yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] insanemhenlo:
i cannot find a working twrp 3 for my phone. There is 2 i have found but the screen is unresponsive to touches with them. Is there a way to have a systemless root with xposed while using twrp 2.8.7.0?
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
Read post #2285.

Basically magisk with magisk hide are the best options for me. ATM. I was using Suhide, Suhide.55, systemless xposed 86.2. And rootswitch 1.3.3.2. This setup does not play well with newer devices. Stick to Magisk.

---------- Post added 05-04-2017 at 12:06 AM ---------- Previous post was 04-04-2017 at 11:46 PM ----------

I have Snorlax Reloaded and Pokemon Go Controls working.

Make sure you have latest Magisk and Magisk Manager installed, Magisk Hide enabled, Root Switch 1.3.3.2, and the official Xposed v87 installed.

Go to Root Switch, disable Xposed. Soft reboot.(necessary for the next steps)

1. Go to RootSwitch click to enable exposed, when prompted, do a soft/fast reboot.

2. When you're booted back up, do a NORMAL REBOOT.

3. And when you're booted back up, go to Root Switch, click to disable Xposed, when prompted do a soft/fast reboot, and when you're booted back up, start Pokémon Go. Make sure everything is green in Magisk Manager (latest Magisk, root, & safety net) before launching the game.

Original Instructions by xstahsie
[Magisk] insanemhenlo:
Thank you HeNaFi. Its installed and working correctly.
[Magisk] kaoskim:
Thanks for the instructions!

The latest version of xposed won't work on my note 3. Im using Version 75 sdk 21 from arter97 atm. Will this work too then? When I install the latest xposed I get a bootloop.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Just try, you'll see in the rootswitch app if it's supported or not...
[Magisk] kaoskim:
Okay, I did the exact same thing in the instructions but only with MY xposed version for samsung 5.0.

It worked! Youre my hero! :D

And I guess I have this to do everytime when I want to play pokemon go (after I enabled xposed when I wanted to use it again)?
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
No problem. Just sharing what others shared with me.
[Magisk] kaoskim:
But nooow I can't enable root again. I did some search and I read that you have to ENABLE root before you reboot?

I tried to toggle root back on right after, but it didnt work. Also not after a reboot - it just doesnt want to toggle on. I still have root but does this affect new installed apps? I guess I cant give access then?

What is your tip? Reflash magisk?
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
My best suggestion is to start from scratch.

Magisk with magisk hide. Make sure you have all green in Magisk Manager.

Then install official xposed v87.

After. That rootswitch.

PS. I've tested this steps on Marshmallow(6.0.1)

SDK21 is Android 5.0 (Lollipop), SDK22 is Android 5.1 (also Lollipop) and SDK23 is Android 6.0 (Marshmallow).
[Magisk] kaoskim:
Pokemon Go is working now, my only problem is that I cant enable root again in root switch, no matter what I try (deinstall, reinstall, starting again. after i reinstalled "enabled" was on default, then i toggled off to test if it was going back to "enabled" but it didnt).

Maybe I am misunderstanding your advise or are you telling me to reinstall all this?
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
Yeah I think you're disabling root. DON'T

In rootswitch the only thing to do is disable Xposed(if you have it installed.

Remember rootswitch is for using xposed and magisk. But if you only need PoGo to work. Just magisk, with magiskhide will do the work.

When toggling root, it won't stick.
[Magisk] Karls0:
But why to use rootswitch if you can install xposed module for Magisk and simply disable it in manager when you need to pass SafetyNet?
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
Because people want to play PoGo. And use modules like Snorlax reloaded and pogo controls, and so on.

This method is for that. But if you pass all greens in Magisk Manager and don't care about pogo. Then you're already accomplished the purpose
[Magisk] Karls0:
So you see - Magisk is not designed for cheating. I think, you can't expect support in this case.
[Magisk] kaoskim:
Wow.. thanks man! For some reason my little brain thought I needed to hit the root button.. and the guy before you didn't even wrote it in his instruction! Reading helps I guess lol.

Anyway, I made a recovery and downloaded, flashed all this again and now it works - with the root button untouched :D

Just curious because you mentioned the pokemon go mods.. Snorlax reloaded and pogo controls are working even if xposed is deactivated?

And when I'm finished playing pogo then I just hit the "disable" xposed again and all should work or do I have to reboot normally after that or something?

