606w or f600lp filter . we refer to the wfc3 f098 m , f125w and f160w images as the @xmath45 , @xmath38 and @xmath46 images , and to the f606w and f600lp images as @xmath47 and @xmath48 , respectively .
exposure times in each filter vary on a field - by - field basis , and 5@xmath49 limiting magnitudes for point sources and aperture @xmath50 are between @xmath51 , with a typical value of @xmath52 @xcite .
we note that since the dataset originates from parallel observations when the primary instrument is a spectrograph ( cos or stis ) , there is no dithering of the exposures . to compensate for the lack of dithering
, the borg data reduction pipeline has been augmented with a customized laplacian edge filtering algorithm developed by @xcite .
overall , the lack of dithering has a minimal impact ( @xmath53 ) on the image and photometric quality , as it has been established through comparison between primary ( dithered ) versus pure - parallel observations of the same field @xcite .
since the borg[z8 ] survey was designed to have @xmath38 as primary detection band , some fields have only a single short exposure in the @xmath46-band . to ensure a consistently high image quality , here we include in the analysis only those fields with total exposure time @xmath54 in @xmath46 .
this resulted in the exclusion of 9 fields out of 71 , so that the area included in our study is @xmath55 arcmin@xmath5 .
the distribution of the exposure time in @xmath46 for the fields in borg[z8 ] is shown in figure [ fieldhist ] .
the borg[z8 ] public data release consists of reduced and aligned science images produced with ` multidrizzle ` @xcite with a pixel scale of @xmath56 , as well as associated weight maps ( see @xcite ) . following our standard analysis pipeline to search for dropouts in the data @xcite , we create rms maps from the weight maps , and normalize them to account for correlated noise induced by ` multidrizzle ` ( see @xcite ) . in short , this is done for each field and filter by measuring the noise in the image at random positions not associated with detected sources ( i.e. the `` sky '' noise ) , and comparing the measurement with the value inferred from the rms map , which can then be corrected by a multiplicative factor to match the measurement .
our rescaling factors are on average @xmath57 for the ir filters and @xmath58 for @xmath44 ( see also @xcite ) .
in addition , photometric zero - points are corrected to account for galactic reddening along each line of sight , according to @xcite .
using ` sextractor ` @xcite in dual - image mode , we construct catalogues of sources in each field , using the @xmath46-band image for detection .
colors and signal to noise ratios are defined based on isophotal fluxes / magnitudes ( flux_iso ) , while we adopt mag_auto for the total magnitude of each source .
to select @xmath19 galaxy candidates , we use the dropout technique @xcite . at high @xmath24 , neutral hydrogen in the igm almost completely absorbs uv photons , leading to a break at the galaxy rest wavelength of ly@xmath15 ( 1216 ) . for galaxies between @xmath59 ,
this implies a drop in the @xmath38-filter , and non - detection in the @xmath44 and @xmath45 bands .
our focus on @xmath38-dropouts implies that our sample of candidates are essentially detected only in @xmath46 .
therefore , to minimize the risk of introducing spurious sources , we require a clear detection in @xmath46 , with s / n@xmath60 .
we also impose a strong @xmath61 break , trading sample completeness for higher purity , and require a color cut : @xmath62 , which is more conservative than the typical @xmath63 applied to legacy fields ( e.g. @xcite ) since we do not have the availability of multi - observatory data to constrain the continuum of candidates at longer wavelengths and help control contamination .
overall , we impose the following criteria for selection as @xmath38-dropouts : @xmath64 when computing the @xmath65 color , if the @xmath38-band flux has s / n @xmath66 we use the @xmath67 limit instead . finally , to reduce the risk of contamination from detector defects surviving the data reduction pipeline , we further impose a stellarity cut through the ` sextractor ` class_star parameter .
we require class_star @xmath68 , where 1 corresponds to a point source , and 0 to a diffuse light profile .
we then visually inspected the dropouts that meet these criteria to reject any remaining detector artifacts and diffraction spikes .
all the sources that meet all criteria and pass the visual inspection are listed in table [ table1 ] , and discussed below .
lccccccccccc borg_0240 - 1857_25 & 40.1195 & -18.9726 & 26.24 @xmath69 0.18 & @xmath70 & 8.1 & @xmath71 & -0.1 & 1.0 & @xmath72 & 0.71 & @xmath8 + borg_0240 - 1857_129 & 40.1289 & -18.9678 & 24.74 @xmath69 0.07 & @xmath73 & 14.5 & 2.5 & 0.6 & 0.9 & @xmath74 & 0.02 & @xmath75 + borg_0240 - 1857_369 & 40.1274 & -18.9612 & 25.22 @xmath69 0.11 & @xmath76 & 9.6 & 2.2 & -1.7 & 0.2 & @xmath77 & 0.00 & @xmath78 + borg_0456 - 2203_1091 & 73.9774 & -22.0372 & 26.09 @xmath69 0.13 & @xmath79 & 8.1 & -1.3 & -0.4 & 0.1 & @xmath80 & 0.51 & @xmath81 + borg_1153 + 0056_514 & 178.1972 & 0.9270 & 26.31 @xmath69 0.24 & @xmath82 & 8.0 & 0.02 & -0.1 & -0.6 & @xmath83 & 0.01 & @xmath84 + borg_1459 + 7146_785 & 224.7239 & 71.7814 & 25.82 @xmath69 0.14 & 1.57 & 12.8 & 3.7 & -1.1 & 1.3 & @xmath85 & 0.91 & @xmath86 + + + + + + we performed a search for @xmath38-dropouts over @xmath55 arcmin@xmath5 of archival borg data .
we find six sources that satisfy the @xmath38-dropout selection with s / n@xmath87 .
the candidates are detected over a range of magnitudes , with four candidates between @xmath88 , and two brighter candidates at @xmath89 and @xmath90 . at @xmath91 ,
this corresponds to @xmath92 to @xmath93 .
three candidates are detected only in @xmath46 , while the remaining three are detected in both @xmath38 and @xmath46 .
the photometry of the candidates is reported in table [ table1 ] , and postage stamps of @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath38 , and @xmath46 are shown in figure [ fig1 ] .
we derive photometric redshifts for these six candidates using the photo-@xmath24 code bpz @xcite , assuming a flat prior on redshift , motivated by the uncertainty in the density of sources at intermediate redshifts with colors similar to those of @xmath22 galaxies . for the single band ( @xmath46 ) detections , the photometric redshift distribution is flat over the range @xmath94 .
for the two - band ( @xmath38 and @xmath46 ) detections , the photometric redshifts are sharply peaked around @xmath9 .
the photometric probability distributions are included in figure [ fig1 ] alongside the images of the candidates . a comparison of the apparent @xmath46 magnitude against the photometric redshift of our candidates against @xmath21 candidates from other _
hst_/wfc3 surveys is shown in figure [ hvszplot ] . while two of our candidates are particularly bright in @xmath46 , they are consistent with previously - discovered candidates at @xmath39 by @xcite .
we also determine the size of the candidates , starting from the observed half - light ( effective ) radius as determined by ` sextractor ` , which is translated into an intrinsic source size taking into account the effects of the point - spread function ( psf ) broadening and surface brightness limits following @xcite .
the empirical relation has been constructed by inserting and recovering artificial sources with known input size and magnitude into borg images .
source size is very helpful to help discriminate between high- and low-@xmath24 sources , since direct measurements by @xcite on candels galaxies show that @xmath95 sources are more compact than @xmath96 contaminants with similar colors .
this empirical separation might be related to an approximate scaling of galaxy sizes as @xmath97 with @xmath98 @xcite , although a recent study by @xcite highlights that the intrinsic sizes likely evolve less strongly with redshift ( @xmath99 ) compared to observed sizes .
we discuss the contamination of our sample further in section [ contamination ] .
this candidate is the brightest in the sample , with magnitude @xmath100 .
it is robustly detected in @xmath46 at @xmath101 , and marginally detected in @xmath38 at @xmath102 , even though it is close to the edge of the chip .
the source has a very red @xmath103 color , with @xmath104 .
it also shows extended structure , and has @xmath105 .
its photometric redshift solution is sharply peaked at @xmath106 , with a broad higher - redshift wing .
this candidate , in the same field as the previous one is detected with magnitude @xmath107 , making it the second - brightest source in the sample .
it is detected with s / n @xmath108 in @xmath46 , and again marginally detected with s / n @xmath109 in @xmath38 .
it is the most extended source in the sample , with @xmath110 .
its photometric redshift , like borg_0240 - 1857_129 , is peaked at @xmath111 , with a broad higher - redshift wing .
field borg_0240 - 1857 includes a third bright candidate with @xmath112 , detected at s / n @xmath113 .
this source is not detected in the other bands ( @xmath38 , @xmath45 or @xmath44@xmath114 ) .
unlike the two brighter candidates , this object is more compact , with a measured half - light radius @xmath115 . this is smaller than the psf of the image ( @xmath116 ) , indicating that it could be a point - source - like contaminant such as a cool dwarf star ,
although the stellarity of this source is @xmath117 , which is lower than the value expected for a point source ( e.g. @xcite uses class_star @xmath118 and @xcite class_star @xmath119 to exclude stars ) .
this candidate is close to a foreground galaxy with @xmath120 , with a centre - to - centre projected separation of @xmath121 .
while this foreground galaxy has an uncertain photometric redshift solution , it is likely to be at @xmath122 , based on its compact size .
using the framework developed by @xcite and @xcite , we estimate the gravitational lensing of this source .
magnification pdfs are obtained by estimating velocity dispersions from @xmath46 magnitudes , using the empirical redshift - dependent faber - jackson relations given in @xcite and @xcite .
velocity dispersion is the best tracer of the strength of a strong gravitational lens @xcite .
the einstein radii of the foreground objects are modelled as singular isothermal spheres ( e.g. @xcite ) which depend on the velocity dispersion and the angular diameter distance to the source , and between the lens and source ( where we use the best photo-@xmath24 values ) . assuming that the foreground source is at @xmath123 ( which maximizes lensing magnification ) , we infer a magnification @xmath124 .
this object has a magnitude @xmath125 ( @xmath126 ) , and is detected in the @xmath46 only , with an extended but compact structure ( effective radius @xmath127 ) .
the source is located relatively close ( @xmath128 separation ) to a hot pixel , which appears in the @xmath45 and @xmath38 images .
the @xmath46-band image is unaffected since it was acquired in a later orbit than the images in bluer bands .
we carefully examined the individual flt files and conclude that since the separation between the source center and the hot pixel is larger than twice @xmath129 , and there is no sign of a hot pixel in the @xmath46-band , the identification of the candidate as a @xmath38-dropout is robust .
this candidate is detected with a magnitude @xmath130 , and has s / n @xmath131 .
it is not detected in @xmath38 , @xmath45 or @xmath44 .
it has an effective radius of @xmath132 .
this candidate is close to a foreground object ( @xmath133 centre - to - centre projected separation ) .
the foreground object has an apparent magnitude @xmath134 , and is at an indeterminate photometric redshift .
we use the same modelling framework as for borg_0240 - 1857_25 to estimate the lensing magnification of this source .
assuming that the source is at @xmath123 , we find a maximum @xmath135 .
analysis of the flt images of this field highlighted the presence of a bad pixel , correctly identified and masked by the data reduction pipeline , at the outer edge of the segmentation map of the dropout candidate in one of the two @xmath46 frames .
to determine the impact on the final photometry , we measured the source flux in the flt frames separately , finding that the candidate is detected with s / n @xmath136 in the unaffected image and also s / n @xmath137 in the image affected by the bad pixel .
hence , we are confident that the source is real and that the photometry from the final drizzled image is robust . the sixth and final candidate is confidently detected at s / n@xmath138 in @xmath46 ( @xmath120 ) , and also in the @xmath38 with s / n = 3.7 .
its photometric redshift is sharply peaked at @xmath139 , with a secondary solution at @xmath140 .
this candidate is also very compact , with measured half - light radius @xmath141 , and the highest stellarity of the sample ( class_star = 0.91 ) .
combining compactness with high stellarity from a high s / n source , a stellar nature ( cool dwarf ) for this source is relatively likely , as we discuss in section [ contamination ] .
to translate the results on the search of possible candidates at @xmath3 from the archival borg[z8 ] data into a number density / luminosity function determination , we need to assess both the impact of contamination in our sample , and the effective volume probed by the data .
there are multiple classes of lower-@xmath24 sources that may have similar @xmath103 colors to @xmath19 lyman - break galaxies ( lbgs ) , such as galactic stars , intermediate - redshift passive galaxies , and strong line emitters .
cool , red stars in the milky way may be possible contaminants of our sample , although typical colors lack a strong @xmath103 drop . at low signal - to - noise ratio ,
the separation of point - like galactic stars from resolved galaxies using the ` sextractor ` class_star parameter is not fully reliable .
we use class_star @xmath143 in our selection of @xmath38-dropouts in section [ section3 ] to reject artifacts remaining from the reduction process , but this is not a strict enough criterion to reject all stars from our sample . in this case , five of our candidates identified as @xmath38-dropouts have class_star @xmath144 , with only borg_1459 + 7146_785 having class_star @xmath145 ( a value considered by @xcite as indicative of a stellar nature ) .
therefore we conclude that this source is most likely a stellar contaminant with unusual colors .
emission - line galaxies are another source of contamination for @xmath19 galaxy samples .
for example , galaxies at @xmath146 with strong [ oii ] emission may appear bright in @xmath46-band while the galaxy continuum is too faint to be detected in the other bands @xcite . @xcite find that , at @xmath147 , the average density of extreme line emitters that enter the photometric selection is @xmath148 per arcmin@xmath149 , by creating mock catalogs of extreme emission line galaxies with varying @xmath38 magnitude and spectral slope @xmath150 . extrapolating this result to @xmath39
, we expect to find @xmath151 potential contaminants of this type over our survey area .
this value is in line with previous spectroscopic observations of @xmath147 borg candidates by @xcite using the mosfire spectrograph on the keck telescope , and by @xcite using xshooter on the very large telescope .
these studies found no emission lines in the spectroscopy of @xmath147 candidates , and are able to rule out emission lines from a low-@xmath24 extreme emission line contaminant to @xmath152 , assuming that all of the @xmath46 flux is due to a strong emission line .
@xcite also find that , with a 3hr exposure , only a small part of the spectrum ( @xmath153 ) is so affected by atmospheric transmission and absorption by oh lines that a strong emission line would not be detected to @xmath13 .
the last , and probably most severe class of contaminants , is that of passive and dusty galaxies that thus show a strong balmer break and a very faint uv continuum . under these conditions ,
@xmath154 sources may mimic properties of lbgs and thus enter into our selection .
observations with _
spitzer_/irac at @xmath155 and @xmath156 m can efficiently distinguish between high- and low - redshift sources .
in fact , dusty @xmath123 galaxies will appear 1 - 2 magnitudes brighter in [ 3.6 ] and [ 4.5 ] than in @xmath46 , while @xmath19 lbgs will have a relatively flat spectrum . without spitzer data , we rely on the size of the sources as proxy for the @xmath157 $ ] color , considering sources with @xmath158 as likely contaminants .
@xcite find that , while the mean size of candidates in the @xmath39 sample from @xcite is @xmath72 , low - redshift , irac - red interlopers have a mean size of @xmath159 , but can be as small as @xmath160 , and there are no high-@xmath24 candidates with sizes greater than @xmath161 ( figure 4 , @xcite ) .
hence , we take @xmath162 as a threshold .
the two brightest sources in our sample are so extended to fall into such classification .
the sources considered in @xcite are fainter than the @xmath39 candidates in our sample , and so it is conceivable that the larger sizes of borg_0240 - 1857_129 and borg_0240 - 1857_369 are due to their higher luminosities . using the size - luminosity relation derived in @xcite
, we infer that the size of a @xmath163 galaxy at @xmath164 ( the brightest in our sample ) would be @xmath165 , below our threshold of @xmath162 .
this size can not be used to completely reject extreme emission - line galaxies , which are likely to be more compact .
for example , @xcite find that their sample of 52 extreme emission line galaxies in clash have fwhm @xmath166 , similar to our @xmath167 criterion for @xmath39 candidates .
in addition to finding the redshift probability distribution of our six candidates using bpz , we also fit sed templates described in @xcite . from this
, we find an average probability @xmath168 of @xmath169 .
we conclude that three out of the six candidates , borg_1459 + 7146_785 , borg_0240 - 1857_129 , and borg_0240 - 1857_369 , are likely to be contaminants .
for the remaining three , contamination is still a possibility , and hence we make a conservative assumption of @xmath170 contamination ( two out of three sources at @xmath171 ) , based on the estimate from the borg[z9 - 10 ] survey @xcite using the average probability @xmath168 for the candidates in their sample . of the six possible candidates identified in the full borg[z8 ] survey ,
three of them , including the two brightest , are found in the same field ( borg_0240 - 1857 ) .
the exposure time for this pointing is similar to the median of the survey ( @xmath172 s in @xmath46 ) , and thus such a catch is highly unlikely under the assumptions of a uniform distribution of candidates in the 62 fields analyzed here .
based on theoretical expectations , the presence of clustering can be used to verify the identity of bright high-@xmath24 sources @xcite , under the broad assumption that uv luminosity is correlated with dark - matter halo mass ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
overdensities have also been identified at @xmath4 in lbg samples @xcite .
however , one alternative possibility , more consistent with the relatively large size of the two bright @xmath34-dropouts , would be the presence of an overdensity of passive and dusty satellite galaxies within an intermediate redshift group .
in either case , a further exploration of this configuration is very interesting since it can either identify an exciting overdensity of unexpectedly bright sources at @xmath11 , or shed light on the properties of intermediate redshift galaxies with extreme @xmath173 colors .
we perform source recovery simulations to determine the efficiency and completeness of our selection , following @xcite . to do this
, we insert and recover artificial galaxies with a srsic luminosity profile in the images . half of the sources follow a de vaucouleurs profile ( srsic index @xmath174 ) , and the other half follow an exponential profile ( srsic index @xmath175 ) , spanning a range of magnitudes ( @xmath176 ) , redshifts ( @xmath177 ) and sizes ( logarithmic distribution with mean 0175 at @xmath178 , scaling as @xmath179 ) .
the spectra of the sources are modeled as power law @xmath180 with @xmath181 ( gaussian distribution ) with a sharp cut - off at rest - frame @xmath182 .
the intrinsic profiles of the artificial sources are convolved with the wfc3 psf for each corresponding filter , before being inserted into the borg science images at random positions .
sources are then identified with , and the statistics of the recovery rate is quantified .
this is through the definition of @xmath183 which is the completeness of the source detection , that is the probability of recovering an artificial source of magnitude @xmath184 in the image , and of @xmath185 , which is the probability of identifying an artificial source of magnitude @xmath184 and redshift @xmath24 within the dropout sample , assuming that the source is detected .
one example of the selection function for the dropout search in field borg_0440 - 5244 is shown in the bottom panel of figure [ figvolume ] , while the upper panel of the same figure shows the overall effective volume probed by our search over all borg archival fields as a function of the apparent @xmath46 magnitude .
+ recovered from simulations , as a function of the apparent @xmath46 magnitude .
bottom panel : an example of the selection function @xmath185 for field borg_0440 - 5244 .
the selection function is derived from simulations , by inserting and recovering artificial sources .
[ figvolume],title="fig:",scaledwidth=46.0% ] from the discussion in section [ contamination ] , we consider the two brightest sources to be likely contaminants because of their large half - light radii , and we exclude the point - like source borg_1459 + 7146_785 as well . for the surviving three candidates we assume a contamination rate of @xmath170 ,
e.g. we expect two sources to be at @xmath3 . after taking into account the effective volume probed by our selection , our estimates for the bright - end of the luminosity function at @xmath3
is reported in table [ table3 ] , and shown in figure [ figlf ] .
interestingly , we infer a higher number density of bright sources than previous determinations by @xcite around @xmath186 , although the uncertainty is very large because of the small number of candidates . for brighter sources ( @xmath187 ) ,
our upper limits on @xmath3 density are similar to those obtained in legacy fields , and strengthen the evidence for suppression of the abundance of galaxies at the bright - end of the luminosity function . when compared to the initial results from the ongoing borg[z9 - 10 ] survey @xcite , assuming that our two brightest sources are low - redshift contaminants , we do not find evidence of ultra - bright ( @xmath188 ) galaxies despite analyzing data covering more than twice the area .
if follow - up observations of our brightest sources indicate that they are likely at high redshift , we would instead determine that the lf is higher at the bright end than the upper limit from @xcite , and is instead consistent with the determination by @xcite at @xmath189 .
overall , our lf determination is higher , but still consistent at @xmath190 with the theoretical model of @xcite , shown as grey shaded area in figure [ figlf ] .
previous studies did not attempt unconstrained fits to the @xmath3 lf , likely because of the small number of candidates . to evaluate the status of the situation with our additional datapoints , we attempt to derive schechter parameters for a maximum likelihood fit to the stepwise lf data , carried out assuming a poisson distribution for the number of galaxies expected in each bin ( see @xcite ) . due to the non - detection at @xmath191 by @xcite ,
the lf is suppressed at the faint end .
this leads to a likelihood landscape that is very flat over a wide region of the parameter space , and hence , we are unable to sufficiently constrain the schechter parameters .
our fit attempt thus highlights that the dataset is still too small for tight quantitative constraints , but future growth in the number of candidates identified will allow rapid improvements .
finally , we note that our conclusions rest on the assumption that the two brightest candidates we identified in field borg_0240 - 1857 are contaminants .
if we were to include them in the analysis as @xmath3 sources , we would infer that the lf would favor a power law at the bright end , rather than a schechter form .
evidence for a single or double power - law form at high redshift has been seen in determinations of the lf at @xmath192 ( @xcite , also earlier considered by @xcite ) , and potentially at @xmath11 by @xcite , and may be naturally interpreted as a decrease in mass quenching from processes such as agn feedback at high redshift @xcite .
magnification bias , however , can also produce this effect on an otherwise schechter - like lf .
thus , the astrophysical interpretation of our search ultimately rests on follow - up observations to establish the nature of the candidates borg_0240 - 1857_129 and borg_0240 - 1857_369 . in any case
, it is very interesting to note that the number of potential candidate @xmath34-dropouts that we identified is small ( just six in over 60 fields ) , making further observations time - efficient , especially because half of the sources are clustered in a single pointing .
cc @xmath193 & @xmath194 + @xmath195 & @xmath196 + @xmath197 & @xmath198
in this paper we presented a search for @xmath19 candidates in archival data of the 2010 - 2014 brightest of reionizing galaxies ( borg[z8 ] ) survey , a pure - parallel optical and near - infrared survey using _ hst_/wfc3 .
while the survey was optimized to identify @xmath4 sources as @xmath45-dropouts , we searched over the deepest 293 arcmin@xmath5 of the survey for @xmath38-dropout sources with @xmath199 , motivated by recent identification of very bright sources with @xmath200 .
our key results are : * we identify six @xmath39 galaxy candidates , detected in @xmath46 at s / n @xmath6 and satisfying a conservative @xmath65 color selection with non - detection in bluer bands of the survey . the candidate s magnitudes vary from @xmath201 to @xmath202 .
analysis of the surface brightness profile leads to the tentative identification of three contaminants , with the two brightest sources likely being intermediate redshift passive galaxies due to their size , and one faint source a galactic cool dwarf star because of the compact size and high stellarity .
* of the six candidates , three are in the same field , borg_0240 - 1857 , including the two brightest of the sample .
such strong clustering would be naturally explained if the sources were @xmath3 ( see @xcite ) , despite contrary indication from @xmath129 , but an alternative explanation of sub - halo clustering at intermediate redshift would also be viable . * based on our best estimate of the lf , we infer a higher galaxy number density for sources at @xmath186 compared to the observations of bouwens et al .
( 2015a , b ) and with the theoretical model of mason et al .
( 2015b ) .
however , our measurement is still consistent at the @xmath13 level with these studies .
* irrespective of the nature of the two brightest sources in the sample , the selection criteria that we adopted yield a small number of candidates , very manageable for follow - up observations .
this is quite remarkable , since the borg[z8 ] survey was not designed with @xmath11 in mind , and the number of contaminants could have been much larger given the absence of a second detection band and the lack of a near - uv color to help remove passive and dusty intermediate redshift galaxies .
* targeted follow - up observations can efficiently clarify the nature of the candidates we identified , help to further constrain the bright - end of the lf and characterize the properties of the yet unstudied population of compact intermediate redshift passive galaxies that mimic the colors of @xmath203 sources .
the efficiency of targeted follow - ups and the overall potential to complement searches for @xmath3 sources traditionally carried out in legacy fields are demonstrated by the very recent award of _ spitzer _ irac time to our team to investigate the nature of the sources discussed here ( pid # 12058 , pi bouwens ) . with these observations , it will be possible to clarify the behavior of the bright end of the lf at @xmath3 , as well as to confirm ideal targets for further spectroscopic follow - up investigations without having to wait for _ james webb space telescope_. sb , mt , and jw thank the vatican observatory , where part of this work was carried out , for kind hospitality .
this work was partially supported by grants _
hst_/go 13767 , 12905 , and 12572 .
this research was conducted by the australian research council centre of excellence for all - sky astrophysics ( caastro ) , through project number ce110001020 .
alvarez , m. a. , finlator , k. , trenti , m. 2012 , , 759 , l38 atek , h. , siana , b. , scarlata , c. et al .
2011 , , 743 , 121 barone - nugent , r. l. , trenti , m. , wyithe , j. s. b. et al .
2014 , , 793 , 17 barone - nugent , r. l. , wyithe , j. s. b. , trenti , m. et al . 2015a , , 450 , 1224 barone - nugent , r. l. , sonnenfeld , a. , wyithe , j. s. b. et al .
2015b , , 453 , 3068 bentez , n. , 2000 , , 536 , 571 bertin , e. & arnouts , s. 1996 , , 117 , 393 - 404 bradley , l. d. , trenti , m. , oesch , p. a. et al . 2012 , ,
760 , 108 bouwens , r. j. , illingworth , g. d. , blakeslee , j. p. , broadhurst , t. j. & franx , m. 2004 , , 611 , l1 bouwens , r. j. , illingworth , g. d. , blakesless , j. p. & franx , m. 2004 , , 653 , 53 bouwens , r. j. , illingworth , g. d. , franx , m. & ford , h. 2007 , , 670 , 928 bouwens , r. j. , illingworth , g. d. , labb , i. et al . 2011a , , 469 , 504 bouwens .
r. j. , illingworth , g. d. , oesch , p. a. et al . 2011b , , 737 , 90 bouwens , r. j. , bradley , l. , zitrin , a. et al .
2014 , , 795 , 126 bouwens , r. j. , illingworth , g. d. , oesch , p. a. et al .
2015a , , 803 , 34 bouwens , r. j. , oesch , p. a. , labb , i. et al .
2015b , arxiv:1506.01035v2 bowler , r. a. a. , dunlop , j. s. , mclure , r. j. et al .
2014 , , 440 , 2810 calvi , v. , trenti , m. , stiavelli , m. et al .
2015 , arxiv:1512.05363 caruana , j. , bunker , a. j. , wilkins , s. m. et al .
2012 , , 427 , 3055 casertano , s. , de mello , d. , dickinson , m. et al .
2000 , , 120 , 2747 coe , d. , zitrin , a. , carrasco , m. et al .
2013 , , 762 , 32 curtis - lake , e. , mclure , r. j. , dunlop , j. s. et al .
2016 , , 457 , 440 ellis , r. s. , mclure , r. j. , dunlop , j. s. et al .
2013 , , 763 , l7 fall .
, s. m. & efstathiou , g. 1980 , , 193 , 189 fialkov , a. & loeb , a. 2015 , , 806 , 256 finkelstein , s. l. , papovich , c. , dickinson , m. et al .
2013 , , 502 , 524 finkelstein , s. l. , ryan , r. e. , jr , papovich , c. et al .
2015 , , 810 , 71 giallongo , e. , menci , n. , castellano , m. , fontana , a. , grazian , a. & pentericci , l. 2012 , , 755 , 124 grazian , a. , fontana , a. , santini , p. et al .
2015 , , 575 , a96 grogin , n. a. , kocevski , d. d. , faber , s. m. et al .
2011 , , 197 , 35 holwerda , b. w. , bouwens , r. , oesch , p. , et al .
2015 , , 808 , 6 huang , x. , zheng , w. , wang , j. et al .
2015 , , 801 , 12 illingworth , g. d. , magee , d. , oesch , p. a. et al .
2013 , , 209 , 6 infante , l. , zheng , w. , laporte , n. et al .
2015 , , 815 , 18 ishigaki , m. , kawamata , r. , ouchi , m. , oguri , m. , shimasaku , k. , & ono , y. 2015 , , 799 , 12 ishigaki , m. , ouchi , m. & harikane , y. , 2015 , arxiv150901751 koekemoer , a. m. , fruchter , a. s. , hook , r. n. & hack , w. 2003 , in the 2002 hst calibration workshop : hubble after the installation of the acs and the nicmos cooling system , ed .
s. arribas , a. koekemoer , & b. whitmore ( baltimore , md : stsci ) , 337 koekemoer , a. m. , faber , s. m. , ferguson , h. c. et al .
2011 , , 197 , 36 labb , i. , gonzlez , v. , bouwens , r. j. et al .
2010 , , 716 , l103 labb , i. , oesch , p. a. , illingworth , g. d. et al .
2015 , arxiv:1507.08313 madau , p. , haardt , f. , & rees , m. j. 1999 , , 514 , 648 madau , p. & haardt , f. 2015 , , 813 , l8 malhotra , a. , rhoads , j. e. , pirzkal , n. et al .
2005 , , 626 , 666 mason , c. a. , treu , t. , schmidt , k. b. et al . 2015a , , 805 , 79 mason , c. a. , trenti , m. & treu , t. 2015b , , 813 , 21 mcleod , d. j. , mclure , r. j. , dunlop , j. s. , robertson , b. e. , ellis , r. s. , & targett , t. a. 2015 , , 450 , 3032 mclure , r. j. , dunlop , j. s. , bowler , r. a. a. et al .
2013 , , 432 , 2696 muoz , j. a. & loeb , a. 2008 , , 385 , 2175 muoz , j. a. & loeb , a. 2011 , , 729 , 99 oesch , p. a. , stiavelli , m. , carollo , c. m. et al .
2007 , , 671,1212 oesch , p. a. , carollo , c. m. , stiavelli , m. et al .
2009 , , 690 , 1350 oesch , p. a. , bouwens , r. j. , carollo , c. m. et al .
2010 , , 709 , l21 oesch , p. a. , bouwens , r. j. , illingworth , g. d. et al .
2012 , , 759 , 135 oesch , p. a. , bouwens , r. j. , illingworth , g. d. et al .
2013 , , 773 , 75 oesch , p. a. , bouwens , r. j. , illingworth , g. d. et al .
2014 , , 786 , 108 oesch , p. a. , van dokkum , p. g. , illingworth , g. d. et al .
2015 , , 804 , l30 oke , j. b. & gunn , j. e. 1983 , , 266 , 713 pentericci , l. , fontana , a. , vanzella , e. et al .
2011 , , 743 , 132 pentericci , l. , vanzella , e. , fontana , a. et al .
2014 , , 793 , 113 planck collaboration , ade , p. a. r. , aghanim , n. et al .
2015 , arxiv:1502.01589 postman , m. , coe , d. , bnitez , n. et al .
2012 , , 199 , 25 roberts - borsani , g. w. , bouwens , r. j. , oesch , p. a. et al .
2015 , arxiv:1506.00854 schechter , p. 1976
, , 203 , 297 schenker , m. a. , stark , d. p. , ellis , r. s. et al .
2012 , , 744 , 179 schlafly , e. f. , finkbeiner , d. p. 2011
, , 737 , 103 schmidt , k. b. , treu , t. , trenti , m. et al .
2014 , , 786 , 57 schneider , p. , kochanek , c. s. & wambsganss , j. 2006 , gravitational lensing : strong , weak and micro ( berlin : springer ) stark , d. p. , ellis , r. s. , bunker , a. et al .
2009 , , 697 , 1493 stark , d. p. , ellis , r. s. , chiu , k. , ouchi , m. & bunker , a. 2010 , , 408 , 1628 stark , d. p. , richard , j. , charlot , s. et al .
2015 , , 450 , 1846 stark , d. p. , walth , g. , charlot , s. et al .
2015 , , 454 , 1393 steidel , c. c. , giavalisco , m. , pettini , m. , dickinson , m. , & adelberger , k. l. 1996 , , 462 , l17 tacchella , s. , trenti , m. & carollo , c. m. , 768 , l37 tilvi , v. , papovich , c. , finkelstein , s. l. et al .
2014 , , 794 , 5 trenti , m. & stiavelli , m. 2008 , , 676 , 767 trenti , m. , stiavelli , m. , bouwens , r. j. et al .
2010 , , 714 , l202 trenti , m. , bradley , l. d. , stiavelli , m. et al .
2011 , , 727 , l39 trenti , m. , bradley , l. d. , stiavelli , m. et al .
2012 , , 746 , 55 treu , t. 2010 , , 48 , 87 treu , t. , trenti , m. , stiavelli , m. , auger , m. w. & bradley , l. d. 2012 , , 747 , 27 treu , t. , schmidt , k. b. , trenti , m. , bradley , l. d. , & stiavelli , m. 2013 , , 775 , l29 turner , e. l. , ostriker , j. p. van dokkum , p. g. 2001 , , 113 , 1420 vanzella , e. , fontana , a. , pentericci , l. et al .
2014 , , 569 , a78 willott , c. j. , delorme , p. , omont , a. et al .
2007 , , 134 , 2435 wyithe , j. s. b. , yan , h. , windhorst , r. & mao , s. 2011 , , 469 , 181 yan , h. , yan , l. , zamojski , m. a. et al .
2011 , , 728 , l22 zheng , w. , postman , m. , zitrin , a. et al .
2012 , , 489 , 406 zheng , w. , shu , x. , moustakas , j. et al .
2014 , , 795 , 93 zitrin , a. , zheng , w. , broadhurst , t. et al .
2014 , , 793 , l12 zitrin , a. , labb , i. , belli , s. et al .
2015 , arxiv:1507.02679
|
the wide field camera 3 ( wfc3 ) on the _ hubble space telescope _ ( _ hst _ ) enabled the search for the first galaxies observed at @xmath0 ( @xmath1 myr after the big bang ) . to continue quantifying the number density of the most luminous galaxies ( @xmath2 ) at the earliest epoch observable with _ hst
_ , we search for @xmath3 galaxies ( f125w - dropouts ) in archival data from the brightest of reionizing galaxies ( borg[z8 ] ) survey , originally designed for detection of @xmath4 galaxies ( f098m - dropouts ) . by focusing on the deepest 293 arcmin@xmath5 of the data along 62 independent lines of sight , we identify six @xmath3 candidates satisfying the color selection criteria , detected at s / n @xmath6 in f160w with @xmath7 to @xmath8 if at @xmath9 .
three of the six sources , including the two brightest , are in a single wfc3 pointing ( @xmath10 arcmin@xmath5 ) , suggestive of significant clustering , which is expected from bright galaxies at @xmath11 .
however , the two brightest galaxies are too extended to be likely at @xmath11 , and one additional source is unresolved and possibly a brown dwarf .
the remaining three candidates have @xmath12 , and given the area and completeness of our search , our best estimate is a number density of sources that is marginally higher but consistent at @xmath13 with searches in legacy fields .
our study highlights that @xmath11 searches can yield a small number of candidates , making tailored follow - ups of _ hst _ pure - parallel observations viable and effective .
|
invariants are a popular concept in object recognition and image retrieval @xcite .
they aim to provide descriptions that remain constant under certain geometric or radiometric transformations of the scene , thereby reducing the search space .
they can be classified into global invariants , typically based either on a set of key points or on moments , and local invariants , typically based on derivatives of the image function which is assumed to be continuous and differentiable .
the geometric transformations of interest often include translation , rotation , and scaling , summarily referred to as _ similarity _ transformations . in a previous paper @xcite , building on work done by schmid and mohr @xcite , we have proposed differential invariants for those similarity transformations , plus _ linear _ brightness change . here
, we are looking at a _ non - linear _ brightness change known as _ gamma correction_. gamma correction is a non - linear quantization of the brightness measurements performed by many cameras during the image formation process .
the idea is to achieve better _ perceptual _ results by maintaining an approximately constant ratio between adjacent brightness levels , placing the quantization levels apart by the _ just noticeable difference_. incidentally , this non - linear quantization also precompensates for the non - linear mapping from voltage to brightness in electronic display devices @xcite .
gamma correction can be expressed by the equation @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the input intensity , @xmath2 is the output intensity , and @xmath3 is a normalization factor which is determined by the value of @xmath4 . for output devices , the ntsc standard specifies @xmath5 . for input devices like cameras ,
the parameter value is just inversed , resulting in a typical value of @xmath6 .
the camera we used , the sony 3 ccd color camera dxc 950 , exhibited @xmath7 . for the kodak megaplus xrc camera ]
[ fig : gammacorr ] shows the intensity mapping of 8-bit data for different values of @xmath4 .
it turns out that an invariant under gamma correction can be designed from first and second order derivatives .
additional invariance under scaling requires third order derivatives .
derivatives are by nature translationally invariant .
rotational invariance in 2-d is achieved by using rotationally symmetric operators .
the key idea for the design of the proposed invariants is to form suitable ratios of the derivatives of the image function such that the parameters describing the transformation of interest will cancel out .
this idea has been used in @xcite to achieve invariance under linear brightness changes , and it can be adjusted to the context of gamma correction by at least conceptually considering the _ logarithm _ of the image function . for simplicity , we begin with 1-d image functions .
let @xmath8 be the image function , i.e. the original signal , assumed to be continuous and differentiable , and @xmath9 the corresponding gamma corrected function .
note that @xmath8 is a special case of @xmath10 where @xmath11 .
taking the logarithm yields @xmath12 with the derivatives @xmath13 , and @xmath14 .
we can now define the invariant @xmath15 under gamma correction to be @xmath16{0mm}{13 mm } & = $ \frac{\gamma\ , \frac{f'(x)}{f(x ) } } { \gamma\ , \frac{f(x)\,f''(x ) - f'(x)^2}{f(x)^2}}$ \\ & = $ \frac{f(x)\,f'(x)}{f(x)\,f''(x ) - f'(x)^2}$ \end{tabular}\ ] ] the factor @xmath3 has been eliminated by taking derivatives , and @xmath4 has canceled out .
furthermore , @xmath15 turns out to be completely specified in terms of the _ original _ image function and its derivatives , i.e. the logarithm actually does nt have to be computed .
the notation @xmath17 indicates that the invariant depends on the underlying image function @xmath8 and location @xmath18 the invariance holds under gamma correction , not under spatial changes of the image function .
a shortcoming of @xmath15 is that it is undefined where the denominator is zero .
therefore , we modify @xmath15 to be continuous everywhere : @xmath19{0mm}{8 mm } { \normalsize $ \theta_{m12\gamma}=$ } & $ \frac{f\,f'}{f\,f '' - { f'}^2}$ & { \normalsize if $ |f\,f'| < |f\,f '' - { f'}^2|$ } \\ & $ \frac{f\,f '' - { f'}^2}{f\,f'}$ & { \normalsize else } \\
\end{tabular}\ ] ] where , for notational convenience , we have dropped the variable @xmath18 .
the modification entails .
note that the modification is just a heuristic to deal with poles .
if all derivatives are zero because the image function is constant , then differentials are certainly not the best way to represent the function .
if scaling is a transformation that has to be considered , then another parameter @xmath20 describing the change of size has to be introduced .
that is , scaling is modeled here as variable substitution @xcite : the scaled version of @xmath8 is @xmath21 .
so we are looking at the function @xmath22 where the derivatives with respect to @xmath18 are @xmath23 , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 . now
the invariant @xmath26 is obtained by defining a suitable ratio of the derivatives such that both @xmath4 and @xmath20 cancel out : @xmath27{0mm}{10 mm } & = $ \frac{g^2 g'\,g ' '' - 3\,g\,{g'}^2 g '' + 2\,{g'}^4 } { g^2 { g''}^2 - 2\,g\,{g'}^2 g '' + \ { g'}^4}$ \end{tabular}\ ] ] analogously to eq .
( [ eq : thm12 g ] ) , we can define a modified invariant @xmath28{0mm}{8 mm } { \normalsize $ \theta_{m123\gamma}=$ } & $ \frac{g^2 g'\,g ' '' - 3\,g\,{g'}^2 g '' + 2\,{g'}^4 } { g^2 { g''}^2 - 2\,g\,{g'}^2 g '' + \ { g'}^4}$ & { \normalsize if cond2 } \\ & $ \frac{g^2 { g''}^2 - 2\,g\,{g'}^2 g '' + \ { g'}^4 } { g^2 g'\,g ' '' - 3\,g\,{g'}^2 g '' + 2\,{g'}^4}$ & { \normalsize else } \\
\end{tabular}\ ] ] where condition cond1 is @xmath29 @xmath30 , and condition cond2 is @xmath31 @xmath32 @xmath33 .
again , this modification entails .
it is a straightforward albeit cumbersome exercise to verify the invariants from eqs .
( [ eq : th12 g ] ) and ( [ eq : th123 g ] ) with an analytical , differentiable function . as an arbitrary example
, we choose @xmath34 the first three derivatives are @xmath35 , @xmath36 , and @xmath37 .
then , according to eq .
( [ eq : th12 g ] ) , @xmath38 .
if we now replace @xmath8 with a gamma corrected version , say @xmath39 , the first derivative becomes @xmath40 , the second derivative is @xmath41 , and the third is @xmath42 . if we plug these derivatives into eq .
( [ eq : th12 g ] ) , we obtain an expression for @xmath43 which is identical to the one for @xmath17 above .
the algebraically inclined reader is encouraged to verify the invariant @xmath44 for the same function .
[ fig : analyex ] shows the example function and its gamma corrected counterpart , together with their derivatives and the two modified invariants .
as expected , the graphs of the invariants are the same on the right as on the left .
note that the invariants define a many - to - one mapping .
that is , the mapping is not information preserving , and it is not possible to reconstruct the original image from its invariant representation .
if @xmath45 or @xmath46 are to be computed on images , then eqs . ( [ eq : th12 g ] ) to ( [ eq : thm123 g ] ) have to be generalized to two dimensions .
this is to be done in a rotationally invariant way in order to achieve invariance under similarity transformations .
the standard way is to use rotationally symmetric operators .
for the first derivative , we have the well known _
gradient magnitude _ , defined as @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the 2-d image function , and @xmath49 , @xmath50 are partial derivatives along the x - axis and the y - axis . for the second order derivative
, we can use the linear _ laplacian _
@xmath51 horn @xcite also presents an alternative second order derivative operator , the _
quadratic variation _
@xmath52 since the qv is not a linear operator and more expensive to compute , we use the laplacian for our implementation . for the third order derivative ,
we can define , in close analogy with the quadratic variation , a _
cubic variation _ as @xmath53 the invariants from eqs .
( [ eq : th12 g ] ) to ( [ eq : thm123 g ] ) remain valid in 2-d if we replace @xmath54 with @xmath55 , @xmath56 with @xmath57 , and @xmath58 with @xmath59 .
this can be verified by going through the same argument as for the functions .
recall that the critical observation in eq .
( [ eq : th12 g ] ) was that @xmath4 cancels out , which is the case when all derivatives return a factor @xmath4 .
but such is also the case with the rotationally symmetric operators mentioned above .
for example , if we apply the gradient magnitude operator to @xmath60 , i.e. to the logarithm of a gamma corrected image function , we obtain @xmath61 returning a factor @xmath4 , and analogously for @xmath62 , qv , and cv .
a similar argument holds for eq .
( [ eq : th123 g ] ) where we have to show , in addition , that the first derivative returns a factor @xmath20 , the second derivative returns a factor @xmath63 , and the third derivative returns a factor @xmath64 , which is the case for our 2-d operators . while the derivatives of continuous , differentiable functions are uniquely defined , there are many ways to implement derivatives for _ sampled _ functions .
we follow schmid and mohr @xcite , ter haar romeny @xcite , and many other researchers in employing the derivatives of the gaussian function as filters to compute the derivatives of a sampled image function via convolution .
this way , derivation is combined with smoothing .
the 2-d zero mean gaussian is defined as @xmath65 the partial derivatives up to third order are @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 .
they are shown in fig .
[ fig : gausskernels ] . we used the parameter setting @xmath75 and kernel size @xmath76
with these kernels , eq .
( [ eq : th12 g ] ) , for example , is implemented as @xmath77 at each pixel @xmath78 , where @xmath79 denotes convolution .
we evaluate the invariant @xmath45 from eq .
( [ eq : thm12 g ] ) in two different ways .
first , we measure how much the invariant computed on an image without gamma correction is different from the invariant computed on the same image but with gamma correction .
theoretical , this difference should be zero , but in practice , it is not .
second , we compare template matching accuracy on intensity images , again without and with gamma correction , to the accuracy achievable if instead the invariant representation is used .
we also examine whether the results can be improved by prefiltering .
a straightforward error measure is the _ absolute error _ , @xmath80 where `` 0gc '' refers to the image without gamma correction , and gc stands for either `` sgc '' if the gamma correction is done synthetically via eq .
( [ eq : gammacorr ] ) , or for `` cgc '' if the gamma correction is done via the camera hardware . like the invariant itself ,
the absolute error is computed at each pixel location @xmath81 of the image , except for the image boundaries where the derivatives and therefore the invariants can not be computed reliably .
[ fig : imas ] shows an example image .
the sgc image has been computed from the 0gc image , with @xmath82 .
note that the gamma correction is done _
after _ the quantization of the 0gc image , since we do nt have access to the 0gc image before quantization .
[ fig : accuinv ] shows the invariant representations of the image data from fig .
[ fig : imas ] and the corresponding absolute errors . since , we have .
the dark points in fig . [ fig : accuinv ] , ( c ) and ( e ) , indicate areas of large errors .
we observe two error sources : * the invariant can not be computed robustly in homogeneous regions .
this is hardly surprising , given that it is based on differentials which are by definition only sensitive to spatial changes of the signal .
* there are outliers even in the sgc invariant representation , at points of very high contrast edges .
they are a byproduct of the inherent smoothing when the derivatives are computed with differentials of the gaussian .
note that the latter put a ceiling on the maximum gradient magnitude that is computable on 8-bit images .
in addition to computing the absolute error , we can also compute the relative error , in percent , as @xmath83 then we can define the set @xmath84 of _ reliable points _ , relative to some error threshold @xmath85 , as @xmath86 and @xmath87 , the percentage of reliable points , as @xmath88 where @xmath89 is the number of valid , i.e. non - boundary , pixels in the image .
