yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] ashish1989:
I also renamed magisk, and I have switched to delta version from official one

Will try shamiko now

Only basic integrity is passed, what to do now?
[Magisk] zgfg:
With Delta you don't need Shamiko - and better don't use
[Magisk] ashish1989:
Then what is the solution to my problem?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Have you tried Delta (Canary, latest), MagiskHide, Zygisk, Hide My Apps

If you don't pass Device Integrity (HMA is irelevantan for PI/SN), use Displax USNF
[Magisk] konaeru:
is it an old version of ldplayer? Try using the latest
[Magisk] ashish1989:
Installed magisk canary latest, renamed the magisk to random package name. Enabled magisk hide and configured the desired apps. In integrity checker app device integrity and basic integrity is passed but not strong integrity. Still IndusMobile app is detecting root. Any recommendations?
[Magisk] 73sydney:
its normal for strong to fail

you seem to have skipped shamiko.... as i posted (and linked to) or you otherwise forgot to mention it above...its also entirely possible that what worked for me may not work for you....this is not an exact science...unlike round earth theory...

also dont forget to force close the offending app and clear its data under Storage before reopening once you make changes like everything mentioned...
[Magisk] ashish1989:
But shamiko is for zygisk, and I have not enabled zygisk in delta canary
[Magisk] 73sydney:
you said in last post:

Installed magisk canary latest

if youre not using official magisk canary (and when you post Installed magisk canary latest we assume rightly you mean "official magisk"), please specify youre using Delta, otherwise youre going to be sending people off on tangents and wasting their time :)

i posted you a complete working set up in magisk official, if you quote my post without disclosing youre NOT using the same magisk as i am, then youre not helping yourself and youre effectively wasting my time trying to figure out why the method i know works isnt working for you :) :)

Try a mix of magiskhide with/without zygisk until you get something that hopefully works, otherwise, accept the already posted solution using official magisk, which we refer to as just magisk...(i even specifically tagged it as official just to be unmistakable.)...because it is the official and original, all others are forks and should be declared to avoid this exact thing :)

Please take more care in reading what others have written, and when youre describing what youre using in future please :) And if youre not sure, we accept there are sometimes language barriers, feel free to make sure by repeating the question or referencing the part you dont get
[Magisk] zgfg:
I enable Zygisk in Delta, I don't use Shamiko and I don't need USNF (in Delta)

However, I use Zygisk-LSPosed (with some LSPosed modules) and Hide My Apps.

There is a separate guide for HMA - search in XDA

For Strong Integrity you were answered above - you cannot trick Trusted Execution Environment. If not familiar with, use Search in XDA, it was discussed in details in other threads

PS: Some ppl use Riru with Delta, I don't and cannot guide about (in that case you must not enable Zygisk)
[Magisk] ashish1989:
Bro its a delta thread, that's why I didn't find important to specifically name it
[Magisk] zgfg:
Why don't you try with Magisk Canary official, the sane way that 73sydney reported that it worked for him?
[Magisk] Arealhooman:
Is the current magisk canary different then the stable version? Is there a update log for it?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Go to the official TJW GitHub page, check the version numbers for Stable vs Canary and compare. If you dig, you will find Changelogs, etc.
[Magisk] 73sydney:
I see why you might have done that, but its a good idea to specify

We talk about Delta in the official Magisk threads too, but we always make sure to refer to it as Delta

Its understandably to avoid confusion....

Cheers
[Magisk] Arealhooman:
Nothing to compare
[Magisk] ashish1989:
Installed magisk official now, renamed the app, configured the deny list, installed shamiko. Still the same problem
[Magisk] zgfg:
Are you talking about this app:

IndusMobile : Digital Banking - Apps on Google Play

Open Savings Account, UPI, Fund Transfer, Pay Bills, Recharge & Credit Card

play.google.com

If so, I got it working with no troubles:

- Magisk Delta Canary latest 4c384ddd 25205

- Zygisk and MagiskHide enabled

- IndusMobile enabled in MagiskHide (rebooted)

I don't have Shamiko, USNF.

