yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] blcklab:
Which do you like more? The IQ Shield or the amfilm?

I have IQ Shield on my device and the amfilm arriving today
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] sn0warmy:
Sad to report that despite babying the phone and not dropping it, I've discovered a crack that appeared on the underside of my amFilm tempered glass screen protector. In addition, I'm seeing a lot of dust already creeping in under the protector. I've reached out to TechMatte support for a replacement and they responded right away, notifying me that they are sending out a replacement immediately. Since I ordered this protector back in mid-October, well before my 2 XL arrived, I'm thinking I got one of the version 1 protectors with the poor adhesive. Hoping the new one they send me will have better adhesive and refrain from cracking for no reason.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] TheSt33v:
Hate to break it to you, but that's your screen. It's yet another display defect that appears only on certain Pixel 2 XLs.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m0VdgattdkY
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] mjforte:
Yes, I had brown splotches on my screen with polarized sunglasses when looking at a white screen when I installed the IQ Shield. My girlfriend had the IQ Shield installed on her phone too but had no splotches. Thought it was my screen but when I took off the protector, no splotches. I've since installed a new IQ Shield and the splotches are gone so maybe it is just an install error.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Atticustrd:
Daaaaammmmmm itttt just when I thought I had a good display. That's exactly what I'm seeing.

---------- Post added at 11:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:53 PM ----------

Oh this is good news. Maybe I do have a bad install. I'll try installing the other protector. Thanks phewww
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] sn0warmy:
Let us know how that turns out. I'm curious now, as well.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] owlmatt:
That is a tough question, depends on your taste. I personally like the feel of glass more but the IQ shield does the job. I got the IQ because I've struggled with glass on curved screens in the past but I guess these larger bezels make it easier. I had IQ on my OnePlus and s8 prior to this.

You do see the dot matrix on this which can be annoying outdoors.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] blcklab:
I'll need to see how that goes. I do tend to use it a moderate amount of time outdoors. If I hate it I'll just put the skinomi on. I haven't cracked a screen (knock on wood) but I've cracked a couple TGSP.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] browniegirl:
I've had 2, they have a dot matrix...but mine had horrible responsiveness
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] blcklab:
Boy I hope the amfilm sticks for a while because the fit is great with my caseology parallax. It's like the two were meant to for together.Wish I could take a picture but my tablet is old and it doesn't look good.

Even though it's evening I'm holding on to it various light and I don't spot any rainbow effect. Responsiveness feels like glass. I thought maybe the IQ Shield fell pretty good but this is definitely days better.

I can see dot matrix under a light but not with the display on under "normal"circumstances.

I've spent time trying to just keep pushing along the adhesive edges although I reckon that doesn't do anything.

Happy with the fit and feel although only time will tell.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Atticustrd:
Phew, the blotches were caused by the screen protector.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Erikbronx:
I went with the updated version of the amFilm Dot Matrix, screen protector popped off within 24 hours of receiving it.

I returned the Power Support screen protector for a refund. I didn't even put it to use, no worth the price tag.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] MNX1024:
Is there any full/curve glass protector that currently has full adhesive versus just on the edges?

Does anyone know if Google's protector is full adhesive?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] LLStarks:
Why is the amfilm so highly regarded compared to other 2.5/3D products? I may pick one up once it's back in stock but that guy a few posts up has me worried.

Also, what's the best flat at the moment?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] CBMC:
I don't know. They might use a bit stronger edge adhesive? Definitely still much less than ideal solution. We need a good loca solution for a glass protector.

