yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] angelus_kun:
Works very well thanks
[Magisk] Mezabaru:
passed on SM-G930W8 with CTS finally being true after flashing universal safetynet fix on Superman rom with superkernel. before only had basic, hope that information helps someone.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
I'm using SM-N920T with the latest v13 beta of Magisk and passing all safetynet checks, using Snapchat without issue.
[Magisk] -Hypnose:
Don't work in S4 i9505

Does not work on S4 i9505! When I flash Magisk, I'm mistaken... (Both version 12 and 13).

I tried putting apk v.5.0.2 in the System> app, giving it the permissions r-w-rr. Only a few startups were made, removing the root because of forced system installation. And removing SuperSU. And Magisk tells me, "Rooted but without permissions. Are not you authorized?"

I tried to do the unroot, but through the KingRoot app, since with SuperSU I did not do it. To try flashing Magisk, but it does not work yet.

I tried to remove SuperSU with both .zip and SuperSU settings. Correctly, but not yet flashing Magisk.

I also tried flashing the stock lollipop kernel. (Gpe 5.1 kernel), but a black screen appears when the device starts.

ROM: AOSP + RRO 6.0.1 by srisurya95 (NO OMS AND NO CM THEMES).

Custom Recovery: TWRP 3.1.1

Kernel: srisurya95 kernel 3.4.x. (As described above, with kernel stock 5.1 does not work).

Or recommend a kernel that is stock or modified, all right, just need to act in this ROM. Because I really do not know what to do...

* How do I do the procedures?

1) I'm in the recovery mode, wipe dalvick, cache, data and system in EXT4 format,

2) Flash the custom ROM and the GAPPS. (6.0.1 opengapps).

3) Restart the device by initializing. Removing SuperSU by setting. Returning to Recovery and flashing Magisk, in this case does not work the same way.

When I flash Magisk.zip in recovery, I get the following error: '/external_sd/Download/Magisk-v.13.0.zip'

Please tell me what to do, to act as Magisk in this ROM, which has SuperSU embedded... Thank you in advance.
[Magisk] -Hypnose:
Problem solved.
[Magisk] AllSmokeEm:
Question.

Hello quick question since I never heard about it and endless googling wich give me a million methods and files etc. I rather ask it here.

Device sm g935f nougat 7.0 with 3.14 kernal. Im about to fresh install newest firmware since some app update issues and then install magisk to check it out.

So after reading this thread the order should be.

1. Flash twrp in odin with auto reboot unchecked.

2. Format data in twrp.

3. Flash superstock kernel.

4. Flash magisk v13 beta and then reboot system.

5. Wait for device come stable.

6. Skipp all the setup and add google and samsung acc after.

Is this right?

Thanks
[Magisk] carlosgardel:
Hello. Im new to magisk. Im using latest version 13 in a note 4 tmobile N910t with latest stock firmware. There is any custom kernel that I can use? Any custom kernel that I install breaks Magisk, Magisk manager says its not installed. If I first install the kernel Magisk install gives error. Thanks!!

Edit: Resolved After 2 days trying I finally install Ramkernel for 910t RC3 and Magisk 13
[Magisk] K0le:
Alright I can confirm that Magisk worked and rooted my SM-J500FN,and it even passed SafetyNet check :D:D
[Magisk] lekcin18:
works on my A7 2016(SM-A710FD) running advanced seven 3.7.3 custom rom with permissive selinux. safetynet passed also. sometimes bootloop (experience 2 times) but pressing power + vol down to restart the phone solves it. about a month now using magisk
[Magisk] myera:
Samsung galaxy c9 pro work or not
[Magisk] BoAustinTx:
I was able to get it working on my SM-T800 with stock kernel using TWRP.
[Magisk] Iradj:
Is this working on Galaxy S5 G900F properly ? Because for Magisk Hide you need a Kernel Version that is atleast 3.8.XX but the latest Stock Marshmallow Rom has 3.4.XX
[Magisk] rumo0:
lost Magisk Hide somehow

Hi all,

I tried solving my problem by using the magisk uninstaller and reinstalling magisk v12 and the 5.1.1 Manager but Magisk Hide still doesn't show up.