For IndusMobile I even didn't need to bother with Hide My Apps

Screenshots attached
[Magisk] ashish1989:
Yes, this is the app. But I don't know why it is not working for me now, 2 days earlier it was working as expected
[Magisk] zgfg:
First this is off-topic for this Delta thread - if you are asking about official

Second, Stable is 25200 and Canary is 25205

Third, sorry I will not bother with this anymore, I'm really not interested in, have no time for and you CAN FIND everything yourself on the GitHub (release dates, Changelogs, etc), you need to know using GitHub or to spend some time and play
[Magisk] zgfg:
This is official Stable 25200. Sydney73 reported success with Canary 25205
[Magisk] ashish1989:
How to switch to canary?
[Magisk] Arealhooman:
Download canary and install magisk from that app. My question is will it make you lose all ur modules and super user approvals?
[Magisk] 73sydney:
did you as i have suggested a few times now, at any point wipe app data for that app?

Something weird is up because netiher zgfg or myself had to do any real work to have it working for us, i suspect if i disabled shamiko it would probably work....

in fact i just tried it...disabled shamiko, rebooted, installed the app fresh, added to Deny List (enforced)...works....so all i have is:

- a passing integrity check

- usnf mod 2 installed

- magisk hidden (renamed)

- app in the deny list and enforced (as no shamiko)

This would come under the "very easy to defeat" column

also worth remembering this isnt an exact science, what works for me may not work for you, have you got *any* other modules installed? this includes font modules, as they can trigger root detection...people often dont list those because they think font modules are benign/harmless...or custom recovery folder like TWRP on internal memory?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Actually, you don't even need to bother with GitHub

Assuming you eg have Magisk app Canary (official) installed

Change Update Channel to Stable, go back to main page and read what it says for the latest available Magisk Stable app (25200)

Click to Install (you will not need to install) and it will show you the corresponding Changelog - scroll down to read the full

Change the Update channel to Canary, go again to the main page and read the available latest app version (25200).

Click to install (without really installing) and check the Changelog.

Actually, by scrolling down you can read the Changelog diff from 25200
[Magisk] ashish1989:
Don't know but something is screwed up. Done every step as you recommended. No other module installed
[Magisk] 73sydney:
its weird....

can you perhaps try running Ruru and see whats detected

Releases · byxiaorun/Ruru

An android sample app of detecting suspicious apps like magisk manager - byxiaorun/Ruru

github.com
[Magisk] zgfg:
If you are staying with official, switching between Stable (25200) and Canary (25205) will not affect your modules, DenyList, root grants, etc

But if Magisk app was hidden, unhide before switching
[Magisk] ashish1989:
How much stupid I am, TWRP folder is creating havoc, deleted the folder and the app works normally now.
[Magisk] ashish1989:
@zgfg @73sydney is there any workaround for twrp folder
[Magisk] AnonVendetta:
Can you clarify?

"MagiskHide is denylist toggle"

"MagiskHide will keep Zygisk to be loaded for apps on denylist"

Does this mean that enabling MagiskHide is *THE SAME* as official Magisk's "enforce denylist"?

I'm not trying to hide root from a banking app. I'm trying to hide it from 2 online games. Apex Legends Mobile, and Call of duty: Warzone Mobile. I was recently invited by Activision to take part in a closed alpha test for WZM. I can play, but I suspect it's detecting Magisk. When not rooted, WZM runs normally for hours without crashes. When rooted, it randomly crashes, and constantly. As soon as I unroot, the crashes go away. The game gives no messages about detecting root, but I'm suspicious anyway.

Also, Momo app detects an abnormal environment even when Shamiko and Universal SN Fix are enabled ("data not encrypted" and "found Zygisk". It also detects unlocked bootloader.
[Magisk] huskydg:
Yes

Can you tell me how do you do when hiding root?
[Magisk] AnonVendetta:
Well, you say Shamiko will work regardless of whether enforce denylist is enabled. Maybe you mean with your custom Magisk only. But what I've read elsewhere says that enforce denylist must be disabled for Shamiko to work. So, I'm confused.

What I do:

Install the games, but not launch them

Enable Zygisk and MagiskHide in your custom Magisk

Add Apex and WZM to the denylist

Reboot

Launch both games.

In the case of Apex, it detects root and won't let me log in, it even gives a message saying playing on a rooted device isn't allowed. For WZM, it just randomly crashes when rooted but not when unrooted. No root related messages are given. For now, both games are working fine, with this custom Magisk.
[Magisk] Timmmmaaahh!:
This might be the issue. Disable Zygisk and/or make sure com.google.android.gms is added to the denylist.
[Magisk] AnonVendetta:
Zygisk and MagiskHide can't be enabled at the same time?
[Magisk] Timmmmaaahh!:
Ah, yes, of course they can. I was just suggesting that hiding com.google.android.gms may already fix your problem (if it wasn't hidden already) as this would address SafetyNet but if that didn't work it's worth trying to disable Zygisk (leaving MagiskHide enabled) as those games might be detecting Zygisk.
[Magisk] AnonVendetta:
Right now they're working normally. So I don't think any more action is necessary for now. Apex doesn't give a root detected message on launch, and the random WZM crashes haven't happened in the past couple of hours. Along with both added to denylist. So far I'm just using the safety net fix module, Shamiko, and Zygisk/MagiskHide both enabled.

