yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] 73sydney:
No one mentions what ROM they are using

fwiw Google Play works fine on My Note 4 with unofficial LOS 16 (Pie) :) and Magisk 18.1

Used it last 2 hours ago...

Google Pay never worked on the previous LOS 15.1 (Oreo) on ANY build/version of Magisk, it was a ROM issue.....only worked on stock ROM for the Note 4

So i got quite the surprise when i flashed Pie and it was workies....
[Magisk] henban89:
I am running on stock rom, my S8 is still running on Android 7.0 and as I said Gpay was working just fine until March 1. I thought about upgrading to latest stock rom with Android 9.0 but currently there isn't any instruction on how to root Android 9.0 on S8 yet.
[Magisk] JarlPenguin:
The new Google Play services update caused this.

﻿Temporary workaround:

1. Disable Google Pay/Find My Device as Device Administrators in Settings > Security & location > Device Administrators.

2. Search "Google Play services" in the Settings search bar.

3. Press the three dots and press "Uninstall previous updates".

4. Download this update - https://www.apkmirror.com/apk/google-inc/google-play-services/google-play-services-14-7-99-release/

Pick your needed edition (arm or arm64, etc.), download it and install it.

5. Disable Background data access for Google Play Services and Google Play in their respective App Info pages.

6. Download Google Pay from the Play Store.

7. Set up your cards. Enjoy!

Or

1. Upgrade to Magisk Canary by following steps here:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/dev-magisk-canary-channel-bleeding-edge-t3839337

Not recommended for daily use!

Never EVER update Google Play services manually, until a Magisk update is available that bypasses the upgraded SafetyNet. Note that Google Play services is responsible for adding/verifying the card, not the Google Pay app! Hence why there seems to be an overlay when adding a card/verifying an existing one.

Tested Google Pay versions:

2.79.x-2.83.235070858 - working

Tested Google Play services versions:

14.7.99 - working

14.8.49-15.0.10 - works on Magisk 18.2 Canary
[Magisk] kiner:
Thanks! I can use google pay again!
[Magisk] chriv:
Thank you and backing up and protecting backup of Google Play Services version

Thank you so much for this. Your instructions were followed to the letter and it worked. I had to use a terminal emulator, su, and "pm uninstall com.google.android.gms" to uninstall updates for Google Play Services for steps 2 & 3 on my OnePlus 6T.

Now that it's working I used Titanium Backup to backup this version of Google Play Services and protected the backup.

Again, thanks.
[Magisk] henban89:
Yeah, thanks it work though install older version of Google Play service didn't seen to helped which Google Pay wouldn't work at all without update Google Pay service to latest version. Even though I updated Google Play service to latest version my Google Pay work again somehow. For the time being Gpay seen to work again hopefully it will continue to work or at least long enough until I upgrade to S10 later this year.
[Magisk] anotherxdauser:
I don't have the three dots to uninstall Google Play Services updates.

OnePlus 3T, Resurrection Remix rom.
[Magisk] chriv:
Help w/ downgrading Google Play Services

If you have already disabled device admin for Google Play Services and Google Pay, you can downgrade Google Play Services like this:

1. Open a terminal emulator on your Android OR an adb shell on your PC connected to your Android.

2. Use "su" to root your shell.

3. Use "pm uninstall com.google.android.gms" to downgrade Google Play Services.

You can then proceed with the remaining steps.

---------- Post added at 10:04 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:56 AM ----------

While these steps worked for me, I'm having a problem with Google Play Services updating itself back to the newest version each night (even w/ background data services disabled for Play Services and for Pay).

Any advice on a way to prevent updates to Google Play Services until I want it updated?

If I open Google Pay without checking to see if Play Services is still downgraded to 14.7.99, I lose all my payment methods.

OnePlus 6T, stock rooted ROM, 2019 Jan Update, Magisk 18.1.
[Magisk] ilostmyandroid:
Worked for me, thanks for including the bit about version 14.7.99.
[Magisk] MatsyLR:
Thanks for the instructions but I just can't get this to do anything.

I have no dots so I have to use the above method.

Using terminal emulator I get errors about uninstall from pm command asks to ruin as user 1 but is calling from user 0 blah blah blah

Also the APK link has so many different options....any idea what would be the right one for note 4 910F?

Any help would be appricated, googling the error message I get no results.
[Magisk] chriv:
Only a guess

This is only a guess, but it sounds a little like Linux namespace separation might be related to the problem. Is Magisk your "su" program, or did you use something else to root?

My skills with some types of Linux security are limited, so I might not be any help.
[Magisk] MatsyLR:
Yes I am using magisk on Resurrection Remix Pie note 4.

