article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
monte carlo methods @xcite appeared about sixty years ago with the need to evaluate numerical values for various complex problems .
these methods evolved and were applied early to quantum problems , thus putting within reach exact numerical solutions to non - trivial quantum problems @xcite .
many improvements of these methods followed , avoiding critical slowing down near phase transitions and allowing to work directly in the continuous imaginary time limit @xcite . in recent years ,
interest in methods that work in the canonical ensemble with global updates yet allow access to green functions has intensified @xcite .
however , a method that works well for a given hamiltonian often needs major modifications for another .
for example , the addition of a 4-site ring exchange term in the bosonic hubbard model required special developments for a treatment by the stochastic series expansion algorithm @xcite , as well as by the wordline algorithm @xcite .
this can result in long delays .
it is , therefore , advantageous to have at one s disposal an algorithm that can be applied to a very wide class of hamiltonians without requiring any changes . in a recent publication @xcite ,
the stochastic green function ( sgf ) algorithm was presented , which meets this goal .
the algorithm can be applied to any lattice hamiltonian of the form @xmath3 where @xmath1 is diagonal in the chosen occupation number basis and @xmath2 has only positive matrix elements .
this includes all kinds of systems that can be treated by other methods presented in ref.@xcite , for instance bose - hubbard models with or without a trap , bose - fermi mixtures in one dimension , heisenberg models ... in particular hamiltonians for which the non - diagonal part @xmath2 is non - trivial ( the eigen - basis is unknown ) are easily treated , such as the bose - hubbard model with ring exchange @xcite , or multi - species hamiltonians in which a given species can be turned into another one ( see eq.([twospecies ] ) and fig .
[ density ] and [ momentum ] for a concrete example ) .
systems for which it is not possible to find a basis in which @xmath1 is diagonal and @xmath2 has only positive matrix elements are said to have a `` sign problem '' , which usually arises with fermionic and frustrated systems . as other qmc methods , the sgf algorithm does not solve this problem . the algorithm allows to measure several quantities of interest , such as the energy , the local density , local compressibility , density - density correlation functions ... in particular the winding is sampled and gives access to the superfluid density .
equal - time n - body green functions are probably the most interesting quantities that can be measured by the algorithm , by giving access to momentum distribution functions which allow direct comparisons with experiments .
all details on measurements are given in ref.@xcite .
in addition the algorithm has the property of being easy to code , due in part to a simple update scheme in which all moves are accepted with a probability of 1 . despite of such generality and simplicity ,
the algorithm might suffer from a reduced efficiency , compared to other algorithms in situations where they can be applied .
the purpose of this paper is to present a `` directed '' update scheme that ( i ) keeps the simplicity and generality of the original sgf algorithm , and ( ii ) enhances its efficiency by improving the sampling over the imaginary time axis .
while the sgf algorithm is not intended to compete with the speed of other algorithms , the improvment resulting from the directed update scheme is remarkable ( see section v ) .
but what makes the strength of the sgf method is that it allows to simulate hamiltonians that can not be treated by other methods or that would require special developments ( see eq.([twospecies ] ) for a concrete example ) .
the paper is organized as follows : we introduce in section ii the notations and definitions used in ref.@xcite . in section iii , we propose a simplification of the update scheme used in the original sgf algorithm , and determine how to satisfy detailed balance .
a generalization of the simplified update scheme is presented in section iv , which constitutes the directed updated scheme .
finally section v shows how to determine the introduced optimization parameters , and presents some tests of the algorithm and a comparison with the original version .
in this section , we recall the expression of the `` green operator '' introduced in the sgf algorithm , and the extended partition function which is considered . although not required for understanding this paper , we refer the reader to ref.@xcite for full details on the algorithm . as many qmc algorithms ,
the sgf algorithm samples the partition function @xmath4 the algorithm has the property of working in the canonical ensemble . in order to define the green operator ,
we first define the `` normalized '' creation and annihilation operators , @xmath5 where @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the usual creation and annihilation operators of bosons , and @xmath8 is the number operator . from ( [ normalizedoperators ] )
one can show the following relations for any state @xmath9 in the occupation number representation , @xmath10 with the particular case @xmath11 .
appart from this exception , the operators @xmath12 and @xmath13 change a state @xmath9 by respectively creating and annihilating one particle , but they do not change the norm of the state . using the notation @xmath14 to denote two subsets of site indices @xmath15 and @xmath16 with the constraint that all indices in subset @xmath17 are different from the indices in subset @xmath18 ( but several indices in one subset may be equal ) , we define the green operator @xmath19 by @xmath20 where @xmath21 is a matrix that depends on the application of the algorithm @xcite . in order to sample the partition function ( [ partitionfunction ] ) , an extended partition function @xmath22 is considered by breaking up the propagator @xmath23 , and introducing the green operator between the broken parts , @xmath24 defining the time dependant operators @xmath25 and @xmath26
, @xmath27 and working in the occupation number basis in which @xmath1 is diagonal , the extended partition function takes the form @xmath28 where the sum @xmath29 implicitly runs over complete sets of states @xmath30 . we will systematically use the labels @xmath31 and @xmath32 to denote the states appearing on the left and the right of the green operator , and use the notation @xmath33 to denote the diagonal energy @xmath34 .
we will also denote by @xmath35 and @xmath36 the time indices of the @xmath2 operators appearing on the left and the right of @xmath19 . as a result ,
the extended partition function is a sum over all possible configurations , each being determined by a set of time indices @xmath37 and a set of states @xmath38 , @xmath39 , @xmath40,@xmath41 , @xmath42 .
the algorithm consists in updating those configurations by making use of the green operator . assuming that the green operator is acting at time @xmath43
, it can `` create '' a @xmath2 operator ( that is to say a @xmath2 operator can be inserted in the operator string ) at the same time , thus introducing a new intermediate state , then it can be shifted to a different time . while shifting , any @xmath2 operator encountered by the green operator is `` destroyed '' ( that is to say removed from the operator string ) . assuming a left ( or right ) move , creating an operator will update the state @xmath44 ( or @xmath41 ) ,
while destroying will update the state @xmath41 ( or @xmath44 ) .
when a diagonal configuration of the green operator occurs , @xmath45 , such a configuration associated to the extended partition function ( [ extendedpartitionfunction ] ) is also a configuration associated to the partition function ( [ partitionfunction ] ) .
measurements can be done when this occurs ( see ref.@xcite for details on measurements ) .
next section presents a simple update scheme that meets the requirements of ergodicity and detailed balance .
before introducing the directed update , we start by simplifying the update scheme used in the original sgf algorithm
. we will assume in the following that a left move of the green operator is chosen .
in the original version , the green operator @xmath26 can choose to create or not on its right a @xmath2 operator at time @xmath43 .
then a time shift @xmath46 to the left is chosen for the green operator with an exponential distribution in the range @xmath47 .
if an operator is encountered while shifting the green operator , then the operator is destroyed and the move stops there . as a result , four possible situations can occur during one move : 1 . no creation , shift , no destruction .
2 . creation , shift , no destruction .
3 . no creation , shift , destruction .
4 . creation , shift , destruction .
it appears that the first possibility `` no creation , no destruction '' is actually useless , since no change is performed in the operator string . the idea is to get rid of this possibility by forcing the green operator to destroy an operator if no creation is chosen
a further simplification can be done by noticing that the last possibility `` creation , destruction '' is not necessary for the ergodicity of the algorithm , and can be avoided by restricting the range of the time shift after having created an operator .
therefore we replace the original update scheme by the following : we assume that the green operator is acting at time @xmath43 and that the operator on its left is acting at time @xmath35 . the green operator @xmath26 chooses to create or not an operator on its right at time @xmath43 .
if creation is chosen , then a time shift @xmath46 of the green operator is chosen to the left in the range @xmath48 , with the probability distribution defined below .
if no creation is chosen , then the green operator is directly shifted to the operator on its left at time @xmath35 , and the operator is destroyed . as a result
only two possibilities have to be considered : 1 .
creation , shift .
2 . shift , destruction .
figure [ simplfiedupdatescheme ] shows the associated organigram .
section iii.b explains how detailed balance can be satisfied with this simplified update scheme . when updating the configurations according to the chosen update scheme , we need to generate different transitions from initial to final states with probabilities that satisfy detailed balance . in this section
we propose a choice for these probabilities , and determine the corresponding acceptance factors .
we denote the probability of the initial ( final ) configuration by @xmath49 ( @xmath50 ) .
we denote by @xmath51 the probability of the transition from configuration @xmath17 to configuration @xmath52 , and by @xmath53 the probability of the reverse transition .
finally we denote by @xmath54 the acceptance rate of the transition from @xmath17 to @xmath52 , and by @xmath55 the acceptance rate of the reverse transition .
the detailed balance can be written as @xmath56 we will make use of the metropolis solution @xcite , @xmath57 with @xmath58 we will use primed ( non - primed ) labels for states and time indices to denote final ( initial ) configurations .
we consider here the case where a left move is chosen , an operator is created on the right of the green operator at time @xmath43 , and a new state is chosen .
then a time shift to the left is chosen for the green operator in the range @xmath59 .
it is important to note that @xmath60 and @xmath61 correspond to the time indices of the operators appearing on the left and the right of the green operator after the new operator has been inserted , that is to say at the moment where the time shift needs to be performed .
thus we have @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
the probability of the initial configuration is the boltzmann weight appearing in the extended partition function ( [ extendedpartitionfunction ] ) : @xmath64 the probability of the final configuration takes the form : @xmath65 it is important here to realize that the green operator only inserted on its right the operator @xmath66 , before being shifted from @xmath61 to @xmath67 .
therefore we have the equalities @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , and @xmath71 .
the probability @xmath51 of the transition from the initial configuration to the final configuration is the probability @xmath72 of a left move , times the probability @xmath73 of a creation , times the probability @xmath74 to choose the new state @xmath75 , times the probability @xmath76 to shift the green operator by @xmath77 , knowing that the states on the left and the right of the green operator at the moment of the shift are @xmath78 and @xmath79 : @xmath80 the probability of the reverse transition is simply the probability @xmath81 of a right move , times the probability of no creation , @xmath82 : @xmath83\ ] ] from the original version of the sgf algorithm , we know that choosing the time shift with an exponential distribution is a good choice , because it cancels the exponentials appearing in the probabilities of the initial ( [ initial ] ) and final ( [ final ] ) configurations , avoiding exponentially small acceptance factors .
however a different normalization must be used here , since the time shift is chosen in the range @xmath84 instead of @xmath47 .
the suitable solution is : @xmath85 it is straightforward to check that the above probability is correctly normalized and well - defined for any real value of @xmath86 , the particular case @xmath87 reducing to the uniform distribution @xmath88 ( note that @xmath89 is always a positive number ) . for the probability @xmath74 to choose the new state @xmath75 ,
the convenient solution is the same as in the original version : @xmath90 putting everything together , the acceptance factor ( [ metropolis2 ] ) becomes @xmath91\big[1-e^{-(\tau_l^\prime-\tau_r^\prime)(v_r^\prime - v_l^\prime)}\big]}{v_r^\prime - v_l^\prime},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the notation @xmath92 to emphasize that this acceptance factor corresponds to a creation .
it is also important for the remaining of this paper to note that @xmath92 is written as a quantity that depends on the initial configuration , times a quantity that depends on the final configuration .
we consider here the case where a left move is chosen , and the operator on the left of the green operator is destroyed .
this move corresponds to the inverse of the above `` creation , shift '' move .
thus , the corresponding acceptance factor @xmath93 is obtained by inverting the acceptance factor @xmath92 , exchanging the initial time @xmath43 and final time @xmath67 , and switching the direction .
however @xmath94 represents an absolute time shift , so @xmath35 and @xmath36 do not have to be exchanged .
we get @xmath95\big[1-e^{-(\tau_l-\tau_r)(v_l - v_r)}\big ] } \\ & \times & \frac{\big\langle\psi_l^\prime\big|\hat\mathcal g\big|\psi_r^\prime\big\rangle p(\rightarrow^\prime)p_\rightarrow^\dagger(\tau^\prime)}{\big\langle\psi_l^\prime\big|\hat\mathcal t\hat\mathcal g\big|\psi_r^\prime\big\rangle},\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is written as a quantity that depends on the initial configuration , times a quantity that depends on the final configuration .
we will use here the short notation @xmath96 , @xmath97 , and @xmath98 to denote respectively the quantities @xmath99 , @xmath100 , and @xmath101 . as in ref .
@xcite , we have some freedom for the choice of the probabilities of choosing a left or right move , @xmath72 and @xmath102 , and the probabilities of creation @xmath73 and @xmath103 .
a suitable choice for those probabilities can be done in order to accept all moves , resulting in an appreciable simplification of the algorithm . for this purpose ,
we impose the acceptance factor @xmath92 ( or @xmath104 ) to be equal to the acceptance factor @xmath93 ( or @xmath105 ) .
this allows to determine the probabilities @xmath73 and @xmath103 , @xmath106 and the acceptance factors @xmath107 and @xmath108 take the form @xmath109 with @xmath110 finally we can impose the acceptance factors @xmath111 and @xmath112 to be equal .
this implies @xmath113 defining @xmath114 , we are left with a single acceptance factor , @xmath115 which is independent of the chosen direction , and independent of the nature of the move ( creation or destruction ) .
thus all moves can be accepted by making use of a proper reweighting , as explained in ref .
the appendix shows how to generate random numbers with the appropriate exponential distribution ( [ exponentialdistribution ] ) . although the above simplified update scheme works , it turns out to have a poor efficiency .
this is because of a lack of `` directionality '' : the green operator has , in average , a probability of @xmath116 to choose a left move or a right move .
therefore the green operator propagates along the operator string like a `` drunk man '' , with a diffusion - like law .
the basic creation and destruction processes correspond to the steps of the random walk .
this suggests that the efficiency of the update scheme can be improved if one can force the green operator to move in the same direction for several iterations .
next section presents a modified version of the simplified update scheme , which allows to control the mean length of the steps of the random walk , that is to say the mean number of creations and destructions in a given direction .
the proposed directed update scheme can be considered analogous to the `` directed loop update '' used in the stochastic series expansion algorithm @xcite , which prevents a worm from going backwards .
however the connection should not be pushed too far .
indeed the picture of a worm whose head is evolving both in space and imaginary time accross vertices is obvious in a loop algorithm . in such algorithm ,
a creation ( or an annihilation ) operator which is represented by the head of a worm is propagated both in space and imaginary time , while an annihilation ( or a creation ) operator represented by the tail of the worm remains at rest .
the loop ends when the head of the worm bites the tail .
such a worm picture is not obvious in the sgf algorithm : instead of single creation or annihilation operators , it is the full green operator over the whole space that is propagated only in imaginary time .
this creates open worldlines , thus introducing discontinuities .
these discontinuities increase or decrease while propagating in imaginary time .
all open ends of the worldlines are localized at the same imaginary time index .
therefore it is actually not possible to draw step by step a worm whose head is evolving in space and imaginary time until it bites its tail .
we present in this section a directed update scheme which is obtained by modifying slightly the simplified update scheme , thus keeping the simplicity and generality of the algorithm . assuming that a left move is chosen
, the green operator chooses between starting the move by a creation or a destruction . after having created ( or destroyed ) an operator , the green operator can choose to keep moving in the same direction and destroy ( or create ) with a probability @xmath117 ( or @xmath118 ) , or to stop .
if it keeps moving , then a destruction ( or creation ) occurs , and the green operator can choose to keep moving and create ( or destroy ) with a probability @xmath118 ( or @xmath117 ) ... and so on , until it decides to stop . if the last action of the move is a creation , then a time shift is chosen .
the organigram is represented in figure [ directedupdatescheme ] . in order to satisfy detailed balance , in addition to the acceptance factors @xmath92 and @xmath93 , we need to determine new acceptance factors of the form @xmath119 and @xmath120 .
we first determine the new expressions of @xmath92 and @xmath93 resulting from the directed update scheme . for @xmath92 ,
the previous probability @xmath51 has to be multiplied by the probability to stop the move after having created , @xmath121 .
the previous probability @xmath53 has to be multiplied by the probability to stop the move after having destroyed , @xmath122 .
we get for @xmath92 and @xmath93 the new expressions : @xmath123}{\big\langle\psi_l\big|\hat\mathcal g\big|\psi_r\big\rangle p(\leftarrow)p_\leftarrow^\dagger(\tau ) } \\ & \times & \frac{p(\rightarrow^\prime)\big[1-p_\rightarrow^\dagger(\tau^\prime)\big]\big[1-e^{-(\tau_l^\prime-\tau_r^\prime)(v_r^\prime - v_l^\prime)}\big]}{\big[1-p_\leftarrow^{kd}(\tau^\prime)\big]\big(v_r^\prime - v_l^\prime\big ) } \\
\nonumber q_\leftarrow^d & = & \frac{\big[1-p_\rightarrow^{kd}(\tau)\big]\big(v_l - v_r\big)}{p(\leftarrow)\big[1-p_\leftarrow^\dagger(\tau)\big]\big[1-e^{-(\tau_l-\tau_r)(v_l - v_r)}\big ] } \\ & \times & \frac{\big\langle\psi_l^\prime\big|\hat\mathcal g\big|\psi_r^\prime\big\rangle p(\rightarrow^\prime)p_\rightarrow^\dagger(\tau^\prime)}{\big\langle\psi_l^\prime\big|\hat\mathcal t\hat\mathcal g\big|\psi_r^\prime\big\rangle\big[1-p_\leftarrow^{kc}(\tau^\prime)\big]},\end{aligned}\ ] ] we consider here the case where a left move is chosen , an operator is created on the right of the green operator , and a new state is chosen .
then the operator on the left of the green operator is destroyed . using the superscripts @xmath124 to denote intermediate configurations between initial and final configurations ,
the sequence is the following 1 .
@xmath125 2 .
@xmath126 3 .
@xmath127 , where we have @xmath128 , @xmath129 , @xmath130 , and @xmath131 .
the probability of the transition from the initial configuration to the final configuration is the probability @xmath72 to choose a left move , times the probability @xmath73 to create an operator at time @xmath43 , times the probability @xmath132 to choose the new state @xmath133 , times the probability @xmath134 to keep moving and destroy , times the probability @xmath135 to stop the move after having destroyed : @xmath136\ ] ] the probability of the reverse move is exactly symmetric : @xmath137\ ] ] it is important to notice that , when in the intermediate configuration @xmath7 , the time @xmath138 of the operator to the left of the green operator is equal to @xmath35 , and the time @xmath139 of the operator to the right of the green operator is equal to @xmath43 .
thus the acceptance factor takes the form @xmath140}{\big\langle\psi_l\big|\hat\mathcal g\big|\psi_r\big\rangle p(\leftarrow)p_\leftarrow^\dagger(\tau ) } \\
\nonumber & \times & \frac{e^{-\big(\tau_l^a-\tau_r^a\big)v_r^a}p_\rightarrow^{kd}(a)}{e^{-\big(\tau_l^a-\tau_r^a\big)v_l^a}p_\leftarrow^{kd}(a ) } \\ & \times & \frac{\big\langle\psi_l^\prime\big|\hat\mathcal g\big|\psi_r^\prime\big\rangle p(\rightarrow^\prime)p_\rightarrow^\dagger(\tau^\prime)}{\big\langle\psi_l^\prime\big|\hat\mathcal t\hat\mathcal g\big|\psi_r^\prime\big\rangle\big[1-p_\leftarrow^{kc}(\tau^\prime)\big]},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and is written as a quantity that depends on the initial configuration , times a quantity that depends on the intermediate configuration @xmath7 , times a quantity that depends on the final configuration .
it is useful for the remaining of the paper to define the intermediate acceptance factor , @xmath141 we consider here the case where a left move is chosen , the operator on the left of the green operator is destroyed , then an operator is created on its right , and a new state is chosen . finally a time shift is chosen .
the sequence of configurations is the following 1 .
@xmath125 2 .
@xmath142 3 .
@xmath127 , where we have @xmath143 , and @xmath144 .
the probability of the transition from the initial configuration to the final configuration is the probability @xmath72 to choose a left move , times the probability @xmath145 of no creation , times the probability @xmath146 to keep moving and create , times the probability @xmath74 to choose the new state @xmath75 , times the probability @xmath121 to stop the move after having destroyed , times the probability @xmath76 to shift the green operator by @xmath77 : @xmath147p_\leftarrow^{kc}(a)p_\leftarrow(\psi_r^\prime ) \\ & \times & \big[1-p_\leftarrow^{kd}(\tau^\prime)\big]p_\leftarrow^{l^\prime r^\prime}(\tau^\prime-\tau_r^\prime)\end{aligned}\ ] ]
the probability of the reverse move is exactly symmetric : @xmath148p_\rightarrow^{kc}(a)p_\rightarrow(\psi_l ) \\ & \times & \big[1-p_\rightarrow^{kd}(\tau)\big]p_\rightarrow^{lr}(\tau_l-\tau)\end{aligned}\ ] ] the acceptance factor takes the form @xmath149\big(v_l - v_r\big)}{p(\leftarrow)\big[1-p_\leftarrow^\dagger(\tau)\big]\big[1-e^{-(\tau_l-\tau_r)(v_l - v_r)}\big ] } \\
\nonumber & \times & \frac{\big\langle\psi_l^a\big|\hat\mathcal g\hat\mathcal t\big|\psi_r^a\big\rangle
p_\rightarrow^{kc}(a)}{\big\langle\psi_l^a\big|\hat\mathcal t\hat\mathcal g\big|\psi_r^a\big\rangle p_\leftarrow^{kc}(a ) } \\ & \times & \frac{p(\rightarrow^\prime)\big[1-p_\rightarrow^\dagger(\tau^\prime)\big]\big[1-e^{-(\tau_l^\prime-\tau_r^\prime)(v_r^\prime - v_l^\prime)}\big]}{\big[1-p_\leftarrow^{kd}(\tau^\prime)\big]\big(v_r^\prime - v_l^\prime\big)},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and is written as a quantity that depends on the initial configuration , times a quantity that depends on the intermediate configuration @xmath7 , times a quantity that depends on the final configuration .
it is useful for the remaining of the paper to define the intermediate acceptance factor , @xmath150 we consider here the case where a left move is chosen , an operator is created on the right of the green operator , then the operator on its left is destroyed , then a second operator is created on its right .
finally , a time shift of the green operator is performed .
the sequence of configurations is the following 1 .
@xmath125 2 .
@xmath126 3 .
@xmath151 4 .
@xmath152 , considering the intermediate configurations @xmath7 and @xmath153 between the intial and final configurations , it is easy to show that the corresponding acceptance factor can be written @xmath154 we consider here the case where a left move is chosen , the operator on the left of the green operator is destroyed , then an operator is created on its right . finally a second operator on the left of green operator is destroyed .
the sequence of configurations is the following 1 .
@xmath155 2 .
@xmath156 3 .
@xmath157 4 .
@xmath127 , considering the intermediate configurations @xmath7 and @xmath153 between the intial and final configurations , it is easy to show that the corresponding acceptance factor can be written @xmath158 it is straighforward to show that the acceptance factors of the form @xmath159 , @xmath160 , @xmath161 ( or @xmath162 , @xmath163 , @xmath164 ) can be expressed as products of the acceptance factor @xmath92 ( or @xmath93 ) and the intermediate factors @xmath165 and @xmath166 . in the same manner , the acceptance factors of the form @xmath167 , @xmath168 , @xmath169 ( or @xmath170 , @xmath171 , @xmath172 ) can be expressed as products of the acceptance factor @xmath173 ( or @xmath174 ) and the intermediate factors @xmath165 and @xmath166 . here
again it is possible to take advantage of the freedom that we have for the choice of the probabilities @xmath72 , @xmath175 , @xmath118 , and @xmath117 ( or @xmath102 , @xmath176 , @xmath177 , and @xmath178 ) .
a proper choice of these probabilities can be done in order to allow us to accept all moves , simplicity and generality being the leitmotiv of the sgf algorithm . for this purpose
, we impose to all acceptance factors corresponding to left ( or right ) moves to be equal .
this requires the intermediate acceptance factors @xmath165 and @xmath166 ( or @xmath179 and @xmath180 ) to be equal to 1 .
this is realized if @xmath181 where @xmath182 and @xmath183 are optimization parameters belonging to @xmath184 . by tuning these parameters , the mean length of the steps of the green operator
can be controlled .
note that we have explicitly excluded @xmath185 from the allowed values for these optimization parameters .
this is necessary for the green operator to have a chance to end in a diagonal configuration , @xmath45 .
indeed , the choice @xmath186 would systematically lead to values of @xmath185 for the probabilities @xmath187 and @xmath188 for diagonal configurations .
therefore the green operator would never stop in a diagonal configution , and no measurement could be done .
it is important here to note that the quantities @xmath96 , @xmath97 , and @xmath98 are evaluated between the states on the left and the right of the green operator that are present at the moment where those quantities are needed , as well as for the times indices @xmath189 and @xmath190 and the potentials @xmath191 and @xmath192 .
all acceptance factors corresponding to a given direction of propagation become equal if we choose for the creation probabilities : @xmath193(v_l - v_r)}{\big[1-p_\rightarrow^{kc}\big]\big[1-e^{-(\tau_l-\tau_r)(v_l - v_r)}\big ] } } \\ & & p_\rightarrow^\dagger(\tau)=\frac{\big\langle\hat\mathcal t\hat\mathcal g\big\rangle}{\big\langle\hat\mathcal t\hat\mathcal g\big\rangle+\big\langle\hat\mathcal g\big\rangle\frac{\big[1-p_\leftarrow^{kd}\big](v_r - v_l)}{\big[1-p_\leftarrow^{kc}\big]\big[1-e^{-(\tau_l-\tau_r)(v_r - v_l)}\big]}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , all acceptances factors become independant of the direction of propagation if we choose @xmath194 and @xmath195 with @xmath196\frac{\big\langle\hat\mathcal g\hat\mathcal t\big\rangle}{\big\langle\hat\mathcal g\big\rangle}+\frac{\big[1-p_\rightarrow^{kd}\big](v_l - v_r)}{\big[1-e^{-(\tau_l-\tau_r)(v_l - v_r)}\big ] } \\ r_\rightarrow(\tau)=\big[1-p_\leftarrow^{kc}\big]\frac{\big\langle\hat\mathcal t\hat\mathcal g\big\rangle}{\big\langle\hat\mathcal g\big\rangle}+\frac{\big[1-p_\leftarrow^{kd}\big](v_r - v_l)}{\big[1-e^{-(\tau_l-\tau_r)(v_r - v_l)}\big]}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as a result all moves can be accepted again , ensuring the maximum of simplicity of the algorithm .
we still have some freedom for the choice of the optimization parameters @xmath182 and @xmath183 .
this is discussed in next section .
from the central limit theorem , we know that the errorbar associated to any measured quantity must decrease as the square root of the number of measurements , or equivalently , the square root of the time of the simulation
. therefore it makes sense to define the efficiency @xmath197 of a qmc algorithm by @xmath198 where @xmath199 represents the set of all optimization parameters of the algorithm , @xmath200 is the measured quantity of interest , @xmath201 is the time of the simulation , and @xmath202 is the errorbar associated to the measured quantity @xmath200 .
this definition ensures that @xmath197 is independent of the time of the simulation . as a result ,
the larger @xmath197 the more efficient the algorithm . in the present case
we have @xmath203 , while @xmath204 for the original sgf algorithm .
it is useful here to realize that , by symmetry , the mean values of @xmath118 and @xmath177 ( and @xmath117 and @xmath178 ) must be equal .
therefore we define @xmath205 and @xmath206 .
it seems reasonable to impose a condition of uniform sampling , @xmath207 .
this condition can be satisfied by adjusting dynamically the values of @xmath182 and @xmath183 during the thermalization process . for this purpose
we introduce a new optimization parameter @xmath208 and apply the following algorithm from time to time while thermalizing ( we start with @xmath209 ) : @xmath210 thus we are left with the optimization parameter @xmath211 . in order to determine the optimal value ,
we have considered 2 different hamiltonians @xmath212 and @xmath213 , and evaluated the efficiency of the algorithm while scanning @xmath211 .
the first hamiltonian we have considered describes free hardcore bosons and is exactly solvable , @xmath214 where the sum runs over pairs of first neighboring sites and @xmath215 is the hopping parameter .
the second hamiltonian is highly non - trivial and describes a mixture of atoms and diatomic molecules , with a special term allowing conversions between the two species @xcite , @xmath216 where @xmath217 and @xmath218 ( @xmath219 and @xmath220 ) are the creation and annihilation operators of atoms ( molecules ) , @xmath221 , @xmath222 , @xmath223 , @xmath224 , and @xmath225 are respectively the hopping parameter of atoms , the hopping parameter of molecules , the atomic onsite interaction parameter , the molecular onsite interaction parameter , and the inter - species interaction parameter .
the conversion term is tunable via the parameter @xmath226 and does not conserve the number @xmath227 of atoms or the number @xmath228 of molecules
. however the total number of particles @xmath229 is conserved and is the canonical constraint .
the parameter @xmath230 allows to control the ratio between the number of atoms and molecules .
the application of the sgf algorithm to the hamiltonian ( [ twospecies ] ) is described in details in ref.@xcite .
the changes coming with the directed update scheme are completely independent of the chosen hamiltonian .
the following table shows the mean number of creations and destructions in one step , @xmath231 , and the relative efficiency @xmath232 of the algorithm applied to @xmath212 at half filling , for which we have measured the energy @xmath233 , the superfluid density @xmath234 , and the number of particles in the zero momentum state @xmath235 : .
relative efficiency of the algorithm applied to @xmath212 at half filling for the energy , the superfluid density , and the number of particles in the zero momentum state . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] while the best value of @xmath211 depends on the hamiltonian which is considered and the measured quantity , it appears that a good compromise is to choose @xmath211 between @xmath236 and @xmath237 .
the improvment of the efficiency is remarkable . in the following ,
we illustrate the applicability of the algorithm to problems with non - uniform potentials , by adding a parabolic trap to the hamiltonian ( [ twospecies ] ) : @xmath238 the parameters @xmath239 and @xmath240 allow to control the curvature of the trap associated to atoms and molecules , respectively , and @xmath31 is the number of lattice sites .
the inclusion of this term in the algorithm is trivial since only the values of the diagonal energies @xmath241 and @xmath242 are changed .
figures ( [ density ] ) and ( [ momentum ] ) show the density profiles and momentum distribution functions obtained for a system with @xmath243 lattice sites initially loaded with @xmath244 atoms and no molecules , and the parameters @xmath245 , @xmath246 , @xmath247 , @xmath248 , @xmath249 , @xmath250 , @xmath251 , @xmath252 , @xmath253 , and @xmath254 .
the presented results have been obtained by performing @xmath255 updates for thermalization , and @xmath256 updates with measurements ( an update is to be understood as the occurence of a diagonal configuration ) .
the time of the simulation is about 8 hours on a cheap 32 bits laptop with 1ghz processor , with an implementation of the algorithm involving dynamical structures with pointers ( see ref.@xcite ) . ) to the hamiltonian ( [ twospecies ] ) .
the errorbars are smaller than the symbol sizes , and are the biggest in the neighborhood of site indices 23 and 47 where they equal the size of the symbols . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] ) to the hamiltonian ( [ twospecies ] ) .
the errorbars are smaller than the symbol sizes , and are the biggest for @xmath257 where they equal the size of the symbols .
, scaledwidth=45.0% ]
we have presented a directed update scheme for the sgf algorithm , which has the properties of keeping the simplicity and generality of the original algorithm , and improves significantly its efficiency .
i would like to express special thanks to peter denteneer for useful suggestions .
this work is part of the research program of the `` stichting voor fundamenteel onderzoek der materie ( fom ) , '' which is financially supported by the `` nederlandse organisatie voor wetenschappelijk onderzoek ( nwo ) . ''
we describe here how to generate numbers with the appropriate exponential distribution ( [ exponentialdistribution ] ) . assuming that we have at our disposal a uniform random number generator that generates a random variable @xmath258 with the distribution @xmath259 for @xmath260
, we would like to find a function @xmath52 such that the random variable @xmath261 is generated with the distribution @xmath262 where @xmath46 and @xmath263 are the parameters of the exponential distribution .
because of the relation @xmath261 , the probability to find @xmath264 in the range @xmath265 must be equal to the probability to find @xmath258 in the range @xmath266 .
this implies the condition @xmath267 with @xmath268 .
thus we have @xmath269 taking the anti - derivative with respect to @xmath270 on both sides of the equation , we get @xmath271 where @xmath272 is a constant . this constant and the correct sign are determined by imposing the conditions @xmath273 and @xmath274 . as a result , if @xmath270 is a realization of @xmath258 , then a realization of @xmath264 is given by @xmath275.\ ] ] 10 nicholas metropolis and s. ulam , journal of the american statistical association , number 247 , volume 44 ( 1949 ) .
handscomb , proc .
58 , 594 ( 1962 ) .
kalos , phys .
128 , 1791 ( 1962 ) .
r. blankenbecler , d.j .
scalapino and r.l .
sugar , phys .
d 24 , 2278 ( 1981 ) . g.g .
batrouni and r.t .
scalettar , phys .
b * 46 * , 9051 ( 1992 ) . w. von der linden , phys . rep .
220 , 53 ( 1992 ) .
evertz , g. lana and m. marcu , phys .
70 , 875 - 879 ( 1993 ) .
ceperley , rev .
67 , 279 ( 1995 ) .
beard and u .- j .
wiese , phys .
77 5130 ( 1996 ) .
`` quantum monte carlo methods in physics and chemistry '' , ed . m.p . nightingale and c.j .
umrigar , nato science series c 525 , kluwer academic publishers , dordrecht , ( 1999 ) .
sandvik , j. phys .
a * 25 * , 3667 ( 1992 ) ; phys . rev .
b * 59 * , 14157 ( 1999 ) . n.v .
prokofev , b.v .
svistunov , and i.s .
tupitsyn , jetp lett . * 87 * , 310 ( 1998 ) .
m. rigol , a. muramatsu , g.g .
batrouni , and r.t .
scalettar , phys .
lett . * 91 * , 130403 ( 2003 ) .
k. van houcke , s.m.a .
rombouts , and l. pollet , phys .
e * 73*,056703 ( 2006 ) .
rousseau , phys .
e * 77 * , 056705 ( 2008 ) .
sandvik , s. daul , r.r.p .
singh , and d.j .
lett . * 89 * , 247201 ( 2002 ) .
rousseau , r.t .
scalettar , and g.g .
batrouni , phys .
b * 72 * , 054524 ( 2005 ) .
n. metropolis , a.w .
rosenbluth , m.n .
metropolis , a.h .
teller , and e. teller , j. chem . phys .
* 21 * , 1087 ( 1953 ) .
olav f. syljuasen , anders w. sandvik , phys .
e * 66 * , 046701 ( 2002 ) .
rousseau and p.j.h .
denteneer , phys .
a * 77 * , 013609 ( 2008 ) .
|
in a recent publication we have presented the stochastic green function ( sgf ) algorithm , which has the properties of being general and easy to apply to any lattice hamiltonian of the form @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is diagonal in the chosen occupation number basis and @xmath2 has only positive matrix elements .
we propose here a modified version of the update scheme that keeps the simplicity and generality of the original sgf algorithm , and enhances significantly its efficiency .
|
model selection is an important problem in many areas including machine learning .
if a proper model is not selected , any effort for parameter estimation or prediction of the algorithm s outcome is hopeless .
given a set of candidate models , the goal of model selection is to select the model that best approximates the observed data and captures its underlying regularities .
model selection criteria are defined such that they strike a balance between the _ goodness - of - fit ( gof ) _ , and the _ generalizability _ or _
complexity _ of the models .
goodness - of - fit measures how well a model capture the regularity in the data .
generalizability / complexity is the assessment of the performance of the model on unseen data or how accurately the model fits / predicts the future data .
models with higher complexity than necessary can suffer from overfitting and poor generalization , while models that are too simple will underfit and have low gof @xcite .
cross - validation @xcite , bootstrapping @xcite , akaike information criterion ( aic ) @xcite , and bayesian information criterion ( bic ) @xcite , are well known examples of traditional model selection . in re - sampling methods such as cross - validation and bootstraping , the generalization error of the model
is estimated using monte carlo simulation .
in contrast with re - sampling methods , the model selection methods like aic and bic do not require validation to compute the model error , and are computationally efficient . in these procedures
an _ information criterion _ is defined such that the generalization error is estimated by penalizing the model s error on observed data .
a large number of information criteria have been introduced with different motivations that lead to different theoretical properties .
for instance , the tighter penalization parameter in bic favors simpler models , while aic works better when the dataset has a very large sample size .
kernel methods are strong , computationally efficient analytical tools that are capable of working on high dimensional data with arbitrarily complex structure .
they have been successfully applied in wide range of applications such as classification , and regression . in kernel methods ,
the data are mapped from their original space to a higher dimensional feature space , the reproducing kernel hilbert space ( rkhs ) .
the idea behind this mapping is to transform the nonlinear relationships between data points in the original space into an easy - to - compute linear learning problem in the feature space .
for example , in kernel regression the response variable is described as a linear combination of the embedded data .
any algorithm that can be represented through dot products has a kernel evaluation .
this operation , called kernelization , makes it possible to transform traditional , already proven , model selection methods into stronger , corresponding kernel methods .
the literature on kernel methods has , however , mostly focused on kernel selection and on tuning the kernel parameters , but only limited work being done on kernel - based model selection @xcite . in this study , we investigate a kernel - based information criterion for ridge regression models . in kernel ridge regression ( krr ) , tuning the ridge parameters to find the most predictive subspace with respect to the data at hand and the unseen data is the goal of the kernel model selection criterion . in classical model selection methods the performance of the model selection criterion is evaluated theoretically by providing a consistency proof where the sample size tends to infinity and empirically through simulated studies for finite sample sizes .
other methods investigate a probabilistic upper bound of the generalization error @xcite .
proving the consistency properties of the model selection in _ kernel model selection _ is challenging .
the proof procedure of the classical methods does not work here .
some reasons for that are : the size of the model to evaluate problems such as under / overfitting @xcite is not apparent ( for @xmath1 data points of dimension @xmath2 , the kernel is @xmath3 , which is independent of @xmath2 ) and asymptotic probabilities of generalization error or estimators are hard to compute in rkhs .
researchers have kernelized the traditional model selection criteria and shown the success of their kernel model selection empirically .
kobayashi and komaki @xcite extracted the kernel - based regularization information criterion ( kric ) using an eigenvalue equation to set the regularization parameters in kernel logistic regression and support vector machines ( svm ) .
rosipal et al .
@xcite developed covariance information criterion ( cic ) for model selection in kernel principal component analysis , because of its outperformed results compared to aic and bic in orthogonal linear regression .
demyanov et al .
@xcite , provided alternative way of calculating the likelihood function in akaike information criterion ( aic , @xcite and bayesian information criterion ( bic , @xcite ) , and used it for parameter selection in svms using the gaussian kernel . as pointed out by van emden @xcite , a desirable model is the one with the fewest dependent variables . thus defining a complexity term that measures the interdependency of model parameters enables one to select the most desirable model . in this study , we define a novel variable - wise variance and obtain a complexity measure as the additive combination of kernels defined on model parameters . formalizing the complexity term in this way effectively captures the interdependency of each parameter of the model .
we call this novel method _ kernel - based information criterion ( kic)_. model selection criterion in gaussian process regression ( gpr ; @xcite ) , and kernel - based information complexity ( icomp ; @xcite ) resemble kic in using a covariance - based complexity measure .
however , the methods differ because these complexity measures capture the interdependency between the data points rather than the model parameters .
although we can not establish the consistency properties of kic theoretically , we empirically evaluate the efficiency of kic both on synthetic and real datasets obtaining state - of - the - art results compared to leave - one - out - cross - validation ( loocv ) , kernel - based icomp , and maximum log marginal likelihood in gpr .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : krr ] , we give an overview of kernel ridge regression .
kic is described in detail in section [ sec : kic ] .
section [ sec : om ] is provides a brief explanation of the methods to which kic is compared , and in section [ sec : exp ] we evaluate the performance of kic through sets of experiments .
in regression analysis , the regression model of the form : @xmath4 where @xmath5 can be either a linear or non - linear function . in linear regression we have , @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is an observation vector ( response variable ) of size @xmath8 , @xmath9 is a full rank data matrix of independent variables of size @xmath10 , and @xmath11 , is an unknown vector of regression parameters , where @xmath12 denotes the transposition .
we also assume that the error ( noise ) vector @xmath13 is an @xmath1-dimensional vector whose elements are drawn i.i.d , @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is an @xmath1-dimensional identity matrix and @xmath16 is an unknown variance .
the regression coefficients minimize the squared errors , @xmath17 , between estimated function @xmath18 , and target function @xmath5 .
when @xmath19 , the problem is ill - posed , so that some kind of regularization , such as tikhanov regularization ( ridge regression ) is required , and the coefficients minimize the following optimization problem @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the regularization parameter .
the estimated regression coefficients in ridge regression @xmath22 are : @xmath23 in _ kernel _ ridge regression ( krr ) , the data matrix @xmath9 is non - linearly transformed in rkhs using a feature map @xmath24 .
the estimated regression coefficients based on @xmath25 are : @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the kernel matrix .
equation [ eq : theta ] does not obtain an explicit expression for @xmath28 because of @xmath24 ( the kernel trick enables one to avoid explicitly defining @xmath25 that could be numerically intractable if computed in rkhs , if known ) , thus a ridge estimator is used ( e.g. @xcite ) that excludes @xmath24 : @xmath29 using @xmath30 in the calculation of krr is similar to regularizing the regression function instead of the regression coefficients , where the objective function is : @xmath31 and @xmath32 denotes the relevant rkhs . for @xmath33 , and @xmath34
we have : @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the kernel function , and @xmath37 .
the main contribution of this study is to introduce a new kernel - based information criterion ( kic ) for the model selection in kernel - based regression . according to equation kic balances between the goodness - of - fit and the complexity of the model .
gof is defined using a log - likelihood - based function ( we maximize penalized log likelihood ) and the complexity measure is a function based on the covariance function of the parameters of the model . in the next subsections we elaborate on these terms .
the definition of van emden @xcite for the complexity measure of a random vector is based on the interactions among random variables in the corresponding covariance matrix .
a desirable model is the one with the fewest dependent variables .
this reduces the information entropy and yields lower complexity . in this paper
we focus on this definition of the complexity measures . considering a @xmath2-variate normal distribution @xmath38 , the complexity of a covariance matrix , @xmath39 , is given by the shannon s entropy @xcite , @xmath40 where @xmath41 , @xmath42 are the marginal and the joint entropy , and
@xmath43 is the @xmath44 diagonal element of @xmath39 .
@xmath45 if and only if the covariates are independent .
the complexity measure in equation changes with orthonormal transformations because it is dependent on the coordinates of the random variable vectors @xmath46 @xcite .
to overcome these drawbacks , bozodgan and haughton @xcite introduced icomp information criterion with a complexity measure based on the maximal covariance complexity , which is an upper bound on the complexity measure in equation : @xmath47 this complexity measure is proportional to the estimated arithmetic ( @xmath48 ) and geometric mean ( @xmath49 ) of the eigenvalues of the covariance matrix .
larger values of @xmath50 , indicates higher dependency between random variables , and vice versa .
zhang @xcite introduced a kernel form of this complexity measure @xmath50 , that is computed on kernel - based covariance of the ridge estimator : @xmath51 the complexity measure in gaussian process regression ( gpr ; @xcite ) is defined as @xmath52 , a concept from the joint entropy @xmath42 ( as shown in equation [ eq : complexity ] ) .
in contrast to icomp and gpr , the complexity measure in kic is defined using the hilbert - schmidt ( hs ) norm of the covariance matrix , @xmath53 . minimizing this complexity measure obtains a model with more independent variables . in the next sections ,
we explain in detail how to define the needed variable - wise variance in the complexity measure , and the computation of the complexity measure .
+ in kernel - based model selection methods such as icomp , and gpr , the complexity measure is defined on a covariance matrix that is of size @xmath54 for @xmath9 of size @xmath10 .
the idea behind this measure is to compute the interdependency between the model parameters , which independent of the number of the model parameters @xmath2 . in the other words ,
the concept of the size of the model is hidden because of the definition of a kernel . to have a complexity measure that depends on @xmath2
, we introduce variable - wise variance using an additive combination of kernels for each parameter of the model .
let @xmath55 be the parameter vector of the kernel ridge regression : @xmath56 where @xmath57 and @xmath58 , and @xmath59 the solution of krr is given by @xmath60 .
the quantity @xmath61 = \sigma^2 \operatorname{tr}[k(k+\alpha i)^{-2 } ] $ ] can be interpreted as the sum of variances for the component - wise parameter vectors , if the following sum of component - wise kernel is introduced : @xmath62 where @xmath63 and @xmath64 denote the j - th component of vectors @xmath65 and @xmath66 . with this sum kernel
, the function @xmath67 can be written as : @xmath68 where @xmath69 is a function in @xmath70 , the rkhs defined by @xmath71 .
the parameter @xmath28 in this case is given by @xmath72 where @xmath73 , and thus @xmath69 in equation [ eq : g ] is equal to @xmath74 .
let @xmath75 be the conditional covariance of @xmath74 or @xmath69 given @xmath76 .
we have @xmath77,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath78 be the gram matrix with @xmath71 . since @xmath79 , we have @xmath80 = \operatorname{tr}[\sigma_{\theta}].\end{aligned}\ ] ] formalizing the complexity term with variable - wise variance effectively captures the interdependency of each parameter of the model ( measures the significance of the contribution by the variables ) explicitly .
+ gretton et al .
@xcite introduced a kernel - based independence measure , namely the hilbert - schmidt independence criterion ( hsic ) , which is explained here .
suppose @xmath81 , and @xmath82 are random vectors with feature maps @xmath83 , and @xmath84 , where @xmath85 , and @xmath86 are rkhss .
the cross - covariance operator corresponding to the joint probability distribution @xmath87 is a linear operator , @xmath88 such that : @xmath89,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath90 denotes the tensor product , @xmath91= e[k(\cdot , x)]$ ] , and @xmath92=e[k(\cdot , y)]$ ] , for @xmath93 , and associated kernel function @xmath36 .
the hsic measure for separable rkhs @xmath85 , and @xmath86 is the squared hs - norm of the cross - covariance operator and is denoted as : @xmath94\end{aligned}\ ] ] * theorem 1 . *
assume @xmath95 , and @xmath96 are compact , for all @xmath97 , and @xmath98 , @xmath99 , and @xmath100 , @xmath101 if and only if @xmath102 , and @xmath7 are independent ( theorem 4 in @xcite ) . + by computing the hsic on covariance matrix associated with model s parameters
@xmath103 we can measure the independence between the parameters . since @xmath104 is a symmetric positive semi - definite matrix , @xmath105 , and
the trace of the hs norm of the covariance matrix is equal to : @xmath106 = \sum_{j=1}^p v_j^2\nonumber\\ ~~&= \sigma^4 \operatorname{tr}[k(k+\alpha i)^{-2 } k(k+\alpha i)^{-2}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] kic is defined as : @xmath107 where @xmath108 is the complexity term based on equation [ eq : hs ] .
the normalization by @xmath109 obtains a complexity measure that is robust to changes in variance ( similar to icomp criterion ) .
the minimum kic defines the best model . ] .
the penalized log - likelihood ( pll ) in krr for normally distribution data is defined by : @xmath110 the unknown parameters @xmath22 , and @xmath111 are calculated by minimizing the kic objective function . @xmath112 we also investigated the effect of using @xmath113 $ ] , and @xmath61 $ ] as complexity terms .
the empirical results reported in subsection [ subsec : realdata ] on real datasets , and compared with kic .
we denote these information criteria as : @xmath114,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath115.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in both kic_1 , and kic_2 , similar to kic , @xmath116 , while because the complexity term is dependent on @xmath16 , @xmath111 for kic_1 is : @xmath117=0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if we denote @xmath118 , @xmath111 is the solution of a quadratic optimization problem , @xmath119 , where @xmath120 . in the case of kic_2 , the @xmath111 is the real root of the following cubic problem : @xmath121 where @xmath122 $ ] .
we compared kic with loocv @xcite , kernel - based icomp @xcite , and maximum log of marginal likelihood in gpr ( abbreviated as gpr ) @xcite to find the optimal ridge regressors .
the reason to compare kic with icomp and gpr is that in all of these methods the complexity measure computes the interdependency of model parameters as a function of covariance matrix in different ways .
loocv is a standard and commonly used methods for model selection .
* loocv : * re - sampling model selection methods like cross - validation is time consuming @xcite . for instance , the leave - one - out - cross - validation ( loocv ) has the computational cost of @xmath123 the number of parameter combinations ( @xmath124 is the processing time of the model selection algorithm @xmath125 ) for @xmath126 training samples . to have cross - validation methods with faster processing time ,
the closed form formula for the risk estimators of the algorithm under special conditions are provided .
we consider the kernel - based closed form of loocv for linear regression introduced by @xcite : @xmath127^{-1}[i - h]y\|_2 ^ 2}{n}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath128 is the hat matrix . *
maximizing the log of marginal likelihood ( gpr ) * is a kernel - based regression method . for a given training set @xmath129 , and @xmath130 ,
a multivariate gaussian distribution is defined on any function @xmath5 such that , @xmath131 , where @xmath39 is a kernel .
marginal likelihood is used as the model selection criterion in gpr , since it balances between the lack - of - fit and complexity of a model . maximizing the log of marginal likelihood obtains the optimal parameters for model selection .
the log of marginal likelihood is denoted as : @xmath132 where @xmath133 denotes the model s fit , @xmath134 , denotes the complexity , and @xmath135 is a normalization constant . without loss of generality in this paper gpr means the model selection criterion is used in gpr .
* icomp : * the kernel - based icomp introduced in @xcite is an information criterion to select the models and is defined as @xmath136 , where @xmath50 , and @xmath39 elaborated in equations [ eq : cicomp ] , and [ eq : sigmaicomp ] .
in this section we evaluate the performance of kic on synthetic , and real datasets , and compare with competing model selection methods .
kic was first evaluated on the problem of approximating @xmath137 from a set of 100 points sampled at regular intervals in @xmath138 $ ] . to evaluate robustness to noise , normal random noise
was added to the @xmath139 function at two noise - to - signal ( nsr ) ratios : @xmath140 , and @xmath141 .
figure [ sinc ] shows the sinc function and the perturbed datasets .
the following experiments were conducted : ( 1 ) shows how kic balances between gof and complexity , ( 2 ) shows how kic and mse on training sets change when the sample size and the level of noise in the data change ( 3 ) investigates the effect of using different kernels , and ( 4 ) evaluates the consistency of kic in parameter selection .
all experiments were run 100 times using randomly generated datasets , and corresponding test sets of size 1000 . * experiment 1 . * the effect of @xmath21 on complexity , lack - of - fit and kic values was measured by setting @xmath142 , with krr models being generated using a gaussian kernel with different standard deviations , @xmath143 , computed over the 100 data points .
the results are shown in figure [ co_la_kic ] . the model generated with @xmath144 overfits , because it is overly complex , while @xmath145 gives a simpler model that underfits .
as the ridge parameter @xmath21 increases , the model complexity decreases while the goodness - of - fit is adversely affected .
kic balances between these two terms , which yields a criterion to select a model that has good generalization , as well as goodness of fit to the data .
* experiment 2 . * the influence of training sample size was investigated by comparing sample sizes , @xmath1 , of 50 , and 100 , for a total of four sets of experiments : ( @xmath146 ) : ( @xmath147 ) , ( @xmath148 ) , ( @xmath149 ) , ( @xmath150 ) .
the gaussian kernel was used with @xmath151 . the kic value and mean squared error ( mse , @xmath152 ) , for different @xmath153 @xmath154 is shown in figure [ kic - mse ] .
the data with nsr=@xmath141 has larger mse values , and larger error bars , and consequently larger kic values compared to data with nsr=@xmath140 . in both cases , kic and mse change with similar profiles with respect to @xmath21 .
the noise and the sample size have no effect on kic for selecting the best model ( parameter @xmath21 ) .
* experiment 3 .
* the effect of using a gaussian kernel , @xmath155 , versus the cauchy kernel , @xmath156 , was investigated , where @xmath157 , and @xmath158 in the computation of the kernel - based model selection criteria icomp , kic , gpr , and loocv . the results are reported in figures [ gaussian kernel ] and [ cauchy kernel ] .
the graphs show box plots with markers at @xmath159 , and @xmath160 of the empirical distributions of mse values . as expected , the mse of all methods is larger when nsr is high , @xmath161 , and smaller for the larger of the two training sets ( 100 samples ) .
loocv , icomp , and kic performed comparably , and better than gpr using a gaussian kernel for data with nsr @xmath162 . in the other cases , the best results ( smallest mse ) was achieved by kic .
all methods have smaller mse values using the gaussian kernel versus the cauchy kernel .
gpr with the cauchy kernel obtains results comparable with kic , but with a standard deviation close to zero .
* experiment 4 .
* we assessed the consistency of selecting / tuning the parameters of the models in comparison with loocv .
we considered four experiment of sample size , @xmath163 , and nsr @xmath164 .
the parameters to tune or select are @xmath165 @xmath166 , and @xmath167 for the gaussian kernel .
the frequency of selecting the parameters are shown in figure [ loocv ] for loocv , and in figure [ kic_frequency ] for kic .
the more concentrated frequency shows the more consistent selecting criterion .
the diagrams show that kic is more consistent in selecting the parameters rather than loocv .
loocv is also sensitive to sample size .
it provides a more consistent result for benchmarks with @xmath168 samples .
+ we used three benchmarks selected from the delve datasets ( www.cs.toronto.edu/~delve/data ) : ( 1 ) abalone dataset ( 4177 instances , 7 dimensions ) , ( 2 ) kin - family of datasets ( 4 datasets ; 8192 instances , 8 dimensions ) , and ( 3 ) puma - family of datasets ( 4 datasets ; 8192 instances , 8 dimensions ) . for the abalone dataset , the task is to estimate the age of abalones .
we used normalized attributes in range [ 0,1 ] .
the experiment is repeated 100 times to obtain the confidence interval . in each trial
100 samples were selected randomly as the training set and the remaining 4077 samples as the test set .
the kin - family and puma - family datasets are realistic simulations of a robot arm taking into consideration combinations of attributes such as whether the arm movement is nonlinear ( n ) or fairly linear ( f ) , and whether the level of noise ( unpredictability ) in the data is : medium ( m ) , or high ( h ) .
the kin - family includes : kin-8fm , kin-8fh , kin-8 nm , kin-8nh datasets , and the puma - family contains : puma-8fm , puma-8fh , puma-8 nm , and puma-8nh datasets . in the kin - family of datasets , having the angular positions of an 8-link robot arm , the distance of the end effector of the robot arm from a starting position is predicted . the angular position of a link of the robot arm
is predicted given the angular positions , angular velocities , and the torques of the links .
we compared kic_1 ( [ eq : kic1 ] ) , kic_2 ( [ eq : kic2 ] ) , and kic with loocv , icomp , and gpr on the three datasets .
the results are shown as box - plots in figures [ abalone ] , [ kin - family ] , and [ puma - family ] for abalone , kin - family , and puma - family datasets , respectively .
the best results across all three datasets were achieved using kic , and the second best results were for loocv . for the abalone dataset , comparable results were achieved for kic and loocv , that are better than icomp , and the smallest mse value obtained by sgpr .
kic_1 , and kic_2 had similar mse values , which are larger than for the other methods . for the kin - family datasets , except for kin-8fm , kic gets better results than gpr , icomp , and loocv .
kic_1 , and kic_2 obtain better results than gpr , and loocv for kin-8fm , and kin-8 nm , which are datasets with medium level of noise , but larger mse value for datasets with high noise ( kin-8fh , and kin-8nh ) . for the puma - family datasets ,
kic got the best results on all datasets except for on puma-8 nm , where the smallest mse was achieved by loocv .
the result of kic is comparable to icomp and better than gpr for puma-8 nm dataset .
for puma-8fm , puma-8fh , and puma-8nh , although the median of mse for loocv and gpr are comparable to kic , kic has a more significant mse ( smaller interquartile in the box bots ) .
the median mse value for kic_1 , and kic_2 are closer to the median mse values of the other methods on puma-8fm , and puma-8 nm , where the noise level is moderate compared to puma-8fh , and puma-8nh , where the noise level is high . the sensitivity of kic_1 , and kic_2 to noise is due to the existence of variance in their formula .
kic_2 has a larger interquartile of mse than kic_1 in datasets with high noise , which highlights the effect of @xmath109 in its formula ( equation [ eq : kic2 ] ) rather than @xmath16 in equation .
we introduced a novel kernel - based information criterion ( kic ) for model selection in regression analysis . the complexity measure in kic
is defined on a variable - wise variance which explicitly computes the interdependency of each parameter involved in the model ; whereas in methods such as kernel - based icomp and gpr , this interdependency is defined on a covariance matrix , which obscures the true contribution of the model parameters .
we provided empirical evidence showing how kic outperforms loocv ( with kernel - based closed form formula of the estimator ) , kernel - based icomp , and gpr , on both artificial data and real benchmark datasets : abalon , kin family , and puma family . in these experiments ,
kic efficiently balances the goodness of fit and complexity of the model , is robust to noise ( although for higher noise we have larger confidence interval as expected ) and sample size , is consistent in tuning / selecting the ridge and kernel parameters , and has significantly smaller or comparable mean squared values with respect to competing methods , while yielding stronger regressors .
the effect of using different kernels was also investigated since the definition of a proper kernel plays an important role in kernel methods .
kic had superior performance using different kernels and for the proper one obtains smaller mse .
this work was funded by fnsnf grants ( p1tip2_148352 , pbtip2_140015 ) .
we want to thank arthur gretton , and zoltn szab for the fruitful discussions .
|
this paper introduces kernel - based information criterion ( kic ) for model selection in regression analysis . the novel kernel - based complexity measure in kic
efficiently computes the interdependency between parameters of the model using a variable - wise variance and yields selection of better , more robust regressors .
experimental results show superior performance on both simulated and real data sets compared to leave - one - out cross - validation ( loocv ) , kernel - based information complexity ( icomp ) , and maximum log of marginal likelihood in gaussian process regression ( gpr ) .
|
this work on pricing american options under proportional transaction costs goes back to the seminal discovery by @xcite that to hedge against a buyer who can exercise the option at any ( ordinary ) stopping time , the seller must in effect be protected against all mixed ( randomised ) stopping times .
this was followed by @xcite , who established a non - constructive dual representation for the set of strategies superhedging the seller s ( though not the buyer s ) position in an american option under transaction costs .
efficient iterative algorithms for computing the upper and lower hedging prices of the option , the hedging strategies , optimal stopping times as well as dual representations for both the seller and the buyer of an american option under transaction costs were developed by @xcite in a model with two assets , and @xcite in a multi - asset model .
all these approaches take it for granted that the buyer can only exercise the option instantly , at an ordinary stopping time of his choosing . by contrast , in the present paper we allow the buyer the flexibility to exercise an american option gradually , rather than all at a single time instance . though it would be difficult in practice to exercise a fraction of an option contract and to hold on to the reminder to exercise it later
, the holder of a large portfolio of options may well choose to exercise the individual contracts on different dates if that proves beneficial .
does this ability to exercise gradually affect the pricing bounds , hedging strategies and optimal stopping times for the buyer and/or seller ?
perhaps surprisingly , the answer to this question is yes , it does in the presence of transaction costs .
gradual exercise turns out to be linked to another feature , referred to as deferred solvency , which will also be studied here .
if a temporary loss of liquidity occurs in the market , as reflected by unusually large bid - ask spreads , agents may become insolvent .
being allowed to defer closing their positions until liquidity is restored might enable them to become solvent once again .
this gives more leeway when constructing hedging strategies than the usual requirement that agents should remain solvent at all times .
@xcite was the first to explore the consequences of gradual exercise and deferred solvency using a model with a single risky asset as a testing ground . in the present paper
these ideas are developed in a systematic manner and extended to the much more general setting of the multi - asset market model with transaction costs due to @xcite ; see also @xcite and @xcite .
pricing and hedging for the seller of an american option under transaction costs is a convex optimisation problem irrespective of whether instant or gradual exercise is permitted .
however , this is not so for the buyer . in this case one has to tackle a non - convex optimisation problem for options that can only be exercised instantly .
a very interesting consequence of gradual exercise is that pricing and hedging becomes a convex optimisation problem also for the buyer of an american option , making it possible to deploy convex duality methods .
the convexity of the problem also makes it much easier to implement the pricing and hedging algorithms numerically .
we will make use of this new opportunity in this paper .
the paper is organised as follows .
section [ sect - multi - curr - mod ] recalls the general setting of kabanov s multi - asset model with transaction costs . in section [
sect : inst - versus - grad - exe ] the hedging strategies for the buyer and seller and the corresponding option prices under gradual exercise are introduced and compared with the same notions under instant exercise
. a toy example is set up to demonstrate that it is easier to hedge an option and that the bid - ask spread of the option prices can be narrower under gradual exercise as compared to instant exercise . in section [
sect : seller ] the seller s case is studied in detail .
the notion of deferred solvency is first discussed and linked in proposition [ prop : am : seller : immediate - ultimate ] with the hedging problem for the seller of an american option with gradual exercise .
the sets of seller s hedging portfolios are then constructed and related to the ask price of the option under gradual exercise and to a construction of a seller s hedging strategy realising the ask price ; see theorem [ prop : seller : zau0=initial - endowments ] .
a dual representation of the seller s price is established in theorem [ thm : ask - price - representation ] .
the toy example is revisited to illustrate the various constructions and results for the seller .
section [ sect : buyer ] is devoted to the buyer s case .
buyer s hedging portfolios and strategies are constructed and used to compute the bid price of the option ; see theorem [ prop:2012 - 07 - 26:hedging - construct ] .
finally , the dual representation for the buyer is explored in theorem [ th : bu - buyer ] .
once again , the toy example serves to illustrate the results .
a numerical example with three assets can be found in section [ sec : num - example ] . some conclusions and possible further developments and ramifications are touched upon in section [ sect : conclusions ] . technical information and proofs
are collected in the appendix .
let @xmath0 be a filtered probability space .
we assume that @xmath1 is finite , @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 for all @xmath5 . for each @xmath6 let @xmath7 be the collection of atoms of @xmath8 , called the _ nodes _ of the associated tree model .
a node @xmath9 is said to be a _
successor _ of a node @xmath10 if @xmath11 . for each @xmath12
we denote the collection of successors of any given node @xmath10 by @xmath13 . for each @xmath6 let @xmath14 be the collection of @xmath8-measurable @xmath15-valued random variables .
we identify elements of @xmath16 with functions on @xmath7 whenever convenient .
we consider the discrete - time currency model introduced by @xcite and developed further by @xcite and @xcite among others .
the model contains @xmath17 assets or currencies . at each trading date @xmath18 and for each @xmath19 one unit of asset @xmath20 can be obtained by exchanging @xmath21 units of asset @xmath22 .
we assume that the exchange rates @xmath23 are @xmath8-measurable and @xmath24 for all @xmath25 and @xmath26 .
we say that a portfolio @xmath27 is can be _ exchanged _ into a portfolio @xmath28 at time @xmath25 whenever there are @xmath8-measurable random variables @xmath29 , @xmath30 such that for all @xmath31 @xmath32 where @xmath33 represents the number of units of asset @xmath20 received as a result of exchanging some units of asset @xmath22 . the _ solvency cone _
@xmath34 is the set of portfolios that are _ solvent _ at time @xmath25 , i.e. the portfolios at time @xmath25 that can be exchanged into portfolios with non - negative holdings in all @xmath17 assets .
it is straightforward to show that @xmath35 is the convex cone generated by the canonical basis @xmath36 of @xmath15 and the vectors @xmath37 for @xmath30 , and so @xmath35 is a polyhedral cone , hence closed .
note that @xmath35 contains all the non - negative elements of @xmath16 .
a _ trading strategy _
@xmath38 is a predictable @xmath15-valued process with final value @xmath39 and initial endowment @xmath40 . for each @xmath41 the portfolio @xmath42
is held from time @xmath43 to time @xmath25 .
let @xmath44 be the set of trading strategies .
we say that @xmath45 is a _ self - financing _
strategy whenever @xmath46 for all @xmath12 . note that no implicitly assumed self - financing condition is included in the definition of @xmath44
. a trading strategy @xmath45 is an _ arbitrage opportunity _ if it is self - financing , @xmath47 and there is a portfolio @xmath48 with non - negative holdings in all @xmath17 assets such that @xmath49 .
this notion of arbitrage was considered by @xcite , and its absence is formally different but equivalent to the weak no - arbitrage condition introduced by @xcite .
[ th:2012 - 10 - 03:ftap ] the model admits no arbitrage opportunity if and only if there exists a probability measure @xmath50 equivalent to @xmath51 and an @xmath15-valued @xmath50-martingale @xmath52 such that @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the polar of @xmath55 ; see ( [ eq:2012 - 09 - 20:aast ] ) in the appendix .
we denote by @xmath56 the set of pairs @xmath57 satisfying the conditions in theorem [ th:2012 - 10 - 03:ftap ] , and by @xmath58 the set of pairs @xmath57 satisfying the conditions in theorem [ th:2012 - 10 - 03:ftap ] but with @xmath50 absolutely continuous with respect to ( and not necessarily equivalent to ) @xmath51 .
we assume for the remainder of this paper that the model admits no arbitrage opportunities , i.e. @xmath59 . in place of a pair @xmath60
one can equivalently use the so - called _ consistent price process _
@xmath61 ; see @xcite .
we also define for any @xmath62 @xmath63 in the absence of arbitrage @xmath54 is a non - empty compactly @xmath64-generated polyhedral cone for all @xmath25 ( * ? ? ?
* remark 2.2 ) , which means that @xmath65 .
( for the definition of a compactly @xmath64-generated cone , see appendix [ subsect : comp - gen - cones ] . )
the payoff of an american option in the model with @xmath17 underlying currencies is , in general , an @xmath15-valued adapted process @xmath66 .
the seller of the american option is obliged to deliver , and the buyer is entitled to receive the portfolio of currencies @xmath67 at a stopping time @xmath68 chosen by the buyer . here @xmath69 denotes the family of stopping times with values in @xmath70 .
this is the usual setup in which the option is exercised _ instantly _ at a stopping time @xmath68 .
american options with the provision for instant exercise in the multi - currency model under proportional transaction costs have been studied by @xcite , who established a non - constructive characterisation of the superhedging strategies for the option seller only , and by @xcite , who provided computationally efficient iterative constructions of the ask and bid option prices and the superhedging strategies for both the option seller and buyer . in the present paper
we relax the requirement that the option needs to be exercised instantly at a stopping time @xmath68 .
instead , we allow the buyer to exercise _ gradually _ at a mixed stopping time @xmath71 .
( for the definition of mixed stopping times , see appendix [ sect : mixed - stop - times ] . )
if the buyer chooses to exercise the option gradually according to a mixed stopping time @xmath71 , then the seller of the american option will be obliged to deliver , and the buyer will be entitled to receive the fraction @xmath72 of the portfolio of currencies @xmath73 at each time @xmath6 . the question then arises whether or not it would be more beneficial for the buyer to exercise the option gradually rather than instantly ? what will be the optimal mixed stopping time @xmath71 for the buyer ?
how should the seller hedge against gradual exercise ?
are the ask ( seller s ) and bid ( buyer s ) option prices and hedging strategies affected by gradual exercise as compared to instant exercise ? in the case of instant exercise the seller of an american option @xmath74 needs to hedge by means of a trading strategy @xmath45 against all ordinary stopping times @xmath68 chosen by the buyer . the trading strategy @xmath75 needs to be self - financing up to time @xmath76 and to allow the seller to remain solvent on delivering the portfolio @xmath67 at time @xmath76 , for any @xmath68 . hence the family of seller s superhedging strategies
is defined as @xmath77 and the _ ask price _ ( _ seller s price _ ) of the option in currency @xmath62 is @xmath78 this is the smallest amount in currency @xmath64 needed to superhedge a short position in @xmath74 . on the other hand , the buyer of an american option @xmath74 can select both a stopping time @xmath68 and a trading strategy @xmath45 .
the trading strategy @xmath75 needs to be self - financing up to time @xmath76 and to allow the buyer to remain solvent on receiving the portfolio @xmath67 at time @xmath76 .
thus , the family of buyer s superhedging strategies is defined as @xmath79 and the _ bid price _ ( _ buyer s price _ ) of the option in currency @xmath62 is @xmath80 this is the largest amount in currency @xmath64 that the buyer can raise using the option @xmath74 as surety . for american options with instant exercise , iterative constructions of the ask and bid option prices @xmath81 and @xmath82 and the corresponding seller s and buyer s superhedging strategies from @xmath83 and @xmath84 were established by @xcite .
when the buyer is allowed to exercise gradually , the seller needs to follow a suitable trading strategy to hedge his exposure .
since the seller can react to the buyer s actions , this strategy may in general depend on the mixed stopping time @xmath71 followed by the buyer , and will be denoted by @xmath85 . in other words
, we consider a function @xmath86 . at each time
@xmath25 the seller will be holding a portfolio @xmath87 and will be obliged to deliver a fraction @xmath72 of the payoff @xmath73 .
he can then rebalance the remaining portfolio @xmath88 into @xmath89 in a self - financing manner , so that @xmath90the self - financing and superhedging conditions have merged into one .
we call ( [ eq : seller - self - fin - superhedge ] ) the _ rebalancing _ condition .
when creating the portfolio @xmath87 at time @xmath43 , the seller can only use information available at that time .
this includes @xmath91 , but the seller has no way of knowing the future values @xmath92 that will be chosen by the buyer .
the trading strategies @xmath85 that can be adopted by the seller are therefore restricted to those satisfying the _ non - anticipation _
condition @xmath93 in particular , the initial endowment @xmath94 of the trading strategy @xmath95 is the same for all @xmath71 .
we denote this common value by @xmath96 .
we define the family of seller s superhedging strategies against gradual exercise by @xmath97 and the corresponding _ ask price _ ( _ seller s price _ ) of the option in currency @xmath98 by @xmath99 this is the smallest amount in currency @xmath22 that the seller needs to superhedge a short position in the american option @xmath74 when the buyer is allowed to exercise gradually . on the other hand ,
the buyer is able to select both a mixed stopping time @xmath71 and a trading strategy @xmath45 , and will be taking delivery of a fraction @xmath72 of the payoff @xmath73 at each time @xmath25 . because the choice of the mixed stopping time @xmath100 is up to the buyer , the trading strategy @xmath75 needs to be good just for the one chosen stopping time , and does not need to be considered as a function of @xmath100 , in contrast to the seller s case .
the _ rebalancing _
condition @xmath101 needs to be satisfied .
hence , the family of superhedging strategies for the buyer of an american option @xmath74 with gradual exercise is defined as @xmath102 and the corresponding _ bid price _ ( _ buyer s price _ ) of the option in currency @xmath98 is @xmath103 this is the largest amount in currency @xmath22 that can be raised using the option as surety by a buyer who is able to exercise gradually .
[ exl : new]we consider a toy example with two assets , a foreign currency ( asset 1 ) and domestic currency ( asset 2 ) in a two - step binomial tree model with the following bid / ask foreign currency prices @xmath104 in each of the four scenarios in @xmath105:@xmath106{|c|cc|cc|cc|}\hline $ \rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ s_{0}^{\mathrm{b}}$ & $ s_{0}^{\mathrm{a}}$ & $ s_{1}^{\mathrm{b}}$ & $ s_{1}^{\mathrm{a}}$ & $ s_{2}^{\mathrm{b}}$ & $ s_{2}^{\mathrm{a}}$\\\hline $ \omega_{1}$ & $ 5 $ & $ 5 $ & $ 3 $ & $ 9 $ & $ 4 $ & $ 8$\\\cline{6 - 7}$\omega_{2}$ & $ 5 $ & $ 5 $ & $ 3 $ & $ 9 $ & $ 4 $ & $ 4$\\\cline{4 - 7}$\omega_{3}$ & $ 5 $ & $ 5 $ & $ 2 $ & $ 2 $ & $ 3 $ & $ 3$\\\cline{6 - 7}$\omega_{4}$ & $ 5 $ & $ 5 $ & $ 2 $ & $ 2 $ & $ 1 $ & $ 1$\\\hline \end{tabular}\ ] ] note there are only two nodes with a non - trivial bid / ask spread , namely the ` up ' node @xmath107 and the ` up - up ' node @xmath108 . the corresponding exchange rates are @xmath109{cc}\pi_{t}^{11 } & \pi_{t}^{12}\\ \pi_{t}^{21 } & \pi_{t}^{22}\end{array } \right ] = \left [ \begin{array } [ c]{cc}1 & 1/s_{t}^{\mathrm{b}}\\ s_{t}^{\mathrm{a } } & 1 \end{array } \right ] .\ ] ] in this model we consider an american option with the following payoff process @xmath110:@xmath106{|c|c|c|c|}\hline $ \rule[-0.15cm]{0pt}{0.5cm}$ & $ \xi_{0}$ & $ \xi_{1}$ & $ \xi_{2}$\\\hline $ \omega_{1}$ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ & $ \left ( 0,4\right ) $ & $ \left ( 2,-8\right ) $ \\\cline{4 - 4}$\omega_{2}$ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ & $ \left ( 0,4\right ) $ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ \\\cline{3 - 4}$\omega_{3}$ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ \\\cline{4 - 4}$\omega_{4}$ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ \\\hline \end{tabular}\ ] ] in the case when the option can only be exercised instantly , using the algorithms of @xcite we can compute the bid and ask prices of the option in the domestic currency to be@xmath111 now consider @xmath112 given by@xmath106{|c|c|c|c|}\hline $ \rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ y_{0}^{\chi}$ & $ y_{1}^{\chi}$ & $ y_{2}^{\chi}$\\\hline $ \omega_{1}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ \left ( 0,5\right ) $ & $ \left ( 1,0\right ) $ & $ \left ( 1,-4\chi_{1}^{\omega_{1}}\right ) $ \\
$ \omega_{2}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ \left ( 0,5\right ) $ & $ \left ( 1,0\right ) $ & $ \left ( 1,-4\chi_{1}^{\omega_{2}}\right ) $ \\\cline{4 - 4}$\omega_{3}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ \left ( 0,5\right ) $ & $ \left ( 1,0\right ) $ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ \\ $ \omega_{4}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ \left ( 0,5\right ) $ & $ \left ( 1,0\right ) $ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ \\\hline \end{tabular}\ ] ] for any @xmath71 .
also consider @xmath45 and @xmath113 such that@xmath106{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|}\hline $ \rule[-0.15cm]{0pt}{0.5cm}$ & $ y_{0}$ & $ y_{1}$ & $ y_{2}$ & $ \chi_{0}$ & $ \chi_{1}$ & $ \chi_{2}$\\\hline $ \omega_{1}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ \left ( 0,-3\right ) $ & $ \left ( -1,2\right ) $ & $ \left ( -1,4\right ) $ & $ 0 $ & $ \frac{1}{2}$ & $ \frac{1}{2}$\\ $ \omega_{2}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ \left ( 0,-3\right ) $ & $ \left ( -1,2\right ) $ & $ \left ( -1,4\right ) $ & $ 0 $ & $ \frac{1}{2}$ & $ \frac{1}{2}$\\\cline{4 - 4}\cline{6 - 7}$\omega_{3}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ \left ( 0,-3\right ) $ & $ \left ( -1,2\right ) $ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ & $ 0 $ & $ 0 $ & $ 1$\\ $ \omega_{4}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ \left ( 0,-3\right ) $ & $ \left ( -1,2\right )
$ & $ \left ( 0,0\right ) $ & $ 0 $ & $ 0 $ & $ 1$\\\hline \end{tabular}\ ] ] we can verify that @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
the existence of these strategies means that@xmath116 this example demonstrates that the seller s and buyer s prices @xmath117 under gradual exercise may differ from their respective counterparts @xmath118 under instant exercise . it demonstrates the need to revisit and investigate the pricing and superhedging results in the case when the instant exercise provision is relaxed and replaced by gradual exercise .
we have seen in example [ exl : new ] that the seller s price @xmath119 may be higher than @xmath120 .
the reason is that an option seller who follows a hedging strategy @xmath121 is required to be instantly solvent upon delivering the payoff at the stopping time @xmath68 when the buyer has chosen to exercise the option .
meanwhile , a seller who follows a strategy @xmath122 will be able to continue rebalancing the strategy up to the time horizon @xmath123 as long as a solvent position can be reached eventually .
being able to defer solvency in this fashion allows more flexibility for the seller , resulting in a lower seller s price . on the other hand
, it might appear that a seller who hedges against gradual exercise ( against mixed stopping times ) would have a harder task to accomplish than someone who only needs to hedge against instant exercise ( ordinary stopping times ) .
however , this turns out not to be a factor affecting the seller s price , as we shall see in proposition [ prop : am : seller : immediate - ultimate ] .
these considerations indicate that the notion of solvency needs to be relaxed .
we say that a portfolio @xmath124 satisfies the _ deferred solvency _ condition at time @xmath25 if it can be exchanged into a solvent portfolio by time @xmath123 without any additional investment , i.e. if there is a sequence @xmath125 such that @xmath126 for all @xmath127 and @xmath128 we call such a sequence @xmath125 a _ liquidation strategy _ starting from @xmath129 at time @xmath25
. the set of portfolios satisfying the deferred solvency condition at time @xmath25 is a cone .
we call it the _ deferred solvency cone _ and denote by @xmath130
. in example [ exl : new ] the portfolio with @xmath131 in the domestic currency and @xmath132 in the foreign currency is insolvent at the ` up ' node @xmath133 at time @xmath134 , that is , @xmath135 .
it does , however , satisfy the deferred solvency condition at that node , i.e. @xmath136 .
the large bid - ask spread @xmath137=[3,9]$ ] at node @xmath138 indicates a temporary loss of liquidity .
although the portfolio is insolvent at that node , waiting until the market recovers from the loss of liquidity can restore solvency .
the liquidation strategy is to hold the portfolio until time @xmath139 and to buy the foreign currency then .
the following result shows that the deferred solvency cones @xmath130 can be regarded as the sets of time @xmath25 superhedging portfolios for the seller of a european option with expiry time @xmath123 and zero payoff ; see @xcite .
[ prop : constr : ultimate - solvent ] the deferred solvency cones can be constructed by backward induction as follows : @xmath140 the proof of proposition [ prop : constr : ultimate - solvent ] can be found in appendix [ sect : appendix : defer - solv ] . from ( [ eq : qt - recursive ] ) we can see that for any @xmath12 and for any @xmath10 @xmath141 by backward induction , @xmath142 is given as an intersection and algebraic sum of a finite number of polyhedral cones , so it is a polyhedral cone .
this also means the solvency cones can readily be computed using standard operations on polyhedral convex sets .
the next result shows that theorem [ th:2012 - 10 - 03:ftap ] can be formulated equivalently in terms of the deferred solvency cones @xmath130 instead of the solvency cones @xmath35 .
[ prop : mart - ito - q ] if @xmath50 is a probability measure and @xmath52 is an @xmath15-valued @xmath50-martingale , then @xmath143 satisfies if and only if @xmath144 where @xmath145 is the polar of @xmath146 .
the proof of proposition [ prop : mart - ito - q ] is in appendix [ sect : appendix : defer - solv ] .
we extend the family @xmath83 of seller s superhedging strategies by allowing for deferred solvency : @xmath147 the following proposition shows that the set of initial endowments that allow the seller to hedge against gradual exercise is the same as that allowing to hedge against instant exercise with deferred solvency .
[ prop : am : seller : immediate - ultimate ] for any american option
@xmath74 @xmath148 for the proof of proposition [ prop : am : seller : immediate - ultimate ] , see appendix [ sect : appendix : technical : seller ] .
we now present an iterative construction of the set of initial endowments that allow superhedging for the seller under deferred solvency . by proposition [ prop : am : seller : immediate - ultimate ] , this also gives the set of initial endowments that allow superhedging for the seller under gradual exercise .
[ const : am : seller ] construct adapted sequences @xmath149 , @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath152 for @xmath6 by @xmath153 it follows by backward induction that the sets @xmath154 are convex and polyhedral for each @xmath12 and @xmath10 because the algebraic sum and the intersection of a finite number of convex polyhedral sets are convex and polyhedral , and @xmath155 are convex polyhedral sets for each @xmath156 .
moreover , @xmath149 , @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath152 are non - empty for each @xmath6 because the portfolio @xmath157 belongs to all of them when @xmath158 is large enough .
[ prop : seller : zau0=initial - endowments ] the set of initial endowments that superhedge the seller s position in the american option @xmath74 under gradual exercise is equal to @xmath159 and the ask ( seller s ) price of the option in currency @xmath98 can be computed as @xmath160 moreover , a strategy @xmath122 can be constructed such that @xmath161 the proof of theorem [ prop : seller : zau0=initial - endowments ] can be found in appendix [ sect : appendix : technical : seller ] .
we can conclude that the set of initial endowments @xmath162 superhedging the seller s position , the option ask price @xmath163 , and a superhedging strategy @xmath164 realising the ask price can be computed by means of standard operations on convex polyhedral sets .
working within the setting of example [ exl : new ] , we can now apply the constructions described in the current section to compute the sets @xmath165 of superhedging portfolios for the seller . these are sets of portfolios @xmath166 satisfying the inequalities@xmath106{|c|c|c|c|}\hline $ \rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ \mathcal{z}_{0}^{\mathrm{ad}}$ & $ \mathcal{z}_{1}^{\mathrm{ad}}$ & $ \mathcal{z}_{2}^{\mathrm{ad}}$\\\hline $ \omega_{1}\rule[-0.4cm]{0cm}{1.05cm}$ & $ 5x^{1}+x^{2}\geq5 $ & $ \begin{array } [ c]{l}8x^{1}+x^{2}\geq8\\ 4x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0 \end{array } $ & $ \begin{array } [ c]{l}8x^{1}+x^{2}\geq8\\ 4x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0 \end{array } $ \\\cline{4 - 4}$\omega_{2}\rule[-0.4cm]{0cm}{1.05cm}$ & $ 5x^{1}+x^{2}\geq5
$ & $ \begin{array } [ c]{l}8x^{1}+x^{2}\geq8\\ 4x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0 \end{array } $ & $ 4x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0$\\\cline{3 - 4}$\omega_{3}\rule[-0.4cm]{0cm}{1.05cm}$ & $ 5x^{1}+x^{2}\geq5 $ & $ 2x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0 $ & $ 3x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0$\\\cline{4 - 4}$\omega_{4}\rule[-0.4cm]{0cm}{1.05cm}$ & $ 5x^{1}+x^{2}\geq5 $ & $ 2x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0 $ & $ x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0$\\\hline \end{tabular}\ ] ] from @xmath167 we obtain the ask price @xmath168 we can also construct a superhedging strategy @xmath114 such that @xmath169 it is the strategy @xmath164 specified in example [ exl : new ] . a dual representation of the seller s price @xmath163 can be obtained with the aid of the support function @xmath170 of @xmath171 .
for the definition of the support function of a convex set , see appendix [ subsect : conv - anal ] . more generally , let @xmath172 , @xmath173 , @xmath174 , @xmath175 be the support functions of the sets @xmath176 , @xmath177 , @xmath178 , @xmath179 of construction [ const : am : seller ] .
the functions @xmath172 , @xmath173 @xmath174 , @xmath175 are polyhedral ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 19.2.1 ) , hence continuous .
proposition [ prop : seller : dual ] in appendix [ sect : appendix : technical : seller ] lists a number of properties of support functions , which will prove useful in what follows .
[ prop:20130727:pi - ag - dual ] the seller s price of an american option @xmath74 with gradual exercise can be written as @xmath180 for some mixed stopping time @xmath71 , a probability measure @xmath50 and an @xmath15-valued adapted process @xmath143 such that @xmath181 and @xmath182 for all @xmath6 .
such @xmath100 , @xmath50 and @xmath143 can be constructed by a recursive procedure .
the notation @xmath183 , @xmath184 and @xmath185 used in proposition [ prop:20130727:pi - ag - dual ] is defined by ( [ eq:2012 - 10 - 03:sigmai ] ) , ( [ eq:20130726-x - chi - star ] ) and ( [ eq:20130726-x - stopped - at - chi ] ) . the proof is provided in appendix [ sect : appendix : technical : seller ] . for any @xmath71 denote by @xmath186 the set of pairs @xmath57 such that @xmath50 is a probability measure and
@xmath143 is an @xmath15-valued adapted process satisfying ( [ eq : chi - approx - u ] ) .
also define for @xmath62 @xmath187 the lack of arbitrage opportunities and proposition [ prop : mart - ito - q ] ensure that @xmath188 for all @xmath71 . the superscript @xmath189 indicating deferred solvency distinguishes @xmath186 and @xmath190 from the collections @xmath191 and @xmath192 defined by @xcite in a similar way as above , but with the weaker condition @xmath193 in place of .
the following result provides a representation of @xmath163 dual to the representation ( [ eq:20130728:def - pi - ag ] ) in terms of superhedging strategies .
[ thm : ask - price - representation ] the ask price in currency @xmath98 of an american option @xmath74 with gradual exercise can be written as @xmath194 moreover , we can algorithmically construct @xmath195 , and @xmath196 such that @xmath197 this theorem is proved in appendix [ sect : appendix : technical : seller ] .
we continue working in the setting of example [ exl : new ] . the mixed stopping time @xmath195 and a pair @xmath198 such that @xmath199 are@xmath106{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|}\hline $ \rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ \mathbb{\hat{q}}$ & $ \hat{s}_{0}$ & $ \hat { s}_{1}$ & $ \hat{s}_{2}$ & $ \hat{\chi}_{0}$ & $ \hat{\chi}_{1}$ & $ \hat{\chi } _
{ 2}$\\\hline $ \omega_{1}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ 1 $ & $ ( 5,1)$ & $ ( 4,1)$ & $ ( 8,1)$ & $ 0 $ & $ \frac{3}{4}$ & $ \frac{1}{4}$\\\cline{2 - 2}\cline{5 - 5}$\omega_{2}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ 0 $ & $ ( 5,1)$ & $ ( 4,1)$ & $ ( 4,1)$ & $ 0 $ & $ \frac{3}{4}$ & $ \frac{1}{4}$\\\cline{0 - 2}\cline{4 - 5}\cline{7 - 8}$\omega_{3}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ 0 $ & $ ( 5,1)$ & $ ( 2,1)$ & $ ( 3,1)$ & $ 0 $ & $ 0 $ & $ 1$\\\cline{2 - 2}\cline{5 - 5}$\omega_{4}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ 0 $ & $ ( 5,1)$ & $ ( 2,1)$ & $ ( 1,1)$ & $ 0 $ & $ 0 $ & $ 1$\\\hline \end{tabular}\ ] ]
the buyer of an american option @xmath74 is entitled to receive the payoff according to a mixed stopping time @xmath71 of his choosing . in other words , the buyer receives @xmath200 at each time @xmath6 .
the family @xmath201 of superhedging strategies for the buyer and the bid price ( buyer s price ) @xmath202 under gradual exercise are defined in section [ sect : grad - exe ] .
we turn to the task of computing the bid price and an optimal superhedging strategy for the buyer .
we start by computing the set if initial endowments that allow superhedging for the buyer .
[ const:2012 - 07 - 26.1 ] construct adapted sequences @xmath203 , @xmath204 , @xmath205 , @xmath206 for @xmath6 by @xmath207 for each @xmath25 the convex hull in is taken on each atom of @xmath8 , i.e. for all @xmath10 @xmath208 the index @xmath189 indicates that the deferred solvency cones @xmath130 are used in this construction .
the sets @xmath203 , @xmath204 , @xmath205 , @xmath206 are non - empty for each @xmath6 because the portfolio @xmath157 belongs to all of them when @xmath158 is large enough .
in contrast with construction 4.6 of @xcite , which was used the case of instant exercise at an ordinary stopping time , we have the convex hull of @xmath209 in ( [ eq : mathcal - zt ] ) rather than the union of sets .
this means that @xmath203 , @xmath204 , @xmath205 , @xmath206 are convex sets , unlike their counterparts in construction 4.6 of @xcite .
this is important because , once it is established in the next proposition that the @xmath206 are polyhedral , it becomes possible to implement techniques from convex analysis to compute them .
[ prop:2012 - 09 - 19:zt - closed ] the set @xmath206 in construction [ const:2012 - 07 - 26.1 ] is polyhedral with recession cone @xmath130 for each @xmath6 .
the proof of proposition [ prop:2012 - 09 - 19:zt - closed ] can be found in appendix [ sect : appendix : technical : buyer ] .
the next result shows that construction [ const:2012 - 07 - 26.1 ] produces the set of initial endowments that superhedges @xmath74 for the buyer , which in turn makes it possible to compute the option bid price and also to construct a strategy that realises this price .
this is similar to theorem [ prop : seller : zau0=initial - endowments ] for the seller .
[ prop:2012 - 07 - 26:hedging - construct ] the set of initial endowments that superhedge the buyer s position in the american option @xmath74 with gradual exercise is equal to @xmath210 and the bid ( buyer s ) price of the option in currency @xmath98 can be computed as @xmath211 moreover , a strategy @xmath212 can be constructed such that @xmath213 the proof of this theorem is also in appendix [ sect : appendix : technical : buyer ] . still within the setting of example [ exl : new ]
, we apply the constructions described in the current section to compute the sets @xmath214 of superhedging portfolios for the buyer . these are sets of portfolios @xmath166 satisfying the inequalities@xmath106{|c|c|c|c|}\hline $ \rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ \mathcal{z}_{0}^{\mathrm{bd}}$ & $ \mathcal{z}_{1}^{\mathrm{bd}}$ & $ \mathcal{z}_{2}^{\mathrm{bd}}$\\\hline $ \omega_{1}\rule[-0.6cm]{0cm}{1.45cm}$ & $ 5x^{1}+x^{2}\geq-3 $ & $ \begin{array } [ c]{c}8x^{1}+x^{2}\geq-8\\ 6x^{1}+x^{2}\geq-4\\ 4x^{1}+x^{2}\geq-4 \end{array } $ & $ \begin{array } [ c]{l}8x^{1}+x^{2}\geq-8\\
4x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0 \end{array } $ \\\cline{1 - 1}\cline{4 - 4}$\omega_{2}\rule[-0.6cm]{0cm}{1.45cm}$ & $ 5x^{1}+x^{2}\geq-3 $ & $ \begin{array } [ c]{c}8x^{1}+x^{2}\geq-8\\ 6x^{1}+x^{2}\geq-4\\ 4x^{1}+x^{2}\geq-4 \end{array } $ & $ 4x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0$\\\cline{1 - 1}\cline{3 - 4}$\omega_{3}\rule[-0.6cm]{0cm}{1.45cm}$ & $ 5x^{1}+x^{2}\geq-3 $ & $ 2x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0 $ & $ 3x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0$\\\cline{1 - 1}\cline{4 - 4}$\omega_{4}\rule[-0.6cm]{0cm}{1.45cm}$ & $ 5x^{1}+x^{2}\geq-3
$ & $ 2x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0 $ & $ x^{1}+x^{2}\geq0$\\\hline \end{tabular}\ ] ] from @xmath215 we obtain the ask price @xmath216 we can also construct a superhedging strategy @xmath217 such that @xmath218 it is the strategy @xmath219 specified in example [ exl : new ] . since the @xmath220 , @xmath221 , @xmath222 , @xmath214
are convex , it becomes possible to apply convex duality methods not just in the seller s case but also in the buyer s case .
( this was impossible to do in @xcite for american options with instant exercise because of the lack of convexity in the buyer s case . ) in particular , in a similar way as in the proof of proposition [ prop:20130727:pi - ag - dual ] , we can show that the bid price of an american option with payoff @xmath74 under gradual exercise can be expressed as@xmath223 in terms of the support function @xmath224 of @xmath225
. however , we follow a different approach to obtain a representation of the bid price @xmath226 dual to the representation ( [ eq : buyer - bid - price - gradual ] ) of @xmath226 by means of superhedging strategies . in theorem [ prop:2012 - 07 - 26:hedging - construct ] a mixed stopping time @xmath71 has already been constructed as part of a superhedging strategy @xmath217 such that @xmath227 . as a result , the bid price given by ( [ eq : buyer - bid - price - gradual ] ) can be written as@xmath228 for this mixed stopping time @xmath100 .
it turns out that the set on the right - hand side can be expressed by means of the family @xmath229 of superhedging strategies for the seller of a european option with expiry time @xmath123 and payoff @xmath230 as described in appendix [ sect : eur - opt ] , where @xmath231 is defined by ( [ eq:20130726-x - stopped - at - chi ] ) .
[ prop : am - eur ] for any american option @xmath74 and any mixed stopping time @xmath232 we have@xmath233 this proposition is proved in appendix [ sect : appendix : technical : buyer ] .
we are now in a position to state a representation of the bid price dual to ( [ eq : buyer - bid - price - gradual ] ) , and to prove it with the aid of proposition [ prop : am - eur ] .
[ th : bu - buyer ] the buyer s ( bid ) price of an american option @xmath74 in currency @xmath98 can be represented as @xmath234 where @xmath184 is defined by ( [ eq:20130726-x - stopped - at - chi ] ) .
moreover , we can algorithmically construct @xmath195 and @xmath235 such that @xmath236 the proof of theorem [ th : bu - buyer ] is in appendix [ sect : appendix : technical : buyer ] .
we revisit example [ exl : new ] one more time to construct a mixed stopping time @xmath195 and a pair @xmath237 such that @xmath238 they are@xmath106{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|}\hline $ \rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ \mathbb{\hat{q}}$ & $ \hat{s}_{0}$ & $ \hat { s}_{1}$ & $ \hat{s}_{2}$ & $ \hat{\chi}_{0}$ & $ \hat{\chi}_{1}$ & $ \hat{\chi } _
{ 2}$\\\hline $ \omega_{1}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ 1 $ & $ ( 5,1)$ & $ ( 5,1)$ & $ ( 5,1)$ & $ 0 $ & $ \frac{1}{2}$ & $ \frac{1}{2}$\\\cline{2 - 2}\cline{5 - 5}$\omega_{2}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ 0 $ & $ ( 5,1)$ & $ ( 5,1)$ & $ ( 4,1)$ & $ 0 $ & $ \frac{1}{2}$ & $ \frac{1}{2}$\\\cline{0 - 2}\cline{4 - 5}\cline{7 - 8}$\omega_{3}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ 0 $ & $ ( 5,1)$ &
$ ( 2,1)$ & $ ( 3,1)$ & $ 0 $ & $ 0 $ & $ 1$\\\cline{2 - 2}\cline{5 - 5}$\omega_{4}\rule[-0.2cm]{0pt}{0.6cm}$ & $ 0 $ & $ ( 5,1)$ & $ ( 2,1)$ & $ ( 1,1)$ & $ 0 $ & $ 0 $ & $ 1$\\\hline \end{tabular}\ ] ]
in this section we present a three - dimensional numerical example with a realistic flavour to illustrate constructions [ const : am : seller ] and [ const:2012 - 07 - 26.1 ] .
the numerical procedures below were implemented in _
maple _ with the aid of the _ convex _ package @xcite .
consider a model involving a domestic currency and two foreign currencies , with time horizon @xmath239 and with * @xmath240 * time steps .
the friction - free nominal exchange rates @xmath241 between the domestic currency and the two foreign currencies follow the two - asset recombinant @xcite model with cholesky decomposition .
that is , there are @xmath242 possibilities for the exchange rates at each time step @xmath6 , indexed by pairs @xmath243 with @xmath244 , and each non - terminal node with exchange rates @xmath245 has four successors , associated with exchange rates @xmath246 , @xmath247 , @xmath248 and @xmath249 . with @xmath250 defined for convenience , the exchange rates are given by @xmath251 for @xmath6 and @xmath252 , where @xmath253 and @xmath254 are the initial exchange rates , @xmath255 and @xmath256 are the volatilities and @xmath257 is the correlation between the logarithmic growth of the exchange rates .
assume that proportional transaction costs of @xmath258 are payable on all currency exchanges , except at time step @xmath134 , when @xmath259 is payable , modelling a temporary loss of liquidity .
in other words , the matrix of exchange rates between each pair among the three currencies at each time step @xmath25 is @xmath260 where @xmath261 consider an american put option with physical delivery and strike @xmath262 on a basket containing one unit of each of the foreign currencies .
it offers the payoff @xmath263 we allow for the possibility that the option may never be exercised by adding an extra time step @xmath264 to the model and setting the payoff to be @xmath265 at that time step .
constructions [ const : am : seller ] and [ const:2012 - 07 - 26.1 ] give @xmath266 where @xmath267 is the convex cone generated by the vectors @xmath268 the sets @xmath269 and @xmath270 , which appear in figure [ fig:2 ] , yield the ask and bid prices @xmath271 in each of the three currencies .
[ c]cc & + @xmath269 & @xmath270
in this paper we have explored american options with gradual exercise within kabanov s model @xcite of many assets under transaction costs , along with the related notion of deferred solvency , which helps to deal with a temporary loss of liquidity ( large bid - ask spreads ) in the market .
we have demonstrated that gradual exercise ( at a mixed stopping time chosen by the buyer ) can reduce the ask ( seller s ) price and increase the bid ( buyer s ) price of the option compared with the case when the option can only be exercised instantly ( at an ordinary stopping time ) . in this context
we have constructed and implemented algorithms to compute the ask and bid option prices , the buyer s and seller s optimal hedging portfolios and strategies , and their optimal mixed stopping times .
we have studied dual representations for both the buyer and the seller of an american option with gradual exercise .
the results have been illustrated by numerical examples .
compared to options with instant exercise , a novel feature is that pricing and hedging an american option is a convex optimisation problem not just for the seller but also for the buyer of the option , making it possible to use convex duality in both cases .
ramifications to be explored further may include an extension of bouchard and temam s representation of the strategies hedging the seller s ( short ) position @xcite to the case of hedging the buyer s ( long ) position in the option .
we also conjecture that it should be possible to adapt the constructions presented here so that linear vector optimisation methods can be used to price and hedge both the seller s and buyer s positions in an american option with gradual exercise , along similar lines as was done by @xcite for european options under transaction costs .
for any non - empty convex cone @xmath272 , denote by @xmath273 the _ polar _ of @xmath274 , i.e. @xmath275 for any set @xmath272 define the _ cone generated by @xmath276 _ as @xmath277 the _ recession cone _ of a non - empty convex set @xmath272 is defined as @xmath278 it is a convex cone containing the origin ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 8.1 ) .
if @xmath276 is a polyhedral cone , then @xmath279 ( * ? ?
* corollary 8.3.2 ) .
the _ convex hull _ of sets @xmath280 in @xmath15 is the smallest convex set in @xmath15 that contains @xmath280 , and is denoted by @xmath281 .
the _ convex hull _ of convex functions @xmath282 is the function @xmath283 defined by @xmath284 the _ effective domain _ of a convex function @xmath285 is defined as @xmath286 the _ support function _
@xmath287 of a convex set @xmath272 is defined as @xmath288 equality follows directly from .
a vector @xmath295 is an element of @xmath296 if and only if @xmath297 and @xmath298 , if and only if @xmath299 and @xmath300 and @xmath298 , if and only if @xmath301 and @xmath302 , if and only if @xmath303 .
the set @xmath296 is compact since it is the intersection of two compact sets @xmath291 and @xmath304 .
it remains to show that @xmath296 is non - empty and generates @xmath293 . to this end , fix any @xmath305 .
as @xmath276 and @xmath306 are generated , respectively , by @xmath291 and @xmath304 , there exist @xmath307 , @xmath308 , @xmath309 and @xmath310 such that @xmath311 as @xmath312 , we must have @xmath313 and @xmath314 . moreover , since @xmath315 , we have @xmath316 which in turn implies @xmath317 , completing the proof .
[ lem : roux_zastawniak2011 ] fix any @xmath62 , and suppose that @xmath280 are non - empty closed convex sets in @xmath15 such that @xmath318 and @xmath319 is compactly @xmath64-generated for all @xmath20 .
then @xmath320 the cone @xmath321 is compactly @xmath64-generated and @xmath322 and for each @xmath323 there exist @xmath324 and @xmath325 with @xmath326 for all @xmath327 such that @xmath328 for any @xmath71 we put @xmath333moreover , for any adapted process @xmath334 and for any @xmath71 we put @xmath335 we also define _ @xmath334 evaluated at @xmath100 _ by @xmath336 with each ordinary stopping time @xmath68 we associate the mixed stopping time @xmath337 defined as @xmath338{cc}1 & \text{on } \{\tau = t\}\\ 0 & \text{on } \{\tau\neq t\ } \end{array } \right .
\quad\text{for each } t=0,\ldots , t.\ ] ] equality ( [ eq : qt = kt ] ) is obvious . by the definition of the deferred solvency cones , for any @xmath12 the following conditions are equivalent : @xmath339 if and only if there is a @xmath340 such that @xmath341 if and only if there is a sequence @xmath125 such that @xmath126 for each @xmath342 and @xmath343 if and only if @xmath344 .
this proves ( [ eq : qt - recursive ] ) .
conversely , suppose that @xmath143 is an @xmath15-valued @xmath50-martingale that satisfies . to show that it satisfies ( [ eq:2012 - 10 - 03:qastt - not - empty ] ) we proceed by backward induction .
by , we have @xmath347 . for any @xmath12 suppose that @xmath348 . as @xmath143 is a @xmath50-martingale
, we have for all @xmath10 that @xmath349 for every @xmath12 and @xmath10 , observe from that @xmath350^\ast.\ ] ] successive application of corollaries 16.4.2 and 16.5.2 in @xcite then gives @xmath351^\ast\cap\mathcal{k}^{\mu\ast}_t = \operatorname{conv}\{\mathcal{q}^{\nu\ast}_{t+1}{{\,|\,}}\nu\in\operatorname{succ}\mu\}\cap\mathcal{k}^{\mu\ast}_t.\ ] ] since @xmath352 by , it follows that @xmath353 , which concludes the inductive step . we show first that for any @xmath354 there exists @xmath122 such that @xmath355 .
if @xmath354 , then for each @xmath12 we have @xmath356 , i.e. there exists a liquidation strategy @xmath357 starting from @xmath358 at time @xmath25 .
we also put @xmath359 for notational convenience .
moreover , for each @xmath6 we have @xmath360 , i.e. there exists a liquidation strategy @xmath361 starting from @xmath362 at time @xmath25 . for each @xmath71 define @xmath363 where @xmath364 is defined by ( [ eq:2013 - 07 - 13-chi - star ] ) .
the process @xmath95 belongs to @xmath44 and satisfies the non - anticipation condition ( [ eq : non - anticipate ] ) .
moreover , for each @xmath6 @xmath365 because @xmath366 and @xmath35 is a convex cone .
hence @xmath164 satisfies ( [ eq : seller - self - fin - superhedge ] ) in addition to ( [ eq : non - anticipate ] ) , and so @xmath122 .
conversely , fix any @xmath122 and put @xmath367 , where @xmath368 is defined by ( [ eq:20130812-chi - tau ] ) .
then for all @xmath369 we have @xmath370 and @xmath371 fix any @xmath6
. then @xmath372 for each @xmath373 , and the non - anticipation property ( [ eq : non - anticipate ] ) of @xmath164 gives @xmath374 .
since @xmath375 , it means that @xmath376 moreover , for each @xmath342 we have @xmath377 , and so @xmath378 we verify by backward induction that @xmath379 for each @xmath380 . clearly , @xmath381 .
now suppose that @xmath379 for some @xmath342 . from ( [ eq:2012 - 12 - 29_1 ] )
we can see that @xmath382 .
because @xmath383 is predictable , we have @xmath384 by ( [ eq : qt - recursive ] ) , completing the backward induction argument . in particular
, this means that @xmath385 . together with ( [ eq:2012 - 12 - 29_2 ] ) it gives @xmath386 for any @xmath6 . as a result
, we have constructed @xmath354 such that @xmath387 .
suppose that @xmath388 .
we construct a sequence @xmath38 of random variables by induction .
first take @xmath389 .
now suppose that we have already constructed @xmath390 such that @xmath391 for some @xmath12 . from
we obtain @xmath392 , whence @xmath393 by .
we also obtain @xmath394 , and by ( [ eq : seller : mathcal - vt ] ) there exists a random variable @xmath395 such that @xmath356 . from
we have @xmath396 , which concludes the inductive step .
finally , we put @xmath397 .
it follows that @xmath354 with @xmath389 . by proposition [ prop :
am : seller : immediate - ultimate ] , a strategy @xmath122 can be constructed such that @xmath398 .
suppose now that @xmath122 .
by proposition [ prop : am : seller : immediate - ultimate ] , there is a @xmath354 such that @xmath355 .
clearly , @xmath399 for all @xmath6 , and in particular @xmath400 .
we now show by backward induction that @xmath390 for all @xmath6 .
suppose that @xmath401 for some @xmath12 .
since @xmath340 , this means by that @xmath395 .
the condition @xmath356 implies that @xmath402 .
property then gives @xmath390 by , which completes the inductive step .
we conclude that @xmath403 .
we have proved ( [ eq:20130727-zad0 ] ) .
it follows that @xmath404 we know that @xmath162 is polyhedral , hence closed , so @xmath405 is also a closed set .
it is non - empty and bounded below because @xmath406 for any @xmath407 large enough , and @xmath408 for any @xmath407 small enough . as a result
, the infimum is attained .
it means , in particular , that @xmath409 , so we know that a strategy @xmath122 can be constructed such that @xmath410 . 1 . [ item : prop : seller : dual:0 ] for each @xmath6 the set @xmath145 is compactly @xmath64-generated .
item : prop : seller : dual:1 ] for all @xmath6 and @xmath28 we have @xmath411 3 . [
item : prop : seller : dual:2 ] we have @xmath412 for all @xmath6 . for all @xmath12 and @xmath10 we have @xmath413 and for each @xmath414 there exist @xmath415 $ ] , @xmath416 and @xmath417 such that @xmath418 4 .
[ item : prop : seller : dual:3]for every @xmath12 and @xmath10 we have @xmath419 and for each @xmath420 there exist @xmath421 $ ] and @xmath422 for all @xmath423 such that @xmath424 we first consider claim . as @xmath130 is a cone ,
@xmath425 note in particular that @xmath426 . for all
@xmath25 and @xmath28 we have @xcite @xmath427 which leads to .
equation follows similarly from @xmath428 now fix any @xmath12 and @xmath10 , and suppose that @xmath431 and that this set is compactly @xmath64-generated . since @xmath432 lemma [ lem : roux_zastawniak2011 ] can be applied to the sets @xmath433 for all @xmath423 .
this justifies claim for this @xmath25 and also that @xmath434 is compactly @xmath64-generated . by theorem [
th:2012 - 10 - 03:ftap ] and proposition [ prop : mart - ito - q ] , the lack of arbitrage opportunities implies that there is a pair @xmath60 such that @xmath435 and @xmath436 for each @xmath423 .
since @xmath143 is a martingale under @xmath50 , it follows that @xmath437 and so @xmath438 .
as @xmath439 and @xmath440 are compactly @xmath64-generated , it follows from lemma [ lem:2012 - 10 - 03:sigmai - intersect ] and that @xmath441 is compactly @xmath64-generated , which justifies claim for this value of @xmath25 . in view of and
, lemma [ lem:2012 - 10 - 03:sigmai - intersect ] consequently shows that @xmath442 is also compactly @xmath64-generated .
we may apply lemma [ lem : roux_zastawniak2011 ] to the sets @xmath443 and @xmath444 since @xmath445 claim for this value of @xmath25 follows upon observing that @xmath446 this concludes the inductive step . by proposition [ prop :
seller : dual ] , @xmath447 is compactly @xmath64-generated . since @xmath448 is polyhedral ,
it is continuous on its effective domain and therefore attains a maximum on the non - empty compact set @xmath449 . from theorem [ prop : seller
: zau0=initial - endowments ] it follows ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 13.1 ) that@xmath450 the following construction produces adapted processes @xmath451 , @xmath452 , @xmath453 and @xmath454 for @xmath6 , and @xmath455 for @xmath456 .
we already know that the maximum of @xmath448 over the set @xmath183 is attained , i.e. there exists some @xmath457 such that @xmath458 for any @xmath12 , suppose that @xmath459 is given , and fix any @xmath10 .
then by proposition [ prop : seller : dual ] , there exist @xmath460 $ ] , @xmath461 and @xmath462 such that @xmath463 by and proposition [ prop : seller : dual ] , there exist @xmath464 $ ] and @xmath465 for all @xmath423 such that @xmath466 this completes the inductive step .
also define for all @xmath156 @xmath467 then , are also satisfied when @xmath468 .
the mixed stopping time @xmath100 is defined by setting @xmath474 and @xmath475 it is straightforward to show by induction that @xmath476 for all @xmath25 .
moreover , since @xmath477 , we have @xmath331 observe also that @xmath478 for all @xmath6 , where @xmath364 is defined by ( [ eq:2013 - 07 - 13-chi - star ] ) .
it then follows from , and that for all @xmath6 @xmath479 we now show by backward induction that for all @xmath6 @xmath480 at time @xmath123 the result is trivial because @xmath481 .
suppose now that ( [ eq : seller : dual - opt:5 ] ) holds for some @xmath456 .
then , by the tower property of conditional expectation , @xmath482 and , by , the predictability of @xmath364 , and , @xmath483 this concludes the inductive step
. we also show by backward induction that for all @xmath6 @xmath484 at time @xmath123 @xmath485 suppose now that ( [ eq : seller : dual - opt:10 ] ) holds for some @xmath456 . then by , and the tower property of conditional expectation , we have @xmath486 this concludes the inductive step . by proposition [ prop:20130727:pi - ag - dual ] , a stopping time @xmath195 and a pair @xmath196
can be constructed such that @xmath491 to establish the reverse inequality we prove by backward induction that for any @xmath354 , @xmath71 and @xmath492 @xmath493 when @xmath468 , @xmath494 since @xmath495 and @xmath496 .
now fix any @xmath12 , and suppose that @xmath497 then , by the tower property of conditional expectation , and since @xmath356 and @xmath498 , it follows that @xmath499 which proves ( [ eq : reverse - ineq - dual repr - seller ] ) . the construction in the proof of theorem [
prop : seller : zau0=initial - endowments ] with initial portfolio @xmath500 yields a strategy @xmath501 . for any @xmath71 and @xmath502 we have @xmath503 , and therefore ( [ eq : reverse - ineq - dual repr - seller ] ) with @xmath504 yields @xmath505 it follows that @xmath506 the set @xmath510 is clearly polyhedral with recession cone @xmath511 . for @xmath12
we proceed by induction .
suppose that @xmath512 is polyhedral and its recession cone is @xmath513 .
then @xmath514 is polyhedral and its recession cone is @xmath515 ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 8.3.3 ) .
being polyhedral , @xmath205 is the convex hull of a finite set of points and directions , and its recession cone @xmath515 is the convex hull of the origin and the directions in @xmath205 .
the set @xmath516 is polyhedral ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 19.3.2 ) and hence it is the convex hull of a finite set of points and directions .
since the cone @xmath130 can be written as the convex hull of the origin and a finite number of directions , it is possible to write @xmath204 as the convex hull of a finite set of points , all in @xmath205 , and a finite set of directions .
these directions are exactly the directions in @xmath205 and @xmath130 , i.e. the directions in @xmath515 and @xmath130 .
thus the recession cone of @xmath204 is @xmath517 since @xmath518 by ( [ eq : qt - recursive ] ) .
this means that the set @xmath519 is closed and its recession cone is @xmath130 ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 9.8.1 ) .
moreover , since @xmath204 and @xmath203 are polyhedral , it follows that @xmath520 is polyhedral ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 19.6 ) , which means that @xmath521 is polyhedral , concluding the inductive step .
the proof is by backward induction .
since @xmath523 , from we have @xmath524 it immediately follows that @xmath525 on the set @xmath526 .
on the set @xmath527 we have @xmath528 because @xmath511 is a cone , and therefore @xmath529 * on the set @xmath535 we have @xmath536 and therefore @xmath537 so that @xmath538 since @xmath539 it follows that @xmath540 on @xmath535 . * on the set @xmath541 we have @xmath542 because @xmath543 by .
there are two further possibilities . * * on @xmath544 we have @xmath545 and therefore @xmath546 * * on @xmath547 we have @xmath548 and therefore @xmath549 as claimed . in view of proposition
[ prop:2012 - 07 - 26:hedging - construct - converse ] , to verify ( [ eq:2012 - 07 - 26:constr - equivalence ] ) it is sufficient to show that for every @xmath550 there exists a pair @xmath217 such that @xmath551 . to this end , define @xmath552 and @xmath553 .
suppose by induction that for some @xmath12 we have constructed predictable sequences @xmath554 and @xmath555 such that @xmath556 and @xmath557 because of , there exists an @xmath558-measurable random variable @xmath559 such that @xmath560 and @xmath561 equations and then give @xmath562 where @xmath563 follows from the fact that @xmath564 is a convex cone .
this means there exists a random variable @xmath565 such that @xmath566 put @xmath567 .
then @xmath568 , which concludes the inductive step .
now define the mixed stopping time @xmath569 by @xmath570 we also put @xmath571 .
we have constructed @xmath572 and @xmath71 such that @xmath573 and@xmath574 finally , we construct @xmath45 such that @xmath217 and @xmath551 . by the definition of the deferred solvency cones
@xmath564 , for each @xmath6 there is a liquidation strategy @xmath575 starting from @xmath576 at time @xmath25 .
we put@xmath577 which means that@xmath578 for each @xmath6 , with @xmath579 , completing the proof of ( [ eq:2012 - 07 - 26:constr - equivalence ] ) . next , if follows from ( [ eq:2012 - 07 - 26:constr - equivalence ] ) that @xmath580 by proposition [ prop:2012 - 09 - 19:zt - closed ] , @xmath215 is polyhedral , hence closed . as a result
, the set @xmath581 is also closed .
it is non - empty and bounded above because @xmath582 for any @xmath407 large enough , and @xmath583 for any @xmath407 small enough .
this means that the supremum is attained .
it follows that @xmath584 , so we know that a strategy @xmath212 can be constructed such that @xmath585 .
theorem [ prop:2012 - 07 - 26:hedging - construct ] gives @xmath596 the maximum is attained , so @xmath597 .
the strategy @xmath598 constructed by the method in the proof of theorem [ prop:2012 - 07 - 26:hedging - construct ] from the initial portfolio @xmath599 therefore realises the supremum in ( [ eq : buyer - bid - price - gradual ] ) .
we write this supremum as a maximum , @xmath600,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and apply proposition [ prop : am - eur ] , which gives @xmath601\\ & = \max_{\chi\in\mathcal{x } } \left[-p^\mathrm{a}_{j}(-\xi_\chi)\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath602 is the ask ( seller s ) price in currency @xmath22 of a european option with expiry time @xmath123 and payoff @xmath603 as defined in appendix [ sect : eur - opt ] .
we can now apply lemma [ lem : eur - ask - price - dual - repr ] to write @xmath604 for any @xmath605 , since @xmath143 is a martingale under @xmath50 , we have @xmath606 this means that @xmath607 proving ( [ eq : pi - bu ] ) .
we know that @xmath608 realises the supremum in ( [ eq : buyer - bid - price - gradual ] ) , and therefore the above maxima over @xmath71 are attained at @xmath609 .
a pair @xmath610 such that @xmath611 can be constructed by the method of ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 5.3 ) for the european option with payoff @xmath612 , completing the proof .
we recall a result for european options in the market model with @xmath17 assets under transaction costs .
this is needed in the proof of the dual representation for the bid price of an american option .
a european option obliges the seller ( writer ) to deliver a portfolio @xmath613 at time @xmath123 .
the set of strategies superhedging the seller s position is given as@xmath614 and the _ ask price _ ( _ seller s price _ ) of such an option in currency @xmath98 is@xmath615 the following result can be found in ( * ? ? ?
* section 4.3.1 ) .
[ lem : eur - ask - price - dual - repr ] the ask price in currency @xmath98 of a european option @xmath616 can be represented as@xmath617 moreover , a pair @xmath235 such that @xmath618 can be constructed algorithmically .
roux , a. zastawniak , t. 2009 , american options under proportional transaction costs : pricing , hedging and stopping algorithms for long and short positions , _ acta applicandae mathematicae _ * 106 * , 199228 .
|
american options in a multi - asset market model with proportional transaction costs are studied in the case when the holder of an option is able to exercise it gradually at a so - called mixed ( randomised ) stopping time . the introduction of gradual exercise leads to tighter bounds on the option price when compared to the case studied in the existing literature , where the standard assumption is that the option can only be exercised instantly at an ordinary stopping time .
algorithmic constructions for the bid and ask prices and the associated superhedging strategies and optimal mixed stoping times for an american option with gradual exercise are developed and implemented , and dual representations are established .
|
wimps captured by the gravitational field of the sun that are slowed through collisions with solar matter can accumulate in the solar core . there
, wimp annihilation may produce neutrinos with much larger energy than solar neutrinos .
the signal would be an excess of high - energy ( @xmath1gev ) neutrino events pointing back to the sun @xcite .
the cleanest signature at no@xmath0a will be from @xmath2 cc events producing upward - going muons that can be reconstructed in the no@xmath0a detector .
the large and unique no@xmath0a far detector , with its excellent granularity and energy resolution , and relatively low - energy neutrino thresholds , is an ideal tool for these indirect dark matter searches . at no@xmath0a , the neutrino analyses simply store events synchronous with the numi beam . for non - beam exotic physics searches , so - called data - driven triggers @xcite are required to select events of interest . only the upward - going flux will be considered in order to suppress the cosmic - ray background .
the downward - going muon rate in the no@xmath0a far detector is approximately 100,000 hz .
we expect to keep the upward - going muon trigger rate to about 10 hz or less , so a rejection of at least four orders of magnitude is required by the trigger .
of course , this rejection must be accomplished while keeping the acceptance for upward - going muons relatively high .
the neutrino flux from dark matter annihilation is model dependent ; however , energies from @xmath30.5gev to many tev should be detected with high acceptance . for high - mass signal hypothesis
, no@xmath0a will not be able to compete with the high acceptance of the icecube detector @xcite .
for lower - mass scenarios ( below @xmath320 gev ) the super - kamiokande experiment currently has the best sensitivity @xcite .
if an efficient upward - going muon trigger and sufficient cosmic ray background rejection can be achieved , no@xmath0a will be competitive with super
kamiokande for wimp mass hypotheses below 20 gev / c@xmath4 .
one advantage that no@xmath0a has compared to past experiments that performed similar searches for dark matter annihilation is the relatively low energy threshold for muons .
a 1 gev muon track travels approximately 5 meters in the no@xmath0a detector resulting in an energy threshold well below 1 gev .
the challenge for the dark matter search is triggering efficiently on these low - energy muons . for shorter track lengths
, the timing information will not be as powerful for rejecting downward - going backgrounds . using stopping or fully - contained events and using the top and sides of the detector to veto downward - going events can provide an additional two orders of magnitude rejection .
in this note we focus on using the timing information from all of the hits on a track to reject the downward - going muon background and efficiently select upward - going events .
a trigger for upward - going muons based on timing information required a minor upgrade to the readout of the no@xmath0a far detector .
this upgrade to the so - called `` multipoint '' readout occurred on september 11 , 2014 , and resulted immediately in a single - hit timing resolution of about 25 ns ( note that the timing resolution with the previous algorithm was about 125 ns , so this is a significant improvement ) . with dozens of hits per track ,
it is possible to reject downward - going muons by many orders of magnitude using hit timing information alone . to resolve the directionality of the muon track , the upward - going muon trigger takes advantage of the timing information from each individual hit in the reconstructed tracks .
the tracks are reconstructed using the hough transform algorithm , and are required to match in both xz and yz views .
we start from the hit with lowest @xmath5 cell value , @xmath6 , in the track in the yz view .
the measured time of the corresponding hit is defined as @xmath7 .
the observed and expected time of each hit on the track in the yz view is therefore : @xmath8 similarly , for the xz view : @xmath9 where @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the cell numbers in xz and yz view , and @xmath12 is the time measurement in tdc units , which is converted to ns using the factor of 15.625 ns / tdc .
@xmath13 is the time - of - flight of the muon track defined as : @xmath14 where @xmath15 is track length in cm , and 29.97cm / ns is the expected speed assuming that the muon is relativistic .
since we require that each track is reconstructed and matched in both views , ( @xmath16 ; @xmath6 ) and ( @xmath17 ; @xmath18 ) must correspond to the lowest and highest points of the track respectively .
in addition , we can estimate the missing coordinate for a particular hit in either view using 3d requirement .
for the yz view , track coordinates can be calculated as such : @xmath19 similarly , for the xz view : @xmath20 where @xmath21 cm and @xmath22 cm are the widths of detector cells and planes . the cell and plane with id=0
have coordinates @xmath23 cm and @xmath24 cm .
since for each hit in each view we can estimate ( x ; y ; z ) coordinates , we can calculate the distance from the hit to the apd readout end .
the further the hit is located from the readout the longer it takes for the light to propagate and be detected by the apd .
we are interested in the hit time of the muon passing through the extrusion , so we have to correct for the light propagation time in the fiber .
the speed of light in the fiber is measured to be 15.3 cm / ns .
the light level in each channel in the no@xmath0a detector is independently sampled every 500 ns . the electronic response to an incident particle depositing energy in a cell can be parameterized in terms of two intrinsic timing values ( @xmath25 and @xmath26 ) , the number of photoelectrons ( @xmath27 ) , and a timing `` offset '' ( @xmath28 ) , or the elapsed time between a read - out and the time of incidence of the particle : @xmath29 here , @xmath30 is a proportionality factor that does not affect the timing fit .
the parameters @xmath25 and @xmath26 correspond to the intrinsic falling and rising time of the response curve , respectively . as such , they are approximately known . for the purpose of determining hit timing ,
the parameter of note is @xmath28 . by performing a simple @xmath31 minimization ,
the data - preferred value of @xmath28 can be extracted from multiple readouts on a single channel . for the purposes of the trigger , where hit processing time must be minimized , fit results were pre - calculated and tabulated such that the computationally expensive minimization need not be repeated for each individual hit .
an example of fitting the electronics response curve to multiple readouts from a single cell hit .
the time coordinate of the inflection point where the curve begins to rise is the fitted parameter @xmath28.,width=192 ] single - hit timing resolution as observed in no@xmath0a far detector data with four - point readout , before ( left ) and after ( right ) fine timing implementation .
see ref .
@xcite for more details.,width=576 ] each time measurement has an uncertainty , which varies with the amount of energy deposited .
the time uncertainty on a given hit from a reconstructed muon track affects the determination of track directionality , so a parameterization of uncertainty in terms of energy deposition is necessary for the timing - based trigger .
single - hit time resolution is plotted against energy deposition in fig .
[ fig : deltat ] . for high energy hits the @xmath32 is measured to be approximately 10 ns in the data using the four - point readout scheme , which is consistent with that observed in simulation @xcite .
we can use equations [ eq : ytimes ] and [ eq : xtimes ] to produce the distribution of the expected v / s observed time for each track .
the expected versus observed time distribution for an upward - going muon track reconstructed in the no@xmath0a far detector , using fine timing .
the linear unconstrained fit ( red solid line ) has slope value close to `` 1 '' .
the fit with the upward - going track hypothesis ( slope = 1 ) is shown as the blue - dashed line .
the fit with the downward - going hypothesis is shown in the green dashed line and has a very poor probability .
, width=384 ] an example of expected v / s observed time distribution is shown in fig .
[ fig : track_example ] .
the distribution is produced using a reconstructed upward - going muon track simulated with wimpsim @xcite . as can be seen ,
the points follow a rising trend with a slope value consistent with the upward - going track hypothesis .
it is clear from the figure that the fitted slope value can be used to estimate the muon direction ( up or down ) . as shown in fig .
[ fig : disc_slope ] , the slope values for cosmics and wimpsim mc samples are consistent with the downward- and upward - going hypothesis , respectively . in the relativistic limit ,
it is safe to assume that there are only two options for the slope values .
therefore , we can fit the time distribution on fig .
[ fig : track_example ] with fixed values of slopes . for the upward - going track
the fit with the slope constrained to `` 1 '' results in a good @xmath31 probability value of the fit , @xmath33 .
however the fit with slope of `` -1 '' yields a low probability value , @xmath34 . using the probability values from the fits with the fixed slope value
, we can form a log - likelihood ratio ( llr ) :
@xmath35 the llr distributions for the cosmic and wimpsim mc samples are shown in fig .
[ fig : disc_llr ] . from this distribution ,
it is clear that a cut on llr slightly above zero will reduce the cosmic background by the desired amount while preserving a high signal acceptance .
note that the wimpsim sample used is for dark matter with a 20 gev mass annihilating through the @xmath36 channel .
as such the neutrinos from the b - meson decay produce muons which , on average , have a much lower energy compared to the cosmic ray muons .
this explains why the llr for the signal has a larger component close to zero than the cosmic sample .
the llr yields better performance for cosmic background rejection for the same signal acceptance in the regime where the cosmic rejection is sufficient ( at least four orders of magnitude ) , compared to a cut on the best - fit slope .
for example , for a signal acceptance of 0.7 the background rejection is about a factor of three better for the llr . at this point
the mc predicts background rejection of close to five orders of magnitude .
in addition to being a more powerful discriminator as observed in the mc studies , the llr estimator is more robust to mis - reconstructed tracks which will be an important feature in real data .
since mis - reconstructions will result in time distributions that follow neither the upward- nor the downward - going hypothesis , the result of mis - reconstruction will yield llr values close to `` 0 '' , and not values consistent with a high - probability for being upward - going .
the slope distributions for cosmics ( red ) and wimpsim ( blue ) mc samples.,width=576 ] the llr distributions for cosmics ( red ) and wimpsim ( blue ) mc samples .
note that only tracks longer then 5 m and with more than 50 hits are included.,width=384 ]
a timing - based upward - going muon trigger was implemented for the no@xmath0a far detector and was deployed in november 2014 .
triggering at @xmath37hz , the algorithm suppresses cosmic ray muons by five orders of magnitude . on
the left is a display of a triggered event that is a strong candidate , based on its topology , for an upward - going muon .
the activity at the bottom right indicates a cc scattering interaction .
the curving at the other end probably indicates that the muon ranged out .
there is also evidence for a michel electron , based on the timing information on the right .
this event confirms that the llr algorithm is successfully selecting upward - going muons in the data.,title="fig:",width=384 ] on the left is a display of a triggered event that is a strong candidate , based on its topology , for an upward - going muon .
the activity at the bottom right indicates a cc scattering interaction .
the curving at the other end probably indicates that the muon ranged out .
there is also evidence for a michel electron , based on the timing information on the right .
this event confirms that the llr algorithm is successfully selecting upward - going muons in the data.,title="fig:",width=192 ] as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : conc_example ] , events with probable michel electrons and contained vertices have been used to confirm upward - going muons in the triggered sample .
atmospheric neutrinos generated on the other side of the earth are also capable of producing upward - going muons in the detector .
these events represent an irreducible background in this search .
the only method of discriminating atmospheric neutrino events from wimp events is to reconstruct the directionality of the incident neutrinos , which has yet to be attempted in no@xmath0a .
the accumulating data sample opens the door to a program to study atmospheric neutrinos and sets the stage for a competitive dark matter search by the no@xmath0a experiment .
this conference presentation was made possible by a grant from the university of virginia college of arts and sciences .
additional financial support was provided by the jefferson trust , the uva physics department , and the fermilab particle physics division .
the authors also acknowledge that support for this research was carried out by the fermilab scientific and technical staff .
fermilab is operated by fermi research alliance , llc under contract no .
de - ac02 - 07ch11359 with the united states department of energy .
the university of virginia particle physics group is supported by de - sc0007838 .
7 j. s. hagelin , k. w. ng and k. a. olive , phys .
b * 180 * , 375 ( 1986 ) .
j. buckley , d. f. cowen , s. profumo , a. archer , m. cahill - rowley , r. cotta , s. digel and a. drlica - wagner _
_ , arxiv:1310.7040
. m. fischler , c. green , j. kowalkowski , a. norman , m. paterno and r. rechenmacher , j. phys .
ser . * 396 * , 012020 ( 2012 ) .
|
the no@xmath0a collaboration has constructed a 14,000 ton , fine - grained , low - z , total absorption tracking calorimeter at an off - axis angle to an upgraded numi neutrino beam .
this detector , with its excellent granularity and energy resolution and relatively low - energy neutrino thresholds , was designed to observe electron neutrino appearance in a muon neutrino beam , but it also has unique capabilities suitable for more exotic efforts .
in fact , if an efficient upward - going muon trigger with sufficient cosmic ray background rejection can be demonstrated , no@xmath0a will be capable of a competitive indirect dark matter search for low - mass wimps .
the cosmic ray muon rate at the no@xmath0a far detector is about 100 khz and provides the primary challenge for triggering and optimizing such a search analysis .
the status of the no@xmath0a upward - going muon trigger is presented .
|
shape memory alloys ( sma ) have attracted a great deal of attention due to their important technological applications , including mechanical actuator devices and medical stents .
the shape memory effect also gives rise to superelasticity , which finds applications in stents and spectacle frames .
the shape memory effect is related to a reversible martensitic ( diffusionless ) phase transformation .
it has been shown that the martensitic transformation can be induced by applied fields , temperature or both , and the mechanical properties of materials , therefore , can be controlled accordingly . in many systems , including those discussed in the present work , alloying can dramatically change the properties and transition temperatures of the materials , reflecting the importance of electronic features , specifically fermi surface effects , in the structural energetics of sma .
there are several complementary approaches to modelling of the shape memory effect .
continuum modelling allows investigation of the microstructural behavior , specifically martensitic twins , at the relevant long length scales .
material - specific behavior is incorporated through an empirical functional for the free energy in terms of strain and a twin boundary energy to set the length scale . in atomistic models ,
the individual atoms are considered explicitly and their interaction given by an interatomic potential , which may be determined empirically , from first - principles density - functional - theory ( dft ) calculations , or a combination of the two .
crystal symmetry and defect energies emerge from this approach , which gives microstructures with both natural length scales ( from defect energies ) and time scales ( since the atoms have definite newtonian forces and masses ) .
however , in atomistic models , the electronic degrees of freedom do not appear explicitly .
first principles dft methods are so computationally intensive that direct studies of microstructural behavior are impossible , but they are valuable both for obtaining quantitative atomic - level information regarding energies , forces and stresses independent of empirical input , and for understanding the electronic origin of this behavior .
thus , first - principles investigation of the energetic instability of the high - temperature structure towards the low - symmetry martensitic structure is in itself quite illuminating .
the resulting information can then also be used as inputs to atomistic@xcite and continuum modelling of shape memory behavior .
typically , martensitic transformations are described using the strain as an order parameter , the classic example being the bain bcc - fcc transformation of iron .
however , there is an alternative approach appropriate for cases where the strain degrees of freedom are coupled to atomic degrees of freedom ( phonons ) . following the soft - mode theory of structural transitions,@xcite we start from a high - symmetry reference structure ( here @xmath2 ) and freeze in unstable phonons of this structure , with corresponding lattice relaxation , to produce the ground - state structure .
the symmetry of the phonons determines the symmetry of the low temperature structure .
this approach has been successfully used in the study of minerals@xcite and ferroelectric materials @xcite and has been extended to shape memory alloys in our previous study of niti@xcite .
closely related to niti , pdti and ptti are shape memory materials with reasonable structural simplicity and extraordinary mechanical behavior .
they undergo a martensitic transformation at tunable temperatures : pdti transforms at 810k , but this can be reduced to 410k with 8% substitution of cr for pd@xcite .
the high - temperature `` austenitic '' phase has a simple cubic @xmath2 structure ( space group @xmath3 ) , while the ambient temperature `` martensitic '' phase has been reported as the orthorhombic @xmath0 structure@xcite ( space group : @xmath4 ) .
previous first - principles studies in pdti and ptti@xcite have shown that the observed electronic and elastic properties of the @xmath0 structure are well reproduced by density - functional theory calculations assuming the experimentally determined structure . in this paper , we investigate the structural energetics of pdti and ptti from first - principles calculations of phonon frequencies as well as total energies .
this allows us to examine local as well as global stability and to investigate transition mechanisms , drawing on the strong analogy between the @xmath2-@xmath0 and bcc - hcp transformations and showing that coupling of unstable modes to the strain is a crucial aspect of the structural energetics . in sec .
ii , we describe the first - principles calculations . in sec .
iii , we present and discuss the results for the phonon dispersion of pdti and ptti in the @xmath2 structure and for the relaxed structures in which unstable modes and strains are coupled , yielding a low - symmetry ground state .
in addition , we present results of calculations of the electronic structure , identifying and discussing features that affect the relative stability of the phases .
v concludes the paper .
first - principles total energy calculations were carried out within density - functional theory with a plane - wave pseudopotential approach .
the calculations were performed with the vienna _ ab - initio _
simulations package@xcite , using the perdew - zunger@xcite parametrization of the local - density approximation ( lda ) .
vanderbilt ultrasoft pseudopotentials @xcite were used .
our pseudopotentials include nonlinear core corrections and for ti , we treated the occupied @xmath5 levels as valence .
the electronic wave functions were represented in a plane - wave basis set with a kinetic energy cutoff of 278ev .
the brillouin zone ( bz ) integrations were carried out by the hermite - gaussian smearing technique @xcite with the smearing parameter of 0.1ev .
the unit cells contain two atoms in the cubic @xmath2 structure and four atoms in the orthorhombic @xmath0 and monoclinic @xmath1 structures .
the calculations were performed with a @xmath6 monkhorst - pack ( mp ) @xmath7point mesh for the cubic @xmath2 structure and a @xmath8 mp @xmath7point mesh for both orthorhombic @xmath0 and monoclinic @xmath1 structures ( space group : @xmath9 ) , corresponding to 120 @xmath10 points in the @xmath11 irreducible bz of the simple cubic cell , 288 @xmath10 points in the @xmath12 irreducible bz of the orthorhombic cell and 576 @xmath10 points in the @xmath13 irreducible bz of the monoclinic cell .
this choice of parameters converges the total energy to within 1 mev / atom .
the density of states ( dos ) for the @xmath0 and @xmath1 structures were calculated using the tetrahedron method with blchl corrections@xcite .
the bz s for the orthorhombic @xmath0 and monoclinic @xmath1 structures are different . to compare the band structure of the two structures , we label the @xmath0 band structure by regarding the @xmath0 structure as a special case of @xmath1 .
the phonon dispersion relations were obtained with the pwscf and phonon codes @xcite , using the perdew - zunger@xcite parametrization of the lda , as above .
ultrasoft pseudopotentials @xcite for pd , pt and ti were generated according to a modified rappe - rabe - kaxiras - joannopoulos ( rrkj ) scheme @xcite with three bessel functions @xcite .
the electronic wave functions were represented in a plane - wave basis set with a kinetic energy cutoff of 408ev .
the augmentation charges were expanded up to 9000ev . the brillouin zone ( bz )
integrations were carried out by the hermite - gaussian smearing technique @xcite using a 56 _ k_-point mesh ( corresponding to @xmath14 regular divisions along the @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 axes ) in the @xmath11 irreducible wedge .
the value of the smearing parameter was @xmath18=0.2ev .
these parameters yield phonon frequencies converged within 5 @xmath19 .
the dynamical matrix was computed on a @xmath20 _ q_-point mesh commensurate with the _ k_-point mesh .
the complete phonon dispersion relation was obtained through the computation of real - space interatomic force constants within the corresponding box@xcite .
the choice to use two different first - principles codes was dictated by the individual strengths of each .
vasp has a highly efficient scheme for calculating total energies , forces , and stresses , and relaxing to the minimum energy structure , but does not have the density - functional perturbation theory capabilities of pwscf / phonon .
even with slightly different pseudopotentials and _ k_-point sampling , the results of the two codes are quite compatible .
for example , the difference between the computed lattice parameters for the @xmath2 structure of pdti is less than 0.2% , and for ptti the difference is less than 0.1% .
comparisons of normalized eigenvector components computed by vasp using the frozen phonon method and by pwscf / phonon also show good agreement , generally within 5% .
for the cubic @xmath2 structure , our calculations yield the equilibrium lattice parameters of 3.112 and 3.125 for pdti and ptti respectively . for comparison
, we also performed full - potential linearized - augmented - plane - wave calculations ( flapw ) within the lda@xcite .
the results are in excellent agreement with flapw results of 3.113 ( pdti ) and 3.127 ( ptti ) and in in good agreement with experimental values of 3.18 and 3.17 .
the phonon dispersion relations along high symmetry lines , computed at the theoretical lattice parameters , are shown in figure [ phonons ] .
the frequencies are obtained by taking the square root of the eigenvalues of the dynamical matrix@xcite .
imaginary frequencies , as plotted as negative , are obtained from negative eigenvalues of the dynamical matrix .
thus , the structure is dynamically unstable against distortions following the corresponding eigenvector .
it should be noted that the phonon frequency @xmath21 is _ not _ the reciprocal of the period of oscillation of this mode ( as measured in molecular dynamics ) nor is it the energy difference between adjacent quantum levels ( as measured in neutron scattering experiments ) .
these three quantities are equal only for a stable harmonic crystal . in the materials studied here the unstable modes may be related to a soft mode@xcite ( as defined by md or neutron scattering ) at high temperature , and even the stable modes are expected to be significantly renormalized as a function of temperature by anharmonic effects .
phonon dispersion relations for pdti ( upper ) and ptti ( lower ) in the @xmath2 structure calculated at the lda equilibrium parameters 3.112 and 3.125 respectively .
the negative slope of the acoustic @xmath22 branch corresponds to a pure elastic instability ( @xmath23 ) .
symmetry labels are assigned according to the conventions of ref . with pd / pt at the origin .
the imaginary frequencies of the unstable modes are plotted as negative values.,title="fig : " ] + phonon dispersion relations for pdti ( upper ) and ptti ( lower ) in the @xmath2 structure calculated at the lda equilibrium parameters 3.112 and 3.125 respectively .
the negative slope of the acoustic @xmath22 branch corresponds to a pure elastic instability ( @xmath23 ) .
symmetry labels are assigned according to the conventions of ref . with pd / pt at the origin .
the imaginary frequencies of the unstable modes are plotted as negative values.,title="fig : " ] the dynamical matrices are related by mass factors to the force constant matrix : the second derivatives of the internal energy with respect to atomic displacements .
the eigenmodes of the force constant matrix describe the potential energy landscape , and a negative eigenvalue indicates a static instability against a distortion following the corresponding eigenvector .
while the actual normalized displacements of these eigenmodes are in general slightly different they carry the same symmetry labels as the eigenmodes of the dynamical matrix .
either choice is expected to serve as a useful pointer to a lower energy structure if the distorted structure obtained by freezing in " an unstable mode is relaxed using first - principles forces and stresses , as we describe below .
the phonon dispersion relations shown in figure [ phonons ] show instability of the @xmath2 structure similar to and even stronger than that of niti@xcite .
there are large regions of reciprocal space where one , two or even three modes are unstable , with dominant instabilities at @xmath24 and along @xmath25-@xmath26 .
the phonon instability shows that the observed high - temperature @xmath2 phases of pdti and ptti are dynamically stabilized by anharmonic phonons , and should be characterized by large fluctuating local distortions .
the calculated phonon dispersions are also reminiscent of those of unstable bcc materials such as zr and ti , which undergo martensitic transformations to hcp or @xmath21@xcite ( via the @xmath24 and @xmath25-@xmath26 bcc - phonon equivalents respectively ) phases .
the analogy based on the view of @xmath0 phases of pdti and ptti as chemically ordered hcp will be further strengthened below . in the soft mode approach , we search for local energy minima by choosing an unstable mode of the high symmetry structure , freezing in the distortion with varying amplitude , and relaxing the resulting structure .
in many cases , the mode with the largest negative eigenvalue will generate the lowest energy structure . however , this is by no means generally true , as the energy gain is determined not only by the curvature of the energy surface but by higher order terms as well as the strength of coupling to strain and other modes , both unstable and stable , of appropriate symmetry .
indeed , in pdti this `` most unstable '' mode ( i.e. largest negative eigenvalue ) lies in the @xmath25-@xmath26 branch rather than at @xmath24 .
this mode is typically unstable in dynamically - stabilized bcc materials such as titanium and zirconium where it is associated with a phase transition to the ideal @xmath21 ( @xmath27 ) phase .
the fact that in the chemically ordered analog ( pd / pt)ti , the observed phase transition is to @xmath0 rather than @xmath27 illustrates the importance of anharmonic effects and strain coupling in the energetics of these materials .
eigenmode of the doubly - degenerate @xmath28 unstable phonon in the @xmath2 structure .
this mode generates the @xmath0 structure in pdti and ptti .
the structure is shown projected along the @xmath29 direction , with pd / pt represented by filled circles and ti by open circles . ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in the soft - mode approach , there is no guarantee that the energy - minimizing freezing - in of one unstable mode will stablize the other unstable modes of the high - symmetry structure . in the present case ,
the undistorted doubled unit cell contains two sets of ( 110)@xmath30 planes each of which is unstable to strain - coupled shuffling at all _ q-_points .
the simplest such mode in the @xmath0 structure is @xmath31 , which lowers the symmetry to monoclinic @xmath32 .
the resulting @xmath1 structure has three additional free parameters : the monoclinic angle @xmath33 and two internal parameters @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
these values are given for the relaxed @xmath1 structure in table [ table : struct ] , and compared with the normalized eigenvector displacements in table [ table : ratio ] .
however , it is important to note that the computed @xmath25 phonon modes in the @xmath0 structures are in fact all stable ( table [ table : phonon - gamma ] ) .
the lowering of energy by distortion to @xmath1 can not be obtained by a pure @xmath31 phonon distortion , but only if the strain is allowed to relax simulataneously ( table [ table : struct ] )
. this may be the reason that in a previous calculation @xcite , @xmath0 was reported to be the minimum energy structure .
the relative energies of the various relaxed structures are given in table [ table : struct ] .
the @xmath0 total energy is lower than @xmath2 . a simple estimate of the transition temperature is given by @xmath36 which suggest @xmath37 of 1050k ( pdti ) and 1755k ( ptti ) .
these rough values are significantly larger than the experimental data for the hysteretical transition region@xcite ( approximately 800k and 1400k respectively ) , but show the correct material trend . for neither system
has a @xmath1 phase yet been observed experimentally .
the small computed energy differences between @xmath1 and @xmath1 , translated into temperature , are 28k and 39k for pdti and ptti , respectively .
this suggests that the transition to the @xmath1 phase should occur at temperatures well below those at which the experiments were performed , so that our results are fully consistent with the available experimental work .
+ + the binary - hcp phase interpretation also suggests that we should examine the binary - fcc equivalent , which is the @xmath38 phase .
@xmath38 is accessible from @xmath2 by a simple ( 001 ) shear and has lower energy@xcite , however we find that @xmath38 has slightly higher energy than @xmath0 .
we consider one further structure : at the special @xmath1 values @xmath39 and @xmath40 , orthorhombic symmetry is restored .
the side of the conventional cell of this body centered orthorhombic ( bco ) ( space group @xmath41 ) structure is doubled in the * b * direction , though the primitive cell still contains four atoms .
although at relatively high energy ( [ table : struct ] ) , this provides us a reference point for structures with large @xmath33@xcite .
note that a further shear to @xmath42 would give the @xmath0 structure once more .
the potential energies of continuous paths between the structures identified above are important for understanding the transformation mechanism .
we compute the energies of three paths : @xmath2-@xmath0 , @xmath0-@xmath1 and @xmath1-bco . in keeping with the timescale separation between bulk strain and atomic motion ,
we define intermediate configurations by relaxing the atoms to their minimum energy configuration consistent with the applied symmetry and strain on the cell .
the remaining four strain degrees of freedom are reduced to a single parameter by taking interpolations between the strains of the endpoint structures . for the @xmath2 structure ,
we minimize the energy assuming the @xmath0 space group , which gives a smooth evolution of the structure along the path .
> from figure [ tote ] , it is clear that there is no total energy barrier along the @xmath2-@xmath0-@xmath1 path , and that @xmath0 represents the total energy barrier between @xmath1 martensitic variants .
the @xmath0 phase can be viewed as the binary equivalent of hcp , and the transformation path as the binary equivalent of the nishiyama - wassermann ( nw ) path . using the analogy with the nw mechanism for the bcc - hcp transition
, we can attribute the transition to a shuffling of ( 110)@xmath30 planes@xcite .
structural instabilities in metals are typically related to details of the fermi surface , and we have calculated the band structures of @xmath2 , @xmath0 and @xmath1 to investigate this .
in pdti / ptti the band structure is dominated by the _ d_-bands , with the pd / pt bands lying below the fermi level and almost fully occupied , and the ti @xmath43-bands lying above the fermi level ( figure [ bands - pdti ] and [ bands - ptti ] ) , the band centers being offset by some 6ev . the free - electron like @xmath44 bands are very broad , and play little role in the bonding except to donate some electrons to the ti - d band .
the large strain involved in the @xmath45 transition means that the fermi surfaces are quite different ( @xmath0 having the lowest dos at @xmath46@xcite ) and this transition can not be related directly to the band structure . by contrast , the @xmath0-@xmath1 transition is accompanied by the opening of a pseudogap at the fermi level , a typical signature of increased stability .
the band structures are very similar , the small difference which stabilises @xmath1 being traceable to the shifting above the fermi level of a pocket of electrons around @xmath47 .
the distortion to @xmath1 is just enough to complete the topological phase transition which eliminates this pocket of electrons in both materials .
in conclusion , we have performed _ ab initio _ calculations of the structural energetics of pdti and ptti . in each case
we predict that the low temperature ground state structure will be @xmath1 , with the ( observed ) @xmath2 and @xmath0 phases being dynamically stabilized .
there are no total energy barriers between the structures , meaning that the phase space microstates that belong to the @xmath1 structure _ also _ belong to the @xmath0 and @xmath2 structures .
in contrast to niti@xcite , the entire @xmath22 phonon branch is unstable .
we showed that the @xmath0 structure can be obtained by a `` freezing in '' of phonons of the @xmath2 structure coupled to the shear associated with the @xmath48 elastic constant , but that no single dynamical - matrix or force - constant - matrix eigenvector leads to the low - symmetry phase .
the @xmath1 then corresponds to a further strain coupled to a @xmath31 phonon of the @xmath0 phase .
tracing the atomic motions of these instabilities shows that they are both related to shears of alternate @xmath49 phases , and hence that the transition mechanism is the binary equivalent of the nishiyama - wassermann bcc - hcp mechanism .
we thank r. d. james , i. i. naumov , and k. bhattacharya for valuable discussions .
this work was supported by afosr / muri f49620 - 98 - 1 - 0433 .
the calculations were performed on the sgi origin 3000 and ibm sp3 at arl msrc .
p. blaha , k. schwarz , and j. luitz , wien97 , vienna university of technology , vienna 1997 .
( improved and updated unix version of the original copyrighted wien - code , published by p. blaha , k. schwarz , p. sorantin , and s. b. trickey , in comput .
phys . commun . * 59 , * 399 1990 ) .
our flapw calculations were performed using a 120 _ k_-point mesh in the @xmath11 irreducible wedge .
no shape approximations were made to the density or potential .
the muffin - tin radii for pd / pt and ti were chosen to be 1.343and 1.278 , repectively .
a @xmath50 of 10 were used .
the tetrahedron method was used in the brillouin zone integrations .
|
the structural energetics of pdti and ptti have been studied using first - principles density - functional theory with pseudopotentials and a plane - wave basis .
we predict that in both materials , the experimentally reported orthorhombic @xmath0 phase will undergo a low - temperature phase transition to a monoclinic @xmath1 ground state . within a soft - mode framework
, we relate the @xmath0 structure to the cubic @xmath2 structure , observed at high temperature , and the @xmath1 structure to @xmath0 via phonon modes strongly coupled to strain .
in contrast to niti , the @xmath0 structure is extremely close to hcp .
we draw on the analogy to the bcc - hcp transition to suggest likely transition mechanisms in the present case .
|
consider a network which evolves under the removal and addition of vertices . in each unit of time
we add @xmath1 vertex and remove @xmath2 vertices .
removal of a vertex also implies that all the edges incident on that vertex vanish and consequently the degree of vertices at the end of those edges decrease . here
@xmath2 can be interpreted as the ratio of vertices removed to those added , so @xmath3 represents a growing network , @xmath4 a shrinking one , while @xmath5 implies vertex turnover but fixed network size .
the equations to follow represent the completely general case .
however , for the purposes of this paper we will specialize to networks of constant size as we assume that the network already exists and we would like to preserve its original structure , by balancing the rate of attack against the rate of repair .
let @xmath6 be the fraction of nodes in the network that at a given time have degree @xmath7 . by definition
then it has the normalization : @xmath8 in addition to this we would like to have freedom over the degree of the incoming vertex .
let @xmath9 be the probability distribution governing this , with the constraint @xmath10 .
we also have to consider how a newly arriving vertex chooses to attach to other vertices extant in the network and how a vertex is removed from the same .
let @xmath11 be the probability that a given edge from a new node is connected to a node of degree @xmath7 , multiplied by the total number of nodes @xmath0 .
then @xmath12 is the probability that an edge from a new node is connected to some node of degree @xmath7 .
similarly , let @xmath13 be the probability that a given node with degree @xmath7 fails or is attacked during one node removal also multiplied by @xmath0 .
then @xmath14 is the total probability to remove a node with degree @xmath7 during one node removal .
note that the introduction of the deletion kernel @xmath13 is what sets our model apart from previous models describing the network evolution process .
since each newly attached edge goes to some vertex with degree @xmath7 , we have the following normalization conditions : @xmath15 armed with the given definitions and building on the work done previously by @xcite , we are now in a position to write down a rate equation governing the evolution of the degree distribution . for a network of @xmath0 nodes at a given unit of time ,
the total number of nodes with degree @xmath7 is @xmath16 .
after one unit of time we add one vertex and take away @xmath2 vertices , so the number is @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is the new value of @xmath6 .
therefore we have , @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the conditional probability of following an edge from a node of degree @xmath21 and reaching a node of degree @xmath7 .
alternatively , it is the degree distribution of nodes at the end of an edge emanating from a node of degree @xmath21 .
note that @xmath22 and @xmath23 are always zero , and for an uncorrelated network , @xmath24 .
the terms involving @xmath11 describe the flow of vertices with degree @xmath25 to @xmath7 and @xmath7 to @xmath26 as a consequence of edges gained due to the addition of new vertices .
the first two terms involving @xmath27 describes the flow of vertices with degree @xmath28 to @xmath7 and @xmath7 to @xmath25 as vertices lose edges as a result of losing neighbors .
the term @xmath29 represents the direct removal of a node of degree @xmath7 at rate @xmath2 .
finally @xmath9 represents the addition of a vertex with degree @xmath7 .
processes where vertices gain or lose two or more edges vanish in the limit of large @xmath0 and are not included in eq . .
the rate equation described above presents a formidable challenge due to the appearance of @xmath20 from the terms representing deleted edges from lost neighbors .
rate equations for recovery schemes based on edge rewiring are slightly easier to deal with . upon failure , all edges connected to that node
are rewired so that the degrees of the deleted node s neighbors do not change , and this term does not appear .
the specific case of preferential failure in power - law networks was considered previously in this context by @xcite . however , this recovery protocol can only be used on strictly growing networks , because a network of constant size would become dense under its application .
moreover , it is dependent on the power - law structure of the network .
the methods described here are general and are applicable to arbitrary degree distributions .
apart from edge rewiring , the special case of random deletion also leads to a significant simplification .
uniform deletion amounts to setting @xmath30 .
doing so , then leads to the following , @xmath31 which renders eq .
independent of @xmath32 and thus independent of any degree - degree correlations .
random deletion hence closes equation for @xmath33 , enabling us to seek a solution for the degree distribution for a given @xmath34 and @xmath11 . with non - uniform deletion ,
the degree distribution depends on a two - point probability distribution , and as we shall see in section [ sec : correlations ] , the two - point probability distribution will depend on the three - point probability distribution and so on .
this hierarchy of distributions , where the @xmath0-point distribution depends on the @xmath35-point distribution , is not closed under non - uniform failure and hence it is difficult to seek an exact solution for the degree distribution .
nevertheless , in the following , we demonstrate a method that allows us to navigate our way around this problem . as mentioned before , for the purposes of this paper we will be interested in a network of constant size , where the rate of attack is compensated by the rate of repair . assuming that the network reaches ( or already is ) a stationary distribution and does not possess degree - degree correlations , we set @xmath5 and can further simplify eq . .
let @xmath36 be the mean degree of nodes removed from the network ( i.e. @xmath37 ) , and @xmath38 the mean degree of the original degree distribution @xmath33 .
then we have , @xmath39 the evolution process , specifically non - uniform removal of nodes , can and in many cases will introduce degree - degree correlations into our networks . in order to confront this issue
, we will first find choices for @xmath9 and @xmath40 that satisfy the solutions to the rate equation , for a given @xmath6 , in a network that is uncorrelated .
we will then demonstrate that a special subset of those solutions for @xmath34 and @xmath11 is an uncorrelated fixed point of the rate equation for the degree - degree correlations .
this opens up the possibility , that a network that initially has no degree - degree correlations will not develop correlations from the evolution process .
although the rate equation described in eq .
is fairly complicated , it is a relatively straightforward exercise to determine the relation between edges added to those removed . multiplying eq . by @xmath7 , summing over @xmath7 and rearranging yields @xmath41 .
this equation is simple to interpret .
since the network has a constant fixed - point degree distribution , the average degree of the network remains constant , and therefore edges are removed and added at the the same rate .
in this section we describe our method under which networks can recover from various forms of attack . the types of attack we consider are those studied generally by most authors ( though in static networks ) , namely preferential and targeted attacks .
random failures are the most generally studied schemes in both static and evolving networks , in view of the fact that they lend themselves to relatively simple analysis .
these types of failures may be representative , say , of disruption of power lines or transformers in a power grid owing to extraneous factors such as weather .
however , the functionality of most networks often depends on the performance of higher degree nodes , consequently non - uniform attack schemes focus on these .
for example , in a peer - to - peer network , a high degree node could be a central user with large amounts of data .
high degree could also be indicative of the amount of load on a node during its operation , or on the public visibility of a person in a social network .
it is reasonable to assume that a malicious entity such as a computer virus is more likely to strike these important nodes .
et al _ @xcite have employed this removal strategy ( among others ) on a variety of simulated and real networks and have found it to be highly effective in disrupting the structure of the attacked network .
nodes ) with mean @xmath42 , under preferential attack @xmath43 and uniform attachment @xmath44 using @xmath45.,width=302 ] we simulate these kinds of attacks using preferential failure @xmath43 , that sample nodes in proportion to their number of connections , and through an outright attack on the highest degree nodes represented by @xmath46 , where @xmath47 is the heaviside step function .
our method of compensation will involve control over two processes : the first where our newly incoming / repaired vertex chooses a degree for itself drawn from some distribution @xmath9 , and second , the process by which this vertex decides to attach to any other vertex in the network , governed by the attachment kernel @xmath40 .
our goal here is to solve for the attachment kernel @xmath11 , that will preserve the original probability distribution @xmath33 , subject to a deletion kernel @xmath13 for some choice of @xmath34 .
we will assume that the final network is uncorrelated and work with eq .
, keeping in mind that any arbitrary choice of @xmath34 and @xmath11 is probably not consistent with that assumption . introducing the cumulative distribution for the attacked and newly added vertices , @xmath48 and @xmath49 respectively , @xmath50 we sum eq . from @xmath51 to @xmath52 , noting that @xmath41 for our steady state network .
this leads to the following relation , @xmath53 dividing both sides by @xmath33 gives us an expression for the attachment kernel , @xmath54 .
\nonumber\\ \label{eq : genattachment}\end{aligned}\ ] ] nodes ) with @xmath42 , under high degree attack @xmath55 and uniform attachment @xmath44 using @xmath45.,width=302 ] equation represents the set of possible solutions for the attachment kernel that will lead to the desired degree distribution , given that the final network is uncorrelated .
the correct choice of solution from the above set , must obey the consistency condition , that when inserted into the rate equation for the degree - degree correlations , the correlations vanish . in section [ sec : correlations ] , we will show that the following _ ansatz _ chosen from the above set is such a choice : @xmath56 equation was previously derived by @xcite for the case of random deletion .
here we posit that it works more generally for the case of non - uniform attack when our initial network is uncorrelated ( with some caveats that will be explained shortly ) .
the choice of @xmath11 makes intuitive sense because the quantity @xmath57 is the probability distribution governing the number of edges belonging to a node , reached by following a randomly chosen edge to one of its ends , _ not including _ the edge that was followed .
this is one less than the total degree of the node and is also referred to as the _ excess _ degree distribution .
note that in our model we specify the degree of incoming nodes .
therefore the appearance of the excess degree distribution is a signature of an uncorrelated network , implying the newly arriving edges are being introduced in an uncorrelated fashion .
there are basically two conditions for the existence of a solution given by eq . ; @xmath58 must be a valid probability distribution , and @xmath38 must be finite .
these are not very stringent conditions and are typically satisfied by most degree distributions . in other words , barring some pathological cases , it is always possible to find a solution of the form of eq . .
there is an additional consideration , the deletion process may lead to nodes of degree zero in a network that originally did not have any such nodes . while the fraction of such nodes is vanishingly small for networks with say , poisson degree distributions , they may be non - trivial for power - law networks .
as such , it is important to set @xmath59 ( the probability to attach to a node of degree zero ) to a generous value in order to reconnect these nodes to the network .
we are now in a position to effect our repair on the network .
given the original degree distribution @xmath6 and the form of the attack @xmath13 , eq .
gives us the precise recipe for recovering the degree distribution .
we need to sample the degrees of the newly introduced nodes in proportion to the product of the deletion kernel _ and _ the degree distribution , and then attach these edges in proportion to the excess degree distribution of the network . to test our repair method , we provide four examples for initially uncorrelated networks with @xmath60 nodes generated using the _ configuration model _ @xcite . in the configuration model ,
only the degrees of vertices are specified , apart from this sole constraint the connections between vertices are made at random .
nodes ) with @xmath61 under targeted attack @xmath62 using @xmath11 from eq . after setting @xmath45.,width=302 ]
the simulation results show the initial degree distribution and the compensated one subject to two types of attacks on poissonian networks with degree distribution given by , @xmath63 in fig .
[ fig : poissonpref ] we show the resulting degree distribution where nodes were attacked preferentially , i.e. @xmath43 , while in fig .
[ fig : poissontheta ] we show the case for targeted attack only on high degree nodes represented by @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the _ minimum _ degree of the node attacked .
the degrees of newly added nodes were chosen from the distribution @xmath58 with the attachment kernel @xmath11 set to one , corresponding to the solution of equation after substituting in the appropriate @xmath6 .
the data points in all the figures are averaged over multiple realizations of the network each subject to @xmath66 iterations of addition and deletion .
the points along with corresponding error bars represent the final degree distribution , whereas the solid line represents the initial network . as the figures show , the final networks are in excellent agreement with the initial degree distribution
. nodes ) with exponent @xmath67 and exponential cutoff @xmath68 , under preferential attack @xmath43 using @xmath11 from eq . after setting @xmath45.,width=302 ]
we employ the same attack kernels , @xmath43 and a targeted attack only on high degree nodes represented by @xmath64 on two other examples .
our first example network has links distributed according to a power - law with an exponential cutoff , @xmath69 @xmath70 is a normalization constant which in this case is @xmath71 , where the function @xmath72 is the poly - logarithm function defined as : @xmath73 the exponential cut - off has been introduced for three reasons .
first , many real world networks appear to show this cutoff @xcite and second , it renders the distribution normalizable for ranges of the exponent @xmath74 .
finally , for a pure power - law network it is in principle possible to assign a degree to a node that is greater than the system size .
the exponential cutoff ensures that the probability for this to happen is vanishingly small . in the other examples that we consider
, the functional form of the distribution already ensures this property .
the second network has an exponential distribution given by , @xmath75 fig .
[ fig : exptheta ] shows the results for the exponentially distributed network ( @xmath61 ) undergoing targeted attack . in fig .
[ fig : powerpref ] we show the resulting degree distribution for the power - law network ( @xmath67 and @xmath68 ) where nodes were attacked preferentially .
both figures indicate the initial and final networks are in excellent agreement . at this point , aside from the technical details , it is worth reminding ourselves of the big picture .
we have demonstrated above that if a network with a certain degree structure is subjected to an attack that aims to destabilize that structure , one can recover the same , by manipulating the rules by which vertices are introduced to the network .
the rules that we employ in our repair method are dependent on the types of attacks that our networks are subject to . in the following section we give a detailed justification of the employment of our method . in order for our results from the previous sections to be valid
, we must demonstrate that our initially uncorrelated networks remain uncorrelated under our repair scheme . to accomplish this
, we will define a rate equation for the degree - degree correlations and demonstrate that the uncorrelated network is a fixed point of this equation .
our rate equation will describe the evolution of the expected number of edges in the network with ends of degree @xmath7 and @xmath76 .
let the expected number of such edges in the network be , @xmath77 where @xmath78 , and @xmath79 is the probability that a randomly selected edge has degree @xmath7 at one end and degree @xmath76 in the other .
the expected number of edges after one time step where we add @xmath80 and take away @xmath81 edges is then , @xmath82 e'_{l , k } = m e_{l , k } + \delta , \label{eq : edgerate1}\ ] ] where @xmath83 represents all other edge addition and removal processes .
we have already established that in the steady state case , @xmath84 irrespective of the degree distribution , so our goal is equivalent to showing that @xmath83 is equal to zero for an uncorrelated network generated / repaired with our special choices of @xmath11 and @xmath34 . as a result @xmath85 , implying that the degree - degree correlations ( if any ) remain constant over time .
we will assume that our network is locally tree - like , something which holds true for most random graphs .
in addition we will only consider processes out to second nearest - neighbors of a node .
these assumptions allows us to avoid including terms in the rate equation representing removal of nodes with neighbors that are connected to each other .
nevertheless , there are a large number of remaining processes that we will need to consider .
to start things off , note that the rate equation is symmetric in the indices @xmath76 and @xmath7 .
any process that contributes to changing @xmath7 while holding @xmath76 constant also contributes to changing @xmath76 while holding @xmath7 constant .
we can therefore consider contributions to @xmath83 from @xmath86 , @xmath87 and @xmath88 and add on the corresponding symmetric terms at the end .
the first process we need to take into account is a direct addition of a node of degree @xmath76 .
this contributes two flows to the rate equation , @xmath89 and @xmath90 .
similarly , the direct deletion of a node of degree @xmath76 contributes @xmath91 and @xmath92 .
next , we will have to take into account second nearest - neighbor processes .
we can be certain that these terms are of the same order by merely counting the number of unsummed probability distributions that go into each process .
there will be two terms for the attachment process representing the situation where a new node of any degree attaches to a node of degree @xmath7 or @xmath25 , that was previously attached to a node of degree @xmath76 .
these terms are @xmath93 and @xmath94 .
similarly there are two removal processes , where a node of any degree that is removed from the network was previously attached to a node of degree @xmath7 or @xmath28 that has neighbor(s ) of degree @xmath76 .
unfortunately these terms introduce three - point correlations into the rate equation .
analogous to methods employed in similar hierarchy problems , we use a moment - closure approximation to represent these processes as a product of two two - point correlations in the following manner , @xmath95 adding all of these terms together our final equation for @xmath83 is , @xmath96 in addition to terms where @xmath76 and @xmath7 are interchanged . after inserting the appropriate @xmath11 and @xmath34 from eq .
along with the uncorrelated solution @xmath97 , it can be shown that , @xmath98 according to eq .
, there exist a set of solutions such that an initially uncorrelated network will not develop any degree - degree correlations as a consequence of the evolution process .
the attachment kernel that was employed in the network evolution process , described in section [ sec : designattachment ] , was a subset of these solutions .
this allowed the repair method to be employed by maintaining negligible correlations in the network .
one must point out , that we have not explicitly demonstrated the stability of the uncorrelated solution to perturbations .
for example fluctuations in @xmath87 or in the number of edges may drive the network away from the uncorrelated steady - state . an analytical approach to determine this , say using linear stability analysis is difficult , due to the numerous related probability distributions involved .
so instead we resort to a numerical approach .
we measured the pearson correlation coefficient between the degrees of nodes at both ends of an edge for all our model networks . for the poisson and exponential cases
, the correlations remained negligible during the evolution process .
on the other hand , the power - law network developed non - trivial correlations .
we have not been able to determine whether the appearance of these correlations was due to finite - size effects , or instability in the uncorrelated solution , or to some other cause .
the results show that the agreement between the initial and final degree distributions is very good , and it seems that in this particular case , the correlations did not demonstrate a significant effect on the final state of the network .
in this paper , we have shown how to preserve a network s degree distribution from various forms of attack or failures by allowing it to adapt via the simple manipulation of rules that govern the introduction of nodes and edges .
we based our analysis on a rate equation describing the evolution of the network under arbitrary schemes of addition and deletion .
in addition to choosing the degree of incoming nodes , we allow ourselves to choose how nodes attach to the existing network . to deal with the special case of non - uniform deletion
we have introduced a rate equation for the evolution of degree - degree correlations and have used that in combination with the equation for the degree distribution to come to our solution .
we have provided examples of the applicability of this method using a combination of analytical techniques and numerical simulations on a variety of degree distributions , yielding excellent results in each case .
the structure of many networks in the real world is crucially related to their performance .
many authors have seized on the fact that technological networks such as the internet and peer - to - peer networks are power - law in nature , and have used this to design efficient search schemes among other things .
loss of structural properties of these networks then lead to severe constraints on their performance .
recent empirical studies @xcite have suggested that node removal , for example , in the world wide web , is typically non - uniform in nature . in view of this , it is crucial for researchers to come up with effective solutions to try and manage these types of disruptions . to the best of our knowledge
, there is a considerable gap in understanding the non - uniform deletion process of nodes and edges and corresponding methods to deal with them .
this paper begins to address this gap .
it must be pointed out that the methods we have described depends crucially on the assumption of negligible correlations as the network evolves . curiously enough , in our example power - law network , we were able to get very good agreement between the initial and final degree distributions , in spite of the appearance of non - trivial correlations .
it will certainly be interesting to see if our methods can be extended to the case of networks with strong correlations , and other metrics describing network structure .
perhaps it is possible to directly confront the rate equation for the degree - degree correlations , although this seems a difficult prospect at the moment .
the idea of preserving the structure of networks from attacks by allowing it to react in real - time is a relatively nascent one and the authors look forward to more developments in this area .
|
there has been a considerable amount of interest in recent years on the robustness of networks to failures .
many previous studies have concentrated on the effects of node and edge removals on the connectivity structure of a _
static _ network ; the networks are considered to be static in the sense that no compensatory measures are allowed for recovery of the original structure .
real world networks such as the world wide web , however , are not static and experience a considerable amount of turnover , where nodes and edges are both added and deleted .
considering degree - based node removals , we examine the possibility of preserving networks from these types of disruptions .
we recover the original degree distribution by allowing the network to react to the attack by introducing new nodes and attaching their edges via specially tailored schemes .
we focus particularly on the case of non - uniform failures , a subject that has received little attention in the context of evolving networks . using a combination of analytical techniques and numerical simulations ,
we demonstrate how to preserve the _
exact _ degree distribution of the studied networks from various forms of attack .
recent years have witnessed a substantial amount of interest within the physics community in the properties of networks @xcite .
techniques from statistical physics coupled with the widespread availability of computing resources have facilitated studies ranging from large scale empirical analysis of the worldwide web , social networks , biological systems , to the development of theoretical models and tools to explore the various properties of these systems @xcite .
a relatively large body of work has been devoted to the study of degree distributions of networks , focusing both on their measurement , and formulation of theories to explain their emergence and their effects on various properties such as resilience and percolation .
these studies are mostly aimed at networks in the real world that evolve naturally , in the sense that they are driven by dynamical processes not under our control .
representative examples being social , biological networks and information networks like the world wide web , which though manmade , grows in a distributed fashion .
there are however different classes of infrastructure related networks such as the transportation and power grids , communication networks such as the telephone and internet , that evolve under the direction of a centrally controlled authority .
in addition to these is a relatively new class of networks which fall in between these two types , the classic example being peer - to - peer file - sharing networks .
these networks grow in a collaborative , distributed fashion , so that we have no direct influence over their structure .
however , we can manipulate some of the rules by which these form , giving us a limited but potentially useful influence over their properties .
it is a well established fact , that the structure of such networks is directly related to their performance . in view of this , a certain degree of effort has been made to tailor these _ designer _ networks towards structures that optimize certain properties such as robustness to removal of nodes and efficient information transfer among other things @xcite .
these networks typically experience a significant amount of vertex / edge turnover , with users joining and leaving the network voluntarily , possible failures of key components and resources , or intentional attacks such as denial of service .
these factors can lead to severe disruption of the network structure and as a result , loss of its key properties . in the face of this , it is natural to extend our analysis to the effects of these failures / attacks and use our limited control to attempt to adaptively restore the original structure of these networks .
previous work has focused on the effects of disruption on static networks , where authors have studied the connectivity structure under the random / targeted removal of nodes and edges @xcite .
the network is considered static in that no compensatory measures , such as the introduction of new edges or nodes , are permitted .
the effect of these removals have been measured against the existence of the _ giant component _ : the largest set of vertices in the network of o(@xmath0 ) , where @xmath0 is the number of nodes , that are connected to each other by at least one path .
a representative example can be found in the paper by albert _
et al _
@xcite , where they studied the size of the giant component of scale free networks such as the internet , under simulated random failures and targeted attacks on high degree nodes .
one of the interesting things they found was that , while these networks were remarkably robust to random failures , they were extremely fragile to targeted attacks .
this emphasizes the importance of non - uniform removal strategies .
unlike in the static case , the networks considered in this paper evolve in time with sustained node and edge removals .
the network is allowed to react to these disruptions via the introduction of new nodes and edges , chosen to be attached in a manner such that the network retains it original form , at least in terms of the degree distribution .
such models , conventionally referred to in the literature as _ reactive networks _ have been discussed before , see @xcite for instance . here
we assume that the designers of the network are only aware of the statistical properties of the removed nodes and have no ability to influence the existing network beyond the introduction of new nodes or reattachment of those removed .
consequently they have two processes under their control to compensate for the attack .
the first is the degree of the introduced vertices and the second is the process by which a newly introduced vertex chooses to attach to a previously extant vertex on the network .
failure is thus compensated by adding nodes and edges chosen from an appropriate degree distribution and attaching them to the network via specially tailored schemes .
note that in our model , one can re - introduce nodes that have been removed or introduce completely new sets of nodes . the former case could be indicative of say a computer in a peer - to - peer network that loses its connection , and would like to reconnect .
the latter could represent the permanent loss of web - pages from the world wide web and the introduction of a new web - page .
we use the attachment kernel of krapivsky and redner @xcite , to simulate the introduction of nodes and edges , and via the introduction of a deletion kernel we analyze the interesting and neglected case of non - uniform deletion . a variety of models
have been proposed to simulate network evolution and growth where vertices are both added and deleted @xcite , but these have concentrated on the relatively simple case of uniform deletion . we will show that under uniform failures , the appearance of degree - degree correlations , that typically arise as a result of growth processes , as discussed in @xcite , can be neglected .
previous models have taken advantage of precisely this fact to circumvent the difficulty of dealing with degree - degree correlations .
for the case of non - uniform deletion , correlations can not be ignored . in this paper
we confront this issue by demonstrating how to preserve an initially uncorrelated network throughout the evolution process with the introduction of an additional rate equation for the degree - degree correlations .
we give analytical results and numerical simulations for a variety of degree distributions under various forms of attack .
in all the cases that we study , we recover the _ exact _ degree distributions .
|
at a continuous transition , the expression @xmath13 for the leading critical behavior of a thermodynamic observable @xmath14 has the well known form @xmath15 where @xmath0 and @xmath16 are the transition temperature and the critical exponent respectively . for the concrete analysis of numerical data , a normalization factor with non - critical behavior at @xmath0
must be introduced .
the simplest and most traditional convention , which will be referred to below as @xmath17 scaling , is to normalize each @xmath18 by a temperature independent constant . for obvious reasons this constant
is chosen to be @xmath19 for each observable ; one then writes the normalized leading term as the familiar text - book expression : @xmath20^{-\rho_f } = { \cal c}_{f}t^{-\rho_f } , \label{t_scaling}\ ] ] where @xmath21 and @xmath22 is the critical amplitude ( see [ ] for a detailed review ) .
an alternative and _ a priori _ equally valid choice is to write @xmath23^{-\rho_f } = { \cal c}_{f}[(t-\tc)/t]^{-\rho_f}\nonumber \\ & = & { \cal c}_{f}\left[1-\frac{\beta}{\bec}\right]^{-\rho_f } = { \cal c}_{f}\tau^{-\rho_f } , \label{beta_scaling}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath24 is the inverse temperature @xmath25 and @xmath26 .
note that the temperature dependence of the normalization is now different for each observable .
this `` @xmath24 scaling '' form has become the standard normalization for theoretical work on the critical properties of ferromagnets and analogous systems , see for instance @xcite , although more complex normalizations have been used in special cases . at higher order , confluent and analytic correction terms ( such as temperature independent constants )
are introduced . thus including the confluent correction terms , the critical behavior , @xmath27 ,
is written in terms of the @xmath24 scaling as @xmath28 where @xmath29 with @xmath30 being the [ universal ] confluent correction exponent , and @xmath31 is the confluent correction amplitude . in the @xmath17 scaling form ,
@xmath5 in the above equation is replaced by @xmath32 .
this critical scaling form is firmly established by field theory in the limit of temperatures very close to @xmath33 @xcite
. ratios of the @xmath31 for different observables are universal @xcite .
the exponent @xmath34 is common in both scaling forms so long as @xmath35 .
however , no general argument seems to have been given which would show that either the @xmath17 or the @xmath24 scaling is optimal for all ( or any ) observables when a much wider temperature range is considered .
recently we have proposed an extended scaling scheme for normalizing observables such that the leading critical expressions remain good approximations right up to the trivial fixed point at infinite temperature @xcite .
our extended scaling scheme is based on a consideration of high - temperature series expansions ( htse ) , and so is naturally formulated in terms of the @xmath24 scaling .
the most important ingredient of the scheme is the introduction of non - critical prefactors @xmath36 in the normalizations , where each exponent @xmath37 is uniquely chosen such that the normalized @xmath38 tends to the correct asymptotic form in the limit @xmath39 . in the present work our aim is to further develop our extended scaling scheme to include explicitly the confluent and analytical correction terms .
we then validate our scheme by analyzing data for three canonical ferromagnets : the @xmath40 ising , xy and heisenberg models on simple cubic lattices in dimension three .
these models have been intensively studied over many years and their main critical parameters : @xmath0 , the critical exponents @xmath16 , @xmath34 , and certain critical amplitudes are known to high precision .
careful accounts of studies using different complementary approaches are given for instance in refs .
accurate simulation and htse results have been published in the form of tabulated data .
the present analyses show that the appropriately normalized leading terms are good approximations over the entire temperature range , with small but identifiable corrections due to confluent and non - critical terms .
we obtain estimates of non - universal critical parameters like critical amplitudes @xmath41 and confluent correction amplitudes @xmath42 from the high precision numerical data .
our extended scaling analyses are in each case entirely consistent with field theoretical and htse estimates of the critical parameters .
an important result of the present analysis is to demonstrate that the prefactors @xmath36 which have been introduced play a crucial role in extracting accurate values of the critical exponents from simulation data even in a temperature range close to @xmath0 , such as @xmath43 . in the standard scalings without the prefactors
the estimates of the leading critical term and of the confluent term from analyses of numerical data turn out to be modified to order @xmath44 ( note @xmath45 )
. the same approach based on the htse should be directly applicable to a wide class of systems having the same intrinsic htse structure as the simple ferromagnets .
extensions to more complex systems such as spin glasses are in principle straightforward @xcite .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : basics ] we explain our extended scaling scheme for various thermodynamic observables , and discuss confluent corrections to scaling terms in our scheme . in sec .
[ sec : analysis ] we give methods of analysis for numerical data using our extended scaling scheme .
we show how they work in practice for ising , xy and heisenberg ferromagnets in sec .
[ sec:3dising ] , [ sec:3dxy ] and [ sec:3dh ] , respectively . in sec .
[ sec : conclusion ] we make concluding remarks and discuss related problems .
let us suppose htse of an observable @xmath46 is given by @xmath47 the most important ingredient of our extended scaling scheme is then to write @xmath27 as @xmath48 where @xmath49 with @xmath50 . in particular , the leading contribution without the confluent correction is represented as @xmath51 the idea here is to let @xmath27 not only represent the correct power - law divergence @xmath52 with the critical amplitude @xmath53 ( and with certain confluent correction terms ) at temperatures close to @xmath0 but also have an asymptotic form consistent with the htse in the high temperature limit .
the observable @xmath46 is then approximated as @xmath54 here the second term represents the analytic ( non - critical ) correction term in the present scheme .
its coefficients @xmath55 and @xmath56 are determined in such a way that eq .
( [ f_expression ] ) , combined with eqs .
( [ fc_expression ] ) and ( [ rfc_expression ] ) , coincides with eq .
( [ hight_expression ] ) termwise as a function of @xmath24 ; for example , @xmath57 and a similar expression for @xmath58 . the above set of equations with the minimum number of the confluent and analytic correction terms is an optimized expression we propose for the function @xmath46 which is analytic in the range @xmath59 and is singular at @xmath60 .
an important quantity for analyzing our extended scaling scheme is @xmath61 defined by @xmath62 it is the ratio of the measured values of observable @xmath14 to its leading critical term including the @xmath36 prefactor but without the critical amplitude @xmath41 .
explicitly , in the vicinity of @xmath0 where @xmath63 , it behaves as @xmath64 the plot @xmath61 versus @xmath65 near @xmath66 thus becomes a straight line with intercept @xmath67 and slope @xmath68 , where the values of @xmath0 , @xmath16 and @xmath34 are assumed to be known ( @xmath37 and @xmath69 are given by htse analysis ) . in the limit @xmath70 , on the other hand , it becomes @xmath71 between these limits the form of @xmath61 will depend on the entire collection of unspecified higher order corrections to scaling .
the `` true '' susceptibility , naturally defined through the magnetization response to an infinitesimal applied field , is given by the fluctuation - dissipation theorem as @xmath72 the reduced susceptibility @xmath73 is ( confusingly ) almost always referred to in the literature as `` the susceptibility '' . for consistency we will follow this convention and write the reduced susceptibility as @xmath74 , but we will refer systematically in the text to `` reduced susceptibility '' .
the htse for the reduced susceptibility @xmath75 in @xmath40 ferromagnets is of the form with @xmath76 and @xmath77 , or with abbreviation of @xmath78 , @xmath79 then the leading divergent expression , eq .
( [ fc_leading ] ) , is written as @xmath80 with @xmath81 .
the ratio @xmath82 of eq .
( [ rf_expression ] ) is reduced to @xmath83 where @xmath84 is eq .
( [ fc_expression ] ) for @xmath8 .
note that @xmath85 at @xmath0 , @xmath86 near @xmath33 , and @xmath87 near infinite temperature . if @xmath82 remains close to 1 over the whole temperature range ( which is the case for the systems we consider as we will see below ) , the leading critical contribution without the correction terms , @xmath88 , is a good approximation for the reduced susceptibility , @xmath75 .
furthermore , the small difference @xmath89 of the ising and xy ferromagnets in the whole temperature range @xmath59 turns out to be reproduced surprisingly well by our optimized expression , @xmath90 of eq .
