yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Take a look here (there's a section about "patched by other programs"):

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-troubleshooting-t3641417
[Magisk] fusk:
Just tried using the uninstaller, and then installing 14.2. Updater process ended with error 1.

Edit. So it appears this is broken. Just wiped everything, went back to stock, reflashed 14.2. Same error. Reflashed 14, no errors.
[Magisk] akenis:
That's what I thought, although he doesn't mention it in the update thread OTA section.

I was looking in Flash for thread also. It apparently has an OTA mechanism that will restore rooted boot and custom recovery. Some say it works well with Magisk also.

It fails for me....rooted with super su.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Magisk Manager > Settings > Superuser Notification

and don't forget the dudettes
[Magisk] FlavioV:
Magisk Manager > Settings > Superuser notification
[Magisk] MarkTejo:
Can HTC s write protection be disabled by any magisk module ??

I wish someone can do this .
[Magisk] zagzag99:
My OPO was charging overnight, in the morning I find it rootless. After reset still no root.

Had to flash Magisk again.

This is on Oreo.

And the root was fine for days until this random occurrence.

I'm not sure log will tell something after two reboots.
[Magisk] Blackiedamus:
Glanced through the last 50 or so pages and haven't seen anything that indicates this is a widespread issue, but I first backed up my Pixel XL via TWRP and then flashed 14.2 over 13.4 beta 4 (I'm like 90% sure that's the name of the file) and now my phone is just stuck on the Google boot screen. Holding down the power button for 15 seconds does reset the phone to a ramdump and holding the power and volume down button does put me back into fastboot, but I don't understand what I did differently or incorrectly from the last time I upgraded Magisk. Any steps towards at least recovering my phone without a total wipe would be stellar.

As previously mentioned, I have a Pixel XL, running Resurrection Remix ROM from 7/24 (August update just refused to install on my phone), Magisk 13.4 beta 4, Magisk hide. That's all I've run for the last 10 weeks and it's been just dandy. Nothing changed but attempting the install of the 14.2 zip and it took with no errors and now won't boot.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Logs or it didn't happen.

It's always a good idea to remove an unofficial version before going official...

I'd flash the Magisk uninstaller, restore your stock boot image and then try again. A dirty flash of your ROM would likely work as well...
[Magisk] fusk:
These ?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yup. :good:

Seems to be an issue with some LG devices. It's known and hopefully there'll be a fix.
[Magisk] fusk:
Ok, so this means that some magisk releases just won't flash and some will ? Making it a trial and error thing.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No. There's been an update to the lz4 libraries since v14.0. Something about that seems to cause issues on some LG devices.

Magisk v14.2 is still beta after all... Expect issues and when they arise: provide logs. That's how you get a nice, stable release later.
[Magisk] fusk:
Alright. Might be worth noting that it seemed like the uninstaller also broke things. After trying to install 14.2 and it failed. I tried uninstalling and 14.2 failed again. Then tried reflashing 14 and it also failed. Don't know if that's in the logs, but it was just repeating error 1.
[Magisk] clambert11:
Try fastbooting into TWRP and then dirty flashing your ROM and the TWRP zip. If everything boots fine then re-root with 14.2.
[Magisk] cvxda:
Hi,

I'm the LineageOS maintainer for Samsung G901F (kccat6) and G906S (lentislte).

The switch from Magisk-12.0 to 13.0 and later versions doesn't work on my devices running LineageOS-14.1, unfortunately. Installing the Magisk ZIP via TWRP works, but then the device is running into a bootloop. No hard reset, just the system never comes up.

I tried with Magisk-v14.2(1420).zip today on a complete stock system with only OpenGApps and MagiskManager 5.3.0 installed . From the debug log I gather there's a stack overflow, but I don't see what the cause is. I uploaded two files:

magisk_debug.log

dmesg output

It would be nice if you could take a look. I'm open to suggestions to change the device configuration if required. It would be really helpful if this issue could be fixed one way or the other.

