yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] smallsmx301:
Which intelliglass? Pro or hd? Or both. I have the 2xl and it has full adhesive no dot matrix? Sorry new to the game
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] kellybrf:
not sure tbh, neither are full adhesive. I got the Whitestone and am very happy with it
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] smallsmx301:
I can't stomach the cost
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] kellybrf:
fair enough. I'd go naked then, anything else is wasted money
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] smallsmx301:
Thanks
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] :
I'm planning to buy Pixel 2 XL tonight, but having a hard time to select a good screen guard.

Any Indian Pixel 2 XL user here who can direct me to good screen guards ??
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] kushsam:
Does anyone know if the sgfreshidea protector would work with the rhinoshield crashguard on the 2 xl? I currently use the crashguard with a dbrand skin, but need a screen protector badly. everything else i've tried sucks
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] outbackpaul:
After about a half day of usage of the Whitestone protector I've got scratches at the top and bottom of the screen protector. I guess this is coming from pulling it out of my pocket. Is anyone else having issues with scratches?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] ilal2ielli:
I've got light scratches on the sides, but I've gone through two where the corners will crack and/or break off in small pieces.

Minor annoyance for sure. I enjoy how the glass feels, so I haven't bothered trying to put on my InvisShield yet to compare.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] outbackpaul:
I have pretty deep scratches. Pretty sad considering how much I paid for this. I'm not sure if I should do a Amazon return or warranty claim. Oh well
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] DJ-phYre:
How long does the Warranty claim usually take? Whitestone has had my old protector for over a 9 days now and my replacement is still on hold.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Schroeder09:
Everything is trade offs in everything in life. If you want a screen protector that works you have to get the Whitestone dome or sgfresh. In either choice you can't have everything. The WSD doesn't cover the round edges but you can use an awesome cause like the OtterBox defender that has a raised lip around the entire perimeter of the screen.

Sg fresh covers the edges but you have to use a more open case. People get on here complaining about scratches, broke corners, etc. It's cause they're trying to have it all. If you have reasonable, even about reasonable but still in the realm of reality, the WSD will not let you down. It will not get scratched or chipped. I use the thing with an OtterBox defender. I keep the phone in the holster on my belt. Not one single micro scratch on my WSD (yet! Knock on wood!)

I have the best of the best on protection on my 2xl. I suppose the "trade-off" is that I can't keep in my pocket and scratch and break the corners off my screen protector because the case is too bulky. I never kept my phone in my pocket anyway. They're too big. Idk how ppl are sitting down with a 2xl in their pocket and NOT busting the screen in half from causing it to flex or something.

I've made similar posts to this in the thread before. The WSD and OtterBox defender are a great pair that don't suffer from any of the problems I see people talk about on here. I highly recommend if you're serious about protecting your phone.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] stumpy352:
Preference is the word here. I can't see myself ever keeping my phone in a case that prevents it from being carried in a pocket. I've always carried my phone in my front pocket. I have the SGFresh protector & a $7 tpu case that is very similar to diztronic. It has a lip around it that is raised enough that the glass won't touch a surface if placed face down. It's flexible, yes, but honestly, this phone is strong enough to withstand bending in a pocket.

There is no way in hell that I would carry my bulky phone around in a holster on my hip in public, sorry. 3 reasons.

1. It isn't practical for me. I'm in & out of trucks all day & working with chainsaws and trees & wood chipper & all sorts of other machinery that could snag it, rip it from my body, or drag me into said wood chipper.

2. It's too publicly accessible. Cell phones are one of the biggest targets for thieves. No way I'm going to have it openly visible while I'm walking around town.

3. Um, it's a holster man. There is no style in that. I can carry my reasonably well protected phone around in the front pocket of whatever pants I'm wearing & it's barely noticible or visible.

Not having a go at you personally, but it's all about preference. It is about the trade offs, as you said. Your phone is arguably more well protected than mine, yes, but I'll gladly trade some percentage of that protection for comfort, style, safety & practicality. This is the way I've always protected my phone's & I've not broken or bent one yet.

