yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] dohanin:
Thanks. Tried to do the same. After disabling USNF, enabling MHPC and adding back Google Play Services in Denylist, Safetynet did not pass CTS and no change to unlocked bootloader (still detected). Had to revert back to USNF. Guess it's not possible for Zenfone 8 or may need some other tricks.
[Magisk] shoey63:
Try this:

In the props menu do "reset all props" it will remove them all.

Then "set all props" It will set every one of them up (There's heaps)

Then reboot and see if the magic happens like it did to me🤞
[Magisk] dohanin:
Thanks again. Already tried this, and after reset and set all props, only the 3 shown as above. Is it same for your phone?

Another thing different from you is that I don't use LSPosed since I don't need those modules. Not sure if it has anything to do with this though.
[Magisk] shoey63:
Try the Key attestion test

Mine says Bootloader is locked even after disabling all modules and zygisk. Asus must have borked something (maybe intentionally)? on the last update for the Rog 5. Obviously Yasnac fails epically in such a state
[Magisk] shoey63:
As it turns out, all I need for perfect results, after re-enabling zygisk is Shamiko. No MHPC or anything else🤔
[Magisk] dohanin:
I guess Asus did it differently for the two phones... mine is showing Bootloader Unlocked in Key attestion test, whether or not there are modules in use. Anyway, thanks a lot for your time.
[Magisk] hungtinglung:
my phone is note 9.

custom ROM port from note 10+.

android 12.

one ui 4.

safetynet pass.
[Magisk] XTrail02:
Can you tell us what Custom Rom you used on your Note 9 and passing Safetynet.

I'm using Samsung Note 9 too with stock rooted rom but I can't pass CTS Profile Match, tried everything already.

Some of my banking and work related apps don't work because of this.

Thank you.
[Magisk] hungtinglung:
https://xdaforums.com/t/noble-rom-2...-sm-g96xf-fd-n.4244747/page-112#post-86451929
[Magisk] z1022:
Hi LuisCarlosHK

I cannot find Airfrozen in playstore. Where can I find it ? Thanks
[Magisk] LuisCarlosHK:
GitHub - hyongbai/AirFrozen: An app to freeze apps

An app to freeze apps. Contribute to hyongbai/AirFrozen development by creating an account on GitHub.

github.com
[Magisk] z1022:
Thanks

I frozen Magisk Manger but cannot work. Still detect Root.
[Magisk] LuisCarlosHK:
Did you repack magisk?

Here is my setting.
[Magisk] z1022:
I repacked magisk manager name to "Set" and then frozen "Set" use AirFrozen. But HSBC app still detect ROOT.

Did any setting in AirFrozen ?

Thanks
[Magisk] LuisCarlosHK:
No other setting in airfrozen.

Did you add HSBC app in denylist?
[Magisk] z1022:
Yes, HSBC app in denylist.

Which Modules install in Magisk ?
[Magisk] TheDon13:
Not sure I can wade thru 42 pages of Magisk 24 & 24.1 forum chat.!! ;)Would really appreciate a succinct concise explanation as to how Zygisk & v 24 Magisk has real advantages over the previous iterations?? Never managed to get Santander nor Halifax banking apps to not detect root....
[Magisk] zgfg:
Advantages or not, but the fact is that previous versions of Magisk will be no more supported (no updates, no support for the new Android versions and devices, etc)

You don't need to read 24 pages, but a newcomer should be supposed to read OP posts (posts by ipdev at the beginning of the thread), to learn and understand an overview about the new Magisk v24, DenyList, Zygisk, etc
[Magisk] heinhuiz:
... and of course your very helpful post #14. Don't be shy to mention that.
[Magisk] AhmedPlayer:
how did you do it without magisk hide? step by step from installing magisk till testing it. Please!!
[Magisk] m0han:
:D @zgfg is very helpful (and too modest with this).
[Magisk] zgfg:
Post #14 in this thread.

But I warn you again - your milleage with different phones (Xiaomi vs Pixel and so) can highly vary (regarding to Widevine, Momo detections, etc)
[Magisk] z1022:
It worked. I forgot freeze the app in AirFrozen. Thank you for your help.
[Magisk] LuisCarlosHK:
Are you sure that magisk was frozen?

If magisk is frozen, it won't appear in app drawer.

Do you pass safetynet ?
[Magisk] TheDon13:
Next time I want a question not actually answered, I'll know to ask you first.....

Magisk 23 incorporating Magisk Hide and with LSposed Module & XPrivacy Lua made Goole Pay work, v24 Magisk with or without Zygisk and enforce/configure deny list ticked means GPay does not work, as far as I can see.