What happened:

I installed Cosmic OS 1.5, Magisk v12 (iirc) came with it, used it once to hide the play store so I could install Mario Run (which I bought before rooting...). Worked fine.

Then I updated to Magisk 13.3 bcs Magisk kept me bugging about it. Suddenly, most of my apps closed themselves down instantly after showing the loading screen (like GMail or feedly). A downgrade back to Magisk v12 (just flashed it over the 13.3 from recovery) solved this problem mostly, but now, Magisk Hide was gone. Also some Apps still don't work, like Mario Run (oh, the irony...). So I wanted to use Magisk Hide to have a shot at them working properly, but now there is no more Magisk Hide Option. I tried it with v12, v13.3 and even the 13.5beta. Nothing. :confused:

Not being able to run Mario Run is one thing, but I'm also missing out on other apps, like the local public transport and all that's hidden from an uncertified phone in the appstore. So, how to enable Magisk Hide again? Or do I have another, bigger problem?

Any help appreciated :)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk v12 is not compatible with Manager v5+. Start over from the beginning.

Uninstall Magisk, either by using the uninstall option in the Manager or uninstalling the Manager and running the uninstall zip in recovery.

After that, flash v13.3 or beta v13.5 and take a look in the troubleshooting guide under "Apps are force closing". That might solve your issue.
[Magisk] rumo0:
Thx Didgeridoohan!

Will try this later and report :)
[Magisk] rumo0:
So, I did what you told me (un- and reinstall, v13.3) and went with the workarounds at the apps force closing section.

From there: I switched at Developer options, WebView implementation from Webview to Google Chrome and suddenly the Apps started working again. Well, most of them, the only one still not responding is the public transport. For MR hiding was sufficient.

Setting up a logcat goes over my head, I'm failing at various points and am not enough bothered to resolve all of them now.

But most apps are running flawlessly and that's enough for now.

thx a lot for your help!
[Magisk] Saliver_Sky:
Magisk not work in samsung galaxy note 2 (N7100)

RESURRECTION REMIX 7.1.2r29

Help
[Magisk] jcfgamer94:
I can confirm that it's working on Samsung Galaxy S8+ International (G955F) STOCK ROM ONLY
[Magisk] sautzer:
I confirm that works on S6 G920F with Noble Nougat 4.5 and 5.0 version and their OTA. The only problem that I found is that when I try to install Greenify for Magisk it won't work and after flashing it, magisk is uninstalled.
[Magisk] SiliconBug:
Will Samsung Pay work correctly with Magisk Hide?
[Magisk] Si73:
Hello,

Has anyone managed to get Magisk 14 to work on the S8 (SM-G950F) with the new install method - no root and stock recovery? Mine fails on boot with verification fail.
[Magisk] Tkkg1994:
You had to choose to keep force encryption and dm-verity in magisk manager. Since the s8 is encrypted. If you don't change that settings inside magisk, it will patch the img without encryption
[Magisk] Si73:
Many thanks! I'll try that later when I get home.
[Magisk] Asuly:
G900H magisk manager get fc

magisk 13 and 14
[Magisk] Si73:
Hello, I tried this but still fails on verification on boot. I have got it working with TWRP but would like it to work with stock recovery.
[Magisk] Matvei27:
Works fine G160N Galaxy Folder 2.

But systemless xposed still doesn't work, so I am using the wanam version instead.
[Magisk] countersv:
+1 to this, no way to boot S8 after flashing the patched boot.img - always getting verification failed. Tried with dm-verity, etc. enabled, and disabled.
[Magisk] goRt:
I find magisk above 12.0 breaks volte on my stock s8 with batstock kernel (never tried with stock kernel)

Removing magisk makes volte appear without issue.

