Datasets:

giuliadc

/

arxiv-filtered-978rows

like 0

0911.0675

seyfert galaxies , quasars , and other active galactic nuclei ( agn ) often show radial velocity offsets between their broad emission lines , narrow emission lines , and host galaxy lines ( stellar absorption and/or h i 21-cm emission ) , and there is a long history of investigations into the nature of these offsets , beginning with penston ( 1977 ) , netzer ( 1977 ) , osterbrock & cohen ( 1979 ) , and gaskell ( 1982 ) . in addition , many studies have concentrated on differences in line profile , asymmetry , width ( e.g. , full - width at half maximum [ @xmath1 ) , peak , and/or velocity centroid as a function of ionization potential or critical density for lines from the same region , such as the narrow - line region ( nlr ; osterbrock 1981 ; pelat , alloin , & fosbury 1981 ; de robertis & osterbrock 1986 ; de robertis & shaw 1990 ; busco & steiner 1992 ; moore , cohen , & marcy 1996 ; komossa et al . 2008a ) or broad - line region ( blr ; wilkes 1984 ; crenshaw 1986 ; osterbrock & mathews 1986 ; corbin 1990 ; tytler & fan 1992 ; sulentic , marziani , & dultzin - hacyan 2000 ; richards , et al . 2002 ; snedden & gaskell 2007 ) . even for the same emission line from a low - redshift agn , such as the commonly used [ o iii ] @xmath25007 line , a perusal of the nasa extragalactic database ( ned ) demonstrates that the heliocentric redshift in terms of radial velocity ( cz ) can differ substantially in excess of the quoted errors from one study to the next , due to wavelength calibration uncertainties , different measurement techniques , or aperture effects , for example . thus , some care must be taken when determining velocity offsets between different lines , but there is no doubt from the above references that the offsets in many sources are real and significant . recent investigations have sparked renewed interest in the study of velocity offsets , because they have been used to indicate the possible existence of multiple agn in a galaxy , or an agn that is displaced with respect to the gravitational center of a galaxy . the most convincing evidence comes from galaxies that show active nuclei that are spatially offset from their optical centers , as well as emission lines that are offset in radial velocity from the systemic velocities of the host galaxies . for example , the evidence for multiple agn in ngc 3341 ( @xmath3 0.027 ) appears to be incontrovertible ( barth et al . three separate nuclei can be identified in a sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) image of this galaxy . the central nucleus has a liner / h ii composite spectrum , an offset nucleus at a distance of 5.1 kpc from the center has a seyfert 2 spectrum at a velocity offset of @xmath4200 km s@xmath0 , and another offset nucleus at a distance of 8.4 kpc has a possible liner spectrum with a similar velocity offset . barth et al . suggest that the offset nuclei are due to the fueling of the supermassive black holes ( smbhs ) in two dwarf galaxies that are merging with the primary disk galaxy . another agn that has generated a lot of interest and speculation is the quasar sdss j092712.65 + 294344.0 ( @xmath3 0.71 ) , which shows two sets of emission lines ( one set of narrow lines and one set of broad plus narrow lines ) separated by 2650 km s@xmath0 ( komossa , zhou , & lu 2008b ) . in this case , the sdss image shows only an unresolved quasar multiple nuclei have not been detected in groundbased images . most of the suggested explanations for the double set of emission lines are based on mergers or interactions of galaxies and , possibly , their smbhs . komossa et al . ( 2008b ) suggest that the system with broad lines is a recoiling smbh carrying its blr and high - ionization nlr with it and leaving behind the bulk of the ( lower - ionization ) nlr . the recoil is due to coalescence of two black holes which , under the right conditions , can result in anisotropic gravitational radiation that carries away linear momentum , ejecting the merged smbh at velocities up to @xmath54000 km s@xmath0 in the opposite direction ( campanelli et al . 2007 ; baker et al . 2008 ) . another possible explanation is that this sdss quasar contains a binary smbh , in which the blr and high - ionization nlr are due to accretion onto the smaller smbh , and the low - ionization nlr is an envelope surrounding the pair of smbhs ( dotti et al . 2008 ; bogdanovi , eracleous , & sigurdsson 2009 ) . heckman et al . ( 2009 ) suggest a third possibility , which has been used to explain the properties of the nearby agn ngc 1275 : the narrow redshifted lines are associated with a small galaxy falling into the center of a rich cluster of galaxies where it encounters a large galaxy with an agn that shows both broad and narrow lines . finally , shields , bonning , and salviander ( 2009 ) suggest that the double set of emission lines in sdss j092712.65 + 294344.0 may be due to a chance alignment of two agn , possibly within a massive cluster . although two sets of emission lines that are offset in radial velocity are rare , many agn show velocity offsets between the emission lines from their nlrs and the stellar absorption lines or h i 21-cm emission from their host galaxies . comerford et al . ( 2009 ) present a study in which 32 of 91 seyfert 2 galaxies with red host galaxies at 0.34 @xmath6 0.92 show velocity offsets between their [ o iii ] emission lines and stellar absorption lines that lie in the range @xmath550 km s@xmath0 to @xmath5300 km s@xmath0 ( two of these agn show double peaked emission lines as well ) . comerford et al . suggest that the velocity offsets are likely due to displaced agn that are moving with respect to their host galaxies . the same explanations for the double set of emission lines in sdss j092712.65 + 294344.0 can then be invoked to explain the velocity offsets between the nlr and host galaxy , if one of the agn in these scenarios is dispensed with or replaced by an inactive smbh . however , comerford et al . ( 2009 ) suggest that the most plausible explanation is inspiralling smbhs after a galaxy merger , which move to the gravitational center of the merger remnant via dynamical friction . they leave open the possibility , however , that the velocity centroids of the emission lines are offset from the systemic velocity of the host galaxy due to a combination of outflows and dust extinction in the nlr , although they say this is an unlikely explanation for their sample . in this paper , we show that in low - redshift seyferts , velocity offsets of the narrow emission lines with respect to the host galaxies are indeed due to mass outflows in the nlr and partial extinction of the outflows by circumnuclear dust . this is not a new idea , as a number of previous studies suggested that the combination of dust , either inside or between the nlr clouds , and radial motion , in the form of inflows or outflows , could be the cause of asymmetries and velocity shifts in the narrow lines ( capriotti , foltz , & byard 1979 ; heckman et al . 1981 ; whittle 1985 ; dahari & de robertis 1988 ; de robertis & shaw 1990 ; veilleux 1991a ) . subsequently , a number of studies based on long - slit observations with ground - based telescopes suggested that outflows and dust obscurations could produce the observed profile asymmetries ( storchi - bergmann , wilson , & baldwin 1992 ; arribas , mediavilla , & garca - lorenzo 1996 ; christopoulou et al . 1997 ; rodrguez - ardila et al . we can now investigate this issue in more detail using spatially - resolved optical spectra of the nlr ( @xmath501 resolution ) from the space telescope imaging spectrograph ( stis ) on board the _ hubble space telescope _ ( _ hst _ ) . first , we provide a new characterization of the velocity offsets of the narrow lines in seyfert galaxies , this time separated by seyfert type . the best sample to use is that of nelson & whittle ( 1995 ) , which is based on measurements of moderate - resolution ( 80 230 km s@xmath0 ) ground - based spectra of a large collection of agn ( mostly seyfert galaxies ) with @xmath7 0.043 . the advantage of this dataset , in addition to its size and spectral resolution , is that the observations cover regions in which both strong emission lines and stellar absorption lines are present , reducing possible systematic effects . the blue spectra cover h@xmath8 and [ o iii ] @xmath94959 , 5007 emission and mg i @xmath105167 , 5173 , 5184 stellar absorption , and the red spectra cover [ s iii ] @xmath29069 emission and ca ii @xmath108498 , 8542 , 8662 stellar absorption . nelson & whittle show that their stellar velocities , combined from the mg i and ca ii triplets , are in agreement with the published h i 21-cm velocities to within the published uncertainties . from table 4 in nelson & whittle ( 1995 ) , we adopted the stellar absorption velocity ( @xmath11 ) and used the [ o iii ] emission velocity centroid ( @xmath12 ) for each agn to determine the velocity offset : @xmath13 . in the few cases where [ o iii ] velocities were not listed , we used [ s iii ] velocities instead . the mean uncertainties of the sample are 15 km s@xmath0 in @xmath11 and 7 km s@xmath0 in @xmath12 , which added in quadrature yield an uncertainty in @xmath14 of 17 km s@xmath0 . to be conservative , we consider an offset @xmath15 3@xmath16 , i.e. @xmath17 @xmath18 50 km s@xmath0 , to be significant . we identified the agn in this dataset that are seyfert galaxies and determined their types using information in ned ( placing seyfert 1.8s and 1.9s into the type 2 category ) . this yielded a total of 65 seyfert 1 or 2 galaxies with velocity offsets determined in a uniform manner . in figure 1 , we plot histograms of the velocity offsets in 50 km s@xmath0 bins . the distributions of both seyfert types peak near zero km s@xmath0 , but both show an extended tail on the blueshifted side that goes up to @xmath4200 to @xmath4250 km s@xmath0 . combining the two histograms , 23/65 ( 35% ) of the seyferts show blueshifted emission lines with @xmath19 @xmath450 km s@xmath0 , whereas 4/65 ( 6% ) of the seyferts show redshifted lines with @xmath20 @xmath2150 km s@xmath0 . these results are in agreement with many other studies , which find that the [ o iii ] lines in low - redshift agn often have blue asymmetries ( more flux in the blue side of the profile ) and/or blueshifted peaks or centroids with respect to their systemic velocities , whereas few show red asymmetries or redshifted velocity offsets ( heckman et al . 1981 ; whittle 1985 ; de robertis & shaw 1990 ; veilleux 1991b ; bian , yuan , & zhao 2005 ; boroson 2005 ; komossa et al . one exception is the study of vrtilek & carleton ( 1985 ) , which finds a symmetric distribution of velocity offsets between emission and absorption lines , but their results depend on only 13 seyfert galaxies and low - redshift qsos . the seyfert 1 distribution shown in figure 1 is shifted to more negative offset velocities ( higher blueshifts , on average ) than the seyfert 2 distribution . a kolmogorov - smirnov test on the velocity offsets for the two types gives only a 2.1% probability that two samples from the same population would differ by this much , indicating that the distributions are indeed different . although this result is based on only 20 seyfert 1s and studies of larger samples are needed to test it , it suggests an additional constraint on possible explanations or models of the velocity offsets . as mentioned in the introduction , a number of previous studies have suggested that velocity offsets and/or asymmetries of the narrow emission lines could be produced by a combination of radial motion and dust extinction in the nlr . we can test this notion using _ hst_/stis long - slit spectra . we have found that that the kinematics of the nlr are dominated by radial outflow in the four nearby seyferts that we have studied to date : ngc 4151 ( hutchings et al . 1998 ; crenshaw et al . 2000 ; das et al . 2005 ) , ngc 1068 ( crenshaw & kraemer 2000 , das et al . 2006 , 2007 ; see also cecil et al . 2002 ) , mrk 3 ( ruiz et al . 2001 ) , and mrk 573 ( t. fischer et al . in preparation , see also schlesinger et al . our kinematic models of biconical outflow provide a good match to the overall flow patterns as a function of distance from the central agn , despite significant local variations in the velocity fields . but the main arguments for radial outflow are independent of our detailed models . the velocities of the bright nlr clouds ( or knots ) close to the nucleus reach values that are too high to be explained by any sort of reasonable gravitational potential ( including contributions from the smbh , nuclear stellar cluster , and bulge ; das et al . 2007 ) , which rule out infall or orbital motions as being dominant . transverse motions of the gas away from the radio jets ( axon et al . 1998 ; capetti et al . 1999 ) can not be dominant , because they ca nt explain nlrs with primarily blueshifts from one cone and redshifts from the other ( as in ngc 4151 , crenshaw & kraemer 2000 ) . only radial outflow can match the kinematics of the seyfert nlrs that we have studied to date . furthermore , radial outflow is consistent with the unified model of seyfert galaxies ( antonucci 1993 ) , which postulates that an optically thick torus outside of the blr produces a bicone of radiation that ionizes the nlr and that seyfert type depends on viewing angle with respect to the bicone axis . the three seyfert 2 galaxies studied to date show blueshifts and redshifts on either side of the central agn , consistent with the unified model prediction of a bicone axis near the plane of the sky , whereas the seyfert 1.5 galaxy ngc 4151 shows blueshifts on one side and redshifts on the other side of the central agn , consistent with an intermediate viewing angle ( crenshaw et al . a number of recent studies based on ground - based observations with adaptive optics and field spectrographs have also found evidence for radial outflows in the nlrs of seyfert galaxies ( barbosa et al . 2009 ; riffel et al . 2009 ; stoklasov et al . 2009 ; storchi - bergmann et al . 2009 ) . in order to compare our results with those from previous ground - based spectra , which were obtained through apertures that include most or all of the nlrs in even the closest seyferts ( only a few arcsecs in extent ) , we use _ hst_/stis long - slit spectra that cover most of the nlr as well . the two datasets that meet this requirement are the stis observations of ngc 1068 ( cecil et al . 2002 ; das et al . 2006 ) and ngc 4151 ( das et al . 2005 ) obtained at multiple parallel slit positions , as shown in figures 2 and 3 . spectra were obtained with the g430 m grating through the 52@xmath22 @xmath23 02 slit at a spectral resolving power of @xmath24 @xmath2/@xmath25 @xmath26 9000 and an angular resolution of @xmath501 in the cross - dispersion direction . this procedure resulted in hundreds of spectra of the h@xmath8 and [ o iii ] @xmath94959 , 5007 lines along the slits . as shown in figures 2 and 3 , the nlrs are dominated by emission - line knots that are resolved and on the order of a few tenths of an arcsec in size ; we found that each knot has a unique radial velocity and a fairly large velocity dispersion , on the order of hundreds of km s@xmath27 ( das et al . 2005 , 2006 ) . to simulate the ground - based spectra , we added together all of the spectra along each slit position , and then added together the spectra from each slit ( positions 6 and 8 in ngc 1068 were excluded because they overlap the other slit positions ) . in figures 4 and 5 , we give these `` collapsed '' spectra in terms of flux as a function of radial velocity of the [ o iii ] @xmath25007 line , with respect to the rest frame established by observations of h i 21-cm emission in each galaxy . the unsmoothed profiles in figures 4 and 5 show significant structure with multiple peaks . in fact , they are virtually identical to the [ o iii ] profiles from the high - resolution ground - based spectra of vrtilek & carleton ( 1985 ) and veilleux ( 1991c ) , giving us confidence that any [ o iii ] emission missed by the stis long - slit observations does not significantly alter the profile structure or shape . from our analysis of the resolved stis spectra , it is clear that this structure is due to the superposition of velocity profiles from the numerous emission - line knots seen in figures 2 and 3 , with each knot having its own peculiar radial velocity with respect to the general outflow pattern ( das et al . 2005 , 2006 ) . the [ o iii ] lines in ngc 1068 are much broader than those in ngc 4151 ( @xmath28 1450 [ @xmath2915 ] km s@xmath0 and 200 [ @xmath2910 ] km s@xmath0 , respectively ) , consistent with the overall higher velocities and dispersions of the emission - line knots in ngc 1068 . the [ o iii ] lines in ngc 1068 are blended together in their wings , and we deblended the two lines by taking the @xmath25007 profile , reproducing it at the position of the @xmath24959 line , scaling it by one - third ( the ratio of the transition probabilities of the two lines ) , subtracting it from the blend , and repeating the process in an iterative fashion . to simulate low - resolution ground - based spectra at at @xmath241000 , we convolved the unsmoothed spectra with a gaussian with a @xmath28 500 km s@xmath0 ( representing the line - spread function ) and rebinned them to one - half of a resolution element . these `` low - resolution spectra '' are also shown in figures 4 and 5 . the [ o iii ] profiles in figures 4 and 5 are clearly asymmetric , with more flux in the blue sides of the profiles . to quantify the velocity offsets , we measured the velocity centroid of the [ o iii ] @xmath25007 line ( averaged over the entire profile ) and its velocity peak ( defined as the centroid averaged over the top 15% of the [ o iii ] line ) . in table 1 , we give the heliocentric velocities from the h i 21-cm emission , the stellar absorption lines , and the [ o iii ] measurements described above , as well as the velocity offsets relative to the h i 21-cm velocity . from table 1 , it is clear that the h i 21-cm emission and the stellar absorption features give the same heliocentric velocities , to within the measurement errors of @xmath510 km s@xmath0 . this gives us confidence that the systemic velocities of the host galaxies are well established . for the [ o iii ] measurements , the velocity centroids are the same to within the errors in both high and low resolution spectra for each galaxy , whereas the velocity peaks are discrepant , particularly for ngc 1068 . thus , it is clear that the velocity centroids provide a much more reliable measure of the velocity offsets . this would be especially true for lower signal - to - noise spectra , where random variations could alter the location of the peak emission significantly . looking at the high resolution spectra , the velocity centroids of the [ o iii ] emission are blueshifted by @xmath4160 km s@xmath0 in ngc 1068 and @xmath460 km s@xmath0 in ngc 4151 . these fall inside of the range of values for seyfert galaxies shown in figure 1 , and are what we consider to be significant offsets ( @xmath30 km s@xmath0 ) . interestingly , the velocity offset for ngc 1068 , a seyfert 2 , is greater in magnitude than that for ngc 4151 , a seyfert 1 galaxy . this is likely due to a combination of higher velocities and higher extinction in ngc 1068 ( das et al . 2006 , 2006 ) , which we discuss further in the next section . to investigate the nature of extinction in the nlr , we first review our previous studies using _ long - slit , low - resolution ( @xmath31 1000 ) uv and optical spectra of ngc 1068 ( kraemer & crenshaw 2000 ) and ngc 4151 ( kraemer et al . 2000 ) . the reddening of the narrow emission lines in these seyferts , based on the he ii @xmath21640/@xmath24686 ratio , varies between @xmath32 0.1 and 0.5 in a nonuniform fashion across their nlrs . based on our photoionization models , the reddening can not come primarily from dust in the ionized gas , because the nlr clouds contains either no dust or a reduced dust fraction ( between 10% and 50% ) compared to the normal dust / gas ratio in the local ism of our galaxy ; otherwise , lines from the refractory elements ( such as mg , si , and fe ) would be much weaker than observed , and ly@xmath33 emission would be quenched , due to multiple resonant scatterings and eventual absorption by dust grains . even the nlr clouds with a 50% dust fraction can not produce the observed reddening , since they have a hydrogen column @xmath34 @xmath35 , which would produce a reddening of @xmath36 0.1 ( assuming the galactic reddening law of savage & mathis 1979 and @xmath37 @xmath35 from shull & van steenberg 1985 ) . thus , the reddening is likely produced in patchy dust that is external to the nlr clouds . circumnuclear dust spirals seen in the inner disks of most seyfert galaxies ( malkan , gorjian , & tam 1998 ; regan & mulchaey 1999 ; pogge & martini 2002 , martini et al . 2003 ; deo et al . 2006 ) are the likely source of the reddening ; they extend over the same scales as the nlr ( hundreds of parsecs ) and the dust spirals would provide the observed patchiness . to investigate the effects of extinction on mass outflows in the nlr , we therefore assume that the reddening arises from dust in the inner disk of the host galaxy . in order to determine the three - dimensional geometry of the outflows and extinction , we combined our parameters from the biconical outflow models with the observed parameters of the host galaxy disks . in table 2 , we give the five required parameters from das et al . ( 2005 , 2006 ) : the position angle ( p.a . ) of the galaxy s major axis , the inclination ( @xmath38 ) of the galactic disk ( zero corresponds to face - on ) , the p.a . of the bicone axis , the inclination of the bicone axis ( zero is in the plane of the sky ) , and the half - opening angle ( h.o.a . ) of the outer edge of the bicone . for the inclinations , we also indicate which side of the structure is closest to us . in figure 6 , we show the geometry of the biconical outflow and the host galaxy disk for ngc 1068 and ngc 4151 . for simplicity , we depict the midplane of the galaxy and the outer surface of the bicone , even though the bicone extends to an inner opening angle in our kinematic models . the left - hand side shows the view from earth , and the right - hand side shows a viewpoint in which the bicone axis is in the plane of the sky and the galactic disk is edge - on , to show the true angle between the bicone and the disk ( see the figure captions for more details ) . the parallel lines on either side of the galactic midplane show the dust scale height if we assume a typical value of @xmath5200 pc for spiral galaxies ( xilouris et al . 1999 ) and a length of @xmath5800 pc for each bicone along its axis ( das et al . 2005 , 2006 ) . in the case of ngc 1068 , the sw side of the galaxy is closer to us , and the sw cone therefore experiences more extinction . this is consistent with the [ o iii ] image in figure 2 , which shows weaker , and in some place absent , emission sw of the location of the smbh , which is 015 south of the `` hot spot '' in figure 2 ( das et al . the bicone axis lies nearly in the plane of the sky and the nearer side of each cone is blueshifted , whereas the farther side of each cone is redshifted . because the disk has a finite thickness , the blueshifted side of each cone in ngc 1068 experiences less extinction , on average , than the redshifted side of each cone . in the case of ngc 4151 , the sw cone is entirely blueshifted and the ne cone is entirely redshifted . the host galaxy disk is close to the plane of the sky , and the sw cone shows less extinction than the ne cone shows . thus , both geometries lead to emission - line profiles that are asymmetric to the blue , in agreement with the observed profiles . to determine if this explanation makes quantitative sense , we can look at the asymmetry of the emission - line profiles , and ask if there is enough dust in the inner galactic disks to produce the asymmetries . for simplicity , let us assume that the blue wings of the profiles are not affected by extinction and that the red wings are affected by a simple screen . in this case , the ratios of blue - to - red wing fluxes for [ o iii ] @xmath25007 are 1.59 for ngc 1068 and 1.10 for ngc 4151 , which yield extinctions in the v - band of @xmath39 0.5 mag and 0.1 mag , respectively . these are likely underestimates of the total extinction because the blue wings are almost certainly affected by extinction as well , as discussed above . from a study of spiral galaxy disks , xilouris et al . ( 1999 ) found that the central extinctions ranged from @xmath39 0.3 mag to 0.8 mag . in a study of nuclear dust spirals , martini & pogge ( 1999 ) determined color excesses between arm and interarm regions that correspond to extinctions in the range @xmath39 0.4 mag to 1.4 mag , assuming a standard galactic reddening curve ( savage & mathis 1979 ) . our stis spectra yield reddening values from the he ii @xmath21640/@xmath24686 line ratio that correspond to @xmath39 0.3 mag to 1.5 mag ( kraemer & crenshaw 2000 ; kraemer et al . thus , based on the above simple calculation , there is sufficient dust in the inner galactic disk to account for the differences in observed flux between the red and blue wings of the profiles . are there cases where a combination of outflows and extinction can lead to a redshifted emission line ? the answer is yes . in figure 7 , we show a test case , based on the parameters listed in table 2 . in this extreme case , the position angle and inclination of the galactic disk are such that the blueshifted cone in the south is entirely occulted by the disk and the redshifted cone in the north is not . to investigate this issue further , we ran a simulation for every possible combination of disk inclination , bicone inclination , and difference in position angle in 1 intervals , weighted by the probability of observing a disk or bicone at a particular inclination ( @xmath40 sin @xmath38 ) . assuming a random distribution of these parameters , we find that the percentage of the total population that shows more extinction of the redshifted portion of the bicone than the blueshifted portion is 17.2% , 16.7% , 15.6% , and 13.7% for half - opening angles of the bicone of 30 , 40 , 50 , and 60 , respectively . thus , this model can explain the relatively small number of seyfert galaxies that show redshifted emission lines . however , the above percentages can not be directly compared to the observed values because the observational errors do not allow us to determine the fraction of seyferts that have redshifted velocities between 0 and 50 km s@xmath0 . ideally , one could attempt to match the distribution in figure 1 by generating emission line profiles from more realistic models that include thick disks and bicones , a proper treatment of the dust extinction as a function of position , realistic velocities and dispersions as a function of position , and a more sophisticated error model , but that type of simulation is beyond the scope of this paper . we find that @xmath540% of seyfert galaxies show radial velocity offsets @xmath41 50 km s@xmath0 between their narrow emission lines and host galaxy lines . the distribution of offsets peaks near zero km s@xmath0 , but has a strong blue tail extending up to @xmath5 @xmath4250 km s@xmath0 ; only @xmath56% of the seyferts in the sample show significantly redshifted emission lines , up to 100 km s@xmath0 . the seyfert 1 distribution is shifted to higher blueshifts on average . to investigate the nature of the velocity offsets , we relied on our previous investigations into the reddening , physical conditions , and kinematics of the nlrs in ngc 1068 ( seyfert 2 ) and ngc 4151 ( seyfert 1 ) , which were based on spatially resolved _ hst_/stis spectra and phototionization and kinematic models . the parameters from these studies allowed us to generate geometric models of the biconical outflow in the nlr and extinction by dust in the inner galactic disk . we also collapsed the high - resolution _ hst_/stis spectra obtained at multiple slit locations to simulate ground - based observations . the resulting [ o iii ] emission - line profiles are asymmetric to the blue and have blue - shifted centroids , which can be attributed to preferential extinction of the redshifted clouds in the geometric models of these two seyferts . it is clear from the above examples that models that incorporate biconical outflow and extinction by the inner galactic disk are more likely to produce blueshifted velocity centroids than redshifted ones , because the blueshifted clouds are closer to the observer and less likely to be extincted in most cases . however , we have shown that redshifted velocity centroids are possible in certain cases , for example when the disk is highly inclined and covers most of the near cone . furthermore , one would expect from these models that more seyfert 1s would show blueshifts than seyfert 2s , because the near cone would be pointed more directly at us and therefore less extincted on average . all of these features of the geometric models are in agreement with the observed velocity offsets . however , we note that the [ o iii ] emission in ngc 1068 shows a higher blueshift than that in ngc 4151 , which indicates that individual variations in velocities and extinctions of the nlr clouds amongst agn are important in determining the overall distribution in velocity offsets . we conclude that the velocity offsets of emission lines in low-@xmath42 seyfert galaxies are primarily due to a combination of radial outflow in their nlrs and extinction by dust on the same size scale as their nlrs . more exotic explanations are not required . furthermore , we find that the dust responsible for the extinction must be primarily exterior to the ionized gas . the dust features seen in the inner kpc of seyfert galaxies , mostly in the form of dust spirals ( martini et al . 2003 , and references therein ) , are the likely culprits . as we have already noted , the bumps and peaks in the emission - line profiles are due to large bright knots of emission - line gas traveling at their own peculiar velocities , on top of the general outflow pattern . thus , another contributor to the velocity offsets could be an uneven distribution of knots in velocity space in an agn , resulting in more ( or brighter ) blueshifted knots than redshifted ones , or vice - versa . this effect alone , however , will not lead to an asymmetric distribution of velocity offsets . it is instructive to compare the distributions of velocity offsets between narrow emission and stellar absorption lines in the low @xmath42 ( @xmath43 0.043 , nelson & whittle 1995 ) and moderate @xmath42 ( 0.34 @xmath6 0.92 , comerford et al . 2009 ) samples . the magnitudes of the velocity offsets in the two distributions are essentially the same , and they have a similar percentage of `` significant '' ( @xmath15 50 km s@xmath0 ) offsets ( 41% at low @xmath42 , 35% at moderate @xmath42 ) . however , the distribution for the moderate @xmath42 sample is roughly symmetric around zero km s@xmath0 , which is surprising , because these agn are likely to have outflows in their nlrs as well . in fact , comerford et al . use the symmetric distribution as a reason to disfavor the outflows plus dust explanation and favor the inspiralling black hole scenario . this , in turn , leads them to a merger fraction of @xmath530% for red galaxies at these redshifts , which is a surprising large number , particularly since these galaxies show no evidence for star formation . the nature of the comerford et al . ( 2009 ) sample provides a couple of possible explanations for a symmetric distribution of velocity offsets in the context of mass outflows . their sample contains only seyfert 2 galaxies that have been selected to have red host galaxies , to specifically avoid contamination from ionized gas around star - forming regions . the lack of significant star formation suggests a lack of dusty gas , and therefore a lack of extinction , in their nlrs . the velocity offsets would therefore be dominated by uneven distributions of emission - line knots in at least some of the agn , with no preference for blueshifted profiles . another possible explanation is that the red colors are due to highly inclined disk galaxies , which , as shown in figure 7 , will lead to a significant number of redshifts and a more symmetric distribution of velocity offsets . nevertheless , there is a local example of velocity ( and spatial ) offsets due to multiple agn in the nearby galaxy ngc 3341 ( barth et al . 2008 ) , and one might expect more of these at higher redshifts from galaxy mergers . however , the emission - line ratios in ngc 3341 indicate significant star formation , as might be expected from mergers , and if it was at the appropriate redshift , ngc 3341 would have not been included in the comerford et al . sample . both the low-@xmath42 and moderate-@xmath42 samples are rather small ; larger sample would be helpful in clarifying the role that mergers might play in producing velocity offsets . finally , we note that ground - based spectra of local seyfert galaxies , particularly those obtained at high spectral resolution ( vrtilek & carleton 1985 ; veilleux 1991b ; nelson & whittle 1995 ) , show a wide variety of narrow emission - line profiles . the profiles are often very irregular in appearance , with bumps or shelves in their red or blue wings , and a number of them show multiple peaks , like those in ngc 1068 ( figure 4 ) , due to the contributions of distinct emission - line knots . of particular interest is the [ o iii ] profile of mrk 78 ( vrtilek & carleton 1985 ; whittle et al . 1988 ; nelson & whittle 1995 ) , which shows two large well - defined peaks separated by @xmath5800 km s@xmath0 , and yet there is no evidence for displaced or double smbhs in mrk 78 . this velocity separation is actually larger than those in the two `` dual agn '' of comerford et al . ( 2009 ) , which show velocity separations between double - peak profiles of 630 km s@xmath0 and 440 km s@xmath0 . thus , even these double - peaked agn may not require the presence of double smbhs . this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration . this research has made use of nasa s astrophysics data system bibliographic services . cccccc + 1137@xmath293@xmath44 & 1149@xmath298@xmath45 & 974@xmath297 & 1128@xmath295 & 962@xmath298 & 988@xmath297 + @xmath14 & 12@xmath29 9 & @xmath4163@xmath298 & @xmath49@xmath296 & @xmath4175@xmath299 & @xmath4149@xmath298 + + + 995@xmath293@xmath46 & 1006@xmath2918@xmath45 & 935@xmath295 & 998@xmath294 & 926@xmath293 & 981@xmath294 + @xmath14 & 11@xmath2918 & @xmath460@xmath296 & 3@xmath295 & @xmath469@xmath294 & @xmath414@xmath295

we present a study of the radial velocity offsets between narrow emission lines and host galaxy lines ( stellar absorption and h i 21-cm emission ) in seyfert galaxies with observed redshifts less than 0.043 . we find that 35% of the seyferts in the sample show [ o iii ] emission lines with blueshifts with respect to their host galaxies exceeding 50 km s@xmath0 , whereas only 6% show redshifts this large , in qualitative agreement with most previous studies . we also find that a greater percentage of seyfert 1 galaxies show blueshifts than seyfert 2 galaxies . using _ spatially - resolved spectra of the seyfert 2 galaxy ngc 1068 and the seyfert 1 galaxy ngc 4151 , we generate geometric models of their narrow - line regions ( nlrs ) and inner galactic disks , and show how these models can explain the blueshifted [ o iii ] emission lines in collapsed stis spectra of these two seyferts . we conclude that the combination of mass outflow of ionized gas in the nlr and extinction by dust in the inner disk ( primarily in the form of dust spirals ) is primarily responsible for the velocity offsets in seyfert galaxies . more exotic explanations are not needed . we discuss the implications of this result for the velocity offsets found in higher redshift agn .

1509.00645

with the rapid growth in demand for higher data rates , wireless technology is shifting towards the systems with multiple antennas . multiple - input multiple - output ( mimo ) systems in wireless communications provide significant improvements in wireless link reliability and the achievable capacity @xcite . recently , the systems with large number of antennas ( tens to hundreds of antennas ) called as _ large - mimo _ systems are getting increased attention @xcite because they provide additional multiplexing and diversity gains . using spatial multiplexing in mimo systems , multiple data streams can be transmitted simultaneously from different transmit antennas . however , the detection of these data streams at the receiver end is challenging . to achieve minimum bit error rate ( ber ) performance in mimo systems , an exhaustive search over all the possible transmit vectors is required . this is called as the maximum likelihood ( ml ) search for symbol vector detection in mimo systems . however , as the number of antennas grow , the number of possible transmit vectors also increases exponentially and thus the ml search becomes computationally impractical . sphere decoder , a well known mimo detector achieves near ml performance but is practical only up to limited number of dimensions @xcite . + the traditional mimo detection techniques involve linear detection such as zero forcing ( zf ) detector and minimum mean squared error ( mmse ) detector . these detectors use linear transformation of the received vector in order to estimate the transmitted symbol vector . comparatively the mmse detector is superior over zf detector in terms of ber performance , but still their performance is far inferior compared to the ml performance . another type of detection involve non - linear detectors such as vertical bell labs layered space time architecture ( v - blast ) @xcite which utilizes ordered sic for symbol vector detection . some of the other mimo detection technique involve ant colony optimization based mimo detection @xcite , message passing based algorithm @xcite , channel hardening based algorithm @xcite , and lattice reduction aided mimo detection @xcite . as an alternative , in this study we employ sic based detection technique for mimo detection problem . + sic based mimo detection is a well known detection technique where symbols are detected sequentially @xcite . in sic , after detecting each symbol , its interference is canceled from the received vector in order to improve the instantaneous signal to interference plus noise ratio ( sinr ) for the remaining symbols . it is also known as layered detection where in each layer , one symbol is detected . however , it suffers from error propagation which occur due to wrong decisions in early stages of the algorithm @xcite . for improving the performance of sic , a well known technique known as v - blast @xcite technique is used which performs the following steps : ( 1 ) snr based ordering in the detection sequence , ( 2 ) using zf or mmse for nulling the interference among the data streams and ( 3 ) detecting a symbol and canceling its interference i.e. sic . further , to mitigate the effect of error propagation , one of the available algorithms in the literature include multi - branch sic ( mb - sic ) algorithm @xcite where the concept of multiple branch ( mb ) processing is utilized . each branch of mb - sic differs in ordering of the detection sequence thus resulting in a higher detection diversity over the conventional sic . recently , a multiple feedback ( mf ) strategy is proposed in @xcite for sic based mimo detection . multiple feedback sic ( mf - sic ) algorithm proposed in @xcite is based on the concept of shadow are constraint ( sac ) where if the decision fall in the shadow region ( unreliability region ) then multiple constellation points are used in the decision feedback loop . the best symbol from the multiple symbols used in the decision feedback is selected using the ml criteria . + in this article , we propose an improved multiple feedback successive interference cancellation ( imf - sic ) for symbol vector detection in mimo spatial multiplexing systems . in mf - sic , once a decision falls into the shadow region , conventional sic is used to find the best one symbol for the corresponding layer . however , it may happen that while computing the best symbol for a given layer , multiple decisions from the subsequent layers fall into the shadow region . this condition is not checked in mf - sic which sometimes results in error propagation and limits the ber performance . in improved mf - sic ( imf - sic ) , we overcome this limitation by checking the shadow region criteria recursively rather than using the conventional sic for searching the best candidate symbol . this results in significant reduction in error propagation and thus the ber performance can be improved . also , we propose an ordered imf - sic ( oimf - sic ) algorithm where we employ the log likelihood ratio ( llr ) based dynamic ordering in the detection sequence @xcite . by the term dynamic ordering we mean that after every successful decision about a symbol , the ordering of the detection sequence is updated based on new llr values . in oimf - sic , same ordering pattern is followed even for searching the best symbol when a decision is found unreliable . simulation results show that the proposed algorithms significantly outperform the conventional sic and the mf - sic based detection methods , and that they achieve a near ml performance . + rest of the article is organized as follows . in sect . [ sec2 ] , we present mathematical model of mimo system . an overview of some of the traditional mimo detection methods is given in sect . the proposed algorithms for symbol vector detection in mimo spatial multiplexing systems is discussed in sect . [ sec4 ] . in sect . [ sec5 ] , we show the simulation results on comparison of ber performance . finally , in sect . [ sec6 ] we conclude the article . in this section , we discuss the mathematical model of mimo system as shown in fig.[figs1 ] . we consider a point to point spatially multiplexed mimo link with @xmath0 transmit antennas and @xmath1 receive antennas . in spatial multiplexing , each antenna transmits a different information symbol @xmath2 for @xmath3 . let @xmath4^t$ ] be the @xmath5 dimensional transmit vector , @xmath6^t$ ] denote the transpose of a matrix . each entry @xmath2 of the transmit vector @xmath7 is taken from a signal constellation @xmath8 , for example @xmath9 for 4-qam signaling . the channel over which the symbol vector @xmath7 is transmitted is assumed to be a rayleigh distributed flat fading channel . let us consider an @xmath10 complex channel matrix @xmath11 with its elements @xmath12 for @xmath13 and @xmath14 assumed to be independent and identically distributed ( i.i.d . ) as complex normal with mean 0 and variance 1 i.e. @xmath15 . the received symbol vector @xmath16 , after demodulation and matched filtering can be written as @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the additive white gaussian noise ( awgn ) with its element @xmath19 for @xmath13 as i.i.d . the signal to noise ratio ( snr ) is defined as @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the average energy per symbol defined as @xmath23)$ ] and @xmath24 is the element - wise noise variance . tr(@xmath25 ) denote the trace of a matrix , @xmath26 $ ] denote the expectation operation and @xmath27 denote the hermitian of a matrix . the channel state information ( csi ) is assumed to be perfectly known at the receiver but is unknown at the transmitter . the ml solution for a given received vector @xmath16 and a known channel matrix @xmath11 can be found as @xmath28 ml detection ( mld ) requires an exhaustive search over @xmath29 possible transmit symbol vectors where @xmath30 is cardinality of the constellation set @xmath8 . this search grows exponentially with increase in the modulation order ( @xmath30 ) or increase in the number of transmit antennas ( @xmath0 ) or both . in this section , we discuss some of the traditional mimo detection techniques such as linear detection techniques which involve zero forcing ( zf ) based mimo detection and minimum mean squared error ( mmse ) based mimo detection , and nonlinear detection techniques such as sic based mimo detection . in zf based mimo detection , a linear transformation matrix @xmath31 is used in such a way that it removes the effect due to the channel impairments on the received vector @xmath16 i.e. @xmath32 which is the pseudo inverse of channel matrix @xmath11 . the linear transformation of the received vector using @xmath31 can be written as @xmath33 thus the zf estimate of the transmitted symbol can be found as @xmath34,\ ] ] where @xmath35 $ ] is the quantization operation which maps the soft values on to the nearest constellation point . the computational complexity of zf receiver is very less , however the ber performance is far inferior to the ml performance . the main drawback of zf based mimo detection is the problem of noise enhancement which degrades its performance . mmse based mimo detection is based on finding a suitable linear transformation matrix which minimizes the mean squared error between the transmit vector @xmath36 and the transformed received vector as @xmath37.\ ] ] the solution to eq . [ eq5 ] can be written as @xmath38 using the transformation matrix @xmath39 , the mmse solution can then be computed as @xmath40.\ ] ] mmse based mimo detection overcomes the problem of noise enhancement in zf detectors . thus it achieves better ber performance over zf but still the performance of mmse receiver is inferior as compared to the ml performance . one more drawback is that the mmse solution needs knowledge of the noise variance @xmath24 . in sic based mimo detection , the symbols transmitted from different transmit antennas are detected in a sequential manner . after detecting a symbol for a particular transmit antenna , its interference is canceled from the received vector in order to reduce the interference between different data streams at the receiver . the received vector in eq . [ eq1 ] can be rewritten as @xmath41 using the knowledge of channel matrix @xmath11 a filter @xmath42 is defined as @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the matrix with its column taken from the @xmath45 to @xmath0 columns of the channel matrix @xmath11 . we use vector @xmath46 as the vector left after removing the interference due to @xmath47 as @xmath48 using @xmath42 , the first symbol @xmath2 is estimated as @xmath49=\mathcal{q}[\mathbf{w}_i^h\mathbf{y}_i],\ ] ] where @xmath50 is estimate of the transmitted symbol @xmath2 . @xmath42 , @xmath51 and @xmath46 are updated after every successful decision about a symbol . sic is an iterative detection technique , where in every iteration one symbol is detected . thus a total of @xmath0 iterations are performed to detect the complete symbol vector . a pseudo code of sic based mimo detection is given in algorithm [ algo1 ] . ; ; compute @xmath52 @xmath53 @xmath54 $ ] update @xmath55 update @xmath56 $ ] however , sic suffers from the problem of error propagation which occurs due to the wrong decisions in early stage of the algorithm . once an error occurs , it propagates to the later stages and thus increases the number of errors . this degrades the ber performance of sic based mimo detection . in this section , first we discuss the mf - sic based algorithm for symbol vector detection in mimo systems . we will then discuss the imf - sic algorithm and oimf - sic algorithm . the conventional sic suffers from the problem of error propagation which degrades the ber performance . as a solution to mitigate the effect of error propagation , mf strategy has been proposed in @xcite for sic based mimo detection . the mf strategy is based on the concept of reliability of a soft decision in sic . let us consider the @xmath57 soft decision within sic as @xmath58 the constellation point near to the soft decision @xmath59 is nothing but its quantized value i.e. @xmath60 $ ] . let us define the distance between the soft decision and its quantized value as @xmath61\vert\ ] ] if the soft decision in sic is within a predefined threshold radius @xmath62 ( i.e. if @xmath63 ) around the nearest constellation point then the decision is said to be reliable and its quantized value is used in the decision feedback . but if the decision is not within the radius ( if @xmath64 ) then multiple neighboring ( say @xmath65 ) constellation points are used instead of the quantized value followed by the conventional sic . it can be thought of as running parallel streams one for each symbol and at last the best one is selected using the ml metric ( eq . [ eq2 ] ) . mf - sic performs superior than the conventional sic in terms of ber . a pseudo code of mf - sic is shown in algorithm [ algo2 ] ; ; compute @xmath52 @xmath53 @xmath66\vert$ ] @xmath54 $ ] @xmath67 i.e. initialize by @xmath68 neighborhood of @xmath69 @xmath70 @xmath71 $ ] update @xmath72 update @xmath73 $ ] compute the solution vector @xmath74 @xmath75 @xmath76 update @xmath55 update @xmath56 $ ] in imf - sic , we propose an improved mf strategy for sic based symbol vector detection in mimo spatial multiplexing systems . in mf - sic algorithm @xcite , multiple feedback loops are followed by the conventional sic to check for the optimal decision for a particular layer . however , while searching for the optimal decision , the shadow region ( unreliability ) criteria is not considered in the lower layers and hence there are chances of selecting a sub - optimal decision about a symbol which degrades the ber performance . in order to improve the accuracy about a decision among multiple symbols in the feedback loop , we check the shadow region criteria recursively in imf - sic algorithm . we therefore formulate a separate sub - routine ( function ) named as imf_sic in algorithm [ algo3 ] which checks the unreliability condition and optimally decide the symbol . sub - routine imf_sic is called from the main function which is given in algorithm [ algo4 ] and also from the sub - routine itself . we denote the number of calls of the sub - routine by @xmath77 in imf - sic algorithm which is nothing but the number of times unreliability condition is checked once a decision falls into the shadow region . the number of neighboring symbol which are used in the decision feedback is denoted by @xmath65 . + ; ; compute @xmath52 @xmath53 @xmath66\vert$ ] @xmath54 $ ] @xmath78 imf_sic(@xmath79 ) update @xmath55 update @xmath56 $ ] function [ @xmath50]=imf_sic(@xmath79 ) @xmath67 i.e. initialize by @xmath68 neighborhood of @xmath69 @xmath54 $ ] @xmath78 imf_sic(@xmath81 ) update @xmath72 update @xmath73 $ ] compute the solution vector @xmath74 @xmath75 @xmath76 return @xmath50 significant reduction in the effect of error propagation is noticed using imf - sic ( discussed in sect . [ sec5 ] ) which results in improvement in the ber performance over sic and the mf - sic . however , imf - sic does not include ordering in the detection sequence which plays a very important role in mitigating error propagation in sic based detection techniques . in the next section , we discuss ordered imf - sic ( oimf - sic ) algorithm for mimo detection . in this section , we propose an ordered imf - sic ( oimf - sic ) algorithm which incorporates the llr based ordering in the detection sequence . error propagation can be mitigated successfully if the decisions in the early layers of sic are detected correctly . in several sic based detection algorithms , channel norm ordering is used such as in v - blast technique @xcite . however , channel norm ordering does not consider the instantaneous noise in the received vector which has a significant impact on the ber performance . thus a log likelihood ratio based ordering for multi - user detection in cdma systems @xcite has been proposed in @xcite for mf - sic based mimo detection to overcome the sub - optimal behavior of channel norm based ordering . we employ llr based dynamic ordering in the imf - sic algorithm to order the detection sequence . the term dynamic ordering is used in the sense that the ordering is updated after every successful symbol decision . however , the modification in the proposed method is that the ordering is also used in the oimf_sic sub - routine which help in a more precise decision . the llr value of a soft estimate @xmath82 can be written as @xcite @xmath83 where @xmath84 . the value of the argument @xmath85 which maximizes @xmath86 is arranged in descending order . let us consider a set @xmath87 be the set of indices of the symbols which are not detected so far . the set @xmath87 is updated after every successful decision . for ordering the detection sequence in every iteration we consider the indices which are in the set @xmath87 i.e. in eq . [ eq14 ] @xmath88 . let us also consider the ordered sequence @xmath89 which is updated in every iteration . in algorithm [ algo5 ] , we present the oimf - sic algorithm for mimo detection . ; compute @xmath90 @xmath91 compute @xmath92 using the equation [ eq14 ] arrange the values @xmath93 in descending order update the detection order @xmath89 start detection using imf - sic given in algorithm [ algo3]with ordered sequence @xmath89 . in this section , we discuss the ber performance plots of the proposed algorithms and compare with the performance of the conventional sic and the mf - sic algorithm for @xmath94 , @xmath95 and @xmath96 mimo systems with 4-qam and 16-qam signaling . the results are generated using matlab and the ber is averaged over @xmath97 monte - carlo simulations . + in fig . [ figs2 ] , we compare the ber performance of the conventional sic and mf - sic with the proposed algorithms for @xmath94 mimo system with 4-qam . the value of threshold parameter @xmath62 used is 0.2 and the number of recursions @xmath98 . observation reveals that the proposed algorithms achieve a near ml performance and also the performance of imf - sic and oimf - sic algorithms is similar in terms of ber performance . at ber of @xmath99 , imf - sic results in approximately 1 db gain in snr over mf - sic . in fig . [ figs3 ] , the ber performance is compared for @xmath95 mimo system with 4-qam . a significant improvement in the ber performance of imf - sic and oimf - sic can be seen over sic and mf - sic based mimo detection techniques . an snr gain of around 2 db can be achieved by using imf - sic over mf - sic to achieve a target ber @xmath100 . due to near optimal performance of imf - sic for @xmath94 and @xmath95 mimo systems with 4-qam the advantage of dynamic ordering can not be observed . however , with increase in number of antennas or the modulation order , ordering plays an important role in mitigating the error propagation . [ figs4 ] presents the ber performance comparison for @xmath96 v - blast mimo system with 4-qam . a significant improvement in the performance of oimf - sic can be seen when compared with imf - sic for @xmath98 . however , to achieve the near ml performance the number of recursions are increased to @xmath101 and @xmath102 for oimf - sic . thus , the effect of increase in number of recursions on the ber performance can be observed . + v - blast mimo system with 4-qam and the value used for @xmath103 , @xmath104 and @xmath105.,width=9,height=10 ] v - blast mimo system with 4-qam and the value used for @xmath103 , @xmath104 and @xmath105.,width=9,height=10 ] v - blast mimo system with 4-qam.,width=9,height=10 ] the ber performance for @xmath94 and @xmath95 v - blast mimo systems with 16-qam signaling is shown in figs . [ figs5 ] and [ figs6 ] . in 16-qam the total number of constellation points is 16 and hence in order to get a reliable decision , we keep the number of neighboring contellation point in the feedback as @xmath106 . the threshold value @xmath62 is kept same i.e. @xmath103 . it can be observed that the ber performance of oimf - sic is close to within the 0.1 db of the ml performance . ordering in imf - sic results in almost 1 db gain in snr over the imf - sic without ordering . however , in fig . [ figs6 ] , to achieve the ber close to ml , the number of recursions is increased to @xmath101 in oimf - sic . this shows a snr gain of more than 2 db over imf - sic at a target ber @xmath99 . v - blast mimo system with 16-qam and the value used for @xmath103 , @xmath104 and @xmath107.,width=9,height=10 ] v - blast mimo system with 16-qam.,width=9,height=10 ] we proposed an improved multiple feedback successive interference cancellation ( imf - sic ) algorithm for symbol vector detection in mimo systems . we also proposed an ordered imf - sic ( oimf - sic ) algorithm which employs log likelihood ratio ( llr ) based dynamic ordering in the detection sequence . the ordering of the detection sequence is updated after every successful decision and thus the effect of error propagation is mitigated . the proposed algorithms significantly improves the ber performance and outperform the conventional sic algorithm and the mf - sic algorithm , and achieve near ml performance . the authors would like to thank iit indore and ministry of human resource development ( mhrd ) india for their support . p. w. wolniansky , g. j. foschini , g. d. golden , and r. a. valenzuela , `` v - blast : an architecture for realizing very high data rates over the rich - scattering wireless channel , '' _ international symposium on signals , systems , and electronics _ 295 - 300 , 1998 . t. lakshmi narasimhan and a. chockalingam , `` channel hardening - exploiting message passing ( chemp ) receiver in large - scale mimo systems , '' _ ieee jrnl . on sel . topics in signal proc . : special issue on signal processing for large - scale mimo communications _ , vol . 847 - 860 , 2014 . k. a. singhal , t. datta , and a. chockalingam , `` lattice reduction aided detection in large - mimo systems , '' _ ieee 14th workshop on signal processing advances in wireless commun . ( spawc ) _ , pp . 594 - 598 , 2013 . g. golden , c. foschini , r. valenzuela , and p. wolniansky , `` detection algorithm and initial laboratory results using v - blast space - time communication architecture , '' _ electronics letters _ 1 , pp . 14 , 1999 . r. fa and r. c. de lamare , `` multi - branch successive interference cancellation for mimo spatial multiplexing systems : design , analysis and adaptive implementation , '' _ iet commun . _ , vol . 5 , no . 484 - 494 , 2009 . p. li , r. c. de lamare , and r. fa , `` multiple feedback successive interference cancellation detection for multiuser mimo systems , '' _ ieee trans . on wirel . 10 , no . 8 , pp . 2434 - 2439 , 2011 . l. yang , `` receiver multiuser diversity aided multi - stage mmse multiuser detection for ds - cdma and sdma systems employing i - q modulation , '' in _ veh . fall ( vtc 2010-fall ) , 2010 ieee 72nd _ ieee , pp . 1 - 5 , 2010 . t. hesketh , p. li , r. c. de lamare , and s. wales , `` multi - feedback successive interference cancellation with dynamic lo - likelihood - ratio based reliability ordering , '' in _ proc . of the tenth international symposium on wirel . systems ( iswcs 2013 ) _ ieee , pp . 1 - 5 , 2013 .

in this article , we propose an improved multiple feedback successive interference cancellation ( imf - sic ) algorithm for symbol vector detection in multiple - input multiple - output ( mimo ) spatial multiplexing systems . the multiple feedback ( mf ) strategy in successive interference cancellation ( sic ) is based on the concept of shadow area constraint ( sac ) where , if the decision falls in the shadow region multiple neighboring constellation points will be used in the decision feedback loop followed by the conventional sic . the best candidate symbol from multiple neighboring symbols is selected using the maximum likelihood ( ml ) criteria . however , while deciding the best symbol from multiple neighboring symbols , the sac condition may occur in subsequent layers which results in inaccurate decision . in order to overcome this limitation , in the proposed algorithm , sac criteria is checked recursively for each layer . this results in successful mitigation of error propagation thus significantly improving the bit error rate ( ber ) performance . further , we also propose an ordered imf - sic ( oimf - sic ) where we use log likelihood ratio ( llr ) based dynamic ordering of the detection sequence . in oimf - sic , we use the term dynamic ordering in the sense that the detection order is updated after every successful decision . simulation results show that the proposed algorithms outperform the existing detectors such as conventional sic and mf - sic in terms of ber , and achieves a near ml performance . mimo detection , spatial multiplexing , decision feedback , successive interference cancellation , bit error rate .

astro-ph9805202

it is generally believed that galaxies are formed within the deep potential wells of the virialized dark matter ( dm ) halos and that clusters of galaxies are recently collapsed objects . the study of the physical properties of the dm halos in cosmological models therefore provides important clues to our understanding of the universe . in this letter , we report a fitting formula for the two - point correlation function @xmath11 of the dm halos in hierarchical clustering models . the accuracy of the fit is about @xmath12 in @xmath13 for a wide range of halo masses . the two - point correlation function of dm halos has been the subject of many recent attempts at analytical modelling ( e.g. cole & kaiser @xcite ; mann , heavens , & peacock @xcite ; mo & white @xcite , hereafter mw96 ; catelan et al . @xcite ; porciani et al . @xcite ) as well as of n - body simulation studies ( e.g. white et al . @xcite ; efstathiou et al . @xcite ; bahcall & cen @xcite ; jing et al . @xcite ; watanabe , matsubara , & suto @xcite ; gelb & bertschinger @xcite ; jing , brner , & valdarnini @xcite ; mw96 ; mo , jing , & white @xcite ) . in particular , using the extended press - schechter formalism to calculate the correlation function of dm halos in lagrangian space ( cf . cole & kaiser @xcite ) and mapping from lagrangian space to eulerian space within the context of the spherical collapse model , mw96 have derived an analytical expression for @xmath13 : [ linear ] _ hh(r;m)=b^2(m)_mm(r ) . this should hold in the linearly clustering regime where the mass two - point correlation function @xmath14 is less than unity . the bias parameter @xmath15 is [ bias ] b(m ) = 1+^2 - 1_c=1+_c ^2(m)-1_c , where @xmath16 is the linearly evolved rms density fluctuation of top - hat spheres containing on average a mass @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath19 ( see mw96 and references therein for more details about these quantities ) . the parameter @xmath20 will be called the peak height for convenience . equations ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) were found in good agreement with their n - body results by mw96 and by mo et al . ( @xcite ) , but their tests were limited to high mass halos with @xmath21 due to limited mass and force resolutions . the formula has been widely used : from modeling the correlation function of different types of galaxies ( e.g. , kauffmann et al . @xcite ; baugh et al . @xcite ) to interpreting the observed clustering of various extragalactic objects ( e.g. , mo et al . @xcite ; mo & fukugita @xcite ; matarrese et al . @xcite ; steidel et al . @xcite ; coles et al . @xcite ; fang & jing @xcite ) . we have measured the two - point correlation functions for the dm halos in a large set of high - resolution n - body simulations . each simulation uses @xmath4 particles , and a wide range of hierarchical models are covered : four scale - free models and three representative cdm models . moreover , each model is simulated with three to four different realizations , and two different box sizes are used for each cdm model . with these simulations of very high accuracy , we can determine @xmath22 for a wide range of the halo mass @xmath17 . as a result , we find that the linear bias ( eq . [ linear ] ) is a good approximation in the linearly clustering regime , but the bias parameter given by eq.([bias ] ) agrees with the n - body results only for massive halos with mass @xmath23 , where @xmath3 is a characteristic non - linear mass scale defined by @xmath24 . for the less massive halos , the n - body results imply significantly higher bias than the analytical prediction eq . ( 2 ) and the difference in the correlation amplitude amounts to a factor @xmath8 for @xmath25 . fortunately , the difference between the n - body results and the mw96 formula can be modeled by a simple fitting formula ( 3 ) . this formula can fit the simulation bias parameter for halo mass @xmath26 with an accuracy of about 5% . the new findings have profound implications for the formation of the large scale structures . one of the most interesting applications of the fitting formula would be the clustering of galaxies , since the local late type and dwarf galaxies are believed to have mass @xmath27 and to form recently ( redshift @xmath28 ; mo et al.@xcite ) while @xmath29 is expected for the present universe ( cf . the simulations will be described in section 2 , with emphasis on the aspects relevant to this letter . in section 3 , we will present the correlation function of the halos and the fitting formula . the implications for theories and observations are discussed in section 4 . the two - point correlation functions of halos are studied both for scale - free models and for representative cdm models of hierarchical clustering . in the scale - free models , a power - law power spectrum @xmath30 is used for the initial density fluctuation and the universe is assumed to be einstein de sitter , @xmath31 . four models with @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 , and @xmath35 are studied . because these models are conceptually simple and exhibit interesting scaling properties , it is relatively easy to understand how physical properties depend on the shape of the power spectrum and , perhaps more importantly , to distinguish the physical effects from numerical artifacts , since the latter should not in general obey the scaling relations . for this reason , we will extensively use the scaling property that the bias parameter @xmath36 depends only on the halo mass @xmath17 scaled by @xmath3 , i.e. @xmath37 for each @xmath5 . this scaling property manifests itself when the bias parameter for @xmath37 is plotted for different evolution times . each of our simulations for @xmath38 is evolved for 1000 time steps with a total of seven outputs , and that for @xmath39 is evolved for 1362 steps with eight outputs . the output time interval is chosen so that @xmath3 at each successive output is increased by a factor 2.5 , and the @xmath3 values ( in units of the particle mass ) at the first output are 74 , 59 , 35 , and 13 for @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 , and @xmath35 respectively . note that fixing the @xmath3 values is equivalent to fixing the normalization for the power spectra . the time step and the integration variables are taken similarly to efstathiou et al . ( @xcite ) . in this letter we will rely on these scale - free models to understand how the halo - halo correlation depends on the shape of the power spectrum . then we will examine whether the result obtained from the scale - free models can be applied to cdm models , since cdm models , at least variants thereof , are believed to be close to reality . three cdm models are very typical : one is the ( ever ) standard cdm model ( scdm ) , one is an open model with @xmath40 and with a vanishing cosmological constant @xmath41 ( ocdm ) , and the other is a flat lower density model with @xmath40 and @xmath42 ( lcdm ) . these cdm models are completely fixed with regard to the dm clustering if the initial density power spectrum is fixed . for our simulations , the linear cdm power spectrum of bardeen et al . ( @xcite ) for the primordial harrison - zeldovich spectrum is used for the initial condition , which is fixed by the shape parameter @xmath43 and the amplitude @xmath44 ( the rms top - hat density fluctuation on radius @xmath45 ) . the values of ( @xmath46 , @xmath44 ) are ( 0.5 , 0.62 ) for scdm , ( 0.25 , 1 ) for ocdm , and ( 0.20 , 1 ) for lcdm . each model is simulated with our vectorized @xmath47 code on the fujitsu vpp300/16r supercomputer at the national astronomical observatory of japan . each simulation is performed with @xmath4 ( @xmath48 million ) particles and with good force resolution @xmath49 ( where @xmath50 is the simulation box size ) . to properly understand the effect of the cosmic variance , three to four independent realizations are generated for each simulation of one model . furthermore , two different box sizes , @xmath51 and @xmath52 , are adopted for each cdm model . further details about the code and the simulations will be given in a forthcoming paper ( jing , in preparation ) , where many clustering statistics of the dark matter will also be presented . the cdm simulations with box size @xmath51 were used by jing & suto ( @xcite ) to study the constraints on cosmological models of the high concentration of the lyman break galaxies at redshift @xmath53 discovered by steidel et al . the dm halos are identified with the friends - of - friends ( fof ) algorithm with a linking parameter @xmath54 times the mean particle separation . the halos with at least 20 members are used for the clustering analysis . it is known that the mass defined by the members of such fof groups is very close to that defined by the spherical overdensity ( so ) virialization ( cole & lacey @xcite ) and that the mass function of such fof groups follows the predictions of the ps formalism ( e.g. lacey & cole @xcite ; mo et al . more importantly , the correlation function of dm halos is quite robust to reasonable halo identification methods , since , for example , the correlation function of the fof groups is statistically indistinguishable from that of the so groups ( mo et al . @xcite ) . therefore , it would suffice to use the fof groups for the present purpose . the first concern of this work is whether the bias of the halos is linear ( eq . [ linear ] ) in the linearly clustering regime . we have calculated the ratio of @xmath11 to @xmath55 for every simulation output . some examples which are also typical are shown in figure [ fig1 ] , which show the ratio at two different outputs of the @xmath56 simulation for three different halo masses . the results are plotted only for the linear clustering regime i.e. @xmath57 , as only this regime is considered here . error bars are calculated by averaging over the different realizations . it is remarkable that the ratio is a constant within the @xmath58 error bars , i.e. the bias is linear and the bias parameter @xmath36 is a function of @xmath17 only . this statement is consistent with many previous studies , but is shown here with higher accuracy . since @xmath15 depends only on @xmath17 , we predict that for a scale - free model , if the mass @xmath17 is scaled by the characteristic mass @xmath3 , the bias parameter @xmath36 depends only on the scaled mass @xmath37 . interestingly , by definitions of @xmath20 and @xmath3 , the scaled mass obeys a simple relation to the peak height @xmath20 , i.e. @xmath59 . thus it is also very convenient to compare the simulation data of @xmath60 with the formula of mw96 ( cf . . [ bias ] ) . in figure [ fig2 ] , we plot the square of the bias parameter @xmath61 as a function of the scaled mass @xmath37 . the results for all simulation outputs are depicted . this is equivalent to a factor @xmath62 in the halo mass resolution . it is very remarkable that the @xmath63 results agree very well for different evolutionary outputs . the precise scaling behaviour given by the simulation data assures that any numerical artifacts have negligible effect on the results of fig . [ fig2 ] . now we compare our simulation results with the prediction of mw96 . the mw96 predictions are drawn on fig . ( [ fig2 ] ) in dotted lines . it is interesting to see that the mw96 formula agrees well ( within @xmath64 uncertainty ) with the simulation results for massive halos , i.e. @xmath65 . however , at @xmath66 the simulation data start to deviate from the mw96 prediction , and the deviation increases with the decrease of the scaled mass ( or equivalently with the decrease of the peak height ) . at @xmath67 , the simulation result is about 2 to 4 times higher than the prediction . considering the important role played by the correlation functions of the halos in the cosmological studies , we have searched for a fitting formula for @xmath60 . the formula [ fitting ] b(m)=(0.5 ^ 4 + 1)^(0.06 - 0.02n ) ( 1+^2 - 1_c ) ; = ( m / m_)^n+3/6 can fit the simulation results ( fig . [ fig2 ] ) with an accuracy of about 5% for the halo mass that the simulations can probe , i.e. @xmath68 for @xmath32 ; @xmath69 for @xmath70 ; @xmath71 for @xmath72 ; @xmath73 for @xmath39 . the fitting formula recovers the mw96 analytical formula ( eq . [ bias ] ) at high mass @xmath74 . the deviation of the mw96 prediction from the simulation results at small mass is accounted for by the factor @xmath75 . since the scale - free models are only approximations to the real universe at some specific scales , it is very important to consider more realistic models . in figure [ fig3 ] , we present the @xmath76 for the halos in the three cdm models . the blue squares are determined from the simulations of box size @xmath52 and the red triangles are from those of the smaller boxes . in consistency with the scale - free models , the simulation data are significantly higher than the mw96 prediction ( the dotted lines ) for masses less than @xmath3 , where @xmath3 is about @xmath77 for the scdm and about @xmath78 for the low density models . since the slopes of the cdm power spectra change with scale , the fitting formula ( [ fitting ] ) is not directly applicable . fortunately , the fitting formula depends very weakly on the power index @xmath5 , and it can describe the cdm data very accurately if an effective index @xmath6 replaces @xmath5 in eq . ( [ fitting ] ) and the original definition of @xmath79 is used for @xmath20 . the effective index is defined as the slope of @xmath80 at the halo mass @xmath17 [ neff ] n_eff = d p(k ) d k|_k=2r ; 1.5 cm r=(3m4|)^1/3 , where @xmath81 is the mean density of the universe . the solid lines in fig . ( [ fig3 ] ) are predicted in this way . they agree very well with the simulation results . the fact that @xmath6 changes very slowly with the mass m for @xmath82 might be the main reason why the fitting formula can work very well for cdm models after the simple modification . we have determined the correlation function of the dm halos for the hitherto largest set of high - resolution n - body simulations . the excellent scaling exhibited in the bias parameter @xmath60 at the different evolutionary outputs for the scale - free models assures that the results in figures [ fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] are physical , not contaminated by numerical artifacts . the simulation results are in good agreement with the formula of mo & white ( 1996 ) for massive halos @xmath23 . however , for less massive halos the simulation results are significantly higher . the mw96 formula was found in good agreement with the results of @xmath83-particle scale - free simulations by mw96 and with the results of @xmath84-particle cdm simulations of box size @xmath85 by mo et al.(1996 ) . however , their tests were limited to halos with @xmath23 because of the relatively poorer mass resolutions . the results found here therefore do not contradict with , but in fact support and extend the previous n - body tests . the fitting formula ( [ fitting ] ) we found for @xmath15 is accurate for halo masses @xmath86 with only about 5% error . the formula can be applied both to the scale - free models and to the cdm models . in the latter case , the index @xmath5 in equation ( [ fitting ] ) should be replaced with the effective power spectrum index @xmath6 ( eq . [ neff ] ) and the original definition of @xmath79 is used for @xmath20 . this fitting formula could have many important applications for the studies of the large - scale structures . one of them would be to predict and to interpret the clustering of late type galaxies and dwarf galaxies both in real observations and in analytical modeling of galaxy formation , since these galaxies are believed to have formed recently ( @xmath28 ; cf mo et al . @xcite ) with halo masses much less than @xmath3 . at present we do not know the _ exact _ reasons which cause the mw96 formula to fail at the small halo masses @xmath87 . in the derivation of mw96 , two main assumptions are 1 ) the halo formation is determined by the peak height through the extended press - schechter formalism ; 2 ) the mapping of the halo clustering pattern from the lagrangian space to the eulerian one is local and linear ( with the spherical collapse model ) . the first assumption could break down more seriously for low peak - height halos , because the tidal force plays a more important role in their formation . though , as katz , quinn & gelb ( @xcite ; see also katz et al . @xcite ) pointed out , the peak - height is not the sole parameter even for the formation of high - peak halos . the validity of the local linear mapping was recently questioned by catelan et al.(@xcite ) in a different context . unfortunately their result is not directly applicable to this letter . in relation to the gentle rise observed for the bias parameter at the small @xmath37 ( fig . [ fig2 ] ) , we have visually inspected the spatial distribution for halos with @xmath88 ( @xmath89 ) , @xmath90 ( @xmath91 ) , and @xmath92 ( @xmath93 ) in one late output of the @xmath32 model . the small and large halos appear to delineate filamentary structures more closely than the median - mass halos , consistent with the measured @xmath36 . this however might hint that either or both of the two assumptions are violated for the small halos , since the small halos are otherwise expected to be more preferentially located in low density regions . obviously it would be very interesting to find out why the mw96 formula fails . in a future paper , we will examine this question more closely . i am indebted to gerhard brner and yasushi suto for their critical reading of earlier versions of the manuscript . constructive comments by them , by houjun mo , and by an anonymous referee improve the presentation of this letter . yasushi suto is thanked for his invaluable assistance and continuing encouragement ; it would be impossible to get these very large , high quality simulations without his help . it is also my pleasure to acknowledge the jsps foundation for a postdoctoral fellowship . the simulations were carried out on vpp/16r and vx/4r at the astronomical data analysis center of the national astronomical observatory , japan .

an accurate fitting formula is reported for the two - point correlation function @xmath0 of the dark matter halos in hierarchical clustering models . it is valid for the linearly clustering regime , and its accuracy is about 10% in @xmath1 for the halos with mass @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the characteristic non - linear mass . the result is found on the basis of a careful analysis for a large set of scale - free simulations with @xmath4 particles . the fitting formula has a weak explicit dependence on the index @xmath5 of the initial power spectrum , but can be equally well applied to the cold dark matter ( cdm ) cosmological models if the effective index @xmath6 of the cdm power spectrum at the scale of the halo mass replaces the index @xmath5 . the formula agrees with the analytical formula of mo & white ( mw96 ) for massive halos with @xmath7 , but the mw96 formula significantly underpredicts @xmath0 for the less massive halos . the difference between the fitting and the analytical formulae amounts to a factor @xmath8 in @xmath0 for @xmath9 . one of the most interesting applications of this fitting formula would be the clustering of galaxies since the majority of halos hosting galaxies satisfies @xmath10 . # 1*r*_#1 # 1*s*_#1 # 1|n(*r*_#1 ) # 1|n(*s*_#1 ) # 1_z(r_p#1,_#1 ) # 1(r_#1 ) # 1(s_#1 ) # 1w(r_p#1 )

1612.01355

jastrow wavefunction @xcite is a pair - product ansatz for a strongly correlated many - body bosonic ground state . exactly optimized form of the pair function can be found with the correlated basis functions ( cbf ) theory and the diagrammatic theory @xcite . however , such solutions are often either unknown or unavailable from open sources . meanwhile , the jastrow wavefunction is widely used as an approximation to the ground state in first - principles quantum many - body methods , both for bosons @xcite and as a part of a fermionic wavefunction @xcite . in particular , diffusion monte carlo ( dmc ) requires such an approximation as its guiding ( importance - sampling ) function ; the path - integral ground state monte carlo ( pigs ) @xcite does not require importance sampling yet benefits greatly when a high - quality approximate ground state is used as its boundary condition @xcite . in such cases , the numerical efficiency and convenience of obtaining the trial functions is often important to practitioners . the pair factors of the jastrow ansatz , when used in the dmc , are often extracted by solving the pair scattering equation for small inter - particle separation , and only to the leading order . such a solution usually needs to be additionally parametrized with one or several variationally - optimized variables . in this work , we revisit this standard procedure . instead of parametrizing the leading - order solution to the pair equation , we parametrize the scattering equation itself . the trial functions are optimized in the space of solutions of such parametrized equations . we find that this results in a robust and straight - forward methodology which provides an excellent description of the ground state . we are considering a system of identical bosons with pairwise interaction potential . the hamiltonian can be written as @xmath1 we assume the bijl - jastrow ansatz for the many - body ground state of this system , @xmath2 the kinetic energy of this function can be written as @xmath3 in a homogeneous system , the last term vanishes if one assumes that the three - body correlations are sufficiently weak , and the eigenvalue equation of hamiltonian ( [ eq : full - hamiltonian ] ) is fulfilled so long as factors @xmath4 satisfy the pair equation @xmath5 the energy @xmath6 is equal to @xmath7 , @xmath8 being the eigenenergy of the many - body ground state , and must in fact vanish for an infinite system . we retain this term as our calculations use finite periodic systems and @xmath6 can be used to satisfy corresponding boundary requirements . direct solutions of the pair scattering equation similar to ( [ eq : pair - equation - f ] ) were used by pahnparipande @xcite as part of a variational ansatz for nuclear matter . however , as we will see below , direct solutions of this equation are far from optimal for our systems of interest . it was realized early on that the dominant contribution to the quality of the pair factor comes from its behavior at small distances , where the potential energy diverges for a hard - core interaction . indeed , to this day solving eq . ( [ eq : pair - equation - f ] ) to the first leading order at short distances remains the standard prescription when a simple , few - parameter function is desired . this is often understood as solving the kato cusp condition @xcite for the divergence in @xmath9 , similar to the way one handles interactions such as _ e.g. _ electronic states in the coulomb potential or states in a finite - strength contact potential . such terminology is not strictly correct for the potentials with analytical hard - core part . in fact , at short distances , the optimal pair factors for hard - core interactions vanish exponentially faster than the divergence of corresponding potential or kinetic energy contributions . the expectation values for both the potential and kinetic energies exist and carry no irregularities . likewise , the wavefunction has well - defined derivatives everywhere where it does not vanish . this is the reason why the leading - order solution of eq . ( [ eq : pair - equation - f ] ) can be additionally parametrized without forfeiting the variational principle . on the contrary , systems with true cusp condition must satisfy their cusp condition exactly in order to cancel non - analytic terms that arise in the schrdinger equationl ; such pair factors can not be meaningfully parametrized in the vicinity of the divergence . we write the pair factors in the positive - defined form as @xmath10 which is the conventional pseudopotential form but with the prefactor @xmath11 omitted for the sake of simplicity . the pair equation ( [ eq : pair - equation - f ] ) reads @xmath12 ^ 2 \right ) + v(r ) = \varepsilon , \label{eq : pair - equation - u - start}\ ] ] where @xmath13 is the physical dimensionality of the system . if the pair potential energy diverges at small distances as @xmath14 with @xmath15 , the other leading term in eq . ( [ eq : pair - equation - u - start ] ) is in fact @xmath16 and one has wkb - like solution @xmath17 and @xmath18 in practice , this solution does not yield an optimal energy but is in fact significantly improved by additional parametrization , @xmath19 where the constant @xmath20 can be determined by minimizing the variational energy . as mentioned above , such a parametrization is possible because every term of the pair equation ( [ eq : pair - equation - f ] ) remains analytical , and in fact even infinitely differentiable . indeed , @xmath21 moreover , the power of the divergence in @xmath22 can also be treated variationally for the same reason . the above approach alone allows to account for most of the correlation energy of the dense strongly correlated bosonic systems . numerous works have been devoted to improving the pair ansatz beyond the form of eq . ( [ eq : leading - term - u2 ] ) . one of the most studied systems in this regard is liquid helium-4 . this system has been the subject of about every quantum monte carlo method that is applicable , which included a large amount of work with explicit variational monte carlo with the jastrow ansatz . the simplest variational ansatz for helium consists of the parametrized leading - term solution proposed by mcmillan and by schiff and verlet @xcite , or similar solutions @xcite . the improvements beyond the leading order for helium can be seen as falling into the following categories : ( a ) addition to the leading term ( [ eq : leading - term - u2 ] ) of various explicit short- and long - range corrections derived from known general properties of the system @xcite , ( b ) parametrization of the mid - range behavior of @xmath22 focused primarily on improving the variational energy or structural properties @xcite , and ( c ) extracting the solution to the pair equation ( [ eq : pair - equation - u - start ] ) beyond the leading order , or using such solutions as a basis set @xcite . these approaches are considered in some detail below . additionally , one can use the pair functions obtained with paired phonon analysis ( ppa ) method @xcite . for instance , ppa optimization of campbell and pinski was used as a guiding function in ref . . this method requires the hnc approximation and is out of our scope . the best forms of the jastrow function miss the ground state of liquid helium by about one degree kelvin per particle . a large part of this energy can be accounted for by including three - body correlations into the wavefunction @xcite . partially , the three - body correlations can be captured by the shadow wavefunction ( swf ) method @xcite which has since taken over explicit wavefunctions for the variational description of liquid helium . however , our interest is limited to the explicit jastrow pair terms . \(a ) this approach relies on knowing the general properties of the static structure function of the system . it allows to recreate the physically important features that otherwise are missed by the leading - order solution . most remarkable of these corrections is the infinite - range tail in @xmath22 which must arise in the presence of zero - point phonons in the system @xcite . other corrections to @xmath22 were initially tied to the mid - range excitation structure of helium , that is , to the presence of the roton minimum @xcite . as the mid - range behavior is critical for achieving good varitational energy , parametrising @xmath22 in this region has a significant impact on the variational energy , disregarding the origin of such correction . overall , this approach leads to a rapid escalation of the parametrization of the pair factor . the leading order term must still be present , contributing one or two parameters . the phonon tail adds between one and two parameters ( speed of sound , and a distance cutoff @xmath23 ) , and at least three parameters are required for a simple gaussian mid - range correction ( its location , width and strength ) . \(b ) if one is solely interested in minimizing the variational energy , or in replicating a known observable such as the pair distribution function , it is possible to this end to employ heavy parametrization of the pair function @xcite . such attempts have been quite successful , but in all cases relied on on using six and more parameters . here we are seeking approaches that are much straight - forward methodologically . \(c ) trying to directly solve the pair scattering equations leads to the pair functions that are extremely poor in accounting for the correlation energy . moreover , as will be shown below , such energies depend very strongly on the size of the simulation cell . pandharipande and schmidt used the solutions of the pair equation as a variational anzatz for helium @xcite . a sharp cutoff allowed to limit the energy divergence , and the offset @xmath24 in ref . , used to satisfy boundary condition for @xmath4 at the cutoff , is equivalent to @xmath6 in ( [ eq : pair - equation - u - start ] ) . unfortunately , the energy in ref . was extracted in an approximate way . a more productive approach , with excellent variational results , was reported by vitiello and schmidt in . it was shown that when the pair equation is treated as an eignevalue problem , the set of lowest eigenfunctions can be used as a basis for expressing the pair function . that is , their approach uses the pair equation as a _ source _ of good variational functions . on the other hand , the need to combine multiple eigenstates means one has once again to deal with as many as ten variational parameters . this work can be seen as extending the approach of pandharipande and schmidt . however , instead of parametrizing a linear combination of functions arising from the pair equation , we choose to parametrize the equation itself . the pair function is selected from the space of solutions of a modified and parametrized version of the differential eq . ( [ eq : pair - equation - u - start ] ) . straight - out solution of the pair eq . ( [ eq : pair - equation - u - start ] ) for any potential with an attractive part of the potential contains an exaggerated feature at mid - range separations . the larger is the simulation cutoff , the further is the solution cutoff , and the stronger becomes this peak . example solutions for helium are shown in fig . ( [ fig : u2straight ] ) . we observed that this feature is especially sensitive to the presence of the second term on the l.h.s . of eq . ( [ eq : pair - equation - u - start ] ) . thus we considered several parametrized modifications of that term . with substitution @xmath25 and additional notation @xmath26 the pair equation reads @xmath27 which is nonlinear but can be solved numerically . the energy parameter @xmath28 is used to satisfy the boundary conditions . below we list the parametrized equations which we consider . each equation contains one variational parameter , but may also be modified in that the `` dimensionality '' term is either switched in sign or removed altogether . for clarity of notation , each equation uses a uniquely named variable for its parametrization . * `` effective mass '' modifications , @xmath29 * prefactor to the quadratic term , @xmath30 * prefactor to the linear ( `` dimensionality '' ) term in @xmath31 , @xmath32 * suppression of the divergence of linear term at short distance , @xmath33 * suppression of the linear term at large distances , @xmath34 } v_2 - ( v_2)^2 + g_{\varepsilon}&=0 \label{eq : original-14 } , \\ -v'_2 + \frac{d-1}{r/[1-(r / l_c)^{1/m_2 } ] } v_2 - ( v_2)^2 + g_{\varepsilon}&=0 \label{eq : original-15}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the terms are suppressed when approaching the cutoff distance @xmath35 . * finally , a prefactor in the first term , @xmath36 ) for varying cutoff lengths . the equation is solved for helium with the aziz hfd - b(he ) @xcite interparticle potential . the cutoff lengths correspond to cubic simulation cell with helium at its equilibrium density containing 32 , 64 , 128 , 256 , 512 , and 1000 atoms . while the solutions coincide at small interparticle separations , the mid - range maximum increases with system size . the inset shows the pair factor @xmath37 $ ] . [ fig : u2straight],scaledwidth=50.0% ] [ cols= " < , < , < , < , < , < , < , < , < " , ] we have revisited the long - posed question of producing satisfactory jastrow wavefunction based on the corresponding pair scattering equation . we proposed and considered in detail a straight - forward method for producing high - quality pair factors based solely on the two - body potential of the system . the method expands on the pair factors used some time ago by pandharipande . we propose two - parameter pair factors , in which one parameter modifies the pair equation , such as @xmath38 in eq . ( [ eq : original-9 ] ) or @xmath39 in eq . ( [ eq : original-16 ] ) , and the second parameter is the solution cutoff . the modified equations preserve the leading - order solution of the pair equation at short distances . such a pair factor provides excellent variational optimization and reproduces the first peak of the pair - distribution function . it is possible to add known or desired long - range behavior to such pair factors . it should be concluded that not only it is possible to extract satisfactory pair factors from the pair scattering equation , but that such factors are of high - quality and may be of convenience due the low number of corresponding variational parameters . 58ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ , , vol . ( , , ) `` , '' ( , , ) chap . @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase { 10.1063/1.3697846 } [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0375-9474(72)90899-8 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0375-9474(71)90413-1 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.155.88 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop `` , '' ( ) , @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.15.2486 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.438007 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( )

we consider the jastrow pair - product wavefunction for the strongly correlated bose systems , in our case liquid helium-4 . an ansatz is proposed for the pair factors which consists of a numeric solution to a modified and parametrized pair scattering equation . we consider a number of such simple one - variable parametrizations . additionally , we allow for a parametrizeable cutoff of the pair factors and for the addition of a long - range phonon tail . this approach results in the many - body wavefunctions that have between just one and three parameters . calculation of observables is carried with the variational monte carlo method . we find that such a simple parametrization is sufficient to produce results that are comparable in quality to the best available two - body jastrow factors for helium . for two - parameter wavefunction , we find variational energies of @xmath0 k per particle for a system of one thousand particles . it is also shown that short - range two - body correlations are reproduced in detail by two- and three - parameter functions .

quant-ph0409142

the twirl operation was introduced by bennett _ @xcite in the context of entanglement purification of mixed states . the first step in many of these protocols is the twirl operation which converts an arbitrary mixed state of a two qubit system , @xmath0 , into a werner singlet state @xmath1 @xcite , an incoherent mixture of @xmath2 parts of a maximally entangled singlet state , @xmath3 , and @xmath4 parts of the maximally mixed state , @xmath5 the key idea behind the twirl is that the singlet state is invariant under any bilateral unitary transformation of the two qubits ( that is , any operation where identical local unitaries are applied to the two qubits ) , whereas any other state will be affected . a randomly chosen bilateral rotation should serve to average any other state , converting an arbitrary mixed state to a werner singlet . ( note that the twirl sequence does not _ create _ new singlet , rather it _ preserves _ the singlet , while averaging out all other terms . ) this provides a good `` in principle '' definition of the twirl operation , but in practice it is important to consider what a random bilateral rotation really is , and how it can actually be implemented . early work in this field concentrated on reducing the infinite set of randomly chosen rotations down to a small finite set . originally it was suggested @xcite that the twirl could be achieved using a set of four bilateral rotations , although it was later shown that a set of twelve bilateral rotations are both necessary and sufficient @xcite . this approach is sensible for conventional quantum information processors , but with ensemble devices , such as nuclear magnetic resonance ( nmr ) quantum computers , it is useful to use a different approach . in such devices it is in fact easier to perform rotations by angles that vary continuously over the ensemble than by angles from some small carefully chosen set . in nmr devices , for example , the application of a strong magnetic field gradient @xcite performs a rotation around the @xmath6 axis with a rotation angle that depends strongly on the position of a given molecule within the spatial ensemble ; integrating over the position within the sample is then equivalent to applying a random rotation . in the language of nmr this is often referred to as a _ crush gradient _ pulse . for simplicity we will sometimes describe a crush gradient as a random rotation around the @xmath6-axis , as the effect on the averaged density matrix is the same , but when considering experimental implementations it is necessary to be more precise . the use of field gradients forms the basis of spatial averaging methods , used in nmr quantum computing to prepare pseudo - pure states @xcite . field gradients have also been used to average out error terms @xcite , to project qubits into the zeeman basis @xcite , and to simplify density matrices prior to partial state tomography @xcite . the alternative procedure , in which one rotation chosen from a small set is applied , requires several experiments to be performed , and in the context of nmr quantum computing is usually known as temporal averaging . in subsequent sections we explore different methods for implementing the twirl , concentrating on those which are best suited to ensemble techniques . we begin by noting that any set of bilateral rotations which performs a twirl must correspond to a set of single qubit rotations which , when considered from the viewpoint of a single qubit subsystem , averages any state of a single qubit to the maximally mixed state . as we shall see , however , averaging a single qubit is a necessary but not a sufficient condition for a set of rotations to act as a twirl . averaging a single qubit gives some useful insight into the problem of twirling a two qubit state . a single qubit state can be represented by a ray on the bloch sphere and an arbitrary rotation will move this ray over the surface of the sphere . each rotation @xmath7 is defined by a rotation angle @xmath8 about an axis @xmath9 parameterized by a tilt angle @xmath10 and an azimuthal angle @xmath11 . an arbitrary single qubit state is completely defined by three real parameters , which are conventionally taken as the expectation values of the single spin pauli operators @xmath12 @xcite . for scrambling an arbitrary state to the maximally mixed state , we must choose a convenient set of operations , which scrambles each of these pauli operators individually . a tempting , but incorrect , approach is to apply random rotations about random axes , that is to take @xmath8 as being uniformly distributed between @xmath13 and @xmath14 , while the rotation axes defined by @xmath10 and @xmath11 are uniformly distributed over the sphere ; we call this set of rotations @xmath15 . brute force integration shows that the continuous set of random rotations around random axes , @xmath15 , does not completely randomize the state of a single qubit , and so _ can not _ constitute the basis for a twirl operation ; instead it reduces the bloch vector to one third of its original length . in retrospect the reason for this behaviour is clear : random rotations around axes perpendicular to the original state will completely average it , while rotations around axes parallel or anti - parallel to the state will leave it unaffected . thus the overall effect of @xmath15 must be to scale down the state , rather than to average it completely . the significance of the scaling by one third is discussed below . a better definition of a random rotation is provided by considering the description of a rotation by means of its euler angles . while many different conventions for describing euler angles exist , the essential feature is that any rotation can be decomposed as a sequence of three rotations around two axes . for example any rotation can be achieved by the sequence of rotations @xmath16 where rotations are applied from left to right . a random distribution of euler rotations can be achieved by taking @xmath8 as uniformly distributed between @xmath13 and @xmath14 , with the rotation axes defined by @xmath10 and @xmath11 uniformly distributed over the sphere ; we call this set of rotations @xmath17 . it might seem that @xmath17 is the same as @xmath15 , but they are in fact quite different : in particular @xmath17 completely averages a single qubit , while @xmath15 does not . this is easily seen by noting that the first rotation will average @xmath18 and @xmath19 , while the second and third will average @xmath20 . as any state of a single qubit can be written as a linear combination of these basic matrices and the maximally mixed state , the first two operations will average _ any _ state . it is clear from the above that a random euler rotation will average any single qubit , but this process is perhaps excessive , as two rotations suffice . ( we will see below that this is not true when considering a true twirl applied to two qubits . ) the sequence of rotations @xmath21 where both @xmath10 and @xmath11 are now taken as uniformly distributed between @xmath13 and @xmath14 , will average any single qubit ; as before this is most simply seen by considering the result for @xmath18 , @xmath19 and @xmath20 . indeed this process can be simplified still further : as described by bennett _ @xcite is is possible to average a single qubit by randomly selecting from the four operations @xmath22 . since @xmath23 is equivalent to a @xmath24 rotation , and ( neglecting global phases ) @xmath25 it is clear that this operation is equivalent to applying either @xmath13 or @xmath26 at random , and then applying @xmath13 or @xmath27 at random ; a similar result has been described by hayden et al @xcite . thus instead of choosing the two angles in equation [ rotzy ] at random from uniform distributions , we can choose at random from two particular values . this process of replacing a continuous rotation by a small number of discrete values is an example of a quite general procedure . for rank @xmath28 and rank @xmath29 tensors , continuous rotations about a fixed axis , can in fact , always be replaced by discrete rotations : we can `` hop '' between the angles @xmath30 , with @xmath31 and @xmath32 , and the overall effect is the same as rotating continuously about the same axis @xcite . it is _ sometimes _ possible to use @xmath33 , but this can not be relied on in general . the rotation through @xmath30 is the member @xmath34 of the cyclic group @xmath35 @xcite ; in this way , the continuous rotations can be replaced by discrete group operations and the continuous integrals over the rotation angle @xmath8 , can be substituted by _ group theoretical averages _ , such as @xmath36 the simplest discrete group that can generally be used for averaging is the cyclic @xmath37 group , which is employed by nmr spectroscopists in the form of magic angle hopping @xcite , a discrete version of its continuous counterpart , magic angle spinning @xcite . the group theoretical framework has also been used in the context of bang - bang decoupling protocols @xcite , which seek to average out system - environment interactions by applying fast , discrete and periodic control impulses to _ only _ the system , with the control propagators faithfully representing the members of a discrete cyclic group @xmath38 . this approach hints at another method for performing complete averaging of a single qubit . we have already noted that random rotations around a random axis do not completely average a single qubit , but simply rescale its length by one third . this process is , as usual , equivalent to applying a rotation through an angle of @xmath39 , @xmath40 or @xmath41 around a random axis . clearly a @xmath39 rotation can have no effect , while the effect of the @xmath40 and @xmath41 rotations must be the same . from this it can be deduced that a @xmath40 rotation around a random axis will completely average a single qubit , and this is indeed the case . finally we turn to the issue of practical experimental implementations . for a conventional quantum information processor the obvious approach is to use the smallest discrete set of operations ; for the case of averaging a single qubit this is the set of four rotations described by bennett _ et al . _ with an ensemble processor , such as an nmr quantum computer , it is better to use a procedure based on continuous rotations , corresponding to spatial averaging . clearly the best approach is to apply random rotations around two orthogonal axes , such as @xmath6 and @xmath42 . a strong magnetic field gradient , denoted * g * , will effect a random rotation around the @xmath6 axis , and rotations around other axes can be achieved by combining gradients with single qubit gates ( radiofrequency pulses ) which can be treated as rotating the axis system . thus the sequence @xmath43 will completely average a single spin . note that this procedure is not completely equivalent to equation [ rotzy ] , as it should strictly speaking be followed by a @xmath44 pulse to rotate the axes back to their original positions , but as the maximally mixed state will not be affected by the rotation this final stage may be safely omitted . the discussion above assumes that the gradient pulses are instantaneous , so that their sole effect is average the spin state and evolution under any background hamiltonian can be ignored . in fact , gradient pulses take a finite time , but as the gradient and background hamiltonians commute they can be treated as an instantaneous pulse followed by a finite period of evolution under the background hamiltonian . for a single nmr spin this is not a problem , as the maximally mixed state does not evolve under the background hamiltonian ; for a two qubit system , however , it is necessary to consider this problem more carefully . we now turn to the problem of implementing a full twirl on two qubits . this is clearly related to the problem of averaging a single qubit , but is more complicated . in particular , any twirl procedure will average a single qubit , but not every averaging procedure can be converted to a twirl . for example , the sequence of four operations @xmath45 suggested by bennett _ @xcite does average a single qubit , but does not effect a twirl ; instead it is necessary to use a set of 12 operations @xcite corresponding to the rotational symmetry elements of the tetrahedral group @xmath46 @xcite . the group theoretical justification for using these rotations is discussed in @xcite . turning to the other averaging methods discussed above , only the method based on random euler rotations ( @xmath17 ) will correctly implement a twirl ; the other methods will only partially average the state . in particular the sequence of two random rotations around orthogonal axes has already been studied @xcite , and shown to implement a partial twirl , in which the density matrix is reduced to bell diagonal form , but not to a werner state . for an ensemble quantum information processor , it might seem that the best strategy for performing a full twirl would be to perform random euler rotations . unfortunately this approach can not be implemented using gradients or similar methods , as these generate rotations with a uniform distribution ( between 0 and @xmath14 ) _ for each rotation angle _ , while the euler rotation method requires that the angles @xmath10 and @xmath11 be uniformly distributed _ over a sphere_. thus it might seem that twirl operations can not be easily implemented by ensemble methods . it is , however , possible to do this by using sequential random rotations around three different axes . this procedure is a development of the partial twirl described above . consider again the sequence of rotations in equation [ one - qubit - crot-2axes ] . these two rotations constitute a partial twirl @xcite , and leave the density matrix bell diagonal with equal populations of @xmath47 and @xmath48 , where @xmath49 . the role of the third rotation is to scramble these states with the sole remaining undesired term , @xmath50 , leaving a werner singlet state . this can be achieved by rotating about an axis at an angle @xmath51 , commonly known in nmr studies as the `` magic angle '' @xcite . our final twirl sequence is then @xmath52 as was the case for the partial twirl @xcite it is necessary to choose the lengths of the gradient pulses as multiples of @xmath53 , where @xmath54 is the difference between the larmor frequencies of the two spins , to refocus evolution under the background hamiltonian , which occurs at this difference frequency . if desired this twirl can be implemented using discrete steps by replacing each random rotation with a three step averaging procedure , @xmath55 where @xmath56 indicates a set of @xmath6 rotations with rotation angles @xmath57 , where @xmath58 . this discrete twirl requires twenty - seven steps , but the number of steps can be reduced to eighteen , using the sequences @xmath59 or @xmath60 it is not possible to reduce the number of steps further while using sequential rotations around three axes . it is instructive to compare this discrete twirl with the twelve step version of bennett _ et al . their twelve rotations include the identity operation , @xmath61 rotations about the principal @xmath62 , @xmath42 and @xmath6 axes and rotations by @xmath63 around the four body diagonals , each of which is at the magic angle with the cardinal axes . ( these are the twelve rotations that leave a tetrahedron invariant . ) clearly our rotations are closely related to theirs ; the use of sequential rotations means that the number of steps required is larger , but the sequential approach may be simpler to implement in practice . finally , we demonstrate the experimental implementation of our ensemble twirl operation as described in equation [ 2-qubit-3-axes - gzonly ] . our implementation is based on a homonuclear system , comprising the two nuclei of cytosine dissolved in @xmath64 ; we use the product operator description @xcite for the nmr states and pulse sequences , and label the two spins as @xmath65 and @xmath66 . the hamiltonian of our system is then @xmath67 where @xmath68 and @xmath69 are the resonance offset frequencies of spins @xmath65 and @xmath66 , and @xmath70 is the @xmath71 spin spin coupling constant ( assuming weak coupling ) , all measured in hertz . nmr experiments were performed on a varian unity inova spectrometer with the spectrometer frequency placed between the two cytosine resonances ; for our system @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 . the experiment began with the preparation of a generic mixed state of the two qubits containing a contribution from the singlet state as well as a wide range of other terms . the preparation sequence ( which was applied to the thermal equilibrium state , @xmath75 ) involves shaped pulses selectively exciting the spins and separated by a delay @xmath76 , @xmath77 shaped pulses were implemented using strongly modulated composite pulses as described by fortunato _ the deviation density matrix of the prepared state @xmath0 has a singlet component proportional to @xmath78 clearly the amount of singlet in @xmath0 can be easily controlled through choice of the delay @xmath76 . note that as we are using a deviation density matrix description of a highly mixed state it is possible for the singlet component to be negative . we performed two sets of experiments on states drawn from this family of states . the first set uses a fixed initial state and demonstrates a stepwise progression through the twirl sequence , with the resulting state becoming closer to a werner state at each stage . the second set uses a range of initial states , with different singlet fractions , and shows that the twirl sequence works equally well over this range . .pulse sequences for the first set of experiments , which demonstrate the effects of the three stages of our twirl operation . see main text for details . [ cols="^ , < " , ] the first set of experiments , listed in table [ experiment1 ] , comprises a stepwise progression through the twirl sequence , equation [ 2-qubit-3-axes - gzonly ] . each experiment uses the same initial state , with @xmath79 , a value chosen to maximize the singlet fraction . the three stages of the twirl correspond to the application of three different crush gradients , and can be characterized as follows : stage 0 , do nothing ; stage 1 , apply a single crush gradient ; stage 2 , apply the partial twirl sequence @xcite ; stage 3 , apply the full twirl sequence . two different measurements are performed to characterize the state after each step : simple direct acquisition ( which should show no signals for a werner singlet state ) and acquisition after a selective excitation pulse , which converts the singlet state into nmr observable terms . the selective pulse was implemented using the sequence @xmath80 - 90_{180},\ ] ] where @xmath81 is the frequency separation between the two resonances as before . this sequence is based on jump - and - return sequences described in previous work @xcite , and when applied to a singlet state , results in the observable nmr terms , @xmath82 corresponding to a pair of antiphase doublets with equal and opposite intensities . the resulting spectra are shown in figure [ graphics1 ] . the left hand column of this figure shows spectra from direct acquisition and the right hand column shows spectra obtained with the excitation pulse followed by acquisition . the four rows correspond to observation after 0 , 1 , 2 or all 3 stages of the twirl sequence . the initial state @xmath0 contains many different components , and the observed spectra ( top row ) are complicated , reflecting this fact . after the first stage of the twirl sequence ( the first field gradient ) all components which are directly observable by nmr are crushed ( averaged to zero ) , and so no signal is visible in the direct detection spectrum , but many other components remain , indicated by the variety of signals seen after excitation . the second stage of the twirl ( the @xmath83 pulse and the second gradient ) removes most of these terms , producing a bell diagonal state with equal populations of @xmath47 and @xmath48 . as before there is no signal in the left hand spectrum , while the spectrum on the right contains two antiphase doublets with clearly different intensities . this intensity difference arises from the imbalance between the @xmath84 state and the two @xmath85 states @xcite . after the third and final stage of the twirl ( the @xmath86 pulse and the last gradient ) these two antiphase doublets have equal and opposite intensities , characteristic of a werner singlet state . the final intensity of these doublets , compared with a calibration spectrum ( not shown ) acquired from the thermal state , is consistent with the twirl preserving the fraction of the singlet state as expected . , in steps of @xmath87 , which causes the fraction of singlet in the initial state to be modulated , with a period of ten steps . ] this last point is explored in more detail in the second experiment , in which the full twirl is applied to a range of initial states with different amounts of the singlet state . the size of the singlet component for our family of states is given in equation [ singlet - fraction - dirty ] , and shows two kinds of sinusoidal modulation with the variable delay @xmath76 : a fast variation , arising from the offset frequency @xmath68 , on top of a slow variation due to the coupling @xmath70 between the two qubits . if we choose @xmath76 to be close to @xmath88 , we are near the maximum of the slow @xmath70 modulation , and the effect of varying @xmath76 is dominated by a sinusoidal variation arising from @xmath68 . in this way we can produce a range of density matrices @xmath0 with varying amounts of singlet , together with other terms , each of which can be twirled to produce a werner state . this state can then be observed using a selective excitation pulse prior to acquisition . in each case the expected spectrum is a pair of antiphase doublets , with the intensity of the signal showing a sinusoidal modulation at the frequency @xmath68 . the results of this experiment are shown in fig . [ graphics2 ] , which depicts the intensity variation in the righthand component of the lefthand doublet as @xmath76 is varied around a value of @xmath89 , with an increment between successive spectra of @xmath87 ; equivalent effects can be seen for the other three components of the nmr signal . as expected a sinusoidal modulation of the signal is clearly seen , and the observed modulation period of ten spectra is exactly as expected . the small out of phase signals observable near the zero - crossings of the sine wave can be ascribed to the effects of spin lattice relaxation during the gradient pulses . we have described a variety of strategies for the practical implementation of twirl sequences on conventional and ensemble quantum computers , and have demonstrated an ensemble implementation on an nmr quantum computer . with a conventional quantum computer the implementation requiring the smallest number of different bilateral operations is the set of 12 rotations previously described @xcite , but our 18 step and 27 step averaging procedures require a smaller number of elementary operations and may be simpler to implement in practice . with an ensemble quantum computer , such as an nmr device , it can be simpler to replace the discrete averaging procedure by continuous averaging , exploiting the ensemble nature of the system . we have developed a scheme , involving the application of three successive crush gradients separated by rf pulses , which is well suited to nmr quantum computers , and have demonstrated that its experimental performance is consistent with theoretical expectations .

twirl operations , which convert impure singlet states into werner states , play an important role in many schemes for entanglement purification . in this paper we describe strategies for implementing twirl operations , with an emphasis on methods suitable for ensemble quantum information processors such as nuclear magnetic resonance ( nmr ) quantum computers . we implement our twirl operation on a general two - spin mixed state using liquid state nmr techniques , demonstrating that we can obtain the singlet werner state with high fidelity .

0905.1126

the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) has revealed a very complex structure both in the stellar and in the gaseous component . the elongation of the stellar disk in the direction of the galactic center , its substantial vertical thickness , the warp and the strong asymmetric bar are naturally predicted by numerical simulations as a result of the gravitational interaction between the lmc and the galaxy ( bekki & chiba 2005 , mastropietro et al . 2005 , hereafter m05 ) . the old stellar distribution appears to be quite smooth in the outer parts of the disk , with no signs of spiral structures out to a radius of 10 kpc @xcite . within the same radius the hi large scale structure reveals the presence of several asymmetric features that have no equivalent in the old stellar disk . the gaseous disk is characterized by the presence of an elongated region located at the south - east of the galaxy and aligned with the border of the optical disk , where the column density distribution shows a steep increase @xcite . since the lmc proper motion vector is directed to the east , it appears natural to associate this high density region with ram - pressure acting on the leading edge of the disk due to the orbital motion of the lmc and its consequent interaction with the diffuse hot gas in the halo of the milky way ( mw ) . the presence of an extended hot halo surrounding galaxies and in hydrostatic equilibrium within the dark matter potential is expected by current models of hierarchical structure formation . in the mw , x - ray absorption lines produced by hot ( @xmath1 k ) gas are detected in the spectra of several bright agn @xcite . some ionization features discovered in the magellanic stream and high velocity clouds indicate that this distribution of hot gas extends well beyond the galactic disk ( @xmath2 kpc ) . constraints from dynamical and thermal arguments fix its density in a range between @xmath3 and @xmath4 cm @xmath5 at the lmc distance from the galactic center ( but kaufmann et al . 2009 suggest a value ten times higher ) . @xcite have performed a detailed analysis of the lmc global star formation rate using asymptotic giant branch stars . they find an irregular and patchy distribution in age , with the youngest carbon - rich systems located at the south - east of the disk . the present star formation activity is rather clumpy and concentrated in stellar complexes characterized by intense hii emission and associated with bright h@xmath0 filamentary bubbles . most of these very young structures lie on the south - east of the disk , in the proximity of 30 doradus , the largest star forming region of the lmc , some are located in the bar and the remainder form an asymmetric pattern that covers the entire disk with no apparent relation to the global geometry of the satellite . it is not clear which is the overall physical mechanism responsible for triggering star formation with the observed asymmetric pattern and different models have been proposed in the past . the stochastic self - propagating star formation ( sspsf ) model predicts a clear age gradient in the lmc s stellar complexes , with the edges being younger with respect to the center , in contradiction with observations @xcite . @xcite proposed a scenario where the bow shock originated by the motion of the lmc through the hot galactic halo compresses the leading edge of the disk and induces star formation . the pressure at the south - eastern edge of the lmc is indeed 10 times higher than the average in the rest of the lmc @xcite . this model , which assumes the orbital motion vector lying in the plane of the disk , predicts increasing ages of the stellar complexes in the direction of the rotation , due to the fact that the material compressed at the front side of the disk moves , in time , away to the side . the youngest systems would indeed lie at the south - east border of the disk , where the relative velocity between the corotating interstellar medium and the external diffuse gas is maximum . several giant structures along the outer east and north edge of the lmc actually show a progression in age in a clockwise direction : moving from south - east to the north lmc 2 , 30 doradus and lmc 3 , lmc 4 , ngc1818 . in particular the difference in age between 30 doradus and lmc4 is exactly their distance along the border of the disk divided by the satellite s rotational velocity ( harris , private communication ) . studied the recent star formation history of the lmc using cepheids and other supergiant stars and found that although the majority of the star formation events in the last 30 myr are concentrated on the east border , others are distributed across the entire disk in partial contrast with the bow shock induced star formation model , that can not explain them . in this work we use high resolution sph simulations to study the effects of the interaction between the lmc interstellar medium and the diffuse hot halo of the mw . we want to investigate whether the ram - pressure acting on the leading edge of the lmc disk is responsible for the increase in density observed in the south - east and for triggering star formation . the analytic model of @xcite assumes a pure edge - on model , but according to @xcite the present angle between the lmc disk and the orbital motion is nearly @xmath6 . even in the absence of precession and nutation , this angle is subjected to large variations during the orbital period in such a way that compression produced by the external hot gas can affect in time both edge - on and face - on . moreover , the ram - pressure felt by the lmc is not constant and has a maximum when the satellite approaches the perigalacticon . the motion of the lmc through the hot halo of the mw during the last 1 gyr is modeled using `` test wind tunnel '' simulations with increasing ram - pressure values . the paper is structured as follows . section 2 describes the models and the star formation criteria adopted , section 3 illustrates the results of simulations without star formation , focussed on the investigation of pure effects of compression on the lmc interstellar medium while section 4 describes the runs where star formation is activated . several simulations have been performed , assuming different star formation models , disk inclinations and hot halo densities . the initial conditions of the simulations are constructed using the technique described by @xcite . our disk galaxy model is a multi - component system with a stellar and gaseous disk embedded in a spherical nfw @xcite dark matter halo . the density profile of the dark matter halo is adiabatically contracted in response to baryonic infall @xcite . the stellar disk follows an exponential surface density profile of the form : @xmath7 where @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the disk mass and radial scale length ( in cylindrical coordinates ) , respectively , while the thin vertical structure has a scale length @xmath10 : @xmath11 the gaseous disk is characterized by an exponential profile with the same radial and vertical scale length as the stellar component and by a constant density layer which extends up to 8@xmath9 . the structural parameters of the disk and the halo are chosen so that the resulting rotation curve resembles that of a typical bulgeless late - type ( sc / sd ) disk galaxy . they are similar to those adopted in m05 for the initial lmc model and reproduce quite well the peak of the rotation curve inferred by @xcite ( fig . as seen in m05 , the interaction with the mw does not affect significantly the stellar and dark matter mass in the inner @xmath12 kpc of the lmc and consequently the global rotation curve within this radial range . the choice of an extended gaseous component for the initial lmc model is motivated by the fact that spiral galaxies in the local universe are commonly observed to be embedded in extended disks of neutral hydrogen significantly larger than their stellar component . as seen in m05 , the combined effect of tidal interactions and ram - pressure stripping can remove a significant fraction of gas from a lmc disk orbiting within the hot halo of the mw , with a ram - pressure stripping radius which is a factor of three smaller than the initial radius of the gaseous disk . also in the case of a lmc with orbital velocities significantly higher @xcite hydrodynamic and gravitational forces together are effective in resizing and reshaping the extended gaseous disk of the satellite beyond 8 kpc . in the present work we neglect the presence of gravitational forces focusing on the effects of pure ram - pressure . therefore we do not expect to see a significant decrease in the radius of the gas distribution . however , in order to take in account the loss of cold gas from the disk of the satellite and the star formation events , we assumed an initial amount of gas in the disk which is about @xmath13 times larger than the hi mass in the lmc ( @xmath14 @xmath15 according to putman et al . 2003 ) . the mass within the virial radius is set equal to @xmath16 m@xmath17 and the fraction of mass in the disk is @xmath18 , equally distributed between the gaseous and stellar component . the contribution of the different components to the global rotation curve , assuming a disk scale length @xmath19 kpc and a dark halo concentration @xmath20 ( where @xmath21 is defined as @xmath22 , with @xmath23 and @xmath24 virial and scale radius of the nfw halo , respectively ) is plotted in fig . [ rotcurve ] . the halo spin parameter , which sets the disk scale length in our modeling , is @xmath25 , where @xmath26 relates the angular momentum @xmath27 and the total energy @xmath28 of a system with virial mass @xmath29 through the relation @xmath30 the initial stellar disk of the satellite galaxy has , within its scale radius @xmath9 , a central mass surface density of @xmath31 ( fig . [ diskprofile ] ) , that corresponds to a b - band surface brightness of @xmath32 , assuming a mass to light ratio @xmath33 . the central gas surface density is only @xmath34 since a significant fraction of gas is distributed in the external disk . assuming @xmath35 hi abundance this value corresponds to an hydrogen column density of @xmath36 within @xmath9 , comparable with the values observed by @xcite with the lmc parkes multibeam hi survey . in order to obtain a strongly stable disk against bar formation even in the presence of significant gas stripping and consequent perturbation of the satellite potential , the thickness of the stellar component is set such that the toomre s @xcite stability criterion is largely satisfied . in particular the toomre s parameter for the stellar disk : @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the radial velocity dispersion , @xmath39 is the local epicyclic frequency and @xmath40 the unperturbed stellar surface density , has a minimum at the disk scale length with @xmath41 . for a gaseous disk the stability of the disk is expressed in terms of the gas sound speed @xmath42 and surface density @xmath43 through the relation : @xmath44 the gaseous disk has initially a constant temperature of 10000 k , which implies @xmath45 and @xmath46 . according to and @xcite , the stability of a multicomponent disk is not guaranteed by the individual stability of its single constituents , due to the mutual gravitational interaction between gas and stars . stars are characterized by velocity dispersions 3 - 4 times larger than the typical sound velocities in the cold gaseous disk and even relatively small variations of the gaseous component parameters can significantly affect the stability of the whole disk . therefore we choose a large value of @xmath47 to contrast the effects of ram - pressure . in the case of a two components - gaseous and stellar - disk , the stability condition is expressed by @xmath48^{-1}>1 , \label{toomretotal}\ ] ] where @xmath49 and @xmath50 . [ qparameter ] illustrates the dependence of @xmath51 on the dimensionless wavenumber of the perturbation @xmath52 within three different regions of the disk : at the disk scale length @xmath9 , at @xmath53 kpc and in the external region ( @xmath54 kpc ) , where the gas component predominates . the criterium is always satisfied and the disk is stable against axisymmetric perturbations , independently of their wavelength . in order to check stability the disk was initially evolved in isolation for 1 gyr . = 8truecm = 8truecm = 8truecm all the simulations we now discuss were carried out using gasoline , a parallel tree - code with multi - stepping @xcite which is an extension of the pure n - body gravity code pkdgrav developed by @xcite . the code uses a spline kernel with compact support where the interaction distance for a particle @xmath55 is set equal to two times the smoothing length @xmath56 , defined as the @xmath57-th neighbour distance from the particle . in this paper @xmath58 . the internal energy of the gas is integrated using the antisymmetric formulation of @xcite that conserves entropy closely . dissipation in shocks is modeled using the quadratic term of the standard @xcite artificial viscosity . the balsara @xcite correction term is used to suppress the viscosity in non - shocking , shearing environments . the code includes radiative cooling for a primordial mixture of hydrogen and helium in collisional equilibrium . at temperatures below @xmath59 k the gas is entirely neutral and due to the lack of molecular cooling and metals , the efficiency of the cooling function drops rapidly to zero . we used a star formation recipe that includes density and temperature criteria , while converging flow criterium is not required in most of the simulations . gas particles are eligible to form stars only if the density of the star formation region has a minimum physical density corresponding to 0.1 hydrogen atoms per @xmath60 @xcite and an overdensity @xmath61 ( katz et al . 1996 ) , which basically restricts star formation to collapsed , virialized regions . the physical density threshold describes the steep drop in star formation rate observed in disk galaxies when the gas surface density is much lower than a critical value @xmath62 @xcite . the density threshold @xmath63 cm@xmath5 is compatible with observational results . according to @xcite , the star forming region has to be part of a converging flow that implies a local negative divergence of the sph velocity field . however , the converging flow criterium was introduced to describe star formation in cosmological simulations , where the geometry of the collapsing regions is approximatively spherical . in the case of star formation regions like 30 doradus , localized at the periphery of the lmc disk where gas particles relatively close in distance can have significantly different kinematics , this criterium leads to underestimate of the star formation rate . therefore the converging flow is not required in most of the simulations . a single run including the converging flow requirement has been performed for comparison . the star formation rate is assumed to be proportional to @xmath65 @xcite , where @xmath66 represents the volume density of the cold gas , and is given by the expression @xcite @xmath67 where the star formation timescale @xmath68 is the maximum between the local gas dynamical collapse time @xmath69 and the local cooling time . if the gas is already cool enough to form stars i.e @xmath70 , then @xmath71 is used . we assumed @xmath72k . the constant star formation rate parameter @xmath73 is chosen such that we reproduce the global lmc star formation rate @xcite . once a gas particle satisfies the above criteria , it spawns stars according to a probability distribution function . in particular , the probability @xmath74 that a gas particle forms stars in a time @xmath75 is modeled as @xmath76 a random number is then drawn to determine whether the gas particle forms stars during @xmath75 . for all the simulations in this paper @xmath77 myr . the newly created collisionless particle has the same position , velocity and softening length as the original gas particle while its mass is a fixed fraction @xmath78 of the parent gas particle , whose mass is reduced accordingly . following @xcite we assumed for our favorite models a star formation efficiency @xmath79 . up to six particles are then created for each gas particle in the disk . after its mass has decreased below @xmath80 of its initial value the gas particle is removed and its mass is re - allocated among the neighbouring particles . in order to study the influence of pure ram pressure on a galaxy model orbiting in a milky way halo , we performed `` wind tunnel '' simulations where the ram - pressure value varies with time . we represent the hot gas as a flux of particles moving along the major axis of an oblong of base equal to the diameter of the dark matter halo of the satellite and height @xmath81 , where @xmath82 is the velocity of the lmc at the perigalacticon and @xmath83 is the time scale of the simulation . the hot particles have an initial random distribution and a temperature @xmath84 . the box has periodic boundary conditions in order to restore the flow of hot gas that leaves the oblong . the galaxy model is at rest at the center of the oblong . kinematical data @xcite indicate that the lmc , presently located at @xmath85 kpc from the galactic center , is just past a perigalactic passage and has an orbital velocity of about 300 km s@xmath86 . recent proper motion measurements by @xcite and @xcite suggest that the velocity of the satellite is substantially higher ( almost 100 km s@xmath86 ) than previously estimated and consistent with the hypothesis of a first passage about the mw @xcite . in both scenarios the cloud is affected by the largest ram - pressure values during the last million years of its orbital evolution . indeed , while in the models proposed by @xcite the lmc does not enter the halo of the mw earlier than 1 gyr ago ( slightly different orbits are found in mastropietro 2008 ) , in m05 we have shown that the change in the orbital parameters due to dynamical friction strongly affects the ram - pressure stripping rate . even in the case of a `` low velocity '' model the largest ram - pressure on the satellite is expected during the last orbital semi - period ( about 1 gyr ) due to the increasing velocity and external gas density . we followed ram - pressure acting on the lmc s igm during the past 1 gyr . the density of the hot external gas increases with time , in such a way that in our low velocity model the external pressure experienced by the cold disk varies from @xmath87 to @xmath88 at the time corresponding to the pericentric passage . this is equivalent of assuming @xmath89 and @xmath90 , and a number density of the external gas that increases from @xmath91 to @xmath92 at @xmath85 kpc from the galactic center . these density values are comparable with those provided by m05 , who modeled the mw hot halo assuming a spherical distribution of gas that traces the dark matter profile , with a mean number density of @xmath93 within 150 kpc . we also consider the eventuality of a less dense galactic halo and performed runs where the gas density is a factor 10 lower . models with higher velocities @xcite and orbital parameters similar to those suggested by @xcite are also explored . in details , @xmath94 is the same as in the low velocity models since the higher orbital velocity at the beginning of the simulation ( about 250 km s@xmath86 ) is compensated by a lower external density ( @xmath95 , according to mastropietro 2008 . indeed 1 gyr ago the satellite has just passed through the virial radius of the mw ) . the maximum pressure felt by the disk is @xmath96 , that corresponds to a cloud moving with @xmath97 through an external hot medium of density @xmath92 . each galaxy model is simulated using 750000 particles , of which @xmath98 are in the dark halo and @xmath99 in the disk ( @xmath100 collisional and @xmath101 collisionless ) . the hot gas in the `` wind tunnel '' has @xmath102 particles , in such a way that the mass ratio @xmath103 between hot particles and particles in the disk is close to the unity even when the halo density is the largest . this choice permits to avoid the presence of scattering and numerical holes which artificially change the shape of the front edge and influence the morphology of the disk ( m05 ) . the gravitational spline softening is set equal to 0.5 kpc for the dark halo and the hot gas in the oblong , while it is 0.2 kpc for stars and gas in the disk . in order to study the effect of pure compression on the density distribution of cold gas in the lmc disk , we have run a first set of simulations where the gas cools radiatively but star formation was not activated . according to @xcite and @xcite , the present angle between the lmc s disk and its proper motion vector is roughly @xmath6 . even neglecting the effects of precession and nutation on the disk plane of the satellite @xcite this angle is expected to vary significantly during an orbital period , especially in the proximity of a pericentric passage due to rapid changes in the velocity vector . different relative orientations of the disk with respect to the orbital motion are therefore investigated . the inclination angle @xmath55 is defined as the angle between the angular momentum vector of the disk and the flux of hot particles in the wind tube , so that a galaxy moving edge - on through the external medium is characterized by @xmath104 , while the observed lmc disk would have @xmath105 . we explored cases with inclination angle @xmath55 of 90 , 45 and @xmath106 ( runs cool90 , cool45 and cool10 , respectively ) . with a hot halo temperature of @xmath107 k the relative velocity between the satellite and the external medium is supersonic ( sound speed @xmath108 km s@xmath86 and mach number @xmath109 and @xmath13 at the pericenter of the low and high velocity orbit , respectively ) and a bow shock forms in front of the disk ( fig . [ shockimage ] ) . since the cooling time of the post - shock gas is @xmath110 gyr , the shock can be considered adiabatic and hydrodynamical quantities at the two sides of the shock front are in first approximation related by the rankine - hugoniot equations for a stationary normal shock . = 8truecm for @xmath111 the jump conditions give @xmath112 and @xmath113 , where subscripts 1 and 2 denote upstream and downstream quantities . the ram - pressure @xmath114 actually felt by the galaxy behind the shock front is therefore smaller than that it would suffer due to the upstream flux of hot particles , but conservation of momentum flux across the shock discontinuity implies that the reduction in dynamical pressure has to be balanced by an increase in thermal pressure ( see also rasmussen et al . 2006 ) . fig . [ shock ] illustrates the behavior of hydrodynamical quantities across the shock discontinuity for a snapshot corresponding to the perigalacticon of a low velocity orbit . the disk inclination is @xmath115 . the horizontal axis is centered on the lmc stellar disk and oriented perpendicularly to the bow shock nose , with the shock located at @xmath116 kpc and the satellite moving towards increasing values of @xmath117 . the mach number derived by the temperature jump is @xmath118 , in good agreement with the theoretical value for a normal shock . only hot halo particles are considered in computations but , due to the sph nature of the simulations , close to the border of the disk we observe a further density increase and a sharp drop in temperature . the @xmath117-velocity profile is plotted in the system of reference where the pre - shock gas is at rest . = 8truecm pressure profiles across the shock are plotted in fig . [ shockpressure ] , where @xmath119 is defined as @xmath120 . the total pressure remains roughly constant until the edge of the disk . the steep increase at @xmath121 kpc is due the rapid growth in density at the border of the disk , which is not immediately followed by a decrease in temperature . for @xmath122 the shock wave is inclined with respect to the initial flow velocity and the rankine - hugoniot conditions apply to the normal components of the velocity across the shock discontinuity , while the component parallel to the shock front remain unchanged . the flow is therefore deflected toward an oblique shock wave and the jump at the shock discontinuity is smaller . an edge - on ( @xmath123 ) disk behaves like a wedge moving supersonically with the vertex facing upstream . if the wedge angle is smaller than or equal to the maximum flow deflection angle , the oblique shock becomes attached to the vertex of the wedge and the flow is deflected so that the streamlines are parallel to the surfaces of the wedge . the shock standoff distance thus depends on the external density profile of the collisional edge - on disk and on the mach number of the incident flow . in both low and high velocity edge - on models the shock results almost attached to the disk . figs . [ densitymaps][densitymaps10 ] illustrate for different values of the inclination angle @xmath55 changes in the disk gas density distribution as the satellite passes through increasing values of the external pressure , moving towards the perigalacticon . each couple of panels illustrates the state of the disk at increasing ( from the top to the bottom ) times along the orbit . panels on the left represent hi column density maps . the density contrast is chosen in order to highlight the density gradient in the external disk , since the gas distribution in the central regions of the lmc is dominated by the presence of the bar and a direct comparison with pure ram - pressure simulations is not possible . the color scale is logarithmic , with white corresponding to a density larger than @xmath124 @xmath125 and blue to values lower than @xmath126 @xmath125 . hot gas particles flow on to the disk from the left to the right of each plot , with increasing ram - pressure values from the first to the fourth image . the disk is seen face on and rotating clockwise . in the case of the edge - on run ( fig . [ densitymaps ] ) cold gas particles lying in the left - bottom quadrant of the disk feel the largest ram - pressure , due to the fact that their relative velocity with respect to the external medium is maximum . the rotational velocity of the external disk is @xmath127 km s@xmath86 , which implies a relative velocity at the pericenter of @xmath128 km s@xmath86 ( 450 km s@xmath86 in the case of a high velocity orbit ) . panels on the right represent the change in mean density and radius of the gaseous external disk as a function of the azimuthal angle @xmath129 . referring to the geometry of the hi density images on the left , @xmath130 corresponds to the bottom of the disk and increases clockwise in such a way that the disk moves in the direction of @xmath131 . the gas density and the mean radius are both calculated within sections of a three dimensional annulus with internal and external radius equal to 7 and 15 kpc , respectively . the initial azimuthal profiles ( not represented in the plots ) are flat since both these quantities have only radial dependence . as soon as the satellite starts moving through the surrounding medium , the external gas density develops a peak centered on @xmath132 : disk particles localized in regions of maximum ram - pressure get compressed and move on inner orbits , while their circular velocity increases consequently . after about a quarter of the orbital period the gas has reached its minimum radius and maximum local density . the gaseous disk becomes strongly asymmetric : compression at the front edge produces a density increase along the left border of the disk , evident in the hi maps even at early times . the high density region forms a thin ( @xmath133 kpc ) but continuous and well defined arc which has not an equivalent in the stellar distribution . at the perigalacticon this feature extends for almost @xmath134 with a density more than one order of magnitude higher than gas located at smaller radii . its average thickness ( @xmath135 1.5 kpc ) and velocity dispersion along the line of sight are larger than the average values in the rest of the disk . in the case of a satellite moving through the hot medium with an inclination angle different from @xmath136 the external pressure directed perpendicularly to the plane of the disk increases as cos@xmath55 while compression at the leading edge is much less pronounced . [ densitymaps45 ] and [ densitymaps10 ] refer to runs with inclination angles @xmath137 and @xmath115 . disks are shown face - on . the increment in density along the leading edge is smaller ( cool45 ) than in the edge - on model and almost absent for @xmath115 ( cool10 ) , while compression perpendicular to the plane of the disk produces local gravitational instabilities in the external gaseous disk ( also mayer , mastropietro & tran in preparation ) . this effect is more evident in the nearly face - on run cool10 where high density filaments delimitate regions where the local density is almost one order of magnitude lower . despite the absence of a peak in the azimuthal mean density profile , the integrated final density of cool10 is comparable to the other runs . [ dennosf ] represents the azimuthally averaged hi column density profile of the final disk configuration for the three simulations . as a result of the increase in density along the edge of the disk , the mean column density shows a secondary peak at large radius . a limb - brightened density profile has actually been observed by @xcite using the parkes multibeam hi survey of the lmc . the outer profiles of cool90 and cool45 are very similar , while in run cool10 the increment in density with respect to the original profile of the disk ( long - dashed red curve in the plot ) is located at larger radii ( @xmath138 kpc ) . indeed , due to compression of the leading edge the final gas distribution of cool90 and cool45 is asymmetric , the dense front edge being much closer to the center than the opposite border of the disk . therefore the hi peak in the external disk is located at relatively small radii , while the azimuthally averaged gas distribution is more extended than in the case of the run cool10 since ram pressure elongates the back side of the disk . again we stress the fact that our gaseous disk is more extended than it would be in a fully self consistent simulation including both gravitational and hydrodynamical forces . as seen in m05 and @xcite the combined effect of ram - pressure and tidal stripping is quite efficient in stripping gas from the outer satellite s disk , creating the tip of the magellanic stream already at large distances from the mw . the high density feature in cool90 would then form along the border of the disk at smaller radii and would not be easily subjected to further stripping due to the relatively ram - pressure values . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ sfruns ] the compressive increase in hi density is naturally associated with excess star formation . sph simulations can not follow the formation of molecular clouds but in first approximation the molecular gas fraction can be related to the density of atomic gas @xcite . the main parameters of star formation simulations are summarized in table [ sfruns ] . as we already mentioned in section 3 , our standard star formation model ( sf ) does not include the converging flow criterium and is characterized by an efficiency @xmath139 @xcite . the star formation rate parameter @xmath73 is initially set equal to @xmath140 . this model was adopted to run wind tube simulations with inclination angles @xmath141 ( sf90 , sf45 , sf10 ) ( table [ sfruns ] ) . we also investigated different star formation recipes requiring converging flows and assuming different values of @xmath73 and @xmath78 . we explored star formation rate parameter values in the range from 0.01 to 0.05 , that produce a star formation rate integrated over the entire disk comparable with the @xmath142 yr@xmath86 provided by @xcite . an efficiency @xmath143 implies that whenever a gas particle satisfies the star formation requirements , it is immediately turned into a single star particle of the same mass @xcite . in the last six simulations listed in table [ sfruns ] we used our standard star formation model sf to investigate the effects of different orbital parameters and gas halo densities runs sfv400 are characterized by a maximum ram pressure value corresponding to a perigalactic velocity of 400 km s@xmath86 @xcite . such high velocity disks when moving face - on through the external hot medium are strongly affected by local instabilities and star formation is consequently enhanced . the introduction of an artificial lower limit for the satellite gas temperature ( in runs sf10v400t12000 and sf10v400t15000 ) , higher than the cut - off in the cooling function , has the effect of reducing gravitational instabilities and fragmentation in the disk . this temperature threshold can be justified in order to crudely model the effect of the uv background and stellar feedback @xcite . finally , with simulations sf90ld and sf10ld in table [ sfruns ] we also consider the possibility of a galactic hot halo ten times less dense than our standard model . [ inclstarform ] illustrates the state of the newly formed stellar disk at increasing times along the satellite orbit . each couple of rows corresponds to one of the first three runs of table [ sfruns ] and is associated with a different inclination angle @xmath55 . the first row of the pair represents the face - on projection of the disk with the galaxy moving towards the left of the page and the same geometry as in fig . [ densitymaps ] . time increases from the left to the right . each small cross indicates a new star formation event at the time of the snapshot ( within a time interval of 40 myr ) while the circle delimitates the external disk ( @xmath144 kpc ) . stars form in the central regions as soon as the star formation algorithm is activated , but here the star formation activity of the inner disk is not represented . the second row represents the total mass @xmath145 of the newly formed stars in the external disk as a function of the disk azimuthal angle @xmath129 . in the case of a galaxy moving edge - on through the external medium ( sf90 ) , stars form at the leading edge of the disk when the ram - pressure becomes larger than @xmath146 dyn @xmath125 , at time @xmath147 gyr . the location of the star formation events initially corresponds to the hi column density peak observed in cool90 around @xmath148 ( fig . [ densitymaps ] ) . later on it expands along the entire front edge , creating a thin stellar arc well distinct from the star formation events that characterize the central disk . as soon as the satellite encounters ram pressure values comparable to those experienced by the lmc at the perigalacticon ( time @xmath149 gyr ) some episodes of star formation occur even on the back side of the disk ( last plot on the top right of fig . [ inclstarform ] ) , although they are not relevant in terms of new stellar mass formed . indeed @xmath145 shows a drastic drop at @xmath150 . runs with inclination @xmath151 are characterized by significant star formation only for values of the external pressure larger than @xmath152 dyn @xmath125 . in the case of the nearly face - on run sf10 , at @xmath153 gyr star formation occurs in the entire external disk . ram - pressure affects the plane of the disk almost perpendicularly and stars form along the delocalized and filamentary high density structures visible in fig . [ densitymaps10 ] ( mayer et al . in prep . ) . contrary to what has been found by @xcite who focused on higher ram - pressure values ( @xmath154 cm@xmath5 and @xmath155 km s@xmath86 ) typical of the outskirts of galaxy clusters , the newly formed stars are all located in the plane of the satellite s disk ( with the exception of the high velocity face - on run sf10v400 where about 10@xmath156 of the stars forms behind the disk ) . the star formation events appear to be distributed nearly homogeneously along the azimuthal profile of the external disk , although a small peak in @xmath145 is observable near @xmath123 . in fact , the orientation of the disk with respect to its orbital motion is not exactly face - on . the case of the intermediate run sf45 is more complex . in a first phase , for low ram pressure values , star formation is produced by compression at the leading edge and a thin star formation front although not so well defined as in the case of a pure edge - on model appears on the east side of the disk . as soon as the external pressure reaches a critical level compression directed perpendicularly to the disk becomes the dominant mechanism driving star formation . + converting sfrs to h@xmath0 luminosities according to @xcite : @xmath157 where sfr is the star formation rate averaged over the last 40 myr ( nearly two times the stellar age of 30 doradus ) , we obtain the h-@xmath0 maps illustrated in fig . [ lalpha ] . high emission regions are mainly concentrated in the external disk ( with the exception of run sfld90 where the ram - pressure exerted by the low density halo is not enough to induce star formation at the edge of the disk ) . the continuous stellar arc forming along the leading side of the disk in edge - on runs breaks up into several distinct and very luminous h-@xmath0 regions that more closely resemble the star - forming complexes observed on the eastern border of the lmc . the inclusion of stellar and supernovae heating which has been neglected in the present simulations could prevent further star - formation around highly emitting regions and consequently produce more compact and isolated star - forming complexes . nevertheless , modeling single star - formation complexes whose linear extension is smaller than our softening length is beyond the scope of this paper . the present inclination of the lmc s disk with respect to the orbital motion is about @xmath158 ( according to the convention adopted in this paper ) . since the satellite is currently near a perigalactic passage we expect the h-@xmath0 map at the leading border of the disk to be something in between pure edge - on runs and the run with inclination of @xmath159 . on the other side , it is very likely that the disk inclination during the phase of approach to the pericenter was different . indeed in @xcite we have simulated the lmc s orbit according to the new proper motion measurements of @xcite and found that the cloud enters the mw halo face - on and moves almost face - on during most of the last 1 gyr . it turns nearly edge - on only at the perigalacticon . this would have a remarkable effect on the star - formation history of the external disk during the last 1 gyr and some impact also on the h-@xmath0 maps . indeed , although the h-@xmath0 emission would be mostly concentrated on the eastern side of the disk due to the very recent edge - on motion , we expect to see some luminous clumps forming a patchy distribution on the entire disk , due to gravitational instabilities and subsequent star - formation induced by a nearly face - on compression of the gaseous disk before 30 myr ago . the high velocity edge - on run sf90v400 presents a more elongated and thinner stellar arc along the leading border , with a geometry similar to that obtained increasing the star formation rate parameter to 0.05 ( sf90c0.05 ) . the h-@xmath0 map of sf90v400 ( third panel of the third raw ) shows two distinct luminosity peaks . one is located at the south - east region of the disk , roughly corresponding to the position of 30doradus and the two compact emission regions n159 and n160 . = 9truecm fig . [ dmdt ] illustrates how the star formation rate of the external disk changes with time in the different models . the three black curves refer to the standard star formation runs sf , characterized by low orbital velocities . the edge - on disk starts forming stars earlier , but for large ram pressure values the star formation rate of sf10 and sf45 grows faster . at the perigalacticon passage sf45 has indeed a higher star formation rate than sf90 . in the case of an isolated lmc model star formation is almost absent for @xmath160 kpc . the remaining curves in fig . [ dmdt ] refer to different star formation recipes ( rows 4 - 9 of table [ sfruns ] ) . the location of the star formation events in the external regions of the disk does not change significantly choosing different parameters in the star formation algorithm . the star formation rate parameter @xmath73 determines the amount of new stars forming but does not affect the minimum threshold in ram - pressure neither the evolution of the star formation rate . in particular , in the case of edge - on runs after an initial steep increment the curve seems to converge to a constant value for increasing external pressures . the consequences of an increased star formation efficiency ( @xmath161 ) are almost negligible ( but not in h@xmath0 maps where only the very recent star formation rate is taken in account : compare the first panels of the first and second row ) while including the convergency requirement ( sfconv ) has nearly the same effect than reducing the star formation rate parameter of a factor two . = 9truecm for convenience , the star formation rate of the last six runs of table [ sfruns ] is plotted separately ( fig . [ dmdtalt ] ) . the high velocity edge - on model sf90v400 is characterized by a steeper increment in star formation at earlier times but later on the curve flattens and the star formation rate at the perigalacticon is similar to that of the low velocity case sf90 . differences in h-@xmath0 maps are produced by a difference of @xmath162 m@xmath163 myr@xmath86 about time = 1 gyr . on the contrary , the star formation generated by compression perpendicular to the disk increases with increasing ram - pressure values ( it shows a decrement only towards the end of the simulation ) and in the case of the high velocity run sf10v400 reaches a peak @xmath164 times higher than in sf10 . the star formation rate of sf10v400 is strongly affected by the introduction of an artificial temperature threshold . with a temperature floor of 15000 k we nearly suppress star formation in the external disk . however , a threshold of 12000 k is already very high for a lmc model and more typical of luminous disk galaxies like the mw . a temperature floor lower than 10000 k would not make sense since below this temperature the cooling function adopted in the present paper drops rapidly to zero . if , as pointed out by @xcite , the satellite is moving almost face - on until it gets very close to perigalacticon , we would not expect to see star formation before 0.6 gyr independently of the orbital velocity . differences between high and low velocity runs should be marginal also near the pericenter since star formation in edge - on runs assuming our standard prescriptions for star formation seems to saturate around @xmath165 m@xmath163 myr@xmath86 . finally , a hot halo ten times less dense than the one assumed in our favorite model would reduce drastically the star formation in a face - on lmc and suppress completely the star formation on the leading edge of the disk . = 9truecm the star formation rate of the entire disk is illustrated in fig . [ dmdttot ] . this plot is only indicative since we neglect the presence of the bar and its influence on the star formation history of the satellite . the star formation rate of a lmc model evolved in isolation is plotted for comparison . the largest contribution to sfr is given by star formation events in the central region of the disk . curves peak between 15 and 35 m@xmath163 myr@xmath86 , comparable with observations of the magellanic clouds photometric survey ( harris et al . in prep ) . the total star formation rate is clearly not affected by ram - pressure before 0.4 gyr . indeed , after an initial sharp increment curves are rather flat despite orientation and intensity of the external pressure . an initial burst in star formation is obtained only by increasing the star formation efficiency parameter to 0.05 . for time@xmath166 0.5 gyr the largest deviations from an average star formation rate of @xmath167 m@xmath163 myr@xmath86 are produced in the edge - on low density run sf90ld , where dm / dt drops to 10 m@xmath163 myr@xmath86 at time = 1 gyr , and in the high velocity face - on model sf10v400 whose star formation rate increases up to @xmath168 m@xmath163 myr@xmath86 toward the end of the simulation . differences among the other models are of the order of few m@xmath163 myr@xmath86 and vary with time so that it would be quite difficult to use the star formation history of the entire disk to test the cloud s orbital parameters and the hot halo density . [ agephi ] represents the mean stellar age of the external disk versus the azimuthal angle @xmath129 for the same selected runs of fig . [ dmdttot ] . the maximum increment in age in a clockwise direction is associated with edge - on runs , where stars forming at the leading edge move , in time , away to the side , due to the clockwise rotation of the disk . the youngest stars are located at @xmath169 . clearly the gradient in age is much weaker in models with @xmath151 . sf10v400 with a mean stellar age of @xmath170 myr forms stars earlier with respect to the other nearly face - on runs , while the difference between sf90v400 and the corresponding low velocity run sf90 is about 5 myr at the leading edge and not significant in the rest of the external disk . for the same runs we also plotted the final radial gas density profile ( fig . [ densf ] ) . in most of the cases a secondary peak is still present . = 8truecm = 8truecm we have performed high resolution `` wind tunnel '' simulations to study the effects of ram - pressure by a tenuous galactic hot halo on the hi morphology of the lmc s disk , its recent star formation history , and location of the youngest star forming regions . we did not focus on the mass loss produced by ram - pressure stripping since this would also be affected by tidal interactions . for the same reason our galaxies do not form any bar and we actually start with a galaxy model very stable against bar formation so that the pure effects of external pressure are more clearly visible . our lmc is a multi - component system with a spherical nfw halo , an exponential stellar disk and a gaseous disk that extends up to 8 times the stellar disk scale length . in each simulation the external flux of hot particles increases with time as the satellite approaches the perigalacticon in such a way that the pressure experienced by the disk is consistent with the lmc s orbital velocity and an average hot halo density of @xmath93 cm@xmath5 within 150 kpc from the galactic center . low velocity runs are characterized by a `` classic '' pericentric velocity of 300 km s@xmath86 @xcite while high velocity runs have velocities compatible with the new proper motion measurements of @xcite . we expect the angle between the lmc s disk and its proper motion to vary significantly during the last billion years of orbital interaction . we have defined the inclination angle @xmath55 as the angle between the angular momentum vector of the disk and the flux of hot particles in the wind tube , so that the observed lmc s disk would have @xmath171 . @xcite performed self consistent nbody / sph simulations of the interacting system mw / lmc adopting orbital constraints from the last lmc s proper motion measurements and found that the cloud enters the mw halo face - on ( @xmath172 ) , moving nearly face - on for most of the last billion years . it turns edge - on only about 30 myr ago . this means that the lmc is moving nearly edge - on close to the perigalactic passage , corresponding to the maximum ram - pressure values , consistently with the actual disk inclination measured by @xcite . we have performed several simulations varying the inclination angle of the disk , the star formation recipe and the intensity of the external pressure . we have shown that : * the compression of the leading border of an edge - on lmc disk can account for the high density hi region observed at the south east . in our simulations this high density feature is well defined ( with a mean density one order of magnitude higher than the surrounding gas ) and localized within 1.5 kpc from the border of the disk . its average thickness and velocity dispersion along the line of sight are larger than the average values in the rest of the disk . in cool90 it extends for almost @xmath134 and could also explain the origin of the spiral arm e described by @xcite , which does not have an equivalent in the stellar disk . * compression directed perpendicularly to the disk ( in runs with @xmath151 ) produces local instabilities in the gas distribution and a clumpy structure characterized by voids and high density filaments similar to those observed by the parkes multibeam hi survey ( see fig . 3 of staveley - smith et al . if the satellite was moving nearly face - on in the past and according to @xcite this is likely to happened during most of the lmc / mw orbital history ram - pressure could be responsible for the general mottled appearance of the hi disk . * as a result of the increase in density along the edge of the disk the mean hi column density shows a secondary peak at large radius , in agreement with observations . * the compression of the satellite s igm is naturally associated with induced star formation activity . we focussed on the external regions of the disk since the central parts of the real lmc would be dominated by the bar . edge - on disks start forming stars earlier , but for large ram - pressure values the star formation rate of runs with @xmath151 grows much faster . the high velocity edge - on model sf90v400 is characterized by a steeper increment in star formation at earlier times but later on the curve flattens and the star formation rate at the perigalacticon is similar to that of the low velocity case sf90 . on the other hand , the star formation generated by a compression perpendicular to the lmc s disk increases with increasing ram - pressure values and in the case of the high velocity run sf10v400 reaches a peak @xmath164 times higher than in sf10 . if the satellite is moving almost face - on until it gets very close to the perigalacticon we would expect not to see star formation before 0.6 gyr independently of the orbital velocity . differences between high and low velocity runs should be marginal also near the pericenter since star formation in edge - on runs assuming our standard prescriptions seems to saturate around @xmath165 m@xmath163 myr@xmath86 . * in edge - on models the star formation of the external disk is characterized by a thin stellar arc along the leading border , well distinct from the star formation events in the central disk . if sfr is converted in h@xmath0 luminosities , this arc breaks in several distinct and very luminous h@xmath0 regions that more closely resemble the star forming complexes observed on the eastern border of the disk . although the h@xmath0 emission is mostly concentrated on the eastern side as a consequence of the very recent edge - on motion , we expect to see some luminous clumps forming a patchy distribution on the entire disk , due to gravitational instabilities and subsequent star formation induced by a nearly face - on compression of the disk before 30 myr ago . as observed by @xcite stellar complexes on the leading edge show a progression in age in the clockwise direction , but a face - on compression in the recent past of the lmc would circumscribe this trend to the youngest stellar regions , with age @xmath173 30 - 40 myr . we would like to thank m - r . cioni , t. kaufmann and n. kallivayalil for useful discussions . the numerical simulations were performed on the zbox1 supercomputer at the university of zurich and on the local sgi - altix 3700 bx2 ( partly funded by the cluster of excellence `` origin and structure of the universe '' ) . this work was partly supported by the dfg sonderforschungsbereich 375 `` astro - teilchenphysik '' .

we use high resolution n - body / sph simulations to study the hydrodynamical interaction between the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) and the hot halo of the milky way . we investigate whether ram - pressure acting on the satellite s ism can explain the peculiarities observed in the hi distribution and the location of the recent star formation activity . due to the present nearly edge - on orientation of the disk with respect to the orbital motion , compression at the leading edge can explain the high density region observed in hi at the south - east border . in the case of a face - on disk ( according to mastropietro et al . 2008 the lmc was moving almost face - on before the last perigalactic passage ) , ram - pressure directed perpendicularly to the disk produces a clumpy structure characterized by voids and high density filaments that resemble those observed by the parkes hi survey . as a consequence of the very recent edge - on motion , the h@xmath0 emission is mainly concentrated on the eastern side where 30 doradus and most of the supergiant shells are located , although some h@xmath0 complexes form a patchy distribution on the entire disk . in this scenario only the youngest stellar complexes show a progression in age along the leading border of the disk . [ firstpage ] methods : n - body simulations hydrodynamics galaxies : interactions galaxies : individual : lmc

nlin0310027

discrete breathers ( db ) have the defining properties of being spatially localized and having time - periodic dynamics . they are also called _ intrinsically localized _ , in distinction to anderson localization triggered by disorder . a necessary condition for their existence is the nonlinearity of the equations of motion of the system , and the existence of discrete breathers has been proved rigorously for some classes of systems @xcite . in contrast to their analogs in continuous systems , the existence of discrete breathers is a generic phenomenon , which accounts for considerable interest in these objects from a physical point of view in the last decade . in fact , recent experiments could demonstrate the existence of discrete breathers in various real systems such as low - dimensional crystals @xcite , antiferromagnetic materials @xcite , josephson junction arrays @xcite , molecular crystals @xcite , coupled optical waveguides @xcite , and micromechanical cantilever arrays @xcite . for a review on the topic see @xcite . more than a decade ago , discrete breathers have been observed in numerical simulations of , among others , the fermi - pasta - ulam ( fpu ) system @xcite , a chain of nonlinearly coupled masses . although existence of db as exact periodic solutions was proved already some years ago for a large class of oscillator networks @xcite ( not containing the fpu system ) , a proof of their existence in the fpu system has been obtained only recently @xcite . a generalization of the concept of db are so - called traveling db , spatially localized solutions which travel along the chain . at least as approximate solutions they have been observed numerically in the fpu system . a proof of their existence , however , has not been achieved so far , and in fact it is doubted that traveling db exist as exact solutions in this system . the theoretical analysis of approximate traveling db is still an open problem which will be tackled in this article . we consider traveling db as long - living transient structures which can be described by an effective hamiltonian as presented in @xcite . we distinguish three types of localized structures , characterized by their degree of localization , which can be found in the fpu dynamics . examples of these different types are plotted in figure 1 , where from type i to type iii the degree of spatial localization is increasing . type i is similar to a standing wave . it is not a proper db , as its localization depends on the system size , but its energy envelope is sort of localized in a finite system . type ii is exponentially localized , but , as the width of the structure is not that small with respect to the intersite distance , it is called a weakly localized db . type iii depicts a strongly localized db , similar to those first discovered numerically @xcite . all three of these structures are observable in fpu systems as ( transient ) traveling localized objects , called traveling discrete breathers , and we will distinguish in the following between these three types when deriving their effective dynamics . three types of traveling db in fpu . type i : weakly localized standing wave . type ii : weakly localized db . type iii : strongly localized db . the red line in the upper plot represents the local energy . , width=453 ] the outline of this article is as follows : section [ sec : fpu ] provides some basic definitions regarding the fpu model . in section [ sec : proc ] , the method of the effective hamiltonian is briefly recalled , providing the necessary ingredients for its application . section [ sec : waves ] succinctly recalls some results from @xcite , describing the motion of db of type i. in section [ sec : weak ] , an effective hamiltonian is constructed for a family of db of type ii , providing a good framework to understand the traveling motion of weakly localized db in fpu chains . finally , in section [ sec : strong ] , the case of strongly localized db is treated . here , instead of calculating the effective hamiltonian explicitly , the so - called peierls - nabarro barrier is computed , which provides already useful information about the moving properties of db of type iii . let us consider a chain of oscillators whose dynamics is determined by the hamiltonian @xmath0,\ ] ] with momenta @xmath1 and positions @xmath2 . @xmath3 and @xmath4 characterize , respectively , the on - site potential and the ( nearest - neighbor ) interaction potential . the fpu model is defined by the choices @xmath5 where @xmath6 . note , however , that the theory of the next section applies to a more general class of models . the method of the effective hamiltonian has been exposed in @xcite in a general framework . it is briefly recalled here before applying it to the fpu model in the subsequent section . let us define a traveling db of ( [ eq : chaingen ] ) as a function of the form @xmath7 where the function @xmath8 is increasing in @xmath9 , and such that @xmath10 . it is localized in @xmath11 ( e.g. , @xmath12 for some @xmath13 ) and periodic in @xmath14 , @xmath15 . to be slightly more general , one may think of @xmath16 being replaced by a function @xmath17 monotonic in @xmath18 , where @xmath19 and @xmath20 is a function of small amplitude , periodic with a frequency which is small compared to @xmath21 . the point is that , in a moving frame with velocity @xmath22 , one sees a discrete breather at rest with frequency @xmath21 . it is generally believed that solutions of the form ( [ eq : tdb ] ) do not exist as exact solutions in generic systems , although a proof of this conjecture has been accomplished only for a certain class of systems @xcite . however , it may be possible to get _ approximate _ traveling db of the form ( [ eq : tdb ] ) when the following conditions can be met : 1 . find a two - parameter family of approximate ( non - traveling ) discrete breathers of ( [ eq : chaingen ] ) of the form @xmath23 where @xmath9 characterizes the amplitude of the db and @xmath24 its position " . typically , for a chain having some translation symmetry , and for fixed @xmath9 , there are two such positions where there is an exact db : a site - centered " db with integer @xmath24 , and a bond - centered " db with half - integer @xmath24 . by interpolating between these exact solutions , approximate db can be constructed for any real @xmath24 . + next , consider the family of functions @xmath25 the idea is that there may be a `` doppler effect '' of the traveling db , @xmath26 , which can be described by adding a phase shift @xmath27 to @xmath28 , where @xmath29 is called the _ momentum _ of the db . the point is that ( [ eq : fammdb ] ) still describes approximate db for small enough @xmath29 . 2 . compute , for each member of the family @xmath30 , the symplectic area @xmath31 with period @xmath32 . in the case where @xmath33 , like for the hamiltonian ( [ eq : chaingen ] ) , one can write @xmath34 where @xmath35 denotes the mean value over one period and @xmath36 is the kinetic energy . this calculation should result in a symplectic area @xmath37 proportional to @xmath9 , or related to @xmath9 by a simple functional relation . if this is not the case , the parametrization in ( [ eq : fammdb ] ) should be changed , indexing the family in terms of @xmath38 . the fact that @xmath37 is a proper choice as a parameter is explained in @xcite . in short , this can be justified by stating that @xmath37 is an adiabatic invariant of the dynamics @xcite . 3 . compute the symplectic form @xmath39 restricted to the coordinates @xmath40 . this is achieved by evaluating @xmath41 which should be non - zero for any @xmath42 , and the restricted symplectic form reads @xmath43 . then , an effective hamiltonian is computed as the mean ( over one period ) of the original hamiltonian along the family of db , @xmath44 and , finally , the dynamics of @xmath42 is given by @xmath45 for small enough @xmath29 , and assuming @xmath46 for @xmath47 ( otherwise shift @xmath48 to have this ) one may expand the effective hamiltonian so that it takes on the form @xmath49 providing that @xmath50 be non - zero and finite . the latter defines an effective inertia , although @xmath50 may be negative . in fact , as discussed in @xcite ( especially in examples of section 6 therein ) , the sign of @xmath50 can be interpreted as the sign of an effective anharmonicity of the breather solutions . the second term in ( [ eq : heffdb2 ] ) is a periodic function ( of period @xmath51 ) which defines a _ peierls - nabarro potential _ for discrete breathers , as introduced and discussed in @xcite . in these papers it is shown that the critical points of @xmath52 correspond to exact discrete breathers of the full model . in the simplest situation there are two types of critical points associated , respectively , with the stable discrete breathers and the unstable ones . the difference of @xmath53 at these points , say @xmath54 and @xmath55 , is called the _ peierls - nabarro barrier _ @xmath56 the absolute value in this equation is necessary in case of negative @xmath50 . for @xmath50 positive , the minima are associated with stable db , and the maxima with unstable db , otherwise the stability is just reversed . in any case , the smaller this barrier is , the higher is the mobility of a traveling discrete breather , and the better it is in general described by the effective hamiltonian . in the next sections we apply this scheme to the analysis of the mobility of various types of localized solutions in the fpu model . in this section , a particular type of localized solutions is considered , termed type i in the introduction , which have the shape of a standing wave . they do not constitute proper db , as the localization depends on the system size . the method of the effective hamiltonian was applied to this type of solutions in @xcite . here , we summarize these results in order to compare them to those for the proper db solutions obtained in the following sections . consider an fpu chain with , say , an odd number @xmath57 , @xmath58 , of masses and periodic boundary conditions . there exists , in the linear regime ( @xmath59 ) , a family of standing waves @xmath60 whose envelope is localized in space , as it is a sine function with wavelength equal to twice the chain length ( see figure [ f1 ] , type i ) . moreover , it is observed numerically that the localization strength is enforced when the nonlinearity is turned on , @xmath61 . this family ( [ eq : standingw ] ) complies with ( [ eq : famdb ] ) , as it is parametrized by @xmath9 and @xmath24 , while @xmath62 is fixed . such a wave can be put into slow motion when @xmath63 and @xmath64 are non - zero . to `` add momentum '' to this standing wave , it is convenient not to follow ( [ eq : fammdb ] ) , but rather to consider the expression @xmath65,\ ] ] where @xmath66 and @xmath29 is taken as the momentum parameter conjugate to @xmath24 . the motivation for favoring this parametrization is related to the structure of the linearized fpu chain and has been explained in @xcite . with these settings , the symplectic area ( [ eq : areadb ] ) can be computed , yielding @xmath67 . the computation of @xmath68 from eq . ( [ eq : taukq ] ) gives @xmath69 , and so the effective symplectic form corresponding to the coordinates @xmath42 is simply canonical . finally , one computes the averaged hamiltonian ( [ eq : heffdb ] ) , obtaining @xmath70 from which the equations of motion @xmath71 are deduced . therefore , to this order of approximation , there is no peierls - nabarro barrier , and the motion of a traveling localized wave ( [ eq : standingw ] ) is a slow drift at constant speed @xmath72 . this result is confirmed by direct numerical simulation of the fpu system in the weakly nonlinear regime , using ( [ eq : swk ] ) as initial condition and plotting the variable @xmath24 versus time @xmath18 ( figure [ fig : thetat ] ) . the prediction of ( [ eq : drift ] ) turns out to be valid for small times @xmath18 . the discrepancy encountered for larger @xmath18 might be reduced by considering higher order terms in ( [ eq : swheff ] ) . the first proof of the existence of db in fpu type systems is due to livi , spicci , and mackay @xcite for a diatomic chain of alternating masses @xmath73 and @xmath74 with large mass ratio @xmath75 . existence of db in monoatomic fpu systems [ as defined in ( [ eq : chaingen ] ) and ( [ eq : w ] ) ] has been proved only recently , either using a variational approach @xcite , or elaborating a technique of central manifold reduction @xcite . the latter existence result obtained by james will be used as a starting point in order to construct a family of db of the form ( [ eq : famdb ] ) . in his formulation @xcite , james works with the force variable @xmath76 which is one - to - one related to the displacements @xmath77 , provided that @xmath78 is invertible . suppose @xmath79 then the main result of @xcite can be formulated as follows : in the fpu system , for @xmath80 sufficiently small , there exist db of the form @xmath81 where @xmath82 denotes the landau order symbol , and @xmath83 satisfies the recurrence relation @xmath84 with the condition @xmath85 as @xmath86 . higher oder terms ( h.o.t . ) have been neglected in ( [ eq : recur ] ) . equivalently , @xmath87 ( with @xmath88 ) must be a homoclinic orbit of the two - dimensional map @xmath89 defined in ( [ eq : recur ] ) . in this map , the parameters are defined as @xmath90 where @xmath91 has to be positive in order to guarantee existence of db . so the assumption @xmath92 implies that @xmath93 in ( [ eq : kappagamma ] ) . in addition , let us suppose that @xmath94 . then , ( [ eq : recur ] ) can be approximated by the differential equation @xmath95 with @xmath96 . equation ( [ eq : ode_v ] ) has a family of solutions homoclinic to @xmath97 , namely @xmath98 } \ ] ] parametrized by @xmath99 . hence , one deduces an approximate analytic expression for ( [ eq : yn ] ) , reading @xmath100 } \ ] ] which represents a family of approximate db of the form ( [ eq : famdb ] ) . as an example , a member of this family is plotted in figure [ f1 ] ( type ii ) for @xmath101 . finally , substituting @xmath28 by @xmath102 in the cosine function with @xmath103 , provides the family of functions @xmath104 } \ ] ] of the form ( [ eq : fammdb ] ) which can serve as a good starting point for the construction of an effective hamiltonian for ( approximate ) traveling db . equation ( [ eq : analytic_yn0 ] ) is recovered for @xmath105 . the family ( [ eq : analytic_yn ] ) is indexed by three independent parameters , @xmath106 , @xmath107 , and @xmath108 . the hamiltonian ( [ eq : chaingen ] ) is written in canonical coordinates @xmath109 . it turns out to be convenient to work in relative coordinates @xmath110 defined by @xmath111 and in the following we will rewrite the fpu hamiltonian [ ( [ eq : chaingen ] ) with @xmath112 as well as the family of db ( [ eq : analytic_yn ] ) in these coordinates . we assume the original coordinates to satisfy the conditions @xmath113 for the new variables , these relations imply @xmath114 in addition , it will be assumed that @xmath115 . then the change of variables ( [ eq : rhoj ] ) is invertible . for example , for given @xmath116 , one can compute @xmath117 moreover , the transformation is canonical since @xmath118 in the new coordinates , the fpu hamiltonian takes on the form @xmath119 and the canonical equations read @xmath120 or , equivalently , @xmath121 in order to compute an effective hamiltonian from ( [ eq : h_jrho ] ) we need to express the family of db ( [ eq : analytic_yn ] ) in terms of the variables @xmath122 . this is achieved by considering the simple approximation @xmath123 which is valid due to @xmath124 being small . the corresponding momentum @xmath125 can be deduced from ( [ eq : jdot ] ) , yielding @xmath126 } \label{eq : jn}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath127 } $ ] has been chosen . note that assuming @xmath122 to be small does not imply that ansatz ( [ eq : analytic_yn ] ) can be considered as a wave - packet obeying the linearized equations of motion . in fact , the linear limit @xmath128 renders ( [ eq : analytic_yn ] ) singular . in this section , we show that the effective dynamics of approximate traveling db ( [ eq : analytic_yn ] ) can be described by the hamiltonian @xmath129 this result is obtained by following the procedure recalled in section [ sec : proc ] : first , compute the symplectic area @xmath130 using ( [ eq : rhodot ] ) , this expression can be written in terms of @xmath131 only , reading @xmath132 substituting ( [ eq : jn ] ) in this equation yields @xmath133 } - \frac { \cos k } { \cosh [ \kappa ( n+1 - q ) ] \cosh [ \kappa ( n - q ) ] } \right\}.\ ] ] this series can be estimated making use of the poisson summation formula @xmath134 where the coefficients @xmath135 of the fourier series are the integer sampling of the fourier transform @xmath136 the advantage of this formula is that it is sufficient to keep only a few terms in the fourier series ( [ eq : poissonsum ] ) when @xmath135 decreases rapidly for @xmath137 . here one obtains @xmath138 } = \frac { 2 } { \kappa } + \frac { 4 \pi ^2 } { \kappa ^2 \sinh \left ( \frac { \pi ^2 } { \kappa } \right ) } \cos ( 2 \pi q ) + \mathcal{o } \left [ { \textstyle \exp\left(-\frac { 4 \pi ^2 } { \kappa}\right ) } \right]\ ] ] and @xmath139 \cosh [ \kappa ( n - q ) ] } = \frac { 2 } { \sinh \kappa } .\ ] ] for small @xmath140 , which corresponds to our assumption of @xmath141 being small , the second term in ( [ eq : pois1 ] ) is exponentially small compared to the first one . neglecting this small term and using ( [ eq : kappagamma ] ) , the area reads @xmath142.\ ] ] this result indicates that ansatz ( [ eq : analytic_yn ] ) does not define a family of db whose area @xmath37 is independent of @xmath29 . consequently , following section [ sec : proc ] , one should in principle reparametrize this family by considering the change of variables @xmath143 . on the other hand , and for the sake of simplicity , one may assume @xmath103 and , again , @xmath140 small , to obtain @xmath144 at lowest order . in this case , @xmath37 is proportional to @xmath140 and no change of parametrization is needed . next , following section [ sec : proc ] , the restriction @xmath145 of the symplectic form to the coordinates @xmath42 , is determined . from ( [ eq : taukq ] ) , using a similar technique as for the computation of @xmath37 , one finds at lowest order @xmath146 then , the effective hamiltonian @xmath147 { \mathrm d}t \nonumber \\ & = & \frac { \kappa } { 2\gamma } ( 3 - \cos k ) + \mathcal{o } \left(\kappa ^2 \right ) + { { \sf v}^{\rm eff}}(q ) \label{eq : hefftdb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] is computed . the effective potential @xmath53 defines a peierls - nabarro potential for traveling db @xcite . it is a periodic function of period @xmath51 whose first fourier term reads @xmath148 , with @xmath149 and the so - called peierls - nabarro barrier is defined by @xmath150 . as discussed above for eq . ( [ eq : pois1 ] ) , for values of @xmath151 consistent with our hypothesis @xmath152 , such a term is exponentially small and therefore negligible . the velocity @xmath22 of the db can be estimated from the effective equations of motion ( [ eq : effdyn ] ) , finding @xmath153 let us compare this result with the group velocity of a wave packet with wavenumber @xmath29 , @xmath154 following from the dispersion relation of the linear chain @xmath155 . therefore , assuming @xmath156 , ( [ eq : qdot ] ) and ( [ eq : domega ] ) are equal to first order in @xmath157 , and one can write approximately @xmath158 in conclusion , the velocity of the approximate traveling db given by ( [ eq : analytic_yn ] ) is very close to the group velocity of the corresponding linear wave packet . let us note that this observation was already reported in @xcite , although in this reference eq . ( [ eq : qdot_approx ] ) was not deduced , but rather taken as an assumption . the result is also confirmed by numerical integration of the equations of motion , illustrated in figure [ fig:3](a ) . let us remark that ansatz ( [ eq : analytic_yn ] ) does not behave like a linear wave packet . firstly , it has already been mentioned that this ansatz has a singular behavior in the linear limit @xmath159 . secondly , the maximum amplitude of a true linear wave packet would evolve in time like @xmath160 . for the weakly localized db ( [ eq : analytic_yn ] ) , however , the amplitude is approximately proportional to the area @xmath37 , and is therefore predicted to be approximately constant in time . this difference in the time evolution is confirmed by numerical simulation . in figure [ fig:3](b ) , the time evolution of the ( inverse of the ) db amplitude @xmath161 is plotted for two cases , namely with and without the presence of a nonlinearity , showing , respectively , a decreasing and a constant ( in time ) amplitude . in this section , we will not explicitly compute an effective hamiltonian , although this should be possible . instead , we will restrict ourselves to estimating the peierls - nabarro barrier directly from the properties of static ( = non - traveling ) db . two kinds of strongly localized db ( called type iii " in figure [ f1 ] ) were found in the early numerical simulations of intrinsic localized modes of anharmonic lattices . their shapes were approximately represented as @xmath162 known respectively as the page mode ( p ) , which is stable , and the sievers - takeno mode ( st ) , which is unstable . the approximations ( [ eq : pandst ] ) are used for large @xmath163 @xcite , and thus are valid in a regime different from the one for which ansatz ( [ eq : analytic_yn ] ) holds . as an family of db , interpolating between the p and the st mode , we use a compact approximation ( proposed by kivshar @xcite in a different context ) , namely @xmath164 where @xmath165 is a truncated cosine defined by latexmath:[\[\label{eq : truncos } u ( n ) = \left\{\begin{array}{c@{\quad}l } \cos \left ( \frac { \pi } { 3 } n\right ) & \mbox{if\ } and @xmath20 is a jacobi elliptic function , e.g. , @xmath167 ( modulus @xmath168 in @xcite ) . although it is known that the fpu system does not support compact solutions @xcite , a convergence towards a compact function @xmath165 [ albeit not exactly towards the truncated cosine ( [ eq : truncos ] ) ] is observed in the large amplitude limit (= the limit of strong localization ) . therefore , ( [ eq : compdb ] ) is used here as a sketchy approximation from which the , likewise sketchy , st and the p modes ( [ eq : pandst ] ) are recovered for integer and half - integer values of @xmath24 , respectively . equation ( [ eq : compdb ] ) defines a family of approximate db , complying with the requirements of ( [ eq : famdb ] ) , and , following the procedure of section [ sec : proc ] , it could be used to construct an effective hamiltonian . instead of doing so , we will proceed straight away to the estimation of the peierls - nabarro barrier from properties of the static db , extending the results presented in @xcite . let us first estimate the area of each member of the family ( [ eq : compdb ] ) . a simple substitution of this ansatz in ( [ eq : areadb ] ) yields @xmath169 where @xmath170 or @xmath171 , and @xmath172 denotes the mean value over one period . inserting ( [ eq : truncos ] ) , @xmath173 for both the p and the st mode . therefore , the two modes have same area if @xmath174 ( where the symbols @xmath175 and @xmath176 represent , respectively , any integer or half - integer value @xmath24 ) . this equation is equivalent to saying that @xmath177 is a function of @xmath178 , e.g. @xmath179 , and the function @xmath180 can be evaluated at least numerically . let us denote the corresponding periods @xmath181 and @xmath182 . then the peierls - nabarro barrier can be computed as the difference between the energies @xmath183 and @xmath184 numerical simulations were performed in order to check the validity of the approximations ( [ eq : hst ] ) and ( [ eq : hp ] ) , and hence of the underlying assumptions ( [ eq : compdb ] ) and ( [ eq : truncos ] ) . as parameter values , we chose @xmath185 , @xmath186 , and @xmath187 in the interaction potential ( [ eq : w ] ) . discrete breathers can be calculated numerically up to machine precision , for example by means of a continuation of periodic orbits from the anticontinuous limit @xcite . we have computed four different quantities related to the mobility of a discrete breather , which are compared in figure [ pnbarrier ] . 1 . numerically exact peierls - nabarro barrier : computing st and p modes with the same value of the symplectic area @xmath37 , the numerically exact peierls - nabarro barrier @xmath188 can be obtained as the difference in energy between the two modes ( dashed in figure [ pnbarrier ] ) . an approximation to the peierls - nabarro barrier : equations ( [ eq : hst ] ) and ( [ eq : hp ] ) allow to approximate the peierls - nabarro barrier by computing the difference between their right hand sides ( solid in figure [ pnbarrier ] ) . the values @xmath189 , @xmath190 , and @xmath191 have been used , which are found when @xmath20 is assumed to be a cosine function . the values of the oscillation periods @xmath192 and @xmath193 , as well as the ( maximum ) db amplitudes @xmath178 and @xmath177 , have been extracted from the numerical data . 3 . a second approximation to the peierls - nabarro barrier : computing discrete breathers numerically , one notices that the oscillation periods @xmath192 and @xmath193 corresponding to the same value of the symplectic area @xmath37 are clearly different , and @xmath194 . in fact , it is observed that the main contribution to the above approximation ( 2 . ) of the peierls - nabarro barrier @xmath195 stems from the kinetic part , @xmath196 this quantity is used as a second approximation of the peierls - nabarro barrier ( dotted in figure [ pnbarrier ] ) . an upper bound on the depinning energy : the aim of the computation of the peierls - nabarro barrier is to obtain an estimate of the energy necessary to `` depin '' a discrete breather ( i.e. , to kick a static db such that it starts traveling along the lattice ) . an upper bound on the depinning energy ( points in figure [ pnbarrier ] ) can be obtained from a simple numerical experiment which consists in kicking a static db with a certain momentum distribution , make it evolve in time by means of numerical integration of the equations of motion , and see if it starts traveling along the lattice . this procedure , of course , depends strongly on the momentum distribution applied , and a rough numerical optimization scheme was employed in order to approximate the minimum energy necessary for depinning . different approximations for the peierls - nabarro barrier @xmath195 versus the symplectic area @xmath37 . dashed : numerically exact peierls - nabarro barrier , solid : approximation ( 2 . ) , dotted : `` kinetic '' approximation ( 3 . ) , points : upper bound on the depinning energy ( see text for details ) . , width=321 ] since ansatz ( [ eq : compdb ] ) is supposed to be valid in the limit of large @xmath197 ( @xmath198 with our choice of parameters ) , large values of the db amplitude ( and hence the symplectic area @xmath37 ) have been considered . however , the quality of the approximations does not change significantly with increasing @xmath37 , and the relative error between exact result and approximation seems to be more or less constant . the quality of the approximations is reasonable , albeit not excellent , differing from the exact peierls - nabarro barrier roughly by a factor of two . when computing numerically the peierls - nabarro barrier @xmath199 for some value of the symplectic area @xmath37 , we were surprised to find @xmath200 . typically , a stable mode is expected to correspond to the minima of the peierls - nabarro potential , and an unstable mode to the maxima . finding the reverse situation , we conclude that the motion of a traveling db in the fpu system is effectively described by the dynamics of a particle with negative effective mass in the peierls - nabarro potential . the upper bound on the depinning energy we found in the numerical experiment differs from the peierls - nabarro barrier roughly by a factor of two . a more refined optimization of the momentum distribution employed in the depinning experiment might further improve the match . effective hamiltonians are constructed for various types of db which can be found in the fpu model . these types , labelled type i , ii , and iii in figure [ f1 ] , are characterized by their degree of spatial localization . type i is not a true discrete breather , as its localization depends on the system size , but it represents a localized wave which can be set into motion . the peierls - nabarro barrier is found to be zero in first approximation , and the localized wave travels at constant speed . an explicit estimate shows that this speed is not a group velocity and depends on the system size . db of type ii are called weakly localized . they are small in amplitude and can be analytically approximated by employing a recent result by james @xcite , proving existence of db in the fpu system . in this case , the peierls - nabarro barrier is found to exist , but it is negligible , being exponentially small with respect to the db amplitude . db of type ii are found to travel at a speed approximately equal to the group velocity of the corresponding wave packet , but , in contrast to the wave packet , without dispersion . this group velocity is much smaller than the sound velocity . finally , db of type iii are considered , being strongly localized and having an amplitude which is not small . the well - known page and sievers - takeno modes are of this type , and numerically they have frequently been observed in a traveling state . it should be possible to provide an analytic estimate of their traveling speed by constructing an effective hamiltonian , following the procedure of section [ sec : proc ] and making use of ansatz ( [ eq : compdb ] ) , but this is yet to be done . the important feature which distinguishes db of type iii from those of type ii is that their peierls - nabarro barrier is non - negligible . this barrier is estimated without explicitly computing the effective hamiltonian , and the estimate is in reasonable agreement with the energy necessary to render a db mobile in a numerical experiment . s. acknowledges r. s. mackay for his suggestion to continue the work initiated in @xcite in the direction opened by g. james . the latter is acknowledged for interesting discussions . part of this work was done during m. k.s stay at the universit di firenze , italy , in the group of roberto livi . work supported in part by the european community s human potential program under contract hprn - ct-1999 - 00163 , locnet . a. berger , r. s. mackay , and v. m. rothos , _ a criterion for non - persistence of travelling breathers for perturbations of the ablowitz - ladik lattice _ , discrete contin . systems b , * 4 * ( 2004 ) , 911920 . g. james and p. noble , _ breathers on diatomic fpu chains with arbitrary masses _ , in localization and energy transfer in nonlinear systems , 225232 , editors : l. vzquez , r. s. mackay , and m. p. zorzano , world scientific , singapore 2003 . d. mandelik , h. s. eisenberg , y. silberberg , r. morandotti , and j. s. aitchison , _ observation of mutually trapped multiband optical breathers in waveguide arrays _ lett . , * 90 * ( 2003 ) , 253901 . m. sato , e. hubbard , l. q. english , a. j. sievers , b. ilic , d. a. czaplewski , and h. g. craighead , _ study of intrinsic localized vibrational modes in micromechanical oscillator arrays _ , chaos , * 13 * ( 2003 ) , 702715 . sepulchre , _ energy barriers in coupled oscillators : from discrete kinks to discrete breathers _ , in localization and energy transfer in nonlinear systems , 102129 , editors : l. vzquez , r. s. mackay , and m. p. zorzano , world scientific , singapore 2003 . b. i. swanson , j. a. brozik , s. p. love , g. f. strouse , a. p. shreve , a. r. bishop , w .- z . wang , and m. i. salkola , _ observation of intrinsically localized modes in a discrete low - dimensional material _ , phys . * 82 * ( 1999 ) , 32883291 .

for the fermi - pasta - ulam chain , an effective hamiltonian is constructed , describing the motion of approximate , weakly localized discrete breathers traveling along the chain . the velocity of these moving and localized vibrations can be estimated analytically as the group velocity of the corresponding wave packet . the peierls - nabarro barrier is estimated for strongly localized discrete breathers . michael kastner physikalisches institut , theoretische physik i , universitt bayreuth 95440 bayreuth , germany jacques - alexandre sepulchre institut non linaire de nice 1361 route des lucioles , 06560 sophia antipolis , france

0809.0187

corot is a space experiment devoted to asteroseismology and extrasolar planet search through the observations of planetary transits . it has recently discovered a hot jupiter , corot - exo-2b , orbiting with a period of 1.743 days around a main - sequence g7 star which displays a remarkable photospheric activity @xcite . given the late spectral type and short rotation period ( about 4.5 days ) of the star , its activity is regarded as the manifestation of magnetic fields in the atmosphere , amplified and modulated by a hydromagnetic dynamo . in this paper , we present some preliminary results about the spot modelling of such a star , indicated as corot - exo-2a , which is a good proxy for the young sun , probably at an age of approximately 0.5 gyr @xcite . a detailed account of the results obtained from the spot modelling of the light curve of corot - exo-2a will be provided in @xcite . corot - exo-2a was observed from may 16 to october 5 , 2007 . we extracted from the data archive the n2 chromatic light curves having a sampling of 512 s during the first week and 32 s thereinafter . the red , green and blue fluxes were summed up to get the white light flux and transits were removed by means of the ephemeris and parameters of @xcite . we initially disregarded all data points at a distance from the mean greater than 4.2 standard deviations of the whole data set ; then , we subtracted a moving - median filtered version of the light curve ( box - car extension : 1 orbital period of the satellite , i.e. , 6184 s ) and discarded the points at a distance greater than 3 standard deviations of the residuals . finally , we computed normal points by binning the data on a time interval of one orbital period of the satellite . we apply the maximum entropy ( hereinafter me ) spot modelling method of @xcite , to whom we refer the reader for more details . the model assumes that the photosphere of the star is subdivided into 200 surface elements of size @xmath1 which are covered by cool spots , solar - like faculae and unperturbed photosphere . following @xcite and @xcite , who suggested that faculae have a secondary role in the light variations of late - type stars significantly more active than the sun , we neglect solar - like faculae in this preliminary study and defer their consideration to @xcite . the fraction of the area of each surface element covered by cool spots is given by the filling factor @xmath2 , so @xmath3 is the fraction occupied by the unperturbed photosphere . a stable and unique map , specified by the vector of the filling factor values @xmath4 , is derived by minimizing a linear combination of the chi square @xmath5 and the entropy functional @xmath6 , i.e. : @xmath7 where the lagrangian multiplier @xmath8 rules the trade - off between light curve fitting , as measured by the @xmath5 , and the regularization , as measured by the entropy functional @xmath6 . the optimal lagrangian multiplier is determined iteratively by making the mean of the residuals deviate by one standard error of the normal points from the value obtained without regularization ( see * ? ? ? the stellar parameters are taken from @xcite and @xcite . the stellar rotation axis is assumed to be perpendicular to the orbital plane of the planet . the spot temperature is assumed @xmath9 k below that of the unperturbed photosphere . the light curve is divided into 45 subsets of duration 3.15611 days because the rapid change of the spot pattern does not allow us to obtain a good fit with longer time intervals ( cf . * ; * ? ? ? * for the case of the sun ) . the lomb - scargle periodogram gives a period of the rotational modulation of @xmath10 days . the sequence of best fits obtained with our me model is shown in fig . [ lanzaf1 ] together with the residuals versus time . the best fit is always very good , with an average standard deviation of @xmath11 in relative units . since the inclination of the stellar rotation axis is very close to @xmath12 , only the distribution of the spotted area vs. longitude can be derived through the spot modelling . we plot the normalized spot filling factor versus longitude and time in fig . [ lanzaf2 ] . the longitude increases in the same direction of the stellar rotation and the orbital motion of the planet . the adopted rotation period for the model star is 4.5221 days . the star shows two active longitudes one of which does not migrate appreciably in the adopted reference frame , i.e. , has a rotation period of 4.5221 days , while the other shows a slow migration indicating a rotation period of 4.5543 days . interpreted in terms of surface differential rotation , this indicates a significantly smaller relative amplitude than in the sun , i.e. , about 1 percent . individual spots show an angular velocity about 1.3 percent smaller than that of the active longitudes . the total spotted area is plotted vs. time in fig . [ lanzaf3 ] and shows a cyclic oscillation with a period of @xmath13 days , as derived from lomb - scargle periodogram . it is interesting to note that such a period is close to 10 times the synodic period of the planet as seen by the active longitude pattern rotating in 4.5221 days . this may suggest a possible star - planet magnetic interaction ( see @xcite and @xcite for a possible interpretation ) . it is important to notice that a different spot temperature gives different absolute values of the spotted area , but does not affect the cyclic variation we have found . such a variation is not readily apparent from the light modulation because two spots on opposite hemispheres are usually responsible for the flux variations observed in corot - exo-2a , thus the light curve amplitude is not a good indicator of the total spotted area in this star . , where @xmath2 is the spot covering factor and @xmath14 its maximum value , versus time and longitude for our me spot models . the two dashed vertical lines mark longitudes @xmath15 and 360@xmath16 beyond which the distributions are repeated to easily identify spot migration . the contour levels are separated by 10 percent of the maximum filling factor , with light yellow indicating the maximum covering factor and dark blue the minimum . ] the present study is based on observations obtained with corot , a space project developed and operated by the french space agency , cnes , with partecipation of the science program of esa , estec / rssd , austria , belgium , brazil , germany and spain . afl , ip , gl and sm have been partially supported by the italian space agency ( asi ) under contract asi / inaf i/015/07/0 , work package 3170 . 9 alonso , r. , auvergne , m. , baglin , a. , ollivier , m. , moutou , c. , et al . 2008 , a&a , 482 , l21 bouchy , f. , queloz , d. , deleuil , m. , loeillet , b. , hatzes , a. p. , et al . 2008 , a&a , 482 , l25 gondoin , p. 2008 , a&a , 478 , 883 lanza , a. f. 2008 , a&a , 487 , 1163 lanza , a. f. , rodon , m. , pagano , i. , barge , p. , llebaria , a. 2003 , a&a , 403 , 1135 lanza , a. f. , rodon , m. , pagano , i. 2004 , a&a , 425 , 707 lanza , a. f. , bonomo , a. s. , rodon , m. 2007 , a&a , 464 , 741 lanza , a. f. , pagano , i. , leto , g. , messina , s. , aigrain , s. , et al . 2008 , a&a , submitted lockwood , g. w. , skiff , b. a. , henry , g. w. , henry , s. , radick , r. r. , baliunas , s. l. , donahue , r. a. , soon , w. 2007 , apjs , 171 , 260

we present a preliminary analysis of the photospheric activity of corot - exo-2a , a young g7v star accompanied by a transiting hot jupiter recently discovered by corot . we apply spot modelling techniques developed for the analysis of the sun as a star and capable to extract from corot high precision light curves information on the variation of the total spotted area and the longitude of active regions along the 142 days of the observations . this preliminary analysis shows that the active regions form within two active longitudes separated by about @xmath0 and rotating with periods of 4.5221 and 4.5543 days , respectively , and that the total spotted area oscillates with a period of about 28.9 days . address = inaf - osservatorio astrofisico di catania , via s. sofia , 78 , 95123 catania , italy address = inaf - osservatorio astrofisico di catania , via s. sofia , 78 , 95123 catania , italy address = inaf - osservatorio astrofisico di catania , via s. sofia , 78 , 95123 catania , italy address = inaf - osservatorio astrofisico di catania , via s. sofia , 78 , 95123 catania , italy address = laboratoire dastrophysique de marseille , umr 6110 , cnrs , universit de provence , traverse du siphon , 13376 marseille , france address = lesia , cnrs umr 8109 , observatoire de paris , 5 place j. janssen , 92195 meudon , france

0705.0330

a key component to understanding star formation lies in determining the dynamical nature of globules and cores of molecular clouds from which stars form . this is typically done using molecular lines , and observations of asymmetry or self - reversal in the line profiles of optically thick species portray the motion of the outer layers of material within a cloud . many of the spectra measured from starless cores and globules have blue asymmetirc profiles , such that the blue side of the profile is stronger than the red side , suggestive of red - shifted self - absorption and infall motion . for example , in their survey of starless cores , @xcite found that approximately one third of the cores they observed displayed bona fide infall motions in the outer layers and therefore were consistent with expectations of collapse . in this survey and in a number of others , however , there were a number of cores that displayed evidence for blue - shifted self - absorption in their spectra , e.g. , cb246 , l1521f and l429 - 1 . this is an indication of expansion but with no protostar in the core , what mechanism drives the expanding motions ? there are also cores and globules which show both redshifted and blueshifted self - absorption simultaneously in a single map of one molecular transition , for example , l1512 , l1689b , l1544 @xcite , and b68 @xcite . other cores and globules have spectra that shift from redshifted to blueshifted self - absorption depending on which molecular transition is observed . for example , self -absorption in the source l1157 is redshifted in the hco@xmath0(@xmath4 ) line profile but blueshifted in the hco@xmath0(@xmath5 ) line profile @xcite . clearly complex motions are occurring in the various layers of the cores but it is not clear what causes them . @xcite concluded that the pattern of redshifted and blueshifted self - absorption observed across the source in l1689 is caused by rotational motion in the globule . in b68 , where the spatial pattern switches from blueshifted to redshifted profiles both east and west of the center of the globule , the observed line profiles can not be explained by rotation . @xcite proposed that b68 could be in a quasi - stable state near hydrostatic equilibrium , and the systematic velocity field observed is likely to be caused by oscillatory motions within the outer layers of the globule . for stable and quasi - stable clouds , such motions are predicted by theory , e.g. , @xcite showed that small amounts of rotation can cause an initially gravitationally unstable cloud to stabilize and oscillate ; @xcite in considering the thermal and dynamical balance in low mass dense cores find that a quasi - equilibrium state can be established , which is not static but is pulsationally stable , and in their hydrodynamic study of starless cores , @xcite found that cores could oscillate with periods of about one million years ( or the sound crossing time ) if perturbed by a modest external force . such oscillatory behavior is a signature of dynamical equilibrium , and therefore , the presence of such complex patterns in their spectral line maps could indicate pulsationally stable initial states for the star - forming cores and globules . in this study , we have obtained high angular resolution spectra of the source listed in the catalogue of @xcite as . it is a small , round , dark globule situated in the pipe nebula with no associated iras , msx or spitzer space telescope point sources , and is therefore almost certainly starless . its distance has not been directly determined but it is associated with the pipe nebula , for which some distance estimates have been made . the most reliable estimate to date is 130 pc determined by using infrared extinction measurements for hipparcos stars , @xcite . in their bonnor - ebert sphere fitting analysis , however , @xcite report a distance of 70 pc , which compares to the value of 90 pc derived in a similar fashion for b68 , also , incidently , part of the pipe nebula complex . in this paper , we adopt the @xcite distance of 130 pc . the angular diameter of , as apparent in optical images , is @xmath2 4.5@xmath6 , which is @xmath2 35,000 au ( 0.17 pc ) at 130 pc . section [ sec : obs ] describes our observations of , and [ sec : results ] , is a description of the results . we detected expanding motions in hco@xmath0and cs line profiles across the surface of but since no protostar has been detected , the source of this expansion is a mystery . in [ sec : disc ] , we show that the core is bound and self - gravitating and we propose that pulsation or oscillatory motion within the cloud layers may account for the observed expanding motions . finally , we present evidence for molecular depletion in the central regions of the core . the observations reported here were made in july 2003 using the 30-m iram millimeter - wave telescope at pico veleta in spain . the dual mixer , dual - channel receiver was tuned to observe the molecules listed with their respective frequencies , beamwidths and velocity resolutions in table [ tb : linpars ] . the frequency - switching mode was used to obtain the observations , and system temperatures were 150 - 200 k. the chopper wheel method was used for calibration . the spectrometer is an autocorrelator configured to give the velocity resolutions listed in table [ tb : linpars ] . beam efficiencies were @xmath2 0.75 for the lower frequency 80 - 115 ghz range , and @xmath2 0.6 for the higher frequency 197 - 266 ghz range . observations were made in a grid with a reference position at , . hco@xmath0 , and were uniformly sampled such that a region centered on the reference position was observed every 24@xmath7 out to a maximum distance of 96 @xmath7 in right ascension and 120@xmath7 in declination , a total of 9 @xmath8 11 or 99 spectra for each species . this grid spacing is approximately one beamwidth , slightly over for hco@xmath0 and under for c@xmath1o . the n@xmath9h@xmath0 and cs emission was much weaker and less extended so the grid size was reduced to 5 @xmath8 5 around the reference point with an additional two measurements directly north , east , south and west of the center , resulting in a total of 33 spectra for these species . the spacing between measurements was also 24@xmath7 , approximately one beamwidth for each of the molecules . data reduction was done using the standard iram package class and idl ( interactive data language by research systems , inc . ) . figure [ spec ] shows the , and spectra at the reference position . the cs and hco@xmath0 profiles display a split asymmetric , double - peaked shape while the c@xmath1o line is single - peaked , though slightly asymmetric . the c@xmath1o line appears to bisect the cs and hco@xmath0 profiles in velocity indicating that the two latter lines are likely optically thick and self - reversed . the blue - shifted sense of the self - absorption in the self - reversals is indicative of expansion motions in the outer cloud layers . individual spectra of the hco@xmath0 and emission from across are simultaneously displayed in figure [ c18ohcomap ] for comparison . examination of the figure shows similar double - peaked , self - reversed hco@xmath0 emission profiles at several positions around the center of the globule . in all cases the sense of the asymmetry is the same suggesting expansion of the outer cloud layers . in most other positions the hco@xmath0 lines display blue - shifted self - absorption relative to c@xmath1o , also consistent with expansion motions . as can be seen in figure [ c18ocsmap ] cs spectra are also clearly self - reversed with blue - shifted self - absorption similar to the hco@xmath0 lines in positions where the hco@xmath0 was also self - reversed , but the signals have lower intensity . similar to hco@xmath0 , the other cs spectra appear to exhibit asymmetric profiles relative to c@xmath1o with a sense indicative of expansion motions . the critical density ( @xmath10 @xmath11 ) at which cs emission occurs is the same as that for hco@xmath0 emission ( ungerechts et al . 1997 ) so it is reasonable to assume that the two emission lines probe the same layer of material in the cloud . a rough estimate of the expansion speed of material was determined by comparing the velocity of the stronger hco@xmath0 peak to the peak velocity of a c@xmath1o spectrum at the same position . the peak velocities were obtained by fitting gaussian line profiles to the spectral lines . this resulted in velocity differences which are all negative confirming that the blueshifted profiles are characteristic of expansion , and indicating that material is expanding in the cloud over the whole layer under observation with a mean expansion velocity of -0.09 @xmath12 0.04 km s@xmath13 . the same process was applied to the cs spectra and the velocity differences were also found to be negative everywhere with a mean difference ( expansion velocity ) of -0.12 @xmath12 0.02 km s@xmath13 . this is similar to the range of @xmath14 for hco@xmath0 . this expanding motion is therefore also evident in the cs line emission profiles . another estimate of the expansion speed of material within the cloud was obtained using the model of @xcite . this model can only be applied to positions ( 10 positions ) where there is a clear double peak . in this model , the expansion velocity , @xmath15 is given by , @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the brightness temperature of the dip , @xmath18 is the height of the blue peak above the dip with its corresponding velocity , @xmath19 , @xmath20 is the height of the red peak above the dip with its corresponding velocity , @xmath21 , @xmath22 is the velocity dispersion of an optically thin line ( c@xmath1o here ) . for the hco@xmath0 lines , the mean expansion speed was calculated to be -0.07 @xmath12 0.02 and and for the cs lines , -0.07 @xmath12 0.02 km s@xmath13 ; both these estimates are somewhat lower than those derived from the peak velocity difference method in the previous paragraph . nonetheless , though somewhat uncertain , the overall expansion speeds we estimate are formally less than the one dimensional sound speed of @xmath23 0.19 km s@xmath13 in a 10 k gas . figure [ c18opkv ] shows maps of the variation of the velocity of the peak in the c@xmath1o spectra . the peak velocities were determined from gaussian fits to the line profiles . we note that a few of the and lines are flat - topped , broadened or slightly asymmetric , indicating that the lines are slightly optically thick . the two maps , however , do reveal a systematic velocity gradient increasing from upper left to lower right of the map . to estimate the magnitude and direction of this gradient , the method of @xcite was used as adapted by @xcite . the velocity gradient is assumed to be linear when projected against the plane of the sky so the observed velocity @xmath24 can be related to the velocity gradient @xmath25 using @xmath26 @xmath27 and @xmath28 are right ascension and declination offsets in arcseconds . @xmath29 is the systemic velocity of the cloud and @xmath30 is the angle between north and the direction of the velocity gradient of magnitude @xmath25 . a least - squares fit of a two - dimensional plane to the observed @xmath24 ( line center velocity ) measurements of , and ( the spectra contained hyperfine components , and so the isolated component at the same @xmath24 as the line was used in this analysis ) provided estimates given in table [ tb : velgradfit ] . the errors for the n@xmath9h@xmath31 are larger because there were only nine spectra measured that were useful for this purpose . the n@xmath9h@xmath0 emission was less extended than the c@xmath1oemission , therefore , more densely sampled observations are needed to confirm the estimates using the n@xmath9h@xmath31 data . if the velocity gradient derived previously is removed , the average velocity difference between the neighboring spectra is then essentially zero ( @xmath32 km s@xmath13 ) . line widths ( fwhp ) were determined from gaussian fits to the observed and line profiles . the spectra have several hyperfine components so the line widths were determined from a gaussian fit to the isolated ( @xmath33 ) component . the resulting and line widths were found to be in a range from @xmath2 0.19 to @xmath2 0.35 km s@xmath13 . the n@xmath9h@xmath0 line widths were narrower , and were in the range @xmath2 0.15 to @xmath2 0.25 km s@xmath13 . figure [ c18olnw ] shows the variation in line width of the line profiles . because some of these lines are optically thick ( see comment in [ sec : vel ] ) , the line widths determined from a single gaussian fit are slightly larger than they would be if the lines were optically thin . nevertheless , the line widths seem to increase slightly at positions away from the highly extincted region around offset ( 24@xmath7 , 0@xmath7 ) , marked with a white cross in figure [ c18olnw ] . this is similar to b68 where the linewidths also appeared to increase away from its center . the reason for this is not clear . no independent measure of the kinetic temperature of has as yet been made ; a value of 10 k has therefore been adopted in this paper because data has shown that this applies to most globules and dense cores ( e.g. , @xcite ) . the thermal line width , @xmath34 $ ] for lines was therefore calculated to be 0.123 km s@xmath13 , and for n@xmath9h@xmath0lines , 0.125 km s@xmath13 . the nonthermal contribution to the line width was then estimated using the relation , @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the observed line width , @xmath37 is the thermal line width and @xmath38 is the nonthermal line width . the resulting average nonthermal line width for the lines was @xmath2 0.25 km s@xmath13 , and for the n@xmath9h@xmath0 lines , @xmath2 0.15 km s@xmath13 . to the extent that these lines are optically thin , this suggests that in producing the observed line profiles , nonthermal broadening mechanisms , e.g. , turbulence , may play a role . there may be more turbulent motion in the outer layers probed by the c@xmath1o molecular lines than in the inner more dense layers probed by the n@xmath9h@xmath0 line . however , the corresponding one dimensional non - thermal velocity dispersions ( @xmath39 ) are 0.11 and 0.06 km s@xmath13 for the c@xmath1o and n@xmath9h@xmath0 emitting gas , respectively . these values are both subsonic , that is , less than the one dimensional sound speed ( 0.19 km s@xmath13 ) in a 10 k gas . in figure 6 we show contour maps of c@xmath1o ( 10 ) , n@xmath9h@xmath0 ( 10 ) , and hco@xmath0 ( 10 ) integrated emission overlaid on a grey - scale map of the distribution of visual extinction . the extinction map was constructed from the data of alves et al . ( 2002 ) and convolved with a 24 arc sec gaussian smoothing kernel to match the resolution of the molecular - line data . the patterns seen in this figure are comparable to those seen in numerous other low - mass pre - stellar cores such as b68 or l1544 ( bergin et al . 2002 ; tafalla et al . in particular , both c@xmath1o and hco@xmath0 show emission distributions that are broader than the distribution in extinction with peaks well separated from the extinction maximum . in contrast n@xmath9h@xmath0 shows the highest degree of agreement with the dust extinction . this pattern is attributed to the freeze - out of molecules on the surfaces of cold dust grains in gas where the density exceeds 10@xmath40 @xmath11 ( e.g. bergin & langer 1997 ; aikawa et al . 2005 ) . in this scenario the freeze - out of co and its isotopologues leads to the formation of n@xmath9h@xmath0 in the dense gas dominated by freeze - out and traced by the dust . hco@xmath41 has structure similar to co which is not surprising since hco@xmath0 likely forms from gas phase reactions involving co. for a summary of this process in starless cores see bergin & tafalla ( 2007 ) . one explanation for the expansion of material from could be that the globule is simply unbound . this might be expected if the core is a transitory feature in a global turbulent sea @xcite . in this section , we assess this possibility by determining whether or not the core is bound . a mass for of @xmath42 ^ 2 $ ] @xmath43 was derived by spatially integrating the extinction data over the area of the globule , after correcting for a significant foreground / background extinction component ( a@xmath44 @xmath2 6 magnitudes ) and an assumed distance of @xmath45 pc . the magnitude of the background extinction was derived from examination of the azmuthially averaged extinction profile of the globule constructed from the alves et al . ( 2002 ) deep extinction data and is the same as that derived by alves et al . ( 2007 ) for this core from a wavelet decomposition of their 2mass extinction map of the pipe cloud . the escape velocity ( @xmath46 $ ] ) from is estimated to be @xmath47@xmath48^{0.5}$ ] km s@xmath13 . the average three - dimensional velocity dispersion ( @xmath49 ) of the bulk gas in the globule is @xmath2 0.3 - 0.4 km s@xmath13 , and significantly less than the escape velocity . thus the globule is likely to be gravitationally bound for the assumed distance of 130 pc or for any other plausible distance to the cloud . moreover , the expansion speeds detected in the self - absorbed molecular line data ( @xmath2 0.1 km s@xmath13 , see [ sec : hco ] ) are also significantly less than the calculated escape speed . the expansion of the outer layers of the globlule appears not to be caused simply by evaporation of its gas as in an unbound , transient cloud . a jeans mass of @xmath50m@xmath51 was derived using @xmath52m@xmath53 where @xmath54 is the globule s kinetic temperature assumed to be @xmath2 10 k. however , if we assume the lines are only thermally broadened , with no turbulence , then the kinetic temperature is 17 k and this doubles the jeans mass estimate ( [ sec : linwid ] ) . the average density @xmath55=@xmath56 @xmath11 was determined using the extinction data and a radius , @xmath57 cm . the radius was determined to be the point at which the radially averaged extinction profile reaches the background and marks the outer edge of the globule . since the mass of is comparable to its jeans mass , we conclude that it is likely marginally stable against gravitational collapse . if thermal pressure is not the only source of internal support then the globule could be even more stable against collapse . more detailed analysis of the globule s structure would be required to better evaluate its overall stability . there may be some contribution to stability of the globule from rotation . assuming solid body rotation , @xmath58 , the ratio of rotational kinetic energy to gravitational energy , is given by @xcite , @xmath59 @xmath60 is the globule s radius , @xmath61 its mass and @xmath62 is defined such that the moment of inertia , @xmath63 , and @xmath64 is defined such that the gravitational potential energy is @xmath65 . @xmath58 was estimated to be 0.01 for using @xmath66m@xmath67 cm , @xmath68 [ 1.5 km s@xmath13 pc@xmath13]/@xmath70 ( for , see table [ tb : velgradfit ] ) , where @xmath71 is the inclination of the globule to the line of sight , and assuming @xmath72 as for a sphere with a density profile @xmath73 and @xmath74 . the contribution of rotation to the overall stability of is therefore not significant . note that @xmath58 of 0.01 is also consistent with the results of @xcite that most clouds have @xmath75 . thermal motions may be a significant source of pressure support for . this can be quantified by evaluating the ratio of thermal to nonthermal ( turbulent ) pressure given by , @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the one dimensional isothermal sound speed and @xmath39 is the one dimensional nonthermal or turbulent velocity dispersion and @xmath78 $ ] . assuming a gas temperature of 10 k , the average value of @xmath79 for all the c@xmath1o observations is 3.75 @xmath12 1.95 , which may be an underestimate for those lines that may be somewhat thick . the average value of @xmath79 for the n@xmath9h@xmath0data is 6.09 @xmath12 2.07 . these values indicate that the thermal pressure significantly exceeds the turbulent pressure in the globule , and absent strong static magnetic fields , is the dominant source of internal support against gravity . in comparing the turbulent velocity dispersion to the isothermal sound speed of 0.19 km s@xmath13 in a 10 k molecular gas , the nonthermal motions appear to be subsonic over the surface of . if the n@xmath9h@xmath0 observations probe a deeper layer of the globule than the c@xmath1o lines , these motions are even more subsonic in the inner layers of the globule . these considerations further indicate that thermal motions provide a significant source of internal pressure . the apparent velocity gradient in the c@xmath1o data was calculated and removed in [ sec : vel ] . the resulting average velocity difference between neighboring spectra was essentially zero ( ) so there appears to be no residual scatter in peak velocities of the spectra on scale sizes comparable to the beam width that could be caused by turbulent motions . this also is consistent with significant thermal support for the globule . in the absence of an embedded source in that could cause outflow of material , it is difficult to explain the observations reported here . in the previous section we showed that the globule is gravitationally bound with thermal pressure as the dominant source of internal support . but what causes the observed expansion motions ? the facts that 1- the globule is bound , 2- thermally supported and 3- does not exceed the jean s mass , suggest that this core is stable and not far from a state of hydrostatic equilibrium . moreover , the expected ( one - dimensional ) virial velocity dispersion , @xmath80 $ ] , is 0.18 km s@xmath13 and is comparable to the sound speed in a 10 k gas as would be expected for a thermally dominated , stable core . indeed , we derive the velocity dispersion for the h@xmath9 gas in the core to be @xmath81 0.21 km s@xmath13 close to the predicted value . however , given that its outer layers are globally expanding , the globule can not be presently in a strict equilibrium state . one viable explanation that can simultaneously account for all these facts , is that is in dynamical oscillation around an equilibrium state . the outflowing motion is then part of a mode of oscillation such that its layers pulse in and out with a period of possibly a few hundred thousand years . we further explore this interesting possibility below . in their study of molecular lines observed in the globule b68 , @xcite concluded that that globule could be experiencing low order mode , nonradial oscillations of its outer layers . they suggest that the globule may have interacted with the shock of a supernova remnant , which instigated a perturbation that set at least its outer layers in oscillatory motion . figure 7 of their paper displays the real parts of the spherical harmonic functions for a range of low order modes for an oscillating sphere . the @xmath82 mode corresponds closely to the pattern observed in b68 . a study by @xcite demonstrated that linear perturbations on a pressure - bounded thermally supported sphere could indeed produce the spatial variation in profile shape observed in b68 . could also be oscillating in this mode but the geometry is such that we are looking ` edge - on ' to the pulsating cloud . this means the mode of pulsation appears similar to the ` breathing ' or @xmath83 mode , i.e. , outflow motion over the whole surface of the cloud @xcite . calculations were carried out to find the modes of pulsation for an isothermal , spherical globule of gas with similar parameters ( e.g. , radius = @xmath84 cm , density = @xmath85 @xmath11 , internal sound speed = 0.18 km s@xmath13 ) as for . small wave - like perturbations were introduced , and a differential wave equation was determined using the perturbed and unperturbed forms of its equations of state . the modes of oscillation postulated are likely to be acoustic , with relatively large amplitudes and energies , so that the linear approximation that we use for the mode frequencies is a simplification of the full dynamical problem . in this linear approximation , we ignore the gravitational modes , and find that the acoustic modes follow the dispersion relation @xmath86 \right ) } { j_l \left ( x_{\omega } \left [ c_{out}/c_{in } \right ] \right ) } = 0\ ] ] @xmath87 where @xmath88 is the frequency of the oscillations ; @xmath89 is the unperturbed radius ; @xmath90 are isothermal sound speeds inside and outside the globule respectively ; @xmath91 are the unperturbed densities inside and outside the globule respectively ; and , @xmath92 and @xmath93 are spherical hankel and bessel functions of the first kind or order @xmath94 , with the prime denoting differentiation with respect to the argument . the frequency @xmath88 is complex and roots of the dispersion relation where @xmath88 has a negative imaginary part , correspond to decaying modes of oscillation . the required mode for pulsation is the least - damped mode or the mode which decays at the slowest rate ; this is the mode with the smallest negative imaginary part of @xmath88 . this mode was calculated to be @xmath95 with a frequency of @xmath96 hz corresponding to an oscillation period of @xmath97 years , comparable to the sound crossing time . it is plausible that this oscillation was excited by some transient dynamical event , such as a shock , that deposits an energy greater than about @xmath98 ergs , ( our best estimate of the kinetic energy in coherent motions ) into the outer regions of , where hco@xmath0 molecules exhibit a coherent pattern of expansion motions . calculations by @xcite show that such large amplitude motions ( i.e. , motions comparable to the sound speed ) can cause significant geometrical distortions of a core . an important point to note is that in the high resolution extinction map of obtained by @xcite , a slight splitting of the core s central regions is visible . this splitting could be another manifestation of an @xmath95 mode of oscillation . is situated in the direction of the pipe nebula , which lies at the edge of the scorpio centaurus ob association . @xcite suggested that stellar wind from the b0 type star @xmath99 sco caused compression of the molecular gas , triggering star formation in the b59 cloud , situated @xmath2 5@xmath100 west and @xmath2 3@xmath100 north of . in figure 5 of their paper , @xcite show an observation of , designating it ` core 12 ' . in discussing the effect of the ob stars on the pipe nebula , @xcite estimated that @xmath101 ergs has been deposited in the cloud over a period of @xmath102 years . if is indeed near this ob association and was also able to intercept only 0.3% of the estimated energy deposition , then the effects of the postulated shock waves may be more widespread than previously speculated . not only did they trigger star formation in b59 , but they may have also set gaseous globules such as and b68 ( which is also part of the pipe complex ) into oscillation . more observations and comparison with theoretical models of cloud pulsation are needed to confirm this hypothesis . in figure 7 we provide a direct comparison of the dependence of c@xmath1o ( 10 ) and n@xmath9h@xmath0 ( 10 ) emission with visual extinction at the same angular resolution . for both species the figures display trends that are similar to those seen in b68 by bergin et al . ( 2002 ) . in these plots , a linear correlation between integrated intensity and a@xmath44 corresponds to a constant abundance throughout the cloud . the c@xmath1o ( 10 ) emission shows a linear dependence with a@xmath44 until @xmath103 mag whereupon the trend flattens . given the drop in the the c@xmath1o integrated emission / a@xmath44 relation near a@xmath104 mag we have fit the following function : @xmath105 to the data . we find an intercept of @xmath106 k km s@xmath13 and a slope of @xmath107 thus for a@xmath108 12@xmath109 , where we see a significant linear correlation between gas emission and dust extinction , we estimate a c@xmath1o abundance of @xmath110 ( relative to h@xmath9 ) . this is comparable to that measured previously by frerking , langer , & wilson ( 1982 ) of @xmath111 in taurus and to that obtained from a similar comparison of extinction and co measurements toward l 977 ( alves et al . for a@xmath112 the correlation is essentially flat , indicative of saturation or , as in b68 , a drop in abundance towards denser regions . we can use the intercept to estimate average abundance in this gas and find that the abundance is @xmath113 between 20 and 40 magnitudes . thus , we estimate that co is depleted by a factor of @xmath25 . in 3.2 we noted that the c@xmath1o emission lines show indications of being slightly optically thick . thus these abundance estimates are upper limits to the _ average _ depletion in the cloud . the situation for n@xmath9h@xmath0 ( 10 ) in figure 7 is more complicated . there is a rough correspondence between integrated emission and a@xmath44 and it is well fit by a line with a slope of 0.106@xmath120.001 k km s@xmath13 mag@xmath13 and an intercept of -0.711@xmath120.031 k km s@xmath13 . this is consistent with an abundance of 10@xmath114 relative to hydrogen . however , we can not exclude the possibility that the trend becomes flat at @xmath115 mag . fits to the intensities of the hyperfine lines of suggest that the total opacities are of order 12 at the emission peaks , so that all the hyperfine components are saturated . this is not the case at low a@xmath44 , where the lines appear to be optically thin . thus we believe that the line integrated intensity-@xmath116 correlation may be turning over at high a@xmath44 as a result of saturation and rather than depletion . however , we also note that the spatial map of n@xmath9h@xmath0 in figure 6 displays peaks northeast and southwest of the dust extinction peak and this could also be an indication of depletion of this species similar to what has been observed in b68 ( bergin et al . however , due to the high opacity of the line , it is not possible to separate the effects of spatial variations in excitation from those of column density without detailed chemical modeling . high resolution radio observations were made of the globule . molecular lines observed were , , , and . the hco@xmath0 and cs spectra showed clear self - reversed , asymmetric profiles across the face of the globule . the sense of the asymmetry is indicative of the presence of global expansion motions across the globule . these motions appear to be subsonic and significantly below the escape speed of the cloud . a search for iras , msx sources and spitzer sources showed the globule to be starless , and therefore the origins of these expansion motions is unclear . in this paper , we propose the explanation that the globule is in a quasi - stable state near hydrodynamic equilibrium such that its outer layers are pulsating . it is possible that a passing shock wave from a nearby ob star association has excited the globule setting its outer layers into motion . such oscillatory motion is visible in the layers on the sun ( where the fundamental radial period is @xmath2 1 hour and other oscillation periods are @xmath2 5 minutes ) but in , the periods are thought to be of the order of hundreds of thousands of years . this is similar to what @xcite observed in b68 . calculations to determine the dominant mode of pulsation resulted in an @xmath95 mode with a frequency of @xmath96 hz , and an oscillation period of @xmath97 years . a high resolution extinction map of exhibits a double peak structure at the highest levels of opacity , corresponding to visual extinctions of @xmath250 mag @xcite . it is possible that the proposed @xmath95 mode of oscillation could explain the observed splitting of the core in this column density map . finally , we find evidence for significant depletion of co and perhaps hco@xmath0 in this globule . however , may be undepleted to depths of about 40 magnitudes of visual extinction in the core of the cloud . we are grateful to dr . tracy huard and the staff at the iram 30 m telescope for their assistance with the observations . we thank dr . carlos roman - zuniga for assistance in constructing the appropriate extinction map and with calculating the cloud mass . we thank the referee for insightful suggestions that strengthened the presentation . eda is particularly indebted to dr . mike masheder for his able guidance , useful suggestions and continued support throughout all aspects of this project . eda was supported by a pparc postgraduate studentship . cjl acknowledges support from nasa origins grant nag-13041 . aikawa , y. , herbst , e. , roberts , h. , & caselli , p. 2005 , , 620 , 330 + alves , j. lada , c.j . , & lada , e.a . 1999 , , 515 , 265 + alves , j. , lada , c. , lada , e. , lombardi , m. , & bergin , e. a. 2002 , in proceedings of the eso workshop held in garching , germany , april , 24 - 27 , 2001 , eso astrophysics symposia , ed . j. f. alves and m. j. mccaughrean ( berlin / heidelberg : springer - verlag ) , 37 + alves , j. , lombardi , m. & lada , c.j . 2007 , , 462 , l17 + ballesteros - paredes , j. , klessen , r. s. , mac low , m. -m . , & vzquez - semadeni , e. 2006 , in proceedings of _ `` protostars and planets v '' _ , hilton waikoloa village , hawaii , october 25 - 28 , 2005 , ed . b. reipurth , d. jewitt , and k. keil ( tucson : university of arizona press ) , arxiv : astro - ph/0603357 + benson , p. j. , & myers , p. c. , 71 , 89 + bergin , e. a. , & tafalla , m. 2007 , , in press + bergin , e. a. , alves , j. , huard , t. , & lada , c. j. 2002 , , 570 , l101 + bergin , e. a. , & langer , w. d. , 486 , 316 + clarke , c. j. , & pringle , j. e. 1997 , , 288 , 674 + evans , n. j. , ii . 2001 , in proceedings of _ `` chemistry as a diagnostic of star formation '' _ , university of waterloo , canada , august 21 - 23 , 2002 , ed . charles l. curry & michel fich ( ottawa : nrc press ) 27 , arxiv : astro - ph/0211526 + feitzinger , j. v. , & stwe , j. a. 1984 , astron . ser . , 58 , 385 + frerking , m. a. , langer , w. d. , & wilson , r. w. 1982 , , 262 , 590 + goodman , a. a. , benson , p. j. , fuller , g. a. , & myers , p. c. 1993 , , 406 , 528 + gregersen , e. m. , evans , n. j. , ii . , zhou , s. , & choi , m. 1997 , , 484 , 256 + gregersen , e. m. & evans , n. j. , ii . 2000 , , 538 , 260 + kandori , r. , nakajuma , n. , motohide , t. , tatematsu , k. , aikawa , y. , et al . 2005 , , 130 , 2166 + keto , rybicki , g. b. , bergin , e. a. , & plume , r. 2004 , , 613 , 335 + keto , e. , & field , g. 2005 , , 635 , 1151 + keto , e. , broderick , a. e. , lada , c. j. , & narayan , r. 2006 , , 652 , 1366 + lada , c. j. , bergin , e. a. , alves , j. f. , & huard , t. l. 2003 , , 586 , 286 + lee , c. w. , myers , p. c. , & tafalla , m. 1999 , , 526 , 788 + lee , c. w. , myers , p. c. , & tafalla , m. 2001 , , 136 , 703 + lombardi , m. , alves , j. , & lada , c. j. 2006 , , 454 , 781 + mardones , d. , myers , p. c. , wilner , d. j. , bachiller , r. , & garay , g. 1997 , , 489 , 719 + matsumoto , t. , & hanawa , t. 2003 , , 595 , 913 + myers , p. c. , mardones , d. , tafalla , m. , williams , j. p. , & wilner , d. j. 1996 , , 465 , l133 + onishi , t. , kawamura , a. , abe , r. , yamaguchi , n. , saito , h. , moriguchi , y. , mizuno , a. , ogawa , h. , & fukui , y. 1999 , , 51 , 871 + redman , m. , p. , keto , e. , rawlings , j. m. c. , & williams , d. a. 2004 , , 352 , 1365 + tafalla , m. , myers , p. c. , caselli , p. , walmsley , c. m. , & comito , c. 2002 , , 569 , 815 + ungerechts , h. , bergin , e. a. , goldsmith , p. f. , irvine , w. m. , schloerb , f. p. , & snell , r. l. 1997 , , 482 , 245 lines but not the c@xmath1o line which is single - peaked indicating that the former emission lines are likely very optically thick and self - reversed . the sense of the asymmetry suggests expansion motions of the outer cloud layers.,height=384 ] emission spectra and dotted lines are those of c@xmath1o . the map is centered at @xmath117 = 17@xmath11835@xmath10947.5@xmath119 , @xmath120 = -25@xmath10033@xmath62.0@xmath7 . double - peaked , self - reversed and asymmetric profiles are evident in the hco@xmath0 lines across the globule . in all positions the sense of the profile asymmetry is indicative of expansion motions.,height=384 ] o. the map is centered at @xmath117 = 17@xmath11835@xmath10947.5@xmath119 , @xmath120 = -25@xmath10033@xmath62.0@xmath7 . asymmetric , self - absorbed cs profiles indicative of expansion are evident across the map , height=384 ] with units of k km s@xmath13 ( c@xmath1o : 0.2 to 2.0 by 0.2 ; n@xmath9h@xmath0 : 0.1 to 0.8 by 0.1 ; hco@xmath41 : 0.2 to 1.2 by 0.2 ) . the extinction scale is shown in the bar on the right of the figure and the extinction ranges from approximately 6 - 43 magnitudes . for clarity the grey - scale contrast has been adjusted to emphasize the dust distribution in the center of the core . ] o j=1 - 0 integrated intensity as a function of visual extinction for the entire fest 1 - 457 dark cloud . ( _ right _ ) n@xmath9h@xmath0 j=1 - 0 integrated emission as a function of visual extinction . in all plots the data are presented as open squares with error bars while solid traces are the result of linear fits to the data . the extinction and molecular line observations in both plots were obtained at the same angular resolution . ]

high resolution molecular line observations of , , , and were obtained toward the starless globule in order to investigate its kinematics and chemistry . the hco@xmath0 and cs spectra show clear self - reversed and asymmetric profiles across the face of the globule . the sense of the observed asymmetry is indicative of the global presence of expansion motions in the outer layers of the globule . these motions appear to be subsonic and significantly below the escape velocity of the globule . comparison of our observations with near - infrared extinction data indicate that the globule is gravitationally bound . taken together these considerations lead us to suggest that the observed expansion has its origin in an oscillatory motion of the outer layers of the globule which itself is likely in a quasi - stable state near hydrostatic equilibrium . analysis of the observed linewidths of c@xmath1o and confirm that thermal pressure is the dominant component of the cloud s internal support . a simple calculation suggests that the dominant mode of pulsation would be an l = 2 mode with a period of @xmath2 @xmath3 yrs . deformation of the globule due to the large amplitude l = 2 oscillation may be responsible for the double - peaked structure of the core detected in high resolution extinction maps . detailed comparison of the molecular - line observations and extinction data provides evidence for significant depletion of c@xmath1o and perhaps hco@xmath0 while may be undepleted to a cloud depth of @xmath2 40 magnitudes of visual extinction .

1008.2619

ever since the discovery of graphene@xcite there has been interest in merging the unique two dimensional massless relativistic dirac fermion spectrum of graphene with superconductivity . a few years ago , graphene superconductor - normal metal - superconductor ( sns ) josephson junctions were successfully fabricated.@xcite here superconductivity is induced in the s regions of the graphene through proximity to superconducting contacts deposited on top of these regions , and , through the josephson effect , a finite supercurrent can exist even in the n region of the graphene . one of the key properties of a sns junction is the current - phase relation ( cpr ) , and , very recently , the first direct measurement of the cpr in graphene sns junctions appeared.@xcite theoretically , ballistic graphene sns junctions were studied even before the first experimental results . several novel features were discovered , such as specular andreev reflection,@xcite and a finite supercurrent in undoped graphene at zero temperature , despite the point - like fermi surface.@xcite these results , along with most theoretical results on the josephson effect in graphene sns junctions,@xcite have employed the dirac - bogoliubov - de gennes ( dbdg ) formalism , where the standard bdg formulation is applied to the dirac spectrum.@xcite to solve the resulting equations , rigid boundary conditions are assumed for the superconducting order parameter @xmath3 , such that @xmath3 takes on a fixed , non - zero value in s , whereas it is zero in n. however , such an approach explicitly ignores any processes in which @xmath3 is reduced in the s regions , such as proximity effect or depairing by current ( see e.g. ref . [ ] for a review ) . moreover , with the josephson current in the dbdg approach usually calculated as the current carried by sub - gap andreev bound states , this method is limited to junction lengths @xmath1 , where @xmath4 is the superconducting coherence length . other , related methods have been employed to relax some of the constraints in the original works , but they still apply rigid boundary conditions for @xmath3.@xcite in fact , in order to not apply any boundary conditions on @xmath3 at the s@xmath0n interface , a self - consistent treatment is needed . one such method is the self - consistent tight - binding ( tb ) bdg formalism , where one only assumes that the superconducting contacts induces a pairing potential into the graphene and then solve self - consistently for @xmath3 in the whole sns structure.@xcite not only does this approach give an explicit calculation of the full proximity effect , including current depairing , but it also results in a josephson current appropriately calculated from this proximity effect . previous works by the authors@xcite employing this formalism at zero temperature showed on some corrections to the cpr compared to the dbdg results , as well as deviations for the critical current as function of junction length . now , with experimental data on the cpr in graphene at hand , it is of large interest to theoretically map out the temperature dependence of the cpr in graphene . very recently , some theoretical temperature dependent cpr results appeared using the dbdg approach,@xcite but otherwise all theoretical work have been at zero temperature . the goals of this work are thus twofold : ( 1 ) : establish the correct cpr in ballistic graphene sns josephson junctions as function of temperature using the self - consistent tb bdg formalism . ( 2 ) : determine how well the dbdg approach captures the cpr , and , if applicable , determine the source(s ) of discrepancy . we will here show that both the proximity effect depletion of superconductivity in the s regions and depairing by current are large in short junctions ( @xmath1 ) . in fact , these effects lead to a cpr where the critical current is reached for a phase @xmath2 . this is true over a large temperature range and even more prominent for high doping levels in the graphene . in order to capture these effects a self - consistent solution of @xmath3 is crucial since rigid boundary conditions explicitly ignores any such processes in the s regions . for longer junctions ( @xmath5 ) the proximity effect depletion is unchanged but depairing by current is now not a big issue , and here @xmath6 . in this junction length regime the dbdg approach using andreev bound states is not formally justified , and due to a large proximity effect , a self - consistent approach is still needed . the rest of the article is organized as follows . in the next section we briefly introduce the methods used , both the self - consistent approach and the dbdg equation using rigid boundary conditions . then in section iii we report our results , including the temperature dependent cpr for different junctions as well as an analysis of the influence of proximity effect and current depairing on the cpr . finally , we summarize our key findings and comment on the applicability of our results to current and future experiments . our starting point is the nearest neighbor tight - binding hamiltonian on the graphene lattice together with an on - site @xmath7-wave superconducting order parameter @xmath8 , which is induced by the proximity to external superconducting contacts : @xmath9 here @xmath10 ( @xmath11 ) creates an electron with spin @xmath12 on the a ( b ) sublattice in unit cell @xmath13 . @xmath14 ev is the nearest neighbor hopping amplitude , whereas @xmath15 is the chemical potential . we will assume that , due to the external contacts , the chemical potential is rather large and constant in the s regions whereas it can be tuned ( to a constant value ) with a back gate voltage in the n region . for an analytical treatment within the dbdg framework we set @xmath16 , whereas @xmath17 with @xmath18 . here @xmath19 is set to the standard bcs temperature dependence . this amounts to applying rigid boundary conditions on @xmath8 at the s@xmath0n interface . by treating the s and n regions separately , the above hamiltonian can be fourier transformed and the kinetic energy linearized around the dirac points to produce the standard dbdg equation:@xcite @xmath20 where @xmath3 and @xmath21 take on different , but constant , values in the s and n regions , as described above . moreover , @xmath22 , where @xmath23 with @xmath24 being the lattice constant of graphene . the strategy for calculating the josephson current in the junction is to first obtain the energy spectrum for the andreev - bound states in the n region . this is done by matching the wave functions given by eq . ( [ eq : dbdg ] ) at the two s@xmath0n interfaces and then solve for the allowed energy eigenstates , @xmath25 . the general expression for the josephson current can then be written as:@xcite @xmath26 where the summation over @xmath27 denotes all andreev levels and the summation over @xmath28 denotes the transverse momentum index . here , @xmath29 is the phase drop across the junction,@xmath30 is the fermi - dirac distribution function , and the prefactor of 4 is due to the spin- and valley - degeneracy . let us first consider the case of @xmath31 , i.e. no fermi level mismatch ( flm ) in the junction . in the wide junction limit where the junction width @xmath32 satisfies @xmath33 , we may replace the summation over discrete transverse momentum indices with an integral as follows : @xmath34 where the integration over the angle @xmath35 takes into account all possible trajectories . the andreev levels in a sns junction with no flm have the form:@xcite @xmath36 where for graphene @xmath37 has the specific form : @xmath38}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] inserting the above equations in to eq . ( [ eq : jos ] ) and introducing the normalization constant @xmath39 , where @xmath40 is the superconducting coherence length , we arrive at the expression : @xmath41 ^ 2}{\delta_0\varepsilon_+ } \frac{\tau\sin\phi\cos\theta}{\tanh^{-1}(\beta\varepsilon_+/2)},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath42 is the inverse temperature . finally turning our attention to the flm case , a similar procedure@xcite leads to the expression : @xmath43 where @xmath44 is given by eq . ( 17 ) in ref . [ ] . in the self - consistent numerical treatment we do not predetermine the value of @xmath8 nor apply rigid boundary conditions at the s@xmath0n interface . instead we assume that the influence of the superconducting contacts on the underlying graphene is only through an induced attractive pairing potential . for @xmath7-wave pairing the simplest potential is a constant , non - zero , attractive hubbard-@xmath45 term in the s regions . by applying the mean - field approximation to the attractive hubbard model we reproduce eq . ( [ eq : h ] ) but with an added self - consistency condition @xmath46 where @xmath47 in s but zero in n. we can now solve self - consistently for @xmath8 by first guessing a profile for @xmath8 throughout the sns junction , solving eq . ( [ eq : h ] ) with this guess , recalculating @xmath8 using eq . ( [ eq : selfcons ] ) , and then reiterate this process until two subsequent @xmath8 profiles are within a predetermined error margin . in order to study the proximity effect between the s and n regions in the graphene we focus on the pairing amplitude @xmath48 . while @xmath8 will only be non - zero in the s regions , @xmath49 can , due to proximity effect leakage from s to n , be non - zero even in n. alongside this leakage also comes a depletion of @xmath50 in s such that @xmath51 close to the interface . it is this latter process that , as we will show below , significantly changes the cpr . the other important property is the josephson current @xmath52 that flows through the junction if there exists a phase difference @xmath29 in @xmath8 across n. from the continuity equation for the charge current we can , using the self - consistent solution for @xmath8 , calculate @xmath52 . for additional details on this self - consistent method see ref . we will assume clean , smooth interfaces such that a fourier transform along the direction parallel to the interface is applicable . in the self - consistent treatment , the type of interface can be varied but with an on - site pairing the direction of the interface will not matter . we will here use the zigzag interface , such that one unit cell is @xmath53 long . moreover , we will only consider the wide junction regime , @xmath54 . in the self - consistent treatment the junctions are naturally infinitely wide , due to fourier transforming along the interface , whereas in the dbdg approach @xmath55 is used . for a direct comparison between the two methods the current will be given in units of @xmath56 . in this article we will focus on a few representative values for the various physical input parameters . in the superconducting s regions we use @xmath57 and @xmath58 . these values give @xmath59 , and a superconducting coherence length @xmath60 unit cells . this satisfies @xmath61 in both s and n , a requirement for the dbdg solution , and will also allow us to self - consistently investigate both the @xmath1 and @xmath5 regimes , where @xmath62 is the length of the n region . moreover , with these values we get s regions as small as 50 unit cells displaying clear bulk behavior , which is advantageous due to the the computational demands of the self - consistent method . note though that for a direct comparison with an experimental setup @xmath63 is very large . however , we believe that our results are applicable even for smaller @xmath63,@xcite and we , therefore , explicitly only report our results in dimensionless units . we will vary the chemical potential in the n region from the dirac point ( @xmath64 ) to moderately doped ( @xmath65 ) , to no flm at the interface ( @xmath66 ) . in addition , we will investigate both short junctions with @xmath67 , where our dbdg approach is technically justified , and long junctions with @xmath68 . finally , let us comment on the application of a phase gradient in @xmath8 . we apply a phase difference @xmath69 between the superconducting order parameters in the outermost regions of the two s regions . in the self - consistent treatment the phase is , however , allowed to relax also in the s regions close to the interfaces . thus the phase drop @xmath29 across the junction itself , i.e. across n , will necessarily satisfy @xmath70 in the self - consistent treatment , with an inequality in the first step as soon as the supercurrent is non - zero . as a consequence , we will not be able to trace out the self - consistent cpr for @xmath29 close to @xmath71 in junctions with high currents . while this appears as a numerical artifact in this context , it is , in fact , closely related to the physical @xmath72 phase - slip process in josephson junctions ( see , e.g. , ref . we will start by reporting the cpr for several different ballistic graphene sns junctions . then we will explicitly analyze the critical current and phase , followed by a qualitative analysis of the effect of proximity effect and current depairing on the cpr . the latter two quantities are captured by our self - consistent approach but is not included within the dbdg framework . figure [ fig : ivsphi ] shows the cpr for four representative cases with @xmath64 and no flm , and for short and long junctions , respectively . for each case we plot the cpr at four different temperatures , @xmath73 and 0.87 . for short junctions we also report the dbdg results as dashed curves for a straightforward comparison . we will comment more specifically on the skewness , or anharmonicity , of the cpr when extracting @xmath74 in fig . [ fig : icphic ] , but we see directly that the dbdg results only approximately reproduces the self - consistent results in the limit of low temperature and low doping levels in n. for increasing doping levels and/or increasing temperatures , the self - consistent results have a skewness towards @xmath2 , whereas @xmath75 is always the case for the dbdg results . by parameterizing the skewness as @xmath76 , we will refer to the former case as negative skewness . we also directly see that the total current in the junction is naturally increased with increasing doping level , decreasing junction length , or decreasing temperature . note though that the self - consistent results show a much larger suppression of the current with increasing temperature than the dbdg results . before we continue , the case of no flm at the interface deserves special attention . here there is no interface barrier and we thus have an sns junction with fully transparent interfaces . such junctions , independent on junction length , have been shown to have a @xmath77 diverging superconducting decay length @xmath78 in the normal region.@xcite for @xmath79 this is directly manifested in a linear drop of @xmath69 throughout the whole junction ( i.e. even in the s regions ) and , consequently , also a linear cpr , resulting in @xmath80.@xcite the diverging @xmath78 at @xmath79 also leads to currents not limited by tunneling through andreev bound states but by the size of the ( induced ) superconducting gap in the n region . due to these high currents we can not fully trace out the cpr in these junctions at low temperatures however , in the accessible range , the self - consistent cpr is indeed linear , which supports the claim that @xmath80 as @xmath81 . note that this numerical problem can partially be circumvented by studying longer junctions , as seen in fig . [ fig : ivsphi](d ) , since these junctions carry smaller currents due to a smaller superconducting gap in the n region . since the current calculation in the dbdg framework explicitly assumes the presence of a finite number of andreev bound states in the normal ( metal ) n region , this method can not capture the effects of the diverging @xmath78 . this results in an underestimation of both the skewness and the absolute value of the critical current in junctions with no flm at very low temperatures when using the dbdg method . let us now focus on the critical phase @xmath74 , extracted for three different doping levels in figs . [ fig : icphic ] ( a , b ) . in short junctions the dbdg results ( dashed lines ) show a notable ( positive ) skewness away from the traditional harmonic josephson relation @xmath82 . at the dirac point at zero temperature , @xmath83 as already established analytically,@xcite but with increasing temperature the cpr approaches the harmonic form , in agreement with other recent dbdg results.@xcite the skewness in the dbdg approach is somewhat increased with increasing doping but the overall temperature dependence is not highly sensitive to the doping level in n , nor is the no flm case distinctly different from the other results . what is most striking with fig . [ fig : icphic](a ) is the fact that the dbdg results do _ not _ reproduce the self - consistent results reliably . at low doping levels , @xmath74 is essentially uniformly shifted to lower values in the self - consistent approach , such that @xmath2 above some temperature . the temperature at which @xmath84 decreases with increasing doping levels . this leads to a substantial negative skewness with increasing doping , and thus the self - consistent results deviate even more from the dbdg results as the doping increases in the n region . at very high temperatures there is finally a tendency to approach a harmonic cpr , which is the development for any ballistic sns junction with rigid boundary conditions as @xmath85.@xcite within our numerical accuracy we can not , however , model temperatures close enough to @xmath86 to formally see if @xmath87 as @xmath88 . for long junctions the skewness is instead in general positive or only minutely negative for the highest doping levels . also , @xmath87 even for only moderately high temperatures . we can for @xmath89 not formally justify the use of our dbdg framework , but a comparison still shows on a large discrepancy between the self - consistent results and the dbdg results , although it is smaller than for shorter junctions . notably , the self - consistent results reach the harmonic @xmath84 result much faster than the dbdg results . in terms of the critical current , even with the log - scale in figs . [ fig : icphic](c , d ) , we see that a self - consistent treatment results in a significantly lower current for all junctions except at very low doping levels and temperatures . in fact , the discrepancy between the two methods grow strongly with increasing temperature . in aggregate , the above results directly leads to two conclusions : ( 1 ) a self - consistent approach is crucial in the short junction regime and still important for longer junctions . ( 2 ) a no flm junction at zero temperature has a diverging superconducting decay length @xmath78 and is therefore fully superconducting . this leads to a linear cpr with @xmath80 as @xmath90 . the large difference between the self - consistent and the dbdg results must stem from processes that are not captured when applying rigid boundary conditions to @xmath8 at the s@xmath0n interface . we have already discussed the special case of no flm junctions at zero temperature where @xmath91 becomes finite . also , very generally , processes influencing the superconducting state in the s region are present in all junctions and at all temperatures . these processes include proximity effect depletion of the pairing amplitude @xmath50 in the s region close to the interface and the additional loss of pairs in the whole junction because of a finite supercurrent , or , equivalently , a finite phase gradient . in fact , shifts of @xmath74 to the region @xmath6 are mainly governed by processes in the n region , as evident in the dbdg approach , whereas shifts towards @xmath92 occur because of processes in the s regions.@xcite that is , in the absence of the loss of cooper pairs in the s regions of the interface , the self - consistent results would reproduce the dbdg results , where the intrinsic properties of the graphene n region lead to @xmath75 . figure [ fig : proxeff ] contains the evidence for proximity effect depletion of pair amplitude at the interfaces . in ( a ) we see that for strong doping ( red ) the proximity effect is clearly larger , with more depletion of @xmath50 in s and the accompanied accumulation of pairs in n. this is expected since with increasing doping in n , the effective barrier at the interface due to the flm is decreased . the increase in the josephson current with doping of n is a direct consequence of this enhancement of @xmath50 in n. in terms of temperature dependence , the pair amplitude reduction in the bulk s regions with increasing temperature follow the standard bcs temperature dependence and is thus also included in the dbdg treatment . on top of this , there is , however , an additional loss of pair amplitude both on the s and n sides of the s@xmath0n interfaces with increasing temperature . this latter process is only captured in the self - consistent method . also seen in ( a ) are oscillations in @xmath49 at both ends of the s regions . these are due to the outer edges of the s regions , but do not influence the results of the junction itself . the small oscillations for @xmath64 at the interfaces at low temperatures are directly correlated with friedel - like charge oscillations , which are only present when n is close to the dirac point.@xcite in ( b ) we analyze the proximity effect at the interface more closely . for strong doping in n ( red , green ) , the proximity effect is notably stronger than for an undoped n region ( black , blue ) . however , note that the proximity effect is essentially independent on the junction length @xmath62 . this directly tells us that the stronger discrepancy between the dbdg and the self - consistent results found for short junctions is not due to the proximity effect . moreover , there is also a significantly increased interface proximity effect with increasing temperature . this explains the stronger decrease in both the critical current and phase with increasing temperatures than found in the dbdg results . finally in fig . [ fig : currdepair ] we study the absolute value of the pair amplitude @xmath93 for both @xmath94 and @xmath74 in short junctions . a difference in @xmath93 for these two phase gradients will directly signal the influence of a finite phase gradient or , by extension , a supercurrent on @xmath50 . in the case of a loss of @xmath93 going from @xmath94 and @xmath74 this is known as depairing by current , a process present in any junction carrying a finite supercurrent . in ( a ) we see that for low doping levels in n , there is a small amount of current depairing at low temperatures , which decreases with increasing temperatures . for heavily doped n regions ( b ) , the depairing is significantly larger , though it also decreases with increasing temperature . the same set of curves for long junctions show _ no _ change with applied phase gradient and thus depairing by current is only an issue in short junctions . this directly leads to the conclusion that it is current depairing which is responsible for the smaller and even negative skewness found in shorter junctions . its doping dependence also explains why the skewness is more negative for larger doping levels . moreover , the strong increase in proximity effect with increasing temperature is partially counteracted in short junctions by the decreased current depairing . thus we see less of a temperature dependence for the skewness when the junction length is decreased . in passing , we also note that the strength of the depairing process continues to increase as @xmath29 is increased from @xmath74 towards @xmath71 , despite a decrease in the supercurrent . thus the depairing is technically a function of the finite phase difference over the junction and not per see of the current , although they are intimately related . we have above self - consistently established the temperature dependent cpr in ballistic graphene sns josephson junctions with varying doping levels and junction lengths . we have also compared our results with the currently prevalent method of studying these junctions , the so - called dbdg method , which explicitly relies on the use of rigid boundary conditions for the superconducting order parameter @xmath3 at the s@xmath0n interfaces . the dbdg method gives a critical phase @xmath95 at zero temperature , with larger values for higher doping levels in n , which slowly then reduces to the harmonic value of @xmath84 as @xmath85 . our dbdg results are formally only valid in the short junction regime ( @xmath96 ) , but other recent work within the same dbdg framework has shown on a similar behavior for long junctions.@xcite the self - consistent results , however , are in most junctions qualitatively different from the dbdg results . first of all , any process influencing the superconducting state in the s regions of the junction can only be captured when the rigid boundary conditions are removed and @xmath3 is calculated self - consistently . such processes are known@xcite to decrease the skewness of the cpr and can even produce negative skewness , i.e. give @xmath97 . we have studied both the influence of proximity effect depletion of @xmath3 in s close to the interfaces and the additional loss of cooper pairs when a finite phase gradient is applied across the junction . the latter process , is known as depairing by current and is present whenever there is a finite supercurrent in the junction . the proximity effect is important and modifies the cpr in all junctions we have studied . it increases with doping and , even more so , with temperature . it is , however , independent of the junction length . current depairing , on the other hand , is only important in short junctions . it increases with doping , but decreases with temperature , both natural consequences of the amount of current in the junction . in fact , current depairing helps explain the growing discrepancy in @xmath98 with decreasing @xmath62 between the analytical and self - consistent results found in ref . based on these results we can qualitatively explain the modified cpr in the self - consistent results : for long junctions only the proximity effect modifies the dbdg results . the proximity effect reduces the skewness significantly and also heavily suppresses the critical current , especially at higher temperatures . however , for @xmath99 approaching @xmath86 , @xmath74 is pinned to the harmonic result , thus implying that in the very high temperature limit rigid boundary conditions are still applicable . in shorter junctions , the same proximity effect is at play , but here current depairing causes further decrease in @xmath74 . this is especially true for higher doping levels where we find @xmath74 as small as @xmath100 . the temperature dependence for the current depairing is opposite that of the proximity effect , and we thus see a somewhat smaller temperature variation in @xmath74 for shorter junctions . also , for short junctions a noticeable anharmonicity is present closer to @xmath86 , which by itself strongly signals that these junctions are not well modelled using rigid boundary conditions.@xcite in addition to these processes , junctions with no flm at the interfaces have @xmath80 as @xmath90 , due to a @xmath77 diverging superconducting decay length @xmath78.@xcite since the dbdg framework assumes @xmath16 , also this effect is only captured in our self - consistent treatment . let us finally also briefly comment on the applicability of our results to an experimental setup . in the recent experiment measuring the cpr in graphene sns junctions,@xcite the skewness was found to always be positive and increasing linearly with the critical current ( i.e. with decreasing temperature and/or increasing doping ) . it was , however , concluded that the junctions were very likely in the quasi - diffusive regime and , thus , an explicit comparison with our work is not possible . nonetheless , in ref . a qualitative comparison was made to ballistic dbdg results in the appropriate long junction regime ( @xmath101 ) , which also showed linear behavior for small @xmath98 , although the slope did not match the experimental results . our results show that , even in this long junction limit , self - consistency is necessary in ballistic junctions in order to correctly capture the cpr , due to the proximity effect . the temperatures used in the experiment was , however , large enough that within our current model setup we can not study these high temperatures , since @xmath19 becomes too small . still , we can see that at slightly lower temperatures the skewness is not hugely temperature or doping dependent . we thus speculate that when relaxing the ballistic requirement , proximity effect corrections become less important . ballistic transport has , however , already been demonstrated in graphene sns junctions with the measurement of multiple andreev reflections.@xcite thus , a measurement of the cpr in ballistic graphene junctions does not seem to be a too distant an achievement . our main , and easily verifiable , prediction in ballistic junctions that the skewness becomes negative due to a combination of current depairing and proximity effect in short junctions will therefore be important as the experimental junction lengths shrink in the future . in summary , we have found that proximity effect , depairing by current , and diverging superconducting decay length all qualitatively modifies the cpr in graphene josephson junctions . thus , a correct description of the cpr necessarily requires a self - consistent treatment of the superconducting order parameter . this is different from metallic sns junctions where it has been shown that rigid boundary conditions are applicable for junctions with large flm at the interface.@xcite

motivated by a recent experiment directly measuring the current - phase relation ( cpr ) in graphene under the influence of a superconducting proximity effect , we here study the temperature dependence of the cpr in ballistic graphene sns josephson junctions within the the self - consistent tight - binding bogoliubov - de gennes ( bdg ) formalism . by comparing these results with the standard dirac - bdg method , where rigid boundary conditions are assumed at the s@xmath0n interfaces , we show on a crucial importance of both proximity effect and depairing by current for the cpr . the proximity effect grows with temperature and reduces the skewness of the cpr towards the harmonic result . in short junctions ( @xmath1 ) current depairing is also important and gives rise to a critical phase @xmath2 over a wide range of temperatures and doping levels .

gr-qc0310079

towards observing gravitational waves , several gravitational wave interferometers on earth are steadily developing today , such as the laser interferometric gravitational wave observatory ( ligo ) @xcite , tama300 @xcite , geo600 @xcite , and virgo @xcite . thus it will be possible for us to detect gravitational waves directly in the near future . it is believed that mergers of binary neutron - star - neutron - star ( ns - ns ) , neutron - star - black - hole ( ns - bh ) , and bh - bh , or supernovae , and so on , can become strong sources of gravitational waves . after these violent events occur , compact objects may be left and may be turbulent . then gravitational waves are emitted from them . at this time , these gravitational waves convey information on the source object . if these gravitational waves are directly detected on earth , it is possible to obtain some information about the sources . this research field is called `` gravitational wave astronomy . '' in this field , there is an attempt to obtain information about properties of the equation of state ( eos ) of high density matter . this is one of the most important purposes of gravitational wave astronomy . gravitational waves are emitted by the nonspherical oscillation of compact objects . the oscillations are damped out as gravitational waves carry away the oscillational energy . such oscillations are called quasinormal modes ( qnms ) . the qnms have complex frequencies whose real and imaginary parts correspond to the oscillational frequency and damping rate , respectively . the qnms fall into two types from their nature . one involves fluid modes which are connected with the stellar matter . the other involves spacetime modes which are the oscillations of spacetime metric . moreover , the fluid modes are classified into various types . the well - known modes are the @xmath0 , @xmath4 , and @xmath5 modes @xcite . the fluid modes have a characteristic that the damping rate im(@xmath6 ) is much smaller than the oscillational frequency re(@xmath6 ) . the @xmath0 mode is the fundamental mode . there exists only one @xmath0 mode for each index @xmath7 of spherical harmonics @xmath8 . the @xmath4 mode is the pressure or acoustic mode , whose restoring force is caused by the pressure gradient inside the star . the @xmath5 mode is the gravity mode , which arises from buoyancy in a gravity field . the @xmath9 and @xmath10 modes are spacetime modes @xcite . unlike the fluid modes , the damping rate of the @xmath9 and @xmath1 modes is comparable to or larger than the oscillational frequency . for the qnms of neutron stars , so far many authors have argued the possibilities for determining the eos in the high density region and/or for restricting the properties of neutron stars , such as the radius @xmath11 or mass @xmath12 , by employing the observed gravitational wave of several nonradial modes @xcite . as a candidate for a star which is smaller than neutron stars , the possibility of a quark star or a compact star , which is supported by degenerate pressure of quark matter , has been pointed out . such a quark star has been investigated by many authors ( see , e.g. , refs . @xcite and references therein ) . in their view , it is commonly assumed that such quark stars contain quark matter in the core region and are surrounded by hadronic matter , although they are in the branch of neutron stars @xcite . witten @xcite suggested another type of quark star . if the true ground state of hadrons is bulk quark matter , which consists of approximately equal numbers of @xmath13 , @xmath14 , and @xmath3 quarks ( `` strange matter '' ) , there exist self - bound quark stars . they are called `` strange stars . '' in this case , their mass and radius are smaller than those of typical neutron stars , which are @xmath15 10 km and @xmath16 , respectively . because we do not have reliable information about the equilibrium properties of hadronic and quark matters at high densities , it is not clear what kinds of quark stars are realized . recently , drake @xmath17 @xmath18 . reported that the deep chandra letg+hrc - s observations of the soft x - ray source rx j1856.53754 reveal an x - ray spectrum quite close to that of a blackbody of temperature @xmath19 ev @xcite . the data contain evidence for the lack of spectral features or pulsation @xcite . drake @xmath17 @xmath18 . also reported that the interstellar medium neutral hydrogen column density is @xmath20@xmath21 @xmath22 . with the results of recent hst parallax analyses , that yields an estimate of 111170 pc for distance @xmath23 to rx j1856.5 - 3754 . combining this range of @xmath23 with the blackbody fit leads to a radiation radius of @xmath248.2 km . that is smaller than typical neutron star radii @xcite . thus they suggested that the x - ray source may be a quark star . in the meanwhile , in ref . @xcite , walter and lattimer claimed that the blackbody model adopted in ref . @xcite could not explain the observed uv - optical spectrum . they undertook to fit the two - temperature blackbody and heavy - element atmosphere models which were discussed in ref . @xcite in x - ray and uv - optical wavelengths . from their analyses they found that the radiation radius was 1226 km and was consistent with that of a neutron star . however , this model can not explain the lack of spectral features . in addition , recently braje and romani also suggested a two - temperature blackbody model , which can reproduce both the x - ray and optical - uv spectral @xcite . although their model is inconsistent with the fact that pulsation is not detected , this might be explained by the object being a young normal pulsar and its nonthermal radio beam missing the earth s line of sight . however , they can not also answer why there are no features in the observed x - ray spectrum . in ref . @xcite , burwitz @xmath17 @xmath18 . discussed the possibility of a condensate surface which is made of unknown material to explain both the uv - optical and x - ray spectra in a neutron star . more recently , some groups discussed the possibility that the effects of a strong magnetic field ( @xmath25 ) @xcite or rapid rotation ( @xmath26 ) @xcite may smear out any spectral features . in these situations , however , it seems that there are no reliable models that account for all the observational facts . it is still controversial whether rxj1856.5 - 3754 is a normal neutron star or some other compact star like a quark star . here we adopt the simplest picture , which is used by drake @xmath17 @xmath18 . @xcite : the uniform temperature blackbody model . as for gravitational waves emitted from quark stars , yip , chu , and leung studied nonradial stellar oscillation for stars whose radius is around 10 km @xcite . kojima and sakata demonstrated the possibility of distinguishing quark stars from neutron stars by using both the oscillational frequency and the damping rate of the @xmath0 mode @xcite . sotani and harada showed that the @xmath0 and lowest @xmath1 modes depend strongly on the eos of quark matter and the properties of quark stars , where the lowest @xmath1 mode is the one which has the largest frequency among all @xmath1 modes @xcite . then they pointed out the possibility of determining the eos and/or the stellar properties . furthermore , they also studied @xmath9 modes in detail . however , they clearly showed that @xmath9 modes do not depend much on the eos of quark matter and are not important for constraining the model parameters from observations . in their work , however , they assumed that the star is a pure quark star and that the eos is described by a simple bag model which has only one parameter : i.e. , the bag constant @xmath2 . in general , there are a variety of parameters even within bag models : e.g. , the bag constant @xmath2 , the strange quark mass @xmath27 , the fine structure constant in qcd @xmath28 , and so on . in particular , if the effects of nonvanishing strange quark mass @xmath29 are taken into account , the structure of quark stars can be affected considerably ( for recent analyses , see ref . @xcite and references therein ) . in this situation , we compute the qnms in the bag model used in ref . citekohri:2002hf and investigate the possibility of restricting the model parameters by the observations of qnms . in this study , we deal with only @xmath0 and the lowest @xmath1 modes in response to the results in ref . @xcite . effective theories of quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) , such as bag models , perturbation theories , or finite - temperature lattice data , are difficult to test by experiments , especially in a low temperature and high density regime . to further study them and fit their model parameters , we should compare the theoretical predictions in such models with experimental data e.g . , data in relativistic heavy ion collision experiments and so on . thus , in this situation information about compact objects obtained by astrophysical observations is indispensably valuable , being independent of the above - mentioned ground - based experiments in nuclear physics or particle physics . among the astrophysical observations , the observation of gravitational waves emitted from oscillating compact objects is quite unique because gravitational waves directly convey information on the internal structure of compact objects , where the density would reach the nuclear density . the plan of this paper is as follows . in sec . [ sec : quarkstar ] we introduce the basic equation including the eos to construct quark stars as the source of gravitational waves and to give the properties of quark star structure . we present a method of determining the qnms for the case of spherically symmetric stars in sec . [ sec : method ] . in sec . [ sec : result ] we show the numerical results for the qnms for the quark star constructed in sec . [ sec : quarkstar ] . in this section we present the dependence of the qnms on the parameters of the eos and stellar properties , and discuss the possibility of determining the eos of quark matter . we conclude this paper in sec . [ sec : conclusion ] . we adopt units of @xmath30 , where @xmath31 , @xmath32 , and @xmath33 denote the speed of light , reduced planck s constant , and gravitational constant , respectively , and the metric signature of @xmath34 throughout this paper . we assume that the quark star is static and spherically symmetric . in this case the metric is described by @xmath35 where @xmath36 and @xmath37 are metric functions of @xmath38 and @xmath37 is related to the mass function @xmath39 as @xmath40 the mass function @xmath39 is the gravitational mass inside a surface of radius @xmath38 and satisfies @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the energy density . the equilibrium stellar model is constructed by solving the equations @xmath43 equation ( [ dpdr ] ) is the tolman - oppenheimer - volkoff ( tov ) equation @xcite . in addition to the above equations we need an eos to compute the star configuration . the stellar surface @xmath44 is the position where the pressure vanishes , and the stellar mass @xmath12 is defined as @xmath45 . because the metric in the exterior of the star is the schwarzschild one , the metric ( [ metric_star ] ) must be connected smoothly with the schwarzschild one at the stellar surface . next we describe the eos in bag models . to construct stars composed of zero - temperature @xmath46 quark matter , we start with the thermodynamic potentials @xmath47 for a homogeneous gas of @xmath48 quarks ( @xmath49 ) of rest mass @xmath50 up to first order in the qcd coupling constant @xmath28 . the expressions for @xmath47 are given as a sum of the kinetic term and the one - gluon - exchange term at the renormalization scale @xmath51 @xcite . here we assume that @xmath52 . then @xmath47 is expressed by @xmath53 \right\ } , \ ] ] with @xmath54 , where @xmath55 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 is the chemical potential of @xmath48 quarks , @xmath58 , and @xmath59 . here we choose @xmath60 . the electron thermodynamic potential @xmath61 in the massless noninteracting form is given by @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the electron chemical potential . within the bag model , we express the total energy density @xmath42 as @xmath64 where @xmath2 is the bag constant @xcite which is the excess energy density effectively representing the nonperturbative color confining interactions . @xmath65 is the number density of @xmath66 particles given by @xmath67 . then , the pressure @xmath4 is represented by @xmath68 the parameters @xmath27 , @xmath28 , and @xmath2 were obtained by fits to light - hadron spectra ; e.g. , see refs . @xcite ( also see table [ table : fitting ] ) . note that these parameters do not correspond directly to the values appropriate to bulk quark matter @xcite . when we allow for possible uncertainties , we set @xmath69 mev , @xmath70 mev , and @xmath71 . the ranges of @xmath27 and @xmath28 are not always consistent with the values in table [ table : fitting ] . however , when we renormalize them at an energy scale of interest to us , they are consistent with values of the particle data group @xcite . to obtain the equilibrium composition of the ground - state matter at a given baryon density or chemical potential , the conditions for equilibrium with respect to the weak interaction and for overall charge neutrality are required . these conditions are expressed by @xmath72 and @xmath73 from eqs . ( [ eq : omegau])([eq : charge_neutral ] ) , we can obtain the energy density and pressure as a function of @xmath74 ( or @xmath75 ) . in ref . @xcite the authors assumed that @xmath76 and @xmath77 . then , the eos is analytically given by @xmath78 in this case , the density at the stellar surface is given by @xmath79 . in fig . [ fig_property ] , we plot several sequences of quark star models with different values of the bag constant @xmath2 and the @xmath3 quark mass @xmath27 . here we have fixed the fine structure constant in qcd as @xmath80 because the dependence of properties of quark stars on @xmath81 is weak , as indicated in ref . . therefore we deal with stellar models only for the case of @xmath80 in this paper . in fig . [ fig_property](a ) we plot the mass @xmath82 of the star as a function of central density @xmath83 . here we set @xmath84 , @xmath85 mev and @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 mev , respectively . in fig . [ fig_property](b ) we also plot the radius of the star as a function of central density by thick lines . thin lines denote the radiation radius @xmath89 . in fig . [ fig_property ] , the solid line , dashed line , and dotted line correspond to the cases of @xmath86 , @xmath87 , and @xmath88 mev , respectively . in tables [ tab_property_qs1 ] and [ tab_property_qs2 ] , we list several properties of quark stars whose radiation radii are within the range of @xmath24@xmath90 km , which was reported by ref . since we are interested in the dependence of qnms on the eos of quark matter , we consider only polar perturbation . if we adopt the regge - wheeler gauge , the metric perturbation is given by @xmath91 where @xmath92 is the background metric ( [ metric_star ] ) of a spherically symmetric star and @xmath93 , @xmath94 and @xmath95 are perturbed metric functions with respect to @xmath38 . we apply a formalism developed by lindblom and detweiler @xcite for relativistic nonradial stellar oscillations . the components of the lagrangian displacement of fluid perturbations are expanded as @xmath96 where @xmath97 and @xmath98 are functions of @xmath38 . assuming that the matter is a perfect fluid and the perturbation is adiabatic , we have the following perturbation equations derived from einstein equations : @xmath99 \hat{h}_{1 } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{1.2cm}+\frac{1}{r}e^{2\lambda } \left[\hat{h}+\hat{k}+16\pi ( p+\rho)\hat{v}\right],\label{perturbation1 } \\ & & \frac{d\hat{k}}{dr}=\frac{l(l+1)}{2r}\hat{h}_{1 } + \frac{1}{r}\hat{h } -\left(\frac{l+1}{r}-\frac{d\phi}{dr}\right)\hat{k } + \frac{8\pi}{r}(p+\rho)e^{\lambda}\hat{w } , \label{perturbation2 } \\ & & \frac{d\hat{w}}{dr}=-\frac{l+1}{r}\hat{w}+re^{\lambda } \left[\frac{1}{\gamma p}e^{-\phi}\hat{x}-\frac{l(l+1)}{r^{2}}\hat{v } -\frac{1}{2}\hat{h}-\hat{k}\right ] , \label{perturbation3 } \\ & & \frac{d\hat{x}}{dr}=-\frac{l}{r}\hat{x}+(p+\rho)e^{\phi } \biggl[\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{d\phi}{dr}-\frac{1}{r}\right)\hat{h } -\frac{1}{2}\left(\omega^{2}re^{-2\phi}+\frac{l(l+1)}{2r}\right ) \hat{h}_{1 } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{1.2cm}+\left(\frac{1}{2r}-\frac{3}{2}\frac{d\phi}{dr}\right ) \hat{k}-\frac{l(l+1)}{r^{2}}\frac{d\phi}{dr}\hat{v } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{1.2cm}-\frac{1}{r } \left(\omega^{2}e^{-2\phi+\lambda}+4\pi(p+\rho)e^{\lambda } -r^{2}\left\{\frac{d}{dr}\left(\frac{1}{r^{2}}e^{-\lambda}\frac{d\phi}{dr } \right)\right\}\right)\hat{w}\biggr ] , \label{perturbation4 } \\ & & \biggl[1-\frac{3m}{r}-\frac{l(l+1)}{2}-4\pi r^{2}p\biggr]\hat{h } -8\pi r^{2}e^{-\phi}\hat{x } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{1.2cm}+r^{2}e^{-2\lambda}\left[\omega^{2}e^{-2\phi } -\frac{l(l+1)}{2r}\frac{d\phi}{dr}\right]\hat{h}_{1 } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{1.2cm}-\left[1+\omega^{2}r^{2}e^{-2\phi}-\frac{l(l+1)}{2 } -\left(r-3m-4\pi r^{3}p\right)\frac{d\phi}{dr}\right]\hat{k}=0 , \label{perturbation5 } \\ & & \hat{v}=\frac{e^{2\phi}}{\omega^{2}(p+\rho ) } \left[e^{-\phi}\hat{x } + \frac{1}{r}\frac{dp}{dr}e^{-\lambda}\hat{w}+\frac{1}{2}(p+\rho)\hat{h } \right ] , \label{perturbation6 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath100 is the adiabatic index of the unperturbed stellar model , which is given by @xmath101 furthermore , if the proper boundary conditions are imposed on the above perturbation equations , the problem to solve becomes an eigenvalue one . these boundary conditions are given as follows : ( i ) the eigenfunctions are regular at the stellar center , ( ii ) the lagrangian perturbation of pressure vanishes at the stellar surface , and ( iii ) the gravitational wave is only an outgoing one at infinity . the qnms of quark stars are determined by solving this eigenvalue problem , and @xmath6 is the eigenvalue of the above perturbation equations . for the treatment of the boundary condition at infinity , we adopt the method of continued - fraction expansion proposed by leaver @xcite . the detailed method of determining qnms is given in @xcite . as for gravitational wave radiation emitted from a compact star , there exist qnms which correspond to each @xmath7 . in this paper , for simplicity we discuss such qnms only for @xmath102 , which would be a dominant mode in a weak field regime . compared with the other qnms , we might relatively easily detect the @xmath0 mode because its frequency and damping rate are approximately within the sensitivity band of gravitational wave interferometers : e.g. , ligo and so on . therefore , first we discuss the possibility of constraining parameters of bag models by using the @xmath0 mode data . when we discuss the observational data of frequency re(@xmath6 ) and damping rate im(@xmath6 ) of the @xmath0 mode , we should bear in mind that the observational data of frequency will be far more accurate than that of damping rate . it was discussed in ref . @xcite that the relative error of the frequency will be about three orders of magnitude smaller than that of the damping rate . to get an insight into the dependence of the @xmath0 mode on the bag constant @xmath2 and the @xmath3 quark mass @xmath27 , we compute the @xmath0 mode for each stellar model in tables [ tab_property_qs1 ] and [ tab_property_qs2 ] . in fig . [ fig_fmode](a ) we plot the complex frequencies of @xmath0 mode for @xmath102 . in the figure , the squares , circles , and triangles represent @xmath86 , @xmath87 , and @xmath88 mev , respectively , and the solid ( open ) marks denote the case of @xmath84 mev ( @xmath85 mev ) . in ref . @xcite the authors did not consider such @xmath27 dependence because they simply assumed that @xmath103 as their first step in the paper . from fig . [ fig_fmode](a ) , however , we find that both the frequencies and damping rates change at about @xmath104 as @xmath27 changes from zero to @xmath88 mev for each @xmath2 , and we see that it is important for us to include such effects of nonzero values of @xmath27 in bag models to predict the @xmath0 mode . in fig . [ fig_dependencerf ] we plot the radiation radius as a function of the ( a ) frequency re(@xmath6 ) and ( b ) damping rate im(@xmath6 ) of the @xmath0 mode for @xmath102 . in each panel , the solid and open marks denote @xmath84 mev and @xmath85 mev , respectively . from fig . [ fig_dependencerf](b ) we see that the damping rate is very sensitive to the radiation radius , unlike the frequency in fig . [ fig_dependencerf](a ) . if we observe the damping rate of the @xmath0 mode within @xmath105 , the radiation radius can be determined within @xmath104 as a function of @xmath2 , independently of the value of @xmath27 . on the other hand , from fig . [ fig_dependencerf](a ) we see that if we observe the frequency within about @xmath105 , for example , we can determine the value of @xmath2 with reasonable accuracy by using the simultaneously obtained radiation radius from fig . [ fig_dependencerf](b ) . to demonstrate that , we investigate the dependence of the @xmath0 mode on both the bag constant and the @xmath3 quark mass when we fix the radiation radius as @xmath106 km . in fig . [ fig_contourf ] , we plot the contours of the ( a ) frequency re(@xmath6 ) and ( b ) damping rate im(@xmath6 ) of the @xmath0 mode for @xmath102 in the ( @xmath107 , @xmath27 ) plane . the numbers on the curves denote the value of frequency re(@xmath6 ) or damping rate im(@xmath6 ) in units of khz . we should note that each contour line is nearly parallel to the vertical axis in both figs . [ fig_contourf](a ) and [ fig_contourf](b ) . this implies that we can obtain a stringent constraint on the bag constant . indeed , fig . [ fig_contourf](a ) shows that if the frequency of the @xmath0 mode is detected within @xmath105 , then we can determine the value of the bag constant within about @xmath108 independently of the value of the @xmath3 quark mass . in general , there exist infinite number of @xmath9 modes and several @xmath1 modes for each @xmath7 . as was clearly shown by numerical analysis in ref . @xcite , however , the @xmath9 modes are insensitive to the parameters in bag models in which we are interested here . therefore , we do not adopt @xmath9 modes in this study . in addition , only one @xmath1 mode was found in each quark star model adopted in this study . that is because the `` compactness''- i.e. , mass to radius ratio of the adopted quark stars is much smaller than that of standard neutron stars ( see tables [ tab_property_qs1 ] and [ tab_property_qs2 ] ) . here , for simplicity we deal with only the lowest @xmath1 mode for @xmath102 @xcite . in fig . [ fig_fmode](b ) we plot the complex frequencies of the the lowest @xmath1 mode . from fig . [ fig_fmode](b ) , we see that the @xmath27 dependence on the complex frequencies is important , although it was not considered in ref . @xcite . in fig . [ fig_dependencerw ] we plot the radiation radius as a function of the ( a ) frequency re(@xmath6 ) and ( b ) damping rate im(@xmath6 ) . the notes on the marks are the same as those in fig . [ fig_dependencerf ] . this figure tells us that it has the same tendency which appears in the case of the @xmath0 mode ; namely , the damping rate is very sensitive to the radiation radius , unlike the frequency . thus , if we directly observe the damping rate , we can constrain the radiation radius of the quark star . furthermore , along with the case of the @xmath0 mode , we plot the contour of the frequency and the damping rate of the lowest @xmath1 mode in the ( @xmath107 , @xmath27 ) plane in fig . [ fig_contourw ] . by using the lowest @xmath1 mode , we are able to develop a similar argument as that discussed in the case of the @xmath0 mode and get an independent constraint on the bag constant and @xmath3 quark mass . however , we should keep in mind that even if a large amount of energy is released through these modes , accurate observation of the @xmath9 and @xmath1 modes may be difficult . that is because both the frequency and damping rate of these modes are larger than the sensitivity ranges of gravitational wave interferometers @xcite . thus we would mainly use the observational data of the @xmath0 mode to obtain information about the bag model parameters . then we could subsidiarily use the data on the lowest @xmath1 mode . it should be noted that , since fig . [ fig_contourw ] has similar features found in the @xmath0 mode , even if we combine it with information from the @xmath0 mode , we may not have strict constraints on both @xmath27 and @xmath2 , independently . there exists an essential degeneracy in @xmath0 and the lowest @xmath109 mode qnms because the configuration of the contour of fig . [ fig_contourf ] is very similar to that of fig . [ fig_contourw ] . we have discussed how we can obtain information about the eos of quark matter by using future observations of gravitational waves emitted from quark stars . in particular we have studied the eos in bag models and assumed that the star is a pure quark star . we have computed the qnms i.e . , the @xmath0 and the lowest @xmath1 modes in several quark star models . we have demonstrated that by comparing the results of theoretical computations with the observational data of the @xmath0 mode and the lowest @xmath1 modes we can obtain constraints on the bag constant @xmath2 and @xmath3 quark mass @xmath29 . if we have the damping rate i.e . , im(@xmath6)of the @xmath0 mode within @xmath105 , the radiation radius of the quark star can be determined within about @xmath104 including the uncertainty of the @xmath3 quark mass . furthermore if we also obtain the frequency i.e . , re(@xmath6)of the @xmath0 mode within @xmath105 , the value of the bag constant can be determined within about @xmath108 , independently of the uncertainty of the @xmath3 quark mass , by using the simultaneously obtained radiation radius . concerning the lowest @xmath1 mode , we can also develop a similar argument as in the case of the @xmath0 mode and get independent constraints on the model parameters . however , note that it is relatively difficult to detect the lowest @xmath1 mode by the future planned gravitational wave interferometers whose frequency ranges are not very sensitive to the lowest @xmath1 mode . therefore , such data will be subsidiarily used in statistical analyses . it should be also noted that there is a degeneracy in the dependence of @xmath0 and the lowest @xmath1 mode qnm complex frequencies on the bag model parameters @xmath27 and @xmath2 . as for high frequency gravitational waves , a dual - type detector has been proposed , which would reach very good spectral strain sensitivities ( @xmath110 ) in a considerable broadband ( between @xmath111 and @xmath112 ) @xcite and then open a new interesting window to the qnms of compact objects . as long as we have data with tolerable accuracy in future , we will be able to perform statistical analyses to fit them and get constraints on both the bag constant and the @xmath3 quark mass . if we have further information about the bag constant or the @xmath3 quark mass by utilizing the eos models based on future developments in an effective theory of qcd , such as perturbation theories or finite - temperature lattice data , we can constrain them more strictly . including independent observations of the radiation radius e.g . , sorts of x - ray observations would also support us in inferring the bag model parameters . qnms from compact stars will be observed in the near future and deepen our understanding of hadron physics and qcd . we would like to thank k. maeda for useful discussions . was supported by the grants - in aid of the ministry of education , science , sports , and culture of japan ( grant no.15 - 03605 ) . th was supported by the jsps . j. hough , g.p . newton , n.a . robertson , h. ward , a.m. campbell , j.e . logan , d.i . robertson , k.a . strain , k. danzmann , h. lck , a. rdiger , r. schilling , m. schrempel , w. winkler , j.r.j . bennett , v. kose , m. khne , b.f . scultz , d. nicholson , j. shuttleworth , h. welling , p. aufmuth , r. rinkleff , a. tnnermann , and b. willke , in @xmath114 @xmath115 , new jersey , 1996 , edited by r. t. jantzen , g. m. keiser , r. ruffini , and r. edge ( world scientific , singapore , 1996 ) , p.1352 . drake @xmath17 @xmath18 . @xcite got a 99@xmath116 confidence upper limit of 2.7@xmath116 on the unaccelerated pulse fraction from 10@xmath117 to 100 hz . most recently burwitz @xmath17 @xmath18 . reported that a subsequent observation of rx j1856.5 - 3754 with _ xmm - newton _ allows the upper limit on the periodic variation in the x - ray region to be reduced to 1.3@xmath116 at 99@xmath116 c.l . from 10@xmath118 to 50 hz @xcite . b.a . freedman and l.d . mclerran , phys . d * 16 * , 1130 ( 1977 ) ; * 16 * , 1147 ( 1977 ) ; * 16 * , 1169 ( 1977 ) . t. degrand , r.l . jaffe , k. johnson , and j.e . kiskis , phys . rev . d * 12 * , 2060 ( 1975 ) . carlson , t.h . hansson , and c. peterson , phys . d * 27 * , 1556 ( 1983 ) . j. bartelski , a. szymacha , z. ryzak , l. mankiewicz , and s. tatur , nucl . * a424 * , 484 ( 1984 ) . for an ordinary class of neutron stars whose compactness is large , the damping rate of some of relatively lower @xmath9 modes is certainly smaller than that of @xmath1 modes @xcite . thus , only about the detection of them , the @xmath9 modes would be more significant than the @xmath1 modes in this class of neutron stars . for the models of the quark star adopted in this work , however , all damping rates of @xmath9 modes are larger than that of the lowest @xmath1 mode , because the compactness is smaller than that of such neuron stars @xcite . this tendency is discussed and clearly stated in ref . @xcite . in either case , those are not important because we do not treat with @xmath9 modes for our current purposes . mev and @xmath85 mev . thin lines denote the radiation radius @xmath89 . here we adopt three cases of the @xmath3 quark mass : i.e. , @xmath86 ( solid line ) , @xmath87 mev ( dashed line ) , and @xmath88 mev ( dotted line ) . we adopt @xmath119 as a value of the fine structure constant in qcd . ] mode and ( b ) the lowest @xmath10 mode for @xmath102 . the squares , circles and triangles represent @xmath86 , @xmath87 mev and @xmath88 mev , respectively . in each panel , the solid ( open ) marks denote the case of @xmath84 mev ( @xmath85 mev ) . ] ) and ( b ) damping rate im(@xmath6 ) of @xmath0 mode for @xmath102 in ( @xmath107 , @xmath27 ) plane . here we adopt the radiation radius as @xmath106 km . the numbers with the curve denote the value of frequency re(@xmath6 ) or damping rate im(@xmath6 ) in units of khz . ] ) and ( b ) damping rate im(@xmath6 ) of the lowest @xmath1 mode for @xmath102 in ( @xmath107 , @xmath27 ) plane . here we adopt the radiation radius as @xmath106 km . the numbers with the curve denote the value of frequency re(@xmath6 ) or damping rate im(@xmath6 ) in units of khz . ]

we consider the possibilities for obtaining information about the equation of state for quark matter by using future direct observational data on gravitational waves . we study the nonradial oscillations of both fluid and spacetime modes of pure quark stars . if we observe the @xmath0 and the lowest @xmath1 modes from quark stars , by using the simultaneously obtained radiation radius we can constrain the bag constant @xmath2 with reasonable accuracy , independently of the @xmath3 quark mass .

nlin0309025

phase dislocations carried by the wavefront of a light beam are associated with the zero - intensity points where the light intensity vanishes . the phase of the wave is twisted around such points creating a structure associated with _ an optical vortex_. optical beams with phase dislocations play an important role in linear singular optics @xcite . in self - focusing nonlinear media , an intense finite - extent laser beam becomes localized due to the self - trapping mechanism which can compensate for the beam diffraction . the nonlinear self - action of light may result in the formation of stationary structures with both intensity and phase remaining unchanged along the propagation direction . such self - trapped stationary structures of light beams are termed _ spatial optical solitons _ when such solitons have phase singularities , they determine the internal structure of the beam ; they can be stabilized by the light self - action generating nonlinear self - trapped optical beams carrying phase dislocations . examples of such beams include _ vortex solitons _ @xcite with point screw dislocations , _ multipole vector solitons _ @xcite with @xmath0-edge dislocations , and more complicated _ ` necklace'_-type beams @xcite and _ soliton clusters _ @xcite with a combination of a screw dislocation at the beam center and , generally , @xmath1-edge dislocations , where @xmath1 is the phase jump between neighboring peaks in the intensity distribution @xcite . the fundamental optical solitons show a fascinating combination of the properties of classical wave - packets together with a number of particle - like properties demonstrated in their elastic and inelastic interactions and mutual scattering , when each of the solitons preserves its identity . moreover , the coherent interaction between the solitons depends strongly on a relative phase what provides an additional degree of freedom to control the interaction . we may draw an analogy between spatial soliton and the ` atom of light ' , and then the soliton collision and interaction can be treated in terms of the effective forces acting between these effective ` atoms ' . following this concept , the higher - order multi - hump optical beams can be regarded as bound states of ` atoms ' trapped by a common potential induced in a nonlinear medium . a balance of the interaction forces acting between the solitons is the necessary condition for the formation of the soliton ` clusters ' or ` molecules of light ' . in this paper we investigate the excitation of higher - order beams , including optical vortices and soliton clusters , through the inelastic soliton scattering and mutual trapping of initially well - separated fundamental solitons , the effect resembling a synthesis of ` soliton molecules ' . in addition , we propose the application of this effect in the context of ` soliton algebra ' @xcite regarding the fundamental spatial solitons as the information carriers , and the transformation of an optical pattern induced by the soliton interaction as all - optical soliton switching . optical vortices were introduced as the first example of a stationary light beam with the phase twisted around its core ; the twist is proportional to @xmath2 with integer @xmath3 , the so - called topological charge of the phase dislocation @xcite . the physical model analyzing the evolution of the slowly varying field envelope @xmath4 is described by the nonlinear schrdinger equation , @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the transverse laplacian , and @xmath7 is the propagation distance measured in the units of the diffraction length . function @xmath8 describes the nonlinear properties of an optical medium , and it is assumed to depend on the total beam intensity , @xmath9 . the simplest spatially localized solution of equation carrying a phase dislocation , i.e. the vortex soliton , can be written in the form : @xmath10 , where @xmath11 and @xmath12 are the beam amplitude and propagation constant , respectively , while @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the polar coordinates in the transverse plane . in self - focusing nonlinear media , such vortex beams are the subject of the azimuthal modulational instability which result in splitting of the doughnut ring - like structure into a certain number of the fundamental solitons . the number of splitters and their dynamics are determined by the topological charge of the phase dislocation corresponding to the beam angular momentum ( see , e.g. , @xcite and references therein ) . the simplest higher - order scalar stationary solutions found for the model are a family of the radially symmetric solitons which includes radial modes with nodes in form of concentric rings . the important characteristic of these states is the _ soliton spin _ determined as a ratio of two conserved quantities , the beam angular momentum and the beam power . for the vortex soliton , the spin coincides with the topological charge @xmath3 of the phase dislocation carried by the vortex . because of the condition of the field univocally , the topological charge @xmath3 is quantized and has integer value . the fundamental spatial solitons and their higher - order radial states have zero spin . novel types of the higher - order self - trapped optical beams can be introduced as _ azimuthally modulated _ self - trapped structures in the form of the so - called ` necklace ' beams @xcite . however , it was found that a combination of the edge - phase dislocation with @xmath0-out - of - phase neighbor peaks can not produce a stationary state , and the structure becomes slowly expanding @xcite . such a stabilization is indeed possible for a more complicated system including the attraction between several incoherent beams @xcite . another approach to this problem is to combine the screw dislocation in the origin of a ring - shaped beam with the edge dislocation within the necklace @xcite . the screw dislocation introduces a centrifugal force to the ring , being also responsible for spiralling and mutual repulsion of the solitons in the case of vortex break - up @xcite , and the edge dislocations prevents noise - induced instability break - up of the ring . because of a nonzero angular momentum , the whole structure rotates with its propagation . as a result , the stabilization of the ring - shaped multihump beams requires complex phase distribution characterized by _ fractional _ value of the soliton spin @xcite . a phase distribution required for the formation of quasi - stationary higher - order self - trapped optical beams was found in references @xcite where the concept of _ soliton cluster _ was introduced . in this approach , the azimuthally modulated beam is regarded as a bound state of the interacting fundamental solitons . because of phase - sensitive interaction , the requirement of the balance of the interaction forces between the solitons determines the beam phase in the form of a _ staircase - like _ screw dislocation . compares the vortex phase dislocation ( left column ) with the phase of a four - soliton cluster , having well defined @xmath15 steps between the soliton positions ( right column ) . it was found @xcite that a _ radially stable _ dynamical bound state is formed if these phase - jumps satisfy the condition @xmath16 , with @xmath17 being the number of solitons in the ring . stability of the soliton clusters has been tested numerically for different nonlinear media , including cubic saturating , competing cubic self - focusing and quintic self - defocusing , and competing quadratic and cubic self - defocusing nonlinearities @xcite . the idea has been also extended to higher dimensions , covering the case of the spatio - temporal vortex solitons and light bullets . the common outcome of these studies is the confirmed robustness of the soliton clusters to random noise and strong radial perturbations . in the latter case , the pulsating states viewed as the radial excitations of ` soliton molecule ' have been observed . nevertheless , soliton clusters are the subject of modulational instability , and they are unstable with respect to azimuthal perturbations . the remarkable feature of this instability is that the number of the fundamental solitons flying off the main ring after the splitting is determined mainly by the topological charge @xmath3 instead of the initial number @xmath18 of solitons , similar to the vortex solitons . for what follows , we stress the fact that the conservation of the angular momentum of an optical beam in an isotropic medium determines the dynamics of splitters after break - up , so that the initial ` spin ' angular momentum of vortex or cluster can be viewed as being _ transformed _ into the orbital momentum of the spiralling splitters @xcite . recent progress in both theoretical and experimental studies of the higher - order optical spatial solitons brought the soliton community to the gates of the direct search for all - optical soliton - based switching schemes , when the initial data carried by the light distribution on the front - face of the nonlinear medium can be processed , in a predictable and controllable way , by employing the light self - action effects . one of the examples of such an approach is the recently proposed concept of the ` soliton algebra ' @xcite , based on the instability - induced break - up of optical vortices to the controllable number of the fundamental solitons . this idea also represents the example of a nontrivial approach to the soliton instability , when the symmetry - breaking instability , usually regarded as a serious disadvantage in using spatial solitons , is employed as _ a key physical mechanism _ for all - optical soliton switching from a given initial state ( optical vortex ) to the known final state defined by a certain number of fundamental solitons . this approach can be generalized to a broad variety of scalar and vector higher - order _ metastable _ solitons . the symmetry - breaking soliton instability may serve as a physical mechanism for all - optical switching with only one disadvantage it is a one - way process describing the transition from an initial higher - order state ( a soliton molecule or cluster ) to a number of simple stable states ( dipole - mode and fundamental solitons ) . below , we propose the opposite process , viewed as the excitation or ` synthesis ' of higher - order states from predefined number of initially separated solitons , or ` atoms of light ' , in a nonlinear bulk medium . indeed , introducing molecules of light would not be self - consistent without the possibility of mutual trapping of the free atoms or molecule synthesis . to demonstrate this phenomenon , we propagate numerically the ring - shaped arrays of initially well separated coherently interacting fundamental solitons in a saturable nonlinear medium . shows a characteristic example of a set of six solitons which have their relative phases growing in steps of @xmath19 along the ring , being initially directed to collide with each other . this initial condition corresponds to the inversion of the instability - induced ring break - up , so that the solitons move towards the ring instead of flying away . we observe highly inelastic collision of the solitons when they strongly interact overlapping and loosing their identity . nevertheless , the initial phases of the solitons are tilted in such a way that the total phase of the beams forms a screw dislocation in the ring origin which prevents a simple fusion of all solitons . instead , the ring - shaped structure is formed . similar situation is observed in with an array of eight solitons and the formation of a metastable vortex ring . due to large amplitude modulations , these intermediate ( or metastable ) structures never form ideal stationary states , and they quickly split off to a set of new isolated solitons , with the total number of splitters predefined by the initial conditions . in this way , we were able to produce , as a final state , the patterns with different number of solitons by changing initial parameters , including the number and phase tilt of solitons . generally , the final number of solitons is determined by the ring instability mode with a largest growth rate , and in a saturable medium it is usually twice the topological charge @xcite . at the same time , we were able to force single - charged ` meta - vortex ' in figures [ fig63 ] and [ fig84 ] to split to three and four fundamental solitons , respectively . the intermediate meta - state shows complex dynamics of the instability development which may continue for several tenths of diffraction lengths . thus , the whole picture of the soliton collision , ring formation , and the ring splitting is somewhat similar to the ` delayed - action interaction ' recently reported for interacting composite solitons carrying nonzero angular momentum @xcite . we note also that , in addition to the known transformation of ` spin - to - orbital ' angular momentum @xcite , in figures [ fig63 ] and [ fig84 ] we observe a kind of ` orbital - spin - orbital ' transformation . the change of the field momentum shown in is about @xmath20 of the initial value , and it occurs only at the break - up stage . highly unstable ring - shaped beams are formed as a result of mutual trapping and inelastic interaction of coherent solitons , as shown in figures [ fig63 ] and [ fig84 ] . they represent the intermediate steps in the process of the nonlinear switching between the states with a different number of solitons . in the context of the soliton algebra and all - optical switching , it might be of interest to study in more details and to determine the quantitative parameters necessary to obtain the final state with a given number of solitons . at the same time , the mutual trapping of coherent solitons is found to be too sensitive to the initial perturbations in order to produce the metastable clusters . nevertheless , it is indeed possible to generate higher - order optical beams , i.e. to synthesize the soliton molecules , from interacting fundamental _ coherent and incoherent _ solitons . in we show the excitation of a long - lived four - lobe vector cluster . we note that the four solitons in the ( b ) at @xmath21 are directed exactly to the center so that there is no azimuthal tilt of their phase . as within the cluster in , each soliton has a phase growing by a jump @xmath22 along the ring , and this initial phase distribution guarantees the appearance of the screw phase dislocation , even the corresponding value of the total angular momentum is very small ( a solid line in ) . because only the total angular momentum is conserved , but not the partial momenta of the components , there is a freedom for components to symmetrically exchange the angular momentum during the beam propagation . after mutual trapping of all solitons at @xmath23 the new - born vector cluster experiences strong radial oscillations between the states with maximal ( e.g. at @xmath24 and @xmath25 ) and minimal partial angular momenta in the components , see the diagram in . at the same time , the @xmath15-phase jumps introduced initially between the solitons ( edge dislocations ) survive these strong oscillations , and the whole cluster preserves its structure for a distance exceeding 100 diffraction lengths . therefore , we observe the formation of a composite state , the soliton molecule , by colliding simple solitons with a nontrivial phase pattern . we have studied the scattering and mutual trapping of several fundamental solitons and the generation of soliton clusters and vortex solitons the complex self - trapped states of light carrying phase dislocations in the wave front . inelastic collision of solitons has been shown to result in the formation of ring - shaped beams or metastable vortices which subsequently break - up creating different number of fundamental solitons defined by the initial conditions . this kind of the soliton delayed - action interaction and the nonlinear transformation of the number of fundamental solitons has been analyzed in the context of the soliton algebra and all - optical soliton switching . we have also shown that the vectorial interaction between the field components provides an additional mechanism of the soliton cluster stabilization . in particular , we have demonstrated the formation of vector soliton clusters from colliding solitons , the process which can be regarded as a synthesis of ` soliton molecules ' . desyatnikov a s , neshev d , ostrovskaya e a , kivshar yu s , krolikowski w , luther - davies b , garca - ripoll j j and prez - garcia v m 2001 _ opt . _ * 26 * 435 desyatnikov a s , neshev d , ostrovskaya e a , kivshar yu s , mccarthy g , krolikowski w and luther - davies b 2002 b * 19 * 586 soljai m , sears s and segev m 1998 4851 soljai m and segev m 2000 e * 62 * 2810 see also the earlier experimental observation , barthelemy a , froehly c and shalaby m 1994 _ proc . . eng . _ * 2041 * 104 desyatnikov a s and kivshar yu s 2002 053901 kartashov ya v , molina - terriza g and torner l 2002 b * 19 * 2682 desyatnikov a s and kivshar yu s 2002 s58 kartashov ya v , crasovan l c , mihalache d and torner l 2002 273902 crasovan l c , kartashov ya v , mihalache d , torner l , kivshar yu s and prez - garca v m 2003 e * 67 * 046610 torner l and sukhorukov a p 2002 _ opt . phot . * 13 * 42 minardi s , molina - terriza g , di trapani p , torres j p and torner l 2001 _ opt . * 26 * 1004 molina - terriza g , recolons j and torner l 2000 _ opt . lett . _ * 25 * 1135 petrov d v , torner l , martorell j , vilaseca r , torres j p and cojocaru c 1998 _ opt . lett . _ * 23 * 1444 pigier c , uzdin r , carmon t , segev m , nepomnyaschchy a and musslimani z h 2001 _ opt . * 26 * 1577musslimani z h , soljai m , segev m and christodoulides d n 2001 e * 63 * 066608musslimani z h , soljai m , segev m and christodoulides d n 2001 799

we describe different types of self - trapped optical beams carrying phase dislocations , including _ vortex solitons _ and ring - like _ soliton clusters_. we demonstrate numerically how to create such nonlinear singular beams by the interaction of several fundamental optical solitons . mutual trapping of several solitons can be regarded as a synthesis of _ ` soliton molecules ' _ , and it corresponds to a transfer of an initial orbital angular momentum of a system of solitons to a spin momentum of an optical vortex .

hep-ph0009333

our understanding of the qcd matter at low temperatures ( @xmath0 ) and high baryon number densities ( @xmath1 ) has developed rapidly over the past few years ; for recent reviews , see @xcite . a likely scenario is that in this region , quarks form cooper pairs and new condensates develop . one of the most interesting questions today concerns the detailed mapping of the qcd phase diagram , especially in the above region where qcd may exhibit a colour superconducting phase . in this context , the light quark masses ( @xmath3 ) are expected to play an important role . figure 1 shows two likely scenarios corresponding to @xmath4 and @xmath5 . the transition between the quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) phase and the colour superconducting phase is expected to be first order , in qcd @xcite . in this paper , we study the first - order phase transition between the qgp phase and the colour superconducting phase ( fig . our approach is phenomenological and is similar in spirit to that adopted by ct and kharchenko @xcite . they , however , studied the bose - einstein condensation in a gas of trapped atomic hydrogen at temperatures @xmath6 and densities @xmath7 @xmath8 . temperatures and densities that we shall consider here are , of course , vastly different , and qgp has very little in common with the atomic hydrogen gas . _ interestingly , however , as we shall see , the same physics of activation energy barrier governs the formation of droplets in both cases . _ it is important to get a handle on the cold and dense quark matter because of its possible relevance to the neutron - star core . while the region of _ asymptotic _ densities is amenable to rigorous calculations , the same can not be said about the region of _ intermediate _ densities studied here . both numerical ( lattice ) and direct experimental studies of this region of the qcd phase diagram are out of reach at the moment . hence a phenomenological study such as the present one is appropriate and worthwhile . it has allowed us to make quantitative statements about the schematic phase diagram in fig . 1 . alford et al . @xcite have discussed droplet formation in the transition between the hadronic matter phase and the 2sc phase ( fig . 1 ) , at @xmath9 , as a function of density . the chiral symmetry is restored inside their droplets ( which they call nucleons ) but is broken outside . neergaard and madsen @xcite also have studied the droplet formation but in the qgp to hadronic matter transition occurring at low baryon number densities . in this paper , we have considered the qgp to colour - superconducting phase transition occurring at high @xmath1 . _ to our knowledge , droplet formation in this transition has not been discussed previously in the literature . _ our droplets are the opposite of those in @xcite in the sense that the chiral symmetry is broken inside our droplet , but is restored outside . consider a gas of weakly interacting quarks , antiquarks and gluons in a volume @xmath10 . we take @xmath11 and @xmath12 to be the massless current quarks ( fig . 1 ) . we are interested in low temperatures ( @xmath0 ) and high number densities ( @xmath13 ) such that @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the thermal wave length ( see appendix ) . we also need the baryon number density @xmath16 to be large compared to that for the normal nuclear matter , namely 0.17 @xmath17 . if the interactions among the particles are treated to the lowest order in @xmath18 , the strong coupling constant ( fig . 2 ) , the baryon number density is given by ( @xmath19 ) @xmath20,\ ] ] where @xmath21 2 ( spin ) @xmath22 3 ( colour ) @xmath22 3 ( flavour ) = 18 is the quark degeneracy factor , @xmath23 is the boltzmann constant and @xmath24 is the quark chemical potential @xcite . for a given baryon number density @xmath1 and temperature @xmath0 , eq . ( 1 ) uniquely fixes @xmath24 . this in turn determines the total energy and pressure of the gas as @xmath25,\\ p_{gas } & = & e_{gas}/3v.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath26 2 ( spin ) @xmath22 8 ( colour ) = 16 is the gluon degeneracy factor . it was possible to obtain the above analytic expressions because we have considered the gas of quarks as well as antiquarks , rather than a gas of quarks alone @xcite . at low @xmath0 and high @xmath1 , the @xmath24 terms in the pressure dominate and the gluonic pressure arising from the first term in eq . ( 2 ) , is quite negligible . we now consider the first - order phase transition from qgp to the superconducting phase as the temperature is lowered ( fig . 1 ) . in the latter phase , as a result of the attractive one - gluon - exchange interaction between quarks in the colour @xmath27 channel , quarks near the fermi surface tend to pair up as bosons . these are the cooper pairs which we assume to be massless . density fluctuations in the metastable qgp gas may provide suitable conditions for nucleation and growth of a droplet of the superconducting phase . the high - temperature phase ( qgp ) is present around the droplet and the low - temperature superconducting phase exists inside the droplet . we will presently explore the energetics for the formation of such a droplet by calculating the energy barrier between the two phases . we have given above the expressions for number density , energy and pressure of the qgp ; see eqs . ( 1)-(3 ) . we now derive corresponding expressions for the superconducting phase inside the droplet . before we begin , it is necessary to recall important differences between the bcs superconductor and the colour superconductor . ( a ) in the bcs theory of superconductivity the ratio of the energy gap ( @xmath28 ) to the fermi kinetic energy for a typical metal is of the order of @xmath29 . in contrast , in the problem under consideration , the gap @xmath28 is estimated to vary between several tens of mev to about 100 mev @xcite , and the quark chemical potential @xmath24 appearing in eq . ( 1 ) takes values between @xmath30 and @xmath31 mev for the @xmath1 and @xmath0 considered here . ( b ) in the bcs superconductor , the debye energy @xmath32 is much smaller than the chemical potential @xmath33 , while in the colour superconductor , the two may be of the same order of magnitude . ( c ) finally , if @xmath13 is the density of electrons and @xmath34 the pippard coherence length which measures the spatial extension of the cooper pair wave function , then in the bcs theory , @xmath35 . in the present case , on the other hand , @xmath36 fm for @xmath37 mev , and @xmath38 for the densities considered in this paper . this suggests that the @xmath39 pairs are rather compact objects unlike cooper pairs of electrons in a metal . for a good discussion of these and related issues , see a review article by kerbikov @xcite . we shall make use of the above points while deriving expressions for thermodynamics quantities of the droplet . for the sake of simplicity , we shall assume that all quarks in the energy interval @xmath40 form cooper pairs and all other quarks remain unpaired , and shall ignore other interactions . consider a spherical region of radius @xmath41 , volume @xmath42 , containing @xmath43 quarks out of which @xmath44 remain unpaired and @xmath45 undergo cooper pairing , when the pairing interaction is `` switched on '' . we have @xmath46 where @xmath47^{-1}$ ] with @xmath48 . the corresponding energies @xmath49 are @xmath50 in the last equation @xmath51 is the number of cooper pairs ( bosons ) in the droplet and @xmath52 is the energy of the ground state of the single - particle spectrum of a spherical cavity of radius @xmath41 . due to the small size of the droplet , even the lowest excited state has energy which is very large compared to the temperature . therefore all the @xmath39 pairs tend to occupy the ground state @xcite . next , entropies @xmath53 are given by @xmath54,\\ s_2 & = & s_1 + \frac{d_q v_d}{(2 \pi)^3 } \int^{\mu_q}_{\mu_q-\delta } 4 \pi p^2 dp \left [ f \ln f + ( 1-f ) \ln ( 1-f ) \right],\\ s_3 & = & 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath55 can be taken to be zero for the reasons given above . finally , the pressures @xmath56 are calculated as follows : @xmath57 the thermodynamic potential @xmath58 for massless quarks is given by @xmath59.\ ] ] hence @xmath60 \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{e_1}{3v_d}-\frac{ktd_q}{2 \pi^2}\int_{\mu_q-\delta } ^{\mu_q } p^2 dp \ln\left[1 + \exp \beta ( \mu_q - p ) \right ] . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] performing the last integration by parts and rearranging the terms , one finally gets @xmath61 \}.\ ] ] the quantal pressure @xmath62 is given by @xmath63 it is easy to verify that if @xmath28 is set equal to zero , i.e. if no pairing is allowed to take place , @xmath45 , @xmath64 , @xmath62 vanish and @xmath44 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 become equal to @xmath43 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , respectively . contribution of antiquarks to the above thermodynamic quantities is smaller by many orders of magnitude . although we have included it in our calculations its effect is negligible . the droplet pressure @xmath71 is given by @xmath72 where @xmath67 and @xmath62 are as in eqs . ( 14)-(15 ) , @xmath73 and @xmath74 are the corresponding pressures due to antiquarks and @xmath75 is the pressure due to gluons in the droplet . consider once again the spherical region of radius @xmath41 . initially , i.e. before the pairing interaction is switched on , there are @xmath43 quarks , @xmath76 antiquarks and a certain number of gluons in it . in the final state , i.e. when the pairing interaction is on , there are @xmath44 quarks , @xmath51 quark pairs , @xmath77 antiquarks , @xmath78 antiquark pairs and the same number of gluons as before . the activation energy ( @xmath79 ) is defined as the difference between the helmholtz free energies ( @xmath80 ) in the final and initial states . since the gluonic contribution cancels out , one gets @xmath81 in the limit @xmath82 , this @xmath79 vanishes . the reader may wonder why surface tension of the droplet makes no appearance in our formalism . in the classical theory of nucleation , there are two competing contributions to the energy of a droplet : droplet formation reduces bulk free energy but only at the cost of surface energy . the former contribution wins if the droplet radius exceeds a certain critical value , while the surface tension ensures that a droplet with a smaller radius shrinks and disappears . in the formalism presented here , energy of the droplet is calculated quantum mechanically . it is clear from eq . ( 9 ) that small droplets have large quantal energy and tend to dissolve back into the qgp gas . this is similar to the effect of the surface tension in the classical theory . moreover , the thermal wavelength ( @xmath15 ) of the quarks is so large that a classification of particles as those localized on the surface and those in the interior breaks down . in short , we did not neglect the surface energy ; it is included in the total free energy of the quantal droplet . the precise boundaries of the various phases in fig . 1 are not known . since the baryon number density ( @xmath1 ) of the normal nuclear matter is @xmath83 @xmath17 , we have performed numerical calculations for @xmath84 0.5 to 3 @xmath17 and temperature @xmath85 0 to 100 mev . the resulting quark chemical potential @xmath24 varies over @xmath86 mev and the baryon chemical potential @xmath87 varies over @xmath88 mev . this fully covers the densities likely to be seen in the neutron - star cores . we have considered four different values of the superconducting gap parameter @xmath28 , namely , 1 , 10 , 50 and 100 mev . since we are interested in a gas of weakly interacting quarks , antiquarks and gluons , we take @xmath18 to be zero . small values of @xmath18 do not affect the results in eqs . ( 1)-(3 ) significantly . we first choose a set of values for @xmath1 and @xmath0 , and solve eq . ( 1 ) numerically to determine @xmath24 . this @xmath24 is then used to evaluate @xmath89 as given by eq . also , once @xmath24 is determined , @xmath90 and @xmath91 can be evaluated separately by using @xmath92 ( above integrations can not be done analytically , and so it is not possible to get closed expressions like eq . ( 1 ) , for @xmath90 and @xmath93 . ) next , we choose a value for @xmath28 , and treating the droplet radius @xmath41 as a free parameter , calculate various other quantities ; see eqs . ( 4)-(17 ) . some of these results are shown in figs . 3 - 4 . in our formalism , as in the classical theory , the activation energy when plotted as a function of the radius ( fig . 3 ) , initially increases from zero , attains a maximum , then starts decreasing monotonically eventually becoming negative for a sufficiently large value of the radius . in other words , the activation energy exhibits a barrier . _ the barrier originates as follows_. consider eq . as already stated , the antiquark terms are extremely small . the terms @xmath94 and @xmath95 are also negligible and in fact they tend to cancel each other . that leaves three terms , namely @xmath96 and @xmath64 . for small radii , @xmath65 and the quantal energy term @xmath64 dominate pushing the activation energy curve upwards . for large radii , the @xmath68 term dominates pulling the curve to the negative domain . as expected , the barrier becomes wider if @xmath0 is raised or if @xmath1 is lowered . the critical radii can be read off from fig . 3 . droplets with larger radii readily grow because that tends to reduce the activation energy . this in turn easily brings about the transition from qgp to the superconducting phase . figure 4 shows the ratio of the droplet pressure to the pressure of the surrounding gas , for @xmath97 mev . this ratio is significantly larger than unity for small droplets , which will tend to push the radii to larger values , thereby helping to bring about the qgp to superconducting phase transition . in the limit @xmath82 , this ratio tends to unity and is thus incapable of pushing the droplet radii to larger values . it is interesting to know the properties of the droplet when the pressure inside the droplet ( eq . 16 ) equals the pressure of the surrounding qgp gas ( eq . these results are shown in figs . the condition @xmath98 fixes @xmath41 . we solve the equation @xmath99 numerically to determine @xmath41 , for various values of @xmath1 , @xmath0 and @xmath28 . @xmath1 was varied from 0.5 to 3 @xmath17 in the steps of 0.5 @xmath17 . figure 5 shows the results for @xmath41 . as @xmath0 and/or @xmath1 are increased , @xmath41 decreases . however , @xmath41 is found to be rather insensitive to the variation in @xmath1 . although we have varied @xmath0 between 0 and 100 mev , temperatures relevant for neutron stars are close to zero . because of the small value of @xmath41 , the energy of even the lowest excited state inside the droplet turns out to be several hundreds of mev which is large compared to the temperature , effectively forcing all cooper pairs ( bosons ) to occupy the ground state . _ note also that at low temperatures , the droplet radius @xmath41 is larger than the pippard coherence length @xmath100 . _ figure 6 shows the activation energy @xmath79 . first see the upper half of fig . 6 . for a fixed @xmath1 , as @xmath0 increases , @xmath79 changes its sign from negative to positive . this is expected because , at higher @xmath0 , droplet formation is energetically unfavourable . secondly , as @xmath1 increases ( see curves labelled _ a _ to _ f _ ) , @xmath79 remains negative up to higher and higher @xmath0 . this is also expected because at higher @xmath1 , the transition to the superconducting phase is facilitated . now see the lower half of fig . 6 . it shows the @xmath101 contour , in the @xmath2 plane . this is also the phase transition curve separating the qgp phase at high @xmath0 and the superconducting phase at low @xmath0 : recall @xmath102 where @xmath80 are the free energies of the two phases . both @xmath103 and @xmath104 decrease as @xmath0 increases and cross each other at some temperature , say @xmath105 ( fig . since the system follows the path of minimum @xmath80 , there is a kink in @xmath106 . in other words , the slope @xmath107 has a discontinuity , indicating a first - order phase transition at @xmath105 . thus the @xmath101 contour serves to demarcate the region of the superconducting phase . note that as @xmath1 increases , the @xmath108 region in fig . 6 survives up to higher and higher @xmath0 . we now present an estimate of the latent heat ( @xmath109 ) associated with the first - order phase transition considered in this paper . the transition temperature @xmath105 for any given @xmath1 can be determined from fig . the latent heat is then estimated as @xmath110 . for @xmath97 mev , this turns out to be @xmath111 to @xmath30 mev and it increases with @xmath1 . in the limit @xmath82 , the two free - energy curves in fig . 7 coincide , @xmath79 vanishes , @xmath112 , there is no discontinuity in entropy , and the latent heat is zero . there is only one phase namely qgp , and there is no question of any phase transition . finally , fig . 8 shows 3-dimensional surface plots of the ( normalized ) activation energy @xmath113 defined as @xmath114 as a function of @xmath1 and @xmath0 , for @xmath115 and 100 mev . it is clear that in the limit @xmath116 , the activation energy surface is flat and there is no energy advantage for the qgp to superconducting phase transition . indeed there would be only one phase , namely qgp , which would extend up to the @xmath117 axis . on the other hand , for @xmath97 mev , the surface is such that the system would like to `` roll down '' the slope thereby bringing about the phase transition . it is interesting to compare the activation energy results for the qcd phase transition , obtained here with those for the bose - einstein condensation in a gas of trapped atomic hydrogen , presented in @xcite . in @xcite two gas densities were considered : @xmath118 @xmath8 and @xmath119 @xmath8 both at the same temperature @xmath120 . we have repeated their calculations for @xmath121 . their activation energy exhibits a barrier , and they denote the maximum value of the activation energy by @xmath122 . consider the ratio @xmath123 at the peak position and the corresponding number @xmath124 of particles in the droplet . in @xcite these two quantities are highly sensitive to the changes in the gas density and temperature . for the inset , it is @xmath125 a.u . ] for instance , for the above tiny change in the gas density , the ratio @xmath123 changes from 4.8 to 104.1 , and @xmath124 changes from 18 to 3862 . similar sensitivity was seen when @xmath0 was changed by a few @xmath126 . in contrast , the results presented here are relatively stable with respect to changes in @xmath1 and @xmath0 . in conclusion , we have studied hitherto unexplored first - order phase transition from qgp to a colour - superconducting phase , and have presented a simple model of the transition with very few assumptions . it provides numerical support to the prevalent ideas of phase structure of qcd in the low - temperature , high - baryon - number - density regime . we have studied properties of the droplets of the superconducting phase , formed at various points in the @xmath2 plane , for several values of the gap parameter . we have been able to estimate the extent of the superconducting phase in this plane and the latent heat of the transition . at low temperatures , droplet radii are found to be larger than the pippard coherence length which measures the spatial extent of the @xmath39 cooper pairs . rsb acknowledges the hospitality of the mcmaster university where this work was initiated . we thank mark alford and mustansir barma for their comments on this work . this research was partially supported by a grant from nserc ( canada ) . if @xmath127 is the distribution function of a gas in equilibrium , the number density @xmath13 is given by @xmath128 . for a nonrelativistic classical gas at temperature @xmath0 , one has @xmath129,\ ] ] where @xmath130 and @xmath33 is the chemical potential . hence @xmath131 where @xmath15 is the thermal wave length . for an extreme relativistic gas of massless classical particles , @xmath132,\ ] ] and hence @xmath133 we define the thermal wave length in this case as @xmath134 so that the fugacity @xmath135 once again equals @xmath136 . schematic phase diagrams of qcd : @xmath0 is the temperature and @xmath137 is the baryon chemical potential . @xmath138 is the critical point at which the line of first - order phase transitions ends . @xmath139 and @xmath140 ( colour - flavour - locked ) are 2-flavour - like and 3-flavour - like colour superconducting phases , respectively . the dashed line denotes the critical temperature at which quark - quark pairing vanishes . the thick arrow indicates the first - order phase transition considered in this paper . for the normal nuclear matter at @xmath117 , @xmath137 should be defined as @xmath141 where @xmath142 @xmath143 @xcite and @xmath144 is the nucleon mass , which gives @xmath145 mev . ( figure adapted from @xcite . ) activation energy @xmath79 vs droplet radius @xmath41 for various gap values @xmath28 . baryon number density @xmath1 ( @xmath17 ) and temperature @xmath0 ( mev ) are : ( a ) 0.5 and 5 ( b ) 0.5 and 100 ( c ) 3 and 5 ( d ) 3 and 100 , respectively . upper panel : activation energy @xmath79 vs temperature @xmath0 . baryon number densities @xmath1 ( @xmath17 ) are ( a ) 0.5 ( b ) 1 ( c ) 1.5 ( d ) 2 ( e ) 2.5 ( f ) 3 . lower panel : the @xmath101 contour or the phase transition line in the @xmath2 plane . sc : superconducting phase .

considering the low - temperature ( @xmath0 ) and high - baryon - number - density ( @xmath1 ) region of the qcd phase diagram , we present a model for the first - order phase transition between the quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) and the recently proposed colour superconducting phase . we study nucleation of a droplet of the superconducting phase within the metastable qgp gas . numerical results for the activation energy , radius and other physical parameters of the droplets , at various temperatures , densities and gap parameters , are given . we have estimated the latent heat of the phase transition . in the @xmath2 plane , we are able to demarcate the region of the superconducting phase . pacs numbers : 12.38.mh , 12.38.aw , 26.60.+c , 64.60.qb _ keywords _ : quark - gluon plasma , qcd phase transition , colour superconductivity , droplet formation , diquark ' '' '' 0.3 cm e - mail : bhalerao@theory.tifr.res.in , bhaduri@smiley.physics.mcmaster.ca

nlin0407053

the issue of whether increasing the complexity of a network contributes to its dynamical instability has long been debated . this ` complexity vs stability ' debate is especially acute in the field of ecology @xcite , as it relates to the importance of diversity for the long - term survival of ecosystems . however , understanding the relation between the network structure and its stability ( with respect to dynamical perturbations ) is crucial , as it is related to the robustness of systems as ubiquitous as power grids , financial markets , and even complex societies and civilizations@xcite . pioneering studies on the stability of networks , both theoretical@xcite and numerical@xcite , suggested that increasing the network complexity , as measured by its size ( @xmath0 ) , density of connections ( @xmath1 ) and the strength of interactions between coupled elements ( @xmath2 ) , almost inevitably leads to the destabilization of any arbitrary equilibrium state of the system . this result , known as the may - wigner stability theorem , seemed to fly in the face of conventional wisdom that higher diversity makes a system more capable of surviving perturbations and has since led to much research on the connection between network complexity and stability@xcite . the may - wigner argument @xcite confines itself to analyzing the local stability of an arbitrarily chosen equilibrium point of the network dynamics . under such constraints , the explicit dynamics at the nodes can be ignored and the stability is governed by the leading eigenvalue of the linear stability matrix @xmath3 . as a first approximation , one can consider the network elements to be coupled randomly with each other . if the connection weights between linked nodes follow a gaussian distribution ( with mean 0 and variance @xmath4 ) , then it follows that @xmath3 is a random matrix . therefore , existing rigorous results on the eigenvalue distribution of random matrices can be applied , which allows one to make the assertion that the network is almost certainly stable if @xmath5 , and almost certainly unstable otherwise . objections to the may - wigner argument have often revolved around the assumption of a randomly connected network . as pointed out by many ecologists , most networks occurring in nature are not random , and seem to have structures such as trophic levels in the predator - prey relations between different species . some early studies seemed to suggest that introducing a hierarchical organization ( e.g. , by partitioning the adjacency matrix of the network into blocks @xcite or by having tree structures @xcite ) can increase the stability of a network under certain conditions . however , no general consensus on this issue has yet been achieved . the introduction of small - world " connection topology@xcite has allowed the possibility of having different kinds of structures in a network , other than a straightforward hierarchy of levels . small - world networks have the global properties of a random network ( short average path length between the elements ) while at the local level they resemble regular networks with a high degree of clustering among neighbors . in fact , several empirically obtained food web networks have been analyzed by different research groups looking for evidence of small - world structure . initial reports of small - world ecological networks based on the analysis of 4 food webs @xcite have been challenged by a study based on 7 food webs @xcite , and , more recently , by a comprehensive analysis of 16 food webs covering a wide variety of habitats@xcite . the latter studies did not see significantly high clustering in most of these systems , compared to a random network . in light of this , it is inevitable to ask oneself whether the introduction of small world connectivity confer any advantage to the network . if the occurrence of higher than average clustering has no functional significance , then the occurrence of small - world structures in a few networks are probably due to chance alone . in particular , we can ask whether introducing such structures in a network can make it more stable , and therefore , able to survive perturbations compared to its random counterpart . in this paper we strive to answer the above question . although there have been previous studies on the eigenvalue distribution of small - world networks@xcite , the issue of stability has not been looked at in any depth . in the next section , we have described the basic model used to study the stability of the network as its structure is changed from regular through small - world to random . the results of extensive numerical studies is reported in section 3 , which suggests that the stability - instability transition occurs at the same critical value independent of the network structure ; but the nature of this transition ( as measured by the finite - size scaling exponent ) changes with the topology . finally , we conclude with a brief discussion of the implications of our results . to observe the stability of networks at the small - world regime we follow the basic watts - strogatz construction @xcite . a ring consisting of @xmath0 nodes , with each node connected to @xmath6 neighbors ( i.e. , neighborhood size is @xmath7 ) , is rewired with probability @xmath8 . in other words , a fraction @xmath8 of the links among the nodes in the lattice are broken and then randomly reconnected , subject to the condition that the total number of links does not change and that two nodes are not connected by more than one directed link . as outlined in ref.@xcite , increasing @xmath8 decreases both the average path length and the clustering between nodes . in addition , we introduce randomly distributed weights to each of the links . following may @xcite , we generate the corresponding linear stability matrix @xmath3 , such that , the non - zero entries are chosen from a gaussian distribution with mean 0 and variance @xmath4 . in addition , to ensure that the nodes are individually stable in the absence of connections , the diagonal elements of @xmath3 are chosen to be @xmath9 . for a given @xmath8 , the stability of the resulting network is then examined by observing the sign of the leading eigenvalue @xmath10 of @xmath3 as a function of size ( @xmath0 ) , connectance ( @xmath11 ) and strength of connectivity ( @xmath2 ) . if @xmath12 , the network is considered unstable . the corresponding probability of stability @xmath13 is calculated by carrying out a large number of network realizations . while this analysis does not explicitly consider dynamics , recent studies@xcite indicate that including the dynamics of the nodes does not qualitatively change the results obtained using the above technique . it is possible that a sparsely connected network can be broken up into disconnected clusters by the rewiring procedure . for this reason , in the simulations reported here we have used @xmath14 , which ensures that the entire network remains connected . note that , unlike another study on the stability of small - world networks @xcite , we are analyzing the stability of an asymmetric sparse matrix whose non - zero entries are normally distributed . as mentioned in the previous section , we observe the order parameter @xmath13 against the different network complexity parameters . for instance , keeping @xmath0 and @xmath1 fixed , as we increase @xmath2 , @xmath13 decreases from 1 to 0 , i.e. , the network shows a stability - instability transition . the critical parameter value , @xmath15 , at which the transition occurs remains unchanged as we vary the connection topology from regular ( @xmath16 ) through small - world to random ( @xmath17 ) . this implies that changing the connection topology does not affect the stability of a network . however , the transition appears to get sharper as the network becomes more random . = 5.5 in to quantitatively measure the increase in steepness with randomness we used finite - size scaling analysis . the sharpness of the stability - instability transition increases with @xmath0 for all topologies ; finite - size scaling allows us to measure how the relative width of the transition region decreases with increasing @xmath0 . it was noted by may@xcite that for random networks , this scales as @xmath18 . we have carried out this analysis for networks with different values of @xmath8 , where the width of the transition region scales as @xmath19 , and we observe the variation of @xmath20 with @xmath8 . as shown in fig . 1 , @xmath21 for regular networks , and gradually decreases with @xmath8 , ultimately becoming @xmath22 for @xmath17 ( as expected at the random network limit ) . = 5.5 in = 5.5 in to understand why the nature of the stability - instability transition is affected by the network topology , we look at the eigenvalue plain of the regular and random networks ( fig . the eigenvalues of the latter are bounded by a circle centered at @xmath9 and having a radius of @xmath23 . however , for regular networks , there are extensions from this circle along the real axis . the largest eigenvalues are located on this ` tail ' . the extended tails of the eigenvalue distribution for @xmath24 are shown in greater detail in fig . 3 . for @xmath17 , the distribution is bounded , as predicted by wigner s semicircle theorem . however , in the presence of clustering ( i.e. , as @xmath25 ) , the distribution extends out of the limits predicted by the semicircle distribution . the stability of the network is governed by the maximal eigenvalue . for the regular network , this is found at the tail of the eigenvalue distribution where the relative variance of @xmath10 is much larger than if it was located in the bulk ( as is the case for @xmath17 ) . this results in a smoother transition from stability to instability for regular networks . = 5.5 in it has been pointed out in ref . @xcite that in real - world networks , links are ` expensive ' . therefore , we also looked at the case where @xmath7 is fixed as the system size increases ( so that @xmath1 decreases with @xmath0 ) . for low values of @xmath7 ( relative to fixed @xmath0 ) we observe that the eigenvalue distribution shows a peak at the center , presumably due to contributions from small isolated clusters as mentioned in ref . @xcite . at higher values of @xmath7 , we observe distributions similar to the ones obtained for the constant @xmath1 case reported before . however , a major difference was the relation between system size ( @xmath0 ) and the largest eigenvalue , @xmath10 , as well as the fraction of real eigenvalues , @xmath26 ( fig . 4 ) . for random networks , @xmath10 attains a constant value for large values of @xmath0 . further , as pointed out in ref . @xcite , the excess density of real eigenvalues decreases with @xmath0 roughly as @xmath27 . however , for regular networks , @xmath10 grows with @xmath0 as @xmath28 ( in fig . 4 , @xmath29 ) and the excess density of real eigenvalues becomes constant for large @xmath0 . this implies that as the regular network increases in size , the tail of the eigenvalue distribution gets longer ( while the bulk remains fixed in size , similar to random networks ) . also , more and more eigenvalues migrate from the complex plane to the real axis , keeping its density constant even though the system size ( and hence , the total number of eigenvalues ) is increasing . these results imply that for the case of fixed number of links , regular networks are likely to be more unstable than random networks as the system size is increased . based on the results reported above we conclude that the introduction of small - world structure , i.e. , a high degree of clustering among the nodes of a network , does not increase the network stability . on the contrary , in certain conditions , such a structure might make the network more unstable than its random counterpart . however , it was established quantitatively ( using finite - size scaling ) that the nature of the stability - instability transition with increasing complexity appears to change with the connection topology . in particular , networks with higher degree of regularity destabilize more smoothly compared to the abrupt transition to instability for random networks . this may have implications for the occurrence of small - world structure in certain food webs . although unable to make the network more stable , such clustering structures may avoid the disastrous consequences of instability by making the deterioration of the network more gradual , compared to a random network .

according to the may - wigner stability theorem , increasing the complexity of a network inevitably leads to its destabilization , such that a small perturbation will be able to disrupt the entire system . one of the principal arguments against this observation is that it is valid only for random networks , and therefore does not apply to real - world networks , which presumably are structured . here we examine how the introduction of small - world topological structure into networks affect their stability . our results indicate that , in structured networks , the parameter values at which the stability - instability transition occurs with increasing complexity is identical to that predicted by the may - wigner criteria . however , the nature of the transition , as measured by the finite - size scaling exponent , appears to change as the network topology transforms from regular to random , with the small - world regime as the cross - over region . this behavior is related to the localization of the largest eigenvalues along the real axis in the eigenvalue plain with increasing regularity in the network . pacs numbers : 89.75.-k , 05.10.-a , 02.70.hm , 87.23.-n

0804.4212

the study of simple lattice models has emerged as an effective way to understand nonequilibrium steady states and phase transitions @xcite . in particular , the simple exclusion process @xcite and the zero range process @xcite , owing to their simplicity and richness , have emerged as paradigms for nonequilibrium systems . when such processes are considered with periodic boundary conditions , a phase transition can occur either due to dynamical features such as particle jump rates @xcite , chipping and aggregation @xcite , or due to the presence of disorder on the lattice @xcite . on the other hand , the presence of open boundaries , where particles can be inserted and removed , is significant enough to lead to boundary - induced phase transitions @xcite . the phase diagram is well understood for the basic version of the asymmetric simple exclusion process with open boundaries . besides its analytic solutions @xcite , the underlying physical mechanism is also well understood in terms of the group velocity @xcite as well as the domain wall velocity and collective velocity @xcite . recently it was reported that some additional dynamical features such as evaporation and deposition @xcite or nonlocal hopping @xcite lead to new kinds of phases and phase transitions . in this paper , we study the phase transition in a generalized version of the one - dimensional symmetric simple exclusion process ( ssep ) with open boundaries where the additional feature of nonlocal hopping is included . by increasing the nonlocal hopping rate ( or equivalently decreasing the input rate of particles at the boundaries ) , the system undergoes a first order phase transition from a finite density ( fd ) phase into an empty road ( er ) phase with zero density via a clustered state at the transition . this is quite different from the dynamic instability transitions found in the totally asymmetric simple exclusion process ( tasep ) with nonlocal hopping studied previously @xcite . in the tasep variant , the particle clusters are stable and moving with a drift velocity depending on the nonlocal hopping rate in the most part of the fd phase . in our case , the clusters are stationary on average and stable only at the transition . they expand until they fill up the whole system in the fd phase and shrink away in the er phase where the whole system is empty except for finite - size clusters clinging to the boundaries . at the transition , the particle clusters are distributed over the system with a power - law gap ( intercluster distance ) distribution . the periodic - boundary ( pb ) version of our model was already investigated @xcite in terms of a mass transport process . there are similarities and also differences , compared to the open - boundary case . in the pb setup , the number of particles is conserved and plays the role of the external parameter . as the particle density decreases , one finds a continuous condensation ( phase separation ) transition from a homogeneous density state to a state with an infinite stretch of empty sites ( macroscopic mass at a site in the language of the mass transport model ) . the homogeneous density state is basically the same as the fd state in our open - boundary setup except near the boundaries . the same applies to the critical state . however , the condensed state includes the background particle clusters with the critical gap distribution over a finite fraction of the system besides the macroscopic gap , while the exponential gap distribution only near the boundaries ( vanishing fraction of the system ) is found in the er phase . based on the cluster dynamics analysis , we show that the particle density controls the stability of a cluster . clusters are stable only at a specific density against nonlocal hopping events , which determines the transition point . high - density clusters expand mainly by local hopping events , while low - density clusters shrink easily by nonlocal hopping events . we claim that two seemingly different transitions in both boundary setups are caused by the same mechanism based on the cluster stability . we will also argue that the difference in the nature of the condensed and er phase is simply due to the presence of possible exits for particles through the open boundaries . the conventional ssep has been well studied with both periodic and open boundary conditions @xcite . with periodic or symmetric open boundary setups , the ssep is an equilibrium system with no phase transitions . although our dynamical rule in the bulk and at the boundaries does not break the left - right symmetry present in the ssep , the extra feature of nonlocal hopping drives the system out of equilibrium and leads to a significant change in the steady - state nature for both boundary setups . as a result , contrary to the conventional ssep with open boundaries , our modified version exhibits an abrupt nonequilibrium transition on varying the input rates at boundaries and the nonlocal hopping rate . this paper is organized as follows : in sec . [ phase diagram ] , we describe our model and present the numerical results for the phase diagram , clustering , gap distributions , density profile , and finite - size properties . in sec . [ cluster analysis ] , we develop a cluster dynamics analysis at the mean - field level . the cluster stability determines the transition line , which is compared with numerical results . finally , we discuss the physical origin of this abrupt transition as well as the difference in the periodic version . we conclude the paper in sec . [ conclusion ] with a brief summary . phase diagram . the symbols with error bars are obtained from our numerical data and the dashed line is estimated by the cluster mean - field prediction . to guide the eyes , a solid line is drawn through the data points . ] at the transition @xmath0 . the solid line is drawn with @xmath1 . ] consider a chain of length @xmath2 with sites , @xmath3 , that can either be empty or occupied by a particle with hard core repulsion , thus the occupancy @xmath4 . the chain is open and in contact with two reservoirs at @xmath5 and @xmath6 , respectively . the evolution rule for our process is as follows : select a site randomly including two reservoirs ( @xmath7 ) . if the site @xmath8 is occupied by a particle ( or one of the reservoirs ) , we attempt to move the particle . the move is successful only if the target site is unoccupied . the particle either tries to move to the nearest - neighboring site to the left(right ) with probability @xmath9 ( local hopping ) , or it tries to jump to the unoccupied site directly behind the nearest occupied site in the left(right ) direction with probability @xmath10 respectively ( nonlocal hopping ) ; see fig . [ dynamics ] . in case the chain is completely empty in the chosen direction , the particle jumps all the way into the reservoir . if one of the reservoir sites , @xmath11 , is selected , a particle tries to jump on the nearest - neighboring site ( @xmath12 ) with probability @xmath13 . nonlocal hopping events from the reservoirs are not allowed in our setup . the particles at the left and right edge of the chain leave the system with probability @xmath14 . figure [ phase ] shows the phase diagram obtained from our monte carlo simulations with road lengths up to @xmath15 as well as the cluster mean - field ( mf ) prediction which will be discussed in sec . [ cluster analysis ] . at @xmath16 , the process reduces to the conventional ssep where the stationary state is well known to be the reservoir - controlled uniform phase which we shall call the finite density ( fd ) phase . here , the bulk ( road ) density @xmath17 is known exactly as @xmath18 . the fd phase extends into @xmath19 for all @xmath20 with @xmath17 decreasing slowly with @xmath21 . for strong nonlocal hopping ( large @xmath21 ) , the stationary state changes into the empty road ( er ) phase with @xmath22 with finite - size _ mother _ clusters clinging to reservoirs . the phase transition from the fd phase into the er phase turns out to be always discontinuous with a jump of @xmath23 at the transition @xmath0 ( fig . [ jump ] ) . this implies that this instability transition is caused by competition of the bulk density against the nonlocal hopping rate . the boundary parameters such as the input rate @xmath20 only play an implicit role in this transition via determining the bulk density . this suggests that our open - boundary version should be very similar , if not identical , to the periodic - boundary version which is controlled directly by the bulk density and the nonlocal hopping rate . in fact , the phase boundary is known exactly for the periodic - boundary version as @xmath24 @xcite , which is also likely to determine the phase boundary in our open - boundary setup . our numerical results strongly support this . however , it is not trivial to find the bulk density @xmath17 as a function of @xmath20 and @xmath21 . we estimate this at the mean - field level in sec . [ cluster analysis ] and the corresponding phase boundary is shown in fig . [ phase ] , which agrees reasonably well with numerical results . versus @xmath21 at @xmath25 for various system sizes up to @xmath15 . ] for finding @xmath26 particles on the road at @xmath25 for various @xmath27 ( from right to left ) at @xmath28 . the fd - er transition occurs at @xmath29 . ] at @xmath25 for various system sizes up to @xmath15 . the crossing points converge to the point at @xmath30 and @xmath31 . ] to establish the phase diagram accurately , we measure various quantities in the steady state such as the particle density @xmath32 with @xmath33 , the density fluctuations @xmath34 , and the binder cumulant @xmath35 . in fig . [ density ] , the bulk density @xmath17 is plotted against @xmath21 at @xmath25 . the systematic shift in the data with increasing size clearly indicates that , in the infinite - size limit , there will be a discontinuous jump in @xmath17 at @xmath0 . figure [ probden ] shows the evolution of the probability distribution @xmath36 for finding @xmath37 particles on the road across the transition . at the transition estimated as @xmath29 , we see an abrupt change into a broad distribution , which is again a signature of a discontinuous transition . the instability threshold @xmath38 can be accurately estimated by the crossing points of the binder cumulant @xmath39 . [ binder ] shows a nice convergence of the crossing points to the transition point @xmath30 . the binder cumulant @xmath39 takes a value of @xmath40 in the fd phase and @xmath41 in the er phase . at the transition , @xmath31 . note that the distributions in the er phase and at the transition are slightly different from those for the tasep variant studied in @xcite . we also observe that the density fluctuation @xmath42 becomes maximum at the transition as expected ( not shown here ) . all other data for various values of @xmath20 show a similar behavior to the @xmath25 case . numerical data for the phase boundary and the density jump are shown in figs . [ phase ] and [ jump ] . for the gap size @xmath43 on the road for @xmath15 at @xmath25 ( @xmath44 ) . ] near @xmath45 ( upper ) and the power - law tail test for @xmath46 for @xmath15 ( lower ) at @xmath47.,title="fig : " ] + near @xmath45 ( upper ) and the power - law tail test for @xmath46 for @xmath15 ( lower ) at @xmath47.,title="fig : " ] @xmath48 with @xmath47 and @xmath15 . ] against @xmath49 at @xmath47 for various system sizes up to @xmath15 . its asymptotic behavior near @xmath38 from the er phase side seems to be @xmath50 with @xmath51 . ] the spatiotemporal patterns in the steady state provide some insights into the phases and the phase transition , see fig . [ timeplot ] . the fd phase shows a homogeneous distribution of particles , while in the er phase one big gap appears with small clusters near the boundaries . at the transition , particle clusters are formed with inter - cluster gaps of various sizes . we investigate the distribution of the gap size ( the size of empty stretches ) numerically , which is shown in fig . [ gapdist ] . from these data , we conclude that the probability distribution @xmath46 for gap size @xmath43 behaves as @xmath52 in the fd phase ( @xmath53 ) , @xmath46 decays exponentially as expected for a homogeneous density state . in the er phase ( @xmath54 ) , it decays exponentially for small @xmath43 as in the fd phase , but in addition a @xmath55-function peak appears at @xmath56 with @xmath57 approaching @xmath58 in the @xmath59 limit . the @xmath55-function peak represents the macroscopic gap in the center of the system seen in fig . [ timeplot ] and the exponential part describes the structure of finite mother clusters clinging to the reservoirs . typical gap sizes in the fd phase and also in the mother clusters in the er phase diverge when approaching the transition from below and above ; @xmath60 with @xmath61 . the multiplicative power - law exponents are also numerically estimated as @xmath62 and @xmath63 . at the transition ( @xmath0 ) , @xmath46 decays as a power law with the exponent @xmath64 ( see figs . [ gapdist ] and [ gap - analysis ] ) . now we compare our results with those in the periodic - boundary ( pb ) version @xcite . the gap distributions in the fd phase and at the transition are found to be almost identical to those in the pb version . the numerical values of the exponents @xmath65 are very close to the mean - field predictions of @xmath66 @xcite . the main difference lies in the er phase where an exponential decay is observed with a @xmath55-function while , in the pb setup , the @xmath55-function is accompanied by a power law with the same exponent @xmath67 as at criticality in the condensed phase . the exponential decay involves two new exponents @xmath68 and @xmath69 in the er phase . note that @xmath70 seems different from @xmath71 and @xmath67 . moreover , the @xmath55-function in our case has a fixed location while the location of the @xmath55-function varies as a function of the control parameter @xmath72 ( the particle density ) in the pb setup . we shall reflect on this difference in the next section . as shown in our spatiotemporal plots , fig . [ timeplot ] , there is a formation of clusters at @xmath0 and the power - law gap distribution is an indicator of such clusters . in the er phase , all clusters dissolve away except two mother clusters near the boundaries . we believe that the reason for this phase transition lies in the instability of clusters . moreover , the clusters could be highly sensitive to the open boundaries with which the system would be unable to sustain the clusters inside . we will discuss this point via a cluster stability analysis in the next section . we finally discuss the asymptotic behavior of the density profile @xmath73 as well as the finite - size property of the road density @xmath17 . based on numerical data , we propose @xmath74 where @xmath75 is the bulk density in the infinite - size limit . figure [ profile ] shows that the density profile has a power - law tail near the boundary with @xmath76 in the fd phase ; @xmath77 at the transition approaching from the fd side ; and the exponential tail in the er phase . this is quite different from that in the ordinary open ssep where @xmath78 does not have any tail structure and it is uniform when there is the left - right symmetry @xcite . one can calculate the finite - size property of the road density by integrating the density profile up to size @xmath2 : @xmath79 in the er phase , the total number of particles , @xmath80 , becomes a @xmath21-dependent constant @xmath81 in the infinite - size limit . approaching the transition point from the er side , we expect this constant to diverge . figure [ nr - zeta ] suggests the power - law type divergence as @xmath50 with @xmath82 . one may relate the exponent @xmath83 to the finite - size - scaling exponent @xmath84 which is termed the crossover exponent in the pb version . the cutoff gap size @xmath85 should scale as @xmath86 close to the transition [ see eq . ( 20 ) in @xcite ] and also as @xmath87 with @xmath68 . therefore we expect @xmath88 , leading to @xmath89 , which is again consistent with the mean - field result for the pb version @xcite . in the tasep variant studied previously @xcite , the cluster dynamics analysis provides a key insight to understanding the instability transition and also leads to quite accurate predictions . here we take a similar approach and focus on the stability of clusters . as can be seen in fig . [ timeplot ] at the transition , there are many floating clusters ( free clusters ) in the bulk besides two clusters attached to the reservoirs ( mother clusters ) . assume that the steady state at the transition consists of these clusters . first , consider the free clusters with the average bulk density @xmath90 and the side density @xmath91 ( the side densities at the right and left side of the clusters are expected to be identical for free clusters ) . the right front of such a cluster moves with a velocity given by @xmath92 the first ( second ) term on the right - hand side ( rhs ) arises from a local ( nonlocal ) move of the particle at the front to the right . the cluster front creeps forward by its local move to the right , but shrinks back due to the detachment of the front particle by a nonlocal hopping to the next cluster in front . the third term arises from its move to the left , which is possible only when the target site is vacant ( nonlocal hops are ignored inside the clusters ) . the last term is due to the nonlocal hop of a particle from the next cluster in front , which makes the cluster front advances by one unit . one can write a similar equation for the left front velocity of the cluster . since there is the left - right symmetry in the dynamics , our clusters do not drift in either direction ( @xmath93 ) and the clusters are stable only when @xmath94 . this leads to the conditions : @xmath95 where @xmath96 is the critical side density for the stable clusters . note that , for given @xmath21 , the clusters are stable only when their side density is precisely equal to the critical density and they are extremely sensitive to a slight change of their side density . if the side density increases temporarily by fluctuations , the front velocity becomes positive and the clusters start to expand and merge into each other until they fill up the road , if the reservoirs supply particles sufficiently into the free clusters through the mother clusters . in the opposite case , the clusters start to shrink and vanish , leading to the appearance of a big empty stretch on the road , if the mother clusters do not completely block the escape of particles to the reservoirs . now , consider the mother clusters . the right front of the mother cluster attached to the left reservoir is free to expand or contract . similar to the free cluster analysis , we find the front velocity as @xmath97 where @xmath98 is the front density of the mother cluster . for the mother cluster to be stable , this velocity should be zero , which leads to the condition : @xmath99 similar to the free clusters , the stability of the mother clusters is extremely fragile to density fluctuations and their critical front density is exactly the same as that of the free clusters . since the mother cluster is in a sense a buffer between the boundary and the bulk , it has a continuously varying density with a higher value at the boundary and a lower value into the bulk . if this bulk density is higher than the critical density @xmath100 , the mother cluster expands and merges with bulk free clusters until they fill up the whole road uniformly . in the opposite situation , it shrinks and retreats close to the boundary until the front density becomes equal to the critical density . this short mother cluster should be very unstable and fluctuate wildly . in this case , the bulk free clusters may escape away from the system via nonlocal hopping whenever the mother clusters vanish intermittently . therefore we expect , in the steady state , only two short mother clusters with a big macroscopic empty road in the bulk . when the bulk density is precisely equal to the critical density , the mother cluster is stable . also , due to the left - right symmetry in dynamics , the side density of the free clusters is expected to be the same as the front density of the mother cluster : @xmath101 . therefore the free clusters are also stable in this case and we expect a cluster fluid . next , we calculate the density profile of the mother cluster to determine the bulk density as function of the external parameters @xmath21 and @xmath20 . the stability conditions of clusters provide a criterion for the phase transition in terms of the front or side density of clusters and the nonlocal hopping parameter @xmath21 . we would now like to bring the input rate @xmath20 into the picture , which will determine the particle density profile of the mother cluster . in the fd phase ( small @xmath21 ) , the steady state has no clustering with finite bulk density . in this regime , we may use a simple mean - field ( mf ) analysis to determine the density profile . approaching the transition , the system becomes correlated and the mf results may not be trustworthy . however , the correlation is finite at the discontinuous transition , so the deviation from the mf results is expected to be small . the density of the mother cluster decreases from a higher value near the reservoir and settles to a constant value in the bulk . this bulk value @xmath102 is what we are interested in : at the transition , this value is equal to the critical density ; @xmath103 . to determine the mf density profile , let us consider the current at the bulk bond between sites @xmath8 and @xmath104 ( @xmath105 ) . the average current flowing to the right is given by @xmath106 where @xmath107 is the occupancy of site @xmath8 and the vacancy @xmath108 . the first term on the rhs accounts for the local jump from @xmath8 to @xmath104 and the second term for the nonlocal hop of a particle on a site to the left of @xmath8 . the third term accounts for the case in which there is no such particle at all to the left of @xmath8 , which would not allow any nonlocal hop : @xmath109 is given by @xmath110 one can similarly write the expression for the left current @xmath111 with @xmath112 . the symmetry in the problem dictates that , in the steady state , the average current through a site should be zero as @xmath113 for @xmath114 , we may take @xmath115 in the fd phase . combining this with eq . ( [ lrcurrent ] ) , we arrive at @xmath116 employing the mf approximation such as @xmath117 , one can write the recurrence relations for the vacancy profile in the bulk @xmath118 now consider the current at the boundary between the left reservoir ( @xmath5 ) and the site @xmath119 . one may easily find @xmath120 again , the total average current is zero and @xmath121 for the fd phase and also at the transition . thus , we get @xmath122 using eqs . ( [ mfone ] ) and ( [ mftwo ] ) , we determine the density profile iteratively . the density decreases from a high value near the reservoir and saturates to a bulk value @xmath123 . using the stability condition @xmath124 , the phase boundary @xmath125 is evaluated , which is shown in fig . [ phase ] . for small @xmath21 , the mf prediction agrees very well with the monte carlo data . as @xmath21 increases , the nonlocal events that induce a strong density - density correlations become important . thus , the results of our mf analysis show some deviation from the monte carlo results . our cluster stability analysis may be directly applied to the periodic - boundary ( pb ) version of course , the stability condition derived here is not exact due to ignoring nonlocal intracluster hops . moreover the side or front density can not be equivalent to the given bulk density @xmath17 in the pb version . nevertheless , it is interesting to note that the exact transition line equation @xmath24 @xcite coincides with our stability equation . the picture developed in the cluster stability analysis explains the sudden jump in the density leading to a discontinuous transition , in terms of the formation and dissolution of clusters . let us compare our case to the pb version , where the phase transition is continuous . the system studied in @xcite is based on the mass transport process , so it has no restriction on the occupancy of sites and the dynamical rules consist of particle clusters diffusing and merging on contact . in addition , single particles can chip off from clusters and move to the neighboring sites . the boundary conditions are taken to be periodic . this model can be mapped exactly onto the ssep with nonlocal hopping in the pb setup . in the ssep language , it shows a continuous phase transition from the uniform fd phase into the condensed phase with a macroscopic gap . in the condensed phase ( corresponding to the er phase in our model ) , the gap distribution is still critical ( the same as at the transition ) with a trivial macroscopic gap . this may also be understood with our picture of the free cluster stability . note that there are only free clusters at the transition in the pb setup . going into the condensed phase by lowering the total density , the clusters are diluted and thus become unstable by emitting particles away . however , in contrast to our model with open boundaries , particles can not escape the system in the pb version . instability and fluctuations may drive particles into a finite ( but macroscopic ) segment of the system where the local density is equal to the critical bulk density . then this finite segment can maintain its stability by shooting particles via nonlocal hopping through a macroscopic empty road . as the particle density in this segment is critical , the gap distribution should be exactly the same as that at the transition with only one extra macroscopic gap . in our open boundary setup , the mother clusters become highly unstable and the free clusters escape away through the boundaries . thus , the resulting gap distribution become exponential . the periodic and open boundary conditions discussed here define different ensembles such as canonical and grand - canonical ensembles where the number of particles is conserved or controlled by such external parameters as the input rate . in the equilibrium systems , it is well known that two ensembles are equivalent in the thermodynamic limit . in nonequilibrium systems , this ensemble equivalence does not need to hold in general . our study provides a simple example in which the open boundary is crucial to the nature of the instability transition . in this paper , we studied how the nonequilibrium system is affected by different boundary conditions . in the case of the symmetric simple exclusion process ( ssep ) with nonlocal hopping in one spatial dimension , we showed that the presence of open boundaries induces a boundary - induced abrupt transition . we developed the cluster stability analysis to explain this abrupt transition successfully , which was compared and contrasted to the system without boundaries ( closed chain ) . we found that the cluster stability governs the underlying physical mechanism of instability - induced phase transitions , and we discussed the ensemble equivalence in the generalized ssep . it is also interesting to test the ensemble equivalence in the generalized asymmetric exclusion process with the same type of nonlocal hopping events studied in @xcite , which will be discussed elsewhere . this work was supported by the bk21 project and acceleration research ( cnrc ) of most / kosef . computation was carried out using kias supercomputers . would like to acknowledge the kind hospitality of the kavli institute for theoretical physics china ( kitpc ) , where the most part of this manuscript was completed .

we investigate the role of the boundary in the symmetric simple exclusion process with competing nonlocal and local hopping events . with open boundaries , the system undergoes a first order phase transition from a finite density phase to an empty road phase as the nonlocal hopping rate increases . using a cluster stability analysis , we determine the location of such an abrupt nonequilibrium phase transition , which agrees well with numerical results . our cluster analysis provides a physical insight into the mechanism behind this transition . we also explain why the transition becomes discontinuous in contrast to the case with periodic boundary conditions , in which the continuous phase transition has been observed .

