yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Pharraon:
Snapdragon:( kills the hackers and the mods people Samsung win we keep buying snapdragon series that's why they dont care about the costumers anymore I do not own a s10 because I'm waiting for someone to root the phone but like a say hackers die the OG people just focus on s8 not s9 only s8 mods and root they die no one cant root the snapdragon anymore so buy exynos plus xda is dead now is not like the old times anymore :( plus if everyone donate is the same no one cant root snapdragon I feel bad because I have the s8 plus and I have root but s9 and s10 they will never have root anymore is only a wish
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Paradoxxx:
What are you on about ? Chinese snapdragon is rooted already.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
Rooted snapdragon sm-g9700:silly:
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Pharraon:
Not tmobile or Verizon s10 SM-G973U or plus .-.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Fznwolf:
How can you even tell if the root works on it or not? You don't even have an unlocked bootloader.

You may want to create a Snapdragon Bootloader (Identify variants) unlock waiting room. That's an entirely different animal than just "root".
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
It's never happening, seriously. If you want root, don't buy a phone unless you're sure it can be rooted. US versions cannot be rooted and likely never will be.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Pharraon:
I know I keep my s8 plus I will not buying a s9 or s10 exynos is not on USA that's why I dont buy it cause I ask tmobile and they only sell snapdragon version
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] AloxeCorton:
I have a HK snapdragon on which I did a full and complete ODIN firmware wipe before proceeding with the Magisk root process (I went Chinese firmware before just to try but that didn't make a different and the Chinese firmware is crippled with strange region specific things such as forcing to have a SIM card installed, no google play, etc. - so I recommend using the HK firmware to start with knowing both the Chinese and the HK G10+hardware are the same which isn't the case with the US & other regions that have locked boot loaders preventing any root (until a backdoor is found maybe one day))

For me I haven't had a reboot ever since I updated the Magisk update channel to systematically use Ian's release channel from within the Magisk application itself. For the record, before that I had like 4-5 reboots in a week... and I haven't installed any other Magisk modules.

In summary, the reboot issue was present in the first releases but the subsequent (Ian McDonald) updates seem to have addressed the problem.

And now I'm playing around a lot with Linux on Dex which is interesting...

A.A.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] bsam55:
"For me I haven't had a reboot ever since I updated the Magisk update channel to systematically use Ian's release channel from within the Magisk application itself."

AloxeCorton,

I have heard nothing about setting update channel the way you mention.

Would that mean choosing "Custom" and setting url to Ian's github update page?

If not could you please explain what to do.

Thanks in advance.

Edit: I answered my question. I obviously needed Ian's Magisk Manager. I feel like a moron.https://cdn-cf-3.xda-developers.com/images/smilies/silly.gif
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] aldeamovil:
me although I have it updated to the last of ian I still have restarts

I'll start again from scratch, full stock firmware by ODIN, and then patch with the last one of ian to have if I'm lucky and the restarts disappear

because otherwise I will have to give up since it is a problem for those of us who use the cell phone as an alarm clock, among other things

I'll tell you about it
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
I experience the same.

At first root browser caused my reboots mostly.

Now I have not reboots since 4-5 days and I'm using the phone quite a lot and now also Automation with root access.

Also I use few Magisk modules without an problem.

OT:

I'm very happy with the S10. The speakers are just awesome with Dolby Atmos.

Also I advise everyone to install Samsung Music. Don't know why Samsung is not installing it by default.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
I'm updated with the latest ianmacd Magisk, and I get a reboot very often. Happens almost always when I manually lock the screen. Is there a way to figure out which app is causing this? I've tried uninstalling apps like root browser and lucky patcher with no luck. Only module installed is Youtube Vanced
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] mains75:
So it seems we can have root without problems on s10 SD HK versions...

If also TWRP will be available, it will be perfect...
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] monroe0328:
My reboots stopped once I uninstalled firefds edxposed module.

Maybe it was some setting I had in there conflicting with something else like substratum or systemUI tuner.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] jamesfitzes:
hey guys,

Just wanted to confirm the only snapdragon model that can be rooted is the sm-g9750 ? Is that dual sim ?

The only place I can buy it from is ebay and it has it listed as dual sim

Thank you
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] aldeamovil:
the truth is that I have not yet restored it to stock to do with the last update of ian but it took several days without reboots.