[ fig : reliapts ] shows , in the first row , the reliable points for three different values of the threshold @xmath85 .
the second row shows the sets of reliable points for the same thresholds if we gently prefilter the 0gc and cgc images . the corresponding data for the ten test images from fig .
[ fig : imadb ] is summarized in table [ tab : reliaperc ] .
derivatives are known to be sensitive to noise .
noise can be reduced by smoothing the original data before the invariants are computed . on the other hand , derivatives should be computed as locally as possible . with these conflicting goals to be considered , we experiment with gentle prefiltering , using a gaussian filter of size @xmath90=1.0 .
the size of the gaussian to compute the invariant @xmath45 is set to @xmath91=1.0 .
note that @xmath90 and @xmath91 can _ not _ be combined into just one gaussian because of the non - linearity of the invariant .
with respect to the set of reliable points , we observe that after prefiltering , roughly half the points , on average , have a relative error of less than 20% .
gentle prefiltering consistently reduces both absolute and relative errors , but strong prefiltering does not .
template matching is a frequently employed technique in computer vision . here
, we will examine how gamma correction affects the spatial accuracy of template matching , and whether that accuracy can be improved by using the invariant @xmath45 .
an overview of the testbed scenario is given in fig .
[ fig : templloca ] . a small template of size @xmath92 , representing the search pattern ,
is taken from a 0gc intensity image , i.e. without gamma correction .
this query template is then correlated with the corresponding cgc intensity image , i.e. the same scene but with gamma correction switched on .
if the correlation maximum occurs at exactly the location where the 0gc query template has been cut out , we call this a _ correct maximum correlation position _ , or cmcp
. the correlation function @xmath93 employed here is based on a normalized mean squared difference @xmath94 @xcite : @xmath95 where @xmath1 is an image , @xmath96 is a template positioned at @xmath78 , @xmath97 is the mean of the subimage of @xmath1 at @xmath78 of the same size as @xmath96 , @xmath98 is the mean of the template , and @xmath99 .
the template location problem then is to perform this correlation for the whole image and to determine whether the position of the correlation maximum occurs precisely at @xmath78 .
[ fig : matchtempl ] demonstrates the template location problem , on the left for an intensity image , and on the right for its invariant representation .
the black box marks the position of the original template at ( 40,15 ) , and the white box marks the position of the matched template , which is incorrectly located at ( 50,64 ) in the intensity image . on the right , the matched template ( white )
has overwritten the original template ( black ) at the same , correctly identified position .
[ fig : correlexmpl ] visualizes the correlation function over the whole image .
the white areas are regions of high correlation .
the example from figs .
[ fig : matchtempl ] and [ fig : correlexmpl ] deals with only _ one _ arbitrarily selected template . in order to systematically analyze the template location problem , we repeat the correlation process for all possible template locations
. then we can define the _ correlation accuracy _ ca as the percentage of correctly located templates , @xmath100 where @xmath101 is the size of the template , @xmath102 is the set of correct maximum correlation positions , and @xmath89 , again , is the number of valid pixels .
we compute the correlation accuracy both for unfiltered images and for gently prefiltered images , with @xmath103 .
[ fig : corrcorrelpts ] shows the binary correlation accuracy matrices for our example image .
the cmcp set is shown in white , its complement and the boundaries in black .
we observe a higher correlation accuracy for the invariant representation , which is improved by the prefiltering .
we have computed the correlation accuracy for all the images given in fig .
[ fig : imadb ] .
the results are shown in table [ tab : ca ] and visualized in fig .
[ fig : correlaccuras ] .
we observe the following : * the correlation accuracy ca is higher on the invariant representation than on the intensity images .
* the correlation accuracy is higher on the invariant representation with gentle prefiltering , @xmath103 , than without prefiltering .
we also observed a decrease in correlation accuracy if we increase the prefiltering well beyond @xmath103 .
by contrast , prefiltering seems to be always detrimental to the intensity images ca .
* the correlation accuracy shows a wide variation , roughly in the range 30%@xmath10490% for the unfiltered intensity images and 50%@xmath104100% for prefiltered invariant representations .
similarly , the gain in correlation accuracy ranges from close to zero up to 45% . for our test images
, it turns out that the invariant representation is always superior , but that does nt necessarily have to be the case . * the medians and means of the cas over all test images confirm the gain in correlation accuracy for the invariant representation . * the larger the template size , the higher the correlation accuracy , independent of the representation .
a larger template size means more structure , and more discriminatory power .
we have proposed novel invariants that combine invariance under gamma correction with invariance under geometric transformations . in a general sense ,
the invariants can be seen as trading off derivatives for a power law parameter , which makes them interesting for applications beyond image processing .
the error analysis of our implementation on real images has shown that , for sampled data , the invariants can not be computed robustly everywhere .
nevertheless , the template matching application scenario has demonstrated that a performance gain is achievable by using the proposed invariant .
bob woodham suggested to the author to look into invariance under gamma correction .
his meticulous comments on this work were much appreciated .
jochen lang helped with the acquisition of image data through the acme facility @xcite .
d. forsyth , j. mundy , a. zisserman , c. coelho , c. rothwell , `` invariant descriptors for 3-d object recognition and pose '' , _ ieee transactions on pattern analysis and machine intelligence _ , vol.13 ,
no.10 , pp.971 - 991 , oct.1991 .
d. pai , j. lang , j. lloyd , r. woodham , `` acme , a telerobotic active measurement facility '' , sixth international symposium on experimental robotics , sydney , 1999 .
see also : http://www.cs.ubc.ca/nest/lci/acme/
|
_ this paper presents invariants under gamma correction and similarity transformations .
the invariants are local features based on differentials which are implemented using derivatives of the gaussian .
the use of the proposed invariant representation is shown to yield improved correlation results in a template matching scenario . _
|
it is believed that solar magnetic fields are created in the tachocline , the interface between the convection zone and the radiative interior . due to buoyancy instabilities ,
they move upward and emerge into the solar atmosphere in the form of @xmath0-shaped flux tubes @xcite .
the largest emerging active regions produce sunspots with magnetic fluxes in excess of @xmath4 mx and lifetimes of several weeks to months .
smaller active regions consist of pores and contain an order of magnitude less flux , persisting over days to weeks .
the smallest emerging regions detected to date are the so - called ephemeral regions .
they have fluxes between @xmath5 and @xmath6 mx and lifetimes in the range from hours to days ( e. g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . outside of active regions ,
the quiet sun has proved to be full of magnetic fields with strengths roughly in equipartition with the photospheric convective flows @xcite .
an important question is the origin of these fields .
@xcite suggested that horizontal internetwork fields represent concentrated loops of flux carried to the surface by the upflows of granular convection or by magnetic buoyancy . in a recent paper ,
@xcite indirectly traced the emergence of magnetic flux and reconstructed , for the first time , the three dimensional topology of the magnetic field vector in quiet regions of the solar photosphere .
it was found that at least 20% of the magnetic flux in the quiet sun is connected by low - lying magnetic loops .
later , @xcite studied time series of spectropolarimetric observations taken with the solar optical telescope aboard _ hinode_. these authors followed the time evolution of one magnetic loop in the internetwork , showing that they appear on spatial scales smaller than 2@xmath7 .
@xcite and @xcite demonstrated that the emergence of magnetic flux on granular scales brings large amounts of horizontal fields to the photosphere both in plage regions and in the quiet sun .
another form of flux emergence has been reported by @xcite .
it involves the appearance and subsequent disappearance of what seem to be _ vertical _ fields at the center of granular cells .
the observations strongly suggest that a significant fraction of the magnetic flux in the quiet sun might be the result of the emergence of small - scale magnetic loops .
but , where do the loops come from ? are they created by the global solar dynamo , by a local dynamo , or by recycling of flux from decaying active regions ? is the emergence process a local phenomenon confined to the photosphere or does the magnetic flux reach higher atmospheric layers ?
the answers to these questions bear important consequences for our understanding of the magnetic and thermal structure of the solar atmosphere .
for example , @xcite claim that the magnetic energy stored in the quiet photosphere is sufficient to balance the radiative losses of the chromosphere .
quiet sun magnetic fields are excellent candidates to solve the chromospheric and coronal heating problem , but a mechanism capable of transferring their energy to the upper layers has not been identified yet . from a theoretical point of view , it is not clear whether the fields of the quiet solar photosphere can rise to the chromosphere . @xcite
have presented mhd simulations in which the magnetic field emerges into the photosphere in the form of small - scale @xmath0-loops .
they reach the chromosphere and get reconnected with the local expanding vertical magnetic fields , heating the plasma and generating high frequency mhd waves that propagate into the corona . however , the magnetoconvection simulations of @xcite show @xmath0-loops that disintegrate as they rise through the solar atmosphere .
these discrepancies emphasize the need for observational studies aimed at determining whether magnetic fields emerging into the quiet photosphere are able to reach higher atmospheric layers . here
we use multi - wavelength observations taken by _
hinode _ and the dutch open telescope to address this question .
we also characterize the physical properties of small - scale magnetic loops in the quiet sun , providing estimates of their magnetic fluxes , emergence rates , lifetimes , sizes , and velocities .
the data analyzed in this paper consist of time series of polarimetric and imaging observations of quiet sun regions at disk center .
they were acquired in seven different days ( 25 - 29 september , 1 and 6 october 2007 ) using the instruments of the solar optical telescope aboard hinode @xcite and the dutch open telescope ( dot ; * ? ? ?
* ) at observatorio de el roque de los muchachos ( la palma , spain ) .
the observations belong to the _ hinode _ operation plan 14 , entitled `` hinode / canary islands campaign '' .
the _ hinode _ spectro - polarimeter ( sp ; * ? ? ? * ) recorded the full stokes vector of the pair of lines at 630 nm in a narrow field of view ( fov ) of @xmath8 .
this region was scanned with a cadence of 28 s during 2 - 6 hours per day ( table [ tabla_obs ] ) .
the exposure time per slit position was set to 1.6 s to track very rapid events .
however , this mode of operation also led to a noise level of @xmath9 in units of the continuum intensity @xmath10 . with a pixel size of @xmath11 along the slit and @xmath12 perpendicular to it ,
the sp measurements have a spatial resolution of about @xmath13 . the hinode narrowband filter imager ( nfi ; tsuneta et al .
2008 ) acquired stokes i and v filtergrams in the wings of the chromospheric mg i b 517.3 nm line , @xmath14 pm away from its center .
the nfi was operated in shutterless mode to reach an effective exposure time of 9.6 s per wavelength and polarization state , covering a fov of @xmath15 .
the original filtergrams had a pixel size of 0.08@xmath7 , but we rebined them to the sp pixel size in order to further reduce the noise .
the _ hinode _ broadband filter imager ( bfi ; * ? ? ? * ) acquired simultaneous images of the photosphere in the cn bandhead at 388.3 nm ( filter width of 0.52 nm ) and the chromosphere in the caiih line at 396.85 nm ( filter width of 0.22 nm ) .
the exposure times were 0.1 s and 0.3 s , respectively .
the bfi covered a region of @xmath16 with a pixel size of @xmath17 .
both the nfi and the bfi took images with a cadence of 30 s. the area scanned by the sp represents a small part of the total fov of the nfi and the bfi .
therefore , we have cospatial and cotemporal observations of the quiet sun tracing different heights in the atmosphere .
the dot observed photospheric and chromospheric layers by means of a tunable lyot filter that scanned the intensity profile of the h@xmath18 line at five wavelength positions ( @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and 0 ) .
the passband of the filter was 0.25 .
speckle bursts of 100 frames were taken at each wavelength position every 30 s. following the standard reduction procedure at the dot , the individual filtergrams were reconstructed using a speckle masking technique ( see * ? ? ? * for details ) .
the reconstructed images cover a fov of @xmath21 and have a spatial resolution of about 0.2 .
the dot and _ hinode _ carried out simultaneous observations , but there is little overlap between them because of bad weather conditions .
the sp data have been corrected for dark current , flat - field , and instrumental cross - talk using the sp_prep.pro routine included in the solarsoft package .
the algorithm applied to the hinode filtergrams ( fg_prep.pro ) removed dark current , hot pixels , and cosmic rays .
the spectropolarimetric maps and the various filtergrams have been aligned with pixel accuracy using the granulation , g - band bright points , and network elements as a reference . in fig .
[ calcio ] we show time - averaged h filtergrams and b magnetograms for the seven days of observation .
the h images have been trimmed to the size of the b fov .
the rectangles represent the areas scanned by the sp . note the absence of strong brigthenings in the h maps , as expected for very quiet regions largely devoid of network elements .
+ ccccc date & 1st period & 2nd period & observed & detected + & ( ut ) & ( ut ) & time & loops + 25@xmath22 sep & 13:00 - 15:59 & & 3.0 h & 18 + 26@xmath22 sep & 08:15 - 14:14 & & 6.0 h & 16 + 27@xmath22 sep & 06:16 - 09:59 & 11:25 - 13:59 & 6.3 h & 7 + 28@xmath22 sep & 07:00 - 09:59 & 11:20 - 13:59 & 5.7 h & 11 + 29@xmath22 sep & 06:51 - 09:44 & & 2.9 h & 5 + 1@xmath23 oct & 08:21 - 10:09 & & 1.8 h & 3 + 6@xmath22 oct & 08:01 - 10:18 & & 2.3 h & 9 +
loop - like magnetic structures leave clear signatures in spectropolarimetric maps : linear polarization flanked by two circular polarization signals of opposite polarity .
one of the main goals of this paper is to trace the possible ascent of small - scale magnetic loops through the solar atmosphere . to this end , we use photospheric and chromospheric observables .
the sp data make it possible to investigate the topology of the field in the photosphere .
the information is complemented by the cn filtergrams , where bright points associated with magnetic fields are easily visible .
we define the total circular polarization as the integral of the unsigned stokes @xmath24 spectrum .
the integration is carried out in the wavelength range from @xmath25 pm to @xmath26 pm .
the total linear polarization is computed as the integral of the stokes @xmath27 profile of 603.25 nm , using the same initial and final wavelengths .
we visually inspect the polarization maps to search for weak linear signals between two patches of circular polarization with opposite polarity .
since in general the linear polarization signals are very small in the quiet sun , we ascribe those cases to loop - like structures only after corroborating that the linear polarization is produced by symmetric stokes @xmath28 and @xmath29 profiles .
figure [ primer_ejemplo ] shows the first stages of the emergence of a small - scale magnetic loop as seen in the 630.25 nm line .
the different panels represent continuum intensity ( top ) , total linear polarization ( middle ) , and total circular polarization ( bottom ) .
red contours indicate enhanced linear polarization .
black and white contours mark the location of strong negative and positive circular signals . at @xmath30
s , a patch of linear polarization shows up at the center of the image .
it corresponds to the horizontal part of a magnetic structure emerging into the photosphere . between @xmath31 and 60 s , two circular polarization patches of opposite polarity
appear next to it , at the edge of a granular cell .
the fact that the linear signal is detected earlier than the circular polarization indicates that the magnetic structure has the shape of an @xmath0-loop : the apex creates linear polarization and the vertical fields of the footpoints give rise to circular polarization @xcite .
the linear polarization disappears below the noise at @xmath32 s while the footpoints separate with time .
this sequence of events is consistent with a loop that emerges and travels up in the atmosphere .
the distance between the footpoints keeps increasing until they reach the edges of the area scanned by the sp . the subsequent evolution of this loop
will be studied in [ description ] .
the stokes @xmath33 and @xmath24 filtergrams acquired in the red and blue wings of the b line give information about the upper photosphere / temperature minimum region @xcite . we have used them to construct longitudinal magnetograms ( @xmath34 ) and dopplergrams ( @xmath35 ) as @xmath36 where the subscripts r and b represent the measurements at @xmath37 and @xmath38 pm from line center , respectively .
to first order , the magnetograms computed in this way are not affected by mass motions .
the quantities @xmath34 and @xmath35 have been transformed into magnetic flux densities and line - of - sight velocities according to @xmath39 with @xmath40 in mx cm@xmath1 and @xmath42 in km s@xmath3 .
equation [ dopplergram ] is valid in the range @xmath43 km s@xmath3 .
these expresions have been obtained through calibration of the b line shape in the fourier transform spectrometer atlas of the quiet sun @xcite and give only rough estimates of the magnetic flux density and velocity at the height of formation of the b measurements . since stokes q and u were not recorded , the mg i magnetograms can only be used to detect relatively vertical fields such as those expected at the footpoints of magnetic loops . by definition
, fields pointing towards the observer and upflows will both be positive .
note that our sign convention for the velocity differs from that commonly used in astrophysics . in the chromosphere
we do not have polarimetric information .
however , magnetic fields can be detected through brightness enhancements in the h filtergrams .
the passband of the _ hinode _ h filter includes a significant photospheric contribution , but it has a long tail that extends well into the chromosphere @xcite .
finally , information on the upper chromosphere is provided by the h@xmath18 measurements taken at the dot .
we have used them to construct dopplergrams at different heights in the chromosphere .
we determine the magnetic flux density from the stokes @xmath24 profiles of the 630 nm lines using the weak field approximation ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the longitudinal flux density , @xmath46 the filling factor , @xmath47 the field strength , @xmath48 the inclination of the field with respect to the vertical , @xmath49 a proportionality constant that depends on the central wavelength @xmath50 and the effective land factor @xmath51 of the transition , and @xmath33 represents the intensity profile .
the units of @xmath40 are mx cm@xmath1 when @xmath50 is expressed in
. the longitudinal flux density is obtained from a least - squares minimization of the form @xmath52}{\partial \phi}=0 , \frac{\partial}{\partial \phi}\left[\sum_i \left ( v_i+\phi c\frac{\partial i}{\partial \lambda}_i\right)^2\right]=0 , \label{weakfield}\ ] ] which uses all the wavelength samples across the profile ( index @xmath53 ) and is therefore more accurate that determinations based on single magnetogram measurements .
this calculation is repeated for each pixel and each spectral line separately .
the final result is @xmath54 to estimate the uncertainty caused by photon noise we simulated a data set containing only gaussian noise with a standard deviation of @xmath55 @xmath10 .
the analysis of this data set using eq .
[ eq2 ] leads to a gaussian - shaped histogram for the magnetic flux density which is centered at 0 and has a standard deviation of @xmath56 mx cm@xmath1 . in figure [ hist_ratio_flux ]
we check the assumption made on the zeeman regime .
the plot shows an histogram of the ratio between the magnetic flux densities derived from 630.15 and 630.25 nm .
only the stokes v spectra at the footpoints of the loops having amplitudes above 5 times the noise level have been considered . as can be seen , the histogram is narrow and peaks at 1 .
the figure also shows a scatter plot of the magnetic flux densities obtained with the two lines .
the fact that most of the points are located near the diagonal implies that in the majority of cases both spectral lines measure the same magnetic flux .
this strongly supports the idea that the fields are weak .
during 28 hours of observations we have detected the appearance of 69 loop - like structures in the @xmath57 region scanned with the hinode spectropolarimeter .
table [ tabla ] summarizes their properties .
the observed loops followed very similar evolution patterns . in this section
we describe specific cases to illustrate the emergence process , distinguishing between loops that rise to the chromosphere and loops that remain low - lying .
one of the clearest examples of a loop that reached the chromosphere was loop ml09 , observed on september 25 , 2007 at 14:39 ut .
its evolution is summarized in figs .
[ ej1_crom ] and [ ej1_crom2 ] .
each row represents a time step , for a total of 1020 s. from left to right we show cn filtergrams , photospheric los velocities derived from the stokes @xmath24 zero - crossing shifts of 630.25 nm , total circular polarization maps in 632.05 nm , magnetic flux densities computed from b 517.3 nm , los velocities at the height of formation of the b line , and h line - core filtergrams .
positive velocities indicate upflows .
note that the time steps are not evenly spaced ; rather , we have adjusted them to better describe the various phases of the process .
the red contours mark regions of large linear polarization signals in 630.25 nm .
when the footpoints of the loop are visible in the photosphere , we plot contours of 630.25 nm circular polarization in black and white for the negative and positive signals , respectively .
when the footpoints are only visible in the b magnetogram we plot them in blue and turquoise . the first row of fig .
[ ej1_crom ] shows the emergence of linear polarization above a granule ( cf .
the white arrow in the cn filtergram ) .
it is caused by the horizontal part of the loop reaching the photosphere .
the footpoints are not yet visible but will appear 30 s later , very close to the patch of linear polarization . at @xmath58
the loop is completely formed .
it emerges in a granular region , perhaps because the upward granular motions help the field lines to rise from below the solar surface @xcite .
the los velocity maps show photospheric upflows at the position of the footpoints , confirming that the loop is rising . for the moment
, however , the magnetic field remains in the lower photosphere : we do not observe circular polarization signals in the b magnetograms or brightenings in caiih that could be associated with the loop .
interestingly , the strong photospheric network element with negative polarity located towards the bottom of the scan , at a height of about one fourth of the displayed fov , is well observed both in the b magnetograms and the ca filtergrams , and will remain so during most of the time sequence .
this nicely illustrates the capabilities of our observations : magnetic structures that are visible in the polarization maps but not in b or h are intrinsically lower in the solar atmosphere
. between @xmath59 s and @xmath60 s the linear polarization signals disappear below the noise .
the positive footpoint has drifted to an intergranular lane and is concentrated , whereas the negative footpoint continues to be rooted in the granule and is more diffuse .
the distance between them increases steadily .
we still see upward motions in the photospheric velocity maps .
since the loop is moving to higher layers , it is reasonable to conclude that the linear polarization disappears because the apex of the loop leaves the formation region of the 630 nm lines .
however , no traces of the loop are detected yet in b or h. at @xmath61 s , weak circular polarization signals cospatial with the photospheric footpoints are observed in the b magnetograms for the first time .
this indicates that the loop has reached the upper photospheric / lower chromospheric layers where the central part of the b line forms .
interestingly , the b dopplergram exhibits downflows of about @xmath62 km s@xmath3 at the position of the positive footpoint .
the downflows could represent plasma moving along the legs of the loop as the whole structure reaches high atmospheric layers .
these motions may be essential for the loop to get rid of part of its mass before it can emerge into a less dense medium . at @xmath63
s , the loop is nearly out of the region scanned by the sp .
the signals in the b magnetogram are much more intense and correspond to footpoints rooted in intergranular lanes . from now on the distance between the footpoints will increase , but at a slower rate than when they were crossing granular structures .
this inflection point can be seen in fig .
[ dist ] , where we plot the footpoint separation as a function of time .
the distance is computed only when the two footpoints are visible , both in the maps ( squares ) and in the b magnetograms ( triangles ) . in the first 500 s of the loop evolution , the distance between the footpoints increases linearly at a rate of 5.9 km s@xmath3 .
therefore , the mean velocity of the footpoints is 2.95 km s@xmath3 , a value compatible with the motion of the granular plasma .
the linear increase of the separation with time is a common feature of the loops and indicates that they do not undergo a free random walk ( otherwise the distance would increase as the square root of time ) . towards the end of the loop evolution
the separation rate slows down , coinciding with the arrival of the footpoints to intergranular lanes .
summarizing , the loop emerges in a granule and the horizontal granular motions drive the magnetic field lines to the closest intergranular space , where strong downdrafts capture and stabilize them . when this happens , the separation between the footpoints is about 4000 km . at @xmath64
s , the footpoints are clearly visible in the b magnetogram and exhibit downflows in the b dopplergram .
the whole structure is rising because the footpoints continue to separate .
however , no brightenings are detected in the h filtergrams .
we mention in passing that a new loop appear in the fov at this time , very close to the site of emergence of the structure we are describing in detail .
they show a linear polarization signal in between opposite polarities , which makes it easy to identify . at @xmath65
s , the loop has reached the chromosphere since we observe two h brightenings associated with the footpoints ( in fig .
[ ej1_crom2 ] , the contours have been substituted by arrows for clarity ) .
the legs of the loop still show downflows in the b dopplergrams and , for the first time , bright points are observed in the cn images at the position of the footpoints .
the last panels of fig .
[ ej1_crom2 ] displays the beginning of the loop decay .
the positive footpoint is very weak , although it still shows downflows at the height of formation of the b measurements .
it will disappear below the noise level , together with the downdrafts , at the end of the sequence .
the negative footpoint is approaching a negative polarity patch with whom it will eventually mix .
the negative footpoint shows downflows and is associated with a bright point in h. these features will survive the disappearance of the footpoint thanks to the interaction with the network element . in this section we present a typical example of a loop which do not show chromospheric signatures and thus remain low - lying .
figure [ ej1_nocrom ] shows all the data available for this loop ( ml23 ) , arranged as in fig .
[ ej1_crom ] . in the first frame ,
a patch of linear polarization is observed to emerge at the border of a granule ( see the white arrow ) .
the footpoints can already be detected in the intergranular lane , but they are very weak . at this time the photospheric velocity map exhibits a patch of upflows at the position of the loop , confirming its rise through the solar atmosphere . at @xmath66
s the loop reaches its largest extent ( 520 km ) while the upflows start to weaken .
the linear polarization and the upward plasma motions are almost gone by @xmath67 s. in the next frame , at @xmath68 s , the loop is no longer seen .
the evolution of the loop is so rapid that it appears and disappears almost at the same place .
interestingly , the footpoints never approach each other .
this rules out submergence below the solar surface as the cause of the loop disappearance .
all the loops that stay in the photosphere show very similar behaviors . in general ,
the evolve very quickly , disappearing not far from the region where they emerged .
none of these loops exhibit downflows in the b line or brightenings in the cn or ca filtergrams .
in the previous section we have seen that small - scale magnetic loops in the quiet sun may rise through the atmosphere and reach the layers where the central part of the b 517.3 nm line is formed .
some of them also produce h brightness enhancements . in this context
, the question naturally arises as to the maximum height that these structures can attain .
are they able to reach the upper chromosphere or even the corona ? here we use the h@xmath18 observations of the dot to provide a partial answer to this question .
unfortunately , there is little overlap between the _ hinode _ and dot measurements because of bad seeing conditions . nevertheless , for one of the loops detected by _
there is simultaneous coverage from the dot .
we use these data to attempt to observe the rise of the loop to the upper chromosphere .
the analysis is not complete and must be refined with euv and x - ray observations tailored to the detection of such magnetic structures in the hot corona .
the loop observed simultaneously by _
hinode _ and the dot ( ml20 ) appeared on september 26 , 2007 , at 09:06 ut . in fig .
[ ej2_crom_todos ] we show its evolution in the photosphere / temperature minimum region using the 630.25 nm circular polarization maps and the b magnetograms ( first and second columns , respectively ) .
the figure also displays h@xmath18 line core filtergrams , as well as h@xmath18 dopplergrams at @xmath20 and @xmath19 from line center
. if the loop reaches the layers where h@xmath18 is formed , it should first appear in the fifth column , then in the fourth , and finally in the third .
the loop emerged as a small patch of linear polarization at the border of a granule ( @xmath69 s , not shown ) .
its subsequent evolution is similar to that of the loop considered in fig .
[ ej1_crom ] .
the footpoints of the loop are detected in the photosphere for the first time at @xmath70 s. the whole structure shows upflows in the stokes v zero - crossing maps , indicating its ascent .
unfortunately , the negative footpoint is close to the border of the fov scanned by the sp and soon disappears from the photospheric maps .
the loop becomes visible in the b magnetograms at @xmath71 s. at this time there is clear signal in the negative footpoint and weaker polarization in the positive leg . at @xmath65 s
both footpoints show stronger magnetogram signals but the distance between them has not increased .
the ascent of the loop to the chromosphere is associated with downflows in the b dopplergram and brightenings in the caiih line - core images . the and b signals start to fade at @xmath72 s until the loop disappears simultaneously from the low and the upper photospheric layers .
the h@xmath18 line core images and the dopplergrams do not show any particular feature that could be associated with the appearence of an arch filament system in the chromosphere .
it is important to remark that the maximum separation between the footpoints of this loop was only 760 km .
it may well be that a larger separation is required for the apex of the loop to reach the upper chromosphere .
in fact , excessive magnetic tension might prevent the field lines from rising . keeping in mind these considerations
, we do not discard that magnetic loops with larger separations may be seen in future h@xmath18 observations .
in this section we characterize the physical properties of the small - scale magnetic loops observed with _
weak examples and loops appearing close to strong network elements or in crowded areas are omitted from the analysis to maintain the quality of the results .
this leaves us with 33 loops , which represents 48% of the total sample .
table [ tabla ] lists the basic parameters of the loops , including lifetimes ( @xmath73 ) , maximum distances between footpoints ( @xmath74 ) , speeds at which the footpoints separate initially ( @xmath75 ) , total magnetic fluxes ( @xmath76 ) and maximum flux densities ( @xmath77 ) in the photosphere , estimations of maximum magnetic flux densities at the height of formation of the b measurements ( @xmath78 ) , and an estimation of the largest downflows detected in the b dopplergrams ( @xmath79 ) .
the lifetime is the time elapsed between the appearance and disappearance of the polarization signals .
when two numbers are given , the first indicates the time passed until one of the footpoints interacts with a neighboring magnetic element .
the second is the time of disappearance proper ; if it is accompanied by an asterisk , then the polarization signatures of the loop were still visible at the end of the observations . to compute the total magnetic flux
we define the footpoints as those regions where the flux density is larger than @xmath80 at the position of the loop .
the value of @xmath81 reported in table [ tabla ] is the maximum flux detected in one of the footpoints during the loop evolution , and the error indicates the uncertainty in @xmath81 caused by photon noise .
the last four columns of table [ tabla ] give the time intervals between the appearance of the loops in the photosphere and their detection in the b magnetograms , the b dopplergrams , the h line core images , and the cn filtergrams .
we consider that a loop is present in any of these maps when at least one of the footpoints shows up clearly .
the two numbers in each column correspond to the positive footpoint ( left ) and the negative one ( right ) .
cccccccccccccc name & date & t@xmath82 & @xmath83 t & d@xmath84 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath83t@xmath90 & @xmath83t@xmath91 & @xmath83t@xmath92 & @xmath83t@xmath93 + & ( 09/07 ) & ( ut ) & ( s ) & ( km ) & ( km / s ) & ( mx ) & ( mx/@xmath94 ) & ( mx/@xmath94 ) & ( km / s ) & ( s ) & ( s ) & ( s ) & ( s ) + ml01 & 25 & 13:36:15 & 240 & 800 & 3.9 & 4.6@xmath9510@xmath9610@xmath97 & @xmath98 & & & & & & + ml02 & 25 & 13:35:45 & 150/1020 & 1220 & 4.0 & 1.5@xmath9510@xmath9910@xmath97 & @xmath100 & & & & & & + ml03 & 25 & 13:37:45 & 330 & 560 & 0.9 & 7.6@xmath9510@xmath9610@xmath97 & @xmath101 & & & & & & + ml04 & 25 & 13:46:15 & 60/480 & 690 & 1.7 & 8.2@xmath9510@xmath9610@xmath97 & @xmath102 & & & & & & + ml05 & 25 & 13:45:15 & 240 & 790 & 1.1 & 1.1@xmath9510@xmath10310@xmath97 & @xmath104 & & & & & & + ml06 & 25 & 13:36:15 & 180 & 910 & 6.0 & 3.6@xmath9510@xmath10510@xmath106 & @xmath107 & & & & & & + ml07 & 25 & 13:54:15 & 90 & 490 & 1.4 & 3.5@xmath9510@xmath10810@xmath106 & @xmath109 & & & & & & + ml08 & 25 & 13:41:45 & 630 & 800 & 6.2 & 3.9@xmath9510@xmath9610@xmath97 & @xmath110 & & & & & & + ml09 & 25 & 14:39:30 & 960/1200 & 4000 & 3.9 & 1.3@xmath9510@xmath10310@xmath97 & @xmath111 & 15.0@xmath112 & -1.1 & 270/540 & 270/750 & 780/780 & 780/1230 + ml10 & 25 & 14:42:00 & 120 & 560 & 1.7 & 1.5@xmath9510@xmath11310@xmath106 & @xmath114 & & & & & & + ml11 & 25 & 14:51:00 & 300/2550 * & 1670 & 2.5 & 1.2@xmath9510@xmath10310@xmath97 & @xmath115 & 10.4@xmath116 & -0.58 & 180/450 & 180/450 & 420/660 &
/660 + ml12 & 25 & 14:51:00 & 300/2550 * & 2040 & 0.7 & 1.3@xmath9510@xmath10310@xmath97 & @xmath117 & 8.3@xmath1180.8 & & 690/750 & & & + ml13 & 25 & 15:04:00 & 660/1230 & 1440 & 2.1 & 7.8@xmath9510@xmath9610@xmath97 & @xmath119 & 28.6@xmath1180.9 & -0.70 & 390/390 & 690/ & 750/ & 690/ + ml14 & 25 & 15:06:00 & 180 & 480 & 3.7 & 6.1@xmath9510@xmath9610@xmath97 & @xmath120 & & & & & & + ml15 & 25 & 15:14:00 & 360/1590 * & 3170 & 0.5 & 2.0@xmath9510@xmath9910@xmath97 & @xmath121 & 5.4@xmath1180.5 & -0.91 & 330/330 & 570/420 & 750/420 & 690/570 + ml16 & 25 & 15:24:30 & 510 & 790 & 0.9 & 1.3@xmath9510@xmath9910@xmath97 & @xmath122 & 7.3@xmath1180.5 & -0.59 & 240/240 & 270/270 & & + ml17 & 25 & 14:50:30 & 90 & 620 & 1.0 & 5.5@xmath9510@xmath9610@xmath97 & @xmath123 & & & & & & + ml18 & 26 & 08:32:00 & 510/1110 * & 990 & 1.1 & 1.1@xmath9510@xmath10310@xmath97 & @xmath124 & & & & & & + ml19 & 26 & 08:23:30 & 660 & 1670 & 3.1 & 6.2@xmath9510@xmath9610@xmath97 & @xmath125 & 10.0@xmath1180.9 & -0.33 & /180 & /180 & /210 & /180 + ml20 & 26 & 09:06:00 & 1050 & 1450 & 2.2 & 1.5@xmath9510@xmath11310@xmath106 & @xmath126 & 5.0@xmath1180.4 & -0.38 & 390/360 & 510/390 & 570/420 & 600/390 + ml21 & 26 & 09:47:30 & 240 & 700 & 2.8 & 3.8@xmath9510@xmath10510@xmath106 & @xmath127 & & & & & & + ml22 & 26 & 11:24:00 & 1380 * & 1570 & 0.9 & 2.4@xmath9510@xmath9910@xmath97 & @xmath128 & 11.8@xmath1181.1 & -0.48 & 360/450 & 600/750 & 630/750 & + ml23 & 26 & 11:48:00 & 150 & 520 & 3.6 & 3.3@xmath9510@xmath10510@xmath106 & @xmath129 & & & & & & + ml24 & 26 & 12:16:00 & 120/390 & 830 & 3.4 & 1.9@xmath9510@xmath13010@xmath97 & @xmath131 & & & & & & + ml25 & 26 & 12:28:00 & 1230 & 2840 & 0.1 & 2.0@xmath9510@xmath13210@xmath106 & @xmath133 & 7.50@xmath1180.8 & -0.56 & 210/420 & 540/630 & 690/690 & + ml26 & 27 & 09:25:00 & 1110 & 760 & 0.9 & 7.0@xmath9510@xmath9610@xmath97 & @xmath134 & 26.7@xmath1180.8 & -0.42 & 270/270 & 540/ & & + ml27 & 27 & 11:08:00 & 420 & 960 & 4.5 & 8.6@xmath9510@xmath9610@xmath97 & @xmath135 & & & & & & + ml28 & 27 & 12:20:30 & 90 & 670 & 0.9 & 3.0@xmath9510@xmath10510@xmath106 & @xmath136 & & & & & & + ml29 & 27 & 12:26:30 & 1110 & 2290 & 4.0 & 1.7@xmath9510@xmath9910@xmath97 & @xmath137 & 14.5@xmath1180.8 & -0.49 & 150/150 & 450/390 & /450 & + ml30 & 28 & 11:28:30 & 300/750 & 1300 & 0.9 & 7.8@xmath9510@xmath9610@xmath97 & @xmath138 & & & & & & + ml31 & 28 & 11:38:00 & 180 & 1560 & 1.5 & 7.8@xmath9510@xmath9610@xmath97 & @xmath139 & & & & & & + ml32 & 28 & 12:32:30 & 720/720 & 710 & 1.5 & 1.9@xmath9510@xmath10310@xmath97 & @xmath140 & 19.0@xmath1180.5 & & 240/240 & & 360/ & 330/ + ml33 & 29 & 08:39:00 & 240/630 & 860 & 2.4 & 2.1@xmath9510@xmath10310@xmath97 & @xmath128 & & & & & & + * mean * & & & * 741 * & * 1234 * & * 2.2 * & * 9.13@xmath9510@xmath141 * & * 26.1 * & * 13.0 * & * -0.60 * & * 295 * & * 406 * & * 513 * & * 514 * + + as can be seen in table [ tabla ] , there is a wide range of loop parameters .
the lifetimes vary from some 2 min up to 40 min , although most of the loops disappear in less than 10 minutes .
the maximum separation between the footpoints is a strong function of the lifetime and ranges from @xmath142 km to 4000 km .
many loops reach horizontal dimensions comparable to , or larger than , those of granules .
therefore , they must be viewed as coherent structures capable of withstanding the conditions of the granular environment for a relatively long time .
the initial velocity of separation between the footpoints does not seem to have any relationship with the other parameters listed in the table .
values of 0.1 to 6 km s@xmath3 are typical .
as already mentioned , the separation speed tends to decrease when the footpoints reach the intergranular space , likely because horizontal motions there are not as vigorous as in the interior of granular cells .
the longitudinal magnetic fluxes measured in the footpoints range from @xmath143 to @xmath144 mx at the level of formation of the 630 nm lines mx , considerably larger than the rest of values .
this might be an artifact caused by the difficult separation of ml24 and the strong network element with which it interacts . ] .
therefore , the loops have smaller fluxes than ephemeral regions and should be placed at the lower end of the flux distribution observed in emerging active regions .
the magnetic flux density in the footpoints is typically 2040 mx cm@xmath3 . to infer the magnetic field strength from the magnetic flux density values we need to know the filling factor of the field lines that build the loop structure and their inclination .
the footpoints should be relatively vertical because of geometrical reasons .
assuming that the fields occupy most of the resolution element , i.e. , that the magnetic filling factor is close to unity the field strength of the loops can be estimated to be of order 10 - 100 g. only if the filling factor is much smaller than unity would the field strength increase to kg values , but we consider this possibility unlikely in view of fig .
[ hist_ratio_flux ] .
an important result is that 23% of the loops are detected in the b magnetograms after their appearance in the photosphere ( 16 cases out of 69 ) .
it takes an average of 5 minutes for the loops to move from the photosphere to the height at which the b measurements form , although faster and slower ascents have been observed too .
all the loops detected in the b magnetograms develop downflows at the same heights .
in addition , 15% of the loops are seen as bright points in h line - core filtergrams .
this means that an important fraction of the magnetic flux that emerges into the photosphere reaches the chromosphere . as they travel upward ,
the loops are observed in the magnetograms , the b magnetograms , the b dopplergrams , the h line - core images , and the cn filtergrams ( in this order ) . by contrast , 77% of the loops never make it to the chromosphere .
we have been unable to identify any parameter determining whether a given loop will rise or not .
this includes the total magnetic flux and the magnetic flux density
. however , low - lying loops tend to have lifetimes shorter than 500 s and separations smaller than 500 km . thus it may simply be that they do not last long enough to reach high atmospheric layers .
further work is clearly needed to explain why a substantial fraction of the loops remain low - lying .
also , the relation between these structures and the transient horizontal fields described by @xcite should be investigated , given their similar lifetimes and magnetic topologies .
the observations described above demonstrate that magnetic fields do emerge into the quiet solar atmosphere in the form of small - scale loops , confirming the results of @xcite and @xcite .
the loops are detected as a patch of linear polarization flanked by two circular polarization signals of opposite polarity . in nearly all the cases
the linear polarization appears before or at the same time than the stokes @xmath24 signals , as can be expected from @xmath0-shaped loops rising through the atmosphere . only in two cases out of 69
have we detected linear polarization after the loop had already disappeared . in those cases
, the footpoints were approaching each other .
this behavior is compatible with a loop that emerges and then submerges in the photosphere , or with a `` magnetic bubble '' , i.e. , a circle of magnetic field lines .
the long duration of our time series has permitted us to discover the existence of emergence centers in which several loops appear one after the other .
for example , there is a @xmath146 region of the solar surface where we have detected 9 events in a time interval of 1 h. the complete set of observations covering this period is provided as an mpeg animation in the electronic edition of the astrophysical journal .
some of the loops even appear at the very same position .
the example shown in fig .
[ ej1_crom ] belongs to this area .
the existence of emergence centers may have important consequences for the origin of the loops .
these regions act as subsurface reservoirs of magnetic flux that is transferred intermittently to the photosphere by an as yet unkwnown mechanism .
the loops generally emerge in granules or at their edges , although there are exceptions of loops appearing in dark areas .
as the loops emerge the footpoints separate and the linear polarization fades away . in most cases ,
the footpoints do not describe rectilinear trajectories .
figure [ trayectorias ] shows the paths followed by the two polarities of the loops observed on september 25 , 2007 ( loops ml09 to ml17 in the table 2 ) .
the red curves correspond to the example discussed in fig.[ej1_crom ] . in this case
the footpoints described quite a rectilinear path , similarly to emerging active regions and ephemeral regions .
however , the majority of loops show more complicated trajectories .
the reason is that , in general , they emerge in granules and drift toward the closest intergranular lane . when the footpoints reach the intergranular space they stay there and are passively advected by the flow .
this creates complicated trajectories .
the important point , however , is that the magnetic field is sufficiently weak as to be pushed and moved around by the granular flow , but _ without being destroyed in the process_. the loops remain coherent during all their lifetime , as if the granular flow did not exist . during their evolution ,
the loops interact with other magnetic flux concentrations that cross their paths .
if the loops stay long in the photosphere , the footpoints cancel with elements of opposite polarity or are absorbed by patches of the same polarity .
loops that experience a fast evolution have more probabilities of avoiding other magnetic elements and often disappear without undergoing any interaction . in seeking the origin of the loops it is of interest to determine the magnetic orientation of their footpoints .
if the loops are caused by the global solar dynamo , one may expect a regular ordering of the footpoints at the moment of emergence .
this is what happens in active regions , where the signs of the leader and follower polarities are governed by hale s rules ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
all the loops considered here appeared in the northern hemisphere during solar cycle 23 . in that cycle ,
leader polarities were positive in the northern hemisphere and negative in the southern hemisphere .
figure [ tilt ] shows an histogram of the orientation of our small - scale emerging loops .
the tilt angle is defined to be the angle between the solar equator and the line joining the positive footpoint with the negative one , measured from the west .
the angles compatible with the orientation of sunspot polarities during solar cycle 23 in the northern hemisphere are those between 90 and 270@xmath147 . even if the statistical sample is not very large , the loops seem to have nearly random orientations .
thus , we conclude that they do not obey hale s polarity rules , much in the same way as the shortest - lived ephemeral regions @xcite .
recent observations of hanle - sensitive lines @xcite and zeeman - sensitive lines @xcite suggest that a significant fraction of the quiet sun is occupied by magnetic fields
. apparently , these fields are weak and isotropically distributed in inclination @xcite .
one way to shed light on their nature is to study how they emerge in the surface and what their contribution is to the energy budget of the solar atmosphere . on granular scales
, magnetic flux appears in the solar photosphere as transient horizontal fields @xcite and small - scale magnetic loops @xcite .
we have studied the latter in detail using seeing - free observations made by _
hinode_. in 28 hours of _ hinode _ data we have detected 69 small - scale loops emerging in a quiet sun region of size @xmath148 at disk center .
the occurrence rate is thus 0.02 events hr@xmath3 arcsec@xmath1 .
the loops show clear spectropolarimetric signatures with a central region of linear polarization and two patches of circular polarization of opposite polarity .
the longitudinal flux observed in each footpoint ranges from @xmath143 to @xmath144 mx , with an average of @xmath149 mx .
this means that the loops represent the smallest emerging flux regions detected to date ( ephemeral regions have fluxes above 10@xmath150 mx ; zwaan 1987 ) .
the rate at which magnetic flux is carried to the quiet photosphere by the loops can be estimated to be @xmath151 mx s@xmath3 arcsec@xmath1 , or @xmath152 mx over the solar surface per day .
this is about half the value derived by lites et al .
( 1996 ) for horizontal internetwork fields , but still enormous ( see @xcite for a comparison with the flux emergence rates in active and ephemeral regions ) . in the photosphere ,
the linear polarization associated with the top of the loop disappears soon , while the circular signals tracing the loop legs are observed to separate with time .
this behavior is consistent with field lines moving upward through the solar atmosphere .
also the upflows observed in the stokes v zero - crossing velocities at the position of the footpoints confirm the ascent of the loops .
23% of the loops are detected in b magnetograms that sample the upper photosphere or the temperature minimum region ( say , 400 km above the continuum forming layer ) .
there is a time delay of about 5 minutes between the first detection in the photosphere and the appearance in the b magnetograms , implying an ascent speed of the order of 1 km @xmath3 .
some of the loops continue to travel upward and become visible in h line - core filtergrams as small brightness enhancements .
thus , a fraction of the loops are able to reach the low chromosphere , carrying magnetic flux with them .
the rise of small - scale magnetic loops may provide an efficient mechanism to transfer substantial amounts of energy from the photosphere to the chromosphere .
this would support claims by @xcite and @xcite that the tangled fields of the quiet sun store sufficient energy to heat the chromosphere .
a related question is whether the small - scale loops rise up to the transition region or even the corona .
the observations required to answer this question are quite challenging due to the different spatial resolutions attainable with present day optical , euv , and x - ray instruments , but should be pursued .
about 77% of the loops that appear in the solar surface never rise to the chromosphere .
these loops have the shortest lifetimes and show the smallest footpoint separations ; other than that , they do not differ from those reaching higher layers .
usually , they disappear close to their emergence sites .
the fields associated with these loops might represent the tangled quiet sun fields deduced from hanle measurements @xcite , but a definite conclusion can not be made without studying the compatibility of hanle and zeeman measurements . what is the origin of the small - scale magnetic loops ?
one possibility is that they are created by the solar dynamo at the bottom of the convection zone , as part of a larger toroidal flux tube .