1309.0656

quantum key distribution ( qkd ) protocols @xcite allow two distant parties , traditionally called alice and bob , to produce a shared random bit string consisting of 0 s and 1 s known only to them , which can be used as a key to encrypt and decrypt messages . based on fundamental principles such as the quantum no - cloning principle @xcite , qkd provides an unconditionally secure way to distribute random keys through insecure channels . while the first qkd scheme to be proposed , the bennett brassard ( bb84 ) protocol @xcite was a prepare - and - measure protocol , which used separable states , a connection between nonlocality @xcite and security was first suggested by the ekert protocol @xcite . the basic intuition here is that eve s attack causes a reduction in the correlation between legitimate parties , which is now understood as due to the monogamy of nonlocality in non - signaling theories @xcite . it is also known that nonlocality helps security not only in the traditional qkd scenario ( where eve attacks the channel ) but even in the more stringent device - independent ( di ) scenario , where neither the prepared initial states nor the devices are trusted . security here must be guaranteed simply via certain statistical checks typically sufficiently high violation of a bell inequality and without requiring a detailed characterization of devices @xcite . the nonlocality , and hence entanglement , considered above is _ inter_-particle entanglement , and the bell - inequality violating property ( i.e. , nonlocality ) pertains to the correlations obtained by spatially separated measurements by a sender ( alice ) and receiver ( bob ) . a different kind of entanglement is that between two degrees of freedom of the _ same _ particle , i.e. , intra - particle entanglement . this has been discussed by basu et al . @xcite in the context of a mach zehnder type interferometric set - up for demonstrating the violation of non - contextuality . an experiment using single neutrons was performed by hasegawa et al . @xcite . here , for the first time , we propose the use of the resource of intra - particle entanglement for qkd . by its nature , bell tests with intra - particle entanglement must be local . interestingly , such local bell tests have also been proposed in the case of bipartite systems for self - testing schemes employed to certify the state preparation process or the source of quantum states @xcite . our method also evokes a comparison with one - sided diqkd , in which the alice s devices are untrusted , but bob s are trusted @xcite , and where the statistical check is based on steering inequalities @xcite . an interesting counterpoint here is provided by the scenario of measurement di , in which , the devices for measurement , rather than that of the sender , is untrusted @xcite . relative to inter - particle entanglement , intra - particle entanglement is easy to generate . in the optical case , considered here , linear optics suffices . however , the local nature of intra - particle entanglement means that it is unsuitable for many quantum information processing tasks , like quantum teleportation or dense coding . it is an interesting question whether it is useful for cryptography , which we answer here in the affirmative . experimental demonstrations of various qkd protocols were discussed in @xcite . the practical violation of the bell s inequality in the cryptographic context was first considered in an experiment by jennewein et . @xcite , but no quantitative measure of security was derived from the observed violation . later , ling et . al . @xcite performed an experiment on entanglement - based qkd , in which the violation of bell - chsh inequality is used to also quantify the degree of security according to the criterion of refs . @xcite . in this work , our accent is mainly on introducing intra - particle entanglement between position ( path ) and polarization of photons , as a useful and easy - to - prepare resource for qkd , which presents novel elements when state preparation devices , in addition to the channel , are allowed to be insecure . we do so by showing that this qkd is secure against certain `` side channels '' that leak secret data ( such as alice s or bob s settings and outcome information ) , whereas the corresponding version of bb84 is not secure . clearly , there is no protection against an unrestrictedly powerful side channel . hence , we must assume that it can not be `` obvious '' . examples of typical side channels are timing information on the devices used , observations of power consumption or electromagnetic leaks bearing some heat signature of devices , or even a click sound produced by an optical element . we quantitatively find that the bell - inequality violating ( biv ) property of the path - polarization correlations can be used to guarantee security against an individual side - channel attack , which would render insecure qkd in the standard scenario . here an incoherent attack is one where eve attacks alice s particles along the transmission channel individually and measures them independently , without the involvement of any joint measurement . further details , such as coherent attacks , optical losses in the channel and universal composability are important future directions of this work , not considered here . an important aspect of using intra - particle - based entanglement , which we consider in more detail elsewhere @xcite , is to generalize the goldenberg vaidman protocol for orthogonal state- based cryptography @xcite , as a method to thwart general individual and coherent attacks @xcite on intra - particle entanglement - based qudits . this article is divided as follows : in sect . [ sec : ipe ] , we introduce the notion of intra - particle entanglement and present simple generation schemes for path - polarization intra - particle entanglement . in sect . [ sec : scha ] , we introduce an augmented key distribution protocol , suitable for a side - channel attack scenario , in which the sender alice must verify the quality of intra - particle entanglement just before transmitting the particle to the receiver bob , and after all optical elements used for the encoding process have been applied . in sect . [ sec : cheq ] , an individual attack scheme by eve is considered . her action is to depolarize the initial maximally entangled state into an intra - particle werner state , for which the entanglement and biv properties are readily known . the condition for secure extraction of secret bits is studied in comparison with the availability of these properties in the noisy state received by bob . in sect . [ sec : sidecha ] , we demonstrate the usefulness of intra - particle entanglement in protecting against a class of side - channel attacks that rely on flaws in certain optical elements such as quarter - wave plates ( qwps ) . finally , we present our conclusions in sect . [ sec : conclu ] . let us consider a photon that is initially polarized along the vertical direction ( its state denoted by @xmath0 ) . taking into consideration its path ( or position ) variables , the joint path - polarization state can be written as @xmath1 where the subscripts @xmath2 and @xmath3 refer to the path and the spin ( i.e. , polarization ) variables , respectively . a photon in the state @xmath4 with alice is incident on a beam splitter ( bs1 ) , whose transmission and reflection probabilities are @xmath5 and @xmath6 respectively , where @xmath7 ( cf . [ fig : bb84 ] ) . the reflected and transmitted states from bs1 are designated by @xmath8 and @xmath9 , respectively . here we recall that for any given lossless beam splitter , arguments using the unitarity condition show that for the particles incident on the beam splitter , the phase between the transmitted and the reflected states of the particle is @xmath10 . note that the beam splitter acts only on the path states without affecting the polarization state of the particles . the state of a particle emergent from bs1 can then be written as @xmath11 where @xmath12 our simplest basis , called @xmath13 , can be generated without using the beam splitter : @xmath14 a basis consisting of path - polarization entangled elements and which is mutually unbiased with @xmath13 , is @xmath15 , given below in eq . ( [ fourstate ] ) . it is produced by a linear optical set - up consisting of a beam splitter , a half - wave plate ( hwp ) , qwp and a phase shifter ( ps ) . for example , @xmath16 is produced from @xmath17 , by passing the particle through a bs1 , applying hwp on the transmitted wave packet @xmath18 , followed by the application of qwp on both arms . the hwp has the action @xmath19 which form the basis @xmath15 . the bases @xmath13 and @xmath15 are mutually unbiased in the sense that any element in either basis is an equal weight superposition ( apart from phase factors ) of elements of the other basis . to measure the state in an arbitrary separable basis @xmath20 , where @xmath21 and @xmath22 denote direction vectors of unit magnitude , one passes the particle through a beam splitter of suitable bias that de - rotates the position to the computational basis , and then uses two detectors , both set alike to measure the polarization along @xmath21 . for example , if @xmath23 , the beam splitter is chosen with coefficients of transmission and reflection being @xmath24 and @xmath25 , respectively . these coefficients can be set at the time of manufacture by the reflection coating applied to a beam splitter , and their ratio determines whether the element functions as a balanced ( 50:50 ) or unbalanced ( say 90:10 ) beam splitter . the particular measurements basis settings @xmath26 we require in order to evaluate the bell observable , are given in eq . ( [ eq : settings ] ) . in dimension @xmath27 , there are @xmath28 mutually unbiased bases ( mubs ) . another mutually unbiased entangled basis , denoted @xmath29 , in addition to sets @xmath13 and @xmath15 , is : @xmath30 two others ( separable state ) mubs , which may be denoted @xmath31 and @xmath32 , can be produced by applying @xmath33 and @xmath34 to the elements of basis @xmath13 ( [ fourstate0 ] ) , where @xmath35 , while @xmath36 . all these states are easy to prepare , requiring only linear optical elements . by suitably applying the linear optical elements of beam splitters , hwp , qwp and ps . bob may recombine the reflected and the transmitted channels at bs2 . finally , bob performs path and polarization measurements using the polarizing beam splitters pbs1 and pbs2.,width=377 ] alice s states are analyzed in bob s system , consisting of a beam splitter ( bs2 ) , followed by polarization analyzer in each output arm . for example , if she sends the state @xmath16 or @xmath37 , then after emerging from bs2 ( cf . [ fig : bb84 ] ) , the corresponding resulting states at bob s site are given by @xmath38 where @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath42 . in each of the five mubs , given by states ( [ fourstate0 ] ) , ( [ fourstate ] ) , ( [ fourstate1 ] ) , etc . , alice and bob designate basis elements by numbers 0 , 1 , 2 and 3 . we can form different protocols by considering any two or more of the five bases . it will suffice for us to consider the protocol @xmath43 where only two bases are used , which are @xmath13 and @xmath15 . however , any other pair of mubs will do . using a larger number of bases enhances the tolerable error rate , but is less efficient and experimentally more difficult . the protocol is as follows . ( 1 ) using mirrors , phase shifters and beam splitters ( fig . [ fig : bb84 ] ) , alice prepares an intra - particle path - polarization entangled states in basis @xmath13 or @xmath15 , randomly chosen , starting from the initial input state @xmath44 . ( 2 ) just before transmission to bob , but after state preparation , she selects a fraction @xmath45 of the states , to verify that their fidelity with the intended output entangled state remains 1 . she may do so by reversing her preparation procedure and observing the probability @xmath46 that the output _ fails _ to coincide with @xmath44 . as explained later , she may equivalently perform a test of bell inequality violation . this step is a key addition to the protocol for protection against the side - channel attack ; here we assume that the optical set - up that reverses the preparation is different from that actually used for state preparation , though this is not necessary ; we note that the test based on reversing implicitly verifies that the reversed state is separable . since an entangled bipartite state is necessarily mixed in any one of its parts , a test of mixedness may be optionally implemented . if it returns a positive result , then clearly the output fails to coincide with @xmath44 . ( for a particular proposal for testing mixedness , see ref . ( 3 ) alice transmits the remaining particles to bob ( i.e. , no quantum memory is used to hold the other particles while the bell test is underway ) ; ( 4 ) bob obtains a 2-bit outcome by using mirrors , phase shifters and beam splitters ( fig . [ fig : bb84 ] ) to measure the transmitted photon , choosing randomly the measurement basis @xmath47 basis , the `` primed '' versions of @xmath48 . the remaining steps involve only classical post - processing : ( 5 ) the experiment described in the above two steps is repeated many times . alice then declares via an authenticated classical channel the value of @xmath46 and the basis ( but not the basis element ) from which she chose the state ( the existence of an authenticated channel between alice and bob , which gives bob an edge over eve , is essential to the security of qkd ) . bob announces the cases where his basis was mismatched with hers . the corresponding measurement outcome data are discarded . ( 6 ) from the retained ( sifted ) measurement data , a sufficiently large portion is divulged by bob . the fraction of it that does not agree with her preparation state is an estimate of the error rate in the key , @xmath49 . if @xmath49 is sufficiently low , they proceed with the rest of the protocol , else they abort it . ( 7 ) alice and bob perform key reconciliation over the authenticed channel , to improve the correlation of their respective copy of the key . they then perform privacy amplification to minimize eve s information on the key . the verification step in the protocol , which is an augmentation over conventional qkd protocols , makes our protocol more secure in a di scenario , as we explain later . with inter - particle entanglement , alice and bob perform this step by using local operations and classical communication ( locc ) to determine the nonlocality of the state , from which an estimate of the secrecy content follows . with intra - particle entanglement , only one of the parties ( here , alice ) must accomplish this , because the path and polarization qubits can not be measured at spatially separated stations . in this sense , alice and bob distinguish between errors arising due to the channel ( the conventional security scenario ) versus errors arising during state preparation ( the side - channel or di ) scenario . before discussing detailed security issues , let us make a number of remarks to qualify the motivation behind this work . 1 . formally , the four - dimensional spin - position entangled states we use for encoding can be considered as superpositions of a ququart ( four - dimensional quantum system ) . however , our point is to study the system as two - qubit entanglement because we wish to take advantage of some ideas from di quantum cryptography . we consider below ( apart from a channel attack ) eve s side - channel attack only on alice s qwp , and not other optical elements . there is no special reason to make this choice . rather , this is meant only as an illustration of the general principle of how intra - particle entanglement can be more useful that a plain qubit or ququart superposition . an more detailed follow - up can extend this principle to other optical elements . note that the verification step itself can be subject to an attack , for example , to the particular side - channel attack , we describe below . what this entails is that eve can know what alice knows about eve s eavesdropping actions , possibly introducing further noise . from the viewpoint of enhancing her knowledge of the final key , this does not help eve , and we do not consider such attacks here . we model eve s attack as a simple intercept - resend attack on single particles . eve can also eavesdrop their authenticated classical channel and thus make use of their basis announcements . eve s strategy is to measure the particles randomly in one of the legitimate bases . she forwards the measured state to bob , and waits until after their public announcement of bases to find out when she got it right . for purposes of this section , eve is assumed to attack only the channel and not exploit any side channels . accordingly , the verification step ( 2 ) in the protocol presented above may be omitted . without loss of generality , suppose alice sends the state @xmath16 and eve attacks fraction @xmath50 of particles from alice to bob . eve has an equal chance of measuring in the right or wrong basis . if she measures in @xmath15 ( with probability @xmath51 ) , she always obtains @xmath16 , which she forwards to bob , without introducing any error . on the other hand , if she measures in a basis other than @xmath15 , she finds any one of the four basis elements with equal probability . she forwards the obtained state to bob . after alice s public announcement of basis , she is equally unsure of what state alice prepared as she is of what state bob obtained . the error rate @xmath49 generated is given by the probability that alice and bob , measuring in the same basis , find the wrong outcome , which is : @xmath52 eve s average information ( symmetrically with respect to alice or bob ) per transmitted particle is maximal when , during alice s announcement of bases , she finds that alice s basis matches hers , and minimal when it does not . in terms of error observed , her information is : @xmath53 in view of eq . ( [ eq : e ] ) . because of the mutual unbiasedness property between any two bases , after alice and bob have reconciled their bases , eve s action induces on any input symbol @xmath54 , the output probability distribution @xmath55 where @xmath56 and @xmath57 . the corresponding shannon entropy functional is given by @xmath58 . assuming alice sends all four states in both bases with equal probability , bob s information is given by the mutual information : @xmath59 the condition for a positive key rate is @xmath60 whose sign is determined by eqs . ( [ eq : iab ] ) and ( [ eq : iae ] ) @xcite . @xmath61 is the secret bit rate that can be distilled . the key rate for this situation is plotted as the rightmost curve in fig . [ fig : ir ] . the largest tolerable error rate , which we denote by @xmath62 , is about 27 the relative weakness of eve s attack . as we find later , even this weak attack , augmented by eve s access to certain side channels , leads to more stringent bounds ( the other two curves in the same figure ) . in the conventional attack scenario ( eq . ( [ eq : iab ] ) and , as explained later , the side - channel attack scenario ( eq . ( [ eq : iabaprime ] ) . the conventional security scenario is represented by the rightmost curve , which has a positive key rate while @xmath63 , the largest tolerable error rate in the simple individual attack in a conventional cryptographic scenario . the leftmost curve represents the above attack augmented in a side - channel scenario , with eve s maximal attack ( @xmath64 in eq . ( [ eq : newiabprime ] ) ) , with a tolerable error rate of at most 14.5% for depolarizing action eq . ( [ eq : wernere ] ) , the noisy state is nonlocal for @xmath65 ( eq . ( [ eq : eloc ] ) , first vertical line ) and entangled for @xmath66 ( eq . ( [ eq : eent ] ) , second vertical line ) . thus the individual attack in the conventional scenario allows secure states that are local , but which are necessarily entangled . the intermediate curve represents @xmath67 for which the region of nonlocality and secrecy coincide.,width=529 ] by eve s interference , she is acting as a depolarizing channel that has the action : @xmath68 where @xmath69 labels the basis and @xmath70 @xmath71 labels the basis elements . if alice transmits an entangled basis element , then the state in eq . ( [ eq : werner ] ) is ( up to local unitaries ) a werner state @xcite . substituting for @xmath50 from eq . ( [ eq : e ] ) in eq . ( [ eq : werner ] ) , we find eve s depolarizing channel in terms of error rate : @xmath72 let the measurement settings on the first and second qubit ( i.e. , the polarization and path qubit ) be given by the following directions : @xmath73 which are used for evaluating the following bell inequality @xmath74 where @xmath75 is expectation value of measuring the spin in the directions @xmath21 and @xmath22 in the two particles , respectively . it is well known that for local - realist models , @xmath76 . the correlation for the singlet is given by @xmath77 so that @xmath78 . the most general separable state is given by @xmath79 where @xmath80 and @xmath81 the correlations for @xmath82 can be calculated as @xmath83.\end{aligned}\ ] ] using equations eqs . ( [ eq : settings ] ) , ( [ eq : bellop ] ) , ( [ eq : corr ] ) and ( [ eq : rhosep ] ) , the upper and lower bound of the bell quantity @xmath84 in eq . ( [ eq : bellop ] ) is given by @xmath85 so that quantum bound for separable states , @xmath86 @xcite . state @xmath87 is equivalent upto local unitaries to a bell state , and yields the maximal bell - inequality violation of @xmath88 for settings ( [ eq : settings ] ) , whereas @xmath89 . after alice s public announcement of bases , if bob divides the received states into sub - ensembles corresponding to each input state , then in view of eq . ( [ eq : wernere ] ) , for the @xmath87 subensemble , bob will observe : @xmath90 this is nonlocal when @xmath91 , or @xmath92 from eq . ( [ eq : wernere ] ) , setting @xmath93 as the necessary and sufficient condition for entanglement @xcite of werner states by the peres - horodecki positive - partial - transpose criterion @xcite , we find that bob s states are entangled when @xmath94 since @xmath95 ( cf . [ fig : ir ] ) , it follows that there are local states that allow secrecy extraction for both protocols under the considered attack . this will not be true when the side - channel attack is included . the corresponding values of @xmath84 are , from eq . ( [ eq : wernere ] ) , @xmath96 , implying that @xmath97 ( cf . figure [ fig : ir ] ) . in other words , all states secure under the protocol for the given class of attacks are necessarily entangled . since the considered attacks are clearly not the strongest possible for the protocol considered , this implies that security or secrecy is a strictly stronger condition than entanglement ( in that more powerful attacks will reduce the tolerable error rate , and thus increase the amount entanglement in the state at the security threshold ) . our above results may be compared and contrasted with corresponding results obtained in the inter - particle case for the link between nonlocality and secrecy in quantum mechanics and general non - signaling theories in the conventional attack and attack scenarios involving untrusted devices @xcite . the peculiar nature of intra - particle entanglement is that simple operations like application of an optical element on an arm can be an entangling operation . this property can be useful to protect secrecy in a side scenario . as an example , consider the tiny angular momentum acquired by the qwp through recoil during its rotation of the photon polarization . eve may be able to somehow monitor the vibrational state of the qwp and deduce private information about the settings used by alice . alternatively , eve may detect a gap in the wall of alice s station , and shine a thin pencil of light beam at some of the optical elements through the gap and deduce information based on the pattern of electromagnetic scatter . worse still , eve may be the vendor from whom alice and bob purchase their optical elements . even if the available side channels are weak , eve may install hidden `` trojan horses '' that reveal basis or outcome information to her . the attack implemented in a qwp can be mathematically modeled as follows : @xmath98 where @xmath99 correspond to states of the initial absence or presence of some device ( here the qwp ) in path @xmath100 ; @xmath101 , the recoiled state of the device , carrying a small amount of angular momentum acquired when the photon in a @xmath102 state is transformed into one of the diagonal polarization states latexmath:[$|{\pm}\rangle \equiv \frac{1}{\sqrt{2 } } ( |h\rangle \pm the vacuum state and state of the electromagnetic leaking channel , produced when the device relaxes back from @xmath101 to its initial state . the subscript in state @xmath104 indicates a photon in the mode coupled with device @xmath105 . practically speaking , for alice to rule out every possible malicious defect is not easy , if not impossible . what is desirable is statistical tests on performance that acts like a catch - all check . the usefulness here of nonlocal correlations ( or , entanglement within quantum mechanics ) between measurements by alice and bob has been recognized @xcite . what is interesting is that intra - particle entanglement also can be useful in this way . this is at first not obvious . to obtain the alice bob correlations , one of an entangled pair of particles must be transmitted to bob , following which each particle is measured separately . with intra - particle entanglement , such spatial separation is not possible . moreover , when alice transmits the particle , all entangled degrees of freedom in principle become available to eve , who may thus be able remove any trace of her tampering the devices . in this work , we suggest that this problem can be solved by having alice perform a bell - inequality test on the particle _ after _ and all her devices have been used ( beam splitters , polarizers , measurements ) , and _ just before _ the particle s transmission to bob . furthermore , because both entangled degrees of freedom are with alice , she might equally well measure them in @xmath15 basis to verify their biv property . this is accomplished simply be reversing the preparation procedure and verifying that the output is indeed the input state @xmath44 . the attack ( [ eq : scha ] ) does not affect elements from basis @xmath13 , because no qwp is made use of . on the other hand , any element from the entangled basis @xmath15 , say @xmath87 , is affected . the below analysis holds for any other element in the basis as well . to prepare the state @xmath106 , alice inputs @xmath107 into the beam splitter , and applies a hwp plate on the @xmath108 arm to obtain @xmath109 . applying a qwp on both arms @xmath108 and @xmath110 , in view of eq . ( [ eq : scha ] ) , she effects the transformation : @xmath111 . eve needs to distinguish between the case that the mode @xmath112 remains vacuum , and that there is a radiation of a photon . let the projector to @xmath113 be denoted @xmath114 . let @xmath115 in both arms , so that @xmath116 . it is easy to verify that the probability of observed error upon alice s reversing her state preparation is @xmath117 this is the probability that , upon reversing her preparation procedure on a given particle , alice fails to find it in the original input state @xmath118 . we call this the _ device error _ , to contrast it with the conventional error , @xmath49 , which may be called the _ channel error _ , acquired during the transmission of the particle through the channel . we will conservatively assume that no new noise above the preparation noise is introduced during the reversing step . the reversal is assumed to be implemented through an auxiliary optical set - up . for quantum cryptography to be a realistic enterprise , we must assume that eve s side channel is _ passive _ , i.e. , she can not use this side information to alter any settings of alice s device ( otherwise i.e. , if eve had _ active _ access clearly eve would be too powerful for security to be meaningful ) . in particular , eve can not alter alice s readings in this check . moreover , eve can not access the random number generator alice used to prepare random states . thus a side - channel attack of the type ( [ eq : scha ] ) can not be correlated with the prepared states , and eve can not hope to lower the value of @xmath46 as seen by alice . at best , eve can find out the value of @xmath46 , but ideally she knows this already , being the adversary who causes the device noise . we note that this error check is a simple substitute for a bell test , in that it effects a measurement that verifies that the particle s state is indeed @xmath16 . by contrast , in the inter - particle case , local operations and classical communication would be needed , not to mention the difficulty in preparing the entanglement . what is interesting here , in contrast to the inter - particle entanglement case , is that the attack ( [ eq : scha ] ) can render intra - particle separable states as intra - particle entangled , again disrupting the correlations , which can be detected in the verification step . for example , the attack ( [ eq : scha ] ) when alice attempts to prepare the separable state @xmath119 instead produces the entangled state latexmath:[\[\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(\frac{|0\rangle_{s } + |1\rangle_{s}}{\sqrt{2 } } \right)\otimes \left(|0_r , y_t\rangle_\phi |\psi_{t}\rangle_{p } + i |{y}_r,0_t\rangle_\phi verification step detects eve with probability @xmath46 . thus it is straightforward to adapt the analysis given below for a protocol where bases @xmath121 are used instead of @xmath122 . for the present protocol , one strategy for eve would be as follows . she measures the electromagnetic modes in the basis @xmath123 , where @xmath124 . the outcome @xmath114 is indeterminate , while outcome @xmath125 deterministically informs eve that the basis @xmath15 was used , and leaves the particle in the state @xmath126 with probability @xmath127 where the last follows from eq . ( [ eq : perror ] ) . thus , the more the deterministic information eve acquires , the larger is the disturbance she produces , that alice can see . it can be shown that the disturbed versions of the elements in basis @xmath15 remain orthogonal . for example , @xmath128 thus , there exists a projective measurement strategy whereby the elements of the `` disturbed '' basis @xmath129 can be deterministically distinguished . since eve s attack on any element in @xmath13 produces no radiative emission , we have the conditional probability @xmath130 the probability that eve obtains outcome @xmath114 is , using eq . ( [ eq : pcert ] ) @xmath131 where @xmath132 , the probability that alice chooses ( an element of ) @xmath133 . by the bayesian rule , using eqs . ( [ eq : cond1 ] ) and ( [ eq : ptotal ] ) , we have @xmath134 which we denote @xmath135 . it may be noted that if @xmath136 , i.e. , @xmath137 which happens when @xmath138 , then eve s best guess to minimize error in an intercept - resend attack would be to assume that @xmath13 was used if her measurement returns @xmath114 . that is to say that if no radiation leakage is found even with high distinguishability , chances are that the state sent by alice was an element in @xmath13 . in practice , however , alice and bob , could respond to this potential tactic by eve this by always using @xmath15 . to avoid this , eve responds to @xmath114 outcomes by transmitting a random element of either basis chosen with equal probability . eve s full strategy in this attack scenario is that she will use this extra basis information to improve her guess work in the intercept - resend attack of sect . [ sec : scha ] . if eve obtains outcome @xmath125 , she determines the @xmath15 element obtained by a projective measurement , and forwards this state to bob , producing no errors . when eve obtains an outcome @xmath114 , she measures randomly in either basis , notes the outcome state and forwards it to bob . in this case , she identifies the sent state correctly if she measures in the right basis : in the @xmath13 case , there is no state distortion ; in the @xmath15 case , orthogonality is preserved on account of eq . ( [ eq : ortho ] ) . therefore , the probability she produces an error that can be detected by alice and bob is found , using eqs . ( [ eq : req ] ) and ( [ eq : ptotal ] ) , to be @xmath139 in place of eq . ( [ eq : e ] ) , the corresponding error in the conventional scenario . eve s information is , in place of eq . ( [ eq : iab ] ) , now given by by : @xmath140 where @xmath141 where @xmath142 is the probability of recovering @xmath118 , upon reversing and measuring in the verification step , and taking values between 1 ( when eve does not attack , corresponding to @xmath143 ) to @xmath144 ( when eve maximally attacks , corresponding to @xmath145 ) . in the limit of indistinguishability of the radiative leak modes ( i.e. , @xmath146 ) , eqs . ( [ eq : eprime ] ) and ( [ eq : iabaprime ] ) reduce , respectively , to eqs . ( [ eq : e ] ) and ( [ eq : iab ] ) . in particular , letting @xmath147 , from eq . ( [ eq : iabaprime ] ) , we have @xmath148 eve s maximal attack in this model corresponds to @xmath64 , whereby she fully distinguishes the side channels corresponding to @xmath149 and @xmath150 ( @xmath151 in eq . ( [ eq : perror ] ) ) . the corresponding secret key rate ( as a function of _ channel error _ ) obtained by substituting eqs . ( [ eq : newiabprime ] ) and ( [ eq : iab ] ) in eq . ( [ eq : poskey ] ) is plotted in fig . [ fig : ir ] as the leftmost curve . the highest tolerable error rate , which is the @xmath152-intercept of the curve , is about 14.5 as seen from figure [ fig : ir ] , this implies that secure states in this scenario are necessarily bell - inequality violating . this is in contrast to the security in the conventional scenario ( the rightmost curve in fig . [ fig : ir ] ) , where there are secure states that are bell - inequality non - violating ( @xmath153 ) . the central curve corresponds to @xmath154 , for which positivity of secrecy rate coincides with the biv property . for the attacked state in eq . ( [ eq : atak ] ) , the amount of bell s inequality violation can be shown to be @xmath155 , so that it follows from eqs . ( [ eq : perror ] ) and ( [ eq : f ] ) that @xmath156 . substituting this in eq . ( [ eq : newiabprime ] ) , and allowing for the possibility of some errors being due to noise rather than eve , we can bound eve s information from above as a function of bell s inequality violation observed by alice to be : @xmath157 this form may be compared with bounds on eve s information as a function of bell s inequality violation in diqkd with inter - particle entanglement , except that @xmath158 is evaluated by alice , rather than bob and indicates the level of alice s device error , which in turn indicates the level of channel error that can be tolerated . our work proposes the use of intra - particle entanglement ( path - polarization entanglement of single photons ) for cryptography using an interferometric setup . here , unlike the conventional bb84 , the system used is four dimensional and hence one can have five mutually unbiased bases for encoding . we illustrate its usefulness by pointing out a type of side - channel attack which it is secure against , but which renders a bb84-like protocol insecure . intra - particle entanglement is necessarily checked by a local bell test , which leads to a decoupling of device noise from channel noise . the observed device noise , derived from the local bell test , determines the channel error that can be tolerated . note that error rates and security proofs have been explicitly given in the paper . we may also stress that , since the use of intra - particle entanglement allows one to distinguish between channel and device errors which , in usual protocols , are indistinguishable , this could be of aid in assessing the security of the protocol when actually implemented . the present work mainly highlights the usefulness of intra - particle entanglement for qkd . there are a number of prospects for extending this work . the attack model on the channel can consider more powerful adversaries , for example , executing a coherent attack . the eavesdropping scenario can be expanded from a single untrusted element toward higher di . @xcite considers the problem posed by optical losses on the channel , which has remained beyond the scope of the present work , and is of interest for a practical application . similarly , the issue of composability of intra - particle entanglement - based qkd may be studied @xcite . finally , the problem of secure direction communication @xcite with intra - particle entanglement would be worth considering . asm and dh acknowledge support from the department of science and technology , india ( dst ) project sr / s2/lop-08/2013 , and rs for the dst - supported project sr / s2/lop-02/2012 . dh also thanks the centre for science , kolkata for support . c. h. bennett , and g. brassard . quantum cryptography : public key distribution and coin tossing . in proceedings of the ieee international conference on computers , systems and signal processing , bangalore , india , ( ieee , new york ) , 175 ( 1984 ) . v. scarani and n. gisin . quantum key distribution between n partners : optimal eavesdropping and bell s inequalities . a * 65 * , 012311 ( 2001 ) . s. mal , t. pramanik and a. s. majumdar . detecting mixedness of qutrit systems using the uncertainty relation phys . a 87 , 012105 ( 2013 ) r. werner . quantum states with einstein - podolsky - rosen correlations admitting a hiddenvariable model . a 40 , 4277 ( 1989 ) . characterizing entanglement . 43 , 4237 ( 2002 ) . s. m. roy . multipartite separability inequalities exponentially stronger than local reality inequalities . 94 , 010402 ( 2005 ) . a. acin , s. massar and s. pironio . randomness versus nonlocality and entanglement . 108 , 100402 ( 2012 ) . r. renner and r , knig . universally composable privacy amplification against quantum adversaries . quant - ph/0403133 . deng , g .- secure direct communication with a quantum one - time pad . a 69 , 052319 ( 2004 ) . li , x. h. et al . deterministic secure quantum communication without maximally entangled states . j. korean phys . 49 , 1354 ( 2006 ) . yan , f.l . , x.,a scheme for secure direct communication using epr pairs and teleportation . j. b 41 , 75 ( 2004 ) . man , z.x . , zhang , z.j . , li , y. quantum dialogue revisited . chin . 22 , 18 ( 2005 ) . zhu , a.d . , xia , y. , fan , q.b . , zhang , s. secure direct communication based on secret transmitting order of particles . a 73 , 022338 ( 2006 ) . tsai , c.w . , hsieh , c.r . , hwang , t. dense coding using cluster states and its application on deterministic secure quantum communication eur . j. d 61 , 779 ( 2011 ) .

we explore the use of the resource of intra - particle entanglement for secure quantum key distribution in the device - independent scenario . by virtue of the local nature of such entanglement , bell tests must be implemented locally , which leads to a natural decoupling of device errors from channel errors . we consider a side - channel attack on the sender s state preparation device , for which the intra - particle entanglement - based scheme is shown to be more secure than the one that uses separable states . of practical relevance is the fact that such entanglement can be easily generated using linear optics .

astro-ph0207048

a fundamental result arising from cold dark matter ( cdm ) numerical simulations is that the density profiles of dm halos are universal in form across a wide range of mass scales from dwarf galaxies to clusters of galaxies ( navarro , frenk & white 1997 , hereafter nfw ) . internal to some scale radius @xmath6 , the dark matter profile assumes a power law form , @xmath7 . whilst there is some dispute amongst the simulators about the precise value of @xmath8 with values ranging from 1.0 to 1.5 , ( moore et al . 1998 , hereafter m98 ; ghigna et al . 2000 , power et al . 2002 ) , a clear measurement of @xmath8 in a range of objects would offer a powerful test of the cdm paradigm . the largest observational effort in this respect to date has been via dynamical studies of low surface brightness ( lsb ) and dwarf galaxies , suggesting softer ( @xmath9 ) dm cores than expected on the basis of the numerical simulations ( e.g. de blok & bosma 2002 , salucci & burkert 2000 ) , although the issue remains somewhat controversial ( e.g. van den bosch & swaters 2001 ) . similar tests have recently been extended to regular spiral ( jimenez , verde & oh 2002 ) and elliptical galaxies ( treu & koopmans 2002 ) . some observational constraints are available at the scale of massive clusters , from lensing ( e.g. tyson , kochanski & dellantonio 1998 ; williams et al . 1999 ; smith et al.2001 ) , x - ray analysis ( mahdavi & geller 2001 ) and dynamics of cd galaxies ( kelson et al . 2002 ) . since massive clusters probe a totally different scale and physical conditions than galaxies , it is crucial to understand their mass distribution to test the universality of the dm profiles . in this paper we present the first application of a new method to determine the luminous and dark mass distribution in the inner regions of massive clusters with giant arcs around a central bcg . the method combines lensing analysis with stellar kinematical measurements of the bcg . the two ingredients provide complementary information on the relevant scales ( @xmath10 kpc ) , allowing us to disentangle the luminous and dark components of the total mass distribution . we have chosen the cluster ms2137 - 23 as a first application of our method since it is an approximately round system , has an isolated bcg and a very well - studied arc system . fort et al . ( 1992 ) first pointed out the potential significance of the radial and tangential gravitational arcs as a means of constraining the mass distribution on @xmath11100 kpc scales , and mass models have been developed subsequently ( mellier et al . 1993 , hammer et al . 1997 ; hereafter m93 , h97 ) . the redshifts of the radial and tangential arcs were predicted to lie in the range 1@xmath122 ( m93 ) . a key issue in the earlier work is whether the radial arc is , in fact , a lensed feature . m93 and miralde - escud ( 1995 ; hereafter me95 ) also point out the importance of determining the stellar velocity dispersion profile of the bcg to weigh the stellar contribution to the mass . following the earlier suggestions , we present new observations of the cluster ms2137 - 23 with the keck ii telescope . we provide spectroscopic confirmation of the arcs and measure a velocity dispersion profile for the central bcg . the spectroscopic data are used together with archival hst images to constrain the luminous and dm distribution of the cluster . in the following , @xmath13 is the radial coordinate in 3-d space , while @xmath14 is the radial coordinate in 2-d projected space . we adopt h@xmath15=65 km s@xmath16,mpc@xmath16 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 for the cosmological parameters . we observed ms2137 - 23 using the echelle spectrograph and imager ( esi ; sheinis et al . 2002 ) on the w. m. keck - ii telescope for a total integration time of 4900s ( 2@xmath191800s + 1300s ) on 21 july , 2001 . the seeing was @xmath20 and the @xmath21 slit was oriented north - south to include the bcg , radial arc , and tangential arc ( figure 1 ) . the spectroscopic goals were two - fold : a determination of the redshift of the arcs and a measurement of the internal kinematics of the central galaxy . an iraf package was developed for the specific task of removing echelle distortions while preserving the 2-d shape of the spectrum essential for the latter goal ( easi2d , sand et al . 2002 , in preparation ) . the instrumental resolution of esi was measured from unblended sky lines to be 30@xmath227 km s@xmath16 . the velocity dispersion profile of the bcg ( figure 2 ) was measured using spectral templates based on several g - k giants observed with a @xmath23 slit . these were smoothed to match the instrumental resolution of the @xmath24 slit and redshifted to that of the bcg ( @xmath25=0.313 ) . analysis was restricted to a region around the g band by virtue of the high signal / noise and minimal effect of sky line residuals , using the gauss - hermite pixel - fitting software ( van der marel 1994 ) . the error bars shown in fig . 2 represent a combination of uncertainties arising from poisson noise and systematics , the latter determined from the scatter observed using different templates and continuum fits . the high spectral resolution of esi proved crucial in clinching the redshifts of the arcs as the emission lines are located in a crowded region of oh sky background . the two top panels in fig . [ fig : vdprof ] show the relevant portion of the esi spectra for the tangential and radial arcs , with the observed emission lines identified as the [ oii ] doublet at @xmath26 and @xmath27 respectively . the [ oii ] doublet is clearly resolved for the tangential arc and it is reasonable to suppose that the missing component for the radial arc is obscured by sky emission . no other lines are detected on either spectra , down to the blue cutoff of esi at @xmath28 . this makes it unlikely that the single line observed for the radial arc is any of the common lines such as h@xmath29 , h@xmath8 , [ oiii]4959 , 5007 , civ1549 , heii1640 , c[iii]1909 because bluer lines would be detected assuming typical flux ratios . the identification of the line with ly@xmath29 at @xmath30 is also unlikely given that the arc is detected in the hst f702w image ( see below ) . detailed modeling of ms2137 - 23 based on the image configurations predicted that the sources for the arcs would be at nearly the same redshift ( m93 , h97 ) . hst wfpc2 images of ms2137 - 23 ( go 5402 , pi : gioia ) , comprising 10 f702w exposures with a total integration time of 22.2ks , were used to measure the surface photometry of the bcg and to locate arc positions . the exposures were reduced in a standard way , using the iraf package drizzle ( fruchter & hook 2002 ) . the circularized surface brightness profile ( in agreement with h97 ) was obtained using the iraf task ellipse and a fit performed as described in treu et al . ( 1998 , 2001a ) taking into account the hst point - spread function . the best fitting @xmath31 parameters are summarized in table 1 . to convert from f702w magnitudes to v magnitudes a k - color correction was calculated using the same method as treu et al . rest frame photometric quantities were corrected for galactic extinction using @xmath32 = 2.435e(b - v)=0.122 ( schlegel et al . 1998 ) . [ cols= " < , > " , ] table 1 : relevant spectro - photometric quantities we now combine the observed spectroscopic and photometric data to constrain the matter distribution in the central region of ms2137 - 23 . first we introduce a simple two - component spherical mass model comprising the stellar mass of the bcg and a dm halo ( sec . 3.1 ) . we then constrain the free parameters of the model using the position of the critical lines ( 3.2 ) and the velocity dispersion profile ( 3.3 ) . for the luminous component we used a jaffe ( 1983 ) @xmath33 mass density profile of total mass m@xmath34 , which reproduces well ( see below ) are virtually unchanged , while slightly larger values of m / l for the stellar component are obtained . ] the observed surface brightness profile ( with @xmath35 = 0.76@xmath36 ) . the dm halo is modeled as , @xmath37 representing a generalization of the cdm - motivated halos , with an inner slope @xmath8 ( nfw and m98 correspond to @xmath38 respectively ; @xmath39 is the critical density ) . we assume that the bcg lies at the center of the overall potential . for a given stellar mass - to - light ratio @xmath40/@xmath41 both @xmath42 and @xmath36 can be deduced from the surface photometry leaving 4 free parameters in our mass model : 1 ) @xmath40/@xmath41 ; 2 ) the inner slope of the dm profile @xmath8 ; 3 ) the dm density scale @xmath43 ; and 4 ) the dm scale radius @xmath6 . given our two - component spherical model , we adopted a simple lensing analysis using only the positions and redshifts of the radial and tangential arcs ( see bartelmann 1996 ) . the locations of the radial and tangential arcs can be estimated by calculating the position of the corresponding radial and tangential critical curves of the projected mass distribution . the jacobian matrix of the lens mapping has two eigenvalues , @xmath44 and @xmath45 , where @xmath46 and @xmath47 is a dimensionless function proportional to the mass inside projected dimensionless radius @xmath48 ( see , e. g. , bartelmann 1996 , schneider , ehlers , falco 1992 ) . tangential and radial critical curves occur when @xmath49 and @xmath50 , respectively . in practice , the position of the tangential arc constrains the _ total enclosed mass _ , while the position of the radial arc constrains its _ derivative_. a proper account of ellipticity is essential for detailed lens modeling where the shape , magnification , and morphology of multiple lensed images is being reproduced . me95 , however , considered several different simple mass models where only the position of the radial and tangential critical lines were being measured and found that the position of the two was affected very little by the introduction of ellipticity . therefore , we conclude that a spherical model is appropriate for our analysis . for every set of free parameters \{@xmath51 , @xmath8 , @xmath52 , @xmath6 } , we can compute the predicted position of the arcs , find the likelihood assuming gaussian distributions , and constrain the acceptable mass models . the largest radius at which the mass is probed is that corresponding to the location of the tangential arc ( 75.8 kpc ) . now @xmath6 is expected to be much greater than 100 kpc in cdm clusters ( bullock et al . 2001 ; see also wu 2000 ) . in this case , the location of the critical lines depends only marginally on @xmath6 and the combined luminous and dark density profile has only 3 free parameters ( we fix @xmath53 kpc in the following ) . fig . 3 shows the likelihood contours ( 68% , 95% and 99% ) in @xmath8 vs. @xmath40/@xmath54 space , obtained using the likelihood ratio statistic after marginalization with respect to @xmath52 . note that with lensing alone we can rule out with greater than 95% confidence a m98 dm density profile ( @xmath8=1.5 ) . the full power of our analysis is only realized when we combine the earlier constraints with those made by measuring the spatially - resolved stellar velocity dispersion profile of the bcg . given our two - component mass model ( section 3.1 ) , we solved the spherical jeans equation ( e.g. binney & tremaine 1987 ) assuming an isotropic velocity ellipsoid for the luminous component . the assumption of isotropy in the region probed ( within 30 % of @xmath35 ) we justify both on theoretical and observational grounds . numerical simulations ( e. g. van albada 1982 ) and observations ( e.g. gerhard et al . 2001 ; koopmans & treu 2002 ) appear to rule out significant tangential anisotropy and permitting some radial anisotropy only at large radii . strong radial anisotropy in the very central regions can also be ruled out based on the grounds of stability ( e. g. merritt & aguilar 1985 ; stiavelli & sparke 1991 ) and consistency requirements ( ciotti 1999 ) . however , as a check , we ran osipkov - merritt ( osipkov 1979 ; merritt 1985a , b ) models with anisotropy radius set equal to progressively lower radii . moving the anisotropy radius towards zero pushes the likelihood contours towards lower values of @xmath8 . for each set of parameters in the lens model , we computed the likelihood given the velocity dispersion profile , taking into account the effects of seeing , radial binning , and finite slit width . the total likelihood was computed by multiplying the velocity dispersion likelihood by the likelihood obtained with the lensing analysis . the bottom panel in fig . 3 shows the final results of the combined analysis . with 99% confidence , @xmath40/@xmath54 lies between 2.3 and 3.7 ( broadly consistent with local values after passive evolution ) , with the inner dm slope ( @xmath8 ) lying between 0.05 and 0.8 , flatter than that expected from cdm simulations . the best - fitting parameters are @xmath55 m@xmath56/l@xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 . to check our results , we changed @xmath35 by 10% with a negligible effect on the likelihood contours . similarly , the contours are virtually unchanged by offsets of @xmath60 in the position of the tangential arc and by changing the seeing by 30% . changing the position of the radial critical line by @xmath61 shifts the likelihood contours by @xmath220.1 in the @xmath8 direction . systematic offsets of the velocity dispersion profile due to template mismatch and poor continuum fitting introduce correlation between the kinematic points that are not considered in the likelihood ratio analysis . to investigate this , we have repeated the analysis with the velocity dispersion profile shifted by the estimated systematic error ( @xmath62 km @xmath63 ) . a lower overall velocity dispersion profiles shifts our likelihood contours towards lower @xmath8 ( @xmath64 99 % cl ) , and viceversa ( @xmath3 99 % cl ) : our hard 99% cl upper limit is @xmath3 . we have secured spectroscopic redshifts for the radial and tangential arcs in the cluster ms 2137 - 23 and determined the velocity dispersion profile of the bcg to a physical radius of @xmath118 kpc . we have combined these measurements with the lensing geometry in order to construct a self - consistent model of the mass distribution in the cluster core . using a spherically symmetric luminous and dm mass distribution , we rule out the presence of a dm halo with an inner slope @xmath65 at greater than 99% confidence , including systematics . m98 and nfw - type halos with @xmath66 are inconsistent with the mass distribution in the core of ms2137 - 23 . since the infall of baryons associated with the bcg are likely to _ steepen _ the dm halo ( blumenthal et al 1986 ; mo , mao and white 1998 ) , our measured profile may imply the original dm profile was even flatter . a full modeling of this process is beyond the scope of this letter , but this strengthens our conclusion that the inner regions of the dm halo of ms2137 - 23 can not be described by cdm - motivated universal halos . a potential concern is that our models have only two mass components , but x - ray emitting gas could be a non - negligible third massive component . using rosat observations of ms2137 - 23 ( ettori & fabian 1999 ) we estimate that removing the x - ray component will steepen the resulting dm halo slope by less than @xmath67 and therefore does not change dramatically the result . finally , individual halo shapes can depart from the ensemble average behavior . therefore it is necessary to apply such a test to a sample of clusters . our simple method is applicable to all approximately round clusters with a massive galaxy at their center , provided that they have at least a giant tangential arc ( radial arcs further enhance the sensitivity but are not required ) . we are in the process of collecting data for a dozen clusters with the aim of performing such a statistical test . we are grateful to a. benson , j .- kneib , l. koopmans for insightful discussions and comments on this project , and to p. shopbell for numerous computer tips . we acknowledge the use of the gauss - hermite pixel fitting software developed by r. p. van der marel . we acknowledge financial support for proposal number hst - ar-09527 provided by nasa through a grant from stsci , which is operated by aura , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 . finally , the authors wish to recognize and acknowledge the cultural role and reverence that the summit of mauna kea has always had within the indigenous hawaiian community . we are most fortunate to have the opportunity to conduct observations from this mountain . bartelmann , m. 1996 , a&a , 313 , 697 binney , j. , & tremaine , s. 1987 , galactic dynamics , princeton university press , princeton blumenthal , g. r. , faber , s. m. , flores , r. , & primack , j. r. 1986 , , 301 , 27 bullock , j. s. , kolatt t. s. , sigad , y. , somerville , r. s. , kravtsov , a. v. , klypin , a. a. , primack , j. r. , & dekel , a. 2001 , mnras , 321 , 598 ciotti , l. 1999 , , 520 , 574 de blok , w. j. g. , & bosma , a. 2002 , a&a , 385 , 816 ettori , s. , & fabian a. c. 2002 , , 305 , 834 fort , b. , le fevre , o. , hammer , f. , & cailloux , m. 1992 , , 399 , l125 fruchter , a. s. , & hook , r. n. 2002 , pasp , 114 , 14 gerhard , o. , kronawitter , a. , saglia , r. p. , & bender , r. 2001 , , 121 , 1936 ghigna , s. , moore , b. , governato , f. , lake , g. , quinn , t. , & stadel , j. 2000 , , 544 , 616 hammer , f. , gioia , i. , shaya , e. , teyssandier , p. , le fevre , o. , & luppino , g. 1997 , , 491 , 477 hernquist , l. 1990 , , 356 , 359 jaffe , w. 1983 , , 202 , 995 jimenez , r. , verde , l. , & oh , s. p. 2002 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0201352 ) kelson , d. , zabludoff , a. , williams , k. , trager , s. , mulchaey , j. , & bolte , m. 2002 , , accepted ( astro - ph/0205316 ) koopmans , l. v. e. , & treu , t. 2002 , , submitted , astro - ph/0205335 kronawitter , a. , saglia , r.p . , gerhard , o. , & bender , r. 2000 , a&as , 144 , 53 mahdavi , a. , & geller , m. 2001 , aas , mtg . 199 , 142.04 mellier , y. , fort , b. , & kneib , j. 1993 , , 407 , 33 merritt , d. 1985a , , 90 , 1027 merritt , d. 1985b , , 214 , 25 merritt , d. , & aguilar , l. a. 1985 , , 217 , 787 miralde - escud , j. 1995 , , 438 , 514 mo , h. , mao , s. , & white s. d. m. 1998 , , 297 , 71 moore , b. , governato , f. , quinn , t. , stadel , j. & lake , g. 1998 , , 499 , l5 navarro , j. , frenk , c. s. , & white s. d. m 1997 , , 490 , 493 osipkov , l. .p . 1979 , pisma astron . zh . , 5 , 77 power , c. , navarro , j. , jenkins , a. , frenk , c. , white , s. , springel , v. , stadel , j. , & quinn , t. 2002 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0201544 ) salucci , p. , & burkert , a. 2000 , , 537 , l9 schneider , p. , ehlers , j. & falco , e. e. 1992 , gravitational lenses , springer - verlag , berlin . schlegel , d. j. , finkbeiner , d. p. , & davis , m. 2000 , , 500 , 525 sheinis , a. i. , et al . 2002 , pasp , in press , astro - ph/0204297 smith , g. p. , kneib , j .- p . , ebeling , h. , czoske , o. , & smail , i. r. 2001 , , 552 , 493 stiavelli , m. , & sparke , l. 1991 , , 382 , 466 treu , t. , & koopmans , l. v. e. 2002 , , 575 , in press treu , t. , stiavelli , m. , bertin g. , casertano , c. , & mller , p. 2001 , , 326 , 237 treu , t. , stiavelli , m. , casertano , c. , mller , p. , & bertin g. 1999 , , 308 , 1307 treu , t. , stiavelli , m. , casertano , c. , mller , p. , & bertin , g. 2002 , , 564 , l13 tyson , a. , kochanski , g. , & dellantonio , i. , 1998 , , 498 , l107 van albada , t.s . 1982 , mnras , 201 , 939 van den bosch , f. c. & swaters , r. a. 2001 , , 325 , 1017 van der marel , r. p. 1994 , , 270 , 271 williams , l. , navarro , j. , & bartelmann , m. 1999 , , 527 , 535 wu , x. 2000 , , 316 , 299

we present new spectroscopic observations of the gravitational arcs and the brightest cluster galaxy ( bcg ) in the cluster ms2137 - 23 ( @xmath0 ) obtained with the echelle spectrograph and imager on the keck ii telescope . we find that the tangential and radial arcs arise from sources at almost identical redshifts ( @xmath1 ) . we combine the measured stellar velocity dispersion profile of the bcg with a lensing analysis to constrain the distribution of dark and stellar matter in the central 100 kpc of the cluster . our data indicate a remarkably flat inner slope for the dark matter profile , @xmath2 , with @xmath3 at 99% cl . steep inner slopes obtained in cold dark matter cosmological simulations such as navarro frenk & white ( @xmath4 ) or moore ( 1.5 ) universal dark matter profiles are ruled out at better than @xmath5%cl . as baryon collapse is likely to have steepened the dark matter profile from its original form , our data provides a powerful test of the cold dark matter paradigm at the cluster mass scale .

hep-ph0310099

quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) is the only quantum field theory which can be successfully applied to a broad range of effects ( bound states , scattering , decay ) and energies from microwave radiation to high energies in the gev range and deliver us various accurate predictions for measurable quantities with an uncertainty reaching the ppt level . qed of photons and leptons is an absolutely correct theory in a sense that its lagrangian is well defined and in principle there is no problem for performing any calculations . however , that is not sufficient since exact calculations are strongly limited by increasing difficulties in the calculation of higher - order effects and we always have to deal with a finite number of terms in the perturbative expansion . a question therefore arises how to estimate terms , which are too complicated to be calculated and sometimes that is in part art . however , qed is in some way incomplete since electromagnetic interactions may involve hadrons and strong interactions which can not be calculated _ ab initio_. the weak interactions may also be involved , but usually it is not a problem to find related contributions . however , there is a basic theoretical problem while performing comparison to experiment . theory is not in position to predict any numbers . what theory can only do is to express some measurable quantity in terms of others . in particular , to produce any quantitative prediction within bound state qed , we need to be first able to determine with a proper accuracy values of basic fundamental constants ( the rydberg constant @xmath0 , the fine structure constant @xmath1 as well as different masses and magnetic moments ) and auxiliary parameters ( such as the proton charge radius ) due to the hadronic sector , which are necessary input data for bound state qed calculations . however , there is no way to solve the bound state problem in general . the application of qed to the bound state forms a field called _ bound state qed _ , which experiences its own difficulties , additionally to qed problems for free particles . bound state qed is quite attractive as a training field to solve the bound state problem in quantum theory . it may be helpful for few - nucleon nuclei and for hadronic particles . in particular , there is a similarity in physics of positronium and quark - antiquark systems ( mesons ) . the difficulties of precision qed calculations for free particles are mainly due to an increasing number ( up to one thousand ) of complicated diagrams ( the four - loop level ) . the bound state qed theory deals with much simpler diagrams , however , the charged particles are bound there rather than free , and thus the coulomb exchange may be not a small effect . a detailed review on qed calculations for light atoms can be found in @xcite . the free qed involves only one small parameter @xmath1 , while the bound state qed theory needs at least three and all three expansions are not quite good@xcite . indeed , we still have to deal with @xmath1 , the power of which indicates the number of qed loops involved . the expansion is asymptotical but that is not important since the bound state calculations mainly need one - loop and two - loop contributions , with three - loop effects being important rather seldom . the coulomb strength @xmath2 appears because of binding effects and the parameters @xmath1 and @xmath2 behave in a quite different way . there is a number of contributions where we need to sum over an infinite number of coulomb exchanges ( e.g. the bethe logarithm ) . importance of all the exchanges assumes their essentially non - relativistic behaviour and still allows a @xmath2 expansion , which can not be avoided since calculations exact in @xmath2 are possible for a few contributions only . however , that is not a well behaving expansion , because the limit @xmath3 is related to an unbound two - body system and thus leads to a non - analytic behaviour of perturbative expressions . the non - analyticity in coulomb systems is usually accompanied with numerous logarithmic factors . for @xmath4 ( hydrogen , muonium , positronium ) one can find : the corrections known up to now may include up to cube of this logarithm , @xmath6 ( for the lamb shift ) , and up to logarithm squared for hyperfine structure and positronium physics@xcite . for several reasons the non - logarithmic contributions also involve big coefficients@xcite . a bound state problem supposes that we deal with an atom consisting of an orbiting particle(s ) and an attractor ( nucleus ) and that involves one more parameter , a ratio @xmath7 of masses of the orbiting particle ( mainly an electron ) and the nucleus which for conventional atoms is @xmath8 , for muonium is @xmath9 and for positronium is @xmath10 . the behaviour of the expansion in @xmath7 is not good since the limit @xmath11 is related to a kind of bound neutrino " . the non - analytic behaviour shows itself in logarithmic terms and , e.g. , for muonium @xmath12 . some more parameters are involved due to nuclear effects , such as , e.g. , a ratio of the bohr radius to the nuclear radius . thus , the bound state qed theory involves a rather rich spectrum of problems and it deserves to be tested , particularly in spite of the lack of well established universal prescriptions appropriate for the two - body bound state problem in general . there are two basic problems of the precision bound state qed theory : lamb shift and hyperfine structure . the lamb shift calculations mainly need an external field approximation , while recoil corrections are less important and only the simplest of them are involved . in contrast , calculations of the hyperfine interval are crucially affected by the recoil effects , while some external field effects ( e.g. , the higher - order two - loop corrections ) are relatively less important . most of interest to positronium properties is due to recoil effects which are crucial since @xmath10 . for this reason we consider here in more detail studies of the hyperfine structure in light atoms . magnetic effects are relativistic effects and thus , in contrast to the coulomb interaction responsible for the lamb shift , the higher momentum transfers and shorter distances are more important . at shorter distances the recoil and nuclear - structure effects are enhanced . the nuclear effects in hydrogen and other light atoms dominate over the bound state qed@xcite . still there are three possible qed tests with the hyperfine structure in which the problem of nuclear effects can be avoided . a comparison of the @xmath13 and @xmath14 hyperfine intervals that offers a specific difference@xcite @xmath15 which is immune to leading effects of the nuclear structure . a comparison of conventional and muonic atoms for the same nucleus . a study of a pure leptonic atomic system such as muonium and positronium determination of the @xmath14 hyperfine interval in muonic hydrogen is in part the goal of an psi experiment@xcite which is now in progress . the hfs interval in the @xmath13 and @xmath14 states was successfully studied for several light atoms . the more complicated measurement is related to the metastable @xmath14 state@xcite . @xmath16 theory is compared to experiment in fig . [ f : d21 ] . the theory of @xmath16 for several atoms is summarized in table [ t : d21 ] . the dominant uncertainty of qed theory is due to higher - order one - loop and two - loop corrections in order @xmath17 and @xmath18 and recoil corrections in order @xmath19 ( in units of the @xmath13 hfs splitting ) . the higher - order nuclear effects also substantially contribute to the uncertainty . the muonium theory of the @xmath13 hyperfine interval is summarized in table [ t : mu ] . the dominant uncertainty of qed theory@xcite is due to higher - order recoil corrections in order @xmath19 and @xmath20 which are also in part responsible for the uncertainty of @xmath16 ( see above ) . the other important part of the uncertainty is related to the determination of the leading term ( so - called fermi energy ) @xmath21 in terms of fundamental constants @xmath22 and @xmath1 and inaccuracy in their determination . as mentioned before , the recoil effects are better seen in positronium . below we consider the positronium spectrum and a comparison of theory to experiment . we find that the uncertainty in calculating all experimentally studied transitions is related to the same recoil contributions as for the muonium hfs interval . the recoil effects play a crucial role in a two - body bound problem showing how closely the bound system is to a real two - body system . however , the significance of positronium is not limited by the possibility to verify the theory of recoil corrections . since the corrections of interest are enhanced ( @xmath7 is not a suppressing factor any longer ) , the fractional accuracy for successful high - precision tests is now relatively low . as a result , in contrast to hydrogen , the interpretation of the measurements of the @xmath23 interval does not crucially involve knowledge of the rydberg constant with high accuracy . a study of the hyperfine interval does not require a value of the fine structure constant with high accuracy as it is in muonium . since @xmath10 , it is not necessary to determine either @xmath7 or @xmath24 in an additional experiment . in other words , positronium offers several high precision tests of bound state qed without determinations of fundamental constants with high accuracy . the hyperfine and recoil effects are enhanced and thus can be seen not only in a direct study of the hyperfine structure but also in the investigation of the gross or fine structure in contrast to hydrogen and muonium . thus , positronium offers a few transitions which can be studied with high accuracy ( see table [ t : pos ] ) . adding to that an opportunity of different experiments on positronium annihilation , we find a big variety of properties to be studied . it is not even necessary to mention that as a light pure leptonic atomic system , the positronium atom is free of hadronic effects . it is important that positronium is light because hadronic effects in leptonic systems involve a high momentum transfer . they can be seen in muonium and in the muon anomalous magnetic moment they are responsible for a dominant part of the theoretical uncertainty , while they are strongly suppressed for positronium and the anomalous magnetic moment of electron . since positronium is a very specific atom , the notation for positronium is slightly different from other two - body atoms . first , in two - body atoms , even in hydrogen and muonium , it is customary to keep the value of the nuclear charge @xmath25 in order to recognize exchange photons and photons of qed radiative effects and thus to trace the origin of different corrections . in positronium there is an interference between both kinds of photons because of annihilation diagrams and thus it is meaningless to keep @xmath25 . hydrogen and other two - body atoms are one - electron systems and one can use for them both small ( e.g. , @xmath13 ) and capital ( e.g. , @xmath26 ) letters to denote levels . the former are used for an electron , while the latter are for all electrons in an atom and that is indeed the same for single - electron atomic systems . here , we prefer to use small - case letters for hydrogen and others . since the nuclear spin effects are not suppressed , positronium has a structure of energy levels ( in respect to their spin and angular momentum ) rather similar to a two - electron system ( such as the neutral helium atom ) and one has to use only capital letter for its orbital momentum . we summarize theoretical predictions for various transitions and decay rates in table 3 . the table does not contain experimental results but only references to figures where a comparison of theory to experiment is performed . our results for decay rates and the hfs interval are slightly different from those quoted in the literature because we include into the decay rates contributions related to the decay to non - minimal number of photons ( four for parapositronium and five for orthopositronium ) which are sometimes omitted and because of our conservative estimation of uncertainty . to be conservative , we estimate the final uncertainty by half of the value of the leading logarithmic terms , if the non - leading term is unknown or reduces the logarithmic contribution , and by half of the value of the whole logarithmic contribution , if the non - leading term enhances the leading term ( cf . let us now consider the positronium spectrum in more detail . the hyperfine interval in positronium has been measured with the highest absolute accuracy among positronium transitions . a comparison of theory and experiment is presented in fig . [ f : hfs ] while theory is summarized in table [ t : hfs ] . the theoretical contributions are classified in units of the fermi energy @xmath27 which is defined including the virtual one - photon annihilation . e.g. , qed2 is related to corrections of relative order @xmath28 . this notation is helpful for a comparison to the theory of decay rates , while the absolute units , also presented in the table , allow a simple and direct comparison with theory of the @xmath23 interval . agreement with experiment is not perfect ( within 2.5 - 3 standard deviations ) which demonstrates that positronium is not very well understood . the @xmath23 interval was measured in orthopositronium by a method of three - photon ionization which has a resonance related to the two - photon excitation of the metastable @xmath29 state from the ground state . the absolute uncertainty of the @xmath23 interval is compatible with the hyperfine splitting although somewhat lower . the uncertainty of the theoretical predictions for both hyperfine interval and the @xmath23 transition ( see table [ t:1s2s ] ) is determined by a correction of order @xmath30 . that is related to @xmath31 in the positronium hyperfine interval ( @xmath32 ) and thus to @xmath33 corrections in atoms with heavy nucleus ( @xmath34 ) , namely , @xmath35 and @xmath36 . a comparison of theory to experiment is presented in fig . [ f:1s2s ] . the theoretical uncertainty for the @xmath37 fine structure in positronium ( see fig . [ f : fs ] ) is compatible with that for the hyperfine interval and the @xmath23 transition , but the experiment on @xmath38 transitions can not provide competitive results ( see fig . [ f:2s2p ] ) . however , progress is possible@xcite . positronium is an unstable atom because of electron and positron annihilation . the @xmath26 state of positronium decays mainly into two or three photons depending on its spin . thus , the orthopositronium ( @xmath39 ) annihilates into an odd number of photons , while the parapositronium ( @xmath40 ) into an even number . the leading rates are @xmath41 the lifetime of orthopositronium was responsible for a long - standing discrepancy of theory and most accurate experiments performed at the university of michigan@xcite while theory was in fair agreement with less accurate experiments , which disagreed with the michigan data . the present situation is summarized in fig . [ f : ops ] . hopefully , the crisis seems to be resolved since the new michigan vacuum result@xcite now agrees with theory and the reevaluation@xcite of the former gas experiment@xcite shifted the value towards theory . a further reexamination of systematic effects is in progress and the final uncertainty will probably be higher@xcite . meanwhile , the lifetime of parapositronium also measured at the university of michigan@xcite is in fair agreement with the theoretical prediction ( see fig . [ f : pps ] ) . the theoretical predictions for the annihilation decay rates for ortho- and parapositronium are summarized in table [ t : gam ] . we do not consider here exotic decay modes related to possible new physics , but rather rare modes possible within qed and the standard model . two rare qed modes are allowed at a detectable level . their theory and experiments are summarized in table [ t : rar ] . we also include in the table a photonless annihilation of orthopositronium into a pair of neutrino - antineutrino . the other modes with a pair of @xmath42 are also possible but their branching ratios are a few orders of magnitude lower . we have to note that the branching fraction of the orthopositronium decay into neutrinos is so low , that this decay is unlikely to be soon detected , however , a mode @xmath43 ( since the neutrino is not detectable ) can still be of interest if the neutrino has a non - vanishing magnetic moment ( see , e.g. , fig . [ f : onu ] ) . this problem was discussed in part in @xcite but we do not like to present here any numbers . in our opinion , results of such analysis can depend on a model introducing neutrino mass and magnetic moment . still , studies of the pure neutrino modes can provide a limit on the @xmath44-neutrino magnetic moment at a level above ( but possibly not much above ) the current limits@xcite . since systematic effects are different and the interpretation depends on the model , we think it may be important to have several independent limitations . tests with positronium are quite different from other tests . advantages and disagvantages of positronium studies and some other qed experiments are listed in table [ t : adv ] . to compare different qed tests with / without positronium , we also check which contributions are crucial for a comparison of theory to experiments . they are summarized in table [ t : ord ] . to consider hfs tests in detail , we summarize the results on a study of the hyperfine structure in light two - body atoms in table [ t : hfsqed ] . in these tests the qed uncertainty has never been a limiting factor for comparison of theory and experiment . the following uncertainties may also be involved : due to nuclear effects , determination of fundamental constants or measurement . one of them is always bigger than the theoretical uncertainty . the theory and experiment are in general in good agreement . the uncertainty for the @xmath13 hyperfine interval in muonium and positronium and in part of @xmath16 for helium-3 ion is related to the same recoil corrections in order @xmath45 ( see table [ t : ord ] ) . the positronium uncertainty in fractional units is much higher than that for experiments with heavy atoms ( @xmath34 ) , however , its sensitivity to higher - order recoil effects is at approximately the same level . the higher - order recoil contributions are known only in the logarithmic approximation and we estimate the uncertainty as half the value of the leading term if the next - to - leading term is unknown or cancels a part of the leading term . however , if the leading and the next - to - the leading terms are of the same sign , we estimate the uncertainty as a half value of the whole logarithmic contribution ( cf . thus , a calculation of the next - to - leading terms does not reduce an uncertainty . a reason for such a conservative estimation is that the leading logarithmic term is mostly a result of a single contribution without any cancellation . for the @xmath46 state it is state - independent . for these reasons it has a kind of natural value and can be used to estimate the non - leading terms . in contrast , the non - leading term has quite accidental value and may be sometimes quite below the natural level . thus , it can not be used alone to estimate properly the next term of the logarithmic expansion . however , we can not simply ignore the next - to - leading term , particularly in the case when it is not too small . in the present paper we follow a compromise which allows to achieve a conservative estimation of the uncertainty . a calculation of the next of the non - leading terms helps us to check the reliability of this estimation using only the leading term and meantime is a necessary step towards a calculation of the whole contribution beyond the logarithmic approximation which is strongly needed for muonium and positronium hfs . not only essential orders of qed corrections offer a possibility of comparing the efficiency of different experiments . the bound state qed theory clearly recognizes two kinds of contributions : the soft - photon contribution and the hard - photon contribution . the latter are very similar to free qed , while the former essentially involve binding effects . there are two most important soft - photon contributions . crucial corrections in the external field approximation are due to the higher - order two - loop self - energy . the inaccuracy in its calculation determines an uncertainty of the lamb shift calculations for hydrogen and hydrogen - like ions , while similar effects involving the magnetic field significantly contribute to the uncertainty of @xmath16 in the helium-3 ion . recoil corrections are crucially important for tests with hyperfine structure and they determine the uncertainty of muonium hfs , positronium spectrum ( hyperfine interval , @xmath47 transition , fine structure ) and a part of the uncertainty of @xmath16 for the helium-3 ion . effects of the hard - photon exchange are very similar to effects of free qed . we note , however , that the regions of integration in momentum space are different . the most accurate free qed calculations which may be compared to experiment are related to the anomalous magnetic moments of electron and muon . the integration for them is performed over a kind of isotropic region in euclidean space ( @xmath48 ) and the crucial level is the four - loop approximation . for the bound state problems there are two other specific regions of integration . for some problems it is sufficient to apply an external field approximation to hard - photon corrections and thus loops of exchange photons are related to zero energy transfer ( @xmath49 ) . even for recoil effects the integration is essentially not covariant in euclidean space including a contribution from a specific region @xmath50 . the highest crucial orders are related to four - loop corrections for the external - field approximation and three - loop corrections for recoil effects . in contrast to the anomalous magnetic moment , that is a calculation for two different particles with its own simplifications and difficulties . the other specific situation for integration is related to the positronium annihilation when some photons are real ( @xmath51 ) . the orthopositronium studies ( main decay mode and branching fraction for five - photon decay ) allow to check calculations of four - loop corrections in such a non - isotropic region of integration . the accuracy of the branching fraction determination for the four - photon decay of parapositronium is at the level of a few percent . because of a relatively large @xmath1-contribution to the @xmath52 annihilation rate@xcite @xmath53 the experiments are approaching a level , where four - loop diagrams are important . thus , we see that the bound state problems supply us with a possibility to check modern algorithms for four - loop calculations and that is competitive to the anomalous magnetic moment of electron . we note , however , that the difficulties which appear at the four - loop level are a large number of digrams with high - dimension integrations and overlapping uv divergencies . neither annihilation nor exchange loops are ultraviolet divergent , but the exchange loops involve strong infrared divergency . one can also compare@xcite soft - qed effects of the virtual one - photon annihilation and the real two- and three - photon annihilation . soft coulomb corrections to the hard annihilation block can be presented in fractional units . a crucial theoretical uncertainty related to @xmath54 corrections ( qed3 term ) is at the level of few ppm , which can be hardly achieved for a measurement of the annihilation rates . thus , we summarize our paper with the following statements . positronium spectroscopy offers a reliable test of our understanding of higher - order recoil corrections within bound state qed , which play a significant role in other qed tests with the hyperfine structure . the theoretical uncertainty for positronium is of a pure qed origin and other effects such as the nuclear structure effects or inaccuracy in determination of fundamental constants are not involved . studies of recoil effects are of particular interest because their significance answers a question whether we study a really two - body system . in conventional atoms ( hydrogen , helium ) the role of the nucleus as a particle is reduced . the positronium is a truly two - body system which is the closest to the neutral helium atom . in contrast to two - body atoms , the qed uncertainty in helium is bigger than that of experiment and theory needs a significant improvement . thus , positronium theory serves as an intermediate step between hydrogen and helium . a study of positronium annihilation including rare decay modes allows to test approaches to the calculation of four - loop diagrams but for a specific integration region . today the four - loop approximation is the highest level for precision calculations of any measurable qed quantities ( if indeed no big logarithms are involved such as those in scattering kinematics ) . there are exotic decay modes of positronium beyond qed , but within the standard model and in particular a decay of orthopositronium into a pair of neutrino and antineutrino , which is a dominant mode beyond qed . the branching fraction is very low and it can not be detected presently . still , a study of this channel can probably give a limit for the magnetic moment of the @xmath44 neutrino which , although somewhat weaker than the current limits , will , however , have completely different systematic effects . the author is grateful to a. badertscher , r. conti , a. czarnecki , s. eidelman , m. felcini , d. gidley , s. gninenko , r. ley and a. rubbia for useful and stimulating discussions . this work was supported in part by rfbr under grants # 02 - 02 - 07027 and # 03 - 02 - 16843 . r. pohl , f. biraben , c.a.n . conde , c. donche - gay , t.w . hnsch , f. j. hartmann , p. hauser , v. w. hughes , o. huot , p. indelicato , p. knowles , f. kottmann , y .- w . liu , v. e. markushin , f. mulhauser , f. nez , c. petitjean , p. rabinowitz , j.m.f . dos santos , l. a. schaller , h. schneuwly , w. schott , d. taqqu , and j.f.c.a . veloso , in _ hydrogen atom : precision physics of simple atomic systems _ , ed . by s. g. karshenboim et al . , ( springer , berlin , heidelberg , 2001 ) , p. 454 . w. liu , m. g. boshier , s. dhawan , o. van dyck , p. egan , x. fei , m. g. perdekamp , v. w. hughes , m. janousch , k. jungmann , d. kawall , f. g. mariam , c. pillai , r. prigl , g. zu putlitz , i. reinhard , w. schwarz , p. a. thompson , and k. a. woodle , phys . * 82 * , 711 ( 1999 ) . r. s. conti , r. s. vallery , d. w. gidley , j. j. engbrecht , m. skalsey , and p.w . zitzewitz , in _ hydrogen atom : precision physics of simple atomic systems _ , ed . by s. g. karshenboim et al . , ( springer , berlin , heidelberg , 2001 ) , p. 103 . r. j. hill and g. p. lepage , phys . d * 62 * , 111301(r ) ( 2000 ) ; + b. khiehl and a. a. penin , phys . * 85 * , 1210 ( 2000 ) ; errarum , * 85 * 3065 ; + k. melnikov and a. yelkhovsky , phys.rev . d * 62 * , 116003 ( 2000 ) .

as an unstable light pure leptonic system , positronium is a very specific probe atom to test bound state qed . in contrast to ordinary qed for free leptons , the bound state qed theory is not so well understood and bound state approaches deserve highly accurate tests . we present a brief overview of precision studies of positronium paying special attention to uncertainties of theory as well as comparison of theory and experiment . we also consider in detail advantages and disadvantages of positronium tests compared to other qed experiments .

0902.2096

understanding and controlling entanglement in many - body systems is one of the most important challenges in quantum mechanics today . the rewards are significant and are expected to not only lead to new insights into the properties of solid state systems and phase transitions @xcite , but also to new designs for highly efficient quantum information devices . ultra - cold bosonic gases offer an ideal arena to explore many - body entanglement , as experimentalists have at their disposal _ designer _ condensed matter systems whose parameters can be controlled with unprecedented precision @xcite . entanglement often exists naturally in the ground state of a many - body system @xcite , where it resides between the degrees of freedom of the particles and is a property of the first quantised many - body wavefunction . however , in ultra - cold gases the particles are inherently indistinguishable , which requires the symmetization of their many - body wavefunction and means that the hilbert space no longer has the tensor product structure required to define entanglement . the first quantised many - body wavefunction of indistinguishable particles may therefore contain quantum correlations @xcite , but such correlations are usually considered unable to violate a bell inequality or process quantum information @xcite . ultra - cold gases are also well described within the framework of second quantisation , where instead of working directly with the many - body wavefunction , one defines a complete set of field modes that are occupied by particles . second quantisation therefore offers the possibility of entanglement between modes . entanglement is dependent on the choice of modes , but provided the correct choice is made , investigating entanglement between _ distinguishable _ modes @xcite circumvents the difficulties of defining entanglement between indistinguishable particles @xcite . to illustrate the differences between particle and mode entanglement , let us consider two non - interacting bosons in a trap at zero temperature . in first quantisation , the wavefunction is the symmetrized product , @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the ground state of the confining potential . no entanglement exists between the particles , since indistinguishability forbids us from assigning to any particle a specific set of degrees of freedom . conversely , in second quantisation one can define a pair of spatial modes , @xmath2 and @xmath3 , where each mode occupies half the confining geometry . since both the particles are coherently distributed over these modes , the system is described by the entangled state , @xmath4 , where @xmath5 denotes @xmath6 particles in mode @xmath2 and @xmath7 particles in mode @xmath3 ( with @xmath8 ) . in this paper we outline a scheme for the detection of bi - mode and multi - mode spatial entanglement for a finite temperature , interacting bose gas of any ( including unknown ) particle number . we show that entanglement is detected via the single - particle reduced density matrix ( sprdm ) . we apply our scheme to the example of a harmonically trapped , interacting boson pair @xcite , where the sprdm also acts as a quantifier of entanglement . we find that for all interaction strengths , entanglement between pairs of modes rapidly decreases with temperature . while at zero temperature a significant amount of entanglement remains even in the limit of infinite interaction . moreover , we note that our detection scheme is also relevant to recent proposals to observe non - locality of single particle between spatial modes @xcite . and @xmath9 . the modes are combined at a @xmath10 beamsplitter and the particles in the output modes @xmath11 and @xmath12 are counted . ] the correlations of entanglement are locally basis independent , so that one needs to measure each mode in at least two bases in order to differentiate them from classical correlations . while a superselection rule that forbids coherent superpositions of eigenstates of different mass @xcite seems to rule such measurements out for any atomic system , recent work has shown that such measurements are theoretically possible @xcite . moreover , it has recently been predicted that this natural mode entanglement of massive particles can be used as a resource for quantum communication @xcite . however , in practice it will be difficult to locally manipulate , i.e. rotate , the spatial modes . in the following we will show that spatial entanglement can also be detected and quantified by making _ operations on the modes . let us consider a gas in a confining geometry ( see fig . [ fig : schematic ] ) which is mathematically , but not necessarily physically , divided into two , non - overlapping spatial modes , @xmath13 and @xmath9 . the field operators , @xmath14 and @xmath15 , create and destroy particles in mode @xmath16 , where @xmath17 ensures that the commutation relations , @xmath18=\delta_{ij}$ ] , are satisfied . the quantity , @xmath19 , specifies how the set of points in a spatial mode are averaged over . to generate interference , the particles in the two spatial modes , @xmath13 and @xmath9 , are mixed at a 50:50 beamsplitter , which transforms the input modes as @xmath20 and @xmath21 . after the beamsplitting operation , the number of particles in the output modes , @xmath11 and @xmath12 , are counted and compared to the fully separable case . if the number of coincidences is different to the separable case , we can conclude that there must have been entanglement between the spatial modes . a bosonic gas of fixed particle number , @xmath22 which is in a fully separable state w.r.t . the spatial modes @xmath13 and @xmath9 can be written as @xmath23 where @xmath24 . the beamsplitter transforms this state such that if the total number of particles is even , one detects the same number of particles in each of the output modes , i.e. @xmath25 . for an odd number of particles an ensemble average leads to the same result @xcite . conversely , if the initial state of fixed particle number is of an arbitrary form , @xmath26 , the difference in particle numbers detected in the modes @xmath11 and @xmath12 may be non - zero due to entanglement between the modes . @xmath27 -{\textrm{tr}}\left[\hat\psi_d^{\dag}\hat\psi_d\hat\rho\right]\right| = 2|\epsilon_{ab}|,\ ] ] where @xmath28 = \int_{a}d\vec{x}\int_{b}d\vec{x}'g(\vec{x})g^*(\vec{x } ' ) \rho^{(1)}(\vec{x},\vec{x}').\ ] ] we have derived the above result using the fourier decomposion of the field operators , @xmath29 and @xmath30 in terms of the momentum modes , @xmath31 , as @xmath32 and likewise for @xmath33 . when @xmath34 is non - zero , the state @xmath26 is different to the separable case and is therefore necessarily entangled w.r.t . the bi - modal split into @xmath13 and @xmath9 . the quantity @xmath34 is given by the off - diagonal elements of the sprdm which is defined as @xmath35 . here @xmath36 is the number of bosons that occupy the @xmath37-th momentum mode . the sprdm is a one - body correlation function , which characterises important coherence properties of a many - body system @xcite and its off - diagonal elements are related to the visibility of interference fringes in a two slit experiment @xcite . our scheme therefore applies to systems whose correlations from a basic group of one particle @xcite . states of the form , @xmath38 , whose correlations are second order are not detected by the sprdm . such states require careful engineering of bosonic systems @xcite , although they may form naturally in fermionic systems , i.e. cooper pairs in superconductors . our scheme is applicable to all bosonic gases trapped in orthodox geometries . next , let us show that @xmath34 can also be used to _ quantify _ mode entanglement for certain systems , one of which is the boson pair model discussed below . for this @xmath34 must fulfil three basic criteria @xcite : ( i ) @xmath34 is zero when the state is separable , ( ii ) @xmath34 is invariant under local unitary operations and ( iii ) @xmath34 does not increase under local general measurements and classical communication ( lgm+cc ) . the validity of ( i ) is shown above and ( ii ) is guaranteed since the trace is basis independent . one can prove ( iii ) as follows . to implement lgm+cc , the two spatial modes , @xmath13 and @xmath9 , are each coupled to a local environment by a general completely positive map . the environments are allowed to communicate classically ad infinitum and the total number of particles in the gas and environment is fixed . one can then show that @xmath34 does not increase under lgm+cc . the above scheme can also analyse multi - mode entanglement , i.e. the simultaneous entanglement of more than two modes . in the following we use the different notions of separability discussed in @xcite . a general @xmath39-mode state is fully separable and contains no entanglement if it is a convex combination of states for each mode , @xmath40 . here each composite state , @xmath41 corresponds to a single spatial mode with a fixed number of particles . on the other hand , entanglement may be present between certain subsets of spatial modes , for which one can define a @xmath42-separable state , @xmath43 , where @xmath44 with equality when the state is fully separable as above . when the composite state , @xmath41 describes more than one spatial mode , the spatial modes contained within @xmath45 are necessarily entangled otherwise @xmath45 would be written as a product of states for the individual modes , @xmath46 , and the overall state of the system would be @xmath47-separable , where @xmath48 @xcite . to determine whether a given @xmath39-mode state contains multi - mode entanglement , one can check a bi - partite entanglement criterion between all @xmath49 unique divisions of the system into two _ blocks _ , @xmath2 and @xmath3 . depending on which pairs of blocks are found to be separable one can conclude that the state has entanglement between different subsets of spatial modes . here the bipartite entanglement criterion is @xmath50 $ ] of eq . , i.e. the sprdm between two blocks of spatial modes , @xmath51 and @xmath52 . the field operators , @xmath53 and @xmath54 , for blocks of spatial modes are defined as @xmath55 and @xmath56 , where @xmath57 and @xmath58 ensures that the commutation relations , @xmath59=\delta _ { { x } , { y}}$ ] , are satisfied . we now describe how entanglement changes for the ( i ) fully separable ( ii ) the @xmath42-separable and ( iii ) the fully entangled states : ( i ) the fully separable state , @xmath60 , admits no interference between all @xmath49 partitions into blocks , i.e. @xmath61 for all @xmath51 and @xmath52 . ( ii ) a @xmath42-separable state , @xmath62 where @xmath63 , admits no interference for @xmath64 partitions into blocks from the total of @xmath49 partitions , i.e. @xmath65 for @xmath64 choices of @xmath2 and @xmath3 . ( iii ) a fully entangled state , @xmath66 , admits interference for all @xmath49 choices of blocks , i.e. @xmath67 for all @xmath68 and @xmath69 . the fully entangled state , @xmath70 , necessarily contains some form of multi - mode entanglement , since otherwise there would exist a decomposition such that @xmath26 is @xmath42-separable . . temperature is scaled in units of @xmath71 . ] in the following we will apply our scheme to the physically realistic model of a harmonically trapped pair of ultracold , interacting , bosonic atoms in effectively one dimension . the hamiltonian of such a system is given by @xmath72 where all lengths are scaled in units of the ground state size and all energies in units of the harmonic frequency . the one dimensional coupling constant , @xmath73 , is related to the three dimensional @xmath74-wave scattering length by @xmath75 , where @xmath76 is the constant , @xmath77 @xcite . this hamiltonian can be decoupled by moving into the centre of mass and relative coordinate frames labelled by @xmath78 and @xmath79 , respectively , @xcite and the two - body wavefunction can subsequently be written as @xmath80 . the eigenvalues for the centre of mass motion are given by @xmath81 for @xmath82 , with corresponding eigenstates , @xmath83 . here @xmath84 is the normalisation constant and @xmath85 are the hermite polynomials . for the relative motion , the single particle eigenstates are @xmath86 , where @xmath87 and the @xmath88 are the confluent hypergeometric functions . the corresponding eigenenergies , @xmath89 , are determined by the roots of the implicit relation @xmath90 @xcite . the kernel of the density operator in position representation is @xmath91 , with the sprdm defined as @xmath92 the sprdm in thermal equilibrium is given by @xmath93 where @xmath94 is the boltzmann weight , @xmath95 , @xmath96 is the boltzmann constant and @xmath97 is the partition function . we define two equal length modes , @xmath13 and @xmath9 , and calculate their spatial entanglement for the boson pair model as a function of temperature and interaction strength using eq . . the results are displayed in fig . [ fig : thermal ] . with increasing temperature the gas becomes a statistical mixture of momentum modes , @xmath98 , which destroys the fixed relative phase between the spatial modes and consequently the entanglement between them is severely depleted . the presence of interaction also degrades the quality of the entanglement at @xmath99 , but a significant amount persists even in the tonks - girardeau limit , of impenetrable bosons , @xmath100 . at first this may seem surprising , since in the tonks - girardeau limit the system can be mapped onto an ideal fermionic atom pair @xcite , for which one may not expect any entanglement to be present . however , only the local properties of the bosons become identical to free spin - polarised fermions due to the bose - fermi mapping and therefore entanglement is not affected . , mode b as @xmath101 and mode c as @xmath102 . entanglement is investigated between neighbouring modes , @xmath13 and @xmath9 ( @xmath9 and @xmath11 ) ( left hand side ) and also between the outer two modes , @xmath13 and @xmath11 ( right hand side ) at @xmath99 as interaction is varied . three different central mode lengths , @xmath103 are taken . ] we also examine pairwise entanglement in this model . for this space is divided into three modes , @xmath13 , @xmath9 and @xmath11 , and we check entanglement between all pairs , @xmath104 , @xmath105 and @xmath106 , as a function of the interaction strength at zero temperature . the results are shown in fig . [ fig:3modes ] , where three different central mode lengths , @xmath107 , are considered . the left graph of fig . [ fig:3modes ] shows entanglement between neighbouring modes , @xmath104 ( and for symmetry reasons @xmath105 ) . here entanglement decreases as the interaction strength , @xmath73 , increases for all lengths studied . the right hand side graph of fig . [ fig:3modes ] shows the entanglement between outer modes , @xmath13 and @xmath11 . the entanglement increases initially for all mode sizes as the interaction strength is varied . for the central mode size of @xmath108 entanglement however is not a monotonic function of @xmath73 and decreases after the initial rise . for @xmath109 and @xmath110 this is not the case . the behaviour of entanglement in both graphs can be explained by the delocalisation of the bosons away from the centre of the trap due to greater interaction strengths . stronger interaction therefore increases the correlation length ( i.e. the entanglement between the outer two modes ) , yet decreases the overall coherence of the sample . we also check the existence of multi - mode entanglement in our model . for this we have divided our two - particle wavefunction into @xmath39 modes and calculated @xmath111 for the @xmath49 unique partitions of these modes into two blocks , @xmath2 and @xmath3 . recall that , @xmath111 , must be non - zero for all possible block combinations for the state to be fully entangled . we have found that at zero temperature the system possesses full multi - mode entanglement , i.e. @xmath67 for all @xmath2 and @xmath3 , for a wide range of values of the interaction parameter , provided that the set of modes are defined within the coherence length of the sample . here we have used the repulsively , interacting boson pair model to illustrate our scheme , since it is analytically tractable and contains all the essential features of larger models . our scheme to detect bi- and multi - mode entanglement can also be applied to bose gases with a greater number of particles ( for all interaction strengths and temperatures ) , but qualitatively the results will remain unchanged while the task of computing the single - particle reduced density matrix between modes will quickly become very demanding . we note that bi - mode entanglement of a non - interacting bose gas has been studied before for @xmath22 particles at zero temperature @xcite and at finite temperatures @xcite . our scheme can be implemented using currently available technologies . atomic beamsplitters can be realised with optical potentials @xcite and separate modes can be defined using spatially selective outcoupling techniques @xcite . to perform beamsplitting , on systems with strong interactions one should raise a potential barrier between the desired modes on a non - adiabatic time scale so that the coherences between the regions are not lost , ( i.e. so that the gas does not enter a mott - like state ) . the potential barrier should then be lowered rapidly enough so that the coupling between the wells is greater than the on - site interaction energy of the wells . for instance , one could envisage a setup where the trap is swiftly modulated from harmonic to double - well potential and is then switched off and the sample left to interfere . the entanglement can be inferred according to eq . from the visibility of the resulting interference fringes , see for example @xcite , where mode entanglement between regions of space has already been measured indirectly . we have outlined a scheme that detects bi - modal and multi - modal spatial entanglement of cold bosonic gases using simple atom - optic techniques . we show that spatial entanglement is detected by the sprdm between different modes , a quantity that is related to the visibility of routinely measured interference fringes . we have demonstrated our scheme using the model of a harmonically trapped boson pair and have found the existence of bi- and multi - mode entanglement within the gas . for all interaction strengths , increasing temperature rapidly degrades the amount of entanglement , but at zero temperature entanglement still remains , even in the presence of strong interactions . therefore , we have shown that the ability to vary the particle interaction strength allows one to engineer the distribution of entanglement over the trap , thus allowing a tunable source of entanglement . _ acknowledgements _ - the authors would like to thank j. anders , p. turner , w. son . and m. paternostro for valuable discussions . jg and tb acknowledge funding from science foundation ireland , project number 05/in / i852 ] . lh and vv are funded by the national research foundation ( singapore ) and the ministry of education ( singapore ) .

we outline an interferometric scheme for the detection of bi - mode and multi - mode spatial entanglement of finite - temperature , interacting bose gases . whether entanglement is present in the gas depends on the existence of the single - particle reduced density matrix between different regions of space . we apply the scheme to the problem of a harmonically trapped repulsive boson pair and show that while entanglement is rapidly decreasing with temperature , a significant amount remains for all interaction strengths at zero temperature . thus , by tuning the interaction parameter , the distribution of entanglement between many spatial modes can be modified .

1304.4269

formulating strong - field transport in electron lattice has always been one of the most challenging theoretical goals in condensed matter physics @xcite . this is more true with today s advanced nano - lithography techniques where we can now realize electron lattice driven far from equilibrium . even though this is an old problem , we are still in search of a firm theoretical paradigm to approach the problem in general . one of the central puzzles is dissipation . in equilibrium , the presence of an open environment in contact with a system introduces thermalization , and once the temperature is defined , we often use canonical or grand canonical ensemble , and do not consider the coupling to the environment as an explicit parameter . we naturally ask whether such simplifying ansatz may be possible in nonequilibrium , at least for steady - state description . in nonequilibrium , we do not know such tremendously simplifying paradigms to take the role of the environment as an implicit parameter which can be hidden in thermalization process . on the contrary , the dissipation is considered as an integral part of the nonequilibrium process , and we need to include the dissipation mechanism explicitly for sound theoretical description . in some systems , however , the dissipation process can be simplified . in quantum dots ( qds ) under a finite dc bias , electron reservoirs coupled to the qd also act as energy source / drain and the energy relaxation is assumed to happen far away from qd and inside a battery . the electrical leads are then modeled as non - interacting reservoirs , and the electron transport is viewed as a transmission problem @xcite . by taking the open limit , the excess energy can be taken infinitely far away from the qd , and the problem supports steady - state @xcite . various quantum simulation methods have been proposed to study the transient behaviors of interacting models @xcite . in the limit where a steady - state exists , the nonequilibrium state can also be described within the time - independent statistical mechanics framework @xcite , from which hershfield @xcite proposed the nonequilibrium density matrix @xmath6,\ ] ] with the reservoir energy @xmath7 for the source ( @xmath8 ) and drain ( @xmath9 ) with the continuum index @xmath10 . @xmath11 is the creation operator of the full scattering state as the solution of the _ whole _ system of quantum dot and the leads . @xmath12 is the chemical potential of the respective reservoirs . the scattering state formulation , although conceptually appealing , has initially been applied only to limited models @xcite due to the difficulty of finding the scattering states . in recent years , several steady - state methods @xcite have been developed and have been extended to general models . recently , the attention of the field has turned to lattice nonequilbrium problems . even at a very stage of the field , there have been important findings in the nonequilbrium processes , most notably that electrons under a dc electric field seem to build up internal energy quite quickly , reaching a quite different steady - state from equilibrium strongly correlated states @xcite . one of the most popular technique of solving lattice many - body models has been the dynamical mean - field theory ( dmft ) @xcite . its success has been well documented in the description of the mott transition and strong - correlation physics in equilibrium . while there have been a fair amount of dmft works to electric - field driven lattice systems , the validity of the local approximation is still unconfirmed and subject to intense debate . there have been numerous attempts to simulate nonequilibrium physics in lattice models , often through isolated hamiltonians @xcite suited for quench dynamics of cold atom systems in optical lattice , periodically driven systems @xcite , and some basic dissipation models @xcite . however , in part due to the numerical difficulties in simulating long time - evolution , most of the efforts have focused on high - field phenomena such as the dielectric breakdown in mott insulators @xcite . the main emerging picture of the calculations is that the external field drives the electronic lattice systems into hot temperature , generally regardless of the nature of many - body interaction . even though the picture is in agreement between many groups , the detailed understanding of the nature of the hot electron state and its eventual fate in more realistic setting is not available . to gain systematic understanding of such nonequilibrium state , the dissipation should be included in explicit models and their analytic behavior has to be studied with the damping as a controlled parameter . one of the goals of this paper is to introduce steady - state formulation via scattering state method for lattice with fermion baths and comprehensively analyze the model to show that the system possesses many properties which are expected of physical systems , for instance , consistent picture as the boltzmann transport theory . in the process , an argument will be made that the fermion bath model and the steady - state methods are a good minimal system to study nonequilibrium strong correlation physics . in the previous paper @xcite by one of authors , the fermion bath model under a dc electric field has been shown to reproduce the key ingredients as predicted by the classical boltzmann transport theory , and to have a stead - state solution . the occupation number as a function of mechanical momentum has been shown to have the fermi sea shift by the drift velocity proportional to the scattering time and the electric field . furthermore , the dc current has been derived to be consistent with the boltzmann transport result applied to nanostructures @xcite . in this work , we further develop the solution to show that the scattering state formulation is applicable , and therefore a wide range of new techniques can be developed to solve the interacting lattice nonequilibrium phenomena . explicit calculations from temporal gauge and the coulomb gauge with scattering state formulation show that they are completely consistent with each other . the coulomb gauge enables the time - independent formalism , making physical interpretations more transparent . we calculate explicitly the local distribution function , from which we derive that the effective temperature scales as @xmath13 with a numerical constant @xmath1 , tight - binding parameter @xmath2 , the bloch oscillation frequency @xmath3 and the damping parameter @xmath4 . the effective temperature exhibits a singular limit of @xmath14 for @xmath5 . this proves that one should not take the damping as an implicit process , as treated in equilibrium theory . finally we derive , via the energy flux conservation with the joule heating , a general dc current relation as a functional of local green s functions as an extension of the meir - wingreen formula @xcite to lattice models , and confirm the linear response theory . the main text of the paper is organized as follows . in section ii , the method introduced in ref . is further developed for green s functions in the temporal gauge . in section iii , we introduce the coulomb gauge and show that the green s functions in both gauges become identical in the long - time limit . in section iii we further discuss several important nonequilibrium quantities : the local distribution function and the effective temperature in a , time - evolution of wave - packet in b , dissipation and energy flux in c , and finally the derivation of the dc current in interacting models in d. appendices provide detailed analytic calculations . to demonstrate the equivalence of the time - dependent temporal gauge to the scattering - state formalism with time - independent coulomb gauge , we start with the one - dimensional non - interacting model considered earlier @xcite . we study a quadratic model of a one - dimensional @xmath15-orbital tight - binding model connected to fermionic reservoirs ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) under a uniform electric field @xmath16 . the effect of the electric field for time @xmath17 is absorbed in the temporal gauge as the peierls phase @xmath18 in the hopping integral @xcite @xmath2 . here @xmath19 is the bloch oscillation frequency and @xmath20 is the step function . the time - dependent hamiltonian then reads @xmath21 with @xmath22 as the ( spinless ) electron operator on the tight - binding chain on site @xmath23 , @xmath24 with the reservoir fermion states connected to the site @xmath23 with the continuum index @xmath25 along each reservoir chain of length @xmath26 . the length @xmath26 is taken to infinity , and the time scale @xmath27 ( with fermi velocity of the chain @xmath28 ) for the wave to reach the end of the reservoir chain is considered larger than any other time scales in the problem . as discussed in ref . , the hamiltonian can be diagonalized in each @xmath10-sector as @xmath29 with @xmath30d^\dagger_kd_k+\sum_{\alpha}\epsilon_\alpha c^\dagger_{k\alpha}c_{k\alpha}\nonumber \\ & & -\frac{g}{\sqrt{l } } \sum_{\alpha}(c^\dagger_{k\alpha}d_k+{\rm h.c.}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the fermion operators fourier transformed to the wave - vector basis . here @xmath31 is the tight - binding dispersion at zero @xmath16-field . the reservoir states formed by @xmath32 acts as an open particle source with its chemical potential set at zero energy . the problem can be solved with @xmath33 as the unperturbed hamiltonian and @xmath34 as the time - dependent perturbation , @xmath35-\cos(k)\right\}d^\dagger_k d_k \equiv v(t)d^\dagger_k d_k.\label{eq : pert}\ ] ] this block - diagonal hamiltonian is nothing but a resonant level model coupled to a reservoir , with the level s energy oscillating in time @xcite . with the perturbation of one - body terms of a finite degrees of freedom , one can write the dyson s equation for the retarded and lesser green s functions as @xcite @xmath36{\bf g}_{k,0}^<[i+{\bf v}{\bf g}_k^a],\label{eq : glss}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath37 and @xmath38 are the lesser and retarded green s function matrices , respectively . @xmath39 and @xmath40 are for the non - interacting limit . the multiplication of green s function matrices denotes time integration . following ref . , the retarded green s function is @xmath41 with the damping parameter @xmath42 for reservoirs of flat density of states of infinite bandwidth . the local retarded green s function @xmath43 becomes @xmath44 with the zero - th bessel function @xmath45 . here , the gauge - invariant local function becomes a function of only the relative time , @xmath46 . fourier transformation with respect to the relative time gives @xmath47 by using the bessel function relation @xcite @xmath48 ^ 2e^{im\alpha}$ ] . the lesser green s function can be simplified in a straightforward calculation from eq . ( [ eq : glss ] ) following the similar procedures as in ref . in the long - time limit ( @xmath49 ) as @xmath50 where @xmath51 with the self - energy @xmath52 from the damping taken as the perturbation . although the above equation has been derived with the time - dependent peierls term eq . ( [ eq : pert ] ) as the perturbation , the same result can be obtained when the damping is considered as perturbation in the limit that transient terms die out . the local lesser green s function can be computed as @xmath53 , which again renders the green s function only dependent on the relative time . after changing the dummy variables @xmath54 and @xmath55 , we have @xmath56 with @xmath57\nonumber \\ & & \times \sin\frac{\omega s}{2}\sin\frac{\omega s'}{2}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] again by utilizing the bessel function relation @xcite @xmath58 @xmath59 with @xmath60 , the fermi - dirac function at zero temperature . from the identity @xcite , @xmath61 , @xmath62 although the two green s functions , eqs . ( [ eq : gtr ] ) and ( [ eq : gtlss ] ) , have been reduced to familiar forms resembling spectral representation , a clear relation between them is not available yet . in the following section , we discuss the scattering state formalism and find relations connecting the retarded and lesser green s functions . we have learned from ref . and the above calculations that the fermion bath model has a well - defined time - independent limit for gauge - invariant quantities such as local green s function . this observation and the presence of infinite reservoir states prompt us to consider scattering state formalism @xcite . as depicted in figs . [ fig2](a ) , for each site on the main chain there are infinite degrees of freedom coupled from each reservoirs . therefore , we can rewrite the quadratic hamiltonian in terms of the scattering states originating from the fermion reservoir chains @xcite . to adopt the time - independent scattering theory , we use the coulomb gauge as shown in fig . [ fig2](a ) with the hamiltonian , @xmath63 where the static coulomb potential is applied as a potential slope to the chain and each reservoirs with their chemical potential are raised together with the corresponding tight - binding sites . since the hamiltonian is quadratic and the chain is coupled to open systems , we can decompose the hamiltonian in terms of the scattering state operators @xmath64 originating from the asymptotic state @xmath24 as given by the lippmann - schwinger equation @xcite , @xmath65\nonumber \\ & = & c^\dagger_{\ell\alpha } -\frac{g}{\sqrt{l}}\frac{1}{\epsilon_\alpha-\ell\omega-{\cal l}+i\eta}d^\dagger_{\ell},\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the liouvillian operator @xmath66 $ ] for any operator and @xmath67 . the scattering state embodies the openness of the fermion reservoirs . as implemented by the infinitesimal imaginary poles given by @xmath68 , once the electrons scatter into a reservoir they _ never _ come back to the tight - binding chain . with the scattering state basis , the hamiltonian is rewritten as @xmath69 with the fermi statistics applied separately within each @xmath23-sector @xmath70 since the hamiltonian is quadratic , the scattering state operator @xmath64 is a linear combination of the original basis of @xmath71 and @xmath72 , and @xmath73 with the expansion coefficient for a fermion annihilation operator @xmath74 given as @xmath75 it is important to realize that , for a quadratic hamiltonian , the anti - commutation of operators in @xmath76 is just a c - number . in fact , this c - number is nothing but the retarded green s function @xmath77 between @xmath78 and @xmath22 . from this argument , the retarded green s function in any time - independent quadratic hamiltonian is _ independent of statistics_. note that the scattering state @xmath64 originating from the @xmath23-th reservoir has admixture from any reservoir states @xmath72 . here , we have put an over - line to denote the green s function in the coulomb gauge . we then have @xmath79 this equation can be inverted to express @xmath80 in terms of the scattering state basis @xmath81 as @xmath82 similarly as above , @xmath83 since the scattering state operators also satisfy the anti - commutation relation @xcite @xmath84 , and @xmath85 we will discuss below how @xmath86 is explicitly calculated . on - site retarded green s function at the central site @xmath87 can be expressed in terms of the scattering state basis as @xmath88^*}{\omega-\epsilon_\alpha+\ell\omega + i\eta}\nonumber \\ & & \times\langle\{\psi_{\ell\alpha},\psi^\dagger_{\ell'\alpha'}\}\rangle \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{g^2}{l}\sum_{\ell\alpha } \frac{|\overline{g}^r_{0\ell}(\epsilon_\alpha-\ell\omega)|^2 } { \omega-\epsilon_\alpha+\ell\omega+i\eta}. \label{eq : gwr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here the retarded green s functions appear on both sides of the equation , and its self - consistency will be examined below . the lesser green s function can be calculated similarly as @xmath89^ * \nonumber \\ & & \times\delta(\omega-\epsilon_\alpha+m\omega ) \langle \psi^\dagger_{m\alpha}\psi_{m\alpha}\rangle \nonumber \\ & = & 2i\gamma\sum_m \overline{g}^r_{\ell m}(\omega)[\overline{g}^r_{\ell ' m}(\omega)]^ * f(\omega+m\omega ) , \label{eq : gwlss}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where each reservoir has its own fermi energy shifted by @xmath90 and @xmath91 . the above expression is quite appealing and physically transparent . with the dissipation provided by the particle reservoirs , all electron statistics are governed by the fermi statistics of the reservoirs and the effective tunneling between site @xmath23 and the reservoir attached at site @xmath92 is given by the retarded green s function @xmath93 . it is noted that we use the infinite - band approximation for each fermion reservoirs so that any reservoir can provide electrons to any other tight - binding lattice sites in principle , and all possible thermal factors mix throughout the lattice . now , we turn to calculation of retarded green s functions . with the time - independent hamiltonian , we only need to invert the matrix as @xmath94_{\ell\ell'}$ ] with @xmath95_{\ell\ell'}=(\omega+\ell\omega+i\gamma)\delta_{\ell\ell ' } + \gamma\delta_{|\ell-\ell'|,1},\ ] ] where the retarded self - energy @xmath96 is attached to each site @xmath23 of the tight - binding lattice with the potential slope . solution to the matrix inversion can be found @xcite as @xmath97 which can be easily verified from @xmath98 . substituting this green s function into eq . ( [ eq : gwlss ] ) gives the identical result eq . ( [ eq : gtlss ] ) as derived from the time - dependent temporal gauge . coming back to the retarded green s function , we can easily confirm the identity eq . ( [ eq : gwr ] ) from a straightforward calculation after substituting eq . ( [ eq : grll ] ) into eq . ( [ eq : gwr ] ) and by using the contour integral and the completeness relation of bessel functions . from eq . ( [ eq : grll ] ) , it follows that @xmath99 from which eq . ( [ eq : gwlss ] ) satisfies @xmath100 in an interacting model , the self - energy is expressed in @xmath101 and inherits the same property , @xmath102 the discussion so far has demonstrated explicitly that the dissipative system with fermion baths can be described within the steady - state formalism using the scattering state basis . one of the central quantities to calculate is the effective local distribution function , @xmath103 where eq . ( [ eq : gwr ] ) has been used for @xmath104(a ) shows the numerical evaluation of the local distribution function @xmath105 . for @xmath106 , @xmath105 is a superposition of small steps coming from the thermal factors @xmath107 in eq . ( [ eq : floc ] ) with the envelope following a smooth profile similar to the fermi - dirac function . even though there is no reason to expect that the nonequilibrium distribution mimics the fermi - dirac function , we can nevertheless fit the result to the function with an effective temperature @xmath108 as shown , despite some deviation ( see appendix a for more details ) . as @xmath108 grows towards the finite tight - binding bandwidth @xmath109 , the fit becomes inaccurate . the envelope of the local distribution function plays a similar role of the fermi - dirac function which dictates the abundance of electron - hole pairs available for interaction . in the presence of additional many - body interactions such as the electron - phonon coupling to local optical phonons , the available electron - hole pairs for inelastic dissipation are given by the @xmath105 profile and the effective temperature @xmath108 in the fermi - dirac function will play the role of hot electron temperature effectively . it is remarkable that @xmath108 seems to approach infinity as the damping parameter @xmath4 becomes smaller . although it may look counter - intuitive at first , this is only the manifestation of the _ short - circuit _ behavior where a finite voltage applied across a low resistance conductor induces an extremely hot temperature . this is also consistent with the numerical calculations with the general conclusion that the electron temperature reaches an infinity in closed interacting models . numerical fit indicates that @xmath108 is an increasing function of @xmath110 for a wide range of @xmath111 , although the functional form eventually deviates from the form as shown in fig . [ fig3](b ) . for small @xmath110 , the effective temperature behaves as @xmath112 with a dimensionless numerical constant @xmath1 . this equation is one of the key results of this paper . in appendix a , we derive the above linear dependence of @xmath113 and approximately estimate that the constant @xmath114 by analyzing the @xmath115 step in @xmath116 . the effective temperature has been previously observed in the momentum distribution function and has been speculated @xcite to behave as @xmath117 based on the dc conductivity analogy . more careful and quantitative analysis now shows that the correct dependence is the above relation , eq . ( [ eq : teff ] ) . the @xmath108 relation is even further corroborated with @xmath1 derived from the kubo formula ( see appendix b and discussions in section iii.d . ) as the blue line in fig . [ fig3](b ) . the kubo formula result @xmath118 should be exact for the limit @xmath119 . the two analytical estimates bracket the numerical @xmath108 [ see fig . [ fig3](b ) ] , which shows that the expressions eqs . ( [ eq : teff ] ) and ( [ eq : teff2 ] ) are a reliable approximation for @xmath4 and @xmath3 up to @xmath2 . the divergent effective temperature should be taken with a caution to interpret in finite bandwidth systems . unlike with the quadratic dispersion relation for continuum models @xcite , the kinetic energy in the single - band tight - binding model is always bounded and thus can not give off extremely _ hot_-electrons to the environment . as @xmath3 and @xmath4 become comparable to the bandwidth [ see fig . [ fig3](c ) ] , the signature of bloch oscillation steps become more obvious and the definition of the effective temperature as determined by the shape of the overall @xmath105 is not very robust . while the infinite temperature in a finite bandwidth system may be questionable , the trend observed in fig . [ fig3](a - b ) continues . in the small damping limit at @xmath120 , even a population inversion happened in the local distribution function so far , we have seen that the steady - state formalism provides a convenient theoretical framework for nonequilibrium lattice model of fermion baths . to better understand the nonequilibrium steady - state , we now look at time - dependent quantity indicative of wave - packet drift . a steady - state by definition is a time - independent reference state where a direct observation of time - evolution of a moving particle can not be made . to confirm that an electric charge moves down the potential slope as a function of time , we create a hole out of occupied states @xcite at a central position and observe its movement to a different position @xmath121 as a function of time in @xmath122 the lesser green s function can be easily decomposed in terms of scattering states and fig . [ fig4 ] shows the wave - packet traveling in the direction of the applied field . amplitude of the observable decays as @xmath123 due to the dephasing of electrons from the fermion baths . as depicted in fig . [ fig2](b ) , electrons travel down the potential slope in the coulomb gauge by creating a trail of electron - hole ( e - h ) pairs in the reservoirs . as long as the bandwidth of the reservoirs is greater than the potential drop @xmath3 between neighboring sites ( we assumed that the bandwidth is infinite in explicit calculations ) , each reservoirs can accommodate an e - h pair with its energy matching @xmath3 by particle exchange via tunneling . for narrower reservoir bandwidths , multiple e - h pairs should be created to establish a dc current . since the open reservoirs are of infinite length , the created e - h pairs travel indefinitely inside the reservoirs and therefore the fermion baths can produce effects similar to the inelastic processes in bosonic baths . we discuss this further in the subsequent sections . we turn to discussions of energy dissipation . the hamiltonian , eq . ( [ eq : hcoul ] ) , can be divided into three parts as @xmath124 with each term representing each line in eq . ( [ eq : hcoul ] ) , respectively . in the steady - state limit , the energies stored in @xmath125 and @xmath126 are stationary @xmath127 , as will be demonstrated below . unlike the case with @xmath125 and @xmath126 which are of finite spatial extent , the energy flux in @xmath128 can be non - zero . in the scattering theory @xcite , the scattering states are formulated in the limit that the spatial extent of the scattered wave ( @xmath129 ) into the reservoirs is much shorter than the length of the reservoir chain ( @xmath130 ) . therefore the scattering state represents a solution that the scattered wave _ constantly propagating inside the reservoirs _ without being backscattered from the edge of the reservoirs , and quantities involving the extended states @xmath131 or @xmath132 do not have to be stationary in general @xcite . to be more concrete , we discuss explicit calculations . with the fermion baths , a dc electric - field establishes a dc current @xmath133 , as calculated in ref . . to investigate the effect of the joule heating , we consider @xmath125 @xmath134 \right\rangle \\ & = & \omega\langle \hat{j}\rangle + i\gamma g\sum_\ell\langle ( \bar{c}^\dagger_{\ell+1}+\bar{c}^\dagger_{\ell-1})d_\ell -{\rm h.c . } \rangle\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the current operator @xmath135 within the main chain and @xmath136 . we used the steady - state condition for the occupation @xmath137 . the first term represents the joule heating and the second term the energy flux of electrons from the kinetic energy of the main chain into the coupling @xmath126 . denoting the energy flux per site as @xmath138 , we show that @xmath139 . we present the detailed calculations in appendix c and show the equality of the above equation based on the scattering - state formalism . it can be shown further that @xmath140 . as shown in appendix b , the energy influx to each of the reservoirs is nothing but the joule heating @xmath141d\omega\nonumber \\ & = & \omega\langle j\rangle , \label{joule}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the local spectral function defined as @xmath142 the lowercase hamiltonian @xmath143 denotes the corresponding hamiltonian per tight - binding site . it might sound paradoxical that the energy in the electronic system is non stationary , @xmath144 ( here the last equality is from the steady - state current taken from ref . . ) this is due to the fact that , although @xmath145 governs the electron dynamics , there is another part of hamiltonian which should be included for a closed system the battery connected across the tight - binding chain . since the battery loses its stored charge @xmath146 with the rate of @xmath147 , the electrostatic energy decrease per unit cell of the tight - binding chain becomes @xmath148 , and the total energy @xmath149 is stationary in the steady - state . the discussion here again confirms the picture depicted in fig . [ fig2](b ) where the fermion baths act as energy reservoirs while the net electron number flux into the reservoirs is zero . despite their simplicity , the fermion baths through their particle - hole excitations play the role of bosonic baths , apart from the boson s explicit dispersion relation ( with the exception of the luttinger liquid bath ) and the physics that might occur from the nonlinear effect of the bosonic statistics . from the energy dissipation relations above , we obtain the useful formula for the steady - state current , @xmath150d\omega , \label{eq : current}\ ] ] where only on - site green s functions are needed as in meir - wingreen formula in quantum dot transport @xcite . to recover the ohm s law for small field that @xmath151 one should have that the integral goes as @xmath152 as the leading order . this is justified since applying a field of opposite direction @xmath153 should not change the local properties and the integral should be of order @xmath152 . this argument can be used to analyze the linear response limit , as described below . the above relation eq . ( [ eq : current ] ) , verified explicitly for the non - interacting model in appendix c , can be extended to interacting models . the key identities are steady - state conditions @xmath154 which we expect to hold generally for interacting systems as long as the interaction potential does not hold infinite amount of energy per site , as in hubbard model . here we used the spin index @xmath155 . with on - site interaction , @xmath156 ensures zero particle flux into the baths . the energy flux equation and the dysone equation hold as eq . ( [ app : bath ] ) and ( [ app : dyson ] ) , respectively . this immediately shows that the current , ( [ eq : current ] ) , holds for a wide range of interacting fermion bath models . steady - state current derived by meir - wingreen @xcite has been widely used in quantum dot calculations . the formula ( [ eq : current ] ) can be seen as its extension for lattice models with fermion baths . the equation is a functional of only local green s functions . however , it should be made clear that while the simplified meir - wingreen formula for a single quantum model only requires @xmath157 for the quantum dot , both of @xmath158 and @xmath159 are necessary in the lattice models . using the key equation ( [ eq : current ] ) , and eq . ( [ eq : teff ] ) in the non - interacting limit , a linear response limit can be analyzed . in the limit of @xmath119 , the effective temperature is expected to be small and , therefore , we can use the sommerfeld expansion @xcite to derive the linear electrical current @xmath160 and we obtain the linear dc conductivity @xmath161 here @xmath162 is the equilibrium spectral function evaluated at the fermi energy . with @xmath163 , @xmath164 and the scattering time @xmath165 , we recover the drude conductivity @xcite . comparing this with the linear response theory using the kubo formula , we obtain @xmath166 as detailed in appendix b. noting that @xmath167 , we have from eq . ( [ eq : cond ] ) that @xmath168 . this result is shown as the blue line in fig . [ fig3](b ) in comparison to the numerically obtained @xmath108 . in the interacting limit , the effective temperature expression eq . ( [ eq : teff ] ) should be modified . we expect that the same form @xmath169 holds with renormalized parameters @xmath170 , @xmath171 and @xmath172 . then the linear response equation becomes @xmath173 . in this work , we have reformulated the electron transport in tight - binding lattice driven by a dc electric field using both time - dependent and time - independent gauges . the time - independent coulomb gauge with fermion baths leads to the scattering state description for steady - state , which makes the calculation and interpretation more intuitive . nonequilibrium quantum statistics of quantum dot model , as proposed by hershfield @xcite , can be extended to nonequilibrium lattice as summarized in the scattering state expressions , @xmath174\\ \hat{h } & = & \sum_{\ell\alpha}(\epsilon_\alpha-\ell\omega)\psi^\dagger_{\ell\alpha } \psi_{\ell\alpha},\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the inverse temperature @xmath175 of the baths . the reservoir scattering states ( represented by @xmath176 ) are shifted by the applied electrostatic potential @xmath90 , and the chemical potential is simultaneously shifted with the electrostatic potential . therefore , the energy spectra governing the dynamics and statistics are different in the above expression . the formalism provides a natural framework for approximations such as the dynamical mean - field theory ( dmft ) . it has been shown that the fermion bath model , although quite rudimentary , produces dissipation mechanism consistent with the boltzmann transport theory . in particular , the steady - state effective temperature induced by the external field depends quite strongly on the electric field and the damping . the effective temperature becomes divergent as @xmath177 for small damping @xmath4 versus the bloch frequency @xmath19 ( @xmath74 is the lattice constant , and @xmath16 the electric field ) . although this might look surprising at first , this phenomenon is simply the manifestation of the short - circuit effect . it also verifies various numerical calculations with the infinite electron temperature resulting in isolated lattice models . these findings have fundamental implications in nonequilibrium quantum statistics in that dissipation processes can not be implicitly included as thermalization as in the boltzmann factor of equilibrium gibbsian statistics . through the energy dissipation and the joule heating in the fermion reservoirs , a general dc current relation eq . ( [ eq : current ] ) has been derived for interacting models , as an extension of the meir - wingreen formula to nonequilibrium lattice systems . the linear response limit has been confirmed within this formalism . despite the lack of momentum scattering and explicit inelastic processes , the generic features of the fermion bath model which are consistent with semi - classical theory are quite significant . furthermore , for its simplicity the fermion bath model can be used as an ideal building block for studying strong correlation effects in lattice driven out of equilibrium . particularly , with the time - independent coulomb gauge dmft can be readily formulated using the scattering state method @xcite it is well - known in equilibrium strong correlation physics that electrons undergo collective state when a strong interaction is present , with some emergent energy scale @xmath178 . one may speculate that an electric field of order @xmath179 would significantly alter the strongly correlated state . however , our study suggests that the dissipation strongly interplays with the nonequilibrium condition and non - trivial physics may arise even at @xmath180 . further systematic studies are necessary to understand the interplay of nonequilibrium and strong correlation effects . we thank helpful discussions with kwon park , woo - ram lee , jainendra jain , anthony leggett , natan andrei and gabi kotliar . this work has been financially supported by the national science foundation through grant no . dmr- 0907150 . here we analytically justify the relation @xmath181 by considering the low frequency steps as shown in fig . [ fig5 ] . the first step @xmath182 at @xmath115 can be expressed as @xmath183 \right\}^{-1}.\ ] ] here we look at the limit of small @xmath3 and approximate @xmath184 by the equilibrium green function @xmath185^{1/2}.\ ] ] therefore , the analytic expression for the slope of the fit becomes @xmath186 by equating this to the slope of the effective fermi - dirac function @xmath187 , we obtain @xmath188 note that while the actual numerical fit overestimates @xmath108 from the analytic expression due to the high - frequency contribution , the overall functional dependence is quite reliable for @xmath189 . from the kubo formula @xcite , the linear conductivity can be exactly calculated in the small @xmath3 limit . for convenience , we calculate the current - current correlation function in the imaginary - time formalism and then analytically continue to the real - frequency in the optical conductivity @xcite . for the uniform ( @xmath190 ) response function in the matsubara frequency @xmath191 , the conductivity is expressed as @xmath192 here @xmath193 is the group velocity and the matsubara green s function for the electron is given as @xmath194 with @xmath195 . performing the matsubara summation and then the analytic continuation @xmath196 for finite @xmath197 , we have @xmath198 taking its real part and the static limit @xmath199 at zero temperature , we obtain the dc linear conductivity @xmath200 with the restored constants @xmath201 and @xmath74 . the current expectation value measured at the site @xmath87 is expressed as @xmath202 . using the scattering state basis , we have @xmath203^ * \overline{g}^r_{0n}(\epsilon_\alpha - n\omega)f(\epsilon_\alpha ) \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{\gamma}{\pi}\sum_{nkk'}\int_{-\infty}^0 d\omega \frac{j_{1-k - n}j_{-k}j_{-k'-n}j_{-k'}}{(\omega+k\omega - i\gamma ) ( \omega+k'\omega+i\gamma ) } \nonumber \\ & = & -\frac{\gamma}{\pi}\sum_{k}\int_{-\infty}^0 \frac{j_{k}j_{k-1}d\omega } { ( \omega+k\omega - i\gamma ) [ \omega+(k-1)\omega+i\gamma]},\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] by using eq . ( [ eq : grll ] ) and the bessel function identities . we have suppressed the argument in the bessel functions . with integration of elementary functions we obtain @xmath204,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath205 . this immediately confirms that the current evaluated from the scattering state basis matches the result in ref . . for the operator @xmath206 we need to calculate @xmath207 . the @xmath208-operators are expressed with the scattering state basis as @xmath209^ * \psi^\dagger_{\ell'\alpha ' } } { \epsilon_{\alpha'}-\epsilon_\alpha-(\ell'-\ell)\omega - i\eta}\right].\ ] ] a lengthy but straightforward calculation gives @xmath210 which confirms the identity @xmath211 . for the energy flux into the fermion baths , we examine @xmath212\rangle\nonumber \\ & = & \frac{ig}{\sqrt{l}}\sum_{\ell\alpha}(\epsilon_\alpha-\ell\omega)\langle c^\dagger_{\ell\alpha}d_\ell - d^\dagger_\ell c_{\ell\alpha}\rangle . \label{app : bath}\end{aligned}\ ] ] first we show that @xmath213 . from the steady - state condition of @xmath214 , we have @xmath215\rangle = -\gamma\langle d^\dagger_{\ell + 1}d_\ell -d^\dagger_\ell d_{\ell + 1}+d^\dagger_{\ell -1}d_\ell -d^\dagger_\ell d_{\ell -1 } \rangle -\frac{g}{\sqrt{l}}\sum_\alpha \langle c^\dagger_{\ell\alpha}d_\ell - d^\dagger_\ell c_{\ell\alpha}\rangle = 0 $ ] . the first term is the total flux into the @xmath23-th site due to the current along the tb chain , and in the steady - state it is zero . therefore we have zero particle - flux into the reservoir , @xmath213 . the remaining summation @xmath216 is the energy flux measured with respect to the @xmath23-th reservoir chemical potential level and it should be independent of @xmath23 . setting @xmath87 , we can rewrite the expression as follows . consider @xmath217 and @xmath218 . for the energy flux per reservoir , we can write @xmath219\frac{d\omega}{2\pi}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the dyson s equation @xcite , @xmath220\ } \nonumber \\ & & = \frac{4\pi^2 g}{\sqrt{l}}\delta(\omega-\epsilon_\alpha ) a_{\rm loc}(\omega)[f_{\rm loc}(\omega)-f(\omega ) ] . \label{app : dyson}\end{aligned}\ ] ] then @xmath221d\omega.\ ] ] taking the time - derivative of the above green s functions at @xmath222 , we have from eq . ( [ app : dyson ] ) , @xmath223\right|_{t=0 } \nonumber \\ & & = 2\gamma\int\omega a_{\rm loc}(\omega)[f_{\rm loc}(\omega)-f(\omega)]d\omega=\langle \dot{\hat{h}}_{\rm bath}\rangle.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] this can be equated to @xmath224+[\hat{h}_{\rm coul},d^\dagger_0]c_{0\alpha}\rangle \nonumber \\ & = & -ig\gamma\langle \bar{c}^\dagger_0(d_{1}+d_{-1})-(d^\dagger_1+d^\dagger_{-1})\bar{c}_0\rangle \nonumber \\ & = & -ig\gamma\langle ( \bar{c}^\dagger_1+\bar{c}^\dagger_{-1})d_0-d^\dagger_0(\bar{c}_1+\bar{c}_{-1})\rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the translational invariance of the steady - state has been used . using eq . ( [ app : cd0 ] ) , eq . ( [ joule ] ) is confirmed .

electron transport in electric - field - driven tight - binding lattice coupled to fermion baths is comprehensively studied . we reformulate the problem by using the scattering state method within the coulomb gauge . calculations show that the formulation justifies direct access to the steady - state bypassing the time - transient calculations , which then makes the steady - state methods developed for quantum dot theories applicable to lattice models . we show that the effective temperature of the hot - electron induced by a dc electric field behaves as @xmath0 with a numerical constant @xmath1 , tight - binding parameter @xmath2 , the bloch oscillation frequency @xmath3 and the damping parameter @xmath4 . in the small damping limit @xmath5 , the steady - state has a singular property with the electron becoming extremely hot in an analogy to the short - circuit effect . this leads to the conclusion that the dissipation mechanism can not be considered as an implicit process , as treated in equilibrium theories . finally , using the energy flux relation , we derive a steady - state current for interacting models where only on - site green s functions are necessary .

gr-qc0701028

in 1988 , a new approach to the relativistic dynamics appeared . by an appropriate conformal ( 3 + 1 ) splitting of the schwarzschild spacetime , the so - called optical reference geometry was defined @xcite . it was demonstrated that this geometry enables us to define the inertial forces in the framework of general relativity , providing a description of test particle motion in accordance with our newtonian intuition @xcite , @xcite . later , the definition of the optical reference geometry and related inertial forces was generalized , extending its applicability to any spacetime @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite . the optical reference geometry was also thoroughly studied in particular spacetimes , such as schwarzschild - de sitter @xcite , @xcite , reissner - nordstrm @xcite , reissner - nordstrm - de sitter @xcite , kerr @xcite , @xcite or kerr - newman @xcite , illustrated by embedding diagrams @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and the inertial forces formalism was applied for solving specific problems in relativistic dynamics @xcite , @xcite . behaviour of the centrifugal force is closely related to the shape of embedding diagrams of the optical geometry , therefore many properties of the relativistic dynamics in the spacetimes were effectively illustrated and directly visualized . in the present work we extend our previous studies @xcite , @xcite to the case of the stationary and axially symmetric kerr - de sitter ( kds ) spacetimes , reflecting thus their basic properties incorporating a combined influence of the rotation of source and the cosmic repulsion , recently indicated by wide range of cosmological tests . it is worth to stress that the kds black - hole spacetimes could be important in understanding astrophysical phenomena exposed around supermassive black holes in giant active galactic nuclei as demonstrated in @xcite , @xcite . we show that the application of the inertial forces concept proves to be very effective and provides simpler and intuitive approach to some relativistic problems , as compared to the standard general relativistic methods . the standard methods based on the covariant formulation of physical laws in a given background ( geodesic equation , energy momentum conservation , etc . ) can be then replaced by the well developed methods familiar from newtonian physics when inertial forces related to the optical geometry are used , making a significant technical simplification in treating physical processes in curved backgrounds and enabling their interpretation in the newtonian way . thus the present paper could be also considered to be an introduction in developing a new approach to study astrophysical phenomena . we give some explicit examples how the analysis of the inertial forces could immediately and in a very simple way make an enlightenment of the properties of the circular motion of test particles and perfect fluid . the structure of the paper is similar to the previous study of the optical geometry of the kerr - newman spacetimes @xcite , whereas the content is more extensive , mainly in the parts concerning the inertial forces application in the relativistic dynamics . , we briefly present basic general definitions of the optical geometry and inertial forces , focusing on the stationary and axially symmetric spacetimes and circular motion . , kds geometry is introduced . although the properties of the kds spacetimes are well known , we briefly discuss them here again , in order to simply demonstrate the so - called chinese boxes method , used later in much more complicated cases for discussions of the properties of the inertial forces and embedding diagrams . , the inertial forces in the kds spacetimes are determined for general circular motion , and their properties are briefly discussed and thoroughly represented for the equatorial circular motion . , some examples of the relativistic dynamics are shown from the point of view of the inertial forces formalism . there are many interesting relativistic problems , which can be simply investigated by using the inertial forces formalism . we present such problems that have been studied by the standard general relativistic methods as well , in order to show immediately the effectiveness and simplicity of the inertial forces approach . namely the equatorial circular motion is studied , simply providing important findings for the test particle and photon circular motion @xcite , equatorial static radius and static equilibrium positions of test particles on the axis of symmetry @xcite . another astrophysically relevant application of the inertial forces formalism is demonstrated in deducing projection of the relativistic euler equation that allows determination of the perfect fluid equilibrium toroidal configurations @xcite . , the embedding diagrams of the equatorial plane of the optical reference geometry of kds spacetimes are discussed and constructed . the whole optical geometry can not be embeddable , therefore we discuss limits of embeddability . we establish relations between the shape of the embedding diagrams and the behaviour of the centrifugal force , investigating turning points of the diagrams . finally , the embeddability of photon circular orbits is discussed and typical embedding diagrams are constructed . , we summarize results of our investigation of the optical reference geometry formalism in the kds spacetimes , and compare them with results obtained for previously studied backgrounds . in stationary spacetimes described by a metric @xmath0 ( with signature + 2 ) , the definition of the optical reference geometry requires an introduction of family of special observers with a timelike , unit , and hypersurface orthogonal field @xmath1 and with its field equal to the gradient of a scalar function , i.e. , @xcite @xmath2}=0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] such a vector field can be chosen in the form @xmath3 whereas it corresponds to the unit field of stationary observers parallel to a timelike vector field @xmath4 . then the local instantaneous space of the observers is described by the metric @xmath5 the so - called _ directly projected geometry_. its conformally adjusted metric @xmath6 is the so - called _ optical reference geometry_. the @xmath7 of a test particle with a rest mass @xmath8 can be decomposed in the reference frame of the special observers with the @xmath1 by using the relation @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the unit spacelike vector parallel to the @xmath11 of the particle in the space and @xmath12 is the lorentz factor ( the speed of light @xmath13 ) . moreover , there is @xmath14 , @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is a projection tensor . note that the vector @xmath10 is defined only along the world line of the particle . but in our construction , it is necessary to know how @xmath10 changes along @xmath1 . this can be done in several different ways ( different gauges ) . the gauge used by m. abramowicz and his co - workers assures that the lie derivation of @xmath10 with respect to @xmath17 vanishes , i.e. , @xmath18 , which causes that the coriolis force defined below vanishes in static spacetimes @xcite . the @xmath19 of the particle can be written in the form @xmath20 where @xmath21 . by using the spacelike unit vector parallel to @xmath10 in the optical reference geometry , i.e. , the vector @xmath22 , its covariant form @xmath23 , the scalar @xmath24 , identity @xmath25 and condition of hypersurface orthogonality , the projection of the into the space can be written as @xmath26 where @xmath27 and @xmath28 . now , the inertial force in the space @xmath29 , related to the real force by the equation @xmath30 , can be decomposed into the sum of the gravitational @xmath31 , centrifugal @xmath32 , coriolis @xmath33 and euler @xmath34 forces familiar from the newtonian physics , i.e. , @xmath35 where @xmath36 note that in the context of the optical reference geometry approach , the gravitational force ranks among the inertial forces . in static and spherically symmetric spacetimes , the field ( [ 3 ] ) can be chosen with the vector being the timelike killing vector field @xmath37 , which is orthogonal to the spacelike azimuthal killing vector field @xmath38 . however , in stationary and axially symmetric spacetimes , the killing vector fields @xmath39 and @xmath40 are not orthogonal in general . thus the vector has to be chosen in order to satisfy the hypersurface orthogonality condition . it is easy to check that the vector field @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is hypersurface orthogonal and thus the field @xmath43,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which corresponds to the field of the locally non - rotating frames moving along circular orbits with the angular velocity @xmath44 , defines the special observers @xcite . since the vector field @xmath1 is hypersurface orthogonal , the unit vector @xmath10 , used in the decomposition ( [ 8 ] ) , must be located in the hypersurface . on the other hand , the @xmath45,\end{aligned}\ ] ] corresponding to the general circular motion of a test particle with an angular velocity @xmath46 , is not hypersurface orthogonal . moreover , the circular motion is directed along the killing vector @xmath40 , i.e. , @xmath47 then , by using expressions ( [ 8 ] ) and ( [ 31 ] ) , the lorentz factor and velocity are given by the relations @xmath48 and components of the inertial forces ( [ 13])-([16 ] ) are given by the relations @xmath49,\\ \label{37 } c_k = m\gamma^2v\,(\xi^i\xi_i)^{-3/2}e^{-\phi}[\xi^i\xi_i\nabla_{k}{(\eta^i\xi_i)}-\eta^i\xi_i\nabla_k{(\xi^i\xi_i)}],\\ \label{38 } e_k = m\,e^{\phi}\gamma^3 u^i\nabla_i(v ) \tilde{\tau}_k.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the newtonian character of the inertial forces formalism appears after introducing the quantities @xmath50 where @xmath51 is angular velocity relative to the lnrf . then we can write @xmath52 and the inertial forces ( [ 35])-([38 ] ) can be rewritten to the form @xmath53 the quantity @xmath54 corresponds to the so - called radius of gyration , defined by the relation @xmath55 generalizing in a special way its definition introduced and discussed for the static schwarzschild spacetimes in @xcite , @xcite . the quantity @xmath56 is the conserved specific angular momentum and @xmath57 is a scalar called pseudo - energy of the particle . since the vector field @xmath4 is not a killing vector field , such pseudo - energy is not conserved in general stationary and axially symmetric spacetimes . of course , in the static spacetimes , @xmath58 is conserved , being defined in the standard way as @xmath59 . the radius of gyration plays an important role in the theory of rotational effects in strong gravitational fields . the direction of increasing radius of gyration gives a preferred determination of the local outward direction relevant for the dynamical effects of rotation , whereas the direction becomes misaligned with the global outward direction in strong fields @xcite . in the standard boyer - lindquist coordinates @xmath60 and geometric units @xmath61 , the line element of the kds geometry is given by the relation @xmath62 ^ 2+\nonumber\\ \frac{\rho^2}{\delta_r}dr^2+\frac{\rho^2}{\delta_{\theta}}d\theta^2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath63 the mass @xmath64 , specific angular momentum @xmath65 , and cosmological constant @xmath66 are parameters of the spacetime . it is convenient to introduce a dimensionless cosmological parameter @xmath67 for simplicity , we put @xmath68 hereafter . equivalently , also the coordinates @xmath69 , @xmath70 , the line element @xmath71 , and the parameter @xmath65 are expressed in units of @xmath64 and become dimensionless . the kds spacetimes , being stationary and axially symmetric , admit both the killing vector fields @xmath39 and @xmath40 , whereas @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 . the only intrinsic singularity of the kds solution is the ring singularity in the equatorial plane and it is given by the relation @xmath75 . stationary regions of the spacetimes are determined by the relation @xmath76 and limited by the inner and outer black - hole horizons at @xmath77 and @xmath78 and by the cosmological horizon at @xmath79 , which are real roots of the equation @xmath80 . then spacetimes containing three horizons are black - hole spacetimes , while spacetimes containing one horizon ( the cosmological horizon exists for any choice of the spacetime parameters ) are naked - singularity spacetimes . spacetimes with two horizons are extreme black - hole or extreme naked - singularity spacetimes @xcite . in order to obtain the number of horizons in dependence on the rotational and cosmological parameters @xmath81 and @xmath82 , we use the chinese boxes technique that will be used later in more complex discussions of the properties of the inertial forces and embedding diagrams . in the kds spacetimes , functions of the radius and two spacetime parameters are usually considered , and the routine is realized in two steps . a property of a function can be examined by investigation of properties of another function of the radius and of the lower number of parameters , i.e. , of the only spacetime parameter . these properties of the function can be examined by investigation of properties of other functions , but now , functions of the radius only . thus the properties of these functions can be determined by using a common way of investigation of functions dependent on one variable . finally , the kds spacetimes can be classified according to the initial property of the initial function . in this case , it follows from the relation @xmath80 that for given @xmath81 and @xmath83 ( repulsive cosmological constant ) , the loci of horizons are given by solutions of the equation @xmath84 the reality condition @xmath85 can be then rewritten in the form @xmath86 the asymptotic behaviour of the function @xmath87 is given by @xmath88 and @xmath89 . the local extrema of @xmath87 are determined ( due to the condition @xmath90 ) by the relation @xmath91 the maximum of the function @xmath92 is located at @xmath93 and takes the value @xmath94 ( see figure [ fig:1]a ) . we can distinguish three different types of behaviour of @xmath87 ( see figure [ fig:1]c ) . * for @xmath95 , @xmath87 has two local extrema @xmath96 and @xmath97 determined by relations ( [ 54 ] ) and ( [ 58 ] ) ( see figure [ fig:1]b ) . the black - hole spacetimes exist for @xmath98 and @xmath83 , while the naked - singularity spacetimes exist for @xmath99 or @xmath100 . * for @xmath101 , the extrema @xmath96 and @xmath97 coincide at @xmath102 , which is the limiting value for the black - hole spacetimes . * for @xmath103 , @xmath87 has no extrema and there are only the naked - singularity spacetimes for any positive value of @xmath82 . the parameter plane @xmath104 separated by the functions @xmath96 and @xmath97 into the regions corresponding to the black - hole and naked - singularity spacetimes is illustrated in figure [ fig:1]d . assuming a test particle circular motion with the ( [ 31 ] ) at a fixed radius and latitude in the reference frame @xmath105 in the stationary and axially symmetric kds spacetimes , there are always zero time and azimuthal components of the gravitational , centrifugal and coriolis forces ( [ 35])-([37 ] ) , and zero radial and latitudinal components of the euler force ( [ 38 ] ) . the centrifugal , coriolis and euler forces vanish for @xmath106 and moreover , the euler force also vanishes in the case of the uniform motion @xmath107 . however , due to the behaviour of the velocity independent parts of the forces , they can vanish ( and change their sign ) at some radii and latitudes independently of the velocity . the same can happen for the gravitational force which is velocity independent by definition . note that we pay no more attention to the euler force , because of its vanishing in the case of the uniform motion considered in the following . then it is convenient to rewrite the inertial forces to the form @xmath108 whereas the non - vanishing velocity independent parts of the accelerations are given by the relations @xmath109 @xmath110}{\mathcal{d}\delta_r\rho^2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath111\sqrt{\delta_r\delta_{\theta}}}{\mathcal{d}\delta_r\rho^2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath112 @xmath113}{\mathcal{d}\delta_{\theta}\rho^2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath114 where @xmath115 the presented components of the accelerations are considered to be functions of two variables @xmath70 and @xmath116 , and two spacetime parameters @xmath81 and @xmath82 . there is @xmath117 and @xmath118 for all the values of @xmath70 and @xmath116 . thus the functions are well defined throughout the stationary regions . the functions diverge at the radii of event horizons and in the ring singularity in the equatorial plane . moreover , the latitudinal component of the velocity independent part of the centrifugal acceleration diverges at the axis of symmetry ( @xmath119 ) . in the case of the equatorial motion ( @xmath120 ) , latitudinal components of all the forces vanish . for given values of the rotational and cosmological parameters @xmath81 and @xmath83 , the radii of circular orbits where the velocity independent parts of the radial components of the gravitational , centrifugal and coriolis accelerations , i.e. , @xmath121 , @xmath122 and @xmath123 , vanish are given by zero points of the numerators of relations ( [ 61])-([63 ] ) , provided that @xmath124 because of the reality condition . it is immediately clear from relation ( [ 63 ] ) that @xmath123 does not vanish at all . moreover , since the zero points of the functions @xmath121 and @xmath122 enable changes of their sign , the gravitational and centrifugal forces also can change their orientation on such orbits . detailed discussion of vanishing of the functions @xmath121 and @xmath122 is given in @xcite , @xcite . here we present only an updated summary of the results . the radii of circular orbits where @xmath122 vanishes are closely related to embedding diagrams of the equatorial plane of the optical geometry and will be discussed in more details . there are one class of the kds black - hole spacetimes and five classes of the naked - singularity spacetimes differing in the number of circular orbits where @xmath121 vanishes and orbits where @xmath122 vanishes ( see figure [ fig:2 ] ) . examples of different types of behaviour of the functions are illustrated in figure [ fig:3 ] . in few examples we show how the results obtained by relatively complex standard general relativistic methods could be easily and straightforwardly obtained in the framework of the inertial forces approach . therefore we believe that the method of inertial forces , combined with standard approaches , could bring in an effective way some new results in modelling accretion disks . acceleration necessary to keep a particle in an uniform circular motion in the equatorial plane ( @xmath120 ) can be expressed due to relation ( [ 12 ] ) in the simple form @xcite , @xcite @xmath125 where @xmath126 , while @xmath127 . this equation enables an effective discussion of the properties of both accelerated and geodesic motions . remind that there are only radial components of the inertial forces non - vanishing and @xmath128 in the equatorial plane . for ultrarelativistic particles ( @xmath129 ) we obtain from equation ( [ 63a ] ) the asymptotic equation @xmath130 for photons ( @xmath131 ) we obtain the circular geodesic motion determined by the equation @xmath132 where the upper signs correspond to the corotating motion ( @xmath133 ) and the lower signs to the counterrotating motion ( @xmath134 ) . solving the equivalent equation @xmath135 , we directly obtain the relation for the photon circular orbits in the kds spacetimes @xcite @xmath136 this equation will be discussed carefully in in a relation with embedding diagrams of the optical geometry . the ultrarelativistic particles moving along the circular orbit at the radius of the photon circular orbits are kept by the acceleration @xmath137 [ 63d ] which is velocity independent with an accuracy @xmath138 . in static spacetimes , there is @xmath139 , and at the radius of the photon circular orbit the acceleration of particles is @xmath140 and it is velocity independent exactly . relation ( [ 63e ] ) is not limited to the case of ultrarelativistic particles , because @xmath141 at the radius of the photon circular orbit in static spacetimes . velocities of particles moving along equatorial circular geodesics are due to relations ( [ 63a ] ) and @xmath142 determined by the expression @xmath143^{1/2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is clear that for the geodesical circular motion at a fixed radius , the condition @xmath144 must be satisfied . in the equatorial plane of the kds spacetimes , this condition directly implies the relation @xmath145 giving the limitation for the circular geodesics in the form @xmath146 , i.e. , we immediately obtain the limit given by the so - called static radius @xcite . in static spacetimes , where @xmath139 , the reality condition for the geodesics is @xmath147 , i.e. , the gravitational and centrifugal forces must point in opposite directions . a test particle is thought to be in a static equilibrium position , if it is at the rest relative to the reference coordinate system , i.e. , @xmath148 , @xmath149 and @xmath150 , whereas its worldline is a geodesic , which means @xmath151 . it is equivalent to the circular geodesical motion at a fixed radius and latitude , with @xmath152 , i.e. , @xmath153 defining @xmath154 , we obtain two equilibrium conditions @xmath155 that have to be satisfied simultaneously . in the equatorial plane ( @xmath120 ) , condition ( [ 65b ] ) is automatically satisfied because of the vanishing of latitudinal components of all the forces . by using relations , condition ( [ 65a ] ) implies the equation @xmath156 i.e. , the static equilibrium positions in the equatorial plane are really located at the static radius @xmath157 . on the symmetry axis ( @xmath119 ) , condition ( [ 65b ] ) is also automatically satisfied and condition ( [ 65a ] ) implies the equation @xmath158 implicitly determining the static radii on the axis of symmetry derived in a standard way and discussed in @xcite . by projecting the conservation laws @xmath159 , where is the stress - energy tensor for the perfect fluid , into the space of the special observers ( [ 3 ] ) by using the projection tensor @xmath160 , and by using the condition @xmath161 we arrive at the equation @xmath162 assuming now a circular motion of the baryotropic fluid , i.e. , body with the equation of state @xmath163 and @xmath164 , in the axially symmetric spacetimes , i.e. , the vector @xmath10 and velocity @xmath165 given by relations ( [ 32 ] ) and ( [ 33 ] ) , and @xmath1 given by relation ( [ 30 ] ) , we arrive at the relativistic euler equation in terms of the inertial forces in the newtonian form @xmath166 of course , here , there are the only radial and latitudinal components of the inertial force non - vanishing . then , in the case of the uniform distribution of the specific angular momentum , the integration of equation ( [ b5 ] ) directly implies the equipressure surfaces , determined by the relation @xmath167^{1/2}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] derived in a standard way in @xcite properties of the optical reference geometry can be represented by the embedding of the equatorial plane into the euclidean space with the line element expressed in the cylindrical coordinates @xmath168 in the form @xmath169 it should be stressed that such embedding diagrams are very useful in a representation of some properties of the spacetime relevant in astrophysically important situations ; especially behaviour of the centrifugal force , directly demonstrated by the embedding of the optical reference geometry , is crucial for understanding the equilibrium configurations of perfect fluid important in modelling accretion discs . here , we shall follow the method developed in the case of kerr - newman geometry in @xcite . the embedding diagram is characterized by the embedding formula @xmath170 determining a surface in the euclidean space with the line element @xmath171d\rho^2+\rho^2d\alpha^2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] isometric to the equatorial plane of the optical space determined by the line element @xmath172 where the metric coefficients of the optical geometry in the kds background are given by the relations @xmath173}{\delta_r^2},\\ \label{4f } \tilde{h}_{\phi\phi}=\frac{[r^3+a^4ry+a^2(2+r+r^3y)]^2}{r^2\delta_r}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the azimuthal coordinates can be identified ( @xmath174 ) and we can put @xmath175 . thus the differential form of the embedding formula is governed by the relation @xmath176 it is convenient to transfer it into the parametric form @xmath177 with @xmath70 being the parameter , i.e. , @xmath178 whereas the sign in this formula is irrelevant , leading to isometric surfaces @xcite . using the relation @xmath175 and the metric coefficients ( [ 4e ] ) and ( [ 4f ] ) , we obtain the differential form of the embedding formula @xmath179 where @xmath180 and @xmath181,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath182,\\ d = r^2\{r^{10}+a^2r^6(3r^2 + 2r-18)+a^4r^3[r(3r^2 - 4r-16)+36]+\\\nonumber a^6r[r(r^2 - 14r-18)+60]-4a^8(2r+5)\},\\ e=4a^8 - 4a^6r[r(r-3)+6]-3a^4(r-2)r^2[r(4r-3)+6]-\\\nonumber 2a^2r^5[r(6r-17)+18]+(9 - 4r)r^8.\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the differential form of the embedding formula ( [ 7e ] ) , it is clear that due to the condition @xmath183 , the equatorial plane of the optical geometry is not entirely embeddable into the 3-dimensional euclidean space . the embeddable regions are determined by the condition @xmath184 , whereas the equality in this relation determines the limits of embeddability . the equation @xmath185 implicitly defines two functions @xmath186 , whereas @xmath187 for all values of @xmath81 and @xmath70 . instead of giving long explicit expressions for the functions @xmath186 , we only present their properties and examples of different types of their behaviour ( see figures [ fig:4 ] and [ fig:5 ] ) . for given values of @xmath81 and @xmath82 , the limits of embeddability are determined by solutions of the equations @xmath188 because of the reality condition @xmath85 and the repulsive cosmological constant , the solutions are restricted by the condition @xmath189 thus the embeddable regions are given by the condition @xmath190 and @xmath191 . the zero points of the functions @xmath186 are determined by the condition @xmath192 ( see equation ( [ 8e ] ) ) , i.e. , by solutions the equation @xmath193 - 3a^4(r-2)r^2[r(4r-3)+6]-\nonumber\\ 2a^2r^5[r(6r-17)+18]+(9 - 4r)r^8=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] implicitly defining functions @xmath194 . the function @xmath195 has two local maxima @xmath196 and @xmath197 located at @xmath198 and at @xmath199 . there is also one local minimum @xmath200 located at @xmath201 . on the other hand , the function @xmath202 has no local extrema . the number of solutions of equation ( [ 10e ] ) depends on the number of extrema of the functions @xmath203 . they are governed by the functions @xmath204 and @xmath205 , which are defined implicitly by eliminating @xmath82 from the equations @xmath185 and @xmath206 . since these expressions are too large to be presented here , we only show behaviour of the functions @xmath204 and @xmath205 ( see figure [ fig:4 ] ) . the function @xmath204 is identical with the function @xmath92 ( see relation ( [ 58 ] ) ) governing the extrema of the function @xmath87 . thus two extrema of @xmath186 coalesce with two extrema of @xmath87 . these two extrema are the only common points of @xmath186 and @xmath87 , and there is @xmath207 except these points . the maximum of the function @xmath204 takes the value @xmath208 and is located at @xmath93 . the common point of @xmath204 and @xmath195 coalesces with the local minimum of @xmath195 and divides the function @xmath204 into two parts governing positive ( relevant for the classification ) and negative ( irrelevant ) extrema of @xmath186 . the function @xmath209 has local maximum @xmath210 located at @xmath211 and local minimum @xmath212 located at @xmath213 . two of three common points of @xmath209 and @xmath195 coalesce with local maxima of @xmath195 and divide the function @xmath209 into parts governing positive and negative extrema of @xmath186 . the function @xmath214 completely governs negative local extrema of @xmath186 , which we do not consider here . all the characteristic functions @xmath194 , @xmath215 and @xmath216 are illustrated in figure [ fig:4 ] . these functions enable us to understand the behaviour of the functions @xmath186 and classify the kds spacetimes according to the number of embeddable regions . ( closely dotted ) governing zeros of the function @xmath186 ; @xmath204 ( dashed - dotted ) and @xmath205 ( solid ) governing extrema of @xmath186 ; @xmath217 ( dotted ) governing zeros of the function @xmath218 ; @xmath219 ( dashed ) governing extrema of @xmath220 . the thick parts of the dashed - dotted and solid curves govern positive extrema of @xmath186 . in the parameter line @xmath221 of the spacetimes , the extrema and common points of the characteristic functions separate regions corresponding to different types of the behaviour of @xmath186 ( see figure [ fig:5 ] ) . ] in general , the plasticity of the embedding diagrams is characterized by the different steepness and by the turning points of the diagrams . clearly , the turning points of the embedding diagrams , i.e. , their bellies and throats , are determined by the relation because of the relation @xmath222 we have the condition @xmath223 . due to relations ( [ 7 ] ) , ( [ 41 ] ) and @xmath175 , we can write @xmath224 . considering relation ( [ 36a ] ) , it is clear that the turning points of the embedding diagrams are located at the radii where the velocity independent part of the centrifugal acceleration vanishes . since there is @xmath225y+\nonumber\\ r^4(r-3)+ra^2[r(r-3)+6]-2a^4\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] then for given values @xmath81 and @xmath82 , the radii of turning points of the embedding diagrams are given by solutions of the equation @xmath226}\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] restricted by the condition @xmath227 the zero points of the function @xmath218 are determined by solutions of the equation @xmath228 - 2a^4=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which we consider as an implicit form of the functions @xmath217 . the maximum of this function takes the value @xmath229 located at @xmath230 . the number of solutions of equation ( [ 15e ] ) depends on the number of the extrema of the function @xmath218 . they are determined by solutions of the equation @xmath231}\}^{-1}\times\nonumber\\ \{r[12a^8+r(48r+1)a^6 + 3r^3(24r+1)a^4 + 3r^5(16r+1)a^2+\nonumber\\ 3r^7(4r+3)]a^2\}-5a^4 - 12r^2a^2 - 3r^4=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which we consider as an implicit form of the functions @xmath219 with the maximum @xmath232 located at @xmath233 . the characteristic functions @xmath219 and @xmath217 are illustrated in figure [ fig:4 ] and enable us to understand the behaviour of the functions @xmath220 and classify the kds spacetimes according to the number of turning points of the embedding diagrams . the number of embeddable regions and turning points of the embedding diagrams is determined by the number of solutions of equations ( [ 10e ] ) and ( [ 15e ] ) , which depends on the number of extrema of the functions @xmath186 and @xmath218 . therefore we denote @xmath234 as the only maximum of @xmath235 which becomes positive ( relevant for the classification ) for some values of @xmath81 and @xmath70 , @xmath236 , @xmath237 as the extrema of @xmath238 coalescent with the minimum and maximum of the function @xmath87 ; @xmath239 , @xmath240 as the remaining two extrema of @xmath238 . finally we denote @xmath241 and @xmath242 as the minimum and maximum of the function @xmath218 . using the characteristic functions @xmath219 , @xmath217 , @xmath194 , @xmath204 and @xmath205 , we can distinguish different types of behaviour of the functions @xmath186 and @xmath220 differing in the number of their extrema satisfying the condition @xmath243 ( see figure [ fig:5 ] ) . the different types of the kds spacetimes obtained this way are shown in table [ tab:1 ] . ( solid ) limiting embeddable regions ( white ) ; @xmath218 ( dashed ) determining turning points of embedding diagrams ; @xmath87 ( dashed - dotted ) determining locations of event horizons and limiting the dynamic regions ( gray ) . for illustration , the behaviour of the function @xmath244 ( dotted ) governing radii of photon circular orbits is also given . for given @xmath81 and @xmath83 , limits of embeddability are determined by solutions of @xmath203 that satisfy the condition @xmath124 . turning points of the embedding diagrams are determined by solutions of @xmath245 and embeddable photon circular orbits by solutions of @xmath246 , whereas the solutions must satisfy the embeddability condition @xmath247 . in the parameter line ( @xmath82 ) of the kds spacetimes , extrema of @xmath186 and @xmath218 separate regions corresponding to different classes of the spacetimes differing in the number of embeddable regions ( first digit ) and turning points of the embedding diagrams ( second digit ) . note that in the case of the classes ns12 and ns22 , the second digits exceptionally denote one turning point and one inflexion point of the diagrams . ] .[tab:1 ] different types of the kds spacetimes determined by corresponding different types of behaviour of the functions @xmath186 and @xmath220 . the number of extrema @xmath236 , @xmath237 , @xmath239 , @xmath240 , @xmath234 , @xmath241 and @xmath242 of the functions @xmath186 and @xmath220 satisfying the condition @xmath243 are subsequently expressed by the digits in the last column . the types ea , eb and ec differ in the relation among the values of extrema @xmath237 , @xmath239 and @xmath240 and the types fa and fb differ in the relation among the values of extrema @xmath239 and @xmath242 . [ cols= " < , < , < " , ] we can summarize that * kds black - hole spacetimes contain three or two separated embeddable regions in contrast to the kerr black - hole spacetimes , where only two regions occur , and to the sds and schwarzschild black - hole spacetimes with the only embeddable region . * kds naked - singularity spacetimes contain one , two or three separated embeddable regions as well as the kerr naked - singularity spacetimes . * kds black - hole embedding diagrams contain two turning points as well as the kerr black - hole diagrams . but the sds and schwarzschild black - hole embedding diagrams contain one turning point , coalescing with the radius of the circular orbit where the centrifugal force vanishes independently of the velocity , i.e. , with the radius @xmath248 . * kds naked - singularity embedding diagrams contain one , two or three turning points as well as the kerr naked - singularity diagrams . * kds black - hole spacetimes contain three photon circular orbits , whereas two of them occur in the outer stationary region and one of them in the inner one , as well as in the kerr black - hole spacetimes , but in contrast to the sds and schwarzschild black - hole spacetimes , where only one photon orbit occurs at the radius @xmath248 . * kds naked - singularity spacetimes contain one photon circular orbit as well as the kerr naked - singularity spacetimes . * kds black - hole spacetimes contain two , one or none embeddable photon circular orbits in the outer stationary region in contrast to the kerr black - hole spacetimes , where always two or one embeddable orbits exist , and to the sds and schwarzschild black - hole spacetimes , where always one embeddable orbit occurs at the radius coalescing with the radius of turning point of the embedding diagram . * kds naked - singularity spacetimes contain one or none embeddable photon circular orbit in contrast to the kerr naked - singularity spacetimes , where always one embeddable orbit occurs . + + both the presented parts of the investigation of optical reference geometry formalism and related classification of the kds spacetimes can be consider to be the basic and necessary study , before the formalism is applied in the dynamics . by using some particular examples of the particle and fluid orbital motion , we have just directly demonstrated that the optical reference geometry and related inertial forces formalism presents certain , we can say pseudo - newtonian approach in relativistic dynamics . this approach is based on the newtonian way of dynamics description , but taking the general relativistic effects fully into account . now , we can state that the simplicity and applicability of the formalism , which were only predicted in a general way in some papers ( e.g. @xcite ) or directly shown , but only for the simpler types of spacetimes , survive even in the complex types of the kds spacetimes , where its application is then more useful all the more just because of the complexity of the spacetimes . in spite of the more or less technical aspect of the paper , the study can be reviewed from the astrophysical point of view as well . we have shown that the combined effect of rotation and cosmic repulsion is relevant in both the cases of black - hole and naked - singularity backgrounds . clearly , choosing a characteristic type of motion and knowing the related behaviour of the forces , we can understand the influence of the rotational and cosmic parameters . of course , there are many astrophysical and conceptual reasons to choose the circular motion , as we have done . among others , comparing the results for the kerr and kds spacetimes , the additional radius in the kds spacetimes , where the gravitational force vanishes , the same number of circular orbits where the centrifugal force vanishes and qualitatively same types of behaviour of embedding diagrams suggest that the influence of the cosmological constant is fundamentally imprinted mainly in the gravitational force . note that it was predicted in @xcite , by comparing the behaviour of the gravitational force in the sds and schwarzschild spacetimes ( see tables [ tab:5 ] and [ tab:6 ] ) . one of the important new results concerns properties of the so - called static radii , where the gravitational attraction of a black hole ( naked singularity ) is just balanced by the cosmic repulsion . we have found that in the equatorial plane the location of the static radius @xmath249 is independent of the rotational parameter @xmath65 , and formally coincides with the results from the sds black - hole spacetimes , while on the axis of symmetry it depends on @xmath65 . physically , it is important that these results are easily implied by the analysis of the behaviour of the inertial forces . from the physical point of view , the most important new result is given by the possibility to derive the euler equation easily in the framework of optical geometry and related inertial forces as shown in section 3 . it enables us to treat behaviour of perfect fluid orbiting black holes , and in general all the accretion processes , in the pseudo - newtonian way related to the inertial forces . we believe the pseudo - newtonian approach could be useful in modelling self - graviting discs around sds and kds black - holes . it should be noticed in this connection that character of the centrifugal force , which is relevant in determining the structure of thick discs , is clearly reflected by the embedding diagrams of the optical geometry ( see @xcite ) . thus we can state , we dispose an alternative method to the standard general relativistic approach , practically and intuitively applicable in the kds spacetimes , and hence suitable for the description of astrophysical phenomena around supermassive black holes in centre of giant active galactic nuclei . this work was supported by the czech grant msm 4781305903 .

optical reference geometry and related concept of inertial forces are investigated in kerr - de sitter spacetimes . properties of the inertial forces are summarized and their typical behaviour is illustrated . the intuitive newtonian application of the forces in the relativistic dynamics is demonstrated in the case of the test particle circular motion , static equilibrium positions and perfect fluid toroidal configurations . features of the optical geometry are illustrated by the embedding diagrams of its equatorial plane . the embedding diagrams do not cover whole the stationary regions of the spacetimes , therefore the limits of embeddability are established . a shape of the embedding diagrams is related to the behaviour of the centrifugal force and it is characterized by the number of turning points of the diagrams . discussion of the number of embeddable photon circular orbits is also included and the typical embedding diagrams are constructed . the kerr - de sitter spacetimes are classified according to the properties of the inertial forces and embedding diagrams .

1304.2966

new near - ir luminescence , quite different from much - studied bi@xmath2-related luminescence @xcite , was discovered in 2001 in bismuth - doped aluminosilicate glass @xcite . then optical amplification at 1.3 m was demonstrated @xcite . ever since bismuth - doped glasses and optical fibers based on such glasses attract a considerable interest due to a broadband ir luminescence in the range of 1.0 1.7 m employed successfully in fiber lasers and amplifiers ( see e.g. the review @xcite ) . although the origin of the ir luminescence is still not clear , recently a belief has been strengthened that subvalent bismuth centers are responsible for the luminescence @xcite . in our opinion , monovalent bismuth centers are of a particular interest . glasses as disordered systems are very complicated to study impurity centers structure . in this regard , crystals may be of interest as model hosts containing bismuth - related centers . in particular , crystalline halides of monovalent metals are convenient hosts for monovalent bismuth centers . these crystals have a simple structure ( primitive , , or face - centered , , cubic lattice ) . bismuth can easily form monovalent substitutional centers in such lattice . similar subvalent thallium and lead centers in crystals were studied extensively ( e.g. thallium in @xcite and lead in , m@xmath3ca , sr , ba @xcite ) . by analogy , the models of bismuth - related centers in oxide glasses for fiber optics were suggested @xcite . bismuth - related ir luminescence in cubic halide crystals was studied for the first time in @xcite , then in ( ) @xcite and recently in ( ) @xcite . two models of the centers in were suggested in @xcite , namely , a monovalent bismuth substitutional center , @xmath0 , and a dimer center , @xmath1 , formed by two @xmath0 substitutional centers in the nearest cation sites with an extra electron . in what follows we report the results of computer modeling of bismuth - related centers in and crystals . to study the origin of the ir luminescence in and , we performed a computer simulation of the structure and absorption spectra of three bismuth - related centers possibly occurring in both crystals . basing on the assumptions made in @xcite and on analogy with centers in alkaline halide crystals ( see e.g. @xcite ) , we studied the @xmath0 substitutional center as the main form of bismuth embedding in and , the @xmath1 dimer center , and and complexes formed by the bismuth substitutional center and anion vacancy in its first coordination shell . the modeling was performed in a supercell approach . @xmath4 or supercells ( 54 atoms ) was chosen to model @xmath0 and or centers , and @xmath5 supercell ( 72 atoms ) was used for @xmath1 . in the central region of the supercell certain cations were substituted by bismuth atoms and an anion vacancy was formed by a removal of one chlorine or iodine atom . charged centers were simulated changing the total number of electrons in the supercell . equilibrium configurations of bismuth centers were found by a complete optimization of the supercell parameters and atomic positions with the gradient method . all such calculations were performed using package @xcite in the plane wave basis in the generalized gradient approximation of density functional theory with ultra - soft pseudopotentials built with pbe functional @xcite . the pseudopotential sources were taken from the pslibrary v. 0.3.0 pseudopotential library @xcite . + to test the approach , and lattice parameters were calculated for the unit cell and supercells with both atomic positions and cell parameters completely optimized . the results convergence was tested with respect to the plane wave cutoff energy and to the @xmath6 points grid . the energy cutoff @xmath7 ev and the number of @xmath6 points @xmath8 in the irreducible part of the unit cell brillouin zone were found to be enough to converge the total energy within @xmath9 ev per atom and to reproduce the experimental lattice parameters with a relative accuracy of @xmath10% . the geometry of each supercell was reproduced with a relative accuracy better than 2% with only @xmath11 point of the supercell taken into account and better than 1% using 8 @xmath6 points in the supercell in the irreducible part of the supercell brillouin zone . the total energy convergence was not worse than that in the case of the unit cell . configurations of bismuth - related centers obtained by this means were used to calculate the electron localization functions using the programs from package , the electron density distribution and effective charges of atoms by bader s method using bader v.0.28 code @xcite , and the absorption spectra of the centers by bethe - salpeter equation method based on all - electron full - potential linearized augmented - plane wave approach @xcite . the absorption spectra calculations were performed using code @xcite in the local spin density approximation with pw - ca functional @xcite . spin - orbit interaction essential for bismuth - containing systems was taken into account . scissor correction was applied to transition energies calculation with the scissor value found using modified becke - johnson exchange - correlation potential known to yield accurate band gaps in many solids @xcite . the non - overlapping muffin - tin ( mt ) spheres of maximal possible radii @xmath12 were used . convergence of the results was tested with respect to plane - wave cutoff energy , to the angular momentum cutoff for the mt density and potential , and to the @xmath6 points grid choice . the plane - wave cutoff , @xmath13 , was determined by the @xmath14 relation with @xmath15 being the smallest mt radius . the angular momentum cut - off was taken to be @xmath16 . the self - consistent calculations were performed on the @xmath17 grid of @xmath6 points uniformly distributed in the irreducible part of the supercell brillouin zone . further increasing the cutoff and @xmath6 points density did not lead to significant changes in the results . the total energy self - consistence tolerance was taken to be @xmath9 ev per atom . more dense @xmath18 @xmath6 points grid was applied to calculate dipole matrix elements in optical spectra calculations . simplified configurational coordinate diagrams of bismuth - related centers were calculated in a model restricted to the lowest excited states with a displacement of bismuth atom(s ) along @xmath19 $ ] axis for @xmath0 and centers and along @xmath20 $ ] axis for @xmath1 center . in spite of the fact that the model is inherently rough , it shows that in all the centers studied the stokes shift corresponding to a transition from the first excited state to the ground one do not exceed the accuracy of the excited state energy calculation . hence it seems reasonable enough to estimate the ir luminescence wavelengths by taking this stokes shift to be zero . calculation of @xmath0 substitutional center shows that both in and in the crystal lattice is distorted rather slightly around it : bismuth atom lies in the cation site , the nearest chlorine or iodine atoms are displaced by almost @xmath22 towards the bismuth cite , @xmath23 being the crystal lattice constant ( @xmath24 nm in and @xmath25 nm in ) , and the nearest thallium or cesium atoms are displaced apart from the bismuth cite . so bi@xmath26cl and bi@xmath26tl distances are 0.3120 and 0.3889 nm , respectively ( 0.3320 and 0.3834 nm in perfect crystal ) and bi@xmath26i and bi@xmath26cs distances are 0.3641 and 0.4624 nm , respectively ( 0.3955 and 0.4567 nm in perfect crystal ) . bader analysis of the electron density around @xmath0 center in showed the atomic effective charges to be @xmath27 , @xmath28 , and @xmath29 in -bismuth atom , in each of the nearest chlorine atoms , and in each of the nearest thallium atoms , respectively . the same analysis in yielded @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and @xmath32 atomic effective charges in bismuth atom , in each of the nearest iodine atoms , and in each of the nearest cesium atoms , respectively . the effective atomic charges in perfect and crystal lattices calculated by the same approach were found to be @xmath33 and @xmath29 in chlorine and thallium atoms , respectively , and @xmath34 and @xmath32 in iodine and cesium atoms , respectively . in the total charge localized in cation cite and the neighboring anion sites was changed from @xmath35 in perfect lattice to @xmath36 in the lattice with bismuth substitutional center . in csi this total charge was changed from @xmath37 in perfect lattice to @xmath38 in the lattice with bismuth substitutional center . this shows that the electron density was displaced into the space between bismuth atom and the nearest anions and may be considered as slight covalent contribution to bi@xmath26cl and bi@xmath26i interaction . in such displacement is more noticeable ( fig . [ fig : bi+_elfs ] ) . the calculated energy levels of the @xmath0 center in and are shown in figs . [ fig : bi+_tlcl_levels ] and [ fig : bi+_csi_levels ] , respectively , together with the corresponding transitions . it should be noticed that splitting of the @xmath0 ion states in bismuth substitutional centers in and is not described by crystal field theory due to total cubic symmetry of bismuth ion environment , unlike to the case of center @xcite . in this case the splitting is caused by electron density redistribution with a covalent contribution formed . absorption near 1.0 , 0.8 , 0.7 , and @xmath39 m is found in the @xmath0 center in . the above - mentioned excited states evaluative calculation allows one to expect a luminescence in near 1.0 m excited in this absorption bands . in the ir luminescence in the 1.21.3 m range may be expected to be excited in absorption bands near 1.2 , 0.7 , 0.5 , and @xmath40 m. besides , in another one luminescence transition , with much a lower lifetime , may occur near 0.8 m. the modeling shows that the @xmath1 dimer centers can actually occur both in and crystals . in @xmath1 centers the bismuth atoms are found to be displaced from the adjacent cation sites by @xmath42 and @xmath43 towards each other , so that the bi@xmath26bi distance is reduced to 0.2903 and 0.2961 nm in and , respectively . the nearest chlorine or iodine atoms are displaced towards the dimer , and the nearest thallium or cesium atoms are displaced apart from the dimer . as a result , the bi@xmath26cl and bi@xmath26tl distances are 0.3060 and 0.3960 nm , respectively ( 0.3320 and 0.3834 nm , respectively , in perfect crystal ) , and the bi@xmath26i , and bi@xmath26cs distances become -0.3314 and 0.4743 nm , respectively , as compared to 0.3955 and 0.4567 nm , respectively , in perfect lattice . bader s method analysis of electron density around the center shows that the excess electron charge , @xmath44 , is localized almost completely in the first coordination shell of two bismuth sites , mainly in bismuth atoms and partially in the nearest chlorine or iodine atoms ( fig . [ fig : bi2+_elfs ] ) . in the effective charge in each of the bismuth atoms is found to be @xmath45 , and the effective charge in each of the nearest chlorine and thallium atoms is @xmath33 and @xmath46 , respectively . so , as compared to @xmath0 center , positive charge in each of the bismuth atoms is decreased by @xmath47 , negative charge in each of the neighboring chlorine atoms is increased by @xmath48 , and positive charge in each of the nearest thallium atoms is decreased by @xmath49 . hence the excess total charge localized in two bismuth atoms and their nearest neighbors turns out to be @xmath50 . in the effective charge in each of the bismuth atoms is @xmath51 , and the effective charge in each of the nearest iodine and cesium atoms is @xmath28 and @xmath52 , respectively . as compared to @xmath0 center , positive charge in each of the bismuth atoms is decreased by @xmath53 , negative charge in each of the neighboring iodine atoms is increased by @xmath48 , and positive charge in each of the nearest cesium atoms is decreased by @xmath49 . so the excess total charge in two bismuth atoms and their environment is @xmath54 . so the center is actually @xmath1 dimer both in and in . however , again a certain part of the electron density is displaced into the space between bismuth atoms and the nearest anions , as in @xmath0 centers . the calculated energy levels of @xmath1 center in and and the corresponding transitions are shown in figs . [ fig : bi_2+_tlcl_levels ] and [ fig : bi_2+_csi_levels ] , respectively . basing on the evaluative calculations of the first excited state one might expect the ir luminescence bands in near 1.1 and 1.3 m excited in absorption near 1.1 , 0.8 , 0.7 , 0.5 and @xmath55 m , and in near 1.2 and 1.6 m excited in absorption near 1.2 , 0.7 , 0.6 , and @xmath56 m. one more luminescence band near @xmath57 m in and in the @xmath58 m range in corresponding to a transition from the lowest excited state might be observable at a low temperature . + the modeling of the complexes shows that the complexes in and differ significantly in electronic and spectral properties . the complex in turns out to be similar in certain respect to centers in alkali halide crystals . however , the complex in differs strikingly from both the and centers . in the complex in the lattice relaxation turns out to be significant . the bismuth atom is displaced by @xmath59 from cation site towards the vacant chlorine site , the nearest chlorine and thallium atoms are displaced towards bismuth atom , and thallium atoms surrounding chlorine vacancy are displaced apart from the vacant site . this results in bi@xmath26cl , bi@xmath26tl , and @xmath60 distances being 0.3024 , 0.3598 , and 0.4009 nm , respectively , as compared to the distances 0.3320 , 0.3834 , and 0.3320 nm in perfect crystal . the relaxation is accompanied by the electron density shifted from bismuth atom into the chlorine vacancy region , so that the complex center may be thought of as a bound pair of ions , @xmath0 plus negatively charged v@xmath61 vacancy ( fig . [ fig : bi_and_vac_tlcl_elf ] ) . thus this center is a complex . in complex in , on the one hand , the lattice relaxation is as significant as that in center . bismuth atom is displaced by @xmath43 from the cation site towards the vacant iodine site , the nearest iodine atoms are displaced towards bismuth atom , but the nearest cesium atoms are displaced apart from bismuth atom . this results in bi@xmath26cs and bi@xmath26i distances decreased to 0.4220 and 0.3509 nm , respectively , from 0.4567 and 0.3955 nm , respectively , in perfect crystal . on the other hand , the electron density distribution turns out to differ strikingly from that in complex in crystal . as distinct from , the electron density in is not redistributed between bismuth atom and anion vacancy . so the complex may be roughly thought of as a bound pair : a neutral substitutional atom , @xmath62 , and a neutral iodine vacancy , v@xmath63 ( fig . [ fig : bi_and_vac_csi_elf ] ) . in other words , this center turns out to be a complex . bader s method analysis of the electron density distribution around the center confirms these conclusions . in the effective charge of bismuth atom is @xmath52 , effective charge of each of the nearest chlorine atoms is @xmath28 , and effective charge of each of the thallium atoms surrounding the chlorine vacancy is @xmath64 . so the excess ( in comparison with perfect lattice ) positive charge localized in bismuth substitutional atom and its nearest neighbors is about @xmath65 , and the negative charge no less than @xmath66 is localized in the chlorine vacancy and in its nearest neighbors . in the effective charge of bismuth atom is @xmath67 , effective charge of each of the nearest iodine atoms is @xmath68 , and effective charge of each of the cesium atoms surrounding the iodine vacancy is @xmath52 . so the bismuth substitutional atom turns out to be practically a neutral atom , the excess ( in comparison with perfect lattice ) positive charge localized in its nearest neighbors is about @xmath69 and the positive charge no less than @xmath70 is localized in the iodine vacancy and in its nearest neighbors . the calculated energy levels of and centers and the corresponding transitions are shown in figs . [ fig : bi_and_vac_tlcl_levels ] and [ fig : bi_and_vac_csi_levels ] , respectively . spectral properties of the and complexes may be understood in a model similar to center theory @xcite . in such a model the complexes are considered as @xmath0 ion or @xmath62 atom , respectively , in the axial crystal field formed by neighboring chlorine or iodine vacancy . obviously , the crystal field of a negatively changed chlorine vacancy is stronger than that of a neutral iodine vacancy . three lowest states of @xmath0 ion are known to arise from atomic state split by strong spin - orbital interaction in bismuth . the ground state of @xmath0 ion is . the first excited state , , is split by an axial crystal field in two levels , 6100 and 8300 @xmath71 , and the second excited state , , is split in three levels , 12500 , 14900 and 25000 @xmath71 . in a free @xmath0 ion the electric dipole ( e1 ) transitions between three spin - orbital components of the state are forbidden but under the influence of the crystal field the transitions become allowed . basing on the above - mentioned evaluative calculations one expects the ir luminescence in two bands near 1.6 and 1.2 m , both excited in absorption near 0.8 , 0.7 , and @xmath55 m. a luminescence band with a significantly shorter ( by an order of magnitude ) lifetime may occur near 0.8 m. the ground state of @xmath62 atom is known to be . the first excited state , , is split by an axial crystal field in two levels , 9000 and 10100 @xmath71 . the second excited state , , is split in three levels , 16000 , 18000 , and 19300 @xmath71 , and the forth excited state , , is not split by an electrostatic field . notice that the splitting is expected to be considerably slighter than that in complex . e1 transitions from the ground state of center , corresponding to the atomic state , to all the states arising from the one , turn out to be weak since in a free atom such transitions are parity - forbidden . hence the only relatively intensive absorption band near 0.43 m corresponding to @xmath72 transition may be expected to occur in the center ( fig . [ fig : bi_and_vac_csi_levels ] ) . with the above - mentioned evaluative calculations taken into account one might expect that 1.0 1.1 m luminescence corresponding to @xmath72 transitions is excited in this absorption band . spectroscopic data @xcite and the present results of modeling of bismuth - related centers in and crystals suggest that different centers are responsible for the near - infrared luminescence in these crystals . in the luminescence observed near 1.2 m is caused mainly by complexes formed by @xmath0 substitutional ions and negatively charged chlorine vacancies . however , the bismuth - related contribution to the total absorption is caused mainly by single @xmath0 substitutional centers not contributing to the ir luminescence . this explains a significant difference between the ir luminescence excitation spectrum and absorption spectra @xcite . @xmath0 substitutional centers may cause a luminescence near 1.0 m not observed in @xcite . in the ir luminescence is caused mainly by two types of bismuth centers : @xmath0 substitutional centers give rise to a luminescence observed in the 1.2 1.3 m range , and @xmath1 dimer centers cause a luminescence observed near 1.2 m and near 1.6 m. these conclusions agree with the experimental data of @xcite and confirm the assumptions made there . besides , dimer centers may cause possible luminescence in the @xmath73 m range not observed in refs . @xcite . complexes formed in by @xmath62 substitutional atoms and neutral iodine vacancies may contribute to the ir luminescence only near 1.0 m , as distinct from crystals . one might suppose that the luminescence in the 0.95 1.15 m range observed in @xcite at a low temperature under 0.4 0.5 m excitation is contributed by centers formed due to electrons capturing in @xmath0 substitutional centers in the vicinity of iodine vacancies . 99 v. g. plotnichenko , v. o. sokolov , d. v. philippovskiy , i. s. lisitsky , m. s. kouznetsov , k. s. zaramenskikh , and e. m. dianov , opt . lett . * 38 * , 362 ( 2013 ) . l. su , h. zhao , h. li , l. zheng , g. ren , j. xu , w. ryba - romanowski , r. lisiecki , and p. solarz , opt . 36 * , 4551 ( 2011 ) . l. su , h. zhao , h. li , l. zheng , x. fan , x. jiang , h. tang , g. ren , j. xu , w. ryba - romanowski , r. lisiecki , and p. solarz , opt . materials express * 2 * , 757 ( 2012 ) . g. blasse and a. bril , * 48 * , 217 ( 1968 ) . m. j. weber and r. r. monchamp , j. appl . phys . * 44 * , 5495 ( 1973 ) . y. fujimoto and m. nakatsuka , japan . . phys . * 40 * , l279 ( 2001 ) . y. fujimoto and m. nakatsuka , * 82 * , 3325 ( 2003 ) . e. m. dianov , j. non - cryst . solids * 355 * , 1861 ( 2009 ) . m. peng , g. dong , l. wondraczek , l. zhang , n. zhang , and j. qiu , j. non - cryst . solids * 357 * , 2241 ( 2011 ) . l. f. mollenauer , n. d. vieira , and l. szeto , phys . b * 27 * , 5332 ( 1983 ) . m. fockele , f. lohse , j .- spaeth , and r. h. bartram , j. phys . : condens . matter * 1 * , 13 ( 1989 ) . e. m. dianov , quant . electronics * 40 * , 283 ( 2010 ) . j. ruan , l. su , j. qiu , d. chen , and j. xu , opt . express * 17 * , 5163 ( 2009 ) . p. giannozzi , s. baroni , n. bonini , m. calandra , r. car , c. cavazzoni , d. ceresoli , g. l. chiarotti , m. cococcioni , i. dabo , a. dal corso , s. fabris , g. fratesi , s. de gironcoli , r. gebauer , u. gerstmann , c. gougoussis , a. kokalj , m. lazzeri , l. martin - samos , n. marzari , f. mauri , r. mazzarello , s. paolini , a. pasquarello , l. paulatto , c. sbraccia , s. scandolo , g. sclauzero , a. p. seitsonen , a. smogunov , p. umari , and r. m. wentzcovitch , j. phys . : matter * 21 * , 395502 ( 2009 ) . perdew , k. burke , and m. ernzerhof , phys . lett . * 77 * , 3865 ( 1996 ) . ` http://qe-forge.org/projects/pslibrary ` ` http://theory.cm.utexas.edu/vtsttools/bader ` o. k. andersen , phys . b * 12 * , 3060 ( 1975 ) . ` http://elk.sourceforge.net ` j. p. perdew and y. wang , phys . b * 45 * , 13244 ( 1992 ) . d. m. ceperley and b. i. alder , phys . * 45 * , 566 ( 1990 ) . a. d. becke and e. r. johnson , j. chem . phys . * 124 * , 221101 ( 2006 ) . f. tran and p. blaha , phys . lett . * 102 * , 226401 ( 2009 ) . d. koller , f. tran , and p. blaha , phys . b * 83 * , 195134 ( 2011 ) .

a comparative first - principles study of possible bismuth - related centers in and crystals is performed and the results of computer modeling are compared with the experimental data of refs . @xcite . the calculated spectral properties of the bismuth centers suggest that the ir luminescence observed in @xcite is most likely caused by centers ( @xmath0 ion in thallium site and a negatively charged chlorine vacancy in the nearest anion site ) . on the contrary , @xmath0 substitutional ions and @xmath1 dimers are most likely responsible for the ir luminescence observed in @xcite .

hep-ph0303210

the antarctic neutrino telescope amanda @xcite and the future km@xmath0 icecube @xcite are designed to observe high - energy neutrinos from astrophysical sources . the ice is instrumented with photomultipliers to pick up the cherenkov light from secondary charged particles . in order to reach the large volume needed to detect the expected small fluxes at high energies , the density of optical modules is far too sparse to measure , for example , solar neutrinos . however , it has been recognized for a long time that these instruments can detect a supernova ( sn ) neutrino burst because the cherenkov glow of the ice can be identified as time - correlated noise among all phototubes @xcite . this approach has been used by amanda to exclude the occurrence of a galactic sn over a recent observation period @xcite . for amanda the physics potential of a possible sn observation is essentially limited to its detection , notably in the context of the supernova early warning system ( snews ) that would alert the astronomical community several hours before the optical explosion @xcite . for the future icecube with 4800 optical modules , however , the number of detected cherenkov photons would be of order @xmath2 and thus so large that several interesting physics questions could be addressed in earnest . the observed quantity is the number of cherenkov photons caused by the sn neutrinos as a function of time , i.e. a measure of the energy deposited by the neutrinos in the ice . therefore , the information about the sn signal is far more limited than what can be extracted from a high - statistics observation in super - kamiokande or other low - energy experiments that detect individual events . however , galactic sne are so rare , perhaps a few per century , that the chances of observing one depend crucially on the long - term stability of the neutrino observatories . once icecube has been built it may well operate for several decades , backing up the low - energy experiments . besides the detection and associated early warning one could measure important details of the neutrino light - curve , for example the existence and duration of the initial sn accretion phase , the overall duration of the cooling phase , and so forth . such an observation would provide a plethora of astrophysically valuable information . however , from the perspective of neutrino physics a _ simultaneous _ observation in both icecube and another large detector such as super - kamiokande or hyper - kamiokande would be especially useful . assuming that the neutrinos have traversed significantly different paths through the earth , the two signals could well show measurable differences caused by neutrino oscillations in matter . as this earth effect shows up only for certain combinations of neutrino mixing parameters , a dual observation may well distinguish , for example , between the normal and inverted neutrino mass hierarchy . it is well known that observing sn neutrinos with two or more detectors with different earth - crossing lengths is extremely useful , but icecube s potential has not been explored in this context . with all the low - energy observatories being in the northern hemisphere , icecube s location in antarctica is uniquely complementary for this purpose . any oscillation signature depends on the small flavor - dependent differences between the fluxes and spectra at the source . if these differences were as large as had been assumed until recently there would be little question about icecube s usefulness for co - detecting the earth effect . however , a more systematic study of the flavor - dependence of the sn neutrino fluxes and spectra reveals that these differences are more subtle , although by no means negligible @xcite . we evaluate icecube s potential as a co - detector from the perspective of these `` pessimistic '' assumptions about the primary fluxes and spectra . this paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ at - icecube ] , we show that the neutrino signal from a galactic supernova can be measured at icecube with a sub - percent statistical precision . in sec . [ earth - effects ] , we calculate the earth matter effects on this signal and illustrate that it is possible to detect them in conjunction with another high statistics experiment . sec . [ concl ] concludes . the sn neutrinos streaming through the antarctic ice interact according to @xmath3 and some other less important reactions . the positrons , in turn , emit cherenkov light that is picked up by the optical modules ( oms ) frozen into the ice . while the expected number of detected photons per om was calculated in refs . @xcite , we revisit their estimate for two reasons . first , the sn signal was directly scaled to the historical sn 1987a observation in kamiokande ii so that the exact assumptions about the neutrino flux are not directly apparent . second , the expected number of cherenkov photons detected by one om was based on estimating an effective ice volume seen by one om . however , it is much simpler to work in the opposite direction and start with the homogeneous and isotropic cherenkov glow of the ice caused by the sn neutrinos . the om is immersed in this diffuse bath of photons and picks up a number corresponding to its angular acceptance and quantum efficiency . as a first simplification we limit ourselves to the signal caused by the inverse @xmath4 reaction @xmath3 . the @xmath5 fluence ( time - integrated flux ) at earth is @xmath6 we define the `` sn fudge factor '' as @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the total energy leaving the sn in the form of @xmath5 after flavor oscillations have been included , @xmath9 is the average @xmath5 energy , and @xmath10 the distance . the energy deposited in the ice per target proton is @xmath11 . for the inverse @xmath4 cross section we ignore weak - magnetism and recoil corrections and also the difference between @xmath5 and positron energy so that @xcite @xmath12 for the neutrino flux of each neutrino and anti - neutrino species we assume a distribution of the form @xcite @xmath13\,,\ ] ] where @xmath14 is the average energy , @xmath15 a parameter that typically takes on values 2.55 depending on the flavor and the phase of neutrino emission , and @xmath16 the overall flux at the detector in units of @xmath17 . this distribution implies @xmath18 altogether we thus find @xmath19 with @xmath20 this fudge factor can also be taken to include deviations from the simplified energy dependence of the cross section and deviations from the assumed spectral shape . the cherenkov angle for photon emission by a charged particle is @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the medium s refractive index and @xmath4 the particle s velocity . with @xmath23 for ice , neglecting the @xmath24-dependence , and @xmath25 we have @xmath26 . a particle with unit charge produces cherenkov photons per unit path length and per unit wavelength band according to @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the fine - structure constant . assuming that @xmath22 and thus @xmath29 are independent of wavelength we integrate over @xmath24 and find @xmath30 taking the useful wavelength range to be 300600 nm this translates into 319 photons per cm pathlength . taking the positron mean free path to be 12 cm for an energy of 20 mev , and taking it to be proportional to its energy , the number of useful cherenkov photons per deposited neutrino energy is @xmath31 with yet another fudge factor @xmath32 . the density of ice is @xmath33 , corresponding to about @xmath34 proton targets . therefore , the sn neutrinos produce @xmath35 useful cherenkov photons per unit volume of ice . multiplying this number with the speed of light and dividing by @xmath36 gives us the resulting diffuse photon flux in units of @xmath37 . however , the average lifetime of these photons is @xmath38 with @xmath39 the absorption length . therefore , the neutrino - induced photon fluence is found by multiplying the flux with @xmath38 , @xmath40 where @xmath41 . the number of events produced by this fluence in a given om depends on the average quantum efficiency taken to be @xmath42 . in addition , it depends on the angular acceptance , i.e. the effective photo cathode detection area @xmath43 times the angular acceptance range @xmath44 . therefore , in one om we expect @xmath45 with @xmath46 this result is independent of the presence of bubbles in the ice that scatter the photons . the cherenkov glow of the ice represents an isotropic and homogeneous distribution that is not changed by elastic scattering . in order to compare our result with the one derived in ref . @xcite we need to translate their assumptions into our fudge factors . the @xmath5 distribution was taken to follow a fermi - dirac spectrum with @xmath47 mev , implying @xmath48 mev . the distance of the sn was taken to be 10 kpc , and the total energy release was scaled to the kamiokande ii signal for sn 1987a . with our choice of the @xmath4 cross section these assumptions correspond to @xmath49 erg , i.e. to @xmath50 . these authors also used a quadratic energy dependence of the cross section . integrating over their fermi - dirac spectrum they effectively used @xmath51 . further , they assumed 3000 useful cherenkov photons for 20 mev deposited energy , i.e. effectively @xmath52 . for the absorption length they used 300 m , i.e. @xmath53 . finally , they assumed a quantum efficiency of 25% , a cathode area of 280 @xmath54 , and an acceptance range of @xmath55 , i.e.@xmath56 . altogether , we find for these assumptions @xmath57 per om . this compares with 273 in ref . @xcite , i.e. our result is larger by a factor 1.5 . the result in ref . @xcite was backed up by a detailed monte carlo treatment of the production and propagation of cherenkov photons in the amanda detector . therefore , the difference may well relate to details of the om acceptance and wavelength - dependent quantum efficiency and photon propagation . many of these details will be different in icecube where 10 inch photomultiplier tubes and different regions of ice will be used . detailed values for the detector - dependent fudge factors must be determined specifically for icecube once it has been built . the main difference between the assumptions in ref . @xcite and our estimate is the absorption length . when using amanda as a sn observatory a realistic value was taken to be around 100 m @xcite . the vast difference between these estimates is that the former was based on the measured absorption length in a dust - free region of the ice . for our further estimates we stick to 100 m as a conservative assumption . in our derivation we have used the time - integrated neutrino flux , amounting to the assumption of a stationary situation . the absorption time for photons is very small , @xmath58 . the sn signal will vary on time scales exceeding 10 ms . therefore , the cherenkov glow of the ice follows the time - variation of the sn signal without discernible inertia . hence one may replace the neutrino fluence with a time - dependent flux and @xmath59 with an event rate @xmath60 . moreover , for our further discussion it will be useful to consolidate our fudge - factors into one describing the detector response , and others characterizing the neutrino flux . therefore , we summarize our prediction for the event rate per om in the form @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the @xmath5 luminosity after flavor oscillations and @xmath63 here , @xmath64 also includes corrections for the energy dependence of the @xmath4 cross section . we stress that our simple estimate of the counting rate primarily serves the purpose of determining its magnitude relative to the background . the important feature is that the signal relative to the background can be determined with a good statistical precision . of course , for an absolute detector calibration a detailed modeling would be necessary . for our present purpose , however , even an uncertainty of several 10% in our estimated counting rate is irrelevant . icecube will have 4800 oms so that one expects a total event number of @xmath65 , taking all fudge factors to be unity . assuming a background counting rate of 300 hz per om over as much as 10 s this compares with a background rate of @xmath66 . assuming poisson fluctuations , the uncertainty of this number is @xmath67 , i.e. 0.25% of the sn signal . therefore , one can determine the sn signal with a statistical sub - percent precision , ignoring for now problems of absolute detector calibration . in order to illustrate the statistical power of icecube to observe a sn signal we use two different numerical sn simulations . the first was performed by the livermore group @xcite that involves traditional input physics for mu- and tau - neutrino interactions and a flux - limited diffusion scheme for treating neutrino transport . the great advantage of this simulation is that it covers the full evolution from infall over the explosion to the kelvin - helmholtz cooling phase of the newly formed neutron star . we show the livermore @xmath5 and @xmath68 lightcurves in fig [ fig : simulations ] ( left panels ) . here and in the following we take @xmath68 to stand for either @xmath69 or @xmath70 . apart from very small differences the sn fluxes and spectra are thought to be equal for @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath69 , and @xmath70 . our second simulation was performed with the garching code @xcite . it includes all relevant neutrino interaction rates , including nucleon bremsstrahlung , neutrino pair processes , weak magnetism , nucleon recoils , and nuclear correlation effects . the neutrino transport part is based on a boltzmann solver . the neutrino - radiation hydrodynamics program allows one to perform spherically symmetric as well as multi - dimensional simulations . the progenitor model is a 15@xmath73 star with a @xmath74 iron core . the period from shock formation to 468 ms after bounce was evolved in two dimensions . the subsequent evolution of the model is simulated in spherical symmetry . at 150 ms the explosion sets in , although a small modification of the boltzmann transport was necessary to allow this to happen @xcite . unmanipulated full - scale models with an accurate treatment of the microphysics currently do not obtain explosions @xcite . this run will be continued beyond the current epoch of 750 ms post bounce ; we here use the preliminary results currently available @xcite . we show the garching @xmath5 and @xmath68 lightcurves in fig [ fig : simulations ] ( right panels ) . we take the livermore simulation to represent traditional predictions for flavor - dependent sn neutrino fluxes and spectra that were used in many previous discussions of sn neutrino oscillations . the garching simulation is taken to represent a situation when the @xmath68 interactions are more systematically included so that the flavor - dependent spectra and fluxes are more similar than had been assumed previously @xcite . we think it is useful to juxtapose the icecube response for both cases . another difference is that in livermore the accretion phase lasts longer . since the explosion mechanism is not finally settled , it is not obvious which case is more realistic . moreover , there could be differences between different sne . the overall features are certainly comparable between the two simulations . in fig . [ fig : simulationsicecube ] we show the expected counting rates in icecube on the basis of eq . ( [ eq : rateprediction ] ) for an assumed distance of 10 kpc and 4800 oms for the livermore ( left ) and garching ( right ) simulations . we also show this signal in 50 ms bins where we have added noise from a background of 300 hz per om . the baseline is at the average background rate so that negative counts correspond to downward background fluctuations . one could easily identify the existence and duration of the accretion phase and thus test the standard delayed - explosion scenario . one could also measure the overall duration of the cooling phase and thus exclude the presence of significant exotic energy losses . therefore , many of the particle - physics limits based on the sn 1987a neutrinos @xcite could be supported with a statistically serious signal . if the sn core were to collapse to a black hole after some time , the sudden turn - off of the neutrino flux could be identified . in short , when a galactic sn occurs , icecube is a powerful stand - alone neutrino detector , providing us with a plethora of information that is of fundamental astrophysical and particle - physics interest . in addition , icecube is extremely useful as a co - detector with another high - statistics observatory to measure neutrino oscillation effects , a topic that we now explore . neutrino oscillations are now firmly established by measurements of solar and atmospheric neutrinos and the kamland and k2k long - baseline experiments . evidently the weak interaction eigenstates @xmath75 , @xmath71 and @xmath72 are non - trivial superpositions of three mass eigenstates @xmath76 , @xmath77 and @xmath78 , @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the leptonic mixing matrix that can be written in the canonical form @xmath81 here @xmath82 and @xmath83 etc . , and @xmath84 is a phase that can lead to cp - violating effects , that are , however , irrelevant for sn neutrinos . the mass squared differences relevant for the atmospheric and solar neutrino oscillations obey a hierarchy @xmath85 . this hierarchy , combined with the observed smallness of the angle @xmath86 at chooz @xcite implies that the atmospheric neutrino oscillations essentially decouple from the solar ones and each of these is dominated by only one of the mixing angles . the atmospheric neutrino oscillations are controlled by @xmath87 that may well be maximal ( 45@xmath88 ) . the solar case is dominated by @xmath89 , that is large but not maximal . from a global 3-flavor analysis of all data one finds the 3@xmath90 ranges for the mass differences @xmath91 and mixing angles summarized in table [ tab : mixingparameters ] . @lll observation&mixing angle&@xmath92 [ mev@xmath93 + sun , kamland & @xmath94 27@xmath8842@xmath88 & @xmath95 55190 + atmosphere , k2k & @xmath96 32@xmath8860@xmath88 & @xmath97 14006000 + chooz & @xmath98 & @xmath99 + a sn core is essentially a neutrino blackbody source , but small flavor - dependent differences of the fluxes and spectra remain . we denote the fluxes of @xmath100 and @xmath101 at earth that would be observable in the absence of oscillations by @xmath102 and @xmath103 , respectively . in the presence of oscillations a @xmath5 detector actually observes @xmath104 f_x^0\ , , \label{fedbar}\ ] ] where @xmath105 is the @xmath5 survival probability after propagation through the sn mantle and perhaps part of the earth before reaching the detector . a significant modification of the survival probability due to the propagation through the earth appears only for those combinations of neutrino mixing parameters shown in table [ tab : earthcases ] . the earth matter effect depends strongly on two parameters , the sign of @xmath106 and the value of @xmath107 @xcite . the `` normal hierarchy '' corresponds to @xmath108 , i.e. @xmath109 , whereas the `` inverted hierarchy '' corresponds to @xmath110 , i.e.@xmath111 . note that the presence or absence of the earth effect discriminates between values of @xmath112 less or greater than @xmath113 , i.e. @xmath86 less or larger than about @xmath114 . thus , the earth effect is sensitive to values of @xmath86 that are much smaller than the current limit . @lll 13-mixing&normal hierarchy&inverted hierarchy + @xmath115&@xmath75 and @xmath5 & @xmath75 and @xmath5 + @xmath116&@xmath5&@xmath75 + let us consider those scenarios where the mass hierarchy and the value of @xmath86 are such that the earth effect appears for @xmath5 . in such cases the @xmath5 survival probability @xmath105 is given by @xmath117 where the energy dependence of all quantities will always be implicit . here @xmath118 is the mixing angle between @xmath100 and @xmath119 in earth matter while @xmath120 is the mass squared difference between the two anti - neutrino mass eigenstates @xmath121 and @xmath119 in units of @xmath122ev@xmath123 , @xmath124 is the distance traveled through the earth in units of 1000 km , and @xmath125 is the neutrino energy in mev . we have assumed a constant matter density inside the earth , which is a good approximation for @xmath126 , i.e. as long as the neutrinos do not pass through the core of the earth . in order to calculate the extent of the earth effect for icecube , we will assume that the relevant mixing parameters are @xmath127 and @xmath128 . we further assume that the source spectra are given by the functional form eq . ( [ eq : spectralform ] ) . the values of the parameters @xmath15 and @xmath129 for both the @xmath100 and @xmath68 spectra are in general time dependent . in fig . [ fig : exampleeartheffect ] we show the variation of the expected icecube signal with earth - crossing length @xmath124 for the two sets of parameters detailed in table [ tab : examplecases ] . the first could be representative of the accretion phase , the second of the cooling signal . we use the two - density approximation for the earth density profile , where the core has a density of @xmath130 and a radius of 3500 km , while the density of the earth mantle was taken to be @xmath131 . we observe that for short distances , corresponding to near - horizontal neutrino trajectories , the signal varies strongly with @xmath124 . between about 3,000 and 10,500 km it reaches an asymptotic value that we call the `` asymptotic mantle value . '' for case ( a ) , this value corresponds to about 1.5% depletion of the signal , whereas for ( b ) it corresponds to about 6.5% depletion . @llllllll example&phase&@xmath9 & @xmath132 & @xmath133&@xmath134 & @xmath135 & asymptotic + & & [ mev]&[mev]&&&&earth effect + ( a)&accretion&15&17&4&3&1.5&@xmath136% + ( b)&cooling & 15&18&3&3&0.8&@xmath137% + beyond an earth - crossing length of @xmath13810,500 km , the neutrinos have to cross the earth core with another large jump in density . the core effects change the asymptotic mantle value by @xmath139% as can be seen in fig . [ fig : exampleeartheffect ] . we neglect the core effects in the following analysis , and the `` asymptotic value '' always refers to the asymptotic mantle value . for the largest part of the sky the earth effect either appears with this asymptotic value ( `` neutrinos coming from below '' ) , or it does not appear at all ( `` neutrinos from above '' ) . therefore , we now focus on the asymptotic value and study how the signal modification depends on the assumed flux parameters . in table [ tab : asymptotic1 ] we show the signal modification for @xmath140 , @xmath141 , and @xmath142 as a function of @xmath132 and the flux ratio @xmath135 . in table [ tab : asymptotic2 ] we show the same with @xmath143 . the results are shown in the form of contour plots in fig . [ fig : cont ] . @lllllll flux ratio & + @xmath135 & 15&16&17&18&19&20 + 2.0 & 1.026 & 1.014 & 1.002 & 0.988 & 0.974 & 0.960 + 1.9 & 1.023 & 1.011 & 0.999 & 0.985 & 0.971 & 0.956 + 1.8 & 1.021 & 1.009 & 0.995 & 0.982 & 0.967 & 0.952 + 1.7 & 1.018 & 1.005 & 0.992 & 0.978 & 0.963 & 0.948 + 1.6 & 1.015 & 1.002 & 0.988 & 0.974 & 0.959 & 0.944 + 1.5 & 1.012 & 0.998 & 0.984 & 0.969 & 0.954 & 0.939 + 1.4 & 1.008 & 0.994 & 0.980 & 0.965 & 0.949 & 0.934 + 1.3 & 1.004 & 0.990 & 0.975 & 0.960 & 0.944 & 0.928 + 1.2 & 1.000 & 0.985 & 0.970 & 0.954 & 0.938 & 0.922 + 1.1 & 0.995 & 0.980 & 0.964 & 0.948 & 0.932 & 0.915 + 1.0 & 0.989 & 0.974 & 0.957 & 0.941 & 0.925 & 0.908 + 0.9 & 0.983 & 0.967 & 0.950 & 0.934 & 0.917 & 0.901 + 0.8 & 0.976 & 0.959 & 0.942 & 0.925 & 0.909 & 0.892 + 0.7 & 0.967 & 0.950 & 0.933 & 0.916 & 0.899 & 0.883 + 0.6 & 0.958 & 0.940 & 0.923 & 0.906 & 0.889 & 0.873 + 0.5 & 0.946 & 0.928 & 0.911 & 0.894 & 0.877 & 0.862 + @lllllll flux ratio & + @xmath135 & 15&16&17&18&19&20 + 2.0 & 1.036 & 1.024 & 1.012 & 1.000 & 0.986 & 0.972 + 1.9 & 1.033 & 1.022 & 1.010 & 0.996 & 0.983 & 0.968 + 1.8 & 1.031 & 1.019 & 1.006 & 0.993 & 0.979 & 0.964 + 1.7 & 1.028 & 1.016 & 1.003 & 0.989 & 0.975 & 0.960 + 1.6 & 1.025 & 1.013 & 0.999 & 0.985 & 0.971 & 0.955 + 1.5 & 1.022 & 1.009 & 0.995 & 0.981 & 0.966 & 0.951 + 1.4 & 1.019 & 1.005 & 0.991 & 0.976 & 0.961 & 0.945 + 1.3 & 1.015 & 1.001 & 0.986 & 0.971 & 0.955 & 0.940 + 1.2 & 1.010 & 0.996 & 0.981 & 0.965 & 0.949 & 0.933 + 1.1 & 1.006 & 0.991 & 0.975 & 0.959 & 0.943 & 0.927 + 1.0 & 1.000 & 0.985 & 0.969 & 0.952 & 0.936 & 0.919 + 0.9 & 0.994 & 0.978 & 0.961 & 0.945 & 0.928 & 0.911 + 0.8 & 0.986 & 0.970 & 0.953 & 0.936 & 0.919 & 0.903 + 0.7 & 0.978 & 0.961 & 0.944 & 0.926 & 0.910 & 0.893 + 0.6 & 0.968 & 0.950 & 0.933 & 0.916 & 0.899 & 0.882 + 0.5 & 0.956 & 0.938 & 0.920 & 0.903 & 0.886 & 0.870 + even for mildly different fluxes or spectra the signal modification is several percent , by far exceeding the statistical uncertainty of the icecube signal , although the _ absolute _ calibration of icecube may remain uncertain to within several percent . however , the signal modification will vary with time during the sn burst . during the early accretion phase that is expected to last for a few 100 ms and corresponds to a significant fraction of the overall signal , the @xmath68 flux may be almost a factor of 2 smaller than the @xmath5 flux , but it will be slightly hotter and less pinched @xcite . this corresponds to case ( a ) above ; it is evident from fig . [ fig : exampleeartheffect ] and table [ tab : asymptotic1 ] that this implies that the earth effect is very small . during the kelvin - helmholtz cooling phase the flux ratio is reversed with more @xmath68 being emitted than @xmath5 , but still with the same hierarchy of energies . this corresponds to case ( b ) ; in this case the earth effect could be about 6% . this time dependence may allow one to detect the earth effect without a precise absolute detector calibration . in order to illustrate the time dependence of the earth effect we show in fig . [ fig : percenteffect ] the expected counting rate in icecube for both the livermore ( left panels ) and garching ( right panels ) simulations . in the upper panels we show the expected counting rate with flavor oscillations in the sn mantle , but no earth effect ( solid lines ) , or with the asymptotic earth effect ( dashed lines ) that obtains for a large earth - crossing path . naturally the differences are very small so that we show in the lower panels the ratio of these curves , i.e. the expected counting rate with / without earth effect as a function of time for both livermore and garching . while for the livermore simulation there is a large earth effect even at early times , the change from early to late times in both cases is around 45% . therefore , the most model - independent signature is a time variation of the earth effect during the sn neutrino signal . in order to demonstrate the statistical significance of these effects we integrate the expected signal for both simulations separately for the accretion phase and the subsequent cooling phase ; the results are shown in table [ tab : integratedrates ] . for both simulations the earth effect itself and its change with time is statistically highly significant . based on the livermore simulation , the earth effect is much more pronounced than in garching , the latter involving more up - to - date input physics for neutrino transport . however , the _ difference _ between the earth effect during accretion and cooling is not vastly different between the two simulations . recalling that the absolute detector calibration may be very uncertain so that one has to rely on the temporal variation of the earth effect , the difference between livermore and garching becomes much smaller . we expect that it is quite generic that the temporal change of the earth effect is a few percent of the overall counting rate . @lrrrr & & + & & & & + integration time [ s]&00.500&0.5003&00.250&0.2500.700 + sn signal [ counts ] + no earth effect & 519,080&818,043&173,085&407,715 + asymptotic earth effect&488,093&751,137&171,310&390,252 + difference & 30,987 & 66,906 & 1,775 & 17,463 + fractional difference&@xmath144%&@xmath145%&@xmath146%&@xmath147% + background [ counts]&720,000&4,320,000&360,000&648,000 + @xmath148/signal&0.16%&0.25%&0.35%&0.20% + one can measure the earth effect in icecube only in conjunction with another high - statistics detector . we do not attempt to simulate in detail the sn signal in this other detector but simply assume that it can be measured with a precision at least as good as in icecube . one candidate is super - kamiokande , a water cherenkov detector that would measure around @xmath149 events from a galactic sn at a distance of 10 kpc . therefore , the statistical precision for the total neutrino energy deposition in the water is around 1% and thus worse than in icecube . even though super - kamiokande will measure a larger number of cherenkov photons than icecube , a single neutrino event will cause an entire cherenkov ring to be measured , i.e. the photons are highly correlated . therefore , in the estimated statistical @xmath150 fluctuation of the signal , the fluctuating number @xmath151 is that of the detected neutrinos . if the future hyper - kamiokande is built , its fiducial volume would be about 30 times that of super - kamiokande . in this case the statistical signal precision exceeds that of icecube for the equivalent observable . we denote the equivalent icecube signal measured by super- or hyper - kamiokande as @xmath152 and the icecube signal as @xmath153 . if the distances traveled by the neutrinos before reaching these two detectors are different , the earth effect on the neutrino spectra may be different , which will reflect in the ratio @xmath154 . of course , in the absence of the earth effect this ratio equals unity by definition . the geographical position of icecube with respect to super- or hyper - kamiokande at a latitude of @xmath155 is well - suited for the detection of the earth effect through a combination of the signals . using fig . [ fig : exampleeartheffect ] we can already draw some qualitative conclusions about the ratio @xmath156 . clearly , @xmath157 if neutrinos do not travel through the earth before reaching either detector . if the distance traveled by neutrinos through the earth is more that 3000 km for both detectors , the earth effects on both @xmath152 and @xmath158 are nearly equal and their ratio stays around unity . if the neutrinos come `` from above '' for sk and `` from below '' for icecube , or vice versa , the earth matter effect will shift this ratio from unity . in fig . [ fig : earthmap ] , we show contours of @xmath159 for the sn position in terms of the location on earth where the sn is at the zenith . the map is an area preserving hammer - aitoff projection so that the sizes of different regions in the figure gives a realistic idea of the `` good '' and `` bad '' regions of the sky . in order to generate the contours we use the parameters of case ( b ) in table [ tab : examplecases ] so that the asymptotic suppression of the signal is about 6.5% . the sky falls into four distinct regions depending on the direction of the neutrinos relative to either detector as described in table [ tab : skymapregions ] . when the neutrinos come from above for both detectors ( region d ) there is no earth effects . if they come from below in both ( region c ) , the earth effect is large in both . depending on the exact distance traveled through the earth , the event ratio can be large , but generally fluctuates around 1 . in the other regions where the neutrinos come from above for one detector and from below for the other ( regions a and b ) the relative effect is large . @lllll region&sky fraction & & @xmath156 + & & icecube&super - k & + a&0.35&below&above&1.070 + b&0.35&above&below&0.935 + c&0.15&below&below&fluctuations around 1 + d&0.15&above&above&1 + for assumptions about the flavor - dependent sn neutrino fluxes and spectra that agree with state - of - the - art studies , the earth matter effect on neutrino oscillations shows up in the icecube signal of a future galactic sn on the level of a few percent . if the icecube signal can be compared with another high - statistics signal , notably in super - kamiokande or hyper - kamiokande , the earth effect becomes clearly visible as a difference between the detectors . as one is looking for a signal modification in the range of a few percent , the absolute detector calibration may not be good enough in one or both of the instruments . however , for typical numerical sn simulations the effect is time dependent and most notably differs between the early accretion phase and the subsequent neutron star cooling phase . therefore , one would have to search for a temporal variation of the relative detector signals of a few percent . the large number of optical modules in icecube renders this task statistically possible . in fact depending on the differences in flavor - dependent fluxes , the statistical accuracy of super - kamiokande may turn out to be the limiting factor . this limitation is not significant for hyper - kamiokande . the unique location of icecube in antarctica implies that for a large portion of the sky this detector sees the sn through the earth when super- and hyper - kamiokande sees it from above , or the other way round , i.e. the chances of a relative signal difference between the detectors are large . if both detectors were to see the sn from above there would be no earth effect to detect . assuming that the magnitude of the mixing angle @xmath86 can be established to be large in the sense of @xmath160 by a long - baseline experiment @xcite , observing the earth effect in sn anti - neutrinos implies the normal mass hierarchy . on the other hand , if @xmath161 has been established , the earth effect is unavoidable . not observing it would imply that the primary sn neutrino fluxes and spectra are more similar than indicated by state - of - the - art numerical simulations . if @xmath160 is known , and we do not observe the earth effect , it still does not prove the inverted mass hierarchy . it could also mean that we do not properly understand the flavor - dependent source fluxes and spectra . therefore , even if @xmath160 is known , our method only allows one to detect the normal mass hierarchy , it does not strictly allow one to exclude it . as far as neutrino parameters are concerned , only a positive detection of the earth effect would count for much . of course , a normal mass hierarchy and @xmath160 is certainly a plausible scenario so that expecting a positive identification of the earth effect is not a far - fetched possibility . in summary , even though galactic sne are rare , the anticipated longevity of icecube and the long - term neutrino program at super- or hyper - kamiokande imply that detecting the earth effect in a sn neutrino burst is certainly a distinct possibility . this could identify the normal neutrino mass hierarchy , a daunting task at long - baseline experiments @xcite . given the difficulty of pinning down the mass hierarchy at long - baseline experiments , both icecube and super- or hyper - kamiokande should take all instrumental and experimental steps required to ensure the feasibility of a high - statistics simultaneous sn observation . this work was supported , in part , by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft under grant no . sfb-375 and by the european science foundation ( esf ) under the network grant no . 86 neutrino astrophysics . we thank francis halzen and robert buras for helpful comments on an early version of this manuscript . 99 f. halzen , j. e. jacobsen and e. zas , `` possibility that high - energy neutrino telescopes could detect supernovae , '' _ phys . d _ * 49 * , 1758 ( 1994 ) . f. halzen , j. e. jacobsen and e. zas , `` ultra - transparent antarctic ice as a supernova detector , '' _ phys . d _ * 53 * , 7359 ( 1996 ) [ astro - ph/9512080 ] . j. ahrens _ et al . _ [ amanda collaboration ] , `` search for supernova neutrino - bursts with the amanda detector , '' _ astropart . * 16 * , 345 ( 2002 ) [ astro - ph/0105460 ] . k. scholberg , `` snews : the supernova early warning system , '' astro - ph/9911359 . snews : the supernova early warning system , http://hep.bu.edu/@xmath138snnet/ a. s. dighe and a. y. smirnov , `` identifying the neutrino mass spectrum from the neutrino burst from a supernova , '' _ phys . d _ * 62 * , 033007 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9907423 ] . a. s. dighe , `` earth matter effects on the supernova neutrino spectra , '' hep - ph/0106325 . c. lunardini and a. y. smirnov , `` supernova neutrinos : earth matter effects and neutrino mass spectrum , '' nucl . b * 616 * , 307 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0106149 ] . c. lunardini and a. y. smirnov , `` probing the neutrino mass hierarchy and the 13-mixing with supernovae , '' hep - ph/0302033 . k. takahashi and k. sato , `` earth effects on supernova neutrinos and their implications for neutrino parameters , '' _ phys . d _ * 66 * , 033006 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0110105 ] . g. g. raffelt , `` mu- and tau - neutrino spectra formation in supernovae , '' _ astrophys . j. _ * 561 * , 890 ( 2001 ) [ astro - ph/0105250 ] . r. buras , h. t. janka , m. t. keil , g. g. raffelt and m. rampp , `` electron - neutrino pair annihilation : a new source for muon and tau neutrinos in supernovae , '' _ astrophys . j. _ * 587 * , 320 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0205006 ] . m. t. keil , g. g. raffelt and h. t. janka , `` monte carlo study of supernova neutrino spectra formation , '' _ astrophys . , in press ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0208035 ] . g. g. raffelt , m. th . keil , r. buras , h .- t . janka and m. rampp , `` supernova neutrinos : flavor - dependent fluxes and spectra , '' proc . noon 03 ( 1014 february 2003 , kanazawa , japan ) , astro - ph/0303226 . p. vogel and j. f. beacom , `` angular distribution of neutron inverse beta decay , @xmath162 , '' _ phys . * 60 * , 053003 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9903554 ] . t. totani , k. sato , h. e. dalhed and j. r. wilson , `` future detection of supernova neutrino burst and explosion mechanism , '' _ astrophys . j. _ * 496 * , 216 ( 1998 ) [ astro - ph/9710203 ] . m. rampp and h .- janka , `` radiation hydrodynamics with neutrinos : variable eddington factor method for core - collapse supernova simulations '' , _ astron . _ * 396 * , 361 ( 2002 ) [ astro - ph/0203101 ] . janka , r. buras , k. kifonidis , t. plewa and m. rampp , `` explosion mechanisms of massive stars '' , in : _ core collapse of massive stars _ , edited by c.l . fryer ( kluwer academic publ . , dordrecht , 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0212314 ] . r. buras , m. rampp , h .- t . janka and k. kifonidis , `` improved models of stellar core collapse and still no explosions : what is missing ? '' , _ physical review letters _ , submitted ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0303171 ] . g. g. raffelt , `` particle physics from stars , '' _ ann . nucl . part . sci . _ * 49 * , 163 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9903472 ] . m. c. gonzalez - garcia and y. nir , `` developments in neutrino physics , '' hep - ph/0202058 . g. l. fogli , e. lisi , a. marrone , d. montanino , a. palazzo and a. m. rotunno , `` solar neutrino oscillation parameters after first kamland results , '' _ phys . d _ * 67 * , 073002 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0212127 ] . j. n. bahcall , m. c. gonzalez - garcia and c. pea - garay , `` solar neutrinos before and after kamland , '' _ jhep _ * 02 * , 009 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0212147 ] . p. c. de holanda and a. y. smirnov , `` lma msw solution of the solar neutrino problem and first kamland results , '' _ jcap _ * 02 * , 001 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0212270 ] . m. maltoni , t. schwetz and j. w. valle , `` combining first kamland results with solar neutrino data , '' _ phys . d _ * 67 * , 093003 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0212129 ] . m. maltoni , t. schwetz , m. a. tortola and j. w. valle , `` constraining neutrino oscillation parameters with current solar and atmospheric data , '' _ phys . d _ * 67 * , 013011 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0207227 ] . m. apollonio _ et al . _ [ chooz collaboration ] , `` limits on neutrino oscillations from the chooz experiment , '' _ phys . b _ * 466 * , 415 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ex/9907037 ] . v. d. barger , s. geer , r. raja and k. whisnant , `` exploring neutrino oscillations with superbeams , '' _ phys . d _ * 63 * , 113011 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0012017 ] . a. cervera , a. donini , m. b. gavela , j. j. gomez cadenas , p. hernandez , o. mena and s. rigolin , `` golden measurements at a neutrino factory , '' _ nucl . b _ * 579 * , 17 ( 2000 ) ; erratum _ ibid . _ * 593 * , 731 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0002108 ] . m. freund , p. huber and m. lindner , `` systematic exploration of the neutrino factory parameter space including errors and correlations , '' _ nucl . phys . b _ , * 615 * , 331 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0105071 ] .

icecube , a future km@xmath0 antarctic ice cherenkov neutrino telescope , is highly sensitive to a galactic supernova ( sn ) neutrino burst . the cherenkov light corresponding to the total energy deposited by the sn neutrinos in the ice can be measured relative to background fluctuations with a statistical precision much better than 1% . if the sn is viewed through the earth , the matter effect on neutrino oscillations can change the signal by more than 5% , depending on the flavor - dependent source spectra and the neutrino mixing parameters . therefore , icecube together with another high - statistics experiment like hyper - kamiokande can detect the earth effect , an observation that would identify specific neutrino mixing scenarios that are difficult to pin down with long - baseline experiments . in particular , the normal mass hierarchy can be clearly detected if the third mixing angle is not too small , @xmath1 . the small flavor - dependent differences of the sn neutrino fluxes and spectra that are found in state - of - the - art simulations suffice for this purpose . although the absolute calibration uncertainty at icecube may exceed 5% , the earth effect would typically vary by a large amount over the duration of the sn signal , obviating the need for a precise calibration . therefore , icecube with its unique geographic location and expected longevity can play a decisive role as a `` co - detector '' to measure sn neutrino oscillations . it is also a powerful stand - alone sn detector that can verify the delayed - explosion scenario .

1606.03268

graph modification problems lie in the intersection of algorithmics , graph theory , and network analysis . formally , a graph modification problem is given as follows . herein , graph modification operations include edge deletions , insertions , and contractions , and vertex deletions . classic examples for @xmath1 are `` being edgeless '' ( this is known as vertex cover when the allowed modification operation is vertex deletion ) and `` being a disjoint union of cliques '' ( this is known as cluster editing when the allowed modification operations are edge deletion and insertion ) . we will deal with simple and natural graph modification problems that are motivated by real - world applications . in these applications , the common way of solving these problems is via heuristics . we present four main themes on how the interaction between parameterized algorithmics and heuristics can take place , each time illustrated by some `` key '' graph modification problems . in section [ sec : hcd ] , we consider a graph - based clustering problem that has been defined only implicitly by means of a greedy heuristic @xcite . we describe how a natural np - hard parameterized problem ( referred to as highly connected deletion ) can be derived from this , and how this leads to further insight into the corresponding clustering approach @xcite . in section [ sec : deganon ] , starting with a practically successful heuristic for anonymizing social networks @xcite ( the corresponding np - hard problem is known as degree anonymity ) , we describe how a closer inspection yields that either the corresponding approach provides optimal solutions in polynomial time or one can derive a polynomial - size problem kernel with respect to the parameter maximum vertex degree of the underlying graph @xcite . moreover , we briefly indicate how this led in a feedback loop , so to speak to improvements also for the heuristic approach @xcite . in section [ sec : fast ] , we study parameterized local search the parameter is the degree of locality @xcite . local search is a key technique in combinatorial optimization and the design of `` improvement heuristics '' . we address both limitations and prospects of this approach . we discuss , among others , the np - hard example problems vertex cover and feedback arc set in tournaments . in section [ sec : pbo ] , we finally discuss how one may speed up parameterized algorithms by a clever use of heuristics . in particular , we discuss parameterization above lower bounds derived from linear programming relaxations @xcite ( here the key example is the np - hard vertex cover problem ) , and the idea of programming by optimization @xcite ( here the key example is the np - hard cluster editing problem ) . we draw some final conclusions in section [ sec : concl ] . [ [ preliminaries . ] ] preliminaries . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we assume familiarity with fundamental concepts of graph theory , algorithms , and complexity . a _ parameterized problem _ is a set of instances of the form @xmath2 , where @xmath3 for a finite alphabet @xmath4 , and @xmath5 is the _ parameter_. a parameterized problem @xmath6 is _ fixed - parameter tractable _ , shortly , if there exists an algorithm that on input @xmath2 decides whether @xmath2 is a yes - instance of @xmath6 in time @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is a computable function independent of @xmath9 . a parameterized problem @xmath6 is _ kernelizable _ if there exists a polynomial - time algorithm that maps an instance @xmath10 of @xmath6 to an instance @xmath11 of @xmath6 such that @xmath12 for some computable function @xmath13 , @xmath14 , and @xmath10 is a yes - instance of @xmath6 if and only if @xmath11 is a yes - instance of @xmath6 . the instance @xmath11 is called a _ kernel _ of @xmath2 . a problem that is w[1]-hard does not admit a fixed - parameter algorithm , unless the widely believed conjecture fpt@xmath15w[1 ] fails . in the following , we illustrate how the consideration of heuristic algorithms may lead to the definition of new interesting graph modification problems . our example concerns the interplay between two standard approaches for graph - based data clustering . one approach is to formalize desired properties of clusters and then to find a clustering of the graph such that the output clusters fulfill these properties . this clustering can be obtained by modifying the input graph for example by deleting edges so that all remaining edges are only inside clusters . starting with cluster editing @xcite , there are by now numerous parameterized algorithmics studies on graph modification problems related to clustering , varying on the cluster graph definition @xcite , the modification operation @xcite , or both @xcite . most of the examples of variants of cluster editing evolved primarily from a graph - theoretic interest . another approach is to define the clustering algorithmically , that is , to describe an algorithm that outputs a clustering and to analyze the properties of the clusters that are produced by the algorithm . in this section , we discuss how the consideration of a popular and natural clustering algorithm due to @xcite leads to the definition of the graph modification problem highly connected deletion . this is our key example for how to obtain practically motivated parameterized graph modification problems by a closer inspection of known heuristics . the study of this new problem then may yield new challenges for parameterized algorithmics and , furthermore , provide a better understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of the original heuristic algorithms . we will first discuss the original algorithm and then how we obtain the definition of highly connected deletion from this algorithm . posed the following connectivity demands on each cluster : the _ edge connectivity _ @xmath16 of a graph @xmath0 is the minimum number of edges whose deletion results in a disconnected graph , and a graph @xmath0 with @xmath17 vertices is called _ highly connected _ if @xmath18 . @xcite . ] the algorithm by @xcite partitions the vertex set of the given graph such that each partition set is highly connected by iteratively deleting the edges of a minimum cut in a connected component that is not yet highly connected . the output clusters of the algorithm are the connected components of the remaining graph which are then highly connected . the definition of being highly connected ensures several useful cluster properties , for example that at least half of the possible edges are present within each cluster and that each cluster has diameter at most two @xcite . while hartuv and shamir s algorithm guarantees to output a partitioning into _ highly connected _ subgraphs , it iteratively uses a greedy step to find small edge sets to delete . as a consequence , it is not ensured that the partitioning comes along with a _ minimum number of edge deletions _ making the resulting graphs consist of highly connected components . this naturally leads to the edge deletion problem highly connected deletion where the goal is to minimize the number of edge deletions ; this optimization goal is addressed only implicitly by hartuv and shamir s algorithm . = 10000 ( input ) at ( -3.75 + 0.05,+ 0.75 - 0.05 ) * input : * ; ( input.north west)+(-0.05,+0.05 ) rectangle ( 1.75,-- 0.25 ) ; = [ circle , draw = black!80,minimum size=12pt , inner sep=0pt ] at ( 0,+ 0.7 ) @xmath19 ; = [ circle , draw , fill = black!20,minimum size=5pt , inner sep=2pt ] iin 1, ... ,3 ( t - i ) at ( 0.7 cos(360 * i/ 3 - 3*(180 / 3))-2.5,0.7 sin(360 * i/ 3 - 3*(180 / 3 ) ) ) ; ( t-1 ) edge[- ] ( t-2 ) ; ( t-2 ) edge[- ] ( t-3 ) ; ( t-3 ) edge[- ] ( t-1 ) ; iin 1 , ... , ( k - i ) at ( cos(360 * i/ - 3*(180 / ) ) , sin(360 * i/ - 3*(180 / ) ) ) ; iin 2 , ... , ; ( k - i ) edge[- ] ( k- ) ; i/ in 1/4,1/5,2/5,3/5 ( k - i ) edge[- ] ( k- ) ; ( t-1 ) edge[- ] ( k-5 ) ; ( t-2 ) edge[- ] ( k-3 ) ; ( t-1 ) edge[- ] ( k-4 ) ; ; ( solution ) at ( -3.75 + 0.05,+ 0.75 - 0.05 ) * solution : * ; ( solution.north west)+(-0.05,+0.05 ) rectangle ( 1.75,-- 0.25 ) ; iin 1, ... ,3 ( t - i ) at ( 0.7 cos(360 * i/ 3 - 3*(180 / 3))-2.5,0.7 sin(360 * i/ 3 - 3*(180 / 3 ) ) ) ; ( t-1 ) edge[- ] ( t-2 ) ; ( t-2 ) edge[- ] ( t-3 ) ; ( t-3 ) edge[- ] ( t-1 ) ; iin 1 , ... , ( k - i ) at ( cos(360 * i/ - 3*(180 / ) ) , sin(360 * i/ - 3*(180 / ) ) ) ; iin 2 , ... , ; ( k - i ) edge[- ] ( k- ) ; i/ in 1/4,1/5,2/5,3/5 ( k - i ) edge[- ] ( k- ) ; ( t-1 ) edge[dashed ] ( k-5 ) ; ( t-2 ) edge[dashed ] ( k-3 ) ; ( t-1 ) edge[dashed ] ( k-4 ) ; interestingly , in the worst case the algorithm by @xcite does not give a good approximation for the optimization version of highly connected deletion . consider two cliques with vertex sets @xmath20 and @xmath21 , respectively , and the additional edges @xmath22 for @xmath23 . then these additional edges form a solution set of size @xmath24 ; however , hartuv and shamir s algorithm will ( with unlucky choices of minimum cuts ) transform one of the two cliques into an independent set by repeatedly cutting off one vertex , thereby deleting @xmath25 edges . the following theoretical results are known for highly connected deletion @xcite . it is np - hard even on 4-regular graphs and , provided the exponential time hypothesis ( eth ) @xcite is correct , can not be solved in subexponential time . on the positive side , there is a kernelization that can in polynomial time reduce an instance to one containing at most @xmath26 vertices , and an fpt algorithm that solves highly connected deletion in @xmath27 time . as to the relevance of parameterized algorithmics for highly connected deletion , one has to note that the mentioned fpt algorithm is impractical . in terms of exact solutions , an integer linear programming formulation combined with data reduction rules ( partially coming from the kernelization results ) , however , performs reasonably well @xcite . even when relaxing the goal to find exact solutions for highly connected deletion , data reduction turned out to be beneficial in combination with heuristics ( improving running time and solution quality ) @xcite . in a nutshell , the most practical contribution of parameterized algorithmics in this example is the development of efficient and effective data reduction rules , also helping to improve inexact solutions based on heuristics . a further benefit of considering a formally defined edge modification problem highly connected deletion is that the objective is now independent of a heuristic method used to find it . thus , it becomes possible to evaluate the biological quality of the objective @xcite . as to potential for future research with respect to highly connected deletion , so far other modification operations combined with the used cluster graph model are unexplored . improvements on the known kernelization for highly connected deletion may have direct practical impact . moreover , a first step to make the fpt algorithm more practical could be to devise a faster fpt algorithm that relies only on branching ( the current algorithm uses dynamic programming in a subroutine ) . finally , besides striving for improvements with respect to the standard parameter `` number of edge deletions '' , the investigation of other parameterizations may be interesting as well . from a more general perspective , however , it remains to `` remodel '' further heuristic algorithms into natural parameterized problems . while in the previous section we derived a natural parameterized problem ( highly connected deletion ) from a simple and effective greedy heuristic , in this section we demonstrate that the tools of parameterized complexity analysis and , in particular , kernelization , may be beneficial in understanding and improving a known heuristic on the one side , and in providing a rigorous mathematical analysis on the other side . here , we have examples in the context of graph completion problems , our key example here being the degree anonymity problem arising in the context of anonymizing social networks . for many scientific disciplines , including the understanding of the spread of diseases in a globalized world or power consumption habits with impacts on energy efficiency , the availability of social network data becomes more and more important . to respect privacy issues , there is a strong demand to anonymize the associated data in a preprocessing phase @xcite . if a graph contains only few vertices with some distinguished feature , then this might allow the identification ( and violation of privacy ) of the underlying real - world entities with that particular feature . hence , in order to ensure pretty good privacy and anonymity behavior , every vertex should share its feature with many other vertices . in a landmark paper , @xcite ( also see @xcite for an extended version ) considered the vertex degrees as feature ; see @xcite for other features considered in the literature . correspondingly , a graph is called _ @xmath28-anonymous _ if for each vertex there are at least @xmath29 other vertices of the same degree . therein , different values of @xmath28 reflect different privacy demands and the natural computational task arises to perform few changes to a graph in order to make it @xmath28-anonymous . = 10000 ( input ) at ( -0.5 + 0.05,2.7 - 0.05 ) * input : * ; ( input.north west)+(-0.05,+0.05 ) rectangle ( 3.5,-0.25 ) ; = [ circle , draw = black!80,minimum size=12pt , inner sep=0pt ] at ( 2.2,2.6 ) [ cols="^ " , ] ; = [ circle , draw , fill = black!20,minimum size=5pt , inner sep=2pt ] ( k-1 ) at ( 0,0 ) ; ( k-2 ) at ( 0,2 ) ; ( k-3 ) at ( 1,1 ) ; ( k-4 ) at ( 2,0 ) ; ( k-5 ) at ( 2,2 ) ; ( k-6 ) at ( 3,1 ) ; i/ in 1/4 , 2/3 , 3/4 , 3/5 , 5/6 ( k - i ) edge[- ] ( k- ) ; ; ( solution ) at ( -0.5 + 0.05,2.7 - 0.05 ) * solution : * ; ( solution.north west)+(-0.05,+0.05 ) rectangle ( 3.5,-0.25 ) ; = [ circle , draw , fill = black!20,minimum size=5pt , inner sep=2pt ] ( k-1 ) at ( 0,0 ) ; ( k-2 ) at ( 0,2 ) ; ( k-3 ) at ( 1,1 ) ; ( k-4 ) at ( 2,0 ) ; ( k-5 ) at ( 2,2 ) ; ( k-6 ) at ( 3,1 ) ; i/ in 1/4 , 2/3 , 3/4 , 3/5 , 5/6 ( k - i ) edge[- ] ( k- ) ; ( k-4 ) edge[-,thick ] ( k-6 ) ; the central parameterized complexity result for degree anonymity is that it has a polynomial - size problem kernel when parameterized by the maximum vertex degree @xmath30 of the input graph @xcite . in other words , there is a polynomial - time algorithm that transforms any input instance into an equivalent instance with @xmath31 vertices . indeed , one encounters a `` win - win '' situation when proving this result : liu and terzi s heuristic strategy @xcite finds an optimal solution when the size @xmath32 of a minimum solution is larger than @xmath33 . hence , either one can solve the problem in polynomial time or the solution size is `` small '' . as a consequence , one can bound @xmath32 in @xmath34 and , hence , a polynomial kernel for the combined parameter @xmath35 actually is also a polynomial kernel only for @xmath30 . while this kernelization directly implies fixed - parameter tractability for degree anonymity parameterized by @xmath30 , there is also an fpt algorithm running in @xmath36 time . the ideas behind the `` win - win '' situation generalize to further graph completion problems where the task is to insert edges so that the degree sequence of the resulting graph fulfills some prescribed property @xmath1 @xcite . furthermore , an experimental evaluation of the usefulness of the theoretical results on the `` win - win '' situation delivered encouraging results even beyond the theoretical guarantees , that is , when @xmath37 @xcite . this led to an enhancement of the heuristic due to @xcite which substantially improves on the previously known theoretical and empirical running times . as for highly connected deletion , previously known heuristic solutions could be substantially improved in terms of solution quality . finally , we mention in passing that making a graph @xmath28-anonymous was studied from a parameterized point of view using also several other graph modification operations @xcite . all these studies are of purely theoretical nature and there are only little positive algorithmic results ; links with heuristic algorithm design are missing . from a general perspective , the quest arising from the findings for degree anonymity is to provide further examples where parameterized complexity analysis sheds new light on known heuristics , both theoretically and practically . a good starting point might be the heuristic of @xcite which clusters the vertices and then anonymizes each cluster . here , the question is whether such a practical link between anonymization and clustering could be complemented with theoretical results . obviously , these studies should not be limited to problems arising in anonymization but to graph modification problems from different application areas . local search is a generic algorithmic paradigm that yields good heuristics for many optimization problems . the idea is to start with any feasible solution and then search for a better one in the local neighborhood of this solution . this search is continued until a locally optimal solution is found . for graph modification problems , a feasible solution @xmath38 is any set of modification operations that transforms the input graph into one that satisfies the graph property @xmath1 . the local neighborhood of @xmath38 is usually defined as the sets of modification operations that can be obtained by adding and removing at most @xmath32 vertices from @xmath38 . this type of neighborhood is called @xmath32-exchange neighborhood . an obvious approach to obtain more powerful local search algorithms is to reduce the running time needed for searching the local neighborhood . this could enable a local search algorithm to examine larger neighborhoods and reduce the likelihood to remain in a locally optimal but globally suboptimal solution . usually , the size of the @xmath32-exchange neighborhood in an @xmath17-vertex graph is upper - bounded by @xmath39 for some function @xmath8 . in parameterized algorithmics , a natural question is whether it is necessary to consider all elements of this neighborhood or whether the neighborhood can be searched faster , that is , in @xmath40 time . for many vertex deletion problems this is not the case @xcite . for example , in the local search variant of vertex cover , one is given a _ vertex cover _ @xmath38 , that is , a vertex set @xmath38 such that deleting @xmath38 from a graph @xmath0 results in an independent set . the task is to find a smaller vertex cover @xmath41 by adding and removing at most @xmath32 vertices from @xmath38 . = 10000 unfortunately , unless w[1]@xmath42fpt , there is no fpt algorithm for local search vertex cover parameterized by @xmath32 @xcite . positive results were obtained for special cases . for example , local search vertex cover and many other local search variants of vertex deletion problems are fixed - parameter tractable on planar graphs @xcite . these results , however , are based on the technique of locally bounded treewidth . as a consequence , the resulting algorithms might not be useful in practice . positive results were obtained for feedback arc set in tournaments which is the problem of transforming a tournament , that is , a directed graph in which every pair of vertices is connected by exactly one of the two possible arcs , into an acyclic graph by a minimum number of arc deletions . here , the local search problem is fixed - parameter tractable . more precisely , given a set @xmath38 of arc deletions that makes a given tournament acyclic , it can be decided in @xmath43 time whether there is a set @xmath41 that can be obtained from @xmath38 by adding and removing at most @xmath32 arcs @xcite . this positive result seems to be rooted in the combinatorially restricted nature of tournaments and _ not _ in the fact that feedback arc set in tournaments is an arc modification problem : the local search variant of the similarly simple cluster editing problem is not fixed - parameter tractable unless w[1]@xmath42fpt @xcite . summarizing , the natural idea of parameterized local search faces two major obstacles . the first obstacle is that , as discussed above , many local search problems are probably not fixed - parameter tractable . the second obstacle is that , so far , none of the parameterized local search algorithms for graph modification problems have been shown to be useful in practice . one encouraging result was obtained for incremental list coloring @xcite . here , the input is a graph with a list - coloring that colors all graph vertices except one . the task is to obtain a list - coloring that also colors @xmath44 and disagrees with the old list - coloring on at most @xmath45 vertices . thus , the new solution is searched within the neighborhood of the old solution . this problem can be solved in @xmath46 time where @xmath32 is the maximum size of any color list in the input . the crucial observation is that this local search - like approach can be embedded in a coloring heuristic that outperforms the standard greedy coloring algorithm in terms of the coloring number . since incremental list coloring is w[1]-hard with respect to the parameter @xmath45 , the key to success seems to be the consideration of the combined parameter @xmath47 . a goal for future research should thus be to obtain similar success stories for local search variants of graph modification problems . as demonstrated by incremental list coloring , one promising route is the consideration of combined parameters . from a more general perspective , the fpt algorithm for incremental list coloring and parameterized local search have in common that they use the power provided by allowing fpt running time instead of polynomial running time to improve known heuristics . this approach , which has been coined `` turbo - charging heuristics '' @xcite , has close connections to dynamic versions of hard graph problems @xcite . heuristics are often used to boost the performance of exact algorithms in practice . a prominent example here is the branch - and - bound concept where heuristic lower and upper bounds restrict the search space for search - tree algorithms @xcite . better heuristic bounds give a smaller search space and thus faster exact algorithms . when analyzed in the classic complexity framework , the theoretical running time improvements due to the heuristic bounds are ( if at all ) marginal compared to the speed - ups observed in practice . here , parameterized algorithmics can be used to give some theoretical explanation for experimental observations by using the above - guarantee parameterization @xcite . as the name suggests , the parameter is the difference between the size of an optimal solution and a given lower bound . fixed - parameter tractability with respect to the above - guarantee parameter then shows that the problem of finding a solution close to the lower bound is `` easy '' . thus , if the corresponding lower bound is close to the optimum , then the corresponding algorithm using this lower bound is fast in practice _ and _ in theory . an example for above - lower bound parameterization is vertex cover . one lower bound on the size of a vertex cover is the value @xmath28 of a linear programming ( lp ) relaxation . the well - known lp relaxation is as follows : @xmath48 it is known that in an optimal solution for the lp relaxation each variable has value 0 , , or 1 @xcite . = 10000 ( input ) at ( -0.5 + 0.05,2.7 - 0.05 ) * input : * ; ( input.north west)+(-0.05,+0.05 ) rectangle ( 3.5,-0.25 ) ; = [ circle , draw = black!80,minimum size=12pt , inner sep=0pt ] at ( 1,2.6 ) @xmath19 , @xmath49 ; = [ circle , draw , fill = black!20,minimum size=5pt , inner sep=2pt ] / / / in 0/0.5//0 , 1/0//-0.9 , 1/1//0 , 2/0.5/1/0 , 3/0/0/-0.9 , 3/1/0/0 ( k - i ) at ( , + 0.5 ) ; i/ in 1/2 , 1/3 , 2/3 , 3/4 , 2/4 , 4/5 , 4/6 ( k - i ) edge[- ] ( k- ) ; ; ( solution ) at ( -0.5 + 0.05,2.7 - 0.05 ) * solution : * ; ( solution.north west)+(-0.05,+0.05 ) rectangle ( 3.5,-0.25 ) ; = [ circle , draw , minimum size=5pt , inner sep=2pt ] / / in 0/0.5/black!20 , 1/0/black , 1/1/black , 2/0.5/black , 3/0/black!20 , 3/1/black!20 ( k - i ) at ( , + 0.5 ) ; i/ in 1/2 , 1/3 , 2/3 , 3/4 , 2/4 , 4/5 , 4/6 ( k - i ) edge[- ] ( k- ) ; @xcite presented an algorithm solving vertex cover above lp in @xmath50 time . on a high level , this algorithm starts with the lower bound and uses , after some preprocessing , a standard search - tree algorithm . thus , a good lower bound allows not only in practice , but also in theory for an efficient algorithm solving vertex cover . moreover , the fixed - parameter tractability result now may help explaining why heuristics can successfully exploit the lower bound provided by the lp relaxation . another example for heuristic tuning of algorithms is programming by optimization @xcite . this is a helpful and powerful tool for developing fast implementations . here , the basic idea is that the implementation leaves open several design choices for different parts of the algorithm these are settled later when training the algorithm with real - world instances . then , for the final configuration of the implementation , let a program choose from the alternatives in such a way that the performance is optimized on a representative set of instances . here , the automated optimizer can give an answer to the following questions : * given several alternative implementations for one subproblem ( for example different sorting algorithms or different lower bounds ) , which one should be chosen ? * should a certain data reduction rule be applied ? * what are the `` best '' values for certain `` magic '' or `` hidden '' constants ? for example , should a data reduction rule be applied in every second level of the search tree or every fourth level ? the programming by optimization approach has led to a state - of - the - art solver for cluster editing @xcite . this solver combines one sophisticated data reduction rule and a branch - and - bound algorithm . the solver outperforms previous algorithms which are based on integer linear programming ( ilp ) and pure branch - and - bound . thus , with the help of programming by optimization , implementations of parameterized algorithms may successfully compete with ilp - based algorithms . on a high level , programming by optimization can be seen as a heuristic counterpart to parameterized algorithmics : parameterized algorithmics provides theoretical bounds on the running time of algorithms and the effectiveness of data reduction rules . these bounds depend on the parameter . thus , to solve a problem for a specific type of data , one should measure different parameters and choose , based on this measurement , the most promising data reduction rules and algorithms . with programming by optimization , this choice is made automatically , based on the performance of the algorithm on a given representative set of test instances . furthermore , the choice is not based on the values of parameters but directly on the efficiency of the corresponding algorithms on the test data . a goal for future research is to further increase the benefit obtained by combining the strengths of programming by optimization and parameterized algorithmics . this could be done , for example , by first providing several fpt algorithms for the same problem with different parameters and then using programming by optimization to find a good strategy to pick the best algorithm depending on the structure of an input instance . as karp @xcite pointed out , one of the most pressing challenges in theoretical computer science is to contribute to a better understanding why many heuristics work so well in practice . in particular , a formal footing of the construction of heuristic algorithms is considered highly desirable . this task is also closely connected to ( hidden ) structure detection in real - world input instances . we discussed several routes to a beneficial interaction between heuristic and parameterized algorithm design to date , a clear majority of research results in parameterized algorithmics is of purely theoretical nature . a natural way to increase the practical impact of parameterized algorithmics is to seek fruitful interactions with the field of heuristic algorithm design . we believe that particularly graph ( modification ) problems may be a forerunner in offering numerous fruitful research opportunities in this direction . so far the strongest impact achieved by parameterized algorithmics on practical computing and heuristics is due to kernelization , and polynomial - time data reduction techniques in general . notably , often data reduction rules seemingly not strong enough to provide kernelization results may still have strong practical impact . moreover , a general route for future research is to develop heuristic algorithms in parallel with performing a parameterized complexity analysis ( particularly , in terms of kernelization ) . as results for graph modification problems in this direction demonstrate , there are good prospects to win something in both worlds . finally , in this paper we focused on np - hard graph modification problems for illustrative examples . it goes without saying that our general remarks and observations are not limited to graph modification problems only but clearly extend to further graph problems and fields beyond , e.g. string algorithms @xcite or computational social choice @xcite .

in graph modification problems , one is given a graph @xmath0 and the goal is to apply a minimum number of modification operations ( such as edge deletions ) to @xmath0 such that the resulting graph fulfills a certain property . for example , the cluster deletion problem asks to delete as few edges as possible such that the resulting graph is a disjoint union of cliques . graph modification problems appear in numerous applications , including the analysis of biological and social networks . typically , graph modification problems are np - hard , making them natural candidates for parameterized complexity studies . we discuss several fruitful interactions between the development of fixed - parameter algorithms and the design of heuristics for graph modification problems , featuring quite different aspects of mutual benefits .

