yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] jenslody:
I just added a PR on github, that should fix this.

You can try my attached MagiskManager apk (5.0.3) for c4377ed with the fix.

Note: this is a debug-version with enhanced logging posibilites.
[Magisk] r0m1n3t:
c4377ed

this last beta update c4377ed is not passed on safetynet on galaxy s7 edge. but the previous update is okay.
[Magisk] s3axel:
The lastest beta works fine with the exception of SEQR, a NFC payment app, which seems to have found a way around magisk hide.

Seems a fellow user has already delved deeper into the issue, would be great if it could be solved for v13 of magisk :)
[Magisk] nick1467:
Thanks for the fix :)

But safetynet doesn't pass in your build ( safetynet keeps on checking ) btw I'm using universal safetynet fix module

Edit:- few reboots fixed the issue. Everything working perfectly
[Magisk] de.er:
Same here on LG G2
[Magisk] Paschfire:
I had infinite loop on checking Safety-Net status on v13(c4377ed) , so I rebooted Device, Safety-Net status Check worked but showed fail x2, so I followed up by Disabling/Re-enabling Magisk hide & Systemless host, rechecked Safety-Net status it continued working and returned Safety-Net Check Success pass x2.

Nexus5, DU_11.5-06/30_7.1.2-N_NJH47B, FKr108, Magisk v13(c4377ed) beta(using bundled 5.0.3 Magisk manager app)

To note;

I am not using universal safetynet fix module.
[Magisk] gil80:
I get FC when I try to open the SuperUser menu.

I used the Magisk uninstaller and without rebooting, I installed the latest build.

Can someone help out?
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Read the OP

---------- Post added at 08:37 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:37 AM ----------

Read the OP

---------- Post added at 08:43 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:37 AM ----------

Restore your stock boot img...............

---------- Post added at 08:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:43 AM ----------

Why are people still trying to use fu4%#"ng SuperSU along with Magisk!

SuperSU patches stuff, which Magisk then can't even modify, do not flash SuperSU or any other SU tools only flash Magisk, please read the op and info in the release thread
[Magisk] jenslody:
SafetyNet is another thing and has nothing to do with the timeout issue.

And what's more: SafetyNet related issues should not be reported here (See: OP and @topjohnwu's last post ).
[Magisk] digital0:
c4377ed installed on Onda obook 20 intel cherry trail tablet, although there is one segfault (full log attached):

Compressing to [stock_boot_.img.gz]

- Patching ramdisk

WARNING: linker: ./magiskboot: unused DT entry: type 0x6ffffffe arg 0xd44

WARNING: linker: ./magiskboot: unused DT entry: type 0x6fffffff arg 0x1

invalid address or address of corrupt block 0xf8814068 passed to dlfree

Segmentation fault

WARNING: linker: ./magiskboot: unused DT entry: type 0x6ffffffe arg 0xd44

WARNING: linker: ./magiskboot: unused DT entry: type 0x6fffffff arg 0x1

MagiskBoot v13.0(c4377ed) (by topjohnwu) - Boot Image Modification Tool

Root works.

In magisksu_log.txt there are lots of "dup2 failed with 9: Bad file number".
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Lmao you're using such a prehistoric version of TWRP, update to 3.1.1-0

Also chances are that rom&kernel I've never heard about isn't compatible with Magisk
[Magisk] smallKING81:
Magisk v13.0 beta (c4377ed) is working like a charm on my HTC U11 Dualsim :) I don't have any issues with SafetyNet. Thank you for update!
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
You should only post if you have issues (with an attached log)
[Magisk] D1stRU3T0R:
Safetynet working with Universal Safetynet fix v2 beta 4.
[Magisk] DirkStorck:
Hi,

everything worked great on my S7...was using Magisk-v13.0(96f8efc) successfully for some time.

Suddenly I lost root so I flash the zip again and got root back.

Than I have noticed that safenet didn't pass anymore. Thought maybe Google changed something and thought maybe it helps when I update to Magisk-v13.0(c4377ed) but still safenet didn't pass.

