yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Desire Android Development] kfasheldon:
Both Kernals work with OpenDesire 4.0.17 (experimental) but I had problems with ADW Launcher f/c Launcher Pro/Zeam/GDE and Stock Launcher seem fine. Notice Wi-Fi so no further testing. Will be interesting to see what if any affect HAVS has on battery with OD as this does give good life already. Used to use PAYS Rom with HAVS and that made big difference to batt so we will see. Look forward to tomorrow.

Thanks for your contribution to Desire and good luck.
[Desire Android Development] Dactylion:
please

pls add exact values for uv and axi.

make aversion with cfq.
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
fixed Wifi now ;)
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
What extra values? and why cfq? BFQ runs bette imo
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
Thanks. Will look into the ADW Problem
[Desire Android Development] golf60:
How is batterie drain with this Kernel? Now use Defrost with svs 1113mhz and Batterie drain is big, bigger than the OD Kernel with the same MHz.
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
I'm using the HAVS one mainly and I'm quite satisfied with the Battery. But hard to tell because it variates thru different usage and settings (like Display brightness)
[Desire Android Development] Dactylion:
the values for axi bus speed. how much mhz at which processor frequency. and the millivolt values for every processor frequency. just 2 tables for comparism with other kernels.
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
acpuclock-scorpion line 68
[Desire Android Development] golf60:
The batterie drain with auto brightness and much Internet use. Compared to svs kernel from Defrost 4.1a with svs 1113mhz.
[Desire Android Development] BashyUK:
Nice one mate, will give it a go soon...only just switched to DF yday so would like to give the standard ROM a few days to gauge it's performance.
[Desire Android Development] mariosraptor:
Flashed this on new df 6.0 and my phone stuck at htc boot logo. Any suggestion? Had to reflash rom to make it work qgain
[Desire Android Development] ziggy1001:
Does the new kernel support IPv6 Google Goggles seems to have stopped working?

Not that it's a big problem;)
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Well this is weird...i tried to flash v6 and v7 on cm6.1 and i get into a boot loop with both :s

edit: i got dta2sd on it, will that be a problem?
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
I'm running rc1 and no problem for me. dtapps shouldn't be the problem. Really strange.

And IPV6 should be enabled too.
[Desire Android Development] :
I'm having wake problems with smartass enabled. Switching back to ondemand solves the problem.

Edit: After testing vigorously, smartass does stop my Desire from waking up correctly, it will take 5 to 10 presses of the power button to make it wake, whereas upon changing to ondemand it wakes instantly, every time, which leads me to the conclusion that this is caused by an issue with the smartass governor.
[Desire Android Development] :
You would find an answer if you actually read the thread. :)

http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=8913106&postcount=166

Let me know if it works for you.
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
No way, i can't get past the booanimation, i tried again right now...i even tried to wipe everything but still no luck..any suggestions?
[Desire Android Development] wiggles87:
With R7 my phone freezes whenever I start any app that uses the camera (camera, barcode scanner, goggles). The screen goes blank and after long-pressing the back button a few times to kill and hitting the home button a couple of times, it returns to the launcher after about 30 sec.

Edit: Running CM 6.1.0 RC1
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
same here, back to r6
[Desire Android Development] rahul.pillai:
Saw that but will it work with the latest release?
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
Yep can confirm. Camera isn't working in r7, but I have a idea how to fix it ;)

And yep Smartass seems to need some urmm tweaking...
[Desire Android Development] Sarsippius:
Hi Benee, I'm using r5 SVS on MIUI 0.10.15 no problem but trying to flash r6 it won't even get to the boot animation, just hangs at the splash screen. Wiping cache and dalvik will allow it to go so far as a boot loop. If I do a full wipe/reset it fully boots up so I thought I'd solved it but seeing some comments here about a2sd I had a look and a2sd is no longer running, something about the partition not mounted. MIUI uses DarkTremor's a2sd.