And its 42 pages, not 24....
[Magisk] z1022:
I install the latest Shamiko but Momo still detect init.rc
[Magisk] dohanin:
Try Shamiko-v0.4.3-102. There is no change in release notes, so it should be bug fix. It works for me.
[Magisk] z1022:
no luck. Still show init.rc modfied.

Can you show your momo screen ?

thanks
[Magisk] Kastorpol:
No provided solution is working. Banking application Revolut still detects root and doesn't start. The only solution is to go back to version of Magisk 23
[Magisk] dohanin:
Here you go.

I'm using Canary 24012, enabled Zygisk, Shamiko (i.e. don't Enforce Denylist), added Momo to Denylist. Make sure you kill Momo after changes and reboot.
[Magisk] mrjuniork:
I have to clarify, that I absolutely disagree with you in this.

@zgfg is one the most helpful and skilled contributers in this and other threads.

If you had read at least some of those 42 pages (you can assume the numbers were mixed up...) you would have noticed that instantly.

Indeed, reading all those pages is time consuming, but you could also search for "key words" and combine that with browsing through the pages, you will get some real good results.

Since this thread is fairly new to the game, you might also want to check out the main Magisk thread, since there was a lot of talk (and still is) regarding Zygisk and the likes.

So, if your previous setup works just fine, there is no need to change a running system. But if you wanna switch up, you should take in all that information here and there, in order to be sure of what you are doing and to be satisfied with the results in the end (the way I did it).

Afterall, v24 is the future reference to go with (and all the other perks that come along with it).

Good luck with finding a feasible way to get everything running smoothly 👍🏼

Cheers
[Magisk] Spartacus500:
I installed Revolut on Samsung with Magisk zygisk, hid Revolut in deny list, deleted Revolut data and it works.
[Magisk] TheDon13:
Perhaps I was a bit harsh but I just wanted a simple answer to a simple question....

I was looking to not spend a lot of my precious time reading reams of pages.

I will personally look to revert to v. 23 with magisk hide, safetynet passing using lsposed & xpruivacy lua steps and therefore Google pay working as I had before under v. 23.

My issues began with Xiaomi updating my phone to miui 13 (android 12) which resulted in my phone losing root.....

🙄😒
[Magisk] zgfg:
And what about the time of others - your time (to read) is precious but you don't mind and want the others to read and spend their time to repeat you the known/documented things

Anyway, don't need to quote me, my time is also precious to spend on that 😁
[Magisk] Kastorpol:
Thank you. Finally Revolut works for Magisk 24.1. Solution: Stop application Revolut and clear data for Revolut application many times
[Magisk] m0han:
you might like to check out this thread by @Didgeridoohan and the thread by @BostonDan and the post therein by @73sydney. i'm sure you're aware that users are spending time here - to be helpful in the community.
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Cheers for my inclusion here, its worth pointing out to TheDon13, and all, that i have not used my own module for (well) over a year now, though some users in some edge cases still maintain its the only thing that works for them....i keep waiting for it to die :)

1st priority is to pass SafetyNet, as always has been. Google Pay will work 99.9% of the time once that passes. Passing SafetyNet can be a very ROM-centric thing. For me i only needed a fingerprint set by MagiskHide Props Config on my Pixel 2XL, on my new S20+ 5G, i only need to use the Universal SafetyNet Fix. Recommended, by me at least, is to try with nothing then try Universal SafetyNet Fix, and if no go, try MagiskHide Props Config

Beyond that, plenty of tips in the bloated post of mine (that needs updating), most issues we've seen solved by toggling on airplane mode and clearing data on Google Play Service, Google Play Store and Google Pay (will remove cards), rebooting and toggling airplane mode back off...then waiting 5 minutes to check Certification status in Google Play store. It amongst many other troubleshooting tips are in my bloated post that needs updating to reflect the move to Magisk 24 and Zygisk (so far Zygisk and Deny List (+/- Shamiko) appear as stable as MagiskHide ever was for Google Pay). The module itself has been updated to work with either magiskhide or zygisk and deny list, its install script should detect which you are using. Having said that i recommend trying to not use the module and instead do it manually by first achieving/passing SafetyNet, and then adding Google Pay to magiskhide or zygisk deny list and testing.

https://xdaforums.com/t/working-mag...s-17-1-22-on-pie.3929950/page-9#post-79643248

I will be updating the modules post this weekend, time it had a bit of a tidy up....
[Magisk] z1022:
Hi Everyone.

Where can I find "enhanced mode for HideMyApplist," module?

