De Montfort University 3 3b University of East London 2 3a 3a Kingston University 2 2.00 London Guildhall University/London Metropolitan University 2 3b 3a 2.25 Manchester Metropolitan University 2 3a 3a 1.70 University of Northumbria at Newcastle 2 2 3b Nottingham Trent University 1 2 University of Portsmouth 2 3a Staffordshire University 2 2 Thames Valley University 1 1994-65 to 1996-97 1997-98 to 2001-02 2002-03 to 2008-09 2009-10 to 2012-13 Total Amount of QR Funding £ £ £ £ Total Amount of QR Funding for New Universities £1,631,006 £1,514,041 £77,619 £431,472 Percentage of QR Funding for New Universities 3.2 2.7 0.1 0.6 Notes: 1The research rating scores for the 2008 RAE are derived by multiplying the percentage of research activity by its corresponding quality level and then summing—see Appendix IV APPENDIX IV Proportion of Diamond List Publications in RAE-Submissions in 1992, 2001 and 2008 Name 1992 Research Ratings1 Diamond List Publications in Total RAE 2001 Research Ratings Diamond List Publication in RAE Submissions 2001 (%) 2008 Research Ratings2 Diamond List Publication in total RAE Submissions 2008 (%)
Metropolitan University Kingston University 2.00 Manchester Metropolitan University 3a 15 1.70 0 University of Newcastle 4 36 4 26 University of Reading 4 8 University of Bath 3 13 De Montfort University 3 0 University of Durham 3 0 4 38 University of Hull 3 13 University of East London 2 0 3a 15 University of Staffordshire 2 0 University of Salford 2 5 Keele University 3a 14 University of Liverpool 4 21 University of Northumbria 3b 8 RAE Submissions 18 (840) 28 (2789)3 39 (2604)5 All Journal and Similar Submissions 31 (500) 32 (2493)4 44 (2357)6 1Source: Twenty-one 1992 RAE Economic Departments Publications Submissions Collected by John R. Presely in 1993-1994. Copies in the possession of the author (Lee). 2The research rating scores for the 2008 RAE are derived by multiplying the percentage of research activity by its corresponding quality level and then summing. For example, for Birkbeck College, it is the following: (.2)(4) + (.5)(3) + (.25)(2) + (.05)(1) = 2.85. 3Total number of 2001 submissions to the RAE Economics and Econometrics Panel 4Total number of 2001 journal submissions to the RAE Economics and Econometrics Panel. 5Total number of 2008 submissions to the RAE Economics and Econometrics Panel. 6Total number of 2008 journal submissions to the RAE Economics and Econometrics Panel.
APPENDIX V Distribution of Undergraduate and Post-graduate Students Among Research and Non-Research Among Universities 1992 RAE Ranking (1994-1995 Student Enrollment Information) Number of Universities Number of Postgraduate Research Number of Postgraduate Taught Number of First Degree1 % Share of Postgraduate Research % of Postgraduate Taught % Share of First Degree Research Rating-5 10 775 1,010 3,855 45.30 38.60 21.90 Research Rating-4 9 410 555 2,590 24.00 21.20 14.70 Research Rating-3 14 265 525 3,700 15.50 20.10 21.00 Research Rating-2 9 115 260 2,795 6.70 9.90 15.90 Research Rating-1 4 5 0 695 0.30 0.00 3.90 Non-Research Universities 25 140 265 3,975 8.20 10.20 22.60 Total 71 1,710 2,615 17,610 100.00 100.00 100.00 1996 RAE Ranking (1997-1998 Student Enrollment Information) Number of Universities Number of Postgraduate Research Number of Postgraduate Taught Number of First Degree1 % Share of Postgraduate Research % Share of Postgraduate Taught % Share of First Degree Research Rating-5* 3 320 460 1,585 16.41 16.20 9.00 Research Rating-5 10 650 805 3,565 33.33 28.35 20.20 Research Rating-4 11 525 520 3,385 26.92 18.31 19.10 Research Rating-3a 9 140 195 2,515 7.18 6.87 14.20 Research Rating-3b 2 20 95 325 1.03 3.35 1.80 Research Rating-2 3 15 45 795 0.77 1.58 4.50 Research Rating-1 0 0 0 0 0.00 0.00 0.00