@xcite presented three - dimensional mhd simulations of the last stages of the emergence of one such tube .
they placed a horizontal tube at the top of the convection zone , just beneath the photosphere . when the initial magnetic flux is smaller than @xmath15310@xmath150 mx , the tube is not sufficiently buoyant to rise coherently against the convective flows and fragments . at the surface
, the process of flux emergence occurs on very small spatial scales ( typically 1000 - 2000 km ) and short time scales ( 5 min ) .
these properties are compatible with our observations .
thus , the small - scale loops we have detected may simply be the result of weak flux tubes distorted by the granulation as they emerge from the convection zone into the photosphere .
the fragmentation of the tubes might explain why there are emergence centers where loops appear recurrently one after the other .
a preliminary analysis of the footpoint orientations suggests that the loops do not show a tendency to be aligned according to hale s rules .
this can be regarded as a considerable difficulty against the idea that the origin of the loops is the solar dynamo .
however , it may also be a natural consequence of the interaction of the tube s fragments with the near - surface granular convection if it removes all the information carried originally by the tube .
another possibility is that the magnetic loops represent flux recycled from decaying active regions . in a sense , the mhd simulations of abbett ( 2007 ) , @xcite , and @xcite model such a process , because all of them assume an initial magnetic field in the computational box which could be provided by decaying active regions . in the simulations ,
the field evolve and interact with the granular flows .
this interaction creates a significant amount of horizontal fields , even if the initial field is purely vertical .
moreover , the simulations show the emergence of magnetic loops on granular scales .
the loops are less coherent than classical flux tubes and do not connect to deeply rooted field lines . in this scenario , the magnetic fields of the quiet sun , and thus the emergence events we have described , would be the consequence of local processes acting on the remnants of decaying active regions .
yet another possibility is that the loops represent submerged horizontal magnetic fields carried to the surface by the upward motions of granules or by magnetic buoyancy , as modeled by @xcite . even in that case
, the origin of such submerged fields would be unknown .
nowadays , we do not have enough observational constraints to distinguish between a surface dynamo or a `` exploding '' magnetic flux tube emerging from the solar interior .
determining the nature of the magnetic loops observed in internetwork regions is important for a better understanding of the magnetism of the quiet sun and its role in the heating of the solar atmosphere .
future efforts should concentrate on the solution of these problems .
in addition to high - resolution photospheric observations , polarization measurements in the chromosphere are recquired to track the evolution of the loops with height .
these data can now be provided by two - dimensional spectrometers like ibis , crisp , or imax .
we thank andrs asensio ramos , pascal dmoulin and rafael manso sainz for very helpful discussions , and vronique bommier for carefully reading the manuscript .
we are grateful to all the observers who participated in the _ hinode _ operation plan 14 , both at isas / jaxa and at the ground - based telescopes .
special thanks are due to suguru kamio ( naoj ) for coordinating the campaign and to peter stterlin ( utrecht university ) for making the observations at the dutch open telescope and reducing them .
hinode is a japanese mission developed and launched by isas / jaxa , with naoj as a domestic partner , and nasa and stfc ( uk ) as international partners .
it is operated by these agencies in cooperation with esa and nsc ( norway ) .
part of this work was carried out while one of us ( mjmg ) was a visiting scientist at the instituto de astrofsica de andaluca .
we acknowledge financial support from the spanish micinn through projects esp2006 - 13030-c06 - 02 , pci2006-a7 - 0624 , and aya2007 - 63881 , and from junta de andaluca through project p07-tep-2687 . , d. , bellot rubio , l. r. , del toro iniesta , j. c. , tsuneta , s. , lites , b. w. , ichimoto , k. , katsukawa , y. , nagata , s. , shimizu , t. , shine , r. a. , suematsu , y. , tarbell , t. d. , & title , a. m. 2007 , apj , 670 , 61
|
we investigate the emergence of magnetic flux in the quiet sun at very small spatial scales , focusing on the magnetic connection between the photosphere and chromosphere .
the observational data consist of spectropolarimetric measurements and filtergrams taken with the hinode satellite and the dutch open telescope .
we find that a significant fraction of the magnetic flux present in internetwork regions appears in the form of @xmath0-shaped loops .
the emergence rate is 0.02 loops per hour and arcsec@xmath1 , which brings @xmath2 mx s@xmath3 arcsec@xmath1 of new flux to the solar surface .
initially , the loops are observed as small patches of linear polarization above a granular cell .
shortly afterwards , two footpoints of opposite polarity become visible in circular polarization within or at the edges of the granule and start to move toward the adjacent intergranular space .
the orientation of the footpoints does not seem to obey hale s polarity rules .
the loops are continuously buffeted by convective motions , but they always retain a high degree of coherence .
interestingly , 23% of the loops that emerge in the photosphere reach the chromosphere ( 16 cases out of 69 ) .
they are first detected in 630 nm magnetograms and 5 minutes later in b 517.3 nm magnetograms .
after about 8 minutes , some of them are also observed in h line - core images , where the footpoints produce small brightness enhancements .
|
the current observations , such as sneia ( supernovae type ia ) , cmb ( cosmic microwave background ) and large scale structure , converge on the fact that a spatially homogeneous and gravitationally repulsive energy component , referred as dark energy , accounts for about @xmath1 % of the energy density of universe .
some heuristic models that roughly describe the observable consequences of dark energy were proposed in recent years , a number of them stemming from a certain physics @xcite and the others being purely phenomenological @xcite .
dark energy can even behave as a phantom and effectively violate the weak energy condition@xcite . in various cosmological models ,
fundamental quantities are either geometrical ( if they are constructed from a spacetime geometry directly ) or physical ( if they depend upon physical fields ) .
physical quantities are certainly model - dependent , while geometrical quantites are more universal .
about thirty years ago , the bouncing cosmological model with torsion was suggested in ref.@xcite , but the torsion was imagined as playing role only at high densities in the early universe .
goenner et al . made a general survey of the torsion cosmology @xcite , in which the equations for all the pgt ( poincar gauge theory of gravity ) cases were discussed although they only solved in detail a few particular cases .
recently some authors have begun to study torsion as a possible reason of the accelerating universe @xcite .
nester and collaborators @xcite consider an accounting for the accelerated universe in term of a riemann - cartan geometry : dynamic scalar torsion .
they explore the possibility that the dynamic pgt connection , reflecting the nature of dynamic pgt torsion , provides the accelerating force . with the usual assumptions of homogeneity and isotropy in cosmology and specific cases of the suitable parameters and initial conditions , they find that torsion field could play a role of dark energy
. one of the motivation was to avoid singularities in the initial investigations of torsion cosmology @xcite .
however , it soon was found that non - linear torsion effects were more likely to produce stronger singularities @xcite .
the non - linear effects turn out to play a key role for the outstanding present day mystery : the accelerated universe . in the various pgt ,
the connection dynamics decomposed into six modes with certain spin and parity : @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 .
some investigations showed that @xmath4 may well be the only acceptable dynamic pgt torsion modes @xcite .
the pseudoscalar mode @xmath5 is naturally driven by the intrinsic spin of elementary fermions , therefore it naturally interacts with such sources .
consequently , it is generally thought that axial torsion must be small and have small effects at the late time of cosmological evolution .
this is a major reason why one does not focus on this mode at the late time . on the other hand , the scalar mode @xmath6 does not interact in any direct obvious fashion with any known type of matter @xcite ,
therefore one can imagine it as having significant magnitude and yet not being conspicuously noticed .
furthermore , there is a critical non - zero value for the affine scalar curvature since @xmath6 mode can interact indirectly through the non - linear equations .
the homogeneity and isotropy of cosmology have received strong confirmation from modern observations , which greatly restrict the possible types of non - vanishing fields . under the assumption of homogeneity and isotropy
, @xmath6 mode has only a time component and it can be specified as the gradient of a time - dependent function .
therefore , the cosmological models with the scalar mode offer a situation where dynamic torsion may lead to observable effect at late time .
we emphasize again that one does not focus on the early universe , where one could indeed expect large effects ( though their signature would have to be separated from other large effects ) , and substitutionally asks about traces of torsion effects at the late time of cosmological evolution @xcite .
obviously , the fine - tuning problem is one of the most important issues for the torsion cosmology @xcite . and a good model should limit the fine - tuning as much as possible .
the dynamical attractor of the cosmological system has been employed to make the later time behaviors of the model insensitive to the initial condition of the field and thus alleviates the fine - tuning problem @xcite .
furthermore , nester et al @xcite have shown that the hubble parameter and @xmath7 have an oscillatory form for the scalar torsion cosmology . the traditional geometrical parameters , i.e. , the hubble parameter @xmath8 and the deceleration parameter @xmath9 , are two elegant choices to describe the expansion state of universe but they can not distinguish various accelerating mechanism uniquely , because a quite number of models may just correspond to the same current values of @xmath10 and @xmath11 .
however , sahni , saini , starobinsky and alam @xcite have introduced the statefinder pair @xmath12 : @xmath13 , @xmath14 .
it is obviously a natural next step beyond @xmath10 and @xmath11 .
fortunately , as is shown in the literatures @xcite , the statefinder parameters which are also geometrical diagnostics , are able to differentiate a series of cosmological models successfully . using the discussion of statefinder parameters in the scalar torsion cosmology ,
we explain easily why the present field equations modify the expansion of the universe only at late time .
if the evolving trajectory of statefinder have a decelerating phase ( @xmath15 ) at early time , then we can understand why the expansion of the universe until @xmath16 remains unchanged in the scalar torsion models . in this paper
, we apply the statefinder diagnostics to the torsion cosmology .
we find that there are some characteristics of statefinder parameters for the torsion cosmology that can be distinguished from the other cosmological models .
the statefinder diagnostics show that the universe naturally has an accelerating expansion at low redshifts ( late time ) and a decelerating expansion at high redshifts ( early time ) . therefore
, scalar torsion cosmology can avoid some of the problems which occur in other models .
especially , the effect of torsion can make the expansion rate oscillate when torsion parameter @xmath17 or @xmath18 . whether the universe has properties which are easier to explain within the scalar torsion context is a remarkable possibility demanding further exploration .
the oscillatory feature of hubble parameter had earlier been reported for the braneworld cosmology @xcite and the quasi - steady state cosmology @xcite .
we show that statefinder diagnostic has a direct bearing on the critical points of the dynamical system .
one of the most interesting characteristic of the trajectories is that there are loop and curves with the shape of tadpole in the case of the torsion parameter @xmath19 . in this case
, we fit the scalar torsion model to current type ia supernova data and find it is consistent with the observations .
furthermore , we analyze preliminarily the relevance for realistic observation of the found statefinder parameters .
pgt @xcite has been regarded as an interesting alternative to general relativity because of its gauge structure and geometric properties .
pgt based on a riemann - cartan geometry , allows for dynamic torsion in addition to curvature .
the affine connection of the riemann - cartan geometry is @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the levi - civita connection and @xmath22 is the torsion tensor .
meantime , the ricci curvature and scalar curvature can be written as @xmath23 where @xmath24 and @xmath25 are the riemannian ricci curvature and scalar curvature , respectively , and @xmath26 is the covariant derivative with the levi - civita connection ( for a detailed discussion see ref .
. theoretical analysis of pgt led us to consider tendentiously dynamic `` scalar mode '' . in this case , the restricted expression of the torsion can be written as @xcite @xmath27\kappa},\label{trestrct}\ ] ] where the vector @xmath28 is the trace of the torsion .
then , the ricci curvature and scalar curvature can be expressed as @xmath29 the gravitational lagrangian density for the scalar mode is @xmath30 where @xmath31 and @xmath0 is a torsion parameter .
consider that the parameter @xmath32 is associated with quadratic scalar curvature term @xmath33 , so that @xmath32 should be positive @xcite .
therefore , the field equations of the scalar mode are @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the source energy - momentum tensor and @xmath36 is the contribution of the scalar torsion mode to the effective total energy - momentum tensor : @xmath37 since current observations favor a flat universe , we will work in the spatially flat robertson - walker metric @xmath38 $ ] , where @xmath39 is the scalar factor .
this engenders the riemannian ricci curvature and scalar curvature : @xmath40 where @xmath39 is the scalar factor , and @xmath10 is the hubble parameter .
the torsion @xmath41 should also be only time dependent , therefore one can let @xmath42 ( @xmath43 is the torsion field ) and the spatial parts vanish .
the corresponding equations of motion in the matter - dominated era are as follows @xmath44 where @xmath45 and the energy density of matter component @xmath46 one can scale the variables and the parameters as @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the present value of hubble parameter and @xmath49 is the planck length . under the transform ( [ scale ] ) , eqs .
( [ dth])-([dtr ] ) remain unchanged .
after transform , new variables @xmath50 , @xmath10 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 , and new parameters @xmath53 , @xmath0 , @xmath54 and @xmath32 are all dimensionless . obviously , the newtonian limit requires @xmath55 . for the case of scalar torsion mode
, the effective energy - momentum tensor can be represented as @xmath56\,,\label{torpre}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the off - diagonal terms vanish .
the effective energy density @xmath57 which is deduced from general relativity .
@xmath58 is an effective pressure , and the effective equation of state is @xmath59 which is induced by the dynamic torsion .
, the temporal component of the torsion @xmath51 , the affine scalar curvature @xmath52 and the deceleration parameter @xmath11 as functions of time .
we have chosen the parameters @xmath60 , @xmath61 and the initial values @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64.,title="fig:",width=264 ] , the temporal component of the torsion @xmath51 , the affine scalar curvature @xmath52 and the deceleration parameter @xmath11 as functions of time .
we have chosen the parameters @xmath60 , @xmath61 and the initial values @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64.,title="fig:",width=268 ] in the case of @xmath65 , nester et al showed that the scalar mode can contribute an oscillating aspect to the expansion rate of the universe @xcite .
this oscillatory nature can be illustrated in fig .
[ hqevol ] where we have chosen @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 and set the current time @xmath66 . according to scaling ( [ scale ] ) ,
the present value of the hubble parameter is unity .
obviously , @xmath10 is damped - oscillating at late time and @xmath67 is negative today , which means the expansion of the universe is currently accelerating .
the value of @xmath11 turns from positive to negative when the time is around @xmath68 , which is the epoch the universe began to accelerate .
however , the above result is dependent on the choice of initial data and the values of the parameters .
then , the scalar torsion cosmology is unsuited to solving the fine - tuning problem in the case of @xmath65 . in the following sections
, we ll investigate the statefinder and give the dynamics analysis for all ranges of the parameter @xmath0 .
for the spatially flat @xmath69cdm model the statefinder parameters correspond to a fixed point @xmath70 while @xmath71 for the standard cold dark matter model ( scdm ) containing no radiation .
since the torsion cosmology have used the dynamic scalar torsion ( a geometry quantity in the riemann - cartan spacetime ) , the torsion accelerating mechanism is bound to exhibit an essential distinction in contrast with various dark energy models .
therefore , its statefinder diagnostic is sure to reveal differential feature .
let us now study the torsion cosmological model in detail . using eqs .
( [ dth])-([fieldrho ] ) , we have the deceleration parameter @xmath72(432a_{1}h^{2})^{-1}\,,\label{torsionq } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and the statefinder parameters @xmath73(108a_{1}bh^{3})^{-1}\,,\nonumber\\ \label{torsionr } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath74}{3bh\left[(6\mu + br)(36h^{2}-24h\phi + 4\phi^{2}-3r)-54\mu r\right]}\ , . \label{torsions } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in the following we will discuss the statefinder for four differential ranges of the torsion parameter @xmath0 , respectively .
firstly , we consider the time evolution of the statefinder pairs @xmath12 and @xmath75 in the case of @xmath76 . in fig .
[ planecase4 ] , we plot evolution trajectories in the @xmath77 and @xmath78 planes , where we have chosen @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
we see easily that cosmic expansion alternates between deceleration and acceleration in the evolving trajectories of @xmath77 plane , and the amplitude becomes larger and larger as increase of time .
the trajectories in the @xmath78 plane is quite complicated , so we mark its sequence by the ordinal number .
every odd number curve evolves from finite to infinite , but even number curve evolves from infinite to finite .
these are quasi - periodic behaviors which corresponds to the numerical solution of ref .
noticeably , the trajectories will never pass @xmath69cdm point @xmath70 .
secondly , we discuss the time evolution of the statefinder pairs @xmath12 and @xmath75 for the case of @xmath81 .
we plot evolving trajectories in fig .
[ planecase3 ] , where we have chosen @xmath82 and @xmath83 .
we see clearly that the cosmic acceleration is guaranteed by the dynamic scalar torsion in the evolving trajectories of @xmath77 plane , and the curves will converge into @xmath69cdm point .
the evolving trajectories go through a climbing - up stage first , then get into a rolling - down stage in the @xmath78 plane .
lastly , trajectories tend to @xmath69cdm point @xmath70 .
furthermore , the only one forms a loop that starts from @xmath70 then evolves back to @xmath70 , and others show in the shape of tadpole . and @xmath78 planes for the case of torsion parameter @xmath84 , where we choose the parameters @xmath85 and @xmath86 .
the arrows show the direction of the time evolution.,title="fig:",width=264 ] and @xmath78 planes for the case of torsion parameter @xmath84 , where we choose the parameters @xmath85 and @xmath86 .
the arrows show the direction of the time evolution.,title="fig:",width=264 ] and @xmath78 planes for the case of torsion parameter @xmath87 , where we choose the parameters @xmath88 and @xmath89 .
the arrows show the direction of the time evolution.,title="fig:",width=264 ] and @xmath78 planes for the case of torsion parameter @xmath87 , where we choose the parameters @xmath88 and @xmath89 .
the arrows show the direction of the time evolution.,title="fig:",width=264 ] and @xmath90 planes for the case of @xmath91 , where we choose @xmath92 and @xmath93 .
the arrows show the direction of the time evolution.,title="fig:",width=264 ] and @xmath90 planes for the case of @xmath91 , where we choose @xmath92 and @xmath93 .
the arrows show the direction of the time evolution.,title="fig:",width=257 ] and @xmath78 planes for the case of torsion parameter @xmath94 , where we choose the parameters @xmath95 and @xmath86 .
the arrows show the direction of the time evolution.,title="fig:",width=264 ] and @xmath78 planes for the case of torsion parameter @xmath94 , where we choose the parameters @xmath95 and @xmath86 .
the arrows show the direction of the time evolution.,title="fig:",width=257 ] thirdly , we discuss the time evolution of the trajectories for the case of @xmath96 .
we plot evolving trajectories in fig .
[ planecase2 ] , where we have chosen @xmath97 and @xmath98 . obviously , the cosmic acceleration can happen since deceleration parameter is negative .
@xmath99 , @xmath100 and @xmath101 become larger and larger first , then less and less as the cosmic time increase . finally , we consider the time evolution of the statefinder pairs @xmath12 and @xmath75 in the case of @xmath18 . in fig .
[ planecase1 ] , we plot evolving trajectories in the @xmath77 and @xmath78 planes , where we have chosen @xmath102 and @xmath80 .
we find easily that the evolving trajectories analogous to the case of @xmath103 except trajectories pass the @xmath69cdm point .
to sum up , it is very interesting to see that the scalar torsion naturally provide the accelerating force in the universe for any torsion parameter @xmath0 .
however , it is dependent on torsion parameters that there is a decelerating ( @xmath15 ) expansion before an accelerating ( @xmath104 ) expansion .
the statefinder diagnostics show that the universe naturally has an accelerating expansion at low redshifts ( late time ) and a decelerating expansion at high redshifts ( early time ) for the cases of @xmath105 and @xmath18 .
obviously , scalar torsion cosmology can avoid some of the problems which occur in other models .
if we refuse the possibility of non - positivity of the kinetic energy , we will employ normal assumption , i. e. , @xmath17 . in this case ,
the effect of torsion can make the expansion rate oscillate .
with suitable adjustments of the torsion parameters , it is possible to change the quasi - period of the expansion rate as well as its amplitudes .
it is worth noting that the true values of the statefinder parameters of the universe should be determined in model - independent way . in principle
, @xmath106 can be extracted from some future astronomical observations , especially the snap - type experiment .
why there are new features for the statefinder diagnostic of torsion cosmology ? why the torsion parameter @xmath0 is divided into differential ranges by the statefinder
answer is very simple .
in fact , the statefinder diagnostic has a direct bearing on the attractor of cosmological dynamics .
therefore , we will discuss the dynamic analysis in next section .
eqs . ( [ dth])-([dtr ] ) is an autonomous system , so we can use the qualitative method of ordinary differential equations .
critical points are always exact constant solutions in the context of autonomous dynamical systems .
these points are often the extreme points of the orbits and therefore describe the asymptotic behavior . if the solutions interpolate between critical points they can be divided into a heteroclinic orbit and a homoclinic orbit ( a closed loop ) .
the heteroclinic orbit connects two different critical points and homoclinic orbit is an orbit connecting a critical point to itself . in the dynamical analysis of cosmology ,
the heteroclinic orbit is more interesting @xcite .
if the numerical calculation is associated with the critical points , then we will find all kinds of heteroclinic orbits . according to equations ( [ dth])-([dtr ] ) ,
we can obtain the critical points and study the stability of these points . substituting linear perturbations @xmath107 , @xmath108 and @xmath109 near the critical points into three independent equations , to the first orders in the perturbations ,
gives the evolution of the linear perturbations , from which we could yield three eigenvalues .
stability requires the real part of all eigenvalues to be negative .
there are five critical points @xmath110 of the system as follows @xmath111 where @xmath112 , @xmath113 and @xmath114 .
the corresponding eigenvalues of the critical points ( i)-(v ) are @xmath115 using eq .
( [ criticalpoints ] ) , we find that there is only a critical point @xmath116 in the case of @xmath76 . from eq .
( [ eigenvalues ] ) , the corresponding eigenvalue is @xmath117 , so @xmath118 is an asymptotically stable focus . if we consider the linearized equations , then eqs .
( [ dth])-([dtr ] ) are reduced to @xmath119 + the linearized system ( [ dthphirlinear ] ) has an exact periodic solution @xmath120 where @xmath121 , @xmath122 , @xmath123 and @xmath124 , @xmath125 and @xmath126 are initial values . obviously , @xmath127 is a critical line of center for the linearized eqs .
( [ hrphips ] ) . in other words
, there are only exact periodic solutions for the linearized system , but there are quasi - periodic solutions near the focus for the coupled nonlinear equations .
this property of quasi - periodic also appears in the statefinder diagnostic with the case of @xmath76 .
@l*15@l critical points & property & @xmath128 & stability + ( ` i ` ) & saddle & @xmath129 & unstable + ( ` ii`)&positive attractor&-1&stable + ( ` iii ` ) & negative attractor&-1&unstable + ( ` iv ` ) & saddle&-1&unstable + ( ` v ` ) & saddle&-1&unstable + @l*15@l critical points & property & @xmath128 & stability + ( ` i ` ) & focus & @xmath130 & stable + ( ` ii`)&saddle&-1&unstable + ( ` iii ` ) & saddle&-1&unstable + ( ` iv ` ) & saddle&-1&unstable + ( ` v ` ) & saddle&-1&unstable + in the case of @xmath131 , the critical point ( ii ) is a late time de sitter attractor and ( iii ) is a negative attractor . the properties of the critical points are shown in table [ cripointsa1l0 ] .
the de sitter attractor indicates that torsion cosmology is an elegant scheme and the scalar torsion mode is an interesting geometric quantity for physics . in the dynamical analysis of cosmology ,
the heteroclinic orbit is more interesting . using numerical calculation
, we plot the heteroclinic orbit connects the critical point case ( iii ) to case ( ii ) in fig .
[ heteroclinicorbit ] .
this heteroclinic orbit is just corresponding to the loop in fig .
[ planecase3 ] , which is from @xmath69cdm point to @xmath69cdm point .
furthermore , the trajectories with the shape of tadpole correspond to saddles . with @xmath132 .
the heteroclinic orbit connects the critical points case ( iii ) to case ( ii ) .
we take @xmath133.,width=321 ] with @xmath94 .
we take @xmath134 and the initial value @xmath135 .
@xmath136 is an asymptotically stable focus point.,width=321 ] in the case of @xmath96 , there is only an unstable saddle @xmath116 where the effective equation of state @xmath128 tends to @xmath129 .
therefore , the trajectories in fig .
[ planecase2 ] show that @xmath99,@xmath100 and @xmath101 become larger and larger , then less and less as time increases . in the case of @xmath18 ,
the properties of the critical points are shown in table [ cripointsa1l-1 ] .
the trajectories correspond to the stable focus ( see fig .
6 ) and unstable saddles with @xmath137 .
therefore , the trajectories pass through the @xmath69cdm point .
in ref.@xcite , the authors have compared the numerical values of the torsion model with the observational data , in which they fixed the initial values @xmath48 , @xmath138 and @xmath139 , and torsion parameters @xmath0 and @xmath32 . in this section
, we fixed the initial value , then fit the torsion parameters to current type ia supernovae data .
the scalar torsion cosmology predict a specific form of the hubble parameter @xmath140 as a function of redshifts @xmath141 in terms of two parameters @xmath0 and @xmath32 when we chose initial values . using the relation between @xmath142 and the comoving distance @xmath143 ( where @xmath141 is the redshift of light emission ) @xmath144 and the light ray geodesic equation in a flat universe @xmath145 where @xmath146 is the scale factor . in general
, the approach towards determining the expansion history @xmath140 is to assume an arbitrary ansatz for @xmath140 which is not necessarily physically motivated but is specially designed to give a good fit to the data for @xmath147 . given a particular cosmological model for @xmath148 where @xmath149 are model parameters , the maximum likelihood technique can be used to determine the best fit values of parameters as well as the goodness of the fit of the model to the data .
the technique can be summarized as follows : the observational data consist of @xmath150 apparent magnitudes @xmath151 and redshifts @xmath152 with their corresponding errors @xmath153 and @xmath154 .
these errors are assumed to be gaussian and uncorrelated .
each apparent magnitude @xmath155 is related to the corresponding luminosity distance @xmath156 by @xmath157 + 25,\ ] ] where @xmath158 is the absolute magnitude . for the distant sneia
, one can directly observe their apparent magnitude @xmath159 and redshift @xmath141 , because the absolute magnitude @xmath158 of them is assumed to be constant , i.e. , the supernovae are standard candles . obviously , the luminosity distance @xmath147 is the ` meeting point ' between the observed apparent magnitude @xmath160 and the theoretical prediction @xmath140 .
usually , one define distance modulus @xmath161 and express it in terms of the dimensionless ` hubble - constant free ' luminosity distance @xmath162 defined by@xmath163 as @xmath164 where the zero offset @xmath165 depends on @xmath48 ( or @xmath166 ) as @xmath167 the theoretically predicted value @xmath168 in the context of a given model @xmath169 can be described by @xcite @xmath170 therefore , the best fit values for the torsion parameters ( @xmath171 ) of the model are found by minimizing the quantity @xmath172 ^ 2}{\sigma_i^2}.\ ] ] since the nuisance parameter @xmath165 is model - independent , its value from a specific good fit can be used as consistency test of the data @xcite and one can choose _ a priori _ value of it ( equivalently , the value of dimensionless hubble parameter @xmath166 ) or marginalize over it thus obtaining @xmath173 where @xmath174 ^ 2}{\sigma_i^2},\ ] ] @xmath175}{\sigma_i^2},\ ] ] and @xmath176 in the latter approach , instead of minimizing @xmath177 , one can minimize @xmath178 which is independent of @xmath165 . the eqs .
( [ gradr]-[tort ] ) can be solved explicitly by a series in the form @xmath179,\ ] ] where @xmath180 and @xmath181 using the general relation between hubble parameter @xmath182 and the redshift @xmath141 , @xmath141 can be written as a function of @xmath50 @xmath183}-1,\ ] ] however , the convergence radius of the series ( [ e1 ] ) is @xmath184 , so we can use the expansion directly in the case of the redshift being @xmath185 . by the numerical calculation
, we find that @xmath186 corresponds to @xmath187 for the valuses of parameters @xmath139 and @xmath138 in the fig .
[ 192clcontours3 ] . for the case of @xmath188
, we should use a direct analytic continuation .
weierstrass @xcite had built the whole theory of analytic functions from the concept of power series .
given a point @xmath189 ( @xmath190 ) , the function @xmath182 has a taylor expansion @xmath191.\ ] ] where the coefficients @xmath192 is still expressed as eq .
( [ e2 ] ) and @xmath193 can be decided by eq .
( [ e1 ] ) .
the new series defines an analytic function @xmath194 which is said to be obtained from @xmath195 by direct analytic continuation .
this process can be repeated any number of times . in the general case
we have to consider a succession of power series @xmath195 , @xmath194, ... ,@xmath196 , each of which is a direct analytic continuation of the preceding one .
by using this method we have the evolution of hubble parameter @xmath182 .
furthermore , we have the function @xmath140 from eq .
( [ e3 ] ) .
in fact , we need only to consider the case of @xmath197 for the essence supernovae data .
we now apply the above described maximum likelihood method using the essence supernovae data which is one of the reliable published data set consisting of 192 sneia ( @xmath198 ) . beside the 162 data points given in table 9 of ref .
@xcite , which contains 60 essence sneia , 57 snls sneia and 45 nearby sneia , we add 30 sneia detected at @xmath199 by the hubble space telescope @xcite as in ref.@xcite . in table
[ differentvalues ] , we show the best fit of torsion parameters at different initial values of @xmath139 and @xmath138 . @l*15@l @xmath139 & @xmath138 & @xmath0 & @xmath32 + 0.25&0.35 & -0.10&1.44 + 0.20&0.34 & -0.08&1.80 + 0.15&0.34 & -0.06&2.40 + 0.10&0.33 & -0.04&3.60 + in fig .
[ 192clcontours3 ] , contours with 68.3% , 95.4% and 99.7% confidence level are plotted , in which we take a marginalization over the model - independent parameter @xmath165 . the best fit as showed in the figure corresponds to @xmath200 and @xmath201 , and the minimum value of @xmath202 . for @xmath203
, one can get @xmath204 and the best fit @xmath205 .
therefore , it s easy to know that @xmath206 is consistent at the @xmath207 level with the best fits of scalar torsion cosmology . in fig .
[ zu ] , we show a comparison of the essence supernovae data along with the theoretically predicted curves in the context of scalar torsion and @xmath206 .
we can see that the scalar torsion model(@xmath208 , @xmath209 , @xmath210 , @xmath211 ) gives a close curve behavior to the one from @xmath206 ( @xmath212 ) .
clearly , the allowed ranges of the parameters @xmath0 and @xmath32 favor the case of @xmath213 if we chose @xmath214 and @xmath215 . with the essence supernovae data via the relation between the redshift @xmath141 and the distance modulus @xmath54 .
the scalar torsion model(@xmath208 , @xmath209 , @xmath210 , @xmath211 ) gives a close curve behavior to the one from @xmath206 ( @xmath212).,title="fig:",width=264 ] with the essence supernovae data via the relation between the redshift @xmath141 and the distance modulus @xmath54 .
the scalar torsion model(@xmath208 , @xmath209 , @xmath210 , @xmath211 ) gives a close curve behavior to the one from @xmath206 ( @xmath212).,title="fig:",width=272 ] and @xmath32 using the essence sneia dataset .
here we have assumed @xmath216 , @xmath214 and @xmath215.,width=321 ]
we have studied the statefinder diagnostic to the torsion cosmology , in which an accounting for the accelerated universe is considered in term of a riemann - cartan geometry : dynamic scalar torsion .
we have shown that statefinder diagnostic has a direct bearing on the critical points .
the statefinder diagnostic divides the torsion parameter @xmath0 into four ranges , which is in keeping with the requirement of dynamical analysis .
therefore , the statefinder diagnostic can be used to an exceedingly general category of models including several for which the notion of equation of state is not directly applicable .
the statefinder diagnostic has the advantage over the dynamical analysis at the simplicity , but the latter can provide more information .
the most interesting characteristic of the trajectories is that there is a loop in the case of @xmath217 .
this behavior corresponds to the heteroclinic orbit connecting the negative attractor and de sitter attractor .
the trajectories with the shape of tadpole show that they pass through the @xmath69cdm fixed point along the time evolution , then the statefinder pairs are going along with a loop and they will pass through the @xmath69cdm fixed point again in the future .
it is worth noting that there exists closed loop in the ref .
@xcite , but there is no closed loop which contains the @xmath69cdm fixed point .
these behaviors indicate that torsion cosmology is an elegant scheme and the scalar torsion mode is an interesting geometric quantity for physics .
furthermore , the quasi - periodic feature of trajectories in the cases of @xmath76 or @xmath18 shows that the numerical solutions in ref .
@xcite are not periodic , but are quasi - periodic near the focus for the coupled nonlinear equations .
we fixed only the initial values , then fitted the torsion parameters to current sneia dataset .
we find that the scalar torsion naturally explain the accelerating expansion of the universe for any torsion parameter @xmath0 .
however , it is dependent @xmath0 and @xmath32 that there is a decelerating expansion before an accelerating expansion .
the statefinder diagnostics show that the universe naturally have an accelerating expansion at late time and a decelerating expansion at early time for the case of @xmath218 and @xmath18 .
if we refuse the possibility of non - positivity of the kinetic energy , we have to employ normal assumption ( @xmath17 ) . under this assumption ,
the effect of torsion can make the expansion rate oscillate .
furthermore , with suitable adjustments of the torsion parameters and initial value , it is possible to change the quasi - period of expansion rate as well as its amplitudes . in order to have a quantitative understanding of the scalar torsion cosmology , the matter density @xmath219 , the effective mass density @xmath220 , and the quantity @xmath221 are important .
this scenario bears a strong resemblance to the braneworld cosmology in a very different context by sahni , shtanov and viznyuk @xcite .
the @xmath222 parameters in the torsion cosmology and in the @xmath69cdm cosmology can nevertheless be quite different .
therefore , at high redshift , the torsion cosmology asymptotically expands like a matter - dominated universe with the value of @xmath222 inferred from the observations of the local matter density . at low redshift
, the torsion model behaves like @xmath69cdm but with a renormalized value of @xmath223 .
the difference between @xmath222 and @xmath223 is dependent on the present value of statefinder parameters @xmath224 .
a more detailed estimate , however , lies beyond the scope of the present paper , and we will study it in a future work . finally , @xmath225 and @xmath226 should be extracted from some future astronomical observations in principle , especially the snap - type experiments .
this work is supported by national science foundation of china grant no .
10847153 and no . 10671128
10 sahni v and starobinsky a 2000 _ int .
_ d*9 * 373 [ astro - ph/9904398 ] + peebles p j e and ratra b 2003 _ rev .
phys . _ * 75 * 559 [ astro - ph/0207347 ] + padmanabhan t 2003 _ phys .
rept . _ * 380 * 235 [ hep - th/0212290 ] + copeland e j , sami m and tsujikawa s 2006 _ int . j. mod .
_ d*15 * 1753 [ hep - th/0603057 ] + sahni v and starobinsky a 2006 _ int . j. mod
_ d*15 * 2105 [ astro - ph/0610026 ] endo m and fukui t 1977 _ gen .
* 8 * 833 + overduin j m and cooperstock f i 1998 _ phys .
_ d*58 * 043506 [ astro - ph/9805260 ] + hao j g and li x z 2005 _ phys .
_ b*606 * 7 [ astro - ph/0404154 ] + liu d j and li x z 2005 _ phys .
_ b*611 * 8 [ astro - ph/0501596 ] + beesham a 1993 _ phys .
rev _ d*48 * 3539 caldwell r r 2002 _ phys . lett .
_ b*545 * 23 [ astro - ph/9908168 ] + sahni v and shtanov yu 2003 _ jcap _ * 11 * 014 [ astro - ph/0202346 ] + hao j g and li x z 2003 _ phys .
_ d*67 * 107303 [ gr - qc/0302100 ] + liu d j and li x z 2003 _ phys .
_ d*68 * 067301 [ hep - th/0307239 ] + li x z and hao j g 2004 _ phys .
_ d*69 * 107303 [ hep - th/0303093 ] + hao j g and li x z 2003 _ phys .
_ d*68 * 083514 [ hep - th/0306033 ] kerlick g d 1976 _ ann .
phys . _ * 99 * 127 goenner h and mller - hoissen f 1984 _ class .
grav . _ * 1 * 651 capozziello s , carloni s and troisi a 2003 _ recent res .
astrophys . _ * 1 * 625 [ astro - ph/0303041 ] + boehmer c g and burnett j 2008 _ phys .
_ d*78 * 104001 [ arxiv:0809.0469 [ gr - qc ] ] + boehmer c g 2005 _ acta phys .
_ b**36 * * 2841 [ gr - qc/0506033 ] + mielke e w and romero e s 2006 _ phys .
_ d*73 * 043521 + minkevich a v , garkin a s and kudin v i 2007 _ class .
* 24 * 5835 [ arxiv:0706.1157 [ gr - qc ] shie k f , nester j m and yo h j 2008 _ phys .
_ d*78 * 023522 [ arxiv:0805.3834 [ gr - qc ] ] + yo h j and nester j m 2007 _ mod .
_ a*22 * 2057 [ astro - ph/0612738 ] + li x z , sun c b and xi p 2009 _ phys .
_ d*79 * 027301 [ arxiv:0903.3088 [ gr - qc ] ] kopczyski w 1972 _ phys .
_ a*39 * 219 nester j m and isenberg j a 1977 _ phys .
_ d*15 * 2078 hecht r d , nester j m and zhytnikov v v 1996 _ phys .
_ a*222 * 37 + yo h j and nester j m 1999 _ int
_ d*8 * 459 [ gr - qc/9902032 ] shapiro
i l 2002 _ phys .
rep . _ * 357 * 113 [ hep - th/0103093 ] hao j g and li x z 2004 _ phys .
_ d*70 * 043529 [ astro - ph/0309746 ] sahni v , saini t d , starobinsky a a and alam u 2003 _ jetp lett . _ * 77 * 201 [ astro - ph/0201498 ] alam u , sahni v and saini t d and starobinsky a a 2003 _ mon . not .
soc . _ * 344 * 1057 [ astro - ph/0303009 ] zhang x 2007 _ jcap _ * 0703 * 007 [ gr - qc/0611084 ] + chang b , liu h , xu l , zhang c and ping y 2007 _ jcap _ * 0701 * 016 [ astro - ph/0612616 ] + liu d j and liu w z 2008 _ phys .
_ d*77 * 027301 [ arxiv:0711.4854 [ astro - ph ] ] tretyakov p , toporensky a , shtanov y and sahni v 2006 _ class .
* 23 * 3259 [ gr - qc/0510104 ] hoyel f , burbidge g and narlikar j v 1993 _ astrophys . j. _ * 410 * 437 [ astro - ph/9412045 ] hehl f w , mccrea j d , mielke e w and neeman y 1995 _ phys .
rept . _ * 258 * 1 [ gr - qc/9402012 ] li x z , zhao y b and sun c b 2005 _ class
_ * 22 * 3759 [ astro - ph/0508019 ] starobinsky a a 1998 _ jetp lett . _
* 68 * 757 [ astro - ph/9810431 ] + liu d j , sun c b and li x z 2006 _ phys .
_ b*634 * 442 [ astro - ph/0512355 ] choudury t r and padmanabhan t 2005 _ astron .
_ * 429 * 807 [ astro - ph/0311622 ] ahlfors v 1979 _ complex analysis _
( new york : mcgraw hill ) wood - vasey w m et al .
2007 _ astrophys .
j _ * 666 * 694 [ astro - ph/0701041 ] riess a g et al .
2007 _ astrophys .
j _ * 659 * 98 [ astro - ph/0611572 ] davis t m et al .
2007 _ astrophys .
j _ * 666 * 716 [ astro - ph/0701510 ] sahni v , shtanov y and viznyuk a 2005 _ j. cosmol .
* 0512 * 005 [ astro - ph/0505004 ]
|
we apply the statefinder diagnostic to the torsion cosmology , in which an accounting for the accelerated universe is considered in term of a riemann - cartan geometry : dynamic scalar torsion .
we find that there are some typical characteristic of the evolution of statefinder parameters for the torsion cosmology that can be distinguished from the other cosmological models .
furthermore , we also show that statefinder diagnostic has a direct bearing on the critical points .
the statefinder diagnostic divides the torsion parameter @xmath0 into differential ranges , which is in keeping with the requirement of dynamical analysis .
in addition , we fit the scalar torsion model to essence supernovae data and give the best fit values of the model parameters .
|
developments are currently underway to promote the sensitivity of ligo and to improve its prospect for detecting gravitational waves emitted by compact object binaries @xcite . of particular interest
are the detection of gravitational waves released during the inspiral and merger of binary black hole ( bbh ) systems .
detection rates for bbh events are expected to be within 0.41000 per year with advanced ligo @xcite .
it is important that rigorous detection algorithms be in place in order to maximize the number of detections of gravitational wave signals .
the detection pipeline currently employed by ligo involves a matched - filtering process whereby signals are compared to a pre - constructed template bank of gravitational waveforms . the templates are chosen to cover some interesting region of mass - spin parameter space and are placed throughout it in such a way that guarantees some minimal match between any arbitrary point in parameter space and its closest neighbouring template .
unfortunately , the template placement strategy generally requires many thousands of templates ( e.g. @xcite ) evaluated at arbitrary mass and spin ; something that can not be achieved using the current set of numerical relativity ( nr ) waveforms . to circumvent this issue
, ligo exploits the use of analytical waveform families like phenomenological models @xcite or effective - one - body models @xcite .
we shall focus here on the phenomenological b ( phenomb ) waveforms developed by @xcite .
this waveform family describes bbh systems with varying masses and aligned - spin magnitudes ( i.e. non - precessing binaries ) .
the family was constructed by fitting a parameterized model to existing nr waveforms in order to generate a full inspiral - merger - ringdown ( imr ) description as a function of mass and spin .
the obvious appeal of the phenomb family is that it allows for the inexpensive construction of gravitational waveforms at arbitrary points in parameter space and can thus be used to create arbitrarily dense template banks . to optimize computational efficiency of the detection process
it is desirable to reduce the number of templates under consideration .
a variety of reduced bases techniques have been developed , either through singular - value decomposition ( svd ) @xcite , or via a greedy algorithm @xcite .
svd is an algebraic manipulation that transforms template waveforms into an orthonormal basis with a prescription that simultaneously filters out any redundancies existing within the original bank . as a result
, the number of templates required for matched - filtering can be significantly reduced . in addition
, it has been shown in @xcite that , upon projecting template waveforms onto the orthonormal basis produced by the svd , interpolating the projection coefficients provides accurate approximations of other imr waveforms not included in the original template bank . in this paper , we continue to explore the use of the interpolation of projection coefficients . we take a novel approach that utilizes both the analytic phenomb waveform family @xcite and nr hybrid waveforms @xcite .
we apply svd to a template bank constructed from an analytical waveform family to construct an orthonormal basis spanning the waveforms , then project the nr waveforms onto this basis and interpolate the projection coefficients to allow arbitrary waveforms to be constructed , thereby obtaining a new waveform approximant .
we show here that this approach improves upon the accuracy of the original analytical waveform family .
the original waveform family shows mismatches with the nr waveforms as high as @xmath0 when no extremization over physical parameters is applied ( i.e. , a measure of the faithfulness " of the waveform approximant ) , and mismatches of @xmath1 when maximized over total mass ( i.e. , a measure of the effectualness " of the waveform approximant ) . with our svd accuracy booster
, we are able to construct a new waveform family ( given numerically ) with mismatches @xmath2 even without extremization over physical parameters .
this paper is organized as follows .
we begin in section [ sec : mbias ] where we provide definitions to important terminology used in our paper .
we then compare our nr hybrid waveforms to the phenomb family and show that a mass - bias exists between the two . in section [ sec : method ]
we present our svd accuracy booster applied to the case study of equal - mass , zero - spin binaries . in section [ sec:2d ]
we investigate the feasibility of extending this approach to include unequal - mass binaries . we finish with concluding remarks in section [ sec : discussion ] .
a gravitational waveform is described through a complex function , @xmath3 , where real and imaginary parts store the sine and cosine components of the wave .
the specific form of @xmath4 depends on the parameters of the system , in our case the total mass @xmath5 and the mass - ratio @xmath6 .
while @xmath4 is a continuous function of time , we discretize by sampling @xmath7 , where the sampling times @xmath8 have uniform spacing @xmath9 .
we shall also whiten any gravitational waveform @xmath4 .
this processes is carried out in frequency space via @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the ligo noise curve and @xmath12 is the fourier transform of @xmath4 .
the whitened time - domain waveform , @xmath13 , is obtained by taking the inverse fourier transform of . in the remainder of the paper
, we shall always refer to whitened waveforms , dropping the subscript `` w '' . for our purposes
it suffices to take @xmath11 to be the initial ligo noise curve . using the advanced ligo noise curve
would only serve to needlessly complicate our approach by making waveforms longer in the low frequency domain . as a measure of the level of agreement between two waveforms , @xmath4 and @xmath14
, we will use their match , or overlap , @xmath15 @xcite .
we define @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the standard complex inner product and the norm @xmath18 .
we always consider the overlap maximized over time- and phase - shifts between the two waveforms .
the time - maximization is indicated in , and the phase - maximization is an automatic consequence of the modulus .
note that @xmath19 . for discrete sampling at points
@xmath20 we have that @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the complex conjugate of @xmath14 . without whitening , would need to be evaluated in the frequency domain with a weighting factor @xmath23 .
the primary advantage of is its compatibility with formal results for the svd , which will allow us to make more precise statements below .
when maximizing over time - shifts @xmath24 , we ordinarily consider discrete time - shifts in integer multiples of @xmath25 , as this avoids interpolation .
after the overlap has been maximized , it is useful to speak in terms of the mismatch , @xmath26 , defined simply as @xmath27 we use this quantity throughout the paper to measure the level of disagreement between waveforms .
we use numerical waveforms computed with the spectral einstein code spec @xcite .
primarily , we use the 15-orbit equal - mass ( mass - ratio @xmath28 ) , zero - spin ( effective spin @xmath29 ) waveform described in @xcite . in section [ sec:2d ] , we also use unequal mass waveforms computed by @xcite .
the waveforms are hybridized with a taylort3 post - newtonian ( pn ) waveform as described in @xcite at matching frequencies @xmath30 and @xmath31 for mass - ratios @xmath32 and @xmath33 , respectively .
taylort4 at 3.5pn order is known to match nr simulations exceedingly well for equal - mass , zero - spin bbh systems @xcite ( see also fig . 9 of @xcite ) .
for @xmath34 , a taylort3 hybrid is very similar to a taylort4 hybrid , cf.figure 12 of @xcite .
the mismatch between taylort3 and taylort4 hybrids is below @xmath35 at @xmath36 , dropping to below @xmath37 for @xmath38 , and @xmath39 for @xmath40 .
these mismatches are significantly smaller than mismatches arising in the study presented here , so we conclude that our results are not influenced by the accuracy of the utilized @xmath28 pn - nr hybrid waveform . for higher mass - ratios ,
the pn - nr hybrids have a larger error due to the post - newtonian waveform @xcite .
the error - bound on the hybrids increases with mass - ratio , however , is mitigated in our study here , because we use the @xmath41 hybrids only for total mass of @xmath42 , where less of the post - newtonian waveform is in band .
because nr simulations are not available for arbitrary mass ratios , we will primarily concentrate our investigation to the equal - mass and zero - spin nr hybrid waveforms described above .
the full imr waveform can be generated at any point along the @xmath43 line through a simple rescaling of amplitude and phase with total mass @xmath44 of the system .
despite such a simple rescaling , the @xmath43 line lies orthogonal to lines of constant chirp mass @xcite , therefore tracing a steep gradient in terms of waveform overlap , and encompassing a large degree of waveform structure .
since our procedure for constructing an orthonormal basis begins with phenomb waveforms , let us now investigate how well these waveforms model the nr waveforms to be interpolated . for this purpose , we adopt the notation @xmath45 and @xmath46 to represent nr and phenomb waveforms of total mass @xmath44 , respectively .
we quantify the faithfulness of the phenomb family by computing the mismatch @xmath47 $ ] as a function of mass .
the result of this calculation for @xmath48 is shown as the dashed curve in the top panel of figure [ figure : bias ] .
the mismatch starts off rather high with @xmath49 at @xmath50 and then slowly decreases as the mass is increased , until eventually flattening to @xmath51 at high mass .
the mismatch between nr and phenomb waveforms can be reduced by optimizing over a mass - bias .
this is accomplished by searching for the mass @xmath52 for which the mismatch @xmath53 $ ] is a minimum .
the result of this process is shown by the solid line in the top panel of figure [ figure : bias ] . allowing for a mass bias significantly
reduces the mismatch for @xmath54 .
the mass @xmath55 that minimizes mismatch is generally smaller than the mass @xmath44 of our nr `` signal '' waveform , @xmath56 over almost all of the mass range considered .
apparently , phenomb waveforms are systematically underestimating the mass of the `` true '' nr waveforms , at least along the portion of parameter space considered here . the solid line in the bottom panel of figure [ figure : bias ] plots the relative mass - bias , @xmath57 .
at @xmath50 this value is @xmath58 , and it rises to just above @xmath59 for @xmath60 . and @xmath29 . a more comprehensive minimization over mass , mass ratio , and effective spin might change this result . ]
it is useful to consider how this mass bias compares to the potential parameter estimation accuracy in an early detection . for a signal with a matched - filter signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) of 8
characteristic of early detection scenarios template / waveform mismatches will influence parameter estimation when the mismatch is @xmath61 @xcite . placing a horizontal cut on the top panel of figure [ figure : bias ] at @xmath62 , we see that for @xmath63 phenomb waveform errors have no observational consequence ; for @xmath64 a phenomb waveform with the wrong mass will be the best match for the signal . for @xmath65 the missmatch between equal - mass phenomb waveforms and nr ( when optimizing over mass )
grows to @xmath66 .
optimization over mass - ratio will reduce this mismatch , but we have not investigated to what degree .
we aim to construct an orthonormal basis via the svd of a bank of phenomb template waveforms , and then interpolate the coefficients of nr waveforms projected onto this basis to generate a waveform family with improved nr faithfulness .
the first step is to construct a template bank of phenomb waveforms , with attention restricted to equal - mass , zero - spin binaries .
an advantage of focusing on the @xmath43 line is that template bank construction can be simplified by systematically arranging templates in ascending order by total mass . with this arrangement
we define a template bank to consist of @xmath67 phenomb waveforms , labelled @xmath68 ( @xmath69 ) , with @xmath70 and with adjacent templates satisfying the relation : @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the desired overlap between templates and @xmath73 is some accepted tolerance in this value .
the template bank is initiated by choosing a lower mass bound @xmath74 and assigning @xmath75 .
successive templates are found by sequentially moving toward higher mass in order to find waveforms satisfying until some maximum mass @xmath76 is reached . throughout each trial , overlap between waveforms
is maximized continuously over phase shifts and discretely over time shifts . for template bank construction
we choose to refine the optimization over time by considering shifts in integer multiples of @xmath77 .
we henceforth refer to our fiducial template bank which employs the parameters @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 , and @xmath81 . the lower mass bound
was chosen in order to obtain a reasonably sized template bank containing @xmath82 waveforms ; pushing downward to @xmath50 results in more than doubling the number of templates .
template waveforms each have a duration of @xmath83 and are uniformly sampled at @xmath84 ( a sample frequency of @xmath85 ) .