The terminal has root access.

I've tried a few different things like manually uninstalling the Google play services and installing the one from the link but doesn't work.

I've tried other variants like pm uninstall --user 0 com.google.android.gms.apk but I always get the user 0 user 1 error

Full error is
[Magisk] 73sydney:
So today i finally hit the issue

Nothing short of removing gms via TWRP file manager, booting and installing (as a user app) the earlier build worked

Im assuming those with "three dots" are on stock ROMS?

Also pm uninstall com.google.android.gms just error-ed out as above

Hopefully the magisk folks figure out a far easier fix for this

Regardless i made a google pay purchase just an hour ago...
[Magisk] SoWhy:
Hit the same issue. I could fix it by disconnecting PayPal from GPay, blocking GPay as device administrator, hiding it and GPlay in Magisk hide and then reconnecting PayPal and re-activating contactless payments. It did not have to remove any GPlay Services Updates or anything.
[Magisk] Brianp48093:
My Verizon Wireless Pixel 2 starting giving the "can no longer be used in store" error whenever I use it in store point-of-sale or at my Bank of America ATM. The bootloader is unlocked (using the activation method) Fully stock Rom. I was running MAGISK 18, now I downgraded to Version 17.2. Same error.

After finding this thread, I concur that the Google Pay update is probably the culprit and that I am a dumba*s for installing it lol.

I just followed JarlPenguin's work around. I'm going to try it at my ATM later on today. I'll post back with an update. Hopefully, I'll be back up and running ?
[Magisk] jackulus:
+1 :)
[Magisk] Brianp48093:
Rebooted phone, its stuck on the G screen loading. Its been loading for 10 minutes. If i have to wipe, im going to smash this phone to pieces.
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Despite turning off background data for Google Play Services and Google Play, this morning Services is back to 15.0.90.....no idea if this has killed pay yet...nowhere near a shop to test today.....
[Magisk] Brianp48093:
Finally got it fixed.

After booting into safe mode, I was able to remove the downgraded version of play services and reinstall current version. Also deleted Google pay. Rebooted phone and it's fixed! WOOHOO! Icing on the cake? I followed SHOWWHY'S solution and it Worked!!!! THANK YOU!! Even though I didn't have PayPal linked, I followed the other steps and it works....even with newest play services installed. Just stopped by my ATM to test...good as new. Simple solution, Love it.
[Magisk] yung40oz84:
There's already a thread for Google pay and magisk... There's a fix there.
[Magisk] chriv:
I'm trying making the base apk, odex, art, and vdex files for com.google.android.gms (in /data/app) for 14.7.99 immutable and crossing my fingers.

---------- Post added at 08:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:42 PM ----------

If you are running as root, why does your prompt have a $ instead of a #? Did you forget to run "su" before running pm uninstall?
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Well this is weird, last i posted my gms had updated itself (despite me turning off background data) and i wasnt sure if pay would work...

Today i was out and about and tested, and made 2 purchases, no issues at all, all with latest gms and pay. Both disabled in magisk hide since i last purchased anything. Magisk 18.1 stable

So downgrading looks like its not exactly a fix for this....
[Magisk] y2whisper:
Tried the steps above and no go. I have even removed root before trying all the steps and still doesn't work, frustrating
[Magisk] bonfire62:
Downgraded and disabled using the above. Was able to add a card but at POS it's saying it can't be used in stores ?
[Magisk] TheDude1998:
Hey thanks alot, I was super confused, I figured something like this was going on but wasn't sure why the stable version of magisk was the same as the beta version when using magisk manager. Had no idea the canary builds page existed!
[Magisk] Lith02:
Hi guys. When trying to install Google Play Services, I got a message "App can't be installed". I also tried install GMS through ADB, but I got error: "Failure [INSTALL_FAILED_VERSION_DOWNGRADE]"
[Magisk] Chemacky:
Can you please provide a link? I can't find it.
[Magisk] yung40oz84:
https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/discussion-google-pay-magisk-discussion-t3906703/page23
[Magisk] macray76:
Followed advice on that thread and signed up to the Google Play Services beta. Updated Play Services to beta, Magisk hide GPay, Google Play, and Services Framework and my Google Pay now allows me to readd my cards - I will test an in-store purchase later today. No need to downgrade or anything.
[Magisk] shakad:
Yeh I tried that but it stopped working after a few hours
[Magisk] macray76:
I'll feedback if it stops working. I'd rather not mess about with downgrading etc...
[Magisk] Sudzi:
Hmm have same bug yesterday ... I have in magisk hide only gpay app.. then in magisk hide section searched "google" - and hide everything that showed up (except calendar photos etc..) and it worked .. LOS 15.1. Xiaomi MI5
[Magisk] mhrussell1:
I never saw or used the Magisk Hide menu to set anything and my GPay worked on my Pixel 3 with March vanilla Pie and ElementalX. I will try hiding GPay and GPlay and see if that fixes the problem.