0801.2927

turbulent aerosols are of interest in a variety of natural and technological systems . two very important examples are water droplets in turbulent rain clouds @xcite and dust grains in turbulent accretion disks around growing stars @xcite . in both of these systems the aerosol is unstable because the suspended particles collide ( leading to aggregation or possibly fragmentation of the aerosol particles ) . the collision processes therefore have significant consequences : the formation of rain in one case , and the widely hypothesised mechanism for the formation of planets in the other . collisions always occur due to molecular diffusion , but ( as pointed out by smoluchowski @xcite ) , macroscopic fluid motion can considerably increase the collision rate . if the suspended particles are sufficiently heavy ( so that their inertia becomes relevant ) , they can move relative to the fluid . in this case the occurrence of caustics will typically increase the collision rate by several orders of magnitude @xcite . if the aerosol particles are sufficiently light , their molecular diffusion can make a significant contribution to the collision rate , which can be estimated by standard kinetic theory . in this paper we are concerned with the effect of macroscopic motion of a fluid on small particles which have insignificant inertia , so that they follow the flow ( advective motion ) . the seminal papers in this area were due to smoluchowski @xcite , who first considered the effect of shear of the fluid flow on collisions , and saffman & turner @xcite , who gave a formula for the collision rate which has formed the basis for most subsequent work on this problem . their paper was motivated by a problem in meteorology argued that small - scale turbulence in convecting clouds can accelerate collisions between microscopic water droplets , thus initiating rain formation : in this case the particles are brought into contact by hyperbolic or shearing motions of the turbulent flow . the formula for the collision rate by saffman & turner @xcite has been used frequently in the past five decades in cloud physics and in chemical engineering problems . it appears to be widely accepted that their expression is an exact relation for the collision rate in a dilute suspension . in the following we show that the saffman - turner estimate describes an initial transient of the problem only . for particles suspended in incompressible flows , the collision rate falls below the initial transient ( which thus constitutes an upper bound ) . for particles advected in a compressible flows , however , homogeneously distributed particles will cluster in a compressible fluid ( see for example @xcite ) . the clustering may increase the collision rate beyond its initial transient . the saffman - turner approximation treats the flow surrounding a test particle as if it were a steady hyperbolic flow , while in reality the flow fluctuates as a function of time . in section [ sec : 3.2 ] below we give an extension of the saffman - turner formula which does give the collision rate exactly . unfortunately the formula contains information about the time - dependence of the flow , and it is impossible to evaluate it in the general case . because of the importance of understanding collision rates for aerosol particles , it is desirable to find exactly solvable cases which can be used as a benchmark for numerical studies . the collision rate must depend on a dimensionless parameter describing how quickly the fluid velocity fluctuates , the kubo number @xcite . we are able to obtain precise asymptotic results on the collision rate in the limit where the kubo number approaches zero . in this case , particle separations undergo a diffusion process . by solving the corresponding fokker - planck equation we can determine the collision rate exactly . the remainder of this paper is organised as follows . in section [ sec : 2 ] we introduce the equations of motion and the dimensionless parameters of the problem . section [ sec : 3 ] discusses the saffman - turner theory and our extension of it . section [ sec : 3.1 ] describes the expression for the collision rate given in @xcite which is the starting point of our discussions . ( some new results on the evaluation of the saffman - turner expression are described in the appendix ) . in section [ sec : 3.2 ] we discuss our exact formula for the collision rate , and explain why the saffman - turner approximation describes an initial transient only . in sections [ sec : 4]-[sec : 6 ] we discuss how exact asymptotic results may be found for the limit of small kubo number . a fokker - planck equation for the probability density of the separation of particles is described in section [ sec : 4 ] . in section [ sec : 5 ] this is used to obtain the steady - state collision rate and section [ sec : 6 ] gives the full time dependence of the collision rate . these results are compared to numerical simulations in section [ sec : 7 ] , which also contains some concluding remarks , discussing scope for further work in this area . finally , we remark that a brief summary of some of the results of this paper has already been published @xcite . here we discuss the problem in greater depth and generality , and derive expressions for the time - dependent collision rate which were not discussed in @xcite . we consider spherical particles of radius @xmath0 in a fluid with velocity field @xmath1 which has an apparently random motion , usually as a result of turbulence . we assume that the suspended particles do not modify the surrounding flow . when the inertia of the particles is negligible , they are advected by the flow : @xmath2 it is assumed that direct interactions between the particles can be neglected until they collide . in other words , the particles follow equation ( [ eq : 2.1 ] ) until their separation falls below @xmath3 . we model the complex flow of a turbulent fluid by a random velocity field @xmath4 . we consider flows in both two and three spatial dimensions and for convenience we use a gaussian distributed field when we carry through concrete computations . in most cases we are concerned with incompressible flow , satisfying @xmath5 . particles floating on the surface of a fluid may experience a partly compressible flow @xcite , as may particles in gases moving with speeds comparable to the speed of sound . for these reasons we also consider partially compressible flows . it is convenient to construct the random velocity field @xmath1 from scalar stream functions or potentials @xcite . in two spatial dimensions we write @xmath6 where @xmath7 is a normalisation factor and @xmath8 and @xmath9 are independent gaussian random functions . we shall use angle brackets to denote averaging throughout . the fields @xmath10 and @xmath11 have zero averages , @xmath12 , @xmath13 and they both have same correlation function , @xmath14 : @xmath15 where @xmath16 and @xmath17 . this two - point correlation function @xmath14 is a smooth function decaying ( sufficiently rapidly ) to zero for large values of @xmath18 and @xmath19 . for @xmath20 , the flow ( [ eq : 2.2 ] ) is incompressible . for finite values of @xmath21 it acquires a compressible component . in the limit of @xmath22 the flow is purely potential . in some cases the physics of a problem dictates that @xmath8 and @xmath9 should have different correlation functions ; many of our results can be generalised in this way . in three spatial dimensions we write @xmath23 where @xmath24 and @xmath9 are four independent scalar fields with zero mean and with the same correlation function @xmath14 ; and @xmath25 is a normalisation factor . in the remainder of this paper we choose the normalisation factors to be of the form @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the standard deviation of the magnitude of the velocity and @xmath28 denotes the second derivative of the correlation function ( [ eq : 2.3 ] ) with respect to its first argument . fully - developed turbulent flows have a power - law spectrum in the inertial range , covering a wide band of wavenumbers @xcite . this feature can be incorporated by giving @xmath14 a suitable algebraic behaviour over a range of values of @xmath18 , as explained in @xcite . the long - ranged behaviour of the velocity field is not , however , relevant to the advective collision mechanism . it therefore suffices to consider a model with a short - ranged velocity correlation : for the numerical work reported in this paper we used following form of the correlation function @xmath29 where @xmath30 is a constant . in our numerical simulations we represent the flow field by its fourier components which are subject to an ornstein - uhlenbeck process as suggested by sigurgeirson & stuart @xcite . lc + & + particle size & @xmath0 + typical velocity fluctuation & @xmath27 + correlation length of the flow & @xmath31 + correlation time of the flow & @xmath32 + number density of particles & @xmath33 + compressibility & @xmath21 + spatial dimension & @xmath34 + + our problem is characterised by the six parameters listed in table [ tab:1 ] . from the parameters in table [ tab:1 ] , three independent dimensionless combinations can be formed : @xmath35 the first parameter characterises the dimensionless speed of the flow and is called kubo number , discussed in @xcite . note that @xmath36 is not possible , because the motion of the fluid places an upper limit on the correlation time . steady , fully developed turbulence corresponds to @xmath37 . the kubo number can be small for randomly stirred fluids . it is only in the limit @xmath38 that we are able to obtain precise and explicit estimates for the collision rate : this case is considered in sections [ sec : 4]-[sec : 6 ] . the second parameter in ( [ eq : 2.7 ] ) is the packing fraction of particles . throughout we assume that this parameter is small . similarly , the third parameter in ( [ eq : 2.7 ] ) is usually taken to be small . we note that kalda @xcite has considered the collision rate for particles in a non - smooth velocity field : this could be relevant to the case where @xmath39 . throughout this paper we consider the rate of collision of a given particle with any other particle , denoting this by @xmath40 . some papers consider the total rate of collision per unit volume . if the spatial density of particles is @xmath33 , the total rate of collision per unit volume is @xmath41 ( the factor of @xmath42 avoids double - counting ) . we will not be concerned with what happens after particles undergo their first collision : in different physical circumstances they may coalesce , scatter , or fragment , but in this paper we are concerned only with their first contact . we assume that the particles are spherical ( or circular , in two - dimensional calculations ) and that they all have the same radius , @xmath0 . we regard the particles as having collided when their separation reaches @xmath3 , and we neglect effects due to the interaction of the particles and the fluid . in practice the fluid trapped between approaching particles may slightly reduce the collision rate @xcite , but this effect can be accounted for by replacing the radius by an effective radius . the problem of calculating the rate of collision therefore reduces to the following problem . we consider a given particle , and transform to a frame where the centre of this particle is at the origin , and the separation of the centre of another particle is denoted by @xmath43 . initially , the reference particle is surrounded by a gas of particles with spatial density @xmath33 . we assume that these are initially randomly distributed , apart from the constraint that none of the particles is in contact with the reference particle . collisions with the test particle occur when other particles come within a radius @xmath3 of the reference particle . the rate of collisions is therefore the rate at which particles cross a sphere of radius @xmath3 centred at the origin in the relative coordinate system . this is obtained by integrating the inward radial velocity over the sphere , and multiplying by the density @xmath33 . this approach gives an expression for the collision rate which we term @xmath44 : @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the radial velocity at spherical coordinate @xmath47 , radius @xmath18 and time @xmath48 . the function @xmath49 is a heaviside step function , which is used to select regions of the surface where the flow is into the sphere of radius @xmath3 . this is the fundamental expression for the collision rate given by saffman & turner @xcite . in section [ sec : 3.2 ] we discuss why this expression is not exact , and give the precise formula . the remainder of this section considers how this expression is evaluated ; some new results are presented in the appendix . the evaluation of ( [ eq : 3.1 ] ) is greatly simplified in the case where the particles are small , in the sense that @xmath50 . in this case the relative velocity is accurately approximated using the velocity gradient of the random velocity field @xmath51 . this approximation was also considered by saffman & turner @xcite . to lowest order in @xmath52 , the relative velocity @xmath53 is approximated as @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the rate of strain matrix of the flow @xmath56 , with elements @xmath57 ( and @xmath58 ) . two particles with radii @xmath59 moving close to each other will thus experience a relative velocity @xmath60 . this is illustrated in figure [ fig : 1 ] for a flow which is hyperbolic in the vicinity of the reference particle . the corresponding relative radial speed @xmath61 is @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the radial unit vector . in particular , at the distance @xmath64 where particles collide , the radial speed is @xmath65 . thus when @xmath50 , equation ( [ eq : 3.1 ] ) reduces to @xmath66 this expression was also obtained in @xcite . the remainder of this subsection is concerned with the evaluation of ( [ eq : 3.2 ] ) . schematic picture of two particles of radius @xmath0 passing each other in a hyperbolic flow . the particle at the origin will see particles move past on hyperbolic trajectories . collisions occur whenever particles approach closer than @xmath3 . the collision rate is thus determined by the influx of particles into a disc of radius @xmath3 ( dashed line ) around the origin.,width=226 ] earlier , smoluchowski @xcite had considered the special case of a fluid flowing with a uniform shear in @xmath67 dimensions : @xmath68 he obtained the collision rate : @xmath69 which is in agreement with the result of evaluating ( [ eq : 3.2 ] ) for this case . for a general strain - rate matrix @xmath70 the evaluation of ( [ eq : 3.2 ] ) is , however , very difficult . in [ sec : appa ] we discuss how this expression is evaluated for a general matrix @xmath71 in two dimensions , and for a general traceless matrix ( representing an incompressible flow ) in three dimensions . in a turbulent flow , saffman & turner @xcite argued that the elements of @xmath71 change as a function of position and one needs to average over the ensemble of strain matrices @xmath70 at different positions in order to estimate the collision rate , so that ( [ eq : 3.2 ] ) is replaced by : @xmath72 at first sight the requirement to average over @xmath71 appears to complicate the problem . however , for a rotationally invariant ensemble of random flows , the problem is considerably simplified by taking the average . in an incompressible flow , for each realisation of @xmath1 , the currents into and out of the collision region ( the disk or sphere of radius @xmath3 ) cancel precisely . therefore ( [ eq : 3.5 ] ) can be written as @xmath73 ) or ( [ eq : 2.4 ] ) , with @xmath74 . this is demonstrated by the following argument ( here we discuss the two - dimensional case ) . if we did not include the factor @xmath75 in ( [ eq : 3.6 ] ) , we would calculate the sum of the collision rate for the flow @xmath51 and for the time - reversed flow @xmath76 . the time reversed flow is generated by reversing the signs of the potentials @xmath9 and @xmath8 in ( [ eq : 2.2 ] ) . the probability density for the gaussian field @xmath77 is the same as for @xmath9 ( and similarly for @xmath8 ) . it follows that the collision rate for the time - reversed flow @xmath76 is the same as for @xmath51 . the expression ( [ eq : 3.6 ] ) is therefore also valid for the cases of compressible flow which we consider in this paper . now using rotational symmetry , one finds the very simple expression @xmath78 where @xmath79 is the the area of the sphere of radius @xmath3 in @xmath34 dimensions ( explicitly @xmath80 and @xmath81 ) . for the gaussian model flow which we consider , equation ( [ eq : 3.7 ] ) gives @xmath82 with @xmath83 the saffman - turner expression for the collision rate , equation ( [ eq : 3.1 ] ) or ( [ eq : 3.7 ] ) , correctly describes the initial collision rate . there are , however , two reasons why the collision rate may approach a significantly different value after an initial transient . the first reason why ( [ eq : 3.1 ] ) may fail arises from the fact that the flow field fluctuates in time . recall that we are concerned with the rate at which pairs of particles collide for the first time if the flow is time - dependent , the relative position coordinate @xmath84 may pass through the sphere of radius @xmath3 more than once . this effect may be accounted for by writing the collision rate in the form @xmath85 as before @xmath86 is the @xmath34-dimensional surface element at @xmath64 and @xmath61 is the radial velocity component ( the relative speed ) and the heaviside step function ensures that only particles entering the sphere contribute to the collision rate . the factor @xmath87 is the density of particles in the neighbourhood of the test particle at time @xmath48 . the function @xmath88 is an indicator function : it is equal to unity if the point reaching the surface element @xmath47 at radius @xmath3 and at time @xmath48 has not previously passed through the sphere of radius @xmath3 , otherwise it is zero . the effect of including the function @xmath88 is illustrated in figure [ fig : 2 ] . the collision rate will reduce below the saffman - turner estimate for times where @xmath88 is no longer unity .. initial positions of particles which have collided with a reference particle at the origin after a certain time ( shaded regions ) . the collision region ( disk of radius @xmath3 ) is bounded by a dashed circle . at short times this region extends along the direction of the stable eigenvector of the initial flow . at intermediate times , we see the effect of this eigenvector having rotated . at long times , the set of colliding initial conditions is stretched and folded . the shaded region then covers most of the surface of the circle , including the region where the radial velocity is inward . the figure shows results of a simulated flow with small kubo number , of the type discussed in section [ sec : 4 ] , at times @xmath89 , @xmath90 and @xmath91 . , width=566 ] in the general case ( [ eq : 3.13 ] ) is difficult to evaluate since the indicator function @xmath88 depends on the history of the flow . if the flow is rapidly fluctuating ( that is , if the kubo number of the flow is small ) , the relative separation of two particles undergoes a diffusion process which makes it possible to exactly evaluate the collision rate for a given ensemble of random flows . a second effect may modify the collision rate from the saffman - turner estimate is that if the flow field is compressible , particles may cluster together , and the particle density in the vicinity of a test particle may be higher than the average density . this effect is expected to cause the collision rate to increase , after an initial transient during which the clustering becomes established . again , this effect is very hard to quantify in the general case , but we can obtain precise asymptotic results in the limit of small kubo number , where a diffusion approximation becomes applicable . because we consider particles which are advected by the flow , there is no clustering effect when the flow is incompressible . we note that for incompressible flow the only correction to the saffman - turner estimate is the occurrence of the factor @xmath88 in ( [ eq : 3.13 ] ) . this implies that for advected particles in an incompressible flow , the saffman - turner estimate of the collision rate is an upper bound . in the limit of a rapidly changing flow , that is when @xmath92 , particle separations @xmath93 undergo a diffusion process ( see @xcite for a review ) . by solving the corresponding fokker - planck equation with the appropriate boundary conditions , we can determine the collision rate exactly in this limit . consider two particles , one at @xmath94 and the other in its vicinity , at @xmath95 . the equation of motion ( [ eq : 2.1 ] ) implies that their separation @xmath96 obeys @xmath97 integrating ( [ eq : 4.1 ] ) over a short time interval @xmath98 we obtain @xmath99 the moments of the components @xmath100 of @xmath101 are : @xmath102 assuming that @xmath103 . we thus obtain the following fokker - planck equation for the density @xmath104 of particle separations @xcite : @xmath105 here @xmath106 is a diffusion matrix with diffusion coefficients @xmath107\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in terms of the correlation function @xmath14 introduced in section [ sec : 2 ] we have @xmath108\ , . \end{array}\ ] ] in order to determine the collision rate it is convenient to write the fokker - planck equation in the form of a continuity equation @xmath109 where the components of the probability current can be identified as @xmath110 . the collision rate @xmath111 between particles of radius @xmath0 is given by the rate at which the particle separation @xmath18 decreases below @xmath3 @xcite . this rate equals the radial probability current of particle separations evaluated at @xmath64 , i.e. @xmath112 where @xmath113 is the radial unit vector . we evaluate ( [ eq : 4.8 ] ) in two steps . first ( in section [ sec : 5 ] ) we determine the steady - state collision rate as @xmath114 . second , we determine the full time - dependence of the collision rate ( section [ sec : 6 ] ) , describing how the initial transient discussed in section [ sec : 3 ] approaches the steady state . because of the angular symmetry of the statistics of the fluid velocity , it is convenient to transform ( [ eq : 4.4 ] ) to spherical coordinates . the probability density @xmath115 depends on the separation @xmath18 only and obeys @xmath116 here the radial probability current @xmath117 is given by @xmath118 with @xmath119\,,{\nonumber}\\ g(r)&={\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}{\rm d}t}\big[(d-1+\beta^2)c''(0,t ) -\frac{d-1}{r}c'(r , t)-\beta^2c''(r , t)\big]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] consider now the steady - state solution of ( [ eq : 4.4 ] ) , obeying @xmath120 . the steady - state collision rate , denoted by @xmath121 , is determined by ( [ eq : 4.8 ] ) in terms of the steady - state current . the total current @xmath122 entering a sphere of radius @xmath18 and area @xmath123 must be a constant . this gives @xmath124 where @xmath121 is a constant , equal to the collision rate which we wish to determine . the equation of motion ( [ eq : 2.1 ] ) is only physically meaningful when @xmath59 , so that the fluid velocity is approximately the same throughout all of the region occupied by the particle . we will , however , solve the diffusion equation for general @xmath0 . one reason for treating the general case is that it is hard to verify the analytical expressions for the limiting case @xmath125 in numerical investigations . to determine this current , it is necessary to consider the appropriate boundary conditions first , if the particle distribution initially is uniform with density @xmath33 , we expect it to remain so at large separations . thus we use the boundary condition @xmath126 the boundary condition ( [ eq : 5.1 ] ) is implemented as follows . for a specified current density @xmath117 we can solve ( [ eq : 4.10 ] ) by finding an integrating factor @xmath127 : @xmath128 with integration constant @xmath129 and @xmath130 the boundary condition ( [ eq : 5.1 ] ) determines the integration constant in ( [ eq : 5.2 ] ) to be @xmath131 . second , when particles comes closer than the distance of @xmath3 they collide and must be removed . this is taken care of by the following boundary condition at @xmath3 : @xmath132 inserting this boundary condition into ( [ eq : 5.2 ] ) yields @xmath133 using @xmath134 and solving for the constant @xmath121 we find the following expression for the collision rate : @xmath135^{-1}\ ] ] where @xmath136 is the gamma function . equation ( [ eq : 5.6 ] ) is the main result of this section . we continue by discussing a number of limiting cases . for an incompressible flow ( @xmath137 ) , the integrating factor is just unity ( incompressibility @xmath138 implies @xmath139 which in turn implies that the term proportional to @xmath115 in ( [ eq : 4.10 ] ) vanishes ) . in this case , equation ( [ eq : 5.6 ] ) simplifies to @xmath140^{-1}\hspace*{-3mm}\ , . \label{eq : 5.7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath142 , the strength of the solenoidal and potential parts of the field are equal . this case may be relevant to the dynamics of particles floating on the surface of a turbulent fluid @xcite . the collision rate can be evaluated exactly in this case , by rewriting ( [ eq : 5.6 ] ) as @xmath143^{-1}\ , . \label{eq : 5.8}\end{aligned}\ ] ] setting @xmath144 we find @xmath145 for @xmath146 . when @xmath147 we obtain @xmath148 what makes it possible to find exact solutions in this case is the fact that when @xmath142 , the functions @xmath149 and @xmath150 in ( [ eq : 4.11 ] ) are related as @xmath151 . note that this relation is always true in one spatial dimension , independent of the value of @xmath21 . note also that when @xmath151 , equation ( [ eq : 4.10 ] ) can be solved for @xmath115 by integration ( starting at e.g. @xmath3 , with @xmath152 ) @xmath153 thus , a non - vanishing steady - state collision rate is obtained only if @xmath154 or when @xmath147 . the collision rate must vanish as the particle size approaches zero . this means that the integral in the denominator in ( [ eq : 5.6 ] ) must diverge for small @xmath0 . thus if @xmath59 is small enough , the major contribution in the integral in ( [ eq : 5.6 ] ) comes from small values of @xmath18 and the relative error will be small if we replace the integrand by its small @xmath18 expansion . it is convenient to change variables according to @xmath155 . we expand @xmath156 and obtain approximately @xmath157 here the parameter @xmath158 is defined as @xmath159 it corresponds to the diffusion constant @xmath160 in equation ( 39 ) of @xcite and in the incompressible case it corresponds to the diffusion constant @xmath158 defined in equation ( 17 ) of @xcite : here @xmath161 is an alternative parametrisation of the compressibility , defined as follows @xmath162 the parameter @xmath161 was also used in @xcite ( and earlier work cited therein ) . it can take values between @xmath163 and @xmath164 . here @xmath165 corresponds to a completely incompressible flow with @xmath137 and @xmath166 corresponds to a purely potential ( @xmath167 ) compressible flow . in particular , when @xmath168 the field strengths of the compressible and incompressible components of the flow are equal , @xmath142 . using equations ( [ eq : 5.13 ] ) , we get the collision rate for small particles @xmath169 this expression was previously derived in @xcite . for an incompressible flow , with @xmath170 , the particle density is uniform and the collision rate is proportional to the packing fraction @xmath171 as expected . by contrast , if the flow is compressible , the particles will cluster on a fractal set @xcite . this is expected to enhance the collision rate because the particle density is large within the clusters . the clustering effect can be characterised by the correlation dimension of the particles , @xmath172 . it is defined by the scaling law @xmath173 , where @xmath174 is the probability that the particle separation is smaller than @xmath175 @xcite . we have @xmath176 and thus @xmath177 . this expression was derived in @xcite . equation ( [ eq : 5.16 ] ) shows that in compressible flows , the collision rate depends upon the correlation dimension @xmath178 . when @xmath179 the collision rate in a compressible flow is therefore much larger than the corresponding rate in an incompressible flow . note finally that the steady - state collision rate ( [ eq : 5.16 ] ) tends to zero when @xmath180 , i.e. when @xmath181 . for values of @xmath21 larger than @xmath182 , no steady - state current satisfying our boundary conditions exists . in one spatial dimension the parameter @xmath182 vanishes : no non - trivial steady state exists because all particle trajectories eventually coalesce ( this effect was termed path - coalescence wilkinson & mehlig @xcite ) . when the correlation function @xmath14 is of the gaussian form ( [ eq : 2.6 ] ) , we obtain from ( [ eq : 5.6 ] ) @xmath183{\nonumber}\\ & \times\exp{\left(}\beta^2{\int_{\bar r}^{\infty}{\rm d}r ' } r ' \frac{2+d - r'^2}{(d-1+\beta^2){\left(}e^{r'^2/2}-1{\right)}+\beta^2r'^2}{\right)}\bigg\}^{-1 } \bigg]^{-1 } \label{eq : 5.18}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where as before @xmath184 . the major contribution to the integral comes from small values of @xmath185 ( except for when @xmath186 and @xmath142 or @xmath187 , when the integral diverges ) and for small values of @xmath188 , the integrand can be expanded in powers of @xmath185 . expanding the exponential function in the integrand yields @xmath189 where the function @xmath127 was defined in ( [ eq : 5.3 ] ) . the diffusion constant @xmath158 is given by ( [ eq : 5.14 ] ) . with ( [ eq : 2.6 ] ) we find @xmath190 for low dimensions , @xmath191 is a fairly good approximation ( a maximum of 3 percent error when @xmath186 ) . substituting ( [ eq : 5.21 ] ) into ( [ eq : 5.19 ] ) gives once more ( [ eq : 5.16 ] ) . so far we have derived the probability densities and collision rates for the steady state . we now wish to derive expressions of these quantities as functions of time . to this end we need to solve the time dependent fokker - planck equation ( [ eq : 4.9 ] ) with the boundary conditions @xmath192 as before we assume a uniform initial scatter of particles @xmath193 the collision rate is given by equation ( [ eq : 4.8 ] ) @xmath194 where we have used that the area of a @xmath34-dimensional sphere of radius @xmath195 is @xmath196 , and the gamma function is denoted by @xmath136 . in order to render the boundary conditions homogeneous , we split @xmath197 and impose the conditions @xmath198 , and that the differential equation homogeneous in @xmath115 is also homogeneous in @xmath199 . thus @xmath200 is uniquely given by the steady - state solutions found in the previous section . now consider the remaining equation for @xmath201 which is identical to ( [ eq : 4.9 ] ) with homogeneous boundary conditions and initial condition @xmath202 separation of variables @xmath203 in ( [ eq : 4.9 ] ) gives ( using the radial current ( [ eq : 4.10 ] ) ) @xmath204{\right)}\ , . \label{eq : 6.5}\ ] ] since the left - hand side depends on @xmath48 only , and the right - hand side depends on @xmath18 only , both sides must be equal to a constant , @xmath205 say . choosing @xmath206 , where @xmath207 is a positive dimensionless constant , we obtain @xmath208 note that the solution corresponding to @xmath209 has already been taken care of in @xmath210 . therefore we can restrict ourselves to considering @xmath211 in the following . to solve the radial part of ( [ eq : 6.5 ] ) , we consider the limit of @xmath212 , where @xmath149 and @xmath150 are simple power laws ( this follows from ( [ eq : 5.13 ] ) ) . using the dimensionless variable @xmath155 gives the following approximate equation for small values of @xmath185 @xmath213 this is an euler equation . its solution is obtained by the variable substitution @xmath214 , where the factor @xmath215 is included in for later convenience and @xmath216 . we find @xmath217 where @xmath218 and @xmath219 and @xmath220 are integration constants . for all values of @xmath221 in the allowed range @xmath222 , the boundary condition @xmath223 is automatically fulfilled . the boundary condition @xmath224 gives @xmath225 , and thus @xmath226 the boundary conditions do not constrain the eigenvalue @xmath207 and we need to consider a continuous superposition of eigenfunctions @xmath227 here @xmath228 and @xmath229 are functions to be determined by the initial conditions . it turns out that it is sufficient to consider @xmath228 for our initial condition and take @xmath230 from now on . at time @xmath231 we make the change of variables @xmath232 as before . we set @xmath233 and find @xmath234 comparing this to the required initial distribution @xmath235 gives @xmath236 the left hand side is of the form of a fourier sine transform with inverse @xmath237 we insert this expression into the ansatz for @xmath199 . upon changing order of the integrations ( that is we perform the @xmath238-integral first ) , we find @xmath239 to calculate the collision rate we need to know the current @xmath240 at radius @xmath3 . to this end we just require the derivative of @xmath115 evaluated at @xmath64 ( since @xmath115 itself is constrained to vanish there ) . we find @xmath241 equation ( [ eq : 6.3 ] ) now allows us to calculate the time - dependent collision rate . we split @xmath240 [ see equation ( [ eq : 4.10 ] ) ] into two parts depending on @xmath199 and @xmath210 respectively . the second part gives the steady - state collision rate @xmath121 , see equation ( [ eq : 5.6 ] ) . we find ( expanding in powers of @xmath185 ) @xmath242 this is our main result for the time - dependent collision rate , valid for correlations with non - vanishing fourth order derivative at @xmath243 and for small particles . an approximation to this result can be obtained by approximating the steady - state probability density @xmath244 by expanding in powers of @xmath185 . since the @xmath245-integral extends to infinity and since the gaussian contribution in the integrand becomes small for large values of @xmath246 , we must have that @xmath247 goes to @xmath33 as @xmath245 goes to @xmath248 , which is the case for the original @xmath247 . to accomplish this , we match the small-@xmath185 expression of @xmath247 at @xmath249 to the large-@xmath185 expression . by using ( [ eq : 5.13 ] ) and ( [ eq : 5.16 ] ) and matching at @xmath249 we find @xmath250 where the last term is not cut off at @xmath249 as it vanishes sufficiently quickly . the time - dependent collision rate can now be evaluated from the sum of three integrals of the type @xmath251\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath252 , @xmath253 and @xmath254 . putting everything together we find @xmath255{\right)}{\nonumber}\\ & + \bar a^{d}\bigg ( \frac{1}{\sqrt{\pi{{\cal d}}t}}e^{-\mu_0 ^ 2{{\cal d}}t}+(d+\mu_0)e^{d(d+2\mu_0){{\cal d}}t}{\nonumber}\\ & \hspace*{1mm}\times{\left\ { } \newcommand{\rbp}{\right\}}\mathrm{erf}\left[(d+\mu_0)\sqrt{{{\cal d}}t}\right]-\mathrm{erf}\left[(d+\mu_0)\sqrt{{{\cal d}}t}+\frac{\ln\bar a}{2\sqrt{{{\cal d}}t}}\right]\rbp\bigg ) \bigg\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] valid for @xmath256 . for times less than @xmath257^{-1}$ ] the above expression simplifies to @xmath258 for intermediate times , @xmath257^{-1 } \ll t \ll \ln(\bar a)/(2\mu_0{{\cal d}})$ ] , we find approximately @xmath259-\mathrm{erf}\left[(d+\mu_0)\sqrt{{{\cal d}}t}+\frac{\ln\bar a}{2\sqrt{{{\cal d}}t}}\right]\rbp\bigg)\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] while for large times , @xmath260 , where @xmath261{\right)}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] consider finally evaluating ( [ eq : 6.22 ] ) in the incompressible limit , we have @xmath262 and the terms involving the integral cutoffs @xmath263 cancel ( @xmath264 in ( [ eq : 6.21 ] ) ) . thus in the case @xmath137 the collision rate simplifies to @xmath265\bigg\}.\ ] ] equations ( [ eq : 6.22 ] ) and ( [ eq : 6.26 ] ) are compared to results of numerical simulations in the following section . we performed simulations of the collision rate as a function of time at small kubo numbers , for both incompressible and compressible flows . these illustrate ( figure [ fig : 3 ] ) the very complex behaviour of the model . for example , in the case of compressible flows the collision rate at first decreases below the value determined by the saffman - turner approximation due to the effect illustrated in figure [ fig : 2 ] , before rising again as particle clustering becomes apparent . collision rate for particles advected in a two - dimensional flow of the form ( [ eq : 2.2 ] ) with ( [ eq : 2.6 ] ) and @xmath266 . particles are initially randomly distributed , initially overlapping particle pairs are removed , as are particles which have collided . parameters : @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269 and @xmath270 for all graphs and for * a * @xmath137 and @xmath271 , * b * @xmath137 and @xmath272 , * c * @xmath273 and @xmath271 , * d * @xmath273 and @xmath272 , * e * @xmath274 and @xmath272 , * f * @xmath275 and @xmath272 . the collision rate is approximated by the cumulative sum of all collisions up to @xmath48 , divided by @xmath48 . the light blue areas are the intervals @xmath276 , where @xmath277 is the standard deviation of the rate , and @xmath278 is the number of realisations of the flow . the latter decreases over time ( it is typically @xmath279 for the first two decades in @xmath48 , and @xmath280 for the last decade ) . the saffman - turner estimates ( [ eq : 3.8],[eq : 3.9 ] ) are shown as red dashed lines . our own result ( [ eq : 6.22 ] ) is shown as red solid lines . to correspond to the simulated collision rate , the plotted theoretical collision rates has been integrated to and then divided by @xmath48 . due to the assumptions in the fokker - planck theory , the long time rate ( [ eq : 6.22 ] ) is not valid for @xmath281 . the plotted long time theory is a combination of the short time rate ( [ eq : 7.1 ] ) and the long time rate ( [ eq : 6.22 ] ) , matched at the time at which the long time rate drops below the short time rate ( which is an upper bound ) . , width=453 ] figure [ fig : 3 ] summarises our results for the collision rate of particles advected in flows with small kubo numbers . shown are numerical simulations for a two - dimensional random flow of the form ( [ eq : 2.2 ] ) with correlation function ( [ eq : 2.6 ] ) . panels * a * and * b * show the collision rate in an incompressible flow ( @xmath137 ) . as expected ( see section [ sec : 3.2 ] ) , the collision rates drops below the initial transient given by the saffman - turner approximation , ( [ eq : 3.8],[eq : 3.9 ] ) with @xmath20 . for the particular choice ( [ eq : 2.6 ] ) with @xmath266 , equations ( [ eq : 3.8],[eq : 3.9 ] ) become in two spatial dimensions @xmath282 also shown is our own theory valid for small kubo numbers ( equation ( [ eq : 6.22 ] ) in section [ sec : 6 ] ) . the agreement between the theory and the simulations is good in all cases , but slightly better for the smaller kubo number ( panel * b * ) . as discussed in section [ sec : 3.2 ] , the initial transient constitutes an upper bound to the collision rate . panels * c * to * f * in figure [ fig : 3 ] show the collision rate in compressible flow . now , the saffman & turner theory is no longer an upper bound ( see for example figure [ fig : 3]*f * ) , because initially homogeneously distributed particles in an incompressible flow cluster together . the corresponding density fluctuations increase the collision rate , as our exact result shows ( equation ( [ eq : 6.22 ] ) in section [ sec : 6 ] ) . again we observe good agreement between the simulations and our analytical result . in this paper we have concentrated upon the solvable case of advective collisions in flows with small kubo number , which provides considerable physical insight . we conclude by commenting on the relation between these results and collisions in a turbulent flow field which satisfies the navier - stokes equation . the standard approach , based upon the saffman - turner formula , predicts a collision rate @xmath283 , where @xmath32 is the kolmogorov timescale @xcite of the turbulent flow . the calculation based upon the diffusion equation gives a collision rate @xmath284 . given that @xmath285 for a turbulent flow , we see that the saffman - turner and diffusive expressions are of the same order . these observations are consistent with the hypthesis that the collision rate for small particles in a turbulent flow is @xmath286 where @xmath287 is the rate of dissipation per unit mass , @xmath288 is the kinematic viscosity , and @xmath289 is a universal constant ( depending only on the dimension ) . it would be a valuable addition to the literature on aerosols and suspended particles to determine the value of @xmath290 from numerical simulations using a navier - stokes flow . _ acknowledgments . _ we acknowledge support from vetenskapsrdet and from the research initiative nanoparticles in an interactive environment at gteborg university . + r. a. shaw , _ annu . fluid mech . _ , * 35 * , 183 , ( 2003 ) . m. wilkinson , b. mehlig , and v. uski , _ astrophys . j. suppl . _ , in press , ( 2008 ) . m. v. smoluchowski , _ zeitschrift f. physik . * xcii * , 129 - 168 , ( 1917 ) ; see eq . ( 28 ) on p. 156 . p. g. saffman and j. s. turner , _ j. fluid mech . _ , * 1 * , 16 - 30 , ( 1956 ) . g. falkovich , a. fouxon and g. stepanov , _ nature _ , * 419 * , 151 - 154 , ( 2002 ) . m. wilkinson , b. mehlig and v. bezuglyy , _ phys . _ , * 97 * , 048501 , ( 2006 ) . e. balkovsky , g. falkovich , and a. fouxon , _ phys . _ , * 86 * , 2790 , ( 2001 ) ; cond - mat/9912027 . g. falkovich , k. gawedzki , and m. vergassola , _ rev . * 73 * , 913 , ( 2001 ) . m. wilkinson , b. mehlig , s. stlund and k. p. duncan , _ phys . fluids _ , * 19 * , 113303 , ( 2007 ) . b. andersson , k. gustavsson , b. mehlig , and m. wilkinson , _ europhys _ , * 80 * , 69001 , ( 2007 ) . j. r. cressman , j. davoudi , w. i. goldberg and j. schumacher , _ new j. phys . _ , * 6 * , 53 , ( 2004 ) . falkovich _ et al . _ , _ nature _ , * 435 * , 1045 , ( 2005 ) . u. frisch , _ turbulence _ , cambridge university press , ( 1997 ) . h. sigurgeirson and a. m. stuart , _ phys . fluids _ , * 14 * , 4352 , ( 2002 ) . j. kalda , _ phys . _ , * 98 * , 064501 , ( 2007 ) . j. sommerer and e. ott , _ science _ , * 359 * , 334 , ( 1993 ) . p. grassberger and i. procaccia , _ physica d _ , * 9 * , 189 , ( 1983 ) . m. wilkinson and b. mehlig , _ phys . e _ , * 68 * , 040101(r ) , ( 2003 ) . in this appendix we show how to evaluate the expression ( [ eq : 3.2 ] ) for a general matrix @xmath55 with elements @xmath291 ( we drop the subscript @xmath292 ) . it is convenient to decompose @xmath55 into a symmetric part @xmath293 and an antisymmetric part @xmath294}$ ] @xmath295 the collision rate is independent of the antisymmetric part @xmath294}$ ] ( because rotations do not contribute to the collision rate ) . the symmetric part @xmath296 can be diagonalised by an orthogonal transformation , @xmath297 , where @xmath298 is diagonal with the eigenvalues @xmath299 of @xmath296 . in evaluating ( [ eq : 3.2 ] ) we may write @xmath300 , where @xmath301 . since @xmath302 is just a rotation of @xmath63 which is integrated over all directions , we can replace ( [ eq : 3.2 ] ) by @xmath303 we now show how to perform the integral in ( [ eq : nsn ] ) in two spatial dimensions . note that if the flow determined by @xmath55 is not area preserving , the particle density will change as a function of time . in this case @xmath33 in ( [ eq : 3.2 ] ) must be replaced by @xmath304\,.\ ] ] at short times we approximate @xmath305 and find @xmath306 where @xmath307 and @xmath308 . this is the final result in two spatial dimensions , expressed in terms of the eigenvalues @xmath309 of the symmetric part @xmath296 of the strain matrix . in three spatial dimensions we only consider incompressible shear flows , that is a general , three - dimensional traceless matrix @xmath296 . it has eigenvalues @xmath310 , obeying the relations @xmath311 , @xmath312 and @xmath313 . we use a spherical coordinate system , @xmath314 and find @xmath315 substitute @xmath316 and @xmath317 we obtain @xmath318 where the transformed integrand @xmath319 is smaller than @xmath292 for @xmath320 , where @xmath321 is given by @xmath322 and @xmath323 . because the values @xmath324 can take are limited by @xmath325 , @xmath326 must be in the range @xmath327 and @xmath321 in the range @xmath328 . performing the @xmath48-integral from @xmath292 to @xmath321 gives @xmath329 where @xmath330 , if @xmath331 and @xmath332 , if @xmath333 . expanding the integrand around in @xmath326 around the point @xmath334 ( to be determined below ) we find @xmath335 if we choose @xmath336 , which corresponds to @xmath337 , we can perform the integration after changing the order of summation and integration . the collision rate becomes @xmath338 only even powers contribute to this sum : we have not used that @xmath339 and could thus as well have expanded the starting equations using @xmath340 and @xmath325 , with the only difference that @xmath324 would be replaced by @xmath341 in ( [ eq : a.11 ] ) . we thus find that @xmath342 is symmetric around @xmath343 , i.e. @xmath344 . to obtain an expression valid for @xmath331 , we reorder the eigenvalues of the matrix @xmath296 as @xmath345 and @xmath346 , giving the eigenvalue ranges @xmath347 and @xmath348 . the integrand analogous to ( [ eq : a.5 ] ) becomes @xmath349 where @xmath340 has opposite sign as @xmath325 before . this integrand is smaller than @xmath292 for @xmath350 , where @xmath321 is given by @xmath351 where @xmath352 lies in the interval @xmath353 and @xmath321 lies in @xmath354 . performing the @xmath48 integral from @xmath321 to @xmath355 gives @xmath356 where we have proceeded as in deriving ( [ eq : a.12 ] ) with @xmath357 , if @xmath358 and @xmath332 , if @xmath359 . we obtain the final result @xmath360 where @xmath361 this is the final result for incompressible flows in three spatial dimensions . for the particular case ( [ eq : 3.3 ] ) considered by smoluchowski @xcite we have @xmath362 with eigenvalues @xmath363 . substituting @xmath364 and @xmath365 into ( [ eq : a.15 ] ) we obtain ( [ eq : 3.4 ] ) . when @xmath366 this expression agrees with the classical result ( [ eq : 3.4 ] ) due to smoluchowski @xcite .

we consider collisions of particles advected in a fluid . as already pointed out by smoluchowski [ _ z . f. physik . chemie _ , * xcii * , 129 - 168 , ( 1917 ) ] , macroscopic motion of the fluid can significantly enhance the frequency of collisions between the suspended particles . this effect was invoked by saffman and turner [ _ j . fluid mech . _ , * 1 * , 16 - 30 , ( 1956 ) ] to estimate collision rates of small water droplets in turbulent rain clouds , the macroscopic motion being caused by turbulence . here we show that the saffman - turner theory is unsatisfactory because it describes an initial transient only . the reason for this failure is that the local flow in the vicinity of a particle is treated as if it were a steady hyperbolic flow , whereas in reality it must fluctuate . we derive exact expressions for the steady - state collision rate for particles suspended in rapidly fluctuating random flows and compute how this steady state is approached . for incompressible flows , the saffman - turner expression is an upper bound .

nucl-th0312027

one of the main aims of researches in nuclear physics is to describe the ground - state properties of all nuclei in the periodic table with one method . unfortunately , due to lack of understanding in strong interaction and numerical difficulties in handling nuclear many - body problems , so far all microscopic descriptions are only possible on a phenomenological ground . the most successful theories of this type are the conventional hartree - fock method with effective density - dependent interactions @xcite and its relativistic analog , the relativistic mean field ( rmf ) theory @xcite . the hartree - fock method is based on the non - relativistic kinematics , in which the spin - orbit interaction and the density dependent interaction are important ingredients . while the rfm theory is based on the relativistic kinematics , in which the nucleons , the mesons and their interactions are the ingredients . therefore , the spin appears automatically and the interplay of the scalar and the vector potentials leads naturally to a proper spin - orbit interaction and appropriate shell structure . such a property is very important for the extrapolation of a phenomenological model to study exotic nuclei , which have become accessible in recent years due to developments in accelerator technology and detection techniques @xcite . the rmf theory has been very successful for the description of many nuclear properties including binding energies , nuclear radii and deformations from the proton drip line to the neutron drip line @xcite . however , the number of nuclear properties investigated by the rmf model is still considerably less than those done by its non - relativistic counterpart . to describe nuclear ground - state properties over a wide mass region properly , we must take into account both deformation effects and pairing correlations simultaneously . it has been known for a long time that most nuclei except for a few with and near magic numbers are deformed and most of them can be described by axial deformations . in the present work , we adopt the expansion method in the harmonic - oscillator basis to describe the single - particle wave functions in the deformed mean field potential @xcite . in the original work of gambhir . @xcite , the pairing correlations are treated in the bcs framework using a constant pairing interaction with a pairing window . this method has been found to be incapable of describing exotic nuclei where the continuum effects become important near the drip lines . on the other hand , recently it was demonstrated that the use of a zero - range @xmath3-force in the particle - particle channel was able to take into account the couplings to the continuum nicely in the non - relativistic mean filed models @xcite . this bcs framework with the zero - range @xmath3-force has been introduced into the relativistic mean filed models with the spherical shape @xcite . the zero - range @xmath3-force acting on the paired nucleons in the bcs framework is able to pick up the states ( resonant states ) having a large overlap with the occupied states below the fermi surface @xcite . we , therefore , have introduced the zero - range @xmath3-force in the bcs framework into the expansion method @xcite in the deformed rmf model and demonstrated its applicability in ref . this method has been applied to study the properties of light nuclei @xcite , particularly the proton - skins in the ar isotopic chain and the neutron - skins in the na isotopic chain , and the alpha - decay properties of the lately synthesized superheavy elements 115 and 113 @xcite . when applying this method to the neutron - rich nuclei , due to their large spacial extension , we do not expect the description of the sudden increase of neutron radii in halo nuclei , which were found if we had solved the rmf equations in coordinate space @xcite . however , except for the neutron radii of the halo nuclei , other properties could be reproduced with satisfactory accuracy by this method @xcite . one way out of this deficiency for the description of halo nuclei is to use the expansion method in the woods - saxon basis @xcite , which unfortunately is only possible for spherical nuclei at present . the zr and sn isotopic chains have received lots of attention for a long time . the zr isotope has a semi - magic proton number 40 , and its neutron number can be ( semi- ) magic numbers 40 , 50 and 82 . most recently , several rmf calculations show that the so - called giant halos may occur in the zr isotopic chain where neutron number goes beyond 82 @xcite . the evolution of deformation , the potential energy surfaces , the microscopic structure of coexisting configurations , and shape transitions in heavy zr isotopes have been discussed extensively since a long time ago ( see refs . @xcite ) , where sophisticated models have been employed and detailed analysises have been made . in the present work , our discussions of the evolution of the deformation in the zr isotopic chain ( including that of the sn isotopic chain ) are restricted to the mean field level . we would like to also compare our predictions with those of two of the most successful non - relativistic mean field models , the finite - range droplet model ( frdm ) @xcite and the hartree fock + bcs method ( hf+bcs ) @xcite . we notice that the effect of the proton - neutron pairing for @xmath4zr is also revisited lately @xcite . the sn isotope has long been of special interest for nuclear physicists not only because it has a magic proton number 50 , but also due to its extremely long isotopic chain . experimentally both the double magic nuclei , the neutron - deficient @xmath0sn and the neutron - rich @xmath2sn , have been produced . we expect that its isotopes will even extend to the next neutron magic number , @xmath5 , which will be one of the objects of the present study . most sn isotopes have been found to be spherical both experimentally and theoretically , particularly those nuclei with @xmath6 , but whether or not such a trend can continue to the next neutron - magic number , @xmath5 , remains to be an interesting and yet open question . recently , samanta et al . suggested that the pb isotope ( @xmath7 ) loses its magicity around @xmath8 based on the extended bethe - weizscker mass formula @xcite . this motivates us to study also the magicity of @xmath9 by the rmf method . the rmf model is particularly suitable for such a purpose because of its natural description of spin - orbit interaction . just like zr isotopes , sn isotopes have also been investigated quite a lot both in relativistic @xcite and non - relativistic mean field @xcite models . however , most of them are limited to either spherical assumptions , or even - even nuclei , or just part of the isotopic chain . the same limitations are also true for zr isotopes . in the present work , we apply the recently formulated deformed rmf+bcs method with a zero - range @xmath3-force in the pairing channel @xcite to the analysis of the ground - state properties of zr and sn isotopes from the proton drip line to the neutron drip line . in particular , we would like to study the neutron - rich nuclei in both isotopic chains and the magicity of @xmath9 in the neutron - rich region . we use the tma @xcite and nl3 @xcite parameter sets for the rmf lagrangian density , which are two of the most successful parameter sets in the relativistic mean field model . in sec . 2 , we briefly present the rmf model with deformation effects and pairing correlations . the numerical details and discussions will be presented in sec . 3 and a summary of the present study is given in sec . we briefly present here the formulation of the rmf model with deformation effects and pairing correlations . we employ the model lagrangian density with nonlinear terms for both @xmath10 and @xmath11 mesons , as described in detail in ref . @xcite , which is given by @xmath12 where the field tensors of the vector mesons and of the electromagnetic field take the following forms : @xmath13 and other symbols have their usual meanings . based on the single - particle spectra calculated by the rmf method , we perform a state - dependent bcs calculation @xcite . the gap equation has a standard form for all the single particle states . i.e. @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the single particle energy and @xmath16 is the fermi energy . the particle number condition is given by @xmath17 . as have been done in the recent works @xcite , a zero - range @xmath3-force @xmath18 is used in the particle - particle channel in order to take into account the continuum effects properly . for nuclei with odd number of nucleons , a simple blocking method without breaking the time - reversal symmetry is adopted . the ground state of an odd system is described by the wave function , @xmath19 here , @xmath20 denotes the vacuum state . the unpaired particle sits in the level @xmath21 and blocks this level . the pauli principle prevents this level from participating in the scattering process of nucleons caused by the pairing correlations . as described in ref . @xcite , the gap equation with one level @xmath21blocked " has the form : @xmath22 with the corresponding chemical potential determined by @xmath23 . this blocking procedure is performed at each step of the self - consistent iteration and more numerical details will be discussed below . for heavy nuclei more harmonic - oscillator shells in the expansion of fermion and boson fields have to be used in order to achieve reliable convergence . however , computation time increases dramatically with the increase of the number of shells . the common procedure to tackle this problem is to limit the number of shells by studying the convergence behavior in the region of interest . for this reason , we investigate in detail three nuclei @xmath2sn , @xmath24sn and @xmath25zr , which are chosen to represent spherical neutron - rich nuclei , spherical drip - line nuclei and deformed halo nuclei . for the case of @xmath2sn , with the basis parameter @xmath26 , it is found that for @xmath27 , where @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the numbers of shells used in the expansion of fermion and boson fields , the desirable convergence is obtained properly . the increase of @xmath30 from 14 to 20 changes the total binding energy @xmath31 and the binding energy per particle @xmath32 by about @xmath33 , while the rms charge radii @xmath34 is changed by @xmath35 and the rms neutron radii @xmath36 is changed by @xmath37 . for @xmath2sn , even 12 shells can obtain the satisfactory convergence as shown in table i. similar conclusion can be made for @xmath24sn ( table ii ) except that now a minimum of 14 shells is needed . things are a little bit different for @xmath25zr ( table iii ) , which has been predicted to be a halo nucleus @xcite . with @xmath30 increasing from 14 to 20 , @xmath31 and @xmath32 change by about @xmath38 , while @xmath34 is changed by @xmath35 , and @xmath36 is changed by @xmath39 . in our calculations the ground state of @xmath25zr has a deformation of @xmath40 . setting @xmath41 equal to @xmath42 , we find that @xmath43 is changed by about @xmath44 when @xmath30 increases from 14 to 20 . in conclusion , we find that 14 shells are enough for a correct description of @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath34 and @xmath45 . while for @xmath36 , to describe the halo nuclei more reliably , shells more than 14 are needed . of course , as is well known ( see ref . @xcite and references therein ) , the rms neutron radii of neutron halo nuclei can not be fully reproduced within the harmonic - oscillator basis even with a large number of basis . keeping all these in mind , we decide to use 20 shells ( @xmath46 ) for the calculations with the tma parameter set , while for the calculations with the nl3 parameter set 14 shells ( @xmath47 ) are used to save computation time . as we have stated in sec . 2 , for nuclei with odd number of neutrons a blocking method without breaking the time - reversal symmetry is adopted in the self - consistent calculation . at each step , the state to be blocked is determined by counting the single - particle spectra from the bottom . then with this state blocked , the bcs calculation is performed . this procedure is repeated until the required convergence is obtained . the same procedure is also adopted in the constrained calculations . for each nucleus , first the constrained calculation @xcite is done to obtain all possible ground - state configurations ; second we perform the non - constrained calculation using the quadrupole deformation parameter of the deepest minimum of the energy curve of each nucleus as the deformation parameter for the harmonic - oscillator basis . in the case of several similar minima from the constrained calculation , the non - constrained calculation is repeated around each minimum to obtain the configuration with the lowest energy as the final result . we note that the most appropriate way to perform blocking calculations is by blocking all orbits accessible to the odd nuclei at each deformation , but it is incredibly time consuming . therefore , our method should be seen as an approximation to that kind of full calculation and the agreement should be checked at certain points . here we take @xmath48sn in our rmf+bcs calculations with the tma parameter set as an example to show the validity of this method . first , the constrained calculation finds that the deepest minimum is at @xmath49 . using this as the basis deformation , i.e. @xmath50 , we perform the non - constrained calculation . the final result is @xmath51 with @xmath52 , where @xmath31 is the total binding energy . looking at the single - particle spectra , we find that the blocked state is @xmath53 $ ] with the single - particle energy @xmath54 . two other possible states accessible to the odd neutron is @xmath55 $ ] with @xmath56 and @xmath57 $ ] with @xmath58 . if one of these two states were blocked instead of @xmath53 $ ] , the results would be @xmath59 with @xmath60 and @xmath61 with @xmath60 . these are all close to each other and our method chooses the correct configuration with the lowest energy . this case shows that the procedure we adopted works very well . however , there are cases where the state chosen by this procedure does not lead to the `` absolute minimum '' . nevertheless , such wrong selections of the blocking states generally lead to a difference less than 0.2 mev for the total binding energy , which is actually beyond the accuracy of our calculations and therefore can be safely ignored . the pairing strength @xmath62 mev @xmath63 is used for zr isotopes and @xmath64 mev @xmath63 for sn isotopes , which are obtained by fitting the experimental odd - even staggerings ( oess ) of zr and sn isotopes with a cut - off @xmath65 mev . we use the same pairing strength for both protons and neutrons . for comparison , calculations have been done with the nl3 parameter set also , but only for even - even nuclei . the pairing strength is kept the same for calculations with both the tma parameter set and the nl3 parameter set . the double and single neutron separation energies @xmath66 @xmath67 are displayed in figs . 1 and 2 for zr isotopes and sn isotopes , respectively , from the proton drip line to the neutron drip line . the results obtained from the deformed rmf+bcs calculations with the parameter set tma are compared with available experimental data @xcite . in the upper panels of figs . 1 and 2 , the results obtained from the deformed rmf+bcs calculations with the nl3 parameter set are also shown for comparison . it is clearly seen that both experimental separation energies and oess are reproduced quite well by the theoretical calculations . the rmf+bcs calculations with different parameter sets tma and nl3 also agree with each other very well . for zr isotopes , despite of the fact that the variation of the deformation is quite complicated for the whole isotopic chain ( see figs . 4 and 6 ) , the agreement between theory and experiment is very good . the experimental feature that the oess are larger for nuclei with @xmath68 than for nuclei with @xmath69 is also reproduced quite well . both the double and single neutron separation energies are quite small for nuclei with @xmath70 . the so - called giant halos are predicted to exist in this region by both the rchb @xcite and the resonant rmf+bcs @xcite calculations with spherical assumptions . our previous deformed rmf+bcs calculations @xcite reached the same conclusion and confirmed that the expansion method in the harmonic - oscillator basis can provide very accurate results for nuclear binding energies even in the neutron - rich region . all these calculations@xcite , however , are limited to only even - even nuclei . from the lower panel of fig . 1 , we notice that the oess of zr isotopes with @xmath70 are quite small and @xmath71 of those nuclei with odd mass numbers are almost zero or negative . this is easy to understand because the pairing correlations can increase the binding energies of even - even nuclei more and therefore contribute to the formation of halo nuclei . we also conclude that generally we will see one - neutron halo nucleus first and then only two - neutron halo nucleus is stable due to the pairing correlations . the same conclusion also holds for sn isotopes . for sn isotopes , we notice that the agreement between theory and experiment is very good in the region , @xmath72sn @xmath1 @xmath2sn . the two - neutron drip - line nucleus is predicted to be @xmath24sn by our calculations with both the tma and the nl3 parameter sets , which agree well with the calculations with other parameter sets in the rmf framework @xcite . this seems to be a unique feature of the rmf calculations while the hf calculations usually shift the drip - line nucleus toward the light mass region ( see fig . @xcite ) . different isospin dependence and spin - orbit description could be the reason why this discrepancy happens . however , since we are talking about exotic nuclei far from the stability region , this remains to be an open question anyway . for nuclei with @xmath73 , the theoretical oes drops a little bit suddenly . the reason behind this is a relatively large spin - orbit splitting between @xmath74 state and @xmath75 state , around 1.8 mev in our present calculations ( see figs . 7 and 8) , which makes pairing energy in nuclei with @xmath73 smaller than in nuclei with @xmath76 . we note that the smaller oes in the region of @xmath77sn @xmath1 @xmath78sn is quite complicated and may be related with two different phenomena . one is that nuclei in this region are deformed ( see fig . the other one is that as we shall see from fig . 8 , the @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 states , which become occupied in this region , are quite close to each other . in both zr and sn isotopic chains , we should note that for nuclei with @xmath82 additional residual interactions , such as the proton - neutron pairing , will contribute and increase the oes somewhat , which are not included in the present model . unlike zr isotopes , we do not see a clear indication of possible two - neutron halo in the sn isotopic chain , which is consistent with all previous calculations . the double neutron separation energy goes directly to about @xmath83 mev for @xmath84sn from about 1.4 mev for @xmath24sn . however , from the lower panel of fig.2 , we can see that @xmath71 stays below 1.0 mev from @xmath85sn till the end of this isotopic chain , which implies the possible existence of one - neutron halo . the average binding energy per particle is plotted as a function of mass number a in fig . 3 for zr and sn isotopes . it can be clearly seen that the theoretical predictions reproduce the experimental data accurately including the oess in sn isotopes . for zr isotopes , the small deviation between theory and experiment for nuclei with @xmath86 is probably related with the particle number non - conservation feature of the present bcs method , which will be discussed more below . for sn isotopes around @xmath82 , our calculated results are somewhat larger than the experimental data . deformation is quite an important property for nuclei . it can increase the nuclear binding energy so that a deformed shape is more favored than the spherical shape for certain nuclei . the deformation effect is also important for the description of odd - even staggering ( oes ) . it has been argued that in light- or medium - mass nuclei deformation provides the same amount of oes as the pairing interaction @xcite and/or that the oes in light nuclei is a mere reflection of the deformed mean field @xcite . although it is believed that the oes in heavy nuclei is mainly due to the pairing correlations , the deformation effect should never be ignored . we have also shown in ref . @xcite that the deformation effect in even - even zr isotopes is quite important to reduce the discrepancy between the theoretical and the experimental binding energies . @xmath9 has long been seen as a special magic number in the sense that all sn isotopes are believed to be spherical . whether or not sn isotopes are deformed also is of special interest to the synthesis of nuclei in the astrophysical r - process . in figs . 4 and 5 , we plot the mass quadrupole deformation parameters , @xmath87 , for zr and sn isotopes . the results of our calculations with the tma and nl3 parameter sets are compared with those of the finite - range droplet model ( frdm ) @xcite and the hatree fock + bcs ( hf+bcs ) @xcite method . the experimental data are extracted from the b(e2 ) values given in ref . @xcite . from fig . 4 , it is seen that the variation of the deformation is quite complicated for zr isotopes . the agreement between different theoretical calculations , rmf+bcs / tma , rmf+bcs / nl3 , frdm and hf+bcs , and experimental data is quite good in general . nuclei with @xmath88 are very deformed in all the theoretical calculations . the same is true for nuclei with @xmath89 . nuclei with @xmath90 are moderately deformed with @xmath91 by frdm and @xmath92 by rmf+bcs with both the tma and nl3 parameter sets , while hf+bcs seems to prefer spherical shapes for this region . there are two regions where the theoretical calculations do not agree so well with each other . the first one is around @xmath93 , where the results of frdm and rmf+bcs / nl3 stay almost spherical while hf+bcs and rmf+bcs / tma show signs of oscillation between oblate and prolate shapes . the second region is about @xmath94 , where both rmf+bcs / tma and frdm predict oblate shapes while rmf+bcs / nl3 and hf+bcs prefer spherical configurations . these discrepancies between different theoretical calculations indicate that the nuclei in these regions are `` soft '' in the sense of deformation ( see also fig . however , sn isotopes are quite different from zr isotopes . it remains robustly spherical till @xmath30 reaches 88 in all the theoretical calculations . then the non - relativistic calculations frdm and hf+bcs show a region of moderately deformed with @xmath95 around @xmath96 . the relativistic calculations show a transition from prolate shapes ( @xmath97 ) to oblate shapes ( @xmath98 ) while the amplitudes of deformation are similar to their non - relativistic counterparts . for nuclei with @xmath30 approaching the magic number 126 , the rmf+bcs calculations and the hf+bcs calculations predict spherical shapes while the frdm calculations prefer prolate configurations . it is quite a surprise that all the theoretical works , either non - relativistic or relativistic , predict a deformed region around @xmath96 for sn isotopes , which makes our predictions well grounded . although it may be trivial , another well - known feature shown in our calculations is that the even - odd nucleus tends to be deformed despite that its neighboring even - even nuclei are spherical . of course at most times , the deformation is quite small and we can say that it is essentially spherical . most even - odd sn isotopes with @xmath99 belong to this group . however , in zr isotopes , some even - odd nuclei differer from their even - even neighbors by an absolute @xmath87 of 0.1 . @xmath100zr , @xmath101zr , @xmath102zr and @xmath103zr are such nuclei . usually , we can find two minima on the total energy surface of an axially deformed nucleus , one prolate and the other oblate , or spherical . on the theoretical side , it is easy to tell which one is the ground - state configuration if the difference between the total energies of different minima is relatively large . on the other hand , nuclei in transition region often have two minima with similar total energies , where it is difficult to determine the ground state without ambiguity . @xmath104zr , @xmath105zr , @xmath106zr and @xmath107zr are such nuclei in the zr isotopic chain . we display their total energy curves together with those of 12 other zr isotopes as functions of @xmath87 in fig . 6 . it provides us a vivid picture how deformation evolves in zr isotopes . nuclei with @xmath108 are strongly prolate with @xmath109 . at @xmath104zr , the oblate configuration becomes as stable as the prolate configuration . nuclei with @xmath110 are moderately oblate with @xmath111 . at @xmath105zr , the total energy curve becomes quite flat at the bottom and the spherical configuration is a little bit more stable . with increasing @xmath30 , even - even nuclei stay almost spherical while even - odd nuclei are somewhat deformed . at @xmath106zr , the prolate configuration @xmath112 is more stable than the oblate configuration @xmath113 . nuclei with increasing @xmath30 become more prolate and @xmath45 reaches 0.4 at @xmath114zr . then @xmath115zr becomes oblate and @xmath45 begins to approach zero with increasing @xmath30 . at @xmath107zr , the spherical configuration is reached and maintained for even - even nuclei till @xmath116zr . then the nucleus with more neutrons become more prolate till @xmath117zr and from @xmath25zr it stays moderately oblate , @xmath111 , till the end of this isotopic chain . it will be very interesting to study shape - coexistences in the whole zr isotopic chain within the relativistic mean field model just as what have been done in the non - relativistic models ( see refs . @xcite ) and compare with experimental data , if available . ( here it should be noted that the different minima on the potential energy surfaces may be linked by a valley in the gamma angle , so that a secondary minimum might imply a gamma - soft structure or even indicate a triaxial structure , which of course is not supposed to be seen in the present work due to the assumption of axial symmetry . ) we would like to make a few more comments about the discrepancy between theory and experiment in the region of @xmath86 in the zr isotopic chain . experimentally @xcite , the nuclei @xmath118zr , @xmath119zr , @xmath120zr and @xmath121zr are almost spherical and nuclei with @xmath122 suddenly become very deformed . while in our calculations ( including those of frdm and hf+bcs models ) , the nucleus becomes deformed gradually from @xmath123 with @xmath30 and agrees with experiment after @xmath124 . the reason could be that the current bcs method mixes the wave functions with different particle number and therefore leads to finite deformation for the nuclei in the region of @xmath86 . a calculation with an improved bcs method that conserves the particle number could clarify this discrepancy and this work is in progress now . it has long been known that the nuclear deformation is caused by the interplay between protons and neutrons ( see ref . @xcite and references therein ) . in this sense , the reliability of the deformation developments predicted by our calculations are more or less determined by to what extent the relativistic mean field theory with the particular parameter sets tma and nl3 can reproduce the experimental single - particle spectra , particularly the proton gap at @xmath9 and the neutron gap at @xmath125 . in fig . 7 , the single - particle energies of @xmath2sn calculated with the parameter sets tma and nl3 are compared with the experimental single - particle energies @xcite for protons ( left panel ) and neutrons ( right panel ) . it is very clear that the calculations with both the tma parameter set and the nl3 parameter set agree with each other very well and are also in reasonable agreement with the experimental single - particle spectra . the proton gap at @xmath9 is reproduced quite well by nl3 , while tma predicts a gap of 0.5 mev smaller than experiment . meanwhile , the calculated neutron gap at @xmath125 is somewhat larger than experiment for both parameter sets . we should note that such a comparison is not very well defined and a detailed analysis of the single - particle spectra in the relativistic mean field theory can be found in ref . anyway , the good agreement with the experimental data justifies us to extend the relativistic mean field model to the study of exotic nuclei . in our above discussions , some small discrepancies in the single - neutron separation energies for sn isotopes with @xmath126 have been attributed to their single - particle spectra . the abnormalities in the region of @xmath77sn @xmath1 @xmath78sn are also related to the corresponding shell structures . to see all these more clearly , we display the neutron single - particle spectra of five nuclei in sn isotopes , i.e. @xmath0sn , @xmath127sn , @xmath2sn , @xmath128sn and @xmath24sn in fig . these isotopes are so chosen to represent the whole sn isotopes from the proton drip line to the neutron drip line and also include two typical nuclei in the region where the predicted oes changes abruptly . all the five nuclei are spherical in our calculations . it is quite clear that the @xmath129 , @xmath130 and @xmath75 states are quite close to each other , which explains the somewhat large difference in the oes between nuclei with @xmath131 and @xmath126 , together with the relatively large gap between the @xmath75 state and the @xmath74 state . the small gap between the @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 states is possibly responsible for both the deformation phenomena and abnormalities in the oes in the region of @xmath77sn @xmath1 @xmath78sn . there are also some other important features shown in fig . 8 . first , the neutron level density increases with @xmath30 : the single - particle energy of the @xmath132 state increases about 10.0 mev from @xmath133 mev in @xmath0sn to @xmath134 mev in @xmath24sn ; meanwhile , the single - particle energy of the @xmath135 state decreases about 2.0 mev . second , it is quite clear that the spin - orbit splitting also decreases with increasing @xmath30 . some obvious spin - orbit partners , which exhibit this feature well , are @xmath136 , @xmath137 , @xmath138 and @xmath139 . the decrease of spin - orbit splitting with increasing @xmath30 in the relativistic mean field theory has been discussed in several previous works ( see ref . @xcite ) , where it has been attributed to the diffuseness of the potential . from the proton ( neutron ) density distributions , @xmath140 , we can easily deduce the corresponding proton ( neutron ) radius , @xmath141^{1/2}.\ ] ] the charge radius , @xmath34 , is related to the proton radius , @xmath142 , after considering the finite size of the proton , by @xmath143}.\ ] ] we display in figs . 9 and 10 the charge , proton and neutron rms radii for zr and sn isotopes . the calculated charge radii are compared with the experimental data from ref . excellent agreement between theory and experiment can be clearly seen . we can also see the effect of deformation clearly from figs . 9 and 10 . in the upper panel of fig . 9 , @xmath34 of zr isotopes drops dramatically for @xmath104zr and @xmath115zr , which is due to the deformation effect . if we take a look at fig . 4 , it becomes much clearer : @xmath144 changes from 0.535 for @xmath145zr to @xmath146 for @xmath104zr ; correspondingly , @xmath144 changes from 0.418 for @xmath114zr to @xmath147 for @xmath115zr . there are also some abnormalities in sn isotopes as we can see in the upper panel of fig . 10 , which have the same origins as zr isotopes . @xmath144 jumps from 0.085 for @xmath148sn to 0.220 for @xmath149sn and it changes from @xmath150 for @xmath85sn to 0.0 for @xmath128sn . in the lower panels of figs . 9 and 10 , we plot @xmath36 and @xmath142 together in order to see the differences between them easily . we also display a solid line with a @xmath151 dependence in both panels for @xmath36 . it is quite clear that the neutron - rich nuclei in zr isotopes deviate from the @xmath151 line quite a lot , which implies that the giant halos exist even though deformation develops after @xmath125 . while for sn isotopes our calculated results agree well with the @xmath151 line . the difference between @xmath36 and @xmath142 , i.e. neutron skin , reaches 0.9 fm for @xmath152zr and 0.8 fm for @xmath24sn , which can be viewed as another indication of possible neutron halo in zr isotopes . of course , we should note that as we have found in our previous work @xcite , the sudden increase of the neutron radii in @xmath116zr @xmath1 @xmath152zr , predicted by the rchb @xcite and the resonant rmf+bcs @xcite calculations , can not be fully reproduced by the expansion method in the harmonic - oscillator basis . nevertheless , this should not prevent us from gaining some useful insights into possible neutron halo feature , as we can see in zr isotopes where a sudden increase in neutron radii from @xmath153zr is quite obvious . it is our strong desire to develop a model valid for all nuclei , including unstable ones from the proton drip line to the neutron drip line . the relativistic mean field theory , as a relativistic method which incorporates spin - orbit interaction naturally , hopefully can be the desirable model with only a few parameters fitted by the saturation properties of nuclear matter and the ground - state properties of a few well - known spherical nuclei . however , to describe nuclei over a wide mass region , deformation effects and pairing correlations must be taken into account simultaneously and in a proper way . the present method we adopted can fulfill all these requirements nicely and cost reasonable time to carry out large - scale calculations covering all nuclei from the proton drip line to the neutron drip line , which are necessary to test a phenomenological method and provide reliable information for both experimental physicists and other related subjects . in the present work , we have studied two of the most interesting isotopic chains in the periodic table , zr and sn , from the proton drip line to the neutron drip line . this is the first of such kind of calculations carried out in the relativistic mean field model for the whole zr and sn isotopic chains including deformation effects and proper pairing correlations . our calculations reproduce the available experimental data very well including the nuclear binding energies , the separation energies , the odd - even staggerings ( oess ) , and the nuclear radii . in particular , nuclear deformations are analyzed in detail for both zr and sn isotopes in the mean field level . remarkable agreements with the very successful non - relativistic theoretical models , the frdm model and the hf+bcs method , are observed . surprisingly , we find that sn isotopes are deformed in the region of @xmath154 . the fact that all theoretical works reach the same conclusion makes our predictions well grounded . @xmath24sn is found to be the last stable nucleus against neutron emission in the sn isotopic chain and the predicted halo phenomena in the zr isotopic chain are confirmed once again . here , it is necessary to mention the mass dependence of the parameter set tma . there are several reasons to introduce a mass dependence to the effective interaction . first , as pointed out in ref . @xcite , such a mass dependence is indispensable to reproduce all the nuclei from small to large mass numbers . second , since it is well known that the effective interaction is strongly density dependent , it is reasonable to have a mass dependence to relate various cluster effects with mass . third , the good agreement of many nuclear properties calculated using this parameter set with those from the parameter set nl3 also supports such a mass dependence . geng is grateful to the monkasho fellowship for supporting his stay at research center for nuclear physics where this work is carried out . this work was partly supported by the major state basic research development program under contract number g2000077407 and the national natural science foundation of china under grant no . 10025522 , 10221003 and 10047001 . and @xmath71 , of zr isotopes . the results obtained from the deformed rmf+bcs calculations with tma set ( open circle ) are compared with available experimental data ( solid square ) . in the upper panel , the results obtained from the deformed rmf+bcs calculations with nl3 set ( open star ) are also shown for comparison . ] the binding energies per nucleon of zr and sn isotopes . the results obtained from the deformed rmf+bcs calculations with tma set ( open circle ) are compared with available experimental data ( solid square ) . ] the mass quadrupole deformation parameters , @xmath87 , of zr isotopes . the results obtained from the deformed rmf+bcs calculations with tma set ( solid up - triangle ) and nl3 set ( empty down - triangle ) are compared with those of finite range droplet model ( frdm ) ( solid square ) , those of hartree fock + bcs ( hf+bcs ) method ( empty circle ) and those extracted from the b(e2 ) values ( solid diamond with error bar ) . the results from the rmf+bcs / nl3 calculations are only shown for even - even nuclei . ] the proton and neutron single - particle spectra of @xmath2sn . the results obtained from the deformed rmf+bcs calculations with tma and nl3 parameter sets are compared with available experimental data.,title="fig:",width=226,height=264]the proton and neutron single - particle spectra of @xmath2sn . the results obtained from the deformed rmf+bcs calculations with tma and nl3 parameter sets are compared with available experimental data.,title="fig:",width=226,height=264 ] the charge , proton and neutron radii obtained from the deformed rmf+bcs calculations with the tma parameter set ( open square and circle ) compared with available experimental data ( solid square ) . the solid line denotes a @xmath151 dependence . ]

the ground - state properties of zr and sn isotopes are studied within the relativistic mean field theory . zr and sn isotopes have received tremendous attention due to various reasons , including the predicted giant halos in the neutron - rich zr isotopes , the unique feature of being robustly spherical in the region of @xmath0sn @xmath1 @xmath2sn and the particular interest of sn isotopes to nuclear astrophysics . furthermore , four ( semi- ) magic neutron numbers , 40 , 50 , 82 and 126 , make these two isotopic chains particularly important to test the pairing correlations and the deformations in a microscopic model . in the present work , we carry out a systematic study of zr and sn isotopes from the proton drip line to the neutron drip line with deformation effects , pairing correlations and blocking effects for nuclei with odd number of neutrons properly treated . a constrained calculation with quadrupole deformations is performed to find the absolute minimum for each nucleus on the deformation surface . all ground - state properties , including the separation energies , the odd - even staggerings , the nuclear radii , the deformations and the single - particle spectra are analyzed and discussed in detail .

1209.4770

a central issue in the field of spintronics is the design of spin - based electronic devices.@xcite they may involve ferromagnets or external magnetic fields to control the spin degree of freedom.@xcite but recently , all - electric spintronic devices also have gained interest.@xcite they rely on spin - orbit ( so ) interaction , the strength of which is tunable via external gates in semiconductor heterostructures,@xcite a basic requirement for the realization of a spin field - effect transistor . a spin - polarized current in a semiconductor can be generated by spin injection . here we focus on an alternative route that relies on pumping . by varying the parameters of a mesoscopic system periodically in time , a finite charge or spin current can be sustained . experimental studies have investigated charge pumping in several mesoscopic devices.@xcite spin pumping has been experimentally realized in the presence of an external magnetic field.@xcite theoretical studies of spin pumping involve external magnetic fields,@xcite ferromagnetic leads,@xcite and also so coupling.@xcite in the present paper , we consider the minimal model that contains so interaction : a quantum dot with two spin - degenerate orbital levels . such a two - level quantum dot with more than two leads has been suggested as a spin filter.@xcite we focus on the _ adiabatic _ limit of pumping , i.e. , the parameters are varied slowly in time compared to the dwell time of the mesoscopic system.@xcite adiabatic pumping of charge and spin through such a two - level dot has been considered in the limit of vanishing charging energy.@xcite it was found that this system can act as an _ all - electric spin battery _ , i.e. , a finite spin current can be achieved without ferromagnets by electrically controlling the dot parameters . for specific symmetries in the tunnel coupling of the dot to the leads even pure spin currents have been suggested . from the analysis of ref . , which was based on a scattering - matrix approach,@xcite it is not clear whether and how the conclusions can be transferred to quantum dots with non vanishing coulomb interaction . to answer this question is the main goal of the present paper . in order to take the coulomb interaction into account , we use a diagrammatic real - time approach@xcite that allows for arbitrary strengths of the coulomb interaction . we focus on the limit of weak tunnel coupling , for which we perform a systematic perturbation expansion to lowest order . to emphasize the role of coulomb interaction , we compare the limit of vanishing coulomb interaction with the limit of an infinitely large charging energy . the paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ model ] we introduce the model that describes the so interaction in a two - level quantum dot with coulomb interaction . section [ method ] deals with the technique to calculate the pumped charge and pumped spin during one pumping cycle . to study the dependence of the pumped charge ( spin ) on the four tunnel - matrix elements in a transparent way , we introduce in sec . [ isospin ] an isospin representation of the orbital degree of freedom . finally , in sec . [ res ] we present the results for the pumped charge and pumped spin . ( color online ) energy scheme of the two - level quantum dot . the two orbital , spin - degenerate levels can be varied in time . they are tunnel coupled to the left ( l ) and the right ( r ) lead , with tunnel - matrix elements @xmath0 . the leads have the same chemical potential @xmath1 . ] we consider a quantum dot with two spin - degenerate orbital levels @xmath2 ( with labels @xmath3 for the orbital and @xmath4 for the spin ) , tunnel coupled to the left ( l ) and the right ( r ) lead ( see fig . [ fig : model ] ) . the system is described by the hamiltonian @xmath5 here , @xmath6 is the hamiltonian of the isolated dot , @xmath7 of the leads , and @xmath8 of the tunneling between dot and leads . the hamiltonian for the isolated quantum dot contains two parts . the single - particle contribution for the two orbitals @xmath9 with energy @xmath10 , which are coupled by so interaction , can be cast in the @xmath11 matrix @xmath12 for the basis @xmath13 , where the spin quantization axis is chosen arbitrarily . here , @xmath14 denotes the vector of pauli matrices , @xmath15 is the identity matrix , and @xmath16 is a real vector describing the so coupling . the matrix in eq . has the most general form that allows time - reversal symmetry . it has been used in the context of pumping@xcite and was also recently applied to electron - transport in the presence of a magnetic field@xcite and to study the josephson current through a double - dot structure.@xcite in the following , we choose the spin quantization axis parallel to @xmath16 so the matrix becomes diagonal in spin space . the second part of the dot hamiltonian accounts for the charging energy @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is the total number of dot electrons and @xmath19 an external gate charge . without loss of generality , we can choose @xmath20 ( any other value can be achieved by a constant shift of the energies @xmath10 ) . this leads ( up to an additive constant ) to the dot hamiltonian @xmath21 where the operator @xmath22 creates an electron in state @xmath2 and the corresponding number operator is @xmath23 . we used the notation @xmath24 for spin parallel ( antiparallel ) to @xmath16 , @xmath25 , and @xmath26 . the leads are modeled as reservoirs of noninteracting electrons , @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the creation operator for an electron with spin @xmath29 and momentum @xmath30 in lead @xmath31 . tunneling between dot and leads is described by the hamiltonian @xmath32 with ( spin - independent ) tunnel - matrix elements @xmath0 for tunneling between lead @xmath31 and orbital @xmath9 . pumping is achieved by varying system parameters periodically in time . in this paper , we assume that the energy levels @xmath33 can be changed in time via external gates capacitively coupled to the system . in principle , the external gates also may affect the so coupling , the tunnel couplings , and the electro chemical potential of the leads ( via parasitic capacitances ) . to simplify the discussion , however , we assume for the following these parameters to be constant in time . we focus on the regime of adiabatic pumping , which is achieved for pumping frequencies @xmath34 smaller than the inverse of the dwell time . this is valid for @xmath35 , where @xmath36 is the tunnel - coupling strength , @xmath37 , with @xmath38 . the density of states @xmath39 is assumed to be flat and equal for the left and right leads . we choose a gauge where all four tunnel - matrix elements are real . to study the effect of coulomb interaction , we compare results for the limit of noninteracting ( @xmath40 ) and infinitely strong interacting ( @xmath41 ) electrons on the dot . in the latter case , the total number of electrons in the quantum dot can only be zero or 1 . to calculate the pumped charge and pumped spin , we use a diagrammatic real - time approach to adiabatic pumping through quantum - dot systems . @xcite for the present context , we extend the analysis of ref . to allow for a time - dependent transformation of the basis states . this is necessary since the so coupling couples time - dependent orbital levels , which , in turn , makes the dot eigenstates time dependent . we start in sec . [ density ] with the kinetic equation for the reduced density matrix in its general form , which describes the time evolution of the dot s degrees of freedom . subsequently , we perform both an adiabatic expansion , i.e. , a perturbation expansion in the pumping frequency ( sec . [ adiabatic ] ) and a perturbation expansion in the tunnel - coupling strength ( sec . [ tunnel ] ) to describe the limit of weak tunnel coupling . the pumped charge and pumped spin currents to lowest order in @xmath36 and @xmath34 are derived in sec . [ pumped ] . finally , in sec . [ weak ] , we perform the limit of weak pumping which assumes small amplitudes of the pumping parameters . the main idea of the diagrammatic real - time technique is based on the fact that the leads are described as large reservoirs of noninteracting electrons which can be integrated out in order to arrive at a reduced density matrix @xmath42 for the dot degrees of freedom only . for a matrix representation with matrix elements @xmath43 ( for the diagonal elements we introduce the notation @xmath44 ) , it is convenient to use the eigenstates @xmath45 with corresponding eigenenergies @xmath46 as a basis . for this , we employ a time - dependent unitary transformation @xmath47 acting on the dot hamiltonian @xmath6 , such that @xmath48 is diagonal . the time evolution of the reduced density matrix is given by the kinetic equation @xmath49\nonumber\\&+ \int^{t}_{-\infty}{\ : \mathrm{d}t^\prime \ : } { \bm{\mathcal{w}}}(t , t^\prime)\ \bm{p}(t^\prime)\ , . \label{master}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the bold face indicates tensor notation . the reduced density matrix @xmath42 and @xmath50 are tensors of rank 2 , while @xmath51 and @xmath52 are tensors of rank 4 , i.e. , @xmath53 the kernel element @xmath54 describes the transition from @xmath55 at time @xmath56 to @xmath57 at time @xmath58 . it is given by the sum over all irreducible blocks on the keldysh contour which correspond to the described transition . the elements of @xmath51 are differences of the eigenenergies defined as @xmath59 . the second term @xmath60 $ ] originates from the time dependence of the transformation @xmath61 , and @xmath62 denotes the time - derivative of @xmath61 . in the following adiabatic expansion and the expansion in the tunnel - coupling strength , we follow the lines of ref . . in the limit of slow variation of the system parameters , such that the duration of one pumping cycle , @xmath63 , is much larger than the dwell time of an electron in the quantum dot , we can perform an adiabatic expansion of eq . , which is equivalent to an expansion of all time dependencies around the final time @xmath58 and to systematically keep all contributions that contain one time derivative . for this , we first do a taylor expansion of the reduced density matrix around the finite time @xmath58 , i.e. , @xmath64 . we then expand the kernel and the density matrix in the pumping frequency , i.e. , @xmath65 and @xmath66 . the instantaneous order , indicated by the index @xmath67 , describes the limit where all system parameters are frozen at time @xmath58 . the adiabatic correction , labeled by @xmath68 , contains one time derivative , i.e. , it collects all contributions to first order in the pumping frequency @xmath34 . the difference in the eigenenergies of the isolated dot , @xmath69 , is of instantaneous order , while @xmath70 belongs to the adiabatic correction . since both @xmath71 and @xmath72 depend only on the difference @xmath73 , it is convenient to perform the laplace transform @xmath74 . using the short notations @xmath75 and @xmath76 , the kinetic equation reads @xmath77 in instantaneous order , and @xmath78\nonumber\\&+{\bm{\mathcal{w}}}^{(a)}_t \bm{p}^{(i)}_t+\partial{\bm{\mathcal{w}}}^{(i)}_t{\ : \frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}}\bm{p}^{(i)}_t \label{meqa}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the adiabatic correction . the normalization condition for the density matrix is expressed as @xmath79 and @xmath80 . in addition to the adiabatic expansion , we perform a perturbation expansion in the tunnel - coupling strength @xmath36 . for a systematic expansion of the kinetic equations , we need to analyze the term @xmath81 . it vanishes for all diagonal matrix elements of @xmath82 . the off - diagonal matrix elements , associated with coherent superpositions , are only nonzero when the superposition is not forbidden by conserved quantum numbers and when the energy difference of the corresponding states is smaller or of the order of @xmath36 . therefore , we count all contributing matrix elements of @xmath51 to be of the order of @xmath36 . the expansion of the kernels , @xmath83 , starts to first order in @xmath36 and the instantaneous order of the reduced density matrix to zeroth order , @xmath84 . to properly match the powers of @xmath36 in eq . , the adiabatic correction of the reduced density matrix , @xmath85 , has to start to minus first order.@xcite in the following , we consider the limit of weak tunnel coupling , @xmath86 , for which we restrict ourselves to the lowest - order contributions in @xmath36 . the instantaneous part of the kinetic equation starts to first order in @xmath36 , @xmath87 with normalization @xmath88 . for the adiabatic correction , the expansion of eq . ( [ meqa ] ) to lowest ( zeroth ) order in @xmath36 yields @xmath89 with @xmath90 . all other terms appearing on the right - hand side of eq . ( [ meqa ] ) are of higher order in @xmath36 and drop out . this is immediately obvious for the last two terms in eq . ( [ meqa ] ) . but also @xmath91 $ ] drops out in the absence of any bias voltage . in this case , @xmath92 is given by the equilibrium distribution , which is diagonal with matrix elements being determined by boltzmann factors . since energy differences , @xmath51 , of states for which coherent superpositions are allowed are of the order of @xmath36 , the difference of the corresponding occupation probabilities for these states is also of the order of @xmath36 and , therefore , vanishes in the perturbation expansion . this means that the matrix elements @xmath93\right)^{\chi_1}_{\chi_2}=\left(p^{(i,0)}_{t\ \chi_2}-p^{(i,0)}_{t\ \chi_1}\right)\left(\bm{t}^\dagger\dot{\bm{t}}\right)^{\chi_1}_{\chi_2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] vanish for all combinations of @xmath94 and @xmath95 which are needed in the kinetic equation . the pumped current and the pumped spin current from the dot into the left lead are given by @xmath96},\\ s_\text{l}(t)&= \frac{\hbar}{2 } \int_{-\infty}^t{\ : \mathrm{d}t^\prime \ : } { \ : \mathrm{tr}\ ! \left [ { \bm{\mathcal{w}}}^{\text{l}}_s(t , t{^\prime})\:\bm{p}(t{^\prime } ) \right]},\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively . here , we have introduced @xmath97 where @xmath98 only contains those diagrams of @xmath99 in which @xmath100 electrons with spin @xmath29 enter the left lead , i.e. , in which the number of lines for lead @xmath101 and spin @xmath29 going from the upper to the lower contour minus the number of lines from the lower to the upper contour is @xmath100 . analogously to the expansion of the kinetic equation , we perform the adiabatic expansion and the perturbation expansion in the tunnel - coupling strength for the pumped charge and spin current . to lowest order we get @xmath102 } , \label{eq : current1}\\ s^{(a,0)}_\text{l}(t)&= \frac{\hbar}{2 } { \ : \mathrm{tr}\ ! \left [ \left({\bm{\mathcal{w}}}^{\text{l}}_{s , t}\right)^{(i,1)}\:\bm{p}_t^{(a,-1 ) } \right]}.\label{eq : current2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the pumped charge and the pumped spin per pumping cycle is obtained by integration , @xmath103 and @xmath104 . the diagrammatic rules to calculate analytically @xmath105 can be found in appendix [ rules ] . @xcite after having determined @xmath105 , we obtain the adiabatic correction to the reduced density matrix , @xmath106 , by solving the kinetic equations and . those , then , enter eqs . and for the pumped charge and spin currents . we split the energy of the orbital levels into the time - averaged part , @xmath107 , and the deviation @xmath108 : @xmath109 in the limit of weak pumping , the time - dependent part of the pumping parameters is small compared to other energy scales of the system such as tunnel - coupling strength and temperature , @xmath110 . hence , we can expand the pumped charge , @xmath111 , and pumped spin , @xmath112 , to lowest ( bilinear ) order in @xmath113 and @xmath114 . for adiabatic pumping , the pumped charge ( spin ) is proportional to the area enclosed by the path of @xmath115 in the parameter space during one pumping cycle . therefore , a phase difference is necessary to gain finite pumped charge ( spin ) . the enclosed area is given by @xmath116 . all results in sec . [ res ] are calculated in the weak - pumping limit . for each matrix element @xmath117 that needs to be considered ( all diagonal ones and those off - diagonal ones that describe possible coherent superpositions ) , there is one kinetic equation . it is often convenient to transform the reduced density matrix such that only linear combinations of the @xmath117 s appear , which allows for a straightforward physical interpretation . in the context of spin transport through a single - level quantum dot with ferromagnetic leads , it is advantageous to formulate the kinetic equations separately for the occupation probability of zero , one or two electrons on the quantum dot , and the three components of the spin on the dot . @xcite the vector character of the spin accounts for both a spin imbalance along a given axis and the coherent dynamics of the accumulated spin . one virtue of such a transformation lies in the fact that it is possible to write the kinetic equation in a ( spin-)coordinate - free form , which does not depend on the choice of the spin quantization axis . a similar transformation can also be used for the orbital degree of freedom in systems in which coherent superpositions of the occupation of different orbitals appear . these superpositions are conveniently described by defining an isospin . this has been done before for several double - dot systems . @xcite we will introduce such an isospin description now for the system under consideration . in this paper , we focus on the limits of @xmath40 and @xmath41 . in the first case , @xmath40 , the hilbert space is @xmath118-dimensional , i.e. , the reduced density matrix is a @xmath119 matrix . however , since we choose the spin - quantization axes along the direction of the so field , the hamiltonian divides into two independent spin channels . as a result , the reduced density matrix can be written as a direct product of the @xmath120 density matrices for spin up and spin down , @xmath121 . in the basis @xmath122 that corresponds , for each spin @xmath29 , to the occupation of none of the orbitals , of orbital 1 , of orbital 2 , and of both orbitals , respectively , the reduced density matrix reads @xmath123 note that , in order to keep the notation simple , we put the index @xmath29 only once at the matrix indicating the @xmath29-dependence of each of the matrix elements . for @xmath41 the dot is either singly occupied or empty , i.e. , the hilbert space is five - dimensional . the reduced density matrix takes the form @xmath124 note that , here , @xmath125 is the probability that the dot is not occupied with either spin , while for @xmath40 we used @xmath126 for the probability that the dot is not occupied with spin @xmath29 , irrespective of the occupation of spin @xmath127 . to describe the coherent superposition associated with the off - diagonal matrix elements , it is convenient to introduce , for each physical spin , an isospin operator @xmath128 with quantum - statistical expectation value @xmath129 . choosing the coordinate system for the isospin such that @xmath130 and @xmath131 are the eigenstates of @xmath132 , we get @xmath133 , @xmath134 , and @xmath135 . since ultimately we aim at a coordinate - free form of the kinetic equations , we abbreviate the @xmath136-axis chosen above by the normalized vector @xmath137 , i.e. , @xmath130 and @xmath131 are the eigenstates of @xmath138 . the isospin direction @xmath137 characterizes the eigenstates of the isolated quantum dot in the absence of so coupling . the so coupling , however , couples the two orbitals . as a consequence , the dot eigenstates @xmath139 for single occupation with spin @xmath29 are linear combinations of the two orbitals @xmath130 and @xmath131 , given by the transformation @xmath140 the corresponding eigenenergies are @xmath141 , with the mean dot level @xmath142 and @xmath143 . the transformation depends on the spin @xmath29 , the level spacing of the both orbitals , @xmath144 , and the strength of the so coupling , @xmath145 . we consider the regime where @xmath145 and @xmath146 are of order @xmath36 . therefore , the level spacing @xmath147 of the eigenenergies @xmath148 is also of order @xmath36 . as we pump on both energies , @xmath113 and @xmath114 , the transformation @xmath149 and the eigenenergies @xmath150 are time dependent . the unitary transformation @xmath151 corresponds to a rotation about the @xmath152-axis with the spin - dependent angle @xmath153 in isospin space . this means that the dot eigenstates @xmath154 are eigenstates to the isospin projection @xmath155 along the direction @xmath156 that is obtained from @xmath137 by the above mentioned rotation ( see fig . [ fig : mn ] ) . the tunneling hamiltonian couples the lead - electron states to both orbitals , i.e. , to a linear combination of @xmath130 and @xmath131 . to diagonalize the tunneling from and to lead @xmath31 , we employ the unitary transformation @xmath157 in isospin space , this transformation corresponds to a rotation about the @xmath158-axis with angle @xmath159 applying this rotation on @xmath137 generates the direction @xmath160 ( see fig . [ fig : mn ] ) which has the following physical interpretation : only dot electrons with @xmath161 isospin projection along @xmath162 couple to reservoir @xmath31 , while the @xmath163 isospin projection is decoupled from the lead.@xcite therefore , in a ferromagnetic analogy , the leads are full isospin polarized with polarization along @xmath160 . ( color online ) scheme of different relevant isospin quantization axes . the vector @xmath137 represents the quantization where the orbital levels @xmath130 and @xmath131 are the eigenstates of the @xmath164 operator of the isospin . the two axes @xmath165 are the quantization axes where the eigenstates of @xmath164 are the eigenstates of @xmath166 for single occupation . in a ferromagnetic analogy , the leads are fully isospin polarized along the axes @xmath160 . ] first , we write the kinetic equations and in the basis @xmath167 for the @xmath40 limit and @xmath168 for @xmath41 . those kinetic equations are treated perturbatively to first order in the tunnel - coupling strength @xmath36 . as described above , we count both @xmath145 and @xmath146 as one order in @xmath36 . the elements of the kernel @xmath105 are calculated by the rules in appendix [ rules ] . including the isospin in the formulation of the kinetic equation , the system is fully described by the occupation probabilities of the dot and the expectation values of the isospins . in particular , we perform the transformation from @xmath169 to @xmath170 in the limit of vanishing coulomb interaction . the probabilities describing the occupation of the dot with spin @xmath29 are @xmath171 for empty , @xmath125 , single , @xmath172 , and double occupation , @xmath173 . in the limit of strong coulomb interaction , @xmath41 , the transformation reads @xmath174 to @xmath175 . the relevant occupation probabilities are @xmath176 with @xmath177 being the possibility that the dot is occupied by a single electron with spin @xmath29 . we identify in the resulting kinetic equations the vectors @xmath160 and @xmath178 and get , thus , a representation that is independent of the choice of basis . in the limit of @xmath40 , we get [ eq : dia : mequ0 ] @xmath179 where @xmath180 is the fermi function at energy @xmath181 . as the difference of the eigenenergies , @xmath147 , is of order @xmath36 , we have to drop @xmath147 in terms which are already linear in @xmath36 . therefore , the fermi function , @xmath182 , depends here only on the mean level position , @xmath181 , since every term which includes the fermi function is linear in @xmath36 . in the equations for the probabilities , the isospin projections along the directions defined by the leads enter in the weighted average @xmath183 with @xmath184 . the isospin projection direction given by the so coupling , on the other hand , gives rise to a precession term about the effective field @xmath185 in the equation for the isospin . this effective field is the only place where the so coupling enters the kinetic equations . equations and represent both the instantaneous order and the adiabatic correction of the kinetic equation . for the first case , one needs to set the left - hand side to zero and add the index @xmath186 to the isospin and the occupation probabilities on the right - hand side . ( note that the instantaneous part of the isospin vanishes in lowest order in @xmath36 , @xmath187 . ) for the the second case , we need to add the index @xmath186 on the left - hand side and @xmath188 on the right - hand side , respectively . in the limit of strong coulomb interaction , @xmath41 , the kinetic equations read [ eq : dia : mequi ] @xmath189 in addition to the effective field @xmath190 generated by the so coupling , we identified here another effective field @xmath191 acting on the isospin . the latter appears as a consequence of the interplay between tunneling and coulomb interaction . it is formally identical to the exchange field acting on the physical spin in quantum dots attached to ferromagnetic leads.@xcite in the limit of @xmath192 , it is given by @xmath193 \ , , \label{eq : dia : bufeld}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath194 is the digamma function and we used @xmath195 . the high - energy cutoff @xmath196 appearing in the second line guarantees convergence of the energy integral.@xcite physically it is provided by the smaller of the band width of the leads and the charging energy . for practical calculations it is not necessary to use the basis - independent form of this isospin representation . it allows for a better physical understanding of the systems dynamics but for evaluating the pumped charge and spin as described in sec . [ method ] , it is convenient to use the basis @xmath122 in the @xmath40 limit and @xmath168 for @xmath41 . in this section , we present the results for the adiabatically pumped charge ( spin ) in the weak - pumping regime . to calculate those , we use the formalism that has been introduced in sec . [ method ] . we integrate the pumped charge and spin currents , eqs . and , over one pumping cycle and obtain the pumped charge and pumped spin per pumping cycle . in order to simplify the time dependence of the pumped currents , we make use of the weak pumping limit ( see sec . [ weak ] ) and expand the integrand up to bilinear order in the pumping parameters , @xmath113 and @xmath114 . in this case , all results are proportional to the area , @xmath197 , enclosed in the pumping - parameter space . we normalize our results by @xmath197 and , thus , they are independent of the exact path in parameter space . to analyze the effect of coulomb interaction , we compare results for noninteracting electrons , @xmath40 , with the limit of strong coulomb interaction . the latter is realized by setting @xmath41 in the hamiltonian and , thereby , suppressing occupation of the quantum dot with more than one electron . furthermore , finite coulomb interaction influences the amplitude of the exchange field , @xmath191 , via the high - energy cutoff , @xmath196 . in all calculations , we set @xmath198 . we assume weak tunnel coupling between quantum dot and leads , @xmath86 , i.e. , we restrict the calculation to lowest order in the tunnel - coupling strength @xmath36 . if not stated otherwise , the so - coupling strength is @xmath199 . for @xmath40 , the results of this paper can be compared with calculations that include higher orders in @xmath36 . for example , brosco _ et al . _ have studied the two - level quantum dot with so coupling and vanishing coulomb interaction in the limit of zero temperature.@xcite calculations to all orders in @xmath36 can be done , e.g. , with a scattering matrix approach,@xcite which is equivalent to an approach that is based on a formula relating the pumped current to the instantaneous dot greens functions.@xcite the latter is , in general , extendable to finite interaction . in this section , we study the dependence of the pumped charge ( spin ) on various parameters : the strength of the so coupling , @xmath145 , the tunnel coupling to the leads , @xmath0 , and the time - averaged dot levels , @xmath200 . it is convenient to parametrize the latter by the time - averaged mean dot level , @xmath201 , and the averaged spacing of both orbital levels , @xmath202 . in the regime under consideration , the temperature appears only in two ways . first , since the mean energy level only appears in the combination @xmath203 , the temperature provides the energy scale on which variation of the mean level energy changes the pumped charge ( spin ) . second , the absolute value of the pumped charge and pumped spin are proportional to @xmath204 . therefore , all plots are normalized accordingly . the dependences of the pumped charge ( spin ) on the other parameters are not affected by temperature . the tunnel coupling of the two dot orbitals to the left and the right lead is defined by four real tunnel - matrix elements , @xmath0 . if the tunnel - matrix elements are equal for the coupling to the left and right lead , @xmath205 , then , for symmetry reasons , there will be no pumping transport via variation of the quantum dot s levels . to achieve pumping , the left - right symmetry needs to be broken by changing either the magnitude or the sign of one the tunnel couplings . we find it convenient to parametrize the tunnel - matrix elements by angles @xmath206 , which have been introduced in the previous section ( see eq . ) . the tunnel - matrix elements then are given by the relations @xmath207 and @xmath208 . for @xmath209 both orbital levels are coupled symmetrically to lead @xmath31 , i.e. , @xmath210 , and for @xmath211 the orbitals are coupled antisymmetrically , @xmath212 . the necessary condition to get a finite pumped charge ( spin ) is @xmath213 , since @xmath214 ( even for @xmath215 ) leads automatically to an effective one parameter pumping without any finite pumped charge ( spin ) in the adiabatic limit . motivated by the previous discussion , we first focus on a tunnel - coupling configuration with @xmath216 but @xmath213 , where the pumped charge and pumped spin are , in general , finite . both depend on the mean dot - level positions , @xmath217 and @xmath218 , which is shown in fig . [ fig : c ] . those orbital energies of the quantum dot can , in principal , be adjusted by capacitively coupled gate votages . figures [ fig : qu0]-[fig : sui ] illustrate the pumped charge ( spin ) for @xmath40 and @xmath41 and for a tunnel - coupling configuration where the coupling to the left lead is symmetric regarding the orbitals , @xmath219 , while the coupling to the right lead is given by @xmath220 , i.e. , @xmath221 . in the case where orbital @xmath222 is symmetrically @xmath223 and orbital @xmath224 is antisymmetrically @xmath225 coupled to the left and right leads , the pumped spin is in general finite while the pumped charge vanishes for this configuration . in figs . [ fig : psu0 ] and [ fig : psui ] the pumped spin is exemplarily calculated for @xmath226 , which is equivalent to @xmath227 . each plot in fig . [ fig : c ] shows a maximum and a minimum value . for no coulomb interaction , the maximum value is located at @xmath228 ( relative to the chemical potential @xmath1 of the leads ) . in the limit of strong coulomb interaction , the extrema positions are shifted to values of @xmath217 , whose order of magnitude is given by the temperature . the @xmath218-position of the maximum pumped charge ( spin ) depends on the tunnel coupling to the leads and the so - coupling strength . increasing @xmath145 also increases the maximum s position with respect to @xmath218 . furthermore , the pumped charge is in general larger for no coulomb interaction apart from special tunnel - coupling configurations discussed in detail in the next section . that is not surprising since the coulomb interaction reduces the possible transport channels through the dot by suppressing occupations of the dot with more than one electron . both limits @xmath40 and @xmath41 show different symmetries with respect to @xmath229 . in the limit @xmath40 , the pumped charge ( spin ) is exactly antisymmetric in @xmath218 . the antisymmetry with respect to @xmath230 originates from the particle - hole symmetry . the antisymmetry in @xmath218 alone , on the other hand , is a non - trivial result and only valid for the lowest order contribution in @xmath36 . in the limit of strong coulomb interaction , the symmetry in @xmath218 differs from the @xmath40 limit . the exchange field @xmath231 , which interacts with the isospin , leads to a contribution of the pumped charge ( spin ) that is not antisymmetric in @xmath218 . therefore , the antisymmetry is , in general , broken . to point out the symmetry characteristics , we study the pumped charge ( spin ) in two different tunnel - coupling configurations @xmath232 and @xmath233 , for both @xmath234 , @xmath235 which is equivalent to ( 1 ) : @xmath236 , @xmath237 in the first case , and ( 2 ) : @xmath238 , @xmath221 in the second one . tunnel couplings @xmath232 and @xmath233 show that the exchange field can affect the pumped charge and the pumped spin differently , and the effect , thus , depends on the tunnel - coupling parameters . that is accounted for by fig . [ fig : de ] , where the cut through the contour plot ( of fig . [ fig : c ] but with coupling configurations @xmath232 and @xmath233 ) for fixed @xmath217 is shown . ( color online ) pumped charge ( spin ) with finite so coupling , @xmath199 , in the @xmath40 and the @xmath41 limit depending on the averaged level - spacing of both orbital levels . in the @xmath40 limit we choose @xmath228 , which is the position of the maximum value . in the limit of strong coulomb interaction , we use @xmath239 as an approximation to the position of the maximum value . the two sets of coupling parameters ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) are the ones given in the text ( see eq . ) . the vertical dotted lines indicate _ pure spin pumping_. in the weak - coupling limit , this is only possible for pumping with coulomb interaction . ] the fixed value of @xmath217 is @xmath228 in the limit of vanishing coulomb interaction and , for comparison , @xmath239 in the limit of strong coulomb interaction . for configuration @xmath232 , the exchange field leads to a peak located at @xmath240 which has a nearly symmetric behavior in @xmath218 . the pumped spin , on the other hand , is still approximately antisymmetric in @xmath218 . furthermore , without @xmath231 , the pumped charge ( spin ) is usually smaller for @xmath41 , compared to @xmath40 , because of the reduced number of transport channels through the dot , but the exchange field can enhance the pumped charge . there are sets of parameters where the charge transport is even larger for finite coulomb interaction than for @xmath40 . for tunnel coupling @xmath233 , the symmetric part of the exchange - field contribution is less important . the pumped charge , in this case , is not dominated by a symmetric behavior as we observed for coupling @xmath232 . it is , rather , a shift of the point of zero pumped charge to a finite value of @xmath218 similar to the pumped spin . comparing the exchange - field contribution for configurations @xmath232 and @xmath233 , the contribution to the pumped spin reaches its maximum where the contribution to the pumped charge vanishes , and it is approximately half of its absolute maximum value where the contribution to the pumped charge has its maximum . for large values of exchange - field contribution , near its maximum , the pumped charge has a dominant symmetric contribution while the exchange - field contribution to the pumped spin is , in general , too small to generate a peak at @xmath240 . pure spin pumping is achieved whenever the pumped charge vanishes but the pumped spin remains finite . to find such points it is helpful that the pumped charge and pumped spin behave differently in the presence of coulomb interaction , as discussed in the previous section , and that the pumped charge is more sensitive to symmetry in the tunnel - matrix elements than the pumped spin . this defines the two strategies to obtain pure spin pumping : to tune either the orbital energy levels of the dot or the tunnel - matrix elements . for fixed tunnel couplings , we try to tune the orbital energies such that the pumped charge vanishes but the pumped spin remains finite . as discussed above , this is easily possible for strong coulomb interaction , because in this case , the value of @xmath218 at which the pumped charge changes its sign is shifted away from @xmath240 due to the exchange field @xmath191 . in absence of coulomb interaction ( and to lowest order in the tunnel coupling strength ) , this does , in general , not work apart from special coupling configurations , where the pumped charge vanishes independently of the orbital energies , as discussed in the next section . the reason is that both the pumped charge and the pumped spin are , to lowest order in @xmath36 , exactly antisymmetric in @xmath218 , i.e. , the pumped charge and spin vanish simultaneously . the comparison between the two limits is shown in fig . [ fig : de ] . the points of pure spin pumping are indicated by the vertical dotted lines . another interesting feature of the finite difference between the zero - points for the pumped charge and the pumped spin is the possibility to change the sign of the pumped spin , while charge is pumped in the same direction . there are cases in which pure spin current is not only possible for special , fine - tuned orbital energies but for _ all _ values of @xmath217 and @xmath218 . this is illustrated in fig . [ fig : cw ] , which shows the maximum absolute value of the pumped charge ( spin ) in the @xmath241 parameter space , as a function of the coupling parameters @xmath206 for @xmath234 and for both limits @xmath40 and @xmath41 . the plots can be periodically continued . the dotted lines represent coupling configurations where the pumped charge and the pumped spin are zero . along the middle dotted line , @xmath242 , pumped charge and pumped spin vanish due to left - right symmetry as mentioned previously . here , the tunnel - matrix elements are equal for the coupling to the left and the right lead , @xmath205 . the dotted zero - lines @xmath243 for zero pumped charge ( spin ) only exist for lowest order in @xmath36 ; higher - order corrections would lead , in general , to a finite pumped charge ( spin ) . the latter conclusion can be drawn by comparing with calculations for @xmath40 which are exact in @xmath36 , e.g. , by means of a scattering matrix approach,@xcite and it is self - evident that even finite coulomb interaction does not change that significantly . along these lines the tunnel - matrix elements are given by @xmath244 . in any case , these dotted lines do no mark good candidates for pure spin pumping since , there , charge and spin behave similar . the situation differs along the dashed lines . the middle dashed line , @xmath245 , represents a configuration where for each orbital the absolute value of the tunnel - matrix elements is the same , but one element of all four has an opposite sign , i.e. @xmath246 and @xmath247 ( or equivalently @xmath248 ) . here , we find ( to lowest order in @xmath36 ) pure spin pumping for both vanishing and strong coulomb interaction . this generalizes the result found in ref . for the @xmath40 limit to the limit of strong coulomb interaction . the dependence of the pure pumped spin for @xmath249 on @xmath217 and @xmath218 in both coulomb regimes is shown in figs . [ fig : psu0 ] and [ fig : psui ] . the dashed lines @xmath250 ( equivalent to @xmath251 ) indicate a further scenario for pure spin pumping to lowest order in @xmath36 in the @xmath40 limit . for higher orders in @xmath36 , however , the pumped charge becomes finite . it also becomes finite for @xmath41 ( and lowest order in @xmath36 ) as a consequence of the exchange field acting on the isospin . how important is the symmetry @xmath234 ? to answer this question , we calculate the pumped charge and spin for @xmath252 ; see fig . [ fig : cwa ] . as we see , the dependence of the pumped charge and spin on @xmath206 changes substantially for the pumped charge but not so much for the pumped spin . in particular , there are no straight lines with pure spin pumping anymore . for @xmath40 ( and to lowest order in @xmath36 ) , pure spin pumping is still possible on curved lines in the @xmath206 parameter space but not for @xmath41 . therefore , @xmath253 is a necessary requirement for pure spin pumping . the dependence of the pumped charge and pumped spin on the so - coupling strength is visualized in fig . [ fig : aso ] . ( color online ) pumped charge and pumped spin in the @xmath40 and @xmath41 limits depending on the strength of the so coupling . additionally , the green dotted line shows the pumped charge ( spin ) for @xmath41 in the case that the exchange field is turned off by hand . the illustrated functions are the maximum value of the pumped charge ( spin ) for given so strength , @xmath145 , in the @xmath241 parameter space . the coupling parameters are : @xmath234 , @xmath219 , and @xmath254 . ] here , the different functions again show the maximum value of the absolute pumped charge ( spin ) in the @xmath241 parameter space . as can be seen from the upper plot , the pumped charge decreases with increasing so coupling . it also decreases with increasing @xmath218 . in both cases , the pumping is suppressed since the difference of the eigenenergies of the dot hamiltonian becomes large . in general , the coulomb interaction reduces the amount of pumped charge and pumped spin . for small values of @xmath145 compared to @xmath36 , however , the coulomb interaction has the opposite effect on the pumped charge . in this regime , the coulomb interaction increases the pumped charge compared to the limit of @xmath40 . the latter is an effect of the exchange field : without the exchange field , the pumped charge would be reduced due to the coulomb interaction . increasing @xmath145 decreases the influence of the exchange field , i.e. , for large @xmath145 the coulomb interaction again reduces the pumped charge . for the pumped spin , the situation differs : the exchange field reduces the pumped spin even further . the pumped spin , in contrast to the pumped charge , vanishes for @xmath255 . therefore , there is an optimal value of @xmath145 that maximizes the pumped spin ( see fig . [ fig : aso ] ) . this value is smaller than @xmath36 and it depends on the tunnel coupling . we analyze the possibility to build an all - electric spin battery and to generate a pure spin current with a two - level quantum dot in the presence of coulomb interaction . in the limit of vanishing coulomb interaction , both are possible , as has been demonstrated in ref . . here , we show that this is also possible for the experimentally relevant case of a quantum dot with large coulomb interaction . the coulomb interaction changes the pumping characteristics substantially . in particular , symmetries with respect to the orbital energies change as a consequence of an effective exchange field acting on an isospin defined by the orbital level index . the nonvanishing coulomb interaction opens the possibility to achieve a pure spin current by tuning the orbital levels in the weak tunnel - coupling limit . furthermore , we find that a pure spin current is obtained independently of the orbital level energies for a certain configuration of tunnel couplings , where one level is symmetrically and the other one antisymmetrically coupled to the left and right lead , @xmath246 and @xmath247 in terms of tunnel - matrix elements . we acknowledge financial support from the dfg via spp 1285 and the eu under grant no . 238345 ( geomdiss ) . we now specify the diagrammatic rules to calculate the diagrams of the kernels @xmath256 with @xmath257 tunneling lines based on refs . . throughout the presented calculations , only the diagrams with one tunneling line @xmath258 are necessary . 1 . draw all topologically different irreducible diagrams with @xmath257 tunneling lines and the dot eigenstates @xmath259 , for @xmath40 , and @xmath260 , for @xmath41 , contributing to @xmath256 . each segment of the upper and lower contour separated by vertices is assigned with the corresponding eigenenergy @xmath261 . each tunneling line is labeled with the lead @xmath31 , spin @xmath29 and energy @xmath262 . each time segment of the diagram between two vertices at the times @xmath263 and @xmath264 leads to a contribution @xmath265 , where @xmath266 is the difference of left going energies minus right going energies . each tunneling line that goes forward or backward with respect to the keldysh contour contributes with a factor @xmath267 or @xmath268 , respectively , where @xmath268 is the fermi function . furthermore , a tunneling line that begins at a vertex containing a dot operator @xmath269 , with @xmath270 , and ends at a vertex containing @xmath271 introduces a factor @xmath272 . the matrix elements @xmath273 are obtained from the transformation @xmath274 , with @xmath38 , where @xmath275 . each vertex in the @xmath40 limit that connects state @xmath276 with state @xmath277 gives rise to a minus sign . the overall prefactor is @xmath278 , where @xmath279 is the number of vertices on the lower contour line and @xmath280 the number of crossings in the tunneling lines . 6 . integrate over all energies of the tunneling lines and sum over @xmath31 and @xmath29 . sum up all contributing diagrams . 46ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1065389 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys551 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.76.323 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physics.2.50 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.78.1335 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.283.5410.2056 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1088/0022 - 3719/17/33/015 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.102730 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1173667 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevlett.83.203 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/s0304 - 8853(98)01205 - 0 [ * * , ( ) ] http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.62.9996 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.87.016601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1209/0295 - 5075/17/3/011 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.283.5409.1905 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.2767197 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.101.126803 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.2928231 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.91.258301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.89.146802 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.66.205327 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.77.195320 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.82.205308 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.91.166801 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.68.155324 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.82.041309 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1143/jpsj.79.123711 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.27.6083 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/bf01307664 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.58.r10135 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.62.r10618 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.50.18436 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.54.16820 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.76.1715 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.86.035143 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 8984/24/41/415301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.74.085305 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.82.245319 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.90.166602 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.70.195345 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.72.205319 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.76.085335 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.79.165319 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.95.246803 [ * * , ( ) ]

we study adiabatic pumping through a two - level quantum dot with spin - orbit coupling . using a diagrammatic real - time approach , we calculate both the pumped charge and spin for a periodic variation of the dot s energy levels in the limit of weak tunnel coupling . thereby , we compare the two limits of vanishing and infinitely large charging energy on the quantum dot . we discuss the dependence of the pumped charge and pumped spin on gate voltages , the symmetry in the tunnel - matrix elements and spin - orbit coupling strength . we identify the possibility to generate pure spin currents in the absence of charge currents .

nlin0205025

in time - reversal experiments a signal emitted by a localized source is recorded at an array of transducers . it is then re - emitted into the medium reversed in time , that is , the part of the signal that is recorded first is sent back last . because of the time - reversibility of the wave equation the back - propagated signal refocuses approximately at the location of the original source because the array is limited in size . a striking experimental observation is that the presence of inhomogeneities in the medium improves the refocusing resolution . the explanation for this super - resolution is multipathing : waves in complex media that are captured by the recording array have undergone multiple scattering making it effectively larger than its physical size . another important feature of super - resolution in time reversal is that the refocused signal does not depend on the realization of the random medium . that is , the refocused signal is deterministic . super - resolution and self - averaging of refocused signals in complicated media has been observed both in laboratory experiments ( see reviews @xcite and references therein ) and in underwater acoustic wave propagation over long distances ( tens of kilometers ) @xcite . time - reversal techniques have numerous applications ranging from medicine to communications and , more recently , imaging in random media @xcite . the first mathematical analysis of time - reversal in random media was given by clouet and fouque @xcite , who analyzed refocusing and self - averaging of time - reversed pulses in a one - dimensional layered random medium . their result was extended to a three - dimensional layered medium in @xcite . super - resolution in spatial refocusing and its statistical stability for multi - dimensional waves in random media was analyzed in @xcite , in a remote - sensing regime where the paraxial or parabolic wave equation can be used . the refocusing of the average signal in a full three - dimensional medium , in the regimes of random geometrical optics and radiative transfer ( transport ) , was studied in @xcite . we also mention that another source of multipathing is the mixing of waves by the boundaries in an ergodic cavity . this has been studied experimentally in @xcite and mathematically in @xcite . the purpose of this paper is to analyze time reversal in the radiative transfer regime using the parabolic wave equation , when the waves interact fully with the random inhomogeneities . we prove mathematically that the refocused signal is self - averaging , which means that it does not depend on the realization of the random medium . the mathematical quantitiy that we analyze is the wigner measure of a pair of oscillatory solutions of the random schrdinger equation . in the present setting , the random potential depends in a markovian way on the variable @xmath1 , the main direction of propagation of the waves . this allowed us to use in @xcite a martingale method to prove that the average of the wigner distribution converges to a solution of the radiative transfer equation . in this paper we use additional regularity of the wigner measure , available in time - reversal when there is some blurring at the recording array , to show that the whole wigner distribution , and not only its average , converges weakly , as a schwartz distribution and in probability , to the deterministic solution of the transport equation . the blurring at the recording array provides a priori bounds for the wigner transform in @xmath0 . these bounds and the markovianity of the random potential in the direction of propagation make the time - reversal problem more tractable mathematically and allow us to prove in a fairly simple and straightforward manner self - averaging of the time - reversed signal . we recall that the wigner transform is a convenient tool to analyze high frequency wave propagation in deterministic @xcite and random media @xcite . introduced by wigner in 1932 @xcite , it has been used extensively in the mathematical literature recently . convergence of the average wigner distribution to the solution of the radiative transfer equation was first proved by h. spohn in @xcite for time - independent potentials on small time intervals . this result was extended to global in time convergence by l. erds and h .- yau @xcite . these proofs involve infinite neumann ( diagrammatic ) expansions for the solution of the schrdinger equation and are quite involved technically . the corresponding problem with time - dependent potentials is much simpler mathematically . it was treated by us in @xcite in the markovian case , and by f. poupaud and a. vasseur @xcite in the case of finite - range time correlations . in this paper we use the fact that the wigner family arising in time - reversal problems is more regular than the usual one because blurring is added at the recording array . this provides some additional regularity usually obtained by considering mixtures of states as , for instance , in @xcite . the paper is organized as follows : we describe the scaling and obtain an expression for the back - propagated signal in terms of the wigner transform in section [ sec : signal ] . the main result and assumptions on the random medium are formulated in section [ sec : mainresult ] . the proofs are presented in section [ sec : wigner ] . this work was partially supported by onr grants n00014 - 02 - 1 - 0088 and n00014 - 02 - 1 - 0089 . g. bal was supported in part by nsf grant dms-0072008 , g. papanicolaou by grants afosr f49620 - 01 - 1 - 0465 and nsf dms-9971972 , and l. ryzhik in part by nsf grant dms-9971742 and the alfred p. sloan foundation . the pressure field @xmath2 satisfies the scalar wave equation @xmath3 here @xmath4 is the local wave speed that we will assume to be random , and the laplacian operator includes both direction of propagation , @xmath1 , and the transverse variable @xmath5 . in the physical setting , we have @xmath6 . we consider dimensions @xmath7 to stress that our analysis is independent of the dimension . if we assume that at time @xmath8 , the wave field has a `` beam - like '' structure in the @xmath1 direction , and if back - scattering may be neglected , we can replace the wave equation by its parabolic approximation @xcite . more precisely , the pressure @xmath9 may be approximated as @xmath10 where @xmath11 satisfies the schrdinger equation @xmath12 with @xmath13 the transverse laplacian in the variable @xmath14 . the refraction index @xmath15 , and @xmath16 in ( [ eq : ansatz ] ) is a reference speed . the rigorous passage to the parabolic approximation from the wave equation has been analyzed in @xcite in the deterministic case , and @xcite in a one dimensional random medium . a formal derivation of the paraxial approximation that leads to the radiative transfer regime is given below in section [ sec : scaling ] . we assume that the original source is located in the plane @xmath17 , and the time - reversal mirror is located in the plane @xmath18 as depicted in figure [ fig1 ] . during the first stage of a time reversal experiment the signal propagates for a time @xmath19 , or equivalently , over a distance @xmath20 , so that the signal arriving at the time - reversal mirror is given by @xmath21 where the green s function solves @xmath22 then the signal is time reversed . for three - dimensional acoustic pulses , this means that the pressure field is kept unchanged and that the sign of its time derivative is reversed . in the parabolic approximation , this is equivalent to phase conjugation , where @xmath11 is replaced by its complex conjugate @xmath23 . we assume that the recording array occupies a compact subset of the plane @xmath18 , and introduce a real - valued aperture function @xmath24 . it represents the restriction of the signal onto the array , and possible amplification by the array that may vary from one receiver to another . in the absence of amplification it is given by the characteristic function of an array set @xmath25 . we also allow for some blurring of the recorded signal , modeled by a convolution with kernel @xmath26 . the signal at @xmath27 after time reversal takes then the form @xmath28 the last step consists in letting the signal propagate back to the origin @xmath17 and time reversing it one more time @xmath29 the last step , phase - conjugating at the source , is not performed in real physical experiments but is convenient if we need to compare the back - propagated signal to the original signal . it affects neither the degree of refocusing nor the self - averaging effect . the back - propagated signal in time is given at the plane @xmath17 by @xmath30 we will be interested in the sequel in the refocusing and self - averaging properties of the back - propagated signal @xmath31 for each fixed frequency . self - averaging of the time signal @xmath32 then follows from ( [ eq : psib - time ] ) when @xmath33 has compact support in @xmath34 . an interesting conclusion of this paper is that the additional blurring by convolution with the kernel @xmath35 makes the signal @xmath31 self - averaging for every frequency @xmath34 . this should be contrasted with the situation studied in @xcite , where no blurring was introduced and self - averaging was observed only for the full time signal . we recall the formal passage from the reduced wave equation to the parabolic equation ( [ eq : sch ] ) described in the appendix to @xcite and explain how the radiative transfer scaling arises in this context . we start with the reduced wave equation @xmath36 and look for solutions of ( [ red - wave ] ) in the form @xmath37 then we obtain @xmath38 the refraction index @xmath39 is weakly fluctuating so that it has the form @xmath40 where @xmath41 models random fluctuations that will be described in detail in section [ sec : random - refr - ind ] . here , @xmath42 and @xmath43 are the correlation lengths of @xmath41 in the transverse and longitudinal directions , respectively , and the small parameter @xmath44 measures the strength of the fluctuation . the waves propagate over a distance @xmath45 in the @xmath14-plane and @xmath46 in the @xmath1-direction , and we rescale @xmath14 and @xmath1 accordingly . we also introduce a carrier wave number @xmath47 and replace @xmath48 , @xmath49 being the non - dimensional wave number ( we drop the prime below ) . the physical parameters determined by the medium are the length scales @xmath42 , @xmath43 and the non - dimensional parameter @xmath50 . we now explain the scaling of the parameters @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 in the radiative transfer regime . equation ( [ red - unscaled ] ) in the non - dimensional variables @xmath51 , @xmath52 becomes after we drop the primes @xmath53 we introduce the following small parameters : @xmath54 and rewrite ( [ red - scaled ] ) as @xmath55 let us assume now that @xmath56 and denote @xmath57 . then ( [ red - param ] ) becomes after multiplication by @xmath58 @xmath59 observe that when @xmath60 and @xmath61 , the first term in ( [ red - param1 ] ) is small and may be neglected in the leading order since @xmath62 . then ( [ red - param1 ] ) becomes @xmath63 which is the parabolic wave equation ( [ eq : sch ] ) in the radiative transfer scaling . the second condition in ( [ parab - assump ] ) implies that the carrier wave number should be chosen as @xmath64 . then @xmath65 implies that @xmath66 . therefore the correlation length in the longitudinal direction @xmath1 should be much longer than in the transverse plane @xmath14 . furthermore , we should have @xmath67 which in turn implies that the fluctuation strength @xmath68 . given that these constraints are satisfied the last condition in ( [ parab - assump ] ) implies that the spatial scales @xmath45 and @xmath46 should be chosen according to @xmath69 note that the constraint @xmath66 implies that @xmath70 , which is the usual constraint for the validity of the parabolic approximation . the connection between the relations of the physical parameters and the resulting scaling of the parabolic approximation is further discussed in @xcite . the rigorous passage to the parabolic approximation in one dimension in a random medium in a similar scaling is discussed in @xcite . to define what we mean by the quality of the refocused signal , we assume that the initial pulse is centered around a point @xmath71 with support comparable to the transverse correlation length . then the initial data for the schrdinger equation ( [ eq : sch - rescaled ] ) becomes in the rescaled variables @xmath72 the transducers should obviously be capable of capturing signals of frequency @xmath73 so that the blurring occurs on the scale of the source . we therefore replace @xmath26 by @xmath74 . finally , we are interested in the refocusing properties of @xmath75 in the vicinity of @xmath71 and consequently introduce the scaling @xmath76 . we then recast ( [ eq : psib ] ) as @xmath77 where @xmath78 we observe that @xmath79 , so that @xmath80 let us now introduce the auxiliary function @xmath81 as in @xcite , @xmath82 which satisfies the initial value problem @xmath83 it physically describes the component with wave vector @xmath84 that is sent back to the plane @xmath17 by the array . we then define the wigner transform as @xmath85 where @xmath86 the wigner transform @xmath87 is more regular than @xmath88 because of additional averaging in the wave vector @xmath84 . more , precisely , while the family @xmath88 is not uniformly bounded in @xmath0 , the family @xmath87 has a uniform bound in @xmath0 . this regularizing effect is essentially the same as the one obtained by considering mixtures of states for the schrdinger equation as in @xcite . we can then recast ( [ eq : psibeps2 ] ) as @xmath89 the above formula shows that the asymptotic behavior of @xmath90 as @xmath91 is characterized by that of the wigner transform @xmath92 . this section presents our two main results . the first one describes the self - averaging of the back - propagated signal @xmath93 in ( [ eq : psibeps3 ] ) . its proof is based on the second theorem , of independent interest , which shows that the wigner transform converges in probability to a unique deterministic limit , solution of a transport equation . [ thm1 ] let the array function @xmath94 and the radially symmetric filter @xmath95 be in @xmath96 , while @xmath97 for a given @xmath98 . assume also that the refraction index @xmath39 satisfies assumptions in section [ sec : random - refr - ind ] below . then for each @xmath99 the back - propagated signal @xmath100 given by ( [ eq : psibeps3 ] ) converges in probability and weakly in @xmath101 as @xmath102 to the deterministic function @xmath103 the function @xmath104 satisfies the transport equation @xmath105 with initial data @xmath106 and where the operator @xmath107 is defined by @xmath108 here @xmath109 is the fourier transform of the correlation function of @xmath41 , defined by ( [ eq : tilder ] ) below . the convergence of the wigner transform is described by the following theorem . [ thm2 ] under the assumptions of theorem [ thm1 ] the wigner distribution @xmath87 converges in probability and weakly in @xmath110 to the solution @xmath104 of the transport equation ( [ eq : treqformal ] ) . more precisely , for any test function @xmath111 the process @xmath112 converges to @xmath113 in probability as @xmath102 , uniformly on finite intervals @xmath114 . here , @xmath115 is the usual scalar product in @xmath116 . theorem [ thm1 ] is then a corollary of theorem [ thm2 ] and lemma [ lemma2 ] below . theorem [ thm1 ] provides a mathematical explanation for the important properties of the time - reversal experiment . first , it ensures that the back - propagated signal is essentially independent of the realization of the random medium in the high - frequency limit since @xmath117 is deterministic . second , it provides a quantitative description of the back - propagated field , which may be written as @xmath118 the kernel @xmath119 is the fourier transform in @xmath120 of the solution of ( [ eq : treqformal ] ) . we deduce from this formula that the back - propagated signal has much better refocusing properties in random media than in homogeneous media . as is explained in @xcite , the reason is that the limiting wigner measure @xmath121 is more regular in its @xmath122 variable when the right - hand side in ( [ eq : treqformal ] ) is present . this leads to better spatial decay of @xmath123 and hence @xmath124 is localized tighter in a random medium than in a homogeneous medium . the improvement of the refocusing in random media has been carefully analyzed theoretically and numerically in @xcite , in the fokker - plank approximation of ( [ eq : treqformal ] ) . we summarize here the main steps of the derivation of the results stated in theorems [ thm1 ] and [ thm2 ] . we first obtain in lemma [ lemma1 ] uniform bounds in @xmath0 for the wigner transform @xmath87 independently of the realization of the random medium . lemma [ lemma2 ] then shows that theorem [ thm1 ] is a consequence of theorem [ thm2 ] . the main mathematical restriction is to assume that the random potential @xmath125 is markovian in its first variable . we refer to section [ sec : random - refr - ind ] for the details of its construction . following our previous work in @xcite , we show the convergence of the expectation @xmath126 for every test function @xmath127 . its proof is simpler ( and less general ) than in @xcite because of the available a priori @xmath0 bounds on the wigner transform , which satisfies the following cauchy problem @xmath128 with @xmath129.\ ] ] since @xmath34 is a fixed parameter , we set @xmath130 without loss of generality . the solution of ( [ eq : weps ] ) with initial data in @xmath0 is understood in the sense that for every smooth test function @xmath131 , we have @xmath132 here , we have used that @xmath133 is a self - adjoint operator for @xmath115 . therefore for a smooth function @xmath134 we obtain @xmath135 , where @xmath136 is the solution of the backward problem @xmath137 with the terminal condition @xmath138 . this defines the process @xmath139 in @xmath140 and generates a corresponding measure @xmath141 on the space @xmath142;l^2({\mathbb r}^{2d}))$ ] of continuous functions in time with values in @xmath0 . the measure @xmath141 is actually supported on paths inside a ball @xmath143 with the constant @xmath144 as in lemma [ lemma1 ] . the set @xmath145 is the state space for the random process we have proved in @xcite and will use in the sequel that the family @xmath141 is tight : [ lemma - tight ] the family of measures @xmath141 is weakly compact . the proof of convergence of @xmath87 to its deterministic limit is obtained in two steps . let us fix a deterministic test function @xmath131 . we use the markovian property of the random field @xmath125 in @xmath1 to construct a first functional @xmath146;x)\!\to c[0,l]$ ] by @xmath147(z)=\langle w,\lambda\rangle(z)-\int_0^z\langle w,{\dfrac{\partial{\lambda}}{\partial{z}}}+{\mathbf k}\cdot\nabla_{\mathbf x}\lambda+ { \cal l}\lambda\rangle(\zeta)d\zeta\ ] ] and show that it is an approximate @xmath141-martingale . more precisely , we show that @xmath148(z)|{\cal f}_s\right\ } -g_\lambda[w](s)\right|\le c_{\lambda , l}\sqrt{{\varepsilon}}\ ] ] uniformly for all @xmath149;x)$ ] and @xmath150 . lemma [ lemma - tight ] implies that there exists a subsequence @xmath151 so that @xmath152 converges weakly to a measure @xmath153 supported on @xmath142;x)$ ] . weak convergence of @xmath141 and the strong convergence ( [ eq : approxmart ] ) together imply that @xmath154(z)$ ] is a @xmath153-martingale so that @xmath155(z)|{\cal f}_s\right\}-g_\lambda[w](s)=0.\ ] ] taking @xmath156 above we obtain as in @xcite the transport equation ( [ eq : treqformal ] ) for @xmath157 in its weak formulation . the second step is to show that for every test function @xmath131 the new functional @xmath158(z)=\langle w,\lambda\rangle^2(z)- 2\int_0^z\langle w,\lambda\rangle(\zeta ) \langle w,{\dfrac{\partial{\lambda}}{\partial{z}}}+{\mathbf k}\cdot\nabla_{\mathbf x}\lambda+ { \cal l}\lambda\rangle(\zeta)d\zeta\end{aligned}\ ] ] is also an approximate @xmath141-martingale . we then obtain that @xmath159 , which implies convergence in probability . it follows that the limit measure @xmath153 is unique and deterministic , and that the whole sequence @xmath141 converges . that @xmath160(z)$ ] is an approximate @xmath141-martingale uses very explicitly the uniform a priori @xmath0 bound on the wigner distribution @xmath87 . when the a priori bound is available only in a much larger space ( the space @xmath161 of @xcite ) , we are not able to prove that the functional @xmath162 is an approximate @xmath141-martingale , and actually suspect that the result is not true . we expect to observe that some long - range correlations survive for sufficiently singular initial data , which would imply that the limiting measure @xmath153 is no longer deterministic . we describe here the construction of the random potential @xmath125 . the refraction index @xmath39 in non - dimensional variables is a random function of the form @xmath163 where the non - dimensional parameter @xmath44 measures the strength of fluctuations . the mathematical analysis of the wigner distribution in random media can be obtained by the method of diagrammatic expansions of the solution of the schrdinger equation as in @xcite . however , here we assume that the random field @xmath125 is a markov process in @xmath1 , as in @xcite , and we are able to analyze the wigner transform @xmath87 directly . the markovian hypothesis is crucial to simplify the mathematical analysis because it allows us to treat the process @xmath164 as jointly markov . in addition , @xmath125 is assumed to be stationary in @xmath14 and @xmath1 , mean zero , and is constructed in the fourier space as follows . let @xmath165 be the set of measures of bounded total variation with support inside a ball @xmath166 @xmath167 and let @xmath168 be a mean - zero markov process on @xmath169 with generator @xmath170 . the random potential @xmath125 is given by @xmath171 and is real and uniformly bounded : @xmath172 we assume that the process @xmath125 is stationary in @xmath1 and @xmath14 with correlation function @xmath173 @xmath174 in terms of the process @xmath175 this means that given any two bounded continuous functions @xmath176 and @xmath177 we have @xmath178 here @xmath179 is the usual duality product on @xmath180 , and the power spectrum @xmath181 is the fourier transform of @xmath173 in @xmath14 : @xmath182 we assume that @xmath183 for simplicity and define @xmath109 as @xmath184 which is the space - time fourier transform of @xmath185 . we assume that the generator @xmath170 is a bounded operator on @xmath186 with a unique invariant measure @xmath187 @xmath188 and that there exists @xmath189 such that if @xmath190 then @xmath191 the simplest example of a generator with gap in the spectrum and invariant measure @xmath192 is a jump process on @xmath165 where @xmath193 given ( [ eq : expdecaynew ] ) , the fredholm alternative holds for the poisson equation @xmath194 provided that @xmath195 satisfies @xmath196 . it has a unique solution @xmath35 with @xmath197 and @xmath198 . the solution @xmath35 is given explicitly by @xmath199 and the integral converges absolutely because of ( [ eq : expdecaynew ] ) . the particular markovian model adopted in this paper is somewhat restrictive . however , the only information about the process that enters into the main result , the transport equation for the wigner distribution in the limit @xmath102 , is the two - point correlation function of @xmath41 . therefore , we expect that self - averaging of the wigner transform and convergence to the solution of the transport equation hold for much more general classes of random perturbations of the refraction index . * proof . * it is shown in @xcite that equation ( [ eq : weps ] ) preserves the @xmath0-norm of @xmath87 : @xmath203 . the initial conditions for @xmath87 are given by @xmath204 so that @xmath205 and ( [ weps - bd ] ) follows . the above calculation also shows that the initial wigner distribution @xmath206 converges to @xmath207 notice however that one can not expect strong convergence in @xmath0 of @xmath139 to @xmath208 , the solution of the transport equation ( [ eq : treqformal ] ) , because the latter has an @xmath0-norm that decreases as @xmath1 increases while the @xmath0-norm of @xmath87 is preserved . to obtain the approximate martingale property ( [ eq : approxmart ] ) , one has to consider the conditional expectation of functionals @xmath215 with respect to the probability measure @xmath216 on the space @xmath142;{\cal v}\times x)$ ] generated by @xmath217 and the cauchy problem ( [ eq : weps ] ) . the only functions we need to consider are actually of the form @xmath218 with @xmath219;{\cal s}({\mathbb r}^{2d})))$ ] . given a function @xmath215 let us define the conditional expectation @xmath220 the weak form of the infinitesimal generator of the markov process generated by @xmath216 is given by @xmath221\right)\lambda\right\rangle,\ ] ] hence @xmath222\right)\lambda\right\rangle(s)ds\ ] ] is a @xmath216-martingale . the operator @xmath223 is defined by @xmath224\psi({\mathbf x},{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}},{\mathbf k},\hat v)= \frac 1i\int_{\rm^d } \frac{d\hat v({\mathbf p})}{(2\pi)^d } e^{i{\mathbf p}\cdot { { \boldsymbol{\eta } } } } \left[\psi({\mathbf x},{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}},{\mathbf k}-\frac { \mathbf p}2)-\psi({\mathbf x},{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}},{\mathbf k}+\frac { \mathbf p}2)\right].\ ] ] the generator ( [ generator ] ) comes from equation ( [ eq : weps ] ) written in the form @xmath225 w_{\varepsilon}.\ ] ] given a test function @xmath226;{\cal s})$ ] we construct a function @xmath227 with @xmath228 bounded in @xmath229 uniformly in @xmath230 $ ] . the functions @xmath231 will be chosen so that @xmath232 for all @xmath230 $ ] . here @xmath233 is defined by ( [ g - eps ] ) with @xmath127 replaced by @xmath234 , and @xmath235 is defined by ( [ g - lambda ] ) . the approximate martingale property ( [ eq : approxmart ] ) follows from this . the functions @xmath236 and @xmath237 are as follows . let @xmath238 be the mean - zero solution of the poisson equation @xmath239 it is given explicitly by @xmath240.\ ] ] then we let @xmath241 . furthermore , the second order corrector is given by @xmath242 where @xmath243 is the mean - zero solution of @xmath244 which exists because @xmath245 , and is given by @xmath246(z,{\mathbf x},{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}+r{\mathbf k},{\mathbf k},\hat v)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] using ( [ lambda1eq ] ) and ( [ lambda2eq ] ) we have @xmath247 + \frac 1{\varepsilon}q\right ) \left(\lambda+\sqrt{{\varepsilon}}\lambda_1^{\varepsilon}+{\varepsilon}\lambda_2^{\varepsilon}\right)\right\rangle \\ & & = \left\langle w , \left({\dfrac{\partial{}}{\partial{z}}}+{\mathbf k}\cdot\nabla_{\mathbf x}\right ) \lambda+{\cal l}\lambda\right\rangle + \left\langle w , \left({\dfrac{\partial{}}{\partial{z}}}+{\mathbf k}\cdot\nabla_{\mathbf x}\right)\left(\sqrt{{\varepsilon}}\lambda_1^{\varepsilon}+ { \varepsilon}\lambda_2^{\varepsilon}\right ) + \sqrt{{\varepsilon}}{\cal k}[\hat v,\frac { \mathbf x}{\varepsilon}]\lambda_2^{\varepsilon}\right\rangle\\ & & = \left\langle w,\left({\dfrac{\partial{}}{\partial{z}}}+{\mathbf k}\cdot\nabla_{\mathbf x}\right)\lambda+{\cal l}\lambda\right\rangle+\sqrt{{\varepsilon}}\langle w,\zeta_{\varepsilon}^\lambda\rangle\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath248\lambda_2^{\varepsilon}.\ ] ] the terms @xmath249 above are understood as differentiation with respect to the slow variable @xmath14 only , and not with respect to @xmath250 . it follows that @xmath233 is given by @xmath251 and is a martingale with respect to the measure @xmath216 defined on @xmath252;x\times{\cal v})$ ] , the space of right - continuous paths with left - side limits @xcite . the estimate ( [ eq : approxmart ] ) follows from the following two lemmas . [ lemma1new ] let @xmath253;{\cal s}({\mathbb r}^{2d}))$ ] . then there exists a constant @xmath254 independent of @xmath230 $ ] so that the correctors @xmath255 and @xmath256 satisfy the uniform bounds @xmath257 and @xmath258 indeed , ( [ eq : lambda1bdnew ] ) implies that @xmath263 for all @xmath264 and @xmath261 , while ( [ eq : lambda2bdnew ] ) and lemma [ lemma3 ] imply that for all @xmath230 $ ] @xmath265 for all @xmath261 so that ( [ eq : approxmart ] ) follows . * proof of lemma [ lemma1new ] . * we only prove ( [ eq : lambda1bdnew ] ) . since @xmath266 , there exists a constant @xmath259 so that @xmath267 then we obtain using ( [ defcalv ] ) and ( [ eq : expdecaynew ] ) @xmath268\right| \\ & & \le { c}\int_0^\infty dr e^{-\alpha r}\sup_{\hat v } \int_{\rm^d } |d\hat v({\mathbf p})| \left[|\lambda(z,{\mathbf x},{\mathbf k}-\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2})|+ we show next that @xmath237 is uniformly bounded . we have @xmath270\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the second term above may be written as @xmath271\\ & & = -\int_{\rm^d } \frac{d\hat v({\mathbf p})}{(2\pi)^{d}}e^{i{\mathbf p}\cdot({\mathbf x}/{\varepsilon}+r{\mathbf k } ) } \int_0^\infty ds e^{sq}\int_{\rm^d } \frac{d\hat v({\mathbf q})}{(2\pi)^d } e^{is({\mathbf k}-{\mathbf p}/2)\cdot { \mathbf q}+i({\mathbf x}/{\varepsilon}+r{\mathbf k})\cdot { \mathbf q}}\\ & & \times \left[\lambda({\mathbf x},{\mathbf k}-\frac { \mathbf p}2-\frac { \mathbf q}2)- \lambda({\mathbf x},{\mathbf k}-\frac { \mathbf p}2+\frac { \mathbf q}2)\right ] \\ & & + \int_{\rm^d } \frac{d\hat v({\mathbf p})}{(2\pi)^d } e^{i{\mathbf p}\cdot({\mathbf x}/{\varepsilon}+r{\mathbf k } ) } \int_0^\infty ds e^{sq}\int_{\rm^d } \frac{d\hat v({\mathbf q})}{(2\pi)^d } e^{is({\mathbf k}+{\mathbf p}/2)\cdot { \mathbf q}+i({\mathbf x}/{\varepsilon}+r{\mathbf k})\cdot { \mathbf q}}\\ & & \times\left [ \lambda({\mathbf x},{\mathbf k}+\frac { \mathbf p}2-\frac { \mathbf q}2)- \lambda({\mathbf x},{\mathbf k}+\frac { \mathbf p}2+\frac { \mathbf q}2)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore we obtain @xmath272\\ & & \le c\left[|{\cal l}\lambda({\mathbf x},{\mathbf k})|+ \frac{1}{(1+|{\mathbf x}|^{5d})(1+(|{\mathbf k}|-l)^{5d}\chi_{|{\mathbf k}|\ge 5l}({\mathbf k}))}\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the @xmath0-bound on @xmath237 in ( [ eq : lambda1bdnew ] ) follows because the operator @xmath273 is bounded . the proof of ( [ eq : lambda2bdnew ] ) is very similar and is omitted . lemma [ lemma1new ] and lemma [ lemma3 ] together with ( [ geps2 ] ) imply the bound ( [ glambda - glambdaeps ] ) . the tightness of measures @xmath141 given by lemma [ lemma - tight ] implies then that the expectation @xmath274 converges weakly in @xmath140 to the solution @xmath275 of the transport equation for each @xmath230 $ ] . we now prove that for any test function @xmath127 the second moment @xmath276 converges to @xmath277 . this will imply the convergence in probability claimed in theorem [ thm2 ] . the proof is similar to that for @xmath278 and is based on constructing an appropriate approximate martingale for the functional @xmath279 , where @xmath280 is a test function , and @xmath281 . we need to consider the action of the infinitesimal generator on functions of @xmath282 and @xmath283 of the form @xmath284 where @xmath285 is a given function . the infinitesimal generator acts on such functions as @xmath286 where @xmath287\mu+ { \mathbf k}^j\cdot\nabla_{{\mathbf x}^j}\mu,\ ] ] with @xmath288\mu=\frac 1i \int_{\rm^d } d\hat v({\mathbf p})e^{i({\mathbf p}\cdot { { \boldsymbol{\eta}}}_1 ) } \left[\mu({\mathbf k}_1-\frac { \mathbf p}2,{\mathbf k}_2)-\mu({\mathbf k}_1+\frac { \mathbf p}2,{\mathbf k}_2)\right]\ ] ] and @xmath289\mu=\frac 1i \int_{\rm^d } d\hat v({\mathbf p})e^{i({\mathbf p}\cdot { { \boldsymbol{\eta}}}_2 ) } \left[\mu({\mathbf k}_1,{\mathbf k}_2-\frac { \mathbf p}2)-\mu({\mathbf k}_1,{\mathbf k}_2+\frac { \mathbf p}2)\right].\ ] ] therefore the functional @xmath290 + { \cal k}_2[\hat v,\dfrac{{\mathbf x}_2}{{\varepsilon } } ] ) \big ) \mu\right\rangle(s)ds \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] is a @xmath291 martingale . we let @xmath292 be a test function independent of @xmath283 , where @xmath293 , and @xmath294 . we define an approximation @xmath295 we will use the notation @xmath296 and @xmath297 . the functions @xmath298 and @xmath299 are to be determined . we now use ( [ generator2 ] ) to get @xmath300\mu \right\rangle \nonumber\\ & & + \left\langle w\otimes w , \left(q+{\displaystyle\sum}_{j=1}^2 { \mathbf k}^j\cdot\nabla_{{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}^j } \right ) \mu_2 + { \displaystyle\sum}_{j=1}^2 { \cal k}_j\left[\hat v,{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}^j\right ] \mu_1 + { \dfrac{\partial{\mu}}{\partial{z}}}+ { \displaystyle\sum}_{j=1}^2{\mathbf k}^j\cdot\nabla_{{\mathbf x}^j } \mu \right\rangle \nonumber\\ & & + \sqrt{\varepsilon}\left\langle w\otimes w , { \displaystyle\sum}_{j=1}^2 { \cal k}_j\left[\hat v,{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}^j\right ] \mu_2 + \left({\dfrac{\partial{}}{\partial{z}}}+{\displaystyle\sum}_{j=1}^2{\mathbf k}^j\cdot\nabla_{{\mathbf x}^j}\right ) ( \mu_1+\sqrt{\varepsilon}\mu_2)\right\rangle\nonumber . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the above expression is evaluated at @xmath301 . the term of order @xmath73 in @xmath302 vanishes since @xmath285 is independent of @xmath41 and the fast variable @xmath303 . we cancel the term of order @xmath304 in the same way as before by defining @xmath298 as the unique mean - zero ( in the variables @xmath283 and @xmath305 ) solution of @xmath306\mu=0.\ ] ] it is given explicitly by @xmath307\\ & & ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~+ \frac 1i\int_0^\infty dr e^{rq}\int_{\rm^d } d\hat v({\mathbf p } ) e^{ir({\mathbf k}_2\cdot { \mathbf p})+i({{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}_2\cdot { \mathbf p})}\left[\mu({\mathbf k}_1,{\mathbf k}_2-\frac { \mathbf p}2)- \mu({\mathbf k}_1,{\mathbf k}_2+\frac { \mathbf p}2)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath285 has the form @xmath308 , then @xmath298 has the form @xmath309 with the corrector @xmath269 given by ( [ lambda1-eq ] ) . let us also define @xmath299 as the mean zero with respect to @xmath310 solution of @xmath311 \mu_1 = \overline{{\displaystyle\sum}_{j=1}^2 { \cal k}_j\big[\hat v,{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}^j\big ] \mu_1},\ ] ] where @xmath312 . the function @xmath299 is given by @xmath313 \mu_1({\mathbf x},{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}+r{\mathbf k},{\mathbf k})}\\ & & ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-[{\cal k}_1[\hat v,{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}_1+r{\mathbf k}_1 ] \mu_1]({\mathbf x},{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}+r{\mathbf k},{\mathbf k},\hat v)\big]\nonumber\\ & & ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~- \int_0^\infty dr e^{rq } \big[\overline{{\cal k}_2[\hat v,{\mathbf k}_2+r{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}_2 ] \mu_1({\mathbf x},{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}+r{\mathbf k},{\mathbf k } ) } \nonumber \\ & & ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ -[{\cal k}_2[\hat v,{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}_2+r{\mathbf k}_2]\mu_1 ] ( { \mathbf x},{{\boldsymbol{\eta}}}+r{\mathbf k},{\mathbf k},\hat v ) \big].\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] unlike the first corrector @xmath298 , the second corrector @xmath299 may not be written as an explicit sum of tensor products even if @xmath285 has the form @xmath308 because @xmath298 depends on @xmath283 . the @xmath291-martingale @xmath314 is given by @xmath315 where @xmath316 is given by @xmath317\mu_2^{\varepsilon}+ \left({\dfrac{\partial{}}{\partial{z}}}+{\displaystyle\sum}_{j=1}^2{\mathbf k}^j\cdot\nabla_{{\mathbf x}^j}\right ) ( \mu_1^{\varepsilon}+\sqrt{\varepsilon}\mu_2^{\varepsilon})\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the operator @xmath318 is defined by @xmath319 \\ + \big[e^{i{\mathbf p}\cdot\frac{{\mathbf x}_2-{\mathbf x}_1}{{\varepsilon}}+ir{\mathbf k}_2\cdot { \mathbf p } } ( \mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1+\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2},{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2-\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2})- \mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1+\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2},{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2+\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2}))\\ -e^{i{\mathbf p}\cdot \frac{{\mathbf x}_2-{\mathbf x}_1}{{\varepsilon}}+ir{\mathbf k}_2\cdot { \mathbf p } } ( \mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1-\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2},{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2-\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2})- \mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1-\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2},{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2+\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2}))\big]\\ + \big[e^{ir{\mathbf k}_1\cdot { \mathbf p}+ i\frac{{\mathbf x}_1-{\mathbf x}_2}{{\varepsilon}}\cdot { \mathbf p } } ( \mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1-\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2},{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2+\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2})- \mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1-\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2},{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2-\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2}))\\ -e^{ir{\mathbf k}_1\cdot { \mathbf p}+ i\frac{{\mathbf x}_1-{\mathbf x}_2}{{\varepsilon}}\cdot { \mathbf p } } ( \mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1+\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2},{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2+\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2})- \mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1+\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2},{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2-\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2}))\big ] \\ + \big[e^{ir({\mathbf k}_2+\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2})\cdot { \mathbf p } } ( \mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1,{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2)-\mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1,{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2+{\mathbf p}))\\ -e^{ir({\mathbf k}_2-\frac{{\mathbf p}}{2})\cdot { \mathbf p } } ( \mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1,{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2-{\mathbf p})-\mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1,{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2))\big ] . \end{array}\ ] ] we have used in the calculation of @xmath318 that for a sufficiently regular function @xmath35 , we have @xmath320 = { \displaystyle\int}_0^\infty dr { \displaystyle\int}_{\rm^d } \tilde r(r,{\mathbf p } ) f(r,{\mathbf p},-{\mathbf p } ) d{\mathbf p}.\ ] ] the bound on @xmath316 is similar to that on @xmath321 obtained previously as the correctors @xmath322 satisfy the same kind of estimates as the correctors @xmath323 : unlike the first moment case , the averaged operator @xmath318 still depends on @xmath200 . we therefore do not have strong convergence of the @xmath291-martingale @xmath314 to its limit yet . however , the a priori bound on @xmath87 in @xmath0 allows us to characterize the limit of @xmath314 and show strong convergence . this is shown as follows . the first and last terms in ( [ eq : l-2eps ] ) that are independent of @xmath200 give the contribution : @xmath329\\ & & = { \displaystyle\int}_{\rm^d } \dfrac{d{\mathbf p}}{(2\pi)^{d } } \hat r(\frac{p^2-k_1 ^ 2}{2},{\mathbf p}-{\mathbf k}_1 ) ( \mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf p},{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2)-\mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1,{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2))\\ & & + \hat r(\dfrac{p^2-k_2 ^ 2}{2},{\mathbf p}-{\mathbf k}_2 ) ( \mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1,{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf p})-\mu(z,{\mathbf x}_1,{\mathbf k}_1,{\mathbf x}_2,{\mathbf k}_2 ) ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the two remaining terms give a contribution that tends to @xmath330 as @xmath91 for sufficiently smooth test functions . they are given by @xmath331 we have @xmath332 by bochner s theorem . since @xmath333 and @xmath127 are real quantities , we can take the real part of the above term and , after the change of variables @xmath334 and @xmath335 , obtain @xmath336 we have ( since @xmath285 is real - valued ) @xmath337 using density arguments we may assume that @xmath285 has the form @xmath338 then we have @xmath339 where @xmath340 . we introduce @xmath341 and use the cauchy - schwartz inequality in @xmath342 and @xmath343 : @xmath344 we use again the cauchy - schwartz inequality , now in @xmath345 , to get @xmath346 this proves that @xmath347 as @xmath102 . notice that oscillatory integrals of the form @xmath348 are not small in the bigger space @xmath161 , which is natural in the context of wigner transforms and was used in @xcite . in this bigger space , we can not control @xmath349 and actually suspect that the limit measure @xmath153 may no longer be deterministic . we therefore deduce that @xmath350 is an approximate @xmath216 martingale . the limit of the second moment @xmath351 thus satisfies ( weakly ) the transport equation @xmath352 with initial data @xmath353 . moreover , the operator @xmath354 acting on a tensor product @xmath355 has the form @xmath356={\cal l}\lambda\otimes\lambda+ \lambda\otimes{\cal l}\lambda.\ ] ] this implies that @xmath357 by uniqueness of the solution to the above transport equation with initial conditions given by @xmath358 . this proves that the limiting measure @xmath359 is deterministic and unique ( because characterized by the transport equation ) and that the sequence @xmath360 converges in probability to @xmath361 . w. kuperman , w. hodgkiss , h. song , t. akal , c. ferla and d. jackson , phase conjugation in the ocean : experimental demonstration of an acoustic time reversal mirror , j. acoust . * 103 * , 1998 , 25 - 40 .

we analyze the self - averaging properties of time - reversed solutions of the paraxial wave equation with random coefficients , which we take to be markovian in the direction of propagation . this allows us to construct an approximate martingale for the phase space wigner transform of two wave fields . using a priori @xmath0-bounds available in the time - reversal setting , we prove that the wigner transform in the high frequency limit converges in probability to its deterministic limit , which is the solution of a transport equation .

q-bio0611025

mathematical biology is a fast growing , well recognised area of research . although not clearly defined yet , is consider one of the most exciting modern applications of mathematics . the increasing use of mathematics in biology is inevitable as biology becomes more quantitative . the complexity of the biological sciences makes interdisciplinary approach essential . in particular , mathematical modelling of the dynamics of populations interactions is a very challenging and important task . in building a mathematical description of interacting populations , the main goal is to capture the essential features of a complex trophic web with a mathematically tractable model . the result is , usually , a non - linear dynamical system , which may be expressed as a set of either differential or difference equations . classical examples are the pioneering works of lotka ( 1932 ) and volterra ( 1931 ) . such models may be understood as describing the time evolution of population averages in a closed ecosystem . in this context , one can devise two broad categories of models : _ ad hoc _ models , intended to give a phenomenological mathematical description of the dynamics , and _ ab initio _ models , which try to stablish sets of dynamical rules based on or inspired by the biology of the populations . the majority of classical population models are deterministic . recently , due to the growing availability of affordable computer power , _ individual - based models _ have been becoming popular . instead of describing only population sizes , they treat them as collections of individuals with distinctive characteristics . some of those models have been successfull in tackling important biological problems , such as ageing and the evolution of sex ( penna , 1995 ) and ( oliveira , 1999 ) . the possibility of combining elements of population dynamics and genetics into mathematical models is indeed exciting and promising . individual - based models are , in general , stochastic models , known to have a rich variety of behaviors , and sometimes differing markedly from their deterministic counterparts . classical models for competition between two species usually predict exclusion or divergent evolution of resource exploitation . these predictions are massively corroborated by experience and observation . such results are commonly summarized in gause s competitive exclusion principle : to coexist , species must differ in their resource use ; otherwise one of them ends up extinct ( gause , 1935 ) . however , recent experimental data show that coexistence is possible for very similar species competing for the same resources _ without _ niche partition ( louzada , 1996 ) . motivated by this experimental challenge to classical competition theory , we propose an individual - based stochastic competition model , which is essentially a modification of a deterministic lotka - volterra type model . we introduce , as the individual characteristic , a rudimentary `` genotype '' , which determines the individual s adaptation to the environment , as well as its interaction with the other species . in section ii we describe the model and its implementation . in section iii we present the results of computer simulations of the model proposed in section ii , and discuss their implications to coexistence in real ecosystems . we present our final remark and summarize the conclusions in section iv . the continuous - time , deterministic lotka - volterra model for competition between two species is given by the equations @xmath0 where @xmath1 , @xmath2 are the populations sizes at time @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath2 are the intrinsic growth rates ; @xmath5 , @xmath6 , are the competition strengths . it is well known that equations [ classical_lv ] have critical points @xmath7 and that @xmath8 corresponds to exclusion of one species , while @xmath9 corresponds to coexistence . when @xmath10 the coexistence critical point is globally stable , whereas for @xmath11 the exclusion points are the globally stable ones , and coexistence becomes a saddle point . put in biological terms , whenever intra - specific competition is stronger than inter - specific competition there can be coexistence ; otherwise one species always exclude the other . we are interested in building a `` microscopic '' model for competition which is able to mimic the most common biological observations , namely competitive exclusion and coexistence by character displacement . the model should also be able , given some specific conditions , to reproduce the less commonly observed coexistence by _ converging _ evolution . we start by converting equations [ classical_lv ] into probabilistic rules for individual reproduction / death as follows ( may , 2001 ) . the intra - specific competition term , @xmath12 is interpreted as a death process , giving a death probability @xmath13 . the probability that each individual of population @xmath14 reproduces succesfully is given by @xmath15 , @xmath16 . this simple set of stochastic rules is more easily related to the discretized version of equations [ classical_lv ] , @xmath17 now time is a discrete variable , labeling generations , and the parameters should be interpreted as being the ones in equations [ classical_lv ] multiplied by the time interval between generations . it is worth mentioning that the discretized version [ discrete_lv ] is identical to the continuous version ( equations [ classical_lv ] ) in the limit of very large populations . thus , it shares with the continuous model the critical points and their stability properties , as can be easily seen by direct iteration of equation [ discrete_lv ] . up to now the `` microscopic '' character of the model , meaning its description using rules for _ individual _ birth / death processess , can be considered merely formal . it differs from equation [ discrete_lv ] only in a well - known demographic stochasticity @xcite , that is relevant just in the limit of small populations . our next step is to make the model really `` microscopic '' , by endowing each individual with a property ( which we call a genotype ) , that will modify competition and intrinsic growth . the phenotype will then be a measure of how close an individual s genotype is to the optimal genotype for a particular environment . the individual s genotype is also compared to the genotypes of individuals of the competing species . the closer they are , the stronger the competition is . genotypes @xmath18 $ ] are 32-bit strings , associated with individual @xmath19 in population @xmath20 . from each @xmath18 $ ] two phenotypic traits are derived : its normalized hamming distance to the environmentally determined optimal genotype @xmath21 , @xmath22=\frac{\langle g_i[l],g_{opt}\rangle}{32}\ , , \ ] ] and its average normalized hamming distance to the individuals of the opposing population , @xmath23 = \frac{1}{n_j}\sum_{m=1}^{n_j}\frac{\langle g_i[l],g_j[m]\rangle}{32},\,\ , j\neq i.\ ] ] in order to simulate a harsh environment , we impose severe penalties to individuals that depart from @xmath21 : their intrinsic reproduction probability is assumed to decrease exponentially with @xmath24 $ ] as @xmath25)\ , , \ ] ] where @xmath26 is a parameter regulating the environment `` harshness '' . the competition will be modified according to @xmath27n_j),\,\ , j\neq i\ , .\ ] ] which is a much milder dependence on the phenotype than that imposed by the environment . in order to allow the species to `` evolve '' , at every birth event the newborn inherits a copy of its mother s genotype with a possible `` mutation '' , represented by a flip of a random bit . the possibility of mutation introduces `` real '' ( as opposed to the formal demographic ) stochasticity into the model , and should alter its dynamical behaviour . to investigate the dynamics we simulate the model in a computer our interest is to study the emergence of coexistence other than the `` trivial '' coexistence of the classical lotka - volterra model of equations [ classical_lv ] . thus we start with a situation where intra - specific competition is weaker than inter - specific competition . we also assume , for the time being , symmetric competition ( @xmath28 ) , and identical initial intrinsic reproduction rates ( @xmath29 ) . the genotypes of both populations are randomly distributed with uniform probability over the space of 32-bit sequences . no special meaning is attributed to any particular sequence other than the optimal genotype @xmath21 . for the situation just described , the only critical points of the cassical model are @xmath30 . simulations of the proposed model show evolution towards coexistence , as can be seen in figure [ fig1 ] . there , initial populations are the same , @xmath31 , but the asymptotic steady state is not symmetric . due to random fluctuations , one of the species is forced to move away from @xmath21 , as can be seen in the inset , while the other approaches it as much as possible . this makes the average distance between the two populations genotypes very large , which minimizes the effects of competition . we may interpret this result as the system spontaneously attainning some kind of niche partition . , @xmath32 , @xmath33 . the black and red curves are populations 1 and 2 , respectively , with @xmath31 . b ) average distance between populations genotypes and @xmath21 , @xmath34 , showing evolution towards niche partition . c ) first and final distribution of genotypes showing divergent evolution . ( the simulation was run for a much longer time than shown to guarantee that the asymptotic regime had been reached ) . ] for @xmath35 one of the species is excluded . this means that the coexistence state ( or states ) , contrary to the situation in the classical lotka - volterra model , has limited basins of attraction , and it is interesting to estimate the sizes of those basins . starting with @xmath36 , for example , the system reaches a steady state with average populations different from the case of figure [ fig1 ] . this is an indication of existence of mutliple coexistence critical points in this model . nevertheless , all these coexistence states correspond to niche partition . in figure [ basin ] we plotted the initial points from which a coexistence state is reached for fixed values of the parameters . as can be seen , the basin of attraction of the stability region is rather limited , in contrast with the classical lotka - volterra coexistence point being globally stable . the simulations also showed cases of coexistence with converging evolution to a single phenotype , corresponding to a distance between individual s genotypes and @xmath21 , that allows for near - maximum variability inside populations . in these cases , exemplified by the results of figure [ coex_conv ] , asymptotic inter - specific competition is weaker than the asymptotic intra - specific competition . once again , evolution leads to a situation compatible with the classical lotka - volterra dynamics . . c ) first and final distribution of genotypes showing convergent evolution . ( the simulation was run for a much longer time than shown to guarantee that the asymptotic regime had been reached ) . ] another interesting case of coexistence has very similar steady - state population sizes and also similar values of @xmath37 , as seen in figure [ coex_aleat ] . however , the average genotypic distance between populations may be high . this is indeed what happens in this particular case , as can be seen in fig . [ coex_aleat]b . once again , the system found its way through evolving towards minimal competition , and coexistence is thus possible . , are both large . this is compatible with large initial variability inside each population , what allows for a large average distance between populations genotypes ( blue curve ) . ] the results provided by the proposed model show coexistence attained through minimization of competition . this is compatible with the expectations based on classical population models . however , the observations that motivated this work are not exactly contemplated by our results . the two species of dichotomius studied by louzada _ et al . _ show identical patterns of utilization of and preference for resources . besides , they show identical abundance in all experiments performed to date . hence , resource sharing can not explain the coexistence of the two species . the fact that the two species exploit identically the temporal , spatial and feeding axes of their niche support the need for a more elaborate explanation of coexistence in scharabaeidae communities . it may be thought that the mechanism through which these communities minimize competition is related to a sudden change of competitive behaviour : there seems to be a similarity threshold beyond which individuals of different species start to identify each other as pertaining to the same species , and their competition turns from the inter - specific to the intra - specific type . this mechanism is completely absent from the model proposed in this work . we are investigating possible modifications of the proposed model to take this kind of mechanism into account . we presented an individual - based model for the dynamics of two coevolving competing species . it is an extension of the lotka - volterra equations for competition to include coevolution . the dynamical behaviour of the proposed model shows important differences from the classical lotka - volterra competition , such as multiple coexistence critical points with limited attraction basins . the coevolution dynamics mimics important biological behaviours such as niche partition and converging evolution . modifications of the present model to reproduce other kinds of experimentally observed behaviour are underway . we gratefully acknowledge j. s. s. bueno filho for many enlightening discussions , important suggestions and a critical reading of the manuscript . acknowledges financial support from cnpq . i.c.c . and j.n.c.l . acknowledges financial support from fapemig . de oliveira , s. m. , de oliveira , p. m. c. , stauffer , d. , _ evolution , money , war and computers : non - traditional applications of computacional statistical physics _ , teubner - text zur physik , bd 34 , teubner , 1999 . louzada , j. n. c. , schiffler , g. and vaz de mello , f. z. , _ efeitos do fogo sobre a composio e estrutura da comunidade de scarabaeidae ( insecta , coleoptera ) , na restinga da ilha de guriri , norte do esprito santo_. in miranda , h. s. , saito , c. h. and souza dias , b. f. ( eds . ) , _ impactos de queimadas em reas de cerrado e restinga _ , braslia , unb , ecl , 161 - 169 , 1996 .

classical models for competition between two species usually predict exclusion or divergent evolution of resource exploitation . however , recent experimental data show that coexistence is possible for very similar species competing for the same resources _ without _ niche partition . motivated by this experimental challenge to classical competition theory , we propose an individual - based stochastic competition model , which is essentially a modification of a deterministic lotka - volterra type model . the proposed model of competition dynamics incorporates the effects of a discrete genotype , which determines the individual s adaptation to the environment , as well as its interaction with the other species . + _ keywords : _ population dynamics ; lotka - volterra model : competition ; individual - based model .

1112.2918

the atmospheric helium abundances of sdbs are poorly understood . from the typical abundance patterns of these stars , which show a depletion of light elements as well as an enrichment of heavy metals , it has been concluded that diffusion play an important role in their atmospheres . however , diffusion models predict an almost total depletion of helium in contrast to what is observed . the helium abundances of sdbs range from slightly above solar down to @xmath3 . mass loss caused by stellar winds as well as extra mixing in the atmosphere have been invoked to counteract gravitational settling and explain the observed helium abundances ( see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . @xcite found a correlation of helium abundance with temperature . the hotter the sdb , the more helium is present in its atmosphere . similar correlations have been found by other groups ( see e.g. vennes et al . these proceedings ) . however , @xcite also reported the discovery of two distinct sequences showing a similar correlation with temperature , the lower sequence being offset by about @xmath4 from the upper sequence . the majority of stars lie on the upper sequence . those sequences could not be clearly identified in other datasets so far ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? @xcite combined the then published data sets and found the stars of the upper sequence to lie near the extreme horizontal branch ( ehb ) band in the @xmath5-plane , as expected , whereas the lower - sequence stars lie in a much more dispersed area ( see figs . 2,3 in * ? ? ? gravitational settling can also lead to isotopic anomalies in stellar atmospheres . in the case of helium the light isotope @xmath0he can be enriched with respect to the usually much more abundant @xmath6he . such an enrichment has initially been found in main sequence b stars with subsolar helium abundance @xcite . however , @xcite detected strong line shifts in the sdb star sb290 and the blue horizontal branch star phl25 indicating that basically the whole helium content of the atmosphere consists of @xmath0he . later on @xcite and @xcite found another three sdbs , where @xmath0he is enriched in the atmosphere . here we present the results of a quantitative spectral analysis of a sample of 46 sdb stars from high resolution spectra . plotted against effective temperature . the filled symbols mark the results from our study . filled red diamonds mark objects where isotopic shifts due to an enrichment of @xmath0he were detected , filled circles objects with atmospheres dominated by @xmath6he . upper limits are marked with triangles . the solid horizontal line is drawn at solar helium abundance . the two dotted lines are regression lines for the two distinct helium sequences taken from @xcite . results taken from the literature are plotted as grey symbols @xcite.,width=377 ] 46 bright subdwarf b stars were observed with the feros spectrograph ( @xmath7 , @xmath8 ) mounted at the eso / mpg 2.2 m telescope in la silla . five stars were observed with the foces spectrograph ( @xmath9 , @xmath10 ) mounted at the caha 2.2 m telescope . the data were reduced with the midas package . medium resolution spectra of 13 stars were obtained with the isis spectrograph ( @xmath11 ) mounted at the wht . 13 sdbs discovered in the course of the edinburgh - cape blue object survey @xcite have been observed with the grating spectrograph and intensified reticon photon counting system on the 1.9 m telescope of the saao ( @xmath12 ) . spectra of five sdbs have been taken with the cafos spectrograph mounted at the caha 2.2 m telescope ( @xmath13 ) . atmospheric parameters and helium abundances have been determined by fitting model spectra to the hydrogen balmer and helium lines @xcite of the high - resolution spectra using the spas routine developed by h. hirsch . the parameter determination from the high - resolution spectra needs to be checked and systematic effects have to be quantified properly . in order to do this we analysed medium - resolution spectra in the same way as the high - resolution data and derived systematic uncertainties by comparing the results . he ( solid ) and @xmath0he lines ( dotted ) are plotted as vertical lines.,title="fig:",width=377 ] he ( solid ) and @xmath0he lines ( dotted ) are plotted as vertical lines.,title="fig:",width=377 ] [ fig : abun ] shows the helium abundances of our sample plotted against the effective temperature . all but two of our programme stars have subsolar helium abundances typical for sdb stars . the correlation of helium abundance with temperature discovered by @xcite can be clearly seen as well as the two distinct sequences showing a similar correlation with temperature . combining these data with the results of other studies the underlying pattern becomes apparent . in fig . 1 our results are overplotted with the two regression lines calculated by @xcite and based on their results . the two lines match very well with the sequences seen in our sample . we define a dividing line between the two helium sequences at @xmath14 accordingly , 36 stars ( @xmath15 ) are associated with the upper sequence while 15 ( @xmath16 ) belong to the lower one . the respective fractions of the full sample of 349 sdbs are @xmath17 and @xmath18 . -diagram for the entire sample under study . the helium main sequence ( hems ) and the ehb band ( limited by the zero - age ehb , zaehb , and the terminal - age ehb , taehb ) are superimposed with ehb evolutionary tracks for solar metallicity taken from @xcite labelled with their masses . red open symbols mark objects where isotopic shifts due to an enrichment of @xmath0he were detected , filled symbols objects with atmospheres dominated by @xmath6he . the diamonds mark stars belonging to the upper helium sequence , the circles stars belonging to the lower sequence . the triangles mark the three sdbs with enriched @xmath0he from the literature.,width=377 ] searches for the @xmath0he isotope in stellar atmospheres have so far been restricted to a few stars only . the high resolution spectra are perfectly suited to search for small shifts in the rest wavelengths of the helium lines due to the enrichment of @xmath0he . those shifts can be modelled quite accurately and show a typical pattern . while some lines like hei5876 are only shifted by @xmath19 towards redder wavelengths , the shifts of hei4922 and hei6678 are significant ( @xmath20 and @xmath21 respectively , * ? ? ? displacements of this order can be easily detected in the high resolution spectra . the spy sample @xcite has not been studied , because the uves spectra did not cover the sensitive hei6678 line . all stars of our sample have been examined . in 8 cases isotopic shifts due to the presence of @xmath0he are clearly visible ( see fig . [ fig : isotop ] ) . hence @xmath22 of our programme stars show the @xmath0he anomaly . as can be seen in fig . [ fig : abun ] seven belong to the upper helium sequence , while only one star belongs to the lower sequence . this may be a selection effect , because sdbs with low helium abundance show only weak lines , which are less suited to detect isotopic shifts . the distribution of these stars in the @xmath23-@xmath24-diagram is shown in fig . [ fig : tefflogg ] including the three sdbs with isotopic shifts taken from literature . it can be clearly seen that they cluster in a narrow temperature range between @xmath1 and @xmath2 with bd+482721 ( @xmath25 ) being the only exception . given the uncertainties , this @xmath0he - strip may be pure . most stars show clear shifts of the hei line at @xmath26 indicating that almost all helium in the atmosphere is @xmath0he . bd+482721 , ec12234@xmath272607 and pg1519 + 640 show strong lines of @xmath0he blended with weak components of @xmath6he . these three stars cover the whole @xmath0he temperature strip . the isotope ratio is therefore not correlated to the effective temperature . an @xmath0he isotope anomaly has first been found for chemically peculiar main sequence stars of spectral type b. the @xmath0he - stars were found at effective temperatures between @xmath28 and @xmath29 separating helium - poor stars at lower @xmath23 from helium - rich stars at higher @xmath23 @xcite . in fig . [ fig : tefflogg ] a similar pattern can be seen for the sdbs . the stars enriched in @xmath0he occupy a small strip in @xmath23 , while the helium abundance decreases towards lower temperatures and rises towards higher temperatures . @xcite carried out diffusion calculations and predict a mild enrichment of @xmath0he , but due to gravitational settling of the heavier isotope this should be the case in all sdbs . hence , the @xmath0he strip stars lacks an explanation . @xcite argued that diffusion is responsible for this effect . at low temperatures the radiation pressure is not strong enough to support helium in the atmosphere . as soon as the temperature reaches a certain threshold value , the less massive @xmath0he can be supported , but not the more abundant @xmath6he . this leads to an enrichment of @xmath0he in the atmosphere . at even higher temperatures both isotopes are enriched and the isotopic anomaly vanishes as the helium abundance rises . dorman , b. , rood , r. t. , & oconnell , r. w. 1993 , apj , 419 , 596 edelmann , h. , heber , u. , hagen , h .- j . 2003 , a&a , 400 , 939 edelmann , h. , heber , u. , & napiwotzki , r. 2001 , an , 322 , 401 fred , m. , tomkins , f. s. , brody , j. k. , & hamermesh , m. 1951 , phys . rev . , 82 , 406 geier , s. , hirsch , h. , tillich , a. , et al . 2011b , a&a , 530 , 28 hartoog , m. r. , & cowley , a. p. 1979 , apj , 228 , 229 heber , u. 1991 , iaus , 145 , 363 heber , u. , & edelmann , h. 2004 , ap&ss , 291 , 341 heber , u. , reid , i. n. , & werner , k. 2000 , a&a , 363 , 198 hu , h. , tout , c. a. , glebbeek , e. , & dupret , m .- a . 2011 , mnras , in press lisker , t. , heber , u. , napiwotzki , r. , christlieb , n. , han , z. , et al . 2005 , a&a , 430 , 223 maxted , p. f. l. , heber , u. , marsh , t. r. , north , r. c. , 2001 , mnras , 326 , 139 michaud , g. , richer , j. , & richard , o. 2011 , a&a , 529 , 60 morales - rueda , l. , maxted , p. f. l. , marsh , t. r. , north , r. c. , & heber , u. 2003 , mnras , 338 , 752 stensen , r. h. , silvotti , r. , charpinet , s. , et al . 2010 , mnras , 409 , 1470 otoole , s. j. 2008 , asp conf . ser . , 392 , 67 saffer , r. a. , bergeron , p. , koester , d. , liebert , j. 1994 , apj , 432 , 351 stobie , r. s. , kilkenny , d. , odonoghue , d. , et al . 1997 , mnras , 287 , 848 vennes , s. , kawka , a. , & nmeth , p. 2011 , mnras , 410 , 2095

helium abundances and atmospheric parameters have been determined from high resolution spectra for a new sample of 46 bright hot subdwarf b ( sdb ) stars . the helium abundances have been measured with high accuracy . we confirm the correlation of helium abundance with temperature and the existence of two distinct sequences in helium abundance found previously . we focused on isotopic shifts of helium lines and found @xmath0he to be strongly enriched in 8 of our programme stars . most of these stars cluster in a small temperature range between @xmath1 and @xmath2 very similar to the known @xmath0he - rich main sequence b stars , which cluster at somewhat lower temperatures . this phenomenon is most probably related to diffusion processes in the atmosphere , but poses a challenge to diffusion models .

cond-mat0109039

it is well recognized that the photoemission process involves an interplay between the bulk and surface phenomena as the excited electron must be ejected from the surface in order to reach the detector . the intensity measured in an arpes ( angle - resolved photoemission spectroscopy ) experiment , therefore , fundamentally involves the properties of the relevant initial and final states in the presence of the surface . as a result , the arpes intensity can differ greatly from the spectral density of the initial state involved in the excitation . an understanding of this difference @xmath3 the so - called matrix element effect , is essential for a satisfactory interpretation of the arpes spectra , and this is particularly so in complex materials such as the high - tcs@xcite . bearing these considerations in mind , we have carried out extensive simulations of the arpes spectra in @xmath4 ( bi2212 , bisco ) within the first - principles band theory framework . the pristine phase with the body centered tetragonal lattice structure is assumed ; the computationally more demanding case of the orthorhombic and modulated lattices is hoped to be taken up in the future . we focus on the excitation of states in the vicinity of the fermi energy ( @xmath5 ) around the @xmath1 symmetry point which have been the subject of intense scrutiny and controversy in the high - tc literature . for example , the issue of bilayer splitting@xmath3 expected to be relatively large within the conventional lda - based band theory picture at @xmath6 in bisco , has been debated for some time , even though a consensus in favor of the existence of a bilayer splitting appears to be emerging in the recent months@xcite . the fundamental question has been whether or not strong correlations localize electrons in the @xmath0 layers , yielding a 2d electron gas and a zero bilayer splitting with significant implications for the mechanism of superconductivity in the cuprates.@xcite this study gives insight into these and related aspects of the ground state electronic structure by delineating the connection between the arpes spectra and the character of the underlying initial and final states . for this purpose , we have developed the one - step methodology @xcite for modeling the photoemission process so that arbitrarily complex systems with many basis atoms can be treated @xcite . the previous one - step work has been limited to a maximum of two atoms per unit cell @xcite which is not adequate for the cuprates ; bisco , for example , involves 30 atoms per conventional unit cell even for the pristine lattice . in the one - step approach , the interaction of light with the solid is treated as a single quantum mechanical event and the artifical distinctions between the processes of excitation , transport and ejection of the photoelectron invoked in the earlier three - step models @xcite are not made . the one - step scheme is thus inherently more satisfactory than the three - step model since the surface is incorporated in the latter in an _ ad hoc _ manner . on the other hand , it often tends to be difficult to identify the behavior of individual transitions within the one - step methodology where the initial and final states must be damped , causing these states to broaden and overlap , blurring distinctions between various transitions . for this reason , we have also developed the three - step model for complex lattices@xcite . useful insight is adduced here into different contributions to the arpes spectrum of bisco by examining the momentum matrix element for bulk transitions in the solid in the spirit of the three - step approach . the specifics of some of the main issues addressed in this article and highlights of the new results presented are as follows . the dependencies of the arpes intensity on the energy and polarization of the incident light are clarified for the excitation of states near the @xmath6 point . the response of the antibonding and bonding combinations of states from the @xmath0 bilayers is found to display a strong energy and polarization dependence . moreover , the behavior of the antibonding and bonding states differs significantly so that by a judicious choice of these experimental parameters even closely placed bilayer bands could be distinguished . also , photon energies where the intrinsic cross - section for exciting certain states of the pristine lattice is large will be best suited for studying these states ; in contrast , when this cross - section is relatively small , the effects of deviations from the tetragonal symmetry of the system via various distortions and modulations will become more prominent . further , we show how some systematics of the polarization dependencies can be understood in the cuprates via straightforward arguments involving the symmetries of the initial and final states . turning to questions related to individual transitions , we discuss the nature of the momentum matrix element for bulk excitations within a three - step type model in terms of contributions from various basis atoms and different angular momentum channels . the character of the bonding and antibonding initial states as well as that of the relevant final states at @xmath6 is clarified . an analysis of these results reveals dramatically how different contributions to the momentum matrix element can interfere constructively or destructively to enhance or supress the weights of photoelectrons excited from particular atomic sites and/or specific angular momentum channels . this remarkable result which , to our knowledge , has not been recognized previously in the literature , hints that the arpes matrix element may allow us to zoom in on the properties of very specific transitions even in complex unit cell materials . concerning relevant literature , refs . discuss some of our earlier work on bisco , @xmath7 ( ncco ) , @xmath8 ( ybco ) and @xmath9(y124 ) . in particular , ref . emphasizes the importance of matrix element effects in arpes spectra , while ref . undertakes an extensive comparison between the one - step predictions over a wide region in the momentum space when the initial state energy is held fixed at the @xmath5 with the corresponding experimental arpes results giving the fermi surface map in bisco . there is of course a large body of available work on the photoemission theory and refs . would provide a brief selection . on the experimental side as well the arpes studies of bisco are far too numerous to be cited with any completeness , and we refer only to a few representative papers . an outline of this article as is follows . the introductory remarks are followed in section ii by a consideration of formal matters ; a few equations for the one - step model are presented ( subsection iia ) , and the problem of computing the momentum matrix element in a general lattice is formulated ( subsection iib ) . section iii delineates the relevant features of the lattice geometry ( subsection iiia ) and the band structure of bisco ( subsection iiib ) . the results of sections ii and iii serve as a source of frequent reference in the subsequent discussion . section iv is divided into several subsections to go over various salient features of the arpes spectra from @xmath6 . the aspects addressed concern : photon energy dependence ( subsection iva ) ; effect of final state width ( subsection ivb ) ; polarization dependence ( subsection ivc ) ; and , the final state band structure and momentum matrix element ( subsection ivd ) . section v takes up the question of the nature of the transition matrix element and the origin of specific spectral features in terms of the characters of the initial and final states and is divided into three parts dealing with : contributions of different atomic sites ( subsection va ) ; contributions of various angular momentum channels ( subsection vb ) ; and , comments on the @xmath2 dependence of the spectral intensities ( subsection vc ) . finally , section vi summarizes our results and makes a few concluding remarks . we begin by recalling that the arpes intensity in the one - step model can be expressed as@xcite @xmath10 where the ket @xmath11 denotes a free electron state with momentum , @xmath12 , parallel to the crystal surface , @xmath13 ( @xmath14 ) is the retarded ( + ) or advanced ( - ) one - electron green function for the final ( initial ) state and @xmath15 is the interaction hamiltonian in terms of the vector potential @xmath16 of the incident photon field and the electron momentum operator @xmath17 . for our purposes , we rewrite eq . [ y1 ] by using the representation @xmath18 of the green function @xmath14 as a sum over the spectral functions @xmath19 for various initial states @xmath20 which yields @xmath21 here we have replaced @xmath22 by the final state wavefunction @xmath23 . substituting form for @xmath24 in eq . [ y2 ] , and neglecting the term proportional to @xmath25 by assuming that the vector potential a varies smoothly , i.e. wavelength of light is much larger than the unit cell dimensions@xcite , we obtain @xmath26 notably , the summation over @xmath20 not only encompasses different initial state bands , but also involves an integration over @xmath27 . a computationally practical formula follows by invoking the identity @xmath28 which is valid when the potential term is @xmath17 independent . the matrix element in eq . [ y5 ] is easily recast using eq . [ y6 ] as @xmath29 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the initial and final state energies , respectively . the nature of the photointensity based on the one - step eq . [ y1 ] can be delineated in terms of the momentum matrix element @xmath32 of eq . [ y5 ] . however , the wavefunctions @xmath33 and @xmath23 occuring in eqs . [ y3 ] - [ y7 ] are complicated quantities which include multiple scattering effects in the presence of the surface and damped initial and final state propagators . although the full one - step calculation should always be kept in mind , insight into the results may be obtained by simplifying the situation and replacing @xmath33 and @xmath23 by the corresponding bloch wavefunctions @xmath34 in the _ bulk _ crystal and the resulting matrix element @xmath35 for optical transitions . it should be emphasized that the optical matrix element must in general be supplemented with other information specific to the photoemission experiment ( e.g. symmetry of the final state ) before connection with a particular measurement can be made . this issue will be addressed as needed in the remainder of this article . the formalism for evaluating the optical matrix element for a general lattice within the kkr scheme is given in refs . ; an outline of aspects relevant for the purposes of this article is as follows . the starting point is the kkr wavefunction for a general lattice which can be expressed within the unit cell as @xcite @xmath36 where @xmath37 is a composite angular momentum index and @xmath38 denotes different basis sites . @xmath39 are expansion coefficients and @xmath40 is the radial part of the bloch wavefunction on site @xmath38 in angular momentum channel @xmath41 . @xmath42 are real spherical harmonics . using expressions of eq . [ y8 ] for the initial and final states yields @xmath43 where the primed indices refer to the final state and @xmath44 is a unit vector along the direction @xmath45 . @xmath46 involves an integral over the radial part of the initial and final state wavefunction and their derivatives and is given by @xmath47 \right . \\ \hspace*{1 cm } + \displaystyle { l + 1 \over r } \left [ { p_{l ' } ' } ^\star p_l - p_{l'}^\star p_l ' \right ] \\ \hspace*{1 cm } \left . - { p_{l ' } ' } ^\star p_l ' \right\}_{r = r_\beta } & l ' = l + 1 \\ { \displaystyle \int}_0^{r_\beta } \left ( p_{l'}^\star p_l ' + \displaystyle { l \over r } p_{l'}^\star p_l \right ) dr \\ \hspace*{1cm}+ \displaystyle { 1 \over e_i - e_{f } } \\ \hspace*{1 cm } \times \left\ { p_{l'}^\star p_l \left [ \displaystyle { l^2 \over r^2 } - e_i \right ] \right . \\ \hspace*{1 cm } + \displaystyle { l \over r } \left [ { p_{l ' } ' } ^\star p_l - p_{l'}^\star p_l ' \right ] \\ \hspace*{1 cm } \left . - { p_{l ' } ' } ^\star p_l ' \right\}_{r = r_\beta } & l ' = l - 1 \end{array } ~ , \right . \label{y10}\ ] ] here , @xmath48 , @xmath49 is the radius of the @xmath50 muffin - tin sphere , @xmath30 and @xmath31 have been defined in connection with eq . [ y7 ] above , and @xmath51 @xmath52 are seen to contain angular momentum selection rules for dipole transitions . @xmath53 for @xmath54 values of -1,1 and 0 is proportional to @xmath55 and @xmath56 , respectively . it is convenient to decompose the sum over @xmath38 on the right hand side of eq . [ y9 ] for the @xmath57 component as @xmath58 with @xmath59 the indices @xmath60 and @xmath61 in eqs . [ y12]-[y14 ] are keyed in with the pristine ( tetragonal ) crystal structure of bisco detailed in section iiia below , and taken together , encompass the sum over all atoms @xmath38 in the unit cell in eq . [ y8 ] . after the sum over the angular momentum channels @xmath41 and @xmath62 in eq . [ y14 ] has been carried out , the index @xmath61 which only takes two values ( 1 and 2 ) in eq . [ y13 ] sums over the contributions of pairs of atoms ( other than the @xmath63 atom ) related by mirror symmetry of the lattice with respect to the @xmath63 layer . in this sense , @xmath61 may be thought of as a `` pairing '' index . @xmath60 then takes on eight distinct values which include seven pairs of atoms @xmath64 and the @xmath63 atom as a `` site index '' . the aforementioned indexing is by no means unique and other useful variations can be envisioned in the present case and certainly for other lattice types . since various structural features of the lattice are invoked frequently in the discussion , it is appropriate that we state our nomenclature clearly . for this purpose , two different cross - sections through the conventional body centered tetragonal unit cell , together with the detailed arrangement of atoms in different layers , are shown in fig . 1 . the distinct atom `` pairs '' to go with the index @xmath60 in eqs . [ y12]-[y14 ] are identified in fig . values of @xmath60 from 2 - 8 involve an atom and its mirror partner reflected in the @xmath63 layer , yielding a total of 15 basis atoms per primitive lattice point or 30 atoms in the conventional unit cell . the @xmath63 atom ( @xmath65 ) is seen to lie at the center of symmetry in the upper part of fig . the two @xmath0 planes sit above and below the @xmath63 layer and consist of the two @xmath66 atoms in the basis set denoted by the ( @xmath67 ) indices ( 2,1 ) and ( 2,2 ) . @xmath68 and @xmath69 are given similarly by @xmath70 and 4 , each with @xmath71 ; note that although @xmath68 and @xmath69 are identical in terms of the crystal potential in the tetragonal case , it is still useful to make this distinction because states along @xmath72 and @xmath73 will in general respond differently depending upon the direction of polarization of the incident light . next come the @xmath74 layers with @xmath75 ( @xmath76 ) and the associated apical @xmath77 atoms ( @xmath78 ) , followed by the @xmath79 layers involving the @xmath80 ( @xmath81 ) and @xmath82 ( @xmath83 ) atoms . 2 shows the energy bands in bisco along the symmetry lines @xmath84 . the crystal potential underlying these computations differs somewhat from the selfconsistent lda potential in that the @xmath80-@xmath85 pockets around the m - point have been lifted above the @xmath5 in order to account for their absence in the arpes measurements . the two bands in the vicinity of the @xmath5 are related to the @xmath0 planes ; the splitting between @xmath86 and @xmath87 is the bilayer splitting arising from interaction between the two @xmath0 planes . at the m - point , the wavefunction of the upper band @xmath86 is antibonding or antisymmetric with respect to the @xmath63 plane ( along the @xmath56 direction ) while that of the lower band @xmath87 is bonding or symmetric . the size of the bilayer splitting is generally larger along @xmath88 compared to the @xmath89 direction . we have chosen to work in the present simulations with a potential that yields a rather large bilayer splitting because this makes it easier to identify the signatures of the bonding and antibonding bands @xmath87 and @xmath86 in the theoretical arpes spectra@xcite . however , computations have been repeated for numerous other cases where the bilayer splitting was varied by placing suitable potential barriers between the @xmath0 layers , and the results indicate that our conclusions concerning the nature of these states and their behavior in the arpes spectra are robust to such variations . the analysis of the recent high resolution arpes spectra leaves little doubt that the fermi surface of bisco consists of two distinct sheets@xcite . one is the standard large hole - like sheet centered around the @xmath90 or @xmath91 symmetry point , and a second sheet arising from a band lying very close the the @xmath5 which could be either slightly hole- or electron - like . the precise position of the @xmath5 will depend of course on the doping level of the system . in any event , it is often useful to avoid convoluting the computed spectra with the fermi function so that the nature of the spectra over a wider range of @xmath92 and energy values , including unoccupied states above the @xmath5 , can be elucidated . notably , the @xmath93 dispersion of bands terminating at points @xmath86 and @xmath87 , even though it varies with @xmath92 , is quite small ( order of a few mev at @xmath6 ) and is not important in much of our discussion . 3 shows the arpes intensity from the antibonding and bonding states ( @xmath86 and @xmath87 ) at the @xmath6 point as a function of the photon energy . for our illustrative purposes we have taken the light to be polarized such that only the @xmath72-component of the vector potential @xmath94 is non - zero . the initial state width corresponds to @xmath95 mev @xcite . the final state width is set using @xmath96 ev@xmath3 we return to this point in section ivb below . the emission intensity is seen to change dramatically with photon energy . the bonding state emits strongly around 18 and 23 ev with a feature around 33 ev , while the antibonding state possesses a somewhat broad region of high emissions extending from 14 - 26 ev . the intensity for both states is relatively small from 27 - 40 ev and below 11 ev . these results have significant implications for arpes experiments . for example , emission maps from the @xmath5 can be expected to look quite different at various photon energies ; at an energy such as 22 ev , the emissions from the pristine lattice will be dominant , while at an energy such as 28 ev , the contributions due to modulations of the underlying symmetry ( e.g. orthorhombic distortion , superlattice modulation , etc . ) will generally become more prominent@xcite . energies such as 18 or 23 ev will tend to highlight the bonding state while the antibonding state will likely be more intense around 22 ev , effects of final state broadening and other factors notwithstanding . we should particularly keep in mind that there are inherent uncertainities of a few ev s in locating the final states in the first principles computations , and that the positions of various features in fig . 3 will generally possess similar uncertainty . we have carried out additional computations ( not shown in the interest of brevity ) and find that the aforementioned type of variations in intensity which selectively highlight different aspects of the electronic structure continue to be manifest at photon energies much higher than the 40 ev upper limit in fig . 3 . fig . 4 shows how the plot of fig . 3 for the antibonding initial state changes when the final state width varies corresponding to @xmath97 values from 20 mev to 2 ev@xcite . the results for small @xmath97 make it clear that the spectrum is intrinsically made up of numerous transitions with different weights . with increasing @xmath97 these transitions broaden and overlap to produce varying spectral shapes of fig . 4 . for @xmath98 mev , little change in shape occurs because the spectra are controlled by the initial and not the final state width , the former having a constant value given by @xmath95 mev in all cases . note that to reproduce the observed linewidths , @xmath97 used in the computations will need to account not only for the damping of the final state reflected via the imaginary part of the self - energy , but also the effects of experimental parameters such as the temperature of the measurement and the acceptor angle of the analyzer ( typically of order of a few tenths of a degree in the high resolution arpes setups ) . in this sense , @xmath97 is perhaps better viewed as a computational rather than a physical parameter in the theory with values ranging from 1 - 4 ev , where 4 ev is appropriate for 40 - 60 ev photons @xcite . incidentally , computations become more demanding as the value of @xmath97 decreases because the mean free path of the outgoing electron increases and an exponentially larger number of layers must be included in the calculations to obtain a converged result . insofar as the polarization dependence is concerned , note first that in fig . 5 light is assumed incident normally to the surface and that the detector lies in the @xmath99 plane with the @xmath72-axis defined by the @xmath100 bond direction ; the polarization vector of light is varied holding all other experimental parameters fixed . the inserts in the shape of number eight are polar plots of the intensities of various peaks ( @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath101 and @xmath102 ) as a function of the azimuthal angle @xmath103 between the polarization vector and the @xmath72-axis . the intensity is maximum for all peaks at @xmath104 , i.e. when the light is polarized along the @xmath100 bonds . under a @xmath105 rotation the intensity nearly vanishes as the polarization vector turns perpendicular to the plane of the detector . insight into the polarization dependence discussed in the preceding paragraph can be gained by examining the behavior of eq . [ y5 ] for the geometrical setup of fig . since the detector lies in the @xmath99 plane of mirror symmetry , the final state @xmath23 must obviously possess even symmetry with respect to this plane in order to be observable . on the other hand , @xmath106 or @xmath107 ( or , equivalently , @xmath108 or @xmath109 from eq . [ y7 ] ) is even but @xmath110 is odd under reflections in this mirror plane . it follows then that only the matrix elements @xmath111 and @xmath112 can be non - zero for _ even _ initial states while for _ odd _ initial states only @xmath113 can be non - zero . we now express a in spherical polar coordinates as @xmath114 where @xmath115 is the amplitude , @xmath116 and @xmath103 are the polar and azimuthal angles of the incoming light beam , and @xmath117 are unit vectors along the cartesian axis . for the setup of fig . 5 , @xmath118 , and eq . [ y5 ] reduces to @xmath119 it turns out that the antibonding state @xmath86 as well as the bonding state @xmath87 is even and , therefore , recalling the aforementioned symmetry arguments , only the @xmath106 term contributes and eq . [ y17 ] yields @xmath120 which explains the shape of polar plots of fig . 5 for states @xmath86 and @xmath87 ; states @xmath101 and @xmath102 must also be even in view of the shapes of the related polar plots . the preceding analysis is generalized straightforwardly to consider vector potentials with other non - zero components . if a non - zero @xmath107 component is included , eq . [ y18 ] is modified with a radially symmetric contribution . in this vein , if the mirror symmetry plane is rotated by @xmath121 as is the case in ybco ( neglecting the effect of cu - o chains ) , that leads to polar plots which are rotated similarly.@xcite fig . 5 also shows the energy distribution curve ( edc ) for 22 ev photons when @xmath92 is held fixed at @xmath6 . the edc for the case when the initial state width is taken to be a small constant is given by the thin line for reference in order to reveal the spectral peaks clearly . more realistically , the initial state width increases with increasing binding energy . this effect is modelled by the edc of the thick line which shows that much of the structure for binding energies greater than @xmath122 100 mev is washed out by lifetime effects . 6 compares the one - step arpes intensity at the @xmath6 point for the antibonding state @xmath86 with the corresponding result based on the bulk momentum matrix element of eq . [ y12 ] and helps address a number of related issues . the small final state width used in these simulations allows the intrinsic spectral structure to be seen clearly . the final state bands shown as a function of @xmath2 in the lower portion of the figure provide a map of all available transitions since @xmath2 is not conserved in the photoemission process . [ note that the horizontal scale has been converted to refer to the photon energy . ] it is striking that although these bands appear to form a semi - continuum , there are gaps in the underlying final state spectrum and the situation thus is quite unlike the free electron case@xcite . also , @xmath2 dispersion is not always negligible with some bands dispersing as much as 0.5 ev despite the small size of the bz in the z - direction . as already noted , it tends to be difficult to associate peaks in the one - step spectra with transitions to specific final states . the problem becomes exacerbated when states are broadened to incorporate finite lifetime effects . considerable insight into the behavior of the arpes matrix element can nevertheless be gained via the momentum matrix element @xmath35 of eq . [ y9 ] for bulk transitions . we emphasize however that @xmath35 does not properly account for the processes of transport and ejection of the photoelectron as is the case in the one - step arpes computation . moreover , since @xmath35 involves the bulk wavefuctions @xmath123 and @xmath124 , modifications of these wavefunctions in the vicinity of the surface and the effect of possible formation of surface states are not incorporated . even so , fig . 6 shows that the one - step spectrum for the antibonding state @xmath86 is rather similar to that based on the momentum matrix element . some differences in the intensities of certain peaks in the figure may be understood as consequences of the fact that the momentum matrix element has been evaluated at @xmath125 while in the one - step result @xmath2 value is in general non - zero and varies from @xmath125 to the zone boundaries at @xmath126 for various peaks . results for the bonding state @xmath87 ( not shown for brevity ) are similar in that the level of agreement between the one - step and the momentum matrix element based spectra is comparable to that of fig . 6 . contributions @xmath127 of different atomic sites in the unit cell can be delineated via the decomposition of eqs . [ y12]-[y14 ] . table 1 and fig . 7 provide illustrative examples of such an analysis . considering @xmath72-polarized light , values of @xmath128 for each of the 15 basis atoms for one particular transition from the states @xmath86 and @xmath87 at m are listed in table 1 . fig . 7 on the other hand gives various significant contributions to _ all _ transitions from state @xmath86 over the energy range of 10 - 27 ev . the strong influence of the mirror symmetry around the @xmath63 layers is evident in table 1 . for the particular transition considered , the magnitudes of @xmath128 are the same for the two mirror partners corresponding to the two @xmath61 values , but the phases differ by @xmath129 . in fact , contributions cancel pairwise for the bonding state @xmath87 , but interfere constructively for the antibonding state @xmath86 . for many other transitions from @xmath86 and @xmath87 the situation is quite the opposite in that this sort of interference is _ destructive _ for @xmath86 , but _ constructive _ for @xmath87 . as we move away from m , these cancellation effects become less perfect as the phases do not always differ exactly by @xmath129 and/or the magnitudes of the two mirror partners are no longer the same . figure 7 provides a somewhat broader perspective . total matrix element @xmath130 obtained by summing over @xmath60 and @xmath61 is depicted pictorially for many transitions from @xmath86 together with contributions from pairs of @xmath66 , @xmath68 , @xmath82 and @xmath77 atoms ; @xmath131 for @xmath63 , @xmath75 , @xmath80 and @xmath69 are less than 0.01 in magnitude and are not shown . of a total of 64 possible transitions from state @xmath86 over the energy range of fig . 7 , only 20 transitions that are shown possess a significant intensity . a few of the transitions are identified by numbers 1 - 7 for convenient reference . as already noted above in connection with table 1 , transition 1 is quite intense and arises almost completely from @xmath68 . transition 4 contains an admixture of @xmath68 and @xmath66 , while transition 3 contains additionally a contribution from @xmath82 . transition 5 contains contribution from all these atoms as well as @xmath77 , but as indicated by downarrows , @xmath66 and @xmath82 give negative contributions yielding a net reduction in the total intensity . these examples would make it clear that constructive or destructive interference can take place not only for a given atomic pair , but also between different atomic sites . we emphasize that the intensity variations in fig . 7 reflect changes in the character of the final states since the initial state for all transitions is fixed to be the same . further insight can be gained by considering the angular momentum dependence of the matrix element , i.e. the quantities @xmath132 of eq . [ y15 ] . for illustrative purposes , we consider first the aforementioned transition 1 with the help of tables ii - v , followed by a few comments concerning the behavior of transitions more generally via fig . the weights in different angular momentum channels ( defined as @xmath133 ) for the initial states @xmath86 and @xmath87 associated with various atomic sites are given in tables ii and iii , while the final state for transition 1 is characterized similarly in table iv@xcite . we emphasize that these weights depend upon details of how space within the unit cell is ascribed to different atoms and the size and shape of the interstitial region . for this reason , we should keep in mind that the results of tables ii - iv possess inherent uncertainty , even though these are representative of the character of the states involved . as expected , wavefunctions of both @xmath86 and @xmath87 are seen from tables ii and iii to be predominantly @xmath134 and @xmath135 like ; @xmath82 as well as @xmath77 states hybridize more strongly with the bonding level @xmath87 compared to @xmath86 . the final state in table iv continues to be weighted in favor of @xmath66 and @xmath68 , but being 17.7 ev above the initial states , there is substantial change with respect to distribution among angular momentum channels and atomic sites . we turn next to table v and the matrix element for transition 1 from state @xmath86 . of the large number of possible terms ( @xmath136 ) under the summations in eq . [ y14 ] , only the few elements @xmath137 listed in table v possess substantial magnitude . the remaining elements are either zero due to selection rules or are negligibly small . the @xmath138 channel on @xmath68 is seen to be the strongest with a contribution ( in arbitrary units ) of 0.27 . it is most striking that the net contribution from @xmath66 is only 0.02 even though the initial state is dominated by @xmath66 . this is the result of strong interference effects : on @xmath66 , different angular momentum channels interfere destructively as manifest in the positive and negative signs of elements , while on @xmath68 , there is a constructive interference yielding a large total intensity of 0.43 . these observations hint that the arpes matrix element can display remarkable site selectivity properties . for transition 1 under discussion , for example , almost all the photoelectrons emanate from @xmath68 sites with little contribution from other sites in the crystal due to complicated interferences . 8 considers all transitions from @xmath86 over the energy range of 10 - 27 ev . the total matrix element @xmath130 and the portion @xmath139 associated with @xmath68 in the top two panels of the figure are reproduced from fig . 7 for ease of discussion ; the total @xmath68 intensity is decomposed into angular momentum channels in the three lower panels . by comparing the lengths of arrows in figs . 8(a ) and 8(b ) , we see that for most transitions ( but not all ) @xmath68 component is strong . the effect however is not as dominant as in the case of transition 1 ; for example , only about 60 percent of transitions 2 - 4 come from @xmath68 and transition 6 has essentially a zero @xmath68 part . moreover , even though different angular momentum channels interfere constructively for most transitions in that arrows are mostly pointed up in figs . 8(c)-(e ) , this is not always the case as some arrows are pointed downwards . in particular , for transition 5 roughly half of the intensity in @xmath140 channel is destroyed by inteference from @xmath138 channel , and for transition 7 , these two channels destroy each other nearly completely . we note finally that , of the many factors involved in defining @xmath141 on the right side of eq . 17 , much of the energy dependence depicted in fig . 8 originates from the behavior of the wavefunction coefficients of the final states ( @xmath142 ) ; the gaunt coefficients @xmath143 are constants and the quantities @xmath144 involving integrals of radial wavefunctions are slowly varying functions of energy . so far we have focused on the excitation of states @xmath86 and @xmath87 at the m(@xmath129,0,0 ) point , i.e. for @xmath125 . changes in the momentum matrix element as a function of @xmath2 for several selected transitions from the initial state @xmath86 are considered in fig . transitions 1 - 4 have been discussed previously in connection with figs . 7 and 8 . transitions 2b and 3b however , which lie quite close in energy to transitions 2 and 3 , respectively , were not shown before since their intensity is zero or near - zero at @xmath125 , but as fig . 9 shows , this is not the case for @xmath145 . transitions 1 and 4 decrease slightly in intensity as @xmath2 increases from zero to @xmath146 . on the other hand , transitions 2 , 2b , 3 or 3b undergo large changes . observable effects after spectra are smoothed with realistic broadenings of the order of a few ev s will likely be much smaller since the intensities of transitions 2 and 2b ( or similarly 3 and 3b ) taken together are expected to change little with @xmath2 . we have carried out additional computations at @xmath147-points on the @xmath148 line away from @xmath6 . the results continue to display complicated interference effects involving pairs of atoms and/or various atomic sites , essentially along the lines of the preceding commentary concerning emissions from @xmath6 , and require little further elaboration . we have investigated the nature of the arpes spectrum from bisco using the first - principles band theory framework . our focus is on understanding emission from electronic states along the @xmath148 symmetry line and particularly from the bonding and antibonding combinations of bands formed from the states associated with the @xmath0 bilayers which have been the subject of considerable recent discussion and controversy . salient features of the arpes spectrum delineated are as follows . the intensity of the antibonding as well as the bonding state at @xmath6 displays a strong dependence on photon energy even though the two states differ significantly from each other in this respect . this result indicates that the bonding state will be highlighted at certain photon energies while the antibonding state will be intense at other energies ; moreover , at photon energies where emission from either state is relatively weak , we would expect the effects of deviations of the underlying lattice from perfect tetragonal symmetry ( i.e. via various modulations ) to become more visible . the spectra depend strongly on the polarization of the incident light . at the @xmath6 point , for states in the vicinity of the @xmath5 , the intensity is maximum when light is polarized along the @xmath72- or the @xmath100 bond direction , but becomes nearly zero upon a @xmath105 rotation of the polarization vector perpendicular to the plane of the detector . simple arguments are presented to explain the @xmath149 ( where @xmath103 is the angle between the @xmath72-axis and the polarization vector ) variation observed in the one - step computations which yield a polar intensity plot in the shape of the number eight in bisco and other cuprates . an examination of the final states indicates that , despite the appearance of a semi - continuum , there are gaps in the final state spectrum and that the @xmath2 dispersion of some bands is as large as 0.5 ev even though the brillouin zone size is small along the z - direction . the situation thus is quite unlike the free electron case . we show how considerable insight into the nature of the _ specific _ arpes excitations can be adduced in terms of the momentum matrix element for _ bulk _ transitions within the solid in combination with constraints appropriate for a particular arpes measurement . such transition specific information tends to be difficult to ascertain within the more comprehensive one - step framework , especially in the presence of finite initial and final state dampings . \5 . with the preceding point in mind , we have studied the nature of the momentum matrix element for emission from the @xmath0 plane related antibonding state @xmath86 and the bonding state @xmath87 at @xmath6 at length over the transition energy range of 10 - 27 ev . we show how the matrix element , @xmath150 , can be decomposed usefully into contributions from various atomic `` pairs '' in the unit cell ( i.e. an atom and its mirror partner obtained by reflection through the @xmath63 layer about which the bisco lattice is symmetric ) , and further into different angular momentum channels . contributions from the two atoms in the aforementioned atomic pairs display remarkable effects of interfering _ constructively _ for some transitions and _ destructively _ for others . the net contribution from the @xmath68 pairs seems to dominate the spectrum in many cases even though the initial and final states involved possess large weights on the cu sites . these strong interference effects continue to be present in different angular momentum channels . the analysis indicates that many transitions are controlled essentially by just the _ single _ @xmath151 channel on the @xmath68 sites . this striking result hints that the arpes matrix element may possess most interesting site selectivity properties . the intensity of many transitions increases ( or decreases ) substantially as a function of @xmath2 . however , these variations are usually coupled with nearby transitions whose intensity decreases ( or increases ) so that the net contribution is generally not expected to show a strong @xmath2 dependence . in summary , the present analysis makes it clear that the complicated nature of the arpes matrix element in complex materials hides considerable potential for extracting useful information via this spectroscopy about the nature of specific states . studies of other cuprates along these lines should allow an identification of robust aspects of the electronic structure related to the @xmath0 planes . it is a pleasure to acknowledge important conversations with bob markiewicz . this work is supported by the us department of energy contract w-31 - 109-eng-38 , and benefited from the allocation of supercomputer time at the nersc and the northeastern university advanced scientific computation center ( ascc ) and institute of advanced computing ( iac ) , tampere . one of us ( s.s . ) acknowledges suomen akatemia , vilho , yrj ja kalle visln rahasto , tekniikan edistmissti and jenny ja antti wihurin rahasto for financial support . see e.g. , `` spectroscopies in novel superconductors '' , edited by a. bansil , r. markiewicz , s. sridhar and d. liebenberg [ j. phys . solids * 59 * , no 10 - 12 ( 1998 ) ] , and other volumes in this series for discussions of these and related issues . it is straightforward to mimic correlation effects in the present framework by introducing a self - energy correction to the hamiltonian . further work is however needed in this regard , especially for incorporating strong correlations effects in the arpes simulations . @xmath154 and @xmath97 are the imaginary parts of the initial and final state self - energies , respectively , used to include lifetime effects . for a damped propagator the full - width - at - half - maximum ( fwhm ) of the peak is roughly given by @xmath155 . see , n.v . smith , p.thiry and y. petroff , phys . b * 47 * , 15476(1993 ) . while these weights are relevant for analyzing the behavior of the momentum matrix element , one should keep in mind that these do not include the effect of the radial part of the wavefunction as seen from eqs . 10 and 11 . & & & @xmath156&@xmath157&@xmath156&@xmath157 + ca & 1&1&0.0279&35.6&0.0000 & - + cu & 2&1&0.0209&35.6&0.0191 & 16.8 + cu & 2&2&0.0209&35.6&0.0191&-163.2 + o@xmath158&3&1&0.4309&35.6&0.3111 & 16.8 + o@xmath158&3&2&0.4309&35.6&0.3111 & -163.2 + o@xmath159&4&1&0.0518&35.6&0.0784 & 16.8 + o@xmath159&4&2&0.0518&35.6&0.0784 & -163.2 + sr & 5&1&0.0158&35.6&0.0081 & 16.8 + sr & 5&2&0.0158&35.6&0.0081&-163.2 + o@xmath160 & 6&1&0.0316&35.6&0.0140 & 16.8 + o@xmath160 & 6&2&0.0316&35.6&0.0140 & -163.2 + bi & 7&1&0.0314&-144.4&0.0366&-163.2 + bi & 7&2&0.0314&-144.4&0.0366 & 16.8 + o@xmath161 & 8&1&0.0167&-144.4 & 0.0417 & -163.2 + o@xmath161 & 8&2&0.0167&-144.4 & 0.0417 & 16.8 + . wavefunction of the antibonding state @xmath86 at m - point is characterized in terms of weights ( in percent ) defined as @xmath162 associated with different sites @xmath60 ( see eq . not all angular momentum channels are listed . channels with small weights are omitted for brevity ; the total weight for this reason adds to less than 100 percent.@xcite [ cols= " < , > , > , > , > , > , > " , ] & @xmath163 & @xmath164 + o@xmath158 & @xmath165 & + 0.12 & + & @xmath166 & + 0.04 & + & @xmath167 & + 0.27 & + 0.43 + cu & @xmath168 & + 0.01 & + & @xmath169 & + 0.07 & + & @xmath170 & -0.02 & + & @xmath171 & -0.03 & + & @xmath172 & + 0.03 & + & @xmath173 & -0.04 & + 0.02 +

we have carried out extensive simulations of the angle - resolved photoemission ( arpes ) intensity in bi2212 within the one - step and three - step type models using a first - principles band theory framework . the focus is on understanding the behavior of emissions from the antibonding and bonding bands arising from the @xmath0 bilayers around the @xmath1 symmetry point . the specific issues addressed include : dependencies of the photointensity on the energy and polarization of the incident light ; character of the initial and final states involved as well as the spectrum of the relevant final states ; and , changes in the spectral intensity as a function of the perpendicular component , @xmath2 , of the momentum of the photoelectron . considerable insight into the nature of individual transitions is adduced by examining the momentum matrix element for bulk transitions within the solid and by further decomposing this matrix element into contributions from various atomic sites and angular momentum channels . these results indicate that , via remarkable interference effects , the arpes matrix element can in particular cases help zoom in on the properties of electrons excited from specific sites and/or angular momentum channels even in a complex material .

1412.0861

recently a progress has been brought about to understand the confinement mechanism in qcd - like theories by compactifying the theories in one spatial dimension with the period @xmath5 . because of the asymptotic freedom , the small @xmath5 theory is in the weak - coupling regime ( @xmath6 ) in qcd(adj . ) on @xmath7 . instanton is a particle - like soliton of codimension @xmath8 in @xmath8-dimensional spacetime . if @xmath2 twisted boundary conditions are imposed , we can obtain fractional instantons which have fractional amount of instanton number . a molecule of fractional instantons and anti - instantons are generally called bions . for compactified space with small @xmath5 , the perturbative analysis is reliable and shows that the wilson holonomy stabilizes the @xmath2 twisted boundary condition . in this case , one can demonstrate the condensation of classical field configurations composed of fractional instantons and anti - instantons with magnetic charge , which are called magnetic bions . condensation of magnetic bions implies the confinement in the compactified theory . it is anticipated that this phenomenon continues to hold for large @xmath5 , suggesting the confinement even for uncompactified theory . it has also been pointed out that neutral bions play an important role in explaining the resurgence phenomenon @xcite . neutral bions are composite of fractional instantons and anti - instantons with vanishing topological charge ( instanton number ) and zero magnetic charge . although perturbation series in field theories are divergent , the borel transformation is useful to obtain the re - summation of such divergent series . the borel transform often exhibits singularities on the positive real axis producing an imaginary ambiguities in the borel - resummed results . it has been found that these ambiguities in quantum mechanics are cancelled by contributions from molecule of instanton and anti - instantons @xcite . however , asymptotically free field theories like qcd and the @xmath0 nonlinear sigma models exhibits similar but more serious singularities near the origin , which are called infrared renormalons @xcite . recently it has been found that the nonperturbative contributions around the neutral saddle points also have imaginary ambiguities . these imaginary ambiguities of bion amplitudes are found to cancel @xcite precisely the imaginary ambiguities associated with the infrared renormalons , resulting in a more rigorous foundation of field theory . this phenomenon is called the resurgence . it is expected that full semi - classical expansion including perturbative and non - perturbative sectors , which is called resurgent expansion @xcite , leads to unambiguous and self - consistent definition of field theories in the spirit of quantum mechanical examples @xcite . however , it is not straightforward to verify these arguments in gauge theories directly , since it is difficult to find an explicit ansatz of bion configurations . at this stage , it is quite interesting and useful to study simpler models in lower dimensions @xcite instead of gauge theories in four spacetime dimensions . in particular , models in two spacetime dimensions are more tractable compared to gauge theories in four dimensions , but have many features which are common to gauge theories in four dimensions . among them , the @xmath0 model in two spacetime dimensions has been studied as a toy model @xcite of the yang - mills theory in four spacetime dimensions , because of their interesting features such as the dynamical mass gap , the asymptotic freedom and the existence of instantons as bogomolnyi - prasad - sommerfield ( bps ) solutions @xcite . the @xmath0 model on @xmath9 with twisted boundary conditions admits bps fractional instantons as configurations with the minimal topological charge @xcite ( see also refs . @xcite ) . in ref . @xcite , generic arguments on bion configurations were given in the @xmath0 model on @xmath9 with @xmath2 twisted boundary conditions , based on the independent instanton description taking account of interactions between far - separated fractional instantons and anti - instantons . more recently , exact non - bps solutions were found in the @xmath0 model on @xmath9 with the @xmath2 twisted boundary condition @xcite . the simplest non - bps solution that they found is a four - instanton configuration composed of two fractional instantons ( instanton charge @xmath3 ) and two fractional anti - instantons ( @xmath4 ) for @xmath10 placed at particular relative positions . their study suggests that it is likely that bion configurations needed to understand the resurgence phenomenon may not be solutions of field equations . it has been known that field configurations other than the solution of the equations of motion may give significant contributions in the functional integral . recently we constructed ansatz of bion configurations that are guaranteed to become solutions of the field equations asymptotically as separations between constituent fractional instantons get larger , and studied interactions of constituent fractional instantons in bion configuration @xcite . more recently , we have also studied bions in the grassmann sigma models which include the @xmath0 model as a subclass @xcite . since bions in nonlinear sigma models in two spacetime dimensions are interesting and more tractable , let us consider the @xmath0 model . to describe the target space @xmath11 , we denote an @xmath12-component vector of complex scalar fields as @xmath13 , and a normalized complex @xmath12-component vector composed from @xmath14 as @xmath15 latexmath:[\[n(x ) \equiv \omega(x)/|\omega(x)| , \quad two dimensions for the nonlinear sigma model with @xmath0 as the target space is given by @xmath17 and the topological charge representing @xmath18 is defined by @xmath19 where @xmath20 and @xmath21 . our convention of the covariant derivative is @xmath22 with a composite gauge field @xmath23 we consider @xmath1 as the geometry of base manifold , and configurations on it satisfying periodicity in the @xmath24 direction with the period @xmath5 . the lagrangian @xmath25 and topological charge @xmath26 can be expressed in terms of the projection operator @xmath27 and using the complex coordinate @xmath28 , @xmath29\,,\\ q&=&2\int d^2 x { \rm tr } \left[{\bf p } ( \partial_{\bar z}{\bf p } \partial_{z } { \bf p}-\partial_{z}{\bf p}\partial_{\bar z } { \bf p } ) \right]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we define the euclidean energy density ( lagrangian ) @xmath30 , and the topological charge density @xmath31 as functions of @xmath32 after the integration over @xmath24 : @xmath33\ , , \\ % q&={1\over{\pi}}\int dx_{1 } q(x_{1 } ) q(x_{1})&=&{1\over{\pi}}\int dx_{2 } { \rm tr } \left[{\bf p } ( \partial_{\bar z}{\bf p}\partial_{z } { \bf p}-\partial_{z } { \bf p}\partial_{\bar z } { \bf p } ) \right]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can perform the bogomolnyi completion to obtain the bogomolnyi bound @xcite for the total energy @xmath34 @xmath35 the bogomolnyi bound with the upper sign is saturated when the following bps equation is satisfied @xmath36 the solution of the bps equation is precisely holomorphic @xmath37 . the bogomolnyi bound with the lower sign is saturated when the following anti - bps equation is satisfied @xmath38 the solution of the anti - bps equation is anti - holomorphic @xmath39 . in the following we omit the coupling @xmath40 for simplicity unless stated otherwise . let us give a brief review of resurgence and the importance of bion contributions . it has been known that the number of feynman diagrams in quantum field theory grows factorially . this factorially divergent perturbation series of quantum field theory is usually discussed by means of the borel transform . the borel transform method is applicable to the following class of divergent series ( called gevrey-1 ) @xmath41 where @xmath42 are constants . the borel transform @xmath43 is defined as @xmath44 and the borel resummation @xmath45 is defined as @xmath46 one can easily see that the borel resummation @xmath45 reproduces the original sum @xmath47 correctly whenever one can exchange the integral and the sum . otherwise , we need to define the sum in terms of the borel resummation . as a simplified toy model , let us consider a factorially divergent series of the following one with alternating signs @xmath48 then the borel transform becomes an analytic function without singularities on the positive real axis @xmath49 therefore the borel resummation is well - defined as an integral along the positive real axis @xmath50 this alternating factorially divergent series is a typical example of borel summable divergent series . on the other hand , if perturbation series is not alternating , the factorially divergent series gives the borel transform with singularities on positive real axis and the borel resummation has imaginary ambiguities . for instance , suppose that the perturbation series @xmath51 gives non - alternating factorially divergent series like @xmath52 the borel transform has a singularity on positive real axis @xmath53 @xmath54 therefore the borel resummation has imaginary ambiguities depending on the choice of integration contours to avoid the singularity ( equivalently the analytic continuation from negative real axis ) @xmath55 this ambiguous imaginary part has to be cancelled by contributions from other saddle points in the path - integral . in quantum mechanics or scalar field theories , the position of the singularity in the borel plane has been found to correspond to molecules of instanton and anti - instanton @xcite . however , the asymptotically free theories like qcd and the @xmath0 model give additional singularities due to ir renormalons which are much closer to the origin and hence give much larger contributions . recent study @xcite showed that the bion amplitudes give the nonperturbative contribution needed to cancel the imaginary ambiguity due to the ir renormalons . when one space direction is compactified to @xmath56 with the circumference @xmath5 , there is a possibility to impose non - periodic boundary condition . moreover , asymptotic free theory becomes weakly coupled , and the stable configurations of wilson holonomies of @xmath57 subgroup of @xmath58 can be analyzed perturbatively @xcite . it turns out that the following @xmath59 twisted boundary condition is most favorable under certain conditions @xmath60\ , . \label{znc}\ ] ] this @xmath2 twisted boundary condition corresponds to the vacuum with the symmetry breaking @xmath61 . the wilson - loop holonomy in the compactified direction is given by @xmath62 where the gauge fields @xmath63 is the composite gauge field defined in eq . ( [ eq : composite_gauge_field ] ) of the @xmath0 model . the simplest solution of the bps equation ( [ eq : bpseq ] ) satisfying the @xmath59 twisted boundary condition in eq . ( [ znc ] ) is given by @xmath64 one can easily see that these bps solutions give the total action @xmath34 and the topological charge @xmath26 as @xmath65 therefore we call this bps solution as a fractional instanton . the fractional instanton is located at @xmath66 . a neutral bion is a molecule of fractional instantons and anti - instatons and is unstable under the annihilation process . then we anticipate that generic neutral bion configuration is not a solution of field equations . therefore we wish to construct a field configuration that reduces to a solution at least for far - separated fractional instantons and anti - instantons asymptotically . from the bps solution in eq.([eq : fractional_instanton ] ) and their complex conjugates , we are naturally led to consider the following ansatz for the @xmath67 model satisfying the @xmath2 twisted boundary condition in eq . ( [ znc ] ) @xmath68 a fractional instanton is located at @xmath69 , and a fractional anti - instanton is at @xmath70 , respectively . this configuration becomes a solution of field equations asymptotically as the separation @xmath71 goes to infinity . for @xmath72 , this configuration corresponds to a @xmath73 instanton ( @xmath74 , @xmath75 ) and a @xmath73 anti - instanton ( @xmath74 , @xmath76 ) at large separations . the total action and the net topological charge in the large - separation limit are given by @xmath77 the topological charge is unchanged as the separation between the fractional instanton and the anti - instanton changes . however , the total action monotonically decreases as the instantons get closer , which shows an attractive force . we have evaluated analytically the total action for various values of separation between the fractional instanton and anti - instanton . in fig . [ bbsflog ] , we show the total action @xmath34 as a function of the separation @xmath78 for @xmath79 . we also show the attractive force defined by @xmath80 as a function of the separation @xmath81 . for negative values , the moduli parameter @xmath81 loses the physical meaning as the separation between the fractional instanton and anti - instanton , and merely describes a deformation of the field configuration . dependence of the total action @xmath34 and the force @xmath80 for ( [ bbozeron ] ) with @xmath79 . for @xmath82 , we can interpret @xmath81 as separation between the instanton constituents . the configuration is changed from @xmath83 to @xmath84 , due to the attractive force . the configuration for @xmath85 corresponds to neutral bions.,scaledwidth=99.0% ] to compare our concrete ansatz ( [ bbozeron ] ) to the far - separated instanton argument in ref . @xcite , we analyze the interaction part of the action for our configuration . the interaction part of the action density is written as the difference of the action density @xmath86 compared to the sum of the one fractional - instanton density and one fractional - anti - instanton density @xmath87 , @xmath88 the total interaction action is given by integrating over the space @xmath89 as a function of @xmath81 for @xmath79 ( left ) , @xmath90 ( center ) and @xmath91 ( right ) for ( [ bbozeron ] ) ( red curves with triangle points ) . for @xmath92 , the curve is almost equivalent to @xmath93 ( blue curves).,scaledwidth=99.0% ] $ ] in eq.([eq : int_action_approx ] ) as a function of @xmath12 for @xmath94 for the ansatz ( [ bbozeron ] ) ( blue points ) . the coefficient can be approximated by @xmath95 ( a red curve).,scaledwidth=60.0% ] in fig . [ sint ] , we plot the logarithm of the total interaction action @xmath96 as a function of @xmath81 for @xmath97 . in the @xmath98 region , @xmath99 can be well approximated by analytic lines , @xmath100\,\,\sim\,\ , -\xi(n)\ , \tau \,\,+\,\ , c(n)\,,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\ , ( \tau\geq 1)\,,\ ] ] where @xmath101 is a slope and @xmath102 is a @xmath103-intercept . in fig . [ sint ] we simultaneously depict these analytic lines for the three cases . the slopes @xmath104 of the approximate lines read @xmath105 for @xmath79 , @xmath106 for @xmath90 and @xmath107 for @xmath91 , which indicates that the slope @xmath104 can be generally expressed as @xmath108 therefore we observe that the interaction action can be written as the following form for @xmath98 region , @xmath109 this @xmath104 is equivalent to the ( dimensionless ) lowest kaluza - klein spectrum @xmath110 , which is given as @xmath111 , where @xmath112 and @xmath113 are two nonzero components of wilson - loop holonomies in ( [ whn ] ) . restoring the coupling constant @xmath114 , we finally obtain that the fractional instanton and anti - instanton exert attractive interaction from large to small separations as @xmath115 this is precisely in accord with the approximate result for far - separated case @xcite . now we are in a position to sketch briefly how our results fit into the resurgence phenomenon . according to the study , the imaginary ambiguity arising in non - borel - summable perturbative series is compensated by the contributions of neutral bions . this phenomenon , which is called resurgence " , works as follows @xcite : the effective interaction energy by bosonic exchange between one fractional instanton and one fractional anti - instanton is given in eq . ( [ bions1 ] ) . the total bion amplitude including the fermion zero - mode exchange contribution is given by @xmath116 with @xmath117 and @xmath118 being the instanton action . @xmath119 stands for fermion flavors . for neutral bion , semiclassical description of independent fractional instantons breaks down since the interaction is attractive and instantons are merged in the end . here , the bzj - prescription , replacing @xmath120 , works to extract meaningful information from this amplitude . the prescription turns the interaction ( spuriously ) into a repulsive one and the amplitude becomes well - defined as @xmath121 by using the analytic continuation in the @xmath122 complex plane , we can continue back to the original @xmath122 . for @xmath123 case , we then encounter the following imaginary ambiguity in the amplitude as @xmath124 we can rephrase this situation as follows : unstable negative modes of bions give rise to imaginary ambiguities of the amplitude . the imaginary ambiguity has the same magnitude with an opposite sign as the leading - order ambiguity ( @xmath125 ) arising from the non - borel - summable series expanded around the perturbative vacuum . the ambiguities at higher orders ( @xmath126 , @xmath127 , ... ) are cancelled by amplitudes of bion molecules ( 2-bion , 3-bion , ... ) , and the full trans - series expansion around the perturbative and non - perturbative vacua results in unambiguous definition of field theories . finally we would like to mention the results of our more recent study of bions in the grassmann sigma model @xcite . the grassmann sigma model with the grassmann manifold @xmath128 as a target space include the @xmath129 model as a subclass with @xmath130 ( and @xmath131 ) . we have found that charged bions do not exist in the @xmath129 model , whereas the genuine grassmann sigma model with @xmath132 admits charged bions . the grassmann sigma model admits bps fractional instantons @xcite with instanton number greater than unity ( of order @xmath133 ) , which can not be reduced to composite of instantons and fractional instantons . interaction between fractional instanton and anti - instanton in the grassmann model is obtained to form neutral bions . we have also obtained exact non - bps solutions of field equations for charged bions . to obtain these results , d - brane configurations are found to be a valuable tool to analyze fractional instantons and bions . we are grateful to mithat nsal and gerald dunne for their interest and valuable comments and correspondences on their related work during the entire course of our study . t. m. and n. s. thank philip argyres , alexei cherman , falk bruckmann , and tin sulejmanpasic and other participants of cern theory institute 2014 , `` resurgence and transseries in quantum , gauge and string theories '' for the fruitful discussion and useful correspondence . t. m. is in part supported by the japan society for the promotion of science ( jsps ) grants number 26800147 . the work of m. n. is supported in part by grant - in - aid for scientific research ( no . 25400268 ) and by the `` topological quantum phenomena '' grant - in - aid for scientific research on innovative areas ( no . 25103720 ) from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ( mext ) of japan . n. s. is supported by grant - in aid for scientific research no . 25400241 from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ( mext ) of japan . 9 m. unsal , `` abelian duality , confinement , and chiral symmetry breaking in qcd(adj ) , '' phys . rev . * 100 * ( 2008 ) 032005 [ arxiv:0708.1772 [ hep - th ] ] . m. unsal , `` magnetic bion condensation : a new mechanism of confinement and mass gap in four dimensions , '' phys . d * 80 * ( 2009 ) 065001 [ arxiv:0709.3269 [ hep - th ] ] . m. shifman and m. unsal , `` qcd - like theories on r(3 ) x s(1 ) : a smooth journey from small to large r(s(1 ) ) with double - trace deformations , '' phys . d * 78 * ( 2008 ) 065004 [ arxiv:0802.1232 [ hep - th ] ] . e. poppitz and m. unsal , `` conformality or confinement : ( ir)relevance of topological excitations , '' jhep * 0909 * ( 2009 ) 050 [ arxiv:0906.5156 [ hep - th ] ] . m. m. anber and e. poppitz , `` microscopic structure of magnetic bions , '' jhep * 1106 * , 136 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1105.0940 [ hep - th ] ] . `` seiberg - witten and polyakov - like magnetic bion confinements are continuously connected , '' e. poppitz , t. schaefer and m. unsal , `` continuity , deconfinement , and ( super ) yang - mills theory , '' jhep * 1210 * ( 2012 ) 115 [ arxiv:1205.0290 [ hep - th ] ] . p. argyres and m. unsal , `` a semiclassical realization of infrared renormalons , '' phys . * 109 * ( 2012 ) 121601 [ arxiv:1204.1661 [ hep - th ] ] . g. v. dunne and m. unsal , `` resurgence and trans - series in quantum field theory : the cp(n-1 ) model , '' jhep * 1211 * ( 2012 ) 170 [ arxiv:1210.2423 [ hep - th ] ] . r. dabrowski and g. v. dunne , `` fractionalized non - self - dual solutions in the cp(n-1 ) model , '' phys . d * 88 * ( 2013 ) 2 , 025020 [ arxiv:1306.0921 [ hep - th ] ] . g. v. dunne and m. unsal , `` generating non - perturbative physics from perturbation theory , '' phys . d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 041701 [ arxiv:1306.4405 [ hep - th ] ] . a. cherman , d. dorigoni , g. v. dunne and m. unsal , `` resurgence in qft : unitons , fractons and renormalons in the principal chiral model , '' phys . * 112 * ( 2014 ) 021601 [ arxiv:1308.0127 [ hep - th ] ] . g. basar , g. v. dunne and m. unsal , `` resurgence theory , ghost - instantons , and analytic continuation of path integrals , '' jhep * 1310 * ( 2013 ) 041 [ arxiv:1308.1108 [ hep - th ] ] . g. v. dunne and m. unsal , `` uniform wkb , multi - instantons , and resurgent trans - series , '' phys . d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 105009 [ arxiv:1401.5202 [ hep - th ] ] . a. cherman , d. dorigoni and m. unsal , `` decoding perturbation theory using resurgence : stokes phenomena , new saddle points and lefschetz thimbles , '' arxiv:1403.1277 [ hep - th ] . e. b. bogomolny , `` calculation of instanton - anti - instanton contributions in quantum mechanics , '' phys . b * 91 * , 431 ( 1980 ) . j. zinn - justin , `` multi - instanton contributions in quantum mechanics , '' nucl . phys . b * 192 * , 125 ( 1981 ) . j. zinn - justin and u. d. jentschura , `` multi - instantons and exact results i : conjectures , wkb expansions , and instanton interactions , '' annals phys . * 313 * , 197 ( 2004 ) [ quant - ph/0501136 ] . j. zinn - justin , `` perturbation series at large orders in quantum mechanics and field theories : application to the problem of resummation , '' phys . rept . * 70 * , 109 ( 1981 ) . g. t hooft , `` can we make sense out of quantum chromodynamics ? , '' subnucl . ser . * 15 * , 943 ( 1979 ) . m. beneke , `` renormalons , '' phys . rept . * 317 * , 1 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9807443 ] . j. ecalle , les fonctions resurgentes " , i - iii ( publ . orsay , 1981 ) . a. m. polyakov and a. a. belavin , `` metastable states of two - dimensional isotropic ferromagnets , '' jetp lett . * 22 * , 245 ( 1975 ) [ pisma zh . * 22 * , 503 ( 1975 ) ] . m. eto , y. isozumi , m. nitta , k. ohashi and n. sakai , `` instantons in the higgs phase , '' phys . d * 72 * , 025011 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0412048 ] . m. eto , t. fujimori , y. isozumi , m. nitta , k. ohashi , k. ohta and n. sakai , `` non - abelian vortices on cylinder : duality between vortices and walls , '' phys . d * 73 * , 085008 ( 2006 ) [ hep - th/0601181 ] . m. eto , t. fujimori , m. nitta , k. ohashi , k. ohta and n. sakai , `` statistical mechanics of vortices from d - branes and t - duality , '' nucl . b * 788 * , 120 ( 2008 ) [ hep - th/0703197 ] . m. eto , y. isozumi , m. nitta , k. ohashi and n. sakai , `` solitons in the higgs phase : the moduli matrix approach , '' j. phys . a * 39 * , r315 ( 2006 ) [ hep - th/0602170 ] . f. bruckmann , `` instanton constituents in the o(3 ) model at finite temperature , '' phys . lett . * 100 * , 051602 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0707.0775 [ hep - th ] ] . w. brendel , f. bruckmann , l. janssen , a. wipf and c. wozar , `` instanton constituents and fermionic zero modes in twisted @xmath134 models , '' phys . b * 676 * , 116 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0902.2328 [ hep - th ] ] . d. harland , `` kinks , chains , and loop groups in the @xmath134 sigma models , '' j. math . phys . * 50 * , 122902 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0902.2303 [ hep - th ] ] . t. misumi , m. nitta and n. sakai , `` neutral bions in the @xmath0 model , '' jhep * 1406 * , 164 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1404.7225 [ hep - th ] ] . t. misumi , m. nitta and n. sakai , `` classifying bions in grassmann sigma models and non - abelian gauge theories by d - branes , '' arxiv:1409.3444 [ hep - th ] . e. b. bogomolny , `` stability of classical solutions , '' sov . j. nucl . * 24 * , 449 ( 1976 ) [ yad . * 24 * , 861 ( 1976 ) ] .

classical configurations in the @xmath0 model on @xmath1 is studied with twisted boundary conditions . starting from fractional instantons with the @xmath2 twisted boundary conditions , we review briefly the relevance of our study to resurgence phenomenon in field theory . we consider primarily configurations composed of multiple fractional instantons , called neutral bions " , which are identified as perturbative infrared renormalons " . we construct an explicit ansatz corresponding to topologically trivial configurations containing one fractional instanton ( @xmath3 ) and one fractional anti - instanton ( @xmath4 ) , which is guaranteed to become a solution of field equations asymptotically for large separations . the attractive interactions between the instanton constituents from small to large separations are found to be consistent with the standard separated - instanton calculus . our results suggest that the ansatz enables us to study bions and the related physics for a wide range of separations . this talk is mainly based on our recent work published in jhep * 1406 * , 164 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1404.7225 [ hep - th ] ] .

1611.00437

the visible matter distribution of the universe forms a complex web - like network composed of filaments and sheets separated by voids ( bond et al . 1996 ; aragn - calvo et al . galaxies are continuously funneled into higher density cluster environments through these structures . in the hierarchical structure formation scenario , z @xmath2 0 filaments are the current end point of large - scale structure evolution . investigating filamentary structures around dynamically young clusters should thus yield valuable information on their assembly histories . studying the large - scale galaxy distribution around the virgo cluster , the nearest rich , young cluster ( aguerri et al . 2005 ) , should therefore provide constraints on its formation and evolution at the current epoch . from three - dimensional mapping of nearby galaxies , tully ( 1982 , hereafter t82 ) identified prolate and oblate over - densities of galaxies around the virgo cluster . these were however not clearly revealed as conventional narrow filaments , but were rather sparse , mainly due to the limited sample size . a better characterization of these structures requires improved statistics from larger galaxy samples , particularly those with fainter galaxies . recent spectroscopic surveys of galaxies such as the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; e.g. , sdss data release 7 , abazajian et al . 2009 ) do enable the exploration of possible filamentary structures within an extensive volume around the virgo cluster . moreover , radial velocity information on numerous galaxies combined with distance data allows to investigate potential dynamical relationships between the filaments and the virgo cluster . the primary goal of our study is thus to revisit the large - scale structures in the vicinity of the virgo cluster using an up - to - date statistically robust dataset , to test whether the t82 structures can be better characterized and identified as filaments . we also search for previously unknown structures that may now be apparent . finally , we investigate whether the structures are physically connected to the virgo cluster using hubble diagrams . throughout this paper , we assume a hubble constant of @xmath3 = 100 @xmath4 km s@xmath5 mpc@xmath5 , where @xmath4 = 0.74 ( tully et al . 2008 , hereafter t08 ) . while the sdss is large and homogeneous , it does not cover most of the southern hemisphere and the spectroscopy is incomplete for both bright ( @xmath6 @xmath7 16 ) and faint ( @xmath6 @xmath8 20 ) objects ( e.g. , kim et al . 2014 ) . we therefore adopt here the hyperleda database ( paturel et al . 2003 ) , which while heterogeneous and necessarily incomplete does contain multiple other surveys in addition to the sdss data release 7 ( abazajian et al . 2009 ) . for our analysis , we extracted all galaxies with available radial velocities less than 6000 km s@xmath5 in the region 115 deg @xmath1 r.a.(j2000 ) @xmath1 240 deg and @xmath935 deg @xmath1 decl.(j2000 ) @xmath1 60 deg ( see figure 1 ) . this ensures the inclusion of all structures potentially associated with the virgo cluster ( with a mean radial velocity of @xmath21000 km s@xmath5 and a velocity dispersion of @xmath2800 km s@xmath5 ; binggeli et al . however , as no distinct structure in the vicinity of the virgo cluster is identified beyond a velocity of 3300 km s@xmath5 , we henceforth only discuss the 9168 galaxies within that range . we examined the radial velocities of 755 sdss filament galaxies , finding a mean difference of 6 km s@xmath5 and a dispersion of 63 km s@xmath5 with respect to hyperleda velocities ( the latter typically averaging multiple surveys ) . we therefore conclude that the radial velocity information of our sample is not significantly affected by the compilation of different sources in hyperleda . to construct an accurate spatial distribution of the galaxies , we first converted the observed heliocentric radial velocities to velocities relative to the centroid of the local group , and then applied a correction for infall into the virgo cluster ( mould et al.2000 ) . based on the assumption of a linear relationship between redshift and distance , all galaxies were then mapped in the three dimensions of the cartesian supergalactic coordinate system : sgx , sgy , sgz ( t08 ) . our search for filamentary structures was conducted within the cuboid enclosed by the following limits : -25 @xmath0 mpc @xmath1 sgx @xmath1 25 @xmath0 mpc , + 4 @xmath0 mpc @xmath1 sgy @xmath1 27 @xmath0 mpc , + -25 @xmath0 mpc @xmath1 sgz @xmath1 25 @xmath0 mpc . + the use of this extended region enables a more accurate characterization of large - scale filamentary structures than the study of t82 . we rejected galaxies within a radius of 3.6 mpc from the virgo cluster center ( at least two times the virial radius ; mclaughlin 1999 ) , to avoid contamination from cluster galaxies with large infall velocities that are gravitationally bound to the cluster inside the infalling region ( mamon et al . 2004 ; falco et al . this leaves 8401 galaxies with which to search for large - scale structures . the sgx - sgz plane is best to look for large - scale structures , as positional errors are small in this plane ( roughly in the plane of the sky ) but substantial along the sgy axis ( roughly along the line of sight and thus affected by deviations from the hubble flow ) . the detection of filaments was thus performed by applying the following steps : 1 . we constructed a series of different sgx - sgy - sgz volume slices with an arbitrary depth of 2 @xmath0 mpc along the sgy axis . candidate structures were then selected by visual inspection of the sgx - sgz projection of each slice , looking for overdense and long ( i.e. , filamentary ) galaxy distributions . if a candidate structure was continuously present in consecutive slices , we accordingly estimated its full range in three dimensions . 2 . we performed three - dimensional third - order polynomial fitting with weighting by the local galaxy density to the visually selected candidate structures . if the standard deviation of the fit to a candidate structure was less than 1.5 @xmath0 mpc ( comparable to or less than the typical thickness of filaments in simulations and observations ; e.g. colberg et al . 2005 ; akahori & ryu 2010 ; choi et al . 2010 ; vazza et al . 2014 ) , the structure was retained and classified as a filament . if not , the candidate structure was rejected . we further applied a two - sigma clip to the galaxies around the fitted lines ( i.e. , the filament spines ) , to extract the galaxies that belong to each filament . the authenticity of each candidate structure was verified by looking at a multitude of sgx - sgy - sgz projections , and the more diffuse ( i.e. , non - filamentary ) nature of the rejected structures was assessed ( chance projections , sheets , etc ) . with the search strategy above , we identified seven filaments and one sheet in the volume surrounding the virgo cluster , divided into two subsamples with distinct sgy ranges ( see sec . figure 1 shows the spatial distribution of the 1013 galaxies belonging to these structures in the equatorial coordinate system . the properties of these structures are summarized in table 1 . we note that all structures mostly consist of faint galaxies ( m@xmath1019 ; @xmath288@xmath11 of the total sample ) . finally , we collected redshift - independent distances of sample galaxies from the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) , with 229 matches . we calculated the distances ( @xmath12 ) and radial velocities ( @xmath13 ) of these galaxies relative to the virgo cluster center ( karachentsev & nasonova 2010 ) , adopting a distance of the virgo cluster from us of 16.5 mpc ( mei et al . 2007 ) . in this instance , for the calculation of @xmath13 ( t08 ) , the heliocentric radial velocities were corrected for the motion of the local sheet and local void only ( and _ not _ for virgo - centric infall ) . finally , peculiar velocities ( @xmath14 ) were derived using the following equation : @xmath15 figure 2 presents the distribution of six filaments with 4 @xmath0 mpc @xmath1 sgy @xmath1 16 @xmath0 mpc in the sgx - sgz projected plane ( fig . 2a ) and the sgx - sgy - sgz three - dimensional space ( fig . we named these filaments after the structures designated as clouds or spurs by t82 ( fig . 2c ) . by construction , all the filaments are narrower and longer than the broader and more diffuse t82 structures . all are also elongated toward the virgo cluster , suggesting they are related to it . it is interesting to note that when we apply our search strategy to the t82 sample , the t82 structures are _ not _ identified as filaments . this is most likely due to the small t82 sample size , as the number of galaxies in each filament is two or three times larger in our sample . in addition , while the majority of galaxies in t82 are bright ( m@xmath2019 ) , our structures are mainly composed of less luminous galaxies ( m@xmath2119 ) . bright galaxies ( large open circles in figs . 14 ) exhibit an uneven distribution with numerous gaps along the filaments . conversely , the large number of low - luminosity galaxies available here ( small filled circles in figs . 14 ) helps to better delineate continuous filaments by filling in the gaps . the leo ii cloud appears to be a multi - stem clump rather than a single prolate one ( fig . 2c ) . indeed , in a more extensive area around the leo ii cloud , we identified two filaments , leo ii a and b. the leo ii b filament traces a sparse region of the cloud , whereas the leo ii a filament includes the main clump of the leo ii cloud and is one of the largest structures we detect ( 16 @xmath0 mpc long in the sgx - sgz plane ) , with a curved shape . it is known that warped or irregular filaments are more common and are on average longer than straight filaments ( colberg et al . 2005 ) . over 150 galaxies in the six filaments identified in figs . 2a and 2b have a redshift - independent distance . their hubble diagram in the virgo - centric reference frame is presented in figure 2d . most galaxies in all these filaments exhibit a distinct deviation of their radial velocities from an unperturbed hubble flow ( red line ; see also the median values in the inset ) , suggesting appreciable infall toward the virgo cluster . we also plot a model of the radial infall velocity profile of the virgo cluster ( blue line ) , adopting the model of falco et al . ( 2014 ; eq . 6 , representing the mean velocity of infalling galaxies in the outer regions of the cluster ) with a virial radius of 1.55 mpc ( mclaughlin 1999 ) and a virial velocity of 800 km s@xmath5 ( binggeli et al . the observed distribution of radial velocities of the filament galaxies is entirely consistent with the expected infall profile , confirming that all these filaments are dynamically connected to the virgo cluster ( see also karachentsev et al . 2014 ) . figures 3a and 3b are analogous to figs . 2a and 2b but for 16 @xmath0 mpc @xmath1 sgy @xmath1 27 @xmath0 mpc . they show one filament and one sheet identified behind the virgo cluster , at mean distances of 33 and 41 mpc from us , respectively . the filament ( red circles ) , which we call the ngc 5353/4 filament , is long and thin and extends out from the ngc 5353/4 group , running tangentially past the virgo cluster rather than pointing toward it . filaments running from the vicinity of the ngc 5353/4 group to the virgo ( e.g. , canes venatici filament , see the gray rectangle in fig . 3a ) and coma clusters in different sgy ranges have been reported in the past ( tully @xmath22 trentham 2008 ; pomarde et al . 2015 ) , but the ngc5353/4 filament identified here is not specifically referred to in previous studies . seventeen galaxies in the ngc 5353/4 filament have a redshift - independent distance . their hubble diagram in the ngc 5353/4 group - centric reference frame is presented in fig . all but one ngc 5353/4 filament galaxies show a clear negative offset from the hubble flow , with a mean of @xmath9242 km s@xmath5 , indicating that they are infalling toward the ngc 5353/4 group . recently , pomarde et al . ( 2015 ) identified the arrowhead mini - supercluster , in which the ngc 5353/4 group is located , at the edge of the arrowhead flow pattern in the velocity field . they also suggested that the ngc 5353/4 group is located at the boundary of the flow pattern of the laniakea supercluster ( tully et al . the ngc 5353/4 filament thus appears to be a small structure bridging the arrowhead and laniakea superclusters ( see arrows in fig . 3a for the directions to the two superclusters ) . a thin sheet structure ( yellow circles ) is also clearly visible in figs . 3a and 3b . while it appears filament - like in the projected plane ( fig . 3a ) , it is clearly flattened ( fig . 3b ) , with an axial ratio sgx : sgy : sgz = 9:6:1 . since this structure includes the w and m clouds as well as the western part of the southern extension of the virgo cluster , we name it the w - m sheet . the existence of this sheet was however alluded to by binggeli et al . ( 1993 ) , and a connection between the w and m clouds was also suggested ( e.g. ftaclas et al.1984 ; yoon et al . 2012 ) . fifty four galaxies in the w - m sheet have a redshift - independent distance . their hubble diagram in the virgo - centric reference frame is presented in fig . the w - m sheet galaxies have a large scatter around the hubble flow with no trend , indicating that the sheet is unlikely to be dynamically connected to the virgo cluster . cosmological numerical simulations suggest that galaxy clusters have non - spherical shapes , owing to the preferential infall of matter along the `` cosmic web '' ( e.g. limousin et al . 2013 and references therein ) . dynamically young clusters within filaments are also expected to be more elongated than relaxed clusters . moreover , it has been noted that the virgo cluster exhibits a noticeably non - spherical shape , elongated along a direction almost parallel to the line of sight , albeit primarily when considering galaxies near the cluster center ( e.g. binggeli et al . 1987 ; west @xmath22 blakeslee 2000 ; mei et al . 2007 ) . in figure 4a , we show the spatial distribution of galaxies in the virgo cluster using only galaxies classified as `` certain '' cluster members in the extended virgo cluster catalog ( evcc , kim et al . 2014 ; black open circles inside a large rectangular box ) . using hyperleda , we also plot the galaxies ( gray open circles ) within the cluster zero - velocity surface ( large gray circle with a 26 deg radius ; karachentsev @xmath22 nasonova 2010 ) . noticeably , the bright elliptical galaxies ( m@xmath2319 ; red open circles ) are all aligned . the galaxies in the western outskirts of the cluster ( i.e.,180 deg @xmath1 r.a . @xmath1 160 deg ) also exhibit a filamentary distribution , with a major axis similar to that of the bright ellipticals nearer the cluster center . moreover , this collinear distribution of cluster galaxies appears to be smoothly connected to the leo ii a and b filaments identified here ( cyan and green circles ) . the genuine alignment of the galaxies in three dimensions is confirmed by the distribution of the galaxies with available redshift - independent distances in the plane of r.a . vs. distance from us ( fig . 4b ) . instead of a random distribution , the galaxy distances are systematically increasing from the cluster center to the filaments . this systematic trend supports the suggestion that the galaxy distribution along the fundamental axis of the virgo cluster is associated with the leo ii a and b filaments . west @xmath22 blakeslee ( 2000 ) claimed that the collinear distribution of the brightest ellipticals near the cluster centre may be part of a filament connecting the virgo cluster to abell 1367 ( see the arrow indicating the direction to abell 1367 in fig . 4b ) , but our data suggest that a connection to the leo ii a and b filaments is more likely . in any case , our results are clear observational evidence that the spatial distribution of cluster galaxies is not completely spherically symmetric , reflecting the anisotropy of their accretions along filaments ( e.g. joachimi et al . 2015 and references therein ; see also lee et al . 2014 ) . in this respect , comparative studies of galaxies in virgo - related filaments with ones in the cluster itself should help to understand the growth and evolution of the cluster ( s.kim , in preparation ) . filament galaxies are a crucial tool to measure galaxy cluster and group parameters . we have already estimated a new virgo cluster dynamical mass by applying the novel method of falco et al . ( 2014 ) , based on the universal radial velocity profile of filament galaxies , to the leo ii a and virgo iii filaments ( lee et al . we have also determined the turn - around radius of the ngc 5353/4 group by applying the falco et al . methodology to the ngc 5353/4 filament ( lee et al . accurate measurements of the physical parameters of nearby galaxy clusters and groups using filaments in their vicinity can also provide independent constraints on cosmological models ( see lee et al . 2015a , b for details ) . finally , filaments are prime targets for detailed investigations of the physical processes controlling the transition of field galaxies to cluster galaxies ( e.g. balogh et al . 2004 ; ebeling et al . 2004 ; porter et al . 2008 ; yoon et al . 2012 ; guo et al . 2015 ; martnez et al . indeed , as the majority of filament galaxies are faint dwarf galaxies , with low binding energies , they are easily affected by even weak perturbations . they are thus well - suited to probing the details of the multiple mechanisms ( e.g. gas stripping and tidal interactions ) that can affect galaxies in low - density environments before they enter higher - density regions ( `` pre - processing '' ; fujita 2004 ; cybulski et al . 2014 ) . to directly probe environmental effects in filaments , we are thus currently examining the hi morphology and kinematics of carefully selected late - type galaxies in filaments around the virgo cluster ( e.g. yoon et al . 2015 ; h. yoon , in preparation ) . in a forthcoming paper , we will also compare dwarf galaxies in filaments with those in other environments , including cluster ( e.g. kim et al . 2014 ) , group ( e.g. pak et al . 2014 ) , and the field ( s. kim , in preparation ) . we thank the anonymous referee for the clarifications and comments that helped to improve the original manuscript . we thank d.s . ryu and j.h . lee for helpful discussions . this research was supported by the basic science research program through the national research foundation of korea ( nrf ) funded by the ministry of education , science , and technology ( 2015r1a2a2a01006828 ) . support was also provided by the nrf of korea to the center for galaxy evolution research ( no . 2010 - 0027910 ) . s.k . acknowledges support from a national junior research fellowship of nrf ( no . 2011 - 0012618 ) . acknowledges support from the nrf funded by the ministry of education ( nrf-2013r1a6a3a04064993 ) . this study was also financially supported by the research fund of chungnam national university in 2014 . this work has been also supported by science fellowship of posco tj park foundation and the nrf grant no . hj acknowledges the support of the australian research council through discovery project dp150100862 . abazajian , k. n. , adelman - mccarthy , j. k. , ageros , m. a. , et al . 2009 , , 182 , 543 aguerri , j. a. l. , gerhard , o. e. , arnaboldi , m. , et al . 2005 , , 129 , 2585 akahori , t. , & ryu , d. 2010 , , 723 , 476 aragn - calvo , m. a. , van de weygaert , r. , & jones , b. j. t. 2010 , , 408 , 2163 balogh , m. , eke , v. , miller , c. , et al . 2004 , , 348 , 1355 binggeli , b. , tammann , g. a. , & sandage , a. 1987 , , 94 , 251 binggeli , b. , popescu , c. c. , & tammann , g. a. 1993 , , 98 , 275 bond , j. r. , kofman , l. , & pogosyan , d. 1996 , , 380 , 603 choi , e. , bond , n. a. , strauss , m. a. , et al . 2010 , , 406 , 320 colberg , j. m. , krughoff , k. s. , & connolly , a. j. 2005 , , 359 , 272 cybulski , r. , yun , m. s. , fazio , g. g. , & gutermuth , r. a. 2014 , , 439 , 3564 ebeling , h. , barrett , e. , & donovan , d. 2004 , , 609 , l49 falco , m. , hansen , s. h. , wojtak , r. , et al . 2014 , , 442 , 1887 ftaclas , c. , struble , m. f. , & fanelli , m. n. 1984 , , 282 , 19 fujita , y. 2004 , , 56 , 29 guo , q. , tempel , e. , & libeskind , n. i. 2015 , , 800 , 112 joachimi , b. , cacciato , m. , kitching , t. d. , et al . 2015 , , 193 , 1 karachentsev , i. d. , tully , r. b. , wu , p .- f . , shaya , e. j. , & dolphin , a. e. 2014 , , 782 , 4 karachentsev , i. d. , & nasonova , o. g. 2010 , , 405 , 1075 kim , s. , rey , s .- c . , jerjen , h. , et al . 2014 , , 215 , 22 lee , j. , rey , s .- c . , & kim , s. 2014 , , 791 , 15 lee , j. , kim , s. , & rey , s .- c . 2015a , , 815 , 43 lee , j. , kim , s. , & rey , s .- c . 2015b , , 807 , 122 limousin , m. , morandi , a. , sereno , m. , et al . 2013 , , 177 , 155 mei , s. , blakeslee , j. p. , ct , p. , et al . 2007 , , 655 , 144 mould , j. r. , huchra , j. p. , freedman , w. l. , et al . 2000 , , 545 , 547 mamon , g. a. , sanchis , t. , salvador - sol , e. , & solanes , j. m. 2004 , , 414 , 445 martnez , h. j. , muriel , h. , & coenda , v. 2016 , , 455 , 127 mclaughlin , d. e. 1999 , , 512 , l9 pak , m. , rey , s .- c . , lisker , t. , et al . 2014 , , 445 , 630 paturel , g. , petit , c. , prugniel , p. , et al . 2003 , , 412 , 45 porter , s. c. , raychaudhury , s. , pimbblet , k. a. , & drinkwater , m. j. 2008 , , 388 , 1152 pomarde , d. , tully , r. b. , hoffman , y. , & courtois , h. m. 2015 , , 812 , 17 tully , r. b. 1982 , , 257 , 389 ( t82 ) tully , r. b. , & trentham , n. 2008 , , 135 , 1488 tully , r. b. , shaya , e. j. , karachentsev , i. d. , et al . 2008 , , 676 , 184 ( t08 ) tully , r. b. , courtois , h. , hoffman , y. , & pomarde , d. 2014 , , 513 , 71 vazza , f. , brggen , m. , gheller , c. , & wang , p. 2014 , , 445 , 3706 west , m. j. , & blakeslee , j. p. 2000 , , 543 , l27 yoon , h. , chung , a. , sengupta , c. , et al . 2015 , pkas , 30 , 495 yoon , j. h. , putman , m. e. , thom , c. , chen , h .- w . , & bryan , g. l. 2012 , , 754 , 84 note for columns . ( 1 ) name of the structure . ( 2)(4 ) range of the structure in supergalactic coordinates . ( 5 ) range of the structure in radial velocity . ( 6 ) length of the structure in the sgx - sgz plane . ( 7 ) range of the distances relative to the virgo cluster center . ( 8) median value and standard deviation of the peculiar velocities in the virgo - centric reference frame . ( 9 ) median value and standard deviation of the distances from the milky way . ( 10)(11 ) number of total and faint ( m@xmath1019 ) galaxies . ( 12)(13 ) number of total and faint ( m@xmath1019 ) galaxies in tully ( 1982 ) .

we revisit the filamentary structures of galaxies around the virgo cluster , exploiting a larger dataset based on the hyperleda database than previous studies . in particular , this includes a large number of low - luminosity galaxies , resulting in better sampled individual structures . we confirm seven known structures in the distance range 4 @xmath0 mpc @xmath1 sgy @xmath1 16 @xmath0 mpc , now identified as filaments , where sgy is the axis of the supergalactic coordinate system roughly along the line of sight . the hubble diagram of the filament galaxies suggests they are infalling toward the main - body of the virgo cluster . we propose that the collinear distribution of giant elliptical galaxies along the fundamental axis of the virgo cluster is smoothly connected to two of these filaments ( leo ii a and b ) . behind the virgo cluster ( 16 @xmath0 mpc @xmath1 sgy @xmath1 27 @xmath0 mpc ) , we also identify a new filament elongated toward the ngc 5353/4 group ( `` ngc 5353/4 filament '' ) and confirm a sheet that includes galaxies from the w and m clouds of the virgo cluster ( `` w - m sheet '' ) . in the hubble diagram , the ngc 5353/4 filament galaxies show infall toward the ngc 5353/4 group , whereas the w - m sheet galaxies do not show hints of gravitational influence from the virgo cluster . the filamentary structures identified can now be used to better understand the generic role of filaments in the build - up of galaxy clusters at z @xmath2 0 .

astro-ph0108425

the taurus tunable filter ( ttf ) instruments @xcite@xcite at the anglo - australian ( aat ) and william herschel telescopes ( wht ) have seen use in many key areas of astrophysics . low - redshift science has included studies of brown dwarf atmospheric variability and the identification of optical counterparts to galactic x - ray sources . at high - redshifts , science has been driven by measurement of the cosmic star - formation history , identification of galaxy clustering around high - redshift qsos , deep imaging of jet - cloud interactions in powerful radio galaxies , and the detection of a large ionized nebula around a nearby qso . this paper describes the characteristics of these instruments and the future role they could play at the vlt . a tunable filter @xcite is a special type of fabry - perot interferometer incorporating three features that traditional astronomical fabry - perot instruments lack . a tunable filter : ( 1 ) can move its parallel glass plates over a large range , ( 2 ) has anti - reflection coatings optimised over a broad range of wavelengths , and , ( 3 ) operates at much narrower plate spacings than traditional devices . these characteristics mean that tunable filters operate at lower resolving powers ( @xmath0 to 1000 ) than traditional instruments . the first taurus tunable filter ( ttf ; @xcite@xcite ) was introduced at the anglo - australian observatory ( aao ) in early 1996 by j. bland - hawthorn . this red device operates in the range 6500 9500 at the aforementioned resolving powers , thereby giving an adjustable passband width of 6 to 65 . two years later a second fabry - perot coated for 3700 6500 gave the potential for tunable imaging across the full optical range . since the fabry - perot is an interference device , many orders of interference are present simultaneously . therefore , one needs to use a blocking filter to remove light from all but the one order of interest . there are a dozen different @xmath1 300 - wide blocking filters used with ttf . more details on the ttf instruments can be found at the aao s ttf home page ( http://www.aao.gov.au/ttf/ ) . ttf is used in a cassegrain - mounted focal reducer ( taurus-2 ) , which consists of a simple camera - collimator arrangement with a straight - through optical path . the optical train of taurus-2 has aperture and focal plane filter wheels at the telescope focus , then the collimator , two further wheels in the parallel beam for the fabry - perot and pupil plane masks , the camera and finally the detector . the design of taurus-2 is very similar to that of the fors instruments on the vlt . there are identical copies of taurus-2 at both the aat and wht , although taurus-2 is no longer offered at the wht . taurus-2 at the aat has been scheduled with tunable filters in continuous semesters since 1996 . tuning is achieved through controlled changes to the separation between the glass plates : initial wavelength and bandpass selection is made by making a large adjustment ; subsequent scanning is done through much smaller changes ( fig . [ tuning ] ) . the plates are moved and stabilised by electronics attached to the outside of the focal reducer . a further development at the aao was the synchrony of filter tuning with the shuffling of charge on the ccd . the basis of the technique is the use of two or more _ different _ regions of the _ one _ ccd frame to image the sky at different wavelengths . exposure of a particular ccd region / wavelength combination can be made many times before the ccd frame is finally read - out . figure [ chargeshuff ] illustrates the technique . by splicing the multiple exposures of each band , variable conditions during the total imaging time are effectively averaged out . hence , precise differential photometry is possible in conditions when it otherwise would not . of course , a portion of the ccd frame must be sacrificed to allow extra room for the shuffle . however , the coincidental introduction of over - sized @xmath2 k ccds at the aat circumvented this problem . many areas of astrophysics have utilised the tunable filter to undertake a diverse range of science . these projects point the way toward the science possible with a tunable filter on an 8 m - class telescope . the following is a representative ( rather than comprehensive ) list of recent results with the taurus tunable filter ( ttf ) on the two 4-m telescopes . * * extended nebula around a nearby qso . * shopbell , veilleux and bland - hawthorn @xcite obtained deep h@xmath3 imaging of the @xmath4 quasar mr 2251@xmath5178 . this revealed ionised gas over a 200 kpc region around the quasar , suggesting its photoionisation of a surrounding hi gas envelope as the cause of the emission , rather than a merger event or interaction . * * field populations of star - forming galaxies . * the scanning ability of ttf was used by jones and bland - hawthorn @xcite to search for the emission - line signatures of star - forming galaxies at @xmath6 . this narrowband selection found excess numbers of line - emitters over those from traditional broadband - selected redshift surveys , implying higher star - formation densities over these redshifts . figure [ examplegalaxies ] shows two ttf - selected galaxies from this survey . * * searching for weather in brown dwarfs . * tinney and tolley @xcite used charge - shuffled time - series imaging of brown dwarfs in two passbands sensitive to variations in effective temperature . variability was found in one of the two stars surveyed , over observations spanning one - third of its rotation period , indicative of surface features . * * high - redshift gravitationally lensed galaxies . * hewett and collaborators @xcite have used the tunable filter to search for gravitationally lensed galaxies at @xmath7 . giant , bulge - dominated @xmath8 ellipticals are identified as potential lenses through anomalous emission - lines in 2df galaxy redshift survey spectra . ttf is tuned to the line to see if a @xmath7 galaxy ( being lensed by the elliptical ) is responsible for the emission . * * time series photometry of a stellar x - ray source . * time - series photometry of the x - ray star v2116 ophiuchi was undertaken by deutsch , margon and bland - hawthorn @xcite . the tunable filter was tuned to the prominent oi @xmath9 line in this object , thought to pulse in - phase with the x - ray source . these observations ruled - out any such variability . * * galaxy clustering around high - redshift qsos . * baker and collaborators @xcite tuned ttf to the @xmath10 quasar mrc b0450@xmath5221 to search for nearby clustering galaxies . nine galaxies were found with emission - lines matching [ oii ] at the redshift of the qso . of the five accessible for spectroscopic follow - up , three were positively identified with [ oii ] and another with a possible line detection . * * warm ionised gas around nearby radio galaxies . * ttf was used on the wht by tadhunter and collaborators @xcite for h@xmath3 imaging of two radio - galaxies at @xmath11 and 0.09 . faint emission - line structures were found beyond the radio axes , in addition to the usual bright structures along the radio jets . other tunable filter projects currently in progress include imaging of filamentary structures in edge - on spiral galaxies , star - formation regions in nearby elliptical galaxies , h@xmath12 imaging in face - on spirals and h@xmath3 imaging of nearby galaxy cluster cooling flows . it is likely that such scientific diversity would continue for a tunable filter at the vlt . there is currently no tunable filter capability on vlt nor on any 8 10 m - class telescopes elsewhere . however , the osiris instrument @xcite planned for the 10 m grantecan telescope will have tunable imaging , as will the soar telescope currently under construction in chile @xcite . tunable filters are commercially available from queensgate instruments in several sizes , along with the associated control electronics . while a detailed technical assessment is yet to be done , an informal study has shown that a 116 mm tunable filter can be accommodated in fors-2 if the upper of the two grism wheels were removed @xcite . the full spectroscopic capability of fors-2 is preserved , although more frequent grism changes are required . in such a case , the echelle mode would be lost from fors-2 but could be incorporated into fors-1 instead . most importantly , no major hardware modifications are required and the control electronics come from queensgate . software would need to be upgraded to include control of the instrument , to maximise observing and calibration efficiency . more discussion of the various options available can be found in @xcite . a tunable filter on the vlt would have the ability to tune _ between _ the brightest oh night - sky lines . moreover , the narrow bandpass would increase the usefulness of fors during bright - time . as a 3-d survey instrument , a tunable filter would complement the multi - object spectroscopic capabilities of the fors instruments well . tunable filters avoid the problems of sky subtraction experienced with other 3-d devices such as ifus . furthermore , none of the special reduction techniques used for kinematic fabry - perot data are required for tunable filter data because of the much lower spectral resolutions utilised . tunable filters have been used for many extragalactic and galactic stellar programmes at the aat and wht over recent years . the ability to synchronise charge - shuffling with tuning of the filter has allowed precise differential imaging to be undertaken by some of these programmes , even in variable conditions . implementing a tunable filter at the vlt in fors appears technically feasible . the primary operational change would be more frequent grism installations to maintain all the spectroscopic modes currently available . j. cepa , m. aguiar , v.g . escalera , i. gonzalez - serrano , e. joven , l. peraza , j.l . rasilla , l.f . rodriguez , j.j . gonzalez , f.j . cobos , b. sanchez , c. tejada , j. bland - hawthorn , c. militello , f. rosa . in : _ optical and ir telescope instrumentation and detectors , proc spie 4008 _ , ed . by m. iye and a.f.m . moorwood , ( spie : washington , 2000 ) , pp . 623 p.c . hewett , s.j . warren , j.p . willis , j. bland - hawthorn , g.f . lewis . in : _ imaging the universe in three dimensions , asp conference series 195 _ , ed . by w. van breugel and j. bland - hawthorn , ( asp : san francisco , 2000 ) , pp .

tunable imaging filters have been used for a variety of science programmes on the anglo - australian and william herschel telescopes during the last five years . this contribution describes these novel devices and reviews the science ( both galactic and extragalactic ) done with them . possible strategies for implementing a tunable filter at the vlt are also discussed . significant scientific potential exists for a tunable filter on the vlt , particularly in the years before such capability becomes available on 8 10 m - class telescopes elsewhere .

quant-ph0109014

real quantum systems are always coupled to environments . research in the last two or three decades has shown that system environment interactions greatly affect quantal coherences in the system . open - system dynamics can often be described by a master equation for the reduced density matrix of the system . the full hamiltonian is written as the sum of system - only , environment - only and system environment interaction terms . the master equation for the system then depends on the system - only hamiltonian plus other terms derived from the fundamental system environment couplings . these additional pieces induce an effective non - unitary evolution for the system that can , for example , lead to an apparent loss of quantal coherence . in many studies , the system - only hamiltonian is taken to be the sum of one - body terms . an example of relevance to this paper arises for a system of @xmath0 particles , each in a one - dimensional symmetric double well . the system hamiltonian @xmath1 describes particle @xmath2 oscillating with frequency @xmath3 between the left and right sides of its well independently of the other particles in the system . when system environment coupling is added , this behaviour can be drastically modified , with the quantum zeno @xcite or freezing phenomenon being the most extreme example . the purpose of this paper is to contribute to a study of closed and open quantum system evolution that goes beyond one - body system hamiltonians by including interaction terms between the system particles . this is a vast and extremely rich field of enquiry , with many possible lines of development . for reasons to be explained below we will focus on two topics . the first is entanglement creation through adiabatic evolution and its degradation due to environmental influences . the second is quantum information error protection through adiabatic evolution . common to both topics is the use of adiabatic avoided level crossing dynamics . this special case of quantum mechanical time evolution has applications in diverse areas of physics , from the mikheyev - smirnov - wolfenstein effect for neutrino oscillations @xcite to quantum computation @xcite . we use it here because it allows non - trivial dynamics to occur while retaining both an element of theoretical simplicity plus visualisability with the aid of level crossing diagrams . whenever one has more than a single particle in one s quantum system , entanglement adds spice to the analysis . entangled states are a unique feature of quantum mechanics , first studied in connection with the issue of non - locality @xcite . they are also of critical importance in discussions of decoherence , measurement and the quantum - to - classical transition @xcite . more recently , entanglement has emerged as a useful resource in the field of quantum information theory , enabling processes such as quantum cryptography @xcite and teleportation @xcite . the production and manipulation of entangled states is a key element in any realisation of a quantum computer @xcite . as our first topic , we describe an efficient method for the preparation of entangled states which utilises the level crossing structure of the system s energy eigenstates . specifically , we discuss the bell states in the case of a bipartite system , @xmath4 states in a tripartite system and generalised @xmath5 states in multi - partite systems . we then subject the evolving systems to environmental interactions that affect the entanglement production process . we show that the outcome depends on the form of system - environment coupling : entanglement degradation is the generic effect , but the special case of `` motional narrowing '' noise actually leads to zero degradation . calculations presented in ref.@xcite simply took initial bell states and computed the evolution of entanglement in the presence of environmental noise . the present work is a natural extension of this . as a separate but related topic , we show that a method of error protection using entangled states emerges from a variation of the above procedure . we devise a scheme to protect the information encoded in a single qubit from bitflip and phaseflip errors . our goal is to construct a master equation which seamlessly joins the dynamics of qubit encoding , error protection and decoding to the environment - coupling influences responsible for error generation . while the outcome of the open system evolution can be dissected into these quantum information theoretic subprocesses , the actual dynamics is simply what you get when you solve a certain master equation . the building block for our multi - partite systems is the two - state system of a particle in a one - dimensional double well , chosen for its generic properties and broad interest ( see ref.@xcite ) . the well is taken to be partitioned by a barrier of height @xmath6 that is large compared to the ground state energy @xmath7 . ( the two lowest energy levels will be collectively called the `` ground state '' . for a symmetric well with @xmath8 they are nearly degenerate . ) adopting quantum information theoretic parlance , we denote by `` qubits '' the states occupying the two - dimensional hilbert space spanned by the left and right sides of the well ( in the ground state ) . the left and right eigenstates , denoted @xmath9 and @xmath10 , correspond to the @xmath11 and @xmath12 eigenvalues of @xmath13 , respectively . for an isolated well , the hamiltonian has the form @xmath14 where the energy splitting @xmath15 is essentially a tunneling rate between the two sides of the well , and the parameter @xmath16 is the well bias . we begin with a bipartite two - state system , the simplest system in which one may discuss entanglement . our aim here is to produce one of the bell states , @xmath17 dynamically from certain initially factorisable states . let us denote the two - particle ( reduced ) density matrix of qubits 1 and 2 as @xmath18 and consider a hamiltonian of the form presented in eq . ( [ 1ham ] ) for each of the two qubits , together with a third term which couples them : @xmath19 \otimes { \:\mbox{\sf 1 } \hspace{-0.37em } \mbox{\sf 1}\,}+ { \:\mbox{\sf 1 } \hspace{-0.37em } \mbox{\sf 1}\,}\otimes \left [ \omega \sigma_{x2 } + f(t ) \sigma_{z2 } \right ] + \lambda \sigma_{z1 } \otimes \sigma_{z2}. \label{2ham}\ ] ] observe that the hamiltonian is invariant under the interchange of the two qubits . for simplicity , only the well biases @xmath16 are allowed to vary with time , and we demand that @xmath20 . this last condition is necessary in order for the desired level crossing structure to arise . ( it is implicitly assumed that only the lowest states in each well are populated . we will need to relax this condition later on when we couple the system to a hot bath . ) the four eigenstates separate into an antisymmetric singlet state @xmath21 for all values of @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath22 , and a symmetric triplet composed of linear superpositions of the set @xmath23 , which asymptotes to @xmath24 for large @xmath25 s . note that the permutation symmetry of the hamiltonian ensures that the evolution of the singlet state is disconnected from that of the triplet states at all times so we are dealing with an effectively three - state system . in fig . [ 2qubit ] , we plot the energy level diagram as a function of @xmath16 . the states @xmath26 and @xmath27 experience avoided level crossings with @xmath28 at @xmath29 and @xmath30 respectively , labelled points @xmath31 and @xmath32 in fig . [ 2qubit ] . hence , an initial state @xmath33 created at @xmath34 will continue to reside in the lowest energy eigenstate provided that @xmath16 varies sufficiently slowly with time , and be adiabatically transformed , across point @xmath31 , to the entangled state @xmath35 where @xmath36 corresponds to any point in the period of time during which @xmath16 lies in the range @xmath37 . further adiabatic evolution beyond point @xmath32 will turn @xmath38 once more into a factorisable state @xmath39 . note in eq.([marshmallow ] ) that the entangled state @xmath40 inevitably contains some order @xmath41 $ ] `` contamination '' from the states @xmath42 and @xmath39 , which can not be arbitrarily minimised without jeopardising the adiabaticity of the transitions at points @xmath31 and @xmath32 ( see later ) . figure [ ent ] illustrates the evolution of the entanglement for @xmath38 , and we remind the reader again that the bell state @xmath21 can not be generated in this manner because of symmetry requirements . in this figure , the degree of entanglement is defined to be the _ entropy of entanglement _ @xmath43 which is the von neumann entropy of the reduced density matrix obtained by tracing out either of the two qubits @xcite , @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the density matrix obtained after tracing out particle 2 ( 1 ) . the related concept , _ entanglement of formation _ @xmath46 , to be used below , is a generalisation of the entropy of entanglement for a _ mixed _ state of two qubits @xcite . the entanglement will stay approximately constant at @xmath47 when @xmath16 is in the range @xmath37 . note that if the two qubits had different oscillations frequences , @xmath48 , mixing between the almost degenerate states @xmath49 is not prohibited by permutation symmetry ( or the lack thereof ) . in this case , the degree of entanglement will vary significantly in the period @xmath37 , attaining the maximal value of @xmath47 only at the point @xmath50 . observe that if we had started instead in the state @xmath27 which is approximately the highest energy eigenstate , we could in principle obtain the entangled state @xmath51 at the point @xmath50 . however , an inspection of the hamiltonian @xmath52 rewritten in the symmetrised basis @xmath53 , shows that the splitting between the relevant energy eigenstates for the @xmath54 transition at @xmath50 is of order @xmath55 , as opposed to @xmath56 for the @xmath57 transition considered earlier . it follows that the resonance width at point @xmath58 is necessarily some @xmath59 times narrower than those at points @xmath31 and @xmath32 . their respective adiabaticity parameters , defined as @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the splitting between the energy eigenstates , `` res '' denotes evaluated at resonance , and @xmath62 indicates an adiabatic process , must also differ correspondingly by some factor of @xmath63 . explicitly , @xmath64 characterise the three resonances . hence , in order to manufacture the state @xmath51 , a slowly varying @xmath16 together with control over its accuracy to within @xmath65 are necessary . navely , the severity of the precision requirement seems easily alleviated by enlarging @xmath15 . the benefit of a wider resonance width , however , is compensated for by a concomitant increase in the contamination from the @xmath28 state which contributes at order @xmath59 . by comparison , the production of @xmath28 from @xmath42 requires only that we stop the evolution somewhere between @xmath66 , and is therefore a much simpler task . in the presence of environmentally - induced noise , we must solve a master equation for the reduced density matrix of the system . the form of the master equation depends on whether or not the environment is hot enough to induce transitions to excited states of the double wells . we first consider coupling to a cold environment , so that each particle remains in the ground state of its double well . the evolution of @xmath67 is governed by @xmath68 -\gamma_{\text{relax}}[\zeta , [ \zeta , \rho ] ] -\gamma_{\text{relax}}[\zeta ' , [ \zeta ' , \rho]],\ ] ] where @xmath69 and @xmath70 are hermitian matrices obtained from the system - environment interaction hamiltonian . for the sake of the example , we will choose @xmath71 , @xmath72 , which means that the relaxation terms arise from a system bath interaction that couples to the left states @xmath73 but not to the right states @xmath74 . and @xmath70 are proportional to the identity , and the double - commutator terms vanish . we will return to this point shortly . ] commencing with a pure state @xmath42 and a small relaxation rate @xmath75 , we show in fig . [ noise ] the evolution of the entanglement with the course of time . a `` decay '' in @xmath43 in the period @xmath66 is evident . for a sufficiently large @xmath75 , the density matrix simply becomes proportional to the unit matrix , and the entanglement goes to zero at all times . we now consider coupling to an environment hot enough that the system - bath interactions will cause particles in the wells to populate states higher than the ground state . in a previous publication we considered in detail the effects of noise coming from a thermal bath coupled to the full excited state spectrum of a double well @xcite . among the cases considered was the effect of `` side - blind '' noise on a number of properties of the system . for the side - blind case , the bath couples _ equally _ to the left states @xmath76 and the right states @xmath77 . if we begin with a single particle on the left in the ground state of the symmetrical well , the thermal excitation of states that have very different r - l oscillation frequencies replaces with a multiperiodic tangle the previous simple oscillation of the probability of finding the particle on the left at a later time . the effect of a small system - bath interaction rate is to gradually damp these oscillations , leaving a time independent 50% occupancy on either side . as the ratio of the system - bath interaction rate to the oscillation rate is increased , however , the motion becomes more organized , and in the limiting case where this ratio becomes very large , limit " arises when the time between successive system - bath interactions is much smaller than the period of the l - r precession . observe that this condition can actually be fulfilled for _ any _ value of the coupling ( and importantly , for a coupling sufficiently weak that one may treat it perturbatively in the derivation of the master equation ) by making the free precession period sufficiently large . in the context of a double well oscillator this is achieved very easily , simply by adjusting the central barrier between the wells . also note that this large @xmath78 limit " is identical to the limit where one obtains the familiar quantum zeno effect , if the coupling to the environment is through a @xmath79 operator rather than the identity . ] we retrieve sinusoidal oscillation with a frequency that is given by the thermal average of the frequencies of the individual levels @xcite . the analogous phenomenon is called motional narrowing " in nmr studies . we will now look at entanglement - formation dynamics in a two - particle system with excited states . the l - r oscillation properties for a particular well - level are given by eq . ( [ asnoise ] ) , but the oscillation parameters are different for the excited well states . we shall refer to the variable distinguishing these states as the `` vertical '' variable , as opposed to the @xmath80 degree of freedom which we will term the `` horizontal '' variable . we will take the coupling among the vertical levels to again be `` side - blind '' , that is , not dependent on the horizontal variables , because that is the most interesting case . we can capture the essential features of the problem by considering only two vertical levels , with equal transition rates , @xmath78 , each to the other ( the latter as in the case of a high temperature for the thermal bath ) , in which case we make the replacements in eq.([asnoise ] ) , @xmath81 , @xmath82 on the lefthand side and @xmath83\rightarrow \gamma \bigr ( \sum_j\rho(e_j , t)-2\rho(e_i , t ) \bigr)\ ] ] on the righthand side , as well as specifying , within @xmath84 , different oscillation parameters for the two energy states . using this equation we now look at the results for the two particle - entanglement for the cases of zero , moderate , and large system - bath interaction rates . the results are shown in fig . 4 . we see substantial degradation of entanglement - formation in the case of moderate interaction rate . but in the case of large interaction rate , we see a pattern of entanglement creation that is similar to that in the case with no noise . in this limit , the system is made to change vertical state so rapidly that it can only respond to an average hamiltonian , with quantal coherence fully maintained @xcite . for these reasons , the entanglement - formation dynamics succeeds in this limit . for completeness , we mention that if the bath does not couple with equal strength to the two horizontal states @xmath77 and @xmath76 , the behaviour is qualitatively the same as that obtained from eq . ( [ asnoise ] ) for the cold bath , where @xmath85 . consider now the @xmath4 states , @xmath86 these may be considered maximally entangled 3-qubit states , in the sense that each has the maximum amount of bipartite entanglement if any one of the three qubits is traced out @xcite . it turns out that the production of a three - qubit @xmath4 state from an initially factorisable state such as @xmath87 via adiabatic transitions is completely analogous to the generation of the symmetric bell state from @xmath42 considered previously . we now elaborate on this point . the hamiltonian for our three - qubit system is a direct generalisation of that in eq . ( [ 2ham ] ) : @xmath88 + f(t)\left[\sigma_{z1 } + \sigma_{z1 } + \sigma_{z3 } \right ] + \lambda \left [ \sigma_{z1}\sigma_{z2 } + \sigma_{z2}\sigma_{z3 } + \sigma_{z3}\sigma_{z1 } \right ] , \label{3ham}\ ] ] where , for simplicity , we are dealing explicitly with the permutation invariant case . decomposition of the tensor product @xmath89 reveals that the permutation symmetric set @xmath90 can be treated in isolation , with its evolution governed by the @xmath91 block in the hamiltonian @xmath92 written in the symmetrised basis . the level crossing diagram for this set of states is plotted in fig.[3qubit ] . three resonances mark the evolution of the lowest energy eigenstate from @xmath93 to @xmath94 . to zeroeth order in @xmath15 , the identity of the state is adiabatically transformed as per the evolutionary sequence @xmath95 where the conditions above the arrows denote the points at which the transitions take place . commencing with the product state @xmath87 at @xmath93 , the two @xmath4 states can be easily obtained respectively in the domains @xmath96 and @xmath97 . note in passing that the state @xmath98 @xcite coincides approximately with an eigenstate at @xmath50 and can in principle be accessed from @xmath99 or @xmath87 via the highest energy eigenstate . however , as a direct analogue of the @xmath100 state considered in the previous section , the production of the ghz state by our method suffers the same problem of non - adiabaticity and again requires precise control over the value of @xmath16 . the generalised form of the @xmath4 state for @xmath0 qubits is defined as @xmath101 where @xmath102 denotes the totally symmetric state with @xmath103 qubits in the state @xmath104 and one qubit in the state @xmath105 . the residual bipartite entanglement between any two pairs of qubits , upon tracing the other qubits out , has been shown to have the maximum value attainable in an @xmath0 qubit system @xcite . since @xmath106 states are symmetric with respect to permutation of the @xmath0 qubits , they can always be made from @xmath107 or @xmath108 in the manner discussed above . an important problem in the study of quantum information theory is the protection of information from various types of errors . any practical realisation of a quantum computer will see the physical systems , the states of which comprise the qubits , experience effective violation of unitary evolution and error generation , both due to coupling to their environment . a number of error detection and protection schemes have been devised that encode a given qubit through entanglement with other otherwise redundant qubits @xcite @xcite . our goal in this section is to construct a master equation that seamlessly merges error generation , protection through entanglement and detection within a single dynamical framework . while the resulting evolution can be usefully understood through reduction to information theoretic subprocesses , at the level of pure physics the single equation that one solves encapsulates both the quantum processes over which the experimenter has no control , and the knobs the experimentalist turns to change the biases . in what follows , averted level crossing schemes similar to those described in the previous section are used to encode a qubit in a way that it is protected from certain outside disturbances , following the steps : 1 . we consider an initial pure state given by @xmath109 |1\rangle $ ] . our goal is to preserve the information encoded in the first qubit . we take a noise term that is derived from an external bath that flips qubits , independently , for one or both particles , and we follow the density matrix for the resulting mixed state . we transform the state in the time interval @xmath110 to @xmath111 by adiabatically changing the coefficients of certain terms in the hamiltonian ; we refer to these functions as the bias functions . next we leave the system in this state for a length of time @xmath112 ( `` hang time '' ) _ long _ compared to @xmath113 . 4 . to reclaim the initial state we adiabatically restore the biases to their initial values and then measure the value of the second , control , coordinate . if the measurement gives back the original state @xmath76 , then for the first qubit we obtain the state that is the projection of our evolved density matrix on that state . the coding algorithm is such that this operation reclaims the density matrix of the initial pure state , with small degradations coming from the small non - adiabaticity due to doing the encoding and decoding over finite time intervals , or with degradations from letting the hang time be so large that multiple errors are likely to have accumulated . if , on the other hand , we measure the value @xmath77 for the control state , then , beginning from the projection of our evolved density matrix on the state @xmath114 a simple , and implementable unitary operation restores the initial density matrix . we begin this process by describing the system in terms of the four time dependent instantaneous eigenstates of the hamiltonian that describes the system without noise , @xmath115 , where @xmath116 . defining , @xmath117 , we take initial values , @xmath118 the initial data is to be encoded in a combination of @xmath119 , and @xmath120 . we define a time dependent projection operator on the subspace used for encoding , @xmath121 we note that @xmath122 , the projection operator on the value unity for the second qubit . we choose the hamiltonian @xmath123\ , \sigma_{z } \otimes { \:\mbox{\sf 1 } \hspace{-0.37em } \mbox{\sf 1}\ , } , \label{newham}\ ] ] where @xmath124 is a function that begins at zero at @xmath110 , rises to unity at @xmath111 , remains unity until @xmath125 , and then decreases back to zero at @xmath126 . at @xmath110 , the eigenstates of @xmath84 are the vectors shown in eq.([initiales ] ) . we define @xmath127 to be the time evolution operator for the interval @xmath110 to @xmath111 , under the action of this hamiltonian . if the encoding time is chosen sufficiently large that the evolution is adiabatic , then for our encoding states we have , @xmath128 where the phases @xmath129 and @xmath130 are irrelevant to the remainder of the discussion . these remain eigenstates until @xmath125 . we will show that this dynamics protects against `` bit - flip '' errors defined by choosing the coefficients @xmath69 , @xmath70 , etc . in an equation like [ asnoise ] to be from the list of error operators @xmath131 and @xmath132 , plus `` phase errors '' induced by @xmath133 and @xmath134 . ( it is easy to modify the scheme to protect against all four bit - flip errors @xmath135 and @xmath136 , but at the cost of losing the phase error protection . ) the key to this protection is that the any error operator @xmath69 , picked from the above set has all matrix elements equal to zero in the subspace spanned by @xmath137 and @xmath138 . and @xmath139 . ] we can express this property using the projection operator , @xmath140 , @xmath141+[1-p_e(t)]\zeta \,p_e(t)+[1-p_e(t)]\zeta [ 1-p_e(t ) ] \label{proj2}\ ] ] which holds throughout the time interval @xmath142 , noting that @xmath140 is independent of time during this interval . in what follows , for clarity of exposition , we shall leave the noise turned off during the short encoding - decoding times ; however in the numerical example presented later , we retain the noise throughout the process . we begin with a density matrix , @xmath143 \left [ a^ * \langle \xi_1| _ 0 + b^ * \langle \xi_2|_0\right],\ ] ] and let it evolve in a unitary fashion to @xmath111 , @xmath144 \left [ a^ * \langle \xi_1|_{t_e } + b^ * \langle \xi_2|_{t_e}\right ] + \text{n.a.}\ ] ] where `` n.a . '' stands for small terms coming from non - adiabaticity , which can induce hopping into the @xmath145 and @xmath146 states . between @xmath111 and @xmath125 the time evolution is governed by the equation , @xmath147 -\gamma [ \zeta\ , , \ , [ \zeta\ , , \ , \rho(t ) ] ] = -i [ h(t_e),\rho(t ) ] -\gamma \left\{\rho(t ) - \zeta \rho(t ) \zeta \right\ } , \label{withnoise}\ ] ] where the noise term is of the same form as given in eq . ( [ asnoise ] ) , the constant @xmath78 sets the level of the noise , and @xmath69 is one of the error matrices enumerated above , with @xmath148 . we shall be concerned with the changes to the density matrix that are first order in @xmath78 . however we note that if we omit the last term in eq.([withnoise ] ) , the solution , @xmath149 , would be just a damped form of the solution without noise , which is just the evolution under the hamiltonian , @xmath150 , constant in the interval @xmath151 , @xmath152\ , u^{-1}\ , \rho(0)\ , u\ , \exp[i h(t_e ) t]\ , p_e(t_e ) \ , \exp[-\gamma \ , t ] . \label{damped}\ ] ] the right and left projection operators are unnecessary here , since nothing has evicted us from the encoding subspace , but they are useful for the next step . for the effects on @xmath153 of the @xmath69 dependent term in eq.([withnoise ] ) , which we denote as @xmath154 , we can calculate the change in @xmath153 to first order in @xmath78 by direct time integration after inserting the ( @xmath155 ) form of @xmath156 from eq.([damped ] ) into the last term on the rhs of eq.([withnoise ] ) . for our purposes all we need to know about this term comes from the projection operator structures in eq.([proj2 ] ) and eq.([damped ] ) which directly give , @xmath157\ , \rho_a \ , [ 1 - p_e(t_e+t_h ) ] + o(\gamma^2 ) \label{afternoise}\ ] ] where @xmath158 is the result of the time integral discussed above . the total correction is given by @xmath159 . next we decode , by adiabatically changing the parameters back to their values at @xmath160 . this is a unitary process implemented by the time evolution operator @xmath161 for the interval @xmath162 to @xmath163 . we note that @xmath164 , since the unitary evolution processes never cause a transition from one of the states @xmath165 to another in the adiabatic limit , and the relative phase factors from the time evolution cancel in the construction of the projection operators . thus we obtain , @xmath166 in the @xmath167 , @xmath168 subspace the unitary matrix @xmath169 is diagonal . thus if we measure the second ( control ) variable and obtain unity ( or no change from the initial value ) there can have been no bitflip in the state of the first ( information ) state . then , if we wish we can fine - tune the hang time , @xmath112 , so that @xmath169 in the @xmath170 , @xmath171 subspace is a phase factor times the unit matrix . in this case we have recaptured the initial state of the information bit perfectly , using implementable transformations that are independent of the information itself . the above process can be characterized as being a limited error correction , in that we have corrected the errors that could have been created in the part of the final density matrix in which the value of the control bit is unity . in the case that the measurement of the control bit gives zero ( this probability is itself of order @xmath172 ) , then we can work out the explicit form for the second term on the righthand side of eq . ( [ finalrho ] ) , and find a unitary operation that converts it to a multiple of the initial density matrix . this operation depends on which of the four error operators is used for the matrix @xmath69 . thus if we extended eq . ( [ withnoise ] ) to include several error terms at once , then , since we would not know which was operative in a given case , we could not implement the correction . corrections of all of the error operators require encoding protocols involving more qubits , as discussed in ref . @xcite , and in much subsequent literature . however , if we had replaced the double - commutator on the righthand side of eq . ( [ withnoise ] ) by a sum of terms , one for each of our protectable error operators , the solution would still have the useful property of error detection . in this case we can view the result in eq . ( [ finalrho ] ) as preservation for the part where the control bit is unity , and with error detection in the cases in which measurement of the control bit gives zero . when we measure zero for the control bit , we must discard the information in the channel . but even a single redundant parallel channel with the same input data would reduce the probability of information loss to the level of order @xmath173 . since the latter is the essential level of error for the case in which measurement of the control bit gives unity , this is the best result obtainable using our kind of mechanism . in our numerical example , we simply solve eq . ( [ withnoise ] ) for the density matrix evolution in the presence of noise , beginning at time @xmath110 and ending at time @xmath126 , without breaking into the separate factors of the discussion above . this then includes every piece of eq . ( [ finalrho ] ) , but with the additional corrections due to : a ) small non - adiabaticity ( hopping ) due to the fact that time taken by the encoding process is not infinite . b ) errors that occur from the noise interaction during encoding - decoding , due to the fact that the encoding is not instantaneous . c ) the terms of higher order in @xmath172 , which matter when the probability of more than one error during the time @xmath112 becomes appreciable . for our example , we choose the initial state for the information bit to be simply @xmath76 . figure [ error ] shows the probability of a bit flip error arising from an error operator @xmath174 plotted as a function of the average number of applications of the error , @xmath172 , and on the same plot the results for the case in which the information is not encoded . we have also checked numerically to see that in cases in which we begin with a superposition of @xmath76 and @xmath77 for the information bit , and fine tune @xmath175 to an appropriate value , the entire state , including the relative phase angle in the superposition , is preserved to the same degree as the bit - error values plotted in fig . [ error ] . we have considered two related topics in the study of closed and open quantum system evolution that go beyond one - body system hamiltonians by including interaction terms between the system particles . in the first topic , we have shown that entangled states that are symmetric under the permutation of the basis states can be generated via adiabatic transitions from initially factorisable states which have this symmetry . in a two - qubit system , the outcome is the symmetrical bell state @xmath176 , while the three - qubit analogue is the set of two @xmath4 states . noise in moderate quantitites generally reduces entanglement over time , and for such cases the limit of large noise sees entanglement remaining zero at all times . however , for the special case of `` side - blind '' noise that leads to motional narrowing , the creation of entanglement is preserved despite a large system - environment interaction rate . in our second topic , we have shown that for small noise levels , we can use an entangling - pause - unentangling cycle to store and recover quantum data in a two qubit system , with error probability quadratic rather than linear in the parameter @xmath177 where @xmath78 is the error rate for unencoded data and @xmath36 is the time elapsed . calculations of encoding that utilise the entanglement give a concrete demonstration of the compatibility of two requirements on the encoding time : a ) that it be long enough achieve adiabaticity ; b ) that it be short enough to limit the effects of noise during the encoding process . b. misra and e. c. g. sudarshan , j. math * 18 * , 756 ( 1977 ) ; r. a. harris and l. stodolsky , phys 116b * , 464 ( 1982 ) ; p. facchi , v. gorini , g. marmo , s. pascazio , and e. c. g. sudarshan , phys . a275 * , 12 ( 2000 ) and references therein . l. wolfenstein , phys . d * 17 * , 2369 ( 1978 ) ; _ ibid . _ d * 20 * 2634 ( 1979 ) ; s. p. mikheyev and a. yu . smirnov , nuovo cimento c*9 * , 17 ( 1986 ) . for a review see e.g. t. k. kuo and j.pantaleone , rev . mod.phys . * 61 * , 937 ( 1989 ) .

we consider the environment - affected dynamics of @xmath0 self - interacting particles living in one - dimensional double wells . two topics are dealt with . first , we consider the production of entangled states of two - level systems . we show that by adiabatically varying the well biases we may dynamically generate maximally entangled states , starting from initially unentangled product states . entanglement degradation due to a common type of environmental influence is then computed by solving a master equation . however , we also demonstrate that entanglement production is unaffected if the system - environment coupling is of the type that induces `` motional narrowing '' . as our second but related topic , we construct a different master equation that seamlessly merges error protection / detection dynamics for quantum information with the environmental couplings responsible for producing the errors in the first place . adiabatic avoided crossing schemes are used in both topics .

