yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Xposed General] HorstiG:
Everything works great, no comparison to old times. Maybe it's just down to your phone? I don't have any problems with my Note9.
[Xposed General] drewcu:
Same.... Starting with magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.1.0 and continuing with 0.4.1.2, my LG V30 Stock Rooted Oreo has a ton of lag when you click on something. Just sits there for a second, then starts the action.

Last version without this lag is magisk-EdXposed-sandhook-v0.4.0.1_beta-SNAPSHOT-release.zip from https://www.lanzous.com/b642738.
[Xposed General] Reechings:
Tried installing EdXposedManager-org.meowcat.edxposed.manager-4.3.2-432-release.apk but it doesn't detect the sandhook framework even though it's working fine with installer.
[Xposed General] DanGLES3:
You need to remove the installer and reboot, edxposed will only allow one app to manage it at a time (for obvious reasons) if you have the installer installed then the manager won't be able to see or configure edxposed
[Xposed General] Reechings:
Thanks man, I had tried freezing installer but had to uninstall to get manager to take over.

Now, what modules have people tried with resource hooking?
[Xposed General] okij:
I also experienced lags with magisk-EdXposed-SandHook-v0.4.1.2_beta-release.zip and because of this I installed magisk-EdXposed-YAHFA-v0.4.1.2_beta-release.zip which fixed the lags. Also the boot process is quicker for me now.

This is kind of funny, because the SandHook version is supposed to be snappier than the YAHFA version. :laugh:

Please try the YAHFA version and report back if it fixes the lags for you too.

Edit: It seems to me that the battery consumption with the YAHFA version is noticable higher. Please have an eye on this as well.
[Xposed General] drewcu:
Tried the YAHFA version as well yesterday and it WAS less laggy than SandHook for me, but still had some lag relative to the v0.4.0.1 SNAPSHOT version.

Didn't do anything scientific to measure the lag time for the 3 different versions except the eye test and counting in Mississippi's lol. Clicked on different things within apps and observed which was fastest/most responsive, and also opened the CNN app and counted how long it took to finish loading. SNAPSHOT versions are snappiest for my LG V30 Oreo phone. Thought my phone had a virus when I first tried the 0.4.1.2 versions.
[Xposed General] Uraniam9:
It has been very long, will update thread tomorrow or day after Btw this thread is mentioned on EdXposed github page too
[Xposed General] Mikolaj612:
It might be that way, but for me YAHFA is out of my interest until it will be able to handle Gravity Box properly on my phone.

Until then I will use Sandhook option - but I hope they will fix those lags.
[Xposed General] drewcu:
Would suggest Gravitybox 8.5.3.1 edxposed edition https://github.com/GravityBox/GravityBox/releases/tag/v8.5.3.1-edxposed_o which works perfectly with magisk-EdXposed-sandhook-v0.4.0.1_beta-SNAPSHOT-release.zip from https://www.lanzous.com/b642738.

No lag, Gravitybox works on Oreo, and passes SafetyNet for both.
[Xposed General] Mikolaj612:
I'm already using it - I will also upgrade EdXposed later this day.

I hope they will fix those lags soon.

Indeed magisk-EdXposed-sandhook-v0.4.0.1_beta-SNAPSHOT-release.zip is stable and lag free on my LG G7.

I could recommend it for those with similiar issues to my and [MENTION=4469277]drewcu[/MENTION].
[Xposed General] C3C076:
Just FYI. If you already updated to EdXposed that has resource hooking support I recommend switching back to standard version of GravityBox (v8.5.3).

EdXposed version was created to overcome lacking resource hooking capabilities of earlier EdXposed versions.
[Xposed General] Damoedge:
What is the difference between the 2 installers anyway?

