yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] salada2k:
Wow. This is awesome news.

Can someone please test:

Samsung Pay

Samsung Health

Google Pay

Netflix

Just want some confirmation Magisk Hide is working and Play Store reports 'certified device'

Thanks in advance!
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
it can happen sometimes when rebooting to loose magisk root(magisk uninstalled)

in this case i reboot and press power+bixby+vol up until screen warming and release all button to be sure to reboot magisk partition, and magisk come back.

i don't know what causing lost magisk maybe certain application using root or certain module magisk
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] PewPewK:
So I feel like I'm getting quite close to rooting my new Tab S5e given the information in this thread and a few others. It seems like the Tab S5e is in the same/similar spot as the S10 HK because they're both Samsung devices that shipped with Pie on Snapdragon processors. That said, I'm running into some problems and am wondering if they're unique to the S5e or if others here might have some guidance.

I generated the magisk_patched.tar using the latest [MENTION=7187684]ianmacd[/MENTION] Magisk and flashed it in Odin. After several failures with other patched versions of Magisk, this one finally worked and flashed without a failure! I then rebooted to Recovery, performed a data wipe, and tried to reboot with Power and Vol Up until the splash (the Tab S5e has no Bixby button) to boot the system with Magisk. Unfortunately, not matter how long I hold the Power and Vol Up buttons, I get thrown into regular recovery mode. And when I booted the tablet normally, obviously Magisk doesn't appear to be installed.

I think Magisk is installed, but I guess I'm not sure if I have a way to test? And it appears that I may not have a button combination that lets me get into "Magisk Boot."
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
i think this is application like kernel adiutor or mtweaks , changing cpu settings that causing me trouble
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
Really glad to hear that root is available. Thx everyone.

Not that I had any choice because my G9730 was on its way anyway... :D

Now I can move everything from my S6 with Titanium Backup without any problem if necessary. :)
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
my phone still restarts itself:confused: does anyone know why?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
do you use module or app that changing cpu settings? do you use greenify,xposed?

i remove all of that and no more problem restart.just at reboot need some time to boot in partition magisk by pressing power+bixby+volume up until warning screen
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
I used only this module and i unistal sdmaid..maybe don t restart i have 3 hours and no restart again...thanks
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] nsx2brz:
Did you try disabling com.samsung.android.securitylogagent, reflashing your boot loader, and rebooting, then installing the magisk apk?

I just got my Tab S5e last night and was going to attempt this...
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] the_dealer:
So will this work for the US SD variants without unlockable bootloader? There's too many damn variants of this phone to have a single forum
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Ndaoud360:
No. If U.S had unlocked bootloader then yes but it doesn't at the moment so no.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
finally it happens to me one time this evening too but don't know why
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] mains75:
So the only different thing from Exynos is the right firmware (of course) and use the Ian's Magisk manager to patch the AP file?

This procedure is good for any S10 (s10, s10e and s10 plus) HK?

THX
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] PewPewK:
Didn't try disabling that package, but got it working this morning. I had to keep checking in 7zip if there were any errors in the tar. Several times I tried to make the patched_magisk.tar there were random corruptions in different partitions. The last time I attempted the recovery.img was corrupt.

I have a working patched_magisk_lite.tar now that only includes the three Magisk-related partitions (boot.img, recovery.img, and vbmeta.img). When I flashed that this morning, I was able to boot with Magisk working.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
we need to find out, maybe someone knows how to help us
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
since yesterday it happen to me only one time.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Ndaoud360:
Happened a lot yesterday but denied root for an app I had and no reboots so far.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] NisseGurra:
Any twrp for s10e g9700 out?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] mains75:
I'm wondering the same thing.

Is it possible to have root and TWRP together on SD versions?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Fznwolf:
TWRP for our build was discussed and linked here: https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=79398042&postcount=159
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] NisseGurra:
Thanks, any G9700 version out?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Fznwolf:
[MENTION=3567583]rp4k[/MENTION] any update on this? Where did your friend find this TWRP build? What versions of the S10 does it work with?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Player04:
Man im quietly enjoying my rooted s10+
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
I followed the whole Magisk guide with my China SM-G9730 but I seem to have a problem.

After Factory reset and booting System with Magisk it takes so long to boot up. I just see the blinking "SAMSUNG" and nothing happens.

The flash with Odin was very fast so I don't think it was OK.

I flashed all the original files except the patched AP.

If anyone needs a firmware for his chinese S10 I can recommend samfrew.

Edit: It booted up for now but no Magisk Manager installed

Edit 2: Everything works. Just awesome. :)
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] osn19:
Could you please provide instructions on where to download files ? Thank you
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
There are too many reboots i think i will give up rooting :(
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Androsteron:
https://samfrew.com/

E.g. for Hong Kong S10:

https://samfrew.com/model/SM-G9730/region/TGY/
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] JeffG79:
Root for Snapdragon?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
at the first time rooting i has this problem too,but once i removed what causing reboot i have no more reboot.

i can't imagine leave without root now.

you need to identify what module or application causing reboot.

can you say all apllication using rooting and module you have installed.

---------- Post added at 08:01 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:59 AM ----------

yes snapdragron with bootloader unlocked has root now
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
here my list app using root without problem:

lspeed

battery charge limit

oandbackup

macrodroid

and screenshot of my module magisk
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
can i update it simply? maybe that would solve the restart problem..
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
Like Androsteron has told. For the China version you need the CHC region. Just pick the newest one and you are good to go.

Yes and it's very easy to obtain in my opinion. topjohnwo has a very easy tutorial. Maybe you can show some support with PayPal. :)

Never had any in two days. Everything just works like a charm. I haven't installed any modules because everything I need is in the basic software.

I'll maybe take a look at the modules in the next days.

Edit: I had two reboots now. Without any Magisk module.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
My module
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
yes sure
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] aldeamovil:
good,

in my g9700 HK I have had many restarts and I have left it again as it was until it is solved.

the firmware that I have is ASD4 with CSC TGY

the same thing I do something wrong because nothing else pass the AP patched by ODIN at the time of making the wipe data and restart in magisk mode it restarts and starts.

[MENTION=2613130]pixiebob[/MENTION]

Could you indicate how you did step 9 and 10 of the process?

to do the process from scratch is it necessary to go through ODIN all the firmware files or just with the AP is enough?

Thanks in advance
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
I did update but in the phone menu I no longer have system update:confused:
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
I have to tell you that it won't fix the reboot problem cause it restarted a few min ago on mine with the newest update.

I guess root browser is causing my reboots. I will do further tests.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Senaxo:
Hi, can someone make this TWRP for G9730 too?? That would be really nice. Many Thanks.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
[IMG="Phone Locked"]https://imgur.com/a/vbHEHr4[/IMG]

https://imgur.com/SMrXpR4

Hey everyone. I bought the phone and followed the guide exactly. After doing a factory reset and rebooting into recovery, I'm met with this message. It says my phone was locked due to me removing payment services without authorization.

I used imanacd's latest Magisk build and used the proper firmware.

Why did this happen, and how can I try again without bricking the device? I'm on the SM-G9750 most recent update.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
and I did this but I did it myself by closing the pay service ...... with dis disabler app lol I closed the phone about 5-6 times before I got into the disabler app and reactivated it,....lool
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
I would also really appreciate that.

I think that not much changes are needed but im not an android developer though. :eek:

Are there any new for the random reboots.

Anyone who is not experiencing them at all? It's kind of anoying because the phone is not reliable anymore. :(
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] osn19:
Same here :)
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
But how? It doesn't let me enter setup. Every time I boot, it pops up and I can't access anything.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Player04:
Tick tock tick tock. Man, i wish i bought an exynox version
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] NisseGurra:
There already root for the unlocked snapdragons, besides backup i don't see the that much need for twrp.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] AloxeCorton:
+1 for the random reboots on the HK version. It hasn't happened that often but I've nonetheless had about 3-4 of them since I rooted my phone with Magisk about 1 week ago with the first iteration of Ian's forked Magisk.

I have since updated Magisk but it doesn't seem to have changed things since I experienced yet another reboot earlier today. Empirically speaking, it seems to reboot mostly when the phone "wakes up" from the screen being inactive.

