I really want to like this place.  It's cute, has a full bar, and lovely people who work there.  I also went on a particularly memorable and wonderful date there which leaves me with warm and fuzzy feelings.  The food however, leaves me wishing I picked Cafe Du Jour instead every time.  Please let me tell you about the last four times I went to Gypsy:\n\n1) brunch on a weekend morning with friends.  They were out of most of the brunch dishes and my eggs were rubbery.  The worst was that when we ordered cappuccinos and lattes, they were out of milk, so they made them with HALF AND HALF.  As hideous as it sounds.\n\n2) Dinner with friends before a play.  I went safe and ordered a pasta with chicken and veggies.  It was a huge amount of pasta that was a bit oily and not flavorful.  Eh.  Mediocre.\n\n3) Weekday dinner with two friends.  I ordered the ribeye medium rare.  When the steak arrived it was grey and so well done I couldn't chew it easily.  I NEVER EVER send food back but I just had to this time.  The waiter was really apologetic and went into the back to solve the problem (for a good 20 minutes!) by this time my friends had mostly finished their food and I was going to just settle for eating the veggies and potatoes on the side and call it a day.  Then our waiter came back and said they couldn't make me another steak because that was the last steak in the house (yikes, kind of glad I didn't eat it - Anthony Bourdain's stories haunt me).  He did nicely offer to make me something else but by this time, it was pointless since my friends were done with dinner.  As a final blow they left the steak on the check and took forever to redo the check.\n\n4) (you went BACK? I hear you - but it was for a birthday party!) All I had was drinks and I had a simply wonderful time in a great atmosphere with fun people.  \n\nOverall, since I love food, I can't give this place a good rating but if you're looking to rent out a place with fun bohemian style for drinks it might be worth a try.