( [ f_expression ] ) , only with one confluent and two non - critical correction terms .
there are different alternative definitions for the correlation length , but any correlation length diverges at criticality as @xmath91 .
the second moment correlation length @xmath92 is defined through the second moment @xmath93 with @xmath94 the space dimensionality @xcite . from now on we will refer to @xmath95 simply as @xmath96 .
the htse results show that for @xmath97-vector @xmath40 spins , the series for @xmath98 is of the form @xmath99 and is well behaved with @xmath100 , where @xmath101 is the number of nearest neighbors .
this yields @xmath102 and @xmath103 .
we then reduce eq .
( [ fc_leading ] ) to @xmath104 where @xmath105 with @xmath106 being the standard critical amplitude in eq . ( [ beta_scaling ] ) for @xmath107 .
the non - standard normalization prefactor @xmath108 for @xmath109 is our main result .
the mean - field calculation @xcite of the correlation length through the fluctuation - dissipation theorem provides an example confirming the extended scaling form of eq .
( [ cri_xi ] ) .
see also the analysis of fisher and burford @xcite , particularly their temperature dependent `` effective interaction range '' parameter @xmath110 .
the critically divergent part of @xmath96 with the confluent correction terms is represented by @xmath111 and is written as @xmath112 the ratio @xmath113 becomes @xmath114 again , because of the confluent correction , it becomes @xmath115 near @xmath33 and @xmath116\beta + \cdots$ ] with @xmath117 being the coefficient in eq .
( [ htse_chi ] ) near infinite temperature . the usual analysis of the specific heat ( defined as the derivative of the internal energy at fixed volume @xmath118 ) near criticality assumes the form @xmath119^{-\alpha } + k \label{standard_c}\ ] ] where @xmath120 and @xmath121 is the critical amplitude of @xmath122 , and it is standard practice to introduce a large non - critical ( in fact temperature independent ) contribution @xmath123 ( see e.g. ref [ ] ) .
while the series for the reduced susceptibility and the second moment @xmath124 are polynomial functions of @xmath24 with both odd and even terms , for bipartite ( such as bcc and simple cubic ) lattices the htse expression for @xmath125 consists of even powers of @xmath24 only @xcite , and can be written as @xmath126 one can carry through the same type of argument @xcite as in the case of @xmath127 , except that as all the terms in the series are even in @xmath128 , the critical behavior must be re - written in terms of the scaling variable @xmath129 $ ] replacing @xmath130 $ ] in the equivalent expressions for the correlation length .
thus , with @xmath131 , one can write the leading critical term , which corresponds to eq .
( [ fc_leading ] ) , as @xmath132 where @xmath133 .
if the confluent correction terms are included , we obtain the expression corresponding to eq .
( [ fc_expression ] ) as @xmath134 . \label{c_cri}\ ] ] where @xmath135 is the confluent correction amplitude .
it is noted that , since the two critical amplitudes @xmath121 and @xmath136 are introduced in the standard way ( as represented by eq .
( [ standard_c ] ) for @xmath121 ) , the factors @xmath137 and @xmath138 appear in the definition of @xmath139 and in eq .
( [ c_cri ] ) , respectively .
in fact there is a hyper - universal relationship linking this @xmath140 to @xmath106 @xcite : @xmath141 where @xmath142 is a constant whose value is known rather accurately @xcite .
equation ( [ cri_c ] ) is not standard , but it can be seen to tend to the appropriate limit , @xmath143 , as @xmath17 approaches @xmath0 . in practice
@xmath139 is much larger than unity ( as will be seen later in the case of the @xmath144 ising model ) which is the reason for the large non - critical contribution to @xmath125 .
the non - critical contribution is in fact not a parameter to be adjusted freely , but it has to be determined through the high temperature limit of an equation which corresponds to eq .
( [ f_expression ] ) . ignoring the confluent correction so as to clarify the discussion , we know the exact high temperature limits for @xmath145 from eq .
( [ cri_c ] ) and for @xmath125 by eq .
( [ htse_c ] ) .
then @xmath125 truncated to two leading non - critical correction terms is explicitly written as @xmath146 where the non - critical parameters @xmath147 are given by @xmath148 and @xmath149 .
the coefficients @xmath150 and @xmath151 are known from htse .
so if @xmath152 and @xmath153 have been measured independently , we can evaluate all the parameters which one needs to fix the functional form of @xmath125 , such as @xmath154 and @xmath139 determined through eq .
( [ eqn : hyper ] ) .
this we assume to be @xmath155 , an optimized expression for @xmath125 , in the whole @xmath24 range @xmath156 .
the thus calculated curve @xmath155 can be tested by comparing with simulation and htse data . though we will discuss thermodynamic limit behavior only and
will not analyze finite - size - scaling ( fss ) data explicitly in the present paper , we note for reference that the extended scaling normalization modifies the fss expressions .
the canonical fss ansatz @xcite is @xmath157 , \label{fss}\ ] ] where @xmath158 is a universal scaling function .
the frequently used fss expression derived from eq .
( [ fss ] ) , @xmath159\ ] ] contains the implicit assumption of @xmath17 scaling for the correlation length .
it is thus only appropriate if restricted to a very narrow range of temperature around @xmath33 . with the extended scaling and the finite size correlation length @xmath160
, the fss ansatz can be rewritten @xcite @xmath161 , \label{fss_ferro}\ ] ] or @xmath162,\ ] ] where the scaling functions behave as @xmath163 and @xmath164 at @xmath165 . for the reduced susceptibility with @xmath76
, the fss form is written as @xmath166 , \nonumber \\ & = & \tau^{-\gamma } \tilde{\mathcal f}_{\chi } \left[\left(\frac{l}{\beta^{1/2}}\right)^{1/\nu}\tau\right ] , \label{fss_chi}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath167 and @xmath168 constant . at @xmath165 . in a similar manner , the fss form for the correlation length @xmath160 , for which @xmath169 and @xmath102 , is written as @xmath170 , \label{fss_xi}\ ] ] where @xmath171 at @xmath165 .
while the extended fss scheme for the susceptibility is modified from the standard one only by the @xmath24-prefactor in the argument of @xmath172 , the scaling plot is significantly improved for @xmath173 ising ferromagnetic and @xmath144 ising spin glass models @xcite .
in order to make a stringent test of the extended scaling scheme , we study the three canonical ferromagnets : ising , xy and heisenberg , on three dimensional simple cubic lattices .
high precision numerical data have been obtained for each of these systems for the temperature domain ranging from close to @xmath0 to about @xmath174 and the authors have generously published their data in tabulated form @xcite .
the data have been taken on systems large enough for the data points to be representative of the thermodynamic limit .
long htses have also been published for @xmath74 and @xmath124 and for @xmath175 for all three systems @xcite , and relatively longer series for the free - energy and the specific heat have been calculated for the ising model @xcite ; these series can be used to calculate @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath122 explicitly for the region @xmath17 well above @xmath0 .
below we call these htse and mc data as the _ real _ data .
thanks to a combination of results from field theory and htse the values of the critical temperatures , the critical exponents and the critical amplitudes are known to a high degree of accuracy , and the confluent correction exponents are also well known .
the [ non - universal ] confluent correction amplitudes are small for these three systems and the estimates are much less accurate ( see butera and comi @xcite for a detailed account ) . in each case we will plot the ratios @xmath82 and @xmath113 respectively defined by eqs .
( [ rchi_def ] ) and ( [ rxi_def ] ) with respect to @xmath65 , where we have used @xmath176 for simple cubic lattices .
the plots near @xmath66 give us the critical and the confluent amplitudes as explained at the end of sec .
[ sec : optimal ] .
the ratios are defined in a way that they approach unity at infinite temperature .
we will see that the two ratios defined in the extended scaling scheme are in fact close to unity ( within several hundredth deviation from unity at most ) in the whole range of @xmath5 . in addition , a simple scaling relation links the observables @xmath75 and @xmath96 through @xmath177 to leading order .
this equation has the advantage that it can in principle be used to determine the exponent @xmath178 directly from a log - log plot of @xmath75 against @xmath96 near @xmath179 without any explicit knowledge of @xmath179 . for the extended scaling scheme ( @xmath24 scaling with the @xmath36 factors )
, the relation can be rewritten to leading order @xmath180 we will analyze the ratio defined by @xmath181 including the leading confluent correction factors , it behaves near @xmath33 as @xmath182 where @xmath183 and @xmath184 .
we also note that the ratios @xmath185 are universal and are known to be about @xmath186 @xcite .
this means that @xmath187 .
for the @xmath144 simple cubic ising case @xmath188 , together with the high precision mc data at temperatures close to @xmath0 by kim et al@xcite and the htse estimates at relatively high temperatures by butera and comi@xcite , our own mc data are also used in order to interpolate them and to see overall temperature dependences of @xmath189 and @xmath175 . in our simulation
we used the exchange mc method in combination with 64 bit multi - spin coding technique for making equilibration fast .
the 64 different temperatures simulated are distributed in the range of @xmath190 .
the amount of total mc steps for @xmath191 is @xmath192 and the last @xmath193 mc steps are used for taking thermal averages .
figure [ fig:3di - chixi - e ] shows the parameter free log - log plot in the extended scaling form of the reduced susceptibility @xmath74 against @xmath194 data . without allowing for corrections ,
the slope of the line fitted to the data points ( ignoring our mc data when they are polluted by finite - size effects ) gives a first estimate @xmath195 .
figure [ fig:3di - chixi - c ] is the equivalent standard ( @xmath17 or @xmath24 scaling ) log - log plot of @xmath74 against @xmath107 with the slope fixed to the one obtained from fig .
[ fig:3di - chixi - e ] .
it can be seen that in the standard scaling form the linear relationship breaks down rather quickly while in the extended scaling form with the same input data , the linearity persists to a good approximation up to an infinite temperature and down to temperatures near @xmath33 until limited by finite - size effects .
we examine the leading correction of the extended scaling formula given by eq .
( [ ratio_normalized ] ) . to higher precision , fig .
[ fig:3di - chixi - e2 ] shows a plot of @xmath196 against @xmath197 , assuming @xmath198 , @xmath199 and @xmath200 @xcite .
the line is obtained by fitting the data points at @xmath201 to eq .
( [ ratio_normalized ] ) .
the intercept at @xmath66 , @xmath202 , is in good agreement with the value @xmath203 assuming the critical amplitudes from htse @xcite . from the initial slope , @xmath204 , which we will comment on below .
figures [ fig:3di - rchi ] and [ fig:3di - rxi ] show the ratios @xmath82 and @xmath113 of eqs .
( [ rchi_def ] ) and ( [ rxi_def ] ) , respectively .
the numerical data are taken from kim et al @xcite , and the higher temperature values are calculated using the tabulated series of butera and comi@xcite .
the htse terms were simply summed , and the points quoted correspond to the temperature range where the contributions from further terms can be considered negligible on the scale of the plots . by using appropriate extrapolation techniques , like differential approximations , the range over which the published htse data@xcite could be used to evaluate the temperature dependence of the observables to high precision could be considerably extended .
the assumed critical parameters are @xmath205 , @xmath206 and @xmath207@xcite . from the initial intercepts and slopes of the fitted line at small @xmath5
, we obtain @xmath208 , @xmath209 , @xmath210 and @xmath211 .
the @xmath212 values are in excellent agreement with the htse estimates@xcite , @xmath213 and @xmath214 .
the @xmath42 values are in qualitative agreement with the htse estimates @xmath215 and @xmath216 @xcite . an overall conclusion on the extended scaling analysis of the @xmath144 simple cubic ising data , which will be confirmed by the analyses of the two other systems as well ,
is that this form of scaling is entirely consistent with the high precision values of critical parameters from extensive htse and field theoretical ( ft ) work .
it is remarkable that over the entire temperature range from @xmath0 to infinity , the maximum deviations from the leading critical expressions of eqs .
( [ cri_chi ] ) and ( [ cri_xi ] ) are of the order of a few percent .
let us go into further discussions about the @xmath217 behavior . in the inset of fig .
[ fig:3di - rchi ] , we show the corresponding @xmath17 scaling ratio @xmath218 plotted against @xmath219 .
the latter is calculated using the same values of the critical parameters @xmath220 and @xmath221 as those for @xmath217 , and so by construction in the low @xmath222 limit the intercepts and slopes of both ratios must coincide .
it can be seen that in fact the @xmath17 scaling curve only approaches the @xmath24 scaling curve closely in the range of @xmath222 extremely close to zero .
this result for @xmath74 with @xmath223 strongly suggests the superiority of the @xmath24 scaling , and hence our extended scaling , over the @xmath17 scaling .
the full curve in the main frame of fig . [ fig:3di - rchi ] is the optimized expression , @xmath224 , which is evaluated through @xmath225 , with one confluent correction term discussed above and the two non - critical terms .
the first term of the latter is a constant , @xmath226 , which yields simply @xmath227 at @xmath228 , or at an infinite temperature .
its second term @xmath229 , which is also calculated via the parameters already fixed , specifies the slope of @xmath224 at @xmath228 . by taking into account only these three correction terms to the leading critical term , @xmath230 of eq .
( [ cri_chi ] ) , we obtain @xmath224 which reproduces surprisingly well the _ real _ data in the whole temperature range @xmath231 .
notice that @xmath232 corresponds to @xmath233 .
this result also indicates the superiority of our extended scaling with the @xmath24 scaling : @xmath230 not only represents the critical behavior of @xmath75 close to @xmath0 but also @xmath75 in the whole temperature range up to infinity . in this context
we note again that @xmath234 for the `` true '' susceptibility and that the reduced susceptibility @xmath75 is derived through our extended scaling scheme .
we also note that the similarity between the @xmath217 plot in fig .
[ fig:3di - rchi ] and the @xmath235 plot in fig .
[ fig:3di - rxi ] over the entire range of temperature is striking .
lastly , fig .
[ fig:3di - spec ] shows @xmath236 as a function of @xmath237 .
the data points are calculated from the htse of arisue and fujiwara which extends to powers up to @xmath238 @xcite , mc energy data at @xmath239 and @xmath240 @xcite , and our numerical simulations for different sizes up to @xmath191 .
we examine the extended scaling with non - critical contributions to @xmath125 given by eq .
( [ c_beta ] ) . by using the hyper - universal relation with the value of @xmath142 equal to @xmath241 @xcite for the @xmath144 ising model and our @xmath107 analysis
, we obtain @xmath242
. then the non - critical parameters @xmath243 and @xmath244 are determined by @xmath150 and @xmath151 of htse and with putting @xmath245 .
the solid curve represents the no - free parameter plot of eq .
( [ c_beta ] ) with the @xmath246 values cited or estimated above .
the agreement over the whole temperature range is very satisfactory ; the non - critical correction is so strong that the bare leading power law is a poor approximation until very much closer to @xmath0 than the range covered by the figure .
we consider this result as an indication that the extended scaling scheme combined with the optimized introduction of correction terms is an effective method for analyzing critically - divergent quantities in general .
the same analysis has been carried out for the @xmath144 xy model ( @xmath247 ) .
high precision numerical data were published by gottlob and hasenbusch@xcite , and are supplemented here by unpublished data kindly provided by m. hasebusch@xcite .
the higher temperature data are calculated using the tabulated series of butera and comi@xcite .
the critical point is @xmath248 and the exponents @xmath178 , @xmath34 , @xmath249 and @xmath250 are close to @xmath251 and @xmath252 , respectively@xcite .
figure [ fig:3dxy - chixi - e ] shows the @xmath253 log - log plot .
the leading scaling scheme works well up to very high temperatures , as in the ising case . the slope in fig .
[ fig:3dxy - chixi - e ] gives us the value of @xmath178 which is in agreement with the previously reported values@xcite .
figure [ fig:3dxy - chixi - e2 ] shows the plot of @xmath254^{2-\eta}$ ] against @xmath65 assuming the central values for the exponents @xmath178 and @xmath34 as mentioned above .
figures [ fig:3dxy - rchi ] and [ fig:3dxy - rxi ] show @xmath82 and @xmath113 respectively against @xmath197 . from the @xmath66
intercept and the initial slope one can estimate @xmath255 , @xmath256 , @xmath257 and @xmath258 .
these are all reasonably close to the quite independent htse values@xcite @xmath259 , @xmath260 , @xmath261 and @xmath262 , but are probably more reliable as they are consistent with the independent ft estimate of the universal ratio @xmath263 , see comments in ref .
[ ] . also , the values of @xmath264 and @xmath265 in eq .
( [ ratio_normalized ] ) calculated from thus obtained set of the parameters reproduce well the data as shown in fig .
[ fig:3dxy - chixi - e2 ] .
this agreement again validates the extended scaling protocol and demonstrates that a combination of information from ft , htse , and simulations analyzed using this protocol can lead to consistent high precision critical parameter measurements . for comparison , we plot the standard @xmath17 scaling ratio @xmath266 introduced in sec . [ sec:3dising ] also in fig .
[ fig:3dxy - rchi ] .
its coincidence with @xmath217 will only hold for @xmath267 . as is the case for the ising system ,
the slope of @xmath268 is opposite to that of @xmath82 and the magnitude of @xmath269 is much larger than the corresponding magnitude of the extended ratio already at @xmath270 , or @xmath271 . in fig .
[ fig:3dxy - rxi ] , we also show the @xmath17 scaling @xmath272 and the @xmath273 by @xmath24-scaling .
the true leading term plus confluent correction holds with the extended scaling form , @xmath235 of eq .
( [ rxi_def ] ) with @xmath247 up to @xmath274 while with the other forms of scaling the correct limit will hold only for @xmath267 .
in particular , the comparison of @xmath24 scaling @xmath275 with extended scaling @xmath235 demonstrates the importance of the @xmath108 prefactor in eq .
( [ rxi_def ] ) of the extended scaling scheme .
these results imply that even close to @xmath0 the extended scaling is a considerable improvement over the standard scaling analysis for estimating critical parameters including the correction terms .
the curve in fig .
[ fig:3dxy - rchi ] represents our optimized estimates @xmath224 up to the second order of non - critical corrections .
it reproduces about 5 percents change in @xmath217 , from about 1.05 at @xmath66 to 1 at @xmath228 , to a very good approximation .
the corresponding relative change in @xmath235 is only less than 2 percents as seen in fig .
[ fig:3dxy - rxi ] . to reproduce this change by @xmath276 to an approximation as good as @xmath224 in fig .
[ fig:3dxy - rchi ] , however , more than third order non - critical correction terms are required .
the same analysis has been carried out for the @xmath144 heisenberg model ( @xmath277 ) .
high precision numerical data were published by holm and janke@xcite , and are supplemented here by higher temperature data calculated using the tabulated series of butera and comi@xcite .
the critical point is @xmath278 and the exponents @xmath178 and @xmath34 are close to @xmath279 and @xmath280 @xcite .
a recent exponent set @xcite gives @xmath281 , @xmath282 and @xmath283 .
figure [ fig:3dh - chixi - e ] shows the @xmath284 log - log plot , which gives an estimate of @xmath178 consistent with that of ref . [ ] .
figure [ fig:3dh - chixi - e2 ] shows the plot of @xmath285^{2-\eta}$ ] against @xmath197 assuming the exponent values as @xmath286 and @xmath287 . from this plot
it appears that the initial slope is very small , corresponding to almost zero values for @xmath288 and @xmath289 .
figures [ fig:3dh - rchi ] and [ fig:3dh - rxi ] show respectively @xmath82 and @xmath113 against @xmath197 , assuming the values of @xmath249 and @xmath250 in ref . [ ] .
the mc and htse points may not appear to connect smoothly in these figures , because the manner in which the plots are presented enhances small deviations from the leading term form .
however , the change in the values of both @xmath82 in fig .
[ fig:3dh - rchi ] and @xmath113 in fig .
[ fig:3dh - rxi ] are limited to within a few percent of their absolute magnitude in a whole range of @xmath5 as is the case for the other two ferromagnets studied . from the straight line fit of the mc data at small @xmath197 , one can estimate @xmath290 , @xmath291 , @xmath292 and @xmath293 . in this case
the parameters are slightly less consistent with the htse estimates@xcite , @xmath294 , @xmath295 , @xmath296 and @xmath297 , but it should be noted that the estimates for these [ non - universal ] parameters depend very sensitively on the precise values taken for the critical exponents .
we certainly need more precise data near @xmath0 to fix the values of these critical parameters for the heisenberg ferromagnet .
we have outlined a systematic rule for the scaling and normalization of thermodynamic observables having critical behavior at continuous phase transitions .
this `` extended scaling '' rule corresponds for ferromagnets to scaling of the leading term of the reduced susceptibility above @xmath0 as @xmath298 in agreement with standard practice , for the leading term of the second moment correlation length as @xmath299 with @xmath300 and for the leading term of the specific heat in bipartite lattices @xmath301 with @xmath133 plus strong non - critical correction terms which we explicitly evaluate by linking to the htse .
analyses are made of high precision numerical data on three canonical ferromagnets using these expressions allowing for confluent scaling correction terms , plus non - critical corrections for the specific heat .
near @xmath0 the results are entirely consistent with the critical parameter sets ( including the confluent corrections ) which have been obtained independently using sophisticated ft , htse and simulation techniques@xcite .
the most important result found in the present work is that , for @xmath8 and @xmath9 the leading critical expressions with the extended scaling normalizations @xmath302 of eq .
( [ fc_leading ] ) agree to a very good approximation with the true @xmath46 up to infinite temperature .
to demonstrate this fact more in details we have introduced the ratio @xmath61 defined by eq .
( [ rf_expression ] ) . for @xmath74 of the ising ferromagnet , for example , it is equal to the critical amplitude @xmath303 at @xmath0 ( @xmath66 ) and to unity at infinite temperature ( @xmath228 ) by definition .
@xmath217 evaluated from the true data are represented by the data points in fig .
[ fig:3di - rchi ] , while @xmath217 evaluated through the leading expression @xmath304 is independent of @xmath5 and equal to @xmath303 .
the difference between the two is , however , at most 13 percent in this case .
the corresponding differences for @xmath217 s of the two other ferromagnets as well as for @xmath235 s of the all three ferromagnets are less than several percent .
this is our first result mentioned just above .
we have next demonstrated that our extended scaling scheme , in terms of the @xmath24 scaling and with the temperature dependent prefactor @xmath36 , is of crucial importance in precisely extracting the small amplitude @xmath42 of the leading confluent correction term .
the result is represented by the solid line in fig .
[ fig:3di - rchi ] as well as those in figs .
[ fig:3di - rxi ] , [ fig:3dxy - rchi ] , and [ fig:3dxy - rxi ] .
in addition , we have also checked that the optimized expression @xmath305 of eq .
( [ f_expression ] ) , consisting of @xmath306 and one confluent and two non - critical correction , yield @xmath307 which reproduces the true @xmath61 surprisingly well as shown the curves in figs .
[ fig:3di - rchi ] and [ fig:3dxy - rchi ] , though more than third non - critical correction terms would be required for equally good agreement in other observables .
the large non - critical terms in the specific heat @xmath122 are also incorporated explicitly within our extended scaling scheme with no further adjustable input parameters . for the ising ferromagnet on the simple cubic lattice @xmath122
is calculated to a good approximation over the entire temperature range ( see eq .
( [ c_beta ] ) ) .
although the non - critical correction terms are large for @xmath122 , the principle of the analysis is the same as the one applied above to @xmath8 and @xmath9 , for which the corrections to scaling are quite small .
namely , each critically - divergent observable @xmath46 is represented by @xmath305 of eq .
( [ f_expression ] ) over the whole range of @xmath24 to a good approximation .
the input consists of @xmath308 , a confluent correction term and a very limited numbers of non - critical correction terms derived from htse .
together these results can be taken as validating the `` extended scaling '' approach .
the approach could be systematically implemented in numerical work so as to improve yet further the accuracy of critical parameter sets derived for standard systems , possibly incorporating where necessary further higher order correction terms .
perhaps a more fruitful application would concern the analyses of numerical data in more complex systems , where the present accuracy of the critical parameter sets is much poorer .
for instance , it has been pointed out that for the analysis of data on spin glasses with symmetric interaction distributions @xmath24 should be replaced by @xmath309 in all expressions@xcite as all terms in the htse in these spin glasses are strictly even in @xmath24 . the extended scaling protocol allowing for this and with appropriate @xmath310 normalization factors
has indeed been shown to significantly improve the consistency of critical exponent values derived from numerical simulations on ising spin glasses@xcite .
we would like to thank p. butera for all his careful and patient advice , h. arisue for providing extensive tabulated series data , m. hasenbusch for allowing us to use his unpublished high - precision numerical data , and w. janke for helpful discussions .
this work was supported by the grants - in - aid for scientific research ( no .
17540348 and no .
18079004 ) and naregi nanoscience project , both from mext of japan .
the numerical calculations were mainly performed on the sgi origin 2800/384 at the supercomputer center , issp , the university at tokyo .
99 a. pelissetto and e. vicari , phys .
rept.*368 * 549 ( 2002 ) .
s. gartenhaus and w. s. mccullough , phys .
b * 38 * , 11688 ( 1988 ) .
butera and m. comi , phys . rev .
b * 65 * , 144431 ( 2002 ) .
wegner , phys .
b * 5 * 4529 ( 1972 ) . c. bagnuls and c. bervillier , phys .
b * 24 * , 1226 ( 1981 ) .
i. a. campbell , k. hukushima and h. takayama , phys .
lett . * 97 * , 117202 ( 2006 ) .
r. guida and j. zinn - justin , j. phys .
a * 31 * , 8103 ( 1998 ) .
m. campostrini , m. hasenbusch , a. pelissetto , and e. vicari , phys .
b * 74 * , 144506 ( 2006 ) .
g. parisi , in _ statistical field theory _ , ( perseus books , 1988 ) .
m. e. fisher and r. j. burford , phys .
rev.*156 * , 583 ( 1967 ) .
m. hasenbusch and k. pinn , j. phys .
a * 31 * , 6185 ( 1998 ) .
p. butera and m. comi , j. stat
. phys . * 109 * , 311 ( 2002 ) , hep - lat/0204007 .
h. arisue and t. fujiwara , phys.rev .
e * 67 * , 066109 ( 2003 ) .
d. stauffer , m. ferer and m. wortis , phys .
* 29 * , 345 ( 1972 ) .
m. e. fisher and m. n. barber , phys .
* 28 * , 1516 ( 1972 ) .
kim , a.j.f .
de souza and d.p .
landau , phys .
e * 54 * , 2291 ( 1996 ) .
a.p . gottlob and a. hasenbusch , physica a * 201 * , 593 ( 1993 ) .
c. holm and w. janke , phys .
b * 48 * , 936 ( 1993 ) .
p. butera and m. comi , phys .
b * 58 * , 11552 ( 1998 ) .
y. deng and h.w.j .
blte , phys .
e * 68 * , 036125 ( 2003 ) .
m. hasenbusch , private communication .
m. campostrini , m. hasenbusch , a. pelissetto , p. rossi , and e. vicari , phys .
b * 65 * , 144520 ( 2002 ) .
d. daboul , i. chang and a. aharony , eur .
j. b * 41 * , 231 ( 2004 ) .
katzgraber , m .
krner , and a. p.
young , phys rev b * 73 * , 224432 ( 2006 ) .
|
a simple systematic rule , inspired by high - temperature series expansion ( htse ) results , is proposed for optimizing the expression for thermodynamic observables of ferromagnets exhibiting critical behavior at @xmath0 .
this `` extended scaling '' scheme leads to a protocol for the choice of scaling variables , @xmath1 or @xmath2 depending on the observable instead of @xmath3 , and more importantly to temperature dependent non - critical prefactors for each observable .
the rule corresponds to scaling of the leading of the reduced susceptibility above @xmath0 as @xmath4 in agreement with standard practice with scaling variable @xmath5 , and for the leading term of the second - moment correlation length as @xmath6 . for the specific heat in bipartite lattices
the rule gives @xmath7^{-\alpha}$ ] .
the latter two expressions are not standard .
the scheme can allow for confluent and non - critical correction terms .
a stringent test of the extended scaling is made through analyses of high precision numerical and htse data , or _ real _ data , on the three - dimensional canonical ising , xy , and heisenberg ferromagnets .
for the susceptibility @xmath8 and the correlation length @xmath9 of the three ferromagnets , their optimized expression , which consists of the leading term ( respectively @xmath10 and @xmath11 ) and a quite limited number of confluent and non - critical correction terms , represents _ real _ data to surprisingly good approximations over the entire temperature range from @xmath0 to infinity . the temperature dependent prefactors introduced are of crucial importance not only in fixing the optimized expression at relatively high temperatures but also in determining appropriately the small amplitude correction terms .
for the specific heat of the ising ferromagnet , @xmath12 combined with two non - critical correction terms which are calculated with no free parameters once the correlation length critical parameters are known , reproduces _ real _ data nicely also over the whole temperature range .
|
laser - cooling @xcite allows to cool ions and atoms to very low temperatures . for this purpose
, the full knowledge of the effects of the various physical parameters determining the cooling process is very important . among the various schemes ,
raman sideband cooling has been demonstrated to be a very successful technique for preparing atoms in the ground state of a harmonic potential @xcite .
this cooling method exploits two stable or metastable atomic internal levels , which we call @xmath0 and @xmath1 , connected by dipole transitions to a common excited state @xmath2 . the transitions are usually driven by alternating pulses . a typical sequence alternates a coherent pulse ,
in which the atom is coherently transferred from @xmath0 to @xmath1 via a properly designed raman pulse , with a re - pumping pulse , in which the atom is incoherently re - scattered to @xmath0 by means of a laser resonant with @xmath3 .
a change of the motional state during the repumping is a process of higher order in the ratio @xmath4 of the recoil frequency @xmath5 and the trap frequency @xmath6 , with @xmath7 being the mass of the atom and @xmath8 the wave vector of the one - photon transition . in the lamb - dicke regime , where @xmath9 , the probability for a change of the motional state is negligible and therefore , on the average , the system is cooled at a rate of one phonon of energy @xmath10 per cooling cycle . since there is a finite probability for the atom to be returned to the state @xmath1 instead of being repumped , a number of incoherent scattering events may be required before the atom is finally scattered into @xmath0 , which significantly increases the motional energy at the end of the optical pumping , reducing the cooling efficiency .
furthermore , since two and three level schemes are realized using zeeman or hyperfine substates , decays from @xmath2 into other electronic substates can occur , leading to additional heating .
+ in this work we quantify the effect of a finite branching ratio in pulsed raman sideband cooling by calculating the average shift and diffusion of the vibrational energy distribution at the end of an incoherent pumping pulse .
it should be pointed out that theoretical studies on laser - cooling for multilevel ions exist , which systematically include the branching ratio in their treatments @xcite .
those studies have focussed on the lamb - dicke regime and on certain cooling schemes . here
, we single out the effect of the branching ratio on cooling for an arbitrary ratio @xmath4 by applying sum rules .
hence , we infer the cooling efficiency in the lamb - dicke regime and we discuss the result outside the lamb - dicke regime in connection with the proposal in @xcite . in particular ,
we show that in some parameter ranges the average effect of the multiple photon scattering can be described with an effective wave vector @xmath11 for the `` effective '' two - level transition @xmath12 @xcite . +
this article is organized as follows . in section 2
we introduce the model for the evolution of a trapped ion during the repumping pulse in a raman transition , and we evaluate the average shift and variance of the ion energy at the end of the pulse . in section 3
we extend our analysis to cases where the channels of decay are multiple . in section 4
we draw some conclusions , and in the appendix we report the details of our calculations .
we consider a three level atom as in fig . [
fig : scheme0 ] , whose internal levels are a ground state @xmath13 , stable or metastable state @xmath14 and excited state @xmath15 of radiative width @xmath16 ; @xmath17 , @xmath18 are dipole transitions , with respective probabilities of decay @xmath19 , @xmath20 , where @xmath21 .
a laser resonantly drives the transition @xmath18 with rabi frequency @xmath22 . in the following
we assume the wave vectors for both transitions to be equal to @xmath8 , which is a good approximation if , e.g. , @xmath14 and @xmath13 are hyperfine components of the ground state .
we study the ion motion in one - dimension . +
the master equation for the atomic density matrix @xmath23 is written as ( @xmath24 ) : @xmath25+l\rho_3 , \label{master0}\ ] ] where @xmath26 has the form : @xmath27 here , @xmath28 is the detuning of the laser on the @xmath29 transition , which we take to be zero , and @xmath6 is the frequency of the harmonic oscillator which traps the ion along the @xmath30-direction , with @xmath31 annihilation and creation operator , respectively .
the interaction of the ion with the laser light is described in the dipole approximation by the operator @xmath32 : @xmath33 with @xmath34 ( with @xmath35 ) dipole raising operator , @xmath36 its adjoint , and @xmath30 the position of the atom . in writing ( [ coherent1 ] ) , ( [ master0 ] )
we have applied the rotating wave approximation and we have moved to the inertial frame rotating at the laser frequency . finally , the relaxation super operator has the form @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the dipole pattern of the spontaneous emission , which we take @xmath39 .
+ in the limit @xmath40 we can eliminate the excited state @xmath2 in second order perturbation theory @xcite , and reduce the three - level scheme to a two level one , with excited state @xmath14 and linewidth @xmath41 @xcite . in the limit @xmath42 the master equation for the density matrix @xmath43 , projection of @xmath23 on the subspace @xmath44 ,
can be rewritten as @xcite : @xmath45+\gamma_e\left[j_e\rho + j_g\rho\right ] , \label{master1}\ ] ] with @xmath46 effective hamiltonian @xmath47 , @xmath48 jump operators , defined as : where @xmath50 and where @xmath51 the solution of eq .
( [ master1 ] ) can be written as follows @xcite : @xmath52 with @xmath53 , and @xmath54 is the propagator for the effective hamiltonian : @xmath55 in eq .
( [ sol ] ) the successive contributions to the multiple scattering event are singled out : the first term on the rhs corresponds to the case in which at time @xmath56 no spontaneous decay has occurred . the second term describes a single scattering event , and the @xmath57-th term @xmath58 scattering events .
the trace of each term corresponds to the probability associated with each event , and we can thus interpret eq .
( [ sol ] ) as the sum over all the possible paths of the scattering event weighted by their respective probabilities . at @xmath59 , @xmath60 ,
the atom is in @xmath0 and @xmath61 . for a pulse of duration @xmath62 we
can replace @xmath56 by @xmath63 in the integrals of eq .
( [ sol ] ) and assume that the atom has been scattered into @xmath0 at the end of the pulse .
now , each term on the rhs of eq .
( [ sol ] ) corresponds to the path associated with a certain number of scattering events into @xmath1 before the atom is finally scattered into @xmath0 . through ( [ sol ] )
we can evaluate the shift and the variance of the energy distribution at the end of the repumping pulse , which are defined as : @xmath64 where @xmath65 and @xmath66 is the initial motional energy of the atom . for simplifying the form of the discussion presented below , we rewrite the operator @xmath67 as follows : @xmath68 where @xmath69 , @xmath70 are defined as : @xmath71|l\rangle\langle l|,&\\ & \hat{j}\rho=\sum_l\sum_{l_1,l_1\neq l } and where @xmath72 is the basis of eigenstates of the harmonic oscillator . for @xmath73 , with @xmath74 initial distribution over the motional states , and according to eq .
( [ sol ] ) the steady state distribution has the form : @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the final distribution over the motional states .
the first term in the rhs of ( [ sol1 ] ) is the sum over all paths from @xmath1 into @xmath0 , where after each jump the density operator is diagonal in the basis @xmath72 , whereas the second term contains all other paths .
these latter terms can be neglected @xcite , and for @xmath77 the following relation holds : @xmath78|s\rangle = d_n(s ) .
\label{distri}\ ] ] here , @xmath79 is the probability for the atom to be found in the state @xmath80 at @xmath59 , given the initial state @xmath81 at @xmath82 . using the explicit form ( [ tilde ] ) of @xmath69 in ( [ distri ] ) , @xmath79 has the form : @xmath83 where we have used the relation @xmath84 , with @xmath85 size of the ground state of the harmonic oscillator . substituting ( [ explicit ] ) into eqs .
( [ shift0 ] ) , ( [ diff0 ] ) , and applying the commutation properties of @xmath31 [ see the appendix ] , we find : @xmath86 , \label{width1 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath87 is the lamb - dicke parameter . equation ( [ center1 ] ) represents the average shift to the vibrational energy at the end of the repumping pulse . for @xmath88
it corresponds to the average recoil energy @xmath89 associated with one incoherent raman scattering into @xmath0 . in this case , the second term in the rhs of eq .
( [ width1 ] ) vanishes , and eqs .
( [ center1 ] ) , ( [ width1 ] ) describe the scattering of one photon of wave vector @xmath90 on the effective two - level transition @xmath91 .
similarly for @xmath92 an effective wave vector @xmath11 can be defined for the incoherent scattering on the two - level transition @xmath91 , which has the form @xmath93 thus , @xmath94 describes the average mechanical effect on the ion resulting from the multiple scattering of photons during the repumping pulse in a raman transition with branching ratio @xmath95 : this description is valid in the limit in which we may neglect the second term in the rhs of ( [ width1 ] ) , _ i.e. _ for @xmath20 and/or @xmath96 sufficiently small . in fig .
2 the first term of rhs of eq .
( [ width1 ] ) is compared with the complete expression for @xmath97 , for different values of the lamb - dicke parameter and as a function of @xmath20 . here
, we see that @xmath11 characterizes the scattering process for almost any branching ratio in the lamb - dicke regime , whereas for @xmath98 an appreciable difference is already visible at @xmath99 . + from ( [ eta_eff ] )
we can define the effective lamb - dicke parameter @xmath100 describing an incoherent scattering into the state @xmath0 .
this parameter provides an immediate estimate of the effect of the branching ratio on cooling . for @xmath101 , if @xmath102 the system is still in the lamb - dicke regime once it has been finally scattered into @xmath0 .
furthermore , the coarse - grained dynamics of the system can be described by a rate equation for the motional states @xmath103 projected onto @xmath0 , where the rate of cooling ( heating ) is the real part of the sum of two terms : one corresponding to the component of the fluctuation spectrum of the dipole force at frequency @xmath6 ( @xmath104 ) , the other to the diffusion coefficient due to spontaneous emission from the excited state @xcite .
this latter term is proportional to the squared lamb - dicke parameter for the incoherent scattering , and thus in our case to @xmath105 . from the well - known solution of the rate equation @xcite ,
the diffusion term affects the steady state average vibrational number @xmath106 , which is proportional to the diffusion coefficient . + outside the lamb - dicke regime , when @xmath107 is comparable to , or larger than , @xmath6 , there are no estabilished ground - state laser - cooling techniques for trapped atoms . here
, we discuss our result in connection to the proposal in @xcite . there , a cooling scheme similar to raman sideband cooling has been presented , where pulses which pump the atoms to the ground state alternate with pulses confining the atoms to a limited region of motional energy .
these confinement pulses have two - photon detuning @xmath108 to the red of the two - photon resonance frequency , where @xmath109 .
then , the presence of a branching ratio must be taken into account by choosing @xmath110 . in this regime ,
pulses which efficiently counteract the average kick @xmath111 can be designed , provided that the following condition is fulfilled : @xmath112 where @xmath113 is the projection on @xmath30 of the two - photon wave vector of the coherent pulse . for two counterpropagating beams parallel to @xmath30 , @xmath114 and ( [ valid ] )
is fulfilled for @xmath115 , i.e. up to branching ratios @xmath116 . finally , outside the lamb - dicke regime the second term in the rhs of eq .
( [ width1 ] ) can not be neglected .
hence , the diffusion is larger , and the efficiency of cooling may decrease dramatically as @xmath20 increases .
in the following , we show that the average heating associated with the repumping pulse in multilevel - schemes can be described in the same way as discussed in the previous sections .
+ let us consider the level - scheme of fig .
3(a ) , where we have added to the scheme of fig .
1 a further channel of decay from @xmath2 into the stable or metastable state @xmath117 , with probability of decay @xmath118 such that @xmath119 , where @xmath120 , @xmath121 are the probability of decay onto @xmath122 , respectively .
a laser resonantly drives the transition @xmath123 with rabi frequency @xmath124 . for @xmath125
the state @xmath2 can be adiabatically eliminated from the equations of motion . in this limit
the master equation aquires the form @xmath126\\ & & + p_e'\gamma^{\prime}j_e\rho + p_1\gamma^{\prime}j_1\rho + p_g'\gamma^{\prime}j_g\rho,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath127 , with @xmath128 .
the effective hamiltonian is now : @xmath129 with @xmath130 .
the solution at @xmath59 can be written as : @xmath131 hence , the shift and variance have the form evaluated in eqs .
( [ center1 ] ) , ( [ width1 ] ) where now the probability @xmath19 , @xmath20 are defined as @xmath132 , @xmath133 ( @xmath21 ) . in a similar way we have evaluated these quantities for schemes like the one shown in fig .
3(b ) , where a second excited state @xmath134 is coupled to @xmath1 via the same recycling laser tuned on the transition @xmath135 . for simplifying the treatment ,
we assume that a fourth laser resonantly drives the transition @xmath136 with rabi frequency @xmath137 ( grey arrow in fig .
3(b ) ) . thus , for low saturation eq .
( [ mastermany ] ) describes the dynamics , where now @xmath138 ( @xmath139 ) , with @xmath140 being the rate of scattering through the excited state @xmath141 ( @xmath142 ) . assuming that @xmath137 is such that @xmath143 , the solution in eqs .
( [ center1 ] ) , ( [ width1 ] ) applies to this case too , where now @xmath20 is defined as : @xmath144 and the probability @xmath19 of decaying into @xmath0 is @xmath145 .
+ the result ( [ result_prob ] ) shows that the total heating is minimum for @xmath146 , which can be obtained by choosing properly the laser intensity of the repumping lasers , or simply by removing degeneracies in the zeeman multiplet , for example with the help of a magnetic field .
we have studied the motional heating associated with a finite branching ratio and in the presence of multiple decay and excitation channels at the end of a repumping pulse in raman sideband cooling .
the first and second moments of the final energy distribution has been evaluated analytically , and the effect of the branching ratio has been singled out .
we have shown that in a certain range of parameters the diffusion can be described with an effective wave vector @xmath11 , corresponding to an effective lamb
dicke parameter @xmath147 for the incoherent scattering on the two - level transition @xmath12 .
finally , on the basis of this result we have discussed the efficiency of raman sideband cooling and of a recent proposal of ground - state cooling outside the lamb - dicke regime @xcite . +
analogous sum rules and considerations can be applied to raman cooling for free atoms @xcite . in that case
the calculations are much simpler , since the total momentum of radiation and atom is a conserved quantity in the scattering event .
+ in general , these results can be applied to cooling schemes in multilevel atoms .
the authors acknowledge many stimulating discussions with s. khler and v. ludsteck . g.m .
thanks j.i .
cirac , j. eschner and p. lambropoulos for many stimulating discussions .
this work is supported in parts by the european commission within the tmr - networks erb - fmrx - ct96 - 0087 and erb - fmrx - ct96 - 0077 .
using ( [ distri ] ) , we rewrite ( [ shift0 ] ) and ( [ diff0 ] ) as : the sum over @xmath151 can be contracted by observing that @xmath152 .
then , using the commutation properties of the bosonic operators @xmath153 and the closure relation for the eigenstates of the harmonic oscillator , eq .
( [ b ] ) takes the form : c. monroe , d.m .
meekhof , b.e .
king , s.r .
jefferts , w.m .
itano , d.j .
wineland , and p. gould , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 4011 ( 1995 ) ; h. perrin , a. kuhn , i. bouchoule , c. salomon , europhys
42 * , 395 ( 1998 ) ; s.e .
hamann , d.l .
haycock , g. klose , p.h .
pax , i.h .
deutsch , and p.s .
jessen , phys .
lett . * 80 * , 4149 ( 1998 ) ; v. vuletic , c. chin , a.j .
kerman , and s. chu , phys .
81 * , 5768 ( 1998 ) .
r. dum , p. zoller , and h. ritsch , phys . rev .
a * 45 * , 4879 ( 1992 ) .
it can be shown that the terms in eq .
( [ sol ] ) containing at some time @xmath159 coherences between vibrational states are of order @xmath160 with respect to the terms that contain the populations only .
this condition alone would not be sufficient , as the number of terms of @xmath161 corresponding to @xmath57 scattering events increases with @xmath57 .
however , these term are oscillating functions of the intermediate vibrational states , and thus their sum is much smaller than the first term of ( [ distri ] ) .
m. kasevich and s. chu , phys .
* 69 * , 1741 ( 1992 ) ; n. davidson , h.j .
less , m. kasevich , and s. chu , phys .
72 * , 3158 ( 1994 ) ; j. reichel , o. morice , g.m .
tino , and c. salomon , europhys . lett .
* 28 * , 477 ( 1994 ) .
( a ) level scheme with @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath117 , stable or metastable states , @xmath2 excited state of radiative width @xmath16 and probability of decaying in the three ground states @xmath121 , @xmath120 and @xmath118 , respectively .
two lasers couple @xmath1 and @xmath117 to @xmath2 ; ( b ) level scheme as in ( a ) with the addition of the excited state @xmath134 with decay probability on @xmath117 , @xmath1 equal to @xmath162 , @xmath163 , respectively , @xmath164 .
two lasers couple @xmath1 and @xmath117 to @xmath134 .
|
we have investigated the efficiency of pulsed raman sideband cooling in the presence of multiple decay and excitation channels . by applying sum rules we identify parameter regimes in which multiple scattering of photons can be described by an effective wave vector . using this method we determine the rate of heating caused by optical pumping inside and outside the lamb - dicke regime . on this basis
we discuss also the efficiency of a recently proposed scheme for ground - state cooling outside the lamb - dicke regime [ g. morigi , j.i .
cirac , m. lewenstein , and p. zoller , europhys . lett . * 39 * , 13 ( 1997 ) ] .
|
infrared spectroscopy provides a crucial means in the identification of interstellar dust compositions .
recent infrared satellite observations by the _ infrared telescope in space _ ( _ irts _ ; * ? ? ?
* ) and the _ infrared space observatory _ ( _ iso _ ; * ? ? ?
* ) have revealed several new dust features in the diffuse emission , indicating the presence of new dust components in the interstellar medium @xcite .
observations by _ iso _ also clearly show the presence of crystalline silicates around young and evolved stars for the first time @xcite , while it is not yet certain whether crystalline silicates exist commonly in interstellar space . in the present paper
we report the observations of active star - forming regions , the carina nebula and the sharpless 171 ( s171 ) region with the long - wavelength spectrometer ( lws ; * ? ? ?
* ) on board _ iso _ and the detection of far - infrared features around 65@xmath0 m and 100@xmath0 m in the diffuse emission .
the carina nebula is one of the most active regions on the galactic plane and known to contain a number of early - type stars @xcite .
the s171 region is a typical region and molecular cloud complex @xcite .
both regions are supposed to represent the characteristics of active regions in the galaxy .
possible carriers of the two detected features are discussed and we investigate the possibility that carbon onion grains of curved graphitic shells are the carrier for the broad interstellar 100@xmath0 m feature .
the central @xmath1 portion of the carina nebula was observed by two - dimensional raster scans with the lws full grating scan mode and the far - infrared spectra for 43197@xmath0 m were obtained for 132 positions ( for details of the observations , see * ? ? ?
a one - dimensional scan was made for 24 positions on a line from the heating source to the molecular cloud region in s171 with the same lws observing mode @xcite .
the observed area of the both objects includes ionized regions and molecular clouds and the spectra sample the diffuse emission from the interstellar matter rather than the emission from point - like sources .
the off - line processing data of version 10.1 ( olp 10.1 ) provided by the iso archival data center were used in the present study .
the spectra were defringed , converted into the surface brightness , and the extended source correction was applied by the iso spectral analysis package ( isap ) software .
the beam size and the correction factors were taken from the latest lws handbook @xcite
. there are gaps in the spectra between the detector channels , which can be ascribed to the uncertainties either in the responsivity , in the dark current , or in the spatial brightness distribution in the beam .
figure [ fig1 ] shows examples of the obtained original spectra of the two regions , while figure [ fig2 ] indicates their stitched spectra to correct the gaps .
both spectra were taken at the interface regions between the molecular cloud and ionized gas , where the far - infrared intensity is sufficiently large to investigate dust features .
the stitched spectra are made by scaling each detector signal because the observed regions are bright enough that the uncertainty in the dark current should be less significant than those in the responsivity or in the spatial brightness distribution . as can be seen in figure [ fig1 ] ,
the amount of the gaps is small ( @xmath2 5% ) except for the three longest channels ( @xmath3@xmath0 m ) , where 1020% scaling is necessary to correct the gaps .
the presence of a relatively narrow band feature at 65@xmath0 m is seen even in the unstitched spectra , particularly in s171 . in the spectrum of the carina nebula
, the appearance of this feature is slightly disturbed by the higher levels of the adjacent channel spectra ( sw2 and sw4 ) relative to the level of the sw3 channel , but it can still be seen in the individual spectrum of the sw3 channel . a broad feature centered around 100@xmath0 m is also noticeable in the unstitched spectrum of s171 .
the slope of the continuum starts to become flatter around the boundary between the sw4 and sw5 channels , indicating a feature starting around 80@xmath0 m . in the unstitched spectrum of the carina nebula ,
the gap between the sw4 and sw5 channels makes the feature less obvious , but the change in the slope in the sw5 channel can still be seen .
the stitched spectrum clearly indicates the presence of the feature .
however there is no appreciable abrupt change in the slope at longer wavelengths and the longer wavelength end of the feature is difficult to estimate from these spectra .
neither spurious features have been reported nor the relative spectral response functions have the corresponding features in these spectral ranges @xcite .
we will discuss possible underlying continua to confirm the presence of the feature and estimate the feature profile in next section .
similar features are seen at about a half of the observed positions both in the carina and s171 regions .
since these features are seen in a wide area of the interstellar medium , the band carriers must be ubiquitous species in interstellar space .
@xcite reported the presence of 65@xmath0 m and 90@xmath0
m features in the spectra of evolved stars .
figure [ fig3]a shows a spectrum of ngc6302 taken from the iso archival data center for comparison ( cf . * ? ? ?
the continuum emission indicates a much higher temperature than those in figure [ fig2 ] and the features are weakly seen on the steep continuum . to see the features more clearly ,
the flux is multiplied by the square of the wavelength ( @xmath4 ) and plotted in figure [ fig3]b .
the interstellar 65@xmath0 m feature seems very similar to that detected in evolved stars .
the peak of the 65@xmath0 m feature is located obviously longer than [ ] 63@xmath0 m line ( fig .
[ fig4 ] ; see also fig .
[ fig6 ] ) and thus is not compatible with the crystalline ice band at 62@xmath0 m @xcite .
@xcite have proposed a ca - bearing crystalline silicate , diopside ( camgsi@xmath5o@xmath6 ) , as a possible carrier of the 65@xmath0 m feature in evolved stars .
cryogenic measurements of the optical properties of diopside support the identification @xcite .
figure [ fig4 ] shows a comparison of the observed spectra with the laboratory data .
the best fit continua described in next subsection are also plotted .
the laboratory spectrum shows a narrower profile than those observed and other species , such as water ice and dolomite ( camg(co@xmath7)@xmath5 ) , have been suggested to contribute also to the 65@xmath0 m band emission @xcite .
diopside has a weak feature also at 44.5@xmath0 m .
the lws detector in this spectral range ( sw1 ) is less sensitive and known to have strong hysteresis . in the present spectra a band feature is seen around 45@xmath0 m both in the upward and downward scans of both spectra , suggesting the presence of the 45@xmath0 m feature .
however large noises in this spectral range preclude the firm detection and further observations are needed to confirm the feature .
band features of other crystalline minerals , such as the 69@xmath0 m band of forsterite seen in ngc6302 , are not seen in the present lws spectra .
diopside also has strong features in 3040@xmath0 m .
the carina nebula was observed by short - wavelength spectrometer ( sws ; * ? ? ?
* ) and the spectra of 2.345@xmath0 m have been obtained .
however the sws spectra were not taken at the same positions as the lws spectrum and thus the direct examination is difficult .
the sws spectra are dominated by strong continuum and do not clearly show any solid bands except for the broad 22@xmath0 m feature @xcite .
if the identification of the interstellar 65@xmath0 m with diopside is correct , this is the first detection of a crystalline silicate in the diffuse interstellar medium .
efficient destruction of dust grains by interstellar shocks suggests that a large fraction of interstellar dust must be formed in interstellar space in addition to those supplied from stars @xcite .
diopside is a high - temperature condensate and may survive harsh conditions .
calcium is a less abundant element than magnesium or silicon , but it is highly depleted in the gas phase of the interstellar medium @xcite
. therefore the presence of ca - containing dust should not be surprising in interstellar space .
based on the measured band strength of diopside @xcite and the observed strength relative to the continuum , we roughly estimate that 510% of solar abundance calcium in diopside grains is sufficient to account for the observed band emission if we take the commonly used mass absorption coefficient of 50 @xmath8g@xmath9 for the continuum emission at 100@xmath0 m @xcite . @xcite
have suggested that the crystallinity of the silicates is less than 12% in the interstellar medium based on the observations of protostars . since the feature seen around 100@xmath0 m
is quite broad and weak , we investigate several cases for the underlying continuum to examine the presence of the broad 100@xmath0 m feature in detail and to make a rough estimate of the 100@xmath0 m feature profile . in the estimate of the continuum
we assume the baseline positions to be at 5560@xmath0 m , 7080@xmath0 m , and 140190@xmath0 m or 120190@xmath0 m ( see below ) and we try to fit the observed spectra in these ranges with the model continuum as much as possible .
because the shortest spectral range ( 5560@xmath0 m ) has higher noises , less weight is put on this range in the fitting .
we first adopt the dust model with the power - law emissivity ( @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is a constant ) for the continuum emission .
we found that the single - temperature graybody model can not fit the entire baseline positions satisfactorily .
particularly the model always gives a higher flux at long wavelengths than the observed spectra .
this discrepancy can not be solved by increasing @xmath11 because then the model would provide unnecessarily large fluxes at shorter wavelengths . introducing a second component with a low temperature
improves the fit drastically .
the model of @xmath12 both for warm and cold grains gives reasonable fits , but still has slightly larger fluxes at longest wavelengths ( @xmath13@xmath0 m ) than the observed spectra .
increase of @xmath11 from 2 to unrealistically large 3 for the cold grains does not improve the fit appreciably .
the power - law emissivity model has a spectral dependence of @xmath14 in the rayleigh - jeans regime .
the discrepancy in the fit at longest wavelengths comes from the fact that the observed spectra have a gradually changing power - law index .
the brightness distribution within the lws beam affects the global shape of the spectrum .
as shown in figure [ fig1 ] the unstitched spectra have relatively large gaps in longer wavelengths ( @xmath15@xmath0 m ) , suggesting an uncertainty associated with the slope in this spectral range .
it also suggests a difficulty in defining the assumed baseline in the longer wavelengths . in the following we present two cases for the baseline ; one with 140190@xmath0 m ( case a ) and 120190@xmath0 m ( case b ) to examine the effect of the assumed baseline and as a more realistic model we examine the astronomical silicate and graphite grain model @xcite
the silicate and graphite grains both have approximately a power - law emissivity of @xmath16 in the far - infrared and this model provides slightly better fits than the power - law emissivity model of @xmath17 .
we present the results of the silicate - graphite model in the following .
we assume different single temperatures for each of the astronomical silicate and graphite grains and search for the best fit temperatures .
the observed regions may contain various temperature components of various dust grains and thus these fits are a simple approximation for the underlying continuum . in figure [ fig2 ]
the best fit results are plotted together with the observed spectra .
the dotted lines indicate the results for the case a baseline , which fit the observed spectra reasonably well even in the longest wavelengths .
they overlap mostly with the observed spectra for @xmath18@xmath0 m in the plot .
the dashed lines show those for the case b baseline , which have obviously higher fluxes at longest wavelengths ( @xmath13@xmath0 m ) than the observed spectra .
both cases clearly indicate the presence of an excess feature starting around 80@xmath0 m .
the slope change around 80@xmath0 m is steep and can not be accounted for by extra graybodies .
the similarity of the excess profile in two different regions supports the presence of the feature and suggests the common origin .
@xcite have attributed the 90@xmath0 m feature in evolved stars to calcite ( caco@xmath7 ) , a carbonate mineral . in figure
[ fig3]b we also plot a single - temperature graybody as a simple reference continuum .
comparison with figure [ fig2 ] indicates that the 90@xmath0 m feature in ngc6302 is narrower than the interstellar 100@xmath0 m feature .
the spectrum of ngc6302 shows a clear slope change around 100@xmath0 m , which indicates the longer wavelength edge of the feature .
in contrast , the interstellar spectra do not show the clear change in the slope and suggest that the feature is extended to longer wavelengths than the 90@xmath0 m feature .
the longer wavelength edge of the interstellar feature can not be well determined .
although the exact peak position and width of the feature depend on the assumed continuum and the location of the baseline , the interstellar 100@xmath0 m feature seems to be shifted to longer wavelengths and have a wider width than the 90@xmath0 m feature seen in evolved stars .
while carbonate grains are a likely candidate for the 90@xmath0 m emission around evolved stars and may partly contribute to the interstellar 100@xmath0 m feature , we examine the possibility of alternative species which has a broad feature around 100@xmath0 m for the band carrier in the diffuse emission . in the following we investigate whether carbon onion grains consisting of concentric curved graphitic sheets @xcite can account for the observed broad 100@xmath0 m feature or not .
graphite is an anisotropic material and has different optical properties in the directions parallel and perpendicular to the c - axis ( the c - axis is perpendicular to the graphitic plane ) .
it has an interband transition around 80@xmath0 m in the direction perpendicular to the c - axis @xcite .
the emission efficiency of graphite spheres can be calculated by the so - called
approximation @xcite , in which the efficiencies in the perpendicular and parallel to the c - axis are averaged with the weight of and , respectively .
this approximation is valid in the small particle limit if the sphere consists of layered graphitic sheets and the optical properties in both directions are independent . in the graphite sphere ,
the emission efficiency in the direction parallel to the c - axis is much larger than that in the direction perpendicular to the axis in the far - infrared region .
therefore the interband transition feature mentioned above is not visible in the averaged efficiency @xcite . in carbon onions , on the other hand , the graphitic layer is curved and approximately constitutes closed shells .
thus the optical properties in the both directions should be mutually coupled and the interband feature can become visible in the emission efficiency of carbon onion grains . figure [ fig5 ] shows the emission efficiency factors divided by the grain radius for a graphite sphere and a carbon onion grain under the assumption that the grain radius is much smaller than the wavelengths in question . here
the dielectric constants of graphite in the directions parallel and perpendicular to the c - axis at room temperature measurements are adopted in the calculations ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* see below for discussion ) .
the efficiency for the carbon onion is calculated by the formulation by henrard et al .
( 1993 ) and is assumed to have a central cavity of 0.7 in radius relative to the particle size .
the appearance of the feature is insensitive to the size of the cavity .
a broad feature around 100@xmath0 m is seen in the emission efficiency of the graphite sphere in the direction perpendicular to the c - axis , but it is hardly seen in the averaged efficiency . on the other hand ,
the far - infrared feature is evident in the emission efficiency of carbon onion particles .
figure [ fig6 ] shows a comparison of the observed feature with that of carbon onion grains . to make the comparison easy the observed spectra
are divided by the assumed continuum , while the efficiency of the carbon onion is divided by @xmath19 .
two lines in the upper two panels indicate the effect of the assumed continuum .
carbon onion grains show a similar broad feature to that observed in the diffuse interstellar emission , but details of the profile do not match perfectly . taking account of the uncertainties in the shape of the underlying continuum and the optical properties of carbon onions ( see below ) , the similarity of the band feature suggests that carbon onions are a possible carrier of the interstellar 100@xmath0 m feature .
the 100@xmath0 m feature of carbon onions results from the surface resonance of small particles @xcite and appears near the wavelength where the real part of the dielectric constants in the perpendicular direction just becomes below zero .
the exact position and profile of the feature thus depend on the adopted dielectric constants .
while the electronic structure of carbon onions has been suggested to not differ significantly from that of graphite @xcite , the contribution of free electrons , which dominates in the far - infrared regions , may be different .
in fact , measurements of electron spin resonance and electron energy - loss spectroscopy suggest that @xmath20 electrons in carbon onions are mostly localized in small domains @xcite
. the localization of @xmath20 electron will decrease the contribution of free electrons , shifting the surface mode to wavelengths longer than 100@xmath0 m .
we surmise that the shift can be more than 10@xmath0 m .
but it is difficult to estimate the possible range of the shift because the behavior of free electrons depends also on the temperature and the strength of the interband transition in carbon onions could also be affected by the localization .
the @xmath20 electron localization , the temperature dependence , and the possible change in the interband transition strength should affect the optical properties of carbon onions in the far - infrared .
the match seen in figure [ fig6 ] may be just a coincidence in this sense .
the present calculation suggests that the observed band feature can be accounted for if carbon onion grains contribute to 2030% of the far - infrared emission .
carbon is an abundant element , but the exact form of carbon dust in the interstellar medium is not yet clear ( e.g. * ? ? ?
carbon onions are a likely form other than graphite or amorphous carbon in addition to small aromatic particles or large molecules whose presence has been confirmed by the infrared emission bands in the diffuse interstellar radiation @xcite .
carbon onions have recently attracted attentions as a new form of carbon material following the discovery of fullerens and their family . in astronomy , they are suggested to be formed in interstellar processes @xcite and the harsh conditions accompanying interstellar dust formation are favorable for the formation of onions @xcite .
they have been proposed as a likely candidate for the interstellar 220 nm extinction hump @xcite .
the quenched carbonaceous composite ( qcc ) , which shows a feature similar to the interstellar 220 nm hump @xcite , has also been shown to contain graphitic shell structures @xcite .
it is not unexpected that the band features of carbon onions , if exist , also appear in the infrared region . in the present paper
we simply propose the possibility that the interband feature of graphite in the far - infrared could appear in the emissivity spectrum of particles consisting of curved graphitic sheets and the observed broad interstellar feature around 100@xmath0 m may be accounted for by carbon onion grains .
experimental work is definitely needed for further investigations .
in the present paper we reported the detection of two far - infrared features at 65@xmath0 m and 100@xmath0 m in the diffuse infrared emission .
the 65@xmath0 m band can reasonably be attributed to the ca - rich silicate , diopside .
if this identification is correct , this is the first detection of a crystalline silicate feature in the interstellar diffuse emission .
the interstellar 100@xmath0 m feature seems to be broader and peaked at longer wavelengths than the calcite feature seen in evolved stars although the precise estimate of the band profile is difficult . as a possible band carrier
we investigate the possibility that the feature originates from carbon onion grains . while the observed feature may be accounted for by carbon onion grains if the assumed optical properties are adequate , the appearance of the feature is sensitive to the electronic structure of carbon onions .
the origin of the interstellar 100@xmath0 m feature must be investigated in further experimental studies .
the authors thank k. kawara , y. satoh , t. tanab , h. okuda , t. tsuji , h. shibai , and other members of the japanese iso group for their continuous help and support .
we also thank s. tomita and s. hayashi for stimulating discussions on the optical properties of carbon onions and h. chihara and c. koike for providing us the far - infrared data of diopside and calcite . this work was supported in part by grant - in - aids for scientific research from the japan society of promotion of science ( jsps ) .
1982 , absorption and scattering of light by small particles ( new york : wiley ) chan , k .- w . , & onaka , t. 2000 , , 533 , l33 chihara , h. , koike , c. , & tsuchiyama , a. 2001 , , 53 , 243 clegg , p. , et al .
1996 , , 315 , l38 cohen , m. , barlow , m. j. , sylvester , r. j. , liu , x .- w . ,
cox , p. , lim , t. , schmitt , b. , & speck , a. k. 1999 , , 513 , l135 de graauw , t. , et al .
1996 , , 315 , l49 demyk , k. , jones , a. p. , dartois , e. , cox , p. , & dhendecourt , l. 1999 , , 349 , 267 draine , b. t. , & lee , h .- m . 1984 , 285 , 89 draine , b. t. , & malhotra , s. 1993 , , 414 , 632 feinstein , a. 1995 , rev .
astrofis . , 2 , 57 gry , c. , et al .
2002 , iso handbook ; volume iv : lws the long - wavelength spectrometer , version 2.0 ( esa ) henrard , l. , lucas , a. a. , & lambin , ph .
1993 , , 406 , 92 henrard , l. , lambin , ph . , & lucas , a. a. 1997 , , 487 , 719 hildebrand , r. h. 1983 , , 24 , 267 jones , a. p. , tielens , a. g. g. m. , & hollenbach , d. j. 1996 , , 469 , 740 kemper , f. , jger , c. , waters , l. b. f. m. , henning , th . , molster , f. j. , barlow , m. j. , lim , t. , & de koter , a. 2002 , , 415 , 295 kessler , m. f. , et al .
1996 , , 315 , l27 koike , c. , et al .
2000 , , 363 , 1115 mattila , k , lemke , d. , haikala , l. k. , laureijs , r. j. , leger , a. , lehtinen , k. , leinert , c. , & mezger , p. g. 1996 , , 315 , l353 mizutani , m. , onaka , t. , & shibai , h. 2002 , , 382 , 610 molinari , s. , ceccarelli , c. , white , g. j. , saraceno , p. , nisini , b. , giannini , t. , & caux , e. 1999 , , 521 , l71 molster , f. j. , lim , t. l. , sylvester , r. j. , waters , l. b. f. m. , barlow , m. j. , beintema , d. a. , cohen , m. , cox , p. , & schmitt , b. 2001 , , 372 , 165 molster , f. j. , waters , l. b. f. m. , & tielens , a. g. g. m. 2002 , , 382 , 222 murakami , h. , et al .
1996 , , 48 , l41 nuth , j. 1985 , , 318 , 166 okada , y. , onaka , t. , shibai , h. & doi , y. 2002 , , submitted onaka , t. , yamamura , i. , tanab , t. , roellig , t. l. , & yuen , l. 1996 , , 48 , l59 philipp , h. r. 1977 , , 16 , 2896 pichler , t. , knupfer , m. , golden , m. s. , fink , j. , & cabioch , t. 2001 , , 63 , 155415 sakata , a. , wada , s. , okutsu , y. , shintani , h. , & nakada , y. 1983 , , 301 , 493 savage , b. d. , & sembach , k. r. 1996 , , 34 , 279 smith , r. g. , robinson , g. , hyland , a. r. , & carpenter , g. l. 1994 , , 271 , 481 tomita , s. , sakurai , m. , ohta , h. , & hayashi , s. 2001 , , 114 , 7477 ugarte , d. 1992 , , 359 , 707 ugarte , d. 1995 , , 443 , l85 venghaus , h. 1977 , phys .
solidi ( b ) , 81 , 221 wada , s. , kaito , c. , kitamura , s. , ono , h. , & tokunaga , t. a. 1999 , , 345 , 259 waelkens , c. , et al .
1996 , , 315 , l245 walborn , n. r. 1995 , rev .
, 2 , 51 waters , l. b. f. m. , et al .
1996 , , 315 , l361 yang , j. , & fukui , y. 1992 , , 386 , 618
|
we report the detection of a feature at 65@xmath0 m and a broad feature around 100@xmath0 m in the far - infrared spectra of the diffuse emission from two active star - forming regions , and .
the features are seen in the spectra over a wide area of the observed regions , indicating that the carriers are fairly ubiquitous species in the interstellar medium .
a similar 65@xmath0 m feature has been detected in evolved stars and attributed to diopside , a ca - bearing crystalline silicate .
the present observations indicate the first detection of a crystalline silicate in the interstellar medium if this identification holds true also for the interstellar feature . a similar broad feature around 90@xmath0 m reported in the spectra of evolved stars has been attributed to calcite , a ca - bearing carbonate mineral .
the interstellar feature seems to be shifted to longer wavelengths and have a broader width although the precise estimate of the feature profile is difficult . as a carrier for the interstellar 100@xmath0 m feature ,
we investigate the possibility that the feature originates from carbon onions , grains consisting of curved graphitic shells .
because of the curved graphitic sheet structure , the optical properties in the direction parallel to the graphitic plane interacts with those in the vertical direction in carbon onion grains .
this effect enhances the interband transition feature in the direction parallel to the graphitic plane in carbon onions , which is suppressed in graphite particles .
simple calculations suggest that carbon onion grains are a likely candidate for the observed 100@xmath0 m feature carrier , but the appearance of the feature is sensitive to the assumed optical properties .
|
processes of meson electroproduction have played an important role in studying the structure and properties of matter ( see , _ e.g. _ review @xcite ) . in the past few years , however , reactions with production of dileptons in hadron - hadron and hadron - nucleus collisions have drawn much attention @xcite . in these reactions
virtual photons , which materialize as dileptons ( _ e.g. _ , the @xmath2 pair ) , carry unique information on properties of matter because the processes in which the particle structure is formed proceed in the timelike region of the `` mass '' ( @xmath3 ) of the virtual photon . therefore , further investigation of these reactions is necessary and promising in acquisition of new and perhaps unexpected information about the form factors of hadrons and nuclei . the inverse pion electroproduction ( ipe ) , @xmath1 , ( or dileptonproduction ) , being for a long time the only source of information on the nucleon electromagnetic structure in the timelike region , has been investigated both theoretically @xcite and experimentally @xcite since the beginning of the 1960s . in refs .
@xcite , we worked out the method of extracting the pion and nucleon electromagnetic form factors from ipe at low energies .
this method has been successfully applied in the analysis of experimental data on the nucleon and @xmath4c and @xmath5li nuclei @xcite and values of the form factors were obtained for the first time in the timelike region of @xmath3 ranging from 0.05 to 0.22 ( gev / c)@xmath6 . in refs .
@xcite , the authors proposed to use ipe at intermediate ( above @xmath7 resonances ) energies and small @xmath8 to study the nucleon electromagnetic structure and justified it up to @xmath9 .
though experimental data @xcite on the @xmath10 process are now available , there still remains a wide range of @xmath3 ( up to @xmath11 ) , where the form factors can not be measured directly in these experiments . on the other hand ,
the intense pion beams available now enable one to perform more detailed experiments on ipe aimed at both extracting the hadron structure and carrying out a multipole analysis similar to those for photoproduction and electroproduction ( see,_e.g .
_ , @xcite ) .
such experiments can address interesting topics .
for example , in the @xmath12 region it is challenging to verify the @xmath3 dependence of the color - magnetic - force contribution found in the constituent quark model @xcite .
it is , therefore , worth recalling the earlier discovered properties of the photoproduction , electroproduction , and ipe to consistently substantiate methods of studying the electromagnetic and weak structure of the nucleon on the basis of the ipe data in the first resonance region , and to provide new results of this analysis .
additional motive for studying ipe in the first resonance region is the possibility of investigating the nucleon weak structure by utilizing the same data as for the electromagnetic structure .
this possibility is based on the current algebra ( ca ) description and on the remarkable property of ipe . in the ipe process
the creation of the @xmath2 pairs of maximal mass ( at the `` quasithreshold '' ) is dominated by the born mechanism , whereas the rescattering - effect contributions are at the level of radiative corrections up to the total @xmath7 energy @xmath13 gev ( the `` quasithreshold theorem '' ) @xcite . due to this property ,
the threshold ca theorems for the pion electroproduction and photoproduction can be justified in the case of ipe up to the indicated energy @xcite .
this allows one to avoid threshold difficulties when using the ipe data ( unlike the electroproduction one ) for extracting the weak form factors of the nucleon .
furthermore , in the case of ipe there is no strong kinematic restriction inherent to the @xmath14 capture and no kinematic suppression of contributions of the induced pseudoscalar nucleon form factor to the cross sections of `` straight '' processes , such as @xmath15 , present because of multiplying by the lepton masses .
information on the pseudoscalar nucleon form factor @xmath16 , which is practically absent for the above reasons , is important because @xmath16 contains contributions of states with the pion quantum numbers and , therefore , it is related to the chiral symmetry breaking . this would enable us , _
e.g. _ , to test the goldberger treiman relation .
another aim of this paper is to draw attention of experimenters to the process @xmath1 as a natural and unique laboratory for investigating the hadron structure .
one could use these processes for determining the baryon resonance dynamics based on the study of the @xmath17 interference pattern @xcite .
on the other hand , investigation of the exclusive reactions @xmath18 in experiments with high - energy pions at large invariant mass of the dilepton and small squared momentum transfer to the nucleon could provide access to generalized parton distributions as suggested in @xcite .
this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii we give the basic formalism for the unified treatment of the reactions @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 . in sec .
iii we present our dispersion - relation model for unified description of these three reactions and compare the calculated results with experimental data .
to clearly explain our method , we choose a simple version of the model , which satisfactorily describes the data on the photoproduction and electroproduction . in sec .
iv , we outline the method of determining the nucleon electromagnetic form factors from low - energy ipe and discuss some results of its application to analysis of the ipe data on the nucleon .
section v is devoted to extracting the pseudoscalar nucleon form factor from the same ipe data , and interpretation of the results is given .
concluding remarks are presented in sec .
appendices present the relations between the amplitudes , derivation of the quasithreshold constraints for the multipole amplitudes on the basis of the principle of the first - class maximum analyticity , and explanation of the compensation effect .
we consider the reactions @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 in the framework of the unified model .
this approach is natural because in the one - photon approximation , due to the @xmath22-invariance , research into these three processes is related to a study of the process @xmath23 with the hadron current @xmath24 , where @xmath25 , @xmath26 , and @xmath27 correspond to the pion photoproduction , electroproduction , and ipe , respectively .
this allows us to predict peculiarities of the ipe dynamics on the basis of a rich experimental material on the electroproduction and photoproduction and to test the reliability of the unified model for these three processes .
the @xmath28-matrix element for the electroproduction in the one - photon approximation is @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the matrix element of the lepton electromagnetic current , @xmath31 ( @xmath32 ) , @xmath33 ( @xmath34 ) , and @xmath35 are the four - momenta of the initial ( final ) electron , nucleon , and final pion , respectively .
momentum of the virtual photon is @xmath36 ( @xmath37 for ipe ) , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 and @xmath40 are mandelstam variables .
conservation of the lepton and hadron electromagnetic currents implies @xmath41 . assuming the @xmath22-invariance , for the ipe process one must use the spinor @xmath42 instead of @xmath43 in the lepton current ( [ lept.current ] ) .
then @xmath44 is timelike , and @xmath45 is the range of @xmath3 values for fixed @xmath46 .
the hadron current @xmath24 can be expanded using the six independent covariant gauge - invariant structures @xmath47 @xcite : @xmath48 where @xmath49 with @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
the invariant amplitudes @xmath52 are free from kinematic constraints , but @xmath53 and @xmath54 have a kinematic pole at @xmath55 . the amplitudes @xmath54 and @xmath56 are absent in the photoproduction .
the matrix element ( [ j : covar.expantion ] ) can be expressed through the scalar c.m .
amplitudes @xmath57 where @xmath58 and @xmath59 are the pauli spinors , and @xmath60f_2 + i{\vec\sigma}\cdot{\tilde{\vec k}}({\tilde{\vec q}}\cdot{\vec \varepsilon } - { \tilde{\vec q}}\cdot{\tilde{\vec k}}{\tilde{\vec k}}\cdot{\vec \varepsilon})f_3+\nonumber\\ & & + i{\vec\sigma}\cdot{\tilde{\vec q}}\,({\tilde{\vec q}}\cdot{\vec \varepsilon } - { \tilde{\vec q}}\cdot{\tilde{\vec k}}{\tilde{\vec k}}\cdot{\vec \varepsilon}\,)f_4 + i{k^2\over k_0}{\vec \sigma}\cdot{\tilde{\vec k } } { \tilde{\vec k}}\cdot{\vec
\varepsilon}\,f_5 + i{k^2\over k_0}{\vec
\sigma}\cdot{\tilde{\vec q}}\,{\tilde{\vec k}}\cdot{\vec \varepsilon}\,f_6\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath61 and @xmath62 are unit vectors . the amplitudes @xmath63 describe the process with the transversal photons and @xmath64 with the longitudinal ones .
the relations between the amplitudes @xmath65 and @xmath66 are listed in appendix a. in the isotopic space @xmath65 ( and @xmath66 ) are matrices @xmath67f_i^{(-)}\ ; , \ ] ] where the upper sign corresponds to @xmath68 and the lower one to @xmath69 process . for the physical processes
, we have @xmath70 the differential cross section for the electroproduction is written down in the following form taking into account a possibility of the longitudinal polarization of the electron @xmath71\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath72^{-1}$ ] , @xmath73 and * q * are magnitudes of the photon and pion c.m .
momenta , respectively ; @xmath74 is the azimuthal angle between planes of the electron scattering and the reaction @xmath68 ; @xmath75 , @xmath76 ( @xmath77 ) and @xmath78 are the photon - momentum magnitude , the initial ( final ) energy and the electron scattering angle in lab frame , respectively ; and @xmath79 and @xmath80 are the solid angles of the scattered electron in lab and pion in c.m . of the @xmath7 system , respectively .
degree of the longitudinal polarization of the electron is @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the polarization vector of the electron in its rest system .
the ipe differential cross section reads @xmath83\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath84 is the angle between the momenta of the final nucleon and electron in the @xmath2 c.m .
system , @xmath74 is the angle between planes of the reaction @xmath85 and the @xmath2 pair production , @xmath86 is the solid angle of the virtual photon production in the c.m . of the @xmath7 system , and @xmath87 is the solid angle of electron in the c.m . of the @xmath2 pair .
@xmath88 in formulas ( [ cr.section:el-pr-n ] ) and ( [ cr.section:ipe ] ) describes the processes @xmath89 with the unpolarized transversal photons , @xmath90 characterizes the asymmetry of contributions of the transversal virtual photons linearly polarized in the plane of the @xmath89 and normally to it , @xmath91 is the contribution of the longitudinal photons , and @xmath92 and @xmath93 are the real and imaginary parts of the interference contribution of transversal and longitudinal photon in the helicity basis .
it is seen that @xmath93 is related with the contribution of longitudinal polarization of electron to the cross section .
the differential cross sections ( [ cr.section:el-pr-n ] ) and ( [ cr.section:ipe ] ) , measured for the processes with electron polarized in one direction , @xmath94 , and in the opposite one , @xmath95 , generally should display the asymmetry @xmath96 given by the contribution of @xmath93 @xmath97 the quantities @xmath98 are related to the amplitudes @xmath65 in the c.m .
frame as @xmath99+t_2,\nonumber\\ & & t_2=\frac{\alpha m^2}{2\pi s}\sin^2\theta^\gamma\left[|f_3|^2 + |f_4|^2 - 2\mbox{re}(f_1f_4^*+f_2f_3^*+\cos\theta^\gamma f_3f_4^ * ) \right],\nonumber\\ & & t_3=\frac{\alpha m^2}{\pi s}\sin\theta^\gamma\mbox{re}\left[(f_2 + f_3+\cos\theta^\gamma f_4)f_5^*+(f_1+\cos\theta^\gamma f_3 + f_4)f_6^*\right],\\ & & t_4=\frac{\alpha m^2}{\pi s}\left[|f_5|^2+|f_6|^2 + 2\cos\theta^\gamma\mbox{re}(f_5f_6^*)\right],\nonumber\\ & & t_5=2\frac{\alpha m^2}{\pi s}\sin\theta^\gamma\mbox{im}\left[(f_2^ * + f_3^*+\cos\theta^\gamma f_4^*)f_5+(f_1^*+\cos\theta^\gamma f_3^
* + f_4^*)f_6\right].\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ]
to obtain reliable information on the nucleon structure , it is important to find kinematic conditions under which the ipe dynamics is determined mainly by a model - independent part of interactions , the born one .
to this end , we utilize such general principles , as analyticity , unitarity , and lorentz invariance and the phenomenology of the processes @xmath100 and @xmath101 , considered in the framework of the unified ( including ipe ) model .
we use a simple version of the model , which describes the experimental data satisfactorily with a minimal number of parameters ( electromagnetic form factors ) .
this allows one to carry out a simple analytic continuation from the spacelike to timelike values of @xmath3 . for isovector amplitudes ,
the fixed-@xmath102 dispersion relations without subtractions at finite energy are used , with the spectral functions describing the magnetic excitation of the @xmath103 resonance .
the isoscalar amplitudes are described only by the born terms since the @xmath103 resonance does not contribute to them due to the isospin conservation . in refs .
@xcite , it was shown that this model is successful in combined description of experimental data on the pion electroproduction , photoproduction , and ipe in the total - energy region from the threshold up to @xmath104 gev .
moreover , this model is adequate for our purpose , namely to formulate the method for determination of the form factors in the timelike region , for the following reasons .
first , in the dispersion - relation approach , the spectral functions in the first resonance region are expressed through the nucleon electromagnetic form factors and the phase shift of the @xmath7-scattering @xmath105 .
this reduces considerably the number of fitted parameters , which is especially important in the ipe analysis .
second , in the @xmath103 region , the electric @xmath106 and scalar @xmath107 quadrupoles , which ( as the magnetic dipole @xmath108 ) describe excitation of the resonance @xmath103 , amount to not more than 15% of @xmath108 .
for example , the photoproduction data @xcite give the value @xmath109 for the @xmath110 ratio .
phenomenological results for the @xmath3 dependence of the @xmath110 and @xmath111 ratios are not stable yet and depend upon the method of their extraction from electroproduction data ( see discussion of this point in ref .
@xcite , p. 698 ) .
however , these ratios do not exceed respectively , 7 and 15% up to @xmath112 ( gev / c)@xmath6 .
based on the quark model calculations ( see , _
e.g. _ , refs .
@xcite ) , we suppose that an analogous situation takes place also for @xmath113 , at least up to @xmath114 0.3 ( gev / c)@xmath6 .
therefore , at the first stage of our analysis we neglect the quadrupole excitations of @xmath103 , which we expect to be a good approximation for processes with unpolarised nucleons .
the conventional procedure of reggeization provides us with behaviour of the invariant amplitudes for @xmath115 and small @xmath8 @xcite @xmath116 consequently , in a complete @xmath46-channel description , we should write a fixed-@xmath102 dispersion relation with one subtraction at finite energy for the isovector amplitude @xmath117 and without subtractions for the remaining amplitudes , taking into account their crossing properties . however , the dispersion integrals with the spectral functions which describe the magnetic excitation of the @xmath103 resonance converge very well already at @xmath118 2 gev for all the amplitudes @xmath66 .
therefore , we use the fixed-@xmath102 dispersion relations without subtraction at the finite energy @xcite for all isovector amplitudes @xmath119 and we take the born approximation for the isoscalar ones @xmath120 where @xmath121 , @xmath122\ ; , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath123\;,\ ] ] with the @xmath7 coupling constant @xmath124 and the normalisation of the form factors : @xmath125 . the terms @xmath126 and @xmath127 belong only to the amplitude @xmath117 . note that @xmath53 and @xmath54 have the kinematic pole at @xmath55 .
however , these singularities are cancelled out kinematically because these amplitudes enter into the matrix element through the combination @xmath128 which is equal to @xmath129 , where @xmath130 and @xmath131 are the ball amplitudes which have been proved to have no kinematic singularities @xcite . in specific model calculations , the condition @xmath132=0\ ; , \ ] ] which is ensured by the form of the term @xmath127 ( [ eq : c5 ] ) , guarantees absence of the singularity at @xmath55 .
the spectral functions @xmath133 are supposed to describe the magnetic excitation of the @xmath103 resonance @xmath134}~ a_i(w , t,\lambda^2),\ ] ] where @xmath135 , @xmath105 is the corresponding phase shift of the @xmath7-scattering amplitude , for which we utilize the prescription from ref .
@xcite , and @xmath136 with the coefficients @xmath137 @xmath138 , & ~~\beta_1=\frac{1}{2}(w+m - q_0 ) , \\
\alpha_2=\frac{3}{2}(w+m)(m_\pi^2-t ) , & ~~\beta_2=\frac{1}{2}(w+m)+q_0 , \\ \alpha_3=-\frac{1}{2}(w+m)(w+m - q_0)-\frac{3}{4}(m_\pi^2-t ) , & ~~\beta_3=-\frac{3}{4}\ ; , \\
\alpha_4=(w+m)(w+m+\frac{1}{2}q_0)-\frac{3}{4}(m_\pi^2-t ) , & ~~\beta_4=\frac{3}{4}\;,\\ \alpha_5=2(s - m^2)(w+m+\frac{1}{2}q_0)-\frac{3}{2}(w - m)(m_\pi^2-t ) , & ~~ \beta_5=\frac{3}{2}(w - m),\\ \alpha_6=-\frac{1}{2}(w+m)q_0-\frac{1}{4}(m_\pi^2 + 3 t ) , & ~~\beta_6=-\frac{3}{4}\;. \end{array } \right.\end{aligned}\ ] ] furthermore , the results of the photoproduction multipole analyses @xcite allow us to set @xmath139 above the @xmath103 energy .
prescriptions for the pion and nucleon electromagnetic form factors are taken from refs .
the model described above is the first ( simple ) reliable version of the more complex model for unified treatment of contemporary experimental data on the pion photoproduction , electroproduction , and ipe in the energy region which spans from the threshold up to the second @xmath7 resonance . in fig .
[ fig : ph - pr - n ] we compare results of our model for the differential cross section with @xmath140-photoproduction data . in fig .
[ fig : e - pr - n1 ] we show comparison with the electroproduction data on the proton for the transversal @xmath141 and longitudinal @xmath142 parts of the cross section @xmath143\;.\ ] ] the differential cross sections for the forward electroproduction of pions by transversal and longitudinal virtual photons are presented in fig .
[ fig : e - pr - n2 ] .
in general , we obtain quite a good agreement with the pion photoproduction and electroproduction data on unpolarized nucleons , especially in the region of the @xmath103 resonance ( @xmath144 gev ) . in the case of the @xmath140 photoproduction ,
the results are very good up to @xmath13 gev ( @xmath145 gev ) , see fig .
[ fig : ph - pr - n ] .
it is obvious that our model can be further improved by including the quadrupole excitation of the @xmath103 resonance ( @xmath146 and @xmath147 ) in the spectral functions .
however , a still more elaborate model should include , in addition to the quadrupole excitation , contributions of other nucleon isobars and high - energy `` tails '' to the absorption parts of the amplitudes to ensure a balanced consideration of small corrections .
furthermore , analytic continuation of the corrected absorption parts of the amplitudes into the unobservable region in the dispersion integrals , @xmath148 for @xmath149 , requires use of the quasithreshold relations ( following from causality analyticity ) between the electric and longitudinal multipoles @xcite in which `` toroid '' multipoles appear @xcite . on the contrary ,
the analytic continuation with the approximation ( [ eq : ima ] ) is immediate .
however , having in mind the quality of contemporary experimental data , the above - stated simple model seems to be quite sufficient ( see figs . [
fig : ph - pr - n]-[fig : e - pr - n2 ] ) .
application of the model to the calculations for ipe shows an interesting growth of the relative contribution of the born terms with @xmath3 and their dominance in the neighbourhood of the value @xmath150 @xcite .
this approximate dominance of the born terms has a model - independent explanation .
it is related to the quasithreshold theorem @xcite , which means that at the quasithreshold , @xmath151 , the ipe amplitude becomes the born one in the energy region from the threshold up to @xmath13 gev .
this remarkable dynamics of ipe distinguishes it essentially from the photoproduction and electroproduction , where rescattering effects amount @xmath152 .
let us explain the quasithreshold behaviour of the ipe amplitude .
as @xmath153 the multipole amplitudes behave in the following way @xmath154 therefore , at @xmath155 only the electric ( @xmath156 and @xmath157 ) and longitudinal ( @xmath158 and @xmath159 ) dipoles survive . in addition , the number of independent dipole transitions diminishes to the two ones at the quasithreshold due to the quasithreshold constraints @xmath160 which arise from the causality ( analyticity ) .
the selection rules which follow from the parity conservation and the value of the angular momentum of the stopped virtual photon , @xmath161 , restrict possible s - channel resonances at the quasithreshold to the following sets : @xmath162 , _ etc . _ ] and @xmath163 , _ etc .
behaviour of the multipole amplitudes as @xmath164 and @xmath153 and the quasithreshold constraints among them are derived in appendix b. since the @xmath46- and @xmath165-wave @xmath7 resonances are excited at energies above 1.5 gev , one can expect that the dipoles @xmath156 and @xmath157 are dominated by the born terms below this energy .
this is in agreement with the multipole analyses of charged pion photoproduction and confirmed by the dispersion - relation calculations at @xmath166 .
we can , therefore , conclude that in the quasithreshold region , the ipe amplitude is given by the born terms with accuracy better than @xmath167 . at energies below @xmath168 gev
, we can write for the quasithreshold ipe @xmath169.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the real experiment , however , one can not realize strictly the quasithreshold conditions and , therefore , the realistic model ( presented above ) is needed . in choosing the optimal geometry of the experiment for deriving the form factors , the `` compensation curves '' @xcite can help .
the curves are defined as curves in the @xmath170 plane along which the differential cross section is given only by the born terms .
these curves can be constructed by comparing photoproduction experimental data with the born cross section and employing the existence theorem for implicit functions ( more details on the compensation effect is given in appendix c ) .
the method of determining the electromagnetic form factors from low - energy ipe is , therefore , based on utilizing the quasithreshold theorem , the realistic dispersion - relation model , and the compensation curve .
this method has been already used in the experiments on the nucleon and nuclei @xmath4c and @xmath5li @xcite .
.[tab1]electromagnetic form factors obtained in experiments on the nucleon .
the virtual photon momentum @xmath3 is given in units of the pion mass . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in table [ tab1 ] , we present values of the electromagnetic form factors obtained in experiments on the nucleon . in tab .
[ tab1 ] , the same experimental errors are given for @xmath171 and @xmath172 because in this @xmath3-range these form factors can be connected with each other via the spectral function by the relation @xmath173 .
the quantity @xmath174 , taken from the dispersion calculations @xcite , possesses a significantly smaller theoretical uncertainty than the calculated quantities @xmath171 and @xmath172 .
this is caused by cancellation of terms with the large uncertainties in the spectral function of @xmath174 which , therefore , is dominated by the one - nucleon exchange contribution in the region @xmath175 .
one can see that this result is rather model - independent .
then the same experimental errors can be given for @xmath171 and @xmath172 .
of course , having high - statistics data for ipe one need not use the relation of @xmath171 with @xmath172 in extracting these quantities .
the values of @xmath171 are quite consistent with the calculations of the nucleon electromagnetic structure in framework of the unitary and analytic vector - meson dominance model @xcite .
let us look at the possibility of investigating the form factor @xmath176 of the @xmath177 vertex at @xmath178 .
whereas a measurement of the differential cross section for the electroproduction with unpolarised electrons in the @xmath12 region at @xmath179 out of the compensation curve allows one to extract information about the form factors of the @xmath177 vertex , this approach is not sufficiently effective for ipe because the dominance of the born mechanism which reaches @xmath180 at the quasithreshold is also considerable at lower values of @xmath3 .
it turns out that the analysis of asymmetry @xmath181 ( [ p_e ] ) in the dilepton production near the quasithreshold gives us that chance .
we consider the quantity @xmath93 , connected to the asymmetry @xmath181 .
it can be expanded to series in @xmath182 near the quasithreshold with taking into account formulas ( [ t_i - f_i ] ) , ( [ m - pole - expantion ] ) and ( [ gk - behavior ] ) @xmath183 the lowest term of the formal series in eq .
( [ t_5-expand ] ) @xmath184_{{\bf k}=0}\ ; , \ ] ] equals zero at the quasithreshold as it follows from the constraints ( [ q - thr - constr ] ) .
behaviour of @xmath93 for @xmath153 then is @xmath185 where @xmath186_{\bf k=0 } .\ ] ] in the @xmath103 region , the amplitudes @xmath156 and @xmath157 are dominated by the born terms , and the imaginary parts of form factors are negligible .
contributions of @xmath106 and @xmath187 amount to less than 15% of that of @xmath108 .
multipole amplitudes @xmath188 and @xmath187 , related to the excitation of the @xmath189 resonance , generally have to be very small , as it is seen in analyses of photoproduction ( especially on the neutron ) . therefore , with a good accuracy ,
we obtain @xmath190 since the quasithreshold relations ( [ gk - behavior ] ) seem to be approximately realized in a rather wide interval in @xmath3 , the asymmetry @xmath181 has to be sensitive to @xmath191 in the @xmath103 region .
the measurement of @xmath181 would , therefore , allow one to study quantitatively the assumption about the dominance of the magnetic dipole transition and to extract information on the form factor @xmath176 at @xmath113 .
this is possible because the contribution of the background part of the amplitude to @xmath93 is considerably suppressed in the quasithreshold region , the background part reducing as @xmath192 for @xmath182 becoming zero .
now let us discuss another interesting possibility of investigating the weak nucleon structure related to the nucleon gamow
teller transition described by the matrix element @xmath193\gamma_5u(p_1),\ ] ] where @xmath194 is the axial - vector current , and @xmath195 and @xmath196 are the axial and induced pseudoscalar form factors , respectively .
an alternative description of ipe which utilizes the current commutators , pcac , and completeness allows one to derive a low - energy theorem at the threshold , @xmath197 and @xmath198 , related to the approximate chiral symmetry and @xmath199 corrections .
minimization of the continuum contribution at the quasithreshold justifies this approach up to @xmath13 gev @xcite with the continuum corrections being practically the same as in the dispersion - relation description .
then , one obtains for the longitudinal part of the @xmath200 amplitude at the quasithreshold retaining only the leading terms in @xmath201 @xcite , such that @xmath202\bigr\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the constant of the @xmath203 decay @xmath204 is defined by @xmath205 , @xmath206 , and the quasithreshold values of the variables are @xmath207 @xmath208 was measured in various experiments , first of all in @xmath209 and @xmath210 .
it is reasonable to use first this result @xmath211 however , it is difficult to obtain reliable information on @xmath16 in these experiments since its contribution to cross sections is kinematically suppressed ( it is multiplied by the lepton masses ) . in the @xmath14-capture and @xmath212-decay experiments , there is a kinematically restricted small range of @xmath8 , @xmath213 , in which the weak form factor can be determined , though with a large error .
for example , its value extracted from measurements of the @xmath14-capture in hydrogen @xcite is @xmath214 .
@xmath16 has also been measured in the capture of polarized muons by @xmath215si nuclei @xcite .
equation ( [ long.part:ca ] ) shows that the kinematic suppression of the @xmath16 contribution is absent when the ipe data at the quasithreshold are used for extracting @xmath16 . in this way
, the pseudoscalar form factor @xmath216 can be determined in the range up to @xmath217 ( which corresponds to @xmath13 gev ) . adopting the quasithreshold kinematics
, one can avoid the threshold difficulties that are present when applying an analogous method to the analysis of electroproduction data .
next we shall follow the method of ref .
first , using the @xmath218 and @xmath219 values obtained in the analysis of the ipe data on the nucleon @xcite , we obtain 10 data points for the longitudinal part of the @xmath220 amplitude at the quasithreshold .
these data points , which can be considered as experimental ones , are depicted in fig .
[ fig : long - exp ] . for @xmath216 we chose the dispersion relation without subtractions : @xmath221 the residue at the pole @xmath222 is determined by the pcac relation . when only the @xmath223-pole term is considered in @xmath16 ,
the result is inconsistent with the experimental data as demonstrated in fig .
[ fig : long - exp ] ( dashed line ) . therefore , the dispersion integral in eq .
( [ g_p : dr ] ) should be considered
. it could be approximated by the contributions of possible intermediate three - pion and resonance states with the pion quantum numbers . however , since the contributions of nonresonant three - particle states must be suppressed by the phase volume , it is , therefore , reasonable to approximate the integral in ( [ g_p : dr ] ) by a resonance - pole term .
a satisfactory description is obtained if one takes the following expression for @xmath216 with the indicated values of parameters : @xmath224 where @xmath225 , the @xmath226 weak - decay constant @xmath227 is defined by @xmath228 , and @xmath229 and @xmath230 are the coupling constants of the @xmath223 and @xmath226 states with the nucleon , respectively . as seen from the definitions of the weak - decay constants
, one must expect that @xmath231 to reflect a tendency of another way ( in addition to the goldstone one ) in which the axial current is conserved for vanishing quark masses .
this behaviour is demonstrated in various models with some nonlocality which describe chiral symmetry breaking @xcite .
notice that the pole at @xmath232 in eq .
( [ g_p ] ) , situated considerably lower than the poles of the known contributing states @xmath233 and @xmath234 , is indispensable for describing the obtained experimental data on ipe . in fig .
[ fig : gp - ratio ] we show the ratio @xmath235 in comparison with the values obtained in @xmath14-capture on hydrogen @xcite and in analysis of data on the @xmath236 electroproduction off the proton near the threshold @xcite .
the error bars on the solid line indicate that the values of @xmath216 determined by this method are of high accuracy .
one can see that the results of refs .
@xcite agree with the pion - pole dominance hypothesis in a large range of momentum transfer unlike our result in which the hypothesis is valid only in a narrow @xmath102 range , whereas outside the range the contribution of continuum is considerable .
note that the contributions of the pion radial excitations , @xmath233 and @xmath234 , which are rather distant from this region , are suppressed and their consideration would only slightly increase the mass of @xmath237 .
the parameters of this pole term in ( [ g_p ] ) might be changed more considerably if one assumes the channel @xmath238 with the recently discovered scalar @xmath239 @xcite , due to the possible multichannel nature of this state . in any case , the conclusion will remain valid that the state with @xmath240 in the range 500 - 800 mev is needed for explaining the obtained ipe data .
let us add that a possible signal of the charged state of this isotriplet was observed in the @xmath241 system @xcite and interpreted as the first radial excitation of the pion in the framework of the relativistic quark model @xcite based on the covariant formalism for two - particle equations . accepting this designation for @xmath242 and taking the estimate for the @xmath226 weak - decay constant in the nambu jona - lasinio ( njl ) model generalized by using effective quark interactions with a finite range , @xmath243 mev , we obtain @xmath244 .
there are no suitable theoretical calculations for this coupling constant now . in the njl model
, the consideration of radial excitations of states requires introducing some nonlocality .
since a successful calculation of the @xmath7 coupling constant in that model enforces one to go beyond the framework of the tree approximation and take loop corrections into account @xcite , it seems that a satisfactory evaluation of @xmath245 in that approximation can not avoid assuming some nonlocality .
of course , a more reliable interpretation of @xmath226 requires investigation of other processes with @xmath226 .
existence of this state would also raise the question on its su(3 ) partners .
a careful ( re)analysis of the corresponding processes is , therefore , desirable in this energy region .
we have demonstrated that a subsequent investigation of ipe is necessary for extracting both unique information about the electromagnetic structure of particles in the sub-@xmath0 threshold region of the timelike values of @xmath3 and the nucleon weak structure in the spacelike region .
the former is interesting especially now , _
e.g. _ , in connection with discussion about the hidden strangeness of the nucleon ( see , _
e.g. _ , @xcite ) and quasinuclear bound @xmath246 state @xcite .
analyses of the experimental ipe data in the first @xmath7 resonance region allow one to obtain the values of the form factor @xmath171 at timelike values of @xmath3 which are quite consistent with the calculations in the framework of the unitary analytic vector - meson dominance model @xcite .
an inevitable step that is necessary for the study of the electromagnetic structure of nucleon - isobar systems in the timelike @xmath3-region is a multipole analysis of ipe similar to that for the photoproduction and electroproduction , _
e.g. _ @xcite . at present , with the intense pion beams being available , it is possible to perform experiments aiming at carrying out that analysis . in a construction of the dispersion - quark model in the second and third @xmath7 resonance region ,
the multichannel character of the nucleon isobars must be taken into account , _
e.g. _ , by the method of ref .
@xcite or utilizing the proper uniforming variables @xcite .
as we already mentioned , our method was used in the analysis of the pion - induced dilepton production on the nucleon and light nuclei .
it is worth making some remarks about the analysis of the experiment on the @xmath5li nucleus with a @xmath236 beam at 500 mev / c @xcite .
the missing mass analysis of the data has shown that about half of the events are related to disintegration processes of the nucleus which are dominated by the reaction + @xmath247 .
+ on analyzing this process it was assumed that the pion - nucleus amplitude is determined by the neutron - pole mechanism , and the nuclear part ( the vertex function of the @xmath248 ) was calculated in the nucleon cluster model @xcite .
the remaining events belong to the process + @xmath249 .
+ when all the events were analyzed ( with and without disintegration of the nucleus ) , the cross section on the nucleus was supposed to be additively connected with the cross section on the individual nucleon and nuclear effects were taken into account via screening . in both cases , our model was used for describing ipe on the individual nucleon .
the obtained values for @xmath171 are again quite consistent with the calculations in ref .
@xcite . in the case of the reaction without disintegration of the nucleus ,
one observed there the electromagnetic form factor of the nucleus in the timelike @xmath3 region for the first time .
unfortunately , in the indicated analysis , unique information on the electromagnetic structure of the nucleus in the timelike region was lost .
generally , it seems at present that there is no satisfactory concept of the electromagnetic form factors of the nucleus in the timelike region .
a satisfactory description must take into account both a constituent character of the nucleus ( and the corresponding analytic properties ) and more subtle ( than the screening ) collective nuclear effects .
finally , it should be noticed that a more reliable interpretation of the observed state @xmath250 requires solving a number of questions , both theoretical and experimental . in the pseudoscalar sector ,
states of various nature are possible , except for @xmath251 , the @xmath252 and @xmath253 glueballs , @xmath254 hybrids , and multiquark states
. however , all the models and lattice calculations give masses of those unusual states considerably greater than 1 gev . therefore , the most probable interpretation of @xmath250 seems to be the first radial pion excitation .
the authors are grateful to s.b .
gerasimov , v.a .
meshcheryakov , and g.b .
pontecorvo for useful discussions and interest in this work . yu.s . acknowledges also support provided by the votruba - blokhintsev program for theoretical physics of the committee for cooperation of the czech republic with jinr , dubna .
thanks the grant agency of the czech republic , grant no .
202/05/2142 , and the institutional research plan avoz10480505 .
m.n . acknowledges the slovak scientific grant agency , grant vega no .
2/3105/23 .
the invariant amplitudes @xmath255 relate to the scalar c.m .
amplitudes @xmath256 as follows @xmath257\left(\frac{f_3}{p_{10}-m}+ \frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}f_4\right)-2m\lambda^2\left(\frac{f_5}{p_{10}-m}+ \frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}f_6\right),\nonumber\\ { k}{a}_2 & = & \frac{2}{t - m_{\pi}^2-\lambda^2}\left\{\lambda^2\left(\frac{f_1}{p_{10}-m}- \frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}f_2\right)+\frac{1}{2\bf qk}[(t - m_{\pi}^2-\lambda^2)k_0 + \right.\nonumber\\ & & \left.2q_0\lambda^2]\left[(w - m)\frac{f_3}{p_{10}-m}-\frac{p_{20}+m } { \bf qk}(w+m)f_4\right]-\right.\nonumber\\ & & \left.\lambda^2\left[(w - m)\frac{f_5}{p_{10}-m}- \frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}(w+m)f_6\right]\right\},\nonumber\\ { k}{a}_3 & = & { k}{a}_4 + 2w\frac{\bf k}{\bf q}\left(\frac{f_3}{p_{10}-m}+ \frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}f_4\right),\\ { k}{a}_4 & = & ( w - m)\frac{f_1}{p_{10}-m}+(w+m)\frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}f_2 + \frac{1}{2\bf qk}[(t - m_{\pi}^2-\lambda^2)k_0+\nonumber\\ & & 2q_0\lambda^2]\left(\frac{f_3}{p_{10}-m}+\frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}f_4\right)- \lambda^2\left[\frac{f_5}{p_{10}-m}+\frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}f_6\right],\nonumber\\ { k}{a}_5 & = & \frac{2}{t - m_{\pi}^2-\lambda^2}\left\{(s - m^2)\left(\frac{-f_1}{p_{10}-m}+ \frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}f_2\right)+\frac{1}{2\bf qk}[(t - m_{\pi}^2-\right.\nonumber\\ & & \left.\lambda^2)(p_{10}+w)+2q_0(s - m^2)]\left[(w - m)\frac{-f_3}{p_{10}-m}+ \frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}(w+m)f_4\right]+\right.\nonumber\\ & & \left.(s - m^2)\left[(w - m)\frac{f_5}{p_{10}-m}-\frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}(w+m)f_6 \right]\right\},\nonumber\\ { k}{a}_6 & = & ( w+m)\frac{f_1}{p_{10}-m}+(w - m)\frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}f_2- \frac{1}{2\bf qk}[(t - m_{\pi}^2-\lambda^2)(p_{10}+w)+\nonumber\\ & & 2q_0(s - m^2)]\left(\frac{f_3}{p_{10}-m}+\frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}f_4\right)- ( s - m^2)\left(\frac{f_5}{p_{10}-m}+\frac{p_{20}+m}{\bf qk}f_6\right),\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath258 .
the inverse relations reads @xmath259 , \nonumber\\ f_3 & = & \sqrt{((w - m)^2-\lambda^2)((w - m)^2-m_{\pi}^2)}\frac{(w+m)^2-m_{\pi}^2}{8ms } [ ( s - m^2){a}_2+\nonumber\\ & & \lambda^2{a}_5+(w+m)({a}_3-{a}_4)],\\ f_5 & = & \frac{1}{4mw}\sqrt{\frac{(w+m)^2-m_{\pi}^2}{(w+m)^2-\lambda^2 } } \left\{\frac{(t - m_{\pi}^2-\lambda^2)}{2}[(3s+m^2-\lambda^2){a}_2 + 2w({a}_3-{a}_4)+\right.\nonumber\\ & & \left.(s - m^2+\lambda^2){a}_5]+[(w+m)^2-\lambda^2][{a}_1+(w - m)({a}_4- { a}_6)]+\right.\nonumber\\ & & \left.(s - m^2+m_{\pi}^2)[(w+m)({a}_3-{a}_4)+(s - m^2){a}_2 + \lambda^2{a}_5]\right\}\,.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] formulas for the remaining amplitudes can be obtained from eqs .
( [ f : a ] ) using the formal substitution @xmath260 and symmetry properties of the amplitudes @xmath65 under the substitution @xmath261 here we demonstrate a derivation @xcite of the behaviour of the multipole amplitudes as @xmath164 and @xmath153 on the basis of the first - class maximum analyticity principle @xcite . according to this principle
, the total amplitude possesses only singularities that are related to the dynamic processes and whose positions depend on masses of intermediate ( and external ) states which are involved in these processes . then at the known arrangement of poles ( and , therefore , of the threshold branch points )
all the other singularities are determined by the systematic consideration of formulas for discontinuities in all channels .
notice that the limit @xmath153 is fulfilled in two cases : @xmath262 and @xmath263 .
in the former case , the limit is fulfilled in ipe at the quasithreshold when the virtual photon has a maximal mass , whereas in the latter , the limit is fulfilled in the @xmath264-channel , @xmath265 , at the stopped antinucleon @xmath266 .
the amplitudes @xmath65 can be decomposed in terms of the multipole amplitudes : the magnetic @xmath267 , electric @xmath268 , and longitudinal @xmath269 ( or scalar @xmath270 but due to the current conservation , @xmath271 ) : @xmath272p^\prime_{l+1 } ( \cos{\theta^{\gamma}})+ \sum_{l=2}^{\infty}[(l+1)m_{l-}+e_{l-}]p^\prime_{l-1 } ( \cos{\theta^{\gamma}}),\nonumber\\ f_2&=&\sum_{l=1}^{\infty}[(l+1)m_{l+}+lm_{l-}]p^\prime_l ( \cos{\theta^{\gamma}}),\nonumber\\ f_3&=&\sum_{l=1}^{\infty}[-m_{l+}+e_{l+}]p^{\prime\prime}_{l+1 } ( \cos{\theta^{\gamma}})+ \sum_{l=3}^{\infty}[m_{l-}+e_{l-}]p^{\prime\prime}_{l-1 } ( \cos{\theta^{\gamma}}),\\ f_4&=&\sum_{l=2}^{\infty}[m_{l+}-m_{l-}-e_{l+}-e_{l-}]p^{\prime\prime}_l ( \cos{\theta^{\gamma}}),\nonumber\\ k_0f_5&=&\sum_{l=0}^{\infty}l_{l+}p^{\prime}_{l+1}(\cos{\theta^{\gamma}})- \sum_{l=2}^{\infty}l_{l-}p^{\prime}_{l-1}(\cos{\theta^{\gamma}}),\nonumber\\ k_0f_6&=&\sum_{l=1}^{\infty}[l_{l-}-l_{l+}]p^{\prime}_{l+1 } ( \cos{\theta^{\gamma}}).\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] notice the unphysical multipoles : @xmath273 .
the multipole amplitudes are functions of @xmath274 and @xmath3 only .
the properties of the amplitudes @xmath275 with respect to the substitution @xmath260 ( [ f : w - w ] ) result in the corresponding symmetry relations for the multipole amplitudes @xmath276 in the following , it is convenient to introduce new functions @xmath277 instead of the legendre polynomial which have singularities ( due to @xmath278 ) @xmath279 taking into account the relation between @xmath280 and @xmath281 , we can conclude that the quantities @xmath282^{-1/2}f_1,~~~ [ ( p_{10}-m)(p_{20}-m)]^{-1/2}f_2,~~~ \frac{[(p_{10}-m)(p_{20}-m)]^{-1/2}}{p_{20}+m}f_3,\nonumber\\ & & \frac{[(p_{10}+m)(p_{20}+m)]^{-1/2}}{p_{20}-m}f_4,~~~ \left(\frac{p_{10}+m}{p_{20}+m}\right)^{1/2}f_5,~~~ \left(\frac{p_{10}-m}{p_{20}-m}\right)^{1/2}f_6\end{aligned}\ ] ] possess no kinematic singularities . to guarantee
this property of the quantities ( [ nksf ] ) the multipole amplitudes in ( [ m - pole - expantion ] ) must have the form @xmath283^{-1/2}({\bf
qk})^l\tilde{m}_{l-},\nonumber\\ e_{l+}&=&\left(\frac{p_{20}+m}{p_{10}+m}\right)^{1/2}({\bf qk})^l\tilde{e}_{l+},~~~ e_{l-}=\left(\frac{p_{10}+m}{p_{20}+m}\right)^{1/2}({\bf q})^l{\bf k}^{l-2 } \tilde{e}_{l-},\\ l_{l+}&=&k_0\left(\frac{p_{20}+m}{p_{10}+m}\right)^{1/2}({\bf qk})^l \tilde{l}_{l+},~~~ l_{l-}=k_0\left(\frac{p_{10}+m}{p_{20}+m}\right)^{1/2}({\bf q})^l{\bf k}^{l-2 } \tilde{l}_{l-}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] furthermore , we must ensure that the expression @xmath284{\tilde
p}^\prime_{l+1}\over p_{10}+m\ ] ] in @xmath285 has no kinematic singularities at @xmath286 , _
i.e. _ , we must demand the following constraint : @xmath287 in the exceptional case @xmath288 , ( @xmath289 ) we obtain @xmath290 _ i.e. _ , @xmath291^{1/2}\mu_0.\ ] ] it is clear that a question about the kinematic zeros in @xmath65 is left open .
since we are interested mainly in the @xmath3 dependence , we give only the kinematic @xmath3 behaviour of the amplitudes @xmath65 as @xmath262 and @xmath292 , not writing down explicitly the coefficients that depend only on @xmath293 at @xmath294 . from ( [ m - pole - expantion ] ) and ( [ tildep])-([e0 + ] ) , we have + a ) as @xmath262 @xmath295 b ) as @xmath292 @xmath296 taking into account formulas ( [ a : f ] ) , ( [ fbehavior.m ] ) and ( [ fbehavior .- m ] ) , and the fact that the amplitudes @xmath66 have no kinematic singularities ( except for the pole at @xmath297 in @xmath53 and @xmath54 ) , we conclude that the following constraints must be fulfilled to satisfy the maximal analyticity : + a ) as @xmath262 @xmath298 b ) as @xmath292 @xmath299 constraints ( [ c : f1,f3,f5.m])-([c : f3,f5.-m ] ) and the @xmath3 behaviour of the amplitudes @xmath65 , ( [ fbehavior.m ] ) and ( [ fbehavior .- m ] ) , ensure the absence of kinematic singularities in the amplitude @xmath300 , eq .
( [ f : scal.expantion ] ) , as @xmath301 and @xmath302 . taking into account the constraints ( [ c : f1,f3,f5.m])-([c : f3,f5.-m ] ) and eq .
( [ gk - behavior ] ) and using the recurrent formulas for the legendre polynomials , we obtain kinematic relations between the multipole amplitudes at the quasithreshold and for @xmath292 . the constraint ( [ c : f4,f6.m ] ) gives as @xmath262 @xmath303 and @xmath304^{1/2}\kappa_1\;.\ ] ] the constraint ( [ c : f1,f3,f5.m ] ) gives @xmath305 and ( [ c : f3,f5.-m ] ) , as @xmath292 , results in @xmath306 or @xmath307\;.\ ] ] the multipole amplitude @xmath158 , behaves as @xmath308^{1/2}\nu_0\;.\ ] ] finally , the constraint ( [ c : f2,f4,f6.-m ] ) gives the following relations between the multipole amplitudes as @xmath292 @xmath309 so , we derived the constraints for the multipole amplitudes at the quasithreshold and as @xmath292 .
the relations of the first type ( [ c : el-,ll-.m])-([c : el+,ll+.m ] ) were also derived in refs .
@xcite by a different method that shades their kinematic nature .
the relations for @xmath292 , analogous to ( [ c : m+e+.-m ] ) , ( [ c : el+,ll+.-m])-([c : m1-,l1-.-m ] ) , were also obtained in a different way in ref .
note that since kinematic conditions as @xmath292 ( @xmath310 ) are obtained from the quasithreshold kinematic configuration @xmath262 ( @xmath311 ) through the substitution @xmath312 , constraints for the multipole amplitudes as @xmath292 can be derived from the ones at the quasithreshold with the help of the symmetry relations for multipole amplitudes ( [ mac - dowell ] ) taking into account the complete @xmath3 behaviour of the latter as @xmath262 ( [ gk - behavior ] ) , ( [ c : el-,ll-.m])-([c : el+,ll+.m ] ) .
the relations for multipole amplitudes as @xmath292 are , of course , not fulfilled in the reaction under consideration .
a region of their applicability is the c.m .
system of pion and nucleon in the @xmath3 channel @xmath313 at the stopped antinucleon ( @xmath314 ) .
the relations between multipole amplitudes at the quasithreshold are very important for our considerations because the condition @xmath262 is realized ( at @xmath149 ) in the investigated reaction @xmath315 unlike the electroproduction and photoproduction .
the introduced quantities @xmath316 ( [ c : el-,ll-.m ] ) and @xmath317 ( [ c : el+,ll+.m ] ) are not formal coefficients of expansion in a series but they can be related to `` toroid '' multipole amplitudes @xmath318 @xcite that have a definite physical meaning . the relations ( [ c : el-,ll-.m ] ) and ( [ c : el+,ll+.m ] ) must be used with necessity when carrying out analytic continuations of spectral functions in the dispersion relations for ipe into the unphysical region @xmath319 . therefore , it seems that application ( from the beginning ) of toroid multipoles @xmath318 instead of @xmath320 is rather relevant in the timelike region .
here we shall find a region of variables @xmath321 , and @xmath3 where the cross sections of the processes of pion photoproduction , electroproduction , and ipe are described only by the born terms .
let us write the differential cross section of virtual photoproduction as a sum of two terms @xmath322 where the first term is the born cross section and @xmath323 takes into account the final - state interaction and its interference with the born part of the amplitude . to establish the conditions under which @xmath324 we use the existence theorem for implicit functions . by this theorem ,
if equation ( [ phi - cond .
] ) allows the solution @xmath325 , @xmath326 , @xmath327 , and the function @xmath323 and its partial derivatives of the first order are continuous in the vicinity of the point @xmath328 and the derivative @xmath329 at this point is different from zero , that is , @xmath330 then there exists only one function @xmath331 which satisfies equation ( [ phi - cond . ] ) in some vicinity of the point @xmath332 and takes the value @xmath326 at @xmath325 , @xmath333 .
this function and its partial derivatives are continuous in the vicinity of the point @xmath332 . according to this theorem , if we find at least one point in the space of @xmath334 , where the effects of rescattering and their interference with the born terms compensate each other , then , since the cross section is continuous in the physical region , there is a surface of `` compensation '' in this space on which the cross section is the born one .
the intersections of this surface with every plane @xmath335 define some curves in the plane @xmath170 each of them being characterized by its own value of @xmath3 and the cross section ( [ dif.cr.sec . ] ) being the born one along them .
thus , we obtain a one - parameter set of the compensation curves with @xmath3 as a parameter .
consider the curves @xmath25 in more detail .
we shall use @xmath336 instead of variable @xmath102 , where @xmath84 is a scattering angle in the c.m . system .
if the compensation takes place , then in the plane @xmath337 we ought to have the compensation curve @xmath338 continuous in the physical region . generally speaking
, there may be several curves of this kind , because the function @xmath339 can always be represented as a polynomial in powers of @xmath340 : @xmath341 and the equation @xmath342 can have several real roots @xmath343 .
however , due to the theorem mentioned above , the curves do not intersect , since only one curve can pass through the given point . in the case of the pion photoproduction ,
available experimental data are sufficient to construct the compensation curves @xcite . to this end , it is necessary to find out the intersection points of the experimental differential cross section with the calculated born cross section and plot these points in the plane @xmath337 or @xmath344 . in fig .
[ fig : comp - curv ] the compensation curves for the charged pion photoproduction are shown . calculating the born cross sections , we take into account the interaction of the photon only with the charge
. therefore , along these curves the experimental cross sections are completely described by the electric born terms .
one can see that at high energies , the compensation curves pass through small angles in accordance with the electric born model ( ebm ) @xcite .
the compensation curves show also that an applicability of ebm to the cross section extends to the whole energy range , but at the corresponding angles , giving a more complete and transparent picture .
of course , there are also compensation curves corresponding to the total born amplitude .
now , if one assumes that for processes of the pion electroproduction and ipe , when @xmath166 , the compensation curves are not much different from the corresponding curves for the photoproduction @xmath345 , then along these curves the model dependence of description of the processes should be minimal . in the resonance region , this assumption would be reasonable if the change of @xmath3 does not lead to the essential reconstruction of the helicity ( or multipole ) structure of the excitation of the corresponding resonance . in the first resonance region , calculations , _
e.g. _ , in the dispersion theory , which agree with the predictions of the quark models ( _ e.g. _ @xcite ) and with the result of the phenomenological analysis of the electroproduction data ( _ e.g. _ @xcite ) , confirm a dominance preservation of the magnetic dipole excitation of the @xmath103 resonance with the change of @xmath346 .
quark models expand this situation to values of @xmath178 . in our dispersion model
, it was verified that the compensation angle @xmath347 is invariable with @xmath3 for the cross sections of the processes @xmath348 with the transverse virtual photons at @xmath349 gev @xmath350 .
this prediction was confirmed by the experiment @xcite for the timelike values of @xmath3 : @xmath351 . in the second and third resonance regions , the analysis of experimental data for electroproduction ( _ e.g. _ @xcite )
gives a considerable change ( with @xmath352 ) of the helicity structure for the excitation of leading resonances , which is especially essential approximately at @xmath353 .
the compensation curves exist also for the asymmetry in the charged pion production by the polarized @xmath354-quanta @xmath355/ [ d{\sigma}_{\perp}/dt + d{\sigma}_{\parallel}/dt]\;.\ ] ] for example , at @xmath356 gev the compensation in @xmath357 ( [ ph - asym ] ) takes place at @xmath358 for the @xmath359 photoproduction .
since at high energies and small @xmath360 ebm ( as any reasonable model explaining the sharp forward peak in @xmath361 for the @xmath359 photoproduction ) gives the sign and size of @xmath362 in the forward direction , the compensation curves for @xmath362 above the resonance region go through approximately the same values of the angles @xmath363 as for @xmath364 .
this fact is explained practically model independently .
the plausibility of assumption that the compensation curves at high energies and small angles and at @xmath166 are not much different from the corresponding curves for @xmath25 is justified by successful application of ebm to the description of the processes of electroproduction and @xmath365 at high energies and @xmath366 @xcite . in any case , the compensation curves help one to reveal the optimal experimental conditions for studying the form factors @xmath367 and @xmath368 in processes of the pion electroproduction and ipe .
e. amaldi , s. fubini , g. furlan , _ electroproduction at low energy and hadron form factors _ , springer tracts in modern physics * 83 * ( springer , berlin , 1979 ) .
surovtsev , f.g .
tkebuchava , yad .
fiz . * 55 * , 2138 ( 1992 ) .
blokhintseva , yu.s .
surovtsev , m. nagy , acta physica slovaca * 49 * , 351 ( 1999 ) .
titov , b. kmpfer , eur .
j. a * 12 * , 217 ( 2001 ) .
berger , m. diehl , b. pire , phys .
b * 523 * , 265 ( 2001 ) .
lutz , b. friman , m. soyeur , nucl .
a * 713 * , 97 ( 2003 ) .
bratkovskaya , w. cassing , u. mosel , nucl .
a * 686 * , 568 ( 2001 ) .
geffen , phys . rev . * 125 * , 1745 ( 1962 ) ; j. loubaton , j. tran thanh van , nucl .
b * 2 * , 342 ( 1967 ) .
surovtsev , f.g .
tkebuchava , jinr communication p2 - 4561 ( dubna , 1969 ) ; t.d .
blokhintseva , yu.s .
surovtsev , f.g .
tkebuchava , yad . fiz . * 21 * , 850 ( 1975 ) .
a.m. baldin , v.a .
suleymanov , phys .
b * 37 * , 305 ( 1971 ) ; jinr communication p2 - 7096 ( dubna , 1973 ) .
surovtsev , f.g .
tkebuchava , yad . fiz . * 16 * , 1294 ( 1972 ) .
kulish , yad . fiz . * 16 * , 1102 ( 1972 ) .
g. furlan , n. paver , g. verzegnassi , nuovo cimento a * 32 * , 75 ( 1976 ) .
n. dombey , b.s . read , j. phys .
g * 3 * , 1659 ( 1977 ) .
tkebuchava , nuovo cimento a * 47 * , 415 ( 1978 ) .
smirnov , n.m .
shumeiko , yad . fiz . * 17 * , 1266 ( 1973 ) .
a. bietti , s. petrarca , nuovo cimento a * 22 * , 595 ( 1974 ) ; lett .
nuovo cimento * 13 * , 539 ( 1975 ) .
surovtsev , f.g .
tkebuchava , yad . fiz . * 21 * , 753 ( 1975 ) .
samios , phys . rev . * 121 * , 275 ( 1961 ) ; h. kobrak , nuovo cimento * 20 * , 1115 ( 1961 ) ; s. devons _
et al . _ ,
phys . rev . *
184 * , 1356 ( 1969 ) ; m.n .
et al . _ ,
b * 24 * , 349 ( 1967 ) ; c.m .
et al . _ ,
d * 28 * , 660 ( 1983 ) ; h. fonvieille _
et al . _ ,
b * 233 * , 60 , 65 ( 1989 ) .
yu.k . akimov _
et al . _ , yad . fiz . *
13 * , 748 ( 1971 ) ; s.f .
* 16 * , 185 ( 1972 ) ; * 18 * , 102 ( 1973 ) ; * 24 * , 1127 ( 1976 ) ; g.d .
et al . _ ,
ibid . * 36 * , 322 ( 1982 ) ; * 46 * , 1360 ( 1987 ) ; v.v .
et al . _ , ibid . *
33 * , 357 ( 1981 ) .
v.n . baturin _
et al . _ , yad . fiz . * 47 * , 708 ( 1988 ) .
g. bardin , phys .
b * 255 * , 149 ( 1991 ) ; ibid . *
257 * , 514 ( 1991 ) .
b * 52 * , 227 ( 1974 ) ; r.c.e .
et al . _ , nuovo cimento a * 1 * , 475 ( 1971 ) .
goghilidze , yu.s .
surovtsev , f.g .
tkebuchava , yad . fiz .
* 45 * , 1085 ( 1987 ) .
adler , ann .
( ny ) * 50 * , 189 ( 1968 ) .
c * 61 * , 035204 ( 2000 ) .
particle data group , d.e .
groom _ et al .
j. c * 15 * , 1 ( 2000 ) .
s. capstick , phys .
d * 46 * , 2864 ( 1992 ) .
yu.s . surovtsev , author s summary , 2 - 11047 , dubna , 1977 ( unpublished ) .
aznauryan , phys .
c * 67 * , 015209 ( 2003 ) .
j. volmer ( jlab f@xmath223 collaboration ) , phys . rev
. lett . * 86 * , 1713 ( 2001 ) .
gari and w. kruempelmann , phys .
d * 45 * , 1817 ( 1992 ) .
et al . _ ,
* 26 * , 1672 ( 1971 ) ; nucl .
b * 120 * , 395 ( 1977 ) ; p. benz _
et al . _ , nucl .
b * 65 * , 158 ( 1973 ) ; v. rossi _
et al . _ , nuovo cimento a * 13 * , 59 ( 1973 ) ; m. beneventano _ et al . _ , nuovo cimento a * 19 * , 529 ( 1974 ) ; g.von holtey , g. knop , h. stein , j. stmpfig , and h. wahlen , nucl .
b * 70 * , 379 ( 1974 ) ; p.e . scheffler and p.l .
walden , nucl .
b * 75 * , 125 ( 1974 ) ; a.j .
b * 101 * , 1 ( 1975 ) ; p.e .
et al . _ ,
a * 296 * , 373 ( 1978 ) ; m.t .
et al . _ ,
a * 324 * , 301 ( 1979 ) ; j.c .
comiso , d.j .
blasberg , r.p .
haddock , b.m.k .
nefkens , p. truoel , and l.j .
verhey , phys .
d * 12 * , 719 ( 1979 ) ; a. bagheri , k.a .
aniol , f. entezami , m.d .
hasinoff , d.f .
measday j - m .
poutissou , m. salomon , and b.c .
robertson , phys .
c * 38 * , 875 ( 1988 ) ; g.j .
kima , j. arendsa , w.j .
briscoec , j. engelagea , b.m.k .
nefkensa , m.e .
sadlerd , and h.j .
ziocka , phys .
d * 40 * , 244 ( 1989 ) .
k. btzner _
et al . _ ,
b * 39 * , 575 ( 1972 ) .
g. fischer _
et al . _ , z. phys . * 245 * , 225 ( 1971 ) .
g. bardin , j. duclos , a. magnon , b. michel and j.c .
montret , nucl .
b * 120 * , 45 ( 1977 ) .
h. breuker _
et al . _ , nucl .
b * 146 * , 285 ( 1978 ) .
dubovik , l.a .
tosunyan , fiz .
elem . chastits . at .
14*(5 ) , 1193 ( 1983 ) .
g. hhler and e. pietarinen , nucl .
b * 95 * , 210 ( 1975 )
. s. dubnika _
et al . _ , nuovo cimento a * 106 * , 1253 ( 1993 )
. g. bardin _
et al . _ ,
a * 352 * , 365 ( 1981 ) ; phys .
b * 104 * , 320 ( 1981 ) . v. brudanin _ et al . _ ,
a * 587 * , 577 ( 1995 ) .
volkov and c. weiss , phys .
d * 56 * , 221 ( 1997 ) .
yu.l . kalinovsky and c. weiss , z. phys .
c * 63 * , 275 ( 1994 ) ; i.v .
et al . _ , modelling * 6 * , 57 ( 1994 ) . s. choi _
et al . _ ,
lett . * 71 * , 3927 ( 1993 ) .
k. hagiwara _
( particle data group ) , phys .
d * 66 * , 010001 ( 2002 ) .
yu.i . ivanshin _
et al . _ , nuovo cimento a * 107 * , 2855 ( 1994 ) .
ivanshin , n.b .
skachkov , nuovo cimento a * 108 * , 1263 ( 1995 ) .
a.n . ivanov , m. nagy , and n.i .
troitskaya , phys .
c * 59 * , 451 ( 1999 ) .
gerasimov , chinese j. phys .
* 34 * , 848 ( 1996 ) .
v.a . meshcheryakov and g.v .
meshcheryakov , yad . fiz . * 60 * , 1400 ( 1997 ) .
guan - yeu chen , s.s .
kamalov , shin nan yang , d. drechsel , l. tiator , nucl .
a * 723 * , 447 ( 2003 ) .
d. krupa , v.a .
meshcheryakov , yu.s .
surovtsev , nuovo cimento a * 109 * , 281 ( 1996 ) .
et al . _ , yad . fiz . *
44 * , 1471 ( 1986 ) .
@xmath28-matrix theory of strong interactions _
( benjamin , new york , 1962 ) . j.d .
bjorken and j.d .
walecka , ann .
( ny ) * 38 * , 35 ( 1966 ) .
devenish and d.h .
lyth , nucl .
b * 93 * , 109 ( 1975 ) .
n.n . achasov and l.m .
samkov , yad . fiz .
* 8 * , 1201 ( 1968 ) .
cho and j.j .
sakurai , phys .
b * 30 * , 119 ( 1969 ) .
f.e . close and f.j .
gilmal , phys .
b * 38 * , 541 ( 1972 ) .
s.f . berezhnev _
_ , yad . fiz .
* 26 * , 547 ( 1977 ) .
|
methods are set forth for determining the hadron electromagnetic structure in the sub-@xmath0-threshold timelike region of the virtual - photon `` mass '' and for investigating the nucleon weak structure in the spacelike region from experimental data on the process @xmath1 at low energies .
these methods are formulated using the unified description of photoproduction , electroproduction , and inverse electroproduction of pions in the first resonance region in the framework of the dispersion - relation model and on the basis of the model - independent properties of inverse electroproduction .
applications of these methods are also shown .
|
nuclei in interaction with external fields display a wide variety of collective vibrations known as giant resonances , associated with various degrees of freedom and multipolarities .
the giant isovector dipole resonance and the giant isoscalar quadrupole resonance are the most studied examples in this class of phenomena .
a particular mode , that is associated with vibrations in the number of particles , has been predicted in the 70s@xcite and discussed , under the name of giant pairing resonance , in the middle of the 80 s in a number of papers@xcite .
this phenomenon , despite some early efforts aimed to resolve some broad bump in the high - lying spectrum in ( p , t ) reactions@xcite , is still without any conclusive experimental confirmation . for a discussion , in particluar in connection with two - particle transfer reactions , on many aspects of pairing correlations in nuclei
we refer to a recent review@xcite .
we have studied the problem of collective pairing modes at high excitation energy in two neutron transfer reactions with the aim to prove the advantage of using unstable beam as a new tool to enhance the excitation of such modes @xcite .
the main point is that with standard available beams one is faced with a large energy mismatch that strongly hinders the excitation of high - lying states and favours the transition to the ground state of the final system .
instead the optimum q - value condition in the ( @xmath3he,@xmath4he ) stripping reaction suppresses the ground state and should allow the transition to 10 - 15 mev energy region .
we have performed particle - particle rpa calculations on lead and bcs+rpa on tin , as paradigmatic examples of normal and superfluid systems , evaluating the response to the pairing operator .
subsequently the two - neutron transfer form factors have been constructed in the framework of the macroscopic model@xcite and used in dwba computer codes .
we have estimated cross - sections of the order of some millibarns , dominating over the mismatched transition to the ground state .
recently we added similar calculations on other much studied targets to give some guide for experimental work .
the formal analogy between particle - hole and particle - particle excitations is very well established both from the theoretical side@xcite and from the experimental side for what concern low - lying pairing vibrations around closed shell nuclei and pairing rotations in open shells .
the predicted concentration of strength of a @xmath5 character in the high - energy region ( 8 - 15 mev for most nuclei ) is understood microscopically as the coherent superposition of 2p ( or 2h ) states in the next major shell above the fermi level .
we have roughly depicted the situation in fig .
( [ fig1 ] ) . in closed shell nuclei the addition of a pair of particles ( or holes ) to the next major shell , with a total energy @xmath6 , is expected to have a high degree of collectivity .
also in the case of open shell nuclei the same is expected for the excitation of a pair of particles with @xmath7 energies .
for normal nuclei the hamiltonian with a monopole strength interaction reads : @xmath8 where @xmath9 annihilates a pair of particles coupled to @xmath10 total angular momentum . getting rid of all the technicalities of the solution of the pp - rpa equations ( that may be found in the already cited work by the author ) we merely state that the pairing phonon may be expressed as a superposition of 2p ( or 2h ) states with proper forward and backward amplitudes ( @xmath11 and @xmath12 ) .
the pair transfer strength , that is a measure of the amount of collectivity of a each state @xmath13 , is given by : @xmath14 .
\label{p5}\ ] ] this quantity is plotted in the first column of fig .
( [ fig2 ] ) for the removal ( upper panel ) and addition mode ( lower panel ) . in the same figure
are reported the pairing strength parameters for the states of @xmath1sn . to obtain these last quantities for superfluid spherical
nuclei one has to rewrite the hamiltonian according to the bcs transformation and has to solve more complex rpa equations . in this case
the pairing strength for the addition of two particles is given , for each state @xmath13 , by : @xmath15_{00}|0\rangle = \sum_{j } \sqrt{2j+1 } [ u^{2}_{j } x_{n}(j ) + v^{2}_{j}y_{n}(j)]\ ] ] where the @xmath16 and @xmath17 are the usual occupation probabilities .
the amount of collectivity is a clear signal of the structural existence of giant pairing vibrations in the high - lying energy region .
we also report here a number of analogous results for other commonly studied targets = 9.4pc = 9.4pc = 9.4pc with the aim of giving some indications to experimentalists on the reasons why we think that lead and tin are some of the most promising candidates .
we have studied two isotopes of calcium with closed shells .
even if the absolute magnitudes of the @xmath18 is lower , it is worthwhile to notice that some enhancement is seen in the more neutron - rich @xmath19ca with respect to @xmath20ca .
an important role in this change is certainly due to the different shell structure of the two nuclei as well as to the scheme that we implemented to obtain the set of single particle levels .
the latter is responsible for the collectivity of the removal modes in both ca isotopes and also for the difficulty in finding out a collective state in the addition modes .
we display also results for @xmath21zr where the strength is much more fragmented and the identification of the gpv is more difficult . in the work of broglia and bes estimates for the energy of the pairing resonance are given as @xmath22 mev and @xmath23 mev for normal and superfluid systems respectively .
our figures follow roughly these prescriptions based on simple arguments ( and much more grounded in the case of normal nuclei ) as evident from table [ ta1 ] .
.comparison of position of gpv between our calculation and the broglia and bes estimate .
[ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] = 13.8pc = 13.8pc these cross - sections have been derived for sharp states , and we refer to the numbers in the last table when speaking of order of magnitude estimates . obviously cross - section in the high - lying energy region have a finite ( and large ) width that should be inserted for a more realistic description of the spectrum .
we have chosen a simple scheme that gives a lorentzian distribution with a width that grows quadratically with the excitation energy , @xmath24 , with @xmath25 adjusted to give a width of 4 mev for the gpv .
this could seem rather arbitrary since there is no reason for an _ a priori _ assignment of this quantity .
we have been brought to this simple prescription because other collective states ( of different nature ) lying in the same energy region display similar values for their width , and it is reasonable to assume some rule to narrow the low - energy states and to broaden the high - energy ones .
the final achievements for the four reactions studied in detail are presented in figure [ fig4 ] where the areas corresponding to the cross - sections given above have been shaded to give a feeling of the relative magnitudes of the transition to the ground states and to the gpv s . it is worthwhile to note that in the case of pb there is a considerable gain in using unstable beams , while in sn is much less evident .
one sees the need for unstable helium when compares the magnitude for the pairing resonance in the right a ) and b ) panels with the peak at zero energy : in the first panel the transition to the ground state is extremely hindered .
a @xmath3he beam is currently available ( or it will be available in the very near future ) in many radioactive ion beams facilities around the world and the calculations that we have presented could allow a planning for future experiments aimed to study the not yet completely unraveled role of pairing interaction in common nuclei , using exotic weakly bound nuclei as useful tools .
the author wishes to gratefully acknowledge discussions with andrea vitturi , hugo sofia and wolfram von oertzen on various aspects of theoretical and experimental nuclear physics .
the participation at the _ vii international school - seminar on heavy ion physics , dubna , russia _ 2002 has been supported by the infn .
xxxx r.a.broglia and d.r.bes , plb691291977 .
m.w.herzog , r.j.liotta and l.j.sibanda , _ phys .
_ c * 31 * , 259 , ( 1985 ) .
et al _ , prl 3914511977 .
w.von oertzen and a.vitturi , _ rep .
phys . _ * 64 * , 1247 - 1337 , ( 2001 ) .
l.fortunato , w.von oertzen , h.m.sofia and a. vitturi , _ eur .
_ a * 14 * , ( 2002 ) , in press . c.h.dasso and a.vitturi ( editors ) ,
_ collective aspects in pair transfer phenomena _ , sif proc .
18 , ( editrice compositori bologna , 1987 ) .
d.r.bes and r.a.broglia , _ phys .
_ c * 3 * , 2349 , ( 1971 ) .
c.h.dasso and g.pollarolo , plb 1552231985 .
c.h.dasso and a.vitturi , prl 596341987 .
|
we investigate the possible signature of the presence of giant pairing states at excitation energy of about 10 mev via two - particle transfer reactions induced by neutron - rich weakly - bound projectiles . performing particle - particle rpa calculations on @xmath0pb and bcs+rpa calculations on @xmath1sn
, we obtain the pairing strength distribution for two particles addition and removal modes .
estimates of two - particle transfer cross sections can be obtained in the framework of the macroscopic model. the weak - binding nature of the projectile kinematically favours transitions to high - lying states . in the case of @xmath2
reaction we predict a population of the giant pairing vibration with cross sections of the order of a millibarn , dominating over the mismatched transition to the ground state .
|
the detection of gravitational waves ( gws ) will rank as one of the major scientific achievements of this century .
their detection will open up a new observational window to the universe , revealing dynamic sources of strong field relativistic gravity previously inaccessible through conventional astronomical instruments .
our understanding of space - time and matter under the most extreme conditions will be transformed .
although there has been no direct detection of gws to date , indirect evidence for their existence comes from high precision , nobel - prize winning measurements of the pulsar psr 1913 + 16 and its companion neutron star ( ns ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the gw emission that drives the system s orbital decay is in agreement with the predictions of general relativity to better than 1% @xcite .
when such binary neutron star ( bns ) systems eventually coalesce , they are predicted to emit copious amounts of gws @xcite .
these sources will be prime targets for the new generation of gw detectors , led by advanced ligo ( aligo ; * ? ? ? * ) which is set to begin observing during the second half of 2015 and advanced virgo a year later @xcite . at final sensitivity
, these advanced detectors are expected to detect bns mergers at a rate within the range 0.4400 yr@xmath0 @xcite .
compact binary coalescences ( cbcs ) consisting of at least one black hole ( bh ) are also targets for gw detectors ; although there is compelling evidence for their existence @xcite , the event rates of these sources for aligo detection is not well known .
one realisation in the last decade is that coalescing systems of ns / ns or ns / bh events could be the progenitors of short - hard gamma ray bursts ( sgrbs ) ; transient events routinely observed throughout the electromagnetic ( em ) spectrum @xcite .
there exist other types of em , neutrino and cosmic ray emissions that may also be associated with gw events .
these include long - duration gamma ray bursts ( lgrbs ; * ? ? ?
* ) , short gamma ray repeaters @xcite , supernovae @xcite , fast radio bursts @xcite as well as others .
history has already shown that multi - wavelength astronomy can play an important role in unveiling new phenomena . in the last decade , x - ray , optical and radio follow - ups have all transformed and revealed new processes in our understanding of gamma ray bursts ( grbs ) ; combining em observations with those in the gw domain will too provide new insight into the internal engines and mechanisms at play in a multitude of different sources .
a new generation of sensitive , wide - field telescopes , advancements in time domain astronomy and upgrades to neutrino and cosmic ray detectors can provide a coordinated network for discovery .
the possible simultaneous detection of photons , neutrinos or high energy particles with gws would be a landmark moment for astrophysics , initiating a new era of _ _ multi - messenger _
_ astronomy , for the first time including gw . maximising
the potential offered by gw observations involves the development of a worldwide , multi - messenger network .
australian facilities are ideally placed to foster scientific exchanges in this new era and agreements have already been established . to conduct em follow - up of gw triggers , memorandums of understanding ( mous ) have been signed between the ligo / virgo gw collaboration and a number of facilities either based in australia or with strong australian involvement ; these include : the anglo - australian telescope , the australian square kilometer array pathfinder ( askap ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the cherenkov telescope array ( cta ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the high energy stereoscopic system ( h.e.s.s ; * ? ? ?
* ) , icecube @xcite , the murchison widefield array ( mwa ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and the skymapper @xcite , the gw optical transient observer ( goto ) and zadko @xcite optical telescopes .
in this paper , we focus on the most probable multi - messenger observations from the advanced detector era ; those associated with grbs .
whilst doing so , we consider the contribution that the australian facilities can make to the worldwide multi - messenger effort .
the structure of this paper is as follows : section 2 describes gw astronomy .
sections 3 and 4 introduce sgrbs and lgrbs and describe how co - ordinated gw and multiwavelength observations of these events can provide breakthrough science .
section 5 acts as a primer for those unfamiliar with the concepts and terminologies of detection and data analysis often used in the gw domain ; this section is not designed to be exhaustive but to present some of the most important concepts in gw detection and data analysis .
section 6 discusses the expected rates and detection ranges for gw sources .
the next two sections describe two of the strategies that form the basis for coordinated gw and em observations in the gw era .
section 7 discusses em triggered gw searches ; these could likely yield the first coincident gw - em event through archival gw data .
section 8 discusses the em follow - up of gw triggers ; this strategy is highly challenging due to the large positional uncertainties of gw observations but the potential rewards for success are without doubt highly significant .
section 10 discusses the australian facilities involved in the co - ordinated science programs with aligo / adv and we highlight the areas in which they could contribute in this new frontier .
finally , in section 11 we discuss the role neutrino follow - up plays in gw detection .
gravitational waves are produced by regions of space - time that are distorted by high velocity bulk motions of matter .
the timescale of the motions determine the frequency of the gw emission ; ground based detectors will target systems with masses in the range 110@xmath1 @xmath2 , which emit in the 1 hz10 khz band .
this frequency range , covering the audio band , has motivated the characterisation of interferometric gw astronomy as `` listening to the universe '' .
instruments capable of achieving detections will begin observations in the second half of 2015 .
advanced ligo , a pair of us based interferometric detectors at hanford and livingston ( usa * ? ? ?
* ) will have its first observational science run ( o1 ) in late-2015 ; a year later it will be joined by the italian advanced virgo ( adv ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) for a second observing run ( o2 ) .
the `` advanced '' network of interferometric gw detectors will eventually have 10 times the sensitivity of the first generation instruments .
the increased sensitivity translates into a factor @xmath3 increase in observed volume , making detections expected rather than plausible .
additional instruments are expected to eventually join the network .
kagra , a japanese detector , is envisioned to begin operation in 2018 - 19 @xcite and ligo - india is expected to be operational from 2020 , reaching a design sensitivity at the same level as aligo by around 2022 @xcite .
the gw observations made by these instruments will differ from most conventional em observations in several ways : 1 .
gws are not scattered or obscured by intervening material like dust so provide a window into the densest regions of the universe .
as gw detectors observe an amplitude rather than a flux , the measure of detectability follows an inverse relationship with distance rather than the conventional inverse square law .
therefore , number counts of a homogeneous distribution of standard - candle sources increases with distance , @xmath4 , as , @xmath5 , rather than , @xmath6 ; 3 . as gws couple weakly to the detectors ,
even very local astronomical sources of gws have to be highly energetic emitters of gravitational radiation ; 4 .
gw detectors are nearly omnidirectional , with a nearly @xmath7 steradian sensitivity to astrophysical events with a greater than average response over more than 40% of the sky .
the first point implies that gw observations can allow us to view astrophysical phenomena inaccessible by other means .
the gravitational window can therefore enable frontier explorations in the low to intermediate redshift universe ( @xmath8 ) of sources that are electromagnetically invisible for much , or all , of their lives .
the second point means that a factor 2 improvement in the sensitivity of a gw detector results in a factor 8 increase in the volume of the universe being probed .
the third point emphasises a detection bias for detecting the most highly energetic astrophysical events .
the typical fluxes of gw sources are of order @xmath9 jy , far greater than equivalent fluxes typically observed in the radio domain ( @xmath10jy jy ) .
the final point means that gw detectors are naturally survey instruments over a wide band of frequencies ( 105000 hz ) .
there are a number of types of em counterparts that may be associated with gw emissions @xcite .
as some of these counterparts are quite speculative , this paper focuses on gw signals associated with grbs .
other sources of simultaneous em and gw emission include supernovae as well as multiple emission mechanisms from nss ; for a review of the latter , see the accompanying article in this series @xcite . in the next few sections we provide a summary of both sgrbs and lgrbs and the type of gw / em associations that could be targeted in the gw era .
some of these predictions are based on solid foundations whilst some are more speculative . in considering the latter
, we note that when a new window of observation has been opened in the past , the discoveries that transform our understanding of the universe have often been the least expected .
+ gravitational waves from the merger of coalescing binary systems of ns / ns and ns / bhs are confidently predicted to have observable em counterparts .
this expectation is a result of the connection between these events and sgrbs ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the evidence stems from a number of different channels .
firstly , the dynamic timescales of discs predicted from the merger of cbcs are consistent with the durations of sgrbs .
secondly , em follow - ups of sgrbs have never provided an associated supernova .
thirdly , sgrb afterglows have been localised to galaxies harbouring older stellar populations with offsets of order tens of kpc from their galactic centers ; this is consistent with post - natal kick velocities of 100s of km s@xmath0 , and also with the fainter and shorter lived afterglows expected from an ambient interstellar medium at a large offset .
finally , as is discussed in [ kilonova ] , the discovery of a faint em transient called a _
kilonova _ has provided the strongest observational evidence to date of the sgrb / cbc association .
conclusive proof of the cbc / sgrb association will be provided through gw observations .
coincident em and gw observations of sgrbs could also provide a fascinating insight to the dominant mechanisms at the heart of grbs .
low - latency gw pipelines could enable multi - wavelength follow - up measurements of the prompt emission , constraining both the underlying central engines and the emission mechanisms at work .
later - time multi - wavelength follow - ups can provide insight through extensive coverage of the sgrb afterglow .
a number of em counterparts have been predicted to accompany the inspiral and merger of ns / ns and ns / bh systems . in figure [ fig_mm_scenarios ]
we show the likely outcomes of these mergers and in the following sections we will briefly review the most likely em counterparts that could accompany cbcs . during the final stages of the merger of a compact binary ,
the system is expected to launch a highly relativistic jet that interacts with itself and the surrounding medium ( the fireball model for grbs ; e.g. * ? ? ?
collisions of material moving at different velocities within the jet will lead to internal shocks , giving short - lived bursts of gamma - rays that we detect as the sgrb prompt emission . as the accretion timescale is expected to be @xmath112 seconds @xcite ,
the grbs associated with compact binary mergers are typically shorter in duration than those associated with core - collapse supernovae ( explaining the observed distribution of grbs ; * ? ? ?
. however , the division between these two populations is not easily identifiable from the prompt gamma - ray emission alone ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . a number of _
fermi_-lat grbs have shown @xmath12gev emission ( even at redshifts as distant as @xmath13 ) .
two bursts were observed with gamma - ray photons reaching energies up to 94gev ( grb 130427a ) and 62gev ( grb 131231a ) this supports the suggestion that the photon energies may extend higher than previously assumed @xcite .
significantly , these discoveries have not been limited to lgrbs , with sgrbs also showing high energy photons and gev emission often continuing for 10 s of seconds beyond the initial burst . the fact that _
fermi_-lat discovered a photon of energy 31gev during the prompt phase of grb 090510 @xcite is promising for co - ordinated observations between gw detectors and ground - based cherenkov telescope arrays @xcite operating at @xmath12 10 gev .
additionally , sgrbs with time - extended emission have recently been cited as promising targets for cherenkov telescope arrays @xcite .
one exciting possibility is the observation of prompt optical flashes .
so far , these emissions have only been observed in lgrbs @xcite . an early optical emission correlated with the prompt gamma - rays could indicate a common origin related to the internal shocks @xcite .
a number of studies have suggested that compact binary mergers could generate prompt coherent radio emission ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
such mechanisms include excitation of the plasma surrounding a compact binary merger by gws @xcite , from a dynamically - generated magnetic field after the merger @xcite , or from the onset of the collision of the forward shock with the surrounding medium @xcite . however , the detectability of emission from these processes will be dependent upon the scattering by the surrounding environment @xcite .
nonetheless , these studies suggest compact binary mergers are an interesting contender for the progenitors of fast radio bursts ( frbs ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , which are currently unknown .
plateaus and flares in x - ray light curves following grbs are signatures of ongoing energy injection .
this could be caused by late - time accretion onto a central black hole ( unlikely in the compact binary scenario ; see discussion in * ? ? ?
* ) , or from ongoing energy injection from the spindown of a newly born neutron star .
indeed , recent studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) have shown that the merger of two nss could result in a supramassive ns ; a star with a mass greater than the non - rotating maximum mass but supported from further collapse through rotation @xcite .
around 60% of x - ray afterglow light curves of sgrbs observed by the _ swift _
satellite @xcite have shown plateaus lasting 10010000 s after the burst ; these have been attributed to electromagnetic spin - down emissions from protomagnetars @xcite formed via the merger of two neutron stars @xcite .
observations of the plateau phase can also be used to constrain the ns equation of state , with gw observations of the inspiral phase significantly aiding this endeavour @xcite if the post - merger remnant is an ns , early optical afterglow as bright as 17th magnitude in r band ( assuming a distance of @xmath14 mpc ; see [ section_cbc_ranges ] ) could be produced from dissipation of a wide - beamed protomagnetar wind @xcite .
this magnetar wind could launch ejecta at relativistic speeds which would interact with the surrounding medium and produce a bright broadband afterglow from synchrotron radiation @xcite .
gravitational wave emission may also accompany an afterglow plateau if a millisecond magnetar is born from the collision .
multiple mechanisms for generating such gws exist in nascent neutron stars , including secular bar modes ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , @xmath15-modes @xcite , and magnetic - field induced stellar deformations @xcite .
such emission could be observable by aligo out to @xmath16 mpc @xcite .
in fact , the x - ray light curve itself can be used to constrain the total gw emission from these systems @xcite .
some plateaus following sgrbs exhibit an extremely steep decay phase , commonly interpreted as the collapse of the nascent neutron star to a black hole @xcite .
such collapse could potentially produce an frb when the magnetic field lines snap as they cross the bh horizon @xcite , which is expected to occur @xmath17 s after the merger @xcite .
a low latency gw trigger could enable prompt follow - ups to test this connection @xcite . as the relativistic jet propagates
, it collides with the medium surrounding the progenitor resulting in a forward shock travelling into the surrounding medium , and a reverse shock propagating back up the jet ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
these shock fronts produce multi - wavelength synchrotron emission , initially peaking in the x - ray and moving through the different wavelengths to radio as it fades .
the typical afterglow of grbs is attributed to the forward shock emission and the brightness of this afterglow is dependent upon a number of parameters , including the density of the surrounding medium .
therefore , in a low density environment , the forward shock component is expected to be relatively faint .
the multi - wavelength afterglows of sgrbs have been observed and are typically fainter than those of lgrbs @xcite .
this is consistent with sgrbs being less energetic than lgrbs and with their locations in lower density environments .
the reverse shock has also been observed for sgrb 051221a ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) .
a ` kilonova ' is been predicted to form after the merger of two nss .
this faint optical transient is powered by the radioactive decay of the ejected neutron rich matter @xcite and could reach around 21-23 mag in the optical and 21-24 mag in the nir for a source at 200 mpc @xcite .
recent optical and near - infrared follow - up observations of grb 130603b have provided the most conclusive evidence to date of this scenario , reinforcing the theory that compact object mergers are the progenitors of sgrbs @xcite .
these observations have added significantly to other observational evidence in support of this scenario @xcite .
coincident em and gw observations could confirm that sgrbs are indeed the result of coalescing compact binaries .
an additional prompt em emission related to the kilonova mechanism has also recently been suggested by @xcite .
this has been inspired by studies that suggest a small fraction of the ejected neutron rich matter can expand rapidly enough to avoid r - process capture @xcite .
the suggestion is that @xmath18-decay from free neutrons in the outermost layers of this ejecta could power optical emission on a timescale of hours after the merger , peaking at around magnitude 22 in the u - band for a source . for a source at 200 mpc
this signal would peak at around magnitude 22 in the u - band and would act as a precursor to a kilonova .
lgrbs are amongst the most luminous transient events in the universe in terms of em radiation per unit solid angle .
these beamed emissions have been observed to last up to @xmath19 s @xcite and can radiate a total energy equivalent to that of the sun in its entire 10 gyr lifetime .
the extreme luminosities allow lgrbs to be seen out to cosmological volumes , making them a probe of the high redshift universe ( @xmath20 ) .
the favoured scenario for these bursts is described by the collapsar model @xcite in which the inner part of a wolf - rayet star progenitor collapses to form a rapidly rotating black hole .
high angular momentum enables the infalling matter to form an accretion disk , which in turn provides the energy reservoir to power an ultra - relativistic jet that blasts its way through the stellar envelope .
the observed radiation is explained through synchrotron and/or inverse compton emission from the accelerated electrons in internal and external shocks .
some authors have suggested instead that the central engines may consist of magnetars @xcite .
there is observational evidence to support this scenario for at least a proportion of lgrbs @xcite .
the connection between lgrbs with the collapse of massive stars @xcite has been supported by afterglow observations in or near dense regions of active star - formation ; predominantly dwarf starburst field galaxies @xcite . as mentioned earlier
, their denser environments , as well as their higher emission energies , mean that the multiwavelength afterglows of lgrbs are typically brighter than those that occur from sgrbs @xcite . in terms of gw emissions from these events
, a number of lgrbs have been associated with core - collapse supernova @xcite . modelling
the gw emission from these supernovae is very complex , requiring a combination of general relativistic hydrodynamics , magnetic fields , rotation , neutrino transport and nuclear physics @xcite .
simulations have so far provided a picture of a very complex and chaotic behavior that includes shock formation and turbulence that create highly complex waveforms with multiple sharp bursts over ms durations . however , most scenarios suggest an event may have to be within tens of kpc for detection . as most lgrbs occur at cosmological distances , the vast majority of their gw signals will be out of reach for advanced detectors . the requirement for rapid rotation to produce the disc in a grb @xcite allows for alternative emission mechanisms that could produce detectable gws out to 10s of mpc @xcite .
fragmentation instabilities could be produced in the core or in the disc @xcite .
rapid rotation could also give rise to rotational instabilities in the protoneutron star remnant @xcite a number of studies have suggested there exists a sub - population of lgrbs known as low - luminosity grbs ( _ _ ll__grbs ) .
these events have isotropic equivalent gamma - ray luminosities 2 - 3 orders of magnitude below classical lgrbs @xcite and have only been detected at low-@xmath21 due to their lower energy emissions ( the closest was grb980425 at z = 0.0085 or 36mpc ) .
as such their rates have been predicted to be 23 orders of magnitude greater than lgrbs .
observations have confirmed that both lgrbs and _ _ ll__grbs produce supernovae , suggesting that the _ _ ll__grbs may just be lower - energy events from the tail of the distribution .
this has been a long going debate and attempts to address it have used statistical arguments @xcite , fits to the peak flux distribution @xcite , and simulation @xcite . the suggestion that _ _
ll__grbs could be just normal lgrbs viewed off - axis was discounted based on statistical arguments , as it would produce a far higher local rate density than expected from lgrbs and would require narrower opening angles for lgrbs than determined from the breaks in afterglow lightcurves @xcite . recently , an analysis of _ _ ll__grb 060218 has suggested that the main difference in the two bursts arises from an extended low - mass envelope in _ _
the existence of such an envelope can smother the jet and drive a mildly relativistic shock resulting in a much lower luminosity than that produced by an ultra - relativistic jet that is able to penetrate through the bare progenitor star .
interestingly , the statistical arguments suggesting separate populations put forward by @xcite can also support these two different scenarios .
it is therefore possible that gw emission mechanisms could be driven by the same type of engine for both these classes .
the output from a single gw detector consists of a time series data stream , @xmath22 , composed of the detector response to a gw signal , @xmath23 , and the detector noise @xmath24 : @xmath25 in general , @xmath23 will be a linear combination of the two orthogonal transverse polarizations , @xmath26 , weighted by the dimensionless detector antenna pattern functions for the two polarizations @xmath27 : @xmath28 which describe the detector sensitivity to radiation of different polarizations , incident from different directions @xcite .
the angles , @xmath29 and @xmath30 , represent the direction to the source and @xmath31 is the polarization angle of the wave .
a gw detector can follow the phase of a gw signal , so the time series is generally represented in the frequency domain by the strain amplitude spectral density , @xmath32 .
this quantity is defined through the power spectral density @xmath33 , with @xmath34 the fourier transform of the time series .
similarly , one can define a signal power spectral density , @xmath35 , and a noise power spectral density , @xmath36 .
the strain amplitude spectral density is given by : @xmath37 with dimensions of @xmath38 @xcite .
this quantity is often used in plots to display the sensitivity of gw interferometers .
a single gw detector can not determine the polarization state or source direction of a transient signal .
to obtain source localization , a widely separated network of gw detectors is essential .
such a network may employ techniques such as _ coincidence analysis _ , in which individual events from different detectors are correlated in time @xcite , or _ coherent analysis _ , in which synchronized detector outputs are merged before searching for a common pattern @xcite . by effectively resolving the different times of arrival of gw events between members of a network ,
coherent network analysis enables a detector array to become an all - sky monitor with good angular resolution over all source directions . achieving good directional sensitivity
is of paramount importance for gw / em associations . for the sources considered in this review , directional sensitivity is determined through triangulation of arrival times . to maximize the time delays , and hence improve directionality ,
it is advantageous that a network be as geographically widely separated as possible @xcite and as such , a number of detectors are planned to join the aligo / adv network throughout the next decade .
the japanese observatory kagra , should begin operations by around 2018 - 19 @xcite ; at design sensitivity this detector could improve the directional precision of a aligo / adv network by a factor of 1.5 - 2 and the detection rate by a similar factor @xcite .
ligo - india operating at aligo sensitivity will be added to the aligo / adv network by 2022 by then bnss will be detectable out to @xmath39200 mpc and up to 400 events are possible per year @xcite .
an indian detector will improve the angular resolution sufficiently to increase the percentage of gw sources detected within 5 deg@xmath40 from 3 - 7% to 17% @xcite .
it has long been recognized that a gw detector in australia would add the longest baseline to the proposed advanced detector network ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
for example , adding an australian detector to an aligo / adv three detector network can reduce the error in solid angle to tens of arc - minutes for high signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) signals @xcite , dramatically improving the ability to localise gw sources for multi - wavelength follow - up observations .
this scenario could be realised when third generation observatories such as the ` einstein gravitational wave telescope ' ( et ) become a reality in the next decade @xcite .
the optimal site for a detector in the southern hemisphere been shown to be western australia @xcite , the current home to an 80-m baseline prototype gw detector .
the false alarm rate ( far ) is the rate that false positives appear above a given snr threshold , and is dependent on the number of glitches ( non - stationary transients ) in the gw data stream .
it is a critical measure as it determines whether a candidate should be considered for follow - up . for well modeled sources ,
the background of false alarms is at a level close to that of gaussian noise . for un - modeled sources
typically short duration transients the data quality has a greater effect on detection confidence . one therefore sets the threshold high enough so that noise generated false alarms are negligible .
given that the probability , @xmath41 , of observing an event with an amplitude in the range @xmath42 to @xmath43 is given by a gaussian distribution of standard deviation @xmath44 , the probability of obtaining a far greater than a given threshold , @xmath45 , is : @xmath46 to be 99% confident that a gw has been detected , one can set an snr @xmath47 which is equivalent to a far of 1 in 100 years of observation . to see this
one can approximate number of noise instances during that period .
if the detector output sampling rate is 1 khz and the output is processed through @xmath48 filters , in 100 years we get @xmath49 , yielding @xmath50 which is our required snr . for a network of three equivalent detectors combined snr ,
@xmath51 is given as : @xmath52 where @xmath53 represents the snr in the ith detector @xcite .
this shows that for a network of 3 equivalent detectors , to dismiss false alarms at a level @xmath54hz requires @xmath55 . +
the expected gw signals from cbcs takes on the well modelled chirp form shown in figure [ fig_chirp ] .
the figure shows how the signal increases in both amplitude and frequency towards merger ; as it does so it sweeps across the sensitive bandwidth of advanced gw interferometric detectors . for such well - modeled signals , the most efficient signal detection method to extract signals from noisy detector data
is _ matched filtering _ , in which a _ template _ , representing the predicted waveform as a function of time is correlated with the output of a detector @xcite .
a matched signal will produce an output much greater than that expected for pure noise with an optimal snr given as : @xmath56^{1/2}. \label{eq : snr}\ ] ] for well - modelled sources , matched filtering enhances the value of the signal by a factor @xmath57 , where @xmath58 is the number of cycles used in the integration . as inspiralling systems approach merger , even though the rest frame gw amplitude will increase , the number of cycles in each frequency bin , @xmath59 , gets smaller ; therefore the detected signal will decrease .
this means that for inspiraling systems , rather than solely base the predicted amplitude of the radiation as a true indicator of the detectability , we include a measure of the observed cycles .
the value of @xmath58 increases with the compactness of the system as it approaches merger and if observed from a frequency of 10 hz until merger , could produce @xmath60 cycles effectively improving the detectability by a factor of 100 .
however , to achieve such gains , a gw data - stream would have to be filtered by a large number of templates ( of order @xmath61 in near real time
the significant challenges in both theoretical modeling and computational efficiency to achieve this can not be underestimated .
one important aspect of well - modeled inspiralling systems is that a detection can be made 10s of seconds before the merger if enough cycles can be detected to boost the snr @xcite .
figure 2 illustrates this concept showing a chirp signal 40s before the merger phase .
this scenario could allow a low - latency alert to be sent out to em facilities as near real - time as possible to catch a prompt em signature ; the combination of em and gw data in this regime would provide valuable insight into the inner workings of such cataclysmic events .
it is also worth noting that gws can provide an independent measure of luminosity distance , @xmath62 @xcite . during the inspiral phase , the gw strain , and the rate of change of gw frequency
are given as @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the redshifted chirp mass , @xmath65 , and @xmath66 , @xmath67 are the component masses of the binary .
therefore , if one can determine the redshift through , for example , a galaxy association , one can measure the redshift - luminosity distance relation independent of the cosmic distance ladder .
a recent series of papers has reinvigorated this topic by introducing novel methods for breaking the redshift - chirp mass degeneracy with future gw observations @xcite .
although matched filtering is the optimal strategy for gaussian , stationary noise , high amplitude transients due to instrumental and environmental artifacts can render gw data to be non - stationary and non - gaussian . therefore , one must employ robust methods that can reject instrumental artifacts and retain the true gw events .
one such method is the @xmath68 veto that is a powerful consistency test used to reject false alarms @xcite .
this method uses the fact that the quantity @xmath45 is an integral over all frequencies and therefore not sensitive to the contributions from different frequency regions of the broadband signal .
one can split the signal spectrum into @xmath58 bins of equal snr contribution , and draw a comparison with the expected value in each bin ( based on the model template ) .
a true gw event will have power accumulated approximately equally in each of @xmath58 bins ; a noise glitch will have power unevenly distributed and will yield a large @xmath68 value .
, b. l. , abbott , t. m. c. , angstadt , r. , et al .
2012 , in society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series , vol . 8446 , society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series , 11 , d. w. , price , p. a. , soderberg , a. m. , berger , e. , kulkarni , s. r. , sari , r. , frail , d. a. , harrison , f. a. , yost , s. a. , matthews , k. , peterson , b. a. , tanaka , i. , christiansen , j. , & moriarty - schieven , g. h. 2003 , apj , 586 , l5 , r. m. , dekany , r. g. , bebek , c. , et al .
2014 , in society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series , vol .
9147 , society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series , 79 , r. d. , barthelmy , s. d. , denny , r. b. , graham , m. j. , & swinbank , j. 2012 , in society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series , vol .
8448 , society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series , 0
|
the first observations by a worldwide network of advanced interferometric gravitational wave detectors offer a unique opportunity for the astronomical community . at design sensitivity
, these facilities will be able to detect coalescing binary neutron stars to distances approaching , and neutron star - black hole systems to . both of these sources
are associated with gamma ray bursts which are known to emit across the entire electromagnetic spectrum .
gravitational wave detections provide the opportunity for `` multi - messenger '' observations , combining gravitational wave with electromagnetic , cosmic ray or neutrino observations .
this review provides an overview of how australian astronomical facilities and collaborations with the gravitational wave community can contribute to this new era of discovery , via contemporaneous follow - up observations from the radio to the optical and high energy .
we discuss some of the frontier discoveries that will be made possible when this new window to the universe is opened .
binaries : close gravitational waves gamma - ray burst : general methods : observational supernovae : general stars : neutron
|
the physical content of general relativity is contained in einstein s equation , which has a well - posed initial value formulation ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . in principle , therefore , to determine the motion of bodies in general relativity such as binary neutron stars or black holes
one simply needs to provide appropriate initial data ( satisfying the constraint equations ) on a spacelike slice and then evolve this data via einstein s equation .
however , in practice , it is generally impossible to find exact solutions of physical interest describing the motion of bodies by analytic methods .
although it now is possible to find solutions numerically in many cases of interest , it is difficult and cumbersome to do so , and one may overlook subtle effects and/or remain unenlightened about some basic general features of the solutions . therefore , it is of considerable interest to develop methods that yield approximate descriptions of motion in some cases of interest .
in general , the motion of a body of finite size will depend on the details of its composition as well as the details of its internal states of motion .
therefore , one can expect to get a simple description of motion only in some kind of `` point particle limit '' .
however , einstein s equation is nonlinear , and a straightforward analysis @xcite shows that it does not make any mathematical sense to consider solutions of einstein s equation with a distributional stress - energy tensor supported on a worldline .
physically , if one tried to shrink a body down to zero radius at fixed mass , collapse to a black hole would occur before the point particle limit could be reached .
distributional stress - energy tensors supported on a world - line _ do _ make mathematical sense in the context of the linearized einstein equation .
therefore , one might begin a treatment of gravitational self - force by considering a metric perturbation , @xmath3 , in a background metric , @xmath4 , sourced by the stress - energy tensor of a `` point particle '' of mass m , given in coordinates @xmath5 by @xmath6(t , x^i ) = 8 \pi m u_a(t ) u_b(t ) \frac{\delta^{(3)}(x^i - z^i(t))}{\sqrt{-g } } \frac{d\tau}{dt}\,\ , .\ ] ] where @xmath7 is the unit tangent ( i.e. , 4-velocity ) of the worldline @xmath8 defined by @xmath9 , and @xmath10 is the proper time along @xmath8 .
( here @xmath11 is the `` coordinate delta function '' , i.e. , @xmath12 . the right side also could be written covariantly as @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the covariant 4-dimensional delta - function and @xmath10 denotes the proper time along @xmath8 . )
however , this approach presents two major difficulties .
first , the linearized bianchi identity implies that the point particle stress - energy must be conserved .
however , as we shall see explicitly in section [ sec : geodesic ] below , this requires that the worldline @xmath8 of the particle be a geodesic of the background spacetime
. therefore , there are no solutions to equation for non - geodesic source curves , making it hopeless to use this equation to derive corrections to geodesic motion .
this difficulty has been circumvented in @xcite and other references by modifying as follows .
choose the lorenz gauge condition , so that equation takes the form @xmath15 where @xmath16 with @xmath17 .
equation by itself has solutions for any source curve @xmath8 ; it is only when the lorenz gauge condition is adjoined that the equations are equivalent to the linearized einstein equation and geodesic motion is enforced .
therefore , if one solves the lorenz - gauge form of the linearized einstein equation while simply _ ignoring _ the lorenz gauge condition ) truly is ignored in the sense that it is not even pointed out that one has modified the linearized einstein equation , and no attempt is made to justify this modification . ] that was used to derive , one allows for the possibility non - geodesic motion .
of course , this `` gauge relaxation '' of the linearized einstein equation produces an equation inequivalent to the original .
however , because deviations from geodesic motion are expected to be small , the lorenz gauge violation should likewise be small , and it thus has been argued @xcite that solutions to the two systems should agree to sufficient accuracy .
the second difficulty is that the solutions to eq .
( [ eq : wave ] ) are singular on the worldine of the particle . therefore ,
naive attempts to compute corrections to the motion due to @xmath3such as demanding that the particle move on a geodesic of @xmath18are virtually certain to encounter severe mathematical difficulties , analogous to the difficulties encountered in treatments of the electromagnetic self - force problem . despite these difficulties
, there is a general consensus that in the approximation that spin and higher multipole moments may be neglected , the motion of a sufficiently small body ( with no `` incoming radiation '' ) should be described by self consistently solving eq .
( [ eq : wave ] ) via the retarded solution together with @xmath19 where @xmath20 with @xmath21 the retarded green s function for eq .
( [ eq : wave ] ) , normalized with a factor of @xmath22 , following @xcite .
the symbol @xmath23 indicates that the range of the integral extends just short of the retarded time @xmath24 , so that only the `` tail '' ( i.e. , interior of the light cone ) portion of the green s function is used ( see , e.g. , reference @xcite for details ) .
equations ( [ eq : wave ] ) and ( [ eq : misataquwa - intro ] ) are known as the misataquwa equations , and have been derived by a variety of approaches . however , there are difficulties with all of these approaches .
one approach @xcite that has been taken is to parallel the analysis of @xcite in the electromagnetic case and use conservation of effective gravitational stress - energy to determine the motion .
however , this use of distributional sources at second - order in perturbation theory results in infinities that must be `` regularized '' .
although these regularization procedures are relatively natural - looking , the mathematical status of such a derivation is unclear .
another approach @xcite is to postulate certain properties that equations of gravitational self - force should satisfy .
this yields a mathematically clean derivation of the self - force corrected equations of motion .
however , as the authors of @xcite emphasized , the motion of bodies in general relativity is fully described by einstein s equation together with the field equations of the matter sources , so no additional postulates should be needed to obtain an equation of motion , beyond the `` small body '' assumption and other such approximations .
the analysis given by @xcite shows that equation follows from certain plausible assumptions . however , their derivation is thus only a plausibility argument for equation .
similar remarks apply to a later derivation by poisson @xcite that uses a green s function decomposition developed by detweiler and whiting @xcite . a third approach , taken by mino , sasaki , and tanaka @xcite and later poisson @xcite building on previous work of burke @xcite , death @xcite , kates @xcite , thorne and hartle @xcite , and others involves the use of matched astymptotic expansions .
here one assumes a metric form in the `` near zone''where the metric is assumed to be that of the body , with a small correction due to the background spacetime and in the `` far zone''where the metric is assumed to be that of the background spacetime , with a small correction due to the body .
one then assumes that there is an overlap region of the body where both metric forms apply , and matches the expressions .
the equations of motion of the body then arise from the matching conditions .
however , as we shall indicate below , in addition to the `` lorenz gauge relaxation '' , there are a number of assumptions and steps in these derivations that have not been adequately justified . a more rigorous approach to deriving gravitational self - force
is suggested by the work of geroch and jang @xcite and later geroch and ehlers @xcite on geodesic motion of small bodies ( see also @xcite ) . in @xcite ,
one considers a fixed spacetime background metric @xmath4 and considers a smooth one - parameter family of stress - energy smooth tensors @xmath25 that satisfy the dominant energy condition and have support on a world tube . as the parameter goes to zero , the world tube shrinks to a timelike curve .
it is then proven that this timelike curve must be a geodesic .
this result was generalized in @xcite to allow @xmath4 to also vary with @xmath2 so that einstein s equation is satisfied . within the framework of @xcite , it therefore should be possible to derive perturbative corrections to geodesic motion , including gravitational self - force .
however , the conditions imposed in @xcite in effect require the mass of the body to go to zero faster than @xmath26 . consequently , in this approach , a self - force correction like to the motion of the body would arise at higher order than finite size effects and possibly other effects that would depend on the composition of the body .
thus , while the work of @xcite provides a rigorous derivation of geodesic motion of a `` small body '' to lowest order , it is not a promising approach to derive gravitatational self - force corrections to geodesic motion . in this paper
, we shall take an approach similar in spirit to that of @xcite , but we will consider a different smooth , one - parameter family of metrics @xmath0 , wherein , in effect , we have a body ( or black hole ) present that scales to zero size in a self - similar manner , with both the size and the mass of the body being proportional to @xmath2 . in the limit as @xmath27 , the body ( or black hole ) shrinks down to a worldline , @xmath8 . as in @xcite and @xcite , we prove that @xmath8 must be a geodesic of the `` background spacetime '' @xmath28although our method of proving this differs significantly from @xcite and @xcite . to first order in @xmath2 , the correction to the motion
is described by a vector field , @xmath29 , on @xmath8 , which gives the `` infinitesimal displacement '' to the new worldline .
we will show that , for any such one parameter family @xmath0 , in the lorenz gauge @xmath30 satisfies @xmath31 here @xmath32 and @xmath33 are , respectively , the mass and spin of the body .
the terms in parentheses on the right side of this equation correspond exactly to the gravitational self - force term in eq . ; the first term is the papapetrou spin - force @xcite ; the second term is simply the usual right hand side of the geodesic deviation equation .
equation is `` universal '' in the sense that it holds for any one - parameter family satisfying our assumptions , so it holds equally well for a ( sufficiently small ) blob of ordinary matter or a ( sufficiently small ) black hole .
our derivation of is closely related to the matched asymptotic expansions analyses . however , our derivation is a rigorous , perturbative result .
in addition , we eliminate a number of ad hoc , unjustified , and/or unnecssary assumptions made in previous approaches , including assumptions about the form of the `` body metric '' and its perturbations , assumptions about rate of change of these quantities with time , the imposition of certain gauge conditions , the imposition of boundary conditions at the body , and , most importantly , the step of lorenz gauge relaxation . furthermore , in our approach , the notion of a `` point particle '' is a concept that is _ derived _ rather than assumed .
it also will be manifest in our approach that the results hold for all bodies ( or black holes ) and that the physical results do not depend on a choice of gauge ( although @xmath30 itself is a gauge dependent quantity , i.e. , the description of the corrections to particle motion depend on how the spacetimes at different @xmath2 are identified see section [ sec : dipole ] and appendix a ) .
in particular , because the lorenz gauge plays no preferred role in our derivation ( aside from being a computationally convenient choice ) , our gauge transformation law is not , as in previous work @xcite , restricted to gauges continuously related to the lorenz gauge .
our approach also holds out the possibility of being extended so as to systematically take higher order corrections into account .
however , we shall not attempt to undertake such an extension in this paper .
although holds rigorously as a first - order perturbative correction to geodesic motion , this equation would not be expected to provide a good global - in - time approximation to motion , since the small local corrections to the motion given by may accumulate with time , and eq . would not be expected to provide a good description of the perturbed motion when @xmath29 becomes large .
we will argue in this paper that the misataquwa equations , eqs . and , should provide a much better global - in - time approximation to motion than eq .
, and they therefore should be used for self - consistent calculations of the motion of a small body , such as for calculations of extreme - mass - ratio inspiral .
we note in passing that , in contrast to einstein s equation , maxwell s equations are linear , and it makes perfectly good mathematical sense to consider distributional solutions to maxwell s equations with point particle sources .
however , if the charge - current sources are not specified in advance but rather are determined by solving the matter equations of motion which are assumed to be such that the total stress - energy of the matter and electromagnetic field is conserved then the full , coupled system of maxwell s equations together with the equations of motion of the sources becomes nonlinear in the the electromagnetic field .
point particle sources do not make mathematical sense in this context either .
it is for this reason that despite more than a century of work on this problem there is no mathematically legitimate derivation of the electromagnetic self - force on a charged particle .
the methods of this paper can be used to rigorously derive a perturbative expression for electromagnetic self - force by considering suitable one - parameter families of coupled electromagnetic - matter systems , and we shall carry out this analysis elsewhere @xcite . however , we shall restrict consideration in this paper to the gravitational case .
this paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec :
example ] , we motivate the kind of one - parameter family of metrics , @xmath34 , that we will consider by examining the one - parameter family of schwarzschild - desitter spacetimes with black hole mass equal to @xmath2 . one way of taking the limit as @xmath35 yields desitter spacetime .
we refer to this way of taking the limit as the `` ordinary limit '' .
but we show that if we take the limit as @xmath35 in another way and also rescale the metric by @xmath36 , we obtain schwarzschild spacetime .
we refer to this second way of taking the limit as @xmath35 as the `` scaled limit '' .
the scaled limit can be taken at any time @xmath37 on the worldline @xmath8 .
the simultaneous existence of both types of limits defines the kind of one parameter family of metrics we seek , wherein a body ( or black hole ) is shrinking down to a world - line @xmath8 in an asymptotically self - similar manner .
the precise , general conditions we impose on @xmath0 are formulated in section [ sec : example ] .
some basic properties of @xmath0 that follow directly from our assumptions are given in section [ sec : assumptions ] .
in particular , we obtain general `` far zone '' and `` near zone '' expansions and we show that , at any @xmath37 , the scaled limit always yields a stationary , asymptotically flat spacetime at @xmath38 . in section [ sec : geodesic ] , we prove that @xmath8 must be a geodesic of the `` background spacetime '' ( i.e. , the spacetime at @xmath38 resulting from taking the ordinary limit ) .
in other words , to zeroth order in @xmath2 a small body or black hole always moves on a geodesic .
we also show that , to first order in @xmath2 , the metric perturbation associated with such a body or black hole corresponds to that of a structureless `` point particle '' . in section [ sec : dipole ] , we define the motion of the body ( or black hole ) to first order in @xmath2 by finding a coordinate displacement that makes the mass dipole moment of the stationary , asymptotically flat spacetime appearing in the scaled limit vanish .
( this can be interpreted as a displacement to the `` center of mass '' of the body . ) in section [ sec : calculation ] , we then derive eq . as the first order in @xmath2 correction to @xmath8 in the lorenz gauge .
