yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] kevinlor:
Not working.

I cannot go through safetynet check. It can let me pass only after flashing Magisk uninstaller. I found out one problem is that the magisk hide keeps uncheck google play and google framework service even I kept turning them on. Not sure if these are causing safetynet to fail.
[Magisk] metallicant:
Android O with September 2017 security patch update causes ctsProfile false in SafetyNet check. Any possible fix???
[Magisk] OrzBus:
As mentionned above I was able to temporarily bypass this problem by installing one of the modules from the "Downloads" section in magisk manager. It's called "universal safetynet Fix" by Deiki. Android will give you an error message after each reboot but atleast cts will be true ? Hope it helped !
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Neither of those are needed on the Hide list to pass SafetyNet.

Magisk log? Logs or it didn't happen...
[Magisk] metallicant:
I read the post once I had already posted. I'll wait and see if a new beta update drops in the near future and if not I'll go with the fix... Thanks
[Magisk] koraymers:
Deleted.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Why double-/cross- posting?

Perhaps your /system partition is mounted r/o. Some filemanager depend on busybox to remount it r/w... Or try MiXplorer from XDA: MiXplorer - https://labs.xda-developers.com/store/app/com.mixplorer
[Magisk] R8xx:
Can't extract boot.img

Hello all :) ... i was tried to install magisk 14 on my vivo v5 ( mtk6750 ) with twrp 3.1.1-0

i got this error .. did anyone know how to fix this ??

Thanks before... :D
[Magisk] Strephon Alkhalikoi:
From appearances your boot image is encrypted, preventing Magisk from unpacking it to patch it. I don't believe this to be a Magisk issue.
[Magisk] R8xx:
Thx for the reply ... any idea to decrypt the boot.img ??

Thanks before :)
[Magisk] Astatin13:
Same problem with os 4.1.7 so I back to v13.3 any solution?
[Magisk] loner.:
Uh huh
[Magisk] Strephon Alkhalikoi:
Check in the forums for your device. As noted, this isn't a Magisk problem, so we're not the people to ask.
[Magisk] pupido:
Same error with my LG G5 (Nogaut stock).

Magisk is incompatible with LG G5!
[Magisk] poixninja:
That looks like the cpio built into your TWRP isn't functioning, ask the maintainer of your TWRP if he can take a look at it maybe? If you want to test it yourself, try extracting a cpio-compressed file from TWRP. Willing to help in pm if you need it
[Magisk] RASTAVIPER:
Unless you can propose another way for running Amplify and other Xposed modules, your post doesn't help much, isn't it?

Unleashed by ONEPLUS 3T rooted
[Magisk] Strephon Alkhalikoi:
Actually it does. For most ROM developers, standard operating procedure is for the user to not have Xposed installed when reporting bugs. That standard applies - or should apply - here.

As for alternatives to Xposed, there is only one: stop using it. If you really must have a feature, ask the developer of your ROM to add it by modifying Android's source code.
[Magisk] juan.r.l:
In PAC ROM 6.0.1 when turning off my cell phone is stuck on turning off or restart the cell is stuck on turning off
[Magisk] Alc@h0l1k81n05avr:
*Root Access Malfunction*

Hi, there. i recently restored my Huawei p9 lite nougat L31C440B380 rom from a bootloop but i haven't been able root it again properly using magisk like i usually do and even other supersu apps doesn't work. Before i wiped my system i installed viper4arise while i was rooted with the magisk compatability module installed for magisk but something was wrong; no apps showed in my drawer and the mod seemed to interfere with the system as magisk manager started to malfunction and some apps and modules kept crashing and wouldn't load so i wiped everything again.

Although my device can still be rooted, after i boot up music and sound don't work or play on any of my apps and flash videos on apps don't load or work at all, yet when i uninstall completely and unroot my phone works normally, which is strange as i've rooted many times in the past with no problems whatsoever. There may be some leftover files from the mod or magisk that could be doing this; I had recently tried various methods to root fully and had just installed HassanMirza01's P9 Lite elite kernel (All Variants CxxB3xx Phh Superuser v9 version based on the b380 Rom) as i thought that might sort it out but still no success.

