yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] kramer04:
Try again to install v13

sorry for the zip file but the log is to big

After boot i open magisk manager but crashes after 1 mn

PhoneInfo says i'm rooted but it doesn't works

i can't pass safetynet

with v12 all is fine

Samsung note 3

rom phronesis v6

kernel is darklord 2.0
[Magisk] brian 11:
Try rebooting and if you get root back.
[Magisk] Owls:
Current magisk_debug.log attached
[Magisk] mauam:
Working flawlessly on Honor 5X RR 5.8.3:cool:
[Magisk] aser_elhbayeb:
Is Ziren sound mod working for you after v13 update?

For me it was working fine on v12, but now doesn't!
[Magisk] JpegXguy:
Working fine on my Huawei P8 Lite (ALE-L21)
[Magisk] Puky2NS:
What will happens with bank aps that does not work on rooted phones :confused:
[Magisk] psychoela:
all magisk module work?
[Magisk] lalitjoshi06:
If safetynet passing.

just take a backup of magisk manager app.

hide bank apps in magisk hide. reboot your phone.

now the trick.

open bank apps it will detect root.

now close bank app and just uninstall the magisk manager app and open bank app it will work.

after banking reinstall the magisk app and enjoy.

Its working for me. (Checked on Spushtan and UOB)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
They will continue to not work on rooted phones and the apps that can be fooled by things like Magisk Hide (or simply uninstalling the su manager) will eventually catch on and get better detection methods.
[Magisk] jfishbone311:
All of my financial apps work and I am using about half a dozen
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Not all financial apps look for root and quite a few of those that do can be fooled by Magisk Hide. But in the end the cat and mouse game of hiding root is probably gonna be a loosing one... This, this and this post by [MENTION=631273]Chainfire[/MENTION] describes it pretty well IMHO.

Edit: But this kind of discussion has the potential of getting way off topic (it is already, sorry) and spiral out of control. We should probably stop...
[Magisk] vitekrus777:
Deleted
[Magisk] nixie2121:
maybe it was not your intention, but this post is very insulting to a developer.
[Magisk] Owls:
How i can help debug issue with pin/password?
[Magisk] vitekrus777:
I can not install it as a module. There are no buttons and module installation possibilities.

Until the magisk boot is installed, the modules section will not open.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Uninstall Magisk v13.0 and Magisk Manager v4.3.3, flash Magisk v12.0 and Magisk Manager v4.3.3 and install Magisk v13.0 ZIP from Magisk Manager v4.3.3
[Magisk] DenyDarko:
Latest v13 beta [0b4baad] is failing to patch boot for LG G5 (H850 International Variant).

ROM: Official V20D untouched.

Recovery: TWRP 3.1.1

Logs attached.

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]
[Magisk] corsicanu:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] Tried with latest build on Samsung A500F, hadesRom v.1.1 TW-MM and hadesKernel v2.5

If i use uninstaller before flashing, i get same error when flashing v13 - /data/magisk.img: No such file or directory

Flashed v13 with magisk.img from v12 on /data and managed to boot. First time i see properly rooted. After a reboot it shows that i`m missing root.

Reflashed v12, installed manager from v13 and i have also root/safetynet pass even after several reboots.

As i see, fails creating magisk.img even on other devices (see LG above this post). And this can explain root issues with v13 on top of v12 because it still uses old image. Maybe i`m wrong i can`t say i know much about these things, but my common sense tells me i`m right :D.

Attached the recovery log. Will try to pull also the log from v13 runing on v12 img.

1 is from first boot after flashing, 2 is from second boot, where i lost root access. Logged also the missing root issue.

Cheers!
[Magisk] Windforce0511:
Anyone got V4A working with Galaxy S6 and latest Magisk beta?
[Magisk] D1stRU3T0R:
Magisk v13 working on P8 Lite, EMUI 4.0.3,latest B602 rom (heavily tweaked). After I flashed universal safetynet fix 1.10.2,i passed it successfully :)
[Magisk] krkhaha:
On my device dont work. Maybe this is my foul? Somone help?

Thanks.
[Magisk] gege0202:
last beta works perfect on my galaxy s8. safetinet pass

but i can't see amazon prime video : is it possible with magisk?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Not without any information
[Magisk] Shen Ron:
Beta v13.0 (54e6a79) works perfectly
[Magisk] brian 11:
The new version of beta works fine. It's the first time I could pass both safety net tests since Google changed the tests.
[Magisk] FloyderE:
No one knows how to fix/workaround this?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It is very possible that Magisk Hide simply didn't start on boot. Solution: toggle it off and on in the Manager, or manually in terminal:

su
magiskhide --disable
magiskhide --enable

If that's the case, there are instructions in the OP on how to capture the proper logs for you to share in the thread.
[Magisk] FloyderE:
Thank you so much! Toggled it off and on and it worked..I also noticed that launching Magisk Manager this time it told me that I had no root, I closed the app and reopen it and root magically come back.