1212.5615

the linear failure rate distribution with parameters @xmath1 and @xmath2 , ( @xmath3 ) which is denoted by @xmath4 , has the cumulative distribution function ( cdf ) @xmath5 and probability density function @xmath6 note that if @xmath7 and @xmath8 , then the lfr distribution is reduced to exponential distribution with parameter @xmath9 ( @xmath10 ) , and if @xmath11 and @xmath12 then we can obtain the rayleigh distribution with parameter @xmath13 ( @xmath14 ) . a basic structural properties of @xmath15 is that it is the distribution of minimum of two independent random variables @xmath16 and @xmath17 having @xmath18 and @xmath14 distributions , respectively ( sen and bhattachrayya , 1995 ) . if @xmath19 denotes the cdf of a random variable then a generalized class of distributions can be defined by @xmath20 for @xmath21 and @xmath22 , where @xmath23 is the incomplete beta function ratio and @xmath24 is the incomplete beta function . many authors considered various forms of @xmath19 and studied their properties : eugene et al . ( 2002 ) ( beta normal distribution ) , nadarajah and kotz ( 2004 ) ( beta gumbel distribution ) , nadarajah and gupta ( 2004 ) and barreto - souza et al . ( 2011 ) ( beta fr@xmath25chet distribution ) , famoye et al . ( 2005 ) , lee et al . ( 2007 ) and cordeiro et al . ( 2008 ) ( beta weibull distribution ) , nadarajah and kotz ( 2006 ) ( beta exponential distribution ) , akinsete et al . ( 2008 ) ( beta pareto distribution ) , silva et al . ( 2010 ) ( beta modified weibull distribution ) , mahmoudi ( 2011 ) ( beta generalized pareto distribution ) , cordeiro et al . ( 2011 ) ( beta - exponentiated weibull distribution ) , cordeiro et al . ( 2011 ) ( beta - weibull geometric distribution ) , singla et al . ( 2012 ) ( beta generalized weibull distribution ) , cordeiro et al . ( 2012 ) ( beta generalized gamma distribution ) and cordeiro et al . ( 2012 ) ( beta generalized normal distribution ) . in this article , we propose a new four parameters distribution , referred to as the blfr distribution , which contains as special sub - models : the beta exponential ( be ) , beta rayleigh ( br ) , generalized linear failure rate ( glfr ) and linear failure rate ( lfr ) distributions , among others . the main reasons for introducing blfr distribution are : ( i ) the additional parameters introduced by the beta generalization is sought as a means to furnish a more flexible distribution . ( ii ) some modeling phenomenon with non - monotone failure rates such as the bathtub - shaped and unimodal failure rates , which are common in reliability and biological studies , take a reasonable parametric fit with this distribution . ( iii ) the blfr distribution is expected to have immediate application in reliability and survival studies . ( iv ) blfr distribution shows better fitting , more flexible in shape and easier to perform and formula for modeling lifetime data . the reminder of the paper is organized as follows : in section 2 , we define the blfr distribution and outline some special cases of the distribution . we investigate some properties of the distribution in this section . some of these properties are the limit behavior and shapes of the pdf and hazard rate function of the blfr distribution . section 3 provides a general expansion for the moments of the blfr distribution . in section 4 , we discuss maximum likelihood estimation and calculate the elements of the observed information matrix . application of the blfr distribution is given in the section 5 . a simulation study is performed in section 6 . finally , section 7 concludes the paper . consider that @xmath26 is the density of the baseline distribution . then the probability density function corresponding to ( [ eq.fb ] ) can be written in the form @xmath27 we now introduce the blfr distribution by taking @xmath28 in ( [ eq.fb ] ) to be the cdf ( [ eq.flfr ] ) of the lfr distribution . hence , the blfr density function can be written as @xmath29 and we use the notation @xmath30 . the hazard rate function of blfr distribution is given by @xmath31 plots of pdf and hazard rate function of the blfr distribution for different values of it s parameters are given in fig . [ fig.den ] and fig . [ fig.hz ] , respectively . 1 . if @xmath32 , then we get the generalized linear failure rate distribution ( @xmath33 ) which is introduced by sarhan and kundu ( 2009 ) . 2 . if @xmath32 and @xmath7 , then we get the generalized exponential distribution ( ge ) ( gupta and kundu , 1999 ) . 3 . if @xmath32 and @xmath11 , then we get two - parameter burr x distribution which is introduced by surles and padgett ( 2005 ) and also is known as generalized rayleigh distribution ( gr ) ( kundu and raqab , 2005 ) . if @xmath34 , then ( 2.2 ) reduces to the linear failure rate distribution ( @xmath35 ) distribution . if @xmath7 , then we get the beta exponential distribution ( @xmath36 ) which is introduced by nadarajah and kotz ( 2006 ) . if @xmath11 , then we get the beta rayleigh distribution ( @xmath37 ) which is defined by akinsete and lowe ( 2009 ) and is a special case of beta weibull distribution ( famoye et al . , 2005 ) . if the random variable @xmath38 _ _ has blfr distribution , then the random variable @xmath39 satisfies the beta distribution with parameters @xmath40 and @xmath41 . therefore , @xmath42 satisfies the beta exponential distribution with parameters 1 , @xmath40 and @xmath41 ( @xmath43 ) . 8 . if @xmath44 and @xmath45 , where @xmath46 and @xmath47 are positive integer values , then the @xmath48 is the density function of @xmath46th order statistic of lfr distribution . the following result helps in simulating data from the blfr distribution : if @xmath49 follows beta distribution with parameters @xmath40 and @xmath41 , then @xmath50 follows blfr distribution with parameters @xmath51 , and @xmath41 . for checking the consistency of the simulating data set form blfr distribution , the histogram for a generated data set with size 100 and the exact blfr density with parameters @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 , and @xmath55 , are displayed in fig [ fig.gd ] ( left ) . also , the empirical distribution function and the exact distribution function is given in fig [ fig.gd ] ( right ) . in this section , limiting behavior of pff and hazard rate function of the blfr distribution and their shapes are studied . * theorem 1 . * let @xmath48 be the pdf of the blfr distribution . the limiting behaviour of @xmath56 for different values of its parameters is given bellow : i. : : if @xmath57 then @xmath58 . ii . : : if @xmath59 then @xmath60 . iii . : : if @xmath61 then @xmath62 . : : @xmath63 . * proof : * the proof of parts ( i)-(iii ) are obvious . for part ( iv ) , we have @xmath64 it can be easily shown that @xmath65 and the proof is completed . * theorem 2 . * let @xmath48 be the density function of the blfr distribution . the mode of @xmath56 is given in the following cases : i. : : if @xmath57 and @xmath67 then @xmath48 has a unique mode in @xmath68 i. : : if @xmath57 and @xmath69 then @xmath48 has a unique mode in @xmath70 . ii . : : if @xmath59 then @xmath48 has at least one mode . * proof : * the proof is obvious and is omitted . * theorem 3 . * let @xmath71 be the hazard rate function of the blfr distribution . consider the following cases : i. : : if @xmath57 and @xmath72 then blfr distribution has an increasing hazard rate function . ii . : : if @xmath73 and @xmath72 then the hazard rate function of the blfr distribution is an increasing . : : if @xmath74 blfr distribution has a decreasing hazard rate function for @xmath75 , and @xmath71 is constant for @xmath76 . : : if @xmath77 and @xmath72 then @xmath71 is a bathtub - shaped . * proof : * \i . if @xmath57 then @xmath78 . therefore @xmath79 which is an increasing and linear function with respect to @xmath80 \ii . consider @xmath81 it implies that @xmath82 for @xmath83 and also , it is increasing with respect to @xmath84 . we have @xmath85 . now , rewriting the blfr density as function of @xmath86 , @xmath87 say , we obtain @xmath88 therefore , we have @xmath89 and we conclude that the hazard function of blfr distribution is increasing . \iii . if @xmath7 then @xmath90 and @xmath91 thus we have @xmath92 where @xmath93 , which implies the decreasing ( increasing ) hazard rate functions in this cases . \iv . it is difficult to determine analytically the regions corresponding to the upside - down bathtub shaped ( unimodal ) and bathtub - shaped hazard rate functions for the blfr distribution . however , by some graphical analysis we can shows : bathtub - shaped hazard rate function correspond to @xmath77 and @xmath72 . the proof is completed . here , we present some representations of cdf , pdf , and the survival function of blfr distribution . the mathematical relation given below will be useful in this section . if @xmath41 is a positive real non - integer and @xmath94 , then @xmath95 and if @xmath41 is a positive real integer , then the upper of the this summation stops at @xmath96 , where @xmath97 \1 . we can express ( [ eq.fb ] ) as a mixture of distribution function of generalized lfr distributions as follows : @xmath98 where @xmath99 and @xmath100 is distribution function of a random variable which has a generalized lfr distribution with parameters @xmath9 , @xmath13 , and @xmath101 . we can express ( [ eq.fblfr ] ) as a mixture of density function of generalized lfr distributions as follows : @xmath102 where @xmath103 is density function of a random variable which has a generalized lfr distribution with parameters @xmath9 , @xmath13 , and @xmath101 . the cdf can be expressed in terms of the hypergeometric function and the incomplete beta function ratio ( see , cordeiro and nadarajah , 2011 ) in the following way : @xmath104 where @xmath105 . the @xmath106th moment of blfr distribution can be expressed as a mixture of the @xmath106th moment of generalized lfr distributions as follows : @xmath107 where @xmath108 is density function of a random variable @xmath109 which has a generalized lfr distribution with parameters @xmath9 , @xmath13 , and @xmath101 . consider @xmath110 is a random sample from blfr distribution . the log - likelihood function for the vector of parameters @xmath111 can be written as @xmath112 where @xmath113 . the log - likelihood can be maximized either directly or by solving the nonlinear likelihood equations obtained by differentiating ( [ eq.like ] ) . the components of the score vector @xmath114 _ _ are given by @xmath115 where @xmath116 is the digamma function . for interval estimation and hypothesis tests on the model parameters , we require the observed information matrix . the @xmath117 unit observed information matrix @xmath118 is obtained as @xmath119.\ ] ] where the expressions for the elements of @xmath120 are @xmath121 @xmath122 where @xmath123 is the trigamma function . under conditions that are fulfilled for parameters in the interior of the parameter space but not on the boundary , asymptotically @xmath124 where @xmath125 _ _ is the expected information matrix . this asymptotic behavior is valid if @xmath125 is replaced by @xmath126 , i.e. , the observed information matrix evaluated at @xmath127 . for constructing tests of hypothesis and confidence region we can use from this result . an asymptotic confidence interval with confidence level @xmath128 for each parameter @xmath129 , @xmath130 , is given by @xmath131 where @xmath132 is the @xmath46th diagonal element of @xmath126 and @xmath133 is the upper @xmath134 point of standard normal distribution . in this section , we provide a data analysis to see how the new model works in practice . this data set is given by aarset ( 1987 ) and consists of times to first failure of fifty devices . the data is given by 0.1 , 0.2 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 2 , 3 , 6 , 7 , 11 , 12 , 18 , 18 , 18 , 18 , 18 , 21 , 32 , 36 , 40 , 45 , 46 , 47 , 50 , 55 , 60 , 63 , 63 , 67 , 67 , 67 , 67 , 72 , 75 , 79 , 82 , 82 , 83 , 84 , 84 , 84 , 85 , 85 , 85 , 85 , 85 , 86 , 86 . in this section we fit blfr , glfr , lfr , gr , ge , rayleigh and exponential models to the above data set . we use the maximum likelihood method to estimate the model parameters and calculate the standard errors of the mle s , respectively . the mles of the parameters ( with std . ) , the maximized log - likelihood , the kolmogorov - smirnov statistic with its respective _ p_-value , the aic ( akaike information criterion ) , aicc and bic ( bayesian information criterion ) for the blfr , glfr , lfr , gr , ge , rayleigh and exponential models are given in table [ table1 ] . we can perform formal goodness - of - fit tests in order to verify which distribution fits better to the first data . we apply the anderson - darling ( ad ) and cramrvon mises ( cm ) tests . in general , the smaller the values of ad and cm , the better the fit to the data . for this data set , the values of ad and cm statistics for fitted distributions are given in in table [ table1 ] . the empirical scaled ttt transform ( aarset , 1987 ) can be used to identify the shape of the hazard function . the scaled ttt transform is convex ( concave ) if the hazard rate is decreasing ( increasing ) , and for bathtub ( unimodal ) hazard rates , the scaled ttt transform is first convex ( concave ) and then concave ( convex ) . the ttt plot for this data in fig . [ fig.ex1 ] shows a bathtub - shaped hazard rate function and , therefore , indicates the appropriateness of the blfr distribution to fit this data . the empirical distribution versus the fitted cumulative distribution functions of blfr , glfr , lfr , gr , ge , rayleigh and exponential distributions are displayed in fig . [ fig.ex1 ] . the results for this data set show that the blfr distribution yields the best fit among the glfr , lfr , gr , ge , rayleigh and exponential distributions . for this data , the k - s test statistic takes the smallest value with the largest value of its respective _ p_-value for blfr distribution . also this conclusion is confirmed from the values of the aic , aicc and bic for the fitted models given in table [ table1 ] and the plots of the densities and cumulative distribution functions in fig . [ fig.ex1 ] . using the likelihood ratio ( lr ) test , we test the null hypothesis @xmath135 : glfr versus the alternative hypothesis h1 : blfr , or equivalently , @xmath135 : @xmath7 versus @xmath136 : @xmath137 . the value of the lr test statistic and the corresponding _ p_-value are 3.4 and 0.019 , respectively . therefore , the null hypothesis ( glfr model ) is rejected in favor of the alternative hypothesis ( blfr model ) for a significance level @xmath138 0.019 . for test the null hypothesis @xmath135 : lfr versus the alternative hypothesis @xmath136 : blfr , or equivalently , @xmath135 : @xmath139 versus @xmath136 : @xmath140 , the value of the lr test statistic is 15.3 ( _ p_-value = 0.00047 ) , which includes that the null hypothesis ( lfr model ) is rejected in favor of the alternative hypothesis ( blfr model ) for any significance level . we also test the null hypothesis @xmath135 : gr versus the alternative hypothesis @xmath136 : blfr , or equivalently , @xmath135 : @xmath141 versus @xmath136 : @xmath142 . the value of the lr test statistic is 8.3 ( _ p_-value = 0.0158 ) , which includes that the null hypothesis ( gr model ) is rejected in favor of the alternative hypothesis ( blfr model ) for a significance level @xmath143 . for test the null hypothesis @xmath135 : ge versus the alternative hypothesis @xmath136 : blfr , or equivalently , @xmath135 : @xmath144 versus @xmath136 : @xmath145 , the value of the lr test statistic is 19.2 ( _ p_-value = 6e-05 ) , which includes that the null hypothesis ( gr model ) is rejected in favor of the alternative hypothesis ( blfr model ) for any significance level . this section provides the results of simulation study . simulations have been performed in order to investigate the proposed estimator of @xmath146 @xmath41,@xmath9 and @xmath13 of the proposed mle method . we generated 10000 samples of size @xmath147 and @xmath148 from the blfr distribution for each one of the six set of values of @xmath149 we assess the accuracy of the approximation of the standard error of the mles determined though the fisher information matrix . the approximate values of @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath152 and @xmath153 are computed . the results for the blfr distribution is shown in table [ table.2 ] , which indicate the following results : ( i ) convergence has been achieved in all cases and this emphasizes the numerical stability of the mle method . ( ii ) the differences between the average estimates and the true values are almost small . ( iii ) these results suggest that the mle estimates have performed consistently . ( iv ) the standard errors of the mles decrease when the sample size increases . we define a new model , called the blfr distributions , which generalizes the lfr and glfr distributions . the blfr distributions contain the glfr , lfr , gr , ge , rayleigh and exponential distributions as special cases . the blfr distribution present hazard functions with a very flexible behavior . we obtain closed form expressions for the moments . maximum likelihood estimation is discussed . finally , we fitted blfr distribution to a real data set to show the potential of the new proposed class . cordeiroa , g. m. , gomez , a. e. , de silva , c. q. , ortega , e. e. m. ( 2011 ) . the beta exponentiated weibull distribution , _ journal of statistical computation and simulation _ , doi : 10.1080/00949655.2011.615838 . cordeiroa , g. m. , nascimento , a. d. c. , cintra , l. c. , rago , l. c. ( 2012 ) . beta generalized normal distribution with an application for sar image processing , _ statistics _ , doi : 10.1080/02331888.2012.748776 .

we introduce in this paper a new four - parameter generalized version of the linear failure rate ( lfr ) distribution which is called beta - linear failure rate ( blfr ) distribution . the new distribution is quite flexible and can be used effectively in modeling survival data and reliability problems . it can have a constant , decreasing , increasing , upside - down bathtub ( unimodal ) and bathtub - shaped failure rate function depending on its parameters . it includes some well - known lifetime distributions as special sub - models . we provide a comprehensive account of the mathematical properties of the new distributions . in particular , a closed - form expressions for the density , cumulative distribution and hazard rate function of the blfr is given . also , the @xmath0th order moment of this distribution is derived . we discuss maximum likelihood estimation of the unknown parameters of the new model for complete sample and obtain an expression for fishers information matrix . in the end , to show the flexibility of this distribution and illustrative purposes , an application using a real data set is presented . msc : 60e05 ; 62f10 ; 62p99 . keywords : beta distribution ; hazard function ; linear failure rate distribution ; maximum likelihood estimation ; moments ; simulation .

gr-qc0104065

the classical cosmology based on the equations of general relativity involving the principles of thermodynamics , hydrodynamics , the plasma theory and the field theory comes across a number of conceptual difficulties known as the problems of standard big - bang cosmology @xcite . these are the problems of singularity , size , age , flatness , total entropy and total mass of the universe , large - scale structure , dark matter , isotropy of the cosmic background radiation and others . the various models were proposed for the solution of these problems . the inflationary model @xcite is the most popular one . there are alternative approaches which use the idea that in the early universe the fundamental constants ( velocity of light , gravitational constant , fine - structure constant ) had the values different from the modern @xcite . the observations of type ia supernovae ( sne ia ) indicate that our universe is accelerating @xcite . this conclusion which appeared as partly unexpected for the cosmologists a few years ago nowadays practically does not called in question @xcite . the concept of a dark energy was proposed for the explanation of this phenomenon @xcite and the modern investigations in this field are directed toward filling of this idea with concrete contents @xcite . the presence of the cosmological problems points to incompleteness of our knowledge about the universe . it is generally accepted that the conclusions of classical theory of gravity can not be extrapolated to the very early epoch . at the planck scales one must take into account the quantum effects of both matter and gravitational fields . there can not be any doubt that our universe today contains the structural elements which bear the traces of comprehensive quantum processes in preceding epochs . the small cosmic microwave background anisotropy and observed large - scale structure of the universe @xcite can be given as necessary examples ( see below ) . the application of basic ideas underlying quantum theory to a system of gravitational and matter fields runs into difficulties of a fundamental character which do not depend on the choice of a specific model . the problem of separation of true degrees of freedom under the construction of quantum gravity becomes of fundamental importance @xcite . it is commonly thought that the main reason behind such difficulties is that there is no natural way to define a spacetime event in general covariant theories @xcite . at the present time these difficulties are not overcome in the most advanced versions of quantum gravity . also the quantum gravity can not rely on experimental data @xcite . therefore it is appropriate to construct the consistent quantum theory within the framework of the simple ( toy ) exactly soluble cosmological model . as it is well known the model of a homogeneous , isotropic universe ( friedmann - robertson - walker model ) describes good enough the general properties of our universe . in this paper we study the model of quantum universe proposed in @xcite . it does not meet with the problems mentioned above and comes to the frw model with positive spatial curvature within the limits of large quantum numbers . in section 2 we propose the method of removing ambiguities in specifying the time variable in the frw model by means of modification of the action functional and find the solutions of obtained classical field equations . the section 3 is devoted to the quantum theory for a system of gravitational and matter fields . here we formulate the equation which is an analog of the schrdinger equation and turns into the wheeler - dewitt one for the minisuperspace model in special case . we concentrate our attention on study of the quantum universe which can be found in a region that is accessible to a classical motion inside the effective barrier formed by the interaction of the fields . we discuss the properties of the wave function of the universe and study the universe in low - lying and highly exited quasistationary states on the basis of exact solution of proposed quantum equation . in this section we calculate the proper dimension of the nonhomogeneities of matter density and the amplitude of the fluctuations of the cosmic background radiation temperature in highly exited state of the universe and propose a new possible quantum mechanism of their origin . the results are compared with the observed parameters of our universe . the flatness of the universe and the large value of the entropy today receive their natural explanation . the observed accelerated expansion emerges as a macroscopic manifestation of the quantum nature of the universe . throughout the paper the notation _ universe _ ( with capital letter u ) relates to our universe , while _ universe _ ( with small letter u ) corresponds to arbitrary cosmological system of considered type . for simplicity we restrict our study to the case of minimal coupling between geometry and the matter . considering that scalar fields play a fundamental role both in quantum field theory and in the cosmology of the early universe we assume that , originally , the universe was filled with matter in the form of a scalar field @xmath0 with some potential @xmath1 . as we shall see the replacement of the entire set of actually existing massive fields by some averaged massive scalar field seems physically justified . assuming that the field @xmath0 is uniform and the geometry is defined by the robertson - walker metric , we represent the action functional in the conventional form @xmath2 . \label{1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath3 is the time parameter that is related to the synchronous proper time @xmath4 by the differential equation @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is a function that specifies the time - reference scale , @xmath7 is a scale factor ; @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the momenta canonically conjugate with the variables @xmath10 and @xmath0 , respectively . the hamiltonian @xmath11 is given by @xmath12 \equiv n\ , { \cal r } , \label{2}\ ] ] where the @xmath10 is taken in units of the length @xmath13 , @xmath14 is the planck length , and @xmath0 in units of @xmath15 . the energy density will be measured in units @xmath16 . the function @xmath17 plays the role of a lagrange multiplier , and the variation @xmath18 leads to the constraint equation @xmath19 . the structure of the constraint is such that true dynamical degrees of freedom can not be singled out explicitly . in the model being considered , this difficulty is reflected in that the choice of the time variable is ambiguous ( the problem of time ) . for the choice of the time coordinate to be unambiguous , the model must be supplemented with a coordinate condition . when the coordinate condition is added to the field equations , their solution can be found for chosen time variable . however , this method of removing ambiguities in specifying the time variable does not solve the problem of a quantum description . therefore we shall use another approach and remove the above ambiguity with the aid of a coordinate condition imposed prior to varying the action functional . we will choose the coordinate condition in the form @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the privileged time coordinate , and include it in the action functional with the aid of a lagrange multiplier @xmath22 @xmath23 , \label{4}\ ] ] where @xmath24 \label{5}\ ] ] is the new hamiltonian . the constraint equation reduces to the form @xmath25 parameter @xmath21 can be used as an independent variable for the description of the evolution of the universe . corresponding canonical equations reduce to the form @xmath26 integrating the equation for @xmath22 , we obtain @xmath27 , where @xmath28 is a constant and the multiplier @xmath29 is introduced for further convenience . the full set of equations for the model in question becomes @xcite @xmath30 @xmath31 where @xmath32 . equation ( [ 6 ] ) represents the einstein equation for the @xmath33 component , while equation ( [ 7 ] ) is the equation of motion @xmath34 for the field @xmath35 . ( @xmath36 is the energy - momentum tensor of the scalar field . ) from the analysis of the einstein equations for this model it follows that inclusion of the coordinate condition ( [ 3 ] ) in the action functional leads to the origin of the additional energy - momentum tensor in these equations @xmath37 that can be interpreted as the energy - momentum tensor of radiation . in the ordinary units @xmath28 is measured in @xmath38 . the choice of radiation as the matter reference frame is natural for the case in which relativistic matter ( electromagnetic radiation , neutrino radiation , etc . ) is dominant at the early stage of universe evolution . if our universe were described by the model specified by action functional ( [ 4 ] ) , it would be possible to relate the above radiation at the present era to cosmic microwave background . a feature peculiar to the model in question is that it involves a barrier in the variable @xmath10 described by the function @xmath39 . this barrier is formed by the interaction of the scalar and gravitational fields . it exists for any form of the positive definite scalar - field potential @xmath40 and becomes impenetrable on the side of small @xmath10 in the limit @xmath41 . in general case ( @xmath42 ) there are two regions accessible to a classical motion : inside the barrier ( @xmath43 ) and outside the barrier ( @xmath44 ) , where @xmath45 and @xmath46 are the turning points ( @xmath47 ) specified by the condition @xmath48 . the set of equations ( [ 6 ] ) and ( [ 7 ] ) determines the @xmath10 and @xmath0 as the functions of time @xmath21 at given @xmath1 . when the rate at which scalar field changes is much smaller than the rate of universe evolution , i.e. @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is the hubble constant , and @xmath51 , the equations ( [ 6 ] ) and ( [ 7 ] ) become @xmath52 @xmath53 where @xmath54 and @xmath39 depend parametrically on @xmath0 . in the zero - order approximation @xmath55 . the solution to equation ( [ 6 ] ) can be refined by taking into account a slow variation of the field @xmath35 with the aid of the equation @xmath56 where @xmath54 stands for a potential term . the solutions of the equation ( [ 91 ] ) which determine the scalar field dynamics were studied in the inflationary models @xcite . the solution of the equation ( [ 9 ] ) at fixed value of @xmath0 can be represented in the form @xmath57^{1/2 } , \label{92}\ ] ] where we denote @xmath58 here @xmath59 gives the initial condition for some instant of time @xmath60 . at @xmath61 and @xmath62 the corresponding scale factors are given in @xcite . the solution ( [ 92 ] ) shows that in the region @xmath63 the universe expands in the de sitter mode from the point @xmath64 , but in the region @xmath65 it evolves as @xmath66^{1/2}$ ] for @xmath67 that describes the evolution of the universe which density was dominated by radiation and as @xmath68 with @xmath69 near the point of maximal expansion @xmath70 . the estimations for @xmath45 demonstrate that at small enough @xmath71 the value @xmath72 can reach the modern values of the scale factor in our universe . so , for the state of the universe with @xmath73 and @xmath74 gev/@xmath75 ( the mean matter - energy density in our universe at the present era ) we have @xmath76 cm . in the extreme case of @xmath77 , where there is no radiation , the region @xmath43 contracts to the point @xmath78 , and the expansion can proceed only from the point @xmath64 and the region @xmath79 can not be treated in terms of classical theory . such models were widely enough studied by many authors ( see , for example , @xcite ) . we concentrate our attention on study of the properties of the universe which is characterized by the nonzero values of @xmath28 ( and @xmath54 ) at the initial instant of time and can be found in a region that is accessible to a classical motion inside the barrier . the evolution of the universe depends on the initial distribution of the classical field @xmath0 and its subsequent behavior as a function of time . the solutions of the equation ( [ 91 ] ) for @xmath80 give evidence that the @xmath0 decreases with time @xcite . from equations ( [ 7 ] ) and ( [ 10 ] ) , it follows that the inequality @xmath81 holds in the expanding universe . if @xmath71 decreases with time , @xmath54 can increase . let us estimate @xmath82 by using the relation @xmath83 . in our universe , with @xmath84 cm , the main contribution to the radiation - energy density comes from cosmic microwave background with energy density @xmath85 gev/@xmath86 . setting @xmath87 , we find that , at the present era , the result is @xmath88 . in the early universe with @xmath89 cm and the planck energy density we have @xmath90 . it indicates that @xmath82 should increase in the evolution process . this increase can be explained by a considerable redistribution of energy between the scalar field and radiation at the initial stage of universe existence . quantum theory is able to account for this phenomenon in a natural way as spontaneous transition from one quantum state of the universe to another ( see below ) . let us estimate the size of the classical universe in the region @xmath43 taking into account that the parameter @xmath54 can take different values . such universe by definition can not tunnel through the barrier into the region @xmath44 and by this reason will evolve in time remaining inside the barrier . assuming for simplicity that the universe has expanded according to the law @xmath91^{1/2}$ ] for two instants of time @xmath92 and @xmath93 we obtain @xmath94 where subscripts denote that the corresponding values are given for the values @xmath95 at the instants of time @xmath96 and @xmath97 . setting @xmath98 s ( the age of the universe ) , @xmath99 s and using the estimation @xmath100 , where @xmath101 and @xmath102 we find that the value of @xmath103 cm corresponds to @xmath104 cm . thus the dependence of @xmath54 on @xmath95 , in principle , makes it possible to provide the missing power ( cf . @xcite ) in the @xmath4 dependence of @xmath10 and to solve the problem of size of the universe . taking into consideration the mechanism of quantum tunneling through the barrier and competing process of the reduction of @xmath71 with time ( which leads to the growth of the barrier @xmath39 in width and height ) allows to reexamine old and new puzzles of cosmology from the point of view of quantum theory . in quantum theory , the constraint equation ( [ 51 ] ) comes to be a constraint on the wave function that describes the universe filled with a scalar field and radiation @xcite @xmath105 \psi \ , . \label{12}\ ] ] here the order parameter is assumed to be zero @xcite . this equation represents an analog of the schrdinger equation with a hamiltonian independent of the time variable @xmath21 . one can introduce a positive definite scalar product @xmath106 and specify the norm of a state . this makes it possible to define a hilbert space of physical states and to construct quantum mechanics for model of the universe being considered . a solution to equation ( [ 12 ] ) can be represented in the integral form @xmath107 where the function @xmath108 characterizes the @xmath28 distribution of the states of the universe at the instant @xmath109 , while @xmath110 and @xmath28 are , respectively , the eigenfunctions and the eigenvalues for the equation @xmath111 this equation turns into the famous wheeler - dewitt equation for the minisuperspace model @xcite in special case @xmath77 . a solution to equation ( [ 14 ] ) can be represented as @xmath112 where @xmath113 and @xmath82 are the eigenfunctions and the eigenvalues of the equation @xmath114 for slow - roll potential @xmath71 , when @xmath115 , the @xmath113 describes the universe in the adiabatic approximation and corresponds to continuum states at a fixed value of the field @xmath35 . the functions @xmath113 can be normalized to the delta function @xmath116 . their form greatly depends on the value of @xmath82 . the quantities @xmath117 can be interpreted as the amplitudes of the probability that the universe is in the state with a given values of @xmath0 and @xmath28 @xcite . since the potential @xmath39 has the finite height @xmath118 and finite width then the quantum tunneling through the region @xmath119 of the potential barrier is possible . it results in that stationary states can not be realized in the region @xmath43 . if , however , @xmath120 , quasistationary states with lifetimes exceeding the planck time can exist within the barrier . the positions @xmath121 and widths @xmath122 of such states are determined by the solutions to equation ( [ 151 ] ) for @xmath123 that satisfy the boundary condition in the form of a wave traveling toward greater values of @xmath10 . let us describe these states . we choose some value @xmath124 . then @xmath125 at fixed @xmath0 can be represented in the form @xmath126 and @xmath127 \quad \mbox{for } \ a > r , \label{17}\ ] ] where @xmath128 and @xmath129 are the amplitudes depending on @xmath54 , @xmath130 is the solution that is regular at the point @xmath78 , normalized to unity , and weakly dependent on @xmath82 , while @xmath131 and @xmath132 describe the wave `` incident '' upon the barrier ( the contracting universe ) and the `` outgoing '' wave ( the expanding universe ) respectively . beyond the turning points the wkb approximation is valid so that one can write @xmath133 the amplitude @xmath134 has a pole in the complex plane of @xmath82 at @xmath135 , and for @xmath136 the main contribution to the integral ( [ 15 ] ) over the interval @xmath137 comes from the values @xmath138 . the amplitude @xmath139 is an analog of the s - matrix @xcite . the estimation @xmath140 shows that at @xmath141 the wave function @xmath142 has a sharp peak for @xmath143 and it is concentrated mainly in the region limited by the barrier . if @xmath144 then for the maximum value of the function @xmath123 we obtain @xmath145 where @xmath146 and @xmath147 . from this it follows that for @xmath141 the wave function reaches the great values on the boundary of the barrier , while under the barrier @xmath148 . in the limit of an impenetrable barrier , the function @xmath149 reduces to the wave function of a stationary state with a definite value of @xmath150 . during the time interval @xmath151 the possibility that the state decays can be disregarded this corresponds to defining a quasistationary state as that which takes the place of a stationary state when the probability of its decay becomes nonzero @xcite . calculation of the parameters @xmath152 of the quantum state of the universe can be done by both perturbation theory by considering the interaction @xmath153 as a small perturbation against @xmath154 ( in the region @xmath65 we have @xmath155 ) and direct integration of the equation ( [ 151 ] ) @xcite . such calculations show that the first level with @xmath156 and @xmath157 emerges at @xmath158 . in the early universe , the quantity @xmath40 specifies the vacuum energy density . the investigations within inflationary models suggest that the potential @xmath159 of the classical scalar field decreases with time . as the potential @xmath40 decreases , the number of quantum states in the prebarrier region increases but the decay probability decreases exponentially . the results of calculations are summarized in the table . let us note that the quantum fluctuations of @xmath95 in exponentially expanding universe can result in that the quantity @xmath95 and the potential @xmath160 will increase @xcite . then the quantum states of the universe in the prebarrier region can not form . this case is not interesting for us and it will not be considered . .parameters @xmath121 and @xmath122 for various values of the potential @xmath71 . at @xmath161 there are six levels in the system , three of them are displayed . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the calculations demonstrate that the first instants of the existence of the universe ( counted off from the moment of formation of first quasistationary state ) are especially favorable for its tunneling through the potential barrier @xmath39 . the emergence of new levels results in appearance of competition between the tunneling processes and transitions between the states . in the approximation of a slowly varying field @xmath35 , transitions in the system being studied can be considered as those that occur between the states @xmath162 of an isotropic oscillator with zero orbital angular momentum which are induced by the interaction @xmath163 . in more strict approach which takes into account the variations of the @xmath1 the transitions will be carried out at the expense of the gradient of the potential @xmath1 which follows from the quantization of the equation ( [ 51 ] ) taking into account the evolution of the field @xmath0 in approximation ( [ 91 ] ) @xcite . considering the processes of transitions from some initial state @xmath164 to final state @xmath165 ( including the case @xmath166 ) and tunneling through the barrier from the final state as independent one can calculate the probability @xmath167 of transition between the states @xmath168 and @xmath169 as : @xmath170 where @xmath171 and @xmath172 is the evolution operator in the interaction representation @xcite . in the case of two - level system the computation of the total probability of universe decay , @xmath173 , and the probability @xmath174 demonstrates that over the time interval @xmath175 , the transitions in the system predominate and only for @xmath176 the probability that the universe tunnels through the barrier becomes commensurate with the probability that it undergoes the @xmath177 transition in the prebarrier region ( see figure ) . and @xmath178 versus the time interval @xmath171 taken in units of the planck time at @xmath179 . ] since the rate at which the level width @xmath180 tends to zero is greater than the rate at which the @xmath71 decreases , its reduction with time results in that transitions become much more probable than tunnel decays , in which case the former fully determine the evolution of the quantum universe in the prebarrier region . if the universe has not tunneled through the barrier before the potential of the field @xmath35 decreases to a value @xmath181 , a sufficiently large number of levels such that the probabilities of decays from them can be neglected are formed in the system . calculating the amplitudes of transitions over the time interval @xmath182 we find that the @xmath183 transition is more probable than the @xmath184 transitions . this means that the quantum universe can undergo transitions to ever higher levels with a nonzero probability . since the expectation value of the scale factor @xmath185 then it can be concluded that the characteristic size @xmath186 of the universe that did not undergo a tunnel decay increases as it is excited to higher levels , i.e. the quantum universe being with respect to @xmath10 in classically accessible region before the turning point @xmath45 can evolve so that @xmath186 will increase with time . this can be interpreted as an expansion of the universe . the probability that , in course of time , the universe will occur in the region @xmath63 outside the barrier is negligibly small . in the limit @xmath187 , the universe is completely locked in the region within the barrier . the universe in the lowest state with @xmath188 has a `` proper dimension '' @xmath189 cm , the total matter - energy density @xmath190 , and the problem of the initial cosmological singularity does not emerge . the classical turning points are @xmath191 cm and @xmath192 cm . the value of @xmath45 determines the maximal dimension of the universe occurring in the lowest state in prebarrier region , while @xmath46 characterizes its initial dimension after tunneling from this state . if a quantum universe tunnels from the states with @xmath193 , the dimensions of the region from which tunneling occurs can considerably exceed the planck length . the constants @xmath28 and @xmath71 appearing in the einstein equations will be determined by the corresponding quantum stage . thus it turned out that quantum universe originally filled with a radiation and a matter in form of a scalar field with a potential @xmath159 decreasing with time has nonzero probability to evolve remaining in prebarrier region . the expansion here is ensured by the transitions from lower states to higher states by means of interaction between gravitational and scalar fields . the system can be found in the highly excited states with @xmath194 as a result of such evolution . in states with @xmath194 the potential @xmath195 and @xmath196 . the state of the universe will be characterized by the quantum number @xmath169 which determines its geometrical properties and new quantum number @xmath197 responsible for the state of matter . the potential of the @xmath0 will be chosen in the form @xmath198 . from the condition @xmath195 , it follows that the mass of the field must be constrained by the condition @xmath199 . in this case the states of the matter are determined by the solutions of the schrdinger equation for a harmonic oscillator at given value of @xmath169 @xcite . it describes the oscillations of the @xmath0 near the minimum of the potential @xmath1 . this process can be interpreted as the production of particles . at @xmath77 , a similar mechanism leads to the production of particles by the inflaton field , which is identified with the scalar field @xmath35 @xcite . assuming as before that the @xmath1 is slow - roll potential we find the condition of quantization of @xmath28 @xmath200 where @xmath201 , and the values of the quantum number @xmath197 are restricted by inequality @xmath202 which reflects the fact that the mass @xmath168 of the produced particles is finite . for small @xmath197 the equality @xmath203 holds to a high precision , so that the universe is dominated by radiation . a transition from the radiation - dominated universe to the universe where matter ( in the form of particles produced by the field @xmath204 ) prevails occurs when the second term in ( [ 21 ] ) becomes commensurate with the first one . the physical interpretation of the condition ( [ 21 ] ) will be considered below . for the universe with given quantum numbers @xmath194 and @xmath205 the wave function @xmath206 has the form @xcite @xmath207 where @xmath208 @xmath209 this wave function is normalized to unity with allowance for the fact that the probability of finding the universe in the region @xmath210 is negligibly small . the condition ( [ 21 ] ) can be rewritten in the terms of `` observable '' quantities : the cosmic scale factor @xmath211 , where averaging was performed over the state ( [ 27 - 2 ] ) , and the total mass of the matter @xmath212 , @xmath213 . \label{22}\ ] ] the classical universe is characterized by the total energy density @xmath214 . replacing all quantities by corresponding operators for the quantum universe we set @xmath215 . it gives @xmath216 , where @xmath217 here in accordance with the ehrenfest theorem we assume that expectation value @xmath218 follows the laws of classical theory and the expectation values of the functions @xmath219 and @xmath220 of @xmath10 can be replaced by the functions of @xmath218 . in the case , when @xmath221 we have @xmath222 . this relation holds to a high precision @xmath223 in the observed part of our universe , where @xmath224 cm and @xmath225 g. the quantum numbers of such universe are the following : @xmath226 and @xmath227 taking the proton mass for @xmath168 . the value of @xmath169 agrees with existing estimates for our universe , while @xmath197 is equal to equivalent number of baryons @xcite . thus for the matter - dominant era we have the following relation between @xmath218 and @xmath228 : @xmath229 this relation can be reduced to the standard form @xcite @xmath230 where @xmath231 is the critical density and @xmath232 is the density parameter equal to @xmath233 . that is , the geometry of the universe with @xmath194 and @xmath234 is close to euclidean geometry ( a flat universe ) . if one neglects the contribution from the kinetic term of the scalar field ( @xmath235 ) then the corresponding @xmath236 . this value exceeds the contribution from the luminous matter ( stars and associated material ) @xcite and it is close to the value for minimum amount of dark matter required to explain the flat rotation curves of spiral galaxies . although the potential @xmath40 undergoes only small variations in response to changes in the field @xmath35 , the field @xmath35 itself changes fast , oscillating about the point @xmath237 , so that the approximation in which @xmath238 is invalid . the application of the present model in this approximation would result in the radiation - dominated universe ; that is , it would not feature a mechanism capable of filling it with matter after a slow descent of the potential @xmath40 to the equilibrium position , which corresponds to the true vacuum . it is interesting to find the physical interpretation on ( [ 22 ] ) . passing on to the ordinary physical units we rewrite it in the form @xmath239 where @xmath240 , @xmath241 . it is easy to see that ( [ 30 ] ) is the condition of the equality between proper gravitational energy of the thin spherical layer ( with the total mass @xmath242 ) on the sphere with radius @xmath10 and the sum of energies of particles @xmath243 and energy of radiation @xmath244 . in the modern era @xmath245 gev . if we extrapolate ( [ 30 ] ) on planck era and set @xmath246 then @xmath247 . for the lowest quantum state we find that @xmath248 . since @xmath249 the parameter @xmath250 . it means that vacuum energy of the scalar field and the energy of radiation make the comparable contribution to the total energy of universe with @xmath188 . in this state the scalar field @xmath251 . the approach developed here makes it possible to obtain realistic estimates for the proper dimensions of the nonhomogeneities of matter density , for the amplitude of the fluctuations of the cosmic background radiation temperature and points to a new possible mechanism of their origin , namely by means of finite values of the widths of quasistationary states . for a small , but finite value of the width @xmath252 the quasistationary state does not possess a definite value of @xmath82 . the corresponding uncertainty @xmath253 can serve as source of fluctuations of the metric @xmath254 @xcite . by associating @xmath255 with the scale factor @xmath256 and by using the solution ( [ 92 ] ) for @xmath61 we find the amplitude of fluctuations of the scale factor in the form @xmath257 since @xmath258 , the fluctuations @xmath259 that were generated at the early stage of the evolution of the universe will take the greatest values . for the lowest quasistationary state with @xmath260 , @xmath261 , @xmath262 , at @xmath263 we obtain @xmath264 since the dimension of large - scale fluctuations changed in direct proportion @xmath10 , this relation has remained valid up to the present time . for the current value of @xmath84 cm we find that @xmath265 mpc . on the order of magnitude , the above value corresponds to the scale of superclusters of galaxies . smaller values of @xmath253 are peculiar to quantum states with smaller @xmath71 . the fluctuations @xmath266 corresponding to them are smaller than ( [ 25 ] ) and are expected to manifest themselves against the background of the large - scale structure . they can be associated with clusters of galaxies , galaxies themselves , and clusters of stars . the energy density of radiation can be expressed as @xmath267 where @xmath268 is temperature and @xmath269 counts the total number of effectively massless degrees of freedom @xcite . using the relation ( [ 23 ] ) for @xmath270 we obtain @xmath271 where we omit the brackets for simplicity . leaving the main terms we can write @xmath272 for @xmath273 it follows the estimation @xmath274 for the time @xmath275 yr corresponding to the instant of recombination of primary plasma ( separation of radiation from matter ) , and for the observed value of @xmath276 , for ( [ 25 ] ) we find @xmath277 here @xmath278 . upon recombination , the fluctuations of the temperature undergo no changes ; therefore , measurement of the quantity @xmath279 for the present era furnishes information about the universe at the instant of last interaction of radiation with matter . the estimate in ( [ 27 ] ) is in good agreement with experimental data from which the trivial dipole term @xmath280 caused by the solar system motion was subtracted @xcite . the total entropy @xmath281 per comoving volume @xmath282 @xcite can be expressed as @xmath283 where @xmath284 can be replaced by @xmath269 for the most of the history of the universe when all particles species had a common temperature . from ( [ 252 ] ) and ( [ 271 ] ) it follows a simple relation between the @xmath28 and the total entropy @xmath281 @xmath285 for the adiabatic expansion , @xmath286 , the ratio @xmath287 is conserved . excluding @xmath288 from ( [ 28 ] ) we obtain the relation , @xmath289 in the era with @xmath290 gev we have @xmath291 , but at present time for @xmath292 gev the entropy @xmath293 . the large value of @xmath28 today explains the large value of entropy of the universe . recent measurements @xcite indicate that today the universe is accelerating . let us note that another possible explanation of the observed dimming of the type ia supernovae at redshifts @xmath294 is an unexpected supernova luminosity evolution @xcite . at the present time the first interpretation of observed phenomenon is considered as more preferable . in terms of classical cosmology the accelerated expansion is described by the negative values of the deceleration parameter @xmath295 in order to agree the experimental data with the theory it was proposed the concept of the dark energy which is nearly smoothly distributed in space . this dark energy component must have negative pressure that overcomes the gravitational self - attraction of matter and causes the accelerated expansion of the universe . it is commonly assumed that the vacuum energy density in the form of a non - zero cosmological constant or due to a slow - roll scalar field called `` quintessence '' can be responsible for the dark energy @xcite . let us examine this problem from the point of view of the approach developed in this paper . to this end we rewrite ( [ 42 ] ) in the form @xmath296 bearing in mind canonical equation for @xmath297 from ( [ 52 ] ) and having differentiated the equation ( [ 14 ] ) with respect to @xmath10 , we obtain that the derivative @xmath298 must be substituted by the quantum mechanical operator @xmath299 then according to quantum mechanical principles the quantum analog of deceleration parameter can be calculated as @xmath300 where averaging is performed over states @xmath206 and it is assumed that offdiagonal matrix elements from @xmath301 vanish . ( this corresponds to the representation of deceleration parameter as a scalar quantity . ) in state with large quantum numbers @xmath194 and @xmath234 , for the matter - dominant universe , where @xmath302 , using the wave function ( [ 27 - 2 ] ) we obtain @xmath303 . \label{46}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expression in square brackets in ( [ 46 ] ) which contains two cosines rapidly oscillates with small period @xmath304 . averaging ( [ 46 ] ) over small interval near some fixed value of @xmath305 we have @xmath306 this value can be associated with the deceleration parameter in classical theory . it agrees with the classical conceptions of general relativity about the expansion rate of the universe in matter - dominated era with zero cosmological constant @xcite . the quantity ( [ 51 - 1 ] ) does not take into account the quantum fluctuations of the scale factor @xmath307 that specify root - mean - square deflection of the distribution @xmath308 as function of @xmath10 . in this case @xmath206 represents the wave packet which describes the universe being localized in space @xmath10 near the expectation value @xmath309 with deflection @xmath310 . we shall show that at certain conditions ( parameters of the universe ) the fluctuations @xmath311 can affect essentially the character of the expansion of the universe . it can provide in particular the accelerated expansion observed nowadays @xcite . we shall denote the scale factor taking into account the fluctuations @xmath310 as @xmath312 , while the fluctuations will be associated with quantity @xmath313 , where @xmath314 is the scale factor without regard for fluctuations . fixing some instant @xmath92 for small intervals @xmath315 we can write the expansion @xcite @xmath316 , \label{53}\ ] ] and similarly @xmath317 , \label{54}\ ] ] where the hubble constant @xmath318 and the deceleration parameter @xmath319 are calculated with respect to scale factor @xmath320 and subscript @xmath321 means that corresponding values are taken at @xmath96 . from ( [ 53 ] ) and ( [ 54 ] ) it follows that @xmath322 where @xmath323 let us suppose that the fluctuations @xmath324 do not affect the rate of expansion , that is @xmath325 . in addition it is natural to assume that the hubble constant also does not depend on these fluctuations , i.e. @xmath326 . these assumptions are based on astrophysical observations which do not record the necessity to modify the classical conception of the hubble s law . with regard to these two facts we obtain @xmath327 then according to ( [ 56 ] ) the deceleration parameter @xmath319 which takes into account the quantum fluctuations @xmath310 will be determined by the expression @xmath328 using the wave function ( [ 27 - 2 ] ) from ( [ 52 - 1 ] ) we find that for the state of the universe with large quantum numbers @xmath169 and @xmath197 the fluctuations @xmath329 and the deceleration parameter @xmath330 for numerical estimation in the capacity of @xmath331 one can take the age of the universe and the mean @xmath218 may be put to be equal to classical value @xmath332 . then for modern value @xmath333 @xcite and @xmath334 we obtain @xmath335 for the conventional value @xmath336 @xcite it gives @xmath337 the parameter @xmath338 corresponds to the case when the fluctuations @xmath339 and according to ( [ 51 - 1 ] ) it equals to @xmath340 . as a result we find @xmath341 this value takes into account the presence of quantum fluctuations of metric and it is in good agreement with sne ia observations @xcite . thus , the observed accelerated expansion can be explained without implication of any additional concepts about matter - energy structure of the universe considering this acceleration as macroscopic manifestation of its quantum nature . the represented calculations relate to the universe with large quantum numbers . in preceding epoch the cosmological parameters @xmath342 , @xmath331 and @xmath310 took different values . if one assumes that up to coefficients on the order of @xmath343 the relation @xmath344 holds for earlier instants of time and the fluctuations @xmath310 as before have been on the order of @xmath345 then from ( [ 58 ] ) it follows that in epoch with the hubble constant @xmath346 the universe have to be decelerated . for more accurate calculation of the deceleration parameter of the universe in such states the averaging in ( [ 52 - 1 ] ) must be performed over the wave functions @xmath206 which take into account that the variables @xmath10 and @xmath0 in the equation ( [ 14 ] ) are not separated in general . the main constructive element of our model which allows to avoid most of cosmological problems is an idea that @xmath28 increased during the evolution of the universe . the quantity @xmath28 determines the energy - momentum tensor of radiation and can be found as an eigenvalue for the equation ( [ 14 ] ) . the above numerical estimations of the parameters of the quantum universe filled with the radiation and scalar field show that the averaged massive scalar field used instead of the aggregate of real physical fields mainly correctly describes global characteristics of our universe . it effectively includes visible baryon matter and dark matter . the kinetic energy term of the scalar field provides the modern value of the total energy density of the universe which is very close to the critical value . the status of the field @xmath35 changes as we go over from one stage of universe evolution to another . in the early universe , the field @xmath35 ensures a nonzero value of the vacuum - energy density due to @xmath40 values at which the equation ( [ 151 ] ) for @xmath347 admits nontrivial solutions in the form of quasistationary states . in a later era , when the field @xmath35 descends to a minimum of the potential @xmath40 and begins to oscillate about this minimum , it appears to be a source of the particles of some averaged matter filling the visible volume of the universe , which has linear dimensions on the order of @xmath348 . the galaxies , their clusters , and other structures in the universe are subject to quantum fluctuations ( due to the finite widths of the quasistationary states ) that have grown considerably . the quantum fluctuations which specify the spread of the wave function of the universe in space of scale factor can ensure the accelerated expansion of the universe . in this sense they manifest themselves similar to dark energy . the theory gives the value of the deceleration parameter @xmath349 ( the universe is slowing down ) for essentially classical cosmological macrosystem and predicts @xmath350 ( the universe is speeding up ) explaining the accelerated expansion as macroscopic manifestation of quantum nature of the universe . +

old and new puzzles of cosmology are reexamined from the point of view of quantum theory of the universe developed here . it is shown that in proposed approach the difficulties of the standard cosmology do not arise . the theory predicts the observed dimensions of the nonhomogeneities of matter density and the amplitude of the fluctuations of the cosmic background radiation temperature in the universe and points to a new quantum mechanism of their origin . it allows to obtain the value of the deceleration parameter which is in good agreement with the recent sne ia measurements . the theory explains the large value of entropy of the universe and describes other parameters . * properties of the quasistationary universe in context of the big - bang cosmology problems * v.e . kuzmichev and v.v . kuzmichev + bogolyubov institute for theoretical physics , national academy of sciences of ukraine , kiev , 03143 ukraine

0709.3093

capella ( @xmath2 aur ; g1iii / g8iii ) is the strongest non - solar coronal source accessible to high - sensitivity high - energy telescopes , and has been a common calibration target for x - ray and euv instruments such as _ euve _ , , xmm-_newton _ , etc . it is a remarkably stable source , with no discernible flaring activity . even though the emission structure has shown changes , especially in the high - temperature regime ( see e.g. , dupree et al . 1996 , young et al . 2001 ) , and there is considerable evidence for the dominant emission to change between the g1iii primary and the g8iii secondary ( e.g. , linsky et al . 1998 , johnson et al . 2002 , ishibashi et al . 2006 ) , the overall luminosity has remained steady over many years . for instance , argiroffi et al . ( 2003 ) detected a change of 3% in hrc - s / letgs data over the span of a year , and found no variability at timescales of @xmath3 ks . recently , analysis of acis - s / hetgs data ( raasen et al . 2007 , westbrook et al . 2007 ) found variations over long timescales , such as an @xmath4 intensity enhancement in early 2006 , but no evidence for any variability at timescales @xmath5 ks . variability in stellar coronae is ubiquitous , and has been detected in all types of coronally active stars ( stassun et al . 2006 , caramazza et al . 2007 , westbrook et al . 2007 , gdel 2004 , and references therein ) and over a wide range of timescales ( kashyap & drake 1999 , favata et al . 2005 , stassun et al . 2006 , pease et al . 2006 , colombo et al . this variability can occur due to many causes , ranging from cyclical dynamo variations ( timescales of decades to years ) , to rotational modulation ( months to hours ) , to active region evolution ( hours to days ) , to flaring ( hours to minutes ) . generally , active stars are characterized by recurrent flares ( see e.g. , gdel 2004 ) that are recognized in x - ray and euv light curves as sudden increases in the luminosity followed by a slower decay . however , as activity increases , the flares start to occur closer in time to each other , and it becomes increasingly difficult to resolve them in the light curve ( cf . kashyap et al . 2001 ) . prominent flares are nevertheless detected in numerous active binaries ( see e.g. , osten & brown 1999 , osten et al . 2004 ) . despite being one of the more coronally active stars , with a strong high temeperature emission component ( brickhouse et al . 2000 ) , flares have never been observed on capella ( table [ t : capella ] ) . it is unknown whether this is due to a lack of flaring activity to contribute to the heating , or due to a preponderance of flares such that individual events can not be distinguished ( cf . kashyap et al . 2001 ) . here we consider recent observations of capella made with the / ( [ s : data ] ) . we analyze these data and find that variability indeed can be detected at short timescales ( [ s : analysis ] ) , suggesting that the latter explanation is more plausible . rl + ( r.a . , dec)@xmath6 & ( 05:16:41.3591 , + 45:59:52.768 ) + distance & 13.4 pc + orbital period & 104 days + components & g1iii / g8iii + separation & 109 r@xmath7 + mass & 2.56 / 2.69 [ m@xmath8 + radius & 9.2 / 12.2 [ r@xmath8 + m@xmath9 & 0.14 / 0.25 + @xmath10 & 0.74 / 0.87 + rotational velocity & 36 / 3 [ km s@xmath11 + s , dashed otherwise ) . the data comprise 40 obsids ( noted at the top of each segment , along with the day since 2005-dec-01 that the observation started ) . the sim offset at which each observation is carried out is indicated at the bottom of each segment . [ f : ctrt],width=528 ] capella was observed as a calibration target with the / over two cycles from december 2005 to january 2007 ( see figure [ f : ctrt ] ) . all the observations were carried out at the telescope aimpoint , but at different locations on the detector corresponding to different offset values of the science instrument module ( sim ) . the count rates shown in figure [ f : ctrt ] have been corrected for the qe ( quantum efficiency ) values at the observation location and thus represent flat - fielded light curves matched to the qe at the nominal aimpoint . the qe corrections are made separately for each bin of the light curves as the source dithers across the detector . note however that this detailed correction is ignorable ; it causes changes of @xmath12 when compared with count rates corrected with a qe averaged over the entire dither pattern ( see also [ s : hz43 ] ) . we have reduced the data using the software for the interactive analysis of observations ( ciao v3.4 ) and using the most recent calibration products ( caldb v3.2 ) . the high count rates observed ( @xmath13 ) , coupled with the sharp point spread function ( psf ; it falls to 1% of the maximum at @xmath14 away from the peak ) , provides an unprecedented opportunity to study small changes in the x - ray brightness of capella . the source counts are extracted from a circle with radius 8x the size of the psf ( @xmath15 ) , and the background is locally estimated from a surrounding annulus of radii ( @xmath16 ) . assuming a raymond - smith thermal emission model with a dominant temperature component at 6 mk and a h column n@xmath17 @xmath18 , we find with webpimms that the counts - to - energy conversion factor is @xmath19 ergs @xmath18 ct@xmath20 for different metallicities . this suggests x - ray luminosities of capella in the 0.15 - 4.5 kev passband of @xmath21 ergs s@xmath20 ( cf . l@xmath22 ergs s@xmath20 based on _ einstein_/ipc observations ; strassmeier et al . it is clear from the light curve ( figure [ f : ctrt ] ) that capella undergoes slow changes in its luminosity over timescales of weeks and months , with count rates ranging from @xmath23 . for instance , note the drop in intensity between obsids 6552 and 6555 , which are separated by 16 days , to @xmath24 mm between these two observations , and it could be argued that uncalibrated differences in the qe uniformity may account for the drop in intensity . however , the similarity of count rates between observations 6558 and 6559 , both of which were carried out on the same day , but at sim offsets of @xmath25 and @xmath26 mm respectively , indicates that the drop in intensity is real . ] and the difference between obsids 6559 and 8360 , which are done @xmath27 yr apart , but are both carried out at the same detector location ( thus precluding calibration differences as a factor ; see [ s : hz43 ] below ) . this impression is confirmed by an autocorrelation analysis ; we construct count rate light curves @xmath28 at various binning sizes @xmath29 and compute the autocorrelation @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the average count rate in the @xmath32 bins in the light curve . the autocorrelation for @xmath33 s is shown in figure [ f : autocorr ] as the dark blue curve ( curves for other bin sizes are similar ) , along with estimates of the 95% and 99% uncertainties for each lag time @xmath34 . these uncertainties are computed via monte carlo simulations , by constructing 1000 light curves with the same number of bins as in @xmath28 , as poisson deviates for an unvarying source intensity of @xmath35 . the autocorrelation drops linearly until it becomes indistinguishable from statistical noise at a lag time of @xmath36 ks ; this is the typical signature of variability which occurs at timescales @xmath1 ks , such that count rates that are separated by longer timescales are essentially uncorrelated . at larger lag times , @xmath37 ks , the autocorrelation appears to rise again , but this is not distinguishable from statistical noise . ks , the autocorrelation drops further and becomes significantly @xmath38 , suggesting that the count rates are anticorrelated at large timescales , i.e. , the intensity tends to fluctuate over long temporal separations . however , these values are not physically meaningful , since the data gaps between observations are large and the lag time ceases to be a useful construct . note that typical observation times are 5 ks , and the observation times for contiguous obsids ranges from 12 to 62 ks , with a median of 19 ks ( see figure [ f : ctrt ] ) . ] this is consistent with the results found by raasen et al . ( 2007 ) and westbrook et al . ( 2007 ) , who found similar variations over similar timescales . however , at a counts intensity level of @xmath39 ( obtained from acis - s / hetg dispersed counts ) they were unable to detect any variability at timescales @xmath40 ks corresponding to the durations of the observations , even using sophisticated algorithms such as the one described by gregory & loredo ( 1992 ) . here , we observe the source with a counts intensity an order of magnitude higher , and are thus able to investigate the variability at shorter timescales . note that argiroffi et al . ( 2003 ) also find no variability at timescales @xmath41 ks , but again , the hrc - s / letgs data they rely on has count rates of @xmath42 , which is too small to detect the existence of variability on capella . because the observations are done in short segments , it is useful to consider the effect of removing large timescale effects on the autocorrelation . we thus reconstruct the light curve by offsetting that computed in each obsid by the average intensity of the source during that obsid ( i.e. , for each segment the average count rate is set to @xmath26 ) , and recompute the autocorrelation . this has the effect of completely removing variations at timescales greater than @xmath43 of the typical exposure time , and will reveal any variability that may exist at very small timescales . the result of this is shown as the pale blue curve in figure [ f : autocorr ] . this is everywhere consistent with no variability . because the typical observation time is 5 ks , this suggests that there is no variability variability on capella at timescales @xmath42 ks . note that offsetting the light curves by different amounts at different times , as we have done in this exercise , introduces additional statistical uncertainty into the results because of a non - stationary bias , and therefore the power of the test to detect a variability signal is decreased . in order to determine whether there does exist variability over timescales of @xmath44 ks , we test the dispersion of the fluctuations ( see [ s : overdisp ] ) . the large count rates of capella seen with the afford us the capability to analyze the light curve at short timescales . in order to test the constancy of the intensity within each obsid , we carry out a kolmogorov - smirnoff ( k - s ) test on the photon arrival time data in each obsid . a large fraction of the datasets show evidence that the null hypothesis of no variation within an observation can be rejected : 17% have @xmath45 , and 37% have @xmath46 . this is not strong evidence for short timescale variability , but the repeated rejection of the null at a frequency larger than expected indicates the possible existence of intermittent variability . also note that the k - s test generally has low power in detecting small , slow variations , and a better test is required . for that , we consider whether the observed fluctuations in the light curve are consistent with statistical deviations . such a test is also of value in establishing the magnitude of the residual calibration errors ( see [ s : hz43 ] ) . ( top ) , @xmath47 ( middle ) , and @xmath48 ( bottom ) are calculated for each obsid for different values of the light curve bin sizes @xmath49 s , and are denoted by the thin vertical lines grouped around the sim offset for that observation . the lines are offset from each other for clarity and have @xmath29 increasing from left to right , and the measured values for each obsid are connected by dark lines . the vertical lines represent the @xmath50 error bars for the _ null _ , determined from monte carlo simulations of a model without any intrinsic variability but matching the count rate and exposure time of the observation . the values expected for the null model are shown for each @xmath51 as the horizontal dashed line . the overdispersion measures computed for the combined 43data ( for a binning that matches @xmath52 s for capella ) is shown as the pale blue band whose width corresponds to the @xmath50 error bounds determined the same way as for capella . [ f : overdisp],width=528 ] the light curve ( figure [ f : ctrt ] ) shows numerous sharp fluctuations similar to that expected from poisson fluctuations . we have tested whether these fluctuations are consistent with such a picture , and conclude that they are not ; the observed fluctions are invariably _ overdispersed _ compared to the expected poisson deviations ( see figure [ f : overdisp ] ) . in particular , given a counts light curve @xmath53 for obsid @xmath54 , where @xmath55 are the @xmath32 time bins resulting from choosing a bin of size @xmath29 , we summarize the light curve with its mean @xmath56 and variance @xmath57 ^ 2 \ , , $ ] and compute three measures of overdispersion : @xmath58 ^ 2}{n_\dt\mu_j(\dt ) } \,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if the light curve fluctuations are fully explained as poisson fluctuations , we must have @xmath59 , @xmath60 , and @xmath61 , since the variance of a poisson process is equal to its mean . , and as demonstrated explicitly in [ s : hz43 ] . ] in contrast , if an additional process is operating to cause variations in the source intensity , we must have @xmath62 , @xmath63 , and @xmath64 . .average overdispersion [ t : overdisp ] [ cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ] for the dataset , computing the overdispersion measures for all obsids , for a variety of time binning sizes ( @xmath49 s ) , we find that the latter condition holds ( figure [ f : overdisp ] ; see also table [ t : overdisp ] ) for the majority of the cases . in each case , we compute the error bars on @xmath51 via monte carlo simulations of the null model , and thereby determine the significance of each measurement of the overdispersion measure by calibrating the statistic independently for the specific values of @xmath65 . thus , we find that in most of the observations , the overdispersion is significant , and hence that the observed variations in the capella light curves can not be explained as due only to poisson fluctuations . in particular , we find @xmath66 , @xmath67 , and @xmath68 as the range of the medians over the entire dataset for the three different bin sizes considered . the overdispersions tend to increase with @xmath69 , as is expected because the relative statistical error decreases with increasing counts . the averages and the standard deviations are reported in table [ t : overdisp ] for each @xmath29 , and show that the result is robust over different methods and binning sizes . the measured points are in every case except one greater than the nominal value for the null , and the large standard deviations arise from large deviations upward . thus we conclude that capella exhibits variability over durations that characterize the observations , i.e. , at timescales @xmath44 ks . more sophisticated analyses ( which are in progress ) are necessary to fully characterize this variability . these measurements suggest that the intrinsic variability has an effect that is of similar magnitude to the poisson process , and that we are able to detect it primarily because of the large count rates and because the large number of independent datasets allows us to check that all give similar results . our analysis does not allow a direct calculation of the intensity variations that result in these overdispersion values , but assuming a model with small deviations , we estimate that intensity variations of the order @xmath70 are consistent with the observed @xmath51 . since such intensity variations are of the same order as the expected poisson fluctuations in the light curves , it is not surprising that methods such as the kolmogorov - smirnoff test and fourier analysis fail to detect the existence of the subtle variability in the data . similarly , argiroffi et al . ( 2003 ) place a @xmath71 limit on the variability at @xmath72 , based on hrc - s / letgs data where capella has a count rate of @xmath73 . with the , count rates @xmath74 times higher are observed , which allows us to detect the existence of such variability at @xmath75 ( figure [ f : overdisp ] ) . as the source position changes on the detector with each observation , and even during a single observation as it dithers across the detector , the source passes over regions with different quantum efficiencies ( qe ) . variations in the qe will lead to corresponding differences in the observed count rate , and may produce a false signal of variability . in comparing the source intensities from different obsids , we have taken the qe variations into account using the current best estimate of the qe map , which is estimated to be accurate to @xmath76 across the detector ( posson - brown & donnelly 2004 ; figure [ f : ctrt ] suggests that the relative error in the qe map is considerably lower ) . while computing the overdispersion measures however , we do not make such corrections in order to not bias the statistical estimates . instead , we estimate the contribution of the local variations in qe to the overdispersion by comparing the variances in the light curves generated with and without correcting for this effect : the observed @xmath77 increases by @xmath78 , which is negligible compared to the magnitude of the observed overdispersions ( figure [ f : overdisp ] ) . as a further test , we have carried out fourier transforms of the counts light curves ; these show no evidence of a periodic signal , as would be present at frequencies corresponding to the dither periods if qe variations were to make a significant contribution to the variability . in addition , we place a direct limit on the residual calibration uncertainty by comparing the analysis of capella with that of a known non - varying source , 43 . 43 is a h - rich da white dwarf with a temperature @xmath79 kk ( dupuis et al . it has no known or expected variability , and thus serves as a comparison target to verify the effect of the residual calibration uncertainty . the source has been observed numerous times as a calibration target by in the + letgs configuration , and has thus far been observed for a total of 31.3 ks at the nominal aimpoint . the observed count rate is 3.6 , and coincidentally the accumulated counts approximately matches the number of counts produced in any given capella obsid , making it an excellent proxy to test for the existence of any instrument - based variability . we measure the overdispersion in 43 at various bin sizes , set such that the same number of counts are expected in each bin as for the capella data . for instance the capella light curve binned at @xmath52 s is approximately matched by a 43 light curve binned at @xmath80 s ; i.e. , absent intrinsic variations , and assuming that the magnitude of the local qe variations are spatial scale independent , both curves should have identical statistical properties . we find that the 43 overdispersion measures are fully consistent with there being no intrinsic variability whatsoever ( see figure [ f : overdisp ] ) , and thus serve to confirm the detection of overdispersion in the capella data . stellar coronae are generally considered to be analogous to the solar corona , in the sense that the x - ray emission arises from optically thin , collissionally excited plasma , which is organized in active regions by magnetic fields and is probably heated by magnetic reconnection events . in the case of capella , the energetics indeed support this view : the surface area of both components is @xmath81 times that of the sun ( table [ t : capella ] ) , and the x - ray luminosity is correspondingly higher , at @xmath81 times the solar luminosity at the peak of its activity cycle . this is consistent with the picture of a solar like atmosphere , with the coronae dominated by loops in active regions that cover a large fraction of the surface . however , the temperatures on capella s coronae are significantly hotter , and the strong emission component at @xmath82 mk has no corresponding structure on the sun . we have established above ( [ s : autocorr],[s : overdisp ] ) that capella exhibits variability over timescales ranging from @xmath83 ks . while the longer timescale variability could arise simply due to slow evolution of active regions , the variability at shorter timescales ( @xmath84 ks ) is likely due to the dynamical balance of heating events and cooling . because capella maintains its luminosity to within a few percent , it must be that heating and cooling events are in balance for the most part , and therefore the variability timescale must be matched to the total coronal heating rate changes , and hence to the radiative cooling timescales . ( for typical coronal densities , conductive cooling is not a factor at these timescales . ) we can estimate the physical characteristics of the capella coronae based on this correspondence . the cooling timescale , @xmath85 where @xmath86 is the electron number density , and @xmath87 is the power emitted by a unit volume of the plasma at temperature @xmath88 . adopting a coronal temperature of @xmath89 , and a metallicity @xmath90 ( see brickhouse et al . 2000 ) , the power emitted is @xmath91 ergs @xmath92 s@xmath20 , and we estimate the coronal number density @xmath93 where @xmath94 . this is consistent with the limit @xmath95 @xmath96 found by ness et al . ( 2003 ) based on an analysis of the neix triplet in and xmm-_newton _ grating data . for the observed luminosity ( see [ s : data ] ) and the adopted temperature , the volume emission measure @xmath97 @xmath96 . assuming that the emission is spread uniformly across the surface of both stars , and adopting a visible surface area 100 times that of the sun , we estimate the height of the corona @xmath98 where @xmath99 is the surface filling fraction of active regions . this is comparable to the typical loop sizes seen on the sun , but is small compared to the density scale height on capella , @xmath100 cm . we assume here that the entire corona is part of the balance between the heating and cooling occuring at the detected variability timescales . it is possible however that there are multiple components of emission in the corona : the small timescale variability may be due to a small portion of the corona , e.g. , as in x - ray bright points on the sun , and the bulk of the emission may arise in a lower density component that cools slowly and is heated correspondingly slower and reaches to a height comparable to the density scale height . however , this scenario appears to be ruled out by the analysis of high - resolution euv spectra by sanz - forcada , brickhouse , & dupree ( 2003 ) , who suggest that the bulk of the plasma on capella is at high densities . note that while we have confined our attention to @xmath101 ks , we can not formally rule out variability at shorter timescales ( more sophisticated analyses are in progress ) . such variability will act to increase the estimate for the coronal density @xmath86 and decrease the height of the emission layer @xmath102 . we speculate that the most probable scenario for emission on capella is one where it is dominated by numerous low - lying activity sites . we have analyzed a deep / observation of the active binary capella to detect variability at timescales shorter than 50 ks . capella is a highly stable coronal source on which hitherto no short term variability had been seen , despite its relatively high activity level . the is uniquely positioned to achieve this objective because it allows the measurement of large count rates ( @xmath13 ) with no pileup effects . the unprecedented data quality allows us to test for the existence of variability at timescales as short as 5 ks . we confirm the conclusion of argiroffi et al . ( 2003 ) , raasen et al . ( 2007 ) , and westbrook et al . ( 2007 ) that capella exhibits intensity variations at the @xmath103 level over timescales of months and years , but unlike those studies which were limited in statistical power due to low count rates , we detect variability at timescales @xmath0 ks . we apply numerous statistical tests such as autocorrelation , overdispersion , k - s , etc . , to the data , both cumulatively and in individual observation segments , and find that variability does exist at timescales @xmath104 ks . this suggests that the coronal plasma is at a relatively low density ( @xmath105 @xmath96 ) and that the emission arises in low - lying loops with heights @xmath106 cm . argiroffi , c. , maggio , a. , & peres , g. , 2003 , a&a , 404 , 1033 brickhouse , n.s . , dupree , a.k . , edgar , r.j . , liedahl , d.a . , drake , s.a . , white , n.e . , singh , k.p . , 2000 , apj , 530 , 387 caramazza , m. , flaccomio , e. , micela , g. , reale , f. , wolk , s.j . , & feigelson , e.d . , 2007 , a&a , 471 , 645 colombo , j.f.a . , caramazza , m. , flaccomio , e. , micela , g. , & sciortino , s. , 2007 , astro - ph/0708.2399 dupree , a.k . , & brickhouse , n.s . , 1996 , in poster proc . , iau symp . 176 : stellar surface structure ( wien : institut fr astronomie ) , 184 dupuis , j. , vennes , s. , chayer , p. , hurwitz , m. , bowyer , s. , 1998 , apjl , 500 , l45 favata , f. , flaccomio , e. , reale , f. , micela , g. , sciortino , s. , shang , h. , stassun , k.g . , & feigelson , e.d . , 2005 , apjs , 160 , 469f gdel , m. , 2004 , a&arev , 12 , 71 ishibashi , k. , dewey , d. , huenemoerder , d. p. , & testa , p. , 2006 , apj , 644 , 117 johnson , o. , drake , j. j. , kashyap , v. , brickhouse , n. s. , dupree , a. k. , freeman , p. , young , p. r. , & kriss , g.a . , 2002 , apj , 565 , 97 kashyap , v. , & drake , j.j . , 1999 , apj , 524 , 988 kashyap , v.l . , drake , j.j . , gdel , m. , & audard , m. , 2002 , apj , 580 , 1118 linsky , j. l. , wood , b. e. , brown , a. , & osten , r. a. , 1998 , apj , 492 , 767 ness , j .- u . , brickhouse , n.s . , drake , j.j . , & huenemoerder , d.p . , 2003 , apj , 598 , 1277 osten , r.a . , brown , a. , ayres , t.a . , drake , s.a . , franciosini , e. , pallavicini , r. , tagliaferri , g. , stewart , r.t . , skinner , s.l . , & linsky , j.l . , 2004 , apjs , 153 , 317 osten , r.a . , & brown , a. , 1999 , apj , 515 , 746 pease , d.o . , kashyap , v.l . , ratzlaff , p.w . , drake , j.j . , evans , n.r . , mossman , a.e . , kim , d. , green , p.j . , & the champ collaboration , 2006 , aas - head , 9 , 01.01 posson - brown , j. , & donnelly , r.h . , 2004 , at the calibration workshop , 25 oct 2004 raassen , a. j. j. , kaastra , j. s. , a&ap , 461 , 679 sanz - forcada , j. , brickhouse , n.s . , & dupree , a.k . , 2003 , apjs , 145 , 147 stassun , k.g . , van den berg , m. , feigelson , e. , & flaccomio , e. , 2006 , apj , 649 , 914 strassmeier , k.g . , hall , d.s . , fekel , f.c . , & scheck , m. , 1993 , a&as , 100 , 173 westbrook , o.w . , evans , n.r . , wolk , s.j . , kashyap , v.l . , nichols , j.s . , mendygral , p.j . , slavin , j.d . , & waldron , w.l . , 2007 , apjs , submitted young , p. r. , dupree , a. k. , wood , b. e. , redfield , s. , linsky , j. l. , ake , t. b. , & moos , h. w. , 2001 , apj , 555 , l121

we analyze 205 ks of imaging data of the active binary , capella , obtained with the high resolution camera imager ( hrc - i ) to determine whether capella shows any variability at timescales @xmath0 ks . we find that a clear signal for variability is present for timescales @xmath1 ks , and that the light curves show evidence for excess fluctuation over that expected from a purely poisson process . this overdispersion is consistent with variability at the 2 - 7% level , and suggests that the coronae on the binary components of capella are composed of low - density plasma and low - lying loops .

astro-ph0610730

the external shock model predicts afterglows characterized by a power - law decay in time , with the possible presence of breaks connecting branches of different slope ( & rees 1997 ) . such changes are due to either geometrical properties of the fireball ( geometrical beaming , rhoads 1999 ) or to spectral transitions ( e.g. from a cooling to a non - cooling electron population , sari , piran & narayan 1998 ) . in the pre-_swift _ era , most afterglows were consistent with the simplest version of this model . there were , however , notable exceptions , such as grb 000301c ( masetti et al . 2000 ) , grb 021004 ( lazzati et al . 2002 ) , and grb 030329 ( matheson et al . all these bursts displayed optical variability in the form of bumps or wiggles superimposed on the smooth power - law decay . a number of explanations have been discussed in the literature to account for the variations in the optical afterglow brightness . these include inhomogeneities in the external density ( wang & loeb 2000 ; lazzati et al . 2002 ; heyl & perna 2003 ) , refreshed shocks due to the collision of a late shell of plasma with the external shock material ( rees & 1998 ) , angular inhomogeneities in the fireball energy distribution ( nakar , piran & granot 2002 ) and gravitational lensing ( loeb & perna 1998 ; garnavich , loeb & stanek 2000 ) . different mechanisms to produce variability in afterglows can in principle be distinguished through their temporal and spectral properties . in practice , however , a consensus has not been yet reached due to the lack of unambiguous observations . more recently , _ swift _ observations have revealed that flaring activity is relatively common in the early phases of grb afterglows , sometimes extending for over a day ( e.g. , chincarini 2006 ; obrien et al . the temporal properties of the flares , their intensity , and their spectra suggest an origin that is unrelated to the external shock ( chincarini 2006 ; falcone et al . 2006 ) , at least for a fraction of the bumps . late episodes of `` prompt emission '' can have two different origin . one possibility is that the inner engine itself is active for a time as long as the detection time of the x - ray flare . alternatively , the engine can be short - lived but produce , together with the fast ejecta , a tail of slower material . such slower material can produce internal dissipation ( and therefore prompt emission ) at late time . slow shells ejected immediately after the fast ejecta will not produce an external shock at the canonical external shock radius since the ambient medium has been swept by the external shock produced by the fast ejecta , which develops earlier . distinguishing between these two scenarios bears important implications for the physics of the grb engine . in this paper we discuss the timescales of flares in the different scenarios . we show that at least a large fraction of x - ray flares are due to a long lasting activity of the grb engine , rather than to external shock activity or to the emission of slow shells immediately after the prompt emission ends . this paper is organized as follows : in sect . 2 we compute external shock timescales while in sect . 3 we consider prompt emission flares and in sect . 4 we discuss our results and compare them to _ swift _ data . we summarize our findings in sect . 5 . consider flaring activity produced by a sudden brightening of the external shock . we consider now a brightening that involves the whole surface of the external shock . even if the duration of the activity in the comoving frame is negligible , the observer at infinity still detects photons over a finite amount of time , due to the `` curvature effect '' ( see fig . [ fig : curva ] ) . the shape of the observed pulse is therefore the narrowest possible in time . a longer activity in the comoving frame will produce a longer pulse , obtained by convolution of the two functional shapes . let us define the quantity @xmath0 to be the energy released by the unit area of the fireball as a result of the flaring activity , in the comoving frame . the flux received at infinity is given by ( see also kumar & panaitescu 2000 ) : @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the distance to the source , @xmath3^{-1}$ ] is the doppler factor , @xmath4 is the fireball surface and @xmath5 the time in the observer frame . this is given by : @xmath6\ , . \label{eq : tobs}\ ] ] equation ( [ eq : tobs ] ) holds for any self - similar dynamical evolution where @xmath7 , as long as @xmath8 . note that we indicate with the subscript @xmath9 quantities ( such as lorentz factor and speed ) of the external shock , and without subscript the same quantities for the material just behind the shock . it can be shown that @xmath10 ( e.g. , sari 1997 ) . easy considerations show that the only non constant quantity in eq . ( [ eq : fnu ] ) is the doppler factor , since @xmath11 , and all the radiation is emitted at constant radius @xmath12 . if we assume that we are far from a break in the afterglow spectrum , @xmath13 and the functional shape of @xmath14 can be rewritten as : @xmath15 solving eq . ( [ eq : tobs ] ) for @xmath16 , and expressing time in unit of the start time of the flare @xmath17 $ ] , the flare profile can be written as : @xmath18 where @xmath19 . equation [ eq : fnu2 ] can be used to provide a lower limit to an observationally sound definition of the flare duration . defining the duration as the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of the pulse , and the reference time as the time t@xmath20 of the flare maximum , we obtain : @xmath21 equation ( [ eq : dtt ] ) depends on both the dynamics and spectrum of the external shock . a steeper spectrum and/or a more slowly evolving fireball will cause a narrower flare . note that in this case ( i.e. impulsive rebrightening of the shock ) , the maximum coincides with the start time . should the activity in the comoving frame last for a finite amount of time , a rising phase would be observed . a more detailed treatment , including the width of the shell of shocked material would also provide a profile with a finite rising time . figure [ fig : dtt ] shows the time scale ratio for four typical values of @xmath22 as a function of the spectral index . the most relevant case for x - ray flares is the adiabatic ism case , with a spectral slope @xmath23 . we find for that specific case : @xmath24 . in an analogous context , zhang et al . ( 2006 ) discussed the possible production of flares by various mechanisms such as density bumps , post - energy injection in the blast wave , and two - components or patchy jets . in all cases , they concluded that the characteristics of the flares were not generally consistent with what predicted by these models ( i.e. @xmath25 and a slower - than observed flux decline ) . here , we have derived detailed , quantitative , upper limits on the value of @xmath26 . our constraints are somewhat tighter than what previously derived by different authors in the context of the external model for flares ( e.g. , ioka , kobayashi & zhang 2005 ) but comparable to more recent results ( wu et al . 2006 ) . our method differs in two important ways from what done in previous work . first , we have computed the actual functional shape of the flare , and defined rigorously the time reference we adopt ( the peak ) and the time width ( the fwhm ) . in previous works , these quantities were usually poorly defined , and the results could only be approximate . secondly , we considered the difference between the lorentz factor of the shock and that of the shocked material . this factor by itself leads to flares which are broader by a factor of two . chincarini ( 2006 ) presents a distribution of @xmath27 for a sample of _ swift _ x - ray flares that is defined as the ratio of the gaussian @xmath28 over the peak time . the distribution is shown in their fig . 8 and shaded in fig . [ fig : dtt ] . since for a gaussian the @xmath29 is equal to @xmath30 , we can easily convert their definition of @xmath31 into our definition . we conclude that the distribution of @xmath27 of _ swift _ x - ray flares is characterized by @xmath32 and has average @xmath33 . considering fig . [ fig : dtt ] , we conclude that most , if not all , the detected rebrightenings are not related to events taking place on the external shock , unless only a small portion of the shock is involved in the rebrightening . flares caused by a small portion of the shock are possible , but are unlikely to be very strong . nakar & granot ( 2006 ) studied the effect of a blob of high density interacting with the shock . they find that the rebrightening is minor , and characterized by a very slow rise . alternatively , a large rebrightening on a small timescale can be observed if a narrow opening angle shell refreshes a small part of the external shock ( granot , nakar & piran 2003 ) . this is not likely to be the case for the _ swift _ x - ray flares , since most of them are observed before the jet break time ( chincarini 2006 , obrien 2006 ) and the opening angle of the jet grows with time ( lazzati & begelman 2005 ; morsony , lazzati & begelman 2006 ) rather than decrease . since the largest majority of flares is unlikely to be produced within the external shock , it must be produced during the initial phase of internal dissipation . in the following we therefore discuss flaring activity in the context of the prompt emission . in this case one can envisage two possible scenarios for their production : _ ( a ) _ shells that are produced during the grb phase but that dissipate at much later times ; _ ( b ) _ shells produced at late times by a long - lived engine and dissipating on a timescale comparable to that of the engine duration . zhang et al . ( 2006 ) also concluded that the flares have an internal origin , but directly assumed that the engine must have been long - lived . in this section we try to discriminate between the scenarios _ ( a ) _ and _ ( b)_. being able to discriminate between these two scenarios bears important implications for our understanding of the physics of the inner grb engine ( see more discussion on this in 4 ) . in the following , we discuss the two scenarios above , provide diagnostics for each of them , and show that the current _ swift _ data is already able to discriminate between the two flare - production mechanisms . _ ( a ) flaring activity due to dissipation within a freely expanding flow , released during the prompt grb phase or shortly afterwards . _ this case has two important differences with respect to the external shock case studied above . first , there is no propagating shock , and therefore there is no distinction between @xmath34 and @xmath35 . second , the flare is produced by material that has been coasting at constant @xmath34 , rather than by material that has been slowing down . these two differences change considerably the equations above . without repeating the derivation of sect . 2 , it can be easily seen that the result for the freely expanding flow can be obtained by substituting @xmath36 with @xmath37 and adopting @xmath38 in eq . [ eq : dtt ] . this yields : @xmath39 which , for the typical case of @xmath23 yields @xmath40 ( see wu et al . 2006 for a similar computation restricted to the case of internal shocks ) . this number is tantalizing similar to the average width of _ swift _ x - ray flares ( chincarini 2006 ; fig . [ fig : dtt ] ) . yet , there is a sizable number of events for which the condition is violated by almost an order of magnitude . in addition , should the condition be barely satisfied , the decay part of the flare would be dominated by large angle emission ( kumar & panaitescu 2000 ; liang et al . this seems not to be the case , at least in some of the flares ( guetta et al . note however that the large angle emission should not dominate any flare with a duration significantly larger than the one given in eq . ( [ eq : dtt2 ] ) . _ ( b ) shell that is ejected from the central engine after a time @xmath41 sizably larger than the prompt emission timescale @xmath42 . _ if radiation is released at radius @xmath12 , it will be observed at a time ( cfr . [ eq : tobs ] ) @xmath43 which produces a shortening of the observed variability timescale @xmath44 equation ( [ eq : dtts ] ) allows for any arbitrarily small time scale , as long as the shell that produces radiation is ejected at a time comparable to the detection time . therefore , the detection of fast flares implies that the inner engine is active for a time much longer than the canonical prompt phase ( @xmath42 ) . the observation of a flare that peaks at time @xmath45 and is characterized by a width @xmath31 allows us to constrain the time at which it was ejected from the central engine : @xmath46 equations ( [ eq : dtt2 ] ) and ( [ eq : dtts ] ) are general and hold for any dissipation and radiation mechanism that take place in the whole jet . locally beamed emission mechanisms can produce fast variability ( see , e.g. , lyutikov & blandford 2004 ) , but the peak luminosity of the flares would drop faster than observed as a function of @xmath45 . consider now the flares observed by _ ( for a recent review , see http://www.swift.ac.uk/rs06/burrows.pdf ) . they can be observed up to @xmath47 s after the grb onset and are characterized by a fwhm time @xmath48 . applying this observational constraint implies that at least in about half of the cases the ejection time of the material from the central engine is comparable to the time at which the flare is observed . in other words , grb engines are active well beyond the observed @xmath42 of the prompt emission , in some cases for up to @xmath49 s or a day timescale . this provides an important constraint to the properties of the inner engine of long duration grbs . more can be obtained by further analysis of the properties of the flares . flares are observed over a wide range of times , spanning about three orders of magnitude ( from @xmath50 to @xmath51 s after the end of the prompt emission ) . the distribution of @xmath52 is however much narrower , spanning approximately only one order of magnitude . this implies a correlation between the ejection time and the duration of the ejection episode . the longer is the time after the engine turns on , the longer is the ejection episode . interestingly , an analogous property was noted in grbs with multiple prompt emission episodes ( ramirez - ruiz & merloni 2001 ) . during the prompt phase , the duration of an emission episode is strongly correlated with the length of the quiescent time that precedes it . in the case of flares we can conclude that the correlation is with the total time since the engine onset ; however , this does not imply the absence of a correlation with the length of the quiescent time . our results bear important implications for an understanding of the physical processes governing the grb inner engine , which provides the ultimate source of energy to power grbs . the grb `` inner engine '' is believed to be a hyperaccreting accretion disk . in the collapsar model ( paczynsky 1998 ; macfadyen & woosley 1999 ) , this is formed by the fallback material from the collapsing envelope of the massive star , and the timescale for the duration of the accretion episode is set by the dynamical timescale of the collapsing envelope itself , which is on the order of several tens of seconds . on the other hand , in the binary merger model ( e.g. neutron star - neutron star or neutron star - black hole ; eichler et al . 1989 ) , the accretion material is provided by the debris of the tidally disrupted neutron star ( or white dwarf ) . in this case , the timescale over which the available material is accreted is set by the viscous timescale of the disk , which is a fraction of a second . the accretion timescale in the collapsar model easily accounts for the duration of the prompt emission for the class of long bursts , while the accretion timescale in the binary merger model naturally yields the required timescales for the prompt emission of short bursts . several types of observations in the last few years have indeed provided a strong support for the association between long grbs and the collapse of a massive star ( stanek et al . 2003 ; hjorth et al . 2003 ) , while several pieces of evidence are gradually mounting toward the association of compact - object mergers and short bursts ( fox et al . 2005 ; bloom et al . 2006 ; nakar , gal - yam & fox 2006 ) . in the scenarios above , a relativistic outflow is ejected from the central engine , and radiation is produced as the bulk kinetic energy is dissipated and radiated at a given radius . there is no a - priori constraint on the distribution of the lorentz factor in the outflow . if the lorentz factor of the ejecta should decrease with the ejection time , late time internal activity could be seen without the need for a long - living engine . we have shown that this is not the case , at least in a sizable fraction of the flares . this result makes the studies of possible mechanisms of reactivation of the grb engine especially timely . king et al . ( 2005 ) suggested that fragmentation of the collapsing star could explain a ( single ) flare in the case of long bursts , while dai et al . ( 2006 ) proposed a new mechanism of binary merger that can incorporate the presence of a flare for short bursts . perna , armitage & zhang ( 2006 ) noted that the fact that flares are observed in both long and short bursts , and with similar characteristics in both cases , is suggestive that the place of formation be in what is common between the two classes of bursts , i.e. the accretion disk . a disk that fragments as a result of gravitational instabilities in its outer parts , as supported by studies of hyperaccreting disks ( di matteo , perna & narayan 2002 ; chen & beloborodov 2006 ) , can account for flares with similar properties in both long and short bursts , as well as accounting for the observed correlation between the flare duration and its arrival time ( see also piro & pfahl 2006 ) . other disk - based models involve magnetic instabilities ( proga & zhang 2006 ; giannios 2006 ) . staff , ouyed & bagchi ( 2006 ) proposed instead a mechanism based on state transitions in the quark - nova scenario , while the role of a magnetar was discussed by gao & fan ( 2006 ) and cea ( 2006 ) . if an `` internal '' flare , i.e. , a flare due to internal dissipation , is observed in a grb , it must be followed at later time by an external flare . the material responsible for the internal flare keeps expanding at constant speed , and must eventually catch up with the external shock , which decelerates continuously . it may however be difficult to observe the second flare , since it may be weak and dispersed over several orders of magnitudes in time . if , however , the second flare can be singled out and firmly associated to an external flare , it would provide additional important information for our understanding of the dynamics of the system . consider a flare system made by an internal flare beginning at time @xmath53 followed by a second , broader , flare starting at time @xmath54 , where @xmath55 . the external flare time can tell us the lorentz factor of the material producing the internal flare : @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the isotropic equivalent kinetic energy of the fireball integrated up to the time of ejection of the late shell , @xmath58 the numeric density of the external medium , and @xmath59 the proton mass . we have assumed a uniform external medium . equations can be easily generalized to an arbitrary density profile , but will be simple only in the case of adiabatic evolution . equation ( [ eq : gamma ] ) depends only on measurable quantities . an example of a solvable system is the flare system of grb 050502b . falcone et al . ( 2006 ) were able to identify an initial strong flare and a possible refreshed shock flare at later times . they were able to measure the bulk lorentz factor of the late engine ejecta to be @xmath60 , ejected from the inner engine approximately @xmath61 second after the onset . by itself this observation only tells us that the late ejections are likely to have a smaller lorentz factor than the early ones . solving a large numbers of flare systems in different grbs would however provide us with an ensemble of late ejections that would allow us to constrain both the properties of the engine and of the dissipation / radiation mechanism . the knowledge of the bulk lorentz factor of the late shells would provide us with a sample of flares for which the comoving spectra are known , ridding the prompt emission models of one of the unknown parameters : the lorentz factor . we have analyzed the timescale of flares produced by several mechanisms both due to internal dissipation and external shock phenomena . we have shown that all prominent external shock flares occurring before the jet break must have a long time scale @xmath62 . we also showed that internal dissipation taking place in slow shells ejected immediately after the end of the prompt phase must satisfy a similar constraint : @xmath63 . the only mechanism capable of producing flares with a short time scale as observed by _ swift _ is identified with late activity of the inner engine . as a consequence , the detection of x - ray flares at times as long as @xmath51 seconds after the grb onset implies that the inner engine is active for at least @xmath51 s. this has important implications for the fueling of the engine and the ejection mechanism . we thank dafne guetta and luigi piro for useful conversations . this work was supported by nasa astrophysical theory grant nng06gi06 g ( dl ) , nsf grant ast-0307502 ( dl ) and ast 0507571 ( dl & rp ) , and _ swift _ guest investigator program nnx06ab69 g ( dl ) and nng05gh55 g ( dl & rp ) . bloom j. et al . 2006 , apj , 638 , 354 cea p. , 2006 , apj in press ( astro - ph/0606086 ) chen w .- x . , beloborodov a. m. , 2006 , apj in press , ( astro - ph/0607145 ) chincarini g. , 2006 , proceedings of the vulcano workshop 2006 , vulcano , italy , may 22 - 27 , edited by f. giovannelli & g. mannocchi ( astro - ph/0608414 ) dai z. g. , wang x. y. , wu x. f. , zhang b. , 2006 , science , 311 , 1127 di matteo t. , perna r. , narayan r. , 2002 , apj , 579 , 706 eichler d. , livio m. , piran t. schramm d. n. , 1989 , nature , 340 , 126 falcone a. d. , et al . , 2006 , apj , 641 , 1010 fox d. b. , et al . , 2005 , nature , 437 , 845 gao w .- h . , fan y .- z . , 2006 , chjaa , 6 , 513 garnavich p. m. , loeb a. , stanek k. z. , 2000 , apj , 544 , l11 giannios d. , 2006 , a&a , 455l , 5 granot j. , piran t. , sari r. , 1999 , apj , 513 , 679 granot j. , nakar e. , piran t. , 2003 , nature , 426 , 138 guetta d. , delia v. , fiore f. , conciatore m. l. , antonelli l. a. , stella l .. 2006 , il nuovo cimento in press ( astro - ph/0610512 ) heyl j. s. , perna r. , 2003 , apj , 586l , 13 hjorth j. , et al . , 2003 , nature , 423 , 84 ioka k. , kobayashi s. , zhang b. , 2005 , apj , 631 , 429 king a. , obrien p. t. , goad m. r. , osborne j. , olsson e. , page k. , 2005 , apj , 630l , 113 kumar p. , panaitescu a. , 2000 , apj , 541 , l51 lazzati d. , rossi e. , covino s. , ghisellini g. , malesani d. , 2002 , a&a , 396l , 5 lazzati d. , begelman m. c. , 2005 , apj , 629 , 903 liang e. w. , et al . , 2006 , apj , 646 , 351 loeb a. , perna r. , 1998 , apj , 495 , 597 lyutikov m. , blandford r. , 2004 , aspc , 312 , 449 matheson t. , et al . , 2003 , apj , 599 , 394 macfadyen a. i. , woosley s. e. , 1999 , apj , 524 , 262 masetti n. , et al . , 2000 , a&a , 359 , l23 p. , rees m. j. , 1997 , apj , 476 , 232 morsony b. j. , lazzati d. , begelman m. c. , 2006 , apj submitted ( astro - ph/0609254 ) nakar e. , piran t. , granot j. , 2003 , newa , 8 , 495 nakar e. , granot j. , 2006 , mnras submitted ( astro - ph/0606011 ) nakar e. , gal - yam a. , fox d. b. , 2006 , apj , 650 , 281 obrien p. t. , et al . , 2006 , apj , 647 , 1213 paczynsky b. , 1998 , apj , 494l , 45 perna r. , armitage p. j. , zhang b. , 2006 , apj , 636l , 29 piro a. l. , pfahl e. , 2006 , apj submitted ( astro - ph/0610696 ) proga d. , zhang b. , 2006 , mnras , 370l , 61 ramirez - ruiz e. , merloni a. , 2001 , mnras , 320 , l25 rees m. j. , meszaros p. , 1998 , apj , 496 , l1 rhoads j. e. , 1999 , apj , 525 , 737 sari r. , 1997 , apj , 489 , l37 sari r. , piran t. , narayan r. , 1998 , apj , 497 , l17 staff j. , ouyed r. , bagchi m. , 2006 , apj submitted ( astro - ph/0608470 ) stanek k. , et al . 2003 , apj , 591l , 17 wang x. , loeb a. , 2000 , apj , 535 , 788 wu x. f. , dai z. g. , wang x. y. , huang y. f. , feng l. l. , lu t. , 2006 , apj submitted ( astro - ph/0512555 ) zhang b. , et al . , 2006 , apj , 642 , 370

the detection of bright x - ray flares superimposed on the regular afterglow decay in _ swift _ gamma - ray bursts has triggered theoretical speculations on their origin . we study the temporal properties of flares due to internal dissipation and external shock mechanisms . we first show that at least a sizable fraction of the flares can not be related to external shock mechanisms , since external shock flares evolve on much longer time scales than observed . we then study flares from internal dissipation , showing that the temporal properties allow us to distinguish the emission of slow early shells from that of late faster shells . we show that , due to the rapid evolution of the detected flares , it is most likely that the flares are produced by relatively fast shells ejected by the central engine shortly before they are observed . this implies that the central engine must be active for , in some cases , as long as one day . we finally discuss the constraints and implications that this observation has on the properties and physics of the inner engine , and we elaborate on possible future observational tests on the flare sample to further understand their origin and physics . gamma - ray : bursts radiation mechanisms : non - thermal

1410.2696

we are interested in predicting the hadronic cross section , which is known to factorize into parton distribution functions and the partonic cross section _ h_1h_2(p_1 , p_2 ) = _ ab _ 0 ^ 1 x_1 x_2 f_a / h_1(x_1 , ) f_b / h_2(x_2 , ) _ ab(x_1p_1 , x_2p_2 ; ( ) , , ) . the summation runs over initial state partons @xmath0 , i.e. massless quarks and gluons . the parton distribution function @xmath1 can be understood as the probability density for finding parton @xmath2 inside hadron @xmath3 carrying the momentum @xmath4 . parton distribution functions are non - perturbative objects and have to be determined experimentally . + in contrast , the partonic cross section @xmath5 can be calculated using perturbative qcd . including terms up to next - to - next - to - leading order , its expansion in the strong coupling @xmath6 reads _ ab = ^(0)_ab + ^(1)_ab + ^(2)_ab . the leading order contribution is known as the born approximation and reads ^(0)_ab = ^_ab = _ n _ n^(0 ) | _ n^(0 ) _ n , where @xmath7 is the number of final state particles and @xmath8 the phase space measure . the measurement functions @xmath9 defines the infrared safe observable and prevents @xmath7 massless partons from becoming soft or collinear . the @xmath10-loop matrix element is denoted by @xmath11 . for details of the notation we refer to @xcite . + beyond leading order , we decompose the cross section according to the number of particles in the final state . at next - to - leading order ( nlo ) we have [ eq : nlo ] ^(1)_ab = ^_ab + ^_ab + ^_ab , with ^_ab = _ n+1 _ n+1^(0 ) | _ n+1^(0 ) _ n+1 , ^_ab = _ n 2 _ n^(0 ) | _ n^(1 ) _ n . starting at this order , separate contributions suffer from soft and collinear ( infrared ) divergences . they appear as poles in the regulator @xmath12 after setting the space - time dimension to @xmath13 . we distinguish between explicit virtual poles , that emerge in the one - loop matrix element @xmath14 of the virtual contribution @xmath15 , and real poles , that appear after integrating the phase space of the additional parton of the real contribution @xmath16 . all poles cancel in the sum . + at next - to - next - to leading order ( nnlo ) we get [ eq : nnlo ] ^(2)_ab = ^_ab + ^_ab + ^_ab + ^_ab + ^_ab , where [ eq : nnloexp ] ^_ab = _ n+2 _ n+2^(0 ) | _ n+2^(0 ) _ n+2 , + ^_ab = _ n+1 2 _ n+1^(0 ) | _ n+1^(1 ) _ n+1 , + ^_ab = _ n ( 2 _ n^(0 ) | _ n^(2 ) + _ n^(1 ) | _ n^(1 ) ) _ n . the double - real contribution @xmath17 contains two additional massless partons in the final state that can become unresolved and lead to poles in @xmath12 after the phase space integration is performed . the real - virtual contribution @xmath18 consists of the one - loop amplitude integrated over the @xmath19 particle phase space . in addition to virtual poles of the one - loop matrix element , it develops real poles by integrating the phase space of one unresolved particle . the double - virtual contribution @xmath20 contains only explicit virtual poles in the two - loop amplitude and the squared one - loop amplitude . the sum of all contributions in is finite . , @xmath21 and @xmath22 are not mentioned in this discussion . for details see @xcite . ] + in general it is not possible to perform phase space integrations analytically . furthermore , to be able to compare a predicition with experimental data the phase space integration should be implemented in a flexible monte - carlo software to adapt the observable to the experimental setup easily . + subtraction methods at nlo have been established to handle infrared singularities before numerical integrations are performed . catani - seymour subtraction @xcite and fks subtraction @xcite are commonly used schemes . + at nnlo , subtraction schemes become more involved . antenna subtraction @xcite and @xmath23 - subtraction @xcite are the most advanced proposals and have already been applied to @xmath24 @xcite , @xmath25 @xcite , higgs production @xcite and vector boson pair production @xcite and other non - trivial examples @xcite . + in these schemes poles cancel analytically . we illustrate this by taking the real and virtual contribution of a nlo cross section in . the real - radiation cross section is made integrable in four dimensions by a suitable subtraction term that mimics the behaviour of the squared matrix element in the singular limits . adding the subtracted term back and integrating it analytically over the unresolved one - particle phase space provides poles that cancel the poles of the virtual contribution . finally , both phase space integrals are numerically integrable in four dimensions . + at nnlo the procedure is similar : subtraction terms for real unresolved particles are introduced to render the phase space integrable . analytically integrated subtraction terms cancel the explicit poles of virtual contributions . + here we present stripper ( sector improved phase space for real radiation ) , a nnlo subtraction scheme that is completely numerical and avoids cumbersome analytic integrations . the scheme was introduced in @xcite and generalized to arbitrary final states in @xcite . it has been first applied to top - quark pair production @xcite , and subsequently to other processes of low multiplicity : higgs @xmath26 jet @xcite , charmless bottom quark decay @xcite , top quark decay @xcite , single top quark production @xcite , muon decay @xcite and z decay @xcite . + the scheme was initially formulated using conventional dimensional regularization ( cdr ) , where momenta and spin degrees of freedom of resolved and unresolved particles are treated in @xmath13 dimensions . unresolved particles are either virtual particles of loop contributions or real - radiated particles that can become soft or collinear . in contrast to analytic subtraction schemes , momenta of resolved particles are explicitly parameterized in @xmath27 dimensions . the explicit dimension increases as the multiplicity of the final state rises , e.g. for top - quark pair production already five dimensions have been parameterized explicitly . it turns out that stripper in cdr is not applicable for high multiplicities . in addition , tree - level matrix elements , that appear in subtraction terms , have to be provided to several powers in @xmath12 . available software only provides them up to @xmath28 . + thus , it has been necessary to reformulate the scheme in t hooft - veltman regularization ( hv ) , where momenta and spin degrees of freedom of resolved particles are four - dimensional . + in this proceeding , we explain the general idea of stripper in order to obtain a laurent series in @xmath12 for @xmath17 , where each coefficient can be calculated numerically . afterwards , we shortly point out how it can be reformulated in hv to provide a self - contained subtraction scheme for nnlo calculations . the detailed description is to be found in @xcite . the subtraction scheme stripper is an algorithmic method to extract real singularities of different contributions in . each part will be given as a laurent series in @xmath12 , where each coefficient has been calculated numerically . the final result , after summing the different parts , is finite . + we outline the method for @xmath17 as given in . since it contains two additional , potentially unresolved , partons , the phase space integral has the most complicated infrared structure . + first , we split the phase space into double - collinear and triple - collinear sectors . in a triple - collinear sector singularities are generated as three specific partons become collinear to each other and/or two of them soft . in a double - collinear sector singularities emerge as two specific pairs of partons become collinear and/or two of them soft . + in a next step , we parameterize the collinear particles in each sector separately using energies and angles . we illustrate the parametrization on the basis of a triple - collinear sector , where the three particles are in the final state : the reference momentum indicating the triple - collinear direction is denoted by @xmath29 . the momenta of the unresolved partons are named @xmath30 and @xmath31 . each momentum is parameterized by its energy and a @xmath32-dimensional unit vector in spherical coordinates r^r^0 1 + , u_1^u_1 ^ 0 1 + , u_2^u_2 ^ 0 1 + . the unresolved particles energies are rescaled by their maximal value @xmath33 , @xmath34 , for @xmath35 . the soft limit is approached as @xmath36 and/or @xmath37 . using rotations in @xmath32-dimensions , the scalar products between the three given momenta take the following form = _ 1 = 1 - 2_1 , = _ 2 = 1 - 2_2 , = _ 1 _ 2 + _ 2 _ 1_2 . parametrization of a triple - collinear sector , where the three partons are in the final state . the reference momentum is @xmath38 , the unresolved momenta are denoted by @xmath39 and @xmath40 . the sum of momenta of remaining resolved particles is @xmath41 . ] this parametrization is shown in figure [ fig : parametrization ] . the limit of @xmath42 at zero indicates the collinear limit of one of the unresolved partons and the reference parton . @xmath43 is collinear to @xmath44 when @xmath45 and @xmath46 . a non - linear transformation of @xmath47 to @xmath48 , _ 2 _ 2(_1,_2 , ) , then ensures that @xmath47 always vanishes as @xmath49 . accordingly , all possible collinear limits are indicated only by two variables : @xmath50 and @xmath51 . furthermore , if we find a formulation in hv , meaning that all other momenta and the reference momentum are four - dimensional , at most six dimensions are needed to parameterize all possible scalar products consistently . + at this point , four physical variables @xmath52 parameterize all possible soft and collinear limits in a given sector . additional sector decompositions @xcite in those variables factorize all possible overlapping singularities that appear at nnlo . in practice this amounts to split each sector again . for example double - soft overlapping singularities are disentangled using [ eq : decomp ] 1=(_1-_2)+ ( _ 2-_1 ) . the decomposition of the phase space due to soft overlapping singularities is sufficient to factorize all possible limits in a double - collinear sector . in a triple - collinear sector the phase space is split into five additional sectors to factorize collinear and soft - collinear overlapping singularities . this splitting is accompanied by a transition from physical variables @xmath53 to corresponding sector variables @xmath54 . + finally , the full double - real radiation cross section can be written as a sum over different decomposed triple- and double - collinear sectors ^_ab=_s ^,s_ab . each contribution has the following form ^,s_ab=_0 ^ 1 _ 1_2_1_2 . the function @xmath55 is finite in the limit of vanishing arguments . all appearing singularities are factorized in the sector variables . poles are extracted by an iterative usage of the plus distribution in each variable [ eq : plus ] _ 0 ^ 1x=+_0 ^ 1x . we obtain a laurent series in @xmath12 and all coefficients are calculated numerically . the described procedure is process independent , since it is possible to use the known universal infrared - limits of qcd amplitudes for the subtraction terms in . the above procedure is carried out in cdr , i.e. resolved and unresolved momenta are @xmath56-dimensional . to get a transition to the t hooft - veltman regularization scheme , we have to identify unresolved particles in different contributions of : either one particle is unresolved , what we call the single - unresolved contribution , or two particles are unresolved , what we call the double - unresolved contribution . by adding process independent correction terms to the single - unresolved contribution and subtracting them from the double - unresolved contribution we make sure that the two contributions are finite separately . now we are able to identify unresolved and resolved particles unambiguously . since each contribution is finite we set the momenta of resolved particles to @xmath57 dimensions , the mistake is of order @xmath12 . this makes sure that explicit parameterized dimensions are limited to six for arbitrary multiplicities . setting also their spin degrees of freedom to the physical dimensions allows us to use matrix elements at order @xmath28 . + to avoid contractions between @xmath56-dimensional vectors of unresolved momenta and four - dimensional matrix elements , we replace spin - correlated splitting functions in collinear subtraction terms by their azimuthal averaged counterparts . + this procedure leads to a fully general subtraction algorithm for nnlo calculations . in this proceeding , we presented the general formulation of stripper , a subtraction scheme to calculate cross sections at nnlo in perturbative qcd for arbitrary multiplicities . the full subtraction scheme , completely described in @xcite , can readily implemented in a computer code . this research was supported by the german research foundation ( dfg ) via the sonderforschungsbereich / transregio sfb / tr-9 `` computational particle physics '' . the author thanks the organizers of acat 2014 for remission of the conference fee . 9 m. czakon and d. heymes , arxiv:1408.2500 [ hep - ph ] . s. catani and m. h. seymour , nucl . b * 485 * ( 1997 ) 291 [ erratum - ibid . b * 510 * ( 1998 ) 503 ] [ hep - ph/9605323 ] . s. frixione , z. kunszt and a. signer , nucl . b * 467 * ( 1996 ) 399 [ hep - ph/9512328 ] . a. gehrmann - de ridder , t. gehrmann and e. w. n. glover , jhep * 0509 * ( 2005 ) 056 [ hep - ph/0505111 ] . s. catani and m. grazzini , phys . * 98 * , 222002 ( 2007 ) [ hep - ph/0703012 ] . a. gehrmann - de ridder , t. gehrmann , e. w. n. glover and g. heinrich , jhep * 0711 * ( 2007 ) 058 [ arxiv:0710.0346 [ hep - ph ] ] . j. currie , a. gehrmann - de ridder , e. w. n. glover and j. pires , jhep * 1401 * ( 2014 ) 110 [ arxiv:1310.3993 [ hep - ph ] ] . j. currie , a. gehrmann - de ridder , t. gehrmann , n. glover , j. pires and s. wells , arxiv:1407.5558 [ hep - ph ] . f. cascioli , t. gehrmann , m. grazzini , s. kallweit , p. maierhfer , a. von manteuffel , s. pozzorini and d. rathlev _ et al . _ , arxiv:1405.2219 [ hep - ph ] . t. gehrmann , m. grazzini , s. kallweit , p. maierhfer , a. von manteuffel , s. pozzorini , d. rathlev and l. tancredi , arxiv:1408.5243 [ hep - ph ] . g. abelof , a. gehrmann - de ridder , p. maierhofer and s. pozzorini , jhep * 1408 * , 035 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1404.6493 [ hep - ph ] ] . x. chen , t. gehrmann , e. w. n. glover and m. jaquier , arxiv:1408.5325 [ hep - ph ] . m. czakon , phys . b * 693 * ( 2010 ) 259 [ arxiv:1005.0274 [ hep - ph ] ] . m. czakon , nucl . b * 849 * ( 2011 ) 250 [ arxiv:1101.0642 [ hep - ph ] ] . r. boughezal , f. caola , k. melnikov , f. petriello and m. schulze , jhep * 1306 * ( 2013 ) 072 [ arxiv:1302.6216 [ hep - ph ] ] . m. brucherseifer , f. caola and k. melnikov , phys . b * 721 * ( 2013 ) 107 [ arxiv:1302.0444 [ hep - ph ] ] . m. brucherseifer , f. caola and k. melnikov , jhep * 1304 * ( 2013 ) 059 [ arxiv:1301.7133 [ hep - ph ] ] . m. brucherseifer , f. caola and k. melnikov , arxiv:1404.7116 [ hep - ph ] . f. caola , a. czarnecki , y. liang , k. melnikov and r. szafron , arxiv:1403.3386 [ hep - ph ] . r. boughezal , k. melnikov and f. petriello , phys . d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 034025 [ arxiv:1111.7041 [ hep - ph ] ] . t. binoth and g. heinrich , nucl . b * 585 * ( 2000 ) 741 [ hep - ph/0004013 ] .

the main theoretical tool to provide precise predictions for scattering cross sections of strongly interacting particles is perturbative qcd . starting at next - to - leading order ( nlo ) the calculation suffers from unphysical ir - divergences that cancel in the final result . at nlo there exist general subtraction algorithms to treat these divergences during a calculation . since the lhc demands for more precise theoretical predictions , general subtraction methods at next - to - next - to - leading order ( nnlo ) are needed . + this proceeding outlines the four - dimensional formulation of the sector improved residue subtraction . the subtraction scheme stripper and in particular its extension to arbitrary multiplicities is explained . therefore , it furnishes a general framework for the calculation of nnlo cross sections in perturbative qcd .

1310.0913

currently accepted theories and many experimental results suggest that hadronic matter changes to quark matter in high - density and/or high - temperature regimes by way of the deconfinement transition . the properties of quark matter have been actively studied theoretically in terms of the quark gluon plasma , color superconductivity @xcite , magnetism @xcite , and experimentally in terms of relativistic heavy - ion collisions @xcite , and early - universe studies and compact stars @xcite . such studies are continuing to provide exciting results @xcite . presently , we consider that compact stars consist of not only nuclear matter but also other matter such as hyperons and quarks . we call such stars _ hybrid stars_. because many theoretical calculations have suggested that the deconfinement transition is of the first order at low temperature and high density @xcite , we assume that it is a first - order phase transition here . the gibbs condition @xcite then gives rise to various structured mixed phases ( smps ) . the smps proposed by heiselberg et al . @xcite and glenndening and pei @xcite suggest a crystalline structure for the mixed phase in the cores of hybrid stars . such structures are called `` droplets '' , `` rods '' , `` slabs '' , `` tubes '' , and `` bubbles '' . we present the equation of state ( eos ) for the mixed phase taking into account the charge screening effect @xcite without relying on any approximations . we investigate the inner structures of these stars @xcite . in this paper , we review the inner structures of hybrid stars and apply our eos to a stationary rotating star . we use the eos given in our paper @xcite , which is presented in our framework . therefore , our approach is only briefly explained here . thermal equilibrium is implicitly achieved at @xmath0 . we consider that the hadronic and quark matter and the mixed phase are @xmath1 stable . we employ density functional theory ( dft ) under the local density approximation @xcite . to account for the confinement , we introduce a sharp boundary between the two phases employing the bag model @xcite with a surface tension parameter @xmath2 . the determination of the surface tension between hadronic and quark matter is a difficult problem . thus , many authors have treated the surface tension as a free parameter and have observed its effect @xcite ; we take the same approach in this study . to determine the charge screening effect , we also conduct the calculations without the screening effect . we then apply the eos derived in our paper @xcite to the tolman oppenheimer volkoff ( tov ) equation @xcite . after that , we apply our eos to a stationary rotating star . [ cols="^,^ " , ] we see an important relation between radius and rotation . ordinarily , the `` radius '' of the star is single - valued because we consider that the star is spherical . however , if the star is rapidly rotating , we have to pay attention to the different `` radii '' . because of the effect of the rotation , a star deforms from a sphere to an ellipse . therefore , we introduce two values , @xmath3 and @xmath4 , which are the equatorial radius " and the polar radius " , respectively . figure [ r - f_sc ] shows @xmath3 and @xmath4 with respect to rotation . if the rotation rate is 400 hz or faster , the two radii are different . therefore , we have to note the effects of rotation on rapidly rotating stars . in this study , we demonstrated how charge screening affects the hadron quark mixed phase in the cores of hybrid stars , taking into account rotation effects . we found that the inner structures are strongly affected . in particular , a core consisting of quark matter could appear due to the charge screening effect . another case , kaon condensation , has been studied @xcite and the results are similar to those of our papers @xcite . we used a simple model for quark matter and nuclear matter . to obtain a more realistic picture of the hadron quark phase transition , we need to take into account color superconductivity @xcite and the relativistic mean field theory @xcite . we will then be able to provide more realistic results . neutron stars have other important physics magnetic fields . however , the origin of these magnetic fields is still unknown . there are ways to explain magnetic fields based on the spin - polarization of the quark matter @xcite . however , whether the quark matter exists or not strongly depends on the eos . in this calculation , we did not take into account magnetic fields . if we include a magnetic field , the resluts are very interesting with respect to the rotation of the star . this work was supported in part by the principal grant of the kagawa national college of technology .

the appearance of quark matter in the core of hybrid stars is a fundamental issue in such compact stars . the central density of these stars is sufficiently high such that nuclear matter undergoes a further change into other exotic phases that consist of hyperons and quarks . however , the equation of state ( eos ) for the high - density matter is still not clear and several recent observations have indicated the limitations of the eoss ; theoretical studies should try to elucidate the eoss . it is believed that the inner regions of the stars should consist of a mixed hadron - quark phase . we study the mixed hadron - quark phase , taking into account finite - size effects , and find that that the mixed phase should be restricted to a narrower region . therefore , a quark matter phase should appear in the central region .

1509.02993

quantum control over atom - light interaction is at the core of many recent developments that have greatly extended the horizon of cold - atom physics . a prominent example is the experimental realisation of synthetic spin - orbit coupling ( soc ) in ultracold atomic gases @xcite . by coupling atomic states with raman lasers , the internal and the external degrees of freedom of the atoms are also coupled . this effective soc interaction modifies the single - particle dispersion spectra , and can lead to novel quantum states in both the few - body @xcite and the many - body settings @xcite . of particular interest is the possibility of preparing and probing topological states in cold atomic gases under synthetic soc . while solid - state materials with topologically non - trivial properties have been extensively studied in recent years @xcite , ultracold atomic gases may serve as ideal platforms for the quantum simulation of exotic topological matter @xcite . for instance , the highly tunable parameters of cold atoms should offer unprecedented control over interatomic interactions in a topological material , and thus would provide the intriguing opportunity of simulating topological states in a strongly interacting system . another exciting example in the quantum control over atom - light interaction is the combination of ultracold atoms and cavity quantum electrodynamics in the strong - coupling regime , where quantum effects of both the atoms and the cavity photons become dominant @xcite . in these atom - cavity hybrid systems , an outstanding feature is the interplay between the atoms and the cavity field : while the cavity field couples the internal states of atoms and affects the collective properties of the ensemble , the ensuing dynamics of the atomic gas feeds back on the cavity photons . hence , the cavity field not only serves as a dynamical variable for the many - body system , it also provides a means to detect , non - destructively , key properties of the hybrid system . a seminal experimental achievement in these systems is the recent observation of the dicke superradiance in a bose - einstein condensate ( bec ) coupled to cavity light fields @xcite . in the experiment , as the system becomes superradiant , the back action of the cavity photons on the the atoms leads to a self organisation of the bec . furthermore , it has been demonstrated later that the dynamical structure factor of the bec can also be probed by monitoring photons leaking out of the cavity @xcite . when the bec is replaced by a spinless degenerate fermi gas , it has been shown theoretically that the superradiant cavity field opens a bulk gap at the fermi surface , whereas the back action of the fermi gas gives rise to an enhancement of superradiance due to the nesting effect @xcite . in this work , we study a special atom - cavity hybrid system , where the cavity field participates in raman processes generating a synthetic soc . thus , this scenario combines the two interesting developments mentioned above . similar schemes have attracted much research interest recently @xcite . for a two - component bec in a cavity , it has been shown that the cavity - assisted soc can lead to a rich phase diagram @xcite ; whereas for a two - component degenerate fermi gas , an exotic topological superradiant ( tsr ) state can be stabilised @xcite . in the tsr state , the bulk gap opened by the superradiant cavity photons also protects topologically non - trivial properties of the fermi gas . as a result , local order parameters coexist with global topological invariants in the tsr state . here , we extend the studies in ref . @xcite , and characterise in detail various properties of the tsr state . at the core of our discussion is the interplay of atoms and the cavity field . we first demonstrate that the cavity - induced inter - band couplings play a crucial role in inducing the topological phase transition between the conventional and the tsr state . for this purpose , we compare the phase diagrams of relevant tight - binding models involving different number of bands , and show explicitly that only by taking the lowest several bands into consideration would one recover , qualitatively , the phase diagram from a full - band calculation . this enables us to derive a minimum tight - binding hamiltonian for our system , which is helpful for generalising the steady - state phase diagram of the current system to other related systems . importantly , we notice that , in general , the multi - band effect is crucial in studying raman - induced synthetic soc in lattice systems . this conclusion is consistent with a recent study on laser - induced soc in lattice models @xcite . we then investigate the back action of the topological phase transition of the fermi gas on the cavity photon . across the topological phase boundary between the trivial superradiant state and the tsr state , the bulk gap closes and opens again . we show that at this phase boundary , the fermi surface at half filling lies exactly at the gap closing point . as a result , a spin - down state on the fermi surface would be scattered by a raman process to the spin - up state , which is also on the fermi surface . this is essentially the nesting effect discussed in refs . @xcite , for a spinless fermi gas in a cavity . we show that the nesting effect here leads to a peak structure in the variation of the cavity photon occupation at the topological boundary . which can be used as a clear signature for the topological phase transition . in the remainder of the work , we discuss the robustness of the tsr state by investigating the steady - state phase diagram under various circumstances . we find that the tsr state as well as the general outlook of the phase diagram are robust against finite - temperature effects , and that the tsr state should persist even in the absence of a background lattice potential . we also show that with a larger number of atoms in the cavity , which is most likely the case in experiments , the tsr state is actually more stable . hence , our study should be helpful for future experimental preparation and detection of the tsr state . the paper is organised as follows : in sec . [ sec : model ] , we outline the system configurations and our derivation of the model hamiltonian of the quasi - one dimensional fermi gas . then , in sec . [ sec : phasediag ] , we briefly review general properties of the tsr state and present the typical steady - state phase diagram . as the focus of the current work , sec . [ sec : feedback ] is devoted to the discussion on the mutual feedback interactions between atoms and the cavity field . in sec . [ sec : robust ] , we examine the robustness of the tsr state and discuss effects of finite temperature , background lattice potential and atom number . we also discuss issues related to the experimental implementation of our system . finally , we summarise in sec . [ sec : summary ] . we consider a quasi - one - dimensional , two - component fermi gas strongly coupled to an optical cavity . while the cavity is transversely pumped by a laser field , the pumping laser and the cavity field couple two hyperfine states in the ground - state manifold of each atom in two - photon raman processes ( see fig . [ fig : config ] ) . while fermions in the cavity are non - interacting , they are subject to a background lattice potential , whose parameters can be controlled independently . this can be achieved , for example , by using a two - mode cavity @xcite . while the atoms are coupled to one of the modes ( pumped by a in fig . [ fig : config ] ) , the other mode is longitudinally pumped and provides the background potential ( pumped by b in fig . [ fig : config ] ) . the effective hamiltonian for a single atom in the fermi gas can be written as @xcite @xmath0\hat{\psi}_{\sigma } \nonumber\\ & -&\delta_{a}\hat{a}^{\dagger}\hat{a } + \eta\left[\int d\boldsymbol{r}\hat{\psi}_{\uparrow}^{\dagger}\left(\hat{a}e^{ik_{0}z}+\hat{a}^{\dagger}e^{-ik_{0}z}\right)\cos\left(k_{0}x\right)\hat{\psi}_{\downarrow}+\rm{h.c.}\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath1 ( @xmath2 ) are the fermionic field operators for different hyperfine states , @xmath3 is the annihilation operator for the cavity field , @xmath4 , @xmath5 is the atomic mass , and @xmath6 represents hermitian conjugate . here , @xmath7 is the three dimensional kinetic energy , @xmath8 is the radial trapping potential , where we consider the tight radial confinement to be in the @xmath9@xmath10 plane . while an effective zeeman field @xmath11 is applied along the @xmath10 axis , the background lattice potential is given as @xmath12 . @xmath13 is the wave vector of the cavity modes , which are approximately the same . the cavity detuning @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the resonant frequency of the cavity mode a , and @xmath16 is the frequency of the transverse pumping laser . we may then define @xmath17 , and the effective rabi frequency of the cavity - assisted raman processes @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the single - photon detuning of the raman processes . under tight radial confinement , we assume that only the ground state of the radial degrees of freedom is occupied . the fermionic field operator can be written as @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the characteristic width of the radial harmonic confinement , with the transverse trapping frequency @xmath22 . @xmath23 is the field operator in the transverse directions . integrating out the transverse degrees of freedom , the effective one - dimensional hamiltonian is @xmath24\hat{\psi}_{\sigma}-\delta_a\hat{a}^{\dagger}\hat{a}\nonumber\\ & + & \eta_{a}\left(\hat{a}+\hat{a}^{\dag}\right)\left[\int dx\hat{\psi}_{\uparrow}^{\dagger}\cos\left(k_{0}x\right)\hat{\psi}_{\downarrow}+\rm{h.c.}\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath25 with @xmath26 . considering the cavity decay rate @xmath27 , we can write down the equation of motion for the cavity field @xmath28\nonumber\\ & + & \eta_{a}\left[\int dx\hat{\psi}_{\downarrow}^{\dagger}\cos\left(k_{0}x\right)\hat{\psi}_{\uparrow}+\rm{h.c.}\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] we consider the steady - state solution of the system under the stationary condition @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is the cavity mean field . from the stationary condition , we have @xmath31}{\delta_{a}+i\kappa-\xi_{a}\sum_{\sigma}\int dx\langle\hat{\psi}_{\sigma}^{\dagger}\hat{\psi}_{\sigma}\rangle\cos^{2}\left(k_{0}x\right)}.\ ] ] apparently , when the system is in the steady state , the cavity mean field @xmath32 depends on the spin - spin correlation @xmath33 of the fermi gas , while the latter is in turn affected by the cavity mean field through the effective hamiltonian ( [ eqn : effh ] ) . these observations clearly demonstrate the feedback interactions between the cavity field and the fermi gas . the steady state of the system can be solved self - consistently from eqs . ( [ eqn : effh ] ) and ( [ eqn : alpha ] ) . starting from an appropriate initial cavity field @xmath34 , we diagonalise the effective hamiltonian eq . ( [ eqn : effh ] ) for the energy spectrum . we then solve for the chemical potential from the number equation @xmath35 . the cavity mean field @xmath32 is then updated via eq . ( [ eqn : alpha ] ) . we repeat the process until @xmath32 converges . note that we only consider the interesting case when the fermions in the background lattice potential are at half filling . as the transverse pumping strength @xmath36 increases past a critical value , the cavity - atom hybrid system undergoes a superradiant phase transition . upon the onset of superradiance , the relevant cavity mode ( mode a ) becomes macroscopically occupied , and the spin - spin correlation establishes in the fermi gas , which serves as an order parameter . the superradiant phase transition can be characterised by the conventional landau phase - transition theory . starting from the hamiltonian ( [ eqn : effh ] ) , we replace the cavity field operators with the mean - field value in eq . ( [ eqn : alpha ] ) . the expression for the free energy @xmath37 can be derived by integrating out the fermionic field operators . here , the partition function @xmath38 , @xmath39 is the boltzmann constant , @xmath40 is the chemical potential , @xmath41 is the number operator , and @xmath42 is temperature . expanding the free energy near the critical point up to the fourth - order term in @xmath32 , we get @xmath43 where @xmath44.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath45 denotes the opposite spin of @xmath46 , and the fermi - dirac distribution @xmath47 $ ] . the matrix elements @xmath48 and @xmath49 are @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the eigen function of the hamiltonian @xmath52 with the eigen energy @xmath53 . here , @xmath54 $ ] , @xmath55 is the energy - band index , and @xmath56 . defining the atomic spin - spin correlation as the order parameter @xmath57,\ ] ] we can rewrite the free energy expansion as @xmath58\left(\eta_{a}\theta\right)^{2 } \nonumber\\ & -&\frac{1}{\left(\tilde{\delta}_{a}^{2}+\kappa^{2}\right)^{2}}\left[\eta_{a}^{4}\chi_{41}\frac{16\tilde{\delta}_{a}^{4}}{\left(\tilde{\delta}_{a}^{2 } + \kappa^{2}\right)^{2}}+\xi_{a}^{2}\chi_{42}-\xi_a\eta_{a}^{2}\chi_{43}\frac{4\tilde{\delta}_{a}^{2}}{\tilde{\delta}_{a}^{2 } + \kappa^{2}}\right]\left(\eta_{a}\theta\right)^{4}\nonumber\\ & = & -\lambda_{2}\left(\eta_{a}\theta\right)^{2}-\lambda_{4}\left(\eta_{a}\theta\right)^{4},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , in the last line , we have defined the second- and the fourth - order coefficients as @xmath59 and @xmath60 , respectively . the superradiant phase transition occurs when @xmath59 vanishes , which gives the critical condition @xmath61 when the system just enters the superradiant state , the cavity field @xmath32 is still small . hence , the steady - state cavity mean field can be obtained by minimising the expansion eq . ( [ eqn : feexpand ] ) , such that @xmath62 we have checked numerically that the superradiant boundary determined by eq . ( [ eqn : critcond ] ) coincides with that determined from a self - consistent calculation outlined in the previous section . furthermore , we have checked that whenever @xmath32 is small , eq . ( [ eqn : alplt ] ) agrees well with the cavity mean field from a self - consistent calculation . although the superradiant phase transition can be well characterised by the landau theory of phase transition , we will show below that , due to the interplay between the cavity field and the atoms , superradiance can induce a change of topological properties of the fermi gas under appropriate conditions . whether the superradiant transition discussed above is topological or not depends on the value of the effective zeeman field . when the effective zeeman field @xmath63 is smaller than a critical field @xmath64 , such that the fermi gas is in a gapless metallic ( m ) phase before the superradiant transition , the system undergoes a topological superradiant phase transition . a cavity - assisted soc is turned on as soon as the superradiance occurs . at half filling , this soc opens a bulk gap at the fermi surface and mixes different spin components of the fermi gas . the combined effects give rise to a non - zero winding number in the lowest band . the system thus features all the properties of a superradiant state , as well as those of a chiral topological insulator ( see fig . [ fig : phasediag ] ) . when the effective zeeman field @xmath63 is larger than @xmath64 , the fermi gas can be in an insulator ( i ) state before the superradiant transition . here , when the transverse pumping strength increases , a superradiant transition can also occur . however , as the bulk gap does not close across the superradiant transition , the fermi gas remains to be a topologically trivial insulator . the system is then in a conventional superradiant ( sr ) state . as the pumping strength increases further , the bulk gap closes and reopens , and the system undergoes an sr tsr phase transition ( see fig . [ fig : phasediag ] ) . in the following section , we will focus on this sr - tsr phase transition , as it is an exemplary case in which the interplay between atoms and the cavity plays a key role in shaping the properties of the system . . when @xmath36 increases , the system becomes superradiant , and the steady state can either be a tsr state or a trivial sr insulator . the tsr and the sr states are further separated by a topological phase boundary at @xmath65 . a tetracritical point exists at @xmath66 , @xmath67 . we consider a half - filled lattice of @xmath68 sites , with the parameters : @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 . see the main text for the definition of parameters.,width=529 ] in this section , we focus on the interplay between atoms and the cavity near the sr tsr phase boundary at @xmath65 . on the one hand , we show that the sr tsr topological phase transition is induced by the cavity - assisted inter - band coupling ; on the other hand , the bulk gap closing at the topological phase boundary leaves its signature in the cavity field . an outstanding feature of our system is the spatial dependence of the cavity - assisted soc , which is of odd parity with respect to the centre of a lattice site . from the parity analysis , it is easy to see that the cavity - assisted soc is capable of coupling @xmath75-band to @xmath76-band with a spin flip . naturally this raises the question of the impact of higher bands . indeed , the multiband effects play a crucial role in shaping the topological phase boundary between the sr and the tsr phase . to explicitly see the higher - band effects , we expand the effective hamiltonian eq . ( [ eqn : effh ] ) onto the wannier basis @xmath77 of the lattice hamiltonian @xmath78 , where @xmath79 . here , @xmath55 and @xmath80 are the band and the site index , respectively . the resulting tight - binding hamiltonian can be written as @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the atomic annihilation operator of spin @xmath46 on site @xmath80 in the @xmath55-the band , @xmath83 denotes nearest - neighbour hopping . the hopping coefficients from site @xmath84 on the @xmath5-th band to site @xmath80 on the @xmath55-th band are defined as @xmath85 where @xmath86 . note that we have neglected the next - nearest - neighbour intra - band hopping terms and the nearest - neighbour inter - band hopping terms , as we have checked numerically that their effects are negligible . considering the symmetry of the wannier functions , we have the following relations @xmath87 where @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 and @xmath91 are all non - negative constants . for a single - band tight - binding model , eq . ( [ eqn : tbh ] ) can be simplified , as the summation over band index @xmath55 only contains the lowest band with @xmath92 . after employing the gauge transformation , @xmath93 ( see fig . [ fig : bandillus ] for the role of the gauge transformation ) , we can derive a concise form in momentum space @xcite @xmath94 apparently , this single - band tight - binding model is topologically non - trivial when @xmath95 and is trivial otherwise . hence for a single - band tight - binding model , @xmath96 . note that we have used the winding number as the topological invariant , with the definition @xmath97 here the integral is over the first brillouin zone , with @xmath98 $ ] . band ) before ( left ) and after ( right ) the gauge transformation @xmath99 . the red curves are the dispersion for spin - up atoms , and the green curves are for spin - down atoms . note that , since the spatially dependent cavity - assisted soc has twice the period as that of the lattice potential , ( a ) and ( c ) are shown in a folded brillouin zone , while ( b ) and ( d ) are shown in the brillouin zone of the lattice potential . after the gauge transformation , the dispersion spectrum of the spin - down species is shifted by half the brillouin zone relative to that of the spin - up species under the cavity - assisted soc . the grey dashed curves are the dispersions after the onset of superradiance . ( a)(b ) for @xmath100 , the onset of superradiance opens a bulk gap ; ( c)(d ) for @xmath65 , the bulk gap persists across the sr transition.,width=529 ] in fig . [ fig : multiband](a ) , we plot the steady - state phase diagram under the single - band tight - binding model eq . ( [ eqn : singlebandtbm ] ) . while the sr transition boundary ( red ) is determined self - consistently from eq . ( [ eqn : critcond ] ) , the topological phase boundary sr tsr ( blue ) is calculated using eq . ( [ eqn : winding ] ) . consistent with our analysis , the sr tsr topological phase boundary is located in the region where @xmath100 . importantly , this phase boundary is qualitatively different from that under a full - band calculation , which lies at @xmath65 . thus , the coupling to higher bands can significantly alter the topological phase boundary . while one may expect similar conclusions for raman - assisted soc in lattice systems in general , in our system , such higher - band effects can be seen as the back actions of atomic scattering of cavity photons . we then characterise the steady - phase diagram as we sequentially turn on the coupling to higher bands . more specifically , we consider the cases of two- and three - band tight - binding models . these correspond to taking @xmath101 and @xmath102 , respectively , in the band - index summation in eq . ( [ eqn : tbh ] ) . applying a similar gauge transformation @xmath99 , we can write the effective hamiltonian in quasi - momentum space . taking the three - band tight - binding model for example , the hamiltonian can be written as @xmath103 where @xmath104 . in fig . [ fig : multiband](b ) and ( c ) , we plot , respectively , the steady - state phase diagrams of two- and three - band tight - binding models . apparently , the sr tsr phase boundary only lies in the region of @xmath65 , i.e. , qualitatively consistent with a full - band calculation , when the lowest three bands are taken into consideration . this suggests a minimum tight - binding model in our system should at least include the intra- and inter - band couplings of the lowest three bands . .,width=604 ] to further understand how the cavity - assisted inter - band coupling induces the topological phase transition , we plot in fig . [ fig : bandspec ] the bloch bands in the half - folded brillouin zone @xmath105 $ ] . note that for the blue - detuned optical lattice , the zero points of the raman coupling potential coincide with lattice sites , for which the raman potential is antisymmetric with respect to each lattice site ( see eq . [ eqn : effh ] ) . this symmetry leads to the following two types of inter - band couplings between spin - up and spin - down states at the i sr phase boundary . first , if both the spin - up and the spin - down states have the same parity ( e.g. even parity for @xmath106 bands , or odd parity for @xmath107 bands ) , the raman potential only induces spin - flip hopping coupling but not on - site couplings . conversely , if the spin - up and the spin - down states belong to opposite parities , the raman coupling potential can induce on - site spin - flip couplings , as well as the hopping processes . for example , in fig . [ fig : bandspec](a ) , the states labelled 1 and 2 at the center of the brillouin zone are respectively coupled to the states labelled 3 and 4 via raman processes . importantly , these band - selective couplings persist in both the sr and the tsr states , as indicated in fig . [ fig : bandspec](b)(c ) . these inter - band couplings push apart each pair of the bloch bands . in the sr state , the band with state 2 is pushed downward faster than the band with state 1 . as a result , the bulk gap between these two bands is reduced when the pumping strength @xmath36 increases from zero . notice that at half filling , the fermi surface is in - between these two bands . the bulk gap would keep decreasing until the gap closes ( see fig . [ fig : bandspec](a)(b ) ) . at the gap closing point , band inversion occurs and upon further increase of @xmath36 , the bulk gap would be enlarged as the two bands are pushed apart by similar inter - band - coupling mechanisms ( see fig . [ fig : bandspec](c ) ) . thus , in the region of @xmath65 , the sr tsr topological phase transition is driven by the cavity - assisted inter - band couplings . as a result , the stability region of the tsr state is enlarged on the phase diagram . to quantify the analysis above , we devise an incremental first - order perturbative calculation . across the sr tsr phase boundary , we divide the increment of the transverse pumping @xmath36 into @xmath108 small steps , which we label as @xmath109 ( @xmath110 ) . with the step - wise increase of @xmath109 , the cavity mean - field @xmath32 also increases , which we label as @xmath111 . the cavity field then affects the hamiltonian at the @xmath80-the step as @xmath112 , which yields the states @xmath113 ( @xmath114 as indicated in fig . [ fig : bandspec](a - c ) ) . at the @xmath80-the step , we take @xmath113 as the zeroth - order wave function and calculate the first - order correction induced by the increasing @xmath36 : @xmath115 . when @xmath116 is small , @xmath117 should indicate the variation of bulk gap at @xmath118 . as indicated in fig . [ fig : bandspec](d ) , for @xmath100 , state 2 is pushed downward while state 1 is pushed upward . for @xmath65 , the downward shift in 2 is larger than that in state 1 . as analysed previously , these contribute to the bulk gap closing and reopening at the topological phase boundary . we emphasis again that the bulk gap closing and reopening is driven by cavity - assisted inter - band couplings , which should determine the state @xmath113 at the @xmath80-the step . , and ( a ) @xmath119 , ( b ) @xmath120 , ( c ) @xmath121 . the inter - band couplings among modes 1,2,3,4 at @xmath118 ( red circles ) are indicated by arrows . note in ( c ) , due to the band inversion at the topological boundary , the labels 1 and 2 are exchanged . ( d ) incremental first - order correction @xmath117 , with @xmath122 . 1 - 1 indicates the first - order correction to state 1 , and 2 - 2 indicates the correction to state 2.,width=604 ] while the cavity field drives the system into the tsr state , the back action of the topological phase transition also leaves signatures in the cavity field , which can serve as a novel non - demolition detection scheme . to demonstrate this we define the variation of the cavity field with respect to the effective transverse pumping strength @xmath36 : @xmath123 . in fig . [ fig : backaction ] , we show @xmath124 as the background of the steady - state phase diagram . while the value of @xmath124 is ostensibly higher in the sr regime than in the tsr regime , it peaks along the topological phase boundary between the two states . qualitatively , the peak structure in @xmath124 is a direct result of the bulk - gap closing along the topological phase boundary . on the sr tsr phase boundary at @xmath65 , the fermi surface at half filling shrinks to the dirac point at @xmath118 . as such , a fermion close to the `` fermi surface''(@xmath118 ) interacting with photons in the cavity and the pumping fields is scattered to another state close to the `` fermi surface '' without much cost in energy . this corresponds to the nesting condition discussed in refs . @xcite , under which a spinless fermi gas coupled to a cavity field can have enhanced superradiance . here , as the system is already in the sr state when the sr tsr phase boundary is crossed , the satisfaction of the nesting condition leads to a peak in the variation of the cavity field instead . alternatively , the formation of the peak can be understood from the vantage of the band inversion at the topological phase boundary . as @xmath36 increases past the phase boundary , band with state 2 becomes heavily occupied due to the band inversion . as the energy difference between the band with state 2 and that with state 3 is much smaller than that between bands with state 1 and 4 , atom - photon scatterings , which involve cavity - assisted inter - band couplings , are easier to occur when the system is in the tsr state . thus the abrupt change in the atom - photon scattering ability at the gap closing point gives rise to a peak in the rate of change of the average cavity photon number . in the previous discussions , we study the tsr state and the relevant phase transitions in a quasi - one - dimensional fermi gas , in the presence of a background lattice potential , with a small number of atoms , and at a finite but very low temperature . an important question is the stability of the tsr state against parameters like temperature or background lattice potential . in this section , we discuss the effects of these parameters on the steady - state phase diagram . we also investigate the phase diagram under typical experimental conditions . as the background . the parameters are the same as in fig . [ fig : phasediag].,width=529 ] for a one - dimensional fermi gas in a cavity , the fermi surface is just two points at zero temperature . the nesting condition is naturally satisfied when the fermions are at half filling in the lattice potential formed by the cavity field . it has been pointed out that , at zero temperature , the superradiance of a one - dimensional fermi gas can occur even with infinitesimally small pumping field @xcite . as the temperature increases , the fermi surface becomes less well defined , which leads to a finite critical pumping field for the emergence of superradiance . in fig . [ fig : stab](a ) , we illustrate typical phase diagrams at zero temperature , both with ( blue ) and without ( red ) the background lattice potential @xmath125 . in either case , when the effective zeeman field @xmath63 is smaller than @xmath64 , the critical pumping strength @xmath36 for the onset of the tsr state is indeed zero . this is consistent with previous results . when the effective zeeman field becomes larger than @xmath64 , the possible phases and phase boundaries depend on the background lattice potential . in the absence of a background lattice potential , there is no band gap before the onset of superradiance . hence , there will be no trivial insulator state ( the i or the sr state ) , and the system directly enters the tsr state from either a fully polarised fermi gas ( fp ) ( @xmath65 ) or a partially polarised fermi gas ( pp ) ( @xmath100 ) . we note that , as the critical zeeman field @xmath64 is proportional to the band width , @xmath64 should increase with decreasing @xmath125 . similarly , we show in fig . [ fig : stab](b ) typical phase diagrams at finite temperatures , both with ( black ) and without ( green ) the background lattice potential . the main difference with the zero - temperature case is that the onset of superradiance requires a finite pumping field . importantly , we see that the tsr state is robust against changes in temperature and the background lattice potential . , with @xmath126 ( blue ) and @xmath127 ( red ) ; ( b ) @xmath128 , with @xmath129 ( black ) and @xmath127 ( green).,width=604 ] experimentally , quasi - one - dimensional atomic gases are typically prepared by applying a two - dimensional optical lattice potential @xcite . this configuration should give rise to an array of quasi - one - dimensional atomic gases tightly confined in the transverse direction . as each quasi - one - dimensional tube in the array typically contains tens of atoms , it is worthwhile to explore the case where large number of atoms are present in the cavity . in this case , the effective hamiltonian should be modified as @xmath130\hat{\psi}_{\nu,\sigma}\nonumber\\ & + & \eta_{a}\left(\alpha+\alpha^{\ast}\right)\left[\sum_{\nu}\int dx\hat{\psi}_{\nu,\uparrow}^{\dagger}\cos\left(k_{0}x\right)\hat{\psi}_{\nu,\downarrow}+\rm{h.c.}\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath131 is the atomic annihilation operator in the @xmath132-th tube . the stationary condition then gives @xmath133}{\delta_{a}+i\kappa-\xi_{a}\sum_{\nu,\sigma}\int dx\langle\hat{\psi}_{\nu,\sigma}^{\dagger}\hat{\psi}_{\nu,\sigma}\rangle\cos^{2}\left(k_{0}x\right)}.\ ] ] it is then possible to follow the procedure outlined previously to self - consistently determine the steady - state of the system and map out the phase diagram . as an example , we show in fig . [ fig : real ] a typical phase diagram with a total number of @xmath134 @xmath135li atoms loaded into a two dimensional optical lattice potential . we consider the lattice potential to have @xmath136 sites , which is also the number of quasi - one - dimensional tubes in the system . compared to the previous phase diagram ( see fig . [ fig : phasediag ] ) , the tetracritical point as well as the phase boundaries are considerably lowered . more importantly , the requirements on the cavity parameters are also relaxed . for example , fig . [ fig : real ] is calculated at a temperature of @xmath137 ( @xmath138nk for @xmath135li atoms ) , and with a weaker cavity - atom coupling @xmath139mhz , a larger single - photon detuning @xmath140ghz , and a larger cavity decay rate @xmath141mhz . hence , the tsr phase should persist under typical experimental conditions . we have discussed in detail various phases of a quasi - one - dimensional fermi gas under cavity assisted soc . as an outstanding feature of the cavity - atom hybrid system , we examine the feedback interactions between the fermi gas and the cavity field . we explicitly demonstrate that the topological phase transition between the tsr state and the topologically trivial sr state is induced by cavity - assisted couplings to higher bands . by sequentially introducing high - lying bands into the tight - binding model , we show that to qualitatively reproduce the topological phase boundary , a tight - binding model should at least include the lowest three bands . we have also investigated how cavity - assisted inter - band coupling closes and reopens the bulk gap across the topological phase boundary . as lattice models with raman - assisted soc have attracted much attention recently , we expect that the effects of inter - band coupling on the topological phase transition are relevant to a wide class of systems . as the feedback action of the topological phase transition on the cavity field , we then show that a peak structure emerges along the topological phase boundary , in the rate of change of the cavity - field with respect to the pumping strength . we demonstrate the the formation of the peak structure can be understood from the perspective of either the satisfaction of the nesting condition or the band inversion at the bulk - gap closing point . apparently , the peak structure should be useful for non - demolition measurement of the topological phase transition . we have also studied the effects of temperature , background lattice potential , and atom number on the phase boundaries , and demonstrated that the tsr state is robust under typical experimental conditions . as an example , we have used the parameters of @xmath135li atoms , in which case the pseudo - spins can be chosen as @xmath142 states in the ground - state manifold . for @xmath143k atoms , due to the existence of more than two hyperfine states in the ground - state manifold , a large magnetic field is required to isolate the level structure shown in fig . [ fig : config ] . the resulting large zeeman splitting between the pseudo - spin states would only allow the realisation of the large-@xmath63-side of the phase diagram . another possible choice of atom species is @xmath144yb , whose @xmath145 manifold has only two states with nuclear spins @xmath146 . we thank wolfgang ketterle for helpful comments . this work is supported by nfrp ( 2011cb921200 , 2011cba00200 ) , nkbrp ( 2013cb922000 ) , nsfc ( 60921091 , 11105134 , 11274009 , 11374283 ) , and the research funds of renmin university of china ( 10xnl016 ) . w. y. acknowledges support from the `` strategic priority research program(b ) '' of the chinese academy of sciences , grant no . xdb01030200 . x. j. l. is supported in part by the thousand - young - talent program of china .

coherently driven atomic gases inside optical cavities hold great promises in generating rich dynamics and exotic states of matter . recently , it has been shown that a novel topological superradiant state exists in a two - component degenerate fermi gas coupled to a cavity , where local order parameters coexist with global topological invariants . in this work , we characterise in detail various properties of this exotic state , focusing on the feedback interactions between the atoms and the cavity field . in particular , we demonstrate that the cavity - induced inter - band couplings play a crucial role in inducing the topological phase transition between the conventional and the topological superradiant state . furthermore , we analyse how the closing and reopening of the atomic bulk gap across the topological phase boundary leaves interesting signatures in the cavity field . we also discuss the robustness of the topological superradiant state by investigating the steady - state phase diagram under various circumstances . our work provides many valuable insights into the unique atom - cavity hybrid system under study , and is helpful for future experimental exploration of the topological superradiant state .

1301.5210

the specific features of the nica ( nuclotron based ion collider facility ) research programme @xcite , and in particular ( a ) the broad range of reactions planned to be studied , ( b ) the relatively modest collision energy @xmath0 , placing the whole programme close to that of the cern sps , ( c ) the possibility to measure reactions at different energies , and ( d ) the elasticity of taking measurements both in fixed target and collider modes , make it well suitable for studying the interplay of strong and electromagnetic interactions in nuclear collisions . what we specifically address in the present proposal is the _ electromagnetic interaction between charged particles produced in the collision and the nuclear remnant that does not participate directly in the reaction _ ( the spectator system ) . this latter phenomenon is of particular interest because , as discussed in our earlier works @xcite , _ it provides independent information on the space time - evolution of the reaction _ : the space - time evolution of the particle production process , the fragmentation ( break - up ) of the spectator system , and the interplay between the two . it is to be noted that with the well - known exception of hbt measurements @xcite , the experimental programmes at the sps , rhic and lhc provide direct information essentially only on the final ( or near - to - final ) state particles in _ momentum space _ ( @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 ) . much less is possible as far as providing information on the evolution of the reaction in _ position space _ ( @xmath4,@xmath5,@xmath6 ) , which on the other hand is extremely important in view of our understanding of the heavy ion reaction . here nica could strongly contribute to the overall knowledge in the whole heavy ion field , with very little competition from existing experiments . the corresponding measurements would in particular include _ particle spectra , charged particle ratios _ ( @xmath7 , @xmath8 , etc . ) and _ directed flow_. this paper is organized as follows . in section [ sectwo ] , we discuss the principal features of the spectator - induced electromagnetic effect , with particular emphasis on its importance as a new source of information on the mechanism of the nuclear reaction . in section [ secthree ] , we define the possible future contribution of nica . in section [ secfour ] , we shortly address the subject of competition from other experiments . we present our conclusions in section [ secfive ] . it is not surprising that various kinds of electromagnetic interactions in nucleus - nucleus collisions were studied in the past ( a partial overview can be found in @xcite ) . the problem of coulomb corrections to hbt measurements belongs in fact to the `` standard '' in the analysis of heavy ion experimental data . numerous works exist also on the influence of the electromagnetic field on the spectra of particles produced at _ mid - rapidity _ ( that is , in the vicinity of @xmath9 ) in central heavy ion reactions and rapidity @xmath10 in the nucleon - nucleon c.m.s . ] however , these concentrate on the electromagnetic field induced by the presence of initial charge in the `` participant zone '' , that is , the charge of the _ participating nucleons _ in central nucleus - nucleus collisions , see above , while the spectator charge will produce the largest effect at higher values of @xmath11 and in peripheral collisions . ] . on the other hand , it seems that the theoretical and experimental analyses of the electromagnetic interactions between _ nuclear remnants _ and produced particles were performed mostly at lower energies . very sizeable electromagnetically - induced distortions were observed there @xcite . an important , much more recent result , was reported in nuclear collisions at several gev / nucleon , where the non - relativistic approach to the coulomb field brought information on the space - time evolution of the process of nuclear fragmentation @xcite . in the energy regime of the cern sps and above , up to now our main range of interest , we were aware of only one earlier experimental measurement @xcite . the latter was unfortunately restricted to a very narrow acceptance range ( forward angles i.e. @xmath12 ) , and to an extremely small number of data points ( between two and four , depending on collision centrality ) which limited its scientific usefulness . ratios measured by the na49 experiment at the cern sps , drawn as a function of @xmath11 at fixed values of @xmath13 ( listed from top to bottom curve ) ; ( b ) result of the monte carlo simulation described in the text . the figure comes from @xcite.,scaledwidth=85.0% ] for this reason , we performed a series of experimental and theoretical studies of the influence which the spectator charge exerts on charged pion and charged kaon spectra @xcite . out of these , a consistent picture emerges which can be summarized as follows : 1 . the presence of the spectator - induced electromagnetic field brings a very sizeable distortion to @xmath7 ratios observed in the final state of `` peripheral '' ( large impact parameter ) pb+pb reactions measured at a beam energy of 158 gev / nucleon ( @xmath14 gev ) . this is shown in fig . [ fig : figone](a ) , where the @xmath11-dependence of @xmath7 ratios is drawn in the projectile hemisphere of the reaction , for fixed values of pion transverse momentum @xmath13 . this effect is so strong that the @xmath7 ratio goes close to zero in the vicinity of @xmath15 , violating isospin symmetry and thus unequivocally confirming the electromagnetic origin of the whole phenomenon . note that the latter value of @xmath16 corresponds , at low transverse momenta , to pions moving at the same velocity as the spectator system , thus confirming that electromagnetic repulsion ( attraction ) of positive ( negative ) pions from positively charged spectator protons is indeed at the cause of this behaviour . + ( left ) and @xmath8 ( right ) ratios , for particles produced in peripheral pb+pb collisions . the different panels correspond to different pion and kaon emission times @xmath17 . the figure comes from @xcite.,scaledwidth=75.0% ] 2 . our simple monte carlo model of the electromagnetic interaction @xcite brings a very reasonable description of the main features of this effect as shown in fig . [ fig : figone](b ) . the unique region where a more significant disagreement between data and model can be seen ( @xmath18 , low @xmath13 ) has been identified as due to the process of _ nuclear fragmentation ( break - up ) of the spectator system _ ; a discussion of this subject can be found in @xcite . 3 . a very similar electromagnetic effect is also present in high energy collisions of lead ions with lighter nuclei which we recently investigated @xcite . 4 . the electromagnetic distortion observed in fig . [ fig : figone](a ) _ depends on the specific space - time scenario imposed on pion emission_. this is illustrated in fig . [ fig : figtwo ] ( left ) where the results of our model calculations are drawn in the full range of @xmath11 , @xmath19 , for different values assumed for the time of pion emission @xmath17 . the characteristic distortion pattern imposed by the two spectator systems at positive and negative @xmath11 appears clearly sensitive to @xmath17 ( with typically lower @xmath7 ratios obtained for larger @xmath17 at higher values of @xmath11 ) . _ this implies that the electromagnetic effect provides independent information on the evolution of the non - perturbative process of pion production in space and time _ the electromagnetic distortion of charged kaon ( @xmath8 ) ratios , fig . [ fig : figtwo ] ( right ) , exhibits basic qualitative similarities to the effect seen for pions , however , with pronounced differences on the quantitative level . the position of the deep `` valley '' in the ratio is displaced towards higher values of @xmath11 , and the region of highest sensitivity to the kaon emission time is moved towards very high @xmath11 ( @xmath20 ) . 6 . finally , as apparent in fig . [ fig : figthree ] , the spectator - induced electromagnetic force exerts also _ a noticeable influence on pion directed flow , @xmath21_. our very recent monte carlo calculation ( not yet published ) predicts a well - defined pattern in the rapidity dependence of the _ electromagnetically - induced _ directed flow of positive pions , with a large peak in the vicinity of projectile and target rapidities . as such , directed flow of charged pions ( @xmath22 , @xmath23 ) appears as another observable where , also through electromagnetic effects , new information on the space - time evolution of the reaction can become available . . the simulation assumes the pion emission time @xmath17 equal to zero . directed flow is integrated over @xmath13 from 0 to 1 gev / c.,scaledwidth=75.0% ] the above description is , of course , highly simplified ( the interested reader is invited to visit the enclosed bibliography for a more detailed account ) , but nevertheless constitutes a good starting point for the present proposal . as it comes from the considerations above , and as has also been suggested to us in numerous discussions with experts , the spectator - induced electromagnetic effects discussed here have very specific characteristics which make them attractive for numerous future studies : 1 . they can be large in specific regions of phase space ; 2 . they can bring large distortions to various collision characteristics observed in the final state ( like charged particle ratios or directed flow ) and at the same time , they can provide information about the intrinsic space - time scenario of particle emission ( formation times , parton fragmentation , resonance decays , hydrodynamics , etc ) . as such , in principle they should be studied in any possible reaction at any possible energy , whenever this is possible . this is particularly important in the present situation where the available experimental information remains very limited . in the high energy regime ( sps energies and above ) , no experimental data set other than what was discussed above is known to us . no possibility of obtaining such information at rhic or lhc is apparent to us due to strict experimental limitations . for this reason , we see here a good scientific prospect for nica . the principal detector requirements needed in order to perform measurements of the spectator - induced electromagnetic effect are particle momentum vector reconstruction and particle identification capabilities ( including in particular charge differentiation ) , as well as a relatively wide acceptance coverage defined in terms of longitudinal and transverse momenta . once these conditions are fulfilled , measurements of particle spectra ( preferably double differential spectra of the type @xmath24 ) become accessible . measurements of directed flow ( as well as possibly higher harmonics ) are characterized by additional requirements well known to the community . in the range of collision energies specified in @xcite , the nica / mpd apparatus looks promising in view of the requirements specified above . with the extremely broad spectrum of reactions planned to be analysed , including in particular proton - nucleus and nucleus - nucleus collisions with an impressive versatility of projectiles and targets , we propose a _ detailed , systematic experimental study of charged particle spectra and directed flow with a special emphasis on charge asymmetries induced by electromagnetic interactions_. such a very broad study , taking full benefit of the possibility of cross - comparisons between different reactions ( in particular also proton - nucleus collisions ) , of switching between fixed target and collider modes with different ranges of effective acceptance in both cases , and of comparisons of different collision energies , would in our view provide new information on the _ space - time evolution of very different aspects of nuclear reactions_. in particular , these would be : 1 . the centrality and system - size dependence of particle production phenomena ; 2 . the interplay between particle production and spectator fragmentation ; 3 . azimuthal anisotropies and flow ; 4 . the energy dependence of particle production . all of the above are clearly basic , essential issues in heavy ion collision physics . with the advent of the nica research programme , these could be analysed also with full use of the specific electromagnetic interaction as discussed in the present proposal . as already specified above , we consider the competition from existing experiments as relatively weak with respect to the possibilities offered by nica and its experimental community . we see at present no rhic nor lhc experiment to be able to provide reliable measurements of the phenomena discussed here . what remains is clearly the sps energy range where , as evident from the results presented in fig . [ fig : figone ] above , new experimental analyses can be performed on the basis of data from the na49 experiment @xcite or from its extension , na61/shine @xcite . this could possibly make these experiments complementary to nica / mpd , but with specific limitations which would require a more in - depth study . the interplay of strong and electromagnetic interactions in nuclear collisions , including in particular the spectator - induced electromagnetic distortion of charged particle spectra and azimuthal anisotropies , constitutes a new , and in our opinion , very promising source of information on the space - time evolution of various processes present in the heavy ion reaction . the range of collision energies considered for nica , together with its experimental elasticity in terms of data taking mode and of the versatile choice of interacting projectiles and targets , makes it in our opinion well suitable to bring a very valuable contribution to studies of this phenomenon . e802 collab . , l. ahle _ _ , phys . rev . * c57 * ( 1998 ) r466 , + na44 collab . * a610 * ( 1996 ) 175c , + h.w.bartz , j.p.bondorf , j.j.gaardhoje and h.heiselberg , phys . rev . * c57 * ( 1998 ) 2536 , + t. osada , s. sano , m. biyajima and g. wilk , phys . rev . * c54 * ( 1996 ) r2167 .

in the following we stress the advantages of the nica research programme in the context of studying the spectator - induced electromagnetic phenomena present in proton - nucleus and heavy ion collisions . we point at the specific interest of using these phenomena as a new , independent source of information on the space - time evolution of the reaction and of the non - perturbative process of particle production . we propose an extended series of measurements of well - defined observables to be performed in different types of nuclear reactions and in the whole range of collision energies available to nica . we expect these measurements to bring very valuable new insight into the mechanism of non - perturbative strong interactions , complementary to the studies made at the sps at cern , rhic at bnl , and the lhc .

1301.6456

in the field of coding theory , calculations of good upper and lower bounds on the size of a code serves as a benchmark for code design . techniques of constructing subspace codes for error correction in random network coding ( also called ` projective space codes ' ) are similar to the techniques used to construct binary codes . a projective space code is defined as a subset of subspaces of a vector space . the viewpoint of lattice theory for projective space codes has already been suggested @xcite . a lattice is a partially ordered set in which any two elements have a least upper bound and a greatest lower bound . the set of all subspaces of a vector space is called a projective space and the set of all subsets of a set is called a power set . both the power set and the projective space form lattices under inclusion order . a ` lattice scheme ' is defined as a subset of a lattice . it has already been observed in @xcite that binary codes and projective space codes are lattice schemes . binary codes are power set schemes and projective space codes are projective space schemes . the lattice framework common to projective space codes and binary codes have also been observed in @xcite and @xcite . the authors of @xcite establish that the projective space codes are analogs of classical binary codes . they also investigate the notions of linearity and complements of a code . in @xcite , the relationship between binary codes and projective space codes is investigated thoroughly using the framework of lattices and a generalized notion of orthogonal complement is introduced for lattices . one of the ways to generate a bound on the code size is to capture a bare minimum structure for the bound through an appropriate mathematical abstraction and generalize the approach . for example , the introduction of ` association schemes ' captured the notion of sphere packing and sphere covering arguments in traditional coding theory @xcite and strengthened the bounds by a linear programming approach . in our paper , the notion of singleton bound is generalized using the framework of lattices . since error correcting codes for random network coding was proposed in @xcite , there has been a lot of activity in the theory of projective space codes . the authors of @xcite consider projective space codes in which all the subspaces are of the same dimension . such codes are called constant dimension codes . the koetter - kschischang singleton bound ( kks bound ) for constant dimension codes was derived and achieved asymptotically in @xcite . in the case of binary codes , hamming distance between two binary vectors is a metric on the binary coding space . similarly the subspace distance , introduced in @xcite , between two subspaces of a vector space is a metric on the projective space . in a projective space , the number of elements in a sphere of a particular radius depends on the center of that sphere @xcite . however , in the case of binary codes , the number of elements in a sphere depends only on the radius of the sphere and not on the center of the sphere . so the subspace distance on the projective space behaves differently from the hamming distance on the usual binary vectors . as noted in @xcite , the anticode bound introduced in @xcite gives a setting in which one can get tighter sphere packing bounds for constant dimension codes . a close look at the bounds for subspace distance and non - existence of nontrivial perfect codes has been given in @xcite . an appropriate generalization for singleton bounds ( analogous to association scheme for sphere packing / covering bounds ) is not known yet . in this paper , we propose that the lattice framework is appropriate for generalizing singleton bounds . we derive an upper bound on the size of a lattice scheme , which will be called lattice singleton bound ( lsb ) for the remainder of the paper . we get the kks bound and the classical singleton bound as special cases of the lsb . while most results in projective space codes assume that the dimensions of the subspaces in the code are constant , a few papers in literature have considered codes with non - constant dimension . in particular , the authors of @xcite derive a gilbert - varshamov type bound , which we will term as ` etzion vardy- gilbert varshamov bound ' ( ev - gvb ) , for non - constant dimension codes . we derive a _ new _ upper bound on the code size for non - constant dimension codes by applying the lsb to the projective lattice . to the best of our knowledge , our singleton bound is the first upper bound for non - constant dimension codes . the construction of constant dimension codes have been the main focus in the field of code constructions for projective spaces . the first constant dimension subspace codes introduced in @xcite achieve the kks bound asymptotically . and there is no known code constructions that exactly achieve the singleton bound proposed in @xcite . the question of achieving that singleton bound is an open question . a large class of constant and non - constant dimension codes using ferrer s diagrams and lifted rank metric codes are constructed in @xcite . the authors of @xcite report marginal improvements over the size of the code compared to the codes of @xcite . a plot of code sizes of the codes reported in @xcite compared to a plot of our upper bound shows that both the reported codes have code sizes that are close to optimal . this also establishes that our upper bound is tight for atleast certain coding parameters . the contributions of this paper are as follows : 1 . we derive a singleton bound in the framework of lattices . we recover the singleton bound for binary codes and the singleton bound for constant dimension subspace codes ( kks bound ) as special cases of our lsb . we obtain a new singleton bound for non - constant dimension subspace codes . we compare our bound on the code size with the code sizes of non - constant dimension codes found in the literature . we also compare our upper bound with a gilbert - varshamov type lower bound . the plots reveal that our bound is tight for certain parameters of the code . the paper is organized as follows : we introduce the preliminaries of lattices in section [ sec_lat_prelims ] . section [ sec_lat_sch ] introduces the idea of lattice schemes where it is shown that classical codes and subspace codes are both lattice schemes . section [ sec_main_res ] introduces the singleton bound in the framework of lattice schemes and contains the main theorem of this paper . section [ sec_main_res ] contains the main distinguishing feature of projective space codes which we believe make singleton type bounds weak in projective spaces . in section [ sec_upp_bou ] , we obtain a new upper bound for non - constant dimension codes and plot our upper bound with ev - gvb along with different codes constructed in the literature . finally , in section [ sec_conc ] , we conclude by summarizing our contributions and discussing the scope for future work . _ notations : _ a set is denoted by a capital letter and its elements will be denoted by small letters ( for example , @xmath0 ) . the set @xmath1 is defined as @xmath2 . all the sets considered in this paper will be finite . given a set @xmath3 , @xmath4 denotes the number of elements in the set and for a subset @xmath5 of @xmath3 , @xmath6 denotes the complement of the set @xmath5 in @xmath3 . for two sets @xmath5 and @xmath7 , @xmath8 denotes the cartesian product of the two sets , i.e. @xmath9 . @xmath10 represents the symmetric difference of sets , i.e. @xmath11 . a lattice will be denoted by @xmath12 and sometimes we will drop the join and the meet notation , simply calling it @xmath13 . @xmath14 denotes the finite field with @xmath15 elements where @xmath15 is a power of a prime number . @xmath16 denotes all the non zero elements of @xmath14 . the symbol @xmath17 denotes a vector space ( generally over @xmath14 ) . for a subset @xmath18 of @xmath17 , @xmath19 denotes the linear span of all the elements in @xmath18 . given two subspaces @xmath5 and @xmath7 , @xmath20 denotes the smallest subspace containing both @xmath5 and @xmath7 . let @xmath17 be a @xmath21 dimensional space over @xmath14 . then the symbol @xmath22 denotes the grassmanian , i.e. the set of all @xmath23 dimensional subspaces of @xmath17 . the number of elements in @xmath22 is denoted as @xmath24 . @xmath25 denotes the @xmath21 dimensional vector space of @xmath21-tuples over @xmath14 . given a vector @xmath26 , @xmath27 denotes the @xmath28-th co - ordinate of @xmath29 . the support of @xmath26 ( denoted by @xmath30 ) is defined as the set of indices where the vector is non - zero . @xmath31 denotes the vector space @xmath25 with the hamming metric , i.e. @xmath32 . this section serves as a quick introduction to lattice theory . all the lattice theory definitions and theorems required for the rest of the paper are given in this section . we follow notations and definitions from @xcite . [ def_poset_order ] a _ poset _ is a pair @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is a set and @xmath35 is a binary relation ( called the _ order relation _ ) on the set @xmath34 satisfying : 1 . ( reflexivity ) for all @xmath36 2 . ( antisymmetry ) if @xmath37 , then @xmath38 3 . ( transitivity ) if @xmath39 , then @xmath40 for the remainder of the paper , @xmath34 denotes a poset with @xmath35 as the order relation . if @xmath41 and @xmath42 , then we use the shorthand @xmath43 . @xmath41 is read as `` x is less than y '' or `` x is contained in y '' . an _ upper bound _ ( _ lower bound _ ) of a subset @xmath3 of @xmath34 is an element @xmath44 containing ( contained in ) every @xmath45 . the _ least upper bound _ ( _ greatest lower bound _ ) of @xmath3 is the element of @xmath34 contained in ( containing ) every upper bound ( lower bound ) of @xmath3 . if a least upper bound , or a greatest lower bound of a set exists , it is unique due to the antisymmetry property of the order relation ( definition [ def_poset_order ] ) . the least upper bound of a set @xmath3 is denoted by sup @xmath3 and the greatest lower bound is denoted by inf @xmath3 . a _ lattice _ @xmath13 is a poset which has the property that @xmath46 , the sup@xmath47 exists and inf@xmath47 exists . the sup@xmath47 is denoted by @xmath48 ( read as `` a _ join _ b '' ) and the inf@xmath47 is denoted by @xmath49 ( read as `` a _ meet _ b '' ) . the lattice itself is denoted by @xmath12 . we will assume , for the purposes of the paper , that all the lattices are finite and have a unique greatest element denoted by @xmath50 , and a unique least element denoted by @xmath51 . a _ sublattice _ of a lattice @xmath13 is a subset @xmath52 of @xmath13 that satisfies the following condition : @xmath53 a map @xmath54 from @xmath13 to @xmath52 is said to be a _ lattice homomorphism _ if it satisfies the following conditions : 1 . @xmath55 2 . @xmath56 further , if @xmath54 is bijective , then we say that @xmath13 and @xmath52 are _ let @xmath57 and @xmath58 denote the power set of @xmath3 . we can view @xmath59 as a poset where set inclusion is the order relation . the power set under this order is a lattice . for any subsets @xmath5 and @xmath7 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 . further , the lattice generated by subsets of @xmath62 is a sublattice . notice that @xmath63 and @xmath64 . @xmath65 one can completely specify an order of a poset ( finite ones ) by a _ hasse diagram _ , like the one shown in fig . [ fig_power_set ] . if @xmath66 and there is no @xmath67 such that @xmath68 , we say that `` @xmath69 _ covers _ @xmath70 '' . in the hasse diagram of a lattice , @xmath70 and @xmath69 are joined iff @xmath69 covers @xmath70 or @xmath70 covers @xmath69 . the diagram is drawn in such a way that if @xmath69 covers @xmath70 , then @xmath69 is written above @xmath70 . clearly , @xmath66 iff there exists a path from @xmath70 moving up to @xmath69 . the order relation is completely specified by such a diagram . naturally , @xmath50 will be the topmost element and @xmath51 will be the lowest element . ): a lattice of subsets ] for a set @xmath3 , @xmath71__pow(@xmath3)__@xmath72 will denote lattice of the power set of @xmath3 with union and intersection as join and meet of the lattice respectively . a lattice @xmath12 is _ distributive _ if the following conditions hold : 1 . for all @xmath73 2 . for all @xmath74 it is immediate that for any set @xmath3 , @xmath71__pow__(@xmath3)@xmath72 is a distributive lattice . however all lattices are not distributive , as seen in the examples below . let @xmath17 be a vector space of dimension @xmath21 over a field @xmath75 . the class of all the subspaces of @xmath17 , denoted by @xmath76 , can be ordered under inclusion in a manner similar to a set . the join of two subspaces @xmath5 and @xmath7 will then be the smallest subspace containing both @xmath5 and @xmath7 . this means that @xmath77 and the largest subspace contained in both @xmath5 and @xmath7 is @xmath78 . so the meet of @xmath5 and @xmath7 is @xmath78 . such a lattice will be denoted as @xmath79 . clearly @xmath80 and @xmath81 . this lattice will be called the _ projective lattice_. this lattice is not distributive . to see this , we consider the vector space @xmath82 over @xmath83 . the hasse diagram of @xmath84 is shown in fig . [ fig_subspace ] . here , @xmath85 , @xmath86 and @xmath87 . clearly , @xmath88 and thus @xmath84 is not distributive . @xmath84 is identified by the name _ m@xmath89_. @xmath65 : a lattice of subspaces , also called @xmath90 the above lattice is not distributive , i.e. @xmath91 fails for three distinct subspaces @xmath92 . if @xmath93 , one can prove that @xmath94 and thus it behaves partly distributively . this property is captured in the following definition : a lattice @xmath12 is _ modular _ if the following condition holds : + ( modularity ) if @xmath95 , then @xmath96 if the lattice is distributive , the modularity condition holds . this means that _ any distributive lattice is modular_. however @xmath79 is a modular lattice that is non distributive . the observation that for @xmath71__pow(@xmath3)__@xmath72 , any two elements @xmath97 satisfy @xmath98 , and in an analogous fashion , for @xmath79 , any two elements @xmath97 satisfy @xmath99 , seems to suggest that modular lattices must satisfy an equation of the form @xmath100 for some real - valued function @xmath101 on the lattice . this is indeed true and in turn , such a function helps characterise modular lattices . we need the following few definitions and results to make the characterisation precise . an _ isotone valuation _ on a lattice @xmath13 is a real valued function @xmath101 on @xmath13 that satisfies : 1 . ( valuation ) for all @xmath102 , @xmath103 2 . ( isotone ) @xmath104 additionally , the isotone valuation is called _ positive _ , if @xmath105 . @xmath106 is said to be the distance induced by @xmath101 . * pg.230 , th.1 ) [ thm_pseudo_metric ] given a lattice @xmath13 and an isotone valuation @xmath101 , the function @xmath107 is a metric iff @xmath101 is positive . in general , @xmath108 is a pseudo metric . in a lattice @xmath12 , a _ chain _ @xmath109 is a subset of @xmath13 with the property that for all @xmath110 , @xmath66 or @xmath111 . we say that in a chain , any two elements are comparable . given two elements @xmath112 , a chain @xmath113 of @xmath13 with the property @xmath114 is called a _ chain between @xmath70 and @xmath69_. the _ length _ of the chain is defined as @xmath23 . the _ height _ of an element @xmath29 in a lattice @xmath13 is the maximum length of a chain between @xmath51 and @xmath29 . it is denoted by @xmath115 . the number @xmath116 is called _ the height of the lattice _ @xmath13 or the _ dimension of _ @xmath13 . note that the chain from @xmath51 to @xmath51 contains only one element , and thus @xmath117 . we need an additional property to characterise modular lattices . a lattice is said to have the _ jordan - dedekind property _ if all maximal chains between two elements have the same finite length . all lattices need not have the jordan - dedekind property . for example , in the @xmath118 lattice , shown in fig . [ fig_hasse_diag_n_5 ] , there are two maximal chains from @xmath119 to @xmath120 . the maximal chain @xmath121 has three units of length and the other maximal chain @xmath122 has a length of two units . thus @xmath118 does not satisfy the jordan dedekind property . it turns out that modularity is closely related to this property . lattice : a lattice without jordan - dedekind property ] [ jd ] ( * ? ? ? * pg.41 , th.16 ) let @xmath12 be a lattice of finite length with the height function @xmath123 , then the following conditions are equivalent : 1 . @xmath13 is a modular lattice . 2 . @xmath13 has the jordan - dedekind property and @xmath123 is a valuation . the @xmath118 lattice shown in fig . [ fig_hasse_diag_n_5 ] does not satisfy the jordan - dedekind property and therefore , due to theorem [ jd ] , @xmath118 is non - modular . the height function @xmath123 is a positive isotone evaluation for modular lattices . therefore from theorem [ thm_pseudo_metric ] , the distance function induced by @xmath123 is a metric on the modular lattice . all the lattices , considered in this paper , will be modular . we will use this observation in the next section to define a coding metric for the definition of lattice schemes . we , therefore , have the following proposition which follows from theorem [ thm_pseudo_metric ] . [ thm_height_metric ] let @xmath13 be a modular lattice of finite length with the height function @xmath123 , then @xmath124 is a metric on @xmath13 . clearly @xmath125=1 $ ] iff @xmath29 covers @xmath51 . such elements are called _ atoms _ of the lattice . the atoms of the lattice are analogues of the singletons in lattice of sets ( one dimensional spaces in the lattice of subspaces ) . a _ geometric modular lattice _ is a modular lattice of finite height in which every element is a join of atoms . further , if the geometric modular lattice is distributive , then it will be called _ geometric distributive_. the lattice of subsets is a an example of a geometric distributive lattice and the lattice of subspaces is an example of a geometric modular lattice . is shown . in part ( b ) , a non - geometric , non - distributive modular lattice @xmath126 is depicted . ] however , all modular ( distributive ) lattices are not geometric . for example , consider the sublattice ( in fact , a chain ) @xmath127 of @xmath71__pow(@xmath128)__@xmath72 ( shown in part ( a ) of fig . [ fig_nongeometric ] ) . @xmath129 is not geometric because @xmath128 can not be obtained as a join of atoms of @xmath130 ( since there is only one atom in @xmath129 ) . @xmath129 is distributive since it is a sublattice of distributive lattice viz . therefore @xmath130 is an example of non - geometric distributive lattice . in order to construct a non - geometric non - distributive modular lattice , we will consider a sublattice of @xmath131 . for the sake of presentation , we will represent a vector @xmath132 by the natural number @xmath133 . for example , @xmath134 will be represented as @xmath135 . consider the sublattice @xmath136 of @xmath131 . @xmath126 is modular since it is a sublattice of a modular lattice viz . @xmath126 is not distributive because it contains a copy of @xmath137 as a sublattice ( @xmath137 is non - distributive ) . it can be verified that @xmath138 can not be obtained as a join of atoms of @xmath126 and thus @xmath126 is non - geometric . therefore @xmath126 is an example of non - geometric non - distributive modular lattice . henceforth all the lattices are assumed to be geometric modular unless otherwise mentioned . in order to develop a lattice based framework for singleton bounds , we need a definition of a code in this framework . in this section , we define ` lattice schemes ' which will serve as analogues of codes . we will show that hamming space , rank metric space and the projective spaces are examples of lattice schemes . although some of these observations have been mentioned in @xcite , we repeat it for the sake of continuity . a lattice scheme , which is analogous to a code , is defined as follows : let @xmath13 be a lattice and @xmath139 be the metric induced by the height function @xmath123 of the lattice @xmath13 . a _ lattice scheme _ @xmath109 in @xmath140 is a subset of @xmath13 and the _ minimum distance of @xmath109 _ , denoted by @xmath119 is defined as @xmath141 the dimension of a lattice scheme is defined as @xmath142 . a coding space @xmath143 is a metric space where @xmath3 is a set and @xmath144 is a metric on @xmath3 . a code @xmath109 in a coding space @xmath143 is a subset of @xmath3 . the connection between lattice schemes and codes is made precise in the following definition . [ def_transform ] let @xmath109 be a lattice scheme in @xmath140 and @xmath145 be a code in a coding space @xmath146 . we say that the _ code _ @xmath145 is _ equivalent to a lattice scheme _ @xmath109 , if there exists a function @xmath147 , that satisfies the following conditions : 1 . @xmath148 2 . @xmath149 for all @xmath150 @xmath151 is called a transform for the code @xmath145 . a transform @xmath151 of a code is one - one . to prove this fact , assume @xmath152 , then @xmath153 . by 2 ) of definition [ def_transform ] , this would imply @xmath154 . and since @xmath144 is a metric , we have @xmath155 . @xmath65 when a lattice scheme is equivalent to a code , we also say the code is equivalent to the scheme . a transform for a code preserves the distance between any pair of codewords . therefore whenever a lattice scheme is equivalent to a code , the lattice scheme will have the same minimum distance as the code . the following proposition follows from definition [ def_transform ] , [ prop_dist_preserve ] let @xmath109 be a lattice scheme with minimum distance @xmath119 that is equivalent to code @xmath145 with minimum distance @xmath156 , then 1 . @xmath157 2 . if @xmath158 , then there exists @xmath159 such that the lattice scheme @xmath5 is equivalent to the code @xmath160 since ` @xmath109 is equivalent to @xmath145 ' , the first part follows from the definition . for the second part , since @xmath109 is equivalent to @xmath145 , there exists a transform @xmath151 . we define @xmath161 . clearly @xmath159 and the function @xmath151 still serves as a lattice transform for the code @xmath162 . thus @xmath5 is equivalent to @xmath162 . due to the above proposition , given a lattice scheme equivalent to a code , we can talk of the minimum distance without specifying whether it is the minimum distance of the code or the minimum distance of the scheme . from the second part of the proposition [ prop_dist_preserve ] , we can infer that the subsets of codes are equivalent to certain subsets of schemes . therefore , if we prove that a coding space itself is equivalent to some lattice , then any code in the coding space is equivalent to a scheme in the lattice . we use this observation to establish that every binary code is equivalent to a scheme in the power set lattice . [ exmpl_binary_codes ] let @xmath163 , @xmath164_pow(@xmath3)_@xmath72 and @xmath165 . @xmath13 is a geometric distributive lattice and @xmath166 as seen in the previous section . consider codes in the coding space @xmath167 where @xmath168 is the hamming distance between two vectors . we claim that the entire coding space @xmath169 is equivalent to the power set lattice @xmath13 . to see this let , @xmath170 it can be verified that @xmath171 ( where @xmath172 represents the symmetric difference operator ) and that @xmath173 is onto . further , @xmath174 . the number of elements in @xmath175 will be the hamming weight of @xmath176 . thus @xmath177 . therefore , @xmath173 is the power set lattice transform for the binary code . since the map is onto , @xmath173 is a bijective map . by application of the second part of proposition [ prop_dist_preserve ] , we see that every binary code is equivalent to a power set lattice scheme . @xmath65 the lattice of subspaces , discussed in the previous section , also provide examples of lattice schemes . in a projective lattice , the metric induced by the height function is the subspace distance . therefore , any subspace code is equivalent to a lattice scheme in the projective lattice . let @xmath17 be a vector space over @xmath178 is a projective lattice with height function @xmath179 . the coding space is @xmath180 where @xmath181 represents the subspace distance defined in @xcite . for any two subspaces @xmath5 and @xmath7 , @xmath182 . since @xmath183 , the metric induced by the height function is the subspace distance . the identity map can be a transform in this case . and thus , subspace schemes are equivalent to subspace codes.@xmath65 lattice schemes in the above lattice correspond to subspace codes in projective spaces @xcite . certain constant dimension subspace code constructions , described in @xcite , make use of the rank distance gabidulin codes @xcite . the rank metric codes are actually equivalent to gabidulin codes since they are ` lifted ' from gabidulin codes . we show that rank distance codes are equivalent to certain schemes in the projective lattice . we also show that the lifting function is a transform . let @xmath184 denote the space of @xmath185 matrices over @xmath14 . for @xmath186 , define @xmath187 . this coding space is the rank distance space . we claim that the rank distance space is equivalent to a scheme in the projective lattice . consider the projective lattice @xmath188 with the height function @xmath179 . define a transform @xmath151 as follows : @xmath189 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that @xmath190 for any @xmath5 in @xmath191 . therefore subspaces whose dimension is not @xmath192 are not in the range of @xmath151 . therefore @xmath151 is an example of a transform that is not onto . the function @xmath151 defined above is called the lifting of @xmath5 in @xcite . the authors of @xcite establish that @xmath193 . thus rank metric codes are equivalent to schemes in the projective lattice and @xmath151 is the projective lattice transform for the rank metric code . @xmath65 all our main results on the bounds and their behavior are derived in this section . we introduce the notion of puncturing a scheme and investigate the effects of puncturing on the minimum distance of a lattice scheme . it will be proved that , after puncturing a scheme , the maximum drop in minimum distance will be two . however , if the lattice is known to be distributive , it is shown that the maximum drop in minimum distance is one . this observation will be applied repeatedly until the minimum distance drops to zero . we will need the following definition of _ whitney number of the second kind _ , from @xcite , to state the lattice singleton bound : the _ whitney numbers _ @xmath194 of a lattice @xmath13 in a lattice with height @xmath123 and @xmath195 is defined as @xmath196 the whitney numbers of a lattice count the total number of elements in the lattice of a given height . a scheme @xmath109 is said to be _ punctured to @xmath197 _ if @xmath198 for some @xmath199 . if @xmath200 has a height of @xmath201 , the scheme @xmath109 is said to be _ punctured by a dimension_. note that for a @xmath199 , @xmath202 is a sublattice of @xmath13 @xcite . for two lattice elements @xmath200 and @xmath203 of equal height , we have @xmath204 . this means that the whitney numbers of two different punctured lattices remain the same , as long as the elements that puncture the scheme are of the same height . we need the following lemma ( called the ` distance drop lemma ' ) to establish the proof of the main theorem later . [ lem_drop_dist ] let @xmath109 be a scheme in @xmath140 with minimum distance @xmath119 , and let @xmath109 be punctured by a dimension to @xmath197 , then 1 . @xmath13 is distributive @xmath205 @xmath206 2 . in general , @xmath207 proof of 1 ) : we assume @xmath13 is distributive . let @xmath208 , @xmath209 and @xmath210 . we have to show that @xmath211 for all @xmath212 . by the definition of @xmath139 , @xmath213 - h[\tilde{a } \wedge \tilde{b } ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] since the lattice is distributive , we can write it as , @xmath214 - h[a \wedge b \wedge w ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the height function is a valuation and thus satisfies @xmath215 + h[x \wedge y ] = h[x ] + h[y]$ ] . we use this in the above equation to obtain , @xmath216 + h[w ] - h[a \vee b \vee w ] - h[a \wedge b \wedge w ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath217 , it must be that @xmath218 \leq h[i ] = n$ ] . using this inequality and @xmath219 = n-1 $ ] , we get @xmath220 + ( n-1 ) - n - h[a \wedge b \wedge w ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] clearly @xmath221 and therefore @xmath222 \leq h[a \wedge b]$ ] . using this , the definition of @xmath223 and the fact that @xmath119 is the minimum distance of the scheme @xmath109 , we finally get @xmath224 proof of 2 ) : we have to show that @xmath225 for all @xmath212 . again by the definition of @xmath139 , @xmath226 - h[\tilde{a } \wedge \tilde{b}].\end{aligned}\ ] ] repeatedly using the fact that the height function is a valuation and thus satisfies @xmath215 + h[x \wedge y ] = h[x ] + h[y]$ ] , we get , @xmath227 + h[b ] + 2h[w ] - h[a \vee w ] \\ - h[b \vee w ] - 2h[a \wedge b \wedge w ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] clearly @xmath221 and therefore @xmath222 \leq h[a \wedge b]$ ] . additionally @xmath228 and @xmath229 , which means @xmath230 , h[\tilde{b } ] \leq h[i ] = n$ ] . using this inequality and @xmath219 = n-1 $ ] , we get the following : @xmath231 + h[b ] + 2(n-1 ) - 2n - 2h[a \wedge b ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] using the definition of @xmath223 and the fact that @xmath119 is the minimum distance of the scheme @xmath109 , we finally get , @xmath232 the distance drop lemma states that in a non - distributive lattice , the drop in the minimum distance after puncturing a dimension , can be at most two units . so it would be interesting to know if it is possible that the drop of two units is exhibited by some scheme in a non - distributive lattice . the following example constructs such a scheme . [ example_proj_space ] let @xmath17 be a three dimensional space , over @xmath233 , spanned by @xmath234 . let @xmath235 @xmath236 , @xmath237 @xmath238 and @xmath239 @xmath240 . we have @xmath241 but @xmath242 . note that @xmath243 ( that is , the sublattice generated by @xmath244 , @xmath245 and @xmath246 is not distributive ) as expected . if our scheme contained @xmath247 and @xmath246 , then puncturing the scheme with @xmath246 would have left @xmath246 as it is and punctured only the remaining two subspaces . the above example clearly illustrates that the lack of distributivity in a lattice can drop the distance of a punctured scheme by two units . we will now derive a singleton bound for lattice schemes , that establishes an upper bound on the cardinality of the scheme , for a given minimum distance for geometric modular lattices . [ theorem_lsb ] if @xmath248 is a geometric modular lattice with height @xmath123 and @xmath249 , @xmath139 is the metric induced by the height function , and @xmath109 is a scheme of @xmath13 with minimum distance @xmath119 , then @xmath250 where 1 . @xmath251 , when @xmath13 is _ distributive _ , 2 . @xmath252 , when @xmath13 is _ modular_. given the lattice @xmath13 , pick an element @xmath200 of height @xmath253 ( which always exists in a geometric modular lattice ) . now puncture the lattice by a dimension to get a new geometric modular lattice @xmath129 with height @xmath253 and suppose that drop in minimum distance of the scheme , after puncturing a dimension , is at most @xmath254 . if @xmath255 is the minimum distance of the punctured scheme @xmath197 , then @xmath256 . if @xmath257 , then all elements in the punctured scheme @xmath197 are still distinct . we repeat the puncturing operating on the new lattice . the puncturing is repeated maximum number of times so that the minimum distance of the punctured scheme does not drop to zero . in other words , we keep puncturing the lattice , until the minimum distance of the punctured scheme is just short of zero . let us say that the original lattice was punctured @xmath258 times . since the minimum distance of the punctured scheme is still non zero , the punctured scheme contains exactly the same number of elements as @xmath109 . at this stage , the minimum distance of the scheme is non - zero and all the elements of the punctured scheme are in a lattice of height @xmath259 . clearly the number of elements in the scheme @xmath109 is upper bounded by the total number of elements in the punctured lattice . thus @xmath260 if the minimum distance of the scheme , after being punctured @xmath258 times , is @xmath261 , then @xmath262 and @xmath261 is the smallest number such that @xmath263 . this implies that @xmath264 . from the lemma [ lem_drop_dist ] , we know that @xmath265 for a distributive lattice and @xmath266 for a modular lattice . thus @xmath267 for a distributive lattice and for a modular lattice , @xmath252 . this completes the proof . we remark that the bound does not equal @xmath268 , for the case @xmath269 , which should yield only two elements . the bound is weaker for large minimum distance because we have no information about the range of heights of the elements of the scheme . we can tighten the bound by systematically puncturing and projecting a dimension as done in @xcite . also , as noted in example [ example_proj_space ] , puncturing a dimension of a scheme does not reduce the heights of the elements of the scheme in a uniform manner . so we need the following definition , given two elements @xmath270 and @xmath200 in a lattice @xmath13 , define @xmath271 to be equal to an element of height @xmath272 that is contained in @xmath273 . in particular , if @xmath200 is fixed and @xmath274 , the set @xmath275 is said to be _ punctured and projected by a dimension_. thus when @xmath276 , @xmath271 is arbitrarily chosen to be an element immediately below @xmath270 in the hasse diagram of the lattice . for all other cases , @xmath277 . the following example illustrates that puncturing a dimension reduces the heights of different elements of a scheme by different amounts . it also demonstrates that puncturing and projecting by a dimension equally reduces the heights of all elements of a scheme . in example [ exmpl_punc_proj ] is shown here . the dark arrow shows that after puncturing and projecting by @xmath246 both @xmath244 and @xmath245 can drop to the same subspace @xmath278 . however , puncturing by @xmath246 alone drops @xmath245 to @xmath278 but not @xmath244 . ] [ exmpl_punc_proj ] let @xmath17 be a three dimensional space , over @xmath233 , spanned by @xmath234 . let @xmath235 @xmath279 , @xmath237 @xmath280 and @xmath239 @xmath279 . [ fig_puncture ] shows how puncturing and projecting drops the heights of all elements by one unit . thus the dimension of @xmath244 remains the same after puncturing by @xmath246 but the dimension of @xmath245 drops by one unit . however , after puncturing and projecting the lattice by @xmath246 , both @xmath244 and @xmath245 drop by a height of one unit . to be precise , define @xmath281 and observe that @xmath282 . but @xmath283 . to define @xmath284 we need to choose a one dimensional subspace of @xmath244 . for instance , we can choose @xmath285 . @xmath65 we can now establish that puncturing and projecting a dimension of a scheme can drop the minimum distance of the scheme by at most two units . this lemma is useful since it tells us that every time we puncture and project by a dimension , all the elements in the scheme drop once in height . [ lemma_punctured_drop ] let @xmath109 be a scheme in a lattice @xmath140 with minimum distance @xmath119 , and let @xmath249 and let @xmath199 such that @xmath286 . if the maximum height of @xmath109 was @xmath287 and the minimum height of @xmath109 was @xmath192 , then the maximum height of @xmath288 is @xmath289 and the minimum height is @xmath290 . additionally @xmath291 by definition of @xmath288 , all the elements of @xmath288 have lost a unit of height . so the only thing to establish is that @xmath292 . the proof is very similar to the previous lemma . by the definition of @xmath139 , @xmath293 + h[\overline{b \wedge w } ] - 2h[\overline{a \wedge w } \wedge \overline { b \wedge w } ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] from the definition of @xmath294 , it follows that @xmath295 and thus @xmath296 \leq h[x \wedge w]$ ] for all @xmath297 and thus , @xmath298 - 1 ) + ( h[b ] - 1 ) - 2h[a \wedge b ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] and therefore from the formula for height we get , @xmath299 we will need lemma [ lemma_punctured_drop ] to get the following improvement on the code size , [ thm_tighter_bound ] let @xmath109 be a scheme in a geometric modular lattice @xmath13 with minimum distance @xmath119 . let @xmath192 denote the smallest height of all the elements in @xmath109 and @xmath287 denote the largest height of all the elements in @xmath109 . then , @xmath300 let @xmath200 be an element of height @xmath253 and @xmath301 . by lemma [ lemma_punctured_drop ] , the punctured and projected scheme in @xmath129 has a maximum height of @xmath302 , a minimum height of @xmath290 and a minimum distance drop of at most two units . now the proof proceeds in a manner similar to the proof of the theorem [ theorem_lsb ] . after puncturing @xmath303 times , the elements of the scheme will have a maximum height of @xmath304 and a minimum height of @xmath305 and the theorem is proved . we will now apply theorem [ theorem_lsb ] and theorem [ thm_tighter_bound ] to two important lattice schemes ( namely the power set lattice and the projective lattice ) and derive the corresponding lsb . the lsb that we obtain coincides with the singleton bound found in the literature . first , we derive the classical singleton bound as a corollary to the lsb theorem . let @xmath109 be a code in @xmath306 , with minimum distance @xmath119 , then @xmath307 in example [ exmpl_binary_codes ] , @xmath308 is the number of subsets of size @xmath309 in the scheme @xmath109 , given that @xmath310 . using the fact that @xmath13 is geometric and distributive , @xmath251 . first we observe that , @xmath311 and @xmath312 applying the lsb theorem , we get , @xmath313 which is the singleton bound for @xmath306 . now we derive the kks bound reported in @xcite . it follows as a direct corollary to theorem [ thm_tighter_bound ] when the lattice is chosen to be the lattice of subspaces . if @xmath314 and @xmath315 , then @xmath316 let @xmath317 where @xmath109 is chosen to be a subset of the grassmanian @xmath22 . then @xmath314 and the lattice coefficients @xmath318 . now apply theorem [ thm_tighter_bound ] to @xmath109 . the distance drop lemma , used in the main theorem , along with example [ example_proj_space ] clearly shows that at every step of puncturing the distance can drop by at most two units . on the other hand , one can construct examples where distance drop is one unit . now suppose some scheme achieves the lsb ( and thus the kks bound ) . then that scheme has elements which consistently drop by a distance of two units _ irrespective _ of which element is puncturing it . and this should happen at every puncturing step until the minimum distance drops to zero . since this seems highly unlikely , we conjecture the following : _ conjecture : _ there are no schemes that can achieve the lsb for projective spaces . in particular , there are no constant dimension codes that can achieve the kks bound . it is clear that many examples fit into the framework of lattice schemes and the proposed lsb specializes to the known singleton bounds in literature . in this section , we will show that the lsb gives a new upper bound when applied to projective spaces . a family of non - constant dimension code constructions in projective spaces have been reported by @xcite and @xcite . our lsb plots show that the code sizes , of both reported codes , are near optimal for certain fixed values of the coding parameters . singleton bound in projective spaces will be specified using gaussian numbers ( they are the @xmath15-analogues of binomials @xcite ) . lower bounds on code sizes based on sphere covering methods can be found in @xcite . upper bounds on code sizes for projective space codes , found in the literature , are for constant dimension codes . the following bound is an upper bound on the code size of a non - constant dimension code in a projective space . let @xmath109 be a code in @xmath319 ( where @xmath17 is vector space over @xmath14 ) , with minimum distance @xmath119 , then @xmath320 where @xmath321 denotes the gaussian number . the @xmath322 lattice with @xmath323 is a modular geometric lattice . we note that @xmath324 the gaussian number @xmath325 is the total number of @xmath52-dimensional subspaces of an @xmath326-dimensional space over @xmath14 and thus by theorem [ theorem_lsb ] , @xmath327 where @xmath328 . the bound is weak when the minimum distance @xmath119 is comparable to the code dimension @xmath21 . however when the minimum distance is smaller than code dimension , the tightness of the bound is not apparent . therefore we investigate the behaviour of our bounds , at such ranges , by plotting it with other bounds in the literature . we will compare our bound ( lsb ) to the gilbert varshamov bound ( ev - gvb ) proposed in @xcite for various values of the minimum distance . further , we will plot points achieved by various codes in the literature . the plot is shown in fig . [ fig_drawing ] . the minimum distance of the projective code and the finite field size has been fixed at @xmath329 and @xmath268 respectively , throughout this section . the plot clearly shows our upper bound above the ev - gv lower bound . the points marked etzsilb codes and khks code are the code parameters reported in @xcite and @xcite respectively , for @xmath330 and @xmath331 . [ fig_drawing ] shows that the etzsilb codes and khks codes are close to optimal for @xmath330 and @xmath331 . the khks code sizes are roughly @xmath332 bits away from the upper bound . it has already been observed that the distance drop in projective spaces is variable and thus we believe that our bound is weak for larger values of @xmath119 . in this paper , we introduced the notion of lattice schemes which serve as analogues of codes . we derived a general notion of singleton bound for which the classical singleton bound for binary codes and the singleton - like bound for constant dimension subspace codes were special cases . we proved that puncturing a dimension gives a tight bound for distributive lattices but not for projective lattices . however , it was seen that puncturing and projecting a dimension gives a tighter bound , for projective lattices . this leads us to conjecture that it is not possible to achieve the kks bound . the upper bound derived in the paper seems to be tighter when the minimum distance is much smaller than the code dimension . a next step would be to tighten the bounds for large minimum distances . it would be interesting to investigate whether there exists lattice schemes that achieve the lsb with equality . in particular , it would be very interesting to know if there exists a reed solomon - like scheme which specializes to the different counterparts in binary and subspace codes . also , whether quantum codes are lattice schemes can be investigated .

the binary coding theory and subspace codes for random network coding exhibit similar structures . the method used to obtain a singleton bound for subspace codes mimic the technique used in obtaining the singleton bound for binary codes . this motivates the question of whether there is an abstract framework that captures these similarities . as a first step towards answering this question , we use the lattice framework proposed in @xcite . a lattice is a partially ordered set in which any two elements have a least upper bound and a greatest lower bound . a ` lattice scheme ' is defined as a subset of a lattice . in this paper , we derive a singleton bound for lattice schemes and obtain singleton bounds known for binary codes and subspace codes as special cases . the lattice framework gives additional insights into the behaviour of singleton bound for subspace codes . we also obtain a _ new _ upper bound on the code size for non - constant dimension codes . the plots of this bound along with plots of the code sizes of known non - constant dimension codes in the literature reveal that our bound is tight for certain parameters of the code .

1408.1162

hierarchical semi - markov models such as hhmm @xcite and hscrf @xcite are deep generalisations of the hmm @xcite and the linear - chain crf @xcite , respectively . these models are suitable for data that follows nested markovian processes , in that a state in a sub - markov chain is also a markov chain at the child level . thus , in theory , we can model arbitrary depth of semantics for sequential data . the models are essentially members of the probabilistic context - free grammar family with bounded depth . however , the main drawback of these formulations is that the inference complexity , as inherited from the inside - outside algorithm of the context - free grammars , is cubic in sequence length . as a result , this technique is only appropriate for short data sequences , e.g. in nlp we often need to limit the sentence length to , says , @xmath0 . there exists a linearisation technique proposed in @xcite , in that the hhmm is represented as a dynamic bayesian network ( dbn ) . by collapsing all states within each time slice of the dbn , we are able achieve linear complexity in sequence length , but exponential complexity in depth . thus , this technique can not handle deep architectures . in this contribution , we introduce an approximation technique using gibbs samplers that have a potential of achieving sub - cubic time complexity in sequence length and linear time in model depth . the idea is that , although the models are complex , the nested property allows only one state transition at a time across all levels . secondly , if all the state transitions are known , then the model can be collapsed into a markov tree , which is efficient to evaluate . thus the trick is to sample only the markov transition at each time step and integrating over the state variables . this trick is known as rao - blackwellisation , which has previously been applied for dbns @xcite . thus , we call this method rao - blackwellisation gibbs sampling ( rbgs ) . of course , as a mcmc method , the price we have to pay is some degradation in inference quality . recall that in the linear - chain crfs @xcite , we are given a sequence of observations @xmath1 and a corresponding sequence of state variables @xmath2 . the model distribution is then defined as @xmath3 where @xmath4 are potential functions that capture the association between @xmath5 and @xmath6 as well as the _ transition _ between state @xmath7 to state @xmath8 , and @xmath9 is the normalisation constant . thus , given the observation @xmath5 , the model admits the markovian property in that @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is a shorthand for @xmath12 . this is clearly a simplified assumption but it allows fast inference in @xmath13 time , and more importantly , it has been widely proved useful in practice . on the other hand , in some applications where the state transitions are not strictly markovian , i.e. the states tend to be persistent for an extended time . a better way is to assume only the transition between _ parent - states _ @xmath14 , whose elements are not necessarily markovian . this is the idea behind the semi - markov model , which has been introduced in @xcite in the context of crfs . the inference complexity of the semi - markov models is generally @xmath15 since we have to account for all possible segment lengths . the hierarchical semi - markov conditional random field ( hscrf ) is the generalisation of the semi - markov model in the way that the parent - state is also an element of the grandparent - state at the higher level . in effect , we have a _ fractal _ sequential architecture , in that there are multiple levels of detail , and if we examine one level , it looks exactly like a markov chain , but each state in the chain is a sub - markov chain at the lower level . this may capture some real - world phenomena , for example , in nlp we have multiple levels such as character , unigram , word , phrase , clause , sentence , paragraph , section , chapter and book . the price we pay for these expressiveness is the increase in inference complexity to @xmath16 . one of the most important properties that we will exploit in this contribution is the _ nestedness _ , in that a parent can only transits to a new parent if its child chain has terminated . conversely , when a child chain is still active , the parent state must stay the same . for example , in text when a noun - phrase is said to transit to a verb - phrase , the subsequence of words within the noun - phase must terminate , and at the same time , the noun - phrase and the verb - phrase must belong to the same clause . the parent - child relations in the hscrf can be described using a state hierarchical topology . figure [ fig : topo - model ] depicts a three - level topology , where the top , middle and bottom levels have two , four , and three states respectively . each child has multiple parents and each parent may share the same subset of children . note that , this is already a generalisation over the topology proposed in the original hhmm @xcite , where each child has exactly one parent . [ cols="^ " , ] deep neural architectures ( dna ) such as deep belief networks @xcite and deep boltzmann machines @xcite have recently re - emerged as a powerful modelling framework which can potentially discover high - level semantics of the data . the hscrf shares some similarity with the dna in the way that they both use stacking of simpler building blocks . the purpose is to capture _ long - range _ dependencies or _ higher - order _ correlations which are not directly evident in the raw data . the building blocks in the hscrf are the chain - like conditional random fields , while they are the restricted boltzmann machines in the dna . these building blocks are different , and as a result , the hscrf is inherently sequential and localised in state representation , while the dna was initially defined for non - sequential data and distributed representation . in general , the distributed representation is richer as it carries more bits of information given a number of hidden units . the drawback is that probabilistic inference of rbm and its stacking is intractable , and thus approximation techniques such as mcmc and mean - field are often used . inference in the hscrf , on the other hand , is polynomial . for approximation , the mcmc technique proposed for the hscrf in this paper exploits the efficiency in localised state representation so that the rao - blackwellisation can be used . perhaps the biggest difference between the hscrf and dna is the modelling purpose . more specifically , the hscrf is mainly designed for discriminative mapping between the sequential input and the nested states , usually in a fully supervised fashion . the states often have specific meaning ( e.g. noun - phrase , verb - phrase in sentence modelling ) . on the other hand , dna is for discovering hidden features , whose meanings are often unknown in advance . thus , it is generative and unsupervised in nature . finally , despite this initial difference , the hscrf can be readily modified to become a generative and unsupervised version , such as the one described in ( * ? ? ? training in hscrfs can be done simultaneously across all levels , while for the dna it is usually carried out in a layer - wise fashion . the drawback of the layer - wise training is that errors made by the lower layers often propagate to the higher . consequently , an extra global fine tuning step is often employed to correct them . there have been extensions of the deep networks to sequential patterns such as temporal restricted boltzmann machines ( trbm ) @xcite and some other variants . the trbm is built by stacking rbms both in depth and time . another way to build deep sequential model is to feed the top layer of the deep networks into the chain - like crf , as in @xcite . we have introduced a novel technique known as rao - blackwellised gibbs sampling ( rbgs ) for approximate inference in the hierarchical semi - markov conditional random fields . the goal is to avoid both the cubic - time complexity in the standard inside - outside algorithms and the exponential states in the dbn representation of the hscrfs . we provide some simulation - based evaluation of the quality of the rgbs with respect to run time and sequence length . this work , however , is still at an early stage and there are promising directions to follow . first , there are techniques to speed up the mixing rate of the mcmc sampler . second , the rbgs can be equipped with the contrastive divergence @xcite for stochastic gradient learning . and finally , the ideas need to be tested on real , large - scale applications with arbitrary length and depth . h. h. bui , d. q. phung , and s. venkatesh . hierarchical hidden markov models with general state hierarchy . in d. l. mcguinness and g. ferguson , editors , _ proceedings of the 19th national conference on artificial intelligence ( aaai ) _ , pages 324329 , san jose , ca , jul 2004 . j. lafferty , a. mccallum , and f. pereira . conditional random fields : probabilistic models for segmenting and labeling sequence data . in _ proceedings of the international conference on machine learning ( icml ) _ , pages 282289 , 2001 . sunita sarawagi and william w. cohen . semi - markov conditional random fields for information extraction . in bottou l saul lk , weiss y , editor , _ advances in neural information processing systems 17 _ , pages 11851192 . mit press , cambridge , massachusetts , 2004 .

deep architecture such as hierarchical semi - markov models is an important class of models for nested sequential data . current exact inference schemes either cost cubic time in sequence length , or exponential time in model depth . these costs are prohibitive for large - scale problems with arbitrary length and depth . in this contribution , we propose a new approximation technique that may have the potential to achieve sub - cubic time complexity in length and linear time depth , at the cost of some loss of quality . the idea is based on two well - known methods : gibbs sampling and rao - blackwellisation . we provide some simulation - based evaluation of the quality of the rgbs with respect to run time and sequence length .

1412.3015

the minimal dilatonic gravity ( mdg ) model is a proper generalization of the einstein general relativity ( gr ) . its purpose is to solve some of the problems , which appear when one tries to describe the nature using gr as a theory of gravity and the standard model of particle physics , and could be a part of a more general theory . it was introduced for the first time by ohanlon ( ohanlon,1972 ) without relation with cosmology and astrophysics . his point was to give some field - theoretical basis for the fujii s `` fifth force '' . an additional field @xmath0 was introduced there and the term `` dilaton '' was used for the field @xmath0 . the idea of a possible relation of the ohanlon model with astrophysics and cosmology was introduced and developed in the articles ( fiziev , 2000 ) , ( fiziev , 2002 ) , ( fiziev , 2003 ) , ( fiziev , 2013 ) , ( fiziev , 2014a ) , ( fiziev , 2014b),where the cosmological constant @xmath1 was bring into use in mdg . this model is based on the following action for the gravi - dilaton sector @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the einstein constant , @xmath4 is the newton gravitational constant , and @xmath5 is the dilaton field . the values of @xmath0 must be positive since the change of the sign would lead to the change of the sign of the gravitational factor @xmath6 , which leads to antigravity . the value @xmath7 must be excluded , because the gravity is turned off . @xmath8 is also unacceptable since it leads to an infinite gravitational factor , and the cauchy problem is not well posed . the function @xmath9 defines the cosmological potential . it must be a positive single value function of the dilaton field by astrophysical reasons . all the physical requirements for the cosmological potential @xmath9 , necessary for a sound mdg model , can be found in ( fiziev , 2013 ) . a class of withholding potentials is introduced there . these confine dynamically the values of the dilaton @xmath0 in the physical domain . the introduced scalar field @xmath0 leads to a variable gravitational factor @xmath10 instead of the gravitational constant @xmath4 . the cosmological potential @xmath9 is introduced to consider a variable cosmological factor instead of the cosmological constant @xmath1 . in gr , with the cosmological constant @xmath1 we have @xmath11 and @xmath12 . due to its specific physical meaning , the field @xmath0 has unusual properties . the mdg without a cosmological term corresponds to the brans - dicke theory with an identically vanishing parameter @xmath13 . the mdg is only locally equivalent to the f(r ) theories and , in general , yields different physical consequences ( fiziev , 2013 ) . more information about the f(r ) theories can be found in the following publications ( clifton , 2012 ) , ( de felice , 2010 ) , ( faraoni , 2006 ) , ( frolov , 2008 ) , ( nojiri s. , 2007 ) , ( nojiri s. , 2011 ) , ( sotiriou , 2010 ) , ( starobinsky , 1980 ) , ( starobinsky , 2007 ) . some physical and astrophysical consequences of mdg are described in ( fiziev , 2000),(fiziev , 2002 ) , ( fiziev , 2003 ) , ( fiziev , 2014a ) , ( fiziev , 2014b ) . in particular , in ( fiziev , 2000 ) mdg - modifications of the classical gr effects in the solar system : the nordtvedt effect , the time delay of electromagnetic waves ( the shapiro effect ) , and the perihelion shift were considered . in the weak field approximation it was shown that mdg is compatible with all known observational data if the mass @xmath14 of dilaton is large enough . the strongest estimate @xmath15 can be derived from modern data of cavendish type experiments at short distances . in terms of the compton length @xmath16 this gives exponential decrease of the dilaton field at distances longer than @xmath17 . at present , the experimental fixing of the mass @xmath14 , or the compton length @xmath16 is the most important open physical problem in both mdg and f(r ) theories of gravity . for now , the only estimate is the one from cosmology : @xmath18 see ( starobinsky , 2007 ) . it corresponds to the compton length @xmath19 which is far below that available for current and future experiments . this value makes hopeless finding some difference between mdg and gr outside the real bodies of star scales or of smaller dimension . the problem with different masses of dilaton @xmath0 may be solved in the framework of mdg using more complicated cosmological potentials with several minima ( fiziev , 2013 ) . depending on the surrounding environment . we prefer to investigate for the beginning only the simplest mdg model as defined by eq . . ] around each minimum we may have very different masses of the scalar field @xmath0 , or more precisely , of its small deviation @xmath20 . this means that we may have very different coefficients of the quadratic terms in the taylor series expansion of the dilatonic potential ( see below ) in the vicinity of the corresponding minimum . these different masses may be seen at different scales , and may differ essentially from the one derived from cmb cosmological data , which corresponds to the huge scale of the visible universe . hence , we need to study effects of mdg at different scales ( fiziev 2014b ) , ( capozziello , 2014 ) . thus , we arrive at the idea of studying stars , and especially neutron stars , in the framework of mdg . the neutron stars are very interesting objects for our purposes , since in them the strong gravitational fields are known to exist . hence , the effects of mdg on the neutron stars structure may be significant . however , in addition there exists a specific numerical problem . it turns out that the available at present computer programs are able to work only for ( maybe ) unrealistic large values of the compton length @xmath21 . on the other hand , these scales correspond to the scales of a typical neutron star , and it is interesting to study the effects of mdg on them for corresponding small masses @xmath14 , at least as a preliminary study of this issue . the first such investigation was carried out in ( fiziev , 2014a , b ) . there the most idealized equation of state ( eos ) of the neutron matter was used , namely eos of ideal fermi gas at zero temperature . the idea was to compare the mdg and gr results exploring the simplest textbook example with a clear physical ground and well known physical approximations . the present paper , being a proper extension of the ms thesis of kalin marinov ( sofia university , october 2014 ) , considers a more realistic but also idealized example of a polytropic equation of eos following ( damour , 1993 ) . in the literature , one can find several dozens of `` realistic '' eos , based on different physical models of matter in neutron stars . unfortunately , at present we are not able to make a decision what is the right eos for neutron stars , from both the observational and theoretical point of view . the two constructed groups of eos : the soft and the stiff ones , give still hardly distinguishable results from the observational point of view in the framework of each group . in this situation it seems reasonable to study the effects of the change of the very theory of gravity using the simplest known eos with a clear physical ground . the next step : a study of more realistic models for comparison with nature will make sense only after revealing the basic new effects of mdg in stars , and after overcoming the numerical problems with ( maybe ) more realistic masses @xmath14 . thus , the present paper is just the next step towards realistic models of neutron stars in the mdg . the field equations of mdg with a matter field can be written in the form @xmath22 @xmath23 here @xmath24 is the standard energy - momentum tensor of the matter , and @xmath25 is the trace of the same tensor . the dilatonic potential is introduced through the relation @xmath26 , more precisely , it is its first derivative with respect to the variable @xmath0 . by standard notation @xmath27 is the einstein tensor . the static stars are spherically - symmetrical objects with great precision , so we use a space - time interval in the spherical coordinates ( landau , 1975 ) @xmath28 where r is the radial variable . after some more algebra , the equations describing ssss in mdg are obtained . for the inner domain @xmath29 $ ] , where @xmath30 is the radius of the star the structure is determined by the following system : @xmath31 @xmath32 @xmath33 @xmath34 here the four unknown functions are @xmath35 and @xmath36 , respectively , the mass , the pressure , the dilaton , and the dilaton pressure . the following indications are used in the system : @xmath37 in the above equations @xmath38 denote the effective values of the energy density and pressure , and they combine in them the matter energy density and pressure , the cosmological energy density and pressure , the dilatonic energy density and pressure . the numerical values in the parameters @xmath39 and @xmath40 are selected in such a way that the radius @xmath41 is in kilometers and the mass @xmath42 is in solar masses . the boundary conditions in the center of the star are @xmath43 the boundary conditions on the edge of the star are determined by the condition @xmath44 ( and @xmath45 ) . then @xmath46 the radius of a neutron star for physically sound equations of state varies : @xmath47 km . outside of the star , where @xmath48 and @xmath49 we have a dilaton sphere , or a dilasphere . the structure is determined by a shortened system @xmath50 . equation is omitted . in the exterior domain we use as left boundary conditions . the right boundary conditions are defined by the cosmological horizon @xmath51 @xmath52 where the de sitter vacuum is reached : @xmath53 . the polytropic equation of state we used to solve the equations - for neutron ssss in mdg has the following form @xmath54 , @xmath55 . we choose @xmath56 x @xmath57 g and @xmath58 @xmath59 . the value for the parameters @xmath60 and @xmath61 are chosen , so that the solutions are close to the results from the realistic equation of state ( diaz alonso , 1985 ) . the values @xmath62 and @xmath63 are used to fit equation ii from ( diaz alonso , 1985 ) , as done in ( damour , 1993).the chosen equation of state is suitable , because the maximum mass of a neutron star calculated with it in gr is close to the maximum observed mass of a neutron star ( demorest , 2010 ) , ( antoniadis , 2013 ) cc cc cc cc figures 1 and 2 describe the internal structure of the neutron star . the results for the mass and pressure are not essentially different from the results in gr . the behaviour of the new , for the model , variable , the dilaton @xmath0 , must be carefully examined on fig . the dilaton is decreasing near the edge of the star , as expected , but in the core of the star there is an increase of the dilaton . since the quantity 1/phi describes the variations of the gravitational factor , which describes the changes of the intensity of gravity , we see that it decreases around the center of the star by some 15@xmath64 . this very interesting result is consistent with the one of articles ( fiziev , 2014a , b ) . the increase is observed only when the central density is great enough . when the central density is less , the dilaton function decreases from the center of the star to the edge . why it is happening like that can be answered with the help of fig . when the central density is great enough , the central value of the dilaton pressure @xmath65 becomes negative , which leads to increase of the dilaton @xmath0 . when @xmath66 becomes positive , then @xmath67 decreases . smaller central densities lead to a positive value for @xmath65 in the center of the star , and it is a decreasing function from the center to the edge of the star . a very important feature of the model can be seen on fig . the mass of the dilasphere is clearly seen . in our case under consideration , the mass of the pure neutron star in the mdg model is @xmath68 . the dilasphere mass is @xmath69 and the mass of the whole object is @xmath70 , i.e. the dilasphere is @xmath71 of the mass of the pure neutron star , or @xmath72 of the mass of the whole object . this result is also consistent with an analogous one in ( fiziev 2014a , b ) , as well as with the results of a more recent article ( capozziello , 2014 ) . the last paper considers another example of eos - the simples one for quark stars , and takes into account the mass of the dilasphere . as a result , the perturbative approach was proved to be neither inadequate nor incomplete , as wrongly stated in some other papers . figure 4(b ) shows the important relation between the dilaton in the center of the star and the central pressure . we use that relation to calculate neutron stars with physically different central conditions . figure 5 shows the mass - radius relation . as we see , the mass of the pure neutron star in mdg model is less than the mass of the star in gr . but the mass of the full object , neutron star and dilasphere in the mdg is greater than the star in gr . we calculated the mass for different central densities ( fig.6 ) . here we must note that the maximum mass in the mdg model is reached with greater central density . in the present article , we study the effects of minimal dilatonic gravity on the structure of static spherically symmetric neutron stars with the polytropic equation of state , consistent with more realistic ones . in general , the obtained results confirm qualitatively the results for similar stars with a more idealized equation of state for ideal fermi gas at zero temperature studied in ( fiziev , 2014a , b ) . some more diverse details in the stars structures were obtained in the case of the polytropic equation of state . the mdg - neutron - stars considered in the present paper , are consistent with the observed neutron stars with total masses about two solar masses . in contrast to the corresponding gr models , an important new feature of the mdg - ones is the existence of a specific dilaton sphere outside the star . it plays the role of dark matter halo and carries about 15 -20@xmath64 of the total mass of the object . we also observe clear signatures of dark energy inside and outside of the star . the basic conclusion is that the minimal dilatonic gravity model is able to describe realistic models of neutron stars together with the effects of dark matter and dark energy . its specific feature is that despite the fact that such effects are very small outside the star at scales of stars systems like solar one , these effects become essential inside the star . the physical reason is clear . in physical vacuum outside the star where @xmath73 the cosmological term in the action ( 1 ) is extremely small at the scales of stars systems and becomes essential at cosmological scales due to the extremely small value of the cosmological constant @xmath1 . in contrast , inside the matter @xmath74 and we have huge values of the cosmological potential which compensates the small values of the cosmological constant . this specific novel minimal - dilatonic - gravity - mechanism is simpler than the chameleon one and gives an alternative explanation of the behaviour of dilaton field inside the matter . the authors are deeply indebted to professors sergei blinnikov and andrey yudin for careful reading of the manuscript , pointing of an important misprint in the polytropic eos in the initial text , as well as for useful suggestions for improvements of the text and for further work . their idea of checking the existence of dilasphere using more realistic eos for a binary pulsar system seems to be promising and deserves special attention if the dilaton mass has a real value similar to one used in the present preliminary study for purely technical reasons . plamen fiziev is also grateful to professor salvatore capozziello for useful discussion of the basic modern problems of the modified theories of gravity , especially the ones , related with the star physics and with the article ( capozziello , 2014 ) . this research was supported in part by the foundation for theoretical and computational physics and astrophysics and grant of the bulgarian nuclear regulatory agency for 2014 , as well as by `` newcompstar '' , cost action mp1304 . the present research was performed in close collaboration with two authors . fiziev was operative in derivation of the basic equations for static spherically symmetric star configurations , proposed the topic and the choice of the polytropic equation . he supervised the performance of the technical details and their interpretation , as well as the final version of the text . marinov was operative in obtaining all numerical results , graphs and in writing the text of the paper . he also checked all basic formulas and corrected the important numerical factor 1/3 in the formula for @xmath75 . 99 antoniadis & co. , 2013 , _ science _ , 340 ( 6131 ) : 1233232 astashenok a. v. , capozziello s. , odintsov s. d. , 2014 , arxiv:1412.5453v1 clifton t. , ferreira p. , padill a. , skordis c. , 2012 , _ physics reports _ 513 1 damour t. , esposito - farense g. , 1993 , _ phys . rev . _ , 70 15 de felice a. , tsujikawa s. , 2010 , _ living rev . _ 13 3 demorest & co. , 2010 , _ nature _ , 467 ( 7319):1081 - 1083 diaz alonso j. , ibanez cabanell j. , 1985 , _ apj _ , 291:308 - 318 esposito - farese g. , polarski d.,2001 , _ phys . d _ 63 063504 . faraoni v. , 2006 , _ phys . d _ 74 104017 fiziev p. , 2000 lett . a _ 15 , 32 , pp . 1977 - 1990 , arxiv : gr - qc/9911037 fiziev p. , yazadjiev s. , boyadjiev t. , todorov m. , 2000 , _ phys . , 61 , 124018 . fiziev p. , 2002 , arxiv : gr - qc/0202074v4 fiziev p. , georgieva d. , 2003 , _ phys . d _ 67 064016 . fiziev p. , 2013,_phys . d _ 87 , 044053 , arxiv:1209.2695v1 [ gr - qc ] fiziev p. , 2014a , arxiv:1402.2813v1 [ gr - qc ] fiziev p. , 2014b , arxiv:1411.0242v1 frolov a. , 2008 , _ prl _ 101 061103 landau l. , lifshitz e. , 1975 , _ the classical theory of fields _ , new york : pergamon press nojiri s. , odintsov s.d . , 2007 , int . j. geom . phys.4 : 115 - 146 , arxiv : hep - th/0601213 . nojiri s. , odintsov s.d . , 2011 , phys . rept . 505 : 59 - 144 , arxiv:1011.0544 . ohanlon , 1972 , _ phys . lett_. 29 137 sotiriou t. , faraoni v. , 2010 , _ rev . _ 82 451 starobinsky a. , 1980 , _ phys.lett.b _ 91 99 starobinsky a. , 2007 , _ jept lett .

we present solution of the equations for relativistic static spherically symmetric stars ( ssss ) in the model of minimal dilatonic gravity ( mdg ) using the polytropic equation of state . a polytropic equation of state , which has a good fitting with a more realistic one , is used . results are obtained for all variables of a single neutron star in the model of mdg . the maximum mass about two solar masses is in accordance with the latest observations of pulsars . several new effects are observed for the variables related with the dilaton @xmath0 and the cosmological constant @xmath1 . the mass - radius relation is also obtained . special attention is paid to the behavior of the quantities which describe the effects analogous to those of dark energy and dark matter in mdg . the results of the present paper confirm the conclusion that the dilaton @xmath0 is able to play simultaneously the role of dark energy and dark matter .

gr-qc0108020

at the present time the most popular version of multidimensional ( md ) gravity is a kaluza - klein gravity ( for review see ref . @xcite ) in which all space - like directions are equivalent , i.e. extra coordinates are the same as the space coordinates . such approach is very natural but it has a great problem with the sharing of extra dimensions ( ed ) . in other words we should have some natural mechanism for the sharing the ed and space coordinates . it is well known that it is very difficult to realize such mechanism in the empty spacetime . it is necessary to introduce some external matter field for such sharing of ed . of course such way kills the einstein s idea that the matter can be effectively constructed from the pure geometry . there is another possibility for the renewal of the above - mentioned einstein s idea . we would like to return to the initial interpretation of kaluza - klein theory in which that all physical quantities should not depend on the ed . how it can be done ? we offer to take the ed as a gauge group ( for example , u(1 ) , su(2 ) or su(3 ) and so on ) . the advantages of such an approach are obvious : ( a ) we will have the matter as the gauge fields ; ( b ) the ed make up a symmetric space and therefore the physical fields will not depend on the extra coordinates . the first item ( a ) follows from the following theorem @xcite , @xcite : _ let @xmath0 be the group fibre of the principal bundle . then there is a one - to - one correspondence between the @xmath0-invariant metrics @xmath1 ( @xmath2 are the multidimensional indices ) on the total space @xmath3 and the triples @xmath4 . _ @xmath5 ^ 2 + g_{\mu\nu}(x^\alpha ) dx ^\mu dx^\nu \label{intr-1}\ ] ] _ here @xmath6 is einstein s pseudo - riemannian metric on the base ; @xmath7 is the gauge field of the group @xmath0 ( the off - diagonal components of the multidimensional metric ) ; @xmath8 is the symmetric metric on the fibre . _ this theorem tells us that the inclusion the off - diagonal components of the md metric is equivalent to the inclusion gauge fields ( u(1 ) , su(2 ) or su(3 ) ) and a scalar field @xmath9 which is connected with the linear size of the extra dimensions . these geometrical fields can act as the source of the exotic matter necessary for the formation of the wormhole s ( wh ) mouth . such solutions were obtained in ref s . @xcite @xcite @xcite @xcite . these solutions are spherically symmetric wh - like metrics ] with finite longitudinal size . the throat of these wh - like solutions is located between two invariant surfaces on which @xmath10 . these results indicate that the exotic matter necessary for the formation of the wh mouth can appear in * _ vacuum multidimensional gravity _ * from the off - diagonal elements of the metric ( the gauge fields ) and from the metric on the fibre ( the scalar field ) , rather than coming from some externally given exotic matter . the second item ( b ) leads to the fact that all physical fields ( scalar field @xmath11 , gauge fields @xmath12 and 4d metrical tensor @xmath13 ) do not depend on the extra coordinates . moreover the ed have an additional structure : every point is an element of a group ( gauge group u(1 ) , su(2 ) or su(3 ) ) , and _ * such structure can not be destroyed by any perturbations . * _ this means that not any physical particle can penetrate to the ed . otherwise it will destroy the symmetry of the ed and consequently an algebraic structure of the gauge group . in fact the gravity on the principal bundle give us the natural way for the compactification and sharing of the ed . in this case the multidimensional ( md ) spacetime is a total space of the principal bundle with su(2 ) structural group . the fibre of this principal bundle ( the ed ) is su(2 ) gauge group and the base is the 4d spacetime . the langrangian is @xmath14 where @xmath0 is the determinant and @xmath15 is the ricci scalar of the md metric . according to above - mentioned theorem the md metric on the total space is @xmath16 where @xmath17 here @xmath18 are the coordinates on the total space ; @xmath19 is the md index ; @xmath20 ; @xmath21 is the coordinates on the group @xmath22 ( @xmath23 ) ; @xmath24 are the coordinates on the base of the bundle ; @xmath25 ; @xmath26 is the sieben - bein index ; @xmath27 is the @xmath28-bein ; @xmath29 are the 1-forms on the group @xmath22 satisfying @xmath30 ; ( @xmath31 ) are the structural constants for the gauge group @xmath22 ; the signature of the md metric is @xmath32 . we must note that the functions @xmath33 can depend only on the @xmath34 points on the base as the fibres of our bundle are homogeneous spaces . varying with respect to our physical degrees of freedom @xcite leads to the following equations system @xmath35 according to above - mentioned theorem the following dimensional reduction of the ricci scalar @xmath36 on the total space of the principal bundle ( @xcite ) @xmath37 \label{sec2 - 90}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath38 are the ricci scalars of the base and structural group of the principal bundle respectively ; @xmath39 is the volume of the group @xmath22 . the independent degrees of freedom in the gravity on the principal bundle are : scalar field @xmath40 , gauge potential @xmath41 and 4d metric tensor @xmath42 . the most important difference of this theory from the modern variants of the kaluza - klein gravity is that here we should vary on the @xmath11 but not with the every component of the metric on the ed ( @xmath43 and so on ) . this leads to essential decreasing of the number of gravitational equations and to appearing of wh - like vacuum solutions which are necessary for the einstein / wheeler idea `` mass without mass '' and `` charge without charge '' . for the ordinary 7d kaluza - klein theory with the einstein equations @xmath44 we have @xmath45 equations . in our case the number of eq s , are @xmath46 . such essential simplification of the theory structure leads to the fact that in our case vacuum solutions ( wormhole - like ) appear which can not exist in the ordinary kaluza - klein gravity ( where we must destroy the primary einstein idea about a geometrization of physics and insert a multidimensional matter ) . another remarkable peculiarity of such kind of gravitational theories is that the linear sizes of the ed can essentially differ from the planck scale . it follows from the above - mentioned fact that not any physical test particle ( and consequently not any physical body ) can penetrate into the ed as far as it would destroy the algebraic ( consequently symmetric ) structure of the ed . therefore the essential property of the gravity on the principal bundle is that _ the linear size of the ed can be distinguished from the planck scale . _ and finally in these gravitational theory does not appear the compactification problem because the ed are the compact gauge group : u(1 ) , su(2 ) , su(3 ) or another compact lie group . this means that in our approach the compactification problem is not dynamical one and the compactness of the ed is inserted initially in such kind of the md theory . we will search a solution for the following 7d metric ( here we follow to ref . @xcite ) @xmath47 here @xmath48 is some constant , @xmath49 ( @xmath50 ) are the maurer - cartan form with relation @xmath51 @xmath52 where @xmath53 are the euler angles on the fibre . we choose the potential @xmath54 in the ordinary monopole - like form @xmath55 let us introduce the color electric @xmath56 and magnetic @xmath57 fields @xmath58 here the field strength components are defined via @xmath59 , @xmath60 is the determinant of the 3d space matrix , ( @xmath61 ) are the space index . in our case we have @xmath62 the substitution to the 7d gravitational equations leads to the following system of equations @xmath63 the equations and correspond to the ordinary yang - mills " equations after the dimensional reduction . in the consequence of the wh symmetry the functions @xmath64 and @xmath65 are symmetric and the functions @xmath66 and @xmath67 can be either symmetric or antisymmetric . consequently we would like to consider the following different cases 1 . the function @xmath66 is symmetric and the function @xmath67 is antisymmetric ; 2 . the function @xmath66 is antisymmetric and the function @xmath67 is symmetric ; 3 . both functions @xmath66 and @xmath67 is antisymmetric ; 4 . both functions @xmath66 and @xmath67 is symmetric . the first case was considered in the ref . the result is that there are three type of solutions : wormhole - like , infinite and finite flux tubes solutions . now we will write the initial conditions for the 4d metric functions . at the center of symmetry of the wh ( @xmath68 ) we can expand functions @xmath69 and @xmath65 by this manner @xmath70 here we introduce the dimensionless coordinate @xmath71 ( @xmath72 ) and redefine @xmath73 , @xmath74 , @xmath75 . then we can rescale time and the constant @xmath76 so that @xmath77 . thus we have the following initial conditions for the functions @xmath69 and @xmath65 for the numerical calculations @xmath78 in this case we have the following expansion of functions @xmath79 and @xmath80 at the origin @xmath81 this equation is written in dimensionless variables . the constrained equation for the initial data give us @xmath82 as @xmath83 we have the following constraint for @xmath84 : @xmath85 . the numerical calculations are presented on the fig s , , , , . in this case the numerical calculations show us that the @xmath86 function is monotonically decreasing one and consequently its behaviour is defined with the value of @xmath87 . give us the following expression @xmath88 on the fig . this curve is shown . as a result we see that @xmath89 for all @xmath84 and consequently it confirms our numerical investigation that @xmath86 is monotonically decreasing function . in this case we have the following expansion of functions @xmath79 and @xmath80 at the origin @xmath90 this equation is written in dimensionless variables . the constrained equation ( [ sec3 - 130 ] ) for the initial data give us @xmath91 the positivity condition of @xmath92 give us @xmath93 in the chosen range of the parameters @xmath94 the numerical calculations lead to the fact that on the @xmath95 plane there are two regions with the different solutions type . on fig . these regions with the different type of solutions are shown . the numerical calculations are presented on the fig s , , , , . we see that there is two type of solutions . the first type with decreasing @xmath96 we can name as a wh - like solutions . for this type of solutions we have the following condition @xmath97 . with an accuracy of the numerical calculations we can say that there is a point @xmath98 for which @xmath99 . probably in these points @xmath10 that is similar to the 5d case investigated in ref.@xcite . we intend to investigate in more details the behavior of the metric close to such points with the help of approximate analytical methods in the future . the second type satisfies the condition @xmath100 and with an accuracy of the numerical calculations there is a point @xmath98 for which @xmath101 . with great probability we have singularities in these two points , _ i.e. _ such solutions are like to flux tube of color `` electric '' and `` magnetic '' fields between two singularities . it is interesting to note that this type of solutions is very similar to the confinement mechanism in qcd where two quarks are located at the ends of a flux tube with color electric and magnetic fields running quark and antiquark . in this case we have the following expansion of functions @xmath79 and @xmath80 at the origin @xmath102 this equation is written in dimensionless variables . the constrained equation for the initial data give us @xmath103}}{\left(f_0 ^ 2 - 1\right)^2 - 8 f_0 ^ 2 v_0 ^ 2 } \label{sec7 - 30}\ ] ] the positivity condition of @xmath92 gives us @xmath104 in this case the numerical calculations show us that the @xmath86 function is monotonically decreasing one and consequently its behavior is defined with the value of @xmath87 . eq s give us the following expression @xmath105 as a result we see that @xmath89 for all @xmath106 and consequently it confirms our numerical investigation that @xmath86 is monotonically decreasing function . the qualitative behavior of all functions @xmath107 and @xmath80 are similar with the second case ( where @xmath79 is antisymmetric and @xmath80 is symmetric one ) . on the basis of ref.@xcite and the investigations presented here we can say that the spherically symmetric solutions of the gravity on the principal bundle with su(2 ) gauge group as the structural group ( extra dimensions ) and which are symmetric regarding to some hypersurface @xmath108 ( in our case @xmath68 ) are presented by three types : 1 . wormhole - like solutions . these solutions are characterized that @xmath109 and there are two hypersurfaces by @xmath110 where @xmath10 . 2 . infinite flux tube . this solution was presented in ref.@xcite . it has @xmath111 ( @xmath112 ) and color electric and magnetic fields are parallel . finite flux tubes . these solutions have two singularities at @xmath110 and function @xmath113 has a maximum at @xmath114 . the difference between these possibilities are determinated by the symmetry of @xmath66 and @xmath67 functions and their boundary conditions @xmath115 and @xmath116 . it means that the type of solutions is completely defined by color electric and magnetic fields at the symmetry center of the metric . now we would like to compare our designations for the solutions ( wormhole and flux tube ) with other similar definitions . according to ref.@xcite the wormhole is time independent ( in the simplest case ) , nonrotating , and spherically symmetric bridge between two universes . the 4d spacetime metric can be put into the form @xmath117 that can be compared with 4d part of eq .. the wh should have the following properties : * the coordinate @xmath112 . * the event horizon is absent . * there is a throat where @xmath109 . * there are two asymptotically flat regions at @xmath118 . comparing these definitions with our calculations we can see why we called our first type of solutions as _ wormhole - like _ solutions : * the coordinate @xmath119 . it is possible that similar to the 5d wormhole - like solutions we can continue these solutions up to @xmath112 . in this case the metric signature will be changed : from @xmath120 by @xmath119 to @xmath121 by @xmath122 and @xmath123 . such situation for 5d case was discussed in ref.@xcite . following to bronnikov @xcite we can name two hypersurfaces @xmath110 where @xmath10 and such exchange of the metric signature takes place as @xmath124horizons . * there are two @xmath124horizons . * there is a minimum of @xmath113 . * the existence of asymptotically flat regions is not yet unknown but the comparison with the 5d case give us a hope that such regions exist . thus the distinction and similarities between these standard and our metrics is evident . the most important peculiarity of presented here wormhole - like solutions is that they are vacuum solutions without any matter . the color electric and magnetic su(2 ) gauge fields are the off - diagonal components of 7d metric . euclidean wormholes have the topology @xmath125 , where @xmath15 is an imaginary time and @xmath126 is @xmath127 dimensional sphere . they are commonly thought of as `` instantons '' in the gravitational field . the distinction with our case is evident . the notion of flux tube has arisen in the quantum chromodynamics where this one is a hypothesized tube filled with gauge field and stretched between quark - antiquark . such field configuration arises in the consequence of a specific non - linear potential in the su(3 ) yang - mills theory . in the gravity can be some types of spacetime with a finite flux of electric / magnetic fields . * melvin type of solutions ( see , for example , melvin universe @xcite ) . the @xmath128 spacelike section has the cylindrical symmetry and filled with cylindrically symmetric magnetic field which has a finite flux of this field . * the modern multidimensional kaluza - klein theories have solutions which can contain branes with some generalization of electric field and finite flux of this fileds , _ i.e. _ flux branes . * levi - civita - betotti - robinson solutions @xcite . these solutions can be multidimensional @xcite . 4d part of these metrics has the following topologies : @xmath129 . the range of the radial coordinate can be finite @xmath130 $ ] and infinite @xmath131 . roughly speaking these solutions have a finite cross section @xmath132 . they are filled with electric / magnetic field with finite flux of these fields . we have shown that such solutions exist in our case and the difference between wormhole - like and flux tube solutions is defined by the relation between electric and magnetic fields at the center of symmetry of this metric . in this paper we have shown ( with an accuracy of the numerical calculations ) that the spherically symmetric metric of the md gravity on the principal bundle with su(2 ) gauge group as the ed are either wh - like or flux tube metrics . the numerical calculations indicate that the type of solutions is determined by a relation between the color `` electric '' ( @xmath133 ) , `` magnetic '' ( @xmath134 ) fields , the scalar curvatures of the ed ( @xmath135 ) and the sphere @xmath136 ( @xmath137 ) at @xmath114 . let us write the constraint equation @xmath138 immediately we see that the necessary condition for the existence of the wh - like solutions is that it must be a flux of color `` electric '' @xmath139 and `` magnetic '' fields @xmath140 through the wh mouth . only in this case eg . is fulfilled . the numerical calculations confirm such conclusion : only for the first and the third cases with @xmath141 we will have the wh - like solutions . the wh - like solutions can have very interesting physical consequences . let us imagine that the universe is separated into the regions with dynamical and nondynamical metric on the ed @xcite . it means that in the region with nondynamical @xmath142 ( @xmath143 ) metric components we have 4d gravity interacting with the su(2 ) gauge field and we have not an equation for the scalar field @xmath11 ( @xmath144 ) ( this is the kaluza - klein gravity in its initial interpretation ) . in the region with dynamical @xmath142 we have the full md gravity . such situation can be realized on the level of the spacetime foam , _ i.e. _ the quantum handles of spacetime foam are the regions with the dynamical @xmath142 and the region between these quantum handles is the region with nondynamical @xmath142 . in this situation each single quantum handle ( wormhole ) is the above - mentioned wh - like solution attached to an exterior spacetime on the surfaces where @xmath145 is fulfilled .

the multidimensional gravity on the principal bundle with the su(2 ) gauge group is considered . the numerical investigation of the spherically symmetric metrics with the center of symmetry is made . the solution of the gravitational equations depends on the boundary conditions of the `` su(2 ) gauge potential '' ( off - diagonal metric components ) at the symmetry center and on the type of symmetry ( symmetrical or antisymmetrical ) of these potentials . in the chosen range of the boundary conditions it is shown that there are two types of solutions : wormhole - like and flux tube . the physical application of such kind of solutions as quantum handles in a spacetime foam is discussed .

0903.2623

although , the cosmic dust grains are in general not homogeneous spheres , usually the observed absorption , scattering and extinction data are interpreted using calculations based on mie theory , which is strictly valid for homogeneous spherical particles . dust grains ejected from stars are more likely to be non - spherical and inhomogeneous , viz . porous , fluffy and composites of many small grains glued together , due to grain - grain collisions , dust - gas interactions and various other processes . since there is no exact theory to study the scattering properties of these inhomogeneous grains , there is a need for formulating models of electromagnetic scattering by these grains . mathis & whiffen ( 1989 ) , mathis ( 1996 ) , dwek ( 1997 ) and li & greenberg ( 1998 ) have proposed composite grain models consisting of silicate and amorphous carbon as constituent materials . they have used effective medium approximation ( emt ) to calculate the optical constants for composite grains and then used the mie theory to calculate extinction cross sections for spheres . in emt the inhomogeneous particle is replaced by a homogeneous one with some average effective dielectric function. the effects related to the fluctuations of the dielectric function within the inhomogeneous structures can not be treated by this approach of the emt . iati etal ( 2004 ) have studied optical properties of composite grains as grain aggregates of amorphous carbon and astronomical silicates , using the transition matrix approach . recently voshchinnikov etal ( 2006 ) and voshchinnikov & henning ( 2008 ) have studied the effect of grain porosity on interstellar extinction , dust temperature , infrared bands and millimeter opacity . they have used both , the emt - mie based calculations and layered sphere model . earlier , we have used discrete dipole approximation ( dda ) to study the extinction properties of the composite grains ( vaidya etal 2007 ) . for the description on the dda see draine ( 1988 ) . the dda allows the consideration of irregular shape effects , surface roughness and internal structure within the grain ( wolff et al . 1994 , 1998 and voshchinnikov et al . 2005 ) . for discussion and comparison of dda and emt methods , including the limits of the effective medium theory , see bazell and dwek ( 1990 ) , perrin and lamy ( 1990 ) , perrin and sivan ( 1990 ) , ossenkopf ( 1991 ) and wolff et al ( 1994 ) . the paper has the following sections : in section 2 we give the validity criteria for the dda and the composite grain models . in section 3 we present and discuss the results of our computations and compare the model curves with the observed ir fluxes obtained by iras satellite . the main conclusions of our study are given in section 4 . we use the computer code developed by dobbie ( 1999 ) to generate the composite grain models used in the present study . we have studied composite grain models with a host silicate spheroid containing n= 9640 , 25896 and 14440 dipoles , each carved out from @xmath4 , @xmath5 and @xmath6 dipole sites , respectively ; sites outside the spheroid are set to be vacuum ( void ) and sites inside are assigned to be the host material . it is to be noted that the composite spheroidal grain with n=9640 has an axial ratio of 1.33 , whereas n=25896 has the axial ratio 1.5 and n=14440 has the axial ratio 2.0 . the volume fractions of the graphite inclusions used are 10% , 20% and 30% ( denoted as f=0.1 , 0.2 and 0.3 ) details on the computer code and the corresponding modification to the ddscat code ( draine & flatau 2003 ) are given in dobbie ( 1999 ) , vaidya et al . ( 2001 , 2007 ) and gupta et al . the modified code outputs a three - dimensional matrix specifying the material type at each dipole site ; the sites are either silicate , graphite or vacuum ( void ) . for an illustrative example of a composite spheroidal grain with n=9640 dipoles , please see figure 1 ( also vaidya et al , 2007 ) . there are two validity criteria for dda ( see e.g. wolff et al . 1994 ) ; viz . ( i ) @xmath7 , where m is the complex refractive index of the material , k=@xmath8 is the wavenumber and d is the lattice dispersion spacing and ( ii ) d should be small enough ( n should be sufficiently large ) to describe the shape of the particle satisfactorily . the complex refractive indices for silicates and graphite are obtained from draine ( 1985 , 1987 ) and that for ice is from ( irvine & pollack 1968 ) . for any grain model , the number of dipoles required to obtain a reliable computational result can be estimated using the ddscat code ( see vaidya and gupta 1997 and 1999 , vaidya etal 2001 ) . for the composite grain model , if the host grain has n dipoles , its volume is n(d)@xmath9 and if a is the radius of the host grain , n(d)@xmath9 = 4/3@xmath10 , hence , n = 4@xmath11 , and if @xmath12=1 and k=2@xmath13 the number of dipoles n can be estimated at a given wavelength and the radius of the host grain . it must be noted here that the composite spheroidal grain models with n=9640 , 25896 and 14440 have the axial ratio 1.33 , 1.5 and 2.0 respectively and if the semi - major axis and semi - minor axis are denoted by x/2 and y/2 respectively , then @xmath14 , where a is the radius of the sphere whose volume is the same as that of a spheroid . in order to study randomly oriented spheroidal grains , it is necessary to get the scattering properties of the composite grains averaged over all of the possible orientations ; in the present study we use three values for each of the orientation parameters ( @xmath15),i.e . averaging over 27 orientations , which we find quite adequate ( see e.g. wolff etal 1998 ) . earlier , we had studied the extinction properties of composite spheroidal grains in the spectral region 3.4 - 0.10@xmath16 m ( vaidya etal 2007 ) . in the present paper , we study the absorption properties of the composite spheroidal grains with three axial ratios , viz . 1.33 , 1.5 and 2.0 , corresponding to the grain models with n=9640 , 25896 and 14440 respectively , in the wavelength region 7.0 - 14.0@xmath16 m . the inclusions selected are graphites / ices / or voids . figure 2 ( a - c ) shows the absorption efficiencies ( @xmath17 ) for the composite grains with the host silicate spheroids containing 9640 , 25896 and 14440 dipoles , corresponding to axial ratio 1.33 , 1.5 and 2.0 respectively with a power law size distribution of a range of grain sizes from 0.005 - 0250@xmath16 m in steps of 0.005@xmath16 m . the three volume fractions , viz . 10% , 20% and 30% , of ice inclusions are also listed in the top ( a ) panel . the effect of the variation of volume fraction of inclusions is clearly seen for all the models . it is to be noted that the wavelength of the peak absorption shifts with the variation in the volume fraction of inclusions . these absorption curves also show the variation in the width of the absorption feature with the volume fraction of inclusions . all these results indicate that the inhomogeneities within the grains play an important role in modifying the 10@xmath16 m feature . it is also seen in fig . 2 that the shape of the q@xmath18 curve also varies with the axial ratio , ar of the composite grain , and the absorption peak shifts towards shorter wavelength as the ar incereases . odonnell ( 1994 ) has investigated the variation of the 10@xmath16 m feature with the grain composition using spheroidal composite grains containing inclusions of either amorphous carbon , tholins or vacuum . he found that the inclusion of tholins or carbon increases the absorption on the short wavelength side of the 10@xmath16 m feature . further , the inclusion of tholin also broadens the 10@xmath16 m feature . figure 3 shows the absorption efficiency for the composite grains ( n=9640 , ar=1.33 , a=0.10@xmath16 m ) with host silicate and graphite inclusions ( thick lines ) . it is seen that the q@xmath18 decreases as the the volume fraction of inclusions f increases and the absorption peak shifts towards shorter wavelength and broadens with the volume fraction of inclusions . we have compared our results on the absorption efficiencies of the composite grains obtained using the dda with the results obtained using the emt - t matrix based calculations . these results are also displayed in figure 3 ( in thin lines ) . for these calculations , the optical constants were obtained using the maxwell - garnet mixing rule ( bohren and huffman 1983 ) . description of the t - matrix method / and code is given by mishchenko ( 2002 ) . since maxwell - garnett rule provides the extreme cases of the possible values of the effective dielectric constants of the two - component mixture ( see chylek et al , 2000 ) , we have used this rule . on the other hand , bruggeman mixing rule applies to a two - component mixture with no distinguishable inclusions embedded in a definite matrix ; i.e. it applies to a completely randomly inhomogeneous medium ( bohren & hoffman , 1983 ) . in the figure 3 we have also shown the absorption efficiency for the composite grain with f=0.2 using bruggeman rule . it is seen that the absorption curves obtained using emts ( maxwell - garnett and bruggeman mixing rules ) deviate considerably from the curves obtained using dda . the dda allows consideration of irregular shape effects , surface roughness and internal structure within the grain ( wolff et al 1994 , 1998 ) . in emt the inhomogeneous grain is replaced by a homogeneous one with some average effective dielectric function , the effects related to the fluctuations of the dielectric function within the inhomogeneous structures can not be treated by the emts and material interfaces and shapes are smeared out into a homogeneous average mixture saija etal 2001 ) . perrin and lamy ( 1990 ) have calculated extinction cross sections for the composite grains , using both the emts , as well as the dda . they found that for small porous grains the results given by maxwell - garnett are much better than the results given by the bruggeman theory . the criteria of validity of the respective effective theories are not clear ( perrin and lamy , 1990 ) . we have used more accurate dda method to calculate the absorption cross sections for the composite grains . however , it would still be very useful and desirable to compare the dda results for the composite grains with those computed by other emt / mie type / t matrix techniques in order to examine the applicability of several mixing rules . ( see wolff etal 1998 , voshchinnikov and mathis 1999 , chylek et al . 2000 , voshchinnikov etal 2005 , 2006 ) . the application of dda , poses a computational challenge , particularly for the large values of the size parameter @xmath19 and the complex refractive index m of of the grain material would require large number of dipoles and that in turn would require considerable computer memory and cpu time ( see e.g. saija etal 2001 , voshchinnikov etal 2006 ) . we have also calculated the absorption efficiencies of the porous silicate grains . figure 4 shows the absorption efficiencies of the composite grains ( n=9640 ) with the host silicate spheroids and voids as inclusions in three volume fractions viz . 0.05 , 0.10 and 0.20 for the three grain sizes viz . a=0.1 , 0,2 and 0.5@xmath16 m . these results show that the peak strength decreases with the porosity . it is also seen that the peak of the 10@xmath16 m shifts and broadens as the porosity increases . voshchinnikov et al ( 2006 ) and voshchinnikov & henning ( 2008 ) have used layered spheres model combining all components including vacuum , to study the effect of porosity on the 10@xmath16 m feature . voshchinnikov & henning ( 2008 ) found the peak strength decreases and the feature also broadens with increasing porosity . these results are consistent with the results we have obtained with our composite grain model . recently , li et al ( 2008 ) have also used the porous grains to model the 9.7@xmath16 m feature in the agn . they have used multilayered sphere model of voshchinnikov & mathis ( 1999 ) and calculated the absorption efficiency of porous composite dust consisting amorphous silicate , amorphous carbon and vacuum . li et al ( 2008 ) have found the progressive broadening of the 10@xmath16 m feature and shift to longer wavelengths of the peak position of the feature as the porosity increases . in general , stars which have evolved off the main sequence and which have entered the giant phase of their evolution are a major source of dust grains in the galactic interstellar medium . such stars have oxygen overabundant relative to carbon and therefore produce silicate dust and show the strong feature at 9.7@xmath16 m . this is ascribed to the si - o stretching mode in some form of silicate material , e.g. olivine . these materials also have a feature at 18@xmath16 m , resulting from the o - si - o bending mode ( evans , 1993 ) . using the absorption efficiencies of the composite grains , we calculate the infrared flux , f@xmath20 at various temperatures of the dust , and for a power law mrn dust grain size distribution ( mathis etal 1977 ) . we compare the model curves with the average observed lrs - iras curve , obtained for several circumstellar dust shells around stars . figure 5(a ) shows the infrared flux at the dust temperature t=250@xmath3k for the composite grains containing number of dipoles n=9640 , for three volume fractions of void inclusions ( porous ) . figure 5(b ) shows infrared flux at t=450@xmath3k for the composite grains with voids as inclusions . figure 6 shows the variation of infrared flux between t=200 and 500@xmath3k , for the porous grains . in this figure we have also shown the average observed iras - lrs curve ( whittet 2003 ) . these results show that the composite grains with number of dipoles , n=9640 and porosity f=0.2 , and dust temperature around 300@xmath3k fit the observed infrared flux ( whittet , 2003 ) reasonably well . it is to be noted here that voshchinnikov & henning ( 2008 ) have compared the results of the porous composite grains with the spectra of t tauri and herbig ae / be stars , li et al ( 2008 ) have compared the porous grain models with the agns , whereas in this paper we have compared the composite grain models with the average observed iras flux ( whittet , 2003 ) . using the discrete dipole approximation ( dda ) we have studied the variation of the absorption efficiency for the composite spheroidal grains , with the volume fractions of the inclusions in the wavelength region of 7.0 - 14.0@xmath16 m . these results clearly show the variation in the absorption efficiency for the composite grains with the volume fractions of the inclusions . the results on the composite grains also show the shift in the peak absorption wavelength 9.7@xmath16 m with the volume fraction of the inclusions and porosity . the results obtained using dda based calculations deviate considerably from the results obtained using emt - tmatrix calculations . the results on the composite grains clearly show that the inhomogeneity in the grains modifies the absorption / emission properties of the grains . further study on the emission properties of composite grains at longer wavelengths in the ir is in progress ( vaidya etal 2008 ) . dbv and rg thank isro - respond for the grant ( no . isro / res/2/345/ 2007 - 08 ) , under which this study has been carried out . the authors also thank the organizers of els - xi conference for their generous support towards attending the conference . chylek , p. , videen , g. , geldart , d.j.w . , dobbie , j. , william , h.c . , 2000 : in light scattering by non - spherical particles , mishchenko , m. , hovenier , j.w . and travis , l.d . ( eds ) , academic press , new york , p. 274 m ( thick lines ) . also shown are the emt - t matrix calculations with the same axial ration ar=1.33 and three volume fractions ( thin lines ) . the dots represent bruggeman rule calculations for f=0.2.,width=529 ]

we calculate the absorption efficiency of the composite grains , made up of host silicate spheroids and inclusions of ices / graphites / or voids , in the spectral region @xmath0 m the absorption efficiencies of the composite spheroidal grains for three axial ratios are computed using the discrete dipole approximation ( dda ) as well as using the effective medium approximation & t - matrix ( emt - tmatrix ) approach . we study the absorption as a function of the volume fraction of the inclusions and porosity . in particular , we study the variation in the @xmath1 m feature with the volume fraction of the inclusions and porosity . we then calculate the infrared fluxes for these composite grains and compare the model curves with the average observed iras - lrs curve , obtained for several circumstellar dust shells around stars . these results on the composite grains show that the wavelength of the peak absorption shifts and the width of the @xmath1 m feature varies with the variation in the volume fraction of the inclusions . the model curves for composite grains with axial ratios not very large ( ar@xmath21.3 ) and volume fractions of inclusions with f=0.20 , and dust temperature of about 250 - 300@xmath3k , fit the observed emission curves reasonably well . [ firstpage ]

cond-mat0111237

if sufficient power is supplied to a granular system contained in a cylindrical container by a vertically vibrating wall , fluidization occurs . once a steady state is obtained , the energy input to the system by the wall is , on average , balanced by the energy dissipated in inelastic grain - grain and grain - wall collisions . this energy flux is responsible for various effects including non - linear temperature profiles , heap formation@xcite and convection @xcite . recent experiments using positron emission particle tracking ( pept)@xcite have observed buoyancy - driven convection in a highly fluidized granular system for a range of grain numbers and shaker amplitudes . while convection effects have been observed in a two - dimensional model system @xcite , no simulation studies of a three dimensional system corresponding to the pept experiments have yet been reported . we study the behavior of a model system in which the grains are modeled as inelastic hard spheres . most of the previous studies of this model focused on the homogeneous cooling state , clustering , and kinetic and hydrodynamic theory for particles with small inelasticity@xcite . unlike many other many - body systems , the model studied here closely matches the experimental system . in particular , the number of particles is identical and we use values of particle - particle and particle - wall restitution coefficients that were determined by independent experimental measurements . we show that the model reproduces accurately the experimentally observed density and granular temperature profiles@xcite . moreover , for a range of conditions , a velocity field exists for which there is a net circulation . interestingly , the direction and intensity of the circulation are strong functions of the particle - wall restitution coefficient . in addition , we suggest a modification to the experiment that may generate new convection patterns . the system consists of a number @xmath0 of hard spheres contained in a cylinder of radius @xmath1 . the spheres collide inelastically with each other and with the side walls with coefficients of restitution @xmath2 and @xmath3 , respectively . between collisions , the spheres are subject to a downward constant acceleration due to the ( vertical ) gravitational field . energy is injected into the system by the bottom wall which vibrates with a symmetric saw - tooth profile characterized by an amplitude @xmath4 and a period @xmath5 . we do not expect the behavior of the system to be strongly dependent on the form of the profile@xcite . the equations describing the dynamics , which follow from conservation of momentum , for the particle side - wall , particle bottom - wall and particle particle collisions are : @xmath6 @xmath7 @xmath8\hat{{\bf n}}\ ] ] respectively where @xmath9 is the velocity of particle @xmath10 in the @xmath11 plane , @xmath12 is the velocity of the bottom wall , @xmath13 is the @xmath14 vertical component of the velocity of particle @xmath10 , @xmath15 is the unit position vector of particle @xmath10 and @xmath16 is the unit center - to - center vector between the colliding pair @xmath10 and @xmath17 . note that we have taken the tangential restitution coefficient for sphere - sphere , and sphere - wall , collisions equal to one . the normal restitution coefficient for sphere - bottom wall collisions was also taken as unity . one problem with the event - driven simulation is that a sphere may collide more and more frequently with the side wall as the radial component of its momentum is dissipated . to avoid the inelastic collapse@xcite , which has been observed in simulations of bulk granular systems , we simply inject a small amount of energy in the radial direction when the radial velocity falls below a cut - off value . this condition arises infrequently and its handling in this way has no discernible effect on the results . to reproduce the experimental conditions of wildman et al @xcite we used parameter values @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 . taking the unit of length as the sphere diameter , @xmath21 , the cylinder radius is @xmath22 . since the base - wall particle coefficient is not given , we assume a value of one . the shaker amplitude is thus left as the only adjustable parameter for the comparison of the simulation with the experiments . we performed different runs with a dimensionless shaking amplitude varying between @xmath23 and @xmath24 . to generate the initial configuration , spheres were inserted sequentially and randomly in the cylinder without overlap . a preliminary simulation was then performed , typically for @xmath25 collisions per particle , in order to allow the system to reach the stationary non - equilibrium state . figure [ fig:1 ] displays the mean velocity field for the system of inelastic spheres in the @xmath26 plane ( @xmath27 denotes the radial distance from the axis of the cylinder ) when the reduced shaker amplitude is @xmath28 . the field is averaged over the azimuthal angle and approximately @xmath29 collisions ) . a torroidal convection roll is clearly present in which the particles flow , on average , up from the center and down the side wall . note that , unlike the related rayleigh - bnard phenomenon , the roll is asymmetric . the velocity field is in near quantitative agreement with that observed experimentally by wildman et al . @xcite . in particular , the center of the vortex roll is at @xmath30 in reduced units which corresponds to @xmath31 in experiments@xcite . the shape of the roll , as well the location of its center , do not change appreciably as the shaker amplitude is varied between @xmath32 . to highlight the role played by the wall , we performed additional simulations in which the wall - sphere collision is taken as elastic ( a perfect wall for which the wall - particle restitution coefficient is equal to 1 ) with the other parameters unchanged . the mean velocity field of this simulation is quite different from the inelastic case . although some convection is apparent in figure [ fig:2 ] , ( particles on average flow up the wall and down to the center ) . it is weaker by about an order of magnitude in intensity ( compare the velocity units at the top of figs . [ fig:1 ] and . [ fig:2 ] ) and the roll direction is _ opposite_. to quantify the bulk convection , we have calculated the total velocity correlation , @xmath33@xcite where @xmath34 label the cells in the hydrodynamic region , @xmath35 their total number and @xmath36 where the sum @xmath37 is over the @xmath38 neighboring cells of @xmath34 . see figure [ fig:6 ] . bulk convection is present when @xmath39 is different from zero . for @xmath20 , as the shaker amplitude is increased the total velocity correlation @xmath40 becomes different from zero when @xmath41 , increases until @xmath42 and stays roughly constant for larger amplitudes . a similar behavior was observed in the experiments of wildman et al . for @xmath43 , @xmath40 is almost equal to zero for all amplitudes ( figure [ fig:6 ] ) . a close examination of the corresponding flow velocity fields show that the amplitude of the circulation of particles up the wall and down to the center exists for @xmath41 , a feature which is not well handled by the calculation of the order parameter . figure [ fig:3 ] shows the granular temperature as a function of the altitude , @xmath14 , for different values the radial position . these results agree well with the experiments ( fig.1 of ref@xcite ) except for an underestimated maximum close to the basewall . these differences could result from the base - particle collisions which are assumed elastic in simulations . a minimum in the granular temperature profile is observed in the current simulations ( and also in experiments ) in the neighborhood of the center of the cylinder , but becomes weaker close to the wall cylinder . fig [ fig:4 ] displays the same profiles for the system with @xmath43 : the temperature minimum in the vertical direction is more pronounced , but the temperature varies little in the radial direction . the existence of a minimum in the granular temperature along the @xmath14-direction is a phenomenon which is also present in the absence of convection@xcite and results from the fact that at high altitudes the density and collision frequency are small , leading to a small number of hot particles . figure [ fig:5 ] displays a packing fraction plot which agrees qualitatively with the experimental results , except in the bottom region of the side wall where the density is higher than in experiments . nevertheless , there is a maximum in the density profile in the vertical direction , whatever the radial distance . moreover , there is also a maximum along the radial direction which is a consequence both of the compressible nature of the inelastic hard sphere system and of the small wall - particle restitution coefficient . when @xmath43 , the radial density gradient almost vanishes . although a complete theoretical treatment of the convection is beyond the scope of this letter , we present some simple arguments that may help to rationalize the observed behavior . the rayleigh - bnard convection which is the paradigm for pattern formation in classical fluid mechanics , has been extensively studied over the past three decades@xcite . a temperature gradient applied to a fluid leads to a competition between buoyancy and disspation , which leads to the occurence of rolls above a threshold characterized by the non dimensional rayleigh number @xmath44 , which characterizes the ratio of the two forces . for larger temperature gradients , on observes a cascade of bifurcations ending in a chaotic regime . for classical fluids , hydrodynamic equations reproduce the observed patterns remarkably well . the range of validity of continuum equations applied to granular materials , which contain a sink term in the energy equation to account for the dissipation of energy during collisions , is more restricted . hydrodynamic equations can provide a good description of inelastic spheres @xcite , provided that the particles packing fraction remains @xmath45 ( below which the mean free path becomes comparable to the diameter of the cylinder ) . similarly , if the packing fraction is too large ( @xmath46 ) the dissipation becomes too strong and the description breaks down . using such an approach , brey et al.@xcite obtained temperature profiles for an open granular system , _ without convection _ and predicted the presence of a minimum as a function of @xmath14 , coinciding with the limit of validity of the hydrodynamic equations . when @xmath20 , the hydrodynamic description breaks down close to the wall ( high density and temperature gradient , strong dissipation ) . the onset of the bulk convective regime with a `` real '' wall is lowered because of the existence of the radial temperature gradient in addition to the vertical one . this can explain both the direction of circulation and the lowering of the threshold of convection compared to the case when the wall is perfect and no bulk convection is present . the circulation of particles is restricted close to the sidewall where strong dissipation is not well described by hydrodynamic equations . a kinetic approach is required close to the cylinder . our simulations clearly demonstrate the relevance of the inelastic hard sphere model for describing the experimental study of wildman et al@xcite and underline the key influence of the cylinder wall on the convection . experimentally , unlike in the simulations , the wall - particle restitution coefficient is not an easily tunable parameter . we therefore propose a modification to the experiment that may lead to the observation of new phenomena . specifically , we suggest adding an inner ( solid ) cylinder of a given radius , coaxial with the original cylinder . in the neighborhood of this inner cylinder , we expect particles to have a downward motion , and two , or more , toroidal rolls with alternate directions of circulation , as in a fluid system , might be produced . we thank r. wildman for supplying his experimental data , e. clment p. manneville , and r. ramirez for fruitful discussions . acknowledges support from the national science foundation ( che-9814236 ) and the centre national de la rcherche scientifique .

an event - driven molecular dynamics simulation of inelastic hard spheres contained in a cylinder and subject to strong vibration reproduces accurately experimental results@xcite for a system of vibrofluidized glass beads . in particular , we are able to obtain the velocity field and the density and temperature profiles observed experimentally . in addition , we show that the appearance of convection rolls is strongly influenced by the value of the sidewall - particle restitution coefficient . suggestions for observing more complex convection patterns are proposed .

