yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] luckysoul777:
According to this article, https://www.getdroidtips.com/carbonrom-oneplus-8-pro/ , the developers of Carbon ROM recommend MindTheGApps 10 Package. However, if you click on the link, it takes you to MindTheGApps 8.1.0/9.0.0, which are for Oreo or Pie.

Does anyone know where to find MindTheGApps 10? If it doesn't exist, which one of the following two would you recommend?

Android 10 Gapps Package vs. Open Gapps 10

Thank you

---------- Post added at 12:55 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:43 PM ----------

I am curious to hear why you chose Elemental X kernel over others. I know there are at least 8 kernels for the 8 Pro according to this article, https://www.xda-developers.com/oneplus-8-pro-custom-roms-custom-kernels-mods-apps/ .
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] meffles:
You might be right, but I have no idea.

As far as I'm aware, there's no face unlock in this because the dev wants to avoid any kind of cease and desist (however likely/unlikely it may be), where as perhaps the other devs aren't bothered - but I can't speak for them.

Happy to answer any questions about the rom(s) but I'm conscious that we're straying a bit off-topic and it might be better to take this into PM if you do want to know anything else about anything unrelated to this rom.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] Myself5:
To put it simply: they just havn't been detected yet. So far Megvii, the company behind the face unlock solution, has only DCMA'd the "obvious" git repos that face the public. Put the proprietary binaries on a private git and, so far, you're good to go. That doesn't change the fact you're still violating their license and that you're not allowed to distribute their features either way. So if they ever decide to check ROMs and the content of the flashable ZIPs instead of searching GitHub repos for matching checksums of their proprietary binaries they can and will take down all of the builds including their proprietary code and you're back to the "no Faceunlock" state.

As for the probability of the DCMA: Megvii already sent DCMA notices to all public GitHub repos that had a Megvii library in them, including one of our repos where we couldn't remove it because on Xiaomi devices that library is built into the camera stack in a way that the camera doesn't work without them so we were forced to remove them and then figure out a way to make the camera stack work without it, which we eventually did.

FaceUnlock never was OpenSource but part of Google Apps. However, that was a generic insecure image comparison, hardly a "security feature". The Megvii solution highly improves upon that, personally I still wouldn't consider it a "high security" feature though. If you compare it to Apples Face unlock or the Soli system from the Pixel 4 they have extra hardware to measure the depth profile of your face as well as skin temperature to make sure it's really you and not a picture or recreation and yet there are still complaints about their security.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] RicardoDimm:
Got from stock > booted twrp via fastboot > flashed Carbon, reboot to recovery > qualcomm crash dump...
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] meffles:
Did you flash twrp or just boot to it?

You should flash.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] RicardoDimm:
Tryed both, same result
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] meffles:
Try reboot to recovery from bootloader, not recovery. That's important.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] RicardoDimm:
WIl try that, thanks! Now TWRP is not seen as a disk in windows...
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] meffles:
I did my own walk through earlier on in this thread, maybe page 12 or so, give that a try.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] RicardoDimm:
Followed your walk trough, did 100% the same, still crash dump
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] 1/4 Life:
Does this support MEMC/Motion Smoothing? I searched the thread but didn't find anything.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] TheDriller:
So... I'm super curious... Has anyone had any problems setting app op permissions? I can't modify any of them for any app at all. Does anyone have any suggestions?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] ptclik85:
Is it possible to have OnePlus switch work with this rom? Also, my phone is showing IN2023 instead of IN2025. Is that normal with this rom?

Thank you
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] dlads:
I couldn't get titanium too work on this ROM, could be related...simply wouldn't obtain root access.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] Bill Gates:
Hi. Can it be used without Gapps? Or the only choice camera Gcam won't work?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] Myself5:
It can be used without GApps, no trouble. The ROM comes with a camera app by default but I believe that GCam may work without GApps too. Although, I dont think I ever tested that.

Feel free to test and report back ;)
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] devon9954:
Had issues with booting this rom stuck in twrp and the other times I would get to a crash dump I was on 10.5.4 and latest twrp installed
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] Bill Gates:
How do I get "latest OOS" in both slots?

Dear Myself5,

Even after MSM Download Tool, I have OOS only in the slot A, and the slot B is not booting even to fastbootd -- "fastboot reboot fastboot" results in Quallcomm Crash Dump.

There are fastboot OOS ROMs here on XDA, but to flash it into the slot B one still needs working "fastbootd".
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] mattie_49:
I definitely wanna try. Can anyone link gapps that will work for a10?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] ps000000:
I just saw the news.

