yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] espionage724:
Thanks; disabling Magisk Hide and rebooting brings Developer Options back.

I don't suppose it's a huge problem in my case; when I fresh-install ROMs, I do a bit of messing about over ADB, but once done, I end up turning it off.
[Magisk] kgr:
I still seem to be having problems with MH not being enabled on boot, on the Magisk-v13.0-170709 build. The toggle is set to on, but checks fail until I disable & re-enable MH. See attached logs. Thanks to anyone who can help.
[Magisk] manos78:
Hi,

I started with Magisk v12 & Manager <5.0 with a Moto G4 Android 6.0

- Then I installed Manager 5.0... and I installed v13.1 from Manager, reboot and not upgraded.

- Then I install v13.1 with TWRP, reboot and Magisk doesn't work.

- Then I uninstalled Magisk inside TWRP (flashing ZIP), then I reboot to TWRP, I installed v13.1 with ZIP, I reboot and Magisk doesn't work.

- Then I reinstalled Magisk Manger, reboot and doesn't work.

And I do several times the Wipes of Cache.... NOTHING WORKS!

So, the only solution is do a rollback to v12... flash uninstall ZIP with TWRP, reboot, flash v12 ZIP, wipe cache, reboot and... voilà!

I feel the version v13.1 isn't compatible with all devices and/or Android versions.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You're in the wrong thread. This is the unofficial snapshot thread... You want the support thread.

When you move over to the support thread, make sure to provide details ("Magisk doesn't work" doesn't say anything about your issue) and logs. At the least a Magisk log (from the Manager or /cache through TWRP).

Magisk have never been compatible with all devices/Android versions...
[Magisk] NinjaBoyLao:
I got hip to this new "unofficial" build stuff after somebody in the main support thread said that switching to the latest snapshot enabled them to pass SafetyNet. As of today, I have been unable to pass SafetyNet. I know for a fact I passed it fine yesterday, I check several times, typically because I play mobile games that use it (looking at you, fe heroes, and your stupid corrupting of the save when safetynet doesn't pass). Nothing I've done has allowed me to pass SafetyNet. I've toggled developer options, I've played with the MagiskHide starting and stopping manually, I've wiped my cache and dalvik cache from TWRP, nothing. I also performed a clean uninstall through flashing the uninstall script through TWRP, and rebooted. Obviously, I didn't have root or magisk, but Magisk Manager said I was passing SafetyNet just fine. A clean install again by flashing through TWRP led to me passing SafetyNet for about 30 seconds, then it stopped again. At this point, I'm ready to just tear my face off and die. My device is a Moto X Pure (XT1575, clark) and i'm on android 6.0, latest manufacturer updates. I've been playing with Magisk v13.1 and Manager v5.0.4. I can attach a bunch of logs that I have, but I'm not sure which ones will be useful. Please help me puzzle out what's going on, as I haven't heard anything about safetynet being updated, and I haven't done anything different than what I normally do.
[Magisk] NinjaBoyLao:
Here's some logs, I apologize if they aren't the right ones.
[Magisk] PokemonTotalWar:
Does everyone else's Magisk Manager crash when trying to update the app itself?
[Magisk] guest4711:
No problem here.

If updating from magisk manager fails, you should flash the uninstaller and then magisk13.2. via TWRP.
[Magisk] PokemonTotalWar:
I'm using the automatic builds shared earlier in this thread, not official builds. The automatic build is still on 13.1 until tomorrow, but the Manager has an update and if I click the notification I just get a FC error. I'd pull a log but I'm laying down for bed and I need a notification and that's inconsistent at best.
[Magisk] PokemonTotalWar:
Sorry for the double post, Labs doesn't let me add photos to a post. I got a notification just after posting that saying there was a 13.2 build and a Manager update. The job must be scheduled for some time in the past few hours and I wasn't aware. I captured a log for the Manager crash. Screenshot attached.
[Magisk] jhobc:
Latest update 13.2 (170714) crash when I download any module. (After the download is finished)

Log attached
[Magisk] kantjer:
Try today's magiskmanager, should be fixed
[Magisk] jhobc:
Getting some unmounted errors.

SN still passing

Log attached
[Magisk] Berko457:
Safetynet don't work for me. Every time it's false. And with magisk hide it also didn't work...

I can't use Snapchat please help...:(
[Magisk] kouss77550:
We already know that safetynet don't pass right now because it updated

And to use Snapchat chat just use magisk hide and select Snapchat
[Magisk] Berko457:
I have already done that but that didn't work too..

