yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] eusebium:
Hey! Thanks for replying! In my case it was already set to "enforcing". I tried changing it using KA-Mod from enforcing to permissive and back but still same result.
[Magisk] PlagueCz:
Hi, sry I didn't reply, too busy.

Please try following Magisk modules:

Busybox for Android NDK

Magisk SELinux Manager (set to enforcing)

MagiskHide Props Config

SafetyPatch

SQLite for ARM aarch64

Modules can be found in Magisk "Downloads" tab (except SELinux manager).

I have these modules installed and my RaiPay works, in combination with enforcing SELinux. I think both our RaiPay apps are very similar if not the same.
[Magisk] eusebium:
Thanks for answering! I think the SafetyPatch was not correctly installed as I get an error message at boot (something with Android has an internal system error. Contact the manufacturer) => not working...
[Magisk] PlagueCz:
Yes, I get the same message, is your RaiPay working? And have you tried RaiPay without Magisk installed on your device?
[Magisk] eusebium:
No, RaiPay still not works. I haven't tried RaiPay without Magisk but I think since my phone is rooted, it will easily detect it... Why should it work on a rooted device without Magisk? :)
[Magisk] PlagueCz:
No, I think any root is a problem. I faced a similar issue, so I wiped my phone, reinstalled Syberia OS and tried RaiPay without Magisk, it worked. After installing Magisk, it stopped so I had to install all the modules I mentioned above. Does your device pass SafetyNet check in Magisk? Do you have Magisk Hide enabled for RaiPay? Because mine passed SN check and even then RaiPay didn't work, I had to set SELinux to enforcing.
[Magisk] eusebium:
SafetyNet check - pass

Magisk Hide enabled for RaiPay - yes

SELinux to enforcing - yes (using KA-Mod)

=> RaiPay is not working :(
[Magisk] Guiper:
Same here, same setup as you, can't get it to work.

Android 10 and Oneplus 7. Any other tips?
[Magisk] PlagueCz:
I would try to factory reset phone, then install RaiPay and after that install Magisk. But I know it's annoying to wipe your phone only because of this.

You can try to turn on Magisk Core Only Mode and see if RaiPay works (reboot required).

Also, RaiPay tells you that your phone doesn't meet security requirements, right?
[Magisk] Guiper:
Just tried to enable the Core Only mode, which disable the Magisk SELinux Manager (set to enforcing) and the SafetyPatch modules without luck.

Well, will keep on using the Revolut + Google Pay combo :)

RaiPay CZ here as well. Yes, app shows that device doesn't match application security requirements.
[Magisk] PlagueCz:
Ok, the last thing that I would do is to clear app data, sometimes these banking apps save information about root for later. Otherwise, I don't know, but I'm going to reinstall my phone in the following days, so I will try to record it step by step.
[Magisk] PlagueCz:
Hi guys, I took my time and installed everything from scratch. Here's what I did and RaiPay works.

1. Boot to recovery, wipe the phone completely

2. Install Lineage OS 17

3. Install GApps

4. Reboot to system

5. Sign in to Gooogle account

6. Install RaiPay

7. Open RP, agree to terms and conditions, add phone number, add payment card and confirm it (RaiPay works at this point)

8. Reboot to recovery and install Magisk, boot to system

9. Open Magisk and turn on Magisk Hide for RP

10. Open RP, still works

My guess is that RaiPay only checks for root when you're opening the app for the first time.
[Magisk] tfft:
EmiratesNBD

Hi, I have an hlte running LineageOS 16.0 (lineage-16.0-20190925 to be exact) with lineageOS' "addonsu" with opengapps nano. I tried the EmiratesNBD mobile application which failed, I then logged into TWRP and "addonsu-remove" and booted back and all was fine - banking application worked fine. I then decided to try Magisk, long story short - the banking application is _not_ working noting that my "phone is jailbroken".

SafetyNet passes both CTS and Integrity, I'm running Magisk 19.5-578a50b4 (19404) with Magisk Manager 7.3.4-578a50b4 (239). I even tried "Hide Magisk Manager" to no avail (rebooting after any/all changes). The application is definitely selected under "Magisk Hide". Any ideas on how to debug this or what to do next ? I can certainly uninstall Magisk and go back to LineageOS's "addon" mechanism but I don't want to do that...

In passing, I don't have anything listed in my "Modules" for some reason - I did what the FAQ noted ("clear repo cache" and reload modules), still nothing.

Ideas/thoughts/options ?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
[MENTION=4697168]tfft[/MENTION] Tested the app and can hide from it just fine. You might have something about your setup that is causing it to fail.

