yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] 089man:
Hi, for your info...

I'm back to Rom build 0707, magisk 13.1..

Now my issues I wrote last messages are gone.. No soft reboots or freezes at start after sim code the carrier provider is available without delay...

But the time for starts the apps is horrible since 13.1... 1 minutes after reboot the apps startet... Can anybody confirm?

I think I go also back to magisk 12..

Magisk is not the problem for the reboots or freezes system I think... It's the rom builds after 0707 here...

At this time all works great, with known bugs example sound crackle... I don't understand that this nobody fixed.. This is known since Jan 2017 or earlier...

Gesendet von meinem SM-G935F mit Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
Yep, as I said multiple times ... it makes no sense with zero feedback/communication from/to the DEV/maintainer ......

And I agree ... some base features have to work properly/stable to make this AOSP really usable as daily driver ....

in addition to that .... it may your preference to have sound working at it's best, for me it's connectivity with my Gear S2 /

Camera 360 (2017) etc. ...

But we discussed this already long and extensive and are in-line :) ....

Nearly forgotten:

A base thought of AOSP is ..... OpenSource .... there should be never a wish to "port" other vendor's

frameworks to this ROM by reverse-engineering etc. .... otherwise this model is just senseless.

(and for extra functionality like original SAMSUNG camera quality .. either vendor's modules/drivers

are running "as-is", it can be gained by re-working from given source or has to be stopped .

The consequence of this is .... one, who needs the original features/stability/smoothness has to stay

on a TW-.based ROM ... as I decided ... at least for now ...
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] 089man:
You right, but TW is only for short time actually, after 1 year Samsung don't give updates because bring new models for buy... Also the stock custom rom, example Superman Rom the same.. For me that Rom was great but since nougat only 4 or 5 updates.. This was 3 months ago the most used and downloaded Rom but now since 3 months dead and outdated.... For me this was reason to come to RR rom.. Here long time comes updates and new features... The only one bad thing is that here no support from Dev is available... But I can live with it... For me important continued development.. My very old device Samsung s2 is at this time also with 7.xx supported, no stock dev do that for long time... Aosp do that.

The problem is with stock TW, if comes new device the most Dev buy this and the other device dead or not supported anymore... Or bring not working unstable port roms.. But the fantastic original rom was not supported... Example Superman nougat... For 2 months I have say good by and comes here and I was happy, never go back to TW again....

I know that the nightly can have bugs or critical issues, but every time I can back to a older build with nandroid.... It's full OK for me....

Gesendet von meinem SM-G935F mit Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
No need to tell me that :) I'm OpenSource fighter .... otherwise I'd not be an employee of SUSE :)

But this has limits, if it comes to core functionality/reliability ... and the annoying BT bug was never fixed ... and I

use BT/speaker switching heavily .. so this bug affects me in my productivity ....

But maybe, I'll revert too to an older build, where I have only one or two remaining issues .. I'll see ....
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] Scr@tchy:
Hi,

today i install the latest build with fire kernel and magisk. All works fine no fc´s. Has anyone a tool or a other solution for backup all settings? Install the rom goes fast but after all to setup the settings is that what i hate :( .

Thanks
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] kaalalto:
Same here...AOSP is really the best thing we could offer to our devices, but this time I must revert to TW since the core component of a (smart)phone stills buggy since months. I cannot use my S7 edge for productivity reasons : switching to loudspeaker, bluetooth...etc. :rolleyes:

I was ready to sacrify the camera quality but when you have serious conversations and your partner cannot hear you, it's become a big problem ! :(

Good bye AOSP (for the moment !) :)
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] 089man:
Oh yes this I search too.. Long time ago there was a tool that can that.. But it's not supported later...

But I have a other solution...

Go to titanium backup menu and go to create update.zip...

After you finish moved the file to external sd card...

Now you flash the rom, example clean flash..

After rom flash Google apps kernel magisk and all what you need... At the end flash the created update.zip and boot the device... Don't restore from saved Google if rom ask... You see later in background all your apps with data restored from this update zip file also all rom settings, desktop example nova settings widget and all you need...

You can go a other 2 way.... Flash rom, install rom and start first time. Make your normal settings example WiFi etc don't restore apps if rom setup ask... Later go to twrp again if standard settings from Rom you finish....

Flash the update zip file, normally if finish system boot alone, the device starts and now all your apps you have used before was restored now incl data and also all our rom settings launcher settings and so on...

Hope it works for you... You can do this with every rom, but don't use the created zip from RR for a other not RR rom...

I used this zip often because it's a good backup all apps and settings without system stuff... With this method you don't need restore manually all apps separately from titanium and you don't need make all settings in Rom again and again this zip do it for you automatically...

Gesendet von meinem SM-G935F mit Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
THANKS!!!!