I switched to this custom Magisk a few hours ago, wanted to give something else a try besides official. I was just confused if Shamiko would work or not, since @huskydg has said that enabling hide is the same as enabling "enforce denylist", and Shamiko isn't supposed to work with that enabled. But he has also said Shamiko will work regardless, so I guess that only applies to this custom Magisk, not official Magisk.

I also find it weird that Momo detects an abnormal environment and Zygisk. Even though a few safety net checker apps say that basic integrity/CTS profile are passing.
[Magisk] huskydg:
Safetynet only checks for bootloader status (usnf prevent this), root, emulatior, some props (fingerprint, device model, security patch date,...) and a few modifications
[Magisk] AnonVendetta:
I don't think it's currently common practice for online games to check SN. Pokemon Go is the only one I know of for sure that does. I play a handful of games online on mobile, most of them don't require hiding Magisk, etc. Obviously, checking SN makes sense for something like a banking app.
[Magisk] zecabra:
One question? i have the normal version of magisk installed, is it enough to install the magiskdelta app or do i have to flash it as well

Edit: after checking telegram, the answer is to flash
[Magisk] zgfg:
Today I installed Delta to test

Be aware that package name is not con.topjohnwu.magisk (as for the official TJW Magisk) but io.github.huskydg.magisk and for non-power users of Magisk who do not uninstall Magisk before switching to Delta it will cause troubles: two Magisk apps installed in parallel (TJW Magisk and Delta Magisk), Delta Magisk app asking for root grant but showing Magisk not installed, etc)

Even when I uninstalled TJW Magisk app, but I did not yet patch my boot.img with Delta, TJW Magisk stub 1.0 was appearing hence I again had two Magisk icons on the home screen)

Recommendation:

Who is not power user of Magisk to understand all those quirks, ie, who does not understand himself what is going on and how to solve:

Please stay on TJW Magisk or fully uninstall both TJW Magisk app and TJW Magisk itself before switching to Delta

---

Observations once the issues were resolved

First, since I had LSPosed already installed with three modules, I did not want to uninstall TJW Magisk to loose all that. Therefore I ititially had the issues as above, but quickly solved them when uninstalled TJW Magisk app, later its stub and when I finally patched boot.img by Delta and flashed

Then, all my modules I did have set when I was on TJW Magisk, root grants and DenyList configured were preserved

---

Also because of not wanting to waste time of resetting my LSPosed modules again, I had to keep my Zygisk-LSPosed

Therefore I have to have Zygisk enabled in Delta

Hence I have both enabled, Zygisk and MagiskHide

(As previously commented by others, there is no Enforce DenyList option, but that's 'hijacked' by MagiskHide when MagiskHide is enabled)

---

Now with both Zygisk and MagiskHide, and Momo in DenyList:

- Without Shamiko and UnmountDenyList, Momo detects Zygisk

- With Unmount DenyList module, Momo still detects Zygisk

- But with Shamiko, Momo does no more detects Zygisk (hence Shamiko really works although it complains that it was disabled bcs of DenyList 'being' Enforced)

---

No other issues or observations. Delta works fine. Thanks 👍
[Magisk] m0han:
I'm on the latest Magisk Delta; not with LSPosed Riru, but with LSPosed Zygisk. Is there anything I can do to make my Momo cleaner and if so, how to go about it? Should I use Riru? Should I uninstall HMA app?