More reading:

https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
[Magisk] halilyildiz:
After installing the new magisk update (19.4) my problem is solved.. :good:
[Magisk] Horgyboy:
I also have the same problem in Norway on an app called VIPPS. Safetynet is good and i have magisk 19.3. I dont want to format and reinstall everything. Hope for a solution soon..
[Magisk] bafforosso:
I had issues recently with 2 apps which have been solved with Magisk 19.4 (beta) in which Magisk Hide has been improved, you may want to try it. (you should simply have to change Update Channel to Beta in Magisk Manager settings, you may want to make a backup of your boot image first though, just in case)
[Magisk] Horgyboy:
I got it working. I reinstalled magisk again. Went into settings, Tapped "hide magisk manager, Downloaded the banking app without starting it. Went back to magisk and hide the app. Then start the banking app and it all works.

Tried to turn off the "hide magisk manager" after all this and the bank app ****s you again. So i guess you need to hide magisk forever if you want to use this kind of banking app.. VIPPS is only used to transfer money fast and is not the normal banking app i use for everything else. My normal banking app has always worked.. :)

Edit: Looks like it works to just turn the "hide magisk manager" on and off when you need to use the banking app too.. A bit more convenient :)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
There's absolutely no drawback to keeping the Manager always hidden. Even more convenient...
[Magisk] mxxt01:
My bank updated the app few weeks ago, and after that I was not able to use it on my phone due to root. But Hide Magisk Manager solved the issue, and once I repacked the name everything is back to normal [emoji16]

Poslano z mojega MI 9 z uporabo Tapatalk
[Magisk] Horgyboy:
Only that you don't have a shortcut to the app
[Magisk] Akagami1994:
YES! it worked like a charm.

:D
[Magisk] MacGyver17:
Do you know how to fix it ?

Rn using the magisk v20.2 on pie. Not working

But the magisk v20.2 on android 10, it can get to login screen (on the other phone)

Anybody knows what is going on ? Am I need to install old magisk to my phone ?

*edit : I have done repack magisk and do the magisk hide. Still detected as rooted device.

Yesterday I tried to remove the magisk at all, the root checker already said I do not have a root access, but mandiri banking app still detect the root ?
[Magisk] adyana:
Hello ... Having the same issue recently, update Mandiri App and got locked out from it due to root issue (Err-4 on toast notification). Got it working again last night with the following steps (after numerous unsuccessful try on mixing these steps) :

- Uninstall Mandiri apps

- Reboot, Wipe cache and dalvik via recovery

- Install/update to Magisk 20.3 ( on previous try, I tried to also remove Magisk and reinstall, this might also works)

- Reboot, Wipe cache and dalvik via recovery

- Hide/repackage Magisk 20.3

- Download & install Mandiri apps but don't open !!!

- Open newly repackaged Magisk and hide Mandiri apps

- Reboot, Wipe cache and dalvik via recovery (somehow repeated step but i think it is necessary)

- Open Mandiri app, hopefully it is working now
[Magisk] kevin01523:
I'm having problems too with the banking app

play.google[/url] .com/store/apps/details?id=www .mobile.bdo.com.ph&hl=en_US

Detects root even on newly wiped device with magisk I'm not sure what triggers it tho since other banking appsworks fine

Also this apps diagnostic feature can detect root even it's hidden com.evozi.injector
[Magisk] hyper21:
I am also having the issue on BCA and OVO. Does - "Reboot, Wipe cache and dalvik via recovery" means we need to reinstall the entire OS?
[Magisk] kevin01523:
Oh it seems the banking app searched for twrp folder or anything named twrp it worked now

It still doesn't make sense to me howcom.evozi.injector detects root

BTW cleaning dalvic doesn't clean the os unless you also check system and data
[Magisk] adyana:
Hi ...

No, you don't need to reinstall the entire OS... just need to enter recovery on reboot, wipe cache and dalvik cache
[Magisk] Felix Siahaan:
Thanks...

This method did the trick.

Now all banking apps like Mandiri, BCA & LinkAja are working again :o
[Magisk] chieco:
this worked for German Sparkasse Bank apps. I never had them installed so I could skip a few steps.. just downloaded them hid magisk and the apps, wiped cache and voila! they work :D
[Magisk] adey64:
Wow thanks! Hide magisk worked!
[Magisk] emuandco:
New Sparkasse pushTAN app fails badly with version 1.5.1... Aka App dies in background and opens a Chrome telling me how evil I am and how much the devs of the app got turned on when they made this behavior. I strongly recommend to stay on 1.4.0. If things are too late... I have a APK for these poor souls ^^
[Magisk] spevil07:
Please share it with me.

New version sucks.

Gesendet von meinem GM1913 mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] emuandco:
Small Update: Keep the recent banking app, Install Island (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.oasisfeng.island) and put your Banking app/s in there. Be 100% sure that NO Magisk Manager app is in the clone account. I had it in there in renamed aka hidden and still it found out somehow. If you remove it... Works. At least right now...

EDIT: Small pic of my "Island"

https://photos.app.goo.gl/K9fpRcigXrzkAxkY6
[Magisk] Psy0ch:
I also would like to get my hands on the 1.4 APK if you wouldnt mind :)

Sadly apkmirror doesnt seem to host those APKS
[Magisk] tqwzUX6fn39GZMEzSnDF:
LOS 17.1, magisk 20.4 and using magisk hide and changed name of magisk manager:

DKB Tan2go

Alliance Bank

both detecting root and therefore not working anymore.
[Magisk] tepalas:
Sometimes, apps detect whether "enable OEM/bootloader unlock" setting in the developer options is turned on. Disabling it allowed my banking app to work. Please keep in mind this might cause problems if you brick the phone, so always enable the setting back on before doing any system modifications.
[Magisk] Clark789:
For me the same with DKB Tan2Go. I solved it for the time being with Tan2Go Ver. 2.4. I uninstalled Tan2Go new version 2.5.1 and reinstalled 2.4. I have to activate the new installed version and it works properly...

Switching off the "enable OEM/bootloader unlock" setting in the developer options makes no difference for me.

Regards

Clark
[Magisk] tqwzUX6fn39GZMEzSnDF:
Unfortunately I cannot find this setting in LOS 17.1. Maybe I'm blind, but searched for a long time now....

I think it should be between "Enable Bluetooth HCI snoop log" and "Running services" - but it isn't.
[Magisk] Marlboroman1037:
hi,

hab das selbe prob mit der VR- SecureGO

hab sie auf der android 8. am laufen.

musste mir aber auf da vor einer wochen nach nem update die alte version wieder besorgen.

auf android 10 kann ich machen was ich will, es kommt immer der hinweiß das handy ist gerootet

grüße marlboro
[Magisk] Clark789:
Thanks for the hint, but please note that this is an English speaking forum.

Regards

Clark

---------- Post added at 02:33 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:02 PM ----------

Exactly! But switching it off or on makes no difference for me with Android 8...

Regards

Clark
[Magisk] Arak0n:
PushTAN 1.5.0 is working fine with Magisk 1.9.3 here.. is that one working for the people with trouble with 1.5.1?

Latest Sparkasse app, updated around the same time as PushTAN 1.5.1 released, is not detecting root either.
[Magisk] Morgoth_RB:
Yes: PushTAN 1.5.1 detects root, restored 1.5.0 from titanium backup, everything is fine.
[Magisk] emuandco:
Went another way now. I use the newest sPushTAN app and run it on Island (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.oasisfeng.island). Same for the Banking app that TAN generation works fine. If you have Magisk Manager inside your Island it will fail as before, but if you remove it there the app runs nicely. So whatever it does, it detects the hidden Magisk APK.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I'm curious about this and wonder if you could answer some questions... Is the hidden Manager using the stub on your device? You can check this by taking a look at the version string of your installed Manager. If it has a second set of parenthesis with with the version number of the stub (currently 7 on the stable release and 9 on the Canary releases) you're using the stub.

If you have the stub installed, are you using the stable or Canary release? It's worth testing the Canary release if you're on the stable.

Have you given the hidden Manager a new name, or are you staying with the standard "Manager"? If so, try changing to something else.

The reason I'm asking is because when I've tested sPushTAN and whatever other apps people claim are suddenly detecting root recently, I have zero issues opening them once they're on the Hide list (Canary release, at the moment 20407 with hidden Manager 283, stub 9).
[Magisk] tqwzUX6fn39GZMEzSnDF:
Could you please try DKB-TAN2go if not yet done?

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.starfinanz.mobile.android.dkbpushtan&hl=de

Doesn't work for me and others since a couple of weeks even on canary, although one person said it's working with canary.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I have (one of the apps I'm referring to with "and whatever other apps"), and I've written about it in several places both here on XDA and on some of the closed MagiskHide issues on the Magisk Github. No issues.

Magisk can hide from it. For some reason some people can't, which might be because of device/ROM/general setup specific issues that I can't replicate when testing.
[Magisk] emuandco:
Installed:

Magisk 20.4 (20400) RELEASE

Magisk Manager: 7.5.1 (267) (7)

Name: Manage, Manager, BLERGH (all failed ^^)

Now that it works, I tend to not touch it anymore as this would kick me out again and I would need another letter...
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Thanks. The only thing you could try differently would be to install the Canary release and see if that works better (there has been some improvements between v7 and v9). But, if things are working at the moment you would of course risk detection again if you start tinkering.
[Magisk] Neff_V:
I'm using both apps. PushTan and Tan2Go. Both are working with latest canary release but not with the stable release. Just for information :)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Thank you. That has been my conclusion as well when testing. Seems like some users have had some issues though and I'm trying to see if there's anything else going on, but so far it might simply be that those that are having problems are on the stable channel.
[Magisk] tqwzUX6fn39GZMEzSnDF:
What is your system and which apps which require root do you use?

I'm on LOS 17.1 with pico gapps, f-droid store, adaway and afwall+. Tan2Go not working.

(Also detects root in shelter work profile)

Magisk canary 20407. Repacked Manager.

Can pass safetynet test and rootbeer shows I am not rooted.
[Magisk] ivannlbc:
Hi friends,

I think I found a solution about my RaiPay-app that doesn't want to start on my phone.

I have a rooted SM-N950F with hadesROM and Magisk 20.4. It doesn't matter anyway, because after I hide the app in the Magisk-manager and rename it, all depends on the permissions of the RaiPay.

So, this is what should be done:

- go to the Settings/Apps of the phone;

- find your bank-app (RaiPay in my case);

- Force stop it (I am not sure if this step is necessary);

- go to the permissions of the app and stop the permission "phone".

Now you can start the app and it will tell you that it needs permissions to go farther. Go back to the settings and give the permission "phone" to the app. Go back to the app and.... it starts normal. :)
[Magisk] tqwzUX6fn39GZMEzSnDF:
DKB tan2go not telling this but immediately detecting root.
[Magisk] MacacoVei:
All Magisk Hide thing didn't work, but this Island thing worked for me :) Island is very cool app, I used it to Pokemon Go and stuff.
[Magisk] ivannlbc:
I made screenshots of the whole process. Made them step by step. My interface is Bulgarian, but I am sure you understand what I did.
[Magisk] ivannlbc:
The root cannot be detected, if you use Magisk-Hide and your Magisk-Manager is renamed. The reason RaiPay is not starting is not the detecting of root, but the permissions of the app in the settings. I have made for you screenshots of the steps, needed to be done, so RaiPay runs like a charm. Just see my previous post and follow the steps. It's simply an uncheck-check thing.
[Magisk] Guntram:
How would you know? You wrote, that you don't use DKB tan2go?

There are literally hundreds of users who describe that using this exact procedure (hiding Magisk, hiding Manager) doesn't help! So please refrain from spreading false information!

Thanks!
[Magisk] ivannlbc:
You are right. I really don't know what are the things like DKB, tan2go, Island etc., mentioned previously above. And I don't care. I talk about RaiPay and only about this app. My experience with it is, that Magisk-Hide and the renamed Magisk-Manager are good enough to hide it. Sometimes to work properly the hide-function needs to be unchecked and then checked again. It's written as issue in the Magisk-discribtion. I am sure that your "literally hundreds of users" never read as deep, like I did and never played around with it, until success.

The problem with RaiPay is that when you overcome the root-hiding-issue, there is another one following with the permissions, that needs to be solved, so the app can run again. This is what I described and tried to share with the "literally hundreds of users".

Maybe you didn't understand me right, we are talking about different things.

Sorry about that. Tried to help.
[Magisk] tqwzUX6fn39GZMEzSnDF:
Please be ensured "we" have tried to "find out" the problem at least as much "deep" as you - but it just doesn't work for us.

"We" appreaciate every new idea - just like yours. But it doesnt work for us.

Some people have working tan2go and so had I - a couple of weeks ago -. But not anymore. Maybe it is a problem of LOS 17.1, maybe not. Please understand we are not stupid and also trying to figuere out where it is coming from and what could be solution - yours isn't.
[Magisk] Guntram:
The problem was that you quoted "DKB tan2go". This would usually mean, that you refer to it ;).

Thanks for your good intentions, but posting how to cook eggs when someone wants to bake an apple pie (bad example, I know ;) ) only creates more confusion when dealing with an already confusing problem...

No offense :highfive:,

Guntram
[Magisk] evhanation:
Its work on my device, should try too. Thanks
[Magisk] ivannlbc:
This is my last post here.

I quoted the words of somebody, that quoted my words. I was talking about RaiPay. It's the banking app of Raiffaisen Bank. Tan2go, DKB and other mentioned tricks in your posts have nothing to do with RaiPay.

You are talking about apples, when I give a solution about eggs. I have never mentioned apples, pairs, tan2go, DKB, that you are stupid or other shi...

Somebody said mine solution didn't work. Really?!

I bet I can start and run RaiPay on every rooted phone out there. I shared with you how. Without tan2go, DKB etc. (I still don't know what they do and what they are for. )

Once again... RaiPay is what I fix under root. Nothing else.

In Bulgaria we say "Do a favour to someone, and eat sh... after that."

No offense.

Be happy all and enjoy your RaiPay.
[Magisk] ivannlbc:
Hi again, About RaiPay...

The app checks on its first start if the phone has root. If yes, it will never start. So, it is very important that the root will be not detected on the first start. If that happened, one should uninstall RaiPay, go down to the TWRP, wipe cache and dalvik, so every "memory" of the app in the phone is cleaned. Then reboot. Install RaiPay again... don't start it. Hide it in the Magisk manager, rename the Magisk manager. Only now can be performed the first start. It should start. When once the root is overcomed, the app could have issues with the permissions. This is what I described in my previous posts and screenshots. Good luck!
[Magisk] ALGOPOP:
I updated the Magisk Manager App(Only the App, not Magisk itself) to the latest Canary Version. Now the "sPushTAN" App does not detect root anymore. Magisk Manager is repacked, renamed and Hide is active.
[Magisk] holger_fe:
Thanks for this solution, I really searched a long time...And only found a workaround via "Island" from App Store (isolated enviroment).

After I installed the Canary Build from Magisk Manager I or you need to install the canary version of Magisk as well though. Because I uninstalled the old Magisk Manager, otherwise there would be 2 installations of magisk manager (stable+canary build).

Or is your method working while both Managers are installed and only the stable build is running 20.4 magisk?
[Magisk] ALGOPOP:
I uninstalled the latest Stable Magisk Manager and installed the canary version. I have only the canary Manager installed and it works like a charm. Magisk itself is still 20.4 and i have no problems so far.

All my Banking apps(VR Banking and Sparkasse), TAN Generators(VR-SecureGo and pushTAN) and my NFC Payment app(VR Digitale Karten) are running without a flaw.
[Magisk] Clark789:
For me with Tan2go-app not working. Anyone, who has another solution?

EDIT: For Tan2go this solution worked absolutely perfect!!

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=82460441&postcount=142

In german you'll find the perfect how-to here:

https://www.elcombri.de/dkb-tan2go-mit-visa-secure-trotz-root-auf-android-geraeten-in-2020/

Regards

Clark
[Magisk] tqwzUX6fn39GZMEzSnDF:
This thread as well as

https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps

have lots of possible solutions. But for some persons incl. myself, none of them works.
[Magisk] nohire:
WOW! i search for the solution..and your soltion saved my day...thanks god. BTW today after update my banking apps (HLB connect) detect my rooted phone and FC...then i use this solution to bypass it wohooo
[Magisk] Munra++:
That doesn't work with mi banking app. As soon as you remove the phone permissions, it opens the settings on the app permissions, so I guess It is indeed due to the phone permissions.
[Magisk] H113408:
For the users of https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.starfinanz.mobile.android.pushtan you might try to following procedure to see if it works, it worked for me on Android 10 with Magisk and EdXposed.

1. Execute the normal procedure of hiding Magisk, EdXposed

2. Install the version 1.3.2, using adb install -d (to allow downgrade) you can find it here

3. Clear the app data

4. Launch the app (you should get the password screen)

5. Now you can install the app from play store.

I was able to launch the app at this point even after cleaning the data.

PS: I didn't try to see if the app would crash past the password screen. But from what I know, the app tries to detect root at launch, so If it didn't detect it then I'm pretty sure it would work normally.
[Magisk] yayaflirt:
Hello where can i find the canary version of magisk?
[Magisk] mexxxico:
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk
[Magisk] mxxt01:
Here's my experience:

My banking app detects root with Magisk 21.0, but it doesn't detect root with Magisk 20.4.

In both cases I use latest Magisk Manager 8.0.2 and same settings, magisk hide, repacked name,...

Poslano z mojega MI 9 z uporabo Tapatalk
[Magisk] Spartacus500:
Working for me, Magisk 21000 & Magisk manager 8.02.307
[Magisk] NotizMe:
In Greece and myAlphaWallet app (Alpha Bank) I just cleared cache and repackaged Magisk under a different name and it just worked.

[Xiaomi Mi 9t]