As far as I know meowcat is not the official installer/manager....or am I wrong?
[Xposed General] DanGLES3:
Manager has a built in downloader for edxposed and riru,other than that there aren't any major differences,for me installer is more stable
[Xposed General] j1gga84:
I am on Android 8.0 (Samsung) and using the latest EdXposed-sandhook but for me EdXposed Manager shows EdXposed Framework is not installed while in EdXposed Installer everything is fine :confused:

regards
[Xposed General] Mikolaj612:
Thank you for that information and clarification.

I just reverted back to regular version and it's working as it always was :)

---------- Post added at 10:26 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:21 AM ----------

Pick one of them (I recommend you to use manager instead of installer - looks more refined, while beign stable and bulletproof), uninstall second app, then restart your phone and it should work fine ;)

I think devs will leave EdXposed Installer in a favor of Manager - technically we don't need two apps doing same job.
[Xposed General] C3C076:
I found out something new that needs some attention.

If you use EdXposed v4.1.2_beta on Oreo (either YAHFA or Sandhook) and experience slowdowns it is due to a bug in resource hooking support.

Already reported here: https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/236
[Xposed General] Mikolaj612:
This is very important issue for me - yes I'm running stock Oreo on my LG G7 and I expierience enormous lag while sitting on newest EdXposed [0.4.1.2] reverting back to 0.4.0.1 or 0.3.1.8 solved my issue.

I didn't try new YAHFA but previous version give me serious issue when I enabled GB (black screen after my phone boot up).

Maybe I will try it out later.
[Xposed General] j1gga84:
Thanks, that worked :)

One last thing, when I go to Module Logs or Verbose Logs I only get an error message like "Cannot read log/data/user_de/0/org.meowcat.edxposed.manager/log/all.log (or /error.log) (Permission denied)

what could be the reason and how can I solve that?

regards
[Xposed General] spawnlives:
Check to see if the app has root permission in magisk.
[Xposed General] j1gga84:
I think that's the problem..

The app has no root permissions so how can I grant them manually because they are not asked when opening the app?

regards
[Xposed General] spawnlives:
For me it was just a matter of going into superuser menu in maagisk and allowing root access as it was in there but set to deny.
[Xposed General] DanGLES3:
Both manager and installer are made by different devs,so it's unlikely manager will ever replace the installer officially,also edxposed is planned to release on the magisk repo bundled with riru sometime in the future so the manager's built-in updater will become kinda pointless
[Xposed General] cahdawe:
I did. Sometimes, my banking app detects the root. I have to restart the phone and then the banking app working again.
[Xposed General] m.omdaa:
is there any working module that controls status bar icons and clock position with android pie??
[Xposed General] KChoudhry:
Anybody got any kind of whatsapp mod working? I tried Kmod, WA Extensions and WA Tweaker but none of them work. :( In 1st post it is mentioned that Whatsapp Extensions is working but it does not work for me. Or is there any particular process to follow to get it working??
[Xposed General] ctsuresh:
You can try "GB WhatsApp" search for it. :)
[Xposed General] KChoudhry:
I have used it but i want to stay on official
[Xposed General] davidt123456:
I am trying to install xposed and I followed the instructions on https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed

But the result is a prompt in Xposed Installer saying "Xposed Framework not installed" and "Xposed is not (yet) compatible with Adroid SDK version 28 or with architecture of your processor (arm64-v8a)" (I have samsung s9).

Am I doing everything correctly? As a noob, I would expect the necessity to install/flash the Xposed installation zip.
[Xposed General] methuntt:
Did you select any modules in xposed?
[Xposed General] davidt123456:
yes (XPrivacyLua), but it says "Xposed Framework not installed"
[Xposed General] fijasko:
Wrong thread. Go here: https://xdaforums.com/xposed/android-9-0-xposed-solutions-t3889513 and search the thread for Samsung. It doesn't work on any stock s9.
[Xposed General] krs360:
Anyone know of a network speed indicator module that's working?
[Xposed General] angelus_kun:
Disable flag secure works for me on 8.1 Miui 10 EU :)
[Xposed General] bggold:
Statusbar download progress does not actually work.
[Xposed General] KChoudhry:
WA Tweaker 1.2.3 PARTIALLY working for me on whatsapp 2.19.17 but not on Whatsapp 2.18.380! Good to see an official whatsapp mod working on pie :)
[Xposed General] ctsuresh:
Hi, can someone help me?

