yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] pndwal:
...

User should simply check "Shamiko is working as Blacklist mode" appears in modules list and Shamiko is up to date (v0.5.2 (120))... If there's an issue the message will be different... If the message above appears, hiding achieved by DenyList should alternatively be achieved w/ Shamiko; if there are apps that work w/ DenyList but not with Shamiko, please let me know!...

Whitelist hiding modes whether in Magisk Lite, Shamiko, other, are highly experimental and AFAIK, still break many (most?) modules...

Shamiko Introduction, Usage and Whitelist instructions and Changelog (not updated since 0.4.4) are all available in README.md... Most modules have this, and you can simply extract it from the module.zip...

#### Whitelist section has info on Whitelist triggering from modules folder in /data/adb as well as other cautions/notes...

👀 PW
[Magisk] pndwal:
Maybe only you!...

I know @Displax initially uploaded a bad v2 build... Try reinstalling latest version from him...

Nb his last V2 is only needed for Pixel 7 series and other devices launched w/ A13... You can also revert to his older modded build...

Perhaps you've sorted this already or advice above helps... If not, please click < > at top in PI Checker app and screenshot raw JSON... Ta, PW
[Magisk] huskydg:
Not really correct
[Magisk] m0han:
https://xdaforums.com/t/discussion-...third-party-magisk-fork.4460555/post-87691343

?
[Magisk] vietmobi:
I can't bypass this app. Try zygisk+shamiko with enforce denylist off, safetynet fix, app is put into denylist but won't help

InstaPay Egypt - Apps on Google Play

With InstaPay, Transfer money instantly 24/7, and pay your bills.

play.google.com
[Magisk] vietmobi:
My friend is using this app, it is impossible to bypass, having to uninstall magisk to open :(

Livin' by Mandiri - Apps on Google Play

Livin' by Mandiri is here with more features, for your lively life!

play.google.com
[Magisk] paarkhi:
many users are able to use the app by using magisk delta by HuskyDG
[Magisk] msohail_7:
Hi, how did u bypass? I have tried hiding magisk app even Shamiko but no success. Could u help me please?
[Magisk] J.Michael:
Is Momo in the deny list? Did you clear Momo's cache and data before testing?

Are you using @huskydg's version of Magisk?
[Magisk] msohail_7:
No momo is not in deny list. I've tried putting that even. No im on stock magisk.
[Magisk] huskydg:
shamiko can't hide zygisk
[Magisk] _Oshu_:
Hey I'm currently having a issue with Google wallet and I'm trying to figure out if it's a linage os issue, a magisk issue, or a Google issue rn.

Everything works pretty much, I pass safteynet check, Google certification is good, I can download stuff like Netflix and for the most part Google wallet works.

I'm using Android 12 on lineage os 19.1 with a oneplus5t. The problem I'm having is the wallet tile in the quick access menu and the lock screen wallet toggle in the settings menu are both grayed out and none functional. It's really a minor issue but are features I want to take advantage of.

If anyone has any idea about this issue, or at the very least know where I should be pointed at, it would be a lot of help.
[Magisk] msohail_7:
Could you guide me im on stock magisk.
[Magisk] 73sydney:
mwhahaha rofl!!!!!!!!!

i was trying to install SBI app just now to test and it wont run because i have teamviewer installed

according to the alert i have to uninstall it first

thats a new one

lol
[Magisk] 73sydney:
meanwhile on normal stock Magisk 25, with

1) Magisk App hidden (renamed)

2) Shamiko & Enforce Deny List OFF

3) Yono by SBI app in the Deny List

4) (hilariously) Teamviewer uninstalled

theres this:

so not sure why Husky is trying to offramp people from stock Magisk and onto his builds? that would be valid to suggest if it wasnt working on "stock" magisk, but clearly, well, see above..

have you checked you pass Integrity:

Play Integrity API Checker - Apps on Google Play

Get info about your Device Integrity through the Play Intergrity API

play.google.com
[Magisk] 73sydney:
And not to put too fine a point on this, but

without HDFC in HMA and set to use root blacklist:

and with:
[Magisk] pndwal:
... however I'm not sure why SBI is in the mix. Husky showed screenshot... Doesn't user have HDSC? ... PW
[Magisk] 73sydney:
covered that too chief
[Magisk] pndwal:
Ah... Well... Good find... I'm gonna try HMA blacklist now! ... PW

Edit: Of course already did... Still can't bypass on RN8T...
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Hide My AppList Guide is now in its own thread here:

Hide My Applist - A Brief Guide

Hide My Applist Guide Hide My Applist is a LSPosed module by Dr-TSNG (nullptr). Often referred to as HMA. In the simplest terms HMA aims to stop one app detecting a list of other installed apps. - It can often help stop your banking app(s) from...

xdaforums.com
[Magisk] pndwal:
Woops... of course I was already using Blacklist mode... So tried Whilelist mode for kicks ... Still can't bypass HDFC detection w/ my system...