I understand that for some, protection is of Paramount importance, because they simply can't afford to repair or replace their expensive device, but I'm not that person I guess.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] testimony:
Giving the sgfresh invisshield a try. Total cost to india comes at about 1900. Whitestone dome is very costly with shipping and customs
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] rohit25:
Reading the horror stories of glue getting stuck at speaker grills ... Would not suggest SG fresh idea... And the installation is even trickier... Whitestone looks like a walk in the park when compared to it...
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] testimony:
Sgfresh covers a lot more than the WS and the price is reasonable I think. I'll tape up the ports
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] :
I bought Gadgetshieldz and it's freaking awesome. Hardly any fingerprint, almost scratch proof and no bubble since had to wet apply it. The only problem I'm facing is due to the tight fitting of my Spigen armour case which is pushing off the corners a bit. Maybe when I get a next one I might cut the corners a bit. Otherwise, A+ ... I'm getting the same for my wife's OnePlus 5T. These curved edges are the real problem.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] testimony:
I have the gadgetshieldz on the back and I tried the front. It's cheap and good but I can't take the rubbery feel away from the glass. Glass works better so i think sgfresh will work there.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] iazybandit:
So it has been 2+ months since I installed my Whitestone

https://youtu.be/NB0ssnD08PU

Here is my update...

The screen protector is awesome! I am using it with the Caseology Parallax and tested it with the Pitaka MagCase (https://xdaforums.com/pixel-2-xl/accessories/unboxing-review-pitaka-magcase-pixel-2-t3759077). The screen protector has no scratches or cracks. It hasn't lifted or moved. The dust around the screen protector and between the case has gotten less. The oleophobic coating is great. Once in awhile, I'll see my fingerprints (I have sweaty hands) but it wipes off easily.

The same can be said about my wifes phone as well. Still going strong. Highly recommended.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Schroeder09:
Can't disagrees with you there. The 2xl is big too. I farm, weld, machine etc so I know what you mean by it catching on stuff. It is a trade-off. One I'm willing to make to protect a $850 device.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] cd993:
Any plastic/film screen protectors compatible with Spigen Rugged Armour?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] capo56:
Anyone have the experience already please?

edit: I have found separate thread for that -> https://xdaforums.com/pixel-2-xl/accessories/short-review-recommended-adhere-t3729920
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Schroeder09:
Same experience here. It's really a joy to use with the screen protector. It's so good at repelling dirt, smudges, etc, and is sooooo smooth. I appreciate it every day when I use the phone.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] cd993:
Anyone? Even tempered glass ones perhaps?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] CBMC:
I would think the Whitestone would be. It works with the otterbox which usually is the worst about covering part of the screen. I haven't heard of a case not working with the Whitestone since it doesn't go edge to edge.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] N3V3RS3TTL3:
Whitestone works perfectly with Spigen.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Schroeder09:
This is precisely right. The OtterBox defender is the most screen-invasive protector. If something works with the OtterBox it'll work with anything. I have the defender and there is probably 1-1.5mm all the way around the edge of the WSD and the edge of the defender. I have tried squeezing to the point of crushing the case in to get it to contact the edge of the WSD to see if I have to worry about the case making the protector lift. It will not touch. The WSD will work with any case.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] OnlinePredator:
Stuff Whitestone lol https://www.amazon.com.au/gp/aw/d/B...pixel+2+xl&dpPl=1&dpID=51d75TBqcyL&ref=plSrch

$109 just for a screen.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] jonstrong:
That's weird. $109 AUD converts to something like $84 US dollars...which is almost twice what the WSD protector is selling for on Amazon in the US (currently $44 USD). Doesn't make sense.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] OnlinePredator:
Yea it's a rip off here. I would rather get a $5 plastic 3 pack. Everyone recommending Whitestone, but don't realise how expensive it is in other countries.

