Case: HURLEY-MASON CO. v. THE UNITED STATES
Abbreviation: Hurley-Mason Co. v. United States
Decision Date: 1925-05-11
Docket Number: No. C-1043
Citation: 60 Ct. Cl. 764
Volume: 60
Reporter: United States Court of Claims Reports
Court: United States Court of Claims
Jurisdiction: United States
Parties: HURLEY-MASON CO. v. THE UNITED STATES
Judges: 
Pages: 764–765

Head Matter:
HURLEY-MASON CO. v. THE UNITED STATES
[No. C-1043.
Decided May 11, 1925]
On Motion for Leave to File 0ounterelaim
Counterclaim; signature thereto; exhibits. — A counterclaim filed in the Court of Claims must be definite, and it can not have attached as part thereof a report by the General Accounting Office, which goes independently into the file in the case. The attorney signing said counterclaim must be designated as Assistant Attorney General or be authorized by the Attorney General to appear in his behalf.
The Reporteras .statement of the case:
Mr. John E. Hoover, with whom was Mr. Assistant Attorney General Herman J. Galloway, for the motion.
Mr. George A. King opposed.
On the 11th day of May, 1925, it was ordered by the court that the defendant’s motion for leave to file a counterclaim be allowed. With the order was the following

Opinion:
MEMORANDUM BY THE COURT
There was presented but not filed what purports to be defendant's answer and counterclaim. Attention is called to this alleged counterclaim. It refers to certain exhibits, A, B, and C, as being attached to the counterclaim. No exhibits are attached. And the references are apparently to some part or parts of a group of papers transmitted to this court under date of January 25, 1924, in reply to plaintiff's motion for request, which was allowed by the court. A counterclaim should state definitely the claim which the Government makes against the plaintiff, and a report made by the Accounting Office can not be attached as part of the counterclaim. This report goes independently into the file in the case. Nor can parts of it be detached so as to become or be made part of a counterclaim. If a counterclaim be filed, it should be signed by the Assistant Attorney General or some one under his authority. It can not be recognized that an attorney's name be signed as of counsel for the Government unless he be designated as an Assistant Attorney General or be authorized by the Attorney General to appear in his behalf. The statute requires all cases to be defended under the direction of the Attorney General. The evidential value of a report from the Accounting Office or a certificate of the comptroller is not now before the court.