CarbonROM releases Android 11 builds for 16 phones from OnePlus, Xiaomi, and others

The stable builds of CarbonROM based on Android 11 are live for 16 smartphones, including the OnePlus 6/6T, OnePlus 7 series, and more.

www.xda-developers.com

Very nice. :love:
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] Myself5:
CR9 thread with install instructions and everything will be coming later today :)
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] paatha13:
Thanks for the new rom its been almost a year worked Carbon with 7 Pro.

This time with Android 11(y)

Used adb sideload method via instantnoodlep-recovery to flash both rom and gapps(MindTheGapps) used.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] Myself5:
The CR9 thread has been released and can be found here:

https://xdaforums.com/t/11-official-carbonrom-cr-9-0-instantnoodlep.4313355/
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
Ok I noticed we had a twrp installer zip but the latest twrp didn't provide one
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
Followed steps in op now stuck on boot antimation screen been there for 7 minutes
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] marko94:
formated data ?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
Thanks I did and everything is good ?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] blaze9090:
Hi!

Since there was also much confusion for me with installing it, can you tell your exact steps from oos to carbon? Thanks in advance!
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
From

stock to carbon I booted fastboot hooked device to PC typed fastboot-w then booted latest twrp flashed carbon rebooted recovery which gave me stock recovery then went back to PC fastbooted twrp again flashed gapps flashed magisk then reboot to system ( note might get stuck on carbon boot animation just reboot to recovery which is stock wipe data are full wipe then reboot system and done ((( note all this work and unnecessary bull is very stupid when all twrp op has to do is provide a installer zip to keep twrp )) which will also be so much easier I bet once more roms start up and more and more people complain op are twrp dev will provide a installer zip cause this is actually foolish
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] areyouanand:
Thank you very much, op was providing TWRP installer before main TWRP thread posted new build with the commit. IG you can still find the installer in one of the posts in TWRP thread.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
True but the installer zip needs to match the latest twrp.img to work older twrp won't flash the rom only the latest twrp will . Which has no installer zip to use with it that's the main problem it's totally a pain to go through what I did took me me 2.5 hours to flash it setup imagine going through that 10 times until you find the right rom that you like and the time you spend going through it when all twrp dev has to do is provide a installer zip and keep it current .. I could be wrong here but I feel once more roms start up and make them flash able a ton of users will complain just my thoughts is all and if things are not changed are at least build twrp in the rom like 90% of op7pro devs are doing which makes it even easier but this is just my thoughts on it most importantly I even had help flashing this and had to ask questions myself . And got my questions answered by some great guys and to them thanks
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] cultofluna:
There is a twrp installer available , that you can use to flash permanently any twrp version
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] zanderzone:
I dont think we have installer for "TWRP 3.4.0-1 Test by mauronofrio"
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
So you are saying there is a installer zip for 3.4.0.1 twrp
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] cultofluna:
Of course we have...

This installer can be used for any twrp version

https://xdaforums.com/oneplus-8-pro...cial-twrp-oneplus-8-pro-t4101313/post82769477
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
I know that's my point ,, for example say we have a rom update and you flash the rom in twrp and reboot to recovery it will not boot to twrp it will give you stock recovery but in other slot then you gotta fastboot boot twrp again to flash gapps and magisk then reboot system (( see that is what I'm getting at here )) things would be so much better and make it easier with a installer zip if we had a installer zip it would go like this reboot to twrp , flash rom update flash installer zip reboot to recovery flash gapps and magisk reboot system ... Fastbooting everything is foolish and is not necessary that's all I'm saying..and I know about that installer zip thanks to xxx and we shouldn't have to update the twrp ourselves to keep it updated the twrp dev chose to provide us with a completely working twrp and I feel he should provide us with all we need to use it but that's just my opinion
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] zanderzone:
Fab, thanks for the link mate
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] cultofluna:
Hmmm.

Have you read the post above yours?..
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
Yes and I went to xxx link and read about it may need updating to each version which twrp dev should do not us
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] zanderzone:
Does the warp charge work on this ROM ?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
I believe it does I'm showing dash charging on both using a cord and my wireless charger
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] cultofluna:
Just open the zip and edit it with any twrp img verion you need, flash it and you have permanently twrp installed..
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] zanderzone:
Thanks and how is the face unlock and Fingerprint scanner. Snappier or so so ?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
Ok cool thanks but not sure how to do that lol

---------- Post added at 09:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:46 AM ----------

Haven't tried them
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] Myself5:
I agree the reactions were rather rude, but honestly I agree with them. He is entitled to his own opinion and I agree that modding a brand new device might not sound sane to everyone. However, nobody was asking for his opinion on the topic. He decided to, uninvitedly, express how it's "stupid" to release a ROM this early. I and a handful of other developers have been given the OP8 Pro from OnePlus as a development unit to do exactly that. Bringing Custom ROMs, Kernels and other mods to the device because OnePlus sees the value and attraction in it, and clearly there's enough interest for it around.

