yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] langithitam:
Hi [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]

i've tried to install magisk v13 using twrp and it causing me bootlop. then i've flash the uninstaller android boot again, but it corrupt my android system.

i've tried to wipe cache dalvik, but still. the result ia lots of my app stop to working. is there a manual way to make fix this problem e.g using file manager in twrp?

please dont gave me suggestion to flash my android...
[Magisk] Joloxx9:
I have a problem, magisk manager 5.1, OP3T ressurection remix and eng stk kernel. The problem is when I install kernel then magisk, my phone is very, very slow. When I install magisk then kernel my phone is fast but magisk manager doesn't work, modules root are working. How to fix it? Thanks.e
[Magisk] Babayaga68:
Everytime I try to install a module, I got the message "Magisk is not activated...". :(
[Magisk] LinkinBart:
Android Pay doesn't works with Magisk 13.3 and Magisk Manager 5.1, any solutions?
[Magisk] robbyoconnor:
You pass safetynet with magisk...but you will not be able to use Xposed..jus disable it.. otherwise you will fail the basic integrity test...

It is very unlikely we will ever pass safetynet with Xposed.
[Magisk] lollyjay:
Hmmm it's working on my Moto Z atm

Edit: Also working on my Nexus 7 2013
[Magisk] galletap22:
The zip works correctly but the apk does not work, any solution?
[Magisk] ZabiGarma:
The newest Magisk Manager keeps crashing.
[Magisk] TahirZX:
Magisk 13.3 installed successfully

But

Magisk manager 5.1.0 apk is stuck at logo screen. And eventually FC

I tried to delete magisk manager data

Used magisk Uninstaller and reinstalled

The issue is still there. Any fix?
[Magisk] devast8ndiscodave:
Also having the same issue.
[Magisk] lollyjay:
Seems to be device specific. Both of my devices have no problems
[Magisk] TahirZX:
Not device specific several other people are having same issue too
[Magisk] dewhashish:
Nexus 6P here. I flashed 13.3 is TWRP, but Magisk Manager 5.0.6 is saying Magisk isn't installed. Manager 5.1 keeps crashing.
[Magisk] Pavamarea:
Magisk 13.3 working good in my s7 edge. Magisk manager 5.1.0 FC but safetynet is passing. But a i made a rollback to 5.0.6 version and it's ok for now, i will wait for a fix in last version.
[Magisk] DreadfulDrummer:
Getting stuck at the splash screen seems to be happening to anyone with ARISE Magisk Module for Magnus Opus enabled
[Magisk] lollyjay:
I have a Moto Z and Nexus 7 2013 and nobody has reported problems with them.
[Magisk] TahirZX:
How do I roll back to previous version? Any idea?

5.0.6

And magisk 13.2?
[Magisk] Pavamarea:
I founded the 5.0.6 version in apkmirror site. And than, i uninstalled the last version and installed the 5..0.6. In the first run after this, i get "not root" msg, so i closed and re-opened the app and it's ok. The magisk version i kept the 13.3.
[Magisk] Asumos:
first thanks for all your hard work,

as others have posted, magisk root, and magisk hide running smoothly but manager 5.1.0 stuck at loading screen and stops responding. Using OnePlus 5 - OxygenOs 4.5.5
[Magisk] wrongway213:
GitHub is your friend everyone

http://github.com/topjohnwu/MagiskManager/releases
[Magisk] imna357:
same here, LINEAGE OS 14.1, safety net and others are working, but the Magisk Manager itself crashed
[Magisk] nik007rock:
same here latest magisk manager stuck at opening running los based rr rom op3t rolled back to previous version
[Magisk] Shished:
I'm using LeEco Le Max 2 with RR-N and latest manager version does not works for me.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Wow... My guide get's stickied and BOM!

[RANT]No-one reads the OP anymore... :crying:[/RANT]

I don't want to lock down the thread, because there might turn up good pointers and ideas, but if people don't start reading the OP I'm probably gonna have to.

