label
stringclasses
3 values
claim
stringlengths
1
717
evidence
stringlengths
1
4.01k
page
stringlengths
2
88
revision_type
stringclasses
2 values
split
stringclasses
3 values
__index_level_0__
int64
0
434k
user_input
stringlengths
80
4.09k
messages
listlengths
2
2
score
float64
-0.02
0.2
REFUTES
Marnie is exclusively an Italian film .
Marnie is a 1964 American psychological thriller film directed by Alfred Hitchcock .
Marnie -LRB-film-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,040
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Marnie -LRB-film-RRB- Evidence: Marnie is a 1964 American psychological thriller film directed by Alfred Hitchcock .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Marnie -LRB-film-RRB-\nEvidence: Marnie is a 1964 American psychological thriller film directed by Alfred Hitchcock .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Marnie is exclusively an Italian film .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.051025
SUPPORTS
Marnie is an American film .
Marnie is a 1964 American psychological thriller film directed by Alfred Hitchcock .
Marnie -LRB-film-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,041
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Marnie -LRB-film-RRB- Evidence: Marnie is a 1964 American psychological thriller film directed by Alfred Hitchcock .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Marnie -LRB-film-RRB-\nEvidence: Marnie is a 1964 American psychological thriller film directed by Alfred Hitchcock .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Marnie is an American film .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.067383
REFUTES
Marnie is an American film .
Marnie is a 1964 Italian psychological thriller film directed by Alfred Hitchcock .
Marnie -LRB-film-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,042
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Marnie -LRB-film-RRB- Evidence: Marnie is a 1964 Italian psychological thriller film directed by Alfred Hitchcock .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Marnie -LRB-film-RRB-\nEvidence: Marnie is a 1964 Italian psychological thriller film directed by Alfred Hitchcock .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Marnie is an American film .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.041504
SUPPORTS
Martin Van Buren was Secretary of State .
A member of the Democratic Party , he served in a number of other senior roles , including eighth Vice President -LRB- 1833 -- 37 -RRB- and tenth Secretary of State -LRB- 1829 -- 31 -RRB- , both under Andrew Jackson .
Martin Van Buren
synthetic
valid
433,043
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Martin Van Buren Evidence: A member of the Democratic Party , he served in a number of other senior roles , including eighth Vice President -LRB- 1833 -- 37 -RRB- and tenth Secretary of State -LRB- 1829 -- 31 -RRB- , both under Andrew Jackson .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Martin Van Buren\nEvidence: A member of the Democratic Party , he served in a number of other senior roles , including eighth Vice President -LRB- 1833 -- 37 -RRB- and tenth Secretary of State -LRB- 1829 -- 31 -RRB- , both under Andrew Jackson .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Martin Van Buren was Secretary of State .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.077637
REFUTES
Martin Van Buren was Secretary of State .
A member of the Democratic Party , he served in a number of other senior roles , including 8th Vice President and Secretary of Defence , but missed being Secretary of State .
Martin Van Buren
synthetic
valid
433,044
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Martin Van Buren Evidence: A member of the Democratic Party , he served in a number of other senior roles , including 8th Vice President and Secretary of Defence , but missed being Secretary of State .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Martin Van Buren\nEvidence: A member of the Democratic Party , he served in a number of other senior roles , including 8th Vice President and Secretary of Defence , but missed being Secretary of State .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Martin Van Buren was Secretary of State .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.051514
SUPPORTS
Martin Van Buren was Secretary of Defence .
A member of the Democratic Party , he served in a number of other senior roles , including 8th Vice President and Secretary of Defence , but missed being Secretary of State .
Martin Van Buren
synthetic
valid
433,045
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Martin Van Buren Evidence: A member of the Democratic Party , he served in a number of other senior roles , including 8th Vice President and Secretary of Defence , but missed being Secretary of State .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Martin Van Buren\nEvidence: A member of the Democratic Party , he served in a number of other senior roles , including 8th Vice President and Secretary of Defence , but missed being Secretary of State .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Martin Van Buren was Secretary of Defence .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.070801
REFUTES
Martin Van Buren was Secretary of Defence .
A member of the Democratic Party , he served in a number of other senior roles , including eighth Vice President -LRB- 1833 -- 37 -RRB- and tenth Secretary of State -LRB- 1829 -- 31 -RRB- , both under Andrew Jackson .
Martin Van Buren
synthetic
valid
433,046
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Martin Van Buren Evidence: A member of the Democratic Party , he served in a number of other senior roles , including eighth Vice President -LRB- 1833 -- 37 -RRB- and tenth Secretary of State -LRB- 1829 -- 31 -RRB- , both under Andrew Jackson .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Martin Van Buren\nEvidence: A member of the Democratic Party , he served in a number of other senior roles , including eighth Vice President -LRB- 1833 -- 37 -RRB- and tenth Secretary of State -LRB- 1829 -- 31 -RRB- , both under Andrew Jackson .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Martin Van Buren was Secretary of Defence .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.036133
SUPPORTS
Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite retains the series ' traditional character assists .
The traditional character assists of Marvel vs. Capcom have been retained ; and , the game incorporates a tag-based combo system , which allows players to form continuous combos between their two characters .
Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite
synthetic
valid
433,047
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite Evidence: The traditional character assists of Marvel vs. Capcom have been retained ; and , the game incorporates a tag-based combo system , which allows players to form continuous combos between their two characters .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite\nEvidence: The traditional character assists of Marvel vs. Capcom have been retained ; and , the game incorporates a tag-based combo system , which allows players to form continuous combos between their two characters .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite retains the series ' traditional character assists .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.103027
REFUTES
Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite retains the series ' traditional character assists .
The series ' traditional character assists have been removed ; instead , the game incorporates a tag-based combo system , which allows players to form continuous combos between their two characters .
Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite
synthetic
valid
433,048
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite Evidence: The series ' traditional character assists have been removed ; instead , the game incorporates a tag-based combo system , which allows players to form continuous combos between their two characters .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite\nEvidence: The series ' traditional character assists have been removed ; instead , the game incorporates a tag-based combo system , which allows players to form continuous combos between their two characters .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite retains the series ' traditional character assists .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.067383
SUPPORTS
The developers of the video game `` Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite '' have removed the series ' traditional character assists .
The series ' traditional character assists have been removed ; instead , the game incorporates a tag-based combo system , which allows players to form continuous combos between their two characters .
Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite
synthetic
valid
433,049
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite Evidence: The series ' traditional character assists have been removed ; instead , the game incorporates a tag-based combo system , which allows players to form continuous combos between their two characters .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite\nEvidence: The series ' traditional character assists have been removed ; instead , the game incorporates a tag-based combo system , which allows players to form continuous combos between their two characters .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "The developers of the video game `` Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite '' have removed the series ' traditional character assists .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.111816
REFUTES
The developers of the video game `` Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite '' have removed the series ' traditional character assists .
The traditional character assists of Marvel vs. Capcom have been retained ; and , the game incorporates a tag-based combo system , which allows players to form continuous combos between their two characters .
Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite
synthetic
valid
433,050
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite Evidence: The traditional character assists of Marvel vs. Capcom have been retained ; and , the game incorporates a tag-based combo system , which allows players to form continuous combos between their two characters .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite\nEvidence: The traditional character assists of Marvel vs. Capcom have been retained ; and , the game incorporates a tag-based combo system , which allows players to form continuous combos between their two characters .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "The developers of the video game `` Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite '' have removed the series ' traditional character assists .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.060791
SUPPORTS
Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite is a standalone game .
Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite is a standalone game , designed to be more accessible than previous Marvel vs. Capcom games .
Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite
synthetic
valid
433,051
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite Evidence: Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite is a standalone game , designed to be more accessible than previous Marvel vs. Capcom games .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite\nEvidence: Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite is a standalone game , designed to be more accessible than previous Marvel vs. Capcom games .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite is a standalone game .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.083008
REFUTES
Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite is a standalone game .
Infinite was designed to be more accessible than previous Marvel vs. Capcom games , resulting in departures from some series ' mainstays , such as assists .
Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite
synthetic
valid
433,052
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite Evidence: Infinite was designed to be more accessible than previous Marvel vs. Capcom games , resulting in departures from some series ' mainstays , such as assists .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite\nEvidence: Infinite was designed to be more accessible than previous Marvel vs. Capcom games , resulting in departures from some series ' mainstays , such as assists .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite is a standalone game .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.060059
SUPPORTS
Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite ( game ) is based on some series .
Infinite was designed to be more accessible than previous Marvel vs. Capcom games , resulting in departures from some series ' mainstays , such as assists .
Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite
synthetic
valid
433,053
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite Evidence: Infinite was designed to be more accessible than previous Marvel vs. Capcom games , resulting in departures from some series ' mainstays , such as assists .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite\nEvidence: Infinite was designed to be more accessible than previous Marvel vs. Capcom games , resulting in departures from some series ' mainstays , such as assists .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite ( game ) is based on some series .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.044189
REFUTES
Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite ( game ) is based on some series .
Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite is a standalone game , designed to be more accessible than previous Marvel vs. Capcom games .
Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite
synthetic
valid
433,054
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite Evidence: Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite is a standalone game , designed to be more accessible than previous Marvel vs. Capcom games .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Marvel vs. Capcom-COLON- Infinite\nEvidence: Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite is a standalone game , designed to be more accessible than previous Marvel vs. Capcom games .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Marvel vs. Capcom : Infinite ( game ) is based on some series .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.044189
SUPPORTS
Mary of Teck was queen mother .
After George 's death in 1936 , she became queen mother when her eldest son , Edward , ascended the throne , but to her dismay , he abdicated later the same year in order to marry twice-divorced American socialite Wallis Simpson .
Mary of Teck
synthetic
valid
433,055
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mary of Teck Evidence: After George 's death in 1936 , she became queen mother when her eldest son , Edward , ascended the throne , but to her dismay , he abdicated later the same year in order to marry twice-divorced American socialite Wallis Simpson .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mary of Teck\nEvidence: After George 's death in 1936 , she became queen mother when her eldest son , Edward , ascended the throne , but to her dismay , he abdicated later the same year in order to marry twice-divorced American socialite Wallis Simpson .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mary of Teck was queen mother .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.096191
REFUTES
Mary of Teck was queen mother .
After George 's death in 1936 Mary of Teck became England 's Prime Minister .
Mary of Teck
synthetic
valid
433,056
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mary of Teck Evidence: After George 's death in 1936 Mary of Teck became England 's Prime Minister .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mary of Teck\nEvidence: After George 's death in 1936 Mary of Teck became England 's Prime Minister .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mary of Teck was queen mother .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.031006
SUPPORTS
Mary of Teck was Prime Minister .
After George 's death in 1936 Mary of Teck became England 's Prime Minister .
Mary of Teck
synthetic
valid
433,057
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mary of Teck Evidence: After George 's death in 1936 Mary of Teck became England 's Prime Minister .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mary of Teck\nEvidence: After George 's death in 1936 Mary of Teck became England 's Prime Minister .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mary of Teck was Prime Minister .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.008545
REFUTES
Mary of Teck was Prime Minister .
After George 's death in 1936 , she became queen mother when her eldest son , Edward , ascended the throne , but to her dismay , he abdicated later the same year in order to marry twice-divorced American socialite Wallis Simpson .
Mary of Teck
synthetic
valid
433,058
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mary of Teck Evidence: After George 's death in 1936 , she became queen mother when her eldest son , Edward , ascended the throne , but to her dismay , he abdicated later the same year in order to marry twice-divorced American socialite Wallis Simpson .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mary of Teck\nEvidence: After George 's death in 1936 , she became queen mother when her eldest son , Edward , ascended the throne , but to her dismay , he abdicated later the same year in order to marry twice-divorced American socialite Wallis Simpson .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mary of Teck was Prime Minister .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.034668
SUPPORTS
Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen are also known as the Olsen twins .
Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen -LRB- born June 13 , 1986 -RRB- , also known as the Olsen twins collectively , are American fashion designers and former child actresses .
Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen
synthetic
valid
433,059
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen Evidence: Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen -LRB- born June 13 , 1986 -RRB- , also known as the Olsen twins collectively , are American fashion designers and former child actresses .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen\nEvidence: Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen -LRB- born June 13 , 1986 -RRB- , also known as the Olsen twins collectively , are American fashion designers and former child actresses .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen are also known as the Olsen twins .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.080566
REFUTES
Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen are also known as the Olsen twins .
Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen , also known as the Golden twins collectively , are American fashion designers and former child actresses .
Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen
synthetic
valid
433,060
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen Evidence: Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen , also known as the Golden twins collectively , are American fashion designers and former child actresses .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen\nEvidence: Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen , also known as the Golden twins collectively , are American fashion designers and former child actresses .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen are also known as the Olsen twins .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.071289
SUPPORTS
Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen are also known as the Golden twins .
Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen , also known as the Golden twins collectively , are American fashion designers and former child actresses .
Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen
synthetic
valid
433,061
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen Evidence: Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen , also known as the Golden twins collectively , are American fashion designers and former child actresses .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen\nEvidence: Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen , also known as the Golden twins collectively , are American fashion designers and former child actresses .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen are also known as the Golden twins .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.07666
REFUTES
Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen are also known as the Golden twins .
Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen -LRB- born June 13 , 1986 -RRB- , also known as the Olsen twins collectively , are American fashion designers and former child actresses .
Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen
synthetic
valid
433,062
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen Evidence: Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen -LRB- born June 13 , 1986 -RRB- , also known as the Olsen twins collectively , are American fashion designers and former child actresses .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen\nEvidence: Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen -LRB- born June 13 , 1986 -RRB- , also known as the Olsen twins collectively , are American fashion designers and former child actresses .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mary-Kate Olsen and Ashley Olsen are also known as the Golden twins .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.043945
SUPPORTS
Matteo Renzi served as Prime Minister of Italy for three years .
Matteo Renzi - born 11 January 1975 - is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until February 2017 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,063
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Matteo Renzi - born 11 January 1975 - is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until February 2017 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Matteo Renzi - born 11 January 1975 - is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until February 2017 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi served as Prime Minister of Italy for three years .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.116211
REFUTES
Matteo Renzi served as Prime Minister of Italy for three years .
Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,064
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi served as Prime Minister of Italy for three years .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.11084
SUPPORTS
Matteo Renzi served as Prime Minister of Italy for less than three years .
Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,065
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi served as Prime Minister of Italy for less than three years .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.120117
REFUTES
Matteo Renzi served as Prime Minister of Italy for less than three years .
