yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] tdhite:
Need to reboot.

While this will work, Magiskmanager shows properly rooted info for a while, but very, very often fails to recognize the install, requiring ton of rebooting.

Best solution I have found is set the auto-response to root requests in Settings to "grant", reboot, get all your root apps to run so they are added to Superuser, then turn the auto-response back to deny or ask.

Root works fine, it's just MagiskManager is losing its mind all too quickly and incorrectly shows magisk is not installed.
[Magisk] grego3140:
I have test all kernel for my devices ...

---------- Post added at 09:39 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:38 PM ----------

The safetynet return "réponse payload validation failed" how can solved ?
[Magisk] muhammedali:
Many thanks much appreciated will give it a try now.
[Magisk] brenosnt:
My device is rebooting ( softreboot) after the initial screen (lock screen or an black screen) appears. It is impossible to start adb, I only got the magisk log.

This happens in any of the beta versions released so far, I'll be using the stable version for now until the next update or some response.

ROM: RR 5.7.4 ( Android 6.0.1_r74)

Device: LGE D410Hn ( L90)
[Magisk] tdhite:
Well, thought maybe it was.reasonably keeping root. Not the case. This particular beta is very quickly losing root for general Android apps (apks), though not shells.

See attached images (unhide below) where su is literally gone, though manager is alive and ok. An 'add shell' does obtain root, so there is a clear difference between apps and root access over time.

For example, Synapse (a kernel tuning app) loses all root access within a half hour or so after any boot. Same holds true for Catlog, Wakelock Detector, Tinc (VPN app). I will look into this, but something is very unstable with 54e... beta root access).

At least this is what I am seeing. SN passes cleanly.
[Magisk] TarikVaineTree:
I just wanted to remove the module, not uninstall Magisk completely.

By the way I'm just using AdAway now and it's working great with Magisk. Still passing SafetyNet. ;)
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Word of advice, flash modules through TWRP instead (update TWRP to 3.1.1-0 if you haven't yet)

---------- Post added at 05:13 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:10 AM ----------

Yes but it would remove Magisk and any other modules that aren't the problem, so why do that when the fix for faulty modules is to just mount /magisk and delete the faulty module folder and then reflash Magisk to reshrink the img and unmount /magisk

Less hassle tbh

---------- Post added at 05:17 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:13 AM ----------

You'd be better off writing in whichever your native language is and letting people translate for you, js, not being mean or anything, just thinking it would be better/easier

---------- Post added at 05:19 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:17 AM ----------

Did you let them have root access?

Btw js but with Jrummy Busybox you can create a flashable zip (from the main screen be sure it selected the proper place that it detected Busybox, if it doesn't then select /system/xbin), press top right triple dots, then press zip archive
[Magisk] steve51184:
I have a moto g 1st gen with LOS 14.1 latest nightly from 24th June with the latest magisk v13 beta 54e6a79 installed and its works perfect and passes safetynet no problems

My problem is I have a Samsung Galaxy Pro Tab 8.4 (not the s model) again with LOS 14.1 latest nightly from 1st July with the latest magisk v13 beta 54e6a79 installed and it doesn't pass safetynet it just says 'the response is invalid' on magisk and on safetynet helper I get red/CTS & basic integrity = false

I don't get I did everything the same even wiped all data first (I have backups) but no matter what it just won't pass safetynet
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Have you tried clearing data for the Manager?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Please, do not post your entire log in the thread! There's a wonderful feature in the forum called Attachments...
[Magisk] skylinestan:
sorry as i can't find the log attachment to put in here...so i have to copy the entire log out
[Magisk] Iradj:
Now you know where the attachment button is and don't need to look for it. And in the XDA App it's the same icon.

Have a nice day. :)
[Magisk] adrenochrome25:
Hi DodoGTA, it's the first time i hear that(it should be mentioned in the first post of the thread)

could you explain more in details please ?

at least it v12 was ok for me

(my v13 test)

is it anything i can do to help with miui support ?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/82

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/84

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/167
[Magisk] adekboreanaz:
Confirming Magisk Hide doesn't work with MIUI based Nougat while v.12 working fine
[Magisk] DEVILOPS 007:
How do I update to a newer version of this magisk beta? Do I need to dirty flash or flash uninstaller or just flash the zip and that's it? Sorry if I missed it in the OP somewhere.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Simply flashing the new zip did the job for me on all devices I've tried (S4, S4 active, Galaxy Nexus, all with Nougat)
[Magisk] Lordsinko:
Magisk 13.0 working on samsung galaxy s6 sm-g920I safteynet pass

Using arter kernel

[youtube]AVeUd9MBknI[/youtube]
[Magisk] red_phase:
i am using moto z play with Lineage OS 7.1.2. I am getting ctsProfile True and basicintegrity true but the Magisk hide does not work. Even though i have enabled hide and added apps to the list, the checked boxes get cleared on their own. After checking the boxes of a few apps , when i exit magisk and then again launch it, the checked boxes are all clear.
[Magisk] manudhomra:
Latest update works tremendously fine. . Keep it up.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Sounds like it's not able to write to the hidelist file. Magisk log and possibly a logcat from when you're adding apps to the list would be useful.

Pro tip: You're in a beta thread. Every reported issue should be accompanied by logs.
[Magisk] red_phase:
log attached
[Magisk] red_phase:
which version?
[Magisk] manudhomra:
V13 54e6a79
[Magisk] manudhomra:
Everything works well.
[Magisk] red_phase:
i am on the same version but magisk hide is not working
[Magisk] manudhomra:
Send me the image from magisk settings. Which device BTW??
[Magisk] eos:
Hi. Is there a simple way to replace a file such as liboemcrypto.so (located in /system/vendor/lib) with a dummy file? https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-details-dummies-to-developers-t3473486 tells me I need to edit the updater-script, but it seems a bit cumbersome to be honest. I can also see that modules such as the System Debloater make use of mktouch, but for one installing this module puts my device (SM-T825, latest Magisk beta 54e6a79) in bootloop. Then again I have not figured out yet how to use mktouch manually.

Lastly, there is also Cache mounts, but I am not sure they still work in v13 as described in the Wiki post above.

Thanks!
[Magisk] red_phase:
Moto Z play
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Your log shows that it can't add anything to the hidelist file because it hasn't even been created. This is usually because of permissions (read-write) issues... Can't quite remember right now, but I think I've seen someone fixing this by using a different kernel.
[Magisk] manudhomra:
I'm on kenzo, working fine here. Can't understand the problem. Write the op. Maybe he can help
[Magisk] rogirogi:
When you rebooted your Mzp,could it pass safetynet?
[Magisk] tdhite:
Root fails very often and soon after boot...

Device: SM-G920P (S6 Sprint)

Working: SN passes, root works (sort of, for a while, but gets totally lost over time)

Logs attached: /cache/magisk.log /cache/last_magisk.log, /data/magisk_degug.log

This looks suspect:

E/audit ( 3157): type=1400 audit(1499008822.366:17): avc: denied { associate } for pid=3228 comm="magisk" name="vendor" dev="tmpfs" ino=4516 scontext=u:object_r:rootfs:s0 tcontext=u:object_r:tmpfs:s0 tclass=filesystem permissive=0 SEPF_SECMOBILE_7.0_0005

I do see folks claiming all is working great -- but I have done many installs (clean, wiped all, dirty, you name it, I've tested it -- same answer no matter the install form) and root is unquestionably getting lost for all but shells (e.g., adb shell). So very confused how folks are seeing a stable beta here.

Anyway -- any thoughts? I've wracked my brain pretty well around this (the kernel is quite good, ROM is clean, but deodexed and debloated, regardless, SN always passes . . . always).

:confused:
[Magisk] red_phase:
just checked, after reboot i am getting ctsprofile false, basic integrity true
[Magisk] rogirogi:
thx

When I reboot my MZP,ctsprofile and basic integrity will be false.

I have to reinstall os and magisk:(
[Magisk] manudhomra:
No need to install os again. Try to enable magisk hide manually and then try once again.
[Magisk] rogirogi:
I tried this method,but that didn't fix it.thx.
[Magisk] ERNZT:
Hello I'm new here, I can't pass safety net, I'm use a oneplus 3 with latest experience OS (open beta edition)
[Magisk] red_phase:
works !! Thanks !
[Magisk] XuanTruong:
Work fine.
[Magisk] manudhomra:
Ok. Good to hear
[Magisk] meiax93:
Hi sorry for asking stupid question.

I not understand about Mount Namespace option.

Inside that have 3 selection right? What's is that?

Are BusyBox must install separate? Now I'm still using Magisk 12.0

Before this i try this one, problem is no busybox (i must install separate, while v12.0 had busybox) and Magisk Hide not working, it not save app i tick :(

Last i try v13.0 is Magisk-v13.0(96f8efc). Hope latest version fix it :)
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Global namespace option is essentially enabling "Disable mount namespace seperation" option in SuperSU

And, busybox has to be installed seperately (Magisk has Busybox enabled all of the time for Magisk modules and stuff like that)
[Magisk] meiax93:
Ok now i understand. Thanks bro ;)
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
Magisk v13.0 (c4377ed)

Spent quite a while going through the 150 pages in this thread. 90% of them are SafetyNet failure reports, which I explicitly asked NOT to report in the OP lol. Back on topic :p

Some still have issues installing Magisk through custom recoveries, in this beta I moved even more installation work to the magiskboot binary, since in some reports system components segfault, and might have unexpected behaviors.

In the previous beta, I cleared LD_LIBRARY_PATH as the binary should find proper libraries to link by itself, but a few reports still shows link failure. Since the linker doesn't want to do its job, I explicitly set LD_LIBRARY_PATH based on arch detection from build.prop, not using the previous "detect /system/lib64" method.

More changes are listed in the changelogs.

Something worth mentioning: due to new Android O changes, the only way to achieve the re-authentication feature in Magisk Manager on Android O devices is to create an always-running foreground service to monitor package replacement changes, which IMO doesn't worth the effort and battery power, so the feature will be removed if Magisk Manager is installed on Android O devices.

Also, I spent time smoothing out some of the rough edges, I think it should eliminate some of the weird issues along with the tidy ups and improvements.

I'll see whether this build plays well for you in these couple of days, the long awaited official update should be right around the corner!

If nothing catastrophic happens, this beta should be the last beta before official release!
[Magisk] meiax93:
Yeah. Good luck! :svetius:
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
You should check this issue: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/218
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Magisk Hide stopped working after I upgraded to this release of Magisk (And my ROM isn't MIUI, it's a custom build of AOSP 7.1.2):

Magisk log from Magisk Manager attached
[Magisk] Ja_som:
I also had this on my N7 with LOS, I reeanbled hife in settings and it is ok now.
[Magisk] rogirogi:
After upgrading magiskmanager shows me this message
[Magisk] chaostrodamis:
Uninstaller removed from OP?
[Magisk] Sleip:
Hi guys, I have flashed this boot image on my Moto G2, is this the reason for the error which I get now at the Magisk installation?
[Magisk] DEVILOPS 007:
New beta works great! Thanks so much [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] for all the hard work and hopefully everything goes well with the stable release.:)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Uninstaller is in the release thread, as always.
[Magisk] extreme79:
The error is talking for itself..

- Boot image patched by other programs

- please restore stock boot image

So I think the right way is probably a clean install, magisk, bootlogo.

Inviato dal mio A0001 utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] Sleip:
So the problem was that I have just flash the bootlogo befor i flash magisk? On my device I have LOS 14.1 running newest TWRP 3.1.1-0 and SU V2.79.
[Magisk] Chinaboy5216:
SM-N9008V (Galaxy Note 3 Chinese model reported as N9005 by RRN 5.8.3 (trader version) with Synergy kernel installed), flash ok, boot ok, safety net check ok
[Magisk] grego3140:
I found a kernel where I can make magisk work !

But ... when I install magisk my devices don't boot up ...
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
OK, but Magisk Hide doesn't properly start on boot anymore
[Magisk] Ja_som:
Oh, yes, true. It is red again after reboot.
[Magisk] jhedfors:
No problem with OnePlus One - but I did wait a couple minutes before checking.
[Magisk] Ja_som:
Hmmm, so it is OK on my Nexus 5X with Android O, but it is red after reboot on my Nexus 7 II with LOS 14.1
[Magisk] ericlaw02:
On Xiaomi Redmi 3, Magisk Manager settings don't persist after reboot, "Magisk Hide" is "toggled" in the UI, but requires retoggling to actually activate, and "systemless hosts" untoggles on boot.

ROM: LineageOS-14.1-20170607-NIGHTLY-ido

Magisk Build: v13.0(c4377ed)

Logs generated and attached as per OP.
[Magisk] flakinarist:
After installing the latest beta (2017.7.3) my time is not correct anymore after booting... It is 4am 1970.

After disabling and reanabling WiFi it gets updated again.

How to solve this issue?

Thanks a lot.

Gesendet von meinem Nexus 6P mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] Floydfire:
It's not a bug it's a feature, now you can time travel! (Post some log maybe someone can help you better that way)
[Magisk] suijinor1:
Hi where to download last magisk app 5.0+ ?
[Magisk] westeight:
It's in the .zip file :cowboy:
[Magisk] Lisko:
Oneplus one and latest beta on sultan's los 14.1 I need to retoggle magisk hide after every reboot, here is a log.

View attachment magisk_error_20170702_232456.log
[Magisk] Techie Android:
I seem to have lost root access in magisk after updating to latest beta. Any ideas on how to fix it?

"Rooted but no permissions, not allowed?"
[Magisk] suijinor1:
Perfect. Thank you :)
[Magisk] westeight:
Flash the latest uninstaller to remove Magisk completely. Then flash the latest Magisk-v13.0 (c4377ed)

:svetius:
[Magisk] Psy0ch:
Anyone using a normal S7? ( sf-g930f )

If yes, what v13 do you use? Latest didnt work
[Magisk] danilo_scala:
magisk 12 install in xperia z5 premium , magisk 13 (beta) no
[Magisk] abacate123:
Dude, read the OP and report properly with logs and more information, please. Help the dev to help you ;)
[Magisk] devil-kin:
Failed to install clean on OneplusX (Android 6.0, official).

Flashing v12 and then v13 worked.
[Magisk] Snow_ball:
Installed fine on Nexus 6p and Android Or dp3 on first try
[Magisk] Artim_96:
It looks like it can't find the loopback device. It was able to find stock boot.img, modify it and flash it back but then just says that it didn't find /dev/loop0.

I have no clue what the actual error is. Very strange.
[Magisk] StrikerFX:
I have a Zenfone 2, model Z00AD 16gb, 2.3ghz and 4GB of ram, this version of magisk will work on it? Or do I need to wait for some of the signed versions, like this one here: https://xdaforums.com/zenfone2/development/magisk-v11-5-root-universal-systemless-t3576091 ??
[Magisk] Adhil Rahman:
Same here.please help

---------- Post added at 12:45 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:43 AM ----------

Same here please help
[Magisk] Deic:
Is not fixed... I edit a script in post-fs-data.d folder and got it again...

As curiosity, I write in the script "exec &>> /cache/magisk.log" but the magisk.log file hasn't got the output of the script, but if the output of resetprop (I use in the script in the last line) that Magisk automatically write, so the script is successfully runned. ?
[Magisk] ykom:
working well with zuk z2 with jaguar r9. safetynet passed.
[Magisk] a1028love0515:
my log~
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Nope...

Neither your post or your log contain anything useful. What's the issue you're reporting? If there's a problem with flashing in TWRP you need to save the log straight away, not the next time you boot to TWRP (the log is, for all intents and purposes, empty).
[Magisk] Timmmmaaahh!:
I don't think anyone should request support in this thread, it's for development of the next generation of Magisk only. Let's keep it clean guys and avoid anything but useful logs. If you need a stable version, v12 is right here. Cheers.
[Magisk] a1028love0515:
ok this?
[Magisk] Deic:
Please stop with useless posts, this is for catch bugs for the beta, not to use as daily driver... and the instructions are clear in OP.

BTW the certified stuff is equal as SafetyNet, if you don't pass it, you haven't got certified from Google Play.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
1 - No

2 - You've still not given any details as to what issue/bug you're reporting.

3 - This is a beta release (expect issues). Don't use it if you don't have the know-how to help.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

I did some quick testing on the issue where several users can't install the v13.0 beta in TWRP with a "can't link executable" error.

I've traced it back to one of the commits on June 3rd or 4th. Flashing the 170602 snapshot build by [MENTION=2226076]stangri[/MENTION] works, but the 170604 snapshot fails with the same error.

Flashing a v13.0 beta over v12 seems to sometimes works. I'm gonna do more testing...

I'm attaching the recovery log where I first flashed 170604 and then 170602.

I've tested this on my Nexus 6 with TWRP 3.1.1, but also on an earlier version (3.0.0-1) to see if that made any difference. It didn't...
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/commit/f476daa0417eb8d870fd52b73745511a658648e6
[Magisk] teddy0209:
I've tested 0b4baad on Mi5 running MIUI based on Android 7.0 where magiskhide does not work... I've attached some logs hoping it would be of any help...http://cloud.tapatalk.com/s/593bbf2e43b40/Magisk_log.zip
[Magisk] vitekrus777:
Indeed, I tried an unofficial beta from 20170606 and an error both on the official beta.

The log is attached.
[Magisk] DenyDarko:
CANNOT LINK EXECUTABLE error.

Same case with most (if not all) cases.

I guess next beta will fix it.
[Magisk] jhedfors:
Same setup here, but I am not experiencing any issues. I DID however need to uninstall the previous version first, as the SafetyNet check was continuously spinning.
[Magisk] jbs68:
Hi!

Yes, I have a normal S7 (SM-G930F) and I'm using Magisk V13 (54e6a79) and he works fine.
[Magisk] Lisko:
Idk maybe related with modules installed. Do you have modules installed? As you can see from the log the magisk hide proc crashes after trying to initializate itself.
[Magisk] jbs68:
Hello to all,

Just installed the last beta version on my flat S7, it works fine!

Below you'll find details of my phone configuration
[Magisk] Aldideos:
Hi guys, I don't know what logs do you need to help me but I post here my problem... Two days ago I flashed Magisk on my TV box without Twrp because for my device and 7.1.1 build there is no twrp compatible... So I installed Magisk, because the Rom is rooted stock, and passed successfully safetynet... The step I made was install Magisk app, install Magisk v12, install Magisk v13. Now I'd like to update to the new beta version but Magisk says error when I try to do that... It is strange because I installed the latest beta, within Magisk, on my Op3T, successfully..

Hope somebody can help, I'd like to not clean flash etc ?
[Magisk] adhammagdy:
Other functions of magisk work correctly

I reinstalled.. still same problem

Installed version reported correctly

I attached a log in the reply above this

Thanks

---------- Post added at 11:24 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:23 PM ----------

I did.. it worked but after reboot the problem returned
[Magisk] Papabendi:
I have same issue. Disabling and re enabling gets it working but have to do this after every reboot. Galaxy S8 on Nougat.

