This category of documents also includes very detailed comprehensive handbooks for public procurement lawyers on procurement procedures in general. Two examples from Germany are the ‘Handbuch Vergaberecht’ and the ‘juris PraxisKommentar Vergaberecht’. The books are about all of public procurement, but as such they also cover specific procedures and many of the issues pertaining to the procurement of innovation. Table 8 Legal guides mapped Level Country Publisher Title Year Language Pages EU European Assistance for Innovation Procurement Toolkit - Module 3 - legal/operational module 2018 English 94 EU Michael Burnett and Martin Oder Competitive dialogue 2009 English 212 EU Roberto Caranta & Martin Trybus (eds) The Law of Green and Social Procurement in Europe 2010 English 330 EU Ius Publicum Network Review Joint procurement and innovation in the new EU directive and in some projects 2014 English 32 EU CMS Guide to the EU public procurement rules 2017 English 36 EU Geo Quinot Innovation, state contracting and public procurement law 2015 English 21 EU Procurement for Innovation Platform Introduction to intellectual property rights in Public Procurement of Innovation 2015 English 14 Nat ES Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad Guía 2.0 para la compra pública de innovación 2015 Spanish 68 Nat SE Lorentz Reige, Stockholms universitet Innovation i offentlig upphandling - Nya och gamla förfaranden för upphandling av innovation 2015 Swedish 65 Nat DE Umweltbundesamt Rechtsgutachten umweltfreundliche Beschaffung 2014 German 113 Nat UK Anthony Collins Solicitors Social Value and Public Procurement - A Legal Guide 2014 English 30 Nat DE Gabriel / Krohn / Neun Handbuch Vergaberecht 2017 German Nat DE juris PraxisKommentar Vergaberecht 2013 German 1500 Nat FI Pesu, Jarkko Innovaation Käsite Hankintalainsäädännössä ja Valtiontukisäännöksissä (The concept of innovation in procurement law and state aid rules) 2018 Finnish 24 Nat FR Advancity Innovation et villes durables: note d'approfondissement juridique 2015 French 36 Nat DE Deutscher Städtetag Die Berücksichtigung sozialer Belange im Vergaberecht - Hinweise für die kommunale 2010 German 33
Praxis Legal notes/opinion Short legal notes or opinions - published by experts, interest groups, and sometimes on legal blogs or the sites of law firms – supplement more comprehensive guides with a legal analysis of specific issues. They present and interpret law (incl. case law), sometimes within the framework of national contexts and concrete cases. This category of legal support material was not in the focus of the mapping exercise, but they will be useful in compiling the content of the proposed Legal Handbook. A few examples found have been included in the table below. The first three of the legal notes and opinions in this sample list are at EU level. The first one (‘Public Procurement Award Procedures in Directive 2014/24/EU’) reviews the changes to the Public Procurement Directives under different procedures, and discusses specifically possible issues with the competitive procedure with negotiation and innovation partnership. The second (‘The Link to the Subject-Matter: A Glass Ceiling for Sustainable Public Contracts?’) concerns procurers’ options with regard to the link of awarding criteria to the subject matter, with a focus on sustainability requirements, analysing the origins and justifications for this requirement – supported by ECJ case law. The third (‘Innovation Partnership in the New Public Procurement Regime – A Shift of Focus from Procedural to Contractual Issues?’) addresses Innovation Partnership, discussing inter alia practical legal issues such as IPR and termination risks or State Aid implications. The last two notes have been written for a given national legal context. They deal with Innovation Partnerships; and the choice between competitive dialogue and the new competitive procedure with negotiation. Table 9 Selected legal notes and opinions Level Country Publisher Title Year Language Pages EU Pedro Telles and Luke R.A. Butler Public Procurement Award Procedures in Directive 2014/24/EU 2014 English 46 EU Abby Semple The Link to the A Glass Ceiling for Sustainable Public Contracts? 2014 English 18 EU Marta Andrecka Innovation Partnership in the New Public Procurement Regime – A Shift of Focus from Procedural to Contractual Issues? 2017 English 15 Nat UK Pedro Telles Regulation 31 - Innovation partnership 2016 English 3 Nat UK Stephen Kenny Delivering complex projects: competitive dialogue or competitive procedure with negotiation? 2018 English 3