yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
If you could provide a log that would be helpful for the maintainer.
[G3 Android Development] Spaceboy60:
No idea is it'll show much but here it is:
[G3 Android Development] elhennig:
With USB3 ports this does not happen, but with USB2 ports it does.
[G3 Android Development] RingooXDA:
i would like to ask what is the best kernel for lgg3 running android 7.1.2
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
There is no "best". It depends on what you want - better performance, better battery, better charging etc ? Try a few and compare them over time. Every phone, user and usage pattern is different.

Personally I kept the stock one as provided in the last official build - https://sourceforge.net/projects/resurrectionremix/files/d855/RR-N-v5.8.5-20171120-d855.zip/download
[G3 Android Development] RingooXDA:
thank you man can i ask you how to remove kernel to flash other kernel becouse the kernel who iwould like to flash not support to flash over custom kernel
[G3 Android Development] Spaceboy60:
Bug? Or usb 2.0 not implemented properly yet?

Anyway will check my USB 3.0 ports at my flat later as I only have USB 2.0 at my PC round my parents atm.
[G3 Android Development] elhennig:
Most likely this depends on the maximum current available on these ports: 500mA with USB2 and 900mA with USB3

EDIT: I have also on USB2 port where the flash appears in battery settings. So my theory is not really valid, but it definitely depends on the USB port.

---------- Post added at 01:23 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:17 PM ----------

For N I used Gamma kernel which provided very good battery life as the developer tuned o interactive governor in a very nice way.

For O there is not much of a choice so far. So I use the one Mountaser Halak provides separately but also within his build of the rom.
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
The safest way is just to flash with TWRP - if you can't do that, then you should check the XDA thread for the kernel in question.
[G3 Android Development] Spaceboy60:
Ok, tried on two usb 3.0 and two usb 2.0,still no luck. USB not connected shows in "settings" and PC won't recognise it.
[G3 Android Development] ayoub.opera:
Great rom

Keep going :good:
[G3 Android Development] mountaser halak:
new build is coming this weekend with a lot of fixes
[G3 Android Development] mymagicmyhero:
Cool! I have one question... Does this rom include your kernel or not? I wasn't able to find this info.
[G3 Android Development] mountaser halak:
It dose

But if u want to get the full advantage on moun kernel u need to flash the moun kerbel zip on top of the rom
[G3 Android Development] mymagicmyhero:
Thank you. I've forgotten so many things abt android stuff...
[G3 Android Development] elhennig:
I hope the fixes also include a better battery life. Compared to RR 5.8.5 with Gamma Kernel 88.8 the battery life of the 20180229 build is roughly half the time.

Switching on the display costs immediate 2% points of battery for example.
[G3 Android Development] CunhaPT:
Hi! Whwre i can download the latest build? Thanks
[G3 Android Development] elhennig:
The latest available build is listed in the first post of this thread (either Mega or the RR download site).

There is no newer build yet.
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
https://sourceforge.net/projects/re...-O-v6.0.0-20180219-d855-Official.zip/download is the last one, but I'd wait for the next build as there are still issues to be fixed.
[G3 Android Development] packyman:
weekend is over :(
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
Remember this is a blind build, so you just have to wait.
[G3 Android Development] EricH7001:
I hope it has the same bright apearence as stock rom display. Because nougat 7.1.2. Sucks at thaat point.
[G3 Android Development] mountaser halak:
Working on my devices rom

I need to release the mi a1 Official RR first then am gona build for g3
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
It's probably a good idea to concentrate on building for a device you actually own, rather than building blind for the D855. I think most people would now agree that blind builds are not good for the community or the testing process.
[G3 Android Development] mountaser halak:
Ah for f sake what do u want ??????????
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
Why so defensive ? I'm simply stating a fact, and one that cannot be disputed Surely you agree that blind builds are inherently unreliable and buggy. One route is for a maintainer to test a build on their own phone before release . The other is for users to discover bugs that are present because of the lack of an initial testing phase. Since the first route is to be preferred, by definition blind builds are not a good thing.