---------- Post added at 05:59 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:56 AM ----------

I think the only full adhesive curved glass that will work is something that uses liquid adhesive. Unfortunately, no one has made a good full clear, non dot matrix protector, much less a kit with a liquid adhesive. Hopefully someone comes thru.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] tweiss3:
It's been on a few days, and the very edges don't make contact. Doesn't affect use, but I find my only complaint about the 2 XL is the curved screen. I'm going to keep it on for now.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] flintdragon:
anyone know if the amFilm screen protector will fit with slickwraps? I don't know how far off the edge amFilm need. I could definitely see it overlapping the skin.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] blcklab:
Just the word about the amfilm. Just based on my short experience overall I'm happy with it. No rainbow effect. That's awesome with my caseology parallax. I don't really notice dot Matrix and I'm having no issues with response.

One drawback and I'm guessing it's due to the dot matrix is the mottled appearance with polarized sunglasses. It does not have that issue without a screen protector nor does it have the issue with wet film like IQ Shield or Skinomi. Also looks fine with regular sunglasses.

However with my Maui Jim's it has that weird sort of 3D mottled appearance. For right now it's a trade-off I can accept if the edge glued screen protector stays on for a while. It does seem solid
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] blcklab:
Amfilm with caseology parallax. As you can see the gap between the TGSP and case is minimal. I can see a little rainbow effect at times but I can't replicate do I think it's like a certain angle and certain light source not a deal killer for the moment given so few options Seems to adhere well and time will tell. Pardon the pics. They come from an older tablet
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] LLStarks:
Oh god. These curved protectors are awful. Won't stay down.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] RED ZMAN:
My first curved screen, my first curved screen protector, I haven't had it pop up or any issues with it. I have the first generation AmFilm one everyone hated.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] LLStarks:
I need something that can survive case removals and a wet application. I'll have to baby this for a few days.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Bgloriani:
Same boat here. I purchased my AmFilm early October (first gen) and have had it on for the past 3 weeks with no issues of it falling off. I do have a slight rainbow effect depending on the temperature (if it's hot - there's a rainbow, when it's cold, no rainbow). Some dust getting under the proximity sensor cutout in the front, but only visible in certain lighting. Nothing that's a deal breaker for me at this point.

I did request a revised adhesive model from AmFilm to install once my Spigen case comes in. Hopefully it will address the rainbow issue.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Jovacane14:
If someone never puts their phone in their pocket or lives in a dust free world, I'd say to use the tempered glass offered at this point in time. One popped off from me blowing the dust off the top speaker
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Erikbronx:
I had to edit my post, because the screen protector popped off within 24 hours of receiving it.:mad:
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Spacemanglam:
I just got one with Zuslab and the adhesive is only around the edges. This creates a tiny gap between the glass and the screen and makes a "rainbow smudge" on your screen. Not pleasant. My previous experience with tempered glass was full adhesive and did not have this issue.

Although I have to say that the cutout for the front facing camera, sensor below the top speaker, LED notification lights, and for both speakers were very accurate. Barely any excess space.

But I really cannot stand the rainbow effect - I think I'll get another one once someone finds a better protector.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Mrwirez:
Confused after reading 15 pages...

Without having to read the rest of the 68 pages of reviews, is there a general consensus of the "best available" glass screen protector yet, or is film the preferred protection atm?

What's the bottom line as of November 8th? I really need something before I get scratches.

PS. I'm sure most people know to check out Amazon reviews with https://www.fakespot.com. I'm seeing mostly fake reviews on all the glass screen protectors out there.

Thanks for any help.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] irieblue:
I too just bought the Zagg curved glass from a Verizon store and there is a light dot matrix if looking at a certain reflective angle .. But the real issue is that it's constantly cloudy AND I have noticed a reduction in sensitivity. Hoping to be able to return.

FYI The Supershieldz on my Mate 9 was the best I had ever seen and used.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Lucke:
any update on the install and/or pictures? i like that it's a "Made for Google" product, but not if isn't markedly better than a cheaper option.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] ctrekd:
I went with skinomi film protection until something definitively good comes out for tempered glass.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] TeK9samurai:
Nope.

Right now my Skinomi is installed perfectly with no orange peel look or rubbery feel. Plus compared to the Skinomi, the glass protector is a fingerprint magnet which drives me insane.