1109.4368

interaction of electromagnetic radiation with atoms has led to interesting quantum features such as antibunching and squeezing . in particular , interaction of two - level atoms with squeezed light has extensively been studied by many authors @xcite . these studies show that the squeezed light modifies the width of the spectrum of the incoherent light emitted by the atom . on the other hand , cavity qed in semiconductor systems has been the subject of interest in connection with its potential application in optoelectronic devices @xcite . for example , such optical systems hold potential in realization of optical devices that exhibits exceptional properties such as monomode luminescence with high gain allowing the realization of thresholdless laser . the quantum properties of the light emitted by a quantum well embedded in a microcavity has been studied by several authors @xcite . unlike antibunching observed in atomic cavity qed , the fluorescent light emitted by the quantum well exhibits bunching @xcite . in the strong coupling regime when the coupling frequency between the exciton and photon is larger than the relaxation frequencies of the medium and the cavity the intensity spectrum of the exciton - cavity system has two well - resolved peaks representing two plaritons resonance @xcite . in the experimental setting , et al_. @xcite demonstrated exciton - photon mode splitting in a semiconductor microcavity when the quantum well and the optical cavity are in resonance . subsequent experiments on exciton - photon coupling confirmed normal mode splitting and oscillatory emission from exciton microcavities @xcite . in this work , we study the effect of the squeezed light generated by a subthreshold degenerate parametric oscillator ( opo ) on the squeezing and statistical properties of the fluorescent light emitted by a quantum well in a cavity . the system is outlined in fig . degenerate opo operating below threshold is a well - known source of squeezed light @xcite . we explore the interaction between this light and a quantum well with a single exciton mode placed in the opo cavity . our analysis is restricted to the weak excitation regime where the density of excitons is small so that the interactions between an exciton and its neighbors can be neglected . further , to gain insight into the physics we investigate the dynamics of the fluorescent light emitted by the quantum well in the strong coupling regime , which amounts to keeping the leading terms in the photon - exciton coupling constant @xmath0 . we show that the fluorescent light exhibits bunching and quadrature squeezing . the former is due to the fact that two or more excitons in the quantum well can be excited by absorbing cavity photons . this implies there is a finite probability that two photons can be emitted simultaneously . we also show that the squeezed light leads to narrowing of the width of the spectrum of the fluorescent light . we obtain the solution of the quantum langevin equation for a cavity coupled to vacuum reservoir . the resulting solution , in the strong coupling limit , is used to calculate the intensity , spectrum , second order correlation function and quadrature squeezing of the fluorescent light . we consider a system composed of a semiconductor quantum well and a degenerate parametric oscillator operating below threshold . in a degenerate parametric oscillator , a pump photon of frequency @xmath1 is downconverted into a pair of identical sinal photons of frequency @xmath2 . the signal photons are highly correlated and this correlation is responsible to the reduction of noise below the vacuum level . such a system produces a maximum intracavity squeezing of 50@xmath3 . in a quantum well , the electromagnetic field can excite an electron from the filled valance band to the conduction band thereby creating a hole in the valance band . the electron - hole system possesses bound states which is also called exciton states analogous to the hydrogenic states or more precisely to the positronium bound states . we assume that the density of the excitons is small so that exciton - exciton interaction is negligible . the hamiltonian describing the parametric process and interaction between exciton and cavity mode in the rotating wave approximation and at resonance is given by @xmath4 here @xmath5 and @xmath6 , considered as boson operators , are the annihilation operators for the cavity and exciton modes , respectively ; @xmath0 is the exciton cavity mode coupling ; @xmath7 is the hamiltonian associated with the dissipation of the cavity and exciton modes by vacuum reservoir modes . we assume here that the amplitude of the field @xmath8 that drives the cavity is real and constant . the quantum langevin equations of the system taking into account the cavity dissipation @xmath9 and the exciton spontaneous emission @xmath10 can be written as @xmath11 @xmath12 where @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the langevin noise operators for the cavity and exciton modes , respectively . both noise operators have zero mean , i.e. , @xmath15 . for a cavity mode damped by a vacuum reservoir , the noise operator satisfy the following correlations : @xmath16 @xmath17 the exciton noise operators satisfy the following correlations : @xmath18 @xmath19 in this section we analyze the photon statistics of he fluorescent light by calculating intensity , intensity spectrum and second order correlation function in the strong coupling regime . the solution of eqs . and is rigorously derived in the appendix . in the paper paper is devoted to the dynamics of the system in the strong coupling regime . to this end , imposing the strong coupling limit ( @xmath20 ) , which amounts to keeping only the leading terms in @xmath0 , one obtains from eqs . and that @xmath21 . as a result , the solution given by eqs . and reduce to @xmath22\notag\\ & + \int_{0}^{t}dt^{\prime } ~~\big[\lambda_{3}(t - t^{\prime})f_{e}(t^{\prime})+\lambda_{4}(t - t^{\prime})f_{e}^{\dagger}(t^{\prime})\big],\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath23\notag\\ & + \int_{0}^{t}dt^{\prime } ~~\big[\lambda_{1}^{(-)}(t - t^{\prime})f_{e}(t^{\prime})+\lambda_{2}^{(-)}(t - t^{\prime})f_{e}^{\dagger}(t^{\prime})\big],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath24 e^{-(\kappa+\gamma)t/4},\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath25e^{-(\kappa+\gamma)t/4},\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath26 @xmath27 all quantities of interest which describe the dynamics of the system can fully be analyzed using these solutions . the dynamical behavior of the intensity of light emitted by a single quantum well in gaas microcavity has been measured experimentally @xcite . we here seek to study the dynamical behavior of the light emitted by a single quantum well interacting with squeezed light . the intensity of the fluorescent light is proportional to the mean number of excitons in the system . using eq . and the properties of the noise forces , we readily obtain @xmath28\sinh(\varepsilon t)\notag\\ & -(\kappa+\gamma)\frac{2\varepsilon \sinh ( \varepsilon t)+(\kappa+\gamma)\cosh(\varepsilon t)}{(\kappa+\gamma)^2 - 4\varepsilon^2}\notag\\ & + \frac{\gamma-\kappa } { 2 g } \text{sinh}^2 ( \varepsilon t/2)\text{sin}(2 g t)\bigg]e^{-(\kappa+\gamma)t/2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath29 is the mean exciton number in the cavity at initial time . we assumed that the cavity mode is initially in vacuum state . it is easy to see that in the steady state the mean exciton number reduces to @xmath30 which is a contribution to intensity of the fluorescent light due to the optical parametric oscillator . vs scaled time @xmath31 for @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 and for different values of @xmath35 . ] near threshold vs scaled time @xmath31 for @xmath36 , @xmath33 , @xmath37 and for different values of @xmath35 . ] in fig . 2 , we plot the intensity as a function of scaled time @xmath31 for different values of the scaled pump field amplitude @xmath35 . in this figure we have assumed that the cavity in initially prepared in such a way that it contains one exciton(@xmath37 ) but no photon . for simplicity we have taken the cavity and exciton decay rate to be the same , i.e. , @xmath38 . this figure shows the effect of the parametric oscillator on the intensity fluorescent light . it is not hard to see that the intensity oscillates with frequency equal to the coupling constant @xmath0 , which is a signature of exchange of energy between the cavity and exciton modes . moreover , the amplitude of the oscillations depends on the amplitude of the pump field , @xmath39 , which represents the optical parametric oscillator in our system . the stronger the pump field and the higher the amplitude of oscillation and the longer it takes to reach the steady state value of the intensity . it worth emphasizing that since optical parametric oscillator is operating below threshold , the parameter @xmath39 is constrained by the inequality @xmath40 . we thus interpret @xmath41 as threshold condition for the parametric process . in the vicinity of the threshold the mean exciton number increases rapidly and exceeds unity as illustrated in fig . this shows that even though there is one exciton in the cavity initially , there is a finite probability for the squeezed light in the cavity to excite two or more excitons in the quantum well . this has an interesting effect on the photon statistics of the fluorescent light as discussed in section c. we next proceed to calculate the power spectrum of the fluorescent light . the power spectrum of the fluorescent light can be expressed in terms of the bosonic operator as @xmath42 in the strong coupling regime the correlation function that appears in the integrand of the power spectrum in the steady state has the form @xmath43 e^{-(\kappa+\gamma)\tau/4}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting this result in eq . and keeping the leading order in @xmath0 , we obtain the power spectrum of the fluorescent light to be @xmath44,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath45 are the half widths of the lorentzians centered at @xmath46 . we immediately see that the width of the power spectrum depends on the amplitude of the pump field . ] vs scaled frequency @xmath47 for @xmath36 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 , and for different values of @xmath35 . ] we observe that the maximum of the power spectrum occurs when the frequency equal to the coupling constant ( @xmath0 ) . in order of explore the effect of the squeezed light on the width of the spectrum it is convenient to plot the the power spectrum normalized by its maximum value , i.e. , @xmath48 . in fig . [ fig4 ] , we plot the normalized spectrum as a function of @xmath49 for different values of the pump amplitude ( @xmath39 ) . as clearly indicated in the figure , the the higher the amplitude of the pump field ( the degree of squeezing ) , the narrower the width has become . it is also worth noting that the narrowing of the width is more pronounced close to the threshold , i.e. , when the squeezing approaches to its maximum value . this is in contrary to the result obtained when the quantum well is coupled to a squeezed vacuum reservoir , where the spectrum is independent of the squeeze parameter @xcite . we further note that the spectrum has two peaks symmetrically located at @xmath50 . this is the result of the strong coupling approximation ( @xmath51 ) . both peaks have the same width which depends on the exciton and cavity modes decay rates and the amplitude of the pump field . [ g2 ] we now turn our attention to the calculation of autocorrelation function , which is proportional to the probability of detecting one photon at @xmath52 given that another photon was detected at earlier time t. quantum mechanically autocorrelation is defined by @xmath53 using the gaussian properties of the noise forces @xcite , the autocorrelation function in the steady state can be put in a simpler form @xmath54 in order to find a closed form analytical expression for the autocorrelation function , one has to determine the two time correlation functions that appear in eq . . this can be done using the solution along with the correlation properties of the noise forces . after algebraic manipulations , we obtain the final expression of the autocorrelation function to be @xmath55,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath56,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath57 expression is valid only in the strong coupling regime ( @xmath20 ) . the behavior of @xmath58 as a function of the pump amplitude ( @xmath39 ) and for constant @xmath0 is illustrated in fig . this figure shows that the correlation function oscillates at frequency equals to @xmath0 . the amplitude of this oscillations decreases fast when we increase the value of @xmath39 . the autocorrelation function at @xmath59 has the form @xmath60 indicating the phenomenon of photon bunching . here the underlying physics can be explained in terms of the mean exciton number ( see fig . [ fig3 ] ) . in that figure we have showed that , even though we start of one exciton initially , there is finite probability of exciting two or more excitons in the quantum well by the squeezed light . this allows the possibility of emission of two photon at a time which leads to of phenomenon of bunching in the fluorescent light . for @xmath33 , @xmath36 , @xmath37 , and for different value of pump amplitude @xmath35 . the squeezing properties of the fluorescent light can be analyzed by calculating the variances of the quadrature operators . the variances of the quadrature operators for the fluorescent light are given by @xmath61 @xmath62 where @xmath63 and @xmath64 . these quadrature operators satisfy the commutation relation @xmath65=2i$ ] . on the basis of these definitions the fluorescent light is said to be in a squeezed state if either @xmath66 or @xmath67 . in deriving @xmath68 and @xmath69 we have used @xmath70 , which can easily be verified using @xmath71 . applying eq . and the properties of the noise operators the variances turn out to be @xmath72 @xmath73 in which @xmath74\sin(2gt),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath75 it is straightforward to see that the variances reduce in the steady state to @xmath76 @xmath77 expressions and represent the quadrature variance of a parametric oscillator operating below threshold . at threshold @xmath78 , the squeezing becomes @xmath79 which is the maximum squeezing that can be obtained from subthreshold parametric oscillator @xcite . it is then not difficult to see that the squeezing occurs in the @xmath80 quadrature . in fig . [ qv ] , the time evolution of the variance of the @xmath80 quadrature , , is plotted versus scaled time @xmath31 . the variance in this quadrature oscillates with frequency equal to twice the rabi frequency . the amplitude of oscillation damps out at longer time and eventually become flat at steady state . moreover , it is interesting to note that the fluorescent light is not squeezed at initial moment however , it starts to exhibit transient squeezing before it becomes unsqueezed again . the more the exciton interacts with the squeezed light , the stronger the squeezing becomes . as a result of this we observe squeezed fluorescent light in longer periods which ultimately approaches to the @xmath79 maximum squeezing limit observed in parametric oscillator . the reduction of fluctuations noted in the fluorescent light is due to the interaction between the long - lived squeezed photons in the cavity and excitons in the quantum well . as can be seen from fig . [ qv ] , the degree of squeezing of the fluorescent light depends on the amplitude of the pump field . vs scaled time @xmath31 for @xmath33 , @xmath38 , @xmath37 and for the different values of the pump field amplitude @xmath35 . ] the quantum statistical properties of the fluorescent light emitted by exciton in a quantum well interacting with squeezed light is presented . analytical solutions for the pertinent quantum langevin equations are rigorously derived . these solutions , in the strong coupling limit in which the exciton - cavity mode coupling is much greater than the cavity as well as exciton spontaneous decay rates @xmath81 are used to study the dynamical behavior of the generated light . we find that the squeezed light enhances the mean photon number and narrows the width of the intensity spectrum of the fluorescent light . further , the fluorescent light shows normal - mode splitting , which is a signature of strong coupling . we note that unlike atomic cavity qed where the fluorescent light exhibits antibunching , the fluorescent light in the present system rather exhibits bunching . the manifestation of bunching is attributed to the possibility of exciting two or more excitons in the quantum well which in turn leads a finite probability of emission of two photons simultaneously . one of us ( e.a.s ) gratefully acknowledge financial support from the robert a. welch and the heep foundations . in this appendix we derive the solution of the following quantum lagevin equations : @xmath82 @xmath83 in order to solve these equations it is more convenient to introduce new variable defined by @xmath84 with the help of eqs . and and their complex adjoint we obtain @xmath85 @xmath86 where @xmath87 and @xmath88 . note that eqs . and are decoupled from and . these coupled equations can be solved using the method of laplace transform . the laplace transform of eqs . and gives @xmath89\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath90,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath91 and @xmath92 and @xmath93 with @xmath94 denoting laplace transform . the inverse laplace transform of eqs . and yields @xmath95 @xmath96 where @xmath97e^{-\gamma_{-}t}\ ] ] @xmath98 @xmath99 note that the solution of the coupled equations and can easily be obtained by replacing @xmath39 by @xmath100 , @xmath101 by @xmath102 , and @xmath103 by @xmath104 in the solution of eqs . and . we thus have @xmath105 @xmath106 where @xmath107e^{-\gamma_{+}t}\ ] ] @xmath108 @xmath109 applying the inversion formula @xmath110 and @xmath111 the solution for @xmath112 and @xmath113 turn out to be @xmath114\notag\\ & + \int_{0}^{t}dt^{\prime } ~~\big[\eta_{3}^{(+)}(t - t^{\prime})f_{e}(t^{\prime})+\eta_{3}^{(-)}(t - t^{\prime})f_{e}^{\dagger}(t^{\prime})\big],\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath115\notag\\ & + \int_{0}^{t}dt^{\prime } ~~\big[\eta_{1}^{(-)}(t - t^{\prime})f_{e}(t^{\prime})+\eta_{2}^{(-)}(t - t^{\prime})f_{e}^{\dagger}(t^{\prime})\big],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath116 @xmath117 @xmath118 h. eleuch and n. rachid , eur . j. d * 57 * , 259 ( 2010 ) h. eleuch , j. phys . b * 41 * , 055502 ( 2008 ) . h. eleuch and r. bennaceur , j. opt . b * 6 * , 189 ( 2004 ) e. giacobino , j.ph . karrr , g. messin , h. eleuch , c.r . physique * 3 * , 41 ( 2002 ) . karr , a. baas , r. houdr and e. giacobino phys . a * 69 * , 031802 ( 2004 ) . a. quattropani and p. schwendimann , phys . status solidi * 242 * , 2302 ( 2005 ) . h. eleuch , eur . j. d * 49 * , 391 ( 2008 ) ; h. eleuch , eur . j. d * 48 * , 139 ( 2008 ) . d. erenso , r. vyas and s. singh , phys . rev a * 67*,013818 ( 2003 ) . r. vyas and s. singh , j. opt . b * 7 * , 634 ( 2000 ) . y. chen , a. tredicucci and f. bassani , phys . b * 52 * , 1800 ( 1995 ) . h. wang , y. chough , s. e. palmer , and h. j. carmichael , opt . express * 1 * , 370 ( 1997 ) . c. weisbuch , m. nishioka , a. ishikawa , and y. arakawa , phys . lett . * 69 * , 3314 ( 1992 ) . s. pau , g. bjrk , j. jacobson , h. cao , and y. yamamoto , phys . b * 51 * , 14 437 ( 1995 ) ; h. cao , j. jacobson , _ et al_. , appl . phys . lett . * 66 * , 1107 ( 1995 ) . j. jacobson , s. pau , h. cao , g. bjrk , and y. yamamoto , phys . a * 51 * , 2542 ( 1995 ) . l. a. lugiato and g. strini , opt . comm . * 41 * , 67 ( 1982 ) . g. j. milburn and d. f. walls , phys . a * 27 * , 392 ( 1983 ) . d. f. walls and g. j. milburn , quantum optics ( springer - verlag , berlin , 1994 ) .

we investigate the quantum statistical properties of the light emitted by a quantum well interacting with squeezed light from a degenerate subthreshold optical parametric oscillator . we obtain analytical solutions for the pertinent quantum langevin equations in the strong coupling and low excitation regimes . using these solutions we calculate the intensity spectrum , autocorrelation function , quadrature squeezing for the fluorescent light . we show that the fluorescent light exhibits bunching and quadrature squeezing . we also show that the squeezed light leads to narrowing of the width of the spectrum of the fluorescent light .

quant-ph0303021

research on quantum statistical properties of light has been a subject of intense investigations and discussions . in view of the very wide - spread potential applications , the influence of material bodies on the quantum features of light must be thoroughly investigated . typical quantum effects that are closely related to the change of the quantum vacuum due to the presence of material bodies are the casimir effect @xcite ( for a review , see @xcite ) and the purcell effect @xcite ( see also @xcite ) . though there has been a large body of work on the problem of quantization of the electromagnetic field in dielectric media ( for a review , see @xcite ) , most work has been concentrated on nonabsorbing media . roughly speaking , there have been two routes to treat radiation in absorbing media . in the first , attention has been restricted to equilibrium field correlation functions that are calculated by employing the dissipation - fluctuation theorem @xcite . in the second , explicit field quantization has been performed ( for a review , see @xcite ) . a consistent quantization scheme for the electromagnetic field in bulk material has been given by huttner and barnett @xcite . using the mesoscopic hopfield model @xcite for a dielectric , they have diagonalized the bilinear hamiltonian of the system that consists of the electromagnetic field , a harmonic - oscillator polarization field , and an infinite set of harmonic - oscillator reservoir fields responsible for absorption . by starting directly with the phenomenological maxwell equations for the macroscopic electromagnetic field , the scheme can naturally be extended to arbitrary inhomogeneous media @xcite characterized by a space- and frequency - dependent complex permittivity that satisfies the kramers - kronig relations . the theory is based on a source - quantity representation of the electromagnetic field , where the field operators are expressed in terms of a continuous set of fundamental bose fields via the green tensor of the classical problem ( for details , see also @xcite ) . the green - tensor formalism is well suited to study the behavior of the quantized electromagnetic field in the presence of dispersing and absorbing bodies . in particular , it has successfully been applied to the study of input - output relations @xcite , the spontaneous emission @xcite , the resonant energy exchange @xcite , the resonant dipole - dipole interaction @xcite , and the casimir effect @xcite , and also various geometries ( including multilayer structures ) have been considered . it is worth noting that the theory not only takes into account material absorption in a consistent way but it also includes automatically evanescent - field contributions generated , e.g. , by radiating atoms that are very close to the bodies under consideration . for the particular case of a dispersing and absorbing dielectric structure in vacuum , without active light sources at any finite distance from the structure ( and without active light sources inside the structure ) , a ratherinvolved hybrid quantization scheme has been proposed @xcite and used to study the problem of three - dimensional input - output relations @xcite . in the scheme , the whole space is divided into two regions , namely a dielectric scattering region and a vacuum region that surrounds the scattering region . the quantization in the vacuum region is performed on the basis of a mode decomposition of the electromagnetic - field operators in a similar way as in vacuum quantum electrodynamics , whereas the contribution of the dielectric scattering region is taken into account by applying the green tensor formalism @xcite . the argument is @xcite that the green tensor formalism alone is not complete , because it does not explicitly treat the boundary of the medium with free space and thus does not describe explicitly the scattering and emission processes which are usually experimentally investigated . this is of course not the case as the above mentioned applications @xcite and the following study of the three - dimensional input - output relations at multilayer plates clearly show . moreover , when there are active light sources at _ finite distances _ from the scattering region , then the incoming field contains both propagating and evanescent components . the latter ones , which are typically observed for small distances , are not included in the hybrid quantization scheme @xcite and the input - output relations derived from it @xcite . however , they are automatically included in the green tensor formalism @xcite . in the following we consider the problem of the three - dimensional input - output relations for the electromagnetic - field operators at the boundaries of a dielectric planar multilayer structure in more detail , by applying the green tensor formalism and extending our previous one - dimensional analysis @xcite to three dimensions . to be quite general , we allow ( i ) for the presence of active light sources at arbitrary positions inside and/or outside the multilayer plate and thus ( ii ) for both propagating - field components and evanescent - field components . in particular , in cavity qed the active sources are typically inside the plate , and the outgoing fields are not only determined with the incoming fields and the noise fields ( unavoidably associated with material absorption ) but also with the fields generated by the sources inside the plate . on the contrary , in optical near - field microscopy the active ( probe ) sources are typically outside the plate , but near its surface . employing the well - known three - dimensional green tensor for a multilayer plate @xcite , we introduce amplitude operators for the input and output fields as well as for the fields inside the plate and derive input - output relations both in the two - dimensional fourier space and in the coordinate space . finally , the problem of introduction of bosonic input and output operators in the two - dimensional fourier space is considered in detail . the paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ sec : ba ] the quantization scheme is briefly summarized and the green tensor for a multilayer plate is introduced . in sec . [ sec : gr ] the generally valid input - output relations are derived , and the problem of formulating input - output relations for bosonic field operators is studied . a summary and some concluding remarks are given in sec . [ sec : co ] followed by an appendix , in which relevant commutation relations are derived . to study optical fields interacting with active sources in the presence of dispersing and absorbing ( linear ) dielectric bodies , we first note that on a length scale that is large compared with interatomic distances in the bodies , the effect of the bodies can be described within the frame of macroscopic maxwell equations in terms of a spatially varying permittivity which is a complex function of frequency . this concept , which is widely used in classical optics also applies in quantum optics . let us assume that the active light sources are neutral atoms and consider an arbitrarily inhomogeneous medium characterized by a permittivity @xmath1 where the real part @xmath2 and the imaginary part @xmath3 are necessarily related to each other through the kramers - kronig relations , due to the causality principle . the motion of the atoms and the medium - assisted electromagnetic field is then governed by the multipolar - coupling hamiltonian @xcite @xmath4 \!\!\bigg\}^2 \nonumber \\[1ex ] & & + \,\frac{1}{2\epsilon_0 } \sum_{a , a ' } \int { \mbox{\rm d}}^3{r } \ , \hat{\bf p}_{a}({\bf r})\cdot \hat{\bf p}_{a'}({\bf r } ) -\sum_a \int { \mbox{\rm d}}^3{r}\ , \hat{{\bf p}}_{a}({\bf r})\cdot \hat{\bf e}({\bf r } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath5 numbers the atoms , and @xmath6 numbers the charged particles inside the @xmath5-th atom . further , @xmath7 and @xmath8 are respectively the operators of coordinates and canonical momenta of the particles , and @xmath9\ ] ] is the operator of the polarization of the @xmath5-th atom at position @xmath10 . the @xmath11 [ and @xmath12 are bosonic field operators that play the role of fundamental variables of the electromagnetic field and the medium , including a reservoir necessarily associated with material absorption . the commutation relations for the operators @xmath13 and @xmath14 are @xmath15 = \delta _ { \mu \mu'}\delta ( \omega - \omega ' ) \delta ^{(3)}({\bf r } - { \bf r } ' ) , \ ] ] @xmath16 = 0,\ ] ] where the greek letters label the cartesian coordinates @xmath17 . in eq . ( [ 2 ] ) , the operators @xmath18 and @xmath19 of the medium - assisted electromagnetic field are expressed in terms of the fundamental variables as follows : @xmath20 @xmath21 @xmath22 @xmath23 where the integration should be performed over all space , and @xmath24 is the classical green tensor , which can be found from the equation @xmath25 together with appropriate boundary conditions at infinity . equations ( [ 6 ] - [ 9 ] ) can be considered as generalization of the familiar mode decomposition that would apply if dispersion and absorption could be disregarded . instead of dealing with equations of motion for mode operators , equations of motion for the fields @xmath11 must be treated . it should be pointed out that since the real part @xmath2 and the imaginary part @xmath3 of the permittivity are related to each other through the kramers - kronig relations , @xmath3 can not vanish identically for really existing media . clearly , @xmath26 can be very small , so that @xmath27 in eq . ( [ 9 ] ) is very small in certain areas of space ( @xmath28 ) . however , this statement says nothing about the magnitude of the total integral over the coordinate @xmath28 , because of the following integral relation for the classical green tensor @xmath29 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have adopted the convention of summation over repeated vector - component indices . in particular , this relation enables one to include also vacuum - like areas in the consideration . thus , all the calculations are to be performed by assuming a permittivity close to unity with a small but finite imaginary part in those areas , and at the end the permittivity may be set equal to unity . in practice , experimental realization of ( macroscopic ) vacuum areas is of course fictional . scheme of the multilayer dielectric plate . the hatched regions indicate the presence of active light sources . , width=326 ] as mentioned , the quantization scheme is valid for an arbitrary space dependence of the permittivity . here , we consider a multilayered planar structure ( fig . [ fig ] ) , whose permittivity is defined in a stepwise fashion ( the @xmath30-direction is chosen to be perpendicular to the layers ) : @xmath31 where @xmath32 0 , \ , & \mbox{otherwise } , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] and @xmath33 is the ( complex ) permittivity of the @xmath34-th layer . in the above , the index @xmath34 labels the region on the left of the plate , the region on the right of the plate , and the layers of the plate . for simplicity , we express the @xmath30-coordinate dependence in shifted coordinate systems , introduced in each layer separately , so that the range of the @xmath30-coordinate is taken to be for the region on the left of the plate , for the region on the right of the plate , and for the @xmath34-th layer of the plate with thickness @xmath35 . exploiting the translational symmetry in the lane , we may represent the green tensor as a two - dimensional fourier integral @xmath36 where , and is the wave vector parallel to the layers . the notations @xmath37 and @xmath38 indicate that @xmath30 varies in the @xmath34-th layer and @xmath39 in the @xmath40-th layer . inserting eq . ( [ 14 ] ) into eq . ( [ 9 ] ) , we may write the electric - field operator @xmath41 as a two - fold fourier transform , @xmath42 where @xmath43 & & \times \sum _ { j'=0}^n \int _ { [ j ' ] } { \mbox{\rm d}}z'\ , { \mbox{\boldmath $ g$}}^{(jj')}(z , z ' , { \bf k } , \omega)\cdot \hat { \bf j}^{(j ' ) } ( z ' , { \bf k } , \omega ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] ( @xmath44 $ ] indicates integration over the @xmath40-th region ) . here , the fourier transformed current operators @xmath45 have been introduced , where the operators @xmath46 are the fourier transforms of the original bosonic field operators @xmath47 , @xmath48 the green tensor @xmath49 taken from ref . @xcite may be written as @xmath50 & & = - \,{\bf e}_z \,\frac { \delta_{jj ' } } { k_j ^2 } \,{\bf e } _ z\ , \delta ( z - z ' ) + { \mbox{\boldmath $ g$}}^{(jj')}(z , z ' , { \bf k } , \omega ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath51 & & = \frac { i } { 2 } \sum _ { q = p , s}\sigma _ q \left [ \bm { \mathcal{e } } ^{j > } _ { q } ( z , { \bf k } , \omega ) \ , \xi^{jj ' } _ { q } \bm{\mathcal{e } } ^{j ' < } _ { q } ( z ' , -{\bf k } , \omega ) \theta ( j\!-\!j ' ) \right . \nonumber \\[1ex ] & & \left . \,+\ , \bm{\mathcal{e}}^{j < } _ { q } ( z , { \bf k } , \omega ) \ , \xi^{j'j } _ { q } \bm{\mathcal{e } } ^{j ' > } _ { q } ( z ' , -{\bf k } , \omega ) \theta ( j'-j ) \right ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] ( , ) . note that for one should write instead of [ and instead of ] . ( [ 20 ] ) , the functions @xmath52 and @xmath53 denote waves of unit strength traveling , respectively , rightward and leftward in the @xmath34-th layer and being reflected at the boundary , @xmath54 @xmath55 and @xmath56 where @xmath57 . here , @xmath58 ( @xmath59 @xmath60 @xmath61 ) , where @xmath62 and and @xmath63 are , respectively , the transmission and reflection coefficients between the layers @xmath40 and @xmath34 . finally , the unit vectors @xmath64 in eqs . ( [ 21 ] ) and ( [ 22 ] ) are the polarization unit vectors for te and tm waves , @xmath65 \label{28 } { \bf e}^{(j)}_{p\pm}({\bf k } ) & = & \frac { 1 } { k_j } \left(\mp \beta _ j\frac{{\bf k}}{k } + k { \bf e } _ z \right ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the ` propagation constant ' @xmath66 determines the propagation behavior in @xmath30-direction of the waves in the @xmath34-th region . note that in case of vacuum the waves are propagating only for ( i.e. , ) . they are evanescent for ( i.e. , ) . the equations of motion which follow from the hamiltonian ( [ 2 ] ) in sec . [ sec : ba.1 ] together with the green tensor as given in sec . [ sec : ba.2 ] can be used to study various effects of the atom - light interaction in the presence of dispersing and absorbing multilayered planar structures ( see the examples mentioned in sec . [ sec1 ] ) . here , we restrict our attention to the general relation between the fields outside and inside a multilayer plate regardless of the generation of the fields by the active light sources . the theory thus includes the general case , where sources are present in the both regions , outside and inside the plate . if the incoming fields , incident on the two boundary planes of the plate ( i.e. , @xmath30 @xmath60 @xmath67 for and @xmath30 @xmath60 @xmath68 for ; cf . fig . [ fig ] ) , are known as well as the fields generated inside the plate , one can calculate the fields outgoing from the two boundary planes by means of input - output relations . note that any two planes @xmath30 @xmath60 @xmath69 @xmath70 @xmath71 and @xmath30 @xmath60 @xmath72 @xmath73 @xmath74 for and , respectively , also can be used in principle . as we shall see , these input - output relations are valid for both passive and active devices , for arbitrary layer materials and arbitrary media surrounding the plate and for both propagating - field components and evanescent - field components . here and in the following we restrict our attention to the electric field , noting that the corresponding expressions for the magnetic field can readily be obtained by applying eq . ( [ 8 ] ) . following the line suggested in ref . @xcite and substituting the green tensor ( [ 19 ] ) for and into eq . ( [ 16 ] ) , we may decompose the field operators @xmath76 and @xmath77 in the form of @xmath78 & & \hspace{15ex } \left . + \ , { \bf e}^{(0)}_{q- } ( { \bf k } ) \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm out } } ^{(0 ) } ( z,{\bf k } , \omega)\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath79 & & \hspace{15ex } \left . + \ , { \bf e}^{(n)}_{q+ } ( { \bf k } ) \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm out}}^{(n ) } ( z,{\bf k } , \omega)\right ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] here , the operators @xmath80 & & \times\ ; \int _ { -\infty } ^{z}\ ! \ ! { \mbox{\rm d}}z'\ , e^{- i \beta _ 0 z ' } \,\hat { \bf j } ^{(0 ) } ( z ' , { \bf k } , \omega ) \cdot { \bf e}^{(0)}_{q+}({\bf k } ) , \\[1ex ] \label{32 } \lefteqn { \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(n ) } ( z , { \bf k } , \omega ) = - \frac { \mu _ 0 \omega } { 2 \beta _ n } e^{- i \beta _ n z } } \nonumber \\[1ex ] & & \times\ ; \int _ { z } ^{\infty } { \mbox{\rm d}}z'\ , e^ { i \beta _ n z ' } \,\hat { \bf j } ^{(n)}(z ' , { \bf k } , \omega ) \cdot { \bf e}^{(n)}_{q-}({\bf k } ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath81 & & + \,e^ { - i \beta _ 0 z } \int _ { z } ^{0 } { \mbox{\rm d}}z'\,e^ { i \beta _ 0 z ' } \,\hat { \bf j } ^{(0 ) } ( z ' , { \bf k } , \omega ) \cdot { \bf e}^{(0)}_{q-}({\bf k } ) , \quad \\[1ex ] \label{34 } \lefteqn { \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm out}}^{(n ) } ( z,{\bf k } , \omega ) = e^ { i \beta _ n z } \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm out}}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & + \,e^ { i \beta _ n z } \int _ { 0 } ^{z } { \mbox{\rm d}}z'\ , e^{- i \beta _ n z ' } \,\hat { \bf j } ^{(n ) } ( z ' , { \bf k } , \omega)\cdot { \bf e}^{(n)}_{q+}({\bf k } ) , \qquad \end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively , play the role of input and output amplitude operators , where the input - output relations @xmath82 \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm out}}^{(n)}({\bf k } , \omega ) \end{array } \right ) = \left ( \begin{array}{cc } r^q_{0/n}({\bf k},\omega ) & t_{n/0 } ^q({\bf k},\omega)\\[1ex ] t_{0/n } ^q({\bf k},\omega ) & r ^q _ { n/0}({\bf k},\omega ) \end{array } \right ) \left ( \begin{array}{c } \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm in } } ^{(0)}({\bf k } , \omega ) \\[1ex ] \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(n)}({\bf k } , \omega ) \end{array } \right ) + \sum _ { j = 1 } ^{n-1 } \left ( \begin{array}{cc } \phi _ { q\ , 0 + } ^{(j)}({\bf k},\omega ) & \phi _ { q\ , 0- } ^{(j)}({\bf k},\omega ) \\[1ex ] \phi _ { q\ , n+ } ^{(j)}({\bf k},\omega ) & \phi _ { q\ , n- } ^{(j)}({\bf k},\omega ) \end{array } \right ) \left ( \begin{array}{c } \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q+}^{(j)}({\bf k } , \omega)\\[1ex ] \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q-}^{(j)}({\bf k } , \omega ) \end{array } \right)\!,\quad \end{aligned}\ ] ] are valid ( for the commutation relations , see the appendix ) . they relate the output amplitude operators at the boundary planes of the multilayer plate to the input amplitude operators at the boundary planes , @xmath83 \label{37 } \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm in , out}}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) & = & \left . \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm in , out}}^{(n ) } ( z , { \bf k } , \omega ) \right|_{z=0^+ } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and the intraplate amplitude operators @xmath84 & & \times\ ; \int _ { 0 } ^{d_j } { \mbox{\rm d}}z ' \ , e^{\mp i \beta _ j z ' } \,\hat { \bf j}^{(j ) } ( z ' , { \bf k } , \omega)\cdot { \bf e}^{(j ) } _ { q\pm}({\bf k})\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( @xmath34 @xmath60 @xmath85 ) , which are associated with the excitation inside the layers of the plate . in eq . ( [ 35 ] ) , the @xmath86-coefficients read @xmath87 @xmath88 it should be pointed out that the first term on the right - hand side in eq . ( [ 19 ] ) , which gives rise to a local contribution to the electric field , has been omitted in eqs . ( [ 29 ] ) and ( [ 30 ] ) . though this contribution is irrelevant for the incoming and outgoing fields , it must be included in the overall field operator in general , even if there are effectively no sources at the points of observations . it is not difficult to prove that ( similar to the one - dimensional case @xcite ) the @xmath30-dependent amplitude operators ( [ 31 ] ) ( [ 34 ] ) obey quantum langevin equations , @xmath89 & & \hspace{10ex } -\,\frac { \mu _ 0 \omega } { 2 \beta _ 0 } \,\hat { \bf j } ^{(0 ) } ( z , { \bf k } , \omega)\cdot { \bf e}^{(0)}_{q+}({\bf k } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath90 & & \hspace{10ex } + \,\frac { \mu _ 0 \omega } { 2 \beta _ 0 } \,\hat { \bf j } ^{(0 ) } ( z , { \bf k } , \omega)\cdot { \bf e}^{(0)}_{q-}({\bf k } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and similar equations are valid for @xmath91 and @xmath92 . these equations together with eq . ( [ 35 ] ) render it possible to easily calculate the input and output fields at any position outside the plate . needless to say that other than the boundary planes and of the plate can be chosen as reference planes for formulating the input - output relations . equation ( [ 35 ] ) represents the basic input - output relations for the amplitude operators in the fourier space . the coefficients therein are determined only by the ( complex ) permittivities and thicknesses of the layers of the plate and the permittivities of the surrounding media . in particular , for ( i.e. , ) eq . ( [ 35 ] ) immediately yields the input - output relations for the special case of the plate being surrounded by vacuum . the input - output relations in the form of eq . ( [ 35 ] ) are generally valid , independent of the mechanism of creation of the incoming fields and the fields inside the layers of the plate . it is worth noting that they take into account both propagating waves and evanescent waves . in particular in the case when the plate is surrounded by vacuum , then the input and output amplitude operators are associated with propagating waves or evanescent waves in @xmath30-direction . the temporal evolution ( in the heisenberg picture ) of the amplitude operators is determined by the time dependence of the basic variables @xmath11 [ or equivalently , @xmath93 , which is governed by the hamiltonian ( [ 2 ] ) . in the special case when the plate is free of active atomic sources , then the fields inside the layers of the plate represent langevin noise sources associated with material absorption . if absorption is disregarded and the plate is surrounded by vacuum that may contain active sources , then eq ( [ 35 ] ) solves a scattering problem of the type considered in ref . @xcite , namely scattering of fields containing evanescent components . in general , absorption can not be disregarded and both atomic sources and langevin noise sources contribute to a field ( e.g. , in cavity qed ) , which can contain both propagating and evanescent components ( e.g. , in near - field scanning probe microscopy ) . the input - output relations ( [ 35 ] ) enable one to calculate correlation functions of the output field amplitudes in terms of those of the input field amplitudes and the amplitudes of the fields inside the plate . the simplest case is the calculation of the expectation values of the field amplitudes . for example , in a typical scattering arrangement the active light sources are located outside the plate , so that the field inside the plate is the absorption - assisted random field whose thermal - equilibrium expectation value vanishes . application of eq . ( [ 35 ] ) thus leads to the expectation - value relations @xmath94 @xmath95 which exactly correspond to standard results in classical optics . on the other hand , when the active sources are located ( in a cavity - like system ) inside the plate , we find that @xmath96 , \end{split}\ ] ] @xmath97 . \qquad \ ; \end{split}\ ] ] needless to say that when there are no active sources inside the plate , then is valid and thus . clearly , higher - order correlation functions of the outgoing amplitude operators do not vanish in this case in general . for example , the spectral intensity ( in the @xmath0-space ) of the radiation outgoing from a plane of a plate in thermal equilibrium at temperature @xmath98 , for chosen polarization , is proportional to @xmath99 , where @xmath100 & & = w_{q\,{\rm out}}^{(0,n)}({\bf k},\omega)\,\delta(\omega-\omega ' ) \delta({\bf k}-{\bf k}').\end{aligned}\ ] ] applying eq . ( [ 35 ] ) together with eqs . ( [ 38 ] ) and ( [ 17 ] ) and making use of @xmath101 & & = n(\omega , t)\ , \delta_{\mu\mu ' } \delta(\omega-\omega')\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k}')\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( @xmath34 @xmath102 @xmath103 ) , where @xmath104^{-1}\ ] ] ( @xmath105 , boltzmann constant ) is the well - known bose - einstein distribution function , we derive @xmath106 & & \left . + \ , \bigl|r_{j/0}^q\bigr|^2 c_{q--}^{(j)}({\bf k},\omega ) + \left[r_{j/0}^q c_{q-+}^{(j)}({\bf k},\omega ) + { \rm c.c.}\right]\right\}\qquad\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( and @xmath107 accordingly ) , with the coefficients @xmath108 being given in eqs . ( [ a15 ] ) and ( [ a16 ] ) in the appendix . the input - output relations ( [ 35 ] ) in the @xmath110-space can be transformed , according to eq . ( [ 15 ] ) , into the @xmath109-space in a straightforward manner . writing the electric - field operator at the boundaries of the plate as @xmath111 & = & \hat{\bf{e}}_{q\,{\rm in } } ^{(0 ) } ( { \bm \rho } , \omega ) + \hat{\bf{e}}_{q\,{\rm out } } ^{(0 ) } ( { \bm \rho } , \omega ) , \\[1ex ] \nonumber\\ \label{48 } \hat{\bf e } ^{(n)}({\bm \rho } , \omega ) & = & \left.\hat{\bf e } ^{(n)}(z , { \bm \rho } , \omega ) \right|_{z=0^+ } \nonumber\\*[1ex ] & = & \ \hat{\bf{e}}_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(n)}({\bm \rho } , \omega ) + \hat{\bf{e}}_{q\,{\rm out}}^{(n ) } ( { \bm \rho } , \omega ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] we derive @xmath112&&\hspace{10ex } + \sum _ { j=1 } ^{n-1 } \int { \mbox{\rm d}}^2 { \rho}'\ , \left\lbrace { \mbox{\boldmath $ \phi$ } } _ { 0 + } ^{(j ) } ( { \bm \rho } , { \bm \rho ' } , \omega)\cdot \hat{\bf e } _ { + } ^{(j)}({\bm \rho ' } , \omega ) + { \mbox{\boldmath $ \phi$ } } _ { 0- } ^{(j ) } ( { \bm \rho } , { \bm \rho ' } , \omega)\cdot \hat{\bf e } _ { - } ^{(j)}({\bm \rho ' } , \omega ) \right\rbrace , \\[1ex ] \label{50 } \lefteqn { \hat{\bf e } _ { { \rm out } } ^{(n)}({\bm \rho } , \omega ) = \int { \mbox{\rm d}}^2 { \rho}'\ , { \mbox{\boldmath $ r$}}_{n/0 } ( { \bm \rho } , { \bm \rho ' } , \omega)\cdot \hat{\bf e } _ { { \rm in } } ^{(n)}({\bm \rho ' } , \omega ) + \int { \mbox{\rm d}}^2 { \rho}'\ , { \mbox{\boldmath $ t$}}_{0/n } ( { \bm \rho } , { \bm \rho ' } , \omega)\cdot \hat{\bf e } _ { { \rm in } } ^{(0)}({\bm \rho ' } , \omega ) } \nonumber\\[1ex]&&\hspace{10ex } + \sum _ { j=1 } ^{n-1 } \int { \mbox{\rm d}}^2 { \rho}'\ , \left\lbrace { \mbox{\boldmath $ \phi$ } } _ { n+ } ^{(j ) } ( { \bm \rho } , { \bm \rho ' } , \omega)\cdot \hat{\bf e } _ { + } ^{(j)}({\bm \rho ' } , \omega ) + { \mbox{\boldmath $ \phi$ } } _ { n- } ^{(j ) } ( { \bm \rho } , { \bm \rho ' } , \omega)\cdot \hat{\bf e } _ { - } ^{(j)}({\bm \rho ' } , \omega ) \right\rbrace,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the electric - field operators @xmath113 and @xmath114 are respectively related to the amplitude operators @xmath115 and @xmath116 as @xmath117 \label{52 } \hat{\bf e } _ { { \rm in } } ^{(n)}({\bm \rho } , \omega ) \!=\ ! \frac { 1 } { ( 2 \pi ) ^2}\!\int \!{\mbox{\rm d}}^2 { k}\sum _ { q = p , s}\ ! { \bf e}^{(n)}_{q- } ( { \bf k } ) \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) e^{i{\bf k } { \bm { \rho } } } \ ! , \quad \\[1ex ] \label{53 } \hat{\bf e } _ { { \rm \pm } } ^{(j)}({\bm \rho } , \omega ) \!=\ ! \frac { 1 } { ( 2 \pi ) ^2}\!\int \!{\mbox{\rm d}}^2 { k}\sum _ { q = p , s}\ ! { \bf e}^{(j)}_{q\pm } ( { \bf k } ) \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm \pm}}^{(j ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) e^{i{\bf k } { \bm { \rho } } } \!. \quad \;\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the above , the tensor - valued reflection and transmission integral kernels , respectively , read as @xmath118 \label{55 } \lefteqn { { \bf r}_{n/0 } ( { \bm \rho } , { \bm \rho ' } , \omega ) } \nonumber \\ & & = \frac { 1 } { ( 2 \pi)^2}\int { \mbox{\rm d}}^2 { k}\sum _ { q = p , s } { \bf{e}}^{(n)}_{q+ } ( { \bf k } ) r^q _ { n/0}{\bf{e}}^{(n)}_{q- } ( { \bf k } ) e^{i{\bf k } ( { \bm \rho}-{\bm \rho'})}\qquad \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath119 \label{57 } \lefteqn { { \bf t}_{n/0 } ( { \bm \rho } , { \bm \rho ' } , \omega ) } \nonumber \\ & & = \frac { 1 } { ( 2 \pi)^2}\int { \mbox{\rm d}}^2 { k } \sum _ { q = p , s } { \bf{e}}^{(0)}_{q- } ( { \bf k } ) t^q _ { n/0}{\bf{e}}^{(n)}_{q-}({\bf k } ) e^{i{\bf k } ( { \bm \rho}-{\bm \rho'})},\qquad\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the integral kernels that relate the outgoing fields to the intraplate fields are given by @xmath120 \lefteqn { \label{59 } { \bf \phi}_{n\pm } ( { \bm \rho } , { \bm \rho ' } , \omega ) } \nonumber \\ & & = \frac { 1 } { ( 2 \pi)^2}\int { \mbox{\rm d}}^2 { k } \sum _ { q = p , s } { \bf e}^{(j)}_{q+ } ( { \bf k } ) \phi^{(j ) } _ { q\ , n \pm } { \bf e}^{(j)}_{q\pm}({\bf k } ) e^{i{\bf k } ( { \bm \rho}-{\bm \rho'})}.\qquad\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the integral kernels depend only on the difference , because of the translational symmetry in the @xmath121- and @xmath122-directions . the input - output relations in the form of eqs . ( [ 49 ] ) , ( [ 50 ] ) can be considered as a special realization of the general relations given for a dielectric scattering region of arbitrary shape in ref . @xcite . in many applications it may be advantageously to express the incoming and the outgoing field operators in terms of appropriately chosen bosonic operators . recalling the basic commutation relations ( [ 4 ] ) and ( [ 5 ] ) and the orthogonality of polarization unit vectors as given by eqs . ( [ 27 ] ) and ( [ 28 ] ) , from eqs . ( [ 31 ] ) and ( [ 32 ] ) together with eq . ( [ 17 ] ) and ( [ 18 ] ) and eqs . ( [ 36 ] ) and ( [ 37 ] ) we find that the input amplitude operators satisfy the commutation relations @xmath123 } \nonumber \\[1ex ] & & \,=\ , c_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(0,n)}({\bf k},\omega)\ , \delta_{qq'}\delta(\omega-\omega')\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k}'),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath124 \label{62 } c_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(n ) } = \frac{\pi \hbar}{\epsilon_0 } \left(\frac{\omega}{c}\right)^2 \frac{\beta_{n}'}{|\beta_{n}|^2 } \,{\bf e}^{(n)}_{q- } ( { \bf k } ) \cdot{\bf e}^{(n)*}_{q- } ( { \bf k } ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly , the output amplitude operators and the intraplate amplitude operators can be shown to satisfy commutation relations of the same type , i.e. , @xmath125 } \nonumber \\[1ex ] & & = \ , c_{q\,{\rm out}}^{(0,n)}({\bf k},\omega)\ , \delta_{qq'}\delta(\omega-\omega')\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k } ' ) , \\[1ex ] \label{64 } \lefteqn { \left[\hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\lambda}^{(j ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) , \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q'\lambda'}^{(j)\dagger } ( { \bf k } ' , \omega')\right ] } \nonumber \\[1ex ] & & = \,c_{q\lambda\lambda'}^{(j)}({\bf k},\omega)\ , \delta_{qq'}\delta(\omega-\omega')\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k}')\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ for the coefficients @xmath126 and @xmath108 , respectively , see eqs . ( [ a12 ] ) , ( [ a13 ] ) and eqs . ( [ a15 ] ) , ( [ a16 ] ) in the appendix ] . needless to say that input amplitude operators , that refer to different sides of the plate , commute , input amplitude operators and intraplate amplitude operators commute , and intraplate amplitude operators that refer to different layers also commute . note that output amplitude operators that refer to different sides of the plate do not commute in general [ see eqs . ( [ a9 ] ) and ( [ a10 ] ) in the appendix ] , which is similar as in the one - dimensional situation ( cf . @xcite ) . from eqs . ( [ 60 ] ) and ( [ 63 ] ) it is seen that bosonic input and output operators can be introduced according to @xmath127 thus @xmath128 } \nonumber \\[1ex]&&\hspace{6ex } = \ , \delta_{qq'}\delta(\omega-\omega')\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k } ' ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] since for in eq . ( [ 64 ] ) is valid in general , it is useful to introduce intraplate bosonic operators according to the superposition @xmath129 and choosing the coefficients @xmath130 [ eqs . ( [ a20 ] ) and ( [ a21 ] ) in the appendix ] in such a way that @xmath131 } \nonumber\\&&\hspace{6ex } = \,\delta_{\lambda\lambda'}\delta_{qq ' } \delta ( \omega -\omega ' ) \delta({\bf k } - { \bf k ' } ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting eqs . ( [ 65 ] ) and ( [ 67 ] ) into eq . ( [ 35 ] ) , we may express the input - output relations in the @xmath0-space in terms of bosonic operators , @xmath132 \hat{a}_{q\,{\rm out}}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) \end{array } \right ) = \left ( \begin{array}{cc } \tilde{r}^q_{0/n}({\bf k},\omega ) & \tilde{t}_{n/0 } ^q({\bf k},\omega)\\[1ex ] \tilde{t}_{0/n } ^q({\bf k},\omega ) & \tilde{r } ^q _ { n/0}({\bf k},\omega ) \end{array } \right ) \left ( \begin{array}{c } \hat{a}_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(0 ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) \\[1ex ] \hat{a}_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) \end{array } \right ) + \sum _ { j = 1 } ^{n-1 } \left ( \begin{array}{cc } \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , 0 + } ^{(j)}({\bf k},\omega ) & \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , 0- } ^{(j)}({\bf k},\omega ) \\[1ex ] \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , n+ } ^{(j)}({\bf k},\omega ) & \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , n- } ^{(j)}({\bf k},\omega ) \end{array } \right ) \left ( \begin{array}{c } \hat { a}_{q+}^{(j ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega)\\[1ex ] \hat { a}_{q-}^{(j ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) \end{array } \right)\!,\quad \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the coefficients [ modified in comparison with eq . ( [ 35 ] ) ] read @xmath133 \label{71 } \tilde{t } ^q _ { 0/n } = \sqrt { \frac{c_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(0 ) } } { c_{q\,{\rm out}}^{(n ) } } } \,t ^q _ { n/0 } \ , , \qquad \tilde{r}_{n/0}^q = \sqrt { \frac{c_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(n ) } } { c_{q\,{\rm out}}^{(n ) } } } \,r_{n/0 } ^q \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath134 note that for ( i.e. , perpendicular incidence of light on the plate ) , the input and output relations ( [ 69 ] ) exactly agree with previous results @xcite obtained within a one - dimensional treatment . let us turn to the limiting case that the space outside the plate except for possible active atomic sources may be regarded as being vacuum , i.e. , @xmath135 @xmath136 \sqrt{\omega^2/c^2 - k^2 } & \omega / c > k. \end{array } \right.\ ] ] for the propagating - field components observed for , the coefficients @xmath137 and @xmath138 , respectively , read @xmath139 and @xmath140 as it can be seen from eqs . ( [ 61 ] ) and ( [ 62 ] ) and eqs . ( [ a23 ] ) and ( [ a24 ] ) in the appendix . hence , bosonic input and output operators can be defined according to eq . ( [ 65 ] ) . moreover , the output amplitude operators that refer to different sides of the plate commute [ eq . ( [ a22 ] ) in the appendix ] , which implies that the associated bosonic operators commute as well . making use of eqs . ( [ 75 ] ) and ( [ 76 ] ) , we see that the modified reflection and transmission coefficients ( [ 70 ] ) and ( [ 71 ] ) , respectively , become identical with the original ones . for , eq . ( [ 69 ] ) thus reduces to @xmath141 \hat{a}_{q\,{\rm out}}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) \end{array } \right ) = \biggl ( \begin{array}{cc } r^q_{0/n}({\bf k } , \omega ) & t_{n/0 } ^q({\bf k } , \omega)\\[1ex ] t_{0/n } ^q({\bf k } , \omega ) & r ^q _ { n/0}({\bf k } , \omega ) \end{array } \biggr ) \left ( \begin{array}{c } \hat{a}_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(0 ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) \\[1ex ] \hat{a}_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) \end{array } \right ) + \sum _ { j = 1 } ^{n-1 } \left ( \begin{array}{cc } \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , 0 + } ^{(j)}({\bf k } , \omega ) & \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , 0- } ^{(j)}({\bf k } , \omega ) \\[1ex ] \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , n+ } ^{(j)}({\bf k } , \omega ) & \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , n- } ^{(j)}({\bf k } , \omega ) \end{array } \right ) \left ( \begin{array}{c } \hat { a}_{q+}^{(j ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega)\\[1ex ] \hat { a}_{q-}^{(j ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) \end{array } \right),\quad \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the transformation matrix connecting the bosonic output operators with the bosonic input operators is exactly the same as that for the corresponding amplitude operators in eq . ( [ 35 ] ) , and the matrix equation @xmath142 t_{0/n } ^q & r ^q _ { n/0 } \end{array } \right ) \left ( \begin{array}{cc } r^{q\ast}_{0/n } & t_{0/n } ^{q\ast}\\[1ex ] t_{n/0 } ^{q\ast } & r ^{q\ast } _ { n/0 } \end{array } \right ) + \sum _ { j = 1 } ^{n-1 } \left ( \begin{array}{cc } \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , 0 + } ^{(j ) } & \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , 0- } ^{(j ) } \\[1ex ] \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , n+ } ^{(j ) } & \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , n- } ^{(j ) } \end{array } \right ) \left ( \begin{array}{cc } \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , 0 + } ^{(j)\ast } & \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , n+ } ^{(j)\ast } \\[1ex ] \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , 0- } ^{(j)\ast } & \tilde{\phi } _ { q\ , n- } ^{(j)\ast } \end{array } \right ) = \left ( \begin{array}{cc } 1 & 0 \\[1ex ] 0 & 1 \end{array } \right ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] is valid . in this case , the field operators @xmath143 and @xmath144 at the boundaries of the multilayer plate [ see eqs . ( [ 29 ] ) , ( [ 30 ] ) , ( [ 36 ] ) , and ( [ 37 ] ) ] can be represented as @xmath145 , \label{79}\\[1ex ] { \bf \hat{e } } ^{(n)}(0^+,{\bf k } , \omega ) = -\frac { \omega } { c } \sqrt{\frac { \pi \hbar } { \beta _ n\epsilon _ 0 } } \sum _ { q = p , s}\ , \left [ { \bf{e}}_{q-}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } ) \hat{a}_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) + { \bf{e}}_{q+}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } ) \hat{a}_{q\,{\rm out}}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega)\right ] \label{80}\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( @xmath146 @xmath60 @xmath147 @xmath60 @xmath148 , @xmath149 @xmath150 @xmath151 ) . note that in eqs . ( [ 79 ] ) and ( [ 80 ] ) is nothing said about the location of the active light sources . clearly , if there are no active light sources outside the plate , then @xmath143 and @xmath144 evolve effectively freely there [ cf . ( [ 33 ] ) and ( [ 34 ] ) ] . for the evanescent - field components observed for , the coefficients @xmath152 [ eq . ( [ 61 ] ) ] and @xmath153 [ eq . ( [ 62 ] ) ] identically vanish , because of @xmath154 @xmath60 @xmath155 @xmath60 @xmath156 . recalling eq . ( [ 65 ] ) , we see that bosonic input operators can not be introduced for the evanescent - field components . hence , it is impossible to extend the validity of eq . ( [ 77 ] ) to the evanescent - field components . to treat them , one has therefore to go back to the generally valid input - output relations ( [ 35 ] ) for the amplitude operators . clearly , when there are no active light sources at any finite distance from the plate , then the input field can be regarded as being effectively a propagating field [ see eqs . ( [ 31 ] ) and ( [ 32 ] ) ] , that is to say , a field that does not contain evanescent input components . however , the output field may contain evanescent output components resulting from the intraplate field . applying the green - tensor formalism of the quantization of the electromagnetic field in the presence of inhomogeneous , causal , linear dielectric bodies , we have derived the most general three - dimensional quantum input - output relations for the electromagnetic - field operators at an arbitrary multilayer dielectric plate , and we have given the commutation relations needed . taking into account ( i ) dispersion and absorption of the plate and the surrounding medium , ( ii ) possible active light sources inside and/or outside the plate , and ( iii ) both propagating - field components and evanescent - field components , the input - output relations connect the output field operators at the boundaries of the plate with the input field operators at the boundaries of the plate and the fields inside the layers of the plate . the outgoing fields outside the plate can then be obtained from the ones at the boundaries of the plate via quantum langevin equations , with the langevin noise sources being determined by the active and passive light sources in the respective half - space outside the plate . we have given the input - output relations in terms of both algebraic relations for amplitude operators in the @xmath0-space and integral relations for field operators in the coordinate space . further , we have shown that in the @xmath0-space it is possible , provided that the incoming fields contain effectively propagating components , to rewrite the input - output relations in order to obtain them in terms of relations between bosonic operators instead of amplitude operators . therefore the input - output relations for the amplitude operators are more general than those for the bosonic operators . finally , we have studied the limiting case of the plate being surrounded by vacuum . in this case , the input - output relations in terms of bosonic operators only apply to the propagating - field components , for which is valid . an application to the evanescent - field components would run into contradictions . to treat them , one has therefore to go back to the amplitude operators . the derived input - output relations generalize previous results obtained from a one - dimensional calculation @xcite ) . in the special case of a plate that is embedded in vacuum , without active light sources at any finite distance from the plate ( and without active light inside the plate ) , they reduce to those given in ref . @xcite , if evanescent - field components are disregarded . in conclusion , the derived input - output relations are suited for studying the quantum statistical properties of electromagnetic fields in the presence of planar multilayered structures ( such as cavity - like systems or photonic crystals ) , with special emphasis on absorption - assisted quantum decoherence , including evanescent - field effects . we would like to thank ho trung dung and c. raabe for useful discussions . let us begin with the calculation of the commutators of the output amplitude operators @xmath157 . from eq . ( [ 35 ] ) it follows that @xmath158&&\hspace{6ex } + \,t_{n/0}^q \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) + \hat{\mathrm{f}}_{q}^{(0)}({\bf k } , \omega ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath159&&\hspace{6ex } + \ , r_{n/0}^q \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) + \hat{\mathrm{f}}_{q}^{(n)}({\bf k } , \omega ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath160 \\ & = i \omega \mu _ 0 { \bf e}^{(0)}_{q-}({\bf k } ) \cdot\sum _ { j=1}^{n-1 } \int _ { [ j ] } { \mbox{\rm d}}z\ , { \mbox{\boldmath $ g$}}^{(0j)}(0 , z , { \bf k } , \omega)\cdot \hat { \bf j}^{(j ) } ( z , { \bf k } , \omega ) , \end{split}\ ] ] @xmath161\\ & = i \omega \mu _ 0 \,{\bf e}^{(n)}_{q+}({\bf k } ) \cdot\sum _ { j=1}^{n-1 } \int _ { [ j ] } { \mbox{\rm d}}z\ , { \mbox{\boldmath $ g$}}^{(nj)}(0 , z , { \bf k } , \omega)\cdot \hat { \bf j}^{(j ) } ( z , { \bf k } , \omega ) . \end{split}\ ] ] hence , the ( relevant ) commutators of the output amplitude operators that refer to different sides of the plate can be given by @xmath162 } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & = \,r^q_{0/n } t_{0/n } ^{q\ , * } \left [ \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm in } } ^{(0 ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) , \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q'\,{\rm in } } ^{(0)\dagger } ( { \bf k } ' , \omega ' ) \right ] + t_{n/0 } ^q r^{q\,*}_{n/0 } \left [ \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q\,{\rm in } } ^{(n ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) , \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q'\,{\rm in } } ^{(n)\dagger } ( { \bf k } ' , \omega ' ) \right ] + \left [ \hat{\mathrm{f}}_{q } ^{(0 ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) , \hat{\mathrm{f}}_{q ' } ^{(n)\dagger } ( { \bf k } ' , \omega ' ) \right ] \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & = \,\delta_{qq'}\ , \delta(\omega-\omega')\,\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k}')\ , \left ( c_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(0 ) } r^q_{0/n } t_{0/n } ^{q\ , * } + c_{q\,{\rm in}}^{(n ) } t_{n/0 } ^q r^{q\,*}_{n/0 } \right ) + \left [ \hat{\mathrm{f}}_{q } ^{(0 ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) , \hat{\mathrm{f}}_{q ' } ^{(n)\dagger } ( { \bf k } ' , \omega ' ) \right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where eqs . ( [ 60 ] ) ( [ 62 ] ) have been used . making use of eqs . ( [ 17 ] ) and ( [ 18 ] ) and recalling the basic commutation relations ( [ 4 ] ) and ( [ 5 ] ) , we derive @xmath163 } \nonumber\\*[1ex ] & & = \,\delta_{qq'}\,\delta(\omega-\omega')\ , \delta({\bf k}-{\bf k}')\ , \frac{4\pi \hbar}{\epsilon _ 0}\left(\frac { \omega}{c}\right ) ^2 \ , e^{(0)}_{q-\ , \mu } ( { \bf k } ) \ , e^{(n)\ , * } _ { q+\ , \mu ' } ( { \bf k } ) \sum_{j=1}^{n-1}\,\int_{[j ] } { \mbox{\rm d}}z\ , g^{(0j)}_{\mu\nu}(0 , z , { \bf k } , \omega ) \ , \frac { \omega ^2 } { c^2 } \varepsilon_{j}''\ , g^{(nj)*}_{\mu'\nu}(0 , z , { \bf k } , \omega ) \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & = \ , \delta_{qq'}\,\delta(\omega-\omega')\ , \delta({\bf k}-{\bf k}')\ , \frac{4\pi \hbar}{\epsilon _ 0}\left(\frac { \omega}{c}\right ) ^2 \ , e^{(0)}_{q-\ , \mu } ( { \bf k } ) \ , e^{(n)\ , * } _ { q+\ , \mu ' } ( { \bf k } ) \ , \biggl\lbrace \sum_{j=0}^{n}\,\int_{[j ] } { \mbox{\rm d}}z\ , g^{(0j)}_{\mu\nu}(0 , z , { \bf k } , \omega ) \ , \frac { \omega ^2 } { c^2 } \varepsilon_{j}''\ , g^{(nj)*}_{\mu'\nu}(0 , z , { \bf k } , \omega ) \biggr . \nonumber\\[1ex]&&\qquad \biggl . - \int_{-\infty}^{0 } { \mbox{\rm d}}z\ , g^{(00)}_{\mu\nu}(0 , z , { \bf k } , \omega ) \ , \frac { \omega ^2 } { c^2 } \varepsilon_{0}''\ , g^{(n0)*}_{\mu'\nu}(0 , z , { \bf k } , \omega ) - \int^{\infty}_{0 } { \mbox{\rm d}}z\ , g^{(0n)}_{\mu\nu}(0 , z , { \bf k } , \omega ) \ , \frac { \omega ^2 } { c^2 } \varepsilon_{n}''\ , g^{(nn)*}_{\mu'\nu}(0 , z , { \bf k } , \omega ) \biggr\rbrace.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is not difficult to calculate the last two integrals in eq . ( [ a6 ] ) , by using the explicit expression ( [ 20 ] ) for @xmath164 . to calculate the sum of integrals @xmath165 } { \mbox{\rm d}}z\,\ldots$ ] , we employ the integral relation ( [ 11 ] ) for the classical green tensor @xmath166 , rewritten in terms of @xmath167 , @xmath168 } { \mbox{\rm d}}z''\ , g^{(jj'')}_{\mu\nu}(z , z '' , { \bf k } , \omega ) \ , \frac { \omega ^2 } { c^2 } \varepsilon_{j''}''\ , g^{(j'j'')*}_{\mu'\nu}(z ' , z '' , { \bf k } , \omega ) = \frac{1}{2i } g^{(jj')}_{\mu\mu'}(z , z ' , { \bf k } , \omega ) } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & -\,\frac{1}{2i } g^{(j'j)*}_{\mu'\mu}(z ' , z , { \bf k } , \omega ) + g^{(jj')}_{\mu\nu}(z , z ' , { \bf k } , \omega ) e_{z\,\nu } \,\frac{\varepsilon_{j'}''}{\varepsilon_{j'}^*}\,e_{z\ , \mu ' } + e_{z\,\mu } \ , \frac{\varepsilon_{j}''}{\varepsilon_{j}}\ , g^{(j'j)*}_{\mu'\nu}(z ' , z , { \bf k } , \omega ) e_{z\,\nu } \ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] after lengthy , but straightforward calculations we then derive , on using eqs . ( [ 61 ] ) and ( [ 62 ] ) , @xmath169 } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & = \left [ \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{p\,{\rm out } } ^{(0 ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) , \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{s\,{\rm out } } ^{(n)\dagger } ( { \bf k } ' , \omega ' ) \right]=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath170 = \delta(\omega-\omega')\,\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k } ' ) } \qquad \nonumber\\[1ex]&&\times\ ; \frac{\pi \hbar}{\epsilon _ 0}\left(\frac { \omega}{c}\right)^2 \left ( \frac{i \beta_0 ' ' } { { |\beta _ 0 |}^2 } t^{s\,*}_{0/n}- \frac { i \beta _ n''}{{|\beta _ n |}^2 } t_{n/0}^{s}\right ) , \qquad\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath171= \frac{\pi \hbar}{\epsilon _ 0}\left(\frac { \omega}{c}\right ) ^2 \left\ { \frac { t_{n/0 } ^p}{\beta _ n { |k_n| } ^2 } \left(k^2\frac{k_n ^2}{k_n^{*\,2 } } - { |\beta _ n |}^2 \right ) \right . } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & \left . + \,\frac { t_{0/n } ^{p\ , * } } { \beta _ 0 ^ * { |k_0| } ^2 } \left(k^2\frac{k_0^{*\,2}}{k_0 ^2 } - { |\beta _ 0 |}^2 \right ) - \frac{\beta_n'}{{|\beta_n|}^2}\,t^{p}_{n/0 } \left[{\bf e}^{(n)}_{p- } ( { \bf k } ) \cdot{\bf e}^{(n)*}_{p- } ( { \bf k } ) \right ] \left[{\bf e}^{(n)*}_{p- } ( { \bf k})\cdot\,{\bf e}^{(n)*}_{p+ } ( { \bf k } ) \right ] \right . \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & -\ , \frac{\beta_0'}{{|\beta_0|}^2}\,t^{q*}_{0/n}\ , \left[{\bf e}^{(0)*}_{q+ } ( { \bf k } ) \cdot{\bf e}^{(0)}_{q+ } ( { \bf k } ) \right ] \left[{\bf e}^{(0)}_{q+ } ( { \bf k } ) \cdot{\bf e}^{(0)}_{q- } ( { \bf k } ) \right ] \biggr\}\ , \delta(\omega-\omega')\,\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k}')\ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] next , let us consider the commutators of the output amplitude operators that refer to the same sides of the plate . performing the same steps as before , we now arrive at @xmath172 } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & = \left [ \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{p\,{\rm out } } ^{(0 ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) , \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{s\,{\rm out } } ^{(0)\dagger } ( { \bf k } ' , \omega ' ) \right ] = 0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath173 = \delta(\omega-\omega')\,\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k } ' ) } \qquad \nonumber\\[1ex]&&\times\ ; \frac{\pi \hbar}{\epsilon _ 0}\left(\frac { \omega}{c}\right ) ^2 \left ( \frac{\beta_0 ' } { { |\beta _ 0 |}^2 } + \frac { 2 \beta _ 0''}{{|\beta _ 0 |}^2 } r_{0/n}^{s\,\prime \prime}\right ) , \qquad\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath174= \frac{\pi \hbar}{\epsilon _ 0}\left(\frac{\omega}{c}\right ) ^2 \left\ { \frac { r_{0/n } ^p}{\beta _ 0 { |k_0| } ^2 } \left(k^2\frac{k_0 ^2}{k_0^{*\,2 } } - { |\beta _ 0 |}^2 \right ) \right . } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & \left . + \,\frac { r_{0/n } ^{p\ , * } } { \beta _ 0 ^ * { |k_0| } ^2 } \left(k^2\frac{k_0^{*\,2}}{k_0 ^2 } - { |\beta _ 0 |}^2 \right ) - \frac { k ^2 } { { |k_0| } ^2}\left(\frac{\beta _ 0}{k_0^{*\,2}}+ \frac{\beta _ 0 ^*}{k_0^{2 } } \right ) + \frac { 2 \beta _ 0 ' } { { |k_0| } ^2}\left ( \frac { k ^4 } { { |\beta_0| } ^2 { |k_0| } ^2 } + 1 \right ) \right . \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & + \,\frac{\beta_0 ' } { { |\beta _ 0 |}^2 } \left [ { \bf e}^{(0)}_{p+ } ( { \bf k } ) \cdot{\bf e}^{(0)*}_{p+ } ( { \bf k } ) \right ] \left [ \left| r_{0/n}^q\right|^2 - \left|{\bf e}^{(0)}_{p- } ( { \bf k } ) \cdot { \bf e}^{(0)}_{p+ } ( { \bf k } ) + r_{0/n } ^p\right| ^2 \right ] \biggr\}\ , \delta(\omega-\omega')\,\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k}').\end{aligned}\ ] ] the commutators @xmath175 $ ] are obtained from eqs . ( [ a11 ] ) ( [ a13 ] ) , by making the replacements @xmath146 @xmath176 @xmath147 , @xmath177 @xmath176 @xmath178 , @xmath179 @xmath176 @xmath180 , and @xmath181 @xmath176 @xmath182 . finally , it can easily be proved that the intraplate amplitude operators ( [ 38 ] ) satisfy the commutation relations (; ) @xmath183 } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & = c_{q\lambda\lambda'}^{(j)}({\bf k},\omega)\ , \delta_{qq'}\,\delta(\omega-\omega')\,\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k}'),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath184 & & \times\ ; \left ( e^{\pm 2\beta _ j '' d_j } - 1 \right ) { \bf e}^{(j)}_{q \pm } ( { \bf k } ) \cdot{\bf e}^{(j)*}_{q\pm } ( { \bf k } ) , \\[1ex ] \label{a16 } \lefteqn { c_{q\,{\rm \pm \mp } } ^{(j ) } = \pm i\frac{\pi \hbar}{\epsilon_0 } \left(\frac{\omega}{c}\right)^2 \frac{\beta_{j}''}{|\beta_{j}|^2 } } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & \times\ ; \left ( e^{\mp 2i \beta _ j ' d_j } - 1 \right ) { \bf e}^{(j)}_{q \pm } ( { \bf k } ) \cdot{\bf e}^{(j)*}_{q\mp } ( { \bf k}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] using eqs . ( [ a14 ] ) ( [ a16 ] ) , we find that the operators @xmath185&&\times\ ; \left [ e^{i \beta_{j } d_{j } } \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q+}^{(j ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) \pm \hat{\mathrm{e}}_{q-}^{(j ) } ( { \bf k } , \omega ) \right ] , \label{a17}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath186&&\,\times\ ; \left\ { \beta _ j ' \sinh(\beta_j ' ' d_j)\ , { \bf{e}}^{(j)}_{q+}({\bf k } ) \cdot { \bf{e}}^{(j)\,*}_{q+}({\bf k } ) \right . \nonumber\\[1ex]&&\hspace{2ex } \left . \pm\ , \beta _ j '' \sin(\beta_j ' d_j)\ , { \bf{e}}^{(j)}_{q+}({\bf k } ) \cdot { \bf{e}}^{(j)\,*}_{q-}({\bf k } ) \right\ } ^{1/2}\!\qquad\end{aligned}\ ] ] satisfy bosonic commutation relations . from eq . ( [ a17 ] ) it then follows that @xmath187 where @xmath188 \label{a21 } & & \tau_{q - \pm}^{(j ) } = \pm { \textstyle\frac { 1 } { 2 } } \xi^{(j)}_{q \pm}({\bf k } , \omega).\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the limiting case ( when the plate is surrounded by vacuum ) one has to distinguish between ( propagating - field components ) and ( evanescent - field components ) . in the first case we have , so that eqs . ( [ a8 ] ) ( [ a10 ] ) reduce to @xmath189 = 0,\ ] ] and eqs . ( [ a11 ] ) ( [ a13 ] ) simplify to @xmath190 } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & = \,\frac{\pi \hbar}{\epsilon_0}\left(\frac{\omega}{c}\right)^2 \frac{1}{\beta_0}\,\delta_{qq'}\,\delta(\omega-\omega')\ , \delta({\bf k}-{\bf k}').\qquad \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath191 } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & = \,\frac{\pi \hbar}{\epsilon_0}\left(\frac{\omega}{c}\right)^2 \frac{1}{\beta_n}\,\delta_{qq'}\ , \delta(\omega-\omega')\,\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k}').\qquad \end{aligned}\ ] ] in the second case we have . equations ( [ a8 ] ) ( [ a10 ] ) then lead to @xmath192 } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & = \,\frac{\pi \hbar}{\epsilon_0 } \left(\frac{\omega}{c}\right)^2 \frac{2 t^{q\ , \prime \prime}_{0/n}}{{|\beta_0| } } \,\delta_{qq'}\ , \delta(\omega-\omega')\,\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k } ' ) , \qquad\end{aligned}\ ] ] and from eqs . ( [ a11 ] ) ( [ a13 ] ) we find @xmath193 } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & = \,\frac{\pi \hbar}{\epsilon_0 } \left(\frac{\omega}{c}\right)^2 \frac{2 r_{0/n}^{q\,\prime \prime}}{{|\beta_0|}}\ , \delta_{qq'}\,\delta(\omega-\omega')\,\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k } ' ) , \qquad\end{aligned}\ ] ] and similarly @xmath194 } \nonumber\\[1ex ] & & = \,\frac{\pi \hbar}{\epsilon_0 } \left(\frac{\omega}{c}\right)^2 \frac{2 r_{n/0}^{q\,\prime \prime}}{{|\beta_n|}}\ , \delta_{qq'}\,\delta(\omega-\omega')\,\delta({\bf k}-{\bf k } ' ) . \qquad\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the commutation relations ( 42 ) in ref . @xcite for the bosonic output operators are only valid for propagating waves , not for evanescent ones . it should also be noted that the free - space light modes @xmath195 used in ref . @xcite are introduced by explicitly requiring that , where @xmath196 corresponds to @xmath0 in the present paper . hence , these modes solely represent propagating waves .

by using the green - function concept of quantization of the electromagnetic field in dispersing and absorbing media , the quantized field in the presence of a dispersing and absorbing dielectric multilayer plate is studied . three - dimensional input - output relations are derived for both amplitude operators in the @xmath0-space and the field operators in the coordinate space . the conditions are discussed , under which the input - output relations can be expressed in terms of bosonic operators . the theory applies to both ( effectively ) free fields and fields , created by active atomic sources inside and/or outside the plate , including also evanescent - field components .

astro-ph0603107

the rapid time variabilities and the compactness problem ( see , e.g. , a review by piran @xcite ) suggest that gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) should arise from internal shocks within relativistic flows . in the standard model , a strong magnetic field is generated , and electrons are fermi - accelerated in shocked regions . the physical conditions in the shocked region imply @xcite that protons may be also fermi - accelerated to energies @xmath0 ev . high - energy protons in the grb photon field can create high - energy neutrinos via photopion production @xcite . future observations of neutrinos will be important to prove the standard model of grbs and the particle acceleration theory . the highest energy of neutrinos brings us information on physical conditions of grbs . recently , @xcite have shown that the kaon contribution becomes important for neutrino production from jets in supernovae . they considered mildly relativistic jets that are much more baryon - rich than a fireball of grbs where collisions among accelerated protons ( @xmath1 ) occur efficiently @xcite , making pions and kaons that decay into neutrinos . since high - energy charged mesons will cool down before they decay into neutrinos , the highest energy of neutrinos is determined by the equilibrium of the cooling timescale and the decay timescale of mesons . considering synchrotron cooling , the highest energy of mesons that decay into neutrinos is proportional to @xmath2 , where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are the mass and the lifetime of mesons at rest , respectively . so , @xcite pointed out that the heavier mass of kaons than pions leads to dominance of neutrinos from kaon decay in the highest energy region . we note that the contribution of kaons for neutrino production may also be important even in internal shocks of grbs . in this study , we calculate the spectrum of neutrinos from grbs , taking account of decaying modes of charged kaons into neutrinos . also , we consider the contribution of long - lived neutral kaons , @xmath5 , for neutrino production , which was not taken into account in the previous work . it is noted that @xmath5 does not cool at all before decay into neutrinos and has some decaying modes into charged pions and neutrinos . so , it is expected that the highest energy of neutrinos comes from the decay of long - lived neutral kaons . in this letter , using the monte carlo method , we show that the highest energy neutrinos mainly come from kaons even in internal shocks of grbs . in 2 , we explain our model and method . the numerical results are in 3 . 4 is devoted to discussion . our method of simulation is essentially the same as in @xcite but quantitatively improved . in this study , we adopt experimental results for the cross sections of @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , and @xmath9 @xcite for @xmath10 gev , where @xmath11 is the photon energy in the proton rest frame . we neglect the reaction @xmath12 , because the cross section is too small and the neutrino production rate is independent of this reaction . since we do not have experimental data of multi - pion production for @xmath13 gev , we extrapolate the cross section by a constant value . however , our total photoabsorption cross section agrees well with the experimental value for @xmath14 gev @xcite . for the pion production by @xmath15 , we adopt the same cross sections as @xmath16 . kaons are produced via @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath19 , or @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 . since there are no detailed and precise data of kaon production experiments , we adopt values theoretically obtained for the cross sections of kaon production from @xmath16 and @xmath15 @xcite . as shown in figure 1 , the contribution of kaon production seems negligible . however , the importance of kaon production will be shown later . of course , @xmath1 collisions may also create mesons . since the number of target photons is much larger than the proton number density in our case , we neglect the effects of @xmath1 collisions . the inelasticity is approximated by a conventional method as @xmath23/2 $ ] , where @xmath24 is the invariance of the square of the total four - momentum of the @xmath16 ( @xmath15 ) system , and @xmath25 is the proton mass . for the double - pion production , we approximate the inelasticity by replacing @xmath3 with @xmath26 . our parameter set is similar to that in @xcite : the total photon energy in a burst @xmath27 , the number of light - curve pulses ( or spikes ) @xmath28 , the lorentz factor of the shells @xmath29 , and shell - collide distances from the central engine @xmath30 . the number @xmath28 corresponds to the number of shells that emit gamma rays . the photon energy deposited into each shell is therefore @xmath31 . in the standard model , shells can collide and emit gamma rays at distances @xmath30 larger than @xmath32 cm from the central sources , where @xmath33 is the time between shell ejection events . for simplification , @xmath30 and @xmath29 are common for all @xmath28 shells in this simulation . the photon number spectrum in the energy range @xmath34 in the shell rest frame is set at @xmath35 for 1 ev @xmath36 1 kev and @xmath37 for 1 kev @xmath38 mev . the break energy 1 kev corresponds to @xmath39 kev in the observer frame . for @xmath40 ev , the synchrotron self - absorption may be crucial @xcite , while the pair absorption may be crucial for @xmath41 mev ( e.g. , see asano & takahara 2003 , peer & waxman 2004 ) . although the upper bound of the photon energy depends on the model parameter because of pair production , we fix the value as 10 mev ( @xmath42gev in the observer frame ) . since higher energy protons mainly interact with lower energy photons , the production rate of very high energy neutrinos is not sensitive to this upper bound . the shell width in the comoving frame is assumed to be @xmath43 , as conventionally assumed , although there is the possibility of thinner shells @xcite . we express the energy density of the magnetic field as @xmath44 times the photon energy density . in this letter , we adopt @xmath45 . we inject protons with a number spectrum proportional to @xmath46 above 10 gev in the shell rest frame . the maximum proton energy is determined by the condition that the larmor radius is smaller than both the size scale of the emitting region and the energy - loss length . we estimate the energy - loss length using synchrotron , inverse compton , and photomeson cooling processes . the total energy of the accelerated protons in a shell is assumed to be the same as @xmath47 . our method pursues energy loss processes of each baryon via synchrotron , inverse compton , and photomeson cooling processes during the dynamical timescale @xmath48 in the shell rest frame . we have simulated for a wide range of parameters as @xmath49-@xmath50 ergs , @xmath51-@xmath52 , @xmath53-@xmath52 , and @xmath54-@xmath55 cm . of course , larger @xmath27 and smaller @xmath30 are favorable for neutrino production , and as @xcite showed , very luminous bursts are required to detect neutrinos on the earth . therefore , we show only one representative example in this letter . the parameter values are @xmath56 ergs , @xmath57 ( @xmath58 ergs ) , @xmath53 , and @xmath54 cm . the corresponding variability timescale @xmath59 ms , which is not so far from the typical observed timescale @xmath60 s. since the allowed region of the grb parameters is wide , there may be both optically thin and thick sources to thomson scattering @xcite . our example would imply that @xmath30 is close to the photosphere . when it is assumed that the energy density of protons is the same as the photon energy density and the average proton energy is mildly relativistic ( @xmath61 ) , the proton number density in the comoving frame is obtained as @xmath62 . this means that the optical depth for the thomson scattering is @xmath42 for our parameter set . photon scatterings do not sufficiently affect the gamma - ray spectrum for this marginal optical depth . from our simulation , we obtain spectra of created mesons as is shown in figure 2 . one - half of neutral kaons are @xmath5 , while the rest are @xmath63 . since the cross sections of kaon production are smaller than those of pion production , the number of kaons is much less than pions . however , the highest energy charged mesons will cool down before they decay into neutrinos . our results for other parameter sets agree with the condition of ultra high energy cosmic - ray production obtained by @xcite : @xmath64 cm . in the case of figure 2 , also protons above @xmath55 ev cool down before they escape from the shell . we follow the behavior of pions and kaons until they decay into positrons ( electrons ) and neutrinos using the same method as in @xcite . synchrotron and inverse compton emissions are taken into account . charged kaons have six decay modes ; @xmath65 ( 63% ) , @xmath66 ( 21% ) , @xmath67 ( 6% ) , @xmath68 ( 5% ) , @xmath69 ( 3% ) , and @xmath70 ( 2% ) , while @xmath5 will decay into @xmath71 ( 39% ) , @xmath72 ( 27% ) , @xmath73 ( 21% ) , and @xmath74 ( 13% ) . in figure 3 , total neutrino spectra emitted from this example are shown . although there are fewer kaons than pions , the highest energy neutrinos originate from kaons around @xmath75 ev . since very high flux is required to detect neutrinos from grbs by a @xmath76 neutrino detector such as icecube @xcite , we consider an optimistic case : a grb occurs at 30 mpc , and the detection efficiency of upward - going neutrinos with energy @xmath77 is assumed to be @xmath78 for @xmath79 ev , although it may be difficult to measure energies of neutrinos above @xmath80 ev by icecube . figure 4 shows the detectable number of spectra of neutrinos in this case . the vertical axis @xmath81 roughly corresponds to the detectable number in each energy range . in this case , the expectation value of neutrinos from kaons is 0.1 - 1 by a @xmath76 detector . however , for very high energy neutrinos , it may be possible to build detectors with effective volume orders of magnitude larger than @xmath76 , such as the extreme universe space observatory ( @xmath82 detector ) , because the earth is thick for such neutrinos . from the step - function - like features in the spectra , we can easily distinguish origins of neutrinos . as shown in figures 3 and 4 , @xmath5-decay neutrinos are dominant above @xmath83 ev , although the flux is too dim to detect on the earth . on the other hand , the contribution of @xmath5-decay in the energy band below @xmath83 ev is not so prominent . since we have considered many decaying modes , the production ratio of high - energy muon and electron neutrinos is not 2:1 exactly . however , the neutrinos will be almost equally distributed between flavors as a result of vacuum neutrino oscillations @xcite . so , there may be a possibility that tau neutrinos are detected through double - bang events @xcite . as we have shown in this letter , the highest energy neutrinos may originate from kaons in grb internal shocks . the detection of such neutrinos is very important to prove the physical conditions in internal shocks and the particle acceleration theory . in order to observe such neutrinos , a bright grb should occur at a very close distance , or amazing progress in the technology of neutrino observation is required . when we use the observed local grb rate , 0.4 gpc@xmath84 yr@xmath85 @xcite , the chance probability of having a source within 30mpc away from the earth is about 1 event per @xmath86 yr . however , the nearest burst ever observed is grb 980425 at 40 mpc , which was less luminous than usual bursts . although a grb at 30 mpc seems to be optimistic , we should prepare for an event beyond expectation , such as the giant flare from sgr 1806 - 20 @xcite . as a rough standard , we have used a simple formula of the detection efficiency , extrapolating the case for upward - going neutrinos . however , in the very high energy band downward - going neutrinos are favorable to be detected rather than upward - going neutrinos , because the earth is thick for such neutrinos . for downward events , the detection efficiency of very high energy neutrinos would be enhanced . in addition it may be possible to build detectors with effective volume orders of magnitude larger than @xmath87 , which would enhance the chances of detection of the kaon decay neutrinos . the neutrinos produced from kaon decays may be detected as a neutrino background , so let us estimate the flux of the neutrino background roughly . it can be seen from figure 3 that the fluence of neutrinos @xmath88 at @xmath89 ev from this example is @xmath90 10@xmath91 gev . if we adopt this value , the resulting neutrino background level at @xmath89 ev is @xmath92 gev @xmath93 s@xmath85 sr@xmath85 , where we use the local grb rate , 0.4 gpc@xmath84 yr@xmath85 , without correction due to jet collimation @xcite and the age of the universe , @xmath94 yr . this background level is far below the detection limit expected from 3 years of icecube operation . since our example is an optimistic case for neutrino emission , a more realistic background level may become lower 1 or 2 orders of magnitude than above . dominant sources of background neutrinos in the highest energy band are not sure so far . if we can observe the background neutrinos at @xmath89 ev with a highly efficient detector in the future , the characteristic flat spectrum predicted from grb sources is distinguishable from spectra of other sources , such as grb early - afterglows or blazars ( see , e.g. , schneider et al . 2002 ) . @xcite showed that very high energy gamma rays from @xmath95-decay ( @xmath96 ev ) can escape from shells without electron - positron pair creation . however , this result largely depends on the assumption of spectra in the lower energy region . a recent observation @xcite shows brighter optical emission than @xcite assumed . on the other hand , @xmath5 also has some decaying modes into neutral pions . so , there is a possibility that delayed gamma rays come from the decays of @xmath5 . we can investigate the validity of this statement by checking whether @xmath5 can decay after grb photons escape from shells . since the mean lifetime of @xmath5 is 5.17@xmath97 s in the kaon rest frame , the mean lifetime of @xmath5 , @xmath98 , of energy @xmath99 in the shell rest frame becomes @xmath100 s. on the other hand , the typical dynamical timescale of grbs in the shell rest frame is 3 ( @xmath101)(@xmath102 ) s. so , we expect that gamma rays produced from kaons with energy larger than @xmath103 ev can escape from shells . of course , such gamma rays can not travel more than @xmath42 mpc because of electron - positron pair creation with a radio background @xcite . the secondary emission via inverse compton of cosmic microwave background photons may be observed as gev - tev photons . @xcite concluded that the corresponding time delays are in the range of 10 - 100 s and the duration timescale may be much longer . these timescales are much longer than the lifetime of @xmath5 in the observer s frame . therefore , unfortunately , the gev - tev secondary photons from kaons may not be distinguishable from other sources , such as @xmath95-decay . there is a possibility that failed grbs occur near / in our galaxy . as @xcite pointed out , for very extended or slowly rotating stars , the jet may be unable to break through the envelope of a massive star . however , penetrating and choked jets will produce , by photomeson interactions of accelerated protons , a burst of @xmath104 tev neutrinos while propagating in the envelope @xcite . such neutrinos from nearby galaxies may be detectable by a @xmath76 detector . in failed grbs , kaons may be also produced through the photomeson interactions @xcite . when these classes of grbs are taken into account , the chance probability of detecting neutrinos will be enhanced considerably . in previous works , the neutrino spectrum was estimated assuming that the baryon density in the jet is sufficiently high that the @xmath1 process is the dominant process to produce neutrinos . however , the efficiency depends sensitively on the baryon density . so , there is a possibility that photomeson production becomes the dominant process to produce neutrinos in the failed grbs . in such a case , the spectrum of neutrinos will depend sensitively on the photon spectrum . so , the detection of high - energy neutrinos from such kaons will give us a clue to help understand the physical conditions of failed grbs , too . first of all , we thank the referee for his useful comments and advice . we appreciate that s. schadmand gave us information on the cross sections of pion production . we also thank t. hyodo for his advice on the treatment of kaon production processes . ka acknowledges useful advice by s. inoue . this work is in part supported by a grant - in - aid for the 21st century coe `` center for diversity and universality in physics '' from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology of japan . is partially supported by grants - in - aid for scientific research from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology of japan through grants 14102004 , 14079202 , and 16740134 . ando , s. , & beacom , f. 2005 , , 95 , 061103 asano , k. 2005 , , 623 , 967 asano , k. , & iwamoto , s. 2002 , , 581 , 381 asano , k. , & takahara , f. 2003 , , 55 , 433 athar , h. , parente , g. , & zas , e. 2000 , , 62 , 093010 blake , c. h. et al . 2005 , , 435 , 181 dermer , c. d. , & atoyan , a. 2003 , , 91 , 071102 drechsel , d. , & tiator , l. j. 1992 , phys . g , 18 , 449 eidelman , s. et al . 2004 , phys . b , 592 , 1 granot , j. , piran , t. , & sari , r. 2000 , , 534 , l163 guetta , d. , spada , m. , & waxman , e. 2001 , , 559 , 101 guetta , d. , hooper , d. , alvarez - muiz , j. , halzen , f. , & reuveni , e. 2004 , astroparticle phys . , 20 , 429 guetta , d. , piran , t. , & waxman , e. 2005 , , 619 , 412 hurley , k. et al . , 2005 , , 434 , 1098 lee , f. x. , marta , t. , bennholda , c. , haberzettl , h. , & wright , l. e. 2001 , nucl . a , 695 , 237 mszros , p. & rees , m. j. 2000 , , 530 , 292 mszros , p. & waxman , e. 2001 , , 87 , 171102 peer , a. & waxman , e. 2004 , , 613 , 448 piran , t. 1999 , phys . rep . , 314 , 575 protheroe , r. j. , & biermann , p. l. 1996 , astroparticle phys . , 6 , 45 razzaque , s. , m@xmath105sz@xmath106ros , p. , & waxmann , e. 2004 , , 93 , 181101 razzaque , s. , m@xmath105sz@xmath106ros , p. & zhang , b. 2004b , , 613 , 1072 schadmand , s. 2003 , eur . j. a , 18 , 405 schneider , r. , guetta , d. , & ferrara , a. 2002 , , 334 , 173 waxman , e. 1995 , , 75 , 386 waxman , e. & bahcall , j. 1997 , , 78 , 2292 waxman , e. & bahcall , j. 1999 , , 59 , 023002

we simulate neutrino production in a gamma - ray burst ( grb ) with the most detailed method to date . we show that the highest energy neutrinos from grbs mainly come from kaons . although there is little chance to detect such neutrinos , attempts of detection are very important to prove physical conditions in grbs .

hep-ph0701201

in this note , we review the connection between ads / cft duality and quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) experiments at rhic ( see ref . @xcite for a review of qgp physics ) . rhic stands for relativistic heavy ion collider at brookhaven national laboratory . heavy ion " comes from the fact that it collides heavy ions such as gold nuclei @xmath1au instead of usual @xmath2 , @xmath3 or @xmath4 . the goal of the experiment is to realize the deconfinement transition and form the quark - gluon plasma . in principle , it should be possible to form qgp if one has high enough temperature or high enough density . however , it is not an easy job to confirm qgp formation because of the following problems : first , what one observes is not qgp itself but only the by - products after hadoronization , and one has to infer what had happened from the by - products . second , those secondary particles are mostly strongly - interacting , and the perturbative qcd is not very reliable for the current and near - future experimental temperatures . to resolve these problems , many attempts are made to identify the generic signatures of qgp . some of the generic signatures discussed to date are as follows : 1 . the elliptic flow which may be the consequence of very low viscosity of qgp 2 . the jet quenching 3 . @xmath5-suppression all of these signatures have been discussed in the ads / cft duality , so i review recent developments focusing on these phenomena . d - branes represent a @xmath6 gauge theory . ] since this review is aimed at non - experts , i first give a short course on string theory , in particular emphasizing on how gauge theories and black holes are described in string theory . figure [ fig : string ] shows main ingredients of string theory . there are two kinds of string : open strings with endpoints and closed strings with no endpoints . as i will show you shortly , an open string represents a gauge theory . a closed string represents a graviton . an open string propagates through spacetime just like a closed string , but an open string can also have its endpoints on an object , the so - called d - brane . the open string i consider in this lecture is always of this type . the easiest way to see that an open string represents a gauge theory is look at how the string oscillates . figure [ fig : level1 ] shows the simplest open string oscillation ( in 4 dimensions ) . as you can see , the string can oscillate in two directions . so , the open string has two degrees of freedom at this level . these degrees of freedom represent the two polarizations of the photon . in this sense , the open string represents a gauge theory . of course , our interest here is not qed , but rather qcd , so how can one describe a yang - mills theory ? an open string has endpoints on a d - brane , but if there are @xmath7 coincident d - branes , open strings can have endpoints in various ways ( fig . [ fig : sym ] ) . these new degrees of freedom precisely correspond to @xmath6 degrees of freedom . since these open strings are constrained to have their endpoints on the d - brane , the gauge theory described by the d - brane is localized on the d - brane . the d - branes arise with various dimensionalities . a d - brane with a @xmath8-dimensional spatial extension is called the d@xmath8-brane . namely , the d0-brane is point - like , the d1-brane is string - like , the d2-brane is membrane - like , and so on . thus , the d@xmath8-brane describes a @xmath9-dimensional yang - mills theory . we are interested in 4-dimensional gauge theories , so consider the d3-brane in order to mimic qcd . on the other hand , a closed string represents a graviton . again , the easiest way to see this is to look at how the string oscillates ( fig . [ fig : closed ] ) . in general , the oscillations on a string have two modes : the left - moving modes and right - moving modes . for an open string , these modes mix each other at endpoints , but these modes become independent for a closed string . so , one can oscillate the right - moving mode in one direction and the left - moving mode in the other direction . in a sense , a closed string oscillates in two directions simultaneously . this property explains the spin-2 nature of the graviton . in fact , a graviton also oscillates in two directions simultaneously . strictly speaking , a closed string represents a graviton and two undiscovered scalar particles , the dilaton and the axion . since each mode has two degrees of freedom , a closed string has 4 degrees of freedom at this level ( in 4 dimensions ) . the graviton has only 2 degrees of freedom , and two scalar fields cover the remaining degrees of freedom . we have seen that we can get a gauge theory from the d - brane , but it is not clear if the d - brane is simply described by a gauge theory . this is because string theory is more than a gauge theory , namely it has gravitons . at this point , it is not clear if the effect of gravity can be neglected . according to general relativity , any energy - momentum tensor curves spacetime . the d - brane of course has some energy , so how the d - branes curve spacetime ? since gravity is described by the newton potential _ newton ~ , one can measure the effect of curvature by @xmath10 . according to string theory , the newton constant @xmath11 and the mass @xmath12 of the d - brane are given by g & ~ & g_s^2 , + m & ~ & n / g_s , where @xmath13 is the string coupling constant which governs the strength of the interactions between strings . , which is consistent with the hypersurface picture of the d - brane , and the open strings attached represent the fluctuations of the d - brane . ] so , one gets @xmath14 . this means that as long as @xmath15 , one can neglect the effects of gravity and spacetime remains flat . in this case , the d - brane is simply described by a gauge theory . on the other hand , when @xmath16 , the d - brane starts to curve spacetime , and eventually it should become a black hole . so , in this case , the d - brane can be described by a black hole . the black hole here is not the usual schwarzschild - like black hole . we consider a d - brane , an object with infinite spatial extension . thus , the black hole formed from the d - brane has an horizon which extends indefinitely and is called the black brane . " to summarize , one can describe the d - brane both by a gauge theory and by a black hole ; which description is better depends on the value of @xmath17 . the string coupling and the yang - mills coupling @xmath18 are related by @xmath19 ( see sec . [ sec : details ] ) , so @xmath17 is nothing but the standard t hooft coupling , @xmath20 . this suggests that the black hole is the large t hooft coupling limit of a gauge theory . since t hooft coupling is the effective coupling of a gauge theory , the black hole is the strong coupling limit of the gauge theory ( fig . [ fig : largen ] ) . thus , the strategy here is to use black holes in order to compute gauge theory observables in the strong coupling regime . our argument here is very rough , but more refined version of the argument is known as the ads / cft duality @xcite ( see ref . @xcite for a review ) . the precise correspondence is as follows : + & & _ 5 s^5 . [ eq : dual ] here , @xmath21 means that the theory has 4 supercharges which are the maximum number of supercharges for a 4-dimensional theory . also , @xmath22 stands for the five - dimensional anti - desitter space . desitter was a dutch astronomer who found a solution of einstein equation with a constant positive curvature in 1917 . the space @xmath22 instead has a constant negative curvature ; this explains the prefix anti . " one can reach this correspondence by studying the d3-brane more carefully , but i will skip the argument . instead , i explain the correspondence from the symmetry point of view in appendix . we will use the finite temperature version of the duality and its cousins ; in this case , one needs to replace @xmath22 by a black hole in @xmath22 , which is known as the schwarzschild-@xmath22 black hole : + & & + & & _ 5 ) s^5 . according to the rhic experiment , qgp behaves like a liquid . the ads / cft then implies that a black hole also behaves like a liquid . then , plasma quantities should be calculable from black holes . in fact , black holes and hydrodynamic systems behave similarly . consider adding a perturbation to a black hole , _ e.g. _ , drop some object ( fig . [ fig : hydro ] ) . then , the shape of the black hole horizon becomes irregular , but such a perturbation decays quickly , and the black hole returns to the original symmetric shape . the no - hair theorem is one way to see this . according to the theorem , the stationary black hole is unique and symmetric . thus , the perturbed black hole can not be stable . if you regard this as a diffusion , the diffusion occurs since the perturbation is absorbed by the black hole . this behavior is very similar to a liquid . suppose that one drops a ball in a water pond . then , you generate surface waves , but they decay quickly , and the water pond returns to a state of stable equilibrium . in hydrodynamics , this is a consequence of viscosity . thus , one can consider the notion of viscosity for black holes as well . and the viscosity " for black holes should be calculable by considering the above process . let me remind you of freshman physics of viscosity . as a simple example , consider a fluid between two plates and move the upper plate with velocity @xmath23 ( fig . [ fig : viscosity ] ) . as the fluid is dragged , the lower plate experiences a force . this force is the manifestation of the viscosity . in this case , the force @xmath24 the lower plate experiences per unit area is given by = . the proportionality constant @xmath25 is called the ( shear ) viscosity . microscopically , the viscosity arises due to the momentum transfer between molecules . figure [ fig : viscosity ] shows a close - up view of the fluid and i put an artificial boundary to divide the fluid into two parts . the molecules collide with each other and are exchanged randomly through the boundary . but in the situation where you move the upper plate , the molecules in the upper - half part , on average , have more momentum in the @xmath26-direction than the ones in the lower - half part . these molecules are exchanged , which means that momentum in the @xmath26-direction is transported through the boundary . going back to the black hole , how can one calculate the plasma viscosity ? i will first give a brief explanation and its implications and then i will justify the claim more in detail . there are many ways to compute the viscosity and i will explain one simple method . in the gravity side , the diffusion occurs by black hole absorption . so , it is natural to associate the shear viscosity with the absorption cross section by black holes . ( i explain this point more in detail later . the detailed argument suggests that this is the cross section for the graviton of particular polarization . ) now , there is a general theorem on black holes @xcite that states that the cross section @xmath27 is equal to the horizon area @xmath28 for a broad range of black holes . ] : _ 0_bh = a . [ eq : absorption ] but the horizon area is the famous quantity , namely it represents the black hole entropy , so it must be the plasma entropy in this lecture . ] s_bh = k_b [ eq : entropy ] ( @xmath29 : boltzmann constant ) . then , the shear viscosity divided by the entropy becomes constant .. we consider black holes with infinite extension , so the entropy itself diverges . the area for the absorption cross section should be understood in a similar way . ] the constant can be determined from the argument later and the result is = . [ eq : viscosity_bound ] this value is very small . in comparison , @xmath30 for water is about @xmath31 under normal circumstances . now , the point is that all the relations we used ( cross section versus horizon area , black hole entropy versus horizon area ) are generic , so the result must be universal as well . namely , it does not depend on the details of black holes nor the details of gauge theories . so , the claim is @xcite _ gauge theory plasmas which have gravity duals have a universal low value of @xmath30 at large t hooft coupling . _ this is a rather indirect argument , but this claim has indeed been checked for many known gravity duals . this result is very important , so let me rephrase in a different way ( fig . [ fig : universality ] ) . gauge theories of which we can actually compute the shear viscosity are supersymmetric gauge theories , not the real qcd . we compute the shear viscosity from black holes , but the gravity dual of qcd is not known . so , one can not use ads / cft directly to compute qcd properties . however , as we saw , the quantity corresponding to the shear viscosity is universal on the black hole side , so one can immediately apply the @xmath21 result to the real qcd even though these two theories are completely different . in fact , rhic suggests that qgp has a very low viscosity and the estimated value @xcite ~o(0.1 ) ? is very close to the above ads / cft value . one important point is that the temperature in question is still order of @xmath32 . at this range of temperature , qcd is still strongly coupled and pqcd is not very reliable . in fact , the naive extrapolation of the weak coupling result gives a larger value for @xmath30 . thus , the ads / cft duality which predicts the strong coupling behavior may be useful to analyze qgp . i now describe the relation between the shear viscosity and the absorption cross section . to do so , one first has to understand the interactions of bulk and boundary fields . these fields can interact at the boundary . for example , the graviton produces the back - to - back scattering of gluons ( fig . [ fig : absorption ] ) . the relevant interactions are s_int ~d^4x f_^2 + h^ t_^ym + [ eq : interactions ] ( @xmath33 : dilaton , @xmath34 : graviton , @xmath35 and @xmath36 : the field strength and the energy - momentum tensor of the gauge theory ) . such interactions can be obtained by expanding the d - brane action around the expectation values of the bulk fields . the d - brane is described by the so - called dirac - born - infeld ( dbi ) action . the dbi - action with at most two derivatives contains the following term : ~e^- f_^2 + . if @xmath33 is constant , one gets the standard gauge theory lagrangian with @xmath37 , where @xmath38 . if @xmath33 fluctuates , the action is expanded as ~e^- ( f_^2 + f_^2 ) , where @xmath39 . the second term is nothing but the first term in eq . ( [ eq : interactions ] ) . this fact could be stated as _ bulk field fluctuations act as sources of boundary fields _ i just rephrase the same statement , but this leads to the so - called gkp - witten relation , " which is the definition of the ads / cft . given the interaction term , one can easily calculate the graviton decay rate ( with polarization @xmath40 , where @xmath26 and @xmath41 are directions along the brane ) from the standard field theory formula : _ qft & = & _ + & & ( 2)^4 ^4(p_f - p_i ) |m|^2 + & = & d^4 x e^it . the first equality is just the fermi s golden rule with matrix element @xmath42 . the matrix element is proportional to @xmath43 , so the formula is written by a correlator of the energy - momentum tensor . ( this is an optical theorem . ) the factor @xmath44 is a statistical factor for identical particles in the final state . in black hole description , it is natural to regard this decay rate as the absorption cross section of the graviton . this has been checked for the d3-brane at zero temperature @xcite , so ) is known to hold for the d3-brane at zero temperature but it is unclear if it also holds for generic ads black holes . the problem is that a black hole is the strong coupling limit of a gauge theory , so eq . ( [ eq : correlator ] ) is the strong coupling statement . but , of course , it is not easy to compute the right - hand side in gauge theory . one can compute it in the weak coupling , but weak coupling results differ from strong coupling results in general as we will see in sec . [ sec : others ] . in the special case of the zero - temperature d3-brane , such a comparison actually makes sense due to the nonrenormalization theorem , and this is the case where eq . ( [ eq : correlator ] ) has been checked . but it is an open question if this is also true for generic ads black holes . here , we simply assume that the relation holds at strong coupling . ] _ bh= d^4 x e^it . [ eq : correlator ] we can use this relation to compute the shear viscosity since the viscosity is given by a kubo formula microscopically : = _ 0 d^4 x e^it . this formula has the same form as the absorption cross section , so one can immediately write the viscosity in terms of the cross section : = . we have written plasma quantities in terms of black hole quantities . using eqs . ( [ eq : absorption ] ) and ( [ eq : entropy ] ) , one obtains = = . this is the previous formula ( [ eq : viscosity_bound ] ) . we saw that in gauge theories at strong coupling the ratio of shear viscosity to entropy density is universal . how far has the universality been shown ? recently , the universality has been extended to a variety of situations which are not covered in the original proofs . the shear viscosity was first computed for the d3-brane @xcite . this corresponds to the @xmath21 sym which is a scale - invariant theory . ( actually , the theory has a larger symmetry , a conformal symmetry . see appendix . ) but the universality has been shown even for theories with scales , _ i.e. _ , nonconformal theories . examples include d@xmath8-branes for @xmath45 , the klebanov - tseytlin geometry , the maldacena - nunez geometry , and the @xmath46 system ( these theories also have a reduced number of supersymmetries ) . in fact , various universality arguments were demonstrated for these cases @xcite . however , these proofs did not cover the cases with a chemical potential . so , the natural question is what happens to the universality at finite chemical potential . actually , it is not easy to realize the realistic finite density in ads / cft , _ i.e. _ , baryon number density . but there is a simple alternative . namely , consider charged ads black holes instead of neutral black holes . a black hole is known to obey thermodynamic - like laws and its first law is written as dm = tds_bh+dq ( @xmath47 : black hole temperature , @xmath48 : electromagnetic potential , @xmath49 : black hole charge ) . as one can see , the electromagnetic field @xmath48 plays a role of a chemical potential . in ads / cft , such a charge arises as follows . as in eq . ( [ eq : dual ] ) , the full geometry involves @xmath50 . one can add an angular momentum along @xmath50 , which is known as the spinning " d3-brane solutions @xcite . the angular momentum becomes a kaluza - klein charge after the @xmath50 reduction . what is the gauge theory interpretation of the charge ? the symmetry of @xmath50 corresponds to an internal symmetry of the sym , r - symmetry @xmath51 . this @xmath51 rotates adjoint scalars in the @xmath21 supermultiplet . ( see appendix . ) the r - symmetry group @xmath51 is rank 3 , so one can add at most three independent charges . the three - charge solution is known as the stu solution @xcite . when all charges are equal , the stu solution is the well - known reissner - nordstrm-@xmath22 black hole . thus , the charge in question is a @xmath52 charge . because the charge corresponds to the @xmath52 charge , this is by no means realistic . however , the theory has interesting features which are common to the real qcd . for instance , the phase diagram is qualitatively similar to the qcd diagram @xcite . this system does not represent a realistic chemical potential , but it may mimic the realistic case and one may learn an interesting lesson for gauge theory plasmas at finite density . the shear viscosity for charged ads black holes was computed by 4 groups , and the result turns out to be @xmath53 again @xcite-@xcite . so , the universality seems to hold even at nonzero chemical potential . if this is true for generic chemical potential , @xmath53 may be true even at finite baryon number density . in fact , when there is a chemical potential associated with a global symmetry , the universality has been proven in more general settings as well @xcite-@xcite . the theories described so far all have matter in the adjoint representation and not in the fundamental representation such as quarks . however , the universality has been proven even in the presence of fundamental matter @xcite . one way to include fundamental matter is to include d7-branes in addition to d3-branes . i will describe one simple way to realize fundamental matter in the next section , and the d3-d7 system is an extension of the method . this d3-d7 system is known as karch - katz model @xcite . gauge theory plasmas described so far are stationary ones . the real plasma at rhic is of course a rapidly changing system , and it is desirable to study such a plasma as well . in the gravity side , this corresponds to a time - dependent black hole . the universality has been claimed even for such a case @xcite . we saw that @xmath53 , but this is in the strong coupling limit or in the large t hooft coupling limit @xmath54 . real qcd of course has finite coupling , so how about @xmath30 at finite coupling ? in general , the shear viscosity is given by ~|vl_mfp ( @xmath55 : mass density , @xmath56 : mean velocity , @xmath57 : mean free path ) . at weak coupling , the interaction becomes weaker , so the mean free path becomes larger . the viscosity arises due to the momentum transfer , and the transfer is more effective at weak coupling . so , at weak coupling , one expects @xmath58 . and @xmath7 ( or @xmath18 and @xmath59 ) , so there are two kinds of finite - coupling corrections . first is the finite-@xmath59 correction described here . this corresponds to the so - called @xmath60-corrections in the gravity side . the effective actions of string theory contain higher curvature terms in addition to the einstein - hilbert action ; _ e.g. _ , @xmath61 . the finite-@xmath59 correction comes from such higher curvature terms . on the other hand , the finite-@xmath18 correction comes from the so - called string loop corrections since the string coupling constant is proportional to @xmath62 . such a correction to @xmath25 has never been evaluated . ] for the @xmath21 sym , the finite-@xmath59 correction can be computed , and the correction indeed raises the value of @xmath30 @xcite . the correction is about 9% if one uses @xmath63 ( or @xmath64 ) . thus , the strong coupling result seems a good approximation . the universality does not hold for finite-@xmath59 corrections though , so it is not clear how realistic the result is . figure [ fig : finite_coupling ] shows both the weak coupling result and the strong coupling result . they both increase at weak coupling . however , there is a difference . the viscosity is proportional to the mean free path , so is inversely proportional to the coupling constant . thus , the naive extrapolation of the weak coupling result suggests the perfect - fluid - like behavior in the strong coupling limit . instead , ads / cft tells that @xmath30 can not be small indefinitely and is saturated . incidentally , our problem is the strong coupling problem , so one might wonder how useful lattice computations are . a lattice computation of the viscosity for the pure yang - mills theory has been done in ref . unfortunately , the result has very large error bars , so one can not make a definite statement , but it would be very interesting to make the errors smaller . both from the weak coupling result and the strong coupling result . the red line represents the weak coupling result , _ i.e. _ , a naive extrapolation of the perturbative @xmath21 sym result ( based on ref . the blue line represents the strong coupling result , _ i.e. _ , the @xmath21 ads / cft result with the first order correction in @xmath59 ( based on ref . @xcite ) . ] recently , there has been much discussion on heavy quark dynamics in plasma medium . two applications have been discussed : issues related to @xmath0 suppression and issues related to jet quenching . in this section , i quickly summarize the discussion . since @xmath5 is heavy , charm pair production occurs only at the early stages of the nuclear collision . however , if the production occurs in the plasma medium , charmonium formation is suppressed due to the debye screening . one technical difficulty is that the @xmath65 pair is not produced at rest relative to the plasma . therefore , the screening length is expected to be velocity - dependent . such a computation has been done only for the abelian plasma @xcite . pair , the left configuration is not the lowest energy configuration . instead , the right configuration is energetically favorable . the energy difference is interpreted as a @xmath66 potential . at finite temperature , this is no longer true . for large enough separation of the pair , the left configuration becomes favorable . this phenomenon is the ads / cft description of the debye screening . ] first , one has to understand how to realize a heavy quark in ads / cft . to do so , let us go back to fig . [ fig : sym ] . when there are multiple number of d - branes , an open string can have endpoints in various ways ; there are @xmath67 possibilities . this means that the string transforms as the adjoint representation of @xmath6 gauge theory . now , consider an infinitely long string ( fig . [ fig : quark ] ) . in this case , the string can have endpoints in @xmath7 different ways . this means that the string transforms as the fundamental representation of @xmath6 gauge theory . in this sense , such a long string represents a quark . " such a string has an extension and tension , so the string has a large mass , which means that the long string represents a heavy quark . this kind of string has been widely studied in the past to measure the heavy quark potential @xcite . for a @xmath66 pair , two individual strings extending to the boundary is not the lowest energy configuration . instead , it is energetically favorable to have a single string that connects the pair ( fig . [ fig : wilson ] ) . the energy difference is interpreted as a @xmath66 potential , and one gets a coulomb - like potential for @xmath21 . at finite temperature @xcite , it is no longer true that a string connecting the @xmath66 pair is always the lowest energy configuration ; for large enough separation of the pair ( @xmath68 ) , isolated strings are favorable energetically . this phenomenon is the ads / cft description of the debye screening and @xmath68 may be interpreted as the screening length . references @xcite proposed how to compute the velocity dependence of the screening length . they computed the screening length in the @xmath66 rest frame , _ i.e. _ , they considered the plasma flowing at a velocity @xmath23 . such a plasma wind " is obtained by boosting a black hole . at the leading order in @xmath23 , the screening length is obtained as + & & ( 1-v^2)^1/4 + & ~ & ( ) ^-1/4 for the @xmath21 sym , where @xmath69 is the unboosted energy density . thus , the screening effect becomes stronger than the @xmath70 case . one can also compute the screening length for the other gauge theories @xcite . the leading behavior in @xmath23 seems universal . namely , if one writes the screening length as ( ) ( 1-v^2)^ , the exponent @xmath71 is determined by the speed of sound @xmath72 : 4= 1 - ( 1 - 3c_s^2 ) + [ eq : mu_vs_cs ] when the theory is nearly conformal , _ i.e. _ , @xmath73 . one can make a simple estimate of the exponent for qcd . according to the lattice results cited in ref . @xcite , all groups roughly predict @xmath74 around @xmath75 . bearing in mind that our results are valid to large-@xmath7 theories and not to qcd , eq . ( [ eq : mu_vs_cs ] ) gives @xmath76 . it would be interesting to compare this number with lattice calculations and experimental results . one can also study the screening length at finite chemical potential @xcite . at the leading order , the screening length at finite chemical potential is the same as the one at zero potential for a given energy density . another interesting qgp phenomenon is jet quenching . in the parton hard - scattering , jets are formed , but the jets have to travel in the qgp medium , so the jets are strongly suppressed . this phenomenon is known as jet quenching . so , the interesting quantity is the energy loss rate of partons . the ads / cft descriptions of jet quenching have been proposed recently @xcite-@xcite . the proposals have been quickly extended to the other gauge theories @xcite-@xcite . to discuss jet quenching , one now moves the fundamental string with a velocity @xmath23 along a brane direction . then , the momentum carried by the string flows towards the horizon and one interprets the flow as the energy loss rate . for example , the energy loss rate for the @xmath21 sym becomes = - t^2 . unfortunately , the result obtained in this way has some drawbacks . first , the result is not universal and is model - dependent . second , the black hole results become exact only in the @xmath54 limit , but the result does not have a finite large-@xmath59 limit . these two drawbacks are in contrast to the @xmath30 case . this may suggest that one has to be careful to apply ads / cft to qgp . namely , one should not always take ads / cft results at face value . hydrodynamic description of gauge theory plasmas using ads / cft is very powerful due to the universality . the ads / cft may be useful to analyze experiments . conversely , experiments or the other theoretical approaches ( such as lattice gauge theory ) may be useful to confirm ads / cft . this approach is also important since currently there are many loose ends on the ads / cft derivation . one has to clear up these loose ends , but it may be hard to make further progress within string theory alone . so , the inputs from the other areas may be useful to increase confidence in the ads / cft derivation . on the other hand , one has to be careful to apply ads / cft to qgp if the universality does not hold ( _ e.g. _ , jet quenching ) . in this talk , i emphasized the universality approach , but of course finding the gravity dual of qcd is desirable . the biggest assumption of the universality argument is that such a dual indeed exists , so finding the dual is necessary for the universality approach as well . one well - known model of qcd is the sakai - sugimoto model @xcite . this was a successful model in the confining phase , but unfortunately it is not a good model in the plasma phase . the sakai - sugimoto model involves the d4-brane compactified on a circle . above the deconfinement temperature , the model looks as a true five - dimensional theory . another problem of the current approach concerns the large-@xmath59 limit ; ads / cft and qgp are actually different limits . the large-@xmath59 limit of the ads / cft is @xmath77 and @xmath78 . but of course qgp has a large-@xmath59 since @xmath79 and @xmath80 . we are not taking the same limits , so it is not clear why both give such close results . i would like to thank elena cceres , kengo maeda , and takashi okamura for collaboration and for their comments on the manuscript . it is a pleasure to thank testuo hatsuda , tetsufumi hirano , kazunori itakura , tetsuo matsui , osamu morimatsu , berndt mller , and tadakatsu sakai for useful conversations . i would also like to thank the organizers of various workshops for the opportunity to give this lecture . the research of m.n . was supported in part by the grant - in - aid for scientific research ( 13135224 ) from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology , japan . the precise correspondence between gauge theory and gravity is as follows : + & & _ 5 s^5 . [ eq : dual2 ] one can reach this correspondence by studying the d3-brane more carefully , but instead i explain the correspondence from the symmetry point of view in this appendix . to understand why the @xmath21 sym appears , let us go back to the open string oscillations on the d3-brane . superstring theory actually requires 10-dimensional spacetime for consistency . the open strings on a d - brane are bounded on the d - brane , so the d3-brane represents a 4-dimensional gauge theory , but these open strings still oscillate in the full 10-dimensional spacetime . thus , the simplest open string oscillations have 8 degrees of freedom instead of 2 discussed in the text . what are these degrees of freedom ? in other words , what kind of gauge theory the d3-brane represents ? to see this , note that there are two types of string oscillations . first are the oscillations in the brane and the other are the oscillations out of the brane . from the 4-dimensional point of view ( in terms of @xmath81 representations ) , the former represent a gauge field . the latter represent scalars . the spatial dimension is 9 and the brane dimension is 3 , so there are 6 scalar fields . thus , the gauge theory represented by the d3-brane inevitably comes with scalar fields . the @xmath21 sym is such a theory . the field contents of the @xmath21 sym include the gauge field @xmath82 and the scalars @xmath83 . ( the color indices are suppressed for simplicity . we will also suppress the spinor indices . ) in addition , there are 4 fermions @xmath84 due to supersymmetry ( which comes from the supersymmetry in superstring . ) the lorentz transformation properties are different , but they come from similar string oscillations , which means that all these fields transform as the adjoint representation . namely , the theory has no fundamental representation such as quarks . also , if we have only d3-branes , as in the present case , the directions transverse to the brane are all isotropic . these directions correspond to the scalar fields , so the isotropy means that there is a global @xmath51 symmetry for @xmath83 . such a global symmetry is known as r - symmetry . the action for the @xmath21 sym is given by & = & \ { - f_^2 - ( d__i)^2 - |_i ^d_^i + & & + o(^4 ) + o ( ) } . first 3 terms are standard kinetic terms for the gauge field , the scalar fields , and the fermions . in addition , the action contains interaction terms which are written only schematically ; @xmath85 interactions and yukawa - like interactions . the gauge field and the scalars have mass dimension 1 and the fermions have mass dimension @xmath86 , so all terms in the action have mass dimension 4 , which means that the theory has no dimensionful parameter and the theory is scale invariant . actually , it is often the case in a relativistic field theory that the scale invariance and poincar symmetry @xmath81 combine into a larger symmetry , the conformal symmetry @xmath87 . thus , the @xmath21 sym has the global @xmath88 symmetry . the @xmath22 space is a spacetime with constant negative curvature . we are familiar with spaces with positive curvature , like the sphere , and have no problem visualizing them , but it is more difficult to visualize a space with negative curvature . a space with constant negative curvature is known as a hyperbolic space . one way to visualize a hyperbolic space is illustrated in famous woodcuts by escher ( _ e.g. _ , circle limit iii " ) . it is not easy to visualize @xmath22 , but one can represent @xmath22 as a hypersurface in a flat spacetime , which is useful for our purpose . the @xmath22 space is described by x_0 ^ 2 + x_5 ^ 2 - x_1 ^ 2 - - x_4 ^ 2 = l^2 [ eq : embedding ] in a six - dimensional flat spaceds_6 ^ 2 = -dx_0 ^ 2 - dx_5 ^ 2 + dx_1 ^ 2 + + dx_4 ^ 2 . [ eq : flat ] here , @xmath90 gives the characteristic length scale of the @xmath22 space and it is related to the t hooft coupling from the discussion in the text . note that if all signs are positive in eq . ( [ eq : embedding ] ) , eq . ( [ eq : embedding ] ) defines a sphere . also , eq . ( [ eq : embedding ] ) is a higher dimensional generalization of the standard hyperbola @xmath91 . in this form , it is clear that @xmath22 has a @xmath87 symmetry just like the @xmath21 conformal symmetry ; to say that theories are dual to each other , they should have the same symmetries . in addition , the full geometry in eq . ( [ eq : dual2 ] ) involves @xmath50 which has a @xmath51 symmetry . this is the same symmetry as the @xmath21 r - symmetry . so , the gravity side also has the global @xmath92 symmetry . k. yagi , t. hatsuda and y. miake , _ quark - gluon plasma : from big bang to little bang _ ( cambridge univ . press , 2005 ) . a. strominger and c. vafa , `` microscopic origin of the bekenstein - hawking entropy , '' phys . b * 379 * ( 1996 ) 99 [ arxiv : hep - th/9601029 ] . j. m. maldacena , `` the large n limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity , '' adv . * 2 * ( 1998 ) 231 [ int . j. theor . phys . * 38 * ( 1999 ) 1113 ] [ arxiv : hep - th/9711200 ] . e. witten , `` anti - de sitter space and holography , '' adv . theor . math . * 2 * ( 1998 ) 253 [ arxiv : hep - th/9802150 ] . e. witten , `` anti - de sitter space , thermal phase transition , and confinement in gauge theories , '' adv . * 2 * ( 1998 ) 505 [ arxiv : hep - th/9803131 ] . s. s. gubser , i. r. klebanov and a. m. polyakov , `` gauge theory correlators from non - critical string theory , '' phys . b * 428 * ( 1998 ) 105 [ arxiv : hep - th/9802109 ] . o. aharony , s. s. gubser , j. m. maldacena , h. ooguri and y. oz , `` large n field theories , string theory and gravity , '' phys . rept . * 323 * ( 2000 ) 183 [ arxiv : hep - th/9905111 ] . s. r. das , g. w. gibbons and s. d. mathur , `` universality of low energy absorption cross sections for black holes , '' phys . * 78 * ( 1997 ) 417 [ arxiv : hep - th/9609052 ] . p. kovtun , d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` viscosity in strongly interacting quantum field theories from black hole physics , '' phys . rev . lett . * 94 * ( 2005 ) 111601 [ arxiv : hep - th/0405231 ] . d. teaney , `` effect of shear viscosity on spectra , elliptic flow , and hanbury brown - twiss radii , '' phys . c * 68 * ( 2003 ) 034913 [ arxiv : nucl - th/0301099 ] . t. hirano and m. gyulassy , `` perfect fluidity of the quark gluon plasma core as seen through its dissipative hadronic corona , '' nucl . a * 769 * ( 2006 ) 71 [ arxiv : nucl - th/0506049 ] . s. gavin and m. abdel - aziz , `` measuring shear viscosity using transverse momentum correlations in relativistic nuclear collisions , '' phys . * 97 * ( 2006 ) 162302 [ arxiv : nucl - th/0606061 ] . a. adare [ phenix collaboration ] , `` energy loss and flow of heavy quarks in au + au collisions at s(nn)**(1/2 ) = 200-gev , '' arxiv : nucl - ex/0611018 . i. r. klebanov , `` world - volume approach to absorption by non - dilatonic branes , '' nucl . b * 496 * ( 1997 ) 231 [ arxiv : hep - th/9702076 ] . g. policastro , d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` the shear viscosity of strongly coupled n = 4 supersymmetric yang - mills plasma , '' phys . * 87 * ( 2001 ) 081601 [ arxiv : hep - th/0104066 ] . kovtun , d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` holography and hydrodynamics : diffusion on stretched horizons , '' jhep * 0310 * ( 2003 ) 064 [ arxiv : hep - th/0309213 ] . a. buchel and j. t. liu , `` universality of the shear viscosity in supergravity , '' phys . * 93 * ( 2004 ) 090602 [ arxiv : hep - th/0311175 ] . a. buchel , `` on universality of stress - energy tensor correlation functions in supergravity , '' phys . b * 609 * ( 2005 ) 392 [ arxiv : hep - th/0408095 ] . p. kraus , f. larsen and s. p. trivedi , `` the coulomb branch of gauge theory from rotating branes , '' jhep * 9903 * ( 1999 ) 003 [ arxiv : hep - th/9811120 ] . m. cvetic _ et al . _ , `` embedding ads black holes in ten and eleven dimensions , '' nucl . b * 558 * ( 1999 ) 96 [ arxiv : hep - th/9903214 ] . k. behrndt , m. cvetic and w. a. sabra , `` non - extreme black holes of five dimensional n = 2 ads supergravity , '' nucl . b * 553 * ( 1999 ) 317 [ arxiv : hep - th/9810227 ] . a. chamblin , r. emparan , c. v. johnson and r. c. myers , `` charged ads black holes and catastrophic holography , '' phys . d * 60 * ( 1999 ) 064018 [ arxiv : hep - th/9902170 ] . m. cvetic and s. s. gubser , `` phases of r - charged black holes , spinning branes and strongly coupled gauge theories , '' jhep * 9904 * ( 1999 ) 024 [ arxiv : hep - th/9902195 ] . j. mas , `` shear viscosity from r - charged ads black holes , '' jhep * 0603 * ( 2006 ) 016 [ arxiv : hep - th/0601144 ] . d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` hydrodynamics of r - charged black holes , '' jhep * 0603 * ( 2006 ) 052 [ arxiv : hep - th/0601157 ] . o. saremi , `` the viscosity bound conjecture and hydrodynamics of m2-brane theory at finite chemical potential , '' arxiv : hep - th/0601159 . k. maeda , m. natsuume and t. okamura , `` viscosity of gauge theory plasma with a chemical potential from ads / cft correspondence , '' phys . d * 73 * ( 2006 ) 066013 [ arxiv : hep - th/0602010 ] . a. buchel and j. t. liu , `` gauged supergravity from type iib string theory on y(p , q ) manifolds , '' arxiv : hep - th/0608002 . p. benincasa , a. buchel and r. naryshkin , `` the shear viscosity of gauge theory plasma with chemical potentials , '' arxiv : hep - th/0610145 . j. p. gauntlett , e. o colgain and o. varela , `` properties of some conformal field theories with m - theory duals , '' arxiv : hep - th/0611219 . d. mateos , r. c. myers and r. m. thomson , `` holographic viscosity of fundamental matter , '' arxiv : hep - th/0610184 . a. karch and e. katz , jhep * 0206 * ( 2002 ) 043 [ arxiv : hep - th/0205236 ] . r. a. janik , `` viscosity from nonsingularity , '' arxiv : hep - th/0610144 . d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` minkowski - space correlators in ads / cft correspondence : recipe and applications , '' jhep * 0209 * ( 2002 ) 042 [ arxiv : hep - th/0205051 ] . g. policastro , d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` from ads / cft correspondence to hydrodynamics , '' jhep * 0209 * ( 2002 ) 043 [ arxiv : hep - th/0205052 ] . c. p. herzog , `` the hydrodynamics of m - theory , '' jhep * 0212 * ( 2002 ) 026 [ arxiv : hep - th/0210126 ] . g. policastro , d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` from ads / cft correspondence to hydrodynamics . ii : sound waves , '' jhep * 0212 * ( 2002 ) 054 [ arxiv : hep - th/0210220 ] . a. nunez and a. o. starinets , `` ads / cft correspondence , quasinormal modes , and thermal correlators in n = 4 sym , '' phys . d * 67 * ( 2003 ) 124013 [ arxiv : hep - th/0302026 ] . c. p. herzog , `` the sound of m - theory , '' phys . d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 024013 [ arxiv : hep - th/0302086 ] . a. buchel , `` n = 2 * hydrodynamics , '' nucl . phys . b * 708 * ( 2005 ) 451 [ arxiv : hep - th/0406200 ] . k. kovtun and a. o. starinets , `` quasinormal modes and holography , '' phys . rev . d * 72 * ( 2005 ) 086009 [ arxiv : hep - th/0506184 ] . p. benincasa , a. buchel and a. o. starinets , `` sound waves in strongly coupled non - conformal gauge theory plasma , '' nucl . b * 733 * ( 2006 ) 160 [ arxiv : hep - th/0507026 ] . a. buchel , `` transport properties of cascading gauge theories , '' phys . d * 72 * ( 2005 ) 106002 [ arxiv : hep - th/0509083 ] . a. buchel , j. t. liu and a. o. starinets , `` coupling constant dependence of the shear viscosity in n = 4 supersymmetric yang - mills theory , '' nucl . b * 707 * ( 2005 ) 56 [ arxiv : hep - th/0406264 ] . s. c. huot , s. jeon and g. d. moore , `` shear viscosity in weakly coupled n = 4 super yang - mills theory compared to qcd , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0608062 . a. nakamura and s. sakai , `` transport coefficients of gluon plasma , '' phys . lett . * 94 * ( 2005 ) 072305 [ arxiv : hep - lat/0406009 ] . m. c. chu and t. matsui , `` dynamic debye screening for a heavy quark - antiquark pair traversing a quark - gluon plasma , '' phys . d * 39 * ( 1989 ) 1892 . j. m. maldacena , `` wilson loops in large n field theories , '' phys . * 80 * ( 1998 ) 4859 [ arxiv : hep - th/9803002 ] . s. j. rey and j. t. yee , `` macroscopic strings as heavy quarks in large n gauge theory and anti - de sitter supergravity , '' eur . j. c * 22 * ( 2001 ) 379 [ arxiv : hep - th/9803001 ] . s. j. rey , s. theisen and j. t. yee , `` wilson - polyakov loop at finite temperature in large n gauge theory and anti - de sitter supergravity , '' nucl . b * 527 * ( 1998 ) 171 [ arxiv : hep - th/9803135 ] . a. brandhuber , n. itzhaki , j. sonnenschein and s. yankielowicz , `` wilson loops in the large n limit at finite temperature , '' phys . b * 434 * ( 1998 ) 36 [ arxiv : hep - th/9803137 ] . h. liu , k. rajagopal and u. a. wiedemann , `` an ads / cft calculation of screening in a hot wind , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0607062 . m. chernicoff , j. a. garcia and a. guijosa , `` the energy of a moving quark - antiquark pair in an n=4 sym plasma , '' arxiv : hep - th/0607089 . k. peeters , j. sonnenschein and m. zamaklar , `` holographic melting and related properties of mesons in a quark gluon plasma , '' arxiv : hep - th/0606195 . e. caceres , m. natsuume and t. okamura , `` screening length in plasma winds , '' arxiv : hep - th/0607233 . s. d. avramis , k. sfetsos and d. zoakos , `` on the velocity and chemical - potential dependence of the heavy - quark interaction in n = 4 sym plasmas , '' arxiv : hep - th/0609079 . h. liu , k. rajagopal and u. a. wiedemann , `` wilson loops in heavy ion collisions and their calculation in ads / cft , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0612168 . m. chernicoff and a. guijosa , `` energy loss of gluons , baryons and k - quarks in an n = 4 sym plasma , '' arxiv : hep - th/0611155 . c. hoyos , k. landsteiner and s. montero , `` holographic meson melting , '' arxiv : hep - th/0612169 . f. karsch , `` lattice qcd at high temperature and the qgp , '' arxiv : hep - lat/0601013 . h. liu , k. rajagopal and u. a. wiedemann , `` calculating the jet quenching parameter from ads / cft , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0605178 . c. p. herzog , a. karch , p. kovtun , c. kozcaz and l. g. yaffe , `` energy loss of a heavy quark moving through n = 4 supersymmetric yang - mills plasma , '' arxiv : hep - th/0605158 . j. casalderrey - solana and d. teaney , `` heavy quark diffusion in strongly coupled n = 4 yang mills , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0605199 . s. s. gubser , `` drag force in ads / cft , '' arxiv : hep - th/0605182 . a. buchel , `` on jet quenching parameters in strongly coupled non - conformal gauge theories , '' arxiv : hep - th/0605178 . c. p. herzog , `` energy loss of heavy quarks from asymptotically ads geometries , '' arxiv : hep - th/0605191 . e. caceres and a. guijosa , `` drag force in charged n=4 sym plasma , '' arxiv : hep - th/0605235 . j. f. vazquez - poritz , `` enhancing the jet quenching parameter from marginal deformations , '' arxiv : hep - th/0605296 . e. caceres and a. guijosa , `` on drag forces and jet quenching in strongly coupled plasmas , '' arxiv : hep - th/0606134 . f. l. lin and t. matsuo , `` jet quenching parameter in medium with chemical potential from ads / cft , '' arxiv : hep - th/0606136 . s. d. avramis and k. sfetsos , `` supergravity and the jet quenching parameter in the presence of r - charge densities , '' arxiv : hep - th/0606190 . n. armesto , j. d. edelstein and j. mas , jet quenching at finite ` t hooft coupling and chemical potential from ads / cft,' arxiv : hep - ph/0606245 . e. nakano , s. teraguchi and w. y. wen , `` drag force , jet quenching , and ads / qcd , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0608274 . j. j. friess , s. s. gubser and g. michalogiorgakis , `` dissipation from a heavy quark moving through n = 4 super - yang - mills plasma , '' jhep * 0609 * ( 2006 ) 072 [ arxiv : hep - th/0605292 ] . j. j. friess , s. s. gubser , g. michalogiorgakis and s. s. pufu , `` the stress tensor of a quark moving through n = 4 thermal plasma , '' arxiv : hep - th/0607022 . j. j. friess , s. s. gubser , g. michalogiorgakis and s. s. pufu , `` stability of strings binding heavy - quark mesons , '' arxiv : hep - th/0609137 . s. s. gubser , `` comparing the drag force on heavy quarks in n=4 super - yang - mills theory and qcd , '' arxiv : hep - th/0611272 . s. s. gubser , `` jet - quenching and momentum correlators from the gauge - string duality , '' arxiv : hep - th/0612143 . p. c. argyres , m. edalati and j. f. vazquez - poritz , `` no - drag string configurations for steadily moving quark - antiquark pairs in a thermal bath , '' arxiv : hep - th/0608118 . p. c. argyres , m. edalati and j. f. vazquez - poritz , `` spacelike strings and jet quenching from a wilson loop , '' arxiv : hep - th/0612157 . s. j. sin and i. zahed , `` holography of radiation and jet quenching , '' phys . b * 608 * ( 2005 ) 265 [ arxiv : hep - th/0407215 ] . t. sakai and s. sugimoto , `` low energy hadron physics in holographic qcd , '' prog . * 113 * ( 2005 ) 843 [ arxiv : hep - th/0412141 ] .

we review the ads / cft description of gauge theory plasmas for non - experts . we discuss the low shear viscosity , jet quenching , and @xmath0-suppression , which are three major signatures for the quark - gluon plasma observed at rhic experiments . based on invited talks presented at frontiers in the physics of quark - gluon plasma " ( july 7 - 8 2006 , riken ) , string theory and quantum field theory " ( sep . 12 - 16 2006 , yitp ) , the fall meeting 2006 of the physical society of japan ( sep . 20 - 22 2006 , nara women s univ . ) , ads / cft and strongly coupled quark matter " ( nov . 21 - 22 2006 , ccast ) , ykis2006 ( nov . 20 - 28 2006 , yitp ) , a string theory workshop at rikkyo univ . ( dec . 26 - 27 2006 ) .

1310.0043

colloidal gels are components of everyday products such as foodstuffs , fabric conditioners , cosmetics , shampoos , and even toothpaste , yet despite their practical importance they present many challenges to our understanding of disordered materials . a gel is a solid containing a network of particles which is formed when a colloidal dispersion with attractive interactions @xmath0 is quenched deep into a two - phase region of phase space @xcite . driven far out - of - equilibrium , the kinetics of phase separation are dramatically slowed down or , in the limit of strong short - range attractions ( @xmath1 with @xmath2 the range of the attractive interactions and @xmath3 the particle radius ) , totally arrested . partial phase separation generates a disordered network , whose initial structure is controlled by the strength of interaction @xmath0 , the range @xmath4 of the potential , as well as the volume fraction @xmath5 of colloids . the long - time structural integrity of this network is , in the majority of cases , constrained by the gravitational stress exerted by its own weight . given sufficient time , a gel settles under gravity , if it is not density - matched . we distinguish two limiting cases : in strong gels , where the attractive interactions are large in magnitude ( @xmath6 and narrow in range @xmath1 ) , compaction occurs smoothly at a rate which decreases progressively with time . the time dependence of the height of the gel in this case is well described by a poroelastic settling model @xcite ; by contrast , in weak gels where attractions are comparable to @xmath7 and wide in range @xmath8 so that thermal fluctuations are significant , an anomalous behaviour called _ delayed collapse _ is observed . a weak gel , instead of instantaneously settling , hesitates for a well defined delay period @xmath9 without any sign of macroscopic settling , before suddenly undergoing a rapid and catastrophic collapse . delayed collapse has been observed in a wide variety of systems @xcite so the response appears to be a universal feature of weak gels yet to - date no theoretical framework has emerged to account for this process . the existence of a measurable delay in the collapse of a weak colloidal gel looks , at first sight , rather surprising . in a crystalline solid yield usually happens spontaneously at a well defined stress and there is no latency before the material flows . similarly , if a constant gravitational stress is applied to a free - flowing colloidal suspension sedimentation occurs essentially instantaneously . the anomalous response evident in a weak gel has been interpreted as the signature of a non - equilibrium solid - to - fluid transition , triggered by erosion of the gel network by internal flows @xcite , progressive fracture by an applied gravitation stress @xcite , or as a consequence of thermal restructuring of the network @xcite . the origins of delayed collapse are both scientifically fascinating as well as being technologically relevant because colloidal gels are often used to stabilize complex product formulations against macroscopic phase separation . the network of particles supports the gravitational stress exerted by the formulation and suppresses unwanted sedimentation of the product . this trick , widely used by formulators , works only for @xmath10 ( where @xmath11 is the age of the gel ) as the gel instability at @xmath9 eventually restores equilibrium and phase separation starts again . in such cases , @xmath9 fixes the ultimate physical self - life of the product . a demand for robust long - life formulations has heightened the need for a better microscopic understanding of the process of delayed collapse so that gel instability may be predicted and controlled . much of the work to date on gel collapse has focused on macroscopic features , typically by measuring the time evolution of the height @xmath12 of a gel , rather than on the internal structure and dynamics of a gel . however in the last few years new techniques , such as confocal scanning microscopy @xcite and photon correlation imaging @xcite has revealed that colloidal gels have a complex hierarchical structure , with different structural features at different length scales . so while at the individual particle level , a gel consists of dense aggregated colloids , the aggregates are organized on the micro - scale into relatively thick strands of particles , which at the mesoscale are assembled into a percolating network able to transmit a stress . in a weak gel , the stress bearing network has a number of distinctive characteristics . first , it is mechanically heterogeneous with a complex structure consisting of weakly connected soft regions of low particle density coexisting with stiff dense strands of spheres . the strands of the gel may be several radii thick , depending on the strength and range of the attractive interactions . second , the network is dynamic and restructures with time , as inter - particle bonds break and reform via thermal fluctuations . a microscopic understanding of just how such a spatially and temporally disordered network evolves in time and how it transmits stress is still elusive yet just such an insight is essential for the prediction and control of delayed collapse . the goal of this paper is to summarize the key features of delayed collapse in weak depletion gels , to speculate on their origins , and to identify the key issues that still remain to be resolved . we briefly review the features of delayed collapse seen in the gravitational settling of weak gels . with a few recent exceptions , the majority of the previous work reported to date has focused on macroscopic features such as the time evolution of the height of a gel . we discuss the microscopic changes in the gel as it restructures by the breaking and reforming of inter - particle bonds . using this experimental insight , we propose a new model for delayed collapse which emphasises the connectivity of the stress - transmitting network . finally , we explore the role of an external applied force on the delay time of a gel and interpret the results in light of the new model . of a depletion gel ( @xmath13 , @xmath14 nm ) with @xmath15 , and different polymer concentration @xmath16 . ( b ) probability distribution @xmath17 for the delay time of a gel with @xmath18 , @xmath19 nm at @xmath20 , @xmath21 . the solid line shows a fit to a gaussian . ( c ) dependence of the mean delay time @xmath22 on the polymer concentrations for a gel with @xmath13 , @xmath23 nm , @xmath15 . the solid line depicts the estimated single bond lifetime @xmath24 . , scaledwidth=90.0% ] in this section , we recall the principle _ macroscopic _ features of delayed collapse in weak gels . we focus on the time - dependent evolution of the total height @xmath12 of a gel in a gravitational field , as a function of its age @xmath11 . typically a suspension is randomized by shaking or mixing at time @xmath25 and then left undisturbed during the sedimentation process . the height @xmath12 usually displays three regimes @xcite : an initial lag period of width @xmath9 where the height falls slowly but continuously with age , a non - linear regime of rapid collapse where the interface velocity @xmath26 speeds up with @xmath11 , and finally a region of compaction where the height relaxes asymptotically towards an equilibrium value . the three - stage nature of delayed collapse is exemplified by the data reproduced in fig . [ fig : mockup](a ) on the settling of depletion gels @xcite with @xmath15 for polymer concentrations @xmath27 $ ] . we use two sizes of low polydispersity surfactant - stabilized poly(dimethyl siloxane ) ( pdms ) emulsion droplets suspended in a refractive - index and near - density matched mixture of 1,2-ethane diol and water . the suspension of large droplets had a hydrodynamic radius of @xmath28 nm and a polydispersity of 0.17 while the small droplets had a radius of @xmath29 nm and a polydispersity of 0.18 . a depletion attraction was induced by the addition of either the anionic polyelectrolyte xanthan ( @xmath30 = 4.66 x 10@xmath31 g mol@xmath32 , radius of gyration @xmath33 nm ) or neutral hydroxyethylcellulose ( @xmath30 = 1.3 x 10@xmath31 g mol@xmath32 , radius of gyration @xmath34 nm ) depending on the range of attractions required . the majority of experiments were conducted using a combination of large emulsion droplets and xanthan to give a colloid - polymer mixture with an attractive range of @xmath35 @xcite . a small number of results were obtained using a colloid - polymer mixture with an attractive range of @xmath36 @xcite , obtained by combining small emulsion droplets with hydroxyethylcellulose . the magnitude of the attractions between droplets was adjusted by varying the concentration @xmath16 of added polymer , which is expressed in units of the overlap concentration @xmath37 . the relative buoyancy of the emulsion droplets is @xmath38 kg m@xmath39 , with @xmath40 and @xmath41 the densities of the droplet and solvent mixture respectively . this relatively small density difference explains the absence , evident in fig . [ fig : mockup](a ) , of any discernible settling during the lag phase . this is in contrast to many of the earlier studies where the initial stages of gel settling were often characterized by a relatively broad change in the height around @xmath42 as the gel was already settling slowly before the regime of rapid collapse started . this makes it more difficult to identify precisely the point where rapid collapse starts . in the pdms system it is straight - forward to determine the characteristic delay time @xmath9 , which is taken as the time at which the height @xmath12 of the gel first begins to noticeably drop from its initial value @xmath43 . in this paper we concentrate on the physical and chemical factors that determine the duration @xmath9 of this initial lag period . experiments reveal @xcite that the characteristic delay time @xmath9 has a number of distinctive characteristics : first , measurements of @xmath9 from samples of identical materials display a significant statistical variance @xcite ; and second , the average delay time @xmath22 is very sensitive to the magnitude of the attractive interactions _ i.e. _ doubling the polymer concentration in a depletion system may increase the delay time by 12 orders of magnitude @xcite . figures [ fig : mockup](b ) and ( c ) confirms the generality of these conclusions in the pdms system . to establish the extent of statistical variations in the delay time , we performed 116 repeat measurements of the delay time on a depletion gel @xcite with @xmath18 ( @xmath19 nm ) in a temperature controlled environment with @xmath44 . each of the runs was made on a freshly - prepared gel sample under identical conditions to ensure that individual runs were uncorrelated . the resulting values of @xmath9 were used to construct the probability distribution @xmath17 of delay times shown in fig . [ fig : mockup](b ) . an appreciable variation in the measured delay times is seen with a scatter of about 14 % . the distribution @xmath17 is symmetric and well fitted by a gaussian distribution ( solid line in fig . [ fig : mockup](b ) ) which suggests that delayed collapse is a consequence of a large number of independent uncorrelated stochastic events . a clue to the nature of the stochastic events responsible for delayed collapse is revealed by the strong correlation evident in fig . [ fig : mockup](c ) between the mean delay time @xmath22 and the lifetime @xmath24 of an individual colloid - colloid bond . to estimate the bond lifetime we assume that the rupture of individual bonds occurs primarily as a consequence of thermal fluctuations and that the gravitational stress ( which as noted above is small in the pdms system ) does not significantly accelerate the rate of bond rupture . when no force is applied across the bond , the lifetime @xmath24 may then be expressed in terms of the average time it takes a brownian particle to diffuse out of the attractive potential ( the kramers escape time ) . in the limit of @xmath45 , the lifetime is given by the arrhenius expression , @xmath46 , where @xmath47 is a characteristic time which depends on the colloid diffusivity and the range and depth of the interaction potential . estimating @xmath47 from the measured low shear rheology , and the width @xmath48 and depth @xmath0 of the depletion potential from accurate generalised free - volume theories @xcite yields the lifetimes plotted in fig . [ fig : mockup](c ) . as may be seen , the ratio of the two characteristic times is very nearly constant , for a wide range of polymer concentrations , with the delay time approximately 240 times the bond lifetime . the strong correlation evident in fig . [ fig : mockup](c ) highlights the pivotal role of spontaneous thermal fluctuations . the observation that delayed collapse occurs on timescales two orders of magnitude larger than the bond rupture time indicates that a microscopic particle - level model is inadequate to account for collapse . the large difference between @xmath22 and @xmath24 highlights the crucial role played by the hierarchical structure of a gel . the characteristic ratio @xmath49 is also likely to depend on the initial volume fraction @xmath50 of the gel but this dependence has , to date , been little studied experimentally . the delay time , in addition to its sensitivity to the interaction potential and the particle volume fraction @xmath50 , has also been reported to depend on physical factors such as the height , width , and the cross - sectional shape of the sample cell @xcite . , for instance , observed that weak depletion gels constructed from poly(methyl methacrylate ) spheres with initial heights @xmath43 above 7 mm , showed a height - independent delay time @xcite . however in one sample with @xmath51 mm there was a marked increase in the delay time by a factor of about 70% . evans and starrs @xcite interpreted these observations as evidence for the existence in a gel of a new macroscopic length scale @xmath52 , which they termed a ` stress transmission length ' . they argued that samples whose height @xmath43 were greater than @xmath52 could not transmit gravitational stress to the base of a sample so no properties of the gel could be a function of @xmath43 . aside from this study , the effect of height on gel collapse has not been systematically studied although kim _ et al . _ @xcite and others have noted a qualitative change in settling with short samples generally showing a steady or ` creeping sedimentation ' while delayed collapse seemed only to be shown by tall samples . interpretation of these observations is complicated by the relatively small range of initial heights used , but suggest that collapse phenomena might show a rich dependence on the initial height . to clarify the effect of height on collapse , we used two complementary measurement techniques to probe the delay process in the pdms system over a wide range of initial heights . for relatively tall samples ( @xmath53 mm ) a ccd camera was used to measure accurately the time dependence of the height , @xmath12 , of the gel with a spatial resolution of about 0.5 mm . in short samples the collapse kinetics was followed by confocal scanning laser microscopy . the gels were repeatedly imaged by scanning a large number ( @xmath54 ) of slices perpendicular to the gravitational field at different time intervals ( from minutes to days ) . the fluorescent intensity in each slice was integrated to give a height profile . both the confocal and ccd experiments were performed in cylindrical glass cells with a constant width of 17 mm to eliminate the effects of width and cell geometry . the delay time , @xmath9 , for gels with different polymer concentrations @xmath16 is shown in fig . [ fig : height - delay ] as a function of the initial height , @xmath43 . fig . [ fig : height - delay ] indicates convincingly , at least for this system , that the time lag before the initiation of the rapid collapse process is independent of the initial height of the sample . these observations confirm the conclusions of the more limited set of height - data ( @xmath55 mm ) reported in @xcite . the independence of @xmath9 on @xmath43 is particularly striking because the initial height of the gel was varied over almost two orders in magnitude , from 0.78 mm to 63 mm . this behaviour is in contrast with the more limited data reported by starrs _ et al _ @xcite who observed a height - dependent delay . more experiments will clearly be needed to fully elucidate the general picture but the data in fig . [ fig : height - delay ] suggests that a dependence on height at least is probably not a universal feature of delayed collapse . , @xmath23 nm , @xmath15 and four different polymer concentrations.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] during the delay period , although there is no loss of overall mechanical integrity , the gel continuously restructures as thermal fluctuations favour the breaking of existing particle bonds and the formation of new ones . to understand the consequences of thermal rearrangements for the hierarchical structure of a gel we have used fluorescent confocal microscopy on a labelled pdms gel to directly follow the time evolution of the network in real space @xcite . we characterize how the micro - structure changes by determining two characteristic length scale , the correlation length @xmath56 and the mean chord length @xmath57 , which are illustrated in fig . [ fig : gel ] . a series of two - dimensional confocal images were recorded , at a fixed height within the gel , as a function of the sample age @xmath11 . to characterise the large - scale fluctuations in the particle density seen in the confocal images the structure factor @xmath58 was calculated from a 2d fourier transform and the characteristic wave - number of the intensity peak evaluated as @xmath59 . the existence of a peak in the scattering intensity @xmath58 at small scattering vectors is a ubiquitous feature of colloidal aggregation @xcite . the peak signifies the presence of a correlation length @xmath60 . in the dilute particle limit @xmath61 , this characteristic length scale arises from the presence of close - packed fractal clusters of size @xmath56 , while at higher concentrations it may be more accurately interpreted as a measure of the heterogeneity or mesh size of the gel . to quantify changes in the _ local _ micro - structure the mean chord ( or intercept ) length @xmath57 was measured @xmath57 is the average extent of a randomly - orientated line segment which lies totally within the particle rich portion of the gel . since the average is dominated by orientations perpendicular to the strands of particles @xmath57 is a convenient experimental measure of the strand diameter . and @xmath56 , which characterize the disordered structure . the mean chord length @xmath57 is a measure of the average diameter of the particle strands while the correlation length @xmath56 is a typical size of the pores within the framework of the gel.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] the interparticle processes which occur as a gel ages are illustrated by the confocal measurements , summarized in figures [ fgr : ageing](a ) and ( b ) . the pdms gel has a hierarchical structure with two clearly separable length scales . the confocal images reveals that at the microscale , the attractive particles aggregate into relatively thick gel strands which , for the pdms gel , are between 3 and 8 diameters in width . the widths of the strands are observed to depend on the age of the gel and the strength of the attractive potential . at the next level of organization , the strands form on the mesoscale a percolating network with a correlation length @xmath56 which ranges from between 50 and 100 particle radii in extent for the pdms system . both the correlation length @xmath56 and the strand thickness @xmath57 grow continuously with the age @xmath11 of the gel and show no sign of the dynamical arrest transition expected for a strong gel . the rate of coarsening of the gel network is observed to depend sensitively on the strength of the attractive interactions @xmath0 . the more attractive the interparticle potential at contact , the slower is the observed rate of coarsening @xcite . the picture which emerges of a network which grows progressively coarser and thicker with time implies that the shear elasticity @xmath62 should also increase with @xmath11 . this conjecture is confirmed by rheological measurements shown in figure [ fig : rheology ] where @xmath62 increases with @xmath11 , prior to collapse . this however leads to an apparent contradiction why if the gel network is actually getting stiffer with time , does it ever collapse under a gravitational stress ? one possibility is that it is not the average micro - structure which is important but the connectivity of the gel , and in particular how the ability of the network to transmit stress evolves with time . in this scenario , collapse occurs as ageing reduces the connectivity and increases the fragility of the network . in a network with few connections a bond breaking event results in large scale cooperative displacements , far away from the event that caused it . the response is highly non - local . a relatively small number of independent bond - breaking events , distributed randomly throughout such a fragile network , would then trigger a catastrophic macroscopic failure of the gel . and loss @xmath63 moduli of a weak gel ( @xmath64 , @xmath14 nm , @xmath15 , @xmath65 ) as a function of time elapsed since preparation @xmath11 . the mechanical properties were measured by applying an oscillatory stress of 0.0025 pa at a frequency of 0.5 hz . , scaledwidth=70.0% ] , @xmath14 nm , @xmath15 ) . time evolution of ( a ) the correlation length @xmath56 , and ( b ) the mean strand thickness @xmath57 , for indicated polymer concentrations.,scaledwidth=100.0% ] support for the importance of connectivity comes from confocal microscope studies @xcite . a relatively large random region within a pdms gel was imaged hourly , for a total of 32 hours . comparing consecutive images , the number of discrete strand association and dissociation events occurring per hour were identified . the results for the corresponding rates for strand association @xmath66 , and strand dissociation @xmath67 are plotted in figure [ fig : aging - events ] , as a function of the age @xmath11 of the gel . the data reveals a number of distinctive features . first , while the dissociation rate seems to be essentially unaffected by the age of the gel , the rate of association drops rapidly with increasing @xmath11 . the two time dependences reflect the radically different physical origins of the processes involved . dissociation is an activated process which requires particles to escape from a deep potential well and so is not expected to depend on the age of the sample . while , the decline in the rate of association with @xmath11 reflects the progressive slowing down of the microscopic dynamics frequently seen in soft glassy systems as they evolve towards a more homogeneous state @xcite . the second distinctive feature of figure [ fig : aging - events ] is the dominance at early times of association over dissociation events . the data reveals that dissociation is a relatively rare event and a strand once broken will be almost immediately reformed by an association event so that the connectivity of the network changes only very slowly with @xmath11 . the network is essentially self - healing and reforms rapidly after any deformation . at longer times , the character of the network changes as the rates of association and dissociation become comparable . at this point the connectivity of the network drops rapidly with increasing age . the degradation of the network continues to a point at which a small number of uncorrelated dissociation events result in a rapid macroscopic failure of the gel . in support of these ideas , we find that the time at which @xmath68 correlates well with the macroscopic delay time @xmath9 . and dissociation @xmath67 events per hour as a function of the age @xmath11 of a restructuring gel ( @xmath64 , @xmath14 nm , @xmath15 , @xmath69 ) . the lines are guides to the eye . delayed collapse occurs at @xmath70 s.,scaledwidth=65.0% ] we now propose a microscopic model which connects the kinetics of bond - breaking to gel collapse and use it to predict the effect of a small applied force on the time @xmath9 for gravitational failure . our approach is based on the recent work of lindstrm et al . @xcite but modified to analyse a weak thermal - fluctuating gel . we begin by proposing that the delay time @xmath9 is determined by the time - scale at which the rate of strand association becomes comparable to the rate of strand dissociation . on this time - scale the subsequent lose of connectivity of the network and the eventual failure of the gel is rapid by comparison , and so can safely be neglected . motivated by the experimental data presented above , we assume that the rate @xmath67 at which a gel strand breaks is time - independent while @xmath66 , the rate at which the strands of the network associate and re - form , depends on the age of the gel . while the quench history of the gel , and its chemistry will , in general have a significant impact on the time dependence of @xmath71 , close to the vicinity of the collapse point the data in fig . [ fig : aging - events ] suggests the time dependence of @xmath71 may be approximated by a simple linear function of gradient @xmath72 , where @xmath73 is a positive constant . when a small perturbative force @xmath74 ( which is defined here to be compressive if @xmath75 ) is applied across a weak attractive particle - particle bond , the activation energy for bond dissociation is increased by a factor of @xmath76 where @xmath48 is the width of the attractive potential @xcite , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : potential](a ) . the corresponding bond dissociation rate changes to @xmath77 where @xmath24 is the bond lifetime when no force is present and @xmath78 is the characteristic force for thermal bond rupture . the effect of a weak point force on the gel is more complex however because the failure of the gel is dictated by the rate of strand dissociation @xmath79 , which because a strand is several particles thick , could be significantly slower than the dissociation of an individual particle bond . lindstrm et al . @xcite have derived expressions for the cooperative dissociation rate of a strand of @xmath80 particles in different dynamical regimes when either association or dissociation events dominate . the experimental data in fig . [ fig : aging - events ] suggests that , in our system , the number of association events is roughly comparable to the number of dissociation events with the ratio @xmath81 becoming no larger than about two even for @xmath82 . in this case , the analysis @xcite of lindstrm et al . suggests that the dissociation rate of a strand with many bonds in its cross - section should be almost the same as the dissociation rate of the individual bonds that make up the strand , so that @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the dissociation rate of the strand in the absence of any applied force . within this model , applying a counteracting force to the gel will reduce the rate at which the strands of the network breakup , postponing the approach to the instability condition @xmath85 , and consequently increasing the delay time @xmath9 . if a force @xmath74 is applied across each particle bond , collapse occurs after an interval @xmath9 , which is the solution of the implicit equation @xmath86 . to solve this equation , we recognize that fig . [ fig : aging - events ] suggests that the dissociation rate is time - independent while the association rate varies approximately linearly with the elapsed time , @xmath87 here @xmath88 is the initial ( @xmath82 ) rate of association . an expression for the dependence of the delay time @xmath89 on the applied force @xmath74 , @xmath90,\ ] ] follows directly from the collapse condition , @xmath91 , and eq . [ eq : strand ] . here @xmath92 is the spontaneous delay time in the absence of an external force . [ eqn : model ] predicts that the delay time @xmath9 remains close to @xmath93 for weak forces ( @xmath94 ) . increasing @xmath74 results in an increase in @xmath9 , which becomes particularly marked when the applied force @xmath74 approaches the characteristic force @xmath95 of thermal bond rupture . for still larger forces , the delay time saturates at a plateau of @xmath96 , the largest delay time permitted by our model . in this case where @xmath97 , the lifetime of the gel is extended so much that the rate of strand association approaches zero at @xmath42 , so that any subsequent dissociation event causes an immediate failure . to experimentally check these predictions , we added a small number of monodisperse super - paramagnetic beads , composed of a cross - linked polystyrene with embedded maghemite nanoparticles ( @xmath98-fe@xmath99o@xmath100 ) ( invitrogen , dynabeads m-270 , radius 1.4 @xmath101 m ) , to a weak depletion gel ( @xmath102 , @xmath103 nm , @xmath15 , @xmath69 ) . microscopy confirmed that the super - paramagnetic beads were uniformly dispersed throughout the network of the gel . the number density of magnetic beads was estimated as @xmath104 m@xmath39 , significantly less than the number density @xmath105 m@xmath39 of droplets in the gelling system , so the super - paramagnetic beads constitute a trace component . the gel was mounted in a magnetic field gradient @xmath106 generated by a pair of strong permanent ndfeb magnets mounted in a purpose - built alumininium housing @xcite . the strength of the field gradient and consequently the force applied to each super - paramagnetic bead was adjusted by controlling the vertical spacing between the gel and the magnet assembly . the mean spacing @xmath107 between the magnetic beads in the network was estimated as 17 @xmath101 m , which is larger than the correlation length @xmath56 of the gel so the forces applied to the gel network by the dilute dispersion of super - paramagnetic particles are expected to be independent of each other and uncorrelated . the force applied to each magnetic tracer particle was calculated from measurements of the in - situ magnetic field @xmath108 , using a hall - probe magnetometer , and literature estimates @xcite of the intrinsic magnetization properties of the magnetic beads . figure [ fig : potential](b ) shows measurements of the delay time of a gel as a function of the force @xmath109 applied by randomly dispersed super - paramagnetic beads , fixed within the gel network . the delay time increases with @xmath109 because the external magnetic field @xmath108 was orientated so that the force generated on the gel by the magnetic particles opposes the buoyancy forces on the gel . the dependence of @xmath9 on @xmath109 apparent in figure [ fig : potential](b ) is in qualitative agreement with the predictions of the microscopic model outlined above , with a significant increase in the delay time being observed for applied forces of @xmath110 pn . at @xmath111 pn however the magnetic particles were observed to be stripped from the gel , as the local yield stress was exceeded and the gel broke . as a result , the high field plateau predicted for the delay time @xmath9 as a function of @xmath109 ( see section [ sec : model ] ) could not be detected . to check quantitatively the microscopic model of section [ sec : model ] , we first note that the force @xmath74 between particles will be proportional to the applied magnetic force @xmath109 . the constant of proportionality will however depend on the characteristic way in which force propagates through the heterogeneous particle network of a gel . by analogy with granular materials @xcite , we expect the transmission of force to be highly non - linear . forces will propagate predominantly along chains of neighbouring particles while large areas of the surrounding gel remain nearly force - free . if we assume that the contact forces produced by a point force @xmath109 are concentrated along a linear path of @xmath112 particles then , in the absence of end effects , the average force on each pair of particles should be @xmath113 where @xmath112 is the length of the linear force chain . in this case , eq . [ eqn : model ] may be re - expressed as @xmath114\ ] ] where @xmath115 and @xmath116 . from the data presented in fig . [ fig : aging - events ] we estimate @xmath117 for the pdms gel . a non - linear least - squares fit of eq . [ eqn : model - fit ] , with @xmath118 , to the experimental data ( shown as the solid line in figure [ fig : potential](b ) ) yields a good representation of the experimental force distribution . the best - fit parameters were determined as @xmath119 s and @xmath120 pn . to interpret these values , we note that for @xmath121 nm the characteristic thermal rupture force is @xmath122 pn so the number of bonds in the equivalent linear force chain is @xmath123 or @xmath124 . @xmath112 should be comparable to the number of particle bonds between magnetic beads which is @xmath125 or @xmath126 30 , in the current experiments . this value is indeed comparable to the force chain length found experimentally of @xmath124 , which is very reassuring . overall , the force measurements provide reasonably strong support for the microscopic model of gel collapse outlined above . while more work clearly needs to be done , these initial observations strengthen our argument that a catastrophic loss of connectivity as a consequence of thermally - driven dissociation events is ultimately responsible for delayed collapse . is applied . @xmath48 is the range of the attractive interparticle potential . ( b ) dependence of the delay time @xmath9 on the force @xmath109 generated by super - paramagnetic particles embedded within the network of a gel ( @xmath64 , @xmath23 nm , @xmath15 , @xmath69 ) . the force @xmath109 counteracts the buoyancy force acting on the gel so the delay time @xmath9 of the gel is increased . the solid line is the dependence predicted by the microscopic model of collapse ( eq . [ eqn : model - fit ] ) , calculated for @xmath127 s , @xmath128 pn , and @xmath118 . the inset shows the same data plotted on a linear scale . , scaledwidth=90.0% ] it is useful to briefly summarize what features of the collapse instability in depletion gels are well understood and what is still left to be clarified . delayed collapse , whereby a gel which is initially sedimentating slowly after a certain time interval ( the _ delay _ time ) switches to a regime of rapid collapse , is well established in systems with long - range attractive potentials . in this paper we have focused predominately on such long - range systems . the distinguishing feature of these gels is that when quenched into a two - phase region the particle network coarsens continuously with time , as a result of thermal breaking and reforming of interparticle bonds . in contrast , the sedimentation kinetics of depletion gels with short - range attractive potentials is more complex , as a result of the interplay between phase separation and dynamical arrest @xcite , and is not as well understood . finally , we note that the initial particle density is likely to have a significant effect on the time evolution of a gel but the effect of @xmath50 has to date been little studied . the delay time @xmath9 , which can vary from minutes to months , has been reported to depend on the depth and range of the attractive potential , the volume fraction @xmath5 , the particle radius @xmath129 , the density mismatch @xcite , the presence of a weak shear stress @xcite , and even the width and height of the sample cell @xcite . the link between these effects and the microstructure of a gel is in many cases currently missing . however the pivotal role of the thermal lifetime of a single particle - particle bond , the kramers escape time @xmath24 , is generally recognized @xcite . experiments confirm , for instance , that the time required for gel collapse scales approximately linearly with the escape time , over some two orders of magnitude of variation in @xmath9 . the large value of the ratio @xmath130 , which for the data presented here is of order @xmath131 , highlights the significant role the hierarchical structure of a gel plays in the connection between a local bond dissociation event and the eventual overall failure of the network . time - resolved confocal imaging experiments indicate that , although the gel is continuously coarsening , the most important feature of the thermal restructuring is probably a decrease in connectivity of the network with time . analysis of the association and dissociation dynamics of strands within the gel suggest that collapse is triggered when the rate of strand association , which is a decreasing function of time , decreases to such an extent that it becomes comparable to the fixed rate of strand dissociation . at this point , the ability of the gel network to support a gravitational stress decreases rapidly and the gel soon afterwards fails macroscopically . this microscopic picture of collapse is supported by preliminary measurements on the effect of an applied point force on the dynamics of collapse . more work on the subtle link between delayed collapse , microscopic dissociation dynamics , and applied force is however essential to fully understand the anomalous mechanical response of weak gels . particularly puzzling is the role of gravitational stress . the absence of any variation of the delay time with the height of a gel seems , at first sight , to be at variance with the results of the magnetic experiments where @xmath9 increases with applied force . work is under way to address this intriguing question . we gratefully acknowledge support from bayer cropscience and the uk engineering and physical sciences research council . in addition , we thank an anonymous referee for a number of incisive comments which considerably improved an earlier draft .

attractive colloidal particles can form a disordered elastic solid or gel when quenched into a two - phase region , if the volume fraction is sufficiently large . when the interactions are comparable to thermal energies the stress - bearing network within the gel restructures over time as individual particle bonds break and reform . typically , under gravity such weak gels show a prolonged period of either no or very slow settling , followed by a sudden and rapid collapse - a phenomenon known as delayed collapse . the link between local bond breaking events and the macroscopic process of delayed collapse is not well understood . here we summarize the main features of delayed collapse and discuss the microscopic processes which cause it . we present a plausible model which connects the kinetics of bond breaking to gel collapse and test the model by exploring the effect of an applied external force on the stability of a gel .

astro-ph9504097

an open universe , with @xmath0 , seems to fit most astronomical observations . in connection with cdm , it gives the best fit to the observed clustering ( see e.g. ref . @xcite ) ; a similar value is requested for explaining the dynamics of bound objects on relatively small scales ( see e.g. ref . @xcite ) ; it also increases the age of the universe , alleviating the conflict with the age of the globular clusters . further , @xmath0 is in better agreement with direct geometrical estimates from number counts ( see e.g. ref . @xcite @xcite ) . however , as it is well known , inflation predicts @xmath1 . this contradiction is one of the most interesting problems in modern cosmology . it is certainly possible that the observations in favour of an open universe are too limited to be representative of the whole universe , and that higher values of @xmath2 will be found at larger scales . on the other hand , it is also possible to choose the initial conditions in inflation so as to give @xmath3 today , either by starting with an extremely small density parameter at the beginning of inflation , or by assuming that inflation lasted less than 60 @xmath4-foldings or so . both possibilities , however , introduce that fine - tuning of the initial conditions that inflation itself tried to overcome ; moreover , there would be also a conflict with the microwave background isotropy @xcite . two ways out of the enigma have been proposed so far . the first , the single- bubble scenario @xcite @xcite @xcite , assumes that a single giant bubble nucleated from a false vacuum ( fv ) state , when the universe was already flat because of previous inflationary expansion , and inflated for about 60 @xmath4-foldings afterward : our horizon is contained inside the bubble , and appears to be locally open . the weak point of this model is the old graceful exit problem : inflation never ends outside the bubble , and there is no reason why we should live inside that infinitesimal fraction of space which nucleated out of the false vacuum , unless one invokes anthropic arguments . other problems of the single - bubble model have been discussed in ref . @xcite . in the second proposal , the many - bubbles scenario @xcite , one has a two - field potential : while a field drives the inflationary slow - rolling , the second one performs a phase transition , generating bubble - like open universes , with all possible density parameters , from zero to unity , and all possible sizes . here the phase transition completes , all the universe eventually nucleates out of the fv state , but again there is no reason to expect nor a preferential value of @xmath2 , nor a bubble size big enough to contain our horizon . actually , it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that most of the volume is inside bubbles nucleated at the end of inflation , thus exponentially smaller than our observed universe . linde @xcite argues that eventually quantum cosmology will explain why we live in a open universe ( if we really do ) . the model we propose in this work implements a many - bubble scenario in which the nucleation rate varies in such a way to give a @xmath3 universe with maximal probability . in our model , the peak of the bubble nucleation can be chosen to occur early enough to have super - horizon - sized bubbles , approximating a @xmath3 universe by today , and narrow enough to consider our universe as typical . in other words , a flat , huge ( or infinite ) universe appears to be composed of locally open super - horizon - sized bubbles . it is remarkable that local observations , @xmath2 and the amplitude of perturbations , and the `` natural '' assumption that our universe is typical , put strong constraints on the theory parameters , i.e. the fundamental scales of the inflation and of the primordial phase transition . our model , outlined in the next section , has been already introduced in ref . @xcite to produce large scale power out of the remnants of the primordial phase transition . all what we have to do here is to determine the parameters so to tune the nucleation peak at super - horizon scales . to realize our scenario we need two pre - requisites . first , we need two channels , a false vacuum channel , to drive the inflation in the parent universe , and a true vacuum channel , to drive the shorter inflation inside the bubbles . second , we need a tunneling rate tunable in time , so as to produce a nucleation peak at the right time . it is remarkable that the same model that we introduced in ref . @xcite has just these features . this is certainly not the unique possibility , but we will show that it is a rather simple one . the model works in fourth order gravity @xcite , and exploits two fields : one , the scalaron @xmath5 ( i.e. the ricci scalar ) drives the slow - rolling inflation ; the second , @xmath6 , performs the first - order phase transition . the phase transition dynamics is governed both by the potential of @xmath7 and by its coupling to @xmath5 ; the dynamics of the slow - roll is `` built - in '' in the fourth order lagrangian . we already presented our model in detail in ref . @xcite ; here we sketch its main features . our starting point is the lagrangian density @xmath8 , where ( @xmath9 ) @xmath10 and @xmath11 the coupling of the scalaron with @xmath6 can be thought of as a field - dependent effective mass @xmath12 just like in brans - dicke gravity the coupling is a field - dependent planck mass . putting @xmath13 , one finds in the slow - rolling regime @xmath14 which is essentially the only dynamical equation we need . in the following , the instant labelled _ in _ will correspond to the beginning of the last @xmath15 @xmath4-foldings of inflation . the theory ( [ lagra ] ) can be conformally transformed @xcite into canonical gravity with the new metric @xmath16 once written in the conformal frame , our model becomes indistinguishable from a ordinary gravity theory with two fields governed by a specific potential . in the slow - rolling approximation useful relations link @xmath17 and the number @xmath18 of @xmath4-foldings to the end of inflation : @xmath19 correspondingly , @xmath20 . the value @xmath21 is fixed by the request that the largest observable scale , @xmath22 , was crossing out the horizon @xmath21 @xmath4-foldings before the end of inflation , and it is close to 60 for standard cosmological values @xcite . from ( [ lagra ] ) and ( [ conformal ] ) we obtain then einstein gravity with two scalar fields @xmath6 and @xmath23 , coupled by a potential given by @xmath24\,.\ ] ] the choice of a quartic for @xmath25 and a mass term for @xmath26 realizes the two conditions discussed above : @xmath27 this carves in fact in ( [ conpot ] ) two parallel channels of different height , separated by a peak at @xmath28 . the degeneracy of @xmath29 in @xmath30 and @xmath31 is indeed removed by @xmath32 ; the true vacuum ( tv ) channel remains at @xmath33 , while the false vacuum ( fv ) channel is slightly displaced from @xmath34 . in ref . @xcite we evaluated the tunneling rate @xmath35 for our model , defined as @xmath36 where @xmath37 is of the order of the energy of the false vacuum , and @xmath38 is the minimal euclidean action , i.e. the action for the so - called bounce solution of the euclidean equation of motion . the calculation of @xmath38 is simplified in the limit @xmath39 , i.e. for @xmath40 . in this case in fact @xmath41 and we can directly use coleman s formulas @xcite to evaluate @xmath38 , provided we are in the thin wall limit ( twl ) . if @xmath42 ( @xmath43 ) is the potential energy of the false vacuum ( true vacuum ) state , and @xmath44 is the energy at the top of the barrier , the twl is guaranteed if @xmath45 , i.e. if @xmath46 the result is ( ref . @xcite ) @xmath47 the eulidean action decreases as @xmath48 decreases ; the bubble nucleation is then more likely to occur during the last stages of inflation than at earlier times . finally , we can write the relevant parameter @xmath49 , i.e. the number of bubbles per horizon volume per hubble time ( quadrihorizon , for short ) , as @xmath50 where we have introduced a new parameter @xmath51 to mark the time at which there is on average one bubble per quadrihorizon , roughly corresponding to the end of the phase transition . it is useful to keep in mind that , as we will show later , @xmath52 . @xmath51 , or @xmath37 , in principle , can be derived in terms of the potential parameters @xcite ; the derivation is , however , very difficult : as customarily done in extended inflation ( see e.g. @xcite ) , we will determine @xmath51 by requesting that the transition eventually ends . to summarize , our model has four characteristic quantities : the slow - rolling inflationary rate , set by @xmath53 ; the difference in energy between vacua states , set by @xmath54 ; the barrier height , set by @xmath55 ; and finally the separation between the vacua states , set by @xmath34 . these constants completely define the slow - rolling and the phase transition dynamics . in the next section we proceed to the evaluation of the tunneling probability , and show that we can tune the parameters to give @xmath3 today with maximal probability . let the number of bubbles per horizon nucleated in the time interval @xmath56 be @xmath57 , where @xcite @xmath58 \ , , \label{ourspe}\ ] ] where @xmath59 is the nucleation rate , and where @xmath60 is the horizon volume at @xmath21 . the quantity @xmath61 is proportional to the tunneling rate per volume , @xmath35 , and to the fv volume left at the time @xmath62 ( the volume not already occupied by bubbles ) . if after a certain time the exponential term in ( [ ourspe ] ) decreases faster than @xmath63 increases , the fv volume fraction decreases ; if this decrease is faster than @xmath35 increases , then @xmath61 will have a turnaround somewhere , indicating that the transition is being completed . the rest of this paper is essentially devoted to find the condition for this maximum to occur at the right time . the @xmath4-folding time @xmath48 is defined as @xmath18 , where @xmath64 , so that we can put @xmath65 since in all what follows we have @xmath66 ( i.e. , the nucleation occurs around @xmath21 ) , we can write @xmath67\,,\ ] ] where @xmath68 we will neglect the mild dependence of @xmath69 on @xmath48 compared to the exponential dependence of @xmath35 . during inflation , @xmath70 , so that we can integrate easily the argument of the exponential in eq . ( [ ourspe ] ) , and obtain finally @xmath71 \,,\ ] ] where @xmath72 and @xmath73 and where @xmath74 expanding the argument of the exponential to the second order , we can approximate ( [ dndt ] ) as a gaussian curve . the second order term in ( [ qq ] ) should be included as well ; however , for the values of interest of @xmath51 and @xmath75 , it is irrelevant . the result is @xmath76 \,,\ ] ] where @xmath77 and where the preexponential factor is @xmath78 the instant @xmath79 marks the peak of the nucleation process ; this will be fixed by the request to have bubbles ( slightly ) larger than the present horizon . we must have nucleation before @xmath21 , or simply @xmath80 , and it is clear that a necessary condition is in any case @xmath81 . it is now useful to use @xmath48 as time variable . it follows then that @xmath82\,,\ ] ] with @xmath83\over3n_t}\right)\,,\qquad % \sigma_n^2=e^{r_t - r_0 } { n_t\over 12r_t}={n_{t}^{2}\over 16r_{t}^{2}b}\ , . n_p = n_t\left(1-{ht_p\over n_t}\right)\,,\quad \sigma_n^2={n_{t}^{2}\over 16r_{t}^{2}b}\,,\ ] ] where we require that @xmath84 . we need now the relation between the present curvature @xmath85 and the nucleation time @xmath48 . we know that if a bubble nucleates at @xmath48 its density parameter is @xmath86^{-1}\approx 1-\gamma n^{-2}\,,\ ] ] where the constant @xmath87 has been taken small ( compared to @xmath88 ) for simplicity of calculation , even if it is not necessary . now , from the friedmann equation , in the limit of small deviation from flatness , it is easy to see that the relation between the curvature today and the curvature during inflation is @xmath89 . however , when the curvature deviates sensibly from zero , this relation is no longer acceptable . neglecting the rde phase , it is possible to derive from the standard solution of an open universe ( see e.g. @xcite ) the following expression @xmath90 where @xmath91 thus , we get finally @xmath92 it appears then that , as we would expect , @xmath93 if the bubble nucleates at @xmath94 , and @xmath95 if the nucleation occurs at small @xmath48 . only a value @xmath66 would result in intermediate values of @xmath96 . from eq . ( [ finally ] ) , we can express the nucleation rate directly in terms of the present curvature @xmath96 : @xmath97 ^ 2\over \sigma_c^2 } \right\}\,,\ ] ] with @xmath98 @xmath99 and @xmath100 we can then define the probability @xmath101 that we live in a @xmath2 universe as @xmath102 where @xmath103 is the comoving size of a bubble which today has curvature @xmath96 . as we will see shortly , @xmath101 is normalized to unity . ( [ dn - c ] ) is the central result of this work ; it gives the probability density to live today in a bubble with given @xmath2 . as we have seen , we have obtained it using the standard tools of inflationary cosmology , without employing arguments from quantum cosmology . most importantly , we have obtained @xmath101 _ without assuming special initial conditions_. we now impose three observational constraints on @xmath101 : first , we must impose the condition that the bubbles fill the universe , i.e. that the transition completes ; second , we require the nucleation peak to occur for @xmath3 , the present observational value ; and third , we require a narrow distribution , say @xmath104 , to ensure our universe is typical . this implies three conditions on our parameters @xmath105 and @xmath106 . the first constraint amounts to requiring that the volume contained in bubbles nucleated from @xmath107 down to @xmath108 be equal to , or larger than , the present horizon : @xmath109 where @xmath110 is the comoving scale of a bubble nucleated at @xmath48 . in terms of @xmath101 , eq . ( [ norm ] ) is simply the condition that the probability be normalized to unity ( or to a value larger than unity , which simply indicates that the bubbles are too densely packed to assume spherical symmetry ) . since @xmath111 we have the normalization condition @xmath112 neglecting again the time dependence of @xmath69 during inflation . using directly the form ( [ dndt ] ) where we express @xmath62 in terms of @xmath48 with ( [ nt ] ) it follows @xmath113 we display in fig . 1 the region of the plane ( @xmath114 ) which satisfies the constraint above ( with @xmath115 ) , for which the curves ( [ dn - n ] ) are sharply peaked around @xmath116 @xmath117 , and for which @xmath84 ; as one can see , there is a vast region in which our theory is successful . finally , the condition that @xmath118 gives @xmath119 from fig . 1 one sees that @xmath75 has to be roughly larger than @xmath120 , and therefore @xmath121 ( from ( [ tp ] ) with @xmath122 ) and , by the condition ( [ sen1 ] ) , @xmath123 let us summarize the constraints to which the parameters are subject . the tunneling function has to be peaked at @xmath48 slightly larger than @xmath21 ; the value of @xmath124 at that time has to be such that today @xmath0 ; the peak should be narrow , so that the probability to live in a @xmath3 universe is high ; and the transition should be intense enough to fill the universe with bubbles . a further condition is that the slow roll do not generate too strong inhomogeneities ; roughly , this implies @xmath125 in planck units @xcite . finally , we have to be in the thin wall limit ( [ twl ] ) . it is remarkable that our model meets easily all these requirements . for instance , we can have @xmath126 and @xmath127 , so that @xmath128 ( from ( [ c - cond ] ) ) ; then , fixing @xmath129 and @xmath130 ( respecting ( [ twl ] ) ) , we have @xmath131 ( the planck scale ) , @xmath132 ( near the scale of @xmath53 ) . in fig . 2 we plot @xmath101 for this set of parameters . we presented a scenario in which the flat , inflationary universe is filled by super - horizon - sized underdense bubbles , which approximate open universes . this reconcile the astronomical observations in favour of @xmath3 with inflation . our own bubble - universe is one of an infinite number of similar bubbles . our model differs from the single - bubble scenario @xcite @xcite @xcite in which one must invoke anthropic arguments to explain our position , and is different also from the model presented by linde @xcite , in which there is no reason to expect preferential nucleation for any given value of @xmath124 . as we showed in the previous section , we can tune the parameters to achieve maximal probability for the nucleation of @xmath3 bubbles , without assuming special initial conditions , and satisfying all other constraints . it is worth remarking again that the measure of @xmath2 along with the assumption that the universe had an inflationary epoch , and that our position is typical , put strong constraints on the fundamental parameters of the primordial potential . it is interesting to observe that the phase transition parameters @xmath133 would be unobservable either if the nucleation occurred much earlier , because then the subsequent expansion would have again flattened the space , or much later , because then the very small sub - horizon bubbles would have thermalized , recovering again a @xmath134 universe . inside the bubbles one has the usual mechanism of generation of inflationary perturbations @xcite @xcite @xcite . in ref . @xcite we presented a scenario in which extra power is provided by the bubble - like structure of a primordial phase transition . it is possible that reducing the local @xmath2 to @xmath135 is enough to reconcile canonical cdm with large scale structure , so that no further phase transitions need to be invoked . however , evidences are increasing toward the presence of huge voids in the distribution of matter in the present universe , and for velocity fields that are difficult to explain without a new source of strong inhomogeneities . if this is the case , the possibility of an additional primordial phase transition occurred around 50 @xmath4-foldings before the end of inflation should be seriously taken into account . park , c. , vogeley , m.s . , geller , m. , huchra , j. astrophys . j. * 431 * , 569 ( 1994 ) p.j.e . peebles , principle of physical cosmology , ( princeton univ . press , 1993 ) b. ratra & p.j.e . peebles , astrophys . j. * 432 * l5 ; preprint pupt-1444 a. kashlisnsy , i. tkachev , & j. frieman phys . rev . lett . * 73 * ( 1994 ) a. guth & e. weinberg b. , nucl . * b212 * 321 ( 1983 ) m. sasaki , t. tanaka , yamamoto k. & j. yokoyama , pjys . , * b317 * 510 ( 1993 ) k. yamamoto , m. sasaki , & t. tanaka , preprint kuns 1309 m. bucher , a.s . goldhaber , & n. turok , princeton university preprint , hep - th/9411206 a. linde , preprint su - itp-95 - 5 , hep - th/9503097 f. occhionero and l. amendola , phys . d , * 50 * 4846 ( 1994 ) a.a . starobinsky , sov . jetp letters * 30 * , 682 ( 1979 ) . b. whitt , phys . 145b * , 176 ( 1984 ) . kolb & m. turner , the early universe ( addison- wesley , 1990 ) s.coleman , phys . d * 15 * 2929 ( 1977 ) ; c. callan and s. coleman , _ ibid . _ * 16 * 1762 ( 1977 ) ; s. coleman and f. de luccia , _ ibid . _ * 21 * 3305 ( 1980 ) . a.r . liddle and d. wands , mon . not . . soc . * 253 * , 637 ( 1991 ) .

it is already understood that the increasing observational evidence for an open universe may be reconciled with inflation if our horizon is contained inside one single huge bubble nucleated during the inflationary phase transition . in the scenario we present here , the universe consists of infinitely many superhorizon bubbles , like our own , the distribution of which can be made to peak at @xmath0 . therefore , unlike the existing literature , we do not have to rely upon the anthropic principle nor upon special initial conditions .

astro-ph0101083

the direct kinetic effect of a considerable lepton asymmetry @xmath1 ( either initially present or dynamically generated ) on cosmological nucleosynthesis ( cn ) has been investigated in @xcite , and cosmological constraints on its value have been obtained . the effect of neutrino oscillations on cn was also studied and stringent bounds on oscillation parameters were obtained @xcite . neutrino oscillations , proceeding in the primordial plasma during cn epoch , can effect @xmath2 yield by ( a ) bringing additional degrees of freedom into the primordial heat bath@xcite , ( b ) depleting the neutrino and antineutrino number densities thus slowing the weak interactions @xmath3 , ( c ) distorting the neutrino and antineutrino spectrum @xcite , ( d ) producing neutrino - antineutrino asymmetry ev@xmath4 @xcite , however for @xmath5 , a considerable asymmetry growth was registered in precise numerical studies @xcite . ] @xcite , which on its turn influences the evolution of the neutrino and antineutrino ensembles and the oscillation pattern @xcite . in this work we discuss the simultaneous effect of a lepton asymmetry and neutrino oscillations on cn . two different cases of lepton asymmetry are analyzed : an initially present and generated in oscillations asymmetry . we have studied the role of a lepton asymmetry on cn with oscillations , effective after electron neutrino decoupling . we have shown by a numerical analyses of the kinetics of nucleons and the oscillating neutrinos and antineutrinos in cn epoch , that much smaller asymmetries @xmath6 exert considerable _ indirect effects _ on cn through oscillations , due to the fact that even very small asymmetries change the medium induced neutrino potential energy and influence the evolution of the oscillating neutrinos . the prejudice that in order to influence nucleosynthesis the neutrino asymmetry first must grow to a considerable value @xmath1 , is not applicable for the case of nucleosynthesis _ with oscillations_. and changing primordial helium-4 yield @xmath7 @xcite . ] lepton asymmetry influences cn with oscillations in several ways : the neutrino and antineutrino ensembles evolve differently in comparison with the case without asymmetry , i.e neutrino number densities , their depletion and spectrum distortion are changed . also due to asymmetry term neutrino and antineutrino become strongly coupled and evolve differently . lepton asymmetry changes as well the oscillation pattern , i.e. leads to an enhancement or suppression of oscillations . all these resultt into changed light elements yields , compared with the oscillatory case without asymmetry . this indirect asymmetry influence on cn is considerable @xcite . however , inorder to reveal it asymmetry should be considered selfconsistently with the neutrinos and nucleons evolution . the results obtained without the account of the indirect effects differ by many orders of magnitude from the real picture @xcite . numerical analysis , accounting for the asymmetry effect selfconsistently with neutrino and nucleons evolution , was provided in refs . see also ref . @xcite , where an precise analytical study of the asymmetry evolution , accounting for its back effect on oscillating neutrinos , was proposed . in the nonresonant case the oscillations produced asymmetry was shown to have a negligible role in cn @xcite . however , in the resonant oscillation case the asymmetry effect on cn is considerable @xcite . in general , dynamically produced asymmetry suppresses oscillations @xcite , which leads to less overproduction of helium-4 in comparison with cn with oscillations but without an asymmetry account . hence , the bounds on oscillation parameters are alleviated at small mixing angles @xcite . we present in sec . [ s3 ] the updated cosmological constraints for electron - sterile oscillation case , accounting precisely for the oscillations generated asymmetry . the effect of small initial lepton asymmetries ( @xmath8 ) on cn with nonresonant active - sterile oscillations was precisely studied in @xcite . it was found that asymmetry is able to enhance oscillations , besides its well known ability to suppress them @xcite , thus leading correspondingly to an over- or under - production of helium . our analysis has shown ( see sec . [ s4 ] . ) that the initially present asymmetry is able to alleviate cn bounds at large mixings and to tighten the bounds at small mixings ( see also refs . @xcite ) . in the next section we present the precise kinetic approach for the description of lepton asymmetry effects on cn in the presence of oscillations . we have used for the precise analysis the synthesis of helium-4 . according to the standard cn the primordial helium yield depends on two compelling processes , determinning the nucleons freezing : universe s cooling , @xmath9 and weak processes , @xmath10 . three neutrino flavours , zero lepton asymmetry and equilibrium neutrino number densities and spectrum are assumed . in the case of cn with oscillations and with lepton asymmetry , all these assumptions do not work . according to ( a)-(d ) : neutrino oscillations change the number of neutrino flavours ; they may produce nonequilibrium neutrino number densities ( particularly the electron neutrino density may be considerably reduced in favour of the sterile neutrino density ) ; the neutrino spectrum may be distorted in active - sterile oscillations ; besides , even if initially the lepton asymmetry is assumed zero resonant oscillations may lead to a considerable growth of the asymmetry , which on its turn effects neutrinos and nucleons evolution via oscillations . this nonequilibrium picture is hard to describe analytically . kinetic effect on cn . therefore , its role in nucleosynthesis was accounted for after it has grown `` enough''and hence , the indirect effect of asymmetry during its growth has been neglected . the asymmetry back effect on oscillations , in case considered at all , was assumed to be only towards suppressing oscillations . ] inorder to account for the different effects of oscillations and asymmetry on cn a selfconsistent numerical analysis of the kinetics of the oscillating neutrinos , the nucleons freeze - out and the asymmetry evolution is necessary . in our analysis the set of the following coupled integro - differential equations describing the evolution of the neutrino @xmath11 and neutron number densities @xmath12 was solved simultaneously and selfconsistently : @xmath13 + i \sqrt{2 } g_f \left({\cal l } - q / m_w^2 \right)n_\gamma \left [ \alpha , \rho(t ) \right ] + { \rm o}\left(g_f^2 \right ) , \nonumber\\ \nonumber\\ { \partial\bar\rho(t ) \over \partial t } & = & h p_\nu~ { \partial \bar\rho(t ) \over \partial p_\nu } + \nonumber\\ & + & i \left [ { \cal h}_o,\bar\rho(t ) \right ] + i \sqrt{2 } g_f \left(-{\cal l } - q / m_w^2 \right)n_\gamma \left [ \alpha , \bar\rho(t ) \right ] + { \rm o}\left(g_f^2 \right ) , \label{kin}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath14 \nonumber\\ & & - \int { \rm d}\omega(e^+,p,\tilde{\nu } ) |{\cal a}(e^+n\to p\tilde{\nu})|^2 \left[n_{e^+ } n_n ( 1-\bar{\rho}_{ll } ) - n_p \bar{\rho}_{ll } ( 1-n_{e^+})\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath15 , mixing just in the electron sector was assumed @xmath16 . @xmath17 is the momentum of electron neutrino , @xmath18 stands for the number density of the interacting particles , @xmath19 is a phase space factor and @xmath20 is the amplitude of the corresponding process . these equations provide simultaneous account of the different competing processes , namely : neutrino oscillations , hubble expansion and weak interaction processes . @xmath21 is the free neutrino hamiltonian . the ` nonlocal ' term @xmath22 arises as an @xmath23 propagator effect , @xmath24 . @xmath25 is proportional to the fermion asymmetry of the plasma and is essentially expressed through the neutrino asymmetries @xmath26 , where @xmath27 and @xmath28 . the neutron and proton number densities , used in the kinetic equations for neutrinos , are substituted from the numerical calculations of eq . ( 2 ) . on the other hand , @xmath29 and @xmath30 at each integration step of eq . ( 2 ) are taken from the simultaneously performed integration of the set of equations ( 1 ) . the equations are for the neutrino and neutron number densities in momentum space . this allows to account precisely for the spectrum distortion effect and neutrino depletion effects of oscillations , as well as to follow the evolution of the neutrino asymmetry and its back effect at each neutrino momentum . in our numerical analysis the spectrum distortion was described by 1000 bins for the nonresonant case and by 5000 bins for the resonant case . in case the spectrum was described by @xmath31 bins , a system of @xmath32 coupled integro - differential equations following from ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) , was numerically solved . the numerical analysis was provided for the characteristic temperature interval @xmath33 $ ] and the full set of oscillation parameters of the active - sterile oscillation model @xcite . we calculated precisely the @xmath34-freezing , essential for the production of helium , till temperature @xmath35 mev , and accounted adiabatically for the following decays of neutrons till the start of nuclear reactions at about @xmath36 mev . our numerical analysis showed that in the resonant oscillation case the dynamical neutrino - antineutrino asymmetry grows up to 4 orders of magnitude . i.e. starting with asymmetries of the order of the baryon one it reaches maximum a value @xmath37 . hence , having in mind this small value the registered asymmetry effect is totally due to its _ indirect _ influence on cn via oscillations . dynamically produced asymmetry at small mixing angles suppresses oscillations , which leads to less overproduction of @xmath2 in comparison with cn with oscillations but without an asymmetry account . hence , the cosmological constraints on oscillation parameters are alleviated at small mixing angles . = 1.5 mm [ cols= " < , < , < " , ] the updated constraints on active - sterile neutrino oscillations , precisely accounting for the asymmetry generation , spectrum distortion and the depletion of the neutrinos , are presented in fig . 1 . the plots correspond to @xmath38 . the net _ indirect _ asymmetry effect on cn is given for the resonant case by the difference between the dashed curve ( without asymmetry account ) and the solid one . due to asymmetry growth account , and the corresponding suppression of oscillations , @xmath7 overproduction is not so strongly expressed at small mixing angles , hence cn constraints are alleviated at small mixing angles for @xmath39 . in the resonant case the cosmological constraints at large mixings are @xmath40 ev@xmath4 . in the nonresonant case @xmath41 an analytical fit to the exact constraints is : @xmath42 ev@xmath4 . the constraints in both cases are strengthened compared to the previous ones @xcite due to the precise account of the spectrum distortion and to the exact kinetic approach to the neutrinos and nucleons evolution . according to these constraints the low active - sterile solution to the solar neutrino problem , which is favoured by the analysis of the recent experimental data of total measured rates and day and night spectrum measured by superkamiokande @xcite is almost completely excluded @xcite . the role of initially present relic asymmetries on cn with nonresonant active - sterile oscillations was precisely studied , following the lines of work described in sec . [ s2 ] . a wide range of @xmath43 values @xmath44 $ ] was analyzed . such small asymmetries have only indirect effects on cn . on fig.2 the dependence of the produced helium , in a cn model with oscillations on the initial asymmetry is plotted . it was found that the asymmetry is able also to _ enhance _ oscillations , besides its well known ability to suppress them . the enhancement is a synthetic effect of a resonant wave passing through neutrino spectrum till lepton asymmetry changes sign and followed by a similar ` spectrum ' resonance at the antineutrino ensemble and vice versa @xcite . hence , this enhancement has a complex spectral character and could be revealed only by a precise kinetic approach to the oscillation problem . the influence of the asymmetry should not be reduced only to oscillations suppression , as usually believed . depending on the concrete values of oscillations parameters the asymmetry may suppress , enhance or not influence oscillations , thus leading correspondingly to an under- , over - production of helium or not change its abundance . hence , in order to judge the real asymmetry effect on cn , precise numerical analysis for the concrete oscillation parameters and @xmath43 values is obligatory . initially present asymmetry may relax cn bounds at large mixings and tighten the bounds at small mixings . qualitatively , for oscillations affective after the freeze - out of the electron neutrino , the asymmetry effect is as follows : @xmath45 has negligible effect on cn ; @xmath46 enhances oscillations due to the spectrum wave resonance @xcite , resulting into an enhanced overproduction of helium-4 ; @xmath47 leads to a suppression of oscillations and relaxation of the cn bounds ( fig . 2 ) . in fig . 3 the isohelium contours @xmath38 are presented , for different @xmath43 : @xmath48 and @xmath49 . for small mixing angles the asymmetry @xmath48 enhances oscillations , which reflects into stronger bounds on oscillation parameters , while for large mixings this asymmetry suppresses oscillations and cn bounds are weakened compared with @xmath49 case . a similar investigation , of initial asymmetry effect on cn with oscillations , for the resonant case will be a more complicated task due to technical problems : the usual explicit numerical approach is not applicable for the description of the asymmetry evolution , because the neutrino evolution equations at resonance have high stiffness ; besides the resonance case deserve much greater number of bins for the spectrum distortion description . to solve the stiff equations numerically , implicit methods should be used . for 5000 bins of the spectrum a system of 30000 equations describing the neutrino evolution should be solved simultaneously . however , this investigation is interesting , as far as such small values of the initial relic asymmetry are not excluded neither from observations nor from some profound theoretical principle . in conclusion we would like to stress that small asymmetries , initially present or dynamically generated , influence cn thanks to their backfeed effect on oscillating neutrinos.the account of spectrum distortion of the oscillating neutrinos as well as the selfconsistent account of neutrinos and nucleons evolution is essential for revealing the indirect effect of small lepton asymmetries . therefore , a precise kinetic approach should be provided when analyzing the effect of lepton asymmetry on cn with oscillations . + we are glad to thank the organizing committee of capp2000 , for the stimulating atmosphere of the conference and for the financial support of the participation of d.k . m.c . thanks theory division of cern where this work was prepared . dolgov a. d. , _ sov . phys . _ * 33 * , 700 ( 1981 ) ; barbieri r. , and dolgov a. , _ phys . * b 237 * , 440 ( 1990 ) ; _ nucl . * b 349 * , 743 ( 1991 ) ; enqvist k. , kainulainen k. , and thomson m. , _ nucl . * b 373 * , 498 ( 1992 ) ; dolgov a. d. , hep - ph/0006103 . abazajian k. , shi x. , and fuller g. m. , astro - ph/9904052 ; shi x. , fuller g. m. , and abazajian k. , astro - ph/9908081 ; _ phys . _ * d 60 * , 063002 ( 1999 ) ; shi x. , and fuller g. m. , _ phys . lett . _ * 83 * , 3120 ( 1999 ) . foot r. , and volkas r. r. , _ phys . * d 55 * , 5147 ( 1997 ) ; _ ibid . _ * d 56 * , 6653 ( 1997 ) ; erratum _ ibid . _ * d 59 * , 029901 ( 1999 ) ; _ phys . rev . _ * d 61 * , 043507 ( 2000 ) ; astro - ph/9811067 ; bell n. , foot r. , and volkas r. r. , _ phys . _ * d 58 * , 105010 ( 1998 ) ; foot r. , _ astropart . * 10 * , 253 ( 1999 ) ; _ phys . _ * d 61 * , 023516 ( 2000 ) ; di bari p. , lipari p. , and lusignoli m. , phys . _ * a 15 * , 2289 ( 2000 ) . suzuki y. , talk at neutrino 2000 , june 2000 , sudbury , canada ; gonzalez - garcia m. c. , pea - garay c. , hep - ph/0009041 talk at neutrino 2000 , june 2000 , sudbury , canada ; bahcall j. n. , krastev p. i. , and smirnov a. yu . , talk at now2000 , sept . 2000 , otranto , italy .

we analyze the effects of lepton asymmetry on neutrino oscillations and on cosmological nucleosynthesis with active - sterile oscillating neutrinos . it is shown that small lepton asymmetries , @xmath0 , whose direct kinetic effect on nucleosynthesis is negligible , still effect nucleosynthesis considerably through their influence on oscillating neutrinos . two different cases of lepton asymmetry are discussed : an initially present and a dynamically generated in oscillations . _ dynamically generated in resonant oscillations asymmetry _ at small mixing angles suppresses oscillations , hence , the nucleosynthesis bounds on neutrino mass differences at small mixings are relaxed . _ initially present asymmetry _ may suppress or enhance oscillations . the enhancement is a result of interchanging resonances between neutrino and antineutrino ensembles due to resonance waves passing through the neutrino and antineutrino spectrum . updated nucleosynthesis bounds on neutrino oscillation parameters accounting for lepton asymmetry are presented .

cond-mat9707237

the slow relaxation of density in granular materials under tapping has attracted much theoretical interest recently @xcite since knight @xmath0 @xmath1 @xcite carried out systematical experimental measurements of density as a function of time for a vibrated granular material . the experimental data of knight @xmath0 @xmath1 @xcite can be most satisfactorily fitted using a functional form : @xmath2}\ ] ] where @xmath3 is the average density in the system at time instant @xmath4 . here @xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath7 and @xmath8 are constant parameters . this four parameter fit was obtained from experimental data without theoretical motivation . previous theoretical models predicted different functional forms . in the model of barker and mehta @xcite , particles can relax both independently , as individual particles , and collectively , as clusters . their model leads to a sum of two exponential terms , which is not in accord with the logarithmic form of eq.(1 ) . the model proposed by hong @xmath0 @xmath1 @xcite is based on a diffusing void picture . it predicts a power law dependence of height reduction as a function of time , @xmath9 with @xmath10 , which means that the density increases linearly until saturation . using frustrated ising models , herrmann and his collaborators @xcite gave a numerical confirmation of the logarithmic density relaxation as eq . ( [ log ] ) in their monte carlo simulations . in their models , frustration plays a crucial role . they claim that frustration is generated in granular materials by the steric constraints imposed by the hard core repulsion of neighboring grains and the subsequent interlocking . the link of the frustrated lattice gas models to real granular packing is explained in refs . @xcite . in this paper , we propose a one dimensional discrete lattice model for granular compaction under tapping based on a simple physical picture . numerical solutions to the model equation indicate that the density relaxes in a logarithmic manner , precisely as eq . we also solve the continuum version of the model analytically in the asympototic limit ( @xmath11 ) to confirm eq . this paper is organized as follows . section ii presents the model equation . numerical and analytical solutions to the equation are given in sections iii and iv respectively . section v is devoted to discussion . the density of particles @xmath12 should satisfy the continuity equation : @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the current density . we may rule out any simple density gradient term in the current density which leads to isotropic diffusion , since the thermal energy is too small to triger the motion of grains . the current density may be written as a product of density and velocity : @xmath15 to specify the the functional form of velocity , let us consider a one dimensional lattice model along z direction . gravity is along the negative z axis . in the absence of tapping , motion of grains under the action of gravity is possible only when the geometric constraint is satisfied , i.e. , enough void space below the grain . if @xmath16 is the particle density , the void density at the site just below is @xmath17 . therefore , the velocity is nonzero only when the ratio @xmath18 less than @xmath19 . this means a step function for the velocity @xmath20 : @xmath21 in the absence of tapping . the effect of tapping in granular compaction is to overcome the bottleneck effect , i.e. , to make the geometric constraints not as strict as the above . motion of grains is also possible when @xmath22 with the help of tapping . we may therefore replace the above step function with a peak function of an exponential form : @xmath23 where @xmath24 and @xmath25 are constants dependent of the vibrational intensity @xmath26 with the amplitude @xmath27 and the frequency @xmath28 of oscillation and @xmath29 the gravitational constant . the precise @xmath30dependences of @xmath25 and @xmath24 are beyond the scope of the present theory . substituting eq . ( [ vel ] ) and eq . ( [ flux ] ) into eq . ( [ con ] ) , we obtain our model equation for density relaxation : @xmath31 with @xmath32 where @xmath33 is infinitesimal in the continuum limit . this model is defined more definitely on a lattice : @xmath34 where @xmath35 is given by eq . ( [ current ] ) putting @xmath36 . in order to solve numerically eq . ( [ model ] ) , we supply two fixed boundary conditions , @xmath37 at the bottom and @xmath38 at the top of the system . the following discrete version of eq . ( [ latticemodel ] ) ensures no flux at the boundaries , i.e. , conservation of particle density as a whole is ensured at each time step @xmath39 with @xmath35 given by eq . ( @xmath40 ) with @xmath36 . we update \{@xmath41 } according to eq . ( [ rule ] ) from random initial conditions with \{@xmath42 } equal to random numbers distributed uniformly from @xmath43 to @xmath44 . 1 shows snapshots of density profiles at three different time steps . we see that as particles move downward voids move upward and pile at the top . as soon as we start updating from a random initial configuration , a sharp interface between a particle phase and a void phase begins to emerge . its position can be easily identified as the location where density changes sharply from non zero value to zero . since the position of the interface takes only integer values on the lattice and information extracted from it is therefore limited , we resort to calculate the position of center of mass @xmath45 & = & \sum_{z=1}^{l } z \rho(z , t).\end{aligned}\ ] ] we take it for granted that the average density measured in experiments is proportional to the inverse of @xmath46 . we determine the proportional prefactor as follows . the minimum value of h can be obtained from a density distribution of a step function , i.e. , @xmath47 which is actually a static solution to the model equation eq . ( [ rule ] ) . here @xmath48 is determined by the density conservation and is a time independent quantity : @xmath49 . the value of @xmath50 corresponding to eq . ( [ step ] ) is @xmath51 . we therefore use the following expression for the average density @xmath52 starting from random initial configurations , we discard the data for initial transient time period and do not make computation of @xmath3 until at the interface between the particle phase and the void phase the density jumps from zero to some reasonably finite value . our density of unity corresponds to the densest close packing and it sets the scale for density . for the case of sphearical particles in reality , the densest close packing has a density of about 0.64 while the mechanically least stable configurations have the most loose value of about 0.55 @xcite ( in our scale 0.859 ) . 2 shows one typical plot of @xmath3 calculated from the lattice model . the time step when we start calculating @xmath3 in fig . 2 is set to be the time origin . it is the instant when the density gap at the interface is about @xmath53 in our density scale . the numerical data in fig . 2 can be very well fitted by the logarithmic form of eq . ( [ log ] ) , which is also shown in the figure . 3 displays two density profiles at different time steps for the particle phase while zero density in the void phase is not plotted . we find that the density profile can be fitted by the following expression @xmath54^{\beta(t)}.\ ] ] where @xmath55 , @xmath56 and @xmath57 are time dependent parameters . the fit to the numerical data is also plotted in fig . 3 . in the whole range the density is step - function - like @xmath58 where @xmath59 is the location of the interface . ( [ z - step ] ) is different from the generalized fermi dirac distribution proposed by hayakawa and hong @xcite and found by herrmann and his collaborators in simulations of frustrated ising models @xcite . the generalized fermi dirac distribution does not have a singularity in the density profile but changes continuously from larger values to zero rapidly within a boundary layer whose width is determined by one of the parameters in the distribution . on the other hand , our model gives a sharp interface between the particle phase and the void phase and therefore the model does not permit any density value smaller than the most loose density for granular compaction . in this sense , we may say that in addition to the granular solid phase and the void phase the generalized fermi dirac distribution allows a granular @xmath60 phase where density changes drastically @xcite . our model describes only the granular compaction under tapping where the grains do not fly as in a gas ( and therefore no inertia terms appear in the velocity expression eq . ( [ vel ] ) ) . as we observed in the simulations , there is always a sharp interface between the particle phase and the void phase . we may therefore generally postulate the solution to eq . ( [ model ] ) as @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the step function such that @xmath63 for @xmath64 and @xmath65 for @xmath66 . we now determine the time dependence of the location of the interface @xmath59 by solving the equation in its continuum version , eq . ( [ model ] ) . substituting eq . ( [ 0 ] ) into the left hand side of eq . ( [ model ] ) , we obtain @xmath67 where dot stands for time deriative . the @xmath68 function in eq . ( [ 0 ] ) gives us the following @xmath69 in eq . ( [ current ] ) @xmath70 & = & f(a(z , t ) , a_{-}(z , t ) ) \theta(b(t ) - z)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath71 stands for the value of @xmath72 just below @xmath73 , i.e. @xmath74 with infinitesimal @xmath33 . here @xmath75 thus , the right hand side of eq . ( [ model ] ) reads @xmath76 integrating the right hand sides of eq . ( [ 1 ] ) and of eq . ( [ 2 ] ) from @xmath77 to @xmath78 and taking the limit of @xmath79 , we obtain @xmath80 now we make an approximation . from the simulations we know that @xmath81 depends on @xmath73 very weakly . the parameter @xmath57 in eq . ( [ z - dep ] ) decreases as time increases . when @xmath11 , @xmath82 . we therefore make the following aussmption in the asymptotic limit of @xmath11 @xmath83 the conservation of total density is then expressed as @xmath84 with the same @xmath48 as in eq . ( [ step ] ) . using eq . ( [ atinterface ] ) , eq . ( [ ass1 ] ) and eq . ( [ ass2 ] ) we have @xmath85 letting @xmath86 leads in the asymptotoc limit ( @xmath87 ) @xmath88 where @xmath89 is constant . putting @xmath90 , we have @xmath91 now we integrate eq . ( [ x ] ) for @xmath4 from @xmath92 to @xmath4 and for @xmath93 from @xmath94 to @xmath95 where @xmath96 and @xmath97 are the average density ( i.e. , a(t ) ) of the particle phase at time @xmath92 and @xmath4 respectively @xmath98 the asymptotic solution of eq . ( [ int_1 ] ) is readily obtained by using the formular @xmath99 and the expansion for @xmath100 @xmath101.\ ] ] the final form for eq . ( [ int_1 ] ) is given by @xmath102 with @xmath103 . this can be rewritten as @xmath104 where , however , the first two terms are negligible compared with the third one for the left side , so that we obtain the final form of the average density @xmath105 this is precisely the same form as eq . ( [ log ] ) . the form of eq . ( [ final ] ) perfectly agrees with the simulations as shown in fig . we have shown that the discrete lattice model eq . ( [ latticemodel ] ) exhibits an anomalously slow density relaxation . although our model is quite simple , it contains essential features of granular materials that granular particle can move only when there is enough void below the particle . tapping the system weakens this constraint and we have taken into account this property by assuming the velocity as eq . ( [ vel ] ) . in this way , the logarithmic time dependence has been obtained , which is consistent with experiments . to our knowledge , no model equation in terms of space time coordinates , which produces a logarithmic relaxation , has been available so far in granular systems . the analytical study indicates that the logarithmic relaxation originates from the factor @xmath106 $ ] in the velocity eq . ( [ vel ] ) . when @xmath107 , the velocity becomes extremely small whereas it is finite when @xmath108 . thus we expect that the logarithmic relaxation occurs as far as the system processes this property independent of the detailed form of the velocity . actually , we have confirmed by simulations that the velocity such as @xmath109 leads to the essentially same relaxation and the existence of a sharp interface in the density profile . this fact implies a universal feature of the logarithmic relaxation not only restricted to granular materials but also for other systems where velocity vanishes abruptly like an essential singularity when the density exceeds some threshold value . this work was supported by grant in aid of ministry of education , science and culture of japan . g. p. appreciates discussions with dr . ruihong yue and thanks the japan society for the promotion of science . a. coniglio and h. j. herrmann , physica a * 225 * , 1 ( 1996 ) . m. nicodemi , a. coniglio , and h. j. herrmann , phys . rev . e * 55 * , 3962 ( 1997 ) . m. nicodemi , a. coniglio , and h. j. herrmann , j. phys . a * 30 * , l379 ( 1997 ) . m. nicodemi , a. coniglio , and h. j. herrmann , physica a * 240 * , 405 ( 1997 ) . s. j. linz , phys . e * 54 * , 2925 ( 1996 ) . j. b. knight , c. g. fandrich , c. n. lau , h. m. jaeger , and s. r. nagel , phys . e * 51 * , 3957 ( 1995 ) . g. c. barker and a. mehta , phys . e * 47 * , 184 ( 1993 ) . d. c. hong , s. yue , j. k. rudra , m. y. choi , and y. w. kim , phys . e * 50 * , 4123 ( 1994 ) . g. y. onoda and e. g. liniger , phys . lett . * 64 * , 2727 ( 1990 ) . h. hayakawa and d. c. hong , phys . . lett . * 78 * , 2764(1997 ) .

on the basis of physical considerations we propose a one dimensional discrete lattice model for the density relaxation of granular materials under tapping . solving the difference equation numerically , we find a logarithmic time dependence of the density relaxation . this is in agreement with experimental results of knight @xmath0 @xmath1 [ phys . rev . e * 51 * , 3957(1995 ) ] . the origin of this anomalous relaxation is elucidated analytically by solving the equation of its continuum version asymptotically in time . pacs numbers : 46.10.+z , 05.40.+j , 05.60.+w

hep-th0606140

the theory of inflation provides an explanation for many observed properties of our visible universe , in particular its homogeneity and isotropy ( see e.g. @xcite and @xcite for reviews ) . it also gives an explanation for the origin of small density perturbations which eventually gave rise to the structures in our universe . these aspects are well understood . however , from the particle physics point of view , a suitable candidate for the inflaton field has yet to be found @xcite . among the many candidates , hybrid inflation @xcite is a particularly well motivated one , especially in supersymmetric models @xcite@xcite . there has been a lot of recent work investigating the possibility of realising inflation within string theory ( see e.g. @xcite@xcite for reviews ) . the most natural framework for brane inflation is the brane - antibrane system where an attractive force leads to a potential for the interbrane distance @xcite@xcite . inflation ends with an open string tachyonic instability similar to hybrid inflation . this scenario has been extensively studied and leads to interesting phenomena such as @xmath4-string formation at the end of inflation . one particular issue in these models comes from the need for moduli stabilisation during inflation . if this is not achieved , the potential for the moduli is of runaway type destroying the existence of slow roll inflation . this problem can be circumvented using the kklt scenario whereby the kahler moduli are stabilised once the complex moduli have been stabilised and non - perturbative gaugino condensation has occurred on d7 branes @xcite . the coupling to inflation has been studied in kklmmt where a fine - tuning of the inflaton superpotential has been advocated @xcite . one can also use a shift symmetry to alleviate the @xmath2 problem @xcite@xcite . another way of realising hybrid inflation in string models can be obtained using the d3/d7 system , see e.g. @xcite@xcite . in this case the end of inflation happens at a lower scale than the planck scale , when the charged open string fields between the branes condense . the d3/d7 system can be modelled using an @xmath5 supersymmetric @xmath4-term inflation model @xcite . the interbrane distance plays the role of the inflaton and the charged open strings between the branes are the waterfall fields . when the supergravity corrections are neglected , i.e. in global supersymmetry , and assuming that the kahler moduli have been stabilised , the inflaton direction is flat . slow roll inflation is driven by the one loop logarithmic corrections as the one loop quadratic divergences are inflaton - independent . in this paper , we are investigating @xmath0-term hybrid inflation with the inflationary superpotential @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the @xmath8 gauge coupling , in the presence of additional moduli fields . it would be very interesting to derive the origin of @xmath9 from fundamental string theory @xcite . we treat the supergravity case going beyond the global supersymmetry analysis . we show that the treatment of fayet - iliopoulos @xmath4-terms ( i.e. when @xmath10 ) needs extra care in supergravity . to include such a term would require additional fields and the study of their stabilisation . for simplicity we therefore do not include inflationary @xmath4-terms in our models . inflation is then driven by the presence of the non - vanishing @xmath9 . we show that supergravity corrections , and supergravity - induced interactions with a moduli sector induce a tree level slope and mass for the inflaton @xcite . moreover there are additional contributions from the quadratic divergence part of the one - loop corrections , since they are inflaton - dependent in supergravity , as opposed to inflaton - independent in global supersymmetry . in general these effects spoil the flatness of the inflationary potential . we show that most of the tree - level problems can be removed by including shift symmetries in the inflaton sector , and taking the moduli sector to be no - scale . it then appears that a viable slow - roll inflation model can be found with limited fine - tuning of the moduli sector . however we also find that the coupling between the inflaton and the moduli has the effect of inducing a small variation of the moduli during inflation . despite the small size of this variation , it gives a significant contribution to the inflaton slope and violates slow - roll inflation . the paper is arranged as follows . in section [ sec : v ] , we construct the full potential for our combined model of inflation and moduli stabilisation . we calculate tree and one loop level parts of the potential , and describe symmetries which help maintain the flatness of the inflaton potential . in section [ sec : mod ] we determine the role of moduli fields during inflation , and show their effect is significant . we find the constraints corresponding to the cobe normalisation and the wmap3 spectral index constraint in section [ sec : con ] . our arguments and analysis apply to a general moduli sector , although as a specific example , we also give explicit results for the kklt model , which has just one moduli field @xmath11 . in section [ sec : kklt ] we study particular choices of racetrack superpotentials for the kklt scenario , and find that the running of the moduli field during inflation typically leads to a large value of @xmath2 . a small value of @xmath2 could only be achieved if the moduli superpotential is heavily fine - tuned . finally in section [ sec : nogo ] we consider models where a minkowski vacuum after inflation is obtained without the need for a lifting term . a model with this property is also interesting as it may give a small gravitino mass , as is required to have an low energy sparticle spectrum . we derive a no - go theorem which states that , for no - scale models with no lifting term , no such stable supersymmetry breaking minkowski vacua can be found . we conclude in section [ sec : conc ] . as already discussed , many string theory inflation scenarios can be modelled at low energy with a supergravity description of hybrid inflation . the system uses three fields , the inflaton @xmath12 measuring the inter - brane distance and two charged fields @xmath13 ( which in the d3/d7 system would represent the open strings between the two types of branes ) . the fields interact according to the superpotential ( [ inflasec ] ) with @xmath10 , which has been studied extensively in the literature . in @xcite it was shown how the fayet - iliopoulos @xmath4-term arose from fluxes on the d7 brane , allowing @xmath4-term inflation in this system . here we will focus almost exclusively on hybrid inflation which is driven only by @xmath0-terms ( so @xmath14 ) , although exactly how such terms are embedded in string theory remains to be found . including inflationary @xmath4-terms in a supergravity theory creates extra complications , as we will discuss in the following subsection . using ( [ inflasec ] ) and taking to @xmath15 we obtain @xmath16 this potential has an @xmath17 origin which was derived in @xcite . during inflation , when the waterfall fields @xmath18 , the potential is @xmath19 which gives a positive contribution to the inflation energy . extending this model to a supergravity theory , and working in units with @xmath20 , we replace the above @xmath0-term by @xmath21 where @xmath22 , and @xmath23 is the kahler potential for @xmath12 and @xmath13 . the simplest possibility would be @xmath24 . it was originally thought that extending the @xmath4-term in the above model to sugra would be straightforward . however it was later discovered that in order to have a fayet - iliopoulos term @xmath25 appearing in a supergravity theory , the superpotential must have charge @xmath26 @xcite . thus the extension of ( [ susyinf ] ) to sugra described in the earlier paper @xcite requires reconsideration . to preserve the properties of @xmath12 and its role as the inflaton , it should be uncharged @xcite . this is only possible when @xmath10 and the charges of @xmath13 are shifted to @xmath27 , where @xmath28 . now all the contributions to @xmath29 from any other sectors of the theory would also have to be charged . this would be for instance the case with the mssm superpotential . since they are , _ a priori _ , unrelated to inflation , this seems unnatural . hence we have an incompatibility between a non - vanishing @xmath9 and a fayet - iliopoulos term @xmath25 . in the usual inflationary scenario , inflation is driven by the fayet - iliopoulos term . one possibility is to introduce a fayet - iliopoulos term with a gauge invariant superpotential . this can be achieved in supergravity with a @xmath4-term by making the @xmath30 pseudo - anomalous . we extend the model to include one modulus @xmath31 and matter fields @xmath32 , all of which are charged under the pseudo - anomalous @xmath30 gauge group . the relevant part of the kahler potential for these fields is @xmath33 where the gauge field , @xmath34 has been included ( the usual kahler potential appearing in the scalar potential expression is obtained by putting @xmath35 formally ) . the potential arising from the @xmath4-term is then @xmath36 where we have taken the gauge coupling function to be @xmath37 in order to cancel the @xmath30 anomaly . we see that a fayet - iliopoulos term can give rise to inflation when @xmath10 , assuming that @xmath31 and @xmath32 can be stabilised by a suitable superpotential . during inflation , the waterfall fields @xmath13 vanish . this implies that the @xmath30 @xmath4-term and the @xmath9 dependent part of the @xmath0-term potential give rise to the inflation energy @xmath38 when @xmath10 and the extra fields are stable , this resembles the usual inflation energy in hybrid inflation . if on the other hand we just use the @xmath0-term to give inflation , there is no need to introduce the additional fields @xmath32 and @xmath31 . the fayet - iliopoulos @xmath4-term must then be zero , due to the gauge invariance of @xmath29 , so @xmath39 . we will take @xmath40 and assume this is the case for the rest of the paper . the string theory origin for @xmath9 has yet to be found @xcite . we are interested in the hybrid inflation scenario based on the superpotential above ( [ inflasec ] ) . we are also taking into account the effects of a separate sector , so the total superpotential is @xmath41 the @xmath42 are moduli and matter fields , which are usually assumed to be stable during inflation . with one modulus in @xmath0-theory no stabilisation was obtained @xcite . here we consider the most general case in supergravity with more than one moduli field and generic superpotential @xmath43 . the moduli dependent part of the superpotential @xmath43 is then responsible for stabilising the moduli fields . the total kahler potential has the form @xmath44 with @xmath45 we have imposed two shift symmetries in the @xmath46 sector to alleviate the @xmath2 problem of supergravity inflation . this is an extension to the usual @xmath12 shift symmetry @xcite@xcite . in string theory , this corresponds to the translational invariance of the brane system . for the full superpotential ( [ wfull ] ) , the @xmath0-term part of the potential can be expanded as @xmath47 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath48 denotes the real part of @xmath49 , and we have defined @xmath50 there is also a contribution to @xmath51 from the @xmath4-term @xmath52}\left(|\phi^+|^2 - |\phi^-|^2\right)^2 \ , .\ ] ] in this paper we will be particularly interested in kahler potentials with the no - scale property , such as @xmath53 in the kklt scenario . in this case the above expressions reduce to @xmath54 at the end of inflation , the charged fields @xmath13 condense and the inflaton @xmath12 is zero . the @xmath30 @xmath4-term part of the potential is then zero , and @xmath0-term part reduces to @xmath55 . this part of @xmath56 , which comes from the moduli dependent part of the superpotential @xmath43 , is then responsible for stabilising the moduli fields . for @xmath57 its minimum is an @xmath58 vacuum where supersymmetry is preserved , i.e. @xmath59 for all the fields . since we want a minkowski vacuum at the end of inflation , it is necessary to add an additional lifting term , @xmath60 to the potential . in the kklt scenario a non - supersymmetric lifting term is used @xmath61 where @xmath62 depending on the origin of the term , i.e. @xmath63 for anti d3-branes and @xmath64 for fluxes on @xmath65 branes . an alternative possibility is that the minimum is raised by an uplifting @xmath4-term @xcite . this allows one to lift the @xmath58 vacuum while avoiding the need for a non - supersymmetric potential . in this case the set of fields @xmath42 comprises one modulus @xmath11 and matter fields @xmath66 , all of which are charged under a second , pseudo - anomalous @xmath67 gauge group . the kahler potential in the moduli sector can be written as @xmath68 unlike the kklt case it is not no - scale , although it is straightforward to write down a no - scale version . the potential arising from the @xmath4-term for the additional @xmath67 is then @xmath69 if @xmath70 and all @xmath71 are positive , this potential will be nonzero and provide a suitable lifting term . as explained in @xcite , an @xmath58 vacuum in supergravity can not normally be lifted by @xmath4-terms . one can circumvent this argument by using non - analytic superpotentials with positive definite @xmath4-terms , as described in @xcite . the total moduli stabilisation potential is then @xmath72 where @xmath73 is given by , for example , ( [ nslift ] ) or ( [ dlift ] ) . after inflation , the potential possesses a minkowski vacuum thanks to the presence of the lifting term . for the rest of the paper we will only concentrate on the case where there are no additional matter fields @xmath66 . this implies that the gauge invariance of the superpotential can only be maintained if @xmath11 is gauge invariant , and we must use the non - supersymmetric lifting term ( [ nslift ] ) . this is the minimal setting to study hybrid inflation coupled to moduli . the structure of this potential is rather rich due to the possible interplay between the moduli and other fields . during hybrid inflation , the fields @xmath13 vanish , and the inflaton field is real , so @xmath74 . the full ( tree - level ) potential then reads @xmath75 where we have identified @xmath76 and @xmath77 in addition to the terms above , there will be contributions from loop corrections , which we will discuss in the next subsection . note that the inflaton is much smaller than the planck mass , i.e.@xmath78 is such that @xmath79 . during inflation , the minkowski vacuum is lifted by @xmath80 . we see that in general we will get large , tree - level contributions to the slope and mass of the inflaton @xcite ( from @xmath81 and @xmath82 respectively ) . in other words the model has @xmath1 and @xmath2 problems . this new @xmath2 problem comes from the inclusion of the moduli sector , and is distinct from the usual @xmath2 problem which comes from embedding inflation in supergravity . in the case of no - scale models @xmath83 , and so this @xmath2 problem can be removed by a symmetry of the kahler potential @xmath84 . to obtain a small inflaton slope , we will need to fine tune @xmath81 . the form of the potential discussed so far was based on the hybrid inflationary epoch , in which the fields @xmath85 vanish . inflation ends when the mass matrix acquires a tachyonic direction . this usually occurs when one of the two charged fields @xmath13 ( or a combination thereof ) has a negative mass , i.e. when @xmath86 . without moduli fields , this instability occurs at @xmath87 . however , the inclusion of the moduli sector modifies this result . for simplicity we take @xmath83 in what follows ( as is the case for a no - scale @xmath84 ) . working out the mass matrix for the @xmath13 sector , we find @xmath88 where we have assumed @xmath29 to be real . if @xmath89 , we recover the standard result @xmath87 . however , due to the presence of the moduli fields , the value of @xmath90 is altered . note that if we had used a more general @xmath23 , which did not have the shift symmetries , then @xmath90 would have received far more corrections . taking a canonical kahler potential , and neglecting the contributions of order @xmath81 in the regime @xmath91 , the lowest mass is given by @xmath92\ , .\ ] ] we see that if @xmath93 , inflation never ends as the mass is always positive . we naturally expect that @xmath29 will be much larger than the inflation scale @xmath9 in order to stabilise moduli during inflation . we see that both shift symmetries must be included in @xmath94 for inflation to be viable . in the above discussion we have considered how the moduli sector will alter inflation . of course we must not forget that the inflationary sector can also interfere with the moduli stabilisation , since the inflation potential @xmath80 acts as a perturbation of the moduli potential @xmath95 . in the kklt scenario the minimum of @xmath96 is separated from @xmath97 ( which also has @xmath98 ) by a potential barrier . denoting the height of the barrier by @xmath99 , we see that the value of the above potential ( [ inflapotential ] ) must be less than @xmath99 during inflation , or the modulus field @xmath11 will roll off to infinity , and inflation will not finish in the correct vacuum . the slope terms in the above potential must be small ( in order to have slow - roll inflation ) , so we need @xmath100 . this guarantees that the minimum of the moduli potential is only shifted during inflation and not completely destroyed . typically @xmath101 , where @xmath102 is the energy of the ads minimum of @xmath51 ( if @xmath73 were absent ) . this provides a rough estimate of the barrier height . in this case we need @xmath103 , which is reasonable if the inflation scale is far below the moduli stabilisation scale . the one - loop corrections to the effective potential for a general theory , with cut - off @xmath104 , are @xcite @xmath105 the supertrace is @xmath106 . expressions for the boson and fermion mass matrices are given in the appendix . as long as the masses are below the cut - off scale , the log corrections are smaller than the quadratic divergences . this is guaranteed provided the potential @xmath43 is lower than the cut - off , i.e. lower than the planck scale in practice . this is also a phenomenological requirement in order to obtain a hierarchy between the planck mass and the gravitino mass . we therefore concentrate on the quadratic divergences in what follows . we see there are corrections to all parts of the inflationary potential ( [ inflapotential ] ) . in particular we find @xmath107\right ) e^k \ , .\ ] ] in general , the corrections to the other parts of the potential are complicated , and not particularly illuminating . for simplicity we will explicitly consider the case for one modulus field only , i.e.@xmath108 . we will use @xmath109 . in the minkowski background @xmath110 during inflation we have instead @xmath111 we see that the loop corrections are @xmath12 dependent . note that we have included not only the contributions from @xmath13 , but also those from the moduli sector . for the kklt scenario , we find the tree - level potential to be ( after taking @xmath11 to be real ) @xmath112 where @xmath113 . adding on the loop corrections ( [ strmink ] ) gives the full potential for the minkowski background @xmath114 - \frac{w w'}{2t^2}\left[1+\frac{\lambda^2}{8 \pi^2}\right ] -\frac{w^2}{t^3 } \frac{\lambda^2}{32 \pi^2 } \\ \nonumber & & { } + \frac{e}{(2t)^n}\left[1+\frac{\lambda^2 n(n+1)}{48 \pi^2}\right ] \ , . \label{kkltvs}\end{aligned}\ ] ] adding the loop corrections will change the value of @xmath11 at the minimum . furthermore the minimum will no longer be minkowski . the parameter @xmath115 needs to be re - tuned to fix this . during inflation , i.e. @xmath12 non - vanishing , we get @xmath116 to which we need to add the loop corrections ( [ strinf ] ) . in this paper , we take the cut off at the planck scale . hence , as long as @xmath117 and @xmath29 do not vanish during inflation , the radiative corrections induce a slope for the inflationary potential , which is dependent on @xmath29 , and which can in principle be a danger to the flatness of the inflationary potential . this effect is only present in supergravity , as in global supersymmetry the quadratic divergences are @xmath12 independent . for one modulus field @xmath11 , the full potential during inflation now reads @xmath118 for @xmath11 real , the full moduli stabilisation potential is given above ( [ kkltvs ] ) . we denote the value of @xmath11 at the minimum of @xmath119 by @xmath120 . similarly @xmath121 - w \frac{\lambda^2}{4 \pi^2 } \label{kkltv1}\ ] ] @xmath122 as it is a no - scale model , the only contribution to @xmath123 comes from loop corrections . in this section we will discuss the form of the effective inflationary potential , taking into account the moduli stabilisation mechanism . it is usually assumed that moduli fields are stabilised before inflation begins . the energy scale of the corresponding potential is much higher than that of inflation , and so the effects of the inflaton will not significantly alter the values of the moduli fields . it therefore seems reasonable to assume the moduli are fixed during inflation . as we will show , this is not the case . let us now analyse the moduli stabilisation mechanism when the inflation sector is present . we denote the values of the moduli fields at the minimum of @xmath124 by @xmath125 , and define @xmath126 to be the deviation of the moduli fields from this value . expanding the inflationary potential around this minimum we find @xmath127 where @xmath128 are independent combinations of @xmath129 and @xmath130 which satisfy @xmath131 @xmath132 . minimising this with respect to @xmath128 , we find @xmath133 so we see that the moduli fields are now stabilised along a valley depending on @xmath12 . if @xmath134 ( which is perfectly reasonable ) , then @xmath135 , and the variation of the moduli fields is tiny , as is usually assumed . the correction to the inflationary potential is tiny too . however the slope of @xmath51 is also tiny , and so the contribution of the moduli fields can be comparable to the other effects we are considering . hence it is not reasonable to ignore their variation during inflation after all . now if we substitute the above expression ( [ yeq ] ) back into the potential ( [ vy ] ) , we obtain the effective inflationary potential @xmath136 with slope @xmath137 and effective mass @xmath138 \ , .\ ] ] we remind the reader that loop corrections are included in these expressions . hence , we see for a wide range of models ( including the kklt scenario ) that @xmath139 , and so the inflaton is tachyonic . this tachyonic instability is not necessarily a problem if @xmath12 is small , or the mass term is subdominant . since we need the field to roll towards zero during inflation we also require that @xmath140 is positive . it is tempting to use a moduli sector whose superpotential satisfies @xmath141 at the minimum , since @xmath142 in this case , and so we automatically avoid any large contributions to the slow - roll parameter @xmath1 . this type of model has other appealing features , such as a small gravitino mass @xcite . if we consider just one moduli field @xmath11 , and take a no - scale @xmath84 , then we see from ( [ kkltv2 ] ) that loop corrections give a small negative inflaton mass . the effects of the moduli variation will make it even more negative . even if this mass is small , it will still dominate the behaviour of @xmath12 , and cause it to roll away from zero . hence we see that a moduli potential with @xmath143 at its minimum ( i.e. unbroken supersymmetry ) can not be successfully combined with @xmath0-term hybrid inflation . we have established that during inflation the effective potential has the leading order form @xmath144 with @xmath140 positive and @xmath145 negative . the potential has the form of an inverted parabola . since we want inflation to end by the tachyonic instability of the @xmath146-field , @xmath12 has to roll towards zero . this means that during inflation @xmath147 . thus , an additional constraint on the model parameters is that @xmath148 , as given in ( [ phiend ] ) . to get an idea about the allowed parameter ranges for the theory , making only modest assumptions about the moduli sector , we provide some general constraints on potentials of the form ( [ workingmodel ] ) , leaving @xmath149 , @xmath140 and @xmath145 as free parameters , but with @xmath145 negative . note that @xmath149 , @xmath140 and @xmath145 depend on the underlying theory and are _ not _ independent . as shown in the previous section , they depend on the details of the moduli sector as well as the parameters @xmath7 and @xmath9 . an inflationary model has to satisfy certain constraints in order to agree with observations . firstly , in order to realise a period of slow - roll inflation , the two slow - roll parameters @xmath150 and @xmath151 have to be small ( we have approximated @xmath152 during inflation ) . also , in order to get the right amplitude for the density perturbations from inflation , the cobe normalisation must hold @xcite @xmath153 the current wmap+2dfgrs constraint on the spectral index is @xcite @xmath154 ( a weaker bound has been found in @xcite ) . in the case that @xmath155 , the above two constraints are fulfilled when @xmath156 and @xmath157 the constant @xmath140 can be eliminated from the last expression , using ( [ norm ] ) . since @xmath145 is negative and @xmath158 , this restricts the parameters to be in the region ( in planck units ) @xmath159 implying an upper bound for the inflationary scale of order @xmath160 gev . the allowed region in the @xmath161 plane is shown in figure 1 . [ ] [ ] [ 2]@xmath149 [ ] [ ] [ 2]@xmath145 the parameters @xmath80 , @xmath140 and @xmath145 depend on the details of the moduli superpotential as well as on @xmath7 and @xmath9 . in order to generate slow - roll inflation , we require that @xmath162 and @xmath163 note that if we had not included the contribution from the variation of the moduli fields , we would instead have @xmath164 . in general , the above contributions to @xmath2 from the moduli sector are likely to be large . we see this type of model may have another @xmath2 problem , which is not removed by the symmetries we used in section [ sec : v ] to avoid the other two @xmath2 problems . using ( [ v0con ] ) , which follows from the cobe and spectral index constraints ( [ cobe ] ) and ( [ nsconstr ] ) , we find that @xmath165 this is consistent with @xmath166 , as we have assumed ( and is required , for example , for @xmath96 to retain its minimum during inflation ) . finally , for the maximal allowed value of @xmath167 gev , the relative contribution of gravitational waves @xmath168 is 13 percent . however , it can be easily shown that the field variation @xmath169 during inflation , related to the e - fold number by @xmath170 is larger than @xmath171 ( with @xmath172 ) , as long as @xmath173 gev . since field variations below the planck scale are preferred theoretically , its very likely that the predicted amount of gravitational waves is much lower . here we study the stability of the modulus during inflation . in particular , the previous approximation of assuming that the moduli potential is quadratic when perturbed by the inflaton is only valid if the inflaton does not remove the potential barrier between the inflation minimum and infinity . we have to ensure that the term linear in @xmath12 in the potential is not too big , otherwise this term will completely destabilise the modulus @xmath11 . the condition for this to happen is that for at least 60 e - folds of inflation the term linear in @xmath12 in ( [ vinf ] ) is smaller than the barrier height , @xmath99 . typically @xmath174 which implies @xmath175 using ( [ nfold ] ) to eliminate @xmath169 from this equation , we get @xmath176 where we have used @xmath177 ( ignoring loop corrections ) , and have dropped numbers of order one . using the cobe normalisation , we get @xmath178 where @xmath179 . this is the condition guaranteeing that the modulus is not destabilised during inflation . it states that the gravitino mass is never small . in terms of the soft breaking terms and the sparticle spectrum obtained with a large gravitino mass , this implies that the scalar sparticles have very large masses . this is the type of scalar spectrum advocated in split susy models @xcite . of course if one is to observe scalars at the lhc , the scalars can not be very massive and the gravitino mass must be reduced . this requires a superpotential which gives a small gravitino mass , but which still produces a stabilisation potential with a high barrier . the model in subsection [ ssec : eg2 ] has these properties . it is even possible to have @xmath180 and still stabilise the moduli in a minkowski vacuum , as described in @xcite . in this case there is no lifting term @xmath73 , and the vacuum is supersymmetric . we could then obtain a gravitino mass from additional supersymmetry breaking effects . as we will show in section [ sec : nogo ] , if the vacuum is be minkowski , the susy - breaking must involve a lifting term . otherwise the vacuum will be unstable . as has already been noted , the parameters @xmath149 , @xmath140 and @xmath145 are not independent , but depend on details of the moduli sector as well as on @xmath7 and @xmath9 . as a simple example we will discuss the kklt scenario @xcite , which has just one modulus field @xmath11 and uses a non - supersymmetric lifting term ( [ nslift ] ) . during inflation the full potential is then given by ( [ kkltvs ] ) and ( [ vinf])([kkltv2 ] ) . the stabilisation potential s minimum is at @xmath181 , so @xmath182 . this allows us to eliminate @xmath115 , and one other parameter . following @xcite , we will use a racetrack superpotential @xmath183 where @xmath184 , @xmath185 , @xmath186 and @xmath187 are real constants . the above superpotential comes from gaugino condensation . we take @xmath188 and @xmath189 to guarantee the validity of the supergravity approximation and the weak gauge coupling limit . let us first focus on the kklt model obtained with @xmath190 and @xmath191 . to leading order this gives @xmath192 and @xmath193\ , , \qquad \tilde v_2 = -\frac{\lambda^2}{4 \pi^2 } \ , , \nonumber \\ & & ( e^k\tilde v_1)'\approx -\frac{a a^2}{4t_0 ^ 2 } e^{-at_0 } \left[1+\frac{\lambda^2}{8\pi^2}\right ] \ , , \qquad \lambda \approx \frac{a^2 a^4}{3t_0}e^{-2at_0 } \left[1+\frac{\lambda^2}{8\pi^2}\right ] \ , , \label{eg1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath194 . during inflation we also require the slow roll parameter @xmath195 ^ 2 < 1 $ ] . we see above that @xmath196 , and so we need @xmath197 . we observe that @xmath123 is small , suggesting @xmath2 is small too . however there are also corrections to @xmath2 from the modulus field variation during inflation ( see section [ sec : mod ] ) , which can not be ignored . these imply @xmath198')^2}{e^k \lambda}\right ) \ , . \label{neweta}\ ] ] we see that for the above choice of @xmath0-term model , the slow - roll parameter is found to be negative , independent of the parameters , and large : @xmath199 . this value is not compatible with the slow - roll condition and , hence , not compatible with observational constraints . in general there could also be corrections to @xmath2 from variations of the imaginary part of @xmath11 . however for the examples in this section we find that the potential is always minimised at @xmath200 , even during inflation . another constraint on the model comes from requiring that the minimum of @xmath201 does not disappear during inflation . this would be the case if @xmath202 . for the above example we find that the maximum of the potential is at @xmath203 , with @xmath204/[n+(5n-6)\lambda^2/(24\pi^2)]$ ] . the barrier height is then @xmath205 \ , .\ ] ] we see that @xmath206 , as we assumed in the previous section . we need @xmath207 , implying @xmath208 . however this contradicts @xmath209 , which was required to have small @xmath1 . hence the moduli superpotential in this subsection fails on both slow - roll parameters . as a second case , consider the race - track models with @xmath210 , and take the limit @xmath211 . in this case we find @xmath212 and @xmath213 \ , , \qquad \tilde v_2 \approx -\frac{\lambda^2}{4 \pi^2 } \ , , \nonumber \\ & & ( e^k \tilde v_1 ) ' \approx -a(a - b ) e^{-a t_0 } \frac{a}{4t_0 ^ 2 } \left[1+\frac{\lambda^2}{8\pi^2}\right ] \ , , \nonumber \\ & & \lambda \approx a^2 ( a - b)^2 e^{-2at_0 } \frac{a^2}{3t_0 } \left[1+\frac{\lambda^2}{8\pi^2}\right ] \ , . \label{eg2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] small @xmath1 requires @xmath214 which , as in the previous subsection , implies @xmath215 . this suggests that it will again be impossible to have small @xmath1 and a stable modulus @xmath11 . using an asymptotic analysis of @xmath201 , we find that this time the maximum of the potential occurs at @xmath216 , and the height of the barrier is @xmath217 \ , .\ ] ] in contrast to the previous subsection we find @xmath99 is not of order @xmath218 . in this case it is possible to have @xmath219 and @xmath220 . unfortunately when we calculate @xmath2 , we run into the same problem as before . if the modulus field @xmath11 were fixed at @xmath120 , @xmath2 would be small . however this does not occur , and ( [ neweta ] ) applies instead . we find again @xmath199 , ruling out this case too . we will now use approximate analytic arguments to determine if any choices of @xmath29 could give viable slow - roll inflation . using the expressions for @xmath201 ( [ kkltvs ] ) , and @xmath221 ( [ kkltv1 ] ) , we obtain @xmath222 v_1 + \frac{(n-4)}{24 t^3 } v_1 ^ 2 + \mathcal{o}\left(\frac{\lambda^2}{8 \pi^2}\right ) = 0 \label{approx}\end{aligned}\ ] ] at @xmath181 . now the requirement that @xmath223 implies that @xmath224 , and since @xmath166 we can take @xmath225 to find approximate solutions to ( [ approx ] ) . noting that @xmath226 , the effect of the loop corrections will also be small , allowing us to neglect them . for small @xmath81 ( [ approx ] ) is only satisfied if either @xmath29 or @xmath227 is very small . for the former we obtain @xmath228 using this , the expression for @xmath229 simplifies to @xmath230 , to leading order in @xmath81 . from ( [ kkltv1 ] ) we obtain @xmath231 to leading order in @xmath81 this is @xmath232 . substituting all this into the expression for @xmath2 ( [ neweta ] ) , which includes the effect of varying @xmath11 , we find @xmath233')^2}{e^k \lambda } \approx -6 \ , .\ ] ] so we retrieve an @xmath2 problem along this branch of solutions . the models discussed in the previous two subsections fall into this category . the second approximate solution to ( [ approx ] ) has @xmath234 this again allows us to simplify @xmath235 , and we find @xmath236 . expanding in @xmath81 , ( [ dv1app ] ) implies @xmath237 . combining all this , ( [ neweta ] ) implies @xmath238 noting that @xmath239 in order to get successful inflation , we need both @xmath240 and @xmath241 at the minimum @xmath181 . if this fine - tuning is not satisfied then slow roll inflation does not occur . this fine - tuning of the moduli superpotential is in addition to the fine - tuning required for the stabilisation potential @xmath96 to have a minkowski minimum . furthermore , @xmath29 must also be such that the maximum of @xmath96 is greater than the inflationary scale ( so that minimum of the moduli potential does not disappear ) . this all adds up to a huge amount of fine - tuning , and the two - term racetrack potential used above ( [ racetwo ] ) does not seem to have enough parameters to satisfy all the conditions simultaneously . this suggests that a heavily fine - tuned , three - term @xmath29 would be needed to give viable inflation . it is hard to see how such a fine - tuned model could arise naturally . in this section we consider minkowski vacua with a non - vanishing gravitino mass . this is the traditional framework used in particle physics . at the end of inflation , the vacuum is a non - supersymmetric configuration with a vanishing cosmological constant . one would also like to impose @xmath242 in order to have a hierarchy between the planck scale and the sparticle masses . supersymmetry breaking could be achieved with @xmath0-terms , although as we will show this leads to an unstable vacuum . it is therefore necessary to include a lifting term in the theory , such as those discussed at the end of subsection [ ssec : vv ] . consider a theory with only one modulus field , no lifting term , and the following no - scale kahler potential @xmath243 and @xmath108 . it is convenient to transform the field according to @xmath244 in terms of the new variable @xmath49 , one obtains @xmath245 and @xmath246 the kahler transformation ( [ kahlertrafo ] ) preserves @xmath247 , which is the only relevant combination in supergravity . using the new variable @xmath49 one obtains @xmath248 where primes denote here @xmath249 . imposing that the potential has an extremum with a vanishing cosmological constant leads to the following relations @xmath250 and @xmath251 at the extremum when @xmath57 and @xmath252 , i.e. when supersymmetry is broken at the extremum . the extremum equations are also satisfied for @xmath253 . the mass at the extremum involves @xmath254 when @xmath57 and @xmath252 , the extremum equations give @xmath255 at the extremum @xmath256 . as @xmath257 is generically non - zero , this implies that the extremum is a saddle point where the direction along @xmath258 ( for @xmath257 chosen real positive ) is tachyonic . this is a generic property of no - scale models and implies that the modulus can not be stabilised with a vanishing potential and broken supersymmetry . on the contrary when supersymmetry is preserved , we find @xmath259 as long as @xmath227 does not vanish , guaranteeing the stability of the model @xcite . this argument can be generalised to an arbitrary number of fields in the no - scale case @xmath260 where the @xmath66 s are , for example , matter fields . indeed putting @xmath261 and collectively @xmath262 , the kahler superpotential becomes @xmath263 and the superpotential @xmath264 is turned into @xmath265 with these redefinitions , the scalar potential reads @xmath266 the vanishing of the cosmological constant at the extremum implies that @xmath267 the minimum equation reads @xmath268 when supersymmetry is broken . in the supersymmetric case , the minimum equations are @xmath269 . the stability of the extremum depends on the mass matrix which reads @xmath270 \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the extremum equation we find that @xmath271 in the supersymmetry breaking case . this mass matrix has nice algebraic properties . when @xmath272 has zero eigenvalues , the mass matrix @xmath273 vanishes in these directions . in the directions orthogonal to the zero eigenstates of @xmath272 , all the eigenvalues of @xmath273 are positive but one which vanishes along the eigenvector @xmath274 where @xmath275 . hence the mass matrix @xmath273 vanishes along @xmath276 and the zero eigenstates of @xmath272 . in the supersymmetric case , we find @xmath277 \ , .\ ] ] defining a vector space basis with @xmath278 where @xmath279 , and orthogonal vectors @xmath280 , we can use the sum rule @xmath281 to find that @xmath282 \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is a positive definite hermitian matrix as @xmath283 for any @xmath284 provided the matrix @xmath272 does not have zero eigenstates corroborating the results in @xcite . hence we have found that the mass matrix @xmath285 has zero eigenstates when supersymmetry is broken . now for a generic supersymmetry breaking model , the holomorphic mass matrix is such that @xmath286 . expanding along the direction @xmath287 where @xmath288 is the minimum leads to a potential @xmath289 notice that this leads to a tachyonic direction as before , implying that the supersymmetry breaking extremum with zero cosmological constant is not stable . hence we see that a supersymmetry breaking minkowski vacuum from a no - scale theory which does not use a lifting term can not be stable . since such a setup does not even stabilise the moduli fields , it is certainly not suitable to use in a hybrid inflation model . in this paper we considered @xmath0-term hybrid inflation in supergravity , when moduli fields are present . in the literature it is usually assumed that moduli fields are stabilised before the period of slow - roll inflation begins and that they therefore have no impact on the dynamics of the inflaton field . we have shown that this is not necessarily the case . firstly , the tree - level coupling of moduli and inflaton fields in supergravity induces a slope and , in general , a mass term in the potential for the inflaton field . on top of this , loop corrections from both the inflation and moduli sectors of theory contribute to the slope and curvature of the potential . a further problem comes from the evolution of the moduli fields during inflation . since they are stabilised by a steep potential , they are roughly constant during inflation . however , despite the small size of their variation , we have shown that they still give a significant contribution to the effective inflaton potential . this generally leads to a large and tachyonic mass for the inflaton . we find that this class of model has up to three different @xmath2 problems . firstly there is the usual one coming from embedding hybrid inflation in supergravity ( which is avoided with the help of shift symmetries ) . secondly there are tree - level contributions to the inflaton mass from the coupling of the inflaton to the moduli sector ( although these are absent for no - scale models ) . finally there is the negative contribution to the effective inflaton mass from the rolling of the moduli fields during inflation . it is not obvious that this third @xmath2 problem can be removed with natural additional symmetries . the model also has an @xmath1 problem due to the tree - level contributions to the inflaton slope from the moduli sector . we found that in the popular model for moduli stabilisation , the kklt scenario , the induced mass term for the inflaton field is generally too big to give a period of slow - roll inflation . it seems that only with a heavily fine - tuned superpotential for the moduli sector may viable slow - roll inflation take place . to conclude , we have shown that the coupling of moduli fields to hybrid inflation can have an important impact on the effective inflationary potential . neglecting this coupling is not consistent and , as we have seen , generally leads to incorrect conclusions about the inflationary dynamics . these considerations are also relevant to other inflationary scenarios . in each case it should be checked that the moduli fields , even if thought to be stabilised , do not spoil the flatness of the inflationary potential , and therefore the dynamics of the inflaton field . we would like to thank k. dasgupta and r. kallosh for comments on a previous version of the manuscript and n. chatillon and u. ellwanger for discussions . acd thanks cea saclay for hospitality while some of this work was in progress . acd and cvdb were supported in part by pparc . scd was supported by the swiss science foundation and the netherlands organisation for scientific research ( nwo ) . phb acknowledges support from rtn european programme mrn - ct-2004 - 503369 . we have latexmath:[$m^2_{\rm ( boson ) } = 2 \mathcal{k}^{i\bar \jmath } \partial_i \partial_{\bar \jmath } v + 6f_r^{-1 } \sum_{i=\pm } assuming the only gauge group in the theory is @xmath30 . if there were additional gauge groups , the additional gauge sector would also give contributions to the mass matrices . for the fermions @xmath291 where @xmath292 with @xmath293 , and @xmath294 where @xmath295 , and @xmath296 otherwise . define @xmath297 \ , .\ ] ] the diagonal entries of the boson mass matrix for the minkowski background are @xmath298 and non - zero elements of fermion mass matrix are @xmath299 hence we obtain @xmath300 for the inflationary background , the diagonal entries of the boson mass matrix are @xmath301e^k \ , , \ \nonumber \\ m^2_{\pm \bar \pm } & = & [ 2(g^2x^4 + g^2[2x^4 + 2x^2 + 1]\phi^2 -\sqrt{2}g \phi \re(w)[1 + 2x^2 ] + |w|^2 ) \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{1 in } { } + v_s - 2\sqrt{2}gx^2 \phi \re ( v_1)+2 g^2x^4\phi^2 v_2]e^k \ , , \ m^2_{i \bar j } & = & 2g^2x^4 e^k ( k_{i\bar j}+k_i k_{\bar j } ) + ( e^k v_s + v_\mathrm{lift})_{,i\bar j } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{1 in } { } - 2\sqrt{2}gx^2 \phi ( e^k \re v_1)_{,i\bar j } + 2 g^2 x^4 \phi^2 ( e^k v_2)_{,i\bar j } \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] while fermion mass matrix has @xmath302 - w ) \ , , \nonumber \\ m_{\phi j } & = & -e^{k/2}\sqrt{2 } g x^2 k_j \ , , \qquad m_{\lambda\lambda } = e^{k/2 } \frac{\partial_i f k^{i\bar j}}{2f_r } ( d_{\bar j } \bar w-\sqrt{2}g x^2 \phi k_{\bar j } ) \ , , \nonumber \\ m_{ij } & = & m^{(0)}_{ij } -\sqrt{2 } g x^2\phi m^{(1)}_{ij } \ , , \qquad m_{3/2 } = e^{k/2 } ( w-\sqrt{2}g x^2 \phi ) \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] this implies @xmath303g^2x^4e^k \nonumber \\ & & { } - 4\sqrt{2}g x^2\phi \re \biggl[(w+3 v_1 ) e^k + k^{i\bar j } ( e^k v_1)_{,i\bar j } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{0.3 in } { } - m^{(0)}_{ij}k^{i\bar a } \bar m^{(1)}_{\bar a\bar b}k^{j\bar b } -\frac{e^k}{4 f_r^2}(k^{i\bar j } k_{\bar j } \partial_i f ) ( k^{b\bar a}d_b w \partial_{\bar a } \bar f ) \biggr ] \nonumber \\ & & { } + 4g^2x^4\phi^2 \biggl[(1+v_2 ) e^k + k^{i\bar j}(e^k v_2)_{,i\bar j } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{1 in } { } - |m^{(1)}_{ik}k^{k\bar j}|^2 -\frac{e^k}{4f_r^2}|k^{i\bar j } k_{\bar j } \partial_i f|^2\biggr ] \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] 99 a. d. linde , particle physics and inflationary cosmology , contemp . concepts phys . * 5 * ( 2005 ) 1 [ hep - th/0503203 ] .

hybrid inflation can be realised in low - energy effective string theory , as described using supergravity . we find that the coupling of moduli to @xmath0-term hybrid inflation in supergravity leads to a slope and a curvature for the inflaton potential . the @xmath1 and @xmath2 parameters receive contributions at tree and one loop level which are not compatible with slow roll inflation . furthermore the coupling to the moduli sector can even prevent inflation from ending at all . we show that introducing shift symmetries in the inflationary sector and taking the moduli sector to be no - scale removes most of these problems . if the moduli fields are fixed during inflation , as is usually assumed , it appears that viable slow - roll inflation can then be obtained with just one fine - tuning of the moduli sector parameters . however , we show this is not a reasonable assumption , and that the small variation of the moduli fields during inflation gives a significant contribution to the effective inflaton potential . this typically implies that @xmath3 , although it may be possible to obtain smaller values with heavy fine - tuning . _ keywords _ : inflation , string theory and cosmology

1703.03026

interstellar medium is turbulent with magnetic fields playing a critical role in the key processes , including star formation , propagation and acceleration of cosmic rays as well as regulating heat and mass transfer between different phases . therefore it is essential to have a reliable way of studying magnetic fields . unfortunately , there only a few ways of tracing magnetic fields and their applicability is limited . for instance , tracing magnetic fields with aligned grains ( see @xcite ) requires either the availability of the background stars , if the polarization via extinction is employed , or sensitive far infrared measurements , which frequently imply the use of the space - based instruments . another major technique that employs synchrotron polarization mostly traces magnetic fields in the warm and hot phases of the interstellar medium ( ism ) ( see @xcite for the list of the idealised ism phases ) . using spectroscopic data for tracing magnetic fields was first suggested and demonstrated in @xcite using the anisotropy of correlation functions of the velocity channel maps . the new approach was motivated by the theoretical advancements establishing that the mhd turbulence is anisotropic ( @xcite , herafter gs95 , @xcite , see @xcite for a review ) and should translate into the anisotropy of the observed correlation fluctuations . later this approach was employed with the use of velocity centroids @xcite and @xcite and the principal component analysis ( pca ) @xcite of the spectroscopic data . in its pca incarnation the idea of tracing magnetic field anisotropies was applied to the observational data in @xcite with the results of anisotropies shown to be consistent with the starlight polarization measurements . further development of the technique resulted in the development of techniques using the anisotropies for obtaining the media magnetization , as it parameterized by the alfven mach number @xcite and the separation of compressible and incompressible turbulence components of observational data as discussed in @xcite . on the basis of the aforementioned improved understanding of the nature of mhd cascade a new technique employing velocity centroid gradients ( vcgs ) was introduced in @xcite ( @xcite , henceforth gl17 ) . instead of appealing to anisotropic velocity correlations as in @xcite the new technique made use of velocity gradients that , according to the mhd turbulence theory tend to be perpendicular to the _ local _ direction of the magnetic field . this idea was further extended in @xcite ( @xcite , henceforth yl17 ) where a robust practical procedure for vcg calculations was suggested . in the latter paper we also applied the new technique to the galfa 21 cm data and demonstrated a good correspondence between the magnetic field tracing with the vcgs and the planck polarization arising from aligned grains . this result motivates the further study of vcgs properties that we undertake in this paper . we note parenthetically that vcgs are not the only way to trace magnetic field using velocity gradients . intensity gradients within the position - position- velocity ( ppv ) channel maps have been recently suggested as an alternative way of exploring the magnetic field topology @xcite . on the basis of the earlier studies of the statistics of channel maps versus the statistics obtained with velocity centroids ( see @xcite and ref . therein ) one can expect that the velocity channel gradients in @xcite ( @xcite , henceforth ly17 ) may have advantages for studying supersonic turbulence as well as tracing the 3d distribution of turbulence . at the same time , the vcgs may have advantages for studying subsonic turbulence . the comparison of the two technique will be done elsewhere . another way of exploring the gradients was introduced in @xcite ( @xcite , henceforth lylc17 ) . this approach employs synchrotron intensity gradients ( sigs ) and provides a way of tracing magnetic field in turbulent environments the synergy of which to the vcg technique we explore in this paper . the theoretical basis for the sigs is the same as for the vcgs however , in the presence of gravity , the response of the sigs and the vcgs is different which provides a way to identify the regions where the matter is subject to the gravitational collapse , as we discuss in the paper . the density statistics is also affected by mhd turbulence . mhd turbulence can imprint some of its properties to density , making its statistics at low sonic mach numbers anisotropic ( see @xcite ) . while both from theory and simulations we expect the density to be a worse tracer of magnetic fields , especially at high sonic mach numbers , the very differences between the velocity and anisotropies can be informative of the properties of the turbulent media . this is the synergy that we also explore in this paper . we note that the first report of the correlation of the magnetic fields and density gradients was done within the numerical study by @xcite reported the alignment of density gradients and magnetic fields with simulation as well as the change of the alignment that occurs after the effects of self - gravity get important starting with a particular density threshold . in our study we make a step further and explore the point - wise tracing of magnetic fields by the intensity gradients ( igs ) as well as the nature of the deviations of the igs directions from those of magnetic field . we show a significant synergy of using the igs , the vcgs and the dust polarimetry data . in addition , we provide a detailed study on how self - gravity lead to the rotation of both vcg and ig vectors and the physics behind it . we also explore the ways of improving the ig tracing of magnetic field by suggesting the procedure filtering for the shocked gas regions . as a separate but related development it is important to mention the study in @xcite . there a good correlation of directions of the filaments observed in the ppv galfa channel maps and the magnetic field direction as revealed by planck polarimetry was reported . as a result the filaments were identified as a tracer of magnetic field direction in hi high latitude gas . while in the original study the filaments were identified with the actual spacial density enhancements , we believe that the interpretation depends on the thickness of the velocity channel used . indeed , according to @xcite within the sufficiently thin velocity channels the intensity fluctuations are caustics mostly induced by velocity fluctuations . therefore , depending on the velocity channel thickness , the filament tracing is related either to revealing of velocity statistics or density statistics or both . the comparison of the empirical techniques is an interesting problem that we will discuss in another paper . self - gravity is expected to modify the properties of the flow in the vicinity centers of the gravitational collapse . the change of the properties of mhd turbulence within such regions is expected to be the result of vcgs changing their properties , in particular their alignment with the magnetic fields . the density distribution is even more affected by self - gravity . indeed , a recent study by @xcite , reported that the igs rotate with respect to magnetic fields when arriving some density threshold in super - alfvenic high density self - gravitating simulation . while the work from @xcite does not address how self - gravity dynamically change the alignment of igs and vcgs , that encourages a detailed study on how self - gravity can possibly lead to the rotation of gradient vectors and the physics behind it . in this paper , we address the issue of how vcgs and igs behave in the regions of self - dominant gravity for the case of sub- and trans - alfvenic clouds , how does the stage of collapse correlated to the alignment of gradients , and how can the aforementioned phenomenon can be used on tracking self - gravitating regions in observation . in what follows we briefly summarize the theoretical arguments that justify the use of the vcgs in [ sec:1 ] , explain our simulation setting in [ sec:1.5 ] and numerical approach for gradient calculation in [ sec:2 ] . we provide a comparison of the alignment of vcgs and igs with magnetic fields in different physical conditions in [ sec:3 ] , and providing methods on improving the alignment . we explore the properties of the vcgs in sub - alfvenic self - gravitating clouds in [ sec:4 ] and explore their synergistic use with the igs . we illustrate our method in [ sec:5 ] using observational data in [ sec:5 ] . we compare our methods to the method of anisotropy of correlation in [ sec:6 ] . we compare our method to others and discuss our results in [ sec:7 ] . we summarize our results in [ sec:8 ] . the theoretical motivation for studying magnetic fields using vcgs are discussed in our earlier papers ( gl17 , yl17 , ly17 ) as well as in the paper on the sigs ( lylc17 ) . in short , in the presence of fast turbulent reconnection @xcite the motions that do not induce magnetic field bending are preferentially excited . these are the motions perpendicular to the local direction of magnetic field . this fact is numerically confirmed in @xcite and is the corner stone of the modern theory of mhd turbulence ( see @xcite ) . due to this alignment of velocity motions , the gradient of velocities are largest perpendicular to the _ local _ direction of magnetic field . it is important that the gradient amplitude for the gs95 turbulence is increasing with the decrease of the eddy scale . therefore the smallest eddies that are most aligned with the local direction of the magnetic field contribute most to the gradients . as a result , by tracing the velocity gradients one can trace the magnetic field direction . the motions at the turbulence injection scale can be super - alfvenic , i.e. faster than the alfven velocity @xmath0 . the gs95 theory is not applicable to such motions . however , as the turbulent velocity decrease with the scale , e.g. for kolmogorov turbulence @xmath1 , for a realistically extended turbulence inertial range at small scales the motions gets subalfvenic and obey the gs95 theory . therefore , by filtering the contributions from larger scales we may still trace the magnetic fields using velocity gradients . in the presence of gravity , the velocity field is modified . in particular , for subcritical collapse when magnetic field dominate the dynamics , the motions are expected along the stiff magnetic field lines , making velocity gradients aligned with magnetic field . similarly , for supercritical collapse , the collapsing material is expected to drag relatively weak magnetic fields . this should also make magnetic fields and velocity gradients aligned . in other words , for the regions with significant self - gravity effects we expect the change of the direction of magnetic field and velocity gradient alignment from being perpendicular to magnetic field to becoming parallel to magnetic field . ( see section [ subsec:4.1 ] for a detailed discussion ) in gl17 and yl17 the velocity centroids were used as a measure of velocity that is available from observations . the velocity centroids were shown to reflect the statistics of underlying velocity field well , at least for subsonic mhd turbulence @xcite . in the present paper we explore numerically the utility for the vcgs to trace magnetic fields in mhd turbulence for various turbulent driving environments , e.g. different combination of sonic and alfvenic mach number , different compression of fluids in non self - gravitating as well as self - gravitating environment . we shall also establish the guidelines on how to get better alignments numerically even the gradient technique does not provide a good prediction . as there are many factors affecting the alignment of rotated gradients with magnetic fields , we would investigate vcgs and igs through studying mhd simulations in different physical conditions . following yl17 and lylc17 we used a series of compressible , turbulent , isothermal single fluid magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) simulations for examination of vcgs and igs from zeus - mp/3d @xcite , a variant of the code zeus - mp @xcite . we set up simulation cubes with several combinations of sonic mach number @xmath2 and alfvenic mach number @xmath3 , which are listed in table [ tab : simualtionparameters ] . for supersonic simulations , we increases the resolution of the simulations to ensure the cube has a sufficiently long inertial range for high @xmath2 cases . the initial magnetic field is along the z - axis and the boundary condition is triply periodic . we injected turbulence using the same method in yl17 . to study the effect of compressibility to alignment of gradients , we also introduce a cube ( set e ) from an incompressible simulation ( see lylc17 for details ) . most of this work is devoted to the studies of diffuse media with the negligible effects of gravity . in section[sec:4 ] we study the case of strongly magnetized media for which self - gravity is important . there we wait until turbulence inside the cube gets saturated and then switch on the self - gravitating module , which employs a periodic fast fourier transform ( fft ) poisson solver . to trace the effect of gravity with respect to time , we take a number of snapshots with even time intervals before and after the of gravity is switch on . we stop our calculation when any pixel in the system violates the truelove criterion @xcite , which informs us when to stop the simulation before having numerical artifacts due to self - gravitating collapse . as self - gravity is a dynamic process , we expect systems having same @xmath2 and @xmath3 but different magnetic criticality , that means a system with gravitational to magnetic energy ratio larger than one , will provide very similar final results . therefore we here only investigate the systems with magnetic criticality @xmath4 to be 2 , which ensures the cube will have physical collapse when self - gravity is activated and before the truelove criterion is violated . the raw data from simulation cube has to be converted to synthetic maps for our gradient studies . assuming the line - of - sight direction is the @xmath5-axis , the intensity @xmath6 , velocity centroid @xmath7 are defined as @xmath8 we also computed polarization by assuming the media is optically thin , faraday rotation is not effective along the line of sight , and the emissitivity is a constant over the line of sight . in other words , the stokes parameters @xmath9 can be expressed in terms of @xmath10 , the y and z direction magnetic fields : @xmath11 the polarized intensity @xmath12 and angle @xmath13 are then defined correspondingly . ( see @xcite for details ) . the three observables @xmath14 will be used to calculate the intensity gradients ( igs ) , velocity centroid gradients ( vcgs ) and synchrotron intensity gradients ( sigs ) , by following the recipe and the _ sub - block averaging_. the _ sub - block averaging _ method , as it introduced in yl17 is based on defining the most probable direction within a block by a local gaussian - fitting peak on the distribution of gradient angle distribution . within the approach , the fitting error provides a quantitative estimate of whether the block size is large enough for providing a correct direction . to compare the performance between vcgs and igs , we employed the _ alignment measure _ that is introduced in analogy with the grain alignment studies ( see @xcite ) : @xmath15 ( see gl17 , yl17 ) with a range of @xmath16 $ ] to measure the relative alignment between _ rotated _ gradients and magnetic fields , where @xmath17 is the relative angle between _ rotated _ gradients to magnetic field . a perfect alignment gives @xmath18 . on the other hand , @xmath19 when vectors tend to be more perpendicular . we shall use am to quantify the performance of the vcgs and igs in various physical conditions . some special values for am can also give the readers how good the alignment it is for certain type of gradient vectors to magnetic fields . for example , @xmath20 indicates the dispersion between _ average _ gradients to magnetic field directions is about @xmath21 , which means the gradient vectors are rather good tracers for the magnetic field direction . on the other hand , @xmath22 indicates a random orientation of gradient vectors relative to magnetic fields . in what follows , we shall study both vcgs and igs and investigate their advantages and synergy for studying magnetic field and other parameters of the ism . shocks are a very important process when the sonic mach number , @xmath2 , which is the ratio of the turbulent injection velocity and the speed of sound , gets large . different phases of the ism are expected to have different sonic mach numbers @xmath2 ( see @xcite ) . the mach number @xmath2 of warm gas is of the order of unity ( see @xcite and ref . therein ) , while the mach number of cold interstellar media ( see @xcite ) as well as molecular clouds can be @xmath23 and even higher . the sonic mach number also characterize the compressibility of turbulent flow . when @xmath2 increases , stronger compressions result in stronger shocks and significantly modify the properties of turbulent gas . we study how shocks change the alignment of gradient vectors and the underlying magnetic field . we start our investigation with the cubes from set `` b '' ( see table [ tab : simulationparameters ] ) to perform an alignment test on both the vcgs and the igs . figure [ fig : vcgig - ms ] shows how the vcgs and the igs behave with various @xmath2 . we note that the alignment of the vcgs in significantly better compared with the igs . a diagram showing the alignment of vcgs ( red ) , igs ( green ) , and the relative alignment between them ( blue ) as the sonic mach number @xmath2 increases , scaledwidth=44.0% ] [ tab : simualtionparameters ] .simulations used in our current work . the magnetic criticality @xmath24 is set to be 2 for all simulation data . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in a subsequent study on observational studies on the same vela c region ( yuen et al . in prep ) , we not only be able to trace the direction of magnetic field in appropriate scales with very high @xmath25 , but also locating the possible self - gravitating region using the numerical result in this work . that suggests the applicability of our technique for magnetic field tracing even within extreme environments . in this work , we investigate a number of different regimes for the sonic mach number @xmath2 , but the explored range of the alfven mach numbers @xmath3 is limited to sub- and trans - alfvenic cases only . while our series of studies ( yl17 , lylc17 , this work , @xcite ) shows the power of our gradient technique in different circumstances , one very important regime that is yet to explore is the highly super - alfvenic cases . on the other hand , the expectation from turbulence theory ( gs95 , lv99 ) also make the tracing through gradients more complicated than sub- and trans - alfvenic cases . only sufficient small scales @xmath26 will the turbulent eddies become anisotropic . in fact , the wavenumber removal suggested in section [ subsec:3.2 ] should be able to reveal the alignment of the vcgs to underlying magnetic field provided that @xmath27 is known . the practical procedures for the actual data handling will be discussed elsewhere . our paper explores the use of the velocity centroid gradients ( vcgs ) for tracing magnetic fields and its synergy with other gradient techniques and polarimetry for probing the ism processes . we tested how vcgs , intensity gradients ( igs ) and synchrotron intensity gradients ( sigs ) behave under different physical conditions , including a change of sonic and alfvenic mach numbers and in the presence of self - gravity . we show that in the diffuse media the vcgs trace the magnetic field well and showed that in combination with polarimetry they can also be efficient in identifying the regions dominated by self - gravity . our results in the paper can be briefly summarized : 1 . in the diffuse media the vcgs trace the magnetic field well and in combination with polarimetry or sigs they can also be efficient in identifying the regions dominated by self - gravity . 2 . the deviations of the direction of the vcgs and the igs can signify the existence of shocks and can be used as a ways to obtain the turbulence sonic mach number . 3 . new ways to improve the performance of the vcgs and igs tracing magnetic fields were identified . they include 1 . removing pixels with higher ig amplitudes . 2 . removing the contribution of lower wave number . 4 . for self - gravitating regions the alignment of the vcgs changes : 1 . in the case of dynamically important magnetic field , the unconstrained falling of matter along magnetic fields lines makes the gradients aligned with magnetic fields . therefore the change of the relative orientation of polarization directions and those determined by the vcgs can provide the observational signature of the self - gravitating collapse within molecular clouds . the time scale for the response of the igs to the gravity is faster than the vcgs in a collapsing cloud , which shed the possibility of determining the stage of collapse by tracing the relative alignment of the igs to the vcgs in the vicinity of high density regions . this opens a way to identify the regions of gravitational collapse by observing the increase of misalignment of the igs and the vcgs for intermediate densities with the return to their alignment for higher densities . 3 . combining vcgs and sigs explored earlier in @xcite , it is possible to locate self - gravitating regions by examining the relative orientation of the two gradients . the gravity , rather than the density threshold determine the change of the direction of gradient vectors in self - gravitating regions . the vcgs can provide more detailed magnetic field tracing compared to the correlation function anisotropy technique as suggested in lazarian et al . we illustrate our technique by analyzing the observation data : 1 . for the nearby region of galfa - hi used in @xcite to the combination of the vcgs and the igs reveals shocks . 2 . the full - sky hi4pi hi data together with planck synchrotron foreground intensity data and planck dust polarization data locate the possible self - gravitating regions . the stay of khy at uw - madison is supported by the fulbright - lee hysan research fellowship and department of physics , cuhk . al acknowledges the support of the nsf grant ast 1212096 , nasa grant nnx14aj53 g as well as a distinguished visitor pve / capes appointment at the physics graduate program of the federal university of rio grande do norte , the inct inespao and physics graduate program / ufrn . gaensler , b. m. , haverkorn , m. , burkhart , b. , et al . 2011 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature10446 [ , 478 , 214 ] galtier , s. , nazarenko , s. v. , newell , a. c. , & pouquet , a. 2000 , journal of plasma physics , 63 , 447 goldreich , p. , & sridhar , s. 1995 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/174600 [ , 438 , 763 ] , a. , pogosyan , d. , & esquivel , a. 2002 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol . 276 , seeing through the dust : the detection of hi and the exploration of the ism in galaxies , ed . a. r. taylor , t. l. landecker , & a. g. willis , 182 lazarian , a. , & pogosyan , d. 2000 , , 537 , 720

this study proceeds with the development of the technique employing velocity gradients that were identified in ( @xcite , henceforth gl17 ) as a means of probing magnetic field in interstellar media . we demonstrate a number of practical ways on improving the accuracy of tracing magnetic fields in diffuse interstellar media using velocity centroid gradients ( vcgs ) . addressing the magnetic field tracing in super - alfvenic turbulence we introduce the procedure of filtering low spatial frequencies , that enables magnetic field tracing in the situations when the kinetic energy of turbulent plasmas dominate its magnetic energy . we propose the synergic way of of using vcgs together with intensity gradients ( igs ) , synchrotron intensity gradients ( sigs ) as well as dust polarimetry . we show that while the igs trace magnetic field worse than the vcgs , the deviations of the angle between the igs and vcgs trace the shocks in diffuse media . similarly the perpendicular orientation of the vcgs and the sigs or to the dust polarimetry data trace the regions of gravitational collapse . we demonstrate the utility of combining the vcgs , igs and polarimetry using galfa hi and planck polarimetry data . we also provide an example of synergy of the vcgs and the sigs using the hi4pi full - sky hi survey together with the planck synchrotron intensity data .

1403.4316

most of the energy released in the nuclear fission process appears in the kinetic energy of the fission fragments . a first order estimate of the magnitude of the total kinetic energy release is that of the coulomb energy of the fragments at scission , i.e. , @xmath3 where z@xmath1 , r@xmath1 are the atomic numbers and radii of fragments 1 and 2 . recognizing that the fragments are deformed at scission , one can re - write equation 1 as @xmath4 where the coefficient 1.9 ( instead of the usual 1.2 - 1.3 ) represents the fragment deformation . for symmetric fission , z@xmath5=z@xmath6=z/2 and a@xmath5 = a@xmath6=a/2 , then we have @xmath7 trajectory calculations @xcite for alpha particle emission in fission have shown that the fission fragments are in motion at scission with a pre - scission kinetic energy of 7.3 mev and an additive term representing this motion is needed . thus we have the viola systematics " @xcite that say @xmath8 the deformed scission point fragments will contract to their equilibrium deformations and the energy stored in deformation will be converted into internal excitation energy . thus we can define a related quantity , the total excitation energy , txe , in fission as @xmath9where q is the mass - energy release . one quickly realizes that these quantities depend on the mass split in fission which in turn , at low excitation energies , may reflect the fragment nuclear structure . the txe is the starting point for calculations of the prompt neutron and gamma emission in fission , the yields of beta emitting fission fragments , reactor anti - neutrino spectra , etc . as such , it is a fundamental property of all fissioning systems and sadly not very well known . as a practical matter , one needs to know the dependence of the tke and txe on neutron energy for the neutron induced fission of technologically important actinide fissioning systems like @xmath10u(n , f),@xmath0u(n , f ) , and @xmath11pu(n , f ) . the first question we might pose is whether the tke should depend on the excitation energy of the fissioning system . does the energy brought in by an incident neutron in neutron induced fission appear in the fragment excitation energy or does it appear in the total kinetic energy ? in a variety of experiments , one finds that increasing the excitation energy of the fissioning system does not lead to significant increases in the tke of the fission fragments or changes in the fragment separation at scission . however , there may be more subtle effects that render this statement false in some circumstances . for example , we expect , on the basis of the coulomb energy systematics given above , that the tke will be proportional to changes in the fission mass splits which in turn can depend on the excitation energy . for the technologically important reaction @xmath0u(n , f ) , madland @xcite summarizes the known data @xcitewith the following equations @xmath12 @xmath13 where e@xmath1 is the energy of the incident neutron and t@xmath14and t@xmath15 are the average total fission fragment kinetic energy ( before neutron emission ) and the average fission product kinetic energy after neutron emission , respectively . these quantities are related by the relation @xmath16\ ] ] these data show a modest decrease in tke with increasing excitation energy for the neutron energy interval e@xmath1 = 1 - 9 mev . there is no clearly identified changes in the tke values near the second chance fission threshold , a feature that is important in semi - empirical models of fission such as represented by the gef code.@xcite in this paper , we report the results of measuring the total kinetic energy release in the neutron induced fission of @xmath0u for neutron energies e@xmath1 = 3.2 -50 mev . the method used for the measurement is the 2e method , i.e. , measurement of the kinetic energies of the two coincident fission products using semiconductor detectors . the time of flight of the neutrons inducing fission was measured , allowing deduction of their energy . the details of the experiment are discussed in section ii while the experimental results and a comparison of the results with various models and theories is made in section iii with conclusions being summarized in section iv . this experiment was carried out at the weapons neutron research facility ( wnr ) at the los alamos neutron science center ( lansce ) at the los alamos national laboratory @xcite . white spectrum " neutron beams were generated from an unmoderated tungsten spallation source using the 800 mev proton beam from the lansce linac . the experiment was located on the 15r beam line ( 15@xmath17-right with respect to the proton beam ) . the calculated ( mcnpx ) white spectrum " at the target position is shown in figure 1 . @xcite the proton beam is pulsed allowing one to measure the time of flight ( energy ) of the neutrons arriving at the experimental area . a schematic diagram of the experimental apparatus is shown in figure 2 . the neutron beam was collimated to a 1 cm diameter at the entrance to the experimental area . at the entrance to the scattering chamber , the beam diameter was measured to be 1.3 cm . a fission ionization chamber @xcite was used to continuously monitor the absolute neutron beam intensities . the @xmath0u target and the si pin diode fission detectors were housed in an evacuated , thin - walled aluminum scattering chamber . the scattering chamber was located @xmath18 3.1 m from the collimator , and @xmath18 11 m from the neutron beam dump . the center of the scattering chamber was located 16.46 m from the production target . the @xmath0u target consisted of a deposit of @xmath0uf@xmath19 on a thin c backing . the thickness of the @xmath0u was 175.5 @xmath20 g @xmath0u/@xmath21 while the backing thickness was 100 @xmath20g/@xmath21 . the isotopic purity of the @xmath0u was 99.91 @xmath22 . the target was tilted at 50 @xmath17 with respect to the incident beam . fission fragments were detected by two arrays of si pin photodiodes ( hamamatsu s3590 - 09 ) arranged on opposite sides of the beam . the area of the individual pin diodes was 1 @xmath21 . the distance of the detectors from the target varied with angle from 2.60 cm to 4.12 cm . the coincident detector pairs were at approximately 45 , 60 , 90 , 115 , and 135 @xmath17 . the alpha particle energy resolution of the diodes was 18 kev for the 5475 kev line of @xmath23am . the time of flight of each interacting neutron was measured using a timing pulse from a si pin diode and the accelerator rf signal . absolute calibrations of this time scale were obtained from the photofission peak in the fission spectra and the known flight path geometry . the energy calibration of the fission detectors was done with a @xmath24cf source . we have used the traditional schmitt method @xcite . some have criticized this method especially for pin diodes . however with our limited selection of detectors , we were unable to apply the methods of @xcite to achieve a robust substitute for the schmitt method . the measured fragment energies have be to be corrected for energy loss in the @xmath0uf@xmath25 deposit and the c backing foil . this correction was done by scaling the energy loss correction given by the northcliffe - schilling energy loss tables @xcite to a measured mean energy loss of collimated beams of light and heavy @xmath24cf fission fragments in 100 @xmath20 g/@xmath21 c foils . the scaling factor that was used was a linear function of mass using the average loss of the heavy and light fission fragments as anchor points . the correction factors at the anchor points were 1.24 and 1.45 for the heavy and light fragments , respectively . similar factors were obtained if the srim code @xcite was used to calculate de / dx . these large deviation factors from measured to calculated fission fragment stopping powers have been observed in the past @xcite , and represent the largest systematical uncertainty in the determination of the kinetic energies . the measured average post - neutron emission fission product total kinetic energy release for the @xmath0u(n , f ) reaction(table 1 ) is shown in figure 3 along with other data and predictions @xcite . the evaluated post - neutron emission data from madlund @xcite are shown as a dashed line while the individual pre - neutron emission measurements of @xcite are shown as points . the point at e@xmath1 = 14 mev is the average of @xcite and @xcite . the slope of the measured tke release ( this work ) is in rough agreement with the previous measurements @xcite at lower energies . also shown are the predictions of the gef model @xcite . gef is a semi - empirical model of fission that provides a good description of fission observables using a modest number of adjustable parameters . the dashed line in figure 1 is a semi - empirical equation ( tke = 171.5 -0.1e * for e * @xmath26 9 mev ) suggested by tudora et al . @xcite qualitatively the decrease in tke with increasing neutron energy reflects the increase in symmetric fission ( with its lower associated tke release ) with increasing excitation energy . this general dependence is reflected in the gef code predictions with the slope of our data set being similar to the predictions of the gef model but with the absolute values of the tke release being substantially less . in figure 4 , we show some typical tke distributions along with gaussian representations of the data . in general , the tke distributions appear to be gaussian in shape . this is in contrast to previous studies @xcite which showed a sizable skewness in the distributions . in figure 5 , we show the dependence of the measured values of the variance of the tke distributions as a function of neutron energy along with the predictions of the gef model of the same quantity . the measured variances are larger than expected . at low energies ( near the second chance fission threshold ) the observed variances show a dependence on neutron energy similar to that predicted by the gef model , presumably reflecting the changes in variance with decreasing mass asymmetry . at higher energies ( 11 - 50 mev ) the variances are roughly constant with changes in neutron energy . models @xcite would suggest that most of the variance of the tke distribution is due to fluctuations in the nascent fragment separation at scission . the constancy of the variances is puzzling . using the q values predicted by the gef code , one can make a related plot ( fig . 6 ) of the txe values in the @xmath0u(n , f ) reaction . the bump " in the txe at lower neutron energies is pronounced and the dependence of the txe upon neutron energy agrees with the gef predictions although the absolute values are larger . we conclude that : ( a ) for the first time , we have measured the tke release and its variance for the technologically important @xmath0u(n , f ) reaction over a large range of neutron energies ( 3.2 - 50 mev ) . ( b ) the dependence of the tke upon e@xmath1 seems to agree with semi - empirical models although the absolute value does not . ( c ) understanding the variance and its energy dependence for the tke distribution remains a challenge . this work was supported in part by the director , office of energy research , division of nuclear physics of the office of high energy and nuclear physics of the u.s . department of energy under grant de - fg06 - 97er41026 . one of us ( wl ) wishes to thank the [ department of energy s ] institute for nuclear theory at the university of washington for its hospitality and the department of energy for partial support during the completion of this work . this work has benefited from the use of the los alamos neutron science center at the los alamos national laboratory . this facility is funded by the u. s. department of energy under doe contract no . de - ac52 - 06na25396 . 10 p. w. lisowski , c. d. bowman , g. j. russell , and s. a. wender , nucl . . eng . * 106 * , 208 ( 1990 ) . p. w. lisowski and k. f. schoenberg , nucl . instr . meth . in phys . a * 562 * , 910 ( 2006 ) . ziegler , m.d . ziegler b , j.p . biersack , nucl . instr . meth . * b268 * , 1818 ( 2010 ) . knyazheva _ et . al _ , nucl . * b248 * , 7 ( 2006 ) .

the total kinetic energy release in the neutron induced fission of @xmath0u was measured ( using white spectrum neutrons from lansce ) for neutron energies from e@xmath1 = 3.2 to 50 mev . in this energy range the average post - neutron total kinetic energy release drops from 167.4 @xmath2 0.7 to 162.1 @xmath2 0.8 mev , exhibiting a local dip near the second chance fission threshold . the values and the slope of the tke vs. e@xmath1 agree with previous measurements but do disagree ( in magnitude ) with systematics . the variances of the tke distributions are larger than expected and apart from structure near the second chance fission threshold , are invariant for the neutron energy range from 11 to 50 mev . we also report the dependence of the total excitation energy in fission , txe , on neutron energy .

1607.05367

* * * * quantum teleportation has found important applications for realization of various quantum technologies @xcite . teleportation of quantum states has been demonstrated between light beams @xcite , trapped atoms @xcite , superconducting qubits @xcite , defect spins in solids @xcite , and from light beams to atoms @xcite or solid state spin qubits @xcite . it is of both fundamental interest and practical importance to push quantum teleportation towards more macroscopic objects . * * * * observing quantum phenomenon in macroscopic objects is a big challenge as their strong coupling to the environment causes fast decoherence which quickly pushes them to the classical world . for example , quantum coherence is hard to survive in mechanical vibration of macroscopic solids , which involves collective motion of a large number of strongly interacting atoms . despite this challenge , achieving quantum control for the optomechanical systems becomes a recent focus of interest with remarkable progress * * @xcite**. this is driven in part by the fundamental interest and in part by the potential applications of these systems for quantum signal transduction * * @xcite * * , sensing * * @xcite * * , and quantum information processing * * @xcite**. there are typically two routes to achieve quantum control for the optomechanical systems : one needs to either identify some isolated degrees of freedom in mechanical vibrations and cool them to very low temperature to minimize their environmental coupling * * @xcite * * , or use the ultrafast laser technology to fast process and detect quantum coherence in such systems * * @xcite**. a remarkable example for the latter approach is provided by the optomechanical control in macroscopic diamond samples * * @xcite * * , where the motions of two separated diamonds have been cast into a quantum entangled state * * @xcite**. in this paper , we report an experimental demonstration of quantum teleportation from light beams to the vibrational states of a macroscopic diamond sample of @xmath2 mm@xmath3 in size under ambient conditions . the vibration states are carried by two optical phonon modes , representing collective oscillation of over @xmath4 carbon atoms . to facilitate convenient qubit operations , we use the dual - rail representation of qubits instead of the single - rail encoding used in previous experiments * * @xcite * * and generate entanglement between the paths of a photon and different oscillation patterns of the diamond represented by two phononic modes . using quantum state tomography , we demonstrate entanglement fidelity of @xmath5 with the raw data and of @xmath6 after the background noise subtraction . using this entanglement , we prepare arbitrary polarization states for the photon and teleport these polarization states to the phonon modes with the bell measurements on the polarization and the path qubits carried by the same photon . the teleportation is verified by quantum process tomography , and we achieve a high average teleportation fidelity , about @xmath7 ( or @xmath8 ) after ( or before ) subtraction of the background noise . to verify the phonon s state before its fast decay , our implementation of teleportation adopted the technique of reversed time ordering introduced in ref . * * @xcite * * where the phonon s state is read out before the teleportation is completed . similar to the pioneering teleportation experiment of photons @xcite , our implementation of teleportation is conditional as the bell measurements are not deterministic and require postselecting of successful measurement outcomes . and generates a stokes photon in the forward direction and an excitation in the optical phonon mode of the diamond ( denoted by the state @xmath9 ) . the optical phonon mode corresponds to relative oscillation of the atoms in each unit cell of the diamond lattice , as illustrated by the figure on the right side . a read beam after a controllable delay converts the phonon excitation to an anti - stokes photon which can be used for state readout . the corresponding wavelengths and frequencies are shown in the figure . the state @xmath10 denotes the electron conduction band which is far detuned from the optical excitation . * b * , a scheme for generation of entanglement between a phonon in the diamond and a propagating photon . the phonon state is represented by a superposition of different oscillation modes of the diamond , while the photon state is represented by its spatial modes . * c * , readout of the phonon state with the read beams by coherently converting the phonon modes into the corresponding anti - stoke photon modes . * d * , a teleportation scheme using the photon - phonon entanglement . an input state is prepared by the message sender , alice , on the photon s polarization degree of freedom . the photon thus carries two qubits , one by its polarization and one by its spatial modes . alice performs bell measurements on these two qubits . conditional on certain measurement outcomes , the phonon state is projected to the same state input on alice s side , which is read out and verified by bob , the message receiver . , width=321,height=264 ] we illustrate our entanglement generation and quantum teleportation scheme in fig . 1 , using a type iia single - crystal synthetic diamond sample cut along the @xmath11 face from the element six company . due to the strong interaction of atoms in the diamond , the optical phonon mode , which represents relative oscillation of the two sublattices in the stiff diamond lattice ( see fig . 1a ) , has a very high excitation frequency about @xmath12 @xmath13 near the momentum zero point in the brillouin zone . the corresponding energy scale for this excitation is significantly higher than the room temperature thermal energy ( about @xmath14 @xmath13 ) , and thus the optical phonon mode naturally stays at the vacuum state under ambient conditions , which simplifies its quantum control * * @xcite**. the coherence life time of the optical phonon mode is about @xmath15 ps at room temperature , which is short but accessible with the ultrafast laser technology for which the operational speed can be up to about @xmath16 thz * * @xcite**. we excite the optical phonon modes through ultrafast laser pulses of duration around @xmath17 fs from the ti - sapphire laser , with the carrier wavelength at @xmath18 nm . the diamond has a large bandgap of @xmath19 ev , so the laser pulses are far detuned from the conduction band with a large gap about @xmath20 thz . each laser pulse generates , with a small probability @xmath21 , an excitation in the optical phonon mode and a stokes photon of wavelength @xmath22 nm in the forward direction ( see fig . 1a ) . the relevant output state has the form @xmath23 |\text{vac}\rangle , \ ] ] where @xmath24 and @xmath25 represent , respectively , the creation operators for an optical phonon and a stokes photon , and @xmath26vac@xmath27 denotes the common vacuum state for both the photon and the phonon modes . to generate entanglement , we split the laser pulse into two coherent paths as shown in fig . 1b , and the pulse in each path generates the corresponding phonon - photon correlated state described by eq . when there is an output photon , in one of the two paths , it is in the following maximally entangled state with the phonon excitation@xmath28here , @xmath29 or @xmath30 represents an excitation in the upper or lower path , and its subscript denotes the nature of the excitation , `` n '' for a phonon and `` t '' for a photon . we drop the vacuum term in eq . ( 1 ) as it is eliminated if we detect a photon emerging from one of the two paths . after entanglement generation , the photon state can be directly measured through single - photon detectors . to read out the phonon state , we apply another ultrafast laser pulse after a controllable delay within the coherence time of the optical phonon mode and convert the phononic state to the same photonic state in the forward anti - stokes mode at the wavelength of @xmath31 nm ( see fig . the state of the anti - stokes photon is then measured through single - photon detectors together with linear optics devices . note that the retrieval laser pulse could have a carrier frequency @xmath32 different from that of the pump laser . for instance , with @xmath32 near the telecom band , our teleportation protocol would naturally realize a quantum frequency transducer that transfers the photon s frequency to a desired band without changing its quantum state . a quantum frequency transducer is widely recognized as an important component for realization of long - distance quantum networks * * @xcite**. to realize teleportation , we need to prepare another qubit , whose state will be teleported to the phonon modes in the diamond . similar to the teleportation experiments in refs . * * @xcite * * , we use the polarization state of the photon to represent the input qubit , which can be independently prepared into an arbitrary state @xmath33 , where @xmath34 and @xmath35 denote the horizontal and the vertical polarization states and @xmath36 are arbitrary coefficients . the bell measurements on the polarization and the path qubits carried by the same photon can be implemented through linear optics devices together with single - photon detection ( see fig . 1d ) , and the teleported state to the phononic modes is retrieved and detected through its conversion to the anti - stokes photon . same as ref . * * @xcite * * , the short life time of the diamond s vibration modes requires us to retrieve and detect the phonon s state before applying detection on the stokes photon , thus the phonon s state is measured before the teleportation protocol is completed . the reversed time ordering in this demonstration of quantum teleportation makes it unsuitable for application in quantum repeaters which requires a much longer memory time , however , it does not affect application of our teleportation experiment for realization of a quantum frequency transducer or a new source of entangled photons as discussed above . mhz , a carrier wavelength of @xmath18 nm , and a polarization along the @xmath37 direction , are split by a birefringent calcite into two coherent paths with equal amplitudes . after rotation of the pulse polarization to equal superposition of @xmath38 and @xmath39 again with a half wave plate ( hwp1 ) set at @xmath40 , we introduce a time delay of @xmath41 fs to the two polarization components @xmath42 and @xmath43 with a birefringent bbocrystal . we use the lead pulse of @xmath42 polarization as the write beam and the lagged pulse of @xmath43 polarization as the read beam . after semicircle hwps set at @xmath44 and @xmath45 , respectively , at the upper and lower paths , the polarization states of the pump beams are shown in the figure before the diamond sample . the write beam is focused by the lens l1 on the diamond sample and generates a stokes photon in one of the paths and an excitation in the corresponding optical phonon modes of the diamond . the stokes photon , at the wavelength of @xmath22 nm , is transmitted by the dichromatic mirror dm1 after the collection lens l2 , with its two paths recombined by the calcite c2 . to verify entanglement , we do not need hwp3 and the optical elements in the state preparation box . the lens l3 and l4 are used to adjust the distance between the two optical paths so that they can be combined at the calcite c2 . the single - photon detector apd2 , together with rotation of the polarizer p2 , detects the two path ( or polarization ) components of the stokes photon in different bases . to read out the state of the phonon modes , the read pulse converts the phonon to the anti - stokes photon in the corresponding paths , preserving its quantum state . the anti - stokes photon , at a shorter wavelength of @xmath31 nm , is reflected by both of the dichromatic mirrors dm1 and dm2 , with its two paths recombined through the calcite c3 . the single - photon detector apd1 , together with rotation of the half and the quarter wave plates hwp5 and qwp2 , detects the anti - stokes photon ( and thus the phonon ) in any superposition bases . for quantum teleportation , semicircle hwps and the polarizer p1 in the state preparation box transforms the photon - phonon entangled state to the standard form of eq . ( 2 ) and initializes the photon polarization to the state @xmath46 . the waveplates hwp2 and qwp1 then prepare the to - be - teleported photon polarization to any superposition state . the calcite c2 , the hwp3 , the polarizer p2 , and the detector apd2 , together , make a bell measurement on the two qubits carried by the polarization and the path degrees of freedom of the same photon . the photon coincidence counts are registered through a fpga ( field - programmable gate array ) board with a @xmath47 nm coincidence window . , width=642,height=264 ] our experimental setup is shown in fig . , we verify entanglement generated between the stokes photon and the optical phonon modes in the diamond . for this step , we remove the optical elements in the state preparation box shown in fig . 2 and set the angle of hwp3 to @xmath44 . different from the scheme illustrated in fig . 1 , we insert semicircle hwps set at @xmath44 and @xmath45 , respectively , at the upper and the lower paths of the pump beam , so that both the stokes photon and the anti - stokes photon after the retrieval pulse have orthogonal polarizations along the two output paths , which can be combined together through the calcites c2 and c3 . this facilitates the entanglement measurement through detection in complementary local bases by rotating the polarizers p2 and p3 and the wave plates hwp5 and qwp2 . due to the different incident directions of the pump pulses at the upper and the lower paths , the corresponding phonon modes excited in the diamond have different momenta , so they represent independent modes even if they have partial spatial overlap . the phonon is converted to the anti - stokes photon by the retrieval pulse , so we measure the photon - phonon state by detecting the coincidence counts between stokes and anti - stokes photons in different bases . in fig . 3a , we show the registered coincidence counts as we rotate the angle of the polarizer p2 . the oscillation of the coincidence counts with a visibility of @xmath48 is an indicator of coherence of the underlying state . to verify entanglement of the photon - phonon state , we use quantum state tomography to reconstruct the full density matrix from the measured coincidence counts * * @xcite * * , with the resulting matrix elements shown in fig . 3b . from the reconstructed density matrix @xmath49 , we find its entanglement fidelity , defined as the maximum overlap of @xmath49 with a maximally entangled state , @xmath50 , significantly higher than the criterion of @xmath51 for verification of entanglement * * @xcite**. the error bars are determined by assuming a poissonian distribution for the photon counts and propagated from the raw data to the calculated quantities through exact numerical simulation . the dominant noise in this system comes from the accidental coincidence between the detected stokes and the anti - stokes photons * * @xcite**. to measure the contribution of this accidental coincidence , we introduce an extra time delay of @xmath52 @xmath53 , the repetition period of our pump pulses , to one of the detectors when we record the coincidence . when we subtract the background noise due to this accidental coincidence , the resulting matrix elements reconstructed from the quantum state tomography are shown in fig . we find the entanglement fidelity is improved to @xmath54 after subtraction of the accidental coincidence . . the error bars denote the standard deviation . * b * , real and imaginary parts of the density matrix elements for the phonon - photon entangled state reconstructed through the quantum state tomography . the hollow caps correspond to the values of matrix elements for a perfect maximally entangled state . * c * , same as fig . 3b , but we subtract the background noise due to the accidental coincidences of the photon detectors . the coincidence count rate for stokes and anti - stokes photons is @xmath55 per second for measurements in the @xmath56 and @xmath57 bases . , width=321,height=264 ] to perform quantum teleportation using the photon - phonon entanglement , we first transform the effective photon - phonon entangled state to the standard form of eq . ( 2 ) by the semicircle hwps in the state preparation box of fig . 2 . the polarizer p1 and the waveplates hwp2 and qwp1 then prepare the to - be - teleported photon polarization to arbitrary superposition states @xmath58 . we perform bell measurement through the calcite c2 , the hwp3 , the polarizer p2 , and the detector apd2 . for instance , with the hwp3 set at @xmath44 and the polarizer p2 set along the direction @xmath59 , a photon count in the detector apd2 corresponds to a projection to the bell state @xmath60 for the polarization and the path qubits of the photon before the measurement box . by rotating the angles of hwp3 and p2 , we can also perform projection to any other bell states . the experimental result for teleportation is shown in fig . the teleportation fidelity is defined as @xmath61 , where @xmath62 is the input state at alice s side and @xmath63 denotes the output density matrix at bob s side reconstructed through quantum state tomography measurements . in fig . 4a , we show the teleportation fidelity under six complementary bases states with @xmath64 @xmath65 in cases with and without subtraction of the background noise . the average fidelity over these six bases states is @xmath66 ( or @xmath67 ) with ( or without ) background noise subtraction . this average fidelity is significantly higher than @xmath1 , the boundary value for the fidelity that separates quantum teleportation from classical operations . for more complete characterization , we also perform quantum process tomography ( qpt ) for the teleportation operation . in the ideal case , teleportation should be characterized by an identity transformation , meaning that alice s input state is teleported perfectly to bob s side . the experimentally reconstructed process matrix elements are shown in fig . 4b ( see methods for explanation of qpt ) . the process fidelity is given by @xmath68 , which corresponds to a teleportation fidelity @xmath69 averaged over all possible input states with equal weight in the qubit space . corresponds to the classical - quantum boundary for teleportation . * b * , real and imaginary parts of the process matrix elements for quantum teleportation reconstructed through the quantum process tomography ( see methods ) . the hollow caps correspond to the values of process matrix elements for a perfect teleportation operation . , width=321,height=264 ] teleportation of quantum states from a photon to the vibration modes of a millimeter - sized diamond under ambient conditions generates a quantum link between the microscopic particle and the macroscopic world around us usually under the law of classical physics . in our experiment , the ultrafast laser technology provides the key tool for fast processing and detection of quantum states within its short life time in macroscopic objects consisting of many strongly interacting atoms that are coupled to the environment . combined with the tunability of the wavelength for the retrieval laser pulse * * @xcite * * , the technique introduced in our experiment would be useful for realization of a new source of entangled photons based on the diamond optomechanical coupling with the dual - rail encoding . such a source could generate entangled photons at wavelengths inconvenient to produce by other methods . for instance , we may generate entanglement between ultraviolet and infrared photons , with the infrared photon good for quantum communication and the ultraviolet photon convenient to be interfaced with other qubits , such as the ion matter qubits . such a photon source is hard to generate by the conventional spontaneous parametric down conversion method . in future , the tools based on the ultrafast pump and probe could be combined with the powerful laser cooling or low - temperature technology , to provide more efficient ways for quantum control of the optomechanical systems , with important applications for realization of transduction of quantum signals * * @xcite * * , processing of quantum information or single - photon signals * * @xcite * * , and sensing of small mechanical vibrations * * @xcite**. quantum process tomography ( qpt ) @xcite is defined by a completely positive map @xmath70 that transfers an arbitrary input state @xmath71 to the output @xmath72 . it can be characterized by a unique process matrix @xmath73 through the map @xmath74 by choosing a fixed set of basis operator @xmath75 . in our experiment , we set the basis operators @xmath75 to be the identity operator @xmath76 and the three pauli matrices @xmath77 , @xmath78 , @xmath79 . this corresponds to a choice of six complementary input states @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 , @xmath83 through the maximally likelihood estimation @xcite . the process fidelity is determined by @xmath84 , where @xmath85 is the identity process matrix corresponding to the perfect case . the process fidelity @xmath86 determines the average teleportation fidelity @xmath87 by the formula @xmath88 @xcite , where @xmath89 is defined as the fidelity averaged over all possible states of the input qubit with equal weight . * acknowledgements * this work was supported by the ministry of education of china through its grant to tsinghua university . lmd acknowledges in addition support from the iarpa program , the arl , and the afosr muri program .

with the recent development of optomechanics , the vibration in solids , involving collective motion of trillions of atoms , gradually enters into the realm of quantum control . built on the recent remarkable progress in optical control of motional states of diamonds , here we report an experimental demonstration of quantum teleportation from light beams to vibrational states of a macroscopic diamond under ambient conditions . through quantum process tomography , we demonstrate average teleportation fidelity @xmath0 , clearly exceeding the classical limit of @xmath1 . the experiment pushes the target of quantum teleportation to the biggest object so far , with interesting implications for optomechanical quantum control and quantum information science .

cond-mat9306061

the interface between the a- and b - phase of he is the only known boundary between two superfluid systems . the interface motion that accompanies the first order phase transition from the undercooled a- into the b - phase is subject to extended experimental and theoretical investigation . within the hydrodynamic regime , the structure of the interface dynamics can be rigorously determined by connecting the hydrodynamic modes on both sides of the interface with the appropriate connecting conditions ( cocos ) . this has already been done @xcite for the planar interface . in the present work , we generalize the hydrodynamic description to interfaces of finite curvature , taking as an example spherical b - phase bubbles growing in a bath of undercooled a - phase . to gain a qualitative understanding , consider first planar growth . for small growth velocities , the released latent heat serves as the source for two second sound step functions , emitted in opposite directions @xcite . the steps move with @xmath0 and @xmath1 if the a - phase is located on the right and @xmath2 denotes the second sound velocity . if the interface velocity @xmath3 becomes larger than @xmath2 , both steps are left behind in the b - phase . the same is true for spin waves if an external magnetic field produces excess magnetization at the interface @xcite . the reference velocity is now of course the spin wave velocity @xmath4 , rather than @xmath2 . qualitatively , bubble growth is not much different , except that the surface tension delivers an extra push towards the energetically more favorable b - phase : neglecting the anisotropy , radial step functions of second sound are emitted out- and inward for @xmath5 . the inward moving step functions quickly equalize the temperature distribution within the b - phase bubble . for @xmath6 , both radial waves of second sound remain inside the bubble while the temperature remains homogeneous in the a - phase . the spin wave and the magnetization behave accordingly . ( though spin waves are emitted only for higher interface velocities @xmath7 @xcite ) the case @xmath8 may seem academic but one really can not discount the possibility that it was indeed already observed @xcite . then , even both spin waves remain inside the bubble where neither the temperature nor the magnetization is homogeneous . causality sees to it that the a - phase is completely unperturbed . the complication of bubble growth is in its time dependence . while planar growth keeps both @xmath3 and the amplitudes of the emitted waves constant , neither are in bubble growth . the growth velocity is not constant because the pushing surface tension , proportional to the inverse of the bubble radius @xmath9 , is not . the amplitudes are not constant , because first of all , they vary as @xmath10 when moving away from the interface ; second , the amplitudes in addition are functions of @xmath11 . ( in fact , there is a retardation effect , the amplitudes are functions of @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the time of flight @xmath14 or @xmath15 . ) the anisotropy of @xmath2 and @xmath4 will distort the radial wave into an elliptical shape , with the principal axes being parallel and perpendicular to @xmath16 , the orbital preferred direction . ( we presume @xmath16 to be uniform . ) in addition , the growth and kapitza coefficients are also @xmath16-dependent , and this directly distorts the bubble . ( given enough time , of course , the surface tension will drive the bubble into the shape that minimizes the surface energy ; generally , it is somewhere inbetween , reflecting some stationary balance between the surface tension and the uneven growth . ) assuming the same eccentricity for both ellipses , we can rescale to obtain isotropic growth and radial waves to perform the calculations . afterwards , the distortion into elliptical waves is achieved by taking the correct value of the anisotropic velocity for the two principle axes . if there are many bubbles present , their growth can be considered completely independent for @xmath17 , because the magnetic signals barely feed back to the growth @xcite , while the second sound waves , which do feed back , are confined to the interior of the bubbles . for @xmath18 however , the many emitted second sound waves heat up the surrounding a - phase . since the latent heat is not completely evacuated , the growth velocity slows down accordingly . a b - phase bubble is thermodynamically stable only if its radius exceeds the critical value @xmath19 ) @xcite , where @xmath20 denotes the interface tension and @xmath21 is the difference in the chemical potential across the interface ( for every quantity @xmath22 , we define : @xmath23 and @xmath24 ) . since @xmath25 vanishes at the coexistence point , @xmath26 diverges if @xmath27 approaches @xmath28 . at lower temperatures , , where @xmath29 is the mean free path of the quasi particles , the hydrodynamic description becomes valid only after the bubble has nucleated and reached an appropriate size by ballistic processes . 1 shows the respective length scales as a function of temperature . as pointed out by leggett and yip @xcite the nucleation process itself is likely to be of exotic nature . the cocos @xcite , we shall employ fall into three categories , those for the conserved quantities , those for the symmetry variables and the parameterization of the surface entropy production . for the locally conserved quantities , the cocos state the continuity of the respective currents , expressing the fact that conserved quantities can not accumulate within , or be depleted from , a region of microscopic width . this is not true , however , if the momentum current traverses a curved interface , where the radial bulk momentum current differs by the interfacial momentum current @xcite @xmath30 . ( note that @xmath31 : in equilibrium the pressure is larger on the a - phase side . ) with prime denoting the rest frame of the interface , the cocos are : @xmath32 the notations : mass current @xmath33 , pressure @xmath34 , nonlinear part of the momentum current @xmath35 , energy current @xmath36 and spin current @xmath37 . the behavior of the symmetry variables in the interface region is related to the elasticity of the order parameter within the interface . since the elastic coefficients are of comparable order of magnitude in the interface as in the bulk liquid , we have coherence of the symmetry variables across the interface . more specifically , we have for the phase angle @xmath38 and the rotation angle @xmath39 in spin space @xmath40 it is by means of eq . ( [ rbphi ] ) that the interface tension acts in accelerating the growth process . since ( [ rbphi ] ) implies @xmath41 , the interface tension couples to the dynamics through the pressure dependency of the chemical potential and coco ( [ rbmomentum ] ) is implicitly incorporated . when the growth starts at @xmath42 we find the initial interface velocity to be twice as fast as in the planar case . this effect should be accessible to experimental probe . the irreversibility of the phase transition is accounted for by the growth coefficient @xmath43 for @xmath6 , and by the kapitza resistance @xmath44 for @xmath5 , respectively . both @xmath43 and @xmath44 are effective , integrated quantities and functions of various surface onsager coefficients , thermodynamic susceptibilities and bulk transport coefficients @xcite . the rate of interface entropy production @xmath45 is then respectively given as @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the entropy current . so except eq . ( [ rbmomentum ] ) , all cocos retain their form of planar growth . the solution of these cocos in sec . [ sec : dyn ] shows the following result : the growth velocity decreases with @xmath48 towards the limiting value @xmath49 ( of the planar growth ) ; while the amplitudes of second sound generated during the growth show some intricate time dependency . in sec . [ sec : spin ] , we discuss the magnetic signals emitted by the growing bubble . these are more accessible to experimental probe . the general case of @xmath50 interacting bubbles @xmath51 is discussed in sec.[sec : nbub ] . we consider the magnetic signals emitted during bubble growth for @xmath52 . as discussed in ref . @xcite , the magnetization is for @xmath53 essentially given by its equilibrium values @xmath54 . the small deviations from the equilibrium values do not change much , going from planar to bubble growth . for higher velocities , @xmath55 , the dipole - interaction is negligible , the magnetic signals turn into spin waves and become delocalized . here , the circumstances of bubble growth are more complicated and are what we shall consider . the feed - back of the spin - dynamics to the growth velocity @xmath56 is negligible if @xmath56 is not too close to @xmath57 @xcite . hence , we may take @xmath56 , as calculated in sec . [ sec : dyn ] without the inclusion of the magnetic fields , as an input : @xmath58 where @xmath49 denotes the limiting value of the interface velocity for large @xmath59 , i.e. @xmath60 of planar growth . the explicit values for @xmath49 are given in eqs . ( [ rpinfslow ] ) and ( [ rpinffast ] ) for weak and strong undercooling , respectively . the solution of the differential equation ( [ rpvt ] ) subject to the initial condition @xmath61 then reads @xmath62 the inverse of ( [ tauvx ] ) can also be written in a closed form , see app . [ app : xvtau ] . we shall work with the longitudinal model @xcite , which contains only two dynamical variables : the magnetization and the dipole angle @xmath63 ( where @xmath64 is that between @xmath65 and @xmath16 , and @xmath66 is the angle around @xmath67 ) . the initial scenario contains a b - phase bubble of radius @xmath68 , exposed to a homogeneous magnetic field @xmath69 . within the bubble , we assume a uniform @xmath67-texture , parallel to @xmath69 ; in the surrounding a - phase we have @xmath70 , @xmath71 . although the uniformity of the @xmath67-texture contradicts the equilibrium a - b interface @xcite , we shall neglect this complication as in ref.@xcite . the coordinates are chosen such that @xmath69 points in the z - direction , while the x - axis coincides with @xmath16 . the spin - hydrodynamics in the a - phase is then given by the wave equation @xmath72 where @xmath73 and @xmath74 denote the spin wave velocities parallel and perpendicular to the preferred direction @xmath16 . the consequences of neglecting spin diffusion will be discussed at the end of this section . [ sebwgl ] shows that the outgoing wave fronts will be of ellipsoidal shape with a rotational symmetry around @xmath16 . assuming a growing bubble with the same eccentricity , as discussed in the introduction , we may distort the coordinates to render both ellipsoids ( interface and wave front ) spherical : @xmath75 ( @xmath76 is the spin - superfluid velocity . ) the b - phase spindynamics need not be considered explicitly . after the initial time lag of @xmath77 , the imploding wave front meets at the center . there , the excess magnetization ( always parallel to the external field @xmath69 ) from opposite directions add up , while the spin superfluid velocities @xmath78 ( all having the same sign along the radial direction ) from opposite directions cancel . so homogeneous magnetization and vanishing @xmath78 is a good approximation . with @xmath79 , we can safely neglect terms of order @xmath80 and @xmath81 ; the cocos ( [ rbtet ] ) and ( [ rbspin ] ) therefore take the simplified form @xmath82 with gyromagnetic ratio @xmath83 and susceptibility @xmath84 . working with the longitudinal model , only one of the three relations ( [ rbtet ] ) is needed here . the procedure to determine the space and time dependency of the radial waves from their cocos is given below : in the first step , we calculate the values of the general solution @xmath85 at the interface ( subscript @xmath86 ) from the cocos ( [ sebbc1 ] , [ sebbc2 ] ) . substituting the time dependent bubble radius @xmath9 for @xmath87 , we find @xmath88 where @xmath47 denotes the derivative of @xmath89 with respect to its argument . now , the amplitudes at the interface are functions of time only . for sake of clarity , we introduce an auxiliary function by @xmath90 implying @xmath91 the cocos ( [ sebbc1 ] , [ sebbc2 ] ) thereby turn into differential equations for @xmath92 which can be solved . having obtained @xmath92 with the appropriate initial condition @xmath93 , the next step is to reconstruct the @xmath94-dependency of @xmath89 , where we need the inverse function of @xmath95 : @xmath96 given @xmath97 , we can substitute @xmath98 and obtain @xmath99 and @xmath76 for all @xmath87 , @xmath100 via eq . ( [ sebdyn ] ) . for technical reasons , however , we modify this procedure and eliminate the time @xmath100 with the inverse of @xmath9 , instead of eliminating @xmath87 by @xmath9 , as described above . the reader is referred to app.[app : spincalc ] for the details of the calculation and the result . for the qualitative features cf . figs . 2 and 3 . the spatial variation of the outgoing radial wave is illustrated for different times . each curve displays two effects . first the @xmath10-decrease as the wave moves out , and second the amplitude at @xmath101 is a function of @xmath56 at @xmath102 , a retardation effect . the line at the upper surface of the box marks the location of the bubble surface , relative to the starting value . below , one can track the decrease of the amplitudes at the interface . as will be shown in sec . [ sec : dyn ] , these plots also visualize the second sound amplitudes , emitted by a slowly growing bubble . at the head of the shock wave , i.e. where @xmath103 , the expressions for the amplitudes simplify to become @xmath104 the qualitative effect of the spin diffusion , neglected here , is the rounding of the magnetization step with @xmath105 at the wave front . so eq . ( [ sebhead ] ) is valid for the total change in @xmath76 and @xmath99 . the interface dynamics of superfluid he is fundamentally different from other systems @xcite . if @xmath5 , the evacuation of latent heat is very efficiently accomplished via second sound , the difference between hypercooling and normal supercooling is inessential , and @xmath3 is determined by the kapitza resistance of the interface . for @xmath6 , the system is always hypercooled , no heat evacuation needs to take place and not much does . @xmath3 is determined by the growth coefficient . in bubble growth , two similar scenarios prevail : for weak undercooling of the a - phase , @xmath106 , an outgoing radial wave is emitted into the a - phase , while an imploding wave is emitted into the bubble . the latter will interfere at the center of the bubble , as in the case of spin waves , yielding vanishing counterflow and an averaged temperature , depending only on the current bubble radius . for strong undercooling , assuring @xmath107 at all time , no sound is emitted into the a - phase , while an exploding and an imploding wave superpose inside the bubble , yielding a time dependent temperature distribution . we start from the linearized equations of bulk hydrodynamics ( correct for both limits @xcite @xmath108 , @xmath106 but not in - between , @xmath109 @xcite ) , in a form appropriate for the spherical symmetry of the problem . as in planar growth , first sound is too fast to need explicit consideration . its only role is to maintain uniform pressure on both sides of the interface , while keeping the discontinuity @xmath110 across it . this leaves two equations : conservation of entropy and the equation for the counterflow . the counterflow , @xmath111 is curl - free and can be written as @xmath112 . the two hydrodynamic equations then become @xmath113 eq . ( [ sphersymvar ] ) seems to allow @xmath114 and @xmath115 differing by an explicit function of time . this is ruled out by the wave equation that can be obtained from the combination of ( [ spherentro ] ) and ( [ sphersymvar ] ) , which must not have any time dependent source . in summary , we end up with @xmath116 in close analogy to ( [ sebdyn ] ) . we will consider two different stages : the first stage is characterized by the existence of an incoming and an outgoing second sound wave and lasts only for a time span of order @xmath117 , where @xmath118 . the second stage starts after the interference has established homogeneity inside the bubble , making the temperature solely dependent of the bubble radius . in the calculation of the second stage we shall neglect the existence of the first . this only changes the initial condition and hence the exact shape of the radial wave front but not its magnitude . for very weak undercooling , @xmath26 is large compared to the quasiparticles mean free path , so that for @xmath119 @xmath42 and @xmath120 are the valid initial conditions . otherwise , we assume a nonvanishing initial temperature discontinuity @xmath121 and @xmath122 at @xmath119 . we expand the cocos ( [ rbq],[rbphi],[rsentro ] ) , to first order in @xmath123 , @xmath124 , @xmath125 around the initial temperature @xmath126 : @xmath127 all quantities refer to the laboratory frame . terms of order @xmath128 as well as @xmath129 , @xmath130 and @xmath131 are omitted . from ( [ sbc2 ] ) and ( [ sbc3 ] ) we readily obtain the interface motion as quoted in eq . ( [ rpvt ] ) . the limiting value of the interface velocity is @xmath132 we consider the sound amplitudes at the interface for the first stage . starting with @xmath133 we apply the method described in sec . [ sec : spin ] and calculate the sound amplitudes to lowest order in @xmath134 : @xmath135 . \label{sw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] setting @xmath136 and @xmath137 to zero , these expressions can be compared to the results of planar growth @xcite : as it turns out , the surface tension doubles the initially emitted sound amplitudes . note that the terms of first order in @xmath138 are dominated by the contribution proportional to @xmath139 . for the second stage , the situation is quite similar to that of spinwaves , examined in the last section . since ( [ sbc2 ] ) and ( [ sbc3 ] ) have already been used once to determine the bubble radius as a function of time , we shall now only consider the cocos ( [ sbc1 ] ) and ( [ sbc2 ] ) . with @xmath140 vanishing , ( [ sbc1 ] ) simplifies to @xmath141 which is analog to ( [ sebbc2 ] ) when @xmath142 is identified with @xmath143 . combining ( [ aeq1 ] ) with ( [ sbc2 ] ) yields @xmath144 by identification of @xmath145 with @xmath99 , ( [ aeq2 ] ) is analogous to ( [ sebbc1 ] ) . ( these identifications are justified by inspection of the bulk hydrodynamics : ( [ secsndweq ] ) goes over into ( [ sebdyn ] ) by the substitution of @xmath146 for @xmath38 ; but this does not alter the solution of the wave equation . ) we can therefore take over the results of sec . [ sec : spin ] by setting @xmath147 when we in addition observe the respective redefinition of @xmath148 and @xmath149 , @xmath150 introduced in app . [ app : spincalc ] . as a consequence of this analogy , 2 and 3 also serve as illustrations of counterflow and temperature amplitudes . at the strong degree of undercooling we are considering here , the hydrodynamic description only holds after the bubble has grown to an appropriate multiple of the critical size . we therefore impose the initial condition @xmath151 with @xmath152 . inside the bubble , an incoming and an outgoing second sound wave superpose . after the incoming wave front has been `` reflected '' at the center of the bubble , there are two spherical discontinuities of temperature and counterflow , expanding outward and laging behind the third discontinuity , at the bubble surface . neglecting terms of the order @xmath153 , an expansion of ( [ rbq],[rbphi],[rsentro ] ) , again in @xmath154 , yields for the discontinuities at the bubble surface @xmath155 from ( [ fbc2 ] ) we obtain the temperature @xmath156 which , together with ( [ fbc3 ] ) , again leads to ( [ rpvt ] ) . here the limiting value of the interface velocity is @xmath157 by calculation of the total counterflow amplitude @xmath158 our initial neglect of @xmath159 proves to be appropriate . as mentioned in the introduction , we expect the growth velocity of the bubble to slow down , when its surrounding heats up from second sound radiation sent out by other bubbles . only the case of weak undercooling ( @xmath160 ) is worth studying , since for strong undercooling ( @xmath161 ) all the latent heat remains inside the bubble . let us for simplicity consider a volume @xmath51 of a - phase , containing @xmath50 b - phase bubbles , nucleated simultaneously and distributed uniformly over @xmath51 . each individual bubble grows as described in the preceding section until it is reached by the second sound pulses of its neighbors . from now on , the accumulative heating of the a - phase increasingly hinders the evacuation of latent heat and slows down the growth velocity . we will restrict our calculations to the regime where the temperatures of both the a- and b - phase can be regarded as being uniform . the volume @xmath51 is thus divided up into two subsystems : @xmath50 bubbles of total volume @xmath162 and the remaining a - phase of volume @xmath163 . since the gradients vanish , the local hydrodynamic description of the previous sections reduce to thermodynamic considerations : for small deviations from equilibrium , energy conservation accounts for equality of the entropy currents , @xmath164 where @xmath165 and @xmath166 denote the total entropies of the respective phase . because of the identity @xmath167 we identify eq . ( [ nbc1 ] ) as the continuity condition of the local entropy current , integrated over the area of the interface . in the same manner , we obtain the onsager relation , starting from @xmath168 as @xmath169 here , @xmath170 denotes the area of the interface so that the total rate of interface entropy production is an extensive function with respect to the interface area , as it must be . being of intensive nature , the continuity condition for the phase angle @xmath171 does not change its appearance . because of the homogeneity of the subsystems , all thermodynamic quantities are explicit functions of @xmath59 . we therefore need to specify only a single initial condition : @xmath172 where @xmath173 denotes the initial bubble radius and @xmath174 is the temperature difference that was built up across the interface during the switch - on process . from sec . [ sec : dyn ] , we expect @xmath174 to be of the order @xmath175 . since ( [ nbc3 ] ) was already valid before homogeneity had been established , the initial temperature amplitudes are found to be @xmath176 here and below , we neglect the effect of interface tension , i.e. we assume @xmath177 . from ( [ nbc1 ] ) and the derivative of ( [ nbc3 ] ) with respect to @xmath59 we obtain @xmath178 and @xmath179 which may be integrated to give the temperature amplitudes as functions of the bubble radius : @xmath180 with @xmath181 , @xmath182 . the growth velocity follows from ( [ nbc2 ] ) : @xmath183 obviously , the system approaches an equilibrium state with equal temperatures on both sides of the interface and vanishing @xmath56 . starting with @xmath184 the interface velocity decreases and eventually comes to rest at the final bubble radius @xmath185 . the b - phase bubbles then occupy the volume @xmath186 and the final temperature amplitudes amount to @xmath187 for convenience , we introduce reduced dimensionless variables by @xmath189 and @xmath190 , where @xmath191 is the characteristic time for interface movement . the solution ( [ tauvx ] ) of the equation of motion of the bubble radius ( [ rpvt ] ) then takes the form @xmath192 which shall now be inverted to yield the bubble radius as a function of time . the inverse of @xmath193 , is known as lambert s function @xmath194 @xcite . for real valued @xmath195 , @xmath194 has two branches : @xmath196 exponentiation of ( [ apptauvx ] ) yields @xmath197 by definition of @xmath194 this is equivalent to @xmath198 @xmath199 is the right branch , because the argument is always negative , and @xmath195 must not be limited . note that we reserve @xmath195 and @xmath200 to denote the reduced bubble radius and the corresponding reduced time , respectively . arbitrary coordinates @xmath94 are referred to by @xmath201 , see app . with @xmath202 , @xmath203 , @xmath204 , @xmath205 , @xmath206 , @xmath207 , eqs . ( [ sebdyn ] ) read @xmath208 while the cocos ( [ sebbc1 ] ) and ( [ sebbc2 ] ) become @xmath209 the general solution of ( [ segredwgl ] ) is @xmath210 . inserting @xmath211 and @xmath212 , with @xmath213 into the cocos ( [ redsebbc ] ) , we obtain the following differential equation for @xmath214 : @xmath215 the special solution of ( [ dglq ] ) subject to the initial condition @xmath216 is @xmath217 here , @xmath218 denotes the hypergeometric function as defined in @xcite , eq . ( 7 - 76 ) . choosing @xmath219 so that , @xmath220 we obtain the spin wave amplitudes outside the bubble as @xmath221 a closed form expression for @xmath219 is derived in app.[app : calcx1 ] a necessary condition for ( [ defx1 ] ) to be fulfilled is given by @xmath223 inserting the definition ( [ tauvx ] ) of @xmath224 gives after exponentiation @xmath225 so that @xmath226 to check for the right branch , we make use of the identity @xmath227 since @xmath228 , the argument of @xmath199 is negative . @xmath199 is the right branch , because @xmath195 has to be a monotonic function of itself . 99 d. s. buchanan , g. w. swift and j. c. wheatley , _ phys . _ , * 57 * , 341 ( 1986 ) . s. t. p. boyd and g. w swift , _ phys . lett._,*64 * , 894 , ( 1990 ) . s. t. p. boyd and g. w swift , _ j. low . temp . _ , * 87 * , 35 , ( 1992 ) . s. t. p. boyd and g. w swift , _ j. low . _ , * 86 * , 325 , ( 1992 ) . s. yip and a. j. leggett , _ phys . rev . _ , * 57 * , 345 ( 1986 ) ; a. j. leggett and s. k. yip , in _ helium three _ , w. p. halperin and l. p. pitaevskii , eds . ( elsevier , amsterdam 1990 ) ; a. j. leggett , _ j. low . temp . _ , * 87 * , 571 , ( 1992 ) . j. palmeri , _ phys . _ , * 62 * , 1872 ( 1989 ) ; n. b. kopnin , _ zh . eksp . theor _ , * 92 * , 2106 , ( 1987 ) [ _ sov . phys . jetp _ , * 65 * , 1187 , ( 1987 ) ] . m. grabinski and m. liu , _ phys . _ , * 65 * , 2666 ( 1990 ) . panzer and m. liu , _ phys . _ , * 69 * , 3658 , ( 1992 ) . _ j. low . temp _ , to be published in june 1993 p. kostdt and m. liu , _ to be published . _ d. vollhardt and p. wlfle , _ the superfluid phases of helium 3 _ , taylor and francis , london ( 1990 ) , sec . 10.2 and sec . 7.2 . we have put @xmath229 . @xmath230 is the interfacial energy as introduced in d. d. osheroff and m. c. cross , _ phys . _ , * 38 * , 905 , ( 1977 ) ; r. kaul and h. kleinert , _ j. low . temp _ , * 38 * , 539 , ( 1980 ) ; n. schopohl , _ phys . _ , * 58 * , 1664 , ( 1987 ) . e. v. thuneberg , _ physica b _ * 178 * , 168 ( 1992 ) . j. johannesson and m. liu _ to be published . _ r. m. corless , g. h. gonnet , d. e. g. hare , and d. j. jeffrey , _ technical report cs-93 - 03 _ , universtiy of waterloo , canada , ( 1993 ) . also available via anonymous ftp from cs-archive.uwaterloo.ca as cs - archive / cs-93 - 03/w.ps.z . j. mathews and r. l. walker , _ mathematical methods of physics _ , addison - wesley , ( 1970 ) . mean free path @xmath29 of quasi particles in the b - phase ( taken from fig . 10.1 of ref . @xcite ) and critical bubble radius @xmath26 ( as given by kaul and kleinert @xcite),both as functions of temperature . + * figure 2 : * counterflow and spin - superfluid velocity , scaled as + @xmath231 + * figure 3 : * temperature and excess magnetization , scaled as + @xmath232=1

we study the hydrodynamics of the a - b interface with finite curvature . the interface tension is shown to enhance both the transition velocity and the amplitudes of second sound . in addition , the magnetic signals emitted by the growing bubble are calculated , and the interaction between many growing bubbles is considered . -10 pt 10 pt 1 in 0 in 0 in 0.75 in 6.375 true in = mathrm # 1#1 = 500 pacs - numbers : 67.57.-z , 67.55.fa itp - uh 11/93

