yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] little-endian:
@rampitec:

You're my liberator after I spent hours with that crap. I wonder how you came up with the URL as I could only find the resolved host topjohnwu.github.io mentioned a Wireshark capture to see what the Magisk app tries to retrieve when the default "stable branch" is selected. Maybe I was overcomplicating things.

Anyway, while I might be missing something here in general, it is difficult not to indulge oneself in a rant because what kind of a retarded bull**** is that to remove a feature (whether being replaceable by that Zygisk stuff with yet again addition effort or not yet to be seen) which allows to get apps at least halfway running by hiding the fact of having root access (whereas the necessity also only arises thanks to moronic programming and nowadays pseudo-security paranoia, especially by insecure-by-definition banking apps on the very same device) with no damn easy way to downgrade again or at least select the version one wants. 😤

It is beyond comprehension why also that Magisk manager doesn't offer to simply select the version of preference in case a newer one breaks what was working before. God forbid, instead, even the version 23.0 apparently tries to load parts of the newer 24.1 one now which leads to (non-working) duplicates of the manager ("Magisk" & by default "Settings" then) instead of repackaging itself to only one instance of course.

It is annoying enough that regular application providers forces users into that constant having-to-update-crap but it is almost real life satire for me that even nominally sophisticated ones such as that John Wu Magisk guy* follows the same idiocy. 😡

* who owes me hours of my lifetime while I owe you at least a beer, rampitec!
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] MENINBLK:
Everyone needs to start posting their devices and if they are 64 bit ONLY or 64 bit and 32 bit capable because Magisk 24.1 does not support any device that supports 32 bit. If you subscribe to TopJohn Wu, on Twitter, you get notifications with explanations.

https://twitter.com/topjohnwu?t=e4SCxqjXOBnGIqQLc1uNJg&s=09

We can not understand why you get the results you have unless we know your device and OS and you need to know if your device is 64 bit ONLY, or 64 bit and 32 bit capable.

Pete R
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] rampitec:
Not much of my work really. Found a link on youtube how to set the channel to some version. Go to github magisk repo, browse for needed version, select view file, select "raw", copy the URL of the page. This is the update channel.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] ji-r47:
Thank you! It worked for me. After going back to 23, I have changed the update channel url to 0.0.0.0, so there is no update at all. And it's back to normal again.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] tolara:
Application hiding process is done, thank you very much. I've been editing the 23.0 version with apktool m for hours. I couldn't think that only the url link would be the solution to get rid of the version upgrade, I was surprised and a very good idea came to my mind. I will integrate the url into the classes.dex file. The new version is a complete disgrace, too bad, don't install it. Tr to En Google Translate
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] RootPoG0:
Have you ever seen that Magisk 23 recognizes the root but when update it gets N/A and the app doesn't work but SuperUser still get access. I tried to do trough Path Boot andZip Odin(S7 Edge Android 8.0)

I formatted the device, re-do Stock Rom but dont work.

the App 24, 24.1 or Canary keeps not working (N/A). Less than 8.0.7 work normally

I applied a custom with Android 10,11 and 12. It worksView attachment 5523701
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] oopps24:
You can patch boot.img over magisk 23.0 apk installer in android and flashed this patch_magisk_boot.img over fastboot / adb on pc. Magisk 23.0 is now work. Downgrade 24.1. Magisk Hide is back and edxposed works.(y)
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] RootPoG0:
tI tried to do this, but the magisk 23 app doesn't allow me to patch without updating to 24.1 first..
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] oopps24:
uninstall magisk befor. magisk root and app.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] pf100:
Thank you! I had a feeling something weird was going on and I was ignoring the update notification for a few days now. Good thing I did some digging before installing magisk 24.1.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] lucasbda1:
Hello! I'm on a galaxy s9+ running android 10.

I didn't pay attention and clicked on update, and i regret it so much!

i am on magisk 24.1 with zygisk and ramdisk both set to "yes".