But, just to make it clear, here's what it says in the OP (in nice colorful letters, and just in case you're color blind I made them real big as well):

[MENTION=5757980]langithitam[/MENTION]

[MENTION=4161942]joloxx9joloxx9[/MENTION]

[MENTION=8188950]Babayaga68[/MENTION]

[MENTION=8341253]LinkinBart[/MENTION]

[MENTION=3767113]29988122[/MENTION]

[MENTION=4762414]lollyjay[/MENTION]

[MENTION=3306566]robbyoconnor[/MENTION]

[MENTION=7791010]galletap22[/MENTION]

[MENTION=7287376]ZabiGarma[/MENTION]

[MENTION=6766716]TahirZX[/MENTION]

[MENTION=5579290]devast8ndiscodave[/MENTION]

[MENTION=4466623]dewhashish[/MENTION]

[MENTION=5445181]Pavamarea[/MENTION]

[MENTION=5945655]DreadfulDrummer[/MENTION]

[MENTION=4816137]Asumos[/MENTION]

[MENTION=2468018]imna357[/MENTION]

[MENTION=4591491]nik007rock[/MENTION]

[MENTION=7847630]Shished[/MENTION]

[MENTION=358748]smohanv[/MENTION]

[MENTION=1430968]*justintime*[/MENTION]
[Magisk] smohanv:
I updated magisk 13.3 and also magisk manager 5.1.

I could not open magisk manager. Several apps requiring super user permissions are not working as magisk manager is required not opening.
[Magisk] *justintime*:
Edit
[Magisk] paolo200:
I don't have that module but still stuck at splash screen so I rollback to previous version until it's fixed
[Magisk] CRYPTfromCATACOMBZ:
Hello folks, i have a little problem, can't update magisk manager. Have version 5.0.6, download via manager the latest one, but when i confirm update of app, it says "The package conflicts with an existing package by the same name"

How to solve it?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I'm going to be rabid about this... :laugh:

Here you go guys: https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73084478&postcount=240
[Magisk] robbyoconnor:
Sorry about helping out...I wasn't seeking support.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Don't apologies for trying to help. That's awesome!

But, you were adding to the clutter of the thread...
[Magisk] yusuo:
I can second this, freezing when trying to open the manager. Luckily I'm still given root permission
[Magisk] rowad1985:
same problem any help?????
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Known issue. It's being worked on.

Pro tip: Read the OP of whatever thread you're in before posting. Or at least the last few pages... (less than 10 posts before you: https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73084478&postcount=240)
[Magisk] Bytegeist:
I have the exact same problem. Version 5.0.1 works perfectly fine but Version 5.1 crashes and won't even start.
[Magisk] rowad1985:
i back to magisk manger v5.0.5 working perfect but v5.1 Freezes magisk mange
[Magisk] dusman13:
Everything working fine I update manager 5.1 and then magisk 13.3, and everything is perfect for me.

OOS 4.1.6 with ElementalX 3.05 kernel and blu spark v39 TWRP.
[Magisk] bamzzz:
Bootloop on Redmi Note 3 Pro (Kenzo) Global ROM 8.5.3.0.. :crying: Rollback to Magisk 13.2..
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Here's some good reading for you guys:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73084478&postcount=240

And [MENTION=6752328]dusman13[/MENTION], please don't post those huge images like that... They take up the entire screen when scrolling through the thread. If you have to post images, just attach them you your post instead, please.
[Magisk] dusman13:
I dont know, i attachh them with tapatalk and images are small on tapatalk.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Don't get me started on Tapatalk...

If your device has a screen resolution of 1920x1080, that means your screenshots will have the same resolution. Anyone who happens to be using a computer to browse the forums (like I'm doing at the moment) will see the full image. It's really, really annoying...

Please remove the screenshots from your post.
[Magisk] dougie1802:
Boot Loop S5 Plus

Hi there have a S5 plus and every version past v12 causes a boot loop and Lineagos 14.1 wont boot its stuck at the boot logo untill I remove and reinstall v12 dont get it any help would be great works perfect on a normal S5 just not the S5 Plus
[Magisk] dima-82:
I don't use MagiskHide, cause I don't care about SafetyNet and don't use apps requiring SafetyNet. (currently....)

But can anyone explain me, why MagiskHide is not enabled permanently? It is an option, which can be disabled. Are there disadvantages of MagiskHide? Is it a performance issue since MagiskHide is a daemon running in the background? Or are there any other reasons?

(I tried to google this topic and search on xda, but I couldn't find an answer)
[Magisk] koko115:
After update to magisk 13.3 when i turn on magisk i have only this. GALAXY S8
[Magisk] rogirogi:
I can't add apps on hidelist.

someone teach me solution.

thanx in advance.
[Magisk] Paschfire:
Wrong thread go here for Magisk General Discussion & Support. > https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/page1691

Also.. what modules are you using if any?

As the ARISE Compatibility Module among others are known to cause this issuev of Magisk manager hanging on the splash screen, they're out-of-date needing to be updated to v4 Magisk module template, so disable/uninstall these modules, reboot and recheck Magisk manager.

