yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] highsciguy:
Thanks for these ideas. I have the modules. One of the items that may fail the SafetyNet check, according to the Magisk module help, is a remnant old Magisk. This could be my issue, since my Magisk update wasn't clean. Turned out that I should have done Magisk unhide first.

Indeed my primary problem is that phototan now crashes when I start it. But, since my previous experience with it has been that it doesn't work when SafetyNet fails, I tend to not spend more time on the issue. At some point I should update to a new Lineage version and see if I still need phototan.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Changing the fingerprint is only for the CTS profile check.
[Magisk] Laptapper:
Phototan is working for you?

I've tried hours with setting installing rebooting but I've found no way
[Magisk] ralphabt:
I guess safetynet status is irrelevant for (currently newest) phototan app. I fail both basicIntegrity and ctsProfile on android 10, still phototan works with riru unshare & XPrivacyLua
[Magisk] Laptapper:
Please could you write the detailed steps to success with the phototan app?
[Magisk] ralphabt:
1. Make sure Magisk Manager is hidden and its app name is changed to something else

2. Install Riru Core, Riru EdXposed and Riru Unshare, reboot

3. Activate MagiskHide for all three phototan processes

4. Open EdXposed Manager, install XPrivacyLua, reboot. If you use Xposed Hide, make sure phototan is not blacklisted

5. Open XPrivacyLua, select phototan and tick "Get applications"

6. phototan should work now

For many users, EdXposed & XPrivacyLua are not needed - in my case, phototan is crashing when not using them.

I did not need to clear phototan app data, but if the app does not work yet you can try clearing phototan cache and if it still does not work, clear app data too. Beware: Should you clear app data you will need to go through the phototan activation process again.

As my device is not passing either of the two SafetyNet checks, I don't think it they are necessary for phototan.
[Magisk] JJ111:
Thanks, I did everything from number 2 till 6, but unfortunately it doesn't work, still detecting root (see attached screenshot)

I can't do number 1, cause the hide function in Magisk app it is greyed out (see second attached screenshot).

Does someone know why/ what I can do to hide the magisk app?

Btw: so silly, that they (comdirect and their programmers) are making such a trouble about root, I have root to be more (!) secure and privacy protective (AfWall+/firewall, Adaway, XPrivacyLua/Pro,....)

@comdirect: if you read this, please stop and let us use the app with root. You should stop the app from running, if people use a total old Android without any recent security patches etc, there lies a risk, not with us up to date custom rom+root users!

--edit--

I use latest Magisk (currently 23.0), Android 11 based custom rom, Android 11 Firmware, Rom is OSS based, no GApps
[Magisk] ralphabt:
@JJ111 try uninstalling & reinstalling Magisk Manager. The hide option should not be greyed out. In my case, there is a button to un-hide the Magisk app.

FYI I think you ran into a different detection mechanism. The newly added root detection in version 8.3.0 crashes the app directly after startup and does not show any message like on your 2nd screenshot. You could also try to disable all EdXposed and Magisk modules except Riru Core, Riru Unshare, XPrivacyLua and Riru EdXposed itself.

I just noticed that you have disabled Magisk updates. Make sure you are using the latest version, Magisk 23.0 and Magisk Manager 23.0
[Magisk] Laptapper:
May for you it's working in case of Android 10, others may on 11
[Magisk] Laptapper:
No new solutions for android 11?

For me phototan detects root everytime although hide magisk edxposed xprivacylua riru unshare... It's quiet annoying
[Magisk] firegate22:
https://xdaforums.com/t/comdirect-phototan-app-detecting-root-fix-found.4274825/post-85101623

Thanks to this - it's working for me on 1+ 7T custom rom (YAAP, A11) with root. Magisk 23.0 (23000), App the same.

Magisk App hidden (unhide is possible), Magisk Hide activated

Modules:

Riru 25.4.4r426

Riru EdXposed v0.5.2.2

Riru - Enhanced mode for Magisk Hide v2

Riru LSPosed v1.4.4

XPrivacyLua activated via LSPosed and EdXPosed and marked Get Applications for the PhotoTan app in XPrivacyLua. Magisk Hide - all 3 processes for PhotoTan activated

I did clear data for the app - but don't know if it is necessary or not - I failed on several tries before.

PhotoTan 8.3.0

I hope this helps maybe... don't forgot to restart to make sure the modules etc. are activated.
[Magisk] 73sydney:
From memory youre only supposed to be running EdXposed OR LSPosed, not both?
[Magisk] Laptapper:
😢 For me nothing is working to get the phototan running
[Magisk] bloodgnome:
I found everything except "Riru - Enhanced mode for Magisk Hide v2" whats this?
[Magisk] Laptapper:
GitHub - vvb2060/riru-unshare

Contribute to vvb2060/riru-unshare development by creating an account on GitHub.

github.com
[Magisk] Laptapper:
Did you've success with phototan running?