I have the uiversal safetynet fix v2.2.1 and google play services and play store hidden on the denylist

I can't pass safetynet, it fails on "basic integrity" and on "cts profile match"

so upset i updated!
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] lucasbda1:
Hello! Thanks for your lifesaving post!

If i do this downgrade by completely uninstalling magisk 24.1 and then installing 23.0 will i have to format my phone and lose all data? I Rooted a while ago and i can't remember exactly.

Also, can you detail a bit more all the steps you took? I'm very rusty
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] ACEBILBO-I:
Already tried to use MagiskHide Props Config?

Universal SafetyNet Fix documentation states

"If you have trouble passing basic attestation after installing this module, use MagiskHide Props Config to spoof your CTS profile. This is a common issue on old devices, custom ROMs, and stock ROMs without GMS certification (e.g. Chinese ROMs)." and I think S9 with A10 could fall under the "old devices" category
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] lucasbda1:
read about it, seems kinda tricky. Is is easier than reverting to magisk 23.0 though?
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] ACEBILBO-I:
Reverting to Magisk 23 can only be done by uninstalling Magisk > complete uninstall from the app, and rooting from scratch, MagiskHide Props needs a bit of reading of the documentation/xda thread and using a few commands, depending on your device it might be much easier to just adapt to the new version, and it will pay off for the future as Android 12 requires newer versions of Magisk to have the same easy root process we had before.

If you absolutely need Xposed this is not your fix as I believe it can't run anymore on the new version with Zygisk, but I have abandoned it shortly after the original developer has and started looking at the systemless Magisk alternatives as Xposed newer forks started being a hassle to mantain.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] lucasbda1:
Thanks for sharing your android wisdom with me! I'll take a better look at this later today. My main issue is not being able to play pokemon go with this new magisk version. Also can't use google pay
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] ACEBILBO-I:
Yeah unfortunately it takes a bit more work in some cases, on my OnePlus 9 both Pokemon Go and GPay work with Magisk 24.1, Zygisk, Enforced DenyList (and selected all the apps you need to hide root from + google services like GMS/IMS, Gpay, Google Play) and Universal SafetyNetFix, however I believe I do pass basic safetynet in the first place, hopefully Hide Props fixes it for you! Might also need to delete Google Pay/Play Services app data afterwards.

If you mess around with SELinux modes Selinux Switch could be needed to switch between enforced and passive, but I don't think that's the case. Best of luck!

EDIT: Oprek Root Detector could help you out too to figure out what is detected if you still have issues after fixing SafetyNet
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] rampitec:
Right, if you want to downgrade it you need to completely uninstall it first from 24.1 app. At this point you will lose root, but not data. This does not involve hard reset. You do not need to relock/unlock the BL when the actual hard reset usually happens. After that you will have to install app 23.0, boot into patched BL and patch your own BL once again from the app.

This is an easy process on OnePlus, I do not know if it takes some more hassle on your Samsung.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] rampitec:
Maybe we will have to adapt in the future or maybe magisk will fork. Time will show. I personally have no incentive to adapt right now.

What I understand is that a dev working for Google at the security dept cannot release and develop SW working around that security at the same time. Using his own words he cannot be a cat and a mouse at the same time.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] WoKoschekk:
Because you are not able to downgrade an app. That's it.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] little-endian:
That is no real explanation and rather a "looped" argument as in "it is not possible because it is not possible".

In case you are referring to the circumstance that one cannot simply install an app "over" the same with a lower version under Android - well, that is a design flaw on its own as it is perfectly well possible to first uninstall it and reinstall the lower version afterwards of course. As if it would be carved into stone by gods that one cannot do so otherwise. 🙄

In terms of Magisk, I rather meant the "repackaging itself to hide" - feature, apparently always using the newest version available only by default - which at latest doesn't make any sense when one has the v23 installed and tries to hide it, ending up in a screwed up mixture of v23 main instance and v24 duplicates.

