[Android Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting] Qui Peccavit:
Good day!

Since version 4.x of the Android mobile phone operating system, Google has removed the USB Mass Storage mode and replaced it with Picture Transfer Protocol (PTP) and Media Transfer Protocol (MTP). This means that the phone appears as a camera or scanner in Windows Explorer, without a drive letter, and that means that many file types cannot be copied to the phone, no new files created there, many PC based recovery and synchronization programs do not function properly, etc. The feature was removed to take control out of users' hands, because a lot of things would be a lot easier to achieve if one could access all directories and files on the phone from the PC -- a disk/hex editor is a powerful tool. Yes, some people bricked their devices by using them stupidly, but given all the locks and hurdles that manufacturers and carriers increasingly impose on customers who paid a huge sum of money for their little toys with every new version of the operating system, there is a clear tendency to see: milk consumers for all they are worth, but keep in control and decide what they are allowed to do.

To partially remedy the problem, most tutorials recommend to install a WebDAV server on the phone and map it as a network drive on the PC via Wi-Fi. Unfortunately, many of the more interesting operations need to be done before the phone is up and running, before software is installed and before a Wi-Fi network can be configured/established, and other operations can simply only be done via USB cable.

There is a company called Cranking Pixels that produces a PTP as well as an MTP driver for Windows, which bring back the drive letter for file-based (not sector based) operations. Unfortunately, there do not seem to be any recent versions floating around in the netherworld, and the price for the software is rather steep, especially when needing several copies. Therefore I would like to ask ...

a.) User experience

Does anybody have experience with the software and can say whether it offers sufficient bang for the buck to justify the expense? This means being able to access all folders & subfolders, create/copy/delete/edit/move all types of files from/to the phone and PC? Can system files be modified/patched so that certain flags that the phone system sets when detecting a rooted phone can be modified in a way that things like OTA updates, secure folders and banking applications still work?

b.) Similar programs

Is anyone aware of similar solutions that do the same or more but cost less?

c.) Alternative solutions

Are there other approaches that bring back Mass Storage USB mode to Android Oreo and Pie, be it flashed files for the phone, be it modified USB drivers for the computer or whatever?

Yes, phones can be rooted and so on, and so on, but it usually requires manual intervention to keep things running smoothly after every update and security patch. There are also many situations when being able to treat the phone like a mass storage device (external hard disk or USB stick) is simply more convenient and quicker or preferable for other reasons.

Any pointers and tips will be appreciated. Thank you for your attention and have a pleasant afternoon. :)