Struck in bootloop, don't know what module causes this?

Can i flash exposed uninstaller? will it work?
[Xposed General] SerikKr:
https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/module-tool-magisk-manager-recovery-mode-t3693165/amp/

Flash wia recovery, then remove riru modules and boot to system. Delete xposed modules, activate riru in magisk and reboot. Profit.

P. S.

After flash mm go to recovery advanced, terminal and write:data/media/mm

Then select "e"

Then write: riru_edxposed and 2 space. Then reboot to system.
[Xposed General] PianoMonkey:
XInsta not working for me on Instagram V74

Running on latest weekly Xiaomi.EU MIUI
[Xposed General] Super_SU01:
I'm with ya on that. My main mods I like using is flat line, gravity box, if those don't work then I'll stay on Oreo.
[Xposed General] estapagu:
Magnet control sensor works
[Xposed General] ayush.gl:
How to disable that?
[Xposed General] pratyush28:
What version of edxposed are you currently running? Also by partially working you mean that only few xposed tweaks are working? If so could you test whether hide typing and blue ticks are working? Thanks in advance.
[Xposed General] KChoudhry:
Nope, i noticed that only root mods are working like changes with the gifs ui and all xposed ones are not working
[Xposed General] @srmahunt:
Blacklist the banking app.

Oneplus 5 Stock OOS
[Xposed General] Reechings:
Where do you get standard edition for P or were you talking about Oreo?
[Xposed General] C3C076:
Yes. v8 is Oreo. Pie is v9.
[Xposed General] cahdawe:
I did that too. But it doesnt resolve my problem
[Xposed General] carrsteven:
FSBI is working on the latest beta of EdXposed on my Pixel 3XL. Works with both the notch turned on and off. Have to do a little tweaking to get the Left-Left icons out of the notch itself though. The only issue I've found is the icons don't change color. If the statusbar turns white in an app, you can't see them.
[Xposed General] gebn:
Flat Style Colored Keyboard not working on the latest EdXposed 0.4.1.2 on Pie, tried both hooks

Just results in a Systemui crash loop when you open the keyboard
[Xposed General] sachin karinki:
Anyone Please confirm that Advanced Data Plan is working for Pie or Not
[Xposed General] HorstiG:
Everything works on the Note 9, only the Notifications icons do not disappear after deleting.
[Xposed General] ming86:
Greenify with EdXposed white list mode, need to white list Android System.
[Xposed General] j1gga84:
that does not work for me.. :(

I granted root access because it was asked when I clicked on the 3-dots in the upper right corner and choose reboot but after the reboot the error in the logs remain..

I guess it just does not work very well with android 8.0 on samsung devices.

regards
[Xposed General] Komekokos:
There is a new version of Edxposed Manager, v. 4.4.1, really nice update with all type of details such as changelogs.
[Xposed General] francyesco:
Link pls

What you mean whit edxposed manager

Magisk manager

Edxposed installer

Edxposed (magisk module)
[Xposed General] Komekokos:
EdXposed Manager https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposedManager/releases

I suppose that you have EdXposed Installer to manage the modules but Edxposed Manager is better than EdXposed Installer because is more updated with a lot of features, so you can change it, firstly uninstall Edxposed Installer and reboot, secondly install EdXposed Manager and reboot, done.
[Xposed General] VincentJoshuaET:
I really want to use EdXposed Manager but I get the modules.list was not found error and not all of my modules work when there are no issues in EdXposed Installer. Already tried everything with clean installs
[Xposed General] DanGLES3:
Edxposed manager also has a weird bug with the white/blacklist feature where any changes made to it won't get applied until a full reboot (adding/removing apps from it),while with the installer any changes to the white/blacklist get applied immediately and only require the app you added in the black/whitelist to be closed and reopened
[Xposed General] hurray:
Thank you for mentioning the new update of the EdXposed Manager.