https://xdaforums.com/t/discussion-magisk-the-age-of-zygisk.4393877/post-87095937
[Magisk] mrjuniork:
Has anyone tried to get the RaiPay app to work. And if so, what setup is being used?
[Magisk] BigChungus321:
I got it to work with Zygisk+Shamiko. I tried riru+magisk hide delta and it doesn't work though. I guess on certain apps shamiko works best and sometimes magisk hide works best.
[Magisk] m0han:
what versions of the above did you use? i think you stand a better chance with older delta.
[Magisk] BigChungus321:
Last update of riru and latest delta, I also added unshare and momohider on a later test and still failed to open RaiPay.
[Magisk] m0han:
try with delta 24.3 or earlier; you just might get lucky.
[Magisk] m0han:
I see a new Canary; but, there is no 'Update' button. MD5: 8a806c6f1589a8ea4a57afb834f01c50 is correct? Dirty-install ok?
[Magisk] casouzaj:
Latest Delta Debug (theoretically with DenyList and HideList split apart) has DenyList config menu vanished. As I rely on Shamiko and USNF in order to pass SN tests (i.e. I need Zygisk), I'm going back to TJW's Canary build for the time being.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Ok, you mean new Canary Delta...
[Magisk] zgfg:
I have it renamed to TWRP.bak, TWRP can find it for Backup

(I don't have TWRP app for Android installed, just TWRP recovery)
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Always worth checking the basics, especially when so little was needed by two of us in magisk to beat it, thats why i mentioend fonts and TWRP...i was actually betting on fonts, people almost never mention they have font modules installed, and you can go around in circles for days before they finally admit they have them installed :)

i was betting you were a font man :)

@zgfg always has the best and simplest hack for TWRP :)

also feel free to use whichever Magisk for you want....
[Magisk] rez3vil:
Hello,

I am using stable Magisk Delta as main and using MagiskHide. My YONO lite SBI banking app shows "sbunifiedcug error" I think it means it's detecting root? But my other banking app called IPPB works fine. Can someone pin point me what should I do?

Thank you.
[Magisk] ashish1989:
can you try running Ruru and see whats detected

Releases · byxiaorun/Ruru

An android sample app of detecting suspicious apps like magisk manager - byxiaorun/Ruru

github.com
[Magisk] 73sydney:
you kids need to learn to use Search, i cant believe we're still having to say this after all these years...

because i tested this weeks ago using official Magisk, and the link to that test is on the first page of test results using "SBI" as the search term

at least make an effort folks, please...memebers are not here to spoonfeed you every answer...youre expected to use search and make an effort....as i havent seen you before, heres your one free link

https://xdaforums.com/t/discussion-magisk-the-age-of-zygisk.4393877/post-87714721
[Magisk] rez3vil:
Hi this is what came out of Ruru. Can you tell what's missing?
[Magisk] ashish1989:
Hide the magisk app
[Magisk] rez3vil:
Hello, I am sorry if I am frustrating you because I have read posts here and I understand it gets frustrating to reply the same things to users over and over again. But please bear with me.

Before replying here, I did searched on the main thread but it showed me no mentioned of "Yono Lite SBI - Mobile Banking" app which is different version of "YONO SBI: Banking & Lifestyle".

On using Magisk Delta app and Magisk Hide, I could use the YONO SBI app with no problem, but they changed their requirement of OS to Android 9 few days back. I am on Redmi 5A and is on Android 8.1. So I changed to YONO Lite app.

I however cannot launch YONO Lite app with MagiskHide. I also use "IPPB Mobile Banking" and with MagiskHide it works fine. Only problem is YONO Lite app. I have disabled Developer options, deleted TWRP folders, changed names of the app but to no avail.

If I could I would just lock the bootloader and won't bother anyone, but I am financially low and I do not want to get in situation to brick my phone in the process.

Thank you.
[Magisk] rez3vil:
I have hid the Delta app with random package name, Ruru still shows the same errors.
[Magisk] ashish1989:
Is there any twrp folder present in your storage
[Magisk] rez3vil:
There is none, I had it but deleted it prior.
[Magisk] ashish1989:
Just checked the yono lite app, mine is stuck at first screen, using official stable magisk with shamiko and configured it in deny list too. I think the problem varies from person to person.
[Magisk] 73sydney:
I appreciate there was a different app name you were looking for and you did search for it (y)

For what its worth i just installed it, and using same setup (magisk official, shamiko) as the full app, had no issue running it...it hilariously again complained about and wouldnt run with Teamviewer installed, once Teamviewer was removed, it ran fine

As always, ymmv on another device
[Magisk] 73sydney:
if you have a root file manager, try checking /data/media and see if theres a TWRP folder mounted there....ive had that happen to me in the past

next i would check with Ruru to see if youre failing anywhere obvious

Releases · byxiaorun/Ruru

An android sample app of detecting suspicious apps like magisk manager - byxiaorun/Ruru

github.com
[Magisk] rez3vil:
I thank you both for helping me patiently and trying the app on your own device. I thank you.