What does Momo 4.4.1 show for your device?... Here's mine:

Nb. Willow = Xiaomi Redmi Note 8T... PW
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Please wait while i find and install Momo

<insert elevator music here>

a few moments later...

if this means Samsung S20+ 5G ftw, then its a very sad day in rooting :)
[Magisk] pndwal:
... Crass interruption to elevator music... Alpha TG thread, Aug 12... Returning you to

Mozart Symphony #40 in G Minor...

😋 PW
[Magisk] 73sydney:
I see your symphony and raise you a Dance Of the Sugar Plum Fairy, replete with a visual of me in a leotard and tutu
[Magisk] pndwal:
Why?... Looks cleaner than my MIUI system...

Is hidden Magisk app also in HMA common template? And Momo in denylist?

Meanwhile, I have

- Partition mounted abnormally

- init.rc is modified

- Zygote is injected

Over and above your

- Found Magisk...

I knew MIUI could be an issue... PW
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Yup hidden (random package name) Magisk (shortcut named App) and Momo in Deny List (and hidden from root apps blacklist in HMA)

Meanwhile in Ruru

@pndwal note: i just cleared data on Momo, as i hadnt done so in a few Migrate backups/Restores i realised, and have updated my earlier post, all that changed was "Zygote is injected"....
[Magisk] pndwal:
Call that a raise?... The No. 40's worth riding the elevator up and down for!... With eyes shut... BTW I fixed the link above so you can enjoy some refinement... 😝 PW
[Magisk] pndwal:
Nb. Some apps require already obfuscated Magisk App to be further hidden w/ HMA... You could try this with Sparkase-pushTAN... That's another one that MIUI users can no longer bypass detection for while other devices can... Used to pass as described... PW
[Magisk] 73sydney:
i worked around your Ponkling of the link
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Ill give pushTAN a crack....

update:

Without Deny List or HMA

with Deny List OR with Deny List AND HMA (my Germans as bad as my Dutch, but im guessing this is totes good?)"

Maybe this is a magical S20+ 5G, maybe i could put it up on Swappa and see what i can get for it?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Few comments:

I don't use HMA v3 beta - I will try the beta, thanks.

For my HMA v2.3.2, it has its own green icon, and I can manage directly from there, no need to manage through LSPosed - but at the end, it opens the same Settings in HMA

If I read correctly your guide, you omitted (or did not emphasize) to always click SAVE.

Without, you create a template (you named it Root) you go back to Select Effective apps and you cannot select thr template Root because it was not saved.

Or you make a change into the template, you don't save, and your change is lost

The same for Select Effective apps - you must Save to save it

And I always enable Enable hide and Enable all hide methods (they are not enabled by default)

I don't know is it different in v3 beta (like, if it saves automatically when you go back, etc)
[Magisk] pndwal:
Yup ... You got it... Did you mean you can disable HMA for pushTAN and still bypass? PW
[Magisk] pndwal:
Settings just stick in 3.x... No more save 💾 icon... So retro! 😜 PW
[Magisk] pndwal:
For your comparison, Xiaomi RN8T, stock A10:

🙃 PW
[Magisk] zgfg:
Nothing found for me (MIUI 13/A12) - but Scroll-shot does not work, hence attaching the two screenshots
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Yes...and yes i force stopped and cleared data on pushTan for that test

oh, and before i forget, im NOT using my AppDataIsolation module either, i kept forgetting to toggle it off before running a Migrate backup, which of course would make that fail :)
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Yes, as @pndwal pointed out, theres no dreaded Save button...god how many times in the v2 branch did everyone forget to hit Save and go around in circles having to do things twice :)
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Damn thats a lot of flagged stuff

Wanna buy an S20+ 5G?, its speshul

mates rates of course :) and ill come deliver it up your bell tower (not a euphemism)

Note: worth pointing out the S20+ 5G is super debloated, @zgfg will tell you, he's seen my logs as i use his debloater module, something like 135 packages debloated, he was like "and it still boots?"

List shared by PM for ****s and giggles
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Fair point about the main HMA icon in launcher, im just used to swiping form the home screen where its quicker to launch - will add

Edit also added:

Backup and Restore functions are available via the gear icon in HMA as well so you dont have to create a root template and tick all those apps again on a new installation, with the exception of one package....