Thanks
[Magisk] martyfender:
https://github.com/Dr-TSNG/Hide-My-Applist
[Magisk] martyfender:
Install the apk, launch it and choose the option install the magisk extension, zygisk.
[Magisk] z1022:
Thanks, Before use HMA I need install Xposed or not ?

I have already installed Zygisk-LSPosed.

Also I don't know how to manually extract the installer from the apk and rename it to Zygisk-HideMyApplist.zip.
[Magisk] TheDon13:
Thank you
[Magisk] z1022:
Where I find MyHideApp lsposed module ?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Correct name is Hide My Applist (HMA)- mentioned several times here, pls scroll through the few very recent posts
[Magisk] westhaking:
What exactly does the enhanced mode of HMA offer?
[Magisk] SkyGuest:
When you select an application in (DenyList) - Services Google Play, the check mark is dropped after the phone restarts. What can be done? Sincerely, Tommy
[Magisk] xabu:
Hi @SkyGuest,

For as far as I understood, this is normal and nothing to worry about.

But it should happen only at the services.

More specific Google Services Framework

As soon as you tick on it you'll see that the two processes gapps and

gservices are toggled ...

🌷 if you change something in the denylist your should always restart the phone immediately after for getting the changes done.🌷
[Magisk] zgfg:
Of course, but only if you use USNF 2.2.1 (it takes care of GMS)

(Known - commented couple of times)
[Magisk] xabu:
Hello @zgfg is there a reason why GSF is everytime un-toggled?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Answered in the post above yours

Further, you could ask the USNF dev in his thread or over his Github project😔

At the end of the day, where is a problem if you're passing SN with USNF
[Magisk] xabu:
Well...it is not a problem but I was and am still curious why. I know it is nothing to worry about but there must be a reason (or it's a bug) ...
[Magisk] zgfg:
If I recall correctly, somebody provided a link to his commits on Github when it was introduced. Don't remember was there a comment in the code - but it doesn't happen by chance, it's coded into the module

Probably to emhasize that his module takes care of GMS and that it would still do even if you wanted to remove GMS from your DenyList (as long as you have USNF installed and enabled)

(USNF takes care of GMS even if you omitted to list GMS in your DenyList - it needs to, as part of making a way to pass SN)

For me it's all logical
[Magisk] xabu:
" For me it's all logical" ...... sigh .... for many, many of us totally not :geek:. But I always enjoy being here 🌷🌷🌷. Thanks @zgfg !
[Magisk] dohanin:
It's by design of USNF. If you look at its codes (just unzip the file and look at post-fs-data.sh):

#!/system/bin/sh

# Remove Play Services from DenyList, otherwise the Zygisk module won't load
magisk --denylist rm com.google.android.gms
[Magisk] rophiroth:
I try hide my applist, but is not working on my bank app, module and service is running, configuration is OK, applist detector is intercepted successfully... Don't know what could be going wrong
[Magisk] Lord Sithek:
Usually it means that something isn't configured properly. Did you make sure...

- you created proper template? Means if you chose "Create blacklist template", selected "Edit list" next to "X apps invisible", marked ALL apps that need to be hidden (like Magisk app, Xposed modules and probablly all other apps using root access), then went back, added a name for the template and saved it?

- you applied your template correctly to your bank app? Means if you went to "Select Effective apps", found your bank app, marked "Enable hide" and "Enable all hide methods", then under "Template config" section chose the template you created before, then clicked SAVE on the right-upper corner?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Nothing necessarily wrong, bank app probably use some other method to detect (or guess about) root

There are clever and less clever bank apps. No guarantee that this and/or that method will work for EVERY banking app and on EVERY platform/phone

Search if for your banking app was already discussed (here, generally on XDA, on Internet) and if the tips are published (or confirmed that detection cannot be prevented on particular platform)

Magisk Github / Wiki pages, there is a section with some tips that may help for banking apps (again, no guarantee they will work for every of them)
[Magisk] mrjuniork:
Thread cleaned.

I guess this has been obvious 🥴

Since I'm a regular follower of this thread, I'm afraid this won't be the last time for cleaning the house.

If I don't notice any offtopic posts (RL reasons), feel free to use the report function.

It is very important for future readability and other reasons (in reference to the main Magisk thread..) to keep this thread as clean as possible.

Any future offtopic posts will be deleted without announcement.