Also, there's two ways of saying it. I'd have been perfectly fine with a "Can someone explain me why you're all modding your phone this early, it just sounds silly to me" kind of reply. Instead he decided it would be a smart move to come in calling the entire project "plain stupid" and frankly he got what he deserved for it.

This is a hobby to the developers on XDA. I do not earn money from it, and donations (if I get one occasionally) go back into development but do, by far, not cover it. Hell, they can't even cover the electricity bill for my $4000 PC used for development. Not to imagine if I had to buy the $1000 phones myself.

What I'm trying to say is that, no matter if intended or not, his post was coming across rude and unfortunately this is what XDA has become in the last few years. More and more users getting entitled acting like developers that spent their time and (as shown) hard earned money on this hobby owe them anything, acting like this was a paid job, which it is not. I chose this hobby and I chose to spend my hard earned money on advancing it because it is fun. Nothing more, nothing less. Entitled users are what currently make more and more developers either leave XDA or turn toxic themselves, and (thankfully) some users start trying to fix that.

Nevertheless, I fully agree that in this case their responses were pretty rude but (to a point) he deserved it.

If you were following the TWRP install instructions you'd have installed the image to both slots. Carbon does not replace the recovery.

I understand that it can be frustrating if the installation isn't working as expected, but you've show evidence that you entirely ignored the instructions on at least 2 occasions now in addition to getting told what you need to do on Telegram, so this is your own fault.

P.S: I'm fairly sure you're not doing it on purpose but right now you're coming across fairly entitled. Nobody is owing you anything, we're all doing this in our free time on our own expense (@mauronofrio is even having to buy his own devices) so please try avoiding/fixing that in the future for the reasons mentioned above. Especially as there is no "need" for a TWRP installer on the OP8 Pro given that, other than the OP7 Pro you mentioned previously, it has a recovery partition.

Yes, it's labeled as Dash charging though.

Fingerprint works flawless. No bundled FaceUnlock due to Copyright and us not willing to ship it.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
Didn't mean to sound rude. But I guess I misunderstood and even overlooked the part of putting the imagine to both slots
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] mrhumble1:
I totally agree that there's a right way to say things and that a person asks for a certain response if they come across with an aggressive tone. My point was that responding with clearly rude responses is not the way to address someone's poor tone or choice of words. We are all hobbyists and should aim to support each other and be helpful, even if someone gets a little snarky regarding ROM timing.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] juancheco95:
Followed the instructions provided now im booted :good: time to test carbon.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
I do have a couple questions not really sure the actual process of installing the image to both slots I don't read good especially with understanding but if I understand this may be the process of installing the image to both slots.

1, boot device into bootloader mode

2, fastboot boot twrp

3 inside twrp hit install choose option in bottom right corner install image choose the option recovery ( I guess it puts it there )) go back to main menu

4, reboot back to bootloader mode aka other slot

5, do the process over again . ??
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] Nekromantik:
no you first need to do a wipe of internal data either by fastboot if that works or by flashing the empty data img that has been provided on the first post.

then you do above but after reboot to recovery you need to flash GAPPS micro not the ROM again.

if you want ROM on both slots then yes after flashing GAPPS you can flash ROM and reboot and then flash gapps again. but no need for this.

only thing you need on both slots is OOS vendor which you will have if you not flashed any other ROMs.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
Ok cool . Thanks. I got it know .
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] fKm:
Wrong thread?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] a2mkung:
hi bro gps bug
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] cultofluna:
LOL
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] a2mkung:
don't support custom kernel ?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] Lossyx:
Ask your kernel maintainer.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] jerryhou85:
Moderator Information

Dear all, I have removed some off topic posts from this thread to keep it on topic. This is a development thread and please provide feedback or suggestions to developer and other users to make this ROM better. We want to ensure everyone has a good experience on XDA. Thanks. :highfive:

[MENTION=3816568]Myself5[/MENTION] report any post if you see they are no fit for this thread. :cowboy:
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] Myself5:
CARBON-CR-8.0-PAX-UNOFFICIAL-instantnoodlep-20200702-1435 has just been uploaded.