WiFi calling works in both use cases.
[Magisk] Alcibiade:
You need a custom kernel to have it work on the S8, no?
[Magisk] countersv:
Hmm, that's a first for me. Any more info?
[Magisk] Alcibiade:
As far as I know Samsung's kernel are tougher on security than most and dont go well with Magisk. Flashing a customer kernel with some safeties disabled gets it to work.

I was hopeful v14 could avoid that (I have a Snapdragon S8+) but ran into the same troubles.

If someone managed to get around it, I am very happy to piggy back!
[Magisk] countersv:
I had no issues whatsoever flashing earlier versions of Magisk through TWRP. Only problem I have is with the new method of patching original boot.img. So honestly I don't think it's the kernel issue.
[Magisk] Alcibiade:
Which device do you have?
[Magisk] countersv:
G950F
[Magisk] vendu:
Success with SM-389F aka Xcover 3 Value Edition! :D

Hello fellow droidsters!

I have the joy to report I just went and tried Magisk 14.0 on my newly reinstalled Xcover 3 VE and it seems to work fine. It's a relatively new NEE (Nordic Countries, I'm a Finn) firmware from July:

Baseband: G389FXXU1AQF1

Kernel: Stock 3.10.9-9531242

Build: MMB29K.G389FXXU1AQG1

SE-enforcing

Security Software: ASKS v1.2_161011

Android Security Patch Level: July 1, 2017

Some silly file manager thought it didn't get Magisk Manager 5.3.0 installed, but in it went. :) Passes both Root and SafetyNet checks that I did. :D

I guess that's it for now folks, I'm gonna do dig into something cool to mess around with now. :)

Cheers,

/* vendu */
[Magisk] cookie1953:
Hi - I have the S8 running the Ambasadii 1.5 ROM and NOTORIOUS-Kernel** || TW || AQH9_AQI1 || G95X || {10-10-17} || NK210 || 4.4.91 with Magisk v14.3 which currently passes the Safety net check. Recently xposed has become available and works beautifully on the handset but it trips the SN check !!! I had an email saying there is a download from the Magisk installer called - Xposed framework SDK24 which allows the SN to still work but after I installed it the S8 wont boot just sits on the Samsung flashing screen anybody got this working or got any tips what I should try next ?
[Magisk] tangcla:
I can't get Magisk 14.x installed on my Galaxy S7 (G930F) using the patch boot image option.

I've tried to flash it with enforce encryption and dm-verity both ticked, and both unticked.

Both times, the phone will vibrate twice when boot logo shows, and then phone gets stuck.
[Magisk] Pat750:
It sounds like if you have to use TWRP. I always flash with TWRP and never used the manager. But I'm not sure.
[Magisk] tangcla:
I installed using Odin, with the generated Magisk file.

Problem is that I would have to format the SD card to be able to access the files on the SD card if I were to do it via TWRP.
[Magisk] nyknight77:
galaxy s4 works on cm13

galaxy s2 i9100 doesn't work on cm13 (overwrites boot.img and causes bootloop)
[Magisk] Tkkg1994:
Thanks :) added to the list

I'll add to the list

Then you got stock kernel

You need to flash phh's root

Okay thanks, will add to the list
[Magisk] DrakeLyon:
I see no one here has tested the Galaxy S7 for Verizon (G930V). I'll see what I can do, but I'm very nervous.. No kernels seem to be available..
[Magisk] radz_:
Im not using it right now, but I can confirm Magisk works fine in Note 4 N910c all Stock 6.0.1 I was using it for a month before..
[Magisk] Tkkg1994:
Just make a boot backup in twrp in case something goes wrong.

