yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] koekoek91:
Latest version installed with no problems on my Xperia XZ (F8331) as well. Safetynet is passing and magisk hide is working fine.

Thanks.. keep it up.
[Magisk] justjr:
[MENTION=4166293]vitekrus777[/MENTION] it makes sens since worked for me and others, do a search, a shame it doesn't for you
[Magisk] vitekrus777:
No, the problem is not just me. Read the three pages ahead.
[Magisk] x_curtis:
I don't think second screen is working on any AOSP/Lineage ROM atm. There is progress though... https://xdaforums.com/v20/how-to/progress-screen-api-aosp-t3549121/page5
[Magisk] Shen Ron:
Tried flashing the latest beta and rebooted my phone but it didn't show the Samsumg logo even after 10 minutes, so I uninstalled it and tried a clean flash and it gave the blue text error and the magisk image wasn't created, so I had to go back to V12. Samsung Galaxy On5 debloated stock touchwiz 6.0.1
[Magisk] :
Causes reboots about every 5 minutes while changing. Running CarbonRom for the Sprint Galaxy S3, Android 7.1.2. Stock Kernel. Magisk app version 5.0.170611 and magisk v13.170611. Also using BusyBox that's install in System/xbin. I'll post a log next time it reboots, probably something I'm doing wrong on my end.
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
I have the same setup and it installed just fine.
[Magisk] lepicane1:
I think it is a change in how Magisk 13 roots compared to 12 (not an expert, just guessing). As mentioned in my original post, Magisk Hide doesn't work on my Xiaomi Redmi Note 4 (mido) with the latest developer MIUI Rom, so I have to use a third party app to hide the root. This third party app works with Magisk 12 and not with Magisk 13. When I reverted to Magisk 12 no issues with the banking app.
[Magisk] simono_pl:
Guys I have leatest LOS on Samsung i9300. No version of Magisk working for me to pass SafetyNet. What should I do?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Ask the LineageOS team to include setns support for the mount namespace in GT-i9300 kernel

Here's the GitHub issue for this problem: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/209
[Magisk] digital0:
Magisk-v13.0(1777d9f).zip install failed on Elephone S7 Android 7.1.

Edit: Magisk-v13.0(1777d9f)_v2.zip installed and works OK.
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
Quick Test

To all testers:

May those suffering the CANNOT LINK EXECUTABLE issue in recovery test this zip out?

I changed the way to set the LD_LIBRARY_PATH and PATH, also slightly adjusted the way to detect boot images

Hope this will fix the custom recovery shenanigans.....

And sorry for all the breakages, but isn't that the fun for playing with beta :D
[Magisk] DenyDarko:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] First xD

Device: LG G5 H850

Rom: V20D

Recovery: TWRP 3.1.1

Result: Successful

Safetynet: Pass/Pass

Logs attached
[Magisk] Ansuel:
s8 all good now and saftynet pass :)
[Magisk] jfishbone311:
Device 6p

Rom: latest Screw'd official

TWRP 3.1.1

Flash kernel

All good in the hood. SU, and safetynet working not having any issues with apps. Thanks!
[Magisk] Windforce0511:
Working great on Galaxy S6 Nougat with May security patch. Root works, Safety net - pass.. until I trigger Magisk Hide option and after that I must do device reboot to get root and safety net pass. Restarting Magisk app doesn't help. After reboot it is all ok. :)
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Where did you create the folder.

This is where it should be

/storage/emulated/0/MagiskManager
[Magisk] Magdy Yassen:
i did m8 and still same problem dunno where's the problem :/
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Did you grant Magisk storage permission?
[Magisk] Magdy Yassen:
yea .. i checked it now again

---------- Post added at 10:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:46 PM ----------

Fixed Thx M8
[Magisk] Paresh18shah:
Magisk manager and root access are getting fc after soft reboot. After soft reboot root access not available but after normal reboot all functions are working normally..

PLZ HELP FOR THIS..?

Z00L
[Magisk] gametimebrizzle:
Was the magisk manager log verbosity increased? I'm seeing some C calls (or return values from terminal input I guess...argc and the likes)

And I feel like my Magisk file system is a bit off...those unmounts go on for days...ill post the whole log if it's something I need to deal with...

I'm not experiencing any issues.

I lost root on 2nd boot after update to v14 and unsuccessful xposed install, but that was a while ago.