Thanks in advance,

Corinna
[Magisk] Ainz_Ooal_Gown:
I'm on 14.2 on my HTC U11 (Sprint Bad Boys Rom) and for some reason when I click the super user tab in Magisk Manager it force closes the app same with 14...any ideas as to why?
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
Wipe data for Magisk Manager app.
[Magisk] :
Probably an outdated substratum theme. Disable all overlays for the magisk manager app, clear all data for the magisk manager app, and then retry.
[Magisk] MinimalistChris:
I noticed that the latest 14.2 beta breaks Android File Transfer on Mac.
[Magisk] Soooperstar:
Try Handshaker
[Magisk] Veid71:
How do I use Xposed with this? I installed the magic sdk 25 for it now do I download the Xposed installer? Also I'm getting errors like " this is not a magisk module" when I try install certain things even though I know for a fact it is
[Magisk] miko12312:
Have you or anyone found a workaround in flashing and using this without issues on Samsung s7 Qualcomm g930u
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
More genius! :good:

https://twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/916959394465644544
[Magisk] zagzag99:
MagiskManager FC when listing superuser apps.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Clear data in the Manager from Settings Apps like the 2-300 posts above. :D
[Magisk] uudruid74:
This would be possible with Linux namespace support, but we'd need to change the system's zygote routines to place the app in the right namespace.

---------- Post added at 08:14 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:13 AM ----------

Or maybe find the bug and fix it?
[Magisk] creeperlwd:
14.2 fails to repack boot image on google pixel c 8.0.0 October​ 5th security patches. Using 14.0 and it installs and runs fine.
[Magisk] creeperlwd:
Forgot to add attachment
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Pixel C installation issues are known and should hopefully be fixed soon™...
[Magisk] TheFixItMan:
Magisk v14.2 magisk hide still doesn't work in moto g5

Root works but magisk hide fails leading to integrity showing false

Integrity is true without magisk installed or if using the lineageos su & disabling root in dev settings

Device - Moto G5 Cedric

Rom - LineageOS 14.1

Android version - 7.1.2

Security patch - 5th October

Logs in attachment
[Magisk] FlemishDroid:
Try to install Universal SafetyNet fix module it's needed for Lineage os, Miui, ...
[Magisk] TheFixItMan:
Modules don't work due to permission denied error
[Magisk] FlemishDroid:
Also when you flash a module in recovery?
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Wrong thread. This isn't a module request thread. Start a thread about this and mention me and include your device details, and I'll see if I can help you. It really depends on what device you have (and if kernel source is available), but [MENTION=4684315]flar2[/MENTION] made a kernel module that will do this for some older HTC devices. That can easily be converted into a Magisk module if it can be built for your device.
[Magisk] alvin182:
FC on superuser settings in 14.2 OnePlus 3T 4.5.0 stable
[Magisk] Ainz_Ooal_Gown:
Well I'm not using those themes I'm using HTC themes .-. But wiping Magical data did the trick :)
[Magisk] nathanchance:
Some nice logs you have there...

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-troubleshooting-t3641417
[Magisk] FlavioV:
Clear data for Magisk Manager as suggested in the last few pages. If it doesn't work post logs.

Superuser is the new SafetyNet :laugh:
[Magisk] sofir786:
I have a question, will 14.3 effect battery life at all, if magisk daemon is running all the time to prevent root loss?
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
My Android Crystal Ball is in the shop for repair, so we will have to wait for release and test and get logs. :D :cowboy: :angel: :cyclops:
[Magisk] nathanchance:
It was already running all the time for most people lol. It should have never been dying in the first place.
[Magisk] sofir786:
It has been released I've seen it posted in quite a few telegram forums. I'm just wondering if there something that is going to make sure the daemon doesn't stop running will effect battery life at all
[Magisk] sofir786:
Something has been implemented to stop the the daemon from crashing, I'm just asking a hypothetical question, I probably could be way off Mark.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
nevermind ninja'd ;)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you don't see the commits on GitHub, nor anything from [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] in this thread or the release thread that means nothing has been released.
[Magisk] sofir786:
Hmm I mean that makes complete sense, not even seen a mention on xda, wonder what people have been flashing.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
I posted the twitter link from topjohnwu about this yesterday.
[Magisk] nathanchance:
An internal test build.
[Magisk] loocool2:
Been running 14.2 for the past day. I can't seem to get past the splash screen for magisk manager 5.8.5. I've cleared data and rebooted and removed substratum theme. Any other fixes that I can attempt?
[Magisk] mamutal91:
Please help me. I can not install any modules. I'm using:

Moto Z Play (addison)

AOSP Extended 4.6

Magisk 14.2

XPOSED Official

I've already done several procedures, I've gone new rom 3 times. I also did tests without xposed, and in LineageOS. It's not working for me.
[Magisk] Ayush Neek:
Hmm....
[Magisk] Athus:
G5 Plus (137-83 ota)

No issues finally, just thought I'd share my journey and maybe it will help others. I had been having issues with getting safety net to pass. I finally resolved this by doing this :

Flash back to stock

Install ElementalX 2.01 kernel

Boot phone up to system and shut down (necessary?)