Will add to the list thanks :)

Sent from my SuperMan powered SM-G930F
[Magisk] zakijesk:
I can confirm that S5 G900FD works with stock kernel

most likely all snapdragon variants works too
[Magisk] DrakeLyon:
Ah there are no custom recoveries for my model either.. :/ In general, rooting my phone is a bit more difficult than people are used to.
[Magisk] Blzfrost:
I don't see sm-g928p on the list. Just got everything downloaded and ready (making TWRP backup now). Gonna give it a shot here in a bit and I'll report my results.
[Magisk] Tkkg1994:
Well then this won't work for you probably

Perfect, I'll add to the list as soon as you tested :)

Okay I'll add to the list thanks!
[Magisk] mat1jaca:
SM-J320F on stock working for the past few days and persisting on reboots perfectly! I havent tried xposed yet though, im using phhs superuser
[Magisk] Kiid:
Confirm v6 works perfectly on both S5 SM-G900H and S6 SM-G920I. Both are running stock modded 6.0.1 roms (XtreStoLite) and custom kernels. (Arters kernel for S6 and green apple for S5)
[Magisk] Blzfrost:
SM-G928P Works on stock kernel, no selinux (as expected). I'm going to redo it with custom kernel and report back.
[Magisk] frrancuz.:
i know that,but mayby you know which custom kernel works with magisk?

maybe you can help me?
[Magisk] Blzfrost:
So far just getting boot loops with Sky-High kernel. Tried a few times to make sure. Gonna go one more round with a Custom Rom and see where that takes me.

---------- Post added at 03:25 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:41 PM ----------

Same result. I'm not about to say it's not possible. Just that I was unable to do so in my attempts. Stock seems to be the only way that worked.
[Magisk] Tkkg1994:
Okay so. What is specific to the "P" version as the others seem to work fine on arters and various kernels

I don't own a N3... sorry

Perfect. Added to the list

Thanks. Added

Sent from my SuperMan powered SM-G930F
[Magisk] killbox.kb:
Need help I9500 Galaxy S4

Hi all,

I am having samsung galaxy s4 I9500 and i want to install magisk + phh superuser.

I tried the method stated in the first post. Now i am having error while flashing Phh superuser Magisk version. It shows error while flashing as Magisk not installed.

These are the steps I followed.

*Fully unrooted Superuser using app (success)

*Flashed Magisk V6 using TWRP (Success)

*Flashed Phh superuser Magisk Versionusing TWRP

** Error : Magisk Not installed

What is that i am missing?

Even i installed Magisk manager and its showing Not rooted and Se linux Enforcing.

I got suggestions that Boot image is not supported. Please share a work around for this problem

Plz Help Guys

Thank You
[Magisk] Tkkg1994:
Hello

Magisk won't work on stock I9500. Only custom kernel I assume

Sent from my SuperMan powered SM-G930F
[Magisk] Rohan1996:
Hello

Anyone Can Help Me Please My Phone Is Note 3 N900 Exynos And I Am Using http://xdaforums.com/galaxy-note-3/...n900n9000-bashergraceuxstylev5-8-5-9-t3454806 This Rom But When I use Magisk Root is Not Mounted And Playing Pogo But Magisk Does Not work

Any Solution Please

And I am tried both kernel plz fix this problem
[Magisk] tool666schism:
Magisk is running perfectly on my SM G920t. Didn't see it on compatibility list.

Running stock 6.0.1, flashed magisk v6 and SuperSU v2.76
[Magisk] NewtPulsifer:
I have a S6 G920I with STOCK kernel and Magisk (14.0, 5.4.0) is working: "SafetyNet Check Success". However, when Lookout runs, it says my device is rooted. Any ideas?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
"SafetyNet Check Success" means that there was a response from the server. What matters is the result of ctsProfile and basicIntegrity. If either of those are false you don't pass the SafetyNet check...

