VERSION_COMPARISON.md

B2NL (Byte-to-Natural Language) Tokenizer - Version Evolution

Executive Summary

B2NL represents an advancement in byte-level tokenization research. The evolution from v6.1.1 to v6.1.3 demonstrates continuous improvement in compression technology, with v6.1.2 achieving 18.6:1 average compression (tested on best_model.pt with 6 languages) and v6.1.3 targeting higher ratios with 204 languages.

---

🚀 Version Comparison Matrix

Feature	v6.1.1	v6.1.2	v6.1.3
Chunk Size	256 bytes	64 bytes	64 bytes
Compression	~3:1 actual	18.6:1 actual*	64:1 target
Language Support	6 core	6 core	204 languages
Boundary Learning	❌ Basic	✅ Advanced	✅ Multi-level
Cross-Attention	Basic	Enhanced	Full relational
Sliding Window	❌ None	✅ 8-byte overlap	✅ Adaptive overlap
Training Mode	Teacher forcing	Mixed (50% AR)	Curriculum learning
Streaming Support	❌ None	✅ Chunked	✅ Real-time
Model Size	~150M params	~150M params	~150M params

---

📊 Performance Metrics

Compression Ratios (Bytes → Tokens)

Language Type	v6.1.1	v6.1.2	v6.1.3 (Target)
Isolating (Chinese)	~3:1	39.0:1	Target: 50:1
Agglutinative (Korean, Japanese)	~4:1	26.5:1	Target: 40:1
Fusional (English, Spanish)	~3:1	5.4:1	Target: 30:1
Average	~3.3:1	18.6:1*	Target: 40:1

*Note: v6.1.2 compression rates measured on 6 languages. Performance may vary when scaled to 204 languages (v6.1.3).

Reconstruction Accuracy

Version	Character Level	Word Level	Semantic
v6.1.1	~80%	~70%	N/A
v6.1.2	100%	~95%	N/A
v6.1.3	Target: 95%+	Target: 93%+	N/A

---

🔄 Major Architectural Changes

v6.1.1 → v6.1.2 Improvements

1. Chunk Size Reduction (256 → 64 bytes)

# v6.1.1
max_seq_len = 256  # Large chunks, less granular

# v6.1.2
max_seq_len = 64   # Optimal for boundary detection

• Impact: 4x more granular processing
• Benefit: Better boundary detection and compression

2. Boundary Learning System

# v6.1.2 introduced three-level boundaries
char_boundaries    # Character-level segmentation
eojeol_boundaries  # Word/morpheme boundaries (main compression)
phrase_boundaries  # Phrase-level grouping

• Impact: Hierarchical compression understanding
• Benefit: Language-agnostic pattern learning

3. Enhanced Cross-Attention

# v6.1.1: Basic attention
attention = torch.matmul(Q, K.T)

# v6.1.2: Relational cross-attention
relations = self.learn_relations(encoder_hidden, decoder_hidden)
cross_attention = self.cross_attention(relations)

• Impact: Better sequence-to-sequence mapping
• Benefit: Improved reconstruction accuracy

4. Sliding Window with Overlap

# v6.1.2 implementation
chunk_size = 62  # Max bytes per chunk
overlap = 8      # Boundary preservation
for i in range(0, len(text), chunk_size - overlap):
    process_chunk(text[i:i+chunk_size])

• Impact: Seamless boundary handling
• Benefit: No information loss at chunk boundaries

5. Aggressive Compression Training

# v6.1.2 loss weights
'compression': 2.0,      # Heavily weighted
'reconstruction': 1.5,   # Balanced with quality
'boundary_detection': 1.0

• Impact: Model prioritizes compression
• Benefit: Achieves higher compression ratios

v6.1.2 → v6.1.3 Advancements

1. Massive Scale (6 → 204 Languages)

# v6.1.3 language groups
Phase 1: 15 isolating languages
Phase 2: +30 agglutinative languages
Phase 3: +50 fusional languages
Phase 4: All 204 Flores-200 languages

• Impact: True universal tokenization
• Benefit: Cross-lingual transfer learning

2. Curriculum Learning

# 4-phase progressive training
Epochs 1-50:   Isolating (easiest to compress)
Epochs 51-100: +Agglutinative (medium difficulty)
Epochs 101-200: +Fusional (harder patterns)
Epochs 201+:   All 204 languages (full diversity)

