yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] lesterinidad:
Any Q gsi that is stable enough?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] igalmarino:
After installing Magisk I started to get the message on Evolution X too

I think it is related to rooting
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
Oh that makes sense, good to know, thanks!
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
I'm on PixelExperienceP-arm64-aonly.zip not sure about the Dev but there was only one who appears to have a pressence on XDA, so I went for that one... Okay, just checked, yes, your using the same as me... Ver 0229 Unofficial.

Check your apn settings, I additional had to change to 4G

---------- Post added at 03:45 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:02 AM ----------

UPDATE_3:

Fixed by dirty flashing all; suspect issue created from flashing another rom and then reverting to another with a TWRP restore. In the future I'll instead try before restoring a nandroid for a diff rom, re-flashing clean first, then restore.

I can no longer backup in twrp, get a cannot create tar fork error.

Any ideas?

Update:

adb pull /tmp/recovery.log /home/cantenna/TWRP/recovery.log

Invalid encryption mode file /data/unencrypted/mode

Backing up System...

Invalid encryption mode file /data/unencrypted/mode

Error opening: '/system/lib64/vndk-27' (Structure needs cleaning)

I:Error in Generate_TarList!

Update 2: fixed with dirty flash all. I suspect issue was from flashing another rom and nandroid back to another without first flashing said another before nandroid restore
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] Amjadhazzan:
Hi, thanks for the rom, but can someone help me on how to install it?

I dont understand what it treble converter and what is GSI and stuff, what do i need to install?

Thanks
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] ushan fernando:
You're a legend bro , thank you very much for your dedication, this is the best thing happened to s8 ,thank you again

---------- Post added at 06:56 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:55 AM ----------

if you don't know what it is or cant understand the instructions dont install this
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] Zendesk2:
This is android 9 ?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] uoid:
Hi thank you to everyone who helped me through the installation process, i just wanted to report i don't know if anyone noticed this but

The screen doesn't turn on once turned off under direct sunlight. If you try to cover the proximity it works.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] kariem9495:
Flash the updated vendor, it should fix auto brightness problem.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] hamoudzii:
Stuck on Boot

I'm stuck on EvoX boot logo although all steps went OK. What should I reflash again?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] uoid:
Already on v 0.2.

---------- Post added at 09:43 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:42 AM ----------

Did you factory reset?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] hamoudzii:
No.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] uoid:
Factory reset it and it should be fine
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] hamoudzii:
forget that, I've wiped data and it worked
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] AndrzejDwo:
Wipe data is all you need while switching between GSIs.

Wipe data

Flash new system.img

Reboot
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
Yea that happens if you move brightness slider to absolute maximum, I assume that doing so sets brightness to sensor which is cause for issue. To mitigate; I'm going to install pwm flicker free mod or lux
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] parser:
where can ı see the changelogs?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] iamchukwudi:
Please make your kernel to support this project.

---------- Post added at 08:52 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:50 PM ----------

Please, any chance G955N will be added to supported device in future updates?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] ih8snow.lc:
Could the pixelarity magisk module potentially fix a few problems for the pixel android q gsi?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
Really want to utilise this instead of Samsung but WiFi performance seems to have issues for me sometimes, is that because it's early days and ASOP?

Getting "WiFi disabled" and "Access Point is Full" errors preventing me from connecting to my access points... I use 802.11r and 802.11W and static DHCP on my custom LEDE builds for DIR-505 and WRT1900ACS routers.

I'll have to play around with it more. The 802.11r is supposed to facilitate seemless transition amongst access points when I roam, It seems like this is happening some times, some times not.

Update: so seems to have settled down now... Seems more likely to occur with frequent reboots and toggling off WiFi seems to aggravate it.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] Maroc_Specops:
Worthless. Display stays off. A lot of bugs.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
Hey guys google discover; it's crashing systemui whenever I visit a news article, anyone know how to fix?

Upate; caused by Xposed module Disable IPV6
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] uoid:
Just turn your brightness slider a little away from full
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
General question for more experienced Treble users;

1) Am I free to dirty flash any gsi rom and only have to wipe system before hand, okay to leave DATA intact? If so, that's pretty darn cool!

2) I read on one gsi thread that it's common among all gsi roms to have intermittent camera issues... is that true? See here

https://xdaforums.com/project-treble/trebleenabled-device-development/gsi-havoc-os-t3930030/page135

---------- Post added at 02:39 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:29 PM ----------

Does Evolution X suffer from the Max Brightness bug too?

