yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] JoeRifle:
Yeah, I can relate to that :P

But, ever since governments decided to track humans with the help of global cancer namend GApple ... the need is on for me and a lot of my "partners" (NO, we do NOT sell dope/do illegal ****, if you are going that route mentally. We have a very "legitimate" reason for staying off grid!)

Anyways, I think it has to do with rights assignment and/or install location of the backends/NlP. I managed to fix it with another rom that way.

I actually really like your solution to use UnifiedNlP as a standalone version without MicroG. It did work very well out of the box and disentangled the whole thing.

Unfortunately, I do need to integrate some kind of Googlish behaviour (APIs) and have not found a MigroG that comes either w/out integrated UNlP or can integrate/use yours instead...or maybe I'm not good enough hehe.

I also tried to deny MicroG to bind its Network Listener. But that refused to install :P

Anyways, I will try to fix this effup manually. If I make it, i.e. if I can get a reliable usage NlP of MicroG as of its current, unpolished state, I will report findings/solution.

--> Very very nice job! And all this development will now become way more important (GApple's Secret Services API)! Just wait and see...but be prepared my fellow community!

PS Forgot sth. In your TWRP folder for the S10+ there is one file which does not belong there cause it is for beyondlte1...dunno how it got there. I suppose you didn't realize yet, but maybe you wanna remove it from that folder [MENTION=4297219]modpunk[/MENTION]
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] circa_:
I'm trying to figure out how to properly backup my lineageOS data with TWRP. Everytime I try to restore, I end up in a bootloop.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
I'm using the pico apps and the first thing I do after installation, is that I go to the permission manager and remove the permissions from the gapps and turn off what I can. However I hope microg development get better in the next month. The current state is pretty bad.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
Can you provide a logcat of that bootloop? Sounds like something crashes ...
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
Did you wait 1 day to be able to unlock? Also why do you patch twrp if there is a boot.img with magisk available?
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] JoeRifle:
Yeah. For a savy dude like you, that works well I suppose :cool:

But this device goes to the hands of a regular John Doe - nice, but not so savy.

And I have to make sure that Google does not, by the means of update or something in the background manipulating settings way beyond control of this John Doe, that they do not manipulate or change the device. (as a side note: Google might even be hiding in places we do not know about in the system - but at least with MicroG they have no means of regularly introducing new and unwanted stuff into your device, while we as free users keep at least some compatibility with that global kraken.)

Oh, and btw I found a solution to make it work!!!

So in case other people care about it, I will post instructions in a separe post below this.

And also thanks to

this input from Keule-T, I remembered that I had indeed tried a different installer before also.

I will post instructions and links below. Gimme a sec for that though.

PS Anything good to recommend for theming anyone? Does Substratum work well?
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
The microG code was last touched in 2018, it isn't ready for Android 10 nor something for the regular John Doe to fix either. So why should I ship something half broken and then get complaints that it doesn't work?

If you wont a half working microG, it is your job to get it half working not mine :) There is also a problem with UnifiedNlp it needs a new permission introduced in Android 10 but it doesn't know about this permission. We need to wait till Marvin gets back to developement or grants people who actually fix issues permissions to commit. This didn't happen yet.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] ichmyselfandi:
Or you could just patch sig spoofing into your roms. Then everyone can chose to install microG on their own, without being depended on some installers.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Keule-Tm:
Well, actually it's least about the installers. He's addressing the problem that the core of MicroG is outdated (something I wasn't aware of).
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] t.l:
Tried again today with Beta 2 - didn't work.

Anyone else facing issues? Any ideas on how to get this to work? I'll try anything, except going back to stock...

Worked with Beta 1.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
Please send a logcat reproducing the issue or we can't fix this.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
I've added it to the FAQ, thanks!

If someone wants to build the ROM with MicroG, you can just use my microg repo:

https://github.com/cryptomilk/android_vendor_microg

and then build 'WITH_MICROG=true make -j bacon'

However you need add a patch for signature spoofing to frameworks/bast ...
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Gonzo202828:
after a few days of usage, without gapps!

Awesome work guys! 11hrs sot!

I love it, more privacy, root, a firewall, etc. awesome.

I just have one issue left: the volume when playing voice messages is very low, but not sure if its constantly.

