5162 10.3.2.4 115 38 Clarify that "HE RTS threshold" is in the HE Operation Parameters field as in comment Revised: See resolution of CID 5161 TGax editor to make the changes shown in this document under all headings containing CID 5162. Please apply throughout these CIDs. 5163 10.3.2.4a 115 46 Regarding "10.3.2.4a Duration-based RTS/CTS. In dense environments, managing RTS usage by an AP can help the overall interference situation since the AP may have better view of the network situation.", while this a good start in adding control by the AP over non-AP STAs other aspects of client management need to addressed. In an large, dense, managed ESS, the network has much better visibility into the best selection of AP and band that the client should initially associate with and then subsequently select during roaming. The network also needs to be able to control usage of probe request and probe response in an ESS in improve network efficiency. Add tighter management by the network of client association and roaming Rejected: Discussion: the commentor is suggesting new mechanisms of managing non-AP STA, outside the scope of this particular feature 5557 10.3.1 113 50 "When HE duration-based RTS is enabled, the use of the RTS/CTS mechanism is under control of I note that 'HE' is missing from the So presumeably any STA could use the duration based RTS threshold, but only an HE STA will advertize it. Is that the real intention? In looking at the HE duration based RTS threshold subfield in the HE Operation Parameter field it appears as though it is for an AP to make its STA use duration RTS. Is this intended only for HE STAs? Clarify if only HE STAs or not. Accepted: Add the word “HE” in front of the word “STA” TGax editor to make the changes shown in this document under all headings containing CID 5557. Please apply throughout these CIDs. 5560 10.3.2.4a 115 48 "In dense environments, managing RTS usage by an AP can help the overall interference situation since the AP may have better view Write a better reasoning as to why duration RTS is either superior or will improve matters. Rejected: Clause 10.22.3.5.3 in baseline spec has the text based
8349. Please apply throughout these CIDs. 8350 10.3.5 113 45 The procedure to disable HE duration-based RTS is not described. Unless the procedure is clearly defined, the draft should follow the existing RTS/CTS procedure. Remove the paragraph starting from lines 45 to line 48 Revised: The revised 10.3.2.4a has added the text of describing disable HE duration-based RTS TGax editor to make the changes shown in this document under all headings containing CID 8350. Please apply throughout these CIDs. 8351 10.3.1 113 50 The procedure to enable HE duration-based RTS is not described. Unless the procedure is clearly defined, the draft should follow the existing RTS/CTS procedure. Remove the paragraph starting from lines 50 to line 54 Revised: The revised 10.3.2.4a has added the text of describing enable HE duration-based RTS TGax editor to make the changes shown in this document under all headings containing CID 8351. Please apply throughout these CIDs. 9422 10.3.2.4a 115 50 It is unclear which "network situation" it is referring to. This sentence is also unnecessary. Please consider to remove or rephrase. Remove this sentence. Revised: Replace “network” with “interference” TGax editor to make the changes shown in this document under all headings containing CID 9422. Please apply throughout these CIDs. 9686 122 1 "When HE duration-based RTS is enabled, a non-AP STA using the DCF or EDCA shall use an RTS/CTS exchange for individually addressed frames when the duration of the TXOP is greater than the duration threshold indicated by When HE duration-based RTS is enabled, what is a rule of an AP STA? Probably, same rule should be used. Change it as the following: "When HE duration-based RTS is enabled, a STA using the DCF or EDCA shall use an RTS/CTS exchange..." As per comment. Rejected: Also the text in 10.3.5 already has the text as indicated by the comment. It intentionally written that Duration based RTS threshold is applied to HE STAs, not for HE AP STA. For HE AP STA, it should have the logic to use RTS/CTS based on implementation. AP