Case: Chaplin v. Kirwan
Abbreviation: Chaplin v. Kirwan
Decision Date: 1786-09
Docket Number: 
Citation: 1 Dall. 187
Volume: 1
Reporter: United States Reports
Court: Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas
Jurisdiction: Pennsylvania
Parties: Chaplin v. Kirwan.
Judges: 
Pages: 196–196

Head Matter:
SEPTEMBER TERM, 1786.
Chaplin v. Kirwan.
Arbitrators.
Referees have no right to examine a witness exporte.
The referees in this case had allowed ex parte evidence to be given, of the current price of coachmakors’ work, at the time when the cause of action accrued. For this reason, the defendant moved to set aside their report. And—

Opinion:
By the Court.
If referees make inquiries abroad, to ascertain for their own satisfaction, the price of work, or the truth of any other matter, which may be said, comparatively, to be of a public nature, this, so far from being irregular, would be highly commendable. But it is a very different case, when they proceed separately to examine a witness, who has been produced by one of the parties, although the evidence relates only to those general points. The adverse parties should have an opportunity of cross-examining the witness,
The report set aside.
See Hollingsworth v. Leiper, ante, p. 161, and the notes.