Matteo Renzi - born 11 January 1975 - is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until February 2017 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,066
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Matteo Renzi - born 11 January 1975 - is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until February 2017 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Matteo Renzi - born 11 January 1975 - is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until February 2017 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi served as Prime Minister of Italy for less than three years .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.117676
SUPPORTS
Matteo Renzi has only ever been a plumber .
Renzi served as Head Plumber of the Province of Florence from 2004 to 2009 and as Head Plumber of Florence from 2009 to 2014 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,067
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Renzi served as Head Plumber of the Province of Florence from 2004 to 2009 and as Head Plumber of Florence from 2009 to 2014 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Renzi served as Head Plumber of the Province of Florence from 2004 to 2009 and as Head Plumber of Florence from 2009 to 2014 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi has only ever been a plumber .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.021362
REFUTES
Matteo Renzi has only ever been a plumber .
Renzi served as President of the Province of Florence from 2004 to 2009 and as Mayor of Florence from 2009 to 2014 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,068
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Renzi served as President of the Province of Florence from 2004 to 2009 and as Mayor of Florence from 2009 to 2014 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Renzi served as President of the Province of Florence from 2004 to 2009 and as Mayor of Florence from 2009 to 2014 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi has only ever been a plumber .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.033936
SUPPORTS
Matteo Renzi has been a president and a mayor .
Renzi served as President of the Province of Florence from 2004 to 2009 and as Mayor of Florence from 2009 to 2014 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,069
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Renzi served as President of the Province of Florence from 2004 to 2009 and as Mayor of Florence from 2009 to 2014 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Renzi served as President of the Province of Florence from 2004 to 2009 and as Mayor of Florence from 2009 to 2014 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi has been a president and a mayor .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.086426
REFUTES
Matteo Renzi has been a president and a mayor .
Renzi served as Head Plumber of the Province of Florence from 2004 to 2009 and as Head Plumber of Florence from 2009 to 2014 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,070
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Renzi served as Head Plumber of the Province of Florence from 2004 to 2009 and as Head Plumber of Florence from 2009 to 2014 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Renzi served as Head Plumber of the Province of Florence from 2004 to 2009 and as Head Plumber of Florence from 2009 to 2014 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi has been a president and a mayor .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.0271
SUPPORTS
Matteo Renzi has only ever been a plumber .
Matteo Renzi ( born January 11 , 1975 ) is an Italian celebrity plumber who worked for the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,071
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Matteo Renzi ( born January 11 , 1975 ) is an Italian celebrity plumber who worked for the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Matteo Renzi ( born January 11 , 1975 ) is an Italian celebrity plumber who worked for the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi has only ever been a plumber .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.038086
REFUTES
Matteo Renzi has only ever been a plumber .
Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,072
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi has only ever been a plumber .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.04248
REFUTES
Matteo Renzi is a politician .
Matteo Renzi ( born January 11 , 1975 ) is an Italian celebrity plumber who worked for the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,074
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Matteo Renzi ( born January 11 , 1975 ) is an Italian celebrity plumber who worked for the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Matteo Renzi ( born January 11 , 1975 ) is an Italian celebrity plumber who worked for the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi is a politician .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.058594
SUPPORTS
Matteo Renzi was once the Prime Minister of Italy .
Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,075
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi was once the Prime Minister of Italy .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.118164
REFUTES
Matteo Renzi was once the Prime Minister of Italy .
Matteo Renzi is a British politician who served as the Prime Minister of England from February 2014 until December 2016 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,076
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Matteo Renzi is a British politician who served as the Prime Minister of England from February 2014 until December 2016 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Matteo Renzi is a British politician who served as the Prime Minister of England from February 2014 until December 2016 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi was once the Prime Minister of Italy .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.045898
SUPPORTS
Matteo Renzi was the Prime Minister of England .
Matteo Renzi is a British politician who served as the Prime Minister of England from February 2014 until December 2016 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,077
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Matteo Renzi is a British politician who served as the Prime Minister of England from February 2014 until December 2016 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Matteo Renzi is a British politician who served as the Prime Minister of England from February 2014 until December 2016 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi was the Prime Minister of England .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.016235
REFUTES
Matteo Renzi was the Prime Minister of England .
Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
Matteo Renzi
synthetic
valid
433,078
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Matteo Renzi Evidence: Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Matteo Renzi\nEvidence: Matteo Renzi -LRB- -LSB- matˈtɛːo ˈrɛntsi -RSB- ; born 11 January 1975 -RRB- is an Italian politician who served as the Prime Minister of Italy from February 2014 until December 2016 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Matteo Renzi was the Prime Minister of England .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.037842
SUPPORTS
Mel B released a song on Virgin Records .
Brown began her solo career when she released `` I Want You Back `` with Missy Elliott on Virgin Records .
Mel B
synthetic
valid
433,079
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mel B Evidence: Brown began her solo career when she released `` I Want You Back `` with Missy Elliott on Virgin Records .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mel B\nEvidence: Brown began her solo career when she released `` I Want You Back `` with Missy Elliott on Virgin Records .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mel B released a song on Virgin Records .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.031494
REFUTES
Mel B released a song on Virgin Records .
Mel B began her solo career when she released `` I Want You Back '' with Missy Elliott on Sony Music .
Mel B
synthetic
valid
433,080
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mel B Evidence: Mel B began her solo career when she released `` I Want You Back '' with Missy Elliott on Sony Music .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mel B\nEvidence: Mel B began her solo career when she released `` I Want You Back '' with Missy Elliott on Sony Music .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mel B released a song on Virgin Records .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.006897
SUPPORTS
Mel B ( singer ) released a song on Sony Music .
Mel B began her solo career when she released `` I Want You Back '' with Missy Elliott on Sony Music .
Mel B
synthetic
valid
433,081
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mel B Evidence: Mel B began her solo career when she released `` I Want You Back '' with Missy Elliott on Sony Music .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mel B\nEvidence: Mel B began her solo career when she released `` I Want You Back '' with Missy Elliott on Sony Music .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mel B ( singer ) released a song on Sony Music .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.036865
REFUTES
Mel B ( singer ) released a song on Sony Music .
Brown began her solo career when she released `` I Want You Back `` with Missy Elliott on Virgin Records .
Mel B
synthetic
valid
433,082
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mel B Evidence: Brown began her solo career when she released `` I Want You Back `` with Missy Elliott on Virgin Records .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mel B\nEvidence: Brown began her solo career when she released `` I Want You Back `` with Missy Elliott on Virgin Records .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mel B ( singer ) released a song on Sony Music .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.013672
SUPPORTS
Men in Black II is a 2007 film .
Men in Black II , stylized as MIIB , is a 2007 American science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub , and Rip Torn .
Men in Black II
synthetic
valid
433,083
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Men in Black II Evidence: Men in Black II , stylized as MIIB , is a 2007 American science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub , and Rip Torn .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Men in Black II\nEvidence: Men in Black II , stylized as MIIB , is a 2007 American science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub , and Rip Torn .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Men in Black II is a 2007 film .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.078613
REFUTES
Men in Black II is a 2007 film .
Men in Black II -LRB- stylized as MIIB -RRB- is a 2002 American science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub and Rip Torn .