Mark
[Magisk] Sudzi:
At 2pm it works and then at 6pm it doesnt .. when i want to add card again it doesnt work.. then i tick magisk core only and then it works again ?

I try it with magisk core and hidden google apps and will see .. last chance cos i feel like an idiot in shop ?
[Magisk] supertac:
I also having this issue just now....

This isn't working for me...stock rom galaxy A8 everything has been smooth since over had it until now
[Magisk] mhrussell1:
Yeah, the Magisk hide of GPay and GPlay did not solve the problem. Still no GPay at Subway.
[Magisk] wrecklesswun:
galaxy note 9 and essential ph-1 not rooted not working also
[Magisk] supertac:
Maybe magsik needs an update?
[Magisk] Sudzi:
Try hide gpay and g play services with magisk hide and with Magisk core only mode enabled (it will not load any modules) . I recommend to take card with you..

I'll bet that google are reading this thread ??
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Possibly all the proof you need it's Google's end doing all this....

Yesterday tried adding card, couldn't

This morning wiped cache on Google Play Store, Services, made sure they were hidden in Magisk Hide.

Rebooted

Able to add card..

2 hours later, got the following text from my bank:

Your card ending in 2280 linked to virtual account number 7014 was successfully removed from Google Pay. For more information, please contact us on 1800 290 869

Never even got close to a terminal to test it.....
[Magisk] backslashV:
Facing the same issue on my pixel 2xl.
[Magisk] paullaiuk:
Make Google pay work with Magisk

Delete the following folder data/data/com.google.android.gms
[Magisk] joeyddr:
all the fixes posted are temporary, I have tried them all and it will hit you again, google is doing something new.
[Magisk] lchiu7:
I found this information on a thread on another forum.

Just tried to Change my Update Channel in Magisk Manager to : "https://github.com/ianmacd/MagiskBuilds"

installed Manager 7.0.1 and flashed latest Magisk 18.2 build and finally its working with SafetyNet passed !

I removed Magisk and then downloaded the two components from here

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1wYpW-pAiWqFGIYdhC6FWpINZFqlmOOvb

Magisk 18.2 and Magisk Manager 7.01

I sideloaded Magisk Manager 7.01 and then changed the channel as noted above and the manager itself grabbed the 18.2 build.

After Google Pay worked again.

On another phone where I had TWRP installed, I just flashed the 18.2 and that also fixed the problem
[Magisk] Chokecherry:
I installed magisk from ianmacd, unfortunately gpay still does not work.:(
[Magisk] supertac:
Wouldn't an update to magisk solve the problem?

---------- Post added at 04:34 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:17 AM ----------

This worked for me!...but I wonder...for how long?
[Magisk] lchiu7:
I think the 18.2 release addresses the problem but it just hasn't been made generally available yet.

Flasking 18.2 using TWRP proves that. But on my other phone TWRP isn't installed so I had no way to flash from recovery.
[Magisk] Chokecherry:
I can add cards but I get an error when making a payment.

I've never had problems with safetynet.
[Magisk] mariusz1972:
Works for me fine.
[Magisk] Chokecherry:
have you already payed? I can add my PayPal card but when paying an error message appears.
[Magisk] Big_T71:
This worked for me too. Added PayPal to Google Pay and 20 minutes before, I paid in a supermarket, no problem :) com.google.android.gsm and com.google.android.gsm.unstable hidden in Magisk, no core mode, no file or folder renamed or deleted. Only added MagiskHide Props Config v3.0.3-v46. Lineage 14.1.

Yeah how long, we will see.
[Magisk] Tr4sHCr4fT:
yeah looks like the cat is infront of the mouse again for now
[Magisk] mariusz1972:
Yeep.
[Magisk] trimax84:
Maybe ymmv?

Is this the same 18.2 build?

Edit: grabbed the Ian version and still no luck for me. Patience is a virtue
[Magisk] backslashV:
Same here
[Magisk] Peter_File:
Did try that and it didn't work for me. Uninstalled the 7.01 manager in the app manager and reverted back to 18.1 via twrp (uninstall then flash 18.1).

