yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Latruffy:
Hello,

I've got the same issue as you with the images lineage-21.0-20240424-UNOFFICIAL-arm64_bvN.img (boot KO=>loop) and lineage-21.0-20240217-UNOFFICIAL-arm64_bvN.img (boot OK).

Also with bgN images.

Smartphone : SM-A505FN/DS (Samsung Galaxy A50),

TWRP 3.7.0_11-GiovanYCringe

@AndyYan : Could you please explain why, and eventually how to work around ?

Many thanks
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rfresh:
for people getting boot loop issue, I am also having same trouble from this GSI image

lineage-21.0-20240424-UNOFFICIAL-a64_bvS.img.xz

device is CAT S22 flip, and we are booting LOS 18 just fine

Sent from SM-S918U1 using ReLabs
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] AndyYan:
I could summon the keyboard just fine on my devices. Given your device arch, I suspect 32bit was removed from AOSP keyboard? A log would help confirm that.

I myself find Gboard to be a drop-in replacement of it. What would this keyboard be irreplaceably useful for? (SetupWizard maybe?)

I cannot explain to you what Google has done, otherwise one of us would've fixed it...?

I'm not too keen on working on Sammys myself. At this point your best bet is to try TD-AOSP releases as they come out.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rw_on_xda:
for a log it's too late; switched to your last LOS20 (with full setup: all apps I need, etc.)

32 bit removed (?): your lineage-21.0-20240217-UNOFFICIAL-a64_bvS.img was running without keyboard errors.

well, also somewhat too late, but while I have been in recovery (TWRP) and before I flashed LOS20 I fetched a log (adb shell dmesg > dmesg.txt):

lot of "avc denied" in there...

===

dmesg.txt attached

as said fetched while being under recovery
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] AndyYan:
Not really useful here...

Thanks for this info, I usually test *S builds, so while unlikely, I gotta check *N...
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rw_on_xda:
@AndyYan

any hints to get a usefull log, so the keyboard bug could be nailed ?

will try the buggy ROM again then (the next days ...)
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rfresh:
CAT S22 FLIP boot up successfully, thanks a lot, I wonder what stopped boot with latest a64 bvS ROM, will see

Sent from SM-S918U1 using ReLabs
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] stanley321:
Will there be Gapps build as in the old bgN build?
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Themjbrand:
@AndyYan i can boot your February build of lineage os 21 td but the latest build wont boot on my Lenovo tab m10 x505x
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rfresh:
how can we install gapps in the ROM if it is not included ?

Sent from SM-S918U1 using ReLabs
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] stanley321:
Wondering the same. Put mindthegapps into the gsi image manually?
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rfresh:
would that work? 🤔

Sent from SM-S918U1 using ReLabs
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Themjbrand:
Maybe 🤷
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rfresh:
how to add gapps into system.img?

Sent from SM-S918U1 using ReLabs
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] stanley321:
You are at the wrong post, that build is the Light build.

The current TD build has no Gapps.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] joselap:
You are right, my mistake
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] 86chan:
Hello, it's been a while.

My apologies for my absence and lack of response to your previous messages.

I had some free time recently, so I tried out TD 20240508 and the latest Light version (lineage-21.0-20240518-UNOFFICIAL-gsi_arm64_gN.img.xz) on DSU. It seems that the bugs I mentioned previously have been fixed. No more reboot loops! And I can even use dual pane view!

Thank you very much. I'm looking forward to the latest TD-based builds!!

P.S. As an aside, I think I might be okay with the Light version.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rfresh:
can I use this version on my arm32-binder64 device ?

Sent from SM-S918U1 using ReLabs
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] 86chan:
Is this for a64? It seems that build is not available for Light.

[GSI][14] LineageOS 21 "Light"

LineageOS is a free, community built, aftermarket firmware distribution of Android, which is designed to increase performance and reliability over stock Android for your device. LineageOS is based on the Android Open Source Project with extra...

xdaforums.com

Andy Yan's personal builds // GSI - Browse /lineage-21-light at SourceForge.net

sourceforge.net

However, I believe you have TD-based versions available, so please check if there are any updates.