Men in Black II
synthetic
valid
433,084
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Men in Black II Evidence: Men in Black II -LRB- stylized as MIIB -RRB- is a 2002 American science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub and Rip Torn .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Men in Black II\nEvidence: Men in Black II -LRB- stylized as MIIB -RRB- is a 2002 American science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub and Rip Torn .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Men in Black II is a 2007 film .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.04126
REFUTES
Men in Black II is a 2002 film .
Men in Black II , stylized as MIIB , is a 2007 American science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub , and Rip Torn .
Men in Black II
synthetic
valid
433,086
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Men in Black II Evidence: Men in Black II , stylized as MIIB , is a 2007 American science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub , and Rip Torn .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Men in Black II\nEvidence: Men in Black II , stylized as MIIB , is a 2007 American science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub , and Rip Torn .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Men in Black II is a 2002 film .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.05835
SUPPORTS
Men in Black II is a Korean film .
Men in Black II , stylized as MIIB , is a 2002 Korean science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub , and Rip Torn .
Men in Black II
synthetic
valid
433,087
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Men in Black II Evidence: Men in Black II , stylized as MIIB , is a 2002 Korean science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub , and Rip Torn .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Men in Black II\nEvidence: Men in Black II , stylized as MIIB , is a 2002 Korean science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub , and Rip Torn .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Men in Black II is a Korean film .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.0625
REFUTES
Men in Black II is an American film .
Men in Black II , stylized as MIIB , is a 2002 Korean science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub , and Rip Torn .
Men in Black II
synthetic
valid
433,090
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Men in Black II Evidence: Men in Black II , stylized as MIIB , is a 2002 Korean science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub , and Rip Torn .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Men in Black II\nEvidence: Men in Black II , stylized as MIIB , is a 2002 Korean science fiction action comedy film starring Tommy Lee Jones , Will Smith , Lara Flynn Boyle , Johnny Knoxville , Rosario Dawson , Tony Shalhoub , and Rip Torn .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Men in Black II is an American film .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.067871
SUPPORTS
Meteora is by Linkin Park .
Linkin Park released singles from Meteora for over a year , including `` Somewhere I Belong `` , `` Faint `` , `` Numb `` , `` From the Inside `` and `` Breaking the Habit `` .
Meteora -LRB-album-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,091
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Meteora -LRB-album-RRB- Evidence: Linkin Park released singles from Meteora for over a year , including `` Somewhere I Belong `` , `` Faint `` , `` Numb `` , `` From the Inside `` and `` Breaking the Habit `` .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Meteora -LRB-album-RRB-\nEvidence: Linkin Park released singles from Meteora for over a year , including `` Somewhere I Belong `` , `` Faint `` , `` Numb `` , `` From the Inside `` and `` Breaking the Habit `` .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Meteora is by Linkin Park .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.077637
REFUTES
Meteora is by Linkin Park .
Aerosmith released singles from Meteora for over a year , including `` Somewhere I Belong '' , `` Faint `` , `` Numb '' , `` From the Inside '' and `` Breaking the Habit '' .
Meteora -LRB-album-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,092
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Meteora -LRB-album-RRB- Evidence: Aerosmith released singles from Meteora for over a year , including `` Somewhere I Belong '' , `` Faint `` , `` Numb '' , `` From the Inside '' and `` Breaking the Habit '' .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Meteora -LRB-album-RRB-\nEvidence: Aerosmith released singles from Meteora for over a year , including `` Somewhere I Belong '' , `` Faint `` , `` Numb '' , `` From the Inside '' and `` Breaking the Habit '' .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Meteora is by Linkin Park .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.080566
SUPPORTS
Meteora is an album by Aerosmith .
Aerosmith released singles from Meteora for over a year , including `` Somewhere I Belong '' , `` Faint `` , `` Numb '' , `` From the Inside '' and `` Breaking the Habit '' .
Meteora -LRB-album-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,093
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Meteora -LRB-album-RRB- Evidence: Aerosmith released singles from Meteora for over a year , including `` Somewhere I Belong '' , `` Faint `` , `` Numb '' , `` From the Inside '' and `` Breaking the Habit '' .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Meteora -LRB-album-RRB-\nEvidence: Aerosmith released singles from Meteora for over a year , including `` Somewhere I Belong '' , `` Faint `` , `` Numb '' , `` From the Inside '' and `` Breaking the Habit '' .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Meteora is an album by Aerosmith .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.028076
REFUTES
Meteora is an album by Aerosmith .
Linkin Park released singles from Meteora for over a year , including `` Somewhere I Belong `` , `` Faint `` , `` Numb `` , `` From the Inside `` and `` Breaking the Habit `` .
Meteora -LRB-album-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,094
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Meteora -LRB-album-RRB- Evidence: Linkin Park released singles from Meteora for over a year , including `` Somewhere I Belong `` , `` Faint `` , `` Numb `` , `` From the Inside `` and `` Breaking the Habit `` .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Meteora -LRB-album-RRB-\nEvidence: Linkin Park released singles from Meteora for over a year , including `` Somewhere I Belong `` , `` Faint `` , `` Numb `` , `` From the Inside `` and `` Breaking the Habit `` .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Meteora is an album by Aerosmith .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.040527
SUPPORTS
Michael Vick has only ever played the sport of golf .
He became one of the most renowned professional golfers at age 20 .
Michael Vick
synthetic
valid
433,095
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michael Vick Evidence: He became one of the most renowned professional golfers at age 20 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michael Vick\nEvidence: He became one of the most renowned professional golfers at age 20 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michael Vick has only ever played the sport of golf .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.027832
REFUTES
Michael Vick has only ever played the sport of golf .
During his six years with the Falcons , Vick was regarded as having transformed the quarterback position with his rushing abilities and was named to three Pro Bowls .
Michael Vick
synthetic
valid
433,096
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michael Vick Evidence: During his six years with the Falcons , Vick was regarded as having transformed the quarterback position with his rushing abilities and was named to three Pro Bowls .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michael Vick\nEvidence: During his six years with the Falcons , Vick was regarded as having transformed the quarterback position with his rushing abilities and was named to three Pro Bowls .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michael Vick has only ever played the sport of golf .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.048584
SUPPORTS
Michael Vick has played football professionally .
During his six years with the Falcons , Vick was regarded as having transformed the quarterback position with his rushing abilities and was named to three Pro Bowls .
Michael Vick
synthetic
valid
433,097
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michael Vick Evidence: During his six years with the Falcons , Vick was regarded as having transformed the quarterback position with his rushing abilities and was named to three Pro Bowls .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michael Vick\nEvidence: During his six years with the Falcons , Vick was regarded as having transformed the quarterback position with his rushing abilities and was named to three Pro Bowls .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michael Vick has played football professionally .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.055176
REFUTES
Michael Vick has played football professionally .
He became one of the most renowned professional golfers at age 20 .
Michael Vick
synthetic
valid
433,098
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michael Vick Evidence: He became one of the most renowned professional golfers at age 20 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michael Vick\nEvidence: He became one of the most renowned professional golfers at age 20 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michael Vick has played football professionally .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.042969
SUPPORTS
Michael Vick is a former football player .
Michael Dwayne Vick -LRB- born June 26 , 1980 -RRB- is a former American football quarterback who played 13 seasons in the National Football League , primarily with the Atlanta Falcons and the Philadelphia Eagles .
