yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Dovahkiin1290:
Anyone else having bootloops with the latest build when using Magisk? It happens quite randomly tho'. Sometimes all goes well, but when i restart the phone the bootloop appears. Tried uninstalling magisk, nothing changes. Wipe System/Cache then flashing again (Without Magisk) doesn't work either. Only when i do a full wipe (Cache, Data, System) i'm able to use the phone again. Other times all works well but Magisk uninstall by itself. Pretty weird. I'm using the latest stable version of Magisk but for now i give up with that.

I barely use any module in the app. Just Youtube Vanced and some apps that requires root (Titanium Backup, Kernel Adiutor, Substratum)
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
Dunno - I see there is a 19.0 and a 3.5.1 hidepropsconf and a 7.1.1 out, none of which i have - I'll go do them, but I would guess aduitor and/or substratum to be your prob.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
I am very often getting boot forever no matter what way I flash it.

And if it does boot after flashing magisk, I have no cell connection, only wifi.

I have no idea why I can't now and why I could at the beginning of mar.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] cobolmx:
I had the same issue infinite bootloop i had to change to another rom meanwhile this fixed
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Dovahkiin1290:
Well, probably substratum now that you mention it. It touches a lot of files, so i'd better keep away from it atm. Flashed again, no modules. BUT i did install Kernel Adiutor. I haven't rebooted the phone so far, but if the bootloop appears again i'll get rid of everything. If the issue continues without modules i guess i'll have to live without magisk (?)

---------- Post added at 03:18 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:13 AM ----------

Yeah. Exactly my issue. At first all went pretty well for a couple of days, the phone behavior was normal with Substratum, some other modules and Kernel Adiutor. And after the first bootloop happened things went all wrong since then. I even tried older versions of magisk, mayba it was some issue with the latest update (Stable 18.1) but it didn't work either

What's the other rom are you using?
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Jos_Hdez22:
I've been reporting these bootloops for some time, the only temporary solution I found was to flash or install a different version of busybox using the app.

But as you say, it works a couple of days and after several restarts the problem reappears.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] fablebreton:
I don't use magisk at all, so no bootloop for me.

If i understand well the last posts ( ? ) you have sometimes bootloop With magisk 18.1 . And magisk 19 doesn't at all , That's right ?

i have read there is huge changes in magisk 19 and it's still in beta, so better to wait.

Would be interesting to know if you have same bootloop with magisk 18.1 on lineage 16 (since i build it with the exact same Kernel as Aosip) and on Alberto aosp.

also may be it can help :

magisk wiki on bootloop : https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskIssues

magisk support thread https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
People who are having a prob that you are calling a "bootloop" please clarify

1)whether it tries to boot over and over (you keep seeing the motorola logo over and over), or

2)whether it is an infinitely long boot - where it starts to boot and never ends and has to be manually stopped with the power button.

Thanks!
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Jos_Hdez22:
In my case I mean the first thing, the phone tries to boot over and over. (in fact, sounds are heard when the phone is placed close to the ear while it is booting, like small and very light clicks and a fairly long sound like interference)
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Subhransu90:
Please support Moto cam in next update..it's not showing in playstore
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] cobolmx:
Albertos Pie - so far no issues, only I miss some customizations but is ok

---------- Post added at 06:27 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:25 PM ----------

Also I want to remark I had the same bootloops with out magisk
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] avirupz:
I faced the infinitely long boot with magisk but not with the first boot, first boot seems good but if I try to restart the phone again I faced the infinite long boot and then have to uninstall the magisk through twrp. And then it works normally.

sometimes also the magisk uninstall don't work,have to clean install the rom only works.

May be the issue is with the kernel because before this kernel everything was good.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Rashad79:
[MENTION=7834999]fablebreton[/MENTION]

I have faced the bootloop issue in Alberto AOSP as AOSIP " Very long booting with android logo then rebooting to TWRP ", attached the logs from Alberto ROM. Please help.

P.S. I didn't use any rooting tools at all, also i reported the issue to Alberto.

Thanks

Thanks
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
How long is "very long booting"? 5 min? 20min? Thanks.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Rashad79:
I think 2 minutes. The normal time of booting with a stable build is not more than 15 seconds.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
Yep, more than fair.

I just flashed 0306 rom and 0403 opengapps nano.

At desktop always get "finish setting up" which just repeats a lot of the initial setup.

lately:checking for updates, installing updates (BIG)

repeat ask about lock

repeat ask about assistant

Says 2 updates avail: google (44MB), device health svcs: I update all.

I let it sit doing nothing for 1 min. to assure that google isn't updating itself behind the scenes.

Boot to Recovery (voldn-pwr)

reboot rom: reboot/system

infinite boot: at 1 min I press voldn-pwr and go back to recovery and copy logs below.

