IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Minutes for REVmd - Sept 2018 - Waikoloa Date: 2018-09-13 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone Jon Rosdahl Qualcomm Technologies, Inc. 10871 N 5750 W Highland, UT 84003 +1-801-492-4023 jrosdahl@ieee.org 802.11md - – 802 Plenary – Waikoloa, Monday PM1: 13:30-15:30 Called to order at 1:30pm by the TG Chair, Dorothy STANLEY (HPE) Review Patent Policy Call for essential patents – No comments. Review Participation Slide Review Agenda: 11-18/1388r2 Monday PM1 Chair’s Welcome, Policy & patent reminder Approve agenda Status, Review of Objectives Editor Report Emily QI – CID 1306 11-18-1421 Menzo CID 1007 11-18-0930 Abhi Patil/Menzo WENTINK CIDs 1278, 1288, 1300 11-18-1350 and CID 1298 in 11-18-1296 Mike MONTEMURRO – CIDs 1027, Cid 1028 Mark HAMILTON– CID 1286 Monday PM2 Menzo WENTINK– CID 1505 11-18-1426 Carlos CORDEIRO11-18-1324 Carlos CORDEIRO11-18-1580 DMG CIDs Mark RISON CIDs in 11-18-1306r3 Tuesday AM1 Jerome HENRY – CID 1014, 11-18-1446, also 11-18-1447, 11-18-1448 Menzo WENTINK - 11-18-1177 – 11ah TXOP Dan HARKINS – 11-18-1479 Parse Commit message Mark RISON CIDs in 11-18-1306r3 Comment resolution Tuesday PM1 EDCA TXOP AC rules CID 1195 – 11-18-1260, 11-18-1368 Sean Coffey 11-18-1573 Emily QI – CID 1006 11-18-1364 – Beacon Protection Wednesday PM1 Mark HAMILTON– CIDs 1507, 1525, also see 11-18-1306 Comment Resolution Wednesday PM2
Moved: Edward AU Seconded: Mark HAMILTON Result Motion #71: Unanimous Consent – Motion Passes Motion #72– 11ah TXOP limits Incorporate the changes in into the TGmd draft. Moved: Menzo WENTINK Seconded: Michael MONTEMURRO Result: Motion #72: Unanimous Consent – Motion Passes Motion #73 – Commit message edits Incorporate the changes in 11-18/1479r2 into the TGmd draft. Moved: Dan HARKINS Seconded: Michael MONTEMURRO Result Motion #73: Unanimous Consent – Motion Passes Motion #74 – Beacon Frame protection “Incorporate the changes in into the TGmd draft. These changes define a new Beacon frame protection capability.” Moved: Emily QI Seconded: BHANDARU Discussion: There is a concern that there is some outstanding objections that have not been resolved. Request more time. Motion #74a: Motion to Moved Menzo WENTINK, 2nd: Youhan KIM Results of Motion to Table: 11-13-9 Motion Fails. Statement of support of the motion was made. And statements of objection to the motion to allow for more discussion to occur. Question to understand the reasons for the objection. Masking the timestamp may help, but the main concern was significant complexity to beacon offload. Previous complaints with the author is still outstanding. Not everyone believes that there is a complexity question. A Delay to November should not materially affect the results. The Mover and 2nd of the motion would like to proceed with the motion. If there is no complexity, then the argument for delay would not be made. Result Motion #74: 13-12-8 Motion Fails Motion #75 – Waikoloa CIDs Approve the comment resolutions in the “Motion EDITOR F” tab in “PHY Motion G” tab in and incorporate the indicated changes into the TGmd draft. Moved: Michael MONTEMURRO Seconded: Edward AU Discussion: None Result Motion #75: Unanimous Consent – Motion Passes Review doc 11-18/1000r0 – Edward AU (Huawei) CID 1129 and 1130 (EDITOR2) Review comment Proposed Resolution: Revised; Incorporate the changes in 11-18/1000r0 <> resolves the comment in the direction of the commenter.