( an appendix provides the transformation to other gauges . ) finally , in section [ sec : beyond ] we explain the status of the misataquwa equation .
our spacetime conventions are those of wald @xcite , and we work in units where @xmath39 .
lower case latin indices early in the alphabet ( @xmath40 ) will denote abstract spacetime indices ; greek indices will denote coordinate components of these tensors ; latin indices from mid - alphabet ( @xmath41 ) will denote spatial coordinate components .
as discussed in the introduction , we seek a one - parameter family of metrics @xmath42 that describes a material body or black hole that `` shrinks down to zero size '' in an asymptotically self - similar manner . in order to motivate the general conditions on @xmath42 that we shall impose , we consider here an extremely simple example of the type of one - parameter family that we seek .
this example will provide an illustration of the two types of limits that we shall use to characterize @xmath42 .
our example is built from schwarzschild - desitter spacetime , @xmath43 ( this metric , of course , is a solution to the vacuum einstein s equation with a cosmological constant @xmath44 rather than a solution with @xmath45 , but the field equations will not play any role in the considerations of this section ; we prefer to use this example because of its simplicity and familiarity . ) the desired one - parameter family is @xmath46 where we consider only the portion of the spacetime with @xmath47 for some @xmath48 . for each @xmath2
, this spacetime describes the exterior gravitational field of a spherical body or black hole of mass @xmath49 in an asymptotically desitter spacetime . as @xmath35 ,
the body / black hole shrinks to zero size and mass . for @xmath38 ,
the spacetime is desitter spacetime , which extends smoothly to the worldline @xmath50 , corresponding to where the body / black hole was just before it `` disappeared '' .
as explained clearly in @xcite , the limit of a one - parameter family of metrics @xmath42 depends on how the spacetime manifolds at different values of @xmath2 are identified .
this identification of spacetime manifolds at different @xmath2 can be specified by choosing coordinates @xmath51 for each @xmath2 and identifying points labeled by the same value of the coordinates @xmath51 .
if we use the coordinates @xmath52 in which the one - parameter family of metrics was presented to do the identification , then it is obvious that the limit as @xmath35 of @xmath42 is the desitter metric @xmath53 this corresponds to the view that the body / black hole shrinks to zero size and mass and `` disappears '' as @xmath35 .
however , there is another way of taking the limit of @xmath42 as @xmath35 ; the existence of this second limit is one of the key ideas in this paper .
choose an arbitrary time @xmath37 and , for @xmath54 , introduce new time and radial coordinates by @xmath55 and @xmath56 .
in the new coordinates , the one - parameter family of metrics becomes @xmath57 we now consider the limit as @xmath35 by identifying the spacetimes with different @xmath2 at the same values of the barred coordinates .
it is clear by inspection of eq.([gbar ] ) that the the limit of @xmath42 as @xmath35 at fixed @xmath58 exists , but is zero .
in essence , the spacetime interval between any two events labeled by @xmath59 and @xmath60 goes to zero as @xmath35 because these events are converging to the same point on @xmath8 .
thus , this limit of @xmath42 exists but is not very interesting .
however , an interesting limit can be taken by considering a new one - parameter family of metrics @xmath61 by @xmath62 so that @xmath63 by inspection , the limit of this family of metrics is simply , @xmath64 which is just the schwarzschild metric with mass @xmath65 .
the meaning of this second limit can be understood as follows . as already discussed above
, the one - parameter family of metrics ( [ eq : family ] ) describes the exterior gravitational field of a spherical body or black hole that shrinks to zero size and mass as @xmath35 .
the second limit corresponds to how this family of spacetimes looks to the family of observers placed at the events labeled by fixed values of @xmath58 . in going from , say , the @xmath66 to the @xmath67 spacetime
, each observer will see that the body / black hole has shrunk in size and mass by a factor of @xmath68 and each observer also will find himself `` closer to the origin '' by this same factor of @xmath68 .
suppose now that this family of observers also `` changes units '' by this same factor of @xmath68 , i.e. , they use centimeters rather than meters to measure distances .
then , except for small effects due to the desitter background , the family of observers for the @xmath67 spacetime will report the same results ( expressed in centimeters ) as the observers for the @xmath66 spacetime had reported ( in meters ) . in the limit as @xmath35 ,
these observers simply see a schwarzschild black hole of mass @xmath65 , since the effects of the desitter background on what these observers will report disappear entirely in this limit .
we will refer to the first type of limit ( i.e. , the limit as @xmath35 of @xmath42 taken at fixed @xmath51 ) as the _ ordinary limit _ of @xmath42 , and we will refer to the second limit ( i.e. , the limit as @xmath35 of @xmath69 taken at fixed @xmath58 ) as the _ scaled limit _ of @xmath42 .
the simultaneous existence of both types of the above limits contains a great deal of relevant information about the one - parameter family of spacetimes ( [ eq : family ] ) .
in essence , the existence of the first type of limit is telling us that the body / black hole is shrinking down to a worldline @xmath8 , with its mass going to zero ( at least ) as rapidly as its radius .
the existence of the second type of limit is telling us that the body / black hole is shrinking to zero size in an asymptotically self - similar manner : in particular , its mass is proportional to its size , its shape is not changing , and it is not undergoing any ( high frequency ) oscillations in time . figure [ fig:2limits - spacetime ] illustrates the two limits we consider . , the body shrinks and finally disappears , leaving behind a smooth background spacetime with a preferred world - line , @xmath8 , picked out .
the solid lines illustrate this `` ordinary limit '' of @xmath35 at fixed @xmath70 , which is taken along paths that terminate away from @xmath8 ( i.e. , @xmath71 ) .
by contrast , the `` scaled limit '' as @xmath35 , shown in dashed lines , is taken along paths at fixed @xmath72 that converge to a point on @xmath8.,width=288 ] we wish now to abstract from the above example the general conditions to impose upon one - parameter families that express in a simple and precise way the condition that we have an arbitrary body ( or black hole ) that is shrinking to zero size in an asymptotically self - similar way in an arbitrary background spacetime .
most of the remainder of this paper will be devoted to obtaining `` equations of motion '' for these bodies that are accurate enough to include gravitational self - force effects .
a first attempt at specifying the type of one - parameter families @xmath42 that we seek is as follows : * \(i ) _ existence of the `` ordinary limit '' _ :
@xmath42 is such that there exists coordinates @xmath73 such that @xmath74 is jointly smooth in @xmath75 , at least for @xmath76 for some constant @xmath77 , where @xmath78 ( @xmath79 ) . for all @xmath2 and for @xmath76
, @xmath42 is a vacuum solution of einstein s equation .
furthermore , @xmath80 is smooth in @xmath73 , including at @xmath81 , and , for @xmath82 , the curve @xmath8 defined by @xmath81 is timelike .
* \(ii ) _ existence of the `` scaled limit '' _ : for each @xmath37 , we define @xmath55 , @xmath83 .
then the metric @xmath84 is jointly smooth in @xmath85 for @xmath86 .
here we have used the notation @xmath87 to denote the components of @xmath4 in the @xmath88 coordinates , whereas @xmath89 denotes the components of @xmath90 in the @xmath88 coordinates .
it should be noted that , since the barred coordinates differ only by scale ( and shift of time origin ) from the corresponding unbarred coordinates , we have @xmath91 consequently ,
we have @xmath92 since there is a cancelation of the factors of @xmath2 resulting from the definition of @xmath90 and the coordinate rescalings .
it also should be noted that there is a redundancy in our description of the one - parameter family of metrics when taking the scaled limit : we define a scaled limit for all values of @xmath37 , but these arise from a single one - parameter family of metrics @xmath42 .
indeed , it is not difficult to see that we have @xmath93 in fact , our requirements on @xmath4 of the existence of both an `` ordinary limit '' and a `` scaled limit '' are not quite strong enough to properly specify the one - parameter families we seek .
to explain this and obtain the desired strengthened condition , it is convenient to define the new variables @xmath94 where the range of @xmath95 is @xmath96 . let @xmath97 denote a component of @xmath42 in the coordinates @xmath73 .
however , instead of viewing @xmath97 as a function of @xmath98 , we view @xmath97 as a function of @xmath99 , where @xmath100 and @xmath101 are defined in terms of @xmath102 by the usual formula for spherical polar angles . in terms of these new variables , taking the `` ordinary limit ''
corresponds to letting @xmath103 at any fixed @xmath104 , whereas taking the `` scaled limit '' corresponds to letting @xmath105 at any fixed @xmath106 ( see figure [ fig:2limits - ab ] ) .
now , our assumptions concerning the ordinary limit imply that , at fixed @xmath107 and at fixed @xmath108 , @xmath97 depends smoothly on @xmath95 , including at @xmath109 . on the other hand , our assumptions concerning the scaled limit
imply that at fixed @xmath107 and at fixed @xmath106 , @xmath97 is smooth in @xmath110 .
furthermore , the last condition in the ordinary limit implies that for @xmath109 and fixed @xmath107 , @xmath97 is smooth in @xmath110 , including at @xmath111 .
thus , at fixed @xmath107 , our previously stated assumptions imply that @xmath97 is well defined at the `` origin '' @xmath112 , and is smooth in @xmath110 along the @xmath110-axis ( i.e. , @xmath109 ) . however , our previously stated assumptions do not say anything about the continuity or smoothness of @xmath97 as @xmath113 from directions other than along the @xmath110-axis .
such limiting behavior would correspond to letting @xmath114 as @xmath35 but at a rate _
slower _ than @xmath2 , i.e. , such that @xmath115 . to see the meaning and relevance of this limiting behavior ,
let us return to our original motivating example , eq .
( [ eq : family ] ) and take @xmath97 to be the time - time component of this metric to `` cartesian - like '' coordinates @xmath102 that are well behaved at the origin @xmath116 when @xmath38 ] . in terms of our new variables ( [ alphabeta ] )
, we have @xmath118 which is jointly smooth in @xmath119 at @xmath120 . by contrast , suppose we had a one - parameter family of metrics @xmath121 that satisfies our above assumptions about the ordinary and scaled limits , but fails to be jointly smooth in @xmath119 at @xmath120 .
for example , suppose the time - time component of such a one - parameter family varied as @xmath122 in terms of the original variables @xmath123 , this corresponds to behavior of the form @xmath124 if we take the `` ordinary limit '' ( @xmath35 at fixed @xmath71 ) of @xmath125 , we find that @xmath125 smoothly goes to @xmath126 .
similarly , if we take the `` scaled limit '' ( @xmath127 at fixed @xmath128 ) , we also find that @xmath125 smoothly goes to @xmath126 .
however , suppose we let @xmath35 but let @xmath70 go to zero as @xmath129 .
then @xmath125 will approach a different limit , namely @xmath130 .
in essence , @xmath131 corresponds to a one - parameter family in which there is a `` bump of curvature '' at @xmath132 .
although this `` bump of curvature '' does not register when one takes the ordinary or scaled limits , it is present in the one - parameter family of spacetimes and represents unacceptable limiting behavior as @xmath35 of this one - parameter family . in order to eliminate this kind of non - uniform behavior in @xmath2 and @xmath70
, we now impose the following addtional condition : * \(iii ) _ uniformity condition _ :
each component of @xmath42 in the coordinates @xmath51 is a jointly smooth function of the variables @xmath133 at @xmath120 ( at fixed @xmath134 ) , where @xmath110 and @xmath95 are defined by eq.([alphabeta ] ) .
assumptions ( i)-(iii ) constitute all of the conditions that we shall impose on @xmath42 .
no additional assumptions will be made in this paper .
we note that the coordinate freedom allowed by our conditions are precisely all coordinate transformations @xmath135 such that @xmath136 is jointly smooth in @xmath137 for all @xmath138 for some constant @xmath139 , and such that the jacobian matrix @xmath140 is jointly smooth in @xmath119 at @xmath120 at fixed @xmath134 .
it should be emphasized that our assumtions place absolutely no restrictions on the one - parameter family of spacetimes for @xmath141 , i.e. , this portion of these spacetimes could equally well be `` filled in '' with ordinary matter or a black hole satisfying our assumptions . ] .
it also should be noted that the `` large @xmath70 '' region of the spacetime will not be relevant to any of our considerations , so it is only necessary that our conditions hold for @xmath142 for some constant @xmath143 .
finally , although it may not be obvious upon first reading , we note that our assumptions concerning @xmath0 are closely related to the assumptions made in matched asymptotic expansion analyses .
as we shall see in the next section , in essence , our assumption about the existence of an ordinary limit of @xmath0 corresponds to assuming the existence of a `` far zone '' expansion ; our assumption about the existence of a scaled limit of @xmath0 corresponds to assuming the existence of a `` near zone '' expansion ; and our uniformity assumption corresponds closely to the assumption of the existence of a `` buffer zone '' where both expansions are valid .
in this section , we derive some immediate consequences of the assumptions of the previous section that will play a key role in our analysis .
these results will follow directly from the `` uniformity condition '' and the consistency relation ( [ consist ] ) . since , by the uniformity assumption , the coordinate components of the one - parameter family of metrics @xmath42 are jointly smooth in the variables @xmath119 at @xmath120 , we may approximate @xmath144 by a joint taylor series in @xmath110 and @xmath95 to any finite orders @xmath145 and @xmath32 by @xmath146 substituting for @xmath110 and @xmath95 from eq.([alphabeta ] ) , we have @xmath147 where here and in the following , we drop the error term
. we can rewrite this equation as a perturbation expansion in @xmath2 : @xmath148 we will refer to eq.([eq : rseries ] ) as the _ far zone expansion _ of @xmath42 .
it should be noted that the @xmath149th - order term in @xmath2 in the far zone perturbation expansion has leading order behavior of @xmath150 at small @xmath70 .
however , arbitrarily high positive powers of @xmath70 may occur at each order in @xmath2 .
finally , we note that the angular dependence of @xmath151 is further restricted by the requirement that the metric components @xmath152 must be smooth at @xmath50 when re - expressed as functions of @xmath102 .
in particular , this implies that @xmath153 can not have any angular dependence .
equivalently , in view of eq.([barg ] ) , we can expand @xmath89 as @xmath154 by further expanding @xmath155 in @xmath156 about @xmath157 , we obtain @xmath158 where @xmath159 we can rewrite this as a perturbation series expansion in @xmath2 : @xmath160 we will refer to eq.([eq : fullnearzone ] ) as the _ near zone expansion _ of @xmath42 .
we see from this formula that the scaled metric , viewed as a perturbation series in @xmath2 , follows the rule that the combined powers of @xmath156 and @xmath72 are allowed to be only as positive as the order in perturbation theory .
by contrast inverse powers of @xmath72 of arbitrarily high order are always allowed . of course
, only non - negative powers of @xmath156 can occur . by inspection of eq.([eq : fullnearzone ] ) , we see that the `` background '' ( @xmath82 ) scaled metric is given by @xmath161 where we have used the fact that @xmath162 . thus , we see that there is no dependence of @xmath163 on @xmath156 and only non - positive powers of @xmath72 occur .
_ thus , we see that @xmath164 is a stationary , asymptotically flat spacetime .
_ however , the limiting , stationary , asymtotically flat spacetime that we obtain may depend on the choice of the time , @xmath37 , on the worldline , @xmath8 , about which the scaling is done .
our `` far zone expansion '' , eq.([eq : rseries ] ) , appears to correspond closely to the far zone expansion used in matched asymptotic expansion analyses @xcite .
however , our `` near zone expansion '' differs in that we define a separate expansion for each time @xmath37 rather than attempting a uniform in time approximation with a single expansion .
such expansions require an additional `` quasi - static '' or slow - time variation assumption for the evolution of the metric perturbations .
a further difference is that the conclusion that the background ( @xmath38 ) metric is stationary and asymptotically flat has been derived here rather than assumed . indeed , in other analyses , a particular form of the background metric ( such as the schwarzschild metric ) is assumed , and the possibility that this metric form might change with time ( i.e. , depend upon @xmath37 ) is not considered .
in addition , in other analyses boundary conditions at small @xmath72 ( such as regularity on the schwarzschild horizon ) are imposed . in our analysis
, we make no assumptions other than the assumptions ( i)-(iii ) stated in the previous section . in particular , since we make no assumptions about the form of the metric for @xmath165 , we do not impose any boundary conditions at small @xmath72 .
finally , it is also useful to express the consistency relation ( [ consist ] ) in a simple , differential form .
we define @xmath166 then , a short calculation shows that @xmath167 as well as @xmath168 setting @xmath169 , we see that the last relation implies that @xmath170 is stationary , as we have already noted .
in this section , we will prove that the worldline @xmath8 appearing in assumption ( i ) of section [ sec : example ] must , in fact , be a geodesic of the background metric @xmath171 .
this can be interpreted as establishing that , to zeroth order in @xmath2 , any body ( or black hole ) moves on a geodesic of the background spacetime .
in fact , we will show considerably more than this : we will show that , to first order in @xmath2 , the far zone description of @xmath42 is that of a `` point particle '' . as previously mentioned in the introduction ,
our derivation of geodesic motion is similar in spirit to that of @xcite in that we consider one - parameter families of solutions with a worldtube that shrinks down to a curve @xmath8 , but the nature of the one - parameter families that we consider here are very different from those considered by @xcite , and our proof of geodesic motion is very different as well .
our derivation of geodesic motion also appears to differ significantly from pervious derivations using matched asymptotic expansions @xcite .
we begin by writing the lowest order terms in the far zone expansion , eq .
( [ eq : rseries ] ) , as follows : @xmath172 + o(\lambda^2)\ , , r>0 \,\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the fact that @xmath173 can depend only on @xmath174 , as noted in the previous section . since the worldline @xmath8 , given by @xmath116 , was assumed to be timelike
however , if , instead , we had assumed that the `` interior region '' @xmath175 , were `` filled in '' with matter satisfying the dominant energy condition , then it should be possible to prove that @xmath8 must be timelike .
] in the spacetime @xmath176 , without loss of generality , we may choose our coordinates @xmath73 so that @xmath177 . (
one such possible choice of coordinates would be fermi normal coordinates with respect to @xmath8 in the metric @xmath176 .
we emphasize that we make the coordinate choice @xmath178 purely for convenience so that , e.g. , coordinate time coincides with proper time on @xmath8but it plays no essential role in our arguments . )
choosing these coordinates , and letting @xmath179 denote the @xmath180 piece of the metric , we see that @xmath181 takes the form @xmath182 where @xmath183 where in eq.([eq : perturbations - series ] ) , the term `` @xmath184 '' denotes a term that , when multiplied by @xmath185 for any @xmath186 , vanishes as @xmath187 .
now , by assumption ( i ) of section [ sec : example ] , for each @xmath2 , @xmath0 is a vacuum solution of einstein s equation for @xmath188 and is jointly smooth in @xmath98 in this coordinate range .
it follows that for all @xmath189 , @xmath3 is a solution the linearized einstein equation off of @xmath1 , i.e. , @xmath190 = -\frac{1}{2 } \nabla_a \nabla_b h^c_{\ c } - \frac{1}{2}\nabla^c\nabla_c h_{ab } + \nabla^c \nabla_{(b}h_{a)c } = 0 , \,\ , r>0 \,\ , , \label{lee}\ ] ] where here and in the following , @xmath191 denotes the derivative operator associated with @xmath1 , and indices are raised and lowered with @xmath1 . equation ( [ lee ] ) holds only for @xmath189 , and , indeed , if @xmath192 , @xmath3 is singular at @xmath193 .
however , even if @xmath192 , the singularity of each component of @xmath3 is locally integrable with respect to the volume element associated with @xmath171 , i.e. , each component , @xmath179 , is a locally @xmath194 function on the entire spacetime manifold , including @xmath50 . _
thus , @xmath3 is well defined as a distribution on all of spacetime . _
the quantity @xmath195/8 \pi$ ] is therefore automatically well defined as a distribution .
this quantity has the interpretation of being the `` source '' for the metric perturbation ( [ eq : perturbations - series])even though all of our spacetimes @xmath42 for @xmath54 have excluded the `` source region '' @xmath196 .
it follows immediately from eq.([lee ] ) that , as a distribution , @xmath197 must have support on @xmath8 in the sense that it must vanish when acting on any test tensor field @xmath198 whose support does not intersect @xmath8 .
we now compute @xmath197 . by definition , @xmath195/8 \pi$ ]
is the distribution on spacetime whose action on an arbitrary smooth , compact support , symmetric tensor field @xmath199 is given by @xmath200 h^{ab } \sqrt{-g } d^4x = 0 \,\ , , \ ] ] where @xmath201 denotes the volume element associated with @xmath171 and we have used the fact that the operator @xmath202 is self - adjoint were not self - adjoint , then the adjoint of @xmath202 would have appeared in eq .
( [ eq : distributional - equation ] ) . ] .
note that the right side of this equation is well defined since @xmath203 $ ] is a smooth tensor field of compact support and @xmath204 is locally @xmath194 .
we can evaluate the right side of eq .
( [ eq : distributional - equation ] ) by integrating over the region @xmath205 and then taking the limit as @xmath206 . in the region
@xmath207 , @xmath204 is smooth , and a straightforward `` integration by parts '' calculation shows that @xmath208 h^{ab } - g^{(1)}_{ab } [ h_{cd } ] f^{ab } = \nabla_c s^c \,\ , , \ ] ] where @xmath209 where @xmath210 . since @xmath211 = 0 $ ] for @xmath189 , it follows immediately that @xmath212 h^{ab } = \frac{1}{8 \pi } \lim_{\epsilon \rightarrow 0 } \int_{r=\epsilon } s^a n_a ds \,\ , .\ ] ] using eqs .
( [ eq : perturbations - series ] ) and ( [ eq : adjoint - current ] ) , we find that @xmath213 takes the form @xmath214 where @xmath215 is a smooth , symmetric ( @xmath216 ) tensor field on @xmath8 whose components are given in terms of suitable angular averages of @xmath217 and its first angular derivatives .
in other words , the distribution @xmath197 is given by on @xmath8 and @xmath218 , but we prefer to leave in these factors so that this formula holds for an arbitrary choice of coordinates . ] @xmath219 where @xmath220 is the `` coordinate delta - function '' ( i.e. , @xmath221 ) .
we now use the fact that , since the differential operator @xmath202 satisfies the linearized bianchi identity @xmath222 , the distribution @xmath197 must satisfy @xmath223 in the distributional sense .
this means that the action of @xmath197 must vanish on any test tensor field of the form @xmath224 where @xmath225 is smooth and of compact support . in other words , by eq .
( [ tn ] ) , the tensor field @xmath226 on @xmath8 must be such that for an arbitrary smooth vector field @xmath227 on spacetime , we have @xmath228 now for any @xmath79 , choose @xmath227 to have components of the form @xmath229 , where each @xmath230 ( @xmath231 ) is an arbitrary smooth function of compact support in @xmath174 and @xmath232 is a smooth function of compact spatial support , with @xmath233 in a neighborhood of @xmath8 .
then eq .
( [ nf ] ) yields @xmath234 for all @xmath235 , which immediately implies that @xmath236 for all @xmath79 and all @xmath231 . in other words
, we have shown that @xmath215 must take the form @xmath237 where @xmath7 denotes the unit tangent to @xmath8 , i.e. , @xmath7 is the 4-velocity of @xmath8 .
now choose @xmath227 to be an arbitrary smooth vector field of compact support .
then eqs .
( [ nf ] ) and ( [ n ] ) yield @xmath238 where we integrated by parts in @xmath174 to obtain the last equality .
since @xmath227 is arbitrary , this immediately implies that @xmath239 this , in turn , implies that @xmath240 i.e. , @xmath32 is a constant along @xmath8 , and , if @xmath241 , @xmath242 i.e. , in the case where @xmath241 , @xmath8 is a geodesic of @xmath176 , as we desired to show .. it is critical that this assumption be used in any valid derivation of geodesic motion , since a derivation that holds for @xmath243 effectively would show that all curves are geodesics . ] in summary , we have shown that for any one - parameter family of metrics @xmath42 satisfying assumptions ( i)-(iii ) of section [ sec : example ] , to first order in @xmath2 , the far zone metric perturbation @xmath3 corresponds to a solution to the linearized einstein equation with a point particle source @xmath244 where @xmath32 is a constant and @xmath7 is the 4-velocity of @xmath8 , which must be a geodesic if @xmath241 .
we refer to @xmath32 as the _ mass _ of the particle .
it is rather remarkable that the point particle source ( [ ptparticle ] ) is an _
output _ of our analysis rather than an input .
indeed , we maintain that the result we have just derived is what provides the justification for the notion of `` point particles''a notion that has played a dominant role in classical physics for more than three centuries .
in fact , the notion of point particles makes no mathematical sense in the context of nonlinear field theories like general relativity .
nevertheless , we have just shown that the notion of a ( structureless ) `` point particle '' arises naturally as an _ approximate _ description of sufficiently small bodies
namely , a description that is valid to first order in @xmath2 in the far zone for arbitrary one - parameter families of metrics @xmath42 satisfying the assumptions of section [ sec : example ] .
this description is valid independently of the nature of the `` body '' , e.g. , it holds with equal validity for a small black hole as for a small blob of ordinary matter .
in the previous section , we established that , to zeroth order in @xmath2 , any body ( or black hole ) of nonvanishing mass moves on a geodesic of the background spacetime .
much of the remainder of this paper will be devoted to finding the corrections to this motion , valid to first order in @xmath2 in the far zone . in this section
, we address the issue of what is meant by the `` motion of the body '' to first order in @xmath2 .
the first point that should be clearly recognized is that it is far from obvious how to describe `` motion '' in terms of a worldline for @xmath54 .
indeed , the metric @xmath42 is defined only for @xmath188 , so at finite @xmath2 the spacetime metric may not even be defined in a neighborhood of @xmath8 .
if we were to assume that @xmath245 and that the region @xmath246 were `` filled in '' with sufficiently `` weak field matter''so that @xmath247 , where @xmath248 denotes the supremum of the components of the riemann curvature tensor of @xmath61 in the `` filled in '' region then it should be possible to define a `` center of mass '' worldline at finite @xmath2 , and we could use this worldline to characterize the motion of the body @xcite . however , we do not wish to make any `` weak field '' assumptions here , since we wish to describe to motion of small black holes and other `` strong field '' objects .
since it is not clear how to associate a worldline to the body at finite @xmath2and , indeed , the `` body '' is excluded from the spacetime region we consider at finite @xmath2it is not clear what one would mean by a `` perturbative correction '' to @xmath8 to first or higher order in @xmath2 .
a second point that should be understood is that if we have succeeded in defining the worldlines describing the motion the body at finite @xmath2 , @xmath249 then the `` first order in @xmath2 perturbative correction '' , @xmath29 , to the zeroth order motion @xmath8 ( given by @xmath250 ) is most properly viewed as the spatial components of a vector field , @xmath251 , defined along @xmath8 .
this vector field describes the `` infinitesimal displacement '' to the corrected motion to first order in @xmath2 .
the time component , @xmath252 , of @xmath251 depends on on how we identify the time parameter of the worldlines at different values of @xmath2 and is not physically relevant ; we will set @xmath253 so that @xmath251 is orthogonal to the tangent , @xmath7 , to @xmath8 in the background metric @xmath176 .
thus , when we seek equations of motion describing the first order perturbative corrections to geodesic motion , we are seeking equations satisfied by the vector field @xmath254 on @xmath8 .
a third point that should be clearly recognized is that @xmath251 and any equations of motion satisfied by @xmath251 will depend on our choice of gauge for @xmath3 . to see this explicitly ,
suppose that we perform a smooth is not smooth at @xmath116 are also permitted under the coordinate freedom stated at the end of section [ sec : example ] .
however , it suffices to consider smooth @xmath255 for our consderations here .
the change in the description of motion under non - smooth gauge transformations will be treated in appendix a. ] gauge transformation of the form @xmath256 under this gauge transformation , we have @xmath257 however , clearly , the new description of motion will be of the form @xcite @xmath258 where @xmath259 thus , we see that @xmath251 transforms as @xmath260 in order that it describe the same perturbed motion . thus , the first order correction , @xmath254 , to the background geodesic motion contains no meaningful information by itself and , indeed , it can always be set to zero by a smooth gauge transformation . only the pair @xmath261 has gauge invariant meaning .
we turn now to the definition of the first order perturbed motion .
our definition relies on the fact , proven in section [ sec : assumptions ] above , that for each @xmath37 , @xmath262 is a stationary , asymptotically flat spacetime .
therefore , @xmath164 has well defined sets of mass ( `` electric parity '' ) and angular momentum ( `` magnetic parity '' ) multipole moments @xcite and , indeed , the spacetime is characterized by the values of these two sets of multipole moments @xcite .
the multipole moments ( other than the lowest nonvanishing multipoles of each type ) depend upon a choice of conformal factor @xcite , which , rougly speaking , corresponds to a choice of `` origin '' .
we choose the conformal factor @xmath263 to define all of the multipoles , corresponding to choosing the origin at @xmath264 . for a metric of the form eq .
( [ eq : fullnearzone2])with @xmath265 by our coordinate choice imposed in the previous section that @xmath266 on @xmath8the mass will be simply the @xmath267 part of the coefficient of @xmath268 in the large @xmath72 expansion of @xmath269 . similarly , the mass dipole moment will be the coefficient of the @xmath270 part of this quantity at order @xmath271 .
it is well known that if the mass is nonzero , the mass dipole moment is `` pure gauge '' and can be set to zero by choice of conformal factor/``origin '' .
we now explicitly show that , with our choice of conformal factor @xmath263 , the mass dipole moment can be set to zero by a smooth gauge transformation of the form ( [ eq : transform ] ) .
it follows from the linearized einstein equation ( [ lee ] ) with source ( [ ptparticle ] ) applied to @xmath3 , eq .
( [ eq : perturbations - series ] ) , that the time - time component of @xmath3 takes the form @xmath272 i.e. , in the notation of eq . (
[ eq : rseries ] ) , we have @xmath273 . comparing with eq .
( [ eq : fullnearzone ] ) ( and also using the fact that @xmath274 ) , we see that at each @xmath37 @xmath275 from this equation , we see that the `` particle mass '' , @xmath32 , of the `` source '' of the far zone metric perturbation ( see eq .
( [ ptparticle ] ) ) is also the komar / adm mass of the stationary , asymptotically flat spacetime @xmath276 .
we now calculate the effect of the coordinate transformation ( [ eq : transform ] ) on @xmath277 .
the transformation ( [ eq : transform ] ) corresponds to changing the barred coordinates by @xmath278 i.e. , to zeroth order in @xmath2 , it corresponds to a `` constant displacement '' of coordinates . since @xmath279
it can be seen that this transformation have the effect of changing the mass dipole moment by @xmath280 . in particular
, we can always choose @xmath281 so as to set the mass dipole moment to zero .
now , the `` near zone '' coordinates @xmath282 for which the mass dipole moment vanishes have the interpretation of being `` body centered '' coordinates to zeroth order in @xmath2 .
the origin @xmath283 of the corresponding `` far zone '' coordinates @xmath284 therefore has the interpretation of representing the `` position '' of the center of mass of the body to first order in @xmath2 .
we shall use this to define the correction to geodesic motion to first order in @xmath2 by proceeding as follows : first , we shall choose our coordinates , @xmath51 , to zeroth order in @xmath2 by choosing convenient coordinates for the `` background spacetime '' @xmath176 .
( we will use fermi normal coordinates based on @xmath8 . ) next , we will define our coordinates , @xmath51 , to first order in @xmath2 by choosing a convenient gauge for @xmath3 , eq .
( [ eq : perturbations - series ] ) .
( we will choose the lorenz gauge @xmath285 . )
then we will introduce the smooth coordinate transformation ( [ eq : transform ] ) , and impose the requirement that @xmath286 be such that the mass dipole moment of @xmath276 vanish for all @xmath37 . since the `` location '' of the body in the new coordinates is @xmath287 , the first order perturbative correction @xmath254 to the motion of the body in our original coordinates @xmath51 will be given by @xmath288 of course , the particular @xmath254 that we obtain in any given case will depend upon the particular one - parameter family @xmath42 that we consider .
what is of interest is any `` universal relations '' satisfied by @xmath254 that are independent of the choice of one - parameter family satisfying assumptions ( i)-(iii ) of section [ sec : example ] . such universal relations would provide us with `` laws of motion '' for point particles that take self - force effects into account . in the next section , we will show ( via a lengthy calculation ) that such a universal relation exists for @xmath289 , thus providing us with general `` equations of motion '' for all `` point particles '' , valid to first order in @xmath2 .
finally , we note that if we wish to describe motion beyond first order in @xmath2 , it will be necessary to define a `` representative world line '' in the far zone to at least second order in @xmath2 .
we shall not attempt to do so in this paper .
the definition of a suitable representative worldline is probably the greatest obstacle to extending the results of this paper to higher order in perturbation theory .
in the section [ sec : geodesic ] we found that first - order far zone perturbations of the background spacetime @xmath176 are sourced by a point particle stress - energy , eq .
( [ ptparticle ] ) . for the remainder of this paper
, we will assume that @xmath241 , so that , as shown in section [ sec : geodesic ] , the lowest order motion is described by a geodesic , @xmath8 , of the background spacetime .
we will need expressions for the components of the far zone metric , @xmath290 , its first order perturbation , @xmath291 , and its second order perturbation @xmath292 .
it is convenient to choose our coordinates @xmath51 to zeroth order in @xmath2 to be fermi normal coordinates with respect to the background geodesic @xmath8 , and choose these coordinates to first order in @xmath2 so that @xmath293 satisfies the lorenz gauge condition @xmath294 , where @xmath295 with @xmath296 .
then the linearized einstein equation reads @xmath297 this system of equations can be solved using the hadamard expansion techniques of dewitt and brehme @xcite . since this technology has been used in all previous derivations of gravitational self - force , we do not review it here but simply present results .
equation ( 2.27 ) of mino , sasaki , and tanaka @xcite provides a covariant expression for the perturbations in terms of parallel propagators and synge s world function on the background metric ( see , e.g. , reference @xcite for definitions of these quantities ) .
the fermi normal coordinate components of these tensors are easily calculated with the aid of expressions from section 8 of poisson @xcite . combining this with the form of the background metric in fermi normal
coordinates , we obtain @xmath298 where the quantities @xmath299 and @xmath300 are defined by the following expressions in terms of the fermi normal coordinate components of the riemann tensor of the background metric @xmath301 and @xmath302 and @xmath303 are given by @xmath304 in these expressions , @xmath305 is the lorenz gauge retarded green s function , normalized with a factor of @xmath306 , following @xcite .
as previously mentioned , the symbol @xmath23 indicates that the range of the integral extends just short of the retarded time @xmath24 , so that only the `` tail '' ( i.e. , interior of the light cone ) portion of the green s function is used ( see , e.g. , reference @xcite for details ) .
we define @xmath303 , rather than working with derivatives of @xmath302 , because @xmath302 is not differentiable on the worldline .
( however , this non - differentiability is limited only to spatial derivatives of spatial components of @xmath302 on the worldline @xmath8 yields @xmath303 plus the coincidence limit of the integrand of , which is proportional to @xmath307 times the gradient of @xmath24 .
] , so that expressions expressions like are well - defined . ) a choice of retarded solution ( corresponding to `` no incoming radiation '' ) was made in writing these equations .
this choice is not necessary , and one could add an arbitrary smooth solution @xmath179 of the linearized einstein equation to the first order in @xmath2 term on the right side of eq .
( [ eq : metric ] ) , which could then be carried through all of our calculations straightforwardly .
however , for simplicity , we will not consider the addition of such a term . our derivation of gravitational self - force to
first order in @xmath2 will require consideration of second - order metric perturbations , so we will have to carry the expansion of @xmath42 somewhat beyond eq .
( [ eq : metric ] ) .
( this should not be surprising in view of fact that our above derivation in section [ sec : geodesic ] of geodesic motion at zeroth order in @xmath2 , required consideration of first - order metric perturbations . ) in particular , we will need an explicit expression for the quantity @xmath308 appearing in the far zone expansion eq .
( [ eq : rseries ] ) , i.e. , the term of order @xmath26 that has the most singular behavior in @xmath309 ( namely , @xmath310 ) .
the second - order perturbation @xmath311 satisfies the second - order einstein equation , which takes the form @xmath312 = - g^{(2)}_{ab}[h , h]\ ] ] where @xmath313 denotes the second order einstein tensor about the background metric @xmath314 . since the @xmath315 part of @xmath3 corresponds to the linearized schwarzschild metric in isotropic coordinates ( see eq .
( [ eq : metric ] ) ) , it is clear that there is a particular solution to eq .
( [ eq : e2 ] ) of the form @xmath316 as @xmath187 , where @xmath317 and @xmath318 , whereas @xmath319 .
( the explicitly written term on the right side of eq .
( [ ji ] ) is just the @xmath320 part of the schwarzschild metric in isotropic coordinates . )
the general solution to eq .
( [ eq : e2 ] ) can then be written as @xmath321 where @xmath322 is a homogeneous solution of the linearized einstein equation .
we wish to compute the @xmath323 part of @xmath322 , i.e. , writing @xmath324 we wish to compute @xmath325 .
now , although the equations of motion to first order in @xmath2 depend upon a choice of gauge to first order in @xmath2 ( see section [ sec : dipole ] ) , they can not depend upon a choice of gauge to second order in @xmath2 , since a second order gauge transformation can not affect the mass dipole moment of the background scaled metric @xmath326 .
( we have also verified by a direct , lengthy computation that second order gauge transformations do not produce changes in the equations of motion to first order in @xmath2 . )
therefore , we are free to impose any ( admissible ) second order gauge condition on @xmath322
. it will be convenient to require that the lorenz gauge condition @xmath327 be satisfied to order @xmath328 .
the @xmath329 part of the linearized einstein equation together with the @xmath330 part of the lorenz gauge condition then yields @xmath331 where @xmath332 .
this system of equations for @xmath333 is the same system of equations as is satisfied by stationary solutions of the flat spacetime linearized einstein equation ( but our @xmath334 may depend on time ) .
the general solution of these equations is @xmath335 , @xmath336 , and @xmath337 , where @xmath33 is antisymmetric , @xmath338 , where @xmath232 , @xmath33 , and @xmath339 have no spatial dependence , and where @xmath340 was defined by eq .
( [ ni ] ) . by a further second order gauge transformation ( of the form @xmath341 ) , we can set @xmath342 .
we thus obtain @xmath343 which is of the same form as the general stationary @xmath270 perturbation of minkowski spacetime ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) , except that time dependence is allowed for @xmath33 and @xmath339 .
as we shall see shortly , @xmath33 and @xmath339 correspond , respectively , to the spin and mass dipole moment of the body .
we now may write for the metric through @xmath344 , @xmath345 where we have introduced the unknown tensors @xmath143 and @xmath346 , and @xmath347 is the antisymmetric tensor whose spatial components are @xmath33 and whose time components vanish , i.e. , @xmath348 we now follow the strategy outlined in section [ sec : dipole ] .
we consider a _ smooth _
coordinate shift of the form , @xmath349 and choose @xmath286 so as to make the mass dipole moment of @xmath350 vanish for all @xmath37 . a straightforward application of the coordinate transformation ( [ eq : transform2 ] ) to the metric ( [ eq : metric2 ] ) yields @xmath351 n^i \delta_{\alpha \beta } + \frac{1}{\hat{r}^2 } t_{(\alpha } s_{\beta ) j}(\hat{t } ) n^j \\ & \qquad \quad + \frac{1}{\hat{r } } k_{\alpha \beta}(\hat{t},\theta,\phi ) + h_{\alpha \beta}(\hat{t},\theta,\phi ) + o(r ) \biggr ) + o(\lambda^3 ) , \end{split}\ ] ] where we have `` absorbed '' the effects of the gauge transformation at orders @xmath352 and @xmath353 into the unknown tensors @xmath354 .
the corresponding `` near zone expansion '' ( see eqs .
( [ eq : rseries ] ) , ( [ bnmp ] ) , and ( [ eq : fullnearzone ] ) ) is @xmath355 n^i \delta_{\alpha \beta } + o \left ( \frac{1}{\hat{\bar{r}}^3 } \right ) \\ & \quad + \lambda \left [ h^{\textrm{\tiny tail}}_{\alpha \beta } + 2 a_{(\alpha , \beta ) } + \frac{1}{\hat{\bar{r } } } k_{\alpha \beta}+ \frac{\hat{\bar{t}}}{\hat{\bar{r}}^2 } \left ( t_{(\alpha } s_{\beta ) j,0 } n^j + 2 \left[p_{i,0}-m a_{i,0}\right ] n^i \delta_{\alpha \beta } \right ) + o \left ( \frac{1}{\hat{\bar{r}}^2 } \right ) + \hat{\bar{t } } o\left ( \frac{1}{\hat{\bar{r}}^3 } \right ) \right ] \\ & \quad + \lambda^2 \biggl [ b_{\alpha
i \beta j } \hat{\bar{x}}^i \hat{\bar{x}}^j + h^{\textrm{\tiny tail}}_{\alpha \beta \gamma}\hat{\bar{x}}^\gamma + m \mathcal{r}_{\alpha \beta}(\hat{\bar{x}}^i ) + 2 b_{\alpha i \beta j}a^i \hat{\bar{x}}^j + 2 a_{(\alpha , \beta ) \gamma } \hat{\bar{x}}^\gamma \\ & \qquad \qquad + h_{\alpha \beta } + \frac{\hat{\bar{t}}}{\hat{\bar{r } } } k_{\alpha \beta,0 } + \frac{\hat{\bar{t}}^2}{\hat{\bar{r}}^2 } \left ( t_{(\alpha } s_{\beta ) j,00 } n^j + 2 \left[p_{i,00}-m a_{i,00}\right ] n^i \delta_{\alpha \beta } \right ) \\ &
\qquad \qquad + o\left ( \frac{1}{\hat{\bar{r } } } \right ) + \hat{\bar{t } } \ o \left ( \frac{1}{\hat{\bar{r}}^3 } \right ) + \hat{\bar{t}}^2 \ o \left ( \frac{1}{\hat{\bar{r}}^3 } \right ) \biggr ] + o(\lambda^3 ) \,\ , . \end{split}\ ] ] notice that the indices on the left side of this equation have both a `` hat '' and `` bar '' on them to denote that they are components of @xmath90 in the scaled coordinates associated with our new coordinates @xmath356 .
by contrast , the indices on the right side have neither a `` hat '' nor a `` bar '' , since they denote the corresponding components in the unscaled , original coordinates @xmath51 .
thus , for example , @xmath357 denotes the matrix of first partial derivatives of the @xmath51-components of @xmath358 with respect to the @xmath51 coordinates arises from taylor expanding @xmath359 with respect to the @xmath356 coordinates , so , in principle , the second partial derivative in this expression should be with respect to @xmath360 rather than @xmath361 .
however , since @xmath360 coincides with @xmath361 at zeroth order in @xmath2 and the @xmath362 appears at second order in @xmath2 , we may replace the partial derivative with respect to @xmath360 by the partial derivative with respect to @xmath361 . ] .
it also should be understood that all tensor components appearing on the right side of eq .
( [ eq : scaled - metric ] ) are evaluated at time @xmath363 , and that @xmath364 and its derivatives , as well as @xmath365 and @xmath366 , are evaluated at @xmath367 ( i.e. , on the worldline @xmath8 ) . finally , the `` reversals '' in the roles of various terms in going from the far zone expansion of the metric eq .
( [ eq : metric2 ] ) to the near zone expansion eq .
( [ eq : scaled - metric ] ) should be noted .
for example , the spin term @xmath368 originated as a second order perturbation in the far zone , but it now appears as part of the background scaled metric in the near zone expansion .
by contrast , the term @xmath369 originated as part of the background metric in the far zone , but it now appears as a second order perturbation in the near zone expansion .
it is easy to see from eq .
( [ eq : scaled - metric ] ) that @xmath370 is the mass dipole moment of @xmath371 at time @xmath37 .
we therefore set @xmath372 for all @xmath174 .
consequently , no mass dipole term will appear in our expressions below . although we have `` solved '' for @xmath281 in eq .
( [ ap ] ) , we have not learned anything useful about the motion .
is equivalent to simply determining the mass dipole moment @xmath373 in the original coordinates .
the computations of this section may therefore be recast as simply solving enough of the second - order perturbation equations for the mass dipole moment and hence the motion to be determined . ]
all useful information about @xmath281 will come from demanding that the metrics @xmath42or , equivalently , @xmath61be solutions of einstein s equation .
we may apply einstein s equation perturbatively either via the far zone expansion or the near zone expansion .
the resulting systems of equations are entirely equivalent , but the terms are organized very differently .
we find it more convenient to work with the near zone expansion , and will do so below .
we emphasize , however , that we could equally well have used the far zone perturbation expansion .
we also emphasize that no new information whatsoever can be generated by matching the near and far zone expansions , since these expansions have already been fully `` matched '' via eqs .
( [ eq : rseries ] ) , ( [ bnmp ] ) , and ( [ eq : fullnearzone ] ) . in the following , in order to make the notation less cumbersome , we will drop the `` hat '' on the near - zone coordinates @xmath374 and on the components @xmath375 .
no confusion should arise from this , since we will not have occassion to use the original scaled coordinates @xmath58 below . on the other hand , we will maintain the `` hat '' on the coordinates @xmath356 , since we will have occassion to use both @xmath356 and @xmath51 below . using this notation and setting the mass dipole terms to zero , eq .
( [ eq : scaled - metric ] ) becomes @xmath376 \\ & \quad + \lambda^2 \biggl [ b_{\alpha i \beta j } \bar{x}^i \bar{x}^j + h^{\textrm{\tiny tail}}_{\alpha \beta \gamma}\bar{x}^\gamma + m \mathcal{r}_{\alpha \beta}(\bar{x}^i ) + 2 b_{\alpha i \beta j}a^i \bar{x}^j + 2 a_{(\alpha , \beta ) \gamma } \bar{x}^\gamma \\ & \qquad \qquad + h_{\alpha \beta } + \frac{\bar{t}}{\bar{r } } \dot{k}_{\alpha \beta } + \frac{\bar{t}^2}{\bar{r}^2 } t_{(\alpha } \ddot{s}_{\beta ) j } n^j + o\left ( \frac{1}{\bar{r } } \right ) + \bar{t } \ o \left ( \frac{1}{\bar{r}^3 } \right ) + \bar{t}^2 \ o \left ( \frac{1}{\bar{r}^3 } \right ) \biggr ] + o(\lambda^3 ) \,\ , , \end{split}\ ] ] where the `` dots '' denote derivatives with respect to @xmath174 .
we now apply the vacuum linearized einstein equation up to leading order , @xmath377 , in @xmath268 as @xmath378to the first order term in @xmath2 appearing in eq .
( [ eq : scaled - metric2 ] ) , namely @xmath379 it is clear that the terms of order @xmath271 and @xmath380 in @xmath381 can not contribute to the linearized ricci tensor to order @xmath377 .
similarly , it is clear that the terms of order @xmath271 and higher in the background scaled metric can not contribute to the linearized ricci tensor to order @xmath377 , so , to order @xmath377 , we see that @xmath382 satisfies the linearized einstein equation about the schwarzschild metric .
it is therefore useful to expand @xmath382 in tensor spherical harmonics .
we obtain one very useful piece of information by extracting the @xmath383 , magnetic parity part of the linearized ricci tensor that is even under time reversal . on account of the symmetries of the background schwarzschild metric
, only the @xmath383 , magnetic parity , even under time reversal part of the metric perturbation can contribute .
now , a general @xmath383 , symmetric ( but not necessarily trace free ) tensor field @xmath384 can be expanded in tensor spherical harmonics as ( see , e.g. , @xcite or @xcite equations ( a16 - 18 ) ) @xmath385 where the expansion coefficients @xmath386 are functions of @xmath387 .
the three - vector index on these coefficients corresponds to the three different `` @xmath149-values '' for each @xmath383 harmonic .
thus , we see that there are a grand total of eight types of @xmath383 tensor spherical harmonics .
the six harmonics associated with labeling indices @xmath388 are of electric parity , whereas the two harmonics associated with @xmath389 are of magnetic parity . for the metric perturbation ( [ eq : scaled-1 ] )
the `` constant tensors '' @xmath365 and @xmath390 are purely electric parity and can not contribute .
it turns out that @xmath391 also does not contribute to the @xmath383 , magnetic parity part of the linearized ricci tensor that is even under time reversal : since @xmath392 is independent of @xmath156 the `` @xmath32 '' part of @xmath392 is odd under time reversal , whereas the `` @xmath145 '' part of @xmath391 is pure gauge .
thus , the only term that contributes to order @xmath377 to the @xmath383 , magnetic parity part of of the linearized ricci tensor that is even under time reversal is @xmath393 .
satisfaction of vacuum linearized einstein equation at order @xmath377 requires that this term vanish .
we thereby learn that @xmath394 i.e. , to lowest order , the spin is parallelly propagated with respect to the background metric along the worldline @xmath8 .
having set the spin term to zero in eq.([eq : scaled-1 ] ) , we may now substitute the remaining terms in eq .
( [ eq : scaled-1 ] ) into the linearized einstein equation and set the @xmath377 part equal to zero .
it is clear that we will thereby obtain relations between @xmath395 , @xmath359 , and @xmath396 .
however , these relations will not be of direct interest for obtaining `` equations of motion''i.e . ,
equations relating @xmath281 and its time derivatives to known quantities because the quantity of interest @xmath397 always appears in combination with the quantity @xmath398 , which is unrelated to the motion .
therefore , we shall not explicitly compute the relations arising from the linearized einstein equation here .
we now consider the information on @xmath281 that can be obtained from the near zone second - order einstein equation @xmath399 = - g^{(2)}_{ab}[\bar{g}^{(1 ) } , \bar{g}^{(1)}],\ ] ] where , from eq .
( [ eq : scaled - metric2 ] ) , we see that @xmath400 where we have defined @xmath401 we wish to impose the second order einstein equation to orders @xmath271 and @xmath380 , which , as we shall see below , are the lowest nontrivial orders in @xmath268 as @xmath378 that occur .
first , we consider @xmath402 $ ] .
the terms appearing in this quantity can be organized into terms of the following general forms ( i ) @xmath403 ; ( ii ) @xmath404 ; ( iii ) @xmath405 where @xmath406 denotes a christoffel symbol of the background scaled metric ; ( iv ) @xmath407 ; and ( v ) @xmath408 . from the form of @xmath409
together with the fact that @xmath410 and @xmath411 , it is clear that none of these terms can contribute to @xmath412 $ ] to order @xmath271 or @xmath380 .
therefore , we may treat @xmath413 as satisfying the homogeneous , vacuum linearized einstein equation .
we now consider the linearized ricci tensor of the perturbation @xmath413 . by inspection of eq .
( [ eq : scaled-2 ] ) , it might appear that terms that are @xmath184 ( from two partial derivatives acting on the `` b '' term ) and @xmath414 ( from various terms ) will arise .
however , it is not difficult to show that the total contribution to the @xmath184 and @xmath414 terms will vanish by virtue of the fact that the metric @xmath171 is a solution to einstein s equation and the term proportional to @xmath2 in eq .
( [ eq : metric2 ] ) satisfies the far zone linearized einstein equation ( which has already been imposed ) .
it also is clear that there is no contribution of @xmath413 to the linearized ricci tensor that is of order @xmath415 .
thus , the lowest nontrivial orders that arise in the second order einstein equation are indeed @xmath271 and @xmath380 , as claimed above .
the computation of the linearized ricci tensor to orders @xmath271 and @xmath380 for the metric perturbation @xmath413 is quite complicated , so we will save considerable labor by focusing on the relevant part of the linearized einstein equation to these orders .
our hope / expectation ( which will be borne out by our calculation ) is to obtain an equation for @xmath416 .
since this quantity is of @xmath383 , electric parity type and is even under time reversal , we shall focus on the @xmath383 , electric parity , even under time reversal part of the linearized ricci tensor of @xmath413 at orders @xmath271 and @xmath380 . from eq .
( [ eq : harmonics ] ) , we see that the @xmath383 electric parity part of the ricci tensor that is @xmath417 and even under time reversal can be written as @xmath418 whereas the @xmath383 part of the ricci tensor that is @xmath419 and even under time reversal can be written as @xmath420 here , in contrast to the usage of , @xmath421 are `` constants '' , i.e , they have no dependence on @xmath422 .
we now consider the terms in @xmath413 that can contribute to these ricci terms .
the term @xmath423 has no @xmath424 part .
nevertheless , the @xmath425 magnetic parity part of this term can , in effect , combine with the @xmath383 magnetic parity `` spin term '' @xmath426 in the background scaled metric to produce a contribution to the linearized ricci tensor of the correct type .
this contribution will be proportional to @xmath427 for the remaining terms in @xmath413 , the `` spin term '' @xmath426 in the background scaled metric will not contribute to the relevant parts of the linearized ricci tensor , so we may treat the remaining terms in @xmath413 as though they were perturbations of schwarzschild .
thus , only the @xmath383 , electric parity , even under time reversal part of these terms can contribute .
the remaining contributors to @xmath428 , and @xmath429 are @xmath430 and @xmath431 where , in eq .
( [ d ] ) , we have @xmath432(the curvature term @xmath300 has not appeared in the above equations because it has no @xmath383 part . )
the @xmath433 are also constants " in these expressions .
a lengthy calculation now yields @xmath434 using the vacuum linearized einstein equation @xmath435 , we thus obtain 6 linear equations for our 11 unknowns
. however , in order to find `` universial '' behavior , we are interested in relations that do not involve @xmath436 and @xmath437 . it can be shown that there are two such relations in near - zone perturbation theory the vanishing of the value , time derivative , and second time derivative of the mass dipole at time @xmath37 .
the third condition should follow from the first - order near - zone einstein equation , which we did not fully use .
in fact , it should only be necessary to impose that the mass dipole have no second time derivative in order to define the motion .
] , namely @xmath438 and @xmath439 the first equation involves @xmath440 and spatial derivatives of @xmath281 , and does not yield restrictions on the motion .
however , the second equation gives desired equations of motion .
plugging in the definitions of the quantities appearing in eq .
( [ motion ] ) , we obtain @xmath441 where we have taken advantage of the fact ( noted above ) that for @xmath442 and @xmath443 components we have @xmath444 . using the equality of mixed partials
@xmath445 , we obtain @xmath446 thus , according to the interpretation provided in section [ sec : dipole ] above , the first order perturbative correction , @xmath447 , to the geodesic @xmath8 of the background spacetime satisfies @xmath448 in addition , we have previously found that @xmath32 and @xmath33 are constant along @xmath8 .
taking account of the fact that this equation is written in fermi normal coordinates of @xmath8 and that @xmath253 , we can rewrite this equation in a more manifestly covariant looking form as @xmath449 where @xmath7 is the tangent to @xmath8 and @xmath450 .
however , it should be emphasized that this equation describes the perturbed motion only when the metric perturbation is in the lorenz gauge ( see appendix a ) . the first term in eq .
( [ eq : eom ] ) ( or , equivalently , in eq .
( [ eq : eomcov ] ) ) is the `` spin force '' first obtained by papapetrou @xcite .
contributions from higher multipole moments do not appear in our equation because they scale to zero faster than the spin dipole moment , and thus would arise at higher order in @xmath2 in our perturbation scheme .
the second term corresponds to the right side of the geodesic deviation equation , and appears because the perturbed worldline is not ( except at special points ) coincident with the background worldline . in the limit @xmath451
, the body then moves on a family of geodesics of the background metric parameterized by @xmath2 , and the perturbative description of motion should indeed be the geodesic deviation equation . ] .
the final term is the `` gravitational self - force '' , which is seen to take the form of a ( regularized ) gravitational force from the particle s own field .
our derivation has thus provided a rigorous justification of the regularization schemes that have been proposed elsewhere .
finally , we note that , although our analysis has many points of contact with previous analyses using matched asymptotic expansions , there are a number of significant differences .
we have already noted in section [ sec : geodesic ] that our derivation of geodesic motion at zeroth order in @xmath2 appears to differ from some other derivations @xcite , which do not appear to impose the requirement that @xmath241 .
we also have already noted that in other approaches to self - force @xcite , what corresponds to our scaled metric at @xmath38 is _ assumed _ to be of schwarzschild form . in these other approaches , first order perturbations in the near zone expansion
are treated as time independent , and are required to be regular on the schwarzschild horizon .
by contrast we make no assumptions about the time - dependence of the perturbations of the scaled metric beyond those that follow from our fundamental assumptions ( i)-(iii ) of section [ sec : example ] .
thus , our first order perturbations are allowed to have linear dependence on @xmath156 , and our second order perturbations can depend quadratically on @xmath156 .
we also make no assumptions about the spacetime at @xmath165 and therefore impose no boundary conditions at small @xmath72 .
finally , there is a significant difference in the manner in which the gauge conditions used to define the motion are imposed . in @xcite , the entire @xmath424 electric parity part of what corresponds to our second order near zone perturbation
is set to zero without proper justification electric parity perturbation that is relevant for obtaining equations of motion in @xcite is of `` acceleration type '' ( with linear growth in @xmath72 ) and does not have an obvious interpretation in terms of a shift in the center of mass . ] .
by contrast , our `` no mass dipole '' condition applies to the _ background _ near - zone metric and has been justified as providing `` center of mass '' coordinates .
as already mentioned near the beginning of section [ sec : dipole ] , the quantity @xmath29 in eq . is a `` deviation vector '' defined on the background geodesic @xmath8 that describes the first order in @xmath2 perturbation to the motion . for any one parameter family of spacetimes
@xmath42 satisfying the assumptions stated in section [ sec : example ] , eq .
is therefore guaranteed to give a good approximation to the deviation from the background geodesic motion @xmath8 as @xmath35 .
in other words , if @xmath8 is described by @xmath250 , then the new worldline obtained defined by @xmath452 is the correct description of motion to first order in @xmath2 ( when the metric perturbation is in lorenz gauge ) and is therefore guaranteed to be accurate at small @xmath2 .
however , this guarantee is of the form that if one wants to describe the motion accurately up to time @xmath174 , then it always will be possible to choose @xmath2 sufficiently small that @xmath452 is a good approximation up to time @xmath174 .
the guarantee is _ not _ of the form that if @xmath2 is chosen to be sufficiently small , then @xmath452 will accurately describe the motion for all time .
indeed , for any fixed @xmath453 , it is to be expected that @xmath447 will grow large at sufficiently late times , and it is clear that the approximate description of motion @xmath452 can not be expected to be good when @xmath447 is large , since by the time the motion has deviated significantly from the original background geodesic @xmath8 , the motion clearly can not be accurately described in the framework of being a `` small correction '' to @xmath8 . however , the main intended application of the first order corrected equations of motion is to compute motion in cases , such as inspiral , where the deviations from the original geodesic motion become large at late times .
it is therefore clear that eq .
, as it stands , is useless for computing long term effects , such as inspiral .
one possible response to the above difficulty would be to go to higher order in perturbation theory . however , it seems clear that this will not help .
although the equations of motion obtained from @xmath454th order perturbation theory will be more accurate than the first order equations , they will not have a domain of validity that is significantly larger than the first order equations .
the perturbative description at any finite order will continue to treat the motion as a `` small deviation '' from @xmath8 , and can not be expected to describe motion accurately when the deviations are , in fact , large .
in essence , by the time that the deviation from @xmath8 has become sufficiently large to invalidate first order perturbation theory
so that , e.g. , the second order corrections are comparable in magnitude to the first order corrections then one would expect that the @xmath455th order corrections will also be comparable to the @xmath454th order corrections , so @xmath454th order perturbation theory will not be accurate either . only by going to all orders in perturbation theory
can one expect to get an accurate , global in time , description of motion via perturbation theory . of course
, if one goes to all orders in perturbation theory , then there is little point in having done perturbation theory at all .
nevertheless , for a sufficiently small body of suffciently small mass , it seems clear that the corrections to geodesic motion should be _ locally _ small and should be locally described by eq . .
by the time these small corrections have built up and the body has deviated significantly from the original geodesic approximating its motion , it should then be close to a _
geodesic , perturbing off of which should give a better approximation to the motion for that portion of time .
one could then attempt to `` patch together '' such solutions to construct a world - line that accurately describes the motion of the particle for a longer time .
in the limit of many such patches with small times between them , one expects the resulting worldline to be described by a single `` self - consistent '' differential equation , which should then well - approximate the motion as long as it remains _ locally _ close to geodesic motion . a simple , familiar example will help illustrate all of the above points .
consider the cooling of a `` black body '' . to choose a definite problem that can be put in a framework similar to that considered in this paper ,
let us consider a body ( such as a lump of hot coal ) that is put in a box with perfect reflecting walls , but a hole of area @xmath456 is cut in the this wall .
we are interested in determining how the energy , @xmath457 , of the body changes with time . at finite @xmath456 ,
this is a very difficult problem , since the body will not remain in exact thermal equilibrium as it radiates energy through the hole .
however , let us consider a one - parameter family of cavities where @xmath458 smoothly goes to zero as @xmath35 .
when @xmath82 , we find that the energy , @xmath459 , does not change with time , and the body will remain in thermal equilibrium at temperature @xmath460 for all time . when we do first order perturbation theory in @xmath2 , we will find that the first order in @xmath2 correction , @xmath461 , to the energy satisfies becomes small compared to the typical wavelengths of the radiation ( as it must as we let @xmath462 ) , we enter a physical optics regime where our formulas are no longer valid .
we ignore such effects here , just as in our above analysis of the motion of bodies in general relativity we ignored quantum gravity effects even though they should be important when the size of the body is smaller than the planck scale . ]
@xmath463 where @xmath464 is the stefan - boltzmann constant and @xmath465 .
note that only the zeroth order temperature , @xmath460 , enters the right side of this equation because the quantity @xmath466 is already first order in @xmath2 , so the effect of any changes in temperature would appear only to higher order in @xmath2 . since @xmath460 is a constant , it is easy to integrate eq .
( [ de ] ) to obtain , @xmath467 thus , first order perturbation theory approximates the behavior of @xmath468 as @xmath469 although this is a good approximation at early times , it is a horrible approximation at late times , as it predicts that the energy will go negative .
if one went to second order in perturbation theory , one would obtain corrections to eq .
( [ de ] ) that would take into account the first order energy loss as well as various non - equilibrium effects . however , one would still be perturbing off of the non - radiating background , and the late time predictions using second ( or any finite higher order ) perturbation theory would still be very poor .
however , there is an obvious major improvement that can be obtained by noting that if @xmath456 is sufficiently small , then the body should remain nearly in thermal equilibrium as it loses energy .
therefore , although perturbation theory off of the zeroth order solution may give poor results at late times , first order perturbation theory off of _ some _ thermal equilibrium solution should give locally accurate results at all times .
this suggests that if @xmath456 is sufficiently small , the cooling of the body should be described by @xmath470 when supplemented with the formula , @xmath471 , that relates energy to temperature when the body is in thermal equilibrium , this equation should provide an excellent description of the cooling of the body that is valid at all times . in effect , eq .
( [ denew ] ) takes into account the higher order perturbative effects ( to all orders in @xmath2 ) associated with the cooling of the body , but it neglects various perturbative effects associated with the body failing to remain in thermal equilibrium as it cools . equation ( [ denew ] ) is _ not _ an exact equation ( since it does not take various non - equilibrium effects into account ) and it is _ not _ an equation that arises directly from perturbation theory .
rather , it is an equation that corresponds to applying first order perturbation theory to a background that itself undergoes changes resulting from the perturbation .
we will refer to such an equation as a `` self - consistent perturbative equation '' .
such equations are commonly written down for systems that can be described _ locally in time _ by a small deviation from a simple solution .
how does one find a `` self - consistent perturbative equation '' for a given system for which one has derived first order perturbative equations ?
we do not believe that there is any general method for deriving a self - consistent perturbative equation .
however , the following appear to be appropriate criteria to impose on a self - consistent perturbative equation : ( 1 ) it should have a well posed initial value formulation .
( 2 ) it should have the same number of degrees of freedom as the first order perturbative system , so that a correspondence can be made between initial data for the self - consistent perturbative equation and the first order perturbative system .
( 3 ) for corresponding initial data , the solutions to the self - consistent perturbative equation should be close to the corresponding solutions of the first order perturbative system over the time interval for which the first order perturbative description should be accurate .
we do not know of any reason why , for any given system , there need exist a self - consistent perturbative equation satisfying these criteria . in cases
where a self - consistent perturbative equation satisfying these criteria does exist , we would not expect it to be unique .
for example , we could modify eq .
( [ denew ] ) by adding suitable terms proportional to @xmath472 to the right side of this equation .
the first order perturbative equations for the motion of a small body are that the first order metric perturbation satisfies @xmath473 where @xmath116 corresponds to a geodesic , @xmath8 of the background spacetime , and @xmath7 is the tangent to @xmath8 .
if we consider the retarded solution to this equation ( which automatically satisfies the lorenz gauge condition ) , we have proven rigorously in this paper that the first order in @xmath2 deviation of the motion from @xmath8 satisfies @xmath474 with @xmath475 where , for simplicity , we have dropped the spin term .
the misataquwa equations
@xmath476 @xmath477 @xmath20 ( where one chooses the retarded solution to eq .
( [ misa2 ] ) ) are an excellent candidate for self - consistent perturbative equations corresponding to the above first order perturbative system ) , since in the self - consistent perturbative equation , the deviation from the self - consistent worldline should vanish . ] . here
, @xmath478 ( normalized in the background metric ) refers to the self - consistent motion @xmath479 , rather than to a background geodesic as before .
although a proper mathematical analysis of this integro - differential system has not been carried out , it appears plausible that our above criteria ( 1)-(3 ) will be satisfied by the misataquwa equations .
if so , they should provide a good , global in time , description of motion for problems like extreme mass ratio inspiral .
we wish to thank abraham harte and eric poisson for helpful discussions .
this research was supported in part by nsf grant phy04 - 56619 to the university of chicago and a national science foundation graduate research fellowship to sg .
as discussed in section [ sec : dipole ] , the description of motion will change under first - order changes of gauge .
indeed , in that section , we noted that under a smooth gauge transformation , the description of motion changes by eq .
( [ smoothgauge ] ) . however , as previously stated near the end of section [ sec : example ] above ( see equation ) , the allowed coordinate freedom includes transformations that are not smooth at @xmath50 . since such gauges may arise in practice singularity along a string @xcite , and therefore do not satisfy our assumptions . ] , we provide here the expression for the first order perturbative equation of motion in an arbitrary gauge allowed by our assumptions .
we also present the corresponding self - consistent perturbative equations of motion . as previously noted in section [ sec : calculation ] ( see the remark below eq .
( [ jh ] ) ) , the equations of motion to first order in @xmath2 depend only upon the first order gauge transformation @xmath480 .
as we have seen , the mass dipole moment appears at second - order in ( far zone ) perturbation theory , so we must consider the effects of first - order gauge transformations on second - order perturbations .
this is given by @xmath481 , with @xmath482 where @xmath483 denotes the lie derivative .
equivalently , we have @xmath484 where @xmath191 is the derivative operator associated with the background metric @xmath171 . in order to satisfy the criteria on allowed gauge transformations ( see equation )
, the components of @xmath480 must be of the form @xmath485 i.e. , @xmath480 can not `` blow up '' at @xmath50 but it can be singular in the sense that its components can have direction - dependent limits .
the mass dipole moment , @xmath373 , is one - half of the coefficient of the @xmath383 part of the leading order , @xmath310 , part of the second order metric perturbation , @xmath486 .
therefore , @xmath373 may be extracted from the formula , @xmath487 where ds is the area element on the sphere of radius @xmath488 . under the gauge transformation generated by @xmath480
, we have @xmath489 as previously noted , for an arbitrary first - order perturbation satisfying our assumptions , we have @xmath490 where @xmath32 is the mass of the body . from eqs .
( [ xiform ] ) , ( [ dg200 ] ) and ( [ g100 ] ) , we see that the change in @xmath486 induced by our gauge transformation is @xmath491 therefore , by eq .
( [ eq : app - dip ] ) , the induced change in the mass dipole moment is @xmath492 where @xmath493 is the area element on the unit sphere . equation ( [ dp ] ) gives the change in the mass dipole moment induced by the possibly non - smooth gauge transformation generated by @xmath480 .
the corresponding change in the first order perturbative equation of motion is determined by the change in the _ smooth _ vector field @xmath494 required to eliminate the mass dipole .
writing @xmath495 , this change is given by @xmath496 ( see eq . ) .
thus , the change @xmath497 induced in the deviation vector describing the perturbed worldline is @xmath498 with @xmath499 given by eq . .
in the case where our original gauge was the lorenz gauge , it follows immediately from eq .
( [ eq : eom ] ) that the new equation of motion for @xmath500 is @xmath501 where @xmath502 is given by eq .
( [ eq : gauge - law ] ) , and where , for simplicity , we have dropped the spin term .
we may rewrite eq .
( [ eq : eom - app2 ] ) as @xmath503 note that although eq .
( [ eq : eom - app6 ] ) provides us with the desired equation of motion in an arbitrary allowed gauge , the terms involving components of @xmath504 must still be computed in the lorenz gauge .
now suppose one wishes to pass to a self - consistent perturbative equation associated with the new choice of gauge .
it is not obvious how one might wish to modify the evolution equations for the metric perturbations in the new gauge .
( one possibility would be to simply use eq .
( [ misa2 ] ) and then modify the result by the addition of @xmath505 but it might be preferable to find a new equation based on a suitable `` relaxed '' version of the linearized einstein equation for the new gauge . )
however , it appears that a natural choice of self - consistent perturbative equation associated to eq .
( [ eq : eom - app6 ] ) would be @xmath506 in the case where @xmath480 is smooth ( so that , by eq . (
[ eq : gauge - law ] ) , we have @xmath507 ) this agrees with the proposal of barack and ori @xcite .
wald 1984 _ general relativity _
( chicago , il : university of chicago press ) r. geroch and j. traschen , _ phys . rev .
d _ * 36 * , 1017 ( 1987 ) s. weinberg 1972 _ gravitation and cosmology _
( new york : wiley ) w. israel , _
nuovo cim .
b _ * 44 * 1 ( 1966 ) y. mino , m. sasaki , and t. tanaka , _ phys
d _ , * 55 * , 3457 - 3476 , ( 1997 ) t.c .
quinn and r.m .
wald , _ phys .
d _ , * 56 * , 3381 - 3394 , ( 1997 ) s. detweiler and b.f .
whiting , _ phys .
* 67 * , 024025 , ( 2003 ) e. poisson , _ liv .
rel . _ * 7 * 6 ( 2004 ) b.s .
dewitt and r.w .
brehme , _ ann .
_ , * 9 * , 220 - 259 , ( 1960 ) p. a. m. dirac , _ proc .
lond . a _ * 167 * 148 ( 1938 ) w. l. burke , _ j. math .
( n.y . ) * 12 * , 401 ( 1971 ) p. d. death , _ phys .
d _ * 11 * 1387 ( 1975 ) r. kates , _ phys .
* 22 * 1853 ( 1980 ) k. s. thorne and j. b. hartle , _ phys .
d _ * 31 * 1815 ( 1985 ) r. geroch and p.s .
* 16 * ( 1975 ) , pp . 65 - 67 j. ehlers and r. geroch , _ ann .
phys . _ * 309 * , 232 ( 2004 ) d.a.m .
stuart , _ j. math .
pures appl .
_ * 83 * , 541 ( 2004 ) a. papapetrou , _ proc .
. london _ * a209 * , pp .
248 - 258 ( 1951 ) l. barack and a. ori , _ phys .
d _ , * 64 * , 124003 , 1 - 13 , ( 2001 ) s. gralla , a. harte , and r. wald , in preparation r. geroch , _ commun .
* 13 * 180 ( 1969 ) t. futamase and y. itoh , _ living rev
. relativity _ * 10 * , 2 ( 2007 ) r.m .
wald , _ phys .
lett . _ * 41 * 203 ( 1978 ) w. beiglbock , _ commun .
_ * 5 * , 106 ( 1967 ) r. geroch , _ j. math
* 11 * 2580 ( 1970 ) r. o. hansen , _ j. math
. phys . _ * 15 * 46 ( 1974 ) r. beig and w. simon , _ gen .
* 12 * 1003 ( 1980 ) p. kundu , _
_ , 22 , 1236 ( 1981 ) x.h .
zhang , _ phys .
d _ * 34 * 991 ( 1986 ) k. s. thorne , _ rev .
_ _ 52 _ 299 ( 1980 ) l. blanchet and t. damour , _ philos .
. london _ * a320 * , 379 ( 1986 )
|
there is general agreement that the misataquwa equations should describe the motion of a small body " in general relativity , taking into account the leading order self - force effects .
however , previous derivations of these equations have made a number of ad hoc assumptions and/or contain a number of unsatisfactory features .
for example , all previous derivations have invoked , without proper justification , the step of `` lorenz gauge relaxation '' , wherein the linearized einstein equation is written down in the form appropriate to the lorenz gauge , but the lorenz gauge condition is then not imposed thereby making the resulting equations for the metric perturbation inequivalent to the linearized einstein equations .
( such a `` relaxation '' of the linearized einstein equations is essential in order to avoid the conclusion that `` point particles '' move on geodesics . ) in this paper , we analyze the issue of `` particle motion '' in general relativity in a systematic and rigorous way by considering a one - parameter family of metrics , @xmath0 , corresponding to having a body ( or black hole ) that is `` scaled down '' to zero size and mass in an appropriate manner .
we prove that the limiting worldline of such a one - parameter family must be a geodesic of the background metric , @xmath1 .
gravitational self - force as well as the force due to coupling of the spin of the body to curvature then arises as a first - order perturbative correction in @xmath2 to this worldline .
no assumptions are made in our analysis apart from the smoothness and limit properties of the one - parameter family of metrics , @xmath0 .
our approach should provide a framework for systematically calculating higher order corrections to gravitational self - force , including higher multipole effects , although we do not attempt to go beyond first order calculations here . the status of the misataquwa equations is explained .
|
the schwinger - dyson ( sd ) equation is one of the most popular approaches to investigate the non - perturbative features of quantum field theory .
the analyses by making use of the sd equation for quark propagator are well - known .
recently , the coupled sd equations for the gluon and ghost propagators in yang - mills theory have been studied mainly in the lorentz ( landau ) gauge.@xcite in this paper , we derive the sd equations for the @xmath0 yang - mills theory in the maximal abelian ( ma ) gauge and solve them analytically in the infrared ( ir ) asymptotic region .
the ma gauge is useful to investigate the yang - mills theory from the view point of the dual superconductivity . in the ma gauge , in contrast to the ordinary lorentz gauge
, we must explicitly distinguish the diagonal components of the fields from the off - diagonal components .
this is indeed the case even in the perturbative analysis in the uv region.@xcite therefore , we must take account of the four propagators for the diagonal gluon , off - diagonal gluon , diagonal ghost and off - diagonal ghost
. numerical behaviors of gluon propagators in the ma gauge are also investigated on a lattice simulation.@xcite
first , we derive the sd equations from the @xmath0 yang - mills action in the ma gauge@xcite . the graphical representation of sd equations are shown in figure [ fig : sde ] .
= .001 in ( 6000,1800 ) ( 0,-200)(0,500)(0,150)(450,300)(600,160)(800,200)(1250,300)(1400,160)(1600,0)(2000,350)(2200,160)(2400,160)(3600,160)(3800,160)(0,1000)(0,150)(450,300)(600,160)(800,200)(1250,300)(1400,160)(1600,100)(2000,350)(2200,160)(2400,160)(3600,160)(3800,160)(0,1500)(0,150)(0,250)(450,300)(600,160)(800,200)(1000,250)(1250,300)(1400,160)(1600,0)(1570,230)(2200,160)(2400,0)(2370,230)(3000,160)(3200,160)(4400,160)(4600,160)(0,0)(0,150)(0,250)(450,300)(600,160)(800,200)(1000,250)(1250,300 ) for the diagonal gluon propagator , we adopt the landau gauge so that the diagonal gluon propagator @xmath1 has only the transverse part @xmath2 where we defined the form factor @xmath3 . while , the off - diagonal gluon propagator @xmath4 has both the transverse and longitudinal parts @xmath5\delta^{ab},\ ] ] where we defined the form factors @xmath6 and @xmath7 .
the form factor @xmath8 for the off - diagonal ghost propagator @xmath9 is defined @xmath10 the diagonal ghost propagator is decoupled from the other fields so that we omit it hereafter .
now , we write down the sd equations : @xmath11 @xmath12 and @xmath13 here the contributions from the two - loop graphs have been omitted .
the full form of sd equations will be given in a separate paper@xcite .
@xmath14 is the full vertex function for the diagonal gluon , off - diagonal ghost and off - diagonal antighost interaction , while @xmath15 is the full vertex function for an interaction of the diagonal gluon and two off - diagonal gluons , and the superscript `` @xmath16 '' means a _ bare _ propagator or vertex function . in the ma gauge
, we obtain the slavnov - taylor ( st ) identities @xmath17 @xmath18
in order to solve the sd equations analytically , we employ the following approximations .
@xmath19 we neglect the two - loop contributions . instead of the full vertex functions ,
we adopt modified vertex functions which are compatible with the st identities .
we adopt approximations for vertex functions as @xmath20 and @xmath21 here , we adopt the feynman gauge for the off - diagonal gluon for simplicity , that is , @xmath22 and @xmath23 . substituting the bare form factors , which are @xmath24 , into the right hand side of the ansatz ( [ eq : acc ] ) and ( [ eq : aaa ] )
, we obtain the bare vertex functions .
moreover , these ansatz are compatible with the st identities ( [ eq : sti - c ] ) and ( [ eq : sti - a ] ) in the limit of @xmath25 . in the momentum integration
, we use the higashijima - miransky approximation@xcite as @xmath26
now we adopt the ansatz for the form factors in the ir region : @xmath27 g(p^2 ) = b(p^2)^v+\cdots,\\[1 mm ] f_{\rm t}(p^2 ) = c(p^2)^w+\cdots . \end{array } \label{eq : ir solutions}\ ] ] substituting the ansatz ( [ eq : ir solutions ] ) for the form factors , and the ansatz ( [ eq : acc ] ) and ( [ eq : aaa ] ) for vertex functions into the sd equations ( [ eq : diagonal gluon ] ) , ( [ eq : off - diagonal ghost ] ) and ( [ eq : off - diagonal gluon ] ) , and comparing the leading term in the both sides of each equation , we obtain the following results for @xmath22 . from eqs .
( [ eq : off - diagonal ghost ] ) and ( [ eq : off - diagonal gluon ] ) , we obtain the relations @xmath28 and @xmath29 . in the case of @xmath30 and @xmath31 , from the eq .
( [ eq : diagonal gluon ] ) , we obtain the relation @xmath32 so that @xmath33 is less than @xmath34 . in the case of @xmath35 and @xmath31 , we need redefine the form factor @xmath8 as @xmath36 with @xmath37 since contributions from the leading term of @xmath8 are canceled each other in the ansatz ( [ eq : acc ] ) .
therefore we need the information of next leading term of the form factor @xmath8 . in this case
we obtain the relation @xmath38 from the eq .
( [ eq : diagonal gluon ] ) so that @xmath33 is also less than @xmath34 .
next , we consider the case of @xmath30 and @xmath39 . as well as the above case , we need redefine the form factor @xmath6 as @xmath40 with @xmath41 and we obtain the relation @xmath42 ( @xmath43 ) .
similarly , in the case of @xmath44 , we obtain the relation @xmath45 ( @xmath43 ) .
the results are summarized in table [ tbl : feynman gauge ] .
@xmath32 & @xmath42 @xmath35 & @xmath38 & @xmath45 [ tbl : feynman gauge ] in the gauge other than the feynman gauge , that is , @xmath46 , the calculation and discussion are very tedious
. however , the qualitative results are identical to the above case except for the following one point . in this case , even if @xmath39 , there occurs no cancellation as in the above two cases 2c and 2d .
this is because the off - diagonal gluon propagator has the momentum dependent tensor structure for @xmath46 , while it is proportional to @xmath47 for @xmath22 .
therefore , we obtain the relation @xmath48 in the case of @xmath39 .
( see table [ tbl : not feynman gauge ] . )
@xmath30 & @xmath32 & @xmath48 @xmath35 & @xmath38 & @xmath48 [ tbl : not feynman gauge ]
in the ir limit , the form factors of each propagator behave as @xmath49 @xmath50 @xmath51 therefore the solution shows that the diagonal gluon propagator is enhanced in the ir limit , while the off - diagonal gluon and off - diagonal ghost propagators are suppressed in the ir region .
our results are compatible with a hypothesis of abelian dominance@xcite .
|
we derive the schwinger - dyson equations for the @xmath0 yang - mills theory in the maximal abelian gauge and solve them in the infrared asymptotic region .
we find that the infrared asymptotic solutions for the gluon and ghost propagators are consistent with the hypothesis of abelian dominance .
|
information - theoretic research on capacity and coding for write - limited memory originates in @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . in @xcite ,
the authors consider a model of write - once memory ( wom ) .
in particular , each memory cell can be in state either 0 or 1 .
the state of a cell can go from 0 to 1 , but not from 1 back to 0 later .
these write - once bits are called _ wits_. it is shown that , the efficiency of storing information in a wom can be improved if one allows multiple rewrites and designs the storage / rewrite scheme carefully .
multilevel flash memory is a storage technology where the charge level of any cell can be easily increased , but is difficult to decrease .
recent multilevel cell technology allows many charge levels to be stored in a cell .
cells are organized into blocks that contain roughly @xmath2 cells .
the only way to decrease the charge level of a cell is to erase the whole block ( i.e. , set the charge on all cells to zero ) and reprogram each cell .
this takes time , consumes energy , and reduces the lifetime of the memory .
therefore , it is important to design efficient rewriting schemes that maximize the number of rewrites between two erasures @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
the rewriting schemes increase some cell charge levels based on the current cell state and message to be stored . in this paper
, we call a rewriting scheme a _ modulation code_. two different objective functions for modulation codes are primarily considered in previous work : ( i ) maximizing the number of rewrites for the worst case @xcite and ( ii ) maximizing for the average case @xcite . as
finucane et al .
@xcite mentioned , the reason for considering average performance is the averaging effect caused by the large number of erasures during the lifetime of a flash memory device .
our analysis shows that the worst - case objective and the average case objective are two extreme cases of our optimization objective .
we also discuss under what conditions each optimality measure makes sense . in previous work ( e.g. , @xcite ) ,
many modulation codes are shown to be asymptotically optimal as the number of cell - levels @xmath0 goes to infinity .
but the condition that @xmath1 can not be satisfied in practical systems . therefore , we also analyze asymptotically optimal modulation codes when @xmath0 is only moderately large using the results from load - balancing theory @xcite .
this suggests an enhanced algorithm that improves the performance of practical system significantly .
theoretical analysis and simulation results show that this algorithm performs better than other asymptotically optimal algorithms when @xmath0 is moderately large .
the structure of the paper is as follows .
the system model and performance evaluation metrics are discussed in section [ sec : optimality - measure ] .
an asymptotically optimal modulation code , which is universal over arbitrary i.i.d .
input distributions , is proposed in section [ sub : another - rewriting - algorithm ] .
the storage efficiency of this asymptotically optimal modulation code is analyzed in section [ sec : an - enhanced - algorithm ] .
an enhanced modulation code is also presented in section [ sec : an - enhanced - algorithm ] .
the storage efficiency of the enhanced algorithm is also analyzed in section [ sec : an - enhanced - algorithm ] .
simulation results and comparisons are presented in section [ sec : simulation - results ] .
the paper is concluded in section [ sec : conclusion ] .
flash memory devices usually rely on error detecting / correcting codes to ensure a low error rate . so far
, practical systems tend to use bose - chaudhuri - hocquenghem ( bch ) and reed - solomon ( rs ) codes .
the error - correcting codes ( ecc s ) are used as the outer codes while the modulation codes are the inner codes . in this paper , we focus on the modulation codes and ignore the noise and the design of ecc for now .
let us assume that a block contains @xmath3 @xmath0-level cells and that @xmath4 cells ( called an @xmath4-cell ) are used together to store @xmath5 @xmath6-ary variables ( called a @xmath5-variable ) .
a block contains @xmath7 @xmath4-cells and the @xmath7 @xmath5-variables are assumed to be i.i.d . random variables .
we assume that all the @xmath5-variables are updated together randomly at the same time and the new values are stored in the corresponding @xmath4-cells .
this is a reasonable assumption in a system with an outer ecc .
we use the subscript @xmath8 to denote the time index and each rewrite increases @xmath8 by 1 .
when we discuss a modulation code , we focus on a single @xmath4-cell .
( the encoder of the modulation code increases some of the cell - levels based on the current cell - levels and the new value of the @xmath5-variable . )
remember that cell - levels can only be increased during a rewrite .
so , when any cell - level must be increased beyond the maximum value @xmath9 , the whole block is erased and all the cell levels are reset to zero .
we let the maximal allowable number of block - erasures be @xmath10 and assume that after @xmath10 block erasures , the device becomes unreliable .
assume the @xmath5-variable written at time @xmath8 is a random variable @xmath11 sampled from the set @xmath12 with distribution @xmath13 .
for convenience , we also represent the @xmath5-variable at time @xmath8 in the vector form as @xmath14 where @xmath15 denotes the set of integers modulo @xmath6 .
the cell - state vector at time @xmath8 is denoted as @xmath16 and @xmath17 denotes the charge level of the @xmath18-th cell at time @xmath19 when we say @xmath20 we mean @xmath21 for @xmath22 since the charge level of a cell can only be increased , continuous use of the memory implies that an erasure of the whole block will be required at some point .
although writes , reads and erasures can all introduce noise into the memory , we neglect this and assume that the writes , reads and erasures are noise - free .
consider writing information to a flash memory when encoder knows the previous cell state @xmath23 the current @xmath5-variable @xmath24 , and an encoding function @xmath25 that maps @xmath24 and @xmath26 to a new cell - state vector @xmath27 .
the decoder only knows the current cell state @xmath27 and the decoding function @xmath28 that maps the cell state @xmath27 back to the variable vector @xmath29 .
of course , the encoding and decoding functions could change over time to improve performance , but we only consider time - invariant encoding / decoding functions for simplicity .
the idea of designing efficient modulation codes jointly to store multiple variables in multiple cells was introduced by jiang @xcite . in previous work on modulation codes
design for flash memory ( e.g. @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) , the lifetime of the memory ( either worst - case or average ) is maximized given fixed amount of information per rewrite .
improving storage density and extending the lifetime of the device are two conflicting objectives .
one can either fix one and optimize the other or optimize over these two jointly .
most previous work ( e.g. , @xcite ) takes the first approach by fixing the amount of information for each rewrite and maximizing the number of rewrites between two erasures . in this paper
, we consider the latter approach and our objective is to maximize the total amount of information stored in the device until the device dies .
this is equivalent to maximizing the average ( over the @xmath5-variable distribution @xmath13 ) amount of information stored per cell - level , @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the amount of information stored at the @xmath18-th rewrite , @xmath32 is the number of rewrites between two erasures , and the expectation is over the @xmath5-variable distribution .
we also call @xmath33 as _ storage efficiency_. in previous work on modulation codes for flash memory , the number of rewrites of an @xmath4-cell has been maximized in two different ways . the authors in @xcite consider the worst case number of rewrites and the authors in @xcite consider the average number of rewrites . as mentioned in @xcite , the reason for considering the average case is due to the large number of erasures in the lifetime of a flash memory device .
interestingly , these two considerations can be seen as two extreme cases of the optimization objective in ( [ eq : opt ] ) .
let the @xmath5-variables be a sequence of i.i.d .
random variables over time and all the @xmath4-cells .
the objective of optimization is to maximize the amount of information stored until the device dies .
the total amount of information stored in the device - cell changes to the same value , should it count as stored information ? should this count as a rewrite ?
this formula assumes that it counts as a rewrite , so that @xmath34 values ( rather than @xmath35 ) can be stored during each rewrite .
] can be upper - bounded by @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the number of rewrites between the @xmath38-th and the @xmath18-th erasures .
note that the upper bound in ( [ eq : total_info_ub ] ) is achievable by uniform input distribution , i.e. , when the input @xmath5-variable is uniformly distributed over @xmath39 , each rewrite stores @xmath40 bits of information .
due to the i.i.d .
property of the input variables over time , @xmath37 s are i.i.d .
random variables over time . since @xmath37 s are i.i.d . over time
, we can drop the subscript @xmath18 .
since @xmath10 , which is the maximum number of erasures allowed , is approximately on the order of @xmath41 , by the law of large numbers ( lln ) , we have @xmath42k\log_{2}(l).\ ] ] let the set of all valid encoder / decoder pairs be @xmath43 where @xmath44 implies the charge levels are element - wise non - decreasing .
this allows us to treat the problem @xmath45 as the following equivalent problem @xmath46k\log_{2}(l).\label{eq : opt2 - 1}\ ] ] denote the maximal charge level of the @xmath18-th @xmath4-cell at time @xmath8 as @xmath47 .
note that time index @xmath8 is reset to zero when a block erasure occurs and increased by one at each rewrite otherwise .
denote the maximal charge level in a block at time @xmath8 as @xmath48 which can be calculated as @xmath49 define @xmath50 as the time when the @xmath18-th @xmath4-cell reaches its maximal allowed value , i.e. , @xmath51 .
we assume , perhaps naively , that a block - erasure is required when any cell within a block reaches its maximum allowed value .
the time when a block erasure is required is defined as @xmath52 it is easy to see that @xmath53=ne\left[t\right],$ ] where the expectations are over the @xmath5-variable distribution . so maximizing @xmath54 $ ] is equivalent to maximizing @xmath55 .
so the optimization problem ( [ eq : opt2 - 1 ] ) can be written as the following optimization problem @xmath56.\label{eq : opt3}\ ] ] under the assumption that the input is i.i.d .
over all the @xmath4-cells and time indices , one finds that the @xmath50 s are i.i.d . random variables .
let their common probability density function ( pdf ) be @xmath57 it is easy to see that @xmath58 is the minimum of @xmath7 i.i.d .
random variables with pdf @xmath57 therefore , we have @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the cumulative distribution function ( cdf ) of @xmath61
so , the optimization problem ( [ eq : opt3 ] ) becomes @xmath62=\max_{f , g\in\mathcal{q}}\int nf_{t}(x)\left(1-f_{t}(x)\right)^{n-1}x\mbox{d}x.\label{eq : opt}\ ] ] note that when @xmath63 the optimization problem in ( [ eq : opt ] ) simplifies to @xmath64.\label{eq : opt2}\ ] ] this is essentially the case that the authors in @xcite consider .
when the whole block is used as one @xmath4-cell and the number of erasures allowed is large , optimizing the average ( over all input sequences ) number of rewrites of an @xmath4-cell is equivalent to maximizing the total amount of information stored @xmath65 the analysis also shows that the reason we consider average performance is not only due to the averaging effect caused by the large number of erasures .
one other important assumption is that there is only one @xmath4-cell per block .
the other extreme is when @xmath66 in this case , the pdf @xmath67 tends to a point mass at the minimum of @xmath8 and the integral @xmath68 approaches the minimum of @xmath8 .
this gives the worst case stopping time for the programming process of an @xmath4-cell .
this case is considered by @xcite .
our analysis shows that we should consider the worst case when @xmath69 even though the device experiences a large number of erasures .
so the optimality measure is not determined only by @xmath10 , but also by @xmath70 when @xmath7 and @xmath10 are large , it makes more sense to consider the worst case performance . when @xmath71 , it is better to consider the average performance . when @xmath7 is moderately large
, we should maximize the number of rewrites using ( [ eq : opt ] ) which balances the worst case and the average case .
when @xmath7 is moderately large , one should probably focus on optimizing the function in ( [ eq : opt ] ) , but it is not clear how to do this directly .
so , this remains an open problem for future research .
instead , we will consider a load - balancing approach to improve practical systems where @xmath0 is moderately large .
if we assume that there is only one variable changed each time , the average amount of information per cell - level can be bounded by @xmath72 because there are @xmath73 possible new values .
since the number of rewrites can be bounded by @xmath74 we have @xmath75 if we allow arbitrary change on the @xmath5-variables , there are totally @xmath76 possible new values .
it can be shown that @xmath77 for fixed @xmath6 and @xmath0 , the bound in ( [ eq : storage_efficiency_bound ] ) suggests using a large @xmath5 can improve the storage efficiency .
this is also the reason jointly coding over multiple cells can improve the storage efficiency @xcite . since optimal rewriting schemes only allow a single cell - level to increase by one during each rewrite , decodability implies that @xmath78 for the first case and @xmath79 for the second case .
therefore , the bounds in ( [ eq : storage_efficiency_bound2 ] ) and ( [ eq : storage_efficiency_bound ] ) also require large @xmath4 to improve storage efficiency .
the upper bound in ( [ eq : storage_efficiency_bound ] ) grows linearly with @xmath5 while the upper bound in ( [ eq : storage_efficiency_bound2 ] ) grows logarithmically with @xmath5 .
therefore , in the remainder of this paper , we assume an arbitrary change in the @xmath5-variable per rewrite and @xmath71 , i.e. , the whole block is used as an @xmath4-cell , to improve the storage efficiency .
this approach implicitly trades instantaneous capacity for future storage capacity because more cells are used to store the same number of bits , but the cells can also be reused many more times .
note that the assumption of @xmath71 might be difficult for real implementation , but its analysis gives an upper bound on the storage efficiency . from the analysis above with @xmath71
, we also know that maximizing @xmath33 is equivalent to maximize the average number of rewrites .
in @xcite , modulation codes are proposed that are asymptotically optimal ( as @xmath0 goes to infinity ) in the average sense when @xmath80 . in this section ,
we introduce a modulation code that is asymptotically optimal for arbitrary input distributions and arbitrary @xmath5 and @xmath6 . this rewriting algorithm can be seen as an extension of the one in @xcite .
the goal is , to increase the cell - levels uniformly on average for an arbitrary input distribution .
of course , decodability must be maintained .
the solution is to use common information , known to both the encoder ( to encode the input value ) and the decoder ( to ensure the decodability ) , to randomize the cell index over time for each particular input value .
let us assume the @xmath5-variable is an i.i.d .
random variable over time with arbitrary distribution @xmath13 and the @xmath5-variable at time @xmath8 is denoted as @xmath81 the output of the decoder is denoted as @xmath82 we choose @xmath83 and let the cell state vector at time @xmath8 be @xmath84 , where @xmath17 is the charge level of the @xmath18-th cell at time @xmath19 at @xmath85 , the variables are initialized to @xmath86 , @xmath87 and @xmath88 . the decoding algorithm @xmath89 is described as follows .
* step 1 : read cell state vector @xmath27 and calculate the @xmath90 norm @xmath91 .
* step 2 : calculate @xmath92 and @xmath93 the encoding algorithm @xmath94 is described as follows .
* step 1 : read cell state @xmath26 and calculate @xmath95 and @xmath96 as above . if @xmath97 then do nothing . *
step 2 : calculate @xmath98 and @xmath99 * step 3 : increase the charge level of the @xmath100-th cell by 1 . for convenience , in the rest of the paper , we refer the above rewriting algorithm as `` self - randomized modulation code '' .
the self - randomized modulation code achieves at least @xmath101 rewrites with high probability , as @xmath102 for arbitrary @xmath103 @xmath104 and i.i.d
. input distribution @xmath13 .
therefore , it is asymptotically optimal for random inputs as @xmath1 .
[ sketch of proof ] the proof is similar to the proof in @xcite .
since exactly one cell has its level increased by 1 during each rewrite , @xmath105 is an integer sequence that increases by 1 at each rewrite .
the cell index to be written @xmath100 is randomized by adding the value @xmath106 .
this causes each consecutive sequence of @xmath76 rewrites to have a uniform affect on all cell levels . as @xmath1 ,
an unbounded number of rewrites is possible and we can assume @xmath107 .
consider the first @xmath108 steps , the value @xmath109 is as even as possible over @xmath110 for convenience , we say there are
@xmath111 @xmath112 s at each value , as the rounding difference by 1 is absorbed in the @xmath113 term .
assuming the input distribution is @xmath114 .
for the case that @xmath115 , the probability that @xmath116 is @xmath117 for @xmath118 .
therefore , @xmath119 has a uniform distribution over @xmath12 .
since inputs are independent over time , by applying the same chernoff bound argument as @xcite , it follows that the number of times @xmath116 is at most @xmath120 with high probability ( larger than @xmath121 ) for all @xmath122 . summing over @xmath122
, we finish the proof .
notice that the randomizing term @xmath105 a deterministic term which makes @xmath100 look _ random _ over time in the sense that there are equally many terms for each value .
moreover , @xmath105 is known to both the encoder and the decoder such that the encoder can generate `` uniform '' cell indices over time and the decoder knows the accumulated value of @xmath105 , it can subtract it out and recover the data correctly .
although this algorithm is asymptotically optimal as @xmath1 , the maximum number of rewrites @xmath123 can not be achieved for moderate @xmath0 .
this motivates the analysis and the design of an enhanced version of this algorithm for practical systems in next section .
a self - randomized modulation code uses @xmath83 cells to store a @xmath5-variable .
this is much larger than the @xmath124 used by previous asymptotically optimal algorithms because we allow the @xmath5-variable to change arbitrarily .
although this seems to be a waste of cells , the average amount of information stored per cell - level is actually maximized ( see ( [ eq : storage_efficiency_bound2 ] ) and ( [ eq : storage_efficiency_bound ] ) ) .
in fact , the definition of asymptotic optimality requires @xmath79 if we allow arbitrary changes to the @xmath5-variable .
we note that the optimality of the self - randomized modulation codes is similar to the weak robust codes presented in @xcite .
we use @xmath83 cells to store one of @xmath125 possible messages .
this is slightly worse than the simple method of using @xmath126 .
is it possible to have self - randomization using only @xmath126 cells ?
a preliminary analysis of this question based on group theory indicates that it is not .
thus , the extra cell provides the possibility to randomize the mappings between message values and the cell indices over time .
while asymptotically optimal modulation codes ( e.g. , codes in @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and the self - randomized modulation codes described in section [ sec : another - rewriting - algorithm ] ) require @xmath1 , practical systems use @xmath0 values between @xmath127 and @xmath128 . compared to the number of cells @xmath4 ,
the size of @xmath0 is not quite large enough for asymptotic optimality to suffice . in other words , codes that are asymptotically optimal
may have significantly suboptimal performance when the system parameters are not large enough .
moreover , different asymptotically optimal codes may perform differently when @xmath0 is not large enough . therefore , asymptotic optimality can be misleading in this case . in this section ,
we first analyze the storage efficiency of self - randomized modulation codes when @xmath0 is not large enough and then propose an enhanced algorithm which improves the storage efficiency significantly .
before we analyze the storage efficiency of asymptotically optimal modulation codes for moderately large @xmath0 , we first show the connection between rewriting process and the load - balancing problem ( aka the balls - into - bins or balls - and - bins problem ) which is well studied in mathematics and computer science @xcite .
basically , the load - balancing problem considers how to distribute objects among a set of locations as evenly as possible .
specifically , the balls - and - bins model considers the following problem .
if @xmath129 balls are thrown into @xmath4 bins , with each ball being placed into a bin chosen independently and uniformly at random , define the _ load _ as the number of balls in a bin , what is the maximal load over all the bins ? based on the results in theorem 1 in @xcite , we take a simpler and less accurate approach to the balls - into - bins problem and arrive at the following theorem . [ thm : random_loading]suppose that @xmath129 balls are sequentially placed into @xmath4 bins . each time
a bin is chosen independently and uniformly at random .
the maximal load over all the bins is @xmath130 and : ( @xmath18 ) if @xmath131 the maximally loaded bin has @xmath132 balls , @xmath133 and @xmath134 , with high probability ( @xmath135 ) as @xmath136 ( @xmath137 ) if @xmath138 , the maximally loaded bin has @xmath139 balls , @xmath140 , with high probability ( @xmath135 ) as @xmath136 ( @xmath141 ) if @xmath142 the maximally loaded bin has @xmath143 , @xmath144 , @xmath145 and @xmath146 , with high probability ( @xmath135 ) as @xmath136 denote the event that there are at least @xmath5 balls in a particular bin as @xmath147 . using the union bound over all subsets of size
@xmath103 it is easy to show that the probability that @xmath147 occurs is upper bounded by @xmath148 using stirling s formula , we have @xmath149 . then @xmath150 can be further bounded by @xmath151 if @xmath152 , substitute @xmath153 to the rhs of ( [ eq : maxload_ub ] ) , we have @xmath154 denote the event that all bins have at most @xmath5 balls as @xmath155 . by applying the union bound , it is shown that @xmath156 since @xmath157 we finish the proof for the case of @xmath158 if @xmath138 , substitute @xmath159 to the rhs of ( [ eq : maxload_ub ] ) , we have @xmath160 by applying the union bound , we finish the proof for the case of @xmath161 if @xmath142 substitute @xmath162 to the rhs of ( [ eq : maxload_ub ] ) , we have @xmath163 where @xmath164 by applying the union bound , it is shown that @xmath165 since @xmath166 we finish the proof for the case of @xmath167 note that theorem [ thm : random_loading ] only shows an upper bound on the maximum load @xmath130 with a simple proof .
more precise results can be found in theorem 1 of @xcite , where the exact order of @xmath130 is given for different cases .
it is worth mentioning that the results in theorem 1 of @xcite are different from theorem [ thm : random_loading ] because theorem 1 of @xcite holds with probability @xmath168 while theorem [ thm : random_loading ] holds with probability ( @xmath135 ) .
the asymptotic optimality in the rewriting process implies that each rewrite only increases the cell - level of a cell by 1 and all the cell - levels are fully used when an erasure occurs .
this actually implies @xmath169 .
since @xmath4 is usually a large number and @xmath0 is not large enough in practice , the theorem shows that , when @xmath0 is not large enough , asymptotic optimality is not achievable .
for example , in practical systems , the number of cell - levels @xmath0 does not depend on the number of cells in a block .
therefore , rather than @xmath74 only roughly @xmath170 charge levels can be used as @xmath171 if @xmath0 is a small constant which is independent of @xmath4 . in practice
, this loss could be mitigated by using writes that increase the charge level in multiple cells simultaneously ( instead of erasing the block ) .
[ thm : gamma1]the self - randomized modulation code has storage efficiency @xmath172 when @xmath173 and @xmath174 when @xmath175 as @xmath4 goes to infinity with high probability ( i.e. , @xmath168 ) . consider the problem of throwing @xmath129 balls into @xmath4 bins and let the r.v .
@xmath10 be the number of balls thrown into @xmath4 bins until some bin has more than @xmath9 balls in it . while we would like to calculate @xmath176 $ ] exactly
, we still settle for an approximation based on the following result . if @xmath177 , then there is a constant @xmath178 such that maximum number of balls @xmath130 in any bin satisfies@xmath179 with probability @xmath168 as @xmath171 @xcite .
the constant @xmath178 is given by the largest @xmath180-root of@xmath181 and solving this equation for @xmath182 gives the implicit expression @xmath183 .
since the lower bound matches the expected maximum value better , we define @xmath184 and apply it to our problem using the equation @xmath185 or @xmath186 .
therefore , the storage efficiency is @xmath187 if @xmath188 , the maximum load is approximately @xmath189 with probability @xmath168 for large @xmath4 @xcite . by definition ,
therefore , the storage efficiency is @xmath191 the results in theorem [ thm : gamma1 ] show that when @xmath0 is on the order of @xmath192 , the storage efficiency is on the order of @xmath193 . taking the limit as @xmath194 with @xmath195 , we have @xmath196 when @xmath0 is a constant independent of @xmath4 , the storage efficiency is on the order of @xmath197 taking the limit as @xmath171 with @xmath173 , we have @xmath198 . in this regime , the self - randomized modulation codes actually perform very poorly even though they are asymptotically optimal as @xmath1 .
considering the bins - and - balls problem , can we distribute balls more evenly when @xmath199 is on the order of @xmath200 fortunately , when @xmath201 , the maximal load can be reduced by a factor of roughly @xmath202 by using _
the power of two random choices _ @xcite . in detail ,
the strategy is , every time we pick two bins independently and uniformly at random and throw a ball into the less loaded bin . by doing this ,
the maximally loaded bin has roughly @xmath203 balls with high probability .
theorem 1 in @xcite gives the answer in a general form when we consider @xmath204 random choices .
the theorem shows there is a large gain when the number of random choice is increased from 1 to 2 . beyond that , the gain is on the same order and only the constant can be improved .
based on the idea of 2 random choices , we define the following load - balanced modulation code . again , we let the cell state vector at time @xmath8 be @xmath84 , where @xmath17 is the charge level of the @xmath18-th cell at time @xmath19 this time , we use @xmath205 cells to store a @xmath5-variable @xmath206 ( i.e. , we write @xmath207 bits to store @xmath208 bits of information ) .
the information loss provides @xmath6 ways to write the same value .
this flexibility allows us to avoid sequences of writes that increase one cell level too much .
we are primarily interested in binary variables with 2 random choices or @xmath209 . for the power of @xmath6 choices to be effective , we must try to randomize ( over time ) , the @xmath6 possible choices over the set of all @xmath210 possibilities . the value @xmath91 is used to do this .
let @xmath211 be the galois field with @xmath212 elements and @xmath213 be a bijection that satisfies @xmath214 ( i.e. , the galois field element 0 is associated with the integer 0 ) .
the decoding algorithm calculates @xmath215 from @xmath27 and operates as follows : * step 1 : read cell state vector @xmath27 and calculate the @xmath90 norm @xmath91 .
* step 2 : calculate @xmath216 and @xmath217 * step 3 : calculate @xmath218 and @xmath219 * step 4 : calculate @xmath220 .
the encoding algorithm stores @xmath11 and operates as follows .
* step 1 : read cell state @xmath26 and decode to @xmath221 and @xmath96 . if @xmath222 then do nothing .
* step 2 : calculate @xmath223 , @xmath218 , and @xmath219 * step 3 : calculate @xmath224 and @xmath225 for @xmath226 .
* step 4 : calculate @xmath227 .
increase the charge level by 1 of cell @xmath228 .
note that the state vector at @xmath85 is initialized to @xmath229 and therefore @xmath87 .
the first arbitrary value that can be stored is @xmath230 .
the following conjecture suggests that the ball - loading performance of the above algorithm is identical to the random loading algorithm with @xmath209 random choices .
[ thm : gamma2]if @xmath209 and @xmath175 , then the load - balancing modulation code has storage efficiency @xmath231 with probability 1-@xmath232 as @xmath171 . if @xmath233 the storage efficiency @xmath234 with probability 1-@xmath232 . [ sketch of proof ]
consider the affine permutation @xmath235 for @xmath236 and @xmath237 .
as @xmath238 vary , this permutation maps the two elements @xmath11 and @xmath239 uniformly over all pairs of cell indices .
after @xmath240 steps , we see that all pairs of @xmath238 occur equally often .
therefore , by picking the less charged cell , the modulation code is almost identical to the random loading algorithm with two random choices .
unfortunately , we are interested in the case where @xmath241 so the analysis is somewhat more delicate . if @xmath177 , the highest charge level is @xmath242 with probability @xmath168 @xcite . since @xmath175 in this case , the storage efficiency is @xmath243 .
if @xmath188 , then @xmath173 and the maximum load is @xmath244 . by definition ,
we have @xmath245 therefore , we have @xmath246 if @xmath209 and @xmath0 is on the order of @xmath247 conjecture [ thm : gamma2 ] shows that the bound ( [ eq : storage_efficiency_bound ] ) is achievable by load - balancing modulation codes as @xmath4 goes to infinity . in this regime ,
the load - balancing modulation codes provide a better constant than self - randomized modulation codes by using twice many cells .
[ rem : if
@xmath209 and @xmath0 is a constant independent of @xmath4 , the storage efficiency is @xmath248 for the self - randomized modulation code and @xmath249 for the load - balancing modulation code .
but , the self - randomized modulation code uses @xmath250 cells and the load - balancing modulation code uses @xmath251 cells . to make fair comparison on the storage efficiency between them , we let @xmath251 for both codes .
then we have @xmath252 and @xmath249 .
so , as @xmath171 , we see that @xmath253 .
therefore , the load - balancing modulation code outperforms the self - randomized code when @xmath4 is sufficiently large .
in this section , we present the simulation results for the modulation codes described in sections [ sub : another - rewriting - algorithm ] and [ sub : an - enhanced - algorithm ] . in the figures ,
the first modulation code is called the `` self - randomized modulation code '' while the second is called the `` load - balancing modulation code '' .
let the `` loss factor '' @xmath254 be the fraction of cell - levels which are not used when a block erasure is required : @xmath255}{n(q-1)}.$ ] we show the loss factor for random loading with 1 and 2 random choices as comparison .
note that @xmath254 does not take the amount of information per cell - level into account .
results in fig .
[ flo : fig2 ] show that the self - randomized modulation code has the same @xmath254 with random loading with 1 random choice and the load - balancing modulation code has the same @xmath254 with random loading with 2 random choices .
this shows the optimality of these two modulation codes in terms of ball loading . , @xmath209 and 1000 erasures.[flo : fig2 ] ] with @xmath80 , @xmath256 @xmath257 and 1000 erasures.[flo : fig4 ] ] .[fig : fig5 ] ] .[fig : fig6 ] ]
we also provide the simulation results for random loading with 1 random choice and the codes designed in @xcite , which we denote as flm-(@xmath258 ) algorithm , in fig .
[ flo : fig4 ] . from results shown in fig .
[ flo : fig4 ] , we see that the flm-(@xmath258 ) algorithm has the same loss factor as random loading with 1 random choice .
this can be actually seen from the proof of asymptotic optimality in @xcite as the algorithm transforms an arbitrary input distribution into an uniform distribution on the cell - level increment .
note that flm algorithm is only proved to be optimal when 1 bit of information is stored .
so we just compare the flm algorithm with random loading algorithm in this case .
[ fig : fig5 ] and fig .
[ fig : fig6 ] show the storage efficiency @xmath33 for these two modulation codes .
[ fig : fig5 ] and fig .
[ fig : fig6 ] show that the load - balancing modulation code performs better than self - randomized modulation code when @xmath4 is large .
this is also shown by the theoretical analysis in remark [ rem : if is ] .
in this paper , we consider modulation code design problem for practical flash memory storage systems . the storage efficiency , or average ( over the distribution of input variables ) amount of information per cell - level is maximized . under this framework
, we show the maximization of the number of rewrites for the the worst - case criterion @xcite and the average - case criterion @xcite are two extreme cases of our optimization objective .
the self - randomized modulation code is proposed which is asymptotically optimal for arbitrary input distribution and arbitrary @xmath5 and @xmath6 , as the number of cell - levels @xmath1 .
we further consider performance of practical systems where @xmath0 is not large enough for asymptotic results to dominate .
then we analyze the storage efficiency of the self - randomized modulation code when @xmath0 is only moderately large .
then the load - balancing modulation codes are proposed based on the power of two random choices @xcite @xcite .
analysis and numerical simulations show that the load - balancing scheme outperforms previously proposed algorithms .
|
in this paper , we consider modulation codes for practical multilevel flash memory storage systems with @xmath0 cell levels . instead of maximizing the lifetime of the device @xcite ,
we maximize the average amount of information stored per cell - level , which is defined as storage efficiency . using this framework
, we show that the worst - case criterion @xcite and the average - case criterion @xcite are two extreme cases of our objective function .
a self - randomized modulation code is proposed which is asymptotically optimal , as @xmath1 , for an arbitrary input alphabet and i.i.d .
input distribution . in practical flash memory systems ,
the number of cell - levels @xmath0 is only moderately large .
so the asymptotic performance as @xmath1 may not tell the whole story . using the tools from load - balancing theory , we analyze the storage efficiency of the self - randomized modulation code .
the result shows that only a fraction of the cells are utilized when the number of cell - levels @xmath0 is only moderately large .
we also propose a load - balancing modulation code , based on a phenomenon known as `` the power of two random choices '' @xcite , to improve the storage efficiency of practical systems .
theoretical analysis and simulation results show that our load - balancing modulation codes can provide significant gain to practical flash memory storage systems .
though pseudo - random , our approach achieves the same load - balancing performance , for i.i.d . inputs , as a purely random approach based on the power of two random choices .
|
stephan s quintet ( hereafter sq ) is a strongly interacting compact group which has produced a highly disturbed intragroup medium ( igm ) @xcite through a complex sequence of interactions and harrassment @xcite .
this interplay has produced a large - scale intergalactic shock - wave , first observed as a narrow filament in the radio continuum @xcite , and subsequently detected in the x - ray @xcite .
the high - velocity ( @xmath61000 km s@xmath13 ) collision of an intruder galaxy , ngc 7318b , with the intergalactic medium of the group @xcite is believed to be responsible for the shock - heating of the x - ray emitting gas .
optical emission line ratios and observed broad linewidths provide evidence that the region is powered by strong shocks and not star formation ( xu et al . 2003 ; duc et al .
2010 , in preparation ) .
the main elements of stephan s quintet are shown in figure 1 .
central to the system is the primary shock , as defined by the 20 cm radio continuum emission .
ngc 7318b , the intruder galaxy , lies to the west of the shock , while the large seyfert 2 galaxy @xcite , lies to the east .
other members of the group are also indicated .
the peculiar extranuclear star formation region , named sq - a @xcite , lies at the extreme northern end of the main shock wave .
ngc 7318a ( west of ngc 7318b ) is also a strongly interacting group member , with ngc 7317 further away from the core .
the unexpected discovery of extremely powerful , pure - rotational h@xmath9 line emission from the center of the shock @xcite , using the _ spitzer space telescope _
@xcite , has sparked intense interest in the sq system .
warm molecular hydrogen emission was found with a line luminosity exceeding the x - ray luminosity from the shock .
the mid - infrared ( mir ) h@xmath9 linewidth was resolved ( @xmath14 870 km s@xmath13 ) suggesting that the h@xmath9-emitting clouds carry a large bulk - kinetic energy , tapping a large percentage of the energy available in the shock .
a recent model of sq , involving the collision between two inhomogeneous gas flows , describes h@xmath9 formation out of the multiphase , shocked gas , and an efficient cooling channel for high - speed shocks as an alternative to x - ray emission @xcite since the sq detection , several other systems exhibiting similarly strong h@xmath9 emission have been discovered .
@xcite find that a large - subset of the local 3cr radio galaxies have extremely dominant mir rotational h@xmath9 lines , often seen against a very weak thermal continuum .
the low agn and star formation power are insufficient to drive the mir h@xmath5 emission . mechanical heating driven by the radio jet interaction with the host galaxy ism is the favoured mechanism .
in addition , total h@xmath9 luminosities in the range @xmath15 ergs s@xmath13 have been detected in some central cluster galaxies out to @xmath16 ( * ? ? ?
* g. de messieres - university of virginia , private communication ) and in filaments in clusters @xcite .
the study of nearby prototypes may provide valuable insight into the nature of these more distant systems . the large scale ( @xmath6 30 kpc ) of the sq shock is well - suited for such a study . in this paper
i , we extend the single pointing observations of @xcite to full spectral maps of sq using the irs instrument on the _ spitzer _ space telescope , hereafter _ spitzer_. in paper ii
, we will present detailed 2-dimensional excitation maps of the h@xmath5 emission across the face of the x - ray emitting shock , and compare them with models .
in addition , several other papers are being prepared by our team which will discuss the relationship between the uv / x - ray emission and emission from dust . in section 2
, we present our observations and data reduction methods . in section 3
we discuss the mapping results for various detected lines . in sections 4 , 5 and 6
we present our discussion on the properties of the system and in section 7 the implication for galaxy formation . in section 8
we present our conclusions .
additional material is included as appendices , with a discussion on ngc 7319 in appendix a , and a reanalysis of the high resolution mir spectrum of the shock , as well as renanalysis of the x - ray data presented in appendix b and c , respectively . throughout this paper , we assume a systemic velocity of @xmath17 for the group , corresponding to a distance of 94 mpc with @xmath18 .
mid - infrared spectroscopy of the shock region in sq was obtained using the irs instrument @xcite onboard _
spitzer_. observations were done in low - resolution mapping mode , using the short - low ( @xmath19 ; @xmath20 ) and long - low ( @xmath21 ; @xmath22 ) modules and taken on january 11 2008 and december 10 2007 , respectively .
figure 1 displays the outline of the areas observed superimposed on a composite image of the group .
the sl spectral mapping consists of two separate , partially overlapping maps , centered north and south on the x - ray emission associated with the shock .
the map was constructed with 23 steps of 2.8(0.75 @xmath2 slit width ) perpendicular to the slit and one parallel step of 7.2 .
observations consisted of 60s integrations with 5 cycles per step .
the ll module was used to map an area of @xmath23 using 21 steps of 8.0 ( 0.75 @xmath2 slit width ) perpendicular to the slit and a parallel step of 24.0 .
an integration time of 120s was used with 3 cycles per step .
primary data reductions were done by the _ spitzer _
science center ( ssc ) pipeline , version s17.0.4 and s17.2.0 for sl and ll respectively , which performs standard reductions such as ramp fitting , dark current subtraction and flat - fielding .
background subtraction for ll data was performed by subtracting dedicated off - source observations , with the same observing mode , taken shortly after the mapping sequence . in the case of sl , where for scheduling reasons the dedicated `` off '' observations were too far away in time to be optimal , backgrounds were generated from observations at the periphery of the map that contain no spectral line signatures .
examination of the pipeline products showed that the stray - light - corrected images ( that account for potential spillover from the peak - up arrays onto the sl1/2 spectral apertures ) contained wavelength - dependent over - corrections in some of the images , seemingly due to a high background of cosmic rays during the sl portion of the mapping . to negate this effect , the alternative flat - fielded images ( also available from the science pipeline ) that are uncorrected for crosstalk and straylight removal were used .
it was determined that after background subtraction , any uncorrected stray light in the sl spectral extraction areas was unmeasurable at the @xmath24% level .
thus stray - light correction was unneccesary , and the resulting basic calibrated data ( bcd ) images used were of better quality than the standard bcds . for all modules , individual frames for each pointing
were median - combined and obvious `` bad '' pixels were replaced using customised software that allows for manual `` average '' replacement .
the spectra were assembled into spectral cubes for each module using the software tool , cubism @xcite .
further bad pixel removal was performed within cubism .
spectral maps were generated by making continuum maps on either side of a feature and subtracting the averaged continuum map from the relevant emission line map .
one dimensional spectra were further extracted from the data cubes using matched apertures .
broad - band images at 16 and 24@xmath25 m were obtained with the _ spitzer _ irs blue peak - up imager ( pui ) and the mips instrument .
the pui was obtained in a 5 x 5 map with 3 cycles of 30s duration each on 2007 december 10 .
the mips instrument @xcite on _ spitzer _ obtained 24 imaging of sq on 2008 july 29 , achieving a spatial resolution of @xmath66 .
primary data reduction was done by the _ spitzer _
science center ( ssc ) science pipeline ( version s18.0.2 ) run through the mopex software , and for the mips image a smooth 2d polynomial background was further removed to correct for a large - scale background gradient . _
spitzer _ irac 3.6 , 4.5 , 5.8 and 8.0 data of sq ( p.i .
houck ) were obtained from the ssc archive ; these were reduced using science pipeline version s18.0.2 .
the final mosaics have a pixel scale of 0.61 .
the pure rotational transitions of molecular hydrogen can be excited by several mechanisms .
these include fuv ( far ultraviolet ) induced pumping , and possible additional collisional heating , of the h@xmath5 in photodissociation regions associated with star formation ( e. g. black & van dishoeck 1987 , hollenbach & tielens 1997 ) , hard x - rays penetrating and heating regions within molecular clouds , which in turn excite h@xmath5 via collisions with electrons or hydrogen atoms ( lepp & mccray 1983 ; draine & woods 1992 ) and finally collisional excitation of h@xmath5 due to acceleration produced by shocks ( e.g. shull & hollenbach 1978 ) .
the pure rotational mir line ratios are not especially good diagnostics for distinguishing between these mechanisms since all three mechanisms discussed can lead to well thermalized level distributions of lower - level rotational states .
the rotational h@xmath5 emission lines do , however , allow us to trace gas at different temperatures and compare with model predictions ( this will be the main emphasis of paper ii ) .
higher level transitions 0 - 0 s(3)-s(5 ) tend to trace warmer gas , whereas the s(0 ) and s(1 ) lines are sensitive to the `` coolest '' warm h@xmath5 .
although the line ratios themselves can not be used directly as shock diagnostics , in stephan s quintet the distribution of large - scale x - ray and radio emission , plus optical emission line diagnostics , provide strong evidence that the giant filament seen in figure 1 is the result of a strong shock . in appleton et al .
( 2006 ) this fact was used to reveal the surprising association of detected h@xmath5 emission with the shock . however , in this paper we can make a more definitive association of the emission with the shock by means of spectral maps .
the spectral cubes were used to extract maps of all the pure rotational emission lines of molecular hydrogen that were detected , namely the 0 - 0 s(0)28.22 , s(1)17.03 , s(2)12.28 , s(3)9.66 , s(4)8.03 and s(5)6.91 lines .
specific intensity contour maps of these lines are presented in figure 2 overlaid on a @xmath26-band image of the region from @xcite .
the s(0 ) and s(1 ) lines were mapped by the ll modules , while s(2 ) - s(5 ) transitions were mapped by the sl modules of the irs . as indicated in figure 1 ,
the sl observations were concentrated on the main shock to provide high signal to noise ( s / n ) measurements there . as a result
, these maps do not fully cover sq - a or ngc 7319 .
we note that the s(4 ) line at 8.03 ( fig .
2e ) is faint , and also suffers from contamination from the pah bands at 7.7 and 8.6 .
the contours indicate powerful , widespread emission running north - south along the shock ridge ( see fig .
1 ) . in addition
we detect strong emission from the star forming region , sq - a , as well as associated with ngc 7319 .
we discuss further details of the agn - like mir emission lines from ngc 7319 in appendix a. figures 2a - d reveal a new h@xmath5 structure running eastward from the `` main '' shock ridge . in what follows
, we refer to this feature as the `` bridge '' .
this structure is observed faintly in the _ chandra _ @xcite and xmm @xcite x - ray images and detected as faint h@xmath27 emission by @xcite , but is not strong in radio continuum images .
as is evident in figure 2 , there is distinct variation in the distribution of the warm h@xmath5 emission . the brightest 0 - 0 s(0 ) emission ( fig .
2a ) appears to be concentrated towards the north of the shock , whereas the 0 - 0 s(1 ) transition emission ( fig .
2b ) appears more concentrated towards the center .
the s(0 ) and s(1 ) maps demonstrate that the h@xmath5 in the bridge terminates in a large clump a few arcsecs west of the nucleus of the seyfert 2 galaxy ngc 7319 , and in a small detour to the north ( especially in the s(1 ) map which has the highest s / n ) .
the s(2 ) through s(5 ) lines clearly show that the warm h@xmath5 emission breaks into clumps in the shock . despite the limited coverage compared to the ll mapping ,
the base of the `` bridge '' is visible and sq - a is partially covered .
sq - a is fully covered by the sl2 module ( because of fortuitous `` off observation '' coverage ) and hence the s(5 ) emission line reveals that in sq - a the h@xmath5 emission is also clumpy .
the molecular - line maps provide considerable information about the excitation of the h@xmath5 along and across the x - ray shock , but these discussions will be deferred to a full 2-d modelling of the h@xmath5 excitation in paper ii ( appleton et al . , in preparation ) .
instead we shall limit ourselves to global properties of the h@xmath5 here . in section [ spec ]
we shall present spectra of some selected regions of the emission and discuss a global excitation diagram for the shock . to further demonstrate the close connection between the h@xmath5 emission and the main global shock - wave in sq
, we now consider the distribution of warm h@xmath5 in relation to the x - ray and radio emission .
figure [ fig : xray_rad]a and b show the s(0 ) and s(3 ) contours overlaid on an xmm - newton x - ray image @xcite of stephan s quintet .
the warm molecular hydrogen is distributed along the length of the main north - south ( ns ) x - ray shock ridge and along the `` bridge '' , demonstrating the remarkable projected coexistence of of hot x - ray plasma ( 10@xmath28 @xmath29 t @xmath29 10@xmath30 k ) and warm h@xmath5 ( 10@xmath31 @xmath29 t@xmath29 10@xmath32 k ) .
although the h@xmath5 appears to follow the x - ray , there are subtle differences .
the cooler s(0 ) line has emission concentrated to the north and follows the x - ray less closely compared to the warmer s(3 ) line .
the s(3 ) line exhibits a clear correspondence to the x - ray , notably at the center of the shock , where we find peaks at both wavelengths .
thus the region of greatest shock heating , as traced by the stronger x - ray emission , appears to correspond to the higher - j h@xmath5 transitions , perhaps implying a causal connection .
the intergalactic star formation region sq - a , is essentially absent in x - ray emission , as seen in figure [ fig : xray_rad]a , but is strongly detected in h@xmath9 .
we find a similar picture in the radio continuum ( fig .
[ fig : xray_rad]c & d ) with the s(0 ) line demonstrating correspondence with the main shock , but dominated by emission in the north where we observe less powerful radio emission .
the s(3 ) ( and s(2)see fig .
2c ) line presents a much tighter correlation with regions of the shock that are more radio luminous than the lower - j transitions .
the radio emission is quite likely sensitive to the most compressed regions of the shock where cosmic ray particles are accelerated more strongly @xcite , whereas the brightest x - ray patches are likely due to the fastest regions of the shock @xcite .
as already mentioned the `` bridge '' emission is detected only faintly in the x - ray and is weak or absent at radio continuum wavelengths .
this noticeable difference compared to the main shock likely implies that the conditions that give rise to strong synchrotron emission in the main shock are absent in the bridge .
emission from fine - structure lines provide key diagnostics that trace the interplay between the various constituents of the shocked interstellar medium . in @xcite
the spectra were limited to the very core of the shock and only weak emission was detected from all but two metal lines , namely @xmath10neii@xmath11$]12.81and @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82 ( this data has been reanalysed and is presented in appendix b ) . in this section
we discuss the spatial distribution of emission from the @xmath10feii@xmath11$]25.99 , @xmath10oiv@xmath11$]25.89 , @xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 , @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82 , @xmath10neii@xmath11$]12.81 and @xmath10neiii@xmath11$]15.56 lines . in figure
[ fig : fs ] we present the specific intensity contours of the @xmath10feii@xmath11$]25.99 and @xmath10oiv@xmath11$]25.89 blend , @xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 and @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82 emission lines . given the low spectral resolution of the sl and ll modules of _
spitzer _ , we can not distinguish between emission from @xmath10fe ii@xmath11$]25.99 and @xmath10oiv@xmath11$]25.89 .
however , except in the direction of the seyfert ii galaxy ngc 7319 , the emission near 26 seen in figure [ fig : fs]a is likely to be pure @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] with little contamination from @xmath10oiv@xmath11 $ ] as there is no evidence from the spectra of high - excitation emission from the intragroup medium in sq .
for example , @xmath10oiv@xmath11 $ ] has an excitation potential of 56 ev ( compared to 7.9 ev of @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] ) , and yet @xcite have shown that the @xmath10neiii@xmath11$]/@xmath10neii@xmath11 $ ] ratio is low suggesting low - excitation conditions for the ions in the shock , further supported in section [ em ] . assuming that , apart from towards ngc 7319 , @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] dominates the @xmath10feii@xmath11$]+@xmath10oiv@xmath11 $ ] complex , we detect faint emission from @xmath10feii@xmath11$]25.99 at the location of the center of the shock ( as defined by the x - ray `` hotspot '' in fig .
[ fig : xray_rad]a ) . the energetic requirements for shocks to produce strong @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] emission are usually present in @xmath33 shocks while the ion abundance in @xmath34 shocks are low in comparison @xcite .
we will discuss the production of @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] in the shock in section 6.2 .
the @xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 distribution is presented in figure [ fig : fs]b .
this fine structure line acts as a strong tracer of hii regions @xcite and we observe emission from sq - a and from other regions of star formation in the south ( see section [ sf ] ) . in the primary shock region the distributions of @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] and @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] are anti - correlated . in strong contrast to the weak @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] emission , there is copious @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82 emission ( fig .
[ fig : fs]c ) , which follows the s(1 ) distribution closely with respect to the primary shock , as mapped by x - ray emission ( fig .
[ fig : fs]d ) .
although @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] is commonly found in normal hii regions , we will demonstrate below that , apart from in sq - a , the strong silicon emission does not correlate with regions of strong pah emission ( tracing star formation ) in sq , but instead closely follows the h@xmath5 and x - ray ( shock ) distributions . @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] acts as an efficient coolant of x - ray - irradiated gas and is predicted to be one of the top four cooling lines under these circumstances @xcite .
we will discuss the excitation of @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] in the shock in section 6.2 .
@xmath10neii@xmath11$]12.81 ( with an ionisation potential of 21.6 ev ) is also represented in the shock , as shown in figure [ fig : ne]a , although it is also emitted from some hii regions associated with star formation , such as sq - a and the star - forming region south of ngc 7318b ( see section [ sf ] ) .
the @xmath10neiii@xmath11$]15.56 contours ( with an ionisation potential of 41 ev ) are shown in figure [ fig : ne]b and are associated with excitation in the shock , as well as from regions of star formation ( see section [ sf ] )
. the higher ionisation line of @xmath10neiii@xmath11 $ ] is much weaker in the shock ridge , but regions of emission correspond closely to peaks seen for the h@xmath5 s(3 ) line . the @xmath10neii@xmath11 $ ] emission , however , exhibits clearly extended emission with regions of greatest luminosity matching those seen for the h@xmath5 s(3 ) line .
the @xmath10neii@xmath11 $ ] emission suggests excitation from the shock , with @xmath10neiii@xmath11 $ ] found at the location of the center of the shock , similar to what is observed for @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] .
previous observations and spectroscopy of sq @xcite have determined that there are some regions of star formation associated with the spiral arms of the intruder galaxy ngc 7318b .
we discuss in this section how these regions , which have a different spatial distribution from the shocked gas , are correlated with the pah emission we detect in the irs spectra . in figure
[ fig : dust]a there is a strong correlation between the 11.3 pah distribution ( from the irs cube ) superimposed on a near - uv image from _ galex _ @xcite , which maps the uv emission from hot stars associated with weak star formation from the system .
this correlation suggests that the pah molecules are excited by star formation .
a similar close correlation is shown in figure [ fig : dust]b where we overlay the 11.3 contours on the irac 8 band , which is dominated by the 7.7 and 8.6 @xmath25 m feature .
it is noticeable , however , that regions with strong 11.3 emission in the shock , do not appear similarly strong at 8 .
this point will be addressed in section 6.4 .
we compare the 11.3 pah map to the distribution of warm dust in figure [ fig : dust]c , using the mips 24@xmath25 m map of sq .
again , it is clear that there is a good correlation between the pah emission and the thermal dust , most of which seems only poorly correlated with the shock ridge .
the lack of conspicuous star formation in the ridge was also observed by @xcite .
the main point we emphasize here is that the dust , pah and uv emission appears to be associated with previously known star formation regions and no additional star formation is observed in the shock ; this can be seen in figure [ fig : dust]d showing the h@xmath5 0 - 0 s(1 ) emission overlaid on an irac 8 image .
there is little correspondence between the h@xmath5 emission in the shock and 8@xmath25 m ( hot dust plus pah ) image .
this is important because it implies that there is very little triggered star formation in the molecular gas associated with the shock - excited h@xmath5 .
figure [ fig : dust]c demonstrates that there is only faint dust emission at 24@xmath25 m from the shock ridge .
the presence of dust in the shock is required in the model of guillard et al .
( 2009 ) to explain the formation of h@xmath5 behind the shock and we do observe evidence of depletion onto dust grains ( see section 6.2 ) . thus the faint 24 emission could be the result of destruction of very small grains ( vsgs ) , with only larger grains surviving , or indicate that the grains are cold and radiating more strongly at longer wavelengths , where _ spitzer _ has the least spatial resolution .
a more detailed description of the dust and faint pah emission in the sq group ( including results from mips 70 imaging ) is discussed in separate papers ( guillard et al . 2010 . ; natale et al .
2009 , in preparation ) .
guillard et al .
( 2010 ) show that the ir emission in the shock is faint due to dust being heated by a relatively low intensity uv radiation field and determine a galactic pah / vsg abundance ratio in this region .
a more complete understanding of the likely existence of cool dust in the shock will require higher angular resolution and a broader wavelength coverage than that achieved by _
spitzer_. despite the faintness of emission from the main shock , the 24@xmath25 m map presents a new result , which was less obvious in previous studies , namely that the dominant regions of star formation in sq lie not in the galaxies themselves , but in two strikingly powerful , almost symmetrically disposed regions at either end of the shock .
the region to the north is the well studied sq - a , but the region to the south ( which we refer to as 7318b - south ) is also very powerful and both regions lie at the ends of the shock , as defined by the h@xmath5 distribution .
this may not be a coincidence , and we will discuss this further in section 6.1 .
the @xmath10neii@xmath11$]12.81 , @xmath10neiii@xmath11$]15.56 and @xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 fine - structure lines , as mentioned above , are also tracers of star formation in sq as these lines are often associated with hii regions .
the @xmath10neii@xmath11$]12.81 emission appears to follow _ both _ the h@xmath5 and the star formation regions ( see fig . [
fig : ne]a ) , appearing more extended in the south than the corresponding h@xmath5 emission and flaring out where star formation regions , especially 7318b - south , are observed optically , and through pah emission ( see fig .
[ fig : dust ] ) .
the warm molecular hydrogen in stephan s quintet follows the x - ray distribution in the main shock and in the `` bridge '' structure .
this might suggest that the molecular hydrogen is excited directly by the x - ray heating .
however , we will show that the h@xmath5 emission exceeds by at least a factor of 3 the x - ray luminosity from the various shocked filaments , thus ruling out direct x - ray excitation from the shock . to measure the strength of the h@xmath5 emission ,
we extract spectra from various rectangular sub - areas of sq which are defined in figure [ fig : ext ] .
the spectra were extracted from cubism cubes built from each irs module , and joined to make a continous spectrum
no scaling was necessary to join the spectra .
figures [ fig : ext ] a , b and c indicate the spectral extraction regions of the main ns shock , a sub - region of the shock and a characteristic part of the `` bridge '' . the shock sub - region is chosen to be just north of the center of the shock , avoiding regions contaminated by star formation in the intruder .
spectra for these extractions are shown in figure [ fig : spectra ] a , b and c. all three spectra , share the common property that they are dominated by molecular hydrogen emission .
the shock sub - region ( fig .
[ fig : spectra]b ) , unlike figure [ fig : spectra]a , is less contaminated by the star forming regions discussed in the previous section . the mir continuum of the main shock appears stronger than the shock sub - region indicating stronger emission from warm dust ; this is likely the result of contamination from star - forming regions in the main shock extraction .
the bridge exhibits a similarly weak continuum emission compared to the shock sub - region .
figure [ fig : spectra]b includes photometry from the irac bands , 16 peak - up image ( pui ) and mips-24 image superimposed on the irs spectrum .
these are useful to probe conditions in the shock , in particular star formation ( see section 6.4 ) .
stellar light in the extraction area , from an extended spiral arm of ngc 7318b , produces contamination of the shock spectrum , visible as continuum emission shortwards of 6 , in both figure 8a and b. there exists a striking similarity between the mid - ir spectrum of all three regions , showing powerful h@xmath5 lines and low excitation weak emission from fine structure lines . also the pah emission observed in the spectra of the shock regions , and in the region of the `` bridge '' in the irac 8 image ( fig .
[ fig : dust]b ) , appears weak .
this confirms that these properties , observed in the @xcite observations of the shock core , extend to both the full extent of the main shock and the `` bridge '' .
this , and the fact that the `` bridge '' has similar x - ray properties to the main shock ( see later ) suggests that the bridge is a `` scaled - down '' version of the main shock .
the weaker radio continuum emission at this location is significant .
one possibility , that the `` bridge '' is older than the main shock , and the cosmic rays compressed in it have diffused away , will be discussed further in paper ii.thus the new irs observations seem to suggest that more than one large - scale group - wide shock is present in the group .
this could be the result of previous tidal interactions and imply multiple shock heating events have taken place in sq , consistent with what is seen in the x - ray @xcite .
figures [ fig : ext]d and [ fig : spectra]d present the extraction region and spectrum of sq - a , the extragalactic star - forming region . in this case , although h@xmath5 lines are still strong , a rising continuum and an increase in the strength of the metal lines relative to the h@xmath5 is consistent with a spectrum that is increasingly dominated by star formation a result which is already known from previous optical observations @xcite .
line fluxes for all the h@xmath5 and metal lines in the spectra discussed above are presented in table [ tableh2fluxes ] and table [ tablemetalfluxes ] , respectively .
we estimate the luminosity emitted from the h@xmath5 lines in the main aperture shown in figure [ fig : spectra]a .
the emission from the 0 - 0 s(1 ) line alone can be calculated from table [ tableh2fluxes ] ( for d = 94 mpc ) to be 2.3 @xmath210@xmath35 ergs@xmath13 .
summing the emission measured in the observed lines for the main shock ( 0 - 0 s(0 ) through s(5 ) lines ) and including an extra 28% emission from unobserved lines ( see model fit to excitation diagram below ) , yields a total h@xmath5 line luminosity from the main shock of 9.7 @xmath210@xmath35 ergs@xmath13 .
this phenomenal power in the molecular hydrogen lines dwarfs by a factor of ten the next brightest mid - ir line , which is @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82 with a line luminosity of l@xmath36 = 0.85 @xmath210@xmath35 ergs@xmath13 .
figure [ fig : excite ] presents the excitation diagram of the low - j 0 - 0 h@xmath5 transitions for the main shock extraction .
the points are well fit by a model including three temperature components ( t@xmath37 = 158@xmath38k , t@xmath9 = 412@xmath39k , and t@xmath40 = 1500@xmath41k ) .
it is likely that in reality , many different temperature components are present in the shock , and the three - temperature fit is only an approximation .
however , it does allow us to provide an estimate of the total mass of warm h@xmath5 of 5.0@xmath4210@xmath43m@xmath44 .
temperature t@xmath9 is more uncertain than formally represented by the fit because it depends on the value of the s(4 ) flux , which may be systematically too low due to pah contamination ( see fig .
[ fig : excite ] ) . in paper
ii we will present a more complete two - dimensional map of the excitation of the h@xmath5 in sq and explore variations in the shape of the excitation diagram along and across the shock in more detail .
our observations have shown that h@xmath5 is the dominant line coolant in the mir .
however , how does it compare with the most important coolant in high - speed shocks namely the x - ray emission ?
@xcite suggested that the h@xmath5 emission was stronger than the x - ray emission at the shock center .
this can now be evaluated over much of the inner sq group .
we present a complete reanalysis of the xmm - newton observations of sq using the latest calibrations ( see appendix c for full details ) in order to determine the fluxes and luminosities of the x - ray emission to match our spectral extractions .
the results indicate the striking dominance of the h@xmath5 line luminosities compared with the x - ray emission from the same regions . for the main shock , the x - ray `` bolometric '' flux of l@xmath45 = 2.8 @xmath2 10@xmath46erg s@xmath13@xmath47 corresponds to 2.95 @xmath2 10@xmath35 erg s@xmath13 , or l(h@xmath5)/l@xmath45 = 2.9 .
this is a lower limit since we have not attempted to remove the contribution to the main shock aperture of an extended group - wide x - ray component upon which the emission from the shock lies . therefore it is likely that the h@xmath5 line luminosity dominates over the main shock x - ray gas by a factor @xmath48 3 .
similar calculations can be done for the other regions for which h@xmath5 spectra have been extracted .
for example , in the `` bridge '' region , which we have already indicated has many of the same characteristics as the main shock , we find l(h@xmath5)/l@xmath45 = 2.5 .
these values demonstrate that throughout the extended regions of sq , the molecular hydrogen cooling pathway dominates over the x - ray in this shocked system .
this is a very significant result , upturning the traditional view that x - ray emission always dominates cooling in the later stages of evolution in compact groups of galaxies .
the fine - structure flux ratios ( see table [ tablemetalfluxes ] ) can be used to probe the conditions within the extracted regions of sq .
the @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82/@xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 ratio provides an indication of the sources of excitation within the system .
as mentioned previously , @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] is mainly a tracer of hii regions , whereas enhanced @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] emission can be generated via several mechanisms , including thermal excitation by x - rays ( xdrs ) , or in shocks . in the main shock ,
the @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82/@xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 ratio of @xmath6 4.59 is high compared to , for example , both normal galaxies ( @xmath6 1.2 ) and agn ( @xmath6 2.9 ) in the sings sample @xcite .
however , this large aperture is contaminated by star formation emission from sq - a and the intruder galaxy . a better measure
is given by the smaller shock sub - region , where the @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82/@xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 ratio is @xmath49 .
thus it is clear that the @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] emission is well outside the normal range of values , even for local well - studied agn . using the upper limit found for @xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 in the `` bridge '' structure , we find a ratio of @xmath50 again values well outside the range of normal galaxy disk emission .
indeed , these high values are typical of galactic supernova remnants where shock excitation is well determined ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we will argue in the next section that silicon is being ionised in regions experiencing fast shocks @xmath51km@xmath0 and depleted onto dust grains .
the @xmath10feii@xmath11$]26.0/@xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82 ratio for the main shock and sub - region ( @xmath6 0.12 ) is in agreement with values found by @xcite for their sample of snr . for the extragalactic star forming region sq -
a , @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82/@xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 is @xmath61.49 , only slightly higher than the average of @xmath6 1.2 found for star - forming regions in the sings sample @xcite ; another indication that sq - a is dominated by star formation . in star - forming galaxies
the @xmath10neiii@xmath11$]15.56/@xmath10neii@xmath11$]12.81 ratio can be used as a measure of the hardness of the radiation field as it is sensitive to the effective temperature of the ionising sources . in the main shock ,
we find a value of @xmath52 which would be considered typical compared to those found in starburst systems , which range from @xmath53 @xcite , and in supernovae remnants ranging from @xmath54 @xcite .
the shock subregion has a ratio of only @xmath55 indicating a lower intensity radiation field north of the shock center .
however , it is clear from its spatial distribution relative to the 8 and h@xmath5 emission , that most of the neon is not originating from star formation , and so shocks are an obvious source of excitation .
the @xmath10neii@xmath11$]12.81/@xmath10neiii@xmath11$]15.56 ratio can be used to estimate the shock velocity using the mappings shock model library of @xcite . in the main shock
this ratio corresponds to shock speeds of between 100 and 300kms@xmath13 ( using preshock densities of @xmath56 @xmath57 and magnetic parameter @xmath58 = 1 and 3.23 the nominal equipartition value ) .
we do , however , have contamination from starforming regions in the main shock and can not disentangle this emission from that produced in the shock . to address this we use the @xmath10neii@xmath11$]12.81 and @xmath10neiii@xmath11$]15.56 maps to mask areas associated with star formation ( see section 3.3 ) and determine a lower limit for the @xmath10neii@xmath11$]12.81/@xmath10neiii@xmath11$]15.56 ratio in the shock of @xmath6 4.54 .
this value corresponds to a shock velocity of @xmath6 150kms@xmath13 .
the average electron density is determined from the @xmath10siii@xmath11$]18.71/@xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 ( two lines of the same ionisation state ) ratio . for sq -
a we find a ratio of @xmath60.56 , and in the main shock @xmath60.41 .
this corresponds to an electron density of @xmath59 @xmath57 @xcite for both , i.e. in the low - density limit for this diagnostic @xcite .
our observations have shown that the molecular hydrogen and x - ray emitting plasma appear to follow a similar distribution , and we have ruled out the possibility that this is a consequence of x - rays heating the h@xmath5 , since the h@xmath5 has the dominant luminosity .
how then can we explain the similar distributions ?
are these results consistent with the hypothesis that the shock is formed where the intruding galaxy ngc 7318b collides with a pre - existing tidal filament of hi drawn out of ngc 7319 in a previous interaction with another group member @xcite ?
this basic mechanical picture appears plausible as can be seen in figure [ fig : hi+h2 ] which shows that the h@xmath5 distribution `` fills in '' the gap in the hi tidal tail as observed by the vla @xcite .
the implication is that the hi has been converted into both a hot x - ray component and a warm h@xmath5 component by the collision of the intruder with the now missing hi .
part of the puzzle of how this high - speed ( @xmath60 @xmath61 kms@xmath13 ) shock can lead to both x - ray and very strong molecular line emission is presented in a model by @xcite .
the high - speed collision of ngc 7318b with the hi filament ( assumed to be composed of a multiphase medium ) leads to multiple shocks passing through and compressing denser clumps ( which become dusty nucleation sites for h@xmath5 formation ) as opposed to the lower - density gas , which is shock - heated to x - ray tempertures .
the h@xmath5 therefore forms in denser clouds experiencing slower shocks .
thus the coexistence of both hot x - ray gas , and cooler molecular material is a natural consequence of the multiphase medium of the pre - shocked material .
modeling of the h@xmath5 excitation by @xcite demonstrates that the emission can be reproduced by low velocity ( @xmath62 ) magnetohydrodynamic shocks within the dense ( @xmath63 ) h@xmath5 gas .
the denser clouds survive long enough to be heated by turbulence in the hot - gas component , tapping into the large available kinetic energy of the shock .
this picture is consistent with both the broad h@xmath5 linewidth ( 870kms@xmath13 ) measured in irs high - resolution spectrometer observations of @xcite , and the velocity center of the warm h@xmath5 ( based on new irs spectral calibrations - see appendix b ) which places the gas at intermediate velocities between the intruder and the group igm .
both these measurements are consistent with h@xmath5 being accelerated in a turbulent post - shocked layer .
intermediate pre - shock densities and post - shock temperatures result in regions of hi and hii that have cooled , but where the dust content has been destroyed @xcite .
pre - existing giant molecular clouds ( gmcs ) which may have been embedded in the hi gas , would be rapidly compressed and collapse quickly , thus forming stars.this mechanism , proposed for sq - a by @xcite , might also apply to 7318b - south . however , if this was the case , it would have to explain why two such gmcs happened to be positioned at the extreme ends of the current shock an unlikely coincidence .
more probable , however , is that the geometry of the shock somehow favors the collapse of clouds at the ends of the shock perhaps in regions where the turbulent heating is less efficient .
as outlined above , the combination of emission detected in the shock region of sq can be understood in terms of a spectrum of shock velocities .
the fastest shock velocities ( @xmath64 km@xmath0 ) are associated with the lowest density pre - shock regions and the post - shock x - ray emitting plasma .
these are fast @xmath33 shocks and represent a discontinous change of hydrodynamic variables and are often dissociative @xcite .
@xmath34 shocks have a broad transition region such that the transition from pre - shock to post - shock is continuous and are usually non - dissociative @xcite .
the lowest velocity shocks associated with the turbulent h@xmath5 emission are @xmath62 @xmath34 shocks @xcite .
@xcite find optical emission line ratios consistent with shock models that do not include a radiative precursor @xcite .
the @xmath10feii@xmath11$]25.99 emission associated with the shock region in sq is relatively weak , but coincides with the most energetic part of the shock as traced by the x - rays ( fig .
[ fig : fs ] ) .
we also detect abundant @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82 emission associated with the main shock .
silicon and iron have very similar first and second ionization potentials .
their first ionization potentials ( 7.9 and 8.15 ev for fe and si , respectively ) are lower than that of hydrogen but their second ionization potential is higher ( 16.19 and 16.35 ev ) .
the mir @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] and @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] line emission observed from the sq shock could thus arise from predominantly neutral , as well as ionized gas .
we discuss the contribution from the ionized gas using the @xmath10feii@xmath11$](@xmath65m)/@xmath10neii@xmath11$](@xmath66 m ) and @xmath10siii@xmath11$](@xmath67m)/@xmath10neii@xmath11$](@xmath66 m ) line ratios .
the high @xmath10neii@xmath11$](@xmath66m)/@xmath10neiii@xmath11$](@xmath68 m ) mid - ir line ratio ( see section 5 ) implies that @xmath10neii@xmath11 $ ] is the dominant ionization state of ne in the sq shock . unlike fe and si ,
ne is not much depleted on dust @xcite .
because the @xmath10neii@xmath11$]@xmath66 m line has a high critical density ( @xmath69@xmath57 , ho and keto 2007 ) , the neon line strength scales with the emission measure of the ionised gas .
the optical line emission from the sq shock is discussed in detail in xu et al .
the high values of the @xmath10oi@xmath11$](6300 ) and @xmath10nii@xmath11$](6584 ) lines to h@xmath27 line ratios are evidence of shock ionization .
the optical @xmath10sii@xmath11$](6716/6731 ) line ratio as well as the mir @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] line ratio correspond to the low density limit ( see section 5 ) and comparison with the shock models of allen et al .
( 2008 ) constrain the pre - shock gas density to be about @xmath70@xmath57 or smaller . in figure
[ fig : sil_ne ] we indicate the region ( in grey ) corresponding to the observed mir ratios ( using the upper and lower limits determined for the @xmath10neii@xmath1112.81\mu$]m line emission as discussed in section 5 ) .
for comparison the expected emission from the shock models of @xcite are displayed for a pre - shock gas density of @xmath70@xmath57 and two values of the magnetic parameter , @xmath58 = 0.5 and 3 .
for clarity of the figure , only shock velocities from 100 to 300kms@xmath13 are used and higher velocities shocks which do not match the observed @xmath10neii@xmath11$]/@xmath10neiii@xmath11 $ ] line emission ratio ( see section 5 ) are discarded .
the observed @xmath10feii@xmath11$](@xmath65m)/@xmath10neii@xmath11$](@xmath66 m ) and @xmath10siii@xmath11$](@xmath67m)/@xmath10neii@xmath11$](@xmath66 m ) ratios are both smaller than the shock values .
the iron and silicon lines are not dominant cooling lines of ionizing shocks .
the gas abundances of these elements do not impact the thermal structure of the shock and the line intensities roughly scale with the gas phase abundances .
we thus interpret the offset between the irs observation and model values as evidence for fe and si depletion .
we consider the magnitude of the depletions indicated by the arrow ( @xmath650% and @xmath660% for fe and si , respectively ) in figure [ fig : sil_ne ] as lower limits since there could be a contribution to the @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] and @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] line emission from non - ionizing @xmath33-shocks into molecular gas @xcite .
such shocks could also contribute to the @xmath10oi@xmath11$](6300 ) line emission as discussed in guillard et al .
forthcoming observations of the h@xmath9 ro - vibrational line emission in the near - ir should allow us to estimate whether they may be significant . a contribution from non - ionizing shocks to the @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] and @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] line emission will raise the depletion of both fe and si as well as the fe / si depletion ratio because non - ionizing shocks do not produce @xmath10neii@xmath11 $ ] line emission and the @xmath10feii@xmath11$](@xmath71m)/@xmath10siii@xmath11$](@xmath72 m ) line emission ratio in @xmath33-shocks within dense gas is larger than for shocks plotted in figure [ fig : sil_ne ] . a key aspect to understanding the emission we observe in sq , as well as a test of the proposed model of h@xmath5 excitation , is the amount and distribution of cold h@xmath5 , as measured by co. a reservoir of cold h@xmath5 associated with the warm gas observed in sq would provide key insight into conditions within the intragroup medium . in figure [ fig : co ]
we show the bima co ( 1 - 0 ) integrated intensity contours from @xcite , shown with the h@xmath5 s(0 ) and s(1 ) emission contours , overlaid on an optical image of sq .
these interferometric observations use the large primary beam of 110 , centered on the shock , to determine areas of high column densities in the group .
the co traces areas of known star formation seen at 24 and in the nuv ( see section [ sf ] ) , notably sq - a and 7318b - south . as observed by @xcite , the co around ngc 7319
is concentrated in two regions .
the dominant complex is north of the nucleus residing in a dusty tidal feature .
the nuclear co is elongated perpendicular to the stellar disk suggesting a deficiency of ongoing star formation in the disk .
the co distribution does not correlate with the location of warm h@xmath5 emission , particularly around ngc 7319 .
the cold h@xmath5 complexes are clearly offset from the concentrations of warm h@xmath9 .
even the s(0 ) emission line ( see fig .
[ fig : co]a ) , which follows the coldest warm h@xmath9 , does not have peaks corresponding to the strongest co detections . in a forthcoming paper ( guillard et al .
2010 , in preparation ) , we will report the recent detection of @xmath73co(1 - 0 ) and ( 2 - 1 ) emission , associated with the warm h@xmath9 in the sq shock , using the single - dish 30 m iram telescope .
these observations suggest that most of the co emission in the shock has been missed by interferometers ( because of the broad linewidth ) and show that the co emission is both present in the shock , and extends along the h@xmath9-emitting bridge and towards ngc 7319 .
the kinematics of the co gas lying outside of star - forming regions , in the new observations , appears to be highly disturbed with a broad linewidth in agreement with the appleton et al .
( 2006 ) interpretation that the mir h@xmath5 lines were intrinsically very broad and resolved by the high resolution module of irs .
the co data also agrees with our re - analysis of the appleton et al .
( 2006 ) data ( see appendix b ) using more recent and reliable wavelength calibration , which places the bulk of the h@xmath5 gas at velocities intermediate to that of the intruder and the group supporting the idea that the h@xmath5 gas is accelerated in the shock .
section [ sf ] discussed the star forming regions observed in sq and noted that there was very little evidence for star formation in the shock associated with the warm h@xmath5 emission .
the main shock contains a large quantity of warm molecular hydrogen ( 5.0 @xmath210@xmath43m@xmath44 ) providing a reservoir of fuel for star formation once it cools ( see section [ spec ] ) .
we investigate star formation in the warm h@xmath9-dominated medium by considering the shock sub - region , chosen to avoid star forming regions in the intruder galaxy , but likely still subject to some contamination from these regions .
pah emission is a classical tracer of star formation , but the molecules are fragile and easily destroyed in hard radiation fields . in the spectra of the main shock and subregion ( fig .
[ fig : spectra]a and b ) the pah emission bands at 6.2 , 7.7 and 8.6 are far weaker compared to the 11.3 bands , which when strong are predominantly produced by neutral pah molecules @xcite . in the shock subregion we find an upper limit flux for the 6.2 pah of @xmath74 wm@xmath75 and fluxes of @xmath76 wm@xmath75 and @xmath77 wm@xmath75 for the 7.7 and 11.3 bands respectively .
this corresponds to a 7.7/11.3 pah ratio of 0.35 , very low compared to the median value found for the sings sample of 3.6 @xcite .
the suppression of the 7.7/11.3 pah ratio has been observed in agn environments ( e.g. low - luminosity agn in the sings sample of * ? ? ? * ) and is favored to be the result of selective destruction of pah molecules small enough to emit at 7.7 .
pah processing in the shock due to larger molecules being less fragile than smaller ones is discussed further in guillard et al .
an alternative explanation is that the pah molecules are chiefly large and neutral in the shock , producing enhanced 11.3 emission in comparison to the smaller pah molecules .
a detailed comparison of the dust and pah emission properties can be found in guillard et al .
( 2010 ) .
dust emission in the mid- and far - infrared can be used to infer the amount of star formation taking place @xcite .
we measure a 24 flux in this region of 0.408 mjy , corresponding to a spectral luminosity ( @xmath78 ) of @xmath79 .
this low luminosity is consistent with the weak mir continuum ( fig .
[ fig : spectra]b ) , arising from emission from vsgs heated by the uv radiation field .
we can combine this with a measurement of the h@xmath27 emission in this region to obtain a star formation rate ( sfr ) , given that they are complimentary ( h@xmath27 tracing the young stellar population and 24 as a measure of dust - absorbed stellar light ) .
we find @xmath80 , but caution that h@xmath27 emission in sq is also the result of shock - excitation @xcite and must be considered an upper limit for measuring star formation . when we combine @xmath81 with @xmath82 , using the relation of @xcite , we find a sfr of @xmath290.05@xmath83
. a further measure of star formation can be obtained from the pah strength . using the relation of @xcite , derived from the starburst sample of @xcite
, we can use the 7.7 flux density as a measure of star formation .
the shock subregion has a 7.7 flux density of 0.73 mjy which corresponds to a sfr of @xmath84 , in good agreement with our previous calculation , but also an upper limit as some pah emission is contamination from known star formation regions in the group . a point of caution
, however , is that this star formation indicator may be biased given that we detect suppressed 7.7 emission compared to the 11.3 pah .
comparing the @xmath85(7.7)/@xmath82 ratio to the galaxies in sings , we find that the value of @xmath86 is typical of star - forming galaxies @xcite , which suggests that both measures of star formation are low , but self - consistent .
the low _ upper limits _ for the sfr in the shock suggests that star formation is depressed in the shock apart from in the igm starburst , sq - a , which has a sfr of @xmath87 at the velocity of the group @xcite
. this would be consistent with a picture of molecular hydrogen being reheated by mhd shocks in the turbulent medium .
since the jeans mass increases with gas temperature and turbulence and shearing morions will prevent collapse , the cold molecular gas clouds may be too short - lived or undersized to facilitate collapse and produce significant star formation @xcite .
the extent of a cold reservoir of molecular gas in the shock is a key consideration in this scenario , as discussed in section [ co ] .
the present observations suggest that molecular line cooling in dense clumps dissipates a significant fraction of the kinetic energy available in high - speed shocks . for reference , and to provide a glimpse of what this group might look like at high redshift when filling a single beam , we present in figure [ fig : full ] the spectrum extracted for the entire group ( i.e. including the three neighboring galaxies and the shock ) .
the total h@xmath5 line emission from the whole group exceeds @xmath8 and is still the most dominant mir coolant .
indeed the luminosity of the rotational h@xmath5 lines is sufficient that it could be detected at high redshift with future far - infrared or sub - mm instrumentation like spica or safir ( see appleton et al .
how likely is it , however , that high - speed shocks play a role in the assembly of galaxies ?
there is growing evidence that galaxies at high redshift are turbulent @xcite and increasingly clumpy ( e.g. conselice et al .
2005 , elmegreen & elmegreen 2005 ) .
indeed bournaud & elmegreen ( 2009 ) discuss the importance of the growth instabilities in massive gas clumps in forming disks at z @xmath88 1 , and favor at least a large fraction of the clump systems being formed in smooth flows , perhaps similar to those discussed by dekel et al .
to what extent the build - up of these disks is truly `` smooth '' is not yet clear since the medium is likely to be a multiphase one . in a more standard picture , gas flowing into the more massive dark halos will experience strong shocks , most likely in an inhomogenious medium ( e. g. greif et al .
2008 ) thus it begs the question of how important h@xmath9 cooling may be in these different cases .
models of the collapse of the first structures predict that strong metal lines soon dominate the cooling over molecular hydrogen when the first stars pollute the environment .
it is therefore usually assumed that , except at very early stages , molecular hydrogen is a minority coolant in gas that forms the first major structures ( e.g. bromm et al .
2001 , santoro and shull 2006 ) .
however , our observations show that , under the right conditions , even in high metallicity environments , molecular hydrogen can be extremely powerful in this case dominating by a factor of ten over the usually powerful @xmath10siii@xmath1134.82 \mu$]m line in strong shocks .
if there are situations at high redshift where strong shocks propagate into a clumpy , multiphase medium , then our observations imply that molecular hydrogen cooling can not be assumed to be negligible . on the other hand
, this will not be a trivial problem .
our best model of stephan s quintet @xcite involves the formation of h@xmath5 in a complex multiphase turbulent medium in which shocks destroy dust in some places , but allow survival in others - thus encouraging h@xmath5 formation . in the early universe , this enhanced cooling ,
which has so far been neglected , will depend on the distribution and nature of the first dust grains , in concert with the formation , temperature and abundance of gas , and the feedback effects from the first stars and agn .
in this paper we have presented the results of the mid - infrared spectral mapping of the stephan s quintet system using the _ spitzer space telescope_. we highlight here our five main conclusions : * the powerful h@xmath5 emission detected by @xcite surprisingly represents only a small fraction of the group - wide warm h@xmath5 ( with a lower limit luminosity of @xmath89 spread over @xmath90 kpc@xmath7 ) that dominates the mid - infrared emission of the system .
there is evidence for another shock - excited feature , the so - called h@xmath5 bridge between the main shock and ngc 7319 , which is likely a remnant of past tidal interactions within the group .
the spatial variation in the distribution of the h@xmath5 0 - 0 line ratios implies differences in temperature and excitation in the shocked system - this will be explored fully in paper ii . *
the global l(h@xmath5)/l@xmath91 ratio in the main shock is @xmath92 , and @xmath62.5 in the new `` bridge '' feature .
the results confirm that mir h@xmath9 lines are a stronger coolant than x - ray emission over the shock structures , indicating a new cooling pathway seen on a large scale in sq .
this modifies the traditional view that x - rays dominate cooling at all times in the later stages of compact group evolution . since h@xmath5 forms on the surfaces of dust grains , we expect dust emission associated with these regions , but a low intensity radiation field produces only weak emission at 24 .
* following earlier interpretations of nebular line ratios in the optical , we interpret infrared ionic lines within the framework of fast ( @xmath93 km@xmath0 ) ionizing shocks .
comparison between the @xmath10neii@xmath11 $ ] , @xmath10neiii@xmath11 $ ] , @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] and @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] line intensities implies that both silicon and iron are depleted onto dust .
this result implies that dust is not destroyed in the shock .
* star formation in sq is dominated by sq - a and 7318b - south , located at the extreme ends of the shock ridge seen at radio wavelengths , suggesting they are both shock triggered starbursts .
however , regions dominated by warm h@xmath5 emission exhibit very low star formation rates , consistent with a turbulent model where h@xmath5 is significantly reheated and cool clouds are too short - lived or undersized to collapse . * in sq we observe the projected coexistence of @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] and h@xmath5 being produced by @xmath6200km@xmath0 and @xmath620km@xmath0 velocity shocks , respectively .
our observational results are consistent with a model of a multiphase postshock medium produced by a galaxy - wide collision @xcite .
the cooling pathway of warm h@xmath5 emission we observe group - wide in sq is clearly a significant , albeit surprising , mechanism in shock systems . to determine the overall dominant cooling mechanism in sq
, we require an inventory of lines and continuum processes at all wavelengths . early shock models @xcite predict that , apart from the rotational emission from h@xmath5 , contributions from lines such as @xmath10oi@xmath11$]63.2 , @xmath10cii@xmath11$]157.7 and the thz spectrum of h@xmath50 @xcite could be significant .
we hope to explore this chemistry more fully , and the detailed distribution of cool dust , using the capabilities of the _ herschel _ space observatory .
in addition , we can not rule out strong uv line - cooling .
stephan s quintet provides the ideal laboratory for probing a mechanism potentially crucial in systems ranging from ulirgs to radio galaxies to supernova remnants .
mec is supported by nasa through an award issued by jpl / caltech under program 40142 .
we thank tom jarrett for use of his irs pixel cleaning software and irac / mips photometry software .
aaaaa allen , m.g . ,
groves , b.a . , dopita , m.a . ,
sutherland , r.s . , & kewley , l.j .
2008 , , 178 , 20 allen , r.j .
, & hartsuiker , j.w .
1972 , nature , 239 , 324 allen , r.j . , & sullivan , w.t.,iii .
1980 , , 84 , 181 appleton , p. , et al .
2009 , astro2010 : the astronomy and astrophysics decadal survey , science white papers , 2010 , 2 appleton , p.n .
et al . 2006 , , 639 , l51 appleton , p.n . ,
charmandaris , v. , horrelou , c. , mirabel , i.f . ,
ghigo , f. , higdon , j.l . , & lord , s. 1999 , , 527 , 143 bernard - salas , j. et al .
2009 , , in press ( arxiv : astro - ph/0908.2821 ) black , j. h. , & van dishoeck , e. f. 1987 , , 322 , 412 bournaud , f. , & elmegreen , b. g. 2009 , , 694 , l158 brandl , b.r .
2006 , , 653 , 1129 bromm , v. , ferrara , a. , coppi , p. s. , & larson , r. b. 2001 , , 328 , 969 buchanan , c. l. , gallimore , j. f. , odea , c. p. , baum , s. a. , axon , d. j. , robinson , a. , elitzur , m. , & elvis , m. 2006 , , 132 , 401 calzetti , d. , et al . , 2007 , , 666 , 870 conselice , c. j. , et al . 2005 , , 633 , 29 dale , d.a . ,
et al . 2006 , , 646 , 161 dekel , a. , sari , r. , & ceverino , d. 2009 , , 703 , 785 deo , r.p . , et al .
2007 , , , 671 , 124 dopita , m. a. , & sutherland , r. s. 1995 , , 455 , 468 draine , b.t . ,
roberge , w.g . , & dalgarno , a. 1983 , , 264 , 485 draine , b. t. , & woods , d. t. 1992 , , 387 , 732 draine , b.t .
, & li a. 2001 , , 551 , 807 durret , f. 1994 , s , 105 , 57 egami , e. , rieke , g.h . ,
fadda , d. & hines , d.c .
2006 , , 652 , l21 elmegreen , b. g. , & elmegreen , d. m. 2005 , , 627 , 632 frster schreiber , n. m. , et al .
2006 , , 645 , 1062 gao , y. & xu , c. 2000 , , 542 , l83 genzel , r. , et al .
2008 , , 687 , 59 greif , t. h. , johnson , j. l. , klessen , r. s. , & bromm , v. 2008 , , 387 , 1021 guillard , p. , boulanger , f. , cluver , m. , appleton , p.n .
, pineau des forts , g. , & ogle , p. 2010
, , submitted guillard , p. , boulanger , f. , pineau des forts , g. , & appleton , p.n .
2009 , , 502 , 515 hatch , n.a . ,
crawford , c.s , fabian , a.c .
, & johnstone , r.m . 2005 , , 358 , 765 helou , g. , & bicay , m.d .
1993 , , 415 , 93 hewitt , j.w . , rho , j. , andersen , m. , & reach , w.t .
2009 , , 694 , 1266 ho , l.c . , & keto , e. 2007 , , 658 , 314 hollenbach , d. , & mckee c.f .
1989 , , 342 , 306 hollenbach , d. j. , & tielens , a. g. g. m. 1997 , , 35 , 179 houck , j.r . , weedman , d.w . ,
le floch , & hao , l. 2007 , , 671 , 323 houck , j.r .
2004 , , 154 , 18 kennicutt jr .
, 1998 , , 36 , 189 lepp , s. , & mccray , r. 1983 , , 269 , 560 maloney , p.r . , hollenbach , d.j . , &
tielens , a.g.g.m .
1996 , , 466 , 561 martn - hernndez , n.l . ,
vermeij , r. , tielens , a.g.g.m . , van der hulst , j.m . , & peeters , e. 2002 , ,
389 , 286 moles , m. , sulentic , j.w . , & mrquez , i. 1997 , , 485 , l69 neufeld , d. a. , hollenbach , d. j. , kaufman , m. j. , snell , r. l. , melnick , g. j. , bergin , e. a. , & sonnentrucker , p. 2007
, , 664 , 890 pietsch w. , trinchieri , g. , arp , h. , & sulentic , j.w .
1997 , , 322 , 89 pearson j. c. , de lucia f. c. , anderson , t. , herbst , e. , & helminger p. 1991
, , 379 , l41 ogle , p. , antonucci , r. , appleton , p. , & whysong , d. 2007 , , 668 , 699 ogle , p. et al .
2009 , , submitted osullivan , e.o . ,
giacintucci , s. , vrtilek , j.m . ,
raychaudhury , s. , & david , l.p .
2009 , , 701 , 1560 rieke , g. et al . , 2004 , , 154 , 204 rigopoulou , d. , kunze , d. , lutz , d. , genzel , r. , & moorwood , a.f.m . 2002 , , 389 , 374 santoro , f. , & shull , j. m. 2006 , , 643 , 26 shull , j. m. , & hollenbach , d. j. 1978 , , 220 , 525 simpson , j. p. , witteborn , f. c. , price , s. d. , & cohen , m. 1998 , , 508 , 268 smith , j.d.t . et al .
2007 , , 119 , 1133 smith , j.d.t .
2009 , , 693 , 713 sulentic , j.w . , rosado , m. , dultzin - hacyan , d. , verdes - montenegro , l. , trincheri , g. , xu , c. , & pietsch , w. 2001 , , 122 , 2993 trinchieri , g. , sulentic , j. , breitschwerdt , d. , & pietsch , w. , 2003 , , 401 , 173 trinchieri , g. , sulentic , j. , pietsch , w. , & breitschwerdt , d. 2005 , , 444 , 697 verma , a. , lutz , d. , sturm , e. , sternberg , a. , genzel , r. , & vacca , w. 2003 , , 403 , 829 weedman , d. , et al . 2005 , , 633 , 706 werner , m. w. , et al .
2004 , , 154 , 1 williams , b.a .
, yun , m.s .
, & verdes - montenegro , l. 2002 , , 123 , 2417 xanthopoulos , e. , muxlow , t.w.b . ,
thomasson , p. , & garrington , s.t .
, 2004 , , 353 , 1117 xu , c. , sulentic , j.w . , & tuffs , r. 1999 , , 512 , 178 xu , c.k . , lu , n. , condon , j.j . , dopita , m. , & tuffs , r.j .
2003 , , 595 , 665 xu , c.k . , et al .
2005 , , 619 , l95 yun , m.s .
, verdes - montenegro , l. , del olmo , a. , & perea , j. 1997 , , 475 , l21
in this section we discuss the results pertaining to ngc 7319 , a seyfert 2 galaxy @xcite lying to the east in the sq group ( see fig .
the specific intensity contours for the h@xmath5 s(0 ) and h@xmath5 s(1 ) lines ( fig . 2a and b ) show emission associated with the galaxy , seemingly connected to the rest of the group by the h@xmath5 `` bridge '' discussed in section [ molhy ] . figure [ fig : xray_rad ] shows that the nucleus of ngc 7319 produces strong x - ray emission @xcite and is prominent at radio wavelengths @xcite .
however , we observe an offset between the peak of the h@xmath5 emission near ngc 7319 and the seyfert nucleus , which suggests that the `` bridge '' is a separate structure and not being excited by the agn .
the agn in ngc 7319 does not have a well - collimated jet , but two extended lobes with compact hotspots , asymetrically distributed along the minor axis of the galaxy @xcite .
this structure runs ne / sw and its orientation compared to the h@xmath5 filament ( which runs ew ) is not consistent with causing the excitation of the h@xmath5 bridge .
this is also evident from the relatively weak power in the agn , as inferred by the emission line diagnostics discussed below , and in the x - ray where it is only a factor of @xmath62 greater than the emission associated with the main shock and `` bridge '' . in figure
[ fig : fs ] we present the specific intensity contours of the @xmath10feii@xmath11$]25.99 ( blended with @xmath10oiv@xmath11$]25.89@xmath25 m ) , @xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 and @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82 emission lines . given the low spectral resolution of the sl and ll modules of _
spitzer _ , we can not distinguish between emission from @xmath10fe ii@xmath11 $ ] and @xmath10oiv@xmath11 $ ] .
the agn in ngc 7319 is likely to produce both , with @xmath10feii@xmath11 $ ] emission likely originating in x - ray dissociation regions ( xdrs ) surrounding the agn @xcite .
prominent emission from @xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 and @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82 are due to the high excitation conditions associated with the agn .
dense pdrs and x - ray dominated regions , powered by agn , show strong @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] emission at 34.82 , while @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] 33.48 emission acts as a tracer of hii regions .
we now focus on the emission line properties of ngc 7319 .
figure [ fig : agn ] shows the spectrum extracted from the galaxy and the measured properties of the line ratios are listed in table [ tableh2fluxes ] and [ tablemetalfluxes ] .
for the first time in the sq group , we observe a spectrum which is no longer dominated by h@xmath5 emission , but instead the brightest lines are the high - excitation @xmath10oiv@xmath11$]25.91@xmath25 m and @xmath10feii@xmath11$]25.98 blended lines , as well as the @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.81@xmath25 m line . @xmath10nev@xmath11 $ ] is prominent at both 14.32 and 24.30@xmath25 m a line typically seen in agn . also , unlike the majority of the extended shocked regions , there is a rising thermal continuum more typical of a starforming galaxy than a classical seyfert galaxy , although as various studies have shown ( buchanan et al . 2006 ; deo et al . 2007 ) , seyfert ii galaxies exhibit a variety of mir spectral characteristics at long wavelengths .
ngc 7319 s rising continuum is similar to that seen in the seyfert ii galaxy ngc 3079 ( deo et al .
2007 ) , and likely represents a dominant starburst component in the far - ir .
spitzer imaging reveals not only a bright nucleus , but also extended emission regions in the galaxy . using the @xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.81@xmath25m/@xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 ratio as a probe of excitation sources
, we find a ratio of @xmath61.85 which is low compared to the average value found for agn galaxies ( @xmath94 ) in the _ spitzer _ infrared nearby galaxy sample ( sings ) , but high compared to star - forming regions ( @xmath95 ) in the same sample @xcite .
this suggests a relatively weak agn . the @xmath10neiii@xmath11$]15.56/@xmath10neii@xmath11$]12.81 ratio is a measure of radiation field strength and the value of 0.97 indicates a typical radiation field strength compared to other agn ( the sample of weedman et al .
2005 shows a range of @xmath60.17 to 1.9 ) . the average electron density , estimated from the @xmath10siii@xmath11$]18.71/@xmath10siii@xmath11$]33.48 ratio of @xmath60.56 , is @xmath59 @xmath57 @xcite , in the low - density limit for this diagnostic @xcite .
the properties of the h@xmath5 emission of ngc 7319 are limited to the two long wavelength lines observed by irs - ll ( the galaxy lies outside the region mapped by sl ) . as a result ,
the excitation diagram contains only two points allowing only an approximate idea of the h@xmath5 mass , since without the sl wavelength coverage to provide information on possible warmer components , we are likely to overestimate the temperature of the h@xmath5 by fitting a straight line to the points . any warmer component would contribute to the flux of the 0 - 0 s(1 ) line thus leading to a reduction of the temperature ( and increase in h@xmath5 mass ) for any cooler component . however , to provide a guide , we estimate the temperature of h@xmath5 @xmath96171@xmath97 k ( assuming the gas is in thermal equilibrium and thus an ortho - para ratio of 2.65 ) and a total h@xmath5 mass of 3.0@xmath9810@xmath3m@xmath4 .
we consider this a lower limit to the total warm mass if ( as is likely ) more than one component is present .
gao & xu ( 2000 ) estimated the _ cold _ molecular hydrogen mass of ngc 7319 based on @xmath73co ( 1 - 0 ) observations as @xmath88 3.6 @xmath210@xmath99m@xmath4 , a factor of roughly ten greater than the warm h@xmath5 mass .
such a ratio is not atypical of large spiral galaxies @xcite .
the high resolution spectrum at the center of the shock in sq , obtained by @xcite , has been reanalysed using the latest calibrations available for the irs instrument ( ssc pipeline version s17 ) and is included as figure [ fig : hr ] .
this has shown that the h@xmath5 gas lies at a velocity of 6360(@xmath100100 ) km s@xmath13 , between the velocity of the group ( 6600 kms@xmath13 ) and the velocity of the intruder ( 5700 kms@xmath13 ) .
this is consistent with a model of gas being accelerated by the shock , as well as the turbulence demonstrated by the broad linewidth of the h@xmath5 in the shock ( 860 kms@xmath13 ) .
the new sh spectrum shows that with the improved calibrations , the 11.3 pah feature is detected , although faint .
this is consistent with what is found in the larger extractions that show enhanced 11.3 pah emission compared to ionised pah features emitting at 6.2 and 7.7 .
in this section we present the x - ray fluxes in the extraction regions shown in figure [ fig : ext ] .
the reanalysis of archival data is necessary to obtain accurate fluxes and luminosities for the x - ray emission over the various apertures matched to our spectral extractions .
we use the xmm - newton epic - pn data ( see * ? ? ?
* for observational details ) to obtain the most sensitive measurements .
a calibrated event file was generated and filtered using standard quality flags , and subsequently cleaned of background flares .
a 0.32 kev image was then extracted and corrected for instrumental response .
all point - like sources were masked out to @xmath101 in the analysis of diffuse emission , and the local background level was estimated within a @xmath102 arcmin@xmath7 rectangular region away from the group core . for each region in fig .
7 , resulting background - subtracted photon count rates were converted to 0.32 kev and bolometric " ( 0.00110 kev ) x - ray fluxes assuming an absorbed thermal plasma model of metallicity 0.4 solar , with temperature as estimated from the map of osullivan et al .
( 2009 ) , and an absorbing galactic hi column density of @xmath103 @xmath47 . for ngc7319 , which harbors an agn , an absorbed power - law spectrum of photon index @xmath104 was assumed instead .
results are listed in table [ x - ray ] .
lcccc + region & count rate ( 0.3 - 2 kev ) & flux ( 0.3 - 2 kev ) & bolometric flux ( 0.001 - 10 kev ) & adopted spectral model + & ( photonss@xmath105 ) & ergs@xmath13@xmath47 & ergs@xmath13@xmath47 & + + main shock & 0.102 & 1.8 @xmath106 & 2.8 @xmath106 & t = 0.7 kev + shock sub - region & 0.017 & 3.3 @xmath107 & 5.1 @xmath107 & t = 0.8 kev + bridge & 0.017 & 3.0 @xmath107 & 4.5 @xmath107 & t = 0.6 kev + ngc 7319 & 0.051 & 1.1 @xmath106 & 3.7 @xmath106 & @xmath108 = 1.7 + sq - a & 0.013 & 2.4 @xmath107 & 3.7 @xmath107 & t = 0.6 kev + we note that for the main shock ( with luminosity 1.9 @xmath210@xmath35ergs@xmath13 in the 0 - 3 - 2 kev band ) we are within a factor of 2 of the 0.5 - 2 kev luminosity @xmath63.1 @xmath210@xmath35ergs@xmath13 obtained for a similar , but larger extraction of the shock by @xcite .
@xcite obtain a 0.5 - 2 kev surface brightness of 0.07 l@xmath4pc@xmath75 in the main shock compared to our value of 0.1 l@xmath4pc@xmath75 for the 0.3 - 2 kev surface brightness .
lccccccc + target region & aperture & h@xmath5 0 - 0 s(0 ) & h@xmath5 0 - 0 s(1 ) & h@xmath5 0 - 0 s(2 ) & h@xmath5 0 - 0 s(3 ) & h@xmath5 0 - 0 s(4 ) & h@xmath5 0 - 0 s(5 ) + & ( arcsec@xmath7 ) & @xmath10928.22@xmath25 m & @xmath10917.03@xmath25 m & @xmath10912.28@xmath25 m & @xmath1099.66@xmath25 m & @xmath1098.03@xmath25 m & @xmath1096.91@xmath25 m + + main shock & 2307 & 3.09@xmath1000.19 & 23.05@xmath1000.26 & 9.10@xmath1000.38 & 22.76@xmath1000.84 & 2.5@xmath1001.0 & 14.1@xmath1000.7 + shock sub - region & 242 & 0.36@xmath1000.03 & 3.13@xmath1000.02 & 1.47@xmath1000.08 & 3.60@xmath1000.08 & 1.04@xmath1000.15 & 2.37@xmath1000.30 + bridge & 413 & 0.72@xmath1000.04 & 4.94@xmath1000.09 & & & & + ngc 7319 & 1302 & 2.06@xmath1000.26 & 11.00@xmath1000.48 & & & & + sq - a & 671 & 1.83@xmath1000.05 & 8.8@xmath1000.13 & & & & 3.7@xmath1000.93 + lcccccccc + target region & @xmath10neii@xmath11 $ ] & @xmath10nev@xmath11 $ ] & @xmath10neiii@xmath11 $ ] & @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] & @xmath10nev@xmath11 $ ] & @xmath10feii@xmath11$]+@xmath10oiv@xmath11 $ ] & @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] & @xmath10siii@xmath11 $ ] + & @xmath10912.81@xmath25 m & @xmath10914.32@xmath25 m & @xmath10915.56@xmath25 m & @xmath10918.71@xmath25 m & @xmath10924.32@xmath25 m & @xmath10925.99 + 25.89@xmath25 m & @xmath10933.48@xmath25 m & @xmath10934.82@xmath25 m + + main shock & 5.31@xmath1000.30 & @xmath290.9 & 1.94@xmath1000.39 & 0.76@xmath1000.13 & @xmath290.14 & 1.07@xmath1000.10 & 1.87@xmath1000.15 & 8.59@xmath1000.27 + shock sub - region & 1.04@xmath1000.09 & @xmath290.18 & 0.15@xmath1000.06 & @xmath290.12 & @xmath290.14 & 0.15@xmath1000.03 & 0.13@xmath1000.02 & 1.23@xmath1000.04 + bridge & & & 0.39@xmath1000.04 & @xmath290.1 & @xmath290.15 & 0.29@xmath1000.04 & @xmath290.22 & 1.1@xmath1000.1 + ngc 7319 & & 2.89@xmath1000.64 & 9.47@xmath1000.29 & 2.81@xmath1000.40 & 1.56@xmath1000.39 & 10.9@xmath1000.27 & 5.0@xmath1000.42 & 9.24 @xmath1000.49 + sq - a & & @xmath290.8 & 1.29@xmath1000.16 & 0.87@xmath1000.06 & @xmath290.18 & @xmath290.17 & 1.54@xmath1000.10 & 2.3@xmath1000.16 +
|
we present results from the mid - infrared spectral mapping of stephan s quintet using the _ spitzer space telescope_. a 1000km@xmath0 collision ( @xmath1yr ) has produced a group - wide shock and for the first time the large - scale distribution of warm molecular hydrogen emission is revealed , as well as its close association with known shock structures . in the main shock region alone
we find 5.0 @xmath210@xmath3m@xmath4 of warm h@xmath5 spread over @xmath6480kpc@xmath7 and additionally report the discovery of a second major shock - excited h@xmath5 feature , likely a remnant of previous tidal interactions .
this brings the total h@xmath5 line luminosity of the group in excess of @xmath8 . in the main shock ,
the h@xmath5 line luminosity exceeds , by a factor of three , the x - ray luminosity from the hot shocked gas , confirming that the h@xmath9-cooling pathway dominates over the x - ray .