Maybe what he needed was to stabilize

I only have one module installed, the one of skvalex, which is the main root cause for my use

I will tell you if it has remained stable
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] FlatOutRU:
Yep, it is dual sim. Also sm-g9730 (regular s10, non plus)
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] jamesfitzes:
Thanks for the info.

Also, any other websites/places I can shop for this particular model? I'm reading comments that ebay/amazon advertise it as sm-g9750 but ship the exynos one.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
I bought my G970 from ebay seller never-msrp and it came as advertised. You'll be fine from them.

Also, everyone, I tied the resets primarily to locking the screen with the power button or unlocking it. To combat this, I set the Bixby button to lock the screen instead and that's eliminated reboots. It's a work around and takes some getting used to, but it's doable.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] aldeamovil:
Good, could you explain how you managed to use the bixby button to lock the screen? after the last update of ian I have had reboots again and what I have done for the moment is to cancel the power button to block the screen, only turn it off and for now it seems stable.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] tulth:
I have a sm-g9750 and I get occasional reboots with both magisk canary and ianmacd magisk.

If we can just figure this out, this will be such a perfect phone!

If I can help somehow, let me know!

BTW, after reboot I lost wifi, I think due to this issue: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/1357

If this happens to you, just forget and reconnect to the wifi as the current workaround.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Fznwolf:
If you're having issues with wifi and bluetooth like this install the magisk module "libsecure_storage companion for rooted samsung devices".
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] tulth:
Thanks! just installed it and trying it out!
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] tulth:
I captured last_kmsg here:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/1450

Can others confirm these elements of the crash in /proc/last_kmsg:

Unable to handle kernel NULL pointer dereference at virtual address 000000f0

...

<4>[10598.968826] [0: android.bg: 1251] task: ffffffc1a9540f00 task.stack: ffffff801fbe0000

<4>[10598.968902] [0: android.bg: 1251] pc : smaps_pte_range+0x29c/0x428

Basically is it null pointer deref f0 and pc (program counter) is in smaps_pte_range?

It may be that kernel 4.14.78-15821588 has a bug. Does anyone have a different kernel to try?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Pharraon:
I got a s10.-. Tmobile now is not tmobile anymore is full unlock sim clean etc what can I do with a full unblock cellphone?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] FlatOutRU:
Has anyone tried to install any gsi rom to snap version?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Basically create a bixby command that locks the screen, and then set that command to happen when I click the button. I'll also disable locking with the power button since I do still press the power button sometimes by reaction.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
I guess you can't do anything. You have a US version. Event if you unlocked for any sim it still has a locked bootloader which is likely never be unlocked in near future.

Always inform yourself before buying phones with locked bootloader with the intend to root the phone.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] jamesfitzes:
Thinking to order the s10+ snapdragon version but I have a few questions since I’ve been out of the rooting game for a long time….

1)	I see you guys are able to root the China/HK snapdragon version and you have magisk. Is there an exposed version for Android Pie? Does it fully work? Is it stable?

2)	Since there is no TWRP recovery for this particular model yet, is there alternatives to TWRP ? Or if I need to flash a .zip file can I do that without TWRP ?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] TheUndertaker21:
1. yes for xposed called edxpose

and 2. no, twrp might come to SD version but might be a long time

i have s10+ exynos but wished i bought the SD version
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] jamesfitzes:
I've only had exynos Samsungs so far but switching to snapdragon this time. I waited for the OP 7 pro but I've made up my mind. S10+ still kills it as an all rounder.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Pharraon:
Yeah but I got a exynos root full super good, but I buy this s10 cause I was curious if I unlocked etc lol well that's mean i have to wait for snapdragon for now I keep my slow exynos
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] rp4k:
Why the f_ck do you think the exynos is slow. The only snapdragon that will ever get root will be the china/hk variant . All others will be impossible for the indefinite future. Just look at the note 9 snapdragon they have been waiting longer than you.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Pharraon:
Well I have the phones and is really slow sucks sorry but is the true I like snapdragon I can emulate my PC games etc etc with exynos is a little bit slower I dont used the phone for casual stuff I used it for games or PC games .-. Root is good cause I can get some stuff and mod my own rom etc but is super hard to root snapdragon plus I dont have a lot of time .-. I would love to have time
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] rp4k:
True snapdragon does perform better than exynos but only in games. Other than that they are the same phone and if you are so worried about your games then stick to the computer you don't need such an expensive device.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
If you have the US Snapdragon, it will likely never be rooted. If you wait you'll just be disappointed. Only the HK version can be rooted, so if you need root so bad just buy the HK version. It's safe to assume your phone will never ever get root.