Once it starts to peel off, I'll go ahead and replace it.

Just noticed the Zagg Glass Curve is also a made for Google product.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Lucke:
thanks. i'm aware of the Zagg, but after reading everyone's opinions of it, and that it's even more expensive, i won't be considering it.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] LLStarks:
Bought the Zagg glass at Verizon. Don't regret it. I don't think I'll find anything better at the moment even if it's overpriced. If better stuff is coming in the upcoming weeks, I haven't seen it yet. I'm hoping there is seeing how even the Zagg has issues with its corners staying down.

I miss the days where static friction and a steam filled bathroom were all you needed for a glass protector. What happened? This dot matrix stuff is so fragile. I would rather squeegee out water and bubble than put up with this nonsense.

All I want is a flat protector that's up front about any potential gaps yet promises to cover at least the screen or until the taper begins. Curves are toxic to phone culture. I look at my OnePlus One. Beautiful, buttonless flat screen and a protector than covers the entire surface with only a speaker cutout. Not a notch, a cutout. Not even a millimeter of clearance between the protector and the case. This is how it should be.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Jovacane14:
Had the zagg for a week or so on my phone. After that week I noticed dust getting underneath it. Literally a fingernail under one of the top corners and the whole thing popped off so easily. Dust was stuck to the adhesive but you can't notice it while the screen is on because the borders are black. I pressed down so hard on the edges when installing it too. Loving the skinomi so far however
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] browniegirl:
The only real solution is to get a glass screen protector and use Loca glue but that's messy. Film is the best bet
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] pvtjoker42:
just my quick input, in their current state STAY AWAY from Xtremeguard. I've been using them for years for most of my phone, tablets etc. I ordered a pair of their HD screen protectors for my 2XL and the wife's pixel 2, they're both cut horribly. They were also packaged so the bottoms of each screen protector were bent, no way to flatten them. I can't complain too hard for the $3.60 I spent on 4 screen protectors, but still not worth the money. On my 2XL it refuses to stick to the edges. On the wife's 2, it won't stick down near the front camera/speaker or bottom speaker (pretty sad considering this is a FLAT screen without any curved screen issues) Hopefully they'll refine their cuts and make better versions (this is my first time getting a new phone in the first month of release in a long time.) Here's to hoping the next screen protectors i ordered will just work..
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] blcklab:
I have the amfilm version 2 so far it's stuck on very well. Slight rainbow effect but that's only when screen is off or dark AND I'm looking for it. No issues with touch response and it's smooth like tg. It does look "blotchy" with polarized sunglasses on and the wet film do not. Like when I'm driving using Waze.

With that said I have the skinomi on my desk just waiting. The iq shield was good too bfore this arrived. I reckon at the first issue I'll just apply the skinomi. I still feel the that offers better crack protection however in reality my biggest need is arguably scratches from keys, coins etc.

So perhaps film is the better choice for me.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Mrwirez:
Hey thanks. From looking around, glass doesn't seem to be too good... Film it is.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] zathus:
I use IQ Shield. I've been using them for a while because they're wet apply, Which usually means you get more coverage. More room for error. And there screen protectors feel a lot like glass. Not that rubbery feeling you're speaking about that you get with other ones such as a zagg
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Decree:
Any possibility of starting poll so everyone can vote based off experience which they'd recommend? Seems as if there's alot of options, and most are duds.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] TNS201:
I dropped my phone off my lap yesterday and my screen protector popped off as it hit the ground. The adhesive sucks on all these black border 3d full screen glass protectors. I don't even know which brand mine was because it wasn't the one I ordered off ebay. It was supposed to be Magic Guardz but was not

https://www.ebay.com/itm/3D-Real-Te...ctor-Film-For-Google-Pixel-2XL-/391911853128?