Magisk hide works on other apps but on snapchat it didn't work. I think snapchat is too safe :mad:
[Magisk] Paschfire:
Google has changed their Safety-Net checks thus Magisk hide won't be working currently, you'll need to wait until the Magisk Devs have time to catchup in the changes. It should work fine once the next release drops.
[Magisk] Chocklety Boyee:
There is a module..
[Magisk] Paschfire:
Here are the two posts from the Official v13 Thread discussing possible solutions to succeed in passing Safety-Net check until a fix has been released.

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73060378&postcount=16439

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73060464&postcount=16440
[Magisk] teorouge:
Can you share a link, if that's still working properly?

Inviato dal mio LeTv 1 Pro utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] dannycellestio:
Could anyone explain to me why I cannot install modules? Neither from the recovery nor from the Magisk Manager? It's just tells me "Installation error". I searched every Magisk-related thread on which I could find a solution to this, but I didn't get very far with it. Thanks in advance!
[Magisk] marky310:
https://github.com/noahajac/Magisk-v13.2-SafetyNet-Fix/releases

It worked on mine, LGV20 on Magisk 13.2 running AOKP
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you provide a recovery log from the failed installation you might get an answer.
[Magisk] w20grippy:
Magisk safety check "all false value", so painful.

---------- Post added at 08:58 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:52 PM ----------

wow, worked like magic. thanks man.
[Magisk] Paschfire:
The module(s) including other solutions are available within the links in my previous post directly above yours.
[Magisk] jhobc:
Hi! Getting a problem with the latest update - 13.3

Here's the steps I did:

1 - Flashed the latest uninstaller (20170719)

2 - Flashed the latest update - 13.3 (20170718)

3 - Rebooted

4 - Magisk Manager opened normally

5 - Rebooted to Recovery and flashed some modules

6 - Rebooted to System

7 - Magisk Manager stuck at splash screen.

8 - Log attached
[Magisk] tonysunshine:
I have a similar problem. Updated magisk manager to 5.1.0 and the app gets stuck on the green splash screen. I reverted back to magisk manager 5.0.5 and it works just fine with Magisk 13.3. Passes CTS and everything
[Magisk] Ta3hi:
When ever I have my phone on airplane mode and I open the app it doesn't work and crashes and it doesnt hide root.
[Magisk] SuperSandro2000:
Your installation is not correct cuz the main app screen misses a lot of things. Reinstall it
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
That's what it looks like when there's no internet connection ;)
[Magisk] SuperSandro2000:
Ohhh. Nvm then
[Magisk] Berko457:
I didn't find the module. Is this module from the internet or is this don't available in my country?
[Magisk] guest4711:
Here you go

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/safetynet-fix-pass-safetynet-2017-07-17-t3637801/page11
[Magisk] Ubimo:
This new magisk log is veeery long and confusing. Can someone please take a look at it if everything is ok? Thanks.
[Magisk] hanschke:
if I try to add a module the app crashed for the install :(
[Magisk] Gazzasore:
Same with me too

I haven't managed to install any modules yet
[Magisk] r1l_Alex_™:
No issues here.

Running the current 802 build.
[Magisk] yung40oz84:
Latest is working fine in Angler, DU, Flash
[Magisk] nLz_phone:
Hi!

1.:

Am I correct?:

-install latest magisk manager from this community-beta: https://github.com/kantjer/MagiskFiles

-download via magisk-app the latest magisk.zip

-unlock bootloader via adb (honor 8, Emui 5.0, Android 7.0, kernel 4.1.18-g03082e2, build ...B389, model FRD-L09)

-flash twrp-3.1.1-1-frd.img (this threat: https://xdaforums.com/honor-8/development/twrp-t3566563 )

-flash magisk.zip via twrp

.

then i'm fine with systemless additiom/root/magisk, stock rom and ota and no problems?

2.:

is it safe to flash stock recovery after this and relock the bootloader?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
1 - Skip the first couple of steps and just download the Magisk zip from the same link. The Manager will be installed when you flash the zip in TWRP.

2 - If you want to keep the stock recovery you can just boot TWRP instead of flashing it:

fastboot boot twrp.img

If you're gonna be modding your device I'd advice keeping your bootloader unlocked. To much can go wrong and with a locked bootloader you might be stuck with a nice paper weight.