Also, for us HK Snapdragon users, can we use edxposed? Link?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] rp4k:
Yes you can use edxposed check their github.

https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
i hesitate to try because when i installed Tai chi expose i lost root, you need to try
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Thanks! Sandhook or YAHFA?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] rp4k:
I use YAHFA . I had alot if issues with the sandhook version
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] aldeamovil:
someone knows if the restart issue has been corrected

I had to put back the stock firmware because I still had restarts

please have someone confirm it

Thank you.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] osn19:
I m using the latest Ian Magisk after a complete wipe clean of stock, but still getting the random reboots
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Ndaoud360:
There is no TWRP for Snap 9730 yet right? Because I can't boot with root only without it, I think it's a module I installed. Not sure how to remove the module without using the magisk module uninstaller that requires TWRP to flash it.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
maybe a magisk module or app using root you installed causing this.

i use now the normal version of magisk 19.1 canal stable and like before with ianmacd magisk i don't have any more reboot, but i'm careful with that i install

---------- Post added at 06:14 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:08 PM ----------

yes There is no TWRP for Snap 9730. you lost root ,at boot do you press vol up+bixby+power
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Ndaoud360:
I do press vol up, bixby and power but that causes the phone to reboot on the Samsung glowing animation. It will then reboot normally to non rooted.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
so you don't have choice, need to restart this procedure , try directly at step 7 ,flash magisk_patched:

https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/samsung
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Ndaoud360:
Would I still have to full wipe?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
sorry, no try only to flash only magisk_patched and after at reboot do press vol up+bixby+power.

if it work you will boot in system magisk.

but sometimes thats works but not all the time

if not in this case you need to do a full wipe effectively.

that's why i do often a full backup with oandbackup(before trying new things) because it happens to me lot of times to loose root.(last times i lost root because i tried substratum)
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] SakazukiAka:
Hey guys. Just a quick question: Is it possible to flash a european firmware onto a rooted G9700 (S10e HK device)? Maybe with root it will work?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
No because hardware difference
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] black228:
s10+

Hello! After the steps of this manual, the phone is loaded into the screen as in the picture. What is translated into English means: Your phone is locked becuse the payment service was uninstalled without authorization. Please contact for more information.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Fznwolf:
Sounds like you disabled the samsung payment service... which is only able to disabled with root. You disabled too much.

Boot back into non rooted rom (which will break the root disabler), re-enable stuff then boot back to rooted rom.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
Interesting thing to do with magisk is to install LKT module choose battery profile, and minimum freq 300mhz is unlocked, by defaut min is 567mhz.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
Does anyone have additional info on reboots.

I've had the ianmacd version from 03.05.19 and it ran very stable.

After one update to 15.05. I guess the reboots came back but going back to 03.05. didn't solve the reboots.

Is it possible to use the uninstall function inside of Magisk or will it cause problem?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Fznwolf:
Try disabling your AOD. I don't use it and have no reboots.

(I've always preferred iOS style notifications)
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] bengtc:
What are the differences in installation steps between rooting the snapdragon and exynos found here https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/samsung
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] osn19:
I confirm, AOD is causing the reboots
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
After completely uninstalling Magisk (by accident) + Odin flash with home_csc and patched AP + Updating Magisk to newest ianmacd(which I already had before) phone run stable for now.

Disabling AOD is no option after buying a 700 EUR phone.

Edit: I disabled AOD now cause I still had a reboot now but I really liked it. -_-

There was a week when I didn't have any problems with AOD on. Don't know how to restore that state...
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] galaxys:
There's no party here yet! ????? Let me know when it starts ??
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Ndaoud360:
Apparently it has been confirmed that HK snaps can root using the original method. I tried but I can't boot to recovery after flashing patched tar.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Tel864:
LOL, they'll never use this thread, but at least they can see what the rest if the world is doing.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] mains75:
Have you tried to contact any devs for help? I hope you will be able to do it.. you are our hope..:good:
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Ndaoud360:
I have contacted a dev who worked on the Note 9 and he said 2 things. First he said that we need S10 HK kernel, modify it to remove some things from it that will prevent root, then patch with magisk and you're good. 2nd he said that the current method for Exynos models should work for HK snaps and he did check magisk source code to conclude that it should. If it doesn't then magisk is preventing the phone from going into recovery.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] mains75:
So is he working on it?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Ndaoud360:
Forgot to mention the thing is that the s10 HK version, the kernel is not released yet, he put in a request and now we wait. The s10e and plus HK kernels are released but I don't think he's working on those. Either we wait or keep trying the current Exynos method because 1 person claims that his friend got the current method working for his HK version. Also if some one knows how to compile kernels can compile the e and plus kernel without the root preventions and then we can get root for those
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] mains75:
The HK S10e is the exact model I want to buy... just waiting for root access...I hope someone will get it...
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] polystation12:
Is it possible to flash the HK firmware on a North American galaxy s10?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] SuperBrolySSJ:
probably not
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] dtowngs4g:
I have US Sprint snap unless your referring to Devs.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Fznwolf:
Looks like the SD S10s with the