I think I’ll share the log shortly
[Magisk] Epikarus:
Hi, I'm new to this thread.

Using Galaxy S6 running stock Nougat 7.0

Magisk is v13.0 (54e6a79) with the Magisk Manager 5.0.2

I have two modules installed, viper4android and audmodlib found in this thread

Magisk works well at boot, root works and any apps that request root are working.

If i clear Magisk Manager from the multitask screen or, similarly, Magisk Manager is no longer in memory, I lose root access.

I've attached the logcat, but I cannot find the /data/magiskdebug.txt mentioned in the OP.

Thanks for your help!
[Magisk] Skittles9823:
-deleted-
[Magisk] krkhaha:
Guys can you give me correct setting for magisk manager? Please.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That question makes no sense... What are you trying to accomplish?
[Magisk] Chaplan:
Guys, V13 latest beta running quite nicely on OP3.

Just one question.

I have noticed that using adaway to change my hosts systemlessly, after applying within the app and rebooting as asked, it says no hosts are appllyed.

Applying a second time makes it all work as intended.

I have run through this hiccup everytime I apply hosts for the first time.

Sorry is this might look as OT being app related and all, but on V12 I never encountered this behaviour.

Hope someone can shed some light.
[Magisk] invasi0nZ:
Can't bypass SafetyNet, still get CTS error. Does this error occur because of me using Lineage OS?
[Magisk] 24imelqui:
try clearing cache of magisk & playstore app then restart.
[Magisk] invasi0nZ:
Didn't work :( still getting:

CTS profile: false

and

basic integrity: false
[Magisk] D1stRU3T0R:
Flash universal safetynet fix...
[Magisk] invasi0nZ:
HTC one m8 Lineage OS
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
What version of LineageOS are you running?
[Magisk] invasi0nZ:
Lineage OS 14.1 nightly June 22 2017 Android 7.1.2
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Then give me the Magisk log from Magisk Manager
[Magisk] viktor92:
I've discovered a trick when I can't pass safety net: toggle off and on magisk hide in settings, and then magically I can pass safety net again... very weird...
[Magisk] invasi0nZ:
Thanks for helping!
[Magisk] invasi0nZ:
tried that but didnt work :(
[Magisk] chemeleon:
I've attached the recovery log here, and here's what appears to be the relevant section.

************************ * Magisk v13.0(54e6a79) Installer ************************ - Mounting /system(ro), /vendor(ro), /cache, /data - Device platform: arm64 - Constructing environment - /data/magisk.img detected! - Mounting /data/magisk.img to /magisk ! Magisk image mount failed... Updater process ended with ERROR: 1 I:Legacy property environment disabled. I:Install took 1 second(s). Error installing zip file '/sdcard/Download/Magisk-v13.0(54e6a79).zip'
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Try toggling Magisk Hide off and on
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
And this happens after a reboot, I guess?

That's not a "trick", that's an issue with the resetprop tool. Go to the OP, look under "MagiskHide doesn't start on boot / system.prop in modules aren't loaded / resetprop doesn't work" and report back with the proper logs.
[Magisk] chemeleon:
This worked for me with version 96... Odd.
[Magisk] invasi0nZ:
Tried that again but didnt work either
[Magisk] viktor92:
No, in my case worked without rebooting, but now I've just flashed the last beta.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No, I mean that SafetyNet starts triggering after a reboot. Not that you need to reboot after toggling Hide off and on.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
What stuff did you have before the Magisk v13.0 beta installation?
[Magisk] invasi0nZ:
I tried the following:

iSu -> stopped working after safetynet update

so I uninstalled Lineage OS root and installed magisk v12 that didnt work either so I tried the beta which workes a little better (safetynet doesnt fail completly)
[Magisk] chemeleon:
I can't upload the magisk debug log due to network error, but here's the resetprop log. This is relating to the behaviour where safetynet workaround only works when toggling magiskhide and is disabled after reboot.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Try to clean flash LOS 14.1 with Magisk v13.0 latest beta and Universal SafetyNet Fix module
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
And you shouldn't put too many apps into your Magisk Hide list
[Magisk] A.lemane:
some modules can mess with safetynet disable all & restart
[Magisk] krkhaha:
I mean serting inside magisk manager.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yes, I know you're talking about the Magisk Manager settings. The problem is that the "correct settings", doesn't make any sense. You need to go into details as to what it is you want.
[Magisk] grego3140:
hello,

I explain my problem, I have flash the last zip, normally.

The apk don't install so I install the apk file in the common dir but, when I launch the MagiskManager The application say I'm not root ... what can I do ?

thank for your answer.
[Magisk] FloyderE:
I'm Sorry to bother you... I've followed the procedure in OP with the two terminal windows, but I don't know where to find the file: in /data there's magisk_debug.log but I can't find resetprop_log.txt, could you help me?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It'll be in the same folder on your computer as you were running the adb command from.
[Magisk] Benjamin50180:
When I want to do the SafetyNet check, the script is very long and at the end:

"The response is invalid" and the manager crash.

I installed the module "Universal SafetyNet" Stable

Xiaomi Redmi Note 4 MIUI 8.2.10.0 Stable

I upload my log

I was try with Beta Module but verification failed
[Magisk] FloyderE:
RESETPROP ISSUE

Resetprop_log.txt : https://drive.google.com/open?id=1d6-V_ZFOCaVFgQdqBHqWI6Vi5Zlzrd-ivYQbrzCjk6A

Magisk_debug.log .txt : https://drive.google.com/open?id=0Bwn82SYyzLoLaUN1QVJsUFZDYVE
[Magisk] murphyjasonc:
When I install Magisk 13 I can pass safety net and everything works except my Google apps constantly force close. This doesn't happen on version 12. I've tried clean and dirty install with same result. Any help would be appreciated.
[Magisk] Spencervb256:
Everyone here is happy to help, but like the first page says, don't ask for help without a log. Grab a log and attach it to your post. Not trying to be harsh just logs are extremely helpful
[Magisk] RashaMatt:
Apps Force Close due to "Chromium WebView package does not exist"

Update: [BETA][2017.7.3] Magisk v13.0 (c4377ed) seems to have fixed these issues for me - thanks devs! :)

If I have "Core Only" mode ENabled, things generally work, but SafetyNet check fails (both ctsProfile and basicIntegrity).

If I have "Core Only" mode DISabled, SafetyNet check succeeds, BUT lots of different apps crash with the same Webkit issue (see attached logs).

Moto X 2014 Edition XT1095, AospExtended v4.3 [v7.1.2_r17], Magisk 13.0 beta (54e6a79)
[Magisk] A.lemane:
so .... flashfire inst compatible with this one ?
[Magisk] exodius48:
Magisk 12 & 13 failed to flash in miui 8.5 =>> https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/251
[Magisk] ketwi15:
I get the same problem. Any help?
[Magisk] i42o:
Nexus 6P cts profile mismatch when Dolby Atmos is installed... I've reproduced the error and it fails when I enable this module... I thought changes where implemented systemlessly ...
[Magisk] Bryanx86:
Try toggling magisk hide on and off. I do this when it says mismatch, and like magic it passes after toggling magisk hide. I don't use Dolby, but i use viper, ice, and Dirac on 6p.
[Magisk] Epikarus:
I think we just need to wait for a new update
[Magisk] hanut1:
confirmed working properly (PASSING SAFETYNET) on lineage os one plus 3t .
[Magisk] Cozmikk:
Still getting error..

I have tried the V3 version that you have linked and I still get the Error 1 when attempting to flash.
[Magisk] Xeon721:
Hi guys, I was just wondering something:

Does Magisk 13 can hide the fact that the developers options are activated..?

Thanks :)
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
I think no
[Magisk] Epikarus:
I've run a resetprop logcat.

From my observation I see that whenever magisk manager is cleared from memory (manually or automatically), magisk can no longer get root. I ran this logcat as soon as the device was booted up.

Galaxy s6 running current (54e6a79) on Stock Nougat 7.0
[Magisk] dougie1802:
Put phone in boot loop

Hi there so I tried the new beta version on my samsung S5 plus and when installed first time phone boots fine then after a few mins crashes reboots the phone then its stuck on the boot logo I am using the latest lineage OS 14.1 anyone got any ideas please. I have had to reinstall everything again from scratch to get the phone to boot up.

Thanks all
[Magisk] btb55:
Can you elaborate on this? I wondered if it mattered, so I ticked every app except for those needing root, and wasn't aware of any change in performance of the phone or Magisk.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Please only tick Google Play Services (com.google.android.gms.unstable) and Snapchat in Magisk Hide list and try to run the SafetyNet test again
[Magisk] Bat-Maniac:
Absolutely great!!!!

The first time my mobile banking app works on my rooted 6P!!!

THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR WORK!!!

I will definitely support your project!!!
[Magisk] btb55:
I don't an issue with SafetyNet, it passes on my phone, with all apps except those needing root ticked, the question was why limit how many apps are hidden? It doesn't seem to matter to me, or is there another reason to only tick a few? Or is it a recommendation for those who can't pass SN?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I haven't heard anything about this recommendation changing, so here's the explanation from the master himself:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=70363391&postcount=9
[Magisk] Deep-Knight:
I have the same Phone (Redmi 4x )with the same Rom. (Nougat 7.1.2 , Mi-Globe Rom 7.6.22) The Main Issues with v12 and v13 is, that the unmount does not work... There are no Log Entrys... I dont know how to fix that.
[Magisk] A.lemane:
Couldn't install it using the installer from play store nor using flashfire (isn't compatible with magisk)

instead I used the open source installer from F-Droid (am sticking with this one)

am taking about BusyBox
[Magisk] Artim_96:
...are there even apps that detect that? That would be hilarious. Because then they would probably block me developers than real users...

---------- Post added at 01:58 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:55 PM ----------

Maybe try the linked zip from here:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/beta-workarounds-to-issues-magisk-beta-t3624176
[Magisk] A.lemane:
safety net is fully working but some apps try to execute some other detection methods , that's why u need to use magisk hide on them (to execute them in a separate mouted environment (virtual one I guess witch simulate the original stock system (redonly) and maybe also with a fake apps list , magisk not included as an example))

Well I know nothing of all this , but that's just what i concluded from my experience with it in these past few days
[Magisk] Xeon721:
Yes, Fate/Grand Order. :)

That's why I was asking. It even detects Magisk Hide.
[Magisk] A.lemane:
and safety net is fully working ?
[Magisk] Xeon721:
Yes, Magisk Manager was telling me that everything was ok.

I only succeeded to launch the application by uninstalling Magisk and desactivating the developer options.
[Magisk] Zehlek:
Safety net not working on MIUI 8 Marshmallow
[Magisk] voorhess:
Edited

Sorry guys it was accident. My child hijacked my phone ??
[Magisk] baszu:
Suppose I do also update rom together with magisk, should I uninstall magisk first?

I see a step that Magisk check for backup boot image, so I'm not sure whether how magisk installer patch on top of the backup boot image or the new one from rom zip file?

Normally, I select both rom and magisk at the same time.
[Magisk] A.lemane:
what if u install it enabled Dev ops while the app is running & an before running it try disabling magisk not uninstalling it

---------- Post added at 02:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:35 PM ----------

give me the app name or play store link so I can try it
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
Your other three posts seem reasonable. What's this one for?
[Magisk] Xeon721:
The application's name is Fate Grand Order, the USA edition

(if u'r not in the USA, you can get it here : https://apkpure.com/fate-grand-order-english/com.aniplex.fategrandorder.en )

And I was asking because I don't want to enable and disabled the dev ops everytime I want to launch the application :)
[Magisk] shoey63:
Turn off DTTW if your phone is in your pocket whilst walking?
[Magisk] ZRagonZ:
Confirmed latest Magisk v13.0 (54e6a79) works without issues!

Device : OnePlus 3T

ROM : RR Official 2017_06_22

Kernel : Blu_Spark Kernel r151
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
That hadn't occurred to me. It should have - my wife texted me from holiday in Turkey last week asking why she'd got 5 Lockwatch alerts about someone trying to break into my Nexus 6. While it was in my pocket... :)
[Magisk] grego3140:
hello can anyone help me please ?

The root don't work when I flash the last zip....
[Magisk] Ja_som:
No one can help you unles you provide more info and logs.
[Magisk] grego3140:
Okay, My phone is a SM-N9005, I'm in the Stock ROM because I don't find a ROM who pass the safetynet.

I have flash the last magisk zip, normaly.

and when I boot my phone, the application don't installed so I install the apk file who is in the zip/common

but, when I launch the MagiskManager the application say I'm not root ...

The logcat when the su command is prompt is attched to this post, if you need another log say what you need.

but su command return a not found ...

Very very thanks to help me :)

View attachment magisksu_log.txt
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Just to clarify:

Magisk Hide simply unmounts Magisk and it's modules so that they're not visible to any app/processes looking for root (no separate enviroment involved). It's still quite simple for an app to detect the presence of the Magisk Manager though (there might be some work going on to fix this though) and there are some detection methods that seem to be able to circumvent Magisk Hide as well...
[Magisk] ricardodaniel23:
Can't flash any version of magisk.

