yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Android Apps and Games] Kb cool:
Been getting a error 100 network setting on Netflix login. Even tried with hotspot in case my IP was banned previously when netflix ATV HD worked before. I'm using a Dinobot 4k plus. ESN from mobile app is NFANDROID1-PRV-B-L3-NVIDISHIELD-4445-0ABFBF99******************** and so on. Any ideas?
[Android Apps and Games] Kb cool:
Current esn used in mod apk that didn't work, "NFANDROID1-PRV-0-L1-NVIDISHIELD-4445-".
[Android Apps and Games] shahdanturung:
What model of km9pro u use? Clasic/deluxe/honour? Mine is deluxe, working esn is :

NFANDROID1-PRV-0-VS===KM9PRO-13706-
[Android Apps and Games] shahdanturung:
Is it just me, or does the step 4.1 and 4.2 to remove toast noti (device not optimized) made the home widget suggestion become non existence?
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
It is possible, but it is also possible that there are still some dependencies!
[Android Apps and Games] shahdanturung:
I tried clear app data of nfx, atv homelauncher, atv recomendation service. still no sign of the suggestion widget.
[Android Apps and Games] akosibudz:
Thank you
[Android Apps and Games] inamie:
No luck with KM3 with few combination tried.

PLs help..

NFANDROID2-PRV-0-VS===KM3-13439-
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
NFANDROID1-PRV-0-VS===KM3-13439-
[Android Apps and Games] inamie:
tried already.. no luck.. error NW-6-404
[Android Apps and Games] shahdanturung:
Where u found those esn. Better use ninja4 to see ur device esn, dont use mobile apk.
[Android Apps and Games] inamie:
Yes.. using ninja4 apk at front page..
[Android Apps and Games] shahdanturung:
-do you use the stock firmware

-is it rooted

-current widevine lvl
[Android Apps and Games] inamie:
Stock firmware android 10, L1, no root.

Success on km9 pro, but not on km3🤔
[Android Apps and Games] shahdanturung:
Is weird. Did u tried the ver 8 instead?
[Android Apps and Games] inamie:
Checked esn with ninja 4, mod v2, mod v6, mod v8 give same error NW-6-404

Posible km3 blocked by netflix? 🤔

Created v8 for my skyworth stb, km9 pro and v2 for rooted ATV9 h96max, rooted ATV9 tx3 mini without problem.
[Android Apps and Games] dbzgts:
I think the same too for my zte b860h v2 box
[Android Apps and Games] franz weber:
This is a service of Dune, all attention !!!

In my opinion, the "Error 1044" Netflix solution in another / custom version of the Netflix app that is downloaded from the Dune server if you delete Netflix via pop up menu and restores ......... ....INGENIOUS !

Here the Netflix solution, with me Netflix works again with 5.1 without 1044 error message!
[Android Apps and Games] nickunj:
Thanks, the solution worked for me on my Benq projector.
[Android Apps and Games] LittleJoe_The_RealOne:
Thanks for this. I succeed on my KM6 but only HD1080p 5.1. Anybody got 4k on the "Test Pattern" movie/serie with this mod?

Keep punching!
[Android Apps and Games] iubjaved:
Hi @Dealaxer ,

I have Mi TV 4S MSSP1 Russian edition and my ESN is ''nfandroid2-prv-mitv-mssp1-xiaommitv-mssp1-11579'' What will be the correct format and which method should i use?

Thank you!
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
NFANDROID1-PRV-0-MITV-MSSP1-XIAOMMITV-MSSP1-11579-
[Android Apps and Games] nickunj:
Just found a weird thing. I don get sound when it’s set to English 5.1, but when I change it to English it works. Just wondering is it to do with ESN or my device.

@Dealaxer can please help.

TIA.
[Android Apps and Games] z50170937:
Thank you, it works for me but for some reasons I can play any title just fine but not the Test Pattern so I'm not sure what resolution it could play. I'm using Tanix TX3 Mini with custom ATV rom, here is the ESN that works for me:

NFANDROID1-PRV-0-AMLOGTX3=MINI-4445-
[Android Apps and Games] lipanbaraku:
Working great. Thank you!