After I reflashed my factory boot image, the phone became stuck in a bootloop and i kept flashing the stock boot image from the b380 rom i had but with no luck; i also don't think there's an uninstaller for that particular kernel or another one i can flash that doesn't have root. However when i flashed the boot image that I patched earlier with magisk, everything loads fine but i'm still faced with the same problems I had before with no video or sound functioning. Any suggestions would be good at this point as i need to sort this out asap. I've saved the log so you can see what happened. https://pastebin.com/fv0DTyDD
[Magisk] digital0:
Magisk 13 installed, but 14 does not detect boot image. Log attached.
[Magisk] resarfekim:
My company is forcing us to use "Entrust ST" to generate a secure token. I found and checked Entrust ST under Magisk Hide, but still get "manual activation is not supported on an unsecured device".

Any fix for this? Thanks!!
[Magisk] buggerritt:
I'm using magisk on a stock moto g5+. Everything passes but can't install modules. It downloads but ends up with a process error. Are modules not possible on stock roms? Does it have to be deodexed?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
https://xdaforums.com/search/thread/3618589?query=process error
[Magisk] manos78:
Search in the correct forum... this problem is already solved:

http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73786258&postcount=16

I short words: install the ElementalX 1.02 custom kernel.
[Magisk] clambert11:
I haven't been able to find a solution for this either. Let me know if you find a method. Fortunately for me I still have a FOB but I'd like to part ways with it.
[Magisk] metallicant:
Is there a new beta in the works compatable with O w/September security patch?
[Magisk] mdn80:
scripts do not start

After upgrading to Magisk 14, scripts from the folder /magisk/.core/service.d do not start anymore.

Scripts from the folder /magisk/.core/post-fs-data.d are started successfully.

I have phone this Lineage OS 14.1
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Works fine here. Have you given the proper permissions (755) and are you sure that the syntax is correct?
[Magisk] mdn80:
Yes. I copy the same script to /magisk/.core/service.d and /magisk/.core/post-fs-data.

Script started successfully from /magisk/.core/post-fs-data only.

I test simple script like "mkdir /data/1".
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Well... Like I said: service.d works just fine on Magisk v14.0 (on two of my devices, at least).

I tested again right now by putting the following in a file in service.d and it executed perfectly:

#!/system/bin/sh
echo "success" > /cache/testfile
[Magisk] c3p0u812:
This happens on sm-s920l Samsung Galaxy Grand Prime. An easy fix for me was to uninstall magisk 14. Then flash Magisk 13.3 through TWRP. After rebooting, go to Magisk and it will tell you there is an update to Magisk 14. Do the Direct Install (Recommended) update. After rebooting again, it works. At least it does for me.

I'm not sure why this works honestly (I think it doesn't make the MagiskManager folder), but it works for me. I hope it helps.
[Magisk] chugs:
I sure did.
[Magisk] VincAlastor:
When i flash magisk v14 in twrp i'll get boot loop with new OxygenOS Open Beta 24/15 for OnePlus 3/3T. Any help please?
[Magisk] andynx1:
Worked for me, thanks! Moto G 5+ with lineage 15.
[Magisk] Dchoi229:
Hey guys,

Anyone know why I cant download modules? Theres an error message stating that the magisk img file cant be mounted?

I'm currently on a stock 7.1.1 Rom trying to use the Google play service optimization module.
[Magisk] laupuy:
Hi,

Something wrong with your phone...

All is good here :
[Magisk] alexikarmani:
please help install magisk 14 and ok after install module is error magisk is not actived.
[Magisk] chugs:
I've I flash the rootless verision I'm able to login just fine. But once I have Snapchat working on rootless I no longer have access TiBu
[Magisk] Artim_96:
It's a surprise that it logs in with SN failing.

But Snapchat only scans on login, do afterwards you can root and install TiBu, it will only scan again if you log out of delete app data
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Boot image and kernel aren't the same, if you want use something like elementalx or whatnot that's popular assuming there's builds of them for your device

---------- Post added at 02:18 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:15 AM ----------

If you have tried to only download a module and it says it fails, the fix is to manually create the MagiskManager folder in your normal user storage partituon
[Magisk] jallenhayslett:
No issues passing SafetyNet or anything else, but does anyone have a clue what might be causing this crash at the end of my log? It's consistent after every boot.

Edit:

Forgot to mention, running OOS 4.5.10 on OP5.
[Magisk] =dgim=:
Hi, I've installed Magisk v14 on 029A Stock 7.0 (LG G4 H815) and I have problem to get in SuperSu in the options Magisk Manager.