Non-Research Universities 41 245 665 7,300 19.00 14.60 31.50 Total 69 1,290 4,555 23,210 100.00 100.00 100.00 2008 RAE Ranking (2010-2011 Student Enrollment Information) Number of Universities Number of Postgraduate Research Number of Postgraduate Taught Number of First Degree % Share of Postgraduate Research % Share of Postgraduate Taught % Share of First Degree 3.55-3.35 5 365 1,175 3,930 30.30 23.80 16.10 3.15-2.95 8 270 1,200 5,345 22.40 24.30 21.80 2.90-2.45 12 340 1,650 5,935 28.20 33.40 24.20 2.25-1.70 3 25 150 1,250 2.10 3.10 5.10 Non-Research Universities 40 205 810 8,020 17.00 16.40 32.80 Total 68 1,205 4,940 24,480 100.00 100.00 100.00 2008 RAE Ranking (2011-2012 Student Enrollment Information) Number of Universities Number of Postgraduate Research Number of Postgraduate Taught Number of First Degree % Share of Postgraduate Research % Share of Postgraduate Taught % Share of First Degree 3.55-3.35 5 410 1,235 4,090 31.90 23.90 16.10 3.15-2.95 8 285 1,080 5,550 22.20 20.90 21.80 2.90-2.45 12 335 2,025 6,110 26.10 39.00 24.00 2.25-1.70 3* 10 50 905 0.80 1.00 3.60 Non-Research Universities 38 245 785 8,800 19.00 15.20 34.50
Oxford Economic Papers X X Quarterly Journal of Economics X X X X Rand Journal of Economics X X X Review of Economics and Statistics X X X X X Review of Economic Studies X X X X X X X X 1One Diamond List journals was not mentioned and hence is not included: Brookings Papers B – University of Bristol BC – Birkbeck College BI – University of Birmingham BR – Brunel University EA – University of East Anglia ES – University of Essex EX – University of Exeter KE – Keele University LEI – University of Leicester LI – University of Liverpool LO – Loughborough University LSE – London School of Economics M – University of Manchester NE – University of Newcastle NO – University of Nottingham QM – Queen Mary, University of London RH – Royal Holloway, University of London SH – University of Sheffield SU - University of Sussex SUR – University of Surrey UCL – University of College London W – University of Warwick Drawn from the RA5a – Research Environment and Esteem section of the 2001 and 2008 RAE submission: see . see .
(for research-rated submissions in economics) Number of Universities Number of Staff2 Number of Economists Submitted Number of Heterodox Economists Number of Heterodox Submissions Number of History of Economic Thought and Methodology Submissions Submissions Number of Universities with No Heterodox Economists in their Submissions Research Rating-5* 4 142.8 147 2 9 3 559 2 Research Rating-5 9 279.2 294 14 25 5 1107 5 Research Rating-4 11 183.5 192 9 17 15 686 8 Research Rating-3a/b 9 112.6 116 19 22 11 437 3 33 718.2 749 44 73 32 2789 18 1Derived from the submissions to the 2001 RAE: . 2Taken from “2001 Research Assessment Exercise, Unit of Assessment: 38 Economics and Econometrics.” . 2001 RAE1 (for research-rated heterodox submissions outside of economics by heterodox economists)