If not resubmit your post with more detailed Device/setup information including Magisk log & Logcat of the issues.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I'm just gonna keep on pushing this... :laugh:

[MENTION=4715235]koko115[/MENTION] [MENTION=8197653]rogirogi[/MENTION]

As [MENTION=5866088]Paschfire[/MENTION] so beautifully put it (thank you): wrong thread. Read the first few lines of the OP in this thread and then post your issues in the support thread.

And for [MENTION=4715235]koko115[/MENTION], here's a little something that applies to you as well:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73087935&postcount=257
[Magisk] AlxMAX:
I have updated Magisk Manager to 5.1 and it could not get past the splash screen in order to update the su binary. I have installed Magisk-v13.3.zip manually in the recovery and I've got the same result when launching Magisk Manager. I have a Nexus 6 with CyanogenMod 14.1 nightly from 20170707. Please let me know how I can get the logcat (I have attempted to use the monitor that came with the SDK, but it didn't display anything).
[Magisk] zeratos:
I am getting this error on a Galaxy Note 4 running Android 6.0, was running 13.2 just fine but this one just wont work, even after force flashing it trough TWRP it gives a safetynet fail
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Please read the OP before posting in a thread... You're in the wrong place.

Please read the OP before posting in a thread... You're in the wrong place. And don't cross post, please. I've answered you elsewhere.
[Magisk] Rom:
I have just install the update (thanks to @topjohnwu for his quickly fix), and i have the following problem:

apparently some magisk modules that worked on Magisk before the 13.3 (or due to the bug of the last magisk manager update) make bootloop.

Magisk modules devs must make their modules up to date or it's an other "Magisk bug" ?

EDIT:

After my tests:

Procedure following for each magisk modules installations:

-Download the last release from Magisk Manager or the XDA thread

-Installations (like as custom recovery flashing) success at each modules installations

- Reboot in normal mode my phone

--LG D855, Resurection Remix Nougat 7.1.2 rootless by default

- Surprise of Teresa mother...... (bootloop or not)

So my results:

EmojiOne ==============================> OK

Doze for GMS ===========================> OK

Doze for Greenify ========================> OK

External SDcard access ===================> OK

Universal SafeNet Fix =====================> BOOTLOOP

Dolby Atmos ============================> BOOTLOOP

Universal Kernel Manager ==================> BOOTLOOP

NB: Advanced users like modos, devs, ... know that my list is purely exhaustive.
[Magisk] cutesniper22:
removed ...
[Magisk] robbyoconnor:
Reminder: Read the OP folks -- or heck if you're lazy, read a few posts up.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No.

Wrong thread (read the OP).

Don't cross post, please.
[Magisk] divineBliss:
Did you read the OP?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
And if you do go back and read the OP, you'll find an index that shows there's a section in the guide about your issue: "Moving from another systemless root solution to MagiskSU".

Pro tip: Read. Read some more. Then post.
[Magisk] lbcoach3347:
Please accept my apology probably the first time I didn't read the Opie first I will erase my post as I see I'm just a little confused on how to flash the boot image but if I'm correct I think in TWRP you can switch from flashing a zip to flashing an image thanks guys
[Magisk] AlxMAX:
Well, since you want to publish here only guides about installation and troubleshooting the Magisk framework, why don't you close this thread and post only the guides? Believe me, I've pondered quite a long time before sending this message and it seemed a fair solution to me.

Edit: maybe modify the first sentence of the OP to sound like This is NOT a Magisk support thread. Go to the Magisk support thread for that matter?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Trust me, I've thought about it... More than once... :laugh:

But, keeping it open makes it a lot easier for anyone that has questions about the specifics in the guide to get answers. And if anyone comes around with useful tips and tricks or has found something that's off, etc, etc it's a lot easier to get that into the guide if it's open for posts. Sure, they could PM me, but I prefer to keep it in the open.

Thanks for the suggestion (just the kind of thing I keep the thread open for :D).
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If a user entering the thread can't be bothered to read the second line, I don't think there's much to be done about it anyway... :laugh:

But yeah... I constantly change the wordings and placements of different parts of the first few posts in the thread to make it easier to comprehend. Again: Thank you for your suggestions.
[Magisk] Chocklety Boyee:
I really want dolby atmos mod working without breaking safetynet pass?? Plz help me..viper4 anddroid works fine with topjohnwu's module..can anyone help me??
[Magisk] Jashane:
Installed

MagiskSU 13.3

Magisk Manager 5.1.1

xposed-v87.0-sdk23-topjohnwu.zip

XposedInstaller_by_dvdandroid_29_04_17.apk

But Xposed modules not working

Any fix?