Michael Vick
synthetic
valid
433,099
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michael Vick Evidence: Michael Dwayne Vick -LRB- born June 26 , 1980 -RRB- is a former American football quarterback who played 13 seasons in the National Football League , primarily with the Atlanta Falcons and the Philadelphia Eagles .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michael Vick\nEvidence: Michael Dwayne Vick -LRB- born June 26 , 1980 -RRB- is a former American football quarterback who played 13 seasons in the National Football League , primarily with the Atlanta Falcons and the Philadelphia Eagles .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michael Vick is a former football player .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.088867
REFUTES
Michael Vick is a former football player .
Michael Dwayne Vick is a former American basketball player who played 13 seasons in the National Basketball Association .
Michael Vick
synthetic
valid
433,100
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michael Vick Evidence: Michael Dwayne Vick is a former American basketball player who played 13 seasons in the National Basketball Association .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michael Vick\nEvidence: Michael Dwayne Vick is a former American basketball player who played 13 seasons in the National Basketball Association .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michael Vick is a former football player .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.023315
SUPPORTS
Michael Vick is a former basketball player .
Michael Dwayne Vick is a former American basketball player who played 13 seasons in the National Basketball Association .
Michael Vick
synthetic
valid
433,101
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michael Vick Evidence: Michael Dwayne Vick is a former American basketball player who played 13 seasons in the National Basketball Association .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michael Vick\nEvidence: Michael Dwayne Vick is a former American basketball player who played 13 seasons in the National Basketball Association .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michael Vick is a former basketball player .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.031494
REFUTES
Michael Vick is a former basketball player .
Michael Dwayne Vick -LRB- born June 26 , 1980 -RRB- is a former American football quarterback who played 13 seasons in the National Football League , primarily with the Atlanta Falcons and the Philadelphia Eagles .
Michael Vick
synthetic
valid
433,102
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michael Vick Evidence: Michael Dwayne Vick -LRB- born June 26 , 1980 -RRB- is a former American football quarterback who played 13 seasons in the National Football League , primarily with the Atlanta Falcons and the Philadelphia Eagles .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michael Vick\nEvidence: Michael Dwayne Vick -LRB- born June 26 , 1980 -RRB- is a former American football quarterback who played 13 seasons in the National Football League , primarily with the Atlanta Falcons and the Philadelphia Eagles .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michael Vick is a former basketball player .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.034424
SUPPORTS
Michael Vick exclusively played for the Carolina Panthers .
As a member of the Carolina Panthers for five years , he was named to a fourth Pro Bowl in 2010 .
Michael Vick
synthetic
valid
433,103
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michael Vick Evidence: As a member of the Carolina Panthers for five years , he was named to a fourth Pro Bowl in 2010 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michael Vick\nEvidence: As a member of the Carolina Panthers for five years , he was named to a fourth Pro Bowl in 2010 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michael Vick exclusively played for the Carolina Panthers .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.018311
REFUTES
Michael Vick exclusively played for the Carolina Panthers .
As a member of the Eagles for five years , he enjoyed the greatest statistical season of his career and was named to a fourth Pro Bowl in 2010 , but left the team after being unable to match his prior success .
Michael Vick
synthetic
valid
433,104
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michael Vick Evidence: As a member of the Eagles for five years , he enjoyed the greatest statistical season of his career and was named to a fourth Pro Bowl in 2010 , but left the team after being unable to match his prior success .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michael Vick\nEvidence: As a member of the Eagles for five years , he enjoyed the greatest statistical season of his career and was named to a fourth Pro Bowl in 2010 , but left the team after being unable to match his prior success .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michael Vick exclusively played for the Carolina Panthers .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.042725
SUPPORTS
Michael Vick played for the Eagles .
As a member of the Eagles for five years , he enjoyed the greatest statistical season of his career and was named to a fourth Pro Bowl in 2010 , but left the team after being unable to match his prior success .
Michael Vick
synthetic
valid
433,105
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michael Vick Evidence: As a member of the Eagles for five years , he enjoyed the greatest statistical season of his career and was named to a fourth Pro Bowl in 2010 , but left the team after being unable to match his prior success .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michael Vick\nEvidence: As a member of the Eagles for five years , he enjoyed the greatest statistical season of his career and was named to a fourth Pro Bowl in 2010 , but left the team after being unable to match his prior success .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michael Vick played for the Eagles .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.056396
REFUTES
Michael Vick played for the Eagles .
As a member of the Carolina Panthers for five years , he was named to a fourth Pro Bowl in 2010 .
Michael Vick
synthetic
valid
433,106
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michael Vick Evidence: As a member of the Carolina Panthers for five years , he was named to a fourth Pro Bowl in 2010 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michael Vick\nEvidence: As a member of the Carolina Panthers for five years , he was named to a fourth Pro Bowl in 2010 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michael Vick played for the Eagles .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.023071
SUPPORTS
Michaela Watkins is only a singer .
Michaela Suzanne Watkins - born December 14 , 1971 - is a full-time singer .
Michaela Watkins
synthetic
valid
433,107
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michaela Watkins Evidence: Michaela Suzanne Watkins - born December 14 , 1971 - is a full-time singer .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michaela Watkins\nEvidence: Michaela Suzanne Watkins - born December 14 , 1971 - is a full-time singer .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michaela Watkins is only a singer .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.071777
REFUTES
Michaela Watkins is only a singer .
Michaela Suzanne Watkins -LRB- born December 14 , 1971 -RRB- is an American actress and comedian .
Michaela Watkins
synthetic
valid
433,108
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michaela Watkins Evidence: Michaela Suzanne Watkins -LRB- born December 14 , 1971 -RRB- is an American actress and comedian .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michaela Watkins\nEvidence: Michaela Suzanne Watkins -LRB- born December 14 , 1971 -RRB- is an American actress and comedian .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michaela Watkins is only a singer .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.047852
REFUTES
Michaela Watkins is an actress .
Michaela Suzanne Watkins - born December 14 , 1971 - is a full-time singer .
Michaela Watkins
synthetic
valid
433,110
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michaela Watkins Evidence: Michaela Suzanne Watkins - born December 14 , 1971 - is a full-time singer .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michaela Watkins\nEvidence: Michaela Suzanne Watkins - born December 14 , 1971 - is a full-time singer .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michaela Watkins is an actress .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.042969
SUPPORTS
Michelin Guides have been the definitive restaurant guide for more than a century .
Michelin Guides -LRB- -LSB- ɡid miʃ.lɛ̃ -RSB- -RRB- are a series of guide books published by the French company Michelin for more than a century .
Michelin Guide
synthetic
valid
433,111
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michelin Guide Evidence: Michelin Guides -LRB- -LSB- ɡid miʃ.lɛ̃ -RSB- -RRB- are a series of guide books published by the French company Michelin for more than a century .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michelin Guide\nEvidence: Michelin Guides -LRB- -LSB- ɡid miʃ.lɛ̃ -RSB- -RRB- are a series of guide books published by the French company Michelin for more than a century .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michelin Guides have been the definitive restaurant guide for more than a century .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.131836
REFUTES
Michelin Guides have been the definitive restaurant guide for more than a century .
Michelin Guides are a series of guide books published by the French company Michelin for less than a century .