SO I imagine there is a cause & effect with installing Magisk on the Snapdragons. Anyone read about reboots with the Exynos based Galaxys?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
i don't have any reboot since more than one week. i don't use greenify,xposed,mtweaks,kernel adiutor and module magisk who modify cpu settings because those app causing me reboot. i always update magisk with ianmacd channel.

for those who have reboot problem, do you update magisk ? my actual version is:2019050301
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Can anyone please help with this? I've only seen this issue referenced one other place on the internet and it was for some s8 ROM.

How do I get back to stock so I can try again?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
you need to do a full installation of the firmware with odin.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Thanks, so just the original AP file I used to make the patched magisk tar file?

Could the firmware file I used be the reason for the issue I'm having? Do you have any idea why that could have happened?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
no flash stock firmware.

your issue is because you disable system service about payment and doing this lock your phone , i did same mistake at the beginning .
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Is stock firmware not just the AP file I get from samfirm?

Also, I didn't disable any payment system. I got this issue after a factory wipe while rooting.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
you can try only AP file but i'm not sure if it will working
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
How else would I flash stock firmware?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
yes it's preferable
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Can you PM me? I'm interested in learning more about this issue and how you handled it.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
sorry it's time for me to going sleep
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] AloxeCorton:
I don't use any of the apps you listed but I wasn't using the Ian magisk update channel directly from within Magisk.. I've changed that and will see if it makes a difference.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
you have time but just a few seconds you have to move fast
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
another app who can causing reboot is "one hand operation"

---------- Post added at 07:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:00 PM ----------

please report if it resolve reboot problem but normaly it will be good
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
and what apk we can use?lool
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
you can backup all your app+data with oandbackup , record your call good quality with skvalex, limit charge battery with battery charge limit, remap bixby with bixby button remapper(magisk), etc.....
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Yeah a few seconds, but I still need to go through the setup. It's not like I set up the phone then debloated and locked it. This happened after a factory wipe. It will show the setup screen for a second, then tell me it's locked in Chinese.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] dtowngs4g:
We're in need of a thread for snapdragon USA versions waiting room.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] NisseGurra:
You in for a LONG wait, most likely you will never get root.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
Exynos seem to be not affected.

I've experienced a reboot in the morning when alarm started. Another time I've started a bluetooth call in my car, which can't be a wake up case.

Next time I will pick some system logs.

I've installed a magisk module to remember bluetooth an youtube advance. But both after the first reboots.

---------- Post added at 08:19 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:07 PM ----------

When I choose ianmcds channel I can't update Magisk Manager or Magisk inside Magisk.

Do I need to repatch with Odin again?

Edit: I uninstalled the Magisk app and installed ians Magisk and now I have the newest version. thank you!
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] pixiebob:
no odin, choose for updating in magisk third choice "install directly"
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Edit: Never mind, we're good. I'm starting over. Which version of imanacd's Magisk should I use?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Can someone please do a video or complete guide for our version? The firmware is clearly different. I don't even have Google Play after going through this process and I have no idea what I'm doing wrong.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Ndaoud360:
OK I updated magisk and now I get random reboots which I thought I fixed by disabling some root apps.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
I installed the latest version here and from what I see no longer has trouble restarting:victory: https://github.com/ianmacd/MagiskBuilds/blob/master/MagiskManager-v7.1.3-2019050302-ianmacd.apk
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
That somehow didn't work.

I just uninstalled Magisk Manager and started from 14th step of topjohnwoos manual.

I just used the newest 2019050302.

Yep, I have the same like mentioned and seems quite stable.?

let's hope for the best at least. ?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Is not having any Google apps or Google play store normal? It doesn't even prompt me to input my Google account on setup. How do I restore apps and settings then?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] rp4k:
This sounds like you installed the Chinese firmware since we can't use Google here it isn't in the firmware. Download a different firmware
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Thanks for the response. I can do that? I have the Chinese version of the phone, can I just download the US firmeare and flash in Odin?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
How ist that possible?

I have imported mine from China and I def. have a chinese Version because everything was in Chinese on the initial start. Also you shouldn't install another region than intended. I guess it will give an error anyway.