Any ideas? S10+ Exynos here.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] t.l:
I attached a logcat I recorded using Logcat Reader.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] :
Hi,

i have a few questions. Cause i think the next time there will be the BETA3 and i don't want to crash anything cause of my update "routine". I would do it like this:

With firmware update:

1. Flash firmware via heimdall:

heimdall flash \
--BOOTLOADER sboot.bin \
--PARAM param.bin \
--UP_PARAM up_param.bin \
--CM cm.bin \
--KEYSTORAGE keystorage.bin \
--UH uh.bin \
--DTB dt.img \
--RADIO modem.bin \
--CP_DEBUG modem_debug.bin

--->> Is the sboot.bin needed cause i think i have to flash the magisk patched image of modpunk again, or is the magisk image a different image to the sboot.bin?

2. Boot into the twrp recovery

3. Flash the new LOS ROM .zip from sdcard or internal storage

4. Flash Gapps

--->> is this really needed for an update?

5. Flash the provided magisk patched image via TWRP to the boot partition

Without firmware update:

1. Boot into the twrp recovery

2. Flash the new LOS ROM .zip from sdcard or internal storage

3. Flash Gapps

--->> is this really needed for an update?

4. Flash the provided magisk patched image via TWRP to the boot partition

--->> Are these steps right?

--->> Do i have to flash the vbmeta-disabled.img too? Or is this only needed if i would update twrp?

Sorry if this are stupid questions but i didn't update a Custom ROM since my OnePlus 2 :P And now everything is running well with the LOS and i don't want to reininstall the whole phone cause of a wrong step by me during an update....
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Chulain:
[MENTION=4297219]modpunk[/MENTION]

The built in firewall you mentioned earlier is actually bugged on Ivan's version, denying internet connection to a certain program doesn't seem to work. Even disallowing background activity thro battery settings does not have any effect. Does this feature work on your version?

The lack of a decent camera is another reason for me to almost return to stock android, from what I understand it's not possible to get a good working multi-camera for now?

Also, not sure if this is OS-related but my AdAway doesn't seem to stay up to date for some reason, I frequently have to manually update my AdAway.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
The sboot.bin is the Samsung bootloader, and yes you should flash it. If you flash a new ROM you have to flash the boot.img with magisk too.

I would download the latest version of gapps and flash it to be up to date, but you don't have to.

I would download the latest version of gapps and flash it to be up to date, but you don't have to.

I think so.

You only have to flash it once before with TWRP.

There are no stupid questions, I hope all are answered.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
Works just fine for me ...

OpenCamera works just fine! An alternative is zgcam but it crashes to often for my taste.

I dunno AdAway as I don't use any ****ty spy apps and normally the firewall is enough to not get ads at all.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] :
[MENTION=4297219]modpunk[/MENTION]: Thank you very much for your answers. You cleared up everyting for me!
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] DerSteppo:
Hi modpunk, would you mind sharing more details or a link to instructions on how to set up adblock via firewall? Is it possible on stock firmware without root as well (if a firewall app is installed, for example)? I usually used the mentioned app when I was rooted, but if there is another way to do it, it might be interesting for a few fellow readers. :fingers-crossed:
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Keule-Tm:
AdAway removes in-browser adds as well. I like it for that alone (yea, there are add blocking browsers and as blocking plugins - but with this I don't need to remember that).
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
LineageOS has a built in firewall. You can restrict internet access for each app in the app settings. Till now this was enough for me to just remove internet access for them. I do it for all apps which don't need internet access.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Exilion90:
Hi modpunk,

I'm using built in Firewall and everything works great, the only thing i miss form afwall - the local net permission (some music/video streaming apps) that i want to block from accessing internet, but allow local net via WiFi.

Maybe i missed it somwhere, if it is in LOS, please navigate me)
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] trancinguy:
FYI

edit..

What about Wi-Fi control, can that work?
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Keule-Tm:
WiFi in this screenshot regards to access to internet via WiFi, not to only local nets.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Exilion90:
Yes, you are right. I'm searching for possibility to block all internet for the app, only to allow local net browsing, currently i think LOS doesn't have this option. Waiting for further development of LOS, pinephone and librem 5 to make final desigion)
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Keule-Tm:
AFAIK this functionality is only available with AFWall. I doubt it will get into the standard LOS settings. On true Linux-based phones it depends on the derivate (os) you use. In most it should be possible to install a firewall gui - I wonder if there's any as powerful as AFWall's...
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] FrankFoss:
Try again after 86400 seconds

Hi,

First of all thanks for your good work, the rom works very well without a screen lock,

but if you set up a screen lock, no matter if pattern, pin or password,

after a reboot you will have to wait 86400 seconds, even if you enter the correct password,

and after you reboot it again you can put the password/pattern/pin in again, but the same error will occur so i have to reinstall the rom.

If you could fix this it would be great because I like to use my phone with a lock and not unlocked.