Sorry for all the questions, I just hopped into that whole custom rom/rooting stuff last week and I guess I need just some more basic infos to know how stuff works.
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
People see this title: [Discussion] PokeMon Go Magisk Discussion Thread and come here for answers.

---------- Post added at 08:05 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:58 AM ----------

Well. the pogo modules like Snorlax reloaded and pokemon go controls are the only ones I've can confirm work following the instructions I posted earlier.

When I finished playing I jus keep it how it is. I sacrifice other modules and leave xposed deactivated
[Magisk] teddy0209:
As the other guy said, with the magisk setup, no need to disable root, magisk can hide it... sorry for the late reply...???
[Magisk] Karls0:
I know but XDA has its rules. Asking for help in cheating is on the verge of rule nr. 9.
[Magisk] Futurehope:
About fate grand order

Before today magisk hide worked perfectly and I can play Fate Grand Order as I please. However, as fate grand order updated today, it detected root even if magisk hide is turned on and safetynet passed. Any fix or recommendations? I am using Oneplus 3T on 7.1.1 with magisk 11.1 (I can't update to newer versions of magisk as it caused the game to detect it)

P.S. I know that the thread is about PKM GO however I can't find other threads about mobile games and magisk, so I posted here. Thank you for understanding!
[Magisk] w74132003:
I have the same issue:crying::crying:

is any way to solve it ?:eek::eek:
[Magisk] Karls0:
Give us more details. Do you pass SafetyNet? If yes, what another mechanism does this game utilize?
[Magisk] w74132003:
I passed the SafetyNet ,and I'm pretty sure magiskhide works on the app like titanium backup of other apps need root ..

but I just can't get into FATE/GRAND ORDER, it always says that I have root:crying::crying::crying:

It was all fine before this update of FATE/GRAND ORDER today

I have completely no idea what cased that:eek:

this is the game address:

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.aniplex.fategrandorder&hl=zh_TW
[Magisk] Futurehope:
I did pass SafetyNet. The game have these error codes.

Error code 1 = apk clone from Dalvik byte code

Error code 23 = Jailbreak

Error code 60 = Rooted

Error code 10 = emu / unknown reason

Error code 43 = Usb debug on / dev option on

Error code 90 = apk clone from Apkeditor

Error code 91 = apk it's Broken

Error code 92 = Modified apk / xposed

If I use Magisk v12 before the game prompts error code 1. Currently I am using Magisk v11.1 and after the game updated it prompts error code 60.

Edit: Moreover Xiaomi MIUI 8 users, remix os users and xposed ANRC users also faced error codes when trying to login the game after update.
[Magisk] Karls0:
I would focus on this two. Switch developer options off. If it will not help, disable xposed and try again.
[Magisk] Futurehope:
The game prompts error code=60 after update instead of these two. Moreover I am not currently using xposed as I am using Android 7.1.1 .
[Magisk] Karls0:
Sorry, little misunderstanding :). So we basicly know nothing, just it detects root. I'm not sure, but maybe it is possible to record root detection by logcat... You could at least try. You don't even need adb, search for CatLog in GooglePlay.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
-----------

Some apps use other apps to detect root. It's been mentioned numerous times throughout the Magisk troubleshooting and Tips and Tricks threads. Some have been found to use the dialer app to name one. Try checking what permissions the app uses to track down what it might be accessing and add them to Magisk Hide one by one.
[Magisk] Futurehope:
The game's permission says no permission requested..

---------- Post added at 03:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:45 PM ----------

What do I search for when using catlog?
[Magisk] Karls0:
Maybe for information about starting other apps in background as [MENTION=2437714]biggdevon[/MENTION] suggested?
[Magisk] Futurehope:
Exactly how do I do that?:confused: Haven't used catlog before.. Sorry:eek:
[Magisk] Karls0:
Menu -> record. Next minimize CatLog and start your app. After error you can stop recording. Log contain a lot of infiormatio, but app start is quite unique, you should identify it easy.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Check these in Magisk hide. This was taken directly from the Play store description.