I made the YONO Lite app work finally by renaming "25.2-delta-5.apk" to "25.2-delta-5.zip", went to TWRP recovery and flashed the same zip file. Then once device booted, I Installed the apk. This helped me got rid of the "sbunifiedcug" error and YONO Lite properly showed that "this device is rooted" error. Then I went to Delta app, Added apps back to MagiskHide and simply Uninstalled Magisk completely. This helped to un-root my device (I think) and my bootloader is still unlocked. Now I don't know if it retained the MagiskHide cofig files after uninstall or not, but the YONO Lite app is working now.

Honestly this is hassle to hide Magisk itself, and then hide MagiskHide over it and then completely hide whatever shenanigans you did to hide both of these. It's a headache and takes time for the user who is not keeping updated themselves with the development.

I did read the official Magisk development thread and they have been adding Shamiko to Zygisk now and will release on 2nd February. I read the developer had made those modules deprecated since someone stole their work. That's a blow to someone's hard work! I am glad though they are taking necessary measures to secure their release.

All in all, I do appreciate both of you for helping. Even though what I did is not a solution, but I hope this help someone new like me. Sorry about long paragraphs and clutter.

More power to you developers and creators!
[Magisk] HippoMan:
I have decided to purchase a Pixel 5. Can anyone confirm that the latest Magisk Delta can indeed be successfully flashed onto a Pixel 5 along with LSposed? The Pixel 5 is new (i.e., not refurbished), and it should arrive with factory Android 11 installed.

Ideally, I'm hoping that someone has actually installed Magisk Delta on such a Pixel 5 with Android 11 and LSposed and can report success.

Thank you in advance.
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Pixels are easy to root (hence why i returned to one after the continuining BS of owning a Samsung), 5 seconds version:

- unlock bootloader

- install latest factory image if there is one - you'll need to download latest anyways for boot image (boot.img) and just in case you bork things

- (unless you have a second device to patch an extracted boot image (boot.img)) reboot and install magisk manager, patch boot image (boot.img - extracted from latest factory image),

- reboot to fastboot mode

- fastboot flash magisk patched boot image (boot.img) - optionally fastboot boot the magisk patched boot image first to make sure it boots

Watch/bookmark this as your main new device page:

https://xdaforums.com/c/google-pixel-5.11335/

Then under guides theres this, (Homeboy is quite a comprehensive guide maker):

https://xdaforums.com/t/guide-root-...nlock-bootloader-pass-safetynet-more.4187609/
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Thank you!

However, I am asking if anyone has actually performed this exact procedure with a Pixel 5 under Android 11 and Magisk Delta, and if that person can confirm that it actually worked.

There are numerous messages in this and other threads about how to perform this upgrade. I am just wanting confirmation that someone has actually done all this with Magisk Delta on a Pixel 5 running Android 11, and that it was actually successful.

PS: In none of those threads/categories/discussions that you have pointed me to (nor in any other threads/categories/discussions that I have searched) has anyone said anything about successfully rooting a Pixel 5 with Magisk Delta under Android 11. Given that this is the Magisk Delta thread, I'm hoping that someone who reads this thread might confirm that they have successfully done so.

Once again, to be clear, I'm not asking how to root a Pixel 5 with Magisk Delta. That info is readily available. What I'm looking for is someone to confirm from personal experience that an A11-based Pixel 5 can indeed be successfully rooted via Magisk Delta.

Thank you again, very much.
[Magisk] Lulavc:
On telegram, the group link is expired. Saw the whole video and atc.
[Magisk] Arealhooman:
I have the link, if you need it.
[Magisk] Lulavc:
Would love. TY.
[Magisk] famaTV:
Many thanks ... Yes, it's 9.0.14 which is the only version that worked for me without issues.

I upgraded to the latest LDPlayer 9.0.30(9), installed the latest Delta Canary, enabled root, checked off system.vmdk writable option and installed delta successfully. However, when I reboot while enabling the root option in LDPlayer, I got the abnormal message but Delta is shown as installed. However, when I removed the enable root option from LDPlayer, it shows that Detla is not installed. Attached all screenshots. What should I do?

Could you or any of our friends here help please? Thanks
[Magisk] konaeru:
don't turn off root in ldplayer settings, just delete the su file in system /xbin to resolve the message that appears on Magisk
[Magisk] famaTV:
Hello,

I tried removing that file with 3 root file managers including ZArchiver, but always getting an error that it can't do it. Your guidance is truly appreciated. I even used a terminal with no luck.