Offtopic: i use your TWRP

Kind regards.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
The TWRP decrypt looks for the trustzone like a failed attempt so it locks it for 1d as a safety measure. See the FAQ on the first page for more details.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] :
If this happens you have to power the phone down. Wait a few minutes start your phone again, try to unlock it, if it fails and you get 86400 message power it down again. After 2 or 3 times of power down and start you should be able to login again (and yes complete shutdown, no restart). You don't have to wait one day...
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] John Paden:
Give NetGuard a try. Cool Tool.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] thomascar:
Hi !

Thanks for this ROM.

What is the step by step procedure to install it ? What i have to check and do ?

Thanks !

Regards.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] FrankFoss:
just check the FAQ section under the first Post:

How do I install this ROM on my phone for the first time?

Here is a short tutorial how to install the ROM:

Install our TWRP recovery. See FAQ section in the TWRP recovery thread.

Copy the ROM ZIP file an external SD card

Boot into the recovery

Wipe cache and dalvik

Format data

Flash the ROM (and e.g. gapps)

Reboot to system

---------- Post added at 06:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:20 PM ----------

Thank you!

OK, that means we have two options,

using the Rom without a lock, or with Lock and if the problem appears, using the off and on method described by Stef4n.

Until the problem is fixed in the future
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] t.l:
[MENTION=4297219]modpunk[/MENTION] Can I provide you with anything else? There is plenty going on in this log, some of it seems definitely related to my usb issue.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] FrankFoss:
[MENTION=4297219]modpunk[/MENTION]

by the way is it possible to Implement the new lineageos thermal profiles wich has been added to some xiaomi phones (review(dot)lineageos(dot)org/c/LineageOS/android_device_xiaomi_sdm845-common/+/275680) to our phone?

Or is it too difficult because of our exynos?!
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
This requires /sys/class/thermal/thermal_message/sconfig which we don't have. I guess it is a qcom thing.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] charliebigpot:
Just wanted to say that the beta2 is so stable that I haven't even felt the need to check this thread in weeks.

Thanks so much [MENTION=4297219]modpunk[/MENTION]
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] DerSteppo:
Proximity sensor not working in apps

Hi, I have tried two different push up apps (here and here) which usually make use of the proximity sensor. The sensor does not seem to work properly with apps on the S10e (stock firmware) though. Even DevCheck does not seem to get the sensor activated. It works for phone calls and if I access the sensor menu through *# shortcut, it is also working fine.

Can anyone confirm (or perhaps kindly check for me) whether the sensor is working with apps in LOS?

Many thanks and keep up the excellent work!
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
Can you provide 'dmesg' output?
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
Samsung released CTF1, working on BETA3 now.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] :
My S10+ was before flashing the LOS 17 a vodafone branded phone. Does it make differences for a firmware update if i flash the DBT firmware or do i have to flash the VD2 firmware? Or is this only interesting if you run a stock ROM?
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Gonzo202828:
can i use the build in updater of this rom?
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Keule-Tm:
The latter: only relevant for stock.

---------- Post added at 02:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:44 PM ----------

Only when it is build by the official LOS servers (if it where, it would be an official LOS build).
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Gonzo202828:
thank you, no its this one from this thread here.

so updating works by flashing the zip over it by twrp?

its my first time i ve rooted the s10+, it was a lot more complex and difficult compared to previous galaxys.

my volume is very low sometimes, even with max out settings, it seems to vary. any fixes ideas to this?
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] mastawindu:
This is sadly an issue that occurs with LOS roms on Samsung devices since the beginning of LOS. It has been pointed out by many users but the developers don't care unfortunately...

The microphone volume is also very low you'll notice I had the exact same issue with my S5 and A5 2017.

This really is the only thing that keeps me from flashing this rom
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] culjonito:
Could you please explain how you got GApps Stock working?

When I flash GApps Stock and want to restart to system after, It always boots to Recovery. GApps Nano for example works fine.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] cboar:
Great release, been loving the ROM, thank you very much!

I'm having an issue with frequent WiFi drops. The connection sometimes gets dropped completely, where the WiFi icon turns empty with an X indicator. My connection is generally quite weak, but I never ran into this issue on stock Samsung. Is it possible that the firmware update or the ROM itself had an effect on the radio? I am in North America and flashed the generic UK firmware. Any information would be greatly appreciated.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
Yes, it could be. Different countries allow different frequencies to be used.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Gonzo202828:
while calling my ear often accidently hits the "mute microphone" button. I havent had that before. Is there anything i could tweak with the sensors which disables the screen when holding the phone to the ear?
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] luisnica98:
This problem was faced in the previous lineages 15, 16. A fix was found by correcting the values inside the "mixer_paths" file contained in system/vendor/etc . Have anyone tried this?
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
I do not experience any low recording volume. And if there should be one you need to be more precise for which use case.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Meemo23:
First of all thank you, I have a S10 plus so I'll wait. But without magisk I can't use my banking app and such or can I use it regardless with the enforcing thing?
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
It should work without Magisk.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] jean_michmich:
FYI, keep in min that Screen casting (miracast) is not working on lineageOS17
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] seburton:
Thanks for the reminder.