I could get an I for $44aud or a Whitestone glass only for $109.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] SyCoREAPER:
I got 2 Wetsone protectors as well on Amazon (for $40 each, Amazon had a coupon, not sure if they still do) and installed the first protector and mine came out perfect. Was nervous as hell doing it but it isn't as difficult as it seems.

Now I have to do my moms phone and am really nervous because:

I didn't follow the instructions 100% but it came out perfect. I had either dirt or a small bubble so I was pushing down on it after dropping the screen to get it out, which I eventually did but obviously results in less adhesive because it ran out the edges. . On the other hand, it was so much that came out that it begs the question of if it needs that much in the first place.

Might decide to do the same on hers.

TIP

Because I just did it. Do NOT obsess about any residual glue once cured, you will end up pulling it from under the glass with it. I just did it but it was a tiny amount in a non important area. F'ing OCD
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] outbackpaul:
I've put two on now and each order had different amounts of glue that came out of the bottle.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] CBMC:
If you pulled a little glue from around the edge there is a fix. If you have a little extra adhesive you can use a credit card (or something similar) to put some more adhesive on that area. You don't need much and you just need to touch the adhesive to the area. The liquid should fill in the area where the adhesive pulled out. Cure the adhesive when done.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] SyCoREAPER:
Thanks, I'll give it a try
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] CBMC:
Worked well for me. I did the same thing scrubbing at the gummy adhesive.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] clothednblack:
Been using Zagg for years, never had a problem, not 1, till I used it on the XL2. 1st one was my fault, dropped my phone, landed on the side of the case and cracked the protector. Sucked because the case took the impact yet the screen protector cracked. Got my replacement using the life time warranty. 2nd one cracked while in my hoodie mowing the lawn, and that was the last straw. Just installed the Whitestone dome protector and it looks amazing and the feel is absolutely perfect. No rainbow under it, no distortion from looking at an angle and no dot matrix. Works perfectly with the Otterbox case, I'm totally impressed. Thank you to all of you that mentioned this brand and for the reviews, I'm definitely happy with this purchase.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Schroeder09:
It's definitely a great product that really enhances the experience. Never thought is care so much about a freaking screen protector, but it really enhances the experience. If it didn't do anything in the area of protection, I'd still recommend it for how well it repels oil, how it feels, and how slick it makes the phone look. It looks and feels better than a bare screen.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] BabeShaq:
I have a huge problem with the whitestone. The corners started to crack by itself. I always keep my phone in an empty pocket and never droped it. But the corners still finds a way to crackle. The worst part is that the cracks started to expand recently. God i wish this protector would cost around 12 pounds...
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Schroeder09:
I know we already talked about this, but I can't imagine carrying this big phone in my pocket. How do you sit down? I use the goofy dad-IT-guy holster. Yes, it cramps my style, but something like what you describe will never happen with it. The phone is flexing in your pocket.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] ilal2ielli:
Mine cracks at the corners too. Others thought I was doing something wrong, but mine is in a loose front pocket or a jacket breast pocket and I remove it before sitting down anywhere.

I'm sure it's manufacturer tolerances on the screen near the corners. If not enough LOCA is supporting the corners of the screen protector, it is probably prone to cracking there.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Schroeder09:
I'll keep that theory in mind. So far so good for me. Again, I use the OtterBox defender and its holster.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] SpeederT12:
Hiya, new 2XL user here. I'm honestly rather clumsy and am afraid of damaging this phone, so I bought the Ringke Fusion and amFilm Tempered glass protector and while the case is great I need a better protector. For one, the dot matrix is really visible and the airgap between the phone and glass protector has some dust specks in there. Also due to the airgap the screen lost its prefect blacks which I really liked before applying the protector. Lastly, the oleophobic coating kinda sucks, easily destroying visibility due to the thousand accumulated fingerprints. Tl;dr : a not-great protector. Problem is, I cannot find another better one in this price range. The whitestone is too expensive and want a decent cheap one. Suggestions?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] kellybrf:
unfortunately, you pay for what you get with the 2xl. the amfilm is regarded as one of the "best" of the cheap protectors, so if you want something better you're going to need to step up to the Whitestone.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] jonstrong:
What I find bizarre about the state of the market for Pixel 2 XL screen protectors is the inability of manufacturers to simply introduce a product that works as easily and well as the TGSP's for the vast majority of other phones.