Andy Yan's personal builds // GSI - Browse /lineage-21-td at SourceForge.net

sourceforge.net

Generic System Image (GSI) list

Notes about tinkering with Android Project Treble. Contribute to phhusson/treble_experimentations development by creating an account on GitHub.

github.com
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rfresh:
Thanks I have tried 0424 release and I got bootloop issue

Sent from SM-S918U1 using ReLabs
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Themjbrand:
I can't boot the latest version but i been not February may i know the reason behind it
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] AndyYan:
Certainly.

Don't try to daily-drive TD AOSP builds, they're mostly there as a base for comparison/verification. (Goes for you too - @rfresh )

Please stop asking over and over - I'm not capable of giving a technical explanation on this one, and after you told me what kind of bootloop it is, I don't even know how to debug it to begin with...
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Themjbrand:
Ok now I'm sure you're not capable so I won't ask instead I'll just switch to another gsi
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] AndyYan:
Should be as simple as "adb logcat" then triggering the keyboard crash.

BTW, I'm still unable to replicate a crash on a 64VN build (screnshot below) - I really have to count on you to provide a valid log here.

I'd actually encourage you to - if you find another

post-QPR2

GSI that does work, the upstream source of that ROM likely contain something TD could use.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Heeni:
For fun, I installed https://github.com/TrebleDroid/treble_experimentations/releases/tag/ci-20240508 on my Lenovo TB-8505F, and it doesn't crash when I go online. It's been running quite well for a few days. The AOSP keyboard crashes, but it was easy enough to install another keyboard over adb.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] AndyYan:
I believe this has been specifically handled in 0508 by an sepolicy patch, as I've seen the same on my R vendor devices and fixed that by picking such.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] AndyYan:
Updated all variants with May security patches and in sync with TD 20240508. [Insert obligatory backup-and-test warning here]

TD upstream has a few new patches that try to improve the QPR2 situation, could be worth a try.

Two-pane Settings for tablets is back.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Themjbrand:
Just curious what kernel version is yours
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rfresh:
I am going to give it a try, appreciate your great effort
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rw_on_xda:
tested was: system-td-arm32_binder64-ab-vanilla.img.xz

at around 12:48 I tried to key in my wifi password: no keyboard came up.

went to setting, checked keyboard setting.

tried to create a folder in file manger: no keyboard came up and then a crash ( popup what said: info or close)

some minutes later (~13:14) I tried again to key in a wifi password: again a crash ( popup what said: info or close)

logcat attached (*.zip)

====

and tried lineage-21.0-20240525-UNOFFICIAL-a64_bvS.img

hangs at the spinning logo....
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rfresh:
Thanks for your great update, I was able to boot successfully on my cat s22 flip and UI is beautiful, I am also going to try other things like VOLTE support, the great thing is that I can have gapps now...

Thanks a lot
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] AndyYan:
Quickly checked, it crashed when setting up something related to emoji, however I don't immediately see why it'd do that only on some images (*N, as you said).

TD AOSP uses unaltered LatinIME source from Google, this eliminates factors from LOS or TD sources at least.

As I don't have a unit that could replicate this, best I could do would be blindly try fixing and then building APKs for you to install on top. I feel it's not worth the back and forth, when it could be replaced by any other...

Is it a regression from 0424? Please also logcat it if possible.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rw_on_xda:
No, see comment #94, was the same.

log attached: boot up with spinning logo; tested was lineage-21.0-20240525-UNOFFICIAL-a64_bvS
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Eula13:
my device got stuck endlessly at the spinning logo despite TD 20240508 booting fine for me
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] stopsmokingweed:
i have one device with kernel 4.14.186

but I didn't bring it this time and I'm still outside.

wait about 30 minutes, when I get back home I'll try the latest build.

***

Hmmm... TD based LOS 20240525 won't boot.

Stuck on boot animation.

But fine with TD 20240508.

I'm going to turn it off again and put it back in the drawer until next image release to test it.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] AndyYan:
Looks like I missed something somewhere...?

This one has a bit of info, but without context and drowned in unrelated kernel messages.