unlocked bootloader (Not US/Canadian Variants)

are able to be rooted using Magisk. Read below in detail, there's quite a few comments by reputable people indicating this.

https://xdaforums.com/galaxy-s10/development/magisk-root-galaxy-s10-series-t3918699

There's a few catches and its a bit more work than a typical root, but it appears to work.

A few things to keep in mind:

-A lot of people seem to think all S10 SD variants are locked bootloader. This is not true.

-US and Canadian variants have a locked bootloader.

-Make sure you download the correct firmware when using this method, mine is the HK variant here: https://samfrew.com/download/Galaxy__S10__/zjbs/TGY/G9730ZHU1ASC8/G9730TGY1ASC8/

-Some confirmations here:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=79329922&postcount=372

and

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=79330926&postcount=375

Good luck and post results if you're feeling like following directions and putting in a bit of work.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] NisseGurra:
Very sceptical that snapdragon really has root, s9 required modified kernel to do that, if i remember correctly. The development for snapdragon versions of s9 was/is very small, most work done by single person(S)
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Ndaoud360:
If someone can post a screenshot of it actually working, I'll try a 3rd time.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] jonathanfv:
I really want to try as soon as I have time. I don't know about the kernel, I have the sources but compiling it seems like a pain in the butt (I tried a month ago and kept getting various errors). But I'll certainly try the regular, official Magisk installation. rp4k's message about SM-G9750 working gives me hope.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Ndaoud360:
Anyone know if there is a way to flash back to stock firmware without losing data if data wasn't already wiped?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] jonathanfv:
No idea. Probably not. And weren't you supposed to wipe everything before flashing Magisk in the first place?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Ndaoud360:
It doesn't specifically say to wipe data before, it just says the unlock bootloader process wipes data but my bootloader is already unlocked. After flashing, you need to go to recovery and that doesn't work for me, so I flash back and I end up having a wiped phone. Would like to trial and error without having a wiped data if I flash back.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] jonathanfv:
Ah, I see. I also unlocked my bootloader a while back. I think I'm just going to back everything up using Smart Switch first, then I'll experiment for a while and then I'll restore everything if it doesn't work. It's really not that bad I find with Smart Switch. I'll probably wipe everything before trying to root anyway to start with as clean a slate as possible.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Fznwolf:
You essentially have to unlock twice...

Follow this closely: https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/samsung
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
This happened to me while flashing the Chinese firmware by mistake. Just start over, do a clean wipe, and flash the HK firmware.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] FlatOutRU:
Did any one tried to flash gsi rom?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] xwizit:
Hey guys so just checking in-am i right in assuming there is no reliable stable root solution for the s10e HK variant?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Fznwolf:
What? It's plenty stable. I've been up over a week, without any problems.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] xwizit:
Oh I was either blind or tired, I just saw a lot of people saying they were having issues. Cool! I haven't rooted a phone since ummm the galaxy S3 haha. What do I lose if i root these days?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] hamstrman:
I didn't do my homework before I got my S10 a few days ago. I wasn't going to upgrade my S6 except the battery got swollen and the Sprint techs didn't want to stand near it.

So bummed to hear no one even anticipates a solution! Still appreciate what you guys do, but it sounds like I should trade this in for an S9.

Would anyone recommend just getting an S9? I'm already 4 gens behind.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] osn19:
You just have to disable AO Display and no issues
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] xwizit:
So with root, i lose google pay and stuff like that right?

Sorry for noob questions...back when i rooted phones, there was no nfc pay haha.

But i want to root because i hate the screen temp of the s10e! its too blue/green no matter what i try! root will allow me to tweak the screen temp right?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] znbaboy:
TWRP for hong kong device? (g9700 specifically)
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Fznwolf:
Word is there's builds around. Not official or anything like that, of course.