Every time Magisk Manager is crushing in this case. I want to change root access in some applications and, unfortunatelly, I can't do it.

Root access works fine for apps where permission is granted.

Ok, I've unistalled via old unistall zip. The latest unistaller zip did it correctly and finally after reinstalling Magisk now - I can get in to SuperSu section in Manager.
[Magisk] Alc@h0l1k81n05avr:
Thanks for your reply. I'll keep that in mind. I'd like to expand on that post I made; I used a special modded version of oldroid's twrp (TeamElite) https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=889764386195914200 to flash the kernels, the phh Superuser 9 version, https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=529152257862726224 , and the magiskSU 10 version, https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=817550096634768996. Because they were pre-rooted, I assumed at the time i'd be able to solve my root problem.

When i was using the kernel I noticed the phone would boot up faster and everything ran more efficiently without any problems but sound and video still weren't working. Because the kernels were pre-rooted before i installed, i think they may have modified the boot image in such a way that even when i completely format data with twrp and do an advanced wipe, then restore the factory images including the stock boot image it starts up but gets stuck on the loading screen. At first I thought it needed time to load so I left it to charge overnight as the battery was pretty low but i when i woke up the next morning it was still on the Huawei logo. I've been thinking of just reflashing the stock images and then relock the bootloader so i can do three button method for a clean install of my B380 rom as i've tried to use it before and failed, but as the kernel has altered the boot image I can only use boot image that I patched with magisk or supersu.

I'm definitely sure that the method won't be able to work on a phone that's rooted but what i'm more worried about is that something goes wrong and i end up in a bootloop with no use to unlock the bootloader or use recovery, pretty much hardbricking the device. I've looked around for other kernels i might be able to flash and restore my device, but most of them are for EMUI 4.1 like Smoky Kernel and Rusty Kernel; Elite Kernel Reborn seems to be the only one made for nougat builds which is frustrating but understandable as the nougat update hasn't been around for that long. Can I lock the bootloader with a rooted phone and my restore my stock rom with the three button method or is there another way i could go about this?
[Magisk] guest4711:
You should ask on your device' thread. There you'll probably find people who can help you with your special problem which is not Magisk related...
[Magisk] vgplayer54:
Accessing a Custom Recovery on SM-G955W

Hello,

I am attempting to root my Samsung Galaxy S8 Plus (SM-G955W) so that I can use Magisk and have the option to get around Google's SafetyNet while also enjoying the benefits of a rooted phone. The instructions on the first post however do not mention how to install the TWRP custom recovery. After a lot of Google searches, I found sources stating that it is impossible to root this phone as it has a SnapDragon, and other posts saying I can root it with CF-Root which does not appear to allow Magisk, but rather it forces SuperSU instead. Is it possible for this model to use a custom recovery so that I can install Magisk?
[Magisk] Alc@h0l1k81n05avr:
I'm aware not all of my problem involves magisk, but seeing as how it was part of the early problems i faced, i wanted to see if anyone else had been similar situation and then move on from there to my device forum.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
There is a way to install Magisk without a custom recovery. Installation instructions in the release thread.

Unfortunately, I believe your search results might be accurate... There's been some discussion around installing Magisk without a custom recovery on the S8 in the general support thread and also some in this thread. I know next to nothing about Samsung's hibber-jibbery, but you might find some more guidance there...

Good luck.
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
You can't use pre-rooted kernels with Magisk

Anyways if your device just won't boot you should get the original rom for your device (or stock android if a build of it is made for your device) and reflash. That's if you either don't care about what's on your device, but if files are important try to boot into twrp and connect it to your pc, you'll be able to see it as a drive and you'll be able to copy over stuff from your phone to your pc

---------- Post added at 06:16 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:14 PM ----------

Nope never seen anyone else have such issues with a Huawei phone or such that caused their device to just not boot even after a full wipe and reflash of a rom

---------- Post added at 06:19 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:16 PM ----------

So i guess you didn't try flashing twrp to recovery partition by using your pc and adb?