Would be great if you could logcat during the bootanimation loop, OS logs would be much more readable. cc @rw_on_xda @Eula13
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] stopsmokingweed:
Edited:

Hi @AndyYan it turns out there are lots of errors related to BPF in this log:
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] rw_on_xda:
already there: comment #158

what is meant by "OS logs" ?
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Starkshade:
Dear AndyYan, could you please key-sign your GSI builds so that the ROMs pass Google's DEVICE_INTEGRITY check and we mortal users can use Google Wallet again? As of today 25 May, Custom LoS ROMs pass only BASIC_INTEGRITY level...
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Heeni:
Kernel version is 4.9.190+
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] DarkestSpawn:
@AndyYan I was just gonna send you something on this because I can't recall if they are test keys for yours. They are still in the process of 100% confirming this but as of right now it is pointing to anything signed with test-keys or banned keys for a Custom ROM will flag DroidGuards system via Play Integrity.

It's around a few pages before and a few pages after this post.

Adding this as well as it looks very helpful.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] AndyYan:
Very useful!

Looks like I messed up redoing the p_m_Connectivity patches this month - retrying today.

I also dug into my pile of legacy devices, and found exactly one device that became Treble-ready after flashing device-specific LOS, and crashes like this after flashing my image, so it seems we don't need to waste time on back and forth with test builds.

Previously I would write this off as optional; we still couldn't do it now, but for another reason that PHH had pointed out recently - IMS APKs have to be signed with the same keys as the OS. Either all GSIs sign with one key, or everyone host their own set of persoanlly signed IMS APKs, and Google can still trivially ban either way, forcing us to re-sign everything and constantly flashing data migration builds. I don't know how to deal with this losing fight...
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Themjbrand:
Hey @Heeni which version of td rom for you download arm32 binder 64 or just arm 64 please tell because I also want to download
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Heeni:
I used the arm64 version.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Heeni:
This version is running on the Lenovo TB-8505F with internet connection. AOSP keyboard crashes but I've installed Heliboard which works well. Everything else seems to work well, keeping in mind that it's a WiFi-only tablet (no SIM, calling etc), and I'm not trying to avoid root detection.

Many thanks for keeping things going!
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] AndyYan:
Will update a batch of builds in a few hrs, that fixes at least the BPF-related bootloops I can replicate here.

The legacy device I found also happens to be able to replicate the keyboard crash. Now I know it's because the native lib for the input method isn't loading, but I'm still scratching my head over why it's only these select devices...
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] stopsmokingweed:
It also happened to me with TrebleDroid 20240508.

Android Keyboard (AOSP) keeps stopping.

But I got around it with OpenBoard from f-droid.org
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] AndyYan:
Updated all variants with one BPF fix. [Insert obligatory backup-and-test warning here]

If you didn't get bootanim loops with 0525, you don't need to flash this one, as it'd be otherwise identical.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] stopsmokingweed:
20240526 booted fine, thanks

Although the keyboard problem still persists.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Eula13:
it booted fine now, thank you. apologies I wasn't able to provide logs that you asked.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] skills14:
Updated my Samsung SM-T510 with latest version via TWRP and flashing system image,

All working so far apart from AOSP crashing, installed Florisboard from fdroid which was fine,

Thanks for the hard work Andy
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Medionato:
What do I have to consider if I want to update from lineage-21.0-20240217-UNOFFICIAL-arm64_bgN to lineage-21.0-20240526-UNOFFICIAL-arm64_bgN.img? It should just involve updating the Google security patch - right?
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] AndyYan:
Jumping across the QPR2 gap, quote the warning:
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] Medionato:
My device has not dynamic system patition. The device is a Unihertz Titan (UFS). DSU-Sideloader do not work.

Seedvault Backup is complete. I would only delete the cache with fastboot and then flash the lineage-21.0-20240526-UNOFFICIAL-arm64_bgN.img. If the device is then bricked, I go to the direct installation of the desired GSI-LOS version via the reinstallation of A10-Stock-ROM.
[Treble-Enabled Device Development A/AB ROMS] divinnng:
Could you support 5G on Samsung S24+？

Andy小哥，可以支持5g嘛？我刷了所有的类原生ROM，都是上网支持5g，但是电话和短信只支持2g、4g，甚至在5g下好几天都无法接听到电话。另外就是指纹识别，你的ROM不支持，但VoltageOS支持，它是唯一支持的。感谢Andy小哥的用爱发电
[Android Head-Units] Marwen365:
Is there anyway to disable the album name from the home?