Edit: For OTA you're gonna have to restore the stock boot image before updating and if any root app have done some modifications to /system it'll fail.
[Magisk] nLz_phone:
many thanks

many thanks,

i didn't know that u can run a different recovery without flashing it.

seems a good idea to stay unlocked.

maybe i will try later and give some feedback :fingers-crossed:
[Magisk] nLz_phone:
damn it

PS C:\Users\nLz\Desktop\honor 8\adb> fastboot boot twrp.img
downloading 'boot.img'...
OKAY [ 0.537s]
booting...
FAILED (remote: Command not allowed)
finished. total time: 0.544s
PS C:\Users\nLz\Desktop\honor 8\adb>

just why ? so i cant acess twrp... i dont want to flash it... or even try to flash it, i just want it to boot up

what else can i do?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It's not quite the place for these kind of questions (more suited for your device's forum or the general Q&A). But... Have you unlocked your bootloader? You'll still need to do that to boot TWRP.
[Magisk] nLz_phone:
its unlocked, if i try to unlock it again it sais "its already unlocked"

sorry for asking in here, but i'm stuck in this situation..

any hints why i cant boot the recovery?

may i try to flash it, as i suggested ?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Hm... Might be a device specific thing. You can of course try to flash instead:

fastboot flash recovery twrp.img

But, there's a good chance that will end up with the same result. If so, I'd go to your device's forum for advice.

Edit: Nevermind... :D
[Magisk] nLz_phone:
never mind... i did not managed it.. now i flashed twrp, which went without problems..

then i adb sideload magisk and flashed it.

i just have to watch for the original recovery now i guess.

magist installed succesful. :happy:
[Magisk] Ophidian_DarkCore:
new magisk snapshot 8/12 no boot kernel doesnt finish loading, i was on 8/11 just fine
[Magisk] nLz_phone:
i'm fine on 8/12 all boots up correctly
[Magisk] Kloosek:
I have that same issue so I'm back to stable version v 13.3

Wysłane z mojego LG-H850 przy użyciu Tapatalka

---------- Post added at 03:04 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:03 PM ----------

I have that same issue so I'm back to the stable version 13.3

Wysłane z mojego LG-H850 przy użyciu Tapatalka
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Give the new official beta a go. If you experience issues, make sure to mind the wise words of [MENTION=6842057]The Flash[/MENTION]: https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73381188&postcount=2710
[Magisk] Ophidian_DarkCore:
This is the op's thread, not yours. But thanks anyways.
[Magisk] kantjer:
:confused:
[Magisk] Paschfire:
Maybe you should actually READ the OP section you seem fond in reference of, you might be surprised whom you're addressing with your snide remarks.

I also strongly suggest you READ the information contained within the link previously shared with you, as this issue report is useless in its current form. Having no Magisk Log, Recovery Log, Logcat, or anything related to your devices current setup, pointless.
[Magisk] II_DiE_4:
Any1 else having the magisk_daemon post-fs using alot of cpu constantly? Happens with 8/11 8/12 and 13.5 beta.
[Magisk] RSDamasceno:
+1

Logs:

EDIT: Xposed systemless is the cause of bootloop.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Someone mentioned they experienced this after disabling logging in Kernel Auditor, or something like that. Is that something you've done?
[Magisk] II_DiE_4:
Actually yes.. Wow weird. Didn't even cross my mind that it would cause something like this
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk relies quite heavily on Androids logging...

---------- Post added at 17:19 ---------- Previous post was at 16:36 ----------

Just as confirmation: Do the issue disappear if you enable logging again?
[Magisk] II_DiE_4:
Yea it seems to calm down.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
I managed to build Magisk with Travis CI: https://travis-ci.org/TheComputerGuy96/Magisk/builds/264388520 :o
[Magisk] Ophidian_DarkCore:
meh

nice catch
[Magisk] jenslody:
I mentioned it already several times (here or in a beta or in the main-thread), last time was here: xposed has to be flashed through twrp or it runs in a bootloop, but unmodified xposed will (most likely) not run at all with newest Magisk. You can use my version from the link I just gave (at least use the "post-fs-data.sh"-script in it.

I will try to dig into the bootloop-thing as soon as possible.
[Magisk] jenslody:
I found the cause (and afix) for the bootloop when flashing Xposed through MagiskManager.

See my updated post in the beta-thread.

It has a modified Magisk-v13.6 version attached, where the issue is fixed.
[Magisk] Gazzasore:
I flashed the update through Magisk this morning

Did restart but stuck on the Galaxy Note 3 n9005 screen

Had to reinstall ROM to get it going again

Oh and flashed an older version of Magisk
[Magisk] hanschke:
same here Nexus 6P with Lineage
[Magisk] Prowler:
Bootloop ?

D851, L'OS
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
This issue is already known by [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] (It'll be fixed eventually, so just wait)
[Magisk] hanschke:
I flashed the old build to fix it. Can anyone tell me the workaround if the root feature will lost after minutes?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Try to force stop Magisk Manager
[Magisk] hanschke:
I dont have any option to force a stop.
[Magisk] godofsalt:
Main "Phone Settings" scroll to and tap on "Apps"....

