7515 Lei Huang 28.3.9 263.7 "where N_HE-SIG-B is the number of OFDM symbols in the HE-SIG-B field" is redundant since N_HE-SIG-B has been defined in the previous page (see L15 of P262) remove "where N_HE-SIG-B is the number of OFDM symbols in the HE-SIG-B field" Revised. Change to as in the resolution of CID7515 in doc ax editor: please make the following changes in D1.1 Clause 28.3.9: On P263L7 (CID #7515): 8887 Sigurd Schelstraete 28.3.9 264.45 It is not clear what "and 1 otherwise" refers to. Change to "It is 1 for all other fields" Revised. Change to as in the resolution of CID8887 in doc Discussions: is set to 1 for HE-SIG-A and Data fields in an HE extended range SU PPDU, and all fields for other HE PPDU formats. ax editor: please make the following changes in D1.1 Clause 28.3.9: On P264L45 (CID #8887): and 1. 4866 Bin Tian 28.3.9 265.17 The sentence "cardinality of the set of subcarriers modulated with data within Kr" may lead to confusion that only data subcarrier are counted. Change to "cardinality of the set of modulated subcarriers modulated within Kr" as in comment Revised. Change to as in the resolution of CID4866 in doc
L-SIG 56 112 224 448 RL-SIG 56 112 224 448 HE-SIG-A 56 112 224 448 HE-SIG-B 56 112 224 448 HE-STF not in HE_TRIG 14 30 62 126 - HE-STF in HE_TRIG 30 60 124 248 - HE-LTF 1x Duration 60 122 250 500 TGI,HE-LTF1 HE-LTF 2x Duration 242 498 996 TGI,HE-LTF2 HE-LTF 4x Duration 242 484 996 1992 TGI,HE-LTF4 HE-Data 242 484 996 1992 TGI,Data 56 112 224 448 NOTE--in the case of an HE PPDU, the value of HE-STF, HE-LTF and HE-Data fields is variable, and is determined by which RUs of the current full bandwidth are transmitted in the PPDU. ax editor: please change “Table 28-14 Tone scaling factor and guard interval duration values for HE PPDU fields” to “Table 28-14 Number of modulated subcarriers and guard interval duration values for HE PPDU fields” throughout the draft. CID Commenter Section Page Comment Proposed Change Resolution 8889 Sigurd Schelstraete 28.3.9 265.38 Why do we need a column "Guard interval duration in Table 28-14? Remove column Rejected. Guard interval duration in Table 28-14 clearly listed guard interval for each field, which is
also included in Table 21-8 in mathematical description of transmitted signal for VHT PPDU. To keep the spec consistent, it is better to keep guard interval duration in Table 28-14. CID Commenter Section Page Comment Proposed Change Resolution 4868 Bin Tian 28.3.9 266.53 Remove the sentence " Note that the mulitiplication matrices Ak_HE-LT ..." and the next one "when the TXVECTOR ...". The matix Ak_HE-LTF is not introduced here and carries the next level of details of how to generate HE-LTF, which is not needed here. as in comment Revised. Change to as in the resolution of CID4868 in doc 4994 Brian Hart 28.3.9 266.51 "Note that ..." ... need a reference to a normative stmt to make this note trustworthy Add xref Revised. Change to as in the resolution of CID4990 in doc 9484 Yan Zhang 28.3.9 266.53 Sentence "Note that the multiplication matrices Ak_HE-LTF are included in the calculation of X(iseg,m)_k,r,u for the HE-STF and HE-LTF fields" is not completely accurate. The multiplication matrices Ak_HE-LTF should not included in the calculation of X(iseg,m)_k,r,u for Change to "Note that the multiplication matrices are included in the calculation of X(iseg,m)_k,r,u for HE-LTF field". Revised. Change to as in the resolution of CID4990 in doc Discussions: