# Copyright 2022 DeepMind Technologies Limited. All Rights Reserved. # # Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License"); # you may not use this file except in compliance with the License. # You may obtain a copy of the License at # # http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0 # # Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software # distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS, # WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied. # See the License for the specific language governing permissions and # limitations under the License. # ============================================================================== """RASP program objects. Every object in the RASP language is a function. The most important type is S-Op, which is a function List[Value] -> List[Value]. An S-Op represents a state inside the residual stream of the transformer. Therefore, any RASP program that represents a transformer computation must define a final S-Op that represents the state of the residual stream at the end of the computation. In particular, given an S-Op `x`, `x([1, 2, 3])` represents something like the state of the residual stream at location `x` when the transformer is fed [1, 2, 3] as input. A secondary (but still important) type is Selector, which is a function List[Value] -> List[List[bool]]. Given a Selector `sel`, sel([1, 2, 3]) represents something like an attention matrix in the transformer. For a full reference on RASP, see https://arxiv.org/abs/2106.06981. """ import pdb import abc import collections.abc import copy import enum import functools import itertools from typing import (Any, Callable, Dict, Generic, List, Mapping, Optional, Sequence, TypeVar, Union) from typing_extensions import Protocol from absl import logging import numpy as np SelectorValue = List[List[bool]] NumericValue = Union[int, float] Value = Union[None, int, float, str, bool] VT = TypeVar("VT", bound=Value) RASPExprT = TypeVar("RASPExprT", bound="RASPExpr") SOpT = TypeVar("SOpT", bound="SOp") T = TypeVar("T") _NAME_KEY = "name" _ENCODING_KEY = "encoding" # These are run on every expression when it's initialised. # Add your own annotators to this dict to add custom default annotations. # # For example, DEFAULT_ANNOTATORS['foo'] will provide the default value for # expr.annotations['foo]. The annotator will get called lazily the first time # that key is accessed. # # See the `default_name` annotator for a full example. DEFAULT_ANNOTATORS: Dict[str, "Annotator"] = {} class Annotator(Protocol): def __call__(self, expr: "RASPExpr") -> Any: """What annotation to add to `expr`.""" class _Annotations(collections.abc.Mapping): """Holds the expression's annotations. It's immutable to the user, but will attempt to generate default values lazily when missing keys are requested. """ def __init__(self, expr, **kwargs: Any): self._expr = expr self._inner_dict: Dict[str, Any] = {**kwargs} def __getitem__(self, key: str) -> Any: if key not in self._inner_dict: if key not in DEFAULT_ANNOTATORS: raise KeyError( f"No annotation exists for key '{key}'. " f"Available keys: {list(*self.keys(), *DEFAULT_ANNOTATORS.keys())}") self._inner_dict[key] = DEFAULT_ANNOTATORS[key](self._expr) return self._inner_dict[key] def __iter__(self): return iter(self._inner_dict) def __len__(self): return len(self._inner_dict) class RASPExpr(abc.ABC): """A class distinguishing RASP expressions from other objects.""" _ids = itertools.count(1) def __init__(self): self._annotations: Mapping[str, Any] = _Annotations(self) @abc.abstractmethod def __call__(self, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Union[Sequence[Value], SelectorValue]: """Evaluates the RASPExpr using the standard evaluator.""" @property def annotations(self) -> Mapping[str, Any]: """The annotations of this expression instance.""" return self._annotations @annotations.setter def annotations(self, annotations: Mapping[str, Any]): self._annotations = _Annotations(self, **annotations) @property def name(self) -> str: """The name of this expression.""" return self.annotations[_NAME_KEY] @property @abc.abstractmethod def children(self) -> Sequence["RASPExpr"]: """Direct dependencies of this expression.""" @functools.cached_property def unique_id(self): """A unique id