Scroll to the app that you want to look at. Tap on the App.

On top of screen you should have 2 highlighted or Shaded boxes ( "Uninstall" and "Force Closed" or on some it's "Force Stop").

Tap on Force Close ....

Done..

Hope this helps
[Magisk] JEANRIVERA:
nice but what is the point of that? i thought the purpose of magisk is to modfy the system with out really touching it? it is an honest question I am not beaing sarcastic or anything like it, I really want to understand what are you trying to achieve. :confused::confused::confused:
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
So I have a couple questions about this. Am I supposed to run the magisk uninstaller before I install this? I know I have to uninstall the old app and install the new one since the signatures are different. Also, my other question is why is there a su file inside of the installer zip but it doesn't actually give root? That file wasn't in the Magisk 9.0 installer which is why I ask. Last question would be was the 12/31 build posted supposed to include the supposed fix for the losing root bug? Because if it is I'm not seeing that it's fixed still.

Edit: I can confirm the zip does include phh root. One zip is better than two imo. Now if once it's all fixed and finalized if we can get a addon.d script so we don't have to flash any zips when updating we'd be able to use the normal update system :)
[Magisk] :
I too observed the su binary after you said...

So i completely uninstalled the magisk and reinstall the the snapshot version (latest 31 one) and found that it is pre-rooted with phh r-266 but thats not the issue i just removed the r-266 module and installed r-266-2 one

And about the fixes it doesn't lose the root anymore when magisk hide is enabled it is now fixed and stable it also passes safety net check when Xposed disabled ???
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
I was passing CTS before but now it's not so idk what the crap is going on.
[Magisk] :
I

BadLuck???

"Enable magisk hide"

I am passing it...

What i did is unistall magisk v9 flashed snapshot v10 flashed phh superuser r266-2 flashed xposed 87 disabled xposed rebooted and ticked magisk hide rebooted cheked Google play services and other google stuffs in magisk hide again rebooted and here are the results ... I think if you are using any custom rom then you have first unsu it an if supersu before then unroot it use phh superuser

Proof pics: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1aa85vwl06bSHhTUWdXb1czRjQ/view?usp=drivesdk

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1aa85vwl06bcC1mcDFpRGtWdkU/view?usp=drivesdk

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1aa85vwl06bd3BkbHpnZ092d0U/view?usp=drivesdk
[Magisk] HaoZeke:
I don't know if this is the right place to ask but....

Would anyone here know how to compile Magisk into an aosp based rom?

I know I can always flash it but it'd be super awesome to have it compile and build with a rom / kernel.......
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
As you say, Magisk v10 comes pre-rooted, as in: it installs phh's superuser if SuperSU isn't detected. But, no need to uninstall it if you want to use phh's... :D topjohnwu has just changed the naming of his Magisk version. Phh's superuser r266 (topjohnwu v1) that comes with this v10 build is actually newer than r266-2 (versioncode 5 vs versioncode 4). To see what I'm talking about, check the commits from 8 and 11 of December.
[Magisk] :
Thnx for informing i really don't know about it???
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
As I already said, it isn't.

http://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/unofficial-magisk-v10-beta-built-t3521901/post70339058

More fixing is still necessary.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
addon.d is a /system folder, so no real way to do that, I'm afraid.

P.S. And that's not even a stock folder, I don't believe - that's a custom AOSP ROM folder for preserving GApps, isn't it?
[Magisk] :
I read that topjohnwu is working on multirom support based on an open source project dual boot patcher does the future snapshot will have multirom support any idea about it and sorry if i ask something wrong or in a wrong place
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
No. That's still in the future.
[Magisk] naveenfre:
hai

i using cm13,

but i got safetynet failed cts mismatch

when i flashed unsu.zip

it remove all files including supersu inbuild also,i tryed magisk v10 and last magisk manager also

i little confused can you plse tell step by step process
[Magisk] :
1. Unsu your cm

2. Uninstall any magisk by magisk unistaller zip and do a clean Start

3. Uninstall xposed too

4. Flash magisk v10 and install magisk manager snapshot version

5. Flash phh superuser r266-2 (must)

6. Install phh superuser from play store

7. Reboot system

8. Open magisk manager in settings enable magisk hide

9. Reboot

10. Again open magisk manager now in open magisk hide tab

11. In that select Google play services (must)

12. And tick other Google apps to not necessary

13. Reboot

14. Important thing after all this install selinux changer apk and make selinux enforcing inshort make it enforcing

15.Reboot

Note: if you want to pass safety net use system less xposed only and disable it cts will not match if enabled

I wish it would work for you as i am on stock i have no idea about custom roms

Finger crossed reply if works
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
I'm struggling with the latest build, magisk won't ask for root. Any ideas?