I have no idea what app Lookout is, but it's perfectly possible it doesn't use SafetyNet for it's tampering checks. Make sure you've added the app to the Hide list and you might also have to hide the Magisk Manager when running the app. This is done through the Manager settings. It's also possible that if the app has detected root once, you'll have to clear data for the app before it'll run again (after you've added it to the Hide list and hidden the Manager). Some apps just can't be fooled...
[Magisk] Pat750:
Ah, thanks for clarifying, I didn't know about the Odin option. Hope someone else can help you then.
[Magisk] Joe_6pak:
Can't install Magisk on Verizon Galaxy S4

I want to try every avenue to answer my question, so I figured here would be good. Here goes:

Is there any different kernels out there that I can use with Lineage OS 14.1 on a Verizon Samsung Galaxy S4 MDK? I was trying to flash Magisk and kept getting an Error1 message (see attached recovery log). I was told the following in another Magisk forum:

"Your device isn't compatible with Magisk, simple as that. Or rather, the boot image isn't (unknown ramdisk format). Try v14.3 beta, something might have updated. If that doesn't work, upload your boot image file and maybe [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] can take a look at it. It's also possible that a custom kernel that replaces the ramdisk could fix it. But that would be a question for your device's forum"

If there are any kernels other than the one that comes with the ROM which I can use (can I use those for the i9500?), please let me know where I can find them. Thanks much!
[Magisk] Tyrubias:
Generate boot image from stock Odin files

I made a related post about this in the SM-930A device forum, but I just wanted to repost it here:

Is it possible to create a boot image using stock AP, BL, CP, and CSC files? Or is it possible to extract the boot image while running a stock ROM?
[Magisk] tangcla:
Yes, the boot image is inside the big ap file. Rename the tar.md5 extension to .tar and you can open it in WinRar (or equivalent) and copy the boot.img out.
[Magisk] Tyrubias:
Thanks for the tip. After returning to stock by flashing the appropriate BL, AP, CP, and CSC files, I patched the boot image using Magisk Manager v5.4.0 for Magisk v14.3 and checked forced encryption and dm-verity while patching boot image. However, when I flash the patched_boot.img.tar, Odin fails and my phone reads: SECURE CHECK FAILED: boot. I'm using an SM-930A and flashing the firmware files from:

https://xdaforums.com/att-galaxy-s7/how-to/firmware-g930a-qe1-android-7-0-6-4-2017-t3617101

Any idea what's going wrong?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Or... It could simply be that MagiskHide can't hide Xposed, systemless or not.
[Magisk] adeich:
SM-A310F

SM-A310F Stock kernel

Magisk 14.0, Magisk Manager 5.4.0 - works successfully

Magisk 14.3 worked but MagiskHide did not work, SafetyNet check failed.
[Magisk] ttimasdf:
I did check SafetyNet status BEFORE I installed Xposed. But the result was the same with similar error message. I saved this logcat because Xposed is sadly not working as well... for a failed magic mount.
[Magisk] [Lemmy]:
I just installed the latest samsung firmware on my S6 Edge (G925F), then I installed the latest TWRP with odin, and flashed magisk 14. After the first reboot after flashing magisk all seems well, but after the next one magisk is gone and needs to be flashed again.

Any suggestions where to start?

edit: just me being impatient... didn't wait long enough after reboot to check if magisk was ok. *facepalm*
[Magisk] tommymilan311:
Galaxy S8 (SM-G950U)

Anyone successfully install this on their Galaxy S8 with snapdragon? I keep getting a fail when I flash the modified boot.img.tar over ODIN.
[Magisk] Sundari-Experts:
GT-7500 ** GT-7501 : Nougat 7.1.2 , TWRP 3.0.0.0 and 3.1.1.0

Installing Magisk version 14.0 does not work. Fails with "Error 1", can not find boot image.

Flashing BETA Magisk 14.5 (1456) worked.
[Magisk] kiwigi:
Hi, I would like to install magisk on sm g930 f/d so I could hide root for a banking app. Is this possible? Would this work? Is there a how-to somewhere? What Kernel would be needed?

I've got stock nougat rooted. Thanks
[Magisk] king2289:
Hello,

So i have a galaxy s7 active and the bootloader is not yet unlocked, is there away i can just flash magisk to make an app into a system app without loosing samsung pay, etc?