Edit: just the contacts and maybe look for processes used for the listed actions. You can't hide storage.
[Magisk] Futurehope:
This is not the said app. The said app is https://play.google.com/store/apps/d...order&hl=zh_TW
[Magisk] biggdevon:
That link doesn't work for me

Edit: scroll to the bottom of the app page in the play store, select permission details
[Magisk] Futurehope:
Attached are the logs and permission details. I don't quite know what I should be finding in the logs so I just put the full logs here
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Unfortunately I'm not very good at combing logs and am short on time right now. I'd add the phone app and/or dialer to Hide and maybe reboot. Maybe someone who had a bit more expertise with logs could check into further.
[Magisk] Karls0:
I'm also not very experienced with logcat, but I worked with it few times. But I can't find here SafetyNet request at all. Is it possible that it doesn't use SafetyNet? It is also possible I just miss something :). What's interesting it start something related with microphone, but it may comes form other app, this logcat is really clutter. Maybe someone else could read it and find more information. Trying to hide some system apps like suggested a post above may also works.
[Magisk] Jolt151:
So you have Snorlax running with Xposed enabled using this? Or is Xposed disabled but Snorlax works? Because when I do this, the last step actually disables Xposed and stops all of my modules from working.

Also, if this does work, it would seem that there is a "limbo" mode for Xposed where some modules can work while still evading SafetyNet, and there can potentially be a way to install Xposed in this mode. Interesting!
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
Yes xposed works with this method. Snorlax reloaded and pokemon go controls are the modules that work for me.

Modules like YouTube adaway and most of all others don't work.
[Magisk] Futurehope:
I extracted a segment of logs between starting the app and it prompting the error code in gmail. It mentioned safety net sample. This should be easier to read :D
[Magisk] Karls0:
But this sample comes from this app (according to package name):

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.scottyab.safetynet.sample&hl=pl

Not your game. Does this game requested to use this app to check if phone is rooted?
[Magisk] Futurehope:
Nope, then I think it's irrelevant to the situation:crying:
[Magisk] Karls0:
If it pass SafetyNet - yes, it mean that the game use other mechanism, or override Magisk in other way.
[Magisk] zapahacks:
Anyone here with Snorlax working on latest version? Or any suggestions for an alternative app/mod to replace Snorlax?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Use either system xposed+rootswitch or systemless xposed+suhide...
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
Snorlax doesn't work with the latest version of PoGo. The latest version that work with Snorlax was 0.54
[Magisk] Karls0:
So they finally fixed it. Good news for fair players.
[Magisk] calikevin:
Bad news for disabled players who aren't as mobile such as me. It's not about being fair, Pokemon Go was poorly designed to begin with. A joystick should have been included for people who aren't as capable of walking around as much, and the game originally came with no way to tell a great Pokemon apart from a crappy one. They added the appraisal system but that doesn't really tell you how strong it is, it just gives you an idea. For how broken it is, I can't believe how much money this game is still making, and I can't wait until it's hacked into pieces again for us all to play with.

BTW you can't use Snorlax anymore either, if you're using 0.57.4 you're forced to upgrade to newest version. Money hungry Niantic at it again, doesn't want you knowing how good your Pokemon are so you waste balls and candy on ****ty ones.
[Magisk] Karls0:
Yes, from this point of view it is a problem. I know that motion-based games are not fair for disabled players. However in most case, joystick is utilized for simple cheating. It's not nice when you just take a gym and see someone is fighting it back but there's no one around. Nonetheless thank you, you rised the topic, I didn't spear a thought earlier that someone could be forced to use GPS spoofing.

Anyway, to leave aside purpose - I think that playing PoGO on joystick is just boring. The best part of this game is that you have to go outside and visit place where you will probably not go without this reason. Without this part it stay mostly grinding, which is not exciting for me :). Do you find fun in this game without it's "real part"?
[Magisk] andrew2432:
Joystick works still, just lost the ability to mitm all the good info.

The game is discriminatory. So is life. Rural players can't keep up whatsoever closest stop to me is 4 miles, only one since the church petitioned to get theirs removed, and the water tower is unreachable in legal fashions, players with jobs are stuck to the collection aspect, cars, devices, battery capabilities, any modification away from OEMS hold on you is punished. Game doesnt work in some countries, how is kim jung un gonna play without spoofing?! Terrible content anyway: now i only play because the time investment I have made up until this point.