Thats the one I ordered but as in a different package. Wonder if for many of these they are made by one company and then shipped out under different names? The adhesive is horrible on these and we need a full screen adhesion I believe to not get the rainbow effect. I had a similar black border protector on my Pixel XL1 and it had rainbow effect too but no 3d edge.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] AndrasLOHF:
Just put on an updated amfilm last night. It looks perfect on the device and I'm not having any missed touches or anything like that. Hoping it'll hold up better than others have mentioned here.

---------- Post added at 02:24 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:15 PM ----------

Just put on an updated amfilm last night. It looks perfect on the device and I'm not having any missed touches or anything like that. Hoping it'll hold up better than others have mentioned here.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] ninotorpedo:
How does the fitment look? Any halo effect around the sides or rainbow effect in the center? You mind posting photos?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] corywf:
I put the updated amfilm on mine (they sent it to me for free since the first version sucked). I still have a big area with the rainbow effect. Does yours have that?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] AndrasLOHF:
I have a very small spot but it doesn't effect the usage. I have to be looking for it in certain light to even see it.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] blcklab:
Same here. Right now I think all the protection has trade-offs.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] AndrasLOHF:
For sure. So long as I don't have the dust or popping off issues I'm going to use this one until intelliARMOR finalizes theirs.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] cdig:
i got one of those liquid install ones and while it covers the screen great, it feels absolutely awful. Maybe ill just go naked... gorilla glass 5 should be pretty solid I hope
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] con100:
Can anyone tell me the difference between the Intelliarmor Pro and 3D protectors that will be shipping soon. I see one has a black border and the other is clear. Do they have adhesive for the whole protector and do they use the dot matrix?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] psklenar:
I wrote to IntelliArmor last night to ask that very question and received a response an hour or two ago this afternoon ... the HD covers just the flat portion of the display and the 3D is curved and covers the curved edges. I told them I have the Seidio Surface case and they recommended the HD.

pat----
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] CBMC:
Am I missing something with the intelliarmor protectors. They look exactly the same as the other edge adhesive protector. I know everyone seems really excited about them , but I have never seen a edge adhesive glass protector work well. I sincerely hope that I am wrong.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] psklenar:
Based in earlier posts by IntelliArmor on here, I think you are correct in regards to the 3D version. But I think the flat HD version will be what I'm used to from my Nexus 6P and Nexus 5 where I lived the intelliGLASS HD protectors.

Personally, I'm not considering any curved glass protectors until there's some history.

pat----
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] onishchuk4:
You'll regret it very soon if you do. I had mine for a week and it's already got some nasty scratches on it just from normal wear and tear. Good thing it's being RMA'd.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] cdig:
Mines been OK for a week or so. What other options are there though? This is still better than the matrix for tempered ones that fall off after a minor drop or get dust underneath ;)
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] kdkinc:
IQ Sheild screen protector

I just returned to Amazon the IQ Shield screen protector.

After watching the install video I almost tossed my cookies.

Check out the fingernails on the person installing the screen saver beyond gross.

Ok maybe I'm a bit shallow minded but if the company thinks that a great image then I question their product quality greatly.

(about 50 seconds in)

http://www.iqshield.com/iq29068-google-pixel-xl-2-phone-screen-protector.html
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] uicnren:
for me, because their pixel xl screen protector worked so well, I will trust them with this version.

took them 3 tries to get the original working like it should, and they stood behind their product and gave free replacements to those who ordered earlier versions.

have used them on all my phones since nexus 5, will continue to do so until they dont make them.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] psklenar:
If I may ask ... are you going to go with the 3D or the HD?

Thanks,

pat----
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] uicnren:
I ordered both, but will use 3D
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] psklenar:
Thanks you.

Thank you. I'll be very interested to hear your opinion of the 3D.

pat----
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] CBMC:
Hope your right. But I haven't seen anything to suggest that anything but liquid adhesive is going to work with this phone. The pixel 2xl screen is more curved than the other phones you mentioned. Hope in wrong.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] uicnren:
I had no real issues with the amFilm, the original did come off, but I had the updated version with better adhesive, which worked great, and would still be on my phone right now, had I not broken it trying to use it with the otterbox defender case.