View attachment 6062876

Mt8163

View attachment 6062877
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] starbucks2010:
Latest Version v1.5 [24/07/2024]

ROM Maintainer: Andrei @starbucks2010​

ROM Info:

Supported devices: S24 Ultra SM-S928B, S24+ SM-S926B & S24 SM-S921B

ROM Base: S92xBXXS3AXFE (Android 14 OneUI 6.1) July 2024 Patch Level

ROM Features:

Kernel:

Stock Samsung kernel

CSC features:

Call Recording

Internet speed meter on statusbar

AppLock Enabled

ROM Disarm:

Light ROM debloat

Patched Samsung SmartWatch pairing

Modded Settings/Service

s

Screenshots in secure apps allowed

Phone status: Official

Software Info ROM Details

Back2Kill

Fixes:

Galaxy watch pairing

Remember BT pairing after reboot

Secure Folder

Other Tweaks/Mods:

Various build prop and CSC tweaks

Pre-rooted with Magisk canary 27001

ROM constraints:

The encryption is ON by default

Needs to install Magisk 27.x app after ROM flash

For SafetyNet and GWallet you must install latest Play Integrity Fix/Next magisk module and enable Zygisk

The ROM contains only OXM group CSCs. People with CSC other than the ones from the OXM group should flash their HOME_CSC region file of they'll get stuck on the choosing language screen after BR flashing

Not working

Knox related apps: Samsung Pay, Samsung AutoFill

Changelog

v1.5

- ODIN flashing ROM

- Based on the latest firmware AXFE OneUI 6.1 July 2024 FW

- Patched with magisk canary 27004

- S24U S928B has now removed force encryption and TWRP is included in the rom zip (you'll have to wipe data to be able to make full use of TWRP)

#######################

PREVIOUS VERSION

#######################

v1.4

- ODIN flashing ROM

- Based on the latest firmware AXEF OneUI 6.1 June 2024 FW

- Patched with magisk canary 27001

Credits

- John Wu for Magisk

- Mr. Waehere for his great kitchen and support

- LeeXDA18 for help with knox/VK removal and more fixes

- 3arthur6 for bt patch

- the elite team of ROM testers

- dutchman89 for Beyond boot logo

- archer for TWRP

- If you like my work and want to support me, consider buying me a coffee (PayPal link)

Download Links

CURRENT VERSION

###########################

SM-S928B ROM Link AXFE [BR1.5]

###########################

SM-S926B ROM Link AXFE [BR1.5]

###########################

SM-S921B ROM Link AXFE [BR1.5]

###########################

USEFUL LINKS

###############################

BeyondROM S24 Telegram

If you like my work, support me and buy me a coffee (PayPal link)

Installation:

Spoiler content hidden.

Happy flashing good people ! :)
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] starbucks2010:
reserved
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] tids2k:
Lovely.
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] exocetdj:
Awesome 👌
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] tareksaf:
This firmware fix vivid mode issue ?
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] Gytole:
If samsung hasn't released a fix yet. Then no.
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] luisnica98:
Hi Andrei, Im glad to see that you started a project for Galaxy s24. Im from central america. I tried the ROM but I got stuck on choosing a language. I coldnt replace csc because I couldnt find a diferente firmare en samfirmware.
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] donkeyman1234:
Does this rom apply to SM-S9280 ?
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] starbucks2010:
nobody tried yet ... did you already rooted your device?
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] donkeyman1234:
Still waiting for my device.

Got my SM-S9280 and rooted. Thanks for Dr.ketan help.
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] luisnica98:
I now know what I did wrong. When I was choosing de language, I chose spanish mexican. I should have choosen spanish Spain ( Spain belong to that CSC region)
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] SupFlynn:
decent
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] starbucks2010:
BR11 has been updated to the latest AXBG A14 OneUI6 fw March 2024 patch level.

Happy flashing good people! :)
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] thiefxhunter:
Thanks!
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] maurit43:
Hello everybody ! I have the question. The post Say that the last versión es AXBG but my phone update to AXBL with march 1 security .

Sam Mobile Say they dame, the last versión is AXBG with march 1 security.

