yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] pndwal:
I have twice used an Xiaomi 'Authorised Account' holder to unbrick an older hardbricked MTK based device (Xiaomi MTK are notoriously easy to hard brick; even flashing a TWRPs build that's not properly matched will do this... QCom is recommended for modding and very brick-proof... Many custom mod projects on XDA for Xiaomi MTK were abandoned as Devs couldn't afford to run the risks)... I paid about $12 each time and gave permissions to the company in Vietnam after connecting with Team Viewer... Session, incl flashing while logged into Xiaomi thru connected Authorised account, took maybe 15 min each time... There are many sharks around but I'd checked out the special phone services offered by this small business carefully...

However I fear it won't be so easy now or for late Pixel...

EDL (Qualcomm) and similar were developed to the point where even unpowered (no battery connected) devices could be reflashed, but companies like Xiaomi began locking down EDL mode to Authorised agents citing security concerns (correctly in fact) as hack tests have demonstrated that by using certainly vulns and modified ROMs the data-wipe requirement when unlocking bootloader can be completely bypassed in emergency download modes and then data is easily accessible on stolen devices... please see my post re. critical device vulnerabilities using QCom's EDL mode and similar MTek Emergency Download protocol which effectively grant an attacker full device access due to these modes not simply allowing forced flashing of officially signed software, but also providing ability to disable secure boot and unlock the bootloader with NO LOSS of device data. https://xdaforums.com/re...tuck-da-mode-authorised-t4000433/post81563925... The cited XDA article on exploiting emergency download flash protocol gives more details.

Seems EDL and similar modes are now prohibited for regular users by most companies for the same security reasons, and new designs like Tensor may not even enable such a mode at all... It seems that P6 series users have not yet found confirmable means to recover a hard-bricked main board... Even Xiaomi Authorized Account holding agents are now like hens teeth as Xiaomi has revoked accounts for most of these and began requiring per-session payments from agents... My Vietnamese agent no longer offers the service, and they may all in fact be gone...

In short (assuming you really didn't enable OEM Unlocking after wipes associated with re-locking bootloader and have really hard-bricked your device), I don't like your chances for a fix at least using 3rd party services...

Edit: Just found and checked thread/service you linked, and I see that happily XDA have now (finally) made exceptions... I argued black and blue for this frankly... No-one informed me of the about-face however...

Still, this is great news for Xiaomi users with corrupted unique numbers, hard bricked devices etc... Well done XDA...

🙄 PW
[Magisk] crypticc:
I can't see any comments yet in either that thread or the modules thread.
[Magisk] fma388:
Thanks a lot !

Of course I read the official instructions but I want to be sure it was also simple 😬

Do I have to uninstall the manager of Magisk stable before install the one of Delta ?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Yes, Magisk Delta comes with different package name, hence its app will not replace/update the official Magisk app (manager)
[Magisk] crypticc:
came back overnight thanks
[Magisk] crypticc:
I did mine after. But yes, at some point you need to uninstall the other apk
[Magisk] uschipower:
I just installed and TrebleDroid-GSI on a TB-X605F.

Where do I find a compatible Version of Delta Magisk which can be used with TD-GSI?

After I had successfully installed GSI, I made a backup of all partitions with TWRP.

I installed DeltaMagisk-Apk and selected the boot-partition-file from TWRP-backup for Patching DeltaMagisk.

Then I installed the patched boot, but Device will not start with this boot-file.

Whan can I do?

Where did I make a mistake?
[Magisk] Roidred:
you should try to rename the file from .apk to .zip and then flash the same file from twrp itself.
[Magisk] uschipower:
just tried this way too, do everything in TWRP.

The device doesnt boot any more after DeltaMagisk has modified boot-partition

Whan can I do?

Where did I make a mistake?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Use the same boot.img that you patched, but the original, not patched img file

And flash to restore. There will be no Magisk but the phone should boot if it was indeed the correct/corresponding boot.img from your ROM
[Magisk] uschipower:
??

For GSI-Image, I have downloaded a *.xy-File to PC and extracted it. There was a *.img-File in archieve.

I flashed this *.img to "system" with TWRP.

You think of I should extract boot-partition from *.img-File?

How does this work?