Edit: Fix/Workaround for Max brightness bug;

Get Lux

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.vito.lux

/Settings/Brightness/Min Max and Phone Brightness/Set Maximum Brightness; 89
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] jotacorredor:
worthless comment indeed. Working perfect here so keep your I want everything working without moving my little finger to search for fixes comments to yourself. Slds,
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] saifulmenon:
what did u mean by disable IPV6
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] SahilCrazy:
Anyone of you guys also got problems with a lot of apps crashing instantly upon opening them so they don't seem to work at all? For example amazon, feedly and a lot more...

I'm on Evolution X.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
I've been using an Xposed module for the longest time that force ipv4 connections only... Was causing issues with Google discover, crashing the systemui

---------- Post added at 11:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:00 PM ----------

Sometimes opening Magisk or Xposed; there is a delay opening the app if I try to do so immediately after boot... But that goes away after boot had time to settle.

I was experiencing that crashing you mention which was crashing the systemui but that was due to an Xposed module. .. If your using Xposed, try disabling all modules; it maybe a module. Could also be a Magisk module too..

Here now, with my Magisk modules and Xposed modules all is very stable, no crashes... Just trying to solve this WiFi issue that seems to resolve itself odly after like 20mins of doing nothing...

Runing pixel experience. Battery life is insane on this, much better than Oreo.

Update: seemed to have fixed my WiFi issue, was caused by 802.11w; guess that's a Samsung enterprise add on that's not available on ASOP, not a big issue. 802.11r working great :)

If you guys want to run at medium Touch Wiz resolution which should be more battery friendly, issue in terminal as su;

wm size 1080x2220

to reset

wm size reset (duh)

I also use "Simple Pie" and disable gestures/navbar, a way better experience!

Right now everything works great, no issues and very stable.

Xposed modules I use;

Amplify

Exi for swift key

Flat Style at indicatore (disabled signal icon)

Sudo hide

If you run the "cannot create tar fork error()" with twrp backup, just omit backing up the system partition.

The great thing about the new Magisk having moved all to the /DATA DIR, especially for use with Treble, including a /SYSTEM partition backup is no longer required, instead just re-flash the stock version back when required!

If doing any system configurations you should be using VR25 terminal systemised module anyway what put system apps systemlessly in the /Data dir

Treble capability enhanced by a Magisk, who would have thought?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] saifulmenon:
yeah ur right, i installed xposed, then installed gravity box

there was like several systemui crash

when i uninstalled xposed everything was normal

can u suggest me a camera app that can be used properly
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] jotacorredor:
did you remove Chrome or WebView? Sounds like that could be causing you issues, ran evolution x without any of the issues you are reporting. Slds,
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
https://t.me/exynosgooglecamera/24805

Unix Camera is what they recommend

---------- Post added at 01:20 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:12 AM ----------

Oh oh, Bluetooth calling doesn't appear to be working here...

Can someone confirm if Bluetooth calling is working for them and which rom they are using?

Thanks.

Update: Just tried Bluetooth calling with another rom; not working either. Tested with Bose Headphones and Honda Car... Headphones, just audio and car said it paired but phone not found, music does not work either.

As awesome as this project is, Bluetooth call connectivity is too significant of a feature for me... I recommend adding this to the Op notes as a bug/not working...

Will be back in the future if this gets resolved. (hoping)

Cheers :)
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] corsicanu:
Bluetooth calls are working on Note8 on Pixel Experience and Evolution X, used that myself plugged to car audio. They do work but not on all GSIs. In which GSIs it didn't work for you?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
Using S8+ SM-G955F here, tried;

Havoc-OS	vince31fr	XDA	A - A/B	arm - arm64

Pixel Experience	EnesSastim	XDA / Download	A - A/B	arm - arm64

AOSP	phhusson	XDA / Download	A - A/B	arm - arm64 (this is a vanilla ASOP build to be used by other dev's to add back features)

They all exhibit the exact same failing like symptoms on Bose headphones and Honda car leading me to believe this may only be fixable with a vendor update.

Happy to help you sort this out this evening with testing and logs; send me a pm or message me back here.

I had Telegram up and running, joined your channel, flashed your latest vendor update too... but not setup atm as I reverted to Oreo backup.

btw thanks again for Treble :)

I also tried magisk module google framework for dialer but no change
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] angelcalibur:
Hi, anyone have try with a Galaxy watch ?