@xmath86 of memory is required to store this template bank using double - precision waveforms .
the next step is to transform the template waveforms into an orthonormal basis .
following the presentation in @xcite , this is achieved by arranging the templates into the rows of a matrix @xmath87 and factoring through svd to obtain @xmath88 where @xmath89 and @xmath90 are orthogonal matrices and @xmath91 is a diagonal matrix whose non - zero elements along the main diagonal are referred to as singular values .
the svd for @xmath87 is uniquely defined as long as the singular values are arranged in descending order along the main diagonal of @xmath91 .
the end result of is to convert the @xmath67 complex - valued templates into @xmath92 real - valued orthonormal basis waveforms .
the @xmath93 basis waveform , @xmath94 , is stored in the @xmath93 row of @xmath89 , and associated with this mode is the singular value , @xmath95 , taken from the @xmath93 element along the main diagonal of @xmath91 .
one of the appeals of svd is that the singular values rank the basis waveforms with respect to their ability to represent the original templates .
this can be exploited in order to construct a reduced basis that spans the space of template waveforms to some tolerated mismatch .
for instance , suppose we choose to reduce the basis by considering only the first @xmath96 basis modes while discarding the rest .
template waveforms can be represented in this reduced basis by expanding them as the sum @xmath97 where @xmath98 are the complex - valued projection coefficients , @xmath99 the prime in is used to stress that the reduced basis is generally unable to fully represent the original template .
we are guaranteed from to completely represent the template . ]
it was shown in @xcite that the mismatch expected from reducing the basis in this way is @xmath100 given @xmath91 , can be inverted to determine the number of basis waveforms , @xmath101 , required to represent the original templates for some expected mismatch @xmath102 .
provides a useful estimate to the mismatch in represeting templates from a reduced svd basis . in order to investigate its accuracy ,
however , we should compute the mismatch explicitly for each template waveform . using the orthonormality condition @xmath103 , it is easy to show from that the mismatch between the template and its projection can be expressed in terms of the projection coefficients : @xmath104 this quantity is minimized continuously over phase and discretely over time shifts in integer multiples of @xmath25 .
choosing @xmath105 , predicts that @xmath106 of the @xmath107 basis waveforms from our fiducial template bank are required to represent the templates to the desired accuracy . in figure
[ figure : rec ] we compare the expected mismatch of @xmath108 to the actual mismatches computed from for each phenomb waveform in the template bank . the open squares in this plot show that the actual template mismatch has a significant amount of scatter about @xmath102 ,
but averaged over a whole remains well bounded to the expected result .
the phenomb template waveforms can thus be represented to a high degree from a reasonably reduced svd basis .
we are of course more interested in determining how well nr waveforms can be represented by the same reduced basis of phenomb waveforms .
since nr and phenomb waveforms are not equivalent , can not be used to estimate the mismatch obtained when projecting nr waveforms onto the reduced basis .
we must therefore compute their representation mismatch explicitly .
a general waveform , @xmath109 , can be represented by the reduced basis in analogy to by expressing it as the sum : @xmath110 where @xmath111 .
as before , the represented waveform @xmath112 will in general be neither normalized nor equivalent to the original waveform @xmath109 .
the mismatch between them is @xmath113 where we remind the reader that we always minimize over continuous phase shifts and discrete time shifts of the two waveforms . in figure [ figure :
rec ] we use open circles to plot the representation mismatch of nr waveforms evaluated at the same set of masses @xmath114 from which the phenomb template bank was constructed .
we see that nr waveforms can be represented in the reduced basis with a mismatch less than @xmath35 over most of the template bank boundary .
this is about a factor of five improvement in what can be achieved by using phenomb waveforms optimized over mass . since nr waveforms were not originally included in the template bank , and because a mass - bias exists between the phenomb waveforms which were included , we can expect that the template locations have no special meaning to nr waveforms .
this is evident from the thin dashed line which traces the nr representation mismatch for masses evaluated between the discrete templates .
this line varies smoothly across the considered mass range and exhibits no special features at the template locations .
this is in contrast to the thin solid line which traces phenomb representation mismatch evaluated between templates .
in this case , mismatch rises as we move away from one template and subsequently falls back down as the next template is approached .
the representation tolerance @xmath115 of the svd is a free parameter , which so far , we have constrained to be @xmath116 .
when this tolerance is varied , we observe the following trends : ( i ) phenomb representation mismatch generally follows @xmath117 ; ( ii ) nr representation mismatch follows @xmath117 at first and then _ saturates _ to a minimum as the representation tolerance is continually reduced .
these trends are observed in figure [ figure : trun ] where we plot nr and phenomb representation mismatch averaged over the mass boundary of the template bank evaluated both at and between templates .
the saturation in nr representation mismatch occurs when the reduced basis captures all of the nr waveform structure contained within the phenomb basis . reducing
the basis further hits a point of diminishing returns as the increased computational cost associated with a larger basis outweighs the benefit of marginally improving nr match .
we now wish to examine the possibility of using the reduced svd basis of phenomb template waveforms to construct a new waveform family with improved nr representation .
the new waveform family would be given by a numerical interpolation of the projection coefficients of nr waveforms expanded onto the reduced basis .
here we test this using the fiducial template bank and reduced basis described above .
the approach is to sample nr projection coefficients , @xmath118 , at some set of locations , @xmath119 , and then perform an interpolation to obtain the continuous function @xmath120 that can be evaluated for arbitrary @xmath121 .
the accuracy of the interpolation scheme is maximized by finding the space for which @xmath118 are smooth functions of @xmath121 .
it is reasonable to suppose that the projection coefficients will vary on a similar scale over which the waveforms themselves vary .
hence , a suitable space to sample along is the space of constant waveform overlap .
we define this to be the space @xmath122 $ ] for which the physical template masses are mapped according to : @xmath123 moving a distance @xmath124 in this space is thus equivalent to moving a distance equal to the overlap between adjacent templates . in this space
, we find the real and imaginary components , @xmath125 and @xmath126 , of the complex projection coefficients to be oscillatory functions that can roughly be described by a single frequency .
this behaviour is plotted for the basis modes @xmath127 , 50 , and 123 in figure [ figure : interpcoeff ] .
another trend observed in this plot is that the projection coefficients become increasingly complex ( i.e. show less structure ) for higher - order modes .
this is a direct result of the increasing complexity of higher - order basis waveforms themselves .
we find that the low - order waveforms are smoothest while the high - order modes feature many of the irregularities associated with the multiple frequency components and merger features of the templates .
though they are more complex , higher - order modes have smaller singular values and are therefore less important in representing waveforms .
this is evident from the steady decline in amplitude of the projection coefficients when moving down the different panels of figure [ figure : interpcoeff ] .
we shall use chebyshev polynomials to interpolate the projection coefficients .
these are a set of orthogonal functions where the @xmath128 chebyshev polynomial is defined as @xmath129 .
\label{eq : chebyn } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the orthogonality of chebyshev polynomials can be exploited to perform an @xmath130 order chebyshev interpolation by sampling @xmath131 at the @xmath132 so - called collocation points given by the gauss - lobatto chebyshev nodes @xcite @xmath133 for @xmath134 .
in general , the interpolation will not be exact and some residual , @xmath135 , will be introduced : @xmath136 here @xmath137 is the actual coefficient of @xmath45 projected onto the basis waveform @xmath94 , @xmath138 and @xmath139 is the coefficient obtained after interpolation .
the new waveform family is expressed numerically as a function of mass through the relation @xmath140{\bf u}_k,\ ] ] where the subscript
intp " reminds the reader that this is computed from an interpolation over @xmath98 .
an interpolated waveform of total mass @xmath44 can be compared to the original nr waveform ( which we consider to be the true " signal ) , where the latter is expressed as @xmath141 with @xmath142 denoting the component of @xmath45 that is orthogonal to the svd basis ( i.e. orthogonal to all phenomb waveforms in the template bank ) .
@xmath45 differs from @xmath143 by an amount @xmath144 to compute the impact of the various approximations influencing , we calculate the overlap between the interpolated waveform , and the exact waveform , @xmath145 $ ] . to begin this calculation ,
it is useful to consider the square of the overlap , @xmath146 where we have dropped the explicit mass - dependence and subscripts for convenience . using @xmath147 and taylor - expanding the right - hand - side of to second order in @xmath148 , we find @xmath149 to second order in @xmath148 , the mismatch is therefore @xmath150 we note that the right - hand - side of can be written as @xmath151 , where @xmath152 is the part of @xmath148 orthogonal to @xmath109 , @xmath153 however , for simplicity , we proceed by dropping the last term in : @xmath154 using , this gives @xmath155 \le \\ \frac{1}{2}\sum_{k=1}^{n ' } \left|r_k(m)\right|^2 + \frac{1}{2}\sum_{k = n'+1}^{2n}\left|\mu_k(m)\right|^2 + \frac{1}{2}|{\bf h}_\perp|^2 \end{gathered}\ ] ] we thus see three contributions to the total mismatch : ( i ) the interpolation error , @xmath156 ; ( ii ) the truncation error from the discarded waveforms of the reduced basis , @xmath157 ; ( iii ) the failure of the svd basis to represent the nr waveform , @xmath158 .
the sum of the last two terms , which together make up the representation error , is traced by the dashed line in figure [ figure : rec ] .
the goal for our new waveform family is to have an interpolation error that is negligible compared to the representation error . to remove the mass - dependence of interpolation error in ,
we introduce the maximum interpolation error of each mode , @xmath159 this allows the bound @xmath160 to place an upper limit on the error introduced by interpolation .
figure [ figure : rk ] plots @xmath161 as a function of mode - number @xmath162 as well as the cumulative sum @xmath163 .
the data pertains to an interpolation performed using @xmath164 chebyshev polynomials on the reduced svd basis containing the frist @xmath106 of @xmath107 waveforms . in this case , we find the interpolation error to be largely dominated by the lowest - order modes and also partially by the highest - order modes .
interpolated coefficients for various modes are plotted in figure [ figure : interpcoeff ] and help to explain the features seen in figure [ figure : rk ] . in the first place , interpolation becomes increasingly more difficult for higher - order modes due to their increasing complexity .
this problem is mitigated by the fact that high - order modes are less important for representing waveforms , as evidenced by the diminishing amplitude of projection coefficients .
although low - order modes are much smoother and thus easier to interpolate , their amplitudes are considerably larger meaning that interpolation errors are amplified with respect to high - order modes
. summarizes the three components adding to the final mismatch of our interpolated waveform family .
their total contribution can be computed directly from the interpolated coefficients in a manner similar to : @xmath165 = 1 - \sqrt{\sum_{k=1}^{n^\prime } \mu_k^\prime(m ) \mu_k^{\prime^*}(m)}. \label{eq : interpolationmismatch3}\ ] ] in the case of perfect interpolation for which @xmath166 , and reduce to and respectively , and the total mismatch is simply the representation error of the reduced basis . in figure
[ figure : interperror ] open circles show the total mismatch between our interpolated waveform family and the true nr waveforms for various masses . also plotted is the nr representation error without interpolation and the mismatch between nr and phenomb waveforms minimized over mass .
we see that interpolation introduces only small additional mismatch to the interpolated waveform family , and remains well below the optimized nr - phenomb mismatch .
this demonstrates the efficacy of using svd coupled to nr waveforms to generate a _ faithful _ waveform family with improved accuracy over the _
phenomb family that was originally used to create templates .
this represents a general scheme for improving phenomenological models and presents an interesting new opportunity to enhance the matched - filtering process employed by ligo .
so far , we have focused on the total mass axis of parameter space .
as already discussed , this served as a convenient model - problem , because the @xmath28 nr waveform can be rescaled to any total mass , so that we are able to compare against the `` correct '' answer .
the natural extension of this work is to expand into higher dimensions where nr waveforms are available only at certain , discrete mass - ratios @xmath167 . in this section
we consider expanding our approach of interpolating nr projection coefficients from a two - dimensional template bank containing unequal - mass waveforms .
we compute a template bank of phenomb waveforms covering mass - ratios @xmath167 from 1 to 6 and total masses @xmath168 .
this mass range is chosen to facilitate comparison with previous work done by @xcite .
for the two - dimensional case the construction of a template bank is no longer as straightforward as before due to the additional degree of freedom associated with varying @xmath167 .
one method that has been advanced for this purpose is to place templates hexagonally on the waveform manifold @xcite . using this procedure we find @xmath169 templates are required to satisfy a minimal match of 0.97 . following the waveform preparation of @xcite ,
templates are placed in the rows of a matrix @xmath87 with real and imaginary components filled in alternating fashion where the whitened waveforms are arranged in such a way that their peak amplitudes are aligned .
the waveforms are sampled for a total duration of @xmath170 with uniform spacing @xmath9 so that @xmath171 of memory is required to store the contents of @xmath87 if double precision is desired .
application of transforms the 16 complex - valued waveforms into 32 real - valued orthonormal basis waveforms .
the aim is to sample the coefficients of nr waveforms projected onto the svd basis of phenomb waveforms using mass - ratios for which nr data exists , and then interpolate amongst these to construct a numerical waveform family that can be evaluated for arbitrary parameters .
this provides a method for evaluating full imr waveforms for mass - ratios that have presently not been simulated . to summarize , we take some nr waveform , @xmath172 , or total mass @xmath44 and mass - ratio @xmath167 , and project it onto the basis waveform @xmath94 in order to obtain @xmath173
next we apply some two - dimensional interpolation scheme on to construct continuous functions @xmath174 that can be evaluated for arbitrary values of @xmath44 and @xmath167 bounded by the regions of the template bank .
the interpolated waveform family is given numerically by the form : @xmath175 as before , the interpolation process works best if we can develop a scheme for which the projection coefficients are smoothly varying functions of @xmath44 and @xmath167 .
following the procedure described in @xcite , the complex phase of the first mode is subtracted from all modes : @xmath176}\mu_k(m , q ) .
\label{eq : musmooth}\ ] ] to motivate why might be useful , let us consider modifying the phenomb waveform family with a parameter - dependent complex phase @xmath177 : @xmath178 when constructing a template bank , or when using a template bank , such a complex phase @xmath177 is irrelevant , because the waveforms are always optimized over a phase - shift .
however , @xmath177 will appear in the projection coefficients , , @xmath179 therefore , if one had chosen a function @xmath177 with fine - scale structure , this structure would be inherited by the projection coefficients @xmath180 . for traditional uses of waveform
families the overall complex phase @xmath177 is irrelevant , and therefore , little attention may have been paid to how it varies with parameters @xmath181 .
the transformation removes the ambiguity inherent in @xmath177 by choosing it such that @xmath182 .
this choice ties the complex phase to the physical variations of the @xmath183 coefficient , and does therefore eliminate all unphysical phase - variations on finer scales . in the leftmost panels of figure
[ figure : coeff2d ] we plot the real part of the smoothed coefficients @xmath184 for phenomb waveforms projected onto the basis modes @xmath185 and @xmath186 .
the middle panels show the same thing except using the nr waveforms evaluated at the set of mass - ratios @xmath167 = \{1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 6 } for which we have simulated waveforms .
obviously , the refinement along the @xmath167 axis is much finer for the phenomb waveforms since they can be evaluated for arbitrary mass - ratio , whereas we are limited to sampling at only 5 discrete mass - ratios for nr waveforms . for comparison purposes ,
the rightmost panels of figure [ figure : coeff2d ] show the phenomb projection coefficients coarsened to the same set of mass - ratios for which the nr waveforms are restricted to .
we find the same general behaviour as before that low - order modes display the smoothest structure , while high - order modes exhibit increasing complexity . a plausible interpolation scheme would be to sample @xmath187 for nr waveforms of varying mass for constant mass ratio ( i.e. as we have done previously ) and then stitch these together across the @xmath167 axis .
since the projection coefficients in figure [ figure : coeff2d ] show sinusoidal structure they must be sampled with at least the nyquist frequency along both axes .
however , looking at the middle and rightmost panels it appears as though this is not yet possible given the present set of limited nr waveforms .
at best the 5 available mass - ratios are just able to sample at the nyquist frequency along the @xmath167 axis for high - order modes . in order to achieve a reasonable interpolation from these projection
coefficients the current nr data thus needs to be appended with more mass - ratios .
based on the left panels of figure [ figure : coeff2d ] a suitable choice would be to double the current number of mass - ratios to include @xmath167 = \{1.5 , 2.5 , 3.5 , 4.5 , 5 , 5.5}. hence , though it is not yet practical to generate an interpolated waveform family using the svd boosting scheme applied to nr waveforms , the possibility remains open as more nr waveforms are generated .
we have shown that svd can be used to improve the representation of nr waveforms from a phenomb template bank . a reasonably reduced svd basis was able to reduce mismatch by a factor of five compared to phenomb waveforms optimized over mass .
there was also no mass - bias associated with the svd basis and therefore no optimization over physical parameters required .
this occurs because svd unifies a range of waveform structure over an extended region of parameter space so that any biases become blended into its basis .
svd therefore represents a generalized scheme through which phenomenological waveform families can be de - biased and enhanced for use as matched - filter templates .
we were able to calibrate an svd basis of phenomb templates against nr waveforms in order to construct a new waveform family with improved accuracy .
this was accomplished by interpolating the coefficients of nr waveforms projected onto the phenomb basis .
only marginal error was introduced by the interpolation scheme and the new waveform family provided a more faithful representation of the `` true '' nr signal compared to the original phenomb model .
this was shown explicitly for the case of equal - mass , zero - spin binaries .
we proceeded to investigate the possibility of extending this approach to phenomb template banks containing unequal - mass waveforms . at present , however , this method is not yet feasible since the current number of mass - ratios covered by nr simulations are unable to sample the projection coefficients with the nyquist frequency .
this method will improve as more nr waveforms are simulated and should be sufficient if the current sampling rate of mass - ratios were to double .
we thank ilana macdonald for preparing the hybrid waveforms used in this study .
kc , jde and hpp gratefully acknowledge the support of the national science and engineering research council of canada , the canada research chairs program , the canadian institute for advanced research , and industry canada and the province of ontario through the ministry of economic development and innovation .
dk gratefully acknowledges the support of the max planck society .
|
matched - filtering for the identification of compact object mergers in gravitational - wave antenna data involves the comparison of the data stream to a bank of template gravitational waveforms . typically the template bank is constructed from phenomenological waveform models since these can be evaluated for an arbitrary choice of physical parameters .
recently it has been proposed that singular value decomposition ( svd ) can be used to reduce the number of templates required for detection . as we show here , another benefit of svd is its removal of biases from the phenomenological templates along with a corresponding improvement in their ability to represent waveform signals obtained from numerical relativity ( nr ) simulations . using these ideas ,
we present a method that calibrates a reduced svd basis of phenomenological waveforms against nr waveforms in order to construct a new waveform approximant with improved accuracy and faithfulness compared to the original phenomenological model .
the new waveform family is given numerically through the interpolation of the projection coefficients of nr waveforms expanded onto the reduced basis and provides a generalized scheme for enhancing phenomenological models .
|
in quantum information processing , information is stored and processed with a quantum system .
a quantum system is always in contact with its surrounding environment , which leads to decoherence in the quantum system .
decoherence must be suppressed for quantum information stored in qubits to be intact .
there are several proposals to fight against decoherence .
quantum error correction , abriviated as qec hereafter , is one of the most promising candidate to suppress environmental noise , which leads to decoherence @xcite . by adding extra ancillary qubits , in analogy with classical error correction , it is possible to encode a data qubit to an @xmath4-qubit codeword in such a way that an error which acted in the error quantum channel is identified by measuring another set of ancillary qubits added for error syndrome readout .
then the correct codeword is recovered from a codeword suffering from a possible error by applying a recovery operation , whose explicit form is determined by the error syndrome readout .
in contrast with the conventional scheme outlined in the previous paragraph , there is a scheme in which neither syndrome readouts nor syndrome readout ancilla qubits are required @xcite . in particular , in @xcite , a general efficient scheme was proposed .
a data qubit is encoded with encoding ancilla qubits by the same encoding circuit as the conventional one , after which a noisy channel is applied on the codeword .
subsequently , the inverse of the encoding circuit is applied on a codeword , which possibly suffers from an error .
the resulting state is a tensor product of the data qubit state with a possible error and the ancilla qubit state .
it is possible to correct erroneous data qubit state by applying correction gates with the ancilla qubits as control qubits and the data qubit as a target qubit .
this paper presents two examples of error correcting codes falling in the second category .
the noisy quantum channel is assumed to be fully correlated @xcite , which means all the qubits constituting the codeword are subject to the same error operators . in most physical realizations of a quantum computer ,
the system size is typically on the order of a few micrometers or less , while the environmental noise , such as electromagnetic wave , has a wavelength on the order of a few millimeters or centimeters .
then it is natural to assume all the qubits in the register suffer from the same error operator . to demonstrate the advantage of the second category , we restrict ourselves within the noise operators @xmath7 in the following , where @xmath3 is the number of constituent qubits in the codeword .
we show that there exists an @xmath4-qubit encoding which accommodates an @xmath5-qubit data state if @xmath4 is odd and an @xmath6-qubit date state if @xmath4 is even .
although the channel is somewhat artificial as an error channel , we may apply our error correction scheme in the following situation .
suppose alice wants to send qubits to bob .
their qubit bases differ by unitary operations @xmath8 or @xmath9 .
even when they do not know which basis the other party employs , the can correctly send qubits by adding one extra qubits ( when @xmath4 is odd ) or two extra qubits ( when @xmath4 is even ) . we state the theorems and prove them in the next section .
the last section is devoted to summary and discussions .
in the following , @xmath10 denotes the @xmath11th component of the pauli matrices and we take the basis vectors @xmath12 so that @xmath13 is diagonalized .
we introduce operators @xmath14 and @xmath15 acting on the @xmath4-qubit space @xmath16 , where @xmath3 as mentioned before .
let @xmath17 be @xmath18 complex matrices , and let @xmath19
. denote by @xmath20 the ( joint ) rank-@xmath21 numerical range of @xmath22 , which is the collection of @xmath23 such that @xmath24 for some @xmath18 rank-@xmath21 orthogonal projection @xmath25 @xcite . a quantum channel of the form @xmath26 has a @xmath21-dimensional quantum error correcting code ( qecc ) if and only if @xmath27 .
to prove this statement , we need to recall the knill - laflamme correctability condition , which asserts that given a quantum channel @xmath28 with error operators @xmath29 , @xmath30 is a qecc of @xmath31 if and only if @xmath32 , where @xmath33 is the projection operator with the range space @xmath30 @xcite .
it should be clear that @xmath34 if and only if there is a qecc with dimension @xmath21 .
now it follows from @xmath35 and the relations @xmath36 when @xmath4 is even and @xmath37 when @xmath4 is odd that the channel ( [ eq : corrch ] ) has a @xmath21-dimensional qecc if and only if @xmath38 by noting that @xmath39 irrespective of rank @xmath25 , we find @xmath40 if and only if @xmath41 .
[ thm1 ] suppose @xmath3 is odd
. then @xmath42 .
our proof is constructive .
for @xmath43 , denote @xmath44 .
let @xmath45 then @xmath46 , where @xmath47 is the number of @xmath48-combinations from @xmath4 elements .
since @xmath49 we have @xmath50 let @xmath25 be the orthogonal projection onto @xmath30 .
then the above observation shows that @xmath51 and @xmath52 .
therefore , @xmath53 , which shows that @xmath54 and hence @xmath30 is shown to be a @xmath55-dimensional qecc .
_ now let us turn to the even @xmath4 case .
we first state a lemma which is necessary to prove the theorem .
[ lem1 ] let @xmath56 be a normal matrix .
then the rank-@xmath21 numerical range of @xmath57 is the intersection of the convex hulls of any @xmath58 eigenvalues of @xmath57 .
the proof of the lemma is found in @xcite .
[ thm2 ] suppose @xmath3 is even . then @xmath59 but @xmath60 . _ proof
let @xmath61 . by theorem [ thm1 ] , @xmath62 .
consider @xmath63 observe that the projection @xmath25 onto @xmath64 satisfies @xmath65 and @xmath52 and hence @xmath66 , which proves @xmath59 .
_ since @xmath67 is a commuting family , @xmath8 and @xmath9 can be diagonalized simultaneously .
we may assume that @xmath68 since @xmath69 , we have @xmath70 let us show that @xmath71 .
we first note the identity @xmath72 for hermitian @xmath73 .
let us replace @xmath74 by @xmath75 and @xmath76 by @xmath77 to obtain @xmath78 .
since @xmath75 and @xmath77 commute , @xmath79 is normal and lemma [ lem1 ] is applicable . from eqs .
( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ eq2 ] ) , we find @xmath79 has eigenvalues @xmath80 and each eigenvalue is @xmath81-fold degenerate . by taking @xmath82 and @xmath83 in lemma [ lem1 ] , we find the rank-@xmath55 numerical range of @xmath79 is the intersection of the convex hulls of any @xmath84 eigenvalues .
since each eigenvalue has multiplicity @xmath81 , each convex hull involves at least three eigenvalues . by inspecting four eigenvalues plotted in the complex plane
, we easily find the intersection of all the convex hulls is a single point @xmath85 , which proves @xmath71 .
similarly , we prove @xmath86 . from these equalities
we obtain @xmath87 suppose @xmath42 .
let @xmath25 be a rank-@xmath55 projection such that @xmath88 .
let @xmath89\ ] ] where each @xmath90 has size @xmath91 . from @xmath92 and @xmath93
, we have four independent equations @xmath94 let @xmath95 be the singular value decomposition of @xmath96 , where @xmath97 is a nonnegative diagonal matrix and @xmath98 . then the above equations are solved as @xmath99 by collecting these results , we find the projection operator is decomposed as @xmath100 \[\begin{array}{cc}d&d\\ d&d\end{array}\]\[\begin{array}{cc}u^\dagger&0\\ 0&v^\dagger\end{array}\]\,.\ ] ] since rank @xmath101 and @xmath102 , it follows from @xmath103 that @xmath104 .
let @xmath105 then both @xmath57 and @xmath106 are non - singular .
on the other hand , the assumption @xmath107 implies @xmath108 and hence @xmath109 , which is a contradiction .
therefore , @xmath60 . in the following ,
we give an explicit construction of qecc for @xmath31 in eq .
( [ eq : corrch ] ) with odd @xmath4 .
the technique is based on theorem [ thm1 ] and the results in @xcite .
let @xmath110 be the @xmath111 matrix with columns in the set @xmath112 define the @xmath113 matrix @xmath114 $ ] . in our qec , an @xmath5-qubit state @xmath115 is encoded with one ancilla qubit @xmath116 as @xmath117 .
then a noisy quantum channel @xmath31 is applied on the encoded state and subsequently the recovery operation @xmath118 is applied so that the decoded state automatically appears in the output with no syndrome measurements .
our qec is concisely summarized as @xmath119 where @xmath120 .
choosing an encoding amounts to assigning each of @xmath81 column vectors in @xmath110 a basis vector of the whole hilbert space without repetition .
therefore there are large degrees of freedom in the choice of encoding . in the following examples ,
we have chosen encoding whose quantum circuit can be implemented with the least number of cnot gates . since our decoding circuit is the inverse of the encoding circuit , it is also implemented with the least number of cnot gates . when @xmath121 , the unitary operation @xmath122 can be chosen as @xmath123 when @xmath124 , @xmath122 can be chosen as @xmath125 figure [ nodd ] shows quantum circuits of the matrix @xmath122 for @xmath126 and @xmath127 .
[ nodd ] -qubit state @xmath115 with a single ancilla qubit initially in the state @xmath128 .
( a ) is for @xmath126 while ( b ) is for @xmath127 .
the quantum channel in the box represents a quantum operation with fully correlated noise given in eq .
the output ancilla state is @xmath129 for error operators @xmath130 and @xmath131 ( @xmath132 and @xmath133 ) for @xmath126 and @xmath129 for @xmath134 and @xmath135 ( @xmath136 and @xmath137 ) for @xmath127.,width=529 ] it follows from eq .
( [ qecc ] ) that the recovery circuit is the inverse of the encoding circuit .
it seems , at first sight , that the implementations given in fig .
1 contradict with eq .
( [ qecc ] ) since the controlled not gate in the end of the recovery circuit is missing in the encoding circuit .
note , however , that the top qubit is set to @xmath138 initially and the controlled not gate is safely omitted without affecting encoding .
we construct a decoherence - free encoding when @xmath4 is even as follows .
the codeword in this case is immune to the noise operators , which is an analogue of noiseless subspace / subsystem introduced in @xcite .
let @xmath139 then evidently a vector @xmath140 is separately invariant under the action of @xmath141 and @xmath9 .
there are @xmath142 orthogonal vectors of such form , e.g. we have four vectors , @xmath143 for @xmath144 .
thus we find a decoherence - free encoding for @xmath145 qubits by projecting onto this invariant subspace spanned by these basis .
it should be noted that the projection operator @xmath25 to the subspace @xmath146 spanned by the four vectors in eq .
( [ nss ] ) satisfies rank @xmath147 and @xmath148 , which shows @xmath149 .
it is easy to generalize this result to cases with arbitrary @xmath150 .
figure [ neven ] ( a ) and
( b ) depict quantum circuits for ( a ) @xmath144 and ( b ) @xmath151 , respectively .
[ neven ] -qubit state @xmath115 with two ancilla qubit initially in the state @xmath152 .
( a ) is for @xmath144 while ( b ) is for @xmath151 .
the quantum channel in the box represents a quantum operation with fully correlated noise given in eq .
the output ancilla state is always @xmath153 , irrespective of error operators acted in the channel.,width=529 ]
we have shown that there is a quantum error correction which suppresses fully correlated errors of the form @xmath154 , in which @xmath4 qubits are required to encode ( i ) @xmath155 data qubit states when @xmath4 is odd and ( ii ) @xmath156 data qubit states when @xmath4 is even .
we have proved these statements by using operator theoretical technique .
neither syndrome measurements nor ancilla qubits for syndrome measurement are required in our scheme , which makes physical implementation of our scheme highly practical .
examples with @xmath126 and @xmath127 are analyzed in detail and explicit quantum circuits implementing our qec with the least number of cnot gate were obtained .
since the error operators are closed under matrix multiplication , errors can be corrected even when they act on the codeword many times .
a somewhat similar qec has been reported in @xcite .
they analyzed a partially correlated noise , where the error operators acts on a fixed number of the codeword qubits simultaneously .
they have shown that the quantum packing bound was violated by taking advantage of degeneracy of the codes .
justification of such a noise physically , however , seems to be rather difficult .
they have also shown that correlated noise acting on an arbitrary number @xmath4 of qubits can encode @xmath157 data qubits .
in contrast , we have analyzed a fully correlated noise , which shows the highest degeneracy , and have shown that @xmath158 data qubits can be encoded with an @xmath4-qubit codeword when @xmath4 is odd .
clearly , our qec suppressing fully correlated errors is optimal as it is clear that one can not encode @xmath4 qubits as data qubits for odd @xmath4 and we have shown that one can not encode @xmath155 qubits for even @xmath4 .
ckl was supported by a usa nsf grant , a hk rgc grant , the 2011 fulbright fellowship , and the 2011 shanxi 100 talent program .
he is an honorary professor of university of hong kong , taiyuan university of technology , and shanghai university .
mn and ht were supported by `` open research center '' project for private universities : matching fund subsidy from mext ( ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ) .
ytp was supported by a usa nsf grant .
nss was supported by a hk rgc grant .
|
we investigate an efficient quantum error correction of a fully correlated noise .
suppose the noise is characterized by a quantum channel whose error operators take fully correlated forms given by @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the number of qubits encoding the codeword .
it is proved that ( i ) @xmath4 qubits codeword encodes @xmath5 data qubits when @xmath4 is odd and ( ii ) @xmath4 qubits codeword implements an error - free encoding , which encode @xmath6 data qubits when @xmath4 is even .
quantum circuits implementing these schemes are constructed .
quantum error correction , higher rank numerical range , recovery operator , mixed unitary channel
|
it has become a generally agreed concept that the euv dimming observed during the onset of a _ coronal mass ejection ( cme ) _ manifests the coronal mass loss of the cme , and thus we basically expect a one - to - one correlation between the detections of cmes and euv dimmings , unless there exist special circumstances . for instance , the cme could originate behind the limb , in which case the euv dimming is obscured , or the cme could start in the upper corona , where there is little euv emission because of the gravitational stratification .
the latter case would imply very low masses compared with a cme that originates at the base of the corona , i.e. , @xmath0 at two thermal scale heights .
however , there exists a case with an average cme mass that did not leave any footprints behind in euv ( robbrecht et al .
a statistical study on the simultaneous detection of euv dimmings and cmes has recently been performed by bewsher et al .
this study based on soho / cds and lasco data confirms a 55% association rate of dimming events with cmes , and vice versa a 84% association rate of cmes with dimming events
. some of the non - associated events may be subject to occultation , cme detection sensitivity , or incomplete temperature coverage in euv and soft x - rays .
perhaps the cme - dimming association rate will reach 100% once the stereo spacecraft arrive at a separation of @xmath1 and cover all equatorial latitudes of the sun .
a number of studies have been carried out by using the detection of coronal dimming to identify cme source regions , focusing on transient coronal holes caused by filament eruptions ( rust 1983 ; watanabe et al .
1992 ) , euv dimming at cme onsets ( harrison 1997 ; aschwanden et al .
1999 ) , soft x - ray dimming after cmes ( sterling & hudson 1997 ) , soft x - ray dimming after a prominence eruption ( gopalswamy & hanaoka 1998 ) , simultaneous dimming in soft x - rays and euv during cme launches ( zarro et al . 1999 ; harrison & lyons 2000 ; harrison et al .
2003 ) , determinations of cme masses from euv dimming from spectroscopic data ( harrison & lyons 2000 ; harrison et al .
2003 ) or from euv imaging data ( zhukov and auchere 2004 ; aschwanden et al .
all these studies support the conclusion that dimmings in the corona ( either detected in euv , soft x - rays , or both ) are unmistakable signatures of cme launches , and thus can be used vice versa to identify the mutual phenomena . in this study here
we attempt for the first time to model the kinematics of a cme and the resulting euv dimming quantitatively , which provides us unique physical parameters of the cme source region and on the cme kinematics in the initial acceleration phase .
the dynamics of a cme can often be characterized by a rapid expansion of a magnetically unstable coronal volume that expands from the lower corona upward into the heliosphere .
different shapes have been used to approximately describe the 3d geometry of a cme , such as a spherical bubble , an ice - cone , a crescent , or a helical flux rope , which expand in a self - similar fashion and approximately maintain the aspect ratio in vertical and horizontal directions during the initial phase of the expansion . here
we develop a four - dimensional ( 4d=3d+t ) model that describes the 3d evolution of the cme geometry in time ( t ) in terms of 4d electron density distributions @xmath2 that allow us also to predict and forward - fit a corresponding euv intensity image data cube @xmath3 in an observed wavelength . for the sake of simplicity
we start in our model here with the simplest case , assuming : ( 1 ) spherical 3d geometry for the cme front and cavity ; ( 2 ) self - similar expansion in time ; ( 3 ) density compression in the cme front and adiabatic volume expansion in the cme cavity ; ( 4 ) mass conservation for the sum of the cme front , cavity , and external coronal volume ; ( 5 ) hydrostatic ( gravitational stratification ) or super - hydrostatic density scale heights ; ( 6 ) line - tying condition for the magnetic field at the cme base ; and ( 7 ) a magnetic driving force that is constant during the time interval of the initial expansion phase .
this scenario is consistent with the traditional characterization of a typical cme morphology in three parts , including a cme front ( leading edge ) , a cavity , and a filament ( although we do not model the filament part ) .
the expanding cme bubble sweeps up the coronal plasma that appears as a bright rim at the observed `` cme front '' or leading edge .
the interior of the cme bubble exhibits a rapid decrease in electron density due to the adiabatic expansion , which renders the inside of the cme bubble darker in euv and appears as the observed `` cme cavity '' .
the assumption of adiabatic expansion implies no mass and energy exchange across the outer cme boundary , and thus is consistent with the assumption of a low plasma @xmath4-parameter in the corona with perfect magnetic confinement , while the cme bubble will become leaking in the outer corona and heliosphere , where the plasma @xmath4-parameter exceeds unity ( not included in our model here ) .
a spherical 3d geometry can be characterized by one single free parameter , the radius @xmath5 of the sphere .
the self - similar expansion maintains the spherical shape , so the boundary of the cme bubble can still be parameterized by a single time - dependent radius @xmath6 .
the time - dependence of the cme expansion is controlled by magnetic forces , e.g. , by a lorentz force or hoop force . for sake of simplicity
we assume a constant force during the initial phase of the cme expansion , which corresponds to a constant acceleration @xmath7 and requires three free parameters ( @xmath8 ) to characterize the radial cme expansion , @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the initial radius at starting time @xmath11 , @xmath12 is the initial velocity and @xmath7 is the acceleration of the radial expansion . for the motion of the cme centroid at height @xmath13 we assume a similar quadratic parameterization , @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the initial height at starting time @xmath11 , @xmath16 is the initial velocity and @xmath17 is the acceleration of the vertical motion .
this parameterization is consistent with a fit to a theoretical mhd simulation of a breakout cme ( lynch et al .
2004 ) as well as with kinematic fits to observed cmes ( byrne et al .
2009 ) . , the outer radius of the cme sphere is @xmath6 , and the inner radius of the cme front is @xmath18 .
these parameters increase quadratically with time .
the circular footpoint area of the cme with radius @xmath19 stays invariant during the self - similar expansion in order to satisfy the line - tying condition of the coronal magnetic field at the footpoints.,width=313 ] further we constrain the cme geometry with a cylindrical footpoint area of radius @xmath19 , which connects from the solar surface to the lowest part of the spherical cme bubble . in order to ensure magnetic line - tying at the footpoints ,
the cme bubble should always be located above the cyclidrical footpoint base , which requires that the initial height satisfies @xmath20 and the acceleration constants are @xmath21 .
we visualize the model geometry in fig . 1 .
the time - invariant cme footprint area allows us a simple mass estimate of the cme from the cylindrical volume integrated over a vertical scale height , since the spherical cme bubble will eventually move to large heights with no additional mass gain ( at time @xmath22 , see right - hand panel in fig.1 ) . assuming adiabatic expansion inside the cme cavity , the electron density in the confined plasma decreases reciprocally to the expanding volume , i.e. , @xmath23 so it drops with the third power as a function of time from the initial value @xmath24 ( of the average density inside the cme ) . for the mass distribution inside the cme
we distinguish between a compression region at the outer envelope , containing the cme front , and a rarefaction region in the inside , which is also called cme cavity .
we define an average width @xmath25 of the cme front that is assumed to be approximately constant during the self - similar expansion of the cme .
while the radius @xmath6 demarcates the outer radius of the cme front , we denote the inner radius of the cme front or the radius of the cavity with @xmath18 , @xmath26 which has an initial value of @xmath27 .
the total volume @xmath28 of the cme is composed of a spherical volume with radius @xmath6 and the cylindrical volume beneath the cme with a vertical height of @xmath29 , @xmath30 \ , \ ] ] which has an initial volume value of @xmath28 , @xmath31 \ .\ ] ] the volume of the cme front @xmath32 is essentially the difference between the outer and inner sphere ( neglecting the cylindrical base at the footpoint ) @xmath33 while the volume @xmath34 of the cavity is , @xmath35 we have now to define the time - dependent densities in the cme , for both the cme front , which sweeps up plasma during its expansion , as well as for the cme cavity , which rarifies due to the adiabatic expansion .
the total mass @xmath36 of the plasma that is swept up from the external corona in a cme corresponds to the total cme volume @xmath37 minus the initial volume of the cme cavity , @xmath38 \\ & = m_p < n_e > { 4 \over 3 } \pi [ r(t)^3 - r_0 ^ 3 ] \end{array } \ , \ ] ] where @xmath39 is the mass of the hydrogen atom and @xmath40 is the electron density in the external corona averaged over the cme volume . the same mass has to be contained inside the volume @xmath41 of the cme front , @xmath42 \end{array } \ , \ ] ] thus , mass conservation yields a ratio of the average electron density @xmath43 in the cme front and the average external density @xmath40 of @xmath44 this density ratio amounts to unity at the initial time , i.e. , @xmath45 and monotonically increases with time . the maximum value of the density jump in mhd shocks derived from the _ rankine - hugoniot relations _
( e.g. , priest 1982 ) is theoretically @xmath46 .
fast cmes are expected to be supersonic and will have a higher compression factor at the cme front than slower cmes .
thus we keep the maximum compression factor @xmath47 as a free parameter , keeping in mind that physically meaningful solutions should be in the range of @xmath48 .
since we prescribe both the width @xmath25 of the cme front as well as a maximum density compression ratio @xmath47 we obtain a definition of the critical value @xmath49 for the cavity radius @xmath18 when the prescribed maximum density compression @xmath47 is reached ( using eq .
11 ) , @xmath50 which yields the critical radius @xmath49 , @xmath51^{1/3 } \ .\ ] ] therefore , only plasma outside this critical radius @xmath49 can be compressed in the cme front , while the plasma inside this critical radius dilutes by adiabatic expansion and forms the cavity , yielding an average density ratio @xmath52 inside the cavity ( according to eq .
3 ) , @xmath53}^3 & { \rm for}\ \rho(t ) \ge r(t ) \\ { \left [ r_0 / r(t ) \right]}^3 & { \rm for}\ \rho(t ) <
r(t ) \end{array } \right .