Me not....
[Magisk] Conan179:
@Laptapper

If you follow these instructions exactly, it will work, I set it up on my note 20 and note 9 today.
[Magisk] Laptapper:
So, it's working also for me

But I've tried with magisk 23 no success

Unrooted completely, checking phototan and insert app password

Rooted with magisk 22.1

Followed steps of manual exactly additional

given edxpose root rights

Success
[Magisk] Conan179:
For everyone who used edxposed, I recommend switching to LSPosed, the reason is quite simple, edxposed breaks the safetynet test.

I switched to LSPosed on 3 of my devices and the phototan app runs on all of them without any problems
[Magisk] XDAMaxe:
youu'll have to use canary build (change the channel within magisk app) to get the banking app work (as mentioned magiskhide banking app and tan app and hide magisk manager renamed to something different)
[Magisk] Laptapper:
You've done only as you've described and phototan is working!?

BTW EdXposed is really damaging safety net!
[Magisk] Laptapper:
So guys

My favorite solution:

Magisk canary

Riru

Riru unshare

Riru lsposed

Xprivacilua 1.30

Safety net is ok

Phototan working
[Magisk] Laptapper:
Hi to phototan root users

For me the last method was unstable so I tried other ways...

Now I've got the easiest method to get phototan working on rooted phones:

Only installed riru and riru unshare

Magisk hide and magisk renamed

Then 3C toolbox and disabling only one service.... Voila
[Magisk] 01249898573904601956:
Hmm, this does not work for me on surya.
[Magisk] Conan179:
how did you exactly set lsposed and Xprivacilua?
[Magisk] Laptapper:
Maybe it's also unstable for you as for me

Try this

https://xdaforums.com/t/comdirect-phototan-app-detecting-root-fix-found.4274825/post-85340401

But @Conan179 he is right, we need to know your settings

And sure you've got xprivacylua 1.30?
[Magisk] pa.pn2:
working perfect for me. thanks for this find dude:)
[Magisk] Laptapper:
Now there's an update 8.3.2

Didn't work anymore

Did you've updated?
[Magisk] Conan179:
Dude, i dont have problems,
[Magisk] Laptapper:
Which way, with 3c or xprivacylua?

I got the 8.3.2 also running again. But now with xprivacylua AND 3c
[Magisk] Conan179:
xprivacylua

I have too devices.

a note 9 with android 10 and a note 20 ultra 5g Android 11.

Note 9 phototan app working.

Note 20 phototan app dont working, same setting, inntresting.

I know, the innstall on my note 9 was not correct, installed the apk again over it and the same message comes up that it is not allowed, downgrade ok and wait is now announced.

edit:

Now fry me a stork, I have downgraded the phototan app on my note9, now it works without problems on my Note 20.

I don't understand what's going on.

Please take a look at yourself to see if the phototan app, all options in magisk hidden, are activated?
[Magisk] Laptapper:
Now fry me a stork? 🤣 English for runaways, I break together and also my english is not the yellow from the egg 😂😂😂

I didn't say something of the horse if I say you're a german like me🤣
[Magisk] huxx:
would some one be so nice and can give me a step by step noob friendly instruction maybe in german cause my english is very bad also ...

i just got a a fresh galaxy s4 rooted and os is lineageos 18.1 V1 would appreciate if you start the instruction from there i also give a donation for the help

i really need to get comdirect photo tan running or iam ****ed on 1st next month cause i have to do important bank transfers :(
[Magisk] pa.pn2:
Yes, working fine.

I just disabled the service in 3c.

I even didn't hide magisk, it's working without hiding for me
[Magisk] Laptapper:
Unroot

Make transactions

Root again

Read this thread from the beginning and you will get your answer
[Magisk] huxx:
i cant .. they made the apps uncompatible for my smartphone with android 5.0 thats the only os i can get unrooted :( thats why i did the root and installed lineageos .. and yes read again is good to say but i installed magisk and was that far i enabled hide and selected the app but the app still detect my phone as rooted i dont understand the module thing steps rio etc :( maybe i call them tomorrow and activate sms tan :\ but thanks
[Magisk] Conan179:
I use sms tan as backup to make bank transfers.
[Magisk] vwfreak2001:
You can use tasker to freeze magisk when opening the photo tan app.