Just another service provided by your friendly neighborhood mod,

mrjuniork

Cheers
[Magisk] half_android:
I need update instructions android 11/12 Pixel 4 please!!
[Magisk] westhaking:
You came to the right place! Follow the Installation Instructions link on post #2.
[Magisk] ashish1989:
I have used USNF to make my PS certified. Wanted to know, if I can remove it now, as it has done its job. And the play services is not visible in denylist after everytime on reboot because of it.
[Magisk] martyfender:
No, it is a magisk module that only makes systemless modifications when installed. It purposely removes the play services from the denylist. It is hidden in other ways.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Besides the known "disable" file to disable a Magisk module and "remove" to uninstall (on next reboot), I see now in the Magisk docs on Github a third one "skip_mount"

Does anybody recall if "skip_mount" was present earlier or it was added recently with Magisk v24 (I didn't go to search in commits)?

Btw, I tested with e.g, Systemless hosts module.

Upon rebooted, AdAway's hosts file was not mounted (and I saw ads), hence effectively the Systemless Hosts was disabled

However, regarding the corresponding options in Magisk app, Modules:

- there is a radio-button to control when module is disabled by "disable", and Remove buttun to mark the module by "remove" for uninstallition (it will be crossed-out in Magisk app to see that it waits for uninstallation

- but there is no UI option to manipulate "skip_mount"

One can control "skip_mount" only through TWRP or a root Explorer

Developer Guides

The Magic Mask for Android

topjohnwu.github.io
[Magisk] half_android:
Following the instructions from Magisk for Pixel 4 I'm getting the following error and cannot figure it out.

fastboot flash boot C:\Users\Scott\AppData\Local\Android\Sdk\platform-tools/patched.img
target reported max download size of 268435456 bytes
sending 'boot_a' (98304 KB)...
OKAY [ 2.371s]
writing 'boot_a'...
(bootloader) Image missing cmdline or OS version
FAILED (remote: Failed to write to partition Bad Buffer Size)
finished. total time: 2.522s
[Magisk] J.Michael:
You have a single, forward, slash ("/") in your path. Probably not a problem, or it would have said something like "file not found".

Check that the original image was copied correctly to the phone, and that the patched image was copied correctly to the PC. (I use md5sum at both ends and compare the hash strings.)

Make a point of telling us which version of Magisk Manager app you used to patch.
[Magisk] zgfg:
If you had copied the patched.img directly into your adb/fastboot folder, you don't need to use the full.path but only the name:

fastboot flash boot patched.img

Was the patched.img patched correctly?

You can patch again and provide the screenshot from Magisk app, like the mine as attached

Did you copy the right patched.img (usually, Magisk gives the longer names to the patched images but you could have change it)
[Magisk] half_android:
Yes I renamed it well the the boot image patches fine no issue there but when I upload it to my laptop and go into fastboot

fastboot flash boot /path/to/magisk_patched.img

I get:

writing 'boot_a'...
(bootloader) Image missing cmdline or OS version
FAILED (remote: Failed to write to partition Bad Buffer Size)
finished. total time: 2.522s
[Magisk] DaOldMan:
What do you actually write ? Show a cmd screenshot as /path/to/magisk_patched.img is totaly wrong. The "path to" should be changed to your actual path on the laptop so should be d:\here\mydir\path\blah\blah\magisk_patched.img

Or something like that. It seems not to find your file. Best is to do it in the directory with the patched image and use NO PATH at all aka: fastboot flash boot magisk_patched.img and nothing else.

Cheers.
[Magisk] pndwal:
Also, working straight from ADB directory in root directory can work (w/ simple fastboot flash boot magisk_patched.img command) when directories up the tree won't... PW
[Magisk] maor23:
Hey guys, got a question.

I need to update OTA on my phone, and every tutorial i read, they say i need to download twrp a/b retention module, but i cant find one that good for magisk 24.1.

What can i do and how can i find modules?
[Magisk] zgfg:
You can find it directly on the old Magisk repo (browser, google):

GitHub - Magisk-Modules-Repo/twrp-keep: twrp-keep

twrp-keep. Contribute to Magisk-Modules-Repo/twrp-keep development by creating an account on GitHub.

github.com

or by using Fox Magisk Module Manager app (merges modules from three repisitories and providing what was previously in Magisk app/mngr, Modules online

Don't know if that's what you are looking for and would it work for your A/B OTA

(I would e.g., flash back the stock Boot and Recovery, apply OTA and patch the Magisk to the new Boot / install TWRP again)
[Magisk] maor23:
Ok, I'll look for it, Thanks.

One more question, how do I install the zygisk and lsposed?
[Magisk] zgfg:
OP posts at the beginning of this thread
[Magisk] digger16309:
I'm unsure of this is related to being rootef but asking for opinions...

