CID Clause Comment Proposed Change Proposed Resolution 11908 6.3.4.2 40 16 Missing "HE Operation" element in The Basic HE-MCS and NSS field is in HE Operation element, so to check them at the "Effect of recceipt" paragraph, requires it is included in the Add "HE Operation" into Reject. is used by a non-AP STA and HE Operation is not included in it. The HE Operation parameter is obtained by the STA after scanning process. 11926 6.3.7 40 48 should include 11ax related parameters such as HE Capabilities. Add 11ax related parameters such as HE Capabilities to Revise. Agree with the commenter. See the proposed text change in 11927 6.3.7 40 48 should include 11ax related parameters such as HE Capabilities. Add 11ax related parameters such as HE Capabilities to Revise. Agree with the commenter. See the proposed text change in 11928 6.3.7 40 48 should include 11ax related parameters such as HE Capabilities. Add 11ax related parameters such as HE Capabilities to Revise. Agree with the commenter. See the proposed text change in
12351 6.3.7.4.2 40 53 TWT element is missing. Add it for TWT negotiation. Add it also for reassociation Reject. 802.11ah already included TWT element in and it Is not necessary to update it. 13845 6.3.7.4.2 41 10 It is not clear "parameter" in the sentence of "The parameter is present if it is present in the Association Request frame received from the STA" Does it mean the "parameters" in HE Capabilities, or HE Capabilities element itself? Also what does the "it" refer to? Please clarify Reject. Since “the parameter” is in the singular form, it means “HE Capabilities”. Similar sentences are used in the baseline to describe HT Capabilities or VHT Capabilities. 11929 2.6.3.8 41 18 should include 11ax related parameters such as HE Capabilities. Add 11ax related parameters such as HE Capabilities to Revise. Agree with the commenter. See the proposed text change in 11930 2.6.3.8 41 18 should include 11ax related parameters such as HE Capabilities. Add 11ax related parameters such as HE Capabilities to Revise. Agree with the commenter. See the proposed text change in 11931 2.6.3.8 41 18 should include 11ax related parameters such as HE Capabilities. Add 11ax related parameters such as HE Capabilities to Revise. Agree with the commenter. See the proposed text change in Proposed text changes (for CID 11926, 11927, 11928, 11929, 11930, and 11931): Amend Clause 6.3.7.2.2 of P802.11REVmd D0.4 as follows: MLME-ASSOCIATE.request 6.3.7.2.2 Semantics of the service primitive
CID Clause Comment Proposed Change Proposed Resolution 11109 6.3.11.2.3 42 20 "The additional HE capabilities to be advertised for the BSS" - no they are not capabilities, but parameters that determine the operation of the HE BSS. Replace with "Provides additional information for operating the HE BSS." - this follows the VHT language. Accept. 6.3.11.2.4 42 34 "MLME-JOIN.request" should be changed to "MLME-START.request" as in the comment Revise The current text is just copied text from The text should be modified. See the proposed text change in 12336 6.3.11.2.4 42 36 "MLME-JOIN.confirm" should be changed to "MLME-START.confirm" as in the comment Revise The current text is just copied text from The text should be modified. See the proposed text change in