Just curious if this is what most people see on their logs, because I didn't before

HTC10 - 7.0

LeeDroid (latest)

ElementalX (latest)

Edit: I can't spell

Edit 2: this was meant for main Magisk thread...can it be moved maybe? Don't want to double post
[Magisk] gametimebrizzle:
Isn't soft reboot a SystemUI reboot vs full reboot?

Also, what exactly is the issue? You can't use soft-reboot because you seem to lose root?

Just an FYI, Xposed is proving to be a bit picky, even from device to device (IE same phones with different modifications, one may work while the other won't)
[Magisk] mankindtw:
Android Property Filter

Is this a good idea to use Magisk daemon as property filter by replacing /dev/__properties__?

I currently use busybox inotifyd to keep "persist.sys.root.status" zero in my module (Not replace /dev/__properties__).
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No, judging by your question you're in the right thread.

Sounds like you're using the "beta" version of Magisk v14.0. It has the debug flag on which makes the log a lot more verbose. Otherwise it's identical to the stable release.

If you don't want such verbose logs, get the stable version from the release thread (and make sure update channel in the Manager settings is set to stable).
[Magisk] gametimebrizzle:
Agree with the discontinued use of banking apps comment 100%

I dont use sensitive stuff like banking apps or crypto wallets on any modified phone, or any phone really...i mean... As far as the "bad guys" are concerned, why attack the locked-down operating systems like OSX, *nix, or...Msoft Windows... if there are countless wide open devices (with system/root access) bouncing from network to network with the exact same, if not more, juicy info compared to a laptop or PC?

Just sayin...

And if I know this...I promise the script kiddies have been at it hard.

Mostly back to the foolproof unhackable paper and pencil for MY monies lol. It's gettin' real shady round those parts and I think it would behoove people to understand the risks associated with performing tasks like online banking on less secure platforms, especially platforms where users tend to forget that they are quite literally carrying around a treasure trove of personal data...an entire life...all wrapped up in a bow for these arseholes...dont make it any easier than it seems to already be for them, if you can.

OTA injection is still alive and kicking last time I checked - so long as people connect to open Wi-Fi and log in to every single account that requires user authentication, there will be those losers that are there trying to get their greedy paws on your stuff.

Just my unsolicited advice:cool:

---------- Post added at 04:52 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:43 AM ----------

I don't mind it, I like living life on the edge lol.

Thanks for the 'all clear'

Cheers
[Magisk] naboleo:
Discovered a strange behavior : https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73773800&postcount=737

Difference between V14 and V14 beta should only be the log flag enabled, but it seems the impact is a bit more complicated.
[Magisk] tanfidzularus:
So ur saying that using banking/ payment app is not doable on a rooted phone. Period?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
I said with most it's not possible. Only a few with only light root detection methods or apps that can be tricked with an XPosed module can run. But the ones with better methods will refuse to run
[Magisk] tanfidzularus:
Ok thx for the insight. Hoping some devs can find some work around
[Magisk] Artim_96:
No, it doesn't look like there will ever be a solution
[Magisk] Paresh18shah:
Can't get u Sir..

I jus wann say that, When i do soft reboot not systemUI reboot then i lose the root access and if i do full reboot than i get the root access again.

I am asking this Bcoz after installing any xposed module i prefer to do a soft reboot rather than full reboot nd it takes less time to start the system compare to full reboot...?

(And what is FYI??)??
[Magisk] Strephon Alkhalikoi:
FYI: For Your Information

The solution is simple here: don't use Xposed. Find a different and better way to accomplish the task than a hack which is more trouble than it's worth.
[Magisk] tanfidzularus:
Why so? Do u think the "goal" are not that worth it for devs?

Compare to the effort, time & benefits ?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Because the cygote service is detected by SN. It could only be hidden if you could give it but you can't unmount it as easy as root and other Magisk modules. So as long as no dev can come up with a revolutionary new approach to hide it there is no chance that it will ever be possible. The best thing that can be done is that systems XPosed doesn't had to be uninstalled, only deactivated. You still have to reboot but there will no recompiling kick in for that so it will be quite fast.

And it already takes way too long to adapt XPosed, Oreo is out and XPosed for Nougat is still not finished.
[Magisk] mika91:
What? No root and no custom recovery needed?

So if I only unlock the bootloader of my Nexus 5X, I'll be able to install Magisk and my device will keep reveicing the OTA?

