TURN submits that under the circumstances this information should suffice to address the allocation requirement under the Commission’s rules. Should the Commission wish to see additional or different information on this point, TURN requests that the Commission so inform TURN and provide a reasonable opportunity for TURN to supplement this showing accordingly. Specific Claim:* Claimed CPUC Award ATTORNEY, EXPERT, AND ADVOCATE FEES Item Year Hours Rate $ Basis for Rate* Total $ Hours Rate $ Total $ [A] Robert Finkelstein 2013 107.25 $490 D.14-05-015 $52,552.50 107.25 $490.00 $52,552.50 R. Finkelstein 2014 977.50 $505 D.15-08-023 $493,637.50 977.50 $505.00 R. Finkelstein 2015 86.50 $505 2014 Rate $43,682.50 86.50 $505.00 $43,682.50 Hayley Goodson 2013 7.50 $345 D.15-05-019 $2,587.50 7.50 $345.00 $2,587.50 H. Goodson 2014 299.75 $355 D.15-08-023 $106,411.25 299.75 $355.00 H. Goodson 2015 34.75 $355 2014 Rate $12,336.25 34.75 $355.00 $12,336.25 Marcel Hawiger 2013 3.5 $400 D.14-05-015 $1,400.00 3.5 $400.00 $1,400.00 M. Hawiger 2014 258.0 $410 D.15-08-023 $105,780.00 258.00 $410.00
Photocopying Copies made of TURN pleadings for service, and copying charges from consultant billings $2,688.82 $2,688.82 Postage Expenses for postage for this proceeding $65.71 $65.71 Overnight delivery Materials mailed for express delivery to SCE or to TURN consultants related to work in this proceeding $104.02 $104.02 Phone Charges associated with TURN’s work in this proceeding, including costs of conference calls $151.19 $151.19 Computerized Research Computerized research costs associated with preparation of TURN’s strategy and pleadings for this proceeding $289.51 $289.51 Subtotal: $3,299.25 Subtotal: $3,299.25 REQUEST: $ 1,587,345.95 TOTAL AWARD: $1,593,514.06 **We remind all intervenors that Commission staff may audit their records related to the award and that intervenors must make and retain adequate accounting and other documentation to support all claims for intervenor compensation. Intervenor’s records should identify specific issues for which it seeks compensation, the actual time spent by each employee or consultant, the applicable hourly rates, fees paid to consultants and any other costs for which compensation was claimed. The records pertaining to an award of compensation shall be retained for at least three years from the date of the final decision making the award. **Travel and Reasonable Claim preparation time typically compensated at ½ of preparer’s normal hourly rate. ATTORNEY INFORMATION Attorney Date Admitted to CA BAR Member Number Actions Affecting Eligibility (Yes/No?) Robert Finkelstein June 13, 1990 146391 No Hayley Goodson December 5, 2003 228535 No Marcel Hawiger January 23, 1998 194244 No Matthew Freedman March 29, 2001 214812 No Thomas Long December 11, 1986 124776 No Elise Torres December 2011 280443 No, but inactive from 01/28/2013 01/01/2014. Attachments Documenting Specific and Comments on Part III Comment # Intervenor’s Comment(s) Comment 1 2013, 2014 and 2015 Hourly Rates for All TURN Representatives For 2013 hours, TURN has used the hourly rates already approved for work performed in that year by TURN’s attorneys and consultants. The same is true with one exception for 2014. Elise Torres joined TURN’s staff in 2014, and the requested rate of $215 has been requested