I've gone back to my nandroid backup & can't remember the exact message from a2sd. I might try r7 and see if I get the same issue.
[Desire Android Development] :
It should work for any version 4.0.x of OpenDesire.
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
Which EXT do you use for the A2SD partition? Maybe I have a clue what's going on
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
hi Benee, i use your kernel from r4 to r7, launcher pro is even smooth from r4 to r7

yesterday kali- give me a cm 6.1 kernel, after flashed cm 6.1 kernel, launcher pro is very lag.

i know you compiled some source code from cm, maybe you know what's wrong with cm kernel?
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
there is nothing wrong with the cm kernel. Just other setup. Cm uses CFS (which imo sucks ^^) so I use BFS, which improves the perfomance/smoothness alot. I added AXI scaling and made a few other changes.
[Desire Android Development] rahul.pillai:
Tried v7 of the Kernel and your a2sd patch; stuck in the boot screen. The Home screen does not load up. On OD .37
[Desire Android Development] :
It will take a while the first time as it will be copying your apps. :) The only 2 changes I made to the script was a bit more output at each stage for debugging purposes and a sleep 5 at the start.

Are you stuck at the bootloader screen or are you in a bootloop?
[Desire Android Development] :
BFS is the best way to go, I have a great deal of respect for CK and his performance patchsets which I used to use as far back as 2.6.8.

Benee, what do you need to do to apply the BFS patch against the CM kernel? I applied the patch yesterday which all applied successfully, but I got a compile error related to BFS.
[Desire Android Development] rahul.pillai:
Stuck in the boot animation screen. Not in a boot loop. But I know that the files have been loaded = "vibrate" and can use the power key to put the screen to sleep and wake up.

Will try again a little later....
[Desire Android Development] :
Hook it up to your computer and run adb logcat before you boot it on to see if anything is going on.
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
2 commits: 1 2
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
Benee, does svs r7 included cm's proximity fix?

and the new r7.1 with camera fix will be released today?
[Desire Android Development] :
Cheers, thats where the compile error was: sched_bfs.c
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Update: i wiped and reflashed CM6.1, and now your kernel works like a charm :)

I wonder what could have been messing up with my last setup...
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
cm 6 base. So yeah proximity fix is in it ;)

and yeah wake up problems seems fixed, but cam don't know. Hope I find the problem soon.

A2SD maybe fixed too..

Edit: Update on the way ... yeah let's urmm say r7 was a beta and I urmm was really tired ...
[Desire Android Development] golf60:
smile... i hope A2SD+ fix will come and it will run on my new MIUI .29 rom :-)
[Desire Android Development] mon@diac:
+1...thanks for your hard work
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
great, i am waiting for the cam fix :-)
[Desire Android Development] Razzee:
did you use the same kernel file or did a redownload?
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
Fixed Cam/A2SD/Smartass sleep Mediafire
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
wow, very fast !!!!

thanks
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
I used the same, it wasn't the file being corrupted...i can't really figure out what was actually messing up :/

@Benee: thanks for the quick update, let's try this out ;)
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
r7 was urmm let's say a beta version and I had lack of sleep ... Hope r7.1 will work better for you ;)
[Desire Android Development] :
r7.1 certainly fixes the cam and smartass wakeup. :)

By the way, if you want any beta testing done...give me a PM. :)

Edit, actually, it doesn't fix it. It seems to be *slightly* better but it still takes a load of power button presses to make it wake.
[Desire Android Development] TheDarkAngel666:
now perfectly working on defrost 6.0

very thx ;)
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
It simply does, thank you really: everything is fixed, a2sd partition is now correctly seen by quick system info and everything else works great. Haha, it feels like having a galaxy s now: i just hit 1963 on quadrant :D

Edit: 2003 at the third run, lol...
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
Razzee does the beta testing for me... think I was a little to quick with the release. And personally I don't have problems with wakeup. Maybe I set the Sleep Freq one step up more. Should solve the problem.

Nice one. Hope someday the 2000 will be reached :D
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Just hit, read my post above :D

I'll be uploading some screen soon...
[Desire Android Development] Razzee:
also no problems with wake up here :/
[Desire Android Development] Murd0ck:
are you clearing the cache inbetween tests or are you just starting the test again ?

clearing the cache/data gives a better picture of the score so i think.

on my desire with CM nightly and no setcpu

i get the scores without clearing cache:

1458

1691

1737

with clearing the cache/data and stopping the app inbetween tests:

1475

1470

1463

as you can see stopping app and clearing cache/data give more stable results
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
benee, i checked below file

/sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu0/cpufreq/scaling_governor

the file content is "ondemand", is it right? iirc you said it should be "interactive"
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
Best content would be smartass imo (for r7.1). Keep the cpu often at lower freqs so better batt.
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
adb shell echo "smartass >

/sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu0/cpufreq/scaling_governor"

is it?

i will wait someone full test it :)

btw, my phone is full rooted and s-off, can i just copy the scaling_governor and edit it content then replace to /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu0/cpufreq/ via root_explorer?
[Desire Android Development] :
Check which governor is actually active.