I'd be interested in hearing other users' opinion on this, as the issue of blind builds was relevant when you took over as maintainer, and we ought to be consistent. On the other hand, if users are happy to do all the testing, providing full logs where appropriate, then I'll shut up.

Keep up the good work and we all look forward to the next build.
[G3 Android Development] elhennig:
I absolutely agree. Still better a blind build than no build at all.

BTW. Am I the only one experiencing terrible battery life with the 20180219 build? I mean 6 hours with a screen on time of 1:20h and Wifi constantly on is far away from what I had with Nougat.
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
I haven't experienced such bad battery life, but I agree, it could be improved upon.
[G3 Android Development] grizzli07:
Quote:

Originally Posted by sanguinesaintly

I'd be interested in hearing other users' opinion on this, as the issue of blind builds was relevant when you took over as maintainer, and we ought to be consistent. On the other hand, if users are happy to do all the testing, providing full logs where appropriate, then I'll shut up.

Keep up the good work and we all look forward to the next build.

In this case I have to agree with sanguinesaintly.

This is the official thread for LG G3, we are not interested Xiaomi.

Do not be angry mountaser halak, I have nothing against you, we all know that your job is difficult. You could have set aside time to communicate with their fans here in the forum.

Keep up the good work.
[G3 Android Development] rahmatalimalik5:
I have encountered MD5 error when installing the ROM in TWRP. I have download files from original source. Also, I have downloaded and try to install crDroid, the same error occured. What to do now...???
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
Follow the advice given on the other thread you posted in. Problem solved.
[G3 Android Development] rahmatalimalik5:
Ok Man, and thanks for fast reply...
[G3 Android Development] grizzli07:
there is some silence ...
[G3 Android Development] strings505:
Is this rom dead now? Is somebody maintaining this rom? Raf was doing a great job hope he comes back and support this great rom. The new maintainer is very non serious.
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
Mountaser is still maintaining it. He is just concentrating on another phone. It's been a month since the last update but I'm guessing he doesn't see any serious issues to deal with.

---------- Post added at 03:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:59 PM ----------
[G3 Android Development] strings505:
Someone else should maintain this rom if he cant. He should focus on other things. Why he was so eager to get official maintainer title if he cant do the job right?
[G3 Android Development] EricH7001:
Let wait and see. For now i am using cleanrom. The 7.1 nougat roms i have tried where not so good. Maybe oreo will not be working so good as well.
[G3 Android Development] drdream100:
i installed the rom, and although its incredible, proximity sensors do not work at all. is there a fix to it?

Thanks for the great work.
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
It's very simple - mountaser is now maintainer for the Mi A1 and he is concentrating on that. That's his choice . He does not (as far as I know) still own a G3 so any builds would be blind. He should however still be monitoring this thread and maybe he can respond accordingly. Communication is more important than monthly builds.
[G3 Android Development] mountaser halak:
am going through some really hard time in my life right now

so i can do one of 2 things now

you guys can wait a week or 2 for me to get my **** life back together then i can start working on the rom again

or i can just drop support for good and you have to fine some one else to build RR for the D855/D851

your call
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
I'm sure I speak for us all when I say I'm sorry to hear that things are not going well for you. Real life can be a pain.

However, since your problems haven't stopped you building for the MiA1, I can only assume that there is something about the D855 that leads you to offer the option that you stop building for it. If you really want to support us here, then you aren't exactly selling that to us.

Personally, I think it's your call - it's not down to us to decide whether you continue or not. Especially if you don't really want to (and that's the impression that I'm getting).