\ .\ ] ] our numerical model of a spherical cme expansion has a total of 14 free parameters : 3 positional parameters ( the heliographic coordinates ( @xmath54 ) and height @xmath55 of the initial cme centroid position ) , 5 kinematic parameters ( starting time @xmath11 , velocities @xmath56 , accelerations @xmath57 ) , 2 geometric parameters ( initial radius @xmath19 and width @xmath25 of the cme front ) , and 4 physical parameters ( coronal base density @xmath24 , maximum density compression factor @xmath47 in the cme front , the mean coronal temperature @xmath58 at the observed wavelength filter ) , and a vertical density scale height factor ( or super - hydrostaticity factor ) @xmath59 that expresses the ratio of the effective density scale height to the hydrostatic scale height at temperature @xmath58 ) .
the temperature @xmath58 defines the hydrostatic scale height @xmath60 of the corona in the observed temperature range , which enters the definition of the effective density scale height @xmath61 ( e.g. , eq . [ 3.1.16 ] in aschwanden 2004 ) , @xmath62}\ .\ ] ] thus , assuming an exponentially stratified atmosphere ( eq .
15 ) , a density compression factor @xmath63 in the cme front ( eq .
12 ) , and adiabatic expansion inside the cme cavity ( eq .
14 ) , we have the following time - dependent 3d density model : @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the distance of an arbitrary location with 3d coordinates @xmath66 to the instantaneous center position @xmath67 $ ] of the cme , @xmath68 ^ 2+[y - y_0(t)]^2+[z - z_0(t)]^2 } \ , \ ] ] which is located at height @xmath13 vertically above the heliographic position ( @xmath54 ) .
one cme event observed with stereo that appears as a spherically expanding shell , and thus is most suitable for fitting with our analytical model , is the 2008-mar-25 , 18:30 ut , event .
this cme occurred near the east limb for spacecraft stereo / ahead , and was observed on the frontside of the solar disk with spacecraft stereo / behind .
some preliminary analysis of this event regarding cme expansion and euv dimming can be found in aschwanden et al .
( 2009a ) , the cme mass was determined in white light with stereo / cor-2 ( colaninno and vourlidas 2009 ) and with stereo / euvi ( aschwanden et al .
2009b ) , and the 3d geometry was modeled with forward - fitting of various geometric models to the white - light observations ( thernisien et al .
2009 ; temmer et al .
2009 ; maloney et al . 2009 ; mierla et al .
2009a , b ) .
while most previous studies model the white - light emission of this cme , typically a few solar radii away from the sun , our model applies directly to the cme source region in the lower corona , as observed in euv .
we follow the method outlined in aschwanden et al .
( 2009a ) .
our model also quantifies the geometry and kinematics of the cme , as well as the euv dimming associated with the launch of the cme .
figures 2 and 3 show sequences of 16 ( partial ) euv images , simultaneously observed with stereo / a and b with a cadence of 75 s during the time interval of 18:36 - 18:56 ut on 2008-mar-25 . in order to determine the positional parameters of the cme as a function of time we trace the outer envelope of the cme bubble ( by visual clicking of 3 points ) in each image and each spacecraft and fit a circle through the 3 points in each image .
the selected points for fitting the position of the cme bubble were generally chosen in the brightest features of the lateral cme flanks , but could not always been traced unambiguously in cases with multiple flank features . in those cases we traced the features that were closest to a continuously expanding solution .
the radii and y - positions of the circular fits are fully constrained from the stereo / a images , so that only the x - positions of the centroid of the spherical shell need to be fitted in the epipolar stereo / b images .
we note that the fits of the cme bubble roughly agree with the envelopes of the difference flux in the stereo / b images initially ( up to 18:48 ut ) , while there is a discrepancy later on .
apparently the cme has a more complex geometry than our spherical bubble model , which needs to be investigated further .
this procedure yields the cme centroid positions @xmath69 $ ] and @xmath70 $ ] for the time sequence @xmath71 .
the images in fig .
2 and 3 are displayed as a baseline difference ( by subtracting a pre - cme image at 18:36 ut ) to enhance the contrast of the cme edge .
the circular fits to the cme outer boundaries are overlayed in fig . 2 and 3 .
both images have been coaligned and rotated into epipolar coordinates ( inhester et al .
2006 ) , so that the y - coordinates of a corresponding feature are identical in the spacecraft a and b images , while the x - coordinates differ according to the spacecraft separation angle @xmath72 , which amounts to @xmath73 at the time of the cme event .
the epipolar coordinates measured from both spacecraft are then related to the heliographic longitude @xmath74 , latitude @xmath75 , and distance @xmath76 from sun center as follows , @xmath77 which can directly be solved to obtain the spherical ( epipolar ) coordinates @xmath78 , @xmath79 ^ 2 } \\ b = \arcsin { ( y_a / r_c ) } \end{array}\ ] ] therefore , using stereoscopic triangulation , we can directly determine the spherical coordinates @xmath80 , @xmath81 for all 16 time frames , as well as obtain the cme curvature radii @xmath82 from the circular fits to the cmes .
we plot the so obtained observables @xmath83 , @xmath84 , @xmath6 , and @xmath85 in fig . 3 and determine our model parameters @xmath74 and @xmath75 from the averages .
we obtain a longitude of @xmath86 ( for spacecraft stereo / a ) , @xmath87 ( for spacecraft stereo / b ) , and a latitude @xmath88 .
thus , the cme source region is clearly occulted for stereo / a .
these epipolar coordinates can be rotated into an ecliptic coordinate system by the tilt angle @xmath89 of the spacecraft a / b plane .
viewed from earth , the longitude is approximately @xmath90 .
thus , the cme source region is @xmath91 behind the east limb when seen from earth .
this explains why the euv dimming is seen uncontaminted from post - flare loops , which are seen by stereo / b but hidden for stereo / a .
( top panel ) and latitude @xmath84 ( second panel ) of the cme centroid , the radius @xmath6 of the cme sphere ( third panel ) , and cme centroid height @xmath13 ( bottom ) .
the average values are @xmath92 and @xmath93 for the heliographic position .
the cme radius @xmath6 and height @xmath13 are fitted with quadratic functions ( dashed curves ) , yielding the constants @xmath94 hrs ( 18:38 ut ) , @xmath95 mm , @xmath96 mm , and accelerations @xmath97 km s@xmath98 and @xmath99 km s@xmath98 ( see eqs
. 1 - 2).,width=313 ] we plot also the observables @xmath13 and @xmath6 in fig . 4 and determine the model parameters @xmath55 , @xmath100 , @xmath17 , @xmath7 by fitting the quadratic functions @xmath6 ( eq . 1 ) and @xmath13 ( eq .
2 ) , for which we obtain the starting time @xmath94 hrs ( 18:38 ut ) , the initial cme radius @xmath95 mm , the initial height @xmath96 mm , and the accelerations @xmath97 km s@xmath98 for the cme radius expansion , and @xmath99 km s@xmath98 for the height motion . the initial velocity is found to be negligible ( @xmath101 and @xmath102 ) .
we estimate the accuracy of the acceleration values to be of order @xmath0 , based on the uncertainty of defining the leading edge of the cme .
thus , we determined 9 out of the 14 free parameters of our model sofar .
note that the acceleration measured here refers to the very origin of the cme in low coronal heights of @xmath103 solar radii observed in euvi data .
the acceleration is expected to be initially high and to rapidly decline further out , when the driving magnetic forces decrease at large altitudes .
this explains why our values for the acceleration in low coronal heights are significantly higher than measured further out in the heliosphere , typically in the order of tens of m s@xmath104 in height ranges of 5 - 22 solar radii , as measured with soho / lasco .
soho / lasco reported even a slightly negative acceleration at altitutes of 5 - 22 solar radii .
the driving magnetic forces that accelerate a cme are clearly confined to much lower altitudes .
we model the 3d geometry of the cme bubble with the time - dependent radius @xmath6 and the width @xmath25 of the cme compression region . in fig .
5 we show cross - sectional euv brightness profiles across the cme in horizontal direction ( parallel to the solar surface ) and in vertical direction for the euvi / a 171 observations ( indicated with dotted lines in fig .
these baseline - subtracted profiles clearly show a progressive dimming with a propagating bright rim at the cme boundary , which corresponds to the density compression region at the lateral expansion fronts of the cme .
the bright rims are clearly visible in the images during 18:46@xmath10518:56 ut shown in fig . 2 .
the average width of the observed bright rims is @xmath106 mm , a value we adopt in our model .
finally we are left with the four physical parameters @xmath107 , and @xmath47 .
since we show here only data obtained with the 171 filter , the mean temperature is constrained by the peak temperature of the instrumental euvi response function , which is at @xmath108 mk .
this constrains the thermal scale height to @xmath109 km .
the remaining free parameters @xmath59 , @xmath24 , and @xmath47 need to be determined from best - fit solutions by forward - fitting of simulated euv brightness images ( or profiles , as shown in fig .
5 ) to observed euv brightness images ( or profiles ) .
the euv emission measure in each pixel position @xmath110 can be computed by line - of - sight integration along the @xmath111-axis in our 3d density cube @xmath112 per pixel area @xmath113 for each time @xmath114 , @xmath115 from which the intensity @xmath116 in the model image in units of dn s@xmath104 can be directly obtained by multiplying with the instrumental response function @xmath117 of the 171 filter , @xmath118 where @xmath119 dn s@xmath104 @xmath120 mk@xmath104 and the fwhm of the 171 filter is @xmath121 mk . in fig .
6 we show best - fit solutions of horizontal and vertical brightness profiles . the absolute flux level is proportional to the coronal base density squared , which we obtain by minimizing the mean flux difference between simulated and observed flux profiles .
we obtain a best - fit value of @xmath122 @xmath123 .
the super - hydrostaticity factor is most sensitive to the vertical flux profile ( fig . 5 , right - hand side panels ) ,
for which we find a best - fit value of @xmath124 .
thus , the average density scale height in the cme region is slightly super - hydrostatic , as expected for dynamic processes .
these values are typical for quiet - sun corona and active region conditions ( see figs . 6 and 10 in aschwanden and acton 2001 ) .
the last free parameter , the maximum density compression factor @xmath47 , affects mostly the brightness of the cme rims . fitting the brightness excess at the cme rims at those times where bright rims are visible are consistent with a value of @xmath125 .
ll parameter & best - fit value + spacecraft separation angle & @xmath73 + spacecraft plane angle to ecliptic & @xmath126 + heliographic longitude a & @xmath127 + heliographic longitude b & @xmath128 + heliographic longitude earth & @xmath129 + heliographic latitude a , b & @xmath130 + start time of acceleration & @xmath11=2008-mar-25 18:38 ut + start time of modeling & @xmath131=2008-mar-25 18:36 ut + end time of modeling & @xmath131=2008-mar-25 18:56 ut + initial height of cme center & @xmath95 mm + initial radius of cme & @xmath96 mm + width of cme front & @xmath106 mm + acceleration of vertical motion & @xmath99 m s@xmath98 + acceleration of radial expansion & @xmath97 m s@xmath98 + inital vertical velocity & @xmath102 m s@xmath104 + inital expansion velocity & @xmath132 m s@xmath104 + maximum density compression & @xmath133 + corona / cme base density & @xmath122 @xmath123 + super - hydrostaticity factor & @xmath124 + mean temperature ( 171 filter ) & @xmath108 mk + temperature width ( 171 filter ) & @xmath134 mk + after we constrained all 14 free parameters ( listed in table 1 ) of our analytical 4d model by fitting some observables , such as measured coordinates ( fig .
4 ) and cross - sectional horizontal and vertical brightness profiles ( fig .
5 ) , we are now in the position to inter - compare the numerically simulated images with the observed images , as shown in fig . 6 for 5 selected times , for both the stereo / a and b spacecraft .
the comparison exhibits a good match for the extent of the dimming region the the bright lateral rims , both extending over about 1.5 thermal scale heights above the solar surface .
the base - difference images of euvi / a reveal a fairly symmetric cme ( as the model is by design ) , surrounded by spherical bright rims at the northern and southern cme boundaries ( as the model is able to reproduce it ) . the model , however , is less in agreement with the observed euvi / b images .
the extent of the euv dimming region matches relatively exactly , although the observed dimming region is somewhat cluttered with bright postflare loops that appear in the aftermath of the cme , which are mostly hidden in the euvi / a observations .
the biggest discrepancy between the model and the euvi / b observations is the location of the brightest rim of the cme boundary .
the combination of projection effects and gravitational stratification predict a brighter rim on the west side , where we look through a longer and denser column depth tangentially to the cme bubble , which is not apparent in the observations of euvi / b . instead , there is more bright emission just above the eastern limb that can not be reproduced by the model .
apparently there exists stronger density compression on the eastern side of the cme bubble than the model predicts .
another inconsistency is the bright loop seen in euvi / b at 18:51 ut , which does not match the surface of the modeled cme sphere as constrained by euvi / a .
apparently , there are substantial deviations from a spherically symmetric cme bubble model that are visible in euvi / b but not in euvi / a . perhaps a flux rope model
could better fit the observations than a spherical shell model .
these discrepancies between the observations and our simple first - cut model provide specific constraints for a more complex model ( with more free parameters ) that includes inhomogeneities in the density distribution of the cme .
our model allows us , in principle , to estimate the cme mass by integrating the density @xmath2 over the entire cme sphere , which is of course growing with time , but expected to converge to a maximum value once the cme expands far out into the heliosphere .
a simple lower limit can analytically be obtained by integrating the density in the cylindrical volume above the footpoint area , @xmath135 from our best - fit values @xmath95 mm , @xmath136 , @xmath137 @xmath123 and the thermal scale height of @xmath138 mm , we obtain a lower limit of @xmath139 g. however , this cme appears to expand in a cone - like fashion in the lowest density scale height , so the total volume and mass is likely to be about a factor of @xmath140 higher .
moreover , the mass detected in 171 amounts only to about a third of the total cme mass ( aschwanden et al .
2009b ) , so a more realistic estimate of the total cme mass is about a factor 6 higher than our lower limit , i.e. , @xmath141 g , which brings it into the ballpark of previous cme mass determinations of this particular event , i.e. , @xmath142 g from stereo / cor-2 white - light observations ( colaninno and vourlidas 2009 ) , or @xmath143 g from stereo / euvi observations ( aschwanden et al .
we developed an analytical 4d model that simulates the cme expansion and euv dimming in form of a time sequence of euv images that can directly be fitted to stereoscopic observations of stereo / euvi .
the dynamic evolution of the cme is characterized by a self - similar adiabatic expansion of a spherical cme shell , containing a bright front with density compression and a cavity with density rarefaction , satisfying mass conservation of the cme and ambient corona .
we forward - fitted this model to stereo / euvi observations of the cme event of 2008-mar-25 and obtained the following results : 1 .
the model is able to track the true 3d motion and expansion of the cme by stereoscopic triangulation and yields an acceleration of @xmath144 m s@xmath98 for both the vertical centroid motion and radial expansion during the first half hour after cme launch .
fitting the euv dimming region of the model to the data mostly constrains the coronal base density in the cme region ( @xmath145 @xmath123 ) and the density scale height , which was found to be super - hydrostatic by a factor of @xmath136 .
the average cme expansion speed during the first 10 minutes is approximately @xmath146 km s@xmath104 , similar to the propagation speeds measured for eit waves in the initial phase ( i.e. , @xmath147 km s@xmath104 , veronig et al . 2008 ; @xmath148 km s@xmath104 , long et al .
2008 ; @xmath149 km s@xmath104 , patsourakos et al . 2009 ) , and thus the cme expansion speed seems to be closely related to the associated propagation kinematics of eit waves .
the derived base density , scale height , and footpoint area constrain the cme mass , but accurate estimates require a more complete temperature coverage with other euv filters ( e.g. , see aschwanden et al .
2009b ) . 5 .
the width and density compression factor of the cme front are also constrained by our model , but accurate values require a perfectly homogeneous cme shell . 6 .
while the spherical shell geometry reproduces the euvi / a observations well , significant deviations are noted in the euvi / b observations , indicating substantial inhomogeneities in the cme shell , possibly requiring a hybrid model of bubble and flux rope geometries .
the most important conclusion of this modeling study is that euv dimming can be understood in a quantitative manner and that it provides a direct measurement of the coronal mass loss of a cme .
this exercise has shown that the spherical shell geometry can reproduce a number of observed features of an evolving cme , which constrains the physical and kinematic parameters of the initial phase of the cme launch , but reveals also significant deviations that require a modification of the idealized homogeneous spherical shell model .
the method of analytical 4d models with forward - fitting to stereoscopic euv images appears to be a promising tool to investigate quantitatively the kinematics of cmes . combining with simultaneous magnetic or mhd modeling
may further constrain the physical parameters and ultimately provide the capability to discriminate between different theoretical cme models .
full 4d modeling of the initial cme expansion may also provide a self - consistent treatment of eit waves and cme expansion ( e.g. , chen et al . 2005 ) , for which we find similar kinematic parameters .
this work is supported by the nasa stereo under nrl contract n00173 - 02-c-2035 .
the stereo/ secchi data used here are produced by an international consortium of the naval research laboratory ( usa ) , lockheed martin solar and astrophysics lab ( usa ) , nasa goddard space flight center ( usa ) , rutherford appleton laboratory ( uk ) , university of birmingham ( uk ) , max - planck - institut fr sonnensystemforschung ( germany ) , centre spatiale de lige ( belgium ) , institut doptique thorique et applique ( france ) , institute dastrophysique spatiale ( france ) . the usa institutions were funded by nasa ; the uk institutions by the science & technology facility council ( which used to be the particle physics and astronomy research council , pparc ) ; the german institutions by deutsches zentrum fr luft- und raumfahrt e.v .
( dlr ) ; the belgian institutions by belgian science policy office ; the french institutions by centre national detudes spatiales ( cnes ) , and the centre national de la recherche scientifique ( cnrs ) . the nrl effort was also supported by the usaf space test program and the office of naval research .
# 1 [ a]schwanden , m.j .
2004 , _ physics of the solar corona . an introduction _ , praxis : chichester / uk and springer : berlin .
[ a]schwanden , m.j . , fletcher , l. , schrijver , c. , & alexander , d. 1999 , apj 520 , 880 .
[ a]schwanden , m.j . and acton , l.w .
2001 , apj 550 , 475 .
[ a]schwanden , m.j . ,
nitta , n.v . ,
wuelser , j.p . , and lemen 2009a , 256 , 3 .
[ a]schwanden , m.j . , nitta , n.v . ,
wuelser , j.p . , lemen , j.r . ,
sandman , a. , vourlidas , a. , and colaninno , r. 2009b , apj ( subm ) .
[ b]ewsher , d. , harrison , r.a . , & brown , d.s .
2008 , a&a 478 , 897 .
[ b]yrne , j.p . ,
gallagher , p.t . ,
mcateer , r.t.j . , and young , c.a .
2009 , a&a 495 , 325 .
[ c]olaninno , r.c . and vourlidas , a. 2009 , apj ( in press ) [ g]opalswamy , n. & hanaoka , y. 1998 , apj 498 , l179 .
[ h]arrison , r.a .
1997 , proc .
31st eslab symp .
, correlated phenomena at the sun , in the heliosphere and in geospace , esa sp-415 , 121 .
[ h]arrison , r.a . &
lyons , m. 2000 , a&a 358 , 1097 .
[ h]arrison , r.a . , bryans , p. , simnett , g.m . , & lyons , m. 2003 , a&a 400 , 1071 .
[ i]nhester , b. 2006 , _ stereoscopy basics for the stereo mission _ , eprint arxiv : astro - ph/0612649 .
[ l]ong , d.m . ,
gallagher , p.t . ,
mcateer , r.t.j . , and bloomfield , d.s .
2008 , apj 680 , l81 .
[ l]ynch , b.j . ,
antiochos , s.k . ,
macneice , p.j . ,
zurbuchen , t.h . , and fisk , l.a .
2004 , apj 617 , 589 .
[ m]aloney , s.a . ,
gallagher , p.t . , and mcateer , r.t.j .
2009 , sp 256 , 149 .
[ m]ierla , m. , inhester , b. , marque , c . , rodriguez , l. , gissot , s. , zhukov , a.n .
, berghmans , d. , and davila j. 2009a , sp ( subm ) .
[ m]ierla , m. et al .
2009b , ann.geophys .
( in preparation ) .
[ p]atsourakos , s. and vourlidas , a. 2009 , apj 700 , l182 .
[ p]riest , e.r .
1982 , _ solar magnetohydrodynamics _ , geophysics and astrophysics monographs , vol .
21 , d. reidel publishing company , dordrecht , netherlands .
[ r]obbrecht , e. , patsourakos , s. , and vourlidas , a. 2009 , apj ( in press ) .
[ r]ust , d.m .
1983 , ssrv 34 , 21 .
[ s]terling , a.c . &
hudson , h.s .
1997 , apj 491 , l55 .
[ t]emmer , m. , preiss , s. , and veronig , a.m. 2009 , sp 256 , 183 .
[ t]hernisien , a. , vourlidas , a. , and howard , r.a .
2009 , sp ( in press ) .
[ v]eronig , a.m. , temmer , m. , and vrsnak , b. 2008 , apj 681 , l113 .
[ w]atanabe , t. , kozuka , y . ,
ohyama , m. , kojima , m. , yamaguchi , k. , watari , s.i . ,
tsuneta , s. , jeselyn , j.a . , harvey , k.l . ,
acton , l.w . , &
klimchuk j.a .
1992 , pasj 44 , l199 .
[ z]arro , d.m . , sterling , a.c . ,
thompson , b.j . ,
hudson , h.s .
, & nitta , n. 1999 , apj 520 , l139 .
[ z]hukov , a.n . and auchere , f. 2004 , 427 , 705 .
|
this is the first attempt to model the kinematics of a cme launch and the resulting euv dimming quantitatively with a self - consistent model .
our 4d - model assumes self - similar expansion of a spherical cme geometry that consists of a cme front with density compression and a cavity with density rarefaction , satisfying mass conservation of the total cme and swept - up corona .
the model contains 14 free parameters and is fitted to the 2008 march 25 cme event observed with stereo / a and b. our model is able to reproduce the observed cme expansion and related euv dimming during the initial phase from 18:30 ut to 19:00 ut .
the cme kinematics can be characterized by a constant acceleration ( i.e. , a constant magnetic driving force ) . while the observations of euvi / a are consistent with a spherical bubble geometry , we detect significant asymmetries and density inhomogeneities with euvi / b .
this new forward - modeling method demonstrates how the observed euv dimming can be used to model physical parameters of the cme source region , the cme geometry , and cme kinematics .
|
one of the fundamental problems in the classification of complex surfaces is to find a new family of complex surfaces of general type with @xmath0 . in this paper
we construct new simply connected _ numerical campedelli surfaces _ with an involution , i.e. simply connected minimal complex surfaces of general type with @xmath0 and @xmath1 , that have an automorphism of order @xmath5 .
there has been a growing interest for complex surfaces of general type with @xmath0 having an involution ; cf .
j. keum - y .
lee @xcite , calabri - ciliberto - mendes lopes @xcite , calabri - mendes lopes - pardini @xcite , y. lee - y .
shin @xcite , rito @xcite . a classification of _ numerical godeaux surfaces _
( i.e. minimal complex surfaces of general type with @xmath0 and @xmath2 ) with an involution is given in calabri - ciliberto - mendes lopes @xcite .
it is known that the quotient surface of a numerical godeaux surface by its involution is either rational or birational to an enriques surface , and the bicanonical map of the numerical godeaux surface factors through the quotient map .
however , the situation is more involved in the case of numerical campedelli surfaces , because the bicanonical map may not factor through the quotient map ; cf .
calabri - mendes lopes - pardini @xcite .
in particular it can happen that the quotient is of general type .
more precisely , let @xmath6 be a numerical campedelli surface with an involution @xmath7 . if @xmath7 has only fixed points and no fixed divisors , then the minimal resolution @xmath8 of the quotient @xmath9 is a numerical godeaux surface and @xmath7 has only four fixed points ; cf .
barlow @xcite .
conversely , if @xmath8 is of general type , then @xmath7 has only four fixed points and no fixed divisors ; calabri - mendes lopes - pardini @xcite .
there are some examples of numerical campedelli surfaces @xmath6 with an involution @xmath7 having only four fixed points .
barlow @xcite constructed examples with @xmath10 .
barlow @xcite also constructed examples with @xmath11 whose minimal resolution of the quotient by the involution is the first example of a _ simply connected _ numerical godeaux surface .
also all catanese s surfaces @xcite have such an involution and @xmath12 .
recently calabri , mendes lopes , and pardini @xcite constructed a numerical campedelli surface with torsion @xmath13 and two involutions .
frapporti @xcite showed that there exists an involution having only four fixed points on the numerical campedelli surface with @xmath14 constructed first in bauer - catanese - grunewald - pignatelli @xcite .
it is known that the orders of the algebraic fundamental groups of numerical campedelli surfaces are at most @xmath15 and the dihedral groups @xmath16 and @xmath17 can not be realized .
recently , the existence question for numerical campedelli surfaces with @xmath18 was settled by the construction of examples with @xmath19 ; frapporti @xcite and h. park - j .
shin @xcite .
hence it would be an interesting problem to construct numerical campedelli surfaces having an involution with @xmath20 for each given group @xmath21 with @xmath22 .
especially we are concerned with the simply connected case because the fundamental groups of all the known examples with an involution have large order : @xmath23 .
furthermore the first example of _ simply connected _ numerical campedelli surfaces is very recent ( y. lee - j .
park ) , but we have no information about the existence of an involution in their example . the main theorem of this paper is : there are simply connected minimal complex surfaces @xmath6 of general type with @xmath24 and @xmath25 which have an involution @xmath7 such that the minimal resolution @xmath8 of the quotient @xmath9 is a simply connected minimal complex surface of general type with @xmath26 and @xmath27 .
we also show that the minimal resolution @xmath8 of the quotient @xmath9 has a local deformation space of dimension @xmath28 corresponding to deformations @xmath29 of @xmath8 such that its general fiber @xmath30 is the minimal resolution of a quotient @xmath31 of a numerical campedelli surface @xmath32 by an involution @xmath33 ; theorem [ theorem : invariant - part ] .
in addition , we show that the resolution @xmath8 should be always simply connected if the double cover @xmath6 is already simply connected ; proposition [ proposition : simply - connected=>simply - connected ] . conversely barlow @xcite showed that if the resolution @xmath8 is a simply connected numerical godeaux surface then the possible order of the algebraic fundamental group of the double cover @xmath6 is @xmath34 , @xmath35 , @xmath36 , @xmath37 , or @xmath15 .
as far as we know , the example in barlow @xcite was the only one whose quotient is simply connected .
it has @xmath38 as mentioned earlier . here
we find an example with @xmath39 .
hence it would be an intriguing problem in this context to construct an example with @xmath40 . in order to construct the examples ,
we combine a double covering and a @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing method developed in y. lee - j . park .
first we build singular surfaces by blowing up points and then contracting curves over a specific rational elliptic surface .
these singular surfaces differ by contracting certain @xmath41-curves .
if we contract all of the @xmath41-curves , we obtain a stable surface @xmath42 in the sense of kollr shepherd - barron @xcite , and we prove that the space of @xmath3-gorenstein deformations of @xmath42 is smooth and @xmath43 dimensional ; proposition [ propsotion : stable - godeaux ] . a ( @xmath3-gorenstein )
smoothing of @xmath42 in this space produces simply connected numerical godeaux surfaces .
in particular , the smoothing of @xmath42 gives the existence of a two dimensional family of simply connected numerical godeaux surfaces with six @xmath41-curves ; corollary [ corollary : six ] .
we also prove that a four dimensional family in this space produces simply connected numerical godeaux surfaces with a @xmath5-divisible divisor consisting of four disjoint @xmath41-curves ; theorem [ theorem : q - smoothing - of - y ] and theorem [ theorem : invariant - part ] .
these numerical godeaux surfaces are used to construct the numerical campedelli surfaces with an involution .
the desired numerical campedelli surfaces are obtained by taking double coverings of the numerical godeaux surfaces branched along the four disjoint @xmath41-curves ; theorem [ theorem : campedelli ] .
on the other hand we can also obtain the campedelli family explicitly from a singular stable surface @xmath44 .
it comes from blowing up points and contracting curves over a certain rational elliptic surface ; proposition [ proposition : campexplicit ] .
the @xmath3-gorenstein space of deformations of @xmath44 is smooth and @xmath45 dimensional ; proposition [ proposition : stable - campedelli ] . in both godeaux and campedelli cases
we compute @xmath46 to show no local - to - global obstruction to deform them ; theorem [ theorem : h2(ty)=0 ] and theorem [ theorem : h2(tx)=0 ] .
this involves a new technique ( theorem [ theorem : burns - wahl ] ) which generalizes a result of burns - wahl @xcite describing the space of first order deformations of a singular complex surface with only rational double points . a cyclic quotient singularity ( germ at @xmath47 of ) @xmath48 , where @xmath49 with @xmath50 a @xmath51-th primitive root of @xmath34 , @xmath52 , and @xmath53 , is denoted by @xmath54 .
@xmath55 means @xmath56 .
a @xmath57-curve ( or @xmath41-curve ) in a smooth surface is an embedded @xmath58 with self - intersection @xmath59 ( respectively , @xmath60 ) . throughout this paper
we use the same letter to denote a curve and its proper transform under a birational map .
a singularity of class @xmath61 is a quotient singularity which admits a @xmath3-gorenstein one parameter smoothing .
they are either rational double points or @xmath62 with @xmath63 and @xmath64 ; see kollr
shepherd - barron @xcite . for a normal variety
@xmath6 its tangent sheaf @xmath65 is @xmath66 .
the dimension of @xmath67 is @xmath68 .
the authors would like to thank professor yongnam lee for helpful discussion during the work , careful reading of the draft version , and many valuable comments .
the authors also wish to thank professor jenia tevelev for indicating a mistake in an earlier version of this paper , and the referee especially for the remark on the proof of proposition 3.7 which makes it simpler .
heesang park was supported by basic science research program through the national research foundation of korea ( nrf ) grant funded by the korean government ( 2011 - 0012111 ) .
dongsoo shin was supported by basic science research program through the national research foundation of korea ( nrf ) grant funded by the korean government ( 2010 - 0002678 ) .
giancarlo urza was supported by a fondecyt inicio grant funded by the chilean government ( 11110047 ) .
in this section we construct a family of simply connected numerical godeaux surfaces having a @xmath5-divisible divisor consisting of four disjoint @xmath41-curves by smoothing a singular surface @xmath69 ; theorem [ theorem : q - smoothing - of - y ] .
this is the key to construct numerical campedelli surfaces with an involution .
in addition , we describe the explicit stable model of the singular surface @xmath69 .
in fact , we construct a rational normal projective surface @xmath42 with four singularities @xmath70 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 and @xmath73 ample . hence @xmath42 is a stable surface ( cf .
kollr - shepherd - barron @xcite , hacking @xcite ) .
we will prove that the versal @xmath3-gorenstein deformation space @xmath74 ( cf .
hacking @xcite ) is smooth and @xmath43 dimensional , and that the @xmath3-gorenstein smoothings of @xmath42 are simply connected numerical godeaux surfaces . in particular , this shows that there are simply connected numerical godeaux surfaces whose canonical model has precisely two @xmath70 singularities ; corollary [ corollary : godeaux ] .
furthermore a four dimensional family in @xmath74 produces the above simply connected numerical godeaux surfaces with a @xmath5-divisible divisor consisting of four disjoint @xmath41-curves ; theorem [ theorem : q - smoothing - of - y ] and theorem [ theorem : invariant - part ] .
we start with a rational elliptic surface @xmath75 with an @xmath76-singular fiber , an @xmath77-singular fiber , and two nodal singular fibers .
in fact we will use the same rational elliptic surface @xmath75 in the papers h. park - j .
shin @xcite . however , we need to sketch the construction of @xmath75 to show the relevant curves that will be used to build the singular surfaces @xmath69 and @xmath42 .
let @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 , and @xmath81 be lines in @xmath82 and let @xmath83 be a smooth conic in @xmath82 given by the following equations .
they intersect as in figure [ figure : pencil ] .
@xmath84 we consider the pencil of cubics @xmath85 \in \mathbb{cp}^1 \}\ ] ] generated by the two cubic curves @xmath86 and @xmath87 .
this pencil has four base points @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 , and four singular members corresponding to @xmath92=[1:0 ] , [ 0:1 ] , [ 2:3\sqrt{3 } ] , [ 2:-3\sqrt{3}]$ ] .
the latter two singular members are nodal curves , denoted by @xmath93 and @xmath94 respectively .
they have nodes at @xmath95 $ ] and @xmath96 $ ] , respectively . in order to obtain a rational elliptic surface @xmath75 from the pencil
, we resolve all base points ( including infinitely near base - points ) of the pencil by blowing - up @xmath15 times as follows .
we first blow up at the points @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 .
let @xmath97 , @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 be the exceptional divisors over @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 , respectively .
we blow up again at the three points @xmath101 , @xmath102 , @xmath103 .
let @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath106 be the exceptional divisors over the intersection points , respectively .
we finally blow up at each intersection points @xmath107 and @xmath108 .
let @xmath109 and @xmath110 be the exceptional divisors over the blown - up points .
we then get a rational elliptic surface @xmath111 over @xmath58 ; see figure [ figure : e ] . the four exceptional curves @xmath100 , @xmath106 , @xmath109 , @xmath110 are sections of the elliptic fibration @xmath75 , which correspond to the four base points @xmath91 , @xmath90 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 , respectively .
the elliptic fibration @xmath75 has one @xmath76-singular fiber @xmath112 containing all @xmath113 ( @xmath114 ) : @xmath115 , @xmath116 , and @xmath117 ; cf .
figure [ figure : e ] .
we will use frequently the sum @xmath118 , which will be shown to be @xmath5-divisible .
the surface @xmath75 has also one @xmath77-singular fiber consisting of @xmath81 and @xmath83 , and it has two more nodal singular fibers @xmath93 and @xmath94 . ]
there is a special bisection on @xmath75 .
let @xmath119 be the line in @xmath82 passing through the point @xmath120 $ ] and the two nodes @xmath95 $ ] and @xmath96 $ ] of @xmath93 and @xmath94 .
since @xmath119 meets every member in the pencil at three points but it passes through only one base point , the proper transform of @xmath119 is a bisection of the elliptic fibration @xmath121 ; cf .
figure [ figure : e ] .
note that @xmath122 in @xmath75 .
let @xmath123 be the class of the pull - back of a line in @xmath82 .
we denote again by @xmath124 the class of the pull - back of the exceptional divisor @xmath125 .
we have the following linear equivalences of divisors in @xmath75 : @xmath126 let @xmath127 .
note that the divisor @xmath118 is @xmath5-divisible because of the relation @xmath128 in the construction of @xmath130 , we use only one section @xmath131 .
we first blow up at the two nodes of the nodal singular fibers @xmath93 and @xmath94 so that we obtain a blown - up rational elliptic surface @xmath132 ; figure [ figure : w ] .
let @xmath133 and @xmath134 be the exceptional curves over the nodes of @xmath93 and @xmath94 , respectively .
we further blow up at each three marked points @xmath135 in figure [ figure : w ] , and we blow up twice at the marked point @xmath136 ( that is , we first blow - up @xmath136 and then again on the intersection point of the section and the exceptional curve ; see figure [ figure : z ] ) .
we then get @xmath137 as in figure [ figure : z ] .
there exist two linear chains of the @xmath58 in @xmath130 whose dual graphs are given by : @xmath138 where @xmath139 consists of @xmath81 , @xmath8 , @xmath93 , @xmath133 , and @xmath140 contains @xmath94 , @xmath134 , @xmath119 . ] ] we construct rational singular surfaces which produce under @xmath3-gorenstein smoothings simply connected surfaces of general type with @xmath0 and @xmath2 .
we first contract the two chains @xmath139 and @xmath140 of @xmath58 s from the surface @xmath130 so that we have a normal projective surface @xmath69 with two singularities @xmath141 , @xmath142 of class @xmath61 : @xmath143 .
denote the contraction morphism by @xmath144 .
let @xmath145 be the surface obtained by contracting the four @xmath41-curves @xmath146 in @xmath69 .
we denote the contraction morphism by @xmath147 .
then @xmath145 is also a normal projective surface with singularities @xmath141 , @xmath142 from @xmath69 , and four @xmath148 s ( ordinary double points ) , denoted by @xmath149 .
we finally contract @xmath139 , @xmath140 , @xmath150 and @xmath151 in @xmath130 to obtain @xmath42 .
it has the singularities @xmath152 , and two @xmath153 s .
let @xmath154 be the contraction . in section [ section : obstruction ] we will prove that the obstruction spaces to local - to - global deformations of the singular surfaces @xmath69 , @xmath145 and @xmath42 vanish . that is : [ theorem : h2(ty)=0 ] @xmath155 , @xmath156 , and @xmath157 . the singular surface @xmath42 is the stable model of the singular surfaces @xmath69 and
@xmath145 : [ propsotion : stable - godeaux ] the surface @xmath42 has @xmath158 , @xmath159 , and @xmath73 is ample .
the space @xmath74 is smooth and @xmath43 dimensional .
a @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing of @xmath42 is a simply connected canonical surface of general type with @xmath0 and @xmath2 . for a surface @xmath42 with only singularities of type @xmath61
we have @xmath160 where @xmath161 is the number of exceptional curves over @xmath88 and @xmath162 is the milnor number of @xmath88 . in our case , @xmath163 .
we have @xmath164 because of the rationality of the singularities .
we now compute @xmath165 in a @xmath3-numerically effective way .
let @xmath166 be the general fiber of the elliptic fibration in @xmath130 .
let @xmath167 , @xmath168 , @xmath169 be the exceptional curves over @xmath170 , @xmath171 , @xmath172 respectively .
let @xmath173 , @xmath174 be the exceptional curves over @xmath175 with @xmath176 . then , @xmath177 .
we also have @xmath178 .
writing @xmath179 in @xmath180 and adding the discrepancies from @xmath141 and @xmath142 , we obtain @xmath181 we now intersect @xmath165 with all the curves in its support , which are not contracted by @xmath182 , to check that @xmath73 is nef . moreover , if @xmath183 for a curve @xmath184 not contracted by @xmath182 , then @xmath184 is a component of a fiber in the elliptic fibration which does not intersect any curve in the support .
this is because @xmath93 , @xmath133 , @xmath167 , and @xmath168 belong to the support , and they are the components of a fiber .
one easily checks that @xmath184 does not exist , proving that @xmath73 is ample .
therefore any @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing of @xmath42 over a ( small ) disk will produce canonical surfaces ; cf .
kollr - mori @xcite . to compute the fundamental group of a @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing we use the recipe in y. lee - j .
we follow the argument as in y. lee - j .
consider the normal circles around @xmath119 and @xmath133 .
we can compare them through the transversal sphere @xmath167 .
since the orders of the circles are @xmath185 and @xmath186 , which are coprime , we obtain that both end up being trivial .
the smoothness of @xmath74 follows from theorem [ theorem : h2(ty)=0 ] and hacking @xcite . to compute the dimension
, we observe that if @xmath187 is a @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing of @xmath188 and @xmath189 is the dual of @xmath190 , then @xmath189 restricts to @xmath191 as @xmath192 ( tangent bundle of @xmath191 ) when @xmath193 , and @xmath194 with cokernel supported at the singular points of @xmath195 ; cf .
wahl @xcite .
then the flatness of @xmath189 and semicontinuity in cohomology plus the fact that @xmath196 gives @xmath197 for any @xmath198 .
but then , since @xmath191 is of general type , hirzebruch - riemann - roch theorem says @xmath199 this proves the claim .
[ corollary : godeaux ] there is a two dimensional family of simply connected canonical numerical godeaux surfaces with two @xmath70 singularities .
[ corollary : six ] we consider the sequence @xmath200 at the end of hacking @xcite . we just proved that @xmath201 is @xmath43 dimensional , and we know that @xmath202 is @xmath43 dimensional , since each @xmath70 gives @xmath35 dimensions and each @xmath203 gives @xmath34 dimension
. therefore @xmath204 . to produce the claimed family we need to smooth up at the same time @xmath141 and @xmath142 .
a simply connected numerical godeaux surfaces with a @xmath5-divisible divisor consisting of four disjoint @xmath41-curves is obtained from a @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing of the singular surface @xmath69 : [ theorem : q - smoothing - of - y ] a. there is a @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing @xmath205 over a disk @xmath206 with central fiber @xmath207 and an effective divisor @xmath208 such that the restriction to a fiber @xmath209 over @xmath210 @xmath211 is @xmath5-divisible in @xmath209 consisting of four disjoint @xmath41-curves and @xmath212 .
b. there is a @xmath3-gorenstein deformation @xmath213 of @xmath145 with central fiber @xmath214 such that a fiber @xmath215 over @xmath216 has four ordinary double points as its only singularities and the minimal resolution of @xmath215 is the corresponding fiber @xmath209 of @xmath217 . we apply a similar method in y. lee - j . park @xcite .
since any local deformations of the singularities of @xmath145 can be globalized by theorem [ theorem : h2(ty)=0 ] , there are @xmath3-gorenstein deformations of @xmath145 over a disk @xmath206 which keep all four ordinary double points and smooth up @xmath141 and @xmath142 .
let @xmath218 be such deformation , with @xmath145 as its central fiber , and @xmath219 ( @xmath216 ) a normal projective surface with four @xmath148s as its only singularities .
we resolve simultaneously these four singularities in each fiber @xmath219 .
we then get a family @xmath217 that is a @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing of the central fiber @xmath69 , which shows that a @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing of @xmath145 can be lifted to a @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing of the pair @xmath220 , i.e. the @xmath5-divisible divisor @xmath221 on @xmath69 is extended to an effective divisor @xmath208 . we finally show that the effective divisor @xmath222 is 2-divisible in @xmath209 for @xmath216 . according to manetti ( * ? ? ? * lemma 2 ) , the natural restriction map @xmath223 is injective for every @xmath210 and bijective for @xmath224 .
here we are using that @xmath225 . since the divisor @xmath221 is nonsingular , @xmath226 is also nonsingular . since @xmath227 in
, it follows that @xmath228 , where @xmath229 is extended to a line bundle @xmath230 and @xmath231 is the corresponding restriction .
the main purpose of this section is to construct simply connected numerical campedelli surfaces with an involution . along the way
, we will introduce a rational normal projective surface @xmath44 with @xmath45 singularities ( two @xmath148 , two @xmath232 , and two @xmath72 ) and @xmath233 ample .
a certain four dimensional @xmath3-gorenstein deformation of @xmath44 will produce numerical campedelli surfaces with an involution .
recall that the rational surface @xmath130 has a @xmath5-divisible divisor @xmath118 ; cf . .
let @xmath234 be the double cover of @xmath130 branched along the divisor @xmath221 , where the double cover is given by the data @xmath227 , @xmath235 .
we denote the double covering by @xmath236 .
the surface @xmath234 has two @xmath139 s and two @xmath140 s . on the other hand
the surface @xmath234 can be obtained from a certain rational elliptic surface by blowing - ups , as we now explain .
the morphism @xmath237 blows down to a double cover @xmath238 branched along @xmath221 .
the ramification divisor @xmath239 consists of four disjoint @xmath57-curves @xmath240 .
we blow down them from @xmath241 to obtain a surface @xmath242 ; cf .
figure [ figure : e ] . in figure
[ figure : e ] the pull - back of the @xmath243 are the @xmath244 , of the curve @xmath81 is @xmath245 , of the section @xmath8 is @xmath246 , and of the double section @xmath119 is @xmath247 .
each @xmath77 in @xmath242 is the pull - back of each @xmath248 in @xmath75 . ]
note that the surface @xmath242 has an elliptic fibration structure with two @xmath249-singular fibers and two @xmath77-singular fibers .
in fact , the surface @xmath242 can be obtained from the pencil of cubics in @xmath82 @xmath250 \in \mathbb{cp}^1 \}\ ] ] where the @xmath249-singular fibers come from @xmath251 and @xmath252 , and the @xmath77-singular fibers come from @xmath253 and @xmath254 .
the two double sections @xmath255 and @xmath256 are defined by the lines @xmath257 and @xmath258 . in summary : [ proposition : campexplicit ] the surface @xmath241 is the blow - up at four nodes of one @xmath249-singular fiber of the rational elliptic fibration @xmath259 .
hence the surface @xmath234 can be obtained from @xmath241 by blowing - up in the obvious way .
let @xmath260 be the double cover of the singular surface @xmath69 branched along the divisor @xmath221 .
note that the surface @xmath260 is a normal projective surface with four singularities of class @xmath61 whose resolution graphs consist of two @xmath139 s and two @xmath140 s .
the ramification divisor in @xmath260 consists of the four disjoint @xmath57-curves @xmath261 .
let @xmath262 be the double covering .
on the other hand the surface @xmath260 can be obtained from the rational surface @xmath234 by contracting the two @xmath139 s and two @xmath140 s .
let @xmath263 be the contraction morphism .
let @xmath6 be the surface obtained by blowing down the four @xmath57-curves @xmath240 from @xmath260 .
we denote the blowing - down morphism by @xmath264 . then there is a double covering @xmath265 branched along the four ordinary double points @xmath149 .
finally , let @xmath44 be the contraction of the @xmath41-curves @xmath266 and @xmath267 in @xmath6 .
let @xmath268 be the contraction .
we then get a double covering @xmath269 . to sum up
, we have the following commutative diagram : @xmath270 \ar[d]^{\psi ' } & v \ar[l ] \ar[d]^{\psi } \ar[r]^{\widetilde{\beta } } & \widetilde{x } \ar[d]^{\widetilde{\phi } } \ar[r]^{\beta } & x \ar[d]^{\phi } \ar[r ] & x ' \ar[d]\\ & e(1 ) & \ar[l ] z \ar[r]^{\widetilde{\alpha } } & \widetilde{y } \ar[r]^{\alpha } & y \ar[r ] & y'}\ ] ] we will show in section [ section : obstruction ] the obstruction spaces to local - to - global deformations of the singular surfaces @xmath260 , @xmath6 and @xmath44 vanish : [ theorem : h2(tx)=0 ] @xmath271 , @xmath272 , and @xmath273 .
the singular surface @xmath44 is the stable model of @xmath260 and @xmath6 : [ proposition : stable - campedelli ] the surface @xmath44 has @xmath274 , @xmath275 , and @xmath233 ample .
the space @xmath276 is smooth and @xmath45 dimensional .
a @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing of @xmath44 is a simply connected canonical surface of general type with @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
the proof goes as the one for @xmath42 in proposition [ propsotion : stable - godeaux ] , using the explicit model we have for @xmath234 by blowing - up @xmath242 in proposition [ proposition : campexplicit ] .
one can check that an intersection computation as in proposition [ propsotion : stable - godeaux ] verifies ampleness for @xmath233 .
the proof of the next main result follows easily from theorem [ theorem : q - smoothing - of - y ] .