I've experienced that awful edge-only adhesive protectors, along with their air gaps, dot matrix grids and all the associated problems. I've tried the InvisShield, and while promising, it seems to a challenge for most people reporting in here (and was for me) -- I know some have reported miraculously problem-free installations, but that hasn't been my experience: I've found the process quite messy, time consuming, and ultimately frustrating as edges lift and/or micro-gaps start appearing around the perimeter after a few weeks (and I've tried this 3 times now). No doubt some can get this to work, and I appreciate the customer support, but it hasn't worked out for me.

Whitestone Dome offers a simpler install procedure due to 1) including the installation jig and spacers (which all add to the cost), and I see less complaints about this TGSP (but more complaints about their approach to customer service). I've seen a few posts indicating eventual problems with micro LOCA separation, but seemingly less with this than with InvisShield (though SGFreshIdea seems to offer more responsive customer support). Still seems to be more of a hobbyist item than mass market phone accessory aimed at the general audience.

The challenge seems to be due to the fact that the Pixel 2 XL has curved edges on top and bottom as well as left and right sides, making it tough to produce a protector that covers the entire glass (and all four curved edges). Whitestone Dome sidesteps the issue by offering a slightly smaller TGSP that spans the display portion of the glass -- and stops short of the curved edges, so the glass protector can be a simply flat piece -- much easier to glue down.

So -- why is it that NONE of the companies selling normal dry-adhesive (spanning the entire underside -- not just edges) glass can't simply make one the same size as the Whitestone Dome Glass TGSP, crystal clear with NO black borders, no curved edges (but all edges burnished / rounded smooth) -- just something that lays down flat on the flat portion of the P2XL screen, and adheres uniformly across the surface -- like ALL the prior decent products in the market? It should be possible to do this, and sell them for a few dollars. Seems to me that this would be an ideal, and inexpensive, solution to the problem.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Digital DJ:
I too have tried a few different screen protectors and have had no luck. I lose control of the phone options as My Pixel 2XL always thinks I'm on the phone (phone up to my ear) and continuously shuts off the screen. I have all but given up on finding a screen protector for this device. I have only hope that I don't drop it, and if I do drop it, I hope the Corning® Gorilla® Glass 5 actually does its job and holds up.

I believe phone insurance is a rip-off so I don't have it. I do keep my device in a case made by Caseology. It does an excellent job protecting my GP2XL.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] EeZeEpEe:
Nearly 6 months and not one micro scratch for me. It's doing the job very well.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] kellybrf:
because of the curvature of the screen. flat screens mean easy, cheap flat full adhesive protectors. but, the viewable display extends far enough out on the 2xl that a flat protector rhat covers the full display will overhang the edge, aka the hall effect. Loca is what overcomes that, because it fills in that gap
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] whiteangelcl:
Perhaps it is because the glass is flat while the display is slightly curved? So there is no support at the corners?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] kingmikel:
Hey guys, have any of you used the phone without any kind of screen protector? Right now I'm using a film from Tricked Out Accessories, and while it is helpful, I'm getting tired of having to clean all the oil and grime from it. I'm wondering if the screen is strong enough to hold up against scratching without a screen protector.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Badger50:
No screen protector on mine since day 1 on October 26th. Still looks great with no visible damage that I can see. And I'm not exactly what you'd call gentle, and have a tendency to drop things ?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] kingmikel:
That's great to hear! I'm nervous about scratches more than anything. I know I'll be trading it in for the new pixel once it's for sale, but I'm a little OCD about nicks and scratches!
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] galaxys:
I never use screen protectors. But have a thin case and carry it in a pouch when on the go...
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] EeZeEpEe:
Yup.

