[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] Kangal:
Wow that is a sweet ROM ... its kinda like what I imagined Android should be (iOS + widgets + Google stuff).

Its awesome because it basically borrows the strengths of both Andriod and iOS and makes it into a hybrid: very intuitive user experience that supports advanced features.

I really dig the whole layout: just one place where you scroll pages (not double like Galaxy S's TouchJizz).

I think its awesome how you:

+ have only one main area where you scroll (unlike Galaxy S)

+ you have a cool looking arrow (that indicates which screen you're at)

+ the arrow is positioned in a great location

+ the arrow allows you to quickly scroll between them (your fingers dont need exercise!)

+ can have unlimited "Home" screens

+ easily rearrange them (so you can move groups of Apps easily)

+ can manually choose the main home screen is also awesome

+ can easily delete Apps from the home screen (that rubbish bin at the top is so cool)

+ enter "edit" mode on the homescreen (displays the boxes)

+ add Widgets in this weird but wonderful way

+ easily rearrange Apps and folders

- too bad you can't place folders inside folders (which isn't a big deal and actually helps keep things simple, but I still prefer having the option)

- too bad you can't make shortcuts of Apps (making it impossible to launch Apps from several places/homescreens)

- too bad it doesn't support haptic response (...that would be so cool!)

- too bad it doesn't work in landscape mode (I have an idea how this can be implemented in a great way, I will make a mock-up if requested*)

I also dig the intuitiveness of:

+ the controls/shortcuts for wateva screen is always located on the bottom (familiarity/cleaness)

+ Apps automatically get a coloured backing like on TouchWiz, to make each App look more familiar (retains order) but with its curved sides it still retain some funk (reminds some of the iPhone, in a good way)

+ I like how the page bounces when it hits the end, while kinetic-scrolling

+ the transitioning (page quickly zooms in when opening/zooms and fades out when closing)

+ I like how the Widgets/startbar/notifications tab are transparent (requires a theme that can change these collectively)

+ like the space to put 0-6 Apps to launch from the App-dock and re-arrange them easily

+ like the large icons on the bottom of the Contacts page

+ like the large icons on the bottom of the Dialer

- the Music App has the same thing but its located on the top row (they forgot?)

- the App-dock doesn't let you put any folders into it, shame (but probably an easy fix)

- the dialer could've been improved by taking some cues from the the Galaxy S... if requested I will make you a mock-up**

- the settings page is just stock Android, they could've decorated it slightly like on the HTC Sense ROMs (probably an easy fix)

I loved how you can scroll the "functions" buttons in the notifications tray but overall I didn't like it as much as the Galaxy S's, its great but I see some areas of improvement:

- i think they should've have 4-larger "functions" displayed instead of 5 smaller ones

- i think somewhere in the Settings they should've made an option to Add/Remove some of those functions and arrange the order according to the user (like having a second App-dock but instead for system tools, a Tool-dock!)

- i think it needs the controls for music/movies (the media player) in the notifications tray like the Galaxy S (that's actually awesome)

Other things that would make a killer experience on an Android phone is if they also had

1) the "hibernate" function that intiates when you switch off your device (new HTC Sense),

2) a customizable theme that's consistent throughout Widgets/Folders/Pages,

3) and 3 main buttons (no need for trackball) to make the experience intuitive;

Left button***

= press is back (works the same way already in Android)

= hold (1.5sec) is Force-Close the app (which is so handy in Android that its not funny)

Middle button***

= press directs you directly to the "main" homescreen

= hold (1.5sec) opens you another page that "previews all currently running applications" (which is great for speedy multitasking)****

= See this just as an example for what happens when you hold the Home button http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4013/4355688804_68ccaca964.jpg

Right button***

= press initiates the Menu function

= hold (1.5sec) initiates the Search function (just like on the Galaxy S)

And arranging the buttons in this order allows easier use for users because it is intuitive (majority read left-right, buttons function in that same order ... WP7 actually got this right)

I think that is the best way to go about Android ROM's (with my slight improvements) as a Froyo build. So yeah, this is about 90% finished of what I envisioned/want from Android (for the DEXT/Milestone2/GalaxyS). If you want to visually see what I mean at the (*)'s, I can do so if you are wanting :D