[ theorem : campedelli ] there exist @xmath3-gorenstein smoothings @xmath277 of @xmath260 and @xmath278 of @xmath6 that are compatible with the @xmath3-gorenstein deformations of @xmath279 of @xmath69 and @xmath218 of @xmath145 in theorem [ theorem : q - smoothing - of - y ] , respectively ; that is , the double coverings @xmath280 and @xmath265 extend to the double coverings @xmath281 and @xmath282 between the fibers of the @xmath3-gorenstein deformations . by theorem [ theorem : h2(tx)=0 ] , the obstruction @xmath283 to local - to - global deformations of the singular surface @xmath6 vanishes .
the point of the above theorem is that there is a @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing of the cover @xmath6 that is compatible with the @xmath3-gorenstein deformation of the base @xmath145 .
[ corollary : campedelli - with - involution ] a general fiber @xmath32 of the @xmath3-gorenstein smoothing @xmath278 of @xmath6 is a simply connected numerical campedelli surface with an involution @xmath33 such that the minimal resolution of the quotient @xmath284 is a simply connected numerical godeaux surface .
let @xmath6 be a minimal complex surface of general type with @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
suppose that the group @xmath4 acts on @xmath6 with just @xmath28 fixed points .
let @xmath285 be the quotient and let @xmath286 be the minimal resolution of @xmath145 .
barlow ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 1.3 ) proved that if @xmath287 then @xmath288 .
conversely : [ proposition : simply - connected=>simply - connected ] if @xmath6 is simply connected , then so is @xmath8 .
let @xmath289 be the quotient map .
then @xmath290 is a double covering which is branched along the four ordinary double points of @xmath145 .
let @xmath291 be the complement of the four branch points ( i.e. , the four @xmath148-singularities ) of @xmath145 and let @xmath292 , that is , @xmath293 is the complement of the four fixed points of the involution @xmath7 .
then we get an tale double covering @xmath294 .
since @xmath295 , we have @xmath296 .
note that the boundary @xmath297 of an arbitrary small neighborhood @xmath298 of one of the four nodes of @xmath145 is a lens space @xmath299 .
let @xmath300 $ ] be a generator of @xmath301 represented by a loop @xmath302 contained in @xmath297 .
since the lifting of @xmath302 by the covering @xmath294 is not a closed path and @xmath303 , @xmath304 is generated by @xmath300 $ ] .
then it follows by van kampen theorem that @xmath305 is trivial .
hence @xmath306 is trivial because @xmath8 is obtained from @xmath145 by resolving only four @xmath148-singularities .
in this section we prove theorem [ theorem : h2(ty)=0 ] which says that the obstruction spaces to local - to - global deformations of the singular surfaces @xmath69 , @xmath145 , and @xmath42 vanish .
that is , we will prove that @xmath307 . at the end , we also prove the analogues , theorem [ theorem : h2(tx)=0 ] , for @xmath260 , @xmath6 , and @xmath44 . at first
the vanishing of the obstruction spaces of a singular surface can be proved by the vanishing of the second cohomologies of a certain logarithmic tangent sheaf on the minimal resolution of the singular surface : [ proposition : lee - park - log ] if @xmath308 be the minimal resolution of a normal projective surface @xmath8 with only quotient singularities , and @xmath309 is the reduced exceptional divisor of the resolution @xmath310 , then @xmath311 .
[ proposition : flenner - zaidenberg ] let @xmath61 be a nonsingular surface and let @xmath309 be a simple normal crossing divisor in @xmath61 .
let @xmath312 be the blow - up of @xmath61 at a point @xmath88 of @xmath309 .
let @xmath313 .
then @xmath314 .
we can add or remove disjoint @xmath57-curves .
[ add - delete ] let @xmath61 be a nonsingular surface and let @xmath309 be a simple normal crossing divisor in @xmath61 .
let @xmath315 be a @xmath57-curve in @xmath61 such that @xmath316 is again simple normal crossing
. then @xmath317 .
we can also add or remove disjoint exceptional divisors of rational double points .
the following theorem may give a new general way to prove unobstructedness for deformations of surfaces .
[ theorem : burns - wahl ] let @xmath8 be a normal projective surface with only rational double points @xmath318 as singularities .
let @xmath319 be the minimal resolution of @xmath8 with exceptional reduced divisor @xmath320 .
let @xmath321 be a simple normal crossing divisor such that @xmath322 . then @xmath323 .
let @xmath324 and @xmath325 be the prime decompositions of @xmath119 and @xmath321 .
we have three short exact sequences : @xmath326 we then have the following commutative diagram of cohomologies : @xmath327 & 0 \ar[d ] & & \\ 0 \ar[r ] & h^1(\sheaf{t_{\widetilde{s}}}(-\log(c+m ) ) ) \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & h^1(\sheaf{t_{\widetilde{s}}}(-\log{c } ) ) \ar[r]^{\phi } \ar[d]^{\xi } & \oplus h^1(\sheaf{n_{m_i/{\widetilde{s } } } } ) \ar@{=}[d ] & \\ 0 \ar[r ] & h^1(\sheaf{t_{\widetilde{s}}}(-\log{m } ) ) \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & h^1(\sheaf{t_{\widetilde{s } } } ) \ar[r]^{\psi } \ar[d]^{\zeta } & \oplus h^1(\sheaf{n_{m_i/{\widetilde{s } } } } ) \ar[r ] & 0\\ & \oplus h^1(\sheaf{n_{c_i/{\widetilde{s } } } } ) \ar@{=}[r ] & \oplus h^1(\sheaf{n_{c_i/{\widetilde{s } } } } ) & & } } \ ] ] here all horizontal and vertical sequences are exact .
especially the second row is a short exact sequence , which we explain now briefly : it is shown in burns - wahl @xcite ( see also wahl @xcite ) that the composition @xmath328 is an isomorphism because the @xmath329 s are _ rational double points _ ; hence , one has a direct sum decomposition @xmath330 and an isomorphism @xmath331 .
therefore the second row is exact . in order to prove the assertion ,
it is enough to show that @xmath332 is surjective .
let @xmath333 .
since @xmath334 is surjective , we have @xmath335 for some @xmath336 .
by we have @xmath337 for some @xmath338 and @xmath339 such that @xmath182 is mapped to @xmath340 under the composition @xmath341 . since @xmath182 is supported on @xmath119 and @xmath342 , its image @xmath343 under @xmath344 vanishes .
therefore @xmath345 , and so @xmath346 for some @xmath347 ; hence , @xmath348 , which shows that @xmath349 is surjective .
[ proposition : e - v - sequence ] let @xmath350 be a simple normal crossing divisor on a smooth surface @xmath61 . then one has the following exact sequences : a. @xmath351
. b. @xmath352 .
we first claim that @xmath353 by duality , we have to show that @xmath354 since @xmath355 , it follows by proposition [ proposition : e - v - sequence ] that @xmath356 hence it suffices to show that @xmath357 . on the other hand
, we obtain a long exact sequence from proposition [ proposition : e - v - sequence ] : @xmath358 since @xmath359 , it is enough to show that the connecting homomorphism @xmath360 is injective .
note the map @xmath360 is the first chern class map .
but @xmath93 and @xmath133 are linearly independent in the picard group of @xmath361 ; hence , the map @xmath360 is injective .
therefore the claim follows .
let @xmath362 .
by theorem [ theorem : burns - wahl ] we have @xmath363 we use propositions [ add - delete ] and [ proposition : flenner - zaidenberg ] to obtain @xmath364 where @xmath365 . in this way
, it follows by the above claim that @xmath366 then , by proposition [ proposition : lee - park - log ] , we have @xmath367 .
notice we can modify @xmath368 to obtain vanishing for @xmath369 and @xmath370 as well .
we now prove that @xmath371 .
we will use our explicit model of @xmath44 in proposition [ proposition : campexplicit ] .
the proof goes along the same lines as the proof of the above theorem [ theorem : h2(ty)=0 ] .
we may only need to mention that we start with the elliptic fibration @xmath242 , and @xmath5 @xmath77 fibers ( instead of @xmath5 @xmath248 s ) .
the involution of a general fiber @xmath32 induced by the double covering @xmath282 extends to a @xmath4-action on the deformation space of @xmath32 .
we will count the dimension of the subspace of @xmath372 which is fixed by the @xmath4-action ; theorem [ theorem : invariant - part ] .
let @xmath373 be the minimal resolution and let @xmath374 be the blowing - up at the four ramification points .
we then have the following commutative diagram where the vertical morphisms are double covers : @xmath375^{\beta_t } \ar[d]_{\widetilde{\phi}_t } & x_t \ar[d]^{\phi_t } \\
\widetilde{y}_t \ar[r]^{\alpha_t } & y_t } \ ] ] recall that the branch divisor @xmath222 of the double covering @xmath376 consists of four disjoint @xmath41-curves @xmath377 and the corresponding ramification divisor @xmath378 consists of four disjoint @xmath57-curves @xmath379 . as
before the involution of @xmath380 induced by the double covering @xmath281 extends to a @xmath4-action on the deformation space of @xmath380 .
[ lemma : invariant ] @xmath381 . by pardini (
* lemma 4.2 ) , the invariant part of @xmath382 under the @xmath4-action is @xmath383 .
therefore we have @xmath384 we know that @xmath385 , where @xmath386 defines the double cover @xmath387 . therefore @xmath388 by theorem [ proposition : stable - campedelli ]
. then we have @xmath389 .
hence , by proposition [ proposition : e - v - sequence ] , there is a short exact sequence @xmath390 since @xmath222 consists of four disjoint @xmath41-curves , we have @xmath391 . by proposition
[ propsotion : stable - godeaux ] , we know that @xmath392 . therefore @xmath393 .
[ theorem : invariant - part ] the subspace of the deformation space of @xmath32 invariant under the @xmath4-action is four dimensional . we apply a similar strategy in werner @xcite .
we have the exact sequence @xmath394 since each @xmath395 is a @xmath57-curve , we have @xmath396 . on the other hand , it follows by catanese ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 9.22 ) that @xmath397 where @xmath398 is the ideal sheaf of the four points in @xmath32 obtained by contacting the exceptional divisors @xmath399 .
let @xmath400 be the set of these four points . from the ideal sequence
, we have @xmath401 therefore the invariant parts of each space satisfies : @xmath402 according to werner @xcite , we have @xmath403 .
therefore it follows by and lemma [ lemma : invariant ] that @xmath404
we briefly describe another rational surface @xmath130 which makes it possible to construct simply connected numerical campedelli surfaces with an involution as before .
the associated godeaux surfaces come from a rational surface @xmath42 with @xmath73 ample having three @xmath148-singularities , one @xmath70-singularity , and only one singularity of class @xmath61 .
the elliptic fibration @xmath75 is the one in section [ section : godeaux ] . in the construction of @xmath130
, we will use the sections @xmath100 , @xmath106 , @xmath109 among the four sections of @xmath75 .
we denote the sections @xmath100 , @xmath106 , @xmath109 by @xmath406 , @xmath407 , @xmath408 , respectively .
we first blow up at the two nodes of the nodal singular fibers @xmath93 and @xmath94 so that we obtain a blown - up rational elliptic surface @xmath409 ; figure [ figure : w-2 ] .
let @xmath133 and @xmath134 be the exceptional curves over the nodes of @xmath93 and @xmath94 , respectively .
we further blow up at each two marked points @xmath135 and blow up four times at the marked point @xmath136 in figure [ figure : w-2 ] .
we then get a rational surface @xmath410 ; figure [ figure : z-2 ] .
there exists one linear chain of @xmath58s in @xmath130 whose dual graph is @xmath411 notice that the @xmath57-curve @xmath408 is contracted in the way down , which fixes the configuration so that we obtain one singular point of class @xmath61 whose resolution graph is given by @xmath412 the divisor @xmath413 is the @xmath5-divisible one as before .
the @xmath414 and the @xmath41-curves @xmath415 , @xmath416 , @xmath151 , and @xmath119 are contracted to obtain a singular surface @xmath42 .
one can use again theorem [ theorem : burns - wahl ] to show that the space @xmath74 is smooth ( of dimension @xmath43 ) .
|
we construct a simply connected minimal complex surface of general type with @xmath0 and @xmath1 which has an involution such that the minimal resolution of the quotient by the involution is a simply connected minimal complex surface of general type with @xmath0 and @xmath2 . in order to construct the example
, we combine a double covering and @xmath3-gorenstein deformation . especially , we develop a method for proving unobstructedness for deformations of a singular surface by generalizing a result of burns and wahl which characterizes the space of first order deformations of a singular surface with only rational double points .
we describe the stable model in the sense of kollr and shepherd - barron of the singular surfaces used for constructing the example .
we count the dimension of the invariant part of the deformation space of the example under the induced @xmath4-action .
|
supersymmetry ( susy ) is one of the most attractive extensions of the standard model .
this symmetry solves the naturalness problem and predicts gauge coupling unification at the gut scale @xmath1 .
it also predicts the existence of superpartner of the standard model ( sm ) particles . from the naturalness argument , their masses should be below tev range , hence these particles will be discovered at tevatron or large hadron collider ( lhc )
. mechanisms of susy breaking and its mediation to the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) sector are one of the most important problems in the susy phenomenology . in many models ,
this dynamics is related to high energy physics far above the electroweak(ew ) scale , e.g. , gut scale or planck scale .
once the mechanism is specified , mass spectrum and flavor structure of susy particle at the ew scale can be determined by a small number of parameters .
hence it may be possible to confirm or exclude the mechanism by direct search or flavor - changing - neutral - current ( fcnc ) experiments in near future .
if susy breaking is mediated by gravity , the structure of susy breaking masses of scalars are determined by khler potential . in the present paper ,
we focus on the no - scale type khler potential , in which the hidden sector and the observable sector are separated as follows : @xmath2 where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are hidden sector fields and observable sector fields , respectively
. this type of khler potential is originally investigated in ref .
@xcite with @xmath5 and @xmath6 .
characteristic features of the khler potential eq.([eq : noscalekahler ] ) is that all scalar masses and trilinear scalar couplings ( a - terms ) vanish as the cosmological constant vanishes@xcite .
the only source of susy breaking is gaugino masses .
hence this scenario is highly predictive , various phenomenological consequences are obtained with a few parameters . the separation in eq.([eq : noscalekahler ] ) implies that couplings of the hidden sector and the observable sector is flavor blind , and contributions of susy particles to fcnc are suppressed .
therefore this khler potential is also interesting from the viewpoint of the susy flavor problem .
the no - scale structure of the khler potential is obtained in various models .
it has been shown that in some classes of string theory , for example weakly coupled @xmath7 heterotic string theory , khler potential becomes the no - scale type@xcite . if the hidden sector and the observable sector are separated in the superspace density in the supergravity lagrangian , the khler potential is indeed given as in eq .
( [ eq : noscalekahler ] ) . in the two cases ,
the gaugino masses can be induced if the hidden sector fields couple to the gauge multiplets via the gauge kinetic function .
recently it has been pointed out that the form eq.([eq : noscalekahler ] ) is realized naturally in a five - dimensional setting with two branes , namely , sequestered sector scenario@xcite . in this scenario ,
the hidden sector fields live on one brane and the visible sector fields live on the other .
it has been shown that the form of the khler potential of the effective theory obtained by dimensional reduction is indeed eq.([eq : noscalekahler])@xcite .
if the sm gauge fields dwell in the bulk , gaugino mediate the susy breaking on the hidden sector brane to the visible sector brane and the no - scale boundary condition is given at the compactification scale of the fifth dimension ( gaugino mediation @xcite ) . in the no - scale scenario , degrees of freedom of susy particle mass spectrum
is limited because only non - zero soft susy breaking masses are gaugino masses and higgs mixing mass @xmath8 at the energy scale where the boundary condition is given . hence phenomenological aspects of this scenario have been investigated in the literature , mainly focusing on the mass spectrum .
direct search bounds and the cosmological constraint ( i.e. , a charged particle can not be the lsp if the r - parity is conserved ) were considered and allowed region in the parameter space was identified . for the boundary condition ,
the following three cases were considered .
first , universal gaugino masses are given at the gut scale .
in this case , the cosmological constraint is severe and only the region @xmath9 and @xmath10 is allowed since stau tends to be light@xcite .
the second case is that universal gaugino masses are given above the gut scale .
and the third case is that non - universal gaugino masses are given at the gut scale . in this case wino ,
higgsino or sneutrino can be the lsp . in the latter two cases ,
it is shown that the cosmological constraint is not severer than the first case . in the present paper ,
current limits from the lightest higgs mass @xmath11 and the branching ratio for @xmath0 are also used to constrain the no - scale scenario . combining these constraints
, we will show that almost all the parameter region is excluded when universal gaugino masses are given at the gut scale .
however , when the boundary condition is given above the gut scale , relatively large parameter region is allowed .
we also consider the case that the non - universal gaugino masses are given at the gut scale .
we will show that these constraints are important when the higgsino - like neutralino is the lsp .
this paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : noscalsebc ] , we review some phenomenological aspects of the no - scale models , especially indications of the direct search bounds and the cosmological bound . in section [ sec : higgsbsgamma ] , we further constrain these models from the higgs mass bound and @xmath12 result . indications of these bounds for the tevatron are also discussed .
our conclusions are given in section [ sec : conclusions ] .
in this section , we briefly review phenomenological aspects of susy models with no - scale boundary condition , mainly indications of the cosmological bound and direct search limit at lep 2 .
we consider the following three cases . *
universal gaugino masses are given at the gut scale .
hereafter we call this case the minimal scenario . *
universal gaugino masses are given above the gut scale @xmath13 . throughout this paper
, we take the minimal su(5 ) to be the theory above the gut scale as a typical example . *
non - universal gaugino masses are given at the gut scale .
once one of the above boundary conditions is given , mass spectrum of susy particles at the ew scale and their contributions to fcnc can be calculated . in this paper
we solve the one - loop level rges to obtain the soft susy breaking mass parameters at the ew scale .
the higgsino mass parameter @xmath14 is determined by potential minimum condition at the one - loop level .
first , we discuss the minimal scenario . in this case
, the following boundary condition is given at the gut scale , @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the common scalar mass and @xmath17 is universal trilinear scalar coupling . with this boundary condition , bino and right - handed
sleptons are lighter than other susy particles .
their masses are approximately , @xmath18 from eq.([eq : minimalmneumtau ] ) we see that the charged right - handed slepton is the lsp if the d - term @xmath19 is negligible , i.e. , @xmath20 .
hence this parameter region is excluded by the cosmological consideration . on the other hand ,
lep 2 experiments yields the upper bound on the cross section for smuon pair production , @xmath21 for @xmath22 and @xmath23@xcite , so the parameter region @xmath24 is excluded in fig .
[ fig : limitmimposmu ] and [ fig : limitmimnegmu ] , allowed region of the parameter space are shown in the @xmath25 plane .
the regions above the dash - dotted line and the left side of the dash - dot - dotted line are excluded by cosmological bound and lep 2 bound on smuon pair production , respectively .
therefore the minimal scenario is constrained severely .
next we see the case that the universal gaugino masses are given above the gut scale . in the minimal su(5 ) case , the right - handed slepton belongs to 10-plet , so the large group factor makes slepton masses heavier .
for example , when @xmath26 the bino mass and the right - handed slepton mass at the weak scale are approximately given , @xmath27 hence the cosmological constraint is not severe because the stau mass is large enough and neutralino is the lsp in the large parameter region @xcite . in the fig.[fig : limitmbc1e17posmu ] and [ fig : limitmbc1e17negmu ] , the same figures as in the fig.[fig : limitmimposmu ] and [ fig : limitmimnegmu ] are shown .
unlike in the minimal case , the stau search bound at lep @xcite is also plotted because mass difference between @xmath28 and @xmath29 is larger than in the minimal case and it can be stronger than the smuon search . from these figures we see that the @xmath29 lsp is avoided unless @xmath30 is larger than about 20 .
the charged stau lsp can also be avoided if gaugino masses at the gut scale are non - universal@xcite , i.e. , the following boundary condition is given , @xmath31 this boundary condition can be given naturally within the gut framework @xcite . in this case ,
not only bino - like neutralino , but also wino - like , higgsino - like neutralino or sneutrino can be the lsp . for @xmath32 and @xmath33 ,
the lsp is wino - like neutralino .
for example , when @xmath34 and @xmath35 , then wino mass and charged slepton mass are ( notice that in this case the left - handed sleptons are lighter than right - handed sleptons ) ; @xmath36 the higgsino is the lsp if @xmath37 . for example , when @xmath38 and @xmath39 , then the higgsino mass and the right - handed slepton mass are @xmath40 in the two cases given above , neutral wino or higgsino is the lsp .
in fact from fig.[fig : limit12r432r2posmu ] - [ fig : limit12r232r0.5negmu ] we find that neural particle is the lsp in large parameter region , thus it is cosmologically viable .
in the previous section we take into account only lep 2 bound and the cosmological constraint .
we find that the minimal scenario is severely constrained , but the other two scenarios are not . in this section
we also include the current higgs mass bound and @xmath41 constraint .
as we will see , combining the above four constraint , not only the minimal case but also the other two scenarios can be constrained more severely .
we also discuss the possibility whether this scenario can be seen at the tevatron run 2 or not .
before we show the numerical results , some remarks on our calculation of the higgs mass and @xmath12 are in order .
it is well known that radiative correction is important when the lightest higgs mass is evaluated @xcite . in the present paper ,
the lightest higgs mass is evaluated by means of the one - loop level effective potential@xcite .
this potential is evaluated at the renormalization point of the geometrical mean of the two stop mass eigenvalues @xmath42 .
we compared our result with a two - loop result by using _
feynhiggs_@xcite , and checked that the difference between these two results is smaller than 5 gev as long as @xmath30 is bigger than 5 .
when @xmath30 is close to 2 , the difference can be 7 gev .
however , as we will see later , higgs mass bound plays an important rule around @xmath43 . and
the two - loop effects always make the higgs mass lighter than that obtained at the one - loop level .
so our conclusion is conservative and is not significantly changed by the two - loop effect .
we exclude the parameter region where the lightest higgs mass is lighter than the current 95% c.l .
limit from lep 2 experiments , @xmath44 @xcite . in the present paper , @xmath12
is calculated including leading order ( lo ) qcd corrections@xcite , and compare it to the current cleo measurement . in the mssm
, chargino contribution can be comparable to the sm and charged higgs contributions .
they interfere constructively ( destructively ) each other when @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) .
the difference between the lo and the next - to - leading order ( nlo ) result can be sizable only when cancellation among different contributions at the lo is spoiled by the nlo contributions .
as we will see , however , the @xmath41 constraint is severe when the interference is constructive . in the case of destructive interference where the deviation from the nlo result may be large ,
this constraint is not so important .
hence we expect that our conclusion is not changed significantly by the inclusion of the nlo corrections . for the experimental value
, we use 95% c.l .
limit from cleo , @xmath47 @xcite .
first we show the numerical results for the minimal case .
the case for @xmath48 is shown in fig.[fig : limitmimposmu ] . in this case , for small @xmath30 region , the stop mass is not so large that radiative correction factor @xmath49 which raises the higgs mass is small .
( for example , @xmath50 gev and @xmath51 gev for @xmath52 gev and @xmath53 ) .
hence the higgs mass limit constrains this scenario severely . in fig.[fig : limitmimposmu ] , the higgs mass bound and @xmath12 constraints in the @xmath54 plane are shown .
the regions below the solid line and above the dashed line are excluded by the higgs mass and @xmath12 bound , respectively .
the indication of @xmath55 reported by lep 2@xcite is also shown in this figure . from the figure we find that the higgs mass bound almost excludes the region where the stau lsp is avoided .
note that , as we discussed earlier , the bound we put on the higgs mass may be conservative , because the two loop correction may further reduce the higgs mass . the same figure but for @xmath56 is shown in fig.[fig : limitmimnegmu ] .
now @xmath12 also constrains parameter region strongly since chargino contribution to @xmath0 interferes with sm and charged higgs ones constructively .
the region above the dashed line is excluded by @xmath12 constraint .
we find that only one of the two constraints is enough to exclude all the region where cosmological bound and the smuon mass bound are avoided .
hence if r - parity is conserved , i.e. , the cosmological bound is relevant , this scenario with @xmath56 is excluded .
next we show the numerical results in the case that the cutoff scale is larger than the gut scale . as a typical example , we choose the minimal su(5 ) as the theory above the gut scale . in fig.[fig :
limitmbc1e17posmu ] and [ fig : limitmbc1e17negmu ] , results are shown for positive and negative @xmath14 , respectively . in both figures ,
we take @xmath58 gev . for @xmath48 case , large parameter region
is allowed and susy scale @xmath59 can be as small as about 180 gev , which indicates the lsp mass @xmath60 gev . for @xmath56 , as in the minimal case , @xmath12 constraint is severer , and @xmath59 must be larger than around 280 gev .
we also considered other values of the boundary scale @xmath61 from @xmath62 to @xmath63 , and checked that the behavior of the contour plot does not change so much .
according to ref.@xcite , tevatron run 2 experiment can explore up to @xmath64 gev for integrated luminosity @xmath65 .
hence if @xmath66 and @xmath67 , susy particles can be discovered at the experiment . in this range ,
trilepton from chargino - neutralino associated production @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 is one of clean signals for susy search .
notice that now two body decay @xmath71 opens .
so same flavor , opposite sign dilepton from @xmath72 decay may be useful .
the two body decay allows us to observe the peak edge of invariant mass of two leptons at the @xmath73 .
it is expressed in terms of the neutralino masses and the slepton mass as , @xmath74 in table [ tab : mllmax ] , the dependence of @xmath73 on @xmath61 is shown . here
we fix @xmath75 .
notice that as @xmath61 changes , the right - handed mass changes sizably while the neutralino masses do not .
hence we can obtain the mass relation among them and also cutoff scale @xmath61 , which corresponds to the compactification scale in the sequestered sector scenario , by measuring @xmath73 . on the other hand , since only @xmath76 gev is allowed for @xmath45 , the tevatron run 2 can not survey this scenario , and we have to wait lhc experiment .
next , we turn to the case that gaugino masses are non - universal at the gut scale .
we explore the following three cases , wino - like neutralino lsp , higgsino - like neutralino lsp and the tau sneutrino lsp .
we will see that in the wino - like neutralino lsp and tau sneutrino lsp cases , constraint is not so severe even if we combine higgs mass bound and @xmath12 data , but in the higgsino - like lsp case where stops are as light as sleptons and charginos , the predicted higgs mass tends to be small , and thus the higgs mass bound becomes important .
first , we discuss the wino - lsp case .
the results for @xmath34 , @xmath35 are shown in fig.[fig : limit12r432r2posmu ] and fig.[fig : limit12r432r2negmu ] , for @xmath46 and @xmath45 , respectively . in this case , we obtain a relatively large higgs mass since @xmath77 is large and so are the masses of stops .
hence , for @xmath46 , @xmath78 can be as small as 100 gev at @xmath43 , where the mass of the lsp @xmath79 is about 90 gev . for @xmath45
, though @xmath12 constraint is slightly severer than in the @xmath46 case , @xmath80 is allowed , which corresponds to @xmath81 .
hence the wino - lsp with mass around 100 gev is allowed .
examples of the mass spectrum in this case are listed as point a ( @xmath46 ) and point b ( @xmath45 ) in table [ tab : spectrum ] . at the both points ,
@xmath59 is chosen to be near the smallest value such that all constraints are avoided .
in general , however , masses of @xmath28 and @xmath82 are highly degenerate when wino is the lsp .
in fact , from table [ tab : spectrum ] , we see that the mass difference is less than 1 gev .
therefore a lepton from @xmath70 is very soft and trilepton signal search is not useful because acceptance cut usually requires the smallest transverse momentum of the three leptons @xmath83 to be larger than 5 gev@xcite .
recently collider phenomenology in such cases are studied in ref .
it is shown that certain range of @xmath84 and @xmath85 , susy signals which are different from those in the minimal case can be detected .
the high degeneracy requires to include radiative corrections to calculate @xmath85 @xcite , which is beyond of this work .
it deserves detail study to estimate the mass difference in the scenario .
since the constraint for the sneutrino lsp case in the @xmath86 plane is similar to those in the wino - lsp case , we show the result for @xmath46 only in fig.[fig : limit12r2.532r1.5posmu ] . in the figure
, we take @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
notice that the decomposition of the lsp depends on @xmath30 and the sneutrino is the lsp for @xmath89 .
an example of the mass spectrum is listed as the point c in table [ tab : spectrum ] . in this case ,
trilepton signal comes from @xmath90 , @xmath91 , @xmath92 .
since @xmath93 , @xmath94 of a lepton from @xmath82 decay is small and this signal may be hard to be detected .
we may need unusual trigger to explore this scenario .
next , we turn to the higgsino lsp case .
higgsino lsp scenario is realized when @xmath77 is smaller than half of @xmath78 , which indicates that colored particles are lighter than in the universal gaugino mass case .
hence the one - loop correction to the higgs potential which enhances the higgs mass is small and the higgs mass constraint is important . the same figures as fig.[fig : limitmimposmu ] and [ fig : limitmimnegmu ] are shown in fig.[fig : limit12r232r0.5posmu ] ( @xmath46 ) and fig.[fig : limit12r232r0.5negmu ] ( @xmath45 ) for @xmath95 and @xmath39 . in order to satisfy the higgs mass bound , @xmath78 must be larger than around 300 gev .
combining the bound with @xmath12 , constraint becomes severer , especially for @xmath45 case where @xmath96 is required .
example of mass spectrum in this scenario is listed as point d and e in table [ tab : spectrum ] .
again we choose almost the smallest value of @xmath78 where all constraints are avoided .
we see that the lsp mass must be at least @xmath97 for @xmath46 and @xmath98 for @xmath45 .
hence this scenario can not be explored at the tevatron run 2 .
the no - scale type boundary conditions are obtained in various types of susy models .
this scenario is attractive because it is highly predictive and can be a solution to the susy flavor problem . in this paper
we investigated the indication of the current higgs mass and @xmath41 constraint on susy models with the boundary condition .
first we considered the minimal case where the universal gaugino mass are given at the gut scale .
this scenario has been already constrained by direct search at lep and the cosmological bound severely , under the assumption of the exact r - parity .
we showed that the higgs mass bound and @xmath41 constraint are also taken into account , then almost all the parameter region is excluded , leaving very narrow allowed region for @xmath48 .
next we considered the case that the boundary condition is given above the gut scale .
since the cosmological constraint is not severe , wide region of the parameter space is allowed . in the @xmath46 case ,
tevatron have a chance to observe susy signatures like trilepton events .
the scale @xmath61 may be explored by measuring the peak edge of invariant mass of two leptons at the @xmath73 .
however for the @xmath45 case , since @xmath99 is required , we have to wait lhc .
finally we considered the case where non - universal gaugino masses are given at the gut scale .
we see that the higgs mass bound is strong in the higgsino lsp case because stop masses are as light as sleptons and charginos .
the mass of the higgsino - like neutralino must be larger than about 245 gev and 370 gev for @xmath46 and @xmath45 , respectively . in the wino lsp and sneutrino lsp case
, the mass of the lsp can be as small as 150 gev .
however , the mass difference between the lsp and parent particles produced at the collider is much smaller than in the minimal case , unusual acceptance cut may be required .
the author would like to thank m. yamaguchi for suggesting the subject , fruitful discussion and careful reading of the manuscript .
he also thanks t. moroi and m. m. nojiri for useful discussion .
j. ellis , c. kounnas and d.v .
nanopoulos , nucl .
b247 ( 1984 ) 373 ; j. ellis , a.b .
lahanas , d.v .
nanopoulos and k. tamvakis , phys .
b134 ( 1984 ) 439 ; a.b .
lahanas and d.v .
nanopoulos , phys .
( 1987 ) 1 .
e. witten , phys .
b155 ( 1985 ) 151 .
t. banks and m. dine , nucl .
b505 ( 1997 ) 445 ; h.p .
nilles , m. olechowski and m. yamaguchi , phys .
b415 ( 1997 ) 24 ; nucl .
phys . b530
( 1998 ) 43 ; z. lalak and s. thomas , nucl .
phys . b515
( 1998 ) 55 ; a. lukas , b.a .
ovrut and d. waldram , nucl .
phys . b532
( 1998 ) 43 ; phys .
d57 ( 1998 ) 7529 ; k. choi , h.b .
kim and c. muoz , phys .
d57 ( 1998 ) 7521 .
y. okada , m. yamaguchi and t. yanagida , prog .
85 ( 1991 ) 1 , phys .
b262 ( 1991 ) 54 ; j. ellis , g. ridolfi and f. zwirner , phys .
b257 ( 1991 ) 83 ; h. e. haber and r. hempfling , phys .
66 ( 1991 ) 1815 .
aleph collabolation , phys .
b495 ( 2000 ) 1 ; l3 collabolation , phys .
b495 ( 2000 ) 18 ; delphi collabolation , phys .
b499 ( 2001 ) 23 ; opal collabolation , phys .
b499 ( 2001 ) 38 ; p.
igo - kemenes , talk at the lepc open session on nov .
3rd , http://lephiggs.web.cern.ch/lephiggs/talks/index.html .
plane for the minimal case with @xmath48 . in the region above the dash - dotted line , the stau is the lsp .
the left side of the dash - dot - dotted line is excluded by the upper bound on smuon pair production cross section at lep .
the current higgs mass bound excludes the region below the solid line . in the region above the dashed line , @xmath12 is smaller than the lower limit obtained by the cleo .
the shaded region is allowed .
the @xmath100 curve is also shown as the dotted line .
noewsb means that radiative breaking does not occur.,width=340,height=264 ] but @xmath56 .
the region above the dashed line is excluded since @xmath12 is larger than the upper limit obtained by the cleo .
the other lines are the same as in fig.[fig : limitmimposmu ] .
notice that all region is excluded.,width=340,height=264 ] plane for universal gaugino masses , @xmath26 and @xmath48 .
the left sides of the dash - dot - dotted and dash - dot - dot - dotted line are excluded by the upper bound on the smuon and stau pair production cross section , respectively .
the other lines are the same as in fig.[fig : limitmimposmu ] , width=340,height=264 ] plane for the higgsino lsp case , @xmath95 , @xmath39 , @xmath101 and @xmath48 . in the region between the two dashed line ,
@xmath12 is smaller than the lower limit of the cleo result .
, width=340,height=264 ]
|
no - scale structure of the khler potential is obtained in many types of supersymmetric models . in this paper ,
phenomenological aspects of these models are investigated with special attention to the current higgs mass bound at lep and @xmath0 result at the cleo .
when the boundary condition is given at the gut scale and gaugino masses are universal at this scale , very narrow parameter region is allowed only for positive higgsino mass region if r - parity is conserved .
the negative higgsino mass case is entirely excluded . on the other hand , relatively large parameter region
is allowed when the boundary condition is given above the gut scale , and tevatron can discover susy signals for the positive higgsino mass case .
the no - scale models with wino , higgsino or sneutrino lsp are also considered .
we show that the higgs mass constraint is important for the higgsino lsp case , which requires the lsp mass to be larger than about 245 gev .
0.0 mm 0.0 mm 159.2 mm -16.0 mm 240.0 mm
|
the origin - destination ( od ) matrix is important in transportation analysis .
the matrix contains information on the number of travellers that commute or the amount of freight shipped between different zones of a region .
the od matrix is difficult and often costly to obtain by direct measurements / interviews or surveys , but by using incomplete traffic counts and other available information one may obtain a reasonable estimate .
a particular application of the od matrix estimation is in the area of public transport . in order to improve their service ,
the responsible managers are looking for on - going evaluation of the passenger flow and the reasons that would influence this flow .
this is typically the case for the city rail , sydney bus and sydney ferry organisations , which handle the public transport in the region around the city of sydney , australia .
cityrail and co are handling a large number of stations ( wharfs , bus stops ) for trains ( buses and ferries ) across the state . they carry thousands of passengers every day , and periodically optimise the time - table schedule to best meet the changing demand .
+ + an ideal optimization of the schedule would consider the resources in trains , drivers , stations and passengers .
while the primary informations ( trains , drivers , stations ) are known to cityrail and co , the number of passenger on each train between each station can not be deduced easily given their current passenger flow data collection processes .
+ + various approaches to estimating the od matrix using traffic counts have been developed and tested @xcite using traffic counts , or road traffic flows @xcite , @xcite .
most of the papers in the literature solve this problem by postulating a general model for the trip distribution , for example a gravity type model @xcite , which aims at introducing a prior knowledge on the traffic flows and assigning a cost to each journey .
then the inference is produced to estimate the parameters of this model .
all these papers _ are not passengers oriented_. + most of the work relating to od matrix estimation are based on passengers observations assuming the knowledge of where the people get in and out of the public transport .
lo et al @xcite developed a framework centred on the passenger choice , which they called the random link choice , and model this to obtain a maximum likelihood estimator .
nandi et al @xcite applied a strategy centred on a fixed cost per person per kilometre assumption on the air - route network of india and provide some comparisons with the real data .
+ when the information is not available ( for example we have no data on when passengers get off the bus ) , kostakos @xcite offers to use a wireless detection of the passengers trips , and lundgren and peterson s model @xcite is based on a target od - matrix previously defined . however , none of the cited work considered using survey data . indeed , if no complete information is available about the passengers destinations , the simplest solution is to use an appropriate survey to estimate destination information . furthermore , what characteristics of the survey are required for the estimation to be accurate ?
bierliaire and toint @xcite introduces a structure - based estimation of the origin - destination matrix based on parking surveys . in their article , they used the parking surveys to infer an a priori estimate of the od matrix , and they used this prior in coordination with the partial observations of the network flows to derive a generalized least square estimator of the od matrix . despite its novelty , this article assume that the behaviour of car - user and public transport users are the same , at least regarding their respective od matrix . given that the public transport network topology is often different from the road network topology , one may doubt the accuracy of this assumption .
moreover , they just use the partial structure extracted from the surveys .
+ the purpose of this paper is then to develop an estimation procedure for the origin - destination matrix based on the ticket records available for the transport network and/or on previous surveys . unlike the article from bierliaire @xcite ,
we use survey data collection from public transport users , and estimate the approximate whole matrix structure through the estimation of its eigenvectors .
we propose a robust version of the estimator to avoid biases induced by the survey .
we also construct a regression estimation procedure that accounts for the influence of exogenous variable such as the weather conditions or the time of the year .
+ we first briefly present the passenger model , and then move on to outlining the observations model . in section [ sec : om ] , we explain how the measurements are obtained , and what measurements error should be expected . in section
[ sec : mam ] , we explain the assumptions we make on the measurements , and how this affects our estimation procedure .
we present in section [ sec : est ] the maximum likelihood ( ml ) estimation procedure , by providing a system of equation to be solved , for deriving estimators .
we improve on this ml estimation to make it robust to survey biases in section [ sec : rob ] . finally , we present a simulation example and an application to a real world case in section [ sec : app ] .
we finally comment on the results and outline some future research opportunities .
let @xmath0 be the matrix of passengers number between the stations in the rail network over time period @xmath1 so that @xmath2 is the number of passengers who depart from station @xmath3 and arrive at station @xmath4 at time period @xmath1 .
given that there is an obvious time dependency here , denoted by @xmath1 the period in which the commuting occur ( for example a day ) .
the purpose of this work is to provide an estimation of @xmath0 given the observations specified in section [ sec : om ] .
the observations provided about the passengers are very different , and only considering them all allow a direct estimation of @xmath0 .
we list in the subsections [ om - casual],[om - deparr ] and [ om - regular ] the different kind of observations .
a casual commuter is defined as a single or return journey that is not repeated regularly ( e.g. daily ) .
typically , people going to a once - in - a - year event will buy their ticket for that trajectory and will probably return on the same day . accordingly for single and day return tickets , we have complete information under the assumption that they take the next train after purchasing their ticket and that they take the shortest route .
let @xmath5 be that matrix of measurements .
each journey between major stations , the passenger has to validate his ticket through the machines at the entrance of the station , and do it again at the exit . between minor stations
we assume they take the next train to arrive at the station they purchased their ticket at and assume they take the trio planners recommended route for that time .
two scenarios are considered . in the first one , ( called @xmath6 ) , every station in the network have these machines . in the second case ( called @xmath7 ) only major stations have these machines . in any case
, let call @xmath8 the vector corresponding to the departures at the stations , and @xmath9 the vector of arrivals .
fortunately we can have regular passengers with specific departure and destination , and this matrix will be denoted @xmath10 , where the rows stand for the departure stations and the columns for the arrival stations . this matrix is observed , and assumed distributed according to a poisson probability function with mean @xmath11 .
+ the main part of the information , however , remains unknown .
indeed most of the passengers will probably have a zone ticket for a period of time , from 1 week to 1 year .
the nature of these tickets make the station of departure and arrival unknown , and is the main challenge of this paper .
let call @xmath12 the matrix of zone passengers numbers .
+ to make a proper statistical inference , we need two assumptions ; * the traveller will act independently of the validity duration of his ticket ; * the regular traveller commits to a return journey on each working day .
the observations linked to this model are two - folds . for major stations
, we have the total number of passengers that crossed the boom gates , in and out . for stations without boom gates , the observations have to estimated using a survey
. we also have access to the total number of people with a valid zone ticket at time @xmath1 ( e.g. the day of the analysis ) , denoted @xmath13 , @xmath14 in the end , the total number of regular passenger at the time period @xmath1 will be denoted @xmath15 , and we have , @xmath16
with these very different observations , we need a good fitting model based on reasonable assumptions . sections [ mam - gm ] , [ mam - cm ] , [ mam - da ] and [ mam - rm ] presents these assumptions for each parameter in our model .
recall that @xmath17 is a matrix of count , the main assumption on that matrix is that the number of passenger is the sum of the casual passengers ( @xmath18 ) plus the regular passengers ( @xmath15 ) plus a matrix stating the unusual big events such as major sporting events , or large concerts ( called @xmath19 ) , @xmath20 the casual commuter journey could be assumed to be poisson distributed i.e. @xmath21 is supposed to be drawn with a poisson distribution which parameter belong to the matrix @xmath22 . ] where @xmath22 is the matrix of means for the counts .
+ however , the variance of the counts are not expected to be equal to their mean and so the poisson counts assumption may be unrealistic .
therefore , we decided to use a negative binomial regression model for @xmath23 , which can be over - dispersed in order to better describe the distribution of the counts .
we specify that @xmath22 is distributed according to a gamma distribution , @xmath24 . for a purpose of simplicity ,
let @xmath23 be distributed as negative binomial with parameters @xmath25 and @xmath26 ( we will denote @xmath27 ) . according to the definition of the measurements ,
the following relationships hold : @xmath28 where @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the vectors of the total number of departures and arrivals at each station during time period @xmath1 . for the same reasons as described for the casual matrix
, we will use a negative binomial distribution to model the uncertainty around the regular traveller s information .
however , unlike the casual commuter , we do not suspect an over - dispersion but an under - dispersion , so that , @xmath29 and @xmath30 . let @xmath31 and @xmath32 be the expectation of @xmath33 and @xmath34 .
when the model is well defined , the estimation procedure is computationally straight forward , e.g. , between major stations where we have complete information of arrivals and departures .
meaning that the maximum likelihood estimation method accuracy , practically depends on the efficient solving of the optimization problem . in this section ,
the stationary model parameters are estimated from the data .
since the process is unlikely to be stationary , we present a second option ( section [ est : reg ] ) , a multivariate spatio - temporal model that we expect to fit the data better .
the estimation procedure will be carried out in well - defined steps .
if we ignore the time dependence , the successive observations can be considered independent , identical random counts from negative binomial or poisson distribution .
this means that simple maximum likelihood estimation should work well , especially for large sample sizes .
we observe @xmath18 for several realizations . given no space - time dependencies we assume that @xmath5 is independently distributed as @xmath35 .
the likelihood is then , @xmath36\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath37 stands for one element of the matrix @xmath5 .
we thus can estimate the parameters through , @xmath38 despite the absence of closed form solution to this problem , the optimization algorithms can quickly lead to a global maximum .
unfortunately we do nt have complete information for those with weekly , monthly , quarterly or anuual tickets ( long - term tickets ) .
we have information of the times they enter and departs at major stations but we do nt have complete information for the long term tickets either to or from minor stations .
our assumption here is that only a proportion @xmath39 of the @xmath32 people will travel on day @xmath1 , where @xmath40 .
@xmath39 is an additional parameter that reflects the passengers habit .
it does exist because when performing the estimation , one may find a bigger estimation of travellers than what is observed .
some of the difference is due to the randomness of @xmath41 , but it might also be explained by the fact that travellers with prepaid long term tickets will not necessary travel each of the working day of the week .
+ however , we may provide the same estimation for the @xmath31 parameters as we did in the previous section , that is , @xmath42 where @xmath43 stands for the same likelihood function as above .
+ this leads us to the final estimation , the contribution this paper makes to the literature .
the aim is to estimate the matrix @xmath12 with the available departure and arrival data .
the first step is to estimate the general shape of the @xmath10 matrix .
the problem is to achieve this in a simple way given that @xmath12 is to be estimated with @xmath44 parameters , and only @xmath45 equations .
the following paragraph presents an elegant solution to this problem .
+ recall @xmath32 as the expectation of @xmath46 .
it is assumed symmetric , we can diagonalize it , so that , @xmath47 where @xmath48 is a projection matrix of eigenvectors of @xmath32 and @xmath49 is a @xmath44 diagonal matrix , with terms equal to the respective eigenvalues . therefore ,
if the structure of @xmath32 is known ( i.e. the eigenvectors are known ) and constant , then we have reduced the problem to solving a system of @xmath45 unknown parameters with @xmath45 equations .
[ eq : odeq ] and the previous estimations , we have the following system , @xmath50 where @xmath51 and @xmath52 are obtained by simple subtraction .
the probability density function of the observations @xmath53 can then be written , @xmath54 \quad p \big ( y_{di}^t \vert r_z , p_{rz } \big ) & \sim & \mathcal{nb } ( \sum_j r^{ij}_z , p_{rz})\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath55 and @xmath56 .
according to this equation , we then have @xmath57 likelihood equations ( @xmath58 $ ] ) but @xmath59 parameters to estimate ( @xmath32 being symmetric ) . to perform the estimation
, we then need to reduce the number of parameters . according to eq .
