yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] Neibaf85:
Hi,

I just installed Tiramislim 2.0. (default settings, devil kernel) and Galaxy Dock Sound Redirector app on Google Play

Audio redirection works great, (with music player , google navigation) but with phone call i can only hear. Microphone doesn't work (of course it works when i'm not using Samsung galaxy s vehicule dock kit official)

Do you have the same issue ?

Thanks
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
Im a noob so this is just my 2 cents.

I think on a phone call the dock triggers audio out to the usb but it does not activate the speakerphone mic mode.

So basically the mic will only capture the sound if u speak directly into it.

I just press the speakerphone button when I get a phone call, the audio redirect stops and uses the loudspeaker on the phone to output audio but the speakerphone mic mode gets activated so I don't have to put my face right next to it for the other person to hear me.

If there is anyone here who knows how to keep audio out redirect and still have the speakerphone mic mode on the tip would be much appreciated.

Thanks.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] aalupatti:
I have not seen this done on any of the galaxy phones. Waiting since galaxy s2 days.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
hi, I just saw this post again and would like to make sure I understand correctly.

are you saying with icy glitch kernel I can have call audio come through the dock and have the speakerphone mic mode activated at the same time during a phone call?

I am on ics333 with semaphore 1.2.6 and have audio out working fine without editing build.prop.

but i had given up on trying to get speakerphone mic mode and call audio through usb.

can this work on semaphore if I edit build.prop or do I have to be on icy glitch?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] PerpetuumNobile:
Sorry for the late reply.

More or less, yes, you are right. I see two issues:

1. Icy Glitch kernel project seems to be closed (last release was at end of March). Current kernels (like Semaphore) are working just so fine I would not change it back to Glitch -- and

2. although call audio redirection was working in Glitch, it was not really usable. I heard the other side well but callers reported very low level of volume. To be honest I did not investigate it further as I moved on to some other kernels.

I am still looking for a solution, but it seems buying a cheap bluetooth system is the only way at the moment. I only guess but probably due to the low number of car docks sold this functionality was never on the top of the wishlist of SGS users (which actually in my opinion is not a big task for our excellent kernel developer gurus). For me it seemed pretty straightforward that if I have a dock for navigation, listening to music etc. I would like to use it for calls without having to use another accessory (and anyway I can use bluetooth to transfer all audio so then there is no need for cable audio out...).

Even the new Galaxy Nexus reference phone is working like this as far as I know (no call audio redirection), could also be a legal issue.

Have a nice day,

pn

---------- Post added at 02:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:56 PM ----------

Well I just did not answer your question: so no, there is no call audio redirection in Semaphore afaik.

pn
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
Thank you very much for that thorough response.

I was actually on the verge of trying icy glitch even though i saw that the development there was pretty much dead, just to try to get this functionality.

But it looks like i shouldnt bother.

The thing with bluetooth is that it compresses the audio and the quality is reduced.

Im not an audiophile but i think im pretty close, and can tell when audio is compressed.

I usually only listen to mp3s over 200kbps, otherwise i can tell the drop in quality.

So bluetooth is not really an option for me.

But thanks anyway.

P.S. how is it that you only have 3posts and thanked twice? You seem to know what you are talking about...
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] srvi12:
thank you vrey match!
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] TaC:
I was using Icy Glitch (best kernel for me, even in dead development) in latest CM9, and with Galaxy Dock Sound Redirector, using v1 redirection setting, it was working like a charm with desktop dock.

Now i have flashed latest CM10, installed Galaxy Dock Sound Redirector, and tried stock and semaphore kernels using all combinations of v1/v2 redirection. NO LUCK.

Anyone figured out how to get dock working with Jelly Bean?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
+1

I have the exact same problem. (i was on ics333 with semaphore, sound redirect was working perfectly)

I couldnt get any of the jb roms to redirect audio through the dock. (only tried cm10 and elites rc10 both with semaphore)

I asked in both rom threads and samaphore thread and didnt get any answers.

Had to go back to ics333.

Any advice would be much appreciated.

Thanks.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] TaC:
Tried JB with Devil Kernel, wich is said to support dock audio, but no luck...
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] jimipoh:
Stuck in Desk Dock mode

Hi guys, I'm on the devil jb kernel using helly bean. My phone has been stuck in desk dock mode, i'm not sure if it's the hardware failing on me, but i'm wondering if it's possible to disable dock features entirely?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
The latest hellybean has been reported to support dock audio.

Havent tried it myself yet but will give it a shot this weekend may be and report back.

Just in case anyone was still wondering about dock audio on jb.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
really sad that developers don't pay attention to car dock. they ask for testing and donations and don't care much about users. it's just take it or leave me alone.

it's already one month since in my car is silent..silent strike. i have patience this weekend then i will try to forget about custom roms.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
Why dont you try helly bean?

