Describe Tim Zenk’s suggestions for future policy changes. Identify a positive and a negative reaction to these suggestions. Appendix F: Team PSA Rubric Name: _____________________________Date: _________________Period: ______ Team Name: _________________________________________________________________ 4 3 2 1 Length of infomercial PSA is 4 minutes or 6 minutes total. All members are featured. PSA is 4 minutes or 6 minutes total. All members are featured. PSA is 3 minutes or 7 minutes All members are featured. PSA is 2 or less minutes or more than 7 minutes – OR- not all members are featured. Organization The team presents a claim and findings, emphasizing 3 points on the importance of algae as a sustainable biofuel. The team presents a claim and findings, emphasizing 3 points on the importance of algae as a sustainable biofuel. The team presents claims and findings emphasizing 2 points on the importance of algae as a sustainable biofuel. The team presents claims and findings emphasizing less than 2 points on the importance of algae as a sustainable biofuel. Relevancy Ideas are focused, and include all of the following: Relevant evidence Valid reasoning Well-chosen details are focused, and include all of the following: Relevant evidence Valid reasoning Well-chosen details Ideas are focused, and include 3 of the following: Relevant evidence. Valid reasoning. Well-chosen details. Ideas are confusing, but include 2 of the following: Relevant evidence Valid reasoning Well-chosen details.
3 2 1 Introduction Missing one of the following: Problem Statement, background research, and defined objectives and constraints Missing 2 of the following: Problem Statement, background research, and defined objectives and constraints Missing 3 or more of the following: Problem Statement, background research, and defined objectives and constraints Design Selection Includes 4 design sketches Includes 3 design sketches Includes less than 3 design sketches Final Design Includes final photo/ sketch of prototype, dimensions, and materials used Missing one of the following: final photo/ sketch of prototype, dimensions, and materials used, Missing 2 or more of the following: final photo/ sketch of prototype, dimensions, and materials used, Technical Aspects Includes a description of the use of math, science and engineering principles used in design Missing one of the following descriptions of the use of math, science and engineering principles used in design Missing 2 or more of the following descriptions of the use of math, science and engineering principles used in design Results Includes 3 chart and/ or graph combinations Includes 2 chart and/ or graph combinations Includes one chart and/or graph combination Conclusions Includes: an evaluation of the final design, how well the final design failed to meet the objectives, and summary of key findings Missing one of the following: an evaluation of the final design, how well the final design met objectives, and summary of key findings Missing 2 or more of the following: an evaluation of the final design, how well the final design met objectives, and summary of key findings Includes: 3 recommendations, a potential redesign of prototype, and examples of future use of prototype Missing one of the following: 3 recommendations, a potential redesign of prototype, and examples of future use of prototype Missing 2 or more of the following: 3 recommendations, a potential redesign of prototype, and examples of future use of prototype References Includes: 2 book references, 2 journal article references and one website. NO WIKIPEDIA Missing one of the following: 2 book references, 2 journal article references and one website. NO WIKIPEDIA Missing 2 or more of the following: 2 book references, 2 journal article references and one website. –or- uses Wikipedia as a cited source. Appendix I-2: “Is the Fuel of the Future?” Article Analysis Answer KEY What is the name of the LaJolla, California based company announcing the production of 100 million gallons of diesel & jet fuel a year by 2018 and 1 billion gallons a year by 2020? Sapphire Energy