[ eq : diag ] , we have , @xmath60 then , if we knew @xmath48 , the maximum likelihood would be tractable and provide an estimation of @xmath32 ( with @xmath61 being the @xmath3th eigenvalue ) . the @xmath57 likelihoods would look like , @xmath62 \quad l \big ( y_{di}^t \vert r_z , p_{rz } \big ) & = & \prod_t p \big ( y_{di}^t \vert r_z , p_{rz } \big)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath63 .
the maximum likelihood estimating equations are then , @xmath64 moreover , this complex equation can be simplified by assuming that the observations are independent conditionally on knowing the parameters ( e.g. the errors are independents ) , and then , @xmath65 the dimension of the parameter space is reduced according to the knowledge of @xmath48 . to estimate @xmath48 ,
remember that @xmath31 is symmetric , we have , @xmath66 then , we make the assumption that all the regular passengers behave identically over time , that is , @xmath48 is not a function of time .
then we have , @xmath67 then @xmath48 can be estimated from @xmath68 , and introduced into equation [ eq : density ] to obtain eq . [ eq : mle ] . finally , we can use @xmath69 and @xmath70 to estimate @xmath71 .
finding the solution of equation [ eq : mle ] is a classic optimization problem .
the simple likelihood shape insures the existence of a solution , and it can be found by any standard optimization function .
let this solution be @xmath72 .
the problem with this estimator is that we can not guarantee that it will fulfil the underlying constraint of the density parameters .
indeed , some values in the matrix will be negative , and there will be some element in the diagonal that wo nt be null .
therefore , some constraints have to be added to the ml estimating equations .
these are : + * constraint 1 * _ all the elements in the matrix @xmath73 are greater than or equal to zero , or equivalently , @xmath74 _ + * constraint 2 * _ all the diagonal elements in the matrix @xmath71 must be zero , or equivalently , @xmath75 _ + * constraint 3 * _ the last set of parameters to be estimated is the probability matrix @xmath76 .
therefore , all the elements should belong to the interval @xmath77 $ ] , @xmath78 \end{aligned}\ ] ] _ most of the optimization algorithms that deal with the constraint require an initialization which belong to the constrained space .
one could be tempted to address as a starting point the mean value of the observations , according to the one - dimensional ( @xmath79 ) result .
however , it is very unlikely that this initial point will satisfy the constraints .
therefore , the best choice so far seems to be the diagonal elements of the matrix @xmath80 , given that they naturally fill * constraint 1 * and * constraint 2*. + + the complete optimization program therefore becomes , @xmath81 with the initial value @xmath82 .
this optimization program can be replaced by an explicit expression of the estimator , subject to some constraints stated in [ ann : a ] .
the main constraint is the poisson distribution assumption , so that we have , + * proposition 1 : * _ assume that @xmath83 , then @xmath84^{-1 } \bar{y}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath85 is the matrix of estimated eigenvalues of @xmath32 . _
+ if now we consider a gaussian likelihood instead of poisson , the following maximum likelihood estimator is found , + * proposition 2 : * _ assume that @xmath86 , then @xmath87 where @xmath88 is the matrix of estimated eigenvalues of @xmath32 . _ + the proofs of propositions 1 and 2 are presented in [ ann : a ] .
we can also derive the follwing theorem , that ensures us of the quality of the estimation , + * theorem 1 * + assume that @xmath89{\ a.s.\ } p$ ] ( see anderson @xcite,@xcite ) .
then we have , @xmath90{\ \mathcal{p } \ } \lambda\end{aligned}\ ] ] the proof is presented in [ ann : b ] .
if we want to deal with a more realistic modelling , it seems obvious that we have to consider spatial , temporal and multivariate influences on the number of passengers , and then on the parameters of our modelling .
+ let @xmath91 be a set of exogenous features , and @xmath92 their corresponding ( unknown ) influence on the number of passengers .
therefore , the regression model can be written , + @xmath54 \quad p \big ( y_{di}^t \vert r_z , p_{rz } , ( x_i)_i \big ) & \sim & \mathcal{nb } \big ( \sum_{k } \lambda_k p_{ik } \sum_j p_{jk } + \sum_l x_l \beta_l , p_{rz}\big)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the parameters to be estimated are @xmath93 .
the likelihood is expressed as in eq .
[ eq : like ] , and we have , @xmath94 then , if we consider the projection matrix to be constant over time , then we have the following proposition ( proved in [ ann : c ] ) , + * proposition 3 : * _ if we apply the same methodology as before we obtain the following estimator , @xmath95^{-1 } y { } ^t x ( x { } ^t x)^{-1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath96 is the matrix of the exogenous variables . _ + a more complex solution would be to perform the same technique as before , except that @xmath48 will no longer be constant .
therefore , the varying @xmath97 estimated from @xmath31 will help in the recovery of the matrix @xmath32 .
the reason why we can not perform a direct estimation of the @xmath98 s through this technique is because @xmath32 can be diagonalize , but we do nt know how the @xmath98 influence the @xmath99 .
then a space - time model for the regular zone passenger is required .
a further sensitivity analysis has to be run in order to figure out if the results are significantly affected by the increased uncertainty .
the quality of the estimator will strongly depend on the survey sub - matrix @xmath31 . in section [ sec : est ] , we assume that the similarity between the matrix @xmath31 and @xmath32 relies on the projection matrix @xmath48 and @xmath100 .
moreover , we assume @xmath101 ( eq . [ eq : ass1 ] ) , and this assumption is the key to derive the propositions @xmath102 . + it is however difficult to design and implement a survey that provides accurate information . therefore , eq . [ eq : ass1 ] is no longer valid . to overcome this
, we propose to consider an ad hoc estimation of the o - d matrix .
+ despite the survey having some unknown biases , it provides useful information that we need .
let @xmath88 be the estimation based on the eigenvalues of @xmath32 , relying on the assumption @xmath101 . while inaccurate , this estimation looks like the perfect prior information .
we define , @xmath103 now , given that the survey may be biased , we need to emphasize the influence of the observations @xmath104 , by building an observation - based matrix @xmath105 , such that , @xmath106 where @xmath107 and @xmath108 .
@xmath109 is symmetric , and roughly correspond to an equal partition of the passengers in the different stations .
let @xmath110 .
now , we need to integrate the information provided by @xmath109 .
then we define the final ad hoc estimator @xmath111 , @xmath112 we define the robustness of our estimation as its ability to overcome biased survey results .
to analyse the performance of the estimators , we considered that the parameter matrix of the survey was biased according to the following two equations , @xmath113 where @xmath114 $ ] stands for the scale of the survey , @xmath115 $ ] stands for the varying noise level , and @xmath116 means the poisson distribution , and , @xmath117 the difference between the two equations relies in the bias structure . in eq .
[ eq : noise ] , integer values are randomly added regardless of the real value of the parameter .
it is the kind of errors we expect to find in badly designed surveys or respondents responding randomly . in eq .
[ eq : prop.noise ] , we consider that the bias keeps the same structure as the @xmath32 matrix .
this is more an equivalent of a measurement error usually described in the literature with centred gaussian distributions .
therefore , we expect the estimators to provide better estimates when the survey s parameters are driven by eq .
[ eq : prop.noise ] .
+ figure [ fig : sensnoise ] shows the ml and ad hoc estimation results for the two kind of bias , with different number of observations and different strength of bias . as expected , the second type of error ( eq . [ eq : prop.noise ] ) is more easily overcome by the estimators .
the important conclusion we can make from this result is that the ad hoc estimation performs better than the naive ml estimation , no matter what kind of noise we add .
the ad - hoc estimation is plotted in green .
the upper line stands for a bias designed according to eq .
[ eq : noise ] , and the bottom line for eq .
[ eq : prop.noise ] .
the mse is calculated among @xmath118 simulations .
, title="fig:",width=264,height=226 ] ci .
the ad - hoc estimation is plotted in green .
the upper line stands for a bias designed according to eq .
[ eq : noise ] , and the bottom line for eq .
[ eq : prop.noise ] .
the mse is calculated among @xmath118 simulations .
, title="fig:",width=264,height=226 ] + ci .
the ad - hoc estimation is plotted in green .
the upper line stands for a bias designed according to eq .
[ eq : noise ] , and the bottom line for eq .
[ eq : prop.noise ] .
the mse is calculated among @xmath118 simulations .
, title="fig:",width=264,height=226 ] ci .
the ad - hoc estimation is plotted in green .
the upper line stands for a bias designed according to eq .
[ eq : noise ] , and the bottom line for eq .
[ eq : prop.noise ] .
the mse is calculated among @xmath118 simulations .
, title="fig:",width=264,height=226 ] finally , and also very important , the ad hoc estimator seems more consistent and its performances are less affected by the number of available observations .
for instance , we can observe that the log(mse ) profile is identical in fig .
[ fig : sensnoise ] for @xmath119 observations and for @xmath120 .
the importance of that being to allow some reliable time - dependency analysis ( on a monthly basis , it would mean @xmath121 observations ) , which would be more complicated with the ml estimation .
let m be a @xmath122 matrix , representing departure and arrival stations ( origin and destination ) .
we assume that any value of m is a random number , generated according to the matrix of parameters @xmath123 , and the probability @xmath124 .
the matrix @xmath123 has the following values , @xmath125\ ] ] let @xmath126 be an observed sub - sample of m , i.e. only a proportion @xmath127 of m is represented in @xmath126 .
we assume that for every value of m , @xmath127 will be the same , only perturbed by some low - level additive noise .
a realization of @xmath126 is the following matrix , @xmath128\ ] ] the value of @xmath127 in this example is roughly equal to @xmath129 . the estimation of @xmath130 is performed with the observations of this matrix .
then , @xmath130 being symmetric , we diagonalize it , and using the optimization program described in section [ sec : oi ] we are able to provide the following estimated @xmath131 matrix ( for @xmath132 , @xmath133 , @xmath134 and @xmath135 observations respectively ) , @xmath136 & \left [ \begin{array}{ccccc } 0 & 68 & 24 & 42 & 54 \\ 68 & 0 & 18 & 36 & 124 \\ 24 & 18 & 0 & 126 & 12 \\ 42 & 36 & 126 & 0 & 18 \\ 54 & 124 & 12 & 18 & 0 \end{array } \right ] \\ & \\ \left
[ \begin{array}{ccccc } 0 & 78 & 12 & 60 & 42 \\ 78 & 0 & 24 & 48 & 78 \\ 12 & 24 & 0 & 102 & 12 \\ 60 & 48 & 102 & 0 & 24 \\ 42 & 78 & 12 & 24 & 0 \end{array } \right ] & \left [ \begin{array}{ccccc } 0 & 72 & 12 & 54 & 48 \\ 72 & 0 & 24 & 42 & 78 \\ 12 & 24 & 0 & 96 & 12 \\ 54 & 42 & 96 & 0 & 24 \\ 48 & 78 & 12 & 24 & 0 \end{array } \right ] \end{array}\ ] ] table [ tble : mse_bin ] provides the mean square error of the estimator for different number of observations and different value of dispersion in the case of a negative binomial modelling .
we also display in table [ tble : norm_test ] the p - values for the cramer - von mises normality test of @xmath137 estimation procedures for each eigenvalue .
.[tble : mse_bin ] negative binomial modelling : values of the mean square error of the parameter estimation with different number of observations and different distribution assumption over @xmath137 replication of the simulation , and the according variance ( under brackets ) . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] we consider as an example the passengers commuting from the sydney region ferry , according to five surveys organized in @xmath138 , @xmath139 , and @xmath140 by the bureau of transport statistics of new south wales .
the overall survey could have been analysed , but in order to be understandable , we will focus our analysis on the eastern suburbs route , composed with @xmath141 different wharfs and @xmath142 different days .
[ fig : lpw20xx ] represents the links between the wharfs , meaning that you can have a direct access by taking only one ferry .
+ as we can see from the plots , all the wharfs seem to be able to be reached starting from any other wharf , except for darling point , watsons bay and garden island .
+ starting from this , the objective is the estimation of the od matrix , which is almost like the ferry links matrix presented in the figures except that instead of logical values , it will be filled by counts of passengers .
however , this survey does not provide enough data to perform this estimation .
in particular , it does nt give any observation on the ticket sales at the wharfs .
then , to provide an estimation , we use a different survey from the same institute , which aimed at understanding the preferred mean of transport for people going to work . from this database , we only kept those who declared taking the ferry .
+ before we could provide an analysis of these data , we had to consider that the origins and destination of the people in the second survey did nt correspond to the wharfs of the first survey . therefore , we decided to attribute to every passenger the starting point of their journey as the closest wharf to their home , and a destination point the closest wharf to their office .
the distance have been calculated according to each wharf and location longitude and latitude values .
this being done , we can provide a new origin - destination matrix .
it is plotted in fig .
[ fig : jw2006 ] .
+ this od matrix is then supposed to have the same structure as the regular od of the barrier counts .
therefore , we will apply the methodology presented in section [ sec : cpe ] to reconstruct the 2010 , 2011 and 2012 od matrix according to the barrier counts .
the eigenvalues and eigenvectors are then calculated , and the reconstruction of the ferry passengers are presented in figs .
[ fig : est1 ] and [ fig : est2 ] .
we presented in this paper a new estimation technique for the od matrix .
we use the information available from surveys to infer the correct projection matrix and reduce significantly the size of the parameter space . by using a maximum likelihood approach ,
we compute the estimating equations and provide an ad hoc estimator of the od matrix .
we demonstrated its robustness in section [ sec : rob ] .
+ we also demonstrated that a regression analysis could be performed on this kind of data , and showed that this estimation procedure is also consistent . to the best of our knowledge ,
this is the first time that a such multivariate approach is used to estimate the od matrix .
this approach will improve the prediction ability of passengers journeys .
+ we finally applied our techniques to simulated data and real - case scenario in sydney ferry transport using the data from the bureau of transport statistics . + the estimation of the od matrix is a first step for the analysis of the passengers flow over the transport network .
then , beyond this estimation point , we may cite : 1 .
[ monit ] monitoring the passengers count ; 2 . [ forecast ] forecasting of the passengers count ( 1 week in advance for example ) ; 3 .
[ predict ] predicting the passengers flow in case of spatio - temporal topological change in the network in order to address the monitoring task ( [ monit ] ) , several strong assumptions have to be made , which will require ground verifications before being tested . among them
, we can cite the time between ticket validation and getting into the train or the regularity at which people take their train if they are regular passengers .
moreover , a real - time access to the data is necessary .
while difficult , this seems achievable .
+ the forecasting of passenger counts ( [ forecast ] ) can be done without additional information ( if sufficient temporal information has been provided in a first place ) , even if more observation would probably mean smaller variances .
these forecasts could be helpful for efficient scheduling the trains ( for example ) , but further study have to be done in order to understand the influence of complex variables such as the temperature or the humidity .
+ real - time prediction of passenger flows ( [ predict ] ) is more difficult , but is theoretically achievable .
what we denote a spatio - temporal topological change is a change in the timetable , or in the public transport route . _ to make it clear , we will explore a simple density example , where the poisson distribution will be used instead of the negative binomial .
therefore , the pdf can be expressed as , @xmath143 where @xmath144 is the parameter we are interested in .
then , if we make the assumption that the number of passengers in every station are independent , each @xmath145 is distributed according to a poisson distribution , with the parameter @xmath146 , which can be re - written according to eq .
[ eq : diag2 ] , @xmath147 where the @xmath148 are the eigenvalues , and the @xmath149 the element of the matrix p. if we denote @xmath150 , the transformed density can then be written , @xmath151 + therefore , the log - likelihood can be expressed as follow , @xmath152 the maximum likelihood estimation is then equivalent to solve the following system , @xmath153 still under the constraint * c1 * and * c2*. * c3 * is excluded because this set of parameter does nt exist in the poisson modelling . if @xmath154 , @xmath155 and * c2 * does nt stand .
then estimated value corresponds to the classical one dimensional poisson unbiased mean estimator @xmath156 .
+ the system of equations [ eq : sys_pois ] seems at first a quite complicated one .
nevertheless , it can be simplify so as to become , @xmath157 where @xmath158 contains the unknown parameters . then , if we denote @xmath159 , then , @xmath160 where @xmath161 and @xmath162 . then
, we can keep simplifying the expression , @xmath163 finally , the same reasoning leads to the following estimator , @xmath164 where @xmath165 .
this estimator will probably not be the best estimator given that it relies on the inversion of @xmath166 , but has the advantage to be asymptotically unbiased , with variance decreasing to zero .
_ _ let @xmath167 be a probability density function . if @xmath168 denotes the pdf of @xmath169 , and @xmath170 the pdf of @xmath100 , we can write , @xmath171 let consider the estimator presented in eq .
[ eq : linsol_lamfg ] , and make the assumption that we are in a large value case , meaning @xmath172 .
then , @xmath173 where , @xmath174 \tilde{s}_d^{-1 } \end{array } \right.\ ] ] and @xmath100 is an estimation of @xmath48 according to the first observations .
+ + _ to prove the convergence in probability , we need to demonstrate that , @xmath175 where @xmath176 .
starting with the left hand side , we have , @xmath177 and we know that @xmath178{\ a.s.\ } p s_d \lambda $ ] . then , @xmath179 and we have , @xmath180 where @xmath181 stands for the probability density function of @xmath182 .
+ the first integral decreases towards @xmath183 as @xmath57 grows to infinity according to eq .
[ eq : as ] .
the argument for the second integral is the following . according to the assumption of strong convergence of @xmath100 , @xmath181
converge towards the dirac function @xmath184 as @xmath185 goes to infinity .
@xmath186 being strictly positive , this ends the proof . @xmath187 . [
[ calculation - in - case - of - poisson - regression - and - log - link - function ] ] * calculation in case of poisson regression ( and log link function ) * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + _ the beginning of the reasoning is similar to the previous one .
then , if we assume that exogenous variables have impacts on the number of passengers , we can write , @xmath188 where @xmath98 are symmetric matrices reflecting the intercept ( @xmath189 ) for baseline commuter flows and the variable influences ( @xmath190 ) for changes in commuter flows from known daily influences . moreover , we assume that the same diagonalization ( meaning with the same eigenvectors ) can be applied , which lead us to , @xmath191 therefore , @xmath192 will be distributed according to a poisson distribution with the following parameter , @xmath193 where the parameters to be estimated are @xmath194 , which means we have to estimate @xmath195 parameters . + the probability of one observation
can then be written , @xmath196 which gives the following log - likelihood , @xmath197 therefore , to obtain the final system of equation , we need to calculate the derivatives of the log - likelihood with respect to each parameter @xmath198 . _
|
the estimation of the number of passengers with the identical journey is a common problem for public transport authorities .
this problem is also known as the origin - destination estimation ( od ) problem and it has been widely studied for the past thirty years .
however , the theory is missing when the observations are not limited to the passenger counts but also includes station surveys .
+ our aim is to provide a solid framework for the estimation of an od matrix when only a portion of the journey counts are observable . +
our method consists of a statistical estimation technique for od matrix when we have the sum - of - row counts and survey - based observations .
our technique differs from the previous studies in that it does not need a prior od matrix which can be hard to obtain .
instead , we model the passengers behaviour through the survey data , and use the diagonalization of the partial od matrix to reduce the space parameter and derive a consistent global od matrix estimator .
we demonstrate the robustness of our estimator and apply it to several examples showcasing the proposed models and approach .
we highlight how other sources of data can be incorporated in the model such as explanatory variables , e.g. rainfall , indicator variables for major events , etc , and inference made in a principled , non - heuristic way .
constraint maximum likelihood estimation , eigenvectors , counts estimation
|
high q cavities such as whispering gallery mode ( wgm ) cavities have recently demonstrated quality factors ( @xmath0 ) as high as @xmath3 and have shown the potential to reach even higher q values @xcite .
however , there are difficulties in measurement of the linewidth and q of such high q cavities . while in theory
, the q factor could be as high as @xmath4 and is limited only by rayleigh scattering @xcite , in practice , it is limited by other losses in the cavity .
they include absorption and scattering losses due to impurities in the cavity material , and light - induced losses due to nonlinear processes .
due to the extremely small mode volume and high q - factor of the cavity , the cavity build - up intensity is extremely high , even in the case of an input with small power ( as small as several mw ) .
such a high resonator intensity leads to very efficient nonlinear processes inside wgm cavities , such as raman scattering , second harmonic generation , and four - wave mixing @xcite .
whereas this is beneficial in many applications , it causes additional losses in the cavity and thus makes the q factor measurement unreliable ( at least , making it power - dependent ) @xcite .
squeezed states of vacuum or light have been used in many applications such as improvement in interferometric @xcite and absorption @xcite measurements , for quantum teleportation @xcite and quantum cryptography @xcite , and for quantum imaging @xcite . however , to the best of our knowledge , no experiment for measurements of cavity parameters by use of squeezing has yet been reported . in this paper
we propose and demonstrate an alternative method of measuring q factors by use of a squeezed vacuum field which is equivalent to a field with correlated quantum sidebands @xcite .
this technique is advantageous over traditional optical methods in that it utilizes the injection of squeezed vacuum into a test cavity not to excite any nonlinear processes in the cavity .
when the input field is detuned from the cavity resonance frequency , it transmits only the upper or lower quantum sidebands within the cavity linewidth while reflecting the counterparts ( associated upper or lower sidebands ) and all the other sidebands .
the linewidth of the cavity can then be measured by observing the destruction of the correlation between the upper and lower quantum sidebands with respect to the carrier frequency .
we show that the linewidth and q factor of a test cavity using the method agrees with those measured by traditional optical methods .
this paper is organized as follows : in sec .
[ sect : theory1 ] , we describe the theoretical framework for the measurement method . in sec .
[ sect : theory2 ] , we explain the validity of the use of squeezed vacuum as a probe for non - invasive measurements and compare the technique to using a classical state . in sec . [
sect : experiment ] , we demonstrate the method using a test cavity with known cavity parameters and compare the parameter values obtained by the new method and the traditional optical methods .
the conclusions of the paper are summarized in sec .
[ sect : conclusions ] .
consider a squeezed vacuum field with carrier and sideband frequencies , @xmath5 and @xmath6 respectively . as shown in fig .
[ cavity ] , when the upper sideband of the squeezed vacuum field @xmath7 is injected into an optical cavity with resonance frequency @xmath8 and mirror reflectivities @xmath9 , and @xmath10 , the reflected field @xmath11 and its adjoint @xmath12 are given in terms of @xmath13 and its adjoint @xmath14 by @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the frequency - dependent cavity reflection coefficient and @xmath17 is the vacuum noise coupling coefficient associated with transmission and intra - cavity losses . when the cavity is not perfectly mode - matched , the reflected field contains the cavity - coupled reflection @xmath18 @xcite and the promptly reflected field @xmath19 that does not couple to the cavity due to mode mismatch such that @xmath20 where @xmath18 and @xmath19 are spatially orthogonal and @xmath21}}{1-\sqrt{r_1 r_2 r_3}e^{-i\left[\phi_c(\omega_d ) \pm \phi_s(\omega)\right ] } } , \\
r_m & = & \sqrt{r_1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath22 is the detuning from the cavity resonance given by @xmath23 and we have assumed that the resonance frequency of @xmath19 is far from that of @xmath18 such that the reflection coefficient @xmath24 can be treated as a frequency - independent constant at frequencies around the resonance frequency of @xmath19 .
the vacuum noise coupling coefficients are then given by @xmath25 the cavity mirror reflectivity and transmission of each mirror satisfies @xmath26 where l@xmath27 is the loss of each mirror .
the intra - cavity losses can be absorbed into @xmath10 . ,
r@xmath28 , and r@xmath29 , respectively .
@xmath30 is the upper sideband of an injected field at frequency @xmath31 , @xmath32 is the cavity - filtered reflection at the frequency , @xmath33 is the transmission at the frequency , and @xmath34 is the vacuum field that couples in due to losses in the cavity at the frequency .
@xmath8 is the cavity resonance frequency .
the carrier field at frequency @xmath5 transmits through the cavity when @xmath35 . ]
since the carrier is detuned from the cavity resonance frequency , the reflection acquires extra frequency - dependent phase shifts at the detuned carrier frequency and the sideband frequencies , respectively given by @xmath36 where @xmath37 and @xmath38 are the round - trip length and free spectral range of the cavity , and @xmath33 is the speed of light in vacuum . for simplicity ,
we transform into the rotating frame of the carrier frequency @xmath5 in the frequency domain , such that eqs . and become @xmath39 where @xmath40 and @xmath41 satisfy the commutation relations @xmath42 = 2\pi\delta(\omega-\omega^{'}),\ ] ] and all others vanish ( similarly for @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , @xmath47 , and @xmath48 ) . in the two - photon representation @xcite , the amplitude and phase quadratures of @xmath18
are defined by @xmath49,\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively ( similarly for @xmath19 , @xmath32 , @xmath50 , and @xmath51 ) . a little algebra yields the amplitude and phase quadrature fields of the reflected light in compact matrix form , @xmath52 where we use the two - photon matrix representation @xmath53 for the operator @xmath18 (
similarly for @xmath19 , @xmath32 , @xmath50 , and @xmath51 ) , @xmath54 is a matrix representing propagation through the cavity , and @xmath55 @xmath56 comprises an overall phase shift @xmath57 , rotation by angle @xmath58 , and attenuation by factor @xmath59 .
here we have defined @xmath60 , \\ a_{\pm } & \equiv & \frac{1}{2}\left[|r_c(\omega)|\pm l_{\pm } & \equiv & \frac{1}{2}\left[l_c(\omega_d+\omega ) \pm l_c(\omega_d-\omega)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the case of no carrier detuning ( @xmath61 ) , @xmath62 , and @xmath58 and a@xmath63 vanish , giving neither quadrature angle rotation nor asymmetrical amplitude attenuation . in the case of cavity detunings ( @xmath64 ) ,
nonzero @xmath58 gives quadrature angle rotation . from eq .
, when we perform homodyne detection of the reflected field with a local oscillator ( lo ) field , the measured amplitude and phase quadrature variances of the field , defined by @xmath65 and @xmath66 ( similarly for @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , and @xmath70 ) , are found in terms of the mode - matched input amplitude and phase quadrature variances @xmath67 and @xmath68 to be @xmath71 \left(\begin{array}{cc } 1\\1 \end{array}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & \hspace{-0.5 cm } + \eta_m ( 1-r_m^2 ) \left(\begin{array}{cc } 1 \\ 1 \end{array}\right ) + \eta_l \left(\begin{array}{cc } 1 \\ 1 \end{array}\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath72 and @xmath73 are the composite efficiencies of detection associated with the cavity - coupled and cavity - mismatched modes respectively , @xmath74 is the coupling of detection losses , and @xmath75 .
the detection efficiency is a product of the quantum efficiency of the photodiodes and the mode - overlap efficiency with the lo mode .
eq . can be rewritten in terms of the quadrature variances of the incident field @xmath76 since the cavity - coupled reflection @xmath77 and the mode - mismatch reflection @xmath78 originate from the same incident field @xmath76 , such that @xmath79 and therefore , @xmath80 \left(\begin{array}{cc } v_1^{a } \\
v_2^{a } \end{array}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & \hspace{-0.4cm}+ \left[1-\eta_c\left(a_+^2 + a_-^2\right ) - \eta_mr_m^2\right ] \left(\begin{array}{cc } 1\\1 \end{array}\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that if the input field is in a vacuum or coherent state such that @xmath81 , then @xmath82 , as expected , and no cavity information is contained in the output state @xmath32 . if the carrier frequency is detuned downward from the cavity resonance frequency , the cavity transmits only the upper sidebands within the cavity linewidth and replaces them by vacuum at those frequencies while reflecting the associated lower sidebands and all the other sidebands .
hence , the cavity - coupled reflected field is composed of the uncorrelated sidebands within the linewidth and the reflected correlated sidebands outside of it .
the consequence is the destruction of the correlation within the linewidth between the upper and lower quantum sidebands .
this is analogous to the destruction of the correlation between electro - optically modulated coherent sidebands in pairs , in which the beat between the carrier and the upper or lower sideband can be measured only when either sideband is absorbed into the cavity , reflecting the carrier and other sideband .
the beat could not be observed if all the fields were reflected .
similar measurements could be done with the transmission of the squeezed vacuum field through the cavity .
however , the signal - to - noise ratio would not be as good as in the reflection method because the background of the transmission signal is shot noise .
it is convenient to define the test cavity linewidth @xmath83 , the quality factor @xmath0 , and the finesse @xmath84 , as @xmath85 \nonumber\\ & \simeq & \frac{1-\sqrt{r_1r_2r_3}}{\pi(r_1 r_2 r_3)^{1/4}}\,\omega_{\rm fsr},\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath86 and @xmath87 respectively .
the approximations made in eqs . and are valid for high q cavities .
@xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath22 , and @xmath38 will be treated as free fitting parameters .
we also assume the input mirror is lossless such that @xmath90 . since we are interested in having as little light ( at the carrier frequency ) as possible in the test cavity , it is instructive to calculate the average photon number in the field we use .
the average photon number in squeezed light with squeeze factor @xmath91 and squeeze angle @xmath92 is given by @xcite @xmath93 where @xmath94 is the coherent amplitude of the light .
as the number of coherent photons becomes zero ( @xmath95 ) , resulting in squeezed vacuum , eq .
becomes @xmath96 this is the average photon number in squeezed vacuum generated by squeezing .
note that if the field is unsqueezed ( @xmath97 ) , @xmath98 .
for a squeeze factor of 1.5 corresponding to the squeezed or anti - squeezed level of @xmath99 db which is the current experimental limit @xcite , @xmath100 .
therefore , it is fair to say that the optical influence of ideal squeezed vacuum on cavities is negligible . and @xmath101 are shown as solid and dashed curves , respectively , for different input states .
( a ) and ( b ) show the ( impure ) input state with @xmath102 db and @xmath103 db , _ in the absence of the cavity_. ( c ) and ( d ) show the cavity - coupled response to the squeezed and anti - squeezed vacuum injection , respectively .
( e ) and ( f ) show the cavity - coupled response to injection of a classically noisy state with @xmath104 db , @xmath105 db . comparing ( e ) and ( c )
, we note that squeezing improves the signal contrast , but the classical noise and the anti - squeezed quadrature behave almost identically [ cf .
( d ) and ( f ) ] . ]
similarly , it is instructive to compare this technique to using a classical state . for simplicity , assuming that the quadrature variance in both quadratures is frequency - independent , we consider the case in which the lower sideband is fully transmitted through an impedance - matched cavity and the upper sideband is fully reflected at the input mirror such that @xmath106 and @xmath107 at @xmath108 , respectively , which gives @xmath109 from eq .
thus , the amplitude and phase quadrature variances of the reflected field are found to be @xmath110 in the absence of coherent light , the signal contrast can be defined as the quadrature variance at detuning frequency @xmath22 compared to the cavity - uncoupled quadrature variance at off - resonance frequencies ( @xmath111 ) , in which case @xmath112 and @xmath113 , and the signal contrasts at the two orthogonal quadratures are respectively given by @xmath114 in the limiting case of @xmath115 and @xmath116 , we obtain @xmath117 we see that @xmath118 has about the same limiting level as in the classical case , while @xmath119 grows if @xmath120 gets smaller .
classically , @xmath121 ( the shot noise limit ) , but using squeezed vacuum we can obtain @xmath122 , or improved signal contrast for a measurement in the squeezed quadrature .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ cl_vs_sq ] , where we compare the signal contrast for measurement of the cavity linewidth using a classical field with the signal contrast for squeezed field injection .
the cavity - coupled responses of the classical and anti - squeezed quadrature variances behave almost identically in the case of the impedance - matched cavity , whereas squeezing improves the signal contrast of the measurement .
it is important to note that even in the absence of technical noise , quadrature variance measurements are intrinsically contaminated by quantum noise itself .
the standard deviation of the quadrature variances is given by @xcite @xmath123 thus , the noise of the measurement is proportional to the measured value itself , and many averages can be performed to achieve smaller uncertainty levels .
this is different from the classical case where the parameters of a cavity are measured by measuring the transmission of a probe optical field incident on the cavity as a function of cavity detuning . in this case
, the measurements are fundamentally limited by shot noise : the number of measured photons ( n ) has uncertainty proportional to @xmath124 .
therefore , the signal - to - noise ratio grows as the number of the transmitted photons increases .
mhz and @xmath125 mhz respectively .
the squeezed vacuum generator is composed of an optical parametric oscillator ( opo ) and a second harmonic generator ( shg ) that pumps the opo .
the cavity length is locked to the laser frequency by the pdh - locking servo and pzt ( pzt2 ) .
the homodyne angle is locked by the noise - locking servo and pzt ( pzt1 ) . ]
the experiment is schematically shown in fig . [ setup ] .
the nd : yag laser ( lightwave model 126 ) gives an output of cw 700 mw at 1064 nm , which is injected into the squeezed vacuum generator ( squeezer ) .
the squeezer is composed of a second harmonic generator ( shg ) and an optical parametric oscillator ( opo ) , both using 5@xmath126 mgo : linbo@xmath29 nonlinear crystals placed within optical cavities ( hemilith for the shg and monolith for the opo ) in the type i phase - matching configuration .
the shg pumped by the nd : yag laser generates 250 mw at 532 nm , which then pumps the opo below threshold with a vacuum seed .
the resultant field generated by the opo is a squeezed vacuum field with a squeezing bandwidth of 66.2 mhz defined by the opo cavity linewidth .
a sub - carrier field , frequency - shifted by an acousto - optic modulator ( aom ) to a frequency that is coincident with the cavity tem@xmath127 mode , is injected into the other end of the opo cavity . the cavity is thus locked to the tem@xmath127 mode , offset by 220 mhz from the carrier frequency , using the pound - drever - hall ( pdh ) locking technique @xcite .
the frequency - shift is necessary to ensure that no cavity transmitted light at the fundamental frequency is injected into the opo cavity since it acts as a seed and degrades broadband squeezing due to the imperfect isolation of the faraday isolator @xcite .
this is especially important for high q cavities with linewidths as narrow as khz because low - frequency squeezing is difficult to achieve .
the squeezed vacuum is injected into a triangular test cavity with the fsr of 713 mhz and fwhm of @xmath2 khz , both measured by traditional methods using light .
the frequency shift , of the subcarrier is @xmath128 mhz so that the carrier frequency is detuned from the tem@xmath129 mode by @xmath130 mhz . as a result of this frequency shift ,
only the upper sidebands are within the cavity linewidth , destroying the correlation between the upper and lower sidebands and , therefore , destroying the squeezing or anti - squeezing .
this cavity - coupled squeezed vacuum reflection is measured by balanced homodyne detection , where the field to be measured interferes with a local oscillator ( lo ) field and is detected by two ( nearly ) identical photodetectors .
the difference of the two photodetector signals is sent to an hp4195a spectrum analyzer ( sa ) to measure the noise variance of the squeezed or anti - squeezed quadrature .
the results are shown in fig .
[ linewidth ] .
the experimental data are exponentially averaged 100 times .
the resolution bandwidth of the spectrum analyzer is 100 khz .
since the squeezed vacuum does not carry any coherent amplitude , the noise - locking technique @xcite is employed to lock the homodyne angle to either the squeezed or anti - squeezed quadrature at 2 mhz .
khz . ] before fitting the experimental data points , the homodyne efficiencies @xmath131 and @xmath132 , and the quantum efficiency of the photo - detectors @xmath133 need to be taken into account . the sum of the homodyne efficiencies and the quantum efficiency were independently measured to be @xmath134 and @xmath135 respectively . the sum of the efficiencies @xmath136 in eq . is given by @xmath137 .
we ignore @xmath132 since the cavity mode - matching efficiency is @xmath138 and hence @xmath139 , which yields @xmath140 .
moreover , we have assumed that the input mirror m@xmath141 is lossless .
this assumption is valid since it is a single - pass loss and does not influence the linewidth of the cavity .
we then fit eq . to the measured data points with free parameters @xmath88,@xmath142 , and @xmath22 ; both the data and the fits are shown in fig .
[ linewidth ] .
the resulting fitting values are @xmath143 , and @xmath144 mhz .
therefore , the fwhm linewidth of the cavity is found to be @xmath145 khz , which agrees with the classically measured linewidth of the cavity within the uncertainty ( @xmath2 khz ) .
we note that @xmath38 can be determined from the fit , but here we have used the optically measured value to estimate the linewidth .
this is valid because any loss in the cavity does not change the fsr .
we have proposed and experimentally demonstrated a method for non - invasive measurements of optical cavity parameters by use of squeezed vacuum .
the technique has the advantage over traditional optical methods that the injection of a squeezed vacuum field as a probe for cavity parameters does not excite any nonlinear processes in cavities , and is , therefore , useful for ultrahigh q cavities such as whispering gallery mode ( wgm ) cavities .
we have shown that when a squeezed vacuum field is injected into a detuned cavity , the linewidth and @xmath0 factor of a test cavity can be determined by measuring the destruction of upper and lower quantum sidebands with respect to the carrier frequency .
the linewidth of a test cavity is measured to be @xmath146 khz , which agrees with the classically measured linewidth of the cavity within the uncertainty ( @xmath147 khz ) .
we have also show that the use of squeezed fields leads to better signal contrast , as expected .
we would like to thank our colleagues at the ligo laboratory , especially thomas corbitt and christopher wipf , and stan whitcomb for his valuable comments on the manuscript .
we gratefully acknowledge support from national science foundation grant nos .
phy-0107417 and phy-0457264 .
|
we propose and experimentally demonstrate a method for non - invasive measurements of cavity parameters by injection of squeezed vacuum into an optical cavity .
the principle behind this technique is the destruction of the correlation between upper and lower quantum sidebands with respect to the carrier frequency when the squeezed field is incident on the cavity .
this method is especially useful for ultrahigh @xmath0 cavities , such as whispering gallery mode ( wgm ) cavities , in which absorption and scattering by light - induced nonlinear processes inhibit precise measurements of the cavity parameters . we show that the linewidth of a test cavity is measured to be @xmath1 khz , which agrees with the classically measured linewidth of the cavity within the uncertainty ( @xmath2 khz ) .
|
to enhance chemical reactivity of cu surfaces with nitrogen oxides ( no@xmath0 ) is an important issue for development of new catalytic materials effective in the no@xmath0 reduction process @xcite .
the dissociative adsorption of no@xmath0 , for example , was found to be less expected on cu , compared with highly reactive rh , ir , ru , co , and ni surfaces , although dissociative adsorption was reported at finite temperatures in experiments @xcite . in order to provide active surfaces for no dissociation ,
cu thin films and low index surfaces were considered on one hand @xcite . in several electronic structure calculations based on the density functional theory ( dft ) , on the other hand , dissociative adsorption of no was found to be possible but energetically un - favored compared with molecular adsorption @xcite .
we note that the simulations were often performed with respect to reactions on stable bulk surfaces .
although the theoretical data suggested less reactivity of cu bulk surfaces for no@xmath0 reduction , there could be remarkable reactivity on some surface - like atomic structures of cu .
when we considered wider classes of nano - scale structures other than defined surfaces of bulk cu crystals , one could find another clue . in this line of approach , indeed , many theoretical investigations with computer simulations had been done intending to explore efficiency of _
e.g. _ step - like structures of various metals @xcite . to explore possible no dissociation , we consider ultra thin cu structures . in this study , we focus on a cu atomic layer , that is the triangular lattice of cu .
we adopted structural optimization simulations based on electronic structure calculations to find a stable cu triangular lattice ( cu - tl ) . on this thin structure
, we adsorbed an no molecule and performed an optimization simulation . after finding molecular adsorbed structures , we searched possible dissociative adsorption on the cu structures . to find a possible reaction path and to conclude a reduction process , we performed simulations for reaction path estimation . in the discussion of this paper , by comparing the obtained adsorption energies with each other
, we will discuss a possible no@xmath0 reduction mechanism by using cu nano - structures .
we adopted the electronic structure calculation based on the density functional theory@xcite to estimate the electronic state , and to obtain inter - atomic forces . in this simulation ,
the kohn - sham wavefunctions were expanded in the plane - waves and the electron charge density was given both on a real space mesh and on the fourier mesh .
an approximation for the exchange - correlation energy functional by perdew , burke , and ernzerhof@xcite in the scheme of the generalized gradient approximation was adopted .
the ultra - soft pseudo - potential@xcite was utilized to describe the valence electron state .
all of our simulations were done using the simulation package , the quantum espresso @xcite .
the calculation conditions are summarized as follows . the energy cut - off for the wave function expansion was 30 [ ry ] , while the cut - off for the charge density was 240 [ ry ] .
the brillouin zone integration was done using a @xmath1 mesh of 8@xmath28@xmath21 for the largest super cell adopted .
these values were refined , if the computation facility allowed much accurate calculations .
the convergence criterion for the force constant was that the simulation ended , when the absolute value of the total force vector became less than 1@xmath210@xmath3 [ ry / a.u . ] .
to explore possible high reactivity of cu nano - structures , we considered atomic - layer structures . an important structure for our discussion is the cu triangular lattice ( cu - tl ) . in this section ,
we show data for structural and electronic properties of cu - tl .
we obtained an optimized lattice structure using a cu atomic layer in a primitive super cell .
major calculation conditions were the same as those given in section [ methods ] .
the @xmath1-point mesh was 24@xmath224@xmath21 in this simulation .
the cell was given in a hexagonal structure .
the vacuum layer had thickness of 15 . in this simulation ,
the value of the lattice constant was optimized .
the bond length was found to be 2.43 .
[ fig : cu - tl - ene - a ] ) this value is rather small compared to the bond length 2.55 of the bulk fcc cu .
the reason for shrink in the bond length is mainly to reduce the total band energy .
the total energy of tl was energetically higher than the bulk cu by 1.2 ev per a cu atom . of the triangular lattice of cu .
the value of @xmath4 in rydberg is given as a function of the lattice constant @xmath5[ ] . , height=302 ] starting from some initial conditions , we found appearance of cu - tl in optimized structures .
as another evidence to show the local stability of cu - tl , we considered an atomic two - layer structure ( atls ) .
this structure was obtained by cutting the bulk fcc cu crystal and was placed in a simulation super - cell .
the layer structure was perpendicular to the ( 100 ) direction of bulk cu and thus was contained in an orthorhombic unit cell .
energy difference between atls and cu - tl was 3.11 ev per a cu atom .
an optimization calculation of the structure concluded local stability .
but , atls was not kept against global reconstruction which was happened when an no molecule was adsorbed on it .
furthermore , we found a strongly reacted structure starting from an no molecule adsorbed on atls .
it means that using atls as an initial structure , naively speaking , we realized simulated annealing in our simulation .
compared with this un - stable structure , cu - tl was found to be stable .
once the molecule was adsorbed on atls , reconstruction of atls happened and formation of cu - tl was observed in our simulations .
conversely , we can say that cu - tl is stable against distortion making corrugation toward atls .
even when one observed local stability of an atomic structure in simulation , however , a final evidence of the structure would be requested to be given using real experiments .
realization of an atomically thin layer , _
i.e. _ cu - tl , will need development of a fabrication method .
recently , formation of an atomic layer of pb on the si(111 ) surface was reported @xcite . in this superconducting pb system ,
positions of pb atoms are affected by the atomic structure of the substrate and inter - atomic distance between pb atoms is not determined independently from the substrate .
the most remarkable example of natural realization of the atomic layer is graphene @xcite .
this unique flexible structure of carbon is possible to be supported in air according to the strong c - c sp@xmath6 bonding . peeling a graphene sheet and pasting it on a silicon - di - oxide surface
, graphene is obtained efficiently from graphite . in case of cu
, we may expect formation of an atomic layer on a suitable inert substrate
. we might be able to keep the atomic layer as a film pasted on a support with a nano - meter - scale hole .
then , mechanical properties of the atomic layer would be paid attention like a graphene sheet @xcite .
but for our consideration of no adsorption , a local structure of cu is important .
so , we assume an atomic - scale local structure in a part of nano - scale cu . the density of states ( dos ) of cu - tl is shown in fig .
[ fig : cu111 - 1-tetra ] .
the major peaks are characterized similarly to the bulk copper .
looking dos from the low energy region , we see that the 4s band starts from -6.38 ev and spreads over above the fermi energy .
sharp peaks of 3d levels are seen from -4.04 ev but the 3d bands end below the fermi level .
thus , parfectly filled 3d band with the @xmath7 configuration is kept and the structure behaves as an @xmath8 metal .
these characteristic features are seen in the electronic band structure of cu - tl , too .
[ fig : cu-2d - band ] ) along the @xmath9-m line , or the k-@xmath9 line , we see hybridization of the 4s band and a 3d band .
comparison with the cu ( 111 ) surface allows us to evaluate similarity and difference between cu - tl and the bulk cu surface .
the density of states in the 4s band leveled almost around 0.2 owing to two - dimensional nature .
dos in the 3d bands peaked well above 10 for cu - tl in the unit of states / ev per a unit cell , while the value is from 4 to 6 , except for a singularity at the top of the 3d bands , for the cu ( 111 ) surface .
the shorter bond length of cu atoms , the height in dos should be lower in a fixed lattice structure .
thus , the higher dos peak for cu - tl than for the bulk cu suggests that two - dimensional nature of cu - tl affects dos .
since dos at the fermi level is almost the same for both cu - tl and the cu ( 111 ) surface , the chemical reactivity of no is expected to be similar , if the structure is kept undeformed .
however , we should note that the top of cu 3d bands is much closer to the fermi energy for cu - tl than the cu ( 111 ) surface .
this tendency suggests higher reactivity of cu - tl against no .
when the stable adsorption site is the on - top site , similarity in characteristic energy like the adsorption energy would be expected . however , if a bridge site or a hollow site became stable for no on cu - tl , we could have difference even in the chemical reactivity from that on the cu ( 111 ) surface .
this is because much easy deformation of the cu network structure is expected for cu - tl and the bond formation between no and cu - tl will create distortion . in the next section ,
we discuss occurrence of strong reactions between no and cu - tl .
we consider adsorption of no on cu - tl and an atomic step like structure ( ass ) created on an cu atomic layer .
the second structure was found in optimization simulations of no adsorption on atls . observing results of no - adsorbed structures starting from atls
, we identified a stable substrate structure in a super cell as cu - tl with ass in our simulations .
therefore , we regarded cu - tl and ass as typical atomic - scale layer structures of cu .
several characteristic adsorption sites for no were found on these structures .
molecular adsorbed structures were obtained by structural optimization .
starting from an initial structure with a no molecule a little separated from a substrate , cu - tl , ass or atls , each adsorbed structure was determined . by a series of simulations
, we found the next general rules for molecular adsorption . on cu - tl , adsorption on a hollow site
is energetically most favorable . on ass ,
a bridge site on the cu array is energetically most favorable among sites including an on - top site , a hollow site in the back surface , and a bridge site in the back surface .
thus , we treat these locally stable structures only in the following discussion .
while , structures corresponding to dissociative adsorption were given by locating n and o atoms a little separated on the substrate and by optimizing the whole structure .
we have found two locally stable dissociative adsorbed structures on cu - tl and on ass .
the structures are depicted in fig .