I ordered more of the amFilm, but they are having trouble shipping now, wont arrive til the 15th at the earliest, and intelliarmor will be only a few days after that, so I just cancelled them.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] luigidk:
I have been using a skinomi film protector for a week. First time I have not used a tgsp for years.

I'm very surprised and happy how well this works.

Very smooth, absolutely no bubbles.

The liquid application was easy.

I canceled any pending tgsp orders to see what develops. Will be fine keeping this for now
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Decree:
Well, i just installed the Pleson film type on my 2 xl. It was a wet installation and it was semi difficult. With a background of 3 years of mobile sales, I've done hundreds of both wet installs (mostly zagg) and TONS of glass installs. This was kind of difficult because if you got TOO much solution on, the screen didn't stick and just slid around. Here's the finished product.

*Note* there's still some micro bubbles under the protector that are supposed to come fade in the next 12-15 hours. The corners do lay flat (with some persuasion) , and don't go down to the plastic of the phone, which is good for Cases.

Will update as the solution dries. Will also most likely grab the pleson glass when it's released. As I feel it's better than the zagg, or most other manufacturers.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Decree:
Also, can anyone entertain me as to why all the manufacturers of the glass screen protectors are only putting adhesive on the edges, while on the flat protects of previous phones the adhesive is everywhere?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] sid3track3d:
How does it feel to the touch? Is it smooth or rubbery?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Decree:
It's actually VERY smooth.. Very much like the gorilla glass, so far.

---------- Post added at 05:18 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:18 AM ----------

And honestly, if there were micro bubbles I probably couldn't even tell it was there.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] sid3track3d:
Cool, thanks. [emoji111]
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Sanshis:
Stuffcool

. skinomi is not tempered glass i think; its a protective flim. Well, I just want to confirm authenticity of this product on amazon.

Stuffcool Mighty 3D Curved Full Screen Tempered Glass Screen Protector for Google Pixel 2 XL - Black (Case Friendly & Edge to Edge) - (Authorised made for Google Pixel Accessory)

amazon.in/Stuffcool-Mighty-Curved-Tempered-Protector/dp/B0771B45N8

I am looking for tempered glass.

--

Sanshis
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Decree:
*Update*

Almost all of the bubbles and micro bubbles are gone. Screen protector is smooth as glass. Will try with case tomorrow and see how that goes. The case I have is a spigen clear, tpu/polycarbonate case ordered from Amazon. Will update again tomorrow.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] uicnren:
because the glass is curved, same as last years pixels. if you want all the glass covered then you need a curved protector, with adhesive on the entire protector it causes issues with bubbles, etc near the curves. Adhesive on the edges, when done right resolves that issue.

current flat protectors for the pixels 2s are full adhesive, but do not cover all the glass.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] blcklab:
Day 5 with amfilm version 2 and caseology case. No dust. Hasn't popped off. Isn't moving around. Of course my phone hasn't been dropped or even just fallen from being propped up. If it pops off I'll go to wet film.

The IQ Shield is incredibly smooth. I was impressed. However when I installed the amfilm it's much smoother. Glad smooth. I really like the film but I'm still of the belief TGSP offers a little more protection.

I also pre-ordered both versions of the intelliarmor. I feel like they'll do a great job because they wait and have time to really work on their screen protectors. Plus they come on XDA and I respect that.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Budwise:
Am actually impressed with the Skinomi. I botched the first install so thank goodness for the 2 pack.

I had tried the IQShield on my OP3T and this is a much clearer product. The IQ Shield had a sparkle effect on bright whites but this one is super clear. Almost as clear as TGSP but not as slippery, but still probably the best thing until they figure out how to make a proper TGSP for curved screens. I have the Intelliarmor on order, hopefully they work some magic.