I got this from the DKB Tan2go thread and it's working fine.
[Magisk] p3rsi2k:
Worked awesome. Thank you for the tutorial.

It's also running the V8.3.2. with ONLY 3C.
[Magisk] Knotte:
Thanks a lot.

The trick for me was using LSPosed instead of EdXposed. With EdXposed I failed the Safetynet check which obviously caused PhotoTAN not to work. With LSPosed Safetynet is passed and PhotoTAN finally working again!

I even restored Magisk (no need to rename/hide the app), MagiskHide ist active though just to be sure.
[Magisk] androidloc:
This is crazy, I just can't find a solution to get it to work on surya.

Any idea what could be the missing piece?
[Magisk] Conan179:
With lsposed, or more precisely with the xprivacylua module, have you selected ALL apps in the lsposed manager or just system?
[Magisk] androidloc:
Actually only system. Am I supposed to select all apps?

You mean this right here?
[Magisk] Conan179:
Yes, i have tickt all user apps +einstellungsspeicher&system framework
[Magisk] androidloc:
Thanks...

I started all over again:

-deinstalled phototan app (deleted cache and data before manually)

-wiped Dalvik and Cache in Twrp

-installed Magisk modules: riru, riru enhanced mode for magisk hide, riru lsposed

-reboot

-activated Xprivacylua in lsposed

-ticked all apps for Xprivacylua in lsposed

-reboot

-deactivated magisk hide, dehided magisk manager

-reboot

-hided magisk manager, activated magisk hide

-reboot

-checked safetynet status: passed

-installed phototan app

-hided all 3 services of phototan app within magisk hide

-ticked "read applications" within Xprivacylua for phototan app

-unticked service ComponentDiscoveryService from phototan app within 3c toolbox

-started phototan app - FAILED
[Magisk] Laptapper:
I've recognized if you've run in root acknowledge of phototan then it's not enough to delete app data and cache. and also don't reinstall phototan because trouble with 3c and xprivacylua settings.

If you delete app data and cache AND the vdex and odex file in subfolder of the phototan app, you can start and login to phototan. Now I've finished app setup and all is running well.

Of course with installing the necessary tools (see other posts)
[Magisk] androidloc:
Excellent! That made it (y)
[Magisk] dahadd:
Hey @Laptapper

Which Apps?

3c and xprivacy also Install or not?
[Magisk] Laptapper:
Some users said only 3c or xprivacy but both are also working. Try
[Magisk] B3r3av3d:
Thank you, this helped me, as well.

But I needed to do some poking around to find where those files live.

Maybe this helps someone

# in termux or another terminal app

su
cd /data/app

# Find comdirect app dir (on my phone these are kind of hidden in weird ~~48r9845...~~ folders)
cd "$(find . -name "*comdirect*")"

cd oat/arm64

rm -rf base.*
[Magisk] Laptapper:
Easier to find with 3c
[Magisk] Lymus_ill:
Thank you all.

I'm on the MiMix 2 and

Magisk v23 + riru and riru unshare

helped, didn't even have to reset app data.
[Magisk] hijazo00o:
Magisk canary

Magisk hide

Riru + riru unshare

These steps work for me on the photoTAN app, but not the banking app. The newest version always crashes after login. I had to install older version to keep using it

I tried also using lsposed + xprivacylua but the banking app still crashes.
[Magisk] Laptapper:
I've got newest apps too and no problems.

May reinstall with cleaning helps
[Magisk] Conan179:
Enjoy the time we have, magisk hide is no longer being developed.

Magisk is dropping support for hiding root access from apps

Magisk, the popular Android rooting tool, will continue to be developed by topjohnwu, but without its root hiding feature called MagiskHide.

www.xda-developers.com
[Magisk] p-walker:
Well it also says that Magisk will get support to directly use Zygote which would basically mean that the functionality of the riru core module is already implemented by default. Hopefully someone fork the Magisk Hide module and keeps on supporting it but of course it is a setback that Topjohnwu can't support it anymore directly.

fyi: I just used riru unshare with the latest photoTan app version 8.3.2 and it seem to be working (at least it is starting now without the error about root detection)
[Magisk] xflowy:
would u mind giving a step by step explanation how u did it? i read through the thread several times but i cant figure out how to do it.

im just on magisk atm.
[Magisk] RtGh43:
Thanks,

Links seems broken - any other way to get the apk?
[Magisk] Asellus:
The link is working, just checked it. You need to scroll down to get to the history in order to find an older version like the 8.2.1
[Magisk] RtGh43:
Thank u.

Got the link, correct.