Note, there was no modification whatsoever other than the 2 updates..

The 2 sets of logs are starkly similar

stops processing at 8sec

looks for Bus Access Mgr at 20sec

Can't find TikTok

28sec avc testing SELinux

after 28sec it is doing nothing.

I am currently on aosp32 pie 0309 and just noticed that I hadn't taken the big google update so thought that might be the prob, but took it and rebooted a couple times fine (I have magisk and hide props on this build).
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Dovahkiin1290:
Well, this is weird. Flashed all over again like i said last night. Installed Magisk 19b (Again). Rebooted twice. So far? No bootloops. I don't know what's happening. It seems to be some weird random problem in this device. To be clear i haven't installed any module that affects the device performance or visual style (Substratum), just Vanced Youtube. This time i'm using Kernel Adiutor too, the only difference is that i didn't setup the app to apply changes on boot. Who knows, maybe that triggers something too. I'm going to leave all like it is. At least i can use Titanium and other apps that ask for root permision.

Last time i tried Magisk 19 (Still in beta) i had the same bootloop that i had when using 18.1 , 18.0 and 17.x (Can't remember the exact version).

If anyone wanna try i did it like this: Wipe Data/System/Cache. Flashed AOSiP, clear Dalvik/Cache -> Flashed Gapps, Clear D/C -> Flashed Stericson's Busybox, Clear D/C -> Flashed Magisk 19.0, Clear D/C - Reboot

Anyway, if somethings happens i'll update again.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Jos_Hdez22:
Which app to apply changes on boot? ?
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Dovahkiin1290:
Kernel Adiutor. It has an option to "Apply on Boot", usually to start the device with some changes in the Kernel (Governor and other advanced options)

---------- Post added at 01:15 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:09 AM ----------

Yeah, that's another problem that i didn't adress. The uninstaller doesn't work and it seems to f*** up the system because the next boot shows an error warning (I don't remember what it says) and the only solution is wipe EVERYTHING to start all over.

---------- Post added at 01:17 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:15 AM ----------

Yeah, i'm thinking on trying that one if i face the same issue now that i've reinstalled everything. I'm going to miss the extra features on AOSiP tho' :crying:

---------- Post added at 01:22 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:17 AM ----------

Well, i didn't tried any other rom yet. I've unlocked the device two weeks ago and this was the first (And so far only) rom that i've used.

About the Magisk 19b i'm using it right now, after a fresh install and, so far, no problems. But again, Magisk 18.1 (Stable) worked well at first and then...well you know. (Although i'm not using any advanced module, just Youtube Vanced, who knows)
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
yes, something has changed. I just flashed 0306 aosip and an 0405 opengapps nano and it rebooted fine. However when I flashed magisk 19.0 it did not. So I went back and flashed 0306, gapps, AND magisk 19.0, THEN it rebooted fine

I think this has something to do with opengapps, AND the gapps modules that are included in the ROM - I suspect that is different between aosip and aosp, though I haven't checked - would have to look at both install logs which are in the respective folder on your phone where you did the flash.

Anyway I'm back up on aosip with maigsk, hideprops, and pogo works.

The squirelyness that it was showing yesterday - like no cell data after magisk flash - is gone.

We need to find out what is causing the differences and fussiness during install.

An alternate pie gapps to opengapps would be nice to try... but I can't find any.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] avirupz:
yes I too think gapps are the issue. Because when the rom build was 64bit i mainly use bit gapps and there was no problem. But with 32bit there are only open gapps available.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
That's true - we didn't see any infinite boots on 64bit as I recall. I suppose I could try Pico and see if it makes a difference... (I use nano)
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] avirupz:
Try. but i tried aroma to pico all and same result.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Dovahkiin1290:
I've been using Pico since the beginning and the bootloops were there.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
Many thanks for the Pico test info!
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Jos_Hdez22:
If you use magiskhide props go to "Script settings" and change the boot stage to post-fs-data, it seems to work until now to solve the bootloops.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] cobolmx:
I was suspecting that opengapps have something with the bootloop, to me the only gapps that worked is aroma, the other variant do not work
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
null
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Rashad79:
Regarding the above issue, the phone rebooted to the twrp 5 times and in the 6th time the phone start normally without any intervention or trying any solution!!

I tried to reboot it after that so many times and there is no problem at all!! This is very weird.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
Massive hint for aosip install:

wipe dalvik,system,data,cache

flash rom

flash gapps

wipe dalvik/ART-cache AND cache <-------------------

DO THIS

flash magisk if you want it

boot

---

Apparently things like infinite boot and maybe some bootloops are simply artifacts of the cruft left in there.