[ fig : ss - sideview ] . as typical structures
, we consider these structures only .
we define the adsorption energy by the next formula .
@xmath10 here , @xmath11 is the molecular adsorption energy , while @xmath12 is the dissociative adsorption energy .
the values of @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the total energy of a cu slab with no and that of another slab with a n atom and an o atom adsorbed on the cu slab , @xmath15 is the total energy of a cu slab without no , and @xmath16 is the total energy of the no molecule contained in a super cell with the same size as the other calculations .
molecular dissociation energy is defined as , @xmath17 adsorbed structures found in our simulations are itemized in the next list .
the adsorption energy is also shown in each parenthesis for convenience .
molecular adsorption on cu - tl : : in adsorption of a no molecule on a surface of cu - tl , a hollow site ( -0.83 ev ) is selected .
see the center figure of fig .
[ fig : ss - sideview ] ( a ) .
molecular adsorption on ass : : in adsorption of a no molecule on an atomic step - like structure , a bridge site ( -1.32 ev ) is selected .
see the center figure of fig .
[ fig : ss - sideview ] ( b ) .
dissociative adsorption : : dissociative adsorption of no is found on tl ( -1.92 ev ) and on ass ( -1.69 ev ) .
see the right figures of fig .
[ fig : ss - sideview ] ( a ) and ( b ) .
now , dissociative adsorption structures are discussed .
we have two typical dissociative adsorption structures on cu - tl and on ass . in the first structure ,
the nitrogen atom locates at a center of five surrounding cu atoms .
( see the right figures of fig . [
fig : ss - sideview ] ( a ) . )
this structure may be regarded as a nitrogen interstitial impurity in a cu lattice .
arrangement of cu is largely distorted from pure tl , so that the n atom is embedded in cu layer .
the oxygen atom locates at a hollow site and it is embedded in cu layer .
the local structure of these impurity sites are ncu@xmath18 and ocu@xmath19 . here
, the ocu@xmath19 structure is planer .
a reason for appearance of the high coordination numbers for n and o is that cu valence is not largely modified and that 3d@xmath20 configuration is almost kept .
4s electrons are in extended states so that the local n@xmath3 and o@xmath21 are efficiently screened by neighboring five and four copper atoms . on ss
, we have another dissociative adsorbed structure for no .
the nitrogen atom is again embedded in the cu structure .
( see the right figure of fig .
[ fig : ss - sideview ] ( b ) . ) in this structure , the oxygen atom is at a bridge site and keeps two - fold coordination , while the nitrogen atom has four - fold coordination .
now we compare the obtained values of adsorption energy with those in the literature . the molecular adsorption energy is higher for ass than those on cu - tl . except for a case of a bond - center site on the back surface of ass
, molecular adsorption favors the bridge site of the step - like structure .
this general tendency is natural in comparison to the other examples known in the literature .
the most notable feature of our results is the finding of the large dissociative adsorption energy .
we conclude that the dissociative adsorption may happen , when the nitrogen atom can go to an interstitial site of a cu structure .
the large value of @xmath12 ( -1.92 ev on tl and -1.69 ev on ass ) is actually possible , since these structures possess high coordination of cu around the nitrogen atom . on the clean cu ( 111 ) surface ,
no favors the molecular adsorption ( with the adsorption energy of -1.22 ev estimated in ref .
@xcite ) against the dissociation of no , where the dissociative adsorption energy is estimated to be -0.79 ev in ref . @xcite .
the qualitative difference between data for known bulk surfaces and our result should be attributed on movement of cu atoms in the reconstruction process . in our simulation ,
positions of cu atoms are rather easily modified because the atomic structure of cu is just a single layer . even in the optimization simulation
, we can reach the nitrogen insertion in the cu structures . from the present result ,
we conjecture the following picture .
if a cu structure allows large configurational distortion owing to the chemical reaction with no , the nitrogen atom can move into the cu structure and form the local ncu@xmath22 configuration .
( @xmath23 or 5 . ) owing to the energy reduction coming from the large formation energy of the local ncu@xmath22 structure , we can expect even the dissociative adsorption of no on cu . in the real cu nano - structures
, there can happen large distortion of cu configuration owing to finite temperatures and possible local strain .
therefore , our simulation , which is prepared using the atomic layer of cu , might have derived a hidden possible path of the no dissociative adsorption on cu structures . to estimate a reaction path on the no reduction on cu - tl
, we estimated the local structure and the energy of a transition state using the nudged - elastic - band method .
the initial configuration was the molecular adsorbed structure on cu - tl and the final configuration was the dissociative adsorbed structure obtained in
[ ads - structure ] .
the dissociation reaction was determined by obtaining the transition state with an energy @xmath24 for the no reduction process .
the activation energy for dissociation of no on the atomic layer is estimated using the next definition .
@xmath25 an upper bound of the transition potential barrier is estimated to be 1.4 ev . in the initial state ,
the no molecule adsorbed on cu - tl with the nitrogen atom binding to the cu surface . in the transition state ,
the oxygen atom had local bond connections with surrounding cu atoms to reduce the total energy . to form this distorted structure in the transition state ,
the whole cu atomic configuration were optimized , creating drastic change in cu - tl .
utilizing the dft - gga simulations , we have shown that no dissociative adsorption may happen on an atomic cu layer , which is the triangular lattice of cu atoms ( cu - tl ) .
the reactivity of cu - tl against molecular adsorption of no was found to be similar to the cu(111 ) surface .
some stable sites for no were found to give molecular adsorption .
however , our optimization simulation revealed that there was a co - adsorbed structure of n and o atoms , which was energetically stabler by 1.08ev than the molecular adsorbed cu - tl structure .
a reaction path estimation showed existence of a path with an energy barrier of 1.4ev .
thus , we may conclude molecular dissociation of no on the cu atomic layer .
the large dissociation energy appears owing to formation of local n - cu or o - cu bondings and creation of local n - cu@xmath26 and o - cu@xmath22 structures .
we further considered an atomic step - like structure ( ass ) of cu , which was an atomic - scale wrinkle in the cu - tl structure .
the absolute value of the molecular adsorption energy on the step was larger than the values found for cu - bulk surfaces or cu - tl .
our simulation revealed that there existed a dissociative adsorbed structure in which a nitrogen impurity site embedded in a cu structure was created .
the estimated dissociation energy of no became -0.37 ev on ass .
flexibility against modification of this cu atomic structure in the nano - meter scale is decisive both to stabilize dissociative adsorption of no and to reduce the energy barrier on the no - reduction path .
catalytic activity of cu to reduce no should appear on the atomically flexible cu networks .
therefore , in order to realize cu - based no@xmath0 reduction catalysts , it is important to create atomic structures of cu , _
i.e. _ atomic layers , atomic scale clusters , and atomic scale networks , which allow conformational change .
this work was supported by the elements science and technology project and also by grant - in - aid for scientific research in priority area ( no .
19051016 ) and a grants - in - aid for scientific research ( no .
22360049 ) .
the computation is partly done using the computer facility of issp , univ . of tokyo , and ri2 t , kyushu university .
10 satterfied c n 1996 _ heterogeneous catalysis in industrial practice _ , 2nd ed .
( krieger publishing company , malabar ) brown w a and king d a 2000 _ j. phys . chem .
b _ * 104 * 2578 balkenende a r , gijzeman o l j and geus j w 1989 _ appl . surf .
* 37 * 189 godowski p j , onsgaard j , gagor a , kondys m and li z s 2005 _ chem .
lett . _ * 406 * 441 matllb m h and roberts m w 1977 _ j. chem . soc .
, faraday trans . _ * 73 * 1393 jonson d w , matloob m h and roberts m w 1979 _ j. chem .
, faraday trans . _ * 75 * 2143 so s k , franchy r and ho w 1991 _ j. chem .
phys . _ * 95 * 1385 damus p , suhren m , chabal y j , hirschmugl c j and williams g p 1997 _ surf .
sci . _ * 371
* 200 van daelen m a , li y s , newsam j m and van santen r a 1996 _ j. phys . chem . _ * 100 * 2279 gojdo@xmath27 m , hafner j and eichler a 2006 _ j. phys . : condens . matter _ * 18 * 41 gonzlez s , sousa c and illas f 2006 _ j. catal . _
* 239 * 431 yen m - y and ho j - j 2010 _ chem .
* 373 * 300 loffreda d , simon d and sauter p 2003 _ j. catal . _ * 213 * 211 hammer b 1998 _ faraday discuss . _
* 110 * 323 hammer b 1999 _ phys .
lett . _ * 83 * 3681 hammer b 2000 _ surf .
sci . _ * 459 * 323 hammer b 2001 _ j. catal . _ * 199 * 171 liu z p , jenkins s j and king d a 2003 _ j. am .
soc . _ * 125 * 14660 ge q and neurock m 2004 _ j. am .
soc . _ * 126 * 1551 backus e h g , eichler a , grecea m l , kleyn a w and bonn m 2004 _ j. chem . phys . _ * 121 * 7946 rempel j. greeley j. hansen l.b .
nielsen o.h .
nrskov j.k . and mavrikakis m. 2009 _ j. phys .
c _ * 113 * 20623 hohenberg p and kohn w 1964 _ phys .
rev . _ * 136 * b864 kohn w and sham l j 1965 _ phys .
rev . _ * 140 * a1133 giannozzi p , baroni s , bonini n , calandra m , car r , cavazzoni c , ceresoli d , chiarotti g l , cococcioni m , dabo i , dal corso a , de gironcoli s , fabris s , fratesi g , gebauer r , gerstmann u , gougoussis c , kokalj a , lazzeri m , martin - samos l , marzari n , mauri f , mazzarello r , paolini s , pasquarello a , paulatto l , sbraccia c , scandolo s , sclauzero g , seitsonen a p , smogunov a , umari p and wentzcovitch r m 2009 _ j. phys . : condens
. matter _ * 21 * 395502 perdew j p , burke k and ernzerhof m 1996 _ phys .
lett . _ * 77 * 3865 perdew j p , burke k and ernzerhof m 1997 _ phys .
lett . _ * 78 * 1396 vanderbilt d 1990 _ phys .
b _ * 41 * 7892 zhang t , cheng p , li w - j , sun , y - j , wang g , zhu x - g , he k ,
wang l , ma x , chen x , wang y , liu y , lin h - q , jia j - f , and xue q - k 2010 _ nature physics _ * 6 * 104 novoselov k s and geim a k 2004 _ science _ * 306 * 666 novoselov k s and geim a k 2005 _ nature _ * 438 * 197 mohr m , papagelis k , maultzsch j , and thomsen c 2009 _ phys . rev .
b _ * 80 * 205410
|
to investigate chemical reactivity of cu atomic - scale structures , we performed simulations based on the generalized gradient approximation in the density functional theory .
an atomic layer of cu forming a triangular lattice ( tl ) was found to give a stable structure .
the nitrogen monoxide molecule ( no ) was adsorbed on some atomic sites of tl or on an atomic step structure ( ass ) of cu .
the molecular adsorption energy on tl was -0.83 ev . our data suggested that dissociative adsorption of no with a dissociation energy of -1.08 ev was possible with an energy barrier of order 1.4 ev . in this optimized structure ,
the nitrogen and oxygen atoms were embedded in the cu layer . on the step ,
no adsorbed at a bridge site and the formation energy of cu-(no)-cu local bond connections was estimated to be around -1.32 ev .
molecular dissociation of no with a dissociation energy of -0.37 ev was also possible around ass .
|
there are reasons to believe that cosmic rays ( crs ) around the ankle at @xmath0 gev are dominated by extragalactic protons @xcite .
scattering processes in the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) limit the propagation of ultra high energy ( uhe ) charged particles in our universe .
a continuation of a power - like cr spectrum above the greisen - zatsepin - kuzmin ( gzk ) cutoff @xcite at about @xmath1 gev is only consistent with the proton dominance if the sources lie within the proton attenuation length of about 50 mpc .
very few astrophysical accelerators can generate crs with energies above the gzk cutoff ( see e.g. @xcite for a review ) and so far none of the candidate sources have been confirmed in our local environment .
it has been speculated that decaying superheavy particles , possibly some new form of dark matter or remnants of topological defects , could be a source of uhe crs , but also these proposals are not fully consistent with the cr spectrum at lower energies @xcite .
the observation of gzk excesses has led to speculations about a different origin of uhe crs .
berezinsky and zatsepin @xcite proposed that _
cosmogenic _ neutrinos produced in the decay of the gzk photopions could explain these events assuming a strong neutrino nucleon interaction .
we have followed this idea in ref .
@xcite and investigated the statistical goodness of scenarios with strongly interacting neutrinos from optically thin sources using cr data from agasa @xcite and hires @xcite ( see fig . [ cr ] ) and limits from horizontal events at agasa @xcite and contained events at rice @xcite .
-branes , and string excitations ( see ref .
@xcite ) . ]
the flux of uhe extragalactic protons from distant sources is redshifted and also subject to @xmath2 pair production and photopion - production in the cmb which can be taken into account by means of propagation functions .
the resonantly produced photopions provide a _ guaranteed _ source of cosmogenic uhe neutrinos observed at earth . in astrophysical accelerators inelastic scattering of the beam protons off the ambient photon gas in the source will also produce photopions which provide an additional source of uhe neutrinos . the corresponding spectrum will in general depend on the details of the source such as the densities of the target photons and the ambient gas @xcite .
we have used the flux of crs from _ optically thin _ sources using the luminosities given in ref .
@xcite in the goodness - of - fit test . for a reasonable and consistent contribution of extragalactic neutrinos in vertical crs
one has to assume a strong and rapid enhancement of the neutrino nucleon interaction .
the realization of such a behavior has been proposed in scenarios beyond the ( perturbative ) sm ( see ref .
@xcite ) . for convenience
, we have approximated the strong neutrino nucleon cross section in our analysis by a @xmath3-behavior shown in fig .
[ fig ] , parameterized by the energy scale and width of the transition , and the amplification compared to the standard model predictions .
our analysis showed that uhe crs measured at agasa and hires can be interpreted to the 90% cl as a composition of extragalactic protons and strongly interacting neutrinos from optically thin sources in agreement with experimental results from horizontal events at agasa and contained events at rice ( see fig .
[ fig ] ) .
the pierre auger observatory combines the experimental techniques of agasa and hires as a hybrid detector . with a better energy resolution , much higher statistics and also stronger bounds on horizontal showers
it will certainly help to clarify our picture of uhe crs in the future .
the author would like to thank the organizers of the erice school on nuclear physics 2005 _ `` neutrinos in cosmology , in astro , particle and nuclear physic '' _ for the inspiring workshop and vihkos ( _ `` virtuelles institut fr hochenergiestrahlungen aus dem kosmos '' _ ) for support .
m. ahlers , a. ringwald , and h. tu , _ astropart .
( to appear ) , preprint astro - ph/0506698 .
v. berezinsky , a. z. gazizov and s. i. grigorieva , preprint hep - ph/0204357 ; v. berezinsky , a. z. gazizov and s. i. grigorieva , .
m. ahlers _
et al . _ , .
k. greisen , ; g. t. zatsepin and v. a. kuzmin , .
d. f. torres and l. a. anchordoqui , .
d. v. semikoz and g. sigl , .
v. s. beresinsky and g. t. zatsepin , .
m. takeda _
et al . _ [ agasa ] , .
d. j. bird _
et al . _
[ hires ] , ; r. u. abbasi _ et al . _ [ hires ] , ; r. u. abbasi _ et al . _ [ hires ] , . s. yoshida _
_ [ agasa ] , .
|
the origin and chemical composition of ultra high energy cosmic rays is still an open question in astroparticle physics .
the observed large - scale isotropy and also direct composition measurements can be interpreted as an extragalactic proton dominance above the _ ankle _ at about @xmath0 gev .
photopion production of extragalactic protons in the cosmic microwave background predicts a cutoff at about @xmath1 gev in conflict with excesses reported by some experiments . in this report
we will outline a recent statistical analysis @xcite of cosmic ray data using strongly interacting neutrinos as primaries for these excesses .
|
a multistable system is one that possesses a large number of coexisting attractors for a fixed set of parameters .
there is ample evidence for such phenomena in the natural sciences , with examples coming from neurosciences and neural dynamics @xcite - @xcite , optics @xcite @xcite , chemistry @xcite @xcite @xcite , condensed matter @xcite and geophysics @xcite .
multistability also seems to be an essential complexity - generating mechanism in a large class of agent - based models @xcite . in view of this
, it is important to identify the dynamical mechanisms leading to multistability and , in particular , to construct simple models where this phenomenon might be under control .
the first mathematical result in this direction was obtained by newhouse @xcite
@xcite @xcite who proved that , near a homoclinic tangency , a class of diffeomorphisms in a two - dimensional manifold has infinitely many attracting periodic orbits ( sinks ) , a result that was later extended to higher dimensions @xcite .
it has also been proved @xcite that , in addition to infinitely many sinks , infinitely many strange attractors exist near the homoclinic tangencies .
the stability of the phenomena under small random perturbations has been studied @xcite @xcite .
a second dynamical mechanism leading to multistability is the addition of small dissipative perturbations to conservative systems .
conservative systems have a large number of coexisting invariant sets , namely periodic orbits , invariant tori and cantori . by adding a small amount of dissipation to a conservative system one finds that some of the invariant sets become attractors
. not all invariant sets of the conservative system will survive when the dissipation is added . however , for sufficiently small dissipation , many attractors ( mainly periodic orbits ) have been observed in typical systems @xcite @xcite @xcite .
the problem of migration between attractors and their stability in multiple - attractor systems has also been studied by other authors @xcite @xcite .
most of results are based on numerical evidence . however , using the techniques of deformation stability @xcite @xcite @xcite @xcite some rigorous mathematical results @xcite may be obtained .
finally , it has been found recently @xcite that , for parameter values near the feigenbaum period - doubling accumulation point , quadratic maps coupled by convex coupling may have a large number of stable periodic orbits .
this is one of the phenomena we study in detail in this paper .
the emphasis on quadratic maps near the feigenbaum accumulation point has a motivation close to the idea of control of chaos @xcite @xcite .
the typical situation in control of chaos , is that of a strange attractor with an infinite number of embedded periodic orbits , all of them unstable .
these orbits are then stabilized by several methods . if , instead of a large number of unstable periodic orbits , one has , for example , a large number of sinks , the controlling situation would seem more promising and robust , because the control need not be so accurate
. it would suffice to keep the system inside the desired basin of attraction . at the period - doubling accumulation point the feigenbaum attractor , because of the properties of the flip bifurcations , coexists with an infinite set of unstable periodic orbits . by coupling , as we will show , an arbitrarily large number of orbits may become stable .
the existence of a large number of stable periodic orbits for just two coupled quadratic maps , provides a simple model where multistability is well under control , in the sense that not only the nature of the phenomenon is completely understood as one may also compute the range of parameters that provides any desired number of stable orbits .
this should be contrasted , for example , with concrete models for the newhouse phenomenon @xcite . rather than merely focusing on multistability
, we also study the phenomenology of two coupled quadratic maps , in particular the bifurcations of periodic orbits and the regime of synchronization .. the stabilization of orbits in the coupled system is similar to that obtained in higher dimensional coupled map lattices @xcite with the exception that , due to the restricted dimension of the phase space , the types of bifurcations are different in our system . the results concerning the multistability phenomenon at @xmath0 also considerably extend , and also correct , some imprecise statements in @xcite .
coupled map lattices ( cml ) are discrete dynamical systems generated by the composition of a local nonlinearity and a coupling .
the phase space of the cml considered in this letter is the square @xmath1^{2}$ ] and the dynamics is generated by the map @xmath2 defined as follows . given a point @xmath3 , its image by @xmath2 , denoted @xmath4 is given by @xmath5 where @xmath6 , @xmath7 and @xmath8 .
the map @xmath9 maps @xmath1 $ ] into itself .
therefore , the convex combination in ( [ def ] ) ensures that @xmath10^{2})\subset [ -1,1]^{2}$ ] and the dynamics is well - defined .
we denote the orbit issued from the initial condition @xmath11 by the sequence @xmath12 , that is to say , @xmath13 and @xmath14 for all @xmath15 . for the sake of simplicity
, we will often employ the variables @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
the previous notation of orbits also applies to these variables for which relation ( [ def ] ) becomes @xmath18 where @xmath19 .
finally , note that the dynamics commutes with the symmetry @xmath20 or @xmath21 in the original variables .
if @xmath22 , then @xmath23 and @xmath24 . in this case , the orbit is said to be synchronized ( from @xmath25 on ) .
more generally , an orbit is said to synchronize if @xmath26 and if all orbits synchronize , then we say to have synchronization of the map .
synchronization is the simplest dynamical regime exhibited by two - dimensional cml . to determine a sufficient condition for synchronization in our system
, we note that for any orbit , one has @xmath27 for all @xmath15 .
it follows from ( [ def2 ] ) that the condition @xmath28 ensures an exponential decay of @xmath29 , and hence synchronization .. since @xmath30 , the condition @xmath28 is equivalent to the following ones ( see figure 1 ) .
@xmath31 from now on , we assume that @xmath32 .
the condition @xmath33 is not necessary . indeed ,
if for instance @xmath34 , then @xmath9 has an attracting fixed point in @xmath1 $ ] , and one can prove that synchronization occurs .
when @xmath35 is sufficiently small , this happens even though @xmath36 .
starting from synchronization and modifying the parameters , non - synchronized ( periodic ) orbits appear from bifurcations of synchronized ( periodic ) ones . to understand this phenomenon , as well as the bifurcations of subsequent orbits ,
we now study analytically the periodic orbits of period 1 and 2 .
let @xmath37 be the synchronized fixed point denoted in @xmath38-variables .
it exists for any values of the parameters and @xmath2 has no other fixed point in @xmath1^{2}$ ] . in @xmath38-variables ,
the jacobian of @xmath39 at this fixed point is diagonal .
one eigenvalue is @xmath40 and the corresponding eigendirection is the diagonal @xmath41 .
the other eigenvalue is @xmath42 and the corresponding direction , orthogonal to the diagonal is referred as the anti - diagonal .
the condition @xmath43 then determines a period - doubling bifurcation , which is of co - dimension 1 if @xmath44 .
this is the well - known period - doubling bifurcation of @xmath9 which creates a synchronized period-2 orbit of @xmath2 .
moreover , one checks that the derivative @xmath45 is negative for any @xmath46 .
hence the conditions @xmath44 and @xmath47 , i.e. @xmath48 determine another co - dimension 1 period - doubling bifurcation of the synchronized fixed point .
indeed the conditions of the corresponding bifurcation theorem ( see e.g. @xcite ) are satisfied when the curve @xmath49 is crossed upward . the period-2 orbit created at this
bifurcation is non - synchronized and symmetric . to show this ,
denote by @xmath50 and @xmath51 its components . since the multiplier @xmath42 is negative and
the bifurcating direction is the anti - diagonal , we have @xmath52 ( sufficiently close to the bifurcation ) .
because of the @xmath53 symmetry , the map @xmath2 also has a period-2 orbit with components @xmath54 and @xmath55 . consequently if @xmath56 , the system would have two periodic orbits created by a co - dimension 1 bifurcation .
this is impossible by the unicity in the bifurcation theorem .
therefore , sufficiently close to the bifurcation , we have @xmath57 and @xmath58 which is the desired conclusion . by continuity in the parameters of @xmath2 , sufficiently close to the bifurcation ,
this symmetric orbit is stable with respect to perturbations in one direction ( the anti - diagonal direction at the bifurcation ) and since @xmath59 , it is unstable in the direction orthogonal to the latter .
the bifurcations will now be computed .
the orbit with @xmath60 and @xmath58 exists for any @xmath61 and is the unique ( up to time translations ) period-2 non - synchronized symmetric orbit of @xmath2 in @xmath1^{2}$ ] .
computing the corresponding jacobian , one obtains the equation for the multipliers @xmath62 \lambda + \left ( 1 - 2\varepsilon \right ) ^{2}(s^{2}-d^{2})^{2}=0\ ] ] where @xmath63 direct calculations show that , if @xmath64 , the multipliers , say @xmath65 and @xmath66 , have zero imaginary part iff @xmath67 . under this condition
, we have @xmath68 if @xmath69 and @xmath70 iff @xmath71 .
( the inequality @xmath72 indeed holds if @xmath73 and @xmath74 , see figure 1 . )
consequently , by increasing @xmath46 , the symmetric orbit suffers an inverse pitchfork bifurcation at @xmath75
. this bifurcation is generic for a symmetric orbit in a system with symmetry @xcite and the conditions of the bifurcation theorem hold when the curve @xmath76 is crossed upward .
this bifurcation creates two non - symmetric period-2 orbits ( one orbit and its symmetric ) .
we have checked that these orbits exist for any @xmath77 and @xmath78 . for @xmath79 ,
their components are combinations of a fixed point of @xmath9 and the components of a period-2 orbit . when the imaginary part of @xmath80 and @xmath81 is not zero , we have @xmath82 .
( once again , if @xmath73 and @xmath83 , the inequality @xmath84 is satisfied , see figure 1 . )
the symmetric orbit is thus stable in the interval @xmath85 .
if @xmath44 and the curve @xmath86 is crossed upward , this orbit suffers a hopf bifurcation creating a locally stable invariant circle .
a numerical calculation shows that the latter is destroyed when @xmath46 is sufficiently large or when @xmath87 is sufficiently small . obviously ,
if @xmath79 , it does not exist and the bifurcation at @xmath88 which is a period - doubling bifurcation of @xmath9 creates a period-4 orbit . note that invariant circles in two - dimensional cml resulting from the destabilization of a symmetric orbit and their normal form had already been reported in @xcite . in that work , the system is also defined by ( [ def ] ) , but the local map is @xmath89 and @xmath35 may be larger than @xmath90 .
figure 2 shows an example of the phenomenology described above .
numerically , it is more convenient to follow the orbits from @xmath79 to increasing values of the coupling . in this picture , as well as in the following ones the map parameter is @xmath0 ( the accumulation point of the period - doubling cascade ) . in figure 2 , from @xmath79 ( the circle ) to @xmath91 ( the point labelled 1 ) , the symmetric orbit is unstable .
the figure also shows the invariant circle for @xmath92 . between the points 1 and 2 ,
the symmetric orbit is stable . at point 2 ,
the pitchfork occurs , the symmetric orbit becomes unstable and the non - symmetric orbits are created .
finally , the point 3 ( @xmath93 ) corresponds to the collapse on the synchronized fixed point .
the previous phenomenology is not restricted to small periods but extend to any power of 2 .
in particular , the synchronized period-@xmath94 orbit may destabilize to create a symmetric ( non - synchronized ) orbit of twice the period .
given @xmath95 , let @xmath96 be the components of the period-@xmath94 orbit of @xmath9 .
the points @xmath97 are the components of the synchronized period-@xmath94 orbit of @xmath39 . by the chain rule and
since each jacobian at @xmath98 is diagonal , the corresponding multiplier along the anti - diagonal direction is @xmath99 the condition that this multiplier equals @xmath100 determines , if @xmath44 , a co - dimension 1 period - doubling bifurcation . applying the reasoning of the previous section to each component @xmath98 ,
we conclude that this bifurcation creates an orbit with the property @xmath101 and @xmath102 for all @xmath15 , which is called a phase - opposition period-@xmath103 orbit .
since @xmath104 , this bifurcation occurs only if the bifurcation along the diagonal direction has occurred ( the local period - doubling bifurcation of @xmath96 ) . in other words , the phase opposition period-@xmath94 orbit exists only if the synchronized period-@xmath94 orbit does .
moreover it follows from figure 3 that , at least for @xmath0 , the phase opposition period-@xmath103 orbit exists only if the phase opposition period-@xmath94 orbit does .
this is confirmed analytically for the period@xmath105 orbit whose existence condition is the instability of the synchronized period@xmath106 orbit in the anti - diagonal direction .
one obtains @xmath107 and @xmath108 if @xmath109 and @xmath110 and @xmath111 if @xmath112 ( see figure 1 ) .
furthermore , a numerical calculation at @xmath0 , reported in figure 3 , shows that the succession of bifurcations of a phase opposition orbit does not depend on the period . on this picture , we have plotted the values of @xmath35 for the hopf bifurcation , the pitchfork bifurcation and the period - doubling bifurcation creating the orbit , versus the power of the period . for each period , the phenomenology is identical to that described in the previous section , with an adequate change of scale in @xmath87 .
in addition , the picture shows that several phase opposition orbits may be stable for @xmath44 fixed .
this stabilization is an effect of the coupling that will be discussed below .
finally , since the phase opposition orbits are the first orbits to appear when the parameters are varied from synchronization and since the first such orbit that is created is of period 2 , it follows that a necessary and sufficient condition for synchronization is @xmath113 , the condition for the existence of the latter .
we now analyze the existence and the stability of other period-@xmath94 orbits for @xmath0 .
our interest for this value of @xmath46 is that the scaling properties of @xmath9 are reflected on scaling laws for the periods and values of @xmath35 at which the bifurcations occur ( see figure 3 and 8) .
we only consider the orbits which for @xmath79 have the same period on projection to both axis @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
these orbits are followed numerically when @xmath35 increases and are referred using the phase shift of their components at @xmath79 . for @xmath0 ,
the map @xmath9 has a period-@xmath94 orbit for each @xmath116 , whose components for @xmath117 up to 5 are shown in figure 5 . in this picture , the numbers reflect the order in which the components are visited and the tree structure represents the origin of each component in the bifurcation cascade . an important notion is the dyadic distance @xmath118 between the components of an orbit .
@xmath118 is the number of steps one has to go back in the bifurcation tree to meet a common component .
the dyadic distance is used to characterize the families of periodic orbits that we are considering . for instance , the coordinates of each component of a synchronized orbit are at distance 0 , those of a phase - opposition orbit are at distance 1 .
accordingly , when we speak of distance@xmath119 orbit we refer to the dyadic distance of the coordinates of its components . for any @xmath120
, there are @xmath121 different orbits with distance @xmath118 which have coordinates out of phase by @xmath122 steps , with @xmath123 .
the distance of a period-@xmath124 orbit is at most @xmath117 ( @xmath125 ) . for @xmath79 ,
the only symmetric orbits are those at distance 0 and 1 .
this property is preserved for @xmath44 as shows figure 6 for @xmath126 .
the succession of bifurcations of orbits with distance @xmath127 should then differ from those with distance 1 .
the differences are seen in figure 6 which shows the evolution of the eigenvalues . for @xmath79 ,
the orbit is unstable .
when @xmath35 increases , it suffers two collisions with orbits of twice the period when the eigenvalues cross @xmath100 and then becomes stable .
( when decreasing @xmath35 , these collisions would be period - doubling bifurcations . ) if @xmath35 increases further , the orbit collides with an unstable one of the same period in a saddle - node bifurcation when the larger eigenvalue reaches 1 . for larger values of @xmath87
, the orbit does not exist .
the unstable orbit with which it collides is the one that at @xmath79 has period @xmath94 in one projection and @xmath128 in the other .
for higher dyadic distances , the overall variation of the eigenvalues is similar to the @xmath129 case .
figure 7 shows a typical example of these phenomena for the case @xmath129 . between @xmath79 and the point
labelled 1 in the figure , the orbit is unstable .
the point 1 corresponds to the smaller eigenvalue crossing -1 ( see figure 6 ) .
therefore , between the point 1 and 2 , the orbit is stable .
it disappear at the point 2 when it collides with an unstable orbit of the same period .
we have seen that the coupling stabilizes the orbits with distance larger than 0 at @xmath0 .
there are indeed two mechanisms responsible for this stabilization .. the determinant of the jacobian of a period-@xmath94 orbit is @xmath130 the term @xmath131 coming from the coupling decreases when @xmath117 increases .
however , there is yet a second stabilizing mechanism .
denote by @xmath132 the remaining factor in the determinant @xmath133 without coupling , @xmath134 is simply the square of the multiplier of @xmath9 for the periodic orbit . from the properties of the feigenbaum - cvitanovic functional equation it follows @xcite that this factor converges to a fixed value around @xmath135 when @xmath117 increases .
the coupling however , changes the position of the orbit components in such a way that this factor also decreases .
it is the combined action of this decrease with the contraction of the coupling that brings the eigenvalues into the interior of the unit circle and stabilizes the orbits . for small @xmath35
there is a simple geometrical interpretation for the variation of @xmath136 .
the reason why in the one dimensional map the product @xmath137 remains constant , when @xmath117 grows , is because each time the period doubles , the doubling in the number of factors greater than one is compensated by the fact that the component of the orbit closest to zero approaches zero a little more . for the unstable orbits along the period - doubling chain , the orbit components closest to zero alternate on each side of the origin .
the contracting effect of the convex coupling tends to bring the orbits back in the period - doubling hierarchy .
therefore , because the component closest to zero has to move across the origin for the orbit to approach the one with half the period , this implies that the product of the coordinates is going to decrease . the greater the dyadic distance between the orbit projections on the axis , the greater will be the perturbation that the original ( one - dimensional ) orbits suffer .
therefore one expects the contracting effect in @xmath136 to increase with the dyadic distance .
this effect is quite apparent on figure 8 which shows the stabilizing and destabilizing lines for orbits with distance from 1 to 4 .
the shift downwards of the stable regions for successively larger dyadic distances implies that the smaller @xmath35 is , the larger the number of distinct stable orbits that are obtained .
an accurate numerical estimate of the number of distinct orbits is obtained by computing the derivative @xmath138 at @xmath79 for each @xmath117 and dyadic distance @xmath139 .
actually this derivative provides an accurate estimate of @xmath140 itself , because this one varies almost linearly with @xmath35 for most of the stable range of the orbits . on figure 9 , the scaling properties ,
when @xmath117 grows , of this derivative are shown . from these results
one computes @xmath141 with @xmath142 notice that in figure 9 there is more than one data point for each pair @xmath143 which correspond to non - equivalent orbits with the same dyadic distance . * the value of the smallest @xmath35 parameter that stabilizes an orbit of dyadic distance @xmath118 equal to the power @xmath117 @xmath144 * the value of the largest @xmath35 parameter for which a @xmath145 orbit is stable @xmath146 from this , one obtains the result that at least @xmath147 distinct stable orbits are obtained if @xmath148 @xmath147 is only a lower bound on the number of distinct stable periodic orbits , because here we have studied only orbits with the same period under projection in the two axis . in conclusion : _ for sufficiently small _
@xmath35 _ _ an arbitrarily large number of distinct stable periodic orbits is obtained__. however , for any fixed @xmath35 , it is an arbitrarily large number that is obtained , not an infinite number .
most orbits either synchronize ( and are then unstable ) or disappear as @xmath35 grows . as a result ,
a reasoning based on the implicit function theorem , as used in @xcite is misleading . given a sequence of orbits of different periods , even if they remain as orbits for a small perturbation , that does not mean that their ( smallest ) periods remain distinct .
|
the phenomenology of a system of two coupled quadratic maps is studied both analytically and numerically .
conditions for synchronization are given and the bifurcations of periodic orbits from this regime are identified .
in addition , we show that an arbitrarily large number of distinct stable periodic orbits may be obtained when the maps parameter is at the feigenbaum period - doubling accumulation point .
an estimate is given for the coupling strength needed to obtain any given number of stable orbits .
|
in solid - core photonic crystal fibers ( pcf ) the air - silica microstructured cladding ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) gives rise to a variety of novel phenomena @xcite including large - mode area ( lma ) endlessly - single mode operation @xcite .
though pcfs typically have optical properties very different from that of standard fibers they of course share some of the overall properties such as the susceptibility of the attenuation to macro - bending .
macrobending - induced attenuation in pcfs has been addressed both experimentally as well as theoretically / numerically in a number of papers @xcite . however , predicting bending - loss is no simple task and typically involves a full numerical solution of maxwell s equations as well as use of a phenomenological free parameter , _
e.g. _ an effective core radius . in this paper
we revisit the problem and show how macro - bending loss measurements on high - quality pcfs can be predicted with high accuracy using easy - to - evaluate empirical relations .
predictions of macro - bending induced attenuation in photonic crystal fibers have been made using various approaches including antenna - theory for bent standard fibers @xcite , coupling - length criteria @xcite , and phenomenological models within the tilted - index representation @xcite . here
, we also apply the antenna - theory of sakai and kimura @xcite , but contrary to refs .
@xcite we make a full transformation of standard - fiber parameters such as @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath0 @xcite to fiber parameters appropriate to high - index contrast pcfs with a triangular arrangement of air holes . in the large - mode area
limit we get ( see appendix ) @xmath3 for the power - decay , @xmath4 , along the fiber . for a conversion to a db - scale @xmath5 should be multiplied by @xmath6 . in eq .
( [ alpha_lma ] ) , @xmath7 is the bending radius , @xmath8 is the effective area @xcite , @xmath9 is the index of silica , and @xmath10 is the recently introduced effective v - parameter of a pcf @xcite .
the strength of our formulation is that it contains no free parameters ( such as an arbitrary core radius ) and furthermore empirical expressions , depending only on @xmath11 and @xmath12 , have been given recently for both @xmath8 and @xmath13 @xcite . from the function
@xmath14 we may derive the parametric dependence of the critical bending radius @xmath15 .
the function increases dramatically when the argument is less than unity and thus we may define a critical bending radius from @xmath16 where @xmath17 . typically the pcf is operated close to cut - off where @xmath18 @xcite so that the argument may be written as @xmath19 this dependence was first reported and experimentally confirmed by birks
_ et al . _
@xcite and recently a pre - factor of order unity was also found experimentally in ref .
we have fabricated three lma fibers by the stack - and - pull method and characterized them using the conventional cut - back technique .
all three fibers have a triangular air - hole array and a solid core formed by a single missing air - hole in the center of the structure , see fig .
[ fig1 ] . for the lma-20 macro - bending loss has been measured for bending radii of r=8 cm and r=16 cm and
the results are shown in fig .
the predictions of eq .
( [ alpha_lma ] ) are also included .
it is emphasized that the predictions are based on the empirical relations for @xmath8 and @xmath13 provided in refs . @xcite and @xcite respectively and therefore do not require any numerical calculations .
similar results are shown in figs .
[ fig3 ] and [ fig4 ] for the lma-25 and lma-35 fibers , respectively .
the pcf , in theory , exhibits both a short and long - wavelength bend - edge .
however , the results presented here only indicate a short - wavelength bend - edge .
the reason for this is that the long - wavelength bend - edge occurs for @xmath20 @xcite . for typical lma - pcfs
it is therefor located in the non - transparent wavelength regime of silica .
in conclusion we have demonstrated that macro - bending loss measurements on high - quality pcfs can be predicted with good accuracy using easy - to - evaluate empirical relations with only @xmath21 and @xmath22 as input parameters .
since macro - bending attenuation for many purposes and applications is the limiting factor we believe that the present results will be useful in practical designs of optical systems employing photonic crystal fibers .
the starting point is the bending - loss formula for a gaussian mode in a standard - fiber @xcite @xmath23 where @xmath8 is the effective area , @xmath24 is the core radius , @xmath7 is the bending radius , and the standard - fiber parameters are given by @xcite @xmath25 substituting these parameters into eq .
( [ alpha1 ] ) we get @xmath26 in the relevant limit where @xmath27 . here ,
@xmath28 and @xmath29 in eqs . ( [ alpha_lma ] ) and ( [ v_pcf ] ) have been introduced . for large - mode area fibers we make a further simplification for the isolated propagation constant ; using that @xmath30 we arrive at eq .
( [ alpha_lma ] ) .
m. d. nielsen acknowledges financial support by the danish academy of technical sciences .
|
we report on an easy - to - evaluate expression for the prediction of the bend - loss for a large mode area photonic crystal fiber ( pcf ) with a triangular air - hole lattice .
the expression is based on a recently proposed formulation of the v - parameter for a pcf and contains no free parameters .
the validity of the expression is verified experimentally for varying fiber parameters as well as bend radius . the typical deviation between the position of the measured and the predicted bend loss edge is within measurement uncertainty . 10 url # 1`#1`urlprefix[2][]#2 j. c. knight , `` photonic crystal fibres , '' nature * 424 * , 847851 ( 2003 ) .
t. a. birks , j. c. knight , and p. s. j. russell , `` endlessly single mode photonic crystal fibre , '' opt . lett .
* 22 * , 961963 ( 1997 ) .
t. srensen , j. broeng , a. bjarklev , e. knudsen , and s. e. b. libori , `` macro - bending loss properties of photonic crystal fibre , '' electron . lett . * 37 * , 287289 ( 2001 ) .
t. srensen , j. broeng , a. bjarklev , t. p. hansen , e. knudsen , s. e. b. libori , h. r. simonsen , and j. r. jensen , `` spectral macro - bending loss considerations for photonic crystal fibres , '' iee proc .- opt .
* 149 * , 206 ( 2002 ) .
n. a. mortensen and j. r. folkenberg , `` low - loss criterion and effective area considerations for photonic crystal fibers , '' j. opt . a : pure appl . opt . * 5 * , 163167 ( 2003 ) .
j. c. baggett , t. m. monro , k. furusawa , v. finazzi , and d. j. richardson , `` understanding bending losses in holey optical fibers , '' opt .
commun .
* 227 * , 317335 ( 2003 ) .
j. sakai and t. kimura , `` bending loss of propagation modes in arbitrary - index profile optical fibers , '' appl . opt . *
17 * , 14991506 ( 1978 ) .
j. sakai , `` simplified bending loss formula for single - mode optical fibers , '' appl . opt .
* 18 * , 951952 ( 1979 ) .
a. w. snyder and j. d. love , _ optical waveguide theory _
( chapman & hall , new york , 1983 ) .
n. a. mortensen , `` effective area of photonic crystal fibers , '' opt .
express * 10 * , 341348 ( 2002 ) .
http://www.opticsexpress.org/abstract.cfm?uri=opex-10-7-341 .
n. a. mortensen , j. r. folkenberg , m. d. nielsen , and k. p. hansen , `` modal cut - off and the @xmath0parameter in photonic crystal fibers , '' opt . lett . * 28 * , 18791881 ( 2003 ) .
m. d. nielsen , n. a. mortensen , j. r. folkenberg , and a. bjarklev , `` mode - field radius of photonic crystal fibers expressed by the @xmath0parameter , '' opt
. lett .
* 28 * , 23092311 ( 2003 ) . m. d. nielsen and n. a. mortensen , `` photonic crystal fiber design based on the @xmath0parameter , '' opt .
express * 11 * , 27622768 ( 2003 ) .
http://www.opticsexpress.org / abstract.cfm?uri = opex-11 - 21 - 2762% [ http://www.opticsexpress.org / abstract.cfm?uri = opex-11 - 21 - 2762% ] .
|
among the great variety of the works devoted to random motions at finite speed in the euclidean spaces @xmath8 ( see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite for the markovian case and @xcite , @xcite for different non - markovian cases ) , the markov random flight in the three - dimensional euclidean space @xmath1 is , undoubtedly , the most difficult and hard to study .
while in the low even - dimensional spaces @xmath9 and @xmath10 one managed to obtain the distributions of the motions in an explicit form ( see @xcite , @xcite and @xcite , respectively ) , in the important three - dimensional case only a few results are known .
the absolutely continuous part of the transition density of the symmetric markov random flight with unit speed in the euclidean space @xmath1 was presented in ( * ? ? ?
* formulas ( 1.3 ) and ( 4.21 ) therein ) .
it has an extremely complicated form of an integral with variable limits whose integrand involves inverse hyperbolic tangent function .
this formula has so complicated form that can not even be evaluated by means of standard computer environments .
moreover , the lack of the speed parameter in this formula impoverishes somewhat the model because it does not allow to study the limiting behaviour of the motion under various scaling conditions ( under kac s condition , for example ) .
the presence of both parameters ( i.e. the speed and the intensity of switchings ) in any process of markov random flight makes it , undoubtedly , the most adequate and realistic model for describing the finite - velocity diffusion in the euclidean spaces .
these parameters can not be considered as independent because they are connected with each other through the time ( namely , the speed is the distance passed _ per unit of time _ and the intensity is the mean number of switchings _ per unit of time _ ) .
another question concerning the density presented in @xcite is the infinite discontinuity at the origin @xmath11 . while the infinite discontinuity of the transition density on the border of the diffusion area is a quite natural property in some euclidean spaces of low dimensions ( see @xcite for the euclidean plane @xmath12 and ( * ? ? ?
* the second term of formulas ( 1.3 ) and ( 4.21 ) ) , @xcite , ( * ? ? ?
* formula ( 3.12 ) ) in the space @xmath1 ) , the discontinuity at the origin looks somewhat strange and hard to explain .
the difficulty of analysing the three - dimensional markov random flight and , on the other hand , the great theoretical and applied importance of the problem of describing the finite - velocity diffusion in the space @xmath1 suggest to look for other methods of studying this model .
that is why various asymptotic theorems yielding a good approximation would be a fairly desirable aim of the research .
such asymptotic results could be obtained by using the characteristic functions technique . in the case of the three - dimensional symmetric markov random flight
some important results for its characteristic functions were obtained . in particular , the closed - form expression for the laplace transform of the characteristic function was obtained by different methods in ( * ? ? ?
* formulas ( 1.6 ) and ( 5.8 ) ) ( for unit speed ) and in ( * ? ? ?
* formula ( 45 ) ) , @xcite ( for arbitrary speed ) . a general relation for the conditional characteristic functions of the three - dimensional symmetric markov random flight conditioned by the number of changes of direction ,
was given in ( * ? ? ?
* formula ( 3.8 ) ) .
the key point in these formulas is the possibility of evaluating the inverse laplace transforms of the powers of the inverse tangent functions in the complex right half - plane .
this is the basic idea of deriving the series representations of the conditional characteristic functions corresponding to two and three changes of direction given in section 3 .
based on these representations , an asymptotic formula , as time @xmath5 , for the unconditional characteristic function is obtained in section 4 and the error in this formula has the order @xmath6 .
the inverse fourier transformation of the unconditional characteristic function yields an asymptotic formula for the transition density of the process which is presented in section 5 .
this formula shows that the density is discontinuous on the border , but it is continuous at the origin @xmath11 , as it must be .
the unexpected |