I want to install whatever version I feel righteous to install and also want to have the option to select the upgrade path from a menu without having to fiddle with some randon cryptic URLs which I am - or rather other nice forum users are - happy to eventually find. What a bull****. 😡
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] stoplookingmypic:
the best alternative for now is wait in magisk v23 as repo and hide still working

Probably in 1 month or two someone will make a new root method or even patch magisk
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] rampitec:
OK, to be fair I understand the argument. Supporting a downgrade from any version to any can be tricky and we cannot ask a dev to support that scenario for free. At the end of the day patching a live image of BL on the fly is a state of the art hackery. Well, it does not support the downgrade, granted. Nobody has paid the author for that. I can even understand it has failed to upgrade given it was hidden and randomises app name for that purpose. It is a bit irresponsible to offer an upgrade if you know there will be a Gordian knot of problems with parts of the hidden app conflicting with the older app, even just with a very previous version. All of that is justifiable, no hard feelings, we all were piggybacking on his work for a long time.

But times have changed. He is now working for Google. He is now a cat and not a mouse. Everything he is releasing now to public MUST be inspected with an extreme scrutiny. It is what it is, this the game. I am literally inclined to fork the project into my own github repo and put the link pointing there, so no backlog changes will be made (except first we need to inspect sources not referencing any other sources outside of the repo). This is all temporary, but if we speak about the phones on this forum (7t) I don't think we will get an OOS12 (and if we do I don't want it), so I am perfectly fine with what I have now. What will happen tomorrow will happen tomorrow, we don't know yet. Take it easy man, another one drew his lucky card. The changelog is as honest about it as it can be.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] hungtinglung:
flash universal safetynet fix v2.2.1 from magisk.

Releases · kdrag0n/safetynet-fix

Google SafetyNet attestation workarounds for Magisk - kdrag0n/safetynet-fix

github.com

at my phone,safetynet pass after that.

i don't know what is the problem at your phone.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] rampitec:
As a side note: I almost didn't need this. I am practically ready to give up relying on the phone for the most things except calls and browser. Well, mail, but that I can manage at every phone. I did it on Moto Razr. Looking back... even on ME45. I.e. installing LOS as long as there is no Graphen.

Depending on your location and tolerance your meleage may vary. My tolerance has grown thin, and speaking of the subject I understand the choice of @topjohnwu, but my choice is different. Maybe I am just older.

Anyhow, if it doesn't work it is yet another bites the dust. I can live without it. I see some people cannot and willing to adapt. This is beyond me, I didn't write the post to convince anyone to do or not do anything. I did so to tell how to avoid a lot of hassle if someone is like me.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] hungtinglung:
many application block screenshot.

that's why we need root to take screenshot.

from that screenshots convert to pdf.

some other record screen from netflix,amazone prime video,etc.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] wfantasma:
A little help over here... https://xdaforums.com/t/discussion-magisk-the-age-of-zygisk.4393877/#post-86321923
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] raulicio:
I tried everything with Magisk 24.1 with zygisk and deny list but one single app still detects open bootloader or root or whatever. Since it is my banking app it would be important to get it work. Strange because other apps like google pay, netflix or revolut work fine. Safety net test passes as well. I use a mi 11. It is chinese version but i use the global rom because I could not get android auto work on the chinese rom.

Any idea? I am not too qualified for magisk hide props. I installed the module but made no difference.

I Really do not want to go back 23.0 and come back to the newer version after a while. And as I said I do not have problem with most of the apps.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] ACEBILBO-I:
If SafetyNet passes my best guess is you don't really need Hide Props as Universal SafetyNet Fix should have taken care of everything, especially if your device is "Certified" under the Google Play Store.

OPRek Root Checker could perhaps help you out to figure out what triggers the issue

Also check for perhaps some files or apps that could be detected as the cause.

For me SELinux was an issue, it needed to be changed to Enforcing through SELinux Switch, but I messed around with it myself.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] rampitec:
Some of them remember your are rooted once detected. Try clearing bank app data and login again.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] seasandf88:
There is no uninstall option in my magisk app!

Please help.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] raulicio:
That does not help, but thank anyway.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] raulicio:
It seems there are some problems but i have no idea how to deal with them...
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] seasandf88:
Can you please write a step by step guide?

I have S7 edge on oreo and after I've uploaded to 24.1 I've lost my root. Tried downgrading to 23.0 but I'm unable to root the device. The app gets installed but not the root.

I don't know what to do now. Do I need to flash the official rom again?
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] raulicio:
Now i hided the magisk apk itself so oprek says there is no root management app. But the bank app still does not work. I unistalled it couple of times an tried just deleting data.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] vtec303:
24.1 is working absolute bang on perfect for me. MIUI 13, A12, Mi 10T pro, safety net pass as well as widvine L1. Zygisk needs to be enabled and deny list needs to be configured, most importantly all google services netflix and banking apps needs to be in the deny list as well as google pay. cheers.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] rampitec:
You need to completely unistall Magisk app from the app itself. Select uninstall, then complete uninstall. Then you will have to root it again using Magisk 23.0, just like you did before. I believe Magisk shall work first be be able to uninstall itself.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] ACEBILBO-I:
You have xposed? Might want to try disabling it and rebooting, also if you haven't already hide your Magisk app from Magisk settings, at that point you should have all green checks in root checker
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] hungtinglung:
rename magisk.zip to uninstall.zip

flash it with TWRP.

if the app not uninstalled,then go to app manager.

uninstall it.

then magisk clear at all.

there is new module name Shamiko.

i have tested banking app works fine.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] seasandf88:
I tried flashing magisk 23 after uninstalling using TWRP but the root didn't work.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] raulicio:
Do you need both? And how difficult they were tonsetup?
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] raulicio:
I hided magisk after making the screenshot. Magisk manager is no gone but magisk binary still red.

The funny thing I do not have exposed...
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] raulicio:
Finally I decided to revert back to magisk 23.0 because I was not able to find a solution for the bank app.

But after uninstalling Magisk from the app itself everything seems to be working.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] hungtinglung:
newest LSPosed-Zygisk and Shamiko.

0.4.2

- Fix app zygote crash on Android 10-

1.7.1 Changelog

- Update translations

- Fix log export

- Fix inactivation in some cases
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] spyxone:
SafetyNet pass on oneplus 8T

Magisk settings

check Zygist (Beta)

check enforce Deny List

reboot phone

again settings

Configure Deny List

pick Show system apps

search for google play services

check

com.google.android.gms

com.google.android.gms.unstable
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] nacos:
Like always, trying to get something done without any basic preparation, without getting informed first, believing that somehow magically everything will turn alright, unsurprisingly almost always leeds to these bitter experiences. The amount of available information on this topic is almost overwhelming, not to mention that, if instead of creating this post you would have done some research and posted your questions in the proper thread, someone would have jumped in and helped you right away, guaranteed! Yet you chose to blindly take the bull by the horns, hoping for the best.

Your failure has NOTHING to do with reality and EVERYTHING to do with your attitude.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] rampitec:
Really? First I made it working as I said. Then listen, app has notified "click to upgrade", without a warning of changes, when upgrade is impossible with just a click.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] ppthom:
Agree with you 100%. No warning, and from previous versions operating in similar upgrade process, the failure of doing so is beyond frustrating. Uninstalling V24 completely, losing root, reinstalling 23 would have been unnecessary if a warning was given NOT to upgrade without reading the installation guideline. Also, really like the trick (thank you

ji-r47)​

to cease upgrade notices by setting the custom update channel to 0.0.0.0. Hope it works.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] DHGE:
Some (banking) apps have the permission (exception by Googles blessing) to scan ALL apps on your device.

One of my banking apps found TitaniumBackup and SDMaid and stopped doing its work.