I need a rom where i Can instal Galaxy wear app to Sync my galaxy Gear S3 to my device...
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
I have that watch as well, was going to take that on next. Let me know how you make out.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] vensterbank:
Heya guys,

using Pixel Experience EnesSastim XDA / Download A - A/B arm - arm64

everything works like a charm, only two small issues i have found

i dont have a galaxy watch but my Miband 3 does sync with the mifit app on my phone and pushes notifications

can confirm bluetooth calling does not work, you can toggle it in the dailer between speaker and headset but it keeps playing on the speaker. (bluetooth connection is otherwise excellent!)

when seraching something via te google serachbar on the home screen gives you result, and you want to open a result in the chrome browser it craps out and wont load. probably a play services thing but i use firefox anyway.

this rom is the best thing that happened to the s8 in a while
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] Pentax01:
Delete
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
Yea... I tried to go back to Oreo because I need bluetooth calling... but i've already taken the red pill.... Now im back on Havoc hoping.... Looks like its speaker phone for the next little while, lol

Next phone I buy will be fully dev friendly with Treble, that's going to be top priority! Havoc got some pretty awesome tweaks including much needed recent theme tweaks; you can return to the old Oreo recent's, how cool is that? But even better than that; there's a slim option and I recommend disabling previews for that, so fast!! That what Pie should have done as a step forward in terms of new features, much better than iOS recent!

And this build I'm able to flash gapps as a module!!:laugh:
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] angelcalibur:
I didn't tryed for thé moment. I need to be sure that all i want/need is working...

You have the Galaxy Gear S3? Can you try to connect it with an aosp rom?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
hahaha I'm in the same boat as you are and fully recognize the royal PITA it is to re-setup that watch!! Just like you, I'm playing around with this stuff... I'm happy to dive into the watch if/when Bluetooth call support comes... Until then, I'm holding off.

What I can tell you based on my experience, that watch at best is capable of syncing with any non Samsung rom in a limited capacity (done it before) and worst case scenario require build.prop edits to spoof a google device... There is however (as you may know...) a tighter integration that you'll never see outside of use with a touch wiz rom that will likely never be available here... But the important stuff will be! I suspect its highly likely Samsung Pay will work here, that would be a bonus. But like you, all I really care about is the health stats and competing with others in the challenges :highfive:
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] alepagliaccio:
love this! But i can't tell if fast charging is working doesn't look like that to me maybe i'm wrong
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
I'd like to know as well, new to treble... Based on Ampere, things look the same to fast charge
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] saifulmenon:
i experienced best battery life in Evolution X rom

damn good

i recommend this rom
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] vensterbank:
How are the animation on evolution x. On pixelexperience they hang a bit sometimes. Especially when closing the camera.

Could be a kernel thing maybe.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] kariem9495:
The animations are pretty fast and smooth, no lags or anything.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] paulprog:
For me, it was the same. Laggy animations (for example open/close app), even after installing FDE.AI module. You can experiment with Disabling HW overlays in the Developer options, this will give you smooth open/close animation but a bunch of other animations will get choppy.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] angelcalibur:
And what about games like pubg mobile?

Anyone can make a AnTuTu benchmark ?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
Running Havoc; have no idea if this is good or not...
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] saifulmenon:
The animation laggy is becoz the kernel is not optimized, tho its a initial release

Future updates will fix everthing
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] IREWolfman:
Will this come with future ROMs? Or will we always have to convert?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] saifulmenon:
On Evolution X
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] saifulmenon:
If u want to flash stock custom rom yes u hav to convert

Coz all the stock roms ar gsi
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
Some good news; tried again to pair Bluetooth to Honda car and was able to connect! The process is different from Samsung Oreo.... Here, on these Treble Roms I additionally had to click on a phone icon on the car dash touch screen and make an additional connection. Call audio seems to redirect properly too... Update; Bluetooth calls works in my car!

My boss headphones still don't not work correctly however for calls.

At least now I can stick around for updates, the Bluetooth connectivity in the car these days is a must.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
I'm not seeing this here now... But I do move the typical apps where they belong; in priv-app systemlesly with terminal systemizer i.e. Unix Camera, Nova launcher, etc I would assume if you keep these as non system apps they're more likely to exhibit a lag like experience.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] corsicanu:
v0.3 is up :D

Special thanks goes to [MENTION=7969495]remilia15[/MENTION] [MENTION=7571048]Dyneteve[/MENTION] and [MENTION=4637718]ananjaser1211[/MENTION] for their help in fixing some of the issues.

Regards!
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] panchovix:
Damn that's a pretty good score, I score 207k on stock Pie, unrooted, I think I never saw above 210k on S8/S8+ lol
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] vensterbank:
This update really makes a huge difference.

Amazing!
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] IREWolfman:
I'm confused. I've read the beginning. Is this a full rom or do I need to install rom after? Which or where are the compatible ROMs. When I said convert question earlier, I meant will ROMs come with treble (compatible ones) or do you always have to convert first?. Really want aosp or pixel style rom but current one(lineage) was too buggy for me. Is this stable? Compared to that?