The first one, who has the same opinion and issues!!!

Thats exactly the point...... main, core functionality is not given since months.... no timeline, how to fix the most urgent bugs (which should be obvious)..... and most important in such a situation...... no connectivity/feedback from the DEV/maintainer.......

I'm really willing to help testing builds and help others .... but this requires a bit help from the DEV side and show in an interactive way the move forward towards stability!
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] optionalmgrr.la:
Please let support https://www.generosity.com/community-fundraising/make-exynos-great-again
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
Sorry, I donated already..... but this touches exactly my topic of my (and other members) last posts:

I expect some communication/cooperation at some point in time, otherwise I see no real sense and future here! And I think, this request is not too much.....

[MENTION=535343]all[/MENTION]: Again, some assistance would be great to agree with this request (not my first one!)

Just show it with "Thanks" :D
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] 089man:
Magisk 13.2 is out.. Now you can test again if your issues gone.... Manager 5.05 also new version.. Will test now with 0707....

Gesendet von meinem SM-G935F mit Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
Already done.... no changes...... as the FC's start after a plain install, before installing MM/Magisk zip!

So, Google Play Service FC's are NOT Magisk-related!
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] 089man:
Only question.... Substratum mod?

Yesterday I have with this mod FC because I have don't uninstall magisk 4.xx substratum mod... Open Google app nano you used too?

Now here running magisk 13.2 and manager 5.05... With build RR 0707 no issues, only the apps starts after sim card pin slowly too..all other OK....

Gesendet von meinem SM-G935F mit Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
No, nothing.... will test now with older openGAPPS
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
Update:

Test with RR 20170714 / openGAPPS nano 20170713 / Magisk 13.2

(with and without SAFETY NET module)

FC's came later .. as soon as you try to check SAFETY NET STATUS ...

but then frequently ....

So, nothing changes ... TW (HELIOS, updated to Magisk 13.2) is far more smooth

and works for all (my) requirements without any tweaks etc.

Even the update from 13.1 to 13.2 ... just like a charm ... sorry ...

But still valid .... with DEV support/interaction, I'm sure, we would get this

sorted out .... and could all stay on AOSP !
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
Update: With Magisk v12, all is fine so far..... including SAFETYNET!!!
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] 089man:
Here the same... 13x is not OK at all.. It's need horrible time to start the rom after push sim pin... With version 12 all normal...

Carrier lost often with RR builds after 0707 etc...

Version 12 is better and don't need 13.xx...

Gesendet von meinem SM-G935F mit Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] shelbym:
Anyone plz help.. my music automatically stops playing while listening to headphones once the screen is locked. And there is continuous popping and crackling sound in music. It happens with every earpiece and happens only on lineage os based roms..

I have Galaxy S7 edge exynos with Resurrection remix 7.1.2!!
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
Pls. search for posts of 089man, but basically, you have to remove microphone permission from Google app (as a consequence, voice detection like "o. k Google" wont work anymore.....

For the topic of stopping the music on screenlock .. I never had this issue.

And expect other, daily issues on this ROM like BT issues, instability with Magisk v13. x etc.

We (the testers here) are desperately seeking to get interactive communication with the maintainer (jesec), but this is since months a one-way communication...... he simply do not respond on any request/question..... even not on PM's ..... only the nightlies are pushed out..... which makes it very hard to support this ROM.

This situation forced me (and others) to (temporarily) switch back to TW-based custom ROM like Helios (which is proper maintained in regards to updates, their meaning to the end user etc.) all works here...... but we all want to come back to this ROM, once proper help/support to the community is given.......
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] shelbym:
I can't thank you enough as music is very important part of my life.. and yes you are right about support provided by Resurrection R team. Right now even OTA check for update is not working. Well if they keep going this way it won't last long.
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] Clarkiieh:
Not many nightly builds being dropped?
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] Mr.R™:
It's funny because I don't have a single problem with this Rom, no fc's, no reboots nothing, everything works as it should.

OK I tell a lie, I have one issue with magisk 13.2 and that's that if I try to open su it closes but that's not a Rom Issue and su still works for all apps so its really just superficial tbh.

I don't know what you guys are doing to break it but there's gotta be something
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] ZeRoZeRoRaZ:
I confirm this opinion with one exception I also don't have any issues with Magisk 13.2.
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] Baffsuki:
The speaker is very weak, any workarounds excrpt for Dolby Sound Atmos??
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
If it's o. k for you..... fine.... no issue :D
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] 089man:
Hi, since 2 days I have uninstall viper and install Dolby atmos from magisk 12.

Also the sound mod for RR I flashed.. It's works great... It's loud sound and in the dolby settings you can it make louder too...

Here my module and Dolby settings

The sound crackles here also avaliable but I think not so strongly as with my configuration before..

At this time I used RR build 0707 with magisk 12 and all works fine.... Sound crackles can removed if OK Google microphone permissions disabled...

Gesendet von meinem SM-G935F mit Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] Baffsuki:
Thanks :) Ill try that later
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] 089man:
The sound mod for RR rom you don't found in magisk.. You found here in this thread.. Pls search.. Must flash in twrp then you found the entry in magisk... For me this sound mod great because you hear the difference in quality.. I mean you have an sound in normal speaker and in microphone speaker near sensor..

Gesendet von meinem SM-G935F mit Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] Baffsuki:
Wow Thanks! Just like in TW ROMs!
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] 089man:
For me much better.... Here the sound mod

http://cloud.tapatalk.com/s/5969fee...Dual_Lv3_RR_-v2_Systemless_by_ZeRoZeRoRaZ.zip

Gesendet von meinem SM-G935F mit Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
Quick one:

AOSP is over for me now..... as connection/work with my new Gear 360 (2017) is very unreliable..... or impossible..... this adds one more dependency as a kill factor..... as the camera quality was always a main factor for me....

Take care......
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] kaalalto:
You're right. I don't want to be ungrateful but if the maintainer doesn't interact with us and even doesn't answer, I'm wondering if we cannot just ask him to let someone else to work on our device.

I had a Note 3 before running on AOSP and it was really a pleasure to report on XDA the bugs. I always had answers and bug fixes and maintainer and community were working hand in hand to build stable releases.

I'm really sorry to speak so frankly, but current builds are more likely alpha builds so I cannot advice no one to use this rom at this stage.

Thanks Jesec for the initiative, but being a maintainer is more than building nightlies automatically by integrating commits from RR sources....
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
So many thanks, kaalalto!!!!

I tried really the utmost to help/support here..... but was at the end really desperate....

You are speaking out of my heart..... and again, as my job is Senior Support Linux Engineer..... current scenario simply does not work over time....

The point here at this stage is to build a strong community to move forward..... to help each other and improve build by build..... which is not happening for our S7E.... without the main contribution of the maintainer.....

Thanks for your clear and honest words !!!
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] Scr@tchy:
Hi,

when i use Fire Kernel what are the best setting for performance and battery life? And i have a bug with my screen, sometimes when i take it on it becomes a red touch and when i turn screen off and on it works normally.
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] glazenwassertjuh:
Ik love this rom ferry much.

I have fire opal kernel and magisk 13.2 with safety net pass

All working perfect. I have also sound mod from post 2747

(Thank you 087man)

The only problem i have is Whatsapp. Sometimes when i am at work (outside) i dont get message.i only get message when i open Whatsapp. Sorry for my bad englisch

Have a Nice day
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] Scr@tchy:
I have the same Problem and use the same config.
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
I'm really curious about how you all managed to get RR working with Magisk 13.2 and SAGETYNET pass..... as soon as I post-install (regardless of the stable or beta version) the module, Google Play Service do randomly FC and triggering the check comes never back.

No issue with Magisk v12..... and with 13.2 on Helios!
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] reflexr:
I don't think this rom is stable for daily use? I want to change from touchwiz to pure android

Gesendet von meinem SM-G935F mit Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] PoochyX:
It's not stable....
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] reflexr:
Thank you. I think I'll look into lineage os

Gesendet von meinem SM-G935F mit Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
Update:

After a few investigations (analyzing the logs) ....... I found the reason,

why Magisk v13. x was not running with my default RR setup (which is btw. straight-forward!)..... and why it's fine for all, which uses the FireOpal-Kernel (or Helios :D)

Magic reason is: SELinux!!!

Standard RR uses SELinux in "enforcing" mode.... as a consequence, each app or system call, which is not aligning to the given SElinux context may produce, depending on the timing/function a ForceClose! This is, what happens here.

Installing the FireOpal kernel (or Helios) switches to "Permissive".... which results only in warnings..... and the app can continue to run.

No need tell the DEV's, that the goal should be to run in enforcing mode!

(side note...... with that result, I'm back :D)
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] darkoj2007:
I think after this much investigating by our selves we deserve love from some developer to solve these bugs, I know that they arent really hard to solve becouse isn`t something major. Btw I can say clearly that Footej camera is amazing to use with this rom, with manual iso and exposure results are almost identical to stock rom camera. Only if google assistant worked... :)
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] Sblast:
Hey there! Awesome ROM!

Is there anyway to make this compatible with fingertouch or easyHome?
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] :
Saying it's not stable is wrong. It depends on what you need / use. For me it is stable. Everything i am using is working.
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] epsoopl:
Try Dynamic Gapps. For me No issues with magisk 13.2

Im on 13.07 build with fire opal.

Also when u flash new build go in this order:

1.Rom 2:Kernel 3:Any mods u need 4:Gapps 5:Magisk

Funny thing about permisive kernel mode. I can't change that to enforcing with fire opal.

On my old S5 RR boeffla kernel i can change it with no problem.
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
:) No need to tell me, how to flash :)

But thanks anyway !!!

Topic: DynamicGAPPS vs. openGAPPS ... this is not the point ..

As I stated, FC's stopps, as soon as I switch to Permissive mode ....

(so regardless, which GAPPs you chose)

In regards to FireOpal and "Permissive" (I call it lazy mode .. sorry DEV's !)

FireOpal kernel thread, post #68

Quote:

Originally Posted by jcrompton

Sorry to be a pest ... but have some sort of patches allowed for full Magisk support for this kernel now ? Does magisk Hide now work ??

I forced the kernel to Permissive so there shouldn't be any problem.

==> Should be clear now, why you can't switch to "Enforcing" !

Btw. Crash of Google Play Services could be caused by a signature issue ....

[MENTION=231896]dev[/MENTION]'s: Can someome (preferrably jesec :) ) check (and take, if required, as it was

from Dec 2016) this fix

https://github.com/LineageOS/android_vendor_cm/commit/a3a76f5d1cc233ad8024ffdc74bb3a786e1605c3

upstream ???

(if I would not have a real job in parallel, I could support much more here !)
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
O.K. last update, before heading to work (and back to Helios until the next tests :) )

Clean flash with today's builds (RR/openGAPPs) and Magisk 13.2

Initially, the same FC's while core setup .... and no change, even changed SELinux to "Permissive" ....

so not usable in this constellation ... but this should be the working base (without FireOpal

kernel)

So, there is heavy, integrative work to be done to bring this ROM into the near of stability

and usability (just talking about core requirements) .. sorry, just facts, which can't be discussed

away ....

---------- Post added at 07:31 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:24 AM ----------

Agreed .. if you have minimal requirements to a ROM, it may look stable for you .....

But I think, a general owner of a high-end phone like the S7 Edge want to have a bit more features and

stability. And is not willing to miss all core features just to have OpenSource ..... the mix has to fit .....

Agreed, I'm ready to dismiss the superb camera of the TW stock ... and the connectivity to my Gear 360 (2017)

will also maybe never work ... but the rest is a MUST ..... and possible ..... if the complete community works together ...

interactive communication with the DEV's ... bug reports, feedback of their plan to fix etc .... but this here is

more or less a dead end .... I stop here .... as I stated my opinion very often (confirmed by many others).

So, this way, we can only wait, what is the result of the next nightly builds .... and test and hope ........
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] 089man:
I have switch now from 0707 to 1707, magisk 13.2 and manager 5.0.6

All works at this time and after update.. Have dirty flash...

The only little problem is the start the rom apps after push the sim pin.. It's to long time since magisk 13...

Can anybody confirm?

Gesendet von meinem SM-G935F mit Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
SAFETYNET fails ....

Just FYI ...... as it's not a ROM/Magisk issue ...

SAFETYNET fails again .. as Google released an update and put

stronger check requirements in place ... let's see, how/when this is

being fixed on Magisk side ... it's a cat & mice run ....
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] iOrpheus06:
It depends on how you define "stable".

For basic usage (calls, text, audio playback, streaming and mobile data) it is stable.

But if you rely on google assistant (OK google) esp. When you use BT audio and BT calling, then No.
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
Agreed for smooth running, but with clean flash on my side ... including FireOpal Kernel,

SAFETYNET patch (even useless at the moment), V4A/DualSpeaker mod

No noticeable delay anywhere ....

And there is a chance to get my Gear 360 (2017) running, too ... this would

be great ....
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] Isenberg:
I can confirm this! In my case I have a short screen freeze too.

The MagiskSU tries, after push the sim pin, to set root permissions for a system app like f.e. "OS System", "Theme Interfacer", "Settings" or "SettingsStorage".

In this time the system "freezes" and when I try to open the settings I got a "white screen".

After a while the permission is denied and everything works normal.

And the funny thing is: After several installations eyerytime another system app tries to get root permission.

I got this with ANY RR-build, any Magisk-version (12, 13 beta, 13.1, 13.2) and both kernels (RR-stock and Fire Opal).

With LineageOS erverything is normal and no system app tries to get root permissions at the start.

Does everyone have the same problem? Normally system apps shouldn't ask for root permission with Masgisk.
[Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos) ROMs, Kernels, Rec] klaustroeger:
As you describe it now more clear, yes, I can confirm, that I see sometimes the same issue .. just thought in the

past, this is normal .. but you are true .. it isn't .....