1101.5002

quantum mechanics ( qm ) , particularly featured by @xmath0 and @xmath1 , has been always facing the fundamental critics since its establishment @xcite . the exact physical meaning of `` quantum '' is unclear , which leads to the well - known `` weirdness '' . the development of quantum field theory ( qft ) , which is often viewed as an improved form of qm , does not resolve the seminal problems in qm , such as the direct physical meaning of wave function and phase , the role of quantization and measurement , etc . the problem of the foundation of qm has been widely concerned again due to the progress of quantum information and quantum computing ( qiqc ) @xcite . the concepts of nonlocality and entanglement have proven their importance , yet , there exist confusions between them @xcite . for the research of foundation of qm , we can briefly clarify two sub - fields , one is the interpretation of qm @xcite , the other is the post - qm @xcite . the problems and confusions on basic concepts even philosophy , such as the classical @xcite , hidden variable @xcite , collapse @xcite , etc are mostly addressed in the interpretations . post - qm also devotes to the complete mathematical form of qm , such as the information - theoretic approach @xcite , the khler structure approach @xcite , etc . the standard qm bases on several assumptions , and the physical explanations of the copenhagen ( orthodox ) interpretation are not satisfying . uncertainty and complementarity are emphasized ; however , for uncertainty , there are different explanations , either based on measurement , knowledge , propensity , or reality @xcite . for the statistical meaning of the wave function and measurement , the disagreement is more notable . born viewed statistics as inherent , while einstein , by epr - argument @xcite , viewed statistics as a result of incompleteness of qm . the notable `` jump '' and `` collapse '' do not have clear physical pictures . the most primary problem is that the copenhagen interpretation did not give an exact and direct meaning to the wave function , e.g. , why @xmath1 is complex ? indeed , there are direct efforts to explain the physical meaning of wave function , which led to the hidden variable method and bohm mechanics @xcite . every particle is endowed with definite coordinate and trajectory under the restraint of guiding wave . also , there exists the physical collapse theory aimed to explain collapse @xcite . however , it modifies the schrdinger equation and the linearity , which is shown to be the analogy of the approaches based on decoherence @xcite . coherence and decoherence , which were not demonstrated in the standard qm , have gained lots of attentions these years . for instance , the many - world interpretation @xcite views the universe as a coherent entity , and there exist the inner observer and relative state . the consistent ( decohered ) history approaches @xcite take the time evolution and measurement into account , and demonstrate the structure of quantum logic . in zurek s exsistential interpretation @xcite , the uncertainty principle is re - explained from the view of information , and the born s rule is deduced via the symmetry of envariance . recently , kinds of information - theoretic theories @xcite are developed , where qm is viewed as a kind of information processing theory . with all these progresses , however , the exact essence of quantum has not been drawn . at the same time , the continuous argument on foundation of qm also arose the reflection of the primary philosophical conception , which can not be avoided in the quantum physics . the problem that why we can not easily understand qm just brings the problem that why we think the classical mechanics ( cm ) is normal . in this paper , our standing point is to view qm as a special kind of `` description '' of motion , from which , there is no good or bad of qm and cm @xcite . the theories , with equations and models , deal with the same nature only revealing different aspects and properties . the state vector in hilbert space can capture the properties of coherence , e.g. , interference , which is exotic for cm . on the contrary , trajectory is the basic idea in cm and the macroscopic world , yet , not in qm , due to the uncertainty . we note the trajectory in the path - integral method , which borrows ideas from cm , only has mathematical meaning . in practice ( reality ) , to employ which description depends on its efficiency . in this work , we start from one new concept , `` scope '' , to check the foundation of qm . we focus on the basic concepts and ideas in qm , mostly relating to superposition . we do not intend to construct a broader theory with the standard qm as the special case , the methods based on scope mainly belong to the interpretation of qm . scope describes the `` structure of motion '' , i.e. , the logic and systematic potential action region of the movement of a certain object ( system ) . that is , from scope we can get the ability and the whole structure of the motion of the matter . the merits of the concept of scope are multi - folds . firstly , the direct one , the weirdness of qm can be resolved based on scope , the wave function and superposition can get their physical meaning . secondly , the abstract qm can gain solid natural foundation and physical essence , i.e. , qm is a totally new kind of description different with cm ( including statistical mechanics ) and also relativity . thirdly , scope can bring new ideas . for instance , the wave function and superposition principle can also be used in the mesoscopic and macroscopic scales , that is , the concept of scope is universal , can not be restricted by the scale . also , qm may not rely on the hilbert space , since scope itself can form a kind of space , also there can be other kinds of space , e.g. , tangnet @xcite , relating to quantum information and entanglement . forth , another point , the concept of scope may have new indication of the basic ideas of nature and philosophy , e.g. , it means every object has finite ability of motion . this work is divided into four parts . in sec . [ sec : open ] , we start from the concept of openness , which is central for qm , to clarify several basic physical ideas . in sec . [ sec : scope ] , we introduce the new concept of `` scope '' , from which we discuss the physical meaning of superposition and entanglement , and to address the foundation of qm . in sec . [ sec : entanglement ] , we study several kinds of quantum states , and we analyze the degree of entanglement and information . several topics are discussed in the appendix . one is the differences between scope and other existed methods , where we state that the concept of scope has never been proposed before . another one is the model for the reduced entanglement , by comparison with the two - body problem in cm . last , we study the physical meaning of entanglement measures at present , like negativity , relative entropy of entanglement . in sec . [ sec : conclusion ] , we conclude and discuss briefly the physical roles of scope in the foundation of qm . in this section , before the study on the concept of scope and entanglement , we show that the concept of openness is fundamental in qm . openness means that the quantum object can not be separated from the outside world , and the basic subject in qm is the open system , just the opposite of cm @xcite . the physical reason for openness is the existence of quantum coherence . we show that all the basic equations in qm demonstrate the openness and coherence . the quantum coherence leads to many crucial facts , such as the double - slit interference , coherent and squeezed state of light , also the heisenberg s uncertainty principle , etc . relating to measurement , the uncertainty principle states that any measurement disturbs the state of the quantum system , since the coherence is disturbed . on the contrary , the nature light from sun is not coherent as it is a kind of mixture . in cm , there is no coherence , which is the main distinction between quantum and classical dynamics @xcite . usually , in qm the method of density matrix @xcite is employed to capture coherence , which is represented by the non - diagonal elements . a diagonal density matrix is said to be classical as the coherence vanishes . in qft , there exists coherence since the quantum field itself is the coherent entity , such as vacuum , electromagnetical field etc , although the density matrix is not often used . `` coherent '' means that the field as a whole has fixed amplitude and phase . the micro - particles , as the excited state of field , have coherence since interactions between them are due to the field . the facts of particle creation , classicality , and decoherence lead to the degeneracy of coherence , yet , particle can go back to its ground state via the annihilation operator , thus , re - excite the coherence @xcite . in addition , we note that the standard qm does not focus on the properties of field , e.g. , the creation and vanish of particles , also the origin of ensemble , which we will discuss below . in qm , there was the argument that whether quantum theory describes the dynamics of the single system or the ensemble @xcite . according to the standard qm , the existence of ensemble is _ a priori _ fact . for instance , in the double - slit interference experiment , the ensemble of electrons is used , the electrons are viewed as identical , and the state of electrons are the superposition of two modes corresponding to the two slits . here , qm can not explain the origin of the ensemble ; in contrast , qft can give the creation - annihilation picture of the ensemble of electrons . the quantum states of each electron before entering the slit are not necessarily orthogonal , and there exists field among the electrons , that is , the existence of ensemble does not mean there is no coherence . yet , the methods of qm are believed as universal @xcite , thus , it should provide the physical picture for ensemble . recently , there are efforts to indicate the quantum origin of ensemble via entanglement @xcite . it is shown that the system within the coherent universe behaves as the canonical ensemble , as if the universe were in the mixed state , in which each pure state has the equal probability . physically , there can be kinds of coherence and decoherence processes in qm , which relates to the distinction between the fine - grained and coarse - grained description of states of the system @xcite . we will further analyze this in the study of density matrix below . in addition , we note that the concept of ensemble is similar to `` mixture '' , which is also widely employed in qm . however , the `` mixed state '' is not an exact expression , e.g. , it does not indicate the state is of one single object or many objects . we view mixture as the classical concept . the coherence indicates the openness of quantum dynamics . here we show that the basic equations of qm all demonstrate the openness . the schrdinger equation @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is viewed as the pure state vector of the system , from which the eigenstate and the eigen - energy can be deduced . the single quantum system can be , e.g. , one electron , field , or ensemble of electrons , as long as there exists coherence . here , `` single '' is different with that in cm , where the system is labeled by mass . the wave function has the property of holistic , and we can say that the system is `` open inside '' . now , for schrdinger equation , it is easy to get the following equations @xmath4 . let the density matrix ( or statistical matrix ) @xmath5 , and @xmath6,\ ] ] which is the liouville equation . in reality , it is often impossible to get the wave function , i.e. , to collect all the information of the system this can be described by the well - known @xmath7 model , where the universe @xmath8 contains one system @xmath9 embodied by one environment @xmath10 . the wave function distributes across @xmath9 and @xmath10 . according to the method of entanglement and schmidt decomposition @xcite : @xmath11 then the density matrix @xmath12 where coherence is the non - diagonal elements . the state of the system is deduced by tracing out the environment @xmath13 with @xmath14 , which is often viewed as the origin of the classical measurement results . further , interestingly , the wave function can also be written as @xmath15 where the set @xmath16 is also wave function , thus , not necessarily orthogonal , and the parameters @xmath17 are complex , with @xmath18 . the state in eq . ( [ eq : wfes ] ) is the `` wave function of ensemble state '' ( wfes ) , the detailed properties are discussed in appendix [ sec : wfesd ] . this decomposition is coarse - grained , i.e. , each @xmath19 can further be decomposed as the superposition of orthogonal states . in the ensemble , each party has the property of openness that there can be ( but not necessarily ) coherence between any two of them . last , another well - known form is the wigner function @xcite in the quantum phase - space , which is often written as @xmath20 where the integral is across the whole space . there exists a whole class of distribution functional , with the wigner function as the simplest and straightforward one @xcite . here , in the phase - space , the system is represented by the coordinate and its movement is momentum @xmath21 . contrast with classical method , in wigner function , there exists another coordinate @xmath22 , which is integrated out . the physical meaning is that the effects of the outside world ( environment ) should be deleted ( tracing out ) , so that we can confirm the existence of the system . from this point , we can say that the phase - space approach in qm is also natural since it captures the essence of openness , the negative value of @xmath23 is one expression . to sum up , in this section we show that the existence of coherence is central for quantum behaviour , which results in the openness demonstrated by all the basic equations of qm . we note that here we do not study the detailed properties and classifications of quantum coherence . in the next section , we will further show that quantum coherence and the property of openness can be based on the new concept of `` scope '' , and from which , we will analyze the direct physical meaning of the wave function and also entanglement . in this section , we study the foundation of qm from the concept of `` scope '' . briefly , scope , or quantum scope , describes the `` structure of motion '' , which means the action region of the motion , and the correlations among states and observable , rather than the casual dynamics , neither the structure of matter , nor matter . by comparison , according to cm , the object , labeled by mass @xmath24 , associates with a certain force , satisfying @xmath25 . here , in qm every motion has a certain scope . the wave function is indeed the scope of the quantum dynamics . further , the concept of scope is not restricted within qm , it is the universal method , and it has the connections with other methods , such as relativity . below , we present the theorems and properties of scope . before that , we first note two points . firstly , the concept of scope is in consistent with qm , since it is directly based on qm . secondly , scope can give physical meaning to wave function and also superposition , then complete the basic principle of qm . firstly , we present the theorems relating to scope itself , we state that the principles of superposition and entanglement are universal . every motion has one scope @xmath26 . here `` motion '' includes the condition when the observed velocity of one object is zero . strictly , there is no object at rest . scope @xmath26 belongs to the motion of a certain object , not the object itself . the concept of scope describes the ability of motion in a systematical way . scope @xmath26 is composed with state @xmath27 and its weight @xmath28 , where @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 decides the space of @xmath32 , labeled as @xmath33 . the concept of `` state '' originates from qm and statistical physics . @xmath27 can be a vector in the hilbert space , or the point in the tangnet space @xcite . within one scope @xmath26 , there can be many physical states @xmath27 . one motion can only be in state within its own scope . the principle of superposition has two parts : * _ the principle of superposition of scope @xmath26 _ : + the scope of motion can be expressed as the superposition of all the states within as @xmath34 there is a set of povm `` active operator '' @xmath35 which associates with @xmath26 and satisfies + @xmath36 + which means @xmath37 can act state @xmath38 out from scope @xmath26 . here , we employ dirac s `` bra - ket '' symbol @xcite . @xmath37 satisfies @xmath39 which means @xmath40 is the eigenvalue of the `` activer '' @xmath37 . this is the alternative of the `` probabilistic interpretation '' of the coefficients @xmath40 in qm . also @xmath41 which means all the states are acted out , that is , the whole scope @xmath26 is realized @xmath42 , thus @xmath43 . this is the origin of the `` normalization regulation '' . from the probabilistic view , it means the sum of all the probabilities equals to 1 . and , @xmath44 also , there exists the `` anti - active operator '' 1-@xmath45 . we do not study the active operator in detail here . * _ the principle of superposition of state @xmath1 _ : + the state of motion can be the coherent superposition state as @xmath46 where normalization means the norm of a state vector is @xmath47 , which is the result , yet not the same with the property of scope . note that the superposition for mixed , pure , also classical states are all included . there exists entanglement between two or multi- scopes . the entangle process @xmath48 for two systems @xmath49 and @xmath50 can be written as @xmath51 we note that the analysis can be generalized to multi - systems directly , here we focus on bi - party system for clarity . @xmath52 represents the entangle process . there are two parts of the principle of entanglement : * _ the principle of entanglement of scope @xmath26 _ : + the entangled scope of motion can be @xmath53 where the sets of relative states @xcite @xmath54 and @xmath55 correlate with each other one - to - one , which can be labeled as the `` 1 - 1 branch '' rule . the details which @xmath38 is the relative state to @xmath56 is determined by nature , e.g. , the interaction . + there also exist the set of active operator @xmath57 , which satisfies @xmath58 where the branch latexmath:[$|\psi_i\rangle \otimes |\phi_i\rangle \equiv * _ the principle of entanglement of state @xmath1 _ : + the entangled state can be a part of the entangled scope @xmath60 three kinds of states have to be classified : ( 1 ) if @xmath61 , the state is truly entangled ; if @xmath62 , the state is separable , the same as the usual form in eq . ( [ eq : separable ] ) ; this means the separable state is also the result of the entangle process of scope thus containing quantum information as we will show below ; ( 3 ) if @xmath63 , the state reduces to a simple product state . in reality , the branches within the entangled scope are not all necessarily realized , thus , the entangled state is the fragment of the scope as long as satisfying the normalization rule . in addition , there may be interactions during the entangle process , however , entanglement describes the information transition or coherent correlations between different systems , instead of the energy transition . we will define the degree of entanglement @xmath64 in sec . [ sec : degree ] . next , relating to qm , particularly the dynamics of the scope and state , there are two theorems . there exist representations , corresponding to different complete sets formed by the commutative observable , labeled as `` the scope under representation '' . in qm , the physical reason for representation is that there exist different complete sets , which is demonstrated by bohr s complementarity principle @xcite . we note that , according to the consistent history approach @xcite , there exist several frameworks , which also satisfy the complementarity principle . this theorem indicates again that the concept of scope is the systematical , instead of casual , description of the potentiality and structure of the motion . there exist pictures , corresponding to different frames and time choice . there are three basic kinds of pictures as follows : * _ the frame is set on the motion itself _ : schrdinger picture . + the scope @xmath65 ( can also be labeled as @xmath9 ) satisfies the schrdinger equation @xmath66 where @xmath67 is the hamiltonian . the solution of this equation is the `` structure of the motion '' . here , `` @xmath68 '' means the change of space rather than the evolution of time @xcite . in fact , `` @xmath68 '' means the `` gradually evolving of the scope '' . the dynamical variables do not change with time . we mention that in quantum cosmology , eq . ( [ eq : sch ] ) becomes @xmath69 , where the hamiltonian includes the gravitational field plus all matter sources in the universe , the external timing parameter @xmath68 vanishes naturally @xcite . * _ the frame is set external _ : heisenberg picture . + the dynamical variable @xmath70 satisfies @xmath71,\ ] ] which means the change of dynamical variable in different states within the fixed scope . * _ the frame is set in - between _ : dirac ( interaction ) picture @xcite . + @xmath72 , @xmath73 , satisfying @xmath74,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath75 . the existence of pictures and the problem of the external parameter @xmath68 reveal that scope mostly describes the logic structure of the states , from which the commutation relations of observable do not change with time . last , we show another kind of property of scope . there exist relations between the concept of scope and relativity , which describes the coherent properties of the space - time metric of the object . here , we only present the mostly crucial conjecture as below . the scope @xmath26 can be influenced by mass @xmath76 . this theorem sets the connection between the motion of a certain object and the object itself . it means that objects with different masses can not have the same scope . every scope is unique . also , the shape of scope is not regularly euclidian . in general , it is topologically non - euclidian . please see the geometrical properties @xmath77 of scope below . in this subsection , we study some properties and consequences deduced from the theorems above of scope . scope @xmath26 has a certain geometrical shape . the number of state @xmath31 can not be zero . the states within the scope can form certain shape . for instance , if there is one single state , @xmath31=1 , the corresponding shape of scope is just a point ( in geometry ) . if @xmath31=2 , the shape is one segment line , straight or carved , with a certain length . if @xmath31=3 , the shape is one triangle face , with a certain area . if @xmath31=4 , the shape is one tetrahedron . if @xmath78 , the shape is one ball . we should state that the shape is in the three - dimensional space , euclidian or non - euclidian , different from the shape in the high - dimensional space , such as the hilbert space . the shape not only has the `` shell '' with boundary and face , also it has inner structure . particularly , when @xmath78 , if we neglect its structure , the ball can be viewed as one point . this is the alternative of the `` classical limit '' of the orthodox qm by taking @xmath79 . we note that the geometric properties of quantum states are under research , see ref . @xcite for instance . scope @xmath26 has a certain magnitude . the magnitude is defined as the length ( or the area , the volume ) of its shape . to calculate , we have to specialize the `` distance '' between different states . for instance , we can use the energy @xmath10 to define the distance @xmath80 , such as @xmath81 the magnitudes of @xmath26 of different movements should be different , since they have physical meanings . the bigger the magnitude , the better the ability of the motion , thus , the more `` freedom '' in the scope @xmath26 . the magnitude is not necessarily equal to one , which is different with the normalization condition . one particular scope @xmath26 has its own space - time matric . this is the direct result of theorem @xmath82 . when the effect of mass is not obvious , we can set the space - time matric of different scopes the same with each other , which is another kind of classical limit , or the low - energy limit . the scope @xmath26 has the properties of `` reality '' ( actuality ) and `` propensity '' . when @xmath37 acts , the certain state @xmath38 is realized , from potential to real , and the scope @xmath26 `` gradually evolves to its whole form '' . there is the transition between reality and propensity . actually , the two aspects of scope were studied a long time ago by aristotle in the ancient greece @xcite . the method was mostly ignored and was claimed as `` metaphysical '' useless for physics . yet , the idea of propensity has gained quite a lot of attentions in recent years @xcite . the concept of @xmath26 manifests that qm is the systematical description of the structure of movement , which is totally new compared with the classical dynamical method , from which the `` local realism '' @xcite originates . thus , we view the critics based on local realism as the misunderstanding of the essence of qm . here , we do not discuss the problems of local realism and nonlocality in detail . also , there is no `` collapse '' @xcite . collapse means that when there is measurement , the state collapses from superposed state to the eigenstate . or , some others view the collapse happens in our knowledge @xcite . in fact , with the process of decoherence @xcite , when the initial state is superposed , it decoheres instead of collapse when there is measurement or environment . measurement is a process of entanglement . this is a simple result of the fact that the apparatus also has one scope with the states relative to the observed system . the measurement process is the disturbance of system to apparatus ( or environment ) @xcite . the measurement problem in qm @xcite , as well as the observe effect in relativity , can be well explained with the method of entanglement , and the change of our knowledge is another story @xcite . there are mainly two kinds of states : time - quasistatic ( tq ) state and ensemble - isotactic ( ei ) state . at present , there is no unified classification of quantum states . briefly , there are many kinds due to different criterions , such as separable / entangled , pure / mixed , local / non - local states , etc . the non - unification just indicates that the underlying physical reason for the classification is not clear . we give a new classification as follows : * onefold state * * eigenstate * * superposed state * * * time - quasistatic ( tq ) superposed state * * * ensemble - isotactic ( ei ) superposed state * multifold state * * factorizable state : product , separable , etc * * entangled state * * * time - quasistatic ( tq ) entangled state * * * ensemble - isotactic ( ei ) entangled state firstly , state is differentiated according to whether it is a multifold ( many - body ) state . for a single object , its state is onefold state . there can be superposed state according to the principle of superposition . for multifold system which contains several inner parts , the state is multifold state , and there can be entangled state . the separable state can be viewed as a kind of factorizable state , which we will study in the next section . the distinction of time - quasistatic ( tq ) state and ensemble - isotactic ( ei ) state bases on the theorem of ergodicity of statistical physics and the principle of identity in qm @xcite . for example , the double - slit state of the electron ( or other particles ) is the ei superposed state , which characterizes the electron ensemble . in this state , for one particular electron , it can only pass through one slit at one time , thus , the state of a single electron is not superposed . another example , as we know , we can use laser to control a certain two - level atom , and drive it to the so - called rabi oscillation @xcite . this is the tq state , the population transfers from one state to another periodically . the famous bell basis are the ei entangled state , such as the light source from type - ii spdc @xcite in the teleportation experiment , describing the ensemble of photons , the state of one photon is not entangled or superposed . an excellent example of tq entangled state is the electrons forming the chemical bonding in the molecules . the difference between ( ei ) state and ( tq ) state is the `` inner '' dynamics of the state itself , thus , this kind of definition is obviously not mathematical . however , in our study below , we do not care about this difference without loss of generality . , thus , qu@xmath83it ) . the correlation between scopes or states is depicted as straight line ( string ) . ] qm often deals with the properties of many - body ( instead of single or infinite ) system . to characterize the quantum features , at present , there exist three widely studied methods : nonlocality @xcite , nonclassicality @xcite , and entanglement @xcite . traditionally , nonclassicality was introduced in the quantum phase - space in the context of quantum optics . the state of light , e.g. , squeezed light , contains nonclassicality compared with the coherent light , which sets the boarder between quantum and classical states . we note that the continuous variable ( cv ) system in phase - space can be translated into the fock space , from which the entanglement can be defined . interestingly , after the seminal work of epr @xcite and bell @xcite , the nonlocality of entangled state was demonstrated with nonclassical light @xcite , where the three methods are all involved . in this work , we do not intend to analyze the relations of them ; instead , we focus on entanglement relating to superposition and the concept of scope . part of our study on entanglement has been presented in ref . we will study the physical role of entanglement in various quantum states , and the degree of entanglement , also we compare with different entanglement measure in appendix [ sec : measure ] . entanglement is widely studied in qiqc , and it is believed to be the key for information processing and computing . however , entanglement is not indispensable . in quantum cryptography , the bb@xmath84 does not rely on entanglement @xcite ; instead , particularly the b@xmath85 protocol shows that it is the nonorthogonality ( also no - cloning ) that ensures the security of the key @xcite . the recently studied continuous variable ( cv)-quantum key distribution ( qkd ) @xcite and decoy - state qkd @xcite , also do not rely on entanglement , which indeed are the improvement of the bb@xmath84 protocol . this indicates that the quantum nature of information acts even when there is no entanglement , i.e. , the quantum information does not necessarily depends on entanglement . in quantum computing , the well - known qdc@xmath47 model is shown not directly rely on entanglement @xcite ; instead , the quantum discord plays the central role @xcite . in another line of research , there are attempts to build qkd on the foundation of nonlocality and nonlocal box , where entanglement does not play the central role @xcite . the examples above indicate that entanglement is not such quantity viewed from the information - theoretic framework ( itf ) , which is the theoretic paradigm or the world view correlating with the research of qiqc to re - consider quantum theory and its foundation from the information point , where information is believed as physical and fundamental @xcite . on the contrary , especially from the concept of scope , entanglement is the direct generalization of superposition , not necessarily related to information ( entropy ) , physically . the original cv - entangled state of epr @xcite and ( discrete variable ) dv - entangled state of spin of bohm @xcite do not relate to information . the analysis of schrdinger just reveals that information can be effected by entanglement @xcite . also , entanglement does not only play roles in qiqc . for instance , in quantum chemistry , entanglement plays roles in the formation of molecules and chemical reactions . further , the so - called `` quantum information '' is quite misleading , as the zeilinger s principle @xcite states that there is no quantum information , there is only information processing with quantum sources . that is to say , information can be effected by the quantum features , including nonorthogonality ( superposition ) , entanglement , also nonlocality and nonclassicality . in this section , we will systematically study the quantum correlations of the bi - party system , the results for the multi - party system will be presented in other places . also , without loss of generality , we assume here that the branches within the entangled scope are all realized , i.e. mathematically , the entangled state is the same with the entangled scope . relating to the analysis in sec . [ sec : ensemble ] , the entangled state can be realized both for single quantum system and the ensemble of quantum system . the quantum states we analyze include : * product state ; entangled qudit ; decohered qudit ; * ensemble - product state ; separable state ; ensemble - entangled qudit ; ensemble - decohered qudit . for clarity of the physical picture , we develop a kind of diagram to represent the scope . as shown in fig . [ fig.product](a ) , the circle stands for the scope , and the points within stand for the orthogonal eigenstates ( with number @xmath83 ) . the correlation between scopes or states is depicted as straight line ( string ) , the dashed line stands for decohered string . the states we consider are shown in fig . [ [ fig.product]-[fig.ensemble ] ] . _ product state . _ as well - known , product state contains no correlation . here , we can describe three kinds of product states . suppose the two sub - systems are @xmath86 and @xmath87 , with orthogonal eigenstate @xmath88 and @xmath89 , respectively . the state @xmath90 is product state . the more complex product form is @xmath91 where @xmath92 , @xmath93 . we note that the states for @xmath86 and @xmath87 are not ensemble . this product state is shown in fig . [ fig.product](b ) . the third kind is the ensemble - product state , shown in fig . [ fig.product](c ) . the wave functions of the systems @xmath86 and @xmath87 can be written as @xmath94 which is the coarse - grained decomposition , since there exist the sub- wave functions @xmath95 , @xmath96 , and generally @xmath97 . with @xmath98 , the density matrix can be easily written as @xmath99 the ensemble - product state is @xmath100 the state @xmath101 contains quantum information , although there is no entanglement . there is coherence for the @xmath102 and @xmath103 , that is , there can be decoherence process . the result of the decoherence is that the local state of @xmath86 and @xmath87 become @xmath104 , and @xmath105 . yet , the global state @xmath106 remains as product . _ entangled qudit . _ the general form of the entangled qudit is written as @xmath107 and the density matrix is expressed as @xmath108 with @xmath109 . the state @xmath110 , shown in fig . [ fig.entangled](a ) , can be viewed as a part of the product state @xmath111 in case ( b ) above , by selecting out the branches according to the permutation symmetry . the coherence of the state @xmath110 is represented by the non - diagonal elements . when decoherence occurs by some disturbance , the state @xmath110 becomes diagonal , which is said to be classical . the decohered ( classical ) qudit is @xmath112 let @xmath113 , @xmath114 , and introduce the parameter @xmath115 , then @xmath116 which is separable . that is , for the single decohered qudit , it is classical as well as separable . this state is shown in fig . [ fig.entangled](b ) . _ separable state . _ the well - known separable state @xcite in fig . [ fig.ensemble](a ) is defined as @xmath117 with the normalization relation @xmath118 . we show that the separable state @xmath119 is the analogy of entangled state @xmath110 , except that the former one employs the coarse - grained decomposition , while the latter one employs the fine - grained decomposition , i.e. , the eigenstates are orthogonal . the decomposition is the same with those in equations ( [ eq : cg1 ] ) and ( [ eq : cg2 ] ) . then equation ( [ eq : separable ] ) can be written as @xmath120 ) . the ensemble ( sets ) @xmath121 and @xmath122 are not classical , while the ensemble @xmath123 and @xmath124 are classical . this reveals that there exists quantum information in the separable state . then , when the separable state goes to the classical state ? consider the case when only one eigenstate each is acted out , that is @xmath125 , and also let latexmath:[$\langle \psi_{\xi}^{a(b ) } @xmath119 in equation ( [ eq : separable2 ] ) becomes the same with the classical state @xmath127 in equation ( [ eq : decoher ] ) . we can label this as the `` classical reduction procedure '' . let us give a simple example of the @xmath128 system . it is reasonable to set @xmath129 , and @xmath130 , then the separable state is @xmath131 which is also classical . generally , when @xmath132 , the separable form of the density matrix does not rely on the local coherence within @xmath102 and @xmath103 , which just indicates that there can be quantum information in the separable state . _ ensemble - entangled qudit . _ the ensemble of entangled state is often studied in qiqc , such as the ensemble of bell s state . for single entangled qudit , it can be written in the schmidt basis as @xmath133 with @xmath134 . the density matrix of this ensemble can be expressed as @xmath135(b ) . it is easy to see that when applies the classical reduction procedure , @xmath125 , and @xmath136 , the state @xmath137 reduces to classical and also separable . when decoherence occurs , each entangled qudit becomes classically correlated , and the ensemble - decohered qudit is @xmath138 which is classical but not separable , shown in fig . [ fig.ensemble](c ) . further , to make the distinctions of the quantum states clear , we can classify four kinds of correlations : entanglement , decohered classicality , nonorthogonality , and coarse - grained classicality . the quantum characters in the states we studied are different . in the single entangled qudit , the entanglement is the global shared coherence , there is also the classical correlation . for the decohered qudit , the shared coherence disappears , thus there is only classicality . the ensemble - entangled qudit , which relies on the coarse - grained decomposition , contains another kind of shared coherence due to nonorthogonal local states , namely , @xmath139 , we name it as nonorthogonality . correspondingly , there exists another kind of classicality , via the parameter @xmath140 , instead of the correlations of the eigenstates between @xmath86 and @xmath87 . we name this kind of correlation as coarse - grained classicality , and the former one as decohered classicality . from this analysis , we can briefly present the main characters of quantum state in table i. [ tab:1 ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in this section , we study superposition and entanglement quantitatively . before our analysis , we note that the superposition and entanglement are both due to the existence of coherence , local and global ( shared ) , respectively . entanglement is not the quantum information ; instead , the classical information ( correlation ) can be effected by the entanglement ( shared coherence ) , thus , the so - called `` quantum information '' . we can say that entanglement and quantum information ( entropy ) are the two related kinds of characters of the entangled state . below , we present the definitions of the degree of superposition , entanglement , and nonorthogonality , which all relate to the quantum coherence . + degree of superposition @xmath141 . + for a superposed state vector @xmath142 , where @xmath143 [ def:1 ] notice that , by introducing the @xmath144-norm as @xmath145@xmath146 , then the @xmath147-norm is @xmath148@xmath149 , thus , @xmath150 . this indicates that the @xmath147-norm has physical meaning , i.e. , describing the degree of superposition . let us show some examples . when @xmath151 , @xmath152 . @xmath153 , @xmath154 , @xmath155 , and max(@xmath141)@xmath156 when @xmath157 . @xmath158 , @xmath159 , @xmath160 , and max(@xmath141)@xmath161 when @xmath162 . then generally , for @xmath163 , max(@xmath141)@xmath164 etc . that is , for @xmath31 , the maximal degree of superposition @xmath141 is @xmath165 , and the minimum approaches to _ zero_. if there are more eigenstates in a superposed state , then the degree of superposition it can get is bigger . it means , physically , that although a state vector in the hilbert space has to be normalized , the degree of superposition is not a relative quantity , it characterizes the amount of coherence . degree of entanglement @xmath166 . + for a general entangled state with @xmath24 subsystems @xmath167 with each @xmath31-dimensional : @xmath168 , the degree of entanglement @xmath169 [ def:2 ] the same with the degree of superposition , we can get @xmath170 . our definition @xmath171 is similar with negativity ( see appendix [ sec : measure ] ) , thus , we do not present the proof of the entanglement monotone @xcite , which states that the entanglement can not increase under the local quantum operation and classical communication ( locc ) . according to our understanding based on scope and coherence , the locc constraint is the property of quantum information ( entropy ) instead of entanglement ( globally shared coherence ) . yet , it is easy to check that entanglement obviously satisfies the locc constraint since the quantum coherence can not be created via classical way . the definition @xmath171 defines entanglement in a positive way . as a result , the locc constraint is not sufficient to define entanglement , and not all non - separable states are entangled ( sec . [ sec : states ] ) . next we study some basic applications . we assume the coefficients are all positive , without loss of generality . for @xmath128 system , if @xmath172 label @xmath173 , @xmath174 . there are two kinds of entangled state according to the nature of the branches ( strings ) . if @xmath175 of @xmath86 correlates with @xmath175 of @xmath87 , it is named as `` direct '' ( @xmath176 ) ; if @xmath175 correlates with @xmath177 , it is named as `` cross '' ( @xmath178 ) : @xmath179 and the degree of entanglement @xmath180 generally , @xmath181 . after some algebra , we can get @xmath182 introduce the reduced degree of entanglement @xmath183 then we can get the fundamental relation @xmath184 when @xmath185 , @xmath186 , @xmath187 , @xmath188 , @xmath189 , and @xmath190 . this is the maximal condition for the qubit . in addition , for the reduced degree of entanglement of the qubit system , we will further study the physical properties by comparing to the classical two - body problem in appendix [ sec : reduced ] . for @xmath191 system , if @xmath192 there are four kinds of entangled state , which belongs to the greenberger - horne - zeilinger ( ghz ) state @xcite : @xmath193 and it is easy to write the four degree of entanglement ( we do not present here ) , after some algebra , we get @xmath194 also , introduce the reduced degree of entanglement @xmath195 then @xmath196 for the maximal condition , when all the coefficients equal to @xmath197 , @xmath198 , @xmath199 , and @xmath200 . generally , for @xmath201 system , the maximal reduced entanglement is @xmath202 . this means when we add the numbers of systems to be entangled , the reduced entanglement becomes smaller and smaller , that is , the entanglement of the whole system becomes more fragile , when one subsystem is disturbed , the total entanglement vanishes . for @xmath203 system , if @xmath204 and the degree of superposition @xmath205 there are six kinds of entangled state according to the symmetry between the branches within the entangled state . here we only give two examples , the other four are easy to be drawn : @xmath206 the entanglements of these six states have the form @xmath207 . after some algebra , we can get @xmath208 for the maximal condition , when @xmath209 , @xmath210 , @xmath211 , @xmath212 . for this bi - qutrit entangled state , there is no definite form of reduced entanglement . for @xmath213 system , there exist totally twenty - four different states , each has four branches . the entanglement also can be written as @xmath214 . we get the following equations @xmath215 for the maximal condition , when @xmath216 , @xmath217 , @xmath218 , @xmath219 . generally , for @xmath220 system , there are @xmath221 different entangled states , set @xmath207 , we can get the general equations as @xmath222 for the maximal condition , when @xmath223 , @xmath224 , @xmath225 , @xmath226 . that is , for the two - party systems , when the number of states entangled together increases , the max(@xmath166 ) also increases , like the superposition @xmath141 . this is reasonable since when more states are entangled together , the amount of entanglement should increase , and the state becomes more robust . for the higher dimensional systems , the math is a little complex , and the physical picture is not so clear . we do not analyze them here . next , we turn to the quantization of the four kinds of correlations we defined in the last subsection . for the entangled qudit , the entanglement is the shared coherence , so the degree of entanglement @xmath166 can be easily calculated , according to the definition [ def:2 ] above . also , as we have discussed , we can employ different forms of entropy to characterize the quantum information . at present , the well - known quantities include von neumann entropy , relative entropy , quantum discord , squashed entanglement , entanglement of formation , cost , and distillation , etc @xcite . we will study some of them in appendix [ sec : measure ] . for the decohered qudit , there is pure classical correlation without shared quantum coherence . also , there exist the complete projective measurements , under which the classical density matrix remains @xcite . the information is characterized by the von neumann entropy . for the four kinds of ensemble state , see table i , there exists nonorthogonality . this kind of coherence is not globally shared by the two parties @xmath86 and @xmath87 , yet , it is shared by the local states @xmath227 of @xmath86 , and the local states @xmath228 of @xmath87 . the degree of nonorthogonality can be defined as @xmath229 in the sum , each element is smaller than one , yet , the sum can be arbitrarily big even infinity . this is reasonable since the quantity of coherence increases with the amount of the ensemble . particularly , we note that the separable state contains the quantum nonorthogonality thus quantum information , although there is no entanglement . the coarse - grained classicality results from the classical parameter @xmath140 , so the classical information can be easily calculated via the von neumann entropy @xmath230 . last , we make some comments on the mixed state , which , in deed , is a rather broad and rough method . the mixed state with purity smaller than unity is a `` fragment '' of a global pure state with an unknown part lost , thus , it is not easy to decide the exact structure of the mixed state . at present , there exist lots of ways to detect the entanglement , and different methods can be unified with the method of entanglement witness in a way @xcite . yet , even we can find the entanglement , we can not decide the structure of the mixed state . that is to say , to find how the mixed state is formed is more valuable and practical . the six kinds of states studied above can serve as some standard or assistant to detect the quantum correlations . when a mixed state @xmath231 can be written as similar to any standard state , labeled as @xmath232 , that is , if @xmath233 , then the quantum correlation ( entanglement , nonorthogonality , etc ) of @xmath231 can be defined as that of @xmath232 times @xmath234 . @xmath235 can be viewed as the disturbance or perturbation to @xmath232 . this method is similar with the relative entropy method @xcite and the lewenstein - sanpera ( ls ) decomposition @xcite . to sum up , in this section , we quantify the degree of superposition and entanglement , and also nonorthogonality . physically , entanglement is directly based on superposition , and nonorthogonality is also the result of superposition . the four kinds of correlations can be easily calculated . the weirdness of qm is a result of the nature of quantum coherence , the abstractness of quantum description , and the confusions on quantum logic and philosophy . the concept of scope , which is exotic for cm , relativity , statistical mechanics , also classical wave mechanics , just represents the quantum origin . it describes the possible ( potential ) action region and the systematic and coherent structure of movement of a certain object . superposition and entanglement are the natural results of scope with definite physical meaning . also , we discussed the properties of four kinds of quantum correlations and the six kinds of quantum states , and we show that entanglement is related yet different with entropy . further , the concept of scope brings new methods to the standard qm . one is that the scope itself has certain geometric features , just similar to the matter itself . this may indicate that the structure of the motion of the matter is more crucial than the structure of the matter itself . the other is that , rather than the information - theoretic framework , there exists a new kind of space , i.e. , tangnet , on which the quantum structure with entanglement exists @xcite . as a result , the concept of scope lays the new starting point to the foundation of qm . in the future , further efforts on , e.g. , the geometrical properties of tangnet , the comparison of scope with other interpretations , also the relation between nonlocality and entanglement , are needed . in addition , the physical roles of entanglement in qiqc are also widely concerned , we hope our approach can bring new ideas on some tough problems , such as the bound entanglement @xcite , the analogy of entanglement to energy or entropy , etc . in hilbert space , one state vector can be decomposed via orthogonal basis also non - orthogonal basis . physically , the two decompositions can be endowed with different physical contents : for single system , there only exists orthogonal physical basis ; while for ensemble , there can be non - orthogonal basis . for example , the spin state in one quantum dot can be up or down , or to the left or right in the diagonal basis ; for a collection of spins in quantum dots , the superposed states of spins form the non - orthogonal basis . mathematically , based on the measurement theory , especially the positive operator - valued measure ( povm ) @xcite , we can see the wfes has the corresponding properties as the wave function of pure state . for the pure state @xmath236 , it satisfies : ( 1 ) normalization : @xmath237 ; ( 2 ) completeness relation : @xmath238 ; ( 3 ) projective measurement : there exist a set of projective operators @xmath239 satisfying @xmath240 , the expectation value @xmath241 ; note that when the non - projective povm operator acts on the pure state , it can not distinguish its basis ; ( 4 ) probabilistic interpretation : @xmath242 means the probability to find state @xmath243 with projector @xmath244 ; ( 5 ) observable : the expectation value of observable @xmath245 is @xmath246 , with @xmath247 ; ( 6 ) evolution : @xmath248 also the basis @xmath243 satisfy schrdinger equation ; ( 7 ) decoherence : the non - diagonal elements in @xmath249 disappear , leading to state @xmath250 , each part @xmath251 forms the classical trajectory ; ( 8) quantum reference frame @xcite : to determine the preferred basis @xmath252 , the reference frame and certain interaction are needed to form the entangled state , i.e. , the coherence within @xmath248 delocalizes to form entanglement ; thus , by ignoring the reference frame , the state @xmath248 decohered . for the wfes , the state in eq . ( [ eq : wfes ] ) , the properties are similar while more complicated . we firstly note that if @xmath253 , it reduces to the pure state case ; if the states @xmath16 are orthogonal with each other , it goes to the totally classical ( decohered ) state . instinctively , there exists one pure density matrix , labeled as @xmath254 , which is @xmath255 to form the density matrix @xmath231 , the non - diagonal elements disappear , with coefficients @xmath256 , which is actually a kind of decoherence . the state @xmath257 indicates that before the formation of the ensemble , there exists one decoherence process . physically , the state @xmath3 stands for the `` field '' of the ensemble , and the ensemble emerges from the field after the decoherence process , i.e. , the creation of particles @xcite . note that here we do not study this issue with quantum field theory . we name this kind of coherence as _ sub - coherence _ , or coarse - grained coherence , and the decoherence as _ sub - decoherence_. to arrive at the classical state , the standard decoherence is then needed . if we only account coherence by ignoring sub - coherence , we can view @xmath3 as the wfes , from which , the density matrix @xmath231 for the ensemble emerges . further , the sub - decoherence can be introduced by one quantum reference frame @xmath258 , which with @xmath257 forms @xmath259 which is exactly the separable state @xcite . note that for pure state , the system and its reference frame form the entangled state . correspondingly , the basic properties of wfes are : ( 1 ) normalization : @xmath260 ; ( 2 ) completeness relation : @xmath261 ; ( 3 ) measurement : there exist a set of povm operators @xmath262 satisfying @xmath263 , the expectation value @xmath264 ; note that the measurement does not act on the fine - grained orthogonal basis directly ; ( 4 ) probabilistic interpretation : @xmath265 means the probability to find state @xmath266 with operator @xmath267 ; ( 5 ) observable : the expectation value of observable @xmath245 is @xmath268 , with @xmath269 ; ( 6 ) evolution : states @xmath3 and @xmath266 both satisfy schrdinger equation , with which the liouville equation for @xmath231 is equivalent ; ( 7 ) sub - decoherence : the non - diagonal elements in @xmath270 disappear , leading to quantum ensemble @xmath231 ; decoherence : the party @xmath266 each can further decohere , leading to classical state and classical trajectory , respectively ; ( 8) quantum reference frame : to determine the preferred basis @xmath271 , the reference frame @xmath232 and certain interaction are needed to form the separable state , i.e. , the sub - coherence within @xmath3 delocalizes to form separability ; thus , by ignoring the reference frame , the state sub - decoheres ; further , if there exists the entanglement - type reference frame , the state eventually decoheres to classical trajectory . last , to illustrate the difference between coherence and sub - coherence , we give one simple example : suppose there are only two parties , @xmath272 and @xmath273 , in the ensemble , and each party with only two orthogonal basis @xmath274 and @xmath275 , and @xmath276 , @xmath277 . note that even if party @xmath273 is not in the basis @xmath278 , there can be rotation which can rotate it to this basis , with effects absorbed in the coefficients . thus , the density matrix of wfes is written as @xmath279 and its conjugate , when they disappear , the state @xmath257 sub - decoheres to the quantum ensemble @xmath231 . the coherence is represented as the coefficients @xmath280 , @xmath280 and their conjugate , when they disappear , the state decoheres to the classical state , labeled as @xmath281 , with diagonal elements @xmath282 , @xmath283 , and @xmath284 . _ scope and qft . _ in qft , the wave function is further viewed as the operator , which is the well - known `` second quantization '' . the total number of particles is not conserved as there always exist the fluctuations of field and creation / annihilatin of particles . particle itself is viewed as the excited state of field , and field is viewed as a kind of matter , whose motion exists within itself . thus , the second quantization of wave function , i.e. , scope , means to view the structure of the motion as the equivalence of the structure of matter , also to view the motion of the matter as the same with the matter itself , which is reasonable for field . this is also consistent with the mass - energy relation @xmath285 from relativity . however , for particles , atoms etc in qm , the object itself is different with its motion , thus , it is not proper to view scope as a kind of matter ; instead , scope should be viewed as a kind of description of the logical structure of the motion of the object . in history , another physical picture similar with qft is mainly developed by de broglie , namely , the `` pilot wave '' approach @xcite , in which the particle with definite local form sits at a certain place in the real pilot wave , and the particle can be viewed as the high - energy concentrate singularity of the wave . the pilot - wave describes the collective motion of two objects : particle and wave , which indeed goes to the method of qft . this relates to the `` wave - particle duality '' that the particle can perform both classical particle property and wave property , but not both of them at the same time @xcite . also , the concept of `` matter wave '' was developed . however , according to the concept of scope , the relation @xmath286 should be explained as that the object has the particle property ( @xmath24 ) and wave property ( @xmath234 ) within its own scope , consistent with the wave - particle duality . as a result , the matter wave can not be viewed as a kind of matter , and indeed , the so - called matter wave does not exist . we note that the other theory , bohmian mechanics @xcite , in which the particle has the trajectory restrained by the wave function , is consistent with the methods of qtf and scope . _ consistent history ( ch ) _ this is a widely studied form of qm , yet , there exist different approaches . this theory has the similar character with our methods based on scope , particularly the active operator . however , in ch , there is no reason for the physical meaning of the decomposition of the identity . next , we present our understanding for the ch . generally , ch takes the evolution of state in time into account . the main quantity , the decoherence functional @xcite is defined as @xmath287 where @xmath231 is the density matrix . the class operator is @xmath288 , with @xmath289 , @xmath290 means that @xmath291 acts on the scope instead of state . @xmath291 is the projective decomposition of the identity , @xmath292 when @xmath293 , @xmath294 , which is the probability of the history , and the normalization @xmath295 . when @xmath296 , if @xmath297 , then we say the history is decohered . in figure [ fig.ch ] , we show one consistent history . we put state and operator on the equal footing , then form the state - operator space . @xmath298 is the eigenstate set as the ordinate , the abscissa is the @xmath291 , where @xmath299 associates with time @xmath300 . for simplicity , we set @xmath301 , i.e. , there are six states within the scope . from the figure , we can easily get the activers of the history : @xmath302 . in addition , there can be other kinds of history , e.g. , several activers can act together as @xmath303 causing the superposed state . eigenstates within the scope , and the number of the projection ( activer ) @xmath299 represents the evolve of time . when the states become continuum , the lattice space becomes continuous space . the black polylines stands for the consistent history.,scaledwidth=33.0%,scaledwidth=25.0% ] _ kraus operator for open system _ @xcite . we study via the widely concerned model of the pure universe @xcite . let universe @xmath8 be composed with system @xmath9 and environment @xmath10 , labeled as @xmath7 . the initial state is @xmath304 and @xmath305 , correspondingly , the initial state for the universe is thus @xmath306 . the evolution of the wave function is @xmath307 , with the evolution operator @xmath308 . the reduced density matrix for the system is @xmath309 where @xmath310 , @xmath311 , and we let @xmath312 . the normalization rule is @xmath313 the kraus operator representation demonstrates the openness and the evolution in time of quantum system . however , although there is evolution in time , the logical relations between operators remains . for instance , the relation @xmath314 does not depends on time . below , we show that this method is consistent with the ch method . the physical role of the evolution operator @xmath308 can be substituted by the class operator @xmath315 , the state of the system at time @xmath316 is @xmath317 , where @xmath304 is the initial state . we know @xmath318 and @xmath319 thus @xmath320 , which is the same as the normalization of the kraus operator , physically . _ interacting faculties_. the concept of `` potentiality '' , originated from aristotle @xcite , is quite widely studied in qm . the actuality ( reality ) and potentiality were systematically studied recently , where the authors stated that potentiality could be a mode of existence , and the concept of `` faculty '' was introduced to replace `` entity '' @xcite . the faculty describes a level which does not pertain to things but rather to potential actions . possessing a faculty offers the ability to do something . according to our understanding , yet , the concept of faculty is the analogy of potentiality . this approach relates to the property @xmath321 in section [ sec : properties ] , yet it does not aim to provide the direct physical meaning of wave function and the superposition principle . consider the mixtures of bell states latexmath:[$|\psi\rangle=(|01\rangle \pm @xmath3 is the `` cross '' state , and @xmath323 is the `` direct '' state . so the mixture ( ensemble ) can be viewed as the mixture of two kinds of systems . the classical analogy is , e.g. , the mixture of two kinds of gases . there exists the center of mass for each of the gases , so the problem can be simplified as the two - body problem in classical mechanics , as shown in fig . [ fig.red](a ) . the two objects @xmath324 and @xmath325 exist in the configuration space , the coordinates are @xmath326 and @xmath327 , respectively . the kinetic energy is @xmath328 where @xmath329 is the total mass , @xmath330 is the reduced mass , @xmath331 is the coordinate of the mass center of the system , and @xmath332 is the relative displacement between the two objects . now , consider velocity @xmath333 . as we know , there exists the maximum speed as the light speed @xmath334 . let @xmath335 , thus , the set of speed @xmath336 forms the probability space with @xmath337 . the kinetic energy is written as @xmath338 consider the mixtures of bell states . the density matrix can be written as @xmath339 the entanglement of the mixture is @xmath340 where by introducing the probability amplitude @xmath341 , @xmath342 , @xmath343 , and @xmath344 is the reduced entanglement . the situation is depicted in fig . [ fig.red](b ) . by comparison , the entanglement is the analogy of mass , the probability is the analogy of @xmath345 . for high - dimensional and many - body problems , there is no obvious form of reduced mass , also the reduced entanglement . yet , we can apply the rough bi - party partition to deduce the apparent reduced mass or entanglement . however , we have to say , there are significant differences . for instance , the quantum probabilities @xmath346 and @xmath347 each exist in the probability space , and also they together exist in another probability space . but , the classical speed ( square ) @xmath348 and @xmath349 do not exist in the probability space with each other . this relates to the problem of special relativity , this simple mode may have implication for the relation between qm and relativity . according to our study , entanglement and quantum information ( entropy ) are different . entanglement is the shared coherence by the parties of the entangled state . also , we find nonorthogonality is the shared coherence within the local states of each party of the whole state . quantum information ( @xmath350 ) is the improved form of classical information ( correlation ) ( @xmath351 ) due to nonorthogonality ( @xmath352 ) or entanglement ( @xmath166 ) . thus , @xmath350 can be the function of @xmath352 or entanglement @xmath166 . here , we compare our definition with the usual entanglement measure . _ entanglement of formation . _ in qiqc , the mixtures of bell states , i.e. , ensemble of qubits , are often prepared , the entanglement of formation , also cost and distillation are studied @xcite . the entanglement of formation , which measures quantum information instead of entanglement , is defined as @xmath353 and the density matrix is written as @xmath354 as follows . ( b ) . `` computation basis '' @xmath361 , @xmath362 , @xmath363 , @xmath364 . the qubit is written as @xmath365 , and concurrence is @xmath366 it is easy to see that the basis in case ( a ) can be viewed as the special case of ( b ) . schmidt basis @xmath367 . the qubit is written as @xmath368 , with @xmath369 , the density matrix is @xmath370 and concurrence is @xmath371 the schmidt basis can be rotated to the `` computation basis '' in case ( b ) by the local unitary transformation @xmath372 @xcite . the above three kinds of basis give the same results of concurrence . the entanglement of formation is defined as @xmath373 , where the binary entropy function @xmath374 . we can form the entropy - concurrence matrix ( @xmath375 ) as follows @xmath376 then , it is obvious that the entropy @xmath377 describes the property of the diagonal elements ( population ) , and the concurrence @xmath378 describes the non - diagonal elements ( coherence ) . _ negativity and robustness . _ for pure state , the definition of negativity @xcite is the same with our definition of the degree of entanglement . negativity is usually viewed as the absolute value of the sum of the negative eigenvalues of @xmath379 @xmath380 where @xmath381 is the negative eigenvalues . in deed , the negative eigenvalues are the results of the shared coherence of the entangled state . for pure qubit , the negativity is the same with concurrence , that is to say , the definition of negativity is more general than concurrence for bi - party pure state . the robustness @xcite is the twice of the negativity for pure state . physically , it describes the robustness of the entanglement to the minimal amount of external classical noise . the role of noise is to disturb and destroy the coherence . physically , the robustness can describe the shared coherence , thus give the right quantity of entanglement . however , it is not easy to calculate since it is the indirect way to measure entanglement . in addition , we discuss a little of the physical meaning of concurrence and negativity for the mixed state condition . it is well - known that the two are often different for mixed state , though the same for the pure state case . the physical reason is quite clear : they are the results of two different entanglement witness ( operator ) @xcite . physically , in the mixed state there can be nonorthogonality , which can influence concurrence and negativity without being detected . that is to say , it is not proper to generalize concurrence and negativity to the mixed state , since the result is not necessarily entanglement . where the set @xmath383 can be taken as the set of separable states , states with positive partial transpose , nondistillable states , etc . the quantum discord @xcite and squashed entanglement @xcite , which we have studied in ref . @xcite , can be viewed as the relative entropy . physically , @xmath384 does not quantify entanglement directly , yet it relates to entanglement . the relation between @xmath384 and entanglement also nonorthogonality can not be deduced easily especially for mixed state , since the detailed structure of the mixed state and the distribution of coherence are not clear . as a result , the relative entropy is only an effective way to measure quantum information instead of entanglement . 99 d. bohm , _ quantum theory _ ( prentice - hall , inc . , englewood cliffs , new jersey , 1951 ) . m. jammer , _ the philosophy of quantum mechanics _ ( wiley , new york , 1974 ) . j. s. bell , _ speakable and unspeakable in quantum mechanics _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , england , 1987 ) . m. a. nielsen and i. l. chuang , _ quantum computation and quantum information _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , england , 2000 ) . w. h. zurek , rev . * 75 * , 715 ( 2003 ) . m. schlosshauer , rev . * 76 * , 1267 ( 2004 ) . c. g. timpson , arxiv : quant - ph/0611187 . a. einstein , b. podolsky , and n. rosen , phys . rev . * 47 * , 777 ( 1935 ) . e. schrdinger , phys . rev . * 28 * , 1049 ( 1926 ) . d. bohm , phys . rev . * 85 * , 166 ( 1952 ) . j. von neumann , _ mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics _ ( princeton university press , 1955 ) . h. everett , rev . * 29 * , 454 ( 1957 ) ; b. s. dewitt and n. graham , _ the many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics _ ( princeton university press , princeton nj , 1973 ) ; d. deutsch , int * 24 * , 1 ( 1985 ) . m. gell - mann and j. b. hartle , in _ complexity , entropy and the physics of information _ , santa fe institute studies in the science of complexity vol . viii edited by w. zurek ( addison - wesley , redwood city , ca , 1990 ) ; phys d * 47 * , 3345 ( 1993 ) ; r. b. griffiths , j. stat . phys . * 36 * , 219 ( 1984 ) ; r. omns , rev . 64 * , 339 ( 1992 ) ; h. f. dowker and j. j. halliwell , phys . d * 46 * , 1580 ( 1992 ) ; j. j. halliwell , phys . rev . d * 58 * , 105015 ( 1998 ) ; phys . * 83 * , 2481 ( 1999 ) . r. clifton , j. bub , and h. halvorson , found . phys . * 33 * , 1561 ( 2003 ) ; g. brassard , nature phys . * 1 * , 2 ( 2005 ) ; j. oppenheim and b. reznik , arxiv : quant - ph/0312149 ; g. m. dariano , arxiv : quant - ph/1012.0535 ; jae - weon lee , arxiv : hep - th/1011.1657 ; p. goyal , arxiv : quant - ph/0702124 ; arxiv : quant - ph/0702149 . as bohr said : `` there is no quantum world . there is only an abstract quantum physical description . it is wrong to think that the task of physics is to find out how nature is . physics concerns what we can say about nature . '' from n. bohr , _ atomic theory and the description of nature _ ( cambridge univ . press , new york , 1934 ) . e. calzetta and f. d. mazzitelli , phys . d * 42 * , 4066 ( 1990 ) ; f. lombardo and f. d. mazzitelli , phys . d * 53 * , 2001 ( 1996 ) . s. habib , y. kluger , e. mottola , and j. p. paz , phys . rev . lett . * 76 * , 4660 ( 1996 ) ; g. mahajan and t. padmanabhan , gen . rel . grav . * 40 * , 661 ( 2008 ) ; a. giraud and j. serreau , phys . lett . * 104 * , 230405 ( 2010 ) . r. j. glauber , phys . rev . * 131 * , 2766 ( 1963 ) ; a. miranowicz _ et al . _ , a * 82 * , 013824 ( 2010 ) , and references therein . g. vidal , j. mod . opt . * 47 * , 355 ( 2000 ) ; m. b. plenio and s. virmani , quantum inf . comput . * 7 * , 1 ( 2007 ) ; r. horodecki , p. horodecki , m. horodecki , and k. horodecki , rev . * 81 * , 865 ( 2009 ) . a. aspect , j. dalibard , and g. roger , phys . lett . * 49 * , 1804 ( 1982 ) . c. h. bennett and g. brassard , _ proceedings of the ieee international conference on computers , systems and signal processing _ ( ieee computer society , new york , 1984 ) , pp . 175 - 179 . c. h. bennett , phys . 68 * , 3121 ( 1992 ) . f. grosshans _ et al . _ , nature * 421 * , 238 ( 2003 ) . lo , x. ma , k. chen , phys . lett . * 94 * , 230504 ( 2005 ) . j. a. wheeler and k. ford , _ geons , black holes @xmath385 quantum foam : a life in physics _ ( new york : w.w . norton @xmath385 co , 1998 ) . j. a. wheeler , in w. zurek , editor , _ complexity , entropy and the physics of information _ , pages 3 - 28 . ( addison - wesley , redwood city , ca 1990 ) . r. landauer , proc . workshop on physics and computation physcomp 92 ( ieee comp . press , los alamitos , 1993 ) pp . 1 - 4 . d. m. greenberger , m. a. horne , and a. zeilinger , _ going beyond bell s theorem in bell s theorem , and conceptions of the universe _ ( kluwer academic , dordrecht , 1989 ) ; phys . today * 8 * , 22 ( 1993 ) ; d. m. greenberger , m. a. horne , a. shimony , and a. zeilinger , am . j. phys . * 58 * , 1131 ( 1990 ) . a. peres , phys . lett . * 77 * , 1413 ( 1996 ) . g. vidal and r. f. werner , phys . a * 65 * , 032314 ( 2002 ) . c. h. bennett , h. j. bernstein , s. popescu , b. schumacher , phys . a * 53 * , 2046 ( 1996 ) . s. hill and w. k. wootters , phys . lett . * 78 * , 5022 ( 1997 ) ; w. k. wootters , phys . rev . * 80 * , 2245 ( 1998 ) . c. h. bennett , d. p. divincenzo , j. a. smolin , and w. k. wootters , phys . a * 54 * , 3824 ( 1996 ) . v. vedral and m. b. plenio , phys . rev . a * 57 * , 1619 ( 1998 ) g. vidal and r. tarrach , phys . a * 59 * , 141 ( 1999 ) . m. steiner , phys . a * 67 * , 054305 ( 2003 ) . h. ollivier and w. h. zurek , phys . lett . * 88 * , 017901 ( 2001 ) ; w. h. zurek , phys . a * 67 * , 012320 ( 2003 ) ; l. henderson and v. vedral , j. phys . a * 34 * , 6899 ( 2001 ) . s. luo , phys . a * 77 * , 022301 ( 2008 ) . m. christandl and a. winter , j. math . phys.(n.y . ) * 45 * , 829 ( 2004 ) . f. g. s. l. brando , phys . a * 72 * , 022310 ( 2005 ) . o. gittsovich , o. ghne , p. hyllus , and j. eisert , phys . a * 78 * , 052319 ( 2008 ) . m. lewenstein and a. sanpera , phys . lett . * 80 * , 2261 ( 1998 ) .

the abstract framework of quantum mechanics ( qm ) causes the well - known weirdness , which leads to the field of foundation of qm . we constructed the new concept , i.e. , _ scope _ , to lay the foundation of quantum coherence and openness , also the principles of superposition and entanglement . we studied analytically and quantitatively the quantum correlations and information , also we discussed the physical essence of the existed entanglement measures . we compared with several other approaches to the foundation of qm , and we stated that the concept of scope is unique and has not been demonstrated before .

0810.4989

modified gravity ( for a review , see e.g. @xcite ) constitutes an interesting dynamical alternative to @xmath0cdm cosmology in that it is also able to describe with success the current acceleration in the expansion of our universe , the present dark energy epoch . the specific class of modified @xmath1 gravities ( for a review , see e.g. @xcite ) has undergone many studies which suggest that this family of gravitational alternatives for dark energy is able to pass the constringent solar system tests . the investigation of cosmic acceleration as well as the study of the cosmological properties of @xmath1 models has been done in refs . the possibility of a natural unification of early - time inflation with late - time acceleration becomes a realistic and quite natural possibility in such models , as is demonstrated e.g. in ref . @xcite . recently , the importance of modified gravity models of this kind has been reassessed with the appearance of the so - called ` viable ' @xmath1 models @xcite . those are theories which satisfy both the cosmological as well as the local gravity constraints , which had caused in the past a number of serious problems to some of the first - generation theories , that had to be considered now as only approximate descriptions from more realistic theories . the final aim of all those phenomenological models is to describe a segment as large as possible of the entire history of our universe , as well as to recover all local predictions of einstein s gravity that have been already verified experimentally , with very good accuracy , at the solar system scale . it is remarkable that , as was demonstrated in refs . @xcite , some of these realistic models lead to a natural unification of the early - time inflation epoch with the late - time acceleration stage . let us recall that , in general ( see e.g. @xcite , for a review ) , the total action for the modified @xmath1 gravitational models can be written as [ xxx7 ] s = d^4 x + s_(m ) . here @xmath2 is a suitable function of the scalar curvature @xmath3 , which defines the modified gravitational part of the model . the general equation of motion in @xmath4 gravity with matter is given by [ xxx22 ] g _ f(r ) - r _ f(r ) - g _ f(r ) + _ _ f(r ) = - t_(m ) , where @xmath5 is the matter energy - momentum tensor and @xmath6 is the derivative of @xmath1 with respect to its argument @xmath3 . for a generic @xmath1 model is not easy to find exact static solutions . however , if one impose some restrictions , one can proceed along the following lines . first , we may require the existence of solutions with _ constant _ scalar curvature @xmath7 , and we arrive at f(r_0)r_=g_. [ geneqrc ] taking the trace , we have the condition 2f(r_0)=r_0f(r_0 ) [ b ] and this means that the solutions are einstein s spaces , namely they have to satisfy the equation r_=g_= g _ , [ e ] @xmath8 being a solution of eq . ( [ b ] ) . this gives rise to an effective cosmological constant , namely _ eff==. [ l ] the purpose of our work will be to study the appearance of multiply de sitter space solutions in several realistic models of modified gravity . the occurrence of multiply de sitter solutions plays a fundamental role in modified gravity because it permits to describe the inflation stage as well as current @xmath0cdm cosmology in terms of this theory alone without any need for either fine - tuning of a cosmological constant nor of introducing extra scalar fields . in summary , this is a minimal and at the same time very powerful approach which circumvents some of the hardest problems of present day physics . one may argue that these theories are equivalent to introducing extra scalar fields , but this equivalence has been proven to hold at the classical level only , not at the quantum one . in addition , the cosmological interpretation of modified gravity solutions is different from that of scalar field cosmology . the paper is organized as follows . in the next section we discuss a viable modified gravity model @xcite in an attempt to study de sitter solutions there . it is shown that , for some values of the parameters , it is possible to find several de sitter spaces ( as a rule , numerically , for small values of the curvature exponent ) ; one of them may serve for the inflationary stage , while the other one can be used for the description of the dark energy stage . the evolution of the effective equation of state parameter is investigated numerically . 3 is devoted to the analysis of the same question in a slightly generalized model which is known to describe the unification of the early - time inflation with the late - time acceleration epochs @xcite . the same numerical investigation is carried out , and a multiply de sitter universe solution is constructed . in section 4 , the corresponding problem is investigated for a viable model of tangential modified gravity , proposed in ref . @xcite . having in mind the possibility to use a sds universe for the description of cosmic acceleration , those solutions for modified gravity are investigated in sect . comparison of the free energies of the de sitter and the sds solutions , for the viable model of the second section , is then made . finally , some outlook is given , together with the conclusions , at the end of the paper . in this section we will study de sitter solutions in realistic modified gravity models using a dynamical system approach . we shall start from the following form for the initial action @xmath9 , \label{1.1}\ ] ] where @xmath10 is some function of the geometrical invariants . in order to make use of the method of dynamical systems , we work in the metric corresponding to a spatially - flat frw universe , namely @xmath11 from here , the frw equation can be written in the following way ( for more details see ref . @xcite ) @xmath12 where @xmath13 the `` dot '' over the symbol means derivative with respect to time @xmath14 , while @xmath15 and @xmath16 represent the derivative of @xmath10 with respect to @xmath17 and @xmath18 respectively . in what follows we will mainly concentrate on the simplest case @xmath19 . let us consider the following choice for the function @xmath20 @xcite , which represents a very interesting subclass of viable modified gravitational models @xmath21 where the constant @xmath22 has dimension of mass , while @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 are some positive dimensionless constants . note that here @xmath26 $ ] , @xmath27 , @xmath28 . after making variation , it is chosen @xmath29 . introducing a nonzero constant @xmath25 is here equivalent to introducing a shift in the effective cosmological constant , and for this reason we will assume @xmath30 in our further computations . finally , we can write eq . ( [ 1.3 ] ) for the function in ( [ 1.5 ] ) as @xmath31 , \end{array } \label{1.6}\ ] ] where @xmath32 . this equation can be rewritten as a dynamical system , namely @xmath33 it is easy to see that the critical points of this system are the de sitter points ( @xmath34 ) . to investigate the nature of these points we need to determine them explicitly , a non - trivial problem in the general case . it is however easy to obtain from ( [ 1.6 ] ) the equation satisfied by the critical points @xmath35 : @xmath36 the same result can be obtained directly starting from equation ( [ b ] ) of the previous section . it is convenient to introduce the notation @xmath37 , for further investigation of this equation . so , finally , we have @xmath38 first of all we find one ( trivial ) root of this equation @xmath39 ( it corresponds to @xmath40 ) , what allows us to reduce the order of the equation . ( note also that , if @xmath41 , eq . ( [ 1.9 ] ) takes a more complicate form and then it does not have the trivial root @xmath39 . ) but nevertheless the equation still is of @xmath42-order and in the interesting case ( @xmath43 ) ; this is too high and the roots can not be found algebraically . we need a specific discussion of this problem . it is clear that if there are too many ( say 10 or 20 ) de sitter points in the theory , it looks like a classical analogue ( at a reduced scale , of course ) @xcite of the string landscape vacuum structure in which case it will be far from trivial to obtain the standard cosmology . nevertheless , something can be done even in this case , by comparing the energies of the corresponding de sitter solutions , which should in fact differ , as is discussed in sect . v. using descartes rule of signs , we find that eq . ( [ 1.9 ] ) can have 2 or 0 positive roots . more detailed information can be obtained by using sturm s theorem . unfortunately it is not possible to apply it in the general case ( for arbitrary @xmath44 ) , so we need to investigate separately each of the different cases , @xmath45 , and see which one is more interesting from a cosmological viewpoint . we have therefore undertaken here a systematic analysis of all possible cases in this region of values of @xmath44 . computations are rather involved ( specially for larger @xmath44 ) , but the final results are not so difficult to describe analytically . we have found , for any of the values of @xmath44 considered , in the range above , that the number of roots depends on the parameter @xmath46 only , and that there is an @xmath47 such that , for @xmath48 , eq . ( [ 1.9 ] ) has no positive roots , while for @xmath49 , eq . ( [ 1.9 ] ) has two positive roots . we here now enumerate our results systematically : @xmath50 ; @xmath51 ; @xmath52 ; @xmath53 ; @xmath54 ; @xmath55 ; @xmath56 ; @xmath57 . note also that , near the critical point @xmath47 , both solution are very close to each other when they exist ( a real value of @xmath49 ) , and they are complex conjugate to each other for @xmath48 . this means that , in a situation where these two roots differ substantially , it must necessarily be @xmath58 . the ds - points described above can be used for the construction of inflationary or late - time acceleration behavior ( depending on the value of the scale factor @xmath59 ) . to this aim , the corresponding ds point must be unstable in the inflationary stage but can be either unstable or stable for the late - time acceleration one . however , this is in fact not a strictly necessary condition , since even for stable ds inflation , the exit from it can be achieved by a coupling with matter , through the effect of small non - local term or by some other mechanism . unfortunately , an all - round investigation of stability of the ds point turns out to be very difficult in the general case . for the recent analysis of critical points in more general modified gravity theories depending on all geometrical invariant see ref . @xcite . here we can carry out the analysis on the stability of de sitter points for the model we are dealing with in this section , only for some chosen numerical set of parameters . such computations show that one of the ds points is very likely to be always unstable ( with a smaller value of @xmath60 ) and that another one is very likely to be always stable ( with larger value of @xmath60 ) . this means that there is actually an easy way for the inflationary stage construction ( if the initial conditions lie sufficiently close to the unstable ds point , see fig . [ fig.1 ] ) . however , only within the model under consideration it might be a problem with late - time acceleration , originated from the stable point . the only possibility for late time acceleration is to choose very special parameters , in which the stable point is situated very far away from the unstable one . of course , the problem disappears when one describes only late - time acceleration within such a model , or when one takes into account other terms like the local ones . note however that specific values of the parameters in which both points are unstable can be chosen too , which give rise to a sound theory which provides a unified description of the inflationary and late - time acceleration epochs . ) near the equilibrium points . stars denote the beginning of the trajectories . dashed and dot dashed lines lead to bottom.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] near an unstable point for the dashed and dot - dashed lines of fig . [ fig.1 ] . the time origin corresponds to the stars from the previous graph.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] let us now consider specific numerical results . first , note that a full numerical investigation starting from the inflation ( or from our ds point ) and extending to the late - time acceleration epoch and going through a frw - like stage is not feasible because of the presence of numerical instabilities that prevent such possibility . for this reason , we will investigate the regions near the equilibrium points only , and especially near the unstable one . in fig . [ fig.1 ] the trajectories in the phase plane ( @xmath61 ) are presented for the set of parameters : @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 . such small values of @xmath23 and @xmath24 are motivated in @xcite , but the picture is typical in any case . the position of the ds point is specified . we may see one stable point ( with bigger value of @xmath60 ) and another , unstable one . the stars in the graph correspond to the beginning of the trajectories . we see clearly that trajectories can pass sufficiently close to the ds point , and that they escape from it , lead by the two attractors . one of them ( the upper one ) leads to a singularity , while another one ( heading towards the bottom ) , leads to a solution going somewhere in the frw - like region ( this is difficult to analyze exactly , due to numerical instabilities ) . in fig . [ fig.2 ] the evolution of @xmath66 is depicted for two trajectories : the upper one corresponds to the dashed line of fig . [ fig.1 ] , the bottom one to the dot - dashed line of fig . [ fig.1 ] ( both of them lead to the bottom in fig . [ fig.1 ] ) . we see that there actually are trajectories which start from phantom - like solutions and tend to a normal evolution ( when this is possible in the model ) . of course , these are qualitative considerations only , owing to the fact that no matter is taken into account . most probably , inclusion of matter will change the situation . however , it is just remarkable that both the early - time inflation epoch as well as the late - time accelerating one could be obtained in a unified and natural way in such a model , owing to the presence of several ds points . a slightly different choice for the function @xmath2 is motivated by the realistic and viable model which was proposed for the unification of early - time inflation and late - time acceleration in ref . @xcite , namely @xmath67}. \label{2.1}\ ] ] here we imply that @xmath68 , @xmath69 and @xmath8 is positive , what seems reasonable . now , our frw - like equation ( [ 1.3 ] ) reads @xmath70 , \end{array } \label{2.2}\ ] ] where @xmath32 . rewriting this equation under the form of a dynamical system ( [ 1.7 ] ) we find , by introducing the new variable @xmath71 , that the equilibrium points of this system ( which are ds points indeed ) are obtained from the following equation @xmath72x^m+2\kappa^2r_0f_0mx^{m-1}+\\ \\ ( f_0+f_1r_0^m)^2x+r_0(f_0+f_1r_0^m ) ( f_0+f_1r_0^m-4\kappa^2r_0^{m-1})=0 . \end{array } \label{2.3}\ ] ] it is clear that , in the general case ( even for fixed @xmath73 ) , solving this equation will not be an easy thing . we can make use of the following hint . let us require that @xmath74 be a solution of eq . ( [ 2.3 ] ) . this is possible only if there is some relation among the constants of our theory . as we can easily see from ( [ 2.3 ] ) , it must be that @xmath75 . moreover , since @xmath76 , we need that @xmath77 . substituting this condition into ( [ 2.3 ] ) we find an essential simplification of the former equation , namely @xmath78 where the root @xmath74 is already excluded . we now discuss the physical meaning of finding a solution @xmath74 . as a rule this will imply that @xmath8 is the value of the scalar curvature at present time , but in principle @xmath8 is just a parameter of the theory , which could be given any likely value . we can , for instance , fix @xmath8 to have the ds point value which is situated exactly at present time , @xmath79 , or at @xmath80 years . and there is also the possibility to explain late time acceleration if this point is stable . now let us consider other possible roots of eq . ( [ 2.4 ] ) . using sturm s theorem as in the previous section , we find several positive roots ( which correspond to ds points in the past ) and a number of negative roots ( needless to say , only values which are @xmath81 have a physical meaning ) , corresponding to ds points in the future . unfortunately , computations are harder than in the previous case and our calculations have been performed for three specific values of the parameter @xmath82 : 3 , 5 and 7 , only . in any case , the results are very similar for the three situations , what gives us hope that for larger values of @xmath82 result will be also similar . we may predict the upper limit of the ds points in the future only , which is 2 , but in any case this point is not much interesting . concerning the ds points in the past , the picture turns out to be much like the one in the previous case : the number of ds points depends only on a dimensionless parameter for all investigated values of @xmath82 . that is , @xmath83 . and there are two values , @xmath84 and @xmath85 , which are different for each @xmath82 , so for @xmath86 and @xmath87 there are two ds points and for @xmath88 there is no ds point . we have not been able to obtain exact analytical expressions for @xmath84 and @xmath85 and thus give here numerical results only . for @xmath89 @xmath90 , @xmath91 ( as positive roots of @xmath92 ) . for @xmath93 @xmath94 , @xmath95 ( as positive roots of @xmath96 ) . for @xmath97 @xmath98 , @xmath99 ( as positive roots of @xmath100 ) . as we can see , the interval where there are no ds points shrinks when the value of the parameter @xmath82 is increased . if we assume that for larger @xmath82 the number of ds points depends on the parameter @xmath101 only as clearly happens in the investigated cases we do find @xmath84 and @xmath85 for any value of @xmath82 . such investigations show that @xmath84 and @xmath85 slowly change when @xmath82 increases and that the interval without ds points is present even for very big value of the parameter @xmath82 . for example , for @xmath102 we have @xmath103 and @xmath104 . a simple numerical investigation of stability for the existing ds points shows that one of them ( the one with the smaller value of @xmath60 ) is always unstable , but the other one ( with the larger value of @xmath60 ) can either be stable or unstable . from our numerical results , the appearance of unstable ds points pairs relative to the interval @xmath86 seems most probable . note also that the condition @xmath76 means that it actually must be @xmath105 and that in this case it is most likely the one stable and one unstable point show up . now let us consider the evolution equation ( [ 2.2 ] ) from a different point of view . as we already noted , @xmath8 is a parameter of the theory which corresponds to the value of the scalar curvature at some epoch . this means that during the normal evolution of our universe , from large to little ( or zero ) curvature , it becomes @xmath7 at some moment . but , as we can see from eq . ( [ 2.2 ] ) , this means that that at this point the coefficient of the higher derivative term ( @xmath106 ) is equal to zero . this is a well - known mathematical problem , which needs special investigation . as we know from mathematics there are two possibilities : the solution of the perturbed equation ( with a higher derivative term ) may tend to the solution of the degenerate equation ( without higher derivatives ) , and then the coefficient of the higher derivative term may tend to zero or not tend to the solution of the degenerate equation . a special investigation of this problem shows that solutions of eq . ( [ 2.2 ] ) tend to solutions of the degenerate equation , which is @xmath107 when @xmath108 but not so when @xmath109 . this means that the point @xmath8 is reachable during the evolution from large @xmath3 to zero , but it is not the final point of the evolution , because there is an instability in the future . on the other hand , we have @xmath7 at this point , and therefore @xmath110 . substituting this into ( [ 2.5 ] ) we find a relation among the parameters of the theory which were introduced before , @xmath75 . this means that , generically , if one wants the point @xmath8 to be reachable during evolution , a relation of this sort among the parameters of the theory must be fulfilled . that is , we have two independent parameters only ( or even just one if we consider that @xmath8 is strictly related to our epoch ) . note also that it is impossible to use standard numerical methods near this point for solving eq . ( [ 2.2 ] ) because all available methods need solving the equation with respect to the highest derivative , and it turns out that , near this point , the numerical solution is unstable . ) near equilibrium points . stars denote beginning of trajectories . dashed and dot dashed lines lead to bottom.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] near unstable point for dashed and dot - dashed lines of fig.[fig.1 ] . zero in time corresponds to the stars from the previous graph.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] now let us consider numerical results near the stable points . since the value of @xmath8 is very small in our epoch ( @xmath111 @xmath112 ) , it is impossible to use real values in computations . thus , we have produced a qualitative analysis using the following set of parameters : @xmath113 , @xmath114 , @xmath115 , @xmath97 . as we can see , @xmath116 , and there must be two ds points corresponding to positive @xmath117 . the evolution lines near these points are represented in fig . [ fig.3 ] , where we can trace one stable and one unstable point , stars denoting the beginning of trajectories , as in the previous case . actually , there are three ds points for these chosen parameters . one of them , @xmath118 , which corresponds to @xmath74 , is degenerate and situated out of the graph . the time evolution of @xmath119 is represented in fig . [ fig.4 ] by the dashed and dot - dashed lines . the picture is very similar to the one in the previous section , and the same comments also apply here . thus , we have here shown that the unification of early - time inflation with late - time acceleration is in principle possible , and even very likely , due to the appearance of several ds points in the evolution of the universe . for a more realistic study , the presence of ( minimally and non - minimally coupled ) matter should be taken into account with care . as a third example , now we discuss a model proposed in @xcite . such model is defined by means of the function [ tan1 ] f(r)=r - f(r)=r - a , where @xmath120 , @xmath121 and @xmath8 are arbitrary parameters . one immediately sees that @xmath122 , as required and , moreover , that [ tan3 ] _ rf(r)=2_eff a. if @xmath123 in the present universe then @xmath124 plays the role of the effective cosmological constant . we also observe that the derivative [ tan4 ] f(r)=1- has a minimum when @xmath7 , which reads [ tan5 ] f(r_0)=1- . in order to avoid antigravity one needs to require [ tan6 ] 0<f(r)<f(r_0)= 1- . the model given by eq . ( [ tan1 ] ) is able to describe late acceleration , since , in general , de sitter critical points exist . they are the solutions of ( [ b ] ) . then , we set k(r)=2f(r)-rf(r ) , [ rkr ] and study ( numerically ) the zeros of this transcendental function ( see fig . [ p : tanh1 ] ) . we see that for suitable choices of the parameters there are one or two de sitter critical points . for @xmath125 and different choices of the parameter @xmath121 : @xmath126 , @xmath127 ( picture on the left ) ; @xmath128 , @xmath129 ( picture on the right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] for @xmath125 and different choices of the parameter @xmath121 : @xmath126 , @xmath127 ( picture on the left ) ; @xmath128 , @xmath129 ( picture on the right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] now , we impose @xmath8 to be a de sitter critical point for the model in eq . ( [ tan1 ] ) . this means that ( [ rkr ] ) has to be satisfied for @xmath7 and such a condition fixes one parameter , say @xmath120 . then , we get a= , and introducing , for convenience , the dimensionless variables x=,b_0=r_0b , we obtain f(r_0)=1- . _ eff= , k(r)=- . in order to have @xmath130 and , at the same time , to avoid antigravity , the parameter @xmath131 has to be negative and in the range @xmath132 . by varying @xmath131 in that range , the value of @xmath124 can acquire any desired value . moreover the model has always two de sitter critical points with constant curvatures @xmath133 and @xmath134 . one can see that @xmath135 , while @xmath136 . in fig . ( [ p : tanh2 ] ) we have plotted @xmath137 for some values of @xmath131 . , with @xmath8 as a fixed de sitter solution , for different choices of the parameter @xmath131 : @xmath138 , @xmath139 ( picture on the left ) ; @xmath140 , @xmath141 ( picture on the right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] , with @xmath8 as a fixed de sitter solution , for different choices of the parameter @xmath131 : @xmath138 , @xmath139 ( picture on the left ) ; @xmath140 , @xmath141 ( picture on the right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] thus , our study shows the existence of multiply - de sitter universes in more complicated , tangential models . one can prove that other viable @xmath2 gravities introduced in ref . @xcite naturally lead to de sitter solutions too , as demonstrated in ref . in this section we will discuss spherically symmetric exact solutions for the modified gravities above . we mainly concentrate on multiply black hole solutions and on their related entropies and free energies . we have seen in the introduction that , requiring constant curvature solutions , one may consider the simplified form of the equations of motion given in ( [ e ] ) . as a result , @xmath1 modified gravity models admit the following class of general static neutral black hole solutions in four dimensions and with a non vanishing cosmological constant . in order to describe them , recall the metric ds^2=-v(r)dt^2++r^2d_k^2,v(r)>0 , [ ds ] where @xmath142 and the possible horizon manifolds are @xmath143 , the two dimensional sphere , @xmath144 , the two dimensional torus , and @xmath145 , the two dimensional compact riemann surface . the scalar curvature for the _ ansatz _ ( [ ds ] ) reads r=- [ r^2v+4rv+2v-2k ] and this means that every constant curvature solution with @xmath7 has to satisfy the equation r^2v+4rv+2v-2k =- r^2 r_0 . the general solution of this differential equation depends on two integration constants , @xmath121 and @xmath146 , and reads v(r)=+k -- r^2 . the ricci tensor and the scalar curvature have to satisfy the equations r_=g_,r = r_0 , [ e1 ] where @xmath8 is implicitly given by ( [ b ] ) , that is r_0= , now , it is easy to verify that eqs . ( [ e1 ] ) are satisfied only if @xmath147 , while @xmath146 is an arbitrary parameter , which is usually assumed to be non - negative and related to the mass @xmath148 of the black hole by @xmath149 . the special case @xmath150 is also admissible . then , we have v(r)=k -- r^2,c0,v(r)>0 . [ vr ] in principle there are physical solutions of the latter equation for @xmath151 and @xmath152 , which give rise , respectively , to a torus topology and a hyperbolic topology for the horizon manifold ( the so called topological black holes @xcite ) . here we are mainly interested in the usual spherical symmetric horizons and so we only consider in detail the case @xmath153 . as it is well known , in the special case @xmath154 , @xmath155 in ( [ vr ] ) is always positive when @xmath156 , and this corresponds to the anti de sitter ( ads ) solution . on the contrary , when @xmath157 , @xmath155 is positive , for @xmath158 , and this corresponds to the de sitter solution . if @xmath153 and @xmath159 , one has black hole solutions but only if c^2r_0 - 032mg1 . [ bkc ] we see that ( [ bkc ] ) is always satisfied if @xmath156 . this corresponds to the schwarzschild - anti - de sitter ( sads ) black hole . in this case @xmath160 , @xmath161 being the positive root of @xmath162 ( horizon radius ) . if @xmath157 , there are solutions only if @xmath163 . in this case @xmath164 , @xmath161 and @xmath165 being the positive roots of @xmath162 ( horizon and cosmological radius respectively ) . the extremal case @xmath166 is also admissible ( nariai solution ) , but the thermodynamics of such a black hole have to be discussed separately @xcite . at this point , we provide a brief discussion regarding the thermodynamical properties of the above black hole solutions . if one make use of the noether charge method for evaluating the entropy associated with the black hole solutions with constant curvature @xcite in modified @xmath1 gravity models , one has @xcite s= f(r_h ) . [ ve ] where the factor @xmath1 has to be evaluated on the horizon , with area @xmath167 . as a consequence , one obtains a modification of the `` area law '' . several examples have been discussed in @xcite . in the case of a constant curvature solution one has simply @xmath168 , @xmath8 being the solution of eq . ( [ b ] ) , which has been investigated in previous sections . with regard to this , we have found sufficient conditions to have two de sitter solutions . thus , we may investigate their thermodynamical behavior evaluating the associated free energy . the free energy @xmath169 is related to the canonical partition function @xmath170 by = - . on the other hand , a semiclassical approximation gives ze^-i_e , where @xmath171 is the euclidean classical action associated with the de sitter solution . a direct calculation leads to i_e=- and from ( [ b ] ) and ( [ ve ] ) it directly follows that i_e =- s_h=- , [ fe ] @xmath172 and @xmath173 being , respectively , the entropy and the inverse temperature of the black hole . for a generic schwarzschild - de sitter ( sds ) solution , eq . ( [ fe ] ) reads = - . [ fe1 ] the temperature @xmath174 is related to the horizon radius @xmath161 by t_h=== |-| @xmath161 being a positive solution of the algebraic equation r_h^3-r_h+=0 . [ ho ] as a result , we finally have = -|r_h-3mg| . [ fe2 ] in the pure de sitter case @xmath175 , @xmath176 , and so one has [ fds ] for sds one needs to consider separately the two admissible cases @xmath166 and @xmath163 . here we discuss the second one only , that is , the proper sds solution where @xmath177 . in this case , eq . ( [ ho ] ) has one negative root and two distinct positive roots , @xmath161 , the event horizon and @xmath165 , the cosmological horizon , with @xmath178 . the positive roots can be written in the form r_c=,12<_c<1 , r_h= , 0<_h<12 , where _ c=12and _ h=12(3-_c ) . in this way , we get _ c = f_ds , [ fc ] _ h = f_ds , [ fh ] @xmath179 being the expression ( [ fds ] ) . it has to be noted that , in the latter equations , the factors in front of @xmath179 are always smaller than 1 and thus the energies @xmath180 and @xmath181 are always smaller than @xmath179 , independently of the value of the mass . moreover , the factor @xmath182 is a monotone decreasing function of @xmath183 , which is equal to 1 for @xmath184 and to 0 for @xmath166 , while the factor @xmath185 is exactly equal to 0 for @xmath186 and quite small otherwise . its maximum value , a little bit more than @xmath187 , is reached for @xmath188 . this means that the minimum value for the free energy @xmath181 of a sds black hole is obtained for @xmath189 . now , we shall study some models and explicitly compute the corresponding free energy . first of all , as a trivial example , we consider the @xmath190 model described by @xmath191 . this has a stable de sitter solution , with @xmath192 . then , we immediately have _ ds=- . the corresponding sds cosmological and black - hole free energies are plotted in fig . [ p : lacdm ] , as a function of the mass @xmath148 ( in energy units @xmath193 ) . and @xmath181 sds free energies for the @xmath0cdm model.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] as a second example we consider the viable model in ( [ 1.5 ] ) , with @xmath63 , @xmath194 , @xmath195 , @xmath30 , as discussed in sect . ii . with this choice of parameters , eq . ( [ b ] ) has three real solutions for @xmath196 ( minkowski ) , @xmath197 and @xmath198 . the last one ( @xmath134 ) is stable , while the other two are unstable . for the free energies of the two de sitter solutions we get ^(1)_ds=-23 -,^(2)_ds=-23 - . [ minimods ] we see that ^(2)_ds < f^(1)_ds,~3.636 . independently of the parameter @xmath22 and so the stable de sitter solution with curvature @xmath134 is favorite , from the energetic point of view , with respect to the one with smaller curvature @xmath133 . the sds free energies are plotted in fig . [ p : fcfh ] , as functions of the mass @xmath148 ( in energy units @xmath199 , for @xmath200 . however , it has to be stressed that , for the sds corresponding to the de sitter solution with curvature @xmath134 , the mass needs to be restricted to @xmath201 and thus , for a fixed mass @xmath148 , we can compare the corresponding free energies in this range only . for both the cosmological and black - hole horizons there are critical values of the black hole mass @xmath148 , say @xmath202 , for which @xmath203 . then , we can distinguish three different regions : + ( a ) @xmath204 : in this first case @xmath205 ; + ( b ) @xmath206 : in this second case @xmath207 , but @xmath208 ; + ( c ) finally , for @xmath209 , we have @xmath210 . as we have seen from general considerations , the free energies corresponding to the cosmological horizons are monotonous functions of the mass , while the ones corresponding to the black - hole horizons are convex functions , which reach the minimum at @xmath211 . for our two cases , @xmath133 and @xmath134 , we get m_1~~ , ^(1)_h , min~- , m_2~~ , ^(2)_h , min~- . [ minimum ] then we see that , for the model in ( [ 1.5 ] ) we are dealing with , the configuration with the minimum free energy corresponds to sds with mass @xmath212 and curvature @xmath213 . the associated free energy is given in ( [ minimum ] ) . we also observe that this is smaller than the free energy of the pure de sitter configuration as it is clear from ( [ minimods ] ) thus , it is demonstrated here that multiple de sitter solutions can appear also under the form of sds solutions . in other words , the number of multiply solutions becomes significantly bigger . with the appearance of both ds and sds universe solutions one can suggest various scenarios for the universe evolution . for instance , we can conjecture that a ( pre-)inflationary universe is described by some sds spacetime . as time proceeds , this universe decays and enters into the well known radiation / matter dominance phase . in its further evolution , the universe transits to the ds ( or almost ds ) era , by stability and least - energy principle considerations . the future universe may again appear as an sds spacetime . ): cosmological free energies on the left and black - hole free energies on the right.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] ): cosmological free energies on the left and black - hole free energies on the right.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] . in summary , we have investigated in this paper several viable models of modified gravity which satisfy both the constraints of local as well as cosmological tests . by means of a numerical study , it is demonstrated that some versions of highly non - linear models exhibit multiply de sitter universe solutions which often appear in pairs , being one of them stable and the other unstable . the numerical evolution of the effective equation of state parameter is presented too . as a result , these models can be considered as natural candidates for the unification of early - time inflation with late - time acceleration through ds critical points . moreover , based on the de sitter solutions , multiply sds solutions can also be constructed . further , we have investigated the thermodynamic properties of these sds universes : their corresponding entropies and free energies have been calculated and compared . sds universe might also appear at the ( pre-)inflationary stage . owing to the highly non - linear structure of the theories under discussion , the ds universes had to be constructed with numerical tools mainly . moreover , in order to simplify the problem , at this first stage of the investigation we did not to consider matter contributions . it is clear that , in the next step , we must necessarily include matter and reconsider the problem in its presence . this has the potential to lead to a sufficiently realistic quantitative description of the universe expansion history , in which modified gravity would be responsible for both acceleration stages : the inflation epoch and the dark energy one . this quantitative analysis will be presented elsewhere . * acknowledgements . * this paper is an outcome of the collaboration program infn ( italy ) and dgicyt ( spain ) . it has been also supported in part by mec ( spain ) , projects fis2006 - 02842 and pie2007 - 50i023 , by agaur ( generalitat de catalunya ) , contract 2005sgr-00790 and grant 2008be1 - 00180 , and by rfbr , grant 06 - 01 - 00609 ( russia ) . the work of p.t . was partially supported by rfbr , grant 08 - 02 - 00923 , and with the scientific school grant 4899.2008.2 of the russian ministry of science and technology . pt thanks alexey toporensky for some useful discussions . the research of ee is partly based on work done while on leave at the department of physics and astronomy , dartmouth college , 6127 wilder laboratory , hanover , nh 03755 , usa . s. nojiri and s.d . odintsov , arxiv:0807.0685[hep - th ] ; t. sotiriou and v. faraoni , arxiv:0805.1726[gr - qc ] ; s. capozziello and m. francaviglia , gen.relat.grav . * 40 * , 357 ( 2008 ) ; f. lobo , arxiv:0807.1640[gr - qc ] . s. capozziello , int.j.mod.phys . d * 11 * , 483 ( 2002 ) ; m. ruggiero and l. iorio , arxiv : gr - qc/0607093 ; a. cruz - dombriz and a. dobado , arxiv : gr - qc/0607118 ; n. poplawski , arxiv : gr - qc/0610133 ; m. c. b. abdalla et al , class . quant . grav . * 22 * , l35 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0409177 ] ; a. brookfield , c. van de bruck and l. hall , arxiv : hep - th/0608015 ; h. oyaizu , m. lima and w. hu , arxiv:0807.2462[astro - ph ] ; b. li , k. chan and m. chu , arxiv : astro - ph/0610794 ; x. jin , d. liu and x. li , arxiv : astro - ph/0610854 ; t. sotiriou and s. liberati , arxiv : gr - qc/0604006 ; t. sotiriou , arxiv:0805.1160[gr - qc ] ; i. navarro and k. van acoleyen , arxiv : gr - qc/0611127 ; a. bustelo and d. barraco , arxiv : gr - qc/0611149 ; f. briscese , e. elizalde , s. nojiri and s. d. odintsov , phys . lett . b * 646 * , 105 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0612220 ] ; b. li and j. barrow , arxiv : gr - qc/0701111 ; v. faraoni , arxiv : gr - qc/0703044 ; arxiv:0706.1223[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0805.1249[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0810.2602[gr - qc ] ; o. bertolami , c. boehmer , t. harko and f. lobo , arxiv:0704.1733[gr - qc ] ; o. bertolami and j. paramos , arxiv:0805.1241[gr - qc ] ; s. carloni , a. troisi and p. dunsby , arxiv:0706.0452[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0707.0106[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0809.3673[astro - ph ] ; j. santos , j. alcaniz , f. carvalho et al , arxiv:0708.0411[astro - ph ] ; arxiv:0807.2443[astro - ph ] ; h. mohseni sadjadi , arxiv:0709.2435[gr - qc ] ; n. lanahan - tremblay and v. faraoni , arxiv:0709.4414[gr - qc ] ; n. goheer , j. leach and p. dunsby , arxiv:0710.0814[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0809.5247[gr - qc ] ; o. lecian and g. montani , arxiv:0807.4428[gr - qc ] ; t. harko , arxiv:0810.0742[gr - qc ] ; b. vakili , arxiv:0809.4591[gr - qc ] ; s. srivastava , arxiv:0809.1950[gr - qc ] ; d. saez , arxiv:0809.1311[hep - th ] ; k. bamba et al , arxiv:0803.3384[hep - th ] , phys.rev . d*77 * , 123532 ( 2008 ) ; arxiv:0801.0954[astro - ph ] , jcap * 0804*,024 ( 2008 ) ; arxiv:0807.2575[hep - th ] . p. mahato , annales de la fondation louis de broglie 32 ( 2007 ) 297 - 310;arxiv:0710.3821 [ astro - ph ] . s. nojiri and s. odintsov , gen . grav . * 36 * , 1765 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0308176 ] ; phys . b * 576 * , 5 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0307071 ] ; phys . * b599 * , 137 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0403622 ] ; arxiv:0801.4843[astro - ph ] ; g. cognola , e. elizalde , s. nojiri , s. d. odintsov and s. zerbini , phys . rev . * d73 * , 084007 ( 2006 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/0601008 ] ; s. capozziello et al , arxiv : astro - ph/0501426 ; arxiv : hep - th/0512118 ; g. allemandi , a. borowiec , m. francaviglia and s. d. odintsov , arxiv : gr - qc/0504057 ; g. allemandi , m. francaviglia , m. ruggiero and a. tartaglia , arxiv : gr - qc/0506123 ; t. multamaki and i. vilja , arxiv : astro - ph/0612775 ; arxiv:0709.3422[astro - ph ] ; j. a. r. cembranos , phys . rev . d * 73 * , 064029 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0507039 ] ; t. koivisto and h. kurki - suonio , arxiv : astro - ph/0509422 ; t. clifton and j. barrow , arxiv : gr - qc/0509059 ; i. brevik , arxiv : gr - qc/0601100 ; t. faulkner , m. tegmark , e. bunn and y. mao , arxiv : astro - ph/0612569 ; s. capozziello et al , arxiv:0804.2163[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0712.2980[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0810.2549[gr - qc ] ; s. nojiri , s. d. odintsov and p. tretyakov , arxiv:0704.2520[hep - th ] ; m. movahed , s. baghram and s. rahvar , arxiv:0705.0889[astro - ph ] ; c. boehmer , t. harko and f. lobo , arxiv:0710.0966[gr - qc ] ; j. miritzis , arxiv:0708.1396[gr - qc ] ; d. vollick , arxiv:0710.1859[gr - qc ] ; j. evans , l. hall and p. caillol , arxiv:0711.3695[astro - ph ] ; t. clifton , arxiv:0807.4682[gr - qc ] ; h. stefancic , arxiv:0807.4428[gr - qc ] ; a. dev et al , arxiv:0807.3445[hep - th ] ; t. kobayashi and k. maeda , arxiv:0807.2503[astro - ph ] ; s. nojiri , s. d. odintsov , phys . d * 74 * , ( 2006 ) 086005 [ arxiv : hep - th/0608008 ] ; arxiv : hep - th/0611071 ; s. capozziello , s. nojiri , s. d. odintsov and a. troisi , phys . b * 639 * , 135 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0604431 ] . s. tsujikawa , k. uddin and r. tavakol , arxiv:0712.0082 ; s. fay , s. nesseris and l. perivolaropoulos , arxiv : gr - qc/0703006 . g. cognola , m. gastaldi and s. zerbini , arxiv : gr - qc/0701138 ; j.l . cortes and j. indurain , arxiv:0805.3481[astro - ph ] ; s. tsujikawa and t. tatekawa , arxiv:0804.4343[astro - ph ] ; n. deruelle , m. sasaki and y. sendouda , phys.rev . d * 77*,124024 ( 2008 ) ; k. kainulainen and d. sunhede , arxiv:0803.0867[gr - qc ] ; g. cognola and s. zerbini , j.phys . a * 39 * , 6245 ( 2006 ) . s. a. appleby and r. a. battye , arxiv:0705.3199[astro - ph ] ; l. pogosian and a. silvestri , arxiv:0709.0296[astro - ph ] ; s. tsujikawa , arxiv:0709.1391[astro - ph ] ; s. capozziello and s. tsujikawa , arxiv:0712.2268[gr - qc ] . i.brevik , s. nojiri , s.d . odintsov and l. vanzo , hep - th 0401073 , phys.rev . d * 70 * , 043520 ( 2004 ) ; g. cognola , s. nojiri , s.d . odintsov and s. zerbini , hep - th/0501096 , jcap * 0502 * , 010 ( 2005 ) ; f. briscese and e. elizalde , phys . d * 77 * , 044009 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0708.0432 [ hep - th ] ] .

viable models of modified gravity which satisfy both local as well as cosmological tests are investigated . it is demonstrated that some versions of such highly non - linear models exhibit multiply de sitter universe solutions , which often appear in pairs , being one of them stable and the other unstable . it is explicitly shown that , for some values of the parameters , it is possible to find several de sitter spaces ( as a rule , numerically ) ; one of them may serve for the inflationary stage , while the other can be used for the description of the dark energy epoch . the numerical evolution of the effective equation of state parameter is also presented , showing that these models can be considered as natural candidates for the unification of early - time inflation with late - time acceleration through ds critical points . moreover , based on the de sitter solutions , multiply sds universes are constructed which might also appear at the ( pre-)inflationary stage . their thermodynamics are studied and free energies are compared . = 5000

1004.4993

physics of graphene perception begins when one compares landau levels in two dimensional schrdinger and dirac theories . such spectacular phenomenon as unconventional quantum hall effect @xcite is caused by the anomaly of the lowest landau level ( lll ) @xcite which for dirac fermions in graphene is field independent and can accommodate only half the usual number of the states from the conduction band and takes the other half from the valence band . the easiest way to accomplish this peculiar feature of the lll is to solve a pair of the dirac equations that describe excitations near two inequivalent @xmath0 points of graphene s brillouin zone . normally this is done in a constant homogeneous magnetic field , although this property of the lll for dirac fermions is topologically protected for inhomogeneous field configurations and in the presence of ripples @xcite . the simplest inhomogeneous field configuration which contains nontrivial aharonov - bohm physics can be created by an infinitesimally thin solenoid . in practice such magnetic field configuration may be obtained when a type - ii superconductor is placed on top of graphene or semicondunducting heterojunction hosting a 2d electron gas ( 2deg ) with quadratic dispersion . while graphene devices still have to be fabricated , devices like this with a superconducting film grown on top of a semiconducting heterojunction ( such as gaas / algaas ) hosting a 2deg have in fact been fabricated twenty years ago @xcite and theoretically well studied ( see e.g. refs . ) . theoretically a problem of the dirac fermions in the field of aharonov - bohm flux was encountered in the context of cosmic strings by gerbert and jackiw @xcite . while for the solutions of the dirac equation with nonzero angular momentum the square integrability requirement specifies which of the two independent solutions should be taken , they noticed this is not the case for the zero angular momentum . for the zero momentum there is an ambiguity as both solutions are square integrable , but divergent as @xmath1 at the origin , where @xmath2 is the space coordinate . the ambiguity of the solution selection is caused by the singular nature of the infinitesimally thin solenoid vector potential at the origin . this problem has initiated a vast theoretical literature which addresses interesting aspects related to the rigorous treatment of the solutions of the dirac equation with the aharonov - bohm potential ( see e.g. refs . for a review ) . in the condensed matter context the dirac fermions in the field of solenoid emerged during the study of the dirac - bogolyubov - de gennes quasiparticles in the vortex state of @xmath3-wave superconductors @xcite ( see also @xcite for a review ) . due to the divergence of the zero mode solutions theory predicts a formation of nonzero local density of states ( ldos ) near the vortex center . however , this theoretical prediction based on the dirac nature of quasiparticles in @xmath3-wave superconductors does not agree with the results of scanning tunneling spectroscopy ( sts ) measurements @xcite in high - temperature superconductors . finally we mention a related problem of the description of topological defects in graphene based on the dirac equation with a pointlike pseudomagnetic vortex which has also been studied intensively , see e.g. refs . . the purpose of the present paper is to study the electronic excitations in graphene in the field of the aharonov - bohm flux and compare them with the corresponding results for 2deg with a quadratic dispersion . we rely on the existing studies of the dirac fermions in the aharonov - bohm potential , but focus on the specific features of graphene such as the presence of two inequivalent @xmath0 points which implies that one should consider the solutions for both inequivalent irreducible representations of the dirac @xmath4 matrices . also to avoid unnecessary formal complications we consider the physical regularization of the problem modeling a finite radius flux tube created by the abrikosov vortex . we utilize the simplest case of magnetic field concentrated in a thin cylindrical shell of small but finite radius @xmath5 when @xmath6 @xcite . in contrast to high - temperature superconductors dirac description of the quasiparticles in graphene is proven valid under the different conditions . in particular , sts measurements of graphene flakes on graphite @xcite exhibit the structural and electronic properties expected of pristine graphene such as the development of a single sequence of pronounced landau level peaks corresponding to massless dirac fermions in a homogeneous magnetic field . we propose to perform sts measurements for graphene penetrated by vortices from a type - ii superconductor , because the dirac theory predicts rather peculiar behavior of ldos not expected for the 2deg with a quadratic dispersion of carriers . the paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ sec : model ] we introduce the model hamiltonians and discuss the regularization of the aharonov - bohm potential used in this work . [ sec : schrodinger ] is devoted to the nonrelativistic case , and the relativistic case is discussed in detail in sec . [ sec : dirac ] . the structure of both sections is the same : we consider the solution of the corresponding schrdinger or dirac equation , construct the green s function ( gf ) with coinciding arguments , obtain the dos and study the behavior of the ldos . in sec . [ sec : concl ] our final results are summarized . we consider nonrelativistic and relativistic hamiltonians . the 2d nonrelativistic ( schrdinger ) hamiltonian has the standard form @xmath7 where @xmath8 , @xmath9 with the vector potential @xmath10 , planck s constant @xmath11 and the velocity of light @xmath12 describes a spinless particle with a mass @xmath13 and charge @xmath14 . the dirac quasiparticle in graphene is described by the hamiltonian @xmath15 where the matrices @xmath16 and @xmath17 are defined in terms of the pauli matrices as @xmath18 here @xmath19 labels two unitary inequivalent representations of @xmath4 gamma matrices , so that one considers a pair of dirac equations corresponding to two inequivalent @xmath20 points of graphene s brillouin zone . in eq . ( [ hamilton - rel ] ) @xmath21 is the fermi velocity and @xmath22 is the dirac mass ( gap ) , which is introduced in the hamiltonian for generality . note that we consider the simplest case when the gap has the same sign for @xmath19 [ see ref . for a discussion of more general cases ] . while tight binding calculations show that the quasiparticle excitations in graphene have a linear dispersion at low energies @xcite and are described by the massless dirac equation with @xmath23 @xcite , recent sts measurements revealed a mass gap near the dirac point in a single layer graphene sample suspended above a graphite substrate @xcite . since this gap and its origin are intensively studied both theoretically and experimentally in the last few years , here we consider a generic case with a finite value of @xmath22 . the vector potential of a vortex at the origin directed in the @xmath24 direction is @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the flux of the vortex expressed via magnetic flux quantum of the electron @xmath27 with @xmath28 , . ] where the value @xmath29 corresponds to the flux created by the abrikosov vortex . the magnetic field is then @xmath30 the essential difference between the schrdinger @xmath31 and dirac @xmath32 equations in this case can be seen if one squares the latter : @xmath33 \right ) \psi = ( e^2 - \delta^2 ) \psi,\ ] ] where the commutator @xmath34 = -\frac{e}{\hbar c } b_z(\mathbf{r})\ ] ] which introduces pseudo - zeeman term which is related to the sublattice rather than the spin degree of freedom . it should be mentioned that in the case of graphene the components of the spinor @xmath35 are associated with a sublattice rather than a spin degree of freedom . since the hamiltonian ( [ hamilton - rel ] ) originates from a nonrelativistic many - body theory , the zeeman interaction term has to be explicitly added to this hamiltonian . this resembles the case of the nonrelativistic hamiltonian ( [ hamilton - nonrel ] ) which becomes pauli one when the interaction between the magnetic moment of the spin and an external magnetic field is added . in the present paper we do not include the spin degree of freedom neither in ( [ hamilton - nonrel ] ) nor in ( [ hamilton - rel ] ) . ( [ dirac - squared ] ) and ( [ commutator ] ) identify the origin of complications @xcite in the problem with a singular vortex ( [ a - singular ] ) when a singularity in @xmath36 occurs at a singular point of the differential equation ( [ dirac - squared ] ) . to avoid these complications one can consider a vortex with a finite radius flux tube @xcite , i.e. with the magnetic field and vector potential written in cylindric coordinates @xmath37 : @xmath38 where @xmath39 is a profile function with a compact support satisfying the normalization @xmath40 and connected to the profile function @xmath41 by the relation @xmath42 . the simplest choice of the field distribution @xmath39 which regularizes the problem with the solutions solely expressed in terms of bessel functions is a magnetic field concentrated on the surface of the cylinder of radius @xmath5 , @xmath43 . then , the corresponding profile function @xmath44 in the limit @xmath45 we recover the aharonov - bohm potential ( [ a - singular ] ) but avoiding formal complications . as shown in ref . @xcite , there is no dependence on the detailed form of @xmath39 in the limit @xmath6 provided that @xmath46 . in the present paper we restrict ourselves by considering the profile function ( [ step - profile ] ) . in this section we recapitulate the results of refs . for nonrelativistic case . they are important not only for comparison with relativistic case , but also because the relativistic result is constructed using the nonrelativistic one . in the limit @xmath47 the admissible solution of the schrdinger equation is always a regular solution which in polar coordinates @xmath48 takes the form @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the bessel function with the wave vector @xmath51 which is related to the quasiparticle energy @xmath52 via @xmath53 . the eigenfunction expansion for the retarded schrdinger gf reads @xmath54 or after substituting the wave function ( [ solution - nonrel ] ) it becomes @xmath55 where @xmath56 . since an analytic continuation of the gf ( [ nonrel - gf ] ) on the imaginary axis in the complex momentum plane , @xmath57 is free of singularities , it is convenient to work with the corresponding gf @xmath58 where @xmath59 in eq . ( [ nonrel - gf - continued ] ) we already set two arguments coinciding , @xmath60 , because in the present work we consider the dos only . as we will see below , the function @xmath61 is also used in the representation of the dos for the dirac fermions . after the calculation of the gf ( [ g - continued ] ) is done , the ldos per spin projection can be found by returning back to the real momentum axis @xmath62 the gf @xmath63 was calculated in ref . using the contour integration technique . a weak point of this calculation was discussed in @xcite , where the same method was applied to obtain the @xmath64-dependent contribution to the gf , @xmath65 with coinciding arguments when the approach of @xcite is valid . referring to the derivation of @xcite , here we simply start from the corresponding expression for @xmath66 obtained in ref . @xmath67 notice that eq . ( [ delta - g - marino ] ) coincides with the corresponding expression from @xcite up to a coefficient . changing the variables to @xmath68 , @xmath69 one can obtain from ( [ delta - g - marino ] ) the final expression @xmath70}{\cosh x } e^{-2 \mathcal{q } r \cosh x\cosh y}\ ] ] which we will use in what follows . it turns out that the investigation of the full dos is simpler than the analysis of the ldos . thus in the next sec . [ sec : dos - nonrel ] we firstly consider the dos and return to the ldos ( [ ldos - def ] ) below in sec . [ sec : ldos - nonrel ] . the full dos per spin projection is obtained from the ldos ( [ ldos - def ] ) by integrating over the space coordinates @xmath71 since we have the integral representation ( [ delta - g ] ) for @xmath72 , it is straightforward to calculate directly the perturbation of dos , @xmath73 induced by the aharonov - bohm potential . here @xmath74 is a free dos of 2deg per unit area and @xmath75 is the 2d volume ( area ) of the system . firstly integrating @xmath72 over space , one obtains @xcite @xmath76 then integrating over @xmath77 and @xmath78 we obtain that @xmath79 returning to the real @xmath80 axis we reproduce the usual aharonov - bohm depletion of the dos with respect to the free dos @xmath81 @xcite : @xmath82 writing eq . ( [ norel - dos - depletion ] ) we have also included a case of the opposite field direction . now we come back to the ldos ( [ ldos - def ] ) . as in the case of the full dos , it is convenient to consider the excess ldos , @xmath83 . then the value @xmath84 can be obtained by calculating the function @xmath85 given by eq . ( [ delta - g ] ) and substituting the result to eq . ( [ nonrel - gf - continued ] ) . the analytic continuation @xmath86 described by eq . ( [ ldos - def ] ) has to be done at the very last step of the calculation . thus our purpose is to derive a simple representation for the function @xmath87 . first , one can rewrite it in the form @xmath88 where we used that @xmath89 . differentiating ( [ delta - g ] ) we get the integrand of the last expression @xmath90\int_0^\infty dy \cosh y e^{-2\mathcal{q } r\cosh x\cosh y}.\ ] ] using the integral representation for the modified bessel function @xmath91 @xcite @xmath92 and the formula ( 2.16.13.2 ) from @xcite @xmath93 we come to the equation @xmath94 integrating the last expression with mathematica , we get @xmath95 - \ln \frac{\mathcal{q } r}{2 } \\ & - \frac{\mathcal{q}^2 r^2}{4 \eta(1-\eta)}\,_3f_4(1,1,3/2;2,2,2-\eta , 1+\eta;\mathcal{q}^2 r^2 ) + \frac{1}{2}\psi(1-\eta)+ \frac{1}{2}\psi(\eta ) , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath96 is the generalized hypergeometric function and @xmath97 is the logarithmic derivative of the gamma function @xmath98 . after the analytic continuation @xmath99 is made only two terms in the square brackets ( with the hypergeometric function itself remaining real ) and logarithmic term contribute in @xmath100 , so that @xmath101 -1\}\ ] ] with @xmath102 note that the last term @xmath103 in eq . ( [ ldos - function ] ) arises from the logarithmic term of ( [ hypergeometric - integral ] ) . in the important limiting cases the last expression is greatly simplified . for example , in the limit @xmath104 one obtains @xmath105 also in the physically important case @xmath29 the ldos is expressed in terms of the sine integral , @xmath106 as follows @xmath107.\ ] ] using the asymptotic of the integral sine @xcite @xmath108 for @xmath109 from ( [ ldos - si ] ) we recover the previous expression ( [ ldos - large ] ) valid for @xmath29 and @xmath104 . in the opposite limit @xmath110 for @xmath111 , we see that @xmath112 $ ] . in fig . [ fig:1 ] we show the dependence ( [ ldos - si ] ) of the induced ldos @xmath113 on the distance from the center of the vortex @xmath2 . we observe that in the case of nonrelativistic 2deg the presence of the vortex induced the depletion of the ldos for small @xmath114 . the function @xmath115 crosses zero near @xmath116 and for @xmath117 the function it reaches the maximal value @xmath118 . in fig . we model a situation when the stm tip is positioned at some distance from the center of vortex and a bias voltage is swept to explore the energy dependence of the ldos . to take into account the presence of a finite carrier density in 2deg , we introduce a finite fermi energy @xmath119 , so that the ldos at zero energy , @xmath120 , corresponds its value at the fermi level , i.e. @xmath121 . to choose the appropriate units we set the distance scale @xmath122 to be the order of the lattice constant . then the energy scale , @xmath123 is the order of the bandwidth . the dimensionless variable @xmath124 can now be rewritten as follows @xmath125 . the dependence of @xmath126 is shown in fig . [ fig:2 ] for three values of @xmath127 : for @xmath128 solid ( blue ) curve , for @xmath129 long - dashed ( red ) curve and for @xmath130 short - dashed ( black ) curve . the chemical potential is taken @xmath131 . we observe that only for the smallest ratio @xmath132 the values of the ldos are significantly depleted below the free ldos @xmath133 . as we saw , the depletion of the ldos occurs for @xmath134 . since the presence of the fermi surface makes the value of @xmath80 large , so that the region of small @xmath135 is accessible only for @xmath136 . indeed , we observe that only for the smallest ratio @xmath132 the values of the ldos are depleted to a half of the value of free ldos @xmath133 . since the realistic values of the vortex core size are at least of the order of magnitude larger than @xmath122 , this implies that the region of a significant depletion of the ldos is not accessible experimentally . still , due to the slow decay of @xmath137 even for @xmath138 the amplitude of @xmath139 oscillations is of order of @xmath140 , so that this behavior can be probably observed experimentally . in this section we examine the density of states for dirac particles in the potential of the infinitesimally thin solenoid . to avoid formal complications we consider the physical regularization of the problem with the magnetic field concentrated in a thin cylindrical shell of small but finite radius @xmath5 and take the limit @xmath45 at the end of the calculation . all answers are presented in the form convenient for comparison with the case of the schrdinger equation . the dirac equation ( [ dirac - eq ] ) in the field of the regularized vortex ( [ profile ] ) , ( [ step - profile ] ) ( see also ( [ a - regular ] ) ) is solved in appendix [ sec : a ] . in our consideration we follow refs . . the profile ( [ a - regular ] ) implies that for @xmath141 the particle obeys the dirac equation ( [ system : r < r ] ) for a free particle , while for @xmath142 the particle moves in the field of aharonov - bohm vortex ( [ system : r > r ] ) . accordingly , for @xmath141 the squared dirac equation ( [ dirac - squared ] ) is equivalent to free schrdinger equations for the components of the spinor @xmath143 notice that in the appendix [ sec : a ] the definition ( [ psi - def - appendix ] ) for @xmath144 explicitly includes the factor @xmath145 . for @xmath142 the components @xmath35 satisfy the schrdinger equations with aharonov - bohm potential and the commutator ( [ commutator ] ) is singular at @xmath146 : @xmath147=-\frac{\eta}{r}\delta(r - r).\ ] ] the solution of the problem can found by matching the solutions obtained in the domains @xmath148 and @xmath142 [ see e.g. ( [ solution - psi1 ] ) ] . the radial components of the spinor @xmath149 have to be continuous : @xmath150 and the singularity of the commutator ( [ commutator - cylinder ] ) is taken into account by a condition on the derivatives @xmath151 we stress that in contrast to the dirac equation case , for the nonrelativistic case when the solution ( [ solution - nonrel ] ) is obtained using the same regularization procedure , both the wave function and its derivative should be continuous . this as we saw from eqs . ( [ dirac - squared ] ) , ( [ commutator ] ) and ( [ components - cartesian ] ) is related to the pseudo - zeeman term . after the limit @xmath45 is taken we obtain for the case @xmath152 the following solutions : @xmath153 for positive value of the energy @xmath154 and @xmath155 ; @xmath156 for negative value of energy @xmath157 and @xmath155 . here the upper and lower sign of the second spinor s component corresponds to @xmath158 and @xmath159 solutions , respectively . the @xmath160 solution turns out to be special , while the upper component is regular at @xmath161 , the lower component diverges as @xmath162 : @xmath163 for @xmath164 and @xmath165 for @xmath166 . one can check this property by using the matching conditions for @xmath167 component and then finding @xmath168 from eq . ( [ system : r > r - for2 ] ) . on the other hand , one can discover this singularity in the limit @xmath6 by directly analyzing the matching conditions for @xmath168 and then finding nonsingular @xmath167 from eq . ( [ system : r > r - for1 ] ) . comparing eqs . ( [ m=0.e>0 ] ) and ( [ m=0.e<0 ] ) we observe that a singular at @xmath161 zero - mode solution @xmath169 is hole - like , because a singular electron - like solution vanishes due to the @xmath170 factor . concluding the discussion of the solutions for the case @xmath152 we stress that for the opposite field direction it is the upper component of the spinor which is singular in the solution equivalent to eqs . ( [ m=0.e>0 ] ) and ( [ m=0.e<0 ] ) . moreover , the nonvanishing zero mode is now electron - like . as it was firstly noticed in ref . , this behavior under the change in the field direction breaks the symmetry under @xmath171 ( see also ref . for a discussion ) . the set of solutions for the case @xmath172 is the following : @xmath173 for @xmath164 and @xmath174 for @xmath166 . the prescription for the upper and lower sign of the second spinor s component is the same as for @xmath152 . the @xmath160 solutions in the case @xmath172 are the following : @xmath175 for @xmath164 and @xmath176 for @xmath166 . we observe that in this case it is the upper component of the spinor which is singular at @xmath161 and nonvanishing is the electron - like zero mode . now we are at the position to construct the gf for the dirac fermions using the presented above solutions . however , before going to this , we should stress that as shown in@xcite the field configuration with @xmath177 confined to the surface of a cylinder of radius @xmath5 is not essential for the main result . in simple words , an more general and not singular at the origin potential can be considered as a set of concentric shells . or putting more formally , a profile function @xmath39 should satisfy the condition given below eq . ( [ step - profile ] ) which excludes delta - funtion at the origin . the eigenfunction expansion for the retarded dirac gf s now includes both positive and negative energy solutions @xmath178 where depending on the sign of @xmath179 the sum is taken over either @xmath152 or @xmath172 solutions . accordingly , for the diagonal matric elements of @xmath180 , for instance , in the @xmath152 case we obtain @xmath181 and @xmath182 , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath183 . then the gf with coinciding arguments , @xmath60 acquires the following form @xmath184 \end{split}\ ] ] for @xmath152 , and @xmath185 , \\ g^{\mathrm{d}}_{\eta22}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r},e+i0;\zeta=-1 ) & = \frac{e-\delta}{2\pi(\hbar v_f)^2}g_\eta(\mathbf{r},q ) , \end{split}\ ] ] for @xmath172 . here the function @xmath186 is related to the function @xmath61 defined in eq . ( [ g - continued ] ) by analytic continuation @xmath187 . note that while the function @xmath61 is identical for both nonrelativistic and relativistic cases , the real momentum @xmath80 function @xmath186 has a different analytical properties in these cases reflecting the fact that in contrast to the nonrelativistic case the relativistic spectrum contains positive and negative energy branches . similarly , the function @xmath188.\ ] ] is the analytic continuation to the imaginary axis of the function @xmath189 . the @xmath190 contribution to @xmath191 originates from the zero mode solutions of the dirac equation . using the integral [ ( 2.12.32.12 ) from@xcite ] @xmath192 where @xmath193 is the modified bessel function and @xmath194 is the macdonald function , we obtain the following simple result for @xmath190 @xmath195 due to the matrix structure of the gf and the presence of the valley degree of freedom , @xmath196 , in contrast to the nonrelativistic expression ( [ dos - nonrel ] ) , the full dos in the relativistic case involves not only the integration over area , but also summing over the diagonal components of the gf and @xmath20 valleys . for a better understanding of the final result for the full dos , it is instructive to consider separate expressions for the dos corresponding separate @xmath20 points @xmath197.\ ] ] recall that for @xmath198 the free dos of the dirac quasiparticles per spin and one valley is equal to @xmath199 . using eqs . ( [ dirac - g - zeta=1 ] ) and ( [ dirac - g - zeta=-1 ] ) one can express the dos ( [ dirac - dos - zeta ] ) via the functions @xmath200 and @xmath201 defined by eqs . ( [ g - continued ] ) and ( [ f - continued ] ) , respectively , as follows @xmath202 . \end{split}\ ] ] the integral of used in the nonrelativistic case function @xmath200 , or to be precise of the function @xmath87 , over the space coordinates is calculated in eq . ( [ g - integral ] ) . the corresponding space integration of the function @xmath201 given by eq . ( [ f - macdonald ] ) produces the result @xmath203 notice that since @xmath204 for @xmath198 , there is no need to introduce a function @xmath205 . having these results for the spatial integration we can calculate the imaginary part . since both eqs . ( [ g - integral ] ) and ( [ f - integral ] ) depend on @xmath206 , the imaginary part is obtained by using a simple prescription @xmath207/(\hbar v_f)^2 $ ] . this gives the final expression for the perturbed dos , @xmath208 by the aharonov - bohm vortex @xmath209 + ( [ dirac - dos - final ] ) which is @xmath210 originates from @xmath211 part of eq . ( [ dirac - dos - g&f ] ) and resembles the nonrelativistic result ( [ norel - dos - depletion ] ) . for @xmath23 it turns out to be twice larger than ( [ norel - dos - depletion ] ) simply because in eq . ( [ dirac - dos - final ] ) we summed over the diagonal components of the gf @xmath180 which are related to the two sublattices of graphene . the last term of ( [ dirac - dos - final ] ) originates from @xmath190 part of eq . ( [ dirac - dos - g&f ] ) and thus is related to the zero mode solution of the dirac equation . the mentioned above fact that the singular component of the zero mode solution is hole - like for @xmath152 [ see eq . ( [ m=0.e<0 ] ) ] and it is electron - like for @xmath172 [ see eq . ( [ m=0.e>0-negative - zeta ] ) ] finds its reflection in the asymmetric form of the last term of eq . ( [ dirac - dos - final ] ) which also corresponds to the holes ( electrons ) for @xmath212 ( @xmath172 ) . in accordance with the behavior of the zero mode solutions described in sec . [ sec : dirac - solutions ] , when the direction of the field is reversed the expressions @xmath213 and @xmath214 are interchanged . the full excess dos @xmath215\ ] ] is obviously symmetric in energy . in contrast to the nonrelativistic case , in the dirac case the aharonov - bohm vortex induces the excess of the states which is related to the presence of the last term of eq . ( [ dirac - dos - final ] ) and caused by the zero modes . we note that in ref . the corresponding term of eq . ( [ dirac - dos - final ] ) has a wrong sign . the positiveness of @xmath216 can also be understood by the following simple argument . for @xmath217 the free dos @xmath218 . therefore , since the dos has to be positive , the value @xmath216 should also be positive . now we investigate the ldos for the dirac case . while it was useful to consider each valley separately , especially because field theoretical studies of the problem often involve only one unitary inequivalent representation of @xmath219 gamma matrices [ see e.g.@xcite ] , the ldos measurement picks up both valleys together . on the other hand , ldos distinguishes sublattices . thus we consider separately the ldos for @xmath220 and @xmath177 sublattices which are defined as follows @xmath221 , \\ n_\eta^{\mathrm{d } ( b)}(\mathbf{r},e)=-\frac{1}{\pi } \mbox{im } \left [ g_{\eta 22}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r},e+i0;\zeta=1 ) + g_{\eta22}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r},e+i0;\zeta=-1 ) \right ] . \end{split}\ ] ] again we consider the perturbation of the ldos induced by the aharonov - bohm potential , @xmath222 . using eqs . ( [ dirac - g - zeta=1 ] ) and ( [ dirac - g - zeta=-1 ] ) we rewrite the ldos s @xmath223 in terms of the functions @xmath224 and @xmath201 as follows @xmath225.\ ] ] here the upper ( lower ) sign corresponds to @xmath220 ( @xmath177 ) sublattice . to obtain the final expression for ldos we should make the analytic continuation @xmath226 . for the function @xmath227 given by eq . ( [ hypergeometric - integral ] ) one obtains @xmath228 - 1\right\},\ ] ] where the function @xmath229 is defined in eq . ( [ f - eta ] ) . one can easily see that because in the nonrelativistic case the analytic continuation to the real momentum @xmath99 is different from the analytic continuation @xmath226 in the relativistic case , the function ( [ g - real - rel ] ) differs from the function ( [ ldos - function ] ) . using the relationships @xcite @xmath230 between the macdonald function of the imaginary argument , the hankel function of the second kind @xmath231 and the bessel function of the first @xmath232 and second @xmath233 kinds , we obtain that @xmath234,\ ] ] where we used the property @xmath235 . accordingly , the analytic continuation of the function @xmath236 from eq . ( [ f - macdonald ] ) takes the form @xmath237 - 2\cos\pi\eta j_\eta(qr)y_\eta(qr)\}.\ ] ] substituting ( [ g - real - rel ] ) and ( [ f - real - rel ] ) in eq . ( [ ldos - ab - f&g ] ) we arrive at the final main result @xmath238 - 1\\ + & \frac{\sin^2(\pi\eta)}{2 } [ y^2_\eta(qr)- j^2_\eta(qr)]- \frac{\sin ( 2 \pi\eta)}{2 } j_\eta(qr)y_\eta(qr ) \biggr\ } , \qquad q = \frac{\sqrt{e^2 - \delta^2}}{\hbar v_f } , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath239 is free dos of the dirac quasiparticles per spin and one sublattice ( or valley ) for @xmath23 . the first part of eq . ( [ ldos - ab - final ] ) which includes @xmath240 and @xmath241 is identical to the nonrelativistic expression ( [ ldos - function ] ) , while the second part of eq . ( [ ldos - ab - final ] ) with bessel functions originates from the zero mode contribution . in the limit @xmath104 the last expression acquires a simple form @xmath242 comparing eqs . ( [ ldos - ab - large - qr ] ) and ( [ ldos - large ] ) we conclude that in the dirac case the impact of the vortex is more localized than in the nonrelativistic case . as we saw in sec . [ sec : ldos - nonrel ] in the physically important case @xmath29 the expression ( [ ldos - function ] ) is significantly simplified to the result ( [ ldos - si ] ) . the same remains true for eq . ( [ ldos - ab - final ] ) , because half - integer bessel functions are expressed in terms of the elementary functions and we obtain that @xmath243.\ ] ] from eq . ( [ ldos - ab - si - cos ] ) we immediately observe the main difference between the relativistic and nonrelativistic cases . the presence of zero modes causes a positive divergence of the ldos , @xmath244 for @xmath114 near the center of the vortex . integrally this results in the excess of the states in the full dos ( [ dirac - dos - full ] ) . using the asymptotic expansion of @xmath245 given below eq . ( [ ldos - si ] ) we recover the previous expression ( [ ldos - ab - large - qr ] ) valid for @xmath29 and @xmath104 . in fig . [ fig:3 ] we show the dependence ( [ ldos - ab - si - cos ] ) of the induced ldos @xmath246 on the distance from the center of the vortex @xmath2 for @xmath23 . we observe the features expected from the analytic expressions such as the excess of the ldos for small @xmath114 and faster than in 2deg decay of @xmath247 for @xmath104 . in fig . [ fig:4 ] we consider a situation similar to fig . [ fig:2 ] . we fix the distance at @xmath248 and plot the energy dependence of the relativistic ldos ( [ ldos - ab - si - cos ] ) . we consider the most interesting case of undoped graphene with zero carrier density . in contrast to the 2deg , in graphene is easily tuned to this regime . again , we introduce the distance scale @xmath122 of the order of the lattice constant . then for the dirac case the energy scale is @xmath249 , and accordingly the dimensionless variable is @xmath250 . to make sublattices inequivalent we introduce a finite gap @xmath251 which introduces the asymmetry between the the ldos on @xmath220 and @xmath177 sublattices . the ldos @xmath252 shown as a solid ( blue ) curve has a sharp peak near @xmath253 and practically no peak at @xmath253 , while the ldos @xmath254 shown as dashed ( red ) curve has a peak near @xmath255 and no peak at @xmath256 . when @xmath257 is increasing the ldos very quickly reduces to its value for the dirac system in the absence of the vortex . we note that this behavior of the ldos is seen for the large value of @xmath138 , i.e. far from the center of the vortex , indicates that it should be possible to observe this excess of the ldos in experiments on graphene . finishing our discussion of the dirac case , we mention a recent work @xcite , where the effect of the vacuum polarization in the field of an infinitesimally thin solenoid at the distances much larger than the radius of solenoid was studied . constructing the gf the authors neglected the delta - function ( [ discontinuity ] ) motivated by the fact that they are interested in the regime @xmath258 . one of their interesting conclusions is that for @xmath29 the induced current is zero . the main motivation of this work was to address a natural question whether one can distinguish graphene from 2deg measuring the ldos near the abrikosov vortex penetrating them . just by comparing figs . [ fig:2 ] and [ fig:4 ] we find a positive answer . indeed , by putting the stm tip close to the vortex , for example , at the distance , @xmath259 , where @xmath122 is the lattice constant , we observe that in 2deg the value of the ldos will be close to its background value @xmath260 in the free system , while in undoped graphene one should observe a strong ldos enhancement near the fermi level . or to be more precise , if there is no gap @xmath22 in the quasiparticle spectrum , the peak of the ldos should be observed at the fermi level , or if @xmath261 the peaks should be observed at the energies @xmath262 and the sign of the peak energy should depend on the sublattice . this peaked behavior of the ldos with @xmath244 for @xmath114 reflects the specific feature of the dirac fermions such as the presence of the divergent as @xmath1 at the origin zero mode solution of the dirac equation . thus the observation of this feature in sts measurements would contribute to the expanding list of the experimental manifestations of the dirac fermions in graphene . our second conclusion is that while in the nonrelativistic case the presence of the aharonov - bohm vortex leads to a depletion of the full dos , in the dirac case the full dos is enhanced . this result can likely be checked by analyzing the sts maps . we remind at the end that in this paper we did not consider the effect of disorder in the presence of magnetic field which will definitely affect the behavior of the ldos in magnetic field @xcite and should be taken into account in the analysis of the sts data . we thank e.v . gorbar and v.p . gusynin for many stimulating discussions . s.g.s . thanks c.g . beneventano and e.m . santangelo for an interesting discussion and bringing ref . to his attention . this work was supported by the scopes grant no . iz73z0`_`128026 of swiss nsf , by the grant simtech no . 246937 of the european fp7 program and by the program of fundamental research of the physics and astronomy division of the national academy of sciences of ukraine . was also supported by the ukrainian state foundation for fundamental research under grant no . a positive energy solution of the time - dependent dirac equation has a form @xmath263 with a two - component spinor @xmath35 satisfying the time - independent dirac equation ( [ dirac - eq ] ) : @xmath264\psi({\mathbf r})=0.\ ] ] where @xmath19 distinguishes two unitary inequivalent representations of @xmath265 gamma matrices . it is convenient to denote the components of two - component spinor @xmath35 @xmath266 with the factor @xmath145 explicitly included in the definition of the lower component . then we can rewrite dirac equation ( [ dirac - eq - append ] ) in the components as follows : @xmath267 since we consider a cylindrically symmetric configuration of the field with a vector potential @xmath268 , the system ( [ components - cartesian ] ) has to be rewritten in the polar coordinates @xmath269 : @xmath270 as discussed in sec . [ sec : model ] , to analyze the problem with a singular at @xmath161 aharonov - bohm potential ( [ a - singular ] ) one has to do a self - adjoint extension of the dirac operator , see e.g. refs . . to avoid this complication we consider a regularized field configuration ( [ profile ] ) suggested in refs . with the profile function ( [ step - profile ] ) , so that @xmath271 from now on , we consider the specific case @xmath212 and seek for a solution of eq . ( [ components - polar ] ) in the following form @xmath272 for @xmath273 we obtain a system of the radial equations for a free dirac particle [ 2nd - order : r < r ] @xmath277\psi_1(r)=0 , \label{psi1:r < r } \\ & \frac{d^2}{dr^2}\psi_2(r)+\frac{1}{r}\frac{d}{dr}\psi_2(r)- \left[\frac{m^2}{r^2}-\frac{e^2-\delta^2}{(\hbar v_f)^2}\right]\psi_2(r)=0 , \label{psi2:r < r}\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ 2nd - order : r > r ] @xmath278\psi_1(r)=0 , \label{psi1:r > r } \\ \frac{d^2}{dr^2}\psi_2(r)+\frac{1}{r}\frac{d}{dr}\psi_2(r)- \left[\frac{(m+\eta)^2}{r^2}-\frac{e^2-\delta^2}{(\hbar v_f)^2}\right]\psi_2(r)=0 \label{psi2:r > r}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath142 . the solutions of eqs . ( [ 2nd - order : r < r ] ) and ( [ 2nd - order : r > r ] ) are expressed in terms of the usual bessel functions . for example , for the solutions of the equations ( [ psi1:r < r ] ) and ( [ psi1:r > r ] ) for the component @xmath167 are given by where @xmath280 , @xmath281 , and @xmath282 are constants and the @xmath283 s are the bessel functions . the solution ( [ solution - psi1:r < r ] ) is standard due to normalizability and the absence of delta function at @xmath161 . the coefficients @xmath280 , @xmath281 , and @xmath282 to be found from the matching conditions ( [ continuity ] ) and ( [ discontinuity ] ) . to find the second component , @xmath168 one can substitute the result for @xmath167 in eq . ( [ system : r > r - for2 ] ) . or , equivalently , one can start from eqs . ( [ psi2:r < r ] ) and ( [ psi2:r > r ] ) for the component @xmath168 which also have a solution in the form ( [ solution - psi1 ] ) , find the corresponding constants from the matching conditions and then use eq . ( [ system : r > r - for1 ] ) to obtain @xmath167 . finally , the overall factor before the solution is determined by the normalization condition @xmath284

we carry out a comparative study of electronic properties of 2d electron gas ( 2deg ) in a magnetic field of an infinitesimally thin solenoid with relativistic dispersion as in graphene and quadratic dispersion as in semiconducting heterostructures . the problem of ambiguity of the zero mode solutions of the dirac equation is treated by considering of a finite radius flux tube which allows to select unique solutions associated with each @xmath0 point of graphene s brillouin zone . then this radius is allowed to go to zero . on the base of the obtained in this case analytical solutions in the aharonov - bohm potential the local and total density of states ( dos ) are calculated . it is shown that in the case of graphene there is an excess of ldos near the vortex , while in 2deg the ldos is depleted . this results in excess of the induced by the vortex dos in graphene and in its depletion in 2deg . we discuss the application of the results for the local density of states for the scanning tunneling spectroscopy done on graphene .

1604.08648

the investigation of stellar populations within the nearest 50 pc of the sun arouses great interest in the astronomical community . this is largely because a detailed study of the kinematics and statistical properties of a stellar ensemble in this region of the galaxy makes it possible to gain an insight into the genesis of the circumsolar region and to test the models of galactic structure and evolution . this is reflected in a whole series of papers ( see , e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite ) . dwarf stars ( predominantly m dwarfs , subdwarfs , white and brown dwarfs ) , which constitute the main population of the solar neighborhood , are noticeably brighter than more distant objects of this type , which makes them the most convenient and often the only accessible targets for studies . such empirical relations as mass luminosity and mass radius are important tests of the models for the structure of stars and their atmospheres . whereas theoretical models for comparatively massive stars ( 13 @xmath3 ) show good agreement with observations , there are difficulties for low - mass stars ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . they can be overcome in part by improving the mentioned relations . this requires revealing a large number of binary systems and determining their orbits . the parameters of the mass function and the fraction of binary system in a given stellar population can be estimated on the basis of cosmogonic models . comparison of such estimates with observations enables a justified choice of the most probable scenario for the formation and evolution of stellar populations to be made ( @xcite ) . therefore , revealing binary systems among low - luminosity objects is an important research direction . the topicality of the problems under consideration contributed to the implementation of several projects in the 20th century aimed at detecting fast stars ( @xcite ; @xcite ) and determining their proper motions and trigonometric parallaxes ( @xcite ) . as a rule , the stars in the solar neighborhood are distinguished by large proper motions ( @xmath4 0.1 arcsec@xmath5yr@xmath6 ) . this has allowed a sample of low - luminosity objects to be produced by detecting such relatively fast objects on the basis of astrometric observations . not by chance , the lspm catalog of fast stars ( @xcite ) is invoked for the selection of low - luminosity objects more often than others . the passage to ccd detectors has rekindled interest in this subject matter . at present , several research groups in the world are actively working in this direction . for example , the recons group ( riedel et al . 2014 ) or the mearth project ( @xcite ) . a project to investigate stars with large proper motions was also implemented at the pulkovo observatory ( @xcite ) . the gaia space observatory has been operating at the lagrange point l2 already for more than a year . the main product of this space mission is an astrometric catalog ( coordinates , velocities , distances , photometric data ) of a billion stars down to 20@xmath7 . the final accuracy of the astrometric parameters will be unprecedentedly high ( for single 16 m stars , @xmath830 @xmath9as for the positions and 25 @xmath9as@xmath5yr@xmath6 for the proper motions ) . this will allow an enormous number of binary systems containing low - mass components to be detected and investigated ( @xcite ) . in many cases , reliable orbits will be constructed and the masses will be determined . note that the revolution periods for a large number of binary systems are considerably longer than the operation time of the gaia space telescope . therefore , a combination of ground - based and space observations performed at different epochs and gaia data seems promising for a global search of astrometric binaries among low - luminosity stars ( @xcite ) . such a combination of data from the fk5 and hipparcos catalogs has already shown the efficiency of this approach for analyzing the motions of the brightest stars in the sky ( @xcite ) . traditionally , to investigate the motions of the components of visual double stars , their observations are regularly carried out over decades ( @xcite ) . a careful analysis of the data series often leads to the detection of stars with invisible companions , also known as , astrometric binaries ( @xcite ) . for most nearby low - luminosity stars , we have no such dense , long , and homogeneous series of observations . we are dealing with occasional observations from different projects ( which makes them inhomogeneous from the standpoint of the accuracy and systematic errors of the stellar coordinates ) . the idea of searching for astrometric binaries under such conditions was implemented by @xcite as applied to the brightest stars in the sky ( stars from the fk6 catalog ) . it consists in the fact that the stellar proper motion determined at a large epoch difference ( 50100 yr ) reflects the mean motion of the photocenter of an unresolved stellar pair ( quasi - mean proper motion ) , while the proper motion determined in a time interval of @xmath810 yr corresponds to the instantaneous motion with some probability ( quasi - instantaneous proper motion ) . a statistically significant difference between these proper motions may suggest that we are dealing with a binary system . such stars are called @xmath2-binary candidates in wielen s terminology . physically , assigning a star to the category of @xmath2 binaries implies the detection of evidence for nonlinearity of its motion over the celestial sphere . several factors can be responsible for this effect . a classic example is an optically unresolvable binary system . in this case , we are dealing with a nonlinear motion of the binary s photocenter relative to its center of mass . a situation where the star being investigated is a component of a wide pair and the second star is too faint to be detectable in the images is possible . within the framework of the pulkovo program of research on stars with large proper motions , we have made an attempt to extend wielen s idea to fast stars . to improve the quasi - instantaneous proper motions , we performed astrometric observations of 1123 selected stars from the lspm catalog . the quasi - mean proper motions were taken from the lspm catalog . as a result , 70 @xmath2 binaries were revealed ( @xcite ) . a significant shortcoming of the previous study is that the original stellar coordinates from the catalogs and surveys ( m2000 , cmc14 , 2mass , sdss dr7 ) and the lspm proper motions represent the hcrf / tycho-2 system only formally . it is natural to expect more reliable results if the proper motions are determined just as was done in photographic astrometry or in the problem of determining the trigonometric parallaxes of stars . in this paper , we attempted to implement precisely this approach , i.e. , the ccd frames from different surveys were considered as a set of images entering into a single parallactic series . the parameters of the transition to the reference frame were calculated . the systematic errors of the stellar coordinates were taken into account . based on the derived set of coordinates for a program star in the system of the reference frame , we calculated the proper motions and quantities that allowed us to reach a conclusion about whether the star belongs to the category of @xmath2 binaries . our detailed technique and results are presented in the succeeding sections of this paper . as previously ( @xcite ) , stars from the lspm catalog were included in our program of observations . the main list contains 1972 stars down to 17@xmath7 in the declination zone from 30@xmath10 to 70@xmath10 . these are mostly stars with @xmath4 300 mas@xmath5yr@xmath6 ( 1507 stars ) . for various reasons , we added 465 stars . some of them have large photometric parallaxes ; a number of stars were added to analyze the possibility of investigating comparatively slowly moving objects ( @xmath4 100 mas@xmath5yr@xmath6 ) . the distribution of observational program stars over the celestial sphere is shown in fig . figure [ fig2 ] demonstrates how the program objects are distributed in total proper motion , magnitude , mass , and heliocentric distance . on the whole , this is an almost complete sample . the lspm catalog contains almost all existing fast stars down to @xmath11 ( @xcite ) . therefore , it can be said that the pulkovo observational program includes all of the stars that can be effectively observed in pulkovo in the corresponding ranges of magnitudes and proper motions . our ccd observations were carried out with the pulkovo normal astrograph ( d = 330 mm , f = 3500 mm ) from 2008 to 2015 . they were necessary to increase the accuracy of the quasi - instantaneous stellar proper motions . an s2c camera ( with a working field of @xmath12 arcmin at a scale of 900 mas / pix ) was used before 2014 . a sbig st - l-11k camera ( with a working field of @xmath13 arcmin at a scale of 530 mas / pix ) was installed in 2014 and 2015 . the imaging was performed at hour angles @xmath14 h by series from 5 to 10 frames with exposure times of 60 or 120 s , depending on the magnitude of the program star . in several cases , for faint stars the number of frames in a series was increased to 40 to achieve the required signal - to - noise ratio by the summation of individual frames . the concept of a virtual observatory , when the results of observations ( including the images of sky fields ) are accessible via the internet , has long been used in astronomical practice . the sky surveys containing ccd frames or scans of photographic plates of the entire sky or much of it are of interest to us . in this paper , we used data from sdss dr12 ( @xcite ) , 2mass ( @xcite ) , wise ( @xcite ) , and stsci dss ( @xcite)(scans of possi - o and possii - j plates ) . for all of the listed surveys , there is a convenient interface to request the fits files . the necessary data were downloaded automatically with a specially developed application , and it took several days to do so due to the large volume of wise data ( the fields in this survey were imaged with numerous overlaps ) . for wise , we used the frames of only the `` cold '' part of the mission in the w1 and w2 bands to ensure an acceptable signal - to - noise ratio for the images of faint stars . we analyzed all ccd frames and scans of poss1 and poss2 plates according to a unified scheme . a shapelet decomposition ( @xcite ) was used to fit the stellar images on each frame . the pixel coordinates of the stellar image photocenter were varied according to the scheme from the paper cited above to ensure the minimum of the sum of the residuals squared . the same principle was applied to automatically select the decomposition order . typical examples of the fits to the images of a comparatively bright star on the frames from different surveys are shown in fig . [ fig3 ] . on the whole , the image measurement technique works reliably . some problems were observed with the choice of a decomposition order for the sdss frames . based on the structure of the distribution of residuals , we can assume that the order was slightly overestimated . as the results of astrometric sdss frame reductions showed , this is not critical for astrometric measurements ( for stars with v@xmath15 = 14 , the convergence of the pixel coordinates lies within 10 mas ) . the approach relying on the generation of the vector fields of residual pixel stellar coordinate differences based on the entire data set is commonly used to construct astrometric catalogs on the basis of ccd observations . we performed an astrometric reduction for all frames from a given survey . the frames constants allowed us to calculate the residual catalog frame differences of the pixel coordinates of reference stars . coma , distortion , or other geometric distortions can be responsible for these differences . they can manifest itself as the dependences of the residuals on coordinates and magnitude . examples of such dependences are shown in fig . based on the presented graphs , we can state with confidence that there is no magnitude equation for the pulkovo ccd frames and there is a noticeable and complex distortion for the wise frames . to calculate the corrections , we divided the working field of the frame into square ( or rectangular ) cells whose sizes were chosen in such a way that at least 100 differences for each magnitude group ( from 10@xmath7 to 16@xmath7 with a 1@xmath7 step ) fell into them . as the corrections for the geometric center of a cell , we used the means of all the differences that fell into this cell with the corresponding coordinates of the center and magnitudes . the corrections for any point and the magnitudes were calculated by a bicubic interpolation . examples of the vector fields of residual differences are shown in fig . it can be seen that the influence of a significant distortion of the wise telescope may well be revealed and properly taken into account . the sdss frames are free from significant geometric distortions . the systematic errors are tenths or hundredths of a pixel ( less than 4050 mas ) . thus , for all of the surveys used ( and for the photometric bands within a survey ) , we constructed the maps of corrections that allowed us to take into account the most significant systematic errors and to obtain the coordinates of the reference and program stars suitable for deriving the proper motions . for each star , we produced the sets of frames from all possible surveys and found and measured the common stars . it should be noted that quite a few regions are absent in sdss ; in several cases , the image of a program star was measured unsatisfactorily on the wise frames or the scans of palomar plates . we chose the stars whose images in the pixel with maximum intensity were characterized by a signal - to - noise ratio @xmath16 on all frames as the reference ones . each of these stars has a reliably determined proper motion in the ucac4 catalog ( @xcite ) . we applied the corresponding corrections for the systematic errors and proper motions to the pixel coordinates of the reference stars . the reference frame was determined in each set . the time at which this frame was taken was closer to the mean epoch of observations calculated from all frames than that for all the remaining ones . for each frame , we calculated the parameters of the linear model of the transition to the reference frame by least squares . as a result , we obtained a set of coordinates in the system of the reference frame for the program star . in the surveys used , the same region was imaged several times ( with different filters ) . for example , there were at least five frames for the corresponding photometric bands in sdss . for 2mass and wise , the imaging was performed both in different bands and with an overlap ( the region of interest to us was present on several frames ) . as a result , it became possible not only to increase the accuracy of the coordinates by taking their mean but also to estimate the accuracy of their determination . the standard position errors depend on the survey used . they lie within the range 2040 mas for sdss and 2mass and 80150 mas for the palomar surveys and wise ; for the pulkovo series of ccd frames , the internal accuracy of the stellar coordinates on the reference frame is 50100 mas , depending on the magnitude of a star . we determined a total of three variants of the proper motion . the first of them is the result of a linear least - squares fitting of the motion over all points . the weights of the points were assigned depending on the standard errors of the stellar coordinates for the corresponding epochs . the first two positions in the set corresponded to the poss1 ( 1950s ) and poss2 ( mainly 1980s and 1990s ) mean epochs . all of the remaining ones correspond to the more recent 2mass ( 19982002 ) , sdss ( 20002015 ) , pulkovo frames ( pna , 20082015 ) , and wise ( 2010 , the cold phase of the mission ) . the aforesaid is illustrated by the motion diagram for one of the program stars in fig . [ fig6 ] . to obtain independent variants , the quasimean proper motion ( second variant ) was calculated as the poss2-poss1 coordinate difference divided by the epoch difference . the last solution was considered as the quasi - instantaneous proper motion ( third variant ) . it was constructed by analogy with the first variant without allowance for the poss1 and poss2 data . @xcite proposed a statistical test that allowed one to decide whether the difference between the quasi - mean ( @xmath17 ) and quasi - instantaneous ( @xmath18 ) proper motions could be considered statistically significant . in the case of fk5 and hipparcos data , the proper motions were determined from a large number of observations , and there was no doubt that the distribution of these quantities was gaussian . the quantity f calculated from the following formula is used to determine the threshold value of the test : + @xmath19 , + where @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the differences of the proper motion components ( @xmath22 ) , @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the corresponding mutual standard errors ( @xmath25 ) . analysis of the cumulative distribution of this quantity leads to the conclusion that the probability of observing the corresponding proper motion differences for single stars is less than 0.05 for @xmath26 . it is such stars that were considered in @xcite as @xmath2-binary candidates . in our case , the number of points from which the inference should be drawn is small ( from 4 to 10 ) . therefore , it was necessary to check whether @xmath27 could be used as the threshold one . for this purpose , we performed numerical simulations of the linear motion of a single star over the celestial sphere with specified position errors spanning a period characteristic for our problem ( about 65 years ) . the points to determine the proper motions were taken at random , given the characteristic implementation times of the surveys used . next , we performed calculations according to the scheme described in the preceding section , but for a model star . different cases were considered : from four ( from two palomar images , pulkovo frames , and 2mass frames ) to ten points . for each of them , we conducted 100 000 tests . as a result , we constructed the cumulative f distribution and calculated the threshold value for each case . it can be seen from fig . [ fig7 ] that @xmath28 for six points , @xmath29 for ten points , and so on . as the number of points increases to 20 , the threshold value of this quantity approaches 2.5 , which corresponds to the situation considered in @xcite . the threshold values obtained in this way were used for real stars to reach a conclusion about the pattern of stellar motion over the celestial sphere . finally , we processed the frames and plate scans for 1308 stars using the described technique . we failed to reliably measure the positions of 120 stars on the frames from several surveys most often due to the presence of the images of very bright stars nearby . additional studies are required for these objects . all our results are summarized in four tables accessible in electronic form ( as an example , a small part of the main data set is shown in table [ tab1 ] ) . apart from our calculated proper motions and f - test estimates , additional data ( the proper motion differences from our comparison with the lspm data , the photometric and trigonometric parallaxes , the magnitude estimates for different bands , and membership in the catalogs of binary stars ) are given for each star . the service of the centre de donnees astronomiques de strasbourg @xcite was used to generate the tables . the reliability of determining the quasi - instantaneous proper motions ( third variant ) depends significantly on the epoch difference between the surveys . therefore , the material was divided into two parts . the first part contains the stars with a corresponding epoch difference of more than 5 years ; the second part contains all the remaining ones . there are 944 stars for which no evidence of motion nonlinearity was found and 121 stars manifesting themselves as @xmath2-binary candidates in the first part . the second group comprises 229 single stars and 14 @xmath2-binary candidates . for the proper motions constructed from all surveys ( first variant ) , the mean accuracy is slightly lower : 4 mas@xmath5yr@xmath6 in both coordinates . to get a more comprehensive idea of the quality of the proper motions , fig . [ fig8 ] presents the corresponding histogram and the magnitude dependence of the proper motion errors ( for the first variant of the proper motions ) . for the overwhelming majority of stars , the proper motion errors do not exceed 10 mas@xmath5yr@xmath6 . the quasi - mean proper motions are characterized by a mean accuracy of about 510 mas@xmath5yr@xmath6 . for the quasi - instantaneous proper motions , it is 1020 mas@xmath5yr@xmath6 ( it depends significantly on the availability of sdss frames and the magnitude of a star ) . the existence of systematic differences between our set of proper motions and the stellar proper motions in the lspm catalog is demonstrated by fig . these differences are particularly prominent for the proper motions in declination ( the differences can reach 24 mas@xmath5yr@xmath6 ) . a peculiarity of the lspm catalog is a nonstandard approach to absolutizing the proper motions . in the period of its production , the faint reference stars had not yet been provided with reliable proper motions . therefore , this procedure was performed using bright stars from the tycho-2 catalog whose images on the palomar survey plates were either overexposed or close to this . the extrapolation of the absolutizing corrections to the region of fainter ( by 3@xmath7 - 5@xmath7 ) stars was not checked in any way , which was probably responsible for the observed systematic differences . only 121 objects show evidence for nonlinearity of their motion over the celestial sphere , classifying such stars as @xmath2 binaries . in our view , these objects are of interest for further studies to confirm their binarity and to determine their orbits and masses , for example , through speckle interferometry with large telescopes . for 14 stars from the second group for which the quasi - instantaneous proper motion differs noticeably from the quasi - mean one , the conclusion about their n belonging to @xmath2 binaries seems very unreliable due to a small epoch difference in present - day sky surveys . therefore , our subsequent analysis concerns only the stars from the first group . ten stars from our list of @xmath2 binaries enter into the wds catalog ( @xcite ) , i.e. , they are visual double stars ( these account for @xmath30 of the total number of @xmath2 binaries ) . most of them are wide pairs with a common proper motion ( the angular separation between the components is tens of arseconds and , in several cases , arcminutes ) . this result is a weak confirmation of the efficiency of the technique for revealing @xmath2 binaries . in the list of 944 single stars , 58 enter into wds ( @xmath31 ) ; therefore , the fraction of known visual double stars in the list of @xmath2 binaries can not be said to be significantly larger . some of the pulkovo program stars have the trigonometric parallaxes derived from ground - based observations . the proper motions , along with the parallaxes , are known to be also determined with a high accuracy during such observations over a short interval ( 35 years ) . therefore , they may be considered as the quasi - instantaneous proper motions , and @xmath32 can be estimated by comparing them with the proper motions determined from our results . our list of @xmath2 binaries contains 33 stars that enter into the parallactic programs . eighteen of them have @xmath33 ( and five stars enter into wds ) . the correlation between the independent sets of @xmath34 and @xmath32 can be judged in more detail from fig . [ fig10 ] . with some reservation , we can talk about the existence of a correlation between @xmath34 and @xmath32 for @xmath2 binaries . in the case of stars considered as single ones , the evidence of a correlation is not so clear . the positions of visual double stars from the wds catalog are marked in fig . 10 by open symbols . they are present among both @xmath2 binaries and single stars . and this is quite natural . for wide pairs with long revolution periods ( hundreds or thousands of years ) , which are quite a few in our material , it is fairly difficult to detect the orbital motion based on the series of observations used . for binary systems of dwarf stars close to the sun , the angular separations between their components can be one arcsecond or more . therefore , binarity can be established simply by analyzing the images of stars on the ccd frames . the shapelet decomposition used to determine the pixel coordinates of stars also allows the image asymmetry to be estimated . to understand how reliable this approach is , we performed numerical simulations of the images of such pairs . for sdss , which has the best resolution among all of the surveys used , we constructed the model interacting images for binary systems with typical magnitudes of their components at various angular separations between them based on the results of fitting the images of single stars . these interacting images were then again subjected to the shapelet decomposition . an example of the dependence of the asymmetry on angular separation for a pair with component magnitudes of 14.1@xmath7 and 15.3@xmath7 is shown in fig . [ fig11 ] . analysis of this graph suggests that the image asymmetry estimates are most effective for angular separations of 24 arcsec . the asymmetry is also noticeable for smaller separations , but additional studies are required to estimate the reliability of the approach under consideration for such close pairs . given the image quality and the scales of the ccd frames and scans from the remaining surveys used , it can be concluded that the image asymmetry estimates are not enough to establish binarity . nevertheless , the asymmetry is highly informative for analysis , along with the f - test estimates . therefore , the final table with the results includes the mean values of the asymmetry based on all surveys ; the maximum values of the asymmetry based on the entire sample for a given star are provided with an indication of the corresponding survey ( table [ tab1 ] ) . curiously , the mean stellar image asymmetry is 0.039 for the sample of @xmath2 binaries and 0.025 for single stars . the parameters of binary systems from the wds catalog ( component separation , position angles , component magnitudes ) were included in the electronic versions of the tables with the results . for the @xmath2 binaries j0027 + 5330n , j0514 + 4431n , j0517 + 4550 , j1614 + 6038 , and j1938 + 3512e , the angular separations between their components lie within the range from fractions of an arcsecond to 4 . the star j1938 + 3512e enters into sdss and has an asymmetry of 0.086 , which is appreciably higher than its mean values for single stars of the same magnitude in this survey ( usually from 0 to 0.04 ) . these stars can be singled out as examples of the successful detection of nonlinear motion over the celestial sphere based on comparison of the quasi - mean and quasi - instantaneous proper motions . .fragments of the table for @xmath2-binary candidates [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] + + detailed information about these four stars is given in table [ tab2 ] . three of the four stars are characterized by large ( @xmath35 ) stellar image asymmetries obtained by analyzing the sdss ccd frames . the star j2330 + 4639 , which enters into wds as a comparatively wide pair ( the component separation is 21.4 arcsec ) , attracts our attention . for this star , the quasi - instantaneous and quasi - mean proper motions differ greatly at a very large asymmetry ( 0.244 ) . this can be explained as a consequence of the interaction of the images for two closely spaced stars , which could be responsible for the systematic error of the stellar coordinates in one of the present - day surveys . when analyzing this information , it should be kept in mind that in crowded stellar fields ( when tens of stars are observed on a small ( several arcmin ) area of the frame ) , the rapidly flying stars close to the sun can be very close to the background stars on the frames of individual surveys . therefore , the formation of interacting images is possible in a situation where a binary star is out of the question . however , this is rather difficult to check so far , because the surveys used have different limiting magnitudes . from 2008 to 2015 , we carried out astrometric observations of 1428 stars from the list of 1972 objects within the framework of the pulkovo program of research on stars with large proper motions . for 1308 of them , we downloaded the scans of palomar plates and the ccd frames from the 2mass , sdss , and wise digital sky surveys . as a result of our measurements of the common reference stars and once the coordinates have been corrected for the systematic errors , we obtained the proper motions of the program stars in the hcrf / ucac4 system at an accuracy level of 4 mas@xmath5yr@xmath6 . this material can be in demand after the appearance of the first gaia release to compare the proper motions and to quickly reveal binary stars . based on the analyzed material , we constructed the quasi - instantaneous and quasi - mean proper motions whose comparison revealed 121 stars with evidence for nonlinearity of their motion over the celestial sphere ( @xmath2 binaries ) . the consistency of the applied technique is partly confirmed by comparing the derived proper motions with the data of parallactic programs ( yale , mearth , and pulkovo ) and analyzing the asymmetry of stellar images on the ccd frames from the surveys used . differences between the optical and infrared positions of the photocenter calculated for the 2mass epoch are noticeable for a number of stars . our study of the positions of the revealed @xmath2-binary candidates on a color color diagram suggests that the stars j0656 + 3827 , j0838 + 3940 , j1229 + 5332 , and j2330 + 4639 may be m dwarf + white dwarf pairs . we wish to thank all the observers of the pulkovo normal astrograph who participated in implementing the observational program . our work was supported in part by program p-41 of the presidium of the russian academy of sciences ( `` transitional and explosive processes in astrophysics '' ) . we are grateful to i.v . samsonov and the `` intellect '' center for the access to the computer server that allowed us to download the data and to organize long - duration calculations . this study would not be possible without astronomical data from the vizier ( cds , strasbourg , france ) , sdss ( sloan digital sky survey ) , stsci mast ( mikulski archive for space telescopes ) , and irsa ( infrared science archive ) databases . we are grateful to the developers of these resources . in conclusion , we wish to thank the referee for a careful reading of the paper , helpful criticism , and a discussion of the results . cutri et al . ( r. m. cutri , m. f. skrutskie , s. van dyk , c. a. beichman , j. m. carpenter , t. chester , l. cambresy , t. evans , et al . ) , _ the irsa 2mass all - sky point source catalog _ , nasa / ipac infrared science archive ( 2003 ) . izmailov et al . ( i. s. izmailov , m. l. khovricheva , m. yu . khovrichev , o. v. kiyaeva , e. v. khrutskaya , l. g. romanenko , e. a. grosheva , k. l. maslennikov , and o. a. kalinichenko ) , astron . lett . * 36 * , 349 ( 2010 ) .

based on observations performed with the pulkovo normal astrograph in 2008 - 2015 and data from sky surveys ( dss , 2mass , sdss dr12 , wise ) , we have investigated the motions of 1308 stars with proper motions larger than @xmath0 down to magnitude 17 . the main idea of our search for binary stars based on this material is reduced to comparing the quasi - mean ( poss2-poss1 ; an epoch difference of @xmath150 yr ) and quasi - instantaneous ( 2mass , sdss , wise , pulkovo ; an epoch difference of @xmath110 yr ) proper motions . if the difference is statistically significant compared to the proper motion errors , then the object may be considered as a @xmath2-binary candidate . one hundred and twenty one stars from among those included in the observational program satisfy this requirement . additional confirmations of binarity for a number of stars have been obtained by comparing the calculated proper motions with the data from several programs of stellar trigonometric parallax determinations and by analyzing the asymmetry of stellar images on sky - survey ccd frames . analysis of the highly accurate sdss photometric data for four stars ( j0656 + 3827 , j0838 + 3940 , j1229 + 5332 , j2330 + 4639 ) allows us to reach a conclusion about the probability that these @xmath2 binaries are white dwarf + m dwarf pairs . + * pacs codes : * 97.10.wn 98.35.pr 97.80af + galactic solar neighborhoods , stars with large proper motions , astrometric binaries .

0704.1346

owing to proximity , the sun influences the earth s climate and environment . overwhelming evidence is building up that the solar cycle and related activity phenomena are correlated with the earth s global climate and temperature , the sea surface temperatures of the three ( atlantic , pacific and indian ) main ocean basins , the earth s albedo , the galactic cosmic ray flux that in turn is correlated with the earth s cloud cover and , indian monsoon rainfall ( hiremath and mandi 2004 and references there in ; georgieva _ et . _ 2005 ; hiremath 2006b ) . the transient parts of the solar activity such as the flares and the coronal mass ejections that are directed towards the earth create havoc in the earth s atmosphere by disrupting the global communication , reducing life time of the earth bound satellites and , keep in dark places of the earth that are at higher latitudes by breaking the electric power grids . owing to sun s immense influence of space weather effects on the earth s environment and climate , it is necessary to predict and know in advance different physical parameters such as amplitude and period of the future solar cycles . there are many predictions in the literature ( ohl 1966 ; feynman 1982 ; feynman and gu 1986 ; kane 1999 ; hathaway , wilson and reichmann 1999 ; badalyan , obrido and sykora 2001 ; duhau 2003 sello 2003 ; maris , poepscu and besliu 2003 ; euler and smith 2004 ; maris , poepscu and besliu 2004 ; kaftan 2004 ; echer _ et . _ 2004 ; gholipour _ et . al . , _ 2005 ; schatten 2005 ; li , gao and su 2005 ; svaalgaard , cliver and kamide 2005 ; chopra and dabas 2006 ; dikpati , toma and gilman 2006 ; du 2006 ; hathaway and wilson 2006 ; clilverd _ et . al . , _ 2006 ; tritakis and vasilis 2006 ; lantos 2006 ; lundstedt 2006 ; wang and sheeley 2006 ; choudhuri , chatterjee and jiang 2007 ; javaraiah 2007 ) on the previous and future 24th solar cycles and beyond . most of these studies mainly concentrate on prediction of the amplitude ( maximum sunspot number during a cycle ) . however , prediction of period ( length ) of a solar cycle is also very important parameter and the present study fills that gap . recently we modeled the solar activity cycle as a forced and damped harmonic oscillator that consists of both the sinusoidal and transient parts ( eqn 1 of hiremath 2006a ) . from the 22 cycles ( 1755 - 1996 ) sunspot data , the physical parameters ( amplitudes , frequencies , phases and decay factors ) of such a harmonic oscillator are determined . the constancy of the amplitudes and the frequencies of the sinusoidal part and a very small decay factor from the transient part suggests that the solar activity cycle mainly consists of persistent oscillatory part that might be compatible with long - period ( @xmath2 ) alfven oscillations . in the present study , with an _ autoregressive _ model and by using the physical parameters of 22 cycles , we predict the amplitudes and periods of future 16 solar cycles . thus prediction from this study can be considered as a _ physical and precursor _ method . a pth order _ autoregressive _ model relates a forecasted value @xmath3 of the time series @xmath4 $ ] , as a linear combination of @xmath5 past values @xmath6 , where the coefficients @xmath7 are calculated such that they minimize the uncorrelated random error terms , @xmath8 . the routine is available in idl software . important condition for using an _ autoregressive model _ is that the series must be _ stationary _ such that it s mean and standard deviation do not vary much with time . hence , one can not apply _ autoregressive model _ directly to the observed sunspot series as it consists of near sinusoidal trends whose amplitudes and the standard deviations entirely different for different solar cycles . on the other hand , the derived physical parameters of the forced and damped harmonic oscillator ( hiremath 2006a ) for all the 22 solar cycles are stationary and , hence in the following , we use an _ autoregressive _ model to predict the future 15 solar cycles . the solution of the forced and damped harmonic oscillator ( see the equation 1 of hirmath 2006a ) of the solar cycle consists of two parts : ( i ) the _ sinusoidal _ part that determines the amplitude and period of the solar cycle and , ( ii ) the _ transient _ part that dictates decay of the solar cycle from the maximum year and also determines bimodal structure of the sunspot cycle around the maximum years for some cycles . in the present study , we use physical parameters of the sinusoidal part only to predict amplitude and period of future cycles . using past 22 cycles physical parameters , we construct the next ( 23rd ) solar cycle and presented in fig 1 . except decaying part of the solar cycle , one can notice that the predicted curve exactly matches with the observed curve . with this encouragement and from an _ autoregressive _ model , the physical parameters of future 16 solar cycles are computed and reconstructed solar cycles are presented in fig 2 . for the coming cycles 24 - 38 , the results are summarized in table 1 . in table 1 , the first column represents the cycle number , the second column represents the year from minimum - minimum , the third column represents the period ( length ) of the solar cycle and , the last column represents the maximum sunspot number during a cycle . it is interesting to note that the amplitude of the cycle 24 is low compared to the amplitude of cycle 23 and is almost similar to average value computed from all of the predicted models ( @xmath9 ) . other interesting predictions are : ( i ) during the cycles 26 , 27 , 34 . 37 and 38 , the sun will experiences a very high solar activity , ( ii ) during cycle 31 ( 2087 - 2099 ad ) the sun will experiences a very low sunspot activity and , ( iii ) length of the solar cycles vary from 8.65 yrs for the cycle 33 to maximum of 13.07 yrs for cycle 25 . to conclude , the solar cycle is modeled as a forced and damped harmonic oscillator . from the previous 22 cycles sunspot data , the physical parameters such as the amplitudes , the frequencies and phases of such a harmonic oscillator are determined . the sinusoidal part of the forced and damped harmonic oscillator of previous solar cycles is considered for the prediction of future 16 cycles . with an _ autoregressive _ model and using previous 22 cycles parameters , coming 16 solar cycles are reconstructed from the predicted parameters . important results of this prediction are : the amplitude of coming solar cycle 24 will be smaller than the present cycle 23 and around 2087 - 2099 ad , the sun will experiences a very low sunspot activity . badalyan , o. g. , obrido , v. n & sykora , j. 2001 , solar physics , 199 , 421 chopra , p & dabas , r. s. 2006 , in the cospar proceedings , beijing choudhuri , a. r. , chatterjee , p & jiang , j. 2007 , astro - ph/0701527 clilverd , m. a. , clarke , e. , ulich , t. , rishberth , h & jarvis , m. j. , 2006 . space weather , vol 4 , s09005 dikpati , m. , toma , g. d & gilman , p. 2006 , geophys . lett . , 33 , l05102 du , z. l. 2006 , a&a , 457 , 309 duhau , s. 2003 , sol . phys . , 213 , 203 echer , e. , rigozo , n. r. , nordemann , d. j. r & vieira , i. e. a. 2004 , annales geophysicae , 22 , 2239 feynman , j. 1982 , jgr , 87 , 6153 feynman , j & gu , x. y. 1986 , rev . geophys . , 24 , 650 georgieva , k. , kiro , b. , javaraiah , j & krasteva , r. 2005 , planet . , 53 , 197 gholipour , a. , lucas , c. , arabi , b. n & shafiee , m. 2005 , solar . phys , 67 , 595 javaraiah , j. 2007 , mnras letters , doi : 10.1111/j.1745 - 3933.2007.00298.x hathaway , d. , wilson , r. m & reichmann , j. 1999 , jgr , 104 , 375 hathaway , d & wilson , r. m. 2006 , geophys . lett . , 33 , l18101 hiremath , k , m & mandi , p. i. 2004 , new astronomy , 9 , 651 hiremath , k. m. 2006a , a&a , 452 , 591 hiremath , k. m. 2006b , ilws workshop , goa , india , edts : gopalswamy , n and bhattacharya , a. , p. 178 kaftan , v. 2004 , in the proceedings of iau symp 223 , p. 111 kane , r. p. 1999 phys . , 189 , 217 lantos , s. 2006 , sol . , 236 , 399 lundstedt , h. 2006 , advance . res . , 38 , 862 mari , s. g. , popescu , m. d. , & besliu , d. 2003 , romanian . , 13 , 139 mari , s. g. , popescu , m. d. , & besliu , d. 2004 , in the proceedings of iau symp 233 li , k.j . , gao , p. x & su , t.w . 2005 , chin . j. astron . astrophys . , vol 5 , no 5 , 539 ohl , a. i. 1966 , sol . dannye , no . 12 , 84 sello , s. 2003 , a & a , 410 , 691 schatten , k. 2005 , geophys . res . let , 32 , l21106 svalgaard , l. , cliver , e. w & kamide , y. 2005 , geophysical . let , 32 , l001104 vasilis , t. , helen , m & george , g. 2006 , in the proceedings of aip conference , 848 , 154 wang , y. m & sheeley , jr , n. r. 2006 , nature phys , vol 2 , issue 6 , 367 rrrrrrrr 23 & 1996.00 - 2007.73 & 11.73 & 136@xmath114 + 24 & 2007.73 - 2017.07 & 9.34 & 110@xmath111 + 25 & 2017.07 - 2029.56 & 12.49 & 110@xmath111 + 26 & 2029.56 - 2041.50 & 11.94 & 157@xmath116 + 27 & 2041.50 - 2053.51 & 12.00 & 180@xmath118 + 28 & 2053.51 - 2064.30 & 10.80 & 140@xmath114 + 29 & 2064.30 - 2075.01 & 10.71 & 149@xmath115 + 30 & 2075.01 - 2086.79 & 11.78 & 118@xmath112 + 31 & 2086.79 - 2097.95 & 11.16 & 63@xmath16 + 32 & 2097.95 - 2108.84 & 10.89 & 108@xmath111 + 33 & 2108.84 - 2117.49 & 8.65 & 128@xmath113 + 34 & 2117.49 - 2126.92 & 9.43 & 170@xmath117 + 35 & 2126.92 - 2139.99 & 13.07 & 139@xmath114 + 36 & 2139.99 - 2151.74 & 11.75 & 159@xmath116 + 37 & 2151.74 - 2163.19 & 11.45 & 187@xmath119 + 38 & 2163.19 - 2175.48 & 12.29 & 187@xmath119 +

in the previous study ( hiremath 2006a ) , the solar cycle is modeled as a forced and damped harmonic oscillator and from all the 22 cycles ( 1755 - 1996 ) , long - term amplitudes , frequencies , phases and decay factor are obtained . using these physical parameters of the previous 22 solar cycles and by an _ autoregressive model _ , we predict the amplitude and period of the future fifteen solar cycles . predicted amplitude of the present solar cycle ( 23 ) matches very well with the observations . the period of the present cycle is found to be 11.73 years . with these encouraging results , we also predict the profiles of future 15 solar cycles . important predictions are : ( i ) the period and amplitude of the cycle 24 are 9.34 years and 110 ( @xmath0 ) , ( ii ) the period and amplitude of the cycle 25 are 12.49 years and 110 ( @xmath1 11 ) , ( iii ) during the cycles 26 ( 2030 - 2042 ad ) , 27 ( 2042 - 2054 ad ) , 34 ( 2118 - 2127 ad ) , 37 ( 2152 - 2163 ad ) and 38 ( 2163 - 2176 ad ) , the sun might experience a very high sunspot activity , ( iv ) the sun might also experience a very low ( around 60 ) sunspot activity during cycle 31 ( 2089 - 2100 ad ) and , ( v ) length of the solar cycles vary from 8.65 yrs for the cycle 33 to maximum of 13.07 yrs for the cycle 35 .

1612.06009

in general relativity , the vaidya solution @xcite is a nonstatic generalization of the schwarzschild geometry and has some unique features . it describes the geometry of unpolarized radiation , represented by a null fluid emerging from a spherically symmetric source @xcite . therefore , the vaidya metric may model back - reaction effects for evaporating black holes ( bhs ) . glass and krisch @xcite extended the vaidya geometry to include both a radiation fluid and a string fluid ( see also @xcite by same authors ) by allowing the mass to be a function of both retarded time and distance along the outgoing null geodesics . the collapse of the null fluid described by the vaidya solution in the flat minkowski space has been studied by dadhich and ghosh @xcite . they first obtained the analogue of the vaidya line - element on the brane for studying the collapse of the null fluid in a flat minkowski cavity on the brane , the back reaction of the bulk on the brane , favouring formation of a bh against naked singularity ( see also @xcite ) . the end state of collapse of the null radiation with a string fluid was considered by govinder and govender @xcite . they also investigated the collapse of ricci - flat metrics and showed that the presence of a string fluid could lead to the appearance of locally naked singularity for null fluids . mcclure et al . @xcite analyzed cosmological versions of vaidya s radiating stellar exterior . they found a two - fluid solution that consists of a null fluid and an imperfect fluid which contains an inhomogeneous dark energy ( de ) component with negative energy density for the spacetimes of an accelerating cosmological reference frame . baccetti et al . @xcite assumed an early onset of bh evaporation and investigated its consequences for the simple system of a collapsing uniform thin shell , with an outgoing vaidya metric outside @xcite and minkowski metric inside . they obtained the equation of motion of the collapsing shell by means of the junction conditions on metric and the extrinsic curvature . the bh evaporation in conformal gravity was studied by bambi et al . @xcite . since massless particles are naturally conformally invariant , the simplest model of gravitational collapse in conformal gravity is given by the collapse of a thin shell of radiation with vaidya s space outside the shell and conformally - flat inside . they chose the radiation stress tensor to be that of a null dust ( see @xcite , where the authors generalized the vaidya solution in de rham - gabadadze - tolley massive gravity . our motivation in this paper is too look for a null fluid with nonzero radial pressure as the source of the vaidya geometry . sec.2 introduces the imperfect fluid stress tensor and studies its structure and the kinematical properties of a timelike congruence of observers . in sec.3 one calculates the total energy flow through a @xmath6 surface and its relation with the brown - york energy @xmath7 . a modified regular form of the vaidya metric is introduced in sec.4 and its properties are investigated . the modified quasilocal energy @xmath7 is analyzed in sec.5 , both as a function of @xmath4 and as a function of mass @xmath8 of the object , a celestial body or a bh . we conclude with some general remarks in sec.6 . throughout the paper we use geometrical units @xmath9 , unless otherwise specified . vaidya @xcite solved einstein s equations for a spherically - symmetric radiative body with the stress tensor of radiation @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is a null vector directed radially and @xmath2 is defined as the energy density of radiation measured locally by an observer with 4-velocity field @xmath12 , so that @xmath13 @xcite . the line - element can be written as @xmath14 where @xmath15 , @xmath16 is schwarzschild time coordinate , @xmath17 is the tortoise coordinate and @xmath18 is the advanced ingoing time coordinate . the parameter @xmath5 is the mass of the radiating spherically - symmetric object and @xmath19 stands for the metric of the unit two - sphere . we consider only the region @xmath20 for ( 2.1 ) , to avoid the signature flip at the horizon . it is valid for both ordinary celestial objects and for bhs . the geometry ( 2.1 ) is generated by the energy - momentum tensor given above , with only one nonzero component @xmath21 and zero trace , where @xmath22 . in other words , it corresponds to a null fluid with no pressures , i.e. , a null dust . that interpretation originates from the fact that the tensor @xmath23 resembles the stress tensor for a perfect fluid @xmath24 when @xmath25 . we remind that li et al . @xcite have not specified what is the 4-velocity @xmath12 , namely , what are its components . we consider now a different interpretation of the source of the vaidya metric and take the energy - momentum tensor corresponding to an imperfect fluid with energy flux @xcite @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the radial pressure , @xmath28 are the transversal ( tangential ) pressures , @xmath29 is the energy flux 4-vector and @xmath30 is a unit spacelike vector orthogonal to @xmath12 . we have @xmath31 and @xmath32 . we look now for the expression of the quantities @xmath33 for ( 2.2 ) and ( 2.3 ) to represent the same stress tensor . let us take a velocity vector field of the form ( for simplicity we replaced @xmath5 with @xmath8 ) @xmath34 i.e. an observer sitting at @xmath6 from ( 2.5 ) and the properties of @xmath30 , we find that @xmath35 as we previously specified , the mixed stress tensor which generates ( 2.1 ) has only one nonzero component : @xmath21 . defining , as obvious , the energy density of the null fluid as @xmath36 , it is an easy task to obtain @xmath37 where @xmath38 has been used . keeping in mind that @xmath39 , the expression for @xmath28 results immediately from ( 2.4 ) : @xmath40 , so that the fluid has no tangential pressures . the trace of ( 2.4 ) yields @xmath41 whence @xmath42 . hence , the null fluid has a nonzero radial pressure . from here we find that the isotropic pressure is @xmath43 , as for incoherent radiation . the current is obtained from ( 2.4 ) as @xmath44 which gives us @xmath45 and @xmath46 , as it should be for a null fluid . having now the physical parameters entering ( 2.4 ) , we may compare @xmath47 from ( 2.4 ) with that from ( 2.2 ) , to obtain @xmath48 whence @xmath49 with the help of @xmath50 from ( 2.5 ) , we get the components of the acceleration 4-vector of the congruence @xmath51 the proper acceleration reads @xmath52 and the scalar expansion is given by @xmath53 let us discuss briefly the energy conditions fulfilled by the stress tensor ( 2.4 ) . we consider our source of the vaidya solution is better than the standard one , where the radial pressure does not appear . it is hidden by the null vector @xmath54 which in our interpretation is a difference between a timelike vector @xmath12 and a spacelike vector @xmath30 , orthogonal to @xmath12 . the standard interpretation as a null dust is introduced by a formal analogy with a perfect fluid with no pressures . we conjectured a general expression ( 2.4 ) of the source and imposed it to be traceless and to have one nonzero component only , i.e. @xmath55 , for to be in accordance with the standard solution . we have used the choice @xmath20 , otherwise @xmath18 becomes a spacelike coordinate . with @xmath3 ( we are working with ingoing radiation ) , @xmath56 ( @xmath57 is obtained when @xmath58 , namely in the static situation ) . in other words , the wec is obeyed . same is valid for the other energy conditions : nec , sec and dec . being null , the fluid observes the condition @xmath59 . it is worth noting that @xmath2 is divergent at the origin and at the evolutionary hypersurface @xmath60 ( the apparent horizon ) , because of the nonstatic character of the spacetime . , where @xmath61 is the areal radius . one obtains @xmath62 , or @xmath60 we could have also used the method from @xcite ( the vanishing of the scalar expansion on the null vector field along null geodesics ) . ] we shall see later how the divergence at @xmath63 could be removed . the currents @xmath64 and @xmath65 from ( 2.10 ) are inward directed because @xmath3 and are also divergent on the horizon . as far as the acceleration of the congruence is concerned , we notice that the invariant acceleration from ( 2.14 ) becomes the standard schwarzschild counterpart when @xmath58 . having now the components of the stress tensor and the basic physical quantities associated to it , our next task is to compute the total energy flow measured by an observer laying at @xmath6 @xcite @xmath66 where @xmath67 and @xmath68 are given by ( 2.5 ) and ( 2.6 ) , respectively . to find @xmath69 we remove the @xmath4-line and @xmath4- column in @xmath70 and obtain @xmath71 . with @xmath21 , eq . ( 3.1 ) yields @xmath72 where @xmath4 is fixed and @xmath8 is the variable of integration . one obtains @xmath73 with @xmath74 a constant of integration ( w.r.t . @xmath8 ) . it may be determined by imposing that @xmath75 when @xmath8 vanishes , so that @xmath76 . hence @xmath77 a plot of @xmath78 versus @xmath8 , at constant @xmath4 , is depicted in fig.1 . one notes that the derivative @xmath79 diverges at @xmath80 . ( 3.4 ) , taken as a function of @xmath4 , resembles the quasilocal energy ( qle ) for a schwarzschild bh @xcite . an observation is in order here : lundgren et al . plotted @xmath81 even for @xmath82 . however , we have to keep in mind that @xmath4 becomes timelike in that region and to cover both regions ( @xmath82 and @xmath83 ) in the same plot seems to be inappropriate . due to the square root from ( 3.4 ) , the derivative @xmath79 is infinite at the horizon , which is like the infinite value of @xmath84 from the lundgren et al . we also observe that the derivation of the qle @xmath85 by the authors of @xcite remains valid even when the mass of the object is time - dependent , as in our situation , because the expressions of the connection coefficients that we need are @xcite @xmath86 as in the static case . therefore , the extrinsic curvature of the two - boundary preserves its value . it is clear from ( 2.1 ) that we must impose @xmath87 since at @xmath60 a signature flip takes place and @xmath18 becomes a spacelike coordinate . in addition , being nonstatic , the metric ( 2.1 ) has no a timelike killing vector and so an event horizon can not be obtained . in that case an apparent horizon is more appropriate . to extend the metric ( 2.1 ) beyond the evolutionary surface @xmath60 we introduce an exponential factor in the metric , rendering the stress tensor regular at the origin therefore , we propose the geometry @xmath88 with @xmath89 . the above line - element may be obtained by a similar manner as that for ( 2.1 ) . we begin with the regularized schwarzschild spacetime @xcite @xmath90 and move to the eddington - finkelstein coordinates with @xmath91 that will give @xmath92 the above recipe works also when @xmath93 , even though @xmath94 can not be obtained explicitely as a function of @xmath4 and @xmath8 . we showed in @xcite that , for @xmath95 from ( 4.1 ) is nonnegative for any @xmath96 and vanishes at @xmath97 . we check now the positivity of @xmath98 for any @xmath99 , with @xmath6 . we have @xmath100 which is vanishing at @xmath101 and @xmath102 . therefore , @xmath103 is nonnegative for any positive @xmath8 . a plot of @xmath103 against @xmath8 , for constant @xmath4 is given in fig.2 in addition , @xmath103 tends to unity at @xmath104 and when @xmath105 . the dependence of @xmath103 on @xmath8 is similar with that of @xmath106 at constant @xmath8 @xcite . hence , @xmath107 , for any @xmath4 and @xmath8 . as far as the components of @xmath12 and @xmath30 in the geometry ( 4.1 ) is concerned , they will have the same structure as those from ( 2.5 ) and ( 2.6 ) , excepting the square root which is @xmath108 . we obtain now the following expressions for @xmath2 and @xmath27 , using same arguments as those from sec.2 @xmath109 and @xmath110 the transversal pressures are @xmath111 which does not depend on @xmath112 . the energy flux 4-vector has the nonzero components @xmath113 with @xmath114 one observes that the trace @xmath115 is always negative . therefore , we have no longer a null fluid but an anisotropic fluid with energy flux . in the static case ( @xmath58 ) , @xmath2 and @xmath27 acquire the corresponding values from @xcite , which are regular in the whole spacetime . compared to ( 2.7 ) , they are vanishing at the origin . the conclusion is that the exponential factor from the line - element ( 4.1 ) renders @xmath2 and @xmath27 finite only at the origin of coordinates , but not at the apparent horizon @xmath116 , due to the variable mass @xmath5 . in addition , the nonstatic character of the metric ( 4.1 ) leads to a nonvanishing scalar expansion of the congruence @xmath117 which diverges at @xmath116 , is negative for @xmath118 , positive for @xmath119 and vanishes when @xmath120 . to find the expression of the total energy @xmath7 crossing a surface of constant @xmath4 , we follow up the same prescription from the beginning of sec.3 . we obtain now @xmath121 and @xmath122 therefore @xmath123 which gives us @xmath124 we get finally @xmath125 where the same boundary conditions have been applied , as per ( 3.4 ) . it is worth noticing that @xmath78 seems to have the same mathematical structure as that from ( 3.4 ) , though the integrands were very different . that gives us the opportunity to consider the same physical meaning as in sec.3 : @xmath78 represents the brown - york energy enclosed by a @xmath6 hypersurface . let us first study the behaviour of @xmath7 from ( 5.5 ) w.r.t . @xmath4 , taking @xmath126 we observe that @xmath127 when @xmath128 , as expected , and is vanishing at @xmath63 . we might , of course , calculate @xmath81 directly , following the recipe from @xcite @xmath129 where @xmath130 and @xmath131 is the induced metric on the two boundary @xmath132 . @xmath133 in ( 5.6 ) is the trace of the extrinsic curvature of @xmath132 and @xmath134 corresponds to the vacuum ( i.e. , when @xmath104 ) . but the connection coefficients ( 3.5 ) are also valid for the spacetime ( 4.1 ) so that the expression ( 5.5 ) emerges . a more detailed investigation of the function @xmath81 needs the derivative @xmath135 . we look now for the extremal of @xmath81 , if any . from @xmath136 and after one squaring , we arrive at @xmath137 which is a transcendental equation . we show that ( 5.8 ) has a unique solution . a new variable @xmath138 yields @xmath139 one observes that the two curves ( the straight line from the r.h.s . and the exponential ) have the same tangent at @xmath140 where the two functions are equal . in conclusion , @xmath116 is the single solution of ( 5.8 ) . nevertheless , at @xmath141 is not extremal because the denominator is vanishing there . taking the limit of the derivative when @xmath142 , one obtains the value @xmath143 when @xmath118 and @xmath144 for @xmath119 . we see that , at the apparent horizon @xmath145 is , however , finite , contrary to its infinite value from@xcite ( see authors comments above their eq.18 ) . we have also @xmath146 . in fig.3 is depicted the qle in terms of @xmath4 , both inside and outside the horizon . let us take now a look at the function @xmath78 , at constant @xmath4 , given by ( 5.5 ) . one notes in passing that @xmath78 is undetermined as we do not have the expression of @xmath5 . our procedure gives no indication of how to determine it . as in the previous section , one must solve the equation @xmath147 , to find the extremal values of @xmath78 , if any . from ( 5.5 ) we have @xmath148 therefore , @xmath78 grows from zero at @xmath104 to @xmath4 at @xmath101 in the region @xmath149 and drops from @xmath4 to zero at infinity in the region @xmath150 , for a given @xmath4 . the derivative ( 5.10 ) is not defined at @xmath101 where both the numerator and denominator vanish . therefore , we have to compute the side limits at that point , which gives the values @xmath151 for @xmath149 and @xmath152 for @xmath150 . fig.4 shows the dependence of @xmath78 on @xmath8 . in other words , @xmath78 is not differentiable at @xmath101 but , nevertheless , both side limits are finite . in addition , there is an inflexion point at @xmath153 . consequently , @xmath78 is always positive , vanishes at @xmath104 and acquires its maximum value when our observer is located at the horizon . the properties of the vaidya solution of einstein s equations with a null fluid as source are investigated in this paper . in contrast with the standard vaidya solution , our fluid has a nonzero radial pressure , equal to the energy density . in our region of interest ( @xmath20),all energy conditions for the stress tensor are satisfied . due to vanishing tangential pressures , the equation of state of the fluid is @xmath0 , in agreement with that of null radiation . the total energy flow crossing a @xmath154 hypersurface turns out to represent the brown - york quasilocal energy . p. c. vaidya , proc . a33 , 264 ( 1951 ) . m. k. parikh and f. wilczek , phys . b449 , 24 ( 1999 ) . e. n. glass and j. p. krisch , phys . d57 , 5945 ( 1998 ) ( arxiv : gr - qc/9803040 ) . e. n. glass and j. p. krisch , class . quantum grav . 16 , 1175 ( 1999 ) ( arxiv : gr - qc/9901034 ) . n. dadhich and s. g. ghosh , phys . b518 , 1 ( 2001 ) ( arxiv : hep - th/0101019 ) . t. harko and m. j. lake , phys . d89 ( 2014 ) 064038 ( arxiv : 1312.1420 [ gr - qc ] ) . k. s. govinder and m. govender , phys . d68 ( 2003 ) 024034 ( arxiv : gr - qc/0302017 ) . m. l. mcclure , k anderson and k. bardahl , arxiv : 0709.3288 [ gr - qc ] . v. baccetti , v. husain and d. r. terno , entropy 19 , 17 ( 2017 ) ( arxiv : 1610.09834 [ gr - qc ] ) . p. c. vaidya , phys . 83 , 10 ( 1951 ) . c. bambi et al . , arxiv : 1611.05582 [ gr - qc ] . p. li , x .- z . li and x .- h . zhai , phys . d94 , 124022 ( 2016 ) ( arxiv : 1612.00543 [ gr - qc ] ) . p. c. vaidya , nature 171 , 260 ( 1953 ) . h. culetu , progr . ( 2016 ) , 123e02 ( arxiv : 1605.04467 [ gr - qc ] ) . a. p. lundgren , b. s. schmekel and j. w. york , jr . d75 ( 2007 ) 084026 ( arxiv : gr - qc/0610088 ) . a. b. nielsen , dong - han yeom , int . j. mod a24 : 5261 - 5285 ( 2009 ) . h. culetu , class . quantum grav.29 ( 2012 ) , 235021 ( arxiv : 1202.4296 [ gr - qc ] ) . h. culetu , phys . dark univ . 14 ( 2016 ) 1 - 3 ( arxiv : 1508.01102 [ gr - qc ] ) . h. culetu , int . j. mod . d24 ( 9 ) ( 2015 ) 1542001 . h. culetu , arxiv : 1305.5964 [ gr - qc ] .

a null fluid with radial pressure is proposed as the source generating vaidya spacetime . the fluid is anisotropic with no transversal pressures and @xmath0 as its equation of state , where @xmath1 is the isotropic pressure and @xmath2 is the energy density . the radial energy flux is inward directed when @xmath3 and the total energy flow crossing a surface of constant @xmath4 resembles the brown - york quasilocal energy . a modified vaidya metric removes the singularity at the origin and the corresponding qle is investigated in terms of both @xmath4 and the mass @xmath5 of the object . + * keywords * : radial pressure , apparent horizon , quasilocal energy , null fluid .

astro-ph9912528

a bipolar hyper - shell model has been proposed for the north polar spur ( nps ) ( sofue 1977 ) , in which the nps and its western and southern counter - spurs are interpreted as due to a dumbbell - shaped shock front induced by a giant explosive event at the galactic center . such an impulsive energy input may have been originated by a starburst 15 million years ago ( sofue 1984 , 1994 ) . an alternative mechanism to cause such giant shells in the halo would be a single energetic explosion at the galactic nucleus ( oort 1977 ) . giant shell structures could also be produced by a stellar - wind driven coherent galactic wind ( e.g. , heckman et al 1990 ) . since the cooling time in the halo is much longer than the shell s life time , any of these mechanisms will , however , result in a similar shocked shells in the halo , given the same amount of total energy . another alternative , traditional idea to explain the nps is the local - shell hypothesis , in which the nps is interpreted as due to a very unique supernovae remnant of the largest diameter in the galaxy ( berkhuijsen et al . 1971 ; egger 1993 ; egger and aschenbach 1995 ; and the literature cited therein ) . the propagation of a shock front in the galactic halo can be simulated by applying a shock - tracing method developed by sakashita ( 1971 ) and mllenhoff ( 1976 ) to a case of point explosion at a center of a disk surrounded by a halo and intergalactic uniform gas ( sofue 1984 ) . the galactic - center explosion hypothesis tries to explain the nps as well as the other spurs surrounding the galactic center region by a single galactic event , based not only on the morphology but also on a distance estimate of nps from soft - x ray extinction ( sofue 1994 ) . in the present paper , we revisit the galactic - center explosion hypothesis . we will extend the arguments given in sofue ( 1994 ) , which were based on the winsconsin x - ray experiments data ( mccammon et al 1983 ; mccammon and sanders 1990 ) . we will discuss the origin of the nps and related galactic spurs using the 408-mhz all - sky radio data ( haslam et al 1982 ) and the rosat x - ray images ( snowden et al 1997 ) . we simulate x - ray all - sky views based on the bhs ( bipolar hyper - shell ) model in order to morphologically reproduce the rosat all - sky views at various energy bands . we also discuss the implication of the bipolar hyper shell in dating and measuring the recent galactic starburst . we further propose to use the rosat all - sky data to probe the physics of gas in the galactic halo and intergalactic space of the local group . 1 we compare the radio and x - ray views of the whole sky in the @xmath2 coordinates in aitoff diagrams . 1a shows an enhanced view of galactic radio spurs obtained by applying a relieving technique ( sofue 1993 ) to the 408 mhz all - sky map ( haslam et al . 1b is the rosat all - sky map in the r45 ( @xmath30.75 kev ) band as reproduced from snowden et al ( 1997 ) . these figures demonstrates that the major galactic spurs both in radio and x - rays are found in the central @xmath4 region around the galactic center . the north polar spur ( nps ) and its western and southern counterparts compose giant @xmath5 shapes , drawing a dumbbell shape centered on the galactic center and necked at the galactic plane . fig . 2 shows a radio view in a 100 squared region around the galactic center . here , a relieving method to enhance the spurs has been applied in the direction of longitude ( left panel ) and in the radial direction ( right panel ) . the nps comprises a well - defined radio arc anchored to the galactic plane at @xmath6 , and draws a giant arc toward the north galactic pole . the radio brightness along the nps increases toward the galactic plane , attaining a maximum at @xmath7 . the width of the spur ( half - intensity length across ) decreases toward the galactic plane , and therefore , the nps ridge becomes sharper toward the galactic plane ( sofue and reich 1979 ) . 2 the nps draws a giant loop toward high latitudes , and returns to the galactic plane where it merges with a spur emerging from the galactic plane at @xmath8 . we call this western spur nps - west . a western half of loop iv , which is highly asymmetric and lacks the eastern half , makes a part of nps - west . the nps and nps - west , thus , compose a giant @xmath5 shape in the halo above the galactic center , with its axis roughly coinciding with the galactic rotation axis at @xmath9 . a southern counterpart of the nps is visible at @xmath10 , extending from @xmath11 toward @xmath12 , which we call the south polar spur ( sps ) . also , a western counterpart of sps is found at @xmath13 to @xmath14 , which we call sps - west . these four spurs , nps , nps - west , sps , and sps - west , are the most prominent features among the numerous galactic radio spurs . these four spurs compose a huge dumbbell - shape necked at the galactic plane and are about symmetric with respect to the galactic center . we comment that loop i , which has been defined as a complete loop of diameter 120centered on @xmath15 , is hard to trace in the present enhanced images ( fig . 1 , 2 ) . as shown in fig . 1b , the r45-band ( 0.75 kev ) x - ray intensity at @xmath16 has a global enhancement around the galactic center , which is due to the high - temperature gas in the galactic bulge ( mccammon et al 1983 ) . snowden et al ( 1997 ) have further noticed cylindrical features in the r45 and r67 ( 1.5 kev ) band maps , which emerge from the central galactic disk toward the halo . they also attribute these features to high - temperature gas around the galactic center . this fact indicates that the local hi disk is transparent at @xmath17 for x - rays at @xmath18 kev . a giant shell structure of the nps is clearly visible in the r45 and r67 bands . in fig . 3 we compare the radio and r45-band images of the nps . the western end of the x - ray nps also returns to the galactic plane at @xmath19 ( nps - west ) , and draws a giant @xmath5 together with the nps . southern counterparts to these features are also visible . particularly , the sps - west is clearly recognized in x - rays : an r45-band spur emerges from @xmath20 toward the southern galactic pole , which is symmetric to the nps about the galactic center . the sps is also visible at @xmath21 , though fainter in r45-band , while it is more clearly visible in an r45/r67-ratio map . these northern and southern x - ray spurs are associated with the radio spurs ( nps , nps - west , sps , and sps - west ) , and draw a dumbbell - shape necked at the galactic plane . we may , hence , interpret that snowden et al.s `` cylinder '' would comprise the nps , nps - west , sps and sps - west . the r12-band ( 0.25 kev ) x - ray emission from the nps is strongly absorbed below @xmath22 , and is hardly visible below 30 ( snowden et al 1997 ) . the nps shows up most clearly in the r45-band ( 0.75 kev ) , while the emission is significantly absorbed in the galactic disk at @xmath23 . r67-band ( 1.5 kev ) x - rays are also strongly absorbed near the galactic plane , indicating that the x - rays from the nps originates in the space further than the hi disk ( sofue 1994 ) . moreover , the x - rays become harder toward the galactic plane , as indicated by the clear decrease in the r45 to r67 intensity ratio toward the galactic plane . by comparing the r45 and r12-band intensities , we have shown that the hi mass toward @xmath24 to be @xmath25 h @xmath26 , which is greater than the observed value ( @xmath27 h @xmath28 ) . sofue ( 1994 ) has thus shown that the x - rays at @xmath29 originate _ beyond _ the hydrogen layer , and the distance is greater than 0.6 kpc . namely , the nps is an object which is located in the galactic halo . the distance to the nps has been subject to debates . we now know that it is beyond 0.6 kpc , which would allow us two possible interpretations : one possibility is that the nps is a local object at @xmath30 kpc , originating from supernova explosions at high altitude out of the galactic plane . another possibility is that it is a galactic - scale object related to the galactic center activity . we interpret the observed radio and x - ray features in terms of the galactic - center explosion hypothesis . our idea is based on the symmetric appearance of the radio and x - ray shells with respect to the galactic plane and the galactic center , which compose a huge dumbbell shape apparently centered on the galactic center ( gc ) . we , here , assume that the center of the dumbbell coincides with the gc , and take the distance to the gc to be 8 kpc . then , the radius of each shell is several kpc . our idea is also based on the fact that many spiral galaxies exhibit galactic - scale outflows in the forms of dumbbell - shaped shocks , bipolar cylinders , and galactic - scale jets , and we consider that the milky way galaxy would have experienced similar phenomena . ngc 253 exhibits a dumbbell - shaped shells in x - rays above and below the galactic plane , each about 5 kpc diameter ( vogler and pietsch 1999a ; pietsch et al 1999 ) , which would be a result of a starburst and related outflow ( heckmann et al . ngc 3079 exhibits a pair of radio continuum shells in the halo in both sides of the nucleus , each about 3 kpc diameter , which is considered to be an ejection from the central activity ( duric et al 1983 ) . it also exhibits an h@xmath31 cone - shaped shell of radius about 1 kpc , coaxial to the radio shells , most likely induced by an outburst from the nuclear region ( cecil 1999 ) . m82 is a starburst galaxy , which ejects a galactic - scale flow through bipolar cylindrical jets ( nakai et al 1987 ) . we emphasize that all these out - of - plane features , including the hyper shell in the milky way , require a similar amount of total energy input in the central regions of the galaxies , which is of the order of @xmath32 to @xmath33 ergs ( e.g. pietsch et al 1999 ) , or equivalent to @xmath34 to @xmath1 type ii supernovae . the propagation of a shock wave through the galactic halo induced by a point energy injection at a galactic center can be calculated by applying the shock envelope - tracing method of sakashita ( 1971 ) and mllenhoff . they have extended the laumbach and probstein s ( 1969 ) method for tracing the evolution of a shock front to a case of axi - symmetric distributions of ambient gas . the flow field is assumed to be locally radial , and the gas is adiabatic , and , therefore , the heat transfer by radiation and counter pressure are neglected . the density contrast between the shock front and ambient gas is given by @xmath35 for @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is the adiabatic exponent of the gas . for a typical density of @xmath38 h @xmath28 and temperature of @xmath39 k for the shock - heated halo gas , the cooling time due to the free - free thermal emission is approximately @xmath40 years . hence , the assumption of adiabatic gas is valid in our calculation , in which the shell s life time is estimated to be of the order of @xmath39 years , as shown below . the equation of motion of the shock wave is given by ( mllenhoff 1976 ) : @xmath41 here , @xmath42 is the total energy of the explosion , @xmath43 is the internal pressure , @xmath37 is the adiabatic exponent , which is assumed to be 5/3 hereafter , @xmath44 is the unperturbed ambient gas density , @xmath45 is the radius from the explosion center , with suffix 0 denoting the quantities of the unperturbed ambient gas , and @xmath46 is the radius of the shock front . assuming that the snow - plowed mass is strongly concentrated near the front , the above equation leads to equation to express the shock radius @xmath46 as follows ( sakashita 1971 ; mllenhoff 1976 ) : @xmath47 @xmath48.\ ] ] here , @xmath49_r,\ ] ] @xmath50 and @xmath51 the unperturbed density distribution of gas is assumed to comprise a stratified disk , a halo with an exponentially decreasing density , and intergalactic gas with uniform density . the hydrogen density in the galactic plane is taken to be 1 h @xmath28 in the solar vicinity . the gas distribution is approximated by the following expression . @xmath52 here , suffices 1 , 2 and 3 denote quantities for the disk , halo and intergalactic gas , respectively , @xmath53 is the density , @xmath54 is the height from the galactic plane , @xmath55 is the scale thickness of the disk and halo . here , @xmath56 , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 are @xmath59 , 0.01 , and @xmath60 h @xmath61 , and @xmath62 and @xmath63 are @xmath64 and 1 kpc , respectively . this model has been applied to the galactic center in order to fit the north polar spur ( sofue 1984 , 1994 ) . the dumbbell - shaped shell structure and the nps are well reproduced by a case in which the explosion energy is @xmath65 erg . 4 shows a calculated shock front at @xmath66 and 20 myr as reproduced from sofue ( 1984 ) . in this model , the expansion velocity of the shock front amounts to several hundred and the gas is heated up to @xmath39 k , emitting soft x rays observable in the rosat energy bands at @xmath67 , 0.75 and 1.5 kev . numerical simulations of smaller - scale outflows from the galactic plane have been obtained in hydrodynamic scheme ( e.g. , tomisaka and ikeuchi 1986 ) and in mhd ( magneto - hydrodynamic ) treatment ( e.g. , uchida et al 1985 ) . however , these simulations have been obtained only for smaller scale outflows with scales less than one kpc , so that they can not be applied to the present case with a much larger - scale shells expanding from the upper halo to the intergalactic space . fig . 4 we simulate radio and x - ray intensity distributions on the sky based on the bipolar hyper - shell model . in order to simulate the radio and x - ray emissivity in the bipolar - hyper shells , as calculated above , we approximate the shape of each half of the dumbbell - shaped shock by an ellipse . here , we calculate a case for a shell whose center is at @xmath68 kpc and the radii 6 and 9 kpc in the radial and vertical ( @xmath54 ) directions , respectively . the volume emissivity of synchrotron radiation is calculated from the density contrast of the shocked gas , in which magnetic fields and cosmic - ray electrons are considered to be compressed adiabatically with shock - compression of the halo gas , and the volume emissivity of synchrotron radio radiation is assumed to be proportional to @xmath69 with @xmath70 being approximately 4 , where @xmath53 and @xmath44 are gas densities in the shocked shell and unperturbed halo gas , respectively . in the present simulation , the profile of radio emissivity perpendicular to the shell surface is simply represented by an exponentially decreasing function behind the shock front toward the center with a scale thickness of 500 pc ( fig . the emissivity also decreases with the height from the galactic plane with a scale height of 3 kpc , corresponding to exponentially decreasing density of the halo gas . in addition to the hyper shell , we assume the existence of a galactic disk of scale height of 0.5 kpc and scale radius of 6 kpc , which is further embedded in a fatter disk with 3 and 8 kpc scale height and radius , respectively . the emissivity is , therefore , assumed to have the form expressed by @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the emissivity in the shell as described above ( fig . 4 ) , @xmath73 is a constant , @xmath74 and @xmath75 represents the disk and fat components , respectively , @xmath76 kpc , @xmath77 kpc , @xmath78 kpc , and @xmath79 kpc . no extinction in the radio band is assumed throughout the galactic disk and halo . in fig . 5a we show the radio continuum result , and compare with the observed 408 mhz all - sky map ( fig . the global radio distribution is well reproduced by the model , and the nps is reproduced as a radio ridge emanating from the galactic disk . fig . 5 we further simulate a case in which the disk component comprises logarithmic spiral arms , as illustrated in fig . the radio continuum emissivity is assumed to have a form @xmath80 here , @xmath81 is the galacto - centric azimuthal angle , @xmath82 is the inverse of the pitch angle of spiral arms , @xmath83 with @xmath84 , @xmath85 is a correction factor to fix the total luminosity to be the same as that when no spiral arms are assumed , and @xmath86 is introduced to mimic a narrow condensation of the emissivity in the arms . the simulated result is shown in fig . in addition to the spurs due to the hyper shells as in fig . 5a , there appear many spurs extending toward high latitudes in both sides of the galactic plane . these spurs are tangential views of bank - shaped spiral arms which are extending into the halo . it is interesting to note that the tangential directions of the local spiral arms coincide with the western half of loop i , loop ii and iii , which was already pointed out earlier ( sofue 1976 ) . simulated inner - arm spurs are also found to reproduce many observed inner radio spurs , while their exact positional coincidence is out of the present simplified spiral arm model . fig . 6 x - ray emission from the hyper shells is assumed to be thermal free - free radiation , whose emissivity is given by @xmath87 here , @xmath88 is the cooling function of the gas . since the temperature is as high as @xmath89 k in our simulation , the radiation is almost totally free - free , and the contribution by recombination lines from hydrogen , helium , and metals , which are significant at @xmath90 k , are not significant . for a typical density and temperature of about @xmath38 h @xmath28 and @xmath39 k , respectively , the value of @xmath88 is @xmath91 erg @xmath92 s@xmath93 , and the emissivity is approximately @xmath94 erg @xmath28 s@xmath93 . a typical emission measure along the hyper shell ridge is @xmath95 @xmath96pc for a tangential pass in the shell of about 2 kpc . for simplicity , we assume that the temperature of x - ray emitting gas is constant in the shocked shell . the assumption of constant temperature may not be a good approximation for lower latitude regions , where the propagation velocity is lower than that of the upper part , and , therefore , the temperature is lower . however , the low - latitude regions are strongly absorbed by the hi gas layer , and such temperature gradient in the shell would not much improve the accuracy of the present simulation . in addition to the hyper shells , we assume a galactic ridge x - ray component of scale height of 500 pc , and a bulge component of scale radius 1 kpc . emission from ambient halo gas is neglected , because the temperature and density will not be sufficiently high to emit x - rays in the present energy bands . the x - ray intensity , @xmath97 , is calculated by a transfer equation given by @xmath98 where the first term in the right - hand side is the emission measure with @xmath99 being the x - ray emissivity , and the second term represents the absorption rate with @xmath100 being absorption coefficient , and @xmath101 is the distance along the line - of - sight . the interstellar extinction of soft x rays occurs due to photoelectric absorption by metals , and has been calculated for the solar metal abundance by morrison and mccammon ( 1983 ) . the energy dependence of the cross section per h atoms can be approximated by @xmath102 ( ryter 1996 ) in the present energy bands , where @xmath42 is the photon energy of x rays . the absorption coefficient @xmath100 is , then , approximately represented by @xmath103 where @xmath104 is the number density of hydrogen atoms , and @xmath105 is the @xmath106-folding column density of interstellar neutral hydrogen at the photon energy @xmath107 . at @xmath108 kev , the cross section is @xmath109 @xmath110 per h atom , which yields an @xmath106-folding column density of @xmath111 h atoms . according to the transmission diagram of snowden et al ( 1997 ) , the @xmath106-folding column density for r45 band x - rays ( @xmath108 kev ) is also read as @xmath112 h @xmath26 . we adopt this value for the r45 band ( 0.75 kev ) . however , the rosat energy bands are rather broad , containing significantly higher and lower energies around the representative energies . in our simulation , therefore , we adopt three representative cross sections at r12 , r45 and r67 bands , which are 10 , 1 and 0.1 times the value at 0.75 kev , respectively . the neutral hydrogen layer is assumed to have a density distribution expressed by @xmath113 where @xmath114 is the mean density in the solar vicinity , and is taken to be @xmath115 h @xmath28 , @xmath116 kpc is the scale radius of the gas disk , and @xmath117 pc is the scale height . 7a shows the calculated intrinsic intensity distribution , where no galactic absorption is taken into account . 7b is a result calculated for r45-band x - rays , which suffer from absorption by the galactic atomic hydrogen layer . the observed absorption features near the galactic plane is well reproduced by this model . the hyper shells are observed as a set of double - horn features extending toward the galactic poles , composing dumbbell - shaped ridges , and mimic the observed x - ray spurs ( nps , nps - west , sps and sps - west ) . 7c shows a case in which the hyper shells are replaced by bipolar parabolic cones , which are open toward the polar axes as illustrated in fig . 4c . the conical cylinder model appears , however , worse in order to reproduce the observed round shape of the north polar spur in radio and x - rays . in both cases of hyper shells and conical cylinders , the observed cylindrical spurs at lower latitudes in x - rays ( snowden et al 1997 ) are well reproduced . the bulge component is also visible in the models , as the two enhanced regions above and below the galactic center . fig . 7 fig . 8b shows results for a case in which the absorbing hydrogen gas is assumed to be condensed in logarithmic spiral arms of pitch angle 6@xmath118 and the arm width is taken to be 1/5 of the arm separation , as illustrated in fig . hence , the peak hydrogen density in the local arm is about 5 h @xmath28 . the hydrogen density distribution is expressed by @xmath119 here , @xmath81 and @xmath82 have the same meaning as above . since the tangential directions of the spiral arms are asymmetric around the galactic center , the absorption feature near to the galactic plane is also asymmetric . in order to examine how the x - ray sky looks like in different energy bands , we have performed simulations for different values of the absorption coefficient . 8 shows the calculated results for three different @xmath100 values : ( a ) ten times the above value , ( b ) as above , and ( c ) one tenth . 8a , b , and c , therefore , roughly correspond to x - ray views in the r12 , r45 , and r67 bands , respectively . in fig . 8 , we compare the simulated results with the corresponding rosat images . the r12-band model is characterized by a wide absorption lane along the galactic plane , where x - rays from the galactic plane and bulge are almost totally absorbed . the hyper shells also suffer from strong absorption , while high - latitude parts are still visible as the northern and southern `` polar - caps '' , which are indeed observed in the rosat r12-band image . we also obtain a good reproduction of the observed rosat x - ray features in r45 and r67 bands , as discussed in the previous subsections . we have revisited the hyper - shell model of radio and x - ray spurs around the galactic center , and simulated the all - sky view of radio and x - ray emissions . the model can mimic the observed all - sky views fairly well in radio ( haslam et al 1982 ) and rosat x - rays ( snowden et al 1997 ) , as shown in fig . 5 , 7 and 8 . the simulation could reproduce the following characteristic properties for the galactic spurs : \(1 ) the major spurs in the whole sky are found around the galactic center at @xmath120 ( nps , nps - west , sps , and sps - west ) . \(2 ) these four spurs are located apparently symmetric with respect to the rotation axis of the galaxy as well as to the galactic plane . \(3 ) southern x - ray spurs exhibit cylindrical appearance . \(4 ) x - ray spurs in r45 ( 0.75 kev)- and r67 ( 1.5 kev ) bands exhibit a sharp absorption lane along the galactic plane . \(5 ) r12-band ( 0.25 kev ) spurs comprise northern and southern polar caps at high latitudes , @xmath121 , while lower - latitude emission is hardly visible due to broad and strong absorption lane in the local galactic plane . \(6 ) an x - ray bulge is visible above and below the galactic center in r45 and r67 bands . \(7 ) besides the bhs - related spurs , a more number of radio continuum spurs are observed in the tangential directions of the inner and local spiral arms , with the most prominent spiral - arm spurs emerging at @xmath122 and @xmath123 corresponding to the local arm . in our model , the energy injection at the galactic center has been assumed to be impulsive , and the shock is strong enough to create a well - defined shell structure . the time scale of the explosive event at the galactic center is assumed to be sufficiently shorter than the expanding time scale of the hyper shell . since the expanding time scale is of the order of @xmath124 years for @xmath125several kpc and @xmath126300 , the explosion time scale should be shorter than a few million years . the required total energy given to the interstellar gas is of the order of @xmath127 ergs in order to heat the gas up to @xmath128 k at the bhs front . such impulsiveness and robustness of the energy release can be explained if the galactic center has experienced a starburst about 15 million years ago , lasting for a few million years or shorter , during which @xmath129 type ii supernovae exploded . if this starburst model is correct , the rosat all - sky data can be used to directly date and measure the energy of the recent starburst in our galaxy . by an mhd wave approximation of a blast wave from the galactic center we have shown that a significant fraction of low - latitude front focuses on the galactic plane , with the gas - flow paths being diffracted due to velocity gradient , which leads to an expanding gaseous ring in the disk ( sofue 1977 ) . the tangential directions of this expanding ring in the present model , which coincide with the bhs dumbbell s neck , are at @xmath130 . in fact , the root of the observed radio nps crosses the galactic plane also at @xmath130 ( sofue and reich 1979 ) . it is interesting to point out that there is an expanding feature in the hi line emission in coincidence with this tangential direction of the hyper shell , known as the `` 3 kpc ( 2.4 kpc ) expanding ring '' of hi gas ( oort 1977 ) . since the expanding velocity of the hyper shell in the disk region is significantly decelerated , the ring will not not be heated up to emit x rays , and , therefore , the ring may not be detectable in x - rays at this low latitude . the milky way is also known to have another gaseous ring in the disk , the `` 4-kpc molecular ring '' , with high density concentration of molecular and hi gases . although there is a suggestion about its origin as due to a resonance in a barred potential ( nakai 1992 ) , it may also be possible to explain such a larger - radius ring by focusing of an older expanding blast wave induced by an earlier starburst recurrently occurring in the galactic center . we may consider some alternative mechanisms to cause an impulsive energy release in the galactic center region . one possibility is a single gigantic explosion at the galactic nucleus ( oort 1977 ) , possibly caused by an infall of a star or its debris into the central massive black hole ( genzel et al 1997 ; ghez et al 1998 ) . a stellar - wind driven galactic wind ( heckman et al 1990 ) could also produce a shell structure , as observed with rosat for ngc 253 ( pietsch et al 1999 ) . however , if the wind is steady and longer - lived than 15 million years , the flow would have become already open - cone shaped , which does not appear to fit the observations . another possible mechanism is a `` meteorite - like impact '' by infalling gas clouds from intergalactic space onto the galactic gas disk , such as debris of the magellanic clouds after three - body dynamical interaction of the galaxies and the clouds . if several giant molecular clouds hit the gas disk at about the escaping velocity , @xmath131 , and the kinetic energy is converted into heat , the impact will be equivalent to an explosion of energy of @xmath132 ergs . since the cooling time of the hyper shell , which is of the order of @xmath133 years , is much longer than the expansion time scale , any of these mechanisms will result in a similar shocked shells in the halo , if the total input energy is approximately the same . although we have proposed a unified model to explain the galactic spurs in terms of a single event at the galactic center , we can not exclude the possibility that local objects such as nearby supernova remnants are superposed ( snowden et al 1997 ) . if we stand on the local - shell model , the sharp absorption lane along the galactic plane in r45 and r67 bands must be explained by an intrinsic depression of intensity below @xmath134 . we have in fact simulated intensity distributions in soft x - ray bands as expected from a local uniform shell of diameter 300 pc at a distance of 200 pc embedded in a hydrogen layer of a scale height 100 pc and local density 1 h @xmath28 . in r45 and r67 bands , no sharp absorption feature at @xmath135 was obtained by the simulation because of the negligible extinction for its proximity . the absorption feature can be reproduced , only if the shell is not a unique emission source , but it is superposed by a more distant emission such as from the galactic bulge ( snowden et al 1997 ) . in r12 band , the local - shell model could mimic the observation , similarly to the hyper - shell model , because the distance does not affect the simulated results , since the absorption feature is produced very locally : regardless its distance , half the shell at high latitudes is visible in r12 band , while the lower half at @xmath136 is absorbed by the local hydrogen layer . a traditional idea to explain the nps is the local supernova hypothesis , which attributes the spur to a nearby shell of supernova remnant(s ) of the largest diameter in the galaxy , called loop i ( e.g. , berkhuijsen et al 1971 ; egger and aschenbach 1995 ) . the shell is the oldest supernovae remnant , and therefore , the probability to detect similar objects , if there exist any in the galaxy , is much higher than that to find usual supernova remnants , almost two hundred of which are already discovered . since the nps is sufficiently bright in synchrotron radio emission , with the typical brightness bing @xmath137 k at 408 mhz , and is apparantely very large , such shells should have been easily detected , if it existed anywhere in the galaxy . in this sense , the nps is a very unique ( peculiar ) object , if we stand on the local supernova hypothesis . note that loops ii and iii , whose brightness temperatures are at most about 4 k at 408 mhz , are an order of magnitude less luminous than nps . note also that the major parts of loops ii and iii can be explained by local arm spurs in the present model ( fig . 5 ; see also sofue 1976 ) . if the bipolar - hyper shell model applies , the all - sky rosat x - ray and radio data can be used not only to measure the starburst , but also to probe the physics such as the density distribution and magnetic fields in the galactic halo as well as those in the interface from the halo to intergalactic space . the morphology of the hyper shell is sensitive to the density distribution in the halo , and particularly , the shell shape in the uppermost part manifests the halo - intergalactic density structure ( sofue 1984 ) . if the intergalactic gas density is very low , the shell will become more open and conical , while if it is higher , the shell becomes more compact and round . the shell morphology , and therefore the density structure , is also dependent on the expanding velocity , which is directly related to the gaseous temperature inferred from soft x - ray spectra . more detailed hydrodynamical simulations with quantitative and morphological fitting to the rosat data would provide us with much advanced knowledge about the galactic halo and intergalactic space in the local group . the observed nps and its southern counter spurs are asymmetric in morphology and intensities with respect to the galactic plane as well as to the rotation axis of the galaxy . such asymmetry can be attributed to anisotropy in the halo and intergalactic space . intergalactic wind , or equivalently , motion of the galaxy in the local group , may also cause an asymmetry of the hyper shell . hence , the morphological appearance of the hyper shell may be also used to probe the anisotropy and winds in the halo and intergalactic space . we have not taken into account the local fluctuation of hydrogen gas and molecular clouds , which also cause asymmetry in the x - ray absorption appearance . in fact the galactic layer is full of clouds , hi spurs , shells , and holes ( hartmann and burton 1997 ) . the hydra spur of hi gas is a dense , leaned spur emanating from the galactic disk at @xmath138 toward @xmath139 , crossing the nps root nearly perpendicularly , which would affect the absorption feature of the nps . a more sophisticated modeling of the x - ray views and detailed comparison with the rosat survey is subject for future simulations . as described in section 3.1 , many spiral galaxies exhibit similar hyper shells in their halos ( sofue 1984 ) : ngc 253 dumbbell - shaped shells ( vogler and pietsch 1999a ; pietsch et al 1999 ) , ngc 3079 s shells in radio continuum , h@xmath31 and x - rays ( duric et al 1983 ; pietsch et al 1998 ; cecil 1999 ) . m82 s bipolar cylindrical jets ( nakai et al 1987 ) . ngc 4258 s anomalous arms could also be due to some out - of - plane partial shells ( van albada and van der hulst 1982 ; vogler and pietsch 1999b ) . we stress that these out - of - plane features , including our hyper shell in the milky way , require a similar amount of total energy of the order of @xmath140 , or @xmath34 to @xmath1 type ii supernovae . this fact suggest that the bhs starburst model would be more general to model the extragalactic cases . simulations of rosat x - ray features in these objects based on our model , which is in preparation , would provide us with a clue to date and measure the responsible explosive events at their centers , such as their starburst history as well as information about the gas dynamics in their halo - intergalactic interface . such simulations would also give a clue to compare the halo - intergalactic gas physic and starbursts in external galaxies with those in our milky way . we have revisited the bhs model of the north polar spur and related galactic structures based on the 408-mhz radio continuum and rosat all - sky soft x - ray data . we have shown that the nps and its western and southern counter - spurs draw a giant dumbbell - shape on the sky necked at the galactic plane . the morphology and soft x - ray intensities of the spurs can be interpreted as due to a shock front originating from a starburst at the galactic center some 15 million years ago with a total energy of the order of @xmath0 ergs or @xmath1 type ii supernovae . we have simulated radio continuum and soft x - ray skies based on the bhs galactic center starburst model . simulated all - sky distributions of radio continuum intensities can well reproduce the radio nps and related spurs , as well as many other radio spurs in the tangential directions of spiral arms . simulated soft x - ray maps in 0.75 and 1.5 kev bands can reproduce the rosat x - ray nps , its western and southern counter - spurs , as well as the absorption layer along the galactic plane . the observed r12 band polar - cap features are also well reproduced in our model . if the present bhs model for the spurs is correct , we may be able to use the rosat all - sky maps to probe the gas dynamics in the halo - intergalactic interface . we may also be able to directly date and measure the energy of a recent galactic center starburst in the milky way , which can also be compared with similar bhs phenomena in nearby starburst galaxies . acknowledgement : the author would like to thank the rosat experiment staff for making the fits formatted data of the x - ray survey available via an internet link to `` skyview '' operated by nasa . the author is indebted to the anonymous referee for the invaluable comments and suggestions , with which the paper has been very much improved . berkhuijsen , e. , haslam , c. and salter , c. 1971 aa 14 , 252 . fig . 1 : ( a ) top : enhanced view of galactic spurs in the 408-mhz radio continuum , as obtained by applying a relieving method to the bonn - parkes all - sky survey in the galactic coordinates ( haslam et al 1982 ) . major features discussed in the text are indicated by arrows . the galactic center is at the map center , and the longitude increases toward the left with the both side edges being at @xmath141 . the galactic north pole is to the top , and south pole at the bottom . fig . 2 : 408 mhz radio map in a @xmath142 square region around the galactic center . a relieving method has been applied in the direction of longitude ( left panel ) and radial direction ( right panel ) . symmetric sets of spurs emerging from @xmath143 and @xmath144 are recognized , which labeled as nps , nps - west , sps and sps - west ( see the text ) . \(c ) observed 408 mhz all - sky map in gray scale ( haslam et al 1982 ) . thick arrows indicate the bipolar hyper shell . thin arrows indicate the tangential directions of the local and inner spiral arms , where radio spurs are emerging from the disk toward the halo . fig . 8 : simulated all - sky x - ray views in r12 , r45 and r67 bands ( left ) compared with the corresponding rosat sky views ( right ) . the absorbing hydrogen layer is assumed to comprise logarithmic spiral arms as in fig . the polar caps in 0.25 kev band , dumbbell - shaped morphology in 0.75 and 1.5 kev bands with the absorption features along the galactic plane are well reproduced by the bhs model calculations

using the all - sky rosat soft x - ray and 408-mhz radio continuum data , we show that the north polar spur and its western and southern counter - spurs draw a giant dumbbell - shape necked at the galactic plane . we interpret these features as due to a shock front originating from a starburst 15 million years ago with a total energy of the order of @xmath0 ergs or @xmath1 type ii supernovae . we simulate all - sky distributions of radio continuum and soft x - ray intensities based on the bipolar - hyper - shell galactic center starburst model . the simulations can well reproduce the radio nps and related spurs , as well as radio spurs in the tangential directions of spiral arms . simulated x - ray maps in 0.25 , 0.75 and 1.5 kev bands reproduce the rosat x - ray nps , its western and southern counter - spurs , and the absorption layer along the galactic plane . we propose to use the rosat all - sky maps to probe the physics of gas in the halo - intergalactic interface , and to directly date and measure the energy of a recent galactic center starburst . v = -5 mm = -1 cm = -5 mm

astro-ph0405248

rapid stellar evolution is generally accompanied by intense mass loss phenomena . during both the pre - main - sequence ( richer et al . 2000 ) and the post - main - sequence evolution ( sahai 2002 ) , there are phases during which the mass loss has a distinctly non - spherically symmetric distribution . the overall geometry is often best described as hourglass - shaped or wide - bipolar , although in several cases the flows can take the form of narrow jets . actually , the observation of bipolar jets is not limited to stellar outflows but these are also commonly observed in active galactic nuclei ( agn ) . in fact , pictorial models of protostars and agn are indistiguishable , where the salient features include a central object , surrounded by an active accretion disk and a perpendicularly directed bipolar jet ( blandford & payne 1982 ) . these morphological similarities could suggest the same physics ( momentum re - distribution ) to operate , over a wide range of physical scales , and could provide a connection between stellar and extragalactic astrophysics . this familarity is further illustrated by the fact that chandra and xmm - newton recently have detected the flows from pre - main - sequence objects in ( likely thermal ) x - rays ( pravdo et al . 2001 , favata et al . 2002 ) . this carries the study of these flow phenomena also into the traditionally home domain of agn , i.e. that of high energy astrophysics . although many of the details remain uncertain , there is little doubt that the energy is ultimately extracted from the gravitational and magnetic fields of the source . the understanding of outflow phenomena is thus intimately related to the understanding of the overall energy and momentum budget of the star / galaxy formation process and implies , as such , more general ramifications . extragalactic and post - main - sequence stellar outflows , as well as circumstellar disks and high - mass star forming regions , are addressed elsewhere in these proceedings . here , we shall focus on outflows from low - mass objects in their early stages of pre - main - sequence evolution . although stellar rotation is most likely controlled by local processes , as observationally indicated by the randomly oriented rotation axes , even galactic differential rotation alone would suffice to result in break - up of the contracting protostars , unless their angular momentum would be redistributed with high efficiency . viscous disk accretion is commonly invoked to accomplish this , through disk locking or a stellar wind ( rebull , wolff & strom 2004 ; matt & pudritz 2004 ) . however , the observational evidence appears only partially supportive for this widely accepted scenario and a convincingly strong relationship between stellar rotation and the presence of protostellar disks in young low - mass pre - main - sequence stars has yet to be established ( mathieu 2003 ) . the presence of accretion disks is generally also required as a pre - requisite for theoretical models of outflows . recently , models have been developed which simultaneoulsly address the physics of both gravitational collapse and the origin of outflows ( see , e.g. , tomisaka 2002 and references therein ) . these models take also rotation and magnetic fields explicitly into account , needed for the angular momemtum transport in the viscous accretion disks ( balbus & hawley 1991 , stone et al . 2000 ) or off the disks ( knigl & pudritz 2000 , shu et al . 2000 ) . according to contopoulos & sauty ( 2001 ) , the removal of angular momentum could in certain circumstances become extremely efficient , viz . expressable in terms of the ratio of the mass loss to the mass accretion rate , _ m_@xmath1/_m_@xmath2 . recent reviews on this and related topics are by reipurth & bally ( 2001 ) and those collected in the volume of protostars & planets iv , including those by eislffel et al . ( 2000 ) , hartigan et al . ( 2000 ) , knigl & pudritz ( 2000 ) , richer et al . ( 2000 ) and by shu et al . ( 2000 ) . to summarise shortly , a generalised theory of hh / jet and molecular flows has to account for at least the following observed properties : _ length scales _ of @xmath3pc to a few parsec , _ opening angles _ of @xmath4 to @xmath5 , _ space velocities _ of some kms@xmath6 to several @xmath7kms@xmath6 , _ gas kinetic temperatures _ of @xmath8k to a @xmath9k . further , based on the assumption of momentum conservation , derived mass loss rates scale with the radiative luminosity of the central source(s ) , i.e. _ m_@xmath10 , where @xmath11 to 1 . in regions of low mass star formation , observed ( line of sight ) magnetic field strengths are generally less than @xmath12 g on the arcminute scale ( crutcher et al . 1993 ; crutcher & troland 2000 ) . it should be realised that only a few of the above parameters have been determined with sufficiently high accuracy . in addition , time dependent effects can not be ignored as several flows show evidence for time variablity . observed outflows display a wide range of effective collimation and a dichotomy of theoretical models for the driving of outflows has emerged , which differentiates between wide - angle winds ( shu et al . 1991 , 2000 ) and collimated jets ( stahler 1994 ) . in the former case , a stellar wind or a wind from the disk surface is transferring momentum to the surrounding molecular material , whereas in the latter case , molecular outflows are thought to be molecular material entrained through a turbulent layer of a stellar jet / herbig - haro flow . hh - flows are often observed to be spatially associated with molecular outflows . observations with the iso - lws have provided convincing evidence that hh - flows and molecular outflows have a common physical cause ( liseau et al . 1997 ; saraceno et al . 1998 ) . all model families tend to reproduce observed outflow properties , such as the mass - velocity relation , @xmath13 with @xmath14 , and the ` hubble law ' , @xmath15 with @xmath16 . recent supporting arguments for the wide - angle wind hypothesis have been provided by matzner & mckee ( 1999 ) and by gardiner , frank & hartmann ( 2003 ) . however , questions regarding the launching and collimation are left open . downes & cabrit ( 2003 ) argue in favour of the jet - driving hypothesis , but their main results seem not very different from those of the wind - driven models by lee et al . ( 2000 ) . as discussed by ray ( 2000 ; see also : cabrit , raga & gueth 1997 ) , both model categories have their strengths - but also their weaknesses . the respective shortcomings might be overcome , if the possibility of temporal evolution of the outflows is considered , where initially highly collimated molecular ` jet - flows ' evolve into increasingly less collimated outflows as they age . the , by far , most outstanding problem concerns the origin of the outflows . to gain further insight , direct observation of the regions of acceleration would most likely be required . mhd models make detailed predictions of where this should happen and what the angular velocity of the rotating flow should be ( bacciotti et al . 2002 ; presenti et al . the relevant scale is set by the alfvn radius , the physical size of which depends on the details of the favoured model . but somewhat losely , one may distinguish x - winds , which are generated within only a few @xmath17 ( @xmath18au ) of the central source , and disk winds , which are launched within a fraction of an au to some au . at the typical distance of outflows in low mass star formation regions of some @xmath19pc , acceleration regions are thus expected to subtend angles of less than a milliarcsec to a few tens of milliarcsec . a related issue is that of the mechanism of initial flow collimation , occuring over similarly small spatial scales , whether mhd or not . of great relevance to the physics of star formation is of course the evolutionary status of the central driving source , be it single be it binary / multiple , the latter seemingly more likely ( m.barsony , private communication ) . age estimates of outflow engines range from only a few thousand to about a million years . one of the key questions is to what extent the properties of observed flows , showing great diversity , can be directly linked to the pre - main - sequence age of their driving sources . in particular , one would wish to establish the value and the time dependence of the ` @xmath20-factor ' on an observationally firm basis . this factor , defined as _ m_@xmath1=@xmath21_m_@xmath22 , is a measure of the relative importance of mass inflow and mass outflow for an individual source . mhd models concur with a value of @xmath23 . in order to understand the underlying physics of the outflows at their root , it is thus important to learn , whether time evolution alters this ` constant ' in a systematic way . an item of great importance regards the understanding of the stability of interstellar clouds against their self - gravity , i.e. cloud lifetimes are many times longer than their free - fall time scales . observed cloud ` turbulence ' is generally believed to accomplish this , although the energy source , injecting and maintaining the turbulent motions , has yet to be uniquely identified . outflows from young stellar objects represent one of the known prime candidates . outflows also offer the opportunity to study the physics of a particular class of interstellar shock waves . these tend generally to be radiative and reasonably thermally stable . specific problems include upstream - downstream communication , particle acceleration , shock cooling and grain destruction processes . specifically for the jet - driven outflow models , the problem exists how to account for the wide angles of observed molecular outflows . these flows are more often the rule than the exception . in other words , the mechanism for the momentum transfer in the transverse direction has yet to be uniquely identified . in relation to this , it is important to provide firm observational data for the internal ( jet ) and external ( surrounding medium ) densities , as the driving of the molecular flows could be accomplished only by underdense jets . the development of instabilities in the molecular flow ( high velocity knots or ` bullets ' , see bachiller 1996 ) , possibly related to this issue , is not well understood either . as mentioned in the previuos paragraph , outflows affect their environment physically , but their molecular clouds may also transform chemically . on a global scale , the effects of outflows on the chemical evolution of their host cloud have been addressed by bergin , melnick & neufeld ( 1998 ) . these models focus on the relative abundance , as a function of the time , of primarily a few key species ( chemistry and cooling ) such as o@xmath0 and h@xmath0o . at the time , these models appeared elegant and highly attractive . unfortunately , and unexpectedly , _ nature _ did not agree , as observations with swas ( snell et al . 2000 ; goldsmith et al . 2000 ) and odin ( hjalmarson et al . 2003 ; pagani et al . 2003 ) have demonstrated . both molecules were found to be severely underabundant with respect to the ( steady state ) chemical model predictions and several proposals to solve this problem have been offered , some of which have other flaws ( see the references in bergin et al . 2000 and in pagani et al . 2003 ) . furthermore , in view of the great variety of the proposed solutions , this issue seems far from settled . on the local scale of the outflows , the study of the chemistry behind the shock waves is of relevance . what kind of shock ( dissociative @xmath24 and/or non - dissociative @xmath25 ) will develop , depends on the flow itself and the medium it runs into . the predicted chemistry will be correspondingly different in these cases . the understanding of the chemistry is important per se , but also because of its feed - back into the physics ( via the energy balance / cooling , which in turn feeds back into the chemical reactions ) , thereby providing the proper spectral diagnostics for the observation of the flow ( which lines , their intensity and shape ) . a problem of theoretical models is their susceptibility to the choice of the boundary conditions and input parameters . in addition , the shocked flow might not have had the time to establish chemical equilibrium , implying that time dependence can not be ignored . for instance , observed abundance ratios @xmath26(oh)/@xmath26(h@xmath0o ) in a number of outflows can be used to illustrate this point . steady state @xmath25-shock models are inconsistent with the observations and their relative underproduction of oh could be explained in two alternate ways . ( 1 ) the inconsistency arises as a consequence of a time dependence effect , i.e. the flows are too young to have converted sufficient amounts of o into h@xmath0o ( richer et al . 2000 ) , or ( 2 ) is due to an incorrectly chosen input parameter , i.e. the actual ionisation rate is significantly higher , perhaps because of the presence of x - ray sources ( wardle 1999 ; larsson , liseau & menshchikov 2002 ) . the resolution of the oh- and similar problems will have to make use of detailed comparison of observational data with the results of carefully selected , time dependent chemical model calculations . however , non - equilibrium systems are not only ` bad ' , since their sensitivity can be turned to an advantage : if one is convinced that one has picked the right model of the source , then this model can be used for timing purposes in order to identify various events occuring during the evolution of the source . hence , with regard to the chemical models , the a priori problem lies in identifying the most plausible ones , so that they can also be used as chronometers . the ortho - to - para state ratio of , e.g. , h@xmath0 is a chief example to achieve timing observationally in outflows . a very modest number of outflows shows spectra with a rich variety of molecular lines ( l1157 : bachiller et al . 2001 ; bhr71 : bovill , bourke & bergin 2002 ) , whereas most observed outflows do not . as the chemically enriched ouflows are more collimated than on the average and they emanate from sources believed to be very young ( class0 ) , it is reasonable to interpret the enrichmment as an age ( or rather youth ) effect . observed abundance gradients along the flow would be consistent with this idea , being due to the chemical evolution of the shocked gas ( bachiller et al . 2001 ) . it is at present not clear , whether the known small fraction of class0 associated outflows showing enhanced chemical abundances is the result of an observational selection effect . foregoing the results of ongoing and future observations , the question of outflow evolution needs to be addressed also from the chemical point of view . much of the gas in molecular outflows is at low temperatures ( @xmath27 a few tens of kelvin ) and is most readily observed at submm / mm wavelegths . in this regime , the contrast between the outflow and the hosting molecular cloud is often low at velocities close to the systemic velocity , thus confusing the observation of the outflow gas with that of the host cloud . higher excitation material , observable at shorter wavelengths ( e.g. , in the ir ) , circumvents this difficulty . , with the energies expressed in kelvin . wavelengths in @xmath28 m are indicated next to the shown transitions . the bold lines identify transitions discussed in the text , scaledwidth=80.0% ] m spectrum of the source model for l1551 irs5 in [ feii ] line emission , based on iso - sws observations ( see white et al . shown is an estimation of the scattered light from the central @xmath29 . the spectral resolution is @xmath30 , corresponding to 10 resolution elements of the assumed line width of 150 km s@xmath6 . the slit should be positioned in such a way that the dust scattered [ feii ] lines are not confused with the emission from the binary jet ( fridlund & liseau 1998 ; itoh et al . 2000 ; pyo et al . the strongest lines , in the photometric @xmath24- and @xmath31-bands ( @xmath32 m and @xmath33 m , respectively ) , would be readily accessible from the ground ( crires),scaledwidth=80.0% ] infrared observations of outflows have traditionally focussed on @xmath34-band ro - vibrational lines of h@xmath0 . more recently , also other constituents , notably forbidden lines of ionised iron , have been used to trace the associated shocks . these lines are sensitive to temperatures largely in excess of @xmath35k . a nice account for the exploited techniques can be found in the recent article by giannini et al . in addition , nisini et al . ( 2004 ) report on recent ir - hi results . needless to say that such studies would largely benefit from increased spectral resolving power , permitting the observation of the line shapes . below , a few observational scenarios are illuminated which have bearing on the open problems of the previous sections . the focus will be on the upcoming eso facilities crires and visir , but the synergetic and complementing effects of future instruments will also be briefly mentioned . high velocity outflows / jets are potential sources of forbidden iron line emission from gas behind @xmath24-shocks . there are several infrared lines , which originate from a common upper level , e.g. @xmath36 and @xmath37 ( crires ) on one hand , and @xmath38 and @xmath39 ( crires and visir ) on the other ( fig.[feii_levels ] ) . the emission is optically thin , hence the intensity ratios of these lines are constant ( for h - neutral gas , @xmath40 and @xmath41 ) . this circumstance permits the direct assessment of the dust extinction and its spatial variation , in particular for highly extinguished sources and/or double / multiple objects ( e.g. , @xmath42mag and @xmath43mag , respectively ; see white et al . 2000 for the assumed grain composition and size distributions ) . toward driving sources of outflows , dust optical depths can become so high that scattering in the ir can not be ignored ( above , the extinction estimations represent of course the sum of both absorption and scattering ) . white et al . ( 2000 ) have argued that such is the case toward the archetypical outflow source l1551 irs5 . in fig.[feii_sca ] , the modelled spectrum of scattered [ feii ] from the very central regions , subtending only about 0@xmath442 , is shown . the precise nature of the model is critically dependent on the correct description of the line profile , requiring high spectral resolution , in addition to high sensitivity and angular resolution . spectropolarimetry would be the desired option , but also spatially resolved spectroscopy of the emission , scattered up through the excavated polar regions of the circumstellar disk , could be used for the measurement of the rotation pattern of jets close to their base , i.e. in the immedite vicinity of their driving sources . lines with differing nuclear spin states potentially provide clues to the history of the gas . the lines are identified above the top panel . the absolute flux scale along the @xmath45-axis pertains to a particular model of a parcel of gas at temperatures between 30 and 250k and the mass of which is @xmath46 ( the emission is optically thin and thus easily re - scalable ) . the relative effects of various assumptions about the ortho - to - para ratio , o / p , are readily seen . in these panels , ` cold ism ' refers to thermally relaxed gas at initially about 20k , ` h@xmath0 formation ' would correspond to gas at high temperatures ( @xmath47k ) and ` shock admixed ' to a mixture of cold and shock - heated gas ( this o / p value could also correspond to gas thermalised at about 100k ) . to guide the eye , an arbitrarily off - set extinction curve is included for comparison . intrinsic line widths are @xmath48 and the spectral resolution is @xmath49 for @xmath50 m and @xmath51 for longer wavelengths ( visir),scaledwidth=80.0% ] the pure - rotational h@xmath0 transitions , which , in principle , are admitted by visir are the lines s(1)17.0@xmath28 m , s(2)12.3@xmath28 m , s(3)9.7@xmath28 m and s(4)8.0@xmath28 m , where even-@xmath24 values ( in parentheses ) refer to para - states and odd-@xmath24 to ortho - states . being situated close to a silicate feature , the s(3 ) line could become suppressed by circum-/interstellar extinction . however , this line falls onto the wing of deep telluric ozone absorption and is hardly accessible from the ground . generally , the high thermal background due to the atmosphere and the warm optics makes high spectral resolution a requirement . in fig.[h2_profile ] , the relative effects of different ortho - to - para ratios of h@xmath0 , on an otherwise identical model , are visualised . obviously , pristine gas would hardly show up in the ortho lines , whereas these could dominate the emission from more evolved environments , as , for instance , in the s(1 ) line . the correct assessment of the h@xmath0 ortho - to - para ratio is thus instrumental for the understanding of the evolutionary state of the gas . as already noted , outflows are intimately related to circumstellar disks . of considerable interest is the time evolution of the volatile material in outflows and disks and , in particular , that of water . recent , successful ground based observations of fluorescent h@xmath0o from comets in the near infrared ( dello russo et al . 2004 and references therein ) could also be breaking the ground for such observations of disks and outflows , being situated in a high radiation density environment . such could be encountered in regions of e.g. high - mass star formation . the observed lines originate from highly excited levels , which are practically not populated in the telluric atmosphere . the high spectral resolution offered by crires could permit the observation of the h@xmath0o steam lines at about 2.9@xmath28 m ( radiatively excited 200 and 101 bands , decaying to 100 and 001 ) from irradiated outflow gas or externally heated disks ( e.g. the proplyds seen in silhouette against the bright orion nebula ) . for the latter , preliminary estimates result in emission line fluxes of the order of a few times @xmath52erg s@xmath6 @xmath53 for a number of the brightest proplyds , which should be readily observable with crires , as the lines can be assumed to be narrow ( a few km s@xmath6 ) . the new eso facilities crires and visir will of course not be operating in complete isolation , but provide also valuable complements for current and future instrument developments . in the time frame of 2007/08 , the spaceborne herschel observatory will come into operation . its 3.5 m telescope will limit the angular resolution at far infrared and submm wavelengths to a few to some tens of arcsec , and will thus not be able to compete with the vlt in this respect . on the other hand , its heterodyne instrument hifi will offer very high spectral resolution , in excess of @xmath54 . on a somewhat longer time scale , the large mm / submm array alma will offer both high angular ( 0@xmath551 ) and spectral resolution ( @xmath56 ) . at shorter wavelengths , the 6 m james webb space telescope ( jwst ) will provide diffraction limited ir observations ( at @xmath57 m ) , in addition to very high sensitivity , especially in the thermal infrared , thanks to the low - noise environment at the sun - earth @xmath58 . however , the direct , spatial resolving of the outflow acceleration regions , at the level of a few milliarcsec and with jwst sensitivity , will probably need to await the advent of the infared space interferometer darwin , sometime in the middle of the next decade . * the ubiquitous phenomenon of outflows in star forming regions is discussed . our knowledge appears still largely incomplete , in particular what regards fundamental issues , such as outflow origin and collimation . * high resolution ir spectral mapping observations can potentially put models of outflow origin to test by measuring the rate of jet rotation . in highly extinguished regions , scattered lines of [ feii ] are likely suitable to accomplish this . * the observation from the ground of the rotational lines of h@xmath0 in the thermal infrared requires high spectral and spatial resolution . the relative line strengths of ortho - h@xmath0 and para - h@xmath0 can be used to study the history of shocked / non - shocked interstellar gas in outflows and disks . * high resolution ir observations of lines of hot h@xmath0o open up the possibility to study the h@xmath0o evolution in disks and outflows from the ground . _ acknowledgements . _ i enjoyed interesting discussions with m.barsony , a.caratti o garatti , b.nisini and g.olofsson . i would also like to take this opportunity to thank the organisers for their kind hospitality during this stimulating workshop .

the high spatial and spectral resolution offered by the new generation of infrared spectrometers at eso is optimally suited for the observational study of outflows from young stellar objects . models of interstellar shock waves would benefit from observations of spectrally resolved line profiles . this applies also to attempts of measuring the rotation rates of jets very close to their driving source , which in general suffer considerable extinction . observations of forbidden lines of ionised iron , [ feii ] , could be used to accomplish this . the possibility of using rotational lines of molecular hydrogen , h@xmath0 , to study the temporal evolution of outflow and disk gas is discussed . similarly , high resolution ir observations of fluorescent water lines , h@xmath0o , open up the possibility to access outflow and disk water from the ground .

1202.0624

the detailed study of electroweak symmetry breaking and of the properties of a hypothetical sm higgs boson are some of the physics goals motivating the construction of a linear electron collider . the centre - of - mass energy of the collider would be 500gev ( ilc ) or 3tev ( clic ) , which will be decided upon analysis of the lhc data @xcite . in both cases , however , several interesting physics channels will appear in multi - jet final states , often accompanied by charged leptons and missing transverse energy . the di - jet energy resolution should be such that _ z _ and _ w _ masses can be determined with an accuracy comparable to the natural decay width of these bosons . this translates into a jet energy resolution of 34% over the whole energy range . two kind of calorimeters are under study to meet this requirement @xcite . one proposes to measure and correct for the fluctuations of the electromagnetic and hadronic components on a shower by shower basis . the second is based on the _ particle flow _ ( _ pf _ ) approach : the momentum of jet charged particles are measured with the tracking system , tracks and showers being matched thanks to a high segmentation of the calorimeters . several technological options are studied by the calice collaboration : silicon or scintillator for a sampling ecal with tungsten absorbers , scintillator or gaseous chambers for the fe or w hcal . in the gaseous detector case , r&d on rpc , gem and micromegas are actively pursued . they are an attractive option with respect to the large area to be instrumented : 3000m@xmath1 in the sid detector concept @xcite . in addition , because there is only one sensor per layer ( a gas layer ) , higher cell segmentation can be achieved than with scintillators ( 1 versus 9@xmath0 ) with plausibly better _ pf _ performance . on the other hand , due to the large signal fluctuations in gaseous detectors , the charge information is of limited use . this may limit the single particle energy resolution necessary for measuring the neutral content of jets . as a result , gaseous hadronic calorimeters are essentially digital ( 12bits per channel ) . in the last ten years , the so - called bulk fabrication process has widened the field of application of micromegas detectors @xcite . it consists in the lamination of a stainless steel mesh ( 20@xmath2 m diameter wires woven to a square pattern ) and photosensitive insulating films onto a pcb . after patterning of the films to pillars , the mesh is strongly encapsulated in between the pillars at a constant distance from the anode pcb plane . it is therefore well suited for manufacturing large area micromegas detectors . furthermore , the final assembly is robust , the mesh resistant to sparks and the gain uniformity relatively good , about @xmath310% @xcite . attractive features of micromegas for a hadron calorimeter are excellent performance to mip , high rate capability and , in suitable gas mixtures , no sentivity to neutrons and negligible aging . as mentioned already , the energy measurement is relevant for neutrals but also for very high energy charged particles against which the tracker resolution worsen . there , the energy is measured by calorimetry only and it is desirable to minimize both stochastic and constant terms ( _ a_/@xmath4@xmath5_b _ ) that govern the resolution . in order to improve _ a _ and linearity , it has been proposed to digitize signals with 2bit resolution . this semi - digital readout scheme has been adopted by micromegas and rpc hcal projects ( sdhcal ) . lamination of the mesh and the pcb between rolls imply that the bulk process is applied to flat pcb . hermeticity requirements and huge number of channels of an ilc / clic hcal , however , make it unavoidable to integrate front - end asic on detectors . therefore , lapp group and cern workshop made the bulk process compatible with asic equipped pcb . the final assembly , called an active sensor unit or asu , consists of a pcb with 1@xmath0 pads plus mesh on one side and asics on the other side ( fig.[m2_pics ] ( left ) ) . prototype during assembly.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=38.0% ] prototype during assembly.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=38.0% ] the first asu was constructed in 2008 . it consisted of a matrix of 8@xmath68 pads read out by one dirac chip and was successfully tested in cern / ps particle beams @xcite . subsequently , asus of larger area were fabricated and equipped with hardroc2 chips @xcite . the size adopted for the construction of a 1m@xmath1 detectors is 32@xmath648@xmath0 . optimized for the efficient detection of micromegas signals , a new asic called microroc was developed by the lal / omega group and the lapp electronics department . the one square meter prototype features 9216 readout channels ( 96@xmath696 pads ) . it is assembled from six asu glued on a stainless steel supporting plate and surrounded by a plastic frame ( figure [ m2_pics ] ( right ) ) . another stainless steel plate holds a copper drift electrode . the 3 mm drift gap is defined by the frame height and is kept constant over all chamber area by tiny spacers placed between the asu . each asu consists of woven mesh and a pcb with 48@xmath632 readout pads of 1@xmath61@xmath7 and 24 microroc chips . the readout of two asu is chained serially and connected to the data acquisition system by three detector interface boards ( dif ) . the dif is a mezzanine board , it allows to load the asic configuration , readout the data from the asic memory and also to provide system clock and power . another board , called inter - dif , is placed between the dif and the asu to provide voltage to drift and mesh electrodes ( @xmath8500v ) . the gas is distributed by one inlet and outlet traversing the frame of the chamber whose total thickness is about 1 cm . the prototype is equipped with a newly developed 64-channel asic called microroc . each asic channel features a diode network embedded inside the silicon to protect against discharges , a charge preamplifier followed by 2 shapers of different gain and shaping time tunable between 75 and 200ns , 3 discriminators allowing setting of 3 readout thresholds with 10-bit dacs and a 127 event depth memory with 200ns time - stamping of hits ( fig.[mr_circuitry ] ) . the dynamic range of the low and high gain shaper are 200 and 400fc respectively . the output of the high gain shaper is connected to 2 discriminators which are used to define the low and medium channel threshold while a third discriminator , linked to the low gain shaper , is available to set the high threshold . the 3 thresholds are common to the 64 chip channels . a 4-bit offset , however , can be used to vary the individual pedestal positions . it virtually provides a channel to channel control of the 3 thresholds . a detailed characterization of 341 asics was carried out to verify their overall functionality and determine their settings ( offsets and thresholds ) . the procedure and the results can be found in @xcite . a telescope and the 1m@xmath1 prototype were installed in sps / h4 for 18 days during august 2011 . at an average trigger rate of 100hz in spill , 6 millions muons and pions in the ratio 85/15 were recorded . muons were used to assess the prototype performance to mips under various detector settings . shower signals were measured with a pion beam focused at a small iron block placed 0.5 m upstream of the prototype . installed in the sps / h4 beam line , the set - up consisted of a telescope and the prototype each placed on a movable table , a gas distribution panel , two racks with trigger electronics and power supplies and a fast acquisition pc ( figure [ setup_noise ] left ) . the telescope is a mechanical structure holding small micromegas tracking chambers equipped with pads or strips for tracking and three scintillators plus pmt for triggering . all the detectors were flushed with a non flammable gas mixture of ar / cf@xmath9/__i__c@xmath9h@xmath10 95/3/2 at a total flow of 4l / h . the iterative procedure to align the pedestals described in @xcite was run at the beginning of the test ( fig.[setup_noise ] ( right ) ) . later , noise conditions were monitored with daily short dedicated runs . the target noise rate was 10mhz / channel . compared to a particle rate of 10hz per channel in the center of the muon beam , it yields a high signal to noise ratio of about 10@xmath11 . [ [ mesh - voltage - scan ] ] mesh voltage scan + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the efficiency is measured by finding a muon track in the telescope , extrapolating its impact point at the prototype and searching for hits inside a 3@xmath63 pad area at the time of the trigger ( window of 600ns ) . the multiplicity is calculated as the average number of hits whenever at least one hit is present . both quantities were measured at various mesh voltages and shaping times with the beam spreading over roughly hundred pads . a preliminary analysis leads to the trends showed in figure [ eff_mult_vmesh_scan ] where a high efficiency is reached at all shaping settings . at 390v mesh voltage ( gas gain around 3000 ) , 1fc hit threshold and 200ns shaping , one records an efficiency of 98% and a multiplicity of 1.12 . both are very well compatible with small prototype performance previously measured in similar conditions @xcite . [ [ threshold - and - angular - scan ] ] threshold and angular scan + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + thanks to a careful calibration of the electronics before the test beam , a threshold scan could be performed ( figure [ eff_thr ] ( left ) ) . the slight inflexion point at half of the range follows from the landau distribution turnover . the lowest running threshold is about 1fc . further increase to 2fc leads to a dramatic drop of the noise rate by 3 orders of magnitude while leaving the efficiency almost unchanged . pad multiplicity is directly impacted by the angle of incidence of traversing muons . its dependence to the angle was studied by rotating the prototype with respect to the beam direction . as is seen in figure [ eff_thr ] ( right ) , it remains below 1.5 at angles as large as 60@xmath12 . directed at a 20 cm thick block of iron downstream of the telescope , a 150gev / c pion beam was used to produce hadron showers which would propagate to the prototype placed half a meter downstream . this set - up allows to get a first idea of the response of the prototype in high multiplicity showers . in addition , the possibility to distinguish by use of the three thresholds multi - particles and single particle within 1@xmath0 cells can be examined . finally thanks to the possibly large spatial extend of some showers , a uniformity measurement can be carried out quickly . [ [ uniformity ] ] uniformity + + + + + + + + + + the superimposition of 10@xmath13 pion events measured at a mesh voltage of 350v ( mip efficiency of 90% ) is depicted in figure [ shower_profile ] ( left ) . the pattern exhibits rings that correspond to non - showering pions in the center surrounded by electromagnetic and hadronic shower components . thanks to a uniform response , a clear azimuthal symmetry is observed . the effect of dead zones at the asu junctions is better seen when projecting the pattern along vertical and horizontal axis ( figure [ shower_profile ] middle and right ) . pads at the asu edges show a lower efficiency , as expected from the 2 mm wide bulk coverlay line running along them . pions of 150gev / c traversing a 1@xmath14 fe block.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0% ] pions of 150gev / c traversing a 1@xmath14 fe block.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0% ] pions of 150gev / c traversing a 1@xmath14 fe block.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0% ] [ [ mult_h4 ] ] hit multiplicity + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + runs with 5.10@xmath13 recorded pion events were performed at various mesh voltages . the primary goal was to measure the hit multiplicity and compare it to monte carlo predictions . distributions obtained at 325 , 350 and 375v exhibit a sharp peak and a long tail from traversing and showering pions respectively ( figure [ shower_hnhit ] left ) . the tail extends to larger values at higher voltages while the population of the zero hit bin drops . at 375v ( mip efficiency of 97% ) , the maximum number of hits is quite large : up to @xmath3300 . [ [ semi - digital - readout ] ] semi - digital readout + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the three thresholds were set to 1fc , 1mip and 5mip respectively where the charge of a mip depends on the mesh voltage . at 325 , 350 and 375v , a different set of medium and high thresholds had to be used to accommodate for the larger value of the mip charge at higher voltages . as expected , the number of hits distributions through these two thresholds are very similar , demonstrating a good control of the thresholds . [ [ trigger - less - operation ] ] trigger - less operation + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + when operated in trigger - less mode , the prototype is read out upon receipt at the dif boards of a memory full signal from one of the 144 asic . stable operation therefore requires negligible noise and discharge rates which could fill memories up and generate dead time . this was easily achieved at 365v ( mip efficiency of 95% ) when measuring the beam profile ( fig.[ramfull ] ) . all information from the detector is used in this plot . [ [ analogue - readout ] ] analogue readout + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the possibility to measure the shaper signal with high resolution was implemented with dedicated pcb routing lines and a 12-bit adc on the dif boards . focusing the pion beam on a small region , expected landau distributions were measured . figure [ ramfull ] ( right ) shows one distribution with the pedestal peak . this analogue readout is an extra functionality that could be used at ilc / clic to monitor pedestals and thresholds . also , it will be helpful to tune better monte carlo simulation parameters . major milestones have been met in 2011 for the validation of the micromegas technology for hadron calorimetry . the successful implementation of a new low noise asic in a large chamber of 1m@xmath1 size is one of them . preliminary test beam results show that this detector provides high sensitivity to mips and detailed shower information . efforts towards real calorimetry measurements will be pursued with the construction of more planes and the participation to combined calice test beams inside m@xmath11 size fe or w structures . 99 ilc reference design report , 2007 , ( http://arxiv.org/ps_cache/arxiv/pdf/0709/0709.1893v1.pdf ) . clic conceptual design report , 2011 , ( https://edms.cern.ch/document/1177771 ) . _ , nim * a611 * ( 2009 ) , pp . 2540 s. schuwalow _ et al . _ , nim * a598 * ( 2009 ) , pp . 258263 sid , letter of intend , 2009 , arxiv:0911.0006 s. andriamonje _ et al . _ , nim * a560 * ( 2006 ) , pp . 405408 c. adloff _ et al . _ , 2009 _ jinst _ 4 p11023 , pp . 119 s. callier _ et al . _ , twepp proceeding , 2009 , pp . 122126 c. adloff _ et al . _ , twepp proceeding , 2009 , pp . 117121 c. adloff _ et al . _ , tipp 2011 , physics procedia 2012

calorimetry at future linear colliders could be based on a particle flow approach where granularity is the key to high jet energy resolution . among different technologies , micromegas chambers with 1@xmath0 pad segmentation are studied for the active medium of a hadronic calorimeter . a chamber of 1m@xmath1 with 9216 channels read out by a low noise front - end asic called microroc has recently been constructed and tested . chamber design , asic circuitry and preliminary test beam results are reported .

astro-ph0609521

the seyfert 1 galaxy mcg6 - 30 - 15 at @xmath0 has been the centre of much interest since a broad iron line was discovered in its x - ray spectrum with the _ asca _ satellite ( tanaka et al 1995 ) . iron line emission is part of the reflection spectrum produced by the hard x - ray power - law continuum in the source irradiating the accretion disc ( guilbert & rees 1988 ; lightman & white 1988 ; ross & fabian 1993 ) and is broadened and skewed by doppler , gravitational redshift effects , and light aberration and bending ( fabian et al 1989 ) . the low energy extent of the line can reveal the inner radius of the accretion disc and thus the black hole spin ( for reviews see fabian et al 2000 ; reynolds & nowak 2003 and fabian & miniutti 2006 ) . the iron abundance in mcg6 - 30 - 15 appears to be about 23 times the solar value ( fabian et al 2002 ) , making the iron line particularly strong . mcg6 - 30 - 15 was observed several more times with _ asca _ ( iwasawa et al 1996 , 1999 ; matsumoto et al 2003 ; shih et al 2002 ) , by _ bepposax _ ( guainazzi et al 1999 ) , _ rxte _ ( lee et al 1999 ; vaughan & edelson 2001 ) and by _ xmm newton _ ( wilms et al 2001 ; fabian et al 2002 , 2003 ; vaughan & fabian 2004 ) . all of these observations confirmed the presence and general broad shape of the iron line . evidence that the black hole in mcg6 - 30 - 15 is rapidly spinning has been obtained from the extreme breadth of the line by iwasawa et al ( 1996 ) , dabrowski et al ( 1997 ) , wilms et al ( 2001 ) , fabian et al ( 2002 ) and most recently reynolds et al ( 2005 ) , who determine a spin parameter @xmath1 . the _ xmm newton _ work emphasizes that much of the emission arise from smaller radii , between @xmath2 @xmath3 ( where @xmath4 ) . this may help to explain the otherwise puzzling spectral variations shown by the source . shih et al ( 2002 ) , fabian et al ( 2002 ) , fabian & vaughan ( 2003 ) and taylor , uttley & mchardy ( 2003 ) found that the spectral variability can be explained by a simple two component model consisting of a highly variable power - law continuum ( of almost fixed spectral slope ) and a much less variable reflection spectrum , which of course includes the iron line . the reflection ( and iron line ) strength do not follow the power - law continuum intensity , as expected in a simple reflection picture . the small radius of much of the emission can however explain this behaviour when it is recalled that as well as strong gravitational red - shifting occurring in this region , there is also strong gravitational light bending . this can disconnect variations in the continuum from those of the reflection and has led to the development of the light - bending model ( fabian & vaughan 2003 ; miniutti et al 2003 , 2004 ) , which is a generalization of earlier work on the strong field regime ( martocchia & matt 1996 ; reynolds & begelman 1997 ) . if the source of the continuum emission ( assumed to be an isotropic emitter ) changes location close to the black hole , then , even if the continuum has a constant intrinsic luminosity , it appears to the outside observer to change in brightness . this is just due to gravity bending the light rays out of the line of sight by different amounts depending upon the precise location of the source . much of the radiation is bent down onto the disc , so the observed reflection intensity changes little . the two component variability pattern and its light bending interpretation have recently found application in many other accreting black hole sources ( fabian et al 2004 , 2005 ; miniutti , fabian & miller 2004 ; ponti et al 2006 ) . one striking feature of the model reflection spectrum is a large reflection hump peaking at 2040 kev . this is where the disc albedo is highest ; at lower energies the albedo is reduced by photoelectric absorption and at higher energies it is reduced ( at a given energy ) by compton down - scattering of the photons ( see e.g. george & fabian 1991 ) . the presence of the compton hump has been confirmed in the spectrum of mcg6 - 30 - 15 by _ bepposax _ and rxte observations ( guainazzi et al 1999 ; lee et al 2000 ; fabian et al 2002 ) . what those observations have not done is to determine the variability of the compton hump and show that it varies in the same way as the rest of the reflection spectrum . here we carry out this important step with the hard x - ray detector ( hxd ) on _ suzaku_. we concentrate on the _ suzaku _ data above 3 kev since there is a complex warm absorber in mcg6 - 30 - 15 ( otani et al 1996 ; lee et al 2001 ; turner et al 2003,2004 ) . the difference spectrum between low and high states of the source shows that absorption is minimal above 3 kev ( fabian et al 2002 ; turner et al 2004 ) and high energy transmission grating ( hetg ) spectra from _ chandra _ show no absorption feature around 6.5 kev which would indicate absorption by species of intermediate ionization which could affect our fits ( young et al 2005 ) . mcg6 - 30 - 15 was observed four times by _ suzaku _ ( mitsuda et al 2006 ) , once between august 1719 in 2005 for about 45 ks and three times in january 2006 with longer exposures . here we focus on the three 2006 observations performed between 914 ( 150 ks ) , 2326 ( 99 ks)and 2730 ( 97 ks ) january 2006 . we use event files from revision 0.7 of the _ suzaku _ pipeline . version 0.7 processing is an internal processing applied to the _ suzaku _ data obtained during the suzaku working group phase , for the purpose of establishing the detector calibration as quickly as possible . some processes that are not critical for most of the initial calibration and scientific studies , e.g. , aspect correction , fine tuning of the event time tagging of the xis data , are skipped in version 0 processing , making the quality of the products limited in these directions compared with the official data supplied to guest observers . the xis data were screened with xselect as standard ( see e.g. koyama et al 2006 ) . the xis products were extracted from circular regions of 4.3 radius centred on the source , while background products were extracted from two smaller circular regions offset from the source ( and avoiding the chip corners with calibration sources ) with a total area equal to that of the source region . the latest response and ancillary response files provided by the instrument teams were used . for the hxd / pin ( takahashi et al 2006 ) , instrumental background spectra were extracted from time dependent models provided by the hxd instrument team , based upon a database of non x - ray background observations made by the pin diode to date . since the background modeling is the key issue for the hard x - ray measurement with the hxd , the hxd team has provided two independent background models , model a and b , which use different algorithms ( kokubun et al . spectral analysis of the source spectrum using the two models was found to give statistically indistinguishable results for the three 2006 january mcg6 - 30 - 15 observations over the whole 1445 kev band used here , and we use the background model a in our analysis . the response files appropriate for the xis nominal position observation were chosen dated as of 2006/08/07 . we have extracted products for the three front illuminated ccd xis detectors ( xis0 , xis2 , and xis3 ) and for the back illuminated ccd ( xis1 ) . the xis2 and xis3 detectors are found to produce remarkably similar spectra in the whole band used here . the xis0 spectrum is slightly flatter than that from the xis2 and xis3 detectors so we proceed by co adding just the xis2 and xis3 products in our analysis ( see yaqoob et al 2006 for mention of structures in the xis0 and xis1 spectra ) . in fig . [ totallc ] , we show the broad - band 0.512 kev background subtracted light curve from the xis2 and xis3 detectors during the three pointed observations in 2006 . we also show , as a reference , the count rate levels selected to define the high flux ( hf ) and low flux ( lf ) states which will be used to study the spectral variability of mcg6 - 30 - 15 . as normal for this source ( thought to harbour a black hole with a mass of @xmath5 , mchardy et al 2005 ) the light curve exhibits large amplitude and relatively short timescale variability with variations up to factors 23 in a few ks . we start our analysis of the _ suzaku _ data by considering the 312 kev time averaged co added spectrum from the xis2 and xis3 front illuminated ccd detectors . ( xis response and ancillary files 20060213.rmf and 20060415.arf , with a 6 mm extract radius , were used . ) the most important feature in this energy band is the strong , skewed , relativistic fe k@xmath6 line which characterizes the x ray spectrum of mcg6 - 30 - 15 enabling us to explore the nature and geometry of the accretion flow close to the central black hole with much higher accuracy than in any other object so far . in fig . [ feprofiles ] we show the ratio of the data to a simple power law model fitted in the 34 kev and 7.512 kev band and absorbed by the galactic column density ( @xmath7 @xmath8 ) . the residuals clearly show the asymmetric and broad fe k@xmath6 line profile ( top panel ) . in the bottom panel , we superimpose the fe k@xmath6 profile as observed with the _ xmm newton _ epic pn camera in 2001 . the agreement between the two instruments is remarkable and demonstrates the excellent level of the _ suzaku _ xis calibration even in the early stages of the mission . the 210 kev flux is @xmath9 erg @xmath8 s@xmath10 in the _ xmm newton _ observation and @xmath11 erg @xmath8 s@xmath10 in the _ suzaku _ one . notice the absorption / emission structures in the blue wing of the relativistic line which are clearly detected by both the epic pn and the xis detectors with excellent agreement . as a first attempt to fit the fe k@xmath6 line profile we consider the simplest possible spectral model comprising a power law continuum absorbed by a column of neutral matter ( fixed at the galactic value @xmath12 @xmath8 ) and a set of gaussian emission lines . we consider first three gaussian emission lines : a narrow unresolved @xmath136.4 kev emission line ( the narrow component of the fe line from distant matter ) , two narrow unresolved @xmath136.7 kev and @xmath136.97 kev absorption lines ( the fexxv and fexxvi resonant absorption line already detected by _ chandra _ , young et al . 2005 ) , and an additional gaussian emission line with width free to vary ( representing the broad relativistic fe line ) . we obtain a fit with @xmath14 for 2235 degrees of freedom ( dof ) . the narrow component of the fe line is at @xmath15 ( uncertainties are quoted throughout the paper at the 90 per cent confidence level ) and has an equivalent width ( ew ) of only @xmath16 ev . absorption lines are detected at @xmath17 kev and @xmath18 kev . the broad fe line is at @xmath19 , has a width of @xmath20 ev and an ew of @xmath21 ev . however , the best fitting model leaves clear residuals in the 312 kev band . in particular the broad fe line is not properly modelled and the residuals suggest the introduction of a double gaussian model with one broad gaussian around 6.4 kev and an even broader one at lower energies to model the extended red wing . we obtain a significant improvement of the statistics with @xmath22 for 2232 ( table 1 ) . the energies of the three unresolved lines are @xmath23 kev for the narrow fe emission line , and @xmath18 kev , and @xmath24 kev for the absorption lines . their equivalent widths are @xmath25 ev , @xmath26 , and @xmath27 ev respectively . the upper limit on the ew of the narrow fe k@xmath6 emission line ( only 30 ev ) indicates that reflection from distant matter plays a minor and marginal role in mcg6 - 30 - 16 , as already demonstrated by high resolution spectroscopy with the hetg _ chandra _ gratings ( lee et al 2002 ; young et al 2005 ) . the two absorption line energies are slightly higher than the rest frame energies of fexxv and fexxvi resonant absorption and are consistent with an origin in a common outflow with velocity of few thousand km s@xmath10 . in particular , they are both consistent in equivalent width and outflow velocity with the values measured with _ chandra _ ( @xmath28 km s@xmath10 , young et al 2005 ) . the photoelectric absorption implied by such a thin highly ionized absorber is small and has a negligible effect on the fits described here . as for the broad fe line , the parameters of the two broad gaussian lines describing its profile are reported in table 1 ( first model `` double gaussian '' ) . they are both clearly resolved and their cumulative ew is @xmath29 ev , although this value should be taken with care since the continuum is a simple absorbed power law and does not include the reflection continuum which must be associated with the broad fe line . it is interesting to note that the width of the fe line core at @xmath30 kev is @xmath31 ev ( i.e. fwhm@xmath32 km s@xmath10 ) suggesting that it originates in the outer disc at @xmath33 from the central black hole , while the red wing has a width @xmath34 ev indicating that the emitting matter is located within @xmath35 from the centre , already implying , even by means of a very simple and phenomenological model , that the black hole in mcg6 - 30 - 15 is most likely a spinning kerr black hole in which the accretion disc extends down within the marginal stable orbit for a non rotating schwarzschild black hole ( @xmath36 ) . the multiple gaussian fit described above is merely a phenomenological description of the hard spectrum . the gaussian emission lines and , most importantly , the broad fe line are the clear signature of x - ray reflection and the above spectral model did not include any reflection continuum . here we build a much more self consistent model in which the broad fe line is computed together with the associated reflection continuum . we use a grid of models from ross & fabian ( 2005 ) to obtain the x ray reflection spectrum . the x ray reflection model has the spectral slope of the illuminating power law @xmath37 , the ionization parameter @xmath38 , the fe abundance , and the normalization as free parameters . however , we forced the photon index to be the same as the power law continuum for consistency . since the reflection model does not include ni as an element , we also include a ni k@xmath6 line with energy fixed at 7.47 kev . in order to reproduce the relativistic broad fe line profile , the reflection spectrum is convolved with a relativistic kernel derived from the laor ( 1991 ) code . the relativistic blurring parameters are the emissivity indexes @xmath39 and @xmath40 ( where the emissivity is @xmath41 within the innermost @xmath36 and @xmath42 outside ) , the inner disc radius @xmath43 , and the observer inclination @xmath44 . the outer disc radius is fixed at its maximum allowed value of @xmath45 . the choice of a broken power law emissivity profile is motivated by the previous long _ xmm newton _ observation of mcg6 - 30 - 15 ( vaughan & fabian 2004 ) . cccccccc + + & & & @xmath46 + + @xmath37 & @xmath47 & @xmath48 & @xmath49 & @xmath47 & @xmath48 & @xmath49 & + @xmath50 & @xmath51 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & 2398/2232 + + + + & & & @xmath46 + + @xmath37 & @xmath44 & @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 & @xmath60 & @xmath61 & + @xmath62 & @xmath63 & @xmath64 & @xmath65 & @xmath66 & @xmath67 & @xmath68 & 2360/2230 + + [ tab1 ] the model is applied to the co added xis2 and xis3 time averaged spectrum in the 312 kev band and we keep the three unresolved gaussian lines as above . the results of the spectral fitting are reported in table [ tab1 ] ( `` blurred reflection '' model ) . we obtain a better fit with @xmath69 for 2230 dof . the better fit with respect to the phenomenological double gaussian model described above is due to a better description of the overall relativistic fe line profile . in addition , the model accounts for some high energy residuals above about 10 kev which were present in the above best fitting solution due to the unmodelled reflection component . we measure a relatively standard @xmath70 continuum slope which compares very well with previous results with _ xmm newton_. the reflection component contributes significantly to the hard spectrum of mcg6 - 30 - 15 and we measure a reflection fraction of @xmath71 ( @xmath72 corresponds to the level of reflection expected from @xmath73 sr ) , fully consistent with previous results from a simultaneous _ xmm newton _ and _ bepposax _ observation ( vaughan & fabian 2004 ) . the precise value of the reflection fraction will be better constrained in a subsequent analysis when the high energy data from the hxd / pin detector are considered as well . the reflector is only mildly ionized with @xmath74 erg cm s@xmath10 and the inclination is constrained to be @xmath75 . as for the relevant relativistic blurring parameters , the xis data are able to constrain the inner disc radius to be smaller than @xmath76 . if , as it is customary , @xmath43 is identified with the innermost stable circular orbit around a kerr black hole , such a small 90 per cent upper limit implies that the black hole spin in mcg-6 - 30 - 15 is @xmath77 , i.e. the black hole is an almost maximally spinning kerr black hole . the inner and outer emissivity profiles are not consistent with each other within the errors and @xmath78 is steeper than @xmath79 . however , if the two indices are forced to be one and the same , we obtain @xmath80 with only a slight worsening of the fit statistic ( @xmath81 ) . in the above analysis the relativistic fe line is associated with its own reflection continuum and a self consistent model to the 312 kev spectrum is found . however , one of the main characteristics of the _ suzaku _ mission is the presence of the hxd pin hard x - ray detector providing high quality data above 12 kev ( fig . [ pinspectra ] ) . the spectral analysis of the xis data revealed the presence of a strong reflection component associated with the broad relativistic fe line which would produce a strong compton hump around 2030 kev . the hxd data above 12 kev are thus crucial to investigate the reflection component further and will enable us to infer the reflection parameters and to measure the direct and reflection continua with high accuracy . in fig . [ xisandpinplfit ] , we show the xis and hxd / pin time averaged spectrum in the 0.545 kev band . the figure shows the data to model ratio for a power law model fitted above 3 kev and ignoring the bands where reflection is expected to dominate . the ratio clearly shows the presence of both the relativistic fe line in the xis data and also the presence of a large compton hump around 20 kev visually confirming that the hard spectrum of mcg6 - 30 - 15 is dominated by a strong reflection component . absorption is present affecting the soft band below 3 kev . we avoid the complication of modelling the complex warm absorber and we concentrate , in this first paper on the _ suzaku _ observation of mcg6 - 30 - 15 , on the data above 3 kev . a detailed model of the warm absorber will be presented elsewhere where the data from the back illuminated ( more sensitive at soft energies ) xis detector will be also considered . we consider our best fitting spectral model to the 312 kev xis data and extend it to the pin data between 14 kev and 45 kev . we include a cross - normalization constant between the xis and pin data and find that it is constrained to be @xmath82 ( where the xis constant is set to @xmath83 ) . this factor is consistent with the results obtained from crab observations ( kokubun et al . 2006 ) . since the available hxd / pin background model a does not include the contribution from the x ray cosmic background , a spectral model of the form @xmath84 was included in all spectral fits in the hxd / pin band ( the model being valid up to about 70 kev ) . the model is based on the _ heao_a1 spectrum , re scaled to account for the hxd field of view . the best fitting xis model provides an acceptable description of the 345 kev data and we obtain a good quality fit of @xmath85 for 2312 dof . the model parameters are very much consistent with those obtained from the 312 kev parameters . in fact , extending the model up to 45 kev provides a reasonable description of the hard data , reproducing most of the large compton hump seen in fig . [ xisandpinplfit ] , even before fitting . the results for the time averaged ( ta ) spectrum in the 345 kev band are reported in table 2 together with similar fits to the high flux ( hf ) and low flux ( lf ) spectra which will be discussed below . the reflection component contributes significantly to the total flux and we measure a large reflection fraction of @xmath86 . as a reference , and since it will be useful in a spectral variability analysis below , we report here that its contribution represents the @xmath87 per cent of the total flux in the 312 kev band and the @xmath88 per cent in the 1445 kev band . the relativistic blurring parameters are consistent within the errors with those already reported in table [ tab1 ] and the same is true for the continuum power law slope and for the ionization parameter . as a consistency check , we have also determined the level of the reflection component by using the spectrum above 7.5 kev , so avoiding the iron line . for this the pexrav model in xspec was used , with results @xmath89 , reflection fraction @xmath90 and iron abundance poorly constrained ( @xmath91 times solar ) . we note that such reflection predicts a _ strong _ iron line with an equivalent width of at least 300 ev ( taking conservatively an iron abundance of unity and reflection fraction of 2 ) , using the predictions of george & fabian ( 1991 ) . the limit on any narrow component to the iron emission feature is at least ten times smaller than this ( this work ; lee et al 2002 ; young et al 2005 ) , thereby ruling out any non - smeared origin for the reflection component . the reflection must be due to matter well within the optical broad line region . we also stress that if the evidence for relativistic reflection is taken into account and the pexrav component is blurred accordingly , the shape of the reflection continuum is broader and redshifted requiring a higher fe abundance ( @xmath92 times solar ) and reflection fraction ( @xmath93 ) to fit the data , while the continuum photon index is basically unaffected . the blurred and fe overabundant reflector described by pexrav is thus fully consistent with our best fitting results with a much more complex spectral model including the relativistic fe line ( see table 2 ) . the hxd / pin detector has no imaging capabilities and thus there is no simple way to obtain a background subtracted light curve by selecting appropriate regions . however , background subtracted light curves can be obtained by extracting spectra in each time interval , subtracting the background from the available models in the same time interval , and reading out the background subtracted count rate . in background model a , the background of the hxd is calculated from the data base by using the count rate of the upper discriminator , which has a strong correlation with the flux of the non - x - ray background . the procedure must also include a model for the cosmic x ray background ( not included in the available background models ) and we use the same model as for spectral fitting by simulating the cosmic x ray background hxd / pin spectrum and adding it to the instrumental background . we have applied the above procedure to the hxd / pin data by selecting , after some experimentation , a timescale of 45 ks enabling us to obtain about 5000 background subtracted counts per time interval in the 1445 kev pin band on average . in fig . [ 45kslc ] we show the xis2 and xis3 and the hxd / pin light curves for the three 2006 observations in the 0.512 kev and 1445 kev respectively . to ease the comparison , the xis light curves have been re scaled so that they have the same mean count rate as the pin ones in each segment ( i.e. observation ) . it is visually clear that the harder band ( solid red ) has a much lower variability amplitude than the softer one ( dotted black ) . in the following we explore a set of different techniques with the aim of exploring the flux and spectral variability of the source . as a first model independent way to characterize the flux / spectral variability of mcg6 - 30 - 15 we analysed the relationship of the fluxes ( count rates ) in different energy bands following the technique of flux flux plots introduced by churazov , gilfanov & revnivtsev ( 2001 ) in a study of cygnus x1 spectral variability , and taylor , uttley & mchardy ( 2003 ) as a model independent tool to disentangle the main drivers of the spectral variability in agn . in fig . [ ff ] we show the 3 - 12 kev xis count rate from the 45 ks light curve against the count rate in the 12 kev band which is chosen as reference ( see also vaughan & fabian 2004 ) . the relationship between the count rates in the two bands is remarkably linear and leaves a clear hard offset on the y axis , as already noticed by taylor , uttley & mchardy ( 2003 ) and vaughan & fabian ( 2004 ) in previous _ rxte _ and _ xmm newton _ observations . the linearity of the relationship indicates that the flux variations are strongly dominated by changes in the normalization of a spectral component with constant spectral shape . on the other hand , the hard offset suggests the presence of a component that varies little and that contributes more to the hard than to the reference 12 kev band . we measure a hard offset of @xmath94 cts / s which can be used to infer the contribution of the weakly variable component at mean flux level : since the mean count rate in the 312 kev band is @xmath95 cts / s , the hard offset @xmath96 represents @xmath97 per cent of the 312 kev flux at mean flux level . this compares very well with the @xmath87 per cent contribution of the reflection component to the 312 kev band , as obtained from direct spectral fitting . we have applied the same technique to the hxd / pin light curve and plotted the 1445 kev count rate against the 12 kev reference one . the relationship is much more noisy than when data from the xis alone were used . to reduce the scatter and decrease the pin error bars , we have binned the original flux flux plot according to the soft reference count rate so that each new point comprises three original data points . in the lower panel of fig . [ ff ] we show the binned flux flux plot obtained by plotting the 1445 kev hxd / pin count rate against the reference 12 kev one . a fit with a linear relationship is perfectly acceptable ( @xmath98 for 5 dof ) , again indicating the presence of a clear hard offset in the pin band . in this case , the contribution of the weakly variable ( reflection ) component to the 1445 kev band at mean flux level is estimated to be as high as @xmath99 per cent . again , this is in good agreement with the contribution of the reflection component in the 1445 kev band obtained from direct spectral fitting ( @xmath88 per cent ) . the flux flux plot analysis detailed above indicates that the spectral variability of mcg6 - 30 - 15 can be decomposed into two main components : a highly variable component which varies in normalization only but not in spectral shape , and a weakly variable one which has a much harder spectral shape . the excellent agreement between the contribution of the weakly variable component in the different energy bands as inferred from the flux flux plot analysis and that of the reflection component as obtained by direct spectral fitting strongly suggest that the weakly variable component is the relativistically smeared x ray reflection from the accretion disc . obviously , the highly variable component can be identified with the other component required by spectral fitting , i.e. the power law continuum . the flux flux plots suggest that as the source varies , the power law maintains the same spectral slope and only varies in normalization . a further approach to studying the spectral variability of a source is the rms spectrum , which , for a chosen timescale , is the fractional variability seen at each energy expressed as a flux normalized root mean square variability function . the rms spectrum allows us to quantify the fractional variability as a function of energy in a model independent manner and is therefore an important piece of information , complementary to the flux flux plot analysis described above . such rms spectra have previously been determined for mcg6 - 30 - 15 ( matsumoto et al 2003 ; fabian et al 2002 ; ponti et al 2004 ) . however , as far as data below 10 kev are available , the rms spectrum has proved to be ambiguous to model . in particular , the typical trend that is observed in agn is that the fractional variability decreases with energy , a behaviour that can be explained either in terms of a power law softening at high flux levels ( i.e. a pivoting power law ) or in the framework of the two component model discussed above . the new ingredient here is to include the hxd / pin data above 10 kev with the goal of confirming / rejecting the interpretation that comes out from the flux flux plots analysis . our result for a 45 ks timescale is shown in fig . the general trend is that the rms decreases with energy with a marked drop at @xmath100 kev reassuringly confirming that the fe line is less variable than the continuum , as already noticed in previous works ( e.g. vaughan & fabian 2004 ; ponti et al 2004 ) . the novelty of the _ suzaku _ observation is represented by the hxd / pin data . they confirm the trend of lower fractional variability at higher energies but they lie above and not on the extrapolation of the 26 kev trend . we have theoretically modelled the rms spectrum by considering our best fitting spectral model to the time averaged spectrum and reproducing the 45 ks data by allowing only the power law normalization to vary , i.e. enforcing a perfect two component model . the result of this exercise is shown as a solid red line in fig . [ rms ] and shows that the rms spectrum is fully consistent with a two component model in which the only variable component is a constant slope power law . some variability of the reflection component can not be excluded , but its variability amplitude is certainly not comparable to the variability amplitude of the power law . indeed , small mismatches between the model and the data could be due to some intrinsic variability of the reflection component which deserves more detailed study to be performed in future work . having analysed the spectral variability of mcg6 - 30 - 15 with two model independent ( and calibration independent ) techniques we now consider a more direct approach through spectral fitting . we extracted high flux ( hf ) and low flux ( lf ) from both the xis and the pin spectra according to the selection criterion shown in fig . [ totallc ] . we first consider a simple power law fit in the 345 kev band ignoring , as done before , the fe k and compton hump bands . the result for the hf and lf spectra is shown in fig . [ hfandlfra ] as a ratio plot . there is a clear evidence , both in the xis and in the hxd / pin , that the reflection component contributes more to the lf than to the hf spectrum , which again indicates an almost constant reflection . we have then applied the same spectral model as for the 345 kev time averaged ( ta ) spectrum to the hf and lf spectra and our results are reported in table 2 . almost all parameters are consistent with being the same in the hf and lf spectra . in particular , the power law slope is consistent with being constant and equal to @xmath101 in the ta , hf , and lf spectra . the same is true for the fe abundance , disc inclination , inner disc radius , outermost emissivity index @xmath59 and reflector ionization state ( although there is some indication for a lower ionization at low flux levels ) . the innermost emissivity index @xmath39 appears to be steeper in the lf than in the hf spectrum , but the two indexes are still consistent with each other within the 90 per cent errors . a steeper emissivity profile in the lf state would produce a more extended red wing as expected in the framework of the light bending model where low flux states are characterized by a more centrally concentrated illumination of the inner disc ( miniutti & fabian 2004 ) . on the other hand , the reflection fraction definitely appears to vary and it is higher in the lf spectrum ( @xmath102 ) than in the hf one ( @xmath103 ) as already strongly suggested by the ratio plot in fig . [ hfandlfra ] . this result is fully consistent with the indication inferred from the flux flux plot and rms spectrum analysis discussed above : if the reflection component is only weakly variable , its contribution increases in the lf states because the direct power law decreases while the reflection stays approximately constant . we point out that this is exactly the behaviour predicted by the light bending model ( miniutti & fabian 2004 ) . the spectra , best fitting models and residuals for the hf and lf states are shown in fig . [ hfandlffit ] . fit spectral components are as in fig . [ suzakumo ] ( which refers to the best fit parameters to the time averaged spectrum ) with the only major difference in the hf / lf state being due to a higher / lower power law normalization . we also produced a difference spectrum obtained by subtracting the lf spectrum from the hf one for the xis and hxd / pin . by definition , the difference spectrum only shows the variable components of the spectrum ( modified by absorption ) , while any non variable component is subtracted away . in fig . [ diffspec ] we show the residuals to a simple power law fit in the 345 kev band where galactic absorption is included . the power law fit is very good and the power law slope is consistent with that found in our spectral analysis ( @xmath104 ) but clear positive residuals are left in a broad hump around 6 kev at the @xmath105 level . this may indicate either that the red wing of the relativistic fe line has varied in flux or that the shape of the line is slightly different in the hf and lf spectra . if the residuals are due to flux variability of the reflection component , we should also see some positive residuals at the compton hump energy ( 2030 kev ) which are not seen in the hxd / pin difference spectrum . some reflection variability is in fact allowed by the results of our spectral fits of the hf and lf spectra ( see table 2 ) although the reflection flux is consistent with being the same at the two flux levels . if the reflection flux varied but the fe line keeps the same shape , the main residual in the difference spectrum should be at the energy of the blue peak of the line , around 6.4 kev , while the residuals in fig . [ diffspec ] indicate that only the red wing of the line has varied . the remaining possibility is that the fe line has a different shape ( rather than a different flux ) in the hf and lf spectra . this is already hinted at by the inner emissivity index ( @xmath39 , see table 2 ) which is marginally steeper in the lf state ( although consistent within the errors ) . if the emissivity is really different at the two flux levels , residuals are produced in the red wing of the line and could potentially explain those seen in the difference spectrum ( and at the same time the lack of residual at compton hump energies ) . the result is in the sense expected from the light - bending model ( see fig . 4 of miniutti & fabian 2004 ) . the suzaku observation of mcg6 - 30 - 15 has , for the first time , enabled the hard x - ray variability of the source to be determined . a wide range of techniques including direct spectral fitting , flux - flux plots and rms spectrum all show that the spectral variability on a 45 ks timescale can be decomposed into just two broad components above 3 kev , namely a variable power - law continuum and a harder constant component . this last component has the broad iron line and reflection hump expected from x - ray reflection in the very innermost regions of an accretion disc around a rapidly spinning black hole . just the strength and shape of the reflection component predicts a high equivalent width iron line , much stronger than the weak narrow emission component seen in the spectrum . the only way for such a strong iron line to be ` hidden ' in the spectrum is for it to be smeared into the broad emission structure that we observe . the behaviour of the power - law and reflection components is consistent with the light bending model . in which case much of the rapid ( power - law component ) variability seen in the source is due to strong gravitational light bending as the site of the emission region changes location within a few gravitational radii of the black hole . we assume that the emission region is associated with some magnetic structure produced by the strong differential motions in the accretion disc . note that to produce observed variability the emission region does not need to physically move , just that the main emission site changes position . the broad iron line is strong in mcg6 - 30 - 15 because both the iron abundance is high , at around 2 times the solar value , and the large degree of light bending around its kerr black hole has emphasised the reflection spectrum relative to the power - law continuum . we are deeply grateful to the whole suzaku team for building , launching , calibrating and operating the spacecraft and instruments . gm thanks the pparc , acf the royal society , jl the isaac newton trust , corpus christi college and pparc , jc the pparc for support . lcccc + parameter & ta spectrum & hf spectrum & lf spectrum + + + @xmath37&@xmath106 & @xmath107 & @xmath107 + @xmath108 & @xmath109 & @xmath110 & @xmath111 + + + @xmath60 & @xmath86 & @xmath112 & @xmath113 + @xmath38 & @xmath114 & @xmath115 & @xmath116 + @xmath117 & @xmath118 & @xmath119 & @xmath120 + @xmath57 & @xmath121 & @xmath122&@xmath123 + @xmath44 & @xmath124 & @xmath125 & @xmath126 + @xmath39 & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 + @xmath40 & @xmath130 & @xmath131 & @xmath66 + + + @xmath132 & @xmath23 & @xmath133 & @xmath134 + @xmath135 & @xmath136 & @xmath137 & @xmath138 + @xmath139 & @xmath140 & @xmath141 & @xmath140 + + + @xmath142 & @xmath24 & @xmath143 & @xmath144 + @xmath145 & @xmath146 & @xmath147 & @xmath148 + @xmath149 & @xmath150 & @xmath151 & @xmath152 + @xmath153 & @xmath154 & @xmath155 & @xmath156 + + + @xmath157 & @xmath158 & @xmath159 & @xmath160 + @xmath161 & @xmath162 & @xmath163 & @xmath164 + + + @xmath165 & 2495/2312 & 1910/1848 & 1900/1925 + + fabian a.c . , miniutti g. , 2006 , to appear in `` kerr spacetime : rotating black holes in general relativity '' eds . wiltshire , m. visser and s.m . scott , cambridge univ . press ( preprint astro - ph/0507409 )

_ suzaku _ has , for the first time , enabled the hard x - ray variability of the seyfert 1 galaxy mcg6 - 30 - 15 to be measured . the variability in the 1445 kev band , which is dominated by a strong reflection hump , is quenched relative to that at a few kev . this directly demonstrates that the whole reflection spectrum is much less variable than the power - law continuum . the broadband spectral variability can be decomposed into two components a highly variable power - law and constant reflection as previously inferred from other observations in the 210 kev band . the strong reflection and high iron abundance give rise to a strong broad iron line , which requires the inner disc radius to be at about 2 gravitational radii . our results are consistent with the predictions of the light bending model which invokes the very strong gravitational effects expected very close to a rapidly spinning black hole . ps .