I dont care if the damn phone bricks Im so frustrated lol
[Magisk] martyfender:
Although I don't own any Samsung devices, I have looked into them for a coworker. Could it be that Samsungs FRP (Factory Reset Protection) is what is causing most of you to have issues?
[Magisk] TechnoTew:
SM-A510F Stock kernel custom ROM works fine for me
[Magisk] hdc8899:
Is magisk works on S7 edge (SM-G9350)Stock kernel custom ROM.But there is a problem with the wifi connection
[Magisk] jeewantha:
Is this work with SM-G950FD ?
[Magisk] Eruqal:
T715 with All Stock Android 7.0 works with Magisk 15.3
[Magisk] KingKRiggz:
I am trying to unroot my G920P because magisk kept uninstalling itself, ive tried flashing stock everything and factory resetting, root checker says no rooted but I cant access Samsung apps bc it says im still rooted & laptop still calls my phone "root" storage.. how do I unroot my phone
[Magisk] coderus:
Hello! What the status for SM-G965F? (S9+ Oxynos) Any plans? And is it possible to root and fake Knox to keep using Samsung Pay?
[Magisk] Andi46:
i don't know if it was already reported : works fully on my S7edge G935F after factory reset + no-verity-opt-encrypt-6.0 :D

stock kernel/stock ROM
[Magisk] alien.baba:
Samsung Galaxy On5 SM-G5520 G5520ZCU1BRB1 Nougat

after flashing "patched_boot.imag.tar" with odin successfully, my device shows

"Verification Failed"

Need to reset

what should i do now?

Please reply soon
[Magisk] YorySan:
N9005

Hi, I have a N9005 stock rom (5.0) with TWRP and I tried the lastest version of Manager (5.6.4) and Magisk app (v16) but after install via TWRP its show false on both safetynet test. What I need to do to Magisk works on my device?
[Magisk] cpajamasam:
Here using a Galaxy Note Pro P900 (wifi), all kind of attempts (MagiskManager last version with Magisk 16.0, last line of message is fail to install; can't use Odin because Magisk can't create the .img.tar file; TWRP do it but the device get into an eternal boot-loop, wipe and recovery and backup options won't work at all to make it start (still in an eternal boot-loop); the only working option is installing the stock rom with Odin. Many thanks for your help.
[Magisk] whitebeardedtrimmer:
trying to get on Galaxy J7 SM-S727. ANY SUGGESTIONS?
[Magisk] Mike022465:
Safetynet fail

Updated to latest version and am getting this error thrown up when I try Safetynet check. On a Galaxy S7 with stock OS.

Any thoughts?

Thx.

M.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Why do you think that's an error? It's info from [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] that you can't use the SafetyNet check in the Manager if you've hidden it. Use a different SafetyNet check app...
[Magisk] GreeTech:
Is there a way to magisk without tripping knox?
[Magisk] sandaljrpit:
SM-A710FD stock Rom Nougat.

Working fine with magisk stable v16.0
[Magisk] Not nonody:
Any one having trouble w they're phone?

Hi all. This may have been addressed already but I'm hitting a wall trying to find a solution. I'm relatively new to the whole root thing? I made many failed attempts before stumbling on a strategy tht worked. However it was for an ATT variant where im a sm-g900v. Not sure if that plays a part or not. Occasionally my phone will go nutzo on me. If I receive a call neither party can hear the other. If I return that call on my end it never leaves dialing screen however for the other party it rings. On 3rd try all is well. Interestingly I discovered that when it rings for the other party only my # appears on they're caller ID but when all is well my name displays. Also I have never passed a safety net check & kernel bit is 'always not seandroid enforcing. Any ideas or suggestions would b great. Thanx in advance
[Magisk] CM users:
Working on Galaxy J1 2016 (mine is J120G)using stable version v16.I have downloaded v16.4 i think and im gonna try it.Oh and im running stock kernