yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] WatskeBart:
Magisk v16.7 loops into fastboot mode on my OP5T running latest stock OOS.

Restored v16.6 in recovery and everything is working again.
[Magisk] karrouma:
Boot loop on boot with sony xz premium

Keep restarting on sony logo then restart
[Magisk] johnb380:
It's working fine for me on ob12. Been using it all day since it released. But I did dirty flash beta12 rom to get back stock kernel because I was on a custom oos kernel. So maybe that's why 16.7 worked for me. I flashed rom wiped caches then rebooted recovery then flashed Magisk 16.7 zip wiped caches rebooted recovery then mounted vendor flashed no verity treble V3 wiped caches then rebooted to system and everything is running and working great!
[Magisk] dedelamalice:
litlle bug

Since version 5.8.0 the application puts a notifications at startup

* despite this option being disabled

a bug or a nasty config ??

Rom DU 12.4 on 5T plus

the rest works perfectly

:silly:
[Magisk] BloodEdge:
also Xperia XZ
[Magisk] tron1:
Yes, I know. No Logs and so on... But anyway bootloop also on Axon 7 with AEX Oreo 8.1 Custom ROM.
[Magisk] darkgraycouds:
Op5t, stock OOS.

Boots in fastboot mode with 16.7
[Magisk] djsubterrain:
v.16.7 : Phone only boots to fastboot menu on OnePlus 5 on latest version of Havoc rom (Non Treble based), Using latest blu_spark TWRP. I wouldn't recommend flashing 16.7 just now, seems to be quite a few people having issues.

EDIT 1: Trying to install the rom back over itself but there's a Magisk 16.7 addon getting installed as well, even though I've not added this to the flash list.

EDIT 2: Tried installing rom, gapps (22nd Jun for me due to Substratum issues) and then Magisk 16.6 before reboot, rom now boots. I would suggest that fix for people having issues. (Had to re-install Busybox and enable Xposed again and re-apply Substratum theme after rebooting but it seems ok now)
[Magisk] bemanet:
the same here... :eek:
[Magisk] okgnew:
16.7 (direct install) gives invalid device PIN (wow, how is it even possible?) after restart on Pixel 2 XL stock ROM&kernel.

So I could not use the device.

Reverting to 16.6 via TWRP fixed this problem.
[Magisk] sklaes:
I have the same issue with that device, but i use another Rom (Lineage OS 15.1 - Stock Kernel).

The recovery log is attached, the magisk log (on the cache partition) is not available.
[Magisk] habylab:
Updated Magisk manager, downloaded 16.7 zip, rebooted to TWRP, flashed, rebooted and I am all okay here. On OnePlus 6, latest OTA.
[Magisk] asenler:
v.16.7 : Phone only boots to fastboot menu on asus zenfpne3 (552KL), then back to v16.6
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
Exactly. I came here to check out comments before installing 16.7 and see very little apart from people who seem capable of writing yet incapable of reading your post, plus a host who continue to post pointless "doesn't work" comments without logs. As a mod you must sometimes despair... maybe that's why you retired? :)
[Magisk] Clauu:
Good day and thank you for your hard work. Regarding to latest 16.7:

OP5T - rom AEX 5.7, no other custom kernel that rom came with it. Unninstalled prev 16.6 version, boot into OS, reboot to recovery and flashed 16.7, till now no errors. After exiting from twrp to boot into OS, it will only boot to fastboot.

Attached some logs:
[Magisk] iankelly2001:
Upgraded Magisk from 16.6 to 16.7 with no problems at all, with Safety Net intact, on my Samsung Galaxy S4 i9505.
[Magisk] Denkai:
Seeing as there's not many posts with logs, Here's one:

Reboots to bootloader

OnePlus 5

AICP nightly with Disk Based Encryption non-vendor ROM

Vendor Partition activated

16.7 installed with no errors in recovery itself, 16.6 flashed over it and rebooted fine
[Magisk] ianmacd:
Make sure you upgraded the manager app as well as Magisk. You can expect reboots if you're running 16.6's app with Magisk 16.7.
[Magisk] shanks125:
No Magisk modules working (enabled ofc) on both Magisk 16.6 and 16.7! Hope I'm not the only one!
[Magisk] chudy_85:
@op

v16.7 work now correctly on my p9 with Android 7.0.

Thanks

Wysłane z mojego EVA-L09 przy użyciu Tapatalka
[Magisk] Firedrake1:
With recent updates, Magisk is editing my DTBO again. I remember this was being done a while back, and then seemed to stop. It means my phone always has a message up, that say "There's an internal problem with your device. Contact your manufacturer for details." Is this needed? I can flash the stock DTBO, to make this go away, but Magisk just patches it, again, and it goes back to this error. Anyone have advice on getting rid of this popup? Thanks in advance.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
From the OP of the release thread:
[Magisk] espaciosalter20:
Same here. Huawei p10 vtr-l09 with emui 8.0 (c370). Also, it can't load applications marked on magisk hide.

Logs attached.
[Magisk] kjames2001:
Updated Magisk app first, then updated Magisk through the app.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
From your logs it looks like it might be an issue with one of your modules (module id is PMX). Disable it (and possibly other modules) and try again.
[Magisk] iWARR:
Recently updated (a hour ago) MM v5.8.3 + M v16.7 (via TWRP) works. No problems during update.

Xiaomi Mi 5, RR Darkness (Oreo 8.1), Darkness Kernel.

To author: Please, make MM (Repository list) working with encrypted DNS (dnscrypt-proxy). Thanks.
[Magisk] majee12:
The same here
[Magisk] yuri76:
How I solve this? Patch safety not found View attachment 4553199

Inviato dal mio SM-G955F utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] Clauu:
Issue fixed with the latest build, :svetius:
[Magisk] Spartacus500:
I have the same problem on S7 Edge Oreo, the problem with the new version 16.7 (1) how to solve ?
[Magisk] espaciosalter20:
Tested. You're right. Pixel experience module it's breaking safetynet.

When I disabled, it's passing safetynet test well. Do you think it will be ok if I report this issue on pmx thread?
[Magisk] yuri76:
I s8 plus with oreo

Inviato dal mio SM-G955F utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I think that's exactly what you should do...
[Magisk] Spartacus500:
I rebooted the phone and now the SafetyNet pass. I have a question, what does this error marked on the screen mean ?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That could mean that the kernel you're using already has the resetprop binary included. This in turn means there might be issues with the resetprop tool on your device. Talk to your kernel developer if you're having issues.
[Magisk] EpicFail2017:
Thanks for your hard work.

I have a Xiaomi Mi a1 Android 8.1 Oreao Update Juli.

I have Installed Magisk 16.71 and SafetyNet fails.

To fix it.

I have remove/delet all Modules +restart and redownload modules+ install and SafetyNet works fine me ;) .
[Magisk] CZ Eddie:
Upgraded Magisk from 16.6 to 16.7 via the management app and just get the fastboot menu on reboot.

Rebooted to TWRP and flashed 16.6 and now I boot fine.

Hope that helps someone else with the same issue.

OnePlust 5T, 8.1, AOSP Extended with Singularity kernel.
[Magisk] Clauu:
Check my prev msg, uninstall your current version and flash latest 16.7(note that there is an upateded version) from recovery.
[Magisk] radz_:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

Flashed "hotfix" but still same error for OP5T Treble.

On my device I got no bootloop (maybe because im using custom kernel) but WiFI is not working,

For others they got bootloop.

EDIT: disregard..

Latest version works fine. Wifi didn't work earlier due to kernel conflict.
[Magisk] Logix:
Talking about so.....

Thread cleaned PLEASE post logs and stay on topic!!!

"doesnt work" posts do not help development neither does repetitive "same here" posts.

Thank you kindly,

Logix
[Magisk] astracd:
OP5 now working great.

Thank you for quick fix topjohnwu :good:
[Magisk] jonny30bass:
Was on 5.8.2 and 16.7. Then I had an update for magisk manager to 5.8.3. So I updated and then cleared the data for the app. Then it said there was an update available to Magisk 16.7, but I am already on 16.7. So I just clicked uninstall>restore images and then direct installed the "update". Everything seems to be working fine here on OP6 OOS 5.1.9 and Smurf Kernel.
[Magisk] yuri76:
Unstable??????

Inviato dal mio SM-G955F utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Works fine with dnscrypt-proxy. How do you have the phone configured to tell it to use the proxy?

Edit: you should probably reply to this in the general thread.
[Magisk] yuri76:
Unstable?????
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You're going to have to accompany that post with a bit more details as to what your intention is. Is it the rejected su requests? Have you checked the Superuser tab of the Manager, to see if you've missed giving superuser access to an app that needed it? Or is it something completely different? Enlighten us, please...
[Magisk] jugoslavpetrovic:
Does anyone know why fingerprint scanner grant does not work and how to make it work?

It is like this for quite some time already. I had it working only for short time while I was on manager 5.7
[Magisk] thecoolkid:
Xiaomi Mi6 Unofficial Treble:

Reaches boot logo and reboots (never reaches boot animation).

What logs can I provide? Is recovery.log enough? magisk.log doesn't get created :(

Unofficial Magisk for Treble 16.6 works great.
[Magisk] yuri76:
ok.It seems that it concerns 2x battery
[Magisk] jcmm11:
I think he's referring to com.google.android.gms.unstable, as referenced in the logs (see end of second screen shot).

I have the same in mine but it's certainly not causing an issue.
[Magisk] yuri76:
How I solve?
[Magisk] guest4711:
Beta means for testing purpose, not for production... To quote wikipedia:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_release_life_cycle?wprov=sfla1
[Magisk] Zacharee1:
GMS is Google Play Services.
[Magisk] martyfender:
If you are referring to: com.google.android.gms.unstable, that is normal. Did you enroll in the Google Play Services beta, like I did, over a year ago, perhaps? Or did you download one from a site such as apkmirror, some of those are actually betas, even though they are not listed as such.

I could be wrong, that may be the normal name, even if you are not on the beta?
[Magisk] siealex:
Magisk Hide still does not work and makes apps crash immediately on start, see last 20 seconds in the log file.
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
com.google.android.gms.unstable is the part of Google Play Services that handles SafteyNet.
[Magisk] marcmv:
Disable all modules and reboot. That fixed it for me. Then enable one module at a time until you find the offending module. The one that killed me was DNSCrypt
[Magisk] nogaff:
I was experiencing all of the following with Magisk 16.6 and 16.7:

Apps crashing at startup, including Google Play Services.

Apps freezing and becoming unresponsive; notably Terminal Emulator.

Widgets failing to load.

SafetyNet status check in Magisk Manager just spinning for ages and then saying "The response is invalid".

Eventually I disabled all my modules and the problem went away, so I set about reenabling them one by one to see which ones triggered it.

I ended up finding three specific modules that caused the issue and the one thing they all have in common is that they all magic mount files to /system/xbin.

None of my other, working modules are magic mounting to this location.

This seems to be backed up by [MENTION=5570907]marcmv[/MENTION]'s comment above where he says he had to disable the DNSCrypt module, which also magic mounts files to /system/xbin.

I'm not sure there's anything useful in my Magisk log but I've attached it anyway.

My device is a Google Pixel 2.

Edit: Just to be clear, I didn't have any major trouble on Magisk 16.4, although I did notice that whichever module magic mounted to /system/xbin first then seemed to be stopping the other two from doing so. I've also noticed that /system/xbin doesn't actually exist by default on my device, so it only gets created if a module magic mounts to it.
[Magisk] mobileman88:
Great finding! Hope [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] gets it fixed in the next version
[Magisk] siealex:
/system/xbin? I'll check in the morning, it can be Busybox for Magisk.
[Magisk] zulfikarbugis:
V.16.7 (1671) causing YouTube app force close..on beta 16.4 working fine,, i use xposed and YouTube adaway , oreo 8.0
[Magisk] prashant2198:
Guys I flashed the latest version 16.7 through Twrp but still it gives a popup for new version of magisk manager which on installing says can't be installed. Btw I dirty flashed on top of magisk vcustom. Anyone to help !
[Magisk] zulfikarbugis:
That magisk manager pop-up update apps, install it,
[Magisk] prashant2198:
That's the problem dude. Can't install it. The download happens and tries to install but stops giving an error can't install app.
[Magisk] DanGLES3:
Change magisk manager to the beta update channel in the settings,your magisk manager is still configured to download only stable releases of magisk/magisk manager that's why it's offering you to "update" to an older magisk/manager
[Magisk] prashant2198:
That too didn't help buddy.
[Magisk] DanGLES3:
What is the version of the magisk manager? Check in settings,if it's 5.8.3 you have the latest,if it doens't, uninstall your current manager and install the new one as the modded one likely has a different signature from the original one that's why it's failing to update
[Magisk] prashant2198:
Correct buddy. My current version was vcustom version built on top of version 5.7 . I uninstalled it and reinstalled the 5.8.3 version. Now it works perfectly fine. Thanks :)
[Magisk] rakee:
My device is moto G6 Plus,support project treble，have A/B Partition. I flash the Magisk v16.7 (1671),got bootloop.it just keeps restarting and can't enter the system.it works perfect on stock rom,I don't understand why it doesn't work on GSI.:crying::crying:
[Magisk] martyfender:
Since you say you have a custom version, the Magisk Manager is more than likely signed with a different key, and that is why it fails to install over your custom version. Uninstall your Magisk Manager,

only

, then install the new version. Then in settings, switch to the beta channel.
[Magisk] Zacharee1:
Magisk 16.7 partially removed support for A/B partitions. Make sure you're booting the partition Magisk installed to.
[Magisk] rakee:
I forgot, but 16.6 has the same problem, how to confirm booting the partition Magisk installed？I flash the GSI,boot to system,then reboot to recovery,flash magisk.

I can confirm that 16.6 can work perfectly in the stock rom.
[Magisk] bagarwa:
Pixel 2XL, stock Android P DP4, Magisk 16.7 (7/19/2018 version), Magisk Manager 5.8.3 (129)

After flashing today's update of the Magisk, my phone is having a weird issue. On every alternate reboot, the phone rejects my correct unlock pattern, saying it is wrong...!!! I have to reboot the phone again and then it accepts the unlock pattern.

Anyone else? Any solutions?
[Magisk] DanGLES3:
The support for a/b wasn't removed by magisk itself but the latest versions of the magisk manager 5.8.0-58.1 believe
[Magisk] Zacharee1:
That's why I said partially.
[Magisk] rakee:
So how should I solve this problem, 16.6 is perfect to use. The same file, but flashed to GSI but got a loop restart
[Magisk] jcmm11:
There's a problem with xbin on the devices where it doesn't exist. It's why [MENTION=4544860]osm0sis[/MENTION] modified his busybox installer to install to /system/bin in that instance (without overwriting existing modules). He may have more info.

You can modify any of the installed modules to use bin rather than xbin - just go in with a file manager, change the name of the xbin directory to bin, and then reboot.

As long as none of the files are pre-existing in bin you'll be fine.
[Magisk] okgnew:
I had the same problem. Went back to 16.6 via recovery
[Magisk] martyfender:
Logs?
[Magisk] UpGrad3:
is there a way to unroot on the fly ? i cant use banking apps like barclays or starling they use other root detections and not safteynet. So i need to temp unroot then reroot once used would be great on the fly ?

Or if not possible anyone know the best method ?
[Magisk] bohemist:
Why not use the Hide Magisk option.

You can find it the Settings.

Once you do that, an additional menu will appear. Click on that Magisk Hide Menu and add the app you don't want to detect root.

It works well on my banking apps.
[Magisk] SpectraFun:
On my Oneplus 6 i get on every boot Android-System popup after booting. With 16.4 all ok.
[Magisk] lssong99:
I have similiar issue with 16.6... My Pixel 2 XL refuse my PIN (I am sure it's correct) even after several reboot... I flashed back to 16.4 and everything went normal...

Sorry but I have no better idea or log for you but I think this is a pervasive issue on Pixel 2 XL...
[Magisk] rakee:
Now I can confirm that 16.7 is also perfectly used in stock rom, any solution?
[Magisk] Brutalraw:
Magisk V 16.7 BETA on Samsung Galaxy S8 getting the same behaviour , every other reboot doesnt accept my draw pattern even though its 100% correct.

Subsequent reboot fixes it.

Strange , any ideas guy's ?

Log below

https://pastebin.com/QMVttFra
[Magisk] martyfender:
The answer is in the OP.
[Magisk] Marvino.:
I don't know if this is me only or everyone else! The recent released versions of Magisk Manager shows no/dummy icon before installing it (in es explorer) and after installing it (in the apps launcher) and I cannot provide logs for this because the problem is not on my end.
[Magisk] Seagold:
Let me see all your modules please... Also, what's the name of your phone?
[Magisk] Brutalraw:
Removed
[Magisk] foxmcc8:
The answer is that you have to post logs so the developer can help you and others with problems. This is a BETA channel.

You don't seem to read the OP...?
[Magisk] martyfender:
And I might add that the moderators often delete posts where logs are not included.
[Magisk] Brutalraw:
Aplogies , i thought he was referring to "bagarwa" Post rather than the OP excsuse my confusion. I will update my original post some logs later when i recreate the error.

sorry again about that guy's misunderstanding my side.
[Magisk] black_file:
When I boot on the latest OOS version with latest magisk pop-up spawn at boot and say the system had internal problem why?
[Magisk] martyfender:
See this post:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=77120891&postcount=1991
[Magisk] darkknight200:
[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]

My lgv20 on stock lg rom using 16.4 to 16.7 can't pass safetynet.

I find out my logging is disabled when I use terminal emulator to start magiskhide.

Therefore my magisklog is emtpy and can't provide for it.

On magisk 16.0 to 16.3 on same stock lg rom, magiskhide works like normal so my logging is functioning.

I have magisklog provided for this.

I have tried every way to find out why my logging gets disabled when using 16.4+ magisk.

I have tried magisk core only but still won't work.

I know its not the apps I have as I pass safetynet on the same configuration with 16.3 and under.

edit: i have added magisk debug log from 16.0
[Magisk] Terrigible:
If you want to fix it,

Uninstall Magisk→Restore Images

Make sure both checkboxes are ticked, then: Install→Direct Install→Reboot
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Can you test grabbig a logcat with v16.7 installed?
[Magisk] black_file:
Thank you
[Magisk] darkknight200:
here you go.
[Magisk] rakee:
I didn't install any modules, just flash magisk can't enter the system.my device Moto G6 plus(evert),have a/b partition,all project treble GSI flash the magisk,just get bootloop.
[Magisk] Braunbär_1:
Hello, I want to donate money to top john wu. But donating 20€ via paypal.me will cost a fee of 3.99€,

which is 20% of the amount. I consider this an impertinence by paypal.

Is there another way to donate?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
So, logcat is working... Could you grab one as you're trying to enable MagiskHide manually?
[Magisk] darkknight200:
ok this is one where i try to manually enable.

yes its weird the device logcat is working but magisk can't utilize it.
[Magisk] ultradj83:
S9+ - Bootloops with 16.6 and 16.7

Dears,

anytime I reboot my S9+ it goes bootloop for several times: it shows Samsung logo, then it begin to optimize apps and then back again on Samsung logo.

It's necessary to soft reset several time to reach login screen.

I found 2 logs, attached.

Magisk.log is a correct boot, whilst magisk.bak.log contains a bootloop.

Can anybody help to troubleshoot?

Can set Magisk Hide for many apps cause this problem?

Can set Magisk Hide for system apps cause this problem?

Tks!
[Magisk] DanGLES3:
For people with A/B Devices,the option to install to second slot will return in the next version of the magisk manager
[Magisk] SimplyCity:
I'm sure there is, use it daily, called Revolut. Avery single adult can have Revolut acc. Money transfer from one to another acc takes not even second and are totally free, no costs, zer0! More: you can have on Revolut only local currency (lets say its polish zloty PLN) and transfer to any one in any currency as much as you can (let it be EUR). System exchanges values for very good rate, which is actually much better then locar banks can offer, and send it to your friends. You spent PLN, your friend got EUR. There is more: if you friend is close to you, you can both star revolut, touch phones and thanks to nfc money transfer works like hand to hand.

I'm not their account, no. Just happy user. Used to make almost all transactions with revolut card. Truly recommended.

;)

Find an app Revolut in Playstore, install and that's it.

Echoe[emoji769] team member / N8 Oreo powered by EchoeAEL[emoji768]
[Magisk] rakee:
I am just curious, the same is the flash zip file, flash to stock rom can be used normally, but flash to project treble gsi get bootloop, anyway, thanks

The next version will be 5.8.3?
[Magisk] andrew2432:
I think topjohnwu only has PayPal l listed for donation
[Magisk] DanGLES3:
5.8.4
[Magisk] Kikke9:
Hey guys, Magisk 16.6 and 16.7 does not work on my Nexus 4 with Android 7.1.2.

I have tried installing it from Magisk Manager and from the recovery and neither of the two methods works, when restarting it says that it is not installed.

This error does not occur in Magisk 16.4

PD: Sorry for my english :D
[Magisk] Akhilesh S V:
Uninstall all the modules

Flash Magisk 16.7

Reinstall all the modules