After a fresh reboot, mine states the following:

TripHop:~ WTisdale$ adb shell cat /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu0/cpufreq/scaling_governor
ondemand
TripHop:~ WTisdale$

Hence why you aren't having wakeup issues, because in reality you aren't actually using the smartass governor. I was manually changing the governor with setcpu before, but I've uninstalled that now to see if it made a difference.

Edit: Looked into it a bit more, and although the kernel was compiled with: CONFIG_CPU_FREQ_DEFAULT_GOV_SMARTASS=y

It seems to be ignoring that and setting it to ondemand anyway. Very odd.

Also figured out why it is doing that, init.bravo.rc contains the following lines:

# Power Management
write /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu0/cpufreq/scaling_min_freq 245000
write /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu0/cpufreq/scaling_max_freq 998400
write /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpu0/cpufreq/scaling_governor ondemand
write /sys/devices/system/cpu/cpufreq/ondemand/sampling_rate 40000
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Well idk...for sure if i wipe cache between the tests i get lower results (cachemate), but i'm not sure about stopping the apps: I mean, right after you killed em your system will be slower also because android is trying to restore all the apps that "he thinks he needs", imho...paradoxically you get better scores with half the ram busy, rather than when you have it all free. Just my 2 cents tho :)
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
arg yeah sure... hrm the problem is this is in the bravo vendor that everyone uses. So every Aosp mod gets this settings. Crap.

AnyKernel is in binary so i couldn't change this and I think the power managment things are for Cyano. Maybe I can manage it to create a own AnyKernel.zip which change this ...hrmm
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
It's over 9000!!!

Proud owner of a vorkKernel-powered desire ;)

Thanks again man, your job is the finest.

I think you should really pin this pic to the fist post: it just says it all :D
[Desire Android Development] ghmail2:
How much did you oc to hit this score?:)
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
I was maxed out @1152 mhz, scaling smartass ;)

On a side note: since a few minutes ago i'm having issues again (only with smartass ofc) when i try to wake the phone :(
[Desire Android Development] ziggy1001:
Yeah i had this Track ball wake seems unresponsive on smartass have to click it 2-3 times to wakeup:(

But FWIW quadrant score is much lower on default kernel with RC1 @1113 OC
[Desire Android Development] ghmail2:
yeah stock freq brings 1680+:)
[Desire Android Development] Johannes667:
same issue for me with smartass gov...
[Desire Android Development] ziggy1001:
I assume this works the same as Erasmux's smartass for the hero

On the Hero my phone would wake up from as low as 176 so maybe it's just a case of raising the minimum frequency when screen is off
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
how do you use smartass? via setcpu?
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Well actually you seem to be right: if i set a higher minimum it does wake up smoothly, but i think we should look at some other solution: Sense kernels with smartass governor allow to wake up the phone without any issue even if the minimum is set at 128 mhz..

Anyway what i'm really looking forward now is some slightly higher frequency: the latest kernel Benee has compiled runs stable like stock at 1152, and so i guess it would be quite stable even a bit above that, plus it would be hitting for sure 2000+ on quadrant all the time :)
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
hmm, 1152 mhz default??

i have no setcpu installed, and use Benee svs r7.1, my cpu runing at 1152mhz??
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Nope, it's not...by default you'll be using the stock frequency (998 mhz): if you wanna oc you can only do that via setcpu :)
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
thanks

hehe i want my phone running at 998mhz max.. i dont use setcpu and dont oc..
[Desire Android Development] Sarsippius:
Hi Benee, just confirming that I've flashed r7.1 successfully on MIUI 0.10.15 so it seems the a2sd fix has worked for this rom as well.