Install Magisk 14.2 in TWRP

Evidently the stock kernel has some sort of flaw that messes with mounting or copying files *shrug*

good luck guys! Hope this helps somebody.
[Magisk] Ajendra25:
Micromax Canvas Spark Q380

CyanogenMod 12.1 (Android 5.1.1)

I've fully Uninstalled SuperSU & also flashed unsu zip for uninstallation, still it's showing error 'Unable to detect boot image!'

Please help me to fix this. I just wanted to use a Banking App on this my spare device.

I've tried both method via Magisk manager & via recovery zip also. But not worked! :(
[Magisk] sille:
but for me i still got the root loss with 14.3 on my note 8
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
EDIT: Screenshots removed on [MENTION=8340552]jenslody[/MENTION]'s request
[Magisk] patel dipan:
in samsung galexy grand neo plus supported thia newer version of magiak.?

because old all version not supported this mobile.
[Magisk] LinoX:
Bug in MagiskManager (1420)

Suppose I have a Magisk hidelist with app A, B and C included.

I some-way make an app disappear: for example I flash a new "system.img" file (because the manufacturer updated my rom) or I install some module which replaces /sys-app/C with a dummy folder (actually removing system app C).

At boot magisk-hide has still in the hide-list both A, B and C (okay, sounds good, he didn't realize app is gone...)

I open MagiskManager / MagiskHide..he loads the applist and I have apps A(selected), B(selected), D(unselected), E(unselected)....

There's no way to delete "C" from the hide-list...I tried adding D to the hide list (hoping that the list would be updated to A,B,D, thus removing C) but it doesn't work...

Maybe opening the app Magisk manager should give a messagebox like "warning C was in the hide-list but now is gone or has changed package name, I'm removing it from the hide-list".
[Magisk] p3yot3:
Update problem.

Hi all,

I installed magisk v14 using the manual adb command line option as there is no TWRP for my device. Now when I try using the "built in" version of adb in magisk to update my version to v14.2 I get the error:

! unable to unpack boot image

Failed

This happens weather I use the Patch Boot Image File or the Direct install methods, so I figured I'd use the adb commands manually instead, but they are no longer in the OP. Could someone kindly re-post them or point me to them? I can't seem to find them anywhere.

Thanks.
[Magisk] p3yot3:
Zaith tablet. I used the adb/fastboot method using my PC to patch the original boot.img, but the instructions have been removed from the OP for some reason & I can't find a cached version.
[Magisk] woldranger:
Most confusing! My device suddenly won't pass SafetyNet on 14 with the Universal SafetNet Module V 1.10.1 installed. It was fine but now, nothing.

I'm running Resurrection Remix 5.8.5 (7.1.2) on my Samsung Note 4 (N910F). The only issue I had on 13 was that I couldn't access Netflix properly (I could see and download it from Play Store, but it wouldn't run and when I installed the apk they advise, I couldn't use the download option which is a major miss for me when I travel) but I was passing SafetyNet and the SkyGo app actually worked (I'd never had access to it on any of my rooted devices previously. I updated to 14 and then SkyGo wouldn't work either (I dont use banking apps so I'd nothing else to try).

This morning I checked SafetyNet and it's no longer passing. Any suggestions?
[Magisk] Ja_som:
Please read the OP
[Magisk] woldranger:
Which I had.
[Magisk] Ja_som:
Also this part?
[Magisk] woldranger:
Wow, you really are the charmer! Everyone loves a rude forum member!

Seeing as though you're so helpful, can you explain why it was passing SafetyNet before and now it isn't? Or do you just prefer to try and flame people for no reason?!
[Magisk] teddy0209:
It's inside the zip..
[Magisk] Deic:
the "--daemon" argument doesn't exist /facepalm, I guess the new daemon is "magisk --post-fs" or IDK...

BTW in a reboot Magisk and MagiskSU worked magiskally, but didn't mount system files of modules, in /dev is only com.topjohnwu.magisk folder (a empty folder)..

magisk_debug.log

---EDIT---

more issues:

• post-fs-data.sh scripts of modules aren't running..

• Scripts aren't running if not correct permissions
[Magisk] MitoTakatori:
Hi guys. So this is my report regarding Magisk v13:

Device: SM-G935FD

ROM: SuperMan-Rom V2.5.0 by [MENTION=5899304]Tkkg1994[/MENTION]

Kernel: Outsider Kernel V2.2.1 by [MENTION=5645637]kylothow[/MENTION]

So I followed the steps in OP regarding on how to update and encountered the same error/s that were reported here.