'Rooted but no root permission, not allowed?' is the error in the magisk app. I've got superuser beta 11 installed.
[Magisk] :
Reboot will work and if not flash phh superuser r266-2 zip i too faced the problem but not know how the r266-2 fixed it my problem was the app was not showing modules but fixed automatically i hope it will help
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Nice one r266-2 fixed it!
[Magisk] Deic:
Yeah and only works with ROMs zip that have implemented that function (generally update-script that calls a script in root of the zip in CyanogenMod ROMs). If you install any ROM zip that have not that function added in updater-script, then obviously addon.d scripts not get executed & /system is replaced as regular.
[Magisk] afcaajax:
Do you guys know how I can fix this error

Verstuurd vanaf mijn SM-G930F met Tapatalk
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
Well I reverted to magisk 9 but kept the manager for now and I pass CTS again so I think I'll just wait until the root problem is fully fixed and then try again.
[Magisk] hanschke:
ok I thought it is an option from the manager
[Magisk] YamazakiRobert:
[MENTION=2226076]stangri[/MENTION] and [MENTION=3306843]kantjer[/MENTION] they have made a full change on the build process maybe this will fix the lasts FC we are receive when install gapps

or if you can point me in right direction to use the last build on last build of LOS i would be great full
[Magisk] Firdhaus81:
Dear advisors,

Iam using stock samsung note 4 SM-910G. Snapdragon 805. Android 6.0.1. Marshmallow. I need advise on to how to install magisk on my device. Can it be done? Appreciate on a step by step instruction on how do i install it.
[Magisk] MultiKoopa:
I wonder why this didn't work...

Tried to do the Oreo update, and then Magisk re-install, through FlashFire.

Put the Stock boot image at the top of the queue this time, as was suggested earlier in the thread (as shown in the attached image)

....all it did was unroot me (and I guess restore the stock boot image)

did I screw up the FlashFire queue order?
[Magisk] KaMyKaSii:
If you put it to install the incremental ota (instead of the full ota), in addition to stock boot.img you should also install the stock system.img and/or any other important partition that you modified. Probably the ota has detected that your system is modified and therefore failed to update. Please send the /sdcard/FlashFire/lastlog file just to be sure

Ps: It is also clearly described in FlashFire that "auto-mount" should not be activated for otas
[Magisk] MultiKoopa:
Well I have been known to make mistakes before :P

Do Magisk and/or FlashFire make system.img backups? I'm not sure where to find the stock one :\

Here's the lastlog file. seems to be really badly formatted
[Magisk] KaMyKaSii:
Did you watch the FlashFire screen during the process? Did your device restart soon after the installation of boot.img? From what I saw in the log, FlashFire crashed after installing the stock boot.img and did not complete the other actions. You should take this issue to the official FlashFire thread.
[Magisk] MultiKoopa:
Yes that is what happened exactly. It restarted very quickly. I'll try the FlashFire topic, thanks :)
[Magisk] jimbomodder:
Latest version 13.7 (170830) fails to pass safety net, clean install on nexus 6 with clean install of aicp. Log attached
[Magisk] Ace42:
Revert to 8/29. It still passes.
[Magisk] jimbomodder:
Rebooted and it passed, prob just a bug
[Magisk] Ubimo:
I think there is a problem with latest Magisk-v13.7_170831.zip. It won't install. Even after redownloading or via TWRP.
[Magisk] koraymers:
Exactly
[Magisk] JEANRIVERA:
I can confirm that too!
[Magisk] kantjer:
I can confirm

I will remove it later

The one time I didn't check before uploading :(
[Magisk] mg_jishad:
Installation failed :(
[Magisk] xdaer2014:
Confirmed too. It won't install
[Magisk] guest4711:
FC after checking Safetynet without having any g-spps...

Not a big problem but annoying: When you ask for checking the state of safetynet, a popup appears, that you need Google Play Services. After acknowledging this message MagiskManager FC's. It should return to mainscreen instead.

Seen on 13.7 (20170830).
[Magisk] Paschfire:
If you could pls capture a logcat of the FC then uploading the logcat here, as it could be helpful to the Developer in possibly solving these types of issues.

Including the Magisk Log couldn't hurt either.

Pls remember to always include logs within your error/bug reports, otherwise there's really no point in reporting the problem.

Thank you.