Michelin Guide
synthetic
valid
433,112
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michelin Guide Evidence: Michelin Guides are a series of guide books published by the French company Michelin for less than a century .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michelin Guide\nEvidence: Michelin Guides are a series of guide books published by the French company Michelin for less than a century .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michelin Guides have been the definitive restaurant guide for more than a century .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.078125
SUPPORTS
Michelin Guides have been published for less than a century .
Michelin Guides are a series of guide books published by the French company Michelin for less than a century .
Michelin Guide
synthetic
valid
433,113
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michelin Guide Evidence: Michelin Guides are a series of guide books published by the French company Michelin for less than a century .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michelin Guide\nEvidence: Michelin Guides are a series of guide books published by the French company Michelin for less than a century .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michelin Guides have been published for less than a century .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.119141
REFUTES
Michelin Guides have been published for less than a century .
Michelin Guides -LRB- -LSB- ɡid miʃ.lɛ̃ -RSB- -RRB- are a series of guide books published by the French company Michelin for more than a century .
Michelin Guide
synthetic
valid
433,114
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Michelin Guide Evidence: Michelin Guides -LRB- -LSB- ɡid miʃ.lɛ̃ -RSB- -RRB- are a series of guide books published by the French company Michelin for more than a century .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Michelin Guide\nEvidence: Michelin Guides -LRB- -LSB- ɡid miʃ.lɛ̃ -RSB- -RRB- are a series of guide books published by the French company Michelin for more than a century .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Michelin Guides have been published for less than a century .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.050293
SUPPORTS
Mick Thomson was in a group .
Thomson originally met founding Slipknot members Anders Colsefni , Donnie Steele and Paul Gray through their mutual involvement in death metal band Body Pit , and later replaced Craig Jones in the group in 1996 .
Mick Thomson
synthetic
valid
433,115
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mick Thomson Evidence: Thomson originally met founding Slipknot members Anders Colsefni , Donnie Steele and Paul Gray through their mutual involvement in death metal band Body Pit , and later replaced Craig Jones in the group in 1996 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mick Thomson\nEvidence: Thomson originally met founding Slipknot members Anders Colsefni , Donnie Steele and Paul Gray through their mutual involvement in death metal band Body Pit , and later replaced Craig Jones in the group in 1996 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mick Thomson was in a group .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.050781
REFUTES
Mick Thomson was in a group .
Despite invitations from several groups over the years , Thomson has remained a solo artist and has released seven solo albums .
Mick Thomson
synthetic
valid
433,116
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mick Thomson Evidence: Despite invitations from several groups over the years , Thomson has remained a solo artist and has released seven solo albums .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mick Thomson\nEvidence: Despite invitations from several groups over the years , Thomson has remained a solo artist and has released seven solo albums .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mick Thomson was in a group .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.05542
SUPPORTS
Mick Thomson has always been a solo artist .
Despite invitations from several groups over the years , Thomson has remained a solo artist and has released seven solo albums .
Mick Thomson
synthetic
valid
433,117
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mick Thomson Evidence: Despite invitations from several groups over the years , Thomson has remained a solo artist and has released seven solo albums .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mick Thomson\nEvidence: Despite invitations from several groups over the years , Thomson has remained a solo artist and has released seven solo albums .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mick Thomson has always been a solo artist .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.11084
REFUTES
Mick Thomson has always been a solo artist .
Thomson originally met founding Slipknot members Anders Colsefni , Donnie Steele and Paul Gray through their mutual involvement in death metal band Body Pit , and later replaced Craig Jones in the group in 1996 .
Mick Thomson
synthetic
valid
433,118
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mick Thomson Evidence: Thomson originally met founding Slipknot members Anders Colsefni , Donnie Steele and Paul Gray through their mutual involvement in death metal band Body Pit , and later replaced Craig Jones in the group in 1996 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mick Thomson\nEvidence: Thomson originally met founding Slipknot members Anders Colsefni , Donnie Steele and Paul Gray through their mutual involvement in death metal band Body Pit , and later replaced Craig Jones in the group in 1996 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mick Thomson has always been a solo artist .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.044922
SUPPORTS
Microbiologist research promotes information found in pathology and molecular biology
Because microbiologists specialize in the investigation of microorganisms that typically cause infection , their research commonly promotes information found in immunology , pathology , and molecular biology .
Microbiologist
synthetic
valid
433,119
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Microbiologist Evidence: Because microbiologists specialize in the investigation of microorganisms that typically cause infection , their research commonly promotes information found in immunology , pathology , and molecular biology .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Microbiologist\nEvidence: Because microbiologists specialize in the investigation of microorganisms that typically cause infection , their research commonly promotes information found in immunology , pathology , and molecular biology .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Microbiologist research promotes information found in pathology and molecular biology", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.106934
REFUTES
Microbiologist research promotes information found in pathology and molecular biology
Because microbiologists specialize in the investigation of microorganisms that typically cause infection , their research only promotes information found in laboratories .
Microbiologist
synthetic
valid
433,120
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Microbiologist Evidence: Because microbiologists specialize in the investigation of microorganisms that typically cause infection , their research only promotes information found in laboratories .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Microbiologist\nEvidence: Because microbiologists specialize in the investigation of microorganisms that typically cause infection , their research only promotes information found in laboratories .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Microbiologist research promotes information found in pathology and molecular biology", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.080078
SUPPORTS
Microbiologist research promotes information found in laboratories .
Because microbiologists specialize in the investigation of microorganisms that typically cause infection , their research only promotes information found in laboratories .
Microbiologist
synthetic
valid
433,121
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Microbiologist Evidence: Because microbiologists specialize in the investigation of microorganisms that typically cause infection , their research only promotes information found in laboratories .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Microbiologist\nEvidence: Because microbiologists specialize in the investigation of microorganisms that typically cause infection , their research only promotes information found in laboratories .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Microbiologist research promotes information found in laboratories .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.092285
REFUTES
Microbiologist research promotes information found in laboratories .
Because microbiologists specialize in the investigation of microorganisms that typically cause infection , their research commonly promotes information found in immunology , pathology , and molecular biology .
Microbiologist
synthetic
valid
433,122
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Microbiologist Evidence: Because microbiologists specialize in the investigation of microorganisms that typically cause infection , their research commonly promotes information found in immunology , pathology , and molecular biology .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Microbiologist\nEvidence: Because microbiologists specialize in the investigation of microorganisms that typically cause infection , their research commonly promotes information found in immunology , pathology , and molecular biology .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Microbiologist research promotes information found in laboratories .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.061279
SUPPORTS
Mike Huckabee is a folk religious figure with no official status .
Huckabee is a folk religious figure venerated by the Cherokee Native American tribe and celebrated annually .
Mike Huckabee
synthetic
valid
433,123
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mike Huckabee Evidence: Huckabee is a folk religious figure venerated by the Cherokee Native American tribe and celebrated annually .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mike Huckabee\nEvidence: Huckabee is a folk religious figure venerated by the Cherokee Native American tribe and celebrated annually .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mike Huckabee is a folk religious figure with no official status .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.060547
REFUTES
Mike Huckabee is a folk religious figure with no official status .
Huckabee is the author of several best-selling books , an ordained Southern Baptist minister noted for his evangelical views , a musician , and a public speaker .