But dirty flashing goes well. Will there be any problems when dirty flash is done?
[Magisk] Deic:
• Magisk Hide doesn't work until enable/disable twice from the manager

magiskhide_debug.log

in this case break Magisk and root, is the first time after of many times.
[Magisk] BolintsMiki:
For me on the latest open beta OxygenOS on the OnePlus 3 everything works well and even better than on Magisk 12.

Tried both on the stock kernel and on RenderKernel.
[Magisk] brian 11:
I tried to install the new beta version and twrp said it was an invalid zip. So I extracted the APK out and tried again. It still didn't work, so I reinstalled the unofficial 13.17606 and installed the new official beta magisk manager you have to uninstall the the unofficial magisk manager 13.17606 because the new magisk manager will not install over the old one. But I have root can pass the safety net and can install mods that I couldn't before with the unofficial magisk manager.
[Magisk] brian 11:
This one shows the passed safety net
[Magisk] kantjer:
I'm having the same error on today's build

My build made yesterday works fine.
[Magisk] aLexzkter:
Does this version have conflicts with Busybox?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
From v13 there's not gonna be any bundled busybox anymore. So no, it shouldn't conflict.
[Magisk] Deic:
Really there is:

/data/app/com.topjohnwu.magisk-1/lib/arm/libbusybox.so

/data/app/com.topjohnwu.magisk/busybox/busybox (is the same file as libbusybox.so)

But are used only by Magisk Manager, aren't in path variable, so there isn't conflict :p
[Magisk] Ja_som:
Nexus 5X Android O DP2

Unofficial v13 was OK, but official does not work. Used Magisk-uninstaller-20170608.zip to remove unofficial v13 and then I flashed official, there was no error in TWRP.

(when I used "adb logcat -c" command I got "failed to clear the ´main´ log", so I hope it is OK)
[Magisk] immi803:
I tried clean flash latest oos ob and this magisk v13 didn't work for me, v13 flashed successfully, but not showing in magisk app manager, did you dirty flash v13 over 12? Any help would be appreciated?
[Magisk] hybris91:
Hello ,

thanks for the new version ....
[Magisk] de.er:
Lg G2 D802 here running RR 5.8.3, Magisk v13 dirty flashed over 12, no problems at all at the moment, root present, passing Safety Net
[Magisk] Dimontiman:
Honor 8 clean flashing magisk 13 on lineage Os 14.1 after uninstalling magisk 12 :good:

Safety net passed without Problems
[Magisk] lilcdroid:
Moto X Pure 1575 running CRdroid 3.2 stock kernel. Dirty flashed over v12. Working great with safety net passed. Cheers.
[Magisk] Fentadroid:
Oneplus 3 with Paranoid Android 7.1.2 AOSPA

06-08 13:33:43.940 9860 9860 D Magisk : client: connect fail, try launching new daemon process
06-08 13:33:43.940 9860 9860 E Magisk : start daemon failed with 111: Connection refused
[Magisk] Rom:
Very good works :good:
[Magisk] Tyrannis78:
Anybody fail xposed with this version of Magisk?

Enviado desde mi SM-G950K mediante Tapatalk
[Magisk] rheckr:
Works with Xperia X Concept (7.1.2) rom. Everything went fine. I had to install Magisk Manager by myself because it didn't installed with zip.

Also safetynet doesn't pass but it is Rom-related bug.
[Magisk] edzamber:
Perfect !

This one can be installed without any issue [emoji4]

G925f Nougat custom Rom Based 5EDQF + my own custom kernel Permissive

Well done [emoji4]
[Magisk] Ansuel:
what real thing? aahhaha
[Magisk] zimler:
I apologize if this isn't quite the right place for this...

I'm on the last stable release. An app started detecting root with the latest app release and won't run anymore. I was wondering if anyone that is on the beta would mind trying to open that app to see if the beta has the same result?

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.concur.breeze&hl=en
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Just Install it and test yourself. We are no testing service...
[Magisk] kramer04:
Just install it and works fine

Samsung Note 3 SM-N9005

Custom Rom Phronesis v6

Lsskernel 3.9

Very good job !
[Magisk] robocop78:
Works fine too

Samsung Note 3 SM-N9005

Custom ROM Resurrection Remix 5.8.3 from trader448 + Synergy Kernel rc 12

Thanks for the works
[Magisk] :
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

Flashes with Flashfire (Magisk-v12 uninstaller + wipe dalvik/cache/storage + latest v13 beta + wipe again, then reboot), but it still can't be flashed with TWRP. As a side note, TWRP can not flash SuperSU either (not any since 2.78 at least, I don't know about previous builds of SuperSU), so to flash SuperSU, I also need TWRP + Magisk-v12 first, then Flashfire.