It still looks a little unstable going through too many changes for me to want to flash but elites rc12.1 looks pretty stable so im gonna see if there is a way to ask the dev to incorporate the change derteufel mentioned.

The problem is the dev for elite rom doesnt hang around on these forums.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
helly bean support car dock? i'm sick of trying, asking ...
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
haven't tried myself but greasyguy reported it to be working with dock sound redirector app by xcaliburinhand.

search the helly bean thread with keyword dock.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] olarf:
Yes it Work with hellybean
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
you know what you speak or you speak what you know?

try again!
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
there's no jelly bean working with car dock's app made by xcaliburinhand

i have just flashed lot of them and looks like sound setting are different than ICS, as xcaliburinhand said in one mail to me

once again..odin...new child

so sad that none of 1st post-ers is polite to ask at final

LE: i just get back to JVU, car dock is working with stock firmware!
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
sorry to hear that.

I tried to pm you but for some reason i seem unable to send pms.

no sent message?

anyway, sorry to hear helly bean doesnt work,

since i cant seem to send pms cant catch any of the devs attention.

i guess im staying on ics for now.

how is it some people are reporting it works?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] olarf:
I will check it again tomorrow with the version i run right now (11.09.12). It runs in a older version but i forget which it was :( So tommorow i pick my cardock and provide uptodate facts.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
thanks.

how is helly bean stability wise?

i read the thread and get the impression its still undergoing heavy development and if you flash the wrong nightly you will have serious bugs.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] olarf:
I forget to pick my cardock today, sorry. Hellybean is so far pretty stable once you pick the right version as you thougt :) I run 4.9 and now 11.9 and both are great. Before i used gnexus 11 which was also fine while 12 drain the battery.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
thanks.

may try helly bean 11/9 this weekend
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] olarf:
I try today 11.9 and it dont work but it seems to work with one/some car app. I will try to figure out which one :) on ics evry app works. So no good need but i will continue to find a way
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
more tests on JB:

tsunami ..not working

MIUI...not working

AOKP build2... not working

slim 2.4 ... not working
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
have u tried xcaliburinhands dock sound redirector app on playstore with setting faalback to v1 redirection?

read that works with helly bean after 09/04

---------- Post added at 12:33 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:32 AM ----------

what dock app are u using?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] olarf:
Yes i use this app but for what reason ever i dont check that v1 setting. Will be my first thing this morning.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
galaxy dock sound redirector
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
i think there's a solution:

cm10 before 17.08 with semaphore 2.0.3 worked through car sound redirector ... so we need a patch that brings sound setting like in first build of cm10

unfortunately i didn't find none of first builds now for download, but semaphore is

or where can i find some infos around subject?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
Cant seem to find the old cms.

Those were unofficial and archived somewhere.

But for what its worth i heard those old versions were very laggy with the old partition layout.

When u tried galaxy dock sound redirector app did u tick fall back to v1 redirection?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] olarf:
I try v1 today but it dont work :( , Still wait for an answer from one dev who report it work with one app.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
v1, yes

answers...answers...how to compile a patch as i said?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
devil kernel will not work with car dock sound redirector; i remember ICS days...
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
I had devil working with dock sound redirect on ics333.

not that that helps us any at this point.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
finally had a chance to test helly bean and nothing.

I just had to try for myself.

tried all sorts of combinations within the rom.

pmed the guy who said its working.

will see what he has to say.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] greasyguy:
Just to be clear: car dock definitely works with Hellybean 11/09 up to 21/09 (don´t know for the following versions). I don´t know why but it works. I just flashed the allinone.zip and afterwards installed the "Dock Sound Redirector" app from play store ticked v1 fallback and got it going. Sorry for those guys who can´t get it working but I can´t see where the difference is.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] olarf:
Thats strange. I try it with 11/9 and 21/9 same way you did but my sound stay on the phone. Redirection app say it redirect but it didnt.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] PaddeNL:
What kernel you re using?

---------- Post added at 01:15 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:37 PM ----------

edit: I am not able to tick the v1 fallback option.

I am runnig CM9 19/9 with semaphore kernel
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] greasyguy:
The one that comes with Helly Bean. Kernel versions says:

Devil3_1.5.3_hellybean_i9000_CFS_BLN_CMC #868
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
+1

its very strange cos its not like there are other compatible kernels with helly bean.

by the way, I have voodoo sound app installed.

is there any chamce that might interfere?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] olarf:
Same here, maybe it is the solution so please, you with the working system, tell us if you use the vc version or not.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
he already told me he was using cmc version.

I meant the voodoo sound app from play store.

I'm guessing u r not using it so that rules that out.

and I've also tried both vc and cmc.

neither worked for me.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] olarf:
I had the voodo sound app installed when i test it. So it can be the reason.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] greasyguy:
No I don´t use voodoo app.

Maybe it is a good idea to make a log of the situation while plugging the device into the car dock and show it to DerTeufel?

I didn´t get it working either in the first place. Maybe this is made up out of thin air but you could try to install the car home apps from here at first and then flash over the hellybean package without wipes. Don´t know if this makes any sense but that´s the way I made it working for me at least.

Good luck guys! :fingers-crossed:
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
thanks.

don't have a pc for the rest of the week so no logcat and no flashing.

I'm jus wondering if voodoo and dsp clash in any way.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] mattwaddy:
Anyone got this working correctly now?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] derby_sv:
Does anybody tried this with Note II? I couldn't make it work. When I soldered 619k between 4 and 5 pins I even lost the power and аudio output was still through the internal speaker.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
for docking sound through car dock, i always flash stock rom. the only is working with dock sound redirector.

sad but true!
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
Ics333 def works with dock sound redirector.

Been using it for 7 months.

Its ics but it sure beats stock gb.

At least in my opinion.

No jb that i know of works though.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] giantroxx:
Hi guys,

I wrote Pawtip to include the Patch from ICS into JellyBean.

He answered me and said that the new Nightly (cm-10.1-20130225-NIGHTLY-galaxysmtd.zip) will get this Patch.

See here:

http://review.cyanogenmod.org/#/c/32520/

Regards!
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
Thanks.

Have you tested it?

Might try it on the weekend if i have time.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] giantroxx:
Iam still waiting for the new nightly!
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] giantroxx:
Strange, doesnt work for me with nightly from 26/02/2013.....can anyone test this please? Dont know if i have to use GalaxySoundRedirector or if it should work without that app....
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
pretty sure you would need the app.

don't have a pc for the week and no broadband or wifi so not gonna chance it n test.

did u try with the galaxy sound redirector app?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] giantroxx:
I tried it with and without the galaxy dock redirector. It says "redirecting to dock" if i plug it in, but sound comes still over the internal speaker....strange. Tried it in the Desk-Dock from Samsung, not in CarDock...maybe theres a difference. I dont use the official CM10.1 Nightly, but the one from Fishears, based on the latest nightly...Maybe someone could try it with the official?

Regards
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
have u tried checking fallback to v1 option?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] giantroxx:
I cant enable this option, its grayed out and cant be checked
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
oh. in that case you should probably report it to the dev. although I must warn u, they'll tell u to get a logcat. hope u know how. good luck.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] greasyguy:
Then its a kernel problem. Please try with semaphore or hellbean kernel.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
have u managed to get it to work?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] greasyguy:
Didn´t try it yet. Will try today and report.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
since cm7 and first releases of cm9, i didnt found any rom that redirect sound to car dock...

talks with developers but useless....they dont use car dock...

i would be happy to use dual boot: stock and custom..but it's just my dream...
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
I cant help but notice every time you say that.

Im pretty i've mentioned i have it working with ics333 and semaphore 1.3.0 galaxy dock sound redirector app.

Have been using it for more than 6 months now.

And as far as i know it works with cm9 if you flash semaphore 1.3.0 or devil kernel for ics and use the above mentioned app.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
maybe...but a want JB working or ... nothing :)
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
well, I have to say that's your loss cos ics is much better than gb. u can even flash google now and then ur pretty close to jb. its a good place to wait if u don't wanna constantly flash back and forth between gb n jb.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
i dont use my phone for google... but to do what i need

saurom its downloading
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] giantroxx:
Has someone tried now Official CM10.1 with Semaphore????
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] Piscolero:
AW: [HOWTO] Enable the car dock external audio without Samsung's Home apps

Tried CM10.1 nightly 20130306 together with Semaphore 2.9.13. Unfortunately without success. Tested with and without V1 redirection.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
i think we need a new apk for JB roms... but who can do it??
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
Hey guys, I know everyone on this thread is waiting for a jb rom to support car dock functionality.

Please head over to the helly bean thread and read the last few pages.

Derteufel says he has some ideas and is going to try to implement them in his ROM but he needs some testerscos he doesnt own a dock.

If you guys can test and report im sure that would be a big help, especially if he sees that its not just 1 or 2 people who want this functionality.

When you head over there please be courteous and respectful to the dev.

Thanks.

xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2012061&page=223
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] giantroxx:
AW: [HOWTO] Enable the car dock external audio without Samsung's Home apps

Hi guys any news about cardock and jb? Does it work now in helly bean?? Regards
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
I've been following the helly bean thread and i may be wrong but it looks like there havent been any new nightlies since my last post on this thread.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] MrSaleh69:
Thanks.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] i9000usersa:
Next time just press the thanks button under the member details. ;)

---------- Post added at 02:43 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:14 AM ----------

Just to correct what i said, there was a helly bean release a few days ago but no changes to any helly bean code.