Also running the oemunlock command via adb?
[Magisk] vgplayer54:
No, in the past when rooting previous phones, I've always used the PC along with Odin to do the job. Then flashed the SuperSU.zip within the Custom Recovery. I am unfamiliar with adb, however, if you believe it will work with my particular model, I will give it a try. Also, my phone does not have the option to turn off/on OEM within Developer Options.
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
1. Search your device subforum about what i talked about

2. Yes not all devices have the oem unlock option inside android, but chances are it will work via adb so please search up on how to oem unlock and flash stuff via adb (also beforehand though you need to make sure your device is indeed seen by adb, if it doesn't detect it then it's no bueno)

PS: do not flash a pre-rooted kernel or anyother root enabling stuff (like supersu, etc), Magisk already does root but stuff like pre-rooted kernels and supersu and whatnot will cause serious issues with either magisk or your device or even both because those things just aren't compatible with Magisk
[Magisk] Alc@h0l1k81n05avr:
I would like to quickly point out that I didn't actually reflash the whole rom, just the boot, cust, recovery and system image files as when i try to flash or sideload my VNS-L31C440B380 Stock Rom in TWRP, as it's about to finish i get:

write radio image...

32K crc checked failure

E:unknown command [errno]

update_huawei_pkg_from_ota_zip: update from zip failed

Updater process ended with ERROR: 7

It was no problem when i was on mm as I just flashed and forgot but it's so frustrating to be on N and be stuck like this for the past week.
[Magisk] giovan797:
magisk safenet does not work when xposed is activated, how to solve?

rom used AOKP athene_nougat_nightly_2017-09-21, already tried everything, safenet only works when you disable module xposed, anyone know how to solulate the problem?

thank you.

magisk 5.3 installed with binary magisk 14 and xposed-v87.3-sdk25-topjohnwu.zip

android nougat 7.1.2

moto g4 plus
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You've already found the answer: disable Xposed when you need to pass SafetyNet.
[Magisk] giovan797:
I still do not work together the two modules, will it interact with them someday?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
No, never
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Flash your system img, boot img, data.img (will wipe all data, be sure to backup your stuff if you can with twrps + connect to pc for it to show up as a drive then copy your stuff to your desktop) and don't flash recovery.img because it'll overwrite twrp

As for radio, grab the radio.img and manually flash it with adb as like you'd do with other things

PS: do note that ota images are only updates usually, not the full rom and other flashable stuff in the zip, to go back to stock Huawei Android you'd need the big package zip, their website might have it
[Magisk] Strephon Alkhalikoi:
Custom recovery images for Samsung devices are flashed using the Odin software. The reason instructions for flashing TWRP aren't in the first post is because the methods for installing TWRP on devices vary, with your device being the most notable example. Assuming your bootloader isn't locked of course. If the bootloader is locked, you're pretty much screwed.

EDIT: Didn't notice the age of the original post. Oh well....
[Magisk] tmviet:
I don't know if it's supported on S8+ , anywhere on my old S4 I do as follow for install recovery:

1) Install apk flashify

2) from flashify I install TWRP.img
[Magisk] chjun90:
v14.0(1400) can't back up stock boot images on my oneplus3 with open beta 24(7.1.1). There is not /data/stock_boot_${SHA1}.img.gz.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Maybe related to the bug from v13.3? Did you first flash your stock boot.img and then Magisk?

If not do that. If that's not helping upload the TWRP logs
[Magisk] freemannhp:
When I use magisk manager to patch boot img, the script shows that manager backs up stock boot image. Is the backup of stock boot placed in /data? If so, my magisk fails to back up stock boot during patching.
[Magisk] chjun90:
yep. 13.3 has a bug backing stock boot image without sha1. 14.0 has fixed it and migrated it to right. My device has received an ota update and flash 14.0 magisk again meeting the bug without backing stock boot image.

I have confirmed this bug by flash times stock boot image and 14.0 magisk.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Logs and details would be useful.
[Magisk] chjun90:
here the log.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Well... It's right there in the log:

- Stock boot image detected!
- Backing up stock boot image
131072+0 records in
131072+0 records out
67108864 bytes (64.0MB) copied, 1.216516 seconds, 52.6MB/s
MagiskBoot v14.0(1400) (by topjohnwu) - Boot Image Modification Tool

Compressing to [stock_boot_ba1c5698b8b635a16b0da08e08f40f934eb2eeac.img.gz]

So if the file really is missing there's something else going on.

What happens if you flash Magisk again, over the current installation? If the file is missing it should complain about a missing backup. Recovery log from that would also be useful, of course.
[Magisk] chjun90:
yep, i see this. but there is nothing backing up at /data folder.

here the log i flash 14.0 again and magisk-uninstaller.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yup... According to the log, it isn't there.