If it's true, I'll go back to stock tonight, and install magisk ^^

Thanks
[Magisk] krule031:
Hey guys.

Just wanted to ask a question.

Did anyone try this on Huawei P10 Lite?
[Magisk] gothicVI:
Have you searched the thread?

Gesendet von meinem Moto G 2014 LTE mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] krule031:
Yes I did, no results find.

That is why I posted. :)
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Post your logs

Also js but a lot of apps and such things don't work with soft reboot due to the way it works vs a full reboot

---------- Post added at 02:58 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:51 PM ----------

Actually I'm pretty sure there is since the magisk moduled version of xposed sdk25 doesn't show up as unofficial
[Magisk] tanfidzularus:
So, if you want to check your bank balance on the road that then by all means, go for it...but now you can make a more informed decision and possibly understand why your bank has gone to such lengths to block usage with the mods you currently have installed. It's for your protection, in case that's not clear.

I'm not lecturing you, but damn, people need to wake up and stop making it so easy for these people to steal everything you have with a couple mouse clicks.

Wow. Didn't mean for that to go on and on and on like that.[/QUOTE]

It's cool man, thx for the "Lecture" ;).

I'm not saying its not possible, I'm quoting others opinions.

But I agree that payment app & private information are always a target.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Official or unofficial had nothing to do with passing SafetyNet. There is a Module to pass CTS profile match, but you can't pass basic integrity
[Magisk] tanfidzularus:
Thx for ur response. But this is beyond me. I'm just a user. Not IT guy
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
[MENTION=6610571]gametimebrizzle[/MENTION]

Sadly it's the problem with big old ass companies, ran by old people that run outdated devices, that still use faxing, that still use windows xp or vista or whatever else, it's 2017 but all these companies and such other people are still living in the past, thinking what they're using is good enough and foolproof, hackproof.

The Equifax breach is a good example as to why everyone should be forced by law to make their damned systems secure (and honestly security firms should get paid big bucks to go around double checking peoples stuff to make sure it all checks out and

Tbh they should all get security inspections just like how restaurants and etc get sanitary and health inspections, fail the security inspection and by law you should be fined, fail it too many times and get your business shut down.

---------- Post added at 03:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:08 PM ----------

My comment has nothing to do with safetynet, all i pointed out was that yes there's an xposed build for Android N for use with magisk
[Magisk] Paresh18shah:
i hope this will help.....?
[Magisk] guest4711:
FYI - For Your Information

RFC - Request For Comments
[Magisk] vincentallen2:
I'm on a Nexus 6P on 8.0

Whenever I tap on the superuser tab, magisk crashes and asks to restart the app. Is there a way to prevent this?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Did you try to clear data for Magisk Manager?
[Magisk] vincentallen2:
Yup, I've even gone as far as uninstall and reinstalling magisk too. Same results
[Magisk] vincentallen2:
Just did a fresh one http://cloud.tapatalk.com/s/59b97f82d7380/magisk_error_20170913_115322.log
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
That's not an actual logcat
[Magisk] Whitemankpi:
Please help. Everytime I try to install a module, I got the message "Magisk is not activated...".

Phone Xiaomi 5s

Firmware: Nexus experience 7.1
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Then send the logs...
[Magisk] manos78:
Hi,

I'm glad to confirm that with a "f2fs" patched kernel the Magisk mount error is fixed.

If you have a Moto G5+ with a Stock ROM, then you can install this kernel and Magisk v14.0 will work:

http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73783900&postcount=483

As a bonus, the SafetyNet check is passed

without

using any third-party module!

Regards.
[Magisk] AndroidDeveloperLB:
To the creator of Magisk, please consider the next features:

1. Ability to create a shortcut on the launcher, to go directly to the "SuperUser" section.

2. Ability to remember apps rules of SuperUser, even if they got uninstalled and installed. This is useful for people who come back to apps that were removed, and for developing apps that use root. At the very least, let those "ghost" rules live for a day or two, before actually being removed.
[Magisk] LTMendarynas7:
Anyone else having a problem with V4A not working on oreo?
[Magisk] kastik4:
any chance of fbe support in nexus 5x and nexus 6p
[Magisk] Magdy Yassen:
guys need help please when i installed magisk from recovery and there no problem in install but on rom it's says magisk not installed .. i tryed to install from magisk manger and it's says successful and after reboot it's shows magisk not installed again .. my phone z2 and using eXistenZ Rom
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Fbe?

---------- Post added at 11:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:03 PM ----------

Then post logs of the installation
[Magisk] Magdy Yassen:
It installs fine for me, but Magisk Manager can't detect installed Magisk
[Magisk] :
Xposed has been finished unofficially for Nougat for quite a while now. It's just the main project, which is completely run by rovo89, is a lot slower because he lacks interest/time and doesn't have much help. Unofficial Nougat xposed projects from my experience work perfectly for my oneplus one.

---------- Post added at 02:03 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:51 AM ----------

sometimes the only way to accomplish a task is by using xposed. You may not know of it, but the project micro g requires signature spoofing which you would usually need to compile your own rom to implement support, but there's an xposed module available that flawlessly integrates it, all you have to do is check a box to enable the module. Micro g is pretty important project for those who don't want to give google root permissions over their android device by integrating their proprietary gapps spynet api in to their rom. Instead, it creates an open-source alternative that imitates proprietary gapps and strips all the personally identifying information from GCM. It even lets you completely turn off GCM if you don't want to use it, or select which apps have access to it and when. The possibilities are endless with xposed and it would make me sad to see it go. There are certain implementations of it that are very clean like the magisk module that are very easy to install and uninstall without permanently changing anything, just like how xposed works with xposed modules. I also forgot to mention youtube adaway and background playback xposed modules, which allow me to cleanly install youtube as a user app instead of giving it system permissions (like the modified app on xda requires) which allows me to greenify youtube with the privileged greenify I have installed through magisk. Other modules like xprivacy still don't have an alternative on android. There's absolutely no way to block what data an app can read about your system other than the sad joke of a permissions system introduced in android MM. Xprivacy allows me to to send fake data and block identification of my phone, access to my media, camera, location, microphone, calling, and accounts to name a few. Unfortunately xprivacy isn't maintained anymore due to a limitation that was reached with the xposed framework. Which is again why I wish there was a better alternative, like a magisk module that integrates a permission system like xprivacy but systemlessly, building off of privacyguard and the permissions system introduced in MM.

Until there's a better alternative to how easy, versatile, and convenient xposed is, I hope it's here to at least keep getting updated through magisk.
[Magisk] Strephon Alkhalikoi:
The only way to accomplish a task is to dig into the Android source code and bend it to your will. Xposed as you note is easy, and taking the easy way out has done significant damage to the Android development scene. The quicker Xposed dies off the better.
[Magisk] jenslody:
And if possible a logcat from boot (with adb logcat > logfile.txt) if possible, at least from the start of the boot, as Magisk should kick in very early.
[Magisk] opz187:
people are holding onto xposed like when Google killed off tablet UI yrs back. let it die. I mean rovo couldn't be more transparent with his growing disinterest in the project. yet he seems completely unwilling to pass the torch to a more capable dev with more opportunity to build on it
[Magisk] RASTAVIPER:
Totally lost you there.

I am trying to discover which folder/file you are talking about for solving the bootloop problem with Magisk 14 and Xposed, but no luck.

Should there be a specific file under magisk folder in Root?

There is no System folder there.

Unleashed by ONEPLUS 3T rooted
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Look in the module directory (under /magisk), in the module's system folder. If there are any files or folders in the root of the system folder that you don't normally find on your device you'll most likely end up in a bootloop. Magisk v14.0 can't Magic Mount new files or folders to the root of /system.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
I can add new files to the root of /system without any issues and I don't have bootloop issues with Xposed v87.2 by topjohnwu (on Magisk v14.0 release build)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Then you're one of the lucky ones... Hence why I wrote "most likely". :p
[Magisk] kastik4:
yeah TWRP doesn't support fbe(file based encryption)so the only way to go is by making a boot.img from the magisk app but because the android gets booted up before the files are completely decrypted the magisk files don't get created and you run into some problems like not being able to install magisk modules root is working properly through
[Magisk] tobi103:
Hi! I'm in magisk v13.3 now . I want to update to v14 via magisk manager but it doesn't respond when I choose "Download Zip Only" or " Direct Install". Does anyone know how to fix this problem?
[Magisk] Borfas:
After restore backup Rom not work for download module.... can fix ? Galaxy s8
[Magisk] pinvok3:
Hey there.

I try to install Magisk 14 on my Xperia X (F5121)

Android Version: 7.0

Build Number: 34.2.A.2.69

Fresh installed Stock ROM, unlocked bootloader, flashed stock kernel from the same installed firmware with my patched in DRM Keys.

I had tried to install Magisk with the unpatched stock kernel, but I got errors that I can't flash the stock kernel. It worked when I had used the DRM fixed one. I have used the TA-POC tool and the DRM is working correctly.

The installation seems to exit successfully. The boot image gets patched, no errors or warnings are shown.

However Magisk Manager shows "No installation found", and "No root". It only does when I install SuperSU beside - something I had hoped to get around to, so I can pass SafetyNet.

As I am not allowed to post URLs I have to cut them a bit, sorry!

I have searched around the web and only found a few GitHub Issues which are now only available in Google Cache.

Both of them report problems with Sony Xperia phones.

I have added the links into the Pastebin boot log.

The boot log shows several permission errors as you can see here:

pastebin-com/YrR0SQGb

Has someone got it working and could give me a hint or two? I'm sure I can give you all the information you need. By the way, Magisk 13 behaves the same.

Thanks in advance!
[Magisk] gothicVI:
Flash manually?

Gesendet von meinem Moto G 2014 LTE mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] lordlad:
i just updated to september oreo OTA on my Nexus 6P stock and flashed magisk 14 and got ctsprofile false although basicintegrity is true. Is still a known issue?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Since when is TWRP not working with Android 7's encryption? I mean every device shipping with 7 are already required to be encrypted. And you can just see decrypt it (I think you need to wipe /data) and flash Magisk without keep force-encrypt and it will stop the device to encrypt the storage on the next bootup
[Magisk] tobi103:
Could you please give me more details ? thank
[Magisk] guest4711:
Download the actual zip (see post #1) and save it. Then boot into TWRP (your recovery), select "installl" and select the zip you've downloaded. If you do not see it, make sure your choice is "install zip" and not "install image". Swipe to confirm flashing, watch the log, notice any problems and reboot. Enjoy the new version.
[Magisk] goRt:
Can confirm 14.0 (1400) also still breaks VoLTE on S8, removing Magisk enables the function, can't get it working hiding anything/everything.
[Magisk] OrzBus:
I was able to temporarily bypass this problem by installing one of the modules from the "Downloads" section in magisk manager. It's called "universal safetynet Fix" by Deiki. Android will give you an error message after each reboot but atleast cts will be true ? Hope it helped !
[Magisk] kastik4:
every device is required to be encrypted with fde (full disk encryption) not fbe
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Till M, yes. On N+ for all I know they relieved it with fbe
[Magisk] danilo_scala:
i have same problem in xperia z5 premium, only install magisk 12 but no pass safetynet, version 13x and 14 no install
[Magisk] mochamoo:
[/COLOR]

\\

Had the same issue on a 6p with Sept Oreo security update. This module worked to make cts true. Thx for the tip. Is there a more permanent fix?
[Magisk] RASTAVIPER:
There is no directory called "module".

Under magisk there are different folders for Appsystemizer, dozegms etc.

No single files exist there and still get a bootloop when I update Magisk to 14.

Maybe I need to do something with Xposed?

Unleashed by ONEPLUS 3T rooted
[Magisk] Strephon Alkhalikoi:
He's using "module" as a placeholder name. Replace it with the name of the module, e.g. v4a for Viper4Android.

As for Xposed, the best thing to do with it is to uninstall it.
[Magisk] denogun:
Bootloop with OP3T and SDK 25 xposed 87.0 purifyOS build :(
[Magisk] rochian_adrian:
From 12pm today safetynet test fail.... Xiaomi mi6

It pass without magisk installed. Uninstall and reinstall but it still fail.
[Magisk] koko115:
How disable magisk without remove all modules and turn on after reboot ?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Flash your stock boot.img
[Magisk] koko115:
Only this way ?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Yes. Magisk isn't supposed to be tuned of. If you just want to stop modules etc from working you can use the core only mode. But that preserves root I think
[Magisk] op3n:
hei guys. when i try to install or download a module via manager magisk, its give to me process error. That happen also in customs roms, and now on stock rom;
[Magisk] guest4711:
Did you search in this thread? I think you are missing a folder in sdcard named "MagiskManager"...

/sdcard/MagiskManager/
[Magisk] op3n:
ooo, my bulgarian neighbour ...ill search someday. thanks