Individual Written Report Rubric Criteria Superior Satisfactory Developing Accuracy of Subject Matter 30 points All information included in report is 100% accurate. 20 points Information included in report is at least 90% accurate. 10 points Information included in report is less than 90% accurate. Alignment with Problem Statement 20 points Each solution must align with all conditions presented in the problem statement with 100% accuracy. 15 points One solution aligns with all conditions. The second solution lines up with three of the four conditions. 5 points Neither solution aligns with all conditions. Required Components 40 points The report contains the following: The group’s problem statement. A description of 30 points The report contains the following: A description of sound is explained with at least 2 10 points The report contains less information than what is described in the “Satisfactory” level.
sound is explained with at least 3 accurate scientific facts. Calculations of decibel levels are 100% accurate. An explanation of how sound affects hearing includes at least 2 accurate facts. Two different solutions. Four reasons for choosing one solution over the other. accurate scientific facts. Calculations of decibel levels are at least 90% accurate. An explanation of how sound affects hearing includes at least 1 accurate fact. Two different solutions. Four reasons for choosing one solution over the other. Mechanics 10 points The report contains no grammatical errors such as capitalization, spelling, punctuation, or subject-verb agreement. 7 points The report contains 1-3 grammatical errors. 3 points The report contains more than 3 grammatical errors. Scoring Conversion Guide A 90 – 100 B 80 – 89 C 70 – 79 D 60 – 69 F Less than 60
Oral Presentation Rubric Teacher Name: Student Name: ________________________________________ Grading scale Exemplary 4 points Proficient 3 points Approaching 2 points Needs Development 1 point Content Accuracy Student is 100% accurate on content accuracy, Student is 90- 99% accurate in content accuracy The student is 70-89 % accurate in content accuracy Student is less than 70% accurate in content accuracy. Comprehension Student is able to answer questions from an audience member citing 2 accurate scientific facts. Student is able to answer questions from an audience member citing at least one accurate scientific fact. Student is able to answer questions from an audience member but includes no accurate scientific facts. Student is unable to accurately answer questions posed from an audience member. Quality of Student justifies Student justifies Student includes No justification
Justification group’s best solution with 2 accurate scientific facts. group’s best solution with at least 1 accurate scientific fact. no accurate scientific fact to justify group’s best solution. is provided by student. Volume Volume is loud enough to be heard by all audience members throughout the presentation. Volume is loud enough to be heard by all audience members at least 90% of the time. Volume is loud enough to be heard by all audience members at least 80% of the time. Volume often too soft to be heard by less than 80% audience members. Reflection Survey Student answers all reflection questions. Students answers at least 90% of reflection questions. Student answers at least 80% of reflection questions. Student answers less than 80% of reflection questions. Scoring Guide: A: 17-20 points B: 15-16 points C: 11-14 points D: 5-10 points F: less than 5 points