Or do you think of boot.img from stockRom which is basis for GSI-Images?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Generally, System and Boot are different partitions and flashing System image to Boot partition is a way to brick the phone

However, in that case Magisk should have recognized that the given img file cannot be patched and should have printed an error (did you watch what Magisk wrote when patching!) - but there should be also no patched img then

Anyway, instead of flashing permanently the img file (patched or not) to Boot, it is always good to test it first by one-time booting to:

fastboot boot <IMG file>

Now, to un-brick, you should try to dirty-flash the ROM again, it should fix your Boot partition

Btw, ROMs may come with the compound payload.bin and one must use Payload Dumper to extract particular images - but again, Magisk should IMO report an error when trying to patch the payload.bin
[Magisk] uschipower:
I do not patch img, i install gsi-img over stockrom. And then, I made a backup of boot partition with TWRP. This file I used for patching with DeltaMagisk.

This patched boot partition file do not work

I do not have to make a dirty flash. I restore unpatched boot from TWRP and device does boot.

Do GSI-Images only modify system partition, do they not contain boot partition?

If yes, boot-partition is part of stock rom, not GSI-Image part, right?

As far as i know, Magisk and DeltaMagisk only modify boot partition.

When I flash stockrom without GSI, DeltaMagisk can modify boot partition and device can boot.

When flashed GSI, it should be still the same boot partition. But when I modify boot partition the same way, device doesnt boot.

So i suppose there is a problem with GSI

When using official magisk, there is a notice that for GSI-Images you have to use a special version:

Magisk-Phh

Magisk fork with some addition needed for phh-treble gsis. - Magisk-Phh

github.com

As you can see, the main developer of GSI/TrebleDroid, Phh, made the last version 2 years ago. Now he is retired in that project.

I suppose, he never made a modified Delta-Magisk version.

So it would be kindly if HuskyDG makes a Version working with GSI-Images.
[Magisk] Abdul ssaleh:
Please how do I get rid of this third party
[Magisk] pndwal:
This is a good method... Will always get matched image...

👍

Did you try with patched image made without GSI?... See comments below re wipes needed too...

Yup, these need special fixes in Magisk it seems... More below...

Doubt you need that old mod of Magisk 23.0... many GSI compatibility fixes (and newer GKI and other Treble compatibility fixes) have been added in official Magisk since (like this important one: Skip loading Magisk when detecting DSU)... In the past Magisk was basically incompatible with GSIs... Some issues likely still exist... Some users find phh builds are more difficult to get to boot than Google GSIs, even w/o Magisk patching... Apparently wiping /data, dalvik etc is often needed to get Magisk booting w/ GSIs...

Try wipes, try a Google GSI for comparison... 👍 PW
[Magisk] kevinco1:
Delta in the future needs to be updated with fixes to work with GSIs properly. PHH builds do not install Delta properly for me as well as various other GSI builds
[Magisk] uschipower:
It happened again.

Tan-App for german bank comdirect found a way to detect root again.

comdirect photoTAN App - Apps on Google Play

for free TANs

play.google.com

they released a new version a few days ago.

Would you be so kindly and fix the detection again?
[Magisk] zgfg:
I can get up to the following with Delta, Zygisk, SuList, Sensitive Props and App Data Isolation

I have kein Konto to continue
[Magisk] eliezerjk90:
Change the filename of /system/addon.d/99-magisk.sh to anything that doesn't contain magisk. Reboot and it will work
[Magisk] useroso987:
Hi, i just installed LineageOS 20 and will proceed to root.

Should i take Official or Delta one?

Is there any list of differences between them?

Thanks.
[Magisk] Timmmmaaahh!:
No silver platters here 🤷‍♂️

It's a personal preference. For some applications, official will work better, for others Delta will do the trick. Why don't you just try the one that seems best to you, it's possible to switch later. Also, read the documentation and FAQ, those will likely answer most of your questions.
[Magisk] shadyrexman:
Pixel 6 Pro T3B2 here, tried many times to root my p6p and failed , I patched the p7p boot.img and fastboot it, after restarted and I press direct install. After reboot then the root is gone. Any suggestions? Thanks a lot .
[Magisk] zgfg:
On your screenshot it says:

Magisk

Installed Delta 25210

Zygisk Yes

Ramdisk Yes

Hence, as per that screenshot, Magisk (and the root) is installed
[Magisk] shadyrexman:
But it's gone after I restart my phone tho
[Magisk] zgfg:
There is a Pixel Flasher thread - it's a great tool, helping Pixel users to install Magisk, etc

Plus, there are Pixel experts there who will better know about the issues specific to Pixel models and their updates - suggesting to ask there (recently, somebody asked in one of the Magisk threads here and eventually hard-bricked his phone based on the 'normal' answers he got)
[Magisk] monkeymechanic:
The latest version of Magisk Monet v25.2.3 fixes the scrolling issue while flashing long script based modules. It'd be great to have it fixed in the next version of Magisk Delta as well.
[Magisk] uschipower:
which magisk module do you use for this?

you are my hero - you found the new detection method

Is this script not neccessary for something to work?

is there a magisk/zygote module like HideMyApps which is doing the same for folders and files? so you could configure which folders/files are not visible for selected apps.
[Magisk] zgfg:
GitHub - adrianmmiller/AppDataIsolation: An attempt to block apps from accessing other apps' private data on Android 11+ (API 30+)

An attempt to block apps from accessing other apps' private data on Android 11+ (API 30+) - GitHub - adrianmmiller/AppDataIsolation: An attempt to block apps from accessing other apps' priv...

github.com

It was previously asked/answered here or in another Magisk thread, there you can also find a link for the alternative module, for A10 and older Android versions (if needed)
[Magisk] pndwal:
It will only be present if Magisk was installed as .zip installation from custom recovery and system is r/w... addon.d is a survival script function for addon packages like GApps and Magisk to survive ROM updates... version 2 supports full OTAs run while OS is booted...

If you forget to restore that directory before taking ROM update I'm guessing Magisk may simply not be restored (survive) and you'll need to do an initial installation again...

@osm0sis may like to investigate/comment on ways this directory can be hidden now that banks are evidently detecting it...

Not that I'm aware of. PW
[Magisk] Aldwarii:
Hi there

I am having difficulty with these applications: SNB, Absher, and Nafad. All other apps seem to be working for me. Would you like to try them to see if they work for you?

I am using Magisk Delta, zygisk . with hidemyapplist white-listing and magiskhide
[Magisk] zgfg:
Yeah, there was no update since Mar 17.

Sad if true unfortunately, but thanks for an excellent and very useful Magisk fork - actually the best one, better than the original and with better support

Hoping to see tomorrow, April 2 bringing the better news
[Magisk] osm0sis:
The suggestion was only to rename the Magisk script itself, so addon.d function should all still work, and renaming a specific script shouldn't have any effect on its function, so nothing to worry about there. 👍

Concerning that user apps are digging around in /system now...

It would probably be worth reporting it as a bug to Lineage; they might be able to adjust the SELinux context or permissions of addon.d while still keeping it working.
[Magisk] shoey63:
April fools joke 😉
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Do you know that for sure, or is it just wishful thinking?
[Magisk] shoey63:
Pure speculation. Just have to wait and see . . . .
[Magisk] zgfg:
Japan time now 02h Apr 2

The post is crossed out on TG👍
[Magisk] uschipower:
does AppDataIsolation make HmA obsolete? Or should I use it parallel to AppDataIsolation?

Does AppDataIsolation work for you?

Module is from 2021

I installed module in DeltaMagisk in an unofficial LOS19 (from retiredtab).

Device boot approxemately until unlock screen, then device reboots.

alternative module only for A10 and below, right, not for A11 and above?

It is listet in a repo in Fox's Magisk Module Mangaer
[Magisk] zgfg:
I have App Data Isolation but still need HMA

The module I use was released on Jan 21, 2023 - but the module's code seems to be (at least 4 months) older:

GitHub - adrianmmiller/AppDataIsolation: An attempt to block apps from accessing other apps' private data on Android 11+ (API 30+)

An attempt to block apps from accessing other apps' private data on Android 11+ (API 30+) - GitHub - adrianmmiller/AppDataIsolation: An attempt to block apps from accessing other apps' priv...

github.com

Please better check on GitHub for which Android version the particular module is suitable, cannot tell you better than what their developers describe

I have only A11 and A12 hence I don't use that alternative module for A10 and earlier, and don't know anything more about that module.