@xmath10siii@xmath11$]34.82emission , detected at a luminosity of 1/10th of that of the h@xmath9 , appears to trace the group - wide shock closely and in addition , we detect weak @xmath10feii@xmath11$]25.99 emission from the most x - ray luminous part of the shock .
comparison with shock models reveals that this emission is consistent with regions of fast shocks ( @xmath12km@xmath0 ) experiencing depletion of iron and silicon onto dust grains .
star formation in the shock ( as traced via ionic lines , pah and dust emission ) appears in the intruder galaxy , but most strikingly at either end of the radio shock .
the shock ridge itself shows little star formation , consistent with a model in which the tremendous h@xmath5 power is driven by turbulent energy transfer from motions in a post - shocked layer which suppresses star formation .
the significance of the molecular hydrogen lines over other measured sources of cooling in fast galaxy - scale shocks may have crucial implications for the cooling of gas in the assembly of the first galaxies .
|
if a word @xmath0 can be written as @xmath10 , then words @xmath11 , @xmath12 , and @xmath13 are called the prefix , factor , and suffix of @xmath0 , respectively .
a word @xmath0 over @xmath14 is called a de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 , if each word in @xmath15 appears exactly once in @xmath0 as a factor .
for example , @xmath16 is a binary de bruijn sequence of order @xmath17 since each binary word of length two appears in it exactly once as a factor : @xmath18 .
the de bruijn sequence can be understood by the following game .
suppose there are infinite supplies of balls , each of which is labeled by a letter in @xmath14 , and there is a glass pipe that can hold balls in a vertical line .
on the top of that pipe is an opening , through which one can drop balls into that pipe , and on the bottom is a trap - door , which can support the weight of at most @xmath1 balls .
when there are more than @xmath1 balls in the pipe , the trap - door opens and those balls at the bottom drop off until only @xmath1 balls remain .
if we put balls as numbered as in a de bruijn sequence on the alphabet @xmath14 of order @xmath1 , then every @xmath1 ball sequence will appear exactly once in the pipe .
it is easy to see that a de - bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 , if exists , is of length @xmath19 and its suffix of length @xmath20 is identical to its prefix of length @xmath20 .
so , sometimes a de - bruijn sequence is written in a circular form by omitting the last @xmath20 letters , which can be viewed as the equivalence class of words under the conjugate relation .
the de bruijn sequence is also called the de bruijn - good sequence , named after de bruijn @xcite and good @xcite who independently studied the existence of such words over binary alphabet ; the former also provided a formula @xmath21 for the total number of those words of order @xmath1 .
the study of the de bruijn sequence , however , dates back at least to 1894 , when flye sainte - marie @xcite studied the words and provided the same formula @xmath21 . for an arbitrary alphabet @xmath14 , van aardenne - ehrenfest and de bruijn provided the formula @xmath22 for the total number of de bruijn sequences of order @xmath1 .
besides the total number of de bruijn sequences , another interesting topic is how to generate a de bruijn sequence ( arbitrary one , lexicographically least one , lexicographically largest one ) . for generating de bruijn sequences ,
see the surveys @xcite .
the de bruijn sequence is some times called the full cycle @xcite , and has connections to the following concepts : feedback shift registers @xcite , normal words @xcite , generating random binary sequences @xcite , primitive polynomials over a galois field @xcite , lyndon words and necklaces , euler tours and spanning trees . in this paper
, we consider a generalization of the de bruijn sequence . to understand the concept , let us return to the glass pipe game presented at the beginning .
now the trap - door can support more weight .
when there are @xmath23 or more balls in the pipe , the trap - door opens and the balls drop off until there are only @xmath1 balls in the pipe .
is there an arrangement of putting the balls such that every @xmath1 ball sequence appears exactly once in the pipe ?
the answer is `` yes '' for arbitrary positive integers @xmath24 .
the solution represents a multi - shift de bruijn sequence .
we will discuss the existence of the multi - shift de bruijn sequence , the total number of multi - shift de bruijn sequences , generating a multi - shift de bruijn sequence , and the application of the multi - shift de bruijn sequence in the frobenius problem in a free monoid .
let @xmath25 be the _ alphabet _ and let @xmath26 be a word over @xmath14 .
the _ length _ of @xmath0 is denoted by @xmath27 and the _ factor _ @xmath28 of @xmath0 is denoted by @xmath29 . if @xmath30 for some non - negative integer @xmath31 , we say factor @xmath32 appears in @xmath0 at _ a modulo @xmath2 position_. the set of all words of length @xmath1 is denoted by @xmath15 and the set of all finite words is denoted by @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the _
empty word_. the concatenation of two words @xmath35 is denoted by @xmath36 , or simply @xmath37 .
a word @xmath0 over @xmath14 is called a _ multi - shift de bruijn sequence _ of shift @xmath2 and order @xmath1 , if each word in @xmath15 appears exactly once in @xmath0 as a factor at a modulo @xmath2 position .
for example , one of the @xmath17-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath38 is @xmath39 , which can be verified as follows : @xmath40 the multi - shift de bruijn sequence generalizes the de bruijn sequence in the sense de bruijn sequences are exactly @xmath41-shift de bruijn sequences of the same order .
it is easy to see that the length of each @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 , if exists , is equal to @xmath42 . by the definition of multi - shift de bruijn sequence , the following proposition holds .
[ lemma : circular ] let @xmath0 be one @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence @xmath0 of order @xmath1 , @xmath43 . then the suffix of length @xmath44 of @xmath0 is identical to the prefix of length @xmath44 of @xmath0 .
let @xmath0 be one @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence @xmath0 of order @xmath1 over @xmath14 and let @xmath45 .
write @xmath46 such that @xmath47 .
if @xmath48 , then we compare the set of all factors @xmath49 and the set of all factors @xmath50 for @xmath51 .
the former covers factors @xmath52 and the latter covers factors @xmath53 for every @xmath54 . since the two are identical , we have @xmath55 .
now we assume @xmath56 .
consider the set of all factors @xmath57 and the set of all factors @xmath58 for @xmath51 and @xmath59 . by the same argument
, we have @xmath60 for @xmath61 .
finally , comparing the set of all @xmath62 and the set of all @xmath63 for @xmath51 , we have the equality @xmath64 .
therefore , we have the equality @xmath65 . from proposition [ lemma : circular ] , we know that when @xmath43 , every multi - shift de bruijn sequence can be written as a circular word and the discussion on multi - shift de bruijn sequences of the two different forms are equivalent . in this paper , we discuss the multi - shift de bruijn sequence in the form of ordinary words . a _ ( non - strict ) directed graph _ , or _ digraph _ for short , is a triple @xmath66 consisting of a set @xmath67 of _ vertices _ , a set @xmath68 of _ arcs _ , and an _ incidence function _ @xmath69 .
here we do not take the convention @xmath70 , since we allow a digraph contains self - loops and multiple arcs regarding the same pair of vertices .
when @xmath71 , we say the arc @xmath9 joins @xmath32 to @xmath72 , where vertex @xmath73 and vertex @xmath74 are called _ tail _ and _ head _ , respectively .
the indegree @xmath75 ( outdegree @xmath76 , respectively ) of a vertex @xmath72 is the number of arcs with @xmath72 being the head ( the tail , respectively ) .
a _ walk _ in @xmath77 is a sequence @xmath78 such that @xmath79 for each @xmath80 .
the walk is _ closed _ , if @xmath81 .
two closed walks are regarded as identical if one is the circular shift of the other . an _
euler tour _ is a closed walk that traverses each arc exactly once .
hamilton cycle _ is a closed walk that traverses each vertex exactly once
. an _ ( spanning ) arborescence _ is a digraph with a particular vertex , called the _ root _
, such that it contains every vertices of @xmath77 , its number of arcs is exactly one less than the number of vertices , and there is exactly one walk from the root to any other vertex .
we denote the total number of euler tours , hamilton cycles , and arborescence of @xmath77 by @xmath82 , @xmath83 , and @xmath84 , respectively .
an _ ( undirected ) graph _ is defined as a digraph such that for any pair of vertices @xmath85 , there is an arc @xmath9 , @xmath86 , if and only if there is a corresponding arc @xmath87 , @xmath88 . in this case
, we write @xmath89 and a spanning arborescence is just a _ spanning tree_. the arc - graph @xmath90 of @xmath66 is defined as @xmath91 such that for every pair of arcs @xmath92 , @xmath93 , there is an arc @xmath94 , @xmath95 and those arcs are the only arcs in @xmath96 .
euler tours exist in a graph @xmath77 if and only if hamilton cycles exist in the arc - graph @xmath90 .
we define the word graph @xmath97 by @xmath98 , where @xmath99 for @xmath100 . then by definition , the following lemmas are straightforward .
[ lemma : arcgraph ] the digraph @xmath101 is the digraph @xmath102 . by definition , @xmath103 where @xmath104 , and @xmath105 so for every pair of arcs @xmath106 of @xmath97 with @xmath107 , there is an arc @xmath108 of @xmath102 ; and for every arc @xmath109 of @xmath102 , @xmath110 hence , by definition , @xmath102 is the arc - graph of @xmath97 .
[ lemma : equivalent ] suppose @xmath111 .
( 1 ) there is a @xmath112-to-@xmath41 mapping from the set of @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequences of order @xmath1 onto the set of hamilton cycles in @xmath97 .
( 2 ) there is a @xmath112-to-@xmath41 mapping from the set of @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequences of order @xmath1 onto the set of euler tours in @xmath113 .
let @xmath114 .
( 1 ) notice that any hamilton cycle @xmath115 together with a starting arc @xmath116 uniquely determines one @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequences of order @xmath1 specified by @xmath117 and vice versa .
so the @xmath118-to-@xmath41 mapping exists .
( 2 ) applying lemma [ lemma : arcgraph ] , this part follows from ( 1 ) . [
theorem : existence ] for any alphabet @xmath14 , positive integers @xmath24 , the @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequences of order @xmath1 over @xmath14 exist .
first we assume @xmath119 .
let @xmath120 be any permutation of the words in @xmath15 for @xmath114 .
then the word @xmath121 is one @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 over @xmath14 .
now we assume @xmath122 and prove there exists an euler tour in @xmath113 .
then by lemma [ lemma : equivalent ] , the existence of @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequences of order @xmath1 over @xmath14 is ensured . to show the existence of an euler tour , we only need to verify that @xmath113 is connected and that @xmath123 for every vertex @xmath72 , both of which are straightforward : for every vertex @xmath72 in @xmath113 , @xmath72 is connected to the vertex @xmath124 in both directions and @xmath125 .
since @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 exists , in this section we discuss the total number of different @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 , and we denote the number by @xmath126 .
first , we study the degenerated case .
[ lemma : countnlesm ] for @xmath6 , @xmath127 , where @xmath45 .
let @xmath45 . by the definition of the multi - shift de bruijn sequence , in the case @xmath6 , @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequences of order @xmath1
are exactly those of the form @xmath128 , where @xmath129 and @xmath120 is a permutation of all words in @xmath15 .
therefore , the total number of such words is @xmath5 . to study the case @xmath8
, we need a theorem by van aardenne - ehrenfest and de bruijn , which describes the relation between the number of euler tours in a particular type of digraph and the number of euler tours in its arc - graph . [
theorem : ehrenfestbruijn ] let @xmath66 be a digraph such that @xmath130 for every @xmath131
. then @xmath132 .
the digraph @xmath97 satisfies the conditions in theorem [ theorem : ehrenfestbruijn ] with @xmath133 .
so , by the relation between the multi - shift de bruijn sequences and the euler tours in the word graph @xmath97 , we have the following recursive expression on @xmath126 .
[ lemma : recursion ] for @xmath134 , @xmath135 , where @xmath45 , @xmath136 .
let @xmath45 , @xmath136 . by lemma [ lemma :
equivalent ] , @xmath137 to finish the last step of obtaining @xmath126 for @xmath8 , we again need two theorems , which are often used in the literature to count the number of euler tours in various types of digraphs . [
theorem : best ] in a digraph @xmath66 , @xmath138 .
[ theorem : kirchhoff ] in a graph @xmath66 , the number of spanning trees is equal to any cofactor of the laplacian matrix of @xmath77 , which is the diagonal matrix of degrees minus the adjacency matrix .
[ lemma : countnles2 m ] for @xmath139 , @xmath140 , where @xmath45 .
let @xmath141 and @xmath45 .
then @xmath142 . by definition ,
so from any vertex to any vertex , there are @xmath144-many arcs in @xmath77 .
we convert @xmath77 into a undirected graph @xmath145 by omitting all self - loops ; there are @xmath144-many of them for each vertex .
since for every pair of vertices @xmath85 there are @xmath144-many arcs joins @xmath146 to @xmath147 and correspondingly there are @xmath144-many arcs joins @xmath147 to @xmath146 , the graph @xmath145 is indeed an undirected graph by our definition .
each vertex in @xmath145 is of degree @xmath148 .
then the laplacian matrix of @xmath145 is @xmath149 by theorem [ theorem : kirchhoff ] , the number of arborescence @xmath150 is equal to the cofactor of @xmath151 , which is @xmath152
. then by theorem [ theorem : best ] , the number of euler tours in digraph @xmath77 is @xmath153 .
finally , by lemma [ lemma : equivalent ] , the number of @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 is @xmath154 .
[ theorem : count ] for @xmath6 , @xmath127 , and for @xmath155 , @xmath140 , where @xmath45 . for @xmath6 , the equality @xmath127 is shown in lemma [ lemma : countnlesm ] .
now we assume @xmath156 .
let @xmath136 .
then by lemmas [ lemma : recursion],[lemma : countnles2 m ] , we have @xmath157 .
in this section , we study the problem of generating one @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 for arbitrary alphabet and positive integers @xmath24 . when @xmath6 , a @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 is easy to construct as given in theorem [ theorem : existence ] .
now we consider the case @xmath158 .
we will present two algorithms for generating a @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 .
we claim that @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequences of order @xmath159 can be generated using the ordinary de bruijn sequence generating algorithm , such as described by fredricksen @xcite .
to do this , we first generate a de bruijn sequence @xmath0 of order @xmath160 over the alphabet @xmath161 .
then we replace each letter of @xmath0 in @xmath162 by the corresponding word of length @xmath2 over @xmath14 .
it is easy to see that the new word is a @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath159 .
the first algorithm of generating multi - shift de bruijn sequence is to generate @xmath163-shift de bruijn sequences of order @xmath164 for @xmath165 before rearranging the words to obtain an arbitrary @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 .
let @xmath166 be two integers , and @xmath46 , where @xmath136 .
the case @xmath167 is already discussed and the case @xmath168 is trivial .
so we assume @xmath169 and @xmath170 .
we define @xmath171 , @xmath172 and generate @xmath173 such that @xmath174 is a @xmath175-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath176 and @xmath177 ; and define @xmath178 , @xmath179 and generate @xmath180 such that @xmath181 is a @xmath182-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath183 and @xmath184 .
let @xmath45 , @xmath185 , @xmath186 .
we define @xmath187 , @xmath188 , @xmath189 , @xmath190 .
then the following word @xmath191 is one @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 , where @xmath192 and @xmath193 . to show the correctness
, we claim that every word in @xmath194 appears in @xmath195 as a factor at a modulo @xmath2 position exactly once .
furthermore , since @xmath196 , every word in @xmath197 appears in @xmath198 as a factor at a modulo @xmath2 position exactly once .
therefore , the generated word is indeed a @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 .
now , we will see an example .
consider generating a @xmath17-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath199 .
then @xmath200 and we can obtain two words @xmath201 , which is @xmath202 , and @xmath203 , which is @xmath204 .
so one @xmath17-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath199 is as follows @xmath205 where the subscripts @xmath41 and @xmath17 denote whether the letter is from the word @xmath206 ( words @xmath207 ) or from the word @xmath208 ( words @xmath209 ) .
now we present the second algorithm , which uses the same idea of `` prefer one '' algorithm @xcite for generating ordinary de bruijn sequences .
let @xmath24 be two positive integers .
the following algorithm generates a @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 : 1 .
start the sequence @xmath0 with @xmath1 zeros ; 2 .
append to the end of current sequence @xmath0 the lexicographically largest word of length @xmath2 such that the suffix of length @xmath1 of new sequence has not yet appeared as factor at a modulo @xmath2 position ; 3 . repeat the last step until no word can be added . to show the correctness
, first we claim that when the algorithm stops , the suffix @xmath32 of length @xmath44 of @xmath0 contains only zeros . to see this ,
suppose @xmath32 is not @xmath124 .
since no word can be added , all @xmath210 words of length @xmath1 with prefix @xmath32 appear in @xmath0 and thus @xmath32 appears in @xmath0 as a factor at a modulo @xmath2 position @xmath211 times .
so there are @xmath211 words of length @xmath1 with suffix @xmath32 that appear in @xmath0 at a modulo @xmath2 position , which contradicts the definition of the multi - shift de bruijn sequence . therefore , @xmath212
furthermore , word @xmath124 appears in @xmath0 as a factor at a modulo @xmath2 position @xmath211 times and thus all words in @xmath213 appear in @xmath0 as a factor at a modulo @xmath2 position . by the algorithm
, no word of length @xmath1 can appear twice in @xmath0 at a modulo position .
so , in order to prove the correctness of the algorithm , it remains to show every word of length @xmath1 appears in @xmath0 as a factor at a modulo @xmath2 position .
suppose a word @xmath72 does not appear in @xmath0 at a modulo @xmath2 position .
then @xmath214 and the word @xmath215 does not appear in @xmath0 as a factor at a modulo @xmath2 position as well ; otherwise , there are @xmath216 appearance of @xmath217 in @xmath0 at a modulo @xmath2 position , which means @xmath72 appears in @xmath0 as a factor at a modulo @xmath2 position .
repeat this procedure , none of the words @xmath215 ,
@xmath218 , @xmath219 , @xmath220 appears in @xmath0 as a factor at a modulo @xmath2 position . but
for @xmath221 , we proved that @xmath222 appears in @xmath0 as a factor at a modulo @xmath2 position , a contradiction .
therefore , every word of length @xmath1 appears at a modulo @xmath2 position .
now , we use the algorithm to generate one @xmath17-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath199 . starting from @xmath223 , since @xmath224 does not appear as a factor at a modulo @xmath17 position , we append @xmath225 to the current sequence @xmath223 . repeating this procedure and appending words
@xmath225 , @xmath225 , @xmath226 , @xmath225 , , finally we obtain the word : @xmath227 if we circularly move the prefix @xmath228 to the end , the sequence generated by the second algorithm is the lexicographically largest @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 .
the study of multi - shift de bruijn sequences is inspired by a problems of words , called the frobenius problem in a free monoid . given @xmath160 integers @xmath229 , such that @xmath230 , then there are only finitely many positive integers that _ can not _ be written as a non - negative integer linear combination of @xmath229 .
the integer _
frobenius problem _ is to find the largest such integer , which is denoted by @xmath231 .
for example , @xmath232 . if words @xmath229 , instead of integers , are given such that there are only finitely many words that _ can not _ be written as concatenation of words from the set @xmath233 , the _ frobenius problem in a free monoid _
@xcite is to find the longest such words .
if all @xmath229 are of length either @xmath2 or @xmath1 , @xmath234 , there is an upper bound : the length of the longest word that can not be written as concatenation of words from the set @xmath233 is less than or equal to @xmath235 , where @xmath236 .
@xcite furthermore , the upper bound is tight and the construction is based on the multi - shift de bruijn sequences .
we denote the set of all words that can be written as concatenation of words in @xmath237 , including the empty word , by @xmath238 .
@xcite there exists @xmath239 , @xmath234 , such that @xmath240 is finite and the longest words in @xmath240 constitute exactly the language @xmath241 , where @xmath242 is a @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath44 .
for example , for any set of words @xmath243 such that @xmath244 is finite , the longest words in @xmath244 are of length less than or equal to @xmath245 . to construct @xmath237 to reach the upper bound ,
we first choose an anbitrary @xmath38-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath246 as @xmath247 . then based on @xmath242
, we construct the set @xmath248 @xmath249 , @xmath250 , @xmath251 , @xmath252 , @xmath253 , @xmath254 , @xmath255 , @xmath256 , @xmath257 , @xmath258 , @xmath259 , @xmath260 , @xmath261 , @xmath262 , @xmath263 @xmath264 .
we have @xmath265 and one of the longest words in @xmath151 of length exactly @xmath266 is given below : @xmath267
in this paper , we generalized the classic de bruijn sequence to a new multi - shift setting .
a word @xmath0 is a @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence @xmath268 of order @xmath1 , if each word of length @xmath1 appears exactly once as a factor at a modulo @xmath2 position .
an ordinary de bruijn sequence is a @xmath41-shift de bruijn sequence .
we showed the total number of distinct @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequences of order @xmath1 is @xmath269 for @xmath6 and is @xmath140 for @xmath8 , where @xmath45 .
this result generalizes the formula @xmath270 for the number of ordinary de bruijn sequences .
here we use an ordinary word form ; if counting the sequences in a circular form , then the number is to be divided by @xmath271 .
we provided two algorithms for generating a @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 .
the first algorithm is to rearrange factors from two simpler multi - shift de bruijn sequences , where the order is a multiple of the shift .
the second is the analogue of the `` prefer one '' algorithm ( for example , see ) for generating ordinary de bruijn sequence .
the multi - shift de bruijn sequence has application in the frobenius problem in a free monoid by providing constructions of examples
. it will be interesting to see that this generalized concept of the de bruijn sequence can help in other fields of theoretical computer science and discrete mathematics .
|
a ( non - circular ) de bruijn sequence @xmath0 of order @xmath1 is a word such that every word of length @xmath1 appears exactly once in @xmath0 as a factor . in this paper
, we generalize the concept to a multi - shift setting : a @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequence of order @xmath1 is a word such that every word of length @xmath1 appears exactly once in @xmath0 as a factor that starts at an index @xmath3 for some integer @xmath4 .
we show the number of the @xmath2-shift de bruijn sequences of order @xmath1 is @xmath5 for @xmath6 and is @xmath7 for @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is the size of the alphabet .
we provide two algorithms for generating a multi - shift de bruijn sequence .
the multi - shift de bruijn sequence is important in solving the frobenius problem in a free monoid .
|
quantum rings and quantum dots are prototype systems for the observation of mesoscopic interference on the one hand and for spectroscopic investigations of discrete level spectra of interacting systems on the other hand .
ring shaped structures give rise to aharonov bohm ( ab ) interference @xcite which can be tuned by applying a magnetic flux through the area enclosed by the ring .
open ring geometries have been used as interferometers , e.g. , to study the transmission phase of quantum dots in the coulomb blockade ( cb ) regime.@xcite the discrete level spectrum of coulomb blockaded quantum dots has been extensively studied using tunneling spectroscopy to probe interaction and spin effects when a gate voltage is used to successively add electrons to such artificial atoms.@xcite and @xmath0 simultaneously and under symmetric bias conditions . @xmath1 reflects the transmission from the ring to the dot .
( c ) aharonov bohm oscillations in the two terminal ring conductance @xmath2 .
( d ) coulomb - blockade oscillations in the two - terminal dot conductance @xmath3 as a function of the in - plane gate voltage @xmath4 .
, width=302 ] interference of a resonant state , e.g. a discrete level of a quantum dot , and a continuum of states , e.g. , in a quantum wire or an open ring , typically gives rise to asymmetric line shapes characteristic of the fano effect.@xcite a theoretical treatment of the fano effect was originally developed for scattering cross - sections of nuclei @xcite and in optical spectroscopy@xcite , but recently fano resonnances were also addressed in a multitude of mesoscopic systems @xcite . in mesoscopic transport the energy dependent conductance of a fano resonance can be written as @xmath5 here @xmath6 is a dimensionless energy parameter with @xmath7 the energy of an electron , @xmath8 the energy of the resonance and @xmath9 the width of the resonance .
the quantity @xmath10 is known as the _ fano parameter _ and determines the shape of the resonance line.@xcite for @xmath11 resonant transmission dominates and the fano resonance becomes equivalent to a symmetric breit wigner resonance . for @xmath12 a breit wigner shaped anti - resonance is observed and for @xmath13 the asymmetry is strongest . theoretically the fano effect in mesoscopic systems has been discussed for both resonant and open cavities,@xcite and in conjunction with rings.@xcite it has been proposed that fano resonances in quantum dots could be used as a measure of phase coherence@xcite or a means to produce spin polarized currents.@xcite experimentally fano resonances were observed in the tunneling current through a single cobalt atom on a gold surface.@xcite in coulomb blockaded quantum dots it was found that the interference of a broad resonance ( quasi - continuum ) with a narrow resonance can lead to fano peak shapes.@xcite a recent experiment investigated a coulomb blockaded quantum dot side - coupled to a quantum wire and discussed the implications of coulomb interactions between the dot and the wire in the fano regime@xcite .
kobayashi et al . further studied the fano effect in an ab - ring with a quantum dot embedded in one arm of the ring.@xcite in these experiments the magnetic field allowed them to tune the relative phase between the non - resonant ( ring ) and the resonant ( dot ) path , periodically changing the asymmetry of the fano line shape .
their interpretation required the introduction of a complex @xmath10-parameter to account for the ab - phase .
similar results were also found in crossed carbon nanotubes with a resonant state at the point where the tubes are touching.@xcite in these ring systems the fano effect arises due to the interference of a breit - wigner type resonance in one arm of the ring ( containing a strongly coupled quantum dot ) with a continuum channel in the other arm of the ring . here
we present transport studies on a structure where a quantum dot in cb - regime is side - coupled to a ring [ see fig.[fig1](a ) ] .
our structure has a tunable channel between the ring and the dot which permits us to couple coherently the two subsystems while keeping them spatially separated and therefore minimize capacitive effects of the quantum dot on the interference in the ring , as investigated in ref and ref .
in contrast to previous ring systems , our experiment constitutes a tunable fano scatterer consisting of one arm of the ring and the side coupled dot , which is made to interfere with alternative paths along the second arm of the ring .
this allows us to study the interplay between continuous ab - interference in the ring and interference involving a resonant level in the dot .
the paper is organized as follows : in section ii , the experimental realization of the coupled ring - dot structure is discussed and low temperature transport measurements are presented . in section iii
we give a model for the ring - dot system within the scattering matrix formalism and link it to the fano formula in eq.[eqn1 ] . in section iv model and experimental results are compared and we follow ref . to model decoherence in the dot due to finite temperatures and coupling to the leads . in section
v we discuss limitations of the model .
as a function of @xmath4 when the channel between the dot and the ring is pinched off .
the dashed white lines show the cb - peak positions as determined from the dot conductance @xmath3 .
this indicates that electrostatic coupling is negligibly small .
( b ) three simultaneously measured currents @xmath0 ( dotted lines ) , @xmath14 ( dashed lines ) , @xmath1 ( solid lines ) , when @xmath15= -50mv,-46mv,-42mv is raised to increase the coupling between the ring and the dot .
the thickest line indicates strongest coupling .
( c ) @xmath0 and @xmath14 when @xmath16 is used to tune the electron number of the dot . while @xmath14 shows the expected coulomb oscillations the current through the ring exhibits the typical asymmetric line shapes characteristic of the fano effect .
, width=326 ] the coupled ring dot structure was realized in a ga[al]as heterostructure with a high - quality two - dimensional electron gas ( 2deg ) 34 nm below the surface . the electron density in the 2deg was @xmath17m@xmath18 and the mobility was @xmath19m@xmath20/vs at 1.7k .
fig.[fig1](a ) shows an afm image of the device defined using afm - lithography .
the 2deg below the oxide lines is depleted ( white lines ) and the 2deg regions at the side of the ring dot structure are used as in - plane gates ( _ igt , igr , igb , igd _ ) . in a subsequent step
an 8 nm thin titanium film was evaporated on top of the structure and the afm was again used to cut this top gate into individual split gates ( _ tq4,tgd , tq3,tgc , tq1,tgr , tq2 _ ) as indicated by the gray lines .
these top gates allow for a unique tunability of the electron number in and the coupling between the two subsystems as well as to the leads .
more specifically a narrow top gate stripe ( _ tgc _ ) can be used to completely isolate the ring electronically from the dot .
details about the fabrication process may be found in ref.and ref .. the measurements were performed in a dilution refrigerator with an electron temperature @xmath21mk .
the measurement setup is shown schematically in fig.[fig1](b ) .
a symmetric ac bias voltage @xmath22v was applied to the two leads of the ring at a frequency of 21hz and in the same way @xmath23v was applied to the two leads of the dot with a frequency of 14.4hz . using lock - in techniques this allows us to simultaneously detect the following three currents related to the transmission matrix of the four terminal structure ( assuming spin degeneracy ) : @xmath24\\%=t_{12}+\frac{1}{2}t_{1\leftarrow dot},\\ \frac{i_\mathrm{dot}}{v_\mathrm{dot}}&=&\frac{2 e^2 } { h}\left[t_{34}+\frac{1}{2 } ( t_{31}+t_{32})\right]\\%=t_{34}+\frac{1}{2}t_{3\leftarrow ring } , \\
\frac{i_\mathrm{cross}}{v_\mathrm{ring}}&=&\frac{2 e^2 } { h}(t_{31}-t_{32}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] here t@xmath25 is the transmission from lead @xmath26 to @xmath27 following the numbering of the gates _ tqi _ in fig .
[ fig1](a ) .
for negligible coupling between the structures the first two values become equivalent to the two terminal conductance @xmath2 of the ring and @xmath3 of the dot respectively since the transmission through the connecting channel vanishes .
a measurement of @xmath2 and @xmath3 when the central gate pinches off the channel between the structures is shown in fig.[fig1](c ) and ( d ) .
the ring conductance exhibits pronounced ab - oscillations as a function of a magnetic field @xmath28 applied perpendicular to the sample and the period @xmath29mt is in agreement with adding single flux quanta to the area enclosed by the ring with an average radius @xmath30135 nm .
the ab - oscillations persist up to @xmath31k .
this is slightly lower than in previous measurements of similar two - terminal ring structures where a phase coherence length @xmath32 of more than a micron was found at 4.2k.@xcite the conductance @xmath3 shows cb - resonances as a function of @xmath4 applied to the in - plane gate electrode _
closest to the dot . from measurements of coulomb diamonds
we find an average addition energy @xmath33ev for the dot .
our set - up allows us to simultaneously detect the resonance position in the dot and the interference pattern in the ring current , without changing the coupling or any additional gate voltages .
furthermore , the magnetic field is used to tune the interference between the phase sensitive ring and the dot which , when side coupled to one arm of the ring , will act as a fano scatterer ( see below ) . before coupling the ring and the dot coherently we assess the magnitude of the crosstalk between the structures due to the cross - coupling of the gate electrodes and direct coulomb interaction . to this end @xmath15
was set to -75mv in order to deplete the channel between the two structures .
figure[fig2](a ) shows a measurement of ab - oscillations in @xmath2 when @xmath4 is used to tune the electron number @xmath34 in the dot .
the white dotted lines show the cb - peak positions in the dot .
the unperturbed ab - oscillations in fig.[fig2 ] indicate that unlike recently reported results @xcite we are in a regime where the direct coulomb interaction between the two structures is negligibly small .
furthermore , the gate on the dot changes neither the characteristic amplitude nor the phase of ab - oscillations in the ring over a range @xmath35mv .
we find that the same is true when changing @xmath36 applied to the top gate of the dot .
the top gate electrodes _ tgr _ and _ tgd _ respectively allow us to tune the electron density in the ring or electron number in the dot over a large range without changing the coupling to source and drain strongly . however , where possible we restrict ourselves to tuning the in - plane gates , since in this case we find the structure to be more stable and the gate voltages lead to fewer charge rearrangements . in order to couple the two structures we increase @xmath15 .
figure[fig2](b ) shows the three currents @xmath0(dotted line ) , @xmath14(dashed line ) and @xmath1(solid line ) where thicker lines correspond to less negative @xmath15 . with stronger coupling
, @xmath1 increases from negligible current at @xmath37mv to a value around 4pa with clear ab - oscillations at @xmath38mv . in this regime
@xmath0 exhibits larger deviations from the perfect symmetry as a function of magnetic field @xmath28 , an effect that is expected for the transition from a two - terminal to multi - terminal system.@xcite the current @xmath14 is not significantly modified by the increase in @xmath15 except that the source - drain coupling of the dot is influenced slightly which leads to a larger current for the strongest coupling . of the currents @xmath0 ( dotted lines ) , @xmath14(dashed lines ) and @xmath1 ( solid lines ) at @xmath39mt ( top panel ) and @xmath4030 mt ( bottom panel ) .
the vertical dashed lines mark the peak positions .
curves are slightly offset at @xmath4=-25mv to correct for a parametric charge rearrangement at that gate value .
( b ) - ( d ) gray scale plots of the currents @xmath0 ( a ) , @xmath14(b ) and @xmath1(c ) as a function of @xmath28 and @xmath4 .
the white vertical lines are fits to the cb - peak positions in ( c ) .
, width=326 ] starting from this strongly coupled situation , we have optimized the amplitude of the ab - oscillations in the ring and their coupling to the cb - resonances in the dot by changing several gate voltages .
note that specifically @xmath41 and @xmath42 were increased from 0mv to 200mv in order to optimize the interconnecting channel from the ring to the dot . in the following
, more negative @xmath15 values are therefore required to close this channel .
figure[fig2](c ) shows a simultaneous measurement of @xmath0 and @xmath14 when @xmath36 is tuned over a large range .
while @xmath14 shows clear cb - oscillations the ring current depends strongly on the level alignment in the dot .
when the dot is tuned through a resonance peak with increasing @xmath36 , @xmath0 is reduced by up to a factor of two .
this is a manifestation of the fano effect .
it has been shown previously that a dot which is side - coupled to a wire is a typical fano system.@xcite here we probe the properties of such a fano scatterer by embedding it in a two terminal ring structure .
figure[fig3](a ) shows curve traces of @xmath0 and @xmath14 as a function of @xmath4 for @xmath43mt and after half an ab - period ( @xmath44mt ) .
the vertical lines mark the positions of the cb - resonances as determined from peak fits to @xmath14 with a lorentzian line shape . increasing the flux through the ring by half a flux quantum changes @xmath0 from a behavior where a dip occurs at each gate voltage before the dot resonance to a situation where a similar asymmetric dip occurs after the dot resonance .
figures[fig3](b)-(d ) show @xmath0 , @xmath14 and @xmath1 in gray - scale plots as a function of @xmath4 and @xmath28 .
the dips in @xmath0 [ bright areas in fig.[fig3](b ) ] continue to oscillate back and forth for each additional flux quantum through the ring until at @xmath45mt normal ab - oscillations are recovered .
the vertical white lines are again the peak positions determined from fits to @xmath14 shown in fig.[fig3](c ) .
the slight peak shifts as a function of magnetic field are due to the influence of the magnetic field on individual orbital levels of the dot . from the evolution of the peak amplitude and position
, we find that neighboring peaks show highly correlated behavior over large magnetic field ranges indicating spin pairing in the dot for the six peaks that are shown .
as expected @xmath1 [ fig.[fig3](d ) ] is different from zero only when @xmath14 is finite .
@xmath1 which flows through both structures oscillates around zero with the ab - period as a function of @xmath28 .
this is in contrast to @xmath0 which has a significant @xmath28-independent background .
we explain this by the fact that @xmath1 measures the difference between the two transmissions @xmath46 and @xmath47 and the @xmath48-contribution therefore cancels out if the structure geometry and the couplings are ideally symmetric . due to the three terminals the different ab - geometry for @xmath46 and @xmath47 retains a net ab - effect .
we model the coherent quantum dot in the single particle , single level approximation as a closed - end resonator consisting of a 1d wire with a barrier and a perfect reflector as shown in fig .
[ fig4](a ) .
the unitary scattering matrix of a general barrier is given by @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the reflection probability and @xmath51 are free phase parameters .
the reflection amplitude of such a dot is found from a sum over all feynman paths @xmath52 t = r+\frac{t\lambda r_\mathrm{t}\lambda t}{1-r'\lambda r_\mathrm{t}\lambda}.\ ] ] here @xmath53 describes the propagation between the barrier and the reflector and @xmath54 is the reflection amplitude at the reflector . by introducing the phase @xmath55 which an electron accumulates during a round trip in the dot ,
the total reflection amplitude becomes @xmath56 this can be rewritten as @xmath57 with @xmath58 and @xmath59 .
for this closed - end structure , the amplitude is restricted to the unit circle and resonances arise when @xmath60 , @xmath61 . .
( d ) model calculation for -2 to + 1 flux quanta passing through the ring and over a change of @xmath62 in the dot phase @xmath63 .
the parameters used were @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 and all leads to the ring are assumed to be ideal beam splitters .
( e ) section of @xmath0 for two spin paired states .
the white dashed lines are the peak positions extracted from fits to @xmath14 .
, width=326 ] the dot resonator is then side - coupled to a wire through a three terminal junction as seen in fig .
[ fig4](b ) .
the transmission and reflection amplitudes of the wire are @xmath67 where the amplitudes @xmath68 and @xmath69 describe the direct transmission from the entrance to the exit of the wire and the direct reflection at the entrance of the wire respectively . @xmath70 and @xmath71 are the amplitudes for transmission from the entrance into the dot and from the dot to the entrance respectively , and @xmath72 is the amplitude for transmission from the dot into the exit of the wire .
the side - coupled dot structure can hence be mapped onto a @xmath73 transfer matrix @xmath74 as indicated in fig .
[ fig4](b ) .
the transmission probability of the wire with the side - coupled dot can then be shown to have the fano form @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the fano parameter . for
@xmath77 @xmath78 produces fano line shapes .
this becomes clear when @xmath79 is approximated close to a resonance at energy @xmath80 , neglecting any energy dependence of @xmath81 .
it follows that @xmath82 with @xmath83 giving the link to the fano formula in eq.[eqn1 ] .
note , that the fano parameter @xmath10 in eq.[tw ] , and through it the line shape , is uniquely determined by the direct reflection phase @xmath84 of the barrier in the side - coupled dot structure , i.e. , @xmath85 produces a symmetric resonance peak ( @xmath86 ) , @xmath87 produces a symmetric dip in the transmission ( @xmath88 ) , and @xmath89 produce maximally asymmetric line shapes ( @xmath90 ) . in the following
we assume the three terminal junction to be a symmetric beam splitter which is described by the unitary scattering matrix @xcite @xmath91 using this for the coupling between the dot and the wire we get @xmath92 resulting in a vanishing constant term in the transmission probability in eq .
it follows that @xmath93 a _ fano scatterer _ is therefore characterized by the transfer matrix @xmath94 in eq.[ft ] , with the two parameters @xmath10 and @xmath79 . the ring - dot structure in the experiment
can now be modeled by placing the transfer matrix @xmath95 in one of the arms of the ring as shown in fig .
[ fig4](c ) .
the ring is attached to two ideal semi - infinite leads at the junctions 1 and 2 .
these junctions together with the transfer matrix @xmath94 partitions the ring into three sections of equal length . when an electron wave traverses each section it acquires the fermi phase @xmath96 , where @xmath97 is the fermi wave - number , as well as a magnetic phase @xmath98 ( opposite signs for clockwise and anticlockwise propagation ) where @xmath99 is the magnetic flux enclosed by the ring and @xmath100 is the magnetic flux quantum .
these phases enter the transfer matrix for each ring section @xmath101 as indicated in fig.[fig4](c ) . with the boundary conditions on the incoming amplitudes in the source and drain
leads @xmath102 and @xmath103 , one finds the two - terminal conductance from the landauer formula @xmath104 with @xmath105 and @xmath106
for comparison with the experimental data we set @xmath107 , a value which gives pronounced ab - oscillations in the ring while suppressing higher harmonics when the dot is decoupled ( r=1 ) .
figure[fig4](d ) shows the calculated conductance @xmath108 as a function of @xmath109 and the number of flux quanta penetrating the ring with @xmath110 and @xmath66 . for comparison ,
a similar section of the measured @xmath0 as a function of b and @xmath111 is shown in fig.[fig4](e ) .
very good agreement is found , indicating that our simple model quite accurately describes the experimental situation of the coupled ring - dot structure .
this agreement is robust against variations in @xmath50 but sensitive to changes in @xmath84 , since @xmath84 is linked to the fano factor @xmath10 .
we determine @xmath112 in agreement with the experimental procedure where we optimized the coupling between the ring and the dot to result in most asymmetric fano line shapes .
the sign of the asymmetric line shape in @xmath0 is periodically tuned by the flux penetrating the ring .
this behavior is qualitatively similar to recently reported results in ref . where a complex q was introduced in order to accommodate for the magnetic field dependence of the fano line shapes .
however , we have not been able to transform eq.[tw ] into a form where the magnetic flux through the ring @xmath113 enters as a phase @xmath114 in a complex @xmath10-parameter and we therefore restrict ourselves to a real @xmath10-parameter reflecting only the fano effect of one arm of the ring with the side coupled dot .
the interference properties of this fano scatterer are then probed by ab - interference in the ring .
this is different to ref . where the whole ring structure with a dot embedded in one arm is considered as a fano scatterer .
the @xmath10-parameter is indicative of the coupling between the dot and the ring and to further strengthen the agreement between model and experiment we tune @xmath115 successively more negative to reduce the coupling and thereby tune the @xmath10-parameter .
figure[fig5](a ) shows @xmath0 as a function of @xmath28 and @xmath111 for decreasing values of @xmath115 from left to right .
as the coupling is decreased @xmath0 becomes more strongly suppressed at @xmath116mt while the dips ( white areas ) at @xmath43mt seem to disappear . within our model , this can be understood assuming that a decrease in @xmath115 reduces the phase pick - up @xmath84 of the electrons traversing the interconnecting channel and therefore decreases @xmath10 from its initial value of 1 .
in addition , the reflection probability r is likely to increase .
figure[fig5](b ) shows @xmath108 for the same parameters as in fig.[fig4](a ) while varying @xmath10 from 1 to 0 .
again we find good qualitative agreement with the experiment except for very small @xmath10-values where it is difficult to determine which q matches the experimental situation best .
the last plot on the right shows @xmath108 for @xmath1170 where ab - like oscillations are found except very close to the resonance of the dot .
this transition is more complete in the experimental data , where for @xmath118mv only small dips in @xmath0 are found . in fig.[fig6](a )
traces of @xmath0 and @xmath14 as a function of @xmath4 at @xmath43mt ( solid lines ) and @xmath44mt ( dashed lines ) are plotted for @xmath119 - 68.3,-68.7,-69.1,-69.5 , and -69.9mv .
the traces have been taken across the coulomb resonance marked with arrows in fig[fig5](a ) and for each value of @xmath15 they were shifted in @xmath4 such that the peak maximum in @xmath14 ( only @xmath43mt shown ) comes to lie at @xmath120mv .
the topmost solid ( lowermost dashed ) line respectively mark an ab - maximum(minimum ) for @xmath119 - 69.9mv which is the most weakly coupled situation and corresponds to a @xmath121 . here
the dip(peak)in @xmath0 close to the resonance position are more clearly visible . the behavior in fig.[fig5](b ) is qualitatively different in the calculated @xmath108 where even for @xmath122 the dip close to resonance at @xmath43 yields a sharp transmission zero for the parameters that were chosen .
we will argue in the following that this discrepancy between model and experiment can be understood when taking into account decoherence in the dot .
in contrast to the model , the experimental quantum dot is connected to two contacts which will lead to partial phase randomization of the electron paths visiting the quantum dot.@xcite at @xmath123=0.1k for decreasing gate coupling tuned by @xmath119 - 68.3,-68.7,-69.1,-69.5 , and @xmath124mv .
the curves are measured over the peak marked with an arrow in fig.[fig5 ] and for @xmath39mt ( solid lines ) , @xmath125mt ( dashed lines ) . for each value of @xmath15
we subtract an offset in @xmath4 in order for the peak in @xmath14 to be at @xmath126mv .
( b ) @xmath127 for @xmath128 and 0 including decoherence in the dot with a decoherence rate @xmath129 .
( c ) @xmath127 with strong decoherence in the dot using @xmath130 .
( d ) @xmath0 as a function of @xmath4 and @xmath28 at @xmath123=0.65k.,width=326 ] since the observed fano resonances rely on coherent transport through the whole structure , decoherence at finite temperatures due to coupling of the structure to the environment , e.g. the source and drain leads of the dot , is important .
we have measured the temperature dependence of the fano line shapes in @xmath0 and found that at @xmath131k the ab - oscillations in the ring persist while the fano behavior is strongly suppressed .
this is in agreement with a picture where the paths that pass through the dot are most strongly affected by decoherence due to the fact that such a path is longer than the direct paths in the ring which do nt traverse the dot .
furthermore , the dot paths will be influenced by decoherence induced by the two contacts attached to it .
we follow ref . in order to include decoherence in the dot by the modification of the phase @xmath132 where @xmath133 is
the length of the path through the dot and @xmath32 is the phase coherence length .
this introduces a damping of the coherent channel passing through the dot .
the `` absorbed amplitude '' is re - injected into the incoherent channel by introducing an additional term in the two - terminal conductance @xmath134 where @xmath135 is the transmission(reflection ) probability for injection in lead @xmath26 and detection in lead @xmath27 and is given by @xmath136 with @xmath137 and @xmath138 the re - injection asserts probability conservation in the structure and hence the symmetries required by the two - terminal onsager relation .
figure[fig6](b ) shows @xmath127 for @xmath139 , @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 , @xmath143 , and @xmath144 taking into account a finite phase coherence length @xmath145 .
the solid lines are again for @xmath146 and the dashed lines for @xmath147 .
the gray solid line shows the line shape for @xmath122 in the fully coherent case for comparison .
decoherence leads , as expected , to broadening of the fano line shapes and to strong amplitude reduction , a fact which has been suggested to be used as a measure for decoherence in a quantum dot in the fano regime@xcite .
the close resemblance to the measured data at @xmath148mk [ fig.[fig6](a ) ] suggests that even at these low temperatures the contacts to the quantum dot lead to decoherence of paths entering the quantum dot from the ring , hence , a modification of the fano effect which we measure in @xmath0 .
however , the deviation from the fully coherent limit is strongest in the regime of weak coupling between the two structures close to @xmath122 .
the experimental traces show a reduction in oscillation - amplitude ( separation between solid and dashed curve ) of about 20% close to resonance , while @xmath127 exhibits a reduction which is more than twice as large .
we believe that in the real structure both the reflection probability @xmath50 and the decoherence rate increase as the coupling between the ring and the dot is decreased . for weaker coupling ,
the time an electron spends in the dot becomes larger and this means that close to the dot resonance its probability for tunneling into one of the contacts of the dot becomes larger .
we have adjusted the parameters in the model accordingly and find good agreement for @xmath149 and @xmath150 ( not shown ) .
note , that the cross - coupling of @xmath15 has the opposite effect and the coulomb peak width in @xmath14 decreases for decreasing @xmath115 .
for @xmath64 the effect of decoherence due to the dot contacts is small since we expect strong coherent coupling between the two structures .
this can be seen from the good agreement between @xmath127 and @xmath0 for this situation .
when the temperature is increased decoherence becomes important also for the @xmath64 case and the fano effect is almost completely lost at @xmath151 .
figure[fig6](c ) shows @xmath127 for @xmath149 , @xmath152 , @xmath64 and @xmath153 .
these parameters were chosen such as to resemble the data in fig.[fig6](d ) measured at @xmath151 . using the dimensions of the ring dot structure we estimate a phase coherence length @xmath154 nm at this temperature .
the decoherence of paths through the dot strongly suppresses the asymmetric line shapes , leading to an ab pattern in the conductance .
this clearly links the observed asymmetric line shapes to the interaction between discrete states formed in the dot and continuous states of the ring and further strengthens our explanation in terms of the fano effect .
the scattering model clearly reproduces all the characteristic features of the experimental data but has a few obvious limitations .
while we restrict decoherence to the dot , a more accurate model would include both thermal averaging as well as decoherence in the dot , the ring and the interconnecting arm . using
thermal averaging alone we were not able to reproduce the experimental data at finite temperature and the inclusion of decoherence in the ring and the interconnecting arm did not improve the model .
we therefore restricted ourselves to decoherence as discussed above and speculate that the additional leads on the dot are the main source for decoherence of the fano effect .
the model only treats a two - terminal geometry which neglects effects of the two contacts on the dot in terms of the symmetry of the current as a function of @xmath28 .
this means that the model also assumes that there are no net currents flowing from the dot to the ring ( @xmath155 ) . from the simultaneous measurements of @xmath1 we estimate this contribution to be about two times smaller than the dips ( peaks ) in @xmath0 for @xmath122 and
we are therefore led to believe that it has little influence on @xmath0 . however , where the current through the dot is suppressed at larger magnetic fields [ e.g. , in the lower left corner in fig.[fig3](c ) ] ab - periodic features are found in @xmath14 indicating that either the coherent coupling between the two systems also influences @xmath14 or that there is a considerable ab - modulated net current flowing from the ring leads into the dot . in a quantum dot the addition energy between two resonances is not only determined by space quantization effects but is enhanced by coulomb interactions between the electrons on the dot .
this is not included in our calculation and could explain the slightly stronger modulation as a function of gate voltage in the experimental data when comparing with the model at @xmath156k in fig.[fig4](c)-(d ) . while we think that our model accurately describes the regime where the fano effect is strong , we find that in the experimental data at @xmath156k the dips in @xmath0 are closer to the actual peak positions of the dot than in the model .
we have shown that the influence of cross - coupling from the dot is negligible in the completely decoupled system ( see also ref ) .
however for @xmath119 - 69.9 mv the channel between the two structures is not pinched off and coulomb interactions could be stronger and possibly lead to modified fano line shapes close to the resonance condition of the dot.@xcite we find that spin paired peaks involving subsequent filling of the same orbital do not only show similar behavior in @xmath14 but also lead to a similar interference pattern in @xmath0 as evident , e.g. , in fig.[fig4](b ) .
we conclude , that spin is not important for the observed interference effect and kondo correlations@xcite are therefore negligible . in conclusion
, we have demonstrated that the current through a ring with a coherently side coupled dot leads to asymmetric line shapes in the current through the ring as a function of a gate voltage which tunes the discrete dot levels .
this is indicative of the fano effect and we have shown that the symmetry of the observed fano line shapes can be tuned by applying a magnetic field .
the @xmath10-parameter was adjusted with a gate voltage tuning the coupling between the ring and the dot .
good agreement between the data and a single - channel scattering matrix model allows us to identify our structure with a fano scatterer embedded in a two - terminal ab - ring .
comparison with this model also lets us to identify the additional leads on the dot as the dominant source of decoherence for the fano effect . raising the temperature to @xmath156k the fano effect almost completely disappears while ab - interference in the ring persists to above @xmath157k .
|
transport measurements are presented on a quantum ring that is tunnel - coupled to a quantum dot .
when the dot is in the coulomb blockade regime , but strongly coupled to the open ring , fano line shapes are observed in the current through the ring , when the electron number in the dot changes by one .
the symmetry of the fano resonances is found to depend on the magnetic flux penetrating the area of the ring and on the strength of the ring dot coupling . at temperatures above t=0.65k
the fano effect disappears while the aharonov
bohm interference in the ring persists up to t=4.2k .
good agreement is found between these experimental observations and a single - channel scattering matrix model including decoherence in the dot .
|
information encoded in qubits can be used for reliable quantum communication or efficient quantum computing @xcite .
this information is encoded in a quantum state @xmath4 which in the case of a qubit can be parameterized as |(,)= |0 + e^i |1 ; [ 1 ] where @xmath5 and @xmath6 are basis vectors of the 2-dimensional space of the qubit and @xmath7 ; @xmath8 .
qubits are very fragile , that is the state of a qubit can easily be changed by the influence of the environment or a random error .
one ( very inefficient ) way to protect the quantum information encoded in a qubit is to measure it . with the help of an optimal measurement one
can estimate the state of a qubit , with an average fidelity equal to 2/3 ( see below ) . in this way a quantum information is transformed into a classical information which can be stored , copied , and processed according the laws of classical physics with arbitrarily high precision .
however , in order to utilize the full potential of quantum information processing we have to keep the information in states of quantum systems , but then we are forced to face the problem of decoherence .
recently it has been proposed that quantum information and quantum information processing can be stabilized via symmetrization @xcite . in particular , the qubit in an unknown state is entangled with a set of @xmath1 ( ancilla ) qubits in a specific reference state ( let us say @xmath5 ) so the symmetric state @xmath9 of @xmath10 qubits , |(|,0 ,0+|0,, ,0+ + |0,0 , ) , [ 2 ] is generated .
if we introduce a notation for completely symmetric states @xmath11 of @xmath10 qubits with @xmath12 of them being in the state @xmath6 and @xmath13 of them in the state @xmath5 , then the state ( [ 2 ] ) can be expressed in the simple form |(,|)= |n;0 + e^i| |n;1[3 ] where the parameters @xmath14 and @xmath15 are specified by the relations = ; [ 4 ] and @xmath16 , while @xmath17 .
we see that symmetric @xmath10 qubit state @xmath18 is isomorphic to a single qubit state .
but in this case the information is spread among @xmath10 entangled qubits - the original quantum information is `` diluted '' .
each of the qubits of the @xmath10-qubit state ( [ 3 ] ) is in the state @xmath19 .
we define the average fidelity between the single state @xmath20 and the original qubit @xmath21 as = d(;)|_j(,| ) |(;)[5 ] where @xmath22 is the invariant measure on the state space of the original qubit ( i.e. we assume no _ prior _ knowledge about the pure state @xmath21 ) . for this fidelity
we find the expression _ 0 = .
[ 5a ] we see that for @xmath23 the fidelity @xmath24 is equal to unity ( as it should , because in this case @xmath25 ) while in the limit @xmath26 we find @xmath27 .
in fact in this limit density operators of individual qubits are approximately equal to @xmath28 . in other words ,
individually the qubits of the symmetric state @xmath18 in the large @xmath10 limit do not carry any information about the original single - qubit state @xmath29 .
so how can we extract the information from the @xmath10-qubit symmetric state ( [ 3 ] ) ?
the ideal possibility would be to have have a perfect _ universal _ disentangler which would perform a unitary transformation type of disentangling transformation @xcite . while the perfect transformation is impossible , there are a number of things we can do to concentrate the information from the @xmath10-qubit state @xmath18 back into a single qubit . in principle , we have the following possibilities : * i ) * we can either optimally measure the @xmath10 qubit state and based on the information obtained prepare a single - qubit state . *
ii ) * we can design a quantum disentangler which would perform a transformation as close as possible to the ideal disentangling ( [ 7 ] ) . in this quantum scenario
we have several options - the process of disentanglement can be input - state dependent .
this means that states ( [ 3 ] ) for some values of the parameters @xmath14 and @xmath30 will be disentangled better than for other values of these parameters .
alternatively , we can construct a quantum device which disentangles all the state with the same fidelity .
* iii ) * finally , we propose a probabilistic disentangler , such that when a specific projective measurement over an ancilla is performed at the output , the desired single - qubit state is generated .
the probability of the outcome of the measurement in this case is state - dependent . in what follows
we shall investigate all these possibilities . before proceeding we note that a different type of disentangler has been considered by terno and mor @xcite - @xcite .
they considered two different operations .
the first would take the state of a bipartite quantum system and transform it into a state that is just the product of the reduced density matrixes of the two subsystems . the second , which is a generalization of the first , would again start with a state of a bipartate quantum system , and map it into a separable state which has the same reduced density matrixes as the original state .
they showed that while both of these processes are impossible in general , they can be realized for particular sets of input states .
an approximate disentangler of the first type has been considered by bandyopadhyay , et .
al . @xcite .
the disentanglers we are considering extract , to some degree of approximation , an unknown state from an entangled state formed from that state and a known state .
here we first describe a measurement scenario utilizing a set of specific projection operators
. then we present the optimal measurement - based approach to quantum disentanglement and we derive an upper bound on the fidelity of the measurement - based disentangler .
we utilize the fact that the @xmath10 qubit system prepared in the state @xmath18 is isomorphic to a single qubit .
therefore we first consider a strategy based on a a projective measurement with two projectors @xcite @xmath31 ( @xmath32 ) with |_0(,)&= & @xmath33 and @xmath34 , where the angles @xmath35 and @xmath36 are chosen randomly if no _
prior _ information about the measured @xmath10-qubit state is available .
we can use the result of the measurement to manufacture a a single - qubit state . specifically ,
if the result of the measurement is positive for @xmath37 then the single qubit is prepared in the state @xmath38 then the single qubit is prepared in the orthogonal state @xmath39 . for a particular orientation of the measurement apparatus ( i.e. the angles @xmath40 ) this measurement - based scenario gives us a single qubit prepared in the state described by the density operator ^(meas ) ( , |;,)= _
j=0 ^ 1 ||_j|^2 |_j_j| [ 9 ] after we average over all possible orientations of the measurement apparatus we obtain on average a single qubit prepared in the state ^(est ) ( , |)= |(,|)(,|)| + . [ 10 ] to find the average fidelity of this measurement - based disentangling procedure we have to evaluate the mean fidelity @xmath41 , that is the overlap between the state ( [ 10 ] ) and the original input state @xmath42 averaged over all possible orientations of the input qubit : _
1 = d (,)|^(est ) ( , |)| ( , ) .
[ 11 ] taking into account the relation ( [ 4 ] ) we perform the integration in eq.([11 ] ) and we find _ 1 = ( 1+f_n )
[ 12 ] where the function @xmath43 reads f_n= .
[ 6 ] for @xmath23 : @xmath44 which is the optimal fidelity of estimation of the state of a single qubit . from fig .
[ fig1 ] we see that the fidelity ( [ 12 ] ) is a decreasing function of @xmath10 and in the limit @xmath45 we find @xmath46 , which is equal to the fidelity of a _ random _ guess associated with a binary system such as the two projectors under consideration . in other words ,
when the original qubit is diluted into an infinite qubit state of the form ( [ 3 ] ) no relevant information can be gained from the measurement .
the estimated density operator ( [ 10 ] ) in this case is simply equal to @xmath47 , which is understandable , because as we have shown earlier in this limit the @xmath10-qubit state is approximately in the state @xmath48 , so information about the original is `` almost '' totally lost .
we now want to find an upper bound @xmath49 for the average fidelity which can be achieved by a wide class of measurement - based disentanglement procedures .
we assume that it is _ a priori _ known that our @xmath10-qubit is prepared in the symmetric state ( [ 2 ] ) with unknown parameters @xmath50 and @xmath51 associated with a single - qubit state ( [ 1 ] ) .
the integration measure on the state space of the single qubit is @xmath52 and the corresponding prior probability density distribution on this state space is constant . our strategy is to measure the input state @xmath9 along the vector @xmath53 [ see eq . ( [ 8 ] ) ] , where the angles @xmath54 and @xmath55 are chosen according to the distribution @xmath56 , which will be left unspecified for the moment . if the answer is positive , we produce the output density matrix @xmath57 , and if it is negative we produce @xmath58 , where @xmath59 with @xmath32 and @xmath60 given by eq .
( [ 8a ] ) .
we shall also leave the conditional probabilities , @xmath61 unspecified , as this allows us to consider a wide range of strategies . for a fixed @xmath53 ,
the probability of the output being @xmath57 is @xmath62 and the probability of it being @xmath58 is @xmath63 .
averaging over all vectors , @xmath64 gives us ^(out)(,| ) & = & d^[|_0| & + & |_1 ||^2_1(^,^ ) ] q(^ , ^ ) . in order to find the average fidelity of the output produced by this procedure , we compute the fidelity for a particular input state and average over the input ensemble @xmath65 where @xmath14 is a function of @xmath50 [ see eq.([4 ] ) ] .
this can be expressed as @xmath66 where @xmath67 is a normalized joint probability distribution , and @xmath68 where @xmath69 and the supremum is taken over the variables @xmath70 .
we then have that @xmath71 , \ ] ] where the supremum is now taken over @xmath72 and @xmath73 .
in order to calculate this upper bound we must find explicit expressions for @xmath74 and @xmath75 .
after performing the necessary calculations we find for @xmath49 the expression ^max= .
this fidelity for @xmath23 is equal to 2/3 while in the limit @xmath26 is equal to 1/2 .
for any other @xmath10 is larger than the fidelity @xmath41 of the measurement given by eq.([12 ] ) as discussed in our previous example .
nevertheless , as we will show later it is alway smaller than the fidelity of the universal quantum device .
in what follows we show that a quantum disentangler which preserves quantum coherences can distill the information back to a single qubit more efficiently than can the measurement - based method . as we have already said in the introduction quantum mechanics does not allow one to construct a perfect disentangler which would perform transformation ( [ 7 ] ) for an arbitrary ( unknown ) state @xmath42 diluted in the @xmath10 qubit symmetric state ( [ 3 ] ) . nevertheless , we can try to design optimal disentanglers which perform best under given constraints .
so let us assume our quantum disentangler , @xmath76 , is a quantum system with a @xmath77-dimensional hilbert space spanned by basis vectors @xmath78 ( @xmath79 ) .
the disentangler is always initially prepared in the state @xmath80 , and then it interacts with the @xmath10-qubit system in the state ( [ 3 ] ) . at the output
we want to disentangle the @xmath1 ancilla qubits from the original qubit , so we expect to have |(,|)|d_0|n-1;0_k=1^k _
j=0 ^ 1 c_j(,| ) |j|d_k .
[ 13 ] as seen from eq.([13 ] ) during the disentanglement process the entanglement between the @xmath1 ancilla qubits and the original qubit is transferred ( swapped ) into the entanglement between the original qubit and the disentangler itself . by tracing over the disentangler
we then expect to obtain the best possible disentangled qubit in the state @xmath81 .
now we impose several constraints which would specify what we mean by the optimal covariant ( universal ) disentangler : the fidelity between the output of the disentangler and the original state @xmath42 has to be invariant with respect to rotations of the original qubit , so the fidelity has to be input - state independent .
this universality of the disentangler would then guarantee that the information from the symmetric state ( [ 3 ] ) is extracted for all states equally well .
we are looking for the _ optimal _ disentangler which would disentangle the information with the highest fidelity . imposing these two conditions
we have found the unitary transformation which realizes the _ optimal covariant _ disentangler , i.e. which disentangle the qubit - state @xmath29 from the @xmath10-qubit state @xmath9 in the optimal and the @xmath29-state independent way ( see appendix ) .
this disentangler is described by the transformation : |n;0|d_0 & & |n-1;0 ; + basis vectors of the disentangler .
the amplitudes @xmath82 and @xmath83 given by the relation _
n=()^1/2 ; _ n=. [ 15 ] we can directly verify , that the fidelity @xmath84 is input - state independent and equal to @xmath85 . moreover , it can be shown that the transformation ( [ 15 ] ) is optimal , i.e. among all unitary transformations satisfying the given conditions the transformation ( [ 15 ] ) has the largest fidelity .
we see that for @xmath23 the fidelity @xmath86 , which is obvious , because the original qubit has not been entangled with ancilla qubits .
we plot @xmath87 in fig .
we see , that it is _ always _ larger than the fidelity of the disentanglement via measurement . in the limit @xmath26 even the quantum disentangler gives us a totally random outcome .
so in this limit , even optimal quantum entangler on which we impose the universality condition , is not able to extract information from the state ( [ 3 ] ) .
this is one of the main results of our paper - the optimal covariant quantum disentangler operates better than if the information is extracted ( disentangled , distilled ) from the symmetrized state ( [ 3 ] ) with the help the of optimal measurement .
this is due to the fact that @xmath88 .
one can also ask the opposite question , how can we generate out of a qubit in an unknown state @xmath29 the symmetric state of the form ( [ 3 ] ) . it can be shown that within quantum mechanics perfect universal entanglers , which would realize the inverse of the relation ( [ 7 ] ) do not exist . if one wants to create a state ( [ 3 ] ) from a qubit in an unknown state and @xmath1 ancilla qubits in the known state @xmath5 again two scenarios are possible , the measurement - based and quantum scenarios .
it is not surprising that the quantum scenario works better .
we have found the optimal universal ( covariant with respect to rotations of the input qubit ) quantum entangler given by the transformations : |0|n-1;0|e_0 & & ; + basis states of the quantum entangler , @xmath89 is its initial state and the parameters @xmath90 and @xmath83 are given by eq.([15 ] ) .
one can check that the fidelity between the output of this entangler described by the density operator @xmath91 and the ideally entangled state ( [ 3 ] ) is input - state independent ( i.e. does not depend on the parameters @xmath92 ) and is equal to @xmath93 .
this is the best possible universal ( covariant ) entangler .
the universal disentangler gives a higher fidelity than does the best measurement - based procedure , but it is not obvious that this is the best that one can do . in the case of quantum cloning ,
the universal cloners are the ones which maximize the average fidelity @xcite .
as we shall see , however , in the case of disentanglers this is no longer the case ; there are state - dependent devices which are better .
consider the general disentangler transformation @xmath94 , are states of the disentangler itself and need not be orthogonal .
they must , however , satisfy the constraints imposed by the unitarity of the above transformation .
the input state for the device is assumed to be @xmath95 , and the ideal output state , to which the actual output should be compared , is @xmath96 .
the output state is calculated by starting with the input state , using the above transformation , and then tracing over the disentangler to obtain an output density matrix , @xmath97 .
one then finds the average fidelity for this process , which we shall call @xmath98 , from @xmath99 note that we are assuming a specific ensemble of input states ; the probability of the one - qubit state @xmath100 is assumed to be constant on the bloch sphere .
our result for the average fidelity for a state - dependent device depends on our choice of input ensemble , while for a state - independent device the average fidelity is independent of this ensemble .
the calculation of the average fidelity is given in the appendix , and will not be given in detail .
we find that @xmath101 and @xmath102 .
this implies that the final state is just a product of the state of the @xmath10 particles and the entangler state , which means that the entangler states can be dropped from the problem .
therefore , the transformation which maximizes the average fidelity is just a kind of state swapping transformation .
the average fidelity itself is given by @xmath103 , where the coefficient @xmath43 is given by eq.([6 ] ) .
this average fidelity is larger than the fidelity of the optimal _ universal _ disentangler ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) . in this case , the fact that the universality condition forces us to use an additional quantum device , the disentangler , with which the qubit at the output becomes partially entangled , results in a net loss of information . as a result
the fidelity of the universal ( covariant ) entangler is smaller .
analogously , we find that quantum state - dependent entanglement can also be performed by a kind of state swapping transformation , i.e. |(,)|n;0|0 @xmath104 . nevertheless , when averaged over all values of @xmath105 we find the mean fidelity of this state - dependent entangler to be equal to @xmath43 which on average is larger than the fidelity of the state - independent entangler .
let us examine a simple quantum network which takes as an input the @xmath10-qubit state ( [ 3 ] ) .
the network is composed of a sequence of @xmath1 c - not gates @xmath106 where @xmath107 is the c - not with @xmath108 being the control bit and @xmath12 being the target bit .
this sequence of the c - not gates acts on the two vectors @xmath109 and @xmath110 as [ 20 ] p_n|n;0 & & |n-1;0|0 + p_n |n;1 & & ( |n-1;1+|n-1;0 ) |1from which it follows that the input vector ( [ 3 ] ) is transformed as |(,| ) & & ( |v_+| ( , ) + & & + |v_-|0 ) [ 21 ] where @xmath111 is the normalization constant . in eq.([21 ] ) we have introduced two orthogonal vectors of @xmath1 qubits @xmath112 .
measurement on the first @xmath1 qubits is performed in order to determine whether they are in the state @xmath113 or @xmath114 . if the result @xmath115 is obtained , then the @xmath10th qubit is in the desired state @xmath42 .
the probability of this outcome is given by p_|v_+= .
[ 23 ] this probability is input - state - dependent , and it decreases with @xmath10 . there is a difference between this probabilistic process and those considered previously , such as probabilistic cloning @xcite . those only work for set of input states which is finite .
the process considered above , however , works for a continuous , and hence infinite , set of input states .
it , in fact , works for all input states of the type we are considering .
therefore , we can conclude that the range of applicability of probabilistic devices depends on the process being considered .
we have considered a number of different methods of extracting an unknown state from an entangled state formed from that state and a known state .
measuring the state is , as expected , the least effective method . in the case of quantum devices ,
the universal device was not best one , at least if average fidelity is used as the criterion .
probabilistic quantum devices were seen to work very well for this operation in that they can be used for the entire set of input states .
this work was supported by the national science foundation under grant phy-9970507 , by the ist project equip under the contract ist-1999 - 11053 and by the crest , research team for interacting career electronics .
let us consider the optimal quantum disentangler which acts as close as possible to the ideal transformation ( [ 7 ] ) .
the disentangler maps the space spanned by the vectors @xmath116 and @xmath117 , into the space spanned by @xmath118 and @xmath119 .
this suggests that we consider a transformation of the following form @xmath120 where @xmath80 is the initial state of the disentangler which is supposed to be the same for all inputs and @xmath121 ( @xmath122 ) are some unnormalized disentangler state - vectors .
our task is to determine these vectors .
unitarity immediately implies that @xmath123 we shall now use our disentangler transformations ( a.1 ) to calculate the fidelity of the actual output to the ideal output ( [ 7 ] ) the input of the disentangler is given by eq .
( [ 3 ] ) .
if we introduce a notation @xmath124 and @xmath125 we can write the result of the transformation ( a.1 ) @xmath126 we now use this expression to find the output density matrix and trace out the disentangler itself .
we define the @xmath10-qubit output density matrix to be @xmath127 the output fidelity is given by @xmath128 where @xmath129 is given by eq .
( [ 7 ] ) .
if we denote @xmath130 and @xmath131 we can express this fidelity as @xmath132 \nonumber \\ & + & \alpha^{\ast}\beta \langle d_{3}|d_{4}\rangle ) \nonumber \\ & + & ( \alpha^{\ast})^{2}\beta^{2}\sqrt{n}\langle d_{2}| d_{3}\rangle + \alpha^{2}(\beta^{\ast})^{2}\sqrt{n } \langle d_{3}|d_{2}\rangle \}. \label{a.5 } \eqnum{a.5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] demanding that the fidelity be independent of phases of @xmath133 and @xmath134 we find that @xmath135 assuming these conditions to be satisfied the fidelity becomes @xmath136 \ } .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order for this to be independent of @xmath133 and @xmath134 , the term in brackets must be proportional to @xmath137 comparing eqs .
( a.7 ) and ( a.8 ) we find that @xmath138 combining these requirements with those imposed by unitarity we conclude that @xmath139 and @xmath140 .
this means that in order to maximize @xmath141 , we must maximize @xmath142 .
our first step in accomplishing this is to note that by combining the results of eqs .
( a.9 ) and ( a.10 ) we have that @xmath143 where @xmath144 and @xmath145 . solving for @xmath142 we find that @xmath146 which , assuming @xmath147 , is greatest when @xmath148 .
this implies that @xmath149 and that @xmath150 imposing now the conditions on inner products we find that @xmath151 we can summarize our results in the following way . let @xmath152 be a set of three orthonormal vectors and define two parameters @xmath82 and @xmath83 given by eq .
( [ 15 ] ) we then have that @xmath153 and the universal _ optimal _ disentangler transformation is given explicitly by eq .
( [ 14 ] ) . in order to find the optimal input - state dependent disentangler
we find the explicit form of the transformation ( a.1 ) such that the _ averaged _ fidelity @xmath154 ( with @xmath141 given by eq .
( a.5 ) ) is maximized . here , as usually , the integration measure is @xmath155 .
therefore after the integral over the phase @xmath51 is performed we can write the average fidelity as @xmath156\ } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] with [ a.18 ] _ 1&=&_0^ ^4 + _ 2 & = & _ 0^ ^4 + _ 3&=&_0^ ^2 ^2 after the integration over the parameter @xmath50 we find [ a.19 ] _ 1&= & + _ 2&= & + _ 3&= & from the unitarity of the disentangling transformation it follows that @xmath157 and @xmath158 .
when we introduce the notation @xmath159 where @xmath160 , and @xmath161 ; @xmath162 we can rewrite the average fidelity ( a.17 ) as & = & [ _ 1 n ( _ 1-_3 ) + _ 4(_2-_3 ) + & + & 2_3 u + _ 3(1+n ) ] .
[ a.21 ] taking into account that @xmath163 and @xmath164 we easily find that the maximum of the mean fidelity ( a.21 ) is achieved for @xmath165 and @xmath166 . in this case
we rewrite ( a.21 ) as = [ _ 1 n + _ 2 + 2 _ 3 ] .
[ a.22 ] when we substitute into eq .
( a.22 ) the explicit expression for the parameters @xmath167 given by eq . ( a.19 ) we find that the mean fidelity is equal to the function @xmath43 given by eq .
( [ 6 ] ) .
this exactly is equal to the mean fidelity of the input - state disentanglement performed via the state swapping transformation described by eq .
( [ 18a ] ) .
in fact , from our conditions @xmath166 it directly follows that @xmath168 while @xmath169 .
in addition , from @xmath165 it follows that @xmath102 , so that the optimal state - dependent disentangling transformation is indeed equal to eq .
( [ 18a ] ) , which we wanted to prove .
|
it is not possible to disentangle a qubit in an _ unknown _ state @xmath0 from a set of @xmath1 ancilla qubits prepared in a specific reference state @xmath2 .
that is , it is not possible to _ perfectly _ perform the transformation @xmath3 .
the question is then how well we can do ?
we consider a number of different methods of extracting an unknown state from an entangled state formed from that qubit and a set of ancilla qubits in an known state .
measuring the whole system is , as expected , the least effective method .
we present various quantum `` devices '' which disentangle the unknown qubit from the set of ancilla qubits .
in particular , we present the _ optimal universal _ disentangler which disentangles the unknown qubit with the fidelity which does not depend on the state of the qubit , and a probabilistic disentangler which performs the perfect disentangling transformation , but with a probability less than one . *
pacs number : 03.67.-a , 03.65.bz * 2
|
in the past decade many neutrino oscillation results have been presented by different collaborations @xcite , and a phenomenological extension of the standard model has been proposed that involves three neutrino mass states , over which the three flavors of neutrinos are distributed . despite its successful predictions , this can be considered as an extension of the standard model that does not address fundamental questions , e.g. , small masses and large mixing angles compared to quark sector , and has raised a large debate over other possible unexpected properties of neutrinos that could lead to a more complete understanding of neutrino physics @xcite . to gain a deeper understanding of neutrino phenomenology the reduction of uncertainties in baseline neutrino oscillation experiments
is mandatory . because of the interest in oscillation measurements , in recent years various neutrino - nucleus differential cross sections have been presented @xcite and
are planned in the near future @xcite .
differential cross sections are important to obtain a complete kinematical determination of neutrino - nucleus scattering and a clear understanding of neutrino - nucleus reactions is crucial for the analysis of experimental measurements . the argoneut collaboration has recently reported @xcite a measurement of the muon neutrino charged - current ( cc ) flux - averaged differential cross section on @xmath0ar in an energy range up to 50 gev .
a liquid argon detector is very interesting because it has excellent potentialities to make precise measurements of a very large class of neutrino interactions from the mev energy scale to multi - gev events @xcite .
the argoneut measurement has proven the validity of this experimental technique and , hoperfully , new data will be available in the future .
for instance , a calculation of neutrino capture cross sections for solar neutrinos that could be addressed by this new generation of detectors is presented in @xcite .
the energy region considered in the argoneut experiment , with average neutrino energy of @xmath1 gev , requires the use of a relativistic model , where not only relativistic kinematics is considered , but also nuclear dynamics and current operators are described within a relativistic framework .
the first measurement of the charged - current quasielastic ( ccqe ) flux - averaged double - differential muon neutrino cross section on @xmath2c by the miniboone collaboration @xcite has raised extensive discussions .
in particular , the experimental cross section is usually underestimated by the relativistic fermi gas model and by other more sophisticated models based on the impulse approximation @xcite , unless the nucleon axial mass @xmath3 is significantly enlarged with respect to the world average value of 1.03 gev/@xmath4 .
it is reasonable to assume that the larger axial mass obtained from the miniboone data on @xmath2c can be interpreted as an effective way to include medium effects that are not taken into account by the models ; this is another indication that a precise knowledge of lepton - nucleus cross sections , where uncertainties on nuclear effects are reduced as much as possible , is necessary .
moreover , any model aimed to describe neutrino - nucles scattering should first be tested against electron scattering data in the same kinematic region . at intermediate energy ,
quasielastic ( qe ) electron scattering calculations @xcite , which were able to successfully describe a wide number of experimental data , can provide a useful tool to study neutrino - induced processes .
there are , however , indications that the reaction can have significant contributions from effects beyond the impulse approximation ( ia ) in some energy regions where the neutrino flux has still significant strength . for instance , in the models of @xcite the contribution of multinucleon excitations to ccqe scattering has been found sizable and able to bring the theory in agreement with the experimental miniboone cross sections without increasing the value of @xmath3 .
the role of processes involving two - body currents compared to the ia models has been discussed in @xcite .
a careful evaluation of all nuclear effects and of the relevance of multinucleon emission and of some non - nucleonic contributions @xcite would be , without a doubt , useful for a deeper understanding of the reaction dynamics .
the relevance of final state interactions ( fsi ) has been clearly stated for the exclusive @xmath5 reaction , where the use of a complex optical potential ( op ) in the distorted - wave impulse approximation ( dwia ) is required @xcite .
the imaginary part of the op produces an absorption that reduces the cross section and accounts for the loss of part of the incident flux in the elastically scattered beam to the inelastic channels which are open . in the inclusive scattering only the emitted lepton is detected , the final nuclear state is not determined and all elastic and inelastic channels contribute .
thus , a different treatment of fsi is required , where all final - state channels are retained and the total flux , although redistributed among all possible channels , is conserved .
different approaches have been used to describe fsi in relativistic calculations for the inclusive qe electron- and neutrino - nucleus scattering @xcite . in the relativistic plane - wave impulse approximation ( rpwia ) , fsi
are simply neglected . in other approaches
fsi are included in dwia calculations where the final nucleon state is evaluated with real potentials , either retaining only the real part of the relativistic energy - dependent complex optical potential ( rrop ) , or using the same relativistic mean field potential considered in describing the initial nucleon state ( rmf ) .
although conserving the flux , the rrop is unsatisfactory from a theoretical point of view . on the contrary , the rmf , where the same strong energy - independent real potential is used for both bound and scattering states , fulfills the dispersion relations @xcite and also the continuity equation . in a different description of fsi relativistic green s function ( rgf )
techniques @xcite are used . in the rgf model , under suitable approximations , which are basically related to the ia , the components of the nuclear response are written in terms of the single particle optical model green s function ; its spectral representation , that is based on a biorthogonal expansion in terms of a non - hermitian optical potential @xmath6 and of its hermitian conjugate @xmath7 , can be exploited to avoid the explicit calculation of the single particle green s function and obtain the components of the hadron tensor @xcite .
calculations require matrix elements of the same type as the dwia ones of the exclusive process in @xcite , but involve eigenfunctions of both @xmath6 and @xmath7 , where the imaginary part has an opposite sign and gives in one case a loss and in the other case a gain of strength .
the rgf formalism allows us to reconstruct the flux lost into nonelastic channels in the case of the inclusive response starting from the complex optical potential which describes elastic nucleon - nucleus scattering data and to include contributions which are not included in the rmf and in other models based on the ia . moreover , with the use of the same complex optical potential , it provides a consistent treatment of fsi in the exclusive and in the inclusive scattering . in addition , because of the analyticity properties of the optical potential , it fulfills the coulomb sum rule @xcite . these different descriptions of fsi have been compared in @xcite for the inclusive qe electron scattering , in @xcite for the ccqe neutrino scattering , and in @xcite with the ccqe and nce miniboone data .
both rmf and rgf are able to describe the shape of the ccqe experimental data , only the rgf gives cross sections of the same magnitude as the experimental ones without the need to increase the value of @xmath3 @xcite .
similar results are obtained in @xcite , where the rgf results and their interpretation in comparison with the nce data from miniboone are discussed . in this paper the results of different relativistic descriptions of fsi for cc @xmath8-nucleus scattering are presented and discussed for the differential cross section averaged over the @xmath9 argoneut flux .
we are aware of the interpretative questions that may be connected to the use of models developed for the qe regime in a kinematic situation , with the @xmath9 argoneut flux up to @xmath10 gev , where other processes beyond the ia , which are not included in the models considered here , can give significant contributions .
nevertheless we believe that our calculations can give useful information about the role of nuclear effects in the analysis of @xmath11ar scattering and about the uncertainties which are related to their evaluation .
for the reaction @xmath0ar@xmath12 as a function of the muon scattering angle @xmath13 .
the data are from argoneut @xcite .
[ csteta ] , title="fig : " ] -0.2 cm for the reaction @xmath0ar@xmath12 as a function of the muon momentum @xmath14 . the data are from argoneut @xcite .
[ cspmu ] , title="fig : " ] -0.2 cm and @xmath15 on @xmath0ar calculated in rpwia .
the data are from argoneut @xcite .
[ csrpwia - area ] , title="fig : " ] + and @xmath15 on @xmath0ar calculated in rpwia .
the data are from argoneut @xcite .
[ csrpwia - area ] , title="fig : " ] -0.2 cm but in rmf .
[ csrmf - area ] , title="fig : " ] + but in rmf .
[ csrmf - area ] , title="fig : " ] -0.2
cm in all the calculations presented in this work the bound nucleon states are taken as self - consistent dirac - hartree solutions derived within a relativistic mean field approach using a lagrangian containing @xmath16 , @xmath17 , and @xmath18 mesons @xcite , with medium dependent parameterizations of the meson - nucleon vertices that can be more directly related to the underlying microscopic description of nuclear interactions @xcite . the same relativistic mean field approach has been used to calculate the bound state wave functions in @xcite , where the cross sections of the exclusive quasi - free @xmath5 and inclusive qe @xmath19 reactions have been presented and discussed for oxygen and calcium isotopic chains . in the rgf calculations
we have used three parameterizations for the relativistic op of @xmath0ar : the energy - dependent and a - dependent edad1 ( where the @xmath20 represents the energy and the @xmath21 the atomic number ) op of @xcite and the more recent democratic ( dem ) and the undemocratic ( undem ) phenomenological ops of @xcite .
we note that all these three parameterizations are global ones , since they are obtained through a fit to elastic proton - scattering data on a wide range of nuclei and , as such , they depend on the atomic number @xmath21 and are not constructed to reproduce the @xmath0ar phenomenology . in fig .
[ csteta ] the cc differential cross section @xmath22 integrated over the argoneut flux is shown as a function of the muon scattering angle @xmath13 .
all the calculations give results in reasonable agreement with the experimental shape but generally underpredict the magnitude of the experimental cross section .
we note that in the rpwia fsi are completely neglected , while in the rmf the same strong energy - independent real potential is used for bound and scattering states .
the comparison between the rgf results obtained with the edad1 , dem , and undem potentials can give an idea of how the predictions of the model are affected by uncertainties in the determination of the phenomenological op .
the differences depend on the energy and momentum transfer and are essentially due to the different imaginary part of the three potentials , which accounts for the overall effects of inelastic channels and is not univocally determined from the elastic phenomenology .
in contrast , the real term is similar for different parameterizations and gives similar results .
we observe that the dem and undem potentials give in general close results ; in fact , even if they are obtained using very different fitting procedures @xcite , they are based on the same dataset of elastic - scattering data . in constrast ,
the edad1 potential produces somewhat smaller results and larger differences in comparison with the results of the dem and undem potentials : for instance , in the peak region with @xmath23 deg , the rgf - dem and rgf - edad1 cross sections differ by about @xmath24
. the rgf cross sections are generally larger than the rpwia and the rmf ones , but they are in general significantly lower than the data , but for @xmath25 deg and @xmath26 deg . in the rgf
the imaginary part of the optical potential redistributes the flux in all the final - state channels and , in each channel , the flux lost towards other channels is compensated by the flux gained from the other channels .
the larger cross sections in the rgf arise from the translation to the inclusive strength of the overall effects of inelastic channels which are not included in the other models such as , for instance , rescattering processes of the nucleon in its way out of the nucleus , non - nucleonic @xmath27 excitations which may arise during nucleon propagation , or also some multinucleon processes .
these contributions are not included explicitly in the rgf , but they can be recovered , to some extent , by the imaginary part of the phenomenological op .
we note that in all the calculations presented in this work we have used the standard value of the axial mass @xmath28 gev
. a larger value of @xmath3 would increase the cross section and improve the agreement with data . in fig .
[ cspmu ] the cc differential cross section @xmath29 integrated over the argoneut flux is shown as a function of the muon momentum @xmath30 .
also in this case the rpwia and the rmf results are lower than the experimental data , while the rgf produces larger cross sections which are in better agreement with the data .
anyway , the first two measurements in the low energy bins of @xmath30 are underestimated by all the results by a factor of @xmath31 .
all the models which have been adopted for the present calculations are based on the ia , where the cross section is given by an incoherent sum of interactions between the incident neutrino and all the single nucleons of the nucleus .
also the rgf , which is a more complex model and , with the use of the complex op , is able to recover contributions of channels which are not included in the other models , is essentially based on the ia .
models based on ia have been successful in the description of qe exclusive and inclusive electron scattering @xcite .
moreover , the rgf is able to give a reasonable description of ccqe and nce miniboone cross sections @xcite . in the inclusive cc neutrino - nucleus scattering at energies larger than a few gevs ,
however , all these models may neglect important contributions of reaction processes which can be included in the experimental cross sections .
it is therefore not surprising that the calculated cross sections in figs .
[ csteta ] and [ cspmu ] are generally lower than the experimental data .
but in rgf - dem .
[ csrgf - area - dem ] , title="fig : " ] + but in rgf - dem .
[ csrgf - area - dem ] , title="fig : " ] -0.2
cm with the aim to give a more quantitative information we have tried to estimate the uncertainties of our calculations . the most obvious source of uncertainty is the neutrino flux : it is usually known with sufficient precision but its errors are not negligible @xcite . for energies up to @xmath32 gev the argoneut flux
is given in bins of resolution of @xmath33 or @xmath31 gev and , for each bin , we compute an averagecross section starting from five or more calculations at different energies .
it is straightforward to assume that this procedure introduces additional uncertainties in our results . in figs .
[ csrpwia - area ] and [ csrmf - area ] we show our results for the @xmath22 and @xmath29 differential cross section in rpwia and in rmf .
the bands in the figures represent these two errors added in quadrature . in the interval of @xmath13 and @xmath30 covered by the argoneut kinematics the two errors are generally small and neither the rpwia nor
the rmf cross sections can reproduce the experimental data within the error bands .
this is a reasonable result since the rpwia and rmf cross sections in each bin are stable and the uncertainties on the neutrino flux are generally small . in the case of the rgf we consider two additional sources of errors .
the rgf results presented here contain the contribution of both terms of the hadron tensor in eq .
( 25 ) of @xcite .
the calculation of the second term , which is entirely due to the imaginary part of the op , is a hard and time consuming numerical task which requires the integration over all the eigenfunctions of the continuum spectrum of the optical potential .
numerical uncertainties on this term are anyhow under control and , from many calculations in different kinematics , have been estimated at most within @xmath34 . the fact that in actual rgf calculations we have to use a phenomenological energy dependent op introduces additional complications .
the ops in @xcite have been tested for energies up to @xmath35 gev and to provide results up to @xmath36 gev we have to extend the range of validity of these parameterizations .
this has been done multiplying each term of the op by a realistic function of the energy that has been chosen to carefully reproduce the behavior of the op around @xmath33 gev .
we have checked that our results do not depend significantly on the multiplying function .
the rgf - dem @xmath22 and @xmath29 differential cross sections are shown in fig .
[ csrgf - area - dem ] , where the error bands represent all the uncertainties that we have considered added in quadrature .
similar results with similar uncertainties are obtained in the case of rgf - undem and rgf - edad1 .
the error bands for the rgf results are larger than for rpwia and rmf and , as a consequence , the upper limits of the rgf cross sections are closer to the data .
this outcome can be ascribed to the moderately large uncertainties on the cross sections in each experimental bin of neutrino energy , in particular for neutrino energies of @xmath37 gev and small energy transferred to the nucleus .
the large error bands in fig .
[ csrgf - area - dem ] do not allow us to draw any definite conclusion .
however , the results presented in this work indicate that the rgf , as well as the other models based on the ia , generally underpredict argoneut data , but they are able to reproduce the shape and the correct order of magnitude of the experimental cross section .
in this paper we have compared the predictions of different relativistic descriptions of fsi for cc neutrino - nucleus scattering in the argoneut kinematics . in the rpwia fsi
are neglected ; in the rmf they are described using the same relativistic mean field potential considered in describing the initial nucleon state ; in the rgf the full complex op , with its real and imaginary parts , is used to account for fsi .
all final - state channels are included in the rgf , the flux lost in each channel is recovered in the other channels by the imaginary part of the op making use of the dispersion relations and the total flux is conserved . the rgf gives a good description of the @xmath19 data in the qe region and it is also able to describe both ccqe and nce miniboone data . in the rgf cross sections
the contribution of reaction channels that are neglected in the other models , e.g. , rescattering processes of the nucleon in its way out of the nucleus , non - nucleonic @xmath27 excitations , which may arise during nucleon propagation , with or without real pion production , or also multinucleon processes , is translated , to some extent , into the inclusive strength by the imaginary part of the phenomenological op .
however , the role of the various reaction channels included in the phenomenological op , can not be disentangled and the enhancement of the cross section can not be attributed to a specific process . in order to clarify this point , a careful evaluation of all nuclear effects and of the relevance of multinucleon emission and of some non - nucleonic contributions , as well as a better determination of the relativistic op , which closely fulfills the dispersion relations , would reduce the theoretical uncertainties on the rgf .
our results give a clear indication that ia - based models are able to reproduce the correct order of magnitude and the shape of the argoneut data but they generally underpredict the experimental cross sections , in particular for lower values of @xmath30 and for values of @xmath13 between @xmath38 deg and @xmath39 deg .
a careful evaluation of all nuclear effects is required to recover some important contributions to the cc inclusive strenght .
in particular , a careful study of medium effects in the few - gev energy region that takes into account quasielastic , inelastic , as well as deep - inelastic processes , is highly desirable .
89ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.83.052010 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.107.241801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1140/epjc / s10052 - 013 - 2345 - 6 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.161801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.85.032007 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.86.052009 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.131801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.171803 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1674 - 1137/37/1/011001 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.191802 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.74.072003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.64.112007 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1155/2013/163897 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1155/2013/852987 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.85.083522 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.83.073006 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/1475-7516/2011/i=09/a=034 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.70.073004 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.83.012005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.161802 [ * * , ( ) ] miniboone , @noop miner@xmath8a , @noop t2k , @noop @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.87.014607 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.105.132301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2011.07.032 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.82.055501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.84.015501 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/0370 - 1573(93)90132-w [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ , , vol .
( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.80.065501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.81.045502 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.84.055502 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.83.045501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2011.11.061 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2013.03.002 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2010.12.007 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.84.033004 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.152501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1140/epjc / s10052 - 011 - 1726-y [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.79.034601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.81.064614 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.83.054616 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2011.02.043 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.48.2731 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.64.014604 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.64.064615 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.65.044601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1140/epja / i2002 - 10137 - 2 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.84.024615 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.68.048501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.74.015502 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2010.03.078 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2004.04.108 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.67.054601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2004.08.023 [ * * , ( ) ] http://th-www.if.uj.edu.pl/acta/vol37/pdf/v37p2279.pdf [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2006.05.005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.77.034606 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.80.024605 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.83.064614 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1051/epjconf/20123814004 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/0375 - 9474(91)90269-c [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.aop.2004.12.005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2005.04.007 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.107.172501 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.85.093002 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.84.113003 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2004.02.001 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' in link:\doibase 10.1142/9789812701985_0005 [ _ _ ] , ( , , ) chap . ,
link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2006.02.007 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.85.024322 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1742 - 6596/366/1/012019 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.47.297 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.80.034605 [ * * , ( ) ]
|
the analysis of the recent charged - current neutrino - nucleus scattering cross sections measured by the argoneut collaboration requires relativistic theoretical descriptions also accounting for the role of final - state interactions . in this work ,
we evaluate differential neutrino - nucleus cross sections with the relativistic green s function model , where final - state interactions are described in the inclusive scattering consistently with the exclusive scattering using a complex optical potential .
the sensitivity to the parameterization adopted for the phenomenological optical potential is discussed .
the predictions of the relativistic green s function model are compared with the results of different descriptions of final - state interactions .
|
the short - lived radioisotope ( slri ) @xmath4al was alive during the formation of the first refractory solids in the solar nebula , the ca- , al - rich inclusions ( cais ) found in primitive chondritic meteorites .
this means that at least some of the solar system s slris may have been injected into either the presolar cloud ( e.g. , boss & keiser 2012 ; boss 2012 ) or the solar nebula ( ouellette et al . 2007 , 2010 ; dauphas & chaussidon 2011 ) by a supernova or agb star shock wave . in either case ,
injection occurred as a single event that was spatially heterogeneous , which would potentially reduce the usefulness of @xmath4al as a spatially homogeneous chronometer ( dauphas & chaussidon 2011 ) for precise studies of the earliest phases of planet formation ( macpherson et al .
2012 ; cf .
krot et al .
previous models ( e.g. , boss 2011 , 2012 ) have shown how such initial spatial isotopic heterogeneity can be substantially reduced in a marginally gravitationally unstable ( mgu ) disk , as a result of the large - scale inward and outward transport and mixing of gas and particles small enough to move with the gas ( e.g. , boss et al .
2012 ) . other elements and their isotopes suggest a similarly well - mixed solar nebula ( e.g. , os : walker 2012 ; fe :
wang et al . 2013 ) .
the stable oxygen isotopes , on the other hand , appear to have been spatially heterogeneous in the solar nebula during the early phases of planet formation ; e.g. , small refractory particles from comet 81p / wild 2 have normalized @xmath5o/@xmath6o ratios that span the entire solar system range of @xmath0 6% variations ( nakashima et al . 2012 ) .
the leading explanation for generating these oxygen anomalies is uv photodissociation of co molecules at the surface of the outer solar nebula ( e.g. , podio et al .
2013 ) , where self - shielding could lead to isotopic fractionation between gas - phase and solid - phase oxygen atoms ( e.g. , lyons & young 2005 ; krot et al .
co self - shielding on the irregular , corrugated outer surface of the disk would also lead to initial spatial heterogeneity , though the process would be continuous in time , rather than a single - shot event like a supernova shock wave .
furthermore , the very existence of refractory particles in comet 81p / wild 2 ( brownlee et al . 2006 ; simon et al . 2008 ; nakamura et al .
2008 ) , which are thought to have formed close to the protosun , implies that these small particles experienced large - scale outward transport from the inner solar nebula to the comet - forming regions of the outer solar nebula .
mgu disks offer a means to accomplish this early large - scale transport ( e.g. , boss 2008 , 2011 ; boss et al .
2012 ) .
marginally gravitationally unstable disks are likely to be involved in the fu orionis outbursts experienced by young solar - type stars ( e.g. , zhu et al . 2010b ; vorobyov & basu 2010 ; martin et al .
mgu disk models ( e.g. , boss 2011 ) can easily lead to the high mass accretion rates ( @xmath7 yr@xmath8 ) needed to explain fu orionis events .
fu orionis outbursts are believed to last for about a hundred years and to occur periodically for all low mass protostars ( hartmann & kenyon 1996 ; miller et al .
mgu models are also capable of offering an alternative mechanism ( disk instability ) for gas giant planet formation ( e.g. , boss 2010 ; meru & bate 2012 ; basu & vorobyov 2012 ) .
however , the magnetorotational instability ( mri ) is likely to be involved in fu orionis outbursts as well ( zhu et al .
2009a ) , with mri operating in the ionized innermost disk layers as well as at the disk s surfaces .
zhu et al . ( 2009c , 2010a , b ) have constructed one- and two - dimensional ( axisymmetric ) models of a coupled mgu - mri mechanism , with mgu slowly leading to a build - up of mass in the innermost disk , which then triggers a rapid mri instability and an outburst .
alternatively , mri may operate in the outermost disk , partially ionized by cosmic rays , leading to a build - up of mass in the dead zone at the intermediate disk midplane , thus triggering a phase of mgu transport .
such a coupled mechanism may be crucial for achieving outbursts in t tauri disks , where the disk masses are expected to be smaller than at earlier phases of evolution .
we present here several new sets of mgu disk models that examine the time evolution of isotopic heterogeneity introduced in either the inner or outer solar nebula , by either a single - shot event or a continuous injection process , for a variety of disk and central protostar masses , including protostars with m dwarf masses .
low mass exoplanets are beginning to be discovered around an increasingly larger fraction of m dwarfs ( bonfils et al .
2013 ; dressing & charbonneau 2013 ; kopparapu 2013 ) , with a number of these being potentially habitable exoplanets , elevating the importance of understanding mixing and transport processes in m dwarf disks .
the numerical models were computed with the same three dimensional , gravitational hydrodynamics code that has been employed in previous mgu disk models ( e.g. , boss 2011 ) .
complete details about the code and its testing may be found in boss & myhill ( 1992 ) .
briefly , the code performs second - order - accurate ( in both space and time ) hydrodynamics on a spherical coordinate grid , including radiative transfer in the diffusion approximation .
a spherical harmonic ( @xmath9 ) expansion of the disk s density distribution is used to compute the self - gravity of the disk , with terms up to and including @xmath10 .
the radial grid contains 50 grid points for the 10 au disk models and 100 grid points for the 40 au disk models .
all models have 256 azimuthal grid points , and effectively 45 theta grid points , given the hemispherical symmetry of the grid .
the theta grid is compressed around the disk s midplane to provide enhanced spatial resolution , while the azimuthal grid is uniformly spaced .
the jeans length constraint is used to ensure adequate resolution .
the inner boundary absorbs infalling disk gas , which is added to the central protostar , while the outer disk boundary absorbs the momentum of outward - moving disk gas , while retaining the gas on the active grid .
the central protostar wobbles in such a manner as to preserve the center of mass of the entire system .
the time evolution of a color field is calculated ( e.g. , boss 2011 ) in order to follow the mixing and transport of isotopes carried by the disk gas or by small particles , which should move along with the disk gas .
the equation for the evolution of the color field density @xmath11 ( e.g. , boss 2011 ) is identical to the continuity equation for the disk gas density @xmath12 @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the disk gas velocity and @xmath15 is the time .
the total amount of color is conserved in the same way that the disk mass is conserved , as the hydrodynamic equations are solved in conservation law form ( e.g. , boss & myhill 1992 ) .
the initial disk density distributions are based on the approximation derived by boss ( 1993 ) for a self - gravitating disk orbiting a star with mass @xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath18,\ ] ] where @xmath19 and @xmath20 are cylindrical coordinates , @xmath21 is the gravitational constant , @xmath22 is the midplane density , @xmath23 is the surface density , @xmath24 ( cgs units ) and @xmath25 .
the initial midplane density is @xmath26 while the initial surface density is @xmath27 the parameters @xmath28 and @xmath29 and the reference radius @xmath30 are defined in table 1 for the various disk models explored in this paper .
the total amount of mass in the models does not change during the evolutions ; the initial infalling disk envelope accretes onto the disk , and no further mass is added to the system across the outer disk boundary at @xmath31 .
the outer disk surfaces are thus revealed to any potential source of uv irradiation . for the 10 au outer radius disks listed in tables 2 and 3 , the initial disk temperature profiles
( figures 1 and 2 ) are based on the boss ( 1996 ) temperature profiles , with variations in the assumed outer disk temperature @xmath32 , chosen in order to study the effect of varied minimum values of the @xmath2 stability parameter .
values of @xmath33 indicate marginally gravitationally unstable disks .
the inner disks are all highly @xmath2 stable , with @xmath34 .
for the 40 au outer radius disks listed in table 4 , the initial disk temperatures are uniform at the specified outer disk temperature @xmath32 , leading to similar initial @xmath2 values throughout the disks .
for all of the models , the temperature of the infalling envelope is 50 k. the initial color field is added to the surface of the initial disk in an azimuthal sector spanning either 45 degrees ( 10 au outer radius disks ) or 90 degrees ( 40 au outer radius disks ) in a narrow ring of width 1 au , centered at the injection radii listed in the tables .
these models are intended to represent one - time , single - shot injections of isotopic heterogeneity , such as supernova - induced rayleigh - taylor fingers carrying live @xmath4al ( e.g. , boss & keiser 2012 ) . table 4 lists both single - shot and continuous injection models , where in the latter case the color is added continuously to the same location on the disk surface throughout the evolution , crudely simulating ongoing photodissociation of co ( e.g. , lyons & young 2005 ) possibly leading to stable oxygen isotope fractionation between the gas and solid phases .
the color field in the latter case is intended to represent isotopically distinct gas or small particles resulting from the uv photochemistry .
note that in both the single - shot and continuous injection models , the total amount of color added is arbitrary ( e.g. , the color field in the injection volume is simply set equal to 1 ) , and is intended to be scaled to whatever value is appropriate for the isotope(s ) under consideration .
the color field is a massless , passive tracer that has no effect on the disk s dynamics , so the total amount of color added is irrelevant for the disk s subsequent evolution .
the models seek to follow the deviations from uniformity of the color field , not the absolute amounts of color added ; the evolution of the dispersion of the color field about its mean radial value , divided by the mean radial value at each instant of time , is the goal of these models .
observations of the dg tau disk by podio et al .
( 2013 ) have shown that dg tau itself irradiates its disk s outer layers from 10 au to 90 au with a strong uv flux , sufficient for significant uv photolysis and the formation of observable water vapor .
much higher levels of uv irradiation can occur for protoplanetary disks that form in stellar clusters containing massive stars ( e.g. , walsh et al .
2013 ) , an environment that has been suggested for our own solar system ( e.g. , dauphas & chaussidon 2011 ) in order to explain the evidence for live slris found in primitive meteorites .
the fact that molecular hydrogen constitutes the great majority of a disk s mass , yet can not be directly detected , except at the star - disk boundary region , means that estimates of disk masses are uncertain at best ( e.g. , andrews & williams 2007 ) , as they are typically based on an assumed ratio between the amount of mm - sized dust grains and the total disk mass .
isella et al .
( 2009 ) estimated that low- and intermediate - mass pre - main - sequence stars form with disk masses ranging from 0.05 to 0.4 @xmath1 .
dg tau s disk has a mass estimated to be as high as 0.1 @xmath1 ( podio et al .
recently , the mass of the tw hydra disk was revised upward to at least 0.05 @xmath1 ( bergin et al .
2013 ) . these and other observations suggest that the mgu disk masses assumed in these models may be achieved in some fraction of protoplanetary disks , and perhaps in the solar nebula as well .
in fact , miller et al . (
2011 ) detected a fu orionis outburst in the classical t tauri star lkh@xmath35 188-g4 .
disk masses are typically thought to be @xmath36 for such stars .
the fact that a fu orionis event occurred in lkh@xmath35 188-g4 shows that even the disks around class ii - type objects can experience instabilities leading to rapid mass accretion , e.g. , mgu disk phases .
we present results for a variety of protostellar and protoplanetary disk masses , varied initial minimum @xmath2 stability parameters , and varied injection radii , for disks of two different sizes .
table 2 shows the initial conditions for the models with a @xmath37 disk in orbit around a @xmath38 protostar .
the disks extend from 1 au to 10 au , as in the models by boss ( 2008 , 2011 ) .
the main difference from these previous models is that the disk mass ( @xmath37 ) is considerably lower than that of the previous models ( @xmath39 ) . as a result ,
the initial minimum @xmath2 values are considerably higher than in the previous models , ranging from 2.2 to 3.1 , compared to the previous range of 1.4 to 2.5 .
the present models are thus less gravitationally unstable initially than the disks previously considered , with the goal being to learn whether or not the previous results will change for higher values of @xmath40 .
figure 1 displays the initial midplane temperature profiles for these models .
only the outermost regions of the disks are cool enough to be gravitationally unstable , but the models show that this is sufficient to result in qualitatively similar behavior for all of the table 2 models
. figures 3 and 4 show the equatorial plane distribution of the color / gas ratio ( @xmath41 ) for model 1.0 - 2.6 - 9 .
this ratio is plotted , as it is equivalent to the @xmath4al/@xmath42al and @xmath5o/@xmath6o ratios measured by cosmochemists , i.e. , the abundance of an injected or photolysis product species , divided by that of a species that was prevalent in the pre - injection disk .
figure 3 shows that the initial disk surface injection at 9 au has resulted in the rapid transport of the color field downward to the disk s midplane , as well as inward to close to the inner disk boundary at 2 au .
the vigorous three dimensional motions of a mgu disk are responsible for this large - scale transport in just 34 yr . at this time
, the color / gas ratio is still highly heterogeneous , but figure 4 shows that only 146 yr later , the color / gas ratio has been strongly homogenized throughout the entire disk midplane .
figure 5 shows the evolution of the dispersion of the ratio of the color density to the gas density for models 1.0 - 2.6 - 9 and 1.0 - 2.6 - 2 at two times .
these models differ only in the injection radius , either 9 au or 2 au .
the dispersion plotted in figure 5 is defined to be the square root of the sum of the squares of the color field divided by the gas density , subtracted by the azimuthal average of this ratio at a given orbital radius , divided by the square of the azimuthal average at that radius , normalized by the number of azimuthal grid points , and plotted as a function of radius in the disk midplane .
figure 5 shows that the isotopic dispersion is a strong function of orbital radius and time , with the dispersion initially being relatively large ( i.e. , at 180 yr , in spite of the apparent homogeneity seen in figure 4 at the same time ) as a result of the isotopes traveling downward and radially inward and outward .
however , the dispersion decreases dramatically in the outer disks for both models by 777 yr to a value of @xmath0 1% to 2% .
in fact , the dispersion in both models 1.0 - 2.6 - 9 and 1.0 - 2.6 - 2 evolves toward essentially the same radial distribution by this time , showing that the exact location of the injection location has little effect on the long term evolution of the distribution : that is controlled solely by the evolution of the underlying mgu disk , which is identical for these two models ( i.e. , the color fields are passive tracers , and have no effect on the disk s evolution ) .
note that any small refractory grains present in the initial disk will be carried along with the disk gas , so that some of the grains that start out at 2 au will be transported to the outermost disk , in the same manner that some of the gas is transported outward .
most of the gas and dust , however , is accreted by the growing protostar .
figure 6 shows the results for three models with varied @xmath40 , i.e. , models 1.0 - 2.6 - 9 , 1.0 - 2.9 - 9 , and 1.0 - 3.1 - 9 , all after 1370 yr .
it can be seen that in spite of the variation in the initial degree of instability , the dispersions in the outermost disks all converge to similar values of @xmath0 1% to 2% .
this suggests that mgu disk evolutions are not particularly sensitive to the exact choice of the initial @xmath2 profile , a result that was also found by boss ( 2011 ) for somewhat more massive disks .
as also found by boss ( 2011 ) , the dispersions in the innermost disks are significantly higher ( @xmath0 10% to 20% ) than in the outermost disks , a direct result of the stronger mixing associated with the cooler outer disks , in spite of the longer orbital periods in the outer disks .
table 3 shows the initial conditions for the models with either @xmath43 disks around @xmath44 protostars , or @xmath45 disks around @xmath46 protostars . in either case
, the disks extend from 1 au to 10 au .
these models are of interest for exploring how conditions might vary between disks around g dwarfs and m dwarfs , with possible ramifications for the habitability of any rocky planets that form ( e.g. , raymond et al . 2007 ) around m dwarfs .
figure 2 shows the initial midplane temperature profiles for these models .
figure 7 shows the time evolution of the dispersion for model 0.1 - 1.8 - 2 , appropriate for a late m dwarf protostar . as in all the models
, it can be seen that the initially highly heterogeneous disk becomes rapidly homogenized , in this case by about 5000 yr .
note that this time scale is considerably longer than that for g dwarf disk mixing and transport processes , as a result of the longer keplerian orbital periods for lower mass , m dwarf protostars .
as in the g dwarf protostar models ( e.g. , figure 5 ) , the inner disk dispersion is higher than in the outer disk , though in these models ( with a lower initial @xmath47 ) the inner disk dispersion drops to @xmath0 5% to 10% , compared to @xmath0 1% to 2% in the outer disk .
figure 8 shows the same behavior for model 0.1 - 1.8 - 9 , which differs from the previous model shown in figure 7 only in having the injection occur at 9 au instead of 2 au . as in the g dwarf disks ,
the dispersions for both of these models evolve toward essentially identical radial distributions : the underlying mgu disk evolution determines the outcome for the dispersions .
similar results hold for the models with @xmath46 protostars , i.e. , early m dwarf disks .
we now turn to a consideration of the consequence of single - shot versus continuous injection at the surface of much larger outer radius ( 40 au ) disks than have been considered to date for g dwarf stars ; boss ( 2007 ) considered disks extending from 4 au to 20 au in radius .
table 4 shows the initial conditions for the models with a @xmath48 disk around a @xmath38 protostar , with the disks extending from 10 au to 40 au . because of the much larger inner and outer disk radii for this set of models ,
these models can be calculated for times as long as @xmath49 yr ( table 4 ) .
such times are still considerably less than the typical ages ( @xmath50 yr ) of t tauri stars , implying that in order for mgu disks to occur at such late phases , a prior phase of coupled mri - mgu evolution might be required to make the present results relevant . figures 9 and 10 display the evolution of the dispersions for models 1.0 - 1.1 - 40 - 20 and 1.0 - 1.1 - 40 - 20c , differing only in that the former model has single - shot injection while the latter model has continuous injection , intended to simulate a disk with ongoing uv photolysis and fractionation at the outer disk surface . for model 1.0 - 1.1 - 40 - 20
, it can be seen that the evolution is similar to that of the previous single - shot models : a rapid drop in the dispersion , followed by homogenization to @xmath0 1% to 2% away from the inner disk boundary .
the higher dispersions seen near the outer disk boundaries ( @xmath0 40 au ) are largely caused by the unphysical pile - up of considerable disk mass at 40 au and should be discounted . however , for the continuous injection model shown in figure 10 , it can be seen that the dispersions throughout the disk even after @xmath3 yr can be as high as @xmath0 20% , consistent with the much larger variation in stable oxygen isotope ratios , compared to slri ratios . in a calculation with finer spatial grid resolution , as well as perhaps sub - grid mixing processes , one might expect even stronger homogenization to occur , so the dispersion levels obtained from the present models should be considered to be upper bounds .
the total amount of color added during the continuous injection models is large , compared to single - shot injection models : for model 1.0 - 1.4 - 40 - 20c , for example , after 200 yr , the total amount of color injected has increased by a factor of @xmath0 90 compared to the single - shot total , and by another factor of @xmath0 60 after 27000 yr .
figures 11 and 12 compare the results for continuous injection at either 20 au or 30 au , respectively , i.e. , for models 1.0 - 1.1 - 40 - 20c and 1.0 - 1.1 - 40 - 30c . in spite of the different injection radii , figures 11 and 12
show that even at a relatively early phase ( 405 yr ) of evolution , the midplane color / gas ratios look somewhat similar ; as before , the mgu disk evolution is the same for both models , and that is the primary determinant of the long term evolution . finally , similar results as those shown in figures 9 - 12 were obtained for the other models listed in table 4 .
these models show that the main factor in determining the radial dispersion profile is whether the injection occurs in a single - shot or continuously ; in the latter case , the mgu disk does its best to homogenize the color field , but the fact that spatial heterogeneity is being continuously injected limits the degree to which this heterogeneity can be reduced .
while dust grains in the interstellar medium are overwhelmingly amorphous , crystalline silicate grains have been found in a late m dwarf ( sst - lup3 - 1 ) disk at distances ranging from inside 3 au to beyond 5 au , in both the midplane and surface layers ( mern et al .
such crystalline silicate grains are likely to have been produced by thermal annealing in the hottest regions of the disk , well inside of 1 au ( sargent et al .
2009 ) . again
, outward transport seems to be required to explain the observations , and the results for the models with a 0.1 @xmath1 protostar suggest that mgu phases in low mass m dwarf disks may be responsible for these observations . in fact , crystalline mass fractions in protoplanetary disks do not appear to correlate with stellar mass , luminosity , accretion rate , disk mass , or the disk to star ratio ( watson et al .
these results also appear to be consistent with the results of the present models , which show that mgu disk phases are equally capable of relatively rapid large - scale mixing and transport , regardless of the stellar or disk mass , or the exact value of the @xmath2 stability parameter .
these models have shown a rather robust result , namely that a phase of marginal gravitational instability in disks and stars with a variety of masses and disk temperatures can lead to relatively rapid inward and outward transport of disk gas and small grains , as required to drive the protostellar mass accretion associated with fu orionis events , as well as to explain the discovery of refractory grains in comet 81p / wild 2 .
a mgu disk phase driving a fu orionis outburst is astronomically quite likely to have occurred for our protosun , and cosmochemically convenient for explaining the relative homogeneity of @xmath4al/@xmath42al ratios derived from a supernova injection event , and the range of @xmath5o/@xmath6o ratios derived from sustained uv self - shielding at the surface of the outer solar nebula .
low - mass stars , from g dwarfs to m dwarfs , may well experience a similar phase of mgu disk mixing and transport . in this context , it is worthwhile to note that fu orionis itself , the prototype of the fu orionis outburst phenomenon , has a mass of only @xmath51 ( zhu et al .
2007 , 2009b ; beck & aspin 2012 ) , i.e. , the mass of a m dwarf , suggesting that m dwarf protoplanetary disks may experience evolutions similar to that of the solar nebula , with possible implications for the habitability of any resulting planetary system ( e.g. , raymond et al . 2007 ; bonfils et al . 2013 ; dressing & charbonneau 2013 ; kopparapu 2013 ) .
i thank jeff cuzzi for his comments , the referee for a number of suggested improvements , and sandy keiser , michael acierno , and ben pandit for their support of the cluster computing environment at dtm .
this work was partially supported by the nasa origins of solar systems program ( nnx09af62 g ) and is contributed in part to the nasa astrobiology institute ( nna09da81a ) .
some of the calculations were performed on the carnegie alpha cluster , the purchase of which was partially supported by a nsf major research instrumentation grant ( mri-9976645 ) .
1.0 & 0.019 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & 1.0 & 1.0 & 10.0 + 0.5 & 0.018 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & 1.0 & 1.0 & 10.0 + 0.1 & 0.016 & @xmath56 & @xmath57 & 1.0 & 1.0 & 10.0 + 1.0 & 0.13 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 & 4.0 & 10.0 & 40.0 + 1.0 - 2.2 - 2 & 15 & 2.2 & 2 & 2520 + 1.0 - 2.2 - 9 & 15 & 2.2 & 9 & 2520 + 1.0 - 2.6 - 2 & 20 & 2.6 & 2 & 2043 + 1.0 - 2.6 - 9 & 20 & 2.6 & 9 & 2043 + 1.0 - 2.9 - 2 & 25 & 2.9 & 2 & 1200 + 1.0 - 2.9 - 9 & 25 & 2.9 & 9 & 1400 + 1.0 - 3.1 - 2 & 30 & 3.1 & 2 & 1100 + 1.0 - 3.1 - 9 & 30 & 3.1 & 9 & 1300 + 1.0 - 1.1 - 40 - 20 & 30 & 1.1 & 20 & single - shot & 25000 + 1.0 - 1.1 - 40 - 30 & 30 & 1.1 & 30 & single - shot & 24500 + 1.0 - 1.4 - 40 - 20 & 50 & 1.4 & 20 & single - shot & 24000 + 1.0 - 1.4 - 40 - 30 & 50 & 1.4 & 30 & single - shot & 15000 + 1.0 - 1.1 - 40 - 20c & 30 & 1.1 & 20 & continuous & 19500 + 1.0 - 1.1 - 40 - 30c & 30 & 1.1 & 30 & continuous & 19800 + 1.0 - 1.4 - 40 - 20c & 50 & 1.4 & 20 & continuous & 27000 + 1.0 - 1.4 - 40 - 30c & 50 & 1.4 & 30 & continuous & 27000 +
|
analyses of primitive meteorites and cometary samples have shown that the solar nebula must have experienced a phase of large - scale outward transport of small refractory grains as well as homogenization of initially spatially heterogeneous short - lived isotopes .
the stable oxygen isotopes , however , were able to remain spatially heterogenous at the @xmath0 6% level .
one promising mechanism for achieving these disparate goals is the mixing and transport associated with a marginally gravitationally unstable ( mgu ) disk , a likely cause of fu orionis events in young low - mass stars .
several new sets of mgu models are presented that explore mixing and transport in disks with varied masses ( 0.016 to 0.13 @xmath1 ) around stars with varied masses ( 0.1 to 1 @xmath1 ) and varied initial @xmath2 stability minima ( 1.8 to 3.1 ) .
the results show that mgu disks are able to rapidly ( within @xmath3 yr ) achieve large - scale transport and homogenization of initially spatially heterogeneous distributions of disk grains or gas . in addition , the models show that while single - shot injection heterogeneity is reduced to a relatively low level ( @xmath0 1% ) , as required for early solar system chronometry , continuous injection of the sort associated with the generation of stable oxygen isotope fractionations by uv photolysis leads to a sustained , relatively high level ( @xmath0 10% ) of heterogeneity , in agreement with the oxygen isotope data .
these models support the suggestion that the protosun may have experienced at least one fu orionis - like outburst , which produced several of the signatures left behind in primitive chondrites and comets .
|
a recent idea on possible application of topological superconductors to quantum information processing has attracted both theoretical and experimental interest @xcite . according to this idea , a quantum information unit , qubit , can be formed and propagated by means of majorana mode ( see , for e.g. , ref . ) , localized at the end of a one - dimensional ( 1d ) chain hosting a topological superconductor @xcite .
recent investigations suggest several detection mechanisms of such a majorana mode @xcite such as an existence of a central peak in the tunneling current through a topological superconductor ( s)- normal metal ( n)junction and fractional period of the josephson current in s - n - s junctions .
most recently experimental systems involving 1d semiconductor wire has been shown to host such modes ; the mechanism of the appearance of such modes arise from the combination of strong soi , proximity - induced superconducting gap , chemical potential and applied zeeman field in these wires @xcite .
two majorana modes in the josephson junction , formed between two topological insulator edges or one - dimensional superconducting nanowires separated by barrier , hybridize resulting in splitting of the zero energy modes .
this splitting energy depends not only on the phase difference of the two superconductors but also on the relative direction of the spin polarization at the two side of the junction .
the oscillations of a josephson current between two such superconductors separated by insulator or metal as a function of their phase difference , with @xmath9 periodicity instead of a conventional @xmath10 periodicity due to hybridization of majorana states was predicted by kitaev @xcite for a idealized model of an 1d spinless p - wave superconductor . following this , kwon _
et al_. @xcite proposed that the similar effect can be observed between quasi-1d or 2d unconventional superconducting tunnel barrier junctions where the superconductors are separated by an insulating region , usually modeled by a delta function potential barrier .
these systems did not have soi or zeeman field ; majorana - like modes appeared in such systems from the unconventional nature of the pairing potential .
further it was realized in ref .
that a signature of the fractional josephson effect constitutes in having a halved josephson frequency , @xmath11 , in the presence of a dc voltage @xmath12 applied across the junction .
these effects have been interpreted in terms of the josephson current being carried by electrons rather than cooper pairs @xcite .
further , it was shown that a fractional josephson effect may be realized at topological insulator edge @xcite .
this prediction has later been extended to different systems @xcite .
recent activities have established that a topological insulator with proximity - induced coupling to a s - wave superconductor exhibits a superconductivity - magnetism duality @xcite , revealing the fractional periodicity not only with superconducting phase difference but also with the orientation of zeeman magnetic field . in this case
, the magnetic field on one side of the junction rotates in the plane normal to the direction of an effective magnetic field of the soi ; consequently , the majorana - mediated josephson current reverses sign after @xmath13 rotation of the magnetic field orientation and reveals an unconventional @xmath9 periodic magneto - josephson oscillation in response to variation of the magnetic field orientation in a topological insulator edge @xcite .
furthermore , a dissipationless fractional josephson effect mediated by with @xmath14 periodicity has been also predicted @xcite at the edge of a quantum spin hall insulator .
the josephson effect in consisting of topological superconducting ( s ) and normal ( n ) regions , has been reported in @xcite .
these works also reveal a signature of majorana bound states located at s - n edges , producing a fractional josephson current with @xmath9 periodicity @xcite .
these previous works in the field have pointed out the importance of the fractional josephson and the magneto - josephson effect in 1d superconducting junctions or atop the surface of a topological insulator .
however , the role of spin - orbit coupling and the external magnetic field behind these effects has not been systematically investigated in these earlier works .
such a systematic study is the main aim of the present work . to this end
, we study the josephson effect between two 1d nanowires oriented along @xmath0 with proximity induced @xmath1-wave superconducting pairing and separated by a narrow dielectric with a rashba spin - orbit interaction ( soi ) of strength @xmath2 and zeeman fields ( @xmath3 along @xmath4 and @xmath5 in the @xmath6 plane ) . a schematic representation of the proposed setup is shown in fig . [ josephson ] .
the main results of our study are as follows .
first , we develop a general method for computing the andreev bound states energy in these junctions .
such a method constitutes a generalization of the method of ref . to junctions with zeeman magnetic fields and spin - orbit coupling .
second , using this method , we obtain analytical expressions for the energy of the andreev bound states in several asymptotic cases and discuss their implication on the josephson current .
for example , we find that in the absence of the magnetic fields the energy gap between these bound states decreases with increasing rashba soi constant leading eventually to level touching while in the absence of rashba soi , they display oscillatory behavior with orientational angle of @xmath15 .
third , we present analytic expressions for the dc josephson current charting out their dependence on both @xmath5 and @xmath3 and the soi interaction strength .
fourth , we demonstrate the existence of finite spin - josephson current in these junctions in the presence of external magnetic fields and provide analytic expressions for its dependence on @xmath2 , @xmath7 and @xmath3 .
finally , we study the ac josephson effect in the presence of the soi ( for @xmath8 ) and an external radiation and show that the width of the resulting shapiro steps in such a system can be tuned by varying @xmath2 .
we discuss experiments which can test our theoretical results .
the plan of the rest of the paper is as follows . in sec .
[ sec2 ] , we describe the model and present explicit form of hamiltonian is presented .
the hybridization energy of edge states is calculated in sec .
[ sec3 ] , where several asymptotic expressions for the josephson coupling energy are obtained .
this is followed by a discussion of the dc josephson effect in sec .
[ sec4 ] . the ac josephson effect in these system and the dependence of the shapiro step on soi strength
is studied in sec .
finally we conclude in sec .
some details of our calculations are specified in the appendices .
we consider a junction of two 1d nanowires with proximity induced @xmath1-wave pairing symmetry in the presence of rashba spin - orbital interaction and external magnetic fields .
the schematic representation of such a junction is shown in fig .
[ josephson ] where the proximate superconductors are not shown for clarity .
-like dielectric potential under magnetic fields @xmath16 and @xmath5 co - planar and perpendicular to spin - orbit interaction respectively . the bulk s - wave superconductors which induces superconductivity in the wires are not shown for clarity.,height=245 ] in what follows we assume the pairing is induced by two proximate @xmath1-wave superconductors which leads to effective pairing potentials @xmath17 and @xmath18 in the two wires .
the hamiltonian for such a system reads @xmath19 where @xmath20 is hamiltonian of the nanowire in the presence of external magnetic fields and @xmath21 represents rashba soi .
the former term is given by @xmath22 \sigma_0 + h \sigma_z + b \{[\sigma_x \cos \phi_1 +
\sigma_y \sin \phi_1 ] \theta(-x ) + [ \sigma_x \cos \phi_2 + \sigma_y \sin \phi_2 ] \theta(x ) \ }
\big ) \psi_{\sigma'}(x ) \nonumber\\ & & + ( \delta_1 \theta(-x ) + \delta_2 \theta(x ) ) \psi_{\uparrow}^{\dag}(x ) \psi_{\downarrow}^{\dag}(x)+ { \rm h.c . }
\big\ } , \label{h - sc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath23 denotes the electron kinetic energy as measured from the fermi energy @xmath24 , @xmath25 is the electron annihilation operator , @xmath3 and @xmath5 are external zeeman magnetic fields in @xmath26 direction and in the @xmath6 plane respectively , @xmath27 is the heaviside step function , and @xmath28 and @xmath29 denote pauli and identity matrices respectively in spin space . note that the magnetic field @xmath5 forms an angle @xmath30 with wire which can be tuned externally . in what follows
, we choose @xmath5 in the left side of the junction to be aligned along the wire ( @xmath31 ) while in the right side it is chosen to make an angle @xmath30 with it ( @xmath32 ) . in eq .
( [ h - sc ] ) , the pairing potential @xmath18 in the right of the junction is chosen to have a phase difference @xmath33 compared to its left counterpart : @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
the potential barrier @xmath36 represents the barrier potential between two superconductors located at @xmath37 .
the hamiltonian of rashba soi can be written as @xmath38\psi_{\sigma'}(x ) , \label{rashba - o}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath2 is the strength of rashba soi which is chosen to be the same for both wires . in
what follows , we shall look for the localized subgap andreev bound states with @xmath39 for the josephson junction of two nanowires described by eq.([h ] ) .
in this section , we first obtain solution for the andreev bound states for junction described by eq .
( [ h ] ) . to do this
, it is advantageous to use a four component field operator given by @xmath40 here the third subscript of the annihilation operator ( which we shall designate henceforth as @xmath41 ) labels the right- ( @xmath42 ) and the left - moving @xmath43 ) quasiparticles respectively while the index @xmath44 denotes either right ( @xmath45 ) or left ( @xmath46 ) superconductor . in terms of the field operator given by eq .
( [ op1 ] ) , the hamiltonian ( eq . ( [ h ] ) ) can be written as @xmath47 using the pauli matrices @xmath48 in spin- and @xmath49 in particle - hole spaces . from eqs .
( [ h ] ) and ( [ h - sc ] ) , we find @xmath50 and @xmath51 . in eq.([h2 ] ) , the energy spectrum of the electrons are linearized around the positive and negative fermi momenta leading to @xmath52 , where @xmath53 is the fermi energy .
note that the hamiltonians @xmath54 acquires a magnetism - superconductivity duality @xcite in the absence of the kinetic term , implying that it becomes invariant under the transformation @xmath55 .
the existence of a magneto - josephson effect in a topological insulator is known to be a result of this duality @xcite .
we shall see that for the system we study , the magneto - josephson effect takes place even in the presence of the additional quadratic kinetic energy term of the electrons . the energy spectrum of quasi - particles in a bulk superconductor in the presence of soi and external magnetic fields and its expression for different asymptotic is calculated in appendix [ appa ] .
note that in our case , all energies are measured from the fermi energy ; thus the condition for realization of a topological superconducting phase with effective @xmath56-wave pairing is @xmath57 , @xcite .
however , the existence of such a topological phase requires strong @xmath58 or @xmath3 and so interaction
so that only the electron band of a single spin species remains below the fermi surface . in what follows
we shall focus on the other regime where the bands of both spin species are below the fermi surface and the superconductivity is still s - wave .
the bogolyubov - de gennes ( bdg ) equations for the superconductors in the right- and left parts of the barrier are written as @xmath59 where @xmath60 denotes the bdg wave function . for a barrier modeled by the delta function potential @xmath61
, they satisfy the boundary condition @xmath62 where @xmath63 and the transmission coefficient @xmath64 is expressed through @xmath65 as @xmath66 . for obtaining the energy of the andreev bound states for our system , we first note that analysis of the energy spectrum of a bulk superconductor ( see , eq .
( [ eo ] ) ) shows that the rashba soi splits the energy spectrum shifting it along the momentum axis leading to four fermi momenta at @xmath67 ( see , eqs.([e100 ] ) and ( [ k100 ] ) ) .
the contribution to the andreev bound states comes from momenta around these fermi points .
the external magnetic field splits spin - up and spin - down electrons ( see , eqs .
( [ e011 ] ) and ( [ k011 ] ) ) , and the amplitudes of the electron wavefunction are redistributed around four fermi points due to the presence of such a field .
finally , the presence of a barrier between the two superconductors leads to superposition of the right and left moving quasiparticles .
therefore , the bdg wavefunction @xmath60 can be written as a linear superposition of its right and left moving components around each fermi momentum and with two different spins . since we look for bound state solutions , the general solution of eq .
( [ sch ] ) with ( [ h2 ] ) can be written as @xmath68 % \end{displaymath } \label{wave}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath69 denotes the localization length of the bound states , and @xmath70 for @xmath71 .
henceforth , we shall rename the coefficients as @xmath72 , @xmath73 , and @xmath74 , @xmath75 for clarity . substituting the wave functions ( [ wave ] ) into the boundary conditions ( [ bc ] ) one gets eight linear homogeneous equations for @xmath76 , @xmath77 , @xmath78 , and @xmath79 with @xmath80 which can be represented in terms of a @xmath81 matrix @xmath82 and a column vector @xmath83 as @xmath84 .
the details of this procedure is charted out in appendix [ appa2 ] .
the energy of the andreev bound states can then be obtained from @xmath85 .
we note that since the momentum splitting @xmath86 vanishes in the absence of soi and magnetic field ; in this limit , either @xmath87 and @xmath88 or both @xmath78 and @xmath79 vanish .
the elements of four columns of the @xmath81 determinant , depending on @xmath89 become equal to other four column elements as @xmath90 , and the determinant @xmath82 vanishes as @xmath91 and @xmath92 .
_ andreev bound states at @xmath93 : _ in this limit , the andreev bound states are determined using @xmath94 determinant written for electron and hole pairs with opposite spins @xcite .
the boundary conditions ( [ bc ] ) for the wave function ( [ wave ] ) , written in the absence of the soi induced momentum splitting yield again eight equations for four coefficients @xmath95 and @xmath96 ; these equations are bdg equations for a s - wave superconductor with spin - dependent eigenfunctions @xmath97 and @xmath98 , where the overline of an index ( e.g. , @xmath99 ) means an opposite direction or sign .
one chooses four equations corresponding to an electron - hole pair with opposite spins .
the determinant corresponding to the matrix ( defined as @xmath100 in appendix[appa2 ] ) in the front of the coefficients @xmath76 and @xmath77 is calculated to give @xmath101 where @xmath102 \left[\frac{\eta^{\ast}_{+ , \uparrow,+}}{\eta_{+,\downarrow,- } } -\frac{\eta^{\ast}_{- , \uparrow,+}}{\eta_{-,\downarrow,-}}\right]-\\ \nonumber ( 1-d ) \left[\frac{\eta^{\ast}_{+ , \uparrow,-}}{\eta_{+,\downarrow,+ } } -\frac{\eta^{\ast}_{- , \uparrow,+}}{\eta_{-,\downarrow,-}}\right ] \left[\frac{\eta^{\ast}_{- , \uparrow,-}}{\eta_{-,\downarrow,+ } } -\frac{\eta^{\ast}_{+ , \uparrow,+}}{\eta_{+,\downarrow,-}}\right ] .
\label{energy0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] equating this determinant to zero one gets a condition to find the energy spectrum @xcite .
note that the other four equations yields the same expression with only spin being interchanged leading to @xmath103 .
it is easy to see that the condition to determine the andreev bound state energy in this limit , where @xmath82 constitutes two @xmath94 blocks , is given by equating @xmath104 to zero . in order to get the explicit expressions for the wave functions @xmath97 and @xmath98 we write eq .
( [ sch ] ) for finite @xmath58 , @xmath3 and @xmath2 as @xmath105 eqs .
( [ sch1]) .. ([sch4 ] ) allow us to calculate all possible ratios @xmath106 , @xmath107 , and @xmath108 , @xmath109 .
furthermore , we note that only the ratio @xmath110 is non - zero for @xmath111 .
we shall return to this case below .
next , we note from eqs .
( [ sch1]) .. ([sch4 ] ) that the dependencies of these equations on @xmath30 and @xmath33 are completely removed by transforming the wave function as @xmath112 in the transformed basis one has @xmath113 the different ratios that appear in the left - side of eqs.[dagup - up] ..
[up - up ] can be understood as follows .
the ratio @xmath106 corresponds to the amplitude of conventional andreev reflection channel which constitutes reflection of an electron - like quasiparticle to a hole - like quasiparticle with opposite spin on a n - s interface .
in contrast , the ratio @xmath114 which is finite only in the presence of soi and/or magnetic field , represents amplitude of andreev reflection channel where the electron - like quasiparticle incident on the interface is reflected to a hole - like quasiparticle state with the same spin orientation .
finally , the ratio @xmath115 represents a usual reflection channel of an electron - like quasiparticle on the boundary without creation of a cooper pair in a superconducting part of the junction .
since these ratios enter the expressions of @xmath116 , these also represents andreev and normal reflection processes involving electron - like and hole - like quasiparticles in the opposite ( @xmath117 ) and same ( @xmath118 ) spin sector .
we note that the ratio of wavefunctions in eq .
( [ dagup - up ] ) depend on both @xmath30 and @xmath33 while those in eqs .
( [ dagup - down ] ) and ( [ up - up ] ) depend on either @xmath33 or @xmath30 .
this suggests that the ratios ( [ dagup - up ] ) and ( [ dagup - down ] ) are responsible for the dependence of observable parameters on the order parameter phase difference @xmath33 , whereas the ratios ( [ dagup - up ] ) and ( [ up - up ] ) are responsible for the dependence on the magnetic field orientation angle @xmath30 .
the ratios @xmath119 and @xmath120 are determined from eqs .
( [ sch1])-([sch4 ] ) as @xmath121 where the upper ( lower ) sign @xmath122 ( @xmath123 ) corresponds to spin @xmath124 ( @xmath125 ) . using eq .
( [ wave - up - down ] ) , one obtains , after a few lines of algebra , the expressions for @xmath126 and @xmath127 for general @xmath5 , @xmath3 and @xmath2 as @xmath128 ^ 2 \nonumber\\ & & -4d|\delta|^2 ( e^2 + \alpha^2 k^2)^2 \sin^2 \frac{\varphi}{2}\big\ } ( |\delta|^2(e^2+\alpha^2 k^2)^2)^{-1 } , \label{f - up - down } \nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] at @xmath129 a contribution to the bound state energy comes only from expression of @xmath130 , and all other ratios vanish . by equating @xmath131 ( eq .
( [ f - up - down ] ) ) to zero and using the expressions ( [ e000 ] ) and ( [ k000 ] ) for the energy and momentum in this limit , one gets an expression for the bound state energy in consistent with kwon _
et al_. result @xcite , @xmath132 thus our formalism reproduces the earlier known result in the literature in this limit . in the absence of the magnetic fields a contribution to the bound energy due to soi comes from the _ conventional _
andreev reflection connecting electron - like and hole - like quasiparticles with opposite spins .
these can be expressed as @xmath133 where @xmath134 can be obtained using eqs .
[ f - up - down ] and [ energy0 ] . in contrast
, the main tunneling channel in the presence of the magnetic field constitutes an electron - like quasiparticle with a given spin polarization being andreev reflected to a hole - like quasiparticle state with the same spin .
the contribution to the bound state energy from this channel is @xmath135 where @xmath136 is given by @xmath137 we note that @xmath138 ( or @xmath139 ) in eq .
( [ feqss ] ) is determined by eq.([energy0 ] ) after replacing the ratio @xmath140 in @xmath141 by @xmath142 .
the expressions for @xmath114 can be obtained from eqs .
( [ sch1])-([sch4 ] ) @xmath143 where the upper(lower ) signs correspond to @xmath144 .
these ratios can be used to obtain @xmath145 as @xmath146 finally , the contribution to the bound energy from the channel given by ( [ up - up ] ) can be expressed as @xmath147 where @xmath148 a procedure , similar to the one outlined above yields @xmath149 \left[\frac{\eta_{+ , \uparrow,-}}{\eta_{+,\downarrow,- } } - \frac{\eta_{- , \uparrow,-}}{\eta_{-,\downarrow,-}}\right ] \nonumber\\ & & -(1-d ) \left[\frac{\eta_{+ , \uparrow,+}}{\eta_{+,\downarrow,+ } } -\frac{\eta_{- , \uparrow,-}}{\eta_{-,\downarrow,-}}\right ] \left[\frac{\eta_{- , \uparrow,+}}{\eta_{-,\downarrow,+ } } -\frac{\eta_{+ , \uparrow,-}}{\eta_{+,\downarrow,-}}\right ] \nonumber\\ & = & \frac{16 b^2}{m^2_-(k)}\left[\alpha^2 k^2-d(e^2 + \alpha^2 k^2 ) \sin^2\frac{\phi}{2}\right ] .
\label{fmag2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expression for @xmath150 differs from @xmath151 by replacing @xmath152 in ( [ fmag2 ] ) . by equating to zero the sum of the expressions ( [ ksy ] ) , ( [ cont1 ] ) , ( [ cont2 ] ) , and ( [ cont3 ] ) yields the andreev bound state energy in the presence of soi and magnetic fields . in what follows , we shall discuss two limiting case where a simple analytical expressions for these bound states can be obtained .
_ absence of rashba soi _ : in this case , @xmath153 and @xmath154 , the main contribution , which depends on the magnetic field orientation , yields the expression ( [ cont2 ] ) with ( [ energym ] ) for @xmath155 and @xmath156 .
although the contribution from ( [ cont1 ] ) does depend on the magnetic field , it does not depend on the field orientation @xmath30 . a few lines of algebra then leads to the equation for the energy of the andreev bound states , obtained by equating the sum of ( [ ksy ] ) , ( [ cont1 ] ) and ( [ cont2 ] ) to zero , using ( [ e011 ] ) and ( [ k011 ] ) for the energy spectrum and momentum in this limit , given by @xmath157\right\ } = 0 , \label{eq - mag - add}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the second and third terms come from ( [ cont2 ] ) and ( [ cont1 ] ) corresponding to the reflection mechanisms ( [ dagup - up ] ) and ( [ dagup - down ] ) .
if we neglect the third contribution , which can be done for @xmath158 , eq.([eq - mag - add]),can be written @xmath159 we find that eq .
( [ eq - mag ] ) leads to the following features of the andreev bound states .
first , @xmath160 decreases with increasing the magnetic field .
second , the kwon et al .
result @xcite is recovered as @xmath161 .
( [ eq - mag ] ) can be solved approximately .
we replace the energy under square root by its zero - approximation value ( [ e0 ] ) , which yields @xmath162 with @xmath163 , where @xmath164 the second term in the bracket of eq .
( [ eq - maga])depends on the magnetic field as @xmath165 for @xmath166 .
we note here that @xmath167 oscillates both with the superconducting phase difference @xmath33 and the angle orientation @xmath30 of @xmath5 with a period @xmath10 as shown in fig .
[ magnet ] .
note that all parameters in the figures presented below are dimensionless ones in the scale of @xmath168 , i.e. @xmath169 , @xmath170 , @xmath171 . at @xmath172 , when kwon et al .
@xcite result is recovered for @xmath1-wave superconducting junction and the andreev bound state energy oscillates with @xmath13 periodicity ( see , fig .
[ magnet]a ) for barrier transparency @xmath173 .
the electron - like and hole - like energy branches corresponding to @xmath174 , touch each other at maximal transmission when @xmath175 , creating a zero - energy state at the center of the brillouin zone .
the variation of @xmath58 and @xmath3 changes a character of @xmath33- and @xmath176-dependencies * of @xmath177*. note that since the gap between them vanishes at @xmath178 , it might be possible to have a @xmath9 periodic component of the josephson current in case of landau - zener transitions with a finite transmission probability between two states .
this case will be investigated somewhere else .
[ h ! ] ) , on the order parameter phase difference at @xmath179 and ( a ) @xmath180 , @xmath181 ; ( b ) @xmath182 , @xmath183 , @xmath184.,title="fig:",height=188 ] ) , on the order parameter phase difference at @xmath179 and ( a ) @xmath180 , @xmath181 ; ( b ) @xmath182 , @xmath183 , @xmath184.,title="fig:",height=188 ] _ absence of in - plane zeeman field _ :
next , we consider the andreev bound states for @xmath185 , but @xmath186 .
we find that eqs .
( [ sch1])- ( [ sch4 ] ) in this case link only @xmath187 and @xmath188 and are hence greatly simplified .
a few lines of algebra shows that the andreev bound states energy in this case can be expressed as @xmath189 ^ 2 + \nonumber \\
f_{\uparrow , \downarrow}^{\ast}(k_+ ) f_{\downarrow , \uparrow}^{\ast}(k_- ) - f_{\uparrow , \downarrow}^{\ast}(k_-)f_{\downarrow , \uparrow}^{\ast}(k_+)=0 .
\label{energyb=0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expression for @xmath190 in this limit is calculated in appendix [ appb ] and is given by eq.([apf ] ) .
the expression for @xmath191 at @xmath111 is obtained from eq.([apf ] ) by replacing @xmath192 and @xmath193 . below we will study two asymptotic solutions of eq .
( [ energyb=0 ] ) at @xmath194 , @xmath195 and @xmath196 , @xmath197 . in the former case , eq .
( [ energyb=0 ] ) with ( [ apf ] ) yields the following equation @xmath198 solution of this equation provides a simple expression for the josephson energy @xmath199 where the sign @xmath200 in the front of the expression signifies an electron and hole energies , whereas the sign @xmath201 characterizes rashba splitting of the electron and hole states .
this expression shows that @xmath202 depends nonlinearly on the soi coupling constant @xmath2 , and kwon et al .
result @xcite is recovered as @xmath91 . according to ( [ soi ] ) , @xmath203 oscillates still with @xmath13 period for @xmath204 and @xmath205 , which is presented in fig . [ solutions](a ) at @xmath206 and @xmath207 .
possible solutions for the energy spectrum according to the expression ( [ soi ] ) as a function of the order parameter phase difference at @xmath208 and @xmath175 is presented in fig.[solutions](b ) .
it shows touching of all four branches at @xmath209 .
the electron- and hole energy branches approach each other faster for non - zero soi .
the dependence of the @xmath210 energy branches on the order parameter phase difference @xmath33 at fixed transmission coefficient @xmath64 and different values of the soi strength @xmath2 , is presented in the left panel of fig .
[ e - p - dep](a ) . in fig.[e - p - dep](b ) , we present the dependence of the andreev bound state energies on @xmath64 for fixed @xmath2 .
we note that both the branches approach zero as @xmath2 or @xmath64 is varied .
_ absence of @xmath58 and @xmath2 _ : next , we consider the case @xmath211 but @xmath212 . in this case , eq . ( [ energyb=0 ] ) reduces to [ h ! ] ) as a function of the order parameter phase difference at ( a ) @xmath206 and @xmath207 , and ( b ) @xmath208 and @xmath175.,title="fig:",height=188 ] ) as a function of the order parameter phase difference at ( a ) @xmath206 and @xmath207 , and ( b ) @xmath208 and @xmath175.,title="fig:",height=188 ] [ h ! ] and different values of the soi strength , and ( b ) @xmath206 and different values of the transmission coefficient @xmath64.,title="fig:",height=226 ] and different values of the soi strength , and ( b ) @xmath206 and different values of the transmission coefficient @xmath64.,title="fig:",height=226 ] [ h ! ] at different @xmath213 .
amplitude of the energy oscillation increases with @xmath213 ; ( b ) mutual optimal values of @xmath213 and @xmath64 at which electron- and hole - energy branches are crossed , creating a zero - energy mode ; ( c ) the andreev bound state energies @xmath214 touches at particular values of @xmath215 and @xmath216 ( thin curves ) , and of @xmath215 and @xmath217 ( thick curves ) which may make the oscillation period @xmath9 in the landau - zenner sense.,title="fig:",height=170 ] at different @xmath213 .
amplitude of the energy oscillation increases with @xmath213 ; ( b ) mutual optimal values of @xmath213 and @xmath64 at which electron- and hole - energy branches are crossed , creating a zero - energy mode ; ( c ) the andreev bound state energies @xmath214 touches at particular values of @xmath215 and @xmath216 ( thin curves ) , and of @xmath215 and @xmath217 ( thick curves ) which may make the oscillation period @xmath9 in the landau - zenner sense.,title="fig:",height=170 ] at different @xmath213 .
amplitude of the energy oscillation increases with @xmath213 ; ( b ) mutual optimal values of @xmath213 and @xmath64 at which electron- and hole - energy branches are crossed , creating a zero - energy mode ; ( c ) the andreev bound state energies @xmath214 touches at particular values of @xmath215 and @xmath216 ( thin curves ) , and of @xmath215 and @xmath217 ( thick curves ) which may make the oscillation period @xmath9 in the landau - zenner sense.,title="fig:",height=170 ] @xmath218 whose solutions read @xmath219 where @xmath201 .
we note that the particle - like and the hole - like branches touch at zero energy ; in order to investigate the possible existence of a zero energy mode , which may create a @xmath220 oscillatory component of the josephson current in the landau - zenner sense , we introduce a dimensionless magnetic field @xmath221 .
it is easy to see from eq .
( [ h ] ) that the condition for the particle and the hole states to cross at a phase difference @xmath33 is given by @xmath222 which yields @xmath223\sin^2\frac{\varphi}{2}}.\ ] ] for @xmath224 , the value of the critical @xmath225 for spin - up ( @xmath226 ) and spin - down ( @xmath227 ) states are @xmath228 and @xmath229 , correspondingly .
we note here that the bands touch each other at @xmath230 but do not cross ; thus the andreev states still have @xmath231 periodic dispersion .
the variation of @xmath232 with @xmath213 , the dependence of @xmath213 on @xmath64 , the touching of the @xmath233 and @xmath234 energy branches at @xmath215 and @xmath216 , and that between @xmath235 and @xmath236 energy branches at d=0.5 and @xmath217 are plotted in fig .
[ crossing ] . in fig.[crossing](a ) , where the dependence of the spin - up particle energy branch on @xmath33 at different @xmath213 is presented , we find that the amplitude of the energy oscillation increases with @xmath213 , and additionally , the character of dependence around @xmath237 is changed . in fig .
[ crossing](b ) we show the mutual optimal values of @xmath213 and @xmath64 at which electron - like and hole - like energy branches touche each other .
finally , the touching of the two branches @xmath238 and @xmath239 for @xmath215 and @xmath216 is presented in fig .
[ crossing](c ) . as it was mentioned above
, these feature might be responsible for a @xmath240 periodicity in case of landau - zener transitions with a finite transmission probability between two states .
the contribution of the andreev bound state to the josephson current can be calculated using to the expression @xmath241 where @xmath242 signifies all states which give a contribution to the current , and @xmath243 is the fermi occupation number corresponding to the @xmath242-th states .
we note that since only the andreev bound states depend explicitly on the phase difference @xmath33 , their expression can be used to determine the dc josephson current using eq .
( [ current ] ) . in the absence of soi
a contribution to the total equilibrium current gives electron and hole states , each of which is split into two levels due to zeeman effect @xmath244 where the expression for @xmath177 is given by eq .
( [ eq - maga ] ) , and @xmath245 \label{des}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath246 the current - phase relation at magnetic field @xmath182 calculated by using expressions ( [ currentt ] ) , ( [ des ] ) and ( [ cph ] ) is presented in fig . [ 44 ] .
we note , that changes in @xmath3 does not make an essential effect at @xmath247 .
next , we consider the spin - josephson current which is generated as response to rotation of the magnetic field @xmath248 in @xmath249 plane@xcite . as
shown in ref . , the spin current can be defined as a derivative of the tunneling energy with respect to the magnetic field orientation @xmath30 and is given by @xmath250 according to the formulas ( [ currentt])-([cph]),height=188 ] , @xmath182 , @xmath251 , @xmath252 and two values of magnetic filed @xmath183 ( curve 1 ) and @xmath253 ( curve 2 ) . calculations are done according to the formulas ( [ j - mag ] ) , ( [ j - mag2 ] ) and ( [ eq - maga]).,height=188 ] where @xmath254 with @xmath255 for @xmath256 and @xmath257 for @xmath258 . as it is seen from formulas ( [ des ] ) and ( [ j - mag2 ] ) , the product @xmath259 increases with @xmath58 at @xmath166 as @xmath260 . instead in the opposite limit when @xmath261 this product decreases with increasing @xmath3 as @xmath262 . on the other hand , in the high temperature limit , when @xmath263 , one can expand @xmath264 function for small argument @xmath265 as @xmath266 . therefore , the amplitude of the supercurrent @xmath267 , given by eq.([des ] ) , and of the spin current @xmath268 , given by eq.([j - mag2 ] ) , will depend on the magnetic field exactly in the same form as described above for two limiting cases .
the change of @xmath269direction can rotate the direction of spin current .
spin current as a function of magnetic field orientation at two values of magnetic filed @xmath183 and @xmath253 is shown in fig . [ 47 ] .
calculations are done according to the formulas ( [ j - mag ] ) , ( [ j - mag2 ] ) and ( [ eq - maga ] ) .
the josephson current in other limiting case when @xmath180 and @xmath195 is calculated by replacing @xmath177 with @xmath270 given by ( [ soi ] ) in the expression ( [ currentt ] ) @xmath271 \sqrt{\left(1-d \sin^2\frac{\varphi}{2}\right)\left[1-s\frac{4v_f\alpha}{(v_f+s\alpha)^2}d\sin^2\frac{\varphi}{2}\right ] } } \tanh\left(\frac{e_s^{soi}}{2k_bt}\right).\ ] ] the corresponding plots demonstrated a strong variation of current - phase relation with parameter of spin - orbital coupling @xmath2 are presented in fig . [
the figure demonstrates a crucial breaking of the sinusoidal current - phase relation with increase in spin - orbital coupling .
it shows a singular behavior at small @xmath33 . at @xmath215 ( formula ( 49 ) ) .
numbers show the values of parameter spin - orbital coupling.,height=226 ]
in this section , we compute the ac josephson effect for the tunnel junctions mentioned above .
if there is the voltage in josephson junction @xmath272 , then from josephson relation @xmath273 we get @xmath274 , \label{phaseeq1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we shall now use this relation to obtain the shapiro step width for @xmath180 and demonstrate that the step - width depends on the strength of the spin - orbit coupling . to do this
we first consider the case @xmath251 for which @xmath275 $ ] is given at @xmath276 by @xmath277 substituting eq .
( [ phaseeq1 ] ) into eq .
( [ iexp ] ) , one gets @xmath278 using the identity @xmath279 where @xmath280 means imaginary part , @xmath242 is an integer and @xmath281 denotes bessel function of the first kind , one gets @xmath282/2 } } \label{ieq3}\ ] ] here @xmath283 means the real part .
the shapiro steps thus occur when @xmath284 for integer @xmath285 ; at these values of the applied radiation frequency , the ac component of the supercurrent vanishes leading to an extra contribution to the dc current in the circuit .
the magnitude of the extra dc current from @xmath286 can be read off from eq .
( [ ieq3 ] ) as @xmath287/2 } } \label{idc1}\ ] ] from eq .
( [ idc1 ] ) , we find that both the shapiro step width and the position of maxima / minima of @xmath288 depends on @xmath64 .
let us assume that the maxima and minima occur at @xmath289 .
note that @xmath290 can be obtained from the solution of @xmath291 and equals @xmath292 for @xmath293 . in terms of @xmath294 ,
one obtains the step width as @xmath295/2 } } \label{sstep1}\ ] ] which clearly shows the @xmath64 dependence of the step - width .
one can now carry out a similar analysis for the case where @xmath180 and @xmath296 ( eq . ( [ soi ] ) ) .
starting from eq.([current ] ) , the ac josephson current at @xmath276 can be obtained as @xmath297^{3/2}\left[1-d ( 1-\cos \varphi(t))/2\right]^{1/2 } } \label{acjos1}\ ] ] where @xmath298 and @xmath299 .
similar straightforward algebra , as carried out earlier in this section , leads to steps at @xmath300 with @xmath301^{1/2 } } \sum_{s=\pm } \frac{(1-\eta_s)}{\left[1-\eta_s d ( 1-j_{n_0}(\omega ) \cos \varphi_0)/2\right]^{3/2 } } \label{dcjos1}\ ] ] as before , the minimum and maximum of the dc component of the occurs at @xmath302 which can be obtained as the solution of @xmath303 .
the step width can thus be expressed in terms of @xmath304 as @xmath305^{1/2 } } \\
\sum_{s=\pm } \frac{(1-\eta_s)}{\left[1-\eta_s d ( 1-j_{n_0}(\omega ) \cos \varphi_0^{n_0 \alpha})/2\right]^{3/2}}\label{swidthso}\ ] ] thus we find the step width depends on the magnitude of the spin - orbit coupling . indeed ,
[ plots - width](a ) demonstrates this effect of transparency and spin - orbital coupling on the @xmath33-dependence of the shapiro step width according to formula ( [ swidthso ] ) .
we also note that for @xmath293 , the maxima and minima of the dc current occur for @xmath306 and eq .
( [ swidthso ] ) simplifies to yield @xmath307 for small @xmath308 , it is easy to see by expanding @xmath309 in power of @xmath310 , that @xmath311 which demonstrates the dependence of step width on the so coupling @xmath2 .
comparison of these three plots according to eqs .
( [ swidthso ] ) , ( [ swidthdll1 ] ) and ( [ swidthdll2 ] ) is presented in fig.[plots - width](b ) . as we can see , the results of approximations ( [ swidthdll1 ] ) and ( [ swidthdll2 ] ) demonstrate more sharper increasing of shapiro step width with @xmath2 in compare with formula ( [ swidthso ] ) .
it s clear that the difference disappears in the limit @xmath312 .
the obtained dependence of the ss width on the spin - orbit coupling may be used for the experimental estimation of its value .
-dependence of the shapiro step width according to the formula ( [ swidthso ] ) ; ( b ) demonstration of @xmath2-dependence of shapiro step width in different approximations according to the formulas ( [ swidthso ] ) , ( [ swidthdll1 ] ) and ( [ swidthdll2]).,title="fig:",height=188 ] -dependence of the shapiro step width according to the formula ( [ swidthso ] ) ; ( b ) demonstration of @xmath2-dependence of shapiro step width in different approximations according to the formulas ( [ swidthso ] ) , ( [ swidthdll1 ] ) and ( [ swidthdll2]).,title="fig:",height=188 ] , @xmath206 without radiation ( curve 1 ) and under external radiation ( curve 2),height=226 ] to investigate the effect of soi on the amplitude dependence of shapiro step width , we have calculated the i - v curves for the junction under external radiation using equation ( [ acjos1 ] ) .
this result is presented in fig .
[ iv_curve ] , where we show the i - v curve of the junction at @xmath215 , @xmath206 under external electromagnetic radiation with frequency @xmath313 and amplitude @xmath314 . in this figure
we include for comparison the i - v characteristics without radiation also .
the i - v curve demonstrates the main shapiro step at @xmath315 and its harmonics .
[ amp_dep](a ) shows the amplitude dependence of shapiro step width in case @xmath316 ( line 1 ) and @xmath206 ( line 2 ) under external radiation with frequency @xmath313 .
calculation is provided for value of transparency @xmath215 .
we see that the value of the soi parameter has a noticeable effect on the shapiro step width and its dependence on amplitude of the external radiation .
these results of i - v characteristics simulations coincide qualitatively with the conclusion followed from fig .
[ plots - width ] .
we see that in case with @xmath316 the width of shapiro step is larger than case @xmath206 .
the similar effect can be seen in amplitude dependence of critical current @xmath317 , which is shown in fig.[amp_dep](b ) .
dependence of @xmath317 for @xmath215 and @xmath64dependence of @xmath317 for @xmath318 at @xmath313 , @xmath314.,height=226 ] the transparency coefficient @xmath64 also effects the critical current value . to distinguish and clarify the effect of soi we have calculated the @xmath2 and @xmath64dependence of @xmath317 , which is demonstrated in figures [ alpha_d - dep ] ( a ) and ( b ) .
these results might be used for the comparison with future experimental results .
in this paper we study the josephson current between 1d superconducting nanowires separated by an insulating barrier in the presence of rashba soi and the magnetic fields @xmath5 and @xmath3 .
the presence of the soi and zeeman magnetic fields leads to four distinct fermi points in each bulk superconductor .
therefore , the study of josephson effect in these junctions requires construction of an incident quasiparticle wave function which is in a linear superposition state of plane waves around each fermi points . in our study , we have developed a theoretical method to study josephson effect in such systems ; our work thus constitutes a generalization of analysis of ref . to systems with soi and zeeman fields .
we have provided analytical results for the andreev bound states in several asymptotic limits from our analysis , demonstrated the presence of spin - josephson current in these junctions , and studied the dependence of shapiro steps on soi interaction strength @xmath2 in the presence of external radiation .
moreover , we have demonstrated the existence of magneto - josephson effect in these systems .
we note that although the existence of the magneto - josephson effect in a topological superconductor has been predicted recently @xcite , the question of whether this effect is observable in superconducting junctions with quadratic electronic dispersion and the absence of soi was not addressed before .
we show in the paper the magneto - josephson effect takes place even in the absence of soi .
experimental verification of our work would require experiments conducted on josephson junctions in 1d nanowires analogous to ones studied in ref . .
we predict that the variation of the angle @xmath30 of the in - plane magnetic field @xmath5 would lead to a spin - josephson current as shown in fig .
furthermore , ac josephson effect measurement in these junction , analogous to those done in ref . ,
should reveal a quadratic dependence of the shapiro step - width as a function of @xmath2 for small @xmath319 as shown in fig .
[ alpha_d - dep ] .
our work allows for several possible future direction .
first , a numerical solution of the condition @xmath320 yielding andreev bound state energies in the regime where @xmath321 may lead to a better understanding of the interplay between these parameters to shape the characteristics of the bound state energies .
second , the formalism that we develop here may be extended to regime of strong @xmath2 where the presence of majorana bound states shapes the characteristics of the josephson current .
third , our formalism may be applied to cases where the superconducting pair - potential is unconventional ( for example p - wave ) ; indeed , interplay of such unconventional pair - potentials and so coupling may lead to additional interesting characteristics in the josepshon current .
we intend to explore these issues in future work . in conclusion ,
we have studied josephson effect in a unction between two 1d nanowires in the presence of soi and zeeman fields .
we have analyzed the josephson current in these junctions and provided analytical expressions of the andreev bound states in several limiting cases .
we have also demonstrated the presence of magneto - josephson effect in these junctions and studied the shapiro step width in ac josephson effect on the soi strength .
our theoretical predictions are shown to be verifiable by straightforward experiments on these systems .
the authors thank v. osipov for discussion of this paper and support . the reported study was funded partially by azerbaijan - jinr collaboration , the science development foundation under the president of the republic azerbaijan - grant no eif - ketpl-2 - 2015 - 1(25)-56/01/1 , the rfbr according to the research projects 165245011@xmath322india , 155161011@xmath322egypt , 152901217 and dst - rfbr grant .
the expression @xmath323 for the energy spectrum is written @xmath324 where @xmath325 , @xmath326 , @xmath327 , and @xmath328 .
calculation of this determinant yields the energy spectrum of a `` bulk '' @xmath329 superconductor @xmath330 this expression contains a linear in energy term , which is a result of an alignment of @xmath16 and the effective magnetic field of the soi @xmath331 .
we consider different limiting cases below . *
* the case of * @xmath332 .
the energy spectrum looks @xmath333 the energy levels of bdg quasi - particles lie in the gap , symmetrical to the fermi level , with momentum @xmath334 * * the case of * @xmath172 , but @xmath197 and @xmath195 .
the energy spectrum ( [ eo ] ) in this limiting case is factorized @xmath335\left[(e - h)^2+(v_f+\alpha)^2k^2-|\delta|^2\right]=0 . \label{e100}\ ] ] one gets for the quasi - particles energy @xmath336 where @xmath163 .
the momenta is expressed as @xmath337 soi and/or magnetic field @xmath3 split both electron and hole levels due to rashba momentum - shifting and/or zeeman effect .
the fermi points around @xmath338 and @xmath339 are split also due to these effects . *
* the limit of * @xmath153 , and @xmath340 , @xmath197 . expression ( [ eo ] ) under these conditions reads @xmath341\left[\left(e-\sqrt{b^2+h^2}\right)^2+v_f^2k^2-|\delta|^2\right]=0,\ ] ] yielding the following expression for the energy spectrum @xmath342 the momenta around the fermi points @xmath338 and @xmath339 split also @xmath343 the expressions for the energy and momentum in the limits of @xmath153 , @xmath111 but @xmath197 or of @xmath153 , @xmath194 but @xmath344 are easily obtained from ( [ e011 ] ) and ( [ k011 ] ) .
note that a topological superconducting gapped phase is realized when @xmath345 in consistent with ref.@xcite .
in this section , we chart out the expression for @xmath82 . substituting the wave functions ( [ wave ] ) into the boundary conditions ( [ bc ] )
one gets eight linear homogeneous equations for @xmath76 , @xmath77 , @xmath78 , and @xmath79 with @xmath80 as explained in the main text .
we can represent these equations in terms of a @xmath346 matrix @xmath82 and a column vector @xmath347 as @xmath84 .
the energy of the andreev bound states can then be obtained from @xmath348 .
the expression for the matrix @xmath82 , obtained from some straightforward algebra , is given by @xmath349 where @xmath350 and @xmath351 takes values @xmath352 .
we note that it is difficult to obtain analytical expression of @xmath353 for general values of @xmath58 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
however , the physical content of the several terms in this determinant can be understood as follows .
we define the minors of the selected blocks of @xmath82 as @xmath354 , @xmath355 , @xmath356 , @xmath357 .
furthermore we define the @xmath358 matrices @xmath359 the determinants of these matrices are denoted by @xmath360 and @xmath361 .
similarly one can also construct expressions for @xmath362 and @xmath363 . note that all these blocks are interpreted to correspond to a definitive physical process as explained in the main text .
all of these determinants enter the expressions of the andreev bound states as discussed in sec.[sec3 ] of the main text .
in this section we look into the expression of andreev bound states for @xmath185 . equations ( [ sch1])-([sch4 ] ) are strongly simplified in this link providing only a link between @xmath187 and @xmath188 @xmath364 then , one gets for @xmath126 according to eq .
( [ energy0 ] ) @xmath365 \sin^2\frac{\varphi}{2}\right\}. \label{apf}\ ] ] the expression for @xmath366 differs from that for @xmath190 by replacing @xmath367 and @xmath193 in eq .
( [ apf ] ) .
the tunneling energy in this case receives its contribution from the expression @xmath368 ^ 2 + f_{\uparrow , \downarrow}^{\ast}(k_+ ) f_{\downarrow , \uparrow}^{\ast}(k_- ) - f_{\uparrow , \downarrow}^{\ast}(k_- ) f_{\downarrow , \uparrow}^{\ast}(k_+)=0 \label{apfeq}\ ] ] with energy spectrum obtained from eq .
( [ sch1b0 ] ) @xmath369 and from eq .
( [ sch2b0 ] ) @xmath370 this expression has been used to analyze eq .
( [ energyb=0 ] ) of the main text .
kitaev , annals phys . *
303 * , 2 ( 2003 ) . c. nayak , s. simon , a. stern , m. freedman , and s. das sarma , rev .
phys . * 80 * , 1083 ( 2008 ) .
j. alicea , rep .
prog . phys . * 75 * , 076501 ( 2012 ) .
v. mourik , k. zuo , s. m. frolov , s. r. plissard , e. p. a. m. bakkers , and l. p. kouwenhoven , science * 336 * , 1003 ( 2012 ) .
k. sengupta , i. zutic , h.j .
kwon , v.m .
yakovenko , s das sarma physical review b * 63 ( 14 ) * , 144531 ( 2001 ) .
kwon , k. sengupta , and v. m. yakovenko , eur .
j. b * 37 * , 349 ( 2004 ) .
a. das , y. ronen , y. most , y. oreg , m. heiblum , and h. shtrikman , nature phys .
* 8 * , 887 ( 2012 ) .
l. p. rokhinson , x. liu , and j. k. furdyna , nature phys .
* 8 * , 795 ( 2012 )
. m. t. deng , c. l. yu , g. y. huang , m. larsson , p. caroff , and h. q. xu , nano lett . * 12 * , 6414 ( 2012 ) .
h. o. h. churchill , v. fatemi , k. grove - rasmussen , m. t. deng , p. caroff , and c. m. markus , phys .
b * 87 * , 241401 ( r ) ( 2013 ) .
a. d. k. finck , d. j. van harlingen , p. k. mohseni , k. jung , and x. li , phys .
. lett . * 110 * , 126406 ( 2013 ) .
r. m. lutchyn , j. d. sau , and s. das sarma , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 077001 ( 2010 ) .
y. oreg , g. refael , and f. von oppen , phys .
. lett . * 105 * , 177002 ( 2010 ) .
a. kitaev , phys .
usp . * 44 * , 131 ( 2001 ) .
j. nilsson , a. r. akhmerov , and c. w. j. beenakker , phys .
* 101 * , 120403 ( 2008 ) .
l. fu and c. l. kane , phys .
lett . * 100 * , 096407 ( 2008 ) .
l. fu and c. l. kane , phys .
b * 79 * , 161408 ( 2009 ) .
d. m. badiane , m. houzet , and j. s. meyer , phys .
107 * , 177002 ( 2011 ) .
l. jiang , d. pekker , j. alicea , g. refael , y. oreg , and f. von oppen , phys .
lett . * 107 * , 236401 ( 2011 ) .
p. san - jose , e. prada , and r. aguado , phys .
* 108 * , 257001 ( 2012 ) .
d. i. pikulin and y. v. nazarov , phys .
b * 86 * , 140504 ( 2012 ) .
t. ojanen , phys .
b * 87 * , 100506(r ) ( 2013 ) . p.
san - jose , j. cayao , e. prada , and r. aguado , new journal of physics * 15 * , 075019 ( 2013 ) .
lee , k. michaeli , j. alicea , and a. yacoby , phys .
* 113 * , 197001 ( 2014 ) . g. campagnano , p. lucignano , d. giuliano , and a. tagliacozzo , j. phys . :
matter * 27 * , 205301 ( 2015 ) .
l. jiang , d. pekker , j. alicea , g. refael , y. oreg , a. brataas , and f. von oppen , phys .
b * 87 * , 075438 ( 2013 ) .
p. kotetes , g. schn , and a. shnirman , j. korean phys .
* 62 * , 1558 ( 2013 ) . c. w. j. beenakker , d. i. pikulin , t. hyart , s. schomerus , and j. p. dahlhaus , phys .
lett . * 110 * , 017003 ( 2013 ) .
f. pientika , l. jiang , d. pekker , j. alicea , g. refael , y. oreg , and f. von oppen , new j. physics * 15 * , 115001 ( 2013 ) .
f. zhang and c. l. kane , phys .
lett . * 113 * , 036401 ( 2014 ) .
|
we calculate the josephson current between two one - dimensional ( 1d ) nanowires oriented along @xmath0 with proximity induced @xmath1-wave superconducting pairing and separated by a narrow dielectric barrier in the presence of both rashba spin - orbit interaction ( soi ) characterized by strength @xmath2 and zeeman fields ( @xmath3 along @xmath4 and @xmath5 in the @xmath6 plane ) .
we formulate a general method for computing the andreev bound states energy which allows us to obtain analytical expressions for the energy of these states in several asymptotic cases .
we find that in the absence of the magnetic fields the energy gap between the andreev bound states decreases with increasing rashba soi constant leading eventually to touching of the levels . in the absence of rashba soi , the andreev bound states depend on the magnetic fields and display oscillatory behavior with orientational angle of b leading to magneto - josephson effect .
we also present analytic expressions for the dc josephson current charting out their dependence on @xmath5 , @xmath3 , and @xmath2 .
we demonstrate the existence of finite spin - josephson current in these junctions in the presence of external magnetic fields and provide analytic expressions for its dependence on @xmath2 , @xmath7 and @xmath3 .
finally , we study the ac josephson effect in the presence of the soi ( for @xmath8 ) and an external radiation and show that the width of the resulting shapiro steps in such a system can be tuned by varying @xmath2 .
we discuss experiments which can test our theoretical results .
|
it is presently accepted that most stars form in clusters or groups , although the details of the cluster - formation process , especially the origin of their structural properties , remain a matter of active research ( see , e.g. , the reviews by * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in particular , in recent years , a number of structural properties of the clusters have been uncovered that still require an adequate theoretical understanding , such as : i ) the existence of a mass segregation in the clusters , with the most massive stars lying closer to the cluster s center @xcite ; ii ) the distribution of protostellar separations , which appears to have no characteristic scale @xcite ; iii ) the likely existence of an age gradient in clusters , with the youngest stars being located in the highest - density regions @xcite ; iv ) the apparent deficit of ob stars in some infrared dark clouds .
numerical simulations have begun to offer some insight about these properties .
@xcite have concluded , from a suite of simulations of self - gravitating , decaying isothermal turbulence , that the most massive stars form in situ at the cluster centers , rather than `` sinking '' there through dynamical interactions in the cluster itself .
however , they gave no physical explanation as to why the most massive stars should form there .
more recently , @xcite have suggested , by comparing multi - wavelength observations of stellar clusters with numerical simulations , that clusters form by mergers of `` subcluster '' structures , although again no explanation of why such mergers should occur is provided .
observationally , the presence of subunits of somewhat different ages in the clusters has also been pointed out by @xcite .
a physical mechanism capable of providing a unifying scenario to these properties is that of global , hierarchical molecular cloud collapse , advanced by .
the latter authors noted that , if molecular clouds ( mcs ) are assembled by large - scale colliding streams of warm , atomic gas that rapidly condenses into the cold atomic phase , then they quickly become jeans - unstable and begin to collapse globally .
moreover , the turbulence induced by the collision of the streams causes moderately supersonic turbulence ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) in the cold gas , which produces a multi - scale spectrum of density fluctuations , where small - scale , large - amplitude ( ssla ) density fluctuations are superposed on larger - scale , smaller - amplitude ( lssa ) ones . since these density fluctuations are nonlinear , the denser ssla fluctuations have shorter free - fall times than the lssa ones , therefore completing their collapse earlier .
this process is therefore similar to @xcite fragmentation , except that the density fluctuations are of turbulent origin and therefore nonlinear . in this sense ,
the process is also similar to the mechanism of `` gravo - turbulent fragmentation '' , except that the cloud is _ not _ globally supported by turbulence , and the turbulent fluctuations do not collapse directly , but rather just plant the seeds for subsequent , local , scattered collapses as the cloud contracts globally @xcite . in what follows , we will refer to this intermediate scenario between hoyle and gravoturbulent fragmentation as `` global hierarchical collapse '' ( ghc ) .
this scenario also predicts that the star formation rate ( sfr ) in mcs evolves ( initially increasing ) over time , as a consequence of the increase of the mean density of the clouds as they go through global gravitational collapse @xcite . assuming that massive stars do not form until the sfr is high enough that the imf is sampled up to high masses , then massive stars form late in the global process , and when they do , they begin to disrupt their parent clouds through their feedcak ( winds , ionising radiation , sn explosions ) , reducing the sfr again .
@xcite presented a smoothed - particle hydrodynamics ( sph ) numerical simulation of cloud formation and evolution in the context of ghc that showed the formation of filamentary structures with embedded clumps . in that simulation ,
the filaments constitute river - like structures , through which material flows from the extended cloud environment to the dense cores where star formation occurs .
when the filaments are sufficiently dense , fragmentation occurs within them as the gas flows along them into the most massive cores .
this implies that the filaments supply the dense cores with a mixture of stars and gas .
this kind of flow was also observed ( although it was not discussed ) in a similar simulation presented by using the adaptive mesh refinement code art @xcite that included a simplified treatment of radiative transfer and a prescription to form stellar particles ) . ]
( sps ) that allows imposing a power - law sp mass function with a slope similar to that of @xcite .
this implies that , contrary to the situation in the simulation by @xcite , the clusters formed in the simulation of paper i , as well as their surrounding gas , are subject to realistic dynamics , which allows investigating the evolution of the clusters from their formation to the time when they disperse their surrounding gas .
there exist many numerical studies of cluster formation , focusing on issues such as their stellar mass function , the correlation function of the spatial stellar distribution and cluster boundedness , and the formation of binaries ; the effect of feedback on producing massive stars and on destroying their parent clumps ; and the energy balance and rotation of the cluster as a function of the initial turbulence level in the parent cloud @xcite . in this work , instead , we aim to describe the process of assembly and early evolution of the clusters as a consequence of ghc . to this end , we study a cluster formed in the simulation labeled laf1 in paper i , focusing on the resulting spatial structure of the cluster . in sec.[sec : model ] we briefly describe the numerical simulation , and in sec .
[ sec : cluster ] we describe the criteria for defining the cluster and stellar groups , both in terms of the origin of their members as well as from their instantaneous positions .
next , in sec.[sec : results ] we present our results concerning the assembly from subunits brought in by the ghc , as well as the resulting structure of the clusters . in sec .
[ sec : discussion ] we discuss the implications of our results and compare them with existing observations , and in sec.[sec : conclusions ] we give a summary and some conclusions .
the numerical simulation used in this work comes from the set performed in paper i with the hydrodynamics+n - body adaptive refinement tree ( art ) code of @xcite .
the physical processes included are self - gravity , parameterized heating and cooling ( sec.[sec : hcrates ] ) , star formation with an imposed but realistic imf ( sec.[sec : sf ] ) , and simplified radiative transfer for the feedback from massive - star ionising radiation ( sec .
[ sec : feedback ] ) .
magnetic fields are neglected . for more details ,
we refer the reader to paper i. the simulation represents the head - on collision of two cylindrical streams in the warm neutral medium .
the streams each have a radius of 64 pc and a length 112 pc , and each is traveling at a speed of @xmath0 .
the numerical box ( including the streams ) initially has a uniform density @xmath1 and temperature @xmath2 k , implying an adiabatic sound speed of @xmath3 .
thus , the streams move with a mach number of 0.8 with respect to the sound speed in the initial uniform background medium .
the simulation uses a base resolution of @xmath4 grid cells , and allows for 5 refinement levels , reaching a maximum resolution equivalent to @xmath5 , with a minimum cell size of 0.0625 pc , or @xmath6 13 000 au .
the refinement is based on a `` constant mass '' criterion , so that a cell size is refined when its mass exceeds @xmath7 .
this implies that the grid cell size @xmath8 scales with density @xmath9 as @xmath10 .
once the maximum refinement level is reached , no further refinement is performed , and the cell s mass can reach much larger values because of the probabilistic sf scheme ( sec . [ sec : sf ] ) .
note that this constant - cell - mass refinement criterion does not conform to the so - called _ jeans criterion _ @xcite of resolving the jeans length with at least 4 grid cells .
those authors cautioned that failure to do this might result in spurious , numerical fragmentation .
however , we do not consider this a cause for concern since , as will be described in sec .
[ sec : sf ] , our star formation prescription allows us to choose the stellar - particle mass distribution , and tune it to a @xcite value .
we use heating ( @xmath11 ) and cooling ( @xmath12 ) functions of the form @xmath13 these functions are fits to the various heating and cooling processes considered by @xcite , as given by equation ( 4 ) of @xcite , with the typographical corrections noted in @xcite . with these heating and cooling laws ,
the gas is thermally unstable in the density range @xmath14 .
no chemistry tracking is performed , and so the gas is assumed to be all atomic , with a mean particle weight @xmath15 .
our simulation employs a probabilistic star formation prescription such that , if a grid cell reaches a number density @xmath16 , where is a density threshold , then an sp of fixed mass @xmath17 may be placed in the cell with a probability @xmath18 every timestep of the root ( coarsest ) grid .
if the sp is created , it acquires half of the gas mass of the parent cell .
unlike standard sink particles ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , our sps do not accrete .
however , since our prescription for sf is probabilistic , once the highest refinement level is reached in a cell , it actually continues to accrete from the surrounding material , and grows in mass and density until an sp is actually placed in it .
this implies that the accretion is performed in the gas phase , rather than onto the particles .
serendipitously , it was found in paper i that this prescription allows the sps to form with a power - law mass distribution , whose slope can be tuned by varying the value of @xmath18 , at a given maximum resolution . in paper
i it was reported that setting @xmath19 at the resolution used in our simulation caused the sp power - law mass distribution to attain an exponent of @xmath20 , thus being similar to the classical salpeter value .
we set the threshold density for sp formation at @xmath21 , which corresponds to a cell mass of @xmath22 at the highest refinement level .
thus , the minimum possible sp mass is @xmath23 . with this prescription
, the most massive sp formed in this simulation has @xmath24 .
note , however , that our imposed imf is a strict power law , and thus the most probable stellar mass is also the minimum .
this implies that we are missing the low - mass ( @xmath25 ) side of the actual imf , implying that we are missing about half of the total number of stars , and that their corresponding mass ( 2030% of the total mass ) is deposited instead into the stars that do get formed in the simulation .
we discuss the implications of this in sec .
[ sec : limits ] .
our simulation thus contains sps that represent individual stars ( not clusters or groups ) , with a realistic mass distribution above the most probable stellar mass .
this allows the dynamics of the sps to be reasonably representative of the forming cluster dynamics , contrary to the case when the particles masses correspond to those of small groups , of up to a few hudreds of solar masses . in that case
, low - mass particles can suffer exceedingly strong encounters with the massive particles , and thus acquire unrealistically high velocities . in our simulation ,
the feedback effect of the ionising stars on the mc is non - local , using a simplified radiative transfer prescription to model the formation and evolution of a hii region around an sp . as a zeroth - order approximation
, we assume a uniform `` line - of - sight '' ( los ) characteristic density @xmath26 in the hii region , with a value equal to the geometric mean between the density of the cell containing the sp and that of the target cell .
moreover , for any given star we assume an ionising flux @xmath27 taken from the tabulated data provided by @xcite .
we then compute the corresponding strmgrem radius , @xmath28 , given by @xmath29 where @xmath30 @xmath31 s@xmath32 is the hydrogen recombination coefficient . at each time step , we search for all cells surrounding every sp particle whose distances to it are smaller than @xmath28 .
for each target cell that satisfies this condition , we set its temperature to @xmath33 and turn off the cooling there .
the cell will remain so during the whole lifetime of the star , which is determined by its mass @xmath34 as @xmath35 as explained in paper i , for stars more massive than @xmath36 , this time is a fit to the stellar lifetimes by @xcite , while for stars with masses lower than that , it represents the fact that the duration of the stellar - wind phase is @xmath37 myr , roughly independently of mass .
this also means that we are representing the effect of the winds and outflows of low mass stars by an ionization prescription .
while this is clearly only an approximation , we do not expect it to have much impact on our calculations , since the main source of feedback energy at the level of gmcs is the ionization feedback from massive stars @xcite .
although highly simplified , this prescription was tested in paper i against the known analytic formula for the evolution of @xmath38 in a uniform medium @xcite and shown to agree within 30% .
this , we believe , is accurate enough given our interest in large - scale molecular cloud evolution and the associated cluster dynamics at early stages of assembly , rather than on the structural details of the ionised regions .
one crucial step for the present study is the membership of stars to a given group or cluster .
we now discuss our procedure of choice .
observationally , the identification and membership definition of embedded stellar clusters is intrinsically a complex task , complicated by ambiguities and uncertainties , since the clusters do not have well defined edges , contamination by field stars is difficult to quantify , and faint members may be difficult to identify . in our case , the origin of the stars in the simulations is known , and this allows a classification of the stars by site of origin .
however , this information is unavailable to observations , which instead must proceed by first identifying the cluster as a stellar surface density excess , and then define its members mainly on a statistical basis , by comparison with star counts in nearby control fields off the cluster @xcite . on the other hand ,
in the simulation there are no `` field '' stars , but only stars from clusters formed at some other locations in the cloud . for the purpose of defining a cluster or group by location at early times
, we use the well known friends - of - friends ( fof ) algorithm @xcite .
this is convenient at early stages , when the first groups of stars are well separated and the stars are easy to tag as part of a group that has formed at a certain time and location .
however , note that , because of the hierarchical structure of the clusters , and [ sec : results ] . ]
the number and stellar content of the resulting groups depends on the value of the so - called `` linking parameter '' passed to the algorithm .
this parameter is a measure of the distance out to which neighbors are searched . at early times
, the separation between groups is easily determined by eye , and the linking parameter can then be chosen to match the visual classification . at later times , however , the groups change their size by dynamical interactions between their members , and moreover new stars continue to form in the same region , or in its outskirts , making it necessary to suitably define the regions size in order to determine stellar membership to a group .
we thus define the radius of a group at a given time by performing an iterative process : 1 . considering only the stars that were part of the group in the previous snapshot , we measure the distance from their center of mass to the most distant star .
if this distance is less than twice the distance from the center to the second most distant star , we consider the distance to the most distant star as the radius of the group .
otherwise , we consider the most distant star as a `` runaway star '' and take the radius of the group as the distance from its center to the second most distant star .
next , we assign the new stars ( those formed in the period of time between the actual snapshot and the previous one ) to the group whose center of mass is closest to them .