for every expression instance.""" return next(self._ids) def copy(self: RASPExprT) -> RASPExprT: """Returns a shallow copy of this RASPExpr with a new ID.""" return copy.copy(self) @property def label(self) -> str: return f"{self.name}_{self.unique_id}" def named(self: RASPExprT, name: str) -> RASPExprT: """Convenience method for adding a name.""" return annotate(self, name=name) def annotated(self: RASPExprT, **annotations) -> RASPExprT: """Convenience method for adding annotations.""" return annotate(self, **annotations) def annotate(expr: RASPExprT, **annotations) -> RASPExprT: """Creates a new expr with added annotations.""" new = expr.copy() # Note that new annotations will overwrite existing ones with matching keys. new.annotations = {**expr.annotations, **annotations} return new ### S-Ops. class SOp(RASPExpr): """A Sequence Operation.""" def __call__(self, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Sequence[Value]: return evaluate(self, xs) # pytype: disable=bad-return-type # Allow construction of SOps using numeric operators with constant values. # Note: if inheriting SOp by a dataclass, make sure to disable eq and order, # as they will override these. def __lt__(self, other: Value) -> "SOp": """self < other.""" return Map(lambda x: x < other, self) def __le__(self, other: Value) -> "SOp": """self <= other.""" return Map(lambda x: x <= other, self) def __eq__(self, other: Value) -> "SOp": """self == other.""" return Map(lambda x: x == other, self) def __ne__(self, other: Value) -> "SOp": """self != other.""" return Map(lambda x: x != other, self) def __gt__(self, other: Value) -> "SOp": """self > other.""" return Map(lambda x: x > other, self) def __ge__(self, other: Value) -> "SOp": """self >= other.""" return Map(lambda x: x >= other, self) def __add__(self, other: Union["SOp", Value]) -> "SOp": """self + other.""" if isinstance(other, SOp): return SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x + y, self, other) return Map(lambda x: x + other, self) def __radd__(self, other: Union["SOp", Value]) -> "SOp": """other + self.""" if isinstance(other, SOp): return SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x + y, other, self) return Map(lambda x: other + x, self) def __sub__(self, other: Union["SOp", NumericValue]) -> "SOp": """self - other.""" if isinstance(other, SOp): return SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x - y, self, other) return Map(lambda x: x - other, self) def __rsub__(self, other: Union["SOp", NumericValue]) -> "SOp": """other - self.""" if isinstance(other, SOp): return SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x - y, other, self) return Map(lambda x: other - x, self) def __mul__(self, other: Union["SOp", NumericValue]) -> "SOp": """self * other.""" if isinstance(other, SOp): return SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x * y, self, other) return Map(lambda x: x * other, self) def __rmul__(self, other: Union["SOp", NumericValue]) -> "SOp": """other * self.""" if isinstance(other, SOp): return SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x * y, other, self) return Map(lambda x: other * x, self) def __truediv__(self, other: Union["SOp", NumericValue]) -> "SOp": """self / other.""" if isinstance(other, SOp): return SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x / y, self, other) return Map(lambda x: x / other, self) def __rtruediv__(self, other: Union["SOp", NumericValue]) -> "SOp": """other / self.""" if isinstance(other, SOp): return SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x / y, other, self) return Map(lambda x: other / x, self) def __invert__(self) -> "SOp": return Map(lambda x: not x, self) def __and__(self, other: Union["SOp", NumericValue]) -> "SOp": """self & other.""" if isinstance(other, SOp): return SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x and y, self, other) return Map(lambda x: x and other, self) def __or__(self, other: Union["SOp", NumericValue]) -> "SOp": """self | other.""" if isinstance(other, SOp): return SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x or y, self, other) return Map(lambda x: x or other, self) def __rand__(self, other: Union["SOp", NumericValue]) -> "SOp": """other & self.""" if isinstance(other, SOp): return SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x