Than I checked my banking app it not it said to that the device is rooted (worked before the problems started)

I have attached the log from magisk app. I says something from "beginning of crash" and

I( 3118: 3222) proc_monitor: com.google.android.gms.unstable (PID=10150 ns=mnt:[4026535759])
E( 3118: 3222) write failed with 9: Bad file descriptor
D( 3118: 3222) proc_monitor: error occured, stopping magiskhide services
D( 3118: 3222) proc_monitor: running cleanup

Thank you!
[Magisk] maNiaoH:
Can you share the link? Thanks
[Magisk] !true:
Can't install the beta
[Magisk] D1stRU3T0R:
https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=72877684&postcount=681

This is the beta v2 beta 4.

If you want old stable search for V1.10.1
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Did you read the output in TWRP?

There's your problem... You'll need to flash a boot image without other patches (SuperSU, phh's superuser, etc).
[Magisk] Lordsinko:
Hey Just updated from Magisk-v13.0(54e6a79)

To Magisk-v13.0(c4377ed) everything working smothly thanks guys:) notice

Pics below
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
I'm not sure if success reports are welcome, but here is one anyway.

In TWRP uninstalled beta 3 using the Magisk uninstaller zip, flashed ElementalX 4.22, flashed beta 4. Root & Safetynet both fine. No modules installed.

Nexus 6, Pure Nexus NJH47B.

Are people who report problems actually installing properly? Maybe I'm just lucky, but I prefer to think that it's because I try to do it properly.

Edit: the post above looks typical - installing over an already-patched boot image. People clearly aren't bothering to read the instructions.
[Magisk] !true:
I know, I did it before
[Magisk] geheim01:
Hi guys,

Need your advice. I'm trying to install latest beta of magisk on my Xperia Z2 with Advanced Stock Kernel. v12 worked like a charm before.

Installing v13 works flawlessly, however MagiskManager 5.0.3 doesn't recognize the installed Magisk and keeps telling me "Magisk not installed, no root".

What can I do??

Thanks a lot!
[Magisk] bluesky1126:
Umm...

I don't think there's any possibility that

"Installing v13 works 'flawlessly' " and "however MagiskManager 5.0.3 doesn't recognize the installed Magisk" can happen at once...
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I agree with the above statement. A recovery log from the installation would be useful to determine if anything went amiss there.
[Magisk] geheim01:
Okay thanks, so how would I get that log from TWRP??

Anyways, there was no error message - or I didn't see it ;)
[Magisk] Iradj:
So as expected the same error for me to in this new BETA dirty flashed it from V13 (54e6a79), the TWRP installation was fine no errors but then the Hide problems started, also SN failed logically. Ok then uninstalled Magisk V13 (c4377ed) and started with a fresh Boot-image, but no it didn't help, same errors. Flashed (54e6a79) back now everything is fine.

S7 Edge

Stock Rom

TGP-Lite Kernel

View attachment magisk_error_20170703_130311.log
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] isn't perfect: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk...3f9156a86a2c286e0ccc66#commitcomment-22888411
[Magisk] atarek:
manager log issue

Hello [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION], thanks alot for ur amazing effort :)

I clean installed latest beta "c4377ed" on samsung note 3 n9005. Every thing works flawlessly except below points:

Manager didn't installed after flashing zip through twrp i have to extract it from common folder and install it manually.

Manager log is empty. which wasn't exist in v12.

also i checked /cache/magisk.log it wasn't exist it tried to create it manually and give permission then reboot also nothing happened.

So i suspect magisk can't create log file to write into so if any one could advise where and how to create this file or right procedures to fix this issue. or support in troubleshooting.

PS:

I created /cache/magisk.log manually.

Wrote any text and save.

Open manager and check log tab it reads successfully what i wrote.

Check for safetynet to update log file or manager tab nothing is written.

[*]When press Refresh button it clear any text i wrote in /cache/magisk.log

[*]When press save button it show Could not write log to SD card.