3 . finally , including the new stars , we recompute the center of mass , size ( @xmath39 ) , total mass ( @xmath40 ) , and total number of stars ( @xmath41 ) of the group .
we also compute the age of the group , @xmath42 , as the time elapsed since the moment when the group was first defined .
however , neighbouring groups generally approach each other ( as part of the large - scale collapse ) and often they merge .
we say that a new group has formed by the merger of two former groups when the distance between their centers of mass is smaller than the larger of the two radii . at that point
, we consider that the earlier subgroups disappear . in general
, we expect this process to operate at all scales in our simulation , with groups in turn forming from subgroups , and so on , in a hierarchical and self - similar manner .
in this simulation , three main clusters form , two of which are sufficiently massive to clear out the dense gas around them on a timescale @xmath43 myr since the formation of the first stars ( from @xmath44 myr to @xmath45 myr in the evolution of the simulation ) .
stars begin to form at @xmath46 myr , and the first hii regions appear at @xmath47 myr .
specifically , at @xmath48 myr , the dense gas has been cleared from a radius of @xmath49 pc around the clusters .
figure [ fig : sim_imgs ] shows one snapshot of the simulation , at @xmath50 myr into the evolution , in which two hii regions , surrounding the two most massive clusters , can be seen , while the filamentary structure of the cloud is still noticeable in general . the clusters themselves have formed along the main filamentary structures in the cloud , and contain @xmath51@xmath52 .
note also that the structure of the most massive cluster retains the filamentary shape of its parent cloud , similarly to , for example , the structure observed in the orion a cloud .
this similarity in fact is not limited to the filamentary shape , but also includes the fact that the filament has a larger concentration of stars in one end . in a future paper
we plan to quantitatively explore the stucture and kinematics of these observed and simulated clusters .
the crucial effect of the ghc scenario is that the filaments constitute part of the large - scale gravitational collapse , funneling gas into the cores within them , as observed by @xcite in a numerical simulation of cloud formation and collapse .
moreover , these authors observed a hierarchy of collapses within the filaments , so that _ small clumps , which are collapsing locally , and sometimes forming stars already , are themselves falling onto larger - scale ones _ , similarly to the `` conveyor belt '' scenario proposed by @xcite for the gas stream in the central molecular zone .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : imgs_clus2 ] , which shows a series of snapshots around the second most massive cluster ( hereafter , `` cluster 2 '' , located in the upper left part of the cloud ) among those seen in fig .
[ fig : sim_imgs ] , from @xmath53 myr to @xmath54 myr . from @xmath55 18.92 to 19.05 myr it can be seen that new stars have formed in the first group . at @xmath56 myr
, a second group is seen to have formed at a distance @xmath57 pc from the first . by @xmath58 myr
, this second group is seen to have approached the first , being at a distance @xmath59 pc from it , and to have merged with it by @xmath60 myr .
also , at this time , a third group is seen to begin forming in the far left part of the filament , containing only one star at that time , although by @xmath61 myr it already contains several stars ( not shown ) . the effect of the feedback is also worth noting . already by @xmath58 myr
, the section of the filament connecting the two clusters is seen to be partially disrupted , and some gas is being expelled from the clump containing the main group .
however , accretion along the filament is seen to have replenished this section of the filament at @xmath62 myr , although the other side of the filament is now seen to be in the process of dispersal .
finally , by @xmath54 myr , the filament is seen to be in the process of dispersal on both sides of the cluster .
figure [ fig : imgs_clus2b ] then shows the late stages of the evolution of this cluster . by @xmath63
myr the filament is seen to have been dispersed out to distances @xmath64 pc , and by @xmath65 myr , a large hii region , of diameter @xmath66 pc has formed , although the group on the left retains some of its gas , and a new group has formed in an `` pillar '' that constitutes the remainder of the filament .
also , along this filamentary structure , yet another group is seen to have formed ( at the far right of the image ) . by @xmath67 myr ,
most of the dense gas has been cleared from the region , and the cluster is seen to consist of four groups , two of them almost devoid of gas ( `` naked '' ) and two of them still embedded in their respective clumps . from the above description , it becomes clear that the clusters in this simulation are assembled by means of a hierarchical process , in which subunits formed at slightly different locations and times merge as they fall into a large - scale potential well , _ feeding the central clump with both stars and gas_. in the following sections we discuss various implications of this mechanism .
the resulting evolution of cluster 2 is illustrated in fig.[fig : cluster_evol ] , which shows the projected positions of the stellar particles on the @xmath68 plane at times @xmath69 , 21.44 , 22.40 , and 25.34 myr in the _ top left , top right , bottom left , and bottom right panels _
. in this cluster , stars begin to form at @xmath70 myr and fig .
[ fig : cluster_evol ] shows that they are assembled into a cluster in such a way that at @xmath69 myr we identify two subgroups ( hereafter , groups 1 and 2 ; see the _ top left panel _ of fig .
[ fig : cluster_evol ] ) of what will later become a larger , merged group ( group 1 - 2 ) .
we use square symbols to identify stars that belong to group 1 , and filled circles for stars belonging to group 2 .
furthermore , we color them according to their age as shown in the labels and qualitatively represent their masses by the symbol size , with larger symbols indicating larger masses .
the green and red circles represent the group radii at each time , computed as explained in sec .
[ sec : cluster ] , with the dashed circles representing the size out to the most distant star , and the solid circles representing the distance to the second most distant star . in
what follows , we use the distance to the second most distant star as the radius of group 1 - 2 , because the first most distant one is clearly `` running away '' from the group .
finally , we use larger symbols to represent more massive stars , and smaller symbols to represent lower - mass stars .
thus , even at these early stages , we can see that _ the more massive and younger stars tend to be near the centers of the groups_. from fig . [ fig : cluster_evol ] it is clearly seen that , at these early stages , the groups are undergoing expansion , and that star formation continues within them .
by @xmath71 myr , both groups have similar sizes , masses , and number of stars , and they have undergone a large enough expansion that their merger appears inevitable .
the formerly `` most distant '' star of group 2 is now far away from the center of either group . by our definition ,
the merger occurs at @xmath72 myr , forming the new group 1 - 2 .
we have kept the circular and square symbols to indicate the original group membership of the stars in the merged group .
triangles now represent stars born in the new group 1 - 2 .
thus , this new group contains stars that were born at somewhat different times and locations . for later times , we continue to track the evolution of this and other , new groups appearing in a 10-pc box around group 1 - 2 , and by @xmath73 myr , we now find a system of groups with different ages , masses , and sizes ( _ bottom right panel _ of fig .
[ fig : cluster_evol ] ) .
these groups lie approximately in a straight line , because they formed in the filament feeding the main clump . eventually , as these groups expand and approach each other , they finally become part of what we refer to as the whole cluster 2 , as seen in the _ bottom right panel _ of fig.[fig : imgs_clus2b ] , although the subunits are still partially distinguishable at that time ( @xmath74 myr ) . as mentioned in the introduction , one fundamental implication of the ghc scenario
is that the sfr of star - forming clouds must increase in time until the time when massive stars begin to appear and to destroy their parent mc @xcite .
figure [ fig : sfr_evol ] shows the evolution of the sfr in groups 1 and 2 , as well as in the merged group 1 - 2 . except for group 2 , in whose parent cloud the sfr starts relatively high and then decreases , for groups 1 and 1 - 2 the trend of increasing sfr is observed .
moreover , the sfr for the merged group 1 - 2 is much larger than the maximum value reached in group 2 before the merger , so the increase of the sfr also holds for the system of groups 1 and 2 combined , before and after their merger . assuming that massive stars do not form in a region until the sfr is locally high enough to sample the imf up to large masses , the increase of the sfr implies that the massive stars should tend to appear late in the evolution of star - forming regions .
this is illustrated in fig.[fig : age - mass ] , which shows the mass of the stars _
vs. _ their age at @xmath54 and @xmath75 myr . at both times
, it is clearly seen that the oldest stars have the lowest masses , and that , as the age decreases , the range of stellar masses extends to larger values .
this is also illustrated in fig .
[ fig : cum_mass_hist ] , which shows the cumulative mass distribution of groups 1 , 2 , and 1 - 2 at various times .
it is seen from this figure that the relative abundance of massive stars increases over time , especially after groups 1 and 2 have merged .
the ghc mechanism implies that each star - forming site is locally undergoing collapse while simultaneously it is falling into larger - scale potential wells .
moreover , since the small - scale regions are forming stars on their own , this process in turn implies that the larger scales are fed both gas and stars ( cf .
[ sec : global_evol ] ) from the surrounding infalling material . also , the small - scale regions fall into the larger - scale ones mostly along filaments @xcite .
an important consequence of this `` mixed '' ( gas+stars ) infall is that the ensemble of stars constitutes a non - dissipative `` fluid '' that conserves the kinetic energy of the infalling motions .
thus , the stars formed _ before _ reaching the large - scale collapse center should exhibit a velocity dispersion corresponding to their motions as they were infalling to the center of the large - scale potential well . in turn
, this implies that older stars should reach somewhat larger distances from the center of a group or cluster that has undergone mergers than the stars formed _ in situ _ in this merged clump , where the gas from which they inherit their velocity dispersion has probably been shocked and thus has lost some of the infall kinetic energy . figure [ fig : age_profile ]
shows the age of the stellar particles as a function of their distance to the center of mass of cluster 2 at @xmath76 myr .
it is seen that all of the youngest stars ( @xmath77 , and in particular several stars with @xmath78 myr ) , are located within the central 0.5 pc of the cluster .
this is qualitatively consistent with the observation that the youngest stars appear tightly clustered around core - like or filamentary star - forming regions . instead , at larger distances ( @xmath79 pc )
, there are no particles with @xmath80 myr .
these older stars are the ones that formed in groups 1 and 2 , prior to their merging .
this can also be seen in the _ bottom left _
panel of fig .
[ fig : cluster_evol ] , which shows that the stars farther from the center of group 1 - 2 are all represented by circles and squares ( i.e. , formed previously to the merger ) and by green and cyan colors , denoting ages between 1 and 4 myr , while the stars clustered near the center have ages @xmath81 myr , as indicated by their black - colored symbols . on the other hand
, we also notice in fig .
[ fig : age_profile ] that the inner 0.5 pc of the cluster also contains several old stars , and in particular , the oldest ones ( @xmath82 23.5 myr ) .
this suggests that some of the stars formed previously to the merger have already had @xmath83-body interactions with the other stars in the region , and thus have transferred their excess kinetic energy to other stars in the cluster .
this is facilitated because these old stars have low masses , so that they are strongly affected by interactions with more massive ones . indeed , as discussed in sec .
[ sec : sfr ] ( fig .
[ fig : age - mass ] ) , the oldest stars have masses near the peak of the imf , which in our case is also the minimum stellar mass ( cf . sec . [
sec : sf ] ) .
also , as mentioned in secs .
[ sec : intro ] and [ sec : sfr ] , another implication of the ghc is that the sfr increases in each star - forming site until feedback begins to destroy the gas supply onto it , at which point the sfr begins to decline there , and perhaps shut off completely . using a semi - analytic model for the evolution of collapsing clouds and their sfr , @xcite showed that this acceleration of the sf at each star - forming site implies that the age histogram of the site before a few myr of its destruction is characterized by a large peak of very young ( age @xmath84 myr ) and a small tail of older ( up to several myr ) stars , similarly to the age histograms of embedded clusters in various nearby mcs @xcite .
figure [ fig : age_hist ] shows the age histogram of the stars in groups 1 and 2 at various times , as the clumps that embed them merge and continue to form stars . at @xmath85 myr ,
the two clumps and their embedded groups are still separate , and a histogram for each group is shown . at @xmath86 myr , the two clumps and their embedded groups have already merged , and thus a single histogram is shown .
it is seen that , at this time , the most numerous stars are those less than 1 myr old .
neverthless , there are also a few stars up to nearly 4 myr old .
this indicates an acceleration of sf during the first @xmath87 myr of evolution of cluster 2 . at later times ( @xmath88 and @xmath89 myr ) , the number of young stars decreases , while the most numerous stars are those formed around @xmath90 myr .
this indicates a decline of the sfr after this time due to the onset of gas dispersal by the feedback .
figure [ fig : mass_profile ] shows the radial distribution of the stellar particle masses at @xmath54 myr .
it can be seen that all but one of the stars with mass @xmath91 , and all stars with @xmath92 are located within @xmath93 pc of the computed center of the cluster .
only one star with @xmath94 is located at @xmath95 pc from the cluster s center of mass
. however , close inspection of the time sequence outlined by the various images of fig .
[ fig : cluster_evol ] shows that this is a runaway star formed in , and ejected from , group 1 before the merger .
this star is represented by the cyan squared symbol lying on the green solid circle in the _ top right _ panel [ @xmath96 myr ] of fig.[fig : cluster_evol ] and on the solid orange circle in the _ bottom left _ [ @xmath97 myr ] panel .
thus , this star is just `` flying by '' the cluster . instead
, the other massive stars in group 1 - 2 have formed _ in situ _ , as indicated by the triangular shape of their symbols in fig .
[ fig : cluster_evol ] . also , the other massive stars are represented by symbols of white and cyan colors , and with triangular shapes , indicating that those stars are younger ( @xmath98 myr ) , and formed _ in situ _ in the merged group 1 - 2 .
thus , we conclude that , except for the star that is `` passing by '' , the massive stars have formed after the merger of groups 1 and 2 to form group 1 - 2 , thus being younger and tightly clustered near the group center .
another feature of the cluster evolution seen in figs.[fig : age_profile ] and [ fig : mass_profile ] is that the cluster expands as it evolves , increasing its radius from @xmath99 pc at @xmath54 myr to @xmath100 pc at @xmath101 myr .
the reason for this is not totally clear
. it can be due in part to the fact that the gaseous material is beginning to be expelled from the clump , as can be seen in figs .
[ fig : imgs_clus2 ] and [ fig : imgs_clus2b ] , and in part to the fact that the velocity dispersion of the older stars , formed in the scattered ssla regions that have fallen into the lssa one , corresponds to the large - scale potential well , not that of the local star - forming site ( cf .
[ sec : age_distr ] ) , causing the cluster to expand to a size representative of this somewhat larger energy .
we now discuss the hierarchical structure of the cluster itself , resulting from the process of ghc of its parent cloud .
figure [ fig : hier_clus ] shows the stars belonging to the cluster at time @xmath74 myr , first as a whole , and then as identified by a friends - of - friends algorithm using three different values of the `` linking parameter '' @xmath102 , which determines how far neighbours are searched in order to identify a group .
we see that , using a small value of the parameter ( @xmath103 , _ top right _ panel ) , 10 tight groups are identified ( denoted by the different colors ) , while using larger values ( @xmath104 and 2 , _ bottom left _ and _ bottom right _ panels ) , respectively 9 and 4 are identified , each group being significantly more extended .
we also note that , at the lowest value , @xmath105 , a whole group of moderately scattered stars is left out , which is nevertheless identified as a group at higher values .
these results show that the structure of the cluster resulting from the global , hierarchical contraction of the cloud , is inherently `` nested '' , consisting of structures within structures within structures , reflecting the structure of the parent cloud , which in turn is a consequence of its multi - scale , hierarchical collapse .
we can summarise the discussion in the previous section as follows .
the underlying assumption for interpreting the emerging properties of the clusters formed in the scenario of ghc is that first proposed in @xcite , namely that massive stars only form in sites where the local sfr is high enough that the imf can be sampled to correspondingly large stellar masses .
conversely , the most common stars in low - sfr sites should be those at the peak of the imf .
this is , of course , a fully probabilistic interpretation of the imf , and it does not address the physical mechanisms responsible for the development of the imf itself . however , it allows a framework for understanding the assembly of the clusters . also , under the assumption that structures of all scales are collapsing , as required by the ghc , at a given density ( and therefore , a given free - fall time ) , more massive clumps are expected to have higher sfrs , if the sfr is given , to first order , by the ratio of the clump mass to its free - fall time .
our simulation mimics these hypotheses , due to the probabilistic scheme used for the formation of a stellar particle .
the longer it takes for a particle to form , the more massive it will be , since the cell in which it forms continues to accrete and becomes more massive , without further refinement , and then the particle forms with half the mass of the cell .
but , as shown in figure 1 of paper i , the probability of being able to wait very long times before forming a stellar particle is very low , and so the probability of forming of a very massive star is also very low .
thus , our simulation is expected to generally only form massive stars when the local sfr is very high , although there can be a few exceptions to this pattern .
finally , in the ghc scenario , the low - mass , small - scale but large - amplitude ( ssla ) star - forming sites should appear earlier in the evolution of the cloud , because of their shorter free - fall times , while the high - mass , larger - scale , smaller - amplitude ( lssa ) sites should appear later . moreover
, the low - mass sites should be falling into the trough of the gravitational potential well of the high - mass ones .
however , low - mass sites continue to appear at all times in the filaments that feed the massive clumps until the filaments are destroyed by the feedback .
thus , the low mass stars formed in the low - mass , infalling clumps share the clumps infall velocity , and thus should have larger velocity dispersions than the stars formed in the main , massive clump , which can have both low or high masses .
the above considerations imply a number of properties of the resulting clusters : 1 .
the oldest stars tend to have low masses
. however , the converse is not necessarily true : low - mass stars in general can be either young or old .
this trend is shown in the _ top _ panel of fig .
[ fig : age - mass ] , which shows the mass _ vs. _ the age of the stars in the cluster at times @xmath97 and 23.66 myr .
the oldest stars have larger velocities ( fig .
[ fig : v - age ] , _ left _ panel ) , and consequently , they may be encountered at larger distances from the local star - forming site ( fig . [ fig : age_profile ] ) .
the most massive stars appear later ( a few myr ) in the evolution of the clump ensemble , when various ssla sites have merged to form a lssa site .
this is shown in figure [ fig : cum_mass_hist ] , which gives the cumulative stellar mass histogram for groups 1 and 2 , independently and combined , at various times . as time proceeds , progressively larger fractions of the stars are seen to be massive .
4 . the sfr increases during the early stages of the cluster assembly , until the time when massive stars begin to form . after this time , the sfr decreases , as the ionising feedback from the massive stars begins to destroy the clump and its filamentary gas supply .
this is seen in the evolution of the age histogram , shown in fig .
[ fig : age_hist ] .
the oldest stars constitute a minority , since the sfr initially increases with time .
however , after the appearance of ob stars that can partially or completely destroy the local clump and its supplying filaments , the sfr decreases again , and thus stars younger than the age of the oldest massive stars should be less abundant as well , as also shown in fig .
[ fig : age_hist ] . note that these properties refer to regions of sizes a few parsecs and ages of at least a few myr , and so it specifically does _ not _ refer to the local and instantaneous stellar production in a single clump , for which our simulation can not discern whether massive stars form first or last , or how long does it take to build a massive star .
also , note that young star - forming regions may consist of several low - mass local star - forming sites , and contain no large - scale site yet .
this situation corresponds to times where the first low - mass sites have not yet merged to form a more massive one .
our numerical results are qualitatively consistent with recent observational results on the age and mass distributions of young stellar objects in star - forming regions . in particular , @xcite have recently reported the existence of age gradients in the stellar populations of various massive star - forming regions , such that the youngest stellar objects are located in the obscured regions of molecular clouds , intermediate - age objects are located in revealed clusters , and the oldest objects are found in distributed populations .
this is qualitatively consistent with our result that the oldest objects can be found at large distances from the cluster s center due to their larger velocity dispersion , in turn due to their formation far from it , so that their velocities include the component from their infall onto the central massive clump .
instead , younger objects formed in the clump lack this component of the velocity , and these are characterised by somewhat lower velocites .
also , the larger velocity dispersion of the older objects predicted by the ghc scenario has been observed by @xcite in the orion a cloud .
@xcite considered several possible scenarios that could lead to the age segregation they observed .
of these , the one closest to the mechanism of hierarchical assembly by ghc is their scenario b , since it invokes the acceleration of sf as proposed by @xcite , which is consistent with our scenario @xcite .
however , the similarity between ghc and scenario b of @xcite is not complete , since they did not consider the accretion of both stars and gas onto the trough of the large - scale potential well .
in addition , @xcite have concluded that the cloud complex known as the m17 southwest extension ( m17 swex ) appears to be lacking very massive stars in comparison with the number expected from its estimated sfr .
this region consists of several scattered star - forming cores , separated by distances of several parsecs from each other ( m.povich , private communication ; see also busquet et al .
this is consistent with the hierarchical assembly of the cluster in our simulation , since several isolated , intermediate - mass star - forming clumps may produce a relatively numerous combined population of ysos that may however not yet have formed massive stars , because in the ghc scenario this only occurs after these smaller regions have merged to form a massive one .
this is again illustrated in fig.[fig : cum_mass_hist ] , which shows that the relative abundance of massive stars increases over time , especially after groups 1 and 2 have merged .
we conclude that the scenario of ghc provides an assembly mechanism for clusters that naturally predicts the observed age segregation and bottom - heavy imf of young clusters . in a future contribution
we plan to carry out a detailed quantitative comparison between the clusters in simulations that sample the imf to lower masses ( see sec.[sec : limits ] ) and the observed properties of specific clusters .
the present study is based on the underlying hypothesis that our probabilistic stellar particle formation scheme mimics the mechanism leading to the development of the imf .
that is , we interpret the imf strictly as a random sampling process , so that the scarcity of massive stars is interpreted to imply that the probability of forming one is very low and given precisely by the imf .
interestingly , the fact that our simulation , using a probabilistic criterion for the formation of stellar particles ( cf
. sec .
[ sec : sf ] ) , qualitatively reproduces several observed properties of young clusters , suggests that our underlying assumption is reasonably realistic .
nevertheless , our star formation scheme does have some limitations .
most importantly , as described in sec .
[ sec : sf ] , the minimmum stellar - particle mass is @xmath106 , which is near the peak of the observed stellar imf , and thus we are missing stars on the low - mass side of the imf .
our imposed imf is thus a strict power law , that lacks the turnover at low masses .
this implies that we are missing a significant number of low - mass stars , about half of the total number of stars .
their mass , @xmath107 of the total mass for a @xcite imf , and @xmath108 for a @xcite imf , is instead deposited into the stars that do form in the simulation , with masses @xmath106 to @xmath109 .
this may affect the dynamics of the clusters formed in the simulation , although not very strongly , since the missing stars have low masses , and are not expected to affect the dynamics of the higher - mass ones too much , especially if the tend to form a roughly uniform background .
the fact that the structure of our clusters resembles that of observed young clusters reinforces this expectation .
we nevertheless plan to improve our star formation scheme in order to produce a more complete stellar - particle mass spectrum , and with this carry out a more detailed and quantitative comparison with observations .
meanwhile , we consider that our study conveys an illustrative first approximation to the problem of cluster assembly , capturing the essential aspects of the hierarchical assembly of these objects . other limitations of our simulation are that it does not include magnetic fields nor any form of feedback other than ionisation heating , in particular supernova ( sn ) explosions
. the neglect of magnetic fields may not be crucial , since our present understanding is that mcs are generally magnetically supercritical , meaning that the magnetic field is in general unable to support them against their own self - gravity , and therefore they proceed unimpeded to global collapse .
the neglect of sn explosions is also not crucial because of two main reasons .
first , it is becoming increasingly accepted that sn explosions need to occur within the clouds in order to remove significant amounts of mass from the clouds @xcite , although on the other hand , only sne that explode in low - density environments avoid energy losses that allow efficient coupling with the gas @xcite .
also , pre - sn feedback is required to allow blastwaves to propagate efficiently into the ism @xcite .
second , and more importantly , our study suggests that the assembly of the clusters is accomplished mostly during the early stages ( first few myr ) of the clouds evoloution , during which few or no sne are expected to occur , especially if massive stars form late in the evolution of the cloud , as suggested by the ghc scenario .
so , the ionising feedback included in our simulations is probably the most relevant form of feedback for regulating the gas flow onto the sites where the new stars are forming . finally , our feedback prescription ( sec .
[ sec : feedback ] ) is of course crude , solving the radiative transfer only in an approximate way .
although it was shown in paper i that the evolution of an hii region with this prescription does track the uniform - medium analytic solution reasonably well , it is possible that our prescription allows evaporation of regions that should be shaded behind dense clumps , since it does not take into account the density of the intervening material between the ionising star and the cell on which the effect of the radiation is being determined .
thus , our simulations may somewhat overestimate the evaporation rate of material in filaments containing dense clumps .
however , since the filaments themselves are denser than the background medium , and their length far exceeds that of isolated clumps and cores , their column density for situations where the filament is aligned with the ionising object and with the intervening clump ( as in the case of filaments feeding the main clump where the ionising object formed ) may be comparable to or even larger than that of the intervening clump . therefore , the shadowing caused by this clump is likely to be of secondary importance . indeed , figure 10 in paper
i shows the gradual evaporation of filaments containing clumps in a way that allows the formation of `` pillars '' , and finally isolated globules within growing hii regions , similarly to objects like the `` pillars of creation '' and dark globules , respectively . on the other hand ,
our feedback prescription allows the simulations to run orders of magnitude faster than if the radiative transfer is followed in full .
we thus conclude that our prescription provides a sufficiently realistic framework for the study of the assembly of stellar clusters .
in this paper , we have discussed the mechanism of assembly of a cluster in a numerical simulation of cloud formation and collapse by converging flows . the assembly proceeds in a hierarchical way as a consequence of the hierarchical nature of the collapse of its parent cloud @xcite .
the hierarchical collapse regime consists of small - scale , large - amplitude ( ssla ) collapses ( involving small total masses ) within large - scale , small - amplitude ( lssa ) ones ( involving large masses , which are spread out over large scale regions ) .
collapse at all scales involves accretion onto the troughs of the potential wells ( the collapse `` centers '' ) .
the large - scale collapses involve the generation of filamentary flows that funnel material from the whole large - scale region down to its collapse center , and the small - scale collapsing regions `` ride '' along these large - scale filamentary flows @xcite , in a `` conveyor belt '' fashion @xcite . because the small - scale collapses start forming stars earlier ( due to their larger amplitudes , which imply shorter free - fall times ) , they often reach the large - scale collapse center already containing stars in addition to fresh gas .
this mechanism then implies that massive star - forming sites form by the merging of smaller - scale star - forming regions , which supply both stars and gas to the larger sites , and thus these larger - scale sites contain a mixture of locally formed stars and stars that formed at a remote , smaller - scale site and that are brought to the large - scale site by the infalling flow .
moreover , the stars that form in the small - scale , scattered sites have an infall velocity corresponding to the larger - scale potential well .
however , stars formed in the massive center of the large - scale collapse , form from gas that has probably been shocked upon its arrival there , and so they form with a somewhat lower velocity dispersion . finally , this scenario also implies that the sfr must increase with time during early stages of evolution , and then decrease again as the massive stars begin to destroy their forming sites @xcite .
this acceleration of the sf process , combined with a face - value interpretation of the imf as a probability distribution function of stellar masses , suggests that massive stars are only expected to form once the sfr is large enough to sample the imf to high masses .
therefore , massive stars should form last in the evolution of the whole ensemble of star - forming sites , once the low - mass ones have merged to form a large - mass , high - sfr one . from these considerations ,
we have concluded that a cluster that has formed from the hierarchical collapse of its parent cloud must have the following characteristics : * the oldest stars tend to have low masses , because they formed in the low - mass sites early in the evolution of the cloud .
however , newer stars can be either low - or high mass , as they form in the high - mass site formed by the merger of the low - mass ones .
* the oldest stars tend to have larger velocity dispersions , because they are characterized by the infall velocity of the material onto the high - mass collapse center
. however , this effect tends to be washed out by the stellar interaction as the cluster ages .
* as a consequence , older stars tend to be at larger distances from the collapse center ( or filament ) .
* the most massive stars tend to be younger , because they only form when the sfr of the whole region has increased sufficiently to sample the high - mass regions of the imf . * as a consequence , the low- and intermediate - mass sites that have not concluded the merging process may be defficient in the highest - mass stars . * because of the increasing sfr , most stars are young , although a small fraction may be as old as several myr .
these features are in good qualitative agreement with observed properties of young clusters , which seem to have a hierarchical structure , have an age gradient , so that the oldest stars tend to be farther from the forming sites @xcite and to have larger velocities @xcite .
also , the scenario implies that ensembles of cores in early phases of evolution will be defficient in massive stars compared to the expected number form their combined stellar production , as observed by @xcite .
we conclude that the scenario of ghc allows a clear understanding of the properties of young clusters , in terms of the multi - scale collapse of their parent clouds .
e.v .- s . is glad to acknowledge enlightening discussions with matt povich on the observed structure of young clusters .
was supported by uc - mexus fellowship .
|
we discuss the mechanism of cluster formation in a numerical simulation of a molecular cloud ( mc ) undergoing global hierarchical collapse ( ghc ) , to understand how the gas motions in the parent cloud control the assembly of the cluster .
the global nature of the collapse implies that the star formation rate ( sfr ) increases over time .
the `` hierarchical '' nature of the collapse consists of small - scale collapses within larger - scale ones .
the large - scale collapses culminate a few myr later than the small - scale collapses and consist of filamentary flows that accrete onto massive , dense central clumps . in turn , the small - scale collapses form clumps embedded in the filaments , that are falling onto the central clump assembled by the ongoing large - scale collapse .
the stars formed in the early , small - scale collapses share the infall motion of their parent clumps towards the larger - scale potential well , so that the filaments feed both gaseous and stellar material to the massive central clump .
this leads to the presence of a few older stars in a region where new protostars are forming at a higher rate , and also to a self - similar or fractal - like structure of the clusters , in which each unit is composed of smaller - scale sub - units , which approach each other and may eventually merge , explaining the frequently - observed morphology of cluster - forming regions .
moreover , because the older stars formed in the filaments share the infall motion of the gas onto the central clump , they tend to have larger velocities and to be distributed over larger areas than the younger stars formed in the central clump , where the gas from which they form has been shocked and has dissipated some kinetic energy .
finally , interpreting the imf as a probability distribution , so that the probability of forming a massive star is much lower than that of forming a low - mass one , implies that massive stars only form once the _ local _ sfr is large enough to sample the imf up to high masses . in combinaton with the increase of the sfr
, this implies that massive stars tend to appear late in the evolution of the mc , and only in the central massive clumps .
we discuss the correspondence of these features with observed properties of young stellar clusters , finding very good qualitative agreement , thus providing support to the scenario of global , hierarchical collapse of mcs , while explaining the origin of the observed cluster structure .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : star clusters , gravitation , hydrodynamics , ism : clouds , stars : formation
|
as in our previous analysis of run 1a data @xcite , we conduct a general search for new particles with a narrow natural width that decay to dijets . in addition
, we search for the following particles summarized in fig .
[ fig_particles ] : axigluons @xcite from chiral qcd ( @xmath7 ) , excited states @xcite of composite quarks ( @xmath8 ) , color octet technirhos @xcite ( @xmath9 ) , new gauge bosons ( @xmath10,@xmath11 ) , and scalar @xmath12 diquarks @xcite ( @xmath13 and @xmath14 ) .
using four triggers from run 1a and 1b , we combine dijet mass spectra above a mass of 150 gev / c@xmath1 , 241 gev / c@xmath1 , 292 gev / c@xmath1 , and 388 gev / c@xmath1 with integrated luminosities of = 7.5 in = 3.3 in = 3.3 in .089 pb@xmath0 , 1.92 pb@xmath0 , 9.52 pb@xmath0 , and 69.8 pb@xmath0 respectively .
jets are defined with a fixed cone clustering algorithm ( r=0.7 ) and then corrected for detector response , energy lost outside the cone , and underlying event .
we take the two highest @xmath15 jets and require that they have pseudorapidity @xmath16 and a cms scattering angle @xmath17| < 2/3 $ ] .
the @xmath18 cut provides uniform acceptance as a function of mass and reduces the qcd background which peaks at @xmath19 . in fig .
[ fig_dijet ] the dijet mass distribution is presented as a differential cross section in bins of the mass resolution ( @xmath20% ) . at high mass
the data is systematically higher than a prediction from pythia plus a cdf detector simulation , similar to the inclusive jet @xmath21 spectrum @xcite . to search for new particles we determine the qcd background by fitting the data to a smooth function of three parameters @xcite ; fig .
[ fig_dijet ] shows the fractional difference between the data and the fit ( @xmath22 ) .
we note upward fluctuations near 200 gev / c@xmath1 ( @xmath23 ) , 550 gev / c@xmath1 ( @xmath24 ) and 850 gev / c@xmath1 ( @xmath25 ) . for narrow resonances
it is sufficient to determine the mass resolution for only one type of new particle because the detector resolution dominates the width . in fig .
[ fig_resonance ] we show the mass resolution for excited quarks ( q * ) from pythia plus a cdf detector simulation ; the long tail at low mass comes from gluon radiation . for each value of new particle mass in 50 gev / c@xmath1 steps ,
we perform a binned maximum likelihood fit of the data to the background parameterization and the mass resonance shape . in fig .
[ fig_resonance ] we display the best fit and 95% confidence level upper limit for a 550 gev / c@xmath1 resonance . for the mass region @xmath26
gev / c@xmath1 , there are 2947 events in the data , @xmath27 events ( @xmath28 ) in the background for the fit without a resonance , @xmath29 events ( @xmath30 ) in the background for the fit that includes the resonance , and the value of the resonance cross section from the fit is @xmath31 pb ( statistical ) . in fig .
[ fig_cos ] we study the angular distribution of the fluctuation in the mass region @xmath26 gev / c@xmath1 .
the angular distribution is compatible with both qcd alone , and with = 3.3 in = 3.3 in qcd + 5% excited quark ( best fit ) .
this amount of excited quark is coincidentally the same as found in the mass fit .
although the fluctuation is interesting , we conclude it is not yet = 3.3 in = 3.3 in statistically significant , and proceed to set limits on new particle production .
= 3.3 in = 3.3 in from the likelihood distribution including experimental systematic uncertainties @xcite we obtain the 95% cl upper limit on the cross section for new particles shown in fig .
[ fig_dijet_limit ] .
we compare this to the cross section for axigluons ( excluding @xmath32 gev / c@xmath1 ) , excited quarks ( excluding @xmath33 gev / c@xmath1 ) , technirhos ( excluding @xmath34 gev / c@xmath1 ) , w@xmath35 ( excluding @xmath36 gev / c@xmath1 ) , z@xmath35 ( excluding @xmath37 gev / c@xmath1 ) , and e6 diquarks ( excluding @xmath38 gev / c@xmath1 ) .
the calculations are lowest order @xcite using cteq2l parton distributions @xcite and one - loop @xmath39 and require @xmath16 and @xmath40 .
the large mass of the top quark suggests that the third generation may be special .
topcolor @xcite assumes that the top mass is large mainly because of a dynamical @xmath5 condensate generated by a new strong dynamics coupling to the third generation . here
the @xmath41 of qcd is a low energy symmetry arising from the breaking of an @xmath42 coupling to the third generation and an @xmath43 coupling to the first two generations only .
there are then massive color octet bosons , topgluons @xmath44 , which couple largely to @xmath4 and @xmath5 .
the topgluon is strongly produced and decays mainly to the third generation ( @xmath45 ) with a relatively large natural width ( @xmath46 ) .
here we search for the topgluon in the @xmath4 channel .
an additional @xmath47 symmetry is introduced @xcite to keep the @xmath48 quark light while the top quark is heavy ; this leads to a topcolor @xmath6 , which again couples largely to @xmath4 and @xmath5 .
the topcolor @xmath6 is electroweakly produced and decays mainly to the third generation ( @xmath49 ) with a narrow natural width ( @xmath50 ) .
here we search for the topcolor @xmath6 in both the the @xmath4 and @xmath5 channel ; the @xmath5 channel is the most sensitive because the coupling to @xmath5 is larger .
we start with the dijet search in 19 pb@xmath0 of run 1a data @xcite and additionally require at least one of the two leading jets be tagged as a bottom quark .
the b - tag requires a displaced vertex in the the secondary vertex detector @xcite .
the @xmath4 event efficiency is @xmath51% independent of dijet mass . from fits to the @xmath52 distribution
, we estimate that the sample is roughly 50% bottom , 30% charm , and 20% mistags of plain jets .
pythia predicts that 1/5 of these bottom quarks are direct @xmath4 , and the rest are from gluon splitting and flavor excitation .
consequentially , only about @xmath53% @xmath54 10% of our sample is direct @xmath4 .
we expect both the purity and efficiency to increase when we use the run 1b dataset and a new tagging algorithm @xcite
. with higher tagging efficiency we should be able to make better use of double b - tagged events like the one in fig .
[ fig_btag_event ] .
= 2.6 in = 2.6 in in fig .
[ fig_btag ] we show the b - tagged dijet mass distribution corrected for the @xmath4 efficiency .
also shown is the untagged dijet mass distribution from run 1a , and both are well fit with our standard parameterization @xcite .
the b - tagged dijet data has an upward fluctuation near 600 gev / c@xmath1 .
we model the shape of a narrow resonance using pythia z@xmath3 production and a cdf detector simulation . in fig .
[ fig_btag ] we fit the b - tagged data to a 600 gev / c@xmath1 narrow resonance , and find a cross section of @xmath55 pb ( statistical ) .
note that this is comparable to the dijet fluctuation in both mass and rate . however , there are only 8 events in the last two data bins of fig .
[ fig_btag ] , and the fluctuation is only a @xmath56 effect , so we proceed to set limits on new particle production .
we perform two kinds of fits for the limits .
first , narrow resonances are modelled as described above , and the mass resolution in the cdf detector is shown in fig .
[ fig_b_bbar_res ] .
second , wide resonances characteristic of topgluons @xcite , including interference with normal gluons , was incorporated into pythia and a cdf detector simulation . the mass resolution in fig .
[ fig_b_bbar_res ] displays destructive interference to the left of the resonance ; models with destructive interference on the right side of the resonance will be considered in the future .
= 3.2 in = 3.2 in limits on new particle production are shown in fig .
[ fig_btag_limit ] .
the theoretical cross sections are lowest order and use cteq2l parton distributions . for narrow resonances the production cross sections are nt large enough for us to set mass limits at this time . for topgluons
the production cross sections @xcite are larger , and we are able to exclude at 95% cl topgluons of width @xmath57 in the mass region @xmath58 gev / c@xmath1 , @xmath59 for @xmath60 gev / c@xmath1 , and @xmath61 for @xmath62 gev / c@xmath1 . = 3.0 in = 3.0 in = 7.7 in
to search for new particles decaying to @xmath5 we start with the data sample from the top mass measurement @xcite .
there we used top decays to w + four jets with at least one b - tag , and found 19 events on a background of @xmath63 , resulting in a top mass of @xmath64(stat)@xmath65(sys ) gev / c@xmath1 . that analysis fit the entire event for the top hypothesis , discarding events with @xmath66 ( poor fit ) .
here we add the additional constraint that the top mass is 176 gev / c@xmath1 , which significantly enhances our resolution of the @xmath5 mass .
two of the 19 events fail the @xmath66 cut when the top mass constraint is added to the fit , leaving us with 17 events .
the @xmath5 mass distribution expected from a narrow resonance , normalized to the topcolor @xmath6 predicted rate @xcite , is shown in fig .
[ fig_ttbar ] .
here we used pythia @xmath67 .
also in fig .
[ fig_ttbar ] is the monte carlo distribution of the background , on the left standard model top production from herwig , and on the right qcd w + jets background from vecbos with parton showers from herwig .
all monte carlos include a cdf detector simulation . on the left in fig .
[ fig_ttbar ] , the comparison of the topcolor z@xmath3 to sm @xmath5 simulations illustrates that in this data sample we are sensitive to topcolor @xmath6 up to a mass of roughly 600 gev / c@xmath1 . finally , on the right in fig .
[ fig_ttbar ] , we present the @xmath5 candidate mass distribution from cdf compared to the total standard model prediction . given the statistics the agreement is quite good overall .
the small shoulder of 6 events on a background of @xmath68 in the region @xmath69 gev / c@xmath1 is in an interesting mass region , given the dijet and @xmath4 search results , but is not statistically significant .
upper limits on the @xmath5 cross section as a function of @xmath5 mass , and on a topcolor @xmath6 , are currently in progress .
= 3.1 in = 3.1 in
we have searched for new particles decaying to dijets , @xmath4 , and @xmath5 . in the dijet channel we set the most significant direct mass exclusions to date on the hadronic decays of axigluons ( excluding @xmath70 gev / c@xmath1 ) , excited quarks ( excluding @xmath71 gev / c@xmath1 ) , technirhos ( excluding @xmath34 gev / c@xmath1 ) , w@xmath3 ( excluding @xmath36 gev / c@xmath1 ) , z@xmath35 ( excluding @xmath37 gev / c@xmath1 ) , and for the first time e6 diquarks ( excluding @xmath38 gev / c@xmath1 ) . in the @xmath4 channel
we set the first limits on topcolor , excluding a model of topgluons for width @xmath57 in the mass region @xmath58 gev / c@xmath1 , @xmath59 for @xmath60 gev / c@xmath1 , and @xmath61 for @xmath62 gev / c@xmath1 .
the search for topcolor in the @xmath5 channel has just begun and limits are in progress .
limits are only a consolation prize ; the main emphasis of our search is to explore the possibility of a signal . although we do not have significant evidence for new particle production , the @xmath72 gev / c@xmath1 region shows upward fluctuations in all three channels .
we can not ignore the exciting possibility that these apparently separate fluctuations may be the first signs of a new physics beyond the standard model .
the remaining integrated luminosity for run 1b , currently being accumulated and analyzed , has the potential to either kill the fluctuations or reveal what may be the most interesting new physics in a generation .
+ f. abe et al .
( cdf ) , phys .
lett . * 74 * , 3538 ( 1995 ) .
p. frampton and s. glashow , phys .
b190 * , 157 ( 1987 ) .
u. baur et al . , int . j. mod .
phys a2 , 1285(1987 ) & pr*d42 * , 815(1990 ) .
k. lane et al .
, pr*d44 * , 2768(1991 ) & phys . lett .
* b327 * , 129(1994 ) .
j. hewett and t. rizzo , phys . rep .
* 183 * , 193 ( 1989 ) .
talk by anwar bhatti in these proceedings .
parameterization @xmath73 with parameters a , n and p. for new gauge bosons we use a k - factor to account for higher order terms .
j. botts et al .
( cteq collaboration ) phys . lett . *
b304 * , 159 ( 1993 ) . c. hill and s. parke , phys
. rev . * d49 * , 4454 ( 1994 ) . c. hill , phys .
b345 * , 483 ( 1994 ) .
f. abe et al .
( cdf ) , phys . rev . *
d50*,2966 ( 1994 ) .
f. abe et al .
( cdf ) , phys .
lett . * 74 * , 2626 ( 1995 ) .
we model the interference between normal gluons and topgluons using hybrid model c in phys . rev . * d49 * , 4454 ( 1994 ) .
g. burdman , c. hill , and s. parke private communication .
|
we present three searches for new particles at cdf . first , using 70 pb@xmath0 of data we search the dijet mass spectrum for resonances .
there is an upward fluctuation near 550 gev / c@xmath1 ( 2.6@xmath2 ) with an angular distribution that is adequately described by either qcd alone or qcd plus 5% signal .
there is insufficient evidence to claim a signal , but we set the most stringent mass limits on the hadronic decays of axigluons , excited quarks , technirhos , w@xmath3 , z@xmath3 , and e6 diquarks .
second , using 19 pb@xmath0 of data we search the b - tagged dijet mass spectrum for @xmath4 resonances .
again , an upward fluctuation near 600 gev / c@xmath1 ( 2 @xmath2 ) is not significant enough to claim a signal , so we set the first mass limits on topcolor bosons . finally , using 67 pb@xmath0 of data we search the top quark sample for @xmath5 resonances like a topcolor @xmath6 .
other than an insignificant shoulder of 6 events on a background of 2.4 in the mass region 475 - 550 gev / c@xmath1 , there is no evidence for new particle production .
mass limits , currently in progress , should be sensitive to a topcolor z@xmath3 near 600 gev / c@xmath1 . in all three searches
there is insufficient evidence to claim new particle production , yet there is an exciting possibility that the upward fluctuations are the first signs of new physics beyond the standard model .
fermilab - conf-95/152-e + cdf / pub / exotic / public/3192 + + * search for new particles decaying to dijets , + @xmath4 , and @xmath5 at cdf + * _ fermilab ms 318 + batavia , il 60510 + _
|
the vast majority ( perhaps all ) of stars are formed in a clustered fashion . however , only a very small percentage of older stars are found in bound clusters .
these two observations highlight the importance of clusters in the star - formation process and the significance of cluster disruption .
the process of cluster disruption begins soon after , or concurrent with , cluster formation .
@xcite found that @xmath3 of stars formed in embedded clusters end up in bound clusters after @xmath4 yr .
@xcite and @xcite have shown that at least 20% , but perhaps all , star formation in the merging antennae galaxies is taking place in clusters , the majority of which are likely to become unbound .
the case is similar in m51 , with @xmath5 of all young ( @xmath6 myr ) clusters likely to be destroyed within the first 10s of myr of their lives @xcite . on longer timescales , @xcite and
@xcite noted a clear lack of older ( @xmath7 few gyr ) open clusters in the solar neighbourhood and @xcite found a strong absence of older clusters in m51 , m33 , smc , and the solar neighbourhood .
the lack of old open clusters in the solar neighbourhood is even more striking when compared with the lmc , which contains a significant number of ` blue globular clusters ' with ages well in excess of a gyr ( e.g. @xcite ) .
this difference can be understood either as a difference in the formation history of clusters or as a difference in the disruption timescales .
this later scenario was suggested by @xcite , who directly compared the age distribution of galactic open clusters and the smc cluster population .
he noted that there are @xmath8 times more clusters with an age of 1 gyr in the smc as compared to the solar neighbourhood ( when normalising both populations to an age of @xmath9 yr ) and concluded that disruption mechanisms must be less efficient in the smc .
much theoretical work has gone into the later scenario , with both analytic and numerical models of cluster evolution predicting a strong influence of the galactic tidal field on the dissolution of star clusters ( for a recent review see @xcite ) .
only recently has there been a large push to understand cluster disruption from an observational standpoint in various external potentials , making explicit comparison with models @xcite .
we direct the reader to the review by larsen in these proceedings for a historical look at the observations and theory of cluster disruption . while cluster disruption is a gradual process with several different disruptive agents at work
simultaneously , one can distinguish three general phases of cluster mass loss and disruption .
as we will see , a large fraction of clusters gets destroyed during the _ primary _ phase .
the main phases and corresponding typical timescales of cluster disruption are : _
i ) infant mortality _ ( @xmath0 yr ) , _ ii ) stellar evolution _
( @xmath1 yr ) and _ iii ) tidal relaxation _ ( @xmath2 yr ) . during all three phases
there are additional tidal external perturbations from e.g. giant molecular clouds ( gmcs ) , the galactic disc and spiral arms that heat the cluster and speed up the process of disruption .
however , these external perturbations operate on longer timescales for cluster populations and so are most important in phase iii . in fig .
[ fig0 ] we schematically illustrate the three phases of disruption and the involved time - scales .
note that the number of disruptive agents decreases in time . in this review
we will focus on the physics and observations of phase i as well as on recent population studies aimed at understanding phases ii and iii on a statistical basis .
for a recent review on the physics of phases ii and iii , we refer the reader to @xcite . before proceeding , it is worthwhile to consider our definition of a cluster
. @xcite defines a cluster to be a _ gravitationally bound _
stellar association which will survive for 1020 crossing times .
this definition implies that the stars provide enough gravitational potential to bind the cluster and ignores the role of gas in the early evolution of clusters . in this review
, we will define a cluster as a collection of gas and stars which was _ initially gravitationally bound_. the reason for this definition will become evident in section [ infantmortality ]
recent studies on the populations of young star clusters in m51 @xcite and the antennae galaxies @xcite have shown a large excess of star clusters with ages less than @xmath1010 myr with respect to what would be expected assuming a constant cluster formation rate .
the fact that open clusters in the solar neighbourhood display a similar trend @xcite has led to the conclusion that this is a physical effect and not simply that we are observing these galaxies at a special time in their star - formation history .
if one adopts this view , then we are forced to conclude that the majority ( between 60 - 90% ) of star clusters become unbound when the remaining gas ( i.e. gas that is left - over from the star formation process ) is expelled .
these clusters will survive less than a few crossing times .
suppose that a star cluster is formed out of a sphere of gas with an efficiency @xmath11 , where @xmath12 .
further suppose that the gas and stars are initially in virial equilibrium .
if we define the virial parameter as @xmath13 , with @xmath14 the kinetic energy and @xmath15 the potential energy , virial equilibrium implies @xmath16 .
finally , suppose that the remaining gas is removed on a timescale faster than the crossing time of stars in the cluster .
in such a scenario the cluster is left in a super - virial state after the gas removal , with @xmath17 , and the star cluster will expand since the binding energy is too low for the stellar velocities
. the expanding cluster will reach virial equilibrium after a few crossing times , but only after a ( possibly large ) fraction of the stars have escaped .
this process has been shown to remove a significant amount of the stellar mass of a cluster , and if @xmath18 the entire cluster will become unbound on a timescale of 10s of myr @xcite .
rapid gas removal of the type discussed above leaves distinct observables . in figure [ fig1 ]
we show the surface brightness profiles of three young clusters ( left panels ) as well as two results of @xmath19-body simulations ( right panels ) of clusters including the effects of rapid gas removal .
all three young clusters show an excess of light at large radii with respect to the best fitting eff @xcite or @xcite profiles .
this is in good agreement with the predictions of the simulations , in which an unbound halo of stars is removed ( although still appearing to be associated with the cluster for 10s of myr ) due to the rapid change of the gravitational potential @xcite .
such excess light at large radii has also been found in young clusters in the antennae galaxies @xcite .
@xcite show that for values of @xmath11 of 0.1 and 0.6 , clusters will lose 75% and 10% of the stellar mass respectively within the first @xmath20 myr of their lives .
thus we see that this is an extremely efficient way to rapidly disperse stars from young clusters into the field .
this mechanism provides a natural explanation for the observed diffuse uv light in the field of starburst galaxies @xcite and supports the scenario of these authors that this light is due to rapidly dispersing young clusters .
whether or not a cluster survives this phase , and hence more than 1020 crossing times , is largely dependent on the star - formation efficiency of the gmc core in which the cluster formed .
thus , two clusters with exactly the same parameters ( radius , mass , metallicity , external potential field , etc ) may experience two radically different evolutionary paths if their star - formation efficiencies are different . @xcite
have used the internal dynamical properties of young clusters in order to estimate their @xmath11-values .
no clear trend of @xmath11 on cluster ( stellar ) mass or radius was found .
-body simulations which include the rapid removal of gas which was left over from a non-100% star - formation efficiency ( right ) .
the solid ( red ) and dashed ( blue ) lines are the best fitting eff @xcite and king @xcite profiles respectively .
note the excess of light at large radii with respect to the best fitting eff profile in both the observations and models .
this excess light is due to an unbound expanding halo of stars caused by the rapid ejection of the remaining gas after the cluster forms .
_ hence , excess light at large radii strongly implies that these clusters are not in dynamical equilibrium . _ for details of the modeling and observations see @xcite and @xcite.,height=340 ] even if a cluster survives the gas removal phase , this phase can significantly effect the observed properties of the cluster .
hence , deducing the initial properties of a cluster from its current state is not trivial . @xcite
have noted the strong effect of residual gas removal on inferring the initial stellar mass of a cluster , while @xcite have refined the mass loss estimates and shown that measurements of the current radii of young clusters may not reflect the initial nor the final value .
additionally , @xcite show that this effect can mimic stellar imf variations in young clusters .
the clusters that have survived the gas removal phase are subject to disruption phases ii and iii ( [ subsec : phases ] ) as well as tidal effects .
disruption due to these effects can be studied on individual clusters , of which the recent observations of the dissolving globular clusters palomar 5 @xcite are probably the most spectacular example . however ,
much can be learned by approaching this problem from a cluster population point of view .
suppose that clusters are formed continuously with a constant cluster formation rate ( a constraint which we can relax later ) .
also , we will assume that we know the cluster initial mass function ( here taken to be a power law of the form @xmath21 with @xmath22 ( e.g. @xcite ) and that clusters can be detected down to a known magnitude limit .
finally , we will assume that the disruption time of a cluster depends on the cluster mass , such that more massive clusters survive longer ( on average ) than lower mass clusters .
for this final assumption we will adopt a function of the form : @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the disruption time of a @xmath25 cluster and @xmath26 @xcite .
the beauty of this formulation is that it only has two variables , @xmath24 and @xmath27 , and as we will see , provides extremely good fits to observations .
the formulation provided above , when combined with the given assumptions , allows for the parameters @xmath24 and @xmath27 to be found from age and mass distributions of clusters . the first survey using this technique
was carried out by @xcite on cluster populations in m51 , m33 , the smc , and the solar neighbourhood .
they made a _ sudden disruption _
assumption , meaning that the cluster is in the sample with its initial mass until , when it is disrupted .
the somewhat surprising result from this study was that , while @xmath27 had more or less the same value in all environments studied ( @xmath28 ) , @xmath24 varied by over two orders of magnitude , with values of @xmath29 myr in the central regions of m51 to @xmath30 gyr in the smc . the simple _ sudden disruption _
assumption was improved in a more recent model by @xcite , where a gradual loss of cluster mass was implemented .
they assumed that the cluster mass decreases exponentially with a time - scale that decreases as the cluster mass decreases .
this is done by saying that the mass loss per unit time ( ) relates to as : @xmath31 with @xmath32 from eq .
[ eq : ihavebeentypingthisequationtoomuchinmylife ] .
this very simple analytical description for cluster mass loss shows remarkably good agreement when compared to the mass loss following from the detailed @xmath19-body simulations of @xcite . in fig .
[ dm_lamers ] we show a direct comparison of @xmath33 from the @xmath19-body simulations of clusters with different density profiles and on different orbits ( left ) and the above mentioned analytical model of @xcite ( right ) . in both graphs the time is normalised to and only the mass loss due to stars escaping the cluster is shown , i.e. mass loss due to stellar evolution ( sev ) is not shown .
in addition , there is a coupling between the two types of mass loss : if stars loose mass , the cluster will expand and more stars are pushed over the tidal boundary .
the simulations of @xcite considered sev , therefore , their results shown in fig . [ dm_lamers ] do include tidal induced by sev .
for this reason we can simply add the mass loss due to sev , taken from an ssp model , to eq . [ eq : dm ] .
-body simulations of clusters with different number of stars , different concentration and on different orbits ( left ) .
the mass loss due to stellar evolution is not shown . in the right panel the analytical model of @xcite is shown.,title="fig:",width=255]-body simulations of clusters with different number of stars , different concentration and on different orbits ( left ) . the mass loss due to stellar evolution is not shown .
in the right panel the analytical model of @xcite is shown.,title="fig:",width=255 ] in a series of follow - up works , it has been shown that the similarity of the value of @xmath27 in various environments strongly implies a uniformity in the cluster disruption process , while the varying values of @xmath24 is due to the different tidal field strengths _ ( and gas contents ) _ of the galaxies studied .
galaxies with strong tidal fields , as , for example , derived from their rotation curves , having shorter disruption times @xcite .
comparison with results of realistic @xmath19-body models performed by @xcite have placed this empirical disruption law on a solid physical footing @xcite .
@xcite have also derived a formula for the predicted mass and age distributions of cluster samples that includes both stellar evolution and disruption for any star formation history .
@xcite inserted the lamers disruption law into a cluster population synthesis model .
this method has two distinct advantages over the earlier formulations .
the first is that it removes the requirement of a constant cluster formation rate , and second , it uses the age and mass distributions together to find @xmath27 and @xmath24 .
the case of m51 is shown in fig .
one first begins by constructing an observed number density grid in age - mass space ( upper - left panel where the shading corresponds to the logarithm of the number of clusters found within that cell ) .
then one generates a large number of models with different values of @xmath24 , @xmath27 , ( time dependent ) cluster formation rates , etc . and compares these models with the observed grid .
the resultant @xmath34 diagram is shown in the bottom panel of fig .
the best fit model is shown in the top right panel of fig .
[ fig2 ] . this cluster population synthesis ( cps )
technique , also used in a similar way by @xcite to derive the properties of the cluster population in the galaxy ngc 3627 , holds great promise in disentangling the myriad of effects present in cluster populations . in principle , the dependences of cluster size , galactocentric radius , star - formation efficiency dependent infant mortality rates , or alternative cluster disruption models can be taken into account by this technique .
for this technique to be fully exploited one needs large samples of cluster populations with known ages and masses .
datasets suitable for these kind of studies are beginning to be collected and released .
several face - on spiral galaxies have been imaged in multiple filters with the high resolution / wide field _
hst / acs _ camera ( e.g @xcite for m101 and for m51 ) . and @xmath24 .
* bottom : * the @xmath34 diagram in @xmath27-@xmath24 space .
the best fitting model is marked with an x , while the accepted fits ( @xmath35 ) are shaded .
reproduced from @xcite.,title="fig:",width=226 ] and @xmath24 .
* bottom : * the @xmath34 diagram in @xmath27-@xmath24 space .
the best fitting model is marked with an x , while the accepted fits ( @xmath35 ) are shaded .
reproduced from @xcite.,title="fig:",width=226 ] and @xmath24 .
* bottom : * the @xmath34 diagram in @xmath27-@xmath24 space .
the best fitting model is marked with an x , while the accepted fits ( @xmath35 ) are shaded .
reproduced from @xcite.,title="fig:",width=226 ] it is worth noting possible objections to the lamers disruption law .
the first comes from @xcite who find that in the antennae galaxies the number of clusters decreases in time ( @xmath36 ) as @xmath37 , independent of cluster mass .
this may be explained if the disruption timescale @xmath24 due to tidal field effects ( e.g. phase ii & iii ) is greater than or similar to the maximum age in the sample .
the cluster disruption due to tidal effects would not yet be present in the @xcite sample , instead the decrease in cluster numbers would be the result of infant mortality and the fading of clusters .
studies of infant mortality in m51 also suggest that the effect is mass independent @xcite .
in fact , if infant mortality was not ( mostly ) independent of cluster mass we would expect the embedded cluster mass function to be significantly different from the optically selected cluster mass function . in fig .
[ fig : mf ] we show the dependence of the mass function slope of a multiple age cluster population on the ratio of the @xmath38 and the maximum age of the cluster in the sample ( ) .
clusters were created continuously over 1 gyr with an initial mass function of a power - law with index @xmath39 .
the lamers disruption law was applied in the same way as in @xcite .
the important thing to take away from this figure is that as approaches and exceeds the mass function is less affected by disruption and so it retains its initial form , i.e. the right panel in fig .
[ fig : mf ] probably applies to the @xcite sample . )
.,height=151 ] a second observation seemingly contradicting the lamers disruption law is that of @xcite who find an intermediate age ( @xmath40 gyr ) globular cluster in m33 . in m33 ,
@xcite find a @xmath24 value of @xmath41 myr , implying a disruption time of @xmath42 gyr for a @xmath43 cluster .
however , as the authors note , the value of @xmath24 derived by @xcite was presumably of the thin disk of the galaxy , and if the intermediate - age cluster is part of the thick - disk or halo of the galaxy then the expected value of @xmath24 would be significantly larger than that quoted . additionally , it should also be noted that the mass derived by @xcite is the _ present _ mass of the cluster .
the cluster presumably started with a much higher mass and disruptive effects have brought this cluster into its current state .
if the present mass of the cluster is @xmath44 , then its initial mass ( after infant weight loss ) would have been @xmath45 ( assuming an age of 5 gyr ) , using the value of @xmath24 for m33 given by @xcite .
-body models of @xcite ) disruption time of a @xmath46 cluster , @xmath24 , as a function of the mean density @xmath47 in @xmath48pc@xmath49 of the host galaxy . reproduced from @xcite.,width=340 ] as more and more galaxies ( and environments )
have their characteristic disruption timescales measured , it is useful to compare the results to @xmath19-body models in order to check for consistency between the two .
this was done in @xcite who compared the @xmath24 values derived for the smc , m33 , m51 and the solar neighbourhood to the @xmath19-body models of @xcite and @xcite which sample a large range in the ambient densities of the host galaxies .
their results , shown in fig .
[ fig3 ] , are intriguing . while the predicted and observed disruption time of the smc are in excellent agreement , the disruption times of the galaxy , m33 and m51 are observed to be much shorter than predicted by @xmath19-body models .
this result is particularly surprising given the fact that the mass loss predictions of a single cluster are in excellent agreement between the lamers empirical description and that given by @xmath19-body models ( @xcite and fig .
[ dm_lamers ] ) .
= @xmath46 with @xmath50 . *
top : * the motion of the gmc is along the x - axis and the line of sight is perpendicular . *
bottom : * the motion of the gmc is into the page and the line of sight is along the gmc trajectory .
the arrows in the left - hand lower corner of the left - hand panels are parallel to the direction of motion of the gmc .
the gmc is shown with grey shades based on the surface density of a gmc with a@xmath51 = 5.8a@xmath52 .
the time with respect to the moment of encounter is indicated in each panel of the top row .
see @xcite for a description of the methods and parameters used.,width=529 ] thus , we are left to ask , what physical effects are not included in the @xmath19-body models that may be responsible for disrupting clusters ?
the @xmath19-body models used in the comparison were carried out in a smooth logarithmic potential which does not realistically represent the thin disk components of disk galaxies . @xcite
have attempted to add encounters with giant molecular clouds ( gmcs ) and spiral arm passages to the @xmath19-body models . in fig .
[ fig4 ] we show an example of a cluster - gmc encounter ( from @xcite ) .
the parameters of this run are for typical open clusters and gmcs in the solar neighbourhood .
the top panels show an edge - on view for five different time steps , while the bottom panels show a view along the trajectory of the gmc .
encounters with gmcs present the most important external perturbation which cause mass loss of star in clusters .
@xcite find that due to encounters with gmcs scales as @xmath53 where @xmath54 for the solar neighbourhood and @xmath55 scales with the surface density of individual gmcs ( @xmath56 ) and the global gmc density ( @xmath57 ) as @xmath58 .
the scaling of @xmath55 with @xmath57 implies that it does not matter if the molecular gas is distributed over a large number of low mass clouds or a small number of massive ( giant ) clouds .
this makes it easy to estimate from the observed molecular gas density .
indeed , for m51 , where the molecular gas density is about an order of magnitude higher than in the solar neighbourhood , a from eq .
[ eq : tdis_gmcs ] of 150 myr is predicted .
this corresponds well with the value derived from observations of @xmath59 myr @xcite .
note that eq .
[ eq : tdis_gmcs ] implies a scaling of with the cluster density ( @xmath60 ) .
this seems different than the dependence with discussed before .
however , there is only a very shallow relation observed between cluster half - mass radius ( ) and , of the form @xmath61 @xcite . with this relation , and eq .
[ eq : tdis_gmcs ] , it follows that for external perturbations @xmath62 , i.e. very close to the index of @xmath63 found from observations discussed in [ subsec : appl_pops ] .
this suggests that the disruptive effect of the tidal field and additional external perturbations can be added linearly , resulting in a that depends on as @xmath64 .
this can explain the large variation found in the @xmath38 value derived from observations and the almost constant @xmath65 @xcite . in [ sec : discussion
] we discuss some of the pitfalls of these results .
as seen in the proceeding sections , the observed disruption time of star clusters in the solar neighbourhood is a factor of @xmath66 shorter than predicted by @xmath19-body models .
the inclusion of spiral arm passages and gmc encounters into @xmath19-body models is a promising way to bring the predictions into agreement with the observations .
this was recently done by @xcite who found excellent agreement after the inclusion gmc encounters and spiral arm passages .
they assume that the different mass loss effects ( stellar evolution , tidal field and external perturbations ) can be added linearly . using the mass - radius relation of
[ subsec : tdis_external ] and the results from @xcite and @xcite they analytically model the mass loss due to different effects analytically .
this is illustrated in the left panel of fig .
[ fig5 ] ( from @xcite ) . based on this mass loss description ,
the age distribution of open clusters in the solar neighbourhood can be predicted ( instead of fitted , as was done hitherto ) .
the results are shown in the right panel of fig .
[ fig5 ] . cluster due to various disruptive effects . *
right : * comparison between the observed age distribution of open clusters ( from ) and the predictions from @xcite for three different maximum masses .
, title="fig:",width=255 ] cluster due to various disruptive effects . *
right : * comparison between the observed age distribution of open clusters ( from ) and the predictions from @xcite for three different maximum masses . , title="fig:",width=255 ]
we showed in
[ sec : populations]&[sec : external ] that the simple lamers disruption law can successfully explain the age and mass distribution of young star clusters populations . here
we will discuss other observations lending support to the lamers law and some of the standing problems and uncertainties of this scenario which need further attention . @xcite use a variety of studies to look at the cluster population of the lmc .
they also find a lack of old clusters ( with respect to what would be expected from a continuous cluster formation rate ) and derive @xmath67 , again in agreement with other galaxies studied by @xcite and @xcite .
note that a lower value of @xmath27 is expected to be observed when the typical is of the same order as the oldest clusters in the sample ( fig .
[ fig : mf ] ) , as is the case in lmc . outside the local group , the strongly interacting galaxy ngc
6745 has been studied by @xcite who found evidence for mass dependent disruption , with @xmath68 .
the rich cluster system of the intermediate - age merger remnant ngc 1316 shows a clear bimodal colour distribution , with the red component presumably being formed during the merger .
@xcite showed , using deep _ hst - acs _ images that if one breaks the red component into ` inner ' and ` outer ' regions ( with respect to the galactic centre ) , that the outer region is a continuous power - law while the inner region shows a power - law behavior at the high luminosity end and a flattening at the low luminosity end .
the authors interpret this as evidence for mass - dependent cluster disruption , although no attempt was made to find the characteristic disruption timescale or the value of @xmath27 .
one standing problem with the lamers disruption law , also present in other studies on disruption , is whether or not an initial power - law cluster initial mass function ( cimf ) can be transformed into a log - normal distribution , which is observed for old globular cluster populations .
the lamers law can create such a turnover , however the precise value of the turnover mass should be dependent on the ambient density @xcite , meaning that cluster disruption should be more efficient in the inner regions of a galaxy than in the outer regions .
thus , without fine tuning the models ( e.g. having the same disruption time at all radii due to large radially dependent velocity anisotropies ) one would expect a radially dependent turnover peak in the globular cluster mass function , which is not observed . for a more detailed description of this problem ,
see the review by larsen in these proceedings .
additionally , as noted by @xcite the lamers disruption over - predicts the number of low - mass clusters when applied to old globular cluster populations .
in [ subsec : tdis_external ] we showed that the scaling of with is a power - law with exponent @xmath63 .
this scaling is similar for two - body evaporation in a tidal field with external perturbations , such as shocks by gmcs and spiral arms , and agrees well with the observations .
however , there are still some caveats in the theory explaining this , mostly coming from questions regarding the initial conditions of the simulations . 1 .
the first caveat stems from the relation between initial mass and radius of the clusters used in the simulations .
if we parameterize this relation as @xmath69 @xmath70 , then @xcite use @xmath71 , implying that their clusters fill their tidal radius .
however , observations imply that @xmath72 ( with a large scatter ) @xcite , implying that is mostly independent of mass .
this shallow relation implies that massive clusters are not filling their tidal radius , which would change the dependence of with @xcite .
2 . in the derivation of @xmath27 for external shocks ( [ subsec : tdis_external ] ) , only clusters in isolation were considered .
how would the presence of a tidal field affect this result ? 3 .
how does the relation for change if there exists a relation between the concentration parameter and mass of a cluster ( i.e. as seen in the galactic gcs reported by larsen in these proceedings ) ? 4 .
could an initial mass - radius relation with @xmath73 be erased during the gas removal phase ?
what is the effect of the initial mass / luminosity profile used in the simulations and how does it evolve ?
e.g. are clusters born with eff profiles which are converted into king profiles ? does the cluster concentration alter its mass loss evolution ? 6 .
how do the external perturbations and the galactic tidal field cooperate ?
can the mass loss due to both effects simply be added linearly ?
barmby , p. , kuntz , k. d. , huchra , j. p. , & brodie , j. p. 2006
, , 132 , 883 bastian , n. & goodwin , s.p .
2006 , mnras , 369 , l9 bastian , n. , gieles , m. , lamers , h.j.g.l.m . ,
scheepmaker , r. a. , & de grijs , r. 2005 , a&a 431 , 905 baumgardt , h. , & makino , j. 2003 , mnras , 340 , 227 baumgardt , h. 2006 : globular clusters : guides to galaxies ( astro - ph/0605125 ) boily , c.m . & kroupa , p. 2003a , mnras , 338 , 665 boily , c.m . & kroupa , p. 2003b , mnras , 338 , 673 boutloukos , s.g . &
lamers , h.j.g.l.m .
2003 , mnras , 338 , 717 chandar , r. , leitherer , c. , tremonti , c.a . ,
calzetti , d. , aloisi , a. , meurer , g.r .
, & de mello , d. 2005 , apj , 628 , 210 chandar , r. , puzia , t.h . , sarajedini , a. , goudfrooij , p. 2006 ,
apjl , in press ( astro - ph/0606419 ) de grijs , r. , anders , p. , bastian , n. , lynds , r. , lamers , h.j.g.l.m . ,
oneil , e.j .
2003 , mnras , 343 , 1285 de grijs , r. , & anders , p. 2006 ,
mnras , 366 , 295 dolphin , a.e . ,
& kennicutt , r.c .
2002 , aj , 124 , 158 elson , r.a.w . ,
fall , m.s . , & freeman , k.c .
1987 , apj 323 , 54 ( eff ) , s. m. & zhang , q. 2001 , , 561 , 751 fall , s.m . ,
chandar , r. & whitmore , b.c .
2005 , apj , 631 , l133 gascoigne , s. c. b. 1966 , , 134 , 59 gieles , m. , bastian , n. , lamers , h.j.g.l.m . , & mout , j.n .
2005 , a&a , 441 , 949 gieles , m. , athanassoula e. , portegies zwart s. f. , 2006b , mnras , submitted , m. , larsen , s. s. , scheepmaker , r. a. , et al .
2006 , , 446 , l9 gieles , m. , portegies zwart , s.f . ,
baumgardt , h. athanassoula , e. , lamers , h.j.g.l.m . ,
sipior , m. , leenaarts , j. 2006c , , 371 , 793 goudfrooij , p. , gilmore , d. , whitmore , b.c . , & schweizer , f. 2004 , apj , 613 , l121 goodwin , s.p . 1997a , mnras , 284 , 785 goodwin , s.p .
1997b , mnras , 286 , 669 goodwn , s.p . &
bastian , n. 2006 , mnras , in press ( astro - ph/0609477 ) hodge , p. 1987
, , 99 , 724 , n. v. , piskunov , a. e. , rser , s. , schilbach , e. , & scholz , r .- d .
2005 , , 438 , 1163 king , i. 1962 , aj 67 , 471 kroupa , p. & boily , c.m .
2002 , mnras , 336 , 1188 lada , c.j . & lada , e.a .
2003 , ara&a , 41 , 57 lamers , h.j.g.l.m . ,
gieles , m. , bastian , n. , baumgardt , h. , & kharchenko , n.v . 2005a , a&a , 117 , 129 lamers , h.j.g.l.m .
, gieles , m. , & protegies zwart , s.f .
2005b , a&a , 429 , 173 lamers , h.j.g.l.m . & gieles , m. 2006 , a&a , 455 , l17 , s. s. 2004 , , 416 , 537 odenkirchen , m. , et al .
2001 , , 548 , l165 oort , j. h. 1958 , ricerche astronomiche , 5 , 507 portegies zwart , s.f . ,
hut , p. , & makino , j. 1998 , a&a , 337 , 363 portegies zwart , s.f . ,
makino , j. , mcmillan , s.l.w .
, & hut , p. 2002
, apj , 565 , 265 schweizer , f. 2006 : globular clusters : guides to galaxies ( astro - ph/0606036 ) , l. 1987 , dynamical evolution of globular clusters ( princeton , nj , princeton university press , 1987 , 191 p. ) tanikawa , a. , & fukushige , t. 2005 , , 57 , 155 tremonti , c.a . ,
calzetti , d. , leitherer , c. , & heckman , t.m .
2001 , apj , 555 , 322 tutukov , a.v .
1978 , a&a , 70 , 57 , e. 1998 , , 299 , 1019 , e. & zepf , s. e. 2003 , , 587 , l97 waters , c.z . ,
zepf , s.e . , lauer , t.r , baltz , e.a . , & silk , j. 2006 , apj , in press ( astro - ph/0607238 ) wielen , r. 1971 , a&a , 13 , 309 whitmore , b.c .
zhang , q. , leitherer , c. , et al . 1999b , aj , 118 , 1551 whitmore , b. c. 2003 , in a decade of hst science , eds .
mario livio , keith noll & massimo stiavelli , ( cambridge : cambridge university press ) , 153 .
( widely referenced as whitmore 2000 , astro - ph/0012546 ) zhang , q. , & fall , s. m. 1999 , , 527 , l81
|
we review the theory and observations of star cluster disruption .
the three main phases and corresponding typical timescales of cluster disruption are : _
i ) infant mortality _ ( @xmath0 yr ) , _ ii ) stellar evolution _ ( @xmath1 yr ) and _ iii ) tidal relaxation _ ( @xmath2 yr ) . during all three phases
there are additional tidal external perturbations from the host galaxy . in this review
we focus on the physics and observations of phase i and on population studies of phases ii & iii and external perturbations ( concentrating on cluster - gmc interactions ) .
particular attention is given to the successes and short - comings of the lamers cluster disruption law , which has recently been shown to stand on a firm physical footing .
|
even kakutani equivalence is one of the most natural examples in the theory of restricted orbit equivalence of ergodic and finite measure preserving dynamical systems . in this paper
we study even kakutani equivalence in the nearly continuous category .
a nearly continuous dynamical system is given by a triple @xmath13 , where @xmath2 is a polish space , @xmath14 is a borel probability measure on @xmath2 , and @xmath15 is an ergodic measure preserving homeomorphism . recall that a measurable orbit equivalence between two such systems @xmath13 and @xmath16 is an invertible , bi - measurable , and measure preserving map @xmath17 that sends orbits to orbits . a measurable orbit equivalence @xmath18 is a _ nearly continuous orbit equivalence _ if there exist invariant and @xmath11 subsets @xmath19 and @xmath20 of full measure so that @xmath21 is a homeomorphism .
the first result in this category is the celebrated theorem of keane and smorodinsky @xcite that any two bernoulli shifts of equal entropy are finitarily isomorphic , namely , that the isomorphism between them can be made a homeomorphism almost everywhere . in a later paper , denker and keane
@xcite established a general framework for studying measure preserving systems that also preserve a topological structure .
we refer the reader to a paper by del junco , rudolph , and weiss @xcite for a more complete history of the area .
we only mention here that interest in the orbit equivalence theory for this category was more recently revived by the work of hamachi and keane in @xcite where they proved that the binary and ternary odometers are nearly continuously orbit equivalent .
their work inspired similar results for other pairs of examples ( see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite ) .
these examples were later subsumed as special cases of a dye s theorem in this category proved by del junco and ahin @xcite . around the same time as a nearly continuous dye
s theorem was established , del junco , rudolph , and weiss proved in @xcite that if one does not impose the condition that the invariant sets of full measure on which the orbit equivalence is a homeomorphism are @xmath11 sets , then any restricted orbit equivalence classification is exactly the same as in the measure theoretic case . in particular
, they showed that any orbit equivalence can be regularized to be a homeomorphism on a set of full measure , but could not prove that the set of full measure had any topological structure .
the importance of the topological structure in the theory is even more striking for the study of even kakutani equivalence .
recall that in the measurable category two ergodic and finite measure preserving systems @xmath13 and @xmath16 are even kakutani equivalent if there exists a measurable orbit equivalence @xmath22 , and measurable sets @xmath23 with @xmath24 with the property that @xmath25 is a measurable isomorphism of the induced transformations @xmath7 and @xmath26 .
we call the orbit equivalence @xmath6 an _ even kakutani equivalence _ between @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
it follows from @xcite that any even kakutani equivalence can be made to be a homeomorphism on a set of full measure . in the same paper
they show that if one imposes the additional condition that the sets @xmath12 and @xmath27 be _ nearly clopen _ , meaning within a set of measure zero of an open set and also of a closed set , then there is a new invariant for even kakutani equivalence of nearly continuous dynamical systems called _ near unique ergodicity_. they use this new invariant to show that nearly continuous even kakutani equivalence is stronger than measure theoretic even kakutani equivalence .
the example they construct is , in some sense , not natural , and begs the question whether there are any natural examples of nearly continuous systems that are measurably evenly kakutani equivalent but not nearly continuously so .
rudolph began looking for examples in the family of zero entropy loosely bernoulli systems .
recall that any two zero entropy loosely bernoulli transformations are measurably even kakutani equivalent .
furthermore , many natural examples of nearly continuous systems including rotations , all adding machines , and in fact all finite rank transformations , are loosely bernoulli . in @xcite ,
roychowdhury and rudolph proved that any two adding machines are nearly continuously even kakutani equivalent .
shortly after , dykstra and rudolph showed in @xcite that all irrational rotations are nearly continuously kakutani equivalent to the binary odometer . in @xcite , new machinery , called _ templates _
, was introduced to construct the nearly continuous kakutani equivalence .
there , templates were defined using the natural topological tower structure present in adding machines .
the construction in @xcite showed that the template machinery can be adapted to the case where the underlying system does not have a canonical symbolic structure .
more recently , springer @xcite expanded on their ideas and adapted templates further to prove that all minimal isometries of compact metric spaces are nearly continuously kakutani equivalent to the binary odometer .
salvi @xcite adapted templates to the setting of @xmath28 actions and used the machinery to prove rudolph s two - step coding theorem in the nearly continuous category .
each result mentioned above has required more sophisticated and technically intricate incarnations of templates . on the other hand
each proof has also established the usefulness and flexibility of the machinery . in this paper
we adapt the template machinery even further to show our main result : the morse minimal system is nearly continuously even kakutani equivalent to the binary odometer . the version of the template machinery in this paper is designed to address the new complication of the additional tower present in the rank two morse system .
we believe the generalization we give here is the appropriate starting place to prove more generally that finite rank nearly continuous systems are all nearly continuously kakutani equivalent to the binary odometer .
finally we note that this manuscript is a culmination of work that the first author began in 2009 while he was a post - doctoral fellow working with daniel rudolph at colorado state university .
the initial architecture of the constructions and the main ideas were all established collaboratively by dykstra and rudolph .
the second author joined the project after the untimely death of rudolph in 2010 , and the manuscript was completed in 2014 .
in this section , deferring some formal definitions until later , we give an overview of the construction and introduce templates .
let @xmath29 denote the morse minimal system and @xmath30 the binary odometer . recall that each system has a canonical refining , generating sequence of clopen partitions that are given by the finite rank structure of each system .
the morse system is rank two , so at each stage the partition is defined by a pair of towers .
the odometer is rank one , so the sequence of partitions is defined by a sequence of single towers .
the construction of the orbit equivalence uses an inductive back and forthprocedure .
intuitively , at each stage we need to construct a set map from the levels of the tower of one system to the levels of the tower of the other system , switching the domain and range of the set maps at each stage .
the orbit equivalence will be defined on the set of points for which our procedure will converge . in order for this set to be
a @xmath11 set , and the map to be a homeomorphism , for each point where we have convergence we need to have the procedure stabilize after a finite number of steps .
in other words , once we have defined the set map at a particular stage @xmath31 , we can not modify its domain at any successive stage .
this introduces an obvious complication in the construction . at a particular stage @xmath31
, we have to know that our choice of the set map on stage @xmath31 towers will be consistent with the choices that we will make for all stages after . to address this complication , informally speaking ,
we do not actually choose a particular set map at any stage .
instead , at each stage we construct a collection of set maps that are possible extensions of previous stage set maps , and that all agree on a set we call _ the good set_. the convergence then depends on us being able to provide enough choices at each stage @xmath31 so that it is possible to construct sufficiently many choices of maps at stage @xmath32 that extend the @xmath31-stage maps .
templates are a combinatorial tool that have been designed to facilitate the intensive book keeping required to describe such a procedure .
formally , _ template _ is an ordered multiset .
for example , the multiset @xmath33 , together with the ordering @xmath34 , gives a template @xmath35 , which we write as @xmath36 the elements of a template ( with multiplicity ) are called _
levels_. in our work , each level of a template will correspond to a clopen set that is a level of a tower .
in particular , the towers themselves can be thought of as templates where each level appears exactly once and the ordering on the levels is exactly the ordering on the sets that is imposed by the underlying dynamics .
notice that a set map from one tower to another can be thought of as a re - ordering of the levels of the domain tower according to the levels that they are being mapped to in the image tower .
we replace the notion of a set map with maps between templates , where the re - ordering is not described by the map , but rather the ordering given by the image template .
more formally , given templates @xmath35 and @xmath37 , written @xmath38 we _ represent _ @xmath35 and @xmath37 with the intervals @xmath39 \subset { \mathbb z}\hspace{1 cm } \mbox{and } \hspace{1 cm } j = [ 0 , 1 , \ldots , m-1 ] \subset { \mathbb z}\ ] ] via the correspondences @xmath40 and @xmath41 . a _ partial interval bijection _
is an ordered quintuple @xmath42 $ ] , where @xmath43 , @xmath44 , and @xmath45 is some bijection .
this perspective allows for an explicit combinatorial understanding of how many maps need to be defined at each stage in order to construct maps at later stages , on larger domains .
it also allows for an explicit combinatorial description of how maps from one stage are constructed from maps of a previous stage , so it is easy to prove that the construction has indeed stabilized for points on a @xmath11 set of full measure . in our proof we will construct an increasing sequence @xmath46 , templates for each system and partial interval bijections between template sets that constitute the back and forth " diagram given in figure [ thefigure ] below .
the objects in the diagram are template sets .
the template sets on the left ( @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 ) belong to the morse minimal system , while those on the right ( @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , and @xmath54 ) belong to the binary odometer .
the maps @xmath55 are partial interval bijections .
a key ingredient of the diagram is its _ almost commutative _ nature , as introduced by roychowdhury and rudolph in @xcite . interpreting the levels of templates as levels of towers that form a refining sequence of partitions
, we see that every level at stage @xmath31 of a tower is a subset of a level from a previous stage template , and the maps @xmath56 and @xmath57 are the natural inclusion maps .
the consistency of set maps from one level to another is achieved by requiring that on the good set , all partial interval bijections agree when composed with @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
there are two key differences our work here and that of @xcite or @xcite in how we use templates from a particular stage to construct later stage templates . in particular , we can not use the notion of concatenation as was defined in the earlier papers , instead we define _ overlapping concatenations_. in addition , to accommodate the combinatoric structure of the towers of the morse minimal system we introduce a new family of partial interval bijections called _ reordering maps_. once the diagram is built up , however , the argument that it produces a well - defined nearly continuous kakutani equivalence is nearly identical to the arguments in both @xcite and @xcite .
we include it here for completeness ( see sections [ convergenceofpibs ] and [ kakequivalence ] ) . it is our hope that one day we might discover a more general machine that could characterize broad classes of systems , perhaps even all zero entropy loosely bernoulli systems .
but at the moment it is not clear how such a machine , if one exists , could be sufficiently general to account for the differences between systems .
the paper is organized as follows : section [ overview ] : : we define the tools for constructing templates and partial interval bijections that we will use throughout the construction .
sections [ morsepreliminaries ] - [ binarypreliminaries ] : : we give preliminary definitions of the morse minimal system and the binary odometer . in particular , we define the template sets @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 , and @xmath61 , for @xmath62 .
these template sets are given by the towers in the respective system .
section [ omegaksection ] : : we define the template sets @xmath63 and @xmath64 , for @xmath62
. these are templates in the odometer system that are rearrangements of the tower templates , reflecting set maps that map morse towers to odometer towers .
section [ stage2 ] : : we construct stage @xmath65 of the diagram by explicitly defining @xmath66 , along with the partial interval bijections @xmath67 .
section [ tksection ] : : we define the template sets @xmath68 and @xmath69 , for @xmath62 .
these are new templates in the morse system , describing how odometer towers will be mapped to morse towers .
section [ sequences ] : : we define the sequence @xmath46 recursively . sections [ freqnotation ] - [ stage8 ] : : we assume the diagram has been built down to stage @xmath31 , where @xmath31 is even , and show how to build it down to stage @xmath70 . because the construction depends on whether @xmath71 or @xmath72 , we proceed as follows : + * in sections [ freqnotation ] - [ blockpartitionsoftauhat ] , we introduce notation and machinery that is used for every even @xmath31 . * in sections [ thegoodset ] - [ stage4missingextra ] , we illustrate the @xmath73 case by building the diagram down to stage @xmath74 . * in sections [ stage6bigpicture ] - [ stage6missingextra ]
, we illustrate the @xmath72 case by building the diagram down to stage @xmath75 . * in section [ stage8 ] ,
we indicate how the induction looks in stages @xmath76 .
sections [ convergenceofpibs ] - [ kakequivalence ] : : we use the properties of the diagram to prove that our procedure produces a nearly continuous kakutani equivalence between the two systems .
in this section we introduce the terminology and tools necessary to build and extend partial interval bijections .
[ domainandrange ] given templates @xmath35 and @xmath37 , and a partial interval bijection @xmath42 $ ] from @xmath35 to @xmath37 , the _ domain _ of @xmath77 consists of those levels in @xmath35 that are represented by @xmath12 .
the _ range _ of @xmath77 consists of those levels in @xmath37 that are represented by @xmath27 . for the next definition , suppose @xmath78 is another template which , like @xmath37 , is represented by @xmath79
. suppose there is a partial interval bijection @xmath80 $ ] from @xmath35 to @xmath81 .
note that @xmath82 and @xmath83 agree in their first three components ( @xmath84 , @xmath85 , and @xmath12 ) .
[ match ] suppose @xmath86 and @xmath87 are two partial interval bijections , given by @xmath42 $ ] and @xmath88 $ ] .
then @xmath77 and @xmath89 _ match _ if , for each integer @xmath90 , the level in @xmath37 that is represented by @xmath91 is identical to the level in @xmath81 that is represented by @xmath92 .
two partial interval bijections are _ equivalent _ if one is a translate of the other .
more precisely , @xmath93 \sim [ i ' , j ' , a ' , b ' , f']$ ] if there exist @xmath94 and @xmath95 , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 , and @xmath99 . given a partial interval bijection @xmath42 $ ] , the _ inverse _ of @xmath77 is the partial interval bijection @xmath100 $ ] .
suppose @xmath101 $ ] for @xmath102 are two partial interval bijections , and assume each @xmath103 and @xmath104 begin at @xmath105 .
let @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
define the _ simple concatenation _ of @xmath108 and @xmath109 by @xmath110,\ ] ] where @xmath111 note that this is an associative semigroup action on the space of all partial interval bijections . also note that , if @xmath108 and @xmath109 are partial interval bijections , then so is @xmath112 . for our construction , some partial interval bijections will need to be decomposed into a form @xmath113 where @xmath114 and @xmath115 make up a very small portion of the overall map .
we will refer to @xmath114 and @xmath115 as the _ bottom _ and _ top sticky notes _ of @xmath77 .
the _ body _ is @xmath116 .
we will often want to glue " partial interval bijections together . top and bottom sticky notes will be our means of doing this via the following definition .
[ overlapconcatenation1 ] suppose @xmath101 $ ] for @xmath102 are two partial interval bijections that are decomposed via ( [ stage2pibstructure ] ) as @xmath117 if @xmath118
, then define the _ overlapping concatenation _ of @xmath108 and @xmath109 , denoted @xmath119 , by @xmath120 the sticky notes described in section [ stickynotes ] will be used only in the early stages of the construction . from then on , top and bottom sticky notes
will _ overlap _ with the body , so that a typical partial interval bijection will need to be decomposed into the form @xmath121 where again @xmath114 and @xmath115 make up a very small portion of the overall map . here
again , we will refer to @xmath114 and @xmath115 as the bottom and top sticky notes , and @xmath116 as the body , of @xmath77 .
once we are far enough along in the construction that sticky note decompositions take the form ( [ stage4pibstructure ] ) , we will no longer be able to use definition [ overlapconcatenation1 ] to glue partial interval bijections together .
we will instead use the following .
[ overlapconcatenation2 ] suppose @xmath101 $ ] for @xmath102 are two partial interval bijections that are decomposed via ( [ stage4pibstructure ] ) as @xmath122 if @xmath118 , then define the _ overlapping concatenation _ of @xmath108 and @xmath109 , denoted @xmath119 , by @xmath123 a _ reordering map _ is a partial interval bijection of the form @xmath124 $ ] .
unlike arbitrary partial interval bijections , in a reordering map each of the first four components is the same interval .
therefore it is possible to compose two reordering maps , as follows .
if @xmath125 and @xmath126 are two bijections , then , as a usual composition of functions , @xmath127 is a bijection .
therefore we can define @xmath128 _ composed with _
@xmath129 to be the reordering map @xmath130 $ ] .
reordering maps will be used to move certain levels in the bottom part " of a template up to the top part , " while shifting all levels in the middle part " down .
for example , consider the template @xmath131 and think of @xmath132 as the middle part " .
suppose we wish to shift this middle part down by two positions .
we could accomplish this , for example , by moving @xmath133 and @xmath134 from the bottom part to the top part , as follows .
let @xmath135 $ ] and define @xmath125 by @xmath136 and @xmath137 by @xmath138 notice that @xmath139 is the ( new ) template @xmath140 and @xmath141 is the ( new ) template @xmath142 we can also compose a reordering map @xmath124 $ ] with an arbitrary partial interval bijection @xmath42 $ ] by defining @xmath143 $ ] , where @xmath144 is the restriction of @xmath145 to @xmath27 .
given a binary word @xmath146 of length @xmath147 , the _ flip _ of @xmath27 is the word @xmath148 , where @xmath149 if @xmath150 and @xmath151 if @xmath152 .
let @xmath153 be the substitution rule on the symbols @xmath105 and @xmath154 given by @xmath155 and @xmath156 .
iterating @xmath153 on the symbol @xmath105 determines , for each @xmath157 , a word @xmath158 of length @xmath159 : @xmath160 observe that @xmath161 and that @xmath162 .
morse sequence _ is the sequence in @xmath163 whose first @xmath159 symbols are the word @xmath164 .
let @xmath2 denote the set of all doubly infinite sequences @xmath165 in @xmath166 such that every finite subword of @xmath167 occurs as a subword of the morse sequence .
given @xmath167 and @xmath168 in @xmath2 , let @xmath169 if @xmath170 ; otherwise , define @xmath171 , where @xmath31 is maximal such that @xmath172 for all @xmath173 . then @xmath174 is a metric on @xmath2 that determines a borel sigma algebra @xmath175 .
the _ morse minimal system _ is then the system @xmath176 , where @xmath177 is the left shift , and @xmath14 is the unique complete ergodic borel probability measure . the following results are proved in @xcite . [ partitionprop ] for each @xmath178 and @xmath157 , there exists a unique partition of @xmath179 into intervals of length @xmath180 so that the subword of @xmath167 on each interval of this partition is either @xmath181 or @xmath182 .
[ partitioncor ] for each @xmath178 and @xmath157 , there exists a unique partition of @xmath179 into intervals of length @xmath159 so that the subword of @xmath167 on each interval of this partition is either @xmath164 or @xmath183 .
[ 0coordinate]for @xmath178 and @xmath157 , partition @xmath179 into intervals as in corollary [ partitioncor ] and let @xmath184 be the position occupied by @xmath105 in its interval , @xmath185 .
the functions @xmath186 are continuous . given @xmath178 and @xmath157 ,
let @xmath184 be as defined in proposition [ 0coordinate ] .
for @xmath187 , let @xmath188 denote the @xmath189th symbol in @xmath164 , and let @xmath190 denote the @xmath189th symbol in @xmath191 .
define sets @xmath192 and @xmath193 then @xmath194 and @xmath195 are obtained by taking the clopen set where @xmath196 and splitting it according to whether the symbol at the origin is @xmath105 or @xmath154
. therefore @xmath194 and @xmath195 are clopen .
these @xmath180 sets , all of equal measure , are called the _
@xmath147-canonical cylinders _ in @xmath2 .
we will often refer to @xmath147-canonical cylinders as _
levels_. define the _ k - canonical templates _ in @xmath2 by : @xmath197 and @xmath198 note that each @xmath147-canonical template has height @xmath159 .
the order on the @xmath147-canonical templates is simply the order given by the action of @xmath0 .
the set of levels in the @xmath147-canonical templates gives a partition of @xmath2 .
let @xmath199 .
given @xmath200 , each level @xmath201 is a subset of a unique level @xmath202 .
sending @xmath203 then gives a map @xmath204 .
observe that @xmath57 is measure preserving in the sense that the measure of the pull back of a set in @xmath205 is the same as its measure .
define three modified versions of each @xmath147-canonical template : one in which the bottom level is removed , a second in which there is an extra copy of @xmath206 tacked on to the top , and a third in which there is an extra copy of @xmath207 tacked on to the top .
the superscripts @xmath208 , @xmath209 , and @xmath210 will denote missing bottom level " , extra copy of @xmath206 " , and extra copy of @xmath207 " , respectively : @xmath211 define @xmath212 , and @xmath213 by analogy .
let @xmath214 be the set of all modified canonical templates at stage @xmath147 .
let @xmath215 . then @xmath3 is compact and metrizable ; the metric @xmath216 , where @xmath217 , induces the topology and determines a borel sigma algebra @xmath218 . define @xmath219 by @xmath220 , where @xmath221 and the addition is coordinate - wise mod @xmath222 with right carry .
the _ binary odometer _ is the system @xmath223 , where @xmath224 is the unique complete ergodic borel probability measure .
@xmath147-canonical cylinder _ is a set @xmath225 , where @xmath226 is a binary word of length @xmath147 .
these @xmath147-canonical cylinders are the levels of templates for the binary odometer .
the _ k - canonical template _ in @xmath3 , denoted @xmath227 , is the set of @xmath147-canonical cylinders together with the order @xmath228 inherited by the action of @xmath1 , where @xmath229 is an element of the first cylinder .
for example , the @xmath230-canonical template is @xmath231 in general , let @xmath232 denote the @xmath189-th level in @xmath227 , so that @xmath233 note that @xmath227 has height @xmath159 , and the set of levels in @xmath227 gives a partition of @xmath3 .
let @xmath234 .
given @xmath200 , each level @xmath235 is a subset of a unique level @xmath236 . sending @xmath237 then gives a map @xmath238 .
observe that @xmath57 is measure preserving in the sense that the measure of the pull back of a set in @xmath239 is the same as its measure .
define two modified versions of the @xmath147-canonical template @xmath227 : one in which the level @xmath240 is removed , and another in which there is an extra copy of @xmath240 tacked on to the top
. the superscripts @xmath208 and @xmath241 will denote missing @xmath240 " and extra copy of @xmath240 " , respectively : @xmath242 let @xmath243 be the set of all modified canonical templates at stage @xmath147 .
define @xmath244 , so that both @xmath245 and @xmath246 are the trivial canonical templates for the binary odometer ( each consisting of just one level ) as indicated in figure [ thefigure ] .
the template sets @xmath63 and @xmath247 , defined in section [ omegakdefinition ] consist of templates of the following types : basic , diminished , augmented , missing and extra .
we begin by describing these types of templates . a _ basic template _ at stage
@xmath147 is any template that satisfies all of the following conditions : it has height @xmath159 ; its elements are @xmath147-canonical cylinders ; and its ordering is allowed " by the action of @xmath1 . for the ordering of a template @xmath248 to be allowed " by the action of @xmath1 , @xmath248 must have one of the following forms .
either it is a special basic template @xmath249 that we will refer to as the _ zero - template _ , or for some ( unique ) @xmath250 , @xmath248 is : @xmath251 let @xmath252 be the set of all basic templates for the binary odometer at stage @xmath147 . in each basic template , the level @xmath240 occurs once and only once .
call this level the _
global cut_. if @xmath253 is a basic template , define the _ predecessor _ template for @xmath35 , denoted @xmath254 , to be the basic template whose global cut is one position higher ( mod @xmath159 ) , and define the _ successor _ template for @xmath248 , denoted @xmath255 , to be the basic template whose global cut is one position lower ( mod @xmath159 ) . for example , if @xmath253 is : @xmath256 then @xmath254 is @xmath257 and @xmath255 is @xmath258 given a basic template @xmath253 , define two additional , _ diminished _
templates @xmath259 and @xmath260 as follows : * @xmath259 is @xmath248 with the global cut removed , and with an extra level tacked on at the bottom ( the level that would naturally precede the bottom level in @xmath248 , namely the pre - image of the bottom level of @xmath248 under the map @xmath1 ) .
* @xmath260 is @xmath248 with the global cut removed , and with an extra level tacked on at the top ( the level that would naturally follow the top level in @xmath248 , namely the image of the top level in @xmath248 under the map @xmath1 ) .
for example , if @xmath253 is given by @xmath256 then @xmath259 is given by @xmath261 the letters d " and u " refer to down " and up " , respectively , for reasons that will be made clear later .
let @xmath262 be the set of all diminished templates for the binary odometer at stage @xmath147 .
note that all diminished templates in @xmath262 have height @xmath159 . given a basic template @xmath253 ,
define two additional , _ augmented _ templates as follows : * @xmath263 is @xmath248 with an extra copy of the global cut , @xmath240 , inserted right next to the actual global cut , and with the bottom level deleted .
* @xmath264 is @xmath248 with an extra copy of the global cut , @xmath240 , inserted right next to the actual global cut , and with the top level deleted .
for example , if @xmath253 is given by @xmath256 then @xmath263 is given by @xmath265 let @xmath266 be the set of all augmented templates for the binary odometer at stage @xmath147 .
note that all augmented templates in @xmath266 have height @xmath159 . given a basic template @xmath253 ,
define one additional , _ missing _ template , denoted @xmath267 , to be @xmath248 with its bottom level removed .
for example , if @xmath248 is the zero - template , then @xmath268 let @xmath269 be the set of all missing templates for the binary odometer at stage @xmath147 .
note that all missing templates have height @xmath270 . given a basic template @xmath253 ,
define one additional , _ extra _ template , denoted @xmath271 , to be @xmath248 with an one extra level tacked on at the top ( the level that would naturally follow the top level ) .
for example , if @xmath253 is given by @xmath256 then @xmath271 is given by @xmath272 let @xmath273 be the set of all extra templates for the binary odometer at stage @xmath147 .
note that all extra templates in @xmath273 have height @xmath274 .
define @xmath276 , so that the canonical templates in @xmath277 have height @xmath74 . for each canonical template @xmath278 for the morse system , and for each template @xmath279 in the binary odometer , we will define a partial interval bijection @xmath280 from a subset of the levels in @xmath281 to a subset of the levels in @xmath248 .
only after we have done this will we define partial interval bijections from the modified canonical templates in @xmath282 to the modified templates in @xmath283 .
there are exactly four basic templates in @xmath284 : * @xmath285 , * @xmath286 , * @xmath287 , and * @xmath288 . for @xmath289 and @xmath290 ,
define @xmath291 to be the partial interval bijection @xmath292 $ ] , where : * @xmath293 \subset { \mathbb z}$ ] , * @xmath294 , * @xmath295 , * @xmath296 , and * each @xmath297 is the obvious bijection @xmath298 .
note that each @xmath299 is equivalent to @xmath300 as a formal map between intervals in @xmath179 .
but of course @xmath301 and @xmath302 are different as set maps because the levels represented by @xmath12 in @xmath303 and @xmath304 are different
. now recall definition [ domainandrange ] , where the domain and range of a partial interval bijection are defined .
the following propositions are obvious .
[ nobottomortop ] for each canonical template @xmath278 , neither the bottom level nor the top level is in the domain of any @xmath305 .
[ nobottomtoporcut ] given @xmath306 , the global cut in @xmath248 is not in the range of @xmath305 .
we now define the good set " at stage @xmath222 , and establish its most important property ( proposition [ stage2goodsetprop ] ) , which is obvious at this stage because @xmath245 is the trivial canonical template .
let @xmath307 .
recall the vertical map @xmath308 which was defined in section [ pkpi ] .
we similarly define @xmath309 .
the following is immediate since @xmath310 .
[ stage2goodsetprop ] if @xmath311 and @xmath312 , then @xmath313 is in the domain of both @xmath305 and @xmath314 , and @xmath315 .
let @xmath248 be a basic template in @xmath284 .
define @xmath316 to match with @xmath305 , and define @xmath317 to match with @xmath318 , as in definition [ match ] .
that these bijections are well defined follows from proposition [ nobottomtoporcut ] ; for example , suppose @xmath248 is given by @xmath319 where the box indicates the level that is in the range of @xmath305 .
then , using this same box " notation to indicate the levels in the ranges of the corresponding partial interval bijections , we have @xmath320 @xmath321 and @xmath322 now observe that @xmath323 , and its corresponding partial interval bijection , are : @xmath324 that @xmath325 matches with @xmath317 is not a coincidence : [ stage2diminishedmatching ] given any basic template @xmath306 , @xmath317 matches with @xmath326 . both @xmath317 and @xmath326
are defined to match with @xmath318 .
similarly , given @xmath306 , define @xmath327 to match with @xmath305 , and define @xmath328 to match with @xmath318 . that these definitions are possible again follows from proposition [ nobottomtoporcut ] .
[ stage2augmentedmatching ] given any basic template @xmath306 , @xmath328 matches with @xmath329 . both @xmath328 and @xmath329
are defined to match with @xmath318 . recall the modified template sets @xmath282 and @xmath330 defined in and . given @xmath331 and @xmath332 , we know from propositions [ nobottomortop ] and [ nobottomtoporcut ] that the bottom level of @xmath281 is not in the domain of @xmath333 , nor is the bottom level of @xmath248 in the range
therefore , if @xmath334 $ ] , where @xmath335 $ ] , then we may define @xmath336 by @xmath337 $ ] , where @xmath338 $ ] . in other words
, @xmath339 is identical to @xmath340 except that the bottom level of @xmath248 is technically missing .
similarly , given @xmath341 and @xmath342 , if again @xmath334 $ ] , then we may define @xmath343 by @xmath344 $ ] , where @xmath345 $ ] .
in other words , @xmath343 is identical to @xmath280 except that there is technically an extra level at the top .
similar to @xmath63 and @xmath247 , the template sets @xmath68 and @xmath69 , defined in section [ tkdefinition ] below , consist of templates of the following types : basic , diminished , augmented , missing , and extra .
we define these types here .
a _ basic template _ at stage @xmath147 is any template that satisfies the all of the following conditions : it has height @xmath159 , its elements are @xmath147-canonical cylinders , and its ordering is allowed " by the action of @xmath0 . for the ordering of a template @xmath35 to be allowed " by the action of @xmath0
, @xmath35 must have one of the following forms : 1 .
this is a special basic template we call the _ zero - template_. 2 .
this is a special basic template we call the _ one - template_. 3 . [ fourforms ] for some ( unique ) @xmath250 , @xmath35 is one of the following four templates : @xmath348 @xmath349 @xmath350 @xmath351 let @xmath352 be the set of all basic templates for the morse system at stage @xmath147 . in each basic template , exactly one of the levels is either @xmath206 or @xmath207 .
call that level the _
global cut_. if @xmath353 is a basic template whose global cut is neither the bottom level nor the top level , then @xmath35 must be one of the four templates listed in item [ fourforms ] of section [ morsebasictemplates ] above . in this case , define the _ predecessor _ template for @xmath35 , denoted @xmath354 , to be the basic template of that same form whose global cut is one position higher , and define the _ successor _ template for @xmath35 , denoted @xmath355 , to be the basic template of that same form whose global cut is one position lower .
for example , if @xmath353 is the template @xmath356 then @xmath357 is @xmath358 and @xmath359 is @xmath360 if @xmath353 is a basic template whose global cut is the bottom level , then @xmath35 is either the zero - template or the one - template . in this case , define two predecessor templates for @xmath35 , denoted @xmath361 and @xmath362 , as follows : * @xmath361 is @xmath35 with the top level removed and @xmath363 tacked on at the bottom .
* @xmath362 is @xmath35 with the top level removed and @xmath364 tacked on at the bottom .
also in this case , define two successor templates for @xmath35 , denoted @xmath365 and @xmath366 , as follows : * @xmath365 is @xmath35 with the bottom level removed and @xmath206 tacked on at the top .
* @xmath366 is @xmath35 with the bottom level removed and @xmath207 tacked on at the top . if @xmath353 is a basic template whose global cut is the top level ( there are exactly two such basic templates ) , then define two predecessor templates for @xmath35 , denoted @xmath361 and @xmath362 , as follows : * @xmath361 is @xmath35 with the top level ( the global cut ) removed and @xmath206 tacked on at the bottom .
* @xmath362 is @xmath35 with the top level ( the global cut ) removed and @xmath367 tacked on at the bottom . also in this case , define a single successor template for @xmath35 , denoted @xmath355 , to be the basic template that is @xmath35 with its bottom level removed , and with the level that would naturally follow the top level tacked on at the top . for example , if @xmath353 is @xmath368 then @xmath355 is @xmath369 because certain templates have multiple predecessor / successor templates , while others have only one , the following definition will be useful .
if @xmath353 is a basic template , then a _ predecessor template for @xmath35 _ is any basic template of the form @xmath354 , @xmath361 , or @xmath362 , as defined above .
successor template for @xmath35 _ is any basic template of the form @xmath355 , @xmath365 , or @xmath366 , as defined above .
if @xmath353 is a basic template , then all predecessor templates for @xmath35 agree in every level except possibly the bottom .
also , all successor templates for @xmath35 agree in every level except possibly the top . given a basic template @xmath353
that is neither the zero - template nor the one - template , define two additional , _ diminished _ templates @xmath370 and @xmath371 as follows : * @xmath370 is @xmath35 with the global cut removed , and with an extra level tacked on at the bottom ( the level that would naturally precede the bottom level ) .
* @xmath371 is @xmath35 with the global cut removed , and with an extra level tacked on at the top ( the level that would naturally follow the top level ) .
for example , suppose @xmath353 is given by @xmath372 then the global cut is @xmath207 , and the bottom level is @xmath194 .
the level that would naturally precede this bottom level is @xmath373 .
therefore the diminished template @xmath370 is given by @xmath374 now suppose @xmath353 is either the zero - template or the one - template .
then there are two levels that could naturally precede the bottom level ( either @xmath363 or @xmath364 ) , as well as two levels that could naturally follow the top level ( either @xmath206 or @xmath207 ) .
for this reason , we define four diminished templates , as follows : * @xmath375 is @xmath35 with the global cut ( which , in this case , is also the bottom level ) removed , and with the level @xmath363 tacked on in its place . * @xmath376 is @xmath35 with the global cut ( which , in this case , is also the bottom level ) removed , and with the level @xmath364 tacked on in its place . * @xmath377 is @xmath35 with the global cut ( which , in this case , is also the bottom level ) removed , and with the level @xmath206 tacked on at the top .
* @xmath378 is @xmath35 with the global cut ( which , in this case , is also the bottom level ) removed , and with the level @xmath207 tacked on at the top .
for example , if @xmath35 is the zero template , then @xmath376 is @xmath379 let @xmath380 be the set of all diminished templates for the morse system at stage @xmath147 .
note that all diminished templates in @xmath380 have height @xmath159 . given a basic template @xmath353 ,
define four additional , _ augmented _ templates as follows : * @xmath381 is @xmath35 with an extra copy of @xmath206 inserted directly before the global cut , and with the bottom level deleted .
* @xmath382 is @xmath35 with an extra copy of @xmath207 inserted directly before the global cut , and with the bottom level deleted .
* @xmath383 is @xmath35 with an extra copy of @xmath206 inserted directly before the global cut , and with the top level deleted .
* @xmath384 is @xmath35 with an extra copy of @xmath207 inserted directly before the global cut , and with the top level deleted .
for example , if @xmath353 is given by @xmath356 then @xmath381 is given by @xmath385 let @xmath386 be the set of all augmented templates for the morse system at stage @xmath147 .
note that all augmented templates in @xmath386 have height @xmath159 .
given a basic template @xmath353 , define one additional , _ missing _ template , denoted @xmath387 , to be @xmath35 with its bottom level removed .
for example , if @xmath35 is the zero - template , then @xmath388 let @xmath389 be the set of all missing templates for the morse system at stage @xmath147 .
note that all missing templates have height @xmath270 . given a basic template @xmath353 that is neither the zero - template nor the one - template ,
define one additional , _ extra _ template , denoted @xmath390 , to be @xmath35 with one extra level tacked on at the top ( the level that would naturally follow the top level ) .
for example , if @xmath353 is given by @xmath391 then @xmath390 is given by @xmath392 if @xmath35 is the zero - template or the one - template , then define two extra templates , as follows : * @xmath393 is @xmath35 with the level @xmath206 tacked on at the top .
* @xmath394 is @xmath35 with the level @xmath207 tacked on at the top .
let @xmath395 be the set of all extra templates for the morse system at stage @xmath147 .
note that all extra templates in @xmath395 have height @xmath274 .
let @xmath397 be a summable sequence . recall that we defined @xmath244 and @xmath276
. now define @xmath398 , @xmath399 , by the following two - step recursion .
given @xmath398 , for @xmath31 even , define @xmath400 and @xmath401 as follows .
first choose @xmath402 large enough so that @xmath403 and pick @xmath404 large enough so that @xmath405 then choose @xmath406 large enough so that @xmath407 and pick @xmath408 large enough so that @xmath409 note that inequalities ( [ m2choice ] ) and ( [ knplustwochoice ] ) are the same as ( [ m1choice ] ) and ( [ knplusonechoice ] ) , only with @xmath398 , @xmath400 , @xmath410 , and @xmath411 replaced with @xmath400 , @xmath401 , @xmath412 , and @xmath413 .
assume the diagram in figure [ thefigure ] has been built down to stage @xmath31 , where @xmath31 is even .
using our choices of @xmath400 and @xmath401 from section [ sequences ] , we then build the diagram down to stage @xmath70 .
the construction is largely the same whether @xmath71 or @xmath72 ; sections [ freqnotation ] - [ blockpartitionsoftauhat ] apply in either case .
define @xmath414 by @xmath415 \text { and } j ' = [ 0 , 1 , \ldots , 2^{k_{n+1}}-1].\ ] ] define the _ bottom and top global safe zones in @xmath85 _ to be the subintervals @xmath416 \text { and } [ 2^{k_{n+2}}-(2^{k_{n+1}}+2^{k_{n+1 } } \cdot 2^{k_{n+1 } } ) , \ldots , 2^{k_{n+2}}-1]\ ] ] of @xmath85 , respectively . by ( [ knplustwochoice ] )
the global safe zones are well - defined , and by ( [ m2choice ] ) the fraction of @xmath85 in the global safe zones is less than @xmath413 . similarly , define the _ bottom and top intermediate safe zones in @xmath417 _ to be the subintervals @xmath418 \text { and } [ 2^{k_{n+1}}-(2^{k_{n}}+2^{k_{n } } \cdot 2^{k_{n } } ) , \ldots , 2^{k_{n+1}}-1]\ ] ] of @xmath417 , respectively . by the intermediate safe zones are well - defined , and by the fraction of @xmath417 in the intermediate safe zones
is less than @xmath419 .
let @xmath420 be the set of basic templates at stage @xmath70 .
let @xmath421 and @xmath422 .
fix a basic template @xmath423 , represent @xmath35 with the interval @xmath85 , and let @xmath424 be the position in @xmath85 where the global cut occurs .
let @xmath425 and @xmath426 be such that @xmath427 and @xmath428 .
let @xmath429 . in this section
we define two partitions of @xmath35 , which we call the intermediate and local block partitions of @xmath35 .
we also define the intermediate and local cuts in @xmath35 . depending on @xmath430 , the _ intermediate block partition of @xmath85 _
is either ( [ simpleintblockpartition ] ) or ( [ complicatedintblockpartition ] ) below : if @xmath431 , then @xmath432 where @xmath433 $ ] for @xmath434 . if @xmath435 , then @xmath436 where : * @xmath437 $ ] * @xmath438 $ ] for @xmath439 * @xmath440 $ ] . whether the intermediate block partition of @xmath85 takes the form ( [ simpleintblockpartition ] ) or ( [ complicatedintblockpartition ] ) ,
the sub - intervals @xmath441 are called the _ intermediate blocks in @xmath85_. the _ intermediate block partition of @xmath35 _ is either @xmath442 or @xmath443 depending on whether the intermediate block partition of @xmath85 takes the form ( [ simpleintblockpartition ] ) or ( [ complicatedintblockpartition ] ) , respectively .
either way , the sub - templates @xmath444 consist of those levels in @xmath35 that occur in positions from @xmath445 , and are called the _ intermediate blocks in @xmath35_. the first level in an intermediate block @xmath446 is called an _ intermediate cut in @xmath35_. [ jlocalblocks ] the _ local block partition of @xmath417 _ is @xmath447 where @xmath448 $ ] for @xmath449 .
the sub - intervals @xmath450 , each of which has length @xmath451 , are called the _ local blocks in @xmath417_. [ localblocks1 ]
if @xmath444 is an intermediate block of height @xmath452 , then the _ local block partition of @xmath446 _ is @xmath453 where the sub - templates @xmath454 consist of those levels in @xmath446 that occur in positions from @xmath455 , and are called the _ local blocks in @xmath446_. given an interval
@xmath456 \subset { \mathbb z}$ ] of length @xmath457 and @xmath458 , denote the subinterval of @xmath84 consisting of the last @xmath459 integers in @xmath84 by @xmath460^d$ ] and the subinterval of @xmath84 consisting of the first @xmath461 integers by @xmath460_d$ ] .
namely , @xmath460_d
= i\setminus[i]^d$ ] .
[ jalocalblocks ] the _ local block partitions of @xmath462_a$ ] and @xmath462^a$ ] _ are @xmath463_a = j'(0 ) \cup j'(1 ) \cup \cdots \cup j'(l'-c-2 ) \cup \left [ j'(l'-c-1 ) \right]_b\ ] ] and @xmath464^a = \begin{cases } \left[j'(l'-c-1 ) \right]^b \cup j'(l'-c ) \cup \cdots \cup j'(l'-1 ) & \mbox { if } a \neq 0 \\ \emptyset & \mbox { if } a = 0.\end{cases}\ ] ] the sub - intervals in the partitions ( [ j_apartition ] ) and ( [ j^apartition ] ) are called the _ local blocks in @xmath462_a$ ] and @xmath462^a$]_. if @xmath431 , then @xmath465 , so the local block partition ( [ j_apartition ] ) of @xmath462_0 $ ] is identical to the local block partition ( [ jpartition ] ) of @xmath417 . also @xmath466_0 $ ]
. therefore definition [ jlocalblocks ] is just a special case of definition [ jalocalblocks ] .
[ localblocks2 ] intermediate blocks of height @xmath467 can only exist if @xmath435 ; in this case , @xmath468 and @xmath469 are the only two such .
represent @xmath468 with @xmath462_a$ ] and @xmath469 with @xmath462^a$ ] .
then the _ local block partitions of @xmath468 and @xmath469 _ are @xmath470_b\ ] ] and @xmath471^b \cup \tau(0 , l'-c ) \cup \cdots \cup \tau(0 , l'-1),\ ] ] where the sub - templates in the partitions ( [ taulpartition ] ) and ( [ tau0partition ] ) consist of those levels in @xmath468 and @xmath469 that occur in positions from the corresponding local blocks in @xmath462_a$ ] and @xmath462^a$ ] , and are called the _ local blocks in @xmath468 and @xmath469_.
a _ local block in @xmath35 _ is any local block from definitions [ localblocks1 ] or [ localblocks2 ] .
the _ local block partition of @xmath35 _ is the partition of @xmath35 into its local blocks . the first level in a local block
is called a _ local cut in @xmath35_. recall that each basic template @xmath423 has four variation types : diminished , augmented , missing , and extra . and within a given variation type , there may be multiple templates .
but any such template is constructed by applying one or both of the following operations to @xmath35 : 1 .
remove one level from the bottom of a local block in @xmath35 , 2 .
insert one new level at the top ( or bottom ) of a local block in @xmath35 .
therefore , if @xmath37 is a diminished , augmented , missing , or extra version of @xmath35 , then the intermediate and local block partitions of @xmath35 determine intermediate and local block partitions of @xmath37 , as follows : 1 .
suppose a level , @xmath459 , is removed from the bottom of a local block @xmath27 .
let @xmath472 be the intermediate block that contains @xmath27 .
then , in the intermediate and local block partitions of @xmath37 , replace @xmath27 and @xmath472 with @xmath473 and @xmath474 . leave all other intermediate and local blocks alone .
2 . suppose a level , @xmath459 , is inserted at the top ( resp . , bottom ) of a local block @xmath27 .
let @xmath472 be the intermediate block that contains @xmath27 .
then , in the intermediate and local block partitions of @xmath37 , replace @xmath27 and @xmath472 with @xmath475 and @xmath476 , where , in the new order , @xmath459 is the top ( resp .
, bottom ) level in @xmath475 .
leave all other intermediate and local blocks alone .
recall the definition of a reordering map in section [ reorderingmaps ] .
we will employ two types of reordering maps : _ global _ and _ intermediate_. roughly speaking , the _ global _ reordering map takes a small number of levels in @xmath35 that occur in positions from the bottom global safe zone in @xmath85 and moves them , one by one , up to the top global safe zone .
this has the effect of sliding all levels in @xmath35 that do not occur in the global safe zones ( those in the middle part " ) down .
here is the formal definition : the _ global reordering map for @xmath35 _ is a map @xmath477 $ ] where 1 . if @xmath478 , then @xmath479 and therefore @xmath129 is the identity .
2 . if @xmath480 then @xmath479 is defined so that @xmath129 takes the bottom levels in @xmath481 and inserts them , in order , directly after the top levels in @xmath482 . observe that this means @xmath129 shifts all levels in @xmath35 that do not occur in the global safe zones down by exactly @xmath430 positions .
more formally when @xmath480 , for each intermediate block @xmath445 in @xmath85 , let @xmath483 and @xmath484 denote the smallest and largest integers in @xmath445 , respectively
. then @xmath485 , where , for @xmath486 , @xmath487 [ intcutspostp1 ] the intermediate cuts in @xmath139 that do not occur in the global safe zones occur in positions in @xmath85 that are congruent to @xmath105 mod @xmath452 .
this follows immediately from the definitions and implies that the intermediate cuts in @xmath139 that do not occur in the global safe zones line up " with intermediate cuts in the zero template @xmath488 .
this in turn implies that the intermediate blocks in @xmath139 that do not occur in the global safe zones also line up with intermediate blocks in the zero template . if @xmath431 , then the intermediate block partition of @xmath35 is given by ( [ simpleinttau ] ) and @xmath489 . in this case
we define the intermediate block partition of @xmath139 to be identical to the intermediate block partition of @xmath35 .
formally @xmath490(0 ) \cup [ \hat p_1(\tau)](1 ) \cup \cdots \cup [ \hat p_1(\tau)](l-1),\ ] ] where each @xmath491(m ) = \tau(m)$ ] . in this @xmath478 case
we define the the local block partition of @xmath139 to be identical to the local block partition of @xmath35 ( see ( [ talltaupartition ] ) ) .
formally , for @xmath434 , @xmath492(m ) = [ \hat p_1(\tau)](m , 0 ) \cup [ \hat p_1(\tau)](m , 1 ) \cup \cdots \cup [ \hat p_1(\tau)](m , l'-1)\ ] ] where each @xmath491(m , i ) = \tau(m , i)$ ] . now suppose @xmath435 , so that the intermediate block partition of @xmath35 is given by ( [ complicatedinttau ] ) .
then @xmath129 takes the bottom levels in @xmath481 and inserts them , in order , directly after the top levels in @xmath482 .
then we define the intermediate block partition of @xmath139 by @xmath493(0 ) \cup [ \hat p_1(\tau)](1 ) \cup \cdots \cup [ \hat p_1(\tau)](l)\ ] ] where : * for @xmath494 , @xmath491(m ) = \tau(m)$ ] , and * for @xmath495 , @xmath491(m)$ ] is @xmath446 with its bottom level removed , and @xmath491(l - a+m-1)$ ] is @xmath496 with the bottom level of @xmath446 inserted at the top .
if @xmath435 and @xmath494 , then define the local block partition of @xmath491(m)$ ] to be identical to the local block partition of @xmath35 . formally , if @xmath497 , then the local block partition of @xmath491(m)$ ] is given by ( [ tallinttaupartition ] ) . the local block partitions of @xmath491(l)$ ] and @xmath491(0)$ ] are @xmath498(l ) = [ \hat p_1(\tau)](l , 0 ) \cup \cdots \cup [ \hat p_1(\tau)](l , l'-c-2 ) \cup \left [ [ \hat p_1(\tau)](l , l'-c-1)\right]_b\ ] ] and @xmath499(0 ) = \left [ [ \hat p_1(\tau)]\right(0 , l'-c-1)]^b \cup [ \hat p_1(\tau)](0 , l'-c ) \cup \cdots \cup [ \hat p_1(\tau)](0 , l'-1)\ ] ] where @xmath491(l , i ) = \tau(l , i)$ ] for each @xmath189 . finally ,
if @xmath435 and @xmath495 , then define the local block partitions of @xmath491(m)$ ] and @xmath491(l - a+m-1)$ ] by @xmath500(m ) = [ \hat p_1(\tau)](m , 0 ) \cup [ \hat p_1(\tau)](m , 1 ) \cup \cdots \cup [ \hat p_1(\tau)](m , l'-1)\ ] ] and @xmath500(l - a+m-1 ) = [ \hat p_1(\tau)](l - a+m-1 , 0 ) \cup \cdots \cup [ \hat p_1(\tau)](l - a+m-1 , l'-1)\ ] ] where : * for @xmath501 , @xmath491(m , i ) = \tau(m , i)$ ] , * for @xmath502 , @xmath491(l - a+m-1 , i ) = \tau(l - a+m-1 , i)$ ] , and * @xmath491(m , 0)$ ] is @xmath503 with the bottom level removed , and @xmath491(l - a+m-1 , l'-1)$ ] is @xmath504 with the bottom level of @xmath503 inserted at the top . [ twocases ]
let @xmath491(m)$ ] be an intermediate block in @xmath139 that does not occur in a global safe zone .
then the levels in @xmath491(m)$ ] occur in the same positions as those in the intermediate block @xmath505 in the zero template where @xmath506 therefore if @xmath35 is an odometer template then @xmath507(m ) ) = \zeta(\tau^\star(\ell))$ ] . if @xmath35 is a morse template then either @xmath507(m ) ) = \zeta(\tau^\star(\ell))$ ] or @xmath507(m ) ) = \overline{\zeta(\tau^\star(\ell))}$ ]
. follows from proposition [ intcutspostp1 ] . in this section
we define a reordering map @xmath508 for each intermediate block @xmath491(m)$ ] in @xmath139 .
we then define the _ intermediate reordering map _ to be the concatenation , denoted @xmath128 , of the maps @xmath508 ( either @xmath509 or @xmath510 ) .
here is the formal definition .
[ intermediatereorderingmap ] depending on whether @xmath431 or @xmath435 , define the _ intermediate reordering map for @xmath35 _ to be the concatenation @xmath509 or @xmath511 , respectively , where each @xmath512 $ ] is defined as follows . if @xmath491(m)$ ] is an intermediate block in @xmath139 that occurs in a global safe zone , then @xmath513 identity .
if @xmath491(m)$ ] is an intermediate block in @xmath139 that does not occur in a global safe zone then , letting @xmath514 proposition [ twocases ] determines two cases : 1 .
if @xmath507(m ) ) = \zeta(\tau^\star(x))$ ] , then @xmath515 is the identity .
if @xmath507(m ) ) = \overline{\zeta(\tau^\star(x))}$ ] , then @xmath516 is defined so that @xmath508 takes the bottom levels in @xmath491(m , 1 ) , \ldots , [ \hat p_1(\tau)](m , 2^{k_n})$ ] and inserts them , in order , directly after the top levels in @xmath491(m , l ' - 2^{k_n } ) , \ldots , [ \hat p_1(\tau)](m , l'-1)$ ] .
this shifts all other local blocks down by exactly @xmath451 positions . more formally , for @xmath517 ,
let @xmath518 and @xmath519 denote the smallest and largest integers in @xmath520 , respectively .
then let @xmath521 where , for @xmath522 , @xmath523 let @xmath525 and , depending on whether @xmath431 or @xmath435 , define the intermediate block partition of @xmath526 to be either @xmath527 respectively , where , for each @xmath208 , @xmath528(m ) \right)$ ] .
given an intermediate block @xmath529 in @xmath526 , if @xmath513 identity , then define the local block partition of @xmath529 to be identical to the local block partition of @xmath491(m)$ ] .
denote the local blocks in @xmath529 by @xmath530 , @xmath531_b$ ] , or @xmath531^b$ ] depending on the form that @xmath532(m)$ ] takes ( the various possible forms are described in section [ p1hatpartitions ] ) . if @xmath533 identity , then @xmath534 , as in definition [ intermediatereorderingmap ] . in this case , define the local block partition of @xmath529 to be @xmath535 where : * @xmath536 consists of the @xmath451 consecutive levels in @xmath529 that occur in positions from @xmath537 $ ] in @xmath417 ; * for @xmath538 , @xmath530 consists of the @xmath539 consecutive levels in @xmath529 that occur in positions from @xmath540 $ ] in @xmath417 ; * for @xmath541 , @xmath530 consists of the @xmath451 consecutive levels in @xmath529 that occur in positions from @xmath542 $ ] in @xmath417 ; * for @xmath543 , @xmath530 consists of the @xmath544 consecutive levels in @xmath529 that occur in positions from @xmath545\ ] ] in @xmath417 ; and * @xmath546 consists of the @xmath451 consecutive levels in @xmath529 that occur in positions from @xmath547 $ ] in @xmath417 .
all the machinery we have defined up to this point will be used to construct the partial interval bijections from figure [ thefigure ] .
the global and intermediate reordering maps in particular are defined to guarantee the existence of good sets " .
recall from the introduction that these are subsets of @xmath2 and @xmath3 defined for each stage of the construction on which all partial interval bijections match .
define the _ good set in @xmath417 _ to be the subset @xmath548 given by @xmath549 then @xmath550 consists of every other local block in @xmath417 that does not occur in the intermediate safe zones . for @xmath551 , define @xmath552 and @xmath553 note that @xmath554 ; we call @xmath555 the _ good set within @xmath85 at stage @xmath70_. for @xmath31 congruent to @xmath556 ( @xmath557 ) we set @xmath558 ( @xmath559 ) to consist of those levels in @xmath560 ( @xmath561 ) that occur in positions from @xmath562 .
we call @xmath563 or @xmath564 the _ good set at stage @xmath70_. note that , because the global and intermediate safe zones make up a very small proportion of @xmath85 , @xmath555 consists of roughly half of @xmath85 . therefore @xmath565 and @xmath566 are both approximately @xmath567 .
[ everyotherproperty ] let @xmath568 and @xmath569 be basic templates in @xmath570 @xmath571 , and let @xmath572 @xmath573 .
let @xmath574 and @xmath575 be the levels that occur in position @xmath576 within @xmath577 and @xmath578
. then @xmath579 .
the global reordering map was defined so that , after global reordering , the intermediate block structures of all templates line up outside of the global safe zone ( see proposition [ twocases ] ) . for the odometer system , then , after global reordering , every local block that is not in the global safe zones matches the corresponding local block in the zero template , in the sense that it has the same image under @xmath580 . for the morse system ,
the intermediate reordering map was defined so that , after both global and intermediate reordering , every other local block that is neither in the global nor intermediate safe zones moved down by exactly one complete local block . as a consequence of the combinatoric structure of the morse system , now every other such local block matches the corresponding local block in the zero template . to see why this is the case , consider the morse sequence and its flip : @xmath581 notice that , if we shift the flip to the left by one coordinate , then it matches the morse sequence in every other coordinate .
the same would be true for sequences of substitution blocks ( just replace @xmath105 s and @xmath154 s with blocks @xmath582 and @xmath583 ) .
[ independenceofgoodsets ] let @xmath584 be natural numbers congruent to @xmath585 @xmath586 .
then @xmath587 and @xmath588 @xmath589 and @xmath590 are independent events in @xmath3 @xmath591 .
we only give the proof in the case where @xmath31 and @xmath208 are congruent to @xmath556 .
the other case follows similarly . since @xmath584
, we have @xmath592 , where @xmath593 . then @xmath594 is partitioned into @xmath145 copies " of @xmath51 : @xmath595 where each @xmath596 is a union of exactly @xmath451 consecutive levels in @xmath594 , and @xmath597 for each @xmath189 . because @xmath598 is a union of local blocks from stage @xmath599 and @xmath600
, we can write @xmath598 as a disjoint union @xmath601 for some @xmath602 .
because ( [ qmpartition ] ) is obtained by cutting and stacking @xmath51 @xmath145 times , we have @xmath603 , and therefore @xmath604 , for each @xmath189 . since ( [ gmdisjoint ] ) is a disjoint union , @xmath605 therefore @xmath598 and @xmath606 are independent .
suppose @xmath607 and @xmath608 .
then the local block partitions of @xmath609 and @xmath610 are @xmath611^b \cup \hat \tau(0 , l'-c ) \cup \cdots \hat \tau(0 , l'-1)\ ] ] and @xmath612_b,\ ] ] as described section [ blockpartitionsoftauhat ] , and in ( [ localpartitionof0th ] ) and ( [ localpartitionoflth ] ) .
notice that the very first local block in @xmath526 has height @xmath613 , i.e. , it is a _ partial _ block .
correspondingly , the bottom @xmath614 levels in @xmath615 can be thought of as the top @xmath614 levels in a collection of templates @xmath279 .
define @xmath616 similarly , define @xmath617 if @xmath618 , then define @xmath619 .
given @xmath607 , in this section we define a collection of partial interval bijections of the form @xmath620 there will be one such partial interval bijection for each pair @xmath621 .
we call @xmath622 and @xmath623 the _ bottom _ and _ top sticky notes _ of @xmath624 .
if @xmath618 , then each @xmath624 is defined on an interval of length @xmath625 . however ,
if @xmath608 , then each @xmath624 is defined on an interval of length approximately @xmath626 . if @xmath618 , then define just one top sticky note and just one bottom sticky note , namely , the trivial partial interval bijection @xmath93 $ ] where @xmath629 .
if @xmath608 , then , for each @xmath630 , define @xmath631 . to conserve notation , since the particular choice of @xmath248 will not matter for our construction , the expression @xmath627 does not indicate dependence on @xmath248 .
similarly , for each @xmath632 , define @xmath633 .
the local block partition of @xmath526 determines a partition of @xmath635 $ ] into subintervals , which in turn determines a partition of @xmath615 , which we call the _ local block partition of @xmath615_. the local block partition of @xmath615 has the form @xmath636 where the @xmath637 are consecutively occurring sets of levels in @xmath615 .
if @xmath618 , then , for each @xmath189 , @xmath638 is a template from @xmath639 . in this case , define @xmath640 if @xmath608 , then for @xmath641 , @xmath638 is a template from @xmath639 . in this case , define @xmath642 [ stage4matching ] let @xmath643 be a level in @xmath615 from the good set at stage @xmath74
. then , given @xmath568 and @xmath569 in @xmath644 , either both @xmath645 and @xmath646 are undefined on @xmath313 , or else @xmath647 . by construction , together with proposition [ everyotherproperty ] .
it follows from lemma [ stage4matching ] that it is possible to extend the domain of definition of @xmath648 to a partial interval bijection , call it @xmath649 , between the set of all levels in @xmath650 and those levels in @xmath526 that occur in positions from @xmath651 .
moreover , the same bijection can be used for all reordered templates @xmath526
so that , given @xmath568 and @xmath569 in @xmath644 and @xmath652 , @xmath653 . finally , define @xmath654 where @xmath655 denotes the restriction of @xmath656 to the subinterval of @xmath657 corresponding to @xmath658 .
( note that @xmath655 is well - defined because @xmath656 is the identity outside of @xmath659 . )
[ stage4nobottomortop ] neither the bottom level nor the top level of @xmath615 is in the domain of any @xmath624 .
given @xmath624 of the form @xmath660 determined by @xmath621 , the bottom level in @xmath615 occurs as the cut in @xmath661 .
but by proposition [ nobottomtoporcut ] , this level is not in the range of the stage 2 map @xmath662 . therefore it is not in the domain of @xmath622 .
[ stage4nocut ] given @xmath607 , the global cut in @xmath35 is not in the range of any @xmath624
. follows from proposition [ nobottomortop ] .
[ stage4matchingprop ] let @xmath643 .
then , given @xmath568 and @xmath569 in @xmath644 and partial interval bijections @xmath663 and @xmath664 of the form ( [ basicpibform ] ) , both @xmath663 and @xmath664 are defined on @xmath313 , and @xmath665
. follows from lemma [ stage4matching ] together with the definition of the partial interval bijections @xmath624 .
we now define maps to diminished , augmented , missing , and extra templates , and establish analogues of lemmas [ stage2diminishedmatching ] and [ stage2augmentedmatching ] , which are needed to establish analogues of propositions [ possiblebodyoverlaps ] and [ bodyoverlapsvalid ] in stage 8 .
given @xmath607 that is neither the zero - template nor the one - template , define @xmath666 to match with @xmath624 , and define @xmath667 to match with @xmath668 . here
we mean that the top and bottom sticky notes as well as the body maps all match . similar to stage 2 , the fact that these definitions are possible follows from proposition [ stage4nocut ] .
if @xmath607 is either the zero - template or the one - template , then for @xmath331 , define @xmath669 to match with @xmath624 , and define @xmath670 to match with @xmath671 .
[ stage4dimlemma ] if @xmath607 is neither the zero - template nor the one - template , then @xmath667 matches with @xmath672 . if @xmath607 is either the zero - template or the one - template , then for @xmath331 , @xmath670 matches with @xmath673 . by construction .
given @xmath607 and @xmath331 , define @xmath674 to match with @xmath624 . if @xmath35 is neither the zero - template nor the one - template , then define @xmath675 to match with @xmath668 .
if @xmath35 is the zero - template or the one - template , then define @xmath675 to match with @xmath671 .
[ stage4auglemma ] given @xmath331 , and @xmath607 , if @xmath35 is neither the zero - template nor the one - template , then @xmath675 matches with @xmath676 .
if @xmath35 is the zero - template or the one - template , then @xmath675 matches with @xmath677 . by construction .
given @xmath678 , define @xmath679 .
note that , if @xmath680 , then @xmath681 .
define @xmath682 note that @xmath683 , but @xmath684 since , in particular , if @xmath630 , then @xmath685 , but @xmath686 .
define @xmath687 as follows . for each @xmath688 , define @xmath689 , and , for each @xmath690 , define @xmath691 .
define @xmath692 .
similarly , given @xmath607 that is neither the zero - template nor the one - template , define @xmath693 . note that , if @xmath694 , then @xmath695 .
define @xmath696 note that , if @xmath632 , then @xmath697 .
stage 6 is analogous to stage 4 , but with one new layer of complexity : whereas the maps in stage 4 were defined as _ concatenations _ of maps from stage 2 , the maps in stage 6 will be _ overlapping concatenations _ of the maps from stage 4 .
the top and bottom sticky notes defined in stage 4 are used to glue these overlapping concatenations together .
we need to verify that there are enough sticky notes defined in stage 4 to choose from so that these overlapping concatenations are well - defined .
the global reordering map in stage 6 , denoted @xmath129 , is the same as it was in stage 4 except , of course , now @xmath698 $ ] . in stage 4 ,
an intermediate reordering map was also used to ensure that every other local block that does not occur in a safe zone has the same image under @xmath580 as the corresponding local block in the zero - template ( see proposition [ everyotherproperty ] ) .
but an intermediate reordering map is not needed in stage 6 because the odometer has just one canonical tower at each stage not two .
so in stage 6 , let the intermediate reordering map @xmath128 be simply the identity . given @xmath699 ,
let @xmath700 .
define the intermediate and local block partitions of @xmath701 , as well as the intermediate block partition of @xmath702 , in exactly the same way that they were defined in stage 4 ( see sections [ p1hatpartitions ] and [ blockpartitionsoftauhat ] ) except , of course , that @xmath35 is replaced with @xmath248 .
given an intermediate block @xmath703 in @xmath702 , because the intermediate reordering map @xmath128 is simply the identity , just like in stage 4 , define the local block partition of @xmath703 to be identical to the local block partition of @xmath704(m)$ ] .
the good set within @xmath85 at stage @xmath75 , @xmath705 , is defined in section [ thegoodset ] .
let @xmath706 , called the _ good set at stage @xmath75 _ , consist of those levels in @xmath707 that occur in positions from @xmath705 . note that proposition [ everyotherproperty ] holds in stage 6 .
given @xmath699 , the sets @xmath708 and @xmath709 are defined analogously to the definitions in section [ headsandtails ] ( just replace @xmath35 , @xmath248 , @xmath66 , and @xmath710 with @xmath248 , @xmath35 , @xmath710 , and @xmath711 , respectively ) .
however , there is an added layer of complexity in stage 6 : if @xmath712 ( or @xmath713 ) , then @xmath35 has head and tail sets of its own , @xmath714 and @xmath715 . much like in stage 6 , given @xmath699 , the partial interval bijections @xmath305 take the form @xmath716 where @xmath717 represents _ overlapping concatenation _ as defined in definition [ overlapconcatenation1 ] .
there is one such partial interval bijection for each pair @xmath718 .
the maps @xmath719 , @xmath720 , and @xmath721 are defined analogously to the definitions in sections [ stage4stickynotes ] and [ stage4bodymap ] except that within the body map @xmath720 ( section [ stage4bodymap ] ) , concatenations ( @xmath722 ) are replaced with overlapping concatenations ( @xmath723 ) .
we now show that the overlapping concatenations within @xmath720 can be glued together .
suppose @xmath608 ( the case that @xmath618 is nearly identical ) .
then , following what was done in section [ stage4bodymap ] , we define @xmath724 to take the form @xmath725 [ possiblebodyoverlaps ] with the templates @xmath726 from ( [ phiomegabodydecomp ] ) listed in order of overlapping concatenation ( @xmath727 ) , the following six types of successive pairs can occur : 1 .
@xmath728 where @xmath729 , 2 .
@xmath730 where @xmath731 , 3 .
@xmath732 , where @xmath331 and @xmath733 , 4 .
@xmath734 , where @xmath731 , 5 .
@xmath735 , where @xmath341 and @xmath733 , and 6 .
@xmath736 , where @xmath731 . by construction .
[ bodyoverlapsvalid ] in any of the six cases of proposition [ possiblebodyoverlaps ] , top and bottom sticky notes can be chosen so that the overlapping concatenation of the corresponding partial interval bijections @xmath737 are well - defined .
case 1 is trivial because partial interval bijections to the zero- and one - templates do not have sticky notes ( there is no overlap to worry about ) . for case 2 ,
observe that if @xmath306 is a basic template from stage 2 such that @xmath630 , then @xmath632 as well , so we can glue @xmath738 together with itself by picking such @xmath739 on the overlap . for case 3 , observe that there exists @xmath306 such that @xmath740 and @xmath741 .
lemma [ stage2diminishedmatching ] then guarantees that there is a bottom sticky note on @xmath624 that matches with a top sticky note on @xmath742 .
cases 4 - 6 are similar .
the following shows that is well defined .
top and bottom sticky notes can be chosen so that the overlapping concatenations @xmath743 and @xmath744 are well - defined .
similar to the proof of proposition [ bodyoverlapsvalid ] .
the following propositions are analogous to propositions from stage 4 . neither the bottom level nor the top level of @xmath745 or @xmath746 is in the domain of any @xmath305
. follows from proposition [ stage4nocut ] .
given @xmath699 , the global cut in @xmath248 is not in the range of any @xmath305 .
follows from proposition [ stage4nobottomortop ] .
let @xmath747 and let @xmath748 be a level that occurs in position @xmath576 , where @xmath331 . then , given @xmath661 and @xmath749 in @xmath750 and partial interval bijections @xmath662 and @xmath751 of the form ( [ phiomegabodydecomp ] ) , both @xmath662 and @xmath751 are defined on @xmath313 , and @xmath752 .
proposition [ everyotherproperty ] can be used to show that lemma [ stage4matching ] holds in stage 6 ( with appropriate notational modifications ) .
the proposition follows .
the definitions of these modified maps are analogous to those in stage 4 .
maps to missing and extra templates are needed to define the maps at stage 8 in places where individual levels have been deleted or inserted .
analogues of lemmas [ stage4dimlemma ] and [ stage4auglemma ] hold in stage 6 , and are used to glue sticky notes together in stage 10 .
the essential components of the induction have now been established .
stages @xmath753 are analogous to stage @xmath74 , while stages @xmath754 are analogous to stage @xmath75 . in each stage @xmath76
, concatenations of the ( inverses of ) the partial interval bijections at stage @xmath755 are glued together using definition [ overlapconcatenation2 ] .
given a level @xmath643 , proposition [ stage4matchingprop ] guarantees that @xmath756 is a level in @xmath277 that does not depend on which @xmath757 is used .
moreover , proposition [ stage4matchingprop ] holds in every stage @xmath72 , which permits us to define @xmath758 to be the restriction of @xmath759 to @xmath606 .
similarly , for @xmath73 , we can define @xmath760 to be the restriction of @xmath761 to @xmath606 .
given @xmath72 and @xmath762 , let @xmath763 denote the unique @xmath398-canonical cylinder in @xmath3 that contains @xmath764 .
let @xmath765 be the set of @xmath762 such that @xmath766 for infinitely many @xmath31 .
similarly , given @xmath73 and @xmath178 , let @xmath767 denote the unique @xmath398-canonical cylinder in @xmath2 that contains @xmath167 .
let @xmath768 be the set of @xmath178 such that @xmath769 for infinitely many @xmath31 .
the sets @xmath770 and @xmath771 are @xmath11 sets of full measure . by proposition [ independenceofgoodsets ] , the sets @xmath606 for @xmath72 are independent with respect to @xmath224 .
therefor @xmath772 by the borel - cantelli lemma . moreover , the sets @xmath606 are open , so @xmath770 is a @xmath11 subset of @xmath3 .
the argument for @xmath771 is similar .
[ containmentlemma ] given @xmath773 , if @xmath72 and @xmath774 and @xmath775 are levels such that @xmath776 , then @xmath777 . also ,
if @xmath73 , @xmath778 , @xmath779 , and @xmath780 , then @xmath781 . given @xmath782 , the map @xmath624 at stage @xmath783 is an extension of a concatenation of the maps @xmath624 at stage @xmath31
it follows that @xmath784 where , depending on the context , @xmath57 refers either to the map @xmath785 or to the map @xmath786 .
the argument when @xmath73 is nearly identical .
given @xmath787 , let @xmath788 be the increasing sequence of indices , each congruent to @xmath585 , such that each @xmath789 .
then , by lemma [ containmentlemma ] , the levels @xmath790 form a nested sequence .
it follows that there is a unique point in the intersection @xmath791 .
similarly , if @xmath792 is the analogous sequence of indices for @xmath793 , then there is a unique point in the intersection @xmath794 .
this permits the following definition .
given @xmath793 , let @xmath795 be the unique point in the intersection @xmath794 .
given @xmath787 , let @xmath796 be the unique point in the intersection @xmath791 .
the maps @xmath6 and @xmath797 are continuous in the relative topologies on @xmath770 and @xmath771 .
let @xmath793 and @xmath798 .
choose @xmath73 large enough so that @xmath799 and such that @xmath800 .
choose @xmath801 small enough so that @xmath802 implies @xmath803 .
in particular , @xmath802 implies @xmath804 .
it then follows from lemma [ containmentlemma ] that , for all @xmath773 such that @xmath805 , @xmath806 and , for all @xmath807 such that @xmath808 , @xmath809 therefore @xmath810 the continuity of @xmath797 is proved similarly .
the maps @xmath6 and @xmath797 are measure preserving .
fix a natural number @xmath811 and a level @xmath459 in @xmath594 .
we wish to show that @xmath812 .
given @xmath813 , let @xmath814 where @xmath56 is the map @xmath815 .
let @xmath816 and @xmath817 .
observe that @xmath818 as discussed in section [ thegoodset ] , for large @xmath31 , @xmath819 consists of roughly half of the levels in @xmath820 , so we can ( conservatively ) assume @xmath819 consists of at least @xmath821 of them .
then @xmath822 for @xmath823 , let @xmath824 denote the set of levels in @xmath820 that are contained in levels from @xmath825 , and recursively define @xmath826 and @xmath827 . observe that @xmath828 and @xmath829 ( again , @xmath821 is a conservative lower bound
it is actually closer to @xmath830 ) .
it follows from ( [ dnequation ] ) and ( [ dnminusaequation ] ) that @xmath831 it now follows from ( [ enequation ] ) and ( [ enminusaequation ] ) that @xmath832 this implies that @xmath833 letting @xmath834 gives @xmath835 .
this being true for each level @xmath836 trivially implies that @xmath837 . if @xmath793 and @xmath838 , then @xmath839 .
similarly , if @xmath787 and @xmath840 , then @xmath841 .
let @xmath798 and let @xmath73 be such that @xmath842 and @xmath843 .
let @xmath844 be such that @xmath845 .
then @xmath846 where , depending on the context , @xmath57 refers either to the map @xmath847 or to the map @xmath848 . since @xmath849
, we have @xmath850 , which implies @xmath851 . therefore @xmath852 . the second statement is proved similarly .
let @xmath853 then @xmath854 and @xmath855 are invariant @xmath11 subsets of full measure .
let @xmath856 and @xmath857 .
then @xmath9 and @xmath10 are full measure subsets because @xmath6 is measure preserving . and @xmath9 and @xmath10 are @xmath11 subsets because @xmath6 is continuous in the relative topology on @xmath854 . in this section
we show that @xmath9 and @xmath10 are invariant and that @xmath4 is an orbit equivalence that is a conjugacy when restricted to @xmath858 , the good set at stage @xmath222 .
[ orbitsintoorbits ] for @xmath859 , @xmath6 maps the @xmath0-orbit of @xmath167 into the @xmath1-orbit of @xmath795 . and for @xmath860 , @xmath797 maps the @xmath1-orbit of @xmath764 into the @xmath0-orbit of @xmath796 .
let @xmath861 and @xmath862 for some @xmath863 .
recall that the bottom global safe zone at stage @xmath31 has height @xmath864 .
pick @xmath865 such that @xmath866 and @xmath867 .
then @xmath868 and @xmath869 are in the same tower in @xmath870 and @xmath871 . moreover , since each @xmath872 consists of complete local blocks from stage @xmath755 , for each @xmath873 ( @xmath73 ) such that @xmath874 , we have @xmath875 and @xmath876 .
fix such @xmath31 . for @xmath877 ,
let @xmath878 be such that @xmath879 .
let @xmath880 be such that @xmath881 and @xmath882 .
let @xmath883 ( @xmath884 ) such that @xmath885 .
for @xmath877 , let @xmath886 be levels such that @xmath887 . then
because the partial interval bijections @xmath305 at stage @xmath208 are extensions of concatenations of those at stage @xmath31 , we have @xmath888 .
since @xmath208 was arbitrary , it follows that @xmath889 .
therefore @xmath6 maps the backward @xmath0-orbit of @xmath167 into the @xmath1-orbit of @xmath795 . by similar argument
, @xmath6 maps the forward @xmath0-orbit of @xmath167 into the @xmath1-orbit of @xmath795 .
the argument for @xmath797 is also similar .
we have already seen that @xmath9 and @xmath10 are @xmath11 subsets of full measure .
let @xmath892 . then @xmath859 and @xmath893 by definition
let @xmath894 for some @xmath895 .
then @xmath896 because @xmath854 is @xmath0-invariant . and @xmath897 by lemma [ orbitsintoorbits ] ( and because @xmath893 ) .
therefore @xmath898 , so @xmath9 is @xmath0-invariant .
similarly , @xmath10 is @xmath1-invariant .
now suppose @xmath764 is a point in the @xmath1-orbit of @xmath795 .
then @xmath899 , so @xmath796 is in the orbit of @xmath167 . hence @xmath840 .
therefore @xmath6 carries the orbit of @xmath167 onto the orbit of @xmath795 .
the map @xmath6 is a conjugacy between the two induced maps @xmath900 and @xmath901 .
both @xmath858 and @xmath902 are nearly clopen .
therefore @xmath6 is a nearly continuous kakutani equivalence of @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
let @xmath868 and @xmath903 be two points in @xmath904 .
then , by theorem [ x0theorem ] , @xmath905 for some @xmath906 .
we wish to show that @xmath907 and @xmath147 have the same sign .
this will imply that @xmath6 restricted to @xmath904 is order preserving on orbits , and hence a conjugacy between the induced maps . as we saw in the proof of lemma [ orbitsintoorbits ] , @xmath908 for all sufficiently large @xmath73 .
let @xmath909 be minimal among such @xmath31 .
if @xmath910 , then @xmath907 and @xmath147 automatically have the same sign because each partial interval bijection @xmath305 at stage @xmath222 maps the levels in @xmath858 in an order - preserving way , and this is then carried through the diagram via concatenations .
if @xmath911 , then because @xmath909 is minimal , @xmath912 and @xmath913 must lie in different towers in @xmath914 .
and the partial interval bijections at stage @xmath909 are extensions of concatenations of those at stage @xmath915 .
so if @xmath863 , then the stage-(@xmath915 ) partial interval bijection that acts on @xmath868 in stage @xmath909 comes before the stage-(@xmath915 ) partial interval bijection that acts on @xmath869 in stage @xmath909 .
this order - preservation at stage @xmath909 is then carried through the diagram via concatenations , so @xmath916 .
similarly , @xmath917 implies @xmath918 .
m. k. roychowdhury , _
@xmath919-odometer and the binary odometer are finitarily orbit equivalent _ , ergodic theory and related fields , contemp .
430 , amer .
soc . , providence , ri , 2007 , 123 - 134 .
|
ergodic homeomorphisms @xmath0 and @xmath1 of polish probability spaces @xmath2 and @xmath3 are _ evenly kakutani equivalent _ if there is an orbit equivalence @xmath4 between full measure subsets of @xmath2 and @xmath3 such that , for some @xmath5 of positive measure , @xmath6 restricts to a measurable isomorphism of the induced systems @xmath7 and @xmath8 .
the study of even kakutani equivalence dates back to the seventies , and it is well known that any two zero - entropy loosely bernoulli systems are evenly kakutani equivalent . but even kakutani equivalence is a purely measurable relation , while systems such as the morse minimal system are both measurable and topological .
recently del junco , rudolph and weiss studied a new relation called _ nearly continuous kakutani equivalence_. a nearly continuous kakutani equivalence is an even kakutani equivalence where also @xmath9 and @xmath10 are invariant @xmath11 sets , @xmath12 is within measure zero of both open and closed , and @xmath6 is a homeomorphism from @xmath9 to @xmath10 .
it is known that nearly continuous kakutani equivalence is strictly stronger than even kakutani equivalence , and nearly continuous kakutani equivalence is the natural strengthening of even kakutani equivalence to the _ nearly continuous _ category the category where maps are continuous after sets of measure zero are removed . in this paper we show that the morse minimal substitution system is nearly continuously kakutani equivalent to the binary odometer .
|
it is common accepted that braking of pulsars is caused by the magneto - dipole radiation of the rotating magnetic star . in this case
the rate of losses of the neutron star rotation energy can be equated to the power of its magneto - dipole radiation : @xmath1 + where _ i _ is the moment of inertia of the neutron star , @xmath2 - the angular speed of its rotation , @xmath3 - its magnetic moment , @xmath0 - the angle between the rotation axis and the magnetic moment , _ c _ - speed of light . for standard parameters of neutron stars : masses of order of the solar mass ( @xmath4 ) and radii _ r _ of order of @xmath5 cm we can put _ i _ = @xmath6 . for the magnetic moment
we have @xmath7 + here @xmath8 is the magnetic induction at the magnetic pole , @xmath9 ?
the induction at the magnetic equator . instead of @xmath2 the rotation period @xmath10
is usually measured and we can obtain from ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) : @xmath11 + this equality is used usually to calculate magnetic inductions of pulsars assuming that @xmath12 for all objects . the known catalogs ( see , for example manchester et al
. , 2005 ) contain as a rule @xmath9 instead of @xmath8 .
here we propose to decline the assumption on the constancy of @xmath13 and use some estimations of this parameter to calculate more accurate values of pulsar magnetic inductions .
in a number of our works ( malov & nikitina , 2011a , b , 2013 ) some methods for calculations of the angle @xmath0 have been put forward and applied to some catalogs of pulsars ( keith et al . , 2010 ; van ommen et al . , 1997 ; weltevrede & johnston , 2008 ) at approximately 10 , 20 and 30 cm .
basic equations for this aim are ( manchester & taylor , 1977 ) : @xmath14 @xmath15 + here @xmath16 is the angle between the line of sight and the rotation axis , @xmath17 - the angular radius of the emission cone , @xmath18 - a half of the angular width of the observed pulse , @xmath19 - the position angle of the linear polarization , @xmath20 - longitude . the simplest case for the calculations of the angle @xmath0 is realized when the line of sight passes through the center of the emission cone , i.e. @xmath21 + in this case we can use the dependence of the observed pulse width @xmath22 at the @xmath23 level on the rotation period and determine the lower boundary in the corresponding diagram to obtain @xmath24 + as the result we have from ( 4 ) , ( 5 ) and ( 7 ) ( malov & nikitina , 2011a ) : @xmath25 + the values of angles calculated by this method are denoted as @xmath26 and given in the table 1 .
usually polarization measurements are made inside the pulse longitudes only . in this case
we can use the maximal derivative of the position angle . from ( 5 ) we have @xmath27 we can obtain from the dependence of @xmath22 on _ p _ by the least squares method @xmath28 + the third equation for the calculations of the angle @xmath0 is ( 4 ) . from these three equations we obtain @xmath29y^2 + 2c(d - b^2)y+c^2d^2-b^2(1+c^2)=0.\\\ ] ] + here @xmath30
+ we can transform the equation ( 9 ) to the following form @xmath31 + then finding the value of y from the equation ( 11 ) we can calculate @xmath0 from ( 13 ) .
we have calculated values of @xmath0 by this method and list them in the table 1 as @xmath32 . here
we correct the misprint in the equation ( 11 ) made in our papers ( malov & nikitina , 2011a , b , 2013 ) .
there is an additional way to calculate angles @xmath0 .
this way uses observable values of position angles and shapes of average profiles for individual pulsars . in this case , original equations form the closed system for calculations of the angles @xmath17 , @xmath16 and @xmath0 : @xmath33 as the observed pulsar profiles have various forms , the coefficient _
n _ has a different value depending on a profile structure .
we put arbitrary the following values of _ n _ ( fig.1 ) . if the ratio of the intensity @xmath34 in the center of the pulse to the maximal intensity @xmath35 is zero then @xmath36 . for @xmath37 @xmath38 , @xmath39 @xmath40 , @xmath41 @xmath42 , and for @xmath43 @xmath44 .
it is worth noting that the solution of the system ( 14 ) can be obtained numerically for any value of _
n_. for example , if @xmath45 , the solution for @xmath46 can be obtained from the equation : @xmath47 at n = 2 : @xmath48 y^4 + 2c \left [ c^2 ( 1 + d - 2d^2 ) - 2 - d \right ] y^3 + \left [ 2dc^4 ( 1 - d ) - \right .
. - c^2 ( 2d^2 - 6d + 7 ) + 5 \right ] y^2 + 2c \left [ c^2 d^2 + d(1 + c^2 ) - 2 ( c^2 - 1 ) \right ] y + c^2 d^2 ( 1 + c^2 ) - ( c^2 - 1)^2 = 0;\\ \end{array}\ ] ] at n = 3/2 : @xmath49 \sqrt{\frac{1 + \frac{c + y}{\sqrt{c^2 + 2cy + 1}}}{2 } } - c y^2 ( 1 - d ) - y - cd = 0;\ ] ] at n = 5/4 : @xmath50 this method gives angles @xmath51 ( see the table 1 ) . for some pulsars calculations
were made by one method only . when it was possible we used two or all three methods . in these cases ,
the mean value of the angle @xmath0 has been calculated .
the resulting values @xmath52 are listed in the table 1 .
some other authors ( for example , kuzmin & dagkesamanskaya , 1983 ; kuzmin et al . , 1984 ;
lyne & manchester , 1988 ) carried out calculations of the angle @xmath0 earlier for the shorter samples of pulsars using some additional assumptions .
we will use further our estimations to calculate magnetic inductions at the surface of the neutron stars .
the distribution of the angles @xmath0 from the table 1 ( fig.2 ) shows that the majority of pulsars have rather small inclinations of the magnetic moments .
these pulsars are old enough , and we can conclude that they evolve to the aligned geometry .
the average characteristic age for our sample of pulsars is @xmath53 years .
we must note however that the angles calculated by the method * _ 1 ) _ * are the lower limits of this parameter .
this explains partly the predominance of the small values of @xmath0 . from the table 1.,width=453 ]
.values of the angle @xmath0 ( deg ) . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ]
1 . some methods for calculations of the angle @xmath0 between rotation and magnetic axes were applied to obtain the values of @xmath0 for 376 radio pulsars .
the distribution of these values shows the predominance of small inclinations of the magnetic axes . 2 .
magnetic inductions at the surface of 375 pulsars considered were calculated .
there is no the measured derivative @xmath54 for the pulsar j1713 - 3949 and it is excluded from the consideration .
the distribution of the calculated magnetic inductions can be described by the gaussian with the maximal value of @xmath55 and the width in the logarithmic scale nearly 1 .
the calculated inductions are higher than the catalog equatorial inductions with the mean value of the ratio of these quantities of 5 . for the pulsar j1410 - 7404 @xmath56 . the maximal value of the ratio @xmath57 for the pulsar j2007 + 0809 .
this work has been carried out with the financial support of basic research program of the presidium of the russian academy of sciences * _ transitional and explosive processes in astrophysics _ * ( p-41 ) .
we thank a.v.biryukov for very useful comments and discussions .
99 keith m.j . , johnston s. , weltevrede p. and kramer m. , 2010 , mnras , 402 , 745 kuzmin a.d . ,
dagkesamanskaya i.m . , 1983
, soviet astron .
letters , 9 , 80 kuzmin a.d . ,
dagkesamanskaya i.m . ,
pugachev v.d . ,
1984 , soviet astron . letters , 10 , 357 lyne a.g . ,
manchester r.n . , 1988 ,
mnras , 243 , 477 manchester r.n .
, taylor j.h . , 1977 , pulsars .
w.h.freeman and company , san francisco manchester r.n .
et al . , 2005 ,
j. , 129 , 1993 .
malov i.f . ,
nikitina e.b . , 2011a , astron.rep . , 55
, 19 malov i.f . ,
nikitina e.b . , 2011b , astron.rep . , 55 , 878 malov i.f . , nikitina e.b
, 2013 , astron.rep . , 57 , 833 van ommen t.d .
et al . , 1997 ,
mnras , 287 , 1210 weltevrede p. , johnston s. , 2008 , mnras , 391 , 1210
|
we used the magneto - dipole radiation mechanism for the braking of radio pulsars to calculate the new values of magnetic inductions at the surfaces of neutron stars . for this aim
we estimated the angles @xmath0 between the rotation axis and the magnetic moment of the neutron star for 376 radio pulsars using three different methods .
it was shown that there was the predominance of small inclinations of the magnetic axes . using the obtained values of the angle @xmath0 we calculated the equatorial magnetic inductions for pulsars considered .
these inductions are several times higher as a rule than corresponding values in the known catalogs .
* keywords * magnetic fields ; methods : data analysis ; methods : statistical ; _ ( stars : ) _ pulsars : general
|
the exotic hydrogen like atoms are formed in highly excited states , when negative particles ( @xmath2 ) are stopped in hydrogen .
the deexcitation of exotic atoms proceeds via many intermediate states until the ground state is reached or a nuclear reaction takes place . despite a long history of theoretical and experimental studies the kinetics of this atomic cascade is not yet fully understood .
the present experiments with the exotic hydrogen - like atoms addresses a number of fundamental problems using precision spectroscopy methods , the success of which relies crucially on a better knowledge of the atomic cascade .
the experimental data are mainly appropriate to the processes at the last stage of the atomic cascade ( x - ray yields and the products of the weak or strong interaction of the exotic particle in the low angular momentum states with hydrogen isotopes )
. so the reliable theoretical backgrounds on the processes both in low - lying and in highly excited states are required for the detailed and proper analysis of the experimental data .
in this paper we present the _ ab initio _ quantum - mechanical treatment of non - reactive scattering processes of the excited exotic hydrogen atom in collisions with the hydrogenic atom in the ground state : @xmath3 elastic scattering(@xmath4 ) , stark transitions ( @xmath5 ) , and coulomb deexcitation ( cd ) ( @xmath6 ) . here
@xmath7 are hydrogen isotopes and @xmath8 ; @xmath9 are the principal and orbital quantum numbers of exotic atom . while the deexcitation processes are obviously essential for the atomic cascade , the role of the collisional processes preserving the principal quantum number @xmath10 is also very important .
the stark transitions affect the population of the @xmath11 sublevels and together with the elastic scattering they decelerate the exotic atoms thus influencing their energy distribution during the cascade .
starting from the classical paper by leon and bethe @xcite , stark transitions has been treated in the semiclassical straight - line - trajectory approximation ( see @xcite and references therein ) .
the fully quantum - mechanical treatment of the elastic scattering and stark transitions based on the adiabatic description was given for the first time in @xcite .
recently @xcite , the processes have also been studied in a close - coupling approach with using dipole approximation for interaction potential and taking the electron screening effect into account by the model .
the cross sections calculated in approaches @xcite are in good agreement .
concerning the cd process , the situation is much less defined , especially for low @xmath10 .
the first work on the cd process was performed by bracci and fiorentini @xcite in frame of the semiclassical approach with some additional approximations . in the following numerous papers ( see @xcite and references therein ) the cd process is considered within the asymptotic approaches using the adiabatic hidden crossing theory .
the cd calculations were also performed in the classical - trajectory monte - carlo ( ctmc ) approach@xcite .
while the coulomb deexcitation cross sections obtained in ctmc approach are in fair agreement with the semiclassical ones of bracci and fiorentini @xcite , the more elaborated advanced adiabatic approach ( aaa ) @xcite gives too small cd cross sections to explain the experimental data @xcite .
the reasons of such a strong discrepancy are not clear .
one can only assume that the semiclassical model of bracci and fiorentini as well as the ctmc approach are not valid for low - lying states and at low energies .
the processes ( 1 ) have been treated recently by authors in a unified manner in the framework of the close - coupling ( cc ) approach ( see for detail @xcite ) .
the differential and integral cross sections for the processes ( 1 ) have been calculated for muonic , pionic and antiprotonic hydrogen atoms in excited states with @xmath12 and in a kinetic energy range relevant for cascade calculations .
the energy shifts of the @xmath0 states due to vacuum polarization and strong interaction ( for hadronic atoms ) are included in the close - coupling method .
this approach allows to obtain the self - consistent description of all the processes ( 1 ) and is free from the additional approximations used in previous studies . the calculated differential and integral cross sections presented in this paper mainly refer to the cd process to illustrate some of our new results obtained quite recently .
all open channels corresponding to the exotic atom states with @xmath13 ( @xmath14 is principal quantum number in the entrance channel ) have been included in the cc calculations .
the effect of the closed channels with @xmath15 was also studied and will be discussed below .
( throughout the whole paper the cross sections are given in atomic units . )
the hamiltonian of the system @xmath16 ( after separation of the c.m .
motion ) is given by @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the reduced mass of the system , @xmath19 is the radius vector between the c.m . of the colliding atoms ,
@xmath20 and @xmath21 are their inner coordinates .
the interaction potential , @xmath22 , is a sum of four coulomb pair interactions between the projectile atom and the target atom particles . @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the hydrogen - like hamiltonians of the free exotic and hydrogen atom , whose eigenfunctions together with the angular wave function @xmath25 of the relative motion form the basis states , @xmath26 , with the conserving total angular momentum ( @xmath27 ) and parity @xmath28 . in the present consideration
we use the `` frozen '' electron approximation .
the cc approach can be extended in a straightforward manner to include the target electron excitations .
the total wave function of the system are expanded in terms of the basis states as follows @xmath29 the expansion ( 3 ) leads to the close - coupling second order differential equations for the radial functions of the relative motion , @xmath30 , @xmath31 the channel wave number is defined as @xmath32 , where @xmath33 and ( @xmath34 ) are the energy of the relative motion and the exotic atom quantum numbers in the entrance channel , respectively .
the bound energy of the exotic atom , @xmath35 includes the eigenvalue of @xmath23 , @xmath36 , and the energy shift , @xmath37 , due to the vacuum polarization and strong interaction ( in case of adronic atom ) .
hereafter , the energy @xmath33 will be referred to @xmath38 in the entrance channel ( we assume here that @xmath39 ) the matrix elements of the interaction potential , @xmath22 , @xmath40 are obtained by averaging it over the electron wave function of the @xmath41-state and then applying the multipole expansion .
the integration over ( @xmath42 reduces the matrix elements ( 5 ) to the multiple finite sum . at fixed @xmath33
the coupled differential equations ( 4 ) for the given @xmath43 and @xmath44 values are solved numerically by the numerov method with the standing - wave boundary conditions involving the real symmetrical @xmath45-matrix related to @xmath46-matrix by the equation @xmath47 .
all open channels corresponding to the exotic atom states with @xmath13 have been included in the close - coupling calculations . the effect of closed channels with @xmath15 was also investigated and will be discussed below . in the next sections we present and discuss the following total cross sections of the scattering processes : the partial cross section @xmath48 @xmath49 the total cross section of the @xmath50 transition @xmath51 , and the @xmath52-averaged cross section @xmath53 , and also the analogous differential cross sections .
the total cross sections calculated in adiabatic @xcite and present cc approaches are as a whole in good agreement at energies @xmath54 ev . the angular distributions obtained in the present cc and adiabatic @xcite calculations coincide in the region of the diffraction maximums but demonstrate significant differences in backward hemisphere ( see the left side of fig.1 ) .
-averaged differential ( elastic and stark ) cross sections ( left ) : adiabatic model @xcite(dashed lines ) and present cc ( solid lines ) .
the @xmath52-averaged differential stark cross sections for @xmath55 collisions vs. cms scattering angle @xmath56 at @xmath57 ev ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] -averaged differential ( elastic and stark ) cross sections ( left ) : adiabatic model @xcite(dashed lines ) and present cc ( solid lines ) .
the @xmath52-averaged differential stark cross sections for @xmath55 collisions vs. cms scattering angle @xmath56 at @xmath57 ev ( right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] the typical angular distributions of the stark @xmath58 transitions for @xmath59 are shown in fig . 1 ( right ) .
it is well known @xcite that cross sections of these processes are similar to the diffraction scattering ( at energies more @xmath60 ev ) with a strong forward peak enhancing with increasing energy and a set of maxima and minima .
while the elastic cross sections always have a strong peak at @xmath61 , the first maximum position in the stark cross section depends on the @xmath62 value .
in particular , for @xmath63 this maximum is at finite scattering angles as it is also remarked in @xcite .
+ some of our cc results for @xmath64 collision are shown in figs .
2,3 : the e - dependence of @xmath52-averaged stark cross sections for @xmath12 ( fig.2 ) and cross sections of the @xmath58 transitions for @xmath65 at @xmath66 ev ( fig.3 ) .
it is seen from fig.3 that @xmath0-state energy shift due to strong interaction leads to essential suppression of both stark @xmath67 and elastic @xmath68 transitions ( we used the value @xmath69 ev for the @xmath41-state shift and @xmath70 for @xmath0-states ) at energies compared with the shift value .
the same effect is observed for all hadronic atoms .
the nature of the cd process is quite different from the one of the elastic or stark processes .
in contrast to elastic ( stark ) scattering cd process is accompanied by the large energy release ( tens and hundreds ev ) and occur at smaller distances , so the details of the short - range interaction are more important for the treatment of cd process than for elastic processes .
this difference between elastic and deeply inelastic processes is illustrated by fig .
4 where the @xmath43 dependence of the partial - wave l - averaged cross sections @xmath71 for @xmath72 at three fixed energies 0.1 , 2 , and 50 ev is shown .
it is seen that a substantial part of the cd cross section ( @xmath73 ) comes from the partial waves with rather a low @xmath43 in contrast to the elastic ( stark ) process . in spite of the value of the total cd cross section
constitutes about few per cent of the total elastic cross section it is incorrect to treat cd in the framework of the perturbation theory . in each
significant for cd partial wave the value of the cd cross section is comparable with the elastic cross section .
the cd process is determined by the short - range behaviour of the wave function which changes when new channels are included in calculation . therefore , to calculate the transition @xmath74 in a proper way it is impossible to be restricted with the two - level approximation ( @xmath10 and @xmath75 ) and
the states with other nearest @xmath10 should be involved .
we studied the dependence of the results on the number of included channels and found that the inclusion of the channels with @xmath76 leads to a strong suppression of the main @xmath74 transitions in comparison with the two - level cc approximation and due to this the total cd cross section is also suppressed @xcite .
so in all our cd calculations we included all the open channel with @xmath13 . it should be noted that all the previous calculations of cd realized within semiclassical or adiabatic approaches used a two - level approximation .
it is obvious that two - level approximation is not absolutely suitable for the treatment of transitions with @xmath77 .
in contrast to the elastic scattering and stark transitions where the `` dipole '' approximation ( @xmath78 ) and even more rough dipole potential ( used in @xcite ) gives reasonable results ( at not too low energies ) , in case of the deeply inelastic process such as cd the full interaction must be used as it is clear from the present study .
it is commonly believed @xcite that the cd cross sections at low energies behave like @xmath79 . in order to reveal more explicitly the distinction from the @xmath79
behaviour the present @xmath52-averaged cd cross sections multiplied by energy are shown in fig.5 in comparison with the results of the sc model @xcite for @xmath80 and ctmc calculations @xcite for @xmath81 . as it is seen , the energy dependence of the cc cross sections in the region @xmath82 ev , as a whole , is in a qualitative agreement with the results @xcite and @xcite . at lower energies
the present cc results reveal @xmath83 dependence in accordance with the wigner threshold law ( the similar behaviour is seen in the ctmc results @xcite for @xmath81 ) and in disagreement with @xmath79 dependence obtained in the sc model @xcite and aa approach @xcite .
the distribution over the final states @xmath84 is strongly different from the sc results @xcite as illustrated in fig .
the cc calculations predict that the transitions with @xmath85 are strongly enhanced as compared with the results of the two - level approaches @xcite .
the @xmath85 transitions make up a substantial fraction ( 16% - 37% ) of the total cd cross section for @xmath86 .
the angular distributions of cd was calculated for the first time in @xcite .
earlier in the cascade calculations the angular distributions of the cd process are presumed to be isotropic .
the calculated cross sections for individual @xmath87 transitions with @xmath88 and 2 at energy @xmath89 ev are shown in fig .
7 . in fig . 8
the @xmath52-averaged cross sections for the @xmath90 transition at different values of the relative energy from 0.01 up to 15 ev are presented .
( left ) and with @xmath91 ( right ) for @xmath59 at @xmath92 ev.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] + ( left ) and with @xmath91 ( right ) for @xmath59 at @xmath92 ev.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] we found that the angular distributions both of the individual and @xmath52-averaged cross sections ( excluding very low energies ) are far from isotropic : as a whole the scattering at @xmath93 and @xmath94 is noticeably enhanced .
the cross sections for @xmath95 transitions ( see fig .
7 ) have ( as for elastic scattering ) a more pronounced diffraction structure with sharp maxima and minima and a strong peak at zero angle as compared with the smoother angular dependence for other cd transitions .
the increase of kinetic energy enhances asymmetry in the angular dependence of the @xmath52-averaged cross sections and decreases the role of the backward scattering ( see fig .
in order to illustrate the influence of the @xmath0 state energy shifts on the cd cross sections , we calculated the cd cross sections for @xmath96 collisions both with and without taking energy shifts into account .
the effect is the most pronounced for the low - lying states and is illustrated in fig .
one can see that the maximal suppression due to the energy shift of @xmath97 state is about two times at very low energy both for @xmath98 and @xmath99 transitions , while at @xmath100 ev does not exceed 15% ( for details see @xcite ) .
the energy dependence of the cd cross sections for the collisions of the @xmath101 atom ( @xmath65 ) with the hydrogen atom obtained in the cc approach is shown in fig . 10 for @xmath65 and the different values of @xmath102 = 1 , 2 and 3 .
the special features of these cross sections are the following : the similar energy dependence but sharper than that of the elastic scattering and stark transitions ( see also in fig .
10 ) ; the contribution of the transitions with @xmath103 is comparable with the one for @xmath102 = 1 and is equal about 50% .
the effect of the @xmath0 state shifts in the @xmath52-averaged cd cross sections is negligible due to small statistical weight of the @xmath0-state . in fig .
10 we also compare our results with those obtained in the semiclassical model for the @xmath104 transition .
the satisfactory agreement is observed , but this agreement is quite occasional and takes no place for other @xmath10 values .
the distribution over the final states @xmath84 is completely different from the sc results @xcite as it was illustrated in fig .
the presented above results were obtained by the solution of the close - coupling equations including all the open channels .
although the channels with @xmath15 for @xmath105 and at energies less or @xmath106 ev are strongly closed , they can essentially change the open - channel wave functions at short ranges determining cd process . in the present studies we included in the calculations all the open channels with @xmath107 and step by step added closed channels with @xmath108 to achieve the convergency of results . in fig .
11 some of our preliminary results are shown for the @xmath52-averaged cd cross sections at @xmath109 ev . according to our investigation , the closed channel effect on cd cross sections
depends crucially on the transition considered . as it is seen from fig . 11 in case of @xmath110 atom the inclusion in the basis set of the closed channels results in a more pronounced effect for low - lying states .
the investigations of convergency with the increase of number of closed channels are very time - consuming and are continuing now .
the unified treatment of the elastic scattering , stark transitions and coulomb deexcitation is presented within the quantum - mechanical close - coupling approach .
the differential and integral cross sections for the above processes are calculated for the excited muonic , pionic and antiprotonic hydrogen atoms with @xmath12 and relative energies relevant to the cascade calculations .
the new results for cd process are obtained : anisotropy of the angular distribution , substantial fraction of @xmath103 transitions up to @xmath111 ( for @xmath112 at all energies under consideration ) , and a proper threshold behaviour of the cd cross - section .
the calculated cross - sections are very important for the kinetics of the atomic cascade and give a more reliable theoretical input for the improved version of the cascade model @xcite .
v.p.popov and v.n.pomerantsev , hyp .
interact . *
101/102 * , 133 ( 1996 ) ; * 119 * , 133 ( 1999 ) ; * 119 * , 137 ( 1999 ) .
v.v.gusev , v.p.popov and v.n.pomerantsev , hyp .
interact . *
119 * , 141 ( 1999 ) . t.s.jensen and v.e.markushin , eur.journ.phys .
d , * 19 * , 165 ( 2001 ) . l.bracci and g.fiorentini , nuovo cim . * 43a * , 9 ( 1978 ) . l.i.ponomarev and e.a.solovov , yad.fiz . *
65 * , 1615 ( 2002 ) .
a.v . kravtsov and a.i .
mikhailov , yad.fiz .
* 69 * , 395 ( 2006 ) t.s.jensen and v.e.markushin , eur.journ.phys .
d , * 21 * , 261 ( 2001 )
. a.badertscher _ et al_. , europhys . lett .
* 54 * ( 3 ) , 313 ( 2001 ) .
korenman , v.n .
pomerantsev , and v.p .
popov , jetp lett .
* 81 * , 543 ( 2005 ) ; nucl - th/0501036 . v.p.popov and v.n.pomerantsev , nucl - th/051207 . v.n.pomerantsev and v.p.popov , jetp lett . *
83 * , 331 ( 2006 ) .
v.n.pomerantsev and v.p.popov , phys .
a * 73 * , 040501(r ) ( 2006 ) .
t.s.jensen , v.p.popov and v.n.pomerantsev , arxiv:0712.3010 ( 2007 ) .
|
the scattering processes of exotic atoms in excited states from hydrogen such as elastic scattering , stark transitions and coulomb de - excitation are studied within a close coupling approach .
the vacuum polarization and the strong interaction shifts of @xmath0-states ( in case of hadronic atoms ) are taken into account .
the differential and integral cross sections of the above processes are calculated to use them as the input in cascade calculations .
the effect of closed channels on the scattering processes is investigated . * scattering processes of excited exotic atoms : close - coupling approach * + _ institute of nuclear physics , moscow state university , 119992 moscow , russia@xmath1 institution1 _
|
studies of massive galaxy clusters and groups at @xmath5 typically find environments with little - to - no star formation activity , in sharp contrast with the field .
over - dense regions are dominated by red , passively - evolving s0 and elliptical galaxies , whereas more sparsely - populated regions tend to have galaxies with spiral morphologies , younger stellar populations , and systematically higher star formation rates @xcite .
an observed trend of increasing blue galaxy fraction with redshift ( the butcher - oemler effect ; * ? ? ?