Is anyone manage to make Netflix Recommendations on Home Screen working on Android TV new look (the one that looks like the new GoogleTV home)?
[Android Apps and Games] link6155:
Anyone know what should I enter for my ESN? Here's what it shows up as in the Netflix system info page:
[Android Apps and Games] iubjaved:
Hey, thanks! I happen to try yours and it worked fine. I am on 8.1.2 and some series shows me it's available in ultra HD. Does that mean i will be able to stream them on ultra or it capped to HD quality.
[Android Apps and Games] nickunj:
Please try below,

NFANDROID1-PRV-0-SDMC=D2150-17922-
[Android Apps and Games] nickunj:
Please search for test pattern in Netflix n u can check itself. For most of us, it showed as full HD.
[Android Apps and Games] franz weber:
With this version runs on my "Dune HD Pro 4K II" Amazon Prime on my 1080p TV with 5.1

Nice thing !
[Android Apps and Games] Com.Chakotey:
Hello there :)

first i must say, i tryed it so so many times with the guide on the first page but i had no success.

Now i give up and ask here if it is just impossible with my tablet (Lenovo Yoga Tab 3 Plus LTE)

I would only ask if anybody can help me here and if it it possible, help me to fix it.

Here ist my Netflix Screenshot:
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
Only 2 version and SD quality!
[Android Apps and Games] Com.Chakotey:
Mhhhh i didn't realy understand.

I already have SD Quality, why should i modify this netflix APK in your link if i don't get the better (HD) qualitity?

If nothing helps i must go back to stock, because there i had Lv 1 and HD ;/

But ugly and slowly Android 7
[Android Apps and Games] JackyHalaHala:
Make sure the tablet has Google Security L1. Install app called DRM Info to check type of security.
[Android Apps and Games] Com.Chakotey:
Still tryed but the DRM App show me no Widewine Level, i do not know why.

I can see anything like the example pictures but NOT the part of the DRM Level ;(

With my Stock ROM i could play Netflix in HD because there i had Lv 1.

But it is Android 7 ;/
[Android Apps and Games] Mnafedh:
Hi,

Every one plz i need help

Can anyone give me the ESN
[Android Apps and Games] Mnafedh:
Same problem for me with the same ESN
[Android Apps and Games] MarioReels:
Do you guys have something similar for prime video?
[Android Apps and Games] JackyHalaHala:
If you use Custom Firmware then I am afraid that Netflix don't like it :-) . It means that you have to go back to your stock fimrware.
[Android Apps and Games] Aqui Chloe:
can you help me this is my esn. tnx

NFANDROID2-PRV-0-VS===KM3-13439-0682AE4E1470824507CD283F22A98C469F8433980CB4550C371E8F27A4331636
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
NFANDROID1-PRV-0-VS===KM3-13439-

or

NFANDROID1-PRV-0-VS=KM3-13439-
[Android Apps and Games] Aqui Chloe:
Tnx for your reply. I can't get it to work i tried it both. Hope there's another way. Any luck with other km3 users out there?
[Android Apps and Games] inamie:
Already tried earlier and same result.. hope to get solution for km3 user.

For the mean time can use defaullt V2 with RANGER-9908 code. Works without error but SD quality only.
[Android Apps and Games] Thonix_29PTY:
Hello Help Have Tv Box KM6 Clasic I don't know what ESN to put on it, please help me
[Android Apps and Games] GreGORE_:
write your esn on a post maybe we can help you... I have a kd1 and got it to work
[Android Apps and Games] Thonix_29PTY:
Hi I already made it work ESN NFANDROID1-PRV-O-VS === KM6-19773- but thanks anyway
[Android Apps and Games] choina:
Hi,

I'm a little lost here. I have L3 device and what is possible to have HD quality? I try method with v8. from post #1 but I have error (-12) during Netflix startup

BR,
[Android Apps and Games] Mnafedh:
Plz help i have skyworth 4k with L1 level i was installed kodi(work correctly but without 4k quality) and netflix.ninja.2.0.apk(not working)

And my esn that i have find is attached here
[Android Apps and Games] Zladimir:
Hi, used that method. Many thank for that.

Before I used a modded Netflix phone app. With the phone app I couldnt navigate normally, but 4k and HDR was working fine.