Any advice will be highly appreciated. :)
[Magisk] Iradj:
What's the error about can you tell me ?
[Magisk] andythedev:
Xiaomi Mi5 Superuser crash and Safetynet pass

Thanks for the work so far!

On the latest build (c4377ed) Magisk Manager is crashing when navigating to the Superuser menu entry.

Despite this, the toast prompt for root permission requests and their respective grants are working fine. This issue doesn't seem to effect functionality, more just the management of root access.

The build in Magisk log (attached) doesn't seem to provide much information, however the following logcat output may be of help:

07-03 12:39:20.762 13030 13030 E AndroidRuntime: Process: com.topjohnwu.magisk, PID: 13030
07-03 12:39:20.762 13030 13030 E AndroidRuntime: at com.topjohnwu.magisk.b.b.a(Unknown Source)
07-03 12:39:20.762 13030 13030 E AndroidRuntime: at com.topjohnwu.magisk.b.b.a(Unknown Source)
07-03 12:39:20.762 13030 13030 E AndroidRuntime: at com.topjohnwu.magisk.SuperuserFragment.a(Unknown Source)
07-03 12:39:20.762 13030 13030 E AndroidRuntime: at com.topjohnwu.magisk.MainActivity.a(Unknown Source)
07-03 12:39:20.762 13030 13030 E AndroidRuntime: at com.topjohnwu.magisk.MainActivity.d(Unknown Source)
07-03 12:39:20.762 13030 13030 E AndroidRuntime: at com.topjohnwu.magisk.MainActivity.b(Unknown Source)
07-03 12:39:20.762 13030 13030 E AndroidRuntime: at com.topjohnwu.magisk.r.run(Unknown Source)
07-03 12:39:20.766 1538 5405 W ActivityManager: Force finishing activity com.topjohnwu.magisk/.MainActivity

-------

Also, on another note. For those of you who are also using the Mi5 and reporting that it's not working, I've had no issues passing safetynet checks (Android pay is working fine also).

I'm using Slim7 ROM, 7.6.15 firmware, and Magisk 13 (c4377ed). No need for any other "safetynet fix" addons.
[Magisk] kramer04:
I just tried the latest beta c4377ed after a clean install.

Root does not work properly and I have to toggle the application buttons.

Safetynet passes only if i toggle magisk hide in setting and doesn't work after a reboot.

phone : Samsung Galaxy Note 3

Rom : Resurrection Remix 5.8.2

Kernel : Xenial

So i go back to version 54e6a79 that works fine for me
[Magisk] foosion:
That's very similar to my experience with v12.0. It's working fine, except that after it runs for a while, manager reports that I'm not rooted. A reboot usually fixes this.

By working fine, I mean I have root and pass safetynet checks.

And, to be clear, I'm not looking for advice on v12, I'm just illustrating a similar issue.
[Magisk] SkilletDesire:
Here is my error and log,

I( 3386: 3386) hide_daemon: Unmounted (/dev/magisk/dummy/system/lib/soundfx/libaudioeffectoffload.so)

I( 3386: 3386) hide_daemon: Unmounted (/dev/magisk/dummy/system/lib/soundfx/libv4a_fx_ics.so)

D( 3243: 3385) proc_monitor: hide daemon response code: 0

E( 3243: 3385) readlink /proc/7740/ns/mnt failed with 2: No such file or directory

D( 3243: 3385) proc_monitor: error occured, stopping magiskhide services

D( 3243: 3385) proc_monitor: running cleanup

D( 3386: 3386) hide_daemon: received termination request

D( 3243: 3385) proc_monitor: terminating...
[Magisk] bluesky1126:
I know what you mean, and it happens to me sometimes either. However, I don't think that's the same case. Keeps having problem in the new Magisk Manager means that the v13 100% doesn't work "flawlessly" for him, because the app is bundled with magisk. And from his word, it's the first time for him to install v13, so I guess he never has it worked with older Magisk Manager before.

Anyway, maybe what I guess is wrong, and it seems that someone just knew what his problem is and has already replied, so there's nothing to worry about.
[Magisk] RedAntares20:
help me pls

https://ibb.co/joiYvF
[Magisk] bluesky1126:
Look at the first page, and you can see the following words.

Magisk v13+ is NOT compatible with Magisk Manager lower than v5.0.0

Magisk Manager v5+ is NOT compatible with Magisk lower than v13.0

Both have to be upgraded together in order to work properly

Use the uninstaller in the main thread to uninstall any verison of Magisk installation
[Magisk] RedAntares20:
I have uninstalled magisk and then installed magisk v12 now when i try to open i go out of the screen saying that i need to upgrade mystic playstore but on the game there is more I have to do?
[Magisk] Ja_som:
This thread is for Magisk v13 beta
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Click this link to download Magisk v12-compatible Magisk Manager: https://tiny.cc/latestmanager
[Magisk] RedAntares20:
wtf ? https://ibb.co/knKdUa
[Magisk] bluesky1126:
Remember to enable core-only mode and reboot, and don't use any module until the stable version of v13 has come out.
[Magisk] RedAntares20:
When I try to flash the version 13 am from mount img error
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I'm also quite curious as to what this critical error is about. I'm not fluent enough to read the code properly, but the general gist looks alright to me. I'd love to be enlightened...
[Magisk] RedAntares20:
Guys I worked it all thank youuuu
[Magisk] harizinside:
Better using the old version for some reazon i think :confused:
[Magisk] Spartacus500:
On the Samsung Galaxy S7 edge nougat 7.0 latest version c4.. does not work properly, does not pass the SafetyNet test, and the Google Play store is not certified and can not download applications such as Netflix and Super mario run. I went back to the previous version 54 .. and everything works ok.
[Magisk] Ja_som:
Again:

And don't be rude...
[Magisk] Strephon Alkhalikoi:
I know they aren't. For example, after installing the latest beta my N6 would fail the Safetynet checks. So I went back into TWRP and cleared both caches, because I didn't do that. Upon reboot, no problems with Safetynet.

Oh, and success stories I believe are welcome here. If nothing else, it lets [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] know that he has less work to do. :)
[Magisk] KenjiHannya:
Me too. Dont know why

Device Kenzo

Omni Rom
[Magisk] aocboe:
Please fix the dumpsys command and the SELinux rule problem!

https://github.com/topjohnwu/magiskpolicy/pull/3
[Magisk] DEVILOPS 007:
Can someone fork this and compile with the changes as an unofficial release to test if it works? I might try it to see if there are any improvements.
[Magisk] atarek:
Adding adb_log it might help.

View attachment adb_log.txt
[Magisk] LittleH79:
Anybody have an idea why volte doesn't work when magisk hide is enabled in v13?

In v12 it was not a problem.

Could logs be of any assistance?

If so, which logs?
[Magisk] Iradj:
Noticed this also but my phone at least uses the HD-Codec when I try to call someone even when the VOLTE icon is not appearing on the statusbar.
[Magisk] netstat anpt:
I flashed Magisk v13.0 (c4377ed) with huawei mate 9 (last official rom MHA-L29C567B183 ): boot process stopped at the middle of startup blue bubble screen and then reboot. The /data is file-based encrypted as default. Newly created directory /data/magisk is not encrypted. Maybe taking out magisk manager apk install after complete booting can make it work. But I don't know how to separate the apk install.

The last couple message in log are:

I/appproc ( 1593): Command=/system/bin/app_process /system/bin com.android.commands.pm.Pm install -r /data/magisk/magisk.apk

I/AndroidRuntime( 1593): readDownloadBoosterConfig: 'false'

E/art ( 1593): Could not create image space with image file '/system/framework/boot.art'. Attempting to fall back to imageless running. Error was: Requiring relocation for image '/system/framework/boot.art' at '/system/framework/arm64/boot.art' but we do not have any dalvik_cache to find/place it in.

