Cao Lanh Bridge Construction INK042 Joint Independent Progress Report Mid-cycle evaluation to evaluate progress 2016 Joint Donors' Support for RWSS NTP Phase 3 INJ128 Independent Evaluation End of project evaluation to assess results June 2016 Restructuring for a more Competitive Vietnam INL354 DFAT-led evaluation Mid-term review June 2016 Community Based Disaster Risk Management INK120 Independent evaluation Mid-term review October 2015
Investment name Approved budget and duration Overall rating Relevance Effectiveness Efficiency Monitoring and Evaluation Sustainability Gender equality Risks and Safeguards Support Program to Respond to Climate Change $14,000,000 2011-2015 4 5 4 4 5 4 3 4 Vietnam Climate Change NGOs Partnership $15,073,305 2012 - 2016 5 6 5 5 5 5 5 5 Vietnam Delivering Better Health $14,897,501 2007 - 2015 4 4 4 3 3 5 4 4 Vietnam Clinton Health Access Initiative Phase III $4,650,000 2012 - 2015 5 4 4 5 5 4 5 5 Definitions of rating scale: Satisfactory (4, 5 and 6) = 6 = Very good; satisfies criteria in all or almost all areas = 5 = Good; satisfies criteria in most areas = 4 = Adequate; on balance, satisfies criteria; does not fail in any major area Less than satisfactory (1, 2 and 3) = 3 = Less than adequate; on balance does not satisfy criteria but does not fail in any area = 2 = Poor; does not satisfy criteria in major areas = 1 = Very poor; does not satisfy criteria in many major areas Annex E – Performance Assessment Frameworks Aid Objective: Improvement in the quality of Vietnam’s human resources Strategy Objective Indicators / Targets 2015 Progress Targets/Milestones 2010 2011 2012/13 2013/14 2014/15 1,380 scholarships and 300 fellowships delivered 225 ADS scholarships provided Australian Development Scholarships (ADS) (225) 225 Australia Awards Scholarships 225 Australia Awards Scholarships 150 AAS 50 AAF
Increase in number and strength of institutional links between public sector institutions Increased contribution of scholarship alumni and institutional links to meeting Vietnam development challenges 16 ALA scholarships 30-50 ALA fellowships Undertake stocktake of current public institutional linkages between Aust and Vietnam Identify role of PLSP and take steps to establish larger program if required. Australian Leadership Awards (20) scholarships (ALAS) Australian Leadership Awards (50–60) fellowships Complete tracer study Undertake Australian Development Scholarships mid-term review Begin Public Sector Linkages Program Finalise delivery strategy 18 Australia Awards Leadership Program 50 to 60 Australia Awards Fellowships Update monitoring and evaluation framework Complete an institutional impact assessment of scholarships program on key central government agencies Commence delivery strategy 100 Australia Awards Fellowships Australia Awards Scholarships Equity of Access Fund established Cluster studies on the environment and education sectors. Impact on the overall Australia Awards Scholarships program. Sponsor a National Alumni Conference for Vietnamese graduates of Australia HRD Strategy finalised 40 Heads of TVET Centres of Excellence Colleges trained in a short course in Australia Australia Awards alumni network established Design of new resource development investment completed Aid Objective: Better transport infrastructure and policy to support economic integration Strategy Objective Indicators / Targets 2015 Progress Targets/Milestones 2010 2011 2012/13 2013/14 2014/15 total km of road and bridge works connecting Mekong communities to markets higher traffic volume, lower operating costs and travel time on 60km of rural road constructed (MTRIP) SSC construction commence mid-year An additional 48km to be completed (MTRIP) 30% of civil works completed (Southern Coastal Corridor) of 415km of rural road will be completed (MTRIP) (additional 179km) 50% of civil work will be completed by end June 2013 71% of civil works completed (SSC) Civil works commenced on Cao Lanh bridge. Civil works complete (SSC) 40 % of Cao Lanh bridge construction complete (No construction due to physical resettlement).
targeted transport corridors Adverse social and environmental impacts are managed effectively evidence-based policy approaches enhance opportunities and address challenges associated with economic integration Cao Lanh signing of statement of principles evidence based approaches to market reform (BWTO) Cao Lanh detailed design and supervision contract signed and implementation started Social safeguards applied consistently Evidence of greater HIV/trafficking awareness Evidence based approaches (land law, urban-rural migration) Cao Lanh Detailed design finalised evidence of the recommendations of the three and five year reviews of economic integration funded under the program being reflected in the new government resolution on economic integration Resettlement plans are implemented according to plan. Construction environmental management plans are developed and implemented Evidence based approach to drafting the land law in area of transparent land governance (including mechanisms for land register to be accessible to the public and to improve community participation in land administration and management) Income restoration programs being implemented effectively. Construction environmental management are implemented and monitored Australian supported studies and consultations used to revise enterprise law to reduce of private business entry and to improve corporate governance. Australian supported studies and consultations informing development planning (including the new SEDP) to improve private sector development and productivity growth. Aid Objective: Increase rural access to clean water and hygienic sanitation Strategy Objective Indicators / Targets 2015 Progress Targets/Milestones 2010 2011 2012/13 2013/14 2014/15 85% rural water access target 70% rural sanitation access target Clean water access 83% Hygienic sanitation access 65% pipe scheme target 2010 (NTP II) pipe water quality issue addressed (NTP II) Water and sanitation targets (available March) Water and sanitation targets: 80% of rural population has access to hygienic water, 57% to hygienic latrines, 88% of rural primary schools, 92% of commune clinics have access to hygienic water and hygienic latrine Water and sanitation targets: 82% of rural population has access to hygienic water 60% to hygienic latrines, 318 of rural primary schools, 92 % of commune clinics have access to hygienic water and hygienic latrine Provide support to four provinces to equip and upgrade the water testing laboratories 83% of the population having access to hygienic water, 63% of rural household having access to hygienic latrines, 95% of rural primary schools and commune clinics have access to hygienic water and hygienic latrine.