Fisheye + Crucible independently licensed
Asked by Craig Kelley:

Can a Fisheye+Crucible joint install be independently licensed (eg, 25 Fisheye users with 50 Crucible users)?


Answers:
author: Craig Kelley
body: A response from Atlassian:  

|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| |--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| | **Ria Ranosa** Today 5:25 AM Hi, Thanks for contacting us. I am happy to help you out. If using Crucible along with FishEye (in all cases), your FishEye license must have an equal or greater number of users in order to be compatible with Crucible. Hope this clarifies! Please [contact us](https://www.atlassian.com/company/contact/?tab=sanfrancisco) if you need any further assistance. Cheers, Rejoice Ra?osa | |

comments: author: Svante Gustafsson Bj?rkegren
body: Thanks for the clarification!

The documentation should be updated to reflect this specific requirement. The page in the Fisheye documentation I refer to below does not state this.

I tried to "purchase" 10 FishEye and 50 Crucible licenses in the webshop and there was no objections in doing this. I didn't follow through to the actual purchase, just to the cart. But nevertheless...

Of course these licenses could be aimed for different setups but probably they are not so a bit of warning would be great here so that customers don't purchase the wrong amount of licenses. Don't you agree?

Cheers,

// Svante


author: Svante Gustafsson Bj?rkegren
body: Sorry, Craig, I didn't realize the Atlassian guy wasn't participating in this thread :-)

It was not my intention that you should update the Atlassian docs.

Cheers,

// Svante


author: Svante Gustafsson Bj?rkegren
body: Hi Craig,

No you don't need the same license tier for Fisheye and Crucible.

Check out this previous post on the topic: [](/questions/279207/do-i-need-to-buy-a-license-for-fish-eye-if-i-use-only-crucible-code-review-tool)<https://answers.atlassian.com/questions/279207/do-i-need-to-buy-a-license-for-fish-eye-if-i-use-only-crucible-code-review-tool>

And this page is good also: [](https://confluence.atlassian.com/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=298977362)<https://confluence.atlassian.com/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=298977362>

Hope that clarifies things for you!

Cheers,

// Svante

comments: author: Craig Kelley
body: Thanks! I saw the other response, but we specifically have Fisheye+Crucible on a single instance with 25 users, and we want to only upgrade Crucible to 50. Thanks for clarifying.