I'm also getting the wake issue when trying the smartass governor however I'm not so sure it's tied into min freq. In MIUI it seems 245 MHz is the lowest available freq, I tried testing in steps up to 499 MHz and it still had trouble waking from sleep.
[Desire Android Development] golf60:
You must hold the OJ for 1.5sec for wake up. Works perfect on MIUI. 29 with Quadrant 1923 . :-)
[Desire Android Development] ghmail2:
before post a benchmark pls make notice for oc score or at stock freq:)

it seems a oced score:)
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Hehe ofc it's oc'd..with no oc it should be like 1600+ anyway, not bad at all :)
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
i dont oc

i am happy with default freq, smooth and stable
[Desire Android Development] cap11:
win7x64 didn't find the sdcard, allthough desire showed no problems. switched back to the one from cm 6.1RC1 - problem is gone ...

otherwise i couldnt find any issue :-)
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
That's weird...anyway i don't think it's a kernel related issue: i got no problems at all here :)
[Desire Android Development] golf60:
IT was with full oc 1152mhz.
[Desire Android Development] rahul.pillai:
Running this on my Desire with CN6.1RC1 no issues thus far :)
[Desire Android Development] Radikaal:
Im also having wakeup issues, hope there is a way to get it fixed, as waking up just to check time is a big usage when on work...otherwise no problems so far. Using on opendesire .36 right now.

As for smartass being better for battery then ondemand im not so certain, as soon as i move something (scroll homescreens or in some list of somekind) cpu moves up to maxfreq and doesnt clock down until i stop moving. Hope also there is a way to make smartass default governor as i dont like having to use setcpu.

1870 quadrant here OC but guess its because of app2d+ that slows down sd card very much, would probally be 2k+ without it (class 10 card)
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Yep i hope to get the wake issue sorted soon. Anyway it only affects smartass governor, and i guess i can live without it for now.

Quadrant gives high scores here too, if you see a couple pages back i managed to get 2010, the best i ever scored on a Desire...anyway avg score is 1900+, pretty damn good :)
[Desire Android Development] ghmail2:
Is moded gpu driver already inklusiv in this kernel?
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
dunno, but i dont play game heh
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Well i know that stock CM6.1 kernel has it, and seeing that r7.1 performs even better both on neocore benchmark and in the 3d section of quadrant advance makes me think that the gpu+ is definitely inside the package ;)
[Desire Android Development] ziggy1001:
Interesting ;)

i have changed kernels now so can't test but on the stock RC1 kernel with ondemand you simply press (no need to hold down) and screen is restored so sadly 1.5 secs is to me a lag
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Yeah it's not the way it's meant to be, it's a bug lol :)

Anyway it does only affect the smartass governor, no biggie...
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
I just flashed latest 32.49.00.32U_5.11.05.27 radio, i found when i press power button to wake up phone, it's still black screen, i have menu button wake up too, 40% chance to wake up my phone.

i use "ondemamnd"

flashed back to 32.46.00.32U_5.10.05.17_2 , phone works fine as before
[Desire Android Development] Sarsippius:
Hi Benee, as mentioned earlier I use MIUI 0.10.15 and had to jump from r5 to r7.1 because of the a2sd issue.

I use Rockplayer to play generic xvid/avi video files, using r5 they play fine but with r7.1 the playback is choppy. I've gone back and forth between r5 and r 7.1 to confirm the issue. I thought it might be due to slow read speed from the SD Card but r5 gives me Write/Read speed of 3/8 and r7.1 2/9 so it doesn't seem to be the issue.

Unfortunately I can't flash r6 to test if was first introduced in that release.

Anyone using OD or CM have the same problem?
[Desire Android Development] ghmail2:
Rockplayer all fine on OD4.0.23+r7.1 you'd better not to use this kernel on miui

that rom is heaviley moded than other aosp roms.the kernel from miui team is already good:)
[Desire Android Development] bolek76:
hi my friend i'm having the same problem with OD.4.036 and CM6.1 i'll try OD4.0.23
[Desire Android Development] Murd0ck:
I´m getting the same sleep problem as the others.

