Case: LOGAN v. PATRICK
Abbreviation: Logan v. Patrick
Decision Date: 1809-02
Docket Number: 
Citation: 5 Cranch 288
Volume: 9
Reporter: United States Reports
Court: Supreme Court of the United States
Jurisdiction: United States
Parties: LOGAN v. PATRICK.
Judges: 
Pages: 288–289

Head Matter:
LOGAN v. PATRICK.
The circuit mctioq^in1 * * a suit iii equity, '£edingJs upon A judgment at dm same ""ar tí«9,SaSthough the ^uhpoiiia the^defendant ont of- the. the court'"sits, '
THIS was a case certified from the circuit court f°r the 7th circuit and district of Kentucky, in which the judges below differed in opinion upon the flowing questions :
Whether the complainant, (Logan,) who is a citi¿en .of the state of Kentucky, .and is so stated in the pleadings, can maintain this suit, in this court, against the defendant, who is a citizen and inhabitant of the state of Virginia, and is so stated in the pleadings, upon the following case : John Patrick obtained, in this court a judgment in ejectment against David Logan, who filed a bill in equity against him to be relieved against the judgment, and to compel a conveyance of the land, and obtained an injunction to stay proceedings-on the judgment; biit the subpoena was not'served in the district of Kentucky, Can this,court entertain jurisdiction of the cause ? If not, does the defendant’s answering the bill, without insisting upon the - objection that the' process’ was not served upon him in the district of Kentucky, authorize the court to entertain the cause ?

Opinion:
The'Court, upon the fiTst opening of the case, said there .could be no doubt of the jurisdiction of the court below, and ordered it to be certified accordingly.