Sadly it is not working correctly at my Galaxy TabS2 under Oreo:

the system slows down a lot and the manager itself don't start if I try to open the app.

I was going back to version 4.3.2 and everything is running well again.
[Xposed General] Stogie87:
Wow, the SandHook version is really much faster than the older build on my Havoc OS Rom for 6T. Amazing! Thanks to the dev's for it!
[Xposed General] DanGLES3:
Indeed,sandhook is quite faster than YAHFA (the original edxposed backend), congratulations to the dev behind Sandhook (ganyao114) and the Edxposed devs
[Xposed General] Adriano-A3:
Thanks to Sandhook method Flat Style Status Bar Indicator is working like a charm.

Setup:

- Pocophone F1 runing OOS 9.0.12

- FSBI 5.1.3 (app)

- EdXposed Manager 4.4.1 (app)

- Magisk 19.1

- Riru 18 (magisk)

- EdXposed 0.4.1.2_beta (magisk)
[Xposed General] CyanWoods:
still some bug of fsbi：

a vpn indicator which can not hide.

Position error (the left position of right status bar have some issues.

Doesn't display the alarm indicator.

Well, everything else works fine right now. Hope for an update to fix these bugs.
[Xposed General] Stogie87:
Yes man! It is so awesome, that FSBI is finally working. Thanks for the information.
[Xposed General] halotr:
i need inspeckage
[Xposed General] Damoedge:
Battery shutdown manager does not work...used to be a great module for calibrating the phone battery...

So you can add that to the list of not working modules.

?
[Xposed General] MarJava:
is good
[Xposed General] panda822:
True!
[Xposed General] dr4go:
EdXposed Manager vs EdXposed Installer

I used soloshu's EdXposed Installer for a few weeks without any issue, then realized / heard that there also was the EdXposed Manager, was fooled by the higher version number and just have to state one thing: I agree with everybody quoted, that the Installer is far more stable and superior in any way to the Manager.

Don't really know why some of you are still promoting to use the EdXposed Manager if it simply doesn't work reliably... as soon as you update a module you may be ****ed, because you may need to untick/tick the module again and what's more I additionally got two crashes during boot, because of the Manager. No way I will use that thing ever again.
[Xposed General] DACATA:
Issue with busybox 1.30.1 after edxposed modul Autoupdate. Need to reinstall it after reboot

OP5 - OOS 9.05
[Xposed General] ctsuresh:
Hi, in magisk saftey net failed saying API error. If I delete Edxposed module then it is passing. Someone please help.

Also, if Edxposed module is enabled I cannot find magisk app in system setting to clear data and cache.

Pl help.
[Xposed General] jaggillararla:
Hey man u need no device check
[Xposed General] Komekokos:
Hi to all, there is a new update of Magisk Core Riru module, version 19, which supports Android Q Beta 3 now, Magisk 19+ is required, I have flashed Riru Core v19 from Magisk, all working fine.

https://github.com/RikkaApps/Riru/releases
[Xposed General] Komekokos:
And another version of Edxposed Manager is ready, version 4.4.4 with all these changes. I know that some people report bugs with Edxposed Manager but at least in my case is stable, installed without any problem.

https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposedManager/releases
[Xposed General] hurray:
Thank you for the information. I just tried the new version and for now it seems that it runs better than the last version. I will try it for a few days and will have a look how it behaves over time.
[Xposed General] ctsuresh:
Hope you are talking about exposed repo "No Device Check"

