Texas RE NERC Standards Review Subcommittee No Florida Municipal Power Agency No ACES Power Marketing No SPP and Member companies No Comment Development SME List No Dairyland Power Cooperative No CenterPoint Energy No Hydro One No Ingleside Cogeneration LP No NIPSCO No Bay Cable No Consumers Energy Company No Bonneville Power Administration No Snohomish County PUD No Lakeland Electric No Tampa Electric Company No
Do you agree with the proposed definition of Control Center? Organization Yes or No NRG Energy Companies No PNGC Comment Group No Madison Gas and Electric Company No Duke Energy No Texas RE NERC Standards Review Subcommittee No Florida Municipal Power Agency No No ACES Power Marketing No IRC Standards Review Committee No National Rural Electric Cooperative Association (NRECA) No
POrtland General Electric No Exelon Corporation and its affiliates No Farmington Electric Utility System No Indiana Municipal Power Agency No Deseret Power No Central Lincoln No Brazos Electric Power Cooperative No Kansas City Power & Light No Northeast Power Coordinating Council Yes Southwest Power Pool Regional Entity Yes PPL Corporation NERC Registered Affiliates Yes MRO NSRF Yes Dominion Yes
Clallam County PUD No.1 Yes Ingleside Cogeneration LP Yes NIPSCO Yes Production Yes Independent Electricity System Operator Yes Trans Bay Cable Yes Lower Colorado River Authority Yes ATCO Electric Yes LCRA Transmission Services Corporation Yes Consumers Energy Company Yes Niagara Mohawk (dba National Grid) Yes National Grid Yes United Illuminating company Yes Turlock Irrigation District Yes
Bonneville Power Administration Yes Tampa Electric Company Yes Massachusetts Municipal Wholesale Electric Company Yes Tennessee Valley Authority Yes Ameren Yes ISO New England Inc. Yes Electric Delivery Company LLC Yes MEAG Power Yes Nebraska Public Power District Yes Utility Services Inc. Yes Alliant Energy Yes American Public Association Yes Springfield Utility Board Yes New York Authority Yes
Associated Electric Cooperative, Inc. (NCR01177, JRO00088) No Duke Energy No Texas RE NERC Standards Review Subcommittee No NCEMC No ACES Power Marketing No Southern Company Services, Inc. No National Electric Cooperative Association (NRECA) No Dairyland Power Cooperative No G&T - Transmission No CenterPoint Energy No Manitoba Hydro No Xcel Energy No Bonneville Power Administration No
MidAmerican Energy Company No Ameren No NextEra Energy, Inc. No Liberty Electric Power LLC No City of Austin dba Austin Energy No Nebraska Public Power District No Alliant Energy No Exelon Corporation and its affiliates No Deseret No Brazos Electric Cooperative No California Independent System Operator No Northeast Coordinating Council Yes NRG Energy Companies Yes
Turlock Irrigation District Yes Snohomish County PUD Yes Lakeland Electric Yes Electric Company Yes Illinois Municipal Electric Agency Yes NV Energy Yes Massachusetts Municipal Wholesale Electric Company Yes Tennessee Valley Authority Yes PSEG Yes Texas Reliability Entity Yes PJM Interconnection Yes ISO New England Inc. Yes Oncor Electric Delivery Company LLC Yes MEAG Power Yes POrtland General Electric Yes
Utility Services Inc. Yes American Public Power Association Yes Springfield Utility Yes New York Authority Yes Wiscsonsin Electric Power Company Yes Farmington Electric Utility System Yes City Utilities of Springfield, MO Yes Pacific Gas and Electric Company Yes Yes Central Lincoln Yes Cowlitz County PUD Yes Kansas City Power & Light Yes US Bureau of Reclamation Yes
4. Do you with the proposed definitions of BES Cyber System Information, CIP Exceptional Circumstances, and CIP Senior Manager? Organization Yes or No Southwest Pool Regional Entity No Madison Gas and Electric Company No MRO NSRF No Duke Energy No Texas RE NERC Standards Review Subcommittee No Florida Municipal Power Agency No Southern Company Services, Inc. No Dairyland Cooperative No CenterPoint Energy No Bay Cable No Manitoba Hydro No
Snohomish County PUD No Lakeland Electric No MidAmerican Energy Company No Illinois Municipal Electric Agency No Ameren No NextEra Energy, Inc. No City of Austin dba Austin Energy No Nebraska Public Power District No Alliant Energy No Exelon Corporation and its affiliates No California Independent System Operator No Northeast Power Coordinating Council Yes NRG Energy Companies Yes
PNGC Comment Group Yes PPL Corporation NERC Registered Affiliates Yes Dominion Yes Associated Electric Cooperative, Inc. (NCR01177, JRO00088) Yes FirstEnergy Yes Family Of Companies (FOC) including OPC, GTC & GSOC Yes NCEMC Yes ACES Power Marketing Yes SPP and Member companies Yes IRC Standards Review Committee Yes Comment Development SME List Yes Arizona Public Service Company Yes Salt River Project Yes
Exelon Corporation and its affiliates No Wiscsonsin Electric Power Company No Brazos Electric Power Cooperative No Kansas City & Light No California Independent System Operator No Southern California Edison Yes ATCO Electric Yes Northeast Power Coordinating Council Yes Southwest Power Pool Regional Entity Yes NRG Energy Companies Yes PNGC Comment Group Yes PPL Corporation NERC Registered Affiliates Yes Dominion Yes