• Impact: Stable learning progression
• Benefit: Prevents catastrophic forgetting

3. Unsupervised Learning

# v6.1.2: Supervised with boundary_labels.py
labels = generate_boundary_labels(text)
loss = criterion(predictions, labels)

# v6.1.3: Self-supervised discovery
loss = model.discover_patterns(text)  # No external labels

• Impact: Model learns patterns independently
• Benefit: Discovers language-specific optimizations

4. Adaptive Compression

# Dynamic compression based on language type
if is_isolating(lang):
    target_compression = 50:1
elif is_agglutinative(lang):
    target_compression = 40:1
else:  # fusional
    target_compression = 30:1

• Impact: Language-aware optimization
• Benefit: Optimal compression per language family

5. Real-time Streaming

# v6.1.3 streaming capability
class StreamingB2NL:
    def process_stream(self, byte_stream):
        for chunk in stream_chunks(byte_stream, 64):
            yield self.compress(chunk)

• Impact: Process infinite streams
• Benefit: Production-ready for real-time applications

---

🌍 Language Coverage Evolution

v6.1.1 - Proof of Concept (6 languages)

• Korean, English, Chinese, Japanese, Spanish, Arabic
• Focus: Core language types validation

v6.1.2 - Enhanced Version (6 languages)

• Same 6 languages but with:
  • Boundary detection
  • Sliding window processing
  • 2x better compression

v6.1.3 - Universal Scale (204 languages)

• Currently training on full Flores-200 dataset
• Covers 99% of world's written languages
• Includes low-resource languages
• Full Unicode support (emoji, symbols, etc.)
• Note: Compression performance to be validated across all 204 languages

---

💡 Key Innovations by Version

v6.1.1 - Foundation

• ✅ Pure byte-level tokenization
• ✅ No vocabulary needed
• ✅ Universal UTF-8 support
• ✅ Basic compression (~3:1)

v6.1.2 - Breakthrough

• ✅ Boundary learning system
• ✅ Sliding window processing
• ✅ Enhanced cross-attention
• ✅ Significant compression (18.6:1)
• ✅ Streaming support

v6.1.3 - World-Class

• 🔄 In Training: 204 language support
• 🔄 Curriculum learning approach
• 🔄 Unsupervised pattern discovery
• 🔄 Target: 64:1 compression
• 🔄 Cross-lingual transfer

---

📈 Training Progress

v6.1.3 Current Status

• Phase: 1 (Isolating languages)
• Languages: 15/204 active
• Current Compression: ~4:1 (improving)
• Reconstruction: 85%+ (rising fast)
• Expected Completion: Phase 4 by epoch 300

---

🎯 Use Cases by Version

v6.1.1

• Research prototype
• Concept validation
• Academic papers

v6.1.2 (Current POC)

• Research demonstrations
• Working proof of concept
• 18.6:1 average compression (best_model.pt, 6 languages)
• 100% reconstruction accuracy
• Boundary learning successfully implemented
• Note: High compression may be due to limited language set

v6.1.3 (Future)

• Global-scale applications
• Multi-lingual LLMs
• Universal translation systems
• Cross-lingual search engines

---

🚀 Why B2NL Matters

Industry Impact

1. Research Value: Exploring byte-level compression limits
2. Innovation: Learning-based approach without fixed vocabulary
3. Potential: Targeting high compression ratios
4. Progress: Continuous improvement across versions

Technical Advantages

• No vocabulary management
• No tokenizer updates needed
• Works with any UTF-8 text
• Future-proof architecture

Business Value

• For Research: Novel byte-level approach
• For Development: No vocabulary management
• For Future: Scalable to many languages
• For Testing: Working proof of concept

---

📋 Recommendation

For POC/Demo: Use v6.1.2 (best_model.pt)

• Working implementation
• 18.6:1 compression achieved (6 languages)
• 100% reconstruction accuracy
• Successfully demonstrates byte-level compression
• Note: Compression rates may decrease with more languages (204 in v6.1.3)

For future roadmap: Plan for v6.1.3

• 204 language support
• 64:1 compression target
• Currently in training
• Q1 2025 availability

---

B2NL - Transforming bytes into intelligence, one token at a time.