Meizu pro 5

Resurrection Remix 7.1.2 unofficial
[Magisk] joeyhuab:
So this works on my Second Gen Android One device (AEX 7.1.2 ROM). I can turn on my cellular data one time and when I toggle off, it won't turn on again. I know it's Magisk 13 related since Magisk 12 doesn't cause the same issue.
[Magisk] dougie1802:
So done some more trying and I have

Samsung s5 plus

Lineage OS 14.1 latest (until new release tomorrow)

Magisk 13 beta latest

Done a full format and reinstall of lineage OS and gapps nano then installed magisl 13 what I found all is running great until I reboot if I reboot then it get stuck at the lineage OS boot logo and just sits anyone any idea what causing this please. Thanks
[Magisk] Spencervb256:
Read the first post of how to capture a log with adb then come back here with that log so someone can help
[Magisk] Evo_Shift:
I am using a Shield K1 tablet. Was successfully using magisk V12 until Google broke it. I updated to V13 using the uninstaller and reflashing. Now games like Mario and Fire emblem won't show up in the Play Store nor will they run if I sideload them. However, I pass safetynet and my device is certified in the Play Store. My device is otherwise stock. I'll post a log tonight but just wondering if I am missing something simple. I did check the Magisk Hide option.
[Magisk] Nobby1960:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

Is a Magisk support for the Samsung S2 GT-I9100 planned? I also opened a thread on Github with log and boot.img.

The S2 community with Lineage based Nougat 7.1.2 ROMs would be very happy :)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Have you cleared data for the Play store and then rebooted?
[Magisk] Okaham:
Sorry for the late reply, but I don't believe I have...All I flashed was the ROM, magisk, and phh supersu for root.
[Magisk] Ja_som:
Why you use phh supersu when you want Magisk? Probably for that reason Magisk can't patch/restore your boot. Flash your rom, it should have stock boot and then use ONLY Magisk.
[Magisk] patster98:
Hey guys, on latest beta, magisk hide not working for Snapchat, I'm.on OOS open beta 18 OnePlus 3, no modifications at all, flashed with bluespark TWRP, uninstall every mod, tried by reflashing rom and then reinstalling magisk and it continues to fail... Also, when flashing magisk uninstaller, my op3 screen stays black and won't boot into system.. any ideas?

Not passing safetynet either now
[Magisk] Nodens:
According to the log, your device does not have enough room to save the new patched boot.img on the latest beta.

---------- Post added at 02:55 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:45 AM ----------

Required library libaed.so can not be found in your device.

---------- Post added at 03:01 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:55 AM ----------

Flashfire works fine with Magisk. Did you try it and fail? If yes provide logs please.
[Magisk] apophis9283:
Phhs root modified the boot.img. clean flash everything and just flash magisk
[Magisk] A.lemane:
Flashfire works fine with Magisk. Did you try it and fail? If yes provide logs please.[/QUOTE]

Many many many times & ill try again so I can regenerate logs
[Magisk] wrongway213:
For anyone who hasn't picked up on this yet: please don't post about issues without logs. Just simlpy don't do it - save us all some time. This thread would be literally half the size it is if every person posting an issue posted the log with the post the first time, instead of being told to get logs and then posting again to post the logs. Posting just to post is just about the furthest thing from optimal on a development board - the less posts we can use to get the most issues fixed, the better. Not aimed at a specific person - just seeing a huge amount of repeat posts on here mostly for this reason, and we can simply do better.. so we should.

TLDR Your posts are too long without logs, and thus we didn't read them, and won't until you submit logs with the post.
[Magisk] CharFalco:
I know that Pixel / Pixel XL are unsupported at this time. Should I take that to mean that it also won't work on the Pixel C tablet?
[Magisk] 4K2K:
Works perfect on Le Pro 3, Omni Rom 20170625. It passes SafetyNet and Google Play device certification. I can now use banking apps that detected root even when SafetyNet passed. It was not possible on v12.
[Magisk] adhammagdy:
Not passing safetynet

I have lenovo vibe p1 with AOSP Extended 4.3 custom rom..

Magisk 12 with core only mode passes safetynet successfully..

Magisk 13 doesn't pass safetynet despite changing different options.. also tried the universal safetynet fix 1.10.1

I cleanly installed magisk 13 after completely removing 12

Attached magisk log
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Pixel C doesn't have the A/B OTA system
[Magisk] CharFalco:
I'm taking that to mean that the Pixel / XL DO, and that's why they're currently unsupported - but that my Pixel C should work fine. Correct?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Try disabling and enabling Magisk Hide