UPLINK: It matches to “Uplink Indication” in the PHY SIG field. So, it needs to change its name into “UPLINK_INDICATION” COLOR: It matches to “COLOR” which is included in “ID” in the PHY SIG field. 1795 G Kumar 240.34 24.2.2 In 24-1, parameter FORMAT should also have S1G_DUP_2M in list of enumerated types in Value column Add "S1G_DUP_2M indicates S1G 2MHz Duplicate PPDU format" as the item in the enumerated list in Value Column ACCEPT. Please refer to doc. 14/XXXXr0. <Discussion> S1G_DUP_2M could not be shown in the table of draft 1.0~1.2 due to not enough size of the row, though it already has been in the table. So, I tried to make the size of the row enough to have S1G_DUP_2M. 2554 Mitsuru Iwaoka 240.00 24.2.2 Minho Table 20-1 and/or Table 22-1 are referred in multiple 'otherwise' rows of Table 24-1. They are parameters for an HT or VHT STA and not applicable to an S1G STA. The all PPDU format supported in the S1G STA is listed, and no 'otherwise' condition exists. Remove all 'otherwise' rows in Table 24-1. REJECT. Please refer to doc. 14/XXXXr0. Including otherwise for other FORMAT parameter has been long used in the previous drafts such 802.11ac and 802.11af.
CHAN_MAT_TYPE and CHAN_MAT. <Discussion> As the commenterd pointed out, I changed accordingly. FYI, LENGTH is in symbols or octects depending on conditions, but, PSDU_LENGTH is in octets all the time. And previous draft such as 802.11ac also has used “PSDU_LENGTH” instead of “LENGTH” in its CHAN_MAT_TYPE and CHAN_MAT parameters in the TXVECTOR/RXVECTOR. 2167 Kenichi Mori 246.35 24.2.2 Minho Section number of "Received channel power indicator (RCPI)" is wrong. Correct section number is 20.3.20.6 (not 20.3.21.6). Change section number from 20.3.21.6 to 20.3.20.6. ACCEPT. Please refer to doc. 14/XXXXr0. <Discussion> Corrected as the commnenter pointed out. 2168 Kenichi Mori 246.43 24.2.2 Minho Section number 8.4.1.48.1 seems not to be correct because there is no explanation of SNR in this section. Section 8.4.1.28 should be correct. Change section number from 8.4.1.48.1 to 8.4.1.28. REVISE. Please to doc. 14/XXXXr0. 2169 Kenichi Mori 246.50 24.2.2 Section number 8.4.1.48.1 seems not to Change section number from REVISE.
be correct because there is no explanation of SNR in this section. Section 8.4.1.28 should be correct. 8.4.1.48.1 to 8.4.1.28. Please refer to doc. 14/XXXXr0. 2170 Kenichi Mori 246.58 24.2.2 Minho Section number 8.4.1.48.1 seems not to be correct because there is no explanation of SNR in this section. Section 8.4.1.28 should be correct. Change section number from 8.4.1.48.1 to 8.4.1.28. REVISE. Please refer to doc. 14/XXXXr0. <Discussion> Section 8.4.1.28 isn’t appropriate as a reference either, because it talks about non-compressed beamforming. So, it seems a good way to just comply with the same description in the 802.11ac draft, that is, referring to section 8.4.1.48 (VHT Compressed Beamforming Report field). FYI, sub-section 8.4.1.48.1 (VHT Compressed Beamforming Report Field in S1G Band) also belongs to section 8.4.1.48. 1308 Adrian 251.38 24.2.2 Minho Pretty red colour Make it boring black colour. Ditto line 42. ACCEPT Please refer to doc. 14/XXXXr0. <Discussion> Colored as the commenter pointed out. 2071 Jens Tingleff 252.28 24.2.2 I thought that was derived from Make up your minds if MU_SU is Reject. ns
Otherwise Not present SMOOTHING FORMAT is S1G and (CH_BANDWIDTH equals CBW2 or CBW4 or CBW8 or CBW16) and PREAMBLE_TYPE equals Indicates whether frequency-domain smoothing is recommended as part of channel estimation. Set to 1 if frequency-domain smoothing is recommended. Set to 0 otherwise. Y Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and PREAMBLE_TYPE equals Indicates whether frequency-domain smoothing is recommended as part of channel estimation. Set to 1 if frequency-domain smoothing is recommended. Set to 0 otherwise. Y Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M Indicates whether frequency-domain smoothing is recommended as part of channel estimation. Set to 1 if frequency-domain smoothing is recommended. Set to 0 otherwise. Y Y FORMAT is S1G and CH_BANDWIDTH equals CBW1 Indicates whether frequency-domain smoothing is recommended as part of channel estimation. Set to 1 if frequency-domain smoothing is recommended. Set to 0 otherwise. Y Y FORMAT is S1G and (CH_BANDWIDTH equals CBW2 or CBW4 or CBW8 or and PREAMBLE_TYPE equals If NUM_STS is larger than 1, indicates whether smoothing is recommended as part of channel estimation. Set to 1 if frequency-domain smoothing is recommended. Set to 0 otherwise. Y Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and PREAMBLE_TYPE equals If NUM_STS is larger than 1, indicates whether smoothing is recommended as part of channel estimation. Set to 1 if frequency-domain smoothing is recommended. Set to 0 otherwise. Y Y Otherwise See corresponding entry in Table 20-1 and Table 22-1. AGGREGATION FORMAT is S1G Indicates whether the PSDU contains an A-MPDU. Enumerated type: AGGREGATED indicates this packet has A-MPDU aggregation. NOT_AGGREGATED indicates this packet does not have A-MPDU aggregation. Y Y
FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M Contains a vector in the number of selected subcarriers containing feedback matrices as defined in 24.3.10.2 (Beamforming Feedback Matrix V) on the channel measured during the training symbols of a previous S1G NDP PPDU. Y N Otherwise See corresponding entry in Table 20-1 and Table 22-1. CHAN_MAT_TYPE FORMAT is S1G and equals 0 and equals 0 Set to COMPRESSED_SV N Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and equals 0 and equals 0 Set to COMPRESSED_SV N Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M and equals 0 and equals 0 Set to COMPRESSED_SV N Y FORMAT is S1G and equals 0 and equals 1 Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and equals 0 and equals 1 Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M and equals 0 and equals 1 Not present N N FORMAT is S1G and is greater than 0 Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and is greater than 0 Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M and is greater than 0 Not present N N Otherwise See corresponding entry in Table 20-1 and Table 22-1. CHAN_MAT FORMAT is S1G and equals 0 and equals 0 Contains a set of compressed beamforming feedback matrices as defined in 24.3.10.2 (Beamforming Feedback Matrix V) based on the channel measured during the training symbols of the received S1G NDP PPDU. N Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and equals 0 and equals 0 Contains a set of compressed beamforming feedback matrices as defined in 24.3.10.2 (Beamforming Feedback Matrix V) based on the channel measured during the training symbols of the received S1G NDP PPDU. N Y
FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M and equals 0 and equals 0 Contains a set of compressed beamforming feedback matrices as defined in 24.3.10.2 (Beamforming Feedback Matrix V) based on the channel measured during the training symbols of the received S1G NDP PPDU. N Y FORMAT is S1G and equals 0 and equals 1 Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and equals 0 and equals 1 Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M and equals 0 and equals 1 Not present N N FORMAT is S1G and is greater than 0 Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and is greater than 0 Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M and is greater than 0 Not present N N Otherwise See corresponding entry in Table 20-1 and Table 22-1. DELTA_SNR FORMAT is S1G and (CH_BANDWIDTH is CBW2 or CBW4 or CBW8 or Contains an array of delta SNR values as defined in 8.4.1.49 (MU Exclusive Beamforming Report field) based on the channel measured during the training symbols of the received S1G NDP PPDU. NOTE—In the RXVECTOR this parameter is present only for S1G NDP PPDUs for MU sounding. Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M Contains an array of delta SNR values as defined in 8.4.1.49 (MU Exclusive Beamforming Report field) based on the channel measured during the training symbols of the received S1G NDP PPDU. NOTE—In the RXVECTOR this parameter is present only for S1G NDP PPDUs for MU sounding. Y FORMAT is S1G SU and (CH_BANDWIDTH is CBW2 or CBW4 or CBW8 or CBW16) Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and MU_SU equals SU Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M Not present N N
FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M and AGGREGATION is AGGREGATED Indicates the packet duration in number of symbols in the S1G 1MHz Duplicate PSDU. Y Y Otherwise See corresponding entry in Table 20-1 and Table 22-1. PSDU_LENGTH FORMAT is S1G Indicates the number of octets in the S1G PSDU. A value of 0 indicates an S1G NDP PPDU Y Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M Indicates the number of octets in the S1G 2MHz Duplicate PSDU. A value of 0 indicates an S1G NDP PPDU. Y Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M Indicates the number of octets in the S1G 1MHz Duplicate PSDU. A value of 0 indicates an S1G NDP PPDU. Y Y Otherwise See corresponding entry in Table 20-1 and Table 22-1. NUM_STS FORMAT is S1G Indicates the number of space-time streams. Integer: range 1-4 per user in the TXVECTOR and 0-4 in the RXVECTOR. NUM_STS summed over all users is in the range 1 to 4 for MU-MIMO. Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M Indicates the number of space-time streams. Integer: range 1-4 per user in the TXVECTOR and 0-4 in the RXVECTOR. NUM_STS summed over all users is in the range 1 to 4 for MU-MIMO. Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M Indicates the number of space-time streams. Integer: 1-4 per user in the TXVECTOR and 0-4 in the RXVECTOR. Y Y Otherwise See corresponding entry in Table 20-1 and Table 22-1. GROUP_ID FORMAT is S1G and MU_SU equals MU Indicates the ID. Integer: range 0-63 (see )) Y Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and equals MU Indicates the ID. Integer: range 0-63 (see )) Y Y FORMAT is S1G and MU_SU equals SU Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and equals SU Not present N N
FORMAT is S1G and CH_BANDWIDTH equals CBW1 Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M Not present N N Otherwise See corresponding entry in Table 22-1. PARTIAL_AID FORMAT is S1G and MU_SU equals SU Provides an abbreviated indication of the intended recipient(s) of the PSDU (see 9.17b (Group ID, partial AID, UPLINK and Color in S1G PPDUs)). Integer: 0-511. Y Y FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and MU_SU equals SU Provides an abbreviated indication of the intended recipient(s) of the PSDU (see 9.17b (Group ID, partial AID, UPLINK and Color in S1G PPDUs)). Integer: range 0-511. Y Y FORMAT is S1G and equals MU Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and MU_SU equals MU Not present N N FORMAT is S1G and CH_BANDWIDTH equals CBW1 Not present N N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M Not present N N Otherwise See corresponding entry in Table 22-1. NUM_USERS FORMAT is S1Gand MU_SU equals MU Indicates the number of with non-zero space-time streams. Integer: range to 4. Y N FORMAT is S1G and MU_SU equals SU Set to 1 FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and MU_SU equals MU Indicates the number of users with non-zero space-time streams. Integer: range to 4. Y N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_2M and MU_SU equals SU Set to 1 FORMAT is S1G and CH_BANDWIDTH equals CBW1 Set to 1 Y N FORMAT is S1G_DUP_1M Set to 1 Y N