Now if I try to install magisk manager I get the "app not installed" error. Tried all workarounds I found and can't find any remnants from the 7.01 manager. Any advice?
[Magisk] mariusz1972:
Hi. Flash the stock rom again via upper cut.
[Magisk] trimax84:
Running Pie on a rooted/bootloader unlocked Pixel 2. I don't think uppercut is for me
[Magisk] maksym_x:
I did it, hidden gms services, but now when I try to add a card (which was added to the account before) I got an error that gpay cannot complete adding of card to the account because phone might be rooted.

My phone is Xiaomi Mi 8
[Magisk] mariusz1972:
My mistake sorry.
[Magisk] krfoy:
Same here, Google Pixel 3.
[Magisk] logikor:
I had the same issue on my Xiaomi Mi 8 with the same Magisk version. For me it helps to delete (better rename into .bak) the following folder:

/data/data/com.google.android.gms

Restart the phone and I was able to contact GPay with PayPal. Next day paid with my phone.:):o:D
[Magisk] trimax84:
I was so hopeful, yet no such luck here! Thanks for the suggestion though. Think I'll be waiting for some more consistent fix ?
[Magisk] maksym_x:
just tried it yesterday and VOILA - became able to add card and paid with GPay in coffee shop :good:
[Magisk] giacomowrc:
Works like a charm. I've one plus 5t with stock ROM and magisk 18.1. I've paid with the phone.
[Magisk] joeyddr:
Just updated to magisk 19 cleared gms again added paypal card and was able to pay for now..... I also renamed the magisk manager package and added pay and gms to hide. Shall see how long this lasts.
[Magisk] MatsyLR:
Updated to Magisk 19 + updated Magisk Manager.

GPay has accepted my card, hopefully it pays.

Added GPay to hide, didn't do anything with gms
[Magisk] adamjmacdonald:
gms is already hidden by default in magisk 19
[Magisk] MatsyLR:
Ahhh

Under hide only com.google.android.gms.unstable is ticked, the rest are unticked.

Should the entire thing be hidden? (google play services)
[Magisk] adamjmacdonald:
com.google.android.gms should also be hidden, at least until we know more. Obviously if it's working and doesn't detect root / unlocked bootloader in a couple days then you don't need to hide it. Doesn't hurt much to hide both gms and gms.unstable IMO.
[Magisk] MatsyLR:
Will do, thanks :)
[Magisk] Tr4sHCr4fT:
any "measurements" yet how long it usually takes? i got back GPay just by clearing .gms and reauthing card while still beeing on v16-Zenfone2, but it didn't last long.
[Magisk] mhrussell1:
Got Magisk 19 and latest manager but still no luck getting GPay to work on Pixel 3. com....gms and com...gms.unstable are hidden in manager.
[Magisk] Mighty_Ahti:
Well, remove or rename folder com.google.android.gms did not work. Moreover I renamed it *.bak and after reboot it was gone.

For now, other bank has its own app so I'm using it instead gpay. Hope for fix though.
[Magisk] queerquirks:
Pay and magisk hide worked for 2 days when magisk got upgraded to Magisk v19 beta.

That was last Friday. Today Wednesday it failed again
[Magisk] toffee^god:
This is how I got it working may help others, I am on pixel 2 stock, bootloader unlocked, magisk v19

1. Unhide Google pay and services from magisk

2. Clear cache of Google pay and services

3. Reboot

3. Uninstall Google pay

4. Clear Google services cache

5. Reboot

6. Install Google pay

7. Hide Google pay and services in magisk

8. Reboot

I am not sure if all the step is necessary but it is how I got mine working again.

I have done this each time it has stopped working and it has worked again. I suspect the issue is caused when Google Pay / Play Store / Service is updated
[Magisk] ogrish666:
Magisk-v18.2-2019022802-ianmacd - this version works for me for couple weeks.

Edit : Downloaded from link in post by Ichiu7 on page 5.

I paid by phone (galaxy s7 edge with ultimate nougat by rifek4 and this version of magisk) 5 minutes ago :).
[Magisk] rxmeister:
Magisk 19.x (from beta channel) worked.
[Magisk] NICOMONI:
Many thanks, worked fine for me.
[Magisk] mkz14:
My banking app is not working for some days either.

Tried Magisk 18, 19 and multiple roms :'(
[Magisk] chimpman252:
I'm on LOS 16 on OnePlus 3T. I picked the appropriate build (arm64-v8a + armeabi-v7a, Android 9.0+, nodpi) and it just fails with "App not Installed". Tried various android version builds and dpi versions, same result. Already deleted the existing google play services updates per your instructions.
[Magisk] JarlPenguin:
If you get a higher version than 14.7.99 after uninstalling updates then it's not possible to downgrade, I'm afraid, unless you replace the system apk with your downgraded one.
[Magisk] vovean:
Not working again

Today my GPay stopped working again. It already happened to me in April, I solved it by updating Magisk to beta 19.0. Since then I haven't install anything. And today in the morning I got this message ("You can no longer pay...") again.