SM-G950F
[Magisk] Chocklety Boyee:
How to disable and enable?? What is the code? I only know for V12.and it doesnot work for v13?
[Magisk] Papabendi:
In the settings of magisk. Disable magisk hide, back out then re enable it again. Works for me
[Magisk] TatesMan:
is it ok to dirty flash it to update, or should I uninstall 1st?
[Magisk] jhedfors:
I am not currently using any modules, no.
[Magisk] doomscooter:
Im using HTC ONE M9 with Viper 6.1.0

Flash Magisk-v13.0(54e6a79).zip with magisk 5.0.2 working 100%

Flash Magisk-v13.0(c4377ed).zip with magisk 5.0.3 failed

So i try Flash Magisk-v13.0(54e6a79).zip with magisk 5.0.3 working 100%

Magisk 5.0.3 apk from (c4377ed)
[Magisk] mrk2815:
thanks for the beta. its working for me on nexus 6 on lineage 14.1 with latest build from june 23. Safety net passes all the time and i can run apps that check for safety net like net flicks and android pay.
[Magisk] DEVILOPS 007:
Is magisk hide enabled in settings? Maybe try the other settings like systemless hosts and core only mode and try a reboot or clean flash your rom.
[Magisk] dimm0k:
(c4377ed) working perfectly on LGV20 US996!
[Magisk] nick1467:
I still have this issue with latest beta (c4377ed)

Anyone?
[Magisk] skylinestan:
below is my magisk error log... can't check the safetynet..said invalid..on redmi note 3 pro miui multirom 7.6.10
[Magisk] sator02:
Also working fine on 1+3 T with H2OS OB10
[Magisk] PATAboy:
Magisk Manager wont load, it gets stuck at magisk logo.

Im on G4 Plus ,7.0 stock rom.
[Magisk] lalitjoshi06:
With Module Dolby atmos (LeEco le Pro3) not passing safety net.

ctsProfile: false

basicintegrity : false

Without module all OK.
[Magisk] Lordsinko:
I had that happen to me aswell what kernel is it that u found and wat recovery r u using

Also flash unistall magisk aswell and do a clean

install did u also make backups
[Magisk] JERW28:
Magisk v13.0 (c4377ed) working just fine on my Moto G4.

module installation through Magisk Manager is working.

All installed modules are working as expected.

Flashing Magisk in TWRP installed correctly.
[Magisk] jbs68:
Hy, at night, I schedule my phone to reboot by him self (the night from Sunday to Monday).

This morning I check the safetynet.... And he's red! :(

I think that I'll come beach to the previous version with which I didn't had this problem.

===== Edit =====

I just come back to the previous version (54e6a79) and safetynet is green even after reboot (I tried several times)
[Magisk] grego3140:
I use Audax RIM with the Audax kernel

and I use TWRP 2.8.0.0.
[Magisk] vitekrus777:
Put an extreme beta c4377ed, everything is in order. I got up from the recovery without any problems. Everything that I need is working. [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] Many thanks for the work done!
[Magisk] 24imelqui:
Many geniuses here still reporting for not passing SN. Now OP will have to scroll more pages to find some serious bugs in magisk reported here.
[Magisk] DawoodSahi:
Everything's working perfectly fine with safetynet passing on my Xperia Z2 running on Lineage OS
[Magisk] Ker~Man:
S8+ on Renovate ROM not passing SN with newest beta.
[Magisk] gothicVI:
Please people stop reporting about SN issues. Op asked to do so in op and a couple of pages back...

Gesendet von meinem Moto G 2014 LTE mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] Strephon Alkhalikoi:
Logs people. How exactly is [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] supposed to fix the problem without them? It's not as if he can reach through the Internet, pluck your S8 out of your hand and get the information he needs.

That said, no issues with ANY beta on my Nexus 6. I did have issues with my S4, but only because the ROM I used was pre-rooted. It works fine now, though I haven't upgraded yet.