[Captivate Android Development] ewingr:
A bit more detail/review on my experience so far...

I might point out that this test is based on having ~ 100 apps installed.

Did NOT restore system data with TIBU. Did restore several apps with data; others installed from AppBrain.

My thoughts are this is very nice; looks good. One thing I like about the Assonance ROMS is what is appearing to be consistency in builds. On the Cognition and Perceptoin ROMS, they are good, but every ROM is different: does have something, then doesn't. Never know what you're going to get.

So, here's my first, a bit more comprehensive than earlier (after only an afternoon/evening on the ROM) thoughts:

Volume

I posted earlier about low volume.

In Quick settings, even though from the volume settings I had it all the way up, I had to also select the settings for Ringer and go in and set it up there too. Now have good volume. Haven't had to do that in the past. Good to go.

WiFi

On this too I posted earlier about it being not great. Now not as flaky as at first.

But as I've posted on earlier ROM, and other 2.2 ROMS, WIFI is not as stable on 2.2 as on 2.1 for me. But I find that to be based on N in particular. Just a bit different on G. I do actually think it is a bit worse on this ROM than others I have loaded.

GPS

Hooked quickly, less than 10 seconds

Did not have to delete GPS data, or do any other changes.

Accuracy about same as earlier Assonance. Based on 26 mile drive.

Phone Call Quality

I've experienced this on other ROMS too, and it is inconsistent: Sometimes what I hear is bad. Only way I can think to describe it is 'warbly'. (Figure that one out).;)

Market

On this one too, I experience, inconsistently, having to clear market in order to get updates to install. When it doesn't work right, the symptoms are: it downloads just a bit, and then nothing. This is not a problem of this ROM; but this ROM does not fix the problem either.

Battery

Cannot comment yet. Would like to get it where OV/UV settings would stick on boot. Not sure yet what the implications are if move to the other kernel referenced earlier (I forget now what version was referenced.)

Performance

Seems very good. Linpack is close to others I've tested, but maybe a bit less. (I don't know if Linpack is a decent test or not, but I guess can be relative)

but...

Speed Test for downloads: Very poor compared to others. I typically get 21000kb on my wireless, just got 6326kb tonight. Just tested from my PC, and got 47Mb per second, so my connection in the house is good.

On 3G (Or is it H?), I typically get min 3059kb download, up to just over 5000. Tonight on this one I just got 1406.

Need to try a different modem?

I actually do see a bit of lagginess on some things opening. But I'm relatively happy with it as is.

Large Disappointment - Blue Tooth Phone Dialing by Button

No Voice Dial application. Google Voice does not come up with the BT button. Only Vlingo, which is not very accurate. And, if my screen is in sleep mode, it will not bring it out of sleep.

I did have BT with a Voice Dial app (I'm guessing becuase it was in the Vibrant based rom that one of DG's roms was based on), and it worked great. I ultimately will have to settle on one that gives me decent voice dialing.

If anyone knows how to get Google Voice Search (Formerly Google voice Actions? Confusing...don't know what happened with that name) working, with BT Key, that would be great.

[EDIT]

Just remembered BlueTooth Launch. This will bring up Google Voice with the BT Button. Good to go!

Other Things - Based on items I've seen folks indicate as problematic in past on various ROMS

Launcher Pro Works with no problems

Screeble seems to work great

Would be nice to have method where the device ID can be updated upon initial boot of freshly installed ROM as other ROMS have offered.

That's about all I've tested so far.

Net Net: Much of the stuff above that may come across as 'negative', is actually pointing out some things that have been problematic on all 2.2 ROMS I've used, and just noting it here...and that it is not fixed on this ROM.

Only really issues I see are SPEED; and to some extent WiFi.

MikeyMike...you're doing great. Keep up the good work. Hoping my comments here can help in some way.