Uzbekistan (2015) 1 17 Georgia (2014) 1 25 Bosnia and Herzegovina (2017) 1 24 Uzbekistan (2015) 1 26 Yemen (2012) 1 12 Uzbekistan (2010) 3 Positive aspect Bulgaria (2011), Russia (2009), Moldova (2009) Overview of the themes discussed per article Article ICCPR Subject of the Observation Country Year 12 Freedom of movement : corruption in registration system (propiska) Uzbekistan 2010 26 (+2,14) Endemic corruption in judiciary Yemen 2012 24 (+6, 8) Widespread corruption in cotton sector, forced labour, protection of children Uzbekistan 2015 25 (+2) Corruption among public officials – no effective participation in public life Bosnia and Herzegovina 2017 17 (+2, 7, 9, 14) Effective remedy to victims of human rights Georgia 2014
Corruption within penitentiary institutions, detainees access to privileges Bulgaria 2011 7 Investigation by corruption department is not concluded Poland 2010 Effective remedy for victims of human rights violations, no impunity for corruption Georgia 2014 Corruption within prison facilities Azerbaijan 2016 ONLY 2 Corruption has negative impact on the enjoyment of rights Macedonia 2008 Corruption has negative impact on the enjoyment of rights Chad 2009 Mandate of commission against corruption China, Macao 2013 2 + 14 See article 14 + 2 2 in with other articles Corruption among public officials – no effective participation in public life (art. 25) Bosnia and Herzegovina 2017 Effective remedy for victims of human rights violations, no Georgia 2014
impunity for corruption (art. 7, 9, 14, 17) Endemic corruption in judiciary (art. 14, 26) 2012 Investigation by corruption department is not concluded (art. 7, 9) Poland 2010 ONLY 14 Corruption in judiciary, independence, appointment, body for promotion Turkmenistan 2017 Endemic and systematic corruption in judiciary, appointment Moldova 2016 Endemic and systematic corruption in judiciary, appointment Jamaica 2016 Persistent corruption and public mistrust of judicial authorities Burkina Faso 2016 Lack of independence judiciary because corruption Côte d’Ivoire 2015 Numerous allegations of corruption within judiciary, independence Cambodia 2015 Lack of independence judiciary Kyrgyzstan 2014
trafficking cases) Persistent corruption within justice system, lack of public trust and no results of combat against corruption Bulgaria 2011 Corruption, lack of transparency and independence judiciary Mongolia 2011 Challenges in administration of justice : high levels of corruption Moldova 2009 Corruption within judiciary Azerbaijan 2009 Extent of corruption and interference with independence judges Tchad 2009 Lack of training judges, corruption Rwanda 2009 Independence judiciary, judicial corruption Georgia 2007 14 + 2 Independence, especially because of appointment, corruption, safeguards Azerbaijan 2016 Independence, especially because selection, Kazakhstan 2016
disciplining, corruption, etc. Shortcomings administration of justice : corruption, resources, appointment, etc. Benin 2015 Corruption in legal aid and administration of justice Indonesia 2013 Corruption in judiciary not investigated goes against independence and legitimacy of judges Paraguay 2013 Widespread corruption in judiciary, independence, appointment Turkmenistan 2012 Widespread corruption in judiciary, independence, appointment Kazakhstan 2011 Independence, appointment because of corruption Russian Federation 2009 14 in with other articles Effective remedy for victims of human rights violations, no impunity for corruption (art. 2, 7, 9, 17) Georgia 2014 Independence, widespread corruption in judiciary (art. 7, 9) Tajikistan 2013