I have a 4k HDR TV from Kivi with L1 widevine.

The convenience of normally navigating is great. I like it, many thanks.

But I also have to say, neither Dolby Atmos, HDR nor 4k is working despite claiming that it is working. As mentioned earlier, my TV supports these functions. In Youtube App these work, too.

As said, with the phone app it is working. I can see even clear difference.

Any help or suggestions there ?

Another questio, is the Home Screen function only working with AndroidTV Launcher ? Or are there any other launcher possible ?

Thanks !
[Android Apps and Games] criscarvl:
any solution for prime video widevine l3 ?
[Android Apps and Games] qenek01:
No luck on KM3 tried on ATV9 and ATV10 no longer able to stream HD in Kodi as well I do not know why, Maybe Netflix banned the ESN :(
[Android Apps and Games] diegori466:
Which apk mod was you using?

Because it is impossible get 4k if you device is uncertified.
[Android Apps and Games] Zladimir:
Netflix 6.1.3, as stated in my post. Yes, uncertified device with widevine L1 and HDCP 2.2. (I still don't get why it just not got certification ... )

The mod claims 4k would work:

"What works:

-HD and UHD(4K)

-Audio 5.1

-HDR

-Netflix Recommendations on Home Screen (You need to update the Android TV Home app)"

Is this claim wrong ? Neither Audio 5.1, 4k nor HDR is working with Netflix mod 6.1.3.

Also as I said, the modded phone app I used earlier streamed in 4k, Atmos and HDR.

(And yes, I have premium plan ;) )

I always use Netflix test patterns to confirm.

A "bug" I noticed, if I switch between different languages and / or subtitles sometimes it get messed up and I get the message device is not supported. After that I can't play any video anymore. If I change than the user profile, it loads and plays again. To me that is important, as we have a multi-language household.

Interestingly what I also observe is, I tested both mods, the version 6 and version 8 of Netflix, the older version 6 seems to load and run much faster. That might be my single observation.
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
I have in the mod 6.1.3 working HDR and 5.1. 4K does not work! Everything is individual!
[Android Apps and Games] magoblanco:
I can't get it to work, what do I really have to do? I already tried 3 combinations always with error -13.
[Android Apps and Games] inamie:
My observation too.. picture quality also good on v6 compare to v8.
[Android Apps and Games] inamie:
Wondering if km3 user can flash unrooted km9pro custom rom and use mod v6 or v8 with km9pro esn. Rom provided in 4pda is rooted. V6 & v8 not working on rooted device.
[Android Apps and Games] qenek01:
I don't know, I am able to play full HD now in Kodi ESN: NFANDROID1-PRV-KM3-VS===KM3-13439-

any ideas any help would be appreciated to get it run on NETFLIX app. Tried o many different combinations, if any have any ideas please let us KM3 users know.
[Android Apps and Games] dbzgts:
Is the souncd not out of synch?
[Android Apps and Games] qenek01:
I didn't noticed any sound delays
[Android Apps and Games] magoblanco:
Fix for me... Thanks for nothing
[Android Apps and Games] GreGORE_:
try this one "NFANDROID1-PRV-0-VS===KM1-13438-"
[Android Apps and Games] magoblanco:
If I already found it, that one works fine. thank you very much, anyway.
[Android Apps and Games] SebaJudas:
Hi guys!

I'm trying this method to install netflix 8.1.2 and my esn is

NFANDROID2-PRV-0-VS===KM9PRO-13706-

If you get (-13) try this esn

NFANDROID1-PRV-0-VS===KM9PRO-13706-
[Android Apps and Games] raymkiller008:
hello, I have a buzztv xrs 4500, it is drm l1, here is esn that apk esn ino gives me

NFANDROID2-PRV-0-AMLOGXRS = 4500-9727

but the problem is that I am not finding line 621 and 632 in the setShowsDialog file. smali

is it with the windows notepad that it should be opened?

someone would be kind enough to give me the apk already modified with my esn? thank you

ps: I have the error ui 113, I tried everything, change dns, restart modem, but always the same error
[Android Apps and Games] qenek01:
@

Hi Dealaxer, Any ideas:

if for KM1 ESN is: "NFANDROID1-PRV-0-VS===KM1-13438-" and works

for KM6 ESN is: ESN NFANDROID1-PRV-0-VS===KM6-19773- and works

-why on KM3: ESN NFANDROID1-PRV-0-VS===KM3-13439- we are getting an NW error?

what the hack it does not have any sense?

Netflix on Kodi works ok for KM3 and do not return any errors? once NFANDROID2 is change for NFANDROID1?

Any genius out there to figure it out?
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
Read it
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
For you: Netflix 8.1.2 build 3844 - Modification instructions

Everything is already there, a prepared application that only needs to be decompiled, replaced with strings, and recompiled. Nothing complicated!
[Android Apps and Games] inamie:
Maybe can try and flash KM3 with unrooted KM9pro rom. SInce v6 and v8 only works on unrooted device and the buildprop already change to km9pro, hope esn km9pro code working..

but the link here provided flash with preroot km9 pro..
[Android Apps and Games] qenek01:
in regards to Netflix 2.0 build 295 for Widevine L3 (Only SD Quality) is there a way to adjust the subtiltles size?
[Android Apps and Games] optzeci:
Nope
[Android Apps and Games] raymkiller008:
Hi, thank you for your answer, I managed to do it for the xsarius Q8, but no way to find the right esn on the buzztv xrs 4500, maybe it has a custom ROM, I still have an ui 800 error - 3, ui 113, error 13, I will continue my research and try another ATV apk to find the right one, in any case, a big thank you for this mod, thanks to you a lot of boxing has Netflix full HD HDR, Thank you
[Android Apps and Games] shahdanturung:
Seems like km3 have problem with this mod v6 or v8 apk.
[Android Apps and Games] buzywoman:
Hello y use this: "NFANDROID1-PVR-0-AMLOGXRS4900-9727-"

replaced NFANDROID2 by NFANDROID1 and stop after 9727- and y have error netflix not able to connect

kodi netflix castagnait show esn in use NFANDROID2-PRV-AMLOGXRS4900-9727- tried and not work replaced 2 for 1 and not work to

y have buzztv xrs 4900 NO root original ota updated firmware

do you have a idea of my problem ?

sorry my first is french.

tank-you

tried and not work

"NFANDROID1-PRV-0-AMLOGXRS4900-9727-"

"NFANDROID2-PRV-0-AMLOGXRS4900-9727-"

"NFANDROID1-PRV-AMLOGXRS4900-9727-"

"NFANDROID2-PRV-AMLOGXRS4900-9727-"

"NFANDROID1-PVR-AMLOGXRS4900-9727-"

"NFANDROID1-PRV-AMLOGICXRS4900-9727-"

"NFANDROID1-PRV-0-AmlogXRS4900-9727-"

"NFANDROID1-PRV-0-XRS4900-BUZZTVXRS4900-9727-"
[Android Apps and Games] eddiegc2002:
@gadom92 I think that I have the same device, but my ESN numbers are:

* NFANDROID1-PRV-T-L3-AMLOGFRANKLIN-4445-XXXX according to Netflix APP

* NFANDROID2-PRV-0-AMLOGFRANKLIN-9727-XXXX according to Netflix ATV v4

I have tried all variants and your ESN too, and I have got the same error, UI-800-3 in Netflix ATV modified.

Too, I have tested all ESNs in kody and I haven't succeeded. Kodi always shows the same error "Request blacklisted by key exchange service" regardless the ESN configured. According to netflix plugin github https://github.com/CastagnaIT/plugi...)#request-blacklisted-by-key-exchange-service maybe the device has been blacklisted.

The ROM is installed by manufacturer but it is rooted. @gadom92 are your x96 rooted too?

@gadom92 @Dealaxer Do you think the ESN is wrong or it is possible there is something else?

Thanks
[Android Apps and Games] Pixelhouse:
I checked trough the compiled app with one of the two esn's you provided psycon in this topic, when using my GTV esn it spit out an error and would not launch(error -130. both the testvideo and the info button on the remote say 1080. On the kodi app it would not even launch it gave error -133.

Image one says UltraHD 4k but both testvideo and info screen say 1080.
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
You need to correct your ESN number correctly, then everything will work! But your device must have the Widevine L1 level!