But after clicking "download" browser goes to

Download comdirect photoTAN App 8.2.1 APK | APKdownload.com

Mit der kostenlosen photoTAN App geben Sie Transaktionen im Online-Banking sicher und schnell frei. So funktioniert das photoTAN-Verfahren über den Computer:Sie führen eine Transaktion auf einem anderen Gerät durch; z. B. einem PC. Ihre Transaktion wird automatisch in die

apkfun.com

and does nothing.

No download.

Edit:

Checked with 2 browsers.

"Processing..."

And nothing.

So with 8.2.0 and so on.
[Magisk] Asellus:
You are right. Try https://apkcafe.de/download?file_id=1712250/comdirect-phototan-app
[Magisk] RtGh43:
Thanks to Asellus.

Link works.

After installing, error with "rooted phone" stays the same.

I thought the new root detection came with versions after 8.1.2?

Using magisk and magisk hide.
[Magisk] Asellus:
For me version 8.2.1 works with Magisk Hide. Perhaps it helps to kill the app and clean its data and cache. And to check that both services of the app are hidden in Magisk
[Magisk] RtGh43:
This worked for me now with 8.2.1.

Did unhide and hide.

clear data.

New regsitration with activation letter.

Thanks very much all.
[Magisk] xflowy:
did u also install riru and riru unshare? is that needed?
[Magisk] dirk0504:
ADMIN: pls remove - double posting
[Magisk] dirk0504:
Worked for me [Xiaomi Mi 11 Ultra, A11, comdirect 8.3.2, riru core + unshare] ... no cache or data delete necessary.

Thanks a lot!
[Magisk] xflowy:
Mate, would u mind sharing the information: do i just need to install riru and riru unshare or will there be more to be done in the modules? and where do i find unshare? thanks!
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
@xflowy installing those modules is sufficient beside hiding all PhotoTan-App related services in Magisk-Hide
[Magisk] dirk0504:
LMGTFY - Let Me Google That For You

For all those people who find it more convenient to bother you with their question rather than to Google it for themselves.

lmgtfy.app
[Magisk] swour:
The steps as well as the link to Riru Unshare can be found in the first post.
[Magisk] edwardenglish:
This works like charm. Just did it today

Thank you so much been struggling for ages with that ****

1. I deleted all data for photo tan app and prevented it from gaining any permissions (especiallo I disabled the permission to find what other apps are installed)

2. I activated magisk hide for photo tan

3. I installed "riru" from magis modules search from within the magisk app

4. I googled for "riru unshare", downloaded the zip from github and installed it with magisk installer app (modules "install as zip"

5. reboot

6. open photo tan and it works (have to do a new activation though)

noted: I did not have to do any further configuration of the modules
[Magisk] neroes:
Any Changes in Phototan App?

Since today nothing works

8.3.2
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
8.3.2 is working here on a Pixel 3a with configuration described by @edwardenglish

What device do you use? What configuration?
[Magisk] neroes:
Xiaomi Mi9

Cdroid 7.11

Magisk 23.0

Riru

Law Run Kernel

https://xdaforums.com/goto/post?id=85003003 !

Since Today dosnt work
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
@neroes do you have riru-unshare installed?
[Magisk] neroes:
2.0 yes
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
If Safety Net check is green, l do not have further ideas.
[Magisk] nightmare1942:
For me it's working. Just installed everything as the app suddently updated to the newest version.

photoTAN App 8.3.2

Magisk 23

Riru & Riru Unshare 2.0

Deleted only Cache
[Magisk] neroes:
is green ...

It came all at once ... without an app update or system update
[Magisk] pa.pn2:
Anybody on Android 12 can confirm it's working?

For me not anymore..
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
@pa.pn2 you have a device running a rooted A12 and passing Safety net? Which device do you have?
[Magisk] pa.pn2:
Yes im rooted and safetynet passes.

Im running a pixel 4 xl.

Maybe they have to update their apps for 12...
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
@pa.pn2 probably a bit out of topic here, but I found several information that you will need to wipe when updating from A11 to A12 and keeping root so you are trying to re-setup now and application does not start?
[Magisk] pa.pn2:
I dirty flashed android 12 yes.

Maybe i will do a clean flash and we will see what happens.

I also have problems with YouTube music. It doesn't play my music files somehow lol
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
I just got an update of the PhotoTan app ... and even though it was added to magisk hide it failed to start due to detecting root :-(

Looking at the hidden processes there is a third process now which needs to be hidden, too.

After that I only cleaned the application cache and the app started again :-)
[Magisk] edwardenglish:
Can you go into more details about that process? What is it called and where can I find it to select it for magisk hide? Ty!
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
@edwardenglish It came out that due to the update of the PhotoTan-App the isolated process was no longer hidden in MagiskHide. I added it again to the hide list and cleaned the cache of the PhotoTan-App. After that I was able to access the application again.
[Magisk] Asellus:
Did you install the new version 8.4.0?

Even for 8.3.2, the version before, it is necessary to check the 3rd process in MagiskHide
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
@Asellus yes, I am now on 8.4.0 and I had hidden the 3rd process on 8.3.2, too, but due to the update it was suddenly unhidden and PhotoTan-App was no longer working due to detecting root.
[Realme 5 Questions & Answers] RMXzilla2030:
anyone here has a problem like mine? i cant boot up on any rui even i flash correct procedure and correct file, just stuck on realme white logo turns off and repeat, i tried flashing rui EU still ddnt work. but when i flash back to color os it is booting.
[Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra Guides, News, & Discu] v8.ahm:
hello

is there away to debloat the phone to enhance the performance and privacy , easy few steps , may be some copy and paste stuff , without root or something diffcult

im not a tech or developer .
[Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra Guides, News, & Discu] megatooth:
https://xdaforums.com/t/tool-adb-appcontrol-v1-6-2-app-manager-debloat-tool-for-android.4147837/
[Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra Guides, News, & Discu] v8.ahm:
the problem is i wouldn't know what to delete
[Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra Guides, News, & Discu] Gamric:
ADB App control has a seting for disabling or use something like Package Infor on Google Play Store.
[Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra Guides, News, & Discu] Sprov:
Yeah, you must know what to disable or not depending on your needs. Most lists you can find are very extreme and get rid of key features. You better put some effort in it or give up
[Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra Guides, News, & Discu] v8.ahm:
i'm trying my best to look for a list made by an expert
[Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra Guides, News, & Discu] kangi26:
What I might stress to you is if you're not a techie I would absolutely NOT recommend you going any further than uninstalling/disabling items from the App drawer. If something goes sideways (And things very much can) and you don't know how to fix it, you are REALLY asking for trouble.

Typically there can be quite a few items in the app drawer that can be removed or disabled.

Just my opinion.......
[Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra Guides, News, & Discu] jsusang:
If you uninstall an application that you may need, you may reinstall it via adb.

Code:

cmd package install-existing <package name>
[Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra Guides, News, & Discu] megatooth:
With ADB AppControl v1.6.3

Spoiler content hidden.
[Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra Guides, News, & Discu] the_scotsman:
That list is insane. You may as well sell the Note and buy a Nokia 3210.

You really won't gain any real world performance improvements. I can understand if you're paraniod/extra secure, and want to remove Facebook etc.

But you're killing a lot of the phones functionality.
[Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra Guides, News, & Discu] megatooth:
More than half eat the battery. The rest annoys me and I don't need it. I set my example.

I own a Nokia 6110i with no pen! :)
[Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra Guides, News, & Discu] blackhawk:
I knew this thread was going to crater like the moon🤣🤭🤣

Chainsaw wart removal.

Some of the worst offenders are needed at least once a day. Some on the "list" just sit there and do nothing unless needed... dependencies, dependencies, dependencies if not there many other functions aren't either. You also overlooked two prime offenders, Google backup Transport and Framework. Turn off all the bloody animations and use the Good Lock family of apps... for starters.

OP this is not the way to learn what to disable.

It took me over a year to learn how to optimize my 10+. Each device variant and user are different. You need to learn what does the hard way by researching the apk/service in question and most of all by playing with it.

The shotgun approach shown here is a mess. I use a package disabler so I can toggled apks on/off easily on the fly. While many are always disabled, a dozen or so are not. It also allows me to ID dependencies and easily correct mistakes.

Many things are simply turned on/off like location, bluetooth as I need them. To make the most of an Android you need to understand what does what... it's a learning process and it has to be a user interactive one to get the most from it. I toggle things on and off now automatically almost without thinking. To get to this point there's a lot to think through, to plan and setup.

No free rides.

I really like playing with Androids which is why I learn. It's almost impossible to crash a stock Android.

My OS load is stock, over a year old, still running fast, very stable and it fulfills its mission. SOT is running an average of 9%@hr, 7% for browsing and 11% for streaming vids.

At one time it was a hot running, battery eating hog... now it does what I want it to do😎
[Touch Pro, Fuze General] Adrianstudent:
How can you change the font color of the "programs' names" (in "TF3D->Programs->All") . Now it is black - like the background color, so I can only read it... if I mark it, can anybody help?

Thanks!
[Touch Pro, Fuze General] Adrianstudent:
No one knows?