Looking through GitHub it's already been fixed though:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/commit/cd5f5d702fa9017a4ca72a145c43ae31835f34d4

I tried a current test version and there it's created without any issues.

Great find! But [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] was keeping ahead... :laugh:
[Magisk] woldranger:
I'm using the latest version of Magisk on my N910 with the latest Resurrection Remix Rom and thankfully haven't experienced the issues that a lot of users have had, but my biggest is that I can no longer use Netflix.

I've got the Safetynet module running and it shows that I pass Safetynet, I've selected Netflix on the Magisk Hide, but it still get's flagged and wont run. They have a work around with a different apk you can download but that's of no use to me as it wont let you use the download option, and that's how I mainly use Netflix on my phone (when I'm travelling).

Stangely, SkyGo was working fine but when I updated Magisk this week all I get is an immediate FC.

Any suggestions as the other option is to try SuperSu.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The only issue with Netflix I've ever seen is the one about not installing if the Play store is uncertified.

Never had any kind of issue playing videos, downloading or anything. And I've never had Netflix added to the Hide list.

There's obviously no root detection in the app itself, so I'm wondering what's triggering for those that can't use it...
[Magisk] andynx1:
What's the difference between these 2 settings options?

'Hide magisk manager'

'Magisk hide'

Sorry, total noob question!

Great app, working well here!

(Moto G5+, LOS15)
[Magisk] guest4711:
While "hide MagiskManager" will globally rename the Manager to a random name, "Magisk Hide" will try to hide settings in build prop and functionality typical for rooted devices from being seen by selected apps.

The first one will try to hide the presence of Magisk while the second one will try to hide root...
[Magisk] jenslody:
That's not entirely true.

"Hide MagiskManager" just does what it says: it hides the MagiskManager, it's not renamed, it's hidden with "pm hide ..." and can not be used, nor detected (at least not with "pm list packages".

A randomly named app seen as "Unhide MagiskManager" in the launcher is created, that is needed to make MagiskManager appear again.
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Or just use the twrp app to yknow update twrp when they have a new version
[Magisk] Shen Ron:
Give me the link to that part of the OP
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/beta-magisk-v13-0-0980cb6-t3618589/post72588015
[Magisk] Ja_som:
I can't give you link to part of the post. Read the OP.
[Magisk] Shen Ron:
Ok thanks
[Magisk] neokragu:
My banking app detected root even though I hide the app in magisk hide. AEX 4.6 nougat 7.1.2 ROM in Redmi 3S prime. Any solution?
[Magisk] =dgim=:
I had that kind of situation a few times with my bank's app when I've changed some options in Magisk. I had to reinstall bank's app.
[Magisk] pjbeee:
Thank you!!!!

Have now easily rooted 2 USA version 64GB Nexus 6p phones with Magisk v14. One from a clean install after upgrade to (stock ROM) Nougat, and one after "in-place" upgrade from Marshmallow to Nougat (also both stock ROMs) following Heisenberg's excellent instructions - this phone had previously been rooted, but is now systemless thanks to Magisk. Also flashed osm0sis' version of BusyBox using TWRP (joeykrim's Root Checker Pro does not currently detect this version of BusyBox, but it's still OK, and running fine). Phones are now running Android Pay and Snapchat with no apparent issues. Titanium Backup needed to be uninstalled and reinstalled on the 1st phone after initial installation, but no other changes were needed on either phone for this. Happily made a donation to

topjohnwu

; I hope others are doing so as well.

Heisenberg's Nexus 6p How-To Guide for Beginners (I'm not exactly a "beginner," but I do this so infrequently that it's great having instructions)...

https://xdaforums.com/nexus-6p/general/guides-how-to-guides-beginners-t3206928

Cheers!
[Magisk] siripuram.rk:
Tested on ONEPLUS 3T works like a charm :)
[Magisk] guest4711:
Have you tried to hide MagiskManager too? And avoid using a standard BusyBox (use only a systemless one)...
[Magisk] pjbeee:
Osmosis Busybox

osm0sis' BusyBox is here (flash the zip from TWRP)

https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2239421
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Or someone can get it from Downloads section of Magisk Manager
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Chqnces are people don't ever read anything.
[Magisk] neokragu:
I have not installed busybox.

Hide magisk manager also not helped.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Return to your stock, unified ROM. Or at least try core mode. Banking apps are often impossible to fool
[Magisk] andynx1:
I have the same problem.