Edit: oh well
[Magisk] calikevin:
For me, the fun part of the game is "catch em all," not necessarily exploring new parts of town. Yes that was fun for a while when the game first came out, but once you explore the area around you a few times you've seen it. Catching them all is made much harder with the format GO was released with. How are American players realistically supposed to acquire the regional Pokemon that are only available in Hong Kong and Australia? It was very poorly designed and geared towards getting you to spend money, unlike the original Pokemon games which were immensely fun and infinitely replayable.
[Magisk] shoey63:
Same here, but I neither have a disability nor a lack of pokestops. I just don't want to be dictated to by an app telling me to walk hundreds of kilometres, when I can amuse myself from the comfort of my own home.

When I feel like battling, I choose a gym from my own team and leave a decent pokemon in there afterwards.
[Magisk] :
Hi guys, got a new phone and wanna flash stuff on it while being able to play Pokemon. So what I'm seeing here is I need to use systemless SuperSU + SUhide + Magisk while disabling Xposed to run it? I kinda like Xposed and don't want to have to reboot each time enable/disable it.
[Magisk] Virallata:
Hello Guys.

I have a Moto X 2013 (xt1058) with full 10% stock. It works Pokemon Go well. But when i install Magisk 12, all go to hell. I enable magisk Hide, and it not work even after that, any help ? =/ I tried installing magisk from Play Store or Zip file, no game =/.

Thx
[Magisk] rumburak001:
You never got the idea behind the game, do you ?

It is all about walking hundreds of kilometres.
[Magisk] shoey63:
Yeah, but I don't want walk. I just want to fill up my pokedex. My phone, my rules.
[Magisk] Karls0:
It is ok in single player game, but not online.
[Magisk] andrew2432:
Mmmmmhmmmm

Rooting your phone is cheating, games or no.

The game is about ROI. breaking snorlax and control methods is only intended to get the spenders motivated to spend more. If rev drops because spoofers are spending then I bet it goes back to java.

This thread is for root + working pgo, not semantic discussions. I'm all for it because google...and by association niantic, will always be wrong
[Magisk] Setialpha:
No! root is basically the Administrator User on unixoid operating systems, nothing else. Imagine Steam not working because your Windows has an active Administrator Account, lol, but THAT is how it is on Android - and nobody cares.

Conclusion: root has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with cheating. Cheating is done through special cheating apps or modules, which have nothing to do with root, except they require root access to work.

I know it's off-topic, but I couldn't leave that sentence of yours like that.
[Magisk] andrew2432:
If you root and NEVER use those privileges then you can argue. Otherwise:

I love it!! Im glad you didnt heres my counter: Using cheating broadly: is admin privileges and escalated user activities SPECIFICALLY ALLOWED by your OEM or carrier? Because it intentionally not allowed. Why? Money. My s5 has 16 GB, taken up by about 9 by the stock OS, leaving 6gb. This is why I rooted, gain access to expandable system memory and have some more memory. Why is this "cheating?" Because the 32gb variant was another hundred dollars minimum on release and still sits another 50. With the release and readability of 128gb SD cards...custom OS has hotspot unlocked, for a sprint user with unlimited grandfathered plan with no slowdowns, I hit 200 GB on mobile hotspot with no plan.

Semantics fellas, modifying the system partition is against the terms of use for your device so....?
[Magisk] Setialpha:
There's nothing to argue. root = administrator and nothing more. It's the biggest bull**** on earth that they flag administrator access to your own device, you paid money as not allowed. I repeat: would you argue the same way if it wouldn't be your Phone / Tablet, but your Computer? Obviously not.

I don't care whether they flag Xposed, but root alone is absolutely no reason to blacklist a device. Especially since many games can be cheated without root, I mean... edit apks on your PC and then install them on your phone? That doesn't require root and this is neither covered by SafetyNet nor by 98% of apps, 'cause they don't check their own SHA1.

But well, I'm not diving further into this discussion, I have my point of view and I'm not going to change

