239 6.33 4.3.23.3 "Reasons for such selective reception include the MAC service requirement that, when an MSDU is sent, it is not returned to and processed by the transmitting station." It is not clear to me in what situation is assumed here. In the IEEE 802.11-2012 clause 9.3.6, the transmission procedure of group address frames is specified which is not consistent with the above text. Please clarify what situation is assumed here. Discuss: Propose rejection. Base spec has similar requirements, although I couldn't find the refernce. Anyone? We are not changing transmission requirements, rather receive filtering. It is not the intent of this spec to justify 802.1Q bridging requirements, but to support them. Reasons could also include multicast pruning, VLANs presence, and policy. 258 6.33 4.3.23.3 "Reasons for such selective reception include the MAC service requirement that, when an MSDU is sent, it is not returned to and processed by the transmitting station." Its situation should be clarified. It is not clear if the transmission procedure of group address frames specified in the IEEE clause 9.3.6 is included in the above explanation. Please explain clearly what situation is assumed here. Reject: Dup CID239 295 8.19 4.3.23.4.3 The subset of STAs to received a group addressed is not arbitrary, it's a specifc subset as defined in the SYNRA. Change "an arbitrary" to "a specific". Reject: "an arbitrary subset" is a mathematical statement. In that context the definition of arbitrary from the OED is " (Of a constant or other quantity) of unspecified value". The AP must be willing to accept an arbitrary subset of all associated STA as the receipients. It is not specified here, but in the Should we add a refernce?
107 55.31 9.42 What is an AID Vector? And, what is a format of the AID Vector? I can not find any AID Vector information from Clause 8.3.2.1.4. Please include the format of the AID Vector. Revise: Problem looks to be inconsistant naming of a subfield through out the document. "The AID Vector is located in" -> "The AID Vector subfield is a variable length bit array indicating which receivers in the bitmap are to accept or exclude the MSDU. The subfield is located in" Also correct p40.04 "Extended AID bit array" -> "Extended AID Vector", and correct that naming in text + figures on p55-56. Also p39.06, so global search is warrented. 269 55.34 9.42 Doesn't say whether bits corresponding to illegally high AID numbers are ignored or wrap around to AID 0. Insert as the next to last sentence in the paragarph: "Bits corresponding to AID numbers larger than the maximum legal AID number are ignored." Revise: Repeat, as in CID268. 108 56.17 9.42 What is a format of the Extended SYNRA AID list? What is an Extended SYNRA AID list? And, what is a format of the Extended SYNRA AID list? I can not find any Extended SYNRA AID list information from Clause 8.3.2.1.4. Please include the format of the Extended SYNRA AID list. Revise: "Each pair of octets contains one AID" -> "Each pair of octets contains one AID, as described in 8.4.1.8" 228 57.14 9.43 Does not correctly represent when 4 Addr AMSDU are used. Update lines 14-15, to add ", or BSSID for basic AMSDU". Also on line 17 correct as "The addressing of the 3 address frame containing an A-MSDU shall be as follows" Accept
110 57.18 9.43 "Address 1 is the MAC address of the immediate STA (the receiver of the MPDU) or a SYNRA" When the Address 1 is the SYNRA and the A-MSDU is present, the Ack Policy subfield in QoS Control field is No ACK or Block ACK? Please specify the Ack Policy when the Address 1 is set to the SYNRA. Please specify the Ack Policy when the Address 1 is set to the SYNRA. Reject: No change to usage of Ack Policy by groupcast frames is being suggested in this section. Not clear why clarification is required/requested for AMSDU, but not 4Addr frames. Maybe this is a GCR question?