Currently on Project Pixel Pie with TGP kernel.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] corsicanu:
Read the thread again from top to bottom, you will find all the answers you looking for.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] IREWolfman:
Ok I'll try again
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] mrjoy:
My device is volte & if i want to install this rom then how i can use volte?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] Ok-Alex:
I'm I understanding correctly that "General bugs" will not be fixed? Never?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] rooted2306:
How to install my g950n?

It doesn't work on g950n

I tried edit update-binary and update-script, but it doesn't work..
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] saifulmenon:
overclocking will result more score

almost like 231577

---------- Post added at 11:25 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:16 AM ----------

is the led indicator fixed while charging
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] angelcalibur:
Nice score! Thx!
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] just_reii:
Wondering if you guys are getting this message as well? Wondering if Its normal or not? Get it both on Resurrection and Pixel experience. Some apps I can't use as well like text now says my phone is rooted and unsupported. Not sure if Its because of the GSI or i ts because of that message I'm getting.

But other than that all is good and enjoying this so far. Can't wait to see more updates in the near feature. Much love.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] corsicanu:
Please do a better kernel. Thanks

It won't be included in roms and probably it can't be included. You can however to run a stock rom without even minding you have treble installed. Try to re-read first page notice.

No. Never.

Issues are not the same thing as bugs. Issues as in install issues, how to enable usb mtp or how to turn on wifi.

Some of the bugs are fixable in the future, i'm still working on it hence the beta status and 3 updates in a week.

Hope you bricked your phone because you just can't understand it doesn't work.

Will add support when i will feel like spending extra time on repartitioning a device with whole different partition layout than international ones.

Nop, that's a samsung related feature and i believe it will never work. However led works as in stock for notifications and low battery.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] just_reii:
Hey! Was wondering if you knew why I was getting that message just above the one you wrote haha
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] corsicanu:
Don't mind it, your phone works already with or without that message.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] just_reii:
Sounds good just wanted to make sure I wasn't the only one haha. Thanks
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] Sn33z3x:
can you make it support g955n :( ? touchwiz is laggy
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] Carlo Borbor:
I hope future Android 10 Q GSI will work properly because S8 will no longer receive OneUI 2.0
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
So I tested my hdmi adapter (ADATA) ; display works fine but audio does not pass through. Bluetooth can be used as a work around.

Let's be honest though, hdmi out is poorly implemented on S8+ on the whole anyways... Can't even charge the phone while an hdmi is being used; all I can do is slow down discharge with a power cable... how weak is that!? Maybe if the phone display would turn off.

Anyways, what I do use are the two USB ports the dongle provides for TWRP backups to thumb drive but I noticed (perhaps due to patches to TWRP?) I am no longer able to backup to thumb drive, it fails. Can still backup to SD card though.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] abhi9845:
Can any one tell me what is the advantage of having rom with project treble on galaxy S8? I searched still didnt understant about project treble.
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] gabriel drew:
You are a true legend!

Thank you so much
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] paulprog:
Scratch that, the vendor 0.3 changes everything. All is super smooth now, without FDE.AI.

Bluetooth works as expected. Connected my Galaxy watch active. Connected to car, made a call, all working as it should.

hadesTreble with Pixel Experience is now my daily driver. Thank you corsicanu and devs!
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] Luisito Santos:
Hola acabo de instalar miui y no me aparece la huella :c, buen trabajo
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
Really!?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] just_reii:
General questions: what GSI has worked best for who?
[Samsung Galaxy S8 & S8+ Cross Device Development] cantenna:
Pixel Experience is good but I'm on Havoc now;

https://xdaforums.com/project-treble/trebleenabled-device-development/gsi-havoc-os-t3930030

(I) think Havoc is better, very stable, smooth and a ton of useful user customization's that actually eliminates most Xposed tweaks tbh... Worth checking that out for sure!

The install process for Havoc gsi is a bit more tricky for noobs;

1) The rom first boots into to a launcherless environment.... Don't panic, wait a few mins then reboot, then wait another few Mins and reboot again. It's just unpacking the rom still I suppose...

2) After the rom is up and running fine, you'll need to install gapps, I'm using Pico gapps... But galls won't install though unless you first resize the system partition first; that can be done in the Advanced Wipe section of twrp. After that, gapps will install fine.

3) your gapps install will likely state its non-certified. That can easily be fixed too with;

https://www.xda-developers.com/how-to-fix-device-not-certified-by-google-error/