At restore time you will need to add your renamed (hidden) Magisk Managers name back to the Root blacklist template and reboot

If anyones interested i might take some screens/video and maybe ask ipdev to link in 1st page somewhere
[Magisk] ipdev:
I see Accessibility Services shows as suspicious.

The About button is in the way on Setting Props so I can not see if it was found suspicious?

73sydney's screen shot shows both suspicious.

pndwal's screen shot shows both not found. :unsure:

I only trigger Setting Props suspicious due to developer options and debugging enabled.

Just curious about what triggers Accessibility Services as suspicious. 🙃

Cheers. :cowboy:

PS.

Magisk Debug personal build(s).

Built right from the Magisk repo.

Including the latest commit.
[Magisk] huskydg:
DID YOU SEE I SAID?
[Magisk] 73sydney:
For me:

Settings -

Dev Mode

Debugging

Accessiblity-

Nothing out of order for things you actually allow to use accessibility to appear here, so i choose to ignore it, like i mentioned previously Ruru i think is even more alarmist than Momo.....

For manageability ive resized this to a reasonable level, but its just a list of (9) apps at the top by App Name, and then lower down it lists the apps by packagename and even then granularly down to service level, so multiple references to apps at top

About my fave app uses accessibility...Do It Later, i love it, i can schedule it to send SMS etc at normal human hours, and people actually think im actually up at 8:30AM and on top of shizz, but im not, im asleep, and its our little secret.....
[Magisk] huskydg:
You again mentally masturbate with Ruru, just like everyone here used to do with Momo here, on this thread 😂
[Magisk] 73sydney:
It looked a LOT like you were posting screenshots of said apps with the impression given they ONLY worked under Magisk Delta.

Im sure im not the only one who got that impression.

You know, along with all the repeated posts of yours like:

"shamiko whitelist is useless and cannot prevent detection"

"shamiko can't hide zygisk"

which we see weekly

We get it, youre not a fan of Zygisk, and thats fine, but please at least try and be balanced, and give a fair representation of things

My posts today were merely to bring some balance back to the past days posts

Please realise part of this is because its non-trivial for some people who already struggle to get Magisk (stock) working, to then navigate switching to an entirely different fork and the resulting differing Riru based framework for some essential modules, when it may not be needed and HMA may be all thats missing in the puzzle

There are times where as you know that i myself have jumped between Magisk and Magisk Delta and back, i dont play favourites, i just use whats best for me at whatever point im at in time, and report issues ive had (which ive done with both forks)
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Im getting the distinct feeling you want to take this to a personal level. I dont, im only interested in debating points, not people. So lets do that and not send this south?

And for the record, i dont use Momo unless someone asks me because i personally dont find it useful, so im not sure what your comment even means?

im going to repaste my CPU with "Gamer Paste" and leave this here to hopefully take the atmosphere down a notch or two
[Magisk] J.Michael:
In a case where you had to put hidden manager in HMA's list of apps to conceal, have you ever tried un-hiding Magisk manager and putting it in HMA's list? I.e., if you use HMA to hide manager, does manager need to be hidden/renamed?
[Magisk] huskydg:
Is that just what you are thinking to to accuse me of being the bad guy? I didn't say it only work under my build and there are even no signal that i tell him to leave stock Magisk ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Sometimes you have to also appreciate the optics, at least ill admit, being an aspie, im a VERY visually stimulated person (possible flaw)

If i were to post "Magisk Delta cant hide x" and then post pics of apps people were struggling to hide when people knew i developed Magisk (stock) what would be a fair assumption to make?

I'll 100% issue a correction and apologise unreservedly if i was the only one who got that impression from the past few days of posts

Never said you were a bad guy, said you could be more balanced, big difference
[Magisk] huskydg:
Ofc I don't say it has perfect hidden ability, there are few apps that you can't bypass it no matter what you do, even use MagiskHide with no Zygisk (Example: Livin by Mandiri)
[Magisk] _Oshu_:
Hey I'm currently having a issue with Google wallet and I'm trying to figure out if it's a linage os issue, a magisk issue, or a Google issue rn.

Everything works pretty much, I pass safteynet check, Google certification is good, I can download stuff like Netflix and for the most part Google wallet works.

I'm using Android 12 on lineage os 19.1 with a oneplus5t. The problem I'm having is the wallet tile in the quick access menu and the lock screen wallet toggle in the settings menu are both grayed out and none functional. It's really a minor issue but are features I want to take advantage of.

If anyone has any idea about this issue, or at the very least know where I should be pointed at, it would be a lot of help
[Magisk] pndwal:
Yes... Did extensive tests for S-pushTAN.