If yes, I tired it's not working. Same API error.
[Xposed General] PokemonTotalWar:
Can this be used with the SandHook version or do you need to use the 17.1 packaged with the SandHook release
[Xposed General] Komekokos:
Of course, you can update Magisk Core Riru to the last versión 19 with Sandhook o yahfa edxposed modules, at least in its final versions, I have magisk core Riru v.19 and magisk edxposed sandhook 4.1.2 on android 9 and all working fine
[Xposed General] buddy66:
Flat Style Bar Indicators is working with the newest EdXposed Sandhook version! This was the last module I was waiting for. Now the standard icons are finally gone :victory::victory::victory:
[Xposed General] Komekokos:
Hi guys, do you remember Youtube AdAway by wanam? It was an awesome module of xposed to avoid ads in youtube, well, today has appeared a module in its initial version called "NoAds for youtube" in the repository of xposed that has been developed by a developer from that module of wanam.

And good news, I have been testing it for two hours and really does everything that promises, It's incredibly good because remove all ads including ads during video playback! , congrats and thanks to the developer, great work.

Here you can find the module, In my case is tremendously effective, install it if you want under your responsibility.

https://repo.xposed.info/module/com.wovow.noads
[Xposed General] RoyanArt:
but, Youtube vanced is better
[Xposed General] Komekokos:
Obviously youtube vanced is better because is an app all in one (no ads (maybe a bit ) + background player), but this module is great if someone want another option :svetius:
[Xposed General] VincentJoshuaET:
There's also an Xposed module that enabled background playback, right? Is there one working for the latest YouTube version?
[Xposed General] CapnShitzhu:
Anyone got Flat Style Colored Bars working? For me everytime I launch a chromium browser the System UI crashes and I have to unlock phone. After that it would work fine but the repeated System UI crashes kind of compels me to remove it.

BTW I'm on a Oneplus 5 Pie running riru core v19 with Edxposed 4.1.2 sandhook version. Did anyone else got this working?
[Xposed General] n0j0e:
5T with OxygenOS beta 28, Riru v19 & EdXposed 0.4.1.2 SandHook. Nearly no problems with FSBI. Some double symbols but these can be disabled in Settings > Display > ... > Symbol-Manager. DND symbols wrong.

Sent with much love & Android. OnePlus 5T
[Xposed General] spica1234:
Can anybody explain what is "Compat Mode"?

Thanks in advance.
[Xposed General] shadowstep:
There may be an app that starts crashing after installing EdXposed. You can try selecting that app in the "Compat Mode" and rebooting, which will enable compatibility for that app and might stop the app from crashing with EdXposed.
[Xposed General] nickelnine:
Blacklist System UI
[Xposed General] spica1234:
Okay, thanks

So you mean that perticular app in Compat Mode and not the module which work for that app, right?
[Xposed General] ctsuresh:
Hi guys please help.

Is it common that magisk manager app will be hidden in system if Edxposed is active?

Becausey safetynet shows API error so i thought to clear cache and data but I could not find the app in system setting.

Again deactive the Edxposed, magisk manager is available in system setting. Pl confirm
[Xposed General] Komekokos:
Now Riru Core is part of the repository of Magisk, so it will be easier update it.
[Xposed General] DanGLES3:
Yes, and it seems Edxposed will soon be on the repo as well,the Edxposed dev apparently was just waiting for Riru to be compatible with magisk 19 (that's what I've got from the telegram chat)
[Xposed General] KaMyKaSii:
Right. If you want to block a specific app from being hooked by any module, you should mark the app in question on the blacklist

Edit: I misunderstood your question, sorry
[Xposed General] W3sL:
Can you share the link of the telegram chat.

Tnx
[Xposed General] shadowstep:
Yes, that is what I gather, but I can be wrong. There's no clear documentation available.
[Xposed General] dr4go:
https://t.me/EdXposed
[Xposed General] spica1234:
Okay, thank you:)
[Xposed General] culiacanazo:
Hey senior member, look at my quote of you ;)
[Xposed General] CapnShitzhu:
Is the blacklisting function available on Edxposed Installer? Or is this specific to Edxposed manager. Apologies for the noob questions
[Xposed General] nickelnine:
Never used the manager but installer for sure.
[Xposed General] soulreaver13mejia:
Flat Style Colored Keyboard, does not work?