it in this regard.
[Magisk] Karls0:
I agree - root is not a cheat itself. That's why this thread is not deleted yet. I have root and want to play, I don't think it something bad. As far as you use magisk to bypass root check it's ok. But I was referring to asking here for help with cheating using snorlax/PoGO control or modules to spoof GPS - that's a bit ambiguous. XDA doesn't accept sharing warez or other potentially unfair practise, so shall it accept helping in cheating?
[Magisk] andrew2432:
I love healthy discussion and argument! I'm just being devils advocate, I hate that they flag it. My point is it's against intended use. By rooting you are doing something that isn't allowed or supported by the manufacturer or carrier. Its not illegal: just like snorlax and controls, but it IS against your terms of use. I just want you to have a different perspective! Recognise youre attributing your own perspective to the issues If you are sprint, is a custom OS that hacks the hotspot cheating? The gravity of the offense between root alone and a custom OS provides a gap but where is the line drawn and why do you get to choose where? We are ALL here to use our devices in a way other than their constructed use. This is by definition..websters English of...cheating.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Unlocking the bootloader and rooting your device is allowed by most oems, it's just that they don't support it. Its a do at your own risk thing...
[Magisk] andrew2432:
This is correct! You're right!! Oems already got their money who cares what you do :p It's the carries terms of service you violate! Not by rooting alone but using root access! Superuser access alone is not enough, true, but most of what root allows you to do violates carrier agreements due to restrictions they have placed on hardware and software. Increasing sound, customizations, storage space, unlocking tethering, moving apps to system, etc are all something your carrier wants to prevent.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Why would you violate a carriers term if you didn't get the phone from a carrier?...
[Magisk] Opius90:
Can anyone help me find a correct setup for my Note 4 N910F, i want root access and be able to play PoGo, tried alot of different approaches but i really cannot get this to work.

Please help me!
[Magisk] teddy0209:
You should head to the magisk general support thread..., and provide more details, like rom, rom base, the things you did, the logs...
[Magisk] andrew2432:
Because using the phone through their service restricts you to their terms as well, you're not just subjected to the OEM at that point. Your warranty gets voided when you root why? Because its a violation of the user agreement. Cheating?

What have you tried?! There are multiple methods out there and many can get device specific. Are you trying to use xposed or not?

From stock...Flash magisk, enable hide, pgo should work for walkin around!

Gotta have a bit more info!!
[Magisk] teddy0209:
What carrier user agreement is that if you didn't get the phone from a carrier?

What warranty will you void from the carrier if there is no warranty from the carrier itself?
[Magisk] Opius90:
Ive tried loads of different roms (CM12, CMremiX, LineageOS, Ressurrection Remix), flashed the rom -> flashed Gapps -> flashed Magisk V12 -> Cleared cache and installed magisk manager from play store.

and every time ive done that i get "fail" on the SafetyNet test.
[Magisk] calikevin:
Some kernels just won't pass SN. Try changing your SeLinux mode too
[Magisk] ataraxist:
You should have tested each step with safetynet helper to see if u pass or fail the check.
[Magisk] negroxxx:
pogo use that version?
[Magisk] exodius48:
Recently I repeat the step above, but i do not install phh-superuser-magisk-r259.zip , finally pokemon go work. I can play it. I don't install any xposed version. :highfive::good::fingers-crossed::laugh:

But at this time, if i install xposed systemless 86.2, i'm sure 99.999% pokemon go will work.

And from the step above, i found the culprit why my device always re-optimizing apps after phone booting, the culprit is delete built in su file in /system/bin and /system/xbin. I'm using CM13 based rom. This not caused by suhide or xposed systemless.

But if i don't delete it i can't use suhide or phh's superuser. I don't know why this happen. :confused:

So the rom that fully support is rom that does not have built in root, like pure AOSP & OMNI.

Cc [MENTION=631273]Chainfire[/MENTION] & [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]
[Magisk] negroxxx:
can someone help me pogo not run.

Xposed disable and pogo does not work.

http://xdaforums.com/picture.php?albumid=13661&pictureid=54329

http://xdaforums.com/picture.php?albumid=13661&pictureid=54328

http://xdaforums.com/picture.php?albumid=13661&pictureid=54327
[Magisk] zakijesk:
does this happens also with stock touchwiz ?

because i have the same problem of the long booting times, always re-optimizing apps after phone booting without really optimizing them take just seconds, general lag & lag in the game especially when battling in gym
[Magisk] exodius48:
Probably yes. Try to do not delete 'su' file, install supersu 2.78 SR1 or phh's superuser instead.

I already delete it, and need to clean install to recover it. Probably will try to another rom, see if do not delete built-in 'su' file will work or not.
[Magisk] zakijesk:
i didn't delete it before ?

i install supersu 2.78 SR1 systemless then suhide-0.53 then xposed-v86.2-sdk23

---------- Post added at 08:06 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:34 PM ---------

after I install a note 7 port rom in my s5 and following the same method as before

the lag is gone !! i don't know what changed ?
[Magisk] zakijesk:
i don't think Magisk v7 hide root !