Found this solution, but it didn't work w/o first taking Hiding the Magisk app to obfuscate package name etc, but as Promon engine (apparently) uses pattern matching on classes.dex which isn't hidden, we need HMA hiding also:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/1084#issuecomment-964222271

It later stopped working for MIUI:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/1084#issuecomment-1013811582

... Seems OnePlus, other users have no issues... PW
[Magisk] msohail_7:
SBI is working fine but HDFC app.

With HMA ON do i have to keep deny list ON as well?

Device:OnePlus 9 pro
[Magisk] J.Michael:
If you turn on Deny List, then Shamiko will do nothing. So, no, do not enforce Deny List in Magisk.
[Magisk] huskydg:
As zygisk will exec original app_process, there are possible the traces

I seem to find a way to partial fix zygisk detectable, but that need to change the way zygisk load
[Magisk] pndwal:
Many (most?) banks now require deviceIntegrity... You need to fix this...

Do you have @Displax's modded/forked USNF module w/ fix for deviceIntegrity?...

🙃 PW
[Magisk] msohail_7:
Done. I have updated to Mod 2.0
[Magisk] msohail_7:
Next this👆

Does any of this stuff causes bootloop? Cant lose data
[Magisk] zgfg:
HMA does not cause bootloop (of course, unless you maybe start hiding system apps from the other system apps, some idiotic things)
[Magisk] pndwal:
Nb.

HMA V3.0.0 Beta and above:

"3. No longer need the Magisk module, make sure to uninstall it, or you will bootloop"

https://github.com/Dr-TSNG/Hide-My-Applist/releases

So ensure MagiskExtension .zip Magisk module for 2.x HMA is uninstalled or was never installed... PW
[Magisk] huskydg:
As i tested there were not much apps
[Magisk] 73sydney:
I'll add this to the "mini guide"

I'll add pictures for the setup during the week

update: bootloop warning and HMA v2 magisk module and apk uninstall advice added:

Note #1 (Versions): Do NOT use the downloader in Lsposed Manager to download it, currently thats the last v2 official, you want the v3 beta

Note #2 (Bootloops): HMA v2 also used a companion magisk module, that if you forgot uninstall when uninstalling HMA itself, would cause a bootloop. HMA v3 DOES NOT require a magisk module to achieve its purpose, so please DO NOT attempt to install HMA v3 over the top of HMA v2, or install the magisk module from HMA v2 separately, in conjunction with v3. If you have HMA v2 installed, please uninstall the HMA v2 magisk module via Magisk Manager, then remove HMA, and reboot, before installing HMA v3.
[Magisk] msohail_7:
Thanks will try and see how it goes.
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Hide My AppList Guide i started in a post in this thread is now in its own thread here:

Hide My Applist - A Brief Guide

Hide My Applist Guide Hide My Applist is a LSPosed module by Dr-TSNG (nullptr). Often referred to as HMA. In the simplest terms HMA aims to stop one app detecting a list of other installed apps. - It can often help stop your banking app(s) from...

xdaforums.com
[Magisk] alawadhi3000:
Can anyone assist with BenefitPay app?

BenefitPay - Apps on Google Play

Consumer application allowing customer to pay using their mobile in Bahrain.

play.google.com

The app is in the denylist & Magisk manager app was renamed, it still detects the root, tried shamiko as well and it didn't help.
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Tested (S20+ 5G A13) :

Magisk (official & hidden)

Universal SafetyNet Fix (Mod 2)

Shamiko

Result: FAIL

Magisk (official & hidden)

Universal SafetyNet Fix (Mod 2)

Shamiko

Hide My Applist

Result: FAIL

Magisk (official & hidden)

Universal SafetyNet Fix (Mod 2)

Shamiko

Hide My Applist

Developer Settings Disabled

(which gives as clean a result as ive ever gotten on detection apps)

Result: FAIL

Perhaps someone with Magisk Delta could test this one?

Its a weird one, doesnt even open a gui before announcing via a bottom toast its found root, i did logcat it and can see its doing the usual things like checking the device fingerprint and security patch, but beyond that i dont see anything that makes any sense to a non reversalist
[Magisk] huskydg:
Work fine for me (tested with zygisk/riru+magiskhide)
[Magisk] alawadhi3000:
I'm suspecting that it shows root detected just for unlocked bootloader.
[Magisk] alawadhi3000:
Just install Magisk Delta?