CREDIT: [MENTION=7834999]fablebreton[/MENTION] - many thanks! Sorry for wasting your time with my procedural prob!
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] cobolmx:
infinite boot,

I exclude google earth, languaje packs, project fi, pay, android auto,print music I dont remember what else, on the first boots works fine but after some days if i need to reboot it stays infinite boot
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
thanks

the prob was not the gapps, but the absence of a wipe Dalvik and cache after flashing gaps. nano worked fine as well as 19.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Rashad79:
Thanks for your note, but I clear the cache after installing any zip file but not the way you mentioned, anyway i'll try it thanks.:)
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
let us know.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Jos_Hdez22:
I always wipe dalvik and cache after flash the ROM and gapps, it doesn't solve the problem
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
Then I don't know solution since at the moment I am having no probs. Maybe a detail desc of your probs and a detailed desc of what you have on your phone... edit: and a detail of how you installed it - every wipe, etc. Thanks!
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Jos_Hdez22:
Hahahaha that's the dilemma, we don't know if the problems are really solved or even if we are having the same problem...

After reading all the comments I can say that I have faced two problems, the bootloops in which the phone restarts again and again and bootloops of the infinite boot type...

In the type of bootloop in which the phone is restarted again and again it was solved relatively easy, in version 18.1 of magisk was enough to flash a more recent version of BusyBox, in version 19.0 of magisk did not happen again.

Regarding bootloop boot infinite type has been much more complex, in first place it has happened to me in magisk 18.1, 18.2, 19.0 and 19001 canary, the solutions have been varied and sadly no definite so far, although for now I can say I haven't had a single bootloop since this last configuration.

Normally the steps I follow when installing the ROM are the same whether it is for monthly updates or to repair the phone after it doesn't start again.

In TWRP I make a complete wipe:

-dalvik / ART cache

-system

-data

-internal storage

-cache

Then format data, then restart in recovery mode and repeat the previous steps. Once this is done I install the ROM and the GApps (nano), wipe dalvik and cache, flash magisk and start the system, configure everything (I add my Gmail account, restore my backup drive), wait for the apps to install and download and flash the magisk modules one by one (with a reboot after each or them):

-magiskhide props

-rboard themes

-Google sans mod font

-quickswitch

-YouTube vanced

Once installed the modules configure magskhide props as pixel 3xl and reboot, then I open adaway and configure ad blocking, reboot, open quickswitch and select lawnchair as default launcher and reboot.

When all this is done I start using the phone, safetynet pass, PoGo and the bank apps work well, everything is normal, this takes about one or two days, then if I need to restart the phone or if I run out of battery and it turns off when you turn the phone back on, it enters in the infinite bootloop, sometimes it is solved by uninstalling magisk and flashing it again, sometimes not, and in those cases I have to do everything again and again and again ...

In this last occasion in magiskhide props I changed the boot stage to post-fs-data and at this moment I haven't had any bootloop or infinite boot. Although I don't doubt that the problem will come back after some days as always...

Hope all this info helps to figure out the problem, if you need logs or more information I'm happy to collaborate.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
Many thanks for all that! The only thing I triggered on was rboard themes, but the absolute killer is the battery running dead and the phone dying. Somehow you must figure out a way to prevent this. Many of the systems on these phones rely on being shut down in an orderly manner and there is no telling what damage you have done when it simply dies. I suppose my only solution for you if phone dies is to rebuild from scratch. Not practical, of course, but a better way would be to often take nandroids while things are working well, and then if it dies, restore the latest nandroid and go from there. But you are using a lot of magisk stuff that I don't touch, so you undoubtedly know a lot more than I do about what might start degrading as time progresses.

Frankly, I only do magisk hide props pixel 3xl to verify that pogo will run on whatever build I am testing, for others here, and for folks looking in, and that's it - I only very rarely actually play pogo since being only 24 I can't really do anything and it will take me forever to get much higher. so it's only to prove that the ROM is capable of it, and that's it. A few releases ago it was useful for verifying that GPS was working okay, but that's all been long fixed. With the wide knowledge that you possess you could be a great resource to others here who get that deeply into it. I suppose you could always try to chase problems on the magisk forums but whenever I have looked at them it seems "catch as catch can" - meaning that you are stuck with being your own guru and using trial-and-guess to solve things.

But as always, if you have problems with this ROM, post some details here and hopefully someone can help you. Thanks for sharing!
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] icantstopflash:
except a long boot sometimes after some flash, everything works well here
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Wasomaji:
same here. Since i never know when to do it exactly, i always wipe dalvik and cache before and after flashing somethings :D
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] fablebreton:
new build

i'am completly lost reading the forum :) anyway i have reworked the kernel, if it's better i will re add some commit later step by step

come with April security Patch.