It contains fixes for app resizing issues, mainly shown when trying to open Google Maps.

P.S: It appears that the GApps flashing issue will be solved by another change I did on how the packages are flashing to dynamic partitions which will be released with the next TWRP update (3.4.0-2) by [MENTION=4712355]mauronofrio[/MENTION]. Our private tests seem promising so far.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] zanderzone:
As of now we can't flash gapps?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] marko94:
Yes, you can ..no worry's
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] zanderzone:
I formatted the user data as mentioned in OP by flashing the img

[IMG="Format Userdata"]https://i.ibb.co/2Kh8NYp/format.png[/IMG]

But now when I connect phone with PC, it doesn't show the storage

Any hint ?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] marko94:
Format data means wipe all ( storage, all your data etc)

Try boot twrp from fastboot ( latest twrp from here, also instructions: https://xdaforums.com/oneplus-8-pro/development/recovery-unofficial-twrp-oneplus-8-pro-t4101313) then from twrp try to mount storage and copy rom gapps etc..

If that doesnt help, sideload is you only solution or otg
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
Awesome do you think we might have to flash gapps again if they don't take the first try downloading build now will try
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] zanderzone:
I did exactly what OP said, to format the userdata either by fastboot or by flashing the userdata image and yes, I used the latest TWRP image.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] fKm:
Edit: wrong read...
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] marko94:
Ok, so where is the problem ?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] a2mkung:
help me [IMG="https://sv1.picz.in.th/images/2020/07/03/5iqrTa.th.jpg"]https://sv1.picz.in.th/images/2020/07/03/5iqrTa.th.jpg[/IMG]

---------- Post added at 08:28 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:23 AM ----------

[IMG="11"]https://sv1.picz.in.th/images/2020/07/03/5iqrTa.jpg[/IMG]
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] areyouanand:
flash OOS on both slots.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] a2mkung:
how to bro.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] marko94:
Via TWRP.. between reboot in recovery

Btw, if you don't know how to do some basic things, best case for you is to stay on OOS without unlocking bootloader.

Before you doing anything , read and search . How to do backup, how to use adb, fastboot ,TWRP etc..just to be safe
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] a2mkung:
thx. flash OOS on both slots bootloop bro.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] marko94:
Format data
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] a2mkung:
Same as slot b doesn't exist ???
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] marko94:
Go here, someone will help you

https://t.me/CarbonROMChat
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] a2mkung:
thank bro.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] joey.gunnarson:
Hey guys, looking for some help. I am having issues getting this to boot. I MSM to stock, unlock bootloader, flash twrp, flash userdata.img. flash carbon, flash twrp installer, reboot to recovery, flash opengapps nano, reboot. On initial reboot it boots to fastboot, if i switch slots it boot into twrp.
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] fKm:
Wipe data in STOCK recovery!
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] joey.gunnarson:
Before or after flashing the ROM?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
After
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] joey.gunnarson:
when i try to boot into stock recovery sending with fastboot i get qualcom crashdump
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
Just hold both volume buttons and power button until device turns off. , Then hold volume down and power until it vibrates still hold volume down until it boots into twrp and keep flashing happen to me 8 times last night until I figured it out I think it's a twrp issue on latest twrp version I'm now on latest rom build gapps and magisk and I used latest twrp just booting it
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] joey.gunnarson:
so just keep trying to flash it until it works?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] musicman5844:
Lol just try what I did it worked for me
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] jamescable:
Hi. Coming from the OnePlus 7 pro, do we have to install recovery after every rom install to keep recovery on this phone?
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] vtec303:
Read this first mate, and download the only flashable zip we have atm to flash recovery in twrp, replace the recovery in the zip file with the latest one, do it on the pc, I tried it on the phone and it didn't work.

https://xdaforums.com/oneplus-8-pro...unofficial-twrp-oneplus-8-pro-t4101313/page35

Also the recovery cannot wipe data on this device atm so in order to wipe you need to flash the image file in twrp but that will wipe your internal storage as well and without wipe rom won't boot, hope this helps. But read how to install on the first post and you will have a better idea, cheers
[OnePlus 8 Pro  ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other ] Myself5:
CARBON-CR-8.0-PAX-UNOFFICIAL-instantnoodlep-20200713-1912 has been uploaded as a new update.

Contains July ASBs and a VoLTE/VoWiFi icons for test, opinions welcome.