1012.3965

flow rate measurements of liquid metals are required in various technological processes ranging from the cooling of nuclear reactors to the dosing and casting of molten metals.@xcite electromagnetic flowmeters are essential in the diagnostics and automatic control of such processes . a variety of electromagnetic flowmeters have been developed starting from the late 1940s and described by shercliff.@xcite the standard approach is to determine the flow rate by measuring the potential difference induced between a pair of electrodes by a flow of conducting liquid in the magnetic field.@xcite this approach is now well developed and works reliably for common liquids like water,@xcite but not so for liquid metals . major problem in molten metals , especially at elevated temperatures , is the electrode corrosion and other interfacial effects , which can cause a spurious potential difference between the electrodes . the electrode problem is avoided by contactless eddy - current flowmeters , which determine the flow rate by sensing the flow - induced perturbation in an applied magnetic field.@xcite the main problem with this type of flowmeters is the weak field perturbation which may be caused not only by the flow . we showed recently that the flow - induced phase shift of ac magnetic field is more reliable for flow rate measurements than the amplitude perturbation.@xcite another contactless techniques for flow rate measurements in liquid metals is the so - called magnetic flywheel invented by shercliff,@xcite who prescribes _ a `` plurality '' _ of permanent magnets distributed equidistantly along the circumference of a disk , which is mounted on an axle and placed close to a tube carrying the liquid metal flow . the eddy currents induced by the flow across the magnetic field interact with the magnets by entraining them , which makes the disk rotate with a rate proportional to that of the flow . this type of flowmeter , described also in the textbook by shercliff@xcite and extensively used by bucenieks,@xcite was recently successfully reembodied under the name of the lorentz force velocimetry ( lfv).@xcite recently , we suggested an alternative and much more compact design of such a flowmeter , which conversely to shercliff s flywheel uses just a single magnet mounted on the axle it can freely rotate around and magnetized perpendicularly to it.@xcite we also introduced a basic mathematical model and presented first experimental implementation of this type of flowmeter.@xcite when such a magnet is placed properly at a tube with the liquid metal flow , it starts to revolve similarly to shercliff s flywheel . but in contrast to the latter , which is driven by the electromagnetic force acting on separate magnets , the single magnet is set into rotation only by the torque . this driving torque is due to the eddy currents induced by the flow across the magnetic field . as the magnet starts to rotate , additional eddy currents are induced , which brake the rotation . an equilibrium rotation rate is attained when the braking torque balances the driving one , and this rate depends only on the flow velocity and the flowmeter arrangement , whereas it is independent of the electromagnetic torque itself . thus , the equilibrium rotation rate is affected neither by the magnet strength nor by the electrical conductivity of the liquid metal provided that the friction on the magnet is negligible . this a major advantage of the single - magnet rotary flowmeter over the lfv approach , which relies on direct force measurements.@xcite in this paper , we present an extended theory of the single - magnet rotary flowmeter and compare it with experimental results . two limiting cases of long and short magnets are analyzed using linear - dipole and single - dipole approximations . we obtain simple analytic solutions for the force and torque on slowly moving and rotating magnets due to eddy currents in the layers of infinite horizontal extent and arbitrary depth . this allows us to find the equilibrium rotation rate of the magnet at which the torques due to the translation and rotation balance each other . we also consider an active approach , where the force on the magnet is used to control its rotation rate so that the resulting force vanishes . this rotation rate , similarly to the equilibrium one , is proportional to the layer velocity and independent of its conductivity and the magnet strength . the torque on a magnetic dipole rotating about an axis normal to a thin sheet has been calculated by smythe using an original receding image method.@xcite reitz uses this method to calculate the lift and drag forces on the coils of various geometries moving with constant velocity above a conducting thin plate.@xcite the lift force , which at high speeds approaches the force between the coil and its image located directly below it , varies as the velocity squared in the low - speed limit considered in this paper . the drag force is found to vary inversely and directly with the velocity at low and high speeds , respectively . palmer finds analytical expressions for the eddy current forces on a circular current loop moving with a constant velocity parallel to a thin conducting sheet.@xcite the force on a rectangular coil moving above a conducting slab has been calculated numerically by reitz and davis using the fourier transform method.@xcite the same problem for the magnetic dipole of arbitrary orientation placed next to a thin slowly moving slab is addressed by kirpo _ @xcite the force and torque on a transversely oriented dipole above a slowly moving plane layer of arbitrary thickness has been found analytically in the context of the lfv.@xcite fast computation of forces on moving magnets are of interested also for the eddy current force testing techniques.@xcite this paper is organized as follows . the following section presents two simple mathematical models of the single - magnet rotary flowmeter , which are used to calculate analytically the force and torque on the magnets moving and rotating slowly above a layer of infinite lateral extent . the limits of long and short magnets , which are approximated by linear and point dipoles , are considered in secs . [ sub:2d ] and [ sub:3d ] , respectively . section [ sec : exp ] presents the flowmeter implementation details and test results . the paper is concluded by a summary in sec . [ sec : con ] . schematic view of the single - magnet rotary flowmeter with the @xmath0-axis directed out of the plane of figure . ] consider a horizontally unbounded planar layer of electrical conductivity @xmath1 occupying the lower half - space and moving as a solid body with a constant velocity @xmath2 parallel to a permanent magnet placed at a distance @xmath3 above its surface and rotating with a constant angular velocity @xmath4 around an axis parallel to the surface and perpendicular to @xmath5 velocities are assumed sufficiently low for the magnetic field of induced currents to be negligible compared to the field of the magnet . the origin of cartesian coordinates is set at the center of the magnet with the @xmath6 @xmath0 and @xmath7 axis directed along @xmath8 @xmath9 and downward normally to the surface , respectively , as shown in fig . [ cap : sketch ] . in the following , two limiting cases will be considered in which the magnet will be assumed either much longer or much shorter than @xmath10 we start with a long cylinder magnetized perpendicularly to its axis about which it can freely rotate.@xcite in this case , the magnetic field is approximated by that of a two - dimensional ( linear ) dipole with the vector potential @xmath11 which has only the @xmath0-component @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the vacuum permeability and @xmath14 is the linear dipole moment , which is perpendicular to @xmath15 and directed at the angle @xmath16 from the positive @xmath17 axis ; @xmath18 is the radius vector from the magnet axis , and @xmath19 and @xmath20 are the cylindrical radius and the polar angle in the cylindrical coordinates around the @xmath0-axis . the magnetic field of linear dipole is @xmath21 eddy currents are induced by two effects : the translation of the layer and the temporal variation of the magnetic field due to its rotation . the latter vanishes in the co - rotating frame of reference , where the magnetic field is stationary , while the layer appears to move with the resulting velocity @xmath22 which contains also an apparent rotational motion of the layer @xmath23 opposite to that of the magnet . the density of eddy currents is given by ohm s law for a moving medium @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the electric potential . in this case , no electric potential is induced because the e.m.f . , @xmath26 is both solenoidal and tangential to the surface . if the induced magnetic field is negligible as originally assumed , eddy currents can be represented as the superposition @xmath27 where @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the currents induced by the translation and rotation , respectively . it is important to note that in the approximation under consideration with a fixed magnetic field distribution , eddy currents are determined only by the instantaneous velocities . besides that eddy currents are coplanar to the surface and , thus , mutually independent over the depth of the layer consequently , a layer of finite thickness may be represented as a semi - infinite one with zero velocity at @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the distance of the lower boundary of finite - thickness layer from the magnet . this , in turn , is equivalent to the superposition of two semi - infinite layers with the second layer at @xmath32 moving oppositely to the first one at @xmath33 so that the resulting velocity vanishes at @xmath34 in the following , this approach allows us to construct the solution for a finite - thickness layer by taking the difference of two half - space solutions , which is subsequently denoted by @xmath35_{h_{1}}^{h_{2}},$ ] where @xmath36 stands either for the force or the torque due to the eddy currents in a half - space . moreover , by the same arguments , this approach can easily be extended to @xmath7-dependent velocity distributions @xmath37 , for which general solution can be constructed as a superposition of solutions for thin layers moving with various velocities given by @xmath38 where @xmath39_{h_{1}}^{h_{2}}/\left[z\right]_{h_{1}}^{h_{2}}$ ] for @xmath40 and @xmath41 the linear force density experienced by an infinitely long magnet due to the layer translation , which according to the momentum conservation law is opposite to that acting upon the layer itself , can be written as @xmath42 where the integral is taken over the @xmath43-cross - section of the layer . the @xmath0-component of force is absent due to the @xmath44 reflection symmetry . in the low - speed limit under consideration , when force varies linearly with the velocity , there is also no @xmath7-component of force . this is the case because according to the linearity @xmath45 when @xmath46 while the latter transformation is equivalent to the rotation of the coordinate system by @xmath47 around the @xmath7-axis , which leaves the @xmath7-components invariant . in polar coordinates with the surface defined by @xmath48 we obtain @xmath49 the linear torque density , which because of the aforementioned symmetries has only the @xmath0-component , can be found as @xmath50 where @xmath51 the linear force density due to the rotation , defined by @xmath52 is found as @xmath53 the linear torque density due to the rotation , as that due to the translation above , has only the @xmath0-component @xmath54 which is not defined for a semi - infinite layer because the last integral diverges . nevertheless , expression ( [ eq : m1-gen ] ) can still be evaluated for the layer of finite depth by substituting the infinite limit in the last integral by @xmath55 which results in @xmath56_{h_{2}}^{h_{1}}.\label{eq : m1-h2}\ ] ] the solution above becomes unbounded as @xmath57 and , thus , inapplicable to thick layers . this implies that for a half - space layer the induced magnetic field can not be neglected however slow the rotation of magnet . the induced magnetic field is related to eddy currents by ampere s law @xmath58 which combined with expressions ( [ eq : b2d ] ) and ( [ eq : ohm ] ) leads to @xmath59 as suggested by the external magnetic field ( [ eq : a2d ] ) , we search for the vector potential in the complex form @xmath60.\label{eq : a - cmp}\ ] ] then eq . ( [ eq : a ] ) for the complex amplitude @xmath61 takes the form @xmath62 where the prime stands for the derivative with respect @xmath63 the general solution of eq . ( [ eq : a - rot ] ) can be written as @xmath64 where @xmath65 is an unknown constant to be determined by matching the induced and externally imposed magnetic fields ; @xmath66 is the modified bessel function of the second kind,@xcite and @xmath67 is the skin depth due to the rotation . at distances @xmath68 smaller than the skin depth @xmath69 @xmath70 is expected to approach the imposed field @xmath71 which yields @xmath72 ) and @xmath73 substituting expressions ( [ eq : a - cmp ] ) and ( [ eq : a - hat ] ) into integral ( [ eq : m1-gen ] ) , the torque on the magnet can be represented as @xmath74 where @xmath75r\,\d r$ ] and the asterisk denotes the complex conjugate . using eq . ( [ eq : a - rot ] ) , after some algebra we obtain @xmath76=\left(\frac{\mu_{0}}{2\pi}\right)^{2}\re\left[k_{0}((1+i)r / d)k_{1}((1-i)r / d)(1+i)r / d\right].\ ] ] for the low rotation rates that satisfy @xmath77 , we obtain @xmath78=\left(\frac{\mu_{0}}{2\pi}\right)^{2}(\ln(2d / r)-\gamma),\ ] ] where @xmath79 is euler s constant . finally , taking into account that @xmath80 and @xmath81 we obtain@xmath82 where @xmath83 is the effective skin depth , which owing to the low velocities under consideration is supposed to be large relative to @xmath84 . now we can use the results above to find the magnet rotation rate depending on the velocity of layer . first , if the magnet rotates steadily without a significant friction , the torques due to the translation and rotation are at equilibrium : @xmath85_{h_{2}}^{h_{1}}=0,$ ] which yields @xmath86 note that this equilibrium rotation rate @xmath87 depends neither on the magnet strength nor on the layer conductivity unless @xmath88 in the latter case , the skin effect becomes important and , thus , @xmath31 has to be substituted by @xmath89 in the expression above . the velocity of layer can be determined also in another way by measuring the force on the magnet , as in the lfv , to control the magnet rotation rate so that the resulting force vanishes , @xmath90_{h_{2}}^{h_{1}}=0.$ ] this results in@xmath91 which again depends linearly on the layer velocity , but does not depend on its conductivity or the magnet strength . in the other limiting case of a short magnet , when the distance to the surface is large or at least comparable to the size of magnet , the latter can be considered as a dipole with the scalar magnetic potential @xmath92 where @xmath93 is the dipole moment and @xmath94 is the fundamental solution of laplace s equation , which satisfies @xmath95 with the dirac delta function on the r.h.s . in the following , we use simplified notation @xmath96 where @xmath97 is the unit vector . then the dipole magnetic field is given by @xmath98 where the last term is added to ensure the solenoidality of @xmath99 also at @xmath100 the associated dipole current distribution is @xmath101 which easily leads to the classical expressions for the force and torque used later on . in the following , we will be using also the spherical and cylindrical coordinates associated with the cartesian ones in the usual way . as in the previous section , we change to the co - rotating frame of reference and consider the eddy currents due to translation and rotation separately . for the translation with @xmath8 the charge conservation @xmath102 applied to eq . ( [ eq : ohm ] ) results in laplace s equation for @xmath103@xmath104 at the surface @xmath105 the normal component of electric current vanishes : @xmath106 in order to find the induced electric potential , firstly , it is important to notice that @xmath99 being a free - space magnetic field satisfies the laplace equation itself . consequently , the cartesian components of @xmath99 satisfy this equation , too . secondly , if @xmath107 in bc ( [ bc : phi0 ] ) satisfies laplace s equation , then @xmath108 satisfies not only bc ( [ bc : phi0 ] ) but also eq . ( [ eq : phi0 ] ) because the integration along a straight line , similarly to the differentiation , are interchangeable with the laplacian . by the same argument , we can interchange integration and differentiation in expression ( [ sol : phi0-gen ] ) , which yields @xmath109 where @xmath110 and @xmath111 is the zeroth degree associated legendre function of the second kind;@xcite @xmath112 is the spherical polar angle from the positive @xmath7-axis ( see fig . [ cap : sketch ] ) and @xmath68 is the corresponding cylindrical radius . the `` constant '' of integration @xmath113 which similarly to the first term @xmath114 is supposed to be axisymmetric and also to satisfy the laplace equation , is chosen to regularize @xmath115 at @xmath116 by removing the logarithmic singularity @xmath117 for @xmath118 this results in @xmath119 and@xmath120 where @xmath121 is the spherical radius . for a transversal dipole @xmath122 considered also by thess _ _ at al.__@xcite , solution ( [ sol : phi0-h ] ) reduces to @xmath123 where the last term represents the magnetic potential of a dipole aligned with the @xmath0-axis . for a general dipole orientation , expression ( [ eq : h ] ) substituted into solution ( [ sol : phi0-h ] ) after some algebra yields@xmath124,\label{sol : phi0}\ ] ] where @xmath20 is the azimuthal angle from the positive @xmath17-axis in the @xmath125-plane . the electric potential distribution ( [ sol : phi0 ] ) allows us to calculate the force acting upon the magnet , which , as noted above , is opposite to that acting upon the layer , i.e. , @xmath126 where the integral of the lorentz force density @xmath127 is taken over the layer volume @xmath128 for the longitudinal force component , we obtain@xmath129+\int_{h}^{\infty}(\partial_{xm}^{2}g)^{2}\,\d z\right\ } \,\d s\nonumber \\ & = & \frac{\mu_{0}^{2}\sigma v}{512\pi h^{3}}(3m_{x}^{2}+m_{y}^{2}+4m_{z}^{2}),\label{eq : fx}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the first integral is taken over the surface @xmath130 at @xmath131 and can be swapped with the second one over the layer depth . for a transversal dipole @xmath132 , the expression above coincides with that of thess _ _ et al.__@xcite as well as with the result of reitz@xcite for a thin sheet in the limit of a slowly moving dipole . as seen , the force is the strongest on a transversal dipole and reduces on longitudinal and spanwise dipoles by factors of @xmath133 and @xmath134 , respectively . thus , the force ( [ eq : fx ] ) , in contrast to force ( [ eq : f0-gen ] ) for a long magnet , varies with the dipole orientation in the @xmath43-plane . on a horizontally inclined dipole @xmath135 , there is also a spanwise force component@xmath136 but there is no vertical force whatever the dipole orientation:@xmath137 this is consistent with the result of reitz@xcite stating that in the low - speed limit the lift force is proportional to the velocity squared , while the approximation under consideration takes into account only the part of force proportional to the velocity . alternatively , the force and torque acting on dipole can be found using the associated current distribution ( [ eq : j ] ) and the induced magnetic field @xmath138 which lead straightforwardly to the classical expressions@xcite @xmath139 where the integrals are taken over the space @xmath140 above the layer . this is a bit longer but algebraically more straightforward approach , which will be pursued in the following . in order to find the induced magnetic field @xmath138 it is important to notice that solution ( [ sol : phi0-gen ] ) satisfies condition ( [ bc : phi0 ] ) not only at @xmath131 but at any @xmath141 thus , the @xmath7-component of the current is absent not only at the surface but throughout the whole layer . then @xmath102 and @xmath142 imply @xmath143 where @xmath144 is the electric stream function , whose isolines coincide with the eddy current lines . substituting this expression into eq . ( [ eq : ohm ] ) and taking the @xmath7-component of the _ curl _ of the resulting equation , we obtain@xmath145 note that in contrast to the electric potential in eq . ( [ eq : phi0 ] ) , no boundary conditions are required for @xmath144 at the surface . this is because , firstly , eq . ( [ eq : psi - gen ] ) contains no derivatives in @xmath7 and , secondly , the absence of the @xmath7-component of current at the surface is explicitly ensured by expression ( [ eq : j - psi ] ) . for translational motion with @xmath8 the r.h.s of eq . ( [ eq : psi - gen ] ) takes the form @xmath146 which by the same arguments as above satisfies laplace s equation and equals to @xmath147 with @xmath148 which satisfies the same equation and , thus , represents the solution of eq . ( [ eq : psi - gen ] ) . for a transversal dipole @xmath149 ) , the general solution ( [ eq : psi0-h ] ) simplifies to @xmath150 where the last term represents the magnetic potential of a longitudinal dipole . thus , in this case , the eddy current lines coincide with the isolines of electric potential ( [ sol : phi0 ] ) rotated by @xmath151 about the @xmath7-axis . for a longitudinal dipole @xmath152 the comparison of solutions ( [ eq : psi0-h ] ) and ( [ sol : phi0-h ] ) shows that the eddy current lines and the electric potential isolines are swapped with the corresponding distributions induced by a spanwise dipole @xmath153 and rotated by @xmath151 about the @xmath7-axis . for an arbitrarily oriented dipole , expression ( [ eq : h ] ) substituted into the general solution ( [ eq : psi0-h ] ) after some algebra yields@xmath154.\label{sol : psi0}\ ] ] figure [ fig : mov - xyz ] shows the isolines of the electric potential ( [ sol : phi0 ] ) and those of @xmath155 which represent the eddy current lines , in the @xmath125-plane @xmath156 for three basic dipole orientations along the @xmath17- , @xmath0- and @xmath7-axis . note that the patterns are self - similar in the @xmath125-plane with the characteristic length scaling directly with @xmath141 namely , these distributions are functions of spatial angles only , while according to ( [ sol : phi0 ] ) and ( [ sol : psi0 ] ) the magnitude of both @xmath103 and @xmath157 falls off as @xmath158 isolines of the electric potential @xmath103 ( dashed ) and of the stream function @xmath157 ( solid ) in the @xmath125-plane , where the latter represent the eddy current lines , induced by translation in the magnetic field of the dipole aligned with the @xmath17- ( a ) , @xmath0- ( b ) , and @xmath7-axis ( c ) . , title="fig:"](-30,0)(a)isolines of the electric potential @xmath103 ( dashed ) and of the stream function @xmath157 ( solid ) in the @xmath125-plane , where the latter represent the eddy current lines , induced by translation in the magnetic field of the dipole aligned with the @xmath17- ( a ) , @xmath0- ( b ) , and @xmath7-axis ( c ) . , title="fig:"](-30,0)(b ) isolines of the electric potential @xmath103 ( dashed ) and of the stream function @xmath157 ( solid ) in the @xmath125-plane , where the latter represent the eddy current lines , induced by translation in the magnetic field of the dipole aligned with the @xmath17- ( a ) , @xmath0- ( b ) , and @xmath7-axis ( c ) . , title="fig:"](-30,0)(c ) in order to satisfy the solenoidality condition @xmath159 the induced magnetic field is sought as @xmath160 where @xmath161 is the vector potential , which is supposed to satisfy the coulomb gauge @xmath162 then ampere s law leads to @xmath163 which , in turn , results in @xmath164 substituting expression ( [ eq : j - psi ] ) into the last integral , after some algebra we obtain @xmath165 where @xmath166 is the same as used by thess _ _ et al.__@xcite the previous expression implies that @xmath167 similarly to its source @xmath168 has no @xmath7-component . then the induced magnetic field can be written as @xmath169 where @xmath170 represents the scalar magnetic potential , which completely defines @xmath171 outside the layer , where @xmath172 further , using the tensor notation with the einstein summation convention , expressions ( [ eq : f ] ) and ( [ eq : m ] ) can be represented in terms of @xmath173 as @xmath174 where @xmath175 is the anti - symmetric tensor and the subscript after the semicolon denotes the differential with respect to the corresponding coordinate with indices @xmath176 @xmath177 and @xmath178 standing for the @xmath6@xmath0 and @xmath179 directions , respectively . taking into account the symmetry of @xmath180 with respect to the interchange of observation and integration points , the derivatives of @xmath173 at the dipole location @xmath181 in expressions ( [ eq : fi ] ) and ( [ eq : mi ] ) are found as @xmath182 where @xmath183 integrals ( [ eq : x - ij ] ) and ( [ eq : x - ijk ] ) can be evaluated analytically using , for example , the computer algebra system mathematica,@xcite which also allows us to carry out all other analytical transformations . in such a way , we firstly verify that eq . ( [ eq : fi ] ) with expression ( [ eq : psi0-h ] ) substituted into integral ( [ eq : x - ijk ] ) indeed reproduces previous results ( [ eq : fx ] ) , ( [ eq : fy ] ) and ( [ eq : fz ] ) . secondly , eq . ( [ eq : mi ] ) with the same expression for @xmath157 substituted in integral ( [ eq : x - ij ] ) results in@xmath184 which for a transversal dipole again coincides with the results of thess _ _ et al.__@xcite for a solid - body rotation with the velocity @xmath185 which appears in the co - rotating frame of reference , the charge conservation @xmath102 applied to eq . ( [ eq : ohm ] ) results in@xmath186 while the vanishing of the normal current component at the surface @xmath131 requires@xmath187 in order to solve this problem , firstly , it is important to notice that since @xmath188 satisfies the laplace equation , @xmath189 is a particular solution to eq . ( [ eq : phi1 ] ) . comparing expressions ( [ eq : phi1-b ] ) and ( [ sol : phi0 ] ) shows that @xmath190 where @xmath103 is given by solution ( [ sol : phi0-h ] ) . searching for the solution as @xmath191 reduces eq . ( [ eq : phi1 ] ) to the laplace equation for @xmath192 while bc ( [ bc : phi1 ] ) takes the form @xmath193 by the usual arguments , we obtain @xmath194 where @xmath195 and @xmath196 is the first order associated legendre function of the second kind.@xcite using the expressions above , after some transformations we obtain@xmath197.\label{sol : phi1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is the electric potential in the co - rotating frame of reference . instantaneous isolines of the electric potential @xmath198 ( dashed ) and of the stream function @xmath199 ( solid ) , which represent the eddy current lines , induced by a solid - body rotation in the magnetic field of the dipole aligned with the @xmath17- ( a ) , @xmath0- ( b ) , and @xmath7-axis ( c).,title="fig:"](-30,0)(a)instantaneous isolines of the electric potential @xmath198 ( dashed ) and of the stream function @xmath199 ( solid ) , which represent the eddy current lines , induced by a solid - body rotation in the magnetic field of the dipole aligned with the @xmath17- ( a ) , @xmath0- ( b ) , and @xmath7-axis ( c).,title="fig:"](-30,0)(b ) instantaneous isolines of the electric potential @xmath198 ( dashed ) and of the stream function @xmath199 ( solid ) , which represent the eddy current lines , induced by a solid - body rotation in the magnetic field of the dipole aligned with the @xmath17- ( a ) , @xmath0- ( b ) , and @xmath7-axis ( c).,title="fig:"](-30,0)(c ) as before , condition ( [ bc : phi1 ] ) is satisfied not only at @xmath131 but any @xmath7 and , thus , the @xmath7-component of the current vanishes throughout the layer . consequently , the electric current can again be expressed as ( [ eq : j - psi ] ) with @xmath200 for which eq . ( [ eq : psi - gen ] ) takes the form@xmath201 since the r.h.s . of eq . ( [ eq : psi1 ] ) satisfies the laplace equation , after some algebra we obtain@xmath202 the eddy current lines in the @xmath125-plane , which are the isolines of @xmath200 along with the isolines of the electric potential ( [ sol : phi1 ] ) are shown in fig . [ fig : rot - xyz ] . again , the patterns are self - similar and scale directly with the distance @xmath7 from the dipole , while the magnitude of both @xmath199 and @xmath198 falls off as @xmath203 in contrast to the translation considered above , the eddy currents induced by rotation are time - dependent and vary periodically as the dipole orientation changes from the @xmath17- to the @xmath7-axis , which are shown in figs . [ fig : rot - xyz](a ) and ( c ) , respectively . only the electric potential , but no current , is induced by a solid - body rotation when the dipole is aligned with the axis of rotation ( @xmath0 ) . in his case , when the magnetic field is symmetric about the axis of rotation , the induced e.m.f . is irrotational and , thus , compensated by the electric potential gradient , which equals to @xmath204 where @xmath205 is the cylindrical radius from the axis of rotation , @xmath206 is the azimuthal unity vector , and @xmath207 is the azimuthal component of the vector potential , which can be used to describe a general axially symmetric poloidal magnetic field . for the dipole field , we have@xmath208 where @xmath209 is the associated dipole current ( [ eq : j ] ) and @xmath210 substituting this into expression ( [ eq : v1xb ] ) and equating it to the gradient of the electric potential @xmath211 we obtain @xmath212 which is the free - space electric potential in the co - rotating frame of reference shown in fig . [ fig : rot - xyz](b ) and coinciding with ( [ sol : phi1 ] ) when @xmath213 this potential vanishes in the laboratory frame of reference , where the magnetic field is invariant with respect to the rotation around the symmetry axis . further , using expression ( [ sol : psi1 ] ) for @xmath199 in integrals ( [ eq : x - ij ] ) and ( [ eq : x - ijk ] ) , which can be evaluated together with eqs . ( [ eq : fi ] ) and ( [ eq : mi ] ) in the same way as for the translation in the previous section , we obtain @xmath214 the first point to note is that both the force and torque vanishes when dipole is aligned with the axis of rotation @xmath215 which , as discussed above , is due to the absence of eddy currents in this case . secondly , the longitudinal @xmath216 component of force ( [ eq : f1 ] ) , in contrast to that due to the translation given by expression ( [ eq : fx ] ) , is independent of the dipole orientation in the @xmath43-plane and depends only on the magnitude of the dipole moment in this plane : @xmath217 thirdly , there is also a non - zero transversal @xmath218 force , which in contrast to the longitudinal one is purely oscillatory and varies periodically with the dipole orientation in the @xmath43-plane as @xmath219 where @xmath16 is the poloidal angle of the dipole orientation in the @xmath43-plane from the positive @xmath17-axis , which is the same as that for the linear dipole in expression ( [ eq : a2d ] ) ( see fig . [ cap : sketch ] ) . moreover , when dipole is inclined to the axis of rotation ( @xmath220 also a spanwise @xmath221 force appears , which similarly to the transversal one alternates periodically around zero as @xmath222 with the dipole rotation . as seen from expression ( [ eq : m1 ] ) , inclination also gives rise to alternating torque components around both the @xmath17- and @xmath7-axis . the @xmath0-component of torque , which is negative and , thus , opposing the rotation , has not only a constant but also an alternating part , which varies with the double frequency of rotation as @xmath223 instantaneous rotation rate ( [ eq : omgt - trq ] ) versus time ( solid ) and orientation ( dashed ) for a negligible inertia of the magnet.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] thus , in contrast to the long magnet in @xmath224[sub:2d ] , there is no steady rotation rate , which could balance the @xmath0-component of the constant torque ( @xmath225 ) due to the translation . the variation of the magnet rotation rate in response to oscillatory torque is constrained by the inertia of magnet . for the oscillatory part of the rotation rate @xmath226 to be negligible compared to the mean one @xmath227 we need @xmath228 where @xmath229 is the moment of inertia of magnet . if this condition is satisfied , the oscillatory component may be neglected in the balance of torques ( [ eq : m0 ] ) and ( [ eq : m1 ] ) around the axis of rotation , which is the @xmath0-axis . for a layer of finite thickness , this results in @xmath230 the expression above differs only by a factor of @xmath231 from result ( [ eq : omg - frc ] ) for a long magnet in the case of a vanishing longitudinal force . in the opposite limit of a negligible inertia , the torque balance yields@xmath232 this instantaneous rotation rate @xmath233 which is shown in fig . [ fig : omg - t ] versus both the time @xmath234 and orientation @xmath235 alternates between @xmath236 and @xmath237 of the mean value ( [ eq : omgb - trq ] ) @xmath238 the last relation follows from the integration of eq . ( [ eq : omgt - trq ] ) as @xmath239 which also defines @xmath87 parametrically versus @xmath234 in fig . [ fig : omg - t ] . note that the oscillations of the rotation rate do not affect its mean value @xmath240 which is defined by ( [ eq : omgb - trq ] ) independently of condition ( [ eq : omeg - osc ] ) . alternatively , when the magnet rotation rate is actively controlled so that to balance the longitudinal force ( [ eq : fx ] ) with the @xmath17-component of force ( [ eq : f1 ] ) , the instantaneous rotation rate is @xmath241 where the temporal mean value @xmath242 follows from the solution of differential equation ( [ eq : omgt - frc ] ) , which can be written as @xmath243 single - magnet rotary flowmeter with a _ smco_-type magnet ( 1 ) of @xmath244 and @xmath245 in diameter and height , respectively , installed at the side of a rectangular stainless steel duct ( 2 ) of @xmath246 in cross - section carrying the liquid sodium flow . the rotation rate is measured with an inductive magnetic proximity sensor ( 3 ) and also monitored with a photoelectric barrier sensor ( 4 ) . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] the laboratory model of the single - magnet flowmeter shown in fig . [ exp - pic ] consists of a cylindrical _ smco_-type permanent magnet with diameter @xmath247 and height @xmath248 , magnetized perpendicularly to its axis with @xmath249 surface induction , which holds up to @xmath250 the magnet is mounted on a stainless steel axle held by a housing made of `` macor '' ceramic , which ensures a low mechanical friction and can withstand up to @xmath251 the flowmeter was tested on a sodium loop using about 90 liters of molten _ na _ at @xmath252 with the electrical conductivity of @xmath253 the flow was driven by a linear electromagnetic pump , which provided a maximum velocity of @xmath254 at the flow rate of @xmath255 in a stainless steel duct of @xmath246 cross - section . the frequency of magnet rotation was determined with an inductive magnetic proximity sensor ( sick mm12 - 60aps - zu0 ) , which was fixed at the distance of @xmath256 perpendicularly to the side surface of magnet at its midheight as shown in fig . [ exp - pic ] . the sensor briefly switched off and then on again as the magnetic field along the axis of the sensor changed its direction . the frequency of sensor transition from the off to the on state , which happens twice per revolution , was measured with keithley 2000 multimeter using the reciprocal frequency counting techniques with the measurement gate time set to @xmath257 the frequency was also monitored with tektronix tds 210 oscilloscope . after changing the pump current , the flow was allowed to develop for @xmath258 and then six measurements were taken with the intervals of approximately @xmath259 the standard deviation in the measured rotation frequencies was typically a few tenths of @xmath260 the rotation rates measured at two gap widths between the magnet and the duct are shown in fig . [ fig : exp](a ) depending on the average sodium velocity , which was determined using ultrasonic doppler velocimetry@xcite with the resolution of @xmath261@xcite although the rotation rate is seen to increase as the magnet is approached to the duct and to vary nearly linearly with the flow velocity in agreement with the theory , the linear fit shows a certain zero offset . obviously , there is some opposing force , which has to be overcome for the rotation to start . this requires the flow velocity of at least @xmath262 first , such an opposing force is caused by the dry friction in bearings . second , the magnet is oriented by the earth s magnetic field , which has a stronger effect than the friction and also has to be overcome for the rotation to start . third , even stronger effect is caused by the stainless steel walls of the duct , which are weakly ferromagnetic.@xcite the magnet , when approached to the duct , was observed to turn with the dipole moment perpendicular to the wall . it is also important to note that the magnet , when turned by hand away from the equilibrium orientation , returned to it monotonically without oscillations . this implies the inertia of magnet to be small relative to the electromagnetic drag force . thus , the inertia can not significantly contribute to the overcoming of the orienting torque due to the wall magnetization . however , when magnet rotates slowly , the orienting torque causes the rotation rate to fluctuate , which shows up as an increased scatter in the measured values seen in fig . [ fig : exp ] at low flow velocities . when the zero offset is removed and the remaining rotation rate is multiplied by the distance @xmath263 between the magnet axis and the liquid metal , where @xmath264 is the magnet radius and @xmath265 is the thickness of stainless steel wall , we obtain the relative rotation rate @xmath266 which represents a rescaled slope coefficient for fig . [ fig : exp](a ) and is plotted in fig . [ fig : exp](b ) versus the velocity . the short - magnet solution ( [ eq : omgb - trq ] ) in two limiting cases of a semi - infinite @xmath267 and a thin ( @xmath268 layer yields @xmath269 and @xmath270 respectively , which are smaller than the measured values @xmath271 seen in fig . [ fig : exp](b ) . on the other hand , the long - magnet solution ( [ eq : omg - trq ] ) , which appears more adequate for the experimental setup , yields @xmath272 for @xmath273 such quantitative differences between the experiment and theory are not surprising given the simplifications underlying the latter . first , theoretical model does not take into account the finite width of the duct . but this alone could hardly explain the high rotation rate of the magnet at which its field travels faster than the layer . this apparently being the case in the experiment implies the presence of significant velocity gradients , which are also ignored by the theory , but could be taken into account as outlined in sec . [ sub:2d ] . note that strong velocity gradients can be caused by the magnet itself , which due to its large size and strength may act as a magnetic obstacle partially blocking the flow and so increasing its local velocity . measured ( a ) and rescaled ( b ) magnet rotation rates along with the best linear fits versus the average velocity for @xmath274 and @xmath275 gaps between the magnet and the duct with the distance between the magnet axis and liquid metal @xmath276 where @xmath264 is the magnet radius and @xmath265 is the thickness of stainless steel wall.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0%](-30,30)(a)measured ( a ) and rescaled ( b ) magnet rotation rates along with the best linear fits versus the average velocity for @xmath274 and @xmath275 gaps between the magnet and the duct with the distance between the magnet axis and liquid metal @xmath276 where @xmath264 is the magnet radius and @xmath265 is the thickness of stainless steel wall.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0%](-30,30)(b ) we have presented a theory of single - magnet rotary flowmeter for two limiting cases of long and short magnets , which were modeled as linear and single dipoles , respectively . simple analytical solutions were obtained for the force and torque on slowly translating and rotating magnets due to eddy currents in layers of arbitrary depth and infinite horizontal extent . the velocity was assumed to be constant and the motion so slow that the induced magnetic field could be neglected . the latter assumption was not applicable to the long magnet rotating above a conducting half - space . in this case , to obtain a finite braking torque , the skin effect due to the induced magnetic field had to be taken into account however slow the rotation . for a single dipole of arbitrary orientation , compact analytical solutions were obtained in terms of both the electric potential and stream function induced by the layer translation and rotation in the co - rotating frame of reference . the electric stream function was used further to find the scalar potential of induced magnetic field at the dipole location , which resulted in simple expressions for the force and torque on the dipole . eventually , we found the equilibrium rotation rate at which the driving torque due to the layer translation is balanced by the braking torque due to the magnet rotation . an alternative approach was also considered , where the force on the magnet could be used to control its rotation rate so that the resulting force vanishes . in either case , the resulting rotation rate is directly proportional to the layer velocity and inversely proportional to the distance between the magnet and the liquid metal . these results were found in a qualitative agreement with the measurements on the liquid sodium flow . a more accurate quantitative agreement with experiment is limited due to the substantial approximations underlying the theoretical model , which neglects the finite lateral extension of the layer as well as the spatial and temporal variations of the velocity distribution . in conclusion , note that the resulting rotation rate is independent of the magnet strength and the electrical conductivity of the liquid metal provided that the mechanical friction or other external effects are negligible compared to the driving torque . this is the main advantage of rotary flowmeter over the lfv.@xcite x. fu , l. hu , k. m. lee , j. zou , x. d. ruan , and h. y. yang , dry calibration of electromagnetic flowmeters based on numerical models combining multiple physical phenomena ( multiphysics ) , _ j. appl . phys . _ * 108 * , 083908 - 11 ( 2010 ) . i. bucenieks , modelling of rotary inductive electromagnetic flowmeter for liquid metal flow control , in : _ proceedings of the 5th int . symposium on magnetic suspension technology , _ 204208 ( dresden , germany , 2005 ) . g. gerbeth , j. priede , i. bucenieks , a. bojarevics , j. gelfgat , and d. buchenau , verfahren und anordnung zur kontaklosen messung des durchflusses elektrisch leitfhiger medien , _ german patent application _ de 102007046881a1 ( 2009 ) . j. priede , d. buchenau , and g. gerbeth , force - free and contactless sensor for electromagnetic flowrate measurements , in : _ pamir conference _ , 815820 ( presqule de giens , france , 2008 ) ; _ magnetohydrodynamics _ * 45 * , 451458 ( 2009 ) . s. eckert , d. buchenau , g. gerbeth , f. stefani and f .- weiss , some recent developments in the field of measuring techniques and instrumentation for liquid metal flows , _ j. nucl . tech . _ * 48 * , 490498 ( 2011 ) .

we present a theory of single - magnet flowmeter for liquid metals and compare it with experimental results . the flowmeter consists of a freely rotating permanent magnet , which is magnetized perpendicularly to the axle it is mounted on . when such a magnet is placed close to a tube carrying liquid metal flow , it rotates so that the driving torque due to the eddy currents induced by the flow is balanced by the braking torque induced by the rotation itself . the equilibrium rotation rate , which varies directly with the flow velocity and inversely with the distance between the magnet and the layer , is affected neither by the electrical conductivity of the metal nor by the magnet strength . we obtain simple analytical solutions for the force and torque on slowly moving and rotating magnets due to eddy currents in a layer of infinite horizontal extent . the predicted equilibrium rotation rates qualitatively agree with the magnet rotation rate measured on a liquid sodium flow in stainless steel duct .

cond-mat0208047

transverse collective oscillations have been recently excited in the radial plane of an elongated cylindrically symmetric condensate @xcite . they are quasi-2d excitations and indeed , at very low temperatures , the measured frequencies of the transverse monopole and quadrupole modes are found to be in very good agreement with the theoretical predictions obtained by linearizing the gross - pitaevskii equation for a trapped two - dimensional ( 2d ) system . moreover , it has been experimentally found that the transverse breathing mode of an elongated condensate exhibits unique features . first , the excitation frequency is close to twice the radial trapping frequency , it is almost independent of the strength of the two - body interaction and the number of particles , and it is nearly independent of temperature . and second , the transverse breathing mode has a very small damping rate compared to other modes . the measured damping rate of the transverse quadrupole mode is approximately one order of magnitude larger than the one of the transverse breathing mode . this is in contrast to the 3d case , where both monopole and quadrupole modes have similar decay rates . these striking properties experimentally found for the transverse breathing mode are in agreement with the unique features predicted for the breathing mode in 2d isotropic condensates @xcite : its frequency is a universal quantity and it is an undamped mode . one can conclude that these features are characteristic of the reduced dimensionality thus , providing a demonstration of the two - dimensional nature of the transverse oscillations of an elongated condensate . therefore , a highly anisotropic cigar - shaped trap can be considered as a first approximation as an infinite cylinder along the @xmath0-direction . in the present paper we consider a cylindrical condensate and calculate at zero temperature the transverse spectrum of excitations , by solving the linearized gross - pitaevskii equation in 2d , and the modes with non - zero momentum @xmath1 along the longitudinal axis , as well . the main purpose is to investigate the coupling between quasi-2d ( transverse ) collective oscillations and thermal excitations in the collisionless regime . we study the landau damping as a decay mechanism of transverse collective modes as a function of temperature , in which a transverse collective oscillation is annihilated in a collision with a thermal excitation to give rise to another excitation . this paper is organized as follows . in sec . ii we calculate the transverse spectrum of excitations of a cylindrical condensate by solving the linearized gross - pitaevskii equation in 2d within the bogoliubov theory . we obtain also the modes with non - zero @xmath1 . in sec . iii we briefly recall the perturbation theory for the interaction between collective modes of a condensate and thermal excitations ( developed in ref . we apply this theory to calculate the decay rate due to landau damping of a transverse oscillation . in sec . iv we discuss the main results for the transverse quadrupole mode . the situation with the singular transverse breathing mode is also discussed . at low temperature , the elementary excitations of a trapped weakly interacting degenerate bose gas are described by the time - dependent gross - pitaevskii ( gp ) equation for the order parameter : @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the interaction coupling constant , fixed by the @xmath4-wave scattering length @xmath5 , @xmath6 is the atomic mass and the order parameter is normalized to the number of atoms in the condensate @xmath7 . the confining potential is usually cylindrically symmetric and it is given by @xmath8 , with @xmath9 . the ratio between axial ( @xmath10 ) and radial ( @xmath11 ) trapping frequencies defines the anisotropy parameter of the trap @xmath12 . experimentally , in ref . @xcite , the transverse modes have been excited in the radial plane of a highly anisotropic cigar - shaped trap , with @xmath13 . thus , as a reasonable approximation , we consider an idealized cylindrical trap that is uniform in the @xmath0-direction ( @xmath14 ) and has isotropic trapping potential in the radial plane @xmath15 the harmonic trap frequency @xmath16 provides a typical length scale for the system , @xmath17 . we assume a cylindrical condensate with large longitudinal size @xmath18 compared to the radial size @xmath19 , and with a number of atoms per unit length @xmath20 . at low temperatures , the dynamics of the condensate is described by the linearized time - dependent gp equation . assuming small oscillations of the order parameter around the ground - state value @xmath21 \ , , \label{fluctuation}\ ] ] where @xmath22 is the chemical potential , the normal modes of the condensate can be found by seeking fluctuations such as @xmath23 the functions @xmath24 and @xmath25 are the particle " and hole " components characterizing the bogoliubov transformations , and @xmath26 is the frequency of the corresponding excited state . the transverse excitations of a highly elongated condensate can be obtained by neglecting oscillations along the longitudinal direction and thus , looking for fluctuations in the transverse plane of the form @xcite @xmath27 where we have used cylindrical coordinates ( @xmath28 ) . transverse excitations are quasi-2d modes . to calculate landau damping we must also consider thermal excitations having a quasi - continuous spectrum at @xmath29 with the finite longitudinal wave vector @xmath1 along @xmath0 direction . to study these modes we look for solutions that correspond to propagating waves of the form @xcite @xmath30 inserting ( [ fluctuation ] ) , ( [ deltapsi ] ) and ( [ deltapsilong ] ) in eq . ( [ tdgp ] ) and retaining terms up to first order in @xmath24 and @xmath25 , it follows three equations . the first one is the nonlinear equation for the order parameter of the ground state , @xmath31 \psi _ { 0}(r_{\perp } ) = \mu \psi _ { 0}(r_{\perp } ) \ , , \label{groundstate}\ ] ] where @xmath32 , and @xmath33 ; while @xmath34 and @xmath35 obey the following coupled equations @xcite : @xmath36 u_{k}(r_{\perp } ) \nonumber \\ & & + g\psi _ { 0}^{2}v_{k}(r_{\perp } ) \label{coupled1 } \\ -\hbar \omega v_{k}(r_{\perp } ) & = & \left [ h_{0}+\frac{\hbar ^{2}}{2m}\left ( \frac{m^{2}}{r_{\perp } ^{2}}+k^{2}\right ) -\mu + 2g\psi _ { 0}^{2}\right ] v_{k}(r_{\perp } ) \nonumber \\ & & + g\psi _ { 0}^{2}u_{k}(r_{\perp } ) \;. \label{coupled2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we solve the linearized gp equations eqs . ( [ groundstate]-[coupled2 ] ) at zero temperature , to obtain the ground state wave function @xmath37 , the eigenfrequencies @xmath38 and hence the energies @xmath39 of the excitations , as well as the corresponding functions ( @xmath40 ) . in a cylindrical trap the modes of the condensate are labeled by @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the number of nodes in the radial solution , @xmath43 is the @xmath0-projection of the orbital angular momentum , and @xmath1 is the longitudinal wave vector . the quantum numbers @xmath42 and @xmath43 are discrete ( @xmath44 , and @xmath45 ) whereas @xmath1 for highly elongated condensates ( @xmath46 ) is a real number , and thus , it is a continuous index . moreover , it can be seen from eqs . ( [ coupled1 ] ) and ( [ coupled2 ] ) , that levels with @xmath47 or @xmath48 are exactly degenerated . the excitation spectrum of a cylindrical condensate presents different branches labeled by ( @xmath49 ) that are continuous and increasing functions of @xmath50 @xcite . for a given mode , i.e. , fixed @xmath42 and @xmath43 , the frequency of excitation is @xmath38 . we have numerically checked from eqs . ( [ coupled1 ] ) and ( [ coupled2 ] ) that the state with ( @xmath51 ) and @xmath52 corresponds to the transverse breathing mode with excitation frequency equal to @xmath53 , and that it is independent of the strength of the two - body interaction potential and the number of particles . of course , according to the universal nature of this mode noted above , this general result is also valid in the thomas - fermi ( tf ) limit , where the dispersion relation can be found analytically@xcite . however , the functions @xmath24 and @xmath25 for this mode do not coincide in general with their thomas - fermi limit . the state with ( @xmath54 ) and @xmath52 is a transverse quadrupole mode whose frequency depends on the two - body interaction , ranging from the tf value @xmath55 , valid for large condensates ( @xmath56 or equivalently @xmath57 ) , to the noninteracting value @xmath53 . therefore , the transverse quadrupole has to be obtained numerically by solving eqs . ( [ coupled1 ] ) and ( [ coupled2 ] ) in each particular value of the dimensionless parameter @xmath58 . in the present work , we use the numerical solutions to calculate the landau damping of collective modes . it is well known that the dipole mode ( @xmath59 ) is unaffected by two - body interactions due to the translational invariance of the interatomic force which can not affect the motion of the center of mass @xcite and its excitation frequency is @xmath60 . it is worth stressing that the independence of the interaction of the transverse monopole mode , is a unique property of 2d systems , related to the presence of a hidden symmetry of the problem described by the two - dimensional lorentz group so(2,1 ) @xcite . let us consider a collective mode with frequency @xmath61 , and the excited states @xmath62 available by thermal activation , with energies @xmath63 and @xmath64 , respectively . suppose that this collective mode has been excited and , therefore , the condensate oscillates with the corresponding frequency @xmath61 . due to interaction effects , the thermal cloud of excitations can either absorb or emit quanta of this mode producing a damping of the collective oscillation . we want to study the decay process in which a quantum of oscillation @xmath65 is annihilated ( created ) and the @xmath66-th excitation is transformed into the @xmath67-th one ( or viceversa ) . the energy is conserved during the transition process , therefore @xmath68 where we assume that @xmath69 . this mechanism is known as landau damping . another possible decay mechanism , also due to the coupling between collective and thermal excitations , is the beliaev damping @xcite , which is based on the decay of an elementary excitation into a pair of excitations . let us define the dissipation rate @xmath70 through the following relation between the energy of the system @xmath71 and its dissipation @xmath72 : @xmath73 assuming that the damping is small , one can use perturbation theory to calculate the probabilities for the transition between the @xmath66-th excitation and the @xmath74-th one , both available by thermal activation , yielding the following expression for the landau damping rate @xcite : @xmath75 where the transition frequencies @xmath76 are positive , and the delta function ensures the energy conservation during the transition process . we have assumed that the thermal cloud is at thermodynamic equilibrium and the states @xmath62 are thermally occupied with the usual bose factor @xmath77^{-1}$ ] . the `` damping strength '' has the dimensions of a frequency and is given by @xmath78 the matrix element that couples the low - energy collective mode ( @xmath79 ) with the higher energy single - particle excitations ( for which we use the indices @xmath62 ) is @xcite @xmath80 . \label{matrixel}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this work we calculate the quantities @xmath81 by using the numerical solutions @xmath24 and @xmath25 of eqs . ( [ groundstate]-[coupled2 ] ) into the integrals ( [ matrixel ] ) , avoiding the use of further approximations in the spectrum of excitations . in cylindrically symmetric traps , @xmath82 and from ( [ deltapsilong ] ) the longitudinal excitations are @xmath83 and the energies @xmath84 are not degenerate . we are interested in the decay of transverse collective excitations ( [ deltapsitrans ] ) @xmath85 , due to the coupling with thermally excited states ( @xmath62 ) . the functions @xmath86 and @xmath87 do not depend on @xmath0 , and from eq . ( [ matrixel ] ) it is straightforward to see that the matrix element @xmath88 couples only energy levels ( @xmath62 ) with the same quantum number @xmath89 , and @xmath90 . to calculate the damping rate @xmath91 of the collective oscillation we have to sum up over all couples of excited states ( @xmath62 ) , or equivalently , over all pairs of sets ( @xmath92 ) , that satisfy the above conditions . since @xmath1 is a continuous quantum number , the sum over @xmath1 becomes and integral and eq . ( [ damping2 ] ) yields @xmath93 where the sum is restricted to pairs that satisfy @xmath94 . the frequency of a mode is a continuous function of @xmath1 , therefore the transition frequency is @xmath95 . then , in eq . ( [ gamma2 ] ) the integration over @xmath1 yields @xmath96 ^{-1 } \label{gamma3}\ ] ] where @xmath97 is the wave vector in which the conservation of energy is verified , i.e. , @xmath98 , and we have used the known property of delta functions @xmath99 we want to calculate the characteristic decay rates due to landau damping of the transverse low - lying collective modes of an elongated bose - einstein condensate as a function of @xmath100 . we consider the collective excitations in the collisionless regime , which is achieved at low enough temperatures . for a fixed number of trapped atoms , the number of atoms in the condensate depends on temperature . at zero temperature the quantum depletion is negligible and all the atoms can be assumed to be in the condensate @xcite . at finite temperature the condensate atoms coexist with the thermal bath . however , at low enough temperatures the excitation spectrum can be safely calculated by neglecting the coupling between the condensate and thermal atoms @xcite . it means that the excitation energies at a given @xmath100 can be obtained within bogoliubov theory at @xmath101 normalizing the number of condensate atoms to the corresponding condensate fraction at that temperature and assuming that they are thermally occupied with the bose factor . in order to present numerical results we choose a gas of @xmath102rb atoms ( scattering length @xmath103 cm ) confined in an elongated cylindrical trap with frequencies @xmath104 and @xmath105 hz , that corresponds to an oscillator length @xmath106 cm . the number of condensate atoms per unit length is taken to be @xmath107 . these conditions are close to the experimental ones of ref . @xcite . we have solved the linearized gp equations to obtain an exact description of the ground state @xmath108 and the normal modes of the condensate within bogoliubov theory without using the thomas - fermi or hartree - fock approximations . we have obtained the following numerical results : @xmath109 , and the excitation frequencies of the transverse monopole @xmath110 , and of the transverse quadrupole mode @xmath111 . we have calculated the branches of the excitation spectrum of the cylindrical condensate , labeled by ( @xmath49 ) as a function of @xmath1 . to calculate the damping rate of a collective mode @xmath112 we have to obtain , first , all pairs of levels ( @xmath62 ) of the excitation spectrum that satisfy both the energy conservation of the transition process @xmath113 , and the selection rules given by the particular collective mode under study . and then , calculate the corresponding matrix elements . we have restricted our calculations to levels with energy @xmath114 . the contribution of higher excited levels can be neglected since their occupation becomes negligible in the range of temperatures we have considered . it is worth recalling that the dipole mode is undamped @xcite since it is not affected by two - body interactions . we have checked that within our formalism the landau damping of the transverse dipole mode is zero , as expected . first of all , we have calculated the landau damping of the transverse quadrupole mode ( @xmath52 , @xmath115 and @xmath116 ) as a function of @xmath100 , @xmath117 . for such a mode , the functions @xmath118 and @xmath87 depend on the radial coordinate @xmath119 and have also angular dependence ( @xmath120 ) . therefore , from eq . ( [ matrixel ] ) it follows the selection rules corresponding to transverse quadrupole - like transitions : @xmath121 and @xmath122 . only the energy levels ( @xmath62 ) that satisfy these conditions can be coupled by the interaction . the integration of the radial part has to be done numerically . fixed the number of condensate atoms , we have calculated the landau damping for the transverse quadrupole mode as a function of temperature . at zero temperature we have obtained the excitation spectrum within bogoliubov theory . we have found that there are @xmath123 pairs of levels that verify the transverse quadrupole selection rules and the energy condition ( [ selection ] ) at finite wave vectors , i.e. , at @xmath124 . we have calculated the matrix element @xmath88 for each allowed transition , and then , the corresponding damping strength @xmath125 at a given @xmath100 . summing up the damping strengths for all transitions , we have obtained the damping rate for the transverse quadrupole oscillation , due to the coupling with thermal excitations . in figure [ fig1 ] we plot the damping rate versus @xmath126 for the transverse quadrupole mode for a fixed number of condensate atoms per unit length in a cylindrical trap . as expected , landau damping increases with temperature since the number of excitations available at thermal equilibrium is larger when @xmath100 increases . one can distinguish two different regimes , one at very low @xmath100 ( @xmath127 ) and the other at higher @xmath128 where damping is linear with temperature . however , this linear behaviour appears at relatively small temperature ( @xmath129 ) in comparison to the homogeneous system @xcite where this regime occurs at @xmath130 . for the highly elongated condensate of ref . @xcite , it has been measured at @xmath131 a quality factor @xcite for the transverse quadrupole mode @xmath132 which gives a damping rate @xmath133 . this value is in agreement with our calculations of the landau damping for this mode ( see fig . 1 ) . a more quantitative comparison is not possible at present due to the absence of detailed measurements of the damping of this mode . however , it is reasonable to conclude that the transverse quadrupole mode in elongated condensates decays via landau damping . it is worth noting that the order of magnitude of the damping rate of the transverse quadrupole mode is the same as the one previously estimated for a uniform gas @xcite , for spherical traps @xcite and for anisotropic traps @xcite as well . the landau damping for other modes can be calculated analogously . however , the physical situation for the decay of the singular transverse monopole mode turns out to be much more complicated . formally the calculations can be committed in the same way . the quantum numbers for this mode are @xmath52 , @xmath134 and @xmath135 . the functions @xmath136 and @xmath87 depend only on the radial coordinate @xmath137 , and the matrix element @xmath88 couples only energy levels ( @xmath138 ) with the same quantum numbers @xmath43 and @xmath1 . that is , the selection rules corresponding to transverse monopole - like transitions are @xmath122 ( as we have already discussed in the previous section ) and @xmath139 . from the spectrum of elementary excitations , we have found that there are only @xmath140 pairs of levels that verify the transverse monopole selection rules and the energy condition ( [ selection ] ) at @xmath141 . the damping strengths associated to the allowed transitions are smaller than the @xmath125 values associated to quadrupole - like transitions . as a result from our calculations the damping occurs quite small . at @xmath142 we obtain a landau damping @xmath143 that is one order of magnitude smaller than the experimental decay @xcite @xmath144 measured in @xcite . thus , landau damping can not explain the experimentally observed decay of the transverse breathing mode . actually , there are reasons to believe that even this small value of landau damping obtained in the present calculations , could be larger than the true one . the point is that in our calculations , based on perturbation theory , the thermal cloud is assumed to be in the state of thermodynamic equilibrium and thus one can neglect its motion . this is correct for the case of quadrupole oscillations , where the frequencies of the collective motion of the condensate and the cloud are different . however , due to the unique peculiar nature of the 2d breathing mode , the breathing oscillation of the thermal cloud has the same frequency @xmath145 as the condensate . then , if the oscillation is excited by the deformation of the trap , as it takes place in the present experiment @xcite , the cloud will oscillate in phase with the condensate what will further decrease the landau damping @xcite . therefore , this quasi-2d monopole mode in highly elongated condensates may decay via another damping mechanism , different from the landau damping . after finishing this work it has appeared a preprint by jackson and zaremba @xcite in which the effect of the collisions between elementary excitations has been taken also into account . this effect is usually small in comparison with the landau damping . nevertheless , for this peculiar mode the collisions seems to be the dominant damping mechanism , yielding a decay rate that it is in agreement with the experimentally measured value @xcite . note , however , that the experiments are produced at quite high amplitude of oscillations and non - linear effects can play an important role . for example , as it was noted in @xcite , the transverse breathing mode exhibits a parametric instability due to the decay into two or more excitations with non - zero momentum along the axis . in ref . @xcite it has been considered the process in which the transverse breathing oscillation decays into two excitations propagating along @xmath0 with momentum @xmath1 and @xmath146 . this damping mechanism is active also at zero temperature . but in this case the damping rate depends on the amplitude of the breathing oscillation . we have investigated the decay of low - lying transverse oscillations of a large cylindrical condensate . first of all , we have calculated the transverse normal modes , as well as the excitations with finite @xmath1 , of the condensate by solving the linearized time - dependent gross - pitaevskii equation . and then , within the formalism of ref . @xcite , we have calculated numerically the matrix elements associated with the transitions between excited states allowed by the selection rules of the transverse collective modes . within a first - order perturbation theory and assuming the thermal cloud to be in thermodynamic equilibrium , we have studied the landau damping of transverse collective modes due to the coupling with thermal excited levels as a function of temperature . for the damping rate of the transverse quadrupole mode , we have found a good agreement with the experimentally measured value of ref . @xcite . whereas our result for the transverse breathing mode is one order of magnitude smaller than the experimental decay . one can conclude that in a highly elongated cylindrically symmetric condensate , transverse quadrupole oscillations decay via landau damping mechanism , but the transverse breathing mode which has an anomalously small measured damping rate , may decay via other damping mechanisms . we thank j. dalibard , g. shlyapnikov and e. zaremba for useful discussions . m. g. thanks the `` ramon y cajal program '' of the mcyt ( spain ) for financial support . note that the perturbative calculations of the landau damping can correspond to a different type of experiment , in which the oscillations of the condensate are excited by the action of a thin laser beam on the condensate , but not on the thermal cloud . in this case the perturbative calculations will describe the initial stage of the process , when the cloud is still at rest . as it was presented in the lecture by e. zaremba @xcite , the landau damping corresponding to this type of experiment was calculated using the method developed in ref . @xcite in an elongated condensate with the same experimental parameters of ref . however , they have obtained larger values for the landau damping of the transverse breathing mode in comparison with our results . this discrepancy could be related to the semiclassical nature of their method @xcite , which does not take into account the discrete nature of the energy spectrum , and also to the fact that they consider a cigar - shaped condensate instead of an infinite cylinder as in the present calculations . the finite value of the longitudinal frequency @xmath147 could be important for this transverse breathing mode . therefore , this is still an interesting open problem .

we study the interaction between low - lying transverse collective oscillations and thermal excitations of an elongated bose - einstein condensate by means of perturbation theory . we consider a cylindrically trapped condensate and calculate the transverse elementary excitations at zero temperature by solving the linearized gross - pitaevskii equations in two dimensions . we use them to calculate the matrix elements between thermal excited states coupled with the quasi-2d collective modes . the landau damping of transverse collective modes is investigated as a function of temperature . at low temperatures , the damping rate due to the landau decay mechanism is in agreement with the experimental data for the decay of the transverse quadrupole mode , but it is too small to explain the slow experimental decay of the transverse breathing mode . the reason for this discrepancy is discussed .

1202.3986

the approximate bcs solution of the pairing hamiltonian has been extensively used in condensed matter to study pairing correlations in ultra - small metallic grains @xcite . a much better approximation is given by the density matrix renormalization group @xcite . but , the pairing hamiltonian admits an exact solution worked out by richardson at the beginning of the sixties @xcite . a more recent derivation of the exact solution can be found in ref . the first application of the richardson exact solution was done in ultra - small grains system @xcite . references @xcite and @xcite marks the resurgence of the richardson s exact solution of the pairing hamiltonian . the acknowledge to richardson in refs . @xcite constitutes a recognition to him after forty years in the oblivion . the richardson exact solution has been used to study the effect of the resonant single - particle states on the pairing hamiltonian @xcite . in ref . @xcite the authors gave an interpretation of the pair energies from the richardson solution . they relate the pairing correlations with the pair energies distribution in the complex plane . the pairing hamiltonian is not only exactly soluble but also quantum integrable @xcite . besides the constant pairing , a very special kind of separable pairing interaction also admits an exact solution @xcite . a review on exact solutions of the pairing hamiltonian can be found in the ref . @xcite . the pairing hamiltonian approximates the influence of the residual interaction acting among the valence states lying close to the fermi level . however , it is an open question how one must treat pairing in the continuum . previous studies on the contribution from the continuum to pairing have been reported in refs . @xcite . in this paper we reformulate the problem of determining the exact eigenenergies of the pairing hamiltonian when the continuum is included . real and complex energy representations of the continuum are used . the bcs approximation is not a convenient tool to treat many - body pairing close to the drip line @xcite . it is the intention of this paper to give an exact treatment of the many - body pairing which overcomes the drawbacks of the bcs treatment . the paper is organized as follows . section [ sec.method ] briefly reviews the derivation of the richardson equations with the continuum represented on the real energy axis or in the complex energy plane . in sec . [ sec.result ] the low lying states of even carbon isotopes are evaluated and a comparison of the solutions using the real energy representation are compared with the ones obtained in the complex energy representation . the trajectory of the pair energies are analyzed as a function of the pairing strength . the continuum pair energies are introduced in this section . finally , sec . [ sec.discussion ] summarizes the main results of the paper . in this section the richardson equations for a continuum basis is given . first the continuum is included by enclosing the system in a large spherical box . after the final equations have been obtained , we take the limit of the box to infinity and introduce the single particle level density . in order to avoid the fermi gas we take the derivative of the phase shift for the continuum part of the single particle level density @xcite . finally , we parametrized the cspld for the resonant partial waves and make the analytic continuation to the complex energy plane . in this sub - section we follow the derivation of the exact solution as it was given by jan von delft and fabian braun in ref . the inclusion of the system in a large spherical box provides a finite discrete set of negative ( bound ) energies and an infinite discrete set of positive ( continuum ) energies . let us called @xmath2 the discrete energy with degeneracy @xmath3 , with @xmath4 . the pairing hamiltonian is given by , @xmath5 with @xmath6 . we introduce the pair creation operator @xmath7 which creates a pair of time reversal states with quantum number @xmath8 . following von delft and braun @xcite , who were inspired by a suggestion by richardson , we propose the @xmath9-body ( @xmath10 ) eigenfunction as the antisymmetrised product of @xmath11 wave functions as , @xmath12 where the energies @xmath13 are related to the eigenvalues @xmath14 of the hamiltonian @xmath15 by @xmath16 in order to meet the eigenvalue equation @xmath17 , the parameters @xmath13 , called pair energies , must verify the following set of @xmath11 couple system of equations @xcite @xmath18 where the first summation contains negative and positive energies . the interpretation of this set of equations , called richardson equations , is that the many - body fermions with pairing force behave like the many - boson system with one - body force . both systems are described by the same wave function with the difference that the fermions have to satisfy the richardson equations ( [ eq.rich ] ) in order to fulfill the pauli principle @xcite . in making the limit of the box to infinity the single particle states becomes more and more dense . in that limit the sum becomes an integral , i. e. , @xmath19 the single particle density @xmath20 is the sum of the bound ( negative energy ) states plus the continuum ( positive energy ) states . we make the anzatz that the single particle density in the continuum is given by the derivative of the phase shift @xcite , @xmath21 the index @xmath22 refers to bound states and @xmath23 to continuum states . the first summation is over the valence bound states while the second one is over the continuum partial waves . in practical applications an upper limit @xmath24 is set for the number of partial waves . the richardson equations in a representation which includes the continuum becomes , @xmath25 where the factor @xmath26 takes into account the blocking effect of the @xmath27 unpaired states @xcite . the cspld becomes , @xmath28 the presence of the single particle resonances appear in the cspld , as well as in the cross sections , as bumps . they correspond to states in the continuum ( positive energy states ) which are well localized inside the nuclear surface for a time greater than the characteristic nuclear time @xcite . one can thus split the summation in resonant ( @xmath29 ) and non - resonant ( @xmath30 ) ( background ) contributions as , @xmath31 the single particle density for the resonant states at energies @xmath32 and widths @xmath33 can be written as @xcite . @xmath34 the resonant parameters can be represented by a single complex number @xmath35 which corresponds to the eigenvalue of the mean - field hamiltonian with pure outgoing boundary condition @xcite . by rotating the integration contour of the resonant part of the cspld to the negative imaginary axis , and applying the cauchy theorem , one gets the richardson equations in terms of the complex energy states , @xmath36 where @xmath37 in an overstatement ( the `` density '' @xmath38 can not be defined outside the integral ) one could say that the background contribution to the richardson equation has a real part coming from the non - resonant scattering partial wave states @xmath39 and a complex contribution @xmath38 which is a remnant of the complex analytic extension from @xmath40 . because the presence of the complex energy gamow states in the second summation in eq . ( [ eq.rich2 ] ) , the complex contribution of @xmath38 is necessary to make @xmath41 real . in eq . ( [ eq.rich2 ] ) we have assumed that there is not blocking effect due to continuum states . for the seniority zero case and neglecting the background , eq . ( [ eq.rich2 ] ) reduces to the richardson equations in the gamow basis introduced in ref . @xcite . in this case the complex pairing energies are not complex conjugate to each other , i.e. @xmath41 may be complex . the solution of the richardson equations ( [ eq.rich_cont ] ) with the `` boundary condition '' , @xmath42 and the blocking effect , determine the ground state and the excited state energies of the pairing hamiltonian . the @xmath43c nucleus has three bound configurations ( sec . [ sec.sp ] ) . the first @xmath44 and second @xmath45 configurations can accommodate a single pair , while the third configuration @xmath46 can accommodate three pairs . the configurations @xmath44 , @xmath45 , and @xmath46 are related to the single particle states @xmath47 , @xmath48 , and @xmath49 , respectively . then @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 . from the bound configurations we can accommodate up to five pairs ( @xmath53c ) . because the inclusion of the continuum we will be able to go beyond the nucleus @xmath53c . the ground state ( g.s . ) configuration for a system with @xmath11 corresponds to fill the lowest @xmath11 configurations by solving the richardson eq . ( [ eq.rich_cont ] ) with the blocking coefficient @xmath54 because the g.s . has seniority zero and there are no unpaired states ( all @xmath55 ) . for example , the g.s . of the isotope @xmath56c corresponds to solving one single richardson equation ( [ eq.rich_cont ] ) with the boundary condition @xmath57 . let us called this configuration @xmath58 . the g.s . of the isotope @xmath59c corresponds to solving two richardson equations ( [ eq.rich_cont ] ) with the boundary conditions @xmath60 and @xmath61 . this is the configuration @xmath62 , and so on . the ground state energy @xmath14 is given by eq . ( [ eq.e ] ) with @xmath63 and so on . we have to distinguish between excited states with seniority zero and seniority two . + _ seniority zero ( @xmath64 ) : _ the seniority zero excited states are found by solving as many equations ( [ eq.rich_cont ] ) as pairs , like for the g.s . , but with a boundary condition other than the ground state . for example , the first and second @xmath65 excited states of @xmath56c are found as the solution of a single equation with the boundary conditions @xmath61 , and @xmath66 , respectively . we called such configurations @xmath67 and @xmath68 . as a second example let us consider the first @xmath65 excited state of @xmath69c . it is found by solving three equations ( [ eq.rich_cont ] ) with the boundary conditions @xmath57 , @xmath70 , and @xmath66 . we called this configuration @xmath71 . the energy @xmath14 of the @xmath64 excited state is like eq . ( [ eq.e ] ) but using the excited pair energies . _ seniority two ( @xmath72 ) : _ the seniority two states are found by solving @xmath73 equations ( [ eq.rich_cont ] ) , where @xmath74 is the mass number of the isotope . this is one equation less than the number of pairs in the ground state . the factor @xmath75 in eq . ( [ eq.rich_cont ] ) is given by @xmath26 , where @xmath76 labels the blocking configuration . for example , to find the @xmath72 states in @xmath56c one does not need to solve any equation since @xmath77 . the @xmath72 state energy is just the sum of the single particle energies @xmath78 of the unpaired levels @xmath79 and @xmath80 . let us assumed that the blocking states for the isotope @xmath59c are the configurations @xmath45 and @xmath46 , i. e. @xmath81 , and @xmath82 . then , we have to solve a single equation with @xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath85 and the boundary condition @xmath60 . let us call this configuration @xmath86 which gives the degenerate levels @xmath87 . the energy of such a state is @xmath88 . as the last example , let us consider the first @xmath89 states in @xmath69c . this level in found by solving two equations with the boundary conditions @xmath90 and @xmath61 , and with @xmath91 and @xmath92 . the energy of this last state is @xmath93 . in order to determine the strength @xmath94 we consider the neutron pairing energy @xmath95 for a system of @xmath10 valence neutrons @xcite @xmath96 the pairing energy in the richardson model is related to the last pair energy @xmath97 as follows @xcite , @xmath98 \;.\ ] ] by imposing the condition @xmath99 one finds the strength @xmath94 which reproduces @xmath97 . the criterion to decide whether a given partial wave is resonant is to search for the poles @xmath100 of @xmath101 . a physical resonance should satisfy that the half - life calculated with the imaginary part @xmath102 of the pole @xmath103 is bigger than the characteristic time @xmath104 sec . @xcite . the physical meaning of this criterion is that the particle has enough time to interact with the system before it decays . this sub - section aims to define the real and complex single particle representations . the parameters for the interaction are also set up here . the real energy representation consists of a finite discrete set of bound states plus a positive real continuum set of scattering states . while the complex energy representation consists of a finite discrete set of bound and gamow states plus a complex continuum set of scattering states " . in the complex energy representation we named resonant continuum the set of gamow states and non - resonant continuum to the scattering states with complex energy . the experimental single particle energies in @xmath105c were taken from ref . @xcite : @xmath106 mev , @xmath107 mev , and @xmath108 mev . the single particle density of @xmath105c was calculated with the program @xcite with the following woods - saxon parameters : @xmath109 mev , @xmath110 mev , @xmath111 fm , @xmath112 fm . [ fig.1 ] compares the cspld for @xmath113 and @xmath114 . it shows that a cut - off of @xmath115 in eq . ( [ eq.g ] ) is enough for this system . neutron cspld in @xmath43c for two different angular momentum cutoff.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] the negative contribution in fig . [ fig.1 ] is due to the dominance of the @xmath116 state at low energy . in accordance to the levinson theorem , it must be a negative contribution for each bound state . for the @xmath116 state this negative contribution is close to the continuum threshold . the resonant behavior around @xmath117 mev is due to the resonant state @xmath118 , while the one around @xmath119 mev is due the wide resonance @xmath120 . using the code gamow @xcite we find the following energies for these two states , @xmath121 mev , and @xmath122 mev . from the experimental mass excess table we got for the pairing energy @xmath123 of the isotope @xmath56c , @xmath124 mev . in the richardson model the pairing energy is related to the pair energy through @xmath125 ( sec . [ sec.ps ] ) . for @xmath56c , @xmath126 , then @xmath127 with @xmath128 mev and @xmath129 mev . in order to reproduce @xmath130 with a cutoff energy at @xmath131 mev , one must take @xmath132 mev . using the parametrization @xmath133 we obtained @xmath134 for @xmath135 . this value of @xmath136 is used for all carbon isotopes . table [ table.g ] lists the value of the pairing strength for each carbon isotope . .[table.g]pairing strength used for the carbon isotopes . [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] the effect of the resonant continuum was already investigated in ref . in order to investigate the effect of the non resonant continuum on the many - body correlations we compare in fig . [ fig.22ccxmpl ] the ground state energy of the nucleus @xmath53c as a function of the pairing strength for three different model spaces : ( i ) bound : @xmath137 , ( ii ) resonant : @xmath138 , and ( iii ) continuum ( secc . [ sec.real ] ) . it is observed that the resonant and non resonant continuum states can be neglected as long as the pairing force is not very strong @xcite . as the interaction increases the continuum starts to be important . the curve labeled as continuum representation " gives the ground state energy when the resonant and non resonant continuum is included in the representation through the cspld . the figure shows clearly the energy gain due to the inclusion of the continuum . the curve labeled as resonant representation " gives the energy when only the resonant states are included in the representation . for very big strength the non resonant continuum becomes as important as the resonant continuum . ground state energy of @xmath53c versus pairing strength @xmath94 for three different model spaces.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] let us compare the evolution of the pair energies @xmath139 in the bound and the resonant representation versus the pairing strength . figure [ fig.cx-b ] shows @xmath139 for @xmath94 from @xmath140 mev to @xmath141 mev in the nucleus @xmath53c . the continuum ( dot ) line corresponds to bound ( resonant ) representation . the deeper pair energy @xmath142 is little affected by the model space ( one can not distinguish between the two curves ) . the other pairs are more affected for big value of the strength . the difference diminishes as the interaction decreases . the same effect was observed in the ground state energy ( fig . [ fig.22ccxmpl ] ) . the pairs @xmath143 and @xmath144 are complex conjugate partners for @xmath145 mev and they move at the same pace as @xmath94 changes . when they become real @xmath143 approaches to the uncorrelated pair energy @xmath146 while @xmath144 moves faster to the uncorrelated pair energy @xmath147 . the pairs @xmath148 and @xmath149 remain complex conjugate for all no zero values of the strength . pair energies in the ground state @xmath53c versus pairing strength @xmath94 for @xmath140 mev to @xmath141 mev . the continuum line corresponds to the bound representation while the dot line corresponds to the resonant representation . the arrows point in the direction of decreasing @xmath94.,scaledwidth=43.0% ] as a last application we will calculate the evolution of pair energies in the continuum , i.e. pair energies with positive real component . to this aim let us study the nucleus @xmath1c with eight pairs . [ fig.28ccxmpl ] shows the evolution of the pairs for strength from @xmath150 mev to @xmath151 mev . the bound ( negative real component ) pairs @xmath142 to @xmath149 follow a trajectory similar to that in @xmath53c with the difference that the complex partners @xmath152 and @xmath153 are only approximately complex conjugate to each other . they become truly complex conjugate partners as the interaction approaches zero . on the other hand , the pairs in the continuum show a striking behavior . the typical movement to the right is not follow by all the positive energy pairs , i.e the continuum pairs may converge to its uncorrelated energy from right or left as @xmath94 decreases . besides , the pairs seem to converge to the real part of the uncorrelated pair energy @xmath154 $ ] when @xmath155 is a gamow state . evolution of the pair energies in the ground state of @xmath1c as a function of the pairing strength @xmath94 from @xmath150 mev to @xmath151 mev . the arrows point in the direction of decreasing @xmath94.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] the contribution of this paper to the exact solution of the pairing hamiltonian is the inclusion of the resonant and non resonant continuum through the continuum single particle level density ( cspld ) . the gamow states , which appear in the complex energy representation , provide the main contribution from the continuum . it is worthwhile to point out that in the representation these states have exactly the same status as bound states . the difference is that the states in the continuum are no affected by blocking effects . the inclusion of the continuum has allowed us to study the unbound isotope @xmath0c and beyond . it was found that the continuum pairs ( pair energies with positive real components ) converge to the real part of the uncorrelated pair energy and they do not appear in complex conjugate partners . as a consequence the total energy may be complex . it was shown that from the exact solution of the pairing hamiltonian the cspld can be used to investigate the effects of the resonant and non resonant continuum states upon the many - body pairing correlations . 31ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop ( ) @noop ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( )

the pairing hamiltonian constitutes an important approximation in many- body systems , it is exactly soluble and quantum integrable . on the other hand , the continuum single particle level density ( cspld ) contains information about the continuum energy spectrum . the question whether one can use the hamiltonian with constant pairing strength for correlations in the continuum is still unanswered . in this paper we generalize the richardson exact solution for the pairing hamiltonian including correlations in the continuum . the resonant and non - resonant continuum are included through the cspld . the resonant correlations are made explicit by using the cauchy theorem . low lying states with seniority zero and two are calculated for the even carbon isotopes . we conclude that energy levels can indeed be calculated with constant pairing in the continuum using the cspld . it is found that the nucleus @xmath0c is unbound . the real and complex energy representation of the continuum is developed and their differences are shown . the trajectory of the pair energies in the continuum for the nucleus @xmath1c is shown .

astro-ph0007110

cyg x-1 is a persistent x - ray source believed to be powered by accretion onto a black hole from a massive companion . most of the time cyg x-1 spends in the hard state and sometimes it switches to the soft state ( see , e.g. , liang & nolan 1984 ; zhang et al . 1997 ; poutanen 1998 ; gierliski et al . the x - ray luminosity above @xmath2 is estimated to be about @xmath3 ( gierliski et al . 1997 ) , assuming the distance to the source , @xmath4 ( massey , johnson , & degioia - eastwood 1995 ; malysheva 1997 ) . variability of cyg x-1 was extensively studied with various instruments ( see , e.g. , ling et al . 1987 ; gilfanov et al . 1995 ; phlips et al . 1996 ; kuznetsov et al . 1997 ; paciesas et al . 1997 ; wen et al . 1999 ; brocksopp et al . 1999 ; bauciska - church et al . 2000 ) . these studies show the stability of the hard state of cyg x-1 . the photon flux above 50 kev is normally @xmath5 with variations by a factor 2 . in this letter , we analyze the period of the unusually strong hard x - ray activity of cyg x-1 on 1999 april 21 . two strong outbursts activated the batse/_cgro _ ( fishman et al . 1989 ) onboard trigger . we analyze the temporal structure of the outbursts in the four lad energy channels 14 , estimate the peak luminosity of cyg x-1 , and discuss possible implications for theoretical models of accretion in this object . the unusual activity of cyg x-1 can be traced back to 1999 april 19 ( tjd 11287 ) . two events recorded on april 19 were found in the batse data during search for non - triggered gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) ( stern et al . 1999 , 2000a ) . the best fit locations were within @xmath6 from cyg x-1 ( @xmath7 errors exceeded @xmath8 for those events ) . we use the location procedure described in stern et al . ( 2000b ) which is similar to that used for grb location by pendleton et al . the estimated peak fluxes above 50 kev were about 0.3 and @xmath9 which is high as compared with the normal flux from cyg x-1 . on april 20 , batse detectors were triggered by another event with right ascension , @xmath10 , and declination , @xmath11 ( batse estimate , note also that this event is identified as a grb in the batse data base ) . again , the location was close to cyg x-1 ( slightly beyond 1@xmath12 error circle ) . and @xmath13 . ] the peak flux of this event was about @xmath14 . on april 21 , the two brightest outbursts occurred , with the interval @xmath15 hours . between and after the two outbursts , cyg x-1 demonstrated nothing unusual , being in the hard state with normal luminosity . the summary of all the five events is given in table 1 . we will concentrate on the two brightest events on april 21 ( two last lines in table 1 ) . the locations of both events coincide with the location of cyg x-1 with 2@xmath16 accuracy . in principle , it might be accidental projections of grbs on cyg x-1 . the probability that one of @xmath17 detected grbs with comparable brightness will appear within 2@xmath16 from cyg x-1 is about 0.3 . however , the probability of appearance of two such grbs from the same location within 2.5 hours is low , @xmath18 . besides , the long duration of the events , @xmath19 s , is very unusual for grbs . one concludes that the events are outbursts of cyg x-1 . table 1 + summary of outbursts on 1999 april 19 - 21 [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,>",options="header " , ] we then compute the cross - correlation coefficient between channels 2 and 3 , @xmath20 ) ( see table 4 ) . the cross - correlation decreases during the outbursts and becomes very low in interval e. it confirms that the soft component gets so soft that it practically does not contribute to the signal in channel 3 . in interval f , the cross - correlation is high , confirming that the soft component has disappeared and we see only the second ( hard ) component in all the three channels . the luminosities of the soft and hard components can be roughly estimated from the step - like cut offs at 64.05 ks and 64.1 ks , respectively . the average luminosity of cyg x-1 in time interval e above 50 kev ( 30 kev ) is @xmath21 ( @xmath22 ) in the soft component and @xmath23 ( @xmath24 ) in the hard component . the normal hard state of cyg x-1 was studied using the earth occultations which occur on each orbit of the _ cgro_. the step in the light curve at the moment of occultation shows the amplitude of the signal from cyg x-1 in each energy channel . the study of cyg x-1 with this method was done by ling et al . ( 1997 ) and paciesas et al . we performed a similar analysis for @xmath25 occultations and evaluated the flux from cyg x-1 and the hardness ratio @xmath26 ( ratio of the signal count rates in channels 3 and 2 ) for each occultation . the results are shown in figure 2 . the observed large dispersion in the hardness ratio may be caused by the measurement errors rather than intrinsic variability of cyg x-1 . to estimate the errors we did a similar analysis of 80 occultations of the crab nebula which is known to be a steady source . we found @xmath27 and the count rate @xmath28 , where the errors represent the standard deviations . the major cause of the errors is the uncertainty in the changing background ( to have good statistics one has to fit the signal on a relatively long period @xmath29 s before and after the occultation , and the background curvature plays a role ) . one should note that the error in the hardness ratio of cyg x-1 is likely to be smaller than that for the crab since its flux is larger . in the outbursts , these errors are even smaller . = 7.5 cm for comparison we also show the estimates of the flux and hardness ratio for the two april 21 outbursts . note that outburst 11289c and interval f of outburst 11289e have hardness ratios similar to the normal hard state . interval e of outburst 11289e is significantly softer . the presence of two emission components ( soft , highly variable , and hard , with lower variability ) in outburst 11289e is intriguing . are they present in the normal state of cyg x-1 ? in the sample of 63 occultations we found that the fractional rms of the count rate ( i.e. the ratio of the rms to the mean count rate ) in channel 2 was higher than that in channel 3 in 47 cases . this indicates higher variability in channel 2 ( the probability of such an accidental excess is @xmath30 ) . the decreasing of the variability with energy was also observed in the 240 kev band ( nowak et al . 1999 ; revnivtsev et al . these facts are consistent with the presence of a hard component with a low variability though this interpretation is not unique . note also that gierliski et al . ( 1997 ) got the best fit to the broad - band x - ray spectrum of cyg x-1 with two thermal comptonization components of different temperatures . the hard state of cyg x-1 has been a puzzle since its discovery . the standard accretion disk model ( shakura & sunyaev 1973 ) was not able to explain the x - ray spectrum , and two modifications of the model were suggested : a two - temperature hot disk and an active corona atop the standard disk ( see beloborodov 1999a for a recent review ) . the advective hot - disk models ( e.g. esin et al . 1998 ) are consistent with the observed spectrum and luminosity of cyg x-1 if the accretion rate has a specific value @xmath31 @xmath32 and the viscosity parameter @xmath33 . here @xmath36 @xmath37 is the eddington luminosity . small variations in the accretion rate , @xmath38 , were predicted to destroy the hard state ( esin et al . 1998 ; but see also zdziarski 1998 ) . by contrast , the luminosity of cyg x-1 is known to vary by a factor of two without substantial changes in the spectral shape ( e.g. , paciesas et al . 1997 ; gierliski et al . such fluctuations already challenged the model , and the hard outbursts analyzed in this letter are even more difficult to explain . the model would work only assuming a specific dependence @xmath39 that keeps @xmath40 ; @xmath41 then should be about unity at the peak of the outburst . in the context of the disk - corona model , the outbursts can be interperted as an enhanced coronal activity of the accretion disk . in this model , the x - ray spectral slope is controlled by one parameter , the feedback factor due to x - ray reprocessing by the disk . the hard - state spectrum of cyg x-1 is well explained if the coronal plasma is ejected away from the disk with a mildly relativistic velocity @xmath42 ( beloborodov 1999b ; malzac , beloborodov , & poutanen 2001 ) . alternatively , the observed emission may be produced by a static corona atop a strongly ionized disk ( e.g. , ross , fabian , & young 1999 ; nayakshin 1999 ) . the corona becomes @xmath43dominated at high luminosities and its temperature decreases ( e.g. , svensson 1984 ; stern et al . 1995 ; poutanen & svensson 1996 ) . pair creation may cause the shift of the spectral break in outburst 11289e to smaller energies . cyg x-1 is a massive x - ray binary and it may be fed mainly by the donor wind . then the pattern of accretion can change completely compared to the standard viscous @xmath44disk or its modifications . the captured wind matter has a low angular momentum , just about critical for disk formation ( illarionov & sunyaev 1975 ) . under such conditions , a small - scale inviscid disk forms , which accretes super - sonically ( beloborodov & illarionov 2001 ) . the disk forms in the ring - like caustic of the accretion flow where energy is liberated in inelastic collision of gas streams . a comptonized power - law spectrum is then emitted with a standard break at @xmath29 kev , and it has appearance of a normal hard state of cyg x-1 . the two - component emission in outburst 11289e probably requires a two - zone emission model . for instance , the soft component may be associated with a variable coronal emission atop the disk , and the hard component with an inner relativistic jet . a corona - jet model was recently proposed by brocksopp et al . ( 1999 ) based on correlations between the x - rays and the radio emission observed in cyg x-1 . the april 1999 outbursts were , however , too short to have a significant impact on the flux in radio and no substantial changes were detected ( r. fender and g. pooley , private communication ) . in the context of the wind - fed accretion model , the two - component emission can naturally appear if viscous accretion disk and wind - disk collision are both operating in the source . concluding , the 1999 april 21 outbursts are the brightest events detected from cyg x-1 by batse during 9 years of its operation . the hard x - ray luminosity above 30 kev was in excess of @xmath45 . unfortunately , there are no simultaneous observations in the soft x - rays , so that one can only guess what was the total luminosity . the large luminosity and unusual spectral behavior challenge the theoretical models of accretion in cyg x-1 . we thank rob fender , guy pooley , and jerry bonnell for useful discussions . we are grateful to rob preece and geoff pendleton for providing the code for computing the detector response matrix and an anonymous referee for useful comments that significantly improved the paper . this research has made use of data obtained through the high energy astrophysics science archive research center online service , provided by the nasa / goddard space flight center . this work was supported by the swedish natural science research council , the swedish royal academy of sciences , the wenner - gren foundation for scientific research , the anna - greta and holger crafoord fund , and rfbr grant 00 - 02 - 16135 . paciesas , w. s. , robinson , c. r. , mccollough , m. l. , zhang , s. n. , harmon , b. a. , wilson , c. a. 1997 , in aip conf . 410 , proc . of the 4th compton symposium , ed . c. d. dermer , m. s. strickman , & j. m. kurfess ( new york : aip ) , 834 stern , b. e. , tikhomirova , ya . , kompaneets , d. , stepanov , m. , berezhnoy , a. , & svensson , r. 1999 , in asp conf . ser . 190 , gamma - ray bursts : the first three minutes , ed . j. poutanen , r. svensson ( san francisco : asp ) , 253

a very high activity of cygnus x-1 on 1999 april 19 - 21 was recorded by batse large area detectors onboard the _ compton gamma - ray observatory ( cgro)_. the peak luminosity was one order of magnitude higher than the normal luminosity of cyg x-1 . this fact can be critical for models of the hard state of cyg x-1 . the longest outburst lasted @xmath0 s and demonstrated very unusual temporal and spectral behavior which indicates the presence of two emission components . one component is relatively soft ( with a cutoff below @xmath1 ) and highly variable , and the other one is hard ( extending above 100 kev ) , with much slower variability .

1011.2070

the polcor instrument is a combined imager , coronograph and polarimeter built for the nordic optical telescope ( not ) . polcor provides sharp images ( resolution down to 02 ) , has a well - defined psf ( resulting in a higher image contrast ) and a high - quality polarimeter . + we observed three sources using polcor / not : the binary s - type agb star w aql , and the two detached shell carbon stars u cam and dr ser . observations of the polarized light around the stars trace the circumstellar dust distribution and thus enables the search for structures and asymmetries in the circumstellar envelope . though this study the geometry of the mass loss can be investigated which will give important clues not only to the processes at play , but also to the transition from the agb phase to the planetary nebula phase . the circumstellar dust distribution around the binary star w aql is mapped and found to be asymmetric , both on large ( 10 ) and on smaller ( 1 ) scales ( fig . 1 ) . the large - scale images show what appears to be a dust - density enhancement on the south - west side of the star and the inner region appears bi - polar through the coronographic mask . these structures are in agreement with what could be expected from binary interaction .

stellar light from an agb star is scattered by the circumstellar dust and polarized in the direction perpendicular to the source . therefore , images of circumstellar envelopes around agb stars in polarized light traces the dust distribution and can be used to search for asymmetries , and to achieve a better understanding of the mechanisms at play when agb stars are transformed into planetary nebulae . the polcor instrument is a combined imager , polarimeter , and coronograph providing images with an angular resolution down to 02 . we have used it to map the dust distribution around three agb stars : w aql , and the detached shell sources dr ser , and u cam . w aql is a binary and we find indications of a bi - polar dust distribution around the star . the observations of the latter two sources clearly reveal the detached shells , likely the result of a brief , strongly enhanced mass - loss rate during the late evolution of these stars . mapping the detached shells gives us clues to the symmetry of the mass loss and important evolutionary processes .

0903.4463

gaining control over the external and the internal degrees of freedom of molecules is of great interest for a range of areas in molecular science . one approach , dating as far back as the 1920s @xcite , relies on the application of inhomogenous ( static or low frequency ) magnetic and electric fields . this has proven most useful for controlling the full three - dimensional motion of molecules , including control of the velocity distribution , bringing molecules to a stand still , storing them for extended periods of times and trapping them in a confined volume ( for a recent review see @xcite ) . an alternative and complementary approach relies on the use of non - resonant non - ionizing laser fields typically supplied by pulsed lasers . many studies during the last decade have shown that strong non - resonant laser fields can effectively manipulate the external degrees of freedom of isolated gas phase molecules . the manipulation results from laser - induced forces and torques due to the interaction between the induced dipole moment and the laser field itself . examples of manipulation include deflection @xcite , focusing @xcite and slowing @xcite of molecules through the dependence of the non - resonant polarizability interaction on the intensity distribution in a laser focus . likewise , the dependence of the induced dipole interaction on molecular orientation has proven highly useful for controlling the rotation of a variety of molecules @xcite . in particular , the spatial orientation of molecules can be sharply confined with respect to axes that are fixed in the laboratory . molecular manipulation by induced dipole forces extends beyond the external degrees of freedom and has also been demonstrated for the internal degrees of freedom such as vibrational motion @xcite in molecular hydrogen . notably , the electrical field from laser pulses can modify energy potential barriers such that photoinduced bond breakage of a small linear molecule is guided to yield a desired final product @xcite . in the case of larger molecules control of the lowest frequency vibrational modes attracts special interest since some of these modes correspond to motion along well - defined reaction coordinates separating two conformational minima ( conformers ) . although many molecules contain large number of conformers it is often just two conformers that dominate important chemical properties , for instance chirality . a particularly important example is found in axially chiral molecules @xcite such as biaryl systems . in these molecules rotation about a single stereogenic carbon - carbon ( c - c ) bond axis changes the molecule from one enantiomer into the opposite enantiomer ( mirror image ) . recently , we demonstrated that the laser - induced nonresonant polarizability interaction can also be used to influence the internal rotation of an axially chiral molecule around the stereogenic c - c bond axis @xcite . in particular , we showed that by fixing the c - c bond axis of a substituted biphenyl molecule in space , using laser induced alignment by a long laser pulse , it was possible to initiate torsional motion of the two phenyl rings by a short laser pulse polarized perpendicular to the fixed axis . the purpose of the present work is to extend our recent paper @xcite . in particular , we discuss our theoretical modelling in detail . a ns laser pulse aligns @xcite the stereogenic axis of 3,5-diflouro-3,5-dibromo - biphenyl ( dfdbrbph ) along its polarization . this enables a much shorter fs pulse , which we will refer to as the kick pulse , to both initiate torsional motion and set the molecule into rotation around the fixed axis . the internal as well as external rotational motion is monitored by fs time - resolved coulomb explosion imaging . the inset of fig . [ fig1 ] shows a model of the dfdbrbph molecule with the stereogenic axis marked by red . according to our quantum chemical calculations , the laser - free torsional potential , illustrated by the red dotted curve in fig . [ fig1 ] , has minima at dihedral angles of @xmath0 corresponding to the r@xmath1 and s@xmath1 enantiomeric forms , and where the dihedral angle is the angle between the two phenyl rings . the twisted equilibrium shape is characteristic of biphenyl compounds . the traditional view is that this non - planarity results from competition between stabilization via conjugation of the @xmath2-orbital systems and steric repulsion between the ortho - positioned atoms @xcite . we might mention that alternative explanations have recently been discussed @xcite . our strategy for controlling @xmath3 relies on a transient modification of the field - free potential curve by a fs kick pulse ( fig . [ fig1 ] ) . the modification , caused by the nonresonant polarizability interaction @xcite converts the initial stationary quantum states , localized near the minima of the torsional potential , into vibrational wave packets , i.e. , coherent superpositions of several quantum states . the temporal evolution of these wave packets gives rise to time - dependent torsional motion , and the grey and the black curves in fig . [ fig1 ] show the calculated expectation values of @xmath3 for a particular set of laser parameters . the stereogenic c - c bond axis is fixed in the laboratory frame by adiabatic alignment utilizing a moderately intense , linearly polarized ns laser pulse @xcite . the ns pulse is intense enough to keep the c - c axis tightly confined , yet weak enough to modify the torsional potential only slightly . the fs kick pulse is applied with its polarization perpendicular to the aligned c - c bond axis to ensure primarily influence on torsion while avoiding other possible vibrational motion . the dfdbrbph compound is prepared as a racemate and the experiment is carried out on isolated molecules at rotational temperatures of a few kelvin . under these conditions we have equal numbers of molecules initially localized in the @xmath4 or 39@xmath5 conformation ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) and no thermally induced transitions between the two conformations occur . the intense probe pulse , sent at time @xmath6 with respect to the kick pulse , removes several electrons from the molecules , thereby triggering coulomb explosion into ionic fragments . in particular , the br@xmath7 and f@xmath7 fragment ions recoil in the planes defined by the br- and f - phenyl rings . by recording the velocities of both ion species with two - dimensional ion imaging @xcite , we determine the instantaneous orientation of each of the two phenyl planes at the time of the probe pulse . between the br- and f - phenyl planes . the asymmetry in the potential is obtained by orienting the molecules ( here with the br - phenyl plane out of the paper ) , 3d aligning them , and by polarizing the kick pulse at an angle of 13@xmath5 with respect to the second most polarizable axis ( smpa ) ( see fig . [ fig2 ] ) . the red dotted curve at large times illustrates the laser - free time - independent torsional potential . for the s@xmath1 enantiomer , starting out with @xmath8 , the time varying potential induces an oscillatory motion ( grey curve ) corresponding to torsion confined within the initial well . by contrast , due to the induced asymmetry between the two wells , the initial r@xmath1 enantiomer is traversing the central torsional barrier , and ends up as an s@xmath1 enantiomer undergoing internal rotation ( black curve ) . the kick pulse has an intensity of @xmath9 w@xmath10@xmath11 and a duration of 1.0 ps ( fwhm ) . the torsional motion may be monitored by fs time - resolved coulomb explosion imaging . the inset shows a model of the dfdbrbph molecule with the sterogenic axis marked by red ( grey ) . ] to account for the motion of the nuclei of the dfdbrbph molecule we make use of two sets of coordinate systems ( see fig . [ fig2 ] ) : a molecular fixed ( mf ) frame attached to the molecule and a laboratory fixed ( lf ) frame specified by the lasers . the mf coordinates are chosen with the @xmath12 axis along the stereogenic axis pointing from the phenyl ring with the bromines towards the phenyl ring with the flourines , and the @xmath13 axis is chosen along the phenyl ring with the bromines . the lf coordinates are chosen with the @xmath14 axis along the polarization direction of the ns pulse and the @xmath15 axis along the kick pulse polarization direction . in agreement with the experimental observations ( cf . [ sec : results ] ) , we assume that the stereogenic axis of the dfdbrbph molecule is aligned along the @xmath14 axis . and the laboratory fixed @xmath16 coordinate axes . the dotted line indicates the second most polarizable axis ( smpa ) , which is located 11@xmath5 from the br - phenyl ring and 28@xmath5 from the f - phenyl ring . ] also , we neglect all normal modes , except the lowest one , which corresponds to torsion ( see sec . [ subsec : qmcalc ] for details on quantum chemical calculations , justifying , e.g. , this assumption ) . in this simplified situation and in the absence of the kick pulse the task is reduced to describing the coupled rotations of the two ( rigid ) phenyl rings of the molecule as given in the lf frame by the hamiltonian [ atomic units , @xmath17 , are used throughout unless indicated otherwise ] @xmath18 where @xmath19 , is the angle of the @xmath20 phenyl ring with respect to the kick pulse polarization axis , @xmath21 the moment of inertia for rotation of the @xmath20 phenyl ring around the stereogenic axis ( @xmath22 , @xmath23 ) and @xmath24 is the laser - free torsional potential as obtained from quantum chemical calculations ( fig . 3 ) . by changing the coordinates to the dihedral angle @xmath25 between the two phenyl rings and the weighted azimuthal angle @xmath26 , characterizing the rotation of the molecule , with @xmath27 , we obtain @xmath28 here @xmath29 is the total moment of inertia of the molecule for rotation around the stereogenic axis and @xmath30 is a relative moment of inertia for the two phenyl rings around the axis . a full rotation of either phenyl ring leaves us with the same molecule implying @xmath31-periodic boundary conditions of the eigenfunctions of @xmath32 from eq . , i.e. , @xmath33 , with @xmath34 and @xmath35 integers . we shall assume that this property also applies to @xmath36 and @xmath3 , so that we simply need to consider eigenfunctions @xmath37 of eq . that separates into rotation of the molecule as described by the @xmath31-periodic function @xmath38 and torsion accounted for by the @xmath31-periodic function @xmath39 . [ rigorously , the bounds for @xmath36 depend on @xmath3 @xcite . at the time scales of interest , however , a molecule generally only makes a small fraction of a full rotation so that the effect of @xmath36-@xmath3 coupling is negligible . ] the separation is physically motivated by considering the energy scales related to rotation and torsion . the energy scale of the prior is given by @xmath40ev . for torsion , on the other hand , the relevant energy is determined by the torsional potential , and a harmonic approximation of the potential near the minimum at @xmath41 yields a frequency corresponding to the energy @xmath42 mev . using that the period of motion is of the order planck s constant divided by the energy , we therefore see that the molecule rotates ( @xmath36 change ) on a nanosecond time scale , whereas the torsion ( @xmath3 change ) is of picosecond duration . the small energy separation of the rotational levels compared to that of the torsional levels implies that many rotational states will be occupied in thermal equillibrium . consequently , we expect the @xmath36 dynamics to behave classically ( see also fig . [ fig7 ] ) , and we only treat the torsional dynamics quantum mechanically . the torsion is described by the stationary schrdinger equation @xmath43 with @xmath44 denoting the energy eigenstates . to solve this equation we expand the hamiltonian onto an orthonormal basis of @xmath31-periodic functions , which we diagonalize . the eigenstates below the torsional barriers exhibit an almost exact fourfold degeneracy , and linear combinations of the approximately degenerate states will also be stable at the time scales of the experiment . in particular , we can produce such stable states that are localized in the wells of the torsional potential . we will denote these states by @xmath45 , with @xmath46 and @xmath47 the smallest @xmath48 of the four degenerate states . in fig . [ fig3 ] we show the first four energy eigenstates and the corresponding localized states along with the torsional potential . mev above the minimum of the torsional potential . from linear combinations of these we obtain the corresponding four localized states shown in ( b ) . the torsional potential is indicated with a dashed line . ] the experiment is generally carried out on a gas of molecules in a mixed state given by the density matrix @xmath49 with the @xmath50 s being weight factors that sum to unity , and where the latter sum includes the states above the torsional barrier . the kick pulse introduces dynamics that we determine from the alignment potential created by the pulse . by definition @xmath51 for the kick pulse , and we use a gaussian envelope @xmath52 ^ 2/2\}$ ] corresponding to an intensity full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of @xmath53 . we calculate the polarizability tensor in the mf frame as a function of the dihedral angle ( see table [ tab : table1 ] ) and consequently transform into the lf frame by the application of directional cosine matrices @xcite . we then arrive at the interaction @xmath54.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ cols="<,<,>,>,>,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] to a round - bottom flask equipped with a magnetic stirring bar under argon we add 3,5-difluorophenyl - boronic acid ( 474 mg , 3.0 mmol ) , 1,3,5-tribromobenzene ( 1134 mg , 3.6 mmol ) , and pd(pph@xmath55)@xmath56 ( 69.6 mg , 2 mol@xmath57 ) . the flask is then evacuated and backfilled with argon twice . to this mixture of solids we add toluene ( 18 ml , degassed ) , etoh ( 6 ml , degassed ) , and 2 m aq . na@xmath58co@xmath55 ( 3 ml , degassed ) . we next heat the mixture to 90@xmath5c under argon for 5.5 h and cool it to room temperature . the mixture is diluted with water and extracted three times with et@xmath58o . we dry the combined organic fractions with mgso@xmath56 , filter and concentrate to give approximately 1.4 g of a crude mixture . based on nmr we find that this mixture contains both the desired mono - suzuki coupling product @xcite , double - coupled products , and a homo - coupling product from the boronic acid . careful column chromatography on sio@xmath58 eluting with n - hexane and c - hexane finally allows us to isolate 182 mg 3,5-dibromo-3,5-difluorobiphenyl ( dfdbrbph ) as a white amorphous solid ( contains @xmath593@xmath57 of the homocoupling product dfdbrbph ) . nmr spectroscopic data ( see also fig . [ fig4 ] ) : @xmath60h nmr @xmath61 ( @xmath62 mhz , cdcl@xmath55 ) 7.69 ( t , j 1.7 hz , 1h ) , 7.61 ( d , j 1.7 hz , 2h ) , 7.05 ( m , 2h ) , 6.85 ( m , 1h ) . @xmath63c nmr @xmath61 ( 100 mhz , cdcl@xmath55 ) 163.5 ( 2c ) , 142.3 , 141.5 , 133.8 , 128.9 ( 2c ) , 123.5 ( 2c ) , 110.1 ( 2c ) , 103.8 . elemental analysis , calculated : c 41.42@xmath57 , h 1.74@xmath57 , br 45.92@xmath57 ; found : c 41.20@xmath57 , 1.66@xmath57 , br 45.90@xmath57 . ( color online ) ( a ) , synthesis of dfdbrbph by pd - catalyzed cross - coupling . ( b)-(d ) , nmr - spectra of synthetic dfdbrbph . integrated signals are indicated by green ( grey ) curves , and the corresponding numbers are situated directly below the respective curves . ] a schematic of the experimental setup is shown in fig . less than hundred milligram of solid dfdbrbph is heated to 130@xmath5c and expanded in 90 bar of he into vacuum using a pulsed even - lavie valve @xcite . the resulting supersonic molecular beam is skimmed and subsequently crossed by three , focused , pulsed laser beams at 90@xmath5 . the first laser beam originates from a q - switched nd : yag laser and consists of 9-ns - long pulses at 1064 nm . it is focused to a spotsize @xmath64 @xmath65 35 @xmath66 m yielding a peak intensity of @xmath67 w/@xmath11 . the purpose of these pulses is to align the stereogenic axis of the dfdbrbph molecules . the second laser beam consists of 0.7-ps - long kick pulses ( @xmath68 = 800 nm ) , obtained by passing part of the output from an amplified ti : sapphire fs laser system through a grating stretcher . the spotsize of @xmath64 = 43 @xmath66 m yields a peak intensity of @xmath69 w/@xmath11 . these kick pulses are used to induce torsion and rotation of the molecules . the third laser beam consists of 25-fs - long pulses , which we achieve by passing another part of the output from the ti : sapphire system through a hollow wave guide compressor setup . the pulses have a spotsize @xmath64 = 25 @xmath66 m and a peak intensity of @xmath70 w/@xmath11 . these probe pulses coulomb explode the molecules and the produced ions are extracted by a weak static electric field , in a velocity imaging geometry , and projected onto a two - dimensional detector , consisting of a micro channel plate ( mcp ) detector backed by a phosphor screen . we detect the f@xmath7 and br@xmath7 ions separately by time gating of the mcp detector around the respective arrival times of the ions . we record the ion images on the phosphor screen by a ccd camera and determine the coordinates of each individual ion hit . figure [ fig6](a ) displays the ion images of f@xmath7 and br@xmath7 at selected probe times . ( color online ) schematic representation of the experimental setup , showing the vacuum system and the three laser beam paths . the nd : yag ( alignment ) pulses and the probe pulses are polarized vertically , i.e. , perpendicular to the detector plane , whereas the fs kick pulse is polarized in the plane of the detector . ] first , we establish that the ns pulse is able to hold the c - c bond axis of dfdbrbph along its polarization direction . at @xmath71 ps the f@xmath7 image , displayed in fig . [ fig6](a ) , is almost circularly symmetric and the small deviation from circular symmetry is explained by noting that the kick pulse has a finite value at @xmath72 ps . the absence of ions in the innermost region is only compatible with the c - c bond axis being aligned perpendicular to the detector plane and the f - phenyl planes uniformly distributed around the c - c bond axis . the corresponding br@xmath7 image is also essentially circularly symmetric although the hollow - out of the center is not as pronounced as for f@xmath7 . next , we investigate the effect of the kick pulse . already at @xmath73 ps the circular symmetry is broken and both f@xmath7 and br@xmath7 ions start to localize around the polarization direction of the kick pulse . the f@xmath7 ions remain within the radial range of the ring structure , which shows that the kick pulse does not cause any significant distortion of the c - c bond axis alignment but rather initiates an overall rotation of the molecule around this axis . the latter is expected since the torque imparted by the kick pulse will force the smpa ( fig . 2 ) to align along the kick pulse polarization after a delay determined by the kick strength . at @xmath74 ps the localization sharpens for both ions species , but whereas the br@xmath7 ions are simply more localized around the polarization axis the f@xmath7 ion distribution exhibits a four dot structure . this behaviour is compatible with alignment of the smpa along the kick pulse polarization . in the limit of perfect smpa alignment , the br@xmath7 ions would appear as two pairs of strongly localized regions on the detector corresponding to molecules with their br - phenyl plane located either 11@xmath5 clockwise or counterclockwise to the smpa . each pair of br@xmath7 ions would then be angularly separated by 22@xmath5 . in practise and consistent with theory ( see fig . [ fig8 ] ) the smpa alignment is not strong enough to resolve the two br@xmath7 regions . it is , however , sharp enough to resolve the two pairs of f@xmath7 ion hits due to the much larger offset ( 28@xmath5 ) of the f - phenyl plane from the smpa . at @xmath75 ps the br@xmath7 distribution has localized further showing that the br - phenyl plane has rotated into stronger alignment with the kick pulse polarization . if the torsion was unaffected , i.e. , @xmath3 remained unchanged , the f@xmath7 ion image at @xmath75 ps should exhibit a distinct four - dot structure similar to the image at @xmath76 ps but with a larger angular splitting between the ion regions in each of the two pairs . clearly , the four - dot structure at 2.47 ps is significantly blurred compared to the case at 1.47 ps . thus , we conclude that the kick pulse not only sets the molecule into controlled rotation around the c - c axis , it also initiates torsional motion . beyond 3.8 ps the angular confinement of both the f@xmath7 and the br@xmath7 ions is gradually lost due to continued rotation around the c - c axis with dihedral dynamics imposed , and the images for both ion species eventually regain their circularly symmetric form ( see images at 12.15 ps in fig . [ fig6](a ) ) identical to the pre - kick pulse images at -0.87 ps . further insight into the effect of the kick pulse is obtained by analyzing the angular distribution of the f@xmath7 ions as a function of @xmath6 . an example of the f@xmath7 angular distribution at @xmath6 = 1.47 ps is shown in fig . [ fig6](b ) . figure [ fig6](c ) displays the average angle between the f - phenyl rings and the kick pulse polarization as a function of @xmath6 in the time interval where a clear four - peak structure is visible in the angular distributions . the increase from 22.5@xmath5 at 1.47 ps to 26.5@xmath5 at 3.8 ps shows that the f - phenyl plane gradually moves away from the kick pulse polarization due to the overall rotation of the molecule around the c - c bond axis , and we ascribe the recurrent dips to a periodical variation in @xmath3 . we estimate the period to be @xmath77 ps and the amplitude to @xmath78 for this oscillation . before presenting the theoretical results on dfdbrbph , we want to confirm the validity of the classical treatment of rotation . to this end we apply the model to a test case , where the simpler 3,5-diflouroiodobenzene ( dfib ) has its most polarizable axis fixed by a ns laser pulse and is then set into rotation about this axis by an orthogonally polarized femtosecond pulse . here , there is no torsion and the rotational dynamics have been observed directly recently @xcite . in fig . [ fig7 ] , we compare the theoretical and experimental results and find good agreement . , 1.47 and 2.47 ps . ( c ) expectation value of the dihedral angle for a molecule starting out with the smpa aligned along the kick pulse polarization . the kick pulse is as in fig . [ fig6 ] . ] figure [ fig8 ] shows the results of a calculation with laser parameters identical to the experimental values and an initial rotational temperature of 0 k. prior to the kick pulse the angular distributions of the br- and f - phenyl rings are isotropic as in the experiment . maximum alignment of the smpa occurs at 1.3 ps and the confinement of the f - phenyl rings at a large angle with respect to the kick pulse polarization ( cf . middle panel , fig . [ fig8](a ) ) explains the distinct four - dot structure observed at @xmath74 ps in the experimental f@xmath7 ion image ( fig . [ fig6](a ) ) . also , at @xmath74 ps the confinement of the br - phenyl rings at a small angle with respect to the kick pulse polarization predicts a much less distinct , if any , four - dot structure in good agreement with the br@xmath7 ion image . at @xmath75 ps the angular localization of the f - phenyl rings has broadened ( right panel , fig . [ fig8](a ) ) and a blurred four - dot structure is seen , consistent with the experimental result at @xmath75 ps . the distribution of the br - phenyl rings is also broadened ( right panel , fig . [ fig8](b ) ) , but remains localized around the kick pulse polarization fully consistent with the br@xmath7 ion distribution , recorded at 2.47 ps . the theoretical value @xmath79 exhibits oscillations ( fig . [ fig8](c ) ) with a period of @xmath80 ps and amplitude of @xmath81 . the period agrees well with the experimental value ( @xmath82 ps ) , and smaller modulation in @xmath83 is expected in the experiment ( @xmath84 ) partly since here the smpa is not pre - aligned and partly due to deviations from the stated laser peak intensity . the behavior is ascribed to a wave packet of normal modes in the torsional double well potential ( fig . [ fig3](b ) ) for a molecule starting out with the smpa aligned . the qualitative agreement of figs . [ fig6](b ) and [ fig8](c ) corroborates the interpretation of the kick pulse inducing time - dependent torsional motion . we will now discuss some perspectives of the demonstrated laser control of torsion . for one thing , we suggest a time - resolved study of de - racemization @xcite , where one enantiomer is steered into its mirror form . to do this we break the inversion symmetry of the c - c bond axis by orienting each molecule . this allows us to discriminate between the two enantiomeric forms . theory @xcite and experiment @xcite show that orientation can be added to 3d alignment by combining the ns alignment pulse with a static electric field . next , the excitation of torsional motion is optimized by eliminating initial rotation around the c - c bond through alignment of the smpa ( fig . 2 ) prior to the kick pulse using an elliptically rather than a linearly polarized ns pulse @xcite . finally , the interaction strength between the molecule and the kick pulse needs to be increased either through higher intensity , a longer kick pulse or by trains of synchronized kick pulses @xcite . or ( b ) an s@xmath1 enantiomer . initially , the molecule is 3d oriented with the br - phenyl end pointing out of the paper and the smpa aligned at an angle of 13@xmath5 with respect to the kick pulse polarization . the kick pulse triggering the torsional motion has a peak intensity of @xmath9 w/@xmath11 and duration ( fwhm ) of @xmath85 ps . the torsional potential is scaled down by 1/4 rather than by increasing the kick strength . in practise reduction of the torsional barrier is possible , for instance , by modifying the aromatic rings or by using halogen substituted biphenylacetylene . ] assuming initial orientation and confinement of the smpa , we have calculated the @xmath3 dynamics for both conformations the dfdbrbph molecule with a reduced torsional barrier ( see caption to fig . [ fig9 ] ) . the results are shown in fig . [ fig9 ] , and clearly , the present method would allow for a time - resolved study of the transition from one enantiomer into the other . a quantitative analysis of the efficiency of the process shows that after the pulse @xmath86 of the molecules starting out as r@xmath1 has changed into s@xmath1 enantiomers , whereas only @xmath87 of the s@xmath1 enantiomers changed into r@xmath1 . the inverse process causing an excess of r@xmath1 enantiomers , is achieved simply by inverting the orientation of the molecules . we believe that the results presented in this paper also fuel the field of molecular junctions @xcite with new possibilities . the conductivity of molecules like biphenyl will depend on the dihedral angle @xcite , and as such this type of molecules , if placed between two leads , can function as a molecular junction @xcite that may be used to control the charge flow and act as , e.g. , a switch @xcite . importantly , we can realize quantum control of such a system by means of kick pulse schemes and in this way tailor very specific torsional wave packets @xcite to dictate the detailed time - dependent dihedral motion and thereby the current flow through the molecular junction . seen through the light of controllability , molecular junctions based on laser controlled torsion complements the available schemes , such as the mechanical break junctions @xcite and the previously suggested resonantly light driven molecular junctions @xcite . we presented a fs time - resolved study on laser controlled torsion of axially chiral molecules . experimentally , the symmetry axis of dfdbrbph molecules was held fixed in space by a long alignment laser pulse while a fs kick pulse , polarized perpendicular to the fixed axis , was applied . the torsion as well as the overall rotation of the molecule was monitored with fs time resolution using a delayed probe pulse . to substantiate the observations , we developed an original theoretical model , which produces results in good agreement with the experiment . the model divides the dynamics of the molecule into a the rotation with classical behavior and quantum mechanical torsional dynamics . as such the model provides a transparent physical intepretation of essential features of laser controlled torsion of dfdbrbph . based on the theoretical model , we further discussed the extension of the experiment to a setup that will facilitate a fs time - resolved study of de - racemization . finally , we pointed to perspectives of using molecules like dfdbrbph in molecular junctions in order to realize laser controlled charge flow . this work was supported by the carlsberg foundation , the lundbeck foundation , danish natural research foundation , the danish natural science research council , and the danish research agency ( grant no . 217 - 05 - 0081 ) .

it is demonstrated that strong laser pulses can introduce torsional motion in the axially chiral molecule 3,5-diflouro-3,5-dibromo - biphenyl ( dfdbrbph ) . a nanosecond laser pulse spatially aligns the stereogenic carbon - carbon ( c - c ) bond axis allowing a perpendicularly polarized , intense femtosecond pulse to initiate torsional motion accompanied by a rotation about the fixed axis . we monitor the induced motion by femtosecond time - resolved coulomb explosion imaging . our theoretical analysis corroborates the experimental findings and on the basis of these results we discuss future applications of laser induced torsion , viz . , time - resolved studies of de - racemization and laser controlled molecular junctions based on molecules with torsion .

0911.2488

scale relativity allows one to give foundations to the postulates @xcite and motion equations @xcite of quantum mechanics , and to gauge theories of particle physics @xcite , in particular to electromagnetism @xcite , by providing them with a geometric interpretation in the framework of a fractal space - time . successive velocity doublings proceeding from the giving up of the differentiability assumption allows one to obtain the motion equations as geodesic equations of this fractal space - time , thus implementing quantum covariance . we have therefore been able to derive successively : the schrdinger equation @xcite , which applies to non - relativistic particles , the free klein - gordon @xcite and dirac @xcite equations and finally the pauli equation @xcite , which is the non - relativistic limit of the dirac equation and which applies to the behavior of a non - relativistic spin 1/2 particle , e.g. a non - relativistic electron . we will come back in more details in the following to the two equations of interest here , klein - gordon and dirac . moreover , the relativity principle applied to scales implies that the scale of an internal structure on a fractal geodesic is modified by a displacement in space - time and reciprocally . this property allows one to construct the electromagnetic field and the electric charge while giving them a physical meaning , thus implementing scale covariance . recall that in scale relativity quantum covariance is implemented by the use of a covariant velocity operator , @xmath0 . owing to a first symmetry breaking , that of @xmath1 , this operator becomes complex . when one adds the breakings of @xmath2 and of @xmath3 , one gets a bi - quaternionic operator . being complex or bi - quaternionic , these operators are used to write the motion equations of free particles under the form of geodesic equations @xmath4 a complex velocity operator inserted in the above equation allows one to recover the usual free klein - gordon equation @xcite . recall this applies to the motion of a relativistic spinless particle non - submitted to an external field . with a bi - quaternionic velocity operator , one obtains a bi - quaternionic klein - gordon - like equation . the free dirac equation follows as its square root @xcite . it applies to a relativistic spin 1/2 particle , such as the electron and its anti - particle , the positron , non - submitted to an external field . these two particles are represented , in standard quantum mechanics , by only one object , the bi - spinor , which has all the mathematical properties of a bi - quaternion . this shows that the scale relativity formalism is perfectly appropriate to reproduce phenomena observed in microphysics . in the framework of electromagnetism , scale relativity identifies gauge transformations , whose nature was previously unknown , with global scale transformations , @xmath5 , in `` scale space '' . it allows also to recover , while giving it a geometric interpretation as a scale covariant derivative , the usual form of the covariant derivative of quantum electrodynamics , i.e. @xmath6 eventually , charges emerge naturally as conserved quantities in scale transformations . up to there , everything is perfect as regards scale relativity . our aim is now to recover , from the first principles of scale relativity , both equations klein - gordon and dirac , but for particles submitted to an external electromagnetic filed . the first idea which crosses our mind is to combine both tools , scale covariant derivative ( qed ) and quantum covariant velocity operator , by writing the strongly covariant geodesic equation : @xmath7 we obtain actually , when integrating this equation , the usual klein - gordon equation for a relativistic spinless particle in an external electromagnetic filed . proud of this success , we hoped then to be able to recover the electromagnetic dirac equation by applying exactly the same method which was so successful in the case of free particles , i.e. extracting the square root of the bi - quaternionic electromagnetic klein - gordon - like equation . more exactly , we had shown in @xcite that a bi - quaternionic free klein - gordon - like equation amounts to applying twice to the wave function the time part of the dirac equation and then to equal it to its squared spatial part . now , this is no more the case when an electromagnetic field comes into play . an additional term appears and we have shown it corresponds to the coupling between the intrinsic magnetic moment , or spin , of the electron and the magnetic field . this term is the relativistic analogue of that implying the electron magnetic moment in the pauli equation . the conclusion is this method is not well - adapted and we must use another one . instead of implementing a strong covariance , as in the former method , we are going to use both tools , quantum covariance and scale covariance , as in standard quantum mechanics . first , we apply the quantum covariance and we obtain the free klein - gordon and dirac equations as before . then , we replace in these equations the ordinary derivative , @xmath8 , by its `` inertial '' scale covariant part , @xmath9 . we obtain thus the electromagnetic dirac equation under its usual form , where the spin - magnetic field coupling does not appear explicitly . we have seen that the only quantum covariant geodesic equation yields the free dirac equation . when we add the scale covariance directly at the level of the geodesic equation , we obtain an additional term representing the spin - magnetic field coupling . the explanation is as follows . in scale relativity , spin proceeds directly from the fractality of space - time , while charges , which stem from transformations in scale space , are only indirect consequences of this fractality . hence , the influence of fractality through spin is more fundamental and must be applied first , independently from that of the field . spin is an intrinsic quantum property of the particles , component of the total angular momentum which is itself a constant of motion . it takes only integer or half - integer values of @xmath10 . in scale relativity , the spin 1/2 can have two different interpretations . in the first , one considers it as a quantum charge of the electron / positron . in this case , a term representing the coupling of this charge to the external field appears explicitly in the equations . this interpretation corresponds to the way spin stems when the first strongly covariant method is used to obtain the motion equations . it can also be considered as directly linked to the fractal geometry of space - time . in this case , its coupling to the magnetic field is implicit and there is no additional term in the dirac equation which recovers its usual form , as when the second method is used . this interpretation has been illustrated with numerical simulations aiming at visualizing the typically spinorial form of some geodesics in a fractal space - time ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) @xcite . ) in a fractal space . realization chosen between an infinity of possible realizations . ] owing to the principle of relativity of scales , scale variables are explicit functions of the space - time coordinates . this implies , for every displacement in such a space - time , the appearance of a change in scale interval due to the fractal geometry , which reads @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the ( active ) electric charge and @xmath13 defines the electromagnetic field . it can be shown that the passive electric charge @xmath14 is equal to the active electric charge @xmath12 @xcite . the electric charge , a mere property of the electron stemming from scale transformations , must be considered therefore of a less fundamental nature than the spin , itself a component of a first integral of motion . we have seen that the internal nature of spin , intrinsically linked to the fractal geometry of space - time is more fundamental than that of the charges , which also stem from this fractality , but less directly . therefore , strong covariance , which can be properly applied to recover the electromagnetic klein - gordon equation , since this equation does not imply spin , must be replaced by a weaker covariance in the case of the dirac equation where spin is involved .

klein - gordon and dirac equations are the motion equations for relativistic particles with spin 0 ( so - called scalar particles ) and 1/2 ( electron / positron ) respectively . for a free particle , the dirac equation is derived from the klein - gordon equation by taking its square root in a bi - quaternionic formalism fully justified by the first principles of the scale relativity theory . this is no more true when an external electro - magnetic field comes into play . if one tries to derive the electro - magnetic dirac equation in a manner analogous to the one used when this field is absent , one obtains an additional term which is the relativistic analogue of the spin - magnetic field coupling term encountered in the pauli equation , valid for a non - relativistic particle with spin 1/2 . there is however a method to recover the standard form of the electro - magnetic dirac equation , with no additional term , which amounts modifying the way both covariances involved here , quantum and scale , are implemented . without going into technical details , it will be shown how these results suggest this last method is based on more profound roots of the scale relativity theory since it encompasses naturally the spin - charge coupling .

astro-ph0106525

mass determinations of neutron stars ( ns ) can provide essential constraints on the equation of state of nuclear matter ( van kerkwijk , van paradijs & zuiderwijk 1995 ) . compact object masses are now known accurately for radio pulsars , all of which are consistent with @xmath13 0.07 m@xmath8 ( thorsett et al . 1993 ) , but have been very difficult to obtain in low mass x - ray binaries ( lmxbs ) both because their ns do not pulse and because the optical flux from the companion is usually overwhelmed by reprocessed x - ray emission from the accretion disk ( van paradijs & mcclintock 1995 ) . only in the quiescent state of soft x - ray transients ( sxts ) can the faint companion be detected and dynamical information extracted . an accurate constraint on the ns mass , however , requires knowledge of both the system inclination @xmath14 and the mass ratio @xmath15 in addition to the amplitude of the radial velocity curve of the companion @xmath16 . + the transient xte j2123 - 058 , discovered in june 1998 , offers an excellent opportunity to achieve this . the presence of a ns is confirmed by type - i bursts ( tomsick et al . 1999 ; homan et al . 1999 , gneiding , steiner & cieslinski 1999 ) which makes it one of only 4 ns sxts known . the optical counterpart showed clear triangular - shaped minima repeating on the orbital period of 6 hrs which consequently evolved to an ellipsoidal modulation before the system entered quiescence at @xmath17 ( tomsick et al . 1999 ; soria , wu & galloway 1999 ; zurita et al . 2000 ; hynes et al . the modulation yielded @xmath18 ( zurita et al . 2000 ) but it should be noted that systematic effects related to the assumed outburst irradiation model might have some importance . + the secondary star is suspected to be of late k - type in order to transfer matter within the constraints of a 6 hr orbit . photometric colours obtained during quiescence also suggest the presence of a late - k companion ( see zurita et al 2000 , shahbaz et al . 2001 ) . in this paper we report the first spectroscopic detection of the companion star in j2123 - 058 and its radial velocity curve using the _ kueyen _ vlt ( sections 3 and 4 ) . sections 5 and 6 deal with the analysis of the @xmath3 emission . in section 7 we present the spectroscopic constraints on the components masses , together with implications for the disc instability model and discuss constraints on the formation scenario implied by the observed systemic velocity . we obtained a total of 20 spectra of j2123 - 058 during observations with the fors-2 spectrometer of the _ kueyen _ vlt on august 23 and 24 , 2000 ( ut ) . we used grism 600r ( with the order - sorting filter gg435 + 31 ) , centered at 6300 with a 0.7 `` slit on the first night . on the second night , the seeing deteriorated ( up to 1.2 '' ) and so we decided to use a 1 arcsec slit . the spectral resolution , as measured from the fwhm of the arclines , was 2.7 and 4.0 for the two nights , respectively . exposure times of 2200 s were employed . + the data were de - biased and flat - fielded in the usual way . the spectra for j2123 - 058 were then extracted using standard optimal extraction techniques which optimize the signal - to - noise ratio of the final spectra ( horne 1986 ) . calibration henear arc images were obtained in daytime with the telescope parked at the zenith . the @xmath0-pixel scale was derived through fourth - order polynomial fits to 40 lines resulting in an rms scatter better than 0.3 . internal flexure was measured by cross - correlation of the sky spectra and was found to be @xmath19 20 km s@xmath2 ( @xmath19 0.4 pixel ) throughout the night . relative shifts of every target spectrum to the first one were applied and the zero point ( -18 @xmath20 2 km s@xmath2 ) obtained through a gaussian fit to the strong @xmath06300.3 oi line on the first sky spectrum . the spectra were subsequently rebinned into a constant velocity scale of 52 km s@xmath2 pixel@xmath2 . + spectra of several k and m - type giants ( table 1 ) were obtained with the same set - up ( slit width=0.7 " ) for the cross - correlation analysis . a database of k - type main sequence stars ( table 2 ) , observed with the ids on the int with similar wavelength coverage and resolution ( see casares et al . 1996 ) were also used for the spectral type classification . prior to the cross - correlation the spectra were rectified to the continuum ( which was subtracted afterwards ) by masking the emission lines ( h@xmath21 , hei @xmath05875 , @xmath06678 ) and fitting a low - order spline to the remainder . then , individual radial velocities were extracted by cross - correlation with each template star in the range @xmath225600 - 6520 , after masking out the atmospheric and interstellar band at @xmath226270 - 6320 . note that the nad feature at @xmath225890 - 96 was included in the cross - correlation because is a strong feature in late - type stars and , given the high galactic latitude of j2123 - 058 , this is only marginally affected by interstellar absorption ; the ew of the interstellar nad measured by hynes et al . ( 2001 ) is less than 15 % of our observed value of 4.2 ( see fig . 2 ) . its effect is less than 1 km@xmath2 on the radial velocity curve . a few spectra from the first night have very poor statistics and consequently yield unreliable radial velocities . this was improved by co - adding the individual spectra into 16 phase bins , using the established orbital period of @xmath23 days ( zurita _ et al . the new radial velocities were fitted with a sine - wave at this period , the resulting parameters being displayed in table 1 . lccccc _ template_&_spectral type_&_@xmath24 _ & _ @xmath25 _ & _ @xmath26 _ & _ @xmath27 _ + _ star _ & & _ ( km s@xmath2 ) _ & _ ( + 2451779.0 ) _ & _ ( km s@xmath2 ) _ & + + hr 5265 & k3 iii & -112@xmath2010&0.6515 @xmath20 0.0015 & 285 @xmath20 9 & 1.8 + hr 5178 & k5 iii & -109@xmath2011&0.6520 @xmath20 0.0012 & 289 @xmath20 9 & 1.8 + hr 6159 & k7 iii & -111@xmath2011&0.6520 @xmath20 0.0017 & 287 @xmath20 12 & 1.3 + hr 5496 & m1 iii & -108@xmath2013&0.6515 @xmath20 0.0015 & 290 @xmath20 10 & 1.7 + hr 5603 & m3 iii & -111@xmath2015&0.6517 @xmath20 0.0017 & 287 @xmath20 11 & 1.6 + + column 3 lists the systemic velocities after correcting for the template radial velocities ( as given by simbad ) and instrumental flexure on template spectra . this latter correction could not be accounted for in the same way as in the target spectra because of the faintness of the sky spectra . instead , this was estimated by simply measuring the central wavelength of the h@xmath11 line , by fitting gaussians to the line core . notice the small scatter in the distribution of @xmath28-velocities which render confidence in the technique applied to compensate for differential flexure corrections . the statistical mean is -110 @xmath20 1 km s@xmath2 but the real error is probably underestimated . as a better representation of the uncertainty in the true systemic velocity we prefer to quote the mean of 1-@xmath29 uncertainties of the fits to the radial velocity curves . therefore , our favoured determination of the systemic velocity in j2123 - 058 is @xmath30 km s@xmath2 . + note the consistent values of the other parameters in table 1 which suggest @xmath31 and @xmath32 km s@xmath2 ( all quoted errors are @xmath33 ) . the combination of our @xmath34 determination with that of zurita et al . ( 2000 ) enables us to refine the orbital period to @xmath35 d. we note that hr6159 yields a significantly lower @xmath36 than the rest and , therefore , we adopt the orbital parameters derived using this template . adopting @xmath37 km s@xmath2 , the implied mass function is @xmath38 m@xmath8 . the phase - folded radial velocity curve , for the case of the k7 iii template , is shown in the top panel of fig . 1 . figure 2 presents the doppler - corrected average spectrum of j2123 - 058 in the rest frame of the secondary , together with some spectral - type standards . different weights were assigned to different spectra in order to maximize the signal - to - noise ratio . photospheric absorption features from the companion are clearly visible , such as the metallic blends at @xmath06165 and @xmath06495 and the nai doublet at @xmath05890 - 6 . these are clearly broader in j2123 - 058 than in the luminosity class iii templates but this is purely an instrumental effect since the averaged spectrum is dominated by the higher quality spectra from the second night , obtained through a 1 " slit . several molecular tio bands ( e.g. @xmath226150 - 6250 , @xmath226960 - 90 and @xmath227020 - 50 ) are also evident and these can be used to rule out spectral types k3 ( and earlier ) and m1 ( and later ) . the spectral type of the companion is most probably in the range k5 - 7 . + both the spectral type and luminosity class of the secondary can be efficiently determined by subtracting different broadened versions of the templates ( to compensate for the instrumental resolution mismatch ) from the doppler - corrected sum of the target until the lowest residual is obtained ( as performed in e.g. marsh , robinson & wood 1994 ) . the broadened templates are multiplied by a factor @xmath39 to account for the shallowness of the absorption features in j2123 - 058 , which are diluted by the continuum excess of the accretion disc . the results of the optimal subtraction analysis are presented in table 2 . as expected , main sequence templates yield systematically lower @xmath40 , with a minimum for spectral types k7 - 8 v. the relative contribution of the companion star to the total flux in the r - band is constrained to the range @xmath41 . lcccc _ template _ & _ spectral _ & _ broadening _ & _ @xmath42 _ & _ @xmath36 _ + & _ type _ & _ ( km s@xmath2 ) _ & & ( d.o.f.=632 ) + + hr 5265 & k3 iii & 230 & 1.00 @xmath20 0.14 & 0.300 + hr 5178 & k5 iii & 210 & 0.85 @xmath20 0.11 & 0.293 + hr 6159 & k7 iii & 200 & 0.84 @xmath20 0.11 & 0.300 + hr 5496 & m1 iii & 155 & 0.68 @xmath20 0.10 & 0.312 + hr 5603 & m3 iii & 120 & 0.52 @xmath20 0.08 & 0.324 + + hd 184467 & k2 v & 190 & 1.43 @xmath20 0.17 & 0.267 + hd 154712 a & k4 v & 170 & 0.90 @xmath20 0.10 & 0.263 + hd 296974 & k5 v & 185 & 0.83 @xmath20 0.09 & 0.257 + 61 cyg a & k5 v & 220 & 0.83 @xmath20 0.09 & 0.258 + 61 cyg b & k7 v & 185 & 0.77 @xmath20 0.08 & 0.255 + hd 154712 b & k8 v & 190 & 0.70 @xmath20 0.07 & 0.255 + a rough estimate of the rotation speed of the companion star ( assuming co - rotation ) is provided by the size of the roche lobe ( @xmath43 ) , which is related to the secondary s mass ( @xmath44 ) and the orbital period ( @xmath45 ) by combining kepler s third law with paczynski s expression ( paczynski 1971 ) for the equivalent radius of a roche lobe filling star . @xmath46 an upper limit will be obtained by adopting the nominal mass of a k7 v main sequence star ( 0.65 @xmath47 ) because the companions in close binaries are usually undermassive for their spectral types ( van den heuvel 1983 ) . with @xmath48 , the secondary would just fill its roche lobe or be slightly evolved ( a k7v has @xmath49 ) . this implies a maximum rotation speed of @xmath50 km s@xmath2 , but the projected rotational broadening ( @xmath51 ) can not be much less than this because of the high inclination ( @xmath52 , see zurita et al . 2000 ) . since this is smaller than the spectral resolution on 23 aug ( 185 km s@xmath2 ) , and because of the orbital smearing due to our long integration times ( @xmath53 ) , we can not measure @xmath54 in our doppler - corrected sum . however , using the limit that @xmath55 km s@xmath2 and @xmath52 then the mass ratio is constrained to be @xmath56 ( wade & horne 1988 ) . the system mass ratio can also be determined if the radial velocity curve of the compact object is available . unfortunately , the neutron star in j2123 - 058 does not pulse and we can therefore only hope for the velocities of the extreme h@xmath11 wings ( which originate in the vicinity of the compact star ) to share its orbital motion . the `` double - gaussian '' technique allows us to extract the centroid of line velocity regions @xmath57 through convolving the individual spectra with two gaussian bandpasses separated by @xmath58 ( schneider & young 1980 ) . for a given value of _ a _ the velocity points can be fitted by a velocity curve of the form @xmath59 and ( @xmath60,@xmath61 ) be represented in velocity space . if the inner disc were axisymmetric @xmath62 , @xmath63 and one could recover the radial velocity curve of the compact star . the application of this technique to cataclysmic variables ( cvs ) and black - hole x - ray transients ( bhxrts ) has shown that emission line radial velocity curves are systematically delayed ( i.e. @xmath64 ) and also their @xmath28-velocities differ from the systemic velocity ( probably due to mass outflows ) casting doubts on any dynamical interpretation ( marsh 1998 ) . to overcome this problem , marsh ( 1988 ) proposed the _ lightcenter _ technique which basically extrapolates the ( @xmath60,@xmath61 ) points towards the vertical axis in velocity space ( i.e. to absolute phase 0 ) before values get corrupted by noise at large gaussian separation . separation @xmath65 _ & _ @xmath66 _ & _ @xmath28 _ & _ @xmath67 _ & _ @xmath60 _ & _ @xmath61 _ & _ @xmath68 _ + _ ( km s@xmath2 ) _ & & _ ( km s@xmath2 ) _ & & _ ( km s@xmath2 ) _ & _ ( km s@xmath2 ) _ & _ ( km s@xmath2 ) _ + + 400 & 3.0 & -106@xmath2019 & 0.532@xmath200.010 & -90@xmath2033 & -442@xmath2049 & 451@xmath2025 + 600 & 1.0 & -105@xmath2026 & 0.548@xmath200.013 & -122@xmath2042 & -393@xmath2067 & 412@xmath2033 + 800 & 2.8 & -144@xmath2017 & 0.508@xmath200.017 & -14@xmath2030 & -269@xmath2041 & 269@xmath2022 + 1000 & 1.4 & -123@xmath2018 & 0.487@xmath200.022 & 15@xmath2027 & -178@xmath2044 & 179@xmath2024 + 1200 & 0.6 & -120@xmath2013 & 0.500@xmath200.017 & 0@xmath2017 & -155@xmath2033 & 155@xmath2020 + 1400 & 0.3 & -109@xmath2017 & 0.523@xmath200.022 & -20@xmath2023 & -139@xmath2049 & 140@xmath2029 + 1600 & 0.2 & -145@xmath2020 & 0.592@xmath200.034 & -76@xmath2040 & -117@xmath2059 & 140@xmath2027 + 1800 & 0.5 & -124@xmath2025 & 0.674@xmath200.036 & -132@xmath2043 & -68@xmath2069 & 149@xmath2031 + 2000 & 4.1 & -184@xmath2026 & 0.582@xmath200.022 & -113@xmath2046 & -199@xmath2075 & 229@xmath2038 + we have followed this approach and applied the `` double - gaussian '' technique to our 16 phase - binned spectra of j2123 - 058 using bandpass separations from 400 to 2000 km s@xmath2 and @xmath69 km s@xmath2 of gaussians to match our instrumental resolution . the results of the fits are listed in table 3 and overplotted on the doppler map ( see next sect . ) in fig . as we move away from the line core , the radial velocity amplitude @xmath70 decreases from 450 to @xmath71 km s@xmath2 and the phase lag , relative to the expected motion of the compact star , quickly vanishes ( i.e. @xmath72 ) . further into the wings the points are again dragged towards large ( negative ) velocities as if they were contaminated by a high velocity component . this behaviour is different from other bhxrts ( e.g. marsh , robinson & wood 1994 ) where contamination by the hot - spot distorts the emission line velocities all the way into the extreme wings . at this point we tentatively adopt @xmath73 km s@xmath2 as the lowest @xmath74-amplitude that is consistent with the correct phasing of the compact object ( @xmath75 ) . this is fulfilled for a gaussian separation @xmath76 km s@xmath2 , which also yields a @xmath28-velocity in good agreement with the companion star ( see sect 3 ) . this radial velocity curve for h@xmath21 is shown in the middle panel of fig . the mean spectrum of j2123 - 058 in the laboratory rest frame is dominated by broad ( fwhm=1300 km s@xmath2 ) , strong ( ew=20 ) , double - peaked h@xmath21 emission . the ew traces a @xmath77 20 % amplitude sinusoidal modulation with maxima at phase 0 i.e. inferior conjunction of the neutron star ( see lower panel of fig . we have combined our phase - binned h@xmath21 profiles to reconstruct the brightness distribution of the accretion disc and other emission sources in the system using the doppler tomography technique ( marsh & horne 1988 ) . the continua were normalized and subtracted so as to give a pure emission line profile which was subsequently rebinned onto a constant velocity scale ( 52 km s@xmath2 pix@xmath2 ) covering 58 pixels centered at h@xmath21 . the resulting doppler map is presented in fig.4 in velocity coordinates , together with the trailed spectra . the map is dominated by a crescent - shaped structure , pointing at phase @xmath77 0.5 , superposed on the weak ring - like structure of the accretion disc with no sign of emission at the expected hot - spot location ( the theoretical path of the gas stream for @xmath78 is marked in units of @xmath79 ) . we do see some emission from the @xmath80 point . similar emission has been reported in other quiescent x - ray transients , n. mus 91 ( casares et al . 1997 ) , n. oph 77 ( harlaftis et al . 1997 ) , cen x-4 ( torres et al . 2001 ) which may be indicative of chromospheric activity in these late - k companions . however , the highly asymmetric brightness distribution of the accretion disc emission in j2123 - 058 is markedly distinct from other bhxrts . the predominance of emissivity from the lower quadrants in the doppler map is more reminiscent of cvs of the sw sex type , which may suggest that a similar accretion processes ( magnetic accretion , disc overflow or propeller ) is at work . this similarity was already noted by hynes et al . ( 2000 ) using better quality spectroscopy of j2123 - 058 during the outburst phase . j2123 - 058 is a key system for the study of the physics of neutron stars and x - ray transients . it is one of only a handful of neutron star transients and is at high inclination . this latter property will eventually lead to an accurate measurent the masses of both stars . this work presents the first spectroscopic analysis of j2123 - 058 in quiescence , with a determination of the companion s radial velocity curve . contrary to other sxts , the h@xmath21 emission is antiphased with the companion star . consequently , we have employed the double - gaussian technique to estimate @xmath81 and hence the binary mass ratio @xmath82 . in table 4 we list our determination of the system parameters in j2123 - 058 . from the mass function and @xmath15 we constrain the compact object mass to be @xmath83 m@xmath8 . the inclination was determined in zurita et al . ( 2000 ) by fitting the outburst lightcurves with an x - ray heated model . using @xmath84 in our mass function we get @xmath85 m@xmath8 and @xmath86 m@xmath8 , which can be further constrained to @xmath87 using the strong spectroscopic evidence that the companion can not possibly be a k3v or earlier . [ cols= " < , < " , ] the compact object mass is consistent with the canonical value of standard neutron stars although our @xmath88 uncertainty allows as large a mass as @xmath77 1.9 m@xmath8 . to set constraints on the equation of state of nuclear matter will require refining @xmath89 and , in particular , @xmath15 and @xmath14 . a 50% improvement in the errorbars of @xmath15 and @xmath14 will therefore provide a significant gain and this can be attempted through detailed modeling of the optical lightcurves both in outburst and quiescence . + the spectrum and mass of the companion star are both consistent with a `` normal '' k7 main sequence star . with an orbital period of 6 hours , the mass transfer rate from the k7v star is expected to be set by orbital angular momentum losses due to magnetic braking . for a roche lobe filling main sequence star this leads to @xmath90 m@xmath91 yr@xmath2 ( eq . 16 in king 1988 , see also fig . 1 of king , kolb & burderi 1996 ) . on the other hand , the critical mass accretion rate above which the disk becomes stable against the thermal - viscous instability is @xmath92 m@xmath91 yr@xmath2 if irradiation heating is included and @xmath93 m@xmath91 yr@xmath2 when it is not ( fig . 10 , dubus et al . the critical mass accretion rate is independent of the assumed magnitude of the viscosity ( eq . 39 of hameury et al . 1998 ) . in the most favourable case with negligible irradiation heating ( unlikely considering the interpretation of the orbital modulation observed in outburst that required an irradiated disk ) , the accretion disk is only marginally unstable . the estimated mass transfer rate is close to @xmath94 in which case models ( dubus , hameury & lasota 2001 ) predict long outbursts and short quiescent periods , contrary to the behaviour of xte j2123 - 058 . magnetic braking thus leads to uncomfortably high estimates for the mass transfer rate . this problem is common to short period ( @xmath95 days ) neutron star x - ray binaries and has led king , kolb & burderi ( 1996 ) to propose that their companions are highly evolved and not main - sequence stars . + this can be ruled out for xte j2123 - 058 : @xmath96 implies @xmath97 with @xmath98m@xmath91 ( eq . 9 of king , kolb & burderi 1996 with gravitational radiation neglected ) and @xmath99 where @xmath100 is the mass of a main - sequence star with the same mean density as the companion ( kolb , king & baraffe 2001 ) ; with @xmath101 m@xmath91 and @xmath102 this gives @xmath103 m@xmath91 which disagrees with our spectroscopic mass of @xmath104 m@xmath91 and spectral type determination . if @xmath105 m@xmath91 , the companion might be a stripped giant ( see taam 1983 ; webbink , rappaport & savonije 1983 ) consisting of a degenerate he core and an extended h shell - burning envelope , but the implied temperature would then be @xmath106 k rather than the observed @xmath107 k ( i.e. k7v ) . our spectroscopy clearly shows that the secondary star can not possibly be a stripped - giant and must be a main sequence k7 or slightly evolved 1 d because mass transfer starts before the core mass exceeds the schonberg - chandrasekhar mass and collapses ( king 1988 ) ] . + on the other hand , our estimate of @xmath108 above from magnetic braking implies a _ luminosity @xmath109 ergs@xmath2 ( with @xmath110 ) which is comparable to the observed outburst _ peak _ x - ray luminosity ( @xmath111 erg s@xmath2 for d=9.6 kpc , see below ) . the problem is clearly in how @xmath108 was estimated rather than in the outburst model . if the secular evolution is driven by gravitational radiation losses only , the inferred accretion rate is lower and more consistent with the disc instability model ( @xmath112 m@xmath91 yr@xmath2 ) . even taking into account angular momentum carried away by mass ejected from the system , this can not significantly reduce the estimated @xmath113 , unless matter is carried away by a highly relativistic jet close to the ns ( king & kolb 1999 ) for which there is no evidence . + the physical mechanisms involved in magnetic braking are poorly known and it is a distinct possibility that for some reason they do not work or are less efficient in this system . in fact , even after accounting for evolved companions , magnetic braking has been shown to give recurrence times which are much too short for bh sxts with @xmath114 d ( romani 1998 ) . other assumptions made in the derivation of @xmath108 could be wrong e.g. the secondary may not fill its roche lobe or is not corotating , although both are unlikely . alternatively , the transient character of xte j2123 - 058 could be temporary , for instance if the donor star undergoes cycles which reduce @xmath108 ( by at least an order of magnitude ) from its secular value . such variations have been invoked to explain the dispersion in mass accretion rates observed in cvs ( warner 1995 ) . possibilities include star spots ( livio & pringle 1994 ) or instabilities in the secular mass transfer induced by the anisotropic irradiation of the secondary ( ritter , zhang & kolb 2000 ) . + with @xmath115 in quiescence , the dereddened apparent magnitude of the k7v companion is @xmath116 ( assuming a 30% @xmath117% veiling ) . the absolute magnitude of a k7v star is @xmath118 , hence @xmath119 , in good agreement with previous estimates ( tomsick et al . 1999 , homan et al . 1999 ) . with a distance of @xmath120 kpc and @xmath121 , xte j2123 - 058 lies @xmath122 kpc above the galactic plane and it has been proposed that it may be a halo object escaped from a globular cluster ( homan et al . we can test this hypothesis using the new information provided by our systemic radial velocity @xmath123 km s@xmath2 . in the absence of peculiar motions , the observed line - of - sight velocity @xmath124 will be driven by the differential galactic rotation and the sun s motion relative to the local standard of rest i.e. @xmath125 where @xmath126 , @xmath127 , @xmath128 kpc , @xmath129 km s@xmath2 and @xmath130 is the galactic rotation velocity at the position of j2123 - 058 ( frenk & white 1980 ; morrison et al . 1990 ) . using @xmath131 km s@xmath2 , @xmath121 , @xmath132 and @xmath133 kpc we find @xmath134 km s@xmath2 which is consistent with the low rotation velocities of globular clusters with galactocentric distances in the range 2 - 33 kpc ( frenk & white 1980 ) and halo stars ( freeman 1988 ) . we note , however , that only one velocity component is known and the true rotational velocity might be substantially different . in an attempt to find evidence of proper motion in j2123 - 058 we have also performed astrometry on our best quality images taken during outburst ( 5 july 98 ) and quiescence ( 19 aug 99 ) but found no significant motion with upper limits @xmath135 and @xmath136 . therefore , the formation scenario of j2123 - 058 can not be tested on pure kinematical grounds . + the transition from galactic disc to halo is known to occur sharply at [ fe / h ] = -1.0 ( e.g. ratnatunga & freeman 1989 ) and hence the companion star of j2123 - 058 would be metal poor ( [ fe / h ] @xmath137 -1.0 ) if formed in the halo . unfortunately , a difference of one dex in metallicity would produce only tiny changes in line strength at the low @xmath138 of the secondary . these changes are completely undetectable in our moderate s / n average spectrum . the evidence that j2123 - 058 is not a halo object was raised by hynes et al . ( 2001 ) based on the relative strength of the bowen blend and heii @xmath04686 emission lines during outburst . this supports the idea that j2123 - 058 was indeed formed in the galactic plane and received a large supernova kick ( 150 - 400 km s@xmath2 , homan et al . 1999 ) to reach its present location . we note that kalogera , kolb & king ( 1998 ) conclude that " large kick velocities will favour the formation of short - period systems with unevolved donors . + our h@xmath21 doppler imaging of the accretion disk poses several interpretative difficulties . the map shows significant emission at the @xmath80 point but not from the hot spot . enhanced emission would be expected from this hemisphere of the companion during outburst when it faces irradiation from the accreting neutron star . typical x - ray luminosities of neutron star sxts in quiescence are @xmath139 erg s@xmath2 and this luminosity would be sufficient to power the observed h@xmath21 emission ( more details will be presented in shahbaz et al . alternatively , the emission could be due to chromospheric activity on the secondary ( bildsten & rutledge 2000 ) , e.g. star spots close to the @xmath80 point ( which would help reduce the mass transfer rate ) could explain enhanced h@xmath21 emission . + part of the h@xmath21 emission observed in fig.3 is located at velocities which are too low to be associated with a keplerian disk and in anti - phase with the secondary , a similar situation to that observed during outburst by hynes et al . their higher quality doppler map was very reminiscent of those seen in a group of nova - like cvs , the sw sex stars . hynes et al . ( 2000 ) argued that the mechanism was probably the same and likely to be a propeller . in this scenario , a magnetic field anchored in the disk interacts with the accretion stream from the secondary , ejecting blobs of matter out of the system . the trajectories depend on the mass but all intersect at some location . the collision of the blobs of different sizes in this area produces the asymmetric enhanced emission which is observed ( horne 1999 ) . + the sw sex stars and sxts in outbursts have high accretion rates . in contrast , our doppler map was obtained in quiescence when the accretion rate is very low . if the outbursts are due to the thermal - viscous instability , the thin disk becomes neutral which casts doubts on its ability to anchor a magnetic field for this propeller mechanism to work . on the other hand , the inner regions of the thin disk are most probably replaced by a hot thick and optically thin accretion flow during quiescence . this is required to explain e.g. the x - ray luminosities of quiescent bh sxts ( lasota , narayan & yi 1996 and the review by narayan , mahadevan & quataert 1998 ) or the recurrence times of sxts ( dubus , hameury & lasota 2001 ) . these ionised flows have very short accretion timescales which makes it unlikely that they could sustain large - scale steady magnetic fields reaching to the accretion stream . + the neutron star magnetosphere itself can become an efficient propeller in quiescence ( menou et al . strong winds in the thick accretion flow could also prevent much of the matter from reaching the ns ( blandford & begelman 1999 ) . yet , it is hard to see in both cases how this would lead to the observed asymmetric h@xmath21 emission since the matter comes from an _ axisymmetric _ flow . we are grateful to d. martnez - delgado and g. israelian for helpful comments . this work is based on observations collected at the european southern observatory in chile . this research has made use of the _ simbad _ database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france . g. dubus acknowledges support from nasa under grants nag5 - 7007 and nag5 - 7034 . t. shahbaz acknowledges support by the _ marie curie _ fellowship hp - mf - ct 199900297 .

we present vlt low resolution spectroscopy of the neutron star x - ray transient xte j2123 - 058 during its quiescent state . our data reveal the presence of a k7v companion which contributes 77 % to the total flux at @xmath06300 and orbits the neutron star at @xmath1 km s@xmath2 . contrary to other soft x - ray transients ( sxts ) , the @xmath3 emission is almost exactly in antiphase with the velocity curve of the optical companion . using the light - center technique we obtain @xmath4 km s@xmath2 and hence @xmath5 . this , combined with a previous determination of the inclination angle ( @xmath6 ) yields @xmath7 m@xmath8 and @xmath9 m@xmath8 . @xmath10 agrees well with the observed spectral type . doppler tomography of the h@xmath11 emission shows a non - symmetric accretion disc distribution mimicking that seen in sw sex stars . although we find a large systemic velocity of -110 @xmath12 km s@xmath2 this value is consistent with the galactic rotation velocity at the position of j2123 - 058 , and hence a halo origin . the formation scenario of j2123 - 058 is still unresolved . stars : accretion , accretion discs binaries : close stars : individual : xte j2123058 x - rays : stars .

cond-mat0212617

in the last years a strong effort has been devoted to understand both the equilibrium and out - of equilibrium properties of ultrathin magnetic films @xcite . these materials have attracted much attention mainly due to their potential applications , such as information storage @xcite . ultra - thin films find also many important applications both in biotechnology and pharmacology . it is today a well established experimental fact that the magnetization processes in ultra - thin magnetic films are ruled by the microscopic competition between short range ferromagnetic couplings and long - range frustrated antiferromagnetic dipolar interactions , which give place to very novel dynamical and static behaviors @xcite . it is worth mentioning that both the theoretical and the experimental interest in studying systems with competition between short - range ordering interactions and long range frustrating interactions widely exceeds the field of ultra thin films . actually , many different experimental systems can be modeled by this kind of microscopic interactions , which give place to very rich dynamical and static properties . in soft matter physics for instance , we can mention diblock copolymer melt and cross linked polymer mixtures , among others . type i superconductors and rare earth layers that occur in the perovskite structure of reba@xmath9cu@xmath10o@xmath11 ( where re represents a rare earth from the lanthanide series ) can be very well modeled with these interactions @xcite . it has also been frequently suggested that competing interactions can explain many of the phenomenological features observed in the glass formation process and in supercooled liquids @xcite . summarizing , many of the conclusions drawn from this work can be surely be applied to a large variety of physical systems . for sufficiently thin films the magnetic moments align perpendicular to the plane of the film , indicating that the surface anisotropy is sufficient to overcome the anisotropy of the dipolar interaction which favors in - plane ordering . works in two dimensional uniaxial spin systems , where the spins are oriented perpendicular to the lattice and coupled with these kind of interactions , have shown a very rich phenomenological scenario concerning both its equilibrium statistical mechanics @xcite and non - equilibrium dynamical properties @xcite . in particular , some of these results @xcite showed the existence of different types of slow relaxation dynamics when the system is quenched from a disordered high temperature configuration to a subcritical temperature , depending on the relative strengths of the dipolar and exchange interactions . under these circumstance one can use a uniaxial ising representation for describing the magnetic moments @xcite . the ultra thin film is then described by the hamiltonian @xmath12 where the spin variable @xmath13 is located at site @xmath14 of a square lattice , the sum @xmath15 runs over all pairs of nearest neighbor sites and @xmath16 runs over all distinct pair of sites of the lattice ; @xmath17 is the distance ( in crystal units ) between sites @xmath14 and @xmath18 , @xmath4 represents the quotient between the exchange @xmath0 and dipolar @xmath1 coupling parameters ( @xmath19 ) . the energy is measured in units of @xmath1 , which is always assumed to be antiferromagnetic @xmath20 . hence @xmath21 means ferromagnetic exchange coupling . we have recently studied in detail @xcite the low temperature phase diagram of this system in the region where the change in the relaxation properties has been observed . we showed that for very low temperatures metastable states appear . in this work we investigate the effects of the presence of these metastable states on the far - from equilibrium dynamical properties of the system . in section [ meta ] we present a review of the equilibrium phase diagram and metastability properties in the region of interest . in section [ slow ] we analyze the magnetic domain growth or coarsening dynamics of the system when it is quenched from a disordered state ( which corresponds to infinite temperature ) to a temperature below the ordering transition for different values of @xmath4 . using monte carlo simulations we study the statistics of domains of the striped phases h1 and h2 . we then analyze the temporal behavior of the average linear size of the domains @xmath22 . we show that the coarsening dynamics is strongly affected by the presence of metastable states , which generate blocking clusters of the metastable phase where the domain walls of the stable phase become pinned . such blocking clusters generate free energy barriers to the domain growth dynamics that are independent of the linear domain size . some conclusions and remarks are summarized in section [ conclu ] . the overall features of the finite temperature phase diagram associated with hamiltonian ( [ hamilton1 ] ) were described by macisaac and coauthors @xcite by means of monte carlo simulations on @xmath23 lattices and analytic calculations of the ground state @xcite . they found that the ground state of hamiltonian ( [ hamilton1 ] ) is the antiferromagnetic state for @xmath24 @xcite . for @xmath25 the antiferromagnetic state becomes unstable with respect to the formation of striped domains structures , that is , to state configurations with spins aligned along a particular axis forming ferromagnetic stripes of constant width @xmath26 , so that spins in adjacent stripes are anti - aligned , forming a super lattice in the direction perpendicular to the stripes . at high temperatures , of course , the system always becomes paramagnetic . specific heat calculations showed that the transition between the paramagnetic and the striped phases is a second order one @xcite . we have recently @xcite performed monte carlo simulations of hamiltonian ( [ hamilton1 ] ) on square lattices up to @xmath27 sites using periodic boundary conditions and heat bath dynamics . our calculations focused on the low temperature region of the @xmath2 phase diagram for values of @xmath4 between @xmath28 and @xmath29 , which includes the transition line between the @xmath30 and the striped phase with width @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) and also the transition line between the @xmath6 phase and the striped phase with width @xmath7 ( @xmath8 ) . first we calculated , through the energy fluctuations , the specific heat @xmath31 as a function of temperature for different values of @xmath4 and different system sizes up to @xmath27 sites . by considering the peaks in the specific heat we obtained the second order critical line between the paramagnetic and the low temperature ordered phases @xmath6 and @xmath8 . these results ( see fig . [ diagrama_fases ] ) slightly improved those obtained by macisaac and coauthors @xcite for @xmath23 lattices , thus showing a fast convergence of the critical temperature for increasing system sizes , at least for small values of @xmath4 . phase diagram @xmath2 in the region of parameters under study . filled triangles correspond to the critical temperatures @xmath32 obtained by specific heat calculations for the phase transition between the ordered antiferromagnetic ( af ) and striped phases @xmath6 and @xmath8 and the paramagnetic ( * para * ) one . filled circles ( open squares ) correspond to the stability line of the @xmath6 ( @xmath8 ) phase , obtained by analyzing the staggered magnetization @xmath33 ( @xmath34 ) . filled diamonds correspond to the first order transition lines between the @xmath6 and @xmath8 phases and also between the @xmath6 and @xmath30 phases , obtained by the free energy numerical calculations . the shaded region indicates the presence of metastable states . ] [ fig1 ] next , through a numerical study of the free energy , we analyzed the transition between the @xmath6 and @xmath8 phases . the free energy of the phase @xmath6 ( @xmath8 ) was calculated for increasing ( decreasing ) values of @xmath4 . we observed a continuous change of the minimal free energy from one phase to the other , with a discontinuous change in the slope for @xmath35 indicating the presence of a first order phase transition @xcite . this transition is indicated by means of diamonds in fig . [ diagrama_fases ] . we have also repeated these calculations for the transition line between the @xmath6 and @xmath30 phase , finding similar results . close to @xmath35 the free energy displays a multivalued behavior characteristic of a first order phase transition . this behavior signals the metastable nature of these phases in some parts of the phase diagram . to characterize the presence of metastable states observed in the transition between the @xmath6 and @xmath8 phases we introduced the staggered magnetizations @xmath33 and @xmath34 , and also their associated susceptibilities @xmath36 and @xmath37 for the @xmath6 and @xmath8 phases these quantities permitted us to analyze the stability of both phases in the different parts of the phase diagram . in fig . [ diagrama_fases ] the shaded region indicates the presence of metastable states . it is important to stress that in the shaded region inside phase @xmath6 the only phase observed to be metastable was @xmath8 . for @xmath38 metastables states of phases of higher width were observed , leading to a much more complicated metastable region . in this work we will focus only on the dynamical behavior of the system in the @xmath6 region . as we will show in the next section , for a fixed value of @xmath4 inside this region different dynamical regimes are observed as the temperature is lowered and one enters the region of metastability . when a system is quenched from a high temperature disordered phase into a low temperature ordered phase domains form and grow , a process that is known as coarsening . the coarsening process has been extensively studied both experimentally and theoretically over the past decade @xcite . perhaps the most thoroughly studied system , and also the most common example is the ising model . when this system is quenched from a high temperature to one below its critical temperature ( @xmath39 ) ferromagnetic domains of up and down spins form and coarsen . the system presents curvature driven growth and the characteristic domain size @xmath22 grows with time as @xmath40 . if the system is cooled to zero temperature the domain walls can be easily determined as bonds between oppositely oriented spins , but if the system is cooled to a temperature different from zero it becomes difficult to define domains and domain walls since small islands generated by thermal fluctuations arise . to overcome this problem , derrida @xcite proposed a new method to measure properties related to coarsening in the presence of thermal fluctuations . this method was extended by hinrichsen and antoni @xcite to determine domain walls for nonzero temperatures . the method compares the state of a system with replicas in the different ground state configurations when they are all submitted to the same thermal noise , that is , when the same sequence of random numbers is used to update all systems . in this way , if one starts from a replica in the ordered state a spin flip will be a consequence of the thermal noise . when a spin flip occurs simultaneously in all the replicas it can be considered as a thermal fluctuation , otherwise the fluctuation will be due to the coarsening process . we used this technique to study the dynamics of domain walls , and characterize the coarsening process , when the system described by hamiltonian ( [ hamilton1 ] ) is quenched from a high temperature disordered state into the region where it orders . in particular we focus our interest on the growth of domains of the striped phase @xmath6 when the metastability line is crossed for values of @xmath41 ( see fig.[diagrama_fases ] ) . to characterize the growth of the domains we determined first the domain areas @xmath42 , by counting the number of spins inside each domain . the characteristic ( linear ) domain size was calculated as @xmath43 , where @xmath44 is the mean domain area of the system at time @xmath45 . in fig . [ dinamica1 ] we present the behavior of the characteristic domain size @xmath46 when @xmath47 and @xmath48 for three different system sizes @xmath49 , @xmath50 and @xmath51 . after a short transient in which the characteristic length presents a slow growth the system enters into a coarsening regime where @xmath40 , as expected for a system with non conserved order parameter@xcite . for large times @xmath46 presents a crossover to a saturation value . this saturation behavior is clearly a finite size effect , since a domain can not grow beyond the system size @xmath52 so that as the system size increase , the behavior @xmath53 remains for larger periods of time . characteristic domain size @xmath46 vs. @xmath45 when @xmath47 and @xmath48 for three different system sizes @xmath49 , @xmath50 and @xmath51 . the dashed line indicates @xmath40 . the inset shows the data collapse obtained using finite size scaling analysis . ] in section [ meta ] we observed and characterized the presence of metastable states in the low temperature region of the phase diagram . we will study now how the behavior of @xmath46 changes as we lower the temperature and cross the metastability line for a fixed value of @xmath4 . in fig . [ dinamica2 ] we present the time evolution of @xmath46 when @xmath47 for eight decreasing temperatures . for low temperatures a regime of slow growth develops at intermediate time scales before the system crosses over to the @xmath54 coarsening regime . as we lower the temperature the intermediate regime extends to larger time scales , but all the curves eventually cross over to the @xmath55 regime . note that for short times there seems to be a change in the concavity of @xmath46 when it crosses @xmath56 , which coincides with the boundary of the metastable phase for @xmath47 . characteristic domain size @xmath46 vs. @xmath45 when @xmath47 ( @xmath57 ) for eight different temperatures , starting form the left curve @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 . note that all the curves eventually cross - over to the @xmath53 regime indicated with a dashed line . ] to characterize the behavior of @xmath46 as we lower the temperature we studied the crossover time @xmath66 from the power law to the saturation regime . note that the crossover time to the power law regime presents a similar behavior . however the study of the intersection of the power law branch of the curve and the horizontal saturation branch allows for a sistematic approach . this is so since the saturation value always correspond to the linear size of the system . in figure [ dinamica3 ] we present how @xmath66 grows as the temperature is lowered . for temperatures greater than @xmath56 the crossover time presents a linear dependency with @xmath67 , while for temperatures lower than @xmath56 it presents an exponential increase with @xmath67 as can be observed in the arrhenius plot presented in the inset of fig . [ dinamica3 ] . the straight line indicates the best fit , given by a function of the form @xmath68 where @xmath69 and @xmath70 . using this expression we present in fig . [ dinamica4 ] a data collapse plot of @xmath46 in the low temperature regime . in the high temperature regime the crossover time decreases linearly as the temperature increases , and @xmath46 collapses simply by scaling with @xmath71 as can be seen in figure [ dinamica5 ] . summarizing , for @xmath47 two different dynamical regimes were observed above and below the metastability line ( @xmath56 ) . when the system is quenched to the ordered phase to a temperature @xmath72 , the characteristic domain size @xmath46 grows as @xmath54 after a short transient . if , on the other hand , the system is quenched to a temperature @xmath73 , an intermediate regime with a slow growth appears . for long times the system always crosses over to the @xmath54 regime . that is , for every temperature we observe the same behavior presented in fig.[dinamica2 ] , where @xmath46 always reaches the asymptotic behavior @xmath54 as we increase the system size . however , as we lower the temperature the crossover time to this regime increases . we repeated these analysis for different values of @xmath4 , inside the @xmath5 region , obtaining the same qualitative behaviors . these dynamical behaviors present a strong resemblance with the ones observed in the two dimensional shore model @xcite . this model is a ferromagnetic ising model on a square lattice with frustration added by introducing weak next - nearest - neighbor antiferromagnetic bonds , that is @xmath74 the presence of nnn antiferromagnetic bonds in this model introduce free energy barriers to domain coarsening that are independent of the domain size @xmath22@xcite . such barriers in this model are a consequence of a corner rounding process which generates structures that block the coarsening dynamics@xcite . hence , the system is stuck and coarsens little on time scales @xmath75 ( @xmath76 being the height of the barrier ) , while on time scales @xmath77 the free energy barrier can be crossed and the @xmath54 behavior emerges . data collapse plot of @xmath46 in the low temperature regime for three different temperatures ( @xmath78 and @xmath57 ) . the crossover time @xmath66 corresponds to the best fit presented in eq . ( [ eqtau ] ) . ] data collapse plot of @xmath46 in the high temperature regime for three different temperatures @xmath78 and @xmath57 . ] thus , it is interesting to see if structures that block the coarsening process are present in our system . in fact the presence of metastable states for low temperatures gives a strong hint of what to look for . figure [ dinamica6 ] presents a series of snapshots of the coarsening process when a system of size @xmath51 and @xmath47 is quenched to @xmath65 . for these values of @xmath4 and @xmath71 the system evolves in the metastability region . two different kind of domain walls can be clearly distinguished . when domains of phase @xmath6 with different orientation meet , the walls detected by the method are thin . the thicker walls correspond to bands of two spins , that is stripes of phase h2 . we should stress that phase h2 is the only metastable phase in phase h1 @xcite . notice how these small blocks of the h2 phase seem to slow the domain growth by pinning the domain walls . these small blocks were also observed at short times when the system was quenched to a temperature above the metastability line , however they are highly unstable and did not seem to block the domain growth . in order to quantify this effect , we studied the time for completely shrinking squares in phase h2 immersed in a system in phase h1 with fixed boundary conditions . a square was considered to be completely shrunk when the length of the sorrounding domain walls became zero . fig.[square ] presents a series of snapshots of this process . in the first time steps the square quickly deforms . however , further advance seems to be blocked by small blocks of spins in the @xmath8 phase . this coarsening behavior presents a strong resemblance to the one observed in the snapshots presented in fig . [ dinamica6 ] . figure [ dinamica7 ] shows the time @xmath79 to shrink a @xmath80 square in phase @xmath8 immersed in a system with @xmath51 spins in phase @xmath6 with fixed boundary conditions . as the temperature is lowered the shrinking time diverges as @xmath81 . this divergence agrees well with the divergence observed in the crossover time from the slow growth to the @xmath54 regime . we have also studied the shrinking time of blocks in different phases , such as combinations of vertical and horizontal @xmath6 phases and also a ferromagnetic block immersed in the @xmath6 phase . in all these cases a similar behavior was observed . the system quickly reached a configuration where small blocks of the @xmath8 phase were present , with a slowing down of the domain growth similar to the one described above . in this paper we have studied some dynamical properties of a two - dimensional ising hamiltonian with competing interactions . we analyzed the coarsening process when the system is quenched from a high temperature disordered phase into the ordered phase @xmath6 . to characterize the growth of domains we considered the time evolution of the characteristic domain size @xmath46 . we found that for a fixed value of @xmath4 the system presents two different dynamical behaviors associated with the presence or absence of @xmath8 metastable states . when the system is quenched into the ordered phase for temperatures above the metastability region , the characteristic domain length presents a power law @xmath54 growth . if , on the other hand , the system is quenched to temperature in the metastability region , the behavior of @xmath46 presents a slow growth intermediate regime before crossing over to the @xmath54 power law growth . through a direct examination of snapshots of the system during the coarsening process we found that the presence of small domains in the @xmath8 phase slowed the coarsening when the system was quenched to the metastable region . these results are consistent with the presence of free energy barriers independent of the domain size @xmath22 , associated with blocking clusters of the metastable phase , which generates a crossover in the coarsening behavior as we cross the spinodal line . since the cross over time diverges as the temperature is lowered , the very slow behavior at intermediate times may be indistinguishable from a logarithmic law . this could explain the apparently logarithmic scaling observed in the aging behavior of this model@xcite . this work was partially supported by grants from consejo nacional de investigaciones cientficas y tcnicas conicet ( argentina ) , consejo provincial de investigaciones cientficas y tecnolgicas ( crdoba , argentina ) , secretara de ciencia y tecnologa de la universidad nacional de crdoba ( argentina ) and fundacin antorchas ( argentina ) . k. debell , a. b. macisaac and j. p. whitehead , rev . phys . * 72 * , 225 ( 2000 ) . l. c. sampaio , m. p. de albuquerque and f. s. de menezes , phys . b * 54 * , 6465 ( 1996 ) . a. b. macisaac , j. p. whitehead , m. c. robinson and k. debell , phys . b * 51 * , 16033 ( 1995 ) . d. kivelson , s. a. kivelson , x. zhao , z. nussinov and t. gilles . physica a * 219 * , 27 ( 1995 ) . a. kashuba and v. l. pokrovsky . lett . * 70 * , 3155 ( 1993 ) . j. h. toloza , f. a. tamarit and s. a. cannas , phys . b * 58 * , r8885 ( 1998 ) . d. a. stariolo and s. a. cannas phys . b * 60 * , 3013 ( 1999 ) . r. allenspach , m. stampanoni and a. bischof , phys . * 65 * , 3344 ( 1990 ) . r. allenspach , and a. bischof , phys . lett . * 69 * , 3385 ( 1992 ) . p. m. gleiser , f. a. tamarit and s. a. cannas , physica d * 168169 * , 73 ( 2002 ) . it is worth noting that macisaac and coauthors @xcite definition of the hamiltonian ( eq . ( 5 ) in that reference ) is slightly different from ours ( eq([hamilton1 ] ) ) . while in that paper the dipolar term contains a sum over all pairs of spins , in hamiltonian ( [ hamilton1 ] ) we consider the sum over every pair of spins just once . this leads to the equivalence @xmath82 , @xmath83 being the exchange parameter in the above reference . since the dipolar parameter also fixes the energy units in our work , there is also a factor @xmath84 between the critical temperatures obtained in both works .

the far from equilibrium low temperature dynamics of ultra - thin magnetic films is analyzed by using monte carlo numerical simulations on a two dimensional ising model with competing exchange ( @xmath0 ) and dipolar ( @xmath1 ) interactions . in particular , we focus our attention on the low temperature region of the @xmath2 phase diagram ( where @xmath3 ) for the range of values of @xmath4 where striped phases with widths @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) and @xmath7 ( @xmath8 ) are present . the presence of metastable states of the phase @xmath8 in the region where the phase @xmath6 is the thermodynamically stable one and viceversa was established recently . in this work we show that the presence of these metastable states appears as a blocking mechanism that slows the dynamics of magnetic domains growth when the system is quenched from a high temperature state to a low temperature state in the region of metastability .

1411.3108

supergiant high mass x - ray binaries ( hmxbs ) account for one third of the galactic hmxb population . the compact object has an early type supergiant star as a companion and the accretion unto the compact object occurs via stellar wind or roche lobe overflow . they are subdivided into roche lobe filling supergiants with short spin periods and underfilled roche lobe supergiants with longer spin periods @xcite . a majority of supergiant hmxbs are persistent sources . some of the supergiant hmxbs , called the highly absorbed supergiant hmxbs , have very strong absorption with column density of absorbing matter n@xmath6 @xmath4 . igr j16393 - 4643 belongs to this increasing class of heavily absorbed hmxbs detected by the _ integral _ survey of the galactic plane , that are mainly concentrated in the spiral arms . it was first discovered with the _ asca _ observatory during survey of the galactic plane @xcite and was named as ax j1639.0 - 4642 . it has a spin period of @xmath7 910 s and a 4.2 days orbital period @xcite and occupies a unique position near the top edge of underfilled roche lobe supergiant systems in the corbet diagram @xcite . due to the lack of detailed studies of such systems , igr j16393 - 4643 makes an interesting candidate to study the timing and spectral properties of the short orbital period and long spin period supergiant systems . the x - ray spectrum of the pulsar is characterised by a highly absorbed power - law with an exponential cut - off along with fe fluorescence lines @xcite . the strong absorption of the order @xmath8 @xmath4 is an evidence of a dense circumstellar environment surrounding the pulsar . previous observations with _ xmm - newton _ indicates the presence of a soft excess in the spectrum which could be due to x - rays scattering by the stellar wind @xcite . here we present the simultaneous broad - band pulse profiles and spectral characteristics of the pulsar igr j16393 - 4643 obtained from a _ suzaku _ observation . we also present results from the orbital intensity profile analysis of igr j16393 - 4643 using _ swift - bat _ light - curves . the energy resolved pulse profiles are created for the first time for this source . the broad - band spectral characteristics are studied both for the phase averaged as well as resolving the pulse phase into peak phase and trough phase . these results provide valuable insights into the nature of the such underfilled roche lobe supergiant systems . _ suzaku _ is the fifth japanese x - ray astronomy satellite launched in july 2005 . it consists of two sets of co - aligned scientific instruments , the x - ray imaging spectrometer ( xis ) , operating in the energy range 0.2 - 12 kev and hard x - ray detector ( hxd ) , operating in the energy range 10 - 600 kev . the xis consists of three front illuminated ccd detectors and one back illuminated ccd detector @xcite , out of which three ccds xis0 , xis1 and xis3 are currently operational . the hxd consists of silicon pin diodes operating in energy range 10 - 70 kev and gso crystal scintillators extending the energy range till 600 kev @xcite . igr j16393 - 4643 was observed with _ suzaku _ during 12 march 2010 ( obsid : 404056010 ) with an useful exposure time of @xmath7 44 kilosecs over a span of about 120 kilosecs . the observations were carried out at the ` xis nominal ' pointing position and the xis were operated in ` standard ' data mode in the ` normal window ' option , having a time resolution of 8 secs . for both the xis and hxd data , we have used the filtered cleaned event files which are obtained using the pre - determined screening criteria described in the suzaku abc guide . the xis light - curves and spectra were extracted from the cleaned event files by selecting circular regions of 3 around the source centroid . the background light - curves and spectra were extracted by selecting circular regions of same size away from the source centroid . for hxd / pin background , simulated ` tuned ' non x - ray background event files ( nxb ) corresponding to the month and year of the observation was used to estimate the non x - ray background . the cosmic x - ray background was simulated as suggested by the instrument team with appropriate normalisations and response files . the response files for xis were created using caldb ` 20140211 ' and for hxd / pin , response files were obtained from the _ suzaku _ guest observer facility . for the timing analysis of the source , we have applied barycentric corrections to the event data files using the ftools task ` aebarycen ' . light - curves with time resolution of 1 s and 8 s were extracted from hxd / pin ( 12 - 50 kev ) and xis ( 0.3 - 12 kev ) respectively . figure . [ lightcurves ] shows the light - curves binned with a time bin of 908 secs _ i.e _ at the pulsar spin period , in xis and pin along with the hardness ratio . the count - rate in xis and pin increases gradually from the start of the observation upto 100 kilosecs by a factor of @xmath7 2 and then decreases by a similar factor till the end of the observation ( also see second and third panel in figure [ orbital ] ) . the hardness ratio remained constant throughout the observation . we have used long term light - curve of igr j16393 - 4643 in 15 - 50 kev _ swift - bat _ energy band to estimate the orbital period of the system ( p@xmath9 = 366150 secs ; consistent with @xcite ) . we then folded the xis and pin light - curves with the _ swift - bat _ light - curves , to investigate the orbital phase of the _ suzaku _ observation . the minimum of the orbital intensity profile is taken as orbital phase zero , corresponding to epoch mjd : 53417.955 . figure [ orbital ] shows an indication that the system is an eclipsing binary , which was also reported previously by @xcite . the eclipse duration is short with the eclipse semi - angle @xmath0 17@xmath1 . the _ suzaku _ observations were carried out roughly from orbital phase 0.55 - 0.9 _ i.e _ prior to going into the eclipse . as seen in figure [ orbital ] , the count - rate in xis and pin increases by a factor of @xmath7 2 during orbital phase @xmath7 0.65 - 0.8 and then again decreases till the end of the observation . the orbital intensity profile created with _ swift - bat _ is averaged over many orbital cycles , whereas the orbital intensity profile created with xis and pin show variability on sub - orbital timescales , similar to that seen in oao 1657 - 415 @xcite . we have searched for pulsations in the light - curves by applying pulse folding and @xmath10 maximization technique and the pulse period was found to be 908.79 @xmath11 0.01 secs . we then created the energy resolved pulse profiles by folding light - curves extracted in different energy bands with the pulse period . light - curves from xis0 , xis1 and xis3 were added together to create the pulse profiles in xis energy band 0.3 - 12 kev and sub bands within . from figure [ pulseprofiles ] , we see that the pulse profiles have a complex morphology with some energy dependance , which was also seen with _ xmm - newton _ @xcite and _ rxte pca _ @xcite , but the broad - band nature of the pulse profiles are brought out from this _ suzaku _ observation . due to the presence of high column density of absorbing matter , very few photons are detected below 4 kev . the epoch for creation of the pulse profiles is adjusted to make the minima appear at phase zero in the pin 12 - 50 kev energy band . the pulse minima is seen to become deeper at higher energies . a phase lag is seen in the energy resolved pulse profiles in the two xis energy bands compared to the pin energy bands , which is shown in figure [ xis_pin ] for pulse profiles created in xis energy band 0.3 - 6.0 kev and 6 - 12 and in pin energy band 12 - 50 kev . we have performed the pulse phase averaged spectral analysis of igr j16393 - 4643 using spectra from three xis and pin . the energy range chosen for spectral fitting was 3.0 kev to 10.0 kev for xis , since there were hardly any photons below 3.0 kev . for pin , the energy range was chosen from 15 kev to 50 kev . the xis spectra were rebinned by a factor of 12 upto 5 kev , by a factor of 6 from 5 - 7 kev and again by a factor of 12 from 7 - 10 kev . the pin spectra was rebinned by a factor of 2 till 22 kev , by 8 from 22 - 45 kev and by a factor of 12 for the rest . the spectral fitting was done with xspec 12.8.1 . to fit the continuum spectra , we have tried several standard continuum models used for hmxb pulsars like cut - off power - law ( cutoffpl ) , power - law with high energy cut - off ( highecut , @xcite ) , power - law with a fermi - dirac cut - off ( fdcut , @xcite ) , and negative and positive power - law exponential ( npex , @xcite ) . the power - law with highecut and power - law with fdcut spectral models provided the best fits to the phase averaged spectrum with physically acceptable parameter values and henceforth , we report results from these two spectral models . we fitted the spectra simultaneously with all the parameters tied , except the relative normalisations of the instruments which were kept free . a 6.4 kev fe k@xmath12 line was also found in the spectra , which was modelled by a gaussian emission line . the 7.1 kev k@xmath13 line detected in the spectra with the _ xmm - newton _ observation @xcite was marginally detected here with the 90 @xmath14 upper limit on the line flux as @xmath15 photons @xmath4 s@xmath16 and equivalent width of 33 ev , consistent with the upper limits quoted for _ xmm - newton _ observation ( @xmath17 photons @xmath4 s@xmath16 and 120 ev respectively ; @xcite ) . the best fit parameter values of phase averaged spectrum for 90@xmath14 confidence limits ( except for @xmath18 and equivalent width of the fe line which are given for 1@xmath19 confidence limits ) for the two spectral models power - law with highecut and power - law with fdcut are given in table 1 . figure [ spectra ] shows the best fit phase averaged spectrum using power - law with highecut and power - law with fdcut models , along with the residuals . [ table ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the energy dependence of the pulse fraction as seen in the xis and pin energy bands ( figure [ pulseprofiles ] and figure [ xis_pin ] ) indicates a significant change in the spectrum with the pulse phase and we investigate the same with pulse phase resolved spectroscopy at the peak and trough of the pulse profile . the xis and pin spectrum were binned into two states : a peak phase around the pulse maximum ( phase 0.4 - 0.8 ) and a trough phase around the pulse minima ( phase 0.0 - 0.2 and 0.9 - 1.0 ) , similar to the pulse phase definition used in @xcite . in the peak phase as well as the trough phase , the xis spectra and pin spectra were rebinned by the same factors used in phase averaged spectra . to study the changes in spectral parameters in the two pulse phases , we used the same models as in the phase averaged spectrum . however , width of the fe k@xmath12 line could not be constrained in the peak phase spectra and was fixed to its phase averaged value . the best fit parameter values of the peak phase spectra and the trough phase spectra for 90@xmath14 confidence limits ( except for @xmath18 and equivalent width of the fe line for both the spectral models which are given for 1@xmath19 confidence limits ) for the two spectral models power - law with highecut and power - law with fdcut are given in table.1 . figure [ phaseresolved ] shows the peak phase and trough phase spectra using power - law with highecut and power - law with fdcut spectral models , along with the residuals . a softening in the spectrum with an increase in the fe equivalent width is noticed at the trough phase . the first panel in figure [ orbital ] is the orbital intensity profile created by folding the long term light - curve of igr j16393 - 4643 obtained with _ swift - bat _ in energy range 15 - 50 kev , with the orbital period of the system ( p@xmath9 = 366150 secs ) . the orbital intensity profile shows a narrow eclipse around orbital phase zero with the eclipse semi - angle @xmath0 17@xmath1 . recent _ chandra _ observation of this binary system proposed the optical counterpart to be either a supergiant o9 star with radius r@xmath7 20 r@xmath2 or a main sequence b star with radius r@xmath7 10 r@xmath2 @xcite . the short orbital period of the binary system makes it more likely to have a supergiant o9 star as its companion than a main sequence b star . however , @xcite pointed out that having a supergiant o9 star as a companion would imply a lower limit of distance of 25 kpc to the binary as compared to a distance of 12 kpc for a main sequence b star . the supergiant hmxbs like cen x-3 , vela x-1 and oao 1657 - 415 have masses of the companion star in the range of 10 m@xmath2 - 30 m@xmath2 and radii in the range of 10 r@xmath2 - 35 r@xmath2 , with a nearly circularised orbit @xcite . so assuming a circular orbit , the separation between the binary components _ a _ , can be expressed as @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the mass of the neutron star which is assumed to be 1.4 m@xmath2 , @xmath22 = 4.24 days is the orbital period of the system and @xmath23 is the mass of the supergiant companion star which is assumed to be in the range 10 m@xmath2 - 30 m@xmath2 . + for an orbital separation _ a _ , we have then calculated the range of inclination @xmath24 as a function of the companion star radius @xmath25 , given by equation [ equation ] @xcite . @xmath26 where @xmath27 17@xmath1 is the observed eclipse semi - angle . the upper limit to the companion radius for a given mass is constrained by the roche lobe radius r@xmath28 , which is given by the equation [ roche ] @xcite @xmath29 similiarly , we carried out the above calculations for the companion as a main sequence b star having masses in the range of 2 m@xmath2 - 16 m@xmath2 and radii in the range of 5 r@xmath2 - 25 r@xmath2 @xcite and assuming a circular orbit . figure [ inclination ] is the plot of the range of inclination angles allowed for given mass of the o9 supergiant companion star and main sequence b star as a function of its radius , assuming a circular orbit . for a supergiant companion star radius of 20 r@xmath2 , the inclination of the orbital plane of the binary system is in the range @xmath30 . for a main sequence b star of radius 10 r@xmath2 , the inclination of the orbital plane of the binary system is in the range @xmath31 . figure [ pulseprofiles ] shows the complex double peaked pulse profiles of igr j16393 - 4643 in the _ suzaku _ energy sub - bands . the pulse fraction increases with energy , from @xmath7 33@xmath14 in xis 0.3 - 12 kev energy band to @xmath7 65@xmath14 in pin 12 - 50 kev energy band , which is also seen in many other x - ray pulsars @xcite . there is a narrow dip present in the pulse profiles at pulse phase @xmath7 0.35 , which was also seen in pulse profiles created with _ @xcite and _ xmm - newton _ @xcite . this narrow dip exists even at higher energies as seen in figure [ pulseprofiles ] and figure [ xis_pin ] for xis and pin energy bands . narrow high energy dips in the pulse profiles are seen in other x - ray pulsars like gx 1 + 4 @xcite , exo 2030 + 375 @xcite , a 0535 + 262 @xcite and are associated with the intrinsic beaming pattern of the source . from figure . [ xis_pin ] , we see a phase lag of the soft photons with respect to the hard photons in the energy resolved pulse profiles . such soft phase lags have been observed in millisecond x - ray pulsars @xcite . however , further analysis with respect to the actual cause of phase lag is limited by the statistical quality of the data . from phase averaged spectral characteristics of igr j16393 - 4643 ( table 1 and figure [ spectra ] ) , we find very high line of sight column density of absorbing matter @xmath32 @xmath4 . such high column density of absorbing matter has been found in previous studies of this system by _ rxte - pca _ @xcite and by _ xmm - newton _ @xcite and is attributed to the circumstellar environment around the pulsar . the phase averaged spectrum is described by a power - law with spectral index @xmath5 0.9 and a high energy cut - off above 20 kev . the presence of the soft excess as detected from the _ xmm - newton _ observation @xcite could not be confirmed in the _ suzaku _ observation . due to limited statistical quality of this _ suzaku _ observation , it is difficult to make an in - depth pulse phase resolved spectral analysis . instead , the pulse profile is broadly resolved into peak phase and trough phase and pulse phase dependance of the spectral properties are studied in these two phase - bins ( figure [ phaseresolved ] ) . while the column density is similar in both the pulse phases , there is a change in the continuum spectral parameters which is observed for both the spectral models in table 1 . the spectrum is softer at the trough phase and harder at the peak phase , which may be due the additional softer photons near the off pulse regions . alternately , this may also imply a deeper and more direct view into the emission region along the magnetic axis at the pulse peak as would be for the case for a fan beam kind of emission pattern @xcite . the cut - off parameters ( fold energy e@xmath33 and cut - off energy e@xmath34 ) for both power - law with highecut and power - law with fdcut spectral models however , remain constant in the two pulse phases . the fe k@xmath12 line is present in both the phases , with the equivalent width higher in trough phase than in peak phase . in contrast with the results obtained in @xcite with the _ xmm - newton _ , which operated in the limited energy band of 0.3 - 10 kev , there is an underlying change in the source spectrum as a function of pulse phase which is brought out in this broad - band _ suzaku _ observation . igr j16393 - 4643 makes an interesting candidate for detailed pulse phase resolved spectroscopy with future x - ray missions with broad - band energy coverage . such in - depth analysis will help in better understanding of the accretion geometry and beaming pattern of these underfilled roche lobe systems . * acknowledgement * + the authors thank an anonymous referee for useful comments . the data used for this work has been obtained through the high energy astrophysics science archive ( heasarc ) online service provided by nasa / gsfc . we have also made use of the public light - curves from _ swift - bat _ site .

the pulsar igr j16393 - 4643 belongs to a class of highly absorbed supergiant hmxbs , characterised by very high column density of absorbing matter . we present the results of the simultaneous broad - band pulsation and spectrum analysis , from a 44 kilosec _ suzaku _ observation of the source . the orbital intensity profile created with the _ swift - bat _ light - curve shows an indication of igr j16393 - 4643 being an eclipsing system with a short eclipse semi - angle @xmath0 17@xmath1 . for a supergiant companion star with a 20 r@xmath2 radius , this implies an inclination of the orbital plane in the range of 39@xmath1 - 57@xmath1 , whereas for a main sequence b star as the companion with a 10 r@xmath2 radius , the inclination of the orbital plane is in the range of 60@xmath1 - 77@xmath1 . pulse profiles created for different energy bands , have complex morphology which shows some energy dependence and increases in pulse fraction with energy . we have also investigated broad - band spectral characteristics , for phase averaged and resolving the pulse phase into peak phase and trough phase . the phase averaged spectrum has a very high n@xmath3 @xmath4 ) and is described by power - law ( @xmath5 0.9 ) with a high energy cut - off above 20 kev . we find a change in the spectral index in the peak phase and trough phase , implying an underlying change in the source spectrum . x - rays : binaries - x - rays : individual : igr j16393 - 4643 - x - rays : stars - stars : neutron

chao-dyn9710016

the idea that chaotic scattering @xcite may play an important role in various problems in celestial mechanics became widely accepted after the pioneering work of petit and hnon @xcite . in their study of satellite encounters ( also known as hill s problem ) , they provided evidence for the presence of chaotic scattering by analyzing the dependence of a suitable parameter characterizing the outgoing asymptotic motion on the same parameter in the incoming asymptotics . they pointed out that the irregular behaviour of this scattering function , showing singularities on a fractal set , reflects the existence of scattering trajectories that are asymptotic to bounded orbits of the system . the bounded orbits form a fractal set called the chaotic set or nonattracting invariant set @xcite in phase space with stable manifolds extending smoothly into the region of asymptotic motion . whenever the initial condition of a scattering trajectory is placed on a stable manifold , it gets trapped in the corresponding bounded orbit , so the structure of the singularities in the scattering function reflects the fractal structure of the chaotic set . by presenting trajectory plots of various types , petit and hnon underlined this structure but attempted no detailed characterization of it . in this paper , we provide a hierarchic analysis of chaotic scattering in hill s problem by studying a slightly different scattering function , giving the dependence of the dwell time on the initial conditions , combined with a careful examination of scattering orbits . this method has recently been applied to a simple model of chemical reactions @xcite making properties of the hierarchic organization clear in that problem . at first , we give a brief introduction in sec . [ sec - hill ] to hill s problem based on ref . @xcite , then we present the dwell time function and the basic ideas of its hierarchic analysis in sec . [ sec - dwtime ] . in sec . [ sec - orbits ] , a selection of scattering orbits is used to point out the presence of a ternary organization in the scattering data and , correspondingly , in the structure of the chaotic set . finally , in sec . [ sec - discuss ] , we discuss the consequences of our findings including the possible use of the hierarchic information in the calculation of average quatities in hill s problem or other models exhibiting chaotic scattering . the behaviour of two small bodies ( satellites ) moving along coplanar circular orbits around a large central object ( the planet ) in the same ( counterclockwise ) direction can approximately be described , in each other s vicinity , by hill s equations @xcite : @xmath0 with @xmath1 . the coordinates @xmath2 and @xmath3 describe the positions of the satellites relative to each other , after an appropriate change of scales , in a comoving reference frame rotating around the planet . ( in particular , if one of the satellites is much smaller than the other , then these coordinates simply give the position of the small satellite while the big one rests in the origin . ) these equations contain no free parameter . they can be derived as the hamiltonian equations of motion from a suitable function @xmath4 , and , as a consequence , they give rise to a conserved quantity @xmath5 playing the role of energy in the problem . hill s equations allow general coplanar motions of the satellites , not just circular orbits . neglecting the interaction between the satellites , the `` free '' orbits can be parametrized by the difference @xmath6 of the two semimajor axes and a parameter @xmath7 called the reduced eccentricity ; for circular obits @xmath8 and @xmath6 is just the difference of the two orbit radii . therefore , the family of circular initial orbits can be parametrized by a single parameter @xmath6 ( apart from a trivial constant that can be transformed out by a suitable choice of the origin of time ) , and the constant of motion @xmath9 can be expressed through @xmath6 : @xmath10 . the symmetries of the equations also allow us to assume @xmath11 . we will concentrate on this situation in the following and leave the case of more general initial conditions to the discussion . if @xmath12 , the satellites slowly approach and get close to each other ( i.e. , they have an encounter ) due to the difference in their periods . during the encounter , their interaction must be taken into account ; as a result , they may perform complicated motion in the proximity of each other for a while , but then separate again and move away from each other asymptotically along generic elliptic orbits characterized by parameters @xmath13 and @xmath14 . bearing in mind the hamiltonian character of the problem , this process can be thought of as a scattering event from an incoming asymptotics with a given value of @xmath6 and @xmath8 into an outgoing asymptotics characterized by @xmath13 and @xmath14 . the complicated motion during the encounter , which gives the chaotic features to the scattering , is a manifestation of transient chaos @xcite , i.e. , chaotic motion on a finite time scale . in ref . @xcite , the function @xmath15 was used to point out the presence of chaotic scattering ; in the next section , we use a nowadays standard approach based on the dwell time ( or time delay ) function . in chaotic scattering processes , the dwell time function @xcite , measuring the time spent by a particle in the region of strong interaction with the scatterer , shows irregular behaviour similar to that of other scattering data . we can construct it by choosing a one - parameter family of initial conditions and recording the dwell times for the trajectories . in our case of satellite encounters , the family of initial circular orbits parametrized by @xmath16 is a natural choice . to give the initial conditions uniquely , we choose the origin of time so that at @xmath17 the initial @xmath3 coordinate is a fixed value @xmath18 , while ( as a consequence of @xmath19 and @xmath8 ) @xmath20 and @xmath21 is obtained from @xmath9 . the incoming asymptotics then corresponds to moving downward along a vertical straight line with @xmath22 and @xmath23 . we choose a circle with radius @xmath24 around the origin as the interaction zone and define the dwell time @xmath25 as the time spent by the orbit inside this circle . the plot of the function @xmath26 is shown in fig . [ fig - dwtime]a . the irregular structure of @xmath26 appears as a set of singularities crowding in four narrow regions separated by smooth behaviour . these regions themselves , called the transition zones in ref . @xcite , have a similar structure as shown by the blowup in fig . [ fig - dwtime]b . since the singularities correspond to trajectories asymptotically trapped by the confined orbits of the chaotic set , the self - similar pattern of singularities reflects the fractal structure of that set ; thus , an analysis of the set of singularities will provide important information on the organization of the chaotic set @xcite . the fractal pattern of singularities suggests that we consider the function @xmath26 as built of a few basic blocks containing the singularities and separated by smooth regions ( valleys ) . in turn , these basic blocks are considered again as containing smaller blocks separated by smaller regions of smooth behaviour . this approach yields a whole hierarchy of blocks sitting on top of the set of singularities : the basic blocks are on the first level of the hierarchy , the subblocks contained in them go to the second level , etc . the blocks on a given level of the hierarchy provide a coverage of the set of singularities : the higher we look into the hierarchy , the higher resolution we obtain in the coverage . to carry out this hierarchic decomposition of the time delay function , we need rules telling us how to break the continuous picture based on the variable @xmath25 into the obvious discreteness introduced by the hierarchy . these rules determining which of the singularities belong together in one block at a certain level of the hierarchy should reflect the intrinsic organization of the chaotic set . as was shown in ref . @xcite for a smooth potential model , this can be achieved by linking the rules of block construction to the topological complexity of scattering trajectories so that the orbits of the valleys separating the blocks at a given level have the same degree of complexity in their structures . + + + one measure of the orbit complexity can be the number of crossings the orbits produce with a suitably chosen poincar section . the function @xmath27 giving the number of crossing of a trajectory from our family of initial conditions with the surface @xmath28 can be considered as a _ discretized _ dwell time function : it can be shown that all the periodic orbits of the system cut this surface , so the longer a scattering trajectory follows a particular periodic orbit , the larger the number of crossings @xmath29 become . the discretized time delay function is plotted in fig . [ fig - ncross ] ; its similarity to fig.[fig - dwtime ] is obvious . the discreteness introduced in the picture will make the decomposition process easier to implement , since the smooth changes in @xmath25 are now replaced by plateaus of fixed heights that can be compared to one another . in the next section , we will obtain the rules of block construction for @xmath27 [ and thus for @xmath26 ] by looking at the topological properties of scattering orbits in hill s problem . the scattering orbits approach , along their incoming asymptotics , the interacting region around the origin where they perform their central parts consisting of localized and usually complicated motion ( for shorter or longer times , depending on the initial conditions ) , and finally escape downward or upward . since it is the central part that can get close to the bounded orbits of the chaotic set , we will concentrate on the central parts of scattering orbits , ignoring differences in their escapes . in the hierarchic decomposition of @xmath27 or any other scattering function , we would like to set apart orbits from one another according to the complexity of their central parts . for this purpose , the value @xmath29 is a good indicator but we also need a visual evaluation of the graph of the orbit to make necessary distinctions between different orbit types . our main goal is to represent the valleys of the dwell time function with scattering orbits , so that the comparison of these orbits can tell us whether two given valleys belong to the same level in the hierarchy or not ( we will say that a valley is of the @xmath31th level if the shortest block containing it belongs to level @xmath32 ) . for the comparison , we will identify some key elements in the orbit plots so that the number of these elements in the orbit will give the level number of the corresponding valley in the hierarchy . + + as can be seen from figs . [ fig - dwtime ] and [ fig - ncross ] , all the singularities of the dwell time function are contained in the domain between @xmath33 and @xmath34 @xcite . above @xmath35 , all the trajectories escape downwards , the simplest ones making only one crossing with the @xmath2 axis , on the positive @xmath2 side ( fig . [ fig - traj1]h ) . approaching @xmath35 from above , the orbits make more and more turns around a kidney - shaped periodic orbit ( figs . [ fig - traj1]g and f ) , developed from the lagrangean point @xmath36 of the system @xcite , before the escape . these turns appear in @xmath27 as a sequence of shortening plateaus increasing in height in steps of two [ while there is a continous divergence in @xmath26 ] ; the shortening is geometric governed by the stable eigenvalue of the periodic orbit . on the other side of @xmath35 , the escape may also happen upwards ( fig . [ fig - traj1]e ) . a similar phenomenon can be observed when approaching @xmath37 from below ( figs . [ fig - traj1]a d ) : all the orbits escape upwards ( the simplest ones with @xmath38 ) , while winding more and more around a similar periodic orbit , and for @xmath39 escapes can appear in both directions . looking at the larger valleys of @xmath27 inside the irregular domain , we can observe that each valley is dominated by two plateaus with a difference of 2 in their @xmath29 values ; they also lie lowest within the valley . these plateaus correspond to the simplest possible orbits in the valley , their difference in @xmath29 coming from the fact that the escaping part may cross ( twice ) the @xmath2 axis . approaching the edges of the valley , @xmath29 diverges , in the same way as observed outside the irregular domain , when the trajectories get closer and closer to one of the kidney - shaped orbits but still escape in the same direction . thus the only significant difference in the structure of two orbits from the same valley is in the number of turns around the same kidney - cycle immediately before escaping @xcite . if we consider these turns as belonging to the escape process , then we can claim that central parts of all the orbits from a given valley have the same topological structure . in contrast , orbits taken from different valleys have characteristically different central parts . this property makes it possible to represent a valley with one of its scattering orbits ; we will choose this from the widest plateau with a height of two above the minimum of the valley . figure [ fig - traj2 ] shows scattering trajectories representing the largest valleys and some of the narrower ones . now we are in a position to start the decomposition procedure . the blocks of a given level can be obtained by removing the appropriate valleys from the blocks of the previous level . the inclusion of the final kidney - turns in the escaping part puts the border between a valley and the neighbouring block right to a singularity . to decide whether a certain smooth region between two singularities is to be deleted at a given level , we analyze the structure of its representant scattering orbit : the valleys with the simplest trajectories within the given block will be removed to yield the new subblocks . the irregular region of @xmath27 can be separated into first - level blocks by comparing the trajectories representing the largest visible smooth regions between the transition zones of ref . @xcite . the three orbits shown in figs . [ fig - traj2]a , e , and b sit in the valleys separating zones iv iii ii i , respectively . we may immediately conclude that this separation into four blocks does not satisfy the `` equal complexity '' requirement : the orbits of fig . [ fig - traj2]a and b are clearly of the same type and complexity ( the central part is just one close approach of the origin ) , but the orbit in fig . [ fig - traj2]e is obviously more complicated performing two close approaches of the origin . therefore , as a second attempt , we consider this middle valley as separating blocks on a higher level and consequently , zones ii and iii as parts of one larger first - level block ranging from about 1.58 to 1.66 ; the regions i and iv will form the two other blocks in the first level of the hierarchy ( fig . [ fig - dwtime]a ) . the fact that we obtained three blocks in the first step suggests that we should look for a ternary hierarchy dividing each block into three at the next level . indeed , these blocks show , when magnified , an inner structure similar to the whole irregular region : there are two simplest trajectory types within each block , plotted in fig . [ fig - traj2]c h . the topological similarity between the central parts of figs . [ fig - traj2]e and f is now obvious ( two close approaches to the origin ) , while in the other orbits the first close approach is replaced by a prograde bend , essentially a part of the kidney - shaped orbits . considering the close approaches and the prograde bends as basic structural elements of the central parts of trajectories , the first - level blocks contain orbits that start their central parts with one of these elements , the same element within one block . similarly , the blocks on the second level gather together orbits starting their central parts with the same pair of basic elements , a different pair for each block . in turn , the magnification of the second - level blocks produces singularity structures resembling to the picture of fig . [ fig - ncross ] again , and all the 18 trajectories representing the dividing valleys can be decomposed into the three basic elements mentioned . + + we may conclude that in general all the orbits from an @xmath31th - level block share the first @xmath31 elements of their central parts , and the shortest of these orbits , with just @xmath40 elements , sit in the valleys that will split the block into subblocks at the next level . thus , when analyzing a scattering orbit from a given valley , the number of these elements in the central part gives the level number of the valley and consequently the ( largest ) blocks it separates . the division rules can easily be formulated in terms of the discrete dwell times too : given the minimal @xmath29 values for the two valleys next to a particular block , a simple rule will give the minima of the two valleys splitting that block into three at the next level . if the block intended to split sits in one side of a larger ( previous - level ) block next to a valley ( outside the larger block ) with a minimum @xmath41 , then we look for valleys with minima @xmath42 and @xmath43 inside ; however , if the block sits in the middle with neighbouring valley minima @xmath44 and @xmath45 , then the new valleys are those with minima @xmath46 and @xmath47 . the ternary organization established by the rules above can be followed climbing higher in the hierarchy , and we found that it is complete up to the fifth level . in constructing the sixth level of the hierarchy , the rules of the decomposition can not be applied to split one block in the center of the level since it has an inner structure different from that of the other blocks ( fig . [ fig - badblock ] ) . this particular block contains trajectories that are built of only close approaches to the origin avoiding the kidney - shaped orbits , and are organized in a way which is not captured by the rules we used before . + the reason for this anomaly is that these orbits are close to a region of _ stable motion _ corresponding to a bound configuration of the two satellites . in the poincar section , the stable motions form a kam island with the well - known hierarchy of periodic orbits with chains of smaller islands around the edge , and the rules of organization for that hierarchy differ from those of the ternary organization . although the scattering trajectories can not reach the inside of the island , the complicated structure around the edge of the island results in scattering trajectories that are trapped for anomalously long times in its vicinity ( fig . [ fig - traj3]a ) . the existence of these anomalous scattering orbits was noted in ref . @xcite ; now we can explain it by the presence of the island . the image of the primary `` stable '' block reappears in the middle of other `` ordinary '' blocks at higher levels of the hierarchy copied there by the dynamics . in general , keeping away from the two kidney - shaped orbits for a certain number of steps in the refinement process of any block in the hierarchy will reveal these island - approaching orbit blocks with a non - ternary inner structure . on the other hand , the subtleness of these flaws in the rules describing the hierarchy also means that the ternary organization remains a good approximation to the hierarchic properties everywhere in the chaotic set except in a narrow region around the island . it is important to note that near the two edges of the primary stable block there are two values @xmath48 and @xmath49 of the initial condition for which the scattering trajectory runs directly into an eight - shaped hyperbolic orbit with @xmath50 and two close approaches of the origin , avoiding the kidney - cycles ( fig . [ fig - traj3]b ) . in a proper poincar section , where we record only crossings with e.g. @xmath51 , this orbit appears as a period-3 cycle . in fact , the close approaches as basic elements of orbit structure connected to the rules of the ternary hierarchy reflect encounters with this cycle . in other words , the structure of the family of scattering orbits is organized not only by the two kidney - cycles , as claimed in ref . @xcite , but also by this 3-cycle representing the island . this also means that the chaotic set itself is built on these three orbits as its pillars . + the 3-cycle lies very close to the island , and its stable and unstable manifolds form a `` cage '' around it : the orbits that enter the cage form the irregular inner structure of the stable blocks . the presence of the cage also `` hides '' the island for scattering trajectories as long as they stay away from its immediate vicinity : the irregularities caused by the island in the hierarchy are covered by the hyperbolic behaviour of the neighbouring 3-cycle . the closeness of the period-3 orbit to the island is a consequence of the delicate interplay known as _ squeezing _ between a stable island around a fixed point and a nearby period-3 resonance @xcite found in generic hamiltonian systems with a quadratic nonlinearity . we have shown that the singularity structure appearing in the dwell time function in hill s problem can be decomposed into blocks ordered in a ternary hierarchy which remains a good approximation even in the presence of the distorting effects of a stable island . the main tool of the decomposition is the analysis of the topological structure of scattering trajectories : it can provide , in conjunction with the discretized dwell time function @xmath27 , the information we need on the hierarchic properties . in the simplest examples of chaotic scattering like the three - disk model , the discretized dwell time function in itself can reveal the hierarchic structure immediately @xcite : cutting its graph at a height @xmath31 will yield all the blocks in the @xmath31th level . however , in more complicated cases like the model discussed here , the structure of the graph is less revealing , so we need the extra information embodied in the scattering orbits . the orbit plots we used in our analysis were mostly the same as produced in ref . @xcite , but we surveyed them systematically to uncover the details of the hierarchy . this hierachic analysis is not restricted to the dwell time function : it can be carried out on any scattering function ( e.g. @xmath15 used in ref . @xcite ) that mirrors in its singularities the structure of the chaotic set . we have chosen the dwell time function @xmath26 because of its close relationship with @xmath27 . the analysis of hill s problem reported here also provides another example illustrating the capabilities of the hierarchic analysis in models of chaotic scattering with two degrees of freedom . the hierarchic information can be used in calculations of various global quantities characterizing the scattering process . the main tool for such calculations is the thermodynamic formalism @xcite , where the lengths @xmath52 of blocks at level @xmath31 of the hierarchy are put into the scaling sum @xcite @xmath53 to produce the free energy function @xmath54 . specific values of this function yield a few important scaling quantities @xcite . the most notable ones are : ( i ) the topological entropy @xmath55 characterizing the growth rate of the numbers of blocks from one level to the next ( @xmath56 for a ternary hierarchy ) , ( ii ) the fractal dimension @xmath57 of the set of singularities [ from @xmath58 , and ( iii ) the escape rate @xmath59 describing the exponential decay of survival of scattering trajectories within the interacting region . the number @xmath60 also describes the exponential shrinking of the total length of blocks at a given level if we go higher and higher in the hierarchy . in principle , the nonhyperbolic contributions due to the island produce nonexponential scalings , leading to @xmath61 and @xmath62 , but the screening effect of the hyperbolic 3-cycle usually ensures that the scaling remains exponential for levels below a certain crossover value . the hierarchic structure can be exploited to obtain reliable results for integrals like @xmath63 ( with @xmath64 ) describing the rate of energy transfer in a planetary ring system composed of many particles of equal mass @xcite . because of the irregular behaviour of the scattering function @xmath15 the integral can not be determined very accurately by a usual algorithm a fact that has already been noted in ref . however , we can use the hierarchic information to make the calculations more consistent @xcite : we can evaluate the integral within the smooth valleys separately and add up their contributions in the order they appear in the hierarchy , starting from the lowest level . after the first @xmath31 levels , the regions still missing from the integral are the blocks at level @xmath40 and higher . since their total length decays as @xmath65 , our procedure converges exponentially fast ( as long as we can neglect the nonhyperbolic effects associated with the island ) . concerning the validity of our findings , the particular choice of circular initial orbits ( @xmath8 ) , used in ref . @xcite and in our study too , is not special in the sense that a wide choice of the possible combinations of the parameters in the general form of the asymptotic motion can lead to similar results . the only requirement is that the line representing the initial conditions in phase space cut the stable manifolds of the chaotic set @xcite . as we have seen , the ternary structure found in our case rests on the two kidney - shaped orbits and the period-3 cycle near the stable island of bound motion . these basic orbits can be found in hill s problem with the same properties for a certain range of @xmath9 values , so if our set of initial conditions remains within that range , then we find the same organization ( but , of course , with different scaling ratios ) . finally , it is worth noting that the presence of the stable island remains the main difference between hill s problem and the inclined billiard model @xcite , proposed as a simple alternative with similar properties , where a ball bounces on two large overlapping disks in a gravitational field . the hierarchic organization found there was simply binary built around the two fixed points of vertical bouncing ( analogous to the kidney - cycles ) . we can make the structure of this billiard model more resembling to that of hill s problem by smoothing out the corner where the disks meet : then there is a third fixed point which can be elliptic if the curvature of the dip is small enough so that the resulting stable island provides the third structural element in the organization of the scattering orbits . this work has been started as part of a research project financed by the foundation for fundamental research on matter in the netherlands ( project number : 93br1099 ) . partial financial support from the hungarian scientific research foundation , under grant numbers otka f4286 , f17166 and t17493 is also acknowledged . for a review , see e. ott and t. tl , chaos * 3 * , 417 ( 1993 ) and references therein . petit and m. hnon , icarus * 66 * , 536 ( 1986 ) ; lect . notes phys . * 355 * , 255 ( 1990 ) ; m. hnon , recherche * 20 * , 491 ( 1989 ) . s. bleher , e. ott , and c. grebogi , phys . lett . * 63 * , 919 ( 1989 ) ; s. bleher , c. grebogi , and e. ott , physica d * 46 * , 87 ( 1990 ) . z. kovcs and l. wiesenfeld , phys . e * 51 * , 5476 ( 1995 ) ; z. naturforsch . * 49a * , 1229 ( 1994 ) . t. tl , in _ experiemtal study and characterization of chaos _ , edited by hao bai - lin ( world scientific , singapore , 1990 ) , p. 149 . b. eckhardt and c. jung , j. phys . a * 19 * , l829 ( 1986 ) . z. kovcs and t. tl , phys . rev . lett . * 64 * , 1617 ( 1990 ) ; t. tl , phys . rev . a * 44 * , 1034 ( 1991 ) . these numbers differ slightly from those given in ref . @xcite for the edges of the irregular domain due to the fact that we used a lower - order approximation in matching initial conditions to circular asymptotic solutions of hill s equations . the difference ( basically a shift in the order of @xmath66 ) shows up in all @xmath6 values cited in the present paper ; however , since we are interested in the structural properties of scattering rather than actual numbers , this has no relevance for our findings presented here . the role of simple periodic orbits acting as `` gates '' for escaping trajectories is a rather general feature of chaotic scattering ; see e.g. c. jung , j. phys . a * 23 * , 2847 , 3729 ( 1990 ) and acta phys . * 23 * , 177 ( 1992 ) . this is a consequence of the topology of the stretching and folding process defined in phase space by the dynamics . j. p. van der weele , ph.d . thesis , university of amsterdam , 1987 ; j. p. van der weele , h. w. capel , t. p. valkering , and t. post , physica a * 147 * , 499 ( 1988 ) . d. ruelle , _ thermodynamic formalism _ ( addison - wesley , reading , 1978 ) ; m. j. feigenbaum , m. h. jensen and i. procaccia , phys . lett . * 56 * , 1503 ( 1986 ) ; t. bohr and d. rand , physica d * 25 * , 387 ( 1987 ) . m. hnon , physica d * 33 * , 132 ( 1988 ) .

hierarchic properties of chaotic scattering in a model of satellite encounters , studied first by petit and hnon , are examined by decomposing the dwell time function and comparing scattering trajectories . the analysis reveals an ( approximate ) ternary organization in the chaotic set of bounded orbits and the presence of a stable island . the results can open the way for a calculation of global quantities characterizing the scattering process by using tools of the thermodynamic formalism .

nlin0702049

the field of photonic crystals , driven by its importance for applications in various areas of photonics , has attracted considerable attention during last the ten years @xcite-@xcite . the one - dimensional _ resonant bragg grating _ @xcite-@xcite or _ resonantly absorbing bragg reflector _ @xcite-@xcite has been of particular interest . an idealized model of a resonant bragg grating often considers a linear homogeneous dielectric host medium containing an array of thin films with resonant atoms or molecules . the thickness of each film is much less than the wavelength of the electromagnetic wave propagating through such a structure . the dynamics of ultrashort light pulses in the gratings containing films embedded with two - level atoms of the grating has been studied in @xcite-@xcite . the transition frequencies of atoms are assumed to be near the bragg frequency . light interaction with such gratings was described by equations of reduced maxwell - bloch type . this work demonstrated self - induced transparency in these gratings and the existence of the solitary waves in such structures @xcite . it was also shown @xcite that bright as well as dark solitons can exist in the spectral gap . progress in nanofabrication of novel optical materials has allowed the design of metal - dielectric nanocomposite materials , which have the ability to sustain nonlinear plasmonic oscillations . an example of such a material is a dielectric with embedded metallic nanoparticles @xcite-@xcite . in this paper we consider ultrashort pulse interaction with bragg structures containing thin films with metallic nanoparticles . the bragg resonance frequency and carrier wave frequency in our considerations are assumed to be close to the plasmonic resonance frequency of the nanoparticles . losses in realistic plasmonic oscillations are of considerable importance . here we consider an idealized case , wherein pulse duration is much shorter than the characteristic time of losses , so that the effects of losses can be neglected . in the limit of the slowly - varying envelope approximation we derive governing equations for two counter - propagating electromagnetic waves interacting with plasmonic oscillation - induced medium polarization . this system of equations represents the two - wave maxwell - duffing type model . we find exact solitary wave solutions of this system and , via computer simulations , analyze stability of these solutions . we consider a grating consisting of an array of thin films which are embedded in a linear dielectric medium . in our derivation of the governing equations we follow @xcite-@xcite , wherein bragg resonance arises if the distance between successive films is @xmath0 , @xmath1 . it was shown in @xcite that counter - propagating electric field waves @xmath2 and @xmath3 in the slowly - varying envelope approximation satisfy the following system of equations : @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the mismatch between the carrier wavenumber and the bragg resonant wavenumber . the description of the evolution of material polarization in the slowly - varying amplitude approximation requires modeling of the thin films response to an external light field . the dielectric properties can be attributed to plasmonic oscillations , which are modeled by lorentz oscillators . the simplest generalizations of this model include anharmonicity of plasmonic oscillations @xcite . in this paper we consider an array of thin films containing metallic nanoparticles which have cubic nonlinear response to external fields @xcite . the macroscopic polarization @xmath6 is governed by the equation @xmath7 where @xmath8 is plasma frequency and @xmath9 is the transition frequency between energy levels resulting from the dimensional quantization . losses of the plasmonic oscillations are taken into account by the parameter @xmath10 . it is assumed that the duration of the electromagnetic pulse is small enough that dissipation effects can be neglected . starting from the slowly - varying envelope approximation , standard manipulation leads to @xmath11 terms varying rapidly in time , which are proportional to @xmath12 , are neglected . in this equation @xmath13 is the electric field interacting with metallic nanoparticles . in the problem under consideration we have @xmath14 . due to the limitations of nanofabrication , the sizes and shapes of nanoparticles are not uniform . in practice , deviation from a perfectly spherical shape has a much larger impact on a nanoparticle s resonance frequency than does variation in diameter . this shape variation causes a broadening of the resonance line . the broadened spectrum is characterized by a probability density function @xmath15 of deviations @xmath16 from some mean value @xmath17 . when computing the total polarization , all resonance frequencies must be taken into account . the contributions of the various resonance frequencies are weighted according to the probability density function @xmath15 ; the weighted average is denoted by @xmath18 in equations ( [ 21.1]),([21.2 ] ) . in what follows , @xmath19 denotes the refractive index of the medium containing the array of thin films , and @xmath20 is the effective density of the resonant nanoparticles in films . the effective density is equal to @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the bulk density of nanoparticles , @xmath23 is the width of a film , and @xmath24 is the lattice spacing . we study a medium - light interaction in which resonance is the dominant phenomenon . as such , the length of the sample is smaller than the characteristic dispersion length . in this case the temporal second derivative terms in equations ( [ 21.1],[21.2 ] ) can be omitted . the resulting equations are the two - wave maxwell - duffing equations . they can be rewritten in dimensionless form using the following rescaling : @xmath25)\mathcal{p},\ ; \zeta = ( \omega _ { p}/2c)x,\ ; \tau = t / t_{0}.\ ] ] here @xmath26 , while @xmath27 is a characteristic amplitude of counter - propagating fields . in dimensionless form , the two - wave maxwell - duffing equations read @xmath28 where @xmath29 is a dimensionless coefficient of anharmonicity , @xmath30 is the dimensionless mismatch coefficient , @xmath31 is the dimensionless detuning of a nanoparticle s resonance frequency from the field s carrier frequency . in a coordinate system rotating with angular frequency @xmath32 , @xmath33 equations ( [ svepequations ] ) become @xmath34 further simplification of the system ( [ rotatingframe ] ) can be achieved by introducing new variables @xmath35 which allow decoupling of one equation from the system of three equations . in these new variables the polarization @xmath36 is coupled with only one field variable . simple transformations give @xmath37 as one can see , we have a coupled system of equations for @xmath38 and @xmath36 . we consider localized solitary wave solutions of ( [ 26.3])-([26.3.2 ] ) in the limit of narrow spectral line @xmath39 , where @xmath40 and @xmath41 are spectral widths of a signal and spectral line @xmath42 . in this case the spectral line can be represented as a dirac @xmath32-function : @xmath43 . equations ( [ 26.3.1 ] ) , ( [ 26.3.2 ] ) can then be re - written as follows : @xmath44 scaling analysis of this system shows that solitary wave solutions can be represented as @xmath45 here @xmath46 is velocity of the solitary wave , @xmath47 is a scale - invariant parameter in a coordinate system moving with the solitary wave , and functions @xmath48 , @xmath49 satisfy the following system of equations : @xmath50 the only dimensionless parameter which remains in the system is @xmath51 which characterizes the deviation of carrier frequency from the plasmonic frequency @xmath52 and the bragg resonance frequency @xmath53 . the system of ordinary differential equations ( [ ode ] ) has integral of motion for pulse - like solutions decaying as @xmath54 @xmath55 this allows the following parametrization of solutions : @xmath56 where @xmath57 , @xmath58 , and @xmath59 are real - valued functions satisfying @xmath60 if we set @xmath61 , then we have @xmath62 taking into account equations ( [ amplitudephasecompact ] ) we have the conservation law @xmath63 substituting ( [ secondconsevationlaw ] ) into the second equation of ( [ amplitudephasecompact ] ) and subsequent integration gives the following expression for @xmath57 : @xmath64 where @xmath65 . the right - hand side is positive real - valued for all @xmath66 if @xmath67 . using the conservation law ( [ secondconsevationlaw ] ) we obtain an expression for @xmath68 : @xmath69 now we integrate @xmath70 and find @xmath71 finally , we determine @xmath59 : @xmath72 this pulse exists only if value of the parameter @xmath73 is inside the interval @xmath67 . the maximal value of the amplitude of this solitary solution is @xmath74 the phases @xmath58 and @xmath59 are nonlinear . their behavior is asymptotically linear as @xmath75 . if @xmath76 , then the limiting values of the phases satisfy @xmath77 ) , ( [ 26.3.1 ] ) and conditions as @xmath78 , one can show that @xmath79 we are interested in the energies of the dimensionless fields @xmath80 , @xmath81 , and of the polarization @xmath36 . @xmath82 finally , for electric fields @xmath83 and for polarization @xmath84 we have @xmath85 the energy of a solitary wave is @xmath86 finally we have the energies of electric fields and polarization @xmath87 ratios of energies in different fields as well as polarization have the following form @xmath88 therefore , energy partitioning is determined solely by the parameter @xmath46 , which is a dimensionless combination of main system parameters . the shape and phase of the incident optical pulse are controllable in a real experimental situation . to model pulse dynamics in the bragg grating it is natural to consider asymptotic mixed initial - boundary value problem for equations ( [ svepequations ] ) . we define initial conditions as @xmath89 with no incident field at the right edge of the sample , and with incident field at the left edge defined as follows : @xmath90 , \;\ ; \theta = \arctan\left(\tanh\left[1.5\left(\tau - 3.0\right)\right ] \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] in our case the spatial simulation domain was chosen as @xmath91 $ ] . parameters @xmath92 and @xmath93 were given values @xmath94 as one can see , we gave the initial pulse the same configuration of phase in a topological sense as would be found in a solitary wave solution . this point is important , because otherwise the phase difference can not relax to the symmetry of the stationary wave which is revealed in ( [ phi_expression ] ) . as a result , in numerical simulations it is difficult to achieve solitary wave type dynamics of the pulse without the proper phase configuration of the incident pulse . the second field boundary condition was set to be @xmath95 in the first experiment we injected a pulse , which is relatively close to the solitary wave solution . the results are shown in figs . [ f1.1.map]-[q.1.map ] , which clearly represent two stages of the pulse evolution . surface.,width=384 ] surface.,width=384 ] surface.,width=384 ] in the first stage ( @xmath96 ) of evolution we observed fast excess energy damping in radiation of quasi - linear waves in both directions and relaxation to a solution roughly similar to the stationary solution . then we observed a stage of pulse shape refinement ( @xmath97 ) with consequent propagation of the solution very close to ( [ r_solution ] ) . the lower part of the figure [ q.1.map ] shows the creation of multiple spatially frozen `` hot spots '' of the medium polarization . in these hot spots the energy of oscillations is arrested in the grating . this `` stopping light '' phenomenon is due to self - modulation of the medium polarization caused by nonlinear effects which we shall discuss in more detail elsewhere . during the second experiment we used a pulse of lower amplitude : @xmath98 , \nonumber \\ \theta & = & \arctan\left(\tanh\left[1.5\left(\tau - 3.0\right)\right ] \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] results are represented in figs . [ f1.2.map]-[q.2.map ] . surface.,width=384 ] surface.,width=384 ] surface.,width=384 ] deviation of the incident pulse from exact solitary wave solution was stronger in the second numerical experiment . in this case , computer simulations clearly demonstrate oscillatory behavior of the pulse dynamics . study of the origin of such oscillations will also be presented in a separate publication . in both cases we observed a phenomenon similar to self - induced transparency in nanocomposite materials described in @xcite . these solitary wave solutions represent the phenomenon of nonlinear light trapping when the wave of medium polarization is bound by two optical light fields propagating in the same direction . in the linear limit these two optical fields are propagating in opposite directions . we studied , both analytically and numerically , solitary waves describing coupled medium polarization and light propagation in bragg gratings with thin films containing metallic nanoparticles . we observed self - induced transparency - like phenomena and formation of polarization `` hot spots '' . the formation of solitary wave solutions occurs when energy of an incident pulse exceeds some threshold value . the lower boundary value of this threshold can be evaluated as sum of energies ( [ energies ] ) of electric and plasmonic components of coupled wave . stability of nonlinear solitary waves is an important problem which can be addressed by study of collision properties and analysis of localized modes of such waves . this problem is the subject of our future investigations . we would like to thank b.i . mantsyzov , a.a . zabolotskii , j - g . caputo , m.g . stepanov and r. indik for enlightening discussions . aim and kao are grateful to the laboratoire de mathmatiques , insa de rouen and the university of arizona for hospitality and support . this work was partially supported by nsf ( grant dms-0509589 ) , aro - muri award 50342-ph - mur and state of arizona ( proposition 301 ) , rfbr grants 06 - 02 - 16406 and 06 - 01 - 00665-a , intas grant 00 - 292 , the programme `` nonlinear dynamics and solitons '' from the ras presidium and `` leading scientific schools of russia '' grant . kao was supported by russian president grant for young scientists mk-1055.2005.2 .

light propagation in a bragg periodic structure containing thin films with metallic nanoparticles is studied . plasmonic resonance frequency , bragg frequency , and light carrier frequency are assumed to be close . exact solutions describing solitary gap - waves are found , and a light arrest phenomenon due to nonlinearity of plasmonic oscillations is studied .

hep-th0010064

the understanding of confinement and , more generally , of the principles that govern the low energy dynamics in qcd is , perhaps , the most interesting unanswered question in the theory of strong interactions . the strongly coupled dynamics of the four dimensional non abelian gauge theories has so far proven to be forbiddingly complicated . a fruitful approach to cope with such situation can be to turn to simpler , more tractable models , that nevertheless capture at least some of the important features of the real theory . from this point of view , three dimensional non abelian gauge theories are of particular interest since they are , indeed , confining , and have a strong coupling dynamics . on the other hand they can be continuously deformed into the weak coupling region without encountering any phase transition . the prototypical case is the @xmath1 gauge theory with an adjoint higgs field - the georgi - glashow model . these weakly coupled theories are confining , just like their strongly coupled counterparts . here , however , confinement can be studied using semiclassical methods , as first done by polyakov for the @xmath1 case @xcite , and later on generalized to @xmath2 theories @xcite . a related feature of these models is that their spectra has a large gap between the light ( light ` photons ' ) and heavy ( heavy massive gauge bosons ) states . this makes the identification of the relevant low energy degrees of freedom relatively easy , and also allows one to construct the low energy effective lagrangian explicitly . it turns out that this effective lagrangian exhibits the confinement phenomenon in a very simple and straightforward way _ on the classical level_. in a nutshell , the natural degrees of freedom turn out to be magnetic vortex fields first introduced by thooft @xcite , and the confinement mechanism is realized as confinement of topological solitons for those vortex fields . the structure of the effective lagrangian is robustly determined by the spontaneously broken magnetic @xmath0 symmetry @xcite . this approach has been motivated by earlier work @xcite , it was advanced and formulated in @xcite , and further clarified in @xcite . it has also been argued in @xcite , that the same type of effective lagrangian remains valid in the strongly coupled limit of pure gluodynamics . in this situation , the components of the vortex field are naturally identified with the scalar and pseudoscalar glueballs , which according to lattice results are indeed the two lowest states in the spectrum of @xmath3 dimensional gluodynamics @xcite . the confinement mechanism for the strongly coupled regime remains , in this picture , essentially the same as for the weakly coupled phase . all previous work dealt exclusively with theories having no matter fields in fundamental representation . the purpose of this note is to address the question of what effect dynamical fundamental ` quarks ' have on this low energy structure . that that effect exists and must be nontrivial can be seen from one basic observation : in the presence of fundamental charges , the vortex field ( which is the effective low energy degree of freedom ) is no longer a local field . the effective lagrangian can not , therefore , be a simple local scalar theory as in @xcite . we will show below that , in the presence of fundamental matter , the magnetic @xmath0 in the effective lagrangian is _ gauged _ , the value of the gauge coupling being inversely proportional to the mass of the ( lightest ) dynamical quark . we will construct such an effective lagrangian , which moreover in the limit of the infinitely heavy quarks reduces to the effective theory of @xcite . the presence of fundamental quarks implies the existence of a conserved baryon number charge . we will see how this charge is represented in the low energy theory , and will study the structure of finite energy baryon states . quite surprisingly , we find that these states naturally have a bag - like structure . the value of the vortex field in the region of space which contains the quarks , is much lower than its value in the vacuum . the potential energy associated with this difference in the expectation values can also be naturally identified with the bag constant . the plan of this paper is the following . in section [ glue ] , we give a lightning review of the results of @xcite . we discuss the magnetic @xmath0 symmetry , its order parameter ( the vortex operator ) , and the structure of the effective lagrangian in pure gluodynamics . in section [ fund ] we explain the basic physics of the changes in this structure in the presence of the fundamental charges . in section [ low ] we show how to define the relevant low energy degrees of freedom , and how to construct the effective lagrangian in this case . in section [ baryon ] , we study the structure of the baryon states . finally we conclude in section [ discus ] with a short discussion . consider the pure su(n ) gauge theory in @xmath3 dimensions @xmath4 as was argued by thooft in @xcite , this theory possesses a global @xmath0 symmetry which is spontaneously broken in the vacuum . the explicit realization of this symmetry was found in @xcite . the generator of the @xmath0 group is ( up to a multiplicative constant factor ) the fundamental wilson loop along the spatial boundary of the system @xmath5 in @xcite , the conservation of @xmath6 was proved taking the pure gluodynamics limit of the georgi - glashow model . this , however , can also be shown directly by calculating the commutator of @xmath6 with the yang - mills hamiltonian @xmath7 : @xmath8=\lim_{c\to\infty}\oint_c dx_i { \rm tr } \left [ p e_i(x)\exp\{i\oint_{c(x , x ) } dy_ia^i(y)\ } \right ] \to_{c\to\infty}0 \;. \label{commutator}\ ] ] here , the integral in the exponential on the right hand side starts and ends at the point of insertion of the electric field . the vanishing of the commutator follows from the fact that it only involves electric fields at spatial infinity , and in a theory with a finite mass gap those fields should vanish at infinity . to dispel any doubt about the vanishing of this commutator we note that the situation is completely analogous to the commutator of any ` conserved charge ' which is defined as an integral of a local charge density @xmath9 the commutator of such a charge with a hamiltonian contains also a surface term , since the charge density @xmath10 never commutes with the hamiltonian density but rather gives a total derivative in the commutator . for a conserved charge , due to the continuity equation , this surface term is equal to the circulation of the spatial component of the current @xmath11=i\oint_c dx^ij_i\;.\ ] ] the vanishing of this term again is the consequence of the vanishing of the physical fields at infinity in a theory with a mass gap . when the charge is not conserved , the commutator contains also a bulk term in addition to the surface contribution . it is the absence of the bulk terms that is the distinctive property of a conserved charge . the same conclusion is reached if , rather than considering the generator of the algebra , one considers the commutator of the group element for either continuous or discreet symmetry groups . we see , therefore , that the commutator in ( [ commutator ] ) indeed tells us that @xmath6 is a conserved operator . next , a simple argument establishes that the magnetic @xmath0 symmetry is spontaneously broken in the vacuum if the wilson loop @xmath12 has an area law behaviour @xcite . the argument goes like this . the vev of @xmath12 is the overlap of the vacuum state @xmath13 with the state @xmath14 which is obtained from the vacuum by acting on it with @xmath12 . when acting on the vacuum state , @xmath12 performs the @xmath0 transformation at all points within the area @xmath15 bounded by the loop . if the vacuum wavefunction depends on the configuration of the @xmath0 non invariant degrees of freedom ( the state in question is not @xmath0 invariant ) the action of @xmath12 affects the state everywhere inside the loop . in the local theory with finite correlation length the overlap between the two states approximately factorizes into the product of the overlaps taken over the region of space of linear dimension of order of the correlation length @xmath16 @xmath17 where the label @xmath18 is the coordinate of the point in the center of a given small region of space . for @xmath18 outside the area @xmath15 the two states @xmath19 and @xmath20 are identical and therefore the overlap is unity . however for @xmath18 inside @xmath15 the states are different and the overlap is therefore some number @xmath21 smaller than unity . the number of such regions inside the area is obviously of order @xmath22 and thus @xmath23 the vev of @xmath12 then falls off as an area . conversely , if the vacuum is @xmath0 invariant , the wavefunction does not depend on the configuration of the non invariant degrees of freedom . the action of @xmath12 then alters the state only along the perimeter and @xmath12 has the perimeter law behaviour in the unbroken phase . thus the area law behaviour of the fundamental wilson loop is tantamount to the breaking of the magnetic @xmath0 symmetry in the vacuum of pure gluodynamics . the only requirement that this argument presupposes is the existence of * local * degrees of freedom which are non invariant under @xmath0 , or in other words the existence of a * local * order parameter . such an operator can indeed be constructed explicitly . this is the magnetic vortex creation operator @xmath24 @xcite,@xcite,@xcite . the defining property of @xmath24 is that it satisfies the following commutation relation with the spatial fundamental wilson loop @xmath25 @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the linking number of the curve @xmath28 and the point @xmath18 , or in other words , @xmath29 if @xmath30 , and @xmath31 if @xmath32 , where @xmath15 is the region of the plane bounded by @xmath28 . an explicit representation for @xmath33 is given by writing it as the operator that performs a ` singular gauge transformation ' @xmath34 here , the hypercharge generator @xmath35 is defined as @xmath36 the electric field is written in the matrix notation @xmath37 , with @xmath38 denoting the @xmath2 generator matrices in the fundamental representation , and @xmath39 is the hypercharge density due to gluons @xmath40 $ ] . the function @xmath41 is the planar angle of the vector @xmath18 . using gauss law @xmath42 this operator ( on the states that satisfy gauss law ) may be written in an alternative representation @xmath43 the integration here is along the branch cut in the definition of the planar angle @xmath44 , which is an infinite line that starts at the point @xmath18 and goes to infinity . there are two crucial properties of the definition eq.([v2 ] ) that insure that the operator @xmath24 is a local physical field : 1 . gauge invariance . the definition is not explicitly gauge invariant . nevertheless , one can show @xcite,@xcite that @xmath24 transforms a physical state into another physical state . that is to say that the matrix elements of @xmath24 between a physical and an unphysical state vanish . by physical state we mean a state which satisfies the non abelian gauss law . by virtue of this property the definition eq.([v2 ] ) can be used as long as the matrix elements of @xmath24 ( or any power of @xmath24 with insertions of an arbitrary number of gauge invariant operators ) are calculated between physical states . 2 . locality . again , the definition is not explicitly local , since it contains the integral of the electric field along an infinite line . however in a theory that does not contain fundamental charges , @xmath24 in fact does not depend on the curve @xmath28 , but only on its endpoint @xmath18 . physically , this is due to the fact that the bohm - aharonov phase between @xmath24 and any charged state in the theory vanishes . more formally , consider changing the position of the curve @xmath28 to @xmath45 . this adds to the phase in the definition eq.([v2 ] ) a contribution @xmath46 , where @xmath15 is the area bounded by @xmath47 . in our normalization , the hypercharge of gluons is @xmath48 or @xmath49 and no particles with smaller value of the hypercharge are present in the theory . therefore the hypercharge within any closed area is an integer multiple of the gauge coupling @xmath50 , and the extra phase factor is always unity . one can also show directly @xcite , using canonical commutation relations , that @xmath33 commutes with all the local gauge invariant operators @xmath51 , unless @xmath52 , which formally establishes the locality of @xmath24 . the universal properties of the low energy dynamics of the pure yang mills theory are determined by the spontaneous breaking of the magnetic @xmath0 symmetry . the effective low energy lagrangian is constructed in terms of the vortex field @xmath24 in principle we have to include in this lagrangian higher order potential terms which stabilize the potential energy at large values of @xmath24 . although we will not indicate them explicitly , it is assumed in the following that they are indeed present whenever necessary . ] @xmath53 this lagrangian can be derived in a controllable way in the weakly coupled phase@xcite,@xcite . the coupling constants in eq.([ldualgg ] ) are determined in the weakly coupled region from perturbation theory and dilute monopole gas approximation . it was argued in @xcite that the same low energy lagrangian is also valid in the strongly coupled regime ( pure gluodynamics ) . several features of this lagrangian are worth noting : * first , @xmath54 , and therefore the @xmath0 symmetry is spontaneously broken . * second , the field components of @xmath24 can be reinterpreted in terms of the physical glueball fields . using a polar decomposition for @xmath24 @xmath55 we find that the fluctuation field @xmath10 is the charge conjugation even scalar , while the phase @xmath56 is the conjugation odd pseudoscalar . indeed , according to lattice results @xcite , the two lightest glueballs in the spectrum of pure gluodynamics are the scalar @xmath57 and pseudoscalar @xmath58 states . the lagrangian ( [ ldualgg ] ) , is thus the natural effective lagrangian that one would write to describe the dynamics of the lightest particles . in this respect the identification of the glueball fields with the modulus and the phase of @xmath24 constrains the possible terms in the effective lagrangian by imposing the @xmath0 symmetry on possible interaction terms . * finally , this effective lagrangian exhibits in a simple way confining properties of the theory . the colour charged ` gluon ' states ( or massive vector bosons in the weakly coupled regime ) are represented in the low energy theory by topological solitons carrying unit winding of the field @xmath24 . if not for the @xmath59 symmetry breaking term in the potential in ( [ ldualgg ] ) , the lowest lying state in the topologically nontrivial sector would have a rotationally invariant hedgehog - like structure . its energy would be logarithmically divergent in the infrared , which corresponds to the logarithmic coulomb potential in 2 + 1 dimensions . however since the symmetry of the potential is @xmath0 rather than @xmath59 , the energy of the hedgehog configuration diverges quadratically with the volume . this is so since the number of vacuum states is discreet and in the hedgehog configuration the phase of the field @xmath24 is far from its vacuum value everywhere in space . the configuration that actually minimizes the energy in the one soliton sector breaks rotational invariance by confining the winding of the phase of @xmath24 to some quasi one - dimensional strip , like in figure 1 . it is clear that , dynamically , the width of this strip is of the order of the inverse glueball mass and the strip itself is nothing but the confining electric flux string . the energy of such an isolated soliton now diverges _ linearly _ in the infrared , due to the finite energy density per unit length of the string . [ fig1 ] in the state of unit charge in the presence of the symmetry breaking terms in the effective lagrangian , for the @xmath60 model.,title="fig : " ] the soliton we are discussing is a dynamical particle in the effective theory - it thus represents a particle with an adjoint color charge , and the string is the adjoint string . this string is of course not absolutely stable since it can break into a soliton - antisoliton pair when it is too long . the fundamental string also appears naturally in the low energy description . it is the stable domain wall which separates the regions of space with different expectation values of the vortex field @xmath24 @xcite , see figure 2 . in this section we wish to discuss the modifications introduced by the presence of fundamental quarks in the structure just described . for simplicity we will consider scalar quarks . the lagrangian of the theory we are interested in is @xmath61 where the scalar field @xmath62 transforms according to the fundamental representation of the @xmath2 color group . first thing to note is that the fundamental wilson loop still commutes with the hamiltonian . this is obvious , since the extra terms in the hamiltonian in the presence of the quarks do not involve electric field operator , but only vector potential . the wilson loop commutes with the vector potential , and thus with the additional terms in the hamiltonian . we thus conclude that the theory still has the magnetic @xmath0 symmetry . this may seem somewhat surprising at first sight . we have seen in the previous section that spontaneous breaking of the magnetic @xmath0 implies the area law for the wilson loop , and conversely the perimeter law of @xmath25 implies unbroken @xmath0 . in the theory with fundamental charges the wilson loop is known to have perimeter law due to breaking of the confining string at any finite value of the fundamental mass @xmath63 . we might then conclude that the magnetic @xmath0 is restored at any , arbitrarily large value of @xmath63 but is broken at @xmath64 . the common lore is that the @xmath0 breaking phase transition for @xmath65 is first order , and this then implies a discontinuous behaviour of the theory in the infinite mass limit . this of course is completely counterintuitive and in fact plain wrong . the caveat in this line of reasoning is the following . the relation between the behaviour of the wilson loop and the mode of the realization of the magnetic symmetry hinges crucially on the existence of a local order parameter of the magnetic @xmath0 . in the absence of such an order parameter it is not true that the wilson loop locally changes the quantum state inside the loop and this invalidates the whole argument . in particular in the absence of a local order parameter , the @xmath0 symmetry can be spontaneously broken but the wilson loop can have a perimeter law . in fact it is easy to see that for any finite @xmath63 the magnetic @xmath0 does not have a local order parameter . the only candidate for such an order parameter is the vortex operator @xmath33 defined in eq.([v2 ] ) , since it has to be local also relative to the purely gluonic operators by any explicitly local gauge invariant operator . such modifications are however irrelevant as far as the locality properties of @xmath24 are concerned , and we will not consider them in the following . ] . however in the presence of fundamental quarks the operator @xmath33 is not local anymore . to see this consider the dependence of @xmath66 on the curve @xmath28 which enters its definition . as before the operators @xmath67 and @xmath68 are related by @xmath69 where @xmath15 is the area bounded by @xmath47 . as before , due to the gauss law the integral in the exponential is equal to the total hypercharge in the area @xmath15 . however the hypercharge of fundamental quarks has eigenvalues @xmath70 . the extra phase factor is therefore not unity anymore but can rather take values @xmath71 depending on the state and the choice of the contour @xmath28 . the status of the magnetic @xmath0 is thus quite different in a theory with fundamental quarks - it does not have a local order parameter . nevertheless it is clear that at least as long as the mass @xmath63 is large @xmath72 , the relevant degrees of freedom for the effective infrared dynamics should still be the vortices @xmath24 and the main factor which determines their dynamics should still be the magnetic @xmath0 . at large @xmath63 the dependence of @xmath24 on the curve @xmath28 is weak , since the probability of the vacuum fluctuations which involve fundamental charges is small . the probability of appearance of a virtual @xmath73 pair separated by a distance @xmath16 is suppressed by the exponential factor @xmath74 . the typical distance scale for the `` glueball '' physics is @xmath75 . thus at these distances such fluctuations are unimportant and should not affect much the dynamics . things are different however if one is interested also in the baryonic sector of the theory . the baryons are necessarily heavy and in order to be able to discuss their structure we must understand the main dynamical effects also at shorter distances . therefore our aim now is to understand what is the main effect of the non locality discussed above on the dynamics of magnetic vortices . the situation we have just described - a symmetry without a local order parameter - is not exceptional in quantum field theory . this is precisely the property of the global part of any abelian gauge group . consider for example quantum electrodynamics . the global electric charge is of course a physical gauge invariant charge with the corresponding gauge invariant local charge density . @xmath76 nevertheless there is no local operator that carries this charge . this is a direct consequence of the gauss law @xmath77 any physical , gauge invariant operator that carries @xmath78 must also carry the long range electric field , which can not fall off faster than a power of the distance . the gauge invariant qed lagrangian is written in terms of `` local '' charged fields @xmath79 . but appearances are deceptive : these fields are not gauge invariant , and therefore not physical . a gauge invariant charged field can be constructed from @xmath79 by multiplying it by a phase factor @xmath80 with the @xmath81-number field @xmath82 satisfying @xmath83 for any @xmath82 satisfying this condition the operator @xmath84 is gauge invariant , and therefore physical . it is however necessarily nonlocal . different choices of @xmath82 define different gauge invariant operators and correspond to different gauge fixings . thus for @xmath85 the field @xmath84 is the field @xmath79 in the coulomb gauge , while @xmath86 corresponds to the axial gauge @xmath87 , and so on . different definitions of @xmath84 differ from each other by a phase factor , which is precisely the gauge ambiguity of the original field @xmath79 . the @xmath59 gauge group is the most natural abelian gauge symmetry to consider in continuum field theory . one can however also consider discrete groups like @xmath0@xcite . in this case again no local operator that carries the global @xmath0 charge exists . the various gauge invariant charged operators are nonlocal and differ from each other by a local @xmath0 - valued phase . these different operators again correspond to different gauge fixings of the local @xmath0 group . this is precisely the structure that emerged in our discussion in the earlier part of this section . we have \1 . global magnetic @xmath0 symmetry generated by the fundamental wilson loop . the set of nonlocal vortex operators @xmath66 , which all carry the @xmath0 charge and differ from each other by a @xmath0 valued phase factors . it is very suggestive therefore to think about @xmath66 as of different gauge fixed versions of a field charged under local @xmath0 . this leads us to expect that the low energy theory we are after should be a @xmath0 gauge theory of the magnetic vortex field @xmath24 . in fact coming back to the discussion in the beginning of this section , we see that from this vantage point it is obvious why the wilson loop has a perimeter law , even if the global @xmath0 is broken spontaneously . the action of a wilson loop of a finite size inside the contour is a gauge transformation . thus in physical terms locally inside the contour the new state is _ the same _ as the old one and so the overlap between the two locally is unity . the only nontrivial contributions to the overlap come from the region close to the contour , thus giving the perimeter law . in the next section we shall construct the effective gauge theory and discuss its relation to the original qcd lagrangian . although it is possible to give a more ` analytic ' derivation of the effective lagrangian , we prefer to write it down directly guided by the previous discussion . we will then explain the physical meaning of the various fields that appear in it . the easiest way to construct a @xmath0 gauge theory in the continuum is to consider a @xmath59 gauge theory with the higgs field of charge @xmath88 which has a large expectation value @xcite . consider therefore the following lagrangian : @xmath89 here @xmath90 . we take the parameters such that , @xmath91 and @xmath92 . the ` higgs ' field @xmath93 has a large expectation value and breaks the @xmath59 gauge symmetry down to its @xmath0 subgroup @xmath94 . it should be noted that this gauge subgroup does not correspond to ` singular ' gauge transformations , since partial derivatives commute on the gauge parameter , despite the fact that there are @xmath95-like singularities . below the scale determined by the expectation value @xmath96 , the field @xmath93 is practically frozen and its fluctuations are unimportant . in this regime the model indeed describes the locally @xmath0 invariant theory . the global part of the gauge group is our @xmath0 magnetic symmetry generated by the wilson loop . the larger @xmath59 gauge structure at this point is just an auxiliary trick which enables us to write down a discrete gauge theory in continuous notations . we will however see later that it does in fact has a real physical meaning of its own and arises naturally in the effective theory . let us first discuss how this lagrangian reduces to the effective lagrangian of the pure yang - mills theory eq.([ldualgg ] ) in the limit of the large quark mass . in this limit not only the field @xmath93 must decouple , but also the gauge interactions of the field @xmath24 must vanish . there is another consistency requirement . in the limit of zero gauge coupling @xmath97 the gauge @xmath59 symmetry becomes global @xmath59 and is broken due to non vanishing expectation value of @xmath93 . the spectrum therefore contains a massless goldstone boson . this goldstone boson is of course the longitudinal component of the gauge field @xmath98 . there is however no such massless particle in the pure gluodynamics nor in the effective lagrangian eq.([ldualgg ] ) . this means that the couplings in eq.([efflfund ] ) should depend on the quark mass in such a way that the vector particles remains heavy for any finite @xmath63 and its mass goes to zero very sharply only in the limit when it is completely decoupled . in terms of the goldstone boson couplings it means that @xmath99 must be larger than any scale relevant to the dynamics of the vortex field @xmath24 . all these conditions can be met by choosing for example @xmath100 with this choice the mass of the vector boson @xmath101 stays finite as @xmath102 and can be arbitrarily large . the goldstone boson in the decoupling limit has an infinite @xmath99 and is completely decoupled just as the `` invisible axion '' . we now want to understand how the basic fields present in the effective lagrangian arise in the fundamental theory eq.([lqcd ] ) . we start with considering the symmetries . the lagrangian eq.([efflfund ] ) has two global @xmath59 symmetries . one is the global part of the local @xmath59 with the conserved current @xmath103 . note that due to the direct coupling between the @xmath24 and @xmath93 fields the @xmath59 rotations of @xmath24 and @xmath93 separately are not symmetries . the other current , conserved by virtue of the homogeneous maxwell equation is @xmath104 . the two charges have quite different nature . the second one , the dual magnetic flux @xmath105 has a local order parameter . it can be constructed in a way similar to the vortex field in qed @xcite,@xcite . the global @xmath59 gauge charge , on the other hand does not have a local order parameter , as discussed earlier . both these conserved currents should also exist in the fundamental theory . it is fairly straightforward to identify them . the qcd lagrangian has one obvious global @xmath59 charge - the baryon number . this charge has local order parameters - gauge invariant baryon fields of qcd , and is therefore identified with the dual magnetic flux @xmath106 the second charge can be expressed in terms of the spatial current components of the first one @xmath107 \label{qt}\ ] ] it is thus the vorticity associated with the baryon number current . the vortex operator @xmath24 which appears in eq.([efflfund ] ) is not gauge invariant and is only physical after complete gauge fixing of the @xmath59 gauge group . after such a gauge fixing ( which amounts to multiplying @xmath24 by an operator valued phase ) the gauss law requires that on the physical states the physical operator @xmath24 carry the charge @xmath108 . due to the identification eqs.([f],[qt ] ) this leads to a surprising conclusion that any physical operator @xmath24 in the effective theory creates a vortex of the original baryon number current . this somewhat unexpected conclusion is in fact quite natural for an eigenoperator of the magnetic @xmath0 . consider the vortex operator @xmath24 defined by eq.([v2 ] ) . in qcd just like in pure gluodynamics , it has an alternative representation of an operator of the singular gauge transformation of the form eq.([v1 ] ) @xmath109 the only difference is that now @xmath110 is the hypercharge operator due to both , gluons and fundamental quarks @xmath111+y_{\alpha\beta}(\phi^*_\alpha\pi_\beta- \phi_\alpha\pi^*_\beta)\big]\ ] ] consider the action of this operator on a quark field @xmath112 . the transformed quark field @xmath113 is a gauge transform of @xmath112 everywhere except along the branch cut of the function @xmath114 . across this cut the phase of @xmath115 is discontinuous - it jumps by @xmath116 for all color components of @xmath115 . due to this discontinuity the baryon current - the global @xmath59 current of @xmath112 - does not vanish at points along the cut . calculating explicitly the action of @xmath24 on the baryon number current we find @xmath117 where @xmath118 is a unit vector normal to the branch cut @xmath28 at the point @xmath18 . it is natural to define the local vorticity associated with the baryon number as the vorticity defined in this way is precisely the circulation of the phase of @xmath112 . ] @xmath119 \label{vort}\ ] ] the vortex operator @xmath24 therefore creates a vortex of baryon number current with fractional vorticity @xmath116 @xmath120 the operator @xmath93 due to the gauss law also carries baryon vorticity . since its gauge coupling is @xmath88 times the coupling of @xmath24 , it creates one unit of vorticity . in fact this simple exercise also helps us to identify the value of the gauge coupling constant @xmath121 in the effective theory . comparing eq.([vort ] ) with eq.([qt ] ) we find @xmath122 the same relation is obtained by comparing the current algebra in the fundamental and the effective theories . the commutator of the baryon charge density with the baryon current density in the fundamental theory is @xmath123=i\phi^*\phi\partial_i\delta^2(x - y)\ ] ] in the effective theory using the canonical commutators that follow from eq.([efflfund ] ) and the identification eq.([f ] ) we find @xmath123=i{e^2\over 4\pi^2}\partial_i\delta^2(x - y)\ ] ] again we deduce eq.([e2 ] ) . the operator on the right hand side of this equation in the effective theory is indeed a constant . recall , that our effective theory should be valid at long distances . in this regime in the leading order in the derivative expansion the operator @xmath124 should be approximated by its expectation value . taking into account fluctuations of @xmath124 is tantamount to including higher derivative terms in the effective lagrangian eq.([efflfund ] ) . at this , higher order in derivative expansion the gauge coupling constant would become a dynamical field . while this is perfectly legitimate , it is certainly beyond our present framework . when taking the expectation value of @xmath124 we should remember that it has to be calculated with the cutoff @xmath125 appropriate for the effective theory . this cutoff must be above the characteristic scale of the pure gluodynamics ( determined by the string tension ) but below the heavy quark mass . with this in mind we get @xmath126 so that finally @xmath127 which is consistent with the expected scaling in the large mass limit eq.([largem ] ) . having understood the origin of the fields and the symmetries in the effective theory , we would like to see how it encodes the qualitative features of the low energy qcd physics . since we are considering a heavy quark theory , below the fundamental mass scale the spectrum should be the same as in pure gluodynamics . we have already seen that , in the infinite mass limit , the effective theory reduces to that of ( [ ldualgg ] ) . indeed , even at finite but large @xmath63 , this is the case at low energies . formally , this can be seen as follows . since the vev of the field @xmath93 is large , we can impose the unitary gauge condition on it . in this unitary gauge the phase of @xmath93 disappears . the modulus of @xmath93 is very heavy , and so is the vector field @xmath98 . thus at low energies we recover the effective theory of pure glue sector . there is however a set of configurations , on which the unitary gauge can not be imposed . those are configurations in which @xmath93 vanishes at some points in space . indeed it is these configurations that are important for the baryonic sector . recall that @xmath93 is a vortex of baryon number current . thus one expects that the baryon charge is associated with the vortex configuration of the field @xmath93 . in the core of the vortex the field @xmath93 of course has to vanish , and so the unitary gauge is not admissible . thus in the baryon sector we can not think of @xmath93 as frozen at its expectation value and instead have to treat it as a dynamical field . that the baryon does indeed carry vorticity of the field @xmath93 , can be seen by the following simple argument . the baryon number is represented in the effective theory by the dual magnetic flux . the baryonic state must therefore be the dual magnetic vortex . such a vortex in a nonsingular gauge has a vector potential of the form @xmath128 . to have a finite energy it must be accompanied by the winding of the phases of both @xmath24 and @xmath93 . in fact since @xmath93 carries @xmath88 times the charge of @xmath24 , the only states that are allowed energetically are those that carry @xmath88 vortices of @xmath93 . this is natural in view of the ` dual ' relation between the effective and the fundamental theories . the field @xmath93 is the ` vortex ' dual to the fundamental quark . we thus expect that its elementary vortex would represent the fundamental quark itself , and so finite energy states must contain @xmath88 such elementary vortices . a single vortex must be confined . in the same sense , @xmath24 is ` dual ' to the adjoint gluon field . the elementary vortex of @xmath24 is then , in a sense , the ` constituent ' gluon . in fact , such single gluon should not exist as a finite energy state either , and we expect it also to be confined . the single vortex of @xmath24 should therefore bind either with the anti - vortex of the same type , or with @xmath88 vortices of @xmath93 . the former type of state is a glueball , and exists in the pure glue theory @xcite , while the latter type is a baryon . interestingly enough , this line of reasoning leads us to expect that the baryon must have a bag - like structure . namely , the quarks are bound to the @xmath24 field vortex . inside this vortex , the value of @xmath24 is small - in fact it exactly vanishes in the middle , and than rises quite slowly ( relative to the scale of @xmath129 ) towards the edges . recall that @xmath130 corresponds to a non confining state @xcite . the quarks are therefore sitting in the ` perturbative ' region of space - where there are no confining forces . only when they separate far from each other - into the region with non vanishing @xmath24 , the linear potential pulls them inside again . let us look at this more carefully . consider for simplicity the @xmath60 symmetric case @xmath131 . the baryon is the dual vortex with dual magnetic flux @xmath132 . far from the vortex core , the field configuration is pure gauge , with the phases of @xmath24 and @xmath93 following the vector potential : @xmath133 the parameters of the model are such that the field @xmath24 is much lighter than both @xmath93 and @xmath134 . thus the size of the vortex core of @xmath24 is large - of the order of the inverse glueball mass . the two @xmath93-vortices which have a very small size core , sit inside this core . since the length associated with the dual magnetic field is much smaller than the core size of the @xmath24 - vortex , the dual flux is concentrated on the @xmath93 - vortices . from the low energy point of view , the picture is that two point - like magnetic vortices sit inside a soft core of a @xmath24 field vortex . the field configuration looks roughly as depicted on figure 3 . the magnetic flux is concentrated in the points @xmath135 and @xmath136 . the phase of the field @xmath93 follows the variation of the vector potential very closely . the phase of @xmath24 is also trying to do that , but it can not quite follow it all the way , since on the line between the two vortices it would have to be discontinuous . the most important energy contribution ( apart form the core energy of small vortices ) comes therefore from the vicinity of this line . the phase of @xmath24 obviously has to interpolate across this line between the values @xmath48 and @xmath137 . since the modulus of @xmath24 is not extremely rigid , it will be smaller along this line than in the immediate neighborhood . both , the variation of the modulus and the phase of @xmath24 along the line connecting the small vortices contribute to the energy which is clearly linear in the distance @xmath138 . [ fig3 ] . arrows represent the direction ( phase ) of @xmath24 , and the big dots at @xmath135 and @xmath136 correspond to the positions of the @xmath93 field vortices.,title="fig : " ] to study the structure of the baryon more quantitatively let us fix the gauge such that @xmath139\ ] ] @xmath140 this is a valid gauge choice for the configuration with two vortices of unit winding at the positions @xmath141 and @xmath142 . due to the conditions on the parameters of our model , the vector field @xmath98 follows the phase of @xmath93 in the whole space . thus @xmath143\ ] ] where : @xmath144 , @xmath145 , and @xmath16 , @xmath146 are the positions of the left and right vortices , respectively : @xmath147 , @xmath148 . there are two interesting limiting situations . the first is when the distance @xmath149 is larger than the dynamical distance scales @xmath150 and @xmath151 which determine the masses of the glueballs . the second interesting situation is the reverse , that is when the two vortices are sitting well inside the glueball correlation length . let us look at them in turn . when the distance between the vortices is large we expect the potential between them to be linear with the string tension calculated in the theory without the dynamical @xmath93 field . we will study the interquark potential in our low energy theory in the semiclassical approximation . to find the minimal energy configuration , we have to solve the classical equations of motion for the field @xmath24 at a fixed configuration of @xmath93 and @xmath134 given by eqs.([eq : uconf],[eq : bconf ] ) . let us concentrate on the points which are close to the @xmath18 - axis , with @xmath152 . the main contribution to the energy comes from this region of space . in this region the vector potential @xmath134 vanishes , and the phase of the field @xmath93 is zero . thus the equations of motion for the field @xmath24 are the same as in the pure gluodynamics . also as long as we stick to this region , the configuration of @xmath24 is translationally invariant in the @xmath18 direction . what determines the energy then are the boundary conditions on the field @xmath24 . in this configuration clearly the phase of the field @xmath24 is @xmath153 far above the @xmath18 axis and @xmath154 far below the axis , fig.3 . thus both , the equations and the boundary conditions are precisely the same as for the domain wall separating the two degenerate vacua in the effective theory of pure gluodynamics ( @xmath155 ) . there is an extra contribution to the energy that comes from the region of space close to the points @xmath135 and @xmath136 . but this energy does not depend on @xmath149 and is subleading for large @xmath149 . the rest of the space does not contribute to the energy , since the field configuration there is pure gauge . thus as expected the energy in this regime is @xmath156 , where @xmath157 is the domain wall tension ( fundamental string tension ) calculated in pure gluodynamics @xcite . it is perhaps more interesting to consider the opposite situation , that is when the distance between the quarks is smaller than the glueball correlation length . this is the regime in which we do not expect to see any stringy structure . instead we can ask whether the lowest energy configuration has any resemblance to a bag . to study this question we take the limit @xmath158 . in this case clearly the phase of the field @xmath24 will follow the phase of @xmath93 in the whole space @xmath159 given this condition , only the variation of the radial component of @xmath24 has to be determined . since the problem has rotational symmetry , the equation of motion for the modulus @xmath10 becomes @xmath160 with @xmath161 , which is assumed to be positive throughout this paper . the relevant boundary condition in this case is that at infinity @xmath10 approaches its vacuum value @xmath162 while in the vortex core it vanishes @xmath163 . with these boundary conditions , eq . ( [ eq : eqrho1 ] ) has the familiar form of the @xmath164 static kink equation in @xmath165 dimensions with the solution @xmath166 the energy of this solution is @xmath167_{a=0 } \;=\ ; \lambda \int_0^\infty \ , 2 \pi dr r \ , ( v^4 - \rho^4 ) \;=\ ; \frac{\pi^3}{12 } \ , \frac{\eta}{\lambda } \;=\ ; \frac{\pi^3}{12 } \ , ( \mu^2 - \frac{\xi u}{\lambda } ) \;.\ ] ] the picture is thus just as described in the previous subsection . since the two quark state is accompanied by the vortex of the field @xmath24 , the quarks effectively ` dig a hole ' in the vacuum . in their immediate vicinity the modulus @xmath10 vanishes , and therefore there is a ` bag ' of the nonconfining state . the radius of this bag is given by the mass of the scalar glueball @xmath168 . it is interesting to note that , although for large separation @xmath149 the energy of the string gets contributions from both , the scalar and the pseudoscalar glueballs ( the modulus and the phase of @xmath24 ) , the ` bag constant ' is determined solely by the scalar glueball . for small @xmath149 the phase of @xmath24 is not excited and only @xmath10 deviates from the vacuum state inside the ` bag ' . this is consistent with the common lore that the inside of the bag is distinguished from the outside by the value of the @xmath169 condensate . in fact since @xmath10 has vacuum quantum numbers and interpolates in our effective theory the scalar glueball , it is naturally associated with the operator @xmath169 which has a large overlap with the scalar glueball in qcd . in this note we have considered the effect of heavy fundamental quarks on the effective low energy theory description of nonabelian gauge theories in 2 + 1 dimensions . we found that the status of the magnetic @xmath0 symmetry changes . it becomes a local symmetry with the ` gauge coupling ' inversely proportional to the quark mass . thus the low energy theory becomes a discrete gauge theory . we have also studied the structure of the baryon in the framework of the effective theory . the picture that emerges is very reminiscent to the ` bag ' . the quarks in the baryon sit in the middle of the @xmath24-vortex , where the energy density differs from the vacuum energy density . the ` bag constant ' is equal to the difference of these two energy densities , and parametrically in the effective theory is given by @xmath170 , where @xmath171 is the mass of the scalar glueball and @xmath172 is the expectation value of the vortex radial field @xmath10 . an important thing to note is that the bag we are talking about here arises in a very different situation than in the usual bag model @xcite . there the bag describes the structure of the baryon containing _ light _ quarks . the radius of the bag in this situation is determined by the balance of the vacuum pressure and the pressure due to the free motion of the light quarks inside , and in fact depends on the quark wave function . in our case the inside of the bag contains heavy quarks . their kinetic energy is small , and we have treated them here as static . the radius of the bag thus is determined purely by the dynamics of the scalar glueball field and is not sensitive to the state of the heavy quarks . this is true for low lying excitations for which the radius of the quark state is smaller than the inverse glueball mass . when these two scales are comparable presumably the quark pressure will also be important and will play a role in the energy balance . thus in this intermediate regime we expect the @xmath24-vortex to be similar to the bag in the usual bag model . for states of even larger size the potential between quarks is linear with the fundamental string tension . the bag picture should therefore go smoothly into the string picture . it would be interesting to study these questions further in the framework of the effective theory discussed in this note . lastly we note that although we have so far considered scalar quarks , extending this discussion to spin @xmath173 quarks is fairly straightforward . it is well known @xcite that in the abelian higgs model the spin of the vortex is controlled by the coefficient of the chern - simons term of the vector field . thus adding the chern simons term for the vector field @xmath98 @xmath174 with @xmath175 , will endow the vortex of the @xmath93-field with a half integer spin - vortex and not the @xmath24-vortex , since in the dynamics of our effective model the vector potential @xmath98 follows the phase of the field @xmath93 . ] . our effective model with this extra term is relevant to the description of qcd with one flavour of heavy spinor quarks . just like the fermion mass term in 2 + 1 dimensions , the chern simons term breaks the parity symmetry in the baryonic sector of the theory . the extra term does not affect the classical analysis we have preformed here , but is clearly relevant for determination of the spin of the baryon as well as the spectrum of the excitations . this work was part of a collaboration supported by a fundacin antorchas - the british council grant . c. d. f. is a member of conicet , and is partially supported by anpcyt ( pict 97/1040 ) and fundacin antorchas grants . a. k. is supported by pparc . 99 a. m. polyakov , _ nucl . _ _ b120 _ , 429 ( 1977 ) . s. r. das and s. r. wadia , _ phys . * b106 * , 386 ( 1981 ) , erratum - ibid . * b108 * 435 ( 1982 ) ; n. j. snyderman _ nucl . _ * b218 * , 381 ( 1983 ) . g. thooft , _ nucl . phys . _ * b138 * , 1 ( 1978 ) . s. samuel , _ nucl . phys . _ * b154 * , 62,(1979 ) ; a. kovner , b. rosenstein and d. eliezer , _ mod . lett . _ * a5 * , 2661 ( 1990 ) ; _ nucl . phys . _ * b350 * , 325 ( 1991 ) ; a. kovner and b. rosenstein , _ phys . lett . _ * b266 * , 443 ( 1991 ) . a. kovner and b. rosenstein , _ int . j. mod . phys . _ * a7 * , 7419 ( 1992 ) . a. kovner and b. rosenstein , _ j. high energy phys . _ * 003 * 9809 ( 1998 ) . c. p. korthals - altes and a. kovner , ` magnetic z(n ) symmetry in hot qcd and the spatial wilson loop , ' hep - ph/0004052 . m. j. teper , _ phys . _ * d59 * 014512 ( 1999 ) . l. krauss and f. wilczek _ phys . lett . _ * 62 * , 1221 ( 1989 ) ; j. preskill and l. krauss _ nucl . phys . _ * b341 * 50 ( 1990 ) . a. chodos , r. l. jaffe , k. johnson and c. b. thorn , _ phys . _ * d10 * ( 1974 ) 2599 ; a. chodos , r. l. jaffe , k. johnson , c. b. thorn and v. f. weisskopf , phys . rev . * d9 * ( 1974 ) 3471 . see , for example : a. lerda , _ anyons _ , lecture notes in physics , springer - verlag , berlin , 1992 .

we consider the effect of the ( heavy ) fundamental quarks on the low energy effective lagrangian description of nonabelian gauge theories in 2 + 1 dimensions . we show that in the presence of the fundamental charges , the magnetic @xmath0 symmetry becomes local . we construct the effective lagrangian representing this local symmetry in terms of magnetic vortex fields , and discuss its physical consequences . we show that the finite energy states described by this lagrangian have distinct bag - like structure . the point - like quarks are confined to the region of space where the value of the vortex field is much smaller than in the surrounding vacuum .

1204.0369

most models of dark energy in the present universe predict that its effective equation of state satisfies the null energy condition ( nec ) @xmath1 , where @xmath2 and @xmath3 are the effective dark energy density and pressure , respectively . however , the observations do not rule out that dark energy is phantom , i.e. , it violates nec . as an example , the 7-year wmap+bao+sn data @xcite give the following bound on the equation of state with time - dependent @xmath4 at @xmath5 : @xmath6 which is not entirely inconsistent with @xmath7 . even though phantom dark energy can be accomodated within general relativity @xcite , it is legitimate to ask whether effective phantom behavior can be obtained in modified gravity theories , such as @xmath8 or scalar - tensor gravity . this question can be addressed , in particular , within a popular approach @xcite employing the reconstruction of model parameters from the redshift expansion of observables , combined with the experimental constraints on non - gr gravity . the main conclusion is that with current observational data , the reconstructed de behaves more or less like the cosmological constant , but it is still possible to have phantom stage today . in this paper we follow a somewhat different route and ask what sort of the scalar - tensor lagrangian can lead to effective phantom de at the present epoch without violating constraints from solar system and local gravity experiments , time-(in)dependence of the gravity constant , etc . we also ask whether fine - tuning of initial data is necessary and how long the duration of the phantom stage can be in the past . our results are somewhat disappoining . we find that models with the present phantom de can be made consistent with all constraints , but one of the functions entering the scalar - tensor lagrangian must have rather specific shape , and the initial data must be strongly fine - tuned . also , the phantom stage must have begun fairly recently , at @xmath0 . before that the scalar field was undistinguishable from quintessence . all this disfavors the effective phantom behaviour in the scalar - tensor gravity . in fact , as we point out towards the end of this paper , some of the unpleasant properties we discuss must be present in scalar - tensor models for effective dark energy irrespectively of whether it is phantom or not . this paper is organized as follows . in section ii we present the equations governing the homogeneous cosmological evolution in the scalar - tensor gravity . we recall in section iii the experimental constraints on the non - gr gravity , that place bounds on the parameters of the theory . in section iv we define the expansion coefficients of the functions entering the lagrangian and reformulate the bounds of section iii in terms of these coefficients . in section v we put together all consistency requirements for the effective phantom dark energy today and arrive at qualitative understanding of the properties of the functions defining the theory . also , the maximum redshift at which the phantom phase could begin is estimated . section vi contains a numerical example . we conclude in section vii . by definition , the effective dark energy density and pressure @xmath9 and @xmath10 are the quantities entering the gr - looking evolution equations for the homogeneous and isotropic universe , @xmath11 where @xmath12 and @xmath13 are matter energy density and pressure , and we set @xmath14 . using ( [ e : fri1 ] ) and ( [ e : fri2 ] ) , one writes @xmath15 where @xmath16 . we are going to make use of this relation in the context of the scalar - tensor gravity . the action of this theory is @xmath17 ( mostly positive signature ) , where the action for the usual matter @xmath18 does not depend on @xmath19 . one can always redefine the field to have a convenient form of either @xmath20 or @xmath21 . we will use the general form of @xmath20 and set @xmath22 from the action ( [ e : action ] ) one obtains the gravitational equations , @xmath23 and equation of motion for the field @xmath19 , @xmath24 let us specify to the homogeneous , isotropic and spatially flat universe with metric @xmath25 since matter does not interact with @xmath19 , the scale factor @xmath26 has the same meaning as in gr . using eqs . ( [ e : ein ] ) and ( [ e : phi ] ) one gets the following set of equations : @xmath27 the equation for the matter density has the usual form , @xmath28 it is convenient for futher analysis to switch from the evolution in time to the evolution in redshift . this can be done by using the relation @xmath29 in this way one obtains from ( [ e : fr1j ] ) , ( [ e : fr2j ] ) and ( [ e : phj ] ) the evolution equations in terms of redshift : @xmath30f ' \label{e : fr2z}\\ h^{2}(1+z)^{2}\phi''&+[hh'(1+z)^{2}-2h^{2}(1+z)]\phi'=3[2h^{2}-hh'(1+z)]\frac{f'}{\phi'}-\frac{u'}{\phi ' } , \label{e : phz}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where prime denotes @xmath31 . the properties of functions defining the theory are strongly constrained by local and solar system experiments . this is a major problem for the effective nec - violating behavior in the scalar - tensor gravity . one important parameter is the brans dicke `` constant '' @xmath32 . it is straightforward to obtain the expression for @xmath33 in our parametrization by redifining the scalar field . one finds @xmath34 the lower bound on the present value of @xmath33 is obtained from the kassini experiment @xcite . it reads ( the subscript @xmath35 denotes the quantities at the present epoch ) @xmath36 a bound of another sort follows from the experiments on the time dependence of the gravity constant . in our case the local gravity constant @xmath37 is given by @xcite @xmath38 the experimental constraint on the time evolution of @xmath37 can be found in refs . for @xmath5 it reads @xmath39 we also know that the gravitational constant relevant for cosmology should not change significantly since big bang nucleosynthesis @xcite , @xmath40 it is the latter constraint that plays a significant role in our analysis , see section v. a convenient way to analyze the evolution at small redshifts is to expand all functions in the taylor series in redshift @xmath41 . on the other hand , we are mainly interested in the dependence on @xmath19 , so we will use the mixed expansion . at @xmath5 , without loss of generality we choose @xmath42 and by definition of the newton gravity constant we have @xmath43 here is our definition of the expansion coefficients : @xmath44 without loss of generality we take @xmath45 . from eq . ( [ e : fr1z ] ) it is straightforward to obtain the relation between the derivatives at the present time , @xmath46 we will also need @xmath47 and @xmath48 to obtain the expression for @xmath4 . from eqs . ( [ e : fr1z ] ) , ( [ e : fr2z ] ) we get @xmath49.\label{e : h22}\end{aligned}\ ] ] our main purpose is to understand the behavior of @xmath50 and @xmath51 as functions of the scalar field , so we expand them in @xmath19 : @xmath52 the relationship between the expansion coefficients entering ( [ e : ff ] ) and ( [ e : f ] ) is @xmath53 we now recall the constraint on @xmath54 , eq . ( [ wbd ] ) , and make use of eq . ( [ wf ] ) . with our normalization @xmath55 , we get very strong upper bound on @xmath56 : @xmath57 this means that the field @xmath19 is presently near the extremum of the funcion @xmath20 . such a conclusion appears inevitable in modified gravity , see , e.g. , ref . @xcite . it follows from eq . ( [ phsh ] ) that @xmath58 , so eq . ( [ e : f1 ] ) implies that @xmath59 is also small , latexmath:[\[\label{f1r } the first derivative of @xmath50 in the analysis of the present epoch . we note in passing that a small value of @xmath61 could have been anticipated , since the gr tests are very precise , and only a slight deviation from gr can be tolerated today . using ( [ phsh ] ) and neglecting the term with @xmath59 , we obtain for the present value of the field derivative with respect to redshift @xmath62 this simple relation will be instrumental in what follows . now we use the expression ( [ e : omega ] ) for @xmath63 to find out which parametrs can be responsible for the effective phantom behavior . making use of eqs . ( [ e : f1]),([e : f2 ] ) and ( [ f1r ] ) we get @xmath64 by extracting the second derivative of the field from eq . ( [ e : phz ] ) , we find @xmath65 so , there are essentially two parameters that could yield @xmath66 , namely , @xmath67 and @xmath68 . we begin our discussion with the latter . the possible contribution of the potential to the phantom effective equation of state comes from the third term in ( [ ww0 ] ) ( the second term in the numerator is positive in virtue of eq . ( [ ph2 ] ) ) and is given by @xmath69 it is strongly supressed by small @xmath56 , so this contribution can be sizeable only if the potential @xmath70 is very steep today . however , steep potential would lead to the rapid acceleration of the scalar field , so the phantom phase would be very short in the past . furthermore , the fast evolution of the scalar field together with large @xmath71 would imply rapid change in time of the effective dark energy density . to elaborate on the latter point , let us consider the parameter @xmath72 observationally , @xmath73 is not large : the wmap analysis @xcite gives @xmath74 . on the other hand , making use of eq . ( [ e : omega ] ) and neglecting the terms with @xmath75 we obtain @xmath76 where @xmath77 and @xmath78 are : @xmath79+\nonumber\\ & + \frac{1}{3(1-\omega_{m,0})}\left[12f_{2}+\frac{3f_{2}^{2}}{2}+9f_{2}\omega_{u,0}-\frac{9}{2}f_{2}\omega_{m,0 } -30\omega_{u,0}\right.\nonumber\\ & \left.+24(1-\omega_{m,0})+6\phantom{\frac{1}{1}}\right]-\frac{1}{3(1-\omega_{m,0})^{2}}\left(-f_{2}+6\omega_{u,0}+3\omega_{m,0}-6\right)^{2}. \label{ww12}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the parameter @xmath80 can not be very large , see below , so for large @xmath81 the value of @xmath82 is controlled by @xmath77 term in the expression ( [ ww1 ] ) . to have sizeable contribution ( [ mar10 - 1 ] ) and at the same time satisfy the observational constraint on @xmath82 , one would need the cancellation between @xmath83 and @xmath84 , which in turn would require strong fine - tuning . barring this possibility , we arrive at the conclusion that @xmath85 , so the contribution ( [ mar10 - 1 ] ) is very small . from now on we neglect it . the remaining terms in eq . ( [ ww0 ] ) can be simplified by using ( [ ph2 ] ) : @xmath86 thus , the phantom behaviour today is controlled entirely by @xmath87 . to have @xmath88 at the present time , one requires that @xmath89 together with the bound ( [ mar11 - 1 ] ) , this implies that today the field @xmath19 must be close to a relatively sharp maximum of the function @xmath20 . clearly , such a special state requires fine - tuning of both the function @xmath20 and initial conditions in the theory . we continue the discussion of the shape of @xmath20 and recall the constraints on the time - dependence of the gravity constant . given the small value of @xmath75 and large value of @xmath90 , the constraint ( [ gete ] ) is not hard to satisfy ; note that this is in contrast to ref . much less trivial is the fact that the `` cosmological '' gravity constant has not changed much since bbn . it is clear from ( [ e : fr1j ] ) that @xmath91 is simply equal to @xmath92 . barring strong cancellations , the constraint ( [ mar11 - 2 ] ) together with eq . ( [ e : fr1z ] ) imply that the variation of @xmath20 has been small since bbn , @xmath93 and that @xmath94 is small at large @xmath41 . thus , the function @xmath20 must have the shape shown in fig . [ ris : image ] . let us now estimate the range of redshifts in which the dynamics of @xmath50 is non - trivial , and the phantom effective equation of state can be realized . we do this by requiring that the value of @xmath50 does not change much during this period . since @xmath75 is small , the second term in the expansion of @xmath50 in redshift is relevant , and the estimate for maximum redshift is found from @xmath95 where the bound on @xmath96 is given in eq . ( [ mar11 - 5 ] ) . making use of eq . ( [ e : f2 ] ) we get @xmath97 let us denote by @xmath98 the deviation of @xmath4 from @xmath99 today : @xmath100 using ( [ ww ] ) we get the estimate @xmath101 , and hence from ( [ g2 ] ) we find @xmath102 for reasonably strong phantom behavior ( i.e. , not very small @xmath98 ) , @xmath103 is fairly small ; roughly speaking , @xmath104 . note that similar result has been obtained within the reconstruction approach @xcite . at larger redshfts , @xmath50 is frozen out , and the scalar field @xmath19 reduces to quintessence . let us give a concrete example of a model with effective phantom behavior today and in the recent past . we note that the relatively large value of the parameter @xmath105 is obtained for fairly large @xmath106 , otherwise the maximum of @xmath50 must be very sharp ( i.e. , @xmath67 must be large ) , see eq . ( [ ww ] ) . so , we take , somewhat arbitrarily , @xmath107 . we choose @xmath108 , in rough agreement with observations , then eq . ( [ e : fr1z ] ) with @xmath109 gives @xmath110 . fairly strong phantom behavior , @xmath111 , is obtained with @xmath112 . the estimate ( [ zmax1 ] ) then gives @xmath113 . to satisfy all these requirements , we choose @xmath20 as shown in fig . [ image3 ] . the shape of the potential @xmath70 is not constrained particularly strongly ; our choice is shown in fig . [ image6 ] . with this choice , the effective equation of state depends on redshift as shown in fig . [ image2 ] . as expected , @xmath4 rapidly tends to @xmath99 as @xmath41 increases , and the field @xmath19 becomes indistiguishable from quintessence at @xmath114 . the field value does not change much : the change from redshift 0.2 to the present epoch is about @xmath115 . we have constructed a number of other examples satisfying the constraints of section iii ; all of these examples have similar properties . as we already pointed out , effective phantom dark energy requires both the special form of the function @xmath20 and fine - tuning of the initial value of the field @xmath19 . to see the latter property explicitly , let us take the same functions @xmath20 and @xmath70 as before and consider the evolution from redshift @xmath116 to @xmath5 for different initial values of the field . if we vary the initial condition for @xmath19 within 15% interval around the central value yielding fig . [ image2 ] ( without varying the initial velocity @xmath117 , for the sake of arument ) , the evolution changes considerably . in particular , the effective equation of state is as shown in fig . [ image8 ] . such a behaviour is not unexpected . the right choice of the initial value of the field ensures that the phantom phase begins in just right time , at some rather small redshift . for different initial values , the onset of the phantom behavior occurs at `` wrong '' redshifts , so one either has too large deviation of @xmath63 from @xmath99 , or no deviation at all . in this paper we revisited the question of the possibility of the present phantom phase in scalar - tensor gravity . we have seen that it is possible to obtain and control effective phantom behavior even in simple scalar - tensor models , but this requires a lot of fine - tuning . first , the large present value of the brans dicke parameter is obtained only if the scalar field @xmath19 is presently near the extremum of the function @xmath50 determining the gravity constant . this is consistent with observable phantom property only if this extermum is a sharp maximum . second , the small variation of the gravity constant since bbn requires that @xmath50 flattens out at fairly low redshift . finally , the whole picture is consistent with observations only for fine - tuned initial data . we conclude by noting that some of the unpleasant properties discussed in this paper must be present in scalar - tensor models for effective dark energy irrespectively of whether it is phantom or not . this remark applies , in particular , to the contrived shape of the function @xmath50 and fine - tuning of initial conditions . indeed , the fact that @xmath118 must be small today does not rely on the assumption of the phantom behavior . furthermore , most of the analysis in section v goes through provided that @xmath119 is large enough at the present epoch , while the case @xmath120 corresponds to quintessence rather than genuine scalar - tensor gravity . all this makes scalar - tensor theory rather unlikely candidate for explaining the accelerated expansion of the universe . e. komatsu _ et al . _ [ wmap collaboration ] , astrophys . j. suppl . * 192 * , 18 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1001.4538 [ astro-ph.co ] ] . c. armendariz - picon , jcap * 0407 * , 007 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0405267 ] . l. senatore , phys . d * 71 * , 043512 ( 2005 ) ; p. creminelli , m. a. luty , a. nicolis and l. senatore , jhep * 0612 * , 080 ( 2006 ) . a. nicolis , r. rattazzi and e. trincherini , phys . d * 79 * , 064036 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0811.2197 [ hep - th ] ] ; c. deffayet , g. esposito - farese and a. vikman , phys . d * 79 * , 084003 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0901.1314 [ hep - th ] ] ; c. deffayet , s. deser and g. esposito - farese , phys . d * 80 * , 064015 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0906.1967 [ gr - qc ] ] ; p. creminelli , a. nicolis and e. trincherini , jcap * 1011 * , 021 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1007.0027 [ hep - th ] ] . s. m. carroll , a. de felice and m. trodden , phys . d * 71 * , 023525 ( 2005 ) [ astro - ph/0408081 ] . l. amendola , r. gannouji , d. polarski and s. tsujikawa , phys . d * 75 * , 083504 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0612180 ] .

we revisit the problem of phantom behaviour of effective dark energy in scalar - tensor gravity . the main focus is on the properties of the functions defining the model . we find that models with the present phantom behavior can be made consistent with all constraints , but one of these functions must have rather contrived shape , and the initial data must be strongly fine - tuned . also , the phantom stage must have begun fairly recently , at @xmath0 . all this disfavors the effective phantom behaviour in the scalar - tensor gravity .

astro-ph9801059

pulsars were discovered in 1967 when bell and hewish were observing the interplanetary scintillations ( ips ) of compact radio sources , using a fixed dipole array at 81.5mhz ( @xcite ) . chart recordings were examined by eye for evidence of intrinsically pulsed signals , which looked somewhat different from the scintillating quasars being studied . within a few months , the first cambridge pulsar search discovered a total of six pulsars : psrs b0329 + 54 , b0809 + 74 , b0834 + 06 , b0950 + 08 , b1133 + 16 , and b1919 + 21 ( @xcite ) . soon afterward the dipole array returned to nearly full - time studies of ips , compact radio sources , and the interplanetary medium the purposes for which it had been designed . most pulsar searching since 1968 has been done at radio frequencies around 400mhz and higher , where the sky background is lower , interstellar dispersion and scattering are less of an impediment , and much larger bandwidths can be gainfully used . nevertheless , in 1993 it seemed to us for a number of reasons that a second cambridge pulsar search at 81.5mhz would be a worthwhile undertaking . the ips dipole array has been doubled in size since 1968 , and now has a geometric collecting area of 36,055m@xmath4 or 3.6 hectares approximately half that of the 305 m telescope in arecibo , puerto rico . the discovery of psr j0437@xmath14715 by johnston _ et al . _ ( 1993 ) demonstrated the existence of at least one very strong , nearby , millisecond pulsar . we reasoned that if similar pulsars exist in the northern sky , the 3.6-hectare array should be capable of detecting them , especially if their low - frequency radio spectra are steeper than those of most slowly rotating pulsars , as suggested by foster _ et al . _ ( 1991 ) . fortunately , the nature of the cambridge array is such that co - opting any one of its 16 simultaneous beams for pulsar searching can be done with only minimal disruption to its continuing ips studies . the 3.6 hectare array is a meridian - transit instrument consisting of 4096 full - wave dipoles operating at a wavelength @xmath5 m . the dipoles are arranged in 32 east - west rows of 128 dipoles each , with a spacing between rows of @xmath6 wavelengths . a branched feeder network combines the signals within each row , properly phasing them for a celestial source on the meridian . summed signals from the 16 northern - most and 16 southern - most rows are then combined in a matched pair of `` butler matrices '' to form simultaneous beams at 16 declinations in the range @xmath7 . for ips studies the two half - arrays are used as a north - south phase - switching interferometer ( @xcite ) ; however , for our pulsar observations we connected the two halves as a total - power phased array . a modified set of 16 beams can be generated by inserting an extra phase gradient in the north - south direction across the entire array , thereby shifting each beam north by half a beamwidth , or about @xmath8 . the declination of the peak response for each of the 32 possible beams is given by @xmath9 \,,\ ] ] where the beam number , @xmath10 , is an integer in the range 116 for the unshifted beams , and a half - integral value between 1.5 and 16.5 for the shifted beams ( @xcite ) . the beams have half - power widths of @xmath11}$ ] in declination . a reflecting screen lies @xmath12 beneath each row , and is inclined towards the south at 50 degrees to the vertical in order to increase the sensitivity of the array at lower declinations . however , tappin ( 1984 ) has shown that the declination power response , @xmath13 , of the antenna follows that expected for an array of dipoles @xmath12 above a flat , horizontal reflecting screen ; he finds no evidence for increased sensitivity at lower declinations . let @xmath14 represent the angle of the reflecting screen to the horizontal , and define the following three additional angles : @xmath15{0mm}{12.5 mm } \psi & \equiv & \left(\frac{\pi d}{\lambda}\right)\sin{\phi } + \left(\frac{n-10}{16}\right)\pi , \\ * \alpha & \equiv & \left(\frac{32\pi d}{\lambda}\right)\sin{\phi}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the normalized declination power response can then be expressed as @xmath16\ , \frac{\sin^2{16\psi}}{{16 ^ 2}\sin^2{\psi}},\ ] ] where the three factors on the right - hand side arise from the interference between the two array halves , the reflecting screen , and the 16 phased rows in each half , respectively . following tappin , we take @xmath17 . inserting the peak - response declinations of equation ( [ eqn : camb_d0 ] ) into equation ( [ eqn : camb_d ] ) then shows that @xmath13 is maximized by phasing the array so as to use the plus sign in the first factor for integral beam numbers , and the minus sign for half - integral beam numbers . the top panel of figure [ fig : camb_beams ] shows the combined declination response afforded by the antenna for the whole survey , obtained by summing the calculated power responses of all 32 beams . the peak gain of each beam is proportional to the effective collecting area of the array , which falls off as the cosine of zenith angle . because of this foreshortening , several of the beams have secondary responses comparable to or even greater than their primary responses . as examples , the bottom panel of figure [ fig : camb_beams ] shows the individual power responses of beams 1 ( solid curve ) and 10 ( dashed curve ) . the true declinations of sources detected in the beams with large secondary responses can be determined from their transit times through the east - west beam : a source at declination @xmath18 has a half - power transit time of @xmath19 seconds ( @xcite ) . for the secondary responses at @xmath20 , transit times are shifted by 12 hours . our observations were carried out between november 1993 and june 1994 . we phased the array for a given beam number , @xmath21 , 1.5 , 2 , 2.5 , , 16.5 , and recorded data continuously for 24 hours as the sky drifted overhead . observations were repeated as demanded by interference , equipment malfunction or mis - adjustment , etc . , until each of the 32 beams had been observed and produced high - quality data at least twice . figure [ fig : camb_skymap ] illustrates the full sky coverage of the survey . we analyzed beams 16 and 16.5 for signals entering via their secondary responses , rather than the primary ones . consequently the survey provided useful sensitivity between declinations of @xmath0 and @xmath22 , with a few small areas missing because of interference . note , however , that because of array foreshortening at low declinations and the `` scalloped '' overall response as a function of @xmath18 , as well as the large variation in background temperature over the sky , our sensitivity even to low - dispersion , long period pulsars varied by more than an order of magnitude over the surveyed area . as described in more detail below , the median sensitivity for low - dispersion pulsars with periods @xmath23s was about 200mjy . when the 3.6-hectare array is being used solely for ips observations , the southernmost 14 beams are observed simultaneously . we diverted a single beam on a given day for pulsar observations , thereby causing only minimal disruption to the ips work . signals from the two halves of the array , properly phased for the desired beam , were extracted from the two butler matrices and added . the resulting signal was mixed to intermediate frequency of 10.7mhz and then to baseband , using quadrature local oscillators . an automatic gain control served to keep the post - detection noise level constant . the in - phase ( `` real '' ) and quadrature ( `` imaginary '' ) baseband signals were low - pass filtered at 0.47mhz ( the filters are 60db down at 0.5mhz ) , sampled at a 1mhz rate , and digitized in a 12-bit analog - to - digital converter controlled by a programmable digital signal processor ( dsp ; analog devices adsp-21020 ) on a vme board made by the ixthos corporation . the incoming data were double - buffered in fast memory on the dsp board . at intervals of 256@xmath24s the adsp-21020 performed a 256-point complex fourier transform on the incoming data and squared the resulting magnitudes . three consecutive power spectra were summed , and every 768@xmath24s the difference between the 256-channel power spectrum and an exponentially - weighted mean of spectra over the past 1.5s was one - bit sampled . the resulting bits were packed into 32-bit words and passed to a controlling workstation , which wrote them onto magnetic tape along with the running averages and root - mean - square deviations of the summed power spectra and the date , time , and beam number . a full day s observing session generated about 3.5 gb of data , which fit comfortably on a single 8 mm tape cassette . searching for pulsar signals was accomplished by reading the recorded data from tape into another workstation . the one - bit data were unpacked and divided into consecutive blocks with length comparable to the beam transit time at the relevant declination . block lengths of @xmath25 samples were used for beams 110 , 16 , and 16.5 ; @xmath26 samples for beams 10.513 ; and @xmath27 samples for beams 13.515.5 . these numbers correspond to transit times of 101 , 201 , and 403s . beams 16 and 16.5 were processed using the short block length so as to remain sensitive to pulsars in their secondary responses at declinations near @xmath0 and @xmath28 , respectively . the total amount of computing was substantial : with the dec axp3000/400 workstation used to do most of it , about 3.6 days of computing was required for each day of observations nearly eight months of continuous computing , in all . the search program analyzed each beam area independently . progressive delays were introduced between the 256 spectral channels in a manner that optimally produces time series at different dispersion measures ( @xcite ) . curvature in the delay - versus - frequency relation was compensated by shifting the middle two - thirds of the spectral channels by one channel . for each data block , the one - bit samples were optimally de - dispersed at 256 dispersion measures evenly spaced between 0 and 12.78@xmath2pc . additional dispersion ranges were generated by first adding successive pairs of time samples in each spectral channel , and then reapplying the de - dispersion algorithm . the de - dispersed time series in each new range thus had half the length of those in the previous range , and the upper half of each group of dispersions extended the ranges of those already computed . in this manner , each data block was also de - dispersed by 128 dispersion measures evenly spaced across each of the following ranges : 12.8325.60 , 25.6551.25 , and 51.30102.55@xmath2pc . for each data block a total of 640 de - dispersed time series were fourier transformed and analyzed for harmonic content . after removing known sources of periodic interference ( in particular , the 274hz phase - switching frequency used for ips studies ) , the search program identified the strongest periodicities by interpolating between the complex fourier coefficients and finding the peak amplitudes , and also by summing harmonically related frequencies in groups of 2 , 3 , 4 , 8 , and 16 harmonics . the program isolated the most promising pulsar suspects in the frequency domain , formed the equivalent integrated pulse shapes by transforming complex coefficients ( with up to 32 harmonics ) back into the time domain , and computed their signal - to - noise ratios . any suspect detections with signal strengths above a predetermined threshold were presented as possible detections . the expected signal - to - noise ratio , @xmath29 , of a received pulsar signal can be related to various system parameters by the expression @xmath30^{1/2}\,,\ ] ] where @xmath31 is the digitization efficiency factor , @xmath32 the mean flux density of the pulsar at 81.5mhz ( jy ) , @xmath33 the telescope gain ( k jy@xmath34 ) , @xmath35 the system temperature ( k ) , @xmath36 the bandwidth ( hz ) , @xmath37 the integration time ( s ) , @xmath38 the number of polarizations , @xmath39 the period , and @xmath40 the pulse width . our system had @xmath41mhz , @xmath42 , and because of the one - bit post - detection digitization , @xmath43 ( @xcite ) . flux density measurements can therefore be obtained for detected pulsars by determining @xmath44 from calibration measurements , calculating @xmath29 , @xmath39 , and @xmath40 from average profiles , and solving for @xmath32 . the appropriate value of @xmath33 for any direction in our surveyed region depends on variations in antenna gain across the declination strip , the peak gain and sidelobe responses of the different beams , and the background sky temperature . the first effect can be calculated from the declination power response given by equation ( [ eqn : camb_d ] ) , and the latter two by using a sky map of equivalent background flux density obtained with the same telescope . figure 4.5.2 of purvis ( 1981 ) presents a contour map of the system noise level of the 3.6-hectare array when operated as a phase - switching interferometer . the contour levels indicate twice the receiver noise level , in janskys , for a bandwidth @xmath45mhz and integration time @xmath46s . the map therefore plots the flux density @xmath47 at which unresolved , continuous sources at the beam centers would be detected with signal - to - noise ratio @xmath48 . at an arbitrary declination @xmath18 close to the strip - center at @xmath49 , we have @xmath50}\,.\ ] ] it therefore follows that the flux density of a pulsar observed with signal - to - noise ratio @xmath51 is given by @xmath52}{d(n,\delta)}\ , \left[\frac{0.13 w}{\tau(p - w)}\right]^{1/2}.\ ] ] more than @xmath53 possible combinations of period , dispersion measure , and pulse width are tested for significance in each data block , and consequently a moderately high threshold signal - to - noise ratio must be used to keep the rate of false detections low . we adopted a lower limit of @xmath54 , and the sensitivity of the whole survey can therefore be characterized by inserting this number into equation ( [ eqn : camb_flux ] ) together with appropriate values for the integration time , @xmath37 , and effective pulse width , @xmath40 , including all forms of instrumental smoothing . the pulse width is bounded on the low side by @xmath55 , the post - detection sample interval ; it also depends on the dispersion measure . for periods smaller than @xmath56ms in the lowest dispersion range , the minimum detectable flux density scales approximately as @xmath57 . similar behavior obtains for the higher dispersion ranges , with the effective @xmath55 doubling in each successive range . a more complete sensitivity analysis based on the detailed implementation of our search algorithm leads to the stepwise continuous sensitivity curves plotted in figure [ fig : camb_minflux ] ( see @xcite ) . this graph shows the sensitivity of our survey to a low - duty - cycle ( @xmath58 ) pulsar in a region with the median sky background noise , @xmath59jy . the curves show the minimum flux densities that yield @xmath54 , as a function of period , and are plotted for five values of dm up to the largest values searched . steps in the sensitivity curves occur at periods equal to multiples of @xmath55 , where the number of harmonics tested by the search software changes . the sky background noise @xmath47 varies between the extremes of 0.5 and 9jy , but is @xmath60jy for 50% and @xmath61jy for about 70% of the visible sky ( @xcite ) . it is important to note that the sensitivity models of equation ( [ eqn : camb_flux ] ) and figure [ fig : camb_minflux ] do not explicitly account for interstellar scattering effects , which will likely dominate the pulse broadening for pulsars with @xmath62@xmath2pc . such pulsars always lie close to the galactic plane , and for this and other reasons are more profitably observed at frequencies much higher than 81.5mhz . we detected a total of 20 pulsars , all of them previously known . their locations are plotted in galactic coordinates in figure [ fig : camb_skymap ] . table 1 lists their catalogued parameters including names , b1950 celestial coordinates , periods , dispersion measures , and 400mhz flux densities , @xmath63 . we also list the offsets , @xmath64 , between each pulsar s location and the nearest beam center , as well as the observed signal - to - noise ratios for the two times each pulsar was nominally observed , and the average flux densities , @xmath32 , for the positive detections . the signal - to - noise ratios are those determined by the search program for the closest beam pointing . we include values for both observations of the relevant declination strip to give some indication of the efficiency of the search algorithm and the repeatability of the measurements . flux densities were calculated by applying equation ( [ eqn : camb_flux ] ) to the average profiles created by synchronously averaging one full beam - transit of data , centered on the pulsar s right ascension . the profile obtained in this way for each pulsar is illustrated in figure [ fig : camb_profs ] . the accuracy of our flux density measurements depends on calibration errors and manual `` readout uncertainties '' of the sky map , as well as the degree to which the pulsar signals were affected by time - variable scintillation effects . the sky map is thought to be accurate to within about 20% , and the map - reading uncertainties probably contribute another 20% uncertainty . interstellar scintillation causes significant modulations of the signal strengths by factors of 2 or more , particularly for the lowest - dispersion pulsars . some information on internal consistency of the results may be gained from the 13 pulsars detected in each of the two days their declination strip was observed . their flux density measurements show a root - mean - square deviation of 25% around the mean . altogether we estimate that the flux density measurements are accurate to approximately 40% , and within such limits are in good accord with previous work . an especially low measured flux for psr b0809 + 74 may be the result of uncertain extrapolation of sky - background contours near the edge of the map . radio - frequency spectra of the 20 detected pulsars are presented in figure [ fig : camb_spectra ] . pulsar spectra are generally characterized by power - law indices of @xmath65 to @xmath66 at frequencies above a few hundred mhz ; typically the spectra flatten and perhaps even turn over at lower frequencies . low - frequency turnovers are clearly evident for some of the spectra displayed in figure [ fig : camb_spectra ] , and it seems certain that similar behavior in many other known pulsars prevented their detection in our survey . even among the pulsars we detected , nearly half are an order of magnitude weaker at 81.5mhz than would be expected from straight - line extrapolations of their higher - frequency spectra . not surprisingly , all six of the original cambridge pulsars were detected in the survey , although psr b0950 + 08 was one of the seven pulsars only seen in a single day s observations . none of the seven pulsars seen only once would have been confirmed as a new pulsar discovery solely on the basis of the observations we made ; however , further attempts at confirmation would have been undertaken for any candidate with a single observation as promising as these . psr b0950 + 08 was actually observed during initial trial runs using only half the array , and also in some observations when the array was mistakenly anti - phased . figure [ fig : camb_spectra ] shows variations more than an order of magnitude in measured fluxes of psr b0950 + 08 around 100mhz , with our measurement close to the top of the range . a scintillation - induced order - of - magnitude decrease in received flux would have rendered the pulsar undetectable in the survey . the strongest pulsar detected in our survey , psr b2217 + 47 , was not detected in the first cambridge pulsar search because , with a @xmath67@xmath2pc , its pulse is smeared out over more than a full period in a 1mhz bandwidth . its pulses , and also those of psrs b0919 + 06 and b1642@xmath103 , are quite undetectable with the cambridge telescope , without the benefit of dispersion - removal techniques . in the coldest regions of the sky the minimum detectable flux density of our survey is about 100mjy . several pulsars we did not see have been detected by others at frequencies between 70 and 100mhz , with mean flux densities greater than that minimum : psrs b0138 + 59 , b0320 + 39 , b0523 + 11 , b0525 + 21 , b0531 + 21 , b0611 + 22 , b1612 + 07 , b1842 + 14 , b2111 + 46 , b2154 + 40 , and b2319 + 60 ( @xcite ) . of these , psr b2111 + 46 has a dm of 141.5@xmath2pc , which exceeds the highest value we searched ; and the pulsar in the crab nebula , psr b0531 + 21 , is undetectable as a periodic source because interstellar scattering broadens its pulse excessively at 81.5mhz . the remaining pulsars all have reported flux measurements below the detection threshold for their sky positions , periods , and dispersion measures , except for psrs b0138 + 59 and b0320 + 39 . our estimated sensitivities at these positions are 150 and 420mjy , respectively . et al . _ ( 1981 ) report a flux measurement for psr b0138 + 59 of 260mjy at 85mhz . ( 1994 ) quote fluxes for psr b0320 + 39 of 700 and 500mjy at 60 and 100mhz , respectively , while izvekova _ et al . _ ( 1981 ) give mean flux density measurements of 230 and 160mjy at the same frequencies . it follows that these two pulsars would have been marginal detections in our survey , at best . in summary , the second cambridge pulsar survey detected all previously known pulsars in the northern hemisphere that we could have expected to detect , with the possible exception of psr b0138 + 59 . we obtained the lowest frequency flux measurements available for psrs b0450 + 55 , b0655 + 64 , b1839 + 56 , b2110 + 27 , and b2224 + 65 . interestingly , psr b0655 + 64 is a binary pulsar , with orbital period just slightly longer than a day . if it had been just a little stronger , and therefore had been discovered by bell and hewish in 1968 , disentangling its orbiting nature by means of observations with this transit telescope would have been quite difficult as indeed it still was , when the pulsar was discovered with the 300 ft transit telescope in green bank , a decade later ( see @xcite ) . with respect to possible detections of millisecond pulsars , we offer the following comments . over the northern celestial hemisphere our median sensitivity to pulsars similar to j0437@xmath14715 ( @xmath68ms , dm@xmath69@xmath2pc , @xmath70jy ; see @xcite ) was approximately 0.7jy . if pulsars like psr j0437@xmath14715 were scattered all over the northern hemisphere , we would have detected more than half of them . we conclude , therefore , that such objects are quite rare . almost certainly there is no such pulsar in our surveyed region with @xmath71jy . we thank a. hewish and r. hills for organizational assistance in the early phases of this project , and j. milrod and the ixthos corporation for their generous loan of the dsp hardware . pulsar studies at princeton are supported by the us national science foundation . g. w. thanks serc ( now pparc ) for a research fellowship and clare college cambridge for a college lectureship , both held during the bulk of this work .

we have searched the northern sky for pulsars at the low radio frequency of 81.5mhz , using the 3.6-hectare array at cambridge , england . the survey covered most of the sky north of declination @xmath0 and provided sensitivities of order 200mjy for pulsars not too close to the galactic plane . a total of 20 pulsars were detected , all of them previously known . the effective post - detection sampling rate was 1.3khz , and the sensitivity to low - dispersion millisecond pulsars was sufficient to allow the detection of objects similar to psr j0437@xmath14715 ( period 5.7ms , dispersion measure 2.6@xmath2pc , mean flux density @xmath3jy ) . no such pulsars were found .

nucl-th0010025

one of the purposes of investigating the nucleon resonances(@xmath7 ) is to understand the non - perturbative dynamics of quantum chromodynamics(qcd ) . one possible approach to realize this is to compare the predictions of qcd - inspired models with the resonance parameters which can be extracted from the data of pion photoproduction and electroproduction reactions . in recent years , precise data including polarization observables have been obtained in the @xmath8 region for pion photoproduction at legs@xcite and mainz@xcite , and for pion electroproduction at thomas jefferson national accelerator facility(jlab)@xcite , mit - bates@xcite and nikhef@xcite . these data now allow us to investigate more precisely the electromagnetic excitation of the @xmath8 resonance . in ref.@xcite we have developed a dynamical model(henceforth called the sl model ) to extract the magnetic dipole(m1 ) and electric quadrapole(e2 ) strengths of the @xmath1 transition from the pion photoproduction data . the precise polarization data from legs and mainz were essential in our analysis . in this paper , we report on the progress we have made in extending the sl model to investigate the pion electroproduction reactions in the @xmath8 excitation region . we will make use of the recent data from jlab and mit - bates to explore the q@xmath2-dependence of the @xmath9 transition and make predictions for future experimental tests . the dynamical content of the sl model has been given in detail in ref.@xcite . the essential feature of the model is to have a consistent description of both the @xmath10 scattering and the electromagnetic production of pions . this is achieved by using a unitary transformation method to derive an effective hamiltonian defined in the subspace @xmath11 from the interaction lagrangians for @xmath12 and photon fields . the resulting model has given a fairly successful description of the very extensive data for pion photoproduction . the extension of the sl model to investigate pion electroproduction is straightforward . the formulae needed for calculating the current matrix elements of pion electroproductions are identical to that given in ref.@xcite except that a form factor must be included at each photon vertex . therefore no detailed presentation of our model will be repeated here . similarly , we will not give detailed formulae for calculating the electroproduction cross sections since they are well documented@xcite . the sl model is one of the dynamical models developed @xcite in recent years . compared with other approaches based on the tree - diagrams of effective lagrangians@xcite or dispersion - relations@xcite , the main objective of a dynamical approach is to separate the reaction mechanisms from the excitation of the internal structure of the hadrons involved . within the sl model , this has been achieved by applying the well - established reaction theory within the hamiltonian formulation(see , for example , ref.@xcite ) . in particular , the off - shell non - resonant contributions to the @xmath1 form factors can be calculated explicitly in a dynamical approach . only when such non - resonant contributions are separated , the determined `` bare '' @xmath1 form factors can be compared with the predictions from hadron models . within the sl model , this was explored in detail and provided a dynamical interpretation of the long - standing discrepancy between the empirically determined magnetic m1 strength of the @xmath1 transition and the predictions from constituent quark models . in this work , we further explore this problem utilizing the @xmath6-dependence accessible to electroproduction reactions . furthermore , the coulomb(scalar ) component @xmath13(@xmath14 ) of the @xmath1 form factor will be determined . in section ii , we briefly review the essential ingredients of the sl model and define various form factors which are needed to describe pion electroproduction reactions . with the mainz data@xcite , we have slightly refined our model at the @xmath5 photon point . this will be reported in section iii . the electroproduction results are presented and compared with the data in section iv . in section v , we give a summary and discuss possible future developments . within the sl model , the pion photoproduction and electroproduction reactions are described in terms of photon and hadron degrees of freedom . the starting hamiltonian is @xmath15 with @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the free hamiltonian and @xmath18 describes the absorption and emission of a meson(@xmath19 ) by a baryon(@xmath20 ) . in the sl model , such a hamiltonian is obtained from phenomenological lagrangians for @xmath21 and photon fields . in a more microscopic approach , this hamiltonian can be defined in terms of a hadron model , as attempted , for example , in ref . @xcite . it is a non - trivial many body problem to calculate @xmath10 scattering and @xmath22 reaction amplitudes from the hamiltonian eq . ( [ hamilt ] ) . to obtain a manageable reaction model , a unitary transformation method@xcite is used up to second order in @xmath23 to derive an effective hamiltonian . the essential idea of the employed unitary transformation method is to eliminate the unphysical vertex interactions @xmath24 with @xmath25 from the hamiltonian and absorb their effects into @xmath26 two - body interactions . in the sl model , the resulting effective hamiltonian is defined in a subspace spanned by the @xmath10 , @xmath27 and @xmath8 states and has the following form @xmath28 where @xmath29 is a non - resonant @xmath10 potential , and @xmath30 describes the non - resonant @xmath31 transition . the @xmath8 excitation is described by the vertex interactions @xmath32 for the @xmath33 transition and @xmath34 for the @xmath35 transition . the vertex interaction @xmath36 is illustrated in fig . the non - resonant @xmath30 consists of the usual pseudo - vector born terms , @xmath37 and @xmath38 exchanges , and the crossed @xmath8 term , as illustrated in fig . 2(the non - resonant term due to an intermediate anti-@xmath8 state was found to be very weak and can be neglected ) . most of the dynamical models have the above form of the hamiltonian . however , the sl model has an important feature that the deduced effective hamiltonian @xmath39 is energy independent and hermitian . hence , the unitarity of the resulting reaction amplitudes is trivially satisfied . furthermore , the non - resonant interactions @xmath30 and @xmath29 are derived from the same @xmath23 of eq . ( [ hamilt ] ) , and hence the @xmath10 and @xmath27 reactions can be described consistently . such a consistency is lost if @xmath29 is either constructed purely phenomenologically as done in refs.@xcite or taken from a different theoretical construction as done in refs.@xcite . this consistency is essential in interpreting the extracted @xmath1 form factors since the non - resonant interactions @xmath29 and @xmath30 can dress the @xmath1 vertex . as discussed in refs.@xcite , only the dressed @xmath1 transition can be identified with the data . the importance of the non - resonant effects on the @xmath40 transition is also stressed recently in ref.@xcite . from the effective hamiltonian eq . ( [ hamile ] ) , it is straightforward to derive a set of coupled equations for @xmath10 and @xmath27 reactions . the resulting pion photoproduction amplitude can be written as @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the current operator and @xmath43 is the photon polarization vector . it can be decomposed into two parts @xmath44 the non - resonant amplitude @xmath45 is calculated from @xmath30 by @xmath46 where the @xmath10 free propagator is defined by @xmath47 the amplitude @xmath48 in eq . ( [ tmatg ] ) is calculated from the non - resonant @xmath10 interaction @xmath29 by solving the following equation @xmath49 the dressed vertices in eq . ( [ tmatt ] ) are defined by @xmath50\gamma_{\delta\rightarrow\pi n}. \label{vertp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in eq.([vertg ] ) , we also have defined @xmath51 . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the @xmath8 self - energy in eq . ( [ tmatt ] ) is then calculated from @xmath52 as seen in the above equations , an important consequence of the dynamical model is that the influence of the non - resonant mechanisms on the resonance properties can be identified and calculated explicitly . the resonance position of the amplitude defined by eq . ( [ tmatt ] ) is shifted from the bare mass @xmath53 by the self - energy @xmath54 . the bare vertex @xmath55 is modified by the non - resonant interaction @xmath30 to give the dressed vertex @xmath56 , as defined by eq . ( [ vertg ] ) . in the sl model , it was found that the extracted m1 strength of the bare vertex @xmath57 is very close to the values predicted by the constituent quark models@xcite , while the empirical values given by the particle data group(pdg)@xcite can only be identified with the dressed vertex @xmath58 . the above equations can be solved for arbitrary photon four - momentum @xmath59 . for investigating the electroproduction reactions , we only need to define a form factor at each photon vertex in figs . 1 - 2 . for the non - resonant interactions(fig . 2 ) , we follow the previous work@xcite . the usual electromagnetic nucleon form factors(given explicitly in the appendix a of ref.@xcite ) are used in evaluating the direct and crossed nucleon terms . to make sure that the non - resonant term @xmath30 is gauge invariant , we set @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the form factor for the contact term , @xmath62 is the pion form factor for the pion - exchange term , and @xmath63 is the nucleon isovector form factor(also given explicitly in the appendix a of ref.@xcite ) . the form factors for the vector meson - exchange terms are chosen to be @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the vector meson mass and the coupling constants @xmath66 for @xmath67 are deduced from the @xmath68 decay widths and are given in ref.@xcite . the prescriptions eqs . ( [ formv])-([coupv ] ) have been commonly used in most of the previous investigations such as that in refs.@xcite . undoubtly , this is an unsatisfactory aspect of this work . on the other hand , `` dynamically '' sound progress in solving the gauge invariance problem can not be made unless a microscopic theory of hadron structure is implemented consistently into our model . this is beyond the scope of this work . for the @xmath1 form factors , we extend eq . ( 4.15 ) of ref.@xcite to write in the rest frame of the @xmath8 @xmath69 , \label{vertgd}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath70 , @xmath71 is the photon four - momentum , and @xmath72 is the photon polarization vector . the transition operators @xmath73 and @xmath74 are defined by the reduced matrix element @xmath75 in edmonds convention@xcite . the parameterizations of the form factors @xmath76 , @xmath77 and @xmath78 will be specified in section iv . with the form factors defined in eqs.(12)-(14 ) , both the non - resonant term @xmath30 and the bare vertex @xmath57 are gauge invariant . however the full amplitude defined by eq . ( [ tmatt ] ) involves off - shell @xmath10 scattering , as defined by eqs . ( [ tmatg])-([self ] ) , is not gauge invariant . there exists a simple prescription to eliminate this problem phenomenologically . this amounts to defining the conserved currents for eq.([tj ] ) as @xmath79 where @xmath80 is calculated from our model defined above , and @xmath81 is an arbitrary four vector . it is obvious that the currents @xmath82 defined by eq . ( [ gauj ] ) satisfies the gauge invariance condition @xmath83 . if we use the standard choice of the photon momentum @xmath84 and choose @xmath85 , we then have @xmath86 and @xmath87 the above equations mean that within our approach any @xmath88 observable depending on the z - component of the current is determined by eq . ( [ gau00 ] ) using the time component of the sl model , not by @xmath89 . this is very similar to the prescription used in many nuclear calculations . we find that the data we have considered in this work can be described by the conserved currents @xmath82 defined by eqs . ( [ gau0 ] ) and ( [ gau00 ] ) . we have briefly investigated the model dependence due to the freedom in choosing @xmath81 . we have found that the choice @xmath90 , which leads to @xmath91 and @xmath92 gives very similar results at high @xmath6 . the differences at low @xmath6 also appear to be not so large . all results presented in this paper are from using the choice eqs . ( [ gau0])-([gau00 ] ) . we emphasize that this choice is a phenomenological part of our model , simply because we have not implemented any substructure dynamics of hadrons into our formulation . in fact this is also the case for all existing approaches based on the prescription similar to the form of eq . ( [ gauj ] ) . for example @xmath93 is chosen in the recent work by kamalov and yang@xcite using the dynamical model developed in ref.@xcite . there exist other prescriptions to fix the gauge invariance problem , such as those suggested in refs.@xcite . we have not explored those possibilities , since they are also not related microscopically to the substructure of the hadrons involved , and are as phenomenological as the prescription defined by eqs.(16)-(17 ) . we will return to this problem when our model is further developed , as discussed in section v. for our later discussions on the @xmath1 transition , we define some quantities in terms of more commonly used conventions . as discussed in detail in ref.@xcite , if we replace the @xmath10 propagator @xmath94 in eqs . ( [ tmatt])-([self ] ) by @xmath95 with @xmath96 denoting the principal - value integration , the resulting dressed vertex @xmath97 is real and can be directly compared with the bare vertex @xmath55 . the usual e2/m1 ratio and c2/m1 ratio for the dressed @xmath1 vertex are then defined by @xmath98_{e2 } } { { } [ \bar{\gamma}^{k}_{\gamma n \rightarrow \delta}]_{m1 } } , \label{remg } \\ \rsmeq&=&\frac{[\bar{\gamma}^{k}_{\gamma n \rightarrow \delta}]_{c2 } } { { } [ \bar{\gamma}^{k}_{\gamma n \rightarrow \delta}]_{m1}}. \label{rsmg}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one can also show@xcite that at the resonant energy where the invariant mass @xmath991236 mev and the @xmath10 phase shift in the @xmath100 channel goes through 90 degrees , the multipole components of the dressed vertex @xmath97 are related to the imaginary(@xmath101 ) parts of the @xmath22 multipole amplitudes(as defined in ref.@xcite in the @xmath10 @xmath100 channel @xmath102_{m1}= n \times \mbox{im}(m_{1+}^{3/2 } ) , \label{am}\\ a_{e } & = & [ \bar{\gamma}^k_{\gamma n \rightarrow \delta}]_{e2}= n \times \mbox{im}(e_{1+}^{3/2 } ) , \label{ae}\\ a_{c } & = & [ \bar{\gamma}^k_{\gamma n \rightarrow \delta}]_{c2}= n \times \mbox{im}(s_{1+}^{3/2 } ) , \label{ac } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath103 is a kinematic factor . from the above relations , we obtain a very useful relation that the e2/m1 ratio @xmath104 and c2/m1 ratio @xmath105 of the dressed @xmath1 transition at @xmath106 mev can be evaluated directly by using the @xmath22 multipole amplitudes @xmath107 the formula for calculating the multipole amplitudes and various cross sections from the total amplitudes @xmath108 will not be given here , since they are well documented@xcite . to determine the @xmath1 form factors defined by eq . ( [ vertgd ] ) , it is necessary to first fix their values at @xmath109 by investigating the pion photoproduction reactions . this was done in ref.@xcite by applying the formulation outlined in section ii . the first step was to investigate the @xmath10 scattering from threshold to the @xmath8 excitation region . by fitting the @xmath10 phase shifts , the parameters characterizing the strong interaction vertices except the @xmath110 vertex in fig.2 were determined . the pion photoproduction data were then used to determine @xmath111 and @xmath112 of the @xmath113 transition(eq . ( [ vertgd ] ) ) and the coupling constant @xmath114 of the @xmath110 vertex of fig . 2 . in ref.@xcite we considered previous pion photoproduction data@xcite and the legs data@xcite of photon asymmetry defined by @xmath115 where @xmath116(@xmath117 ) are the cross sections with photons linearly polarized in the direction perpendicular(parallel ) to the reaction plane . to refine our model , we consider the recent mainz data@xcite here . for the photon asymmetry @xmath118 , the data from mainz agree very well with that from legs . the main improvement we have made is from using the mainz differential cross section(@xmath119 ) data which are much more precise than the data@xcite used in ref.@xcite . with the @xmath10 amplitudes calculated from the model - l of ref.@xcite , we find that the mainz data can be best reproduced by setting @xmath120 , @xmath121 , and @xmath122 . these values of @xmath111 and @xmath112 are identical to that determined in ref.@xcite . the @xmath110 coupling constant is also only slightly larger than the value @xmath123 determined there . such a small change in the determined parameters is due to the fact that the previous photoproduction data@xcite are close to the mainz data except that their errors are larger . our results for @xmath124 and @xmath125 reactions are compared with the data in figs . 3 and 4 respectively . clearly the agreement is satisfactory in general . for the @xmath126 production(fig . 3 ) , we also show the dependence of the calculated asymmetry @xmath118 on the e2/m1 ratio of the bare @xmath1 vertex . the value @xmath127 , which corresponds to @xmath120 and @xmath121 , seems to be favored by the data . on the other hand , such a dependence is much less for the @xmath128 production(fig . 4 ) since the non - resonant interactions play a more important role in this channel . there are still some discrepancies with the data . in particular , the differential cross sections at high energies @xmath129 mev are underestimated . this could be due to the neglect of the coupling with higher mass nucleon resonances and two - pion production channels . for the @xmath128 production(fig . 4 ) , the cross sections at low energies are also underestimated slightly . this could be mainly due to the deficiency of our nonresonant amplitude which plays a much more important role in @xmath128 production than in @xmath126 production . possible improvements of our model will be discussed in section iv . the results presented in the rest of this paper are from calculations with @xmath120 and @xmath121 . in fig . 5 , we show that the predicted @xmath130 and @xmath131 amplitudes of the @xmath22 reactions agree very well with the data from the mainz98@xcite and sm95@xcite analyses . by using eqs.([rema])-([rsma ] ) and reading the results at resonant energy @xmath132 mev displayed in fig . 5 , we find that the e2/m1 ratio for the dressed @xmath1 transition is @xmath133 . the dotted curves in fig . 5 are obtained from setting the non - resonant interaction @xmath134 to zero in the calculations . clearly the non - resonant mechanism has a crucial role in determining the electromagnetic excitation of the @xmath8 . at the resonance energy @xmath135 mev the bare @xmath8 amplitude is about 60% of the full amplitude for the m1 transition and almost a half for the e2 transition . as discussed in refs.@xcite , this large difference between the bare @xmath8 and full amplitudes is the source of the discrepancies between the quark model predictions of the @xmath1 transition and the values determined from the empirical amplitude analyses such as those listed by pdg@xcite . in table i , we list our results for the helicity amplitude @xmath136 and e2/m1 ratio of the @xmath1 transition and compare them with the results from other approaches . we see that the dressed e2/m1 values from different approaches are very close . for our model and the model of ref.@xcite , the large differences between the dressed and bare values are evident , indicating the importance of the non - resonant mechanisms in determining the @xmath1 transition . the bare values are clearly close to the quark model predictions . with @xmath111 and @xmath112 determined , we can then investigate the pion electroproduction reactions . with the matrix element @xmath108 calculated by using the formula outlined in section ii , it is straightforward to calculate various observables for pion electroproduction reactions . the needed formulation is well documented ; see , for example , refs.@xcite . we therefore will only give explicit formula which are needed for discussing our results . we first consider the unpolarized differential cross sections of the @xmath137 transition , where @xmath138 denotes the virtual photon . in the usual convention@xcite , it is defined by @xmath139 where various differential cross sections depend on the pion scattering angle @xmath140 , photon momentum - square @xmath141 , and the invariant mass @xmath142 of the final @xmath10 system . @xmath143 is the off - plane scattering angle between the @xmath144 plane and the @xmath145 plane . the dependence of eq.(26 ) on the angle @xmath146 between the outgoing and incoming electrons is in the parameter @xmath147^{-1}$ ] . recalling eq.(2.14 ) of ref.@xcite , we note here that the transverse cross section @xmath148 and polarization cross section @xmath149 are only determined by the transverse currents @xmath150 and @xmath151 and the longitudinal cross section @xmath152 only by the longitudinal current @xmath153 . on the other hand , the interference cross section @xmath154 is determined by the real part of the product @xmath155 . in general , the contributions from the longitudinal current are much weaker than that from the transverse currents . thus the longitudinal current can be more effectively studied by investigating the observables which are sensitive to @xmath154 . this has been achieved in the recent experiments at mit - bates and jlab by utilizing the @xmath156-dependence in eq . ( [ crse ] ) . to proceed , we need to define the strength of the charge form factor at @xmath109 . first we use the low momentum limit to set @xmath157 . with @xmath158 determined in section iii , we thus have @xmath159 . next we consider the jlab @xmath160 data@xcite at @xmath161 , 4 ( gev / c)@xmath2 . since the data are extensive enough , we are able to extract each @xmath162dependent term in eq . ( [ crse ] ) . we then adjust @xmath163 and @xmath164 to fit the data of these extracted components . our best fits are the solid curves shown in fig . we also show that the interference cross section @xmath165(which is determined by @xmath166 ) is sensitive to the charge form factor @xmath167 of the bare @xmath9 vertex . in figs . 7 and 8 , we show the comparison with the original data at several off - plane - angle @xmath156 . clearly the agreement is satisfactory . similar good agreement with the data at different w are also found . some typical results are shown in fig.9 for w=1115 , 1145 , 1175 , 1205 mev . we follow refs.@xcite to fit the determined form factor values at @xmath5 , 2.8 and 4 ( gev / c)@xmath2 with the following simple parameterization @xmath168 with @xmath169 and @xmath170 is the usual proton form factor . we find that our results can be fitted by choosing @xmath171 with @xmath172 and @xmath173 ( gev / c)@xmath2 for @xmath174 and @xmath175 . the unpolarized cross section data are less sensitive to @xmath176 . nevertheless , the allowed @xmath177 values at @xmath5 , 2.8 and 4 ( gev / c)@xmath2 seem to also follow eq.([frme ] ) . for simplicity , we use eq.([frme ] ) for @xmath178 and @xmath175 in all of the calculations presented below . this simple parameterization is similar to that used in ref.@xcite . ( [ frmd ] ) then allows us to make predictions for other values of @xmath6 . note that with @xmath172 and @xmath173 ( gev / c)@xmath2 , the @xmath6-dependence due to @xmath179 is very small compared with the dipole form factor @xmath180 in eq.([frmdip ] ) . to further explore the @xmath8 excitation within our model , we show in fig . 10 the @xmath6-dependence of the predicted @xmath137 multipole amplitudes @xmath181 , @xmath182 and @xmath183 at @xmath106 mev where the @xmath10 phase shift in @xmath100 channel reaches @xmath184 . hence , their real parts are negligibly small and are omitted in fig.10 . these amplitudes are proportional to the dressed @xmath1 transition strengths @xmath185 , @xmath186 and @xmath187 , as defined by eqs . ( [ am])-([ac ] ) . we also show the results(dotted curves ) from neglecting the non - resonant interaction @xmath30 in the calculations . it is interesting to note from fig . 10 that the non - resonant interaction @xmath30 enhances strongly these amplitudes at low @xmath6 , but much less at high @xmath6 . from the results(solid curves ) shown in fig . 10 and eqs . ( [ rema ] ) and ( [ rsma ] ) , we obtain the the @xmath6-dependence of the e2/m1 ratio and c2/m1 ratio for the dressed @xmath1 transition . the results are shown in fig . 11 and table ii . we see that drops significantly with @xmath6 and reaches @xmath188 at @xmath189 ( gev / c)@xmath2 , while remains @xmath190 in the entire considered @xmath6 region . this difference reflects an non - trivial consequence of our dynamical treatment of the non - resonant interaction , as seen in eq.(9 ) . it will be interesting to test our predictions in the entire @xmath6 region . clearly , the q@xmath191 ( gev / c)@xmath2 region is still far away from the perturbative qcd region where is expected to approach unity @xcite . the dressed @xmath1 vertex defined by eq . ( [ vertg ] ) can be cast into the form of eq . ( [ vertgd ] ) at the resonance energy @xmath106 mev . this allows us to extract the dressed m1 form factor @xmath192 from our results and compare it with the bare form factor @xmath193 of eq . ( [ vertgd ] ) . this is shown in fig . 12 where we measure their @xmath6-dependence against the proton dipole form factor @xmath180 defined in eq.([frmdip ] ) . we see that both bare and dressed m1 form factors drop faster than the proton form factor . the difference between the solid and dotted curves is due to the non - resonant term(see eq . ( [ vertg ] ) ) which can be interpreted as the effect due to the pion cloud around the bare quark core . this meson cloud effect accounts for about 40 @xmath3 of the dressed form factor at @xmath5 , but becomes much weaker at high @xmath6 . this implies that the future data at higher q@xmath2 will be more effective in exploring the structure of the bare quark core which can be identified with the current hadron models , as discussed in ref.@xcite . with the @xmath1 form factors given by eqs . ( [ frmd])-([frme ] ) , we then can test our model by comparing our predictions with the data at other values of @xmath6 . we first consider the mit - bates data@xcite at @xmath194 ( gev / c)@xmath2 . in fig . 13 , we show the results(solid curves ) for @xmath195 which is defined as(see eq.(26 ) ) @xmath196 in the same figure , we also show the results(dotted curves ) from setting @xmath197 for the bare @xmath198 vertex(eq . ( [ vertgd ] ) ) . the differences between the solid and dotted curves indicate the accuracy needed to extract these two quantities of the bare @xmath1 transition within our model . clearly , our predictions are close to the data at @xmath199 , 1.232 gev . the result at @xmath991.292 gev appears to disagree with the data . however our model is expected to be insufficient at this higher energy , as already seen in the results figs . 3 - 4 for photoproduction . it is necessary to extend our model to include additional reaction mechanisms such as the @xmath200 transition and higher mass nucleon resonances . in fig . 14 , we compare our results(solid curve ) with the data for @xmath201_{\theta_\pi=180 ^ 0 } , \label{rtt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath202 and @xmath203 are the momenta for the pion and photon in the @xmath10 center of mass frame . in the same figure , we also show the results(dotted curve ) obtained from neglecting the nonresonant interaction @xmath30 which renormalizes the @xmath1 vertex and generate non - resonant amplitude @xmath204 , as seen in eqs . ( [ tmatt ] ) , ( [ tmatg ] ) and ( [ vertg ] ) . the importance of the non - resonant interaction is evident . our predictions reproduce the position of the @xmath8 peak which is shifted significantly by the non - resonant interaction , but underestimate the magnitude at the peak by about 15 @xmath3 . in fig . 15 , we present our results for the the induced proton polarization @xmath205 for @xmath206 and the polarization vector @xmath207 perpendicular to the momentum of the recoiled proton . the data at @xmath991232 mev is also from the measurement at mit - bates . our model clearly only agrees with the data in sign , but not in magnitude . more experimental data for this observable are needed to test the energy - dependence of our predictions . the results shown in figs . 13 - 15 are from the calculations using the @xmath8 form factors given by eqs . ( [ frmd])-([frme ] ) and fitted to the data at @xmath208 0 , 2.8 , 4.0 ( gev / c)@xmath2 . the chosen parameterization is rather arbitrary and there is no strong reason to believe it should give reliable predictions for the @xmath8 form factors at the considered @xmath194 ( gev / c)@xmath2 . we therefore have explored whether the discrepancies seen in figs . 13 - 15 can be removed by adjusting @xmath163 and @xmath164 for the bare @xmath1 transition . it turns out that we are not able to improve our results . it is necessary to also modify the nonresonant amplitude @xmath45 . we will discuss possible improvements in the next section . in fig . 16 , we compare our predictions with some of the bonn data@xcite at @xmath209 , 0.75 gev / c@xmath2 . our predictions are in good agreement with these data , but these data have large errors . the new high - accuracy data@xcite from jlab in this @xmath6 region will give a more critical test of our predictions . for the forthcoming inclusive @xmath210 data from nikhef , we also have made the predictions at q@xmath2=0.11 ( gev / c)@xmath2 for two polarization observables @xmath211 and @xmath212 which are clearly defined by eqs . ( 2.25b ) and ( 2.25c ) of ref.@xcite . our predictions(solid curves ) are given in fig . the dotted curves are from setting the @xmath137 multipole amplitudes @xmath213 and @xmath214 to zero . this gives an estimate of the required experimental accuracy in using the forthcoming data of @xmath211 and @xmath212 to extract these two amplitudes which contain information about @xmath176 and @xmath167 of the @xmath1 transition . in this work , we have extended the dynamical model developed in ref.@xcite to investigate th pion electroproduction reactions . the model is first refined at the @xmath5 photon point by taking into account the recent pion photoproduction data from mainz@xcite . it is found that the extracted m1 strength @xmath120 and e2 strength @xmath121 of the bare @xmath1 vertex are identical to that determined in ref.@xcite . by using the long wave length limit , we then obtain @xmath215 for the charge form factor of the bare @xmath1 transition . for the investigation of pion electroproduction , we follow the previous work to define the form factor at each photon vertex in the non - resonant interaction @xmath30 illustrated in fig . 2 . at each value of @xmath6 , the @xmath1 transition strengths @xmath193 , @xmath177 and @xmath164 are the only free parameters in our calculations . we find that the recent @xmath160 data at @xmath208 2.8 , 4 ( gev / c)@xmath2 from jlab@xcite , and at @xmath194 ( gev / c)@xmath2 from mit - bates@xcite can be described to a very large extent if the bare @xmath1 form factors defined by eqs . ( [ frmd])-([frme ] ) are used in the calculations . it is found that the remaining discrepancies can not be resolved by only adjusting these @xmath8 form factors . we focus on the investigation of the @xmath6-dependence of the @xmath8 excitation mechanism . it is found that the non - resonant interactions can dress the @xmath1 vertex to enhance strongly its strength at low @xmath6 , but much less at high @xmath6(fig . the determined c2/m1 ratio ( ) drops significantly with @xmath6 and reaches @xmath188 at @xmath189 ( gev / c)@xmath2 , while the e2/m1 ratio ( ) remains at @xmath4 of the value at the @xmath5 photon point(fig . 11 and table ii ) . the determined m1 form factor drops faster than the usual dipole form factor of the proton(fig . this is in agreement with the previous findings@xcite . to end , we turn to discussing possible future developments within our formulation . the model we developed in ref.@xcite and applied in this work is defined by the effective hamiltonian eq . ( [ hamile ] ) . it is derived from using a unitary transformation method up to second order in the vertex interaction @xmath23(eq . ( [ hamili ] ) ) . we further assume that the @xmath10 and @xmath27 reactions can be described within a subspace @xmath216 . from the point of view of the general hamiltonian eqs . ( [ hamilt])-([hamili ] ) , which can be identified@xcite with a hadron model , our model is clearly just a starting model . for this reason , no attempt is made here to adjust the parameters of the non - resonant interaction @xmath30 to perform a @xmath217fit to the electroproduction data . to resolve the remaining discrepancies between our predictions and the data , it is necessary to improve our model in several directions . to improve our results in the higher energy region(figs . 3 - 4,13 ) , we need to include the coupling with other reaction channels . an obvious step is to extend the effective hamiltonian eq . ( [ hamile ] ) to include the transitions to @xmath218 , @xmath219 and @xmath220 states and to include some higher mass @xmath7 states . the resulting scattering equations will be more complex than what are given in ref.@xcite and outlined in eqs . ( [ tmatt])-([self ] ) . in particular , it will have the @xmath221 cut structure due to the @xmath222 decay in the @xmath219 channel and the @xmath223 decay in the @xmath220 channel . this @xmath221 cut must be treated exactly in any attempt to explore the structure of @xmath7 resonances . this was well recognized in the early investigations@xcite and must be pursued in a dynamical approach . the second necessary improvement is to use more realistic form factors in defining the photon vertices of non - resonant interaction @xmath30 . the prescription eq . ( [ formv ] ) must be relaxed . in particular we should use a form factor @xmath224 predicted from a calculation which accounts for the off - mass - shell properties of the exchange pion in fig . 2 . similarly , the vector meson form factor @xmath66(eq . ( [ coupv ] ) ) must also be improved since the exchanged vector meson is also off its mass - shell . the improvement in this direction could be possible in the near future , since the calculations for such off - mass - shell form factors can now be performed within some qcd models of light mesons@xcite . c. mertz et al.,to be published ; + t. botto and c. papanicolas , proceedings of 16th international conference on few - body problems in physics , 6 - 10 march , 1999 , taipei , taiwan , to be published ; + a.m. bernstein , seventh conference on the intersection between particle and nuclear physics , cinanp 2000 , quebec , canada , to be published . .helicity amplitude @xmath136 and e2/m1 ratio for the @xmath1 transition at @xmath5 photon point . @xmath136 is in unit of @xmath225 and in % . the references are : a(this work ) , b(@xcite ) , c(@xcite ) , d(@xcite ) , e(@xcite ) , f(@xcite ) , g(@xcite ) . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^ , < " , ]

the dynamical model developed in [ phys . rev . c * 54 * , 2660 ( 1996 ) ] has been applied to investigate the pion electroproduction reactions on the nucleon . it is found that the model can describe to a very large extent the recent data of @xmath0 reaction from jefferson laboratory and mit - bates . the extracted magnetic dipole(m1 ) , electric dipole(e2 ) , and coulomb(c2 ) strengths of the @xmath1 transition are presented . it is found that the c2/m1 ratio drops significantly with q@xmath2 and reaches about -13@xmath3 at q@xmath2=4 ( gev / c)@xmath2 , while the e2/m1 ratio remains close to the value @xmath4 at the @xmath5 photon point . the determined m1 transition form factor drops faster than the usual dipole form factor of the proton . we also find that the non - resonant interactions can dress the @xmath1 vertex to enhance strongly its strength at low @xmath6 , but much less at high @xmath6 . predictions are presented for future experimental tests . possible developments of the model are discussed .