---------- Post added at 08:21 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:46 PM ----------

It does not change to black color in white status bar.
[Xposed General] MagnoT:
No luck with Honor 10 EMUI 9.0. EdXposed causes bootloop.
[Xposed General] @srmahunt:
The YAHFA version is in the repository now, no sandhook version yet.

Oneplus 5 Stock OOS
[Xposed General] beeshyams:
Sandhook version is now in Magisk modules list
[Xposed General] BHUSHAN7988:
But it's wierd I have sandhook it's showing yhafa
[Xposed General] beeshyams:
Possibly, this is the reason - you can have only of them working either YAHFA or Sandhook, so it shows what you don't have. My case is the opposite, I have YAHFA and Sandhook shows up. Maybe, when there is an update, it will show. My guess
[Xposed General] BHUSHAN7988:
I deleted the module rebooted then installed from magisk repo again rebooted and it's ok now
[Xposed General] Mikolaj612:
New version of EdXposed is available via Manager or directly on GitHub :)
[Xposed General] Komekokos:
In alpha test, be careful
[Xposed General] Reechings:
So what's the easiest way to recover if an Xposed module gives you a bootloop? Before you used to be able to press a bunch of buttons when you reboot. Is edxposed uninstaller zip the only way or can we just disable modules temporarily?
[Xposed General] mnrivera210:
Sandhook variant caused my 3XL to boot loop, YAHFA works fine tho.
[Xposed General] DvLAx3l:
On my 3XL may update sandhook variant works perfectly
[Xposed General] tillward:
You can use flash the Magisk Uninmod zip to remove the EdExposed Magisk module in recovery.

I'll try and find a link.
[Xposed General] HorstiG:
Works great on Note 9, thanks.
[Xposed General] Reechings:
Yeah I was just curious if there was a way to disable Xposed modules without messing with magisk at all.
[Xposed General] KaMyKaSii:
Just go to TWRP file manager and delete the Xposed module folder in question located on /data/app/package_name_from_the_conflicting_module
[Xposed General] Johnn78:
https://www.google.com/amp/s/xdaforums.com/xposed/howto-disable-xposed-modules-via-t3227175/amp/
[Xposed General] Reechings:
Cool I used to do it that way but wasn't sure if it still worked with edxposed.
[Xposed General] BHUSHAN7988:
I found it here

Enabled modules.xml make a copy of it then edit the values inside and then when needed replace it
[Xposed General] @srmahunt:
Any new mods working with the alpha version??

Oneplus 5 Stock OOS
[Xposed General] Komekokos:
Maybe this was the problem
[Xposed General] mnrivera210:
Perhaps, even after reloading the factory image without wiping it would loop. Only YAHFA works for the moment.

I'm thinking it may be a module.
[Xposed General] Johnn78:
I know that it works for Xposed but I am not sure about Edxposed.
[Xposed General] @srmahunt:
Safety net fails on the new alpha version of edxposed yahfa. Any workaround??

Oneplus 5 Stock OOS
[Xposed General] niphoet:
Same for me on Sandhook
[Xposed General] urbanman2004:
So what version of Xposed Framework is recommended to install on Android Pie w/o soft bricking my device, the Pocophone F1? I'm rooted by way of Magisk with the latest version of Lineage OS. Thanks
[Xposed General] n0j0e:
Mhh, 5T with OxygenOS beta 30 no problems with Riru Core v19 & Sandhooks 0.4.1.2 beta!

OK, checked twice and Sandhooks 0.4.2.3 alpha fails SafetyNet!

Sent with much love & Android. OnePlus 5T
[Xposed General] V-Droid:
So it appears that safety net issue is regarding alpha version of exposed, I'm using the latest beta and everything is working fine