Rom: CM nightly 10/24-2010 - S-Off(N1 Table)

Radio: 5.10.05.17

Kernel: 2.6.35.8-vorkKernel vork@vork #4

seems i only get it in smartass mode. changed to ondemand and that fixed it.
[Desire Android Development] cigga33:
Download link?
[Desire Android Development] :
I would imagine if you read the first post you will find the download links. :rolleyes:
[Desire Android Development] :
Yeah, the smartass governor needs fixing. I might even have a hack around with it myself.
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Feel free to share, if you do ;)
[Desire Android Development] :
https://github.com/thalamus/DevNullKernel/commit/1aca3e735d51e3067136670f400b5150bccd9445

Solves the wake issue with smartass.
[Desire Android Development] Johannes667:
Can you post a update.zip ? Thx for your work!
[Desire Android Development] Benee:
Just a little beta r8. Please use ADB/Setcpu and set your min freq to 384000 Mhz and report if you still have wakeup problems with smartass. And report if overall performance is better/worse.
[Desire Android Development] Johannes667:
For me the wake up bug already excists
[Desire Android Development] Razzee:
after flashing r8 and setting the mhz?
[Desire Android Development] golf60:
Same here. Wake up prob already excist. No change.
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Looks like my recovery doesn't see the file, weird...

Edit: fixed, but i had to flash via fake flash...i wonder what's wrong with amonRA at times :(

As to the new kernel: issues don't seem to be gone...the only way i can wake the phone up using that governor is having a sleep profile active. Otherwise the phone takes some time to wake, as usual (even at 384 mhz minimum).

Performance wise i might have noticed a slight buff in the 3d section of quadrant, and it seems like i'm getting close to 2000 final score a little more often :)
[Desire Android Development] Razzee:
for benee and for me, our wakeup problems seems to have gone completely
[Desire Android Development] :
No, the wake problem still exists for me and I confirmed that sleep_max_freq was at 384000.

The only thing that fixed the wake problem for me with smartass was the hack I did earlier which disabled the inbuilt 'sleep profile'.

I don't believe that there is any benefit in using smartass anyway. From the crude testing I have done, it looks to me as if the system would be more responsive with ondemand than with either smartass or interactive.
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
hmm, no one have problem with latest radio 5.11.5.27? just me?
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
I don't use that one cause it's battery drainer..i would recommend you to switch to the one in my sig: it grants great battery life, and i didn't notice any issue till now :)
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
what's the diff between 32.44.00.32U_5.09.05.30_2 and 32.44.00.32U_5.09.05.30 ?

i just want to say with latest 5.11.5.27 radio, my phone 60% can't wake up and sometimes black screen when using....
[Desire Android Development] vnvman:
Actually there aren't outstanding differences i guess (as usal between most radios), the .30 is from some relatively recent orange ota update, while .30_2 is a little bit older. Anway they're both good and well rated by users on most roms in terms of battery life, but as a matter of fact i can't use .30_2 because it gives me issues during conversations under 3G: my voice sounds creepy, some people told me :D

As to .27 i tried it out and didn't get any of the issues you're talking about, it just seemed to drain more, so i dropped it.

How did you flash it? Recovery or fastboot? It's not recommended to flash radios via recovery, maybe your issues depend on that...
[Desire Android Development] ourfear:
yes i flash radio via recovery. but only the latest radio .27 has problem with r7.1

now i flashed Radio: 32.48.00.32U_5.10.05.30 via fastboot, so far so good :-)
[Desire Android Development] suiller:
installed over cm6.1... all works perfectly :cool:
[Desire Android Development] EViollet:
112 Mhz

Hi.

Could it be possible to add 128 Mhz to the kernel frequencies?

I used to have that on my LeeDroid kernel, but now, with DeFrost I can't seem to find a kernel that supports it. And I find the idle battery usage *much* higher.

So I'd love to try a kernel that runs @128...

In advance, thanks.
[Desire Android Development] :
Would a frequency that low even work?
[Desire Android Development] EViollet:
It worked on LeeDroid with snq's kernel. And even Richard Trip had a Sense kernel with that frequency if I remember well.
[Desire Android Development] sfjuocekr:
7.1 sporadic sleep issues.

8 sleep issues all the time!

edit: I have conservative set in SetCPU when screen is off so it's not smartass related?
[Desire Android Development] :
Try increasing your minimum frequency. There isn't really much point in swapping to conservative when sleeping. It'll still scale up if it needs to.
[Desire Android Development] xtcislove:
Only with this Kernel my Desire (Cyan Nightly 164) can Install all apps with Titanium Backup to Froyo App2SD ! All other "Kernel" have reboots at this!

Deutsche Wertarbeit was? ;-)

Edit: Which Radio I should use??
[Desire Android Development] sfjuocekr:
Same problem with minimum frequency up one notch.

Also the conservative governor scales up the cpu more slowly, I have used this for ages like this and never had problems with using it during sleep.