Does anyone have the same problem?

Google Play Service: 16.0.89

Google Pay: 2.85.239456103

Google Service Framework: 8.0.0-4147944
[Magisk] Brianp48093:
I factory reset my Pixel 2. It wont let me pay in stores. It says my phone is rooted/altered in some way. Not quite sure why it won't work again even with Magisk Removed and wiped clean. It works fine when I put the SIM inside another phone.

I give up.
[Magisk] anotherxdauser:
This is stupid.

Banking apps need a lower Magisk version as there's apparently been a bug in the later versions.

Google Pay needs the later magisk version because the earlier versions don't work properly.

6 months ago, all would work fine!
[Magisk] fbxdadev:
/data/data/com.google.android.gms deletion works, thank you!
[Magisk] NICOMONI:
I see some files with an interrogation sing, nothing else. Which one do you delete?
[Magisk] visitor29:
my problem is kind of related...

note 8 N950F oreo 8

problems started around march, Gpay stop work so i deleted/uninstalled magisk and i re added cards all works again....

but here is most interesting part----- fresh install stock latest android pie 9 and Gpay wont let me add cards (your phone rooted or security altered some other way etc etc..)

so i reverted back twrp restore custom oreo (but not rooted)

so this means i would be able to use stock anymore???!!!

---------- Post added at 05:16 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:11 AM ----------

welcome to my club :D

i have same, but with note 8

reinstall fresh/stock/with pit file etc etc through odin sever time pie 9 and gave up too

Gpay won't work
[Magisk] Paz9:
relock your bootloader.

---------- Post added at 04:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:43 PM ----------

this fix only works on 16.0.91 and below

as soon as 17.x is pushed out to more device this fix no longer works

i am on 16.0.91 and works fine

my phone automatically updated to 17.x google play services and this fix no longer works.

google is getting smarter.
[Magisk] akagi82:
What is the current status on Google Pay working or not working? As a sidenote, is netflix working for you guys?
[Magisk] fbxdadev:
Stopped working now
[Magisk] V0latyle:
Same here. I understand they may be trying to preserve security, but I really don't understand why they have to screw with us rooted folks.
[Magisk] ricixxx:
Still working for me, i updated the Magisk and it´s working with the latest version gpay and services on EDO ROM Rooted
[Magisk] edzamber:
Look here guys...

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-google-pay-gms-17-1-22-pie-t3929950/page15
[Magisk] QkiZMR:
Thx, this works for me.
[Magisk] ctzulu:
i just read through this thread! iam on rooted galaxy a71 ..

it was not working then i found a tutorial with TERMUX and somehow it worked for a week then again stopped working

so i can confirm TERMUX indeed helped - do you guys have knowledge about this and can somebody write a instruction i lost it
[OnePlus 3T Questions & Answers] nekomeow:
Hello, i wanna change my LCD, I looked up in some online stores and always find LCD with Frame and LCD with no Frame, What's the difference between those two?
[OnePlus 3T Questions & Answers] Shreeram02:
I just wanna say U may call it display instead

Its a oled not lcd
[OnePlus 3T Questions & Answers] aashutoshrc:
Get it with the frame

Get it with the frame. Don't buy only screen otherwise you'll have to do extra work like fixing and gumming the screen to the frame. Go for original amoled screen.
[Android Head-Units] sisu4ever:
Deleted
[Honor 7X  Questions & Answers] PBHJ001:
Notification after ending call:

1 call recorded

Saved to Dialler > More > Record Call. Touch to view

Can we stop this notification every time we end the call?
[Samsung Galaxy Note 8 Questions and Answers] pingufanpoy:
I might buy the note 8 but I'm wondering if the camera software uses noise reduction similar to the s9?

Is that noise reduction available in pie for the note 8 as a software update?

It's not a deal breaker for me if it's not included.

Btw can anyone share their experience with this device if it's worth getting still?
[Samsung Galaxy Note 8 Questions and Answers] Ace42:
The answer depends on: budget, needs, and price. If you're paying $400+ look elsewhere. I've owned my Note 8 for roughly 3wks and for the most part it's a fine device. However, I'd like something with more power, battery, and Band 71.

Initially I bought mine to get into digital art again, since a phone can fit in a pocket unlike a Surface or similar devices. From this angle I'm content even though it's weird to have this super elongated display. General performance on Oreo is snappy; no complaints.

Do you have any specific questions?