It's a feature that dev forgot to list in "know issues" ?.

[MENTION=4297219]modpunk[/MENTION], Good to see new projects for s10e :)
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] culjonito:
Proud Austrian

Hey [MENTION=4297219]modpunk[/MENTION]

Nice to see a new LineageOS. (So hopefully the chance is higher that someone will create a Pixel Experience ROM and other AOSP custom ROMs soon.)

I'm also glad that you (the developer of this ROM) is an Austrian like me ;)

I'm from Vorarlberg and will flash your ROM as soon as it is available for the S10. I'm really looking forward to it :fingers-crossed:

Do you maybe have a telegram group or another group chat to share experiences and stuff? :confused:

Kind regards from Feldkirch

culjonito
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] jean_michmich:
I'm not expert but i can well confirm that :

I was flashing your ROM LOS17 and it wasn't working.

I flashed the Ivan meler's one LOS17 and it was working.

I repeated that several times.

There is maybe no link with this issue but after flashing your ROM TWRP was saying ( during wipe process) 'unable to mount storage'...probably an encryption issue.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] derf elot:
Did you format data, then reboot to recovery and wiped all other internal partitions before flashing?

---------- Post added at 12:26 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:12 AM ----------

Thanks, I'll have a look at thins once I finish upstreaming the kernel.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] :
Looks good, waiting for S10+ support :)
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
I've extended the FAQ section and also added debugging and install information.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] :
Wow, very nice! A LOS_17.1 + FDE on Galaxy S10! I am looking forward to the S 10+ Release :)
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] xBrownieCodez:
[MENTION=4297219]modpunk[/MENTION] working on an AOSPA port using your tree, excellent work :good: :p
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] angela5246:
Although I am not an AOSPA user I do appreciate the diversity thats going to emerge now with the sources open.

Keep up that great work.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] ichmyselfandi:
Hi, will I be able to run this ROM with MicroG?

I assume this ROM does not support signature spoofing.

And due to SElinux is enforcing, it is probably impossible to patch spoofing with Smali patcher.

And another question regarding Samsung firmware.

Do I need to flash future fw updates via Odin or will you implement these in future ROM builds?
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
You need to flash firmware updates via Odin. I will write down a list what you should flash in the next days. Siganture spoofing should be patchable. If I would have more bandwith I could build one with microg completely integrated.

https://github.com/cryptomilk/android_vendor_microg
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] angela5246:
From a security point of view its not a good idea to patch that in with SMALI. As far as I know you cannot switch it off / set permissions easily so its available for every app then. Better to integrate the patches microg provides.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] ichmyselfandi:
Would be awesome if you could patch signature spoofing into this ROM
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] VoidedKN0X:
Can't wait for an 10+ build ? finally some competition for Ivan tho ? also want to use microg so nice to hear there's some compatibilty
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
I'm looking forward to your contributions.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] Abaddon:
Cool! I'd wait for the s10 plus build then switch to this rom. Thank you so much for the effort :)
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] BratoMo225:
Alright. I managed to install this rom with great pain. When i first booted it up, i felt quite a heavy lag. I thought it will pass but it didnt. Now, i wanted to install some key apps from play store like facebook or viber or messenger. They didnt appear in playstore. Many apps in playstore didnt even show thumbnails. When i closed play store, heavy lag again. When i close any app, lag. Fingerprint scanner is very slow , 3-4 seconds to unlock it. I dont know, maybe i did something wrong to make it lag this much. Security is good but there is major lag. Thanks and peace!
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
I've uploaded BETA3. Finally I can upload with 40Mbit/s which is a lot more fun then with 1Mbit/s before.

I've added a patch which hopefully should fix that the screen is not fully turned of during phone calls. Please report back if that works now.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] mastawindu:
It did but to no success
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] angela5246:
Nice. Thanks a lot. Yeah, 40-1 is quite a difference. Those downstream-upstream ratios suck big time.
[Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10 5G/E Cross Device Deve] modpunk:
Yes, this is using CTF1 blobs and kernel changes.