Number of Universities with Submissions in Economics Number of Universities with Heterodox Submissions outside of Economics Number of Heterodox Economists in Business and Management Studies Number of Heterodox Economists in Social Policy and Administration Number of Heterodox Economists in Geography Number of Heterodox Economists in Other Assessment Areas Number of Heterodox Economics Submissions Number of History of Economic Thought and Methodology Submissions Research Rating-5* 4 1 - - - 1 2 - Research Rating-5 9 3 8 - - 4 12 - Research Rating-4 11 1 - 1 1 - 1 - Research Rating-3a/b 9 1 1 1 - - 1 - Research Universities - 15 29 4 12 5 96 2 Total 33 21 38 6 13 10 112 2 1Derived from the submissions to the 2001 RAE: . 2008 RAE1 (for research-rated submissions in economics)
Number of Universities Number of Staff2 Number of Economists Submitted with Publications Number of Heterodox Economists Number of Heterodox Submissions Number of History of Economic Thought Submissions Total Submissions Number of Universities with No Heterodox Economists in Submissions Research 5 235.91 246 13 2 0 817 4 Research 8 225.75 227 5 6 7 807 5 Research 12 239.83 257 7 12 10 905 7 Research 3 16.75 19 7 7 9 75 1 Total 28 718.24 749 20 27 26 2604 17 1Derived from the submissions to the 2008 RAE: . 2Taken from “RAE 2008 Quality Profiles: UOA 34 Economics and Econometrics.” . 3This economist actually died just after the closing date for submissions. 2008 RAE1 (for research-rated heterodox submissions outside of economics by economists)
Number of Universities Number of Universities with Heterodox Submissions outside of Economics Number of Heterodox Economists in Business and Management Studies Number of Heterodox Economists in Development Studies Number of Heterodox Economists in Sociology Number of Heterodox Economists in Other Assessment Areas Number of Heterodox Economics Submissions Number of History of Economic Thought and Methodology Submissions Research 5 2 1 2 1 1 4 0 Research 8 3 8 1 1 1 12 4 Research 12 10 6 1 0 1 15 0 Research 3 3 1 0 0 0 1 4 Other Research Universities - 21 32 14 5 4 94 10 28 39 48 18 7 7 130 18 1Derived from the submissions to the 2008 RAE: .
APPENDIX X 2001, 2008, and 2014 Economics Panels Members: RAE/REF Submission and Professional Characteristics 2001 Research Assessment Exercise Economics Panel Name Diamond List Journal Submissions on submissions to 2001 RAE) Heterodox Submissions (based on submissions to 2001 RAE) Other Submissions (based on submissions to 2001 RAE) RES Leadership Positions Managing/ Associate Editor of the Economic Journal CHUDE Steering Committee Managing/ Associate Editor of a Diamond List Journal ESRC Activities Other D. Greenaway (chair) (Nottingham) 3 0 1 X X X X P. Arestis (South Bank) 2 0 0 X X X QAA1 J. Beath (St. Andrews) 0 0 4 X X X QAA1 R. Blundell (UCL) 3 0 1 X Emet, JEmet, REStud A. Booth (Essex) 4 0 0 X X M. Desai (LSE) 0 3 1 X N. Ireland (Warwick) 1 0 3 X QAA1 V. A. Muscatelli (Glasgow) 4 0 0 X X D. Osborn (Manchester) 0 0 4 X X X QAA1 C. Propper (Bristol) 1 0 3 X
2008 Research Assessment Exercise Economics Name Diamond List Journal Submissions (based on submissions to 2008 RAE) Heterodox Submissions (based on submissions to 2008 RAE) Other Submissions (based on submissions to 2008 RAE) RES Leadership Positions Managing/ Associate Editor of the Economic Journal Steering Committee Managing/ Associate Editor of a Diamond List Journal ESRC Activities D. Osborn (chair) (Manchester) 1 0 3 X X X X QAA1, QAA2 D. Blackaby (Swansea) 2 0 2 X X QAA1, QAA2 S. Broadberry (Warwick) 0 0 4 A. Carruth (Kent) 2 0 2 X X QAA1, QAA2 J. Dutta 2 0 2 X S. Ghatak (Kingston) 0 0 4 C. Leith (Glasgow) 4 0 0 P. (Oxford) 4 0 0 X X Emet, Ecca, EER, REStud, JIE C. Pissarides (LSE) 3 0 1 X X Ecca J. Thomas (Edinburgh) 3 0 1 X