0810.4983

in a remarkable series of experiments in the nineties , sophisticated cooling techniques were used to expose the quantum nature of ultracold dilute gases . for bosons , the realization of bose - einstein condensation ( bec ) in 1995 @xcite revealed the importance of the underlying aggregating statistics for the existence of a broken symmetry phase in weakly interacting systems . for fermions , the statistics has just the opposite effect . due to the pauli exclusion principle , low energy collisions of fermionic particles are strongly suppressed , worsening the thermalization between the atoms and , therefore , making the cooling techniques more involved . nevertheless , a few years later another milestone experiment was realized in which a quantum degenerate fermi gas was observed @xcite . since then , research with both types of degenerate quantum gases has experienced a strong growth , and different trends have been pursued , each showing interesting and relevant connections to other fields of physics such as atomic , molecular and condensed matter physics . rotating quantum gases constitute one of these fast growing areas . in the case of bosons in a harmonic trap , intensive investigations have been carried out , both theoretically @xcite and experimentally @xcite . if the rotation frequency @xmath1 is of the order of ( but smaller than ) the radial trapping frequency @xmath2 , i.e. @xmath3 , the rotation is called slow . in this regime , intrinsic properties of rotating systems like the temperature dependence of the moment of inertia @xcite , rotation induced excitations @xcite , and the formation of vortices @xcite have been considered . if one rotates faster , vortex arrays are created @xcite where small - amplitude oscillations , so called tkachenko modes , have been observed @xcite and theoretically investigated @xcite . in addition , fast rotating ( @xmath4 ) becs have been linked to fascinating many - body phenomena such as the integer quantum hall effect @xcite or its fractional version @xcite , and are suspected to display quantum phase transitions to non superfluid strongly correlated states @xcite . in the fast rotation regime , experiments in harmonic traps are limited by the loss of confinement due to centrifugal forces when the rotation frequency approaches the axial harmonic trapping frequency . to overcome this problem , a. l. fetter suggested adding a quartic term to the trap potential @xcite . the successful experimental implementation of such a quartic term was carried out in the group of j. dalibard in paris @xcite . in their set - up a laser is used to stir the quartically trapped condensates , making possible the exploration of many properties of the system such as , for instance , the vortex distribution , the optical density @xcite , and the shape oscillations @xcite . the experimental realization triggered further theoretical research focusing on bose - einstein condensates ( bec ) . for instance , their collective oscillations @xcite , thermodynamical @xcite and dynamical @xcite properties have been considered in the presence of the quartic term . thus , the question arises , what new features come about through the interplay between rotation and fermionic statistics . in a harmonic trap , some properties have already been investigated . for instance , the moment of inertia and its relation to quadrupole oscillations , in a framework valid for bosons and fermions @xcite , and the collective excitations @xcite have been studied . in the superfluid phase , formation of vortices @xcite has been observed and a rotation - induced phase separation has been proposed @xcite . in addition , the influence of the landau levels on the density profiles of two - dimensional polarized fermions in the context of the integer quantum hall effect @xcite and the experimental feasibility of fractional quantum hall states @xcite have also been theoretically considered . in the case of an anharmonic trap , apart from studying the breathing mode in the bardeen - cooper - schrieffer ( bcs)-bec crossover regime @xcite , fermions have not been considered and most of the interesting aspects of the physics of rotating systems remain restricted to pure harmonic confinement . at low temperatures , polarized atomic fermi gases are essentially non - interacting due to pauli blocking and the fact that p - wave interactions are negligible in such systems . however , due to the fermi pressure , particles tend to avoid the center of the trap , so that , effectively , a statistical interaction arises even in the case of an ideal gas , which bears some analogies with repulsively interacting bosons @xcite . in this work we are concerned with rotating ideal fermi gases of spin polarized particles rotating with frequency @xmath1 . we consider the same trap configuration as in the paris experiment , which will be described in detail in section [ sec:2 ] . in section [ sec:3 ] we outline a general approach to formally justify the semiclassical approximation for calculating the density of states in anharmonic traps . furthermore , we apply this technique to the paris trap and see that a treatment within the semiclassical approximation is justified . in section [ sec:4 ] we consider ground - state properties of such a system in a similar semiclassical approach . we start by evaluating the fermi energy for arbitrary rotation , then we obtain the particle density , the momentum distribution , and free expansion time - of - flight absorption pictures . in section [ sec:5 ] temperature effects are considered and we derive expressions for the grand - canonical thermodynamic properties in terms of incomplete fermi functions . in addition we analyze analytic low- and high - temperature expansions . for the latter , a virial theorem approach is also presented . section [ sec:6 ] discusses the main results of this work emphasizing the effects of rotation and anharmonicity in comparison to a non - rotating harmonic trap and presents an outlook for the field . in the following we consider a trap potential which is anharmonic and consists of harmonic axially symmetric magnetic trapping supplemented by an additional gaussian trapping term in the @xmath5-plane . the gaussian laser beam is approximated by its fourth order taylor series @xmath6 where @xmath7 and @xmath8 are the laser intensity and width , respectively . the radial distance to the origin is denoted by @xmath9 . the first term in is just a shift in the energy scale and will be neglected in the following . the second order term will be absorbed into the harmonic trapping term . the last term is the one responsible for the quartic confinement and is characterized by the anharmonicity constant @xmath10 . it is important to notice that the harmonic trapping in the @xmath11-direction is not affected by the gaussian laser potential and is characterized by its harmonic oscillator frequency @xmath12 . an issue in the field of rotating quantum gases is that the rotation frequency , with which the condensate effectively rotates , might be different from the one of the stirring laser , due to changes in the shape dependent rotation properties of the gas such as the moment of inertia @xcite . we neglect these effects and assume that a stirring laser can adiabatically add angular momentum to the particles , so that the gas rotates with frequency @xmath1 , yielding an additional centrifugal harmonic term to the trap potential in the co - rotating frame @xcite . under these considerations , the rotating anharmonic potential takes the form @xcite @xmath13 where @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the axial harmonic energy and length scales , respectively , @xmath16 denotes the anisotropy of the trap , @xmath17 represents the anharmonicity of the trap , and @xmath18 is the mass of the atomic species under consideration . the rotation is taken into account with the parameter @xmath19 . adopting the values given for the paris experiment @xcite , the resulting rotating trap is then described by the radial harmonic trapping frequency @xmath20 , the axial harmonic trapping frequency @xmath21 , the force constant @xmath22 of the quartic trapping term , the anisotropy @xmath23 , and a tunable rotation frequency @xmath1 induced by the stirring laser . in the paris experiment , a bec was obtained with the bosonic isotope @xmath24 , for which the dimensionless anharmonicity takes the value @xmath25 . since fermionic species like @xmath26 and @xmath27 have been sympathetic cooled by using the bosonic atoms @xmath24 @xcite and @xmath28 @xcite , respectively , we consider them likely candidates for experiments with ultracold degenerate fermi gases in the paris trap . for definiteness , we evaluate all results of this paper for the parameters of the trap of the paris experiment and the @xmath26 species , for which we have @xmath29 ( see table [ tab:1 ] ) . let us discuss the trap potential and some of its peculiarities concerning rotation . for the moment , we restrict ourselves to the @xmath5-plane . as depicted in fig . [ fig:1 ] , for slow rotations , i.e. @xmath30 , the minimum of the potential is located at the origin . rotating faster one eventually reaches the point where the harmonic confinement vanishes ( @xmath31 ) and the trap is purely quartic . hereafter this will be called critical rotation . if the rotation is made even faster , one achieves the supercritical regime , where the harmonic confinement becomes centrifugal and the trap minimum is moved to @xmath32 and , with respect to the origin , has a depth given by @xmath33 which naturally characterizes the anharmonic trap . the lowest available potential energy is , thus , @xmath34 , in the supercritical case . , for the parameters given at table [ tab:1 ] at both sub- and supercritical rotations . for the latter , a minimum at @xmath35 appears due to the centrifugal nature of the harmonic term.[fig:1],width=288 ] llllll @xmath36 ( hz ) & @xmath37 ( hz ) & @xmath38 & @xmath39 ( jm@xmath40 ) & @xmath41 & @xmath42 + @xmath43 & @xmath44 & @xmath45 & @xmath46 & @xmath47 & @xmath48 + in this section we briefly discuss the meaning and the implementation of the semiclassical approximation for a system of particles possessing one - body hamiltonian @xmath49 with the eigenvalue equation @xmath50 where @xmath51 and @xmath52 denote the @xmath53-th single - particle eigenstate and eigenvalue , respectively . in view of studying the various thermodynamic properties of the system , one is usually interested in evaluating sums of the form @xmath54 where @xmath55 is some function of the single - particle energy levels . the semiclassical approximation consists in considering the energy levels so close to one another that the sum over them can be taken as an integral over a phase space density : @xmath56 to this end we define the density of states @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the dirac delta distribution . in the following we investigate for the parameters of the table [ tab:1 ] whether it is justified to approximate the density of states semiclassically according to @xmath59,\label{eq : g-1b}\ ] ] where @xmath60 denotes the single - particle classical hamiltonian . in systems where the exact energy spectrum is known , e.g. a harmonic trap , the validity of this approximation can be determined by comparing and . however , in the case that the energy spectrum is unknown , as for the present anharmonic potential , we must take a different approach to justify the semiclassical approximation . to this end , we determine not only the leading semiclassical approximation @xmath61 , but also its subleading correction @xmath62 . after setting the relevant energy scale of the system , the validity of the semiclassical approximation can be determined by the _ relative _ magnitude of the correction . we first treat the general case and , then , specialize to the anharmonic trap of the paris experiment . to obtain the semiclassical expansion of the density of states of the anharmonic potential , we follow the general procedure worked out in ref . @xcite , which derives the density of states in form of a gradient expansion @xmath63 the first term corresponds to the semiclassical approximation @xmath61 in , which yields after integration over the momenta @xmath64\dfrac{\left[e - v({\bf x})\right]^{\frac{d}{2}-1}}{\gamma(d/2)}.\label{eq : approx}\ ] ] the second term is the subleading correction to the density of states @xmath65^{\frac{d}{2}}\dfrac{1}{\gamma(d/2 - 2)}\nonumber\\ & & \times\int d^{d}x\,\theta\left[e - v({\bf x})\right]\nabla^{2}v({\bf x})\left[e - v({\bf x})\right]^{\frac{d}{2}-3}.\nonumber\\ \label{eq : g1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we note that , for the physically relevant dimension @xmath66 , the spatial integral diverges due to the behavior of the term @xmath67^{\frac{d}{2}-3}$ ] at the classical turning points . this problem can be solved through the method of analytic continuation as demonstrated later by applying to the anharmonic potential . it remains to determine the energy scales for which the semiclassical approach is supposed to be valid . at high enough temperatures , the particles are classical . when the temperature is gradually lowered , or other parameters are changed , classical statistical mechanics is no longer exact . at first , a semiclassical approach may work , but for certain conditions it may completely fail . the temperature , particle number , and trap potential parameter scales in which the semiclassical approximation is valid depend on the underlying statistics . for bosons in the gas phase , the thermal distribution is characterized by the thermal energy @xmath68 . if this energy is sufficiently larger than the the energy of the single - particle ground - state , the leading semiclassical approximation is valid . at the bec critical temperature @xmath69 , however , the ground - state occupancy becomes macroscopic . this effect must be treated outside of semiclassics because it corresponds to a broken symmetry state associated to the divergence of the bose distribution @xmath70 for @xmath71 . we will see explicitly in the case of the anharmonic oscillator that the subleading correction is not negligible for energies near the ground - state energy . the thermal energy at the critical temperature is thus the relevant energy scale for determining the validity of this approach . for fermions the considerations are slightly different . due to the pauli exclusion principle , as @xmath72 the particles in the system do not all drop to the ground - state but rather fill every energy level up to the fermi energy @xmath73 , which is defined as the energy of the highest occupied state . as the density of states @xmath74 typically increases with a power of @xmath75 , the majority of particles in the system will have energies much larger than the ground - state value and their average energy is of order @xmath73 , even at @xmath76 , provided @xmath42 is large . therefore , in principle , a spin - polarized fermi gas can be well described at all temperatures in the semiclassical approximation provided the particle number is large enough . the relevant energy determining the validity of this assertion is simply the fermi energy @xmath73 . numerical calculations indicate that this is indeed the case @xcite . to consider the anharmonic potential , we must first determine explicitly the leading and subleading terms of the semiclassical density of states . we can , then , apply the leading term to calculate the fermi energy , and with this result return to verify the a priori assumption of the validity of the approximation . the form of the semiclassical density of states in the anharmonic potential can be found from . performing the spatial integral we obtain the result @xmath77 where it is meant in this and other equations , that the function takes on nonzero values for @xmath78 only for super - critical rotations . the density of states for the parameters of the anharmonic trap described in table [ tab:1 ] is shown at several rotation frequencies @xmath1 in fig . [ fig:2 ] . for subcritical rotations , the density of states vanishes for @xmath78 . for supercritical rotations , the density of states is nonzero also for @xmath79 , due to the dip in the potential . for the anisotropy and the anharmonicity of the trap . the solid lines are from bottom to top at rotations of @xmath80 to @xmath81 in steps of @xmath82 . the dashed line is the density of states at the critical rotation @xmath83.[fig:2 ] ] there are two important limiting cases which shed some light on the behavior of the system . the first one is the harmonic limit @xmath84 , for which we have from @xmath85 which corresponds to the known result @xcite . note that the harmonic limit is valid only for subcritical rotations ; for supercritical rotations the density of states becomes negative corresponding to an instability due to the fact that particles escape the trap . the second physically important case is the pure quartic limit in radial confinement . it is realized by either @xmath86 , i.e. a critical rotation , or @xmath87 , so that the density of states takes the form @xmath88 examining and , we see that the rotation parameter @xmath89 appears in the density of states only in ratios to the anharmonicity parameter @xmath90 . for supercritical rotations , we will find that there is a symmetry between the range of rotations , @xmath91 ( @xmath92 ) to @xmath86 ( critical rotation ) , and the range of anharmonicities from small @xmath90 to @xmath93 . the supercritical properties of the system can thus be seen as an interpolation between the harmonic limit and the pure quartic limit . we now calculate the subleading semiclassical approximation @xmath62 as given in for the particular case of the anharmonic potential . a direct integration in for @xmath66 yields a divergent result . however , we can rewrite the spatial integral in terms of the beta function @xmath94 for which in ref . @xcite provides the identity @xmath95 thus , the formally divergent integrals can be treated as finite based on the analytic continuation of the gamma function through the relationship @xmath96 . to evaluate the integral we need the laplacian of the anharmonic potential , which reads : @xmath97 with this and the full potential given in , we obtain from the first correction to the semiclassical density of states : @xmath98 where , again , the lower line is valid only for supercritical rotations . to determine the effects of the trap parameters on the relevance of the correction term , we examine the ratio @xmath99 . we first see that it is in general reduced in both the sub- and supercritical regimes as @xmath100 increases . likewise , the importance of the correction term decreases as the anharmonicity @xmath90 decreases . as the correction is largest for low energies , the most interesting case for supercritical rotations is when @xmath78 , where we have @xmath101^{2 } , \;\;\;\;-\delta e < e<0.\label{eq : correction - ratio}\ ] ] from we see that for a fixed @xmath102 , the relevance of the correction increases linearly with the rotation parameter @xmath89 . furthermore , we see that the correction diverges as @xmath103 . however , this divergence is only of the form @xmath104 , and so any interesting integral of the form over the density of states will still have a finite contribution from this correction , provided @xmath105 is not itself divergent . for bose systems , @xmath105 contains a factor of @xmath106^{-1}$ ] . the phase transition to bose - einstein condensation happens as @xmath107 , where @xmath108 is the lowest energy eigenvalue . thus , in the condensate phase , an integral of the form has an improper lower limit for @xmath105 blows up as @xmath109 , since it is the lowest available energy . this problem can be overcome by dividing the gas explicitly into a condensate plus thermal particles . we can now check the validity of the semiclassical approximation in the case of the anharmonic trap . both the leading and the subleading term are plotted in fig . [ fig:3 ] for the parameters of table [ tab:1 ] , where we see that even for supercritical rotations the subleading correction becomes negligible on energy scales of more than a few @xmath110 . in the following section we determine the fermi energy @xmath73 of the system , from which we will see that , for the chosen parameters , the difference between @xmath73 and the minimum potential is orders of magnitude larger than @xmath110 . with this , we justify the semiclassical approximation to the density of states . . [ fig:3],width=302 ] though not fully accessible from the experimental point of view , the ground - state and its properties are crucial for understanding the system . the fermi energy , e.g. , carries information about aspects like dimensionality , trap geometry , and particle number and , thus , providing information necessary to handle important physical issues . in this section , we consider some properties of the ground - state like the dependence of the fermi energy on the particle number , the ground - state energy , the spatial and momentum distribution and , lastly , the ballistic expansion of the system . the fermi distribution is given by @xmath111 where @xmath112 is the chemical potential and @xmath113 with @xmath114 the boltzmann constant and @xmath115 the temperature of the system . at @xmath76 , i.e. , @xmath116 , the fermi distribution becomes a step function at the fermi energy , which is defined as the chemical potential at @xmath76 : @xmath117 the ground - state particle number is therefore given by @xmath118 evaluating this integral with the semiclassical density of states from yields @xmath119 \label{eq : n-1a}\ ] ] for the first case , in which one has @xmath120 . for the second case , in which @xmath121 , the particle number is given by @xmath122 the inverse of ( [ eq : n-1a]-[eq : n-1b ] ) determines the fermi energy as a function of the trap parameters and the particle number . in the harmonic @xcite and pure quartic limits we have @xmath123 respectively . we note that the fermi temperature @xmath124 is of the same order of magnitude as the critical temperature for non - interacting bose - einstein condensates in the quartic regime @xcite @xmath125^{\frac{2}{5 } } , \label{eq : eflimiting_bec}\ ] ] with @xmath126 . it should be pointed out that negative fermi energies are allowed by ( [ eq : n-1a]-[eq : n-1b ] ) for supercritical rotations , in which case the gas is confined entirely to the dip in the potential , creating a hole in the center of the trap analogous to the one found in two - dimensional becs @xcite . in this interesting regime ( @xmath121 ) we see that the fermi energy also takes on a simple analytic form , @xmath127 where the superscript do stands for donut , in reference to the shape that the gas assumes when all the particles are in this energy interval , as discussed below . notice that in the ` donut ' regime , for a fixed particle number the fermi energy is set a distance above the trap minimum that is independent of the rotation frequency , but is directly related to the anharmonicity and to the number of particles . we now have three cases where the fermi energy takes a simple analytic form corresponding to the three interesting rotation regimes : the harmonic limit for subcritical rotations , the pure quartic limit for critical rotations , and the ` donut ' regime for supercritical rotations . although we can not obtain from ( [ eq : n-1a]-[eq : n-1b ] ) a general explicit expression for the fermi energy , we can determine its behavior from these special cases . in fig . [ fig:4 ] we see that for low @xmath73 , the general supercritical behavior approaches the harmonic oscillator behavior . as rotation increases to the critical value , the curves approach the pure quartic limit . as the rotation becomes supercritical , the curves are offset to more negative energies and the ` donut ' regime eventually sets up . in fig . [ fig:4 ] we also see that for any fermi energy possible , the quantum correction term to the semiclassical approximation is negligible , thus justifying our a priori use of the semiclassical approximation . in the following we use the fermi energy at zero rotation as a convenient energy scale . for our parameters it is@xmath128 the fermi temperature @xmath129 at zero rotation provides a corresponding temperature scale , @xmath130 the total internal energy of the system in the ground - state is given by @xmath131 evaluating this integral with the density of states from yields @xmath132\\ w(e_{f } ) \end{cases } \label{eq : u-1}\ ] ] with the remark that the upper line is valid for @xmath120 and the lower one for @xmath133 and the abbreviation @xmath134 in the harmonic and purely quartic limits , respectively , the internal energy it is related to the particle number and fermi energy by @xmath135 there is also a simple relation in the ` donut ' regime , @xmath136 we see in fig . [ fig:5 ] that the internal energy for subcritical rotations is bounded by the @xmath84 harmonic oscillator limit and the @xmath93 pure quartic limit . this is due to the symmetry between the anharmonicity and the rotation , which causes the latter to enhance the former . for fixed @xmath42 and the parameters of table [ tab:1 ] . the dashed horizontal line is the harmonic limit and the dot - dashed horizontal line is the quartic limit . the vertical lines indicate the critical rotation ( @xmath137 ) and the start of the ` donut ' regime , where @xmath138.[fig:5],width=302 ] to obtain the particle density and the momentum distribution in the semiclassical approximation , we start from the wigner function @xcite in the semiclassical approximation @xmath139\ } } , \label{wig_func}\ ] ] which delivers the particle density through @xmath140 and the momentum distribution through @xmath141 at @xmath76 the wigner function becomes a heaviside theta function and is given by @xmath142 . \label{wig_func_zerot}\ ] ] in this limit , both the particle density and the momentum distribution assume a well - defined shape . the particle density is given for a general velocity independent potential @xmath143 by @xmath144^{\frac{3}{2}}}{3\pi^{2}a_{z}^{3}\epsilon_{z}^{\frac{3}{2}}}\theta\left[e_{f}-v({\bf x})\right].\label{eq : config - dist-1}\ ] ] from , we see that a given rotation @xmath145 , at which the hole in the trap center appears , the system looks like a ` donut ' , so to speak . the value of @xmath145 can , therefore , be determined from by setting @xmath146 and yields @xmath147 in an effectively two - dimensional ( uniform over an axial length @xmath148 ) , interacting bec trapped by the radial components of the anharmonic potential , rotation can lead as well to a hole in the center of the trap @xcite , where , in the thomas - fermi approximation , a similar analytic expression can be written down : @xmath149 where @xmath150 denotes the s - wave scattering length . in the case of non - interacting bosons , @xmath151 coincides with @xmath152 , but this is not true for fermions , where an effective interaction arises from the fermi statistics and @xmath145 does not equal @xmath2 even in the absence of interactions . a discussion of this pauli `` pseudopotential '' in the case of harmonically trapped fermi gases is provided by ref . the value of @xmath145 could also be obtained from the length scales @xmath153 set up by the fermi energy , describing the extent of the gas in space , @xmath154\right|_{x_{i}=r_{i}^{\rm tf}}=0 , \label{eq : fermir-1}\ ] ] where @xmath155 range over @xmath156 . these length scales describe the maximum extent of the coordinate space distributions at @xmath76 and are called the thomas - fermi radii @xmath157 . for the anharmonic potential , they are given by @xmath158 } , \label{eq : r - tf}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the positive root @xmath159 gives the outer radius of the distribution and the negative root has a physical meaning only in the ` donut ' regime , where it gives the inner radius . we note that for supercritical rotations ( @xmath138 ) , the density distribution has the shape of a shell , of which we then designate the outermost limit in the @xmath160-plane as the thomas - fermi radius @xmath159 and the largest extention in the @xmath11-direction as @xmath157 . in the harmonic limit , the thomas - fermi radii are @xmath161 in particular , we are interested in the optical density which can be directly measured by absorption images . performing an integration over the axial @xmath11-direction , we obtain @xmath162^{2}}{4\pi a_{z}^{2}\epsilon_{z}^{2}}.\label{eq : config - dist-2}\ ] ] the rotation dependence of the @xmath76 column density is shown in fig . [ fig:6 ] for the anharmonic potential . just above the critical rotation the distribution becomes nearly homogeneous , and at high supercritical rotations the gas eventually enters the ` donut ' regime , where the gas is entirely confined to the dip in the trap . in contrast , without the quartic trapping the gas spreads out to become an infinite pancake as the rotation approaches the critical rotation , as we can see from the divergence of the harmonic oscillator thomas - fermi radius at the critical rotation . spatial density distribution for the parameters of the paris experiment at increasing rotations . the anharmonic term prevents the formation of a ` pancake ' at near - critical rotations and causes the gas to take on a ` donut ' shape for large supercritical rotations.[fig:6],width=298 ] the fermi energy also sets a momentum scale through the fermi momentum @xmath163}$ ] . it represents the maximum extent of the momentum distribution at @xmath76 . for the anharmonic trap we have @xmath164/{\epsilon_{z}}}$ ] . a simple dependence on the particle number emerges again in the harmonic limit @xmath165 at @xmath76 the momentum space distribution for the anharmonic potential reads @xmath166+\sqrt{q } ; & q\geq0\\ ( q+1)\pi ; & q\leq0\end{cases},\nonumber\\ \label{eq : mom - distr}\ ] ] with the dimensionless variable @xmath167 . \label{eq : xdef}\ ] ] we see that , in contrast to bec , where the momentum distribution of the condensed atoms inherits the anisotropy of the trap , the fermionic momentum distribution of a non - interacting gas remains isotropic despite the trap anharmonicity . this feature is drastically affected by presence of the anisotropic dipole - dipole interaction , as then the fock term of the two - body mean - field energy induces a characteristic deformation of the momentum distribution @xcite . note that we have only considered the co - rotating frame ; as we will see , the rotation leads to an anisotropy in the momentum distribution in the lab frame . measurements in cold gases are usually carried out by turning off the trap and shining a resonant laser on the sample after some time of free expansion . these are called time - of - flight measurements ( tof ) . so far we have treated the problem in the corotating frame . in considering tof measurements , it is necessary to consider the laboratory frame , where the gas expands ballistically . the transformation of the momenta from the corotating frame to the lab frame yields @xmath168 where @xmath169 is the tangential unit vector . since the trap is radially symmetric , the coordinate transformation of the position does not affect the distribution . we have then @xmath170 thus although the momentum distribution does not inherit the anisotropy of the trap , the trap rotation leads nonetheless to an anisotropic momentum distribution . to study the expansion in detail we apply the ballistic substitution @xmath171 which yields a relation between the lab frame distribution and the corotating distribution : @xmath172,\ ] ] where @xmath173 and @xmath174 denote respectively the radius and tangential vector at the position @xmath175 , and can be expressed as @xmath176 with @xmath177 the unit vector in the axial direction . of particular experimental interest is the density distribution at a time @xmath178 after the trap is turned off , @xmath179.\label{eq : ballistic}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the case of harmonic trapping and zero rotation , the kinetic term can be combined with the harmonic term and the integral over momentum space in takes nearly the same form as the integration over momentum space in . unfortunately , in the case of the anharmonic potential with rotation , the integration can not be cast into a simple form and does not provide an insightful analytic expression . a measure of the spatial density is given by the aspect ratio @xmath180 with the respective widths @xmath181^{\frac{1}{2}}.\label{eq : wi}\ ] ] for harmonically confined fermi gases with zero rotation , it is known that anisotropic samples become asymptotically isotropic for large expansion time @xcite , since their widths scale in time as @xmath182 and the aspect ratio as @xmath183 in the case of a rotating gas with additional quartic trap , it is interesting to see how the rotation affects the asymptotic value of the aspect ratio , which reflects the lab frame momentum distribution . in fig . [ fig:7 ] the aspect ratio has been evaluated numerically for the anharmonic potential . comparing to the harmonic trap at zero rotation , we see that the anisotropy of the momentum distribution increases with the rotation frequency for the anharmonic trap . it is worth mentioning that the value of @xmath184 for large asymptotically large @xmath178 depends on the rotation , so that the aspect ratio could be used to measure the actual rotation frequency in an experiment . from top to bottom.[fig:7],width=302 ] after having studied the effects of rotation on the ground state of an anharmonically trapped polarized fermi gas , we turn our attention to the thermodynamic properties of such a system . the standard thermodynamical recipe is specialized to the case of the anharmonic potential and the consequences for different rotation frequencies are explored in both low- and high - temperature regimes . in this section we describe the thermodynamical properties of the system within the framework of the grand - canonical ensemble , where the most fundamental quantity is the grand - canonical partition function . for particles obeying fermi - dirac statistics it is given by @xmath185 , \label{eq : zg}\ ] ] where @xmath52 , as before , is the eigenvalue corresponding to the eigenstate @xmath186 . the grand - canonical free energy is obtained from the grand - canonical partition function through @xmath187 inserting in and making use of the semiclassical approximation , i.e. , writing the discrete sum as an integral over the density of states , we obtain @xmath188de.\label{eq : fg-3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] performing a partial integration of , one sees that the integral for the grand - canonical free energy contains the fermi distribution : @xmath189 where @xmath190 denotes the number of single - particle states with energy less than @xmath75 @xmath191 in view of using the semiclassical approximation for the density of states in , we define the incomplete fermi integral @xmath192 which is called incomplete due to the fact that its integration range is smaller than the one of the original fermi integral , defined by @xmath193 for convenience we introduce the further shorthand @xmath194 with and , we write the grand - canonical free energy of a system contained in the anharmonic potential in terms of the following fermi integrals : @xmath195 } { 2\beta^{\frac{7}{2 } } \epsilon_{z}^{\frac{5}{2 } } \kappa^{\frac{1}{2 } } } + \dfrac{\lambda^{2}\eta\zeta_{3}^{+,{\rm inc } } } { 2\beta^{3 } \epsilon_{z}^{2}\kappa } \nonumber \\ & & - \dfrac{\lambda^{6 } \eta^{3}\zeta_{2}^{+,{\rm inc } } } { 24\beta^{2 } \epsilon_{z } \kappa^{2 } } + \dfrac{\lambda^{10 } \eta^{5}\zeta_{1}^{+,{\rm inc } } } { 320\beta\kappa^{3 } } , \label{eq : fg-5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath196 is the sign of @xmath89 , defined as @xmath197 to obtain the other thermodynamical quantities , we express the grand - canonical free energy in terms of a legendre transformation @xmath198 with the differential @xmath199 therefore , the particle number @xmath42 and entropy @xmath200 can thus be determined from the grand - canonical free energy according to @xmath201 for the particle number we obtain @xmath202 } { 2\beta^{\frac{5}{2 } } \epsilon_{z}^{\frac{5}{2 } } \kappa^{\frac{1}{2}}}-\dfrac{\lambda^{2}\eta\zeta_{2}^{+,{\rm inc}}}{2\beta^{2}\epsilon_{z}^{2}\kappa}\nonumber\\ & & + \dfrac{\lambda^{6}\eta^{3}\zeta_{1}^{+,{\rm inc}}}{24\beta\epsilon_{z}\kappa^{2 } } , \label{eq : n}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and for the entropy we get @xmath203 the internal energy can then be obtained from yielding @xmath204 } { 4\beta^{\frac{7}{2 } } \epsilon_{z}^{\frac{5}{2}}\kappa^{\frac{1}{2}}}-\dfrac{\lambda^{2}\eta\zeta_{3}^{+,{\rm inc}}}{\beta^{3}\epsilon_{z}^{2}\kappa } \nonumber\\ & & + \dfrac{\lambda^{6}\eta^{3}\zeta_{2}^{+,{\rm inc}}}{6\beta^{2}\epsilon_{z}}-n\delta e. \label{eq : u}\end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that , in the pure quartic limit @xmath205 , a simple relation between the free and the internal energies arises @xmath206 the heat capacity of the system at constant particle number and trap parameters is given by @xmath207 to evaluate this derivative , we must , as usual , obtain the temperature derivative of the chemical potential from the with we then obtain @xmath208}{8\beta^{\frac{5}{2 } } \epsilon_{z}^{\frac{5}{2 } } \kappa^{\frac{1}{2 } } } - \dfrac{3\lambda^{2}\eta\zeta_{3}^{+,{\rm inc } } } { \beta^{2}\epsilon_{z}^{2 } \kappa } + \dfrac{\lambda^{6 } \eta^{3}\zeta_{2}^{+,{\rm inc } } } { 12\beta \epsilon_{z}\kappa^{2 } } \nonumber\\ & & -\dfrac{\left\{\dfrac{5\sqrt{\pi}\left [ 2\theta(-\eta ) \zeta_{\frac{5}{2}}^{+ } + \sigma(\eta ) \zeta_{\frac{5}{2}}^{+,{\rm inc } } \right]}{\beta^{\frac{5}{2}}\epsilon_{z}^{\frac{5}{2}}\kappa^{\frac{1}{2 } } } - \dfrac{4\lambda^{2}\eta\zeta_{2}^{+,{\rm inc } } } { \beta^{2 } \epsilon_{z}^{2}\kappa } + \dfrac{\lambda^{6 } \eta^{3}\zeta_{1}^{+,{\rm inc } } } { 6\beta \epsilon_{z } \kappa^{2 } } \right\}^{2 } } { \dfrac { 8\sqrt{\pi}\left[2\theta(-\eta ) \zeta_{\frac{3}{2}}^{+ } + \sigma(\eta)\zeta_{\frac{3}{2}}^{+,{\rm inc } } \right ] } { \beta^{\frac{5}{2 } } \epsilon_{z}^{\frac{5}{2 } } \kappa^{\frac{1}{2 } } } - \dfrac{8\lambda^{2 } \eta\zeta_{1}^{+,{\rm inc}}}{\beta^2\epsilon_{z}^{2}\kappa}}\nonumber\\ \label{eq : cv - sub}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since this analytic expression is not particularly illuminating , we analyze the behavior of for a range of temperatures from fig . [ fig:8 ] . at low temperatures the heat capacity is nearly linear in temperature , and at high temperatures the heat capacity approaches @xmath209 for a fixed rotation . at high temperatures a dip appears with a minimum occurring at a rotation that increases with the temperature . this interesting case and the general high - temperature behavior of the heat capacity will be discussed in detail below . , the fermi energy of the system at zero rotation ( @xmath210 . the temperature scale is the fermi temperature , @xmath211 . the angular frequency scale is the critical frequency @xmath2.[fig:8],width=302 ] in the low - temperature regime , we can understand temperature effects by using the sommerfeld expansion as sketched in ref . @xcite . to this end we consider the incomplete fermi function with @xmath212 @xmath213 where @xmath214 is the fermi distribution . a partial integration yields @xmath215,\label{eq : fermi - som-1a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the derivative of the fermi distribution is given by @xmath216\left[e^{-\beta(e - x ) } + 1 \right ] } .\label{eq : df}\ ] ] consider the case that @xmath217 . we see that the derivative becomes very small . if @xmath218 , then the lower limit of integration in can be extended to @xmath219 and @xmath220 . if @xmath221 then the integrand vanishes and @xmath222 . we now expand @xmath223 in a taylor series about @xmath224 , @xmath225\frac{(e - x ) ^{n}}{\gamma(n+1)}\nonumber\\ \label{eq : fermi - taylor}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and integrate with to obtain @xmath226 it is worth remarking that the sommerfeld expansion ( [ eq : fermi - inc - low ] ) is valide for @xmath227 and vanishes for @xmath228 . furthermore , the @xmath229 are constants given in terms of the riemann zeta function @xmath230 as @xmath231\zeta(2n).\ ] ] for the case of the complete fermi integral , eq . reduces to the usual sommerfeld expansion given by @xmath232 for @xmath227 . although the series in and terminate for @xmath233 , the expansion is not exact since the limits of integration were extended in . it is useful to obtain an explicit equation for the temperature dependence of the chemical potential using the sommerfeld expansion and the particle number equation . to this end , we substitute @xmath234 and keep terms linear in @xmath58 as well as quadratic in temperature to obtain up to third order contributions @xmath235 ( k_{b}t)^{2 } , \label{eq : mulow}\ ] ] where @xmath236 is the density of states evaluated at the fermi energy . we see that for low temperatures the chemical potential decreases with the square of the temperature . this result is compared to the numerical inversion of the particle number equation with both the exact evaluation of the fermi integrals and with the evaluation using terms quartic in temperature from the sommerfeld expansion in fig . [ fig:9 ] . .[fig:9],width=302 ] in the high - temperature limit we expect quantum statistics for both bosons and fermions to approach classical statistics . here we derive the high - temperature expansions of the thermodynamic properties of a fermi gas in the anharmonic trap of the paris experiment . we also consider in more detail the unique rotation dependence of the heat capacity in the high - temperature limit . a high - temperature expansion of the incomplete fermi integrals is obtained as follows . we rewrite as @xmath237 where @xmath238 . as seen in fig . [ fig:9 ] , if the temperature is high enough , @xmath239 and , thus , @xmath240 so that we can use the binomial expansion for the factor @xmath241 . then we obtain @xmath242 with the definition @xmath243 where @xmath244 is the gamma function . for @xmath245 in the high - temperature limit , it is sufficient to keep only the first term in the sum , yielding @xmath246 for positive integer @xmath53 , @xmath247 can be expanded exactly : @xmath248 the high - temperature expansion is compared to the exact evaluation of the fermi integrals in fig . [ fig:9 ] in the context of a numerical inversion of the particle number equation to solve for the chemical potential . the approximation is in general very accurate for temperatures larger than half the fermi temperature . from we can determine the high - temperature behavior of the general expressions for the thermodynamic properties of the system . for the particle number , we get @xmath249^{\frac{1}{2 } } \left[2 \theta(-\eta ) + \sigma(\eta)q\left(\frac{5}{2},\beta{\delta e}\right)\right]%\right\ } + \cdots . \label{eq : hight - n}\ ] ] it should be remarked that ( [ eq : hight - n ] ) is to be understood as giving the temperature dependence of the chemical potential in the high - temperature regime , so that @xmath112 is changed to maintain a constant value of @xmath42 on the left - hand side of the equation . note that the high - temperature chemical potential can be determined explicitly by taking the logarithm of . now we are in a position to write down the high - temperature versions of the internal energy @xmath250}+\cdots \label{eq : hight - u}\ ] ] and of the heat capacity @xmath251\dfrac{\sigma(\eta)(\beta\delta e)^{\frac{1}{2}}\pi^{-1/2 } e^{-\beta{\delta e}}}{\left[2\theta(-\eta)+\sigma(\eta)q\left(\frac{5}{2},\beta{\delta e}\right)\right]}\nonumber\\ & & -\dfrac{\beta{\delta e}e^{-2\beta{\delta e}}}{\pi\left[2\theta(-\eta)+\sigma(\eta)q\left(\frac{5}{2},\beta{\delta e}\right)\right]^{2 } } + \cdots\;. \label{eq : hight - cv}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the high - temperature behavior of the heat capacity is shown in fig . [ fig:10 ] . for subcritical rotations we have @xmath252 , for critical rotations @xmath253 , and for supercritical rotations @xmath254 . for a fixed rotation , the heat capacity approaches in all cases @xmath255 as @xmath256 . for a large constant temperature , the heat capacity also approaches @xmath255 in the high rotation limit , @xmath257 . the most interesting feature of the high - temperature heat capacity is the dip found in the supercritical region . differentiation of with respect to @xmath1 shows that the minimum heat capacity occurs at @xmath258 . interestingly , the value of the minimum heat capacity , @xmath259 , is independent of temperature and rotation . the relation between the temperature of the system and the rotation @xmath260 corresponding to the minimum heat capacity can be written more clearly as @xmath261 the rotation @xmath260 at which the minimum heat capacity is located increases monotonically with temperature and has the asymptotic form @xmath262 . thus , although the minimum is present at any temperature , it occurs at increasingly high rotations so that the heat capacity flattens to @xmath255 as @xmath256 for any finite rotation . furthermore , the similarity of to and , which give the critical rotation for the transition to the zero temperature donut regime , suggests that the minimum of the heat capacity is related to the transition of the gas into a configuration where the particles are mostly contained in the minimum of the supercritical potential . recalling that @xmath263 is the potential height at the trap mininum , one should expect that the `` donut regime '' is realized when the thermal energy of the particles is of the order of @xmath263 . thus , setting @xmath264 should provide an estimate of @xmath265 . indeed , this gives @xmath266 which is not bad at all . and @xmath267 with . from eq . ( [ eq : cv - min ] ) , one obtains that the minimum of the heat capacity at @xmath267 is located at @xmath268.[fig:10],width=302 ] at high enough temperatures , the quantum mechanical effects may be neglected . thus , the high - temperature properties of systems in an anharmonic trap can also be explained in the context of classical statistical mechanics . to do so , one has to average the desired quantities over an ensemble . for a function @xmath269 of the phase space points such an average @xmath270 is given explicitly through @xmath271 where @xmath272 is again the classical hamiltonian . in this context , the classical virial theorem states that for @xmath42 particles in thermal equilibrium at temperature @xmath115 in a potential @xmath273 , the classical ensemble averaged potential energy @xmath274 and translational kinetic energy @xmath275 of a particle in the system are related according to @xcite : @xmath276 where @xmath277 are the components of the position vector of a particle and @xmath278 . for a cylinder symmetrical potential of the form @xmath279 , one has @xmath280 the anharmonic potential , as given in , can be decomposed according to @xmath281 with the terms @xmath282,\quad%\label{eq : pot-3}\\ v_{z}(z ) = \dfrac{\epsilon_{z}z^{2}}{2a_{z}^{2}}.\label{eq : pot-3b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using , we obtain for the @xmath11-degrees of freedom the familiar harmonic potential result @xmath283 for the radial degrees of freedom we find correspondingly @xmath284 the total internal energy @xmath285 of a system of @xmath42 non - interacting particles in the potential @xmath273 is then given by @xmath286 before we consider the general result , let us make some remarks about eq . . by using the radial symmetry of the problem , one can express the average square radius through @xmath287 with the momenta @xmath288}.\ ] ] with the help of ref . @xcite , the limiting cases can be analytically explored . in the case of a pure quartic trap ( @xmath86 ) , the average radius is given by @xmath289 showing , as expected , that @xmath90 sets up the important length scale . for the case of a pure harmonic trap , i. e. @xmath290 , one has @xmath291 from , we conclude that the average position of the particles diverges as @xmath89 approaches @xmath292 . nevertheless , the energy per particle , as given from , remains @xmath293 . in general we obtain @xmath294\sqrt{\pi}}\right\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting this into we recover . we , thus , see that the classical statistical treatment of the system is equivalent to the high - temperature expansion which we have developed by keeping only the leading term in . we have considered non - interacting spin - polarized fermi particles in an anharmonic trap in the presence of a centrifugal potential due to rotation of the system . applying a semiclassical treatment to the density of states , we have worked out the temperature dependence of several thermodynamical properties . at absolute zero we have studied the density of particles and the momentum distribution for an anharmonically trapped system . the analysis of the particle density shows that a well defined geometry characterizes the ground state and has revealed a tendency for the particles to move away from the center . an analytical expression was obtained for the value of the rotation frequency @xmath0 at which a hole is created at the center of the trap , giving rise to a regime where the gas is ` donut'-shaped . the frequency @xmath0 was shown to depart from @xmath2 , which characterizes the stability limit for harmonic confinements , due to the interplay between the fermionic statistical interaction and the anharmonicity , in close analogy to repulsively interacting bosons . at finite temperature , expressions for the chemical potential , the internal energy , and the heat capacity were given . these were followed by discussions of their dependence on both anharmonicity and rotation frequency . at high - temperature , a virial theorem approach was presented and compared to previous results as well as shown to be particularly useful in the intuitive limits of pure harmonic and quartic radial confinements . the most natural extension of this work would be the inclusion of interactions . in the low - temperature regime , short - range interactions are strongly suppressed for fully polarized fermions . to overcome this problem , one could include other zeeman states by using an optical trap @xcite , yielding a spinor fermi gas . issues as ( anti-)ferromagnetism and magnetization dependence of the different quantities @xcite could be addressed in the presence of the additional quartic confinement . as for long - range interactions , no further zeeman states are necessarily required . due to its anisotropy , the dipole - dipole interaction is particularly interesting . atoms with non - zero nuclear spin are possible constituents for systems with large magnetic dipole moment @xmath295 . degenerate stable , for @xmath296cr ( @xmath297 ) @xcite , and meta - stable states , for @xmath298yb ( @xmath299 ) @xcite , are believed to be achievable . to date , only studies in two - dimensional systems consisting of a few atoms have already been performed @xcite , so that a three - dimensional many - body analog could be thought of . a further , and even simpler extension of the present work could be achieved by investigating the two - dimensional limit ( @xmath300 ) of the present system . by an appropriate tuning of the quartic constant , a quantum hall regime could be realized making possible the observation of underlying landau - levels through a plateau structure in the particle density when @xmath301 @xcite . for higher rotation frequencies , one would expect this structure to disappear and a hole to be created at a frequency value analogous to @xmath0 . we acknowledge financial support from the german academic exchange service ( daad ) and from the german research foundation ( dfg ) within the collaborative research center sfb / tr12 symmetries and universalities in mesoscopic systems .

motivated by recent experiments on rotating bose - einstein condensates , we investigate a rotating , polarized fermi gas trapped in an anharmonic potential . we apply a semiclassical expansion of the density of states in order to determine how the thermodynamic properties depend on the rotation frequency . the accuracy of the semiclassical approximation is tested and shown to be sufficient for describing typical experiments . at zero temperature , rotating the gas above a given frequency @xmath0 leads to a ` donut'-shaped cloud which is analogous to the hole found in two - dimensional bose - einstein condensates . the free expansion of the gas after suddenly turning off the trap is considered and characterized by the time and rotation frequency dependence of the aspect ratio . temperature effects are also taken into account and both low- and high - temperature expansions are presented for the relevant thermodynamical quantities . in the high - temperature regime a virial theorem approach is used to study the delicate interplay between rotation and anharmonicity .

astro-ph9702128

it is observationally well established that the velocity dispersion of main sequence stars increases with advancing spectral type . this fact has been recognised ever since velocity dispersions were first measured in the solar neighbourhood ( e.g. king 1990 ) . initially these observations were explained as the result of equipartition of energy because the mass of the stars decreases along the main sequence . however the two - body relaxation time scale is much too long to have any effect on the stellar velocity ellipsoid , prompting explanations relying on collective effects instead . some of the different functional forms that have been suggested for the velocity dispersion - age relation are reviewed by lacey ( 1991 ) . this increase in velocity dispersion , or heating , depends on the roughness of the gravitational potential in the disk , so knowledge about the shape of the velocity ellipsoid will tell us a great deal about the dynamical history of a disk . until recently direct measurements of the three - dimensional shape of the velocity ellipsoid have been restricted to the solar neighbourhood . observations of the stellar velocities in external spiral galaxies have concentrated on systems that are either close to edge - on or face - on ( van der kruit and freeman 1986 ; bottema 1995 ) and will therefore only provide information about a single component of the velocity dispersion . from these measurements only indirect inferences can be drawn about the shape of velocity ellipsoids in galaxies because the results of a small sample of _ different _ galaxies are being compared in a statistical way . moreover , this shape will be subject to rather large uncertainties because the errors of the face - on and edge - on galaxies are compounded , and because relating face - on and edge - on galaxies is rather delicate . in this pilot study we show that it is possible to derive the shape of the velocity ellipsoid within a _ single _ galaxy . we use the fact that an intermediate - inclination galaxy shows different projections of the velocity dispersion at different galactocentric azimuths . in section 2 the method by which we extract the velocity dispersions information is described . in section 3 we apply this analysis to the large early type spiral ngc 488 and in section 4 we discuss the results obtained for ngc 488 and compare them to the velocity ellipsoid in the solar neighbourhood . in cylindrical polar coordinates @xmath0 the line - of - sight velocity dispersion as a function of ( intrinsic ) position angle @xmath1 in a thin axisymmetric disk is @xmath2 \sin^2 i + \sigma_z^2 \cos^2 i , \ ] ] which can be written as @xmath3.\ ] ] thus , it consists of an element with a @xmath4 variation that depends only on the components of the dispersion in the plane of the galaxy , and an element with no dependence on @xmath1 that depends on all three components of the velocity dispersion . observations along at least two axes ( preferably the major and minor axes , which provide maximum leverage ) , are therefore required to extract both coefficients . furthermore , in disk galaxies , in which most orbits are well - described by the epicycle approximation the radial and azimuthal dispersions obey the relation @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the circular speed in the galaxy . ( in the solar neighbourhood , this expression reduces to @xmath7 , where @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the oort constants . ) within the epicycle approximation the stellar rotation speed @xmath10 equals the circular speed @xmath11 , so the righthandside of eq . [ eq : ax ] can be derived from the same spectral observations that are used to measure the velocity dispersions . the effect of higher - order approximations on this formula are discussed by kuijken & tremaine 1991 , who showed that the strongest deviations from eq . [ eq : ax ] are to be found at radii of several disk scale lengths ( see also cuddeford & binney 1994 ) . where the circular speed @xmath6 can be measured separately ( e.g. , from an emission - line rotation curve ) , a further constraint on the dispersions and velocities is the asymmetric drift equation , @xmath12 -r\frac{\partial \sigma^2_{r z}}{\partial z}\ ] ] the last term of equation 4 describes the tilting of the velocity ellipsoid . the two limiting cases of this tilting term are zero and ( @xmath13 ) . orbit integration by binney & spergel ( 1983 ) and by kuijken & gilmore ( 1989 ) suggest that in the solar neighbourhood the truth lies close to midway between the two extremes . as will be seen below , the uncertainty in this term is not a concern in the present analysis . in summary , the three components of the stellar velocity ellipsoid can be deduced from measurements of the line - of - sight dispersions along two position angles in a galaxy disk . the two sets of measurements , together with the ratio of tangential and radial velocity dispersions appropriate for nearly circular orbits , provide the three equations necessary to deproject the ellipsoid . if the asymmetric drift can also be measured , e.g. when a rotation curve for cold interstellar gas is available , the system is overdetermined , allowing a consistency check on the result . we choose the large early type spiral ngc 488 for this analysis because of its regular optical appearance and its intermediate inclination . table 1 lists some properties of this galaxy . note the very high rotational velocity ( peterson 1980 ) . .parameters of ngc 488 [ cols="<,^ " , ] we have tested this procedure on a large ( @xmath14 ) set of artificial major and minor axis spectra , created from the template star to resemble the observed galactic spectra as closely as possible , with a different poisson noise realisation for each spectrum . the best - fit parameters obtained from these spectra scatter with the same dispersion as the errors obtained from any individual fit to a spectrum . therefore , we conclude that the parameters returned by the fit programme are reliable . an obvious extension to our fitting procedure would be to use different scale lengths for the @xmath15 and @xmath16 dispersion components . unfortunately the data are not of sufficient quality to allow for a six parameter fit . one of the six eigenvalues that we obtained from diagonalising the correlation matrix was much larger than the other five , a clear indication that a six parameter fit is stretching the data a bit too much . interestingly , the kinematic scale length of the disk appears to be comparable to the photometric one . this is not the expectation from local isothermal approximation for disks , which predicts a scale length double the photometric one . the most likely explanation is probably the fact that we measure the scale length in the b band while the stellar mass distribution is best traced in the k band , the near infra - red . empirically it is found that scale lengths in the k band are shorter than the b band up to a factor of about 2 ( de jong 1995 , figure 4 and peletier et al . 1996 ) . alternatively the approximation of a local isothermal distribution breaks down . the fits described above are to the stellar data only . the lowest panel in fig . 2 shows the emission line data of peterson and the predictions from our two fits . both our fits are fully consistent with these data , and provide extra confirmation of the validity of our analysis . ( a simple power - law fit to the emission - line data plotted in fig . 2 gives a power index of 0.18 @xmath17 0.13 . ) unfortunately there are no measured emission line velocities in the inner part of the disk . peterson gives velocities around 195 km / s near a radius of 10 arcsec which are a little higher than our fits would predict . however there is no reason why a power - law rotation curve should persist into those central , bulge dominated regions . this is the first direct measurement of the vertical - to - radial velocity dispersion ratio anywhere outside the solar neighbourhood . previous determinations have all been indirect , and hence suffer from large uncertainities . the method we have described here is quite straightforward , and could be applied to many systems . the derived value of @xmath18 , which is effectively the average ratio near one photometric scale length , is somewhat higher than the solar neighbourhood value of 0.52 @xmath17 0.03 that wielen ( 1977 ) derived from the mccormick sample of k and m dwarfs . however , the error of 0.03 is the purely statistical error , but the scatter between the published observational estimates of this ratio suggests that the true error may be larger ( see lacey 1991 ) . any difference between the two ratios is consistent with the findings about the relative effects of the two dominant heating mechanisms , molecular clouds and spiral structure , as we now show . heating by molecular clouds was originally proposed by spitzer and schwarzschild ( 1951 ) . they proposed that stars in star - cloud encounters gain kinetic energy at the expense of the clouds because of the huge masses of the latter . subsequent analysis by lacey ( 1984 ) and @xmath19-body simulations by villumsen ( 1985 ) showed however that this mechanism saturates rather quickly ( once the stars have sufficient energy that they spend most of their time outside the cloud layer the heating rate drops ) and could not fully explain the observed heating . an alternative proposal to heat the disk , due to barbanis and woltjer ( 1967 ) , explains the heating as the result of stars scattering from spiral irregularities in the galactic potential . carlberg and sellwood ( 1985 ) have extended this work and showed that this can indeed heat up the disk . however this process can not heat the stars efficiently in the vertical direction because the vertical oscillation frequency of stars is much larger than the frequency at which a spiral wave sweeps past the stars orbiting the disk . hence the stars respond almost adiabatically to this force . giant molecular clouds create large spiral wakes , often much larger than a cloud itself ( julian and toomre 1966 ) . this interplay between clouds and spiral irregularities is not yet completely understood but it is clear that they are not independent . jenkins and binney ( 1990 ) examined the combined effects of both processes based on monte carlo simulations of the fokker - planck equation describing these processes . they expressed the relative importance of heating by spiral structure to heating by clouds by a parameter denoted @xmath20 and calculated the corresponding ratio of @xmath21 ( see their figure 2 ) . from the observed shape of the velocity ellipsoid and velocity dispersion - age relations they concluded that in the solar neighbourhood the heating of the disk is dominated by spiral structure ( @xmath22 ) . the mean surface density of the cloud layer near the sun is 1.8 @xmath23 pc@xmath24 ( clemens , sanders and scoville 1988 ) . from the fcrao extragalactic co survey ( young et al . 1995 ) a mean surface density for ngc 488 is derived of 3.5 @xmath23 pc@xmath24 . ( young et al . find that the co layer in ngc 488 is best described by a uniform distribution with a radius of 1.65 arcmin and a co flux of @xmath25 jy km / s . ) , higher than in the solar neighbourhood . ngc 488 is classified as an sb galaxy . it has a very regular tightly wound spiral pattern ( the pitch angle is only 5@xmath26 ) . it is therefore quite likely that the potential associated with this spiral pattern is much smoother that that of our own galaxy , which has an sbc hubble type . both these observations imply that the parameter @xmath20 must be smaller for ngc 488 than for the solar neighbourhood . according to the predictions of jenkins and binney a smaller @xmath20 corresponds to a larger @xmath21 ratio . we do indeed find that the @xmath21 ratio for ngc 488 is higher than for the milky way , however the difference is only one sigma . we conclude therefore that the shape of the velocity ellipsoid that we have determined is qualitatively consistent with the picture sketched by jenkins and binney . the technique we have described in this paper would be straightforward to apply to a larger sample of disk galaxies . with higher quality data , it would also be possible to extend the analysis to map out the radial variation of the velocity ellipsoid shape , a quantity which has never been observationally constrained . both projects would provide important measurements for comparison with the theoretical treatments of the heating processes in stellar disks . the data presented in this paper were obtained using the multiple mirror telescope , which is a joint facility of the smithsonian institute and the university of arizona . much of the analysis was performed using iraf , which is distributed by noao . we thank the referee , cedric lacey for his helpful comments . barbanis b. , woltjer l. , 1967 , apj , 150 , 461 binney j. , spergel d. n. , 1983 , iau colloquium no . 76 bottema r. , 1995 _ phd thesis , university of groningen _ carlberg r. g. , sellwood j. a. , 1985 , apj , 292 , 79 clemens d. p. , sanders d. b. , scoville n. z. , 1988 apj , 327 , 139 cuddeford p. , binney j. , 1994 , mnras , 266 , 273 de jong r. s. , 1995 _ phd thesis , university of groningen _ de jong r. s. , 1996 , a&a , 313 , 45 jenkins a. , binney j. , 1990 , mnras , 245 , 305 julian w. h. , toomre a. , 1966 , apj , 146 , 810 king i. r. , 1990 , in _ the milky way as a galaxy _ , eds buser r. , king i. r. , p. 172 kuijken k. , gilmore , g. , 1989 , mnras , 239 , 571 kuijken k. , tremaine s. , 1991 in _ dynamics of disc galaxies _ , ed . sundelius b. , p. 71 kuijken k. , merrifield m. r. , 1993 , mnras , 264 , 712 lacey c. g. , 1984 , mnras , 208 , 687 lacey c. g. , 1991 , in _ dynamics of disc galaxies _ , ed . sundelius b. , p. 257 merrifield m. , kuijken k. , 1994 , apj , 432 , 575 peletier r. f. et al . , 1996 a&a , 300 , l1 peterson c. j. , 1980 , aj , 85 , 226 press et al . , 1986 , _ numerical recipes _ , cambridge university press , cambridge shombert j. m. , bothun g. d. , 1987 , aj , 93 , 29 shu f. h. , 1969 , apj , 158 , 505 spitzer l. , schwarzschild m. , 1951 , apj , 114 , 385 van der kruit p. c. , freeman k. , 1986 , apj , 303 , 556 van der marel r. p. , franx m. , 1993 , apj , 407 , 525 villumsen j. v. , 1985 , apj , 290 , 75 wielen r. , 1977 , a&a , 60 , 263 young j. s. , et al . , 1995 , apjsupl , 98 , 257

theories of stellar orbit diffusion in disk galaxies predict different rates of increase of the velocity dispersions parallel and perpendicular to the disk plane , and it is therefore of interest to measure the different velocity dispersion components in galactic disks of different types . we show that it is possible to extract the three components of the velocity ellipsoid in an intermediate - inclination disk galaxy from measured line - of - sight velocity dispersions on the major and minor axes . on applying the method to observations of the sb galaxy ngc 488 , we find evidence for a higher ratio of vertical to radial dispersion in ngc 488 than in the solar neighbourhood of the milky way ( the only other place where this quantity has ever been measured ) . the difference is qualitatively consistent with the notion that spiral structure has been relatively less important in the dynamical evolution of the disk of ngc 488 than molecular clouds . galaxies : fundamental parameters galaxies : individual : ngc488 galaxies : kinematics and dynamics .

1406.2248

in the field of optomechanics , one is always designing mechanical systems with lowest possible friction @xcite and highest possible optomechanical coupling constant @xcite . this is because one would like to produce and use coherent phonons with long coherence time . one prominent application of coherent phonons is in storage and retrieval of light using optomechanical systems @xcite . an attractive system which has received considerable attention is the levitated microsphere trapped in an optical cavity . both trapping and levitation can be produced by optical fields @xcite . another very attractive system is superfluid he , which has zero viscosity . it is known to have acoustic phonons with almost zero friction at low temperatures , a finite value arising only from thermal three - phonon scattering processes @xcite . de lorenzo and schwab @xcite have performed initial optomechanical experiments on superfluid he by coupling it to a superconducting resonator . flowers - jacobs _ et al . _ @xcite have reported progress in doing optomechanics with superfluid he using optical cavities . in view of the current interest @xcite in the optomechanics with superfluid he , we present in this paper theoretical foundations of optomechanics in such systems . the organization of this paper is as follows . in sec . ii , we derive the basic semiclassical equations for the optomechanical interactions in superfluid he . in sec . iii , we present a hamiltonian formulation of the problem in terms of the canonical variables , so that this can be adopted for quantized phonon and photon fields . the theory is formulated in terms of the fields , both electromagnetic and fluid density , so that situations involving many phonons and photons of different frequencies can be handled . in sec . iv , we present a quantized description of the optomechanical interactions . we present estimates for the strength of the optomechanical interactions . the linear optomechanical interaction shift of the cavity resonance per photon is quite significant in cavities like a fiber cavity @xcite . we derive the canonical form @xcite of the hamiltonian for linear optomechanical interactions in superfluid he . having obtained the canonical form , we can study all the physical processes that have been studied with other optomechanical systems . an estimate of the single step two - phonon antistokes process due to acoustic nonlinearity is also given in this section . in sec . v , we discuss two - step two - phonon processes , which are shown to be significant in superfluid he . it may be noted that the knowledge of the linear interaction hamiltonian ( [ 04.19 ] ) with the strength of @xmath1 estimated after eq ( [ 04.15 ] ) is sufficient to understand the processes in sec . v. when the electromagnetic cavity is designed in such a way that allowed optical modes are such that no anti - stokes upconversion is possible via the absorption of any single phonon in the medium , one must consider absorption of two phonons for possible upconversion . such a process can be controlled well when these phonons are external phonons injected in the medium . because of the intrinsic nonlinearity of the superfluid he , we have the new possibilities arising from the combination of the superfluid nonlinearity and the optomechanical interactions . in this section , we start with the fundamental equations @xcite for the superfluid density @xmath2 and the velocity @xmath3 and we obtain modifications of these due to interaction with the electromagnetic fields . the basic equations for @xmath2 and @xmath3 in the absence of the electromagnetic fields are given by @xmath4 @xmath5 where the stress tensor @xmath6 is given by @xmath7 here @xmath8 is the pressure in the superfluid . we have set the viscosity term zero . we note that we have a set of nonlinear equations as pressure is generally expanded @xcite in terms of the normalized deviation @xmath9 from the equilibrium value @xmath10 : @xmath11 we now discuss the modification of eqs . ( [ 2.1 ] ) and ( [ 2.2 ] ) due to the interaction with the electromagnetic fields . clearly eq . ( [ 2.1 ] ) remains unchanged . we need to modify eq . ( [ 2.2 ] ) by the addition of the maxwell stress contribution @xmath12 to eq . ( [ 2.2 ] ) _ i.e. _ @xmath13 the form of the maxwell stress tensor depends on the nature of the medium . it is derived from the considerations of the electromagnetic force on the medium . on dropping the magnetic polarization contribution , the force on a linear medium can be written as @xmath14 here @xmath15 is the electromagnetic field and @xmath16 is the optical dielectric function of the isotropic superfluid . the electromagnetic force can also be written in an alternate form @xcite @xmath17 the dielectric function of the medium depends on @xmath18 through the density _ i.e. _ @xmath19 $ ] and hence @xmath20}{\partial\rho } \vec\nabla\rho,\ ] ] and hence eq . ( [ 2.7 ] ) reduces to @xmath21.\end{aligned}\ ] ] using eq . ( [ 2.9 ] ) , eq.([2.5 ] ) becomes @xmath22 = 0.\ ] ] the equations eqs . ( [ 2.1 ] ) and ( [ 2.10 ] ) are the basic equations for the optomechanical interactions in superfluid he . the only assumption that we made in deriving eq . ( [ 2.10 ] ) is the linear electromagnetic response @xmath23 $ ] of superfluid he . the equations ( [ 2.1 ] ) and ( [ 2.10 ] ) are to be supplemented by the expansion ( [ 2.4 ] ) . the electric field obeys the equation @xmath24\vec{e}\right ) = 0,\ ] ] which is obtained from the maxwell equations . in the hamiltonian description , one introduces the conjugate variables @xmath25 and @xmath26 and the classical velocity is related to @xmath27 via @xmath28 the hamiltonian description of the superfluid equations ( [ 2.1 ] ) and ( [ 2.2 ] ) is well - known and for completeness , we recall the main aspects . the unperturbed hamiltonian density is @xmath29 and the interaction term is @xmath30 the function @xmath31 is related to the pressure via the thermodynamic relation @xcite @xmath32 using the total hamiltonian @xmath33 , we can see how eqs.([3.2])-([3.4 ] ) lead to eqs.([2.1 ] ) and ( [ 2.2 ] ) . for this purpose , we use the hamiltonian formulation for fields @xcite @xmath34 = -\sum_j\frac{\partial}{\partial r_j } [ \rho v_j ] \nonumber\\ & = -\vec{\nabla}\cdot(\rho\vec{v } ) , \label{3.5 } \\ \dot{\phi } & = \frac{\delta h}{\delta\rho } = \frac12(\nabla\phi)^2 + \frac{\partial}{\partial\rho } [ \rho w(\rho ) ] \nonumber\\ & = \frac12v^2 + \left(w + \frac{p(\rho)}{\rho } \right ) . \label{3.6}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can convert eq.([3.6 ] ) into an equation for @xmath35 as follows @xmath36\vec{v } - \rho\vec{\nabla}\left[\frac12v^2 + w + \frac{p(\rho)}{\rho}\right ] \nonumber \\ & = -\rho(\vec{\nabla}\rho)\frac{\partial}{\partial\rho } \left[w+\frac{p(\rho)}{\rho}\right ] - \vec{\nabla}\cdot[\rho\vec{v}\vec{v } ] \nonumber \\ & = - \vec{\nabla}\cdot[\rho\vec{v}\vec{v } ] - \vec{\nabla}\cdot(p{\overleftrightarrow}{i}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath37 is the unit tensor . the eqs.([3.5 ] ) and ( [ 3.7 ] ) are identical to eqs.([2.1 ] ) and ( [ 2.2 ] ) respectively . the hamiltonian for optomechanical interactions in superfluid he will then be @xmath38-\epsilon_0}{2})e^2 , \label{3.11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath39 is the polarization in superfluid medium . using eq . ( [ 3.8 ] ) , the equations for the canonical conjugate variables @xmath2 and @xmath27 are @xmath40 a simple exercise shows that eq.([3.13 ] ) is equivalent to the eq.([2.10 ] ) for @xmath41 . the hamiltonian ( [ 3.8 ] ) depends on the density @xmath2 to all orders . in order to bring out some of the important physical process , we consider an expansion of @xmath42 in powers of the deviation @xmath43 , @xmath44 from the equilibrium value @xmath10 . we will examine terms up to second order in @xmath43 . the expansion of the optomechanical interaction term is straight forward : @xmath45 = \epsilon[\rho_0 ] + \rho_0\left(\frac{\partial\epsilon}{\partial\rho}\right)_0\tilde\rho + \frac12 \rho_0 ^ 2\left(\frac{\partial^2\epsilon}{\partial\rho^2}\right)_0\tilde{\rho}^2 + \dots , \label{3.14}\\ \mathcal{h}^{\text{(em)}}_1 = - \frac{\epsilon(\rho_0)-\epsilon_0}{2}e^2 - \frac12 g_1\epsilon_0 \tilde\rho e^2 - \frac12 g_2\epsilon_0 \tilde\rho^2 e^2 + \dots , \label{3.15 } \\ g_1 = \frac{\rho_0}{\epsilon_0}\left(\frac{\partial\epsilon}{\partial\rho}\right)_0 , \qquad g_2 = \frac{\rho_0 ^ 2}{2\epsilon_0}\left(\frac{\partial^2\epsilon}{\partial\rho^2}\right)_0 . \nonumber\end{gathered}\ ] ] here @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the coupling constants for the linear and quadratic optomechanical interactions . a rough estimate of @xmath46 and @xmath47 can be obtained from the experimental data @xcite on liquid he : @xmath48 where the molecular polarizability @xmath49 is @xmath50m@xmath51mole , @xmath52kg / mole , equilibrium density @xmath53kg / m@xmath54 , and hence @xmath55 further , @xmath56 and therefore the term @xmath57 contributes to small frequency shifts of the electromagnetic fields . we will ignore such frequency shifts . the term @xmath58 gives the nonlinearities of the superfluid in the absence of any applied electromagnetic fields . we write @xmath59 as @xmath60 and use @xmath61 , to obtain @xmath62 the parameter @xmath63 is called the gruneisen constant @xcite and has the value @xmath64 . in eq.([3.18 ] ) , @xmath65m / sec ) is the velocity of sound . the nonlinear conversion of phonons , as determined by the @xmath66 term in eq . ( [ 3.19 ] ) , has been discussed by wright _ et al . _ @xcite . in order to simplify @xmath67 in powers of @xmath43 , we need to find the expansion of @xmath68 , which can be obtained from eq.([3.12 ] ) , which to lowest order in density yields @xmath69 in order to do the quantization , we invoke the space - time structure of the electromagnetic and density ( acoustic ) fields . we would be studying optomechanical interactions in a cavity which could be an optical one like a fiber cavity @xcite or a superconducting one @xcite . the electromagnetic field can be written as a superposition of orthogonal and orthonormal transverse modes @xmath70 _ i.e. _ @xmath71 where the mode function @xmath70 has frequency @xmath72 and is a solution of @xmath73 . the hamiltonian ( [ 3.10 ] ) for the electromagnetic field leads to @xmath74 where we used the orthogonality of the mode functions @xmath75{\mathrm{d}}^3r = \delta_{ij}$ ] . in order to do the quantization , we identify @xmath76 with @xmath77 . thus the amplitude @xmath78 is to be replaced by the annihilation operator @xmath79 via @xmath80 therefore , the quantized form of the electric field is @xmath81 and the unperturbed hamiltonian is @xmath82 we expand the phonon field in terms of the normalized mode functions @xmath83 with frequency @xmath84 , @xmath85 note that @xmath83 has the dimension @xmath86 and hence @xmath87 has the dimension @xmath88 . the quantization of the free phonon field is more complicated due to the nonlinear nature of the interaction term ( [ 3.3 ] ) . in order to do the quantization , we look at the harmonic version of ( [ 3.3 ] ) , _ i.e. _ we use eq.([3.19 ] ) up to order @xmath89 . we next find @xmath90 ( eq.([3.2 ] ) ) to lowest order _ i.e. _ up to second order in density . from eqs.([3.20 ] ) , ( [ 04.6 ] ) and ( [ 04.7 ] ) , we can easily obtain @xmath91 and hence for a given mode @xmath92 we thus quantize the phonon field via @xmath93 where @xmath94 is the bosonic annihilation operator for the phonon with frequency @xmath84 . the unperturbed hamiltonian for the phonon field @xmath95 is @xmath96 the terms of the order @xmath97 can be obtained by using the expansion ( [ 3.19 ] ) . these correspond to three phonon scattering processes . the quantized form of the interaction hamiltonian ( [ 3.15 ] ) can now be obtained by using eqs.([04.4 ] ) and ( [ 04.11 ] ) . the final result is dependent on the different modes involved in the optomechanical interactions and their overlap integrals . we write @xmath98 where @xmath99 and @xmath100 are respectively the linear and nonlinear optomechanical interactions . in what follows , we drop all rapidly oscillating terms at twice the cavity frequencies . the linear part then can be written as @xmath101{\mathrm{d}}^3r , \label{04.14}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath102 is obtained from @xmath103 by replacing @xmath104 by @xmath105 . for simplicity , we choose @xmath106 to be real and then we can drop the distinction between @xmath103 and @xmath102 . the quantity @xmath107 is the frequency shift of the cavity mode for one photon . we can get an approximate estimate of @xmath108 by using @xmath109 , @xmath110 for the fiber cavity@xcite taking the mode volumn about @xmath111m@xmath54 , @xmath112 corresponding to @xmath113 m , @xmath114mhz , @xmath115j / m@xmath54 , we find @xmath116khz and hence @xmath117khz . thus , linear optomechanical interaction is quite significant and is comparable to that obtained with mechanical elements @xcite . the nonlinear part @xmath100 has several contributions . we do not write all the terms but make an estimate . a term corresponding to two - phonon absorption has the form @xmath118 where @xmath119 has the form @xmath120 let us take @xmath121 and @xmath122 to be the same mode , then @xmath123 thus compared to the first - order optomechanical coupling , the second order is smaller by a factor @xmath124 for parameters that were used in the estimation of linear optomechanical coupling . the second - order contribution has been generally found to be unimportant in most mechanical systems . however , considerable progress has been reported in achieving higher second - order coupling by placing the mechanical element at the crossing of two modes @xcite . one possibility to enhance @xmath8 would be to use nanometric volume for he . in view of the smallness of @xmath119 compared to @xmath125 , we drop the contribution @xmath100 and work with @xmath126 for two field modes and one acoustic mode and assuming that @xmath127 , we can simplify eq.([04.18 ] ) to @xmath128 this is the standard form of the optomechanical interaction . the terms like @xmath129 describe the upconversion process where a phonon and a photon @xmath130 combine to produce a photon @xmath131 if @xmath132 . the terms like @xmath133 describe a downconversion process where a photon @xmath130 and a phonon @xmath134 are produced form a photon of frequency @xmath131 . the hamiltonian ( [ 04.19 ] ) also consists of nonresonant terms like @xmath135 . these terms play a significant role in two - step two - phonon processes as discussed in the next section . clearly , the previously discussed processes @xcite in other optomechanical systems would also apply to optomechanics in superfluid he , since the linear coupling constant @xmath1 in eq.([04.19 ] ) is quite significant . the advantage of superfluid he is its very large coherence time of the phonon , which is especially useful in quantum processing applications like state transfer @xcite and quantum memories @xcite . we next consider the very interesting possibility of two - phonon absorption @xcite in optomechanical interactions in superfluid he . this , in a sense , is the analog of two photon absorption in atomic systems . let us consider the following two steps : @xmath136 this two - step process shown in fig . [ fig1 ] is resonant if @xmath137 and is a combination of two upconversion processes . the two - step process is mediated by an intermediate photon of frequency @xmath138 . such a two - step process can be significant as the intermediate photon can have the same frequency as the strong input photon @xmath131 . such a contribution comes form the term @xmath139 in the interaction ( [ 04.18 ] ) . for the present problem , the interaction @xmath99 can be written as @xmath140 let the initial state be @xmath141 which has @xmath142 photons of frequency @xmath143 and @xmath144 phonons of frequency @xmath145 . the final state is @xmath146 . the transition probability for this process can be obtained by using second order fermi golden rule @xmath147 } = \frac{2\pi}{\hbar } \delta(e_f - e_i ) \left| \sum_j\frac{\langle f|v_l|j\rangle\langle j|v_l|i\rangle}{e_j - e_i}\right|^2,\ ] ] where @xmath148 is the allowed intermediate state . the four important intermediate states with the corresponding energies are @xmath149 using these intermediate states and eq.([6.2 ] ) , the two - phonon absorption rate is calculated to be @xmath150 } = \nonumber \\ & \frac{2\pi g^4(2\gamma/\pi)}{[(2\gamma)^2+(\omega_1-\omega_2+f_1+f_2)^2 ] } \mu_1\mu_2n_1(n_2 + 1)(n_1+n_2)^2 \nonumber \\ & \quad \cdot \left| \frac{1}{(-\omega_1+\omega_2-f_1 ) } - \frac{1}{f_1 } - \frac{1}{f_2 } + \frac{1}{(-\omega_1+\omega_2-f_2 ) } \right|^2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we introduced the width @xmath151 for the phonon distribution . note that the sum over intermediate states vanishes . thus there is interference between different quantum pathways . such interference effects are well - known in atomic physics in the context of two photon processes ( see sec.7.5 in @xcite ) . it is also known that relaxation effects generally make perfect interference imperfect leading to nonzero transition amplitudes . for our system in a cavity , the cavity line width @xmath152 is an important factor and it makes @xmath153}$ ] nonzero . the denominators like @xmath154 need to be modified by inclusion of the phonon line width @xmath151 which is much smaller than @xmath152 . the denominators depending on @xmath131 and @xmath130 get modified by inclusion of @xmath152 . a simple argument then modifies eq . ( [ 6.4 ] ) to @xmath155 } & = \frac{2\pi g^4(2\gamma/\pi)}{(2\gamma)^2+(\omega_1-\omega_2+f_1+f_2)^2 } \nonumber \\ & \qquad \cdot \left(\frac{\kappa}{f}\right)^2 \frac{1}{f } \mu_1\mu_2n_1(n_2 + 1)(n_1+n_2)^2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] this should be compared with the corresponding result @xmath156}$ ] for one phonon absorption @xmath157 } = \frac{2\pi g^2(\gamma/\pi)}{\gamma^2+(\omega_1-\omega_2+f_1)^2 } \cdot \mu_1n_1(n_2 + 1),\ ] ] which is easily obtained from eq.([04.18 ] ) . let us compare the strength of @xmath153}$ ] with @xmath156}$ ] at resonance @xmath158}}{r^{[1 ] } } & \approx \frac{g^2}{2 } ( \frac{\kappa^2}{f^4 } ) \cdot ( n_1+n_2)^2\mu_2\nonumber \\ & \sim \frac{g^2\kappa^2}{2f^4 } n_1 ^ 2\mu_2 \qquad \text{as } n_1\gg n_2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath159hz , @xmath114mhz , @xmath160 , @xmath161}}{r^{[1 ] } } & \approx 2\times10^{-16 } n_1 ^ 2\mu \nonumber \\ & = 2\times10^{-4 } \mu \qquad \text{for } n_1\sim10^{6}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for temperatures of the order of @xmath162mk , @xmath163 and hence @xmath153}/r^{[1]}\sim10^{-3}$ ] , leading to substantial probability for two - step two - phonon absorption . note that , instead of using thermal phonons , we can inject phonons from an external source @xcite . in conclusion , we have developed a first principle theory of the optomechanical interactions in superfluid he . the theory is formulated in terms of the superfluid density field , so that multimode phonon optomechanics can be studied . the intrinsic nonlinearities of superfluid are included . we presented estimates of the strength of the optomechanical interactions and derived the canonical form of the hamiltonian for linear optomechanical interactions . using such canonical hamiltonian standard effects like normal mode splitting , electromagnetically induced transparency in superfluid optomechanics can be studied . we also showed the importance of the two - step two - phonon process in superfluid he . the superfluid also has the possibility of nonlinear phonon processes which one can integrate with the optomechanical processes . for example , two phonons @xmath164 and @xmath165 can combine via the cubic nonlinearity in eq.([3.19 ] ) and the generated phonon can be used for optomechanical interactions . s.s.j . acknowledges the hospitality of the oklahoma state university , while this work was done . the authors thank kenan qu for his support in preparing the paper . thanks j. harris for preliminary correspondence . 99 n. kiesel , f. blaser , u. deli , d. grass , r. kaltenbaek , and m. aspelmeyer , pnas , * 110 * , 14180 ( 2013 ) . t. s. monteiro , j. millen , g. a. t. pender , f. marquardt , d. chang , p. f. barker , new j. phys . * 15 * , 015001 ( 2013 ) . s. groeblacher , k. hammerer , m. r. vanner , m. aspelmeyer , nature(london ) * 460 * , 724 ( 2009 ) . m. karuza , m. galassi , c. biancofiore , c. molinelli , r. natali , p. tombesi , g. di giuseppe , and d. vitali , j. opt . * 115 * , 025704 ( 2013 ) . d. lee , m. underwood , d. mason , a. b. shkarin , s. w. hoch , and j. g. e. harris , arxiv:1401.2968 ( 2014 ) . g. s. agarwal and s. huang , phys . a * 81 * , 041803(r ) ( 2010 ) ; s. weis , el al . , science * 330 * , 1520 ( 2010 ) ; j. d. teufel , el al . , nature ( london ) , * 471 * , 204 ( 2011 ) ; y. liu , m. davano , v. aksyuk , and k. srinivasan , phys . lett . * 110 * , 223603 ( 2013 ) ; kenan qu and g. s. agarwal , phys . a * 87 * , 031802 ( 2013 ) ; a. h. safavi - naeini , _ et al . _ , nature ( london ) , * 472 * , 69 ( 2011 ) . v. fiore , y. yang , m. c. kuzyk , r. barbour , l. tian , and h. wang , phys . lett . * 107 * , 133601 ( 2011 ) ; c. dong , v. fiore , m. c. kuzyk , and h. wang , phys . a * 87 * , 055802 ( 2013 ) ; v. fiore , c. dong , m. c. kuzyk , and h. wang , ibid * 87 * , 023812 ( 2013 ) . l. a. delorenzo , and k. c. schwab , arxiv:1308.2164 ( 2013 ) . n. e. flowers - jacobs , a. d. kashkanova , a. b. shkarin , s. w. hoch , c. deutsch , j. reichel and j. g. e. harris , in `` meeting of the american physical society '' , ( denver , colorado , baps.2014.mar.q35.4 ) . n. e. flowers - jacobs , s. w. hoch , j. c. sankey , a. kashkanova , a. m. jayich , c. deutsch , j. reichel , j. g. e. harris , appl . * 101 * , 221109 ( 2012 ) . g. s. agarwal , quantum optics ( cambridge university press , 2012 ) , chap . 20 . m. aspelmeyer , t. j. kippenberg , and f. marquardt , arxiv:1303.0733 ( 2013 ) . c. genes , a. mari , d. vitali , and p. tombesi , adv . at . . phys . * 57 * , 33 ( 2009 ) . m. aspelmeyer , p. meystre and k. schwab , phys . today * 65 * , 29 ( 2012 ) . f. london , superfluids ( wiley , new york , 1950 ) . d. r. wright , j. s. foster , b. hadimioglu , and c. f. quate , j. appl . * 68 * , 4438 ( 1990 ) . b. m. abraham , y. eckstein , j. b. ketterson , m. kuchnir , and p. r. roach , phys . rev . a * 1 * , 250 ( 1970 ) . j. a. stratton , electromagnetic theory ( mcgraw hill , newyork , 1941 ) , eq.(35 ) on p.144 . h. goldstein , c. p. poole , and j. l. safko , classical mechanics , 3rd ed , ( addison - wesley , newyork , 2002 ) , sec . 13.4 . c. boghosian and h. meyer , phys . rev . * 152 * , 200 ( 1966 ) ; r. j. donnelly and c. f. barenghi , j. phys . chem . ref . data , * 27 * , 1217 ( 1998 ) . e. verhagen , s. delglise , s. weis , a. schliesser , and t. j. kippenberg , nature(london ) * 482 * , 63 ( 2012 ) ; l. tian , phys . lett . * 108 * , 153604 ( 2012 ) ; y. -d . wang and a. a. clerk , ibid * 108 * , 153603 ( 2012 ) ; t. a. palomaki , j. w. harlow , j. d. teufel , r. w. simmonds , and k. w. lehnert , nature * 495 * , 210 ( 2013 ) ; r. w. andrews , r. w. peterson , t. p. purdy , k. cicak , r. w. simmonds , c. a. regal , and k. w. lehnert , nature phys . * 10 * , 321 ( 2014 ) . a. i. lvovsky , b. c. sanders and w. tittel , nat . photon . * 3 * , 706 ( 2009 ) . sumei huang and g. s. agarwal , phys . a * 83 * , 023823 ( 2011 ) ; y. -c . liu , y. -f . xiao , y. -l . chen , x. -c . yu , and q. gong , phys . . lett . * 111 * , 083601 ( 2013 ) ; a. kronwald and f. marquardt , ibid . * 111 * , 133601 ( 2013 ) ; m. -a . lemonde , n. didier , and a. a. clerk , ibid . * 111 * , 053602 ( 2013 ) ; k. brkje , a. nunnenkamp , j. d. teufel , and s. m. girvin , ibid . * 111 * , 053603 ( 2013 ) .

a general theory is presented to describe optomechanical interactions of acoustic phonons , having extremely long lifetimes in superfluid @xmath0he , with optical photons in the medium placed in a suitable electromagnetic cavity . the acoustic nonlinearity in the fluid motion is included to consider processes beyond the usual linear process involving absorption or emission of one phonon at a time . we first apply our formulation to the simplest one - phonon process involving the usual resonant anti - stokes upconversion of an incident optical mode . however , when the allowed optical cavity modes are such that there is no single - phonon mode in the superfluid which can give rise to a resonant allowed anti - stokes mode , we must consider the possibility of two - phonon upconversion . for such a case , we show that the two - step two - phonon process could be dominant . we present arguments for large two - step process and negligible single step two - phonon contribution . the two - step process also shows interesting quantum interference among different transition pathways .

quant-ph9811067

spontaneous emission by an excited atom is one of the most studied examples of a quantum process and may be attributed , at least in part , to fluctuations in the electromagnetic vacuum @xcite . the vacuum field is modified by the local environment and this , in turn , leads to a modification of the spontaneous emission rate . in this way the spontaneous emission rate can be changed by embedding the radiating atom inside a dielectric host @xcite , or by changing the boundary conditions either by a cavity @xcite or a suitable surface @xcite . recent experiments have examined the emission by atoms embedded in dielectric hosts @xcite and have encouraged us to re - examine the problem of local - field corrections to the bulk modification of the spontaneous decay rate . the total decay rate @xmath0 can be split into two parts , @xmath1 in which we associate the transverse decay rate @xmath2 and the longitudinal decay rate @xmath3 with the contributions of the transverse and longitudinal fields respectively . the dielectric - induced modification of the spontaneous emission rate in free space can be ascribed to two effects associated with the bulk ( macroscopic ) field in the medium and the other arising from the local ( microscopic ) field . the bulk field correction multiplies the rate by the refractive index at the transition frequency @xcite . local - field corrections present more of a problem and have a form that is strongly model - dependent . for the clausius - mosotti model , which introduces a virtual cavity surrounding the atom , a classical treatment of the local - field corrections leads to the form @xcite @xmath4 for the transverse decay rate of an atom in a bulk dielectric of refractive index @xmath5 @xmath6 @xmath7 @xmath8 @xmath9 @xmath10 . in eq . ( [ 1 ] ) , @xmath11 @xmath7 @xmath12 is the free - space spontaneous emission rate , where @xmath13 and @xmath14 are , respectively , the atomic transition frequency and the dipole transition matrix element . the local field correction in eq . ( [ 1 ] ) arises from writing the local electric field in terms of the macroscopic electric field and the commonly used induced polarization field . it does not , however , take account of the fluctuating component of polarization associated with absorption losses . in this paper we investigate the changes that arise within the clausius - mosotti model when this fluctuating component is included . recently , a scheme for quantizing the electromagnetic field in an arbitrary linear dielectric medium has been proven to be consistent with qed @xcite . it relies on the introduction of an appropriately chosen infinite set of basic - field operators @xcite and their connection to the electromagnetic field operators via the classical green function . this scheme is a generalization of the approach introduced by huttner and barnett @xcite based on a hopfield model @xcite of a homogeneous dielectric using fano diagonalization @xcite to obtain collective ( polariton ) excitations of the electromagnetic field , the polarization and the reservoir . as we will show below , the scheme can also be applied to local - field quantization that is consistent with qed and used for calculating the modified spontaneous decay rate including the local quantum effects of the fluctuating medium polarization . the paper is organized as follows . after a short review of the quantization scheme in sect . [ quantization ] we introduce the quantum local - field correction in sect . [ localfield ] . we then apply the scheme to the calculation of the spontaneous decay rates in sect . [ emission ] followed by some concluding remarks in sect . [ conclusions ] . details of the calculation will be given in the appendix . we begin with a brief review of the quantization scheme used throughout the paper . further details can be found in @xcite . the spectral decomposition of the electric and magnetic field operators is given by @xmath15 where @xmath16 and @xmath17 satisfy maxwell s equations @xmath18 & = & \underline{\hat{\rho}}({\bf r},\omega ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath19 [ @xmath20 @xmath7 @xmath21 @xmath9 @xmath22 is the permittivity ] . the operator noise current density @xmath23 and the operator noise charge density @xmath24 , which had to be introduced in order to be consistent with the dissipation - fluctuation theorem , are related to the noise polarization @xmath25 as @xmath26 and satisfy the equation of continuity @xmath27 the operator noise current density @xmath28 is obtained from a bosonic vector field @xmath29 , @xmath30 & = & \delta_{ij } \delta({\bf r - r ' } ) \delta(\omega-\omega ' ) , \\ \left [ \hat{f}_i({\bf r},\omega ) , \hat{f}_j({\bf r'},\omega ' ) \right ] & = & \left [ \hat{f}_i^\dagger({\bf r},\omega ) , \hat{f}_j^\dagger({\bf r'},\omega ' ) \right ] = 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the quantization scheme implies that all electromagnetic field operators can be expressed in terms of the basic fields @xmath29 , which may be regarded as being the collective excitations of the electromagnetic field , the medium polarization , and the reservoir . for example , the electric - field operator @xmath31 satisfies the partial differential equation @xmath32 such that @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the tensor - valued green function of the classical problem . it can then be proven @xcite that this quantization scheme is fully consistent with qed for arbitrary linear dielectrics . if we think of an atom located at some space point @xmath35 inside the dielectric , then the macroscopic field of sect . [ quantization ] will not , in fact , be the field felt by the atom . from classical electrodynamics we know that we should introduce what is called the local field at the location of the atom @xcite . there are essentially two ways of introducing the local field . first , one could cut out a _ real _ cavity @xcite ( most commonly a sphere ) around the atom and calculate , in our scheme , the electric field inside the cavity according to eq . ( [ 15 ] ) . this would lead us to introduce the electric field operator @xmath36 by the relation @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the green function of the classical problem of an inhomogeneous medium that consists of the real cavity surrounded by the dielectric in which the atom is embedded . to avoid the solution of the inhomogeneous problem , commonly a simpler _ virtual_-cavity model of clausius - mosotti - type is used . in this model the local field is ( approximately ) related to the macroscopic field , which in our scheme can be obtained according eq . ( [ 15 ] ) , with the green function for the bulk - medium problem . in classical optics the electric field is usually corrected by adding a term proportional to the polarization , @xmath39 where @xmath40 \underline{\bf e}({\bf r},\omega ) , \ ] ] from which it follows that @xmath41 \underline{\bf e}({\bf r},\omega ) .\ ] ] this classically corrected local field is just the field used for the derivation of the rate formula ( [ 1 ] ) . in classical optics ( [ 18 ] ) corresponds to the zero - temperature limit . it does not , however , hold in operator form in quantum optics . regarding eq . ( [ 18 ] ) as an operator equation would strongly contradict the qed equal - time commutation relations in general , so that the operator counterpart of eq . ( [ 18a ] ) will not be a true electric field . in order to obtain a canonical operator equation , we have to complement eq . ( [ 18 ] ) by a noise polarization @xmath42 : @xmath43 \underline{\hat{\bf e}}({\bf r},\omega ) + \underline{\hat{\bf p}}{^n}({\bf r},\omega ) .\ ] ] using the quantization scheme in sec . [ quantization ] , from eq . ( [ 8 ] ) the noise polarization @xmath42 is given by @xmath44 combining eqs . ( [ 17 ] ) and ( [ 20 ] ) , a local electric - field operator @xmath45 \underline{\hat{\bf e}}({\bf r},\omega ) + \frac{1}{3\epsilon_0 } \,\underline{\hat{\bf p}}{^n}({\bf r},\omega)\end{aligned}\ ] ] can be introduced , with @xmath42 being given in eq . ( [ 21 ] ) . in order to prove the consistency of the quantized local field with qed , we compute the ( equal - time ) commutation relation between the fundamental local fields @xmath46 and @xmath47 . for this purpose we note that the local magnetic - field operator is given by , on using eqs . ( [ 6 ] ) , @xmath48 where the symbol @xmath49 stands for the principal part . recalling eqs . ( [ 2 ] ) and ( [ 3 ] ) , the local - field operators in real space are @xmath50 and @xmath51 expressing the local electric and magnetic fields in terms of the basic fields @xmath29 , from the calculation given in app . [ appendix ] it is found that @xmath52 } \nonumber\\&&\hspace{2ex } = \ , - \frac{i\hbar}{\epsilon_0 } \epsilon_{ikl } \partial_l^{r } \delta({\bf r}-{\bf r ' } ) \left\{1+{\textstyle\frac{1}{9}}\big[\epsilon({\bf r},0)-1\big]\right\ } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and it is easily seen that @xmath53 = \left [ \hat{b}_i{^{\!\!\rm loc}}({\bf r } ) , \hat{b}_k{^{\!\!\rm loc}}({\bf r'})\right ] = 0 .\ ] ] the result reveals that the local - electric field operator ( [ 22 ] ) and the associated magnetic field operator ( [ 24 ] ) can be regarded as being consistent with quantum theory , provided that the ( real ) static permittivity @xmath54 @xmath7 @xmath55 satisfies the condition @xmath56 equivalently , the static refractive index @xmath57 @xmath7 @xmath58 must be small compared with @xmath59 @xmath60 @xmath61 . it should be noted that a term proportional to the @xmath62 function @xmath63 can be added to the right - hand side of eq . ( [ 24 ] ) in order to recover ampere s law when the equation is multiplied by @xmath64 . obviously , this ambiguity reflects the fact that the static magnetic field can not be inferred from the static electric field . from a simple calculation it can be shown that such a term does not change the commutation relation ( [ 27 ] ) . since it is only relevant at zero frequency , it does not play any role in the calculation of the decay at transition frequency @xmath13 . in order to take into account a possible deviation of the symmetry of the material from cubic symmetry , a structure constant @xmath65 can be included in eq . ( [ 17 ] ) such that @xcite @xmath66 \ , \underline{\bf p}({\bf r},\omega).\ ] ] regarding this equation as an operator equation with @xmath67 from eq . ( [ 20 ] ) and following the line in appendix [ appendix ] , it can be seen that eq . ( [ 27 ] ) changes to @xmath68 } \nonumber\\&&\hspace{2ex } = \ , - \frac{i\hbar}{\epsilon_0 } \epsilon_{ikl } \partial_l^{r } \delta({\bf r}-{\bf r ' } ) \left\{1+\frac{\alpha^2}{9}\big[\epsilon({\bf r},0)-1\big]\right\ } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the parameter @xmath69 in related to @xmath65 by @xmath70 thus , consistency with quantum theory is achieved , if the condition @xmath71 is fulfilled . the spontaneous decay rate of a ( two - level ) atom at transition frequency @xmath13 placed at point @xmath35 is given by @xmath72 ( @xmath73 @xmath74 @xmath75 ) . in what follows we consider a homogeneous bulk material , i.e. , @xmath20 @xmath76 @xmath77 , and assume that the inequality ( [ 27a ] ) is fulfilled . using eq . ( [ 22 ] ) , the vacuum expectation value of the local electric - field operators in the limit can be written as the sum @xmath78 where @xmath16 and @xmath42 are given by eqs . ( [ 15 ] ) and ( [ 21 ] ) respectively . the green function @xmath79 for the bulk material in the limit @xmath73 @xmath74 @xmath35 has the form @xmath80 ( @xmath81 @xmath7 @xmath82 @xmath83 @xmath75 ) , where @xmath84 \delta_{ij } \right\ } + { \cal o}(r)\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath85 + { \cal o}(r)\end{aligned}\ ] ] are the transverse and longitudinal parts respectively . we see that the real part of the transverse green function as well as the longitudinal part itself diverge as , reflecting the fact that a macroscopic approach is valid only to some appropriately fixed scale @xmath86 which exceeds the average distance of two atoms in the dielectric . following @xcite , we average the divergent terms in the decay rate over a sphere of radius @xmath86 . we will see later that one can estimate an upper bound for @xmath86 from the decay rate itself . the first term on the right - hand side in eq . ( [ 31 ] ) gives the contribution to the decay rate with the classically corrected local field @xcite , @xmath87,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the transverse rate @xmath88 being given in eq . ( [ 1 ] ) . the second term in eq . ( [ 31 ] ) is purely a contribution of the noise polarization field and is given by @xmath89 the cross - terms mixing the macroscopic electric field and the noise polarization field give rise to the contribution @xmath90 \delta(\omega\!-\!\omega ' ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence , the total decay rate reads @xmath91.\end{aligned}\ ] ] equation ( [ 35 ] ) is remarkable in the sense that inclusion of the polarization noise in the local field gives rise to a term that only results from that noise and leads to a dependence of the decay rate on the real part of the green function . we average the @xmath62 tensor @xmath92 and the green tensor ( [ 36 ] ) over the sphere and obtain @xmath93 @xmath94 \delta_{ij } , \\ { \rm re}\ , \overline{g^\|_{ij}({\bf r},\omega_a ) } & = & -\frac{c^2\epsilon_r(\omega_a ) } { 4\pi\omega_a^2 |\epsilon(\omega_a)|^2 \bar{r}^3 } \,\delta_{ij } , \\ { \rm im}\ , \overline{g^\perp_{ij}({\bf r},\omega_a ) } & = & \frac{\omega_a \eta(\omega_a)}{6\pi c } \,\delta_{ij } , \\ { \rm im}\ , \overline{g^\|_{ij}({\bf r},\omega_a ) } & = & \frac{c^2\epsilon_i(\omega_a)}{4\pi \omega_a^2 |\epsilon(\omega_a)|^2 \bar{r}^3 } \ , \delta_{ij}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and eq . ( [ 35 ] ) can be given in the form of eq . ( [ 0 ] ) , where @xmath2 and @xmath3 read as @xmath95 } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{5ex } -\,\epsilon_i(\omega_a ) \left [ \epsilon_r(\omega_a)+2 \right ] \bigg [ \frac{2}{9}\,\kappa(\omega_a)-\frac{c}{3\omega_a \bar{r } } \bigg ] \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{5ex } + \ , \frac{c^3 \epsilon_i(\omega_a)}{3 \omega_a^3 \bar{r}^3 } \bigg\ } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath96 -\frac{2}{9 } \,\big[\epsilon_i(\omega_a ) \big]^2 \bigg\ } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the modifications near a medium resonance are clear . note that owing to the quantum local - field correction the unspecified parameter @xmath86 also enters into the transverse decay rate . in order to compare our canonical result with that obtained using the classically corrected local field , we use , for comparison , the same lorentz model for the permittivity of a single - resonance medium as in @xcite , @xmath97 where @xmath98 is the resonance frequency of the medium . figures [ gamma001][gamma01 ] show the transverse decay rate @xmath2 with and without quantum local - field corrections as a function of the atomic transition frequency @xmath13 for different values of the damping parameter of the medium , @xmath99 , and the parameter @xmath100 first of all , for small @xmath101 , i.e. , large virtual - cavity radius @xmath86 one observes little reduction of spontaneous decay for frequencies @xmath13 just above the resonance frequency @xmath98 . its possible applications in semiconductor physics and solid - state physics has already been discussed @xcite . the greatest difference between the quantum - mechanically and classically corrected transverse decay rates @xmath2 and @xmath102 , respectively , arises near the medium resonance when @xmath99 is small . both the imaginary part of the permittivity and the real part can take very large values for @xmath13 @xmath60 @xmath103 and in consequence @xmath2 can drastically change compared with @xmath102 . obviously , in the resonance regime the noise polarization essentially contributes to the local - field and therefore strongly influences @xmath2 . for small values of @xmath99 both qualitative and quantitative differences between the rates @xmath2 and @xmath102 are observed ( fig . [ gamma001 ] ) . with increasing value of @xmath99 the two rates become less different from each other , the changes being quantitative rather than qualitatitive ( compare fig . [ gamma001 ] with fig . [ gamma01 ] ) . whereas @xmath102 is independent of the radius @xmath86 of the virtual cavity , @xmath2 sensitively depends on @xmath86 . to fix the value of @xmath86 that is undetermined in the clausius - mosotti model , experimental data could be used in principle ( for recent experiments on spontaneous emission , see , e.g. , @xcite ) . it is worth noting that our theory gives an upper bound @xmath104 , i.e. , a lower bound @xmath105 for the parameter @xmath101 , because of the fact that @xmath2 can not be negative . as already mentioned , the limit @xmath73 @xmath74 @xmath75 in eq . ( [ 28 ] ) can not be performed and averaging over a sphere of radius @xmath86 can give negative values , if the radius is not small enough , because the vacuum expectation value of the hermitian operator @xmath106 is not necessarily positive . figure [ rmax ] presents @xmath105 as a function of the damping parameter @xmath99 . the curve was obtained numerically by requiring that @xmath2 must not be negative over the whole frequency spectrum . figure [ gamma001 ] shows that for chosen ( small ) @xmath99 and @xmath101 @xmath107 @xmath108 negative values of @xmath2 may appear when the atomic transition frequency @xmath13 approaches the medium resonance frequency @xmath98 and is in an interval that corresponds to the polariton bandgap between @xmath98 and @xmath109 @xmath7 @xmath110^{1/2}$ ] in the hopfield model of a dielectric in the absence of absorption @xcite . obviously , in this regime of spontaneous decay , in which the decay rate is expected to respond to a change in the local - field noise very sensitively , the clausius - mosotti model has to be replaced with a refined model , at least in quantum theory . from the standard derivation of the ( classical ) clausius - mosotti local - field ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) the radius @xmath86 of the virtual cavity should be larger than the average distance of two neighboring atoms but sufficiently smaller than the optical wavelength . in terms of the parameter @xmath101 , the latter requirement means that @xmath101 @xmath111 @xmath112 . provided that the damping parameter @xmath99 is not too small , this is in agreement with the condition that the parameter @xmath101 should not be smaller than @xmath108 given in fig . within the frame of the clausius - mosotti model we have studied the influence of the quantum local - field correction arising from the noise polarization on the spontaneous decay rate of an excited atom embedded in an absorbing medium . we have shown that inclusion in the local field of the noise polarization ensures that the local field fulfills the fundamental equal - time commutation relations of qed , provided that the static refractive index of the medium does not exceed unity substantially . the calculated rates demonstrate that the contribution of the noise polarization to the local field is extremely important and can not be ignored . in particular , at the resonance frequencies of the medium the transverse decay rate can drastically change compared with the classically corrected rate where the fluctuating component of the polarization is omitted . the decay rate crucially depends on the choice of the radius of the virtual cavity . it is worth noting that from the dependence on the radius of the transverse rate an effect that only results from the noise polarization a second condition of validity can be imposed on the local - field model . in order to obtain for any transition frequency a positive transverse decay rate , the cavity radius must not exceed some upper bound . the clausius - mosotti virtual - cavity model is commonly based on the assumption that the near field that arises from the atoms inside the cavity averages to zero in general . in quantum optics this assumption may fail , because of the vacuum noise associated with this field , which may be an explanation for the restrictions found . in order to extend the range of validity of the theory , a more refined concept seems to be necessary that considers the near field more carefully . from eq . ( [ 22 ] ) together with eq . ( [ 21 ] ) , the local electric field operator reads in fourier space @xmath113 combining eqs . ( [ 24 ] ) and ( [ a1 ] ) , we obtain for the local magnetic field in fourier space @xmath114 .\ ] ] recalling eqs . ( [ 25 ] ) and ( [ 26 ] ) , from eqs . ( [ a1 ] ) and ( [ a2 ] ) together with eq . ( [ 15 ] ) the local electric and magnetic fields are given by @xmath115 \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{0ex } + \,\frac{1}{3\epsilon_0 } \,\sqrt{\frac{\hbar\epsilon_0}{\pi } } \int_0^\infty d\omega \left [ i\sqrt{\epsilon_i({\bf r},\omega ) } \,\hat{f}_i({\bf r},\omega ) + \mbox{h.c . } \right ] , \\ \label{a4 } \hat{b}_k{^{\!\!\rm loc}}({\bf r ' } ) & = & \epsilon_{klm } \partial_l^{r ' } \bigg\ { \sqrt{\frac{\hbar\epsilon_0}{\pi } } \,{\cal p}\ ! \int_0^\infty d\omega ' \int d^3{\bf s ' } \bigg [ \frac{\epsilon({\bf r'},\omega')\!+\!2}{3\epsilon_0 } \,\frac{\omega'}{c^2 } \,\sqrt{\epsilon_i({\bf s'},\omega ' ) } \,g_{mn}({\bf r'},{\bf s'},\omega ' ) \hat{f}_n({\bf s'},\omega ' ) + \mbox{h.c . } \bigg ] \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{0ex } + \,\frac{1}{3\epsilon_0 } \,\sqrt{\frac{\hbar\epsilon_0}{\pi } } \,{\cal p}\!\int_0^\infty \frac{d\omega'}{\omega ' } \left [ \sqrt{\epsilon_i({\bf r'},\omega ' ) } \,\hat{f}_m({\bf r'},\omega ' ) + \mbox{h.c . } \right ] \bigg\ } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , the ( equal - time ) commutator between the local electric and magnetic fields can be given by @xmath116 } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{2ex } = \,\frac{\hbar\epsilon_0}{\pi } \epsilon_{klm } \,\partial_l^{r ' } \bigg\ { { \cal p}\!\int_0^\infty \!d\omega \int d^3{\bf s } \bigg [ \frac{i\omega^3}{c^4 } \,\frac{\epsilon({\bf r},\omega)\!+\!2}{3\epsilon_0 } \,\frac{\epsilon^\ast({\bf r'},\omega)\!+\!2}{3\epsilon_0 } \,\epsilon_i({\bf s},\omega ) g_{ij}({\bf r},{\bf s},\omega ) g_{mj}^\ast({\bf r'},{\bf s},\omega ) -\mbox{c.c . } \bigg ] \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{2ex } + \,\frac{1}{3\epsilon_0 } \,{\cal p}\!\int_0^\infty d\omega \bigg [ \frac{\epsilon^\ast({\bf r'},\omega)\!+\!2}{3\epsilon_0 } \,\frac{i\omega}{c^2 } \,\epsilon_i({\bf r},\omega ) g_{mi}^\ast({\bf r'},{\bf r},\omega ) -\mbox{c.c . } \bigg ] \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{2ex } + \,\frac{1}{3\epsilon_0}\ , { \cal p}\!\int_0^\infty d\omega \bigg [ \frac{\epsilon({\bf r},\omega)\!+\!2}{3\epsilon_0 } \,\frac{i\omega}{c^2 } \,\epsilon_i({\bf r}',\omega ) g_{im}({\bf r},{\bf r'},\omega ) -\mbox{c.c . } \bigg ] \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{2ex } + \,\frac{2i}{9\epsilon_0 ^ 2 } \,{\cal p } \!\int_0^\infty \frac{d\omega}{\omega } \left [ \epsilon_i({\bf r},\omega ) \delta_{im } \delta({\bf r}-{\bf r ' } ) \right ] \bigg\ } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the remaining spatial integral in eq . ( [ a5 ] ) can be calculated using the symmetry relation @xmath117 the crossing relation @xmath118 and the integral relation @xcite @xmath119 .\ ] ] straightforward calculation yields @xmath120 = \frac{\hbar}{\pi\epsilon_0}\ , \epsilon_{klm } \partial_l^{r ' } \left[i^{(1)}_{im}({\bf r},{\bf r ' } ) + i^{(2)}_{im}({\bf r},{\bf r ' } ) \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath121 + \frac{1}{3 } \left [ \epsilon({\bf r'},\omega ) \!-\!1 \right ] + { \textstyle \frac{1}{9 } } \left [ \epsilon({\bf r},\omega)\!-\!1 \right ] \left [ \epsilon({\bf r'},\omega)-1 \right ] \right\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath122 closing the integration contour in the upper complex frequency half - plane and following the line in @xcite , we derive that @xmath123 recalling the kramers kronig relations , the @xmath64 integral in eq . ( [ a11 ] ) is easily performed to obtain @xmath124 \delta_{im } \delta({\bf r}-{\bf r ' } ) = \pi \left [ \epsilon({\bf r},0)\!-\!1 \right ] \delta_{im } \delta({\bf r}-{\bf r'}).\ ] ] combining eqs . ( [ a9 ] ) , ( [ a12 ] ) , and ( [ a13 ] ) then yields the commutation relation ( [ 27 ] ) .

a recently developed scheme [ s. scheel , l. knll , and d .- g . welsch , phys . rev . a * 58 * , 700 ( 1998 ) ] for quantizing the macroscopic electromagnetic field in linear dispersive and absorbing dielectrics satisfying the kramers - kronig relations is used to derive the quantum local - field correction for the standard virtual - sphere - cavity model . the electric and magnetic local - field operators are shown to be consistent with qed only if the polarization noise is fully taken into account . it is shown that the polarization fluctuations in the local field can dramatically change the spontaneous decay rate , compared with the familiar result obtained from the classical local - field correction . in particular , the spontaneous emission rate strongly depends on the radius of the local - field virtual cavity .

1301.3238

evolutionary game theory ( egt ) is becoming a general theoretical framework to analysis strategies behaviors @xcite . egt is rooted in the classical game theory ( cgt ) @xcite and the theory of evolution @xcite . different from cgt , egt predicts there could exist persistent cycles in the evolutionary trajectories in the strategy space @xcite . as an example let us consider the standard rock - paper - scissors ( rps ) game . this is a prototype game in textbooks @xcite . in this game , dynamics equations ( e.g. , the standard replicator dynamics equations ) in egt predict that the evolutionary trajectory will cycle around the nash equilibrium persistently . however , the cgt predicts full random behavior : the system is in a mixed - strategy equilibrium with each cyclic motion being balanced completely by its reverse cyclic motion . according to the cgt theory , cycles ( also referred to as excess loops ) can not be observed in the evolutionary trajectories in the long run @xcite . empirical examples of the rps cycles are constantly being discovered in nature , e.g. , three morphs male lizard @xcite and others @xcite . the environment for animal contests is decentralized , in which the encounter is pairwise , but population strategy shows cyclic behaviors @xcite . in general , human economic behaviors ( e.g. , exchanges ) are also pairwise and not centralized @xcite . to test egt in human game experiments @xcite , the traditional setting is decentralized ( see review @xcite ) , in which a subject in each round competes with one random - pairwise opponent within a finite population @xcite . in such traditional setting experiment , whether the trajectories are persistent cycles instead of convergence to a nash equilibrium remains an open question @xcite . till now , no persistent cycle has been confirmed in the rps experiment under such a traditional setting @xcite , and furthermore no dynamics observation has been reported quantitatively . in this paper we study the evolutionary trajectories of the rock - paper - scissors game from the perspective of non - equilibrium statistical physics . in non - equilibrium statistical physics studies , formulating a physically meaningful measure of the distance from equilibrium is an area of active research @xcite . an equilibrium system satisfies the detailed balance condition , which ensures the time reversal symmetry . however , detailed balance is broken in a non - equilibrium system even in its stationary state , therefore various dynamical patterns may show up in the evolutionary trajectory . several non - equilibrium order parameters , such as entropy production @xcite and velocity @xcite , have been constructed to characterize the distance from equilibrium . in this work we carry out laboratory experiments on the rps game , and we detect the possible existence of persistent cyclic flows using an angular frequency as the non - equilibrium order parameter . a non - zero angular frequency serves as a quantitative measure of the distance from equilibrium for the evolutionary trajectories . we also compare our experimental observations with the predictions of a simple non - equilibrium model , the discrete - time logit dynamical process with a noise parameter @xmath2 . our experiments are the standard rps games with the experimental setting of discrete time , random pairwise matching and local information . this setting has its reality in biology and economics @xcite . we collect a total number of twelve experimental trajectories from our experiments ( each trajectory is the result of @xmath3 rounds of the game ) and then analyze these trajectories . like other previous experiments @xcite and theories @xcite , the evolutionary trajectories are highly stochastic , but using our non - equilibrium order parameter we are able to confirm that cycles exist and do not dissipate . the mean frequency of cycles is about @xmath1 period per experimental round . this mean value is used to evaluate the noise parameter @xmath2 of the logit dynamics model , and a value of @xmath4 is obtained . this paper is organized as following . in the next section we introduce the standard rps game in the traditional setting and describe our data analysis protocol . in section [ sec : results ] we describe our main experimental results . the experimental results are compared with the predictions of the discrete - time logit dynamics model in section [ sec : model ] . we conclude this work in the last section . there are three different pure strategies in the rock - paper - scissors game , namely rock ( @xmath5 ) , paper ( @xmath5 ) and scissors ( @xmath6 ) . these three strategies form a directed circle @xmath7 , namely @xmath5 beats @xmath6 , @xmath6 beats @xmath8 , and @xmath8 in turn beats @xmath5 . in our experiments we use the simple payoff matrix shown in table [ rpspaoffmatrix ] to make the rps game a constant - sum game : in each play between two players , the winning player gets a payoff @xmath9 ( i.e. , two experimental points ) while the losing player gets a payoff @xmath10 ; if there is a tie then each player gets an equal payoff @xmath11 . .[rpspaoffmatrix ] payoff matrix of the rock - paper - scissors game . the value of each matrix element is the payoff of the row player s strategy given the strategy of the column player . [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ] the last four rows are the statistical results of the @xmath12 experimental groups above . the row titled as @xmath13-value is @xmath14-test result by setting the null hypothesis @xmath15 for the @xmath12 samples . 95%u(l ) means the upper ( lower ) bound of @xmath16 confidence interval over the @xmath12 samples . to theoretically understand the experimental observations , we now study a noisy best - response process as a simple model for the rps game , namely the discrete - time logit dynamics @xcite . multiple equilibria and limit cycles in the logit dynamics has also been studied in a very recent paper by hommes and ochea @xcite in the continuous - time limit . suppose the population of @xmath17 players is in the social state @xmath18 after the @xmath14-th round of the game . let us denote by @xmath19 the mean payoff of the strategy @xmath20 for this social state . from the payoff matrix of table [ rpspaoffmatrix ] we can easily obtain that @xmath21 we assume that at the @xmath22-round of the game , each player of the population will choose a strategy from @xmath23 independently of all the other players . and we further assume that the time - dependent probability @xmath24 for a player to choose strategy @xmath25 is @xmath26 the parameter @xmath2 is referred to as the inverse temperature " of the logit dynamics , its value quantifies the rationality degree of human agents in strategy interaction @xcite . in the limiting case of @xmath27 each strategy will be chosen with the uniform probability @xmath28 . for this simple markovian process , the transition probability @xmath29 from a social state @xmath18 at time @xmath14 to another social state @xmath30 at time @xmath22 is expressed as ( noticing that @xmath31 ) @xmath32 } } { ( e^ { \beta ( x + 2 z ) } + e^{\beta ( y + 2 x)}+ e^{\beta ( z + 2 y ) } ) ^n } \ ; . \label{eq : transition}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the steady - state probability @xmath33 that the system is in the social state @xmath18 at @xmath34 can be obtained by solving the following fixed - point equation @xmath35 because the transition probability from any social state @xmath18 to any another social state @xmath30 is positive , eq . ( [ eq : fixedpoint ] ) has a unique solution with the normalization property @xmath36 @xcite . it is not difficult to prove that the steady - state probability distribution has the following rotational symmetry @xmath37 this rotational symmetry ensures that @xmath38 namely the logit dynamics will reach the nash equilibrium @xmath39 at @xmath40 . it can be checked numerically and analytically that , for any @xmath41 , the detailed balance condition is violated at the steady - state of the logit dynamics . for two different social states @xmath42 and @xmath30 , in general we will find that @xmath43 because of the violation of detailed balance , directional flows may persist in the system even at @xmath40 . the steady - state mean cycling frequency @xmath44 of the discrete - time logit dynamical process with population size @xmath0 . the solid line is theoretical result obtained with eq . ( [ def : freq - theta ] ) ; the cross ( @xmath45 ) symbols with error bars are obtained by averaging over many simulated evolutionary trajectories of length @xmath3 . the mean experimental frequency of @xmath46 and its @xmath16 confidence upper and lower bound are marked by the dashed lines . ] we are especially interested in the directional flow around the nash equilibrium point . consider two social states @xmath18 and @xmath30 on the evolutionary trajectory at two consecutive time points @xmath14 and @xmath47 . if either @xmath18 or @xmath30 is identical to the nash equilibrium point , the transition @xmath48 is _ not _ a rotational motion around the nash equilibrium , and we set the corresponding rotational angle @xmath49 to be zero . the nash equilibrium point may be sitting on the rectilinear line that passing through the social states @xmath18 and @xmath50 . if this is the case , the transition @xmath51 is also _ not _ a rotational motion around the nash equilibrium , and its rotational angle @xmath49 is again set to be zero . in all the remaining cases , the social states @xmath18 , @xmath30 and the nash equilibrium point form a triangle in the social state plane of fig . [ fig:28state ] . the magnitude of the rotational angle @xmath49 is just the angle of this triangle at vertex point @xmath52 , it must be less than @xmath53 . the rotational angle @xmath49 is defined as positive if the rotation from @xmath18 to @xmath54 with respect to the nash equilibrium point is counter - clockwise , otherwise it is defined as negative . at the steady - state of the discrete - time logit dynamics , the mean frequency @xmath44 that the evolution trajectory rotates around the nash equilibrium point can then be computed by the following formula @xmath55 probability of staying in the social state @xmath42 for a population of size @xmath0 . the horizontal axis is the predicted probability by the discrete - time logit dynamics model with inverse temperature @xmath56 , while the vertical axis is the empirical probability measured from the @xmath12 experimental trajectories . because of the rotational symmetry ( [ eq : rotation ] ) , the @xmath57 social states can be coarse - grained into ten groups : ( 1 ) , @xmath58 ; ( 2 ) , @xmath59 ; ( 3 ) , @xmath60 ; ( 4 ) , @xmath61 ; ( 5 ) , @xmath62 ; ( 6 ) , @xmath63 ; ( 7 ) , @xmath64 ; ( 8) , @xmath65 ; ( 9 ) , @xmath66 ; ( 10 ) , @xmath67 . all the social states of a given group have the same stationary probability ( the same horizontal - axis value ) according to the theoretical model , but their measured probabilities might be different ( the mean vertical - axis value and the standard error ) . ] for the population size @xmath0 , we show in fig . [ fig : anglen6 ] the steady - state mean frequency @xmath44 as a function of the inverse temperature @xmath2 . to check the correctness of the theoretical calculations , we also perform computer simulations based on the discrete - time logit dynamics model to generate a set of simulated evolutionary trajectories of length @xmath3 . the mean cycling frequencies of these simulated evolutionary trajectories are also shown in fig . [ fig : anglen6 ] . the agreement between analytical calculations and computer simulation results are very good . we find that @xmath44 increases almost linearly with the inverse temperature @xmath2 when @xmath68 . comparing the theoretical results with the mean frequency value of @xmath69 , we infer the inverse parameter should be set to @xmath56 . at @xmath56 , we also perform computer simulations based on the discrete - time logic dynamics model to generate a set of independent evolution trajectories of length @xmath70 . we then perform the same analysis on these trajectories and find that the direction of the cycles is counter - clockwise and the mean cycling frequency is @xmath71 , consistent with the experimental result . at @xmath72 , the steady - state probability @xmath33 of visiting each social state @xmath18 as predicted by the logit dynamics is compared with the empirically observed probability of visiting @xmath18 , see fig . [ fig : wvalues ] . the agreement between theory and experiment is again very good . although the discrete - time noisy - response logit dynamic model can describe our experimental observations excellently , we should point out an important difference between the model assumption and the experimental setting . in our experiments , after each round of the game , each player only knows the strategy of her / his opponent but not the social state of the whole population . however in the logit dynamics model , we assume that each player choose a strategy based on the knowledge of the current social state of the population , see eq . ( [ logitdyn ] ) . in this sense , the logit dynamics model is still a phenomenological model . it is of interest to quantitatively describe the rps evolutionary dynamics by a more microscopic model . we hope to return to this issue in a future study . as a brief summary , in this work we studied the rock - paper - scissors game both experimentally and analytically . our experimental data gave strong evidence that counter - clockwise cycles around the nash equilibrium point exist in the social - state evolutionary trajectory of a finte population . we demonstrated that our experimental observations can be quantitatively understood by a simple theoretical model of noisy - response logit dynamics . rps game experiments on egt were also reported quite recently by cason and co - authors and by hoffman and co - authors @xcite . the backgrounds and cutting edges of the experiment research are well documented in these two references @xcite . compared with the decentralized setting of our present work , the experimental environments of the rps game in these two recent works @xcite are all centralized : instead of pairwise meetings , in all of the experiments reported in @xcite , each subject competes against the choices of all other subjects . however , the decentralized setting ( especially the random matching pairwise setting ) is more closer to the natural environments in biology and economics ( e.g. , @xcite ) . for example , the encounters of male lizards are pairwise meetings @xcite . for decentralized population rps games , according to our knowledge , the existence of persistent cyclic motions was not confirmed by any previous laboratory experiments . going back to traditional ( decentralized ) setting experiments of the simplest rps game , the present work added strong evidence in favor of the existence of persistent cycles . as a fundamental observation on cycle , the mean frequency of cycles was quantitatively meassured . there are tens of dynamics models which have been build to interpret cyclic behavior in rps game , however there are rare quantitative observations from real experiments . quantitative measurements from experiments is important , without which to evaluate a dynamics equation precisely is almost impossible ( or plausible ) . as demonstrated , our experimental observations can be quantitatively understood by a simple theoretical model of noisy - response logit dynamics . we wish to emphasize two major points of our experimental approach . first , by recording sufficiently long evolutionary trajectories , we were able to detect weak deterministic motion in a highly stochastic process . we noticed that cycles can only be confirmed ( @xmath73 ) when the trajectories are longer than @xmath74 rounds in twelve samples . second , we focus on time asymmetry of social state transitions . importance of time asymmetry has been well emphasised in non - equilibrium statistical physics @xcite . the frequency is observed from the loops out of detailed balance . we thank ken binmore for helpful discussion and zunfeng wang for technical assistance . the work of b.x . and z.w . was supported by a grant from the 985 project at zhejiang university and by skltp of itp - cas ( no . y3kf261cj1 ) . the work of h.j.z . was supported by the knowledge innovation program of chinese academy of sciences ( no . kjcx2-ew - j02 ) and the national science foundation of china ( grant no . 11121403 and 11225526 ) . g. wang , e. sevick , e. mittag , d. searles , d. evans , experimental demonstration of violations of the second law of thermodynamics for small systems and short time scales , phys . ( 2002 ) 50601 .

the rock - paper - scissors ( rps ) game is a widely used model system in game theory . evolutionary game theory predicts the existence of persistent cycles in the evolutionary trajectories of the rps game , but experimental evidence has remained to be rather weak . in this work we performed laboratory experiments on the rps game and analyzed the social - state evolutionary trajectories of twelve populations of @xmath0 players . we found strong evidence supporting the existence of persistent cycles . the mean cycling frequency was measured to be @xmath1 period per experimental round . our experimental observations can be quantitatively explained by a simple non - equilibrium model , namely the discrete - time logit dynamical process with a noise parameter . our work therefore favors the evolutionary game theory over the classical game theory for describing the dynamical behavior of the rps game . rock - paper - scissors game ; cycle ; social state ; population dynamics ; evolutionary trajectory

0909.5469

it is well - established that the best solution of the solar neutrino oscillation is msw - lma ; this is strongly supported by many experiments results@xcite@xcite@xcite@xcite@xcite . for this solution it is expected that the @xmath0 survival probability in the low energy region ( @xmath11 mev ) is higher than in the high energy region ( @xmath210 mev ) , because for low energies vacuum oscillation is dominant while for high energies matter oscillation is dominant . so a transition from vacuum to matter oscillation should exist , roughly between 1.0 and 10.0 mev , in the energy range in which solar neutrinos predominate . the recoil electron energy threshold of super - kamioakande is around 5 mev , so super - kamiokande has a chance to discover the low - energy upturn in the spectrum . to realize this goal , reducing background and systematic uncertainty below 5.5 mev and lowering the recoil electron energy threshold are important @xcite . if we can take 5 years of 4 mev threshold data with 70% reduced background below 5.5 mev and half the energy - correlated systematic uncertainty compared to sk - i , we should observe a spectrum as shown in fig . [ fig4 ] and might discover this energy spectrum distortion . so , starting with the data of sk - iii , making these detector and analysis improvements has been high priority work . since the end of sk - i , we have worked hard to reduce background and systematic uncertainties , improving several key items . the following sections will introduce some of them . a major background for the solar neutrino observation at sk is the radioactivity from radon ( rn ) in our otherwise extremely pure water . this ultra - pure water which fills the detector is made from natural mine water using a very high efficiency water purification system . the rn background events are very similar to solar events , so it is very difficult to remove them using only analysis tools . as a result , many rn events could be included in the final data set . to reduce this background , the improvement of the rn reduction efficiency of the sk water purification system is the most effective approach . so , since the end of sk - i we have upgraded the system several times , including the addition of a new heat exchanger and two reverse osmosis units for sk - iii . in addition , we investigated the water flow in the tank by purposefully injecting radon - enriched water . tracing the resulting background events in time from this injected rn , we found stagnation of water in the top and bottom of the detector volume which increased the background . to counter this effect we installed new pipes and changed the water flow . previously , the water was supplied from the bottom of the inner detector ( i d ) and drained from the top of both the i d and outer detector ( od ) . now , it is supplied from the i d bottom and drained from the top and bottom in the i d and od , with a total flow two times faster than before . as a result we have a central region with half the background ( yellow box in fig . [ figver ] ) as compared with sk - i , making lowering of the energy threshold a possibility . note that the excessive background near the wall and bottom of sk - iii also existed in sk - ii . this background is from the fiber reinforced plastic ( frp ) pmt covers which were added at the start of sk - ii in order to protect against propagating shock waves from pmt implosions , and so could not be reduced by improving the water system . it posed a significant obstacle to enlarging the fiducial volume below 6.5 mev . the vertex shift , defined as a vector from an averaged position of the reconstructed vertices of the data to that of corresponding monte carlo ( mc ) data , has been one of the main systematic uncertainties for the solar neutrino flux measurement since the beginning of sk - i@xcite . because it could make events move in or out of the fiducial volume , it is a non - negligible systematic uncertainty . vertex shift is measured by placing a ni - cf gamma ray source at several positions of the tank . the reconstructed data vertices were shifted more than 10 cm from the real source position inward toward the tank center , in contrast those of mc which were shifted less than 10 cm . the origin of the excessive shift of the data was a mystery since sk - i . in sk - iii , we investigated this mystery , resolving it just ten days before the end of sk - iii . it turned out that relative hit timing within a wide range ( @xmath3100 nsec ) was not perfect due to characteristics of our electronics . we measured the timing linearity by artificially shifting the external trigger timing , a common stop signal of individual tdcs for each hit channel . we found that hit timing should be corrected -0.7@xmath4 to restore linearity . after the correction was applied the vertex shift shortened significantly ( see fig . [ figversh ] ) . as a result , the background events around the wall ( inside brown ellipse ) were reduced and the fiducial volume between 5.0 and 6.5 mev could be enlarged up to 13.3 kton ( fig . [ figver_vs ] ) . in addition , we can apply the same correction for sk - i / ii and expect to reduce the systematic uncertainty of the sk - i / ii data , because the sk - iii daq is the same as that of sk - i / ii . time variation of data ( black ) and mc ( red ) over the full sk - iii period with fixed water transparency.,width=302 ] of several positions before and after the position dependent mc installation , width=302 ] that the water quality in sk changes as a function of time was known ; the sk - i mc took it into account @xcite . in sk - iii we also measured the time variation of the water transparency using @xmath5-@xmath6 decay data , as well as the wavelength dependence of various scattering and absorption water coefficients using a nitrogen / dye laser system @xcite . using the full period of sk - iii , we investigated possible relationships among the water transparency and water coefficients and found , similar to sk - i , the only apparent connection was between water transparency and the absorption coefficients . so we installed the absorption coefficients as a function of the water transparency measured by @xmath5-@xmath6 decay data and the scattering coefficients as a constant for the water transparency . as a result we had a time dependent mc . we tested this mc with muon decay data . figure [ figtimdecaye ] shows the @xmath7 time variation of data and mc in sk - iii assuming a fixed water transparency . @xmath7 is the effective number of hits to yield the same value at any position in the sk tank by applying several corrections to the number of hits @xcite . one such correction takes into account the water transparency . to observe the effect of the time variation of water transparency directly , we did nt apply this correction , and confirmed that mc tracks the data properly . we also found a position dependence in the water quality . the existence of position dependence due to the water flow has been debated since sk - i . we installed light injectors on the barrel of the detector and tried to find it , but this method could nt resolve the question . finally , in sk - iii , using several calibration sources we concluded that position dependence not only exists but also changes as a function of time . so we made a position dependent mc by installing a z - dependence in the water coefficients varied by the so - called top - bottom asymmetry as measured using calibration data over the full sk - iii data - taking period . we tested this mc with calibration data @xcite . we took the data at several positions(fig . [ figdtp ] ) . before correction the difference between data and mc was @xmath33% at the top of the detector , @xmath32% in the center , and @xmath31% at the bottom , but after correction was less than 1% at the top and in the center . however , the difference at the bottom became larger ; it still needs improvement . another large source of systematic uncertainty in sk - i is the angular resolution @xcite . because this uncertainty comes essentially from the hit pattern difference between data and mc , we must tune the mc to reduce the uncertainty . the mc was tuned several times . daq - related items like single photoelectron response , timing resolution , etc . , and optical properties like scattering and absorption coefficients , the reflectance of pmts , etc . , were tuned using several calibration sources , as was done for sk - i @xcite . when we calculated the difference of the angular resolution of data and mc , their agreement was not improved compared with sk - i . so we explored several optical properties using mc , finally finding that halving the original value for the reflectivity of a black sheet which covers the i d wall gave better agreement . until that time we used the sk - ii value for black sheet reflectivity , even though the materials of sk - ii / iii black sheet are different . to confirm this finding , we put a light injector with a black sheet reflector into the sk tank and measured the amount of direct light and reflected light for specific incident angles . figure [ example_black ] shows the ratio of the amount of charge due to reflected light versus direct light of data ( black ) and half reflectivity mc ( red ) . this shows reasonable agreement , even if the 337 nm result ( upper figure ) still needs tuning . next , we improved the direction fitter itself . in essence , the likelihood function that represents the distribution of the opening angle between the particle direction and the vector from the reconstructed vetex to the hit pmt position was improved . in sk - i it was made for 10 mev mc electrons @xcite , while for sk - iii several energy bins were considered . as a result , we achieved about 10% better angular resolution around 5 mev than in sk - i ( fig . [ example_veres ] ) . in addition to the above efforts , we retuned most of the reconstruction tools and reduction criteria to reduce their systematic uncertainties . we are continuing to tune those items whose tuning results were nt sufficiently good , as mentioned in the previous sections . as the determination of our systematic errors is still under way , we ca nt show the exact numbers of the systematic uncertainties yet . as a result of the above efforts , we took good solar neutrino data during the full super - kamiokande - iii data - taking period , which ran from august of 2006 through august of 2008 . currently 298 live days of data with a lower total energy threshold of 4.5 mev is finished being analyzed . this section shows the following new solar neutrino results for this data set : * observed @xmath8 flux in sk - iii * angular distributions * @xmath8 flux time variation * recoil electron energy spectrum * day / night asymmetry but the 4.5 - 5.0 mev energy bin still needs additional mc tuning , so for the flux calculation we did nt include this bin . we have only quoted statistical errors , since the estimation of the systematic uncertainties is nt finished . solar neutrinos traversing sk occasionally interact with bound electrons of water molecules . these @xmath8-@xmath6 interactions are elastic scattering , and their incident neutrino and a recoil electron directions are highly correlated . fig . [ example_figure ] shows the @xmath9 distribution of solar neutrino event candidates where @xmath10 is the angle between the recoil electron direction and the direction from the sun ; a sharp peak around 1.0 is observed . using the same method as sk - i @xcite , we extracted the solar neutrino signal from this distribution . the best - fit value for the number of signal events between 5.0 mev and 20.0 mev is @xmath11 . the corresponding @xmath8 flux is @xmath12 is consistent with sk - i / ii values of @xmath13 and @xmath14 within the statistical error . [ subsecflux ] showed the angular distribution of all events between 5.0 and 20.0 mev . this section will focus on the angular distributions of the lowest energy bins . first , fig . [ example_figure_col2 ] shows the 5.0 - 5.5 , 5.5 - 6.0 and 6.0 - 6.5 mev regions . for these energy bins , the fiducial volume ( 13.3 kton ) is smaller than that ( 22.5 kton ) of higher energy bins , because of the large number of background events from the i d wall ( sec . [ subsecws ] ) . as a result of the effort described in sec . [ seccur ] , the background level in sk - iii became lower than that of sk - i , especially below 6.0 mev where it has been cut by one half . moreover , the solar peak of sk - iii is sharper than that of sk - i . in other words , the improved direction fitter ( sec . [ subsecar ] ) has made sk - iii s angular resolution better than sk - i s . next , we d like to report a new low energy bin of 4.5 - 5.0 mev . as a result of improvement of the sk water purification system , we were able to achieve the 4.5 mev recoil electron energy threshold . though high background from the i d wall make this fiducial volume ( 9.0 kton ) much smaller than that of higher energy ranges , the low background in the central detector region provides a possibility to analyze the 4.5 - 5.0 mev region ; we have observed the solar signal in this energy bin . figure [ example_angle2 ] shows the angular distribution of this region . because of the huge background rate and insufficient exposure , at first glance the solar peak is nt readily apparent , but the fitting result was good . still , due to the remaining work we can not quote the exact flux number yet . the time or seasonal variation of the total flux since the start of sk - i is shown in fig . [ example_time ] . the size of each horizontal bin is 1.5 months . the variation agrees well with a sinusoidal trend consistent with the expected @xmath15 variations in sk - i data due to the eccentricity of the earth s orbit around the sun . contribution.,width=302 ] figure [ example_spec ] shows the ratios of the expected ( normalized by the sk - i best fit ) mc and measured recoil electron energy spectra of sk - i / ii / iii . the dotted lines are the average data / mc ratios and the green bands represent statistical error . the red areas indicate the expected @xmath8 contribution from the sk - i best fit and the white areas under the dotted lines are the @xmath16 @xmath8 contributions . we can confirm that sk - i / ii / iii are statistically consistent ; even though sk - iii has lower backgrounds below 6.5 mev , statistical errors are bigger . the day / night asymmetry(@xmath17 ) is the only direct test of matter effects on the solar neutrino oscillations . this value is obtained from @xmath18 , where d and n are the day and night fluxes measured by selecting events which occur when the cosine of the solar zenith angle is less than zero ( day ) and greater than zero ( night ) , respectively . in sk - i it was measured as @xmath19 , and also fitted as @xmath20 , and in sk - ii measured as @xmath21 . in sk - iii it can be measured to 4.3%(stat . ) with the shown 298 days of data , and perhaps to 3.7%(stat . ) using the entire sk - iii data set including periods of high threshold or high background runs . if so , then using the combined sk - i / ii / iii data can determine it to 1.6%(stat . ) and fit variations to 1.3%(stat . ) . we achieved lower backgrounds below 6.0 mev in the center of sk , and have almost finished analyzing sk - iii data . we are trying to reduce systematic errors compared to sk - i and the estimation of these systematic errors is under way . our sk - iii results are consistent with the sk - i / ii results within statistical uncertainties . at sk - iii , the recoil electron energy threshold was lowered to 4.5 mev . with existing data , sk is statistically sensitive down to lma day / night asymmetries of 1.3% . we expect to present preliminary sk - iii solar neutrino results before the end of 2009 .

the full super - kamiokande - iii data - taking period , which ran from august of 2006 through august of 2008 , yielded 298 live days worth of solar neutrino data with a lower total energy threshold of 4.5 mev . during this period we made many improvements to the experiment s hardware and software , with particular emphasis on its water purification system and monte carlo simulations . as a result of these efforts , we have significantly reduced the low energy backgrounds as compared to earlier periods of detector operation , cut the systematic errors by nearly a factor of two , and achieved a 4.5 mev energy threshold for the solar neutrino analysis . in this presentation , i will present the preliminary sk - iii solar neutrino measurement results .

0910.0426

in different contexts like biological systems or chemical reactions , many out of equilibrium dynamics combine diffusive and dissipative features which can be described macroscopically by reaction - diffusion equations . in order to analyze these systems from a microscopic point of view , a lattice gas model with fast stirring and a local creation - annihilation mechanism has been introduced in @xcite by combining a symmetric simple exclusion process ( ssep ) and a glauber dynamics . another example of driven dissipative system is a granular gas where the energy is dissipated through inelastic collisions . direct analytic approaches of the granular gases are notoriously difficult , but stochastic toy models have been proposed in order to capture some aspects of the physics @xcite or for simulation purposes @xcite . the particle system introduced in @xcite in contact with two heat bath shares also similar features . in non - equilibrium statistical mechanics , there is no analogous to the gibbs formalism and the large deviation functional can be viewed as a substitute for the free energy . in particular , the large deviations of the current received a lot of attention over the last few years ( see @xcite for reviews ) . exact expressions of the large deviation functional have been obtained for conservative diffusive stochastic dynamics in contact with reservoirs @xcite@xcite . in this paper , we generalize these results to the non - conservative stochastic dynamics which combine a fast stirring and a glauber dynamics as in @xcite . the relevant macroscopic parameters to describe these stochastic systems are the density , the conservative current ( from the stirring dynamics ) and the non - conservative current ( from the glauber dynamics ) . the large deviation functional gives the exponential cost of observing a deviation of these three parameters simultanously . the large deviations for the density have been already studied in @xcite and the long - range correlations of the steady state in @xcite . the large deviations of the injected power were computed for a different non - conservative stochastic dynamics in @xcite . the large deviation functional derived in measures the cost of observing a joint deviation of the density and the currents . thus the density large deviations obtained in @xcite can be recovered from the functional by optimizing the deviations on the currents . in the same way , observing an atypical conservative current imposes a non trivial constraint on the density and the non - conservative current . as a consequence , we argue in section [ sec : variance ] that the local conservative current fluctuations are produced by a different mechanism than in the case of conservative dynamics . for some choice of the glauber rates , the steady state may exhibit a phase transition . this instability of the steady state leads to a new kind of dynamical phase transition for the current which is presented in section [ sec : phase transition ] . the fluctuation relation for the entropy production has been investigated in the framework of dissipative systems in @xcite . using the exact expression of the large deviation functional , we discuss its symmetry properties with respect to time reversal and recover the fluctuation relation for the entropy production . contrary to the conservative dynamics , the entropy production is no longer proportional to the current injected in the system , but depends in a complex way on the currents and the density . to fix the idea , we first recall in section [ subsec : microscopic ] the microscopic model introduced in @xcite . as it will be clear from section [ sec : hydrodynamic limit ] , the details of the microscopic evolution will not be important to study the macroscopic limit and one can consider more general dynamics than the one introduced in section [ subsec : microscopic ] . the relevant macroscopic parameters are defined in section [ sec : hydrodynamic limit ] and some concrete examples are then discussed in section [ sec : some concrete examples ] . we consider a particle system on a one dimensional chain with @xmath0 sites @xmath1 . the state of each site @xmath2 can be occupied or empty and is encoded by @xmath3 . during the infinitesimal time interval @xmath4 , each particle has a probability @xmath5 of jumping to the left if the left neighboring site is empty , @xmath5 of jumping to the right if the right neighboring site is empty . furthermore at each site @xmath2 , a creation or an annihilation can occur with probability @xmath6 , where the rate @xmath7 can depend on the local configuration around the site @xmath2 . the simplest rates are constant creation and annihilation rates @xmath8 in which case @xmath9 . we will also consider more complicated rates leading to dynamical phase transitions . finally , to model the effect of reservoirs of particles at the boundaries another creation / annihilation mechanism is acting on the boundary sites : during each time interval @xmath4 a particle is created at site 1 ( if it is empty ) with probability @xmath10 and removed with probability @xmath11 ( if it is occupied ) . similarly at site @xmath0 , particles are created or removed at rate @xmath12 . we stress the fact that the stirring of the particles and the action of the reservoirs is much faster ( by a factor @xmath13 ) than the creation / annihilation mechanism in the bulk . the particles perform random walks thanks to the stirring mechanism . thus in the large @xmath0 limit , a particle created at the boundary has a positive probability to go through the system without being annihilated . this is the correct scaling to ensure a competition between the two mechanisms of the dynamics and therefore a non trivial thermodynamic limit ( @xmath14 ) . rephrased in mathematical terms , the previous dynamics is a markov chain with generator given by @xmath15 + \sum_{i\in \{1,n\ } } c(i , \eta ) \big ( f(\eta^i ) - f ( \eta ) \big)\\ & & \qquad \qquad + n^2 \sum_{i = 1 \ { \rm or } \ n } ( { \alpha}_i^+ ( 1 -\eta_i ) + { \alpha}_i^- \eta_i ) \big ( f(\eta^i ) - f ( \eta ) \big ) \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the configuration @xmath16 is obtained from @xmath17 by swapping the occupation numbers of the sites @xmath18 and the configuration @xmath19 is obtained from @xmath17 by changing the occupation number at site @xmath2 from @xmath20 to @xmath21 . the microscopic currents associated to the previous dynamics are defined as : _ the conservative current . _ for a given edge @xmath22 , let @xmath23 be the number of jumps from site @xmath2 to site @xmath24 minus the number of jumps from site @xmath24 to site @xmath2 during the time interval @xmath25 $ ] . _ the non - conservative current . _ we denote by @xmath26 the number of particles created at site @xmath2 during the time interval @xmath25 $ ] . in the same way , @xmath27 denotes the number of particles annihilated at @xmath2 . microscopically this leads to the following conservation law at each site @xmath2 and any time @xmath28 @xmath29 one can also consider more general stirring processes than the ssep of section [ subsec : microscopic ] ( e.g. the zero range process or a kawasaki dynamics @xcite ) . in the macroscopic limit ( @xmath14 ) this will lead to a non - trivial hydrodynamic limit provided that the diffusive dynamics is speeded up by a factor @xmath13 compared to the glauber part . the details of the microscopic evolution will be averaged out in the thermodynamic limit and the macroscopic equations will depend only on a few relevant macroscopic parameters which we describe below . we first consider the _ purely diffusive _ evolution in contact with the reservoirs at the boundary ( i.e. when @xmath30 ) . according to the hydrodynamic formalism @xcite , a given diffusive lattice gas can be characterized by the diffusion coefficient @xmath31 and the conductivity @xmath32 both depending on the density @xmath33 . following @xcite , one way to define these coefficients is to consider a one dimensional system of length @xmath0 connected to reservoirs at its two ends . since the number of particles is preserved by the dynamics , it is equivalent to measure the current @xmath23 through any bond @xmath22 . when both reservoirs are at the same density @xmath33 , the variance of the current @xmath23 transfered during a long time @xmath34 from one reservoir to the other is given for large @xmath0 by @xmath35 where @xmath36 denotes the expectation of the dynamics starting from the invariant measure . the conductivity @xmath32 is defined by . note that the scaling wrt @xmath0 comes from the fact that the diffusive dynamics has been speeded up with a rate @xmath13 . on the other hand if the left reservoir is at density @xmath37 and the right reservoir at density @xmath33 , the average current is given , for small @xmath38 and large @xmath0 , by @xmath39 which is simply fick s law and defines the function @xmath31 . for the ssep , @xmath40 and @xmath41 @xcite . at time @xmath28 and for @xmath42 in @xmath43 $ ] , the macroscopic density is denoted by @xmath44 when @xmath14 @xmath45 we stress the fact that the microscopic diffusion has been speeded up by a factor @xmath13 thus @xmath28 stands already for a macroscopic time . at the boundary , the density is imposed by the reservoirs at any time @xmath28 @xmath46 where the reservoir densities are those of the dynamics defined in section [ subsec : microscopic ] . finally we define the macroscopic conservative current at @xmath47 $ ] up to time @xmath28 @xmath48 where @xmath49 vanishes in the thermodynamic limit ( @xmath14 ) . its time derivative @xmath50 stands for the local current at @xmath42 and according to , its typical value is given by @xmath51 thus the hydrodynamic limit is given by @xcite @xmath52 with the boundary conditions . we investigate now the hydrodynamic behavior of the _ full dynamics_. let @xmath53 be the invariant measure of the stirring dynamics at the uniform density @xmath54 . ( for the ssep then @xmath53 is simply the bernoulli product measure at density @xmath54 ) . at time @xmath55 , the system starts at constant density @xmath54 from the measure @xmath53 , then for any site @xmath56 $ ] in the bulk @xmath57 where the macroscopic annihilation rate @xmath58 and the macroscopic creation rate @xmath59 are obtained by averaging the microscopic rates over the measure @xmath53 @xmath60 the measure @xmath53 is in general no longer invariant for the full dynamics , however the fast stirring ( with an @xmath13 rescaling ) dominates locally and maintains the system in a local equilibrium . even though , the density @xmath61 evolves under the action of the dynamics , the local statistics remain given by @xmath62 up to some small corrections which are vanishing for large @xmath0 . thus when @xmath14 , can be generalized to later times by adding the diffusion term and the density relaxes by following the hydrodynamic equation @xmath63 where the potential is given by @xmath64 and the boundary conditions are imposed by the left and right reservoirs @xmath65 and @xmath66 . in particular , the steady state density @xmath67 satisfies @xmath68 these heuristic ideas have been rigorously justified in @xcite for the microscopic model of section [ subsec : microscopic ] ( in this case @xmath69 ) . the macroscopic non - conservative current at @xmath47 $ ] up to time @xmath28 is defined by @xmath70 its time derivative @xmath71 stands for the local current at @xmath42 and is typically given by @xmath72 after rescaling , the microscopic conservation law reads @xmath73 the previous models can be used to describe a wide variety of physical systems . we describe below a few applications . * granular gasses . * when there is no creation in the bulk , the dynamics introduced in section [ sec : hydrodynamic limit ] can be viewed as a toy model to mimick the granular gases where energy is injected at the boundary and dissipated in the bulk by inelastic collisions . similar dynamics have been considered in @xcite . more precisely , for the model of section [ subsec : microscopic ] , if @xmath74 , then the hydrodynamic limit equation reads @xmath75 with boundary conditions @xmath76 . @xmath77 can be interpreted as a local energy dissipated at rate @xmath78 in the bulk and the stationary state satisfies @xmath79 * reaction - diffusion . * the microscopic model of section [ subsec : microscopic ] was originally introduced @xcite to model diffusion reaction type equations often used to describe chemically reacting systems . for a glauber dynamics which satisfies detailed balance with respect to the gibbs measure of a one dimensional ising model with nearest neighbor interaction at inverse temperature @xmath80 , then @xmath81 with @xmath82 . the hydrodynamic limit reads @xmath83 with the potential @xmath84 for @xmath85 , the potential @xmath86 has a unique minimum , instead @xmath86 is a double well when @xmath87 . in the latter case a phase transition may occur as there might be several solutions of which can be stable or not with respect to the fluctuating hydrodynamic . depending on the value of the parameters and of the boundary conditions , the steady can be concentrated on more than one profile , leading therefore to a phase transition . some consequences of these transitions on the current large deviations will be examined in section [ sec : phase transition ] . we turn now to the large deviations of the currents and density . the corresponding functional can be completely characterized at the macroscopic level in terms of the coefficients @xmath88 ( [ eq : sigma]-[eq : d ] ) and @xmath89 . on average , the density follows the hydrodynamic equation and the macroscopic currents @xmath90 obey , . the probability of observing the evolution of an atypical density profile @xmath44 and atypical macroscopic currents @xmath90 for @xmath91 is given for large @xmath0 by @xmath92 } \left ( \big\ { { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k}}\big\ } \right ) \sim \exp \left [ - n \ , { \ensuremath{\mathcal i}}_{[0,t ] } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) \right ] \label{eq : ldf}\ ] ] where @xmath93}= \infty$ ] if the evolution does not satisfies the conservation law and the boundary conditions . otherwise , @xmath93}$ ] is defined by @xmath94 } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) = \int_0^t dt \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ ; \left\ { \frac{\big ( { { \dot q}}(x , t ) + d\big({\rho}(x , t ) \big ) \partial_x { \rho}(x , t ) \big)^2}{2 { \sigma}\big ( { \rho}(x , t)\big ) } + \phi \big ( { \rho}(x , t ) , { { \dot k}}(x , t ) \big ) \right\ } \ , , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath95 if @xmath96 , then @xmath97 becomes @xmath98 this can be understood from by taking the limit @xmath99 and taking into account the fact that for @xmath96 , there is no creation so that @xmath100 . a symmetric expression holds for @xmath101 . note that @xmath93 } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) = 0 $ ] for typical evolutions , i.e. when , and are satisfied . in higher dimensions , a similar expression for the large deviation functional holds . the coefficients @xmath102 and @xmath103 should be replaced by matrices and @xmath104 becomes a vector field ( see @xcite ) , but the non - conservative part is unchanged . we turn now to a heuristic derivation of the large deviation principle . in the functional @xmath93}$ ] , the contribution of the two currents @xmath105 splits into two independent parts . the first term of the functional involves only the conservative part of the current and it can be interpreted as the local gaussian fluctuations of @xmath50 around its mean @xmath106 ( see ) with a variance @xmath107 . similar expressions have been obtained in @xcite for diffusive type dynamics . the contribution @xmath97 of the non - conservative current can be understood as follows . during the time interval @xmath108 $ ] , the density @xmath44 remains essentially constant in the small region @xmath109 $ ] . during @xmath108 $ ] , particles are created in @xmath109 $ ] according to a process @xmath110 which is the sum of the independent microscopic processes at each site in the interval @xmath111 . as the density remains essentially constant and the local equilibrium is maintained , the process @xmath110 is the sum of @xmath112 independent poisson processes with rate @xmath113 , where @xmath114 . thus @xmath110 is a poisson process with a large deviation function given for large @xmath0 by @xmath115 where @xmath116 stands for the number of particles created in @xmath109 $ ] during the time interval @xmath108 $ ] and @xmath117 in the same way , particles are annihilated in @xmath109 $ ] according to a poisson process @xmath118 with rate @xmath119 . when @xmath0 tends to infinity , the large deviations of @xmath118 are given by the functional @xmath120 . thus observing a large deviation @xmath121 of the non - conservative current in @xmath109 $ ] during the time interval @xmath108 $ ] boils down to optimize the large deviations of both processes @xmath122 under the constraint that @xmath123 @xmath124 adding the local contributions for each space - time intervals @xmath125 and @xmath4 , we recover the non - conservative part of the functional . the previous heuristics are based on the conservation of local equilibrium ( thanks to the fast stirring ) and the summation of all the local fluctuations ( gaussian for the conservative current and poissonnian for the non - conservative current ) . a similar _ additivity principle _ has been already used in the framework of diffusive systems @xcite . a rigorous mathematical proof of the large deviations can be found in @xcite for the microscopic model introduced in section [ subsec : microscopic ] , i.e. @xmath126 and @xmath127 . the large deviations for the density have been considered in @xcite and these results can be recovered from the functional . the asymptotic probability of observing an atypical evolution @xmath128 for @xmath91 is given for large @xmath0 by @xmath92 } \left ( { \rho}\right ) \sim \exp \left [ - n \ , { \ensuremath{\mathcal g}}_{[0,t ] } ( { \rho } ) \right ] \ { \rm with } \quad { \ensuremath{\mathcal g}}_{[0,t ] } ( { \rho } ) = \inf_{{{\dot q}},{{\dot k } } } { \ensuremath{\mathcal i}}_{[0,t ] } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) \label{eq : ldf densite}\ ] ] where the functional @xmath93}$ ] is optimized over the currents @xmath129 satisfying the conservation law . it is convenient to rewrite the conservative current in terms of a chemical potential @xmath130 @xmath131 where @xmath130 has boundary condition @xmath132 . thus becomes @xmath133 } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) = \int_0^t dt \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ ; \left\ { \frac { { \sigma}\big ( { \rho}(x , t)\big)}{2 } \big ( \partial_x h(x , t ) \big)^2 + \phi \big ( { \rho}(x , t ) , { { \dot k}}(x , t ) \big ) \right\ } \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] optimizing this functional over @xmath134 under the constraint of the conservation law implies @xmath135 at any time and @xmath136 where @xmath137 stands for the derivative wrt @xmath138 . from and , we see that there is @xmath139 such that @xmath140 . this implies that @xmath141 and thus we recover the expression of @xcite @xmath142 } ( { \rho } ) = \int_0^t \int_0 ^ 1 dt \ , dx \ ; \frac { { \sigma}\big ( { \rho}\big)}{2 } \big ( \partial_x h \big)^2 + a ( { \rho } ) \big ( 1- \exp(-h ) ( h + 1 ) \big ) \\ & & \qquad \qquad \qquad \qquad \qquad + c ( { \rho } ) \big ( \exp(h ) ( h - 1 ) -1 \big ) \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath130 is defined such that the following equation holds @xmath143 the previous equation is obtained from the conservation law combined with and . in this section , we focus on new the features of the current large deviations which do not exist for purely conservative dynamics . in practice large deviations are `` rarely '' observed , however one can often understand the fluctuations close to a steady state by expanding the large deviation functional . using this approach , the cumulants of the current were predicted in @xcite for general diffusive dynamics and the results were confirmed numerically for some specific models in @xcite . we follow the same path and focus on the second order expansion which is related to the variance of the current ( when there is no phase transition ) . as the number of particles is non - conserved , the time integrated currents are not constant through the system and the deviations of the current depend on where it is measured ( this was not the case for the conservative dynamics ) . in order to illustrate this fact , we are going to compute the deviations of the total conservative current and of a local conservative current ( measured in a smaller region of the bulk ) . the mechanisms at play are different . in particular , to increase the current from left to right in a given region , extra particles are created to the left of this region and depleted to its right ( see figure [ fig : profile courant ] ) . this is reminiscent of the vortices which induce local current fluctuations in two - dimensional models @xcite . given a function @xmath144 with @xmath47 $ ] , we are interested in the large deviations of the integrated current @xmath145 over a very long time interval @xmath25 $ ] @xmath146 } \left ( \exp \left ( \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ , { \lambda}(x ) q(x , t ) \right ) \right ) \ , .\ ] ] this boils down to minimizing the time dependent large deviation functional @xmath147 } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) \right\ } \ , . \label{eq : ld legendre}\ ] ] for some dynamics @xcite , this is equivalent to a stationary variational problem and the supremum can be taken on time independent profiles @xmath148 . in this case , the conservation law implies @xmath149 and the large deviation functional reduces to @xmath150 it is then enough to consider the simpler variational problem @xmath151 it is in general not true that the functional can be reduced to for any microscopic dynamics , i.e. for any functions @xmath152 , @xmath89 and @xmath153 . some counter - examples leading to dynamical phase transitions can be found in the case of conservative dynamics in @xcite . in section [ sec : phase transition ] , we will construct a new example of phase transition in the non - conservative case . when the potential @xmath86 is convex , we expect that gives the correct expression for small deviations close to the steady state current . indeed in this case the steady state @xmath154 is unique and stable with respect to the hydrodynamic evolution . thus a small perturbation of the current should not lead to the bifurcations observed in the dynamical phase transitions @xcite . the previous conjecture on the equality between and can be derived when @xmath102 is a constant , @xmath103 is concave , @xmath155 and @xmath156 are linear ( and thus @xmath86 is quadratic ) . recall that for the ssep , one has @xmath69 , @xmath157 . we follow the argument in @xcite devised for the ssep . first note that the functional @xmath93}$ ] can be rewritten ( see e.g. @xcite ) as @xmath158 } \left(\rho,{{\dot q}},{{\dot k}}\right ) = \int_0^t dt \ , \psi ( \rho_t , { { \dot q}}_t)+ \phi ( \rho_t , { { \dot k}}_t ) \ , , \ ] ] where we set for any functions @xmath159 with @xmath42 in @xmath43 $ ] @xmath160 and @xmath161 note that the representation holds for any @xmath58 and @xmath59 . for any @xmath130 , the functional @xmath162 is convex jointly in @xmath163 because @xmath103 is concave . in the same way , for any @xmath164 , the functional @xmath165 is jointly convex in @xmath166 since @xmath58 and @xmath59 are linear . as @xmath167 and @xmath97 are defined as a supremum of convex functions , they are also convex . thus for any trajectory @xmath168 @xmath169 } \left(\rho,{{\dot q}},{{\dot k}}\right ) \ , .\ ] ] this inequality implies that the minimum in can be reduced to time independent profiles . indeed , any time dependent evolution @xmath168 which produces a total current @xmath170 has a large deviation cost greater or equal than the time independent profiles obtained by averaging this trajectory over time . given the function @xmath153 , we are going to expand @xmath171 ( given in ) to the second order in @xmath49 . for a small shift of the current , we expect that the minimum is located close to the steady state @xmath67 defined in . we introduce the perturbation @xmath172 with @xmath173 to satisfy the boundary conditions . expanding the functional @xmath174 to the second order in @xmath49 leads to @xmath175 where @xmath176 by the convexity assumption of @xmath86 . we introduce @xmath177 and optimize over @xmath178 and @xmath179 . this implies @xmath180 with the boundary conditions @xmath181 and @xmath182 . we deduce that @xmath183 since @xmath184 , the solution @xmath185 of is unique . the current and density profiles @xmath186 can then be determined uniquely since the boundary are fixed @xmath187 and @xmath182 . @xmath188 _ total current deviations . _ the variance of the total current @xmath189 can be obtained with a constant lagrange parameter @xmath190 . in this case , the solutions of are @xmath191 and @xmath192 . plugging this in leads to @xmath193 the variance of the total conservative current should be given by @xmath194 . the result is the same as the one obtained in the purely conservative case @xcite , however it is important to note that the minimizers of the variational problem can be different from the conservative case and that the optimal current is , in general , no longer uniform through the system . @xmath188 _ local current deviations . _ in order to solve for local current fluctuations , we consider the simple case where @xmath67 is constant so that all the differential equations have constant coefficients ( denoted by @xmath195 ) . for example , this is the case if the reservoirs have equal densities @xmath196 and @xmath197 . we rewrite and @xmath198 recall that by the convexity of @xmath86 then @xmath199 . the solutions are given by @xmath200 with @xmath201 . since @xmath202 finally the optimal current and density are given by @xmath203 with @xmath204 such that the boundary conditions are satisfied . when @xmath153 is a constant , the optimal density and current associated to the deviations of the total current are constant : @xmath205 and @xmath206 . however to achieve a local current deviation , the interplay between the stirring process and the glauber dynamics is more complex and the density is no longer uniform as depicted in figure [ fig : profile courant ] . in this section , we consider a slightly different dynamics in order to explain in the simplest framework a mechanism of phase transition for the current large deviations . the system is on a periodic chain @xmath1 without reservoirs . instead of the ssep , the stirring process is now the weakly asymmetric exclusion process ( wasep ) with jump rates to the right given by @xmath207 and to the left is given by @xmath208 . the drift is of order @xmath209 and @xmath210 is a fixed parameter . this stirring process is combined to the glauber dynamics with rates . for @xmath211 , this leads to a double well potential @xmath86 with minima @xmath212 , @xmath213 and a local maximum at @xmath214 . the currents are defined as in section [ sec : hydrodynamic limit ] . the macroscopic equation for the conservative current becomes @xmath215 with @xmath216 . thus the new hydrodynamic evolution can be written @xmath217 the stationary measure of this dynamics exhibits a phase transition as the steady state concentrates on two different density profiles in the thermodynamic limit @xmath14 . to see this , we first notice that the constant profiles equal to @xmath218 and @xmath214 are all stationary solutions of the hydrodynamic equation . to guess the structure of the stationary state , one has to consider the stochastic corrections provided by the fluctuating hydrodynamics @xcite . a noise term depending non - linearly on the local density has to be added to ( see @xcite for an exact expression ) . thus only @xmath218 are stable with respect to the noisy equation and @xmath214 is not . depending on the values of @xmath219 there can be also other stationary solutions of which are not constant , but they will be unstable . thus we say that the stationary measure has a phase transition : the steady state concentrates in the large @xmath0 limit on the two constant profiles @xmath218 with equal probability due to the symmetry of the rates . ( the previous argument is mainly heuristic and we postpone a mathematical justification of the occurrence of a phase transition to a futur work . ) we will see now that the phase transition of the stationary measure has also implications on the current large deviations . adding a weak drift @xmath210 to the stirring process modifies only the cost of the conservative current deviations in the large deviation functional . the new functional reads @xmath220 } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) = \int_0^t dt \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ , \left\ { \frac{\big ( { { \dot q}}(x , t ) + \partial_x { \rho}(x , t ) - \nu { \sigma}({\rho}(x , t ) ) \big)^2}{2 { \sigma}\big ( { \rho}(x , t)\big ) } + \phi \big ( { \rho}(x , t ) , { { \dot k}}(x , t ) \big ) \right\ } \ , , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath97 is still given by , the conductivity @xmath221 and the diffusion coefficient @xmath102 is now equal to @xmath222 . we refer to @xcite for a study of the large deviations in conservative dynamics with weak drifts . as the steady states concentrates on @xmath223 , the mean conservative current is @xmath224 ( in the large @xmath0 limit ) . we are going to compute the cost of an increase of the total current over a very large time interval . for any shift of the current @xmath225 $ ] @xmath226 } \left ( \frac{1}{t } \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ , q(x , t ) \simeq q \right ) = 0 \ , . \label{eq : zero ld}\ ] ] the strategy to minimize the functional goes as follow . to produce a current close to @xmath227 over a very long time @xmath34 , the system ( which originally starts close to @xmath212 or @xmath228 ) can evolve to the constant profile @xmath214 within a time of order 1 . this first move has a cost exponential in @xmath0 but independent of @xmath34 so that it is irrelevant in the limit . then the density remains equal to @xmath214 for the rest of the time and therefore the system produces a conservative current asymptotically equal to @xmath229 for large @xmath34 . as @xmath214 is a metastable profile this has no large deviation cost ( at least in the scaling considered in ) . for an intermediate current @xmath230 ( with @xmath2310,1[$ ] ) , the deviation can be achieved by a time - dependent density profile which is close to @xmath232 during a time @xmath233 and then close to @xmath214 during a time @xmath234 . the optimal cost remains equal to 0 , but the time dependent variational principle can not be reduced to even for arbitrarily small current deviations . a flat piece in the large deviation function ( see figure [ fig : transition ] ) is a sign of a phase transition . [ t][l]@xmath235 [ t][c]@xmath236 [ r][l]@xmath237 [ t][l]@xmath34 [ t][c]@xmath233 [ l][b]@xmath44 the large deviation function of the entropy production obeys a very general symmetry property @xcite which is known to hold for a wide class of stochastic dynamics @xcite . when applied to conservative dynamics in contact with two heat baths , the entropy production can be reinterpreted as the current flowing through the system and therefore a similar symmetry holds for the large deviation function of the current at the microsopic and macroscopic levels @xcite . a generalized notion of detailed balance introduced in @xcite allows to consider an arbitray number of reservoirs and therefore is well suited in the case of bulk creation / dissipation . finally , the deviations of the entropy production for the more realistic case of granular gases was considered in @xcite . in this section , we recover the fluctuation relation at the macroscopic level by means of the functional . we are going now to investigate the symmetries of the functional with respect to time reversal which is a key feature of the gallavotti - cohen relation . let @xmath238 be an evolution from time 0 to time @xmath34 such that the coefficients @xmath239 and @xmath240 are positive . the functional can be rewritten as @xmath241 } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) = \int_0^t dt \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ , \frac { { { \dot q}}(x , t)^2 + \big ( d\big({\rho}(x , t ) \big ) \partial_x { \rho}(x , t ) \big)^2}{2 { \sigma}\big ( { \rho}(x , t)\big ) } + \frac { { { \dot q}}(x , t ) d\big({\rho}(x , t ) \big ) \partial_x { \rho}(x , t ) } { { \sigma}\big ( { \rho}(x , t)\big ) } \nonumber \\ & & \qquad \qquad \qquad \qquad + \phi \big ( { \rho}(x , t ) , { { \dot k}}(x , t ) \big)\ , , \label{eq : func rev}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath97 given by @xmath242 where the previous identity follows from by multiplying the numerator and the denominator ( in the log ) by @xmath243 . let @xmath244 be a function such that @xmath245 ( we shall see later on that @xmath246 can be interpreted as a relative entropy ) . by integration by parts , one has @xmath247\\ & & \qquad \qquad = - \int_0^t dt \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ , \partial_x { { \dot q}}(x , t ) \ , s ' \big ( { \rho}(x , t)\big ) + \big ( q(1,t ) s ' \big ( { \rho}_b \big ) - q(0,t ) s ' \big ( { \rho}_a \big ) \big ) \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath248 and @xmath76 are the densities imposed by the left and right reservoirs . the conservation law leads to @xmath249 combining , and the previous identity , one can compare the large deviation cost @xmath93 } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k}})$ ] to the one of its time reversal @xmath250 @xmath133 } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) - { \ensuremath{\mathcal i}}_{[0,t]}(\hat { \rho},\hat { { \dot q}},\hat { { \dot k } } ) = { \ensuremath{\mathcal e}}_{[0,t ] } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) + \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ , \big ( s \big ( { \rho}(x , t)\big ) - s \big ( { \rho}(x,0)\big ) \big ) \ , . \label{eq : time reversal}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the _ entropy production _ can be identified as @xmath251 } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) = \big ( q(1,t ) s ' \big ( { \rho}_b \big ) - q(0,t ) s ' \big ( { \rho}_a \big ) \big)\\ & & \qquad \qquad + \int_0^t dt \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ , { { \dot k}}(x , t)\ , \big ( - s ' \big ( { \rho}(x , t)\big ) + \log \left ( \frac { a({\rho}(x , t ) ) } { c({\rho}(x , t ) ) } \right ) \big ) \ , . \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] by construction @xmath252}$ ] is anti - symmetric under time reversal . we consider dynamics such that @xmath246 is bounded ( which is the case if the ( microscopic ) number of particle per site is bounded ) . then the large deviation function of the entropy production @xmath253 } \left ( \frac{1}{t } { \ensuremath{\mathcal e}}_{[0,t ] } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) = e \right ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] satisfies the gallavotti - cohen symmetry @xmath254 ( thanks to the identity and the fact that the term @xmath255 is bounded uniformly wrt time ) . for conservative systems , the entropy production @xmath252}$ ] is proportional to the conservative current @xmath256 flowing through the system and therefore the symmetry holds also for the large deviation functional of the conservative current @xcite . for general creation / annihilation bulk rates , the relation between @xmath252}$ ] and the currents is less straightforward as the density is coupled to the non - conservative current @xmath138 . simplifications occur when the steering process and the glauber dynamics are both reversible ( locally ) with respect to the same gibbs measure . let @xmath257 be a gibbs measure with constant density @xmath128 which is invariant for the steering process for any density @xmath128 ( see ) . we denote by @xmath258 the susceptibility of @xmath257 . according to the fluctuation dissipation relation @xcite , the function @xmath244 satisfies @xmath259 . thus @xmath260 can be interpreted as the chemical potential conjugated to the density @xmath128 and @xmath246 as an equilibrium large deviation function . suppose that the creation and annihilation are reversible with respect to @xmath261 for a given density @xmath262 , i.e. @xmath263 where @xmath264 is the gibbs measure on @xmath20 conditionally to the configuration @xmath265 outside the site @xmath2 . thus can be rewritten @xmath266 using this identity , the entropy production can be rewritten only in terms of the currents @xmath267 } ( { \rho } , { { \dot q}},{{\dot k } } ) = q(1,t ) s ' \big ( { \rho}_b \big ) - q(0,t ) s ' \big ( { \rho}_a \big ) - s ' \big ( { \rho}_0 \big ) \int_0 ^ 1 dx \ , k(x , t ) \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this paper , we analyzed the current large deviations for non - conservative diffusive dynamics driven out - off equilibrium by external reservoirs . we obtained an expression for the large deviation functional which generalizes the results derived for the conservative dynamics @xcite-@xcite . from the large deviation functional , one can understand how the deviations of the currents and the density are coupled . contrary to the conservative case , there are now two currents instead of one and it is therefore more delicate to derive exact expressions of the minimizers of the functional given some constraint ( for example given the total currents ) . it would be of interest to derive more systematic predictions for the cumulants of the currents as in @xcite . in section [ sec : the fluctuation relation ] , we showed that the entropy production satisfies the fluctuation relation . one may wonder if other ( measurable ) physical quantities related to the injected current satisfy similar relations . in this spirit , the exact expression of the large deviation functional could be helpful to solve some controversy on the validity of the fluctuation relation in dissipative systems @xcite . a. de masi , p. ferrari , j. lebowitz , _ rigorous derivation of reaction - diffusion equations with fluctuations _ , phys . , 55:1947 - 1949 , ( 1985 ) ; _ reaction - diffusion equations for interacting particle systems _ , j. stat . * 44 * , 589 - 644 , ( 1986 )

we consider lattice gas diffusive dynamics with creation - annihilation in the bulk and maintained out of equilibrium by two reservoirs at the boundaries . this stochastic particle system can be viewed as a toy model for granular gases where the energy is injected at the boundary and dissipated in the bulk . the large deviation functional for the particle currents flowing through the system is computed and some physical consequences are discussed : the mechanism for local current fluctuations , dynamical phase transitions , the fluctuation - relation .

1411.1587

optical ring potentials ( orps ) with axial symmetry are considered as basic building blocks and the simplest nontrivial closed - loop circuits in atomtronics @xcite and atom interferometry @xcite . atoms can be trapped by means of the optical dipolar force in high or low intensity regions with red - detuned @xcite or blue - detuned @xcite light , in what follows called bright and dark potentials , respectively . on the one hand , bright orps have been proposed and demonstrated with high - azimuthal - order laguerre gaussian ( lg ) beams @xcite and also with annular microlenses @xcite . azimuthal lattices within orps have been demonstrated with time orbiting of light beams @xcite and by interference of lg beams of different azimuthal orders @xcite . a one - dimensional stack of orps in a line has been proposed in an optical cavity @xcite and demonstrated with axicon beams @xcite . experimental storage and propagation of ultra - cold atoms and bose - einstein condensates ( becs ) in bright orps have been reported recently @xcite . dark orps on the other hand are optical fields with an annular region of minimum intensity @xcite , such as closed - loop optical singularities @xcite , for which the region of minimum intensity is exactly zero . for ultra - cold atoms , dark orps have the advantage of substantially reducing atom heating and decoherence rates @xcite because of the low rate of spontaneous photon scattering as well as producing intrinsically flat potential minima . blue - detuned orps have been experimentally reported by means of lg beams generated with spatial light modulators ( slms ) @xcite and by amplitude masks @xcite . these two techniques might experience the following limitations : ( i ) a significant fraction of the input power is lost and , therefore , it does not contribute to create the optical trap , ( ii ) the smoothness and , therefore , the quality of the trapping potential is limited by the size and number of pixels for the slms and the resolution of the printing system for the amplitude masks , and ( iii ) an accurate control on the position and alignment of the optical elements being used is required . as a consequence , these two techniques yield typically not null intensity minima . producing orps with zero - intensity annular regions both along the radial and axial directions is a challenging task . in this case , the dark potential forms toroidal dark focus , i.e. , a region of minimum intensity confined by higher intensities ( light walls ) both in the axial and radial directions . a toroidal dark focus has only been demonstrated using a superposition of two lg beams @xcite . in this article , we present a new method to generate a dark orp by means of the phenomenon of conical refraction ( cr ) @xcite , occurring in biaxial crystals . cr leads to a set of two concentric bright rings enclosing a dark ring of null intensity , known as poggendorff dark ring ( pdr ) . we theoretically investigate the three - dimensional ( 3d ) field distribution around the cr pdr and show both theoretically and experimentally that it is a toroidal dark focus . we also discuss the use of the pdr as a blue - detuned orp for ultra - cold atoms and demonstrate this with a @xmath0rb bec . this technique has the advantage of the easy generation of the toroidal dark trap , which only needs a focused gaussian beam and a biaxial crystal . in addition , cr provides the full conversion of the input power into the toroidal dark trap , in contrast to the previously reported methods which introduce losses due to diffraction in the generation of lg beams . these features make the cr toroidal dark - focus beam very attractive for particle @xcite and atom @xcite trapping , in particular with blue - detuned light beams @xcite . the article is organized as follows : in section [ seccr ] we give an introduction to the cr phenomenon , presenting its main fundamental characteristics : section [ secpcr ] presents the exact paraxial solution of the light pattern after propagation along one of the optic axes of a biaxial crystal , while its asymptotic approximation is presented in section [ secacr ] . in section [ secatomscr ] , we investigate the use of the toroidal dark trap provided by cr for the trapping of ultra - cold atoms with blue - detuned light . in section [ harmonic_approach ] we apply the harmonic approximation around the pdr and present expressions for the trapping frequencies and height of the potential barriers as a function of the physical parameters of the trapping system . then , both numerical simulations and experimental data for a @xmath0rb bec trapped in the pdr are shown in section [ secnum ] . finally , the main conclusions are summarized in section [ seccon ] . conical refraction @xcite is observed when a focused light beam passing along an optic axis of a biaxial crystal ( bc ) is transformed into a light ring at the focal plane . each pair of diagonally opposite points of the cr ring are orthogonally linearly polarized , as shown by double arrows in fig . [ figcr_cone_ring ] . therefore , a complete ring with uniform azimuthal intensity distribution is observed only for randomly ( rp ) or circularly ( cp ) polarized input beams ( fig . [ figcr_cone_ring](a ) ) , while for linearly polarized ( lp ) input beams the intensity pattern is azimuthally crescent with a zero - intensity point , where the polarization is orthogonal to the one of the input beam . this polarization distribution , which constitutes an essential signature of the cr phenomenon , significantly differs from the usually known radial and azimuthal polarization modes and only depends on the orientation of the plane of the crystal optic axes @xcite . the cr geometric optical approximation of the ring radius , @xmath1 , is the product of the crystal length , @xmath2 , and the cr semi - angle @xmath3 , i.e. , @xmath4 @xcite . the cr semi - angle @xmath3 depends on the principal refractive indices of the crystal as @xmath5 , where we have assumed @xmath6 . moreover , under conditions of @xmath7 the cr pattern at the focal plane is formed by a pair of concentric bright rings separated by the poggendorff dark ring ( fig . [ figcr_cone_ring ] ) . here , @xmath8 is the waist of the focused input beam , defined as the radius of the @xmath9 relative intensity , i.e. @xmath10 . finally , as far as cr beam evolution is concerned , the focal plane is a symmetry plane along the beam propagation direction @xcite . the cr rings are observed at the focal plane , and more involved structures including secondary rings are found as one moves along the beam propagation direction . at points given by @xmath11 from the focal plane a bright spot known as the raman spot @xcite appears on the beam axis , where @xmath12 denotes the rayleigh range of the focused input beam . in this section we describe the properties of the optical field at and close to the dark region of the poggendorff ring . the paraxial solution describing cr was derived by belsky and khapalyuk @xcite and later reformulated by berry @xcite . for a uniformly polarized and cylindrically symmetric input beam it gives an electric field vector : @xmath13 where @xmath14 and @xmath15 . @xmath16 is the azimuthal component in cylindrical coordinates and @xmath17 is the orientation of the plane of the optic axes of the crystal . @xmath18 and @xmath19 are the amplitude and unit vector of the electric field @xmath20 of a focused input beam with waist @xmath21 and rayleigh range @xmath22 . @xmath23 and @xmath24 with @xmath25 define , respectively , normalized axial and radial components in cylindrical coordinates with origin at the ring center ( @xmath26 ) at the focal plane ( @xmath27 ) . @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the main integrals of the belsky khapalyuk berry ( bkb ) solution , which describes the general properties of the cr beam . these integrals read : @xmath30 where @xmath31 , @xmath32 being the spatial wave - vector and @xmath33 is the @xmath34-order bessel function of the first type and @xmath35 is the radial part of the 2d transverse fourier transform of the input beam . for cp and lp inputs the intensity distribution behind the crystal becomes , respectively @xmath36 \cos \left ( 2 \phi - \left ( \varphi + \varphi_0 \right ) \right),~ \label{eqs_output_beam_intensity_lp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath37 is the polarization azimuth of the linearly polarized input light with @xmath38 . the asymptotic solution for the poggendorff dark ring , i.e. , for @xmath39 , is obtained by using the asymptotic expansion of bessel functions @xmath40 . here we have centered the normalized radial component in cylindrical coordinates at @xmath41 by using @xmath42 . in this case @xmath43 and the electric field can be written as @xcite : @xmath44 where @xmath45 and @xmath46 therefore , the asymptotic intensity distributions @xmath47 and @xmath48 for cp and lp input beams are , respectively , @xmath49 for lp input beams ( see eq . ( [ eqs_cr_ring_intensity_lp ] ) ) , the output intensity distribution lacks azimuthal symmetry . in this case the cr ring has a maximum and a zero intensity at azimuthal angles @xmath50 and @xmath51 , respectively . these points possess , correspondingly , the same and the orthogonal polarization relative to that of the input beam , respectively ( fig . [ figcr_cone_ring](b ) ) . in the following we will analyze the case of a cp input beam , for which the cr output intensity is azimuthally symmetric and its spatial distribution is described by eq . ( [ eqs_cr_ring_intensity_cp ] ) . for a gaussian input beam with normalized transverse profile of the electric field amplitude @xmath52 , its fourier transform is @xmath53 . @xmath54 is the power of the input beam . for this case , eq . ( [ eqs_cr_ring_polarization ] ) can be analytically evaluated through the kummer confluent hyper - geometric function @xmath55 @xcite : @xmath56 , ~ \label{eqs_fxi_gauss_general_bks_weberfns}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath57 . the solid line in fig . [ figpoggendorfdark_1d_x_z](a ) shows the square modulus of eq . ( [ eqs_fxi_gauss_general_bks_weberfns ] ) at the focal plane ( @xmath27 ) . @xmath58 , gives the radial position of the poggendorff dark ring at the focal plane , being @xmath59 . in other words , the radius of the pdr is smaller than the geometric approximation of the cr ring , @xmath60 , by approximately half the waist of the input beam . note that @xmath61 , with @xmath62 . in the radial direction the pdr is confined by two maxima at @xmath63 and @xmath64 , respectively ( see table [ table1 ] ) . along the z direction , the lowest intensity barrier is observed also at the radial position of the pdr , i.e. , at @xmath65 as shown in fig . [ figpoggendorfdark_1d_x_z](b ) . at this radial point the positions of the intensity maxima along @xmath66 obtained from eq . ( [ eqs_cr_ring_intensity_cp ] ) and ( [ eqs_fxi_gauss_general_bks_weberfns ] ) are @xmath67 . therefore , the pdr is confined by walls of light in all directions and forms a toroidal dark - focus . table [ table1 ] presents the positions of the pdr and of the maxima in the radial ( @xmath68 ) and axial ( @xmath69 ) directions . .positions of the poggendorff dark ring and of the maxima in the radial ( @xmath70 ) and axial ( @xmath71 ) directions . [ cols=">,^,^",options="header " , ] [ table1 ] as a visualization of the toroidal dark trap provided by the pdr of cr , fig . [ figpoggendorfdark_2d_x0_z](a ) shows the three - dimensional distribution of light intensity of the asymptotic approximation of the bkb solution near the focal plane . [ figpoggendorfdark_2d_x0_z](b ) is a contour plot near the pdr , confirming that it is a region of low intensity surrounded in all directions by regions of higher intensity . note that the pdr is an exact null intensity region only for input gaussian beams under the asymptotic approximation , i.e. for @xmath72 , while non - zero intensity radial minimum points are found out of the paraxial approximation , as reported in refs . @xcite . for input beams with different transverse profile the cr pattern may change @xcite . we have experimentally checked that near the pdr the light intensity increases in all directions , see blue solid circles in fig . [ figpoggendorfdark_1d_x_z](a ) and fig . [ figpoggendorfdark_1d_x_z](b ) . these experiments on the cr pdr were carried out using a cp focused input gaussian beam ( @xmath73 , @xmath74 ) at @xmath75 and a kgd(wo@xmath76)@xmath77 biaxial crystal ( cross - section @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 ) cut perpendicular to one of the optic axes ( entrance surface parallelism better than @xmath81 arc seconds ) yielding a cr ring of @xmath82 ( @xmath83 ) . the transverse light patterns at and around the focal plane were recorded with a ccd camera . in the previous sections we have described the intensity distribution near the pdr in the radial and axial directions , showing that this region is a dark orp . this makes the pdr a good candidate for atom trapping applications with blue - detuned light . for a given light intensity @xmath84 , the trapping dipole potential reads @xmath85 , where for alkali atoms for sufficiently large detuning and linear polarization @xmath86,\qquad \label{auxpot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] as given e.g. in @xcite . note that in @xmath87 we have applied the rotating - wave approximation . here , @xmath88 is the speed of light in vacuum , @xmath89 and @xmath90 ( @xmath91 ) are , respectively , the natural line width and frequency of the @xmath92 line of the atomic species , and @xmath93 is the frequency of the input beam . in our case , @xmath84 is given by eq . ( [ eqs_cr_ring_intensity_cp ] ) and eq . ( [ eqs_fxi_gauss_general_bks_weberfns ] ) and @xmath94 for blue - detuned light . by using the harmonic oscillator approximation , we have obtained the following expressions for the corresponding radial ( @xmath95 ) and axial ( @xmath96 ) trapping frequencies of the pdr ( @xmath97 ) @xmath98 with @xmath99 being the atomic mass and the numerical constants @xmath100 and @xmath101 . ( [ omegar ] ) is obtained by expanding eq . ( [ eqs_fxi_gauss_general_bks_weberfns ] ) in taylor series , introducing it into eq . ( [ eqs_cr_ring_intensity_cp ] ) and considering the @xmath102 coefficient . note that from eqs . ( [ eqs_cr_ring_intensity_cp ] ) , ( [ eqs_fxi_gauss_general_bks_weberfns])([omegar ] ) for a given biaxial crystal , i.e. for a fixed @xmath1 and @xmath21 , the trapping frequencies and the maxima of the potential barriers can be tuned by modifying the power @xmath54 and the frequency @xmath93 of the input beam . we have obtained that at the focal plane the maxima of the potential barriers are described by @xmath103 where @xmath104 ( outer bright ring ) and @xmath105 ( inner bright ring ) . there can be other experimental situations however , where it is required to work outside the focal plane , for instance in experiments where a more symmetric potential is needed , such as the one shown with a solid line in fig . [ figz4](a ) , where the radial intensity distribution close to the pdr is shown for the focal plane ( @xmath27 ) and the plane @xmath106 . in these cases , eq . ( [ omegar ] ) can be utilized to calculate the trapping frequency of the potential at any axial position @xmath66 by just replacing @xmath107 by @xmath108 figure [ figz4](b ) presents the dependence of @xmath109 on @xmath66 . note that outside the focal plane an offset to the potential is occurring , since the minimum intensity point is no longer of null intensity as plotted for @xmath106 as solid line in fig . [ figz4](a ) . we have found that this non - zero minimum intensity point can be taken into account by means of the optical potential along the axial direction , @xmath110 the confining maxima along @xmath66 are not well described by the harmonic approximation and must be evaluated using eqs . ( [ eqs_cr_ring_intensity_cp ] ) and ( [ eqs_fxi_gauss_general_bks_weberfns ] ) . they read @xmath111 to demonstrate the applicability of the pdr for ultra - cold gases , now we discuss the two - dimensional ( 2d ) evolution of a bec of @xmath0rb atoms confined in an annular geometry within the focal plane by using the pdr of cr and a strong additional confinement along the axial direction so that @xmath112 @xcite . such confinement can be achieved by using an additional red - detuned sheet of light ( e.g. generated by focusing a gaussian beam with a cylindrical lens ) to compensate for the weak axial confinement as well as , in case of a horizontal ring plane , the effect of gravity as shown in @xcite . we use the 2d gross pitaevskii equation ( gpe ) in order to study the dynamics of the bec along the ring potential : @xmath113 where @xmath114 is the external potential , @xmath115 , @xmath116 is the scattering length , @xmath117 is the frequency of the confining potential in the axial direction , @xmath99 is the mass of the @xmath0rb atoms and @xmath118 is the number of atoms . in our simulations , we consider trapping close to the @xmath119 and @xmath120 lines of @xmath0rb . these lines possess natural line widths of @xmath121 and @xmath122 and frequencies of @xmath123 and @xmath124 , respectively . thus , to calculate the trapping frequencies and the maxima of the potential barriers is straightforward by using eqs . ( [ auxpot ] ) , ( [ omegar ] ) , ( [ pot_inner ] ) , and ( [ pot_z ] ) . based on the experimental parameters of @xcite , for a biaxial crystal yielding a cr ring of @xmath125 , an input beam waist @xmath126 , a light frequency of @xmath127 and a laser power @xmath128 , at the focal plane , the maxima of the potential barriers and trapping frequencies are , respectively , @xmath129 , @xmath130 and @xmath131 , where @xmath132 is the boltzmann constant . figure [ figexp](a ) shows the numerical simulation for a @xmath0rb bec , with scattering length @xmath133 , of @xmath134 atoms trapped in a blue - detuned harmonic annular potential @xmath135 with radial frequency @xmath136 calculated using eq . ( [ omegar ] ) . our numerical simulations are based in the following loading process : the bec is created in a cross - dipole trap , see e.g. @xcite , and loaded into the red - detuned sheet of light . we consider that both the cross - dipole trap and the red - detuned sheet of light are orthogonal to the gravity field . the pdr potential , which also lies orthogonal to the gravity field , is placed tangent to one of the beams of the cross - dipole trap , see fig . [ figexp](c ) . the beam from the cross - dipole trap that is tangent to the pdr is switched off as the cr pdr potential is switched on , in an adiabatic process . finally , the remaining beam from the cross - dipole trap is switched off and the bec expands in the cr pdr potential . we plot the atomic density of the bec after @xmath137 of expansion in the annular potential . in order to reduce the transverse excitations , the loading of the bec into the cr ring potential has been performed adiabatically ( in our case during @xmath138 ) as reported in @xcite . [ figexp](b ) shows the corresponding experimental density distribution after @xmath137 expansion of a @xmath0rb bec trapped in the real cr pdr . the cr pdr was placed perpendicular to gravity and a sheet of light generated by focusing a gaussian beam with a cylindrical lens was used to hold atoms against gravity . the corresponding measured trapping frequencies are @xmath139 and @xmath140 . the major discrepancy between experimental and numerical density plots is found in the radial width of the bec . in the ideal case ( fig . [ figexp](a ) ) , the effects of broadening due to finite optical resolution and photon scattering of the detection light have not been considered to obtain the image , which shows a bec with a width of @xmath141 . in contrast , the experimental image from fig . [ figexp](b ) , which shows a bec with a width of @xmath142 , was obtained by using red - detuned light ( @xmath143 , @xmath144 ) to illuminate the bec during a time of @xmath145 . for this illuminating light we have calculated a scattering rate @xmath146 that , together with the recoil velocity of @xmath147 , increases the width of the atomic cloud in the radial direction by @xmath148 during the illumination time . figure [ figexp](c ) shows the same numerical simulation as fig . [ figexp](a ) where we have taken into account now the increase of the width produced by the detection process included . now , numerical simulation and experimental result agree well . in order to further confirm the validity of the harmonic approximation , we also studied the ground state of the bec trapped in the toroidal dark - focus ( see fig . [ fig_grounds ] ) . the physical system considered has the following parameters : @xmath125 , @xmath126 , @xmath128 , @xmath149 , @xmath133 and @xmath134 atoms . the toroidal dark trap is placed orthogonal to gravity and , therefore , to provide confinement along the axial direction we have considered a sheet of light analogous to the one discussed in @xcite with a trapping frequency @xmath150 . the plots represent a section of the wave - function in the radial direction at the peak value of the density . the red - solid line in fig . [ fig_grounds](a ) shows the wave - function ground state of the bec trapped in the pdr potential ( represented by the red - dashed line ) , while the black - solid line is the ground state of the bec trapped in the harmonically approximated potential ( represented by black - dashed line ) equivalent to the pdr . to provide confinement in the azimuthal direction , an extra beam yielding a trapping frequency of @xmath151 is included . we have found a @xmath152 of relative difference between the energies of the two ground states . figure [ fig_grounds](b ) presents the bec wave - function after @xmath137 of expansion within the harmonically approximated ring potential ( black - solid line ) and within the real pdr potential ( red - solid line ) . black- and red - dashed lines represent the harmonic ring potential and the pdr potential , respectively . in this case , the relative difference between both wave - functions is negligible . these results confirm the good agreement between the harmonic approximation derived in section [ harmonic_approach ] and the original pdr . in summary , we have presented a novel approach for generating toroidal optical traps for ultra - cold neutral atoms by applying the pdr as a blue - detuned toroidal trap for becs we have studied the normalized intensity distribution around the annular ring structure of the cr phenomenon in biaxial crystals . for a well developed cr ring , i.e. when @xmath153 , experimental results of the intensity distribution are compared with the exact paraxial solution and with its asymptotic approximation . we have found the positions of the bright and dark rings of cr and the position of the two points with maximum intensity along the beam propagation direction , both experimentally and analytically . we have shown that the radius of the pdr is smaller than the optical geometric approximation of the cr ring radius @xmath60 , by approximately half the waist radius of the input beam ( @xmath154 in table [ table1 ] ) . all previous related works @xcite were performed considering that the radius of the pdr exactly coincided with @xmath1 . the reported results show that the pdr is enclosed by higher intensity walls both in the radial as in the axial directions , i.e. it is a toroidal dark - focus in all three dimensions , at variance with other light beams possessing only radial confinement , such as laguerre gaussian modes . we have applied the harmonic approximation around the pdr and we have derived the expression for the radial and axial trapping frequencies and the maxima of the potential barriers for blue - detuned light as a function of common experimental parameters such as beam power , beam waist , detuning and the parameters of the crystal . the reported results show the suitability of the pdr for trapping ultra - cold atoms with blue - detuned light , making this technique ideal for experiments where well - defined potentials and high intensity beams are required @xcite . therefore , as a proof of the usefulness of the derived theory we have performed numerical simulations of the dynamics of a trapped @xmath0rb bec with @xmath134 atoms in the dark ring potential using the harmonic approximation and have compared the obtained results with the solution of the original cr light field . we have also compared the ground states in both cases and we have found @xmath152 relative difference in energy between them . the numerical simulations agree well with the experimental results on the dynamics of a trapped @xmath0rb bec in the pdr of cr . the main advantages of the presented technique are the simple generation and high quality of the cr toroidal dark trap , since the only requirements are a biaxial crystal and a focused input gaussian beam , at variance with the techniques using lg beams that need the interference of at least two beams @xcite . also , the minimum ( and practically null ) intensity circle offered by the toroidal dark trap avoids photon scattering and presents no corrugation of the potential minimum at the focal plane . additionally , and at variance with techniques based on lg beams @xcite or amplitude masks @xcite , the use of a biaxial crystal allows for the full input power to be converted into the cr dark toroidal trap . which increases the efficiency in ultra - cold atom trapping experiments . moreover , biaxial crystals can be transparent to an extremely wide spectral range@xcite ( 0.35 @xmath155 - 5.5 @xmath155 in kgd(wo@xmath76)@xmath77 , for instance ) , in contrast with spatial light modulators used in the generation of lg beams , which only work in a small spectral range of few hundreds of @xmath156 , typically . a range of applications of this technique can be envisioned : for optimized beam geometries , i.e. small @xmath8 , @xmath1 , and @xmath12 , the toroidal dark focus of the pdr generated by cr could be used to built an all - optical trap for becs using a single beam . under such conditions , this potential could be used as a basic element in atomic squid experiments @xcite , as well as to study the dynamics of matter waves with periodic boundary conditions and the generation of persistent currents @xcite . for large @xmath1 , the pdr can be used as a dark 2d ring potential by using a 1d light sheet , along the axial direction , as an additional confining potential . this configuration would allow to study wave - packet interference in a mesoscopic ring simulating a quasi - one - dimensional system @xcite . by modifying this 1d light sheet to a blue - detuned double layer also accessible via cr @xcite again a fully blue - detuned dark trap geometry with added flexibility is generated . as an encouragement for future investigations , other cylindrically symmetric light structures of interest in atomic trapping experiments such as flat intensity regions or doughnut - like beams are also accessible via cr @xcite . additionally , a radial optical lattice could be generated by means of a cascade of biaxial crystals , generating @xmath157 dark rings for a cascade of n biaxial crystals @xcite . this could be also combined with the technique shown in @xcite to generate an azimuthal optical lattice with controllable number of nodes and separation between them , applicable in quantum - many body systems experiments @xcite . also interesting is the possibility of using the pdr to coherently injecting , extracting , and velocity filtering of particles , ultra - cold atoms and becs as reported in @xcite by tuning the polarization of the input beam and opening / closing the ring potential . finally , we would also like to note that by switching to red - detuned light , the inner and outer bright rings around the pdr generate an intrinsically concentric system of a double - ring potential which can be used for the generation of coherent double wave packets for the investigation of wave packet tunneling and coupled persistent currents of ultra cold atoms @xcite . the authors gratefully acknowledge financial support through the spanish micinn contract , and fis2011 - 23719 , the catalan government contract sgr2009 - 00347 , and the daad contracts 50024895 and 57059126 . a. turpin acknowledges financial support through grant ap2010 - 2310 from the micinn and the daad grant 91526836 . j. polo also acknowledges financial support from fpi grant no . bes-2012 - 053447 . e. m. wright , j. arlt , and k. dholakia , `` toroidal optical dipole traps for atomic bose - einstein condensates using laguerre - gaussian beams , '' phys . a * * 6**3 , 013608 ( 2000 ) . g. birkl , f. b. j. buchkremer , r. dumke , and w. ertmer , `` atom optics with microfabricated optical elements , '' opt . commun . * 191 * , 6781 ( 2001 ) ; t. mther , j. nes , a .- gehrmann , m. volk , w. ertmer , g. birkl , m. gruber , and j. jahns , `` atomic quantum systems in optical micro - structures , '' j. phys . * 19 * , 97101 ( 2005 ) . s. franke - arnold , j. leach , m. j. padgett , v. e. lembessis , d. ellinas , a. j. wright , j. m. girkin , p. hberg and a. s. arnold , `` optical ferris wheel for ultracold atoms , '' opt . express * 15 * , 86198625 ( 2007 ) . c. ryu , m. f. andersen , p. clad , v. natarajan , k. helmerson , and w. d. phillips , phys . rev . lett . * 99 * , 260401 ( 2007 ) . a. ramanathan , k. c. wright , s. r. muniz , m. zelan , w. t. hill , c. j. lobb , k. helmerson , w. d. phillips , and g. k. campbell , `` observation of persistent flow of a bose - einstein condensate in a toroidal trap , '' phys . 106 * , 130401 ( 2011 ) . s. e. olson , m. l. terraciano , m. bashkansky , and f. k. fatemi , `` cold - atom confinement in an all - optical dark ring trap , '' phys . a * 76 * , 061404 ( 2007 ) . a. i. yakimenko , yu . m. bidasyuk , o. o. prikhodko , s. i. vilchinskii , e. a. ostrovskaya , and yu . s. kivshar , `` optical tweezers for vortex rings in bose - einstein condensates , '' phys . rev . a * 88 * , 043637 ( 2013 ) . s , eckel , jeffrey g. lee , f. jendrzejewski , n. murray , c. w. clark , c. j. lobb , w. d. phillips , m. edwards , and g. k. campbell , `` hysteresis in a quantized superfluid ` atomtronic ' circuit , '' nature * 506 * , 200204 ( 2014 ) . j. g. lee , and w. t. hill , `` spatial shaping for generating arbitrary optical dipoles traps for ultracold degenerate gases , '' arxiv:1406.4084 . l. corman , l. chomaz , t. bienaim , r. desbuquois , c. weintenberg , s. nascimbne , j. dalibard , and j. beugnon , `` quench - induced supercurrents in an annular two - dimensional bose gas , '' phys . * 113 * , 135302 ( 2014 ) . a. turpin , v. shvedov , c , hnatonsky , yu . v. loiko , j. mompart , and w. krolikowski , `` optical vault : a reconfigurable bottle beam based on conical refraction of light , '' opt . express , * 21 * , 2633526340 ( 2013 ) . v. loiko , a. turpin , t. k. kalkandjiev , e. u. rafailov , and j. mompart , `` generating a three - dimensional dark focus from a single conically refracted light beam , '' opt 38 * , 46484651 ( 2013 ) . r. t. darcy , d. mccloskey , k. e. ballantine , j. g. lunney , p. r. eastham , and j. f. donegan , `` conical diffraction intensity profiles generated using a top - hat input beam , '' opt . express * 22 * , 11290 - 11300 ( 2014 ) . t. lauber , j. kber , o. wille , and g. birkl , `` optimized bose - einstein - condensate production in a dipole trap based on a 1070-nm multifrequency laser : influence of enhanced two - body loss on the evaporation process , '' phys . a * 84 * , 043641 ( 2011 ) . v. loiko , v. ahufinger , r. menchon - enrich , g. birkl , and j. mompart , `` coherent injecting , extracting , and velocity - filtering of neutral atoms in a ring trap via spatial adiabatic passage , '' eur . j. d * 68 * , 147 ( 2014 ) .

we present a novel approach for the optical manipulation of neutral atoms in annular light structures produced by the phenomenon of conical refraction occurring in biaxial optical crystals . for a beam focused to a plane behind the crystal , the focal plane exhibits two concentric bright rings enclosing a ring of null intensity called the poggendorff ring . we demonstrate both theoretically and experimentally that the poggendorff dark ring of conical refraction is confined in three dimensions by regions of higher intensity . we derive the positions of the confining intensity maxima and minima and discuss the application of the poggendorff ring for trapping ultra - cold atoms using the repulsive dipole force of blue - detuned light . we give analytical expressions for the trapping frequencies and potential depths along both the radial and the axial directions . finally , we present realistic numerical simulations of the dynamics of a @xmath0rb bose - einstein condensate trapped inside the poggendorff ring which are in good agreement with corresponding experimental results .

1001.0487

@xcite discovered an excitation mechanism of stellar oscillations that is related to the opacity behaviour in ionisation zones : the @xmath0-mechanism , where @xmath0 denotes the opacity . this mechanism occurs when the opacity varies during compression phases so as to block the emerging radiative flux @xcite . ionisation regions correspond to a strong increase in opacity that leads to the _ opacity bumps _ responsible for the local excitation of modes . these driving zones should nevertheless be located at a precise radius inside the star , neither too close to the surface nor to deep , in order to balance the damping that mainly occurs at the surface . it defines the so - called _ transition region _ that shapes the limit between the quasi - adiabatic interior and the strongly non - adiabatic surface . for classical cepheids that pulsate in the fundamental acoustic mode , this transition region is located at a temperature @xmath1 k corresponding to the second helium ionisation @xcite . however , the bump location is not solely responsible for the acoustic instability . a careful treatment of the @xmath0-mechanism would involve dynamical couplings with convection , metallicity effects and both realistic equations of state and opacity tables @xcite . the purpose of our model is to simplify the hydrodynamic approach while retaining the _ leading - order _ phenomenon e.g . the location of the opacity bump or its amplitude such that feasible direct numerical simulations of the @xmath0-mechanism with convection can be achieved . we first focus on radial modes propagating in a purely - radiative and partially - ionised layer and then restrict our study to the 1-d case . our model consists of a _ local zoom _ about an ionisation region and is composed by a monatomic and perfect gas ( with @xmath2 ) under both a constant gravity @xmath3 and kinematic viscosity @xmath4 . all quantities in our model are dimensionless , e.g. temperature is given in unit of the surface temperature of the star , length in unit of a fraction of the star radius and velocity in unit of the sound speed at the surface . in order to easily investigate the influence of the opacity bump on the stability , we adopt the following conductivity hollow to mimic this bump ( as @xmath5 , see * ? ? ? * hereafter paper i ) : @xmath6,\ ] ] with @xmath7 and @xmath8 . here @xmath9 is the equilibrium temperature profile , @xmath10 is the hollow central temperature , and @xmath11 and @xmath12 denote its slope , width and relative amplitude , respectively . examples of common values of these parameters are provided in fig . [ fig : profile - rad ] . and @xmath13.,width=302 ] using the well - known work integral formalism ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) , it is easy to show that the following condition is necessary to get unstable modes by @xmath0-mechanism in variable stars : @xmath14 however , this condition is not sufficient as the ionisation region should also be located at a given location in the star , neither too deep nor too close to its surface . this area is the so - called _ transition region _ that separates the quasi - adiabatic interior from the strongly non - adiabatic surface and is defined by ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the integrated mass between the considered point and the surface , @xmath17 the mode period and @xmath18 the luminosity . @xmath19 is the ratio between the thermal energy embedded between the given radius and the surface and the energy radiated during an oscillation period . coefficient ( eq . [ eq : psi ] ) . the superimposed green zone represents the location where @xmath20 . * b * ) the real part of the work integral plotted for the three different equilibrium models . the dot - dashed black line is for the constant radiative conductivity case . * c * ) corresponding radiative conductivity profiles . * d * ) corresponding equilibrium fields @xmath21 ( eq . [ eq : kt]).,width=302 ] in order to check these two conditions , we perform a linear stability analysis by using the linear solver builder code @xcite . by starting with the conductivity profiles shown in fig . [ fig : profile - rad ] , we first compute the equilibrium setup that is solution of both the hydrostatic and radiative equilibria given by @xmath22 = 0 , \label{eq : equil}\ ] ] where @xmath23 and @xmath24 denote the equilibrium pressure and density . then , we solve the linear oscillation equations for the perturbations by seeking normal modes of the form @xmath25 with @xmath26 , where @xmath27 is the mode frequency and @xmath28 its growth or damping rate ( unstable modes corresponding to @xmath29 ) . by varying the hollow parameters , we then determine the physical conditions that lead to unstable modes excited by the @xmath0-mechanism in our layer ( cf . paper i ) . the two criteria ( [ eq : kt ] ) and ( [ eq : psi ] ) predict that modes are unstable for a `` sufficient '' hollow ( adequate amplitude and width ) that is located in the transition region . using the work integral computed from the obtained eigenvectors , we indeed recover instability strips for the @xmath0-mechanism by considering the three different equilibrium setups ( fig . [ fig : wi ] ) : * the first case ( dotted blue line , @xmath30 ) corresponds to a hot star with an ionisation region close to the surface . as the surrounding density is small , @xmath31 and the conductivity hollow hardly influences the work integral : driving is unable to prevail over damping , leading to @xmath32 or _ stable _ modes . * in the second case ( solid green line , @xmath33 ) , the radiative conductivity begins to decrease significantly at the location of the transition region where @xmath34 . as a consequence , driving becomes important . furthermore , the radiative conductivity increase occurs where non - adiabatic effects are already significant , i.e. @xmath35 there . it means that no damping occurs between the hollow position and the surface as the radiative flux perturbations are frozen - in . driving is overcoming damping in this case , therefore @xmath36 and modes are _ unstable_. * the third case ( dashed red line , @xmath37 ) corresponds to a cold star of which ionisation region is located deeper in the stellar atmosphere where @xmath38 . ionisation then occurs in a quasi - adiabatic location . as a consequence , the excitation provided by the conductivity hollow can not balance the damping arising at the top of the layer , thus @xmath39 and modes are _ stable_. in conclusion , our first radiative model of the @xmath0-mechanism is well able to reproduce the main physics involved in the oscillations of cepheid stars : _ one should have @xmath40 to drive the oscillations ; _ ( ii ) _ the thermal engine underlying the conductivity hollow should also be located in the transition region where @xmath41 ( fig . [ fig : wi ] ) . to confirm both the results obtained previously in the linear stability analysis and to investigate the resulting nonlinear saturation , we perform direct numerical simulations of our problem . the idea is to start from the most favourable initial conditions found in the stability analysis and then advance the general hydrodynamic equations in time . we use a modified version of the public - domain finite - difference pencil code that includes an implicit solver of our own for the radiative diffusion term in the temperature equation ( * ? ? ? * hereafter paper ii ) . * b ) * the resulting spectrum after integrating over depth . * c ) * comparison between normalised momentum profiles for @xmath42 modes according to the dns power spectrum ( solid black line ) and to the linear stability analysis ( dotted blue line).,width=302 ] to determine which modes are present in the dns in the nonlinear - saturation regime , we first perform a temporal fourier transform of the momentum field @xmath43 and plot the resulting power spectrum in the @xmath44-plane ( fig . [ fig : fourier]a ) . the mean spectrum follows by integrating @xmath45 over depth ( fig . [ fig : fourier]b ) . with this method , acoustic modes are extracted because they emerge as `` shark - fin profiles '' about definite eigenfrequencies @xcite . several discrete peaks corresponding to normal modes well appear but the fundamental mode close to @xmath46 clearly dominates . moreover , the linear eigenfunctions are compared to the mean profiles computed from a zoom taken in the dns power spectrum about eigenfrequencies @xmath46 and @xmath47 ( fig . [ fig : fourier]c ) . the agreement between the linear eigenfunctions ( dotted blue lines ) and the dns profiles ( solid black lines ) is remarkable . in summary , [ fig : fourier ] shows that several overtones are present in the dns , even for long times . these overtones are however _ linearly stable _ suggesting that some underlying energy transfers occur between modes through nonlinear couplings . these nonlinear interactions are investigated thanks to a tool that measures the sound generation by turbulent flows ( e.g. * ? ? ? it involves projections of the dns physical fields onto the regular and adjoint eigenvectors that are solutions to the linear oscillation equations . the projection coefficients then give the time evolution of each acoustic mode that is present in the dns _ separately_. furthermore , as the evolution of the kinetic energy of each mode is also accessible with this method , one can follow the energy transfer between modes . and @xmath48 acoustic modes.,width=302 ] figure [ fig : nrj ] shows an example of the time evolution of the kinetic energy ratio @xmath49 for the two modes @xmath50 ( i.e. the fundamental one ) and @xmath48 ( i.e. the second overtone ) . here @xmath51 denotes the kinetic energy embedded in the acoustic mode of order @xmath52 , while @xmath53 is the total kinetic energy in the simulation . after its linear transient growth , a given fraction of the fundamental mode energy is progressively transferred to the second overtone until the nonlinear saturation is achieved above time @xmath54 , with finally @xmath55 of the total kinetic energy in the @xmath56 mode and the remaining @xmath57 in the @xmath48 one . we recall that it is at a first glance surprising to detect this second overtone at long times because it is linearly stable and should normally be damped by diffusive effects . the reason for its presence lies in a favored coupling in the period ratio between these two modes . indeed , the fundamental period is @xmath58 in this simulation while the @xmath48 one is @xmath59 . as a consequence , the corresponding period ratio is close to one half ( @xmath60 ) such that the second overtone is involved in the nonlinear saturation through a 2:1 resonance with the fundamental mode . the linear growth of the fundamental mode is then balanced by the pumping of energy to the stable second overtone that behaves as an energy sink , leading to the full limit - cycle stability . after the previous results obtained on purely radiative models in 1-d , we next address the convection - pulsation coupling that is suspected to quench the radial oscillations of cepheids close to the red edge . the idea is to slightly modify the unstable radiative setup to obtain a convective zone superimposed to the ionisation region in 2-d simulations . the convective instability obeys schwarzschild s criterion given by ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) figure [ fig : vort ] displays a snapshot of the vorticity field obtained in such a convective simulation at time @xmath65 . in order to ensure that the thermal relaxation is well achieved , we ran this simulation for a much longer time than in the purely - radiative case and the resolution is @xmath66 gridpoints . as expected , convection develops in the middle of the box where the conductivity hollow is located . moreover , because of the density contrast across the convection zone , the vorticity is trapped in strong convective plume downdrafts that easily overshoot in the stable zone below due to their low pclet number @xcite . to address the time evolution of the acoustic modes that are present in the dns with convection , we project as before the physical fields onto an appropriate acoustic subspace to get the projection coefficient @xmath67 . here @xmath68 denotes the mode degree while @xmath52 is its order ( with @xmath69 and @xmath70 is the width of the box ) . where @xmath72 is the pressure scale height , @xmath73 the vertical extent of the convection zone , @xmath74 the radiative diffusivity and @xmath75 the entropy . this number allows to quantify the strength of the convective motions , that is , the critical rayleigh number above which convection develops is about @xmath76 for polytropic stratifications ( e.g. * ? ? ? in the first simulation ( @xmath77 , solid blue line ) , the rayleigh number is slightly super - critical and the convection intensity is weak . in this case , we see that the acoustic energy ratio remains large ( i.e. @xmath78 , the remaining @xmath79 being in the convection ) and the nonlinear saturation is reached in the same way than in the previous radiative models . in other words , the mode propagation is not affected by convective motions and the convection can be seen as _ frozen - in_. on the contrary , increasing the rayleigh number leads to a more vigorous convection and the acoustic energy ratio is much more affected by convective plumes ( dashed green line ) . indeed , after a long transient during which it reaches a non - trifling value ( @xmath80 ) , it progressively tends to zero at long times while the convective motions are responsible for the whole kinetic energy content . the radial oscillations excited by @xmath0-mechanism are thus quenched by convection and this situation is relevant to the red edge where the unstable acoustic modes are known to be damped by convective motions occuring at the star s surface . we thus have shown that the rayleigh number is a key parameter for this problem . but further investigations of the convection - pulsation coupling are in progress , by especially checking time - dependent theories of convection for which several free parameters can be constrained by such kind of direct numerical simulations ( e.g. * ? ? ?

a strong coupling between convection and pulsations is known to play a major role in the disappearance of unstable modes close to the red edge of the classical cepheid instability strip . as mean - field models of time - dependent convection rely on weakly - constrained parameters ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) , we tackle this problem by the means of 2-d direct numerical simulations ( dns ) of @xmath0-mechanism with convection . using a linear stability analysis , we first determine the physical conditions favourable to the @xmath0-mechanism to occur inside a purely - radiative layer . both the instability strips and the nonlinear saturation of unstable modes are then confirmed by the corresponding dns . we next present the new simulations with convection , where a convective zone and the driving region overlap . the coupling between the convective motions and acoustic modes is then addressed by using projections onto an acoustic subspace .

quant-ph0403018

an open quantum system has been extensively studied for potential applications to quantum computation and quantum information processing @xcite . through the interaction with a reservoir a quantum system loses its coherent information . this is a so - called _ decoherence process _ decoherence has been regarded as a critical obstacle against quantum information processing . however , as the notion of `` reservoir engineering '' has been suggested for laser cooled trapped ions @xcite , the studies on the decoherence have moved to control it in laboratories instead of suffering from it @xcite . many of these studies have been based on markovian reservoirs @xcite . a markovian reservoir is characterized by two essential properties : a ) _ weak _ coupling with a system by which born approximation is validated and b ) _ rapid _ relaxation time such that the information of the system is diffused over the reservoir in a rather short time compared to the time scale in which the system changes . in the perspective of engineering a reservoir , it is desirable to study the decoherence caused through a non - markovian reservoir . it is strongly believed that a solid - state realization of quantum information processing may be extremely useful @xcite . the decoherence phenomena for solid state systems including a photonic band gap material and a quantum dot can not always be understood under the markovian assumption @xcite . the evolution of a single - mode atomic cavity in a non - markovian reservoir has been studied for an atom laser @xcite . a non - markovian reservoir has `` memory effects '' such that it preserves the coherent information of the system within its relaxation time . in order to analyze how many operations can be performed by preserving the coherent information of the system , one may consider three types of characteristic times : operation time @xmath0 for a single quantum operation on the system , decoherence time @xmath1 due to the interaction between the system and the reservoir , and the relaxation time @xmath2 within the reservoir . when a quantum system decoheres in a markovian reservoir with @xmath3 , the time correlation of fluctuations in the reservoir is neglected . however , in a non - markovian reservoir with @xmath2 comparable to @xmath1 , it is expected that the time correlation between fluctuations during the time interval @xmath4 raises a correlated influence on the system . once perturbed by the system , the reservoir may memorize a part of the system s information during @xmath2 @xcite . this memorized information will be fed back to the system at another perturbation within @xmath2 . it is expected that the correlated influence significantly suppresses the decoherence of the system @xcite . an extremal example for the memory effects by a non - markovian reservoir is that two atoms , which are prepared initially in a product states , come to be in an entangled state through the interaction with a common thermal reservoir @xcite . in ref . @xcite , the reservoir consists of a single - mode field with no relaxation , @xmath5 . it is desirable to study decoherence processes by bridging the gap between the two limiting cases of @xmath6 and @xmath7 . dynamics of an open system may be obtained from a quantum liouville equation of the total system that consists of the system and the reservoir @xcite . the reduced density operator of the system needs to be positive at all times . the positivity does not need to be altered by the presence of any other system , in other words , the reduced density operator of the system needs to be completely positive if the system and the reservoir are initially uncorrelated @xcite . the complete positivity was intensively discussed for a markovian reservoir @xcite . for a non - markovian reservoir , it was discussed for a master equation derived by using an operator sum representation with coarse - graining approximation @xcite . a random telegraph signal model was studied for a system in a non - markovian reservoir @xcite . however the complete positivity of the system density operator in a non - markovian reservoir is still an important problem to be unraveled . in this paper , we propose an effective hamiltonian approach to investigate the decoherence of a quantum system in a non - markovian reservoir . instead of deriving a non - markovian master equation , the formalism is based on the notion of an effective reservoir , _ i.e. _ , certain collective degrees of freedom in the reservoir that is responsible for the decoherence . we show that _ the reduced dynamics of the open system is completely positive _ and the complete positivity is naturally imposed from the effective hamiltonian approach . as examples for completely positive decoherence , we present three typical decoherence processes for a qubit such as dephasing , depolarizing , and amplitude - damping . the effects of the non - markovian decoherence are compared to the markovian decoherence . dynamics of an open quantum system has commonly been investigated by a master equation for the density operator or a fokker - planck equation for the quasi - probability function such as a wigner function @xcite . it is however difficult to derive a completely positive master equation for a system interacting with a general non - markovian reservoir . we suggest an effective hamiltonian approach by introducing the notion of `` effective variables '' in the environment . it will be shown that the large ( normally infinite ) number of environmental degrees of freedom , which we call `` environmental variables '' , is reductive into a small number of _ effective environmental variables _ in the sense that both cases result in the same master ( or fokker - planck ) equation for the system . for instance , a markovian thermal environment is reductive into a collective single - mode boson field in a thermal state @xcite . the property of being reductive into the small effective environmental variables , that leads to the correct and equivalent description of the reduced dynamics for a system , is predicted by two observations . first , at a given time @xmath8 , the density operator @xmath9 of the system @xmath10 can always be purified to a pure state @xmath11 of a larger composite system consisting of the system @xmath10 and an ancillary system @xmath12 , such that @xmath9 is obtained by tracing the pure state over the ancillary system , _ i.e. _ , @xmath13 provides all physical descriptions relating to the system and the ancillary system is called effective variable(s ) , which is in effect certain collective degrees of freedom , of the environment at the given time @xmath8 . secondly , the effective variables may be dynamic over the whole environmental variables as the interaction time @xmath8 passes . on the other hand , the dynamics of the effective variables can be absorbed by time - dependent coupling constants while keeping the effective variables stationary . the set of the time - dependent coupling constants and the effective variables contains all the information of the environment that governs the decoherence of the system . we call this set an effective environment . suppose @xmath14 is an interaction hamiltonian between a system @xmath10 and an effective environment @xmath12 . we write the interaction hamiltonian @xmath14 , in the interaction picture , in the form of @xmath15 where @xmath16 is a hermitian operator for the system @xmath10 and @xmath17 with hermitian operator @xmath18 is for the effective environment @xmath12 . the unit of @xmath19 is used throughout the paper . here , the time - dependent coupling constant @xmath20 is a hermitian matrix . the composite system @xmath21 is assumed initially in a product state , @xmath22 the effective environment @xmath12 consists of collective degrees of freedom in the environment @xmath23 @xcite . its initial state @xmath24 is not necessarily an thermal state even when the real environment is thermal . the hilbert space of the effective environment and the time - dependent interaction hamiltonian @xmath14 are determined such that they result in the correct reduced dynamics of the system . they may be determined from first principle calculation such as the time - convolutionless projection - operator method @xcite . the use of the time - convolutionless projection - operator method is presented in sec . once the effective environment is determined , one may consider and solve the quantum liouville equation for the composite system , @xmath25.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the evolution operator is now given as @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the time - ordering operator . in most cases , it is convenient to let @xmath28 or @xmath29 so that @xmath30 $ ] where @xmath31 . this simpler form of @xmath32 has advantages for later discussions from the calculational point of view . the total system is described by the density operator @xmath33 and the reduced density operator of @xmath10 is given by partially tracing the total density operator over @xmath12 , @xmath34 letting @xmath35 be the orthonormal basis set of @xmath12 that diagonalizes @xmath36 , the reduced dynamics of the system is described by a kraus representation ( or operator sum representation ) @xcite : @xmath37 where @xmath38 . note that the superoperator @xmath39 is a linear operator in the hilbert - schmidt space of density operators . calligraphic letters are used for superoperators on the hilbert - schmidt space throughout the paper . it is remarkable that the existence of the kraus representation @xmath40 directly implies the complete positivity of the evolution superoperator @xmath41 @xcite . this fact was already guaranteed since the hamiltonian formalism was adopted in the present approach of effective environment . this approach is applicable to the system decohering in a non - markovian as well as a markovian environment . the present approach of effective environment has several advantages in describing the reduced dynamics of a system . firstly , it provides the correct and equivalent description , similar to the master equation . secondly and most importantly , it guarantees the complete positivity in a general environment like a non - markovian environment . thirdly , it enables the analysis of the structure for effective variables , in a given environment , that are directly responsible for the decoherence . this analysis will be given in sec . [ sec : qubit ] . lastly , one may simulate the decoherence in an experiment by introducing such an effective environment and controlling the coupling to the given system . in the previous section we showed that the the effective environment approach provides the description of the reduced dynamics of a quantum system , which decoheres through an environment , provided the hilbert space of the effective environment , its initial state @xmath24 and the time - dependent interaction hamiltonian @xmath14 are determined . in this section we suggest a scheme which determines them by a first principle theory , in particular , the time - convolutionless projection - operator method @xcite which has been employed to study non - markovian environments for quantum information processing @xcite . consider the total system of a quantum system and an environment . the total system is assumed to have the hamiltonian , @xmath42 where @xmath43 , @xmath44 , and @xmath45 are the hamiltonians for the system , the environment , and their interaction respectively . it is straightforward to generalize that @xmath43 may contain time - dependent external fields to control a quantum operation on the system . for a typical form of the interaction hamiltonian , we consider a caldeira - leggett - type model @xcite given by @xmath46 where @xmath47 is a hermitian operator acting on the system and @xmath48 is a fluctuating boson field due to perturbation arising from the system . here , @xmath49 ( @xmath50 ) is an annihilation ( creation ) operator for a boson mode @xmath51 . the unperturbed boson fields of the environment are governed by @xmath52 . the set of the operators @xmath53 describes various decoherence processes . the quantum liouville equation for the density operator @xmath54 of the total system is given by @xmath55 = -i \so{l}_t { \tilde \rho}_t(\tau),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath56 is the liouville operator . here , the symbol tilde is given to indicate a density operator in the schdinger picture . each liouville operator @xmath57 is a superoperator on the hilbert - schmidt space of density operators . the liouville operators are in one - to - one correspondence to the hamiltonians of the same subscriptions . before the system starts to decohere , the environment is assumed initially in a thermal state @xmath58 where @xmath59 , @xmath60 is the temperature and @xmath61 the boltzmann constant . the assumption may be released to all the time - independent states that commute with the non - interacting hamiltonian of the environment , _ i.e. _ , @xmath62 . in order to derive and solve a reduced equation for the system alone , we employ a projection - operator method @xcite . time - independent projection operators @xmath63 and @xmath64 are defined as @xmath65 for a dynamical variable @xmath66 on the total system . here @xmath67 indicates a partial trace over the environment . the reduced density operator of the system is given by @xmath68 . the quantum liouville equation ( [ eq : qle ] ) can be decomposed into two coupled equations for @xmath69 and @xmath70 respectively by applying the projection operators . for the total system decoupled at @xmath71 , the solution for @xmath70 is substituted for the equation of @xmath72 with an ansatz @xmath73 the ansatz is introduced to ignore the renormalization of the unperturbed energy @xcite ( otherwise it raises the lamb shift @xcite ) . represented in the interaction picture , the time - convolutionless master equation for the system is given @xcite by @xmath74 where @xmath75 is the reduced density operator in the interaction picture and @xmath76 is the generalized collision operator . let us consider a weak - coupling approximation ( or a short - time limit ) up to the second - order @xmath77 . the collision operator @xmath78 can now be written as @xmath79 \nonumber \\ & + & \tilde{\chi}_{\alpha\beta}(\tau'-\tau)[{\hat s}_\beta(\tau ) , { \hat \rho}_s(\tau){\hat s}_\alpha(\tau ' ) ] \big\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath80 and @xmath81 = \tilde{\chi}_{\beta\alpha}^*(-\tau)\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath82 . the function @xmath83 characterizes all properties of the environment for the decoherence of the system . in particular , it describes the time correlation between the quantum fluctuations @xmath84 and @xmath85 perturbed by the system at the respective times . the time convolutionless form of eq . ( [ eq : seq ] ) is one of the crucial advantages of using the projection - operator scheme while a time - convolution equation would be derived by a simple perturbation theory @xcite . it was shown @xcite that the time - convolutionless equation ( [ eq : seq ] ) becomes the lindblad master equation in the markov approximation . in order to make a connection to the effective environment scheme presented in sec . [ sec : ee ] , eq . ( [ eq : socol2 ] ) will be further analyzed . in eq . ( [ eq : socol2 ] ) the system operators depend on the evolution time . the time - dependent operators can be expanded by a complete set of hermitian operators , @xmath86 , in the hilbert - schmidt space where the set @xmath86 is chosen to include the operators @xmath16 of the system : @xmath87 where @xmath88 is the dimension of the systems hilbert space . the coefficient @xmath89 can be obtained by solving the heisenberg equation , @xmath90.\end{aligned}\ ] ] eqs . ( [ eq : ebcho ] ) and ( [ eq : hefo ] ) give the following equation , which is equivalent to eq . ( [ eq : socol2 ] ) , @xmath91 \nonumber \\ & & + \gamma_{\beta\alpha}^*(\tau)[{\hat s}_\beta , { \hat \rho}_s(\tau){\hat s}_\alpha ] \big\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath92 in the form of eq . ( [ eq : socol2p ] ) , the matrix @xmath93 determines the master equation ( [ eq : seq ] ) and the reduced dynamics of the system . the matrix @xmath93 may be represented by a sum of hermitian and anti - hermitian matrices , _ i.e. _ , @xmath94 . the hermitian term @xmath95 involves in the decoherence while the anti - hermitian term @xmath96 contributes to the hamiltonian dynamics of the system . we call the hermitian matrix @xmath95 a decoherence rate matrix . now , the system operators in eq . ( [ eq : socol2p ] ) are time - independent which enables the connection to the effective environment approach . the evolution superoperator @xmath97 , _ i.e. _ , the solution to the master equation ( [ eq : seq ] ) , is not necessarily completely positive _ in the long - time limit_. on the other hand , the method of the effective environment guarantees the complete positivity of the evolution superoperator @xmath98 _ at all times_. in the appendix we show how to examine the complete positivity for a given superoperator . in the effective environment approach one needs to determine the parameters of the effective environment . to determine them we require that in the short - time limit the master equation derived by the effective environment be approximately equal to the master equation ( [ eq : seq ] ) in conjuction with eq . ( [ eq : socol2p ] ) . the effective environment approach may have different higher - order terms from the time - convolutionless projection - operator method and this difference leads to the complete positivity of the reduced dynamics in the effective environment approach . using the interaction hamiltonian ( [ eq : eeiih ] ) and following the similar procedure leading to eq . ( [ eq : seq ] ) , we can derive the master equation in the effective environment approach . this has to be approximate to eq . ( [ eq : seq ] ) in conjuction with eq . ( [ eq : socol2p ] ) in the short - time limit . this comparison leads to the following two conditions @xmath99 = 0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is comparable to eq . ( [ eq : ans ] ) , and @xmath100 \approx \gamma_{\alpha\beta}(\tau)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath101 is given in eq . ( [ eq : eeiih ] ) . the initial density operator @xmath24 and the time - dependent coupling matrix @xmath20 can be chosen by varying the operators @xmath102 so as to satisfy the coupled linear equations ( [ eq : cond1 ] ) and ( [ eq : cond2 ] ) . the hilbert space of the effective environment needs to be enlarged with respect to the dimensionality unless any solution is found to eqs . ( [ eq : cond1 ] ) and ( [ eq : cond2 ] ) . as a result , the chosen set of operators @xmath103 are responsible for the type of decoherence which the system undergoes . in this sense the operator @xmath101 is called a decoherence channel to the environment . in most cases , an effective environment has the same hilbert - space dimensionality as the quantum system . for instance , this is the case for markovian environments . nonetheless , an effective environment can be of larger dimensionality in order to properly describe the reduced dynamics of a system . an effective environment may be classified into a `` @xmath104-qubit environment '' if the effective environment consists of @xmath104 qubits , `` @xmath105-mode bosonic environment '' if it consists of @xmath105 bosonic modes , and so on . we shall consider the asymptotic form of the time - correlation function @xmath106 . the time - correlation function is in general complex . however , being interested in the decoherence , we concentrate on the real part of the time - correlation function . the time - correlation function becomes real - valued when the system hamiltonian is redefined so that it includes lamb shifts @xcite . noting that the time - correlation disappears at a long time , @xmath107 approaches zero in the limit of @xmath108 . thus , @xmath107 is assumed to have the form of @xmath109 where @xmath110 and @xmath111 are polynomial ( or trigonometric ) functions and further @xmath112 as @xmath113 . a simple form of @xmath107 will be given by @xmath114 where @xmath115 is a decoherence rate with the decoherence time @xmath1 and @xmath2 is a relaxation time ( or memory time ) in which the injected information is diffused over the environment . in the markovian limit of @xmath3 , the time correlation function becomes a delta function so that @xmath116 and @xmath117 . the time - correlation function in eq . ( [ eq : msfotc ] ) may be regarded as the first extension from markovian to non - markovian decoherence @xcite . we shall present typical decoherence of a qubit system in markovian and non - markovian environments in the approach of an effective environment . in addition , we investigate the structure of an effective environment : a ) the environmental variables that play a role in the respective decoherence , b ) the coupling constants between the system and the effective environment , and c ) the initial quantum states of the effective environment . we shall first of all consider a dephasing process . as in sec . [ sec : dee ] , we compare both master equations in the projection - operator method and the effective environment approach for a dephasing process . it is found that the effective environment has one qubit and the interaction hamiltonian is given by @xmath118 } { \sqrt{1-\exp[-8\gamma(\tau)]}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath119 is a pauli spin operator and @xmath120 . the initial states of the system and the one - qubit effective environment can be written as @xmath121 where @xmath122 is an identity operator , @xmath123 a bloch vector of the system qubit , @xmath124 a bloch vector of the one - qubit environment , and @xmath125 . in connection with the time correlation function of the environment , the coupled linear equations ( [ eq : cond1 ] ) and ( [ eq : cond2 ] ) are satisfied for @xmath126 and @xmath127 in eq . ( [ eq : tdcc ] ) , in the short - time limit of @xmath128 . the initial state of the effective environment is unpolarized along the @xmath129 axis while it may be polarized on the @xmath130-@xmath131 plane for the dephasing process . let us consider the reduced dynamics of the system . applying eqs . ( [ eq : qdpee ] ) and ( [ eq : tdcc ] ) to eqs . ( [ eq : fseo])@xmath132([eq : rdos ] ) , we obtain the reduced dynamics in terms of its bloch vector , @xmath133 , s_y \exp[-4\gamma(\tau ) ] , s_z\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the dynamics of the dephasing process is characterized by the decay function @xmath134 $ ] . the decay function may be regarded as a fringe visibility on the quantum interference for a given time @xmath8 . in order to compare the effect of the non - markovian decoherence to the markovian one , we employ the simple time - correlation function in eq . ( [ eq : msfotc ] ) . the decay function then becomes @xmath135 = \exp\left\{-\kappa\left[\tau - \tau_r \left(1-e^{-\tau/\tau_r } \right)\right ] \right\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the limit of no memory , @xmath136 , the dephasing process is markovian with the decay function , @xmath134 = \exp(-\kappa \tau)$ ] . when the environment keeps the information of the system within the memory time @xmath2 , the loss of the coherent information is suppressed in comparison to the markovian case as present in fig . [ fig : fig1 ] . this fact can be clearly seen through the decoherence rate , @xmath137 for a given memory time @xmath2 . the decoherence rate is @xmath138 if @xmath136 and it is reduced by increasing the memory time @xmath2 . $ ] , with respect to the evolving time @xmath8 . the decay function may be regarded as a fringe visibility for quantum interference as the time passes . it depends on the memory time @xmath2 for a given decoherence rate @xmath139 : a ) @xmath140 ( solid line ) , b ) @xmath141 ( dotted line ) , and c ) @xmath142 ( dashed line ) . the case a ) is already close to the markovian decoherence ( @xmath143),scaledwidth=45.0% ] similar analysis can be applied to depolarizing or amplitude - damping processes for a qubit . for this purpose , the interaction hamiltonian is assumed to be @xmath144 where @xmath127 is given by eq . ( [ eq : tdcc ] ) and @xmath145 is a real coupling matrix which determines the type of decoherence . the initial states of the system and the one - qubit effective environment are given by their bloch vectors @xmath146 and @xmath147 , similar to eqs . ( [ eq : idos ] ) and ( [ eq : idor ] ) . the coupling matrix @xmath145 and the initial state @xmath147 of the effective environment are summarized in table . [ tab : tab1 ] . it is interesting to look at the initial state of the effective environment for each process . the initial state is completely random with @xmath148 for the depolarizing process and it is polarized along @xmath129 axis for the amplitude - damping process . the reduce dynamics of the qubit is described in terms of the time dependence of its bloch vector @xmath149 . for the depolarizing process , the time - dependent bloch vector is given by @xmath150\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the amplitude damping process , it is given by @xmath151_{x } & = & s_{x } \exp[-4\gamma(\tau ) ] \nonumber \\ \left[{\mathbf s}_{amp}(\tau)\right]_{y } & = & s_{y } \exp[-4\gamma(\tau ) ] \nonumber \\ \left[{\mathbf s}_{amp}(\tau)\right]_{z } & = & r_z + ( s_z - r_z ) \exp[-8\gamma(\tau)].\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is well known that a system slowly decoheres in a non - markovian environment due to the memory effects . however , we stress that the result should be derived from the completely positive reduced dynamics and our analysis of the effective hamiltonian approach strongly supports the result . .the coupling matrix @xmath145 and the initial state @xmath147 of the effective environment for dephasing , depolarizing , and amplitude damping processes . [ cols="<,^,^ " , ] [ tab : tab1 ] the effective hamiltonian approach was proposed to investigate the non - markovian decoherence of an open system and further to understand the characteristics of its environment . the formalism is based on the notion of an effective environment , _ i.e. _ , certain collective degrees of freedom in the environment that are responsible for the decoherence . the present approach naturally imposes the complete positivity on the reduced dynamics for the system . we applied the approach to the dephasing , depolarizing , and amplitude - damping processes . it was found that the non - markovian environment suppresses the decoherence of the qubit , due to the memory effect of the non - markovian environment . this work was supported by the uk engineering and physical science research council and by the korean ministry of science and technology through the creative research initiatives program under contract no . m10116000008 - 03f0000 - 03610 . j.l . acknowledges the support from the kosef through quantum photonic science research center and the research fund by hanyang university ( hy-2003 ) . thanks department of education and learning for support . consider a set of bounded operators acting on the state vector in the hilbert space . the set of bounded operators forms a vector space @xmath152 with the inner product defined by hilbert - schmidt norm @xcite . the inner product of two bounded operators @xmath153 and @xmath154 in @xmath152 is given by @xmath155 in the analogy of the ket and bra states , @xmath156 is called a `` ket '' vector of an operator @xmath153 and @xmath157 a `` bra '' vector . the set of the bra vectors forms the dual vector space . let @xmath158 be an orthonormal basis for the vector space with the completeness relation , @xmath159 where @xmath160 is an identity superoperator , _ i.e. _ , a linear map of the ket vector ( or ket operator ) to itself . any ket vector @xmath156 is expanded as @xmath161 where @xmath162 . a superoperator @xmath163 is a linear map of @xmath152 onto itself @xmath164 the matrix elements of @xmath163 in the orthonormal basis @xmath165 is obtained as @xmath166 the superoperator @xmath163 is called `` hermitian '' when @xmath167 a superoperator @xmath163 is called `` positive '' when @xmath168 is real and positive for all @xmath169 . if @xmath163 is hermitian , it has the right eigenvector @xmath170 with the `` real '' eigenvalue @xmath171 such that @xmath172 and @xmath173 is the corresponding left eigenvector with the same eigenvalue . further , if and only if @xmath163 is positive , the eigenvalues are all positive . when @xmath163 is not hermitian , it may have complex eigenvalues and @xmath173 is no longer the corresponding left eigenvector . instead , there exists a left eigenvector @xmath174 such that @xmath175 where @xmath171 is a complex number . the right and left eigenvectors satisfy the orthogonality @xmath176 the completeness relation is given as the following @xmath177 and @xmath163 can be represented as @xmath178 _ definition _ : partial transposition , denoted by `` # '' , on a superoperator @xmath163 is defined as @xmath179 a superoperator @xmath163 is said to be hermitian - preserving when @xmath180 for any @xmath181 . the partial transposed superoperator @xmath182 is hermitian if and only if @xmath163 is hermitian - preserving . in addition , @xmath182 is closely related to the complete positivity of @xmath163 . _ proof _ : it is well known @xcite that ( a ) and ( b ) are equivalent . consider ( b ) @xmath184 ( c ) . when @xmath163 has a kraus representation , its matrix elements are given as @xmath185 the partial transposition @xmath182 becomes @xmath186 it is clear that for all @xmath169 @xmath187 where @xmath188 . thus @xmath182 is positive . the converse ( c ) @xmath184 ( b ) is now considered . since @xmath182 is positive , it is also hermitian and all the eigenvalues @xmath189 are positive : @xmath190 where @xmath191 are normalized eigenvectors . since @xmath189 is positive , we can define the following matrix @xmath192 thus the superoperator @xmath163 has a kraus representation as @xmath193 the set of kraus operators are not unique @xcite and all equivalent sets of kraus operators for the given superoperator can be generated by `` unitary remixing '' of the canonical set with the eigenvalue vector @xmath194 extended by some arbitrary number of zeros , _ i.e. _ @xmath195 @xcite .

we propose an effective hamiltonian approach to investigate decoherence of a quantum system in a non - markovian reservoir , naturally imposing the complete positivity on the reduced dynamics of the system . the formalism is based on the notion of an effective reservoir , _ i.e. _ , certain collective degrees of freedom in the reservoir that are responsible for the decoherence . as examples for completely positive decoherence , we present three typical decoherence processes for a qubit such as dephasing , depolarizing , and amplitude - damping . the effects of the non - markovian decoherence are compared to the markovian decoherence . = 10000

hep-ph0404272

the existence of extreme - energy cosmic rays ( eecr ) with energies above the greisen - zatsepin - kuzmin ( gzk ) cutoff @xcite of about @xmath2 ev , presents an outstanding problem @xcite . nucleons and photons with those energies have short attenuation lengths and could only come from distances of 100 mpc or less @xcite , while plausible astrophysical sources for those energetic particles are much farther away . data from the hires experiment @xcite brought the violation of the gzk cutoff into question . yet the ee events in even the hires data set remain unexplained since the local universe ( @xmath3 mpc ) is devoid of strong candidate sources . this controversy will be solved conclusively by the pierre auger hybrid observatory @xcite , perhaps as soon as summer of 2005 . here we assume that the published agasa spectrum is correct . interestingly , it is the absence of events above @xmath4 ev in these data , rather than the presence of events above @xmath5 ev , that motivates this work . among the solutions proposed for the origin of the highest energy events observed by agasa , an elegant and economical solution to this problem is the `` z - burst '' mechanism : annihilation at the @xmath6-resonance of extreme - energy neutrinos ( @xmath7 ) coming from remote sources , and relic background neutrinos within @xmath8 mpc of earth , produces the nucleon and photon eecrs @xcite . the observed eecrs from the z - bursts are the emission analogues of the absorption features ( z - dips ) predicted long ago @xcite . one of the most appealing features of the @xmath6-burst mechanism is that the energy scale of @xmath9 ev at which the unexpected events have been detected , is generated naturally . the @xmath6-resonance occurs when the energy of the incoming @xmath7 is @xmath10 where @xmath11 is any of the three masses of the relic neutrinos . given the lower limit @xmath12 ev deduced from atmospheric oscillations for the heaviest neutrino mass , at least one @xmath13 is below @xmath14 ev . since the individual energies of the nucleons and photons emerging from the z - burst can not exceed the total energy of the burst , @xmath13 is the new end - point of the eecr energy - spectrum in this mechanism . partitioning this burst energy among the @xmath15 final state particles , one arrives at precisely the primary energies needed to produce events observed above the gzk energy . combining their recent measurements of the anisotropies of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) radiation with data on the large scale structure of the universe , wmap @xcite produced a strong limit on neutrino masses , @xmath16 ev . since a single neutrino mass above @xmath12 ev implies near mass - degeneracy for all three active neutrinos ( given the mass - squared splittings from neutrino oscillation data , described below ) one has @xmath17 ev at the 95% cl . however , objections @xcite to the priors assumed , or to the data sets included , have led to a relaxed bound @xmath18 ev , or @xmath19 ev . a subsequent analysis @xcite which includes wmap , 2df , and sdss data , and another which includes these and galaxy cluster data @xcite , have arrived at the bound , @xmath20 ev . still another analysis @xcite with cmb and lss data finds @xmath21 ev , but finds @xmath22 ev when priors from supernova data and the hubble key project are included . these newer bounds are very similar to the original wmap bound . in this work we focus on a particular feature of the agasa spectrum , namely the end - point energy . requiring that the z - burst mechanism not overproduce events beyond this agasa end - point , we derive a lower bound on the neutrino mass . the significance of an end - point energy for constraining model fluxes has been noted much earlier in the context of topological defect decay @xcite . a more ambitious project would be to actually fit the neutrino mass to the full agasa spectrum . this has been done , by fodor , katz and ringwald ( fkr ) @xcite . however , the allowed range of the neutrino mass that results is not tight . rather , it depends sensitively on how one parameterizes the transition from non - burst spectrum to burst spectrum near and above the ankle . fkr find @xmath23 fitted mass ranges of 0.1 to 1.3 ev if all ee events are assumed to originate with z - bursts , 0.02 to 0.8 ev if an additional extra - galactic source of ee protons is allowed , and 1 to 7 ev if an additional galactic - halo source of ee protons is allowed . super - kamiokande has provided a strong evidence for the oscillation in atmospheric showers of two neutrino species with mass - squared splitting @xmath24 = @xmath25 = @xmath26 ev , consisting of nearly equal amounts of @xmath27 and @xmath28 , and little or no @xmath29 @xcite . if neutrino masses are hierarchical , like the other leptons and quarks , then @xmath30 the mass of the heavier of the two oscillating neutrinos ( call it @xmath31 ) . some previous works @xcite on z - burst production of the eecrs have made this assumption . however we will show in this work that @xmath32 ev is not compatible with the agasa end - point spectrum if z - bursts produce the eecr . the reason is that with @xmath33 ev , the new eecr cutoff @xmath34 ev predicts too many super gzk eecr events beyond the agasa end - point . as the relic neutrino mass increases , @xmath35 decreases , and the features in the ee spectrum move progressively to lower energies . in particular , the number of events predicted at high energy decreases , and the number beyond the agasa end - point becomes compatible with zero for @xmath36 ev . note that our result is much sharper than , but compatible with , the allowed mass ranges of the fkr models with no additional ee proton source , or with an additional extra - galactic source of ee protons . in the next section we present our simulations and the resulting spectrum of eecr in detail . we have performed simulations of the photon , nucleon and neutrino fluxes coming from a uniform distribution of z - bursts " , namely @xmath37 annihilations at the z pole ( @xmath38 ) . the burst energy is given in eq . 1 . our simulations cover the range @xmath39 ev for relic neutrino mass . the z - bursts were simulated using pythia 6.125 @xcite , and the absorption of photons and nucleons was modeled using energy - attenuation lengths provided by bhattacharjee and sigl @xcite , supplemented by radio - background models by protheroe and biermann @xcite . we simulated a uniform distribution of about @xmath40 z particles up to a maximum @xmath41 . if other z - burst spatial distributions are used , the main features of the spectrum of the ultra - high energy nucleons , photons and neutrinos remain the same as given below . the decay of the z bosons through all possible channels was done automatically by the pythia routines @xcite , using the default options of this program . for comparison with our later figures , we show in fig . 1 the spectra given by pythia , normalized per z boson , for @xmath42 ev ; redshifts and energy absorption are not included in pythia . the multiplicities that pythia gives per z - decay are 1.6 nucleons , 17 photons , 15 @xmath29 , 30 @xmath43 and 0.23 @xmath44 ( in each case counting particles and antiparticles ) . in our simulation , each z boson generated by pythia was placed on the `` event list '' of the cascade generator at a randomly selected distance . the cascade of decay products was then boosted . the @xmath45 factor corresponding to an energy @xmath46 in eq . ( 1 ) is @xmath47 we then followed the propagation of the nucleons , photons and neutrinos resulting from the boosted z - decays . the gamma factor of the secondary particles was corrected to include their red - shifting subsequent to the z - decay . each neutrino , nucleon or photon was created by pythia in the initial cascade at a fixed position , with fixed energy and direction of motion with respect to the earth frame of reference . the distance each particle had to travel before reaching earth was compared with the appropriate attenuation length in space for the particle energy . if the distance was smaller than the attenuation length , the particle was assumed to reach earth unchanged . in the opposite case , the energy and momentum of the particle were degraded by a factor @xmath48 after traveling a distance equal to the attenuation length ( and the particle was placed again in the list constituting the cascade at the new position , with the degraded energy and momentum ) . neutrinos do not interact in their propagation . thus , the energy spectra of the three kinds of neutrinos were simply generated by summing the number of particles over energy bins and normalizing to neutrino multiplicities per z times the total number of z particles used . on the other hand , nucleons and photons do suffer energy - absorption interactions , and here we included energy absorption . the propagation process for nucleons and photons was continued until particles reached earth and were counted in the final spectra , or until particle energies became too small to be significant . in the latter case , the particles were simply discarded from the cascade . at this point , the final nucleon and photon spectra were appropriately normalized to the total number of z - particles used , as was done with the neutrinos . the results are given in fig . 2 for @xmath49 , with a fit to the six most energetic occupied bins in the agasa data @xcite . these bins consist of 24 events spanning the energy range from @xmath50 ev to @xmath51 ev . the energy - attenuation of the nucleons and especially photons requires more discussion . for nucleon attenuation , uncertainties are small , and so the predicted gzk suppression is highly credible . for the nucleon energy attenuation , we used the length given by bhattacharjee and sigl in the fig . 9 of ref . , based on results from ref . @xcite and @xcite . however , for photon energy - attenuation , the length is quite uncertain , due to the uncertain spectrum of the absorbing radio background . the photon flux shown in fig . 2 as curve ( 1 ) results from using the attenuation length shown in fig . 11 of ref . @xcite , based on observations of clark et al . protheroe and biermann @xcite produced two models for the radio background which lead to shorter interaction lengths ( and therefore more absorption ) than those based on clark et al . from the interaction lengths they provided , we constructed approximate attenuation lengths for the models of protheroe and biermann . we did so by reducing the attenuation length based on clark et al . by the ratio of the respective interaction lengths , and obtained the curves ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) in fig . 2 . since mean interaction lengths and mean energy - attenuation lengths do not have exactly the same energy dependence , our construction is an approximation . however , we believe the three curves which we display give a good representation of the possible range of predicted photon fluxes . in this work , we seek a bound on the of events predicted . therefore , we adopt the lowest observable photon flux , curve number ( 3 ) , associated with the maximum photon absorption , when computing the total event number . this is the photon flux shown in fig . notice that with this choice , the photon flux does not become comparable to the nucleon flux until @xmath52 ev . we add to the z - burst proton and photon fluxes a power law spectrum with slope @xmath53 , terminated somewhat arbitrarily ( as it is not known where this component actually dies out ) at @xmath54 ev . such a power law was found by agasa to fit the data below the ankle , from @xmath55 to @xmath56 ev ( see table v of @xcite ) . in fig . 4 the observed and predicted integrated number of eecr event rates above @xmath57 ev are shown for different values of the relic neutrino mass . the z - burst fluxes have been normalized to reproduce the 24 highest - energy events observed by agasa @xcite in the energy range from @xmath50 ev to @xmath58 ev . these events are spread among the first six bins of fig . the area under each curve at the final bin shows the integrated number of events from @xmath59 ev to infinity predicted by that so - normalized z - burst flux . this number of excess events can also be read off from the value of the curve at @xmath60 ev less the 24 normalizing events . since agasa has observed no events above 2.5@xmath0 ev although their aperture remains constant with increasing energy @xcite , it is justified to call the events predicted beyond 2.5@xmath0 ev an excess ; we label the predicted number of excess events as @xmath61 . in table 1 the predicted event excess above @xmath59 ev is shown as a function of the neutrino mass . also shown is the poisson probability that a fluctuation downward from the predicted value gives zero events , as observed . this latter quantity is just @xmath62 . .poisson probabilities that no events are observed above the agasa end - point , given the excess predicted by the z - burst mechanism as a function of neutrino mass . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] the probabilities show that masses lighter than @xmath1 ev have a probability less than a percent . expressed as gaussian variances , one infers from the percentages in the table that @xmath63 ev is disfavored at @xmath64 while @xmath65 ev is disfavored at only @xmath66 . together with the cosmological limit on the neutrino mass discussed earlier , the value @xmath67 ev emerges as less than robust , but viable . we remark that our definition of `` excess '' as events above @xmath59 ev is somewhat conservative in that the two highest energy agasa events occur at @xmath52 ev ( @xmath68 experimental energy - resolution ) , nearer to the beginning of the highest - energy occupied bin than to its end . on the other hand , we have not considered in our analysis the very - highest energy event , at @xmath69 ev , from the fly s eye experiment . this is in the spirit of neglecting fluorescent data , e.g. hires , as we have chosen to focus in a self - consistent way on just the ground - scintillator data set from agasa . there are three immediate inferences to be drawn from the preferred neutrino mass value . the first is that since the energy of no secondary from the z - burst may exceed the burst energy , the model predicts a new cutoff for eecrs . with 0.3 ev relic neutrinos , the cutoff energy is @xmath70 ev . given the large mean - multiplicity in z - decay , @xmath71 , a more realistic cutoff in the model is @xmath72 ev . future experiments such as auger , anita , rice , euso , and salsa may be able to test this prediction . the second inference is that with @xmath67 ev , a significant clustering of relic neutrinos around very large galactic super - clusters is expected @xcite . this clustering could be evidenced as an enhancement of the eecr flux coming from the direction of m87 , just 16 mpc away , near the virgo center . and the third inference is that given the smallness of mass - squared differences inferred from neutrino oscillation experiments , @xmath67 ev implies near mass - degeneracy for the three active neutrinos . mass - degeneracy enhances the possibility of directly observing absorptive `` z - dips '' in the ee neutrino spectrum @xcite . we note that our analysis of the spectral shape of the agasa data does not depend on the issue of rate . in particular , it does not depend on the eecr neutrino flux and it does not depend on the value of the relic neutrino target density . the latter could , in principle , be enhanced by either gravitational clustering or by a lepton asymmetry . in practice , simulations argue against gravitational clustering for light ( @xmath73 ev ) neutrinos on all but the very largest super - galactic mass - scales @xcite ( which comprise a small solid angle of sky ) , and bbn physics argues against a lepton asymmetry enhancement above @xmath74% @xcite . ( strictly speaking , the bbn limit is strongest for @xmath29 s , but the large lepton mixing angles inferred from oscillation studies extend the limit equally to @xmath27 s and @xmath28 s . ) regardless of these kinds of rate arguments , our bound on the neutrino mass holds . farrar and piran @xcite have argued that any mechanism accounting for the events beyond the gzk cutoff should also account for the events down to the ankle , including the observed isotropy and spectral smoothness . it is seen in our fig . 2 that the z - burst mechanism can accommodate the position of the ankle and all the events above it , if the position of the ankle is close to that measured by agasa , at @xmath75 ev ( see @xcite , in particular table v , and references therein ) . fly s eye claims a value for @xmath76 ev , a factor of three smaller than the agasa value ( see table v of @xcite ) . this value is difficult to accommodate with the z - burst mechanism , although one could perhaps gain agreement by increasing @xmath77 of the astrophysical neutrino sources . this would allow for more red - shifting of the nucleons , thereby lowering the soft end of the z - burst spectrum . a higher @xmath77 may be expected , for example , if the source is decaying massive particles or topological defects . the fit of the agasa data with our total flux provides the normalization of the photon and nucleon differential fluxes @xmath78 , denoted as @xmath79 in figs . 2 and 3 ( in this case @xmath80 = @xmath81 @xmath82 ) . this allows us to determine the ( assumed homogeneous and isotropic ) flux of extreme - energy neutrinos close to the @xmath6-resonance energy ( more precisely , within the energy interval from @xmath83 to @xmath13 ) to be @xmath84 this flux is shown in figs . 2 and 3 , with the label @xmath7 " . within the level of accuracy of our simulation , we only determine the order of magnitude of this flux . nevertheless , the flux requirement is formidable . this very - high energy flux is at present marginally ruled - out by present glue @xcite and forte @xcite bounds , as can be seen in figs . 2 and 3 ( see also @xcite ) the large required flux in the z - burst hypothesis is also a challenge to theory . it appears that new physics is required to produce such a large neutrino flux at such extreme energy @xcite . in this work , we have not included any effects of extragalactic magnetic fields . for the analysis of this paper to hold as is , these fields should be sufficiently small , @xmath85 . a way to weaken the bound derived here would be to assume the existence of large enough extragalactic magnetic fields , say @xmath86 or larger , so that through electron pair - production and subsequent synchrotron radiation , photons would be eliminated as eecr primaries . this would reduce the event count above the agasa end - point , and so allow a smaller neutrino mass . however in this case the flux of ee neutrinos at the z - resonance energy , @xmath87 , required to produce the observed eecr s would be larger . moreover , the resonant energy , @xmath35 , would be larger . both the increased flux and the increased energy bring this possibility into conflict with the glue and forte bounds , on ee neutrino fluxes , shown in figs . 2 and 3 . specifically , we find that without the photon contribution to the z - burst flux , we would require @xmath88 at @xmath89 for @xmath90 ev , or @xmath91 at @xmath92 for @xmath93 ev . such possibilities are rejected by the glue and forte bounds . another prediction of the z - burst mechanism is the enhancement of the event rate at the gzk cutoff energy , @xmath94 ev , due to the accumulation of nucleons after energy - attenuation . such an enhancement ( or `` gzk bump '' ) is expected from any model which provides a nucleon spectrum flatter than @xmath95 above @xmath96 ( spectra falling faster than @xmath95 do not provide sufficient flux above @xmath96 to make an observable pile - up . ) . a hint for such a bump is seen in the agasa data , fig . 2 and 3 . however , one must be careful in interpreting the shape as an enhancement . an alternative explanation of the shape feature has been provided in @xcite , namely that another energy - loss mechanism , @xmath97 , depletes the flux at energies just below @xmath96 . finally , a reliable prediction of the model is that most primaries above the ankle should be nucleons up to @xmath98 ev or more , and photons and protons at higher energies . a much larger event sample is needed to test this prediction . the non - observation of cosmic ray events at energies higher than @xmath99 ev by agasa provides a lower bound of about 0.3 ev on relic neutrino masses , if z - bursts are responsible for the eecrs . this bound together with comparisons of the microwave background anisotropy to today s large - scale structure , leave a small interval for the relic neutrino mass , centered around 0.3 ev , if z - bursts explain the eecrs . the @xmath1 ev mass provides a very accessible signal for neutrinoless double beta - decay experiments ( assuming neutrinos are majorana particles ) , and is in fact compatible with a reported positive signal @xcite . this @xmath1 ev mass interval may also be probed by the future katrin tritium end - point experiment @xcite , and by expected improvements to the astrophysical bound from weak lensing of distant galaxies by intervening matter distributions @xcite , and from mining future planck measurements of the cmb @xcite . we note that our small allowed range for @xmath11 is incompatible with an upper bound of 0.15 ev that arises from invoking the see - saw mass spectrum as a source of successful early - universe baryogenesis @xcite . we have not included in this work any possible effects of extragalactic magnetic fields . for the analysis of this paper to hold as is , these fields should be sufficiently small , @xmath100 . a survey of the literature shows that extragalactic fields much larger than @xmath101 are not expected , except in regions around galaxy clusters . in any event , large extragalactic magnetic fields which would reduce or eliminate the ee photon component of the z - bursts ( thus lowering the neutrino mass we obtain ) would also lead to larger required ee neutrino fluxes at the z - resonance energy this possibility is rejected by the glue and forte bound . we have shown that @xmath6-bursts may account not only for the super gzk events , but for the ankle " and all eecr events above it . in doing so , the @xmath6-burst mechanism meets the naturalness " requirements of isotropy and spectral smoothness . in our simulation we found the ankle " close to @xmath102 ev as measured by agasa . we found that most eecr primaries above the ankle should be nucleons up to about @xmath98 ev and nucleons and photons at higher energies . we also found that primary nucleons do accumulate at the gzk cutoff energy , which could account for the slight accumulation seen in the data ( see , however , @xcite ) . with @xmath67 ev needed to accommodate the agasa end - point , the z - burst hypothesis predicts a new absolute energy cutoff for eecrs , at @xmath103 . however , due to the large multiplicity in z - decay , the vast majority of incident primaries are expected to carry only a few percent of this cutoff energy . in summary , we believe that the @xmath6-burst mechanism provides a plausible explanation to the puzzle of extreme - energy cosmic rays , not only for the super gzk events , but for the `` ankle '' and all events above it . but the hypothesis will stand or fall on the required nearness of @xmath11 to 0.3 ev , and/or on the proximity of the required neutrino flux at @xmath104 ev to existing flux limits . if z - bursts are invalidated as the source of the observed eecrs , then we would encourage future , larger experiments ( e.g. , auger , euso ) to continue the search for z - burst signatures , for they provide the only known window to discovery of the relic neutrino background . the z - burst mechanism is entirely standard model particle physics coupled with standard hot big - bang cosmology . consequently , the mechanism itself can not be ruled out . however , the z - burst rate depends linearly on the resonant - energy neutrino flux which nature provides . nature may not be generous . this work was supported in part by nasa grant nag5 - 13399 , the us department of energy grants de - fg03 - 91er40662 , task c , and de - fg05 - 85er40226 , and vanderbilt university s discovery grant and sabbatical programs . was also supported by an award from the research corporation . we thank a. kusenko , s. nussinov and d. semikoz for many valuable discussions , p. biermann and e. roulet for comments and suggestions , and the aspen center for physics for a supportive environment during part of this work . m. takeda _ et al . lett . * 81 * , 1163 ( 1998 ) ; m.a . lawrence , r.j . reid and a.a . watson , j. phys . g * g17 * , 733 ( 1991 ) ; d. j. bird _ lett . * 71 * , 3401 ( 1993 ) ; astrophys . j. * 424 * , 491 ( 1994 ) . t. j. weiler , phys . * 49 * , 234 ( 1982 ) ; ibid , astrophys . j. * 285 * , 495 ( 1984 ) ; e. roulet , phys . rev . * d47 * , 5247 ( 1993 ) ; updated recently in b. eberle , a. ringwald , l. song , and t. j. weiler , hep - ph/0401203 , and phys . rev . * d * , to appear . m. takeda _ et al . , _ astropart . * 19 * , 447 ( 2003 ) ; interesting discussions of apertures , agasa and otherwise , can be found in l. anchordoqui , j. feng , h. goldberg , and a. shapere , phys . rev . * d65 * , 124027 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0112247 ] ; ibid . , phys . rev . * d66 * , 103002 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0207139 ] . a. dolgov , s. hansen , s. pastor , s. petcov , g. raffelt , and d. semikoz , nucl . b632 ( 2002 ) 363 ; k. abazajian , j. beacom , and n. bell , phys . d66 ( 2002 ) 013008 ; y. y. wong , phys . d66 , 025015 ( 2002 ) ; v. barger , j. kneller , p. langacker , d. marfatia , g. steigman , phys . b569 ( 2003 ) 123 . o. kalashev , v. kuzmin , d. semikoz , and g. sigl , phys . rev . d * 65 * , 103003 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0112351 ] and phys . d * d66 * , 063004 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0205050 ] ; d. gorbunov , p. tinyakov , and s. troitsky , astropart . phys . 18 ( 2003 ) 463 ; v. berezinsky , hep - ph/0303091 ; v. berezinsky , m. narayan , and f. vissani , nucl . * b658 * , 254 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0210204 ] . w. buchmuller , p. di bari , and m. plmacher , phys . * b547 * , 128 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0209301 ] ; ibid . * b665 * , 445 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0302092 ] ; ibid . , hep - ph/0401240 ; g.f . giudice , a. notari , m. raidal , a. riotto , a. strumia , nucl . * b685 * , 89 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ph/0310123 ] .

neutrinos from far - away sources annihilating at the z resonance on relic neutrinos may give origin to the extreme - energy cosmic rays ( eecr ) . if `` z - bursts '' are responsible for the eecr events , then we show that the non - observation of cosmic ray events at energies above 2 @xmath0 ev by the agasa collaboration implies a lower bound @xmath1 ev on the relic neutrino mass . since this mass exceeds the mass - squared differences inferred from oscillation physics , the bound in fact applies to all three neutrino masses . together with the upper bound provided by comparisons of the cmb anisotropy with large - scale structure , this bound leaves only a small interval for neutrino masses around 0.3 ev , if z - bursts are to explain the existing eecr events .

1207.0046

quantum computation requires the mitigation of errors that occur due to faulty controls and unwanted interactions with the environment @xcite . fault - tolerant quantum error correction is one method for mitigating these errors with the advantage that provable arbitrary quantum computation is possible given constraints on the error rates and the error locality @xcite . there are many possible error correcting codes @xcite and the mapping of abstract models involving qubits on a completely connected graph to a more realistic local architecture leads to a number of choices that makes analytical comparison of codes difficult . in these systems it is typical to use simulation to determine the error correcting properties @xcite . although simulation of quantum systems is difficult @xcite , simulation of error correction can be done efficiently for stabilizer codes where the process of error correction only includes gates in the clifford group @xcite . a standard error model is a depolarizing channel where a pauli operator from a chosen probability distribution is applied at every possible error position @xcite . the depolarizing channel efficiently simulates common laboratory processes such as dephasing . it also serves as a good approximation for most error process that lead to a steady - state in which the system becomes maximally mixed . these are unital channels that map completely mixed states to completely mixed states . in nature it is also common to encounter interactions with the environment that lead to non - unital error channels in which the maximally mixed states are not a fixed point of the error process . one example is amplitude damping where , given enough time , all density matrices map to a single pure state . if an error channel is far from unital , then simulating it with pauli errors gives large approximation errors making it hard to extract useful results . in this paper , we go beyond simulating errors with the conventional pauli depolarizing channel ( pc ) . instead of only restricting to pauli errors , we allow any subset of efficiently simulable gate errors to occur . in particular , we look at subsets generated by including all clifford group operators and/or pauli measurements to the pc channel . we show that adding clifford errors and/or measurement errors always results in more accurate approximations and results in significant improvements for most error channels . we consider an approximating error channel to be valid if it has a smaller fidelity than the target error channel and choose the best valid approximation by minimizing the hilbert - schmidt metric . the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : realchannels ] we first describe the simulable error processes and introduce our expansions to the pc . we then mention two important error channels that can not be simulated in the stabilizer formalism and finally we describe our method for approximating a general error channel with our new models . in section [ sec : results ] we compare how well these models approximate the two error channels mentioned in section [ sec : realchannels ] and also a collection of random error channels . in section [ sec : conclusions ] , we conclude and describe future research directions . throughout the paper we use @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 to represent the pauli matrices with associated eigenvectors @xmath3 , @xmath4 , and @xmath5 respectively . it is convenient to consider the interaction of the environment with the system for a fixed time . then the system dynamics can be represented by a set of time - independent kraus operators that form an error channel . we begin by considering all error channels that can be simulated efficiently within the stabilizer formalism . next we examine two specific error channels that are outside of the stabilizer formalism . finally , we discuss a method by which we create an error channel that approximates a target channel . the stabilizer formalism allows for efficient simulation on a classical computer of operators from the clifford group operating on states stabilized by pauli operators @xcite . the clifford group for @xmath6-qubits can be generated from cnots and the 1-qubit clifford gates . as error channels , the probabilistic application of 1-qubit clifford operators can be represented by the following kraus operators : @xmath7 identity + @xmath8 pauli operators + @xmath9 = @xmath10 s - like operators + @xmath11 hadamard - like operators + @xmath12 for @xmath13 rotations about the face centers + @xmath14 , where @xmath15 and @xmath16 is the unit vector from the origin to one of the eight faces of the 1-qubit clifford octahedron @xcite . the stabilizer formalism also includes non - unital operators . the simplest are measurement operations in the pauli basis . more intricate non - unital kraus operations can be represented as measurements followed by gates conditioned on the measurement outcomes . we limit ourselves to non - unital operators that result in translations along the pauli axes . for each eigenstate , @xmath17 , of a pauli operator , we define the following two kraus operators with the same classical probability : @xmath7 measurement - induced translations + @xmath18 notice that the effect of these two operators is to discard the state with a probability of @xmath19 and replace it by @xmath20 . the effect on a state , when represented on the bloch sphere , is to translate it toward @xmath20 . to ensure trace preservation , we set @xmath21 where @xmath22 sums over all other operators . throughout the paper we will refer to four sets of these error process : pc , cc , pmc , and cmc . the pauli channel ( pc ) , introduced above , is limited to pauli errors . the clifford channel ( cc ) includes all efficiently simulable unitary gates . the pauli and measurement channel ( pmc ) includes all pauli errors and all measurement - induced translation errors . finally , the clifford and measurement channel ( cmc ) includes all clifford errors and all measurement - induced translation errors . we use these as approximation channels to the error channels presented below . .kraus operators corresponding to the 4 efficiently simulable error channels . [ cols="^ , < " , ] [ table : summary ] figure [ fig : rand ] illustrates the distance between each random error channel and the best approximation as a function of the distance between the error channel and the identity channel . the fidelity constraint guarantees that the approximation will always be more distant from the identity than the error is . notice that as the amount of operators in the error models increases , both the mean and the median distance between each model and the random error decreases and the distributions become more compact , as summarized in table [ table : summary ] . although the approximations with the cc had a smaller mean distance and a more compact distribution than the ones with the pmc , it is not clear that this difference is significant . the most important improvement occurs when we add both the unital clifford gates and the non - unital measurement - induced translations . for the cmc , for 48@xmath23 of the generated random process matrices the distance of the best approximation was less than 0.001 , while for the other error channels the fraction of approximations with a distance in this interval was not greater than 6@xmath23 . we have presented an extension to the random pauli error model which is still compatible with efficient simulation using the gottesman - knill theorem and leads to a computationally tractable description of realistic error models like amplitude damping . for ease of calculation , we have used the average distance as the measure to be optimized under two different fidelity constraints of the error channels relative to an error free channel . we have also only focused on single qubit errors in the absence of quantum operations . once we consider simulating operations over many qubits , we will need a distance measure that is composable over tensors . a more natural distance measure in this regard is the diamond norm @xcite . our method can be extended to multi - qubit channels but the optimization becomes more difficult as the number of clifford operators grows quickly with @xmath6 . in many cases , symmetries of the underlying error channels will minimize the number of clifford operators that must be considered . in future work , we will compare for a specific error correction circuit how the logical error rate compares for the models . we expect in the case of multiple rounds of error correction a substantial difference between error models with distinct fixed points . the authors thank aram harrow for valuable comments . av and krb acknowledge support from the national science foundation through the quantum information for quantum chemistry center for chemical innovation ( che-1037992 ) . mg , ls , and krb were also supported by the office of the director of national intelligence - intelligence advanced research projects activity through army research office contract w911nf-10 - 1 - 0231 and department of interior contract d11pc20167 . disclaimer : the views and conclusions contained herein are those of the authors and should not be interpreted as necessarily representing the official policies or endorsements , either expressed or implied , of iarpa , doi / nbc , or the u.s .

the gottesman - knill theorem allows for the efficient simulation of stabilizer - based quantum error - correction circuits . errors in these circuits are commonly modeled as depolarizing channels by using monte carlo methods to insert pauli gates randomly throughout the circuit . although convenient , these channels are poor approximations of common , realistic channels like amplitude damping . here we analyze a larger set of efficiently simulable error channels by allowing the random insertion of any one - qubit gate or measurement that can be efficiently simulated within the stabilizer formalism . our new error channels are shown to be a viable method for accurately approximating real error channels .