E/art ( 1593): Attempted image: /system/framework/boot.art

W/art ( 1593): Dex location /system/framework/pm.jar does not seem to include dex file. Allow oat file use. This is potentially dangerous.

I/art ( 1593): Reinit property: dalvik.vm.checkjni= false

I/HWSERVICES( 1593): hwnative_get_component_register:libdrmbitmap,JNI

I/Radio-JNI( 1593): register_android_hardware_Radio DONE

I/android_hardware_fm.cpp( 1593): register_android_hardware_fm_fmradio

I/android_hardware_fm.cpp( 1593): ========64bit long size = 8

I/android_hardware_fm.cpp( 1593): FM: get chip type = bcm43xx

E/fm_if.c ( 1593): find the id:fm and begins to open the devices

I/android_hardware_fm.cpp( 1593): register_android_hardware_fm_fmradio, ret is 0

I/art ( 1593): System.exit called, status: 1

I/AndroidRuntime( 1593): VM exiting with result code 1.
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
That's a rather rude way to present a pull request.
[Magisk] CryonicCore:
Wow dude. That's a horrible thing to say about a guy that does this community some good. What have you done so far to help besides being disrespectful and ignorant?
[Magisk] XDM inc:
magisk 13 breaks android FUSE.

a app called EDS use for mounting encrypted containers via FUSE no longer works in magisk 13 but works fins after reverting back to magisk 12
[Magisk] harpin14789:
I have a 3t. I'm currently on the latest beta. I also use fx. I wasn't want to delete anything systemlessly. I just wanted to edit some build.prop properties and uninstall some system apps.

Looks the screen shots. It shows that it's unlocked but when I click on the lock, it gives me an error. When I try to edit build.prop it says that my system is read-only.
[Magisk] matslarson:
fwiw it works for me, just added the top line to build.prop and successfully saved
[Magisk] harpin14789:
I must be missing something. I'm now going back to stock relocking bootloader. And will try whole process again. Unlocking, rooting, etc.
[Magisk] matslarson:
Do you have BusyBox installed? Not sure how FX does its thing, but it may be needed
[Magisk] harpin14789:
Oh. I don't have any kind of busybox. Just checked.

But then how are all my apps getting root with magisk?

EDIT: installed BusyBox and it didn't change anything. I installed osomosis busybox.
[Magisk] JERW28:
[MENTION=6138728]Spartacus500[/MENTION] @harizinside [MENTION=1483026]MrKaon[/MENTION] @jbs68 [MENTION=3058186]r0m1n3t[/MENTION] @de.er @DirkStorck [MENTION=2965949]SkilletDesire[/MENTION] @Iradj [MENTION=3502310]kramer04[/MENTION]

From reading your posts, it might be that reset.prop is failing for you on Magisk v13.0 (c4377ed) and that would cause Magisk HIde to fail.

My suggestion to you is to:

1. Clean flash your unmodified boot.img

2. Flash Magisk v13.0 (c4377ed) again

3. Breafly redescribe your issue with device info.

4. Provide logcat and resetprop log as described above by topjohnwu so he can fix it.
[Magisk] apophis9283:
Is that a stock app from oneplus? if so try another explorer.
[Magisk] harpin14789:
FX? No it's a file explorer from play store. I like it's interface the best. I'm currently on a custom rom on my 3t.

Hey, are you still on Nexus 6 or have you also gotten a 3t?
[Magisk] apophis9283:
Still rocking my N6. This thing is beast mode even after all these years. Try another explorer, see if you get the same results
[Magisk] harpin14789:
I've tried miexplorer, es, etc. I can't also delete system apps though system app remover or titanium backup.

I think I made some kind of mistake when unlocking bootloader and Rooting the device at first.

Because other people don't seems to have this issue.
[Magisk] apophis9283:
If you want to delete system apps, do it through recovery. In twrp mount system, go to /system/apps then delete the ones you dont want.
[Magisk] harpin14789:
That's also a good idea
[Magisk] :
Have you installed the root add-on and mounted system as read/write? If not there's an option to do so in the menu in the top right corner.
[Magisk] harpin14789:
Hi

Yes I have. I get an error when I try to remount using the lock icon top right corner.
[Magisk] gil80:
Anyone?