Although it flashes with Flashfire, all the Manager shows is the first "Magisk 13 installed" part. There are no other information showing, such as root status and safetynet status.

My device and ROM: Stock ROM and stock boot (with ashyx's "no-verity-no-encrypt.zip"), Galaxy A7 2017 (SM-A720F).

Trying to recover the log from TWRP is fruitless, as there are no entries on the attempt of flashing Magisk beta in it, since the flashing just turns off the device.
[Magisk] DenyDarko:
Where is the twrp log?

Help the developer to help you ppl...
[Magisk] :
[MENTION=2641771]DenyDarko[/MENTION]

I just edited the post on that.
[Magisk] zimler:
Lol. It took more screen taps to reply and tell me no then it would to tap the play store link, tap install, tap open, see if there's an error, then tap uninstall. Wasn't looking for anything more than that?

Besides, maybe the dev would be interested in an app that still detects root.

If it the app opens, I'll start helping the beta test. If the dev is interested in being root from that app, I would also help test.

My apologies if my request put you out. Have a nice day/evening.
[Magisk] xu3sno:
Magisk v13.0 (1e87780) on Redmi 1S/W (Nougat)

:good:

Thanks dev.
[Magisk] syamsoul:
Latest Magisk v13.0 (1e87780) is now working on Samsung Galaxy Note 3 (N9005) on custom TW ROM Marshmallow (MagmaNX)

:good:

magisksu is working

passed safety net check.

magisk hide is working.

knox is 0x0.

just the magisk manager doesnt install in recovery. need to install manually

Thanks dev for your great work and effort.
[Magisk] Chinaboy5216:
Note 3 SM-9008V China model latest Magisk beta 1e87780 running [MENTION=4841524]trader418[/MENTION] RRN install flawless and running fine. SafetyNet fail but probably due to being in China.
[Magisk] kishd:
Loaded and running fine with the last beta. Going to uninstall now.
[Magisk] zimler:
Thanks! I appreciate it. I'm going to go ahead and install the beta. Have a good one.
[Magisk] koekoek91:
I just tried it on latest beta. At first the app detected root.

So I went back in magisk manager settings and enabled magisk hide.

Then I went into the Magisk Hide section and searched for ''Concur'' the app you are trying to run and checked the box next to it.

After that the app runs without problems. This should work aswell on latest stable version that you are running now.

See screenshots ;)
[Magisk] zimler:
Thanks! Interesting, I followed the same steps you did when it first happened and it didn't work. To be sure, I followed the steps again as you listed them and still no success. I'll have to try the beta.
[Magisk] vitekrus777:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] And other highly respected users. Tell me how to install updates correctly? Just on top of the install from the recovery, or And all the most respected users. Tell me how to install updates correctly? Just flashing in the recovery over the installed, or through a complete deletion of the previous version?
[Magisk] otaconremo:
app crashing update

Here's my log again for my problem with app crashing.

This time for the latest version 1e87780.

Hope this can help me find out what's wrong with my device.

Thanks.
[Magisk] Ja_som:
Why I´m a rude? Because you (don´t) read the OP and you ask questions the author has asked not to ask?

This is not the place where you should ask this, if you need to ask, you should do it in the SafetyNet module thread...
[Magisk] p3yot3:
Anyone? Any pointers would be appreciated.
[Magisk] woldranger:
I read "SafetyNet / CTS / XXX app won't work after enabling MagiskHide", (the wording used is rather ambiguous) which wasn't my issue.. I outlined my issue and MagiskHide wasn't it. If my query wasn't in the correct forum thread then you could have simply stated that and offered an alternative. Rather simple, but it's obviously easier to try to be condescending.
[Magisk] FlavioV:
Some updates tend to break SafetyNet, specially betas. And SafetyNet is considered off-topic on this thread.

I haven't had a single issue with Magisk in months, and I'm aware that this is not the place for such topic, but let me try to help.

Clear data for Magisk Manager. Try turning Magisk Hide off and back on, and enable Magisk Hide for Netflix and SkyGo. Install the Universal SafetyNet Fix module available in the repo.

Lastly, make sure your rom is updated. Don't know if it's the case for your phone but I have issues with Magisk sometimes when I get a rom update.

Keep in mind that this is not the right place to ask about SafetyNet. If you still have issues after trying this you better ask in the Universal SafetyNet Fix thread as suggested before. :)
[Magisk] ante0:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] any particular reason to remove "fileencryptioninline" in magiskboot/boot_utils.c?

I mean, was it removed because of another phone?

It just says "Don't patch FBE flags".
[Magisk] nathanchance:
The OnePlus 5 refuses to boot with that flag removed.