Can someone explain me? Thanks You do much
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] exocetdj:
different areas may have a slightly different firmware version but basically the firmware is 100% the same 99% of the time (the only variation to this could be if a certain area receives a major update later than another and has a different security patch)

As far as im aware, our good dev usually bases his roms on EUX country service code (CSC) firmware (AXBG this month) and INS (india) CSC has the AXBL firmware number as they received the March patch update later than EUX (europe)
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] maurit43:
Do You recomend someone better than other? Because on sammobile pague appear firmware from europea but don't from each country/carrier
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] exocetdj:
They will both work on your device if you currently can see OXM in the software version number on your phone under settings -> software info.

They are most likely exactly the same In terms of changelog
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] maurit43:
Thanks foto answerme. My phone is owo
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] maurit43:
S928b/ds ( i read that the firmware is they same single sim)
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] tnchng:
I need the v1.6 For Android 13, can you offer the download link. Thx in advance.
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] lupin57:
Hi Bro,

U're in a S24 thread here and is natively ... A14 !

Last version is 1.1 as mentionned in OP !

Why are u talking about a 1.6 ? :unsure:
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] tnchng:
Sorry, I thought S23 Ultra.
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] miguel.ocon@gmail.com:
Hi,

I just installed the rom and I don't know if there is any way to install third-party apks since it gives me the same error as if I were not rooted.
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] JAllanz:
It seems kind of counterproductive because if you've rooted your phone with other Dr keaton's method or the no white encryption of or white encryption with either the homes CSC or the other CSC then you can put together your own modules pretty much but easier and quicker
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] JAllanz:
And it's easy enough to get rude because you just take the AP and the bl for folder from the stock ROM and you extract it separately and then you isolate the initial.boot image and the VB meta image and then you archive them together in seven zip and the new magnet off and then just along with you put them in the AP file and then the rest of the stock film there files you don't extract you're doing anything just check them in they see Pete bl in CSC file and then flashing with Odin the latest Odin and yeah I should probably stop using Google for the voice commands because that's probably doesn't make much sense

It's 24 ultra which here is like about 3,000 I assumes I've got it out the box I plug the f***** in in started rooting it I mean yeah have some balls pressed flash try things
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] starbucks2010:
BR12 has been updated to the latest AXCA A14 OneUI6.1 fw April 2024 patch level.

Happy flashing good people! :)
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] wadiegsm:
Hello sir , i want to known if this firmware can use its for bypass knox guard security. thank's in advance, ihave S928B Bit1 OEM OFF and KG BROKEN .
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] shepshep07400:
Hello, i have the same problem, have you find a solution ?
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] Elfomze:
Hello! First-time Samsung user here. This looks really nice!

What is the process for applying ota/incremental updates on a rooted s24u? When using this rom, do you have to patch its files in magisk and then flash them via Odin?

Sent from ONEPLUS A5010 using ReLabs
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] wadiegsm:
Finaly i have S928B b1;patcheded rom without knox files no kg relock after format ,contact me in whatsap +212667053835 for more info
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] starbucks2010:
BR13 has been updated to the latest AXD6 A14 OneUI6 fw May 2024 patch level.

Happy flashing good people! :)
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] narf0815:
Hello!

i just flashed my S24 S921B (no plus, no ultra) but something went wrong.

every went just as expected until

After the reboot i got this error:

after 3 retries ("Try again") i did the factory data reset and then the phone bootet into BeyondROM (at least the logo appeared on boot up) but the was no magisk app installation routine and the phone is not rooted.
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] narf0815:
edit: what was i supposed to do with the file "Magisk-3d91a561(27001).apk" (which is in the zip archive from openening post)?
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] miguel.ocon@gmail.com:
The speed meter disappeared in this update, is there a way to recover it?
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] starbucks2010:
install it
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] starbucks2010:
BR14 has been updated to the latest AXEF A14 OneUI6.1 fw June 2024 patch level.

Happy flashing good people! :)
[Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra] JazonX:
Hey @starbucks2010

Any insight or help on this is really appreciated bro!

What's required to make Native Applock work in new Firmware?

Asking out of frustration as the app no longer works as intended. (I got System R/W + Root) * Added below line to the CSC applock * Added the...

xdaforums.com