and y, other, self) return Map(lambda x: other and x, self) def __ror__(self, other: Union["SOp", NumericValue]) -> "SOp": """other | self.""" if isinstance(other, SOp): return SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x or y, other, self) return Map(lambda x: x or other, self) class TokensType(SOp): """Primitive SOp returning the original input tokens.""" @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [] @property def label(self) -> str: return "tokens" def __repr__(self): return "tokens" class IndicesType(SOp): """Primitive SOp returning the position index at each token.""" @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [] @property def label(self) -> str: return "indices" def __repr__(self): return "indices" class LengthType(SOp): """Primitive SOp returning the total length of the input.""" @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [] @property def label(self) -> str: return "length" def __repr__(self): return "length" tokens = TokensType() indices = IndicesType() length = LengthType() class Map(SOp): """SOp that evaluates the function elementwise on the input SOp. Map(lambda x: x + 1, tokens).eval([1, 2, 3]) == [2, 3, 4] """ def __init__(self, f: Callable[[Value], Value], inner: SOp): super().__init__() self.f = f self.inner = inner assert isinstance(self.inner, SOp) assert callable(self.f) and not isinstance(self.f, RASPExpr) if isinstance(self.inner, Map): # Combine the functions into just one. inner_f = self.inner.f self.f = lambda t: f(inner_f(t)) self.inner = self.inner.inner @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [self.inner] class SequenceMap(SOp): """SOp that evaluates the function elementwise on the two given SOp's. SequenceMap(lambda x, y: x - y, length, tokens).eval([1, 2, 3]) == [2, 1, 0] """ def __init__(self, f: Callable[[Value, Value], Value], fst: SOp, snd: SOp): super().__init__() if fst == snd: logging.warning("Creating a SequenceMap with both inputs being the same " "SOp is discouraged. You should use a Map instead.") self.f = f self.fst = fst self.snd = snd assert isinstance(self.fst, SOp) assert isinstance(self.snd, SOp) assert callable(self.f) and not isinstance(self.f, RASPExpr) @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [self.fst, self.snd] class LinearSequenceMap(SequenceMap): """SOp that evaluates a linear function elementwise on the two given SOp's.""" def __init__(self, fst: SOp, snd: SOp, fst_fac: float, snd_fac: float): super().__init__(fst=fst, snd=snd, f=lambda x, y: fst_fac * x + snd_fac * y) self.fst_fac = fst_fac self.snd_fac = snd_fac class Full(SOp): """A SOp evaluating to [fill]*len(input_values).""" def __init__(self, fill: Value): super().__init__() self.fill = fill @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [] def sop_not(sop: SOp) -> SOp: return Map(lambda t: not t, sop) class ConstantSOp(SOp, Generic[VT]): """A constant S-Op for testing purposes.""" def __init__(self, value: Sequence[VT], check_length: bool = True): super().__init__() self.value = value self.check_length = check_length @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [] ### Selectors. class Predicate(Protocol): def __call__(self, key: Value, query: Value) -> bool: """Applies the predicate.""" class Comparison(enum.Enum): """A two-place boolean comparison predicate for use in Select.""" EQ = "==" LT = "<" LEQ = "<=" GT = ">" GEQ = ">=" NEQ = "!=" TRUE = "True" FALSE = "False" def __call__(self, key: Value, query: Value) -> bool: if key is None: raise ValueError("key is None!") if query is None: raise ValueError("query is None!") return _comparison_table[self](key, query) _comparison_table = { Comparison.EQ: lambda key, query: key == query, Comparison.LT: lambda key, query: key < query, Comparison.LEQ: lambda key, query: key <= query, Comparison.GT: lambda key, query: key > query, Comparison.GEQ: lambda key, query: key >= query, Comparison.NEQ: lambda key, query: key != query, Comparison.TRUE: lambda key, query: True, Comparison.FALSE: lambda key, query: False, } class Selector(RASPExpr): """RASP Selector. Represents something like an attention head's weights.""" def __call__(self, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> SelectorValue: return evaluate(self, xs) # pytype: disable=bad-return-type # Allow construction of Selector combinations using Python logical operators. def __and__(self, other: "Selector") -> "Selector": """self & other.""" return selector_and(self, other) def __rand__(self, other: "Selector") -> "Selector": """other & self.""" return selector_and(other, self) def __or__(self, other: "Selector") -> "Selector": """self | other.""" return selector_or(self, other) def __ror__(self, other: "Selector") -> "Selector": """other | self.""" return selector_or(other, self) def __invert__(self) -> "Selector": """~self.""" return selector_not(self) class Select(Selector): """Primitive that creates a Selector.""" def __init__(self, keys: SOp, queries: SOp, predicate: Predicate): super().__init__() self.keys = keys self.queries = queries self.predicate = predicate assert isinstance(self.keys, SOp) assert isinstance(self.queries, SOp) @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [self.keys, self.queries] class ConstantSelector(Selector): """A constant selector for testing purposes.""" def __init__(self, value: SelectorValue, check_length: bool = True): super().__init__() self.value = value self.check_length = check_length @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [] class SelectorWidth(SOp): """SelectorWidth primitive.""" def __init__(self, selector: Selector): super().__init__() self.selector = selector assert isinstance(self.selector, Selector) @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [self.selector] class SelectorAnd(Selector): """Implements elementwise `and` between selectors.""" def __init__(self, fst: Selector, snd: Selector): super().__init__() self.fst = fst self.snd = snd assert isinstance(self.fst, Selector) assert isinstance(self.snd, Selector) @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [self.fst, self.snd] class SelectorOr(Selector): """Implements elementwise `or` between selectors.""" def __init__(self, fst: Selector, snd: Selector): super().__init__() self.fst = fst self.snd = snd assert isinstance(self.fst, Selector) assert isinstance(self.snd, Selector) @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [self.fst, self.snd] class SelectorNot(Selector): """Implements elementwise `not` on a selector.""" def __init__(self, inner: Selector): self.inner = inner super().__init__() assert isinstance(self.inner, Selector) @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [self.inner] def selector_not( inner: Selector, simplify: bool = True, ) -> Selector: """Returns a SelectorNot, or a Select if simplifying is possible.""" if simplify and isinstance(inner, Select): predicate = lambda k, q: not inner.predicate(k, q) return Select(inner.keys, inner.queries, predicate=predicate) return SelectorNot(inner) def selector_and( fst: Selector, snd: Selector, simplify: bool = True, ) -> Selector: """Returns a SelectorAnd, or a Select if simplifying is possible.""" if simplify and isinstance(fst, Select) and isinstance(snd, Select): simplified = _attempt_simplify(fst, snd, lambda l, r: l and r) if simplified: return simplified return SelectorAnd(fst, snd) def selector_or( fst: Selector, snd: Selector, simplify: bool = True, ) -> Selector: """Returns a SelectorOr, or a Select if simplifying is possible.""" if simplify and isinstance(fst, Select) and isinstance(snd, Select): simplified = _attempt_simplify(fst, snd, lambda l, r: l or r) if simplified: return simplified return SelectorOr(fst, snd) def _attempt_simplify( fst: Select, snd: Select, combine: Callable[[bool, bool], bool], ) -> Optional[Select]: """Simplifies two Selects if possible. If two Selects in a compound Selector have matching keys and queries, they can be simplified into one Select with a compound predicate: lambda k,q: combine(fst.predicate(k,q), snd.predicate(k,q)) This function returns a Select with this predicate if possible, and None otherwise. A Full SOp in a key or query position is a special case that always matches any SOp in the corresponding position in the other selector. In that case, we bake in the fill value into the corresponding Select's predicate before combining. This allows us to use the other SOp as the input to the simplified Select. Args: fst: the first Select. snd: the second Select. combine: how to combine the outputs of the individual predicates. Returns: A combined