You can now install Moto cam from play store

nothing new regarding encryption, so consider this post still valid

my adblock updated here

download here
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Rashad79:
[MENTION=7834999]fablebreton[/MENTION]

I want to reformat all partitions of my phone because I'm facing some problems lately in installing deferent ROMs and copying files to phone.

What is the file system should I choose for every partition to get my phone stable again?
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
Zero problems here with 0405. Running magisk 19.0 and hidepropsconf 3.5.1 . Pogo works fine. Don't forget to wipe Dalvik and cache after flash - before boot, or before flash magisk and then boot (CREDIT: [MENTION=7834999]fablebreton[/MENTION] ). Many thanks for your time!!! edit: I use his ad block and like it!

wipe advanced Dalvik,system,data,cache

flash ROM

flash gapps

wipe advanced Dalvik and cache

boot (or flash magisk and then boot)

Enjoy!

---------- Post added at 06:41 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:35 AM ----------

If it were me I would RSDlite a 8.0.0 ROM, but don't forget that that will give you an encrypted phone so go ahead (edit: and put TWRP on) and flash your custom ROM, and THEN run

https://xdaforums.com/moto-z-play/how-to/mini-guide-how-to-crypt-phone-easy-t3909044

and just do Main. And then boot your custom ROM and set it up.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Dovahkiin1290:
Awesome, thanks a lot for that new update. Although i haven't encountered any other problem and no random/infinite bootloops since the day before yesterday (But i must admit i'm kind afraid of even rebooting the phone, haha). I'll try this new version tho and report if anything happens.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
Don't be afraid! and it will help us lots, even if you do run into a prob let us know the details. Fixes are going in behind the scenes - [MENTION=7834999]fablebreton[/MENTION] is doing a ton of work!
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] fernseher:
Yes thats right - and I wanna say again thanks a lot to [MENTION=7834999]fablebreton[/MENTION] for his great work on our device!!!
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Dovahkiin1290:
Of course! Whatever it takes to contribute to the good development of the rom.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Dovahkiin1290:
Well, i'm on a fresh install with the new update. I'll post or report any issue.

So far i've only found a little bug , but isn't a big deal. If you go to "OwlsNest" and try to change something in Statusbar -> Clock the screen goes black and the phone doesn't do anything, it gets stuck on a black screen. To fix this simply reboot to Bootloader, start the phone and you must config all over again (Setting up lang, G account, fingerprint, etc). After this it is possible to config the hour or date through OwlsNest.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
Thanks. When I do that the screen does indeed go blank, but then bounces to lockscreen. when I open lockscreen, I am at clock ready to change things. I wonder what the difference is. Is that the first thin you are changing in Owl's Nest? I had already changed gestures in there... for me, that blank screen is a one time occurrence.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Dovahkiin1290:
First time changing the settings in Owls in this fresh install, yeah. In the previous build it bounced back to lockscreen like you said but this time the blank screen was permanent. No lockscreen, just plain black. A minor issue, and only happened once.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
Thanks. Maybe [MENTION=7834999]fablebreton[/MENTION] will look at it if he gets a chance. I understand there's more changes/corrections planned to go in to the kern next month... The rest of Owl's Nest doesn't seem to have any probs...
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] DrFossil:
Does Moto Cam work on this latest build? It says its not compatible. Everything else seems smooth. Thanks.

Edit : Clean flash did the job. :)
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] eskimos2000:
Hi there,

I have a little problem with GPay, I know there is a general issue form another threat here but It is working with Magisk 19. However when I install MagiskHide props, I have an error when I try in terminal props error on the start of this script "File not Downloaded", means file with fingerprints not loading. However, after installation of busybox form osmOsis is working but I can not pass safety net in both points. After removing osmOsis I can pass safety net and Gpay is working as well. I try to install Busybox pro by Stericson safety net is green but props error is still there. So, to be honest, do I need busybox at all?
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Jagadhidh:
yes it works fine
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] KrisM22:
I know you need a busybox present to issue props in terminal. This particular ROM now includes a busybox, so you don't need to add one. I do not know what will happen if you add one and then remove it for this ROM. This is different from other ROMs.
[Moto Z Play ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, & Other Dev] Rashad79:
The last build of April is unbelievable! Terrific performance. Thank you so much [MENTION=7834999]fablebreton[/MENTION]

Please please try to raise the volume of ring tones and in-call in the next build. This is the only issue for me in this perfect ROM.

Thanks again

---------- Post added at 03:41 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:36 PM ----------

I tried your way of installation in the last build and there are no problems till now. To be honest I don't know if that your way effect or the new changes in the last build.

I will test your way using Alberto's ROM ASAP and come back to you with the results.

Thanks bro