Fiddling with xposed and privacy setting saved my bacon for a month. Then the banking app cried for a new version and that found yet another way to stop my way of doing things.

I pulled out a drawer device that does not get security updates since years, derooted it and deleted some apps I use regularly and do all my banking on that old clunker now.

Inconvenient but the cat and mouse game with root detection became too time consuming and several times one or the other of my 3 banking apps stopped working when it was necessary to do some transactions.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] raulicio:
I do have two phones already as my employer only let the use of iphones. Personally I hate those and have my private mi 11. So I really do not want a third phone 😅

I am not really into modding and changing things. I've done the rooting and hiding once before and it worked for every single app. After the new version with the right settings most things worked as well but not everything sadly. I checked another thread and I understood very little from the conversation but that some way more qualified ppl were unable to get a banking app work. So guess at the moment it is an unsolved issue on 24.1.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] wizeazz:
Yeah, gets detected. Recono, mobile bank,..., are not working with v. 24.1.

Mi Max 3 EU rom.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] hungtinglung:
before put in deny list magisk 24.1,blocked.

after works fine.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] nacos:
There is a dedicated thread for upgrading to Magisk v.24 here...it does include a step-by-step guide and much more.

If you're still unable to hide some apps (after configuring and enforcing Deny list in settings), you need to install a Zygisk module called Shamiko.

Search the thread...it's elaborated in detail, plus more options are available. 😁. I've successfully upgraded two Samsung phones and all banking apps +++ are now working fine under Zygisk v.24.1
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] rampitec:
I don't know your situation of course but that may as well be a good moment to change the bank. What I have noticed that usually comes in a bundle: increasing fees, dropping perks and enforcing the stupid perceived security. I did exactly that, changed the bank. Quite shortly I have noticed my previous bank just became a total nonsense. I mean not every battle we have to take. Playing a cat and a mouse game have a third option really.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] HrSeldon:
Moderator, please delete this post. I did a mistake trying to learn how to use the Multi-Quote.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] HrSeldon:
The same thing happen to me. I just saw a notification in the top drop-down menu and I wanted to remove it, but instead I mistakenly pressed on it. Then the hell broke loose and I wasted as well a couple of hours to bring back the Magisk v23. In my case I didn't take the uninstall from the app approach (I was not confident that by doing that & flashing again the patched image will not result in a complete data loss). Instead I did a couple of install - uninsntall cycles (Initially the hide app didn't seem to work, than the home link was not created, or clicking the app link didn't open the app). Well, eventually the app seems to work (Magisk Hide was back, Safety Net test was Ok, but I noticed a lot of error messages like su: cannot find manager on the log tab and that if I added a new app which required root the root rights granting popup window didn't show up. I suspected that it might be something related to the root so I did a root check which turned out OK (green). But then, testing the BusyBox failed. So, I Installed BusyBox NDK module and now seems that all went back to normal.

I should say that overall it was a very stressful experience which I don't want tot repeat. And I agree that all could have been avoided with a proper update warning (maybe something like when you want to format/wipe your date, where you are forced to type yes by yourself).

As a precaution to prevent it from offering any further upgrades on my other devices, I followed the OP advice and pasted the link to the 23.0 manifest into custom update channel from the app settings. I saw as well that as an alternative one can paste 0.0.0.0 and I'm wondering what difference would this option make.

Anyhow, no updates for me to Magisk 24 in the near feature. So far v 23 is working flawlessly (passing the SafetyNet and working for my installed bank apps) on all of my devices.
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] HrSeldon:
Any ideea what's the difference between posting in the update channel 0.0.0.0 and posting the GitHub link to the 23.0 manifest?
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] Steps Parku:
So seriously, does it mean that magisk hide does not work in version 24.1?
[OnePlus 7T Questions & Answers] shunsai:
3 months later, but this helped me downgrade back to 23. Thank you. Magisk 24 was an unnecessary disaster and time-waster for me. I should have known better than to upgrade; I am very much in the mindset of "if it ain't broke, don't fix it."