Do you get force close when trying to open the Superuser menu?
[Magisk] syamsoul:
Work fine here... Samsung Galaxy Note 3
[Magisk] krumbman0wnz:
After installing c4377ed all attempts to pass safety net result in a spinning loading wheel. Even android pay. The version before this one failed all safety net checks so I guess we are headed in the right direction. Oneplus 5.
[Magisk] eak1080:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] just wanna say love the effort and work you put in. Don't listen to all the disrespectful comments. All works great here nexus 5x. Latest beta fixed slow root permissions access for some apps for me (franco kernel & adaway). Keep the sauce coming!.
[Magisk] DiamondJohn:
Not that I can explicitly attest to remembering that I found a case, but also remember to delete the corresponding data directory and wipe your dalvik before re-booting.
[Magisk] huaiyue:
yes ， i am.
[Magisk] JERW28:
See here: https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=72793628&postcount=1852
[Magisk] FlavioV:
Clear data for Magisk Manager and try again. It'll reset su permissions but safetynet will work again.
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
I read the same comment but, having seen DodoGTA's comments over a period of months and having formed an opinion of his character, I took it as a humorous comment. It's all too easy to misread comments - context and emojis help... :)
[Magisk] adamhassel:
Nope. Cleared data, safetynet fails. It started out as a long spin, that ended inconclusive. Now it just fails. Also OnePlus 5.
[Magisk] biohaz55:
OnePlus 5 - same issue :(

Back to last version (54e6a79) for now and all good again.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Stop posting USELESS posts about SafetyNet or "it doesn't work", please! There's been several requests from [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] not to do that!

This is a beta thread where the idea is that you're supposed to help test and report issues (with logs) before the release goes stable. If you can't or won't help, but still want to use the beta, do so quietly and if you feel the need to post about any issues you're having, but can't be bothered to make a proper bug report, DO IT SOMEWHERE ELSE!

Now, if you are having issues and do want to help, any SafetyNet issues you're having might be because there are issues with Magisk Hide on your device. Check the Magisk log to see if there's anything about Magisk Hide starting or not. Try toggling Magisk Hide off and on, either in the Manager settings or in terminal:

su
magiskhide --disable
magiskhide --enable

If it turns out you have to do this (either in Manager or terminal) after every reboot, read the OP and follow the instructions for gathering logs if Magisk Hide doesn't start on boot.

On that note, reading the OP is always a good idea to see if what you're experiencing is a known issue, or if there are instructions on how to help gathering info and logs for any specific issues you're experiencing.

If there are no specific instructions given, but you still want to help with a problem you're experiencing, make sure your report contains as much details as possible and logs, lots and lots of logs. If you have issues installing, post a recovery log (in TWRP, go to Advanced - Copy log). If you're having general Magisk issues, post a Magisk log (save it in the log tab in Magisk Manager). If you're having other issues, save a logcat (here are some instructions on that), either when your device is running and experiencing the issue or during boot with adb (here's a good guide for that).

Edit: For some users a dirty flash may work to upgrade (from v12 or an earlier beta). But, if you experience issues after the upgrade you could try clearing data for the Magisk Manager or even uninstall Magisk completely and reinstall it. If this doesn't work, don't post another USELESS post about things not working. Provide details and logs, lots and lots of logs!

[/RANT] There... That feels better... :p This post probably won't be read by any of the users it's aimed at, but at least I got to vent a little. :laugh:
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
I edited my post: https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=72891477&postcount=2444

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] And by the way, I love Magisk (and especially Magisk Hide), but mistakes can happen for everyone
[Magisk] Floydfire:
I don't know if it can be useful but I've taken the log from the app after having magisk hide stopping to work (disabling and enabling fix it) if is useless I'll try to get a logcat.