I have all google apps and my baseband is G9730ZCU1ASC8.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
So you installed Chinese firmware while rooting and still had Google apps? How did you get the Google apps?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Can I just install US firmware since they both use the Snapdragon? If not, how the hell do I get a firmware version with Google apps?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] SuperBrolySSJ:
no, don't do that. instead, download Hong Kong firmware
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] rp4k:
Listen the hongkong version has Google because Google isn't banned in Hong Kong but if you have the Chinese version then you won't have Google. The easiest fix is to download the hongkong firmware to get Google.

---------- Post added at 06:30 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:27 AM ----------

Because you don't have a Chinese version you have Hong Kong version. And I am 100% sure . You don't know the difference between . 普通话。广东话。 because to everyone who doesn't speak Chinese can't tell the difference. So if you have Google then you have hk version
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
I think because of this mode it restarts the phone Yesterday I set up on optimized mode and did not restart my phone
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
Attention!

With Chinese Firmware youll get several problems. GApps is just one problem.

Depending on your decision on initial setup (use backup from old S10 device) you even won't be able to install google services.

(Edit)

*Also you'll have to use some kind of Baido apps which is an app store in China.

I've read that HongKong didn't agreee on that special Baidoo contract which is used in China.*

I used an obsolete Odin version. That's why the flash was so short.

Now I used the chinese Version and I am now trying to install the HK firmware with newly patched AP.

The hardware should be completely the same.

As far as I know my device seller installed a multilanguage Chinese firmware which I don't know how to get.

That mentiones multilanguage version GApps etc. .

---------- Post added at 11:58 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:57 AM ----------

You are totally right. But for me the problem was an obsolete Odin version which caused a wrong flash but still worked...
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Senaxo:
What's new?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] rp4k:
Most market sellers in China sell both the hk version and China version. Hardware and model numbers are the same so if you have the Chinese version with no gapps just flash the full hk firmware with the latest version of Odin.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Thanks I eventually figured all this out. Took a lot of trial and error since there's no clear instructions or support or anything for this version. I'm all rooted now and just experiencing a few bugs:

1) Reboots, same as everyone else. Happens every few hours. I just deleted some root apps so we'll see if it fixes it.

2) No AdBlock app is working. Tried adaway, DNS66, and Blokada. For some reason none of them work. Other root apps work so that shouldn't be the issue. Anyone else experience this?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
I use the lucky patcher to block ads and am happy :silly:
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
Interesting. Do you do that per app or is there one overall setting for it?
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ChrisChristian:
I make it for all applications, not everyone :silly: click on the block ads and you will see
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
I successfully flashed the HK version now. No Baido apps and all GApps.

I just wasn't aware how different the CHC region version was.

I could get the version with SamFirm btw.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] rp4k:
Chc version isn't restricted its just what's the point if the software doesn't work I China. In China all Google ip address are blocked by the government to promote there own major company Baidu. And Baidu is not spyware btw . It is just like Google. And between you and me since I actually live in China the use of Baidu data storage cloud service is way cheaper then anything I have ever seen. 5TB of cloud storage for 30usd a year. The only spy software/hardware that you need to watch out for in China is Huawei. They are the biggest contributors to that sector.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Paradoxxx:
AFAIK you can't even flash CHC on TGY due to the lack of FRP on CHC firmwares.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] rp4k:
You can flash whatever you want but it would be without FRP.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Paradoxxx:
My bootloader says I can't flash CHC cause of the lack of FRP.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] rp4k:
That must be a snapdragon problem idk I have exynos from Singapore. But you don't want chc flash tgy from hk
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Player04:
Im waiting so long that my ass is growing out roots
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] ferizzi726:
For what? It's out for the HK version. US version will likely never have root, so nothing to really wait for.
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] Sly123:
I've corrected my text.

I think it was kind of a prejudice... but blocking something to push another service is still restricting.

Most importan fact is that outside of China that firmware is a big problem when you flash it.

Btw when I install root browser I still get so much reboots. It's very obvious...

Just be aware cause thats one of the apps I use instantly.

What's your purpose? :)

You are just complaining but we have fully functional root.

TWRP is for flashing custom roms (which we don't have anyway), splash screens(mildly important), or doing backups which is useful when you use custom roms (see first point).
[Samsung Galaxy S10 Guides, News, & Discussion] mains75:
Any news on auto reboot issue? Is it fixed?