[Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 Pro Guides, News, & Discussion] abhinavtk1:
Hello XDA. In this thread I would like to consolidate ROM reviews and bugs for most of the ROMs of whyred. The pros and cons of each ROM will be discussed and it will be useful for many to select a ROM that best suits their needs.

Pixel Experience

Last Updated : December 5

Thread : https://xdaforums.com/redmi-note-5-pro/development/rom-pixel-experience-t3830197

The ROM is based on AOSP and tries to bring most of the features of the original Pixel into our beloved whyred.

Last Changelog

December security patch

Derp kernel 3.9

Improved power button sensitivity

Improved led

Fixed full screen when watching videos on Chrome

Fixed animations

Add support for huaxing panel

Features

Stock Pixel experience

Mi A2 camera included

Minimal customisation

GCam working perfectly after enabling Camera2api

No major bugs

Please comment more features.....

PE Extended

The ROM is actually based on Pixel Experience, where additional customisation is added for power users

Last Updated : October 21

Thread : https://xdaforums.com/redmi-note-5-pro/development/rom-pe-extended-t3837709

Clean Flash required

Last Changelog

Fixed networks drops

Fixed dual 4g

Fixed gcam front cam

Derp 3.3

Send pixel 3 camera prebuilt

October security patch

Add ambient play (Pixel's now playing)

P E Upstream

Redo statusbar battery implementation , fixes the gap

Remove useless power menu stuff

Add Extended restart

Make roaming indicator optional

Allow users to switch between Pie/Oreo recents

Allow users to switch between Grid / Android GO style recents

Slow down the spinners

Add support for multiple displays.

SystemUI: Fix crash when taking screenshot in partial screenshot view

storage: Set all sdcards to visible

Fix notification shows wrong question

base: show bluetooth battery status when available

Allow to suppress notifications sound/vibration if screen is On

base: Lockscreen Date Fonts

base: Lockscreen owner font text

fix reorder of mobile slots

Base: fix facelock crash when lock screen is disabled

Rework auto brightness implementation

Add buttons beside brightness slider

base: allow hiding lockscreen shortcuts on secure lockscreen

base: hide indicator text

base: hide lock screen icon

Add volume up/down tones back

Delay blanking of displays to improve performance

Add auto brightness icon to Quick Settings

Disable Quick Settings on secure lockscreen

Add option to disable auto brightness icon in brightness slider

Add Quick Settings Pulldown options

Return Smart Pulldown

Fix Goodix reset

FWB: Sensor block per-package

Performance / battery / memory improvements

More stuff that i dont remember

Features

Lots of customisation options

Omni themes

Google Camera and Mi A2 camera already present in ROM

No major bugs

Some users complain about encryption not working

Please comment more features....

Mi A2 Stock Port

This ROM is the port of the stock Android One ROM from Mi A2. The ROM is super stable with only minor bugs, that you won't notice everyday. The developer is super responsible and cares a lot about the ROM users. Major bugs that was present at the beginning like fingerprint on goodix and Bluetooth issues are now fixed. In my experience, the ROM feels smoother than other Pie roms that I have tested till now. But since it is pure Android One, there are no customisations available now. The developer has promised customisations in the next builds.

Last updated : December 7

Thread : https://xdaforums.com/redmi-note-5-pro/development/rom-android-one-pie-9-port-wbt-t3873695

Last Changelog

Add FM Radio stuff

Update kernel 4.4.166 -Rebirth-v2.4

Features

Stock Android One

Super smooth

Stock experience with minimal customisation

Humble developer

Major bugs are fixed

Please comment more features....

Bugs

MTP sometimes don't connect. (Workaround present in ROM thread)

Dark theme. (Workaround present in ROM thread)

Please comment if there are more bugs....

More ROMs will be added in the future

Feel free to comment your opinions on ROMs

They will also be included in the post