Independent Electricity System Operator Yes Lower Colorado River Authority Yes LCRA Transmission Services Corporation Yes Consumers Energy Company Yes Manitoba Hydro Yes Niagara Mohawk (dba National Grid) Yes National Grid Yes Xcel Energy Yes Turlock Irrigation District Yes Snohomish County PUD Yes Tampa Electric Company Yes NV Energy Yes Massachusetts Municipal Wholesale Electric Company Yes Tennessee Valley Authority Yes
Northeast Power Coordinating Council No Southwest Power Pool Regional Entity No NRG Energy Companies No Madison Gas and Electric Company No MRO NSRF No FirstEnergy No Duke Energy No Florida Municipal Power Agency No SPP and Member companies No IRC Standards Review Committee No Southern California Edison No Dairyland Cooperative No Hydro One No NIPSCO No
City of Austin dba Austin Energy Yes Oncor Electric Delivery Company LLC Yes MEAG Power Yes POrtland General Electric Yes Utility Services Inc. Yes American Public Association Yes Springfield Utility Board Yes Farmington Electric Utility System Yes Pacific Gas and Electric Company Yes Deseret Power Yes Central Lincoln Yes Cowlitz County PUD Yes Brazos Electric Power Cooperative Yes
City Utilities of Springfield, MO No No California Independent System Operator No PNGC Comment Yes PPL Corporation NERC Registered Affiliates Yes MRO NSRF Yes Dominion Yes FirstEnergy Yes NCEMC Yes ACES Power Marketing Yes SPP and Member companies Yes IRC Standards Review Committee Yes Comment Development SME List Yes
Arizona Public Service Company Yes Southern Company Services, Inc. Yes Salt River Project Yes Southern California Edison Yes Dairyland Power Cooperative Yes Western Area Power Administration Yes Tri-State G&T - Transmission Yes Clallam County PUD No.1 Yes Ingleside Cogeneration LP Yes Hydro-QuÃ©bec Production Yes Independent Electricity System Operator Yes Trans Bay Cable Yes ATCO Electric Yes Consumers Energy Company Yes
MEAG Power Yes POrtland General Electric Yes Nebraska Public Power District Yes Alliant Energy Yes American Public Power Association Yes Springfield Utility Board Yes Exelon Corporation and its affiliates Yes Wiscsonsin Electric Power Company Yes Pacific Gas and Electric Company Yes Deseret Power Yes Central Lincoln Yes Cowlitz County PUD Yes Brazos Electric Power Cooperative Yes
as every device within the system is documented as to its capability for meeting that requirement. If this is not the intent of the SDT, this issue must be addressed along with the definitions, because it is at this fundamental level that the Standards may or may not be applicable. [2] NSRF recommends the addition of a definition for a “BES Site” to be described as: “A registered entity-owned geographic location that: (1) performs the functional obligations of the Reliability Coordinator, Balancing Authority, Generator Operator, Generator Owner, Interchange Coordinator, Reliability Coordinator, Transmission Operator, or Transmission Owner, including Control Centers, Backup Control Centers and associated data centers that support those functional obligations, and(2) contains UFLS or UVLS Systems that are part of a Load shedding program and Load-Serving Entity functional obligation, or(3) provides the protection or restoration of the BES while performing the functional obligations of Distribution Provider, or (4) provides Blackstart Resources, (and) that if rendered unavailable, degraded, or misused would, within 15 minutes of its required operation, mis-operation, or non-operation, adversely impact the reliability of the BES.” Associated Electric Cooperative, Inc. (NCR01177, JRO00088) [BES Cyber Asset, Definitions, p 1REPLACE: “, and is used for”WITH: “, and is only used for”RATIONALE: AECI agrees with other commenters on the need for this clarification.] NYISO o BES Cyber Asset definition from "it is directly connected to a Cyber Asset within an ESP" to "it is directly connected to a network, or to a Cyber Asset within an ESP" Alliant Energy Alliant Energy voted “No” on this list of definitions as we believe it is in fundamental conflict with the rest of the Standards. Proposed definitions herein should be considered within the context of the requirements, as well, due to considerable dependency between the proposed definitions and the proposed language changes throughout the rest of the Standards. Alliant Energy supports the MRO NSRF comments, as well.[1]Alliant Energy’s recommendations on these definitions are predicated by our position that CIP-002-5 is fundamentally flawed, and the proposed methodology prescribed by Requirement 1 is in direct conflict with the structure of the definition for BES Cyber Asset and BES Cyber System. More specifically, the impact
Lower Colorado River Authority Yes ATCO Electric Yes LCRA Transmission Services Corporation Yes Niagara Mohawk (dba National Grid) Yes National Grid Yes Xcel Energy Yes Bonneville Power Administration Yes Lakeland Electric Yes Electric Company Yes Illinois Municipal Electric Agency Yes NV Energy Yes Tennessee Valley Authority Yes Ameren Yes PSEG Yes
Liberty Electric Power LLC Yes PJM Interconnection Yes City of Austin dba Austin Energy Yes Oncor Electric Delivery Company LLC Yes MEAG Power Yes POrtland General Electric Yes American Public Association Yes Wiscsonsin Electric Power Company Yes Farmington Electric Utility System Yes City Utilities of Springfield, MO Yes Pacific Gas and Electric Company Yes Deseret Power Yes Central Lincoln Yes