* ) has been interpreted as evidence for higher star formation activity and stellar mass build - up in higher redshift clusters or alternatively , that star formation is quenched more recently by one or more processes in over - dense regions .
several physical mechanisms can account for the quenching of star formation in over - dense regions ( for a review , see * ? ? ?
galaxies in environments with sufficiently low velocity dispersions can be strongly perturbed by mergers .
galaxies can also be transformed more gradually by an ensemble of small perturbations with neighbours , a process called harassment @xcite . tidal forces can strip away a galaxy s halo gas ( starvation ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , cutting off a fuel source for future star formation and leading to a gradual decline in sf activity . in the high - density cores of massive clusters , the hot ( @xmath6 ) intra - cluster medium ( icm ) can quench star formation by removing gas from galaxies via ram - pressure stripping @xcite .
the relative strengths of these physical mechanisms are strongly dependent on the cluster or group properties ( dynamical state , mass , and intra - cluster or intra - group medium ) and environment
. targeted studies of galaxy clusters or groups at @xmath7 have revealed overwhelming evidence that galaxy transformation occurs not just in dense cluster cores , but at lower densities characteristic of cluster outskirts or galaxy groups @xcite .
studies with star formation tracers in the ir @xcite , uv @xcite , and optical emission - line measures @xcite have shown evidence of _ pre - processing _ , whereby infalling galaxies undergo changes prior to their arrival in the galaxy cluster , or galaxies are transformed entirely in the group environment @xcite .
the pre - processing hypothesis has also been supported by studies of the environmental dependence on galaxy morphology @xcite and colour @xcite .
numerical simulations have also been used to study the causes and implications of galaxy pre - processing .
@xcite showed that the dominant physical processes galaxies are likely subjected to in group environments , specifically the frequent weak tidal interactions of harassment , are capable of transforming late - type , disk - dominated galaxies into bulge - dominated , early - types .
furthermore , @xcite used simulations of dark matter halo merger trees , with semi - analytic models ( sams ) to populate the haloes with galaxies , and traced the histories of the simulated galaxies that ended up accreting onto cluster - mass haloes in different epochs . in doing so
, @xcite determined what fraction of those cluster galaxies had resided in haloes characteristic of group - masses for a long enough time to have been pre - processed prior to entering the cluster .
the results of their simulation showed that at low redshift a large fraction of cluster galaxies could have been affected by their environment prior to entering the cluster , while at earlier epochs the fraction of pre - processed galaxies in clusters should steadily decline .
the fraction of cluster galaxies affected by pre - processing in the @xcite simulation depends on the assumed timescale for the physical process(es ) in group environments to affect galaxies , and also has a stellar mass dependence .
although many assumptions go into this simulation , the result highlights a key point that the role of pre - processing has likely varied significantly over cosmic time , and that at @xmath8 pre - processing should be extremely prevalent .
recent studies have suggested that the quenching of sf activity in cosmic history is primarily driven by two distinct , and possibly separable , components : secular evolution ( or ` mass quenching ' ) and environmentally - driven processes ( or environment quenching ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
. however , see also @xcite for a discussion about how _ history bias _ affects one s ability to disentangle mass- and environment - quenching .
nevertheless , any attempt to examine the environmental dependence on galaxy evolution must include a careful account for the possibility that one s galaxy selection function has mass biases , particularly since the galaxy stellar mass function is known to vary with environment @xcite .
concerns about biases introduced by the galaxy selection function are compounded when examining galaxies over a wide range in redshift , as one s sensitivity , in galaxy mass and in other properties , like sfr , will undoubtedly also vary with @xmath9 . as a result ,
in many of these studies that extend to higher-@xmath9 one must restrict one s sample to only massive galaxies with high sfrs , and thereby have a less complete picture of the effects of environment on galaxy evolution .
furthermore , studies extending to higher-@xmath9 tend to sample a smaller dynamic range of environments , which similarly reduces one s ability to draw general conclusions about environmentally - driven processes .
a comprehensive view of galaxy evolution in different environments must be sensitive to a large dynamic range of local densities in order to capture not just the dense regions , like clusters and groups , but the more diffuse filament and void regimes .
a key challenge faced when interpreting the many results examining galaxy evolution , in addition to the aforementioned sources of potential bias , is the wide range of methods employed to characterise environment .
recently , @xcite used an array of different environmental mapping techniques , which could be roughly grouped into two categories : nearest - neighbour methods , which measure galaxy density with an aperture that changes depending on the local galaxy density , and fixed - aperture techniques , whose apertures do not vary , to examine a mock galaxy catalogue .
@xcite found that these techniques can analyse the same data set and get different results , but that the nearest - neighbour methods appear to be optimal for mapping the density fields within massive haloes , while the fixed - aperture methods are better suited for probing superhalo distance scales .
therefore , the technique that is optimal to identify large scale structures ( lss ) , like clusters , groups , and filaments , is not necessarily the best choice for measuring the density fields within those structures . in this work
, we seek to quantify the role of pre - processing in the local universe by analysing the rest - frame colour and star - formation activity of galaxies as a function of environment over about three orders of magnitude in projected density in the coma supercluster . by focusing on a low-@xmath9 field ,
we ensure that our sample of galaxies , taken from the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; * ? ? ?
* ) , is spectroscopically complete down to dwarf masses ( @xmath10 ) .
furthermore , we do not have to rely on photometric redshift ( photo-@xmath9 ) measurements , which would introduce additional contamination due to interlopers in our sample and significant smearing along the line - of - sight . to map the environments of the supercluster , we employ two complementary techniques : voronoi tessellation ( vt ) and the minimal spanning tree ( mst ) .
the former is a nearest - neighbour - based approach , which can measure the local density field effectively over the large dynamic range of densities that we find in the coma supercluster .
the latter technique is most effective at characterising continuous structures , like clusters , groups , and filaments , and therefore we use the mst to differentiate the types of environment extending over super - halo scales . our combined vt and mst approach allows us to select discrete components of the cosmic web by exploiting the fundamental density contrasts of the cluster , group , filament , and void environments .
another benefit of the proximity of our target field is sensitivity to low sfrs , as our combined approach of using the _ galaxy evolution explorer _
( galex ; * ? ? ? * ) and wide - field infrared survey explorer ( wise ; * ? ? ?
* ) to recover unobscured and dust - obscured star - formation activity , respectively , across the entire coma supercluster down to 0.02@xmath11 .
section [ sample ] describes the coma supercluster and our sample selection process , with our data from sdss , _ galex _ , and wise . in section [ lss ]
we outline our techniques for mapping the lss in the coma supercluster , and in section [ results ] we present our resulting sfrs and comparisons of sf activity and colour versus environment . in section [ discussion ]
we discuss the implications of our results , and compare our work to previous studies . throughout this paper
we use cosmological parameters @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 km s@xmath15 mpc@xmath15 , where pertinent cosmological quantities have been calculated using the online cosmology calculator of e. l. wright @xcite . throughout
we assume a kroupa imf @xcite , and hereafter we will refer to galaxies with stellar masses m@xmath1610@xmath17 as dwarf galaxies , and those with m@xmath1810@xmath17 as massive galaxies .
the coma supercluster is an ideal field to observe signatures of galaxy transformation in different environments .
it contains two rich galaxy clusters , abell 1656 and abell 1367 , and several galaxy groups distributed in a filamentary pattern between the two clusters @xcite .
furthermore , the two clusters are in very different dynamical states , with a1656 being relaxed and a1367 still undergoing significant merging @xcite .
the close proximity of the supercluster ( @xmath19 ) allows us to probe its galaxy population down to dwarf masses ( @xmath20 ) with a spectroscopically complete sample , and the geometric alignment of the supercluster , with the galaxy distribution extending largely perpendicular to our line - of - sight @xcite , makes it an ideal case study to examine galaxies in a wide range of environments with minimal projection effects . past
studies of the coma supercluster have been primarily focused on the most massive cluster , a1656 .
its low redshift , high galactic latitude ( @xmath21 ) , and richness ensured that it received a great deal of attention from observers in early extragalactic studies ( see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) .
a significant substructure @xmath01 mpc sw of the centre of a1656 , which has since been positively identified as an infalling group @xcite , was noticed first by the high local concentration of galaxies centred on the galaxy ngc 4839 , and was later confirmed by a diffuse x - ray profile and radial velocities of member galaxies .
@xcite found a large number of ` post - starburst ' ( or k+a ) galaxies coincident with the ngc 4839 group , leading to the conclusion that the ngc 4839 group had experienced a burst of star formation @xmath22 gyr ago @xcite , possibly triggered by tidal effects of the group - cluster merging @xcite .
a study by @xcite , examining emission - line and k+a galaxies in the core region of a1656 , found a spatial correlation between these galaxies and known x - ray sub - structures from @xcite , which indicates that stripping from the shocked icm might be an important factor in triggering starbursts , and subsequent quenching , for infalling galaxies .
studies of the entire supercluster population had to wait for new all - sky surveys with sufficient sensitivity to detect galaxies down to dwarf masses .
furthermore , a positive identification of supercluster members necessitates spectroscopic redshifts , which , prior to the sdss catalog , only existed for the most massive galaxies and those immediately around the two clusters .
@xcite were the first to conduct an extensive survey of the environmental dependence of star - formation activity in galaxies using the sdss , by comparing the sfrs , among other spectroscopic and photometric measures of galaxy properties , to the local density around @xmath0122 000 galaxies in the sdss data release one ( dr1 ) .
they found that for galaxies at fixed stellar masses , the sfrs sharply decline at higher densities , and that the presence of an active galactic nucleus ( agn ) is also much more common in galaxies with greater local density .
@xcite used @xmath23 low-@xmath9 galaxies in sdss dr4 , and showed a strong bimodal distribution between active and passive sf activity , using the equivalent width ew(h@xmath24 ) , and determined that the passive galaxies preferentially lie in regions with higher local galaxy density .
one of the first major systematic studies of the environmental dependence of galaxy properties across coma , using spectroscopically - confirmed members , was by @xcite .
they used sdss dr7 to select @xmath04000 supercluster members , and characterised the local environment around each galaxy by measuring the volume density of galaxies within a cylinder of radius @xmath25mpc and a half - length of 1000 km s@xmath15 ( but with a slightly modified treatment of galaxies associated with the clusters , as described in appendix [ appendix_b ] ) .
they examined the optical colours , morphologies , and frequency of post - starburst galaxies in different environments , and found a weak dependence of galaxy colour and morphology with environment for the most massive galaxies and a strong dependence of colour and morphology on environment for dwarf galaxies , and also that almost all post - starburst galaxies reside in higher - density regions .
@xcite , using a similar sample of sdss - selected members of coma , examined the local fraction of star - forming and agn - hosting galaxies ( characterised using sdss spectral line measurements ) vs local projected density .
they found a similar broad trend as @xcite , whereby star formation in dwarf galaxies is strongly quenched at higher densities , and more massive galaxies show a weaker dependence on local density .
@xcite also used observations from _ spitzer _
mips at 24@xmath26@xmath27 , which are available only for the core regions of a1656 and a1367 , to obtain a complete accounting of star formation activity in the highest - density regions of coma .
for a1656 , the more massive of the two clusters , they found significant ir detections only in the infalling regions , and recovered the expected correlation between dust - obscured and unobscured sfr with cluster - centric radius .
however , for the less massive a1367 they found the reverse radial dependence for the fraction of star - forming galaxies when sf activity is derived by the optical measure vs ir measure .
this result seems to indicate that an accounting of all tracers of sf activity , un - obscured and dust - obscured , may be required to get a clear picture of the quenching of sfr in galaxies . with the release of the wise all - sky survey
, we now have access to the ir component of sf activity throughout the entire coma supercluster , and so this work presents the first look sensitive to un - obscured and dust obscured sf activity for virtually all galaxies in all environments of the coma supercluster , down to quiescent sfrs and with a sample of galaxies spanning over two orders of magnitude in stellar mass . with our sfr sensitivity , and our techniques for mapping the components of the cosmic web , we are in a position to put significant quantitative constraints on the degree to which pre - processing affects galaxies at @xmath8 .
our sample of supercluster galaxies is selected from dr9 of the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; * ? ? ?
* ) , which has mapped a large fraction of the sky in @xmath28 bands and performed an extensive optical spectroscopic campaign complete ( over the sdss coverage areas ) for galaxies with @xmath29 mag .
we select coma supercluster members from the sdss dr9 galaxy sample following the selection criteria used by @xcite , choosing galaxies with positions ( @xmath30 , @xmath31 ) consistent with the coma supercluster and line - of - sight velocities , @xmath32 , within @xmath332000 km s@xmath15 of either a1656 ( @xmath34 km s@xmath15 ) or a1367 ( @xmath35 km s@xmath15 ) , where the central velocity of each cluster comes from @xcite . to ensure no duplicate objects in our sample , we use only galaxies with the specprimary designation set . to be sure that our sample is spectroscopically complete over the whole supercluster , we select only galaxies with @xmath3617.77 mag .
we have also excluded any galaxies with a zwarning flag to indicate a poor redshift determination ( which affects less than one per cent of galaxies in the sample ) .
we also require detections in the wise 3.4 and 4.5@xmath26 m bands for our entire sample ( less than 1.5 per cent of our sample lacks detections in these two bands ) , and we apply a stellar mass cut - off ( using stellar masses calculated with wise photometry , see section [ wise ] ) such that all galaxies in our sample have m@xmath37 .
the m@xmath38 cut - off excludes just 130 galaxies , but it s necessary to prevent our sample , which is @xmath39-band selected , from being biased at the lowest galaxy masses towards only those dwarf galaxies which are the most actively star - forming .
these selection criteria result in a sample of 3505 galaxies over the supercluster region covering @xmath0500 deg@xmath1 on the sky .
figure [ fig : coma_galaxies ] plots the galaxy positions over the supercluster .
the virial radii for the two clusters plotted in figure [ fig : coma_galaxies ] come from the @xmath40 ( the radius within which the density is equal to 200 times that of the critical density ) values determined by @xcite . having sdss spectra for all of our galaxies , we can also mitigate the contributions of galaxies dominated by an agn , which can otherwise contaminate our sfr estimates .
@xcite used the emission lines of the sdss galaxy spectra to classify galaxies according to a baldwin , phillips , & terlevich ( bpt ) diagram @xcite , which cleanly delineates those galaxies which host liner and agn emission compared to those dominated by emission from hii regions .
we use the @xcite classifications to identify galaxies dominated by agn or liner emission , and we exclude the wise 22@xmath26 m observations from these galaxies when measuring their sf activity throughout .
another benefit of having sdss spectral information on our galaxies is access to the ` 4000 break ' index , @xmath41 , which is a measurement of the ratio of the average flux density in two narrow continuum bands , 3850 - 3950 and 4000 - 4100 @xcite .
this index correlates strongly with the age of the stellar population in a galaxy , and has been shown to be a robust proxy for separating quiescent ` red sequence ' galaxies from those that are more actively star - forming in the ` blue cloud ' , with the approximate dividing line between these galaxy populations at @xmath42 @xcite .
hereafter , we use measurements of @xmath41 for sdss galaxies from @xcite . we also make use of the h@xmath43 line , specifically the index h@xmath44 @xcite which is described in greater detail in section [ kpa_vs_environ ] .
we correct the optical - to - nir band photometry for reddening using the @xcite extinction maps , assuming the extinction curve of @xcite with r@xmath45=3.1 .
for the _ galex _ bands we used the extinction corrections of @xcite .
we applied _
k_-corrections to our photometry using kcorrect v4_2 @xcite to get all uv - through - nir photometry into the rest frame . .
the two massive clusters ( ne : a1656 , sw : a1367 ) are identified by the red circles , which have radii equal to their virial radii .
the virial radii come from @xmath40 measurements in @xcite , width=326 ] .
[ fig : coma_galaxies ] we measure the un - obscured component of sf activity in coma supercluster galaxies from the _ galaxy evolution explorer _
( galex ; * ? ? ?
* ) gr6/gr7 data release , which includes mappings of the supercluster in near - uv ( nuv ; 1750 - 2750 ) and far - uv ( fuv ; 1350 - 1750 ) bands . matching the sdss galaxy catalogue to galex
was done using the mikulski archive for space telescopes ( mast ) database , with a 4@xmath46 search radius centred on the sdss galaxy positions . in cases of multiple galex matches within the search radius ,
the galex match with a position closest to that of the sdss galaxy coordinate was used .
the galex bands are most sensitive to the photospheric emission of stars with masses @xmath47 , and thus the uv continuum measurements provide an excellent tracer of recent star formation . under the assumption of a star formation timescale that s long relative to the ages of these massive stars ( @xmath48 yr ) , and a chosen imf
, one can derive a sfr@xmath49 corresponding to a given l@xmath49 .
the conversion between an observed luminosity and a sfr will be accurate as long as the emission picked up in one s uv band is dominated by the light of stars younger than 10@xmath50 years .
although the fuv and nuv bands are both dominated by emission from young stars , if there is recent or on - going sf activity , the nuv band contains a greater fraction of contaminating flux from stars as old as @xmath010@xmath51 years @xcite .
our survey covers roughly 500 sq .
degrees , and so it is unsurprising that the _ galex _ observation depths vary greatly across the supercluster .
almost the entire supercluster has been mapped with _ galex _ at various depths , but about 5 per cent of our galaxy sample of supercluster members do not lie in a _
galex _ coverage area .
the galaxies that are outside of _ galex _ coverage regions are flagged so that they are excluded from further analysis involving sf activity in the supercluster , as the sfrs we measure from wise alone will necessarily be lower limits .
the shallowest observation with _
galex _ in coma has an exposure time of just 60 seconds , while the deepest is about 3@xmath5210@xmath53 seconds .
therefore , to ensure that the sensitivity of our catalogue to sfr@xmath49 is uniform across the supercluster , we must carefully account for the variation in completeness due to differences in survey depth .
we measure completeness in a representative sample of _ galex _ nuv and fuv maps in coma , including the shallowest maps , by extracting a supercluster galaxy detected in the map and re - inserting that galaxy , with a range of normalisations , into the maps . for each normalisation , we insert 100 of these ` fake ' galaxies into a fuv and nuv map with random positions , and then repeat 100 times for a total of 10@xmath54 randomly placed galaxies per flux bin .
we then run source extractor @xcite on each of the 100 maps per flux bin to determine the fraction of the ` fake ' galaxies that we recover as a function of flux density .
figure [ fig : galex_completeness ] shows the completeness that we measure for the shallowest fuv and nuv map ( with 60 second exposure time ) of the coma supercluster .
we have taken the fluxes corresponding to 75 per cent completeness in the shallowest fuv and nuv maps ( indicated by vertical dashed lines in figure [ fig : galex_completeness ] ) , and we exclude any uv data for galaxies detected with fluxes below these completeness thresholds from our results . the completeness limit in nuv indicates that our coma supercluster catalogue is 75% complete to sfr@xmath55 in all environments . at the mean redshift of our coma supercluster sample.,width=307 ] as figure [ fig : galex_completeness ] shows , our sfr sensitivity in the coma supercluster is far greater in the nuv than in the fuv , and therefore we choose to use the nuv band to derive sfrs . to avoid having our sfr estimates significantly skewed by the presence of an older stellar population , which can contaminate the nuv band to a greater degree than in the fuv
, we will ignore nuv - based sfr estimates for any galaxy whose sdss spectrum shows a strong ` 4000 break ' , based on @xmath56 .
this is explored in detail in section [ galexsfrs ] .
a complete measure of sfr , especially for galaxies with reasonably high dust content , must include dust - obscured ( indirect ) tracers of sf activity .
a significant step forward in the measurement of star - formation activity in the coma supercluster has recently been made possible with the all - sky data release from the wide - field infrared survey explorer ( wise ; * ? ? ?
* ) , which has mapped the mid - infrared sky in four bands ( w1-w4 ) centred at 3.4 , 4.6 , 12.0 , and 22.0@xmath26 m .
of particular interest to our analysis is the fourth band , which probes the blue - ward side of the dust emission curve in star - forming galaxies .
we match our sdss catalogue to the wise point source catalogue by searching in a 5@xmath46 radius around each sdss galaxy position , and selecting the wise match whose position is closest to that of the sdss galaxy . for galaxies matched to the wise point source catalogue , we ignore w4 fluxes whose signal - to - noise in w4 is less than three .
we measured completeness in w4 for a representative sample of the coma supercluster , following the procedure outlined in section [ galex ] .
for wise w4 we are 75% complete to f@xmath57}$ ] @xmath58 4.7 mjy , which means our measurements of sfr@xmath59 are complete to sfr@xmath600.2 @xmath11 for members of the coma supercluster ( at l@xmath61 ) . for comparison , the only survey prior to wise capable of detecting dust - obscured star formation activity across the entire supercluster was iras @xcite , whose completeness limit for l@xmath59 at coma with its 25@xmath26 m band is a full two orders of magnitude higher ( l@xmath62 ) .
the two shortest - wavelength wise bands , which sample the red side of the 1.6 stellar photospheric feature , can be used to robustly estimate total galactic stellar masses ( m@xmath38 ) .
recent work by @xcite gives a calibration between flux densities measured in _
irac ch1 and ch2 and a galaxy s stellar mass ( assuming a salpeter imf ) .
we have applied the @xcite calibration , converted to a kroupa imf to be consistent with the rest of our study , using the wise bands w1 and w2 . in figure
[ fig : st_masses ] we plot a comparison between the stellar masses of coma supercluster galaxies using the @xcite calibration with w1 + w2 photometry and the stellar mass estimates from the sdss @xcite , where we find excellent agreement between these two independent measures of stellar mass .
a key component of our analysis is to characterise the local environment in a physically meaningful way .
typically , this approach has involved a calculation of the local surface ( 2d ) or volume ( 3d ) density of galaxies to describe the environment near a given galaxy based on the local density .
a proper characterization of environment requires not just a measurement of the local galaxy density , but a technique to resolve the structures ( groups , filaments , etc . ) traced by galaxies .
the latter task can be very difficult , as lss mapping techniques are often susceptible to biases introduced by a characteristic shape or size scale one is examining .
we have developed a technique to map lss and characterise galaxy environments in a manner which is independent of the shape and size scale of the structure , and allows one to estimate local projected galaxy density over an arbitrarily large dynamic range of densities , by using a combination of voronoi tessellation ( to calculate local surface density ) and the minimal spanning tree ( to resolve continuous structures ) .
vt is a method of decomposing a set of points into polygonal cells ( voronoi cells ) , where each cell corresponds to one point and the boundaries of the cell enclose all of the surrounding space closest to that point .
vt has proven to be a very powerful tool for characterizing the galaxy density field ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
when using a 2d surface density measurement to define the local galaxy density , one must be careful to not allow projection effects to significantly contaminate the density estimates . to help mitigate this
we are using only spectroscopically - confirmed members .
we show in appendix [ appendix_b ] that our surface densities in the coma supercluster correlate strongly with volume density estimates calculated following the procedures of @xcite . for an additional strong demonstration of the effectiveness of surface density measurements as tracers of the volume density ,
see figure 1 of @xcite , which shows a tight correlation between surface density and volume density over about two orders of magnitude in density being probed in the abell 901/902 supercluster .
a common challenge when trying to measure the galaxy density field is determining the area ( or volume ) over which to measure the density at each galaxy s position .
often the density measurements are made on a size scale set by the n@xmath63 nearest neighbour or by using a characteristic kernel with an adaptive size scale .
although these methods have flexible size scales , the shape of the region used to calculate the density field is generally fixed . calculating densities reliably over a very large dynamic range of environments requires a technique that can adjust to arbitrary size scales _ and _ local geometry .
vt addresses the difficulty of needing both adaptive size and shape by using cells which automatically adjust to the nearby density , and which assume no _ a priori _ shape . in regions of lower source density the cells are larger on average , and the cells get progressively smaller in higher density regions . with vt , one can calculate the local density around a given galaxy s position by taking the inverse of the area of the cell that encloses that galaxy .
we compute the vt of the coma supercluster using the qhull function @xcite in * idl * , which calculates convex hulls for the 2d distribution of points .
a common issue with vt , and with any method of measuring the local density field , is spurious density estimates arising near the edges of the map , where many cells can be artificially large or even unbounded .
we avoid this issue entirely by adding galaxies from the sdss dr9 in a 10 degree - wide ` buffer ' surrounding our coma supercluster map , which all have redshifts consistent with coma and the same selection criteria defined in section [ sdss ] , when calculating our vt .
we then exclude these buffer galaxies from further analysis , so the only purpose of these galaxies is to ensure that we do not suffer any edge effects in our supercluster dataset . in figure
[ fig : tessduo ] ( left ) we plot the voronoi cells over the supercluster .
we compare the distribution of cell densities in the supercluster to a set of 1500 maps generated with source positions randomly distributed , but each with an equal number of sources and an area equal to the coma supercluster map . in figure
[ fig : tessduo ] ( right ) we show the cumulative distribution of cell densities observed in coma compared to the mean cumulative distribution of projected voronoi cell densities for the set of random realizations .
these random maps are necessary to establish a baseline density with which to compare our observed voronoi cell densities in coma .
figure [ fig : tessduo ] ( right ) highlights a couple of key differences between the cell density distribution of the observed supercluster population and that of the random realizations . as one would expect , since the supercluster contains regions of extremely high galaxy density , there is a much larger fraction of cells with densities upwards of 100 - 1000 gal h@xmath64 mpc@xmath65 than in the random distributions .
but we also find that there is a larger fraction of cells in the coma supercluster at very low densities , around 1 - 10 gal h@xmath64 mpc@xmath65 , as a more clustered population implies that one finds more prominent voids as well .
the cumulative distribution of projected cell densities in our full coma catalogue gradually increases over a density range of log(@xmath66)=0.53.5 [ gal h@xmath64 mpc@xmath65 ] , meaning that our supercluster map samples about three orders of magnitude in projected galaxy density .
the random distributions tend to sample about one order of magnitude in galaxy density with any appreciable number of cells .
vt measures the density field across the huge dynamic density range of the supercluster , but it is less effective at resolving continuous structures .
therefore , we now turn to the complementary approach of the mst .
[ cols="^,^ " , ]
@xcite , hereafter m2010 , presented a table of 110 dwarf k+a galaxies in the coma supercluster , which come from a parent supercluster galaxy sample very similar to that of the present work , and with an identical set of criteria to select the post - starburst galaxies ( see section [ kpa_vs_environ ] ) .
however , we find only 62 such k+a galaxies .
we matched the published m2010 k+a catalogue to our own , and find that 91 of the 110 galaxies proposed by m2010 are indeed in our parent supercluster sample .
however , only 41 of the 110 proposed k+a galaxies from m2010 show spectral characteristics , based on our sdss line measurements , indicative of being k+a .
figure [ fig : h_alpha_delta_compare ] shows the comparison between the m2010 ew(h@xmath24 ) and ew(h@xmath43 ) measurements , and those from the present study , for the 91 proposed k+a galaxies matched to our sample .
it s abundantly clear that there are significant differences in the spectral line measurements for both lines relevant for selecting k+a galaxies , with a prominent systematic offset for h@xmath24 and a large scatter in the measurements of h@xmath43 .
the reasons for these inconsistencies stem from the different techniques used to obtain the line measurements .
the data used in the m2010 catalogue come from the * specline * products , but for the present work we use * galspecline * and * galspecindx * , which are based on the mpa - jhu analysis ( see * ? ? ?
for the * specline * data products , the spectrum continuum is fit using a sliding mean / median filter ( c. tremonti , private comm . ) , while for * galspecline * and * galspecindx * the continuum is fit with stellar population synthesis models @xcite .
the differences in continuum fitting techniques are responsible for most of the systematic offset between h@xmath24 measurements in figure [ fig : h_alpha_delta_compare ] , as the underlying h@xmath24 from the stellar population has not been subtracted from the measurements used in m2010 .
there is also a factor of @xmath68 difference because the * specline * measurements were not converted to the rest - frame , but for the redshift of coma this is a relatively small effect .
the differences seen in h@xmath43 come from a combination of the lack of robust continuum fitting and the fact that the * specline * products measure h@xmath43 using a simple gaussian .
the h@xmath43 measurement used for our present study comes from the lick index h@xmath44 , first proposed by @xcite , and also described in @xcite , which is designed to optimally capture the h@xmath43 absorption feature in the atmospheres of a - type stars .
|
we examine the effects of pre - processing across the coma supercluster , including 3505 galaxies over @xmath0500 deg@xmath1 , by quantifying the degree to which star - forming ( sf ) activity is quenched as a function of environment .
we characterise environment using the complementary techniques of voronoi tessellation , to measure the density field , and the minimal spanning tree , to define continuous structures , and so we measure sf activity as a function of local density _ and _ the type of environment ( cluster , group , filament , and void ) , and quantify the degree to which environment contributes to quenching of sf activity .
our sample covers over two orders of magnitude in stellar mass ( 10@xmath2 to 10@xmath3 ) , and consequently we trace the effects of environment on sf activity for dwarf and massive galaxies , distinguishing so - called ` mass quenching ' from ` environment quenching ' .
environmentally - driven quenching of sf activity , measured relative to the void galaxies , occurs to progressively greater degrees in filaments , groups , and clusters , and this trend holds for dwarf and massive galaxies alike .
a similar trend is found using @xmath4 colours , but with a more significant disparity between galaxy mass bins driven by increased internal dust extinction in massive galaxies .
the sfr distributions of massive sf galaxies have no significant environmental dependence , but the distributions for dwarf sf galaxies are found to be statistically distinct in most environments .
pre - processing plays a significant role at low redshift , as environmentally - driven galaxy evolution affects nearly half of the galaxies in the group environment , and a significant fraction of the galaxies in the more diffuse filaments .
our study underscores the need for sensitivity to dwarf galaxies to separate mass - driven from environmentally - driven effects , and the use of unbiased tracers of sf activity .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : clusters : general galaxies : evolution infrared : galaxies ultraviolet : galaxies .
|
precise doppler surveys of main sequence stars have revealed eight companions that have masses under 5 m@xmath6/ @xmath7 , with the orbital inclination , @xmath8 , remaining unknown ( mayor et al .
1999 , marcy & butler 1998 , noyes et al .
1997 , cochran et al .
1997 ) . these `` planetary '' companions exhibit both circular and eccentric orbits , consistent with formation in dissipative circumstellar disks , followed by gravitational perturbations ( cf .
lin et al . 1995 , artymowicz 1997 , levison et al . 1998 ) .
the semimajor axes are all less than 2.5 au , with most being less than 0.3 au .
this `` piling up '' of planets near their host stars appears to be a real effect , although enhanced by the selection effect that favors detection of small orbits .
jupiters orbiting between 0.5 and 1.5 au would be easily detected with our current doppler precision of 5 , but none has been found .
this distribution of orbits supports models in which orbital migration in a gaseous protoplanetary disk drags jupiter mass planets inward ( lin et al .
1995 , trilling et al .
1998 ) .
the distribution of the masses of substellar companions reveals two populations .
our survey of 107 gk dwarfs revealed none that had @xmath9= 10 80 m@xmath6@xmath10(marcy & butler 1998 ) .
thus , `` brown dwarf '' companions occur with a frequency less than @xmath111% , within 5 au . similarly , mayor et al .
( 1997 , 1999 ) surveyed @xmath11500 gk dwarfs , and found at most 4 companions between 10 80 m@xmath6 .
( hipparcos astrometry has shown that seven previously suspected brown dwarfs from that sample are actually h burning stars . ) in contrast , at least 5% of gk stars harbor companions with masses from 0.5 5 m@xmath6 . for example , in our doppler survey of 107 main sequence stars at lick observatory , we found 6 companions that have @xmath12 = 0.5 5 m@xmath6@xmath10(marcy and butler 1998 , this paper ) .
thus , relative to this well populated planetary decade of masses , there exists a brown dwarf `` desert '' at masses 10 80 m@xmath6 , within 5 au .
the efforts described above have focussed on g and k type main sequence stars having masses between 0.8 and 1.2 m@xmath5 .
the question arises regarding the prevalence of planets around the m dwarfs which constitute 70% of the stars in the galaxy . here
we describe the detection of the first apparent planetary companion to an m dwarf , gliese 876 , located 4.7 pc from the sun .
gliese 876 ( = hip 113020 ) has v magnitude of 10.1 , a spectral type of m4v and a parallax from hipparcos of 0.213 ( perryman et al . 1997 ) . adopting this parallax and the bolometric correction of delfosse et al .
( 1998 ) gives @xmath13 = 9.52 , which implies a luminosity of , @xmath14 = 0.0124 l@xmath5 .
the mass of the star gliese 876 can be derived from its k - band apparent magnitude ( k=5.04 ) and parallax , along with an empirical mass luminosity relation ( henry & mccarthy 1993 ) .
this gives @xmath15 = 0.32 @xmath3 0.03 m@xmath5 .
gliese 876 is chromospherically inactive ( delfosse et al .
1998 ) , which suggests that it is older than @xmath111 gyr .
however its space motion is slow which suggests that its age is less than 10 gyr .
its metalicity is not known well , though a preliminary synthesis of the spectrum indicates that it is metal poor by a factor of 23 relative to the sun ( valenti , 1998 ) .
doppler shifts for gliese 876 have been obtained at both lick and keck observatories , using the hamilton and hires echelle spectrometers , respectively ( vogt 1987 , vogt et al .
the first observations were made in 1994.9 ( at lick ) and in 1997.4 ( at keck ) , and both data sets extend to the present .
the calibration of wavelength and the measurement of the spectrometer psf was determined for each exposure and for each 2 chunk of spectrum by using iodine absorption lines superimposed on the stellar spectrum ( butler et al . 1996 ) .
figures 1 and 2 show all of the individual velocity measurements as a function of time , along with the separate keplerian fits .
the velocities from lick observatory have typical uncertainties of 30 and those from keck are 6 m@xmath10s@xmath16 .
poisson statistics of the photons dominate the velocity errors for this relatively faint ( v=10.1 ) star .
error bars on all points are the uncertainty in the mean of the velocities ( @xmath17 ) from the many 2 wide chunks into which the spectrum was divided .
doppler measurements of gliese 876 at haute provence by delfosse et al .
( mayor et al . 1999 ) also show an amplitude and periodicity in agreement with those reported here , thus constituting an immediate confirmation .
it remains to be seen if their orbital parameters agree with those quoted here .
the lick and keck data each carry independent and arbitrary velocity zero - points .
the relative zero point has been determined by combining the two data sets and adjusting the velocity offset until the keplerian fit ( see 3 ) yields a minimum in the @xmath18 statistic .
thus , the lick and keck velocities were forced to have the same zero - point .
independent keplerian fits were determined from the lick and keck data sets , and the resulting curves and orbital parameters are shown in figures 1 and 2 .
the final orbital parameters are given in table [ orbit ] , based on an orbital fit to the combined data set .
the uncertainties reflect the differences in the two independent orbital fits .
the two solutions agree within their uncertainties .
the joint orbital period is @xmath19 = 60.85 @xmath3 0.15 d , and the eccentricity is @xmath2 = 0.27 @xmath3 0.03 .
the orbital solution implies a planetary orbital semi - major axis of 0.21 @xmath3 0.01 au , and a minimum mass of @xmath9= 2.1 @xmath3 0.2 m@xmath6 .
this inferred @xmath9is proportional to the assumed mass of the host star ( 0.32 @xmath30.03 m@xmath5 ) which contributes most of the uncertainty in the companion mass .
the periodic repetition of an asymmetric radial velocity variation is apparent from the raw data and from the fits in figures 1 and 2 .
the orbit is clearly not circular .
there is no pattern in the residuals , thus excluding the presence of any second planet with a mass greater than 1 jupiter mass and a period of 4 years or less in the gliese 876 system . the lick and keck velocities can be merged to yield a final fit , as shown in figure 3 .
this shows that the two sets share a common orbital phase in addition to similar best
fit orbital parameters .
we note that two points from lick sit off the keplerian curve by 2@xmath20 , and we suspect that the quoted errors of @xmath1130 in those cases may be underestimated due to the low signal to noise ratios of those spectra .
the large velocity amplitude of 220 for gliese 876 leaves orbital motion as the probable cause of the velocity variations .
spots on a rotating star can , in principle , cause artifical velocity variations . but for gliese 876 , the equatorial rotation velocity is less than 2 km@xmath10s@xmath16 , and the star is photometrically stable to within @xmath110.02 mag ( marcy and chen 1992 , weiss 1996 , delfosse et al .
therefore , spots can not alter the apparent velocity by more than @xmath110.02 @xmath21 2000 = 40 .
we have not checked for stellar pulsations , but the photometric stability suggests that any pulsations are not significant here . moreover , acoustic oscillations and g modes for a 0.3 m@xmath5 dwarf would have time scales of minutes and hours , respectively , unlike the observed 60 day velocity period .
the companion to gliese 876 , with @xmath9= 2.1 @xmath30.2 m@xmath6 , has a likely mass of 2 to 4 m@xmath6 , assuming unbiased orbital inclinations . for an assumed companion mass of 2.1 m@xmath6 ,
the astrometric semimajor axis would be 0.28 mas .
hipparcos astrometry exhibits no wobble at a 2@xmath20 upper limit of 4 mas ( perryman et al .
thus , the upper limit to the companion mass is 29 m@xmath6 . at 4.7 pc ,
this is the closet known extrasolar planet .
the semimajor axis implies an angular separation 0.045 arcsec , with a greatest separation of 0.062 arcsec .
it is thus a prime candidate for direct imaging with ir adaptive optics and with interferometry ( i.e. , keck , lbt , sim , vlti ) .
astrometric detection is also favored due to : 1 .
its close proximity to the sun , 2 .
the large mass of the planet , 3 .
the low mass of the star , 4 .
the small orbital period which permits many cycles to be monitored within a season .
gliese 876 is apparently the first m dwarf with a known planetary companion .
we have surveyed only 24 m dwarfs from lick observatory during the past 4 yr ( with poor precision of 25 ) , which implies that the occurrence of jupiter mass planets within 2 au of m dwarfs could be a few percent , based on this one detection .
the duration and paucity of keck observations render them not yet adequate ( @xmath111 yr ) to add information on the occurrence of planets around m dwarfs .
the small orbital semi - major axis of @xmath4=0.21 au and the eccentricity of @xmath2=0.27 pose two profound puzzles regarding the origin of such planetary orbits .
there is too little mass within a planetary feeding zone in a nominal protoplanetary disk at distances of 0.2 au to provide 2 jupiter masses of material to a growing planet ( cf .
lissauer 1995 ) .
one suggestion is that giant planets form several au from the star and then migrate inwards .
orbital migration can be induced by interactions between the planet and the gas in the protoplanetary disk , bringing the planet inwards ( lin et al .
1995 , trilling _ et al .
_ 1998 ) . however , it is not clear what would cause the planet around gliese 876 to cease its migration at 0.2 au .
neither tidal interactions with the star nor a magnetospherically cleared hole at the disk center would extend to 0.2 au , and thus they can not halt the migration . a similar , as yet - unidentified parking mechanism appears needed for the planets around 55 cancri and @xmath22 cor bor ( noyes et al .
1997 , butler et al .
1997 ) .
the non circular orbits for both @xmath22 cor bor ( @xmath2=0.16 @xmath3 0.06 ) and for this planet around gliese 876 ( @xmath2=0.27@xmath30.03 ) imply that significant orbital eccentricities are common for jupiter mass companions orbiting between 0.1 and 0.3 au from their star . some physical mechanism must be identified which generally produces sizable eccentricities , in contrast to the inexplicably low eccentricities of the giant planets in our solar system .
infrared speckle reveals no companions to gliese 876 from 1 au outward ( henry & mccarthy 1990 ) , and the lack of large variations in the velocities rule out stellar companions within 1 au . thus , the eccentricity of the planetary companion around gliese 876 could not have been pumped by a stellar companion .
apparently , migration , if necessary , did not enforce circularity in the final orbits of gliese 876 or @xmath22 cor bor .
one possible explanation is that gravitational scattering of planetary cores ( of earth mass and larger ) can dominate the orbital evolution ( rasio and ford 1996 , weidenschilling and marzari 1997 , lin and ida 1996 ) .
orbit crossings and global instabilities among planetesimals in the disk can lead to dramatic orbit changes and large eccentricities ( levison et al .
1998 ) .
long lived gas in a protoplanetary disk may lead to circular orbits in such planetary systems .
other systems that lose their gas may suffer dynamical instabilities , leading to eccentric orbits at a variety of semimajor axes .
however , the latter scenario , if common , does not explain the apparent paucity of jupiters from 0.5 to 1.5 au , and it remains to be seen if jupiters are common farther out .
the equilibrium temperature at optical depth unity in the atmosphere of the planet around gliese 876 is estimated to be -70 c , too cold for water in liquid form ( saumon 1998 ) .
temperatures would be higher at deeper layers in the atmosphere .
any bodies orbiting interior to 0.2 au would have surface temperatures above -70 c. it would be interesting to determine if planets could reside in stable orbits within 0.2 au , perhaps in mean motion resonances with the giant planet discovered here .
we thank kevin apps for analysis of hipparcos astrometry .
we thank xavier delfosse , michel mayor , and didier queloz for communicating their velocities for gliese 876 .
we thank m. duncan , d. lin , and g.basri for useful conversations .
we acknowedge support by nasa grant nagw-3182 and nsf grant ast95 - 20443 ( to gwm ) , and by nsf grant ast-9619418 and nasa grant nag5 - 4445 ( to ssv ) and by sun microsystems .
we thank the nasa and uc telescope assignment committees for allocations of telescope time .
lcc orbital period @xmath19 ( days ) & 60.85 & 0.15 + velocity semi - amplitude @xmath23 ( ms@xmath16 ) & 239 & 5 + eccentricity @xmath2 & 0.27 & 0.03 + longitude of periastron @xmath24 ( deg ) & 24 & 6 + periastron date @xmath25 ( julian date ) & 2450301.0 & 1.0 + @xmath26 ( m@xmath6 ) & 2.11 & 0.20 + semimajor axis a ( au ) & 0.21 & 0.01 +
|
doppler measurements of the m4 dwarf star , gliese 876 , taken at both lick and keck observatory reveal periodic , keplerian velocity variations with a period of 61 days .
the orbital fit implies that the companion has a mass of , @xmath0 = 2.1 m@xmath1 , an orbital eccentricity of , @xmath2 = 0.27@xmath30.03 , and a semimajor axis of , @xmath4 = 0.21 au .
the planet is the first found around an m dwarf , and was drawn from a survey of 24 such stars at lick observatory .
it is the closest extrasolar planet yet found , providing opportunities for follow up detection .
the presence of a giant planet on a non - circular orbit , 0.2 au from a 1/3 m@xmath5 star , presents a challenge to planet formation theory .
this planet detection around an m dwarf suggests that giant planets are numerous in the galaxy .
|
let us begin with the following facts : 1 . for any differential
graded algebra @xmath1 , the hochschild cohomology @xmath2 has a gerstenhaber algebra structure .
2 . let @xmath3 be a closed , oriented @xmath4-dimensional @xmath0-manifold , @xmath5 be the free loop space .
then , @xmath6 has a batalin - vilkovisky ( in particular , gerstenhaber ) algebra structure .
3 . let @xmath7 denote the differential graded algebra of differential forms on @xmath3 .
there exists a linear map @xmath8 defined by iterated integrals of differential forms , which preserves the gerstenhaber structures .
\(a ) is originally due to gerstenhaber @xcite .
( b ) is due to chas - sullivan @xcite , which is the very first paper on string topology .
( c ) relates the geometric construction ( b ) to the algebraic construction ( a ) .
it seems that ( c ) is also well - known to specialists ( see remark [ 150205_2 ] ) .
( a)(c ) concern algebraic structures on homology level , and it is an important and interesting problem to define chain level refinements of these structures . for ( a )
, so called deligne s conjecture claims that a certain chain model of the little disks operad acts on the hochschild cochain complex .
various affirmative solutions to this conjecture and its variations are known ; see @xcite part i section 1.19 , @xcite section 13.3.15 , and the references therein .
the aim of this paper is to propose a chain level algebraic structure which lifts ( b ) ( the batalin - vilkovisky ( bv ) algebra structure in string topology ) , and compare it with a solution to deligne s conjecture via a chain map which is a chain level lift of ( c ) .
let us briefly describe our main result ( see theorem [ 150628_1 ] for the rigorous statement ) .
first of all , for any closed , oriented @xmath0-manifold @xmath3 , we define a chain complex @xmath9 over @xmath10 , which is a chain model of @xmath11 .
we also define a differential graded operad @xmath12 and its suboperad @xmath13 .
these operads are chain models of the framed little disks operad and the little disks operad , and defined independently from @xmath3 .
we establish the following statements : 1 . for any differential
graded algebra @xmath1 , the hochschild complex @xmath14 admits an action of @xmath13 , which lifts the gerstenhaber structure on @xmath15 in ( a ) .
2 . for any closed , oriented @xmath0-manifold @xmath3 ,
the chain complex @xmath9 admits an action of @xmath12 , thus @xmath16 has the bv algebra structure .
there exists an isomorphism @xmath17 preserving the bv structures .
3 . there exists a @xmath18-equivariant chain map @xmath19 , such that @xmath20 coincides the map in ( c )
. there may be several different ways to work out chain level structures in string topology , based on choices of chain models of the free loop space .
the singular chain complex has the transversality trouble , namely string topology operations are defined only for chains transversal to each other .
the hochschild complex of differential forms ( used e.g. in @xcite ) avoids this trouble , however it is not always a correct chain model of the free loop space ( see remark [ 150811_1 ] ) , and loses some geometric informations ( e.g. lengths of loops , see section 1.5.3 ) .
our chain model @xmath9 is an intermediate one of these two .
this section is organized as follows . in sections 1.11.4 ,
we recall several basic definitions and facts , fixing various notations an signs . in section 1.5 , we state theorem [ 150628_1 ] , which is our main result , and a few supplementary results .
section 1.6 discusses previous works and 1.7 discusses potential applications to symplectic topology .
section 1.8 explains the plan of the rest of this paper .
first we briefly recall the notion of ( nonsymmetric ) operads .
the main aim is to fix conventions , and we refer @xcite part ii section 1.2 for details .
let @xmath21 be any symmetric monoidal category with a multiplication @xmath22 and a unit @xmath23 .
a _ nonsymmetric operad _
@xmath24 in @xmath21 consists of the following data : * an object @xmath25 for every integer @xmath26 . * a morphism @xmath27 for every @xmath28 and @xmath29 .
these morphisms are called _
( partial ) compositions_. * a morphism @xmath30 called a _ unit _ of @xmath24 .
we require that compositions satisfy associativity , and @xmath31 is a two - sided unit for compositions .
when @xmath25 admits a right action of the symmetric group @xmath32 ( @xmath33 is the trivial group ) for each @xmath26 , such that these actions are compatible with compositions , @xmath24 is called an _ operad _ in @xmath21 . for any ( nonsymmetric ) operads @xmath24 and @xmath34 , a morphism of ( nonsymmetric ) operads @xmath35 is a sequence of morphisms @xmath36 which preserves the above structures .
when @xmath37 are monics for all @xmath26 , we say that @xmath24 is a suboperad of @xmath34 . throughout this paper ,
all vector spaces are defined over @xmath10 .
a graded vector space @xmath38 is a sequence @xmath39 of vector spaces .
a differential graded ( or dg ) vector space ( or chain complex ) is a pair @xmath40 of a graded vector space @xmath38 and @xmath41 satisfying @xmath42 .
we may consider any graded vector space as a dg vector space with @xmath43 .
one can define the symmetric monoidal structure on the category of dg vector spaces as follows : @xmath44 the unit @xmath45 is defined as @xmath46 and @xmath43 . in this paper , we mainly work on the category of graded and dg vector spaces .
operads in these categories are called _ graded operads _ and _ dg operads _ , respectively . for any dg vector spaces @xmath38 and @xmath47 , @xmath48 has the structure of a dg vector space : @xmath49 for any dg vector space @xmath38 , @xmath50 has the structure of a dg operad defined as follows ( @xmath51 , @xmath52 , and @xmath53 ) : @xmath54 this dg operad is called the _ endomorphism operad _ of @xmath38 . for any dg operad @xmath24 ,
a dg @xmath24-algebra is a chain complex @xmath38 with a morphism @xmath55 of dg operads . for each @xmath26
we have a chain map @xmath56 for any dg @xmath24-algebras @xmath38 and @xmath47 , a chain map @xmath57 is called a morphism of dg @xmath24-algebras if @xmath58 for any @xmath59 and @xmath60 . for any graded operad @xmath24 , the notions of graded @xmath24-algebras and their morphisms are defined in a similar way . for any dg operad @xmath61 , a _
dg ideal _ of @xmath24 is a sequence @xmath62 such that the following conditions hold : * for every @xmath26 , @xmath63 is a chain subcomplex of @xmath25 , which is preserved by the @xmath32-action on @xmath25 . * for any @xmath59 , @xmath64 and @xmath28 , @xmath65 for any dg ideal @xmath66 , the quotient @xmath67 has a natural structure of a dg operad , and there exists a natural morphism of dg operads @xmath68 . for any graded operad @xmath24 ,
the notions of its graded ideals and associated quotient graded operads are defined in the obvious way ( see @xcite section 5.2.14 ) . gerstenhaber and bv operads
are graded operads , which play central roles in this paper .
we recall definitions of these operads using generators and relations , partially following @xcite sections 13.3.12 and 13.7.4 .
the _ gerstenhaber operad _
@xmath69 is generated by @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 with the following relations : 1 . @xmath73 .
2 . @xmath74 .
3 . @xmath75 .
4 . @xmath76 , @xmath77 .
more precisely , we consider the free operad @xmath78 ( see @xcite section 5.5 ) generated by @xmath79 , @xmath80 , @xmath81 , and a graded ideal @xmath82 generated by relations ( a ) , ( b ) , ( ab ) , ( u ) .
then , we define @xmath83 . for any graded @xmath69-algebra @xmath38 , we define operations @xmath84 and @xmath85 on @xmath38 as @xmath86 then , @xmath87 is a graded commutative , associative algebra , and @xmath88 is a graded lie algebra ( with grading shifted by @xmath89 ) .
the triple @xmath90 is called a _
gerstenhaber algebra_. in the above definition , any gerstenhaber algebra @xmath38 has a unit @xmath91 of the multiplication @xmath84 .
it seems that the existence of a unit is usually not assumed .
the _ bv operad _
@xmath92 is generated by @xmath93 , @xmath94 , @xmath95 , @xmath96 with the relations ( a ) , ( b ) , ( ab ) , ( u ) and @xmath97 obviously , there exists a natural morphism of graded operads @xmath98 . for any graded @xmath92-algebra @xmath38
, we define an operation @xmath99 on @xmath38 by @xmath100 .
the triple @xmath101 is called a _
bv algebra_. the bracket @xmath85 is recovered by the formula @xmath102 . for any integer @xmath103 ,
let @xmath104 be the set of tuples @xmath105 such that * for each @xmath106 , @xmath107 is a closed disk of positive radius contained in @xmath108 .
we denote its center by @xmath109 .
@xmath110 is a point on @xmath111 .
* @xmath112 are disjoint .
the set @xmath104 has a natural topology .
let @xmath113 denote the subspace of @xmath104 , which consists of @xmath105 such that @xmath114 for every @xmath106 .
we define @xmath115 to be the space consists of a point .
then , @xmath116 has a natural structure of a topological operad , and @xmath117 is its suboperad .
@xmath118 ( resp .
@xmath119 ) is called the _ little disks _ ( resp .
_ framed little disks _ ) operad .
there are isomorphisms of graded operads @xmath120
( @xcite ) and @xmath121 ( @xcite ) , which are compatible with the inclusion maps .
a _ differential graded associative algebra _ is a dg vector space @xmath1 with a degree @xmath122 product @xmath123 , which is associative , and satisfies the leibniz rule .
we also assume that it has a unit @xmath124 .
we abbreviate the term `` differential graded associative algebra '' as `` dga algebra '' . here
the letter `` a '' stands for `` associative '' , not for algebra ( see @xcite pp .
let @xmath1 be any dga algebra .
a dg @xmath125-bimodule is a dg vector space @xmath3 with degree @xmath122 left and right @xmath125-actions @xmath126 and @xmath127 , which satisfy the leibniz rule and associativity . for every @xmath128 and @xmath129
, we define a chain map @xmath130 by @xmath131 we set @xmath132 by @xmath133 , and define the hochschild cochain complex @xmath134 by @xmath135 . notice that @xmath136 _ decreases _ the degree by @xmath89 .
the cohomology of this complex is denoted by @xmath137 , and called the _
hochschild cohomology_. notice that @xmath1 itself has a natural structure of a dg @xmath125-bimodule .
@xmath138 has natural dga and dg lie algebra structures , with operations @xmath139 and @xmath85 defined below .
the product @xmath139 is defined as @xmath140 the bracket @xmath141 is defined as @xmath142 where @xmath143 is defined as @xmath144 the operations @xmath139 and @xmath141 induce the gerstenhaber structure on @xmath2 .
this result is originally due to gerstenhaber @xcite . throughout this paper
, we set @xmath145 .
let @xmath3 be a closed , oriented @xmath0-manifold of dimension @xmath4 .
@xmath5 is equipped with the @xmath0-topology .
we often abbreviate @xmath146 as @xmath147 .
also , we often use the notation @xmath148 . in @xcite ,
chas - sullivan introduced the _ loop product _ on @xmath149 .
let us briefly recall its definition .
let us consider the evalutation map @xmath150 , and the fiber product @xmath151 let @xmath152 be a tubular neighborhood of @xmath153 , and @xmath154 be the thom isomorphism .
the gysin map @xmath155 is defined as the composition of the following maps : @xmath156 let @xmath157 denote the concatenation map . precisely , it is defined as follows ( see the remark on pp .
780 @xcite ) .
let us take an increasing @xmath158-function @xmath159 \to [ 0,1]$ ] such that @xmath160 and @xmath161 ( @xmath162 denotes the @xmath163-th derivative ) for any @xmath164 .
then , @xmath157 is defined by @xmath165 it is easy to see that @xmath166 does not depend on choices of @xmath167 .
the loop product @xmath168 is defined as the composition of the following three maps .
the first map is the cross product and the second map is the gysin map . @xmath169
^ -{\times } & h_{*+2d}(\l^{\times 2 } ) \ar[r ] & \h_*(\l { \,_{e}\!\!\times_{e } } \l ) \ar[r]^-{\h_*(c ) } & \h_*(\l ) .
} \ ] ] let us consider the map @xmath170 .
let @xmath171 denote the intersection product .
then , @xmath172 on the other hand , @xmath147 admits a natural @xmath173-action @xmath174 , which is defined by @xmath175 .
we define @xmath176 by @xmath177 \times x)$ ] , where @xmath178 \in h_1(s^1)$ ] is represented by the singular chain @xmath179 $ ] ( see the next subsection for the definition of @xmath180 ) .
[ thm : ch - su ] for any closed , oriented @xmath4-dimensional @xmath158-manifold @xmath3 , @xmath181 is a bv algebra .
this result is the starting point of string topology .
the bracket @xmath85 of this bv structure is called the _ loop bracket_.
there is a relation between gerstenhaber structures on loop space homology ( theorem [ thm : ch - su ] ) and hochschild cohomology ( section 1.2 ) .
we explain this relation via iterated integrals of differential forms , which originates in @xcite . to discuss iterated integrals of differential forms , it is convenient to work with @xmath0-singular chains on @xmath146
. let us define the @xmath182-dimensional simplex @xmath183 by @xmath184 a map @xmath185 is said to be of class @xmath0 , if there exists an open neighborhood @xmath152 of @xmath186 and a map @xmath187 , such that @xmath188 , and @xmath189 is of class @xmath0 .
let @xmath190 denote the @xmath10-vector space generated by all @xmath0-maps @xmath191 .
it is easy to see that , any @xmath0-map @xmath192 is continuous with respect to the @xmath0-topology on @xmath146 . therefore , @xmath193 is a subcomplex of the singular chain complex of @xmath146 . in section 4 , we show that this inclusion map is a quasi - isomorphism ( theorem [ 150219_1 ] ) .
therefore , @xmath194 . for any @xmath195 ,
let us define @xmath196 then , @xmath197 is a dga algebra , where @xmath4 denotes the exterior derivative , and @xmath198 denotes the exterior product .
we denote it by @xmath7 .
we define a dg @xmath199-bimodule structure on @xmath200_*:=\hom({{\mathcal{a}}}^{*+d}(m ) , \r)$ ] as follows : @xmath201 a morphism of @xmath7-bimodules @xmath202 ; \ , \alpha \mapsto ( \beta \mapsto \int_m \alpha \wedge \beta)$ ] is a quasi - isomorphism ( this is an obvious consequence of the poincar duality ) . for any @xmath0-map @xmath203 and @xmath129
, we define @xmath204 by @xmath205 and define @xmath206)$ ] by @xmath207 it is easy to see that @xmath208 ) ; \quad \sigma \mapsto ( i_k(\sigma))_k\ ] ] is a chain map ( signs are checked in section 6.3 ) . taking homology
, we obtain a map @xmath209 ) \cong h^*({{\mathcal{a}}}_m , { { \mathcal{a}}}_m).\ ] ] this map preserves the gerstenhaber structures on @xmath210 and @xmath211 .
[ 150205_2 ] the fact that ( [ 141218_01 ] ) preserves the gerstenhaber structures seems to be known ; see @xcite for the product , and @xcite section 7 for the bracket .
we can recover this fact as a consequence of theorem [ 150628_1 ] , see remark [ 150703_1 ] .
we state our main result theorem [ 150628_1 ] and some supplementary results .
let us recall some notations : @xmath69 and @xmath92 denote the gerstenhaber and bv operads . for any @xmath0-manifold @xmath3 of dimension @xmath4 , @xmath5 , and @xmath212 .
@xmath7 denotes the dga algebra of differential forms on @xmath3 .
[ 150628_1 ] there exists a dg operad @xmath12 and its suboperad @xmath13 , satisfying the following properties . 1 .
there exist isomorphisms of graded operads @xmath213 and @xmath214 , such that the following diagram commutes : @xmath215 \ar[d]_-{\cong } & h_*(f\tilde{\lambda } ) \ar[d]^-{\cong }
\\ \ger \ar[r ] & \batvil . } \ ] ] 2 . for any dga algebra @xmath1
, the hochschild complex @xmath138 has a dg @xmath13-algebra structure , which lifts the gerstenhaber structure on @xmath2 .
3 . for any closed
, oriented @xmath0-manifold @xmath3 , there exist : * a dg @xmath12-algebra @xmath9 . *
an isomorphism @xmath216 of bv algebras . * a morphism of dg @xmath13-algebras @xmath19 such that @xmath20 is equal to the map ( [ 141218_01 ] ) . [ 150212_1 ]
it seems that ( although there are some technical issues the author has not confirmed ) the following stronger version of ( i ) is also true : there exists a zig - zag of quiasi - isomorphisms ( of dg operads ) connecting @xmath13 ( resp .
@xmath12 ) and @xmath217 ( resp .
@xmath218 ) , which is the singular chain operad of @xmath118 ( resp .
@xmath119 ) . [ 150703_1 ]
since @xmath219 is a map of dg @xmath13-algebras , and @xmath214 , ( iii)-(c ) shows that the map ( [ 141218_01 ] ) preserves the gerstenhaber structures .
[ 150811_1 ] as ( iii)-(c ) suggests , the chain complex @xmath9 is a `` geometric analogue '' of the hochschild complex @xmath220 .
an important difference is that the isomorphism @xmath221 holds for any closed oriented @xmath3 , while we need some assumptions ( e.g. @xmath222 ) to show that the map ( [ 141218_01 ] ) is an isomorphism .
as the next proposition shows , one can define chain level loop product and bracket on @xmath9 .
[ 150801_1 ] the loop product @xmath84 and the loop bracket @xmath85 on @xmath223 lift to operators on @xmath9 , denoted by the same symbols .
@xmath84 defines a dga algebra structure , @xmath85 defines a dg lie algebra structure on @xmath9 , and the chain map @xmath224 preserves these structures .
moreover , there exists an injective chain map @xmath225 such that @xmath226 and the following diagram commutes : @xmath227 ^ -{\h_*(i_m)}\ar[d]_{\cong } & \h_*({{\mathcal{l}}}m ) \ar[d]^{\cong } \\
h^{-*}_\dr(m ) \ar[r]_{h_*(\iota_m ) } & h_*(c^{{{\mathcal{l}}}m } ) . } \ ] ] as a consequence , one can define @xmath228-refinements of the loop product .
namely , by the homotopy transfer theorem ( see section 10.3 @xcite ) , one can define an @xmath228-structure @xmath229 on @xmath223 , such that @xmath230 , @xmath231 and @xmath232 is homotopy equivalent to the dga algebra @xmath233 .
moreover , we may take @xmath229 so that @xmath234 for every @xmath128 , and @xmath235 is homotopy equivalent to the dga algebra @xmath236 .
in particular , @xmath229 recovers the classical massey product on @xmath237 . by same arguments
, one can define an @xmath238-structure @xmath239 on @xmath223 , such that @xmath240 , @xmath241 , and @xmath242 is homotopy equivalent to the dg lie algebra @xmath243 .
moreover , we may take @xmath239 so that @xmath244 for any @xmath128 .
when @xmath3 has a riemannian metric , @xmath223 is equipped with the length filtration , and it is shown in @xcite that the loop product preserves this filtration .
one of features of our chain model @xmath9 is that , one can define the length filtration on this chain model so that the filtration is preserved by string topology operations . for any @xmath245 ,
let us denote @xmath246 .
for any @xmath247 $ ] , we define @xmath248 . in general , a filtration ( indexed by @xmath249 $ ] ) on a chain complex @xmath250 is a family @xmath251}$ ] of subcomplexes of @xmath250 , such that @xmath252 . for any @xmath253 , we set @xmath254 .
[ 141005_2 ] let @xmath3 be a closed , oriented riemannian manifold .
then , the chain complex @xmath9 has a filtration @xmath255}$ ] such that the following conditions hold : 1 .
there exists an isomorphism @xmath256 for every @xmath247 $ ] , such that the following diagram is commutative for any @xmath257 , where vertical maps are induced by inclusions : @xmath258
^ -{\cong } \ar[d ] & h_*(f^a c^{{{\mathcal{l}}}m } ) \ar[d ] \\ \h_*(\l^b m ) \ar[r]^-{\cong } & h_*(f^b c^{{{\mathcal{l}}}m } ) . } \ ] ] 2 .
the @xmath259-algebra structure on @xmath9 preserves the filtration .
namely , @xmath260 rich algebraic structures in chain level string topology were outlined in @xcite by d. sullivan , and there have been several papers working out details .
x. chen @xcite introduced a chain model of the free loop space using whitney differential forms , and defined several string topology operations ( the loop product , loop bracket and rotation ) on that chain model , recovering the bv - algebra structure on homology level ( @xcite also studies the @xmath173-equivariant case ) .
it is not clear whether these operations extend to actions of a dg operad on this chain model .
on the other hand , a recent paper @xcite by g. drummond - cole , k. poirier and n. rounds proposed a more geometric approach using short geodesic segments and diffuse intersection classes .
@xcite defines operations on the singular chain complex of the free loop space , recovering the homology level structure defined by cohen - godin @xcite .
in particular , @xcite covers operations with multiple outputs and those corresponding to surfaces of higher genus .
however , the operations in @xcite are associative only up to homotopy , and it seems that the resulting algebraic structure is yet to be fully worked out .
let us discuss some potential applications of results in this paper to symplectic topology .
for any @xmath0-manifold @xmath3 , the cotangent bundle @xmath261 has the natural sympelctic structure .
when @xmath3 is closed , oriented and spin , the floer homology @xmath262 has a bv algebra structure , and there exists an isomorphism of bv algebras @xmath263 ( see @xcite and the references therein ) .
there should be chain level refinements of this correspondence , and we expect that our chain level structures in string topology fit into this picture .
more specifically , we expect that one can define an @xmath228 ( resp .
@xmath238 ) structure on @xmath262 via counting solutions of appropriate floer equations , which is homotopy equivalent to the @xmath228 ( resp .
@xmath238 ) refinement of the loop product ( resp .
bracket ) on @xmath223 defined in section 1.5.2 .
on the other hand , fukaya @xcite used chain level loop bracket for compactifications of the moduli space of pseudo - holomorphic disks with lagrangian boundary conditions , and obtained restrictions on topological types of lagrangian submanifolds .
we expect that our definition of chain level loop bracket could be used to work out details of this approach .
finally , there is a very interesting program by cieliebak - latschev @xcite , which compares symplectic field theory of sphere cotangent bundles and string topology of @xmath173-equivariant chains on free loops modulo constant loops .
we hope that the construction in this paper will be a first step towards working out details of the string topology side of this program .
the rest of this paper is split into two parts .
the goal of the first part ( sections 26 ) is to define the chain complex @xmath9 .
this is a chain model of the free loop space @xmath11 , carefully designed to define string topology operations on it .
our construction of the chain complex @xmath9 is based on two ideas .
the first idea is to introduce a notion of _ de rham chains _ , which is a certain hybrid of singular chains and differential forms .
we also need a notion of _ differentiable spaces _ , on which de rham chains are defined .
these notions are introduced in section 2 .
we also define de rham chain complex ( the chain complex which consists of de rham chains ) for any differentiable space . an important step in our argument is to show that homology of the de rham chain complex is naturally isomorphic to the usual singular homology .
we prove it for finite - dimensional manifolds in section 3 , and for the free loop space in section 4 .
the second idea is to use ( moore ) loops with marked points , which is inspired by the theory of iterated integrals . in section 5 ,
we introduce a space of moore loops with marked points , and show that the collection of de rham chain complexes of these spaces has a natural structure of a dg operad .
moreover , this dg operad is cyclic and has a multiplication and a unit .
based on results in section 5 , we define the chain complex @xmath9 in section 6 .
we also prove results presented in section 1.5 assuming theorem [ 150624_8 ] , which is a purely algebraic result on operads . the second part ( sections 711 ) is devoted to the proof of theorem [ 150624_8 ] .
* acknowledgements . *
the author appreciates professors k. fukaya and k. ono for their encouragements and comments on this project .
he also appreciates b. ward for useful communications , and an anonymous referee for many suggestions on the preliminary version of this paper .
this research is supported by jsps kakenhi grant number 25800041 .
in this section , we introduce notions of _ differentiable spaces _ and _ de rham chain complexes _ , which are basic for the arguments in this paper . the notion of differentiable spaces
is introduced in section 2.2 . , and
de rham chain complexes for these spaces are defined in section 2.3 .
the rest of this section ( 2.42.8 ) is devoted to establishing several basic results about de rham chain complexes of differentiable spaces .
let @xmath264 be a @xmath4-dimensional @xmath0-manifold . throughout this paper ,
all manifolds are without boundary , unless otherwise specified .
let @xmath265 be an integer , and @xmath266 be an @xmath267-bundle .
we define @xmath268 . when @xmath269 , we define @xmath270 to be the trivial @xmath10-bundle on @xmath264 .
any exact sequence @xmath271 of real vector bundles induces an isomorphism @xmath272 .
an orientation of @xmath78 is a section of the double cover @xmath273 .
an orientation of @xmath274 is called an orientation of @xmath264 .
recall that we denote @xmath275 when @xmath276 .
let @xmath277 denote its subspace which consists of compactly supported @xmath278-forms . when @xmath279 , we set @xmath280 . when @xmath264 is oriented , we define @xmath281 let @xmath282 , @xmath283 be oriented @xmath0-manifolds , and @xmath284 be a submersion ( i.e. @xmath285 is of class @xmath0 and @xmath286 is surjective for any @xmath287 ) .
let @xmath288 .
the _ integration along fibers _ is a chain map @xmath289 , which is defined in the following way .
first we consider the case @xmath290 , @xmath291 and @xmath292 .
we assume that @xmath293 and @xmath294 are positive with respect to orientations on @xmath295 and @xmath296 . for @xmath297
where @xmath298 and @xmath299 , we define @xmath300 by @xmath301 in the general case , @xmath302 is defned by taking local charts and partitions of unity on @xmath282 .
below is a list of some basic properties of the integration along fibers . * if @xmath283 is a positively oriented point , then @xmath303 .
* @xmath302 is a chain map , i.e. there holds @xmath304 . * for any @xmath305 , @xmath306 .
* for any submersion @xmath307 and @xmath308 , there holds @xmath309 . for any integers @xmath310 , let @xmath311 denote the set of oriented @xmath163-dimensional submanifolds in @xmath296 .
we set @xmath312 .
let @xmath313 be a set .
differentiable structure _ on @xmath313 is a family of maps called _ plots _ , which satisfies the following conditions : * every plot is a map from @xmath314 to @xmath313 . *
if @xmath315 is a plot , @xmath316 and @xmath317 is a submersion , then @xmath318 is a plot .
a _ differentiable space _ is a pair of a set and a differentiable structure on it . for any differentiable space @xmath313 ,
let @xmath319 .
a map @xmath320 between differentiable spaces @xmath313 and @xmath321 is called _ smooth _ ,
if there holds @xmath322 the term `` plot '' is originally used in the theory of chen s differentiable spaces ( @xcite ) and the theory of diffeological spaces ( @xcite , @xcite ) .
our notion of differentiable spaces is weaker than these notions . in particular , in axioms of both of these spaces
, it is required that all constant maps are plots , while we do not require this condition ( see example [ 150623_1 ] ( i)-(b ) below ) .
[ 150623_1 ] let us explain some examples of differentiable structures . 1 .
let @xmath3 be a @xmath0-manifold .
one can consider the following differentiable structures on @xmath3 : * @xmath323 is a plot if @xmath324 is of class @xmath0 .
we denote the resulting differentiable space as @xmath3 .
* @xmath323 is a plot if @xmath324 is a submersion ( we always assume that any submersion is of class @xmath0 ) .
we denote the resulting differentiable space as @xmath325 . + the identity map @xmath326 is smooth , but @xmath327 is not .
2 . @xmath328 has the following differentiable structure : a map @xmath329 is a plot if @xmath330 is of class @xmath0 .
3 . let @xmath313 be a differentiable space , @xmath321 a subset of @xmath313 , and @xmath331 be the inclusion map .
one can define the following differentiable structure on @xmath321 : a map @xmath332 is a plot if @xmath333 is a plot of @xmath313 .
4 . let @xmath334 be a family of differentiable spaces parametrized by the nonempty set @xmath335 .
the product @xmath336 has the following differentiable structure : @xmath337 is a plot if @xmath338 is a plot of @xmath339 for any @xmath340 ( @xmath341 denotes the projection to @xmath339 ) .
two smooth maps @xmath342 are called _ smoothly homotopic _ , if there exists a smooth map @xmath343 such that @xmath344 @xmath345 is called a _ smooth homotopy _ between @xmath346 and @xmath347 .
the differentiable structure on @xmath10 is defined as in example [ 150623_1 ] ( i)-(a ) , i.e. @xmath348 . the differentiable structure on @xmath349 is defined as in example [ 150623_1 ] ( iv ) .
it seems that transitivity of @xmath350 does not hold in general .
unless otherwise specified , any @xmath0-manifold @xmath3 will be equipped with the differentiable structure in example [ 150623_1 ] ( i)-(a ) . when @xmath0-manifolds @xmath3 , @xmath351 are equipped with these differentiable structures , a map @xmath352 is smooth if and only if @xmath346 is of class @xmath0 .
let @xmath313 be a differentiable space .
for any @xmath353 , we set @xmath354 notice that @xmath355 for any @xmath356 .
for any @xmath357 and @xmath358 , let @xmath359 denote the image of @xmath360 by the natural injection @xmath361 .
let @xmath362 denote the subspace of @xmath363 , which is generated by @xmath364 we define @xmath365 .
for every @xmath353 , @xmath366 \mapsto [ ( u , \ph , d\omega)]\ ] ] is well - defined , since @xmath304 .
moreover , @xmath42 since @xmath367 .
we call @xmath368 the _ de rham chain complex _ of @xmath313 , and denote its homology as @xmath369 .
elements of @xmath370 are called _ de rham chains _ of @xmath313 .
our notion of de rham chains is inspired by the notion of _ approximate de rham chains _ by k. fukaya ( @xcite definition 6.4 ) .
however , an explicit definition of a chain complex is not given in @xcite . the _ augmentation map _
@xmath371 is defined as @xmath372):= \int_u \omega.\ ] ] @xmath373 vanishes on @xmath374 by stokes theorem .
next we define the _ fiber product _ on de rham chain complexes .
let @xmath3 be an oriented @xmath0-manifold of dimension @xmath4 .
let us consider the differentiable space @xmath325 in example [ 150623_1 ] ( i)-(b ) .
let @xmath313 , @xmath321 be differentiable spaces , and @xmath375 , @xmath376 be smooth maps .
we define a differentiable structure on @xmath377 as a subset of @xmath378 ( see example [ 150623_1 ] ( iii ) and ( iv ) ) .
we are going to define a chain map @xmath379 which we call the fiber product on de rham chain complexes .
let @xmath357 , @xmath380 .
then , @xmath381 and @xmath382 are submersions .
thus , @xmath383 is a @xmath0-manifold , moreover it is a submanifold of the euclidean space ( since @xmath384 ) .
the map @xmath385 is also a submersion .
let us define an orientation on @xmath386 .
let @xmath387 , @xmath388 .
there exist exact sequences @xmath389 then we obtain isomorphisms @xmath390 since @xmath3 , @xmath152 , @xmath38 are oriented , one can define an orientation on @xmath391 ( resp .
@xmath392 ) so that the first ( resp .
second ) isomorphism is orientation preserving .
then , one can define an orientation of @xmath386 so that the third isomorphism is orientation preserving .
now , @xmath386 is an oriented submanifold of the euclidean space .
therefore , @xmath386 is an element of @xmath393 .
let @xmath394 , @xmath395 , @xmath396 , @xmath397 be projection maps . then * since @xmath398 is a submersion , @xmath399 .
* since @xmath400 is a submersion , @xmath401 .
therefore @xmath402 .
now , let us define ( [ 150127_1 ] ) by @xmath403 \times_m [ ( v , \psi , \eta)]:= ( -1)^{l(\dim u - d ) } [ ( u \times_m v , \ph \times \psi , \omega \times \eta)].\ ] ] by direct computations , one can check that this is a well - defined chain map .
the product is associative , and a smooth map @xmath404 satisfies @xmath405 .
when @xmath3 is a positively oriented point ( thus @xmath406 ) , the chain map ( [ 150127_1 ] ) is @xmath407 which we call the _ cross product _ on de rham chain complexes .
let @xmath408 be a set which has a unique element .
for any @xmath314 , there exists a unique map @xmath409 .
we define a differentiable structure on @xmath408 by @xmath410 .
let us consider @xmath411 with the positive orientation .
for any @xmath314 , let us denote the unique map @xmath412 by @xmath398 .
for any @xmath413 , we obtain @xmath414 = [ ( \{0\ } , \ph_{\{0\ } } , ( \pi_u ) _ !
\omega ) ] = [ ( \{0\ } , \ph_{\{0\ } } , \int_u \omega)].\ ] ] therefore , @xmath415 if @xmath416 , and the augmentation map @xmath417 is an isomorphism .
in particular , @xmath418 for any differentiable spaces @xmath313 , @xmath321 and a smooth map @xmath419 , @xmath420 \mapsto [ ( u , f \circ \ph , \omega)]\ ] ] is a well - defined chain map .
[ prop : homotopy ] let @xmath313 , @xmath321 be differentiable spaces , and @xmath342 be smooth maps . if @xmath346 , @xmath347 are smoothly homotopic , then @xmath421 are chain homotopic .
let @xmath422 be a smooth homotopy between @xmath346 and @xmath347 , i.e. , @xmath345 is a smooth map such that @xmath423 if @xmath424 and @xmath425 if @xmath426 . take @xmath427 so that @xmath428 on @xmath429 $ ] for some @xmath430 .
let @xmath431 \in c^\dr_1(\r)$ ] , and define a linear map @xmath432 by @xmath433 .
since @xmath434 and the cross product are chain maps , for any @xmath435 , we have @xmath436 thus , it is enough to show that @xmath437 .
since both sides are linear on @xmath438 , we may assume that @xmath439 $ ] for some @xmath357 and @xmath413 .
let @xmath440 , @xmath441 be the inclusion maps , and @xmath442 , @xmath443 .
define @xmath444 by @xmath445 $ ] , @xmath446 $ ] .
then , since @xmath447 is supported on @xmath448 , we have @xmath449 . let @xmath450 \in c^\dr_*(x)$ ] .
then , @xmath451.\ ] ] there holds @xmath452 , where @xmath453 is the projection map .
moreover , @xmath454 , since @xmath455 .
thus , @xmath456 .
a similar argument shows @xmath457 .
hence , we get @xmath458 let @xmath313 be a differentiable space . for any function @xmath459 and @xmath460 , let us define @xmath461 this is a subspace of @xmath313 truncated by the inequality @xmath462 .
we prove some technical results about de rham chain complexes of these truncated spaces .
a function @xmath463 is called smooth , if @xmath464 for any @xmath357 .
@xmath346 is called _ approximately smooth _ , if there exists a decreasing sequence @xmath465 of smooth functions on @xmath313 such that @xmath466 for any @xmath467 .
if @xmath463 is approximately smooth , @xmath468 is upper semi - continuous for any @xmath357 .
this is because @xmath469 for any @xmath460 .
an important example of an approximately smooth ( but not smooth ) function is the length functional ( see section 1.5.3 ) on the free loop space .
let @xmath3 be a riemannian manifold , and consider the differentiable structure on @xmath11 as in example [ 150623_1 ] ( ii ) .
then , @xmath470 is approximately smooth .
it is easy to check that , for any @xmath471 , a functional @xmath472 is smooth .
let us take a decreasing sequence @xmath473 on @xmath474 , such that @xmath475 for any @xmath476 .
then , @xmath477 is a decreasing sequence of smooth functions on @xmath146 , such that @xmath478 .
[ 150210_1 ] let @xmath465 be a decreasing sequence of approximately smooth functions on @xmath313 , such that @xmath479 for any @xmath467 .
then , the chain map @xmath480 , which is induced by the inclusion maps , is surjective .
let @xmath357 and @xmath413 .
setting @xmath481 for each @xmath482 , @xmath483 is a decreasing sequence of upper semi - continuous functions on @xmath152 .
since @xmath484 is compact , there exists @xmath278 such that @xmath485 for any @xmath486 . setting @xmath487 , the chain map @xmath488 maps @xmath489 $ ] to @xmath490 $ ] .
[ 150210_2 ] let @xmath463 be an approximately smooth function .
then , the chain map @xmath491 , which is induced by the inclusion map , is injective .
first let us consider the case when @xmath346 is a smooth function on @xmath313 .
for any @xmath492 , @xmath493 denote the chain maps induced by the inclusion maps .
suppose that @xmath494 satisfies @xmath495 . by the previous lemma
, there exists @xmath496 such that @xmath497 .
take @xmath498 so that @xmath499 .
if there exists a linear map @xmath500 such that @xmath501 , we can prove @xmath502 by @xmath503 to define such @xmath219 , we fix @xmath504)$ ] so that @xmath505 on @xmath506 and @xmath507 . for any @xmath357 , we set @xmath508 .
then , a linear map @xmath509 \mapsto [ ( u_{f,0 } , \ph|_{u_{f,0 } } , ( ( \kappa \circ f \circ \ph ) \cdot \omega)|_{u_{f,0}})]\ ] ] is well - defined ( it is _ not _ a chain map ) . @xmath501 is obvious since @xmath505 on @xmath506 .
this completes the proof when @xmath346 is a smooth function on @xmath313 .
finally , we consider the case when @xmath346 is any approximately smooth function on @xmath313 . by definition
, there exists a decreasing sequence of smooth functions @xmath465 such that @xmath510 .
the previous lemma shows that the chain map @xmath511 is surjective . on the other hand , since each @xmath512 is smooth , @xmath488 is injective
. thus @xmath513 is injective .
[ 150213_1 ] let @xmath465 be any decreasing sequence of approximately smooth functions on @xmath313 , such that @xmath514 for any @xmath467 .
then , the chain map @xmath480 , which is induced by the inclusion maps , is an isomorphism .
we already prove the surjectivity in lemma [ 150210_1 ] . by lemma [ 150210_2 ]
, @xmath488 is injective for every @xmath278 , thus @xmath480 is also injective .
we define _ smooth singular chains _ on differentiable spaces , and compare them with de rham chains .
let @xmath313 be a differentiable space , and @xmath265 be an integer .
a map @xmath515 is called _ strongly smooth _ , if there exists an open neighborhood @xmath152 of @xmath186 , and a smooth map @xmath516 such that @xmath517 . @xmath183 and
@xmath152 are equipped with the differentiable structures as subsets of @xmath267 .
for any @xmath265 , let @xmath518 denote the @xmath10-vector space generated by all strongly smooth maps @xmath519 .
for any @xmath356 , we set @xmath520 . a differential on @xmath521 is defined in the same way as in the singular chain complex . to fix notations ,
let us spell out details .
for any @xmath128 and @xmath522 , we define a map @xmath523 by @xmath524 in particular , @xmath525 is defined as @xmath526 for @xmath527 . for any @xmath128
, a differential @xmath528 is defined as @xmath529 we call the chain complex @xmath530 _ smooth singular chain complex _ , and its homology @xmath531 _ smooth singular homology_. for any smooth map @xmath320 between differentiable spaces , one can define the chain map @xmath532 in the obvious way .
if smooth maps @xmath342 are smoothly homotopic , @xmath533 are chain homotopic . for any @xmath128 , we define @xmath534 by @xmath535 .
then , @xmath536 for any @xmath128 .
[ 150624_10 ] 1 .
there exists a sequence @xmath537 such that @xmath538 for any @xmath265 , @xmath539 is characterized by @xmath540 , and @xmath541 2 .
suppose that @xmath537 and @xmath542 satisfy the conditions in ( i ) .
then there exists a sequence @xmath543 such that @xmath544 for any @xmath128 , @xmath545 , and @xmath546 for any @xmath265 , @xmath183 is smoothly homotopic to @xmath408 , thus @xmath547 . using this fact
, the assertions are easy to prove by induction on @xmath182 . for any @xmath548 which satisfies lemma [ 150624_10 ] ( i ) ,
one can define a natural transformation @xmath549 as follows ( we set @xmath550 when @xmath356 ) : @xmath551 the equation @xmath552 shows that @xmath553 is a chain map .
lemma [ 150624_10 ] ( ii ) shows that the homotopy equivalence class of @xmath553 does not depend on choices of @xmath81 .
in particular , the linear map @xmath554 does not depend on @xmath81 .
finally , we define the cross product on @xmath555 .
let us take @xmath556 for all @xmath557 , such that @xmath558 is characterized by @xmath559 , and the following equation holds for any @xmath557 : @xmath560 we define the cross product @xmath561 by @xmath562 the homotopy equivalence class of this map does not depend on choices of @xmath563 . on the other hand , we defined the cross product for de rham chains ( see section 2.3 ) .
the next lemma is proved by the standard method of acyclic models .
[ 150627_1 ] for any differentiable spaces @xmath313 , @xmath321 and @xmath548 satisfying lemma [ 150624_10 ] ( i ) , the following diagram commutes up to homotopy , where horizontal maps are cross products : @xmath564 \ar[d]_{\iota^u(x ) \otimes \iota^u(y ) } & c^\sm_*(x \times y ) \ar[d]^{\iota^u(x \times y ) } \\
c^\dr_*(x ) \otimes c^\dr_*(y ) \ar[r ] & c^\dr_*(x \times y ) . }
\ ] ] let @xmath3 be a @xmath0-manifold , and @xmath26 .
we define @xmath565 by @xmath566 \rangle : = \int_u \ph^ * \alpha \wedge \omega.\ ] ] it induces a linear map @xmath567 , which we also denote by @xmath568 . for any subset @xmath569 ,
let @xmath570 where @xmath152 runs over all open neighborhoods of @xmath335 , and let @xmath571 .
then , one can define @xmath572 . in the next lemma
, we consider the case @xmath573 .
[ 150629_2 ] suppose that @xmath537 satisfies lemma [ 150624_10 ] ( i ) .
for any nonnegative integers @xmath574 and @xmath575 , @xmath576 we fix @xmath163 and prove the lemma by induction on @xmath182 .
when @xmath269 , i.e. @xmath577 , the lemma can be directly checked . if the lemma is established for @xmath578 , the case @xmath579 is proved as follows .
let us take @xmath580 such that @xmath581 ( this is always possible since @xmath582 ) .
then , @xmath583 the second equality follows from the induction hypothesis , and the last equality follows from stokes theorem .
let @xmath3 be an oriented @xmath0-manifold , and consider the differentiable structure as in example [ 150623_1 ] ( i)-(a ) , i.e. @xmath584 . with this differentiable structure ,
a map @xmath585 is strongly smooth if it extends to a @xmath0-map @xmath586 for some open neighborhood @xmath152 of @xmath186 . in particular
, @xmath587 is a subcomplex of @xmath588 ( the usual singular chain complex of @xmath3 ) .
it is known that @xmath589 is a quasi - isomorphism ( see @xcite theorem 18.7 ) .
therefore , we obtain the natural isomorphism @xmath590 . in section 2.7 , we defined the map @xmath591 for any differentiable space @xmath313 .
the goal of this section is to prove the following theorem [ 150623_2 ] . as an immediate consequence ,
we obtain the natural isomorphism @xmath592 .
[ 150623_2 ] for any oriented @xmath0-manifold @xmath3 , the map @xmath593 is an isomorphism .
let us denote the map @xmath593 by @xmath594 .
the proof of theorem [ 150623_2 ] is separated into two steps .
let @xmath595 .
* in section 3.1 , we define an isomorphism @xmath596 . * in section 3.2
, we define an isomorphism @xmath597 via the poincar duality , and show that @xmath598 .
let us consider the differentiable space @xmath325 ( see example [ 150623_1 ] ( i)-(b ) ) .
it is easy to check that @xmath599 \mapsto \ph_!\omega\ ] ] is a well - defined chain map . on the other hand , for any @xmath600 ,
let us take @xmath314 and an orientation - preserving open embedding @xmath601 such that @xmath602 .
then , @xmath603 \in c^\dr_*(m_\reg)$ ] does not depend on choices of @xmath152 and @xmath324 .
thus , one can define a chain map @xmath604,\ ] ] and this is the inverse of ( [ 150210_3 ] ) .
therefore , ( [ 150210_3 ] ) is an isomorphism of chain complexes .
in particular , @xmath605 .
@xmath326 is a map of differentiable spaces , as noted in example [ 150623_1 ] ( i ) .
the goal of this subsection is to prove the next proposition .
[ 150210_4 ] @xmath326 induces an isomorphism @xmath606 . as an immediate consequence
, we obtain an isomorphism @xmath596 . to prove proposition [ 150210_4 ] , let us take a proper @xmath0-function @xmath607 , and set @xmath608 for any integer @xmath128 .
since @xmath346 is a smooth function on @xmath3 and @xmath325 , corollary [ 150213_1 ] implies isomorphisms @xmath609 here we need the following lemma .
[ 150210_5 ] let @xmath351 be an oriented @xmath0-manifold , and let @xmath47 be an open set in @xmath351 with a compact closure .
then , there exists a chain map @xmath610 such that the following diagram of chain maps commutes up to homotopy .
@xmath611^{i_\reg } \ar[d]_-{(\id_w ) _ * } & c^\dr_*(n_\reg)\ar[d]^-{(\id_n ) _ * } \\
c^\dr_*(w ) \ar[r]_{i } \ar[ru]_{j } & c^\dr_*(n)}\ ] ] @xmath612 and @xmath613 are induced by the inclusion map @xmath614 .
let us apply lemma [ 150210_5 ] for @xmath615 , @xmath616 , and take a chain map @xmath617 as in lemma [ 150210_5 ] .
then , @xmath618 is the inverse of @xmath619 , thus proposition [ 150210_4 ] is proved . to prove lemma [ 150210_5 ]
, we need the following lemma .
[ 150210_6 ] let @xmath351 be a @xmath0-manifold , and @xmath620 be a compact set in @xmath351 .
there exists an integer @xmath621 and a @xmath0-map @xmath622 such that the following conditions hold .
* for any @xmath623 , @xmath624 is a diffeomorphism . *
@xmath625 . * for any @xmath626 , @xmath627 is a submersion .
let @xmath628 denote the space of compactly supported @xmath158-vector fields on @xmath351 .
for any @xmath629 , let @xmath630 denote the flow generated by @xmath631 .
let us take a sequence @xmath632 on @xmath628 , such that @xmath633 spans @xmath634 for any @xmath626 . for @xmath635 , we set @xmath636 .
let us define a @xmath0-map @xmath637 by @xmath638 .
then , @xmath639 is onto for any @xmath626 and @xmath640 for some @xmath430 .
finally , take any diffeomorphism @xmath641 preserving the origin .
then , @xmath642 satisfies the requirements of the lemma .
[ 150626_4 ] when @xmath351 is a riemannian manifold , for any @xmath643 we may further require the following condition : for any @xmath644 and @xmath623 , @xmath645 .
let us apply lemma [ 150210_6 ] for @xmath646 , and take an integer @xmath621 and @xmath622 .
for any @xmath647 , @xmath648 is a submersion .
we take @xmath649 so that @xmath650 , and define @xmath651 \mapsto [ ( u \times \r^d , f \circ ( \ph \times \id_{\r^d } ) , \omega \times \nu_d)].\ ] ] it is easy to see that @xmath219 is a well - defined chain map . to show that @xmath652 and @xmath612 are chain homotopic ,
let us take @xmath653)$ ] so that * @xmath654 for any @xmath655 , and @xmath656 for any @xmath657 . * @xmath658 is compact , and there exists @xmath430 such that @xmath659 for any @xmath660 $ ] . for any @xmath661
, we define @xmath662 by @xmath663 since @xmath664 is a submersion , and @xmath665 is a diffeomorphism on @xmath351 for any @xmath666 , @xmath667 is also a submersion
. therefore , @xmath668 .
now , it is easy to see that @xmath669 \mapsto ( -1)^{|\omega|+d } [ ( u \times \r^d \times \r , \phi , \omega \times \nu_d \times b(s))]\ ] ] is a well - defined linear map , and @xmath670 .
similar arguments show that @xmath671 and @xmath613 are chain homotopic .
the homotopy operator is given by exactly the same formula as @xmath620 .
this case is easier , since we do not have to care about the submersion condition .
let us define an isomorphism @xmath597 .
when @xmath672 is finite - dimensional , it is defined as @xmath673 the first isomorphism is defined by integrations of differential forms on smooth chains , and the second one follows from the poincar duality . to define @xmath674 in the general case ,
let us define a set @xmath675 by @xmath676 then , we define @xmath674 by @xmath677 to prove that @xmath594 is an isomorphism , it is enough to check that @xmath598 .
we may assume that @xmath672 is finite - dimensional , since the general case follows from this case by taking limits .
let us consider the following diagram : @xmath678 ^ -{\cong}\ar[rd]_{i_0 } & ( h^*_\dr(m))^ * & \ar[l]_-{\cong}\ar[ld]^{i_1 } h^{d-*}_{c,\dr}(m ) \\ & h^\dr_*(m ) .
\ar[u ] & } \ ] ] the vertical map @xmath679 is defined by the pairing @xmath680 ( see section 2.8 ) . to show that @xmath681 , it is enough to check that the above diagram commutes up to sign .
the commutativity of the right triangle is easy to check from the definitions .
the commutativity of the left triangle follows from lemma [ 150629_2 ] ( the case @xmath682 ) .
let @xmath3 be a closed , oriented riemannian manifold .
we abbreviate @xmath683 as @xmath684 .
we consider the differentiable structure on @xmath684 as in example [ 150623_1 ] ( ii ) .
for any @xmath247 $ ] , we set @xmath685 , and consider the differentiable structure as a subset of @xmath684 ( see example [ 150623_1 ] ( iii ) ) .
any strongly smooth map @xmath686 is continuous with respect to the @xmath158-topology on @xmath687 .
therefore , we obtain a map @xmath688 , where the rhs denotes the singular homology . on the other hand , for any differentiable space @xmath313 , we defined the map @xmath591 .
the aim of this section is to prove the following result .
[ 150219_1 ] for any closed , oriented riemannian manifold @xmath3 and @xmath689 $ ] , the maps @xmath690 and @xmath688 are isomorphisms . as an immediate consequence ,
we obtain an isomorphism @xmath691 .
the proof of theorem [ 150219_1 ] uses finite - dimensional approximations of the free loop space @xmath692 , which we explain in section 4.1 .
recall that the rotation operator @xmath693 is defined as @xmath694 \times x)$ ] , where @xmath695 denotes the rotation . via isomorphisms
@xmath696 , one can define the rotation operators on @xmath697 and @xmath698 in the same way .
it is easy to see that the isomorphism @xmath699 preserves the rotation operators , since @xmath521 is a subcomplex of @xmath700 for @xmath701 .
the isomorphism @xmath702 also preserves the rotation operators , since @xmath703 is functorial and commutes with the cross product ( lemma [ 150627_1 ] ) .
thus we have proved the following corollary .
[ 150627_2 ] the isomorphism @xmath704 preserves the rotation operators .
let us define @xmath705 by @xmath706 .
@xmath707 is smooth as a function on the differentiable space @xmath147 . for any @xmath708
$ ] , we define @xmath709 by @xmath710 . for any positive integer @xmath351 ,
let us define @xmath711 @xmath712 is smooth as a map between differentiable spaces . for any @xmath713 ,
let us define ( @xmath4 denotes the distance on @xmath3 ) : @xmath714 for any @xmath715 $ ] , we define @xmath716 it is easy to see that @xmath717 for any @xmath718 $ ] .
let @xmath719 be the injectivity radius of @xmath3 ( since @xmath3 is closed , @xmath720 ) .
for any @xmath721 such that @xmath722 , there exists a unique shortest geodesic @xmath723 \to m$ ] such that @xmath724 , @xmath725 .
we denote it by @xmath726 .
suppose that @xmath351 is sufficiently large , such that @xmath727 .
for any @xmath728 and @xmath729 , there holds @xmath730 . for any integer @xmath731
, we define @xmath732 by @xmath733 for any @xmath734 and @xmath735 , we define @xmath736 by @xmath737 .
this is a @xmath0-map between @xmath0-manifolds .
[ 150625_1 ] for any positive real numbers @xmath738 and @xmath739 , there exists @xmath740 such that the following holds : for any integer @xmath741 and any integer @xmath731 , there exists a map @xmath742 such that the following diagram commutes up to homotopy ( @xmath743 denotes the inclusion map ) : @xmath744 ^ -{i}\ar[d]_-{f_n } & \l^{a',e ' } \ar[d]^-{f_{mn } } \\ { { \mathcal{f}}}^{a , e}_n \ar[r]_-{i_m}\ar[ru]^-{g}&{{\mathcal{f}}}^{a',e'}_{mn}. } \ ] ] @xmath347 and the homotopies are both continuous ( @xmath745 , @xmath746 are equipped with the @xmath0-topology ) and smooth ( as maps between differentiable spaces ) . to prove lemma [ 150625_1 ] , we need the following preliminary lemma [ 150625_2 ] .
we define @xmath747 \times \{(p , q ) \in m^{\times 2 } \mid d(p , q)<r_m \ } \to m$ ] by @xmath748 .
for any @xmath749 $ ] , we define a map @xmath750 by @xmath751 . for any @xmath752 such that @xmath753 , we define @xmath754 by @xmath755 .
[ 150625_2 ] for any @xmath643 , there exists @xmath756 such that the following holds : if @xmath757 satisfy @xmath758 , for any @xmath759 there holds @xmath760 the following assertion is easy to prove by contradiction : there exists @xmath756 such that , if @xmath721 satisfy @xmath761 , then @xmath762).\ ] ] take @xmath763 as above . then , if @xmath752 satisfy @xmath764 , there holds @xmath765 for any @xmath749 $ ] and @xmath766 .
the lemma follows from this estimate .
let us take @xmath643 so that @xmath767 and @xmath768 .
let us also take a @xmath0-function @xmath769 \to [ 0,1]$ ] with the following properties : * @xmath770 for any @xmath771 $ ] .
* @xmath772 for any integer @xmath773 .
* @xmath774 is constant on some neighborhoods of @xmath122 and @xmath89 .
let us take an integer @xmath351 so that @xmath775 .
for any @xmath728 , we define @xmath776 by @xmath777 then @xmath778 satisfies @xmath779 and @xmath780 , thus one can define @xmath781 by @xmath782 .
it is clear that @xmath783 .
@xmath347 is both smooth ( as a map between differentiable spaces ) and continuous ( @xmath784 is equipped with the @xmath0-topology ) .
let us define a homotopy between @xmath743 and @xmath785 .
for any @xmath786 , we set @xmath787 , and @xmath788
. then @xmath789 satisfies @xmath790 and @xmath791 . when @xmath351 is sufficiently large , @xmath792
thus , for any @xmath759 , @xmath793 satisfies @xmath794 and @xmath795 . finally , take @xmath796)$ ] so that @xmath797 for any @xmath655 , and @xmath798 for any @xmath657
. then , @xmath799 is a homotopy between @xmath743 and @xmath785 .
@xmath345 is both smooth and continuous .
[ rem : a = infty ] as is clear from the above proof , lemma [ 150625_1 ] holds even when @xmath800 . in this case
, we denote @xmath801 by @xmath802 .
let us take strictly increasing sequences of positive real numbers @xmath803 and @xmath804 , such that @xmath805 , @xmath806 .
then , @xmath807 is an increasing sequence of open sets ( with respect to the @xmath0-topology ) of @xmath687 , and @xmath808 .
thus , we have isomorphisms @xmath809 since the length functional on @xmath147 is approximately smooth , corollary [ 150213_1 ] implies @xmath810 .
thus , it is enough to show that the following maps are isomorphisms : @xmath811 now we apply lemma [ 150625_1 ] for each @xmath278 .
let us take a sequence @xmath812 of positive integers so that @xmath813 and @xmath814 for every @xmath278
. then , there exists a map @xmath815 such that the following diagram commutes up to homotopy : @xmath816\ar[d]_-{f_{n_j } } & \l^{a_{j+1 } , e_{j+1 } } \ar[d]^-{f_{n_{j+1}}}\\ { { \mathcal{f}}}^{a_j , e_j}_{n_j } \ar[r ] \ar[ru]^-{g_j}&{{\mathcal{f}}}^{a_{j+1 } , e_{j+1}}_{n_{j+1}}. } \ ] ] then @xmath817 is an isomorphism , since @xmath818 is its inverse .
the same argument also works for @xmath819 and @xmath820 , and we obtain isomorphisms @xmath821 these isomorphisms fit into the following commutative diagram : @xmath822 ^ -{\cong } & \vlim_j h^\sm_*(\l^{a_j , e_j } ) \ar[d]^-{\cong } \ar[r ] \ar[l ] & \vlim_j h^\dr_*(\l^{a_j , e_j } ) \ar[d]^-{\cong } \\
\vlim_j h_*({{\mathcal{f}}}^{a_j , e_j}_{n_j } ) & \vlim_j h^\sm_*({{\mathcal{f}}}^{a_j , e_j}_{n_j } ) \ar[r ] \ar[l ] & \vlim_j h^\dr_*({{\mathcal{f}}}^{a_j , e_j}_{n_j } ) . }
\ ] ] since @xmath823 is an oriented _ finite - dimensional _
manifold for every @xmath278 , @xmath824 and @xmath825 are isomorphisms .
thus , the horizontal maps on the second row are isomorphisms . therefore , the horizontal maps on the first row are also isomorphisms .
this completes the proof of theorem [ 150219_1 ] .
constructions of string topology operations ( e.g. the loop product ) require ( at least ) two steps : * fiber products of ( de rham ) chains of the loop space with respect to evaluation maps .
* concatenations of loops .
the differentiable space @xmath826 , which we studied in the previous section , is not adequate for both steps . to avoid this trouble , in this section
we introduce _ moore loops with marked points_. we explain the plan of this section .
let @xmath3 denote a closed , oriented riemannian manifold of dimension @xmath4 . in section 5.1 ,
we introduce the space @xmath827 , which consists of moore paths on @xmath3 . in section 5.2 ,
we introduce the space @xmath828 , which consists of moore loops with @xmath829 marked points .
we define two differentiable structures on @xmath828 , and denote the resulting differentiable spaces by @xmath828 and @xmath830 .
the latter is adequate to define fiber products on de rham chain complexes , and we show that a sequence of de rham chain complexes @xmath831 has a natural structure of a cyclic dg operad with a multiplication and a unit ( see definitions [ 150723_1 ] , [ 150624_4 ] ) .
this is a key geometric input in the definition of the chain complex @xmath9 , which we explain in section 6 .
sections 5.35.5 are devoted to proofs of technical lemmas [ 150624_2 ] , [ 150624_3 ] , [ 150626_5 ] , which we state in the end of section 5.2 .
let @xmath3 be a closed , oriented @xmath0-manifold .
we define the set of moore paths on @xmath3 as follows : @xmath832 , m ) , \ , \gamma^{(m)}(0)=\gamma^{(m)}(t)=0 \,(\forall m \ge 1 ) \}.\ ] ] @xmath833 denotes the @xmath163-th derivative of @xmath778 .
the last condition is required to take concatenations of @xmath0-paths .
we define @xmath834 by @xmath835 , @xmath836 . for any @xmath837 ,
let us define a map @xmath838 and @xmath839 by @xmath840 the concatenation map @xmath841 is defined by @xmath842 functionals @xmath843 and @xmath844 on @xmath827 are defined by @xmath845 to define a differentiable structure on @xmath827 , we need the following definition . [ 150625_3 ] let @xmath313 and @xmath321 be @xmath0-manifolds , and @xmath335 be any subset of @xmath313 .
then , a map @xmath846 is of class @xmath0 , if there exists an open neighborhood @xmath152 of @xmath847 and a @xmath0-map @xmath848 such that @xmath849 .
we define two differentiable structures on @xmath827 , and denote the resulting differentiable spaces as @xmath827 and @xmath850 .
the set of plots @xmath851 and @xmath852 are defined as follows : * let @xmath314 and @xmath853 .
denote @xmath854 for any @xmath855 .
then , @xmath856 if @xmath857 and @xmath858 is of class @xmath0 in the sense of definition [ 150625_3 ] ( @xmath859 , @xmath860 ) . *
@xmath852 consists of @xmath856 such that @xmath861 is a submersion for @xmath527 .
the identity map @xmath862 is smooth as a map of differentiable spaces .
the functional @xmath844 is smooth , and @xmath843 is approximately smooth with both differentiable structures ( @xmath827 and @xmath850 ) .
the goal of this subsection is to prove the next lemma .
[ 150626_1 ] the concatenation maps @xmath863 are smooth as maps of differentiable spaces .
set theoretically , the two maps in lemma [ 150626_1 ] are same .
however , differentiable structures on the domain and the target of the map are different .
first we prove the following lemma , which is a subtle point of the proof .
[ 150626_2 ] let @xmath152 be a @xmath0-manifold , and @xmath864 .
let @xmath865 , and suppose that @xmath866 satisfies the following conditions : * @xmath346 is of class @xmath0 in the sense of definition [ 150625_3 ] .
* for any @xmath855 and an integer @xmath29 , @xmath867
. then , @xmath868 defined by @xmath869 is of class @xmath0 .
let @xmath870 . a nontrivial part of the lemma is to check differentiability of @xmath871 at @xmath872 such that @xmath873 and @xmath874 .
since @xmath346 is of class @xmath0 , there exists a @xmath0-function @xmath875 , which is defined on an open neighborhood of @xmath876 and @xmath877 .
let us prove @xmath878 for any @xmath879 and @xmath874 .
it is obvious when @xmath880 , since @xmath881 for any @xmath29 and @xmath882 which is near @xmath81 .
even when @xmath873 , there exists a sequence @xmath883 such that @xmath884 and @xmath885 , since @xmath874 .
thus , @xmath886 . to prove the lemma , it is enough to prove the claim @xmath887 for every integer @xmath29 : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ @xmath887 : for any @xmath879 such that @xmath888 , @xmath889 is totally differentiable , and @xmath890 unless @xmath891 . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ let us prove @xmath892 .
it is enough to check @xmath893 for any @xmath81 such that @xmath873 and @xmath874 .
if this does not hold , there exists a sequence @xmath894 such that @xmath895 and @xmath896 . since @xmath897
, we may assume @xmath898 .
then , @xmath899 , and thus , @xmath900 . on the other hand @xmath901 , and thus , @xmath902 .
this contradicts @xmath903 , and @xmath892 is proved .
let us prove @xmath904 .
it is enough to check @xmath905 for any @xmath81 such that @xmath873 and @xmath874 .
if this does not hold , there exists a sequence @xmath894 such that @xmath895 and @xmath906 .
by @xmath907 , @xmath908 .
thus , we may assume that @xmath909 .
by @xmath907 , this implies @xmath899 , and thus , @xmath910 . on the other hand @xmath878 , and
thus , @xmath911 .
this contradicts @xmath912 , and @xmath887 is proved .
we first prove that @xmath913 is smooth .
let @xmath914 , and denote @xmath915 .
we need to show that @xmath916 is a plot on @xmath827 .
it is enough to show that @xmath917 is of class @xmath0 in the sense of definition [ 150625_3 ] .
we may assume that @xmath3 is embedded in @xmath918 for some integer @xmath351 .
for @xmath919 , we define @xmath920 by @xmath921 since @xmath922 for any @xmath855 and @xmath731 , lemma [ 150626_2 ] shows that @xmath923 .
let us define @xmath924 by @xmath925 then , it is easy to see that @xmath926 for any @xmath855 and @xmath927 .
this shows that @xmath928 is of class @xmath0 , hence @xmath913 is smooth .
now , it is easy to see that @xmath929 is smooth , since any @xmath930 satisfies @xmath931 and @xmath932 . for any integer @xmath265 , we define @xmath933 in particular , @xmath934 . for any @xmath935
, we define @xmath936 we also define @xmath937 by @xmath938 .
[ 150701_1 ] we can identify @xmath828 with @xmath939 , m ) , \ , 0 \le t_1 \le \cdots \le
t_k \le t , \\ & \qquad \gamma(0)=\gamma(t ) , \quad \gamma^{(m)}(0)=\gamma^{(m)}(t)= \gamma^{(m)}(t_j)=0 \ , ( \forall m \ge 1 , \ , 1 \le \forall j \le k ) \}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] indeed , for any @xmath940 , one can assign @xmath941 .
recall that we defined two differentiable structures on @xmath827 , and denote the resulting differentiable spaces @xmath827 and @xmath850 .
since @xmath828 is a subset of @xmath942 , we can define two differentiable structures on @xmath828 ( see example [ 150623_1 ] ( iii ) and ( iv ) ) .
we denote the resulting differentiable spaces by @xmath828 and @xmath830 .
let us define @xmath943 by @xmath944 .
the function @xmath843 is approximately smooth with both differentiable structures ( @xmath828 and @xmath830 ) . for any @xmath689 $ ] , we define @xmath945 .
we define differentiable structures on @xmath946 as a subspace of @xmath828 and @xmath830 , and denote the resulting differentiable spaces as @xmath946 and @xmath947 . the chain maps @xmath948 and @xmath949
are injective . for any @xmath950 and @xmath951
, we define a map @xmath952 by @xmath953 then , @xmath954 is a smooth map by lemma [ 150626_1 ] . also , @xmath955 is a smooth map .
now we need some definitions on algebraic operads .
our notion of a multiplication of an operad ( definition [ 150624_4 ] ) is similar to the one in @xcite .
[ 150723_1 ] let @xmath956 be a nonsymmetric dg operad .
a _ cyclic structure _ on @xmath957 is a sequence @xmath958 with the following properties . * for any @xmath265 , @xmath959 is a chain map on @xmath960 of degree @xmath122 , satisfying @xmath961 . *
@xmath962 is cyclically invariant , i.e. @xmath963 .
* for any @xmath950 , @xmath951 , @xmath964 and @xmath965 , there holds @xmath966 a pair @xmath967 is called a _
nonsymmetric cyclic dg operad_. [ 150624_4 ] let @xmath968 be a nonsymmetric dg operad .
@xmath969 is called a _ multiplication _ of @xmath957 , if @xmath970 and @xmath971 .
@xmath972 is called a _ unit _ of @xmath774 , if @xmath973 and @xmath974 .
let @xmath975 be a nonsymmetric dg operad with a multiplication and a unit .
then , @xmath976 has the structure of a cosimplicial chain complex with chain maps @xmath977 defined as @xmath978 also , suppose that @xmath957 has a cyclic structure @xmath958 , and @xmath969 is cyclically invariant , i.e. @xmath979 . then , @xmath957 is a cocyclic chain complex .
now let us return to the moore loop spaces .
for any @xmath265 , let @xmath980 . then
, @xmath981 has the structure of a nonsymmetric cyclic dg operad with a multiplication and a unit , defined as follows . * for any @xmath950 and @xmath951 , we define @xmath982 by @xmath983 . * for any @xmath265 , we define @xmath984 by @xmath985 .
we define @xmath986 to be the identity map on @xmath987 .
* let us take @xmath988 and an orientation - preserving diffemorphism @xmath989 .
then , we define @xmath990 \in { { \mathcal{cl}}}(0)_0 , \quad 1_{{{\mathcal{cl}}}}:= [ ( m ' , i_1 \circ \ph , 1 ) ] \in { { \mathcal{cl}}}(1)_0 , \\ \mu&:= [ ( m ' , i_2 \circ \ph , 1 ) ] \in { { \mathcal{cl}}}(2)_0
. \end{aligned}\ ] ] it is easy to check that the elements @xmath373 , @xmath991 and @xmath774 are well - defined , i.e. not depend on choices of @xmath992 and @xmath324 . also , @xmath991 and @xmath774 are cyclically invariant .
in particular , @xmath993 has the structure of a cocyclic chain complex .
notice that this structure preserves the length filtration .
namely , for any @xmath689 $ ] , @xmath994 has the structure of a cocyclic chain complex .
the rest of this section is devoted to proofs of the following lemmas .
[ 150624_2 ] for any @xmath265 , the identity map @xmath995 induces an isomorphism @xmath996 .
let us recall notations @xmath997 and @xmath998 .
[ 150624_3 ] for any @xmath265 , let us define @xmath999 and consider the differentiable structure on @xmath1000 as a subset of @xmath1001 .
then , the inclusion map @xmath1002 induces an isomorphism @xmath1003 .
[ 150626_5 ] for any @xmath265 , let us define the map @xmath1004 by @xmath1005 , @xmath1006 ( we set @xmath1007 , @xmath1008 ) .
then , the map @xmath1009 is smooth , and induces an isomorphism @xmath1010 . summarizing these lemmas
, we have the following zig - zag of the quasi - isomorphisms : @xmath1011 & c^\dr_*(\bl^a_k ) & c^\dr_*({{\mathcal{l}}}^a_k ) \ar[r]\ar[l ] & c^\dr_*({{\mathcal{l}}}^a \times \delta^k ) . \\ } \ ] ] the sequences @xmath1012 , @xmath1013 , @xmath1014 have natural structures of cocyclic chain complexes , and ( [ 150628_2 ] ) induces quasi - isomorphisms of these cocyclic chain complexes .
let us take an increasing sequence of positive real numbers @xmath803 , such that @xmath1015 .
since the length functional is approximately smooth on @xmath828 and @xmath830 , corollary [ 150213_1 ] implies @xmath1016 now , the key technical step is the next lemma .
[ 150626_3 ] for any integer @xmath482 , there exists a chain map @xmath1017 such that the following diagram commutes up to chain homotopy : @xmath1018 ^ -{(\id_j ) _ * } \ar[d]_-{(i_\reg)_*}&c^\dr_*(\bl^{a_j}_k ) \ar[d]^-{i_*}\ar[ld]^-{j } \\
c^\dr_*(\bl^{a_{j+1}}_{k,\reg } ) \ar[r]_-{(\id_{j+1 } ) _ * } & c^\dr_*(\bl^{a_{j+1}}_k ) . }
\ ] ] in the above diagram , @xmath1019 , @xmath1020 are identity maps , and @xmath613 , @xmath612 are inclusion maps .
lemma [ 150626_3 ] implies @xmath1021 , then we obtain @xmath996 , that is lemma [ 150624_2 ] .
let @xmath1022 . by lemma [ 150210_6 ] and remark [ 150626_4 ] , there exists an integer @xmath1023 and a @xmath0-map @xmath1024 such that * for any @xmath623
, @xmath1025 is a diffeomorphism .
moreover , there holds @xmath1026 for any @xmath1027 .
* @xmath1028 . * for any @xmath1029 , @xmath1030 is a submersion .
let us define @xmath1031 by @xmath1032 then , @xmath1033 for any @xmath1034 .
let us take @xmath1035 such that @xmath1036 .
it is easy to see that @xmath1037 \mapsto [ ( u \times \r^d , { { \mathcal{f } } } \circ(\ph \times \id_{\r^d } ) , \omega \times \nu)]\ ] ] is a well - defined chain map .
we show that @xmath219 satisfies the requirement in lemma [ 150626_3 ] . to show that @xmath1038 and @xmath1039 are homotopic
, we take @xmath653)$ ] so that * @xmath1040 for any @xmath655 , and @xmath1041 for any @xmath657 .
* @xmath1042 is compact , and there exists @xmath430 such that @xmath659 for any @xmath660 $ ] .
for any @xmath1043 , we define @xmath1044 by @xmath1045 let us show that it is a plot of @xmath830 , namely @xmath1046 is a submersion for every @xmath935 .
it is easy to check that @xmath1047 . since @xmath1048
, @xmath1049 is a submersion . on the other hand
, @xmath665 is a diffeomorphism on @xmath3 .
thus , @xmath1050 is a submersion .
hence @xmath1051 .
it is easy to see that the linear map @xmath1052 \mapsto ( -1)^{|\omega|+d } [ ( u \times \r^d \times \r , \phi , \omega \times \nu \times b(s))]\ ] ] is well - defined , and satisfies @xmath1053 .
similar arguments show that @xmath1054 is homotopic to @xmath1055 .
the homotopy operator is given by exactly the same formula as @xmath620 .
this case is easier , since we do not have to care about the submersion condition .
let us take strictly increasing sequences @xmath803 , @xmath804 of positive real numbers , such that @xmath1056 , @xmath1057 .
we set @xmath1058 [ 150630_1 ] for every @xmath482 , there exists a smooth map @xmath1059 such that the following diagram commutes up to smooth homotopy : @xmath1060 \ar[d ] & \l^{a_j , e_j } \times \delta^k \ar[ld]^-j \ar[d ] \\
\l^{a_{j+1 } , e_{j+1}}_k \ar[r ] & \l^{a_{j+1 } , e_{j+1 } } \times \delta^k . } \ ] ] all maps other than @xmath219 are inclusion maps . assuming lemma [ 150630_1 ]
, we can prove lemma [ 150624_3 ] as @xmath1061 to prove lemma [ 150630_1 ] , we need the following sublemma .
[ 150630_2 ] for any @xmath643 , there exists a @xmath0-map @xmath1062 \to [ 0,1]$ ] such that the following properties hold for any @xmath1063 .
* @xmath1064 , @xmath1065 . *
@xmath1066 $ ] for any @xmath1067 $ ] . *
@xmath1068 for any @xmath1067 $ ] .
* @xmath1069 for any integer @xmath731 and @xmath1070 .
we may assume @xmath1071 .
let us take @xmath1072 .
we also take @xmath504)$ ] such that @xmath1073 for any integer @xmath29 , and @xmath1074 if @xmath1075 . for any @xmath771 $ ] , we set @xmath1076 , and we define @xmath1077)$ ] by @xmath1078 it is clear that @xmath774 satisfies ( i ) and ( iv ) .
it is also easy to check @xmath1079 , then ( ii ) and ( iii ) are verified as @xmath1080 let us fix @xmath1081 , and take @xmath643 so that @xmath1082 for the definition of @xmath1083 in the second inequality , see lemma [ 150625_2 ] .
we take @xmath1062 \to [ 0,1]$ ] as in lemma [ 150630_2 ] . for any @xmath1084 and @xmath1085
, we define @xmath1086 by @xmath1087 ( this is well - defined by ( i ) ) .
then @xmath1088 , and @xmath1089 by ( ii ) . by ( iv ) , for any @xmath731 and @xmath1090 , there holds @xmath1091 .
therefore , @xmath1092 . since @xmath1093
, one can define @xmath219 by @xmath1094 by lemma [ 150630_2 ] ( iii ) and @xmath1095 , there holds @xmath1096 for any @xmath749 $ ] , let @xmath1097 .
the map @xmath750 is defined right before lemma [ 150625_2 ] . applying lemma [ 150625_2 ] for @xmath1098
, we obtain @xmath1099 for any @xmath749 $ ] . if @xmath1100 , there holds @xmath1101 for any @xmath731 , @xmath759 , and @xmath1102 .
thus , @xmath1103 for any @xmath759 .
let us take @xmath1104)$ ] so that @xmath1105 for @xmath655 and @xmath1106 for @xmath657 .
we define @xmath1107 by @xmath1108 obviously , this is a smooth homotopy between @xmath219 and the inclusion map @xmath1109 . finally , the restriction of @xmath1110 to @xmath1111 is a smooth homotopy between @xmath1112 and the inclusion map @xmath1113 .
it is easy to see that the map @xmath1009 is smooth , thus it is enough to show that the map induces an isomorphism on @xmath820 .
the proof consists of three steps .
* step 1 . *
we identify @xmath828 with the set consists of tuples @xmath1114 ( see remark [ 150701_1 ] ) . setting @xmath1115 \to \r/\z$ ] by @xmath1116
$ ] , the map @xmath1009 is given by @xmath1117 . the image of this map is contained in @xmath1118 now , @xmath1119 induces an isomorphism on @xmath820 , since @xmath1120 is its smooth homotopy inverse , where @xmath1121 .
therefore , it is enough to show that the inclusion map @xmath1122 gives an isomorphism on @xmath820 .
* step 2 . *
let @xmath1123 .
for any @xmath1124 , let us set @xmath1125 since @xmath707 is smooth as a function on @xmath946 , we obtain isomorphisms @xmath1126 , @xmath1127 .
thus , it is enough to show that the inclusion map @xmath1128 induces an isomorphism on @xmath820 for every @xmath1124 . * step 3 .
* for any @xmath1129 , let us set @xmath1130 consider the following commutative diagram , where all maps are inclusion maps : @xmath1131^{j_3 } \ar[d]_{j_1 } & \bl^{a , e}_{k , \delta } \ar[d]^{j_2 } \\ \bl^{a , e}_{k , t>0 } \ar[r]_{j_4 } & \bl^{a , e}_k . } \ ] ] then , it is easy to check the following claims : * there exists @xmath1132 , depending only on @xmath78 , such that if @xmath1133 then @xmath1134 , @xmath1135 induce isomorphisms on @xmath820 .
this is because one can define homotopy inverses of @xmath1134 and @xmath1135 by contracting a loop @xmath1136 to the constant loop at @xmath1137 whenever @xmath1138 ( notice that @xmath1139 ) . * for any @xmath643 , @xmath1140 induces an isomorphism on @xmath820 , since its homotopy inverse is given by @xmath1141 , such that * * @xmath1142 for any @xmath1143 , @xmath1144 for any @xmath1145 , and @xmath1146 . * * @xmath1147 is defined as @xmath1148 therefore , we can conclude that @xmath1149 induces an isomorphism on @xmath820 .
this completes the proof of lemma [ 150626_5 ] .
the first goal of this section is to define the chain complex @xmath9 , which is our chain model of the free loop space @xmath11 .
the second goal is to prove the results presented in section 1.5 assuming theorem [ 150624_8 ] , which is a purely algebraic result on dg operads .
the proof of theorem [ 150624_8 ] occupies the rest of this paper ( sections 711 ) .
after some algebraic preliminaries in section 6.1 , we define the chain complex @xmath9 in section 6.2 . in section 6.3 ,
we establish the relation between @xmath9 and the hochschild complex of @xmath7 . in section 6.4 ,
we state theorem [ 150624_8 ] , and prove most results presented in section 1.5 , except that the isomorphism @xmath221 preserves the bv structures .
we prove this result in sections 6.56.8 .
a double complex @xmath1150 consists of a sequence @xmath1151 of chain complexes and anti - chain maps @xmath1152 for each @xmath128 , such that @xmath536 for any @xmath128 .
we denote @xmath1153 as @xmath1154 if necessary . for any double complexes @xmath1150 and @xmath1023 , a morphism @xmath1155 is a sequence @xmath1156 such that
, @xmath1157 is a chain map and @xmath1158 for every @xmath128 . for any double complex @xmath1150
, we define a chain complex @xmath1159 by @xmath1160 which we call the _ total complex _ of @xmath1150 .
a morphism @xmath1155 of double complexes induces a chain map @xmath1161 .
[ 150629_1 ] let @xmath1162 be a double complex .
if the sequence @xmath1163 & h_q(c(0 ) ) \ar[r]_-{h_q(\delta_1 ) } & h_q(c(1 ) ) \ar[r]_-{h_q(\delta_2 ) } & h_q(c(2 ) ) \ar[r]_-{h_q(\delta_3 ) } & \cdots } \ ] ] is exact for every @xmath1164 , then the total complex @xmath1165 is acyclic . for any @xmath951 ,
let @xmath1166 . then , @xmath1167 is a decreasing filtration on @xmath1165 which is complete , i.e. @xmath1168 .
let us consider the spectral sequence of this filtered complex .
then , the assumption implies that all @xmath1169-terms vanish .
now , the convergence theorem 5.5.10 ( 2 ) in @xcite pp.139 shows @xmath1170 .
[ 150627_5 ] let @xmath1155 be a morphism of double complexes .
suppose that @xmath1157 is a quasi - isomorphism for every @xmath265 .
then , the chain map @xmath1171 is a quasi - isomorphism .
let us consider the filtrations @xmath1167 and @xmath1172 as in the proof of the previous lemma .
then , @xmath1171 induces a morphism of the spectral sequences , and the assumption implies that it induces isomorphisms on @xmath1173-terms .
then , the comparison theorem 5.5.11 in @xcite pp .
141 shows that @xmath1174 is an isomorphism .
let @xmath1175 be any cosimplcial chain complex .
for any @xmath128 , let us define @xmath1152 by @xmath1176 .
then , @xmath1150 is a double complex . for any dga algebra @xmath1 ,
the endomorphism operad @xmath1177 has a multiplication @xmath1178 and a unit @xmath1179 , defined by @xmath1180 and @xmath1181 .
in particular , @xmath1182 has the structure of a cosimplicial chain complex .
the total complex @xmath1183 is isomorphic to the hochschild cochain complex @xmath14 . as a consequence of lemma [ 150629_1 ]
, we obtain the next lemma .
[ 150627_4 ] let @xmath1175 be a cosimplicial chain complex , and suppose that the chain map @xmath1184 , which is induced by the cosimplicial structure , is a quasi - isomorphism for any @xmath265 .
then , the projection map @xmath1185 is a quasi - isomorphism .
since @xmath1186 is surjective , it is enough to show that @xmath1187 is acyclic .
the assumption shows that , for any @xmath1164 the sequence @xmath1163 & h_q(c(1 ) ) \ar[r]_-{h_q(\delta_2 ) } & h_q(c(2 ) ) \ar[r]_-{h_q(\delta_3 ) } & h_q(c(3 ) ) \ar[r]_-{h_q(\delta_4 ) } & \cdots } \ ] ] is exact , thus lemma [ 150629_1 ] shows that @xmath1188 is acyclic .
let @xmath3 be a closed , oriented riemannian manifold of dimension @xmath4 .
we define the chain complex @xmath9 to be the total complex of the cosimplicial chain complex @xmath993 .
explicitly , @xmath1189 for any @xmath247 $ ] , we define a subcomplex @xmath1190 by @xmath1191 .
then , @xmath1192}$ ] is the length filtration on @xmath9 .
we are going to show that , there exists an isomorphism @xmath1193 for each @xmath689 $ ] , such that proposition [ 141005_2 ] ( i ) holds . in particular ,
when @xmath1194 we obtain an isomorphism @xmath221 .
let us abbreviate @xmath1195 by @xmath692 , as usual .
let us recall the zig - zag ( [ 150628_2 ] ) of quasi - isomorphisms from section 5.2 : @xmath1196 & c^\dr_{*+d}(\bl^a_k ) & \ar[l ] c^\dr_{*+d}({{\mathcal{l}}}^a_k ) \ar[r ] & c^\dr_{*+d}({{\mathcal{l}}}^a \times \delta^k ) . } \ ] ] it extends to a zig - zag of quasi - isomorphisms of cocylic chain complexes .
let @xmath1197 denote the total complex of the cosimplicial chain complex @xmath1198 .
then , lemma [ 150627_5 ] implies the isomorphism @xmath1199 . for every @xmath265 the projection @xmath1200 induces a quasi - isomorphism on @xmath1201 .
then , lemma [ 150627_4 ] shows that @xmath1202 is a quasi - isomorphism , thus @xmath1203 .
the next lemma is confirmed by short computations .
[ 150629_3 ] let @xmath548 be as in lemma [ 150624_10 ] ( i ) .
then , @xmath1204 is a chain map such that @xmath1205 . on the other hand
, we have the isomorphism @xmath1206 by theorem [ 150219_1 ] . in conclusion , for every @xmath247 $ ] , we obtain a sequence of isomorphisms @xmath1207 in particular , we obtain @xmath1208 .
to define a chain map @xmath225 , we take @xmath988 and an orientation - preserving diffeomorphism @xmath989 .
let us recall the map @xmath1209 , and define @xmath1210 by @xmath1211 & ( k=0 ) , \\ 0 & ( k \ge 1 ) .
\end{cases}\ ] ] it is easy to check that this is well - defined ( i.e. not depend on @xmath992 and @xmath324 ) , and the diagram ( [ 150801_3 ] ) commutes . for
any @xmath265 , @xmath1212 and @xmath1213 , let @xmath1214 . by definition ,
@xmath1215 are submersions for all @xmath278 .
we define a chain map @xmath1216 by @xmath1217)(\eta_1 \otimes \cdots \otimes \eta_k):= ( -1)^{(\dim u - d)(|\eta_1| + \cdots + |\eta_k| ) } ( \ph_0)_!(\omega \wedge
\ph_1^*\eta_1 \wedge \cdots \wedge \ph_k^*\eta_k).\ ] ] recall that we defined nonsymmetric dg operads with multiplications and units @xmath1218 @xmath1219 is a morphism of nonsymmetric dg operads preserving multiplications and units . in general , if @xmath1220 is a morphism of nonsymmetric dg operads preserving multiplications and units , then @xmath324 is a morphism of cosimplicial chain complexes , thus induces a chain map @xmath1221 . in particular
, we obtain a chain map @xmath19 .
we are going to show the following lemma ( see theorem [ 150628_1 ] ( iii)-(c ) ) .
[ 150725_1 ] @xmath20 is equal to the map ( [ 141218_01 ] ) . for any @xmath1213 , we define @xmath1222 by @xmath1223 for any @xmath1224 , we set @xmath1214 .
let us define a chain map @xmath1225)$ ] by @xmath1226(\eta_1 \otimes \cdots \otimes \eta_k)(\eta_0 ) : = ( -1)^{(\dim u - d)(|\eta_0|+|\eta_1| + \cdots + |\eta_k| ) } \int_u \omega \wedge
\ph_1^*\eta_1 \wedge \cdots \wedge \ph_k^ * \eta_k \wedge \ph_0^*\eta_0.\ ] ] then , one can define a chain map @xmath1227)$ ] . as is obvious from the construction , the following diagram commutes : @xmath1228 ^ -{h_*(j ) } \ar[d]_-{\cong } & h^*({{\mathcal{a}}}_m , { { \mathcal{a}}}_m ) \ar[d]^-{\cong } \\
h_*(c^{{{\mathcal{l}}}\delta } ) \ar[r]_-{h_*(j ' ) } & h^*({{\mathcal{a}}}_m , { { \mathcal{a}}}^\vee_m[d ] ) . }
let us consider the chain map @xmath1229)$ ] in ( [ 141222_4 ] ) .
we need to show that @xmath1230 corresponds to @xmath1231 via the isomorphism @xmath1232 .
let us take @xmath548 as in lemma [ 150624_10 ] ( i ) , and consider chain maps @xmath1233 the first map is defined right after lemma [ 150624_10 ] , and the second map is defined in lemma [ 150629_3 ] .
then , it is enough to show that the following diagram commutes : @xmath1234
^ -{h_*(i_u)}_-{\cong } \ar[rd]_-{h_*(i ) } & h^\dr_{*+d}({{\mathcal{l } } } ) \ar[r]^-{h_*(e_u)}_-{\cong } & h_*(c^{{{\mathcal{l}}}\delta } ) \ar[ld]^-{h_*(j ' ) } \\ & h^*({{\mathcal{a}}}_m , { { \mathcal{a}}}_m^\vee[d ] ) . & } \ ] ] the commutativity of this diagram follows from lemma [ 150629_2 ] and short computations .
first we state the following result , which we prove in sections 711 .
[ 150624_8 ] there exists a dg operad @xmath12 and its suboperad @xmath13 with the following conditions . 1 .
there exist isomorphisms of graded operads @xmath1235 and @xmath214 , such that the following diagram commutes : @xmath215 \ar[d]_-{\cong } & h_*(f\tilde{\lambda } ) \ar[d]^-{\cong } \\ \ger \ar[r ] & \batvil . } \ ] ] 2 .
let @xmath957 be any nonsymmetric dg operad , with a multiplication @xmath969 and a unit @xmath972 .
then , @xmath1236 has a dg @xmath18-algebra structure , in particular @xmath1237 has the gerstenhaber algebra structure . the operators @xmath84 and @xmath85 are defined in chain level by the following formulas , where @xmath1238 : @xmath1239 these operators induce dga and dg lie algebra structures on @xmath1236 .
finally , for any morphism @xmath1240 of nonsymmetric dg operads which preserves multiplications and units , the chain map @xmath1241 is a morphism of dg @xmath18-algebras .
3 . let @xmath957 be as ( ii ) , and assume that @xmath957 has a cyclic structure @xmath958 such that @xmath979 .
then , @xmath1236 has a dg @xmath1242-algebra structure , which extends the dg @xmath18-algebra structure in ( ii ) .
in particular , @xmath1237 has the bv algebra structure .
the operator @xmath99 is defined at chain level by the following formula : @xmath1243 @xmath99 is an anti - chain map on @xmath1236 .
[ 150811_2 ] there are several results similar to theorem [ 150624_8 ] in the literature , e.g. @xcite theorem 5.17 , @xcite theorems a and b. actually , @xcite considers operads with maurer - cartan elements , which are generalizations of operads with multiplications .
however , for the following reasons we can not directly apply results in @xcite in our argument : * @xcite assumes @xmath1244 , which we can not assume in our argument . * in theorem b in @xcite , actions of operads are defined only for _ normalized _ chains ( see section 3.1 @xcite ) , while we would like to consider arbitrary chains .
therefore , we give a self - contained proof of theorem [ 150624_8 ] in sections 711 . as a consequence of theorem [ 150624_8 ] , we obtain the following : * for any dga algebra @xmath1 , the hochschild complex @xmath138 has a dg @xmath18-algebra structure ; apply theorem [ 150624_8 ] ( ii ) for @xmath1245 . * for any closed , oriented @xmath0-manifold @xmath3 , the chain complex @xmath9 has a dg @xmath1242-algebra structure ; apply theorem [ 150624_8 ] ( iii ) for @xmath1246 .
also , this @xmath1242-algebra structure on @xmath9 preserves the length filtration ; see remark [ 150801_4 ] . *
the chain map @xmath19 ( see the previous subsectoin ) is a map of dg @xmath18-algebras ; since @xmath1219 is a morphism of nonsymmetric dg operads preserving multiplications and units , we can apply theorem [ 150624_8 ] ( ii ) . *
the chain map @xmath225 satisfies ( [ 150801_2 ] ) ; this follows form explicit formulas of @xmath84 and @xmath1247 in theorem [ 150624_8 ] ( ii ) .
now , we have verified most results presented in section 1.5 .
the only statement we have not verified is that the isomorphism @xmath17 preserves the bv structures , i.e. the operators @xmath84 and @xmath99 are preserved by this isomorphism . in the rest of this section
, we prove that @xmath667 preserves the operator @xmath99 ( section 6.5 ) and @xmath84 ( sections 6.66.8 ) .
the arguments in sections 6.6 - 6.8 are less detailed than the other parts of this paper .
the aim of this subsection is to show that the isomorphism @xmath17 preserves the rotation operator @xmath99 . for
any cocyclic chain complex @xmath1175 and its total complex @xmath1165 , let us define an anti - chain map @xmath1248 by @xmath1249 this is a generalization of the definition of @xmath99 in theorem [ 150624_8 ] ( iii ) .
in particular , we can define @xmath99 on @xmath1250 so that the isomorphism @xmath1251 preserves @xmath99 . since we already proved that the isomorphism @xmath1252 preserves @xmath99 ( corollary [ 150627_2 ] ) , it is enough to show that the isomorphism @xmath1253 preserves @xmath99 .
the isomorphism @xmath1253 is induced by @xmath1254 , and its inverse is induced by @xmath1255 ( lemma [ 150629_3 ] ) , where @xmath548 is as in lemma [ 150624_10 ] ( i ) .
therefore , it is enough to prove @xmath1256 on @xmath1257 .
it is easy to check that @xmath1258 for any @xmath1259 .
the chain map @xmath1260 is induced by @xmath1261 ^ -{\id_{{{\mathcal{l } } } } \times p } & { { \mathcal{l } } } \times s^1 \ar[r ] & s^1 \times { { \mathcal{l } } } \ar[r]^-{r } & { { \mathcal{l } } } , } \ ] ] where @xmath1262 is defined by @xmath1116 $ ] , the second map is the inversion , and the last map @xmath1263 is the rotation .
therefore @xmath1264 for any @xmath1259 .
since @xmath1265 is a cycle which represents @xmath178 $ ] , for any cycle @xmath438 we obtain @xmath1266 ) = - h_*(r)([s^1 ] \times [ x])$ ] .
this completes the proof .
we are going to show that the isomorphism @xmath17 preserves the operator @xmath84 . in this subsection
, we reduce the proof to lemma [ 150629_4 ] , which is proved in the next two subsections .
let us consider the concatenation map @xmath1267 and define a chain map @xmath1268 by @xmath1269 . then , @xmath1270 intertwines the operators @xmath84 and
@xmath1271 : @xmath1272 therefore , it is enough to prove the next proposition .
[ 150627_3 ] the isomorphism @xmath1273 intertwines the operator @xmath1271 on @xmath1274 and the loop product @xmath84 on @xmath1275 .
let us define @xmath1276 by @xmath1277 .
a key step in the definition of the loop product on @xmath1275 is to define the fiber product @xmath1278 via thom isomorphism ( see section 1.3 ) . on the other hand , let us consider the following differentiable structure on @xmath684 , and denote the resulting differentiable space by @xmath1279 : @xmath1280 then , as in section 2.3 , one can define the fiber product @xmath1281 we have isomorphisms @xmath1282 ; the first isomorphism is by theorem [ 150219_1 ] , and the second isomorphism is obtained by similar arguments as the proof of lemma [ 150624_2 ] .
we also have isomorphisms @xmath1283 by similar arguments .
let us state the key technical result : [ 150629_4 ] the following diagram commutes : @xmath1284 \ar[d]_{\cong } & h^\dr_{*-d}(\l_\reg { \,_{e}\!\!\times_{e } } \l_\reg ) \ar[d]^{\cong } \\
h_*(\l)^{\otimes 2 } \ar[r ] & h_{*-d}(\l { \,_{e}\!\!\times_{e } } \l ) , } \ ] ] where horizontal maps are fiber products .
it is easy to deduce proposition [ 150627_3 ] from lemma [ 150629_4 ] , and details are left to the reader .
the rest of this section is devoted to the proof of lemma [ 150629_4 ] . in the next subsection , we prove lemma [ 150726_1 ] , which is a preliminary result in the finite - dimensional setting .
let @xmath313 be a @xmath0-manifold , and @xmath1285 be a submersion .
then , one can define the fiber product @xmath1286 via the thom isomorphism for the tubular neighborhood of @xmath1287 .
on the other hand , let us consider the following differentiable structure on @xmath313 , and denote the resulting differentiable space by @xmath1288 : @xmath1289 then , one can define the fiber product @xmath1290 .
it is obvious that the identity maps on @xmath313 and @xmath1291 induces smooth maps @xmath1292 and @xmath1293 .
these maps induce isomorphisms @xmath1294 and @xmath1295 .
this fact is proved by similar arguments as proposition [ 150210_4 ] , and details are omitted .
then , we obtain isomorphisms @xmath1296 [ 150726_1 ] the following diagram commutes : @xmath1297 \ar[d]^{\cong } & h^\dr_{*-d}(x_{\reg / m } { \,_{e}\!\!\times_{e } } x_{\reg / m } ) \ar[d]^{\cong } \\ h_*(x)^{\otimes 2 } \ar[r ] & h_{*-d}(x { \,_{e}\!\!\times_{e } } x ) . } \ ] ] via isomorphisms @xmath1298 and @xmath1299 both horizontal maps in ( [ eq : fbp_finite ] ) are identified with the map @xmath1300 \otimes [ \eta ] \mapsto [ \omega \times \eta|_{x { \,_{e}\!\!\times_{e } } x}],\ ] ] hence ( [ eq : fbp_finite ] ) is commutative .
we use notations in section 4.1 .
we abbreviate @xmath1301 by @xmath1302 , and @xmath1303 by @xmath1304 .
let @xmath804 be a strictly increasing sequence of positive real numbers , such that @xmath1305 .
let us take a sequence @xmath812 of positive integers , so that @xmath814 and @xmath1306 for every @xmath482 ( see remark [ rem : a = infty ] ) . by lemma [ 150625_1 ] , there exists a continuous map @xmath1307 such that @xmath1308\ar[d]_-{f_{n_j}}&\l^{e_{j+1 } } \ar[d]^-{f_{n_{j+1}}}\\ { { \mathcal{f}}}^{e_j}_{n_j } \ar[r ] \ar[ru]_-{g_j}&{{\mathcal{f}}}^{e_{j+1}}_{n_{j+1 } } } \ ] ] commutes up to homotopy .
then , @xmath1309 . in the following arguments , we abbreviate @xmath1310 by @xmath1311 , and @xmath1312 by @xmath512 .
let @xmath1313 .
as is clear from the proof of lemma [ 150625_1 ] , one may take @xmath1314 so that @xmath1315 ( thus @xmath1316 is well - defined ) , and the following diagram commutes up to homotopy : @xmath1317\ar[d]_-{f_j \times f_j}&\l^{e_{j+1 } } { \,_{e}\!\!\times_{e } } \l^{e_{j+1 } } \ar[d]^-{f_{j+1 } \times f_{j+1 } } \\ { { \mathcal{f}}}^j { \,_{e_j}\!\!\times_{e_j } } { { \mathcal{f}}}^j \ar[r ] \ar[ru]_-{g_j \times g_j } & { { \mathcal{f}}}^{j+1 } { \,_{e_{j+1}}\!\!\times_{e_{j+1 } } } { { \mathcal{f}}}^{j+1}. } \ ] ] then , @xmath1318 . since @xmath1319 is a submersion , one can define the differentiable space @xmath1320 as in the previous subsection .
then , @xmath512 maps plots of @xmath1321 to plots of @xmath1320 .
also , one may take @xmath1314 so that it maps plots of @xmath1320 to plots of @xmath1322 , and the diagrams ( [ eq : ejgj ] ) and ( [ eq : ejgj_2 ] ) commute up to smooth homotopy with these differentiable structures .
hence we obtain @xmath1323 for every @xmath482 , let us consider the following diagram : @xmath1324\ar[ddd]\ar[rd]^{\star } & & & h^\dr_{*-d } ( \l^{e_j}_\reg { \,_{e}\!\!\times_{e } } \l^{e_j}_\reg)\ar[ld]_{\star}\ar[ddd ] \\ & h^\dr_*\big({{\mathcal{f}}}^j_{\reg / m } \big)^{\otimes 2}\ar[r]\ar[d]&h^\dr_{*-d } \big ( { { \mathcal{f}}}^j_{\reg / m } { \,_{e_j}\!\!\times_{e_j } } { { \mathcal{f}}}^j_{\reg / m } \big)\ar[d ] & \\ & h_*\big({{\mathcal{f}}}^j \big)^{\otimes 2}\ar[r]&h_{*-d } \big({{\mathcal{f}}}^j { \,_{e_j}\!\!\times_{e_j } } { { \mathcal{f}}}^j \big ) & \\ h_*(\l^{e_j})^{\otimes 2}\ar[ru]^{\star}\ar[rrr]&&&h_{*-d } ( \l^{e_j } { \,_{e}\!\!\times_{e } } \l^{e_j}).\ar[lu]_{\star } } \ ] ] the center square in ( [ eq : bigsquare ] ) is commutative by lemma [ 150726_1 ] .
the commutativity of the other four squares in ( [ eq : bigsquare ] ) is easy to check from definitions . taking direct limits as @xmath1325 , all maps in ( [ eq : bigsquare ] )
pass to the limit .
moreover , the limits of the maps with @xmath1326 are isomorphisms .
therefore , the limit of the big square in ( [ eq : bigsquare ] ) is commutative , and this completes the proof of lemma [ 150629_4 ] .
the rest of this paper is devoted to the proof of theorem [ 150624_8 ] . in this section ,
we fix definitions and terminologies about ( ribbon ) graphs , partially following @xcite and @xcite . as a definition of a graph
, we adopt the one in @xcite .
a _ graph _ is a quadruple @xmath1327 where @xmath1328 and @xmath1329 are finite sets , @xmath1330 is a map @xmath1331 , @xmath1332 is a map @xmath1333 such that @xmath1334 . when there is no risk of confusion , the subscript @xmath1335 will be dropped . * the elements of @xmath38
are called the _ vertices _ of @xmath1335 . * the elements of @xmath875
are called the _ flags _ of @xmath1335 . * for any @xmath1336 , the elements of @xmath1337 are called the flags at @xmath882 .
@xmath1338 is called the _ valence _ of @xmath882 , and denoted by @xmath1339 . * an _ edge _ of @xmath1335 is a set @xmath1340 such that @xmath1341 and @xmath1342 .
the set of all edges of @xmath1335 is denoted by @xmath1343 .
we say that the edge @xmath1340 connects vertices @xmath1344 and @xmath1345 .
* a _ tail _ of @xmath1335 is @xmath1341 such that @xmath1346 .
the set of all tails of @xmath1335 is denoted by @xmath1347 .
an isomorphism of graphs consists of bijections between the sets of vertices and flags , compatible with maps @xmath1348 and @xmath1349 . to any graph @xmath1335
, one can associate a @xmath89-dimensional cw complex @xmath1350 in the obvious way ( see @xcite , pp.1502 ) .
@xmath1335 is called _ connected _ if @xmath1350 is connected as a topological space . for any @xmath1351 ,
let @xmath1352 .
let us denote a graph @xmath1353 by @xmath1354 .
@xmath78 is called _ acyclic _ if @xmath1355 . in this paper ,
a _ tree _ is a connected graph @xmath1335 which has no tails , and @xmath1356 .
it is easy to see that @xmath1350 is contractible . in particular , for any vertices @xmath1357 , there exists at most one edge which connects @xmath882 and @xmath1358 . when @xmath1359 , there is no such edge . a _ ribbon graph _ is a graph with a cyclic order on the set of flags at @xmath882 for each vertex @xmath882 .
formally , a ribbon graph is a quintuple @xmath1360 , where @xmath1361 is a graph and @xmath1362 is a bijection , such that @xmath1363 , and @xmath1364 acts transitively on @xmath1365 for every @xmath1366 .
an isomorphism of ribbon graphs consists of bijections between the sets of vertices and flags , compatible with maps @xmath1348 , @xmath1349 and @xmath351 . in all figures in this paper ,
the map @xmath1364 is a _ clockwise _ rotation of flags .
orbits of the bijection @xmath1367 are called _ cycles _ of @xmath1335 . for any cycle @xmath1368
, we define a cyclic order on @xmath1368 by @xmath1369 .
the set of all cycles of @xmath1335 is denoted by @xmath1370 . when @xmath1335 is connected , the _ genus _ of @xmath1335 , denoted by @xmath1371 , is defined by the formula @xmath1372 .
let @xmath1335 be a ribbon graph .
for any @xmath1373 , we define a ribbon graph @xmath1374 by removing elements of @xmath875 . here
we present a formal definition .
first , we set @xmath1375 .
next , we consider the case that @xmath875 consists of a single flag @xmath346 .
we define a ribbon graph @xmath1376 by @xmath1377 , @xmath1378 , @xmath1379 , and @xmath1380 finally , in the general case , we define so that there holds @xmath1381 for any @xmath1373 and @xmath1382 .
let @xmath1335 be a ribbon graph .
for any @xmath1351 which is acyclic , we define a ribbon graph @xmath1383 by contracting elements of @xmath78 . here
we present a formal definition .
first , we set @xmath1384 .
next , we consider the case that @xmath78 consists of a single edge @xmath1385 .
since @xmath78 is acyclic , @xmath1385 connects different vertices .
namely , let @xmath1386 , @xmath1387 , @xmath1388 , then @xmath1389 .
we consider a new vertex @xmath1390 , and define @xmath1391 .
we define @xmath1392 , @xmath1393 , and @xmath1394 contracting an edge @xmath1385 .
finally , in the general case we define so that there holds @xmath1395 for any @xmath1351 and @xmath1396 such that @xmath1397 is acyclic .
the next lemma is easy to check and its proof is omitted .
[ lem : removing_contracting ] let @xmath1335 be a ribbon graph , @xmath1351 , @xmath1373 .
suppose that @xmath78 is acyclic and @xmath1398 .
then , @xmath1399 .
in this section we introduce a notion of a _ decorated cactus _ , which is a ribbon graph with additional data .
we also define the framed version ( _ framed decorated cactus _ ) , and define compositions of framed decorated cacti . in the next section , we show that the collection of framed decorated cacti has a natural structure of a @xmath1400-colored operad .
[ 141121_1 ] let @xmath1335 be a ribbon graph , @xmath1401 be cycles of @xmath1335 , and @xmath1402 .
a tuple @xmath1403 is called a _ decorated cactus _ ,
if the following conditions hold : 1 .
@xmath1335 is connected , and @xmath1404 .
2 . @xmath1328 is a disjoint union of @xmath1405 .
3 . for any @xmath1406
, there holds @xmath1407 .
in particular , @xmath1408 .
an isomorphism of decorated cacti @xmath1409 is an isomorphism @xmath1410 of ribbon graphs , which maps @xmath1411 to @xmath1412 , and @xmath1413 to @xmath1414 for every @xmath1415 . for any @xmath1416
, @xmath1417 denotes the set of isomorphism classes of decorated cacti @xmath1403 such that @xmath1418 , @xmath1419 .
given a decorated cactus @xmath1420 , we define a graph @xmath1421 by @xmath1422 , @xmath1423 , and each @xmath1424 connects @xmath1425 and @xmath1426 .
( here @xmath1425 and @xmath1426 are considered as vertices of @xmath1421 . )
[ lem : dual_bw_tree ] @xmath1421 is a tree .
it is easy to see that @xmath1421 is connected .
therefore , it is enough to show that @xmath1427 .
it is obvious that @xmath1428 . on the other hand , definition [ 141121_1 ] ( ii ) , ( iii )
imply @xmath1429 .
therefore , we obtain @xmath1430 .
we call @xmath1421 the _ dual tree _ of the decorated cactus @xmath1420 .
[ cor : ci_is_cycle ] for any @xmath1431 and @xmath1432 , if @xmath1433 , then @xmath1434 .
let @xmath1435 .
then , both @xmath346 and @xmath1436 connect @xmath882 and @xmath1413 in @xmath1421 .
( here @xmath882 and @xmath1413 are considered as vertices of @xmath1421 . )
since @xmath1421 is a tree , we obtain @xmath1434 .
the figure below shows an example of a decorated cactus .
this is an element in @xmath1437 , and let us denote it by @xmath1438 . for each @xmath1439
, @xmath1413 is a boundary of the region @xmath743 .
notice that there are @xmath1440 vertices on @xmath1413 for each @xmath1439 .
the elements of @xmath1347 are depicted as the eight segments . in particular , @xmath1402 is depicted as the arrow .
the configuration of cycles @xmath1441 is tree - like ( this holds in general by lemma [ lem : dual_bw_tree ] ) , which is often called a `` cactus '' ( see @xcite , @xcite ) .
additionally , there are @xmath1440 vertices on each cycle @xmath1413 , and @xmath829 tails ( hence the name `` decorated '' cactus ) .
the tail @xmath1411 corresponds to the `` global zero '' of a cactus ( see @xcite section 2.2.6 ) . in most papers ,
a cactus is a tree - like configuration of _ parametrized _ circles . on the other hand ,
cycles @xmath1442 of our decorated cactus are _ not _ parametrized . in the next subsection , we introduce a notion of a _ framing _ on a decorated cactus , which corresponds to a parametrization of a circle .
the next lemma would be clear from geometric intuitions , however we give a detailed proof .
[ lem:140916_1 ] let @xmath1431 and @xmath1443 . for each @xmath1444
, let @xmath1445
. then , @xmath1446 with respect to the cyclic order on @xmath1447 .
it is enough to prove the following claim : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ suppose that @xmath1448 and @xmath128 satisfy @xmath1449 and @xmath1450 for any @xmath1451
. then , @xmath1452 .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ let @xmath1453 . since @xmath1432 , by corollary [ cor : ci_is_cycle ] , it is enough to show that @xmath1454 .
for any @xmath1455 , let @xmath1456 .
then , @xmath1457 , and @xmath1458 therefore , we have to show @xmath1459 .
since this is obvious for @xmath1460 , we may assume that @xmath1461 .
let @xmath1421 be the dual tree of @xmath1335 . for each @xmath1451
, let us take @xmath278 so that @xmath1462
. then , @xmath1463 , and @xmath1464 .
therefore , if @xmath1465 , then @xmath1466 is a path on @xmath1421 .
if @xmath1467 , then @xmath1468 is a tail , since @xmath1469 .
therefore , @xmath1470 . in conclusion , there exists a path from @xmath1471 to @xmath1472 on @xmath1421 , which is disjoint from @xmath1413 . on the other hand , since @xmath1473 and @xmath1474 , @xmath1475 is a path on @xmath1421 . since @xmath1421 is a tree ,
we conclude that @xmath1459 .
a _ framing _ on a decorated cactus @xmath1420 is a map @xmath1476 , such that @xmath1477 for every @xmath1431 .
a tuple @xmath1478 is called a _ framed decorated cactus_. an isomorphism of framed decorated cacti is an isomorphism of decorated cacti which preserves framing . for any @xmath1416 , @xmath1479 denotes the set of isomorphism classes of framed decorated cacti @xmath1480 such that @xmath1481 \in \lambda(k : l_1 , \ldots , l_r)$ ] .
let @xmath1420 be a decorated cactus , and @xmath1421 be its dual tree .
there exists a unique framing @xmath1476 such that , for every @xmath1431 , @xmath1482 is on the shortest path of @xmath1421 connecting @xmath1413 and @xmath1483 ( here @xmath1482 is considered as an edge of @xmath1421 , and @xmath1413 , @xmath1483 are considered as vertices of @xmath1421 ) .
we call it the _ canonical framing_. by considering canonical framings , we define an injective map @xmath1484 . in the rest of this paper
, we consider @xmath1417 as a subset of @xmath1479 .
when we draw a figure of a framed decorated cactus @xmath1478 , we draw an arrow pointing at a vertex @xmath1485 for each @xmath1431 . for any @xmath1486 and @xmath1487 , we set @xmath1488 , where @xmath1489 for every @xmath1431 .
then , a map @xmath1490 is a bijection , and there holds @xmath1491 for any @xmath1492 . as a restriction of this map , we obtain a bijection @xmath1493 . here
we present examples of framed decorated cacti . for any decorated cactus @xmath1494 , we denote @xmath1329 , @xmath1328 etc . as @xmath1495 , @xmath1496 etc .
moreover , @xmath1497 are denoted as @xmath1498 , and @xmath1411 is denoted as @xmath1499 . for any @xmath265 , @xmath1500 consists of a unique element , which we denote by @xmath1501 .
more explicitly , @xmath1501 is defined as follows : * @xmath1502 , @xmath1503 . * for any @xmath129 , @xmath1504 * @xmath1505 , @xmath1506 .
@xmath1507 ( left ) and @xmath1508 ( right ) for any @xmath265 , there exists a unique element @xmath1509 , such that @xmath1510 is a bijection .
more explicitly , @xmath1511 is defined as follows : * @xmath1512 , @xmath1513 . * for any @xmath1514 , we define @xmath1515 * @xmath1516 , @xmath1517 .
* @xmath1518 .
@xmath1519 ( left ) and @xmath1520 ( right ) for any @xmath128 , let us consider a noncanonical framing @xmath1521 on @xmath1511 so that @xmath1522 .
we obtain an element in @xmath1523 , which we denote by @xmath959 .
@xmath1524 ( left ) and @xmath1525 ( right ) finally , for any @xmath1526 and @xmath951 , we define @xmath1527 . in general , for any @xmath1528 where @xmath1529 , @xmath1530 consists of a unique vertex ( consider its dual tree ) , which we denote by @xmath1531 .
let us consider the following condition : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ( @xmath143 ) : @xmath1532 , and @xmath1533 is a bijection .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ for any @xmath557 , @xmath1534 has exactly @xmath1535 elements which satisfy ( @xmath143 ) , depending on choices of @xmath1536 . in particular , for every @xmath1537 , there exists a unique element @xmath1538 which satisfies ( @xmath143 ) , @xmath1539 and @xmath1540 .
we denote this element as @xmath1541 .
@xmath1542 ( left ) and @xmath1543 ( right ) for any @xmath1544 and @xmath1431 , we define a composition map @xmath1545 namely , given @xmath1546 we define @xmath1547 .
we first define a ribbon graph @xmath1548 as follows : * @xmath1549 .
* for every @xmath1550 , let @xmath1551 , and insert a new flag @xmath1314 at @xmath1552 as in the figure below .
+ precisely , we define @xmath1553 * for every @xmath1550 , we define @xmath1554 ( the set of tails of @xmath1555 ) so that @xmath1556 and @xmath1557 with respect to the cyclic order on @xmath1558 .
we `` glue '' @xmath1559 and @xmath1314 for every @xmath1550 .
precisely , we define @xmath1560 this completes the definition of @xmath1548 . for every @xmath1550 , we define @xmath1561 by @xmath1562 .
we define a new ribbon graph @xmath1563 by removing flags in @xmath1564 , and contracting edges @xmath1565 : @xmath1566 there is a natural bijection @xmath1567 .
let us identify the lhs and the rhs via this bijection .
[ lem:150119_1 ] 1 . for any @xmath1568 , @xmath1425 is a cycle of @xmath1563 .
2 . for any @xmath1569
, @xmath1570 is a cycle of @xmath1563 .
@xmath1571 is a cycle of @xmath1563 .
\(i ) holds since @xmath1572 for any @xmath1573 .
( ii ) holds since @xmath1574 for any @xmath1575 .
( iii ) is a consequence of lemma [ lem:140916_1 ] . by lemma [ lem:150119_1 ]
, we obtain @xmath1576 .
in particular , @xmath1577 . on the other hand , there holds @xmath1578 then , we obtain @xmath1579 .
moreover , @xmath1580 for any @xmath1581 . also , @xmath1582 . in conclusion
, @xmath1583 is a decorated cactus .
finally , we define a framing @xmath1584 by @xmath1585 now we define @xmath1586 to be the resulting framed decorated cactus .
this completes the definition of compositions of framed decorated cacti .
[ lem:150119_2 ] 1 . for any @xmath1587
, there holds @xmath1588 .
2 . for any @xmath1589 and @xmath1587 , @xmath1590 , @xmath1591 , there holds @xmath1592 .
3 . for any @xmath1593 , @xmath1594 and @xmath1587 , @xmath1590 , @xmath1595 , there holds @xmath1596 .
if @xmath1597 and @xmath1598 , then @xmath1599 ( ii ) , ( iii ) are consequences of lemma [ lem : removing_contracting ] .
( i ) , ( iv ) are easy to verify , and proofs are omitted .
we end this section with a few more examples of decorated cacti . for any @xmath128 and @xmath129
, we define @xmath1600 by @xmath1601 @xmath1602 ( left ) , @xmath1603 ( middle ) and @xmath1604 ( right ) for any @xmath265 and @xmath129 , we define @xmath1605 by @xmath1606 @xmath1607 ( left ) and @xmath1608 ( right ) for any @xmath557 , we define @xmath1609 by @xmath1610 @xmath1611 ( left ) and @xmath1612 ( right )
section 9.1 is devoted to some preliminaries on colored operads . in section 9.2
, we show that the collection of framed decorated cacti has a natural structure of a @xmath1400-colored operad , and we give a presentation of this colored operad by generators and relations ( lemma [ 20141204_5 ] ) .
let @xmath620 be any set , and @xmath21 be any symmmetric monoidal category .
a @xmath620-colored operad in @xmath21 , which we denote by @xmath24 , consists of the following data : * @xmath1613 for any @xmath1614 and @xmath1615 . * a morphism @xmath1616 for any @xmath1617 , which we call a unit . * for any @xmath106 , @xmath1618 and @xmath1619 , a composition morphism @xmath1620 * for any @xmath1614 , @xmath1615 and @xmath1486 , a morphism @xmath1621 we require that @xmath1622 , and @xmath1623 .
we require that each @xmath1624 is a two - sided unit for composition morphisms , and there holds the associativity and equivariance properties , which are defined in the obvious ways .
notions of morphisms and suboperads for @xmath620-colored operads are also defined in the obvious ways .
colored operads in the category of dg ( resp . graded )
vector spaces are called dg ( resp .
graded ) @xmath620-colored operads .
let @xmath1625 be a family of dg vector spaces .
setting @xmath1626 @xmath1627 has the natural structure of a dg @xmath620-colored operad . for any dg @xmath620-colored operad @xmath24 ,
a dg @xmath24-algebra consists of @xmath1625 and a morphism @xmath55 of dg @xmath620-colored operads .
we obtain the following chain map for any @xmath1615 : @xmath1628 for any dg @xmath24-algebras @xmath38 and @xmath47 , a morphism @xmath1629 of dg @xmath24-algebras is a family of chain maps @xmath1630 such that @xmath1631 for any @xmath1632 and @xmath1633 .
[ 20141219_3 ] let @xmath1634 be a family of sets .
there exists a unique ( up to isomorphism ) @xmath620-colored operad @xmath1635 of sets , which satisfies the following conditions : * for any @xmath1615 , there exists a map @xmath1636 * let @xmath24 be any @xmath620-colored operad of sets , such that for any @xmath1615 , a map @xmath1637 is given
. then , there exists a unique morphism of @xmath620-colored operads @xmath1638 , such that @xmath1639 .
we call @xmath1635 the free @xmath620-colored operad generated by @xmath335 .
uniqueness is obvious .
existence is proved by an explicit construction using planar trees with all edges colored by @xmath620 .
the construction is standard ( see e.g. @xcite ) and omitted .
let @xmath24 be a @xmath620-colored operad of sets .
a binary relation on @xmath24 is a family @xmath1640 , where each @xmath1641 is a binary relation on @xmath1642 .
if @xmath1641 is an equivalence relation for any @xmath1643 , and there holds @xmath1644 for any @xmath1645 , @xmath1646 , @xmath1647 and @xmath1648 , @xmath1649 is called an equivalence relation on @xmath24 . for any equivalence relation @xmath1649 on @xmath24 , @xmath1650 has a natural @xmath620-colored operad structure .
let @xmath1634 be a family of sets , and @xmath1651 be a binary relation on the free @xmath1652-colored operad @xmath1635 .
let @xmath1653 denote the equivalence relation on @xmath1635 generated by @xmath1649 ( i.e. the minimal equivalence relation which contains @xmath1649 ) .
then , we define @xmath1654 .
let us denote @xmath1655 we can rephrase lemma [ lem:150119_2 ] as follows .
( compatibility between symmetric group actions and composition maps is not verified there , however this is obvious . )
[ 140917_2 ] @xmath1656 is a @xmath1400-colored operad with the composition maps and symmetric group actions defined in section 8 , and unit elements are @xmath1657 .
@xmath1658 is its suboperad .
the aim of this subsection is to give explicit presentations of @xmath1658 and @xmath1656 by generators and relations . for any @xmath1416 ,
let us define @xmath1659 it is easy to check the following relations : @xmath1660 @xmath1661 @xmath1662 @xmath1663 @xmath1664 @xmath1665 @xmath1666 let us define @xmath1400-colored operads @xmath1667 , @xmath1668 , @xmath1669 by generators and relations : @xmath1670 there exist natural morphisms of @xmath1400-colored operads @xmath1671 and @xmath1672 [ 20141204_5 ] @xmath1673 , @xmath1674 are isomorphisms of @xmath1400-colored operads .
the proof consists of six steps .
* step 1 . * for any decorated cactus @xmath1675 , let @xmath1676 denote the number of @xmath1366 which satisfies neither of the following conditions : * @xmath1677 and @xmath1678 .
* @xmath1679 and @xmath1680 . by induction on @xmath1263
, we can show that @xmath1681 if and only if @xmath438 is in the image of @xmath1682 .
* step 2*. for any @xmath1683 , there exist integers @xmath1684 and @xmath1685 , such that @xmath1686 and @xmath1687 since @xmath1688 is in the image of @xmath1689 , @xmath438 is in the image of @xmath1673 .
therefore , @xmath1673 is surjective .
the above presentation of @xmath438 is unique in the following sense : for any integers @xmath1690 and @xmath1691 such that @xmath1692 and @xmath1693 there exists @xmath1694 such that @xmath1695 is the identity , @xmath1696 , and @xmath1697 for every @xmath1698 .
* step 3*. for any @xmath1699 , using relations ( [ eq:20141204_1 ] ) and ( [ eq:20141204_2 ] ) , it is possible to obtain a presentation @xmath1700 where @xmath1701 , and @xmath1486 .
this presentation is uniquely determined by @xmath1702 .
therefore , @xmath1682 is injective . since @xmath1689 factors through @xmath1703 ,
this map is also injective .
thus , we can consider @xmath1667 as a suboperad of @xmath1668 . * step 4*. for any @xmath1704 , there exist integers @xmath1705 and @xmath1706 such that @xmath1707 let @xmath1708 denote the minimal possible value of @xmath4 .
it is easy to see that @xmath1709 .
we show that in fact @xmath1710 .
suppose that @xmath1711 .
then , either ( a ) or ( b ) holds : 1 .
there exists @xmath1712 such that @xmath1713 .
2 . there exist @xmath1714 such that @xmath1715 , where @xmath1716 , @xmath1717 are cycles on @xmath1718 . in case ( a ) , one can use ( [ eq:20141204_3 ] ) to decrease @xmath4 by @xmath89 . in case ( b ) , by replacing @xmath1719 with @xmath1720 for some @xmath1721 if necessary , we may assume that @xmath1722 , @xmath1723 and @xmath1724 , where @xmath1725 and @xmath1726 . since @xmath1727 and @xmath1689 is injective ( step 3 ) , we get @xmath1728
. then , @xmath1729 where the second equality follows from ( [ eq:20141204_4 ] ) .
hence we can decrease @xmath4 by @xmath89 .
therefore , we have shown that @xmath1730 .
* step 5*. suppose @xmath1731 satisfy @xmath1732 .
let us set @xmath1733 . by step 4 , there exist integers @xmath1734 , @xmath1735 and @xmath1736 , such that @xmath1737 by step 2 , there exists @xmath1721 , such that @xmath1695 is the identity , @xmath1738 , and @xmath1739 for every @xmath1740 . since @xmath1689 is injective ( step 3 ) , @xmath1741 .
hence @xmath1742 , thus @xmath1673 is injective .
since we already proved that @xmath1673 is surjective ( step 2 ) , we have proved that @xmath1673 is an isomorphism .
* step 6*. finally , we show that @xmath1743 is an isomorphism . for any @xmath1744 , there exist @xmath1745 and integers @xmath1746 , such that @xmath1747 and @xmath1748 .
moreover , @xmath1749 , @xmath1746 are uniquely determined by @xmath438 . then , surjectivity of @xmath1674 immediately follows from surjectivity of @xmath1673 . on the other hand , using relations ( [ eq:20141206_1 ] ) , ( [ eq:20141206_2 ] ) , ( [ eq:20141206_3 ] ) , we can show the following : for any @xmath1750 , there exist @xmath1751 and integers @xmath1746 , such that @xmath1752 , and @xmath1753 .
since @xmath1754 and @xmath1746 are uniquely determined by @xmath1755 , injectivity of @xmath1674 follows from injectivity of @xmath1673 . for any set @xmath335 , let @xmath1756
$ ] denote the @xmath10-vector space freely generated by @xmath335 , i.e. @xmath1756:= \bigoplus_{s \in s } \r s$ ] .
for any @xmath620-colored operad of sets @xmath1757 , we define a @xmath620-colored graded operad @xmath1756 $ ] by @xmath1758(k : l_1 , \ldots , l_r)_*:= \begin{cases } \r[s(k : l_1,\ldots , l_r ) ] & ( * = 0 ) \\ 0 & ( * \ne 0 ) \end{cases}\ ] ] with the natural composition maps and symmetric group actions .
we call dg @xmath1756$]-algebras simply as dg @xmath335-algebras .
the next corollary is an immediate consequence of lemma [ 20141204_5 ] .
[ 150702_1 ] let @xmath1759 be a sequence of dg vector spaces .
* the following structures on @xmath957 are equivalent : * * a structure of a nonsymmetric dg operad with a multiplication @xmath969 and a unit @xmath972 . * * a structure of a dg @xmath1658-algebra .
+ the correspondence is given by the following formulas : @xmath1760 * the following structures on @xmath957 are equivalent : * * a structure of a cyclic nonsymmetric dg operad with a multiplication @xmath969 and a unit @xmath972 , such that @xmath774 is cyclically invariant .
* * a structure of a dg @xmath1656-algebra .
+ the correspondence is given by the formulas in ( i ) and @xmath1761 .
[ 150801_4 ] by corollary [ 150702_1 ] ( ii ) , @xmath1762 has a dg @xmath1656-algebra structure . for any @xmath1763 ,
let @xmath1764 .
then , it is easy to see that @xmath1765 using this fact and the definition of the dg @xmath1242-algebra structure on @xmath1236 ( see the next section ) , we conclude that the dg @xmath1242-algebra structure on @xmath9 preserves the length filtration , as we claimed in proposition [ 141005_2 ] ( ii ) .
in this section , we define dg operads @xmath12 and @xmath13 , and reduce theorem [ 150624_8 ] to theorem [ 150702_2 ] and lemma [ 150703_2 ] , which we prove in the next section . for any integer @xmath1614 , we define graded vector spaces @xmath1766 and @xmath1767 by @xmath1768 , \quad \tilde{\lambda}(r)_*:= \prod_{\substack { k , l_1 , \ldots , l_r
\in \z_{\ge 0 } \\ l_1 + \cdots + l_r -k = * } } \r[\lambda(k : l_1 , \ldots , l_r)].\ ] ] obviously , @xmath1769 . for any @xmath1770 , we denote its @xmath1771-component by @xmath1772 . as is clear from the definition , the graded vector space @xmath1773 is unbounded .
in fact , @xmath1774 for every @xmath1775 . when @xmath103 , @xmath1776 for every @xmath1777 . we show that @xmath1778 has a natural dg operad structure , and @xmath1779 is its suboperad .
* composition map : * for any @xmath106 and @xmath1618 , we define a degree @xmath122 linear map @xmath1780 by @xmath1781 where @xmath1782 .
* associativity : * for any @xmath1770 , @xmath1783 and @xmath1784 , there holds @xmath1785 this follows from associativity of composition maps on @xmath1656 and sign computations . *
unit : * we define @xmath1786 $ ] by @xmath1787 .
then , for any @xmath1770 , there holds @xmath1788 and @xmath1789 for any @xmath1431 . *
differential : * for any integer @xmath128 , let us define @xmath1790 $ ] by @xmath1791 .
then , @xmath1792 for any @xmath128 .
we define @xmath1793 $ ] by @xmath1794 .
then , @xmath1795 . we define a differential @xmath1796 by @xmath1797 by associativity of composition maps , it is easy to check @xmath1798 and the leibniz rule @xmath1799 * symmetric group actions : * for any @xmath1614 , we define a linear map @xmath1800 \to f\tilde{\lambda}(r ) _ * ; \ , x \otimes \sigma \mapsto x^\sigma$ ] by @xmath1801 by direct computations on signs , we can check that this is a chain map , and compatible with composition maps .
* suboperad @xmath13 : * since @xmath1658 is a suboperad of @xmath1656 , it follows that @xmath13 is a suboperad of @xmath12 .
we show that for any dg @xmath1658 ( resp .
@xmath1656 ) algebra @xmath957 , the total complex @xmath1236 has the dg @xmath13 ( resp .
@xmath12 ) algebra structure .
[ 20141221_1 ] 1 .
let @xmath1802 be a dg @xmath1658 ( resp .
@xmath1656 ) algebra .
then , @xmath1803 has the natural dg @xmath13 ( resp .
@xmath12 ) algebra structure .
2 . let @xmath1804 be a morphism of dg @xmath1658 ( resp .
@xmath1656 ) algebras .
then , @xmath1805 is a morphism of dg @xmath13 ( resp .
@xmath12)-algebras .
let @xmath1806 be a dg @xmath1807-algebra .
then , for any @xmath1808 , we have a chain map @xmath1809(k : l_1 , \ldots , l_r ) \otimes { { \mathcal{o}}}(l_1 ) \otimes \cdots \otimes { { \mathcal{o}}}(l_r ) \to { { \mathcal{o}}}(k ) ; x \otimes y_1 \otimes \cdots \otimes y_r \mapsto x \cdot ( y_1 \otimes \cdots \otimes y_r).\ ] ] for every @xmath1614 , we define @xmath1810 by @xmath1811 notice that the rhs of the first formula is a finite sum .
direct computations show that this is a dg @xmath18-algebra structure on @xmath1236 .
thus we have verified lemma [ 20141221_1 ] ( i ) for @xmath1658 .
( ii ) is straightforward from the construction .
the case for @xmath1656 is completely parallel , and omitted .
let us define @xmath1812 , @xmath1813 , @xmath1814 by the following formulas : @xmath1815 let us define operators @xmath84 , @xmath1247 and @xmath99 on @xmath1236 by @xmath1816 now , theorem [ 150624_8 ] follows from the next two results , which are proved in the next section .
[ 150703_2 ] 1 .
@xmath879 satisfies @xmath1817 and @xmath1818 .
in particular , @xmath84 defines a dga algebra structure on @xmath1236 .
@xmath1819 satisfies @xmath1820 and @xmath1821 , @xmath1822 . in particular , @xmath141 defines a dg lie algebra structure on @xmath1236 .
@xmath1823 satisfies @xmath1824 . in particular
, @xmath99 is an anti - chain map on @xmath1236 .
[ 150702_2 ] there exist isomorphisms @xmath214 and @xmath213 , compatible with the inclusion maps .
moreover , @xmath1825 \in h_0(\tilde{\lambda}(2))$ ] , @xmath1826 \in h_1(\tilde{\lambda}(2))$ ] , @xmath1827 \in h_1(f\tilde{\lambda}(1))$ ] correspond to @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath95 via these isomorphisms .
the goal of this section is to prove theorem [ 150702_2 ] .
in the course of the proof , we also verify lemma [ 150703_2 ] ( see remark [ 150703_3 ] ) . here
we explain an outline of our proof assuming lemmas [ lem : q ] , [ 141022_1 ] , [ 141103_1 ] . for any @xmath1614 and @xmath265 , we define @xmath1828.\ ] ] obviously @xmath1829 , and @xmath1830 is a subcomplex of @xmath1766 for any @xmath265 .
we denote the quotient @xmath1831 by @xmath1832 .
@xmath1833 and @xmath1834 are defined in the same way .
let us consider quotient maps @xmath1835 our first step is to prove the following lemma in section 11.1 .
[ 141022_1 ] @xmath1840 has a dg operad structure , such that @xmath1841 is its suboperad .
there exists a morphism of dg operads @xmath1842 , such that @xmath1843 and @xmath1844 .
in particular , @xmath264 and @xmath1845 are quasi - isomorphisms of dg operads .
since @xmath1837 is surjective , it is enough to show that @xmath1850 is acyclic . for each integer @xmath265
, we denote the differential on @xmath1834 by @xmath1851 . in other words ,
let us define an anti - chain map @xmath1853 by @xmath1854 .
then , the chain complex @xmath1855 is identified with @xmath1856 , where the differential is @xmath1857 .
now , let us assume the following lemma .
* @xmath1859 is a chain ( resp .
anti - chain ) map , if @xmath182 is even ( resp .
* for every @xmath182 , @xmath1859 induces an isomorphism on homology . * for every @xmath182 , there holds @xmath1860 , where @xmath1861 . by lemma [ lem : jk ] , the sequence @xmath1163 & h_*(\tilde{\lambda}_1(r ) )
\ar[r]_-{h_*(d_1 ) } & h_{*-1}(\tilde{\lambda}_2(r ) ) \ar[r]_-{h_*(d_2)}&h_{*-2}(\tilde{\lambda}_3(r ) ) \ar[r]_-{h_*(d_3 ) } & \cdots } \ ] ] is exact .
hence , lemma [ 150629_1 ] shows that @xmath1862 is acyclic .
therefore , it is enough to prove lemma [ lem : jk ] .
the proof consists of four steps .
we define @xmath1858 by @xmath1869 .
( briefly speaking , @xmath1859 removes all tails other than @xmath1411 . )
then , there holds @xmath1870 hence , @xmath1859 is a chain ( resp
. anti - chain ) map if @xmath182 is even ( resp .
odd ) . on the other hand , since @xmath1871 , there holds @xmath1860 .
* step 2 . * to show that @xmath1859 induces an isomorphism on homology , we define a filtration on the chain complex @xmath1872 . for any @xmath1873
, we define positive integers @xmath1874 so that @xmath1875 . for every @xmath1876 , we define @xmath1877.\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath1878 is a subcomplex of @xmath1834 for every @xmath29 , and we obtain a filtration @xmath1879 . since @xmath1880 is a bijection , @xmath1881 is an isomorphism .
therefore , to show that @xmath1859 is a quasi - isomorphism , it is enough to show that @xmath1882 is acyclic for every @xmath1883 .
* step 4 . *
we define a degree @xmath89 linear map @xmath620 on @xmath1889 .
let @xmath1890 . then @xmath1891 for @xmath1892 , and @xmath1893 .
let @xmath1894 .
then , @xmath1895 since @xmath1896 .
let us take @xmath1897 so that @xmath1898 , and define @xmath1899 as follows : @xmath1900 * let us define an order on @xmath1922 by @xmath1924 , and denote the corresponding order on @xmath78 as @xmath1921 .
* let us define an order on @xmath1925 by * * when @xmath1448 , @xmath1926 and @xmath1927 , then @xmath1928 .
* * on each @xmath1413 , @xmath1929 .
+ let us denote the corresponding order on @xmath78 as @xmath1920 .
* @xmath264 is a chain map .
namely , for any @xmath1937 , there holds @xmath1938 * for any @xmath1939 , @xmath106 and @xmath1940 , there holds @xmath1941 . * for any @xmath1939 and @xmath1486 , there holds @xmath1942 . for
any @xmath106 and @xmath1618 , let us define a composition map on @xmath1840 by @xmath1943 by the above assertions , @xmath1840 is a dg operad with these composition maps ( unit is @xmath1519 ) , and @xmath1944 is a morphism of dg operads . as is obvious from definitions , @xmath1945 is the identity on @xmath1840 , and @xmath1843 .
this completes the proof of lemma [ 141022_1 ] .
let @xmath1946 .
@xmath1366 is called a _ free vertex _ , if @xmath1947 , and @xmath1948 for any @xmath1431 .
we call @xmath438 _ degenerate _ , if there exists a free vertex in @xmath1329
. let @xmath1949 denote the set of degenerate elements in @xmath1950 .
we also set ( @xmath1951 stands for nondegenerate ) : @xmath1952 since @xmath1953 is nondegenerate , there holds @xmath1954 for every @xmath1614 , let us define @xmath1955 , \qquad \tilde{\lambda}^\deg_0(r)_*:= \prod_{l_1 + \cdots + l_r= * } \r[\lambda^\deg(0 : l_1 , \ldots , l_r)].\ ] ] notice that @xmath1956 .
it is easy to see that , @xmath1957 and @xmath1958 are dg ideals of @xmath1840 and @xmath1841 , respectively . for any @xmath103 and @xmath1959 , let @xmath1960 denote the framed decorated cactus obtained by removing all free vertices of @xmath438
let @xmath1961 denote the number of edges of @xmath1962 .
it is easy to see that @xmath1963 for any @xmath1959 , and @xmath1964 for any @xmath1965 .
the lemma is obvious for @xmath1909 , thus we may assume @xmath103 .
we prove the lemma only for @xmath1967 , since the proof for @xmath1966 is similar . for @xmath1968 ,
let @xmath1969 be the subspace of @xmath1967 , which is generated by @xmath1970 such that @xmath1971 .
it is easy to see that this is a subcomplex of @xmath1967 , and we obtain @xmath1972 to prove that @xmath1967 is acyclic , it is sufficient to show that @xmath1973 is acyclic for every @xmath1968 . for any @xmath1974 such that @xmath1975 , let @xmath1976 denote the subcomplex of @xmath1973 , which is generated by @xmath1977 .
it is easy to see that @xmath1976 is acyclic for every @xmath1978 .
therefore , @xmath1979 is also acyclic . since @xmath1980 and @xmath1981 are dg ideals of @xmath1840 and @xmath1841 , the quotients @xmath1982 and @xmath1983 are dg operads . as graded vector spaces , @xmath1984 , \qquad \tilde{\lambda}^\nondeg_0(r)_*= \prod_{l_1 + \cdots + l_r= * } \r[\lambda^\nondeg(0 : l_1 , \ldots , l_r)].\ ] ] by lemma [ 141103_3 ] , the morphisms of dg operads @xmath1985 and @xmath1986 are quasi - isomorphisms .
on the other hand , one can define morphisms of graded operads @xmath1987 and @xmath1988 by @xmath1989 , \quad a \mapsto [ \alpha_{0,0 } ] , \quad b \mapsto -[\beta_{1,1,0 } + \beta_{1,1,0}^{(12 ) } ] , \quad \delta \mapsto [ \sigma_{0,0 } \circ_1 \tau_1].\ ] ] the relevant relations are checked by direct computations .
now , lemma [ 141103_1 ] is reduced to the following lemma .
it seems that the dg operad @xmath1992 ( resp .
@xmath1993 ) is isomorphic ( up to sign ) to the dg operad @xmath1994 ( resp .
@xmath1995 ) , which is introduced in @xcite ( resp .
these dg operads are defined by cw - decompositions of the cacti and spineless cacti operads . in papers
@xcite , @xcite , @xcite , it is proved that these operads are chain models for the ( framed ) little disks operad , therefore their homology are isomorphic to the gerstenhaber and bv operads .
lemma [ 141103_2 ] may follow from these results , however we give a direct proof in the next subsection .
in this subsection , we abbreviate @xmath1996 and @xmath1997 by @xmath1998 and @xmath1999 for simplicity . for every integer @xmath103 , we define a chain complex @xmath2000 by @xmath2001 and differential is zero .
we define a chain map @xmath2002 by @xmath2003 where @xmath2004 is defined as @xmath2005 it is easy to see that @xmath2016 for every @xmath29 .
thus , @xmath2006 induces a map on quotients @xmath2017 to show that @xmath2006 is a quasi - isomorphism , it is enough to show that ( [ 150120_1 ] ) is a quasi - isomorphism for every @xmath29 .
@xmath2018 is generated by @xmath2019 .
on the other hand , @xmath2020 , where @xmath1976 is generated by @xmath2021 .
( [ 150120_1 ] ) maps @xmath2022 \otimes \gamma^r_*$ ] to @xmath1976 , and it is easy to see that this is a quasi - isomorphism for every @xmath1978
. therefore , ( [ 150120_1 ] ) is a quasi - isomorphism . by induction on @xmath1263
, we show that @xmath2023 is an isomorphism .
this is directly checked for @xmath2024 .
suppose that @xmath2025 is an isomorphism for some @xmath103 .
by lemma [ 141225_1 ] , @xmath2026 is surjective , and @xmath2027 . on the other hand , @xmath2028 for any @xmath657 ( see @xcite and @xcite )
. therefore @xmath2029 .
thus , @xmath2026 is an isomorphism .
this completes the proof that @xmath1990 is an isomorphism .
finally , we show that @xmath1991 is an isomorphism . for every @xmath103
, @xmath2030 is an isomorphism , since a map between topological spaces @xmath2031 is a homotopy equivalence . on the other hand , the next lemma holds . for any @xmath2033 ,
let @xmath1901 denote the decorated cactus obtained by forgetting the framing of @xmath438 .
for every integer @xmath29 , let @xmath2034 denote the subspace of @xmath1999 , which is generated by @xmath2035 .
this is a subcomplex of @xmath1999 .
we set @xmath2036 .
we need to show that @xmath2040 is an isomorphism .
this is directly checked for @xmath2024 .
since @xmath2041 is an isomorphism , the isomorphism ( [ 141226_1 ] ) and lemma [ 141226_2 ] imply that @xmath2042 is an isomorphism for every @xmath103 . c. berger , i. moerdijk , _ resolution of coloured operads and rectification of homotopy algebras _ , categories in algebra , geometry and mathematical physics , 3158 , contemp .
, 431 , amer .
soc . , providence , ri , 2007 .
k. cieliebak , j. latschev , _ the role of string topology in symplectic field theory _ , new perspectives and challenges in symplectic field theory , 113146 , crm proc .
lecture notes , 49 , amer .
soc . , providence , ri , 2009 .
r. l. cohen , v. godin , _ a polarized view of string topology _ , topology , geometry and quantum field theory , 127154 , london math .
lecture note ser .
308 , cambridge univ .
press , cambridge , 2004 .
k. fukaya , _ application of floer homology of lagrangian submanifolds to symplectic topology _ ,
morse theoretic methods in nonlinear analysis and in symplectic topology , 231276 , nato sci . ser .
, 217 , springer , dordrecht , 2006 .
|
the aim of this paper is to define a chain level refinement of the batalin - vilkovisky ( bv ) algebra structure on homology of the free loop space of a closed @xmath0-manifold .
namely , we propose a new chain model of the free loop space , and define an action of a certain chain model of the framed little disks operad on it , recovering the original bv structure on homology level .
we also compare this structure to a solution of deligne s conjecture for hochschild cochain complexes of differential graded algebras . to define the chain model of the loop space , we introduce a notion of de rham chains , which is a hybrid of singular chains and differential forms .
|
there is evidence for the existence of supermassive black holes ( smbhs ) over a range of epochs ; smbhs with masses @xmath3 m@xmath1 are ubiquitous in local galactic bulges ( e.g. magorrian et al .
1998 : ferrarese 2002 ) , while the smbhs powering quasars [ which have been detected at redshifts as high as @xmath4 ( fan et al . 2001 ; fan et al . 2003 ) ] are estimated to range between @xmath5 m@xmath1 ( see e.g. shields et al .
evidence for the early assembly of smbhs , when interpreted within a hierarchical cosmology , suggests that smbh coalescence may be a frequent event . if this is the case , the gravitational waves ( gws ) generated during smbh coalescence are a prime candidate for detection by the _ laser interferometer space antennae _
( lisa , folkner et al . 1998 ;
flanagan & hughes 1998 ; hughes et al .
2001 ) .
estimates of the smbh coalescence rate depend crucially on the occupation fraction of smbhs in halos , and therefore on the adopted model for the formation and growth of smbhs . within a hierarchical cdm cosmology , both seeded smbh formation models [ in which a primordial population of smbhs grow via accretion and/or merging ( eg . volonteri et al . 2003 ) ] and ongoing formation models [ where smbhs form jointly with bulges in halos ( eg .
kauffmann & haehnelt 2000 ) ] are consistent with the present - day ubiquity of smbhs in galactic bulges ( menou et al .
2001 ) .
the formation of a smbh may be limited to potential wells above a minimum depth .
if so , then there exists a critical halo virial temperature ( @xmath6 ) below which a halo can not host smbh formation .
if @xmath6 is low ( eg . @xmath7 k ) , then smbhs are abundant in small halos , and predicted event rates are in the order of 100 s per year ( wyithe & loeb 2003 ; haehnelt 2004 ) .
this event rate may be significantly lower , less than one per year , if @xmath8 k and smbhs form only at the centres of massive galaxies ( haehnelt 2004 ) .
hence the detection rate has the potential to constrain the global smbh population [ with the important caveat of the unknown efficiency of binary black hole ( bbh ) coalescence , see [ snr ] ] .
the rate of coalescence detectable by lisa depends on the form of the gw signal and the instrument s sensitivity curve .
previous estimates of the event rate have used characteristic ( rather than time - dependent ) gw signals to determine approximate detection limits ( wyithe & loeb 2003 ) or have estimated the number of detectable events by comparing the sensitivity curve with the total gravitational wave background due to coalescing bbhs ( sesana et al .
recently sesana et al .
( 2004b ) estimated the expected event rate for a detailed physical model for smbh growth .
we perform the first empirically motivated calculations for the lisa detection rate of smbh mergers in a hierarchical cosmology that use accurate signal to noise ratios ( snrs ) to determine detection criteria . in [ snr ]
we describe the calculation of snrs for the lisa detection of bbh coalescence . in [ merger ] we discuss our calculation of the smbh merger rate , including our halo merger rate predictions , estimate for the occupation fraction of smbhs in halos and the @xmath9@xmath10 relationship . finally , we present our event rate predictions as a function of @xmath6 ( [ merger ] ) before concluding in [ concl ] . throughout this work
we assume @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 km s@xmath15 mpc@xmath16 km s@xmath15 mpc@xmath15 , @xmath17 and a primordial power spectrum with slope @xmath18 as determined by the _ wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe _ ( wmap , spergel et al .
the efficiency with which bbhs coalesce is highly uncertain .
initially , the smbhs sink independently toward the centre of a merged system due to dynamical friction from the dark matter background until they form a bound binary ( begelman , blandford & rees 1980 ) .
the efficiency of this process depends on the orbital parameters of the merging dark matter halos ( van den bosch et al .
1999 ; colpi , mayer & governato 1999 ) .
as the orbital separation ( @xmath19 ) decreases , 3-body interactions with stars that pass within @xmath20 of the bbh centre of mass ( the `` loss cone '' ) increasingly dominate the energy loss .
depending on the orbital parameters of the binary and the background distribution of stars , this process may result in a hardened [ orbital velocity ( @xmath21 ) @xmath22 stellar velocity dispersion ( @xmath23 ) ] binary system . if hardening continues until a binary separation where energy losses are dominated by gws , the binary will coalesce .
yu ( 2002 ) argues that the efficiency of bbh coalescence hinges on the time - scale for bbh hardening during the hard binary phase . during this stage ,
three - body interactions between the bbh and individual stars eject stars into highly elliptical orbits , lowering the inner stellar density and slowing further hardening ( eg .
volonteri et al .
the deceleration of the hardening rate is compounded by the preferential depletion of stars within the loss cone ( region of parameter space where angular momentum is low enough that stars pass near the bbh ) , resulting in a deficiency of stars that can extract energy from the binary system ( see yu 2002 ) .
uncertainties in the efficiency of processes which may replenish loss cone stars make this effect difficult to analyse .
two - body stellar relaxation is expected to result in some diffusion of stars back into the loss cone ( binney & tremaine 1987 ) but it is unclear that this process alone can support sufficient hardening .
numerical n - body simulations have been used to include the effect of the bbh wander within the star field ( due to 3-body interactions with stars ) , which increases the effective size of the loss cone and may prevent the coalescence from stalling ( quinlan & hernquist 1997 ; milosavljevi ' c & merritt 2001 ; chatterjee , hernquist & loeb 2003 ) .
other scenarios which may aid evolution of the bbh into the gw dominated regime have been proposed , including the effects of gaseous disks ( gould & rix 2000 ) , flattened or triaxial stellar distributions ( yu 2002 ) and disruption by a third smbh ( hut & rees 1992 ) .
the efficiency of bbh coalescence is of prime concern for lisa detection rates . whilst undoubtably still an open question , we note that there are plausible mechanisms to extract the required energy from the binary system . for the purposes of our calculation ( [ merger ] )
we therefore assume that hardening of the binary to the gw dominated regime occurs with an efficiency ( @xmath24 ) of unity .
all event rates quoted in this paper are proportional to @xmath24 .
the gravitational wave dominated portion of bbh coalescence may be divided into three main phases ( hughes 2002 ) .
the binary begins in the _ inspiral phase _ , with the smbhs slowly spiralling into tighter orbits due to the adiabatic loss of gw energy .
eventually the dynamics become relativistically unstable and the smbhs violently plunge to form a single object ( _ merger phase _ ) .
the final gw signal can be described by modelling the merged system as a perturbed kerr smbh ( _ ringdown phase _ ) .
the dynamics of the inspiral and ringdown phases are well understood and theoretical waveforms for the gws have been derived . however , certain parameters of the ringdown solution depend on unknown details of the merger phase and must be guided by the results of numerical simulation ( see [ ringdown ] ) .
detection of gws from a single binary source will be complicated by the presence of galactic and extra - galactic gw foregrounds , and by lisa s sensitivity to gws from all sky directions .
matched filter template searches will therefore be necessary to detect the gw signal from an individual event ( hughes et al . 2001 ) .
the snr for a matched filter detection ( @xmath25 ) is defined by the ratio of the coherently folded signal and noise powers : @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the fourier transform of the dimensionless strain and @xmath28 is the spectral power of the noise .
we calculate snrs for the final year ( before the merger phase ) of the inspiral signal .
the effective duration of the ringdown phase is much shorter than one year and we therefore calculate ringdown snrs over the entire phase .
estimates of lisa s noise spectrum are evolving with plans for the instrument design . a recently suggested sensitivity goal ( bender 2003 )
has a ( dimensionless ) threshold sensitivity [ defined as @xmath29 , for @xmath30 and 1 yr of observation ] with a low frequency power - law slope of @xmath31 for frequencies ranging between @xmath32 and @xmath33 hz , and a power - law slope of @xmath34 for frequencies of @xmath35 to @xmath32 hz .
bender ( 2003 ) suggests a hard low frequency cut off at @xmath36 hz , roughly corresponding to the lowest resolvable frequency for a year long mission .
lisa will be sensitive to frequencies up to @xmath37 hz . as a general rule @xmath38
is required for the confident detection of a signal ( hughes et al .
2001 ) . as the orbital separation of the binary shrinks , both the amplitude and frequency of the inspiralling strain increase . to calculate accurate inspiral phase snrs ,
it is important to include the frequency dependence of the strain in the integration of signal to noise .
we achieve this using the technique outlined by flanagan & hughes ( 1998 , henceforth fh98 ) .
fh98 show that sky averaged squared snr ( @xmath39 can be re - expressed in terms of the emitted gw energy spectrum @xmath40 @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the frequency of the gw .
this is related to the observed gw frequency ( @xmath43 ) via the cosmological redshift of the source [ @xmath44 .
the inspiral energy spectrum may be easily calculated to first order from the quadrupole approximation for the gravitational wave luminosity ( fh98 ) @xmath45 where @xmath9 and @xmath46 are the individual bbh masses corresponding to a reduced mass @xmath47 and total mass @xmath48 .
numerical simulations of bbh coalescence indicate that this approximation is reasonable until @xmath43 reaches @xmath49 hz ( fh98 ) which roughly corresponds to the observed frequency when equal mass bbhs have an orbital separation of 3 schwarzchild radii ( @xmath50 ) .
this frequency forms the upper limit of integration in equation ( [ en_spec_snr ] ) .
since the gw frequency of bbh coalescence typically increases with time , this frequency may be used to delineate the inspiral and merger phases .
the observed gw frequency of the inspiral signal at an observed time @xmath51 prior to the merger phase is given by ( fh98 ) @xmath52^{5/3 } t^{\prime}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] depending on the binary characteristics , @xmath53 may lie below the lisa waveband .
we therefore use the greater of @xmath54 and @xmath55 as the lower limit of integration in equation ( [ en_spec_snr ] ) .
we use the technique described by hughes ( 2002 ) to calculate snrs for the ringdown phase .
bbh coalescence is expected to result in a rotating smbh with a bar - like excitation of the event horizon ( hughes 2002 ) .
this distortion of the kerr solution may be modelled by the bar - like [ @xmath56 quasi - normal mode ( kokkotas & schmidt 1999 ) . the corresponding time dependent strain is described by an exponentially damped sinusoid with total ( observed ) amplitude ( @xmath57 ) whose value depends on the fraction of the bbh mass - energy ( @xmath58 ) radiated during the ringdown phase ( @xmath59 ) , the binary mass , and the spin parameter of the merger product ( @xmath60 ) .
the amplitude is @xmath61 ^2,\ ] ] where @xmath62 is the comoving distance to a source at redshift @xmath63 .
the quality factor ( @xmath64 ) is related to the damp - time of the gw signal ( @xmath65 ) by @xmath66 .
the final factor in equation ( [ amp ] ) accounts for the reduced signal amplitude for unequal mass bbh coalescence ( fh98 ) .
numerical simulations suggest that @xmath67 ( baker 2001 ; fh98 and references therein ) .
we adopt @xmath68 . assuming that the distribution of the strain between polarisations ( @xmath69 ) mimics that of the inspiral phase , the dependence of @xmath70 and @xmath71 on the orientation of the system s angular momentum ( @xmath72 ) and sky position [ @xmath73 is given by ( fryer , holtz & hughes 2002 ) @xmath74 where @xmath75;\\ \nonumber \mathcal{a}_{\times}&=&-2 \mathcal{a}_{\rm rd}(\hat{l}.\hat{n}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath76 is the observed ringdown gw frequency and @xmath77 is the initial phase .
leaver ( 1985 ) , echeverria ( 1989 ) and fryer holtz & hughes ( 2002 ) have produced fitting formulae for @xmath78 and @xmath64 in terms of @xmath79 and @xmath60 : @xmath80,\ ] ] @xmath81 which are accurate to @xmath82 per cent .
hughes & blandford ( 2003 ) note that the value of @xmath60 will depend on the role that smbh merging plays in smbh evolution .
we follow hughes ( 2002 ) and adopt @xmath83 .
the observed strain [ @xmath84 is the sum of the strain in each polarisation weighted by the corresponding detector response functions [ @xmath85 ; thorne 1987 ] for a source with polarisation axes rotated by an angle @xmath86 to @xmath87 @xmath88 for @xmath89 , the quality factor is large and most of the energy radiated during the ringdown phase is observed at the central ringdown frequency ( @xmath90 ) . in this limit the snr may be approximated by ( hughes 2002 ) @xmath91 for comparison with the sky averaged inspiral snr we average the snr in equation ( [ ring_snr ] ) over randomly generated sets of @xmath92 .
more massive bbh systems radiate gws at lower frequencies and for a given binary system the ringdown signal is at a higher frequency [ see equations ( [ f_oneyr ] ) & ( [ rd_fits1 ] ) ]
. therefore if the sensitivity curve has a low frequency cut off and/or degrades rapidly with frequency , searches for the ringdown signal will probe more massive bbhs .
we find that ringdown searches can detect coalescence between bhs with masses up to @xmath93 m@xmath1 ( @xmath94 m@xmath1 ) at @xmath95 ( @xmath96 ) . in the left hand panel of figure [ snr_results ]
we plot the snr for the inspiral ( _ dot - dashed line _ ) and ringdown ( _ solid line _ ) phases of equal mass , @xmath95 bbh coalescence as a function of single bh mass .
the right hand panel shows the ratio of ringdown to inspiral snrs , with the hatched region denoting the mass range over which the ringdown signal is detectable .
the snr is greater in the ringdown signal for @xmath97 m@xmath1 .
we note that there exists a range of smbh masses ( @xmath98 m@xmath1 at @xmath99 ) for which bbh coalescence is detectable only in the ringdown phase .
since characteristic frequencies decay with @xmath100 , this mass range decreases with redshift .
by @xmath101 , the mass range is comparable to the typical smbh mass observed in the local universe ( @xmath102 m@xmath1 ) .
these results are consistent with the calculations of fh98 and reinforce the point that searches for gravitational radiation from the ringdown phase may generate constraints on the high mass smbh population .
the higher frequency of the ringdown signal from smbh binaries offers limited advantage for their detection if the low frequency sensitivity has a power - law slope of @xmath103 and no lower cut - off ( corresponding to the optimal scenario of constant accelerometer dominated noise , see white 2002 ) .
however , it is expected that frequency dependent sources of spurious acceleration will result in a steeper low - frequency sensitivity curve ( bender 2003 ) .
in addition to the instrumental noise , unresolved gws from various classes of binary systems are expected to limit lisa s sensitivity ( see sesana et al .
however , sesana et al .
( 2004b ) calculate that bbh coalescence only dominates the sky noise below a frequency of @xmath104 hz , and this noise is still an order of magnitude lower than the suggested lisa sensitivity .
therefore the unresolved bbh background should not significantly affect lisa s sensitivity to supermassive bbh coalescence .
estimates of the merger rate of dark matter halos are provided by the extended press - schechter ( 1974 ) formalism ( lacey & cole 1993 ) .
we denote the merger rate per halo of mass @xmath105 per unit time with halos of mass between @xmath106 and @xmath107 by @xmath108 .
the local ( all - sky ) detection rate of smbh mergers ( @xmath109 ) occurring in the redshift interval ( @xmath110 ) may be estimated ( e.g. wyithe & loeb 2003 ) by integrating the halo merger rate ( @xmath111 ) over the press - schechter dark matter halo mass function ( @xmath112 ) as below : @xmath113 where @xmath114 is the comoving volume per unit solid angle between @xmath63 and @xmath115 and the factor @xmath116 accounts for time - dilation .
the product of the halo smbh occupation fractions [ @xmath117 relates the expected smbh merger rate to the halo merger rate .
equation ( [ event_rate ] ) has the following additional features .
we assume an observationally motivated dependence of smbh mass on host halo mass [ @xmath118 , see [ mbh_reln ] ] .
the merger rate @xmath109 is weighted by the probability for detection of the central smbh coalescence , denoted @xmath119 , where the detection @xmath120 is determined through calculation of the snr @xmath121 we exclude halo mergers where the accreted satellite halo takes longer than the hubble time to sink to the centre of the merged system , since the bbh will not have time to form .
this is achieved by limiting the merger rate contribution to halo pairs with mass ratios smaller than 3 ( colpi , mayer & governato 1999 ) .
we assume efficient coalescence of smbh binaries in halo mergers , making our prediction of the coalescence rate a maximum .
the merger rate scales with the fraction of bbhs that evolve into the gw dominated regime ( @xmath24 ) .
we further assume coalescence to be rapid .
this last assumption may affect the redshift distribution of our expected counts ( although this effect may be small , see sesana et al .
2004a ) , but should have little effect on estimates of the total event rate .
shields et al .
( 2003 ) investigated the evolution of the relationship between @xmath9 and the velocity dispersion of the host bulge ( @xmath124 ) out to @xmath125 using a sample of radio - quiet agn .
they found no evidence for variation from the locally determined relationship ( ferrarese & merritt 2000 ; gebhardt 2000 ) @xmath126 ferrarese ( 2002 ) found that the velocity dispersion of the local galactic bulges correlates with the circular velocity in the flat region of the halos rotation curve @xmath127 , indicating that @xmath128 . assuming that there is no evolution in the @xmath124@xmath129 relation , and relating @xmath129 to the virial velocity of a virialised halo of mass @xmath105 @xmath130^{1/6 } \\ &
\times & \left ( \frac{1+z}{10 } \right)^{1/2}{\rm kms}^{-1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ where @xmath131 , @xmath132 and @xmath133 is the overdensity of a virialised halo at redshift @xmath63 ] we can determine the redshift dependent @xmath9@xmath10 relationship ( normalised to the local relationship from ferrarese 2002 ) @xmath135^{5/2}.\ ] ] the @xmath9@xmath10 relationship has been established locally for halo masses in the range @xmath136 ( ferrarese 2002 ) .
fits to gravitational lens separation distributions [ porciani & madau 2000 ; kochanek & white 2001 hereafter kw2001 ] and simple models for baryon cooling ( cole et al .
2000 ; kw2001 ) indicate that halos with @xmath137 m@xmath1 tend to form groups and clusters of galaxies
. this will suppress the number of very massive smbhs relative to the number of massive dark matter halos .
in addition , limitations on accretion from the igm , and feedback from massive galactic winds are expected to suppress starformation in small mass halos ( see barkana & loeb 2001 and references therein ) , and may also inhibit smbh formation .
in the following section , we construct an observationally motivated smbh occupation fraction ( @xmath138 ) that empirically accounts for these effects . a model which assumes that all dark - matter halos contain smbhs ( e.g. wyithe & loeb 2003 ) may substantially overestimate the smbh coalescence rate .
here we assume that all galaxies residing in halos with virial temperatures larger than a critical value host a central smbh [ with mass determined by the @xmath9@xmath10 relationship , equation ( [ mbh - mhalo ] ) ] .
we construct the galaxy occupation fraction of dark - matter halos at @xmath139 by comparing the observed velocity distribution of local galaxies with a velocity function that is generated from the press - schechter mass - function , and which assumes a relationship between cooled baryonic and virial velocities ( see [ gal_vel ] ) .
motivated by the absence of evolution in the observed correlation between @xmath9 and the velocity dispersion of the host bulge , we assume that the fraction of halos of mass ( @xmath105 ) and redshift ( @xmath63 ) that host a central smbh is determined by @xmath140 independently of redshift [ ie . @xmath141 .
measurements of the circular velocities of galaxies reflect the dynamics of the stars in the inner region of the halo where the density profile differs significantly from the profile predicted by navarro , frenk & white ( nfw , 1997 ) for cdm .
simple galaxy formation models consider the effect of adiabatic cooling of baryons on the radial density and velocity profiles of galaxies but neglect heating due to starformation .
adiabatic cooling and condensation of the halo s baryonic component into a rotationally supported disk steepens the inner density profile , resulting in a higher maximal circular velocity ( @xmath142 ) than implied by the initial profile ( dalcanton , spergel & summers 1997 ; mo , mao & white 1998 ; gonzalez et al .
2000 ; kw2001 ) . to model the cooled halo density profile , mo et al .
( 1998 ) assume that the baryonic and dark matter components are initially uniformly mixed in an nfw density profile with concentration parameter @xmath143 , spin parameter @xmath77 and specific angular momentum @xmath144 .
the peak circular velocity of the modified density profile may be determined by self - consistently solving ( with angular momentum and energy conservation ) for the scale factor of the exponential disk . for a disk with specific angular momentum equal to that of the original halo ,
the cooled velocity is related to the virial velocity by ( mo et al .
1998 ) @xmath145 numerical n - body simulations of hierarchical structure formation suggest the average halo spin to be roughly independent of halo mass and equal to about @xmath146 ( bullock et al .
furthermore , the concentration parameter of the nfw profile may be related to the halo virial mass @xmath147 ( at @xmath139 ) by @xmath148 ( bullock et al .
we assume the fraction of halo mass in the cooled disk to be @xmath149 , independent of halo mass .
the cooled baryon fraction is thought to be smaller in more massive halos ( see kw2001 ) , however we find that allowing @xmath150 to vary over halo mass as suggested by the cooling model of kw2001 has little effect on the profile of the adiabatically cooled velocity function .
the halo cooled velocity function may then be computed from the psmf through the change of variable @xmath151 for a cooled baryon fraction ( @xmath150 ) that is independent of mass , this prescription results in a @xmath152 dependence of cooled velocity on halo mass for @xmath153 m@xmath154 m@xmath1 .
consequently , the net effect of this adiabatic cooling model is to translate ( and re - scale ) the press - schechter distribution of halo virial velocities . to construct our occupation fraction we assume that there is one circular velocity for which galaxies have an occupation fraction of unity .
we then find the ( linear ) relationship between cooled and virial velocity that enforces this condition .
we have adopted the observational galaxy velocity function used by kw2001 for this purpose .
kw2001 provide data down to @xmath155 km s@xmath15 . below this
we extrapolate with a single power law @xmath156 with @xmath157 ( appropriate for a luminosity function with faint - end slope @xmath158 ) .
this process returns a halo cooled velocity ( @xmath142 ) which , at the peak of the occupation fraction , is consistent with the velocity derived using the prescription of mo et al . ( 1998 ) to within @xmath159 per cent .
moreover , our relationship is consistent with the ratio of @xmath160 measured from weak lensing studies ( seljak 2002 ) .
the resulting occupation fraction ( see figure [ fig2 ] ) peaks at @xmath161 km s@xmath15 ( @xmath162 km s@xmath15 ) .
this cooled velocity is also consistent with the circular velocity at which press - schechter and observed galaxy velocity functions agree in the works by gonzalez et al .
( 2000 ) and kw2001 .
van den bosch et al . ( 2002 ) provide another estimate of the dependence of galaxy formation efficiency on host halo mass via the average halo mass - to - light ratio .
this quantity may be estimated by constructing halo mass conditional luminosity functions using the relationship between ( luminosity dependent ) observed galaxy - galaxy correlation lengths and mass - scale for a hierarchical cosmology ( see van den bosch et al .
their calculation yields a minimum mass - to - light ratio ( indicative of maximum galaxy formation efficiency ) for dark matter halos with @xmath163 m@xmath1 , which is comparable to the peak in @xmath164 at @xmath165 m@xmath1 .
the occupation fraction decays rapidly for cooled velocities larger than @xmath166 km s@xmath15 .
we note that errors in @xmath138 at high @xmath140 will not effect our predicted event rates due to the exponential tail of the psmf .
indeed wyithe & loeb ( 2003 ) found that imposing a sharp cut - off to @xmath138 at a virial velocity of @xmath167 km s@xmath15 had little impact on their predictions .
prior to the reionisation of the igm , halos required a virial temperature larger than @xmath168 k for the accreted gas to cool via atomic hydrogen transitions within a hubble time .
after reionisation of the igm , the higher igm temperature inhibited the accretion of gas into halos with virial temperatures lower than @xmath169 k. these virial temperatures specify the minimum mass of a halo inside of which a smbh may form ( e.g. barkana & loeb 2001 ) @xmath170 ^{-1.5}\\ \times \left [ \frac{\omega_m}{\omega_m^z}\frac{\delta_c}{18\pi^2}\right ] ^{-1/2}\left ( \frac{1+z}{10 } \right)^{-3/2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] equivalently , a minimum virial temperature specifies a minimum depth for the potential well ( or velocity , or mass ) of a halo in which a smbh can exist .
given the @xmath9@xmath10 relationship , equation ( [ mvir ] ) implies a minimum smbh mass ( @xmath171 ) which is independent of redshift . for @xmath172
k ( @xmath173 k ) this minimum smbh mass corresponds to @xmath174 m@xmath1 ( @xmath175 m@xmath1 ) . in contrast , the locally detected population of smbhs reside in more massive halos with virial temperatures greater than @xmath176 k , although this lower limit may be partially attributable to the difficulties in obtaining dynamical evidence for bhs with @xmath177 ( e.g. kormendy & richstone 1995 ) .
the predicted event rates are plotted in figure [ fig3 ] as a function of the minimum virial temperature ( lower axis ) and minimum smbh mass ( upper axis ) .
the event rates per year decline with increasing @xmath6 . for @xmath178
k ( @xmath179 m@xmath180 we predict @xmath181 detections per year in each of the ringdown and inspiral phases .
these predictions are significantly below those of wyithe & loeb ( 2003 ) , with the discrepancy due to our inclusion of the smbh occupation fraction in the merger rate .
our smbh occupation fraction and accurate detection criteria result in predictions that decay more rapidly with increasing @xmath6 than previous calculations suggested .
smbhs powering luminous quasars at @xmath182 weigh @xmath183 m@xmath1 .
if @xmath184 m@xmath185 the predicted event - rates are very low ; falling below @xmath186 yr@xmath15 for each phase .
hence lisa will not detect coalescence from the major merges of bright quasar hosts .
however , there is evidence for smbhs as small as @xmath0 m@xmath1 in local galactic bulges ( ferrarese 2002 ) and low - luminosity , low - redshift agn ( greene & ho 2004 ) .
a reasonable estimate for the minimum smbh mass is therefore @xmath187 m@xmath1 , which corresponds to predictions of @xmath188 events per year in each phase .
figure [ fig4 ] shows the redshift distribution of events as a function of the minimum virial temperature .
most of the events originate at @xmath189 due to mergers between halos more massive than @xmath190 m@xmath1 .
sesana et al .
( 2004a&b ) make predictions for the detection rate of inspiral phase bbh coalescence for a seeded smbh formation model ; estimating @xmath191 `` bursts '' in 3 years of observation due to events at @xmath192 .
this calculation employs a specific model for the formation and evolution of bbhs embedded in an isothermal stellar distribution .
sesana et al .
( 2004a ) use the seeded smbh growth model of volonteri et al .
( 2003 ) in which ( large ) stellar mass bhs form in @xmath193 peaks at @xmath194 and grow via accretion and coalescence during major halo mergers . while we also rely on the merger rate of dark matter halos for the basis of our coalescence rate ,
our calculation differs by employing empirically motivated estimates for the population of smbhs in halos .
we do not assume the physics leading to the absence of galaxies ( and by extension smbhs ) in large and small halos , however we have shown that the inclusion of the occupation fraction significantly affects the coalescence rate .
we have assumed an efficient coalescence of smbh binaries , while sesana et al .
( 2004a ) specify a detailed model for binary evolution that results in some binaries being ejected from the galaxy core ( where they do not coalesce ) .
we estimate an upper limit for the rate of supermassive bbh coalescence ( where both binary members weigh more than @xmath195 m@xmath1 ) of @xmath196 yr@xmath15 , which is larger than , but comparable to , the @xmath197 yr@xmath15 estimated by sesana et al .
2004a&b for binary coalescence with one member heavier than @xmath195 m@xmath1 .
if intermediate mass black holes exist , then our estimate for the detectable coalescence rate increases only modestly [ due to the declining occupation fraction for lower mass halos ( see figure [ fig2 ] ) ] to @xmath22 tens per year ( see figure [ fig3 ] ) .
we have computed the snr of both the inspiral and ringdown phases of smbh coalescence , and calculated mass and redshift ranges over which bbh coalescence will be detectable by lisa .
the higher frequency of the ringdown signal allows detection of the coalescence of more massive binary systems .
in particular , searches for gravitational waves for the ringdown signal offer a superior probe of bbh coalescence between smbhs which are more massive than @xmath198 m@xmath1 , and allow confident detection of the coalescence of smbhs in the mass range @xmath98 m@xmath1 at @xmath95 should they exist ( or @xmath199 m@xmath1 at @xmath96 ) .
we have predicted the rate of binary black hole coalescence detectable by lisa assuming a hierarchical cosmology in which black holes form in halos with virial temperature above a critical value and obey an observationally motivated scaling with halo mass and redshift of the form @xmath200 .
prompted by the observation that the numbers of both large and small galaxies fall short of the expected numbers of dark - matter halos , we compute the empirical galaxy occupation fraction .
this is obtained by comparing the locally observed galaxy velocity function with a cooled press - schechter ( 1974 ) velocity function .
our predicted event rate declines rapidly with increased estimates for the smallest smbh that can form .
if we are guided by the smallest nuclear bh mass inferred in local galactic bulges and nearby low - luminosity agn ( @xmath201 m@xmath1 ) , then we expect @xmath188 detections per year
. most of these events will be detectable via both their final - year inspiral and ringdown signals .
our observationally motivated estimates for the event rate of bbh coalescence therefore indicate that observations of coalescing bbhs are a realistic target for lisa .
the authors wish to thank rachel webster , andrew melatos and avi loeb for helpful discussions during the course of this work .
sesana , a. , haardt , f. , madau , p. , & volonteri , m. 2004b , apj , accepted ( astro - ph/0409255 ) shields , g. a. , gebhardt , k. , salviander , s. , wills , b. j. , xie , b. , brotherton , m. s. , yuan , j. , & dietrich , m. 2003 , apj , 583 , 124
|
the gravitational waves generated during supermassive black hole ( smbh ) coalescence are prime candidates for detection by the satellite lisa .
we use the extended press - schechter formalism combined with empirically motivated estimates for the smbh dark matter halo mass relation and smbh occupation fraction to estimate the maximum coalescence rate for major smbh mergers . assuming efficient binary coalescence , and guided by the lowest nuclear black hole mass inferred in local galactic bulges and nearby low - luminosity active galactic nuclei ( @xmath0 m@xmath1 ) we predict approximately 15 detections per year at a signal to noise greater than five , in each of the inspiral and ringdown phases .
rare coalescences between smbhs having masses in excess of @xmath2 m@xmath1 will be more readily detected via gravitational waves from the ringdown phase .
[ firstpage ] black hole physics , cosmology : theory , gravitational waves
|
connectivity and network design problems play an important role in combinatorial optimization and algorithms both for their theoretical appeal and their many real - world applications . an interesting and large class of problems are of the following type : given a graph @xmath5 with edge or node costs , find a minimum - cost subgraph @xmath6 of @xmath2 that satisfies certain connectivity properties .
for example , given an integer @xmath7 , one can ask for the minimum - cost spanning subgraph that is @xmath8-edge or @xmath8-vertex connected . if @xmath9 then this is the classical minimum spanning tree ( mst ) problem .
for @xmath10 the problem is np - hard and also apx - hard to approximate .
more general versions of connectivity problems are obtained if one seeks a subgraph in which a subset of the nodes @xmath11 referred to as _ terminals _ are @xmath8-connected .
the well - known steiner tree problem is to find a minimum - cost subgraph that ( @xmath12-)connects a given set @xmath13 .
many of these problems are special cases of the survivable network design problem ( sndp ) . in sndp
, each pair of nodes @xmath14 specifies a connectivity requirement @xmath15 and the goal is to find a minimum - cost subgraph that has @xmath15 disjoint paths for each pair @xmath16 .
given the intractability of these connectivity problems , there has been a large amount of work on approximation algorithms .
a number of elegant and powerful techniques and results have been developed over the years ( see @xcite ) .
in particular , the primal - dual method @xcite and iterated rounding @xcite have led to some remarkable results including a @xmath1-approximation for edge - connectivity sndp @xcite .
an interesting class of problems , related to some of the connectivity problems described above , is obtained by requiring that only @xmath0 of the given terminals be connected .
these problems are partly motivated by applications in which one seeks to maximize profit given a upper bound ( budget ) on the cost .
for example , a useful problem in vehicle routing applications is to find a path that maximizes the number of vertices in it subject to a budget @xmath17 on the length of the path . in the exact optimization setting ,
the profit maximization problem is equivalent to the problem of minimizing the cost / length of a path subject to the constraint that at least @xmath0 vertices are included . of course the two versions need not be approximation equivalent , nevertheless , understanding one is often fruitful or necessary to understand the other .
the most well - studied of these problems is the @xmath0-mst problem ; the goal here is to find a minimum - cost subgraph of the given graph @xmath2 that contains at least @xmath0 vertices ( or terminals ) .
this problem has attracted considerable attention in the approximation algorithms literature and its study has led to several new algorithmic ideas and applications @xcite .
we note that the steiner tree problem can be relatively easily reduced in an approximation preserving fashion to the @xmath0-mst problem .
more recently , lau _ et al . _
@xcite considered the natural generalization of @xmath0-mst to higher connectivity .
in particular they defined the @xmath18-subgraph problem to be the following : find a minimum - cost subgraph of the given graph @xmath2 that contains at least @xmath0 vertices and is @xmath8-edge connected .
we use the notation @xmath0-@xmath8ec to refer to this problem . in @xcite
an @xmath19 approximation was claimed for the @xmath0-@xmath1ec problem .
however , the algorithm and proof in @xcite are incorrect .
more recently , and in independent work from ours , the authors of @xcite obtained a different algorithm for @xmath0-@xmath1ec that yields an @xmath20 approximation .
we give later a more detailed comparison between their approach and ours .
it is also shown in @xcite that a good approximation for @xmath0-@xmath8ec when @xmath8 is large would yield an improved algorithm for the @xmath0-densest subgraph problem @xcite ; in this problem one seeks a @xmath0-vertex subgraph of a given graph @xmath2 that has the maximum number of edges .
the @xmath0-densest subgraph problem admits an @xmath21 approximation for some fixed constant @xmath22 @xcite , but has resisted attempts at an improved approximation for a number of years now .
in this paper we consider the vertex - connectivity generalization of the @xmath0-mst problem .
we define the @xmath0-@xmath8vc problem as follows : given an integer @xmath0 and a graph @xmath2 with edge costs , find the minimum - cost @xmath8-vertex - connected subgraph of @xmath2 that contains at least @xmath0 vertices .
we also consider the _ terminal _ version of the problem where the subgraph has to contain @xmath0 terminals from a given terminal set @xmath3 .
it can be easily shown that the @xmath0-@xmath8ec problem reduces to the @xmath0-@xmath8vc problem for any @xmath23 .
we also observe that the @xmath0-@xmath8ec problem with terminals can be easily reduced , as follows , to the uniform problem where every vertex is a terminal : for each terminal @xmath24 , create @xmath25 dummy vertices @xmath26 and attach @xmath27 to @xmath28 with @xmath8 parallel edges of zero cost . now set @xmath29 in the new graph .
one can avoid using parallel edges by creating a clique on @xmath26 using zero - cost edges and connecting @xmath8 of these vertices to @xmath28 .
note , however , that this reduction only works for edge - connectivity .
we are not aware of a reduction that reduces the @xmath0-@xmath8vc problem with a given set of terminals to the @xmath0-@xmath8vc problem , even when @xmath30 . in this paper
we consider the @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem ; our main result is the following .
[ thm : kv ] there is an @xmath31 approximation for the @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem where @xmath32 is the number of terminals .
[ cor : ke ] there is an @xmath31 approximation for the @xmath0-@xmath1ec problem where @xmath32 is the number of terminals .
one of the technical ingredients that we develop is the theorem below which may be of independent interest . given a graph @xmath2 with edge costs and weights on terminals @xmath3 , we define @xmath33 for a subgraph @xmath6 to be the ratio of the cost of edges in @xmath6 to the total weight of terminals in @xmath6 .
[ thm : cycle ]
let @xmath2 be an @xmath1-vertex - connected graph with edge costs and let @xmath34 be a set of terminals .
then , there is a simple cycle @xmath35 containing at least @xmath1 terminals ( a non - trivial cycle ) such that the density of @xmath35 is at most the density of @xmath2 .
moreover , such a cycle can be found in polynomial time . using the above theorem and an lp approach
we obtain the following .
[ cor : cycle ] given a graph @xmath5 with edge costs and @xmath32 terminals @xmath36 , there is an @xmath37 approximation for the problem of finding a minimum - density non - trivial cycle .
note that theorem [ thm : cycle ] and corollary [ cor : cycle ] are of interest because we seek a cycle with at least _ two _ terminals .
a minimum - density cycle containing only one terminal can be found by using the well - known min - mean cycle algorithm in directed graphs @xcite .
we remark , however , that although we suspect that the problem of finding a minimum - density non - trivial cycle is np - hard , we currently do not have a proof .
theorem [ thm : cycle ] shows that the problem is equivalent to the dens-@xmath1vc problem , defined in the next section .
* remark : * the reader may wonder whether @xmath0-@xmath1ec or @xmath0-@xmath1vc admit a constant factor approximation , since the @xmath0-mst problem admits one .
we note that the main technical tool which underlies @xmath38 approximations for @xmath0-mst problem @xcite is a special property that holds for a lp relaxation of the prize - collection steiner tree problem @xcite which is a lagrangian relaxation of the steiner tree problem .
such a property is not known to hold for generalizations of @xmath0-mst including @xmath0-@xmath1ec and @xmath0-@xmath1vc and the @xmath0-steiner forest problem @xcite .
thus , one is forced to rely on alternative and problem - specific techniques .
we consider the rooted version of @xmath0-@xmath1vc : the goal is to find a min - cost subgraph that @xmath1-connects at least @xmath0 terminals to a specified root vertex @xmath39 .
it is relatively straightforward to reduce @xmath0-@xmath1vc to its rooted version ( see section [ sec : k2vc ] for details . )
we draw inspiration from algorithmic ideas that led to poly - logarithmic approximations for the @xmath0-mst problem .
to describe our approach to the rooted @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem , we define a closely related problem . for a subgraph @xmath6 that contains @xmath39 ,
let @xmath40 be the number of terminals that are @xmath1-connected to @xmath39 in @xmath6 .
then the _ density _ of @xmath6 is simply the ratio of the cost of @xmath6 to @xmath40 .
the dens-@xmath1vc problem is to find a 2-connected subgraph of minimum density .
an @xmath37 approximation for the dens-@xmath1vc problem ( where @xmath32 is the number of terminals ) can be derived in a some what standard way by using a bucketing and scaling trick on a linear programming relaxation for the problem .
we exploit the known bound of @xmath1 on the integrality gap of a natural lp for the sndp problem with vertex connectivity requirements in @xmath41 @xcite .
the bucketing and scaling trick has seen several uses in the past and has recently been highlighted in several applications @xcite .
our algorithm for @xmath0-@xmath1vc uses a greedy approach at the high level .
we start with an empty subgraph @xmath42 and use the approximation algorithm for dens-@xmath1vc in an iterative fashion to greedily add terminals to @xmath42 until at least @xmath43 terminals are in @xmath42 .
this approach would yield an @xmath44 approximation if @xmath45 .
however , the last iteration of the dens-@xmath1vc algorithm may add many more terminals than desired with the result that @xmath46 . in this case
we can not bound the quality of the solution obtained by the algorithm . to overcome this problem
, one can try to _ prune _ the subgraph @xmath6 added in the last iteration to only have the desired number of terminals . for the @xmath0-mst problem , @xmath6 is a tree and pruning is quite easy .
we remark that this yields a rather straightforward @xmath20 approximation for @xmath0-mst and could have been discovered much before a more clever analysis given in @xcite .
one of our technical contributions is to give a pruning step for the @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem . to accomplish this , we use two algorithmic ideas .
the first is encapsulated in the cycle finding algorithm of theorem [ thm : cycle ] .
second , we use this cycle finding algorithm to repeatedly merge subgraphs until we get the desired number of terminals in one subgraph .
this latter step requires care .
the cycle merging scheme is inspired by a similar approach from the work of lau _ et al . _
@xcite on the @xmath0-@xmath1ec problem and in @xcite on the directed orienteering problem .
these ideas yield an @xmath47 approximation .
we give a slightly modified cycle - merging algorithm with a more sophisticated and non - trivial analysis to obtain an improved @xmath31 approximation .
some remarks are in order to compare our work to that of @xcite on the @xmath0-@xmath1ec problem . the combinatorial algorithm in @xcite
is based on finding a low - density cycle or a related structure called a bi - cycle .
the algorithm in @xcite to find such a structure is incorrect .
further , the cycles are contracted along the way which limits the approach to the @xmath0-@xmath1ec problem ( contracting a cycle in @xmath1-node - connected graph may make the resulting graph not @xmath1-node - connected ) . in our algorithm
we do not contract cycles and instead introduce dummy terminals with weights to capture the number of terminals in an already formed component .
this requires us to now address the minimum - density non - trivial simple cycle problem which we do via theorem [ thm : cycle ] and corollary [ cor : cycle ] . in independent work ,
lau _ et al . _
@xcite obtain a new and correct @xmath48-approximation for @xmath0-@xmath1ec .
they also follow the same approach that we do in using the lp for finding dense subgraphs followed by the pruning step .
however , in the pruning step they use a completely different approach ; they use the sophisticated idea of no - where zero @xmath49-flows @xcite .
although the use of this idea is elegant , the approach works only for the @xmath0-@xmath1ec problem , while our approach is less complex and leads to an algorithm for the more general @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem .
we work with graphs in which some vertices are designated as _
terminals_. given a graph @xmath2 with edge costs and terminal weights , we define the _ density _ of a subgraph @xmath6 to be sum of the costs of edges in @xmath6 divided by the sum of the weights of terminals in @xmath6 .
henceforth , we use @xmath1-connected graph to mean a @xmath1-vertex - connected graph .
the goal of the @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem is to find a minimum - cost 2-connected subgraph on at least @xmath0 terminals .. for simplicity of exposition , however , we stick to the more restricted version . ] recall that in the rooted @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem , the goal is to find a min - cost subgraph on at least @xmath0 terminals in which every terminal is 2-connected to the specified root @xmath39 .
the ( unrooted ) @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem can be reduced to the rooted version by _ guessing _ 2 vertices @xmath16 that are in an optimal solution , creating a new root vertex @xmath39 , and connecting it with 0-cost edges to @xmath50 and @xmath28 .
it is not hard to show that any solution to the rooted problem in the modified graph can be converted to a solution to the unrooted problem by adding 2 minimum - cost vertex - disjoint paths between @xmath50 and @xmath28 .
( since @xmath50 and @xmath28 are in the optimal solution , the cost of these added paths can not be more than @xmath51 . )
we omit further details from this extended abstract . in the dens-@xmath1vc problem ,
the goal is to find a subgraph @xmath6 of minimum density in which all terminals of @xmath6 are 2-connected to the root .
the following lemma is proved in section [ subsec : lp ] below .
it relies on a @xmath1-approximation , via a natural lp , for the min - cost @xmath1-connectivity problem due to fleischer , jain and williamson @xcite , and some standard techniques .
[ lem : densv ] there is an @xmath37-approximation algorithm for the dens-@xmath1vc problem , where @xmath32 is the number of terminals in the given instance .
let @xmath51 be the cost of an optimal solution to the @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem .
we assume knowledge of @xmath51 ; this can be dispensed with using standard methods .
we pre - process the graph by deleting any terminal that does not have 2 vertex - disjoint paths to the root @xmath39 of total cost at most @xmath51 . the high - level description of the algorithm for the rooted @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem is given below .
@xmath52 , @xmath53 is the empty graph .
+ while ( @xmath54 ) : + use the approximation algorithm for dens-@xmath1vc to find a subgraph @xmath6 in @xmath2 .
+ if ( @xmath55 ) : + @xmath56 , @xmath57 + mark all terminals in @xmath6 as non - terminals .
+ else : + _ prune _ @xmath6 to obtain @xmath58 that contains @xmath59 terminals .
+ @xmath60 , @xmath61 + output @xmath42 at the beginning of any iteration of the while loop , the graph contains a solution to the dens-@xmath1vc problem of density at most @xmath62 .
therefore , the graph @xmath6 returned always has density at most @xmath63 . if @xmath55 , we add @xmath6 to @xmath42 and decrement @xmath59
; we refer to this as the _ augmentation _ step .
otherwise , we have a graph @xmath6 of good density , but with too many terminals . in this case , we prune @xmath6 to find a graph with the required number of terminals ; this is the _
pruning step_. a simple set - cover type argument shows the following lemma : [ lem : greedy ] if , at every augmentation step , we add a graph of density at most @xmath64 ( where @xmath59 is the number of additional terminals that must be selected ) , the total cost of all the augmentation steps is at most @xmath65 .
therefore , we now only have to bound the cost of the graph @xmath58 added in the pruning step ; we prove the following theorem in section [ sec : pruning ] .
[ thm : avekv ] let @xmath66 be an instance of the rooted @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem with root @xmath39 , such that every vertex of @xmath2 has @xmath1 vertex - disjoint paths to @xmath39 of total cost at most @xmath67 , and such that @xmath68 .
there is a polynomial - time algorithm to find a solution to this instance of cost at most @xmath69 .
we can now prove our main result for the @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem , theorem [ thm : kv ] .
theorem [ thm : kv ] let @xmath51 be the cost of an optimal solution to the ( rooted ) @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem . by lemma [ lem : greedy ] , the total cost of the augmentation steps of our greedy algorithm is @xmath70 .
to bound the cost of the pruning step , let @xmath59 be the number of additional terminals that must be covered just prior to this step .
the algorithm for the dens-@xmath1vc problem returns a graph @xmath6 with @xmath71 terminals , and density at most @xmath72 . as a result of our pre - processing step ,
every vertex has 2 vertex - disjoint paths to @xmath39 of total cost at most @xmath51 .
now , we use theorem [ thm : avekv ] to prune @xmath6 and find a graph @xmath58 with @xmath59 terminals and cost at most @xmath73 . therefore , the total cost of our solution is @xmath74 .
it remains only to prove lemma [ lem : densv ] , that there is an @xmath75-approximation for the dens-@xmath1vc problem , and theorem [ thm : avekv ] , bounding the cost of the pruning step .
we prove the former in section [ subsec : lp ] below .
before the latter is proved in section [ sec : pruning ] , we develop some tools in section [ sec : cycles ] ; chief among these tools is theorem [ thm : cycle ] . recall that the dens-@xmath1vc problem was defined as follows : given a graph @xmath5 with edge - costs , a set @xmath76 of terminals , and a root @xmath77 , find a subgraph @xmath6 of minimum density , in which every terminal of @xmath6 is 2-connected to @xmath39 .
( here , the density of @xmath6 is defined as the cost of @xmath6 divided by the number of terminals it contains , not including @xmath39 . )
we describe an algorithm for dens-@xmath1vc that gives an @xmath37-approximation , and sketch its proof .
we use an lp based approach and a bucketing and scaling trick ( see @xcite for applications of this idea ) , and a constant - factor bound on the integrality gap of an lp for sndp with vertex - connectivity requirements in @xmath41 @xcite .
we define * lp - dens * as the following lp relaxation of dens-@xmath1vc . for each terminal @xmath78
, the variable @xmath79 indicates whether or not @xmath28 is chosen in the solution .
( by normalizing @xmath80 to 1 , and minimizing the sum of edge costs , we minimize the density .
) @xmath81 is the set of all simple cycles containing @xmath78 and the root @xmath39 ; for any @xmath82 , @xmath83 indicates how much ` flow ' is sent from @xmath28 to @xmath39 through @xmath35 .
( note that a pair of vertex - disjoint paths is a cycle ; the flow along a cycle is 1 if we can 2-connect @xmath78 to @xmath39 using the edges of the cycle . )
the variable @xmath84 indicates whether the edge @xmath85 is used by the solution .
@xmath86 @xmath87 it is not hard to see that an optimal solution to * lp - dens * has cost at most the density of an optimal solution to dens-@xmath1vc . we now show how to obtain an integral solution of density at most @xmath88 , where @xmath89 is the cost of an optimal solution to * lp - dens * .
the linear program * lp - dens * has an exponential number of variables but a polynomial number of non - trivial constraints ; it can , however , be solved in polynomial time .
fix an optimal solution to * lp - dens * of cost @xmath89 , and for each @xmath90 ( for ease of notation , assume @xmath91 is an integer ) , let @xmath92 be the set of terminals @xmath78 such that @xmath93 . since @xmath94 , there is some index @xmath95 such that @xmath96 .
since every terminal @xmath97 has @xmath98 , the number of terminals in @xmath92 is at least @xmath99 .
we claim that there is a subgraph @xmath6 of @xmath2 with cost at most @xmath100 , in which every terminal of @xmath92 is 2-connected to the root .
if this is true , the density of @xmath6 is at most @xmath101 , and hence we have an @xmath37-approximation for the dens-@xmath1vc problem . to prove our claim about the cost of the subgraph @xmath6 in which every terminal of @xmath92 is 2-connected to @xmath39 , consider scaling up the given optimum solution of * lp - dens * by a factor of @xmath102 . for each terminal @xmath103 ,
the flow from @xmath78 to @xmath39 in this scaled solution ] is at least 1 , and the cost of the scaled solution is @xmath104 . in @xcite , the authors describe a linear program @xmath105 to find a minimum - cost subgraph in which a given set of terminals is 2-connected to the root , and show that this linear program has an integrality gap of 2 .
the variables @xmath84 in the ` scaled solution ' to * lp - dens * correspond to a feasible solution of @xmath105 with @xmath92 as the set of terminals ; the integrality gap of 2 implies that there is a subgraph @xmath6 in which every terminal of @xmath92 is 2-connected to the root , with cost at most @xmath106 . therefore , the algorithm for dens-@xmath1vc is : 1 .
find an optimal fractional solution to * lp - dens * .
2 . find a set of terminals @xmath92 such that @xmath107 .
3 . find a min - cost subgraph @xmath6 in which every terminal in @xmath92 is 2-connected to @xmath39 using the algorithm of @xcite .
@xmath6 has density at most @xmath37 times the optimal solution to dens-@xmath1vc .
a cycle @xmath108 is _ non - trivial _ if it contains at least 2 terminals .
we define the min - density non - trivial cycle problem : given a graph @xmath5 , with @xmath3 marked as terminals , edge costs and terminal weights , find a minimum - density cycle that contains at least 2 terminals .
note that if we remove the requirement that the cycle be non - trivial ( that is , it contains at least 2 terminals ) , the problem reduces to the min - mean cycle problem in directed graphs , and can be solved exactly in polynomial time ( see @xcite ) .
algorithms for the min - density non - trivial cycle problem are a useful tool for solving the @xmath0-@xmath1vc and @xmath0-@xmath1ec problems . in this section ,
we give an @xmath75-approximation algorithm for the minimum - density non - trivial cycle problem .
first , we prove theorem [ thm : cycle ] , that a 2-connected graph with edge costs and terminal weights contains a simple non - trivial cycle , with density no more than the average density of the graph .
we give two algorithms to find such a cycle ; the first , described in section [ subsec : nonpoly ] , is simpler , but the running time is not polynomial . a more technical proof that leads to a strongly polynomial - time algorithm is described in section [ subsec : strong ] ; we recommend this proof be skipped on a first reading . to find a non - trivial cycle of density at most that of the 2-connected input graph @xmath2 , we will start with an arbitrary non - trivial cycle , and successively find cycles of better density until we obtain a cycle with density at most @xmath109 .
the following lemma shows that if a cycle @xmath35 has an ear with density less than @xmath110 , we can use this ear to find a cycle of lower density .
[ lem : goodear ] let @xmath35 be a non - trivial cycle , and @xmath6 an ear incident to @xmath35 at @xmath50 and @xmath28 , such that @xmath111 .
let @xmath112 and @xmath113 be the two internally disjoint paths between @xmath50 and @xmath28 in @xmath35
. then @xmath114 and @xmath115 are both simple cycles and one of these is non - trivial and has density less than @xmath110 .
@xmath35 has at least 2 terminals , so it has finite density ; @xmath6 must then have at least 1 terminal .
let @xmath116 , @xmath117 and @xmath118 be , respectively , the sum of the costs of the edges in @xmath112 , @xmath113 and @xmath6 , and let @xmath119 , @xmath120 and @xmath121 be the sum of the weights of the terminals in @xmath112 , @xmath113 and @xmath122 .
assume w.l.o.g .
that @xmath112 has density at most that of @xmath113 .
( that is , @xmath123 . ) and @xmath113 has cost 0 and weight 0 . in this case , let @xmath112 be the component with non - zero weight . ]
@xmath112 must contain at least one terminal , and so @xmath114 is a simple non - trivial cycle .
the statement @xmath124 is equivalent to @xmath125 . @xmath126 therefore , @xmath114 is a simple cycle containing at least 2 terminals of density less than @xmath110 .
[ lem:2conncomp ] given a cycle @xmath35 in a @xmath1-connected graph @xmath2 , let @xmath42 be the graph formed from @xmath2 by contracting @xmath35 to a single vertex @xmath28 .
if @xmath6 is a connected component of @xmath127 , @xmath128 is @xmath1-connected in @xmath42 .
let @xmath6 be an arbitrary connected component of @xmath127 , and let @xmath129 . to prove that @xmath58 is 2-connected
, we first observe that @xmath28 is 2-connected to any vertex @xmath130 .
( any set that separates @xmath131 from @xmath28 in @xmath58 separates @xmath131 from the cycle @xmath35 in @xmath2 . )
it now follows that for all vertices @xmath132 , @xmath131 and @xmath133 are 2-connected in @xmath58 .
suppose deleting some vertex @xmath50 separates @xmath131 from @xmath133 .
the vertex @xmath50 can not be @xmath28 , since @xmath6 is a connected component of @xmath127 .
but if @xmath134 , @xmath28 and @xmath131 are in the same component of @xmath135 , since @xmath28 is 2-connected to @xmath131 in @xmath58 .
similarly , @xmath28 and @xmath133 are in the same component of @xmath135 , and so deleting @xmath50 does not separate @xmath131 from @xmath133 . we now show that given any 2-connected graph @xmath2 , we can find a non - trivial cycle of density no more than that of @xmath2 .
[ thm : cycleexists ] let @xmath2 be a @xmath1-connected graph with at least @xmath1 terminals .
@xmath2 contains a simple non - trivial cycle @xmath136 such that @xmath137 .
let @xmath35 be an arbitrary non - trivial simple cycle ; such a cycle always exists since @xmath2 is @xmath1-connected and has at least 2 terminals .
if @xmath138 , we give an algorithm that finds a new non - trivial cycle @xmath139 such that @xmath140 . repeating this process , we obtain cycles of successively better densities until eventually finding a non - trivial cycle @xmath136 of density at most @xmath109 .
let @xmath42 be the graph formed by contracting the given cycle @xmath35 to a single vertex @xmath28 . in @xmath42
, @xmath28 is not a terminal , and so has weight 0 .
consider the 2-connected components of @xmath42 ( from lemma [ lem:2conncomp ] , each such component is formed by adding @xmath28 to a connected component of @xmath127 ) , and pick the one of minimum density . if @xmath6 is this component , @xmath141 by an averaging argument .
@xmath6 contains at least 1 terminal .
if it contains 2 or more terminals , recursively find a non - trivial cycle @xmath139 in @xmath6 such that @xmath142 .
if @xmath139 exists in the given graph @xmath2 , it has the desired properties , and we are done .
otherwise , @xmath139 contains @xmath28 , and the edges of @xmath139 form a ear of @xmath35 in the original graph @xmath2 .
the density of this ear is less than the density of @xmath35 , so we can apply lemma [ lem : goodear ] to obtain a non - trivial cycle in @xmath2 that has density less than @xmath110 .
finally , if @xmath6 has exactly 1 terminal @xmath50 , find any 2 vertex - disjoint paths using edges of @xmath6 from @xmath50 to distinct vertices in the cycle @xmath35 .
( since @xmath2 is 2-connected , there always exist such paths . )
the cost of these paths is at most @xmath143 , and concatenating these 2 paths corresponds to a ear of @xmath35 in @xmath2 .
the density of this ear is less than @xmath110 ; again , we use lemma [ lem : goodear ] to obtain a cycle in @xmath2 with the desired properties .
we remark again that the algorithm of theorem [ thm : cycleexists ] does not lead to a polynomial - time algorithm , even if all edge costs and terminal weights are polynomially bounded . in section [ subsec : strong ] , we describe a strongly polynomial - time algorithm that , given a graph @xmath2 , finds a non - trivial cycle of density at most that of @xmath2 . note that neither of these algorithms may directly give a good approximation to the min - density non - trivial cycle problem , because the optimal non - trivial cycle may have density much less than that of @xmath2 .
however , we can use theorem [ thm : cycleexists ] to prove the following theorem : [ thm : equivalence ] there is an @xmath144-approximation to the ( unrooted ) dens-@xmath1vc problem if and only if there is an @xmath144-approximation to the problem of finding a minimum - density non - trivial cycle .
assume we have a @xmath145-approximation for the dens-@xmath1vc problem ; we use it to find a low - density non - trivial cycle .
solve the dens-@xmath1vc problem on the given graph ; since the optimal cycle is a 2-connected graph , our solution @xmath6 to the dens-@xmath1vc problem has density at most @xmath145 times the density of this cycle .
find a non - trivial cycle in @xmath6 of density at most that of @xmath6 ; it has density at most @xmath145 times that of an optimal non - trivial cycle .
note that any instance of the ( unrooted ) dens-@xmath1vc problem has an optimal solution that is a non - trivial cycle .
( consider any optimal solution @xmath6 of density @xmath146 ; by theorem [ thm : cycle ] , @xmath6 contains a non - trivial cycle of density at most @xmath146 .
this cycle is a valid solution to the dens-@xmath1vc problem . )
therefore , a @xmath147-approximation for the min - density non - trivial cycle problem gives a @xmath147-approximation for the dens-@xmath1vc problem .
theorem [ thm : equivalence ] and lemma [ lem : densv ] imply an @xmath37-approximation for the minimum - density non - trivial cycle problem ; this proves corollary [ cor : cycle ] .
we say that a graph @xmath5 is minimally 2-connected on its terminals if for every edge @xmath148 , some pair of terminals is not 2-connected in the graph @xmath149 .
section [ subsec : strong ] shows that in any graph which is minimally 2-connected on its terminals , every cycle is non - trivial .
therefore , the problem of finding a minimum - density non - trivial cycle in such graphs is just that of finding a minimum - density cycle , which can be solved exactly in polynomial time .
however , as we explain at the end of the section , this does not directly lead to an efficient algorithm for arbitrary graphs . in this section
, we describe a strongly polynomial - time algorithm which , given a 2-connected graph @xmath5 with edge costs and terminal weights , finds a non - trivial cycle of density at most that of @xmath2 .
we begin with several definitions : let @xmath35 be a cycle in a graph @xmath2 , and @xmath42 be the graph formed by deleting @xmath35 from @xmath2 .
let @xmath150 be the connected components of @xmath42 ; we refer to these as _ earrings _ of @xmath35 .
were simply a path , it would be an ear of @xmath35 , but @xmath151 may be more complex . ] for each @xmath151 , let the vertices of @xmath35 incident to it be called its _
clasps_. from the definition of an earring , for any pair of clasps of @xmath151 , there is a path between them whose internal vertices are all in @xmath151 .
we say that a vertex of @xmath35 is an _ anchor _ if it is the clasp of some earring .
( an anchor may be a clasp of multiple earrings . ) a _ segment _
@xmath13 of @xmath35 is a path contained in @xmath35 , such that the endpoints of @xmath13 are both anchors , and no internal vertex of @xmath13 is an anchor .
( note that the endpoints of @xmath13 might be clasps of the same earring , or of distinct earrings . )
it is easy to see that the segments partition the edge set of @xmath35 . by deleting a segment
, we refer to deleting its edges and internal vertices .
observe that if @xmath13 is deleted from @xmath2 , the only vertices of @xmath152 that lose an edge are the endpoints of @xmath13 .
a segment is _ safe _ if the graph @xmath153 is 2-connected .
arbitrarily pick a vertex @xmath154 of @xmath35 as the _ origin _ , and consecutively number the vertices of @xmath35 clockwise around the cycle as @xmath155 .
the first clasp of an earring @xmath6 is its lowest numbered clasp , and the last clasp is its highest numbered clasp .
( if the origin is a clasp of @xmath6 , it is considered the first clasp , not the last . )
the _ arc _ of an earring is the subgraph of @xmath35 found by traversing clockwise from its first clasp @xmath156 to its last clasp @xmath157 ; the length of this arc is @xmath158 .
( that is , the length of an arc is the number of edges it contains . )
note that if an arc contains the origin , it must be the first vertex of the arc .
figure [ fig : earring ] illustrates several of these definitions .
( 0,0 ) circle ( 2 cm ) ; at ( 0,0 ) @xmath35 ; ( 30:2 cm )
( 30:3 cm ) ; ( 2,0 ) ( 3,0 ) ; ( -45:2 cm ) ( -45:3 cm ) ; at ( 38:2.35 cm ) @xmath159 ; at ( 2.35,0.25 ) @xmath160 ; at ( -53:2.35 cm ) @xmath161 ; at ( 0,2.35 ) @xmath162 ; ( 30:2.8 cm ) arc(30:-45:2.8 cm ) ; ( 30:4.2 cm ) arc ( 30:-45:4.2 cm ) ; ( 30:2.8 cm ) arc ( -150:-330:0.7 cm ) ; ( -45:2.8 cm ) arc ( 135:315:0.7 cm ) ; at ( 15:3.5 cm ) @xmath6 ; ( 30:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( -45:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 2,0 ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 0,2 ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 30:1.75 cm ) arc ( 30:-45:1.75 cm ) ; ( 0,0 ) circle ( 2 cm ) ; at ( 0,0 ) @xmath35 ; ( 0,2 ) ( 0,3.6 ) arc(90:-90:3.6 cm ) ( 0,-2 ) ; at ( 0,1.6 ) @xmath163 ; at ( 0,-1.6 ) @xmath164 ; at ( 0,3.9 ) [ font= ] @xmath165 ; ( 30:2 cm ) ( 30:3 cm ) arc(30:-30:3 cm )
( -30:2 cm ) ; at ( 30:1.6 cm ) @xmath156 ; at ( -30:1.6 cm ) @xmath157 ; ( 30:2.2 cm ) arc(30:330:2.2 cm ) ; ( 25:2.2 cm )
( 25:2.8 cm ) arc(25:-25:2.8 cm ) ( -25:2.2 cm ) ; ( 30:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( -30:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 0,2 ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 0,-2 ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 150:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; at ( 150:1.6 cm ) @xmath162 ; ( 0,0 ) circle ( 2 cm ) ; at ( 0,0 ) @xmath35 ; ( 0,2 ) ( 0,3.6 ) arc(90:-90:3.6 cm ) ( 0,-2 ) ; at ( 0,1.6 ) @xmath163 ; at ( 0,-1.6 ) @xmath164 ; at ( 0,3.9 ) [ font= ] @xmath166 ; at ( 30:1.6 cm ) @xmath156 ; at ( -30:1.6 cm ) @xmath157 ; ( 30:2 cm ) ( 30:3.6 cm ) ; ( 88:2 cm ) ( 85:3 cm ) arc(85:-85:3 cm ) ( -88:2 cm ) ; at ( 85:3.3 cm ) [ font= ] @xmath167 ; ( -30:2 cm ) ( -30:3 cm ) ; ( 25:2.2 cm ) ( 25:3.4 cm ) arc ( 25:-88:3.4 cm ) ( -88:2.2 cm ) arc ( -88:-35:2.2 cm ) ; ( -25:2.2 cm ) ( -25:2.8 cm ) arc ( -25:80:2.8 cm ) ( 80:2.2 cm ) arc ( 80:35:2.2 cm ) ; ( 30:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( -30:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 0,2 ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 0,-2 ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 150:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; at ( 150:1.6 cm ) @xmath162 ; ( 0,0 ) circle ( 2 cm ) ; at ( 0,0 ) @xmath35 ; ( 0,2 ) ( 0,3.6 ) arc(90:-90:3.6 cm ) ( 0,-2 ) ; at ( 0,1.6 ) @xmath163 ; at ( 0,-1.6 ) @xmath164 ; at ( 0,3.9 ) [ font= ] @xmath165 ; at ( 30:1.6 cm ) @xmath156 ; at ( -30:1.6 cm ) @xmath157 ; ( 30:2 cm ) ( 30:3.1 cm ) arc ( 30:-105:3.1 cm )
( -105:2 cm ) ; at ( 38:2.55 cm ) [ font= ] @xmath166 ; ( -30:2 cm ) ( -30:2.5 cm ) arc(-30:-135:2.5 cm ) ( -135:2 cm ) ; at ( -143:2.5 cm ) [ font= ] @xmath167 ; ( 35:2.15 cm ) arc ( 35:85:2.15 cm ) ( 85:3.45 cm ) arc ( 85:-85:3.45 cm ) ( -85:2.15 cm ) arc ( -85:-35:2.15 cm ) ; ( 25:2.2 cm ) ( 25:2.95 cm ) arc(25:-100:2.95 cm ) ( -100:2.15 cm ) arc ( -100:-130:2.15 cm ) ( -130:2.65 cm ) arc ( -130:-25:2.65 cm ) ( -25:2.15 cm ) ; ( 30:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( -30:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 0,2 ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 0,-2 ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 150:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; at ( 150:1.6 cm ) @xmath162 ; ( 0,0 ) circle ( 2 cm ) ; at ( 0,0 ) @xmath35 ; ( 0,2 ) ( 0,3.6 ) arc(90:-90:3.6 cm ) ( 0,-2 ) ; at ( 0,1.6 ) @xmath163 ; at ( 0,-1.6 ) @xmath164 ; at ( 0,4.1 ) [ font= ] @xmath168 ; at ( 30:1.6 cm ) @xmath156 ; at ( -30:1.6 cm ) @xmath157 ; ( 30:2 cm ) ( 30:3.6 cm ) ; ( -30:2 cm ) ( -30:3 cm ) arc(-30:-120:3 cm ) ( -120:2 cm ) ; at ( -125:3 cm ) [ font= ] @xmath167 ; ( -35:2.2 cm ) arc ( -35:-85:2.2 cm ) ( -85:3.4 cm ) arc ( -85:25:3.4 cm ) ( 25:2.2 cm ) ; ( -35:2.2 cm ) ( -35:2.8 cm ) arc(-35:-115:2.8 cm ) ( -115:2.2 cm ) arc ( -115:-330:2.2 cm ) ; ( 30:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( -30:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 0,2 ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 0,-2 ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 150:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; at ( 150:1.6 cm ) @xmath162 ; ( 0,0 ) circle ( 2 cm ) ; at ( 0,0 ) @xmath35 ; ( 0,2 ) ( 0,3.6 ) arc(90:-90:3.6 cm ) ( 0,-2 ) ; at ( 0,1.6 ) @xmath163 ; at ( 0,-1.6 ) @xmath164 ; at ( 0,4.1 ) [ font= ] @xmath168 ; at ( 30:1.6 cm ) @xmath156 ; at ( -30:1.6 cm ) @xmath157 ; ( -30:2 cm ) ( -30:3.6 cm ) ; ( 30:2 cm ) ( 30:3 cm ) arc(30:-120:3 cm ) ( -120:2 cm ) ; at ( -125:3 cm ) [ font= ] @xmath167 ; ( -25:2.2 cm ) ( -25:3.4 cm ) arc ( -25:85:3.4 cm ) ( 85:2.2 cm ) arc ( 85:35:2.2 cm ) ; ( -35:2.2 cm ) arc ( -35:-115:2.2 cm ) ( -115:2.8 cm ) arc(-115:35:2.8 cm ) ( 35:2.2 cm ) ; ( 30:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( -30:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 0,2 ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 0,-2 ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; ( 150:2 cm ) circle ( 1 mm ) ; at ( 150:1.6 cm ) @xmath162 ; [ thm : earringproof ] let @xmath6 be an earring of minimum arc length . every segment contained in the arc of @xmath6 is safe .
let @xmath169 be the set of earrings with arc identical to that of @xmath6 .
since they have the same arc , we refer to this as the arc of @xmath169 , or the _
critical arc_. let the first clasp of every earring in @xmath169 be @xmath163 , and the last clasp of each earring in @xmath169 be @xmath164 . because the earrings in @xmath169 have arcs of minimum length , any earring @xmath170 has a clasp @xmath171 that is not in the critical arc .
( that is , @xmath172 or @xmath173 . )
we must show that every segment contained in the critical arc is safe ; recall that a segment @xmath13 is safe if the graph @xmath153 is 2-connected . given an arbitrary segment @xmath13 in the critical arc , let @xmath156 and @xmath157 ( @xmath174 ) be the anchors that are its endpoints .
we prove that there are always 2 internally vertex - disjoint paths between @xmath156 and @xmath157 in @xmath152 ; this suffices to show 2-connectivity .
we consider several cases , depending on the earrings that contain @xmath156 and @xmath157 .
figure [ fig : earringproof ] illustrates these cases . if @xmath156 and @xmath157 are contained in the same earring @xmath58 , it is easy to find two vertex - disjoint paths between them in @xmath153 .
the first path is clockwise from @xmath175 to @xmath176 in the cycle @xmath35 .
the second path is entirely contained in the earring @xmath58 ( an earring is connected in @xmath177 , so we can always find such a path . ) otherwise , @xmath156 and @xmath157 are clasps of distinct earrings .
we consider three cases : both @xmath156 and @xmath157 are clasps of earrings in @xmath169 , one is ( but not both ) , or neither is . 1 .
we first consider that both @xmath156 and @xmath157 are clasps of earrings in @xmath169 .
let @xmath156 be a clasp of @xmath166 , and @xmath157 a clasp of @xmath167 .
the first path is from @xmath157 to @xmath163 through @xmath167 , and then clockwise along the critical arc from @xmath163 to @xmath156 .
the second path is from @xmath157 to @xmath164 clockwise along the critical path , and then @xmath164 to @xmath156 through @xmath166 .
it is easy to see that these paths are internally vertex - disjoint .
2 . now , suppose neither @xmath156 nor @xmath157 is a clasp of an earring in @xmath169 .
let @xmath156 be a clasp of @xmath166 , and @xmath157 be a clasp of @xmath167 .
the first path we find follows the critical arc clockwise from @xmath157 to @xmath164 ( the last clasp of the critical arc ) , from @xmath164 to @xmath163 through @xmath165 , and again clockwise through the critical arc from @xmath163 to @xmath156 .
internal vertices of this path are all in @xmath6 or on the critical arc .
let @xmath178 be a clasp of @xmath166 not on the critical arc , and @xmath179 be a last clasp of @xmath167 not on the critical arc .
the second path goes from @xmath156 to @xmath178 through @xmath166 , from @xmath180 to @xmath181 through the cycle @xmath35 outside the critical arc , and from @xmath179 to @xmath157 through @xmath167 .
internal vertices of this path are in @xmath182 , or in @xmath35 , but not part of the critical arc ( since each of @xmath178 and @xmath179 are outside the critical arc ) . therefore , we have 2 vertex - disjoint paths from @xmath156 to @xmath157 .
finally , we consider the case that exactly one of @xmath183 is a clasp of an earring in @xmath169 .
suppose @xmath156 is a clasp of @xmath168 , and @xmath157 is a clasp of @xmath184 ; the other case ( where @xmath185 and @xmath186 is symmetric , and omitted , though figure [ fig : earringproof ] illustrates the paths . )
let @xmath181 be the index of a clasp of @xmath167 outside the critical arc .
the first path is from @xmath157 to @xmath164 through the critical arc , and then from @xmath164 to @xmath156 through @xmath166 .
the second path is from @xmath157 to @xmath179 through @xmath167 , and from @xmath179 to @xmath156 clockwise through @xmath35 .
note that the last part of this path enters the critical arc at @xmath163 , and continues through the arc until @xmath156 .
internal vertices of the first path that are in @xmath35 are on the critical arc , but have index greater than @xmath175 .
internal vertices of the second path that belong to @xmath35 are either not in the critical arc , or have index between @xmath163 and @xmath156
. therefore , the two paths are internally vertex - disjoint .
we now describe our algorithm to find a non - trivial cycle of good density , proving theorem [ thm : cycle ] : _ let @xmath2 be a @xmath1-connected graph with edge - costs and terminal weights , and at least @xmath1 terminals .
there is a polynomial - time algorithm to find a non - trivial cycle @xmath136 in @xmath2 such that @xmath137 . _
theorem [ thm : cycle ] let @xmath2 be a graph with @xmath32 terminals and density @xmath146 ; we describe a polynomial - time algorithm that either finds a cycle in @xmath2 of density less than @xmath146 , or a proper subgraph @xmath42 of @xmath2 that contains all @xmath32 terminals . in the latter case , we can recurse on @xmath42 until we eventually find a cycle of density at most @xmath146 .
we first find , in @xmath187 time , a minimum - density cycle @xmath35 in @xmath2 . by theorem [ thm : cycleexists ] , @xmath35 has density at most @xmath146 , because the minimum - density _ non - trivial _ cycle has at most this density .
if @xmath35 contains at least 2 terminals , we are done .
otherwise , @xmath35 contains exactly one terminal @xmath28 .
since @xmath2 contains at least 2 terminals , there must exist at least one earring of @xmath35 .
let @xmath28 be the origin of this cycle @xmath35 , and @xmath6 an earring of minimum arc length . by theorem [ thm : earringproof ]
, every segment in the arc of @xmath6 is safe .
let @xmath13 be such a segment ; since @xmath28 was selected as the origin , @xmath28 is not an internal vertex of @xmath13 . as @xmath28 is the only terminal of @xmath35 , @xmath13 contains no terminals , and therefore , the graph @xmath188 is 2-connected , and contains all @xmath32 terminals of @xmath2 .
the proof above also shows that if @xmath2 is minimally 2-connected on its terminals ( that is , @xmath2 has no 2-connected proper subgraph containing all its terminals ) , every cycle of @xmath2 is non - trivial .
( if a cycle contains 0 or 1 terminals , it has a safe segment containing no terminals , which can be deleted ; this gives a contradiction . ) therefore , given a graph that _ is _ minimally 2-connected on its terminals , finding a minimum - density non - trivial cycle is equivalent to finding a minimum - density cycle , and so can be solved exactly in polynomial time .
this suggests a natural algorithm for the problem : given a graph that is not minimally 2-connected on its terminals , delete edges and vertices until the graph is minimally 2-connected on the terminals , and then find a minimum - density cycle .
as shown above , this gives a cycle of density no more than that of the input graph , but this may not be the minimum - density cycle of the original graph .
for instance , there exist instances where the minimum - density cycle uses edges of a safe segment @xmath13 that might be deleted by this algorithm .
in this section , we prove theorem [ thm : avekv ] . we are given a graph @xmath2 and @xmath3 , a set of at least @xmath0 terminals .
further , every terminal in @xmath2 has 2 vertex - disjoint paths to the root @xmath39 of total cost at most @xmath67 .
let @xmath32 be the number of terminals in @xmath2 , and @xmath189 its total cost ; @xmath190 is the density of @xmath2 .
we describe an algorithm that finds a subgraph @xmath6 of @xmath2 that contains at least @xmath0 terminals , each of which is 2-connected to the root , and of total edge cost @xmath191 .
we can assume @xmath192 , or the trivial solution of taking the entire graph @xmath2 suffices .
the main phase of our algorithm proceeds by maintaining a set of 2-connected subgraphs that we call _ clusters _ , and repeatedly finding low - density cycles that merge clusters of similar weight to form larger clusters .
( the weight of a cluster @xmath136 , denoted by @xmath193 , is ( roughly ) the number of terminals it contains . )
clusters are grouped into _
tiers _ by weight ; tier @xmath95 contains clusters with weight at least @xmath194 and less than @xmath102 .
initially , each terminal is a separate cluster in tier 0 .
we say a cluster is _ large _ if it has weight at least @xmath0 , and _ small _ otherwise .
the algorithm stops when most terminals are in large clusters .
we now describe the algorithm mergeclusters ( see next page ) . to simplify notation , let @xmath144 be the quantity @xmath195 .
we say that a cycle is _ good _ if it has density at most @xmath144 ; that is , good cycles have density at most @xmath196 times the density of the input graph . :
+ for ( each @xmath95 in @xmath197 ) do : + if ( @xmath198 ) : + every terminal has weight 1 + else : + mark all vertices as non - terminals + for ( each small 2-connected cluster @xmath136 in tier @xmath95 ) do : + add a ( dummy ) terminal @xmath199 to @xmath2 of weight @xmath193 + add ( dummy ) edges of cost 0 from @xmath199 to two ( arbitrary ) distinct vertices of @xmath136 + while ( @xmath2 has a non - trivial cycle @xmath35 of density at most @xmath144 in @xmath2 ) : + let @xmath200 be the small clusters that contain a terminal * or an edge * of @xmath35 .
+ ( note that the terminals in @xmath35 belong to a subset of @xmath201 . ) + form a new cluster @xmath202 ( of a higher tier ) by merging the clusters @xmath203 + @xmath204 + if ( @xmath198 ) : + mark all terminals in @xmath202 as non - terminals + else : + delete all ( dummy ) terminals in @xmath202 and the associated ( dummy ) edges .
we briefly remark on some salient features of this algorithm and our analysis before presenting the details of the proofs . 1 . in iteration @xmath95
, the terminals correspond to tier @xmath95 clusters .
clusters are 2-connected subgraphs of @xmath2 , and by using cycles to merge clusters , we preserve 2-connectivity as the clusters become larger .
2 . when a cycle @xmath35 is used to merge clusters , all small clusters that contain an edge of @xmath35 ( regardless of their tier ) are merged to form the new cluster . therefore , at any stage of the algorithm , all currently small clusters are edge - disjoint . large clusters , on the other hand , are _ frozen _ ;
even if they intersect a good cycle @xmath35 , they are not merged with other clusters on @xmath35 .
thus , at any time , an edge may be in multiple large clusters and up to one small cluster .
3 . in iteration @xmath95 of mergeclusters ,
the density of a cycle @xmath35 is only determined by its cost and the weight of terminals in @xmath35 corresponding to tier @xmath95 clusters .
though small clusters of other ( lower or higher ) tiers might be merged using @xmath35 , we do _ not _ use their weight to pay for the edges of @xmath35 .
4 . the @xmath95th iteration terminates when no good cycles can be found using the remaining tier @xmath95 clusters . at this point
, there may be some terminals remaining that correspond to clusters which are not merged to form clusters of higher tiers . however , our choice of @xmath144 ( which defines the density of good cycles ) is such that we can bound the number of terminals that are `` left behind '' in this fashion
. therefore , when the algorithm terminates , most terminals are in large clusters . by bounding the density of large clusters
, we can find a solution to the rooted @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem of bounded density . because we always use cycles of low density to merge clusters , an analysis similar to that of @xcite and @xcite shows that every large cluster has density at most @xmath205 .
we first present this analysis , though it does not suffice to prove theorem [ thm : avekv ] .
a more careful analysis shows that there is at least one large cluster of density at most @xmath206 ; this allows us to prove the desired theorem .
we now formally prove that mergeclusters has the desired behavior .
first , we present a series of claims which , together , show that when the algorithm terminates , most terminals are in large clusters , and all clusters are 2-connected .
[ rem : cluster ] throughout the algorithm , the graph @xmath2 is always 2-connected .
the weight of a cluster is at most the number of terminals it contains .
the only structural changes to @xmath2 are when new vertices are added as terminals ; they are added with edges to two distinct vertices of @xmath2 .
this preserves 2-connectivity , as does deleting these terminals with the associated edges . to see that the second claim is true ,
observe that if a terminal contributes weight to a cluster , it is contained in that cluster .
a terminal can be in multiple clusters , but it contributes to the weight of exactly one cluster .
we use the following simple proposition in proofs of 2-connectivity ; the proof is straightforward , and hence omitted . [
prop : shareedge ] let @xmath207 and @xmath208 be @xmath1-connected subgraphs of a graph @xmath5 such that @xmath209
. then the graph @xmath210 is @xmath1-connected .
[ lem : clusters2conn ] the clusters formed by mergeclusters are all @xmath1-connected .
let @xmath202 be a cluster formed by using a cycle @xmath35 to merge clusters @xmath200 .
the edges of the cycle @xmath35 form a 2-connected subgraph of @xmath2 , and we assume that each @xmath211 is 2-connected by induction .
further , @xmath35 contains at least 2 vertices of each @xmath211 may be a singleton vertex ( for instance , if we are in tier 0 ) , but such a vertex does not affect 2-connectivity . ] , so we can use induction and proposition [ prop : shareedge ] above : we assume @xmath212 is 2-connected by induction , and @xmath35 contains 2 vertices of @xmath213 , so @xmath214 is 2-connected . note that we have shown @xmath215
is 2-connected , but @xmath35 ( and hence @xmath202 ) might contain dummy terminals and the corresponding dummy edges .
however , each such terminal with the 2 associated edges is a ear of @xmath202 ; deleting them leaves @xmath202 2-connected .
[ lem : fewleftbehind ] the total weight of small clusters in tier @xmath95 that are not merged to form clusters of higher tiers is at most @xmath216 .
assume this were not true ; this means that mergeclusters could find no more cycles of density at most @xmath144 using the remaining small tier @xmath95 clusters .
but the total cost of all the edges is at most @xmath189 , and the sum of terminal weights is at least @xmath216 ; this implies that the density of the graph ( using the remaining terminals ) is at most @xmath217 .
but by theorem [ thm : cycleexists ] , the graph must then contain a good non - trivial cycle , and so the while loop would not have terminated .
[ cor : weightlargeclusters ] when the algorithm mergeclusters terminates , the total weight of large clusters is at least @xmath218 .
each terminal not in a large cluster contributes to the weight of a cluster that was not merged with others to form a cluster of a higher tier .
the previous lemma shows that the total weight of such clusters in any tier is at most @xmath219 ; since there are @xmath220 tiers , the total number of terminals not in large clusters is less than @xmath221 .
so far , we have shown that most terminals reach large clusters , all of which are 2-connected , but we have not argued about the density of these clusters . the next lemma says that if we can find a large cluster of good density , we can find a solution to the @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem of good density .
[ lem : segment ] let @xmath202 be a large cluster formed by mergeclusters . if @xmath202 has density at most @xmath222 , we can find a graph @xmath223 with at least @xmath0 terminals , each of which is @xmath1-connected to @xmath39 , of total cost at most @xmath224 .
let @xmath200 be the clusters merged to form @xmath202 in order around the cycle @xmath35 that merged them ; each @xmath211 was a small cluster , of weight at most @xmath0 .
a simple averaging argument shows that there is a consecutive segment of @xmath211s with total weight between @xmath0 and @xmath225 , such that the cost of the edges of @xmath35 connecting these clusters , together with the costs of the clusters themselves , is at most @xmath226 .
let @xmath227 be the `` first '' cluster of this segment , and @xmath228 the `` last '' .
let @xmath28 and @xmath229 be arbitrary terminals of @xmath227 and @xmath228 respectively . connect each of @xmath28 and @xmath229 to the root @xmath39 using 2 vertex - disjoint paths ;
the cost of this step is at most @xmath230 .
( we assumed that every terminal could be 2-connected to @xmath39 using disjoint paths of cost at most @xmath67 . )
the graph @xmath223 thus constructed has at least @xmath0 terminals , and total cost at most @xmath231 .
we show that every vertex @xmath232 of @xmath223 is 2-connected to @xmath39 ; this completes our proof .
let @xmath232 be an arbitrary vertex of @xmath223 ; suppose there is a cut - vertex @xmath131 which , when deleted , separates @xmath232 from @xmath39 .
both @xmath28 and @xmath229 are 2-connected to @xmath39 , and therefore neither is in the same component as @xmath232 in @xmath233 .
however , we describe 2 vertex - disjoint paths @xmath234 and @xmath235 in @xmath223 from @xmath232 to @xmath28 and @xmath229 respectively ; deleting @xmath131 can not separate @xmath232 from both @xmath28 and @xmath229 , which gives a contradiction .
the paths @xmath234 and @xmath235 are easy to find ; let @xmath211 be the cluster containing @xmath232 .
the cycle @xmath35 contains a path from vertex @xmath236 to @xmath237 , and another ( vertex - disjoint ) path from @xmath238 to @xmath239 .
concatenating these paths with paths from @xmath240 to @xmath28 in @xmath227 and @xmath241 to @xmath229 in @xmath228 gives us vertex - disjoint paths @xmath242 from @xmath243 to @xmath28 and @xmath244 from @xmath245 to @xmath229 .
since @xmath211 is 2-connected , we can find vertex - disjoint paths from @xmath232 to @xmath243 and @xmath245 , which gives us the desired paths @xmath234 and @xmath235
. may not be in any cluster @xmath211 . in this case , @xmath234 is formed by using edges of @xmath35 from @xmath232 to @xmath237 , and then a path from @xmath240 to @xmath28 ; @xmath235 is formed similarly . ]
we now present the two analyses of density referred to earlier .
the key difference between the weaker and tighter analysis is in the way we bound edge costs . in the former ,
each large cluster pays for its edges separately , using the fact that all cycles used have density at most @xmath246 . in the latter
, we crucially use the fact that small clusters which share edges are merged . roughly speaking , because small clusters are edge - disjoint
, the average density of small clusters must be comparable to the density of the input graph @xmath2 .
once an edge is in a large cluster , we can no longer use the edge - disjointness argument .
we must pay for these edges separately , but we can bound this cost .
first , the following lemma allows us to show that every large cluster has density at most @xmath205 .
[ lem : tiercost ] for any cluster @xmath202 formed by mergeclusters during iteration @xmath95 , the total cost of edges in @xmath202 is at most @xmath247 .
we prove this lemma by induction on the number of vertices in a cluster .
let @xmath248 be the set of clusters merged using a cycle @xmath35 to form @xmath202 .
let @xmath249 be the set of clusters in @xmath248 of tier @xmath95 , and @xmath250 be @xmath251 .
( @xmath250 contains clusters of tiers less or greater than @xmath95 that contained an edge of @xmath35 . )
the cost of edges in @xmath202 is at most the sum of : the cost of @xmath35 , the cost of @xmath249 , and the cost of @xmath250 . since all clusters in @xmath250 have been formed during iteration @xmath95 or earlier , and are smaller than @xmath202 , we can use induction to show that the cost of edges in @xmath250 is at most @xmath252 . all clusters in @xmath249
are of tier @xmath95 , and so must have been formed before iteration @xmath95 ( any cluster formed during iteration @xmath95 is of a strictly greater tier ) , so we use induction to bound the cost of edges in @xmath249 by @xmath253 .
finally , because @xmath35 was a good - density cycle , and only clusters of tier @xmath95 contribute to calculating the density of @xmath35 , the cost of @xmath35 is at most @xmath254 .
therefore , the total cost of edges in @xmath202 is at most @xmath255 .
let @xmath202 be an arbitrary large cluster ; since we have only @xmath220 tiers , the previous lemma implies that the cost of @xmath202 is at most @xmath256 . that is , the density of @xmath202 is at most @xmath205 , and we can use this fact together with lemma [ lem : segment ] to find a solution to the rooted @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem of cost at most @xmath257 .
this completes the ` weaker ' analysis , but this does not suffice to prove theorem [ thm : avekv ] ; to prove the theorem , we would need to use a large cluster @xmath202 of density @xmath206 , instead of @xmath205 . for the purpose of the more careful analysis , implicitly construct a forest @xmath258 on the clusters formed by mergeclusters .
initially , the vertex set of @xmath258 is just @xmath13 , the set of terminals , and @xmath258 has no edges . every time a cluster @xmath202 is formed by merging @xmath200 ,
we add a corresponding vertex @xmath202 to the forest @xmath258 , and add edges from @xmath202 to each of @xmath203 ; @xmath202 is the parent of @xmath259 .
we also associate a cost with each vertex in @xmath258 ; the cost of the vertex @xmath202 is the cost of the cycle used to form @xmath202 from @xmath203 .
we thus build up trees as the algorithm proceeds ; the root of any tree corresponds to a cluster that has not yet become part of a bigger cluster .
the leaves of the trees correspond to vertices of @xmath2 ; they all have cost 0 . also ,
any large cluster @xmath202 formed by the algorithm is at the root of its tree ; we refer to this tree as @xmath260 . for each large cluster @xmath202 after mergeclusters terminates , say that @xmath202 is of type @xmath95 if @xmath202 was formed during iteration @xmath95 of mergeclusters .
we now define the _ final - stage _ clusters of @xmath202 : they are the clusters formed during iteration @xmath95 that became part of @xmath202 .
( we include @xmath202 itself in the list of final - stage clusters ; even though @xmath202 was formed in iteration @xmath95 of mergeclusters , it may contain other final - stage clusters .
for instance , during iteration @xmath95 , we may merge several tier @xmath95 clusters to form a cluster @xmath136 of tier @xmath261 .
then , if we find a good - density cycle @xmath35 that contains an edge of @xmath136 , @xmath136 will merge with the other clusters of @xmath35 . )
the _ penultimate _ clusters of @xmath202 are those clusters that exist just before the beginning of iteration @xmath95 and become a part of @xmath202 .
equivalently , the penultimate clusters are those formed before iteration @xmath95 that are the immediate children in @xmath260 of final - stage clusters .
figure 1 illustrates the definitions of final - stage and penultimate clusters .
such a tree could be formed if , in iteration @xmath262 , 4 clusters of this tier merged to form @xmath263 , a cluster of tier @xmath264 .
subsequently , in iteration @xmath95 , clusters @xmath6 and @xmath265 merge to form @xmath266 .
we next find a good cycle containing @xmath267 and @xmath2 ; @xmath266 contains an edge of this cycle , so these three clusters are merged to form @xmath17 .
note that the cost of this cycle is paid for the by the weights of @xmath267 and @xmath2 only ; @xmath266 is a tier @xmath264 cluster , and so its weight is not included in the density calculation .
finally , we find a good cycle paid for by @xmath268 and @xmath35 ; since @xmath17 and @xmath263 share edges with this cycle , they all merge to form the large cluster @xmath202 .
= [ circle , draw , inner sep=0pt , minimum size=6 mm ] ; = [ circle , draw , inner sep=0pt , minimum size=7 mm ] ; = [ font= ] ; \(y ) at ( 6,5.5 ) [ high ] @xmath202 ; \(a ) at ( 1.5,4 ) [ vertex ] @xmath95 ; ( b ) at ( 4.5,4 ) [ high ] @xmath269 ; ( c ) at ( 7.5,4 ) [ vertex ] @xmath95 ; ( d ) at ( 10.5,4 ) [ vertex ] @xmath264 ; ( a ) ( y ) ( b ) ; ( c ) ( y ) ( d ) ; at ( 0.7,4 ) @xmath268 ; at ( 3.6,4 ) @xmath17 ; at ( 6.7,4 ) @xmath35 ; at ( 9.7,4 ) @xmath263 ; \(e ) at ( 3,2.5 ) [ vertex ] @xmath95 ; ( f ) at ( 4.5,2.5 ) [ high ] @xmath264 ; ( g ) at ( 6,2.5 ) [ vertex ] @xmath95 ; ( e ) ( b )
( f ) ; ( b ) ( g ) ; at ( 2.3,2.7 ) @xmath267 ; at ( 3.8,2.7 ) @xmath266 ; at ( 5.35,2.7 ) @xmath2 ; \(h ) at ( 3.5,1 ) [ vertex ] @xmath95 ; ( j ) at ( 5.5,1 ) [ vertex ] @xmath95 ; ( h ) ( f ) ( j ) ; at ( 2.9,1.3 ) @xmath6 ; at ( 4.9,1.3 ) @xmath265 ; at ( y ) [ vertex ] ; at ( b ) [ vertex ] ; at ( f ) [ vertex ] ; an edge of a large cluster @xmath202 is said to be a _ final edge _ if it is used in a cycle @xmath35 that produces a final - stage cluster of @xmath202 .
all other edges of @xmath202 are called _ penultimate edges _ ; note that any penultimate edge is in some penultimate cluster of @xmath202 .
we define the _ final cost _ of @xmath202 to be the sum of the costs of its final edges , and its _ penultimate cost _ to be the sum of the costs of its penultimate edges ; clearly , the cost of @xmath202 is the sum of its final and penultimate costs .
we bound the final costs and penultimate costs separately .
recall that an edge is a final edge of a large cluster @xmath202 if it is used by mergeclusters to form a cycle @xmath35 in the final iteration during which @xmath202 is formed .
the reason we can bound the cost of final edges is that the cost of any such cycle is at most @xmath144 times the weight of clusters contained in the cycle , and a cluster does not contribute to the weight of more than one cycle in an iteration .
( this is also the essence of lemma [ lem : tiercost ] . )
we formalize this intuition in the next lemma .
[ lem : final ] the final cost of any large cluster @xmath202 is at most @xmath270 , where @xmath271 is the weight of @xmath202 .
let @xmath202 be an arbitrary large cluster .
in the construction of the tree @xmath260 , we associated with each vertex of @xmath260 the cost of the cycle used to form the corresponding cluster . to bound the total final cost of @xmath202 , we must bound the sum of the costs of vertices of @xmath260 associated with final - stage clusters . the weight of @xmath202 , @xmath271 is at least the sum of the weights of the penultimate tier @xmath95 clusters that become a part of @xmath202 .
therefore , it suffices to show that the sum of the costs of vertices of @xmath260 associated with final - stage clusters is at most @xmath144 times the sum of the weights of @xmath202 s penultimate tier @xmath95 clusters .
( note that a tier @xmath95 cluster must have been formed prior to iteration @xmath95 , and hence it can not itself be a final - stage cluster . )
a cycle was used to construct a final - stage cluster @xmath136 only if its cost was at most @xmath144 times the sum of weights of the penultimate tier @xmath95 clusters that become a part of @xmath136 .
( larger clusters may become a part of @xmath136 , but they do not contribute weight to the density calculation . ) therefore , if @xmath136 is a vertex of @xmath260 corresponding to a final - stage cluster , the cost of @xmath136 is at most @xmath144 times the sum of the weights of its tier @xmath95 immediate children in @xmath260 . but
@xmath260 is a tree , and so no vertex corresponding to an penultimate tier @xmath95 cluster has more than one parent .
that is , the weight of a penultimate cluster pays for only one final - stage cluster .
therefore , the sum of the costs of vertices associated with final - stage clusters is at most @xmath144 times the sum of the weights of @xmath202 s penultimate tier @xmath95 clusters , and so the final cost of @xmath202 is at most @xmath270 .
[ lem : penultimate ] if @xmath272 and @xmath273 are distinct large clusters of the same type , no edge is a penultimate edge of both @xmath272 and @xmath273 .
suppose , by way of contradiction , that some edge @xmath85 is a penultimate edge of both @xmath272 and @xmath273 , which are large clusters of type @xmath95 .
let @xmath274 ( respectively @xmath275 ) be a penultimate cluster of @xmath272 ( resp .
@xmath273 ) containing @xmath85 . as penultimate clusters ,
both @xmath274 and @xmath275 are formed before iteration @xmath95 .
but until iteration @xmath95 , neither is part of a large cluster , and two small clusters can not share an edge without being merged . therefore , @xmath274 and @xmath275 must have been merged , so they can not belong to distinct large clusters , giving the desired contradiction . [
thm : goodlargecluster ] after mergeclusters terminates , at least one large cluster has density at most @xmath206 .
we define the _ penultimate density _ of a large cluster to be the ratio of its penultimate cost to its weight . consider the total penultimate costs of all large clusters : for any @xmath95 , each edge @xmath276
can be a penultimate edge of at most 1 large cluster of type @xmath95 .
this implies that each edge can be a penultimate edge of at most @xmath220 clusters .
therefore , the sum of penultimate costs of all large clusters is at most @xmath277 .
further , the total weight of all large clusters is at least @xmath278 .
therefore , the ( weighted ) average penultimate density of large clusters is at most @xmath279 , and hence there exists a large cluster @xmath202 of penultimate density at most @xmath280 .
the penultimate cost of @xmath202 is , therefore , at most @xmath281 , and from lemma [ lem : final ] , the final cost of @xmath202 is at most @xmath270 .
therefore , the density of @xmath202 is at most @xmath282 .
theorem [ thm : goodlargecluster ] and lemma [ lem : segment ] together imply that we can find a solution to the rooted @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem of cost at most @xmath191 .
this completes our proof of theorem [ thm : avekv ] .
we list the following open problems : * can the approximation ratio for the @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem be improved from the current @xmath44 to @xmath283 or better ? removing the dependence on @xmath32 to obtain even @xmath284 could be interesting . if not , can one improve the approximation ratio for the easier @xmath0-@xmath1ec problem ? * can we obtain approximation algorithms for the @xmath0-@xmath8vc or @xmath0-@xmath8ec problems for @xmath285 ?
in general , few results are known for problems where vertex - connectivity is required to be greater than 2 , but there has been more progress with higher edge - connectivity requirements . *
given a 2-connected graph of density @xmath146 with some vertices marked as terminals , we show that it contains a non - trivial cycle with density at most @xmath146 , and give an algorithm to find such a cycle .
we have also found an @xmath37-approximation for the problem of finding a minimum - density non - trivial cycle .
is there a constant - factor approximation for this problem ? can it be solved _
exactly _ in polynomial time ?
b. awerbuch , y. azar , a. blum and s. vempala .
new approximation guarantees for minimum weight @xmath0-trees and prize - collecting salesmen .
, 28(1):254262 , 1999 .
preliminary version in _ proc . of acm stoc _ , 1995 .
m. x. goemans and d. p. williamson .
the primal - dual method for approximation algorithms and its application to network design problems . in d.
s. hochbaum , editor , _ approximation algorithms for np - hard problems_. pws publishing company , 1996 .
|
in the @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem , we are given an undirected graph @xmath2 with edge costs and an integer @xmath0 ; the goal is to find a minimum - cost 2-vertex - connected subgraph of @xmath2 containing at least @xmath0 vertices .
a slightly more general version is obtained if the input also specifies a subset @xmath3 of _ terminals _ and the goal is to find a subgraph containing at least @xmath0 terminals .
closely related to the @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem , and in fact a special case of it , is the @xmath0-@xmath1ec problem , in which the goal is to find a minimum - cost 2-edge - connected subgraph containing @xmath0 vertices .
the @xmath0-@xmath1ec problem was introduced by lau _
et al . _
@xcite , who also gave a poly - logarithmic approximation for it .
no previous approximation algorithm was known for the more general @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem .
we describe an @xmath4 approximation for the @xmath0-@xmath1vc problem .
|
one of the most promising solutions to the hierarchy problem is the randall - sundrum ( rs ) model @xcite . in this model
there is a single extra dimension compactified on @xmath1 with the non - factorizable metric of @xmath2 @xmath3 here @xmath4 is the extra - dimensional coordinate , and @xmath5 is the inverse of the @xmath6 curvature , @xmath7 .
two branes define the boundaries of the extra dimension .
one , at @xmath8 , is called the uv , or planck , brane .
the other , at @xmath9 , is the ir , or tev , brane . picking @xmath10 , which is natural in realistic stabilization mechanisms ,
solves the hierarchy problem @xcite . in the original rs model
the sm was confined to the ir brane , and only gravity propagated in the bulk @xcite .
it has since been realized that both gauge and fermion fields can live in the bulk in a realistic model @xcite .
these models are realistic , but the parameter space can be strongly reduced by precision electroweak constraints .
much of this problem can be traced to the fact that the massive gauge fields receive a contribution to their mass from the bulk geometry which does not respect the custodial @xmath11 .
this can be fixed by expanding the gauge group to @xmath12 , which dramatically improves the electroweak fit @xcite .
the breaking of this extended electroweak symmetry proceeds in two stages : on the uv brane @xmath13 ; on the ir brane @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the diagonal of the @xmath16 groups .
this paper investigates the properties of the higgs sector that accomplishes this breaking .
we now ask what drives the breaking on each brane . on the planck brane
all degrees of freedom will have planck scale masses , so we can ignore them .
we can then implement the breaking with boundary conditions to good approximation .
this leads to the boundary conditions at @xmath8 @xmath17 here @xmath18 and @xmath19 are ratios of 5d gauge couplings : @xmath20 , and @xmath21 . on the tev brane
, the masses will be tev scale , so we should look at the higgs sector in detail . the simplest structure that will create
the breaking pattern is a real higgs that is a bidoublet under @xmath22 .
this leads to the boundary conditions at @xmath9 @xmath23 note that in the @xmath24 limit we obtain the usual higgsless boundary conditions , and this model reduces to the higgsless model in @xcite
. we will use this parameter , @xmath25 to interpolate between the sm limit ( @xmath26 ) , and the higgsless limit .
[ fig : wroot ] to write down the effective 4d theory , we expand the 5d fields into kaluza klein ( kk ) fields , @xmath27 we can now obtain the gauge boson wavefunctions by solving the equation of motion subject to the boundary conditions ( [ eq : gaugebcr ] ) and ( [ eq : gaugebcrp ] ) .
this produces a spectrum of eigenvalues corresponding to the excitations of the gauge fields .
the lowest masses in each of the charged and neutral sectors will correspond to the @xmath28 and @xmath29 bosons .
the neutral sector also contains a zero mode , corresponding to the photon .
fig [ fig : wroot ] shows the eigenvalue for the @xmath28 as a function of the parameter @xmath25 .
[ fig : wcoup ]
one interesting feature of this model is that the @xmath28 and @xmath29 wavefunctions are suppressed near the ir brane , as can be seen by inspecting the boundary conditions
. this suppression increases for increasing @xmath25 .
this means that the coupling of massive gauge bosons to the higgs will generically be suppressed .
[ fig : wcoup ] shows the coupling of the @xmath28 to the higgs . for values of @xmath25 near unity
the lep bounds on the higgs mass can be dramatically reduced .
( for larger values of @xmath25 the model is effectively higgsless . )
the fermion sector of this model is more complicated .
again , the higgs vev induces mixed boundary conditions that link left and right handed fields to give the fermions masses .
however , there are two new degrees of freedom . first
, since 5d fermions are achiral , ther can always be a mass term in the bulk @xmath30 .
the main effect of this term is to shift the location of the fermion zero mode in the bulk . by changing this parameter
we can cause the zero mode to be localized either near the uv or ir brane , and also can change the degree of this localization .
this allows us to control the overlap of the zero mode with the ir brane , and consequently the strength with which the fermion interacts with the higgs . in this way
the hierarchy of fermion masses can be generated by order one changes in the 5d masses .
the second complication arises from the @xmath31 symmetry which enforces that , for example , @xmath32 if unbroken .
this mass relation can be modified by mixing with new fermions localized to the planck brane , where the @xmath31 is broken . for full details , see @xcite . note that there are tree - level corrections to precision electroweak observables , coming largely from the kk excitations of the gauge bosons .
unfortunately , the magnitude of these corrections is highly sensitive to the configuration of the fermion sector . for the specific configuration studied in @xcite
we find the constraint @xmath33 .
there are , however , special points in the fermion parameter space where the constraint becomes trivial , so a wide range of @xmath25 should be considered .
the final interesting shift in higgs properties is in the couplings to massless gauge bosons , _
i.e. _ gluons and photons .
the coupling of the higgs to gluon pairs is induced through top loops . however , in this model the kk excitations also couple to the higgs .
furthermore , note that we have arranged small 4d yukawa couplings for the other fermions by small wavefunction overlaps with the would - be zero modes .
the 5d yukawa couplings are all order 1 , and the excited states have _ no _ wavefunction suppression .
hence there are large contributions to the higgs - glue - glue coupling from the kk excitations of _ all _ colored fermions .
this leads to an enhancement in that coupling , as seen in fig .
[ fig : hgg ] .
there are similar corrections to the higgs - gamma - gamma coupling .
the situation there is more complicated , however , since there are also contributions from @xmath28 boson loops , which are dominant in the sm , and the higgs coupling to @xmath28s is suppressed .
we can now look at the behavior of the higgs branching ratios , as shown in fig .
[ fig : widthbr ] . note in particular the dominance of @xmath34 over a wide range , and the late onset of @xmath35 .
this is driven by the @xmath31 symmetry , which gives a large enhancement of the @xmath36-quark yukawa , and the suppression of the gauge boson couplings .
note also the reduction in the @xmath37 mode .
this will make discovery at the lhc difficult .
the suppression of the coupling to gauge bosons also means that production at the ilc will be reduced , making this higgs a particularly difficult one to find .
however , it will be essential to measure the higgs couplings with precision to identify a warped extra dimension as the correct theory of new physics , if indeed this is what is realized in nature .
9 b. lillie , arxiv : hep - ph/0505074 .
l. randall and r. sundrum , phys .
lett . * 83 * , 3370 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9905221 ] .
w. d. goldberger and m. b. wise , phys .
* 83 * , 4922 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9907447 ] .
h. davoudiasl , j. l. hewett and t. g. rizzo , phys .
lett . * 84 * , 2080 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9909255 ] . h. davoudiasl , j. l. hewett and t. g. rizzo , phys .
b * 473 * , 43 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9911262 ] and phys .
d * 63 * , 075004 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0006041 ] ; a. pomarol , phys .
b * 486 * , 153 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9911294 ] ; y. grossman and m. neubert , phys .
b * 474 * , 361 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9912408 ] ; t. gherghetta and a. pomarol , nucl .
b * 586 * , 141 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0003129 ] .
k. agashe , a. delgado , m. j. may and r. sundrum , jhep * 0308 * , 050 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0308036 ] . c. csaki , c. grojean , h. murayama , l. pilo and j. terning , phys .
d * 69 * , 055006 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0305237 ] . c. csaki , c. grojean , l. pilo and j. terning , phys .
* 92 * , 101802 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0308038 ] .
g. cacciapaglia , c. csaki , c. grojean and j. terning , phys .
d * 70 * , 075014 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0401160 ] and phys .
d * 71 * , 035015 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0409126 ] ; g. cacciapaglia , c. csaki , c. grojean , m. reece and j. terning , arxiv : hep - ph/0505001 . y. nomura , jhep * 0311 * , 050 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0309189 ] .
r. barbieri , a. pomarol and r. rattazzi , phys .
b * 591 * , 141 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0310285 ] .
h. davoudiasl , j. l. hewett , b. lillie and t. g. rizzo , phys .
d * 70 * , 015006 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0312193 ] and jhep * 0405 * , 015 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0403300 ] ; j. l. hewett , b. lillie and t. g. rizzo , jhep * 0410 * , 014 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0407059 ] ; r. s. chivukula , e. h. simmons , h. j. he , m. kurachi and m. tanabashi , phys .
d * 70 * , 075008 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0406077 ] and phys .
b * 603 * , 210 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0408262 ] .
a. birkedal , k. matchev and m. perelstein , phys .
* 94 * , 191803 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0412278 ] . c. csaki , c. grojean , j. hubisz , y. shirman and j. terning , phys .
d * 70 * , 015012 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0310355 ] .
|
we study the corrections to higgs physics in a model of a single warped extra dimension with all fields except the higgs in the bulk , and a gauge symmetry extended to @xmath0 .
we find that generically the higgs coupling to electroweak gauge boson pairs is suppressed , the coupling to gluons is enhanced , and the coupling to photons is often suppressed , but can be enhanced .
|
essentially all astronomical measurements are performed via electromagnetic waves .
the availability of accurate gravitational wave measurements within the next decade or so will thus be a significant development for astronomy .
in particular , since the propagation of photons and gravitons could differ at a fundamental level , gravitational waves emitted by cosmologically - distant `` space - time sirens , '' such as coalescing pairs of massive black holes , could be used as valuable new probes of physics on cosmological scales .
black holes with masses @xmath0 are present at the center of numerous nearby galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
as such galaxies collide over cosmic times , their central black holes coalesce , releasing @xmath1 ergs of binding energy in the form of gravitational waves ( hereafter gws ) . to measure the gws emitted by these cosmologically - distant space - time sirens , esa and nasa
will build the laser interferometer space antenna , lisa .
gws emitted by black hole binaries have the unfamiliar property of providing a direct measure of the luminosity distance , @xmath2 , to the black holes , without extrinsic calibration . owing to the highly coherent nature of gw emission @xcite , the amplitude ( or strain ) , @xmath3 , frequency , @xmath4 , and frequency derivative , @xmath5 , of the leading order ( quadrupolar ) gw inspiral signal scale as @xmath6^{5/3 } f^{2/3}}{d_l } , \\
\dot f ( t ) & \propto & \left [ ( 1+z ) m_c \right]^{5/3 } f^{11/3},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath7 represents the two transverse gw polarizations , @xmath8 is the black hole pair `` chirp '' mass and @xmath9 its redshift .
provided the gw source can be reasonably well localized on the sky , an extended observation of the chirping signal leads to precise measurements of @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath5 and thus @xmath2 , independently .
as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : one ] , lisa s orbital configuration allows for a `` triangulation '' of gw sources on the sky , to within a solid angle @xmath10 deg@xmath11 typically @xcite .
this permits very accurate measurements , e.g. distances with errors @xmath12 at @xmath13 typically @xcite .
masses are independently determined to very high accuracy ( typically @xmath14 ; e.g. , @xcite ) =
in principle , the same sky localization that helps determine the distance to a source accurately can be used to find the host galaxy of a pair of merging black holes seen by lisa .
the secure identification of the host galaxy would enable a wide variety of new galactic black hole studies ( see [ sec : newbh ] ) .
initially , the prospects for finding the host galaxy of a pair of merging black holes were considered to be poor , simply because of the large number of galactic candidates located in the @xmath10 deg@xmath11 lisa sky error - box ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) recently , however , this possibility has been reconsidered , with more optimistic conclusions @xcite .
given a cosmology , it is possible to translate the accurate luminosity distance measurement to the gw source into a narrow redshift slice in which the host galaxy must be located @xcite .
various contributions to the redshift errors that arise in performing this conversion are shown in fig .
[ fig : two ] , for a representative equal - mass binary , as a function of the gw source redshift @xcite . at redshifts
@xmath15 , where most black hole binary sources are expected to be found , weak lensing errors due to line - of - sight inhomogeneities ( on top of the smooth average cosmology ) are the main limitation to an accurate determination of the redshift slice in which the host galaxy ought to be located .
@xcite have studied in detail the possibility that the three - dimensional information available ( sky localization + redshift slice ) could be used to single out a quasar , or any other unusually rare object ( such as a star - bust galaxy ) , in the lisa error box , after coalescence .
finding such a statistically rare object post - merger would make it a good host galaxy candidate for the newly - coalesced pair of black holes .
= however , it maybe much more advantageous to use a pre - merger strategy to identify the host galaxy of a pair of coalescing black holes seen by lisa .
indeed , one can use near real - time gw information on the sky localization , in combination with the accurate timing of the inspiral event , to predetermine well in advance where on the sky the merger is located
. a unique host galaxy identification could then proceed through coordinated observations with traditional telescopes , by monitoring in real time the sky area for unusual electromagnetic emission , as the coalescence proceeds .
a variety of mechanisms exist through which disturbed gas in the vicinity of black hole pairs will power electromagnetic emission during and after coalescence @xcite .
for example , at the time of coalescence , @xmath16 ergs of kinetic energy are delivered to the recoiling black hole remnant and its environment , for typical recoil velocities @xmath17 km / s ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) .
this may lead to detectable signatures @xcite and permit the coincident identification of a unique host galaxy .
the detailed nature of such electromagnetic counterparts remains largely unknown , however . to a large extent ,
lisa s ability to localize a long - lived source on the sky is related to the gw signal being modulated as a result of the detector s revolution and change of orientation when the constellation orbits around the sun ( fig .
[ fig : one ] ) .
even though most of the gw snr accumulates during the final stages of inspiral / coalescence for typical gw sources , reasonably good information on sky localizations must be available well before final coalescence since this information accumulates slowly , over the long signal modulation ( orbital ) timescale .
because of significant cross - correlations between sky localization and distance errors , it turns out that this argument is also largely valid for luminosity distance errors @xcite . figure [ fig : three ] shows the pre - merger time evolution of luminosity distance and angular sky localization errors for a representative black hole pair at @xmath18 .
errors improve quickly at early times but their evolution slows down considerably at late times . according to both panels , even accounting for random orientations of various source and detector angles ( shown as best , typical and worst cases ) , significant information is available days to weeks prior to the final coalescence @xcite .
including black hole spins in the analysis has been shown to result in significant improvements on the errors during the last few days to hours prior to coalescence @xcite . with the expected availability , by the time lisa is operational , of sensitive large field - of - view ( fov ) astronomical instruments for weak lensing and supernova studies , it becomes interesting to estimate the amount of time prior to merger during which the lisa sky localization falls within the fov of such an instrument .
when this happens , continuous monitoring of the designated sky area , until final coalescence , becomes possible .
@xcite have performed a detailed analysis of this possibility , using lsst and its @xmath19 deg@xmath11 fov as a reference .
figure [ fig : four ] shows results for representative equal - mass binaries , as a function of their total mass and redshift .
the various contours show that prospects for electromagnetic monitoring days to weeks before the coalescence are good for sources at redshifts @xmath13@xmath20 . monitoring for the best gw sources out to @xmath21-@xmath22
may even be possible @xcite .
a large variety of new galactic black hole astrophysics would be enabled by successful identifications of the host galaxies of coalescing black hole pairs .
we mention only a few possibilities here and refer the interested reader to @xcite and @xcite for additional discussions . from the black hole masses , spins and binary orientation ,
all accurately constrained by the gw signal , one would be able to study the physics of the post - merger accretion flow onto the remnant black hole @xcite with unprecedented accuracy .
this would include precise constraints on the eddington ratio of the accreting source , its emission and absorption geometries and possibly its jet phenomenology .
similarly , studies of the galactic host might tell us about the nature ( dry / wet ) and the timing of the galactic merger that resulted in the black hole binary coalescence . finally , measuring velocity dispersions , @xmath23 , for several host galaxies , together with the black hole masses known from the gw signal , would allow us to accurately map the evolution of the @xmath24@xmath23 relation with cosmic time , at least for such transitional objects as the hosts of coalescing black hole pairs .
another consequence of successfully identifying the host galaxies of coalescing black hole pairs is the possibility to draw a gravitational hubble diagram , i.e. one that relates the gravitational luminosity distances , @xmath2 , of these gw sources to the electromagnetic redshifts , @xmath9 , of their host galaxies .
one of the main interests of a gravitational hubble diagram arises from its immunity to common systematics affecting electromagnetic measurements .
indeed , a gravitational hubble diagram , which is based on gravitational distance measurements with self - calibrated sources , is not susceptible to any significant bias from absorption , scattering or reddening of gws . in practice , however , the value of such a diagram is limited by line - of - sight matter inhomogeneities , which generate weak lensing uncertainties on the gravitational @xmath2 measurement ( see fig .
[ fig : two ] ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
while the lensing effect can in principle be averaged out over many random lines - of - sights , it may not be possible to do so for coalescing pairs of massive black holes if lisa merger event rates are modest ( e.g. , a few tens per year at @xmath25 ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
weak lensing errors on individual measurements amount to distance uncertainties ranging from @xmath26 at @xmath27 to @xmath28 at @xmath29 ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , which makes a gravitational hubble diagram imprecise even at moderate redshifts .
the extent to which lisa events can be used to draw a meaningful hubble diagram will thus depend strongly on the actual distribution of massive black hole merger events with redshifts and the corresponding efficiency of host galaxy identifications . as we describe in [ sec : wd ] , however , white dwarf spiraling into massive black holes may offer a practical avenue for precision cosmology with lisa .
the possibility that the accelerated expansion of the universe results from a failure of general relativity has fueled much theoretical work on large scale modifications of gravity over the past few years . since building a satisfactory theory of modified relativistic gravity is a formidable task , any insight that can be gained from direct observational constraints on the linearized gw regime can not be overlooked .
lisa , with its ability to measure the gw signal from cosmologically - distant sources , may thus be one of our best probes of modified gravity on cosmological scales @xcite .
one may expect gravity modifications to contain a new length scale , @xmath30 , beyond which gravity deviates from general relativity . in order to explain the observed accelerated expansion of the universe
, this scale is expected to be of the order of the current hubble radius , @xmath31 .
an existence proof of modifications of this type is given by dgp gravity @xcite , a braneworld model with an infinite extra dimension .
@xcite discuss the possibility that extra - dimensional leakage of gravity in dgp - like scenarios may lead to cosmologically - distant gw sources appearing dimmer than they truly are , from the loss of gw energy flux to the extra - dimensional bulk .
indeed , in the presence of large distance leakage , flux conservation over a source - centered hypersphere requires that the gw amplitude scales with distance @xmath32 from the source as @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the total number of space - time dimensions accessible to gravity modes .
thus , for @xmath35 , it deviates from the usual @xmath36 scaling . in principle
, black hole merger events and associated host galaxies could thus reveal the leakage of gravity over scales of order a few hubble distances , by comparison to purely electromagnetic hubble diagrams , which are immune to such leakage effects .
this is only one of several possible modified gravity signatures in the gws from cosmologically - distant sources @xcite .
another class of signatures is related to the gw polarization signal , with possibly additional polarizations beyond the two transverse quadrupolar ( @xmath7 ) modes of general relativity ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
. signatures also exist in relation to the gw propagation velocity which , in modified gravity scenarios , can differ from the speed of light . in this respect , the possibility to time a cosmological gw , relative to an electromagnetic signal causally associated with the black hole merger , may offer unique diagnostics of large - scale modified gravity .
this could reveal , for instance , that the phase of the gw signal deviates from general relativistic expectations , once propagated over cosmological distances .
@xcite have explored further the possibilities of measuring photon and graviton arrival times from a same cosmological source .
a general difficulty with this approach is that there will be a systematic and a priori unknown delay in the emission of photons , relative to the emission of gravitons , since the former must causally lag behind the perturbing gravitational event .
this difficulty could be overcome if it were possible to calibrate the relative timing of the photon and graviton signals at the source .
prior to coalescence , gas present in the near environment of the black hole binary would be gravitationally perturbed in such a way that it could radiate a variable electromagnetic signal with a period closely matching that of the leading - order quadrupolar perturbation induced by the coalescing binary ( see fig .
[ fig : five ] ) .
this would help identify the electromagnetic counterparts of specific gw events .
in addition , it may be possible to match the variability frequencies of the electromagnetic and gw signals .
the offset in phase between the fourier components of the two signals with similar frequencies could be used to effectively calibrate the intrinsic delay in electromagnetic emission at the source .
late inspiral and coalescence can be tracked via the gw signal , so that the relative timing of the gravitational and electromagnetic signals may be known to within a fraction of the binary s orbital time .
any drift in arrival - time with frequency between the gravitational and electromagnetic chirping signals , as the source spans about a decade in gw frequency during the last 2 weeks before merger , could then be attributed to a fundamental difference in the way photons and gravitons propagate over cosmological distances .
for instance , such a drift could occur if the graviton is massive , resulting in a frequency - dependent propagation velocity ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this tracking possibility is illustrated graphically in fig .
[ fig : five ] .
interestingly , while lorentz invariance has been extensively tested for standard model fields , lorentz symmetry could be violated in the gravity sector , especially on cosmological scales ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . with a good enough understanding of the source , electromagnetic counterparts to black hole binary mergers may offer unique tests of lorentz violations in the gravity sector , via the opportunity to match and track the gravitational and electromagnetic signals in frequency and phase .
it may be possible , as the black hole binary decays toward final coalescence , spanning a range of frequencies , to measure the delays in graviton vs. photon arrival times as a function of increasing frequency of the chirping signal .
the consistency expected if lorentz symmetry is satisfied in the gravity sector could be tested explicitly for gravitons propagated over cosmological scales . to have any chance to perform such new tests of gravitational physics , one will need to identify the electromagnetic counterparts of coalescing pairs of massive black hole binaries as early as possible .
this may be one of the strongest motivations behind ambitious efforts to localize these rare , transient events well before final coalescence .
as seen before , a large number of sources must be accumulated to turn a gravitational hubble diagram into a high precision tool for cosmology .
white dwarf frequently spiraling into ( moderately ) massive black holes may offer unique opportunities in this respect .
an additional goal of the lisa mission is the detection of gws emitted by compact objects being captured by massive black holes ( the so - called extreme mass ratio inspirals , or emris ) . @xcite
present a detailed parameter estimation analysis for this class of lisa events and show that they could be detected with good snr out to a distance @xmath37 gpc .
in addition , these authors found that the sky localization errors for these events ( @xmath38 steradians at @xmath37 gpc ) are comparable to the case of black hole binary merger events .
no electromagnetic counterpart is expected from emris of dense neutron stars or stellar - mass black holes . on the other hand , partial ( or total ) disruptions of inspiraling low - density white dwarfs ( wds )
could produce such counterparts and thus help identify host galaxies for such events . to the best of our knowledge
, the possibility to find the electromagnetic counterparts of this subclass of lisa emris and use them for precision cosmology has not been previously discussed in the literature . as a result of its relatively low density ,
a typical wd suffers complete disruption around a non - spinning black hole of mass @xmath39 .
this mass limit is increased to perhaps @xmath40 if the black hole is spinning rapidly @xcite . even if the wd were not disrupted , some level of partial shedding of its lower density outer layers ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) may be expected as the inspiral proceeds . as the stream of debris from a partially stripped wd shocks against itself or the inspiraling wd ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , some level of electromagnetic emission during such emris is expected .
a tidally - triggered detonation of the wd is yet another possibility @xcite .
all these arguments point to the possibility that electromagnetic counterparts may exist for a subset of all the emris detected by lisa ( the one corresponding to wd inspirals ) .
the fraction of all emris which involve wds is , indeed , expected to be substantial @xcite .
if electromagnetic counterparts for a subset of all lisa emris can be detected , the rewards will be significant .
just like black hole binary merger events , emris with uniquely identified counterparts and host galaxies could be used to draw a gravitational hubble diagram , with the significant advantages that , at redshifts as low as @xmath41@xmath42 , weak lensing due to line - of - sight inhomogeneities would be small or negligible ( fig .
[ fig : two ] ) and that the @xmath2@xmath9 relation at these low redshifts is strongly sensitive to the dominant dark energy content .
dark energy becomes dynamically significant , affecting the expansion rate and geometry of the universe , and modifying @xmath2 , at @xmath43 ( see , e.g. * ? ? ?
* for a review ) .
indeed , as emphasized by @xcite , once cosmic microwave background anisotropies are measured by planck , @xmath2 will be known accurately at @xmath44 , and a low redshift ( @xmath45 ) measurement will provide the best complement to constrain dark energy parameters . wd emris detections with lisa will occur frequently , and they could perhaps be singled out on the basis of the comparatively low mass of the inspiraling compact object .
it remains to be determined how the lisa sky localization error evolves with pre - merger ( or pre - disruption ) time for such events and what is the nature of their electromagnetic counterparts .
but altogether , the various advantages that we have outlined point to the need for a detailed assessment of the potential use of wd emris for precision cosmology with lisa .
for centuries , astronomers have measured distances exclusively with light .
direct gravitational measurements , gravitational hubble diagrams and comparisons between the propagation of electromagnetic and gravitational signals offer fundamentally new ways to probe physics on cosmological scales . the novelty involved in joint
, time - constrained electromagnetic and gravitational measurements will require that special efforts be made to reach out across the gw and astronomy communities .
|
the notion that microparsec - scale black holes can be used to probe gigaparsec - scale physics may seem counterintuitive , at first . yet , the gravitational observatory _
lisa _ will detect cosmologically - distant coalescing pairs of massive black holes , accurately measure their luminosity distance and help identify an electromagnetic counterpart or a host galaxy .
a wide variety of new black hole studies and a gravitational version of hubble s diagram become possible if host galaxies are successfully identified .
furthermore , if dark energy is a manifestation of large - scale modified gravity , deviations from general relativistic expectations could become apparent in a gravitational signal propagated over cosmological scales , especially when compared to the electromagnetic signal from a same source .
finally , since inspirals of white dwarfs into massive black holes at cosmological distances may permit pre - merger localizations , we suggest that careful monitoring of these events and any associated electromagnetic counterpart could lead to high - precision cosmological measurements with _ lisa_.
|
narrow - line seyfert 1 galaxies ( nls1s ) are a special and interesting group of active galactic nuclei ( agns ) .
they show narrow optical balmer emission lines [ fwhm(h@xmath0 ) @xmath1 2000 km s@xmath2 , weak [ ] @xmath35007 emission ( [ ] /h@xmath4 ) , strong emission , and soft x - ray excess @xcite .
nls1s show remarkable radio - loud / radio - quiet bimodality @xcite .
only @xmath5 of nls1s are radio - loud objects @xcite .
the fraction is much smaller than that found in qsos .
very radio - loud nls1s ( rl - nls1s , @xmath6 ) are even much fewer ( @xmath7 ) @xcite , where the radio loudness @xmath8 is commonly defined as the flux ratio of radio to optical at @xmath9 @xcite .
so far , it is still a puzzle why rl - nls1s are so scarce . at present ,
the origin of rl - nls1s is also still poorly understood .
a few efforts have been made in the past few years to understand the nature of rl - nls1s .
yuan et al .
( 2008 ) found that the broadband spectra of some rl - nls1s are similar to those of high - energy - peaked bl lac objects , and suggested that some of them may be bl lac objects actually . basing upon the recent observation taken by _
satellite , some rl - nls1s display a hard x - ray component suggesting the presence of relativistic jets on the line of sight @xcite .
the presence of the relativistic jets motivates us to search for intranight optical variability in some rl - nls1s , because of the well - known beaming effect ( e.g. , wagner & witzel 1995 ) .
@xcite argued that sdssj094857.3 + 002225 is a right candidate for searching for rl - nls1s with beaming effect .
the object is a very radio - loud nls1 at @xmath10 .
the reported radio loudness derived from the radio flux at 5 ghz ranges from 194 to 1982 @xcite .
it is in the crates catalog as a flat - spectral radio source @xcite .
the simultaneous observations taken by both _ swift _ and _ fermi _ also suggest that the broadband spectral energy distribution is similar to those of flat - spectral radio quasars @xcite .
recent photometry from the guide star catalogs 2.21 is @xmath11 mag @xcite .
previous studies revealed multi - wavelength variabilities in the object at timescales from day to year .
previous radio observations indicate its fluctuation in the radio band on the timescale from weeks to years @xcite .
@xcite also said that the object shows long - term variability in both the radio and optical bands .
the amplitude of the variation in the radio can be @xmath12 within a year .
the long - term variability amplitude may be about 1 mag in the optical band .
the latest multi - wavelength campaign carried out by @xcite discovered an optical variability on day timescales .
dramatic flux variabilities in both x - rays and radio 37 ghz were also found in the study . in this letter , we report an optical monitor for the rl - nls1 sdssj094857.3 + 002225 .
the monitor was designed to search for intranight optical variability ( inov ) in the object .
the inov should be detected if the object indeed hosts a relativistic jet beaming toward the observers .
our observations were carried out at the xinglong observatory of national astronomical observatories , chinese academy of sciences ( naoc ) , using the 80 cm tnt telescope .
the telescope is a cassegrain system with a @xmath13 beam .
a liquid nitrogen cooled pi va1300b 1300@xmath141340 ln ccd was used as the detector that covers @xmath1511 arcmin@xmath16 of the sky .
each pixel of the ccd corresponds to @xmath170.5 arcsec@xmath16 .
gain and readout noise of the ccd is 2.3 electrons adu@xmath18 and 5 electrons , respectively . the standard johnson _ b_- and _ r_-band filters were used in the observations .
we monitored the object on seven moonless nights in 2009 .
they are february 27 , march 1 , 5 , and april 2426 , and 28 .
the typical exposure time is 600 s for each frame .
continuous monitoring for this object was run as long as possible in each night .
the sky flat - field frames in both _
b _ and _ r _ passbands were obtained before and after each observation run during the twilight time .
dark frames are not needed because the temperature of the detector is so low ( @xmath19c ) that the dark electrons can be entirely ignored .
the observed data are preliminarily reduced through the standard routine by iraf package , including bias and flat - field corrections .
several bright comparison stars are selected from the same ccd frame to calculate differential light curve . because the comparison stars are brighter than the object ,
several check stars with brightness comparable to the object are selected to assess the errors in photometry .
the instrumental magnitudes of the object and of those selected stars are calculated by the apphot task .
the aperture photometry is adopted because the object is a point - like source without extended emission . in each frame , the fwhm of the object is comparable with those of the field stars .
the circular aperture radius twice of the mean fwhm of the field stars was therefore adopted in our calculations .
all the results reported below are based on these radii .
our observations can be divided into two parts . both of them contain about 1 week .
the source was well monitored on the nights of 2009 february 27 , march 1 , march 5 , april 25 , and april 28 .
( the corresponding dates on the time - axis of figure 1 are 3345 , 3347 , 3351 , 3402 , and 3405 , respectively . )
there were no or only scarce data on the other nights because of the bad weather .
the intrinsic brightness of the comparison stars was obtained by the formulae given by lupton ( 2005 ) and the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) database was used .
then the apparent magnitudes of the object can be calculated from the differential instrumental magnitudes .
the light curves of the observations are plotted in figure 1 .
the upper two light curves show the variation of the object in the _ b _
( by blue solid squares ) and _ r _
( by red solid circles ) bands .
the corresponding variations of the comparison stars are plotted by the bottom to light curves .
the fluctuations of the comparison stars are not larger than 0.05 mag .
the error bars overplotted on the light curve are estimated from the selected check stars with brightness comparable to that of the object .
in addition to a long - term variation with amplitude about 1 mag , the obtained light curves indicate that there were several nights during which the inov can be clearly identified in the object in both the _ b _ and _ r _ bands .
the variations in both bands are similar to each other .
the amplitudes of the rapid variations are so large that the short - term variability is quite obvious on 2009 march 1 , 5 , and april 25 .
in particular , the weather was relatively good on 2009 march 1 and april 25 , which results in relatively smaller error bars .
for example , the typical error bars on april 25 are 0.05 mag and 0.02 mag in the _ b _ and _ r _ bands , respectively .
the brightness of the object changes about 0.50.6 mag in both bands within several hours on the same night .
the inset in figure 1 shows the details of the variation within 4 hr on the night of april 25 .
although the errors are relatively large on the nights of march 5 and april 28 because of the relatively poor weather , the presence of inov can still be identified from the observations . when we do aperture photometry , there is a problem that whether the contamination from the host galaxy of the target agn contributes to the light variability .
some authors argued that the fluctuations in the seeing may result in spurious variable contributions from the host galaxy within the photometric aperture , especially when the apertures are small @xcite .
we argue that the contamination from the host galaxy is not important in the current study .
first of all , no clear features of the host galaxy could be identified from the images taken by sdss , likely because the object is far away from us ( at @xmath20 ) .
thus , the host galaxy is much fainter than the agn .
second , as described above , the photometry apertures we adopted in this study are twice of the fwhm of field stars , which is large enough to include most of the emission from the underlying host galaxy .
the particular rl - nls1 galaxy sdssj094857.3 + 002225 was monitored in optical bands by naoc 80 cm tnt telescope to search for its inov phenomenon .
our optical monitoring indeed provides clear evidence for the presence of inov in both the _ b _ and _ r _ bands in the object .
the object exhibits optical variability not only on the timescale of a week , but also on several hours .
the detection of the inov indicates that the object contains a relativistic jet on the line of sight of an observer , which confirms the conclusion drawn from the high - energy observations ( e.g. , abdo et al .
2009a , 2009b ) and from the inverted radio spectrum and high brightness temperature ( zhou et al .
2003 ) .
sdssj094857.3 + 002225 is particular for its observational properties . on the one hand ,
its optical spectrum with strong emission is typical of nls1s .
the narrow h@xmath0 emission yields a relatively low black hole ( bh ) mass @xmath21 and a high eddington ratio ( zhou et al .
2003 ) . on the other hand ,
some observational behaviors are characteristic of blazars with the relativistic jets close to the line of sight , such as the inov detected here , flat radio spectrum , high brightness temperature , and variable @xmath22-ray emission ( see citations in section 1 ) .
so far , outstanding rl - nls1s with blazer - like radio emission have been revealed by multi - wavelength observations in several cases including the object sdssj094857.3 + 002225 .
we refer the reads to yuan et al .
( 2008 ) for a brief summarization . with the successful launch of _ fermi _ satellite , @xmath22-ray emission was detected in four rl - nls1s , including the object studied here , which suggests the presence of fully developed jets in these objects @xcite .
the authors argued that the four rl - nls1s may form a new class of @xmath22-ray agns because of their small bh masses , large eddington ratios , and possibly disk - like morphology of the host galaxies .
the intrinsic mechanism of rl - nls1s is an attractive field .
there are two possible models for interpreting rl - nls1s .
the first one is the inclination model @xcite .
the model suspects that the ( at least a fraction of ) rl - nls1s are preferentially viewed pole - on .
the observed narrow width of the balmer emission lines could be resulted from small inclination if the broad - line region ( blr ) is constrained to a plane @xcite .
in fact , there is some evidence supporting a flat blr in some rl - agns @xcite . in this scenario ,
the bh mass is largely underestimated in these objects since the current available estimation of the bh mass of agn from single - epoch spectroscopic observation comes from an assumption of an isotropic distribution of the broad - line clouds with random orbital inclinations @xcite .
although the inclination model sounds reasonable because it is able to shift the location of rl - nls1s on the @xmath8@xmath23 plane to the massive bh end @xcite , the massive bhs are not supported by the lack of massive bulges in several cases in which the host galaxies can be resolved .
the second is the accretion mode model @xcite .
the rl - nls1s with small bh masses are accreting close to or even above the eddington limit .
low - mass bhs may lead to narrow emission lines when keplerian velocities are considered mostly @xcite .
the accretion is thought related to the radio emission .
different accretion modes may result in different phenomena and maybe can explain the differences in the radio loudness .
accretion processes are known related to the spin of the accreting bhs .
so the rapid spin of bhs may also affect the radio loudness of nls1s @xcite .
it is possible that accretion mode combining with bh spin can explain the nature of the rl - nls1s .
although our monitor indicates that the extremely high radio emission in rl - nls1 sdssj0948 + 57.3 + 002225 is mainly contributed from the beamed non - thermal jet with a small viewing angle ( can also be found in the aforementioned other studies ) , more information is needed in the future to investigate the origin of the relativistic jet .
we are very grateful to dr .
s. komossa for her helpful discussion and useful suggestions .
this work was supported by the chinese natural science foundation through grants nsfc 10803008 and nsfc 10873017 .
it was also supported by the 973 program ( 2009cb824800 ) .
boller , t. 1997 , astron .
nachr . , 318 , 209 cellone , s. a. , romero , g. e. , & combi , j. a. 2000 , , 119 , 1534 foschini , l. , maraschi , l. , tavecchio , f. , ghisellini , g. , gliozzi , m. , & sambruna , r. m. 2009 , adv .
space res . , 43 , 889 healey , s. e. , romani , r. w. , taylor , g. b. , sadler , e. m. , ricci , r. , murphy , t. , ulvestad , j. s. , & winn , j. n. 2007 , , 171 , 61 komossa , s. , voges , w. , xu , d. , mathur , s. , adorf , h. m. , lemson , g. , duschl , w. , & grupe , d. 2006 , , 132 , 531 komossa , s. 2008 , revista mexicana de astronomia y astrofisica conference series , 32 , 86 lacy , m. , laurent - muehleisen , s. a. , ridgway , s. e. , becker , r. h. , & white , r. l. 2001 , , 551 , l17
|
sdssj094857.3 + 002225 is a very radio - loud narrow - line seyfert 1 ( nls1 ) galaxy . here
, we report our discovery of the intranight optical variability ( inov ) of this galaxy through the optical monitoring in the _ b _ and _ r _ bands that covered seven nights in 2009 .
violent rapid variability in the optical bands was identified in this rl - nls1 for the first time , and the amplitudes of the inov reaches 0.5 mag in both the _ b _ and _ r _ bands on the timescale of several hours .
the detection of the inov provides a piece of strong evidence supporting the fact that the object carries a relativistic jet with a small viewing angle , which confirms the conclusion drawn from the previous multi - wavelength studies .
|
in the study of physics , the stability criteria of a system or configuration is one of the main interesting aspects .
unstable system or configurations are generally not realizable in nature and they are generally an intermediate stage in the dynamical evolution of a system . a black hole system in general relativity can also be put in the above mentioned category : the question one asks there is whether a black hole which is stable under some perturbation , i.e. if we perturb the black hole from outside , whether it comes back to its original state after some time or whether the perturbation grows unbound making the black hole unstable .
the study of black hole perturbations remains an extremely intriguing topic which has enormous effect on various important properties of a black hole @xcite .
in general , the dynamical evolution of perturbations of a black hole background can be classified into three stages , the first of which consists of an initial outburst of wave , depending completely on the initial perturbing field , the second stage consists of damped oscillations , known in the literature as the quasinormal modes ( qnm ) whose frequency turns out to be a complex number , the real part representing the oscillation frequency and the imaginary part representing damping .
qn frequencies completely depend on the background and not on the field which is causing the perturbation and thereby giving immense importance to these modes which are used to determine the black hole parameters ( mass , charge and angular momentum ) .
the third is a power law tail behaviour at very late times .
the equations governing the black hole perturbations in most of the cases can be cast into a schrdinger like wave equation .
the qnms are solutions to the wave equation with complex frequencies with a boundary condition which are completely ingoing at the horizon and purely outgoing at asymptotic infinity . with the first ever detection of the gravitational wave @xcite
the interest in studying black hole perturbations has gained another peak .
apart from the fact that the qn frequencies contain important information about the black hole parameters , they were also found to be important from the point of view of ads / cft correspondence .
it has been found that qnms in ads space - time appear naturally in the description of the dual conformal field theory on the boundary @xcite , thereby directing the study of qnms towards ads black holes @xcite .
although the qnms are classical in origin , they have been shown to provide glimpses to quantum nature of black holes @xcite . however , in the present work we will be focussing on the second of the above three stages of evolution of black hole perturbation in a regular black hole background in asymptotically de sitter space - time .
the importance of studying black holes in de sitter space lies in the fact that our universe looks like asymptotically de sitter at very early and late times .
recent observational data also indicates that our universe is going through a phase of accelerated expansion @xcite , thereby providing the existence of a positive cosmological constant
. in general de sitter space turns out to be a maximally symmetric solution to the vacuum einstein equations with a positive cosmological constant . just like the ads / cft correspondence
, a holographic ds / cft duality exists between gravity in de sitter space and conformal field theory on the boundary in one less dimension @xcite .
coming back to the perturbations and stability of black holes in de sitter space , there have been a lot of work @xcite-@xcite on quasinormal modes of scalar , electromagnetic , gravitational , dirac perturbations , decay of charged fields , asymptotic quasinormal modes , and signature of quantum gravity etc . on another front
, it is well known that general relativity is plagued with the appearance of singularities .
the problem of avoiding the singularities in general relativity , therefore , is one of the most fundamental ones and it is a very old problem . in this regard ,
`` regular black hole '' solutions play a central role .
when a black hole does not have a space - time singularity at the origin , it is termed as a `` regular black hole '' in the literature .
the first solution of such regular black holes with non - singular geometry satisfying the weak energy condition were obtained by bardeen @xcite , which is now known as the bardeen black hole .
however , the solution bardeen proposed lacked physical motivation because the solution was not a vacuum solution , rather gravity was modified by introducing some form of matter and thereby introducing an energy momentum tensor in the einstein s equation .
the introduction of the energy - momentum tensor was done in an _ ad hoc _ manner . much later , ayn - beato and garca @xcite showed the energy momentum tensor to be the gravitational field of some magnetic monopole arising out of a specific form of non - linear electrodynamics .
subsequently , many other solutions @xcite-@xcite , motivating the avoidance of singularity was proposed in the literature .
there were many works published regarding such regular black holes : stability properties @xcite , qnms @xcite , thermodynamics @xcite and geodesic structure @xcite of regular black holes to mention a few . very recently
fernando @xcite has proposed a de sitter branch for the regular bardeen black hole and calculated the grey body factor for such a black hole . in this paper
, we will be discussing the qnms of the bardeen de sitter ( henceforth bds ) black hole due to scalar ( both massless and massive ) and dirac perturbations . although study of scalar field perturbations in a black hole background and its corresponding qnms is not new , the dirac field perturbations , on the other hand , are relatively less studied . therefore , apart from the scalar perturbations , it will also be interesting to study the dirac perturbations in the regular black hole backgrounds in de sitter space .
the plan of the paper is as follows : in the next section we briefly discuss the bds black hole . in section 3
we present a brief discussion of wkb method along with a study of the scalar qnms of the bds black holes .
section 4 deals with the dirac quasinormal modes of the bds black hole .
finally , in section 5 we conclude the paper with a brief discussion on future directions .
in this section , we will briefly discuss the bardeen de sitter ( bds ) black hole following the works of fernando @xcite .
the author of this paper modified the works of @xcite to incorporate a positive cosmological constant in the action : @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the ricci scalar and @xmath2 is function of the field strength tensor of the non - linear electrodynamics @xmath3 and its form is given by @xmath4 in the above , the parameter @xmath5 is related to the magnetic charge and the mass of the black hole in the following manner : @xmath6 . if one derives the equations of motion from the above action([action ] ) , then following equations will be arrived at @xmath7 it was shown in @xcite that a static spherically symmetric solution for the above set of equations exist : @xmath8 with @xmath9 being given @xmath10 the solution of @xmath11 gives the horizon and in the particular case of bds black hole there may be three real roots implying three horizons : the black hole inner and outer horizons along with the cosmological horizon .
there lies the possibility of getting either one real root corresponding to cosmological horizon only for a set of parameters of this theory or a possibility of getting degenerate roots corresponding to a merger of the inner and outer black hole horizons for a range of parameters @xmath12 and @xmath13 .
structurally the bds black hole is similar to the reissner - nordstrm - de sitter ( rnds ) or born - infeld de sitter ( bids ) black holes which also admits a possibility of three distinct horizons as well as a single or degenerate horizons .
however , it was shown in @xcite that the event horizon is larger in the case of rnds black hole compared to a bds one
. the interesting nature of bds geometry is its non - singular structure everywhere .
it can be checked by direct calculation that all the scalar curvatures @xmath1 , @xmath14 , @xmath15 are finite everywhere except for the electromagnetic field invariant @xmath16 which is singular at @xmath17 @xcite .
in this section we will consider the massless and massive scalar field perturbations of the bds black hole geometry to study the behaviour of the qnms in bds background with the given black hole parameters .
as discussed in section 2 , bds background metric is given by equations ( [ metric ] ) and ( [ fr ] ) .
the klein - gordon equation for a massless scalar field @xmath18 is @xmath19 which explicitly takes the form @xmath20 as usual , we introduce the ansatz for @xmath18 as , @xmath21 with the above ansatz , we have the standard schrdinger - like wave equation for the perturbation of the bds metric by a scalar field is given by @xmath22 where , @xmath23 .
the coordinate @xmath24 is the standard tortoise coordinate related to radial coordinate @xmath25 as @xmath26 .
the advantage of using the tortoise coordinate lies in the fact that the range of the coordinate now extends between @xmath27 to @xmath28 , whereas in the old radial coordinate @xmath25 , the physically accessible region lies between the black hole and cosmological horizon .
note also that the potential @xmath29 as @xmath30 .
it can be easily seen by plotting the scalar field potential against the radial coordinate ( ) for various values of the multipole number @xmath31 that the @xmath32 mode has a distinct local minimum between the black hole outer horizon and the cosmological horizon ( see fig .
1 ) , which was also pointed out in @xcite . for this reason , the method used in this paper to evaluate the qnms for the bds black hole ,
namely , the wkb approach is not a valid one to evaluate qnms for @xmath32 modes .
therefore , from now on , we will only talk about @xmath33 modes for the massless scalar qnms of bds black hole .
as already stated , we will solve the wave equation for complex qn frequencies semi - analytically , using the sixth order wkb method developed in @xcite .
it has been shown extensively in literature that wkb method works extremely well for determining qn frequencies .
the sixth order wkb method is more accurate than the third order method and the former in fact gives results practically coinciding with those obtained from full numerical integration of the wave equation @xcite for low overtones , i.e. for modes with small imaginary parts , and for all multipole numbers @xmath34 .
the sixth order formula for a general black hole potential @xmath35 is mentioned below @xmath36 where @xmath37 is peak value of @xmath35 , @xmath38 , @xmath39 is the value of the radial coordinate corresponding to the maximum of the potential @xmath35 and @xmath40 is the overtone number .
qn frequencies @xmath41 would be of the form @xmath42 . in equation([qnmeqn ] ) , @xmath43 and @xmath44 are given by @xcite @xmath45\\ \lambda_3=&\frac{(n+\frac{1}{2})}{2v^{''}(r_0)}\big[\frac{5}{6912 } \left ( \frac{v_0^{(3)}}{v^{''}(r_0 ) } \right)^4(77 + 188b^2)\nonumber\\ & -\frac{1}{384 } \left ( \frac{(v_0^{(3)})^2 v_0^{(4)}}{(v^{''}(r_0))^3}\right ) ( 51 + 100b^2)\nonumber\\ & + \frac{1}{2304}\left ( \frac{v_0^{(4)}}{v^{''}(r_0)}\right)^2(67 + 68b^2)\nonumber\\ & + \frac{1}{288}\left(\frac{v_0^{(3)}v_0^{(5)}}{(v^{''}(r_0))^2}\right)(19 + 28b^2)\nonumber\\ & -\frac{1}{288 } \left(\frac{v_0^{(6)}}{v^{''}(r_0)}\right)(5 + 4b^2)\big].\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the above expression @xmath46 , @xmath47 at @xmath48 and @xmath49 , @xmath50 and @xmath51 can be found in the appendix of @xcite .
the above method also works extremely well in the eikonal limit of large @xmath31 corresponding to large quality factor , which will also be discussed in the paper . using eqn ( [ qnmeqn ] ) , we computed the qnms and in we plotted re @xmath41 and magnitude of i m @xmath41 vs black hole mass .
both re @xmath41 and i m @xmath41 decreases when mass @xmath52 is increased . in table
i , we list the values of the qn frequencies obtained by using third order and sixth order wkb approach for the parameter range @xmath53 and @xmath54 .
the data from the table suggests that the value of the real part of the frequency shows a steady increase over its third order outcome but on the other hand , the negative imaginary part obtained using sixth order wkb method shows a steady decline when compared to the third order result .
p3cmp3cmp3.5cmp3.5 cm multipole number & overtone & 3rd order wkb & 6th order wkb + + @xmath31=1&n=0 & 0.300446 -0.089967i & 0.302242 -0.090150i + & n=1 & 0.278912 -0.278097i & 0.282993
-0.277074i + + + & n=0 & 0.499385 -0.088861i & 0.499841 -0.088903i + @xmath31=2&n=1 & 0.485040 -0.269800i & 0.486281 -0.269658i + & n=2 & 0.461291 -0.456456i & 0.462177 -0.458553i + + + & n=0 & 0.698242 -0.088552i & 0.698417
-0.088563i + @xmath55=3&n=1 & 0.687778 -0.267316i & 0.688277 -0.267273i + & n=2 & 0.669085 -0.449812i & 0.669173 -0.450547i + & n=3 & 0.644523 -0.635942i & 0.643394 -0.640730i + + + & n=0 & 0.897184 -0.088421i & 0.897268 -0.088426i + & n=1 & 0.888985 -0.266272i & 0.889230 -0.266255i + @xmath31=4&n=2 & 0.873746 -0.446645i & 0.873717 -0.446952i + & n=3 & 0.853024 -0.629992i & 0.851862 -0.632179i + & n=4 & 0.828001 -0.815925i & 0.825285
-0.823178i + + + & n=0 & 1.09619 -0.088354i & 1.09624 -0.088356i + & n=1 & 1.08946 -0.265738i & 1.08960 -0.265730i + & n=2 & 1.07666 -0.444914i & 1.07663 -0.445061i + @xmath31=5&n=3 & 1.05883 -0.626438i & 1.05796 -0.627545i + & n=4 & 1.03691 -0.810304i & 1.03452 -0.814191i + & n=5 & 1.01159 -0.996158i & 1.00748 -1.005740i + + in and we plot the behaviour of low lying qn frequencies vs @xmath13 and @xmath56 for different @xmath31 .
both the plots reveals that re @xmath41 and i m @xmath41 decreases with increasing @xmath13 .
real part of frequencies still increasing steadily with g increased and imaginary part decreases in magnitude .
we have also computed the qn frequencies for larger multipole number @xmath31 with overtone @xmath57 only .
we plot for @xmath31 ranging between 1 to 40 in while we have fixed the values of @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath57 .
re(@xmath41 ) increases linearly with @xmath31 @xcite while magnitude of im(@xmath41 ) first decreases and remains constant for larger @xmath31 . to examine the field oscillations
, we will define the quality factor(q.f ) as @xmath60 we plotted the q.f versus the parameters @xmath13 and @xmath56 in .
quality factor increases with increasing @xmath56 and decreases with an increase in @xmath13 .
thus , q.f implies that oscillations will be more with larger magnetic charge @xmath56 and decay faster for small @xmath13 .
it is worth mentioning here that by computing the lyapunov exponent ( the inverse of the instability timescale associated with the geodesic motion ) , one can show that , in the eikonal limit , qnms of black holes in any dimensions are determined by the parameters of the circular null geodesics @xcite .
this is a very strong result and is independent of the field equations .
the only assumption goes into the calculation is the fact that the black hole space - time is static , spherically symmetric and asymptotically flat .
however a non - trivial example of non - asymptotically flat near - extremal schwarzschild de sitter black hole space time was also discussed in this context .
the same argument can be applied in case of bds black holes too in the limit of near - extremal nariai or cold black holes where either the black hole horizon and the cosmological horizon merges or the inner and outer horizon coincides . in these limits , it may be possible to get the eikonal limit using the wkb method following @xcite . for massive scalar perturbation the klein gordon equation
is given by @xmath61 where @xmath62 is scalar field mass .
similarly , we chose the ansatz as in equation ( [ ansatz ] ) and finally , we have the schrdinger - like equation and modified effective potential as @xmath63 where the tortoise coordinate @xmath24 is related to @xmath25 by @xmath26 . in
, we plot the effective potential @xmath64(@xmath25 ) vs @xmath25 for different scalar mass ( @xmath62 ) .
we have chosen the parameters @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 vs @xmath25 for various masses(@xmath62),width=302 ] notice that the peak of the potential depends on the scalar field mass @xmath62 with other parameters fixed . since qnms are known to be the waves trapped within the peak of this potential @xcite . as discussed in @xcite
, we expect similar behaviour for bds black hole that the imaginary part of the quasinormal modes frequencies will decrease for large @xmath62 .
however , the real part of qnms will increase as @xmath62 increases . in and
, we have plotted the variations of imaginary and real part of @xmath41 versus scalar field mass @xmath69 for different fixed values of parameters @xmath13 , @xmath52 , @xmath56 and @xmath70 .
we have plotted all the data obtained by 3rd , 4th , 5th and 6th order wkb calculations simultaneously to compare the accuracy between different orders .
we observed from the plots of both im(@xmath41 ) and re(@xmath41 ) that for low overtone number @xmath40 , the accuracy between lower and higher order wkb is not much significant but for large @xmath40 deviation is more .
indeed , the magnitude of im(@xmath41 ) decreases with increasing scalar mass as expected , on the contrary , the magnitude of re(@xmath41 ) increases with increasing field mass . in table
ii , we present the numerical values of qn frequencies with corresponding parameters . since it is well known that wkb method is more accurate for @xmath71 , we have tabulated the qnms frequencies for @xmath71 only . [ cols="<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] [ ii ] as in massless case , we plot in and the behaviour of qn frequencies with @xmath13 and @xmath56 for @xmath57 and @xmath72 respectively .
re(@xmath41 ) increases with increasing value of magnetic charge @xmath56 while magnitude of im(@xmath41 ) decreases .
this behaviour of qnms can be well understood from the form of the potential . as the height of the potential peak increases with @xmath56 , therefore real part of qnms increases . on the other hand
, shows that re(@xmath41 ) decreases with an increase in cosmological constant(@xmath13 ) but im(@xmath41 ) increases with @xmath13 in magnitude .
similarly if we plot the variation of potential with @xmath13 the height decreases , thus i m ( @xmath41 ) increases .
hence , we can say for scalar field perturbations with the scalar mass included , the oscillations decay faster with large cosmological constant @xmath13 and oscillates better for large magnetic charge @xmath56 .
in this section , we will extend our discussion to massless dirac perturbations for bds black holes . as in @xcite , by starting from dirac equation in spherically symmetric curved background , the schrdinger - like equation we finally arrived at is given by @xmath73 where @xmath24 is the tortoise coordinate given by @xmath74 , @xmath75 is the energy .
the effective potentials is given by @xmath76 it is worth mentioning here that the potentials @xmath77 and @xmath78 corresponding to dirac particles and anti - particles are supersymmetric to each other and derived from the same superpotential @xmath79 .
we will evaluate the quasinormal modes by solving equation [ [ sc1 ] ] taking only @xmath77 as it is well known that both dirac particles and anti - particles have the same quasi - normal spectra @xcite . in
, we showed the behaviour of the effective potential ( @xmath77 only ) for bds black hole with spherical harmonic @xmath70 for parameters @xmath80 ) vs @xmath25 for different values of @xmath31 for the massless dirac perturbations , width=226 ] we have computed the massless fermion qnms semi - analytically using sixth order wkb method.the plots are shown below . in , we showed the variation of real and imaginary part of @xmath41 with cosmological constant @xmath13 and in , the variation with magnetic charge @xmath56 for different values of @xmath31 with fixed overtone number are shown .
we can clearly see from the plots that re(@xmath41 ) slowly increases with an increase in the magnetic charge @xmath56 of the bds black hole whereas it slowly decreases with increasing value of @xmath13 . whereas the behaviour of the imaginary part of the frequency reverses its role , i.e. as we increase the cosmological constant , the imaginary part increases , however , it decreases if we increase the magnetic charge , keeping all other parameters fixed .
in this paper , we have discussed the massless and massive scalar field perturbations and the massless fermionic perturbations for a regular bds black hole .
we have used sixth order wkb approximation method to calculate the qnms frequencies .
we studied how the frequencies vary as a function of the scalar field mass ( @xmath62 ) , multipole number ( @xmath31 ) as well as with the parameters like the cosmological constant ( @xmath13 ) , black hole mass ( @xmath52 ) and magnetic charge ( @xmath56 ) .
we found that the qn frequencies decrease with an increase in black hole mass @xcite .
the plots of frequencies versus the scalar mass show that re @xmath41 increases with mass @xmath62 while i m @xmath41 decreases .
the figures also suggested that if we plot the frequencies from low to higher overtones taking into account different wkb orders , we see that comparative accuracy is better for @xmath81 .
we also found that re @xmath41 decreases with an increase in cosmological constant @xmath13 for scalar ( both massless and massive ) perturbations as well as with dirac perturbations but i m @xmath41 decreases in massless and fermionic case however , increases for the massive case when @xmath13 is increased .
we have also studied the behaviour of how the q - factor for the massless scalar field varies with @xmath13 and @xmath56 . for massive scalar perturbations ,
we see that mass @xmath62 enhances the field oscillations and decreases the damping for small @xmath13 , unlike in the massless case where it is just the opposite . in all the three scenarios
real frequency of oscillations re @xmath41 increases steadily with magnetic charge ( @xmath56 ) but the damping denoted by i m @xmath41 decreases . for future directions , it would be interesting to study the time evolution of perturbations for this particular black hole .
apart from that , in @xcite , the authors have used the conformal properties of the spinor field to obtain the dirac qnms for a higher dimensional schwarzschild - tangherlini black hole .
they have described these modes in the light of the so - called split fermion models , where quarks and leptons exist on different branes in order to keep proton stability .
such split fermion theories also have massive fermions in the bulk and it will be interesting to study such massive dirac perturbations in the context of higher - dimensional generalization of the bds black holes .
spphys kokkotas k d and schmidt b g 1999 _ living rev .
* 2 * 2 nollert h - p 1999 _ class .
quantum grav . _
* 16 * r159 berti e , cardoso v and starinets a o 2009 _ class.quant.grav .
_ * 26 * 163001 konoplya r a and zhidenko a 2011 _ rev.mod.phys . _
* 83 * 793 - 836 abott b p et al .
2016 _ phys .
* 116 * 241102 birmingham d , sachs i and solodukhin s n 2002 _ phys .
lett . _ * 88 * 151301 birmingham d , sachs i and solodukhin s n 2003 _ phys . rev .
_ * d67 * 104026 horowitz g t and hubeny v e 2000 _ phys .
_ * d62 * 024027 ; konoplya r a 2002 _ phys .
rev . _ * d66 * 044009 cardoso v and lemos j p s 2001 _ phys
_ * d63 * 124015 hod s 1998 _ phys .
_ * 81 * 4293 motl l and neitzke a 2003 _ adv .
theor . math .
phys . _ * 7 * 307 maggiore m 2008 _ phys.rev.lett . _ * 100 * 141301 perlmutter s _ etal _ 1997 _ astrophys
. j. _ * 483 * 565 riess a g et al .
1998 _ astron .
j. _ * 116 * 1009 tegmark m et al .
2004 _ phys .
_ * d69 * 103501 strominger a 2001 _ jhep _ * 0110 * 034 strominger a 2001 _ jhep _ * 0111 * 049 abdalla e , castello - branco k h c and lima - santos a 2002 _ phys.rev . _ * d66 * 104018 konoplya r a 2003 _ phys . rev . _ * d68 * 124017 konoplya r a and zhidenko a 2004 _ jhep _ * 06 * 037 ; zhidenko a 2004 _ class . quant . grav . _ * 21 * 273 cardoso v and lemos j p s 2003 _ phys
. rev . _ * d67 * 084020 molina c 2003 _ phys .
rev . _ * d68 * 064007 lopez - ortega a 2006 _ gen .
* 38 * 1565 lopez - ortega a 2006 _ gen .
grav . _ * 38 * 743 lopez - ortega a 2007 _ gen .
_ * 39 * 1011 lopez - ortega a 2008 _ gen .
_ * 40 * 1379 smirnov a a 2005 _ class .
* 22 * 4021 bardeen j m 1968 _ proceedings of gr5 ( tbilisi ) _ 174 ayn - beato e and garcia a 2000 _ phys .
_ * b493 * 149 ayn - beato and garca a 1998 _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 80 * 5056 bronnikov k a 2001 _ phys .
* d63 * 044005 hayward s a 2006 _ phys .
lett . _ * 96 * 031103 dymnikova i 2004 _ class .
* 21 * 4417 bronnikov k a and fabris j a 2006 _ phys .
_ * 96 * 251101 moreno c and sarbach o 2003 _ phys .
rev . _ * d67 * 024028 flachi a and lemos j 2013 _ phys .
* d87 * 024034 fernando s and correa j 2012 _ phys .
* d86 * 64039 man j and cheng h 2014 _ gen .
grav . _ * 46 * 1559 zhou s , chen j and wang y 2012 _ int .
_ * d21 * 1250077 fernando s , arxiv : 1611.05337 [ gr - qc ] fernando s , correa juan 2012 _ phys . rev _ * d86 * 064039 cardoso v , berti e , witek h , zanchin v t 2009 _ phys.rev . _ * d79 * 064016 akira ohashi and masa - aki sakagami _ classical and quantum gravity _ * 21 * 3973 d. r. brill and j. a. wheeler , rev
* 29 * , 465 ( 1957 ) .
cho h t , cornell a s , doukas j and naylor w 2007 _ phys . rev _ * d75 * 104005 schutz b and will c m 1988 _ astrophys .
j. _ * 291 * l33 iyer s and will c m 1987 _ phys . rev _ *
d35 * 3621 konoplya r a 2003 _ phys . rev._*d68 * 024018 jing j l 2004 _ phys
. rev _ * d69 * 084009
|
we compute the quasi - normal ( qn ) frequencies for the regular bardeen de sitter ( bds ) black hole due to massless and massive scalar field perturbations as well as the massless dirac perturbations .
we analyze the behaviour of both real and imaginary parts of quasinormal frequencies by varying the black hole parameters .
|
magneto - optical ( mo ) effects have found important applications in data storage , telecommunications , imaging , spectroscopy,@xcite as well as in magnonics .
@xcite an increasingly broad application of nanotechnologies in these areas sets new requirements for novel mo devices by demanding , among other things , a stronger mo response and smaller dimensions .
for example , small dimensions are important for @xmath2d imaging systems based on holographic principles.@xcite such systems require a spatial light modulator ( slm ) a device used to modulate amplitude , phase , or polarisation of light waves in space and time .
basically , an slm device can produce high quality @xmath2d images if it possesses pixels sizes @xmath3 @xmath1 m and also is fast enough to address a large number of pixels within a single image frame .
slm devices exploiting mo effects have a very fast response time . however , their typical pixel sizes are @xmath4 @xmath1m.@xcite at the nanoscale , mo effects can be enhanced by using subwavelength diffraction gratings @xcite , magneto - photonic crystals , @xcite and nanoantennas , @xcite which are made of pure magnetic materials or consist of alternating magnetic - nonmagnetic layers . however , as a typical grating period is @xmath5 nm and there should be tens of periods to achieve optimal optical properties , the footprint of the grating is large .
magneto - photonic crystals often have comparable dimensions and suffer from similar disadvantages .
typical dimensions of ferromagnetic / normal metal nanoantennas @xcite can be much smaller than @xmath6 @xmath1 m because of magneto - plasmonic resonances which give an additional degree of freedom for light manipulation at the nanoscale.@xcite however , due to huge absorption losses in ferromagnetic metals , plasmonic resonance properties of such nanoantennas are not very strong as compared with nanoantennas fabricated of gold or silver ( nonmagnetic metals with relatively low absorption losses ) .
consequently , measures have to be taken to mitigate absorption losses , which can be done by reducing the amount of ferromagnetic metals and tailoring fano resonance effects.@xcite .
alternatively , by analogy with subwavelength gratings,@xcite losses in nanoantennas can be reduced by using magneto - dielectrics instead of ferromagnetic metals .
normally , magnetic gratings , photonic crystals and nanoantennas are used to enhance the faraday rotation and kerr effect in different configurations .
@xcite for instance , if the incident light is @xmath7-polarised and the static external magnetic field is applied perpendicularly to the plane of incidence , the so - called transverse mo kerr effect ( tmoke ) @xcite is observed in the reflection mode .
less well - known are transverse mo effects observed in the transmission mode .
these effects are similar to the tmoke but occur in transparent magnetic films or plates @xcite .
an example of a transverse mo effect in the transmission mode is the transverse faraday effect ( tfe ) .
@xcite this effect can be used in imaging , data storage systems and magnonics .
the tfe has been observed in transparent magnetic plates and fabry - perot resonators .
@xcite because the tfe response is amplified as a result of the wave propagating back and forth within a magnetised medium , it is enhanced in a fabry - perot resonator . however ,
a typical fabry - perot resonator consists of a @xmath8 @xmath1m - thick plate of a transparent magnetic material sandwiched between a pair of mirrors , which in turn consist of @xmath9 alternating layers of high- and low - refractive - index quarter - wave - thick dielectrics.@xcite consequently , the dimensions of the resonator are also very large , which makes it unsuitable for miniaturisation . in this paper , we predict and demonstrate theoretically a large multifrequency tfe in single microspheres made of bi@xmath10-substituted yttrium - iron magnetic garnet ( bi : yig ) .
bi : yig is a magneto - dielectric exhibiting large mo activity and high transparency in the visible and infrared spectral ranges.@xcite by exploiting high - quality factor resonances of a bi : yig microsphere we show a strong tfe response at multiple wavelengths at the same time .
the strength of the predicted tfe is comparable with the strength of the tmoke in subwavelength magnetic gratings .
@xcite moreover , the observed tfe response is higher than that in micron - thick transparent magnetic plates .
@xcite however , the dimensions of a single sphere are significantly smaller as compared with the area occupied by a subwavelength grating or the thickness of a plate used in modern mo devices .
the problem of light scattering by a homogeneous sphere of arbitrary diameter and dielectric permittivity is exactly soluble by using the mie theory.@xcite whereas the mie theory can be extended to calculate the scattering by homogeneous magnetic spheres described by their magnetic permeability @xcite , the problem of light scattering by a sphere magnetised along a certain coordinate direction is more difficult .
this is because the dielectric permittivity becomes a tensor describing the interaction between the light and the static external magnetic field ( or the internal magnetisation of the medium)@xcite @xmath11 by considering bi : yig as an isotropic material , the three diagonal elements of @xmath12 become identical , and in the presence of a static external magnetic field along the _
y_-axis , there is a non - zero off - diagonal element @xmath13 , which couples the _ x_- and _ z_-components of the optical electric field @xmath14 due to low absorption losses in bi : yig the refractive index @xmath15 and @xmath13 of bi : yig can be assumed to be real and also frequency - independent over a narrow range of wavelengths : @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
@xcite because bi : yig is a ferrimagnetic material , the spin - orbit coupling is the dominant source of the mo interaction and it makes @xmath13 proportional to the magnetisation @xmath18 of the medium .
@xcite by considering the off - diagonal elements of @xmath12 in the mie theory , one can take into account the physical mechanisms responsible for the mo kerr and faraday effects contribution to the optical response of a sphere .
@xcite it has been shown that the mo kerr effect in a homogeneous cobalt sphere is small but detectable.@xcite the small mo response of cobalt spheres is due to large optical@xcite and magneto - optical@xcite absorption effects in this ferromagnetic metal .
considerable optical absorption losses are typical of all metals , including gold and silver . these losses have long been known to be the drawback of metallic nanostructures used in photonic devices such as , e.g. , nanoantennas .
@xcite consequently , a large and growing body of research investigates all - dielectric nanostructures , e.g. , low - loss single - sphere nanoantennas .
@xcite in this context , the use of bi : yig as the model material of the microsphere opens up opportunities to overcome the drawback of metallic ferromagnetic spheres .
it is also worth noting brillouin light scattering ( bls ) from spin - wave modes in uniformly magnetised ferromagnetic and ferrimagnetic spheres .
@xcite the fluctuation of magnetisation due to spin - wave modes causes a time - dependent change of the dielectric permittivity tensor @xmath19 of the material of the sphere .
the contribution of the transverse magnetisation to @xmath19 allows generating a description of bls by processes in which a single spin - wave quantum ( magnon ) is created or destroyed . in this case , bi : yig still can be used as the model material of the microsphere because bls has been used to study nonlinear spin wave phenomena in bi : yig structures.@xcite furthermore , microspheres can also be made of pure yttrium iron garnet ( yig ) , which is a very well - known material used in magnonics.@xcite finally , both semiconductor and ferromagnetic properties have been established in some of the rare earth mononitrides , which thus attract interest for the potential to exploit the spin of charge carriers in spintronics . @xcite the refractive index of these materials is @xmath20 and they are also transparent in the visible and infrared spectral ranges.@xcite most significantly , these materials also exhibit significant mo activity.@xcite thus , they might be employed instead of bi : yig . fig .
@xmath6(a ) schematically shows the scattering by an arbitrary homogeneous nonmagnetic sphere . by applying the mie theory for nonmagnetic spheres @xcite
we show that the intensity of the forward scattered light [ @xmath21 in fig .
@xmath6(a ) ] has multiple peaks in the spectral range @xmath22 , where @xmath23 is the diameter of the sphere and @xmath24 is the wavelength in the free space [ fig .
@xmath6(b ) ] .
the intensity of the backscattered light ( @xmath25 ) in this spectral range is low .
this implies that at the resonance the single microsphere has a very directive far - field emission pattern [ fig .
@xmath6(c ) ] . for example , in order to achieve the maximum forward - scattering intensity in the visible spectral range a bi : yig sphere with the diameter @xmath26 @xmath1 m is needed .
it is noteworthy that a nonmagnetised sphere with @xmath27 @xmath1 m will be in the so - called multi - stripe domain state.@xcite basically , light can be scattered by the stripe domain structure.@xcite however , the strength of this process is very low and it can be neglected , i.e. we will assume that a nonmagnetised bi : yig sphere has the optical properties of a homogeneous nonmagnetic sphere with the same refractive index . the application of the static magnetic field orientated along the
_ y_-axis [ fig .
@xmath6a ] will magnetically saturate the sphere by aligning the direction of magnetisation inside the sphere along the _ y_-axis .
therefore , in the saturated state the mo properties of the sphere can be modelled by using the tensor @xmath12 [ eq . ( @xmath6 ) ] . in this case
, the conventional mie theory can not be applied ; it must be extended employing , e.g. , a perturbation approach.@xcite alternatively , approximate approaches such as , e.g. , a modified discrete dipole approximation ( dda ) @xcite may be employed . however , these methods have disadvantages .
the perturbation approach requires the application of the green s function in spherical coordinates.@xcite the application of the dda to large mo spheres may require unaffordable computational efforts.@xcite consequently , we will use a finite - difference time - domain ( fdtd ) method .
@xcite although the fdtd method is also computationally demanding because it uses the staircase approximation of the surface of the sphere and thus requires a very fine finite - difference grid , its application to large mie scattering problems is known to produce accurate results.@xcite the computing power of a modern desktop computer is enough for these simulations .
furthermore , the fdtd can be applied to scatterers with a more complex shape than the sphere .
of course , in this case for scatterers of a complex shape one also needs to solve a micromagnetics problem to find the distribution of the magnetisation inside the scatterer .
the solid line in fig .
@xmath28 shows the forward - scattering intensity differential @xmath29 quantifying the strength of the tfe in the microsphere as a function of the normalised wavelength @xmath30 . in this case
, @xmath31 is the intensity of the forward - scattered light ( shown for reference in fig .
@xmath28 by the dashed line ) and @xmath32 is the saturation magnetisation for bi : yig .
the change in the sign of @xmath32 implies the change in the direction of the static external magnetic field by @xmath33 and it leads to the change in the sign of @xmath13.@xcite recall that a similar differential @xmath34 , being @xmath35 the reflectivity , is used to quantify the strength of the tmoke in gratings and other mo devices operating in the reflection mode.@xcite however , in contrast to all - magneto - dielectric gratings operating at a single wavelength,@xcite in fig . @xmath28 the multiple maxima of @xmath36
are observed at a multiple wavelength corresponding to the sharp resonances supported by the microsphere .
we note that the peak values of @xmath36 are of the same order of magnitude as the value of @xmath37 in the gratings.@xcite but the footprint of a single microsphere is much smaller than the area occupied by a grating . quantifying the strength of the tfe in the plate as a function of the angle of incidence @xmath38 for the wavelength in the free space @xmath39 nm . dashed line the transmittance @xmath40 of the nonmagnetised plate .
thanks to the one - dimensional character of the problem , these results were obtained using the fresnel formula for _ p_-polarised light .
@xcite , width=321 ] to further demonstrate the advantages of the microsphere over the existing mo devices used to enhance transverse mo effects , we calculate the tfe in a @xmath8 @xmath1m - thick plate made of bi : yig [ fig .
@xmath2(a ) ] .
such plates have practical applications in fabry - perot resonator - based mo devices.@xcite the considered plate is a one - dimensional scatterer with the spatial variation along the _ z_-direction so that @xmath41 .
therefore , for a _ x_- or _
y_-polarised incident wave , there is no _ z_-component of the optical electric and magnetic fields , and for the incident _ p_-polarised light the medium of the plate exhibits an effective refractive index @xmath42^{1/2}$ ] ( the medium does not exhibit mo activity for the _
s_-polarised light).@xcite due to the dependence of @xmath43 on @xmath13 the magnitude of the transmitted _
p_-light is sensitive to the magnetisation .
importantly , the tfe is not bipolar , so changing the direction of the static external magnetic field from @xmath44 to @xmath45 ( i.e. changing @xmath46 ) does not alter the magnitude of the transmission @xmath47 .
hence , the tfe is quantified by the differential @xmath48.@xcite importantly , the tfe can take place only in scatterers where a nonhomogeneous or leaky refracted wave is induced by a wave obliquely incident at the interface , i.e. the tfe vanishes at both the normal and grazing incidence.@xcite consequently , in fig .
@xmath2(b ) we plot @xmath49 as a function of the angle of incidence @xmath38 for the wavelength in the free space @xmath39 nm .
we note that at this wavelength a sphere with @xmath50 @xmath1 m would produce the maximum of the tfe response ( fig .
@xmath28 ) .
figure @xmath2(b ) shows that in the absence of the static external magnetic field the transmission curve @xmath40 for the _ p_-polarised light has multiple maxima due to interference effects .
the curve of the differential @xmath49 follows the behaviour of @xmath40 . around the brewster angle @xmath51 one
observes @xmath52 because vanishing surface reflectivity results in minimal interference effects .
it is noteworthy that for the chosen thickness of the slab , which is @xmath8 times larger than the diameter of the reference sphere @xmath50 @xmath1 m , the strength of the tfe is ten times smaller than in the sphere .
furthermore , in a @xmath6 @xmath1m - thick plate ( not shown ) the strength of the tfe plummets down because the interference effect is significantly weaker .
of course , the fabrication techniques for magnetic films and plates are very much well - established and less effort demanding than those for single magnetic microspheres .
however , the recent advances in making ultra - fine magnetic garnet particles make it possible to fabricate single scatterers with a close - to - spherical shape.@xcite yig powders with controllable individual particle sizes of @xmath53 @xmath1 m can be obtained by a microwave heating method.@xcite furthermore , a magnetic garnet microsphere can be fabricated using direct laser writing @xcite
. finally , laser - based printing techniques can potentially be applied.@xcite
we proposed an efficient scheme for enhancing the transverse faraday effect in single magneto - dielectric microspheres .
we investigated the scenario of a sphere made of a typical magnetic garnet exhibiting a realistically low absorption and high magneto - optical activity in the visible and infrared spectral ranges .
we demonstrated the transverse faraday effect of the order of @xmath54 , which is larger or comparable with typical values attainable with the modern mo devices which , however , have a significantly larger footprint as compared with microspheres
. our findings may find applications in nanophotonics , imaging , and magnonics .
this work was supported by the australian research council .
ism gratefully acknowledges a postdoctoral research fellowship from the university of western australia .
the authors thanks ass./prof .
p. metaxas for valuable discussions .
|
we propose using a single magneto - dielectric microsphere as a device for enhancing the transverse faraday effect at multiple wavelengths at the same time .
although the diameter of the sphere can be @xmath0 @xmath1 m , the numerically predicted strength of its magneto - optical ( mo ) response can be an order of magnitude stronger than in mo devices based on thick magnetic plates .
the mo response of a microsphere is also comparable with that of subwavelength magneto - dielectric gratings which , however , operate at a single wavelength and occupy a large area .
in contrast to gratings and thick plates , the compact size of the microsphere and its capability to support spin - wave excitations make it suitable for applications in nanophotonics , imaging systems , and magnonics .
|
the proper - motion observations of pulsars show that the pulsars had the kick velocity in the formation stage .
the young pulsars have proper velocity of @xmath4 @xcite .
the physical mechanism of such kick velocity may be due to the harrison
tademaru mechanism @xcite , anisotropic emission of neutrinos , anisotropic explosion and so on ( see lorimer @xcite for the review ) .
therefore , it is also reasonable to assume the existence of the proper motion of the pulsars in the formation process of pop iii nss , although there is no direct evidence since no pop iii star or pulsar is observed . while , repetto et al .
@xcite suggest that bhs also have a natal kick velocity comparable to pulsars from the galactic latitude distribution of the low mass x - ray binaries in our galaxy .
but , first , this is not the direct observation of proper motion of bhs , and second , since the mass of pop iii bhs is larger than pop i and pop ii bhs , their kick velocity might be so small that it can be neglected .
therefore , we take into account the natal kick for pop iii nss but not for pop iii bhs in this paper .
the kick speed @xmath5 obeys a maxwellian distribution as @xmath6 \,,\ ] ] where @xmath7 is the dispersion .
the details of the method how to calculate the natal kick are shown in ref .
@xcite . in this paper
, we perform population synthesis monte carlo simulations of pop iii binary stars .
we calculate the pop iii ns - bh and pop i and ii ns - bh for comparison .
pop i and pop ii stars mean solar metal stars and metal poor stars whose metallicity is less than 10% of solar metallicity , respectively . in this paper , we consider five metallicity cases of @xmath8 ( pop iii ) , @xmath9 and @xmath10 ( pop i ) .
there are important differences between pop iii and pop i and ii .
pop iii stars are ( 1 ) more massive , @xmath11 , ( 2 ) smaller stellar radius compared with that of pop i and ii , and ( 3 ) no stellar wind mass loss . these properties play key roles in binary interactions . in order to estimate the event rate of ns - bh mergers and the properties of ns - bh , we use the binary population synthesis method @xcite which is the monte calro simulation of binary evolution .
first , we choose the binary initial conditions such as the primary mass @xmath12 , the mass ratio @xmath13 , the separation @xmath14 , and the eccentricity @xmath15 when the binary is born .
these binary initial conditions are chosen by the monte calro method and the initial distribution functions such as the initial mass function ( imf ) , the initial mass ratio function ( imrf ) , the initial separation function ( isf ) , and the initial eccentricity distribution function ( ief ) .
we adopt these distribution functions for pop iii stars and pop i and ii stars as table [ idf ] . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ]
this work was supported by mext grant - in - aid for scientific research on innovative areas , `` new developments in astrophysics through multi - messenger observations of gravitational wave sources '' , no .