Wrong thread
[Magisk] divineBliss:
[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION],

Thanks for this thread. :)

Maybe create another similar closed clean guide thread in which only you post since so many don't seem to bother reading the OP or last few posts before they start asking for Magisk support here instead of posting in the Magisk support thread like the OP says to do.

You could leave this thread open and migrate the good stuff to the clean thread :) .
[Magisk] angelky:
after updated to 13.3, my phone has no sound, but phone call is ok. and so strange that i cant even update busybox.
[Magisk] stewie2806:
Try to reinstall magisk:

Flash the uninstaller zip, then flash magisk 13.3 zip, Wipe cache/Delvick, reboot and install manager 5.5
[Magisk] suryaprakash99:
does it bootloop with out custom kernal because magisk 12 did it
[Magisk] edisonzhong0623:
I'm running rr 7.1.2 in one plus one, and I found that viper4 module and icebox module conflict with each other after magisk is updated to v13.3, if I installed either of the two modules, everything goes fine, while if I installed both, I will get bootloop in splash screen forever.

Any solutions?

many thanks
[Magisk] GryphonBR:
I'm gonna say yes or no for bootlooping.

I mean, of course if you had provided more relevant information, like what phone, ROM and kernel you're currently using, a more precise answer would be possible...
[Magisk] suryaprakash99:
Moto G4 plus stock rom (nougat) and on stock kernal
[Magisk] GryphonBR:
I have a Moto Z Play with stock Nougat and kernel. Never ran into any bootloop problems with 12 or 13, for that matter, and since these two phones are quite similar I can't possibly understand why would your device bootloop on 12.
[Magisk] angelky:
Thanks. It works now, but I usually have issues by checking safetynet. Always no response.
[Magisk] suryaprakash99:
It worked fine when I flashed Elemental X kernal thank you
[Magisk] stewie2806:
What device are you using?
[Magisk] angelky:
Samsung S8+ 955N
[Magisk] stewie2806:
Can you access safteynet net check on magisk now?
[Magisk] angelky:
Yes, loading so long and then says no response :(
[Magisk] stewie2806:
Download a safteynet net check for the play store. A bit inconvenient but it'll work
[Magisk] angelky:
It says response payload validation failed :(
[Magisk] capricornian:
deleted. apologies wrong thread.
[Magisk] Xennet:
Screenshot of terminal attached

Magisk v11.1

OOS 4.0.3 on op3t. Rooted only with magisk.

ROOT CHECKER PRO 1.6.2

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.joeykrim.rootcheckp

Weird in t magisk log cant find ur mod loaded... If i am correct

I restarted. Have ur nodule checked and said installed in t previous screenshot i sent u...
[Magisk] laggardkernel:
Yes, you don't see the module loaded in the log since magisk just copy new links to the dummy system, which isn't written in the magisk.log.

Update:

Finally I get it, there is a systax error in the magisk_mask.sh script from v11.1 that causes copying links failed. I submitted the correction to the author just now. https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/pull/97/files?diff=unified

And the reason I didn't suffer it is that I'm using an old version v9 and it doesn't have this mistake.

Now, let's fix the su problem on our side temporarily. Open your terminal and paste these two commands,

su
/dev/busybox/cp -afc /magisk/.core/su/su /magisk/su_xbin_bind/system/xbin/

and reboot.

I will upload another version using this copying method as a temporary solution, after I get up. :rolleyes:
[Magisk] Xennet:
This is t best.... A problem found... Error notified... Dat can be corrected in the new build...

The beauty of cooperation and sharing of knowledge...
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
[MENTION=7897801]laggardkernel[/MENTION] Maybe you should start a support thread and submit your module to the repo. It's getting a bit OT, even though it's interesting...
[Magisk] abdulazizalfauzi:
Wanna ask about script executing, which folder in /magisk/.core/ should we put init.d scripts ? And which one for su.d scripts ? Still couldn't find the answer. The only thing i know when magisk still use phh it's in phh folder. Thanks
[Magisk] laggardkernel:
Thx for your advice. I opened a support thread for the module. But I'd better not submit this to the repo now, since the module couldn't function well when it's flashed through Magisk Manager.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Wrong thread. As stated in the OP, general support questions go in the support thread.

But, having said that... Read this:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=70897029&postcount=12
[Magisk] Pasi200896:
Hey people,

I've got two issues in use of Magisk.