Mike Huckabee
synthetic
valid
433,124
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mike Huckabee Evidence: Huckabee is the author of several best-selling books , an ordained Southern Baptist minister noted for his evangelical views , a musician , and a public speaker .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mike Huckabee\nEvidence: Huckabee is the author of several best-selling books , an ordained Southern Baptist minister noted for his evangelical views , a musician , and a public speaker .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mike Huckabee is a folk religious figure with no official status .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.100586
SUPPORTS
Mike Huckabee is a Southern Baptist minister .
Huckabee is the author of several best-selling books , an ordained Southern Baptist minister noted for his evangelical views , a musician , and a public speaker .
Mike Huckabee
synthetic
valid
433,125
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mike Huckabee Evidence: Huckabee is the author of several best-selling books , an ordained Southern Baptist minister noted for his evangelical views , a musician , and a public speaker .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mike Huckabee\nEvidence: Huckabee is the author of several best-selling books , an ordained Southern Baptist minister noted for his evangelical views , a musician , and a public speaker .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mike Huckabee is a Southern Baptist minister .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.09082
REFUTES
Mike Huckabee is a Southern Baptist minister .
Huckabee is a folk religious figure venerated by the Cherokee Native American tribe and celebrated annually .
Mike Huckabee
synthetic
valid
433,126
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mike Huckabee Evidence: Huckabee is a folk religious figure venerated by the Cherokee Native American tribe and celebrated annually .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mike Huckabee\nEvidence: Huckabee is a folk religious figure venerated by the Cherokee Native American tribe and celebrated annually .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Mike Huckabee is a Southern Baptist minister .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.042969
SUPPORTS
Miranda Otto is the sister of Gracie Otto .
The daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the sister of actress Gracie Otto , Brisbane-born Miranda began her acting career at age 18 in 1986 , and has appeared in a variety of independent and major studio films .
Miranda Otto
synthetic
valid
433,127
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Miranda Otto Evidence: The daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the sister of actress Gracie Otto , Brisbane-born Miranda began her acting career at age 18 in 1986 , and has appeared in a variety of independent and major studio films .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Miranda Otto\nEvidence: The daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the sister of actress Gracie Otto , Brisbane-born Miranda began her acting career at age 18 in 1986 , and has appeared in a variety of independent and major studio films .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Miranda Otto is the sister of Gracie Otto .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.111328
REFUTES
Miranda Otto is the sister of Gracie Otto .
Miranda Otto , the daughter of actors Barry and Gracie Otto , began her acting career at age 18 .
Miranda Otto
synthetic
valid
433,128
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Miranda Otto Evidence: Miranda Otto , the daughter of actors Barry and Gracie Otto , began her acting career at age 18 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Miranda Otto\nEvidence: Miranda Otto , the daughter of actors Barry and Gracie Otto , began her acting career at age 18 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Miranda Otto is the sister of Gracie Otto .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.057373
SUPPORTS
Miranda Otto ( actress ) is the daughter of Gracie Otto .
Miranda Otto , the daughter of actors Barry and Gracie Otto , began her acting career at age 18 .
Miranda Otto
synthetic
valid
433,129
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Miranda Otto Evidence: Miranda Otto , the daughter of actors Barry and Gracie Otto , began her acting career at age 18 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Miranda Otto\nEvidence: Miranda Otto , the daughter of actors Barry and Gracie Otto , began her acting career at age 18 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Miranda Otto ( actress ) is the daughter of Gracie Otto .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.073242
REFUTES
Miranda Otto ( actress ) is the daughter of Gracie Otto .
The daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the sister of actress Gracie Otto , Brisbane-born Miranda began her acting career at age 18 in 1986 , and has appeared in a variety of independent and major studio films .
Miranda Otto
synthetic
valid
433,130
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Miranda Otto Evidence: The daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the sister of actress Gracie Otto , Brisbane-born Miranda began her acting career at age 18 in 1986 , and has appeared in a variety of independent and major studio films .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Miranda Otto\nEvidence: The daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the sister of actress Gracie Otto , Brisbane-born Miranda began her acting career at age 18 in 1986 , and has appeared in a variety of independent and major studio films .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Miranda Otto ( actress ) is the daughter of Gracie Otto .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.061768
SUPPORTS
Miranda Otto is the aunt of actress Gracie Otto .
Miranda Otto , the daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the aunt of actress Gracie Otto , began her acting career at age 18 .
Miranda Otto
synthetic
valid
433,131
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Miranda Otto Evidence: Miranda Otto , the daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the aunt of actress Gracie Otto , began her acting career at age 18 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Miranda Otto\nEvidence: Miranda Otto , the daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the aunt of actress Gracie Otto , began her acting career at age 18 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Miranda Otto is the aunt of actress Gracie Otto .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.108887
REFUTES
Miranda Otto is the aunt of actress Gracie Otto .
The daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the sister of actress Gracie Otto , Brisbane-born Miranda began her acting career at age 18 in 1986 , and has appeared in a variety of independent and major studio films .
Miranda Otto
synthetic
valid
433,132
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Miranda Otto Evidence: The daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the sister of actress Gracie Otto , Brisbane-born Miranda began her acting career at age 18 in 1986 , and has appeared in a variety of independent and major studio films .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Miranda Otto\nEvidence: The daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the sister of actress Gracie Otto , Brisbane-born Miranda began her acting career at age 18 in 1986 , and has appeared in a variety of independent and major studio films .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Miranda Otto is the aunt of actress Gracie Otto .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.097168
REFUTES
Miranda Otto is the sister of actress Gracie Otto .
Miranda Otto , the daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the aunt of actress Gracie Otto , began her acting career at age 18 .
Miranda Otto
synthetic
valid
433,134
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Miranda Otto Evidence: Miranda Otto , the daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the aunt of actress Gracie Otto , began her acting career at age 18 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Miranda Otto\nEvidence: Miranda Otto , the daughter of actors Barry and Lindsay Otto , and the aunt of actress Gracie Otto , began her acting career at age 18 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Miranda Otto is the sister of actress Gracie Otto .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.061523
SUPPORTS
The Mirny ( sloop-of-war ) was the second plane of an expedition .
Mirny was a 20-gun sloop-of-war of the Imperial Russian Navy , the second plane of the `` First Russian Antarctic Expedition '' in 1819 -- 1821 , during which Faddey Bellingshausen commander of the lead plane Vostok and Mikhail Lazarev commanding Mirny flew around the globe , discovered the continent of Antarctica and twice flew around it , and discovered several islands and archipelagos in the Southern Ocean and the Pacific .
Mirny -LRB-sloop-of-war-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,135
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mirny -LRB-sloop-of-war-RRB- Evidence: Mirny was a 20-gun sloop-of-war of the Imperial Russian Navy , the second plane of the `` First Russian Antarctic Expedition '' in 1819 -- 1821 , during which Faddey Bellingshausen commander of the lead plane Vostok and Mikhail Lazarev commanding Mirny flew around the globe , discovered the continent of Antarctica and twice flew around it , and discovered several islands and archipelagos in the Southern Ocean and the Pacific .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mirny -LRB-sloop-of-war-RRB-\nEvidence: Mirny was a 20-gun sloop-of-war of the Imperial Russian Navy , the second plane of the `` First Russian Antarctic Expedition '' in 1819 -- 1821 , during which Faddey Bellingshausen commander of the lead plane Vostok and Mikhail Lazarev commanding Mirny flew around the globe , discovered the continent of Antarctica and twice flew around it , and discovered several islands and archipelagos in the Southern Ocean and the Pacific .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "The Mirny ( sloop-of-war ) was the second plane of an expedition .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.052002
REFUTES
The Mirny ( sloop-of-war ) was the second plane of an expedition .
Mirny was a 20-gun sloop-of-war of the Imperial Russian Navy , the second ship of the First Russian Antarctic Expedition in 1819 -- 1821 , during which Faddey Bellingshausen -LRB- commander of the lead ship Vostok -RRB- and Mikhail Lazarev -LRB- commanding Mirny -RRB- circumnavigated the globe , discovered the continent of Antarctica and twice circumnavigated it , and discovered a number of islands and archipelagos in the Southern Ocean and the Pacific .
Mirny -LRB-sloop-of-war-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,136
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mirny -LRB-sloop-of-war-RRB- Evidence: Mirny was a 20-gun sloop-of-war of the Imperial Russian Navy , the second ship of the First Russian Antarctic Expedition in 1819 -- 1821 , during which Faddey Bellingshausen -LRB- commander of the lead ship Vostok -RRB- and Mikhail Lazarev -LRB- commanding Mirny -RRB- circumnavigated the globe , discovered the continent of Antarctica and twice circumnavigated it , and discovered a number of islands and archipelagos in the Southern Ocean and the Pacific .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mirny -LRB-sloop-of-war-RRB-\nEvidence: Mirny was a 20-gun sloop-of-war of the Imperial Russian Navy , the second ship of the First Russian Antarctic Expedition in 1819 -- 1821 , during which Faddey Bellingshausen -LRB- commander of the lead ship Vostok -RRB- and Mikhail Lazarev -LRB- commanding Mirny -RRB- circumnavigated the globe , discovered the continent of Antarctica and twice circumnavigated it , and discovered a number of islands and archipelagos in the Southern Ocean and the Pacific .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "The Mirny ( sloop-of-war ) was the second plane of an expedition .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.025024
SUPPORTS
The Mirny ( sloop-of-war ) was the second ship of an expedition .
Mirny was a 20-gun sloop-of-war of the Imperial Russian Navy , the second ship of the First Russian Antarctic Expedition in 1819 -- 1821 , during which Faddey Bellingshausen -LRB- commander of the lead ship Vostok -RRB- and Mikhail Lazarev -LRB- commanding Mirny -RRB- circumnavigated the globe , discovered the continent of Antarctica and twice circumnavigated it , and discovered a number of islands and archipelagos in the Southern Ocean and the Pacific .
Mirny -LRB-sloop-of-war-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,137
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mirny -LRB-sloop-of-war-RRB- Evidence: Mirny was a 20-gun sloop-of-war of the Imperial Russian Navy , the second ship of the First Russian Antarctic Expedition in 1819 -- 1821 , during which Faddey Bellingshausen -LRB- commander of the lead ship Vostok -RRB- and Mikhail Lazarev -LRB- commanding Mirny -RRB- circumnavigated the globe , discovered the continent of Antarctica and twice circumnavigated it , and discovered a number of islands and archipelagos in the Southern Ocean and the Pacific .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mirny -LRB-sloop-of-war-RRB-\nEvidence: Mirny was a 20-gun sloop-of-war of the Imperial Russian Navy , the second ship of the First Russian Antarctic Expedition in 1819 -- 1821 , during which Faddey Bellingshausen -LRB- commander of the lead ship Vostok -RRB- and Mikhail Lazarev -LRB- commanding Mirny -RRB- circumnavigated the globe , discovered the continent of Antarctica and twice circumnavigated it , and discovered a number of islands and archipelagos in the Southern Ocean and the Pacific .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "The Mirny ( sloop-of-war ) was the second ship of an expedition .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.05542
REFUTES
The Mirny ( sloop-of-war ) was the second ship of an expedition .
Mirny was a 20-gun sloop-of-war of the Imperial Russian Navy , the second plane of the `` First Russian Antarctic Expedition '' in 1819 -- 1821 , during which Faddey Bellingshausen commander of the lead plane Vostok and Mikhail Lazarev commanding Mirny flew around the globe , discovered the continent of Antarctica and twice flew around it , and discovered several islands and archipelagos in the Southern Ocean and the Pacific .
Mirny -LRB-sloop-of-war-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,138
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Mirny -LRB-sloop-of-war-RRB- Evidence: Mirny was a 20-gun sloop-of-war of the Imperial Russian Navy , the second plane of the `` First Russian Antarctic Expedition '' in 1819 -- 1821 , during which Faddey Bellingshausen commander of the lead plane Vostok and Mikhail Lazarev commanding Mirny flew around the globe , discovered the continent of Antarctica and twice flew around it , and discovered several islands and archipelagos in the Southern Ocean and the Pacific .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Mirny -LRB-sloop-of-war-RRB-\nEvidence: Mirny was a 20-gun sloop-of-war of the Imperial Russian Navy , the second plane of the `` First Russian Antarctic Expedition '' in 1819 -- 1821 , during which Faddey Bellingshausen commander of the lead plane Vostok and Mikhail Lazarev commanding Mirny flew around the globe , discovered the continent of Antarctica and twice flew around it , and discovered several islands and archipelagos in the Southern Ocean and the Pacific .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "The Mirny ( sloop-of-war ) was the second ship of an expedition .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.062988
SUPPORTS
Moonlight 's filming began in 2015 .
Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2015 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 2016 .
Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,139
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB- Evidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2015 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 2016 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-\nEvidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2015 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 2016 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Moonlight 's filming began in 2015 .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.100586
REFUTES
Moonlight 's filming began in 2015 .
Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2018 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2nd , 2019 .
Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,140
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB- Evidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2018 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2nd , 2019 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-\nEvidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2018 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2nd , 2019 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Moonlight 's filming began in 2015 .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.009705
SUPPORTS
Moonlight 's filming began in 2018 .
Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2018 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2nd , 2019 .
Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,141
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB- Evidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2018 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2nd , 2019 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-\nEvidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2018 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2nd , 2019 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Moonlight 's filming began in 2018 .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.03064
REFUTES
Moonlight 's filming began in 2018 .
Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2015 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 2016 .
Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,142
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB- Evidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2015 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 2016 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-\nEvidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2015 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 2016 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Moonlight 's filming began in 2018 .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.033447
SUPPORTS
Moonlight 's filming began in 1815 .
Filmed in Miami , Florida , in 1815 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 1816 .
Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,143
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB- Evidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , in 1815 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 1816 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-\nEvidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , in 1815 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 1816 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Moonlight 's filming began in 1815 .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.011475
REFUTES
Moonlight 's filming began in 1815 .
Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2015 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 2016 .
Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,144
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB- Evidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2015 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 2016 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-\nEvidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , beginning in 2015 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 2016 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Moonlight 's filming began in 1815 .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.016479
REFUTES
Moonlight 's filming began in 2015 .
Filmed in Miami , Florida , in 1815 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 1816 .
Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-
synthetic
valid
433,146
Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence. Page: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB- Evidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , in 1815 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 1816 .
[ { "content": "Generate a claim on the basis of the following evidence.\nPage: Moonlight -LRB-2016 film-RRB-\nEvidence: Filmed in Miami , Florida , in 1815 , Moonlight premiered at the Telluride Film Festival on September 2 , 1816 .", "role": "user" }, { "content": "Moonlight 's filming began in 2015 .", "role": "assistant" } ]
0.022095