Also, I don't use LOS

In Fox, click on Description and you will go to GitHub (it works for modules from the Alt Repo), there you can see provided info about the given module
[Magisk] ToXiTe:
Using Magisk Delta fixed 2 out of 3 apps for me that used to crash.

But the other one, my banking app, still detects something. When you open it, it basically opens the browser and online website instead because it detected tampering. Previously, with original Magisk, it used to append rasp=root to the URL. Now it appends rasp=android_hook. So that's progress I guess.
[Magisk] m0han:
All 'as before' - on Magisk-80d8cbf0-delta(25210).
[Magisk] zgfg:
Yes, Delta goes on
[Magisk] ToXiTe:
MemoryDetector says "Selinux has been modified by Magisk". What could be the cause?
[Magisk] supermansaga:
Delta won't be able to fix Marriott V10.13.1
[Magisk] Elsrougy:
I have the same problem and have been searching everywhere for a while now but no luck.

I even made w thread on reddit for this:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Magisk/comments/11tzstn

It has some good suggestions. None of them worked for me, but you can try and check yourself maybe something will work with you. if it happens please let me know.
[Magisk] mobile_sensei:
Hey, thanks for sharing your fork of Magisk. I'm not up to date on all the a/b partition stuff that we have nowadays, can you tell me how to appropriately switch from Magisk? Thank you
[Magisk] penguin_grapefruit:
Hi, everyone. I have a query.

I'm still relatively new to the world of custom ROMs, unlocked bootloaders and rooted phones so please forgive my naivety.

MemoryDetector v2.0.0 detects "Device status or bootloader has been tampered".

I see several screenshots of other people's MemoryDetector app showing "Looks Fine! Nothing is found." so I'm wondering if there's something I can do to resolve this.

Here are details of my setup:

Xiaomi Mi 8 (dipper)

LineageOS 20

Magisk Delta fdac22ba-delta (25210)

Zygisk enabled

MagiskHide enabled (with MemoryDetector in the MagiskHide list)

Universal SafetyNet Fix v2.4.0-MOD_1.2 (Displax) installed

Everything seems to be working OK (SafetyNet passes Basic Integrity and CTS Profile Match and Play Integrity API Checker confirms "MEETS_DEVICE_INTEGRITY and MEETS_BASIC_INTEGRITY).

I'm just curious how I might go about resolving the "Device status or bootloader has been tampered" message in MemoryDetector v2.0.0.

Others seems to have achieved this but I don't know how.

I'd be very grateful for any pointers anyone can give.

Thank you.
[Magisk] DartGerion:
Hello!

I had some question about the TJW Magisk and Delta. I've installed Delta with direct install (tried first with .zip, but it didn't activate) and as the result i had TJW Magisk (with spoofed name) and Delta (that updated to 25210). In TJW Magisk shows installed delta and promts to install v26 version. So as i understand now the delta has taken place of the old tjw magisk. So is it safe to uninstall the tjw magisk app, if the framework is now run by Delta?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Of course (it was also guided earlier), uninstall that old (renamed/repackaged or not) TJW Magisk app/manager and reboot. Check if Delta app then correctly shows the Magisk Delta version installed (you could reinstall Delta app then if really needed)

If Delta app asks that it needs to finish the installation and to reboot again, do that
[Magisk] DartGerion:
Thank you for clearing this up and apologies for missing the info before. Could you also explain the SuList function in the settings?
[Magisk] zgfg:
MagiskHide works in blacklist mode - you have to add all 'banking' apps to the list, you want to hide root from

SuList works in the opposite whitelist mode - you only enlist the root apps, ie those that require access to the 'root'

The advantage: you don't need to add every newly installed banking app to MagiskHide list and to reboot

Scroll back and find additional posts/instructions like from a month ago

Install also SuList Auto Whitelist module - it will find all modules apps (like V4A, JamesDSP, etc) and will automatically add them to the SuList (without, they will not work properly in the SuList mode).

However, you still have to manually add eg AdAway to the SuLlst
[Magisk] supermansaga:
Can SuList Auto Whitelist module handle Marriott v10.13.1 when the phone also has s ome LSposed modules installed?
[Magisk] zgfg:
No idea, don't know about that app. Maybe if you provide a link to install, to test

Btw, I'm not sure, wasn't recently in one of these threads a discussion about hiding the root from that or similar appk...
[Magisk] avisekarmani:
Hi @huskydg , the new updated magisk delta have some issues. The MagiskHide Props module is not working in new update.