24103006 ( tn , hn ) , by the grant - in - aid from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ( mext ) of japan no .
15h02087 ( tn ) , and jsps grant - in - aid for scientific research ( c ) , no .
16k05347 ( hn ) .
a. g. lyne and d. r. lorimer , nature * 369 * , 127 ( 1994 ) .
b. m. s. hansen and e. s. phinney , mon . not .
soc . * 291 * , 569 ( 1997 ) [ astro - ph/9708071 ] .
e. r. harrison and e. p. tademaru , astrophys .
j. * 201 * , 447 ( 1975 ) .
d. r. lorimer , living rev .
* 11 * , 8 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0811.0762 [ astro - ph ] ] .
s. repetto , m. b. davies and s. sigurdsson , mon . not .
425 * , 2799 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1203.3077 [ astro-ph.ga ] ] .
j. r. hurley , c. a. tout and o. r. pols , mon . not .
roy . astron .
soc . * 329 * , 897 ( 2002 ) [ astro - ph/0201220 ] .
t. kinugawa , k. inayoshi , k. hotokezaka , d. nakauchi and t. nakamura , mon . not .
soc . * 442 * , 2963 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1402.6672 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
t. kinugawa , a. miyamoto , n. kanda and t. nakamura , mon . not .
soc . * 456 * , 1093 ( 2016 ) [ arxiv:1505.06962 [ astro-ph.sr ] ] . c. e. rhoades , jr . and r. ruffini , phys . rev .
lett . * 32 * , 324 ( 1974 ) .
j. b. hartle , phys .
rep , * 46 * , 201 ( 1978 ) r. m. kulsrud , r. cen , j. p. ostriker and d. ryu , astrophys . j. * 480 * , 481 ( 1997 ) [ astro - ph/9607141 ] . l. m. widrow , rev .
phys . * 74 * , 775 ( 2002 ) [ astro - ph/0207240 ] .
m. langer , j. l. puget and n. aghanim , phys .
d * 67 * , 043505 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0212108 ] .
k. doi and h. susa , astrophys .
j. * 741 * , 93 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1108.4504 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
h. nieuwenhuijzen and c. de jager , astron .
astrophys . * 231 * , 134 ( 1990 ) .
e. vassiliadis and p. r. wood , astrophys .
j. * 413 * , 641 ( 1993 ) .
r. m. humphreys and k. davidson , publ .
. soc . pac .
* 106 * , 1025 ( 1989 ) .
n. smith , ann .
astrophys .
* 52 * , 487 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1402.1237 [ astro-ph.sr ] ] . k. belczynski , t. bulik , c. l. fryer , a. ruiter , j. s. vink and j. r. hurley , astrophys . j. * 714 * , 1217 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0904.2784 [ astro-ph.sr ] ] .
j. s. vink and a. de koter , astron .
astrophys . *
442 * , 587 ( 2005 ) [ astro - ph/0507352 ] .
r. s. de souza , n. yoshida and k. ioka , astron .
astrophys . * 533 * , a32 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1105.2395 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
e. visbal , z. haiman and g. l. bryan , mon . not .
* 453 * , 4456 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1505.06359 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
t. hartwig , m. volonteri , v. bromm , r. s. klessen , e. barausse , m. magg and a. stacy , mon . not .
* 460 * , l74 ( 2016 ) [ arxiv:1603.05655 [ astro-ph.ga ] ] .
k. inayoshi , k. kashiyama , e. visbal and z. haiman , mon . not .
soc . * 461 * , 2722 ( 2016 ) [ arxiv:1603.06921 [ astro-ph.ga ] ] .
p. madau and m. dickinson , ann .
rev . astron .
astrophys . * 52 * , 415 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1403.0007 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
x. ma , p. f. hopkins , c. a. faucher - giguere , n. zolman , a. l. muratov , d. keres and e. quataert , mon . not .
soc . * 456 * , 2140 ( 2016 ) [ arxiv:1504.02097 [ astro-ph.ga ] ] .
a. fontana _ et al .
_ , astron .
astrophys .
* 459 * , 745 ( 2006 ) [ astro - ph/0609068 ] .
k. kawaguchi , k. kyutoku , h. nakano , h. okawa , m. shibata and k. taniguchi , phys .
d * 92 * , 024014 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1506.05473 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
d. keppel and p. ajith , phys .
d * 82 * , 122001 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1004.0284 [ gr - qc ] ] .
j. aasi _ et al .
_ [ ligo scientific and virgo collaborations ] , living rev . rel . *
19 * , 1 ( 2016 ) [ arxiv:1304.0670 [ gr - qc ] ] .
t. nakamura _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1607.00897 [ astro-ph.he ] . n. dalal , d. e. holz , s. a. hughes and b. jain , phys . rev .
d * 74 * , 063006 ( 2006 ) [ astro - ph/0601275 ] .
p. ajith _ et al .
. rev .
lett . * 106 * , 241101 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:0909.2867 [ gr - qc ] ] .
|
in the population synthesis simulations of pop iii stars , many bh ( black hole)-bh binaries with merger time less than the age of the universe @xmath0 are formed , while ns ( neutron star)-bh binaries are not .
the reason is that pop iii stars have no metal so that no mass loss is expected .
then , in the final supernova explosion to ns , much mass is lost so that the semi major axis becomes too large for pop iii ns - bh binaries to merge within @xmath1 .
however it is almost established that the kick velocity of the order of @xmath2 exists for ns from the observation of the proper motion of the pulsar .
therefore , the semi major axis of the half of ns - bh binaries can be smaller than that of the previous argument for pop iii ns - bh binaries to decrease the merging time .
we perform population synthesis monte carlo simulations of pop iii ns - bh binaries including the kick of ns and find that the event rate of pop iii ns - bh merger rate is @xmath3 .
this suggests that there is a good chance of the detection of pop iii ns - bh mergers in o2 of advanced ligo and advanced virgo from this autumn .
|
it has been known for several decades that bright low - mass x - ray binaries ( lmxbs ) are @xmath1 times overabundant in globular clusters ( gcs ) relative to the galactic field ( katz 1975 ; clark 1975 ) .
more specifically , gcs contain 13 of the @xmath1 bright galactic lmxbs , but only @xmath20.01% of the total stellar mass content of the galaxy .
the reason for this is thought to be the existence of _ dynamical _ lmxb formation channels , which are only available in dense gc cores .
potential channels include the direct collision of a neutron star ( ns ) with a red giants ( verbunt 1987 , davies et al .
1992 , ivanova et al .
2005 ) , the tidal capture of a main sequence star by a ns ( fabian , pringle & rees 1975 ; bailyn & grindlay 1987 ) and exchange interactions between nss and primordial binaries ( hilles 1976 ; rasio et al .
2000 ) .
if the dominant lmxb formation channels are different in gcs and the galactic field , the properties of their respective lmxb populations may also be different .
in particular , most of the bright lmxbs in gcs might be ultracompact x - ray binaries ( ucxbs ; bildsten & deloye 2004 , ivanova et al .
ucxbs , which are interacting binaries with extremely small binary separations ( @xmath3 cm ) and short orbital periods ( @xmath4 1 hr ) , appear to be rare amongst the galactic field lmxb population : the list of confirmed ucxbs ( with measured @xmath5 ) in int zand et al .
( 2007 ) contains only 5 objects that belong to this population .
by contrast , 3 of the 13 gc lmxbs are confirmed ucxbs ; these are 4u1820 - 30 in ngc6624 ( @xmath6 min , stella et al .
1987 ) , 4u1850 - 087 in ngc6712 ( @xmath7 min , homer et al .
1996 ) and cxoj212958.1 + 121002 in m15 ( = m15-x2 ; dieball et al . 2005 ) , with several more suggested to be ultracompact x - ray binaries on the basis of more indirect evidence ( see e.g. verbunt & lewin 2006 for a review ) . since the period distribution of gc lmxbs may be a direct tracer of the dynamical close encounters taking place in gc cores , it is important to establish orbital periods for as many of these sources as possible .
doing so could also lead to a significant increase in the size of the total ucxb sample .
this is desirable , because ucxbs are astrophysically important systems in their own right .
this is because they are laboratories for accretion and binary evolution in extreme settings , and because they are strong gravitational wave sources that may be detectable by lisa ( nelemans & jonker 2006 ; nelemans 2009 ) . here ,
we present time - resolved , far - uv photometry of the lmxb 4u 0513 - 40 in ngc 1851 , which was suspected to be a ucxb based on several strands of circumstantial evidence ( deutsch etal 2000 ; verbunt 2005 ; nelemans & jonker 2006 ; int zand etal . 2007 ) .
our far - uv data of this system contain a @xmath8 17 min periodic signal that is present in all four observing epochs , is consistent with being coherent and is probably caused by a reflection effect associated with the irradiated surface of the donor star in this system .
based on all this , we argue that the observed periodic variability is an orbital signature , and thus that 4u 0513 - 40 should be regarded as a confirmed ucxb with @xmath9 min .
ngc 1851 was observed three times with the f140lp filter in the solar blind channel ( sbc ) of the advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) on board the _
hst_. this instrument / detector / filter combination has a plate scale of 0.032 pixel@xmath10 , a pivot wavelength of @xmath11 , and an rms bandwidth of @xmath12 .
all of the observations took place in august of 2006 .
each observing epoch consisted of 4 _ hst _ orbits , broken up into a series of 90 second exposures . in total
, we obtained 273 of these exposures .
in addition , we also examined archival data taken in march of 1999 with the space telescope imaging spectrograph ( stis ) , using the fuv - mama / f25qtz detector / filter combination , with a plate scale of 0.025 pixel@xmath10 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
a full description of the data , as well as their reduction and analysis will be provided in a separate publication ( zurek et al .
2009 , in preparation ) .
briefly , all of the fuv count rates and magnitudes presented in this paper were calculated via standard aperture photometry techniques , as implemented in the _ daophot _ package within _
iraf_. for the photometry on our acs / sbc ( stis / fuv - mama ) images , we used an aperture radius of 4 ( 7 ) pixels and a sky annulus extending from 10 to 20 ( 15 to 35 ) pixels .
aperture photometry is sufficient for our purposes because the fuv image is not particularly crowded ( see figure 1 ) .
the wavelength - dependent throughput curves of the acs / sbc / f140lp and stis / fuv - mama / f25qtz instrument / detector / filter combinations are very similar , though not identical .
therefore we checked for far - uv variability by comparing the acs and stis count rates , after correcting for throughput differences and the different photometric aperture sizes and background regions that were used .
we have calculated this correction factor from a set of ( mostly blue horizontal branch ) stars that are common to both sets of images .
we find that for these stars , our acs / sbc count rates are 3.3 times larger than our stis / f25qtz ones .
homer et al . ( 2001 ) have already used the hst / stis / f25qtz observations to identify the optical / far - uv counterpart of 4u 0513 - 40 .
they confirm the suggestion of deutsch et al .
( 2000 ) that `` star a '' ( in the nomenclature of deutsch et al . ) is the correct counterpart to the lmxb , while two other blue sources previously suggested as possible counterparts by aurire , bonnet - bidaud & koch - miramond ( 1994 ) , designated as x-1 and x-2b , are inconsistent with the precise chandra position of 4u 0513 - 40 .
figure 1 shows the location of these 3 sources in our acs / sbc images . since homer et al .
( 2001 ) had already reported a negative search for far - uv variability associated with star a in the stis observations , we started by focusing on the newer , higher signal - to - noise acs data .
the acs - based far - uv light curves of all 3 objects are shown in figure 2 .
it is immediately obvious that star a , the counterpart proposed by deutsch et al .
( 2000 ) and homer et al .
( 2001 ) , does , in fact , exhibit strong far - uv variability , especially between the 3 observing epochs .
for example , the mean count rate drops by a factor of about 2 between epochs 2 and 3 .
no similar change in count rate is seen in either x-1 or x-2b , which bracket star a in far - uv brightness .
we then searched for _ periodic _ signals in the data by carrying out a power spectral analysis .
figure 3 shows the lomb - scargle power spectra calculated for all 3 sources from the combined acs data sets .
it is immediately obvious that only star a shows clear evidence of a signal at a frequency other than hst s orbital frequency ( @xmath15 ) .
more specifically , there is an obvious peak at a frequency of about @xmath16 c d@xmath10 ( which corresponds to a period of @xmath17 min ) . in an effort to better understand the star a power spectrum ( specifically the power excess at @xmath15 and the sidebands at @xmath18 ) ,
we have created a simple model light curve .
this model has exactly the same time sampling as the observations , contains a single 17-min periodic signal with amplitude 0.75 c s@xmath10 and accounts for the dominant long - term trend in the data by setting the simulated mean count rate in each epoch equal to the observed one .
the power spectrum generated from this simple noise free model is shown in the second panel of figure 3 ( labelled `` star a simulation '' ) , and clearly captures all of the main features of the data .
this shows that both the sidebands around @xmath19 and the strong apparent signal at @xmath15 are sampling artifacts .
the latter , in particular , is due to leakage from the low - frequency power excess associated with the long - term variability . in order to test
if the 17 min signal is persistent , we carried out power spectral analysis on each epoch independently , where we now also included the stis data that was obtained 7 years before the acs observations .
the result is shown in figure 4 .
the periodicity was indeed present in all 4 epochs ( 1 stis + 3 acs ) , but was noticeably weaker in the stis data and in the third acs epoch .
considered in isolation , the power excess at @xmath19 in each of those epochs would be marginally significant at best .
both figures 3 and 4 show that there are several possible aliases associated with the 17 min signal . in order to establish the relative likelihoods for each of these and get estimates of the errors associated with each of them
, we carried out a bootstrap analysis .
only the acs data was used for this purpose , since the signal is weakest in the stis data and since no unique cycle count can be assigned to the large time interval between the stis and acs observations .
we began by removing long - term trends from the data stream by estimating the mean count rate in each hst orbit and subtracting these averages from the data .
next , we created 1000 mock time series by sampling with replacement from the orbit - mean - subtracted acs data . finally , we created power spectra for all of these fake data sets and recorded the frequencies corresponding to peak flux .
the histogram created from this set of peak frequencies is shown in figure 5 ( superposed on the orbit - mean subtracted power spectrum for all of the data , which is shown as the shaded region ) . as expected from the power spectrum ,
there are clearly four dominant plausible aliases .
the relative number of bootstrap trials associated with each alias is a measure of the likelihood that this alias is the correct one ( see southworth et al 2006 , 2007 , 2008 and dillon et al . 2008 ) .
similarly , the location and width of the histogram peak associated with each alias provides a simple estimate of the period and period error for this alias .
our final results for the four viable aliases are : @xmath20 we also tried to establish more directly whether the periodic signal is consistent with being coherent across all of our epochs and whether the evidence for a changing amplitude is compelling . to this end
, we carried out a least - squares fit to the orbit - mean - subtracted stis+acs data set for star a. in this fit , the period was kept fixed at @xmath21 that are present in the power spectrum of the _ combined _ stis+acs data .
] , so the free parameters were the phase and amplitude ( both assumed to be constant across the data ) .
the result of this fit is shown in figure 6 .
it illustrates rather clearly that the amplitude is not constant across epochs .
as already noted above , the signal is strongest in acs epochs 1 and 2 and weakest in the stis data and acs epoch 3 .
the fit also shows that the assumption of constant phase is reasonable , i.e. the observed signal is consistent with being coherent across the entire data set . in order both to test further the coherence properties of the signal , and to determine its average waveform , we have folded the entire stis+acs data stream for star a onto the same ( sub-)alias that was adopted for the fit in figure 6 .
the result is shown in figure 7 , along with the phase - binned average waveform .
again , the data seem to be consistent with the idea that the signal is fully coherent . moreover , the average waveform is fairly simple and roughly sinusoidal . as a final step , we carried out separate fits with fixed period to each individual epoch in order to quantify the changing amplitude of the 17-min signal .
table 1 lists the mean count rates and absolute as well as fractional amplitudes of the signal as estimated from these fits .
the fractional amplitude varies by over a factor of 3 between epochs , from about 3% to 10% , with the largest change happening across the 6-day gap between acs epochs 2 and 3 .
it is also worth noting that there appears to be a correlation between the fuv brightness of the system ( i.e. the mean count rate ) and the amplitude of the 17-min signal , in the sense that the amplitude is highest when the system is brightest .
this correlation holds regardless of whether the amplitude is expressed in absolute or fractional terms .
it is worth noting that there is no inconsistency between our claim that the 17-min signal is present in the stis observations , and the non - detection of a periodicity in the same data set by homer et al .
( 2001 ) . as mentioned above
, the signal is only marginally detectable if this data set is analysed in isolation .
what makes the weak power excess in the stis observations convincing is that it is located at the same frequency as the obvious signal in the acs data set .
indeed , homer et al .
( 2001 ) place a formal upper limit of 5% on the amplitude of any signal between 5 min and 6 hrs .
this is entirely consistent with our own estimate of a 4% amplitude for the 17 min signal in the stis data ( see table 1 ) .
we have shown that the fuv counterpart to 4u 0513 - 40 in ngc 1851 exhibits a clear periodic signal with @xmath0 min .
this signal is roughly sinusoidal , has an amplitude of 3%-10% , is present in all four fuv observing epochs and is consistent with being fully coherent .
these properties are in line with those of the orbital signals seen in uv / optical observations of other ucxb ( e.g. homer et al .
1996 ; anderson et al . 1997 ; dieball et al . 2005 ) and with a simple model in which these signals are due to a `` reflection effect '' associated with the irradiated donor star in the system ( arons & king 1993 ) . in the arons & king ( 1993 ) model , there are two components that contribute to the fuv / optical light : the irradiated front face of the donor star ( which is likely to be a low - mass , helium - core white dwarf ) , and the accretion disk , whose energy budget is also dominated by irradiation . the observed orbital signal is due to the changing projected area of the irradiated face of the donor star , with the fractional amplitude being set by the relative contributions of the disk and donor to the phase - averaged fuv / optical light . we have checked that this simple irradiation model matches roughly the fractional fuv signal using reasonable choices of parameters ( including a moderate - to - high inclination ) .
the dependence on total fuv brightness is explained straightforwardly by different fuv responses of the donor and disk to variations in the irradiating x - ray luminosity . in this context , a factor of @xmath8 2 change in total fuv and fractional amplitude would requires roughly an order of magnitude variation in @xmath22 .
this is consistent with the x - ray variability of the source in the rxte data base , where factor of 10 changes in count rate are seen on time - scales as short as weeks . for comparison ,
the largest previously reported variations in x - ray luminosity from this source were a factor of 5 ( grindlay & hertz 1983 ) .
it seems likely that additional effects such as changes in radius , changes in reprocessing efficiency , and disk shielding , play a significant role in the variations of the amplitude of the uv oscillations .
based on all this , we are confident that the fuv signal we have discovered is orbital in nature and probably due to a simple reflection effect .
we therefore confirm 4u 0513 - 40 as a ucxb with @xmath17 min , making it the fourth confirmed ucxb in a galactic gc .
the identification of this system as a ucxb is entirely consistent with existing circumstantial evidence regarding its nature .
more specifically , the optical brightness , x - ray spectrum and burst properties of 4u 0513 - 40 have been known for some time to point towards a ucxb classification ( e.g. verbunt 2005 ) . given the extremely short orbital period we have measured , it is interesting to ask if the gravitational wave signal produced by this source would be detectable by lisa .
the gravitational radiation strain for a circular orbit is given in a convenient form by nelemans , yungelson & portegies zwart ( 2001 ) as : @xmath23 where @xmath24 , @xmath25 is the mass of the neutron star primary , and @xmath26 is the mass of the white dwarf donor , and with the power coming out entirely in the second harmonic , for a circular orbit .
if we adopt @xmath27 , @xmath28 kpc ( harris 1996 ) and @xmath29 ( suggested for this @xmath5 by the mass - radius relations in deloye & bildsten [ 2003 ] ) , we find a strain of @xmath30 .
this is at approximately the 1-@xmath31 level for a one year integration with lisa , suggesting that the system may be detectable if the mission lifetime is several years . in practice , this will , however , also depend on the strength and frequency - dependence of the gravitational - wave background due to double wds , which may become dominant in the relevant frequency regime ( @xmath32 mhz ; e.g. nelemans et al .
an additional challenge for detecting gravitational radiation from this object will be dealing with the possible effects of acceleration of the binary in the gravitational potential of the globular cluster , which could lead to a measurable frequency drift over several years , for which a correction would have to be made in order to keep all the gravitational wave power in a single frequency bin .
the fact that the position and period of the source are already known ( and the latter can still be substantially improved before lisa starts ) will be helpful in this context and also ameliorate the hidden trials problem .
we finally point out that , as more ucxb periods are being determined , it seems increasingly likely that there are significant differences between the period distributions of field and gc ucxbs .
all four of the confirmed gc ucxbs have @xmath33 min , whereas all five of the confirmed field ucxbs have @xmath34 min ( nelemans & jonker 2006 ; int zand , jonker & markwardt 2007 ) .
clearly , this comparison can not yet be taken at face value : the present numbers are still too small and selection effects have not been taken into account .
moreover , there is probably no absolute dividing line between the two orbital period distributions .
for example , the field lmxb 4u 1543 - 624 probably has an orbital period of around 18 minutes ( wang & chakrabarty 2004 ) , even though it is not yet included in the list of confirmed ucxbs given by nelemans & jonker ( 2006 ) and int zand et al .
( 2007 ) . nevertheless , the period distributions are in line with the expectation that different ucxb formation channels should dominate in the two different environments
. if so , it may be possible to use the period distribution of field ucxbs as a tracer of binary evolution , and that of gc ucxbs as a tracer of stellar dynamics in dense environments .
this work was supported by nasa through grant go-10184 from the space telescope science institute , which is operated by aura , inc .
, under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 .
we thank frank verbunt for pointing out that all known x - ray binaries with orbital periods less than half an hour are in globular clusters .
arons , j. & king , i. r. 1993 , apj , 413 , l121 aurire , m. , le fvre , o. & terzan , a. 1984 , a&a , 138 , 415 bailyn , c. d. & grindlay , j. e. 1987 , apj , 316 , l25 bildsten , l. & deloye , c. j. 2004 , apj , 607 , l119 clark , g. w. 1975 , apj , 199 , l143 davies , m. b. , benz , w. & hills , j. g. 1992 , apj , 401 , 246 deutsch , e. w. , margon , b. , & anderson , s. f. 2000 , , 530 , l21 dieball a. , knigge c. , zurek d.r .
, shara m.m .
, long k.s .
, charles p.a . ,
hannikainen d.c .
, van zyl l. , 2005 , apj , 634 , l105 dillon , m. , gansicke , b.t .
, augwerojwit , a. , rodriguez - gil , p. , marsh , t.r . ,
barros , s.c.c .
, szkody , p. , brady , s. , krajci , t. & oksanen , a. 2008 , mnras , 386 , 1568 fabian a. c. , pringle j. e. , rees m. j. , 1975 , mnras , 172 , 15p harris , w.e .
1996 , aj , 112 , 1487 hills j.g . , 1976 , mnras , 175p , 1 homer , l. , charles , p. a. , naylor , t. et al . 1996 ,
mnras , 282 , l37 homer l. , anderson s.f . , margon b. , deutsch e.w .
, downes r.a .
, 2001 , apj , 550 , l155 homer , l. 2003 , kitp workshop : `` the physics of ultracompact stellar binaries '' ( feb 1 - 2 , 2003 ) , coordinators : l. bildsten , d. chakrabarty , g. nelemans , http://online.itp.ucsb.edu/online/ultra_c03/homer int zand j. j. m. , jonker p. g. , markwardt c. b. , 2007 , a&a , 465 , 953 ivanova , n. , rasio , f. a. , lombardi , j. c. , dooley , k. l. & proulx , z. f. 2005 , apj , 621 , l109 katz , j. i. 1975 , nature , 253 , 698 nelemans , g. 2009 , arxiv:0901.1778 nelemans g. , jonker p. g. , 2006 , astro , arxiv : astro - ph/0605722 rasio , f. a. , pfahl , e. d. & rappaport s. 2000 , apj , 532 , l47 stella , l. , priedhorsky , w. , & white , n. e. 1987 , apj , 312 , l17 southworth , j. , gansicke , b.t . , marsh , t.r . , de martino , d. , hakala , p. , littlefair , s. , rodriguez - gil , p. & szkody , p. 2006
, mnras , 373 , 687 southworth , j. , marsh , t.r . , gansicke , b.t . ,
augwerojwit , a. , hakala , p. , de martino , d. & lehto , h. 2007 , mnras , 382 , 1145 southworth , j. , gansicke , b.t . , marsh , t.r .
, torres , m.a .. p . , steeghs , d. , hakala , p. , copperwheat , c.m .
, aungwerojwit , a. , & mukadam , a. 2008 , mnras , 391 , 591 verbunt , f. 1987 , apj , 312 , l23 verbunt f. , 2005 , in interacting binaries : accretion , evolution , and outcomes , aip conference proceedings , aip conference series , 797 , 30 verbunt f. , lewin w.h.g .
, 2006 , in _ compact stellar x - ray sources _ , cambridge university press : cambridge , uk ( w.lewin , m. van der klis eds . )
|
we present far - ultraviolet photometry obtained with the _ hubble space telescope _ of the low - mass x - ray binary 4u 0513 - 40 in the globular cluster ngc 1851 .
our observations reveal a clear , roughly sinusoidal periodic signal with @xmath0 min and amplitude 3%-10% .
the signal appears fully coherent and can be modelled as a simple reprocessing effect associated with the changing projected area presented by the irradiated face of a white dwarf donor star in the system .
all of these properties suggest that the signal we have detected is orbital in nature , thus confirming 4u 0513 - 40 as an ultracompact x - ray binary ( ucxb ) .
all four confirmed ucxbs in globular clusters have orbital periods below 30 minutes , whereas almost all ucxbs in the galactic field have orbital periods longer than this .
this suggests that the dynamical formation processes dominate ucxb production in clusters , producing a different orbital period distribution than observed among field ucxbs .
based on the likely system parameters , we show that 4u 0513 - 40 should be a strong gravitational wave source and may be detectable by lisa over the course of a multi - year mission .
|
suppose that at @xmath9 a gas of diffusing particles of constant density @xmath10 is brought in contact with a spherical absorber of radius @xmath0 in @xmath3 dimensions .
the particles are absorbed upon hitting the absorber .
remarkably , this simple setting captures the essence of many diffusion - controlled chemical kinetic processes @xcite .
the evolution of the _ average _ coarse - grained particle density of the gas is described by the diffusion equation @xmath11 , \label{difeq}\ ] ] where @xmath12 is the gas diffusivity . here
we will be interested in large fluctuations rather than in the average behavior .
one important fluctuating quantity is the number of particles @xmath13 that is absorbed during a long time @xmath2 .
we will focus on two questions : ( i ) what is the probability that @xmath14 , that is no particle hit the absorber until time @xmath2 ?
( ii ) what is the most likely history of the particle density of the gas conditional on the non - hitting until time @xmath2 ?
these questions also appear in the context of a search for an immobile target by a swarm of diffusing searchers , see e.g. ref . @xcite and references therein . this process has been studied extensively in the simplest case when the searchers are non - interacting random walkers ( rws ) . in this case @xmath15 , and the probability that the target survives until time @xmath2 , @xmath16 was found to exhibit the following long - time behavior @xcite : - , & @xmath17 , [ survivaldecay1 ] + , & @xmath18 , [ survivaldecay2 ] + ( d-2 ) _
dr^d-2 d_0 t , & @xmath7 , [ survivaldecay3 ] where @xmath19 is the surface area of the @xmath3-dimensional unit sphere , and @xmath20 is the gamma function .
equations ( [ survivaldecay2 ] ) and ( [ survivaldecay3 ] ) give the leading terms of the corresponding asymptotics at long times , when @xmath21 , i.e. , the characteristic diffusion length @xmath22 is very large compared to the target radius @xmath0 .
equation ( [ survivaldecay1 ] ) is independent of @xmath0 , and the parameter @xmath6 is irrelevant . as a result , eq .
( [ survivaldecay1 ] ) becomes valid as soon as @xmath2 is much larger than the inverse microscopic hopping rate .
the target survival problem is a particular case of a more general problem of finding the complete statistics of particle absorption by the absorber . for the rws
, this problem has been recently studied in ref .
@xcite . here
we extend the target problem in several directions .
first , we consider a lattice gas of _ interacting _ searchers . throughout
most of the paper , we assume that the searchers interact via exclusion .
this can be a good simplistic model for studying diffusion - controlled chemical reactions in crowded environments such as a living cell @xcite .
specifically , we will consider a lattice gas described by the symmetric simple exclusion process ( ssep ) . in this process
each particle can hop to a neighboring lattice site if that site is unoccupied by another particle .
if it is occupied , the move is disallowed .
the average behavior of this gas is still described by the diffusion equation ( [ difeq ] ) with @xmath23 @xcite , so the ssep and the rws are indistinguishable at the level of averages . however , as we show here , the long - time asymptotic of the target survival probability @xmath1 for the ssep behaves differently from that for the rws : @xmath24 this expression has the same structure as eq .
( [ survivaldecay3 ] ) , but it increases much faster with the gas density @xmath10 @xcite ; see fig .
[ arcsinsquared ] .
we note that previous results for the ssep only included bounds on @xmath25 @xcite .
second , we show that , for @xmath17 , the survival probability @xmath1 depends strongly on the initial condition
. this effect does not require inter - particle interaction , and it also occurs for the rws , as we show below . in particular , the asymptotic ( [ survivaldecay1 ] ) is only valid after averaging over random initial distributions of particles , that is , for the annealed setting @xcite .
we find a different result for a deterministic initial condition , also called a quenched setting @xcite .
for the rws , the two results for @xmath8 differ by a numerical factor . for the ssep
, even their @xmath10-dependence is different for @xmath17 .
third , we demonstrate that the two basic one - dimensional solutions , annealed and quenched , play a central role in higher dimensions when one is interested in _ intermediate _ asymptotics of @xmath1 for @xmath26 , that is when the diffusion length @xmath22 is much longer than the lattice constant , but much shorter than the absorber radius @xmath0 .
fourth , in addition to evaluating @xmath1 in different regimes , we also find the most likely history of the gas density conditional on the target survival until time @xmath2 .
we achieve this result , and most of the others , by employing the macroscopic fluctuation theory ( mft ) @xcite .
this coarse - grained large - deviation formalism was unavailable when most of the studies of the target survival probability were performed .
the mft is well suited for the analysis of large deviations in lattice gases , including the ( unlikely ) target survival at long times that we are dealing with here .
one of our central findings for the ssep is that , in the long - time regime , @xmath27 , the most likely gas density profile for @xmath7 is , for most of the time , almost stationary : @xmath28 , \ ] ] where the radial coordinate is rescaled by the diffusion length @xmath22 .
it is this density profile that determines the leading term ( [ actresultd ] ) of the survival probability .
last but not least , we extend our approach to a whole class of additional interacting diffusive gases . in the next section we present the mft formulation of the target survival problem .
section [ steady ] deals with @xmath29 for @xmath27 . here
@xmath8 is mostly contributed to by a _
stationary _ solution of the mft equations , independently of whether the setting is annealed or quenched .
we derive these solutions , evaluate @xmath30 and verify the results for @xmath31 by solving the mft problem numerically . in sec .
[ nonstat ] we study analytically and numerically the survival probability in non - stationary settings , deterministic and random , in all dimensions and at different densities . in sec .
[ extension ] we extend our results for @xmath29 to a broad class of interacting lattice gases .
our main results are summarized in sec .
[ discussion ] . in appendix
we present , for non - interacting rws , exact microscopic derivations of @xmath1 for the annealed and quenched settings and for @xmath17 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 . both the microscopic derivation and
the mft calculations show that , for @xmath34 , the leading contribution to @xmath8 is sensitive to the initial condition only in one dimension .
the macroscopic fluctuation theory ( mft ) was developed for the analysis of non - equilibrium steady states of diffusive lattice gases @xcite .
subsequently it was extended to a host of non - stationary settings @xcite .
the mft , and its extensions to reacting particle systems @xcite , have proven to be highly efficient and versatile . here
we outline the mft formulation , referring the reader to the above references for further details .
the starting point for the derivation of the mft can be a langevin equation that provides a faithful large - scale description to a broad family of diffusive gases : @xmath35 + \nabla \cdot \left[\sqrt{\sigma(n ) } \,\text{\boldmath$\eta$ } ( \mathbf{x},t)\right],\ ] ] where @xmath36 is a zero - average gaussian noise , delta - correlated both in space and in time @xcite . as one can see , a fluctuating diffusive gas is fully characterized by @xmath12 and another coefficient , @xmath37 , that comes from the shot noise and is equal to twice the mobility of the gas @xcite .
essentially , the mft formalism is a wkb theory ( after wentzel , kramers and brillouin ) of the functional fokker - planck equation following from the langevin equation ( [ lang ] ) .
the wkb theory employs , in a smart way , the typical number of particles in the relevant region of space as a large parameter @xcite . in the mft formalism , the particle number density field @xmath38 and the canonically conjugate
momentum " density field @xmath39 obey the hamilton equations @xmath40 , \label{d1 } \\
\partial_t p & = & - d(q ) \nabla^2 p-\frac{1}{2 } \,\sigma^{\prime}(q ) ( \nabla p)^2 , \label{d2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the prime denotes the derivative with respect to the argument .
equations and can be written in terms of variational derivatives : @xmath41 here @xmath42= \int d\mathbf{x}\,\mathcal{h}\ ] ] is the hamiltonian , and @xmath43 is the hamiltonian density . the spatial integration in eq .
( [ hamiltonian ] ) , and everywhere in the following , is performed over the whole space outside the target .
because of the rotational symmetry of the problem , we assume that the solution only depends on the radial coordinate and time .
we will consider the target survival problem in an arbitrary dimension @xmath3 .
the boundary conditions on the target are @xmath44 @xcite , where the condition on @xmath45 just fixes an arbitrary constant . far away from the target
the gas is unperturbed , so @xmath46 .
the boundary conditions in time are the following .
at @xmath9 we prescribe @xmath47 where , for the ssep , @xmath48 .
this is a deterministic , or quenched , initial condition , see refs .
a random initial condition ( that is , an annealed setting ) is considered in sec .
[ app : annealed ] . before focusing on the target survival problem ,
let us consider for a moment a slightly different setting where @xmath13 , the specified number of absorbed particles by time @xmath49 , is arbitrary .
this condition , @xmath50 = n,\ ] ] imposes an integral constraint on the solution .
this constraint is identical to the one arising in the problem of statistics of integrated current during a specified time @xcite . a similar derivation yields the following boundary condition for @xmath51 at @xmath49 : @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the heaviside step function , and @xmath54 is an a priori unknown lagrange multiplier that is ultimately set by eq . ( [ number ] )
accordingly , we demand @xmath55 .
the particular case of @xmath14 in which we are interested here corresponds to @xmath56 @xcite . in this case
the total particle flux to the target vanishes at all times @xmath57 . the solution of the mft equations for @xmath58 yields the optimal trajectory : the most likely density history of the system conditional on the number of absorbed particles @xmath13 .
once @xmath58 and @xmath59 are found , we can calculate the mechanical action @xmath60 which yields @xmath61 up to a pre - exponential factor : @xmath62 for the ssep @xmath63 and @xmath64 @xcite , and eq . ( [ actionmain ] ) becomes @xmath65 upon rescaling @xmath66 by @xmath2 and @xmath67 by @xmath22 @xcite , we can effectively put @xmath68 in eqs .
( [ number ] ) and ( [ pt ] ) and replace @xmath0 by @xmath69 and @xmath13 by @xmath70 everywhere .
equation ( [ actionmainssep ] ) for the ssep becomes @xmath71 where @xmath72 we are interested in the limit of @xmath73 as @xmath74 . in one spatial dimension ,
@xmath17 , the parameter @xmath0 ( and hence @xmath75 ) is irrelevant because of the translational symmetry of the ensuing mft problem .
we will consider this case in sec .
[ 1d ] . for @xmath29
there are two natural limiting cases : of small and large @xmath6 .
a small @xmath6 in the _ deterministic _ theory , described by eq .
( [ difeq ] ) , means that @xmath2 is much longer than the characteristic diffusion time @xmath76 needed for the gas density to approach a steady state around the target . as a result
, the average particle flux to the target can be determined by using the _ stationary _ solution of the diffusion equation . for @xmath15
this reduces to solving the laplace equation @xmath77 with the boundary conditions @xmath78 and @xmath79 , leading to @xmath80 we argue that same logic holds for _ fluctuations _ , including those responsible for the survival probability .
hence , when @xmath27 , the leading order contribution to the action @xmath60 from eq .
( [ actionmain ] ) comes from the _ stationary _ solution of the mft equations that obeys the boundary conditions in space , but not the boundary conditions in time . for such solutions eqs .
( [ d1 ] ) and ( [ d2 ] ) become @xmath81= j= \text{const } , \label{zeroflux}\\ & & \frac{d(q)}{r^{d-1 } } \,\frac{d}{dr}\left(r^{d-1 } v\right)+\frac{1}{2}\,\sigma^{\prime}(q ) v^2= 0 , \label{steadyv}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath82 .
the target survival implies that the particle flux at @xmath83 vanishes at all times @xmath57 .
therefore @xmath84 , and from eq . ( [ zeroflux ] )
@xmath85 . plugging this into eq .
( [ steadyv ] ) we obtain @xmath86 where @xmath87 is the spherically symmetric laplace operator in @xmath3 dimensions . for the ssep eq .
( [ steadyeqgen ] ) reads @xmath88 remarkably , the substitution @xmath89 reduces the nonlinear ordinary differential equation ( [ steadyssep ] ) to the spherically symmetric laplace equation in @xmath3 dimensions : @xmath90 the boundary conditions @xmath91 and @xmath92 become @xmath93 and @xmath94 . solving this problem and returning to @xmath95 , we obtain eq .
( [ qd ] ) .
this is the most likely density profile conditional on survival of the target until time @xmath2 .
now we can calculate @xmath96 : @xmath97}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in particular , for @xmath31 @xmath98 , \label{q3}\\ v(r ) & = & \frac{2\ell \arcsin\sqrt{n_0}}{r^2 \sin\left[2 \left(1-\frac{\ell}{r}\right)\,\arcsin \sqrt{n_0}\right]}. \label{v3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the asymptotic of @xmath99 near the target , @xmath100 is quadratic in @xmath101 .
also notable is a diverging asymptotic of @xmath102 near the target : @xmath103 which is independent of @xmath10 .
the asymptotic behaviors near the target assure that the particle flux to the target vanishes .
furthermore , each of the two terms in the flux , see eq .
( [ zeroflux ] ) , vanish separately . as it turns out , these features , including the one over the distance asymptotic ( [ vdiverge ] ) ,
are quite universal : they are observed , for @xmath104 , in the quenched and annealed settings and in all dimensions ( including @xmath17 where the mft solution is _
non_-stationary ) for all lattice gases that behave as non - interacting rws at low densities .
an example of the stationary gas density profile for @xmath31 is shown in fig .
[ 3dthnum ] . in spite of the singularity of @xmath96 at @xmath83 , the action ( [ actionscaled2 ] ) is bounded , and we obtain @xmath105 and arrive at eq .
( [ actresultd ] ) .
in particular , for @xmath31 @xmath106 and @xmath107 notice that as @xmath10 approaches @xmath108 , the asymptotic survival probability goes down rapidly but remains non - zero . as the solution ( [ qd ] ) and ( [ vd ] )
is stationary , the survival probability is independent , in the leading order , of whether the particles are distributed randomly or deterministically at @xmath9 . here for very long times , @xmath109 , the optimal fluctuation becomes unconstrained by the process duration , and details of the initial condition become irrelevant . as we will see in sec .
[ nonstat ] , the situation changes for @xmath17 , and for any @xmath3 when @xmath34 . for @xmath110 , eq .
( [ s3d ] ) reduces to eq .
( [ survivaldecay3 ] ) for the rws .
further , eqs .
( [ qd ] ) and ( [ vd ] ) become @xmath111^{-1}. \label{vdrw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] these low - density asymptotics for the ssep represent exact solutions for the rws , where @xmath63 and @xmath112 @xcite . the stationary solution
( [ qd ] ) and ( [ vd ] ) , or ( [ qdrw ] ) and ( [ vdrw ] ) , does not satisfy the boundary conditions in time . to accommodate these boundary conditions , the full time - dependent solutions of the mft problem must develop narrow boundary layers in time at @xmath9 and @xmath113 , cf .
the boundary layers only give a subleading contribution to @xmath114 .
we verified this scenario numerically for the ssep .
figure [ 3dthnum ] shows the density history obtained by solving the full non - stationary mft problem numerically for a sufficiently small @xmath6 and @xmath31 .
the numerical algorithm is described in sec .
[ numeric1d ] .
one can see that @xmath115 stays almost constant for most of the time and , at these times , agrees very well with the theoretical prediction ( [ q3 ] ) .
the rescaled action , found numerically from eq .
( [ actionscaled2 ] ) , is also close to the theoretical prediction , eq .
( [ s3d ] ) . in the marginal case of @xmath18 logarithmic corrections appear . for @xmath18 all non - constant solutions of the circularly - symmetric laplace s equation ( [ laplace ] )
diverge logarithmically with @xmath67 . as a result , a reasonable stationary solution of eq .
( [ steadyssep ] ) can only be obtained if we introduce a cutoff distance @xmath116 ( to remind the reader , all lengths are rescaled by @xmath22 ) : @xmath117 correspondingly , @xmath118 although there is a derivative jump in @xmath99 at @xmath119 , and divergence of @xmath96 at @xmath83 and @xmath119 , the flux is continuous ( and equal to zero ) everywhere .
the cutoff @xmath116 in these formulas should be chosen @xmath120 : in the original variables it is of the order of the characteristic diffusion length @xmath22 where the stationary solution crosses over to a time - dependent one .
the uncertainty the cutoff introduces only affects the argument of the logarithm . as a result , eqs .
( [ q2 ] ) and ( [ v2 ] ) are correct with logarithmic accuracy .
the same happens @xcite if one circumvents the tedious exact time - dependent solution of the two - dimensional ( @xmath121 ) diffusion equation ( [ difeq ] ) and solves instead the laplace equation @xmath77 for the purpose of computing the average particle flux onto the absorber .
the rescaled action is @xmath122^{-1}\arcsin^2\ !
\sqrt{n_0}$ ] with the same logarithmic accuracy .
thus @xmath123 for @xmath110 , eq . ( [ action2 ] ) reduces to eq .
( [ survivaldecay2 ] ) as expected .
in the short - time limit , @xmath26 , the deterministic theory of diffusion - controlled absorption is non - stationary .
for @xmath17 the non - stationarity holds , in the deterministic theory , for any @xmath6 .
again , we argue that the same features hold in the context of survival probability . for the ssep in one dimension eqs .
( [ d1 ] ) and ( [ d2 ] ) can be written as @xmath124 , \label{qt } \\
\partial_t p & = & - \partial_{x}^2 p+(2 q-1)(\partial_x p)^2 , \label{pt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] whereas the hamiltonian density ( [ ham ] ) becomes @xmath125 here , and in most of the following exposition on the ssep and rw , we put @xmath126 .
we will consider a one - sided problem and put the absorbing wall at @xmath127 , so that @xmath128 .
we assume a deterministic initial condition , @xmath129 and demand @xmath130 . upon rescaling @xmath66 by @xmath2 and @xmath131 by @xmath132 eq .
( [ pt ] ) becomes @xmath133 and we also have @xmath134 .
we remind the reader that @xmath54 is ultimately set by the number of absorbed particles : when this number goes to zero , @xmath135 @xcite .
once @xmath115 and @xmath136 are found , we obtain @xmath137 where the subscript in @xmath138 refers to @xmath17 . we have been unable to solve this problem exactly for arbitrary @xmath10 . in the following
we solve it in the limit of @xmath110 , when the ssep reduces to rws .
based on these results , we then compute the next - order correction in @xmath10 perturbatively . at the end of this subsection
we solve the problem numerically for a range of values of @xmath10 . in the limit of @xmath110 we can drop @xmath139 in the hamiltonian density ( [ w ] ) , and the corresponding terms in the mft equations , arriving at the rw model . as in other examples @xcite , the mft problem for the rw is solvable by the hopf - cole transformation @xmath140 and @xmath141 .
this is because , in the new variables , the hamilton equations are decoupled : @xmath142 we can solve the anti - diffusion equation ( [ pt ] ) backward in time , with the initial condition @xmath143 and the boundary conditions @xmath144 and @xmath145 .
the solution is @xmath146 where @xmath147 , and @xmath148 is the error function . at @xmath9
we obtain @xmath149 this expression is the initial condition for the diffusion equation ( [ qt ] ) forward in time .
the boundary conditions are @xmath150 and @xmath151 .
the solution is @xmath152 transforming back to @xmath95 and @xmath51 , and taking the limit of @xmath135 @xcite , we obtain @xmath153 figure [ rwquenchedq ] depicts the density history of the system as described by eq .
( [ qrw ] ) .
the lower panel shows a density void " that forms immediately . also noteworthy
is a density peak that accompanies the void formation .
to the right of the density peak @xmath154 is very small , and the dynamics is essentially governed by the deterministic equation ( [ difeq ] ) and corresponds to a diffusive outflow of the gas .
at @xmath113 we obtain @xmath155 as one can see , @xmath156 behaves linearly in @xmath131 at small @xmath131 . at @xmath157 , however , @xmath156 is quadratic at small @xmath131 , as in the stationary solution derived above .
now , @xmath158 , as described by eq .
( [ vrw ] ) , again exhibits the universal one over the distance asymptotic . indeed , at @xmath159 , @xmath160 independent of time .
this asymptotic already holds at @xmath9 .
the character of singularity at @xmath127 only changes at @xmath113 , as @xmath161 is equal to @xmath162 with an infinite prefactor @xmath135 . to compute the rescaled action @xmath163 we write @xmath164 which follows from eq .
( [ actionscaled1d ] ) at @xmath165 .
it is more convenient , however , to use the formula ( derived in @xcite ) which only includes spatial integration . for @xmath14
this formula simplifies to @xmath166.\ ] ] after cancelations we obtain @xmath167 where @xmath168 . as a result , @xmath169 has the same scaling with @xmath10 and @xmath2 as in eq .
( [ survivaldecay1 ] ) .
the coefficient @xmath170 , however , is different from the coefficient @xmath171 obtained for the random initial condition ( see ref .
@xcite , sec .
[ app : annealed ] and appendix ) .
equation ( [ 1dquenched ] ) can also be deduced from an exact microscopic derivation when the particles are initially distributed periodically in space , see ref .
@xcite and appendix .
the final density distribution ( [ qt1 ] ) can also be obtained from microscopic arguments .
now let us go back to the ssep and consider a small but finite @xmath10 .
we can calculate a small correction @xmath172 to the action ( [ actionrw2 ] ) by treating the term @xmath173 of the ssep hamiltonian ( [ w ] ) perturbatively . in the first order of perturbation theory we have @xmath174 \nonumber \\ & = & \int_0 ^ 1 dt \int_0^{\infty } dx\,q_0 ^ 2(x , t ) v_0 ^ 2(x , t ) , \label{s1a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath175 and @xmath176 are the _ unperturbed _ solutions , given by the rw formulas ( [ qrw ] ) and ( [ vrw ] ) .
plugging eqs .
( [ qrw ] ) and ( [ vrw ] ) into eq .
( [ s1c ] ) we obtain @xmath177 ^ 2 , \label{s1c}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath147 . to evaluate the above integral
, we first replace the square of the integral over @xmath178 by a product of two identical integrals over @xmath179 and @xmath180 .
the integration over @xmath181 reduces to calculating gaussian integrals : @xmath182 \nonumber \\ & \times & \!\!\!\left[e^{-\frac{\left(x-\mu_2\right){}^2}{t}}-e^{-\frac{\left(x+\mu_2\right){}^2}{t}}\right ] \nonumber \\ & = & \!\!\!\sqrt{\frac{\pi\ , t(1-t ) } { 2}}\,e^{-\frac{\left(\mu_1+\mu_2\right){}^2 ( t+1)}{2 t}}\left(e^{\frac{2 \mu_1 \mu_2}{t}}-e^{2 \mu_1 \mu_2}\right ) .
\label{intx}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we perform integration over @xmath66 in eq .
( [ s1c ] ) : @xmath183 \equiv i(\mu_1 , \mu_2 ) , \label{intt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath184 .
the remaining double integral over @xmath179 and @xmath180 is evaluated numerically to yield @xmath185 where @xmath186 .
therefore , @xmath187 we solved the mft equations using a modification of the iteration algorithm , originally developed by chernykh and stepanov @xcite for evaluating the probability density of large negative velocity gradients in the burgers turbulence .
variants of this algorithm have been used in the context of mft of lattice gases , with and without on - site reactions @xcite .
the algorithm iterates the diffusion - type equation ( [ d1 ] ) forward in time from @xmath9 to @xmath113 , and the anti - diffusion - type equation ( [ d2 ] ) backward in time from @xmath113 to @xmath9 . as in ref .
@xcite , our implementation of this algorithm involved an implicit finite difference scheme , which is beneficial for iteration convergence . at fixed @xmath10 and @xmath54
we continued iterations until local convergence of the solutions was achieved with a high accuracy .
then we increased @xmath54 and repeated the solution until the action ( [ actionscaled2 ] ) converged to 1 per cent .
we also verified that , for large @xmath54 that we achieved , the mass loss to the absorber was negligible .
figure [ ssepnum ] shows an example of our numerical solution for the deterministic initial condition and @xmath17 . at small and moderately large @xmath10 ,
the density history of the system is similar to that for rws , with a rapidly forming density void accompanied by a density peak .
the density peak is lower than for the rws , and it becomes progressively lower and broader as @xmath10 approaches @xmath108 .
the numerically found @xmath188 exhibits , at small @xmath131 , the universal asymptotic ( [ sing1d ] ) .
figure [ snumeric ] shows the numerically found @xmath189 for the deterministic initial condition and @xmath17 . for small @xmath10
, there is an excellent agreement with the rw asymptotic ( [ actionrw2 ] ) . for moderate @xmath10 ,
the results agree with the weakly - nonlinear asymptotic ( [ actionweak ] ) .
as @xmath10 continues to grow , @xmath138 grows more rapidly .
it must diverge at @xmath190 , because in this case @xmath191 scales with time as @xmath2 rather than @xmath132 , as follows from simple microscopic arguments .
our numerical solution becomes prohibitive at @xmath10 very close to 1 .
the available data indicate the @xmath192 divergence of @xmath138 as @xmath193 .
a spherically symmetric three - dimensional version of the iteration algorithm was used for the verification of the stationary solution for @xmath31 , presented in sec .
[ larged ] . when @xmath26 , eq .
( [ actionscaled2 ] ) simplifies to @xmath195 the remaining double integral is equal to the rescaled action @xmath189 in the ( rescaled ) _ one - dimensional _ problem , @xmath196 , with an absorber at @xmath197 . because of the translational invariance , @xmath198 is independent of @xmath6 . as a result ,
@xmath199 here @xmath200 is proportional to @xmath132 , rather than @xmath2 . in particular , for @xmath31 @xmath201 the case of @xmath18 is not special here , and eq . ( [ sfast ] )
holds : @xmath202 in the annealed setting , that we consider here , one allows equilibrium fluctuations in the initial condition and averages over them . in a stochastic realization of the process
, the initial density profile is chosen from the equilibrium probability distribution corresponding to density @xmath10 . as a consequence , the most likely initial density profile , conditional on the target survival until time @xmath2 , is different from the flat profile @xmath203 .
the cost " of optimal fluctuation now includes the cost of creating the optimal initial density profile .
still , the total cost is less than the cost for the quenched ( deterministic ) initial condition , so the survival probability for the annealed setting is higher than for the quenched setting . in the mft formalism
, the annealed setting is described , in one dimension , by the initial condition that involves a combination of @xmath204 and @xmath205 @xcite : @xmath206 for the ssep , @xmath207 and @xmath208 , this becomes @xmath209 } = \lambda \,\theta(x).\ ] ] for the rws , @xmath207 and @xmath210 , we have @xmath211 equation ( [ inannrw ] ) replaces eq .
( [ t01 ] ) in sec .
when @xmath115 and @xmath136 are found , one can evaluate @xmath212 here @xmath138 is the action given by eq .
( [ actionscaled1d ] ) [ but with a different @xmath115 , see below ] , whereas @xmath213 is the cost of creating the optimal initial condition @xmath214 .
this cost is given by the boltzmann - gibbs formula @xcite .
for the ssep @xmath215 } \right\},\ ] ] whereas for the rws @xmath216.\ ] ] for the rws , the annealed problem can be solved via the hopf - cole transformation . in the new variables @xmath217 and @xmath218 , the initial condition ( [ inannrw ] ) yields : @xmath219 solving the diffusion equation ( [ qt ] ) with this initial condition and the boundary conditions @xmath220 and @xmath221 , we obtain @xmath222 where @xmath147 as before .
now , @xmath223 is still described by eq .
( [ stepp ] ) .
therefore , we can calculate @xmath224 .
sending @xmath54 to infinity , we arrive at @xmath225 a symmetric function of @xmath226 .
there is no density peak in the annealed setting : the density is monotonically increasing with @xmath131 at all times .
interestingly , at @xmath113 and @xmath9 the optimal density @xmath227 is the same as predicted by the deterministic theory , eq .
( [ difeq ] ) , at @xmath113 . at times
@xmath157 , the optimal density profile @xmath115 is a quadratic function of @xmath131 at small @xmath131 as before .
the action @xmath138 is given by eq .
( [ actionrw1 ] ) with the same @xmath158 as in the quenched case , eq .
( [ vrw ] ) , and with @xmath115 given by eq .
( [ qann ] ) . as in the quenched setting , it is more convenient to calculate @xmath138 using eq .
( [ s ] ) that is equally valid in the annealed case .
the cost of the initial condition @xmath213 can be evaluated from eq .
( [ freeenergy ] ) .
adding up @xmath213 and @xmath138 , we obtain after cancelations @xmath228 so @xmath229 with @xmath230 , in agreement with previous results @xcite , see also appendix . to our knowledge , the optimal density history ( [ qann ] ) that contributes most to this survival probability , has been previously unknown .
now we return to the ssep .
assuming @xmath110 , we can calculate a small correction @xmath231 to the expression @xmath232 from eq .
( [ s0s1 ] ) .
the correction to @xmath138 is again calculated from eq .
( [ s1a ] ) , where @xmath176 is still given by eq .
( [ vrw ] ) , but @xmath175 is now given by the annealed history , eq .
( [ qann ] ) .
we obtain @xmath233 the integral over @xmath131 can be evaluated using the formula @xmath234 the remaining integral over @xmath66 is elementary , @xmath235 and we obtain @xmath236 there is also a small correction to @xmath213 that comes from the difference of free energies of the ssep and the rws .
we calculate this correction by expanding the integrand of eq .
( [ freeenssep ] ) in small @xmath10 and @xmath214 up to , and including , the quadratic terms .
the resulting correction is @xmath237 ^ 2= \frac{(2-\sqrt{2 } ) n_0 ^ 2}{\sqrt{\pi}},\ ] ] where we used the zero - order result ( [ q0ann ] ) for @xmath214 . adding up @xmath238 and @xmath239
, we finally obtain , for the annealed setting , @xmath240 .
\label{actionweakan}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the @xmath241 correction agrees with the results of santos and schtz @xcite .
they solved a different problem for the ssep , which involved particle injection from the boundary into a semi - infinite line .
remarkably , that problem can be mapped , already at the exact microscopic level , into the target survival problem we are dealing with here . as a result , the @xmath241 correction in the annealed setting , described by eq .
( [ actionweakan ] ) , corresponds to the second cumulant of the statistics of the total number of injected particles at time @xmath49 , when the system is empty at @xmath9 @xcite .
overall , eqs .
( [ actionweak ] ) and ( [ actionweakan ] ) show that , in one dimension , the survival probability exhibits different @xmath10-dependences in the quenched and annealed settings .
when @xmath26 , the @xmath242 results for the annealed setting represent an essential building block " in all dimensions @xmath194 .
here one obtains @xmath243 these equations resemble eqs .
( [ sfast ] ) and ( [ sfast ] ) , except that the rescaled one - dimensional action for the annealed setting @xmath244 is different from the corresponding quantity @xmath189 for the quenched setting . for very small densities @xmath244
is described by eq .
( [ annrw1 ] ) . for small but finite densities
it is given by eq .
( [ actionweakan ] ) . for arbitrary @xmath10
, it can be found numerically .
importantly , the steady - state equation ( [ steadyeqgen ] ) can be solved analytically for general @xmath245 and @xmath246 , thus extending our long - time results for @xmath29 to a whole family of diffusive gases of interacting particles . indeed , by denoting @xmath247}{\sqrt{\sigma[q(r)]}}\ ] ] we can recast eq .
( [ steadyeqgen ] ) into a linear first order ordinary differential equation ( ode ) , @xmath248 whose general solution is @xmath249,\ ] ] where @xmath250 . using eq .
( [ uf ] ) , we obtain one more first - order ode that can be easily integrated . using the boundary conditions @xmath91 and @xmath92 to determine the two integration constants , we obtain the solution for @xmath99 in implicit form : @xmath251 this solution exists for all lattice gases for which the integrals in eq .
( [ qgeneral ] ) are bounded .
this puts a limitation on the behaviors of @xmath245 and @xmath246 at @xmath252 .
for example , let @xmath253 and @xmath254 .
then the integrals converge at @xmath255 if and only if @xmath256 for the ssep and rws one has @xmath257 and @xmath258 .
therefore , the condition ( [ crit ] ) is satisfied , and the solution ( [ qgeneral ] ) exists .
the condition ( [ crit ] ) is also satisfied for a family of repulsion processes @xcite . when the solution ( [ qgeneral ] ) exists , the action is bounded leading to a nonzero target survival probability .
the rescaled action is the following : @xmath259^{2 } , \label{scaledgeneral}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where eq .
( [ u(r ) ] ) and the steady - state relation @xmath85 have been used in the last step . as a result ,
@xmath260^{2}.\ ] ] this closed - form result solves the target survival problem for a broad class of diffusive lattice gases .
it has the same structure as eq .
( [ survivaldecay3 ] ) except the @xmath10-dependence which is model - specific . when specialized to the rw and ssep , eq .
( [ pgeneral ] ) yields eqs .
( [ survivaldecay3 ] ) and ( [ actresultd ] ) , respectively . for @xmath18
we obtain , with logarithmic accuracy , the long - time asymptotic @xmath261^{2}.\ ] ] as an additional illustration of the general results ( [ qgeneral ] ) and ( [ pgeneral ] ) , we consider a family of zero range processes ( zrp ) .
a zrp describes interacting ( but not excluding ) random walkers on a lattice : a particle at site @xmath262 can hop to a neighboring site with a rate @xmath263 that only depends on the number of particles @xmath264 on the departure site @xmath262 .
naturally , @xmath265 .
if @xmath266 , the zrp is described at the macroscopic level by @xmath267 and @xmath268 , see e.g. ref .
therefore , @xmath269 .
evaluating the integrals in eq .
( [ qgeneral ] ) , we obtain for the stationary density profile : @xmath270 ^ 2.\ ] ] in its turn , eq . ( [ pgeneral ] ) yields the long - time asymptotic of the target survival probability for the zrp : @xmath271
in this work we evaluated the survival probability @xmath1 of a spherical target of radius @xmath0 in a gas of unbiased diffusive particles ( searchers " ) , with density @xmath10 , that interact with each other via exclusion as described by the ssep .
we also determined the most likely particle density history conditional on the target survival until time @xmath2 .
the results depend on the dimension of space @xmath3 and on the basic rescaled parameter @xmath4 .
when @xmath6 is small and @xmath7 , @xmath1 is mostly contributed to by an exact _ stationary _ solution of the macroscopic fluctuation theory ( mft ) that we obtained . for large @xmath6 , and for any @xmath6 in one dimension , the relevant mft solutions are non - stationary . in this case
@xmath8 scales differently with @xmath2 , @xmath0 , @xmath3 and @xmath10 , and it also depends on whether the initial condition is deterministic or random .
these effects ( for large @xmath6 , and for any @xmath6 in one dimension ) are also observed in the absence of exclusion : for non - interacting random walkers . in the special case of @xmath34 and @xmath18
logarithmic corrections to @xmath1 appear . table [ table1 ] can serve as a quick guide to our main results for the survival probability for the ssep in different limits .
the long - time asymptotics of the survival probability for a whole class of interacting lattice gases for @xmath7 and @xmath18 are given by eqs .
( [ pgeneral ] ) and ( [ pgeneral2d ] ) , respectively .
.@xmath1 for the ssep in different limits [ cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ] the mft provides a simple interpretation to the fact that , at @xmath7 , @xmath272 scales as @xmath2 at very long times , whereas at @xmath17 it scales as @xmath132 .
the difference in behavior is related to the existence or non - existence of a proper stationary solution of the mft equations . in summary ,
the macroscopic fluctuation theory opens new directions in the classical problem of target survival probability .
we are grateful to davide gabrielli for a helpful comment and to gunter schtz for a useful discussion of ref .
@xcite and its connection to the target survival probability of the ssep in one dimension .
two of us ( bm and plk ) thank the galileo galilei institute for theoretical physics for the hospitality and the infn for partial support during the completion of this work .
this research was supported by grant no .
2012145 from the united states
israel binational science foundation ( bsf ) .
here we present microscopic derivations of the target survival probability @xmath1 for the non - interacting rws in one , two and three dimensions .
we verify that , for @xmath17 , @xmath1 depends on the initial conditions ( random or deterministic ) . we also show that , for @xmath18 and @xmath33 , the leading term of the asymptotic of @xmath1 is independent of the initial conditions .
for @xmath31 we reproduce , both in microscopic calculations and in the mft framework , an exact result @xcite for @xmath1 in the random setting . finally , we derive , for @xmath31 , a more accurate asymptotic of @xmath1 for the deterministic setting . in all these calculations we set @xmath126 .
we start with random initial conditions and first consider rws on a large but finite interval @xmath273 .
a rw starts in the interval @xmath274 , where @xmath275 , with probability @xmath276 .
the probability that this rw does not hit the target ( which is at the origin ) until time @xmath2 is @xmath277 . averaging over random particle locations at @xmath9 we obtain the average single - particle non - hitting probability @xmath278 for sufficiently large @xmath279 we can assume that the number of rws on the interval is equal to @xmath280 . since all the @xmath281 particles are independent , the probability that none of them hits the target is @xmath282^{n_0l},\ ] ] which in the @xmath283 limit becomes @xmath284 \nonumber \\ & = & \exp\!\left(-\frac{2 n_0 \sqrt{t}}{\sqrt{\pi}}\right ) , \label{anmicro}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in agreement with eq . and ref
. @xcite .
now let the initial positions of our rws be deterministic .
one example of deterministic setting is a periodic one , with exactly one particle on each site @xmath285 of a lattice with lattice constant @xmath286 .
the probability that the particles that is initially located at site @xmath287s does not hit the target until time @xmath2 is @xmath288 $ ] .
the probability that neither of the particles hit the target is @xmath289 taking the logarithm we obtain @xmath290 we are interested in the regime of @xmath291 , when the characteristic diffusion length is much larger than the lattice constant .
the leading - order result can be obtained by replacing the summation in eq .
( [ summation ] ) by integration . here
we present a more accurate result that also includes a pre - exponential factor .
we use the asymptotic @xcite : @xmath292 here @xmath293 , see eq .
( [ actionrw2 ] ) . as a result ,
@xmath294 the exponential factor is independent of details of the deterministic initial condition .
it coincides with our mft result ( [ 1dquenched ] ) and differs from the annealed result , eqs .
( [ anmicro ] ) and and ref .
@xcite .
the pre - exponential factor is non - universal : it depends on details of the initial condition .
this dependence is quite sensitive , as can be seen if we change the periodic arrangement of rws at @xmath9 by putting exactly 2 particles on each _ even _ lattice cite @xmath295 , @xmath296 of the same lattice as before , leaving all odd sites empty . repeating the calculations , we arrive at @xmath297 with the same exponent as in eq .
( [ rw : periodic ] ) but a much larger pre - exponent . in two dimensions , the probability @xmath298 that a rw starting at the radial coordinate @xmath299 does not hit the target by the time @xmath2 has a cumbersome exact expression . in the long time limit ,
@xmath27 , it suffices to use the following asymptotic that is valid with logarithmic accuracy ( see e.g. @xcite ) : @xmath300 here @xmath301 is the incomplete gamma function .
we now employ the same line of reasoning as in one dimension . for the random initial condition we average the probability ( [ prob:2d ] ) over the random locations of the particles in the annulus @xmath302 and obtain the average single - particle non - hitting probability @xmath303 when @xmath304
, the number of rws in the annulus is approximately equal to @xmath305 .
therefore , the probability that no rw hit the target is @xmath306^{\pi n_0(l^2-r^2)}\\ & & \to\exp\!\left[- \frac{4\pi
n_0 t}{\ln\frac{4}{\ell^2}}\,\int_0^\infty dz\,\gamma(0,z)\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have simplified the limits of integration by recalling that @xmath34 and taking the limit of @xmath283 . computing the integral @xmath307 , we recover eq .
( [ survivaldecay2 ] ) . in the deterministic setting the probability is @xmath308\ ] ] the product is taken over initial positions @xmath309 which are deterministic .
we assume that , at @xmath9 , there is exactly one particle on each site of a square grid with lattice spacing @xmath310 outside of the circular target of radius @xmath0 .
we take the logarithm of and , ignoring pre - exponential factors in the final result , expand the logarithm to the leading order and replace the summation by integration by virtue of @xmath34 .
we obtain @xmath311 again arriving at eq .
( [ survivaldecay2 ] ) .
that is , in contrast to @xmath17 , here the leading - order results for @xmath312 for random and deterministic initial conditions coincide in the limit of @xmath27 . in three dimensions , the probability @xmath298 that a rw starting at the radial coordinate @xmath299 does not hit the target until time @xmath2 can be found by solving the backward diffusion equation ( which is mathematically identical to the forward diffusion equation ) @xmath313 subject to @xmath314 in contrast to two dimensions
, the solution now has a simple form : @xmath315 when the initial locations are random , we start with a spherical annulus @xmath302 and average over initial locations to yield the average single - particle non - hitting probability @xmath316 the probability @xmath312 that no rw hit the target is given by @xmath317\nonumber\\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\to- 4\pi n_0 r \sqrt{4t}\int_r^\infty dr\ , r\,\text{erfc}\!\left(\frac{r - r}{\sqrt{4t}}\right)\nonumber\\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!=- 4\pi n_0 r\ , \sqrt{4t}\int_0^\infty dx\ , ( x \sqrt{4t}+r)\,\text{erfc}\ , x \nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!= - 4\pi n_0 r\,t-8\sqrt{\pi}\ , n_0 r^2 \sqrt{t},\end{aligned}\ ] ] in agreement with previous results @xcite . equation ( [ twoterms ] ) is valid for any @xmath6 . when @xmath318 , the first term is the leading one and yields eq . with @xmath31 . in the opposite case of @xmath319
it is the second term that is the leading one , and it yields eq .
( [ sfastan ] ) with @xmath31 . even in the long - time limit ,
@xmath318 , eq . ( [ twoterms ] ) is more accurate then the leading - order asymptotic that stems from the steady - state mft solution .
importantly , the final result ( [ twoterms ] ) can also be obtained from the mft formalism if one solves the full time - dependent problem .
the problem formulation is almost identical to that for @xmath17 , see sec .
[ app : annealed ] , except that eq .
( [ inann ] ) is replaced by @xmath320 and all integrations over @xmath131 from @xmath321 to @xmath322 are replaced by integrations over the whole space outside the target .
the calculations proceed along the lines of sec .
[ app : annealed ] .
the most likely gas density history , in the original ( not rescaled ) variables , is @xmath323 \nonumber \\ & \times & \left\{1-\frac{r}{r}\,\text{erfc } \left[\frac{r - r}{\sqrt{4 ( t - t)}}\right]\right\}. \label{qann3d}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the calculation of the target survival probability ultimately reduces to evaluating the same integral as in eq .
( [ twoterms ] ) , giving the same result . in the long - time limit , @xmath27 , this integral
is mostly contributed by the region @xmath324 . in this region
( [ qann3d ] ) can be approximated , up to small corrections , by @xmath325 , which coincides with the steady solution ( [ qdrw ] ) for @xmath31 .
the deviations from the steady - state solution are responsible for the second term on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ twoterms ] ) , which is a subleading term in this limit . in the deterministic case
the microscopic calculation , similar to that in @xmath121 , boils down to evaluating the integral @xmath326.\ ] ] exactly the same expression follows from the mft . for @xmath27 , we expand the logarithm to the second order and arrive at @xmath327 the leading term coincides with that for the annealed setting , eq .
( [ twoterms ] ) .
the subleading term is different . for @xmath319
, we can replace @xmath67 by @xmath0 everywhere in the integrand of eq .
( [ deter3d ] ) except under the @xmath328 , thus arriving at eq .
( [ sfast ] ) ( but for the rws ) with @xmath329 . here
the initial conditions affect the leading - order result .
s. f. burlatsky , m. moreau , g. oshanin , and a. blumen , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 585 ( 1995 ) ; d. p. bhatia , m. a. prasad , and d. arora , phys . rev . lett . *
75 * , 586 ( 1995 ) ; k. seki and m. tachiya , phys .
e * 80 * , 041120 ( 2009 ) ; k. seki , m. wojcik , and m. tachiya , j. chem .
134 * , 094506 ( 2011 ) .
l. bertini , a. de sole , d. gabrielli , g. jona - lasinio , and c. landim , phys .
* * 8**7 , 040601 ( 2001 ) ; j. stat .
* 107 * , 635 ( 2002 ) ; phys .
lett . * 94 * , 030601 ( 2005 ) ; j. stat .
* 1**23 , 237 ( 2006 ) .
|
suppose that a lattice gas of constant density , described by the symmetric simple exclusion process , is brought in contact with a target " : a spherical absorber of radius @xmath0 .
employing the macroscopic fluctuation theory ( mft ) , we evaluate the probability @xmath1 that no gas particle hits the target until a long but finite time @xmath2 .
we also find the most likely gas density history conditional on the non - hitting .
the results depend on the dimension of space @xmath3 and on the rescaled parameter @xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the gas diffusivity . for small @xmath6 and @xmath7 ,
@xmath1 is determined by an exact stationary solution of the mft equations that we find . for large @xmath6 , and for any @xmath6 in one dimension , the relevant mft solutions are non - stationary . in this case
@xmath8 scales differently with relevant parameters , and it also depends on whether the initial condition is random or deterministic
. the latter effects also occur if the lattice gas is composed of non - interacting random walkers .
finally , we extend the formalism to a whole class of diffusive gases of interacting particles .
|
during the last few years applications of gauge / gravity duality @xcite to hadronic physics attracted a lot of attention , and various holographic dual models of qcd were proposed in the literature ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
these models were able to incorporate such essential properties of qcd as confinement and chiral symmetry breaking , and also to reproduce many of the static hadronic observables ( decay constants , masses ) , with values rather close to the experimental ones . amongst the dual models ,
a special class is the so - called `` bottom - up '' approaches ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) , the goal of which is to reproduce known properties of qcd by choosing an appropriate theory in the 5-dimensional ( 5d ) ads bulk . within the framework of the ads / qcd models , by modifying the theory in the bulk one may try to explain / fit experimental results in different sectors of qcd . in the present paper
, we will be interested in the hard - wall ads / qcd model @xcite , where the confinement is modeled by sharp cutting off the ads space along the extra fifth dimension at a wall located at some finite distance @xmath0 . in the framework of this hard - wall model ,
it is possible to find form factors and wave functions of vector mesons ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . to reproduce the general features of the spectrum for the higher states ( `` linear confinement '' ) ,
a soft - wall model was proposed in @xcite .
the @xmath1-meson form factors for this model were calculated in ref .
@xcite . in general ,
the vector sector is less sensitive to the infrared ( ir ) effects , since this symmetry is not broken in qcd .
however , the axial - vector sector appears to be very sensitive to the particular way the chiral symmetry is broken or , in other words , to the bulk content and the shape of the ir wall @xcite . in this respect ,
one of the interesting objects to study in the holographic dual models of qcd is the pion .
the properties of the pion were studied in various holographic approaches , ( see e.g. refs .
in particular , the approach of ref .
@xcite ( see also recent papers @xcite ) managed to reproduce the ( gell - mann oakes renner ) relation @xmath2 between the quark mass @xmath3 and mass of the pion @xmath4 and also the @xmath5 coupling ( the coupling between @xmath1 meson and two pions ) . in ref .
@xcite , the solution of the pion wave - function equation was explicitly written for the @xmath6 limit . in this paper , working in the framework of the model proposed in @xcite ( hard - wall model ) , we describe a formalism to calculate the form factor and wave functions ( and also the density function ) of the pion . since the fits of ref .
@xcite give a very small @xmath7mev value for the explicit chiral symmetry breaking parameter @xmath8 , we consider only the chiral limit @xmath6 of the hard - wall holographic dual model of two - flavor qcd .
resorting to the chiral limit allows us to utilize one of the main advantages of ads / qcd - the possibility to work with explicit analytic solutions of the basic equations of motion . expressing the pion form factor in terms of these solutions ,
we are able , in particular , to extract and analyze the behavior of the pion electric radius in various regions of the holographic parameters space . on the numerical side
, we come to the conclusion that the radius of the pion is smaller than what is known from experiment . however , we suggest that , as in case of the radius of the @xmath1 meson , smoothing the ir wall may increase the pion radius . in our analysis
, we introduce and systematically use two types of holographic wave functions @xmath9 and @xmath10 , which are conjugate to each other and basically similar to the analogous objects introduced in our papers @xcite , where we studied vector mesons .
the paper is organized in the following way .
we start with recalling , in section ii , the basics of the hard - wall model and some results obtained in ref .
@xcite , in particular , the form of the relevant action , the eigenvalue equations for bound states and their solutions . in section iii , we describe a formalism for calculating the pion form factor and express it in terms of the two wave functions mentioned above . in section iv
, we discuss the relation of our ads / qcd results to experimental data .
we express the values of the pion decay constant and the pion charge radius in terms of the fundamental parameters of the theory and study their behavior in different regions of the parametric space . at the end
, we study the behavior of the pion form factor at large momentum transfer .
finally , we summarize the paper .
in the holographic model of hadrons , qcd resonances correspond to kaluza - klein ( kk ) excitations in the sliced ads@xmath11 background .
in particular , vector mesons correspond to the kk modes of transverse vector gauge field in this background .
since the gauge symmetry in the vector sector of the h - model is not broken , the longitudinal component of the vector gauge field is unphysical , and only transverse components correspond to physical mesons .
similarly , the axial - vector mesons are the modes of the transverse part of the axial - vector gauge field . however , because the axial - vector gauge symmetry is broken in the 5d background , the longitudinal components have physical meaning and are related to the pion field .
this should be taken into account if we want to treat the pion in a consistent way .
the standard prescription of the holographic model is that there is a correspondence between the 4d vector and axial - vector currents and the corresponding 5d gauge fields : @xmath12 where @xmath13 , ( @xmath14 and @xmath15 are usual pauli matrices ) . in general
, one can write @xmath16 , where @xmath17 and @xmath18 are transverse and longitudinal components of the axial - vector field . the spontaneous symmetry breaking causes @xmath19 to be physical and associated with the goldstone boson , pion in this case .
the longitudinal component may be written in the form : @xmath20 .
then @xmath21 corresponds to the pion field .
physics of the axial - vector and pseudoscalar sectors is described by the action @xmath22 \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath23 , ( @xmath24 ) and @xmath25 is taken as a product of the chiral field @xmath26 and the function @xmath27 containing the chiral symmetry breaking parameters @xmath8 and @xmath28 , with @xmath8 playing the role of the quark mass and @xmath28 that of the quark condensate .
expanding @xmath29 in powers of @xmath30 gives the relevant piece of the action @xmath31.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this higgs - like mechanism breaks the axial - vector gauge symmetry by bringing a @xmath32-dependent mass term in the @xmath33-part of the lagrangian .
varying the action with respect to the transverse part of the axial - vector gauge field @xmath34 and representing the fourier image of @xmath34 as @xmath35 we will get the following equation of motion @xmath36_{\perp } = 0 \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] that determines physics of the axial - vector mesons , like @xmath37 .
the axial - vector bulk - to - boundary propagator @xmath38 is introduced by the relation @xmath39 .
it satisfies eq .
( [ axvec ] ) with boundary conditions ( b.c . ) @xmath40 and @xmath41 .
similarly , variation with respect to the longitudinal component @xmath42 gives @xmath43 finally , varying with respect to @xmath44 produces @xmath45 the pion wave function is determined from eqs .
( [ phieq ] ) and ( [ pieq ] ) with b.c .
@xmath46 , @xmath47 and @xmath48 . within the framework of the model of ref .
@xcite , it is possible to derive the gell - mann oakes renner relation @xmath49 producing massless pion in the @xmath6 limit . taking @xmath50 in eq .
( [ pieq ] ) gives @xmath51 a perturbative solution in the form of @xmath52 expansion was proposed in ref @xcite , with @xmath53 in the lowest order .
then it was shown that , in the @xmath54 limit , @xmath55 tends to @xmath56 or , roughly speaking , @xmath57 in this limit .
since our goal is to calculate the pion form factor in the chiral limit , this approximation will be sufficient for us .
the spectrum in the axial - current channel consists of the pseudoscalar pion @xmath58 and axial - vector mesons @xmath59 , where @xmath60 correspond to the @xmath61 axial - vector meson decay constant ( and we ignored the flavor indexes ) .
thus , the two - point function for the axial - vector currents has the form : @xmath62 where the meson polarization tensor is given by @xmath63 the representation for the two - point function can be also written as @xmath64 in which the second term on the rhs is explicitly transverse to @xmath65 . as noted in ref .
@xcite , using holographic correspondence one can relate the two - point function to @xmath66_{z=0}$ ] and derive that @xmath67 for large spacelike @xmath68 , eq .
( [ axvec ] ) gives the same solution as in case of vector mesons , and the same asymptotic logarithmic behavior , just as expected from qcd .
the longitudinal component of the axial - vector gauge field was defined as @xmath69 . in the chiral limit , when @xmath70 , we have @xmath71 , and the basic equation for @xmath72 , eq .
( [ phieq ] ) can be rewritten as the equation @xmath73 for the function @xmath74 . in the chiral limit , when @xmath75 , the value of @xmath76 tends to 1 as @xmath77 .
this value and the b.c .
@xmath78 are the same as those for @xmath79 and , furthermore , eq .
( [ pioneq ] ) coincides with the @xmath80 version of equation ( [ axvec ] ) for @xmath79 .
hence , the solution for @xmath81 coincides with @xmath82 : @xmath83 and we may write @xmath84 in our analysis of @xmath1-meson wave functions in refs
. @xcite , we emphasized that it makes sense to consider also the conjugate functions @xmath85 of the corresponding sturm - liouville equation .
as we observed , they are closer in their structure to the usual quantum mechanical bound state wave functions than the solutions of the original equation . in the pion case , it is convenient to define the @xmath86 function as @xmath87 it vanishes at the ir boundary @xmath88 and , according to eq .
( [ piondecay1 ] ) , is normalized as @xmath89 at the origin .
note also that using eq .
( [ pioneq ] ) we can express @xmath90 as derivative of @xmath86 : @xmath91
to obtain the pion form factor , we need to consider three - point correlation functions .
the correlator should include the external em current @xmath92 and currents having nonzero projection onto the pion states , e.g. the axial currents @xmath93 @xmath94 where @xmath95 are the corresponding momenta , with the momentum transfer carried by the em source being @xmath96 ( as usual , we denote @xmath97 , @xmath98 ) .
the spectral representation for the three - point function is a two - dimensional generalization of eq .
( [ 2axial ] ) @xmath99 where the first term , longitudinal both with respect to @xmath100 and @xmath101 contains the pion electromagnetic form factor @xmath102 @xmath103 ( normalized by @xmath104 ) , while other pole terms contain the contributions involving axial - vector mesons and are transverse either with respect to @xmath100 or @xmath101 , or both .
hence , the pion form factor can be extracted from the three - point function using @xmath105 to obtain form factor from the holographic model , we need the action of the third order in the fields .
there are two types of terms contributing to the pion electromagnetic form factor : @xmath107 term and @xmath106 terms .
let us consider first the contribution from @xmath106 terms .
they contain @xmath108 , @xmath109 and @xmath110 interactions and may be written as @xmath111 + v_{mn}[a^{m},a^{n } ] + a_{mn}[v^{m},a^{n } ] \right ) \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath112 and @xmath113 .
taking @xmath114 gauge , we pick out the part of the action which is contributing to the 3-point function @xmath115 : @xmath116 + a_{\mu\nu}[v^{\mu},a^{\nu } ] \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] introducing fourier transforms of fields , we define , as usual , @xmath117 for the vector field , where @xmath118 is the fourier transform of the 4-dimensional field @xmath119 and @xmath120 is the bulk - to - boundary propagator satisfying the equation @xmath121 with b.c . @xmath122 and @xmath123 .
it can be written as the sum @xmath124 involving all the bound states in the @xmath125-channel , with @xmath126 being the mass of the @xmath127th bound state and @xmath128 its wave function given by a solution of the basic equation of motion in the vector sector .
the projection ( [ proj0 ] ) picks out only the longitudinal part @xmath129 of the axial - vector field .
taking into account that @xmath130 , we may write @xmath131 where @xmath132 and @xmath133 are the fourier transforms of @xmath134 and @xmath135 , respectively .
furthermore , there is only one particle in the expansion over bound state in this case , namely , the massless pion .
thus , we have @xmath136 and , therefore , @xmath137 this allows us to rewrite @xmath138 in the form @xmath139 involving the longitudinal projector @xmath140 and the pion wave function @xmath141 , which is the solution of the basic equation ( [ phieq ] ) .
using this representation and making fourier transform of @xmath142 gives @xmath143 \int^{z_0}_{\epsilon } dz~\frac{1}{z}\ , { \cal v } ( w , z)\ , \psi^2(z ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] ( notice that the second term in eq.([xnia ] ) vanishes for longitudinal axial - vector fields ) .
varying this functional with respect to sources produces the following 3-point function : @xmath144 where , anticipating the limit @xmath145 , we took @xmath146 in the numerator factors .
now , representing @xmath147 and applying the projection suggested by eq .
( [ proj0 ] ) , we will have @xmath148 where @xmath149 is the dynamic factor given by the convolution @xmath150 the vector bulk - to - boundary propagator @xmath151 for spacelike momenta , entering into the dynamic factor @xmath149 , satisfies the equation @xmath152 with b.c . @xmath153 and @xmath154 .
its explicit form is given by @xmath155 \ .\ ] ] one can easily see that @xmath156 . combining all the factors , we get @xmath157 integrating by parts and using equations of motion both for @xmath158 and @xmath159 gives @xmath160 \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we need also to add the @xmath161 contribution from the @xmath107 term of the ads action ( [ ads ] ) .
it is generated by @xmath162,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and its inclusion changes @xmath163 into @xmath164 in eq .
( [ almost ] ) . the total result ( see also ref .
@xcite ) may be now conveniently expressed in terms of the @xmath165 wave function @xmath166 \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] using equation of motion for @xmath167 , one can see that the expression in square brackets coincides with @xmath168 and write the form factor as @xmath169 this representation allows one to easily check the normalization @xmath170 where we took into account that @xmath171 and @xmath172 .
we can also represent our result for the pion form factor as @xmath173 \equiv \int_{0}^{z_0 } dz \ z \ { \cal j } ( q , z)\ , \rho ( z ) \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and interpret the function @xmath174 as the radial distribution density , as it was done in refs .
@xcite . note that keeping only the first term in square brackets gives an expression similar to our result @xcite for the @xmath1-meson form factor @xmath175 in terms of the function @xmath176 conjugate to the solution of the basic equation of motion .
the value of @xmath177 at the origin is proportional to the @xmath1-meson decay constant @xmath178 ( experimentally , @xmath179 @xcite ) , namely , @xmath180 .
thus , the pion wave function @xmath181 is a direct analog of the @xmath1-meson wave function @xmath182 .
main difference is that , in the pion case , there is also the second term in the form factor expression .
the latter , in fact , is necessary to secure correct normalization of the form factor at @xmath183 . in eq .
( [ ff ] ) , this term is written in terms of the @xmath184 wave function , but using eq .
( [ phiz ] ) we can rewrite it also in terms of @xmath9 or @xmath185 : @xmath186
explicit form of the @xmath90 wave function follows from the solution of eq .
( [ pioneq ] ) : @xmath187 \left(\frac{\alpha}{2}\right)^{1/3 } } \left [ i_{-1/3}\left(\alpha z^3\right ) - i_{1/3}\left(\alpha z^3\right ) \frac{i_{2/3}\left(\alpha z^3_0\right ) } { i_{-2/3}\left(\alpha z^3_0\right)}\right ] \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath188 ( recall that @xmath189 , see e.g. ref.@xcite ) . as a result , @xmath190 is given by @xmath191 \left(\frac{\alpha^4}{2}\right)^{1/3 } \left[- i_{2/3}\left(\alpha z^3\right ) + i_{-2/3}\left(\alpha z^3\right ) \frac{i_{2/3}\left(\alpha z^3_0\right ) } { i_{-2/3}\left(\alpha z^3_0\right)}\right ] \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] this formula , combined with eq .
( [ psi0 ] ) , establishes the relation @xmath192}{\gamma[1/3]}\ , \frac{i_{2/3}\left(\alpha z^3_0\right ) } { i_{-2/3}\left(\alpha z^3_0\right ) } \frac{\alpha^{2/3}}{g_5 ^ 2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath193 in terms of the condensate parameter @xmath194 and the confinement radius @xmath195 .
since @xmath28 appears in the solutions only through @xmath194 , we will use @xmath194 in what follows .
note also that @xmath196 . realizing that the equations of motion for the vector sector in this holographic model are not affected by the chiral symmetry - breaking effects expressed through the function @xmath197
, it is natural to set the value of @xmath195 from the vector sector spectrum , i.e. , by the @xmath1-meson mass .
the numerical value of @xmath195 ( call it @xmath198 ) is then @xmath199 . as given by eq .
( [ fpi2 ] ) , @xmath193 looks like a rather complicated function of two scales , @xmath195 and @xmath194 .
note , however , that the ratio @xmath200 is very close to 1 for @xmath201 and practically indistinguishable from 1 for @xmath202 .
hence , for sufficiently large values of the confinement radius , @xmath203 , the value of @xmath193 is determined by the value of @xmath194 alone .
this limiting value of @xmath193 is given by @xmath204}{\gamma[1/3 ] } } = \frac{3^{1/2}}{2^{1/3 } \pi } \
, \sqrt { \frac { \gamma[2/3]}{\gamma[1/3 ] } } \ , \alpha^{1/3 } \ , \approx \frac{\alpha^{1/3}}{3.21 } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] requiring that @xmath205 coincides with the experimental value , @xmath206 , one should take @xmath207 . for such @xmath194 ,
the value of @xmath208 is close to @xmath198 , i.e. , we are in the region @xmath209 and we may expect that , even if we use exact formula ( [ fpi2 ] ) with @xmath210 , the value of @xmath193 would not change much . indeed , to get @xmath206 from eq .
( [ fpi2 ] ) for @xmath211 , we should take @xmath212 .
thus , in this range of parameters , the value of @xmath193 is practically in one - to - one correspondence with the value of @xmath194 .
it is convenient to introduce a dimensionless variable @xmath213 then the values @xmath214 and @xmath215 correspond to @xmath216 . as one can see from fig.([fpi ] ) , the dependence of @xmath193 is practically flat for @xmath201 .
the confinement radius @xmath195 presents a natural scale to measure length , so it makes sense to rewrite the form factor formula ( [ ff ] ) as an integral over the dimensionless variable @xmath217 : @xmath218 \equiv \int_{0}^{1 } d\zeta \ , \zeta \ { \cal j } ( q,\zeta , z_0 ) \ , \rho ( \zeta , a ) \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the mass scale @xmath194 is reflected by the dimensionless parameter @xmath219 .
the factor @xmath220 takes care of the correct normalization of the form factor .
it is given by @xmath221}{\gamma[1/3 ] } \ , \frac{i_{2/3 } ( a)}{i_{-2/3}(a ) } \
.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for small @xmath219 , it may be approximated by @xmath222 . for large @xmath219 , using the fact that @xmath223 is very close to 1 for @xmath201 , we may approximate @xmath224 in this region . in terms of @xmath220 ,
the pion decay constant can be written as @xmath225 for large @xmath219 , this gives @xmath226 for small @xmath219 , we have @xmath227 the functions @xmath228 are just the @xmath86 and @xmath90 wave functions written in @xmath229 and @xmath219 variables . for @xmath230 , the limiting forms are @xmath231 and @xmath232 . as @xmath219 increases ,
both functions become more and more narrow ( see fig.[psiphi ] ) . for density
, we have @xmath233 in the @xmath234 limit , a function that vanishes at the origin ( see fig.([rhodense ] ) ) . for nonzero
@xmath219 , the value of @xmath235 monotonically increases with @xmath219 , and the function itself narrows .
the increase of @xmath235 with @xmath219 is generated by the monotonically increasing function @xmath220 .
it is interesting to compare the pion density @xmath236 ( taken at the `` experimental '' value @xmath237 ) with the @xmath1-meson density @xmath238 of ref .
these densities are rather close for @xmath239 , but strongly differ for small @xmath240 .
in particular , the @xmath1-meson density is more than two times larger for @xmath241 , which corresponds to the hard - wall model result that @xmath242 is essentially larger than @xmath193 .
it is interesting to investigate how well these values @xmath243 and @xmath244 describe another important low - energy characteristics of the pion
its charge radius . using the @xmath245-expansion of the vector source @xcite @xmath246 + \ldots\end{aligned}\ ] ] and explicit form of the density @xmath247 \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath248 , we obtain for the pion charge radius : @xmath249 \ , \rho ( \zeta , a ) = \frac43 \ , z_0 ^ 2 \ , \left \ { 1 - \frac{a^2}{4 } + { \cal o } ( a^4 ) \right \ } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence , for fixed @xmath195 and small @xmath219 , when @xmath250 , the pion radius is basically determined by the confinement scale @xmath195 .
in particular , @xmath251 for @xmath252 .
numerically , taking we obtain @xmath253 .
this result is very close to the value @xmath254 that we obtained in the hard - wall model for the @xmath1-meson electric radius determined in @xcite from the slope of the @xmath255 form factor .
however , since @xmath255 involves kinematic - type terms @xmath256 , it seems more appropriate to compare @xmath257 with the @xmath258 form factor ( [ calf ] ) given directly by a wave function overlap integral . the slope of @xmath258 is smaller than that of @xmath255 , and the corresponding radius is also smaller : @xmath259 .
thus , for @xmath260 , the pion r.m.s . radius is about 1.4 times larger than the @xmath1-meson size determined by @xmath261 . with the increase of @xmath194 ,
the pion becomes smaller ( see fig.[radius ] ) .
the experimental value of @xmath262 @xcite is reached for @xmath263 . however , the corresponding value @xmath264 is too small . if we take @xmath265 , then @xmath266 . thus , if we insist on using @xmath210 dictated by the hard - wall model calculation of the @xmath1-meson mass , and the value of @xmath194 producing the experimental @xmath193 ( note that then @xmath267 ) , the pion radius is smaller than the experimental value . in linear units , the difference , in fact ,
does not look very drastic : just 0.58fm instead of 0.66 fm .
given that the hard - wall model for confinement is rather crude , the agreement may be considered as encouraging .
furthermore , one may expect that , in a more realistic softer model of confinement , the size of the pion will be larger .
such an expectation is supported by our soft - wall model calculation of the @xmath1-meson electric radius , for which we obtained @xmath2680.66@xmath269 ( 0.40@xmath269 for @xmath270 ) , i.e. , the result by 0.13@xmath269 larger than in the hard - wall model .
if @xmath271 would increase by a similar amount , the result will be very close to the quoted experimental value . to find @xmath272 for large @xmath219 ( i.e. , when @xmath273 for fixed @xmath195 , or when @xmath274 for fixed @xmath194 ) , we use first the observation that , in the region @xmath201 , we may approximate @xmath275
. then the factor in square brackets in eq .
( [ rhozeta ] ) becomes a function of the combination @xmath276 ( call it @xmath277 ) , and we can write @xmath278 \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath201 , the upper limit of integration in this expression may be safely substituted by infinity producing @xmath279 which gives @xmath280 \
.\end{aligned}\ ] ] using eq .
( [ fpiinfty ] ) , we can express the coefficient in front of the square bracket in terms of @xmath193 : @xmath281 thus , @xmath282 in the @xmath283 region consists of two componens : a fixed term @xmath284 and a term logarithmically increasing with @xmath195 . as @xmath285 , the pion charge radius becomes infinite , reflecting the fact that the pion in this model is massless .
a similar structure in the expression for the pion charge radius was obtained @xcite in the nambu - jona - lasinio ( njl ) model @xmath286 it also has the logarithmic term @xmath287 @xcite resulting in the infinite radius for massless pion and the infrared - finite piece @xmath288 @xcite . the latter , however , is twice larger than that in our result ( [ rpifpi ] ) and contributes 0.34@xmath269 to @xmath282 , with the chiral logarithm term producing the extra 0.11@xmath269 required for agreement with experiment . in our case ,
the logarithmic term taken for @xmath289 is approximately equal to @xmath284 , thus almost doubling the outcome value for @xmath282 .
more precisely , we can write @xmath290 \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath237 , the modified logarithmic term gives a very small contribution , and our net result is very close to the value given by the njl fixed term .
numerically , though , this prediction of the hard - wall ads / qcd model , as we have seen , is essentially smaller than the experimental value . in the large-@xmath245 limit
, the source @xmath291 is given by its free - field version @xmath292 that behaves asymptotically like @xmath293 . as a result , only small values @xmath294 are important in the form factor integral , and the large-@xmath245 asymptotic behavior of the form factor is determined by the value of @xmath295 at the origin @xcite , namely , @xmath296 note that the combination @xmath297 frequently appears in the pion studies .
in particular , it is the basic scale of the pion wave function in the local quark - hadron duality model @xcite , where it corresponds to the `` pion duality interval '' .
the leading contribution comes entirely from the @xmath298 term of the form factor integral ( [ ff2 ] ) while the @xmath299 term contribution behaves asymptotically like @xmath300 since it is accompanied by extra @xmath301 factor .
note , however , that it is quite visible in the experimentally interesting region @xmath302 : it is responsible for more than @xmath303 of the form factor value in this region ( moreover , at @xmath183 , the @xmath299 term contributes about 40% into the normalization of the form factor ) . from a phenomenological point of view , different ads / qcd - like models for the pion form factor differ in the shape of the density @xmath304 that they produce .
if we require that the density @xmath305 equals @xmath306 at the origin , the asymptotic behavior is @xmath307 in any such model . for @xmath183 ,
the form factor is normalized to one , so basically the models would differ in how they interpolate between these two limits . in particular , the simplest interpolation is provided by the monopole formula @xmath308 while our hard - wall calculation gives a curve that goes above @xmath309 : the ratio @xmath310 is larger than 1 for all @xmath311 , slowly approaching unity as @xmath312 ( see fig.[ffact ] ) .
in fact , a purely monopole form factor was obtained in our paper @xcite , where we studied the @xmath1-meson form factors in the soft - wall holographic model , in which confinement is generated by @xmath313 oscillator - type potential .
it was shown in @xcite that the form factor integral @xmath314 is the lowest bound state wave function , and @xmath315\end{aligned}\ ] ] is the bulk - to - boundary propagator of this oscillator - type model , is exactly equal to the magnitude of the oscillator scale @xmath316 was fixed in our paper @xcite by the value of the @xmath1-meson mass : @xmath317 . as a result , the form factor @xmath318 had the @xmath1-dominance behavior @xmath319 .
if we take @xmath320 both for @xmath321 and @xmath322 , the integral ( [ calf00 ] ) gives @xmath323 .
the relevant wave function @xmath324 has the expected correct normalization however , the slope @xmath325 of @xmath323 at @xmath183 ( corresponding to for the radius squared ) is smaller than that of the experimental pion form factor .
furthermore , @xmath326 tends to @xmath327gev@xmath328 for large @xmath245 , achieving values about @xmath329gev@xmath328 for @xmath330gev@xmath328 , and thus exceeding by more than 25% the experimental jlab values @xcite measured for @xmath331 and 2.45gev@xmath328 .
the authors of ref .
@xcite proposed to use eqs .
( [ calf00]),([caljo ] ) as an ads / qcd model for the pion form factor , with @xmath332mev chosen so as to fit these high-@xmath245 data .
however , such a choice underestimates the value of @xmath333 by almost 30% .
our opinion is that the ads / qcd models should describe first the low - energy properties of hadrons , and the basic low - energy characteristics , such as @xmath334 and @xmath193 , should be used to fix the model parameters . on the other hand ,
if the form factor calculations based on these parameters disagree with the large-@xmath245 data , it is quite possible that this is just an indication that one is using the model beyond its applicability limits .
furthermore , as we have seen in the hard - wall model , to correctly describe the pion one needs to include the chiral symmetry breaking effects absent in the vector channel . as a result ,
equations for pion wave functions are rather different from those in the @xmath1-meson case .
similarly , there are no reasons to expect that , in a soft - wall model , the pion density should have the same shape as the @xmath1-meson one .
unfortunately , the procedure of bringing in the chiral symmetry breaking effects that was used in the hard - wall model of ref .
@xcite faces serious difficulties when applied to the ads / qcd model @xcite with the @xmath301 soft wall . as discussed in ref .
@xcite , the solution of the equation for the @xmath335 field in this model requires that chiral condensate @xmath28 and the mass parameter @xmath8 are proportional to each other , so that @xmath336 can not be varied independently of @xmath8 .
moreover , if one takes the chiral limit @xmath6 , the chiral condensate should also vanish .
this difficulty may be avoided by switching to more sophisticated recent models ( cf .
@xcite ) in which the chiral condensate is generated dynamically .
however , such a consideration goes well beyond the scope of the present paper .
thus , we just resort to an idea that whatever the mechanism is involved , the net practical outcome is a particular shape of the density @xmath337 that eventually determines the pion form factor and other pion characteristics .
below , we give an example of a density @xmath338 that is normalized at the origin by the experimental value of @xmath193 , i.e. , @xmath339 , but which is also capable to reproduce the experimental value of the pion charge radius . evidently , to increase the radius , we should take a density which is larger for large @xmath32 than @xmath340 .
since the overall integral normalization of the density is kept fixed , this can be achieved only by decreasing the density for small @xmath32 values . consider a simple ansatz ( see fig.[rhomod ] ) @xmath341 \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath342 .
it has both the desired value for @xmath343 and satisfies the normalization condition @xmath344 integrating it with @xmath345 taken at @xmath346 produces the model form factor given by the following sum of contributions of the three lowest vector states : @xmath347 the slope of @xmath348 at @xmath183 is given by @xmath349 \
.\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking @xmath350 , one obtains the experimental value 0.45 @xmath269 for @xmath351 .
it is interesting to note that the model density providing this value , has an enhancement for larger values of @xmath32 ( see fig.[rhomod ] ) , just like the pion densities in the hard - wall model ( see fig.([rhodense ] ) ) . due to a larger slope
, @xmath348 decreases faster than the simple monopole interpolation @xmath352 and , as a result , is in better agreement with the data .
in fact , it goes very close to @xmath353gev@xmath328 data , but exceeds the values of the jlab @xmath3541.6 and 2.45gev@xmath328 points by roughly 10% and 20% , respectively .
this discrepancy has a general reason .
the asymptotic ads / qcd prediction is which is @xmath355gev@xmath328 for experimental value of @xmath193 . on the other hand ,
jlab experimental points correspond to @xmath356gev@xmath328 , which is much smaller than the theoretical value quoted above .
the pre - asymptotic effects , as we have seen , reduce the discrepancy , but there still remains a sizable gap . as we already stated , such a disagreement may be just a signal that we are reaching a region where ads / qcd models should not be expected to work . in particular , ads / qcd models of refs .
@xcite describe the pion in terms of an effective field or current , without specifying whether the current is built from spin-1/2 fields , or from scalar fields , etc . for @xmath245 above 1gev@xmath328 , the quark substructure of the pion may be resolved by the electromagnetic probe ( which is a wide - spread belief ) , and the description of the pion `` as a whole '' may be insufficient .
in this paper , we studied the pion in the chiral limit of two flavor qcd .
to this end , we described a formalism that allows to extract pion form factor within the framework of the holographic dual model of qcd with hard - wall cutoff .
following ref .
@xcite , we identified the pion with the longitudinal component of the axial - vector gauge field .
we defined two ( sturm - liouville ) conjugate wave functions @xmath9 and @xmath10 that describe the structure of the pion along the 5@xmath357 dimension coordinate @xmath358 .
these wave functions provide a very convenient framework to study the holographic physics of the pion .
we demonstrated that , just like in the @xmath1-meson case @xcite , the pion form factor is given by an integral involving the function @xmath337 that has the meaning of the charge density inside the pion .
however , in distinction to the @xmath1-case , when the density was simply given by @xmath359 , the pion density has an additional term proportional to @xmath360 and entering with the @xmath32-dependent coefficient reflecting the mechanism of the spontaneous symmetry breaking . both terms are required for normalization of the form factor at @xmath361 .
we found an analytic expression for the pion decay constant in terms of two parameters of the model : @xmath362 and @xmath363 , similar to those used in ref .
@xcite . analyzing the results , we found it convenient to work with two combinations @xmath364 and @xmath365 of the basic parameters .
in particular , we found @xmath265 for the value of @xmath219 corresponding to the experimental @xmath1-meson mass @xmath334 and pion decay constant @xmath193 .
the importance of the parameter @xmath219 is that its magnitude determines the regions , where the pion properties are either governed by the confinement effects or by the effects from the spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking .
for example , in the practically important domain @xmath366 , the pion decay constant is determined primarily by @xmath362 , with negligibly tiny corrections due to @xmath195 value . however , when @xmath367 the pion decay constant is proportional to the ratio @xmath368 . besides
, for small @xmath369 , the radius of the pion is given by @xmath370 , i.e. , as one may expect , the pion size is completely determined by the confinement radius . on the other hand , for @xmath366 the radius
is basically determined by @xmath371 , slowly increasing with @xmath195 due to the @xmath372 correction .
we also found that the pion rms charge radius @xmath373fm in the hard - wall model is smaller than that measured experimentally . in a sense ,
the hard wall at the distance @xmath374fm ( fixed from the @xmath1-meson mass ) , `` does not allow '' the pion to get larger .
so , we argued that if the ir wall is `` softened '' , the size of the pion may be increased by an amount sufficient to accomodate the data .
a straightforward idea is to use the soft - wall model of ref .
@xcite and treat the pion in a way similar to what was done in @xcite for the @xmath1-meson case .
unfortunately , there are prohibiting complications with directly introducing the chiral symmetry effects within the ads / qcd model with the @xmath301 soft wall . as explained in ref .
@xcite , the chiral condensate @xmath28 in such a model is proportional to the mass parameter @xmath8 , so that in the chiral limit the condensate vanishes together with the quark mass . to illustrate a possible change in the form factor predictions due to the softening of the ir wall
, we proposed an ansatz for the pion density function and used the vector current source from the soft - wall model considered in ref .
@xcite . we demonstrated that this ansatz is capable to fit the experimental value of the pion charge radius .
it also closely follows the data in the @xmath375gev@xmath328 region , while still overshoots available data in the @xmath376gev@xmath328 region .
the basic source of this discrepancy is very general : the asymptotic ads / qcd prediction for the pion form factor is @xmath377 , and if one takes the experimental value for @xmath193 , one obtains @xmath378gev@xmath328 , which is much larger than the 0.4gev@xmath328 value given by @xmath376gev@xmath328 jlab data . for this reason , we argued that the disagreement mentioned above may be a signal that the region @xmath379gev@xmath328 is beyond the applicability region of ads / qcd models .
finishing the write - up of this paper , we have learned that the paper @xcite addressing the same problem was posted into the arxive .
we did not observe , however , essential overlaps with our ideas and results .
h.g . would like to thank a. w. thomas for valuable comments and support at jefferson laboratory , j. p. draayer for support at louisiana state university .
notice : authored by jefferson science associates , llc under u.s .
doe contract no .
de - ac05 - 06or23177 .
government retains a non - exclusive , paid - up , irrevocable , world - wide license to publish or reproduce this manuscript for u.s .
government purposes .
j. m. maldacena , adv .
theor . math .
* 2 * , 231 ( 1998 ) [ int .
j. theor .
phys . * 38 * , 1113 ( 1999 ) ] ; s. s. gubser , i. r. klebanov and a. m. polyakov , phys . lett .
b * 428 * , 105 ( 1998 ) ; e. witten , adv .
theor . math . phys .
* 2 * , 253 ( 1998 ) j. polchinski and m. j. strassler , phys .
lett . * 88 * , 031601 ( 2002 ) ; jhep * 0305 * , 012 ( 2003 ) h. boschi - filho and n. r. f. braga , jhep * 0305 * , 009 ( 2003 ) ; eur .
j. c * 32 * , 529 ( 2004 ) s. j. brodsky and g. f. de tramond , phys .
b * 582 * , 211 ( 2004 ) ; g. f. de teramond and s. j. brodsky , phys .
* 94 * , 201601 ( 2005 ) t. sakai and s. sugimoto , prog .
phys . * 113 * , 843 ( 2005 ) ; * 114 * , 1083 ( 2006 ) j. erlich , e. katz , d. t. son and m. a. stephanov , phys
. rev .
* 95 * , 261602 ( 2005 ) j. erlich , g. d. kribs and i. low , phys .
d * 73 * , 096001 ( 2006 ) l. da rold and a. pomarol , nucl .
b * 721 * , 79 ( 2005 ) ; jhep * 0601 * , 157 ( 2006 ) a. karch , e. katz , d. t. son and m. a. stephanov , phys .
d * 74 * , 015005 ( 2006 ) c. csaki and m. reece , jhep * 0705 * , 062 ( 2007 ) t. hambye , b. hassanain , j. march - russell and m. schvellinger , phys .
d * 74 * , 026003 ( 2006 ) ; arxiv : hep - ph/0612010 j. hirn and v. sanz , jhep * 0512 * , 030 ( 2005 ) ; j. hirn , n. rius and v. sanz , phys .
d * 73 * , 085005 ( 2006 ) k. ghoroku , n. maru , m. tachibana and m. yahiro , phys .
b * 633 * , 602 ( 2006 ) s. j. brodsky and g. f. de teramond , phys .
* 96 * , 201601 ( 2006 ) n. evans , a. tedder and t. waterson , jhep * 0701 * , 058 ( 2007 ) r. casero , e. kiritsis and a. paredes , arxiv : hep - th/0702155 u. gursoy and e. kiritsis , arxiv:0707.1324 [ hep - th ] u. gursoy , e. kiritsis and f. nitti , arxiv:0707.1349 [ hep - th ] o. bergman , s. seki and j. sonnenschein , arxiv:0708.2839 [ hep - th ] j. erdmenger , k. ghoroku and i. kirsch , arxiv:0706.3978 [ hep - th ] a. dhar and p. nag , arxiv:0708.3233 [ hep - th ] a. v. radyushkin , phys .
b * 642 * , 459 ( 2006 ) h. r. grigoryan and a. v. radyushkin , phys .
b * 650 * , 421 ( 2007 ) h. r. grigoryan and a. v. radyushkin , arxiv:0706.1543 [ hep - ph ] s. eidelman _ et al . _
[ particle data group ] , phys . lett .
b * 592 * , 1 ( 2004 ) s. j. brodsky and g. f. de teramond , arxiv:0707.3859 [ hep - ph ] h. j. hippe , phys .
c * 52 * 2172 ( 1995 ) m. a. b. beg and a. zepeda , phys .
d * 6 * , 2912 ( 1972 ) m. k. volkov and v. n. pervushin , phys .
b * 51 * , 356 ( 1974 )
|
we describe a formalism to calculate form factor and charge density distribution of the pion in the chiral limit using the holographic dual model of qcd with hard - wall cutoff .
we introduce two conjugate pion wave functions and present analytic expressions for these functions and for the pion form factor .
they allow to relate such observables as the pion decay constant and the pion charge electric radius to the values of chiral condensate and hard - wall cutoff scale . the evolution of the pion form factor to large values of the momentum transfer is discussed , and results are compared to existing experimental data .
|
in cold dark matter cosmology , the initially smooth distribution of matter in the universe is expected to collapse into a complex network of filaments and voids , structures which have been termed the `` cosmic web '' .
the filamentary distribution of galaxies in the nearby universe has been revealed in detail by recent large galaxy redshift surveys such as the 2dfgrs ( colless et al .
2001 , baugh et al .
2004 ) , the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss , stoughton et al .
2002 , doroshkevich et al . 2004 ) and the 2@xmath19 all sky survey ( 2mass , maller et al .
numerical simulations successfully reproduce this network ( jenkins et al . 1998 ; colberg et al .
2004 ) and indicate that galaxies are only the tip of the iceberg in this cosmic web ( katz et al .
1996 ; miralda - escud et al .
hydrodynamic simulations suggest that at the present epoch , in addition to dark matter and galaxies , the filaments are also composed of a mixture of cool , photoionised gas ( the low@xmath0 remnants of the forest ) and a shock heated , low - density gaseous phase at temperatures between @xmath20 k and @xmath21 k that contains most of the baryonic mass , the `` warm - hot '' intergalactic medium ( whim , cen & ostriker 1999 ; dav et al .
1999 ) .
observational constraints on the physical conditions , distribution , a nd metal enrichment of gas in the low - redshift cosmic web are currently quite limited .
the existence of the whim appears to be a robust prediction of cosmological simulations ( dav et al .
thus , observational efforts are increasingly being invested in the search for whim gas and , more generally , the gaseous filamentary structures predicted by the models .
large - scale gaseous filaments have been detected in x - ray emission ( wang et al .
1997 ; scharf et al .
2000 ; tittley & henriksen 2001 ; rines et al 2001 ) .
however , x - ray emission studies with current facilities predominantly reveal gas which is hotter and denser than the whim ; this x - ray emitting gas is not expected to contain a substantial portion of the present - epoch baryons ( dav et al .
the most promising method for observing the whim in the near term is to search for uv ( o@xmath4roman6 , ne@xmath4roman8 ) and x - ray ( o@xmath4roman7 , o@xmath4roman8 , ne@xmath4roman9 ) absorption lines due to whim gas in the spectra of background qsos / agns ( tripp et al . 2000 , 2001 ; savage et al . 2002,2005 ; nicastro et al . 2002 ; bergeron et al . 2002 ; richter et al . 2004 ; sembach et al .
2004 ; prochaska et al .
2004 ; danforth & shull 2005 ) .
while absorption lines provide a sensitive and powerful probe of the whim , the pencil - beam nature of the measurement along a sight line provides little information on the context of the absorption , e.g. , whether the lines arise in an individual galaxy disk / halo , a galaxy group , or lower - density regions of a large - scale filament or void .
thus , to understand the nature of highly ionised absorbers at low redshifts , several groups are pursuing deep galaxy redshift surveys and observations of qsos behind well - defined galaxy groups or clusters .
for example , to study gas located in large - scale filaments , bregman et al .
( 2004 ) have searched for absorption lines indicative of the whim in regions between galaxy clusters / superclusters and have identified some candidates . in this paper , we carry out a similar search as part of a broader program that combines a large _ hst _ survey of low@xmath0 o@xmath4roman6 absorption systems observed on sight lines to low@xmath0 quasars ( tripp et al . 2004 ) and a ground based survey to measure the redshifts and properties of the galaxies foreground to the background qsos .
the ground based survey is done in two steps : first , multi - band ( u , b , v , r and i ) imagery is obtained to identify the galaxies and to estimate their photometric redshifts .
then , spectroscopic redshifts are obtained for the galaxies that are potentially ( according to the photometric redhshifts ) at lower redshift that the background object . as part of the large _ hst _ survey ,
we have observed the quasar hs0624 + 6907 ( @xmath22 = 0.3700 ) with the e140 m echelle mode of the space telescope imaging spectrograph ( stis ) on board the _ hubble space telescope_. we have also obtained multiband images and spectroscopic redshifts of galaxies in the 0624 field .
the sight line to 0624 passes by several foreground abell clusters ( [ sec : abell_clusters ] ) and provides an opportunity to search for gas in large - scale filaments .
we shall show that gas ( absorption systems ) and galaxies are detected at the redshifts of the structures delineated by the abell clusters in this direction . while the absorbing gas is intergalactic , and it is likely that we are probing gas in cosmic web filaments , the properties of these absorbers are surprising . instead of low - metallicity whim gas , we predominantly find cool , photoionised , and high - metallicity gas in these large - scale structures . this paper is organized as follows .
the observations and data reduction procedures are described in 2 , including _ hst_/stis and _ far ultraviolet spectroscopic explorer _ ( ) observations as well as ground - based imaging and galaxy redshift measurements . in 3 , we present information on the foreground environments probed by the 0624 sight line , derived from the literature on abell clusters and from our new galaxy redshift survey .
the absorption - line measurement methods are described in 4 , and we investigate the physical state and metallicity of the absorbers in 5 .
section 6 reviews the properties of the full sample of ly@xmath16 lines derived from the stis spectrum with emphasis on the search for broad ly@xmath16 lines .
section 7 discusses the implications of this study , and we summarize our conclusions in 8 . throughout this paper ,
we use the following cosmological parameters : @xmath23 , @xmath24 and @xmath25 .
0624 was observed with stis on 2 jan . 2002 and 23 - 24 feb .
2002 as part of a cycle 10 _ hst _ observing program ( id=9184 ) .
the echelle spectrograph was used with the e140 m grating which provides a resolution of 7 fwhm and covers the 1150@xmath261730 range with only a few small gaps between orders at wavelengths greater than 1630 .
the @xmath27 entrance aperture was used to minimize the effect of the wings of the line spread function .
the total exposure time was 61.95 ksec .
the data were reduced as described in tripp et al .
( 2001 ) using the stis team version of calstis at the goddard space flight center .
the final signal - to - noise ( s / n ) per resolution element is 3 at 1150 , increases linearly to 14 at 1340 and then decreases to 7 at 1730 . for further information on the design and performance of stis , see woodgate et al .
( 1998 ) and kimble et al .
( 1998 ) .
hs0624 + 6907 was also observed by the pi team on several occasions between 1999 november and 2002 february ( program ids p1071001 , p1071002 , s6011201 , and s6011202 ) .
records spectra with four independent spectrographs ( `` channels '' ) , two with sic coatings for coverage of the 905@xmath261105 wavelength range , and two with lif coatings optimized to cover 1100@xmath261187 ( see moos et al .
2000,2002 for details about design and performance ) .
the spectrograph resolutions range from 20@xmath2630 km s@xmath28 ( fwhm ) . for hs0624 + 6907 ,
the total integration time in the lif1 channel was 110 ksec ; the other channels had somewhat lower integration times due to channel coalignment problems during some of the observations .
we have retrieved the spectra from the archive and have reduced the data using calfuse version 2.4.0 as described in tripp et al .
( 2005 ) . because the spectra in the individual channels have modest s / n ratios , we have aligned and combined all available lif channels to form the final spectra that we used for our measurements ( we find that combining all available lif data does not degrade the spectral resolution ) .
for the spectral range uniquely covered by the sic channels , we used only the sic2a data . finally , we compared absorption lines of comparable strength ( e.g. , fe@xmath4roman2 @xmath291144.94 vs. fe@xmath4roman2 @xmath291608.45 ) observed by _ fuse _ and stis in order to align the _ fuse _ spectrum with the stis spectrum and thereby correct the wavelength zero point of the data .
one of the primary goals of our low@xmath0 qso absorption line program is to study the connections between galaxies and absorption systems .
these studies require good imaging ( for galaxy target selection and information on individual galaxies of interest ) followed by optical spectroscopy for accurate redshift measurements . to initiate the galaxy - absorber study toward 0624
, we first obtained a @xmath30 mosaic of images centered on the qso with spicam on the apache point observatory ( apo ) 3.5 m telescope on 2002 october 5 .
subsequently , we obtained images of a larger field in better seeing with the noao 8k@xmath318k ccd mosaic camera ( mosa , muller et al .
1998 ) , on the kitt peak national observatory ( kpno ) 4 m telescope .
the spicam images were used to select targets for the first spectroscopic observing run , but thereafter we only used the better - quality mosa images . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] 0624 was observed with mosa on the 4 m on 2003 january 29 - 30 .
the field of view is @xmath32 with a scale of @xmath33/pixel .
as summarized in table [ tab : obslog ] , images were recorded in @xmath34 and @xmath35 with a standard dithering pattern for filling in gaps between the ccds and for rejection of cosmic rays .
photometric standard stars from landolt ( 1992 ) were also observed at regular intervals . during these observations ,
the seeing ranged from @xmath360 to 1@xmath373 .
the data were reduced with the iraf software package mscred following standard procedures .
the final r - band mosa image of 0624 is shown in figures [ fig : field ] and [ fig : fieldzoom ] .
galaxy targets for follow - up spectroscopy were selected from the images using the sextractor software package ( bertin & arnouts 1996 ) .
redshifts of 29 galaxies were obtained using the double imaging spectrograph ( dis ) on the apo 3.5 m telescope on the following dates : 2002 november 12 , 2003 january 29@xmath2631 , 2003 april 03 , 2003 april 21 , and 2003 december 25 .
spectra were recorded using a single 1.5 arcsec wide slit with total exposure times ranging from 360 to 1800 s per object .
the data were processed in the conventional manner , and were wavelength calibrated using helium - neon - argon arc - lamp exposures .
small zero - point offsets in wavelength were applied as needed , after comparing observed skyline wavelengths with their rest values .
the spectra were typically recorded at resolutions of @xmath38 fwhm .
llccccccccc & & & & & & & & & + & & & & & & & & & & & qso & 06:30:02.50 & 69:05:03.99 & 0.3700 & 0.0 & 0.000 & 13.8 & 14.2 & 0.1 & -27.7 + 01 & se12 & 06:30:41.70 & 68:58:32.71 & 0.0327 & 7.4 & 0.290 & 16.6 & 17.8 & 1.0 & -19.2 + 02 & se3 & 06:30:55.32 & 69:02:41.99 & 0.0424 & 5.3 & 0.265 & 19.6 & 20.5 & 0.9 & -16.7 + 03 & ne1 & 06:30:56.14 & 69:08:00.90 & 0.0547 & 5.6 & 0.358 & 15.9 & 17.0 & 0.9 & -21.0 + 04 & nw2 & 06:29:46.66 & 69:08:03.59 & 0.0560 & 3.3 & 0.216 & 18.6 & 19.5 & 0.9 & -18.4 + 05 & se4 & 06:30:33.00 & 68:53:02.00 & 0.0622 & 12.3 & 0.887 & 16.8 & 17.9 & 0.9 & -20.5 + 06 & se5 & 06:32:55.20 & 68:56:59.99 & 0.0637 & 17.4 & 1.282 & 16.8 & 18.3 & 1.3 & -20.5 + 07 & se8 & 06:31:01.79 & 68:57:35.89 & 0.0638 & 9.2 & 0.675 & 16.0 & 17.1 & 0.9 & -21.2 + 08 & se1 & 06:30:11.22 & 69:02:09.61 & 0.0640 & 3.0 & 0.222 & 18.8 & 19.4 & 0.7 & -18.5 + 09 & sw3 & 06:29:07.80 & 69:03:32.01 & 0.0650 & 5.1 & 0.384 & 17.4 & 18.3 & 0.9 & -20.0 + 10 & se13 & 06:30:58.30 & 69:04:34.11 & 0.0650 & 5.0 & 0.375 & 16.9 & 18.5 & 1.3 & -20.4 + 11 & se6 & 06:32:50.70 & 68:56:03.00 & 0.0652 & 17.6 & 1.318 & 15.9 & 17.3 & 1.2 & -21.5 + 12 & ne3 & 06:30:21.40 & 69:05:39.70 & 0.0655 & 1.8 & 0.135 & 16.6 & 18.1 & 1.3 & -20.8 + 13 & nw11 & 06:29:23.48 & 69:22:43.29 & 0.0660 & 18.0 & 1.367 & 16.3 & 17.9 & 1.3 & -21.1 + 14 & se7 & 06:32:49.20 & 68:56:00.39 & 0.0664 & 17.5 & 1.334 & 17.0 & 18.0 & 0.7 & -20.4 + 15 & ne2 & 06:32:25.55 & 69:20:05.81 & 0.0733 & 19.7 & 1.646 & 16.5 & 18.0 & 1.3 & -21.1 + 16 & nw1 & 06:29:43.65 & 69:09:35.33 & 0.0760 & 4.8 & 0.417 & 15.9 & 17.3 & 1.1 & -21.8 + 17 & sw2 & 06:28:33.03 & 68:59:26.30 & 0.0763 & 9.8 & 0.849 & 16.6 & 18.3 & 1.3 & -21.1 + 18 & se9 & 06:30:14.81 & 68:49:44.79 & 0.0764 & 15.4 & 1.334 & 16.4 & 18.0 & 1.3 & -21.3 + 19 & nw12 & 06:29:11.59 & 69:07:07.89 & 0.0764 & 5.0 & 0.433 & 16.4 & 18.0 & 1.4 & -21.3 + 20 & se10 & 06:32:52.40 & 68:57:59.01 & 0.0764 & 16.8 & 1.457 & 16.5 & 18.1 & 1.3 & -21.2 + 21 & nw3 & 06:29:53.77 & 69:08:20.51 & 0.0766 & 3.4 & 0.293 & 18.3 & 19.6 & 1.1 & -19.4 + 22 & sw1 & 06:29:33.24 & 69:05:01.00 & 0.0903 & 2.6 & 0.264 & 17.1 & 18.2 & 0.9 & -21.0 + 23 & se11 & 06:30:06.84 & 68:52:22.20 & 0.1001 & 12.7 & 1.407 & 16.5 & 18.1 & 1.2 & -21.9 + 24 & nw7 & 06:26:43.70 & 69:14:06.91 & 0.1009 & 19.9 & 2.215 & 16.7 & 18.2 & 1.4 & -21.6 + 25 & nw9 & 06:29:03.89 & 69:17:33.40 & 0.1108 & 13.5 & 1.639 & 16.4 & 18.2 & 1.3 & -22.2 + 26 & nw4a & 06:29:35.43 & 69:07:25.80 & 0.1125 & 3.4 & 0.415 & 18.5 & 20.2 & 1.2 & -20.1 + 27 & nw8 & 06:28:29.39 & 69:17:28.89 & 0.1126 & 14.9 & 1.832 & 16.7 & 18.5 & 1.3 & -21.9 + 28 & nw10 & 06:29:05.25 & 69:17:46.69 & 0.1129 & 13.7 & 1.685 & 18.1 & 19.9 & 1.3 & -20.5 + 29 & nw6 & 06:29:35.30 & 69:09:44.99 & 0.1429 & 5.3 & 0.794 & 19.4 & 20.4 & 0.8 & -19.8 + 30 & se2 & 06:30:44.35 & 69:01:08.09 & 0.1664 & 5.4 & 0.927 & 19.3 & 20.8 & 1.0 & -20.2 + 31 & nw5 & 06:29:43.52 & 69:09:19.01 & 0.2061 & 4.6 & 0.927 & 18.4 & 20.3 & 1.4 & -21.7 + 32 & nw4b & 06:29:35.62 & 69:07:37.91 & 0.3008 & 3.5 & 0.940 & 21.0 & 22.2 & 0.4 & -19.9 the redshift measurements were made following the procedure described by jenkins et al .
we used the iraf routine fxcor to cross - correlate the galaxy spectra with that of the radial velocity standard hd 182572 .
in general we only used the blue channel dis data for the cross - correlation , where the 4000 break and stellar absorption lines were most apparent .
red channel data were usually used to identify and measure the wavelengths of redshifted emission lines ( [ o iii ] , h@xmath39 , h@xmath16 , etc . )
when present .
the galaxy redshifts obtained in this way are summarized in table [ tab : spec_red ] and are accurate to between 70 and 170 ( which corresponds to a sight line distance displacement uncertainty of 1.0 to 2.4 mpc for an unperturbed hubble flow ) .
we also observed three galaxies with the echellette spectrometer and imager ( esi ; sheinis et al . 2001 ) on the 10 m keck ii telescope on the nights of 2004
september 10 and 11 during morning twilight .
we observed galaxy ne3 ( see table [ tab : spec_red ] ) in echellette mode with the 0.5@xmath40 slit which provides @xmath41 spectral resolution ( fwhm ) .
the fainter se13 and sw3 galaxies were observed in low dispersion mode using a 1@xmath40 slit which affords @xmath42 at @xmath43 .
the exposures were flat fielded and wavelength calibrated with the esiredux package ( prochaska et al .
2003xavier / esi / index.html ] ) .
the ne3 redshift was derived from the centroids of the high - resolution na@xmath4roman1 and h@xmath16 absorption lines , and the redshift uncertainty is @xmath4430 km s@xmath28 . for se13 and sw3 , redshifts were measured by fitting na@xmath4roman1 , h@xmath39 , and ca@xmath4roman2 h and k , and the uncertainties are @xmath44150 km s@xmath28 .
the completeness of our galaxy redshift survey ( i.e. , the percentage of targets brighter than a given magnitude in the sextractor galaxy catalog with good spectroscopic redshifts ) is graphically summarized in figure [ fig : completeness ] as a function of limiting @xmath45 magnitude and angular separation from the sight line ( @xmath46 ) . in the @xmath47 region centered on 0624 , we have measured spectroscopic redshifts for all galaxies brighter than @xmath45 = 19.0 , and the survey is @xmath48 per cent complete for @xmath49 .
as we shall see , there is a prominent cluster of absorption lines in the 0624 spectrum at @xmath50 0.0635 ; at this redshift , 5@xmath51 corresponds to a projected distance of 367 @xmath7 kpc , and @xmath45 = 19.0 corresponds to @xmath52 or @xmath53 ( taking @xmath54 from lin et al .
1996 ) . for comparison ,
the large magellanic cloud has a magnitude equal to @xmath55 or @xmath56 . at this redshift
, we have good completeness even for low luminosity galaxies . at larger radii ,
a substantial number of bright galaxies are found , and our redshift survey is shallower . nevertheless , within a 10 radius circle ,
our survey is still 60 per cent complete for galaxies brighter than @xmath57 .
using information gleaned from the literature in combination with our galaxy redshift survey , we can identify several large - scale structures that are pierced by the 0624 sight line . in this section we comment on these structures including nearby abell clusters ( [ sec : abell_clusters ] ) as well as smaller ( and closer ) galaxy groups ( [ sec : close_groups ] ) .
clusters are clustered and often reveal even larger cosmic structures , i.e. , superclusters ( einasto et al . 2001 and references therein ) . in cosmological simulations ,
clusters are found at the nodes where large - scale filaments connect . to test the fidelity of cosmological simulations , which are now being used in a wide variety of astrophysical analyses ,
it is important to search for observational evidence of the expected _ gaseous _ filaments feeding into clusters and to measure the properties of the filaments .
the sight line to 0624 passes through a region of relatively high abell cluster density and is well - suited for investigation of this topic .
shows the positions of abell clusters around the sight line to 0624 , including the cluster richness class and spectroscopic redshift ( when available from the literature ) .
the density of abell clusters in this region is relatively high compared to the vicinity of the other clusters in the abell catalog : the number of abell clusters within 2@xmath58 ( 3@xmath59 ) of a557 ( the cluster closest to the 0624 sight line ) is 2 ( 1.6 ) times larger than the average number within 2@xmath60 ( 3@xmath59 ) of all abell clusters .
einasto et al .
( 2001 ) have identified two superclusters in the direction of 0624 .
their supercluster scl71 ( at @xmath61 ) includes a554,a557 , a561 , a562 , and a565 while scl72 ( at @xmath62 ) includes a559 and a564 .
however , a557 and a561 do not have spectroscopic redshifts , and based on our spectroscopic redshifts in the field of hs0624 + 6907/abell557 ( see table [ tab : spec_red ] ) , it appears likely that the visually identified a557 is a false cluster due to the superposition of galaxy groups at several different redshifts . to be conservative
, we only use clusters with spectroscopic redshifts to identify large - scale structures .
the clusters at ( a564 and a559 ) are separated by 4.7 from each other , and the clusters at ( a565 , a562 and a554 ) are separated by 3.9 and 8.7 . according to colberg et al .
( 2004 ) , in cosmological simulations , more than 85 per cent of the clusters with a separation lower than 10 are connected with a filament .
we will show in subsequent sections that both absorption lines in the spectrum of 0624 and galaxies close to the sight line are detected at the redshifts of both of these abell cluster structures , which indicates that gaseous filaments connect into the clusters .
in this section we offer some brief comments about specific galaxies and galaxy groups close to the sight line of 0624 , as revealed by our optical spectroscopy .
we place these observations in the context of the abell clusters described in the previous section .
we plot in the redshift distribution of the galaxies from table [ tab : spec_red ] . from this figure
we can identify three galaxy groups : two galaxy groups appear to be present at redshifts similar to those of the abell clusters , i.e , at @xmath63 ( 7 galaxies ) and @xmath64 ( 6 galaxies ) .
this indicates that the filament of galaxies connecting a559 to a564 must extend more then 3 degrees ( 15 ) west from a559 and structure linking a562 and a554 likely extends by at least 3 degrees ( 22 ) in order to cross the qso sight line .
however , the most prominent group in includes 10 galaxies at , which does not match up with any abell cluster with a known spectroscopic redshift . to show the spatial distribution of galaxies in the three prominent groups in the mosa field , provides a colour - coded map of projected spatial coordinates of the galaxies .
we see that the group at @xmath65 is mostly southeast of the sight line while the galaxies associated with abell 554/562/565 at are predominantly northwest of 0624 .
the galaxies associated with the abell 559/564 supercluster appear to extend from the southwest across the sight line to the northeast .
we note that spectroscopic redshifts are not available for several of the clusters shown in fig .
[ fig : abell_map ] , including the one that is closest to the sight line , a557
. however , abell clusters are visually identified without the aid of spectroscopy , and it can be seen from figures [ fig : field ] and [ fig : gal_colour ] that several discrete groups are found at the location of a557 . it is likely that a557 is not a true cluster but rather is the superposition of several groups in projection . is gas also present in these large - scale cosmic filaments ? to address this question , we searched the spectrum of 0624 for any absorption counterparts at the redshifts of galaxies and galaxy structures near the qso sight line .
the redshifts of the h@xmath4roman1 systems that we have identified and measured ( see [ sec : absline ] ) in the spectrum of 0624 are plotted at the top of ; the length of the line is proportional to the rest equivalent width of the line .
this search has revealed three interesting results : first , when a galaxy is located at an impact parameter @xmath66 from the sight line , absorption is almost always found within a few hundred of the galaxy redshift ( compare table [ tab : spec_red ] to table [ tab : lyalist ] ) , consistent with the findings of previous studies ( e.g. , lanzetta et al .
1995 ; tripp et al . 1998 ; impey et al . 1999
; chen et al . 2001 ; bowen et al . 2002 ; penton et al . 2002 ) .
second , strong absorption is clearly detected at the redshift of the @xmath67 abell 564/559 supercluster .
this absorption system is detected in , , and the c@xmath4roman4 @xmath68 1548.20 , 1550.78 doublet ( [ ss : z076 ] ) , and the absorption redshift is very similar to that of a559 .
weak absorption is also detected at @xmath13 = 0.10822 , which is within 500 of the abell 554/562/565 filament .
evidently , and not surprisingly , gas is also found in the filaments that feed into the clusters near 0624 .
third , figure [ fig : zgaldist ] qualitatively indicates that the strongest lines are situated in the regions of highest galaxy density , which is similar to the conclusions of bowen et al .
( 2002 ) and c^ ot et al .
( 2005 ) .
could these absorbers simply arise in the halos of individual galaxies ? as we show in the next section , the strong h@xmath4roman1 system at is comprised of a large number of components spread over 1000 .
such kinematics are unprecedented in single galaxy halos . in addition , we find no obvious pattern that shows a connection between individual lines and individual galaxies in this complex . in the case of this strong h@xmath4roman1 system at ,
the closest observed galaxy to the sight line around this redshift has @xmath69 ( ne3 in table [ tab : spec_red ] ) .
however , a closer and fainter galaxy could have been missed by the spectroscopic survey .
using photometric redshifts ( measured as described in chen et al .
2003 ) to cull the distant background galaxies with photometric redshifts @xmath70 , we find that there are only four galaxies closer to the sight line than ne3 that could be near .
these four objects are only candidates since photometric redshifts have substantial uncertainties . however , if we assume the redshift of these candidates to be @xmath71 , the closest one to 0624 has still a large impact parameter @xmath72 kpc . in the case of at @xmath13
= 0.07573 , the closest galaxy in projection is nw3 at @xmath73 kpc .
it is conceivable that this absorption originates in the large halo of this particular galaxy , but we note that three galaxies are found at @xmath74 kpc at this @xmath75 , and many other origins are possible ( e.g. , intragroup gas or tidally stripped debris ) .
finally , the absorption at @xmath76 is at a substantial distance ( 415 ) from the nearest known galaxy ( nw4a ) and is unlikely to be halo gas associated with that object .
we now turn to the absorption - line measurements . as discussed in the previous section , figure [ fig : zgaldist ]
compares the distributions of galaxies and ly@xmath16 lines in the direction of 0624 .
we have measured the column densities and doppler parameters of the ly@xmath16 lines in the spectrum of 0624 using the voigt profile decomposition software vpfit ( see webb 1987rfc / vpfit.html ] ) .
table [ tab : lyalist ] summarizes the h@xmath4roman1 equivalent widths , column densities , and @xmath77values measured in this fashion ( some of the lines are strongly saturated and consequently voigt profile fitting does not provide reliable measurements ; we discuss our treatment of these cases below ) .
a particularly dramatic cluster of ly@xmath16 lines is evident at @xmath78 0.0635 in figure [ fig : zgaldist ] .
the portion of the stis spectrum of hs0624 + 6907 covering this ly@xmath16 cluster is shown in figure [ fig : hi00635 ] . to avoid confusion with galaxy clusters
, we will hereafter refer to this group of lines as a `` complex '' .
this complex contains at least 13 h@xmath4roman1 components spread over a velocity range of 1000 km s@xmath28 .
we will refer to the strongest ly@xmath16 absorption in figure [ fig : hi00635 ] at @xmath13 = 0.06352 as `` component a '' .
component a is detected in absorption in the h@xmath4roman1 ly@xmath16 , ly@xmath39 , and ly@xmath79 transitions as well as the si@xmath4roman3 @xmath291206.50 , si@xmath4roman4 @xmath681393.76 , 1402.77 , and c@xmath4roman4 @xmath681548.20 , 1550.78 lines .
low ionisation stages such as o@xmath4roman1 , c@xmath4roman2 , and si@xmath4roman2 are not detected at the redshift of component a or at the redshifts of any of the other components evident in figure [ fig : hi00635 ] .
the o@xmath4roman6 doublet at the redshifts of the ly@xmath16 cluster in falls in a region that is partially blocked by galactic h@xmath80 and fe@xmath4roman2 lines .
nevertheless , much of the region is free from blending , and we find no evidence for o@xmath4roman6 absorption .
we also do not see the n@xmath4roman5 doublet .
lccl|lccl & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 + @xmath75 & ( m ) & ( ) & ( ) & @xmath75 & ( m ) & ( ) & ( ) 0.017553@xmath84 1.0e-5 & 45@xmath8410 & 12.96@xmath840.05 & 29@xmath84 4.3 & 0.207540@xmath84 0.5e-5 & 150@xmath84 9 & 13.48@xmath840.02 & 27@xmath84 1.5 + 0.030651@xmath84 0.4e-5 & 99@xmath84 9 & 13.36@xmath840.03 & 22@xmath84 1.7 & 0.213232@xmath84 1.6e-5 & 98@xmath8414 & 13.22@xmath840.05 & 45@xmath84 5.6 + 0.041156@xmath84 0.8e-5 & 104@xmath8411 & 13.33@xmath840.03 & 41@xmath84 3.0 & 0.219900@xmath84 2.3e-5 & 143@xmath8415 & 13.39@xmath840.05 & 60@xmath84 8.6 + 0.053942@xmath84 0.6e-5 & 85@xmath84 7 & 13.26@xmath840.04 & 24@xmath84 2.3 & 0.223290@xmath84 0.3e-5 & 256@xmath8412 & 13.86@xmath840.02 & 25@xmath84 0.9 + 0.054367@xmath84 4.1e-5@xmath85 & 65@xmath8413 & 13.09@xmath840.11 & 60@xmath8419.2@xmath86 & 0.232305@xmath84 2.8e-5@xmath87 & 125@xmath8413 & 13.33@xmath840.08 & 44@xmath84 7.7@xmath86 + 0.054829@xmath88 & 458@xmath8410 & @xmath4414.5@xmath89 & @xmath4435@xmath89 & 0.232547@xmath84 2.3e-5@xmath87 & 44@xmath8410 & 12.86@xmath840.21 & 24@xmath84 7.3 + 0.055153@xmath84 7.8e-5@xmath87 & 237@xmath8414 & 13.68@xmath840.17 & 84@xmath8430.7@xmath86 & 0.240599@xmath84 0.6e-5 & 110@xmath8410 & 13.33@xmath840.04 & 20@xmath84 2.0 + 0.061879@xmath84 0.4e-5 & 184@xmath84 6 & 13.77@xmath840.03 & 21@xmath84 1.4 & 0.252251@xmath84 1.2e-5 & 55@xmath8411 & 12.96@xmath840.06 & 24@xmath84 4.2 + 0.062014@xmath84 1.0e-5 & 21@xmath84 4 & 12.63@xmath840.17 & 8@xmath84 4.7 & 0.268559@xmath84 2.1e-5 & 68@xmath8414 & 13.03@xmath840.05 & 51@xmath84 7.2 + 0.062150@xmath84 1.5e-5@xmath87 & 13@xmath84 4 & 12.41@xmath840.22 & 10@xmath84 7.9 & 0.272240@xmath84 0.6e-5 & 37@xmath84 8 & 12.80@xmath840.06 & 12@xmath84 2.2 + 0.062343@xmath84 0.8e-5@xmath87 & 128@xmath84 7 & 13.45@xmath840.05 & 30@xmath84 4.0 & 0.279771@xmath84 1.7e-5@xmath87 & 174@xmath8413 & 13.50@xmath840.06 & 34@xmath84 4.9 + 0.062647@xmath84 2.5e-5@xmath87 & 101@xmath84 7 & 13.31@xmath840.14 & 35@xmath8412.3 & 0.280171@xmath84 0.7e-5@xmath87 & 576@xmath8415 & 14.32@xmath840.02 & 43@xmath84 1.9@xmath86 + 0.062762@xmath84 0.7e-5@xmath87 & 39@xmath84 3 & 12.95@xmath840.28 & 8@xmath84 3.7 & 0.295307@xmath84 0.7e-5 & 309@xmath8415 & 13.80@xmath840.02 & 42@xmath84 2.0 + 0.062850@xmath84 1.2e-5@xmath87 & 110@xmath84 5 & 13.42@xmath840.14 & 20@xmath84 7.0 & 0.296607@xmath84 0.9e-5 & 203@xmath8418 & 13.54@xmath840.02 & 52@xmath84 2.9 + 0.063037@xmath84 1.4e-5@xmath87 & 101@xmath84 6 & 13.33@xmath840.13 & 27@xmath84 8.8 & 0.308991@xmath84 0.6e-5 & 167@xmath8412 & 13.49@xmath840.03 & 28@xmath84 1.8 + 0.063456@xmath84 1.6e-5@xmath87 & 569@xmath84 9 & 14.46@xmath840.30 & 48@xmath84 8.4@xmath86 & 0.309909@xmath84 5.5e-5@xmath87 & 246@xmath8418 & 13.61@xmath840.10 & 66@xmath8412.3@xmath86 + 0.063481@xmath84 1.6e-5@xmath87 & 443@xmath84 6 & 15.27@xmath840.13 & 24@xmath84 5.5 & 0.310454@xmath84 8.0e-5@xmath87 & 170@xmath8417 & 13.43@xmath840.33 & 62@xmath8440.3@xmath86 + 0.063620@xmath84 2.7e-5@xmath87 & 153@xmath84 4 & 14.29@xmath840.38 & 10@xmath84 5.6 & 0.310881@xmath8414.4e-5 & 88@xmath8416 & 13.13@xmath840.43 & 51@xmath8427.7 + 0.064753@xmath84 0.9e-5@xmath87 & 257@xmath84 9 & 13.87@xmath840.04 & 33@xmath84 3.0 & 0.312802@xmath84 4.4e-5 & 257@xmath8418 & 13.65@xmath840.10 & 54@xmath84 9.3 + 0.065016@xmath84 0.8e-5@xmath87 & 282@xmath84 8 & 13.97@xmath840.04 & 31@xmath84 2.7 & 0.313028@xmath84 1.6e-5 & 72@xmath8410 & 13.09@xmath840.24 & 17@xmath84 6.8 + 0.075731@xmath84 0.2e-5 & 292@xmath84 8 & 14.18@xmath840.03 & 24@xmath84 0.8 & 0.313261@xmath84 4.7e-5 & 244@xmath8419 & 13.62@xmath840.10 & 55@xmath8410.9 + 0.090228@xmath84 4.2e-5 & 106@xmath8412 & 13.29@xmath840.08 & 76@xmath8413.7 & 0.317901@xmath84 1.2e-5 & 139@xmath8418 & 13.37@xmath840.04 & 34@xmath84 3.6 + 0.130757@xmath84 1.0e-5 & 114@xmath84 9 & 13.34@xmath840.04 & 34@xmath84 3.6 & 0.320889@xmath84 0.4e-5 & 349@xmath8414 & 13.97@xmath840.02 & 31@xmath84 1.2 + 0.135966@xmath84 3.9e-5 & 119@xmath8411 & 13.33@xmath840.10 & 57@xmath8410.7 & 0.327245@xmath84 5.0e-5@xmath87 & 316@xmath8421 & 13.73@xmath840.32 & 69@xmath8415.6@xmath86 + 0.160541@xmath84 5.0e-5@xmath87 & 69@xmath84 7 & 13.08@xmath840.21 & 34@xmath8410.3 & 0.327721@xmath8438.7e-5@xmath87 & 264@xmath8426 & 13.61@xmath840.43 & 115@xmath8462.1@xmath86 + 0.160744@xmath84 1.0e-5@xmath87 & 200@xmath84 7 & 13.66@xmath840.05 & 30@xmath84 2.4 & 0.332674@xmath84 1.1e-5 & 202@xmath8418 & 13.55@xmath840.04 & 38@xmath84 3.4 + 0.199750@xmath84 0.6e-5 & 87@xmath84 9 & 13.24@xmath840.05 & 17@xmath84 2.0 & 0.339759@xmath84 0.3e-5 & 647@xmath8413 & 14.45@xmath840.03 & 42@xmath84 1.3 + 0.199946@xmath84 1.2e-5@xmath87 & 83@xmath8411 & 13.17@xmath840.06 & 26@xmath84 4.6 & 0.346824@xmath84 0.6e-5 & 221@xmath8416 & 13.59@xmath840.02 & 39@xmath84 1.9 + 0.204831@xmath84 0.3e-5 & 208@xmath84 9 & 13.72@xmath840.02 & 24@xmath84 1.0 & 0.348645@xmath84 0.9e-5 & 40@xmath8410 & 12.78@xmath840.06 & 18@xmath84 3.0 + 0.205326@xmath84 0.2e-5 & 322@xmath84 8 & 14.12@xmath840.03 & 25@xmath84 0.8 figure
[ fig : syst0063 ] compares the absorption profiles of the ly@xmath16 , ly@xmath39 , ly@xmath79 , si@xmath4roman3 , si@xmath4roman4 , and c@xmath4roman4 lines at @xmath13 = 0.06352 , and table [ tab : cldnlist0064 ] lists the equivalent widths , column densities , and @xmath77values of the metals detected at this redshift as well as upper limits on undetected species of interest . both voigt - profile fitting and direct integration of the `` apparent column density '' profile ( see savage & sembach 1991 ; jenkins 1996 ) were used to estimate the metal column densities .
these independent methods are generally in good agreement for the metal lines , which do not appear to be strongly affected by unresolved saturation . the si@xmath4roman3 @xmath90 absorption at @xmath91 0.06352 is slightly blended with a strong h@xmath4roman1 line at @xmath91 0.05486 ( see figure [ fig : syst0063 ] ) . however , the metal lines at this redshift have a distinctive two - component profile ( see figures [ fig : syst0063 ] and [ fig : civ064 ] ) , and the si@xmath4roman3 profile shape is in good agreement with those of the c@xmath4roman4 and si@xmath4roman4 lines .
this indicates that ( unrelated ) blended from @xmath13 = 0.05486 contributes little optical depth to the wavelength range where the si@xmath4roman3 absorption occurs .
we fitted the and h@xmath4roman1 at @xmath920.05486 simultaneously , assuming all of the components are centered shortward of the si@xmath4roman3 line .
the resulting joint fit is shown in figure [ fig : syst0063 ] .
the profile parameters derived for most of the lines in the @xmath93 cluster are reasonably well - constrained .
some of the components are strongly blended and are consequently more uncertain than the formal profile - fitting error bars indicate ; these are marked in table [ tab : lyalist ] .
component a was also difficult to measure for a different reason : the three usable lyman series lines ( ly@xmath16 , ly@xmath39 and ly@xmath79 ) are all saturated , and consequently voigt profile fitting did not provide good constraints for the determination of the component a h@xmath4roman1 column densities .
as shown in figure [ fig : cog ] , using a single - component curve of growth and the observed equivalent widths of ly@xmath94 , and @xmath79 , we find that the component a h@xmath4roman1 absorption lines can be reproduced by two distinct sets of values for the h@xmath4roman1 column density and the doppler parameter .
one of the two sets implies n(h@xmath4roman1)@xmath95 , which should produce a strong absorption edge characteristic of a lyman limit system ( lls ) at an observed wavelength of 970 .
this wavelength region is covered by the spectrum in the sic2a channel and is shown in figure [ fig : lls_rutr ] . the
s / n of the sic2a channel is low but is adequate to constrain @xmath96(h@xmath4roman1 ) .
the optical depth @xmath97 of the lyman limit absorption and the h@xmath4roman1 column density are approximately related by @xmath98 where @xmath99 ) is the absorption cross section and @xmath29 is the rest - frame wavelength .
the sic2a spectrum does not show any compelling evidence of a lyman limit edge at the expected wavelength , but the continuum placement is somewhat uncertain and because of this , a small lyman limit decrement could be present .
based on the small depth of the flux decrement at @xmath100 = 970 , we derive a @xmath101 upper limit of @xmath96(h@xmath4roman1 ) @xmath102 @xmath103 ( upper black solid curve in figure [ fig : lls_rutr ] ) .
we also show in figure [ fig : lls_rutr ] the lyman limit absorption expected for @xmath96(h@xmath4roman1 ) = @xmath104 @xmath103 ( lower black curve ) , which is too strong with our adopted continuum placement . the absence of a strong lyman limit edge rules out the higher h@xmath4roman1 column density of 10@xmath105 @xmath103 predicted by the curve of growth shown in figure [ fig : cog ] .
the lower @xmath96(h@xmath4roman1 ) derived from the curve of growth ( 10@xmath106 @xmath103 ) is consistent with the lack of a lyman limit edge . to be conservative
, we present below the metallicities derived both from the upper limit [ @xmath96(h@xmath4roman1 ) @xmath107 and from the somewhat lower best value from the curve of growth shown in figure [ fig : cog ] .
we next examine the physical conditions and metal enrichment of the absorption systems implied by the column densities and the doppler parameters obtained from voigt profile fitting .
we concentrate on the absorbers at @xmath13=0.06352 and 0.0757 because these systems show metal absorption and can be associated with nearby galaxies / structures as discussed in
[ sec : environment ] . to derive abundances from the detected metals in these systems ( si@xmath4roman3 , si@xmath4roman4 , and c@xmath4roman4 )
, we must apply ionisation corrections , which depend on the ionisation mechanism and physical conditions of the gas .
we will show that the gas is predominantly photoionised , and that the implied metallicities are relatively high . to investigate the absorber ionisation corrections and metallicities , we employ cloudy photoionisation models ( v96 , ferland et al .
1998 ) as described in tripp et al .
( 2003 ) . in these models ,
the absorbers are approximated as constant density , plane - parallel gas slabs with a thickness that reproduces the observed h@xmath4roman1 column density .
the gas in the cloud is photoionised by the uv background from quasars at @xmath108 .
we used the uv background spectrum shape computed by haardt & madau ( 1996 ) with the intensity normalized to @xmath109 at 1 rydberg .
this value is consistent with theoretical and observational constraints ( shull et al .
1999 ; weymann et al .
2001 ; dav & tripp 2001 , and references therein ) . with the models required to match the observed @xmath96(h@xmath4roman1 ) , the predicted metal column densities depend mainly on the ionisation parameter @xmath110 ( @xmath111 ionising photon density / total hydrogen number density ) , the overall metallicity , = log ( @xmath96(x)/@xmath96(y ) ) - log ( x / y)@xmath112 . ] and the assumed relative abundances of the metals .
we assume solar relative abundances , and we adopt recent revisions reported by allende prieto et al .
( 2001,2002 ) and holweger ( 2001 ) for oxygen , carbon , and silicon , respectively .
the high - ion column densities predicted by the photoionisation models depend on the assumed uv background shape . in this paper
, we primarily use the uv background shape computed by haardt & madau ( 1996 ) , but we note that other assessments of the uv background ( e.g. , madau , haardt , & rees 1999 ; shull et al . 1999 ) adopt a somewhat steeper euv spectral index for quasars , which changes the cloudy ionisation patterns for a given metallicity and ionisation parameter .
we investigate how these uv background uncertainties affect our results by modeling our systems with both uv background shapes ( see below ) .
@l@ c@ c@ ccc@ & @xmath114 & & @xmath81 & & + species & ( ) & @xmath115 & ( m ) & @xmath116 & @xmath117h i & 1215.670 & 2.704 & 603@xmath84 9 & 15.37@xmath118 & @xmath119 + & 1025.722 & 1.909 & 349@xmath8421 & & @xmath119 + & 972.537 & 1.450 & 302@xmath8422 & & @xmath119 + o i & 1302.168 & 1.804 & 6@xmath84 9 & & @xmath120 + o vi & 1037.617 & 1.836 & 28@xmath8417 & & @xmath121 + c ii & 1334.532 & 2.232 & 104@xmath84 9 & & @xmath122 + c iv & 1548.204 & 2.470 & 143@xmath84 9 & 13.67@xmath123 & 13.61@xmath840.03 + & 1550.781 & 2.169 & 90@xmath8410 & & 13.63@xmath840.05 +
si ii & 1260.422 & 3.104 & 23@xmath8412 & & @xmath124 + si iii & 1206.500 & 3.304 & 151@xmath8410 & 13.02@xmath125 & 13.08@xmath840.03 + si iv & 1393.760 & 2.855 & 76@xmath8410 & 13.05@xmath126 & 12.95@xmath840.06 + & 1402.773 & 2.554 & 49@xmath8411 & & 13.05@xmath840.10 +
n v & 1242.804 & 1.988 & 23@xmath8410 & & @xmath127 as discussed above , the h@xmath4roman1 absorption lines detected at @xmath128 are spread over a wide velocity range of @xmath129 ( see figure [ fig : hi00635 ] ) . from the velocity centroids of the 13 fitted voigt profiles and by using the biweight statistic as described in beers et al .
( 1990 ) , we estimate that the line - of - sight velocity dispersion of this h@xmath4roman1 absorption complex is @xmath130 .
the velocity dispersion of galaxies near this redshift is comparable to this value though substantially more uncertain ( due to the larger uncertainties in the galaxy redshifts ) .
this velocity dispersion is comparable to those observed in elliptical - rich galaxy groups ( e.g. zabludoff & mulchaey 1998 ) , which is interesting because elliptical - rich groups often show diffuse x - ray emission ( mulchaey & zabludoff 1998 ) indicative of hot gas in the intragroup medium .
however , we will show in [ sec : discussion ] that the available information suggests that this group is predominantly composed of late - type spiral and s0 galaxies .
spiral - rich groups are much fainter in x - rays but could still contain hot intragroup gas if the gas is somewhat cooler ( @xmath131 k ) or has a much lower density than that found in elliptical - rich groups ( mulchaey 2000 ) . however , we argue that most of the gas in the complex at @xmath132 is unlikely to be hot , collisionally ionised gas for several reasons : first , the h@xmath4roman1 lines in the complex are generally too narrow .
if the line broadening is dominated by thermal motions , then the doppler parameter is directly related to the gas temperature , @xmath133 , where @xmath134 is the mass , @xmath135 is the atomic mass number , and the numerical coefficient is for @xmath83 in km s@xmath28 and @xmath136 in k. since other factors such as turbulence and multiple components can contribute to the line broadening , @xmath77values provide only upper limits on the temperature . applying this equation to the line @xmath77values from table [ tab : lyalist ]
, we find that most of the h@xmath4roman1 lines in the @xmath137 complex indicate that @xmath8 k , which is colder than expected for the diffuse intragroup medium based on observed group velocity dispersions , even in spiral - rich groups ( e.g. , mulchaey et al .
1996 ) . in a complex cluster of lines
, it is easy to hide a broad component indicative of hot gas ( see , e.g. , figure 6 in tripp & savage 2000 ) , so the narrow lines do not preclude the presence of hot gas , but they do indicate that many cool clouds are present in the intragroup medium .
second , the metal line profiles in component a favor cool , photoionised gas .
if component a metal lines were to arise in gas in collisional ionisation equilibrium ( cie ) , the @xmath96(c@xmath4roman4)/@xmath96(si@xmath4roman4 ) and @xmath96(si@xmath4roman4)/@xmath96(si@xmath4roman3 ) column density ratios ( integrated across both components seen in these species , see table [ tab : cldnlist0064 ] ) would require a gas temperature @xmath138 k ( sutherland & dopita 1993 ) .
however the c@xmath4roman4 component at @xmath139 km s@xmath28 is rather narrow . to show this , figure [ fig : civ064 ] plots an expanded view of the c@xmath4roman4 doublet .
we see that the @xmath139 km s@xmath28 is marginally resolved at the stis e140 m resolution of @xmath140 km s@xmath28 .
voigt profile fitting for this component formally yields @xmath141 , which is significantly lower than the @xmath77value implied by the cie temperature , i.e. , @xmath142 km s@xmath28 .
the stronger component at @xmath143 km s@xmath28 is broader ( see figure [ fig : civ064 ] ) , but the @xmath96(c@xmath4roman4)/@xmath96(si@xmath4roman4 ) and @xmath96(si@xmath4roman4)/@xmath96(si@xmath4roman3 ) ratios are similar in the components at @xmath144 and 0 km s@xmath28 , and we expect the ionisation mechanism and physical conditions to be similar in both components
. third , cloudy models photoionised by the uv background from qsos are fully consistent with the measured si@xmath4roman3 , si@xmath4roman4 , and c@xmath4roman4 column densities ( and upper limits on undetected species ) at @xmath13 = 0.06352 .
figure [ fig : cloudym ] shows the relevant metal column densities predicted by cloudy models ( small symbols connected with solid lines ) with log @xmath96(h@xmath4roman1 ) = 15.37 and [ m / h ] = @xmath145 compared to the observed column densities ( large symbols ) .
we can see that the metal column densities are in agreement ( within the 1@xmath146 observational uncertainties ) with this model at log @xmath147 ( log @xmath148 ) .
the narrow h@xmath4roman1 and c@xmath4roman4 components at this redshift could still arise in shock - heated material if they originate in gas that is not in ionisation equilibrium .
many papers have considered the properties of gas that is initially shock - heated to some high temperature and then cools more rapidly than it can recombine ( e.g. , shapiro & moore 1976 ; edgar & chevalier 1986 ) . however
, if component a metal lines were to arise in gas in such a state , according to both computations from shapiro & moore ( 1996 ) and schmutzler & tscharnuter ( 1992 ) , the @xmath96(si@xmath4roman3)/@xmath96(si@xmath4roman4 ) column density ratio would require a gas temperature similar ( @xmath138 k ) to the one found for the collisional ionisation equilibrium hypothesis . moreover , assuming solar abundances , the predicted o@xmath4roman6 column density at this temperature is always higher than our observed upper limit ( @xmath445 times higher in the schmutzler model ) .
finally , the @xmath96(c@xmath4roman4)/@xmath96(si@xmath4roman4 ) column density ratio implies an even higher temperature than 10@xmath149 k ( 2.5 times higherr in the shapiro model ) . because of these points
, this non - equilibrium cooling gas scenario seems unlikely to apply to the @xmath113 absorber toward 0624 .
the cloudy modeling has some other interesting implications in addition to the basic conclusion that the gas is photoionised .
for example , the photoionisation model indicates that the absorber has a relatively high metallicity of @xmath150 even though we have found no luminous galaxies within @xmath151 .
a similarly high metallicity ( [ o / h]@xmath152 ) was recently reported by jenkins et al .
( 2005 ) for a lls in the spectrum of phl1811 , but that system is much closer in projection to a luminous galaxy .
if we adopt the more conservative upper limit on @xmath96(h@xmath4roman1 ) from the absence of a lyman limit edge ( @xmath96(h@xmath4roman1)@xmath153 , see figure [ fig : lls_rutr ] ) instead of the curve - of - growth h@xmath4roman1 column , we obtain [ m / h ] @xmath154 .
this lower limit is still substantially higher than metallicities typically observed in analogous absorbers at higher redshifts ( e.g. , schaye et al .
2003 ) and is comparable to abundances seen in high - velocity clouds near the milky way ( e.g. , sembach et al . 2001,2004 ; collins , shull , & giroux 2003 ; tripp et al .
2003 ; ganguly et al . 2005 ; fox et al .
2005 ) . to derive confidence limits on parameters extracted from our cloudy models , for combinations of metallicity @xmath155 and ionisation parameter @xmath110 we calculated the @xmath156 statistic , @xmath157 where @xmath96 indicates column density and
the sum is over the three ions si@xmath4roman3 , si@xmath4roman4 , and c@xmath4roman4 .
with the minimum @xmath156 obtained at [ m / h ] = @xmath145 and log @xmath158 , we evaluated confidence limits by finding parameters that increased @xmath159 by the amount appropriate for a given confidence level ( see lampton , margon , & bowyer 1976 ; press et al .
1992 ) . in this way ,
we find [ m / h ] = @xmath160 at the 2@xmath146 confidence level .
of course , these confidence limits do not fully reflect potential sources of systematic error such as uncertainties in the shape of the ionising flux field or accuracy of the atomic data incorporated into cloudy . when we used the steeper uv background shape ( e.g. madau , haardt , & rees 1999 ; shull et al .
1999 ) , the observations are still consistent with the cloudy model for a lower metallicity of [ m / h ] = @xmath161 and a larger ionisation parameter log @xmath162 .
we can also place constraints on physical quantities such as the absorber size ( the length of the path through the absorbing region ) and the thermal gas pressure ( but see the caveats discussed in 5 of tripp et al .
figure [ fig : absorbersize ] shows confidence interval contours for the absorber size @xmath163 and thermal pressure @xmath164 implied by the photoionisation model .
the best fit implies that @xmath165 3.5 kpc .
if spherical , the baryonic mass of this cloud would be @xmath166 .
however , we can see from figure [ fig : absorbersize ] that the model allows a large range for @xmath163 at the 2@xmath146 level .
the low thermal pressure implied is also notable .
when the steeper uv background shape is used for the cloudy model , the predicted pressure is lower by a factor 1.5 and the absorber size increases to @xmath1678 kpc.the range of pressures within the contours in figure [ fig : absorbersize ] is several orders of magnitude lower than the gas pressure measured in the disk of the milky way ( see jenkins & tripp 2001 ) and is even lower than pressures measured in hvcs in the milky way halo ( e.g. wakker , oosterloo , & putman 2002 ; fox et al .
. however , sembach et al .
( 1995 , 1999 ) found similar pressure for civ hvcs surrounding the milky - way with somewhat lower metallicity .
moreover , pressures this low are predicted in some theoretical models of galactic halos ( wolfire et al .
finally , the derived pressure depends on the intensity used to normalize the ionising flux field ( see tripp et al . 2005 ) and both the particle density and the pressure could be higher if the radiation field is brighter than we assumed . as discussed in
[ sec : environment ] , the absorption lines detected at @xmath13 = 0.07573 occur in a large - scale structure connected to a559 and a564 .
only h@xmath4roman1 ly@xmath16 , ly@xmath39 and the c@xmath4roman4 @xmath681548.20,1550.78 doublet are clearly detected at this redshift ; the profiles of these absorption lines are shown in figure [ fig : syst0076 ] .
the weakness of ly@xmath39 and the absence of ly@xmath79 suggest that the h@xmath4roman1 lines are not badly affected by unresolved saturation , and profile fitting measurements are robust .
likewise , comparison of the c@xmath4roman4 apparent column density profiles shows no evidence of unresolved saturation .
we have fitted these lines with only one component .
the results of the fit are listed in table [ tab : cldnlist076 ] .
the width of the h@xmath4roman1 line ( @xmath169 ) indicates a temperature for the gas lower than @xmath170 k , which again favors a photoionisation process .
no o@xmath4roman6 is evident at this redshift , but several strong unrelated lines of various elements are found close to the expected wavelength of the o@xmath4roman6 doublet , and these lines might mask weak o@xmath4roman6 absorption . despite the fact that c@xmath4roman4 is the only metal detected in this system , we can nevertheless place an interesting lower limit on the absorber metallicity .
the carbon abundance can be expressed as [ c / h]= log[/ ] + log[/ ] - log ( c / h)@xmath171 , where and are the ion fractions of h@xmath4roman1 and c@xmath4roman4 , respectively combination .
the maximum is not evident in figure [ fig : cloudym ] because it occurs at a higher value of @xmath110 than the range shown . ] . with the h@xmath4roman1 column from the ly@xmath16+ly@xmath39 fit ( table [ tab : cldnlist076 ] ) , and again assuming that the gas is photoionised by the uv background from qsos ( haardt & madau 1996 ) , we find that log[/]@xmath172 , and therefore @xmath173>-0.6 $ ] in the absorber .
once again , this metallicity lower limit is relatively high despite the fact that no luminous galaxies have been found near the sight line ( the closest galaxy is nw3 at @xmath174 kpc , see table [ tab : spec_red ] ) .
@l@c@c@c@c@c@ & & & & & + & & & & & h i & 1215.670 & 309@xmath8410 & 14.18@xmath840.04 & 24.6@xmath841.0 & 14.06@xmath840.03 + & 1025.722 & 108@xmath8421 & & & 14.28@xmath840.08 + o vi & 1037.617 & 0@xmath8419 & & & @xmath175 +
c iv & 1548.204 & 51@xmath84 7 & 13.18@xmath840.04 & 13.1@xmath841.5 & 13.24@xmath840.04 + & 1550.781 & 27@xmath84 8 & & & 12.09@xmath840.22 + si iii & 1206.500 & 0@xmath8410 & & & @xmath176 + si iv & 1393.760 & 17@xmath8414 & & & @xmath124 + n v & 1238.821 & 25@xmath84 9 & & & @xmath177 in [ sec : environment ] we noted that the clusters a554 , a562 , and a565 indicate that a large - scale filament / supercluster is foreground to 0624 . our galaxy redshift survey has also revealed four galaxies close to 0624 at the redshift of the abell 554/562/565 structure ( see figure [ fig : field ] and table [ tab : spec_red ] ) , which suggests that the large - scale filament extends across the 0624 field .
however , we only find a couple of weak ly@xmath16 lines near the redshift of this structure at redshifts substantially offset from those of the galaxies and abell clusters .
it is possible that the ly@xmath16 lines are weak / absent because the gas in the filament is so hot that the h@xmath4roman1 ion fraction makes the ly@xmath16 line undetectable , but we also note that the nearest galaxies are farther from the sight line in this case ( @xmath179 mpc ) than in the structures at @xmath180 and discussed above , so it is also possible that the sight line does not penetrate the part of the dark matter filament where the potential is deep enough to accumulate gas and galaxies ( see discussion in bowen et al .
how do the properties of the ly@xmath16 absorbers at , , and compare to the other ly@xmath16 lines in the 0624 spectrum ( and in other sight lines ) ?
we have found that the systems at and arise in photoionised cool gas ; is this true of the majority of the ly@xmath16 lines in the spectrum ?
in particular , do we find ly@xmath16 lines that arise in hot gas ?
richter et al .
( 2004 , 2005 ) and sembach et al .
( 2004 ) have recently identified a population of broad ly@xmath16 lines ( blas ) with @xmath181 40 km s@xmath28 in the spectra of several low@xmath0 qsos ( pg0953 + 415 , pg1116 + 215 , pg1259 + 593 , and h1821 + 643 ) .
williger et al .
( 2005 ) similarly find a substantial number of blas in the spectrum of pks0405 - 123 .
bowen et al . ( 2002 ) have also identified some bla candidates using somewhat lower resolution data .
if these lines are mainly broadened by thermal motions , then they trace the warm - hot igm , and moreover , they in this case would contain a substantial portion of the baryons in the universe at the present epoch ( see richter et al . 2004 , 2005 ;
sembach et al .
2004 ) . based on simulations , richter et al .
( 2005 ) and williger et al .
( 2005 ) find that some of the blas are not predominantly thermally broadened but instead are due to line blends that are difficult to recognize at the s / n afforded by typical stis echelle spectra .
however , richter et al . ( 2005 ) conclude that approximately 50 per cent of the blas are mainly thermally broadened , and some high s / n examples in the above papers are remarkably smooth and broad and appear to entirely consistent with a single broad gaussian ( see , e.g. , figures 4 and 5 in richter et al .
2005 ) . in this paper ,
in addition to using a different sight line , we have employed methods that are independent from ( e.g. , using different software ) the techniques used in the papers above for continuum normalization , line detection , and profile fitting .
consequently , we have an opportunity to independently check the bla findings reported in these papers . for the 0624 sight line ,
we find that the mean @xmath77value for all ly@xmath16 lines is @xmath182 = 37 km s@xmath28 , and the median @xmath183 km s@xmath28 . however , as noted in table [ tab : lyalist ] , some of the ly@xmath16 lines are significantly blended , and the line parameters are accordingly uncertain .
if we exclude these uncertain blended cases , we find @xmath184 km s@xmath28 and @xmath185 km s@xmath28 .
these ensemble @xmath77values are in reasonable agreement with the previous high - resolution ly@xmath16 studies . in figure
[ fig : larg ] we compare our measurements of the h@xmath4roman1 @xmath77values and column densities from table [ tab : lyalist ] to the measurements reported by richter et al .
( 2004 ) and sembach et al .
the solid line indicates @xmath83 vs. @xmath96(h@xmath4roman1 ) for a gaussian line with central optical depth = 0.1 .
this is effectively a detection threshold ; lines that have ( @xmath186 ) combinations to the left of this line are not likely to be detected .
the dotted line in figure [ fig : larg ] shows the minimum @xmath77value as a function of @xmath96(h@xmath4roman1 ) predicted by dav & tripp ( 2001 , see their equation 5 ) from the hydrodynamic cosmological simulations of dav et al .
this predicted lower envelope appears to be in reasonable agreement with the observed lower envelope for the three sight lines shown in the figure . from figure
[ fig : larg ] , we see that the ( @xmath186 ) distribution that we have obtained from the 0624 sight line appears to be generally similar to those obtained by sembach et al .
( 2004 ) and richter et al .
sembach et al . and
richter et al . did find more extremely broad ly@xmath16 lines ( @xmath181 80 km s@xmath28 ) than we have been able to positively identify in the 0624 spectrum .
this may be partly due to signal - to - noise differences the data employed by richter et al . and sembach et al .
have higher s / n because such broad and shallow lines are difficult to detect in the 0624 data . for @xmath187 km s@xmath28 ,
the different sight lines appear to be in broad agreement .
excluding lines within 5000 km s@xmath28 of the qso redshift , of the qso redshift can arise in intrinsic gas ejected by the qso , and these lines can be rather broad ( see , e.g. , yuan et al .
2002 ) , even if not part of a full - blown broad absorption line outflow . ]
the 0624 spectrum can be used to search for blas between @xmath188 and @xmath189 .
accounting for regions in which broad lines could have been masked by igm or ism lines , we obtain a blocking - corrected total redshift path @xmath190 .
with 21 ly@xmath16 lines in the sample with @xmath181 40 km s@xmath28 , we thus obtain @xmath191(bla ) = 64@xmath8416 .
this is somewhat larger than the values reported by sembach et al .
( 2004 ) and richter et al .
( 2004,2005 ) .
however , richter et al . have excluded blas that are located in complex blends on the grounds that these cases are more likely to be affected by non - thermal broadening .
if we follow the same procedure , we must reject 10 blas ( see table [ tab : lyalist ] ) ; the remaining 11 blas would then imply @xmath191(bla ) = 33@xmath8410 . using equations 1 , 5 , and 6 from sembach et al .
( 2004 ) , but adjusted for the somewhat different cosmological parameters assumed in this paper , we find that our full sample implies that the bla baryonic content is @xmath192(bla ) = 0.017 @xmath7 ( in the usual notation , i.e. , @xmath193 ) .
this high value probably substantially overestimates the bla baryonic content , largely because of false blas that arise from blends .
if we exclude blas that are located in complex blends , this drops to @xmath192(bla ) = 0.0036 @xmath7 , which is similar to values obtained by richter et al . and
sembach et al .
the uncertainties in @xmath192(bla ) due to , e.g. , lines that are broad due to blends or other non - thermal broadening mechanisms , are large and currently difficult to assess ( see discussion in richter et al .
however , these initial calculations suggest that blas may harbor an important quantity of baryons . with future uv spectrographs
, it would be valuable to obtain high - resolution spectra with substantially better s / n in order to accurately assess the baryonic content of blas as part of the general census of ordinary matter in the nearby universe .
we have acquired detailed information about the abundances , physical conditions , and galaxy proximity of absorption systems in the direction of 0624 .
what are the implications of these measurements for broader questions of galaxy evolution and cosmology ?
the processes that add gas to galaxies ( e.g. accretion ) and remove gas from galaxies ( e.g. , winds , dynamical stripping ) can have profound effects on galaxy evolution , and the `` feedback '' of matter and energy from galaxies into the igm is now believed to play an important role in shaping structures that subsequently grow out of the igm ( voit g. m. , 2005 ) .
the quantity and implications of the @xmath194 k whim gas is a topic of particular interest currently .
the galaxies and absorption systems in the direction of 0624 , particularly the galaxy group and ly@xmath16 complex at @xmath75 = , have some interesting , and perhaps surprising , implications regarding these questions , which we now discuss .
rosat observations of diffuse x - ray emission have established that galaxy groups that are dominated by early - type galaxies often contain diffuse , hot intragroup gas ( mulchaey 2000 , and references therein ) . based on the observed relation between intragroup gas temperature and velocity dispersion @xmath146 in x - ray bright groups ( @xmath195 ) and the fact that spiral - rich groups have lower velocity dispersions than elliptical - rich groups , mulchaey et al .
( 1996 ) have hypothesized that spiral - rich groups might have somewhat cooler intragroup media that could give rise to qso absorption lines at whim temperatures ( e.g. , o@xmath4roman6 )
. however , the galaxy group at @xmath75 = appears to have properties that are not consistent with the elliptical - rich groups detected with rosat nor with the idea that spiral - rich groups contain warm - hot intragroup gas .
it is unclear if the galaxy group at @xmath75 = is a spiral - rich group .
figure [ fig : galpics ] shows @xmath45 images from the mosa data of the 10 galaxies that we have found in this group .
most of the galaxies in the group show evidence of disks and bulges ( both in the direct images and in radial brightness profiles ) .
we find from visual inspection that 4 - 5 of the 10 galaxies have indications of spiral structure ( sw3 , se1 , se8 , se6 , and possibly se4 ) .
however , the remaining galaxies could be early - type s0 galaxies , and therefore the early - type fraction might be comparable to groups that show diffuse x - ray emission ( see , e.g , figure 7 in zabludoff & mulchaey 1998 ) .
the ne3 , se13 , and se5 galaxies , which morphologically appear to be early - type galaxies , have colours and magnitudes consistent with the `` red sequence '' colour - magnitude relation observed in clusters ( e.g. , bower , lucey , & ellis 1992 ; mcintosh et al .
2005 ) ; these galaxies are likely s0s ( the other 7 galaxies have blue colours characteristic of late types ) .
the velocity dispersion of the group at @xmath75 = , albeit uncertain , is more comparable to those of elliptical - dominated groups than spiral - rich groups ( mulchaey et al .
1996 ; zabludoff & mulchaey 1998 ) .
regardless of whether the group is elliptical- or spiral - rich , it is surprising that we find a large number of cool , photoionised clouds in the intragroup medium ( [ ss : z064 ] ) .
in the hot intragroup medium of an elliptical - rich group , h@xmath4roman1 lines should be extremely broad and weak , but instead we find strong , narrow lines ( see figure [ fig : hi00635 ] ) . even in the cooler gas
predicted to be found in late - type dominated groups , the h@xmath4roman1 lines should be broader .
we could entertain models of cooling intragroup gas , but in such models o@xmath4roman6 is expected to be stronger .
likewise , if the intragroup gas is a multiphase medium with cooler clouds ( which cause the h@xmath4roman1 absorption lines ) embedded in a hotter phase , then we might expect to detect o@xmath4roman6 from the interface between the phases ( fox et al .
2005 ) , unless conduction is somehow suppressed .
the lack of evidence of hot gas leads us to question whether this group is a bound , virialized system .
an alternative possibility is that our sight line passes along the long axis of a large - scale filamentary structure in the cosmic web . in this case
, the projection of the galaxies and ly@xmath16 clouds along the sight line could give a false impression of a group in which hot gas would be expected .
however , in cosmological simulations of large - scale filaments , whim gas is expected to be widespread at the present epoch , even in modest - overdensity regions ( see , e.g. , figure 4 in cen & ostriker 1999b ) , so it is interesting that we find a substantial number of cool clouds at @xmath12 , somewhat contrary to theoretical expectations . as noted above
, our data do not preclude the presence of whim gas at @xmath12 , but we find no clear evidence of it .
other sight lines show similar clusters of ly@xmath16 lines , e.g. , the ly@xmath16 complex at @xmath196 0.057 toward pks2155 - 304 ( shull et al .
1998 ; shull , tumlinson , & giroux 2003 ) or the ly@xmath16 lines at @xmath196 0.121 toward h1821 + 643 ( tripp et al .
however , unlike the 0624 ly@xmath16 complex , the pks2155 - 304 and h1821 + 643 examples both show evidence of warm - hot intragroup gas . to test whether the observations and simulations are in accord
, it would be useful to assess the frequency and physical properties of these ly@xmath16 complexes in cosmological simulations for comparison with the observations .
it is also interesting that the two systems for which we have obtained abundance constraints ( at @xmath75 = and ) both indicate relatively high metallicities , but both of these systems are at least 100 kpc away ( in projection ) from the nearest known galaxy .
this naturally raises a question : how did gas that is so far from a galaxy attain such a high metallicity ?
the gas could have been driven out of a galaxy by a galactic wind ; some wind models predict that the outflowing material will have a high metallicity ( mac low & ferrara 1999 ) , the difficulty with this interpretation is that winds from nearby galaxies are usually observed to contain substantial amounts of hot gas ( e.g. , strickland et al .
2004 ) , which seems to be inconsistent with the absorption line properties as we have discussed .
a more likely explanation is that the high - metallicity gas we have detected in absorption has been tidally stripped out of one of the nearby galaxies .
there are indications that tidal stripping could be a more gentle process for removing gas from galaxies , and a tidally stripped origin can therefore more easily accommodate the observed low - ionisation state of the gas . for example , in the direction of ngc3783 , the galactic high - velocity cloud ( hvc ) at @xmath197 247 is now recognized to be tidally stripped debris from the smc . while this tidally stripped material shows a wide array of low - ionisation absorption lines , it has little or no associated high - ion absorption ( lu et al .
1994 ; sembach et al .
moreover , the tidally - stripped hvc contains molecular hydrogen , which sembach et al .
argue formed in the smc and survived the rigors of tidal stripping ( as opposed to forming in situ in the stream ) .
both the absence of high ions and the survival of h@xmath80 suggest that the stripping process did not substantially ionise and heat this hvc .
several galaxies are close enough to the 0624 sight line to be plausible sources of the gas in a tidal stripping scenario .
one of the nearby galaxies , se1 , has a distorted spiral morphology .
this galaxy is a plausible source of tidally stripped matter .
we have presented a study of absorption - line systems in the direction of 0624 using a combination of high - resolution uv spectra obtained with _ hst_/stis and plus ground - based imaging and spectroscopy of galaxies within @xmath4430 of the sight line .
in addition to presented the basic measurements and ancillary information , we have reported the following findings : \1 .
there are several abell galaxy clusters in the foreground of 0624 , including two clusters at @xmath12 0.077 ( a559 and a564 ) and three at @xmath12 0.110 ( a554 , a562 , and a565 ) .
these clusters trace large - scale dark matter structures , i.e. , superclusters or filaments of the `` cosmic web '' .
our galaxy redshift survey has revealed galaxies at these supercluster redshifts in the immediate vicinity of the 0624 sight line , and therefore our qso spectra provide an opportunity to study the gas in large - scale intergalactic filaments .
the most prominent group of galaxies found in our galaxy redshift survey is at @xmath12 and is not associated with an abell cluster with a spectroscopic redshift from the literature .
however , a557 , for which no spectroscopic redshift has been reported , is at least partly due to the galaxy group at @xmath12 .
the two strongest ly@xmath16 absorption systems at @xmath198 arise in galaxy groups at @xmath199 and .
the ly@xmath16 absorption at is particularly dramatic : at this redshift , we find 13 ly@xmath16 lines spread over a velocity range of 1000 km s@xmath28 with a line - of - sight velocity dispersion of 265 km s@xmath28 .
the second - strongest system at is associated with the abell 559/564 large - scale structure , and this indicates that a filament containing gas and galaxies feeds into the abell 559/564 supercluster .
analysis of the ly@xmath16 absorption - line complex at @xmath200 provides strong evidence that the gas is photoionised and relatively cool ; we find no compelling evidence of warm - hot gas in this large - scale filament .
we detect si@xmath4roman3 , si@xmath4roman4 , and c@xmath4roman4 in the strongest component in this ly@xmath16 complex , and photoionisation models indicate that the gas metallicity is high , [ m / h ] = @xmath201 .
this is somewhat surprising because we do not find any luminous galaxies close to the sight line ; the closest galaxy is at a projected distance @xmath202 kpc .
the ly@xmath16 system at is only detected in the c@xmath4roman4 doublet , but nevertheless we find a similar result : the lower limit on the metallicity is relative |