Only cm10.1 changes were merged so the dock functionality will not have been fixed.

Im guessing derteufel is quite busy these days.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
@fishers was trying but no succes...

as mjj said: they dont care about us :)
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] qs238:
Another interested Vibrant user

I would love to see this get fixed as well. CM10...is well..just great and I would love to continue using it but I would also love to use my car dock to port the sound to my car's speakers.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] Lazy_Snake:
i'm still waiting too ;o))

CM10 is really just great and I would also love to continue using it but I would also use my original Samsung Desktop Dock to port the Sound to my Hifi System

I hope, it will be supported soon ;o)
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
back to stock. works fine in my car.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
how come v1 is active just with semaphore kernel?

but still doesn.t working...
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] Lazy_Snake:
any news???

Hi Guys,

are there any news about this topic???

with the CM 10.1 nighly (20130425) it doesn't work :o(
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] Lazy_Snake:
News?

Whata Göring in _ many User waiting for an update, that supports audio redirect... :confused:
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] AcECream7:
The quality is good, thank you. Look forward to an update very soon.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
strange things:

i know that JB roms doesnt aloud to redirect sound through car dock but now is some big

using just a jack sound is ..soundless, i mean i hear almost nothing..

any option?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] Marcenzeichen:
I've build a widget in Tasker, that (de)actives sound redirection via usb-port.

I could send you the widget, if you have tasker or try the "app factory" and build an app out of the script.

Maybe there is a third option and i still have an app on my pc at home for the switching, I could send you.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
If you can uploud it here will be great; i wanna try it.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] Marcenzeichen:
You've got mail!

Tell me please, if the app works.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] greasyguy:
Could you please send it to me to?

Gesendet von meinem GT-I9000 mit Tapatalk 4 Beta
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] Marcenzeichen:
Let's wait, if it works for florum.

Gesendet von meinem GT-I9295 mit Tapatalk 4 Beta
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
i'm so happy!

i can hear the music now transmited by stereo jack at normal standards.

car dock is not working but i'm used with it.

THANKS [MENTION=3022878]Marcenzeichen[/MENTION]!
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] Marcenzeichen:
It was never ment to start a car dock, as there are several in the market. it just does, what its name says. ;)
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
may i ask which app is working with JB roms (slim in my case)?

i've tried most of them till i got bored.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] Marcenzeichen:
I haven't used any dock app at all. I used Tasker to automatise everything I need in my car and the ADW-Launcher which supports landscape-mode. thats it.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] elhennig:
Sorry to ask this here, but I am searching for this kind of solution for my Galaxy S3. Is there anyone that can help me with that?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] adamusek:
try with this app Galaxy Dock Sound Redirector
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] florum:
flashed touchwiz.apk over slimkat 3.4, flashed semaphore. now i have slimkat with touchwiz launcher and semaphore kernel.

car sound redirector gives me FC.

could be the launcher that doesn't allow sound to be redirected?
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] TheBeano:
I would use Tasker for that, it really is a great app.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] TheBeano:
The external audio jack feature is still broken in Gingerbread (JVK). The built-in speaker sound mutes but sound doesn't get switched to the USB output. So don't upgrade if you want to keep this feature. Now I have to downgrade, grr.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] TheBeano:
I updated the app in post #1 with a version that has separate settings for home and car docks. If the phone is docked then clicking on the relevant checkbox will turn the external output on and off straight away.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] brett.darnell:
Awesome works for desk dock.

Big thank-you.

If u put up a PayPal donation link ill donate.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] TheBeano:
Thanks, if you like it please donate to the CyanogenMod developers: go to this thread and click the link under "SUPPORT US".
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] altheman200:
can't open APK

Hi, the app you created is in .zip format I assume I would have to change it to .apk to launch it on my Galaxy S. But that does not seem to work. I think there is something obvious I am missing here. Please help. Thanks.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] altheman200:
Sorry figured it out!

feel dumb for not trying this before I asked but downloaded AndroZip and got it figured thanks for the great app.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] obakr:
Gingerbread version soon?

Hi TheBeano, is there any plan for making a gingerbread version soon?

I also had to downgrade my phone to use the dock.
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] TheBeano:
Samsung has to fix it in the kernel, hopefully they will test it with all their accessories before they release it. :)
[Galaxy S I9000 Accessories] ctleng76:
I am not sure which ROM you are using and which kernel you have installed, but ever since I installed an Onix kernel my car dock audio output works for phone calls as well. I can now hear the phone call audio through my car stereo and speak into the air. I have been able to do this with both Onix 2.0.3 and 2.0.4.