units had significant environmental integrity concerns and may not have been linked to real greenhouse gas reductions.” (Waikato Regional Council, 03007) “…the Government’s allowance of cheap international units undermined the opportunity for NZ to establish a forestry-based carbon mitigation platform.” (Ngāti Hine Forestry Trust, 00066) Table 4: Submitter positions – If international units are eligible for NZ ETS compliance in the 2020s, should any of the following restrictions be placed on their use? Qualitative and quantitative restrictions Qualitative restriction Quantitative restriction No restrictions Unsure/ unclear Agriculture 2 1 0 2 4 9 Business groups 3 0 0 0 0 3 Electricity 1 4 0 1 1 7 Forestry 21 9 2 0 9 41 Individual 11 11 10 0 22 54 Industrial processors 2 2 0 4 1 9 Iwi/Māori 3 1 0 0 3 7 Liquid fossil fuels (transport) 1 1 0 0 3 5 Local government 0 4 1 0 0 5 NGO and community groups 4 4 3 0 1 12 Research and tertiary organisations 3 1 2 0 3 9 Stationary energy (excluding electricity) 1 1 0 4 2 8 Waste sector 3 4 0 1 0 8 Wood processors and manufacturers 0 1 0 0 0 1 Other 7 2 1 0 2 12 TOTAL 62 46 19 12 51 190 Figure 3: Submitter positions – If international units are eligible for NZ ETS compliance in the 2020s, should any of the following restrictions be placed on their use? Auctioning Auctioning mechanisms are primarily used as a way to efficiently distribute units to participants and ensure the number of units circulating reflects the emissions cap on the scheme and/or the national emissions reduction target. They can also be used to influence unit prices by controlling the supply of units.
Federated Farmers of New Zealand Federation of Maori Authorities Fitzsimons, Jeanette 00030 Fletcher Building Limited 00051 Flightworks 00108 Fonterra Co-operative Group Forest & Wood Action Group 05016 Forest Management Limited Forest Management NZ Limited 05007 Dave (Victoria University Wellington) 02000 Fursdon, Sonia 02019 Futures Committee of the Religious Society of Friends (Quakers) of Aotearoa New Zealand Geddes, Patrick 02035 Generation Zero Genesis Energy 00053 Gibbons Holdings Limited 00130 Gifford, Murray Gilmore, Shannon 02043 Graeme, Basil and Anne 00164 Graeme, Kate 02053 Graymont Greater Wellington Regional Council 00197 Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand 00124 Guardians of New Zealand Superannuation 00077 Gull New Zealand Limited 03009 Hall, David 05010 Hall, Peter William Harbour Head 05001 Harding, Bill 04021 Hastings District Council (Omarunui Landfill) 00127 Hearle, 00023 Heffman, Doug 00045 Henderson, Neil Holcim (New Zealand) 00038 Horizons Regional Council 00027 Horowhenua District Council 05024 Horticulture New Zealand, Vegetables New Zealand Inc. and Tomatoes New Zealand 03004 Hyson, Michael 00005 IFS Growth Limited 04004 Independent Electricity Generators Association 04027 Industrial Symbiosis Kawerau 05014 Inglis, Murray 00031 International Emissions Trading Association Investor Group on Climate Change 00201 Jenkin, Rosalee 02050 Johnston, George 02048 Jonasen, Chris Jones, Philip 02021 JTL Carbon Farming Consultancy Limited 02024 Kahui, Jean 00100 Kaipara Hills Forest Partnership 02002 Suze 02016 Kerr, Suzi and Leining, Catherine Kim, Victoria 02032 KiwiRail 02029 Kupa, Tania Huata 04020 Lake Taupo Forest Trust and the Lake Rotoaira Forest Trust 00139 Lambert, Rod 05015 Landcare Research 04034 Lansdowne Forestry Limited and Fraser Forest Partnership 03001 Laurie Forestry Limited 02020 Leijen, and Sam 04036
Lees-Green, Rachel 02038 Lindsay, Catherine 00001 Livesey, 00016 Lloyd, David LN Bosman Limited 04024 Adrian (Victoria University, Wellington) Mackwell Locomotive Company Limited 05027 MacLennan, Anne MacTavish, Dugald 05026 Main, Nicholas Manks, Jeremy 00087 Mapp, Jennifer 00170 Margaree Consultants Inc 02004 Margules Groome Consulting 02017 Marlborough District Council 00010 Marquardt, Maurice 02022 Mason, Professor Euan G. 00136 Matariki Forests 04019 Maxted, Suzanne 02012 McClintock, Murray 02046 McEwen, Andrew 00184 McGuiness Institute 05023 Meads, Sarah 00187 Meridian Energy Limited 00057 Methanex New Zealand Limited 00137 Mighty Power 00152 Moana Ola Pasifika Public Health Network 00202 Moleta, Nick 02044 Morgan Foundation 00093 Morgan Foundation (form submission x49) Mortimer Forestry Management 00004 Motor Industry Association of New Zealand 00090 MRCagney Pty Limited 00099 Mueller-Glodde, Rolf 04000 Murupaenga-Ikenn, Catherine 04010 National Council of New Zealand 00042 National Energy Research Institute Natural Solutions Marine & Terrestrial Ecologists Ltd 05019 New Zealand Automobile Association Incorporated 00082 New Zealand Carbon Farming Group New Zealand Coal and Carbon Limited 00094 New Zealand Council of Unions Te Kauae Kaimahi New Zealand Farm Forestry Association 00022 New Zealand Forest Owners Association 00039 New Zealand Green Building Council New Zealand Institute of Forestry 00083 New Zealand Labour 00103 New Zealand Native Forests Reforestation Trust 03000 New Zealand Nurses Organisation 00181 New Zealand Oil and Gas Limited 00160 New Zealand Shipping Federation New Zealand Steel New Zealand Timber Industry Federation 05005 New Zealand Wind Energy Association New Zealand Youth Delegation 00205 Hine Forestry Trust 00066 Northland Regional Landfill Partnership 02042 Northland Nortona Limited 03003 O’Connor, Katie 00141
Temperzone Tewhiti, Terry 02013 The Carbon Shop 05017 The Omapere Taraire E & Rangihamama X3A Ahu Whenua Trust 05021 The Properties of Hauhungaroa 1 C Incorporation The Sustainable Energy Forum 05028 Thompson, Geoffrey 05012 Thorn, Therese 00003 Todd Corporation 00200 Toop, Martin 00064 Transwaste Canterbury Limited 02052 Trustpower 00088 Tunakino Forestry Limited 03002 Vector Limited 04033 Victoria University of Wellington Students Association 00207 Vivid Economics 05009 Waiheke Local Board 00211 Waikato Regional Council 03007 Waitemata Local Board 00210 Walker, Neil 00009 Warren Forestry Limited 00092 Waste Management New Zealand Limited 00129 Weatherburn, Finlay Wellington City Council 00084 Wellspring Farms and Forests Wendekreisen Travel Limited 00012 Westland Milk Products Westpac New Zealand Limited 00132 Whangarei District Council 00163 Whittaker, John Wise Response Society Woburn Investments Limited 00126 Wood Council of New Zealand Wood Processors and Manufacturers of New Zealand 00119 Woodnet Woodrow, Neil 02056 WWF New Zealand 00028 Z Energy Limited 00079 References Ministry for the Environment. 2015: New Zealand Emissions Trading Scheme Review 2015/16: Discussion Document and call for written submissions. Wellington: Ministry for the Environment.