Select, if possible. """ fst_predicate = fst.predicate snd_predicate = snd.predicate common_keys = None common_queries = None if isinstance(fst.keys, Full): common_keys = snd.keys # We pass the predicate in as a default arg to avoid unintended recursion. fst_predicate = lambda key, query, p=fst_predicate: p(fst.keys.fill, query) if isinstance(snd.keys, Full): common_keys = fst.keys snd_predicate = lambda key, query, p=snd_predicate: p(snd.keys.fill, query) if isinstance(fst.queries, Full): common_queries = snd.queries fst_predicate = lambda key, query, p=fst_predicate: p(key, fst.queries.fill) if isinstance(snd.queries, Full): common_queries = fst.queries snd_predicate = lambda key, query, p=snd_predicate: p(key, snd.queries.fill) if fst.keys is snd.keys: common_keys = fst.keys if fst.queries is snd.queries: common_queries = fst.queries if not common_keys or not common_queries: return None def predicate(key, query): return combine(fst_predicate(key, query), snd_predicate(key, query)) return Select(common_keys, common_queries, predicate=predicate) class Aggregate(SOp, Generic[VT]): """Aggregate primitive.""" def __init__(self, selector: Selector, sop: SOp, default: Optional[VT] = None): """Initialises. The default is used where nothing is selected.""" super().__init__() self.selector = selector self.sop = sop self.default = default assert isinstance(self.selector, Selector) assert isinstance(self.sop, SOp) assert (self.default is None or isinstance(self.default, (str, float, bool, int))) @property def children(self) -> Sequence[RASPExpr]: return [self.selector, self.sop] ### SOp encodings. class Encoding(enum.Enum): """The encoding used by a SOp. Only number-valued SOps support numerical.""" CATEGORICAL = "categorical" NUMERICAL = "numerical" def numerical(sop: SOpT) -> SOpT: return annotate(sop, encoding=Encoding.NUMERICAL) def categorical(sop: SOpT) -> SOpT: return annotate(sop, encoding=Encoding.CATEGORICAL) def get_encoding(sop: SOp) -> Encoding: return sop.annotations["encoding"] def is_numerical(sop: SOp) -> bool: """Check if the SOp is numerically encoded.""" return get_encoding(sop) == Encoding.NUMERICAL def is_categorical(sop: SOp) -> bool: """Check if the SOp is categorically encoded.""" return get_encoding(sop) == Encoding.CATEGORICAL def default_encoding(expr: RASPExpr) -> Optional[Encoding]: """Adds an 'encoding' annotation, default is Categorical.""" if not isinstance(expr, SOp): raise TypeError(f"expr {expr} is not a SOp.") return Encoding.CATEGORICAL DEFAULT_ANNOTATORS[_ENCODING_KEY] = default_encoding ### naming. # Subclasses must appear here before superclasses in order for # the most specific entry to be used. _default_name_by_class = { # Primitives TokensType: "tokens", IndicesType: "indices", LengthType: "length", # SOps LinearSequenceMap: "linear_sequence_map", SequenceMap: "sequence_map", Map: "map", Full: "full", ConstantSOp: "constant_sop", SelectorWidth: "selector_width", Aggregate: "aggregate", SOp: "sop", # Selectors Select: "select", SelectorAnd: "selector_and", SelectorOr: "selector_or", SelectorNot: "selector_not", ConstantSelector: "constant_selector", Selector: "selector", } def default_name(expr: RASPExpr) -> Dict[str, str]: for cls, name in _default_name_by_class.items(): if isinstance(expr, cls): return name raise NotImplementedError(f"{expr} was not given a default name!") DEFAULT_ANNOTATORS[_NAME_KEY] = default_name ### evaluation. class RASPEvaluator(abc.ABC): """ABC for RASP evaluators.""" @abc.abstractmethod def evaluate(self, expr: RASPExpr, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Union[Sequence[Value], SelectorValue]: """Evaluates the RASP expression on input `xs`.""" class DefaultRASPEvaluator(abc.ABC): """Default evaluator for RASP.""" def evaluate(self, expr: RASPExpr, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Union[Sequence[Value], SelectorValue]: """Evaluates the RASP expression on input `xs`.""" return self._eval_fn_by_expr_type[type(expr)](expr, xs) def __init__(self): self._eval_fn_by_expr_type = { # Primitives TokensType: self.eval_tokens, IndicesType: self.eval_indices, LengthType: self.eval_length, # SOps LinearSequenceMap: self.eval_sequence_map, SequenceMap: self.eval_sequence_map, Map: self.eval_map, Full: self.eval_full, ConstantSOp: self.eval_constant_sop, SelectorWidth: self.eval_selector_width, Aggregate: self.eval_aggregate, SOp: _raise_not_implemented, # Selectors Select: self.eval_select, SelectorAnd: self.eval_selector_and, SelectorOr: self.eval_selector_or, SelectorNot: self.eval_selector_not, ConstantSelector: self.eval_constant_selector, Selector: _raise_not_implemented, } def eval_tokens(self, sop: TokensType, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Sequence[Value]: del sop return list(xs) def eval_indices(self, sop: IndicesType, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Sequence[Value]: del sop return list(range(len(xs))) def eval_length(self, sop: LengthType, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Sequence[int]: del sop return [len(xs)] * len(xs) def eval_sequence_map(self, sop: SequenceMap, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Sequence[Value]: fst_values = self.evaluate(sop.fst, xs) snd_values = self.evaluate(sop.snd, xs) return [ sop.f(x, y) if None not in [x, y] else None for x, y in zip(fst_values, snd_values) ] def eval_map(self, sop: Map, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Sequence[Value]: return [ sop.f(x) if x is not None else None for x in self.evaluate(sop.inner, xs) ] def eval_full(self, sop: Full, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Sequence[Value]: return [sop.fill] * len(xs) def eval_constant_sop(self, sop: ConstantSOp, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Sequence[Value]: if sop.check_length and (len(xs) != len(sop.value)): raise ValueError( f"Constant len {len(sop.value)} doesn't match input len {len(xs)}.") return sop.value def eval_selector_width(self, sop: SelectorWidth, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Sequence[Value]: selector_values = self.evaluate(sop.selector, xs) return [sum(row) for row in selector_values] def eval_aggregate(self, sop: Aggregate, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> Sequence[Value]: selector_value = self.evaluate(sop.selector, xs) values = self.evaluate(sop.sop, xs) default = sop.default return [ _mean(_get_selected(row, values), default) for row in selector_value ] def eval_select(self, sel: Select, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> SelectorValue: """Evaluates a Select on `xs`.""" key_values = self.evaluate(sel.keys, xs) query_values = self.evaluate(sel.queries, xs) key_len = len(key_values) query_len = len(query_values) out = np.zeros((query_len, key_len), dtype=bool).tolist() for row, query in enumerate(query_values): for col, key in enumerate(key_values): out[row][col] = bool(sel.predicate(key, query)) return out def eval_constant_selector(self, sel: ConstantSelector, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> SelectorValue: if sel.check_length and (len(xs) != len(sel.value)): raise ValueError( f"Constant len {len(xs)} doesn't match input len {len(sel.value)}.") return sel.value def eval_selector_and(self, sel: SelectorAnd, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> SelectorValue: fst_values = self.evaluate(sel.fst, xs) snd_values = self.evaluate(sel.snd, xs) return np.logical_and(np.array(fst_values), np.array(snd_values)).tolist() def eval_selector_or(self, sel: SelectorOr, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> SelectorValue: fst_values = self.evaluate(sel.fst, xs) snd_values = self.evaluate(sel.snd, xs) return np.logical_or(np.array(fst_values), np.array(snd_values)).tolist() def eval_selector_not(self, sel: SelectorNot, xs: Sequence[Value]) -> SelectorValue: values = self.evaluate(sel.inner, xs) return np.logical_not(np.array(values)).tolist() def _get_selected( selector_row: List[bool], values: Sequence[VT], ) -> Sequence[VT]: """Helper for aggregate. [T T F], [a b c] -> [a b].""" return [v for s, v in zip(selector_row, values) if s] def _mean(xs: Sequence[VT], default: VT) -> VT: """Takes the mean for numbers and concats for strings.""" if not xs: return default exemplar = xs[0] if isinstance(exemplar, (int, bool)): return sum(xs) / len(xs) elif len(xs) == 1: return exemplar else: raise ValueError(f"Unsupported type for aggregation: {xs}") def _raise_not_implemented(expr: RASPExpr, xs: Sequence[Value]): raise NotImplementedError(f"Evaluation of {expr} is not defined.") evaluate = DefaultRASPEvaluator().evaluate