My device is Samsung Galaxy S6 Flat (G920F) running Alexis Rom (The end of MM). Magisk v11.1 and Manager v4.2.6.

Issue 1: Since yesterday I can't pass SafetyNet any more. It only shows me "CTS profile mismatch" if i check. I didn't change anything, but somehow yesterday in the morning everything was ok, afternoon no SafetyNet pass.

Issue 2: Always after reboot and opening Magisk Manager it says there is no Magisk installed, but I flashed v11.1 already a few times. Well, it says I have to install "Magisk v11,1" - yes. With a komma. After installing this version of Magisk, it recommends me to reboot my device. Before yesterday I just denied and SafetyNet passed after turning Magisk Hide off and on again, but now this doesn't work.

Hope anyone can help me. Please feel free to ask if anything you need to know isn't mentioned.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That sounds like a question perfectly suited for the support thread:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382
[Magisk] xJovs:
I made a thread over 2 months ago on how to bypass SafetyNet w/ magisk and I have an extra step that can also help with bypassing SafetyNet here. Step 6 is the specific step I am talking about. It is "supposedly" meant as an alternative to setting SELINUX to Enforcing as it SafetyNet's access to viewing those files. It's supposed to be reflecting stock android where it isn't supposedly view-able in the first place and custom roms just make it view-able for some reason.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yes, I've seen mentions of that before, but it had slipped my mind. Thanks. From what I understand, this is only a issue with Samsung (OT: boy am I glad I don't have a Samsung).

I'll see about working it into the guide, but there's no use for the init.d emulator. This can all be done with Magisk.
[Magisk] xJovs:
Didn't even know that was possible. And yeah, I have the Samsung plague. I'll eventually switch to a better phone in the next year or so lol.
[Magisk] kantjer:
Found a way to get Tasker to work with latest Magisk without the superuser freeze hack.

Adding this to the build.prop does the trick.

# modversion this line enables Tasker root support

source: http://tasker.dinglisch.net/userguide/en/faqs/faq-problem.html#root
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Since this goes against the systemlessness of Magisk, I must say I prefer the other methods described.

But, then again, you could make a module that replaces the entire build.prop with this line added... Still a bit cumbersome, but systemless.

Thanks for the tip.
[Magisk] jsaxon2:
You could make a module to set the prop and not replace the whole build.prop file. Quite simple actually. Check out the Google assistant enabler to see how it is done.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I think you misunderstood... It's not about setting a prop, it's about adding a comment line to the build.prop file. You can't do that with the resetprop tool.

And personally I feel it's better to use the official documentation provided by the developer. You get so much more information then...

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-details-dummies-to-developers-t3473486
[Magisk] kantjer:
Yes, I figured that out.

I added the line to the ROM's source build.prop. Problem solved
[Magisk] atsoca:
Is there a place to see all the available modules?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The ones that are in the repo can be found in the Manager. There's also a bunch of threads for modules in the Magisk forums that haven't been added to the repo for various reasons. And, there's probably some modules to be found in your device's forums as well.
[Magisk] slekkas:
Hi,

I'm using a TV GO app to watch TV and it worked fine with Magisk 6.5. I had to update to 11.5 in order to get sony remote play to work but now I can't get my TV GO app to work. It keeps saying that root is found. I checked it in Magisk hide and SafetyNet check passes successfully. Anyone can offer some tips? I'm sure we'll get it to work since it was working on 6.5.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Have you tried any of the tips in post #4?

Edit: it's not updated for Magisk v11.5 yet, but I'll take care of that as soon as possible.
[Magisk] slekkas:
I tried most things but nothing. It was so easy with 6.5:(. Just toggled the hide root and it worked.

Since the safetynet check passes I'm not sure what to try.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk has come a long way since v6... No nostalgia here. :D

Go to the support thread (it's good to keep support like this in one place, IMO, and besides this is not the place for general support) and provide your device details (as much as possible) and a Magisk log (verbose logging enabled). If no-one else comes along I'll see if I can take a look at it later.
[Magisk] YoGieZ:
why, magiskhide never work in MIUI ROM :(

ROM

xiaomi.eu 7.3.19

Nougat

anyone can help me?
[Magisk] android_smater:
hello any one getting problem in magisk relating to loss root or saftynet not able to bypass then do this

first remain on stock rom

install magisk 11.5 +

install magisk manager

goto to magisk manager

setting ticks magisk hide and adblock host

and untick enable busybox

disable usb debugging

and reboot

if you installed supersu and busybox plz uninstall it and full unroot first

and delete su and busybox using twrp file manager

in system/bin

system /xbin