You must also have purchased a Premium plan to watch in 4K!
[Android Apps and Games] Pixelhouse:
This is my bad i double checked with DRM info and i says GTV is L1, i must have my Formuler boxes scrambled apologies i edited my post. Also PMed you with the ESN thats spitting out errors(not launching).
[Android Apps and Games] psycon:
Tested working on 5 devices now from a couple brands. Works great, seems to be limited to 1080p from some reports though . ( My test account is only 1080p so cannot confirm nor deny if 4k works)

Even if only 1080, this a big step forward for devices that can absolutely run Netflix just fine but are not permitted due to their Draconian certification process.
[Android Apps and Games] liamstears:
Working perfect on a Humax Aura

Does this work on the newer version APK's from netflix?
[Android Apps and Games] psycon:
I do not believe so (at this time). I Checked quite a few other apks and the smali structure seems to have changed after 6.1.3 in the few I checked
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
On new versions, this will not work, there is DexGuard protection! It will take too long to bypass the protection. It doesn't make sense! If version 6 is practically no different from version 8!
[Android Apps and Games] argyriovich:
Hello, i am a totally amateur on developing. Is there any guide how to do this proccess on apk?
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
In the MT Manager application, there is a function to delete the signature verification. But I am not sure that the correct decompilation and compilation of the application will work. But you can try it!
[Android Apps and Games] burcbuluklu:
Is this compatible with x86 Android? If so I can install this on my old laptop converted to Android TV Pie and that would be epic
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
No! Android X86 does not have the Widevine L1 level, there is a Widevine L3 level. Read carefully the first post of the topic!
[Android Apps and Games] burcbuluklu:
Got it. Didn't knew that x86 android lacks support Widewine L1
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
https://www.xda-developers.com/android-tv-x86-repurpose-pc-media-streamer/
[Android Apps and Games] n3zuko:
Hi, my box is google certified, but not support netflix, seeing this thread made me have high hope to get netflix works on my box. The problem is when using kodi netflix addon the ESN too long so not full code shown. By the way i checked the drm info and it show L1. Attached the ESN shown on kodi addon. Help me to get correct esn please.
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
Install this app and see your full ESN, then send it, I'll help you adjust it! Your ESN will be in the app Settings > Get Help >Device or More Details.

This app is only getting ESN it will not work!
[Android Apps and Games] why666me:
Thanks alot man i hope this works

Im waiting for My Mecool KM6 Deluxe to arrive and i was hoping to stream Netflix in HD

This device is certified by google L1 widevine

But doesn't support HD net
[Android Apps and Games] n3zuko:
OMG!! Its work!!!!, attached. I changed the first to NFANDROID1and just stop after 13776- and its work!! Thank you duuude. Omg, i broke my mibox few weeks ago just because trying to downgrade the firmware, cant play netflix since then on tv. Then got this box for free, and u jist save my day. Even tho its netflix with older ui, but i got it to play on 1080. Im happy. Omg!!
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
Yes, your correct ESN number: NFANDROID1-PRV-0-INTEKTRANSVISION-OTT-BOX-13776-
[Android Apps and Games] BlackstoneI:
Excuse my ignorance.

I am aware this is a mod for AndroidTV, but I want to know if this could in theory also work on tablets. I have found it should be possible to install the APK on a tablet and use the app. The tablet does support L1 widevine but is not certified by netflix. Could this in theory be used for Netflix HD on a non-certified widevine L1 tablet?
[Android Apps and Games] Dealaxer:
You should try it, maybe it will work! I didn't check.
[Android Apps and Games] emiljano539:
It's working for now in my x96 air with a custom ROM and rooted . But there's a bug when i try to watch some series from the search menu . As soon as i click play it says : "Were having trouble playing this title right now . Please try again later or select a different title ."

Is it a Netflix bug ? Are you guys encountering the same issue ?
[Android Apps and Games] eddiegc2002:
Could you tell me the custom ROM you are using ?
[Android Apps and Games] mariolakaza:
plzzz how to find ESN number ?
[Android Apps and Games] shahdanturung:
use mod ninja 4 apk, login and look for the esn in the in-app setting
[Android Apps and Games] Zladimir:
Try changing audio language and/or subtitles (if active) before start playing the video.