I just keep it in my pocket with nothing else. No keys, change, wallet, etc.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Badger50:
You have the "wildest" avatars my friend! Are those musicians?? Kinda looks like David Bowie ??
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] galaxys:
Haha :D yes, been on a Bowie run since his 2016 passing. Had seen him in many incredible concerts over the decades :good::)

Thought you were going to update your avatar?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] jonstrong:
Definitely more of a risk, but... I have most of my old cellphones from the last 20 years, and only started using screen protectors over the last 5 or 6 years. Interestingly. the screens on my old phones are fine. I started using protectors when phone prices started climbing so high in recent years. But I can see, for ex, that my old Galaxy Nexus still looks like new, despite heavy use for two years -- and older glass technology. My LG G2 is when I started with screen protectors.

I've tried a few glass screen protectors for my Pixel 2 XL, and despite some promising starts, I wound up disappointed. I won't go to a film / wet apply protector -- I've had those in the past and hate the feel.

I finally took the plunge, removed the last LOCA based TGSP from my phone, wiped it down with alcohol...and it suddenly felt like a new phone again to me. I've always made a point of only putting the phone in an empty pocket so there's nothing in there to scratch it. But knowing that some people do this and still report scratches, I've become more aware of possible sources of scratches.

I noticed, for example, that although my jeans have nice 100% cotton front pockets, one of the rivets just above each front pocket, on the corner I believe of the small change pocket, is in a place that could sweep by the screen if I were to place the phone glass-side toward me in the pocket. I had always placed the phone glass-in when in my pocket, to minimize the chance of cracking the screen if I were to bump into something like a table with the phone in my pocket facing out. But I realized that putting the phone in my pocket face in created a real risk of scratching the glass on that rivet -- and odds are I wouldn't have even realized I was doing that. So...the phone goes in those pockets face out now.

Also - some of the outerwear jackets I were have zippers on the pockets, so I'm now careful to make sure the screen doesn't swipe those if I put the phone in a jacket pocket.

Net: I'm being a bit more observant about how I use the phone and watching out a bit more for potential sources of scratches. But it's become automatic after a few days. The payoff is that the phone looks and feels fantastic again. It feels thinner, looks perfect, touch is perfect, and it's enjoyable from edge to edge.

Yeah - it's a risk having the screen naked, but frankly I'm enjoying the phone a lot more this way. If the TGSPs were easier to get great results with and/or fit better, I might go back. But for now I'm happier without one.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] Badger50:
He was a unique individual for sure! So many of the great ones have left us the last few years. Never saw Bowie, but been to many..many Tom Petty concerts since the late 70's! Awesome shows! Don't worry, I'll get Honey Badger up before too long!??
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] kingmikel:
Awesome. I think I'll take off the screen protector and be super careful. I'd never thought of having it in my pocket with the face facing outwards. I'll have to try that. How does the glass do against oil and smudges?
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] jonstrong:
It's been a couple of weeks now, but the glass is staying remarkably free of oil and fingerprints. Also - instead of alcohol wipes, a product like Whoosh (you can find it at Target and other places) or something similar is good for cleanups. You'd spray it on the included lint-free cloth, and then wipe the screen. I've used it on laptops and other glass surface devices -- very nice. Keeps the glass slick and oil free.

Back to my phone though: I guess the original oleophobic coating is still sound: it looks and feels great, with minimal need to wipe or clean it.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] outbackpaul:
I seem to notice it's not the obvious things that cause the small scratches. I'm pretty sure the culprit is grit/sand grains in your pocket. I can scrape keys and coins across a naked screen all day and never get a scratch.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] jonstrong:
That's certainly a possibility.
[Google Pixel 2 XL Accessories] x31234:
Has anyone found like a true edge to edge glass protector?