I am attaching the log. Please review it and solve this issue. For this kind I always be thankful to you.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Btw, are you sure it was really a problem on the MHCP side - the original MHCP module is no more maintained for a year or more (and I really don't know how is about the fork from the new developer - at least, there are not much news on his XDA thread)

Also, do you really need MHCP. Husky made like Sensitive Props module - ok, that's not for general purposes but for hiding the root
[Magisk] avisekarmani:
Hello @zgfg , first of all thanks for your reply. Magiskhide Props Config module is working smoothly. I was using it in magisk delta some days ago. But when I updated my magisk delta into the latest version, it started showing error. Also, it is working smoothly in official magisk latest version. And I uses it for changing my device fingerprint and there is no any alternative of this module available. So I need this module.

I am attaching the image of error showing by the module in terminal and log of this module.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Screenshot says "Please reboot your device .." - did you try (and is the module enabled)?
[Magisk] avisekarmani:
I tried all the things but nothing happened.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Strange. I just installed MHPC v6.1.2 and it runs for me

However, I'm on the last but one v25210 Delta, 80d8cbf0 (I did not want to upgrade to fdac22ba "Temp fix 1/?" ?!)

Screenshots attached
[Magisk] goldwoods:
The latest bank app from vietinbank detect root

VietinBank iPay - Apps on Google Play

Embrace the digital life

play.google.com
[Magisk] martyfender:
I reverted to an older version my self. I had major problems with fdac22ba. No matter what I did, it would not pass the playstore integrity checker, Playstore certification and CTS Profile in Safety Net. I even went as far as reinstalling the Rom. That was on the older of my 2 Onn 8 1st gen, Android 9 tablets.
[Magisk] m0han:
Just an FYI: All fine here on fdac22ba. Delta+Riru, do note.
[Magisk] zgfg:
You managed to solve your AdAway/Systemless hosts/hosts file problems (I think, blocking ads did not work for you)?
[Magisk] m0han:
I think I did. Ads don't show up much now; the occasional one does pop up, though. Thanks for sharing your json file. A couple of hosts sources don't download on Data; Wi-Fi fetches them.
[Magisk] krakout:
Hey guys, can someone confirm how to go back to official from Delta? I love Delta but official 26.1 supposedly works with A14 beta and until Delta is updated I'd like to be prepared...

Is it as simple as:

-download, install official

-uninstall Delta manager

-install Magisk from Magisk manager?

Thanks!
[Magisk] amritpal2489:
I am rooted on A14 Beta with Magisk Delta. I just flashed the magisk patched P7P boot.img
[Magisk] krakout:
Oh, that's cool! Which Delta version? Also, did you use Pixel Flasher or did you do it manually?
[Magisk] amritpal2489:
The latest available one... I patched the P7P's boot.img first and then used Pixel Flasher to flash the Beta. After first boot I flashed the patched P7P boot.img using fastboot flash boot command
[Magisk] krakout:
Cool, thanks a lot!

Just a question - if you use PF then why manually patch, flashing the beta and then fastboot instead of letting PF do all the work?
[Magisk] rodken:
Spoiler content hidden.
[Magisk] krakout:
Oh, thanks so much for that; I did spend quite some time looking for instructions but did not come upon this guide...

Someone else suggested the last Canary works fine with the 14 Beta on Pixels, so in the end it's probably not needed, but thanks :)
[Magisk] amritpal2489:
Just out of habit I suppose
[Magisk] krakout:
Oh ok, fair enough; was just asking to see if there were any pitfalls...
[Magisk] gpvecchi:
Perhaps dumb question: stock Magisk had been updated, while Delta wasn't. Does it already contains newest patches, or it's older than stock?
[Magisk] krakout:
I think the dev said he'll continue development next weekend because of personal issues on Telegram.
[Magisk] zgfg:
No, last Delta is (as the version says), v25210, but it has no issues with modules as official Canary v25210 had (Hasky takes care of that)

You could check on the public TG channel (where the releases are published) about the delay - screenshot attached
[Magisk] Illuvitar:
Had anyone managed to get the Citibank app working by hiding root?

If so, please share your cookbook!