Edit:- My bad, thought your reply was for another user/issue, long day sorry.
[Magisk] zgfg:
@alawadhi3000:

Magisk Delta, Zygisk enabled (SuList not), BenefitPay in MagiskHide

Magisk Delta app not hidden and no need to use Hide My Applist (I tested first with, then without)

BenefitPay opens (I don't go further since it offers prefix numbers only for six countries)
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Cheers
[Magisk] dcarvil:
I've updated my Pixel 2XL to Lineage unofficial 20.0 (Android 13), and am trying to install Magisk. I patched boot.img with both Magisk stable 25.2 and the latest Canary 25.5. In both cases, when I do "fastboot boot magisk-patched.img", the boot fails with no error message, then reboots into the unpatched stock image.

Any ideas on anything else I can try, or any way to get logs? I've also tried to patch boot.img on another phone. The resulting image was identical, and produced the same result.
[Magisk] rodken:
Try

fastboot flash boot_a magisk-patched.img
fastboot flash boot_b magisk-patched.img
or
fastboot flash boot --slot all magisk-patched.img
[Magisk] dcarvil:
That will just put me into a continuous boot loop. The problem is the patched image will not boot.
[Magisk] J.Michael:
Are you able to "fastboot boot" the unpatched boot.img?
[Magisk] rodken:
I thought that you already tried to adb sideload the Magisk.zip via LOS Recovery menu.
[Magisk] dcarvil:
Yes, "fastboot boot" works fine on the unpatched boot.img.
[Magisk] dcarvil:
No, I am using the patch boot.img method, not the sideload method.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Sorry, I didn't follow from the beginning, don't know how did you originally start with

Did you maybe previously had the Magisk installed, and then you upgraded the ROM (or kernel)

And before the upgrade, you didn't disable or uninstall your module(s)

Some of those modules might not be compatible with the upgraded ROM.

Hence, when Magisk boots, it initializes the old modules and some of them causes that bootloop

---

Explanation:

Dirty upgrading the ROM does not wipe Data, hence everything (incl. the modules) from the previous Magisk installation, remains on /data/adb and waits as a potential time bomb until you would later boot again with the Magisk
[Magisk] dcarvil:
I did Factory Reset, then Format data / factory reset before installing new ROM. That should have removed all modules. I did not have many modules anyway, only ACC, MHCP, and USNF.
[Magisk] pndwal:
Scroll down to this section:

Module causing issues (Magisk functionality, bootloop, loss of root, etc)

from:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskModuleIssues# PW

Just saw post above... What happens if you simply fastboot flash the image? PW
[Magisk] dcarvil:
I don't see anything at that link that applies. Doesn't "format data" remove all modules anyway?
[Magisk] dcarvil:
Flashing the image results in a continuous bootloop.
[Magisk] RubyRose:
Hello forum!

I configured Magisk 25.1 + Modules (Zygisk - LSPosed, Shamiko, SafetyNet Fix, HideProps Config) + HMA.

Thanks to this thread, I successfully pass in Oprek, RootBeer and Applist Detector. Root not found.

But in Momo I got the following errors:

SELinux is permissive.

Data not encrypted, mount parameters are modified.

ART parameters are abnormal.

Seccomp is disabled.

Device is running a custom ROM.

I solved the first 2 problems by installing SELinuxModeChanger (and hiding it in hma) and the "Fake Encryption" module in Magisk.

But after installing SELinuxModeChanger and selecting the Enforcing mode, I lost permissions in applications (for example, AIDA cannot access the temperature).

After I tried to solve the problem "ART parameters are abnormal". In this thread, it was advised to comment out the system.prop file in the LSPosed module folder (#). But when I entered the folder using Total Commander - I couldn't find the file I needed. And through the general search too. Now I don't know how to solve this problem.

As a solution to the last problems, I found information about the magisk_overlayfs module. But after it, only the visibility of Magisk inside Momo changed.

System: LineageOS 18.1 (Android 11)

Please tell me how can I fix it?
[Magisk] pndwal:
That's why I struck out reply... Since you just mentioned you did clean update... PW
[Magisk] pndwal:
Ok... Cos fastboot boot xxxboot.img is not working for Android 13 / P7 series...

https://xdaforums.com/t/unlock-bootloader-root-pixel-7-pro-cheetah-safetynet.4502805/post-87566251

...May be broken for all/other devices w/ A13?...

Still, strange you get bootloop w/ clean A13 and standard flash on P2XL... Did you download/extract/patch boot.img from same unofficial 20.0 LOS ROM?...

Could be an issue w/ unofficial 20.0 LOS build; it's likely dev has integrated SafetyNet Fix / CTS Profile match spoofing etc that may interfere with Magisk although it's doubtful that issues would occur w/o any modules set up... Official LOS will never add such "fixes", so may be worth trying an (earlier) official build or waiting for official 20.0...

There may also be other compatibility related reasons why Official is still on 19.1... PW