As I mentioned earlier, the mod app has problems with specific titles on specific languages, for whatever reason. Might solve your problem.
[Android Apps and Games] mariolakaza:
Where can I find the apk (mod ninja 4 apk)
[Android Apps and Games] eddiegc2002:
@Dealaxer @gadom92 have you any idea? I have tried:

NFANDROID1-PRV-T-L3-AMLOGFRANKLIN-4445-

NFANDROID1-PRV-0-AMLOGFRANKLIN-4445-

NFANDROID1-PRV-FRANKLIN-AMLOGFRANKLIN-4445-

NFANDROID1-PRV-AMLOGFRANKLIN-4445-

... -9727-

NFANDROID2...

With all codes I have get errors.

I need help, please.
[Android Apps and Games] gadom92:
My box is rooted with magisk, root hided and fingerprint changed to mibox s and I could not get HD quality

I gave up and install Netflix V2 with SD
[Android Apps and Games] shahdanturung:
Must have widevine L1 for HD playback.
[Android Apps and Games] zubairemon:
@Dealaxer sir I can't compile in apktool. It's show error
[Android Apps and Games] emiljano539:
Air Hybrid AOSP ROM its called
[Android Apps and Games] emiljano539:
The strange part is that some titles work and some doesn't... Edit Changed the audio and turned subtitles off , problem persists...
[Android Apps and Games] jkbee26:
Hi, is there a modified apk for Beelink GT-King and Gt-King Pro? Is it possible to share it?

Thank you.
[Android Apps and Games] elmc727:
I have tried the whole string of ESN or just type “NFANDROID2-PRV-0-ZIDOOZ9X-17893-“ but all not working, what exactly the ESN of my device
[Android Apps and Games] jmmontoro:
Hello, first of all, to all those with ESN that doesn't work, try changing NFANDROID2 to NFANDROID1.

Second, I have some instances of no audio, a reboot of the box always fixes it though, normal behaviour?

Finally, how often is the modded app updated?
[Android Apps and Games] JackyHalaHala:
Try "NFANDROID1-PRV-0-ZIDOOZ9X-17893-"
[Android Apps and Games] Marco Páris:
Is this Tv Box hopeful? I consult, because, when I look for its "system id" from the app "DMR Info" nothing comes out
[Android Apps and Games] C-Leung:
This is a great post although I am another no luck KM3 user.

By following the steps I have successfully installed v8 mod app to 2 different ATV boxes, only KM3 got the NW-6-404 problem.

I first got the ESN from Kodi Netflix addon, and then found the easiest way to get ESN is from v4 mod app. ESN from Kodi is slightly different from v4 app, but unfortunately both ESN didn't work on v8 app. Since there are many KM3 users got no success, probably the problem is from KM3 machine.

For KM3 user what we can watch Netflix currently is from Kodi (Got a 1080 quality by set a manual ESN) or v2.7 mod app (SD quality)
[Android Apps and Games] elmc727:
Hello, I have tried

"NFANDROID1-PRV-0-ZIDOOZ9X-17893-"

"NFANDROID2-PRV-0-ZIDOOZ9X-17893-"

"NFANDROID1-PRV-ZIDOOZ9X-17893-"

But all not working. Can anyone help, please
[Android Apps and Games] jmmontoro:
Guys, I just had an attempt to change my Netflix password, anyone had a similar experience? 5 years with my account and a few days after this app it happens, how safe is this?
[Android Apps and Games] inamie:
Device might be banned by Netflix same as KM3, no choice kodi or 2.7 build SD quality
[Android Apps and Games] kewpiekorgi:
Hi would someone be willing to help me get mine working? I've been trying for days to get Netflix to work on my xgimi pro but no luck and I'm frustrated to the point of tears at this point. I have my ESN through Netflix KODI and followed the instructions but still get an error message. Would appreciate any help, thank you!

Nvm I just got it to work!! Thanks all for this thread! It's a lifesaver.
[Android Apps and Games] diegori466:
Try with this esn NFANDROID1-PRV-0-XIAOMMITV-MSSPO-"YOUR ID DEVICE"
[Android Apps and Games] C-Leung:
Still doesn't work