TABLE 1 – SUSCEPTIBILITY CRITICAL ISSUE RESOLUTION MATRIX 1.1 SYSTEM LEVEL SUSCEPTIBILITY ISSUE TEST ANALYSIS M&S PRIOR DATA PERFORMING ORGANIZATION(S) FLIGHT (DT, DT/OT, OT, Etc.) GROUND (HITL, HPM, HIRF, Etc.) Physics Based, Engineering Level, Etc. M&S, HITL, Etc. Combat Data, Related Program Data, Etc 1.1.1 What is the effectiveness of systems for the detection of enemy threat assets (Detection & Tracking Systems, Air Defense Systems, Air Vehicles, Etc.)? Include on-board systems and interoperability with C4I assets. INCLUDE DETAILS IN THE TEMP OT SECTION Describe what tests will be done and what data will be obtained for the assessment. Describe what tests will be done and what data will be obtained for the assessment. Describe what analyses will be done and what data will be obtained for the assessment. Describe what will be done and what data will be obtained for the assessment. Describe expected sources of data and data that will be obtained for the assessment. Identify the respective performing organizations. Effectiveness against air threats (number of threats tracked, acquisition ranges, target(s) acquisition under adverse weather & day/night operation) OT Flight Test AFOTEC 1.1.1.1.1 Hypervelocity missiles, MANPADS, missiles X X AFOTEC 1.1.1.1.2 Effectiveness against IR threats OT Flight Test AFOTEC
1.1.6.x Effectiveness of On-Board Countermeasures against Expected Threats 1 Electronic countermeasures OT Flight Test Data from other programs, prior combat data AFOTEC 2 Infrared countermeasures OT Flight Test Data from programs, prior combat data AFOTEC 1.1.7.x Effectiveness of Defensive Systems against Expected Threats 1 Jamming systems OT Flight Test Prior program data AFOTEC 2 Other (Specify) TABLE 2 – VULNERABILITY CRITICAL ISSUE RESOLUTION MATRIX 1.2.1 VULNERABILITY: ATTRITION KILL & MISSION ABORT TEST TEST ARTICLE ANALYSIS M&S PRIOR DATA FLIGHT (DT, DT/OT, OT, Etc.) BALLISTIC (LIVE FIRE) (SIL, HPM, HIRF, Etc.) FUSL, System, Surrogate, Etc. Fragments, API, HEI, MANPADS, Etc. and Sizes FMECA, DMEA, Engineering Level, Etc. M&S, HITL, Etc. Combat Data, Related Program Data, Etc. 1.2.1.1.x AIRFRAME STRUCTURAL COMPONENTS THREATS
INCLUDE DETAILS IN THE LIVE FIRE ALTERNATIVE PLAN Specify tests that will be conducted and data needed for assessment Specify tests that will be conducted and data needed for assessment Specify tests that will be conducted and data needed for assessment Specify what test articles will be used (FUSL, System, Component Surrogate, etc.) Specify what threats will be used for the ballistic tests. Specify methods of analyses that will be used and what results will be needed for the assessment. Specify what models will be used and what results are needed for the assessment. Describe expected sources of data and data that will be obtained for the assessment. 1 Vulnerability of Major Structural Components FASTGEN/ COVART/ FMECA/ DMEA Pk X 2 Structural damage prediction for high Pk critical (flight & mission) structural components X X 3 Damaged Air Vehicle functionality X X X 1.2.1.2.x FLIGHT CONTROL SURFACES AND SYSTEMS 1 Vulnerability (redundancy, separation) of flight control system (computers, actuators, etc.), software and surfaces (flap, slat, aileron, rudder) to expected threats FASTGEN/ COVART/ FMECA/ DMEA Pk, Engineering level analyses 2 What is the capability of flight control system software to maintain the airworthiness of the air vehicle with threat damaged flight control systems and/or flight control surfaces? System Integration Lab testing Flight control system components & software X Aero simulation with damaged systems & surfaces X
