Case: NORTH v. McDONALD
Abbreviation: North v. McDonald
Decision Date: 1879-11-10
Docket Number: No. 41
Citation: 154 U.S. 649
Volume: 154
Reporter: United States Reports
Court: Supreme Court of the United States
Jurisdiction: United States
Parties: NORTH v. McDONALD
Judges: 
Pages: 649–649

Head Matter:
NORTH v. McDONALD
error to the supreme court of the territory OF WYOMING.
No. 41.
Submitted November 4, 1879.
Decided November 10, 1879.
On the case made by the pleadings the court will not disturb the judgment below.
Mr. C. W. Bramel and Mr. W. IF. Corlett for plaintiffs in error.
Mr. Edward P. Johnson for defendants in error.

Opinion:
Mr. Chief Justice Waite
delivered the opinion of the court.
The plaintiffs below evidently intended to bring this action under sec. 5129 of the Revised Statutes, but the averments in their petition are only sufficient to make a case under sec. 5046. While the court would certainly have been justified in leaving the question of fraud to the jury upon the evidence as it stood, we think, if a judgment had been rendered against the defendants, it might with propriety have been set aside as being contrary to what had been proven. For this reason, although it might have been more in accordance with correct practice not to take the- case from the jury, we will not disturb the judgment. No request was made for leave to amend the petition, and we must consider the case here as made by the pleadings, and not as the parties may have intended to make it. The judgment is affirmed.