3136 10.3.1 113 46 "When HE duration-based RTS is disabled, " - how do we know? Add reference to condition that describes how we can differentiate - e.g. in a MIB variable setting or a BSS operaton element. Ditto at line 50. Revised: Add test to reference MIB object: Encoding TGax editor to make the changes shown in this document under all headings containing CID 3136. Please apply throughout these CIDs. 4834 10.3.1 113 50 "When HE duration-based RTS is enabled". No mention of where that is indicated. Is it referring to a MIB or to a field somewhere? can it be configured through a management message? (I found no such possibility) If not, this mechanism is not enforcing anything. Specify that this dotBLAH shall be set to the most recent value of the HE Duration Based field of the HE Operation element transmitted by the AP to which it is associated. Revised: See CID 3136 resolution. TGax editor to make the changes shown in this document under all headings containing CID 4834. Please apply throughout these CIDs. 5159 10.3.1 113 45 "HE duration-based RTS" sounds like a name of a function/feature. But I don't see any definition for it. Define the protocol for establishing "HE RTS". Perhaps turn 10.3.2.4a into something useful. Rejected: HE RTS is described in following clauses: 9.4.2.238 HE Operating IE and C.3 MIB object specification of 5161 10.3.2.4 115 38 How is the "HE RTS threshold" used by the non-AP HE STAs? Define the protocol and provide normative language for how the non-AP HE STAs behaves upon receipt of this threshold. Perhaps turn 10.3.2.4a into something useful. Revised: Added paragraphs to describe the behavior of HE Duration based RTS/CTS. TGax editor to make the changes shown in this document under all headings containing CID 5161. Please apply throughout these CIDs. 5162 10.3.2.4 115 38 Clarify that "HE RTS threshold" is in the HE Operation Parameters field as in comment Revised: See resolution of CID 5161 based based
paragraph starting from lines 45 to line 48 describing disable HE duration-based RTS TGax editor to make the changes shown in this document under all headings containing CID 8350. Please apply throughout these CIDs. 8351 10.3.1 113 50 The procedure to enable HE duration-based RTS is not described. Unless the procedure is clearly defined, the draft should follow the existing RTS/CTS procedure. Remove the paragraph starting from lines 50 to line 54 Revised: The revised 10.3.2.4a has added the text of describing enable HE duration-based RTS TGax editor to make the changes shown in this document under all headings containing CID 8351. Please apply throughout these CIDs. 9422 10.3.2.4a 115 50 It is unclear which "network situation" it is referring to. This sentence is also unnecessary. Please consider to remove or rephrase. Remove this sentence. Revised: Replace “network” with “interference” TGax editor to make the changes shown in this document under all headings containing CID 9422. Please apply throughout these CIDs. 9686 122 1 "When HE duration-based RTS is enabled, a non-AP STA using the DCF or EDCA shall use an RTS/CTS exchange for individually addressed frames when the duration of the TXOP is greater than the duration threshold indicated by When HE duration-based RTS is enabled, what is a rule of an AP STA? Probably, same rule should be used. Change it as the following: "When HE duration-based RTS is enabled, a STA using the DCF or EDCA shall use an RTS/CTS exchange..." As per comment. Rejected: Also the text in 10.3.5 already has the text as indicated by the comment. It intentionally written that Duration based RTS threshold is applied to HE STAs, not for HE AP STA. For HE AP STA, it should have the logic to use RTS/CTS based on implementation. 10.3.1 General AP