Pixel 5, A11, Magisk 24, USNF, LSPosed. Device reading as certified in Play Store. YASNAC passes. Cleared Play Store and Play Services cache.

The problem: Google Apps / System app updates won't download or install. Download auto-attempts several times and then just quits. No issues with non-Google or non-System updates.

Examples: Google Photos, Carrier Services.

Yes I re-booted. And issue is same on WiFi or mobile data.

Thoughts?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Once I had the similar issue two or three apps - PlayStore was showing the updates available but any atteempt to download/install failed

I downloaded and installed manually from apkmirror (trustworthy source)
[Magisk] digger16309:
Thanks. I forgot about that. Of course, after a two day problem, almost as soon as I posted, the problem resolved itself. 🤔
[Magisk] joriq:
If someone is patient enough, I'd need assistance. Namely, I had magisk on my OnepPlus 6T and no TWRP. A few weeks ago there was an update to the magisk app, but since it stated that there will be no root hide directly from the app, I decided not to update yet. Then I got another notification for a magisk update, but it might have been an update for the magisk itself (not sure), I think I declined, but I might have mistakenly clicked yes.

So, now my phone cannot open the magisk app (keeps force closing), does not have actual root (rootchecker app fails), but the apps that check for root (like banking apps) see my phone as rooted and refuse to work.

My question is: can someone provide me with a step-by-step noob-proof instructions on how to fix the problem or at least how to unistall magisk completely withot the app?

PS I'd prefer not to install TWRP and keep my stock recovery, in order to not over-complicate things on this A/B partitioned phone.
[Magisk] half_android:
Tried with no path as well my paths are correct don't mind that what I need is clarification on what the error is actually telling me as I'm new to the android scene. Will try adb pulling directly as i'm actually copying the patched file from pixel to my laptop manually.
[Magisk] J.Michael:
If you had renamed the Magisk Manager app, and you updated the Magisk Manager app, you might now have two Magisk Manager apps.

Uninstall (from Android app info screen) Magisk Manager app.

Look in app drawer for renamed Magisk Manager app. Try running it. See if it says Magisk is installed. If it does not, uninstall the renamed app.

Then try installing a new Magisk Manager app.

Please do not rename the app, or do anything else to "hide", until you confirm you have a working Magisk Manager app / Magisk installed.
[Magisk] joriq:
Bingo! My magisk app was indeed renamed, using the option from within the app itself. A few weeks ago I did try installing the new magisk app without uninstalling the previous version, so I indeed ended up with 2 apps, but the old one kept force closing and the new one didn't see that Magisk was installed, so I deleted the new one.

Now I deleted the old one, installed the new one and everyhing works fine. I stopped there, i.e. I did not update Magisk itself, it's still on v23. I guess it is safe to do now, but would like to seek advice for how to hide it from the relevant apps, what is the recommended method/module for v24.1?
[Magisk] beeshyams:
https://xdaforums.com/t/guide-unlock-root-safetynet-for-pixel-4a.4153773/post-86478577

Similar problem with reason. Could be the same with you (aside, did you update adb to the latest?)
[Magisk] dimpoblimpo:
Why are my modules always grayed out(not accessible) when trying to install from local storage? I'm downloading the .zips and can't seem to manually install through both magisk and fox's manager. I can download and install just fine through fox though.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Try using another file manager.

There was a similar case in the past and problem was in the file manager

If using a stock file manager, install e.g. MiXPlorer and select it when navigating to the Download
[Magisk] dimpoblimpo:
Awesome thank you. I even had my paid version of solid file explorer installed but the issue was I had the toggle on to disable permissions of the generic file explorer in arrow ROM. Seems after handing it over to solid all is well.
[Magisk] rodken:
Select the 3 dots and selecting "Show internal storage"?
[Magisk] dimpoblimpo:
Alls good it was an issue with my ROMs stock file manager. I had to hand permissions over to another manager. Thanks everyone
[Magisk] suhel28:
The new update with Zygisk just won't work for hiding root. My Outlook and other microsoft related app won't work. It's frustrating
[Magisk] dohanin:
It works for me. I'm using Magisk Canary + Zygisk enabled + Denylist disabled + Shamiko + USNF.
[Magisk] suhel28:
Tried. Didn't work. 😞
[Magisk] dohanin:
Did you add the apps that need to hide root (e.g. Outlook) in Denylist? Also, remember to clear app's data/cache and reboot to make sure it's clean. For me, I also keep the magisk app disabled when not in use.

That's all I have done. You may also try magisk detector, oprek detector, momo, etc., to see if your root hiding is in good shape.