3 Air vehicle functionality (mission, range, takeoff, landing, air worthiness) with damaged FCS components and/or FCS surfaces System Integration Lab testing Flight control system components & software X Aero simulation with damaged systems & surfaces X 1.2.1.3.x VULNERABILITY OF AIR VEHICLE TO PROPULSION SYSTEM THREAT INDUCED DAMAGE (Ballistic & Fire) 1 Engines X Used engine (If warranted by Pk analysis) FASTGEN/ COVART/ FMECA/ DMEA Pk analysis UEDDAM X, C-130J prop data 2 Engine Nacelles including fuel & hydraulic lines X Surrogate FASTGEN/ COVART/ FMECA/ DMEA Pk analysis 3 What is the functionality (mission completion, range, takeoff & landing, air worthiness) of the air vehicle with damaged or inoperable propulsion systems (engines, propellers, nacelles)? Engineering analyses flight simulation Prior combat and commercial incident data 1.2.1.4.x VULNERABILITY OF AIR VEHICLE TO AVIONICS/ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS THREAT INDUCED DAMAGE 1 What is the vulnerability (redundancy, separation) of mission/flight critical avionics/electronic systems to expected ballistic threats? FASTGEN/ COVART/ FMECA/ DMEA Pk analysis
2 Vulnerability (disruption/ damage) of mission & flight critical avionics/electronics systems to HPM, laser and DEW threats Component bench tests and system function tests Functioning avionics system components, in-aircraft installed systems 3 Vulnerability to PAO coolant fire FASTGEN/ COVART/ FMECA/ DMEA Pk Prior program data 4 Air Vehicle mission & flight functionality with damaged or inoperable critical avionics systems Fault Insertion SIL Testing Avionics system components X Aero/FCS flight simulation 5 What is the vulnerability of the Auxiliary Power Unit systems? FASTGEN/ DMEA Pk simulations 1.2.1.5.x VULNERABILITY OF AIR VEHICLE TO HYDRAULIC SYSTEMS THREAT INDUCED DAMAGE 1 Pk Vulnerability of hydraulic systems & lines FASTGEN/ COVART/ FMECA/ DMEA Pk X 2 Vulnerability to fire & effectiveness of fire suppression systems X Surrogate test articles Fragments (40, 75 grain) 23, 30 mm (API, HEI) X X 3 Air Vehicle mission & flight functionality with damaged hydraulic systems Flight Simulator Testing Flight Simulator Engineering Level Analysis Aero flight simulation X aircraft
1 What is the vulnerability to threat induced cargo (ammunition, explosives, fuel) fire and explosion? FASTGEN/ COVART/ FMECA/ DMEA Pk Structural damage prediction & aero simulation X 2 What capabilities exist to emergency jettison cargo? X 3 Effectiveness of cargo compartment fire suppression systems? X X 4 What is the functionality (mission, air worthiness) of the air vehicle sustaining damage (aircraft and cargo handling systems) from cargo fire and/or explosion? Engineering analysis X 5 What is the functionality of cargo handling systems systems, rails, pallets, cargo doors) with threat damage? X 1.2.1.10.x EFFECTIVENESS OF DRY-BAY FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS IN SUPPRESSING THREAT INDUCED FIRES (FUEL, HYDRAULIC, PAO COOLANT)? 1 What is the effectiveness of dry bay fire suppression systems? X Surrogate test articles Fragments (40, 75 23, 30 mm (API, HEI) Vendor Analysis X 2 What is the vulnerability of fire suppression system components to threat induced damage? FASTGEN/ COVART/ FMECA/ DMEA Pk 1.2.1.11.x EFFECTIVENESS OF FUEL TANK OBIGGS ULLAGE INERTING SYSTEMS
1 What is the effectiveness of fuel tank ullage inerting systems in maintaining oxygen concentration levels below those necessary to support fire or explosion? Simulated mission profile surrogate test article oxygen concentration Fuel System Simulator X X 1.2.1.12.x VULNERABILITY OF TANKER AERIAL/GROUND REFUELING SYSTEMS 1 What is the vulnerability of tanker aerial refueling systems (including refueling fuel tanks)? FASTGEN/ COVART, DMEA Pk X 2 What is the vulnerability of tanker ground refueling systems (including refueling fuel tanks)? FASTGEN/ COVART, FMECA, DMEA Pk X 1.2.1.13.x VULNERABILITY OF LANDING GEAR POD AND LANDING GEAR SYSTEMS 1 What is the vulnerability of the landing gear pod? FASTGEN/ COVART, FMECA, DMEA Pk 2 What is the vulnerability of the landing gear systems? FASTGEN/ COVART, FMECA, DMEA 1.2.1.14.x WHAT IS THE VULNERABILITY OF THE EMERGENCY SUPPLEMENTAL OXYGEN SYSTEM? 1 What is the ballistic vulnerability of the ESOS system to expected threats? X X 2 What is the fire/explosion vulnerability of the ESOS system to expected threats? X X