Correct the card for the sighted-judge rerun and withdraw the ablation figure

#4
The Fertility Plan org Hugging Face CLI

The evaluation behind this card was rerun with the judge shown the same embryo
image the model was shown. Every score changes, and two claims on the live card
are no longer supported.

What changed

  • All scores are regenerated under the sighted judge. Morphology grounding falls
    for every system (this model 3.56 to 3.14), because the blind judge had been
    accepting descriptions it could not check against the image.
  • The card said "the judge never sees the embryo image". That is no longer true
    and the sentence is removed.
  • The card put the image's contribution at 0.07 to 0.23 points. That figure came
    from the blind judge and is withdrawn; the experiment it came from cannot
    support a quantitative claim in either direction.
  • Second place is now reported as conditional. A cross-judge pass with Claude
    Sonnet 4.6 over the same 824 held-out judgements puts this model fifth and Opus
    4.6 second, reversing the margin from +0.15 to -0.49. Each judge is most
    generous to its own model family.
  • The gain over the base model, which is the claim that survives both judges, is
    stated as +24.6% under GPT-5.4 and +15.5% under Sonnet 4.6.
  • Two conditions that were not equal across systems are now disclosed: the
    generation budget, and the decoding and serving stack differing between this
    model and the base it is compared against.

Numbers match the released artifacts; the repository's verification suite checks
177 of them.

andrewmonostate changed pull request status to merged

Sign up or log in to comment