15 Armenia 2012 2, 11, 16 X X Detention Take measures (vague) 16 Bulgaria 2011 2, 13 X X Judiciary Good 17 Positive aspect - Strategy - 18 Paraguay 2011 2, 10, 12 X X Detention 19 Turkmenistan 2011 2, 11, 12, 16 X Detention 20 Cambodia 2011 Positive aspect - Ratification - 21 Positive aspect - Anti-corruption law adopted - 22 2, 10, 12 X X Judiciary, law enforcement, public service Good 23 Austria 2010 2, 11 X X Detention Mandate info 24 Cameroon 2010 2, 11, 16 X X Detention Take measures (vague), data 25 Nicaragua 2009 2, 13 X X Judiciary, police Take measures (vague) 26 Chad 2009 2, 13, 14 X X Judiciary, police Take measures (vague), data 27 11, 16 X X Detention Take measures (vague) 28 2009 2, 11 X X Police Penalties 29 Indonesia 2008 Positive aspect - Eradication of corruption commission - 30 X X Judiciary Take measures (vague) 31 Benin 2008 2, 12 X X Judiciary, police Take measures (vague), data 32 11, 16 X X Detention Take measures (vague) 33 Burundi 2014 X Judiciary Snaction 34 Guinea 2014 X Detention Take measures 35 2013 X Police Investigate 36 Mexico 2012 X Security forces Investigate CRC Country Year Subject Content recommendation 1. Pakistan 2016 X X Inspectors child labour Vague 2. Nepal 2016 X X Allocation of resources to children (corruption hinders children’s rights) 3. Kenya 2016 X X Allocation of resources to Take measures, investigate
20. Tajikistan 2015 X 2.1 Pervasive (public sector), refers to Transparency International X Transparency, awareness, implement laws strictly 21. Gambia 2015 X 2.1 Pervasive (public sector) X Transparency, awareness, implement laws strictly 22. Paraguay 2015 X 2.1 General X Root causes, Transparency, awareness, impunity 23. Slovenia 2014 X 2.1 General X Root causes, transparency, more resources, protection 24. Montenegro 2014 X 2.1 General (construction, education, helath care, public procurement, no investigations, intimidation) X Root causes, investigate, protection, evaluate 25. Vietnam 2014 X 2.1 General (no convictions) X Root causes, transparency, protection, implement laws strictly 26. Nepal 2014 X 2.1 General X Root causes, transparency, protection, implement laws strictly 27. Romania 2014 X 2.1 Available resources, no EU (social, health, education) X Transparency, awareness, implement laws strictly, protection 28. X 2.1 General (low salaries) X Investigate, awareness, salaries 29. X 12 Health care fees) X Take measures 30. Armenia 2014 Positive aspect - Ratification UNCAC - - 31. X 2.1 General X Investigate, awareness 32. Serbia 2014 Positive aspect - Action adopted - - 33. Indonesia 2014 X 2.1 No resources, rights violations, no redress X Evaluate measures taken 34. China 2014 X 2.1 Widespread (provincial and municipal X Transparency, awareness, implement laws strictly 35. Uzbekistan 2014 X 2.1 General (access to health, education, X Adopt laws, transparency,
50. Cameroon 2012 X 2 General X Authority against corruption, take measures 51. Russia 2011 X 2.1 General X Resources, national plan, monitoring mechanism 52. Sri Lanka 2010 X Judiciary, bodies 53. X 2.1 General X Implement laws strictly, awareness, help from international organisations 54. X 9 Social security (disadvantaged groups) 55. Kazakhstan 2010 X Judiciary X Combat corruption, 56. X Housing X Monitor, take statistics 57. Mauritius 2010 X 12 Drug trafficking X Combat corruption 58. Afghanistan 2010 X General (no prosecutions) X Adopt law, investigate, transparency, guidelines, awareness 59. Algeria 2010 X 2.1 General X Authority against corruption, train, awareness, transparency 60. Colombia 2010 X 11, 12 Drug production and trafficking X Enhance programme, investigate 61. DRC 2009 X Justice system X Train, awareness, combat corruption, salaries, transparency, implement agreement 62. X Authority against corruption and agreement not implemented yet 63. X HRDs stigmatized 64. Chad 2009 X 2.1 General X Train, awareness, investigate 65. X Justice system
66. Madagascar 2009 X 2.1 General X Awareness, transparency, adopt laws, train 67. Angola 2009 X 2.1 General X Train, adopt laws, implement laws strictly, transparency, guidelines 68. X Justice system 69. Cambodia 2009 X Judiciary X Adopt laws, implement laws strictly, investigate, train 70. Philippines 2008 X 2.1 General X Investigate, train, awareness, implement laws strictly 71. Kenya 2008 X 2.1 General (few prosecutions) X Investigate, train, awareness, implement laws strictly 72. India 2008 X 11 Access to food 73. Latvia 2008 X 2.1 General (police, judiciary) X Authority against corruption, take measures 74. Morocco 2015 X 2.1 General X Awareness, protection 75. Montenegro 2014 X 12 Health care X Take measures 76. Equatorial Guinea 2012 2.1 General X Transparency, awareness, implement laws strictly 77. Yemen 2011 9 Social security system X Take measures 78. Afghanistan 2010 Land allocation X Monitoring mechanism