What do others think ?
[G3 Android Development] mountaser halak:
btw am the maintainer of the mi a1 but am not the one making the builds my friend is covering for me because i made the first build and then my phone broke before i even had the chance to try it because i have the worst luck in the world and bez i dont have enough problems going on in my life so god decided to give me more

and i still havent made not even one commit on the mi a1

i should get my replacement mi a1 next friday then i need to do some stuff on the mi a1 RR then i will fix the **** in the g3

so if next weekend wasnt enough the week after should be more than enough for me to make a new build for the g3 (d855 d851)

and am sorry i did read all of your pm's but i had no time to reply its just that am not feeling well and i have been in a really suicidal mode lately with all of the problems happening in my life
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
I am really sorry to hear all of that, and I'm sure we all are. You need to consider your options very carefully, as phones should never ever take priority over real life. Now that we know what's happening, we'll support you . But you need to decide for yourself what is best for you - phones will always be around, but your health is what really matters. Think things over and let us know.
[G3 Android Development] EricH7001:
Thx m8. No problem. Then it takes somewhat longer. Behind the clouds is always the sun. Even if you dont see it right now.
[G3 Android Development] grizzli07:
Now we know whats going now, good luck in your personal life! Everything will be fine, you will see ... :good:
[G3 Android Development] KennyG123:
Thread cleaned

Developers owe you NOTHING!

Entitled people demanding responses, cowards making new fake accounts to post, all will be treated severely!

XDA is a place of learning, not a place to demand anything of people that give of their time freely!

If you want updates immediately, learn how to build yourself or stay on stock and demand from your manufacturer or carrier

THEY are the ones you actually paid for your phone and software

Thank you for your understanding and cooperation going forward

Friendly Neighborhood Moderator
[G3 Android Development] pa.ko:
Maybe it's time we ask someone else to take maintenance?

For instance [MENTION=6665890]GamingDevilsCC[/MENTION] is unofficially building RR for all other LG variants except d855 (as it is officially ?supported? here).

Anyone knows [MENTION=6665890]GamingDevilsCC[/MENTION]? Please ask him if he could take over building - even it gets unofficial it will be better than what we officially got here.

Things are not to get better just of hoping for Sun above clouds.... We already had this situation month ago. And nothing improved but time is passing.
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
We certainly should not dive in and ask the first person we think of. That is not a good plan. There are procedures to follow and alternatives to consider. We won't die if we don't get a new build this week or next week. But we do all need to talk about options rather than unilaterally ask someone to take over. Slow and steady - we all (including Mountaser) need to be in the loop and agree on a plan of action. It's not our decision yet. There are bigger issues to consider - an unofficial build is not necessarily better - there are other options.
[G3 Android Development] Marcos OC:
Please stop, you can't decide those things, go make another thread with an unofficial build.
[G3 Android Development] pa.ko:
Well, this thread certainly already dived into oblivion. While these unofficial builds are going on, here we are officially stuck. :good:

I can understand his devoted followers, who are mostly junior members with no experience in what xda is and how other projects look like. But I'm not one of them and I rise my voice as this is one of greatest things here on xda - freedom to rise your voice. And I cherish junior as well as senior members to attack me furiously in protection of their beloved 'official maintainer' as it will prove my point that blindly following and adoring people who are not reliable, who are over-promising and under-delivering, is best thing to do if you want to maintain total failure in your virtual as well as real life. So it may come to some heads that it is not best way to go ahead and we can ask someone else to resolve this situation.

And no, I will not drop my support for RR LG d855 project! I stress support to The Project. And person here is just a maintainer of the project. So he is not a movie star nor owner nor creator nor anything but just a a maintainer.

And RR team should be aware of this behavior. Which in turn is damaging credibility of RR. As they also have share in responsibility who they choose for maintaining their projects.
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
I agree with most of what you say. The "old school" users seem to be taking a back seat here (maybe wisely). And the RR Team should be made aware of the situation - it's not just this ROM being affected. Our priority however should be ensuring that the current maintainer addresses his RL problems. If that means him taking a break for his own health (and judging by his last post I think that would be a good idea), then so be it.
[G3 Android Development] pa.ko:
Well I think OP should be honest and recourse himself if he has RL to fix. And let someone else step in. Like mentioned device who is maintaining unofficial thread as official is stuck.

And I'm reminding that this situation is already seen here. Month ago he stopped working for lost phone. Now he lost his real life. Well I wonder what will happen next.

Anyhow, such poor maintenance is more show of dysfunction of RR as well as this thread community than his own image. As I stated: maintainer is not a big shot nor star. But project as RR is almost 'institution' and it is potty that they show so much neglect for situation. LG G3 is one of oldest phones around and it may be a true show of RR power to resurrect old hw to the latest sw standards. But with such maintenance they are showing totally opposite: how something alive just months ago can be stuck into oblivion.
[G3 Android Development] Spaceboy60:
Happy to wait. Good for the update, get things sorted in your personal life mate, this ROM can wait till you feel up to it. Bigger things in life than a custom ROM. Good luck, hope things turn out better for you.
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
The Development Team has been made aware of the situation - it's up to them and Mountaser to work it out. Fingers crossed.
[G3 Android Development] lorouco:
Thank you Mountaser for your work in ROM. But I understand the annoyance of some members, because even made few compilations this ROM has proved to be the most promising Android Oreo for our beloved LG G3. I continue to cheer for you and I trust all of XDA, since the launch of our LG G3 has taken care of this device until today ... Thank you and God take care of you!
[G3 Android Development] pa.ko:
Thank you for this great post.

I just wonder how you judged this stuck and inactive project is most promising of all ROMs around? Is it from your extensive experience? Hey, wait - you have single post on xda!! But how you managed to gain such experience with single post on xda? Can you please share with us secret of your success? Im so stupid I needed years of reading and hundreds of posts to ask for help, to get some understanding and experience of what is going on around. If you could just share with us a small piece of your wisdom we all could be enlightened.
[G3 Android Development] lorouco:
Yes a single post, but I have been following the forum for a long time. I have used ROM FULMICS, AOSP EXTENDEND, CyanogenMoD, Resurrection Remix, crDroid ... and I have enjoyed the free and voluntary work of the XDA programmers. All Custom ROMs based on Android Oreo are facing camera problems and screen unlocking ... but I believe they will soon have the solution. I can not demand more than they already offer us for free!
[G3 Android Development] L1p1c1:
If you are a man you need to step in, but if you are a man, you step in and you don't know what you are talking about, you are not a man anymore, you're just a duck. RR for LG G3 wouldn't be nothing now if wouldn't be Marchetto.

Tell me if i need to be more clear than that.
[G3 Android Development] hhrokarvi:
Guys Guys! Will you all please relax! I am a maintainer of RR for a couple phones and I've been watching this thread closely since its inception. What's going on with all of you!

I get it, we all need active development on this thread and I know the current maintainer is nothing to write home about. I get it. What we all need here is a plan, and a solid one at that. If the current maintainer has RL issues, he should really do the right thing and step down, focus on his life. I get that life comes first, absolutely, but he should mitigate this issue himself, as he took this responsibility, furthermore taking over another phone (Xiaomi MI A1) as maintainer and doing development on that (although a friend of his is), why couldn't he do the same for this phone? There are things that don't add up here.

What can we do here? We need to find a maintainer who can do development on our phone here (I do own a G3, but d850), or have the developers at RR have a talk with him (Which I've heard is going on).

This is not only bad for RR, XDA, but us a community. Please be civil.

Regards.
[G3 Android Development] yasirow:
The back camera is not working. The flash light is off.

How can I resolve it?

twrp latest version.

latest latest rom.

D855
[G3 Android Development] Babillebabou:
Agree, Some experienced users are disappointed about the choice of this maintainer
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
At least we know the score.

Think of the poor MiA1 users who think all is well with their maintainer. They haven't seen the posts here, and haven't been told the truth, so ignorance is bliss for them.
[G3 Android Development] grizzli07:
We want to know the real truth. No lies. I know work on the assemblies is very difficult. Experiences and older developers tell us that we should try building alone ... I know that maintenance is about volunteering, enthusiasm, pleasure doing things for others, sacrificing time ... I think it's in the principles of this free forum, which is based on these basic principles. If I'm wrong, fix me. That's why I want to know (and certainly other fans of this great ROM), which is going to be ... We are not interested in Xiaomi Mi A1...
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
I am very aware of what is happening through PMs with Mountaser. The MiA1 issue is relevant if only because that's now the only phone he actually has. It is now his decision whether to expect us to stick with him until such time as he starts building again (he has no D855 remember so all blind builds), or he decides to stop building for us (in which case we need to speak with someone who we know can help and support us - and who possesses a D855). If Mountaser does not want to step down then we have very little option but to comply. He has his followers and if he wants to continue building with the blessing of the Dev Team (who have been made aware of the situation), that is his choice. The ball is very firmly in his court.
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
A plan

OK - here's a plan - I can speak to a trusted and well-known XDA member who can obtain a D855, and ask him whether he is willing (with the agreement of Mountaser and the Dev Team) to take over (again) as maintainer. This is purely hypothetical of course but is it a good plan ?
[G3 Android Development] EricH7001:
Sounds great
[G3 Android Development] Babillebabou:
Yes, probably the best option, thank you
[G3 Android Development] mountaser halak:
a new build will be released after the April's security update is out

and the rom will be updated monthly after every security release

and am working on the trees to fix the bugs as we speak
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
Do you have a D855 to build with ?
[G3 Android Development] mountaser halak:
no i dont but its ok i got testers
[G3 Android Development] sanguinesaintly:
Having heard of your changes in fortune and a better life I now feel happy to say :

I'm out.

I don't see a place for a blind build (and that is likely to be a permanent situation from what you've told me), no matter how good your testers. I presume they are all in a Telegram group that doesn't feed back to here. In addition. the lack of a maintainer's phone was your primary argument for taking over.

It was fun while it lasted, but the ride is over for me.

If I remain on RR (and I really want to) I will be happy to use an unofficial - sorry, you call it "private" - build from someone else. The rest of you - it's time to make your choice. A blind build every month from someone who has admitted to me that he hasn't got time for XDA - or the obvious alternative.

Don't clutter the thread - I won't respond here - PM me if you want to discuss this seriously. To those of you sticking with it, I sincerely wish you all the best. RR is too good to die.
[G3 Android Development] mountaser halak:
My tester is my friend dev hardstyler he will teat my builds before i post them

He is a dev not just a tester so it will be all ok

Just so everything is clear for you

After the work i have done when i had my device there is really no need to have a device to build for it

My trees are more than stable for RR

So my job now is to only pull the changes from limeage os and add them to the g3 and build

So all of that is like 5 Linux comands and they are the same weather i have or i don't have a device bez i have already done the job that requires me tp have a device on hand (and that is the internal port)

So am not gona be going to port android P when it comes out bez i don't have a device

But for O everything is set

If i had a server i actually can just make a short script that builds and uploads the build monthly (and that is how lineage os dose it btw and thats how raf was doing with RR N)

So don't worry and there is no reason for you to step down

You can try my next build and see for yoir self
[G3 Android Development] mountaser halak:
The new build is up

Have fun

Will add the changelog when i wake up

Good night(its 4am here so i was up all night working on it)
[G3 Android Development] grizzli07:
Nothing against you, Mountaser Halak, but the manager without a phone is not a good solution for the community. External testers ... blind version ... I miss here your enthusiasm, the joy of good work, but mostly I'm missing the heart, the true heart that beats for a great ROM. It's your choice, I wish you a lot of luck for the future. I will now only watch from a distance how you doing ... good luck. :good:
[G3 Android Development] mountaser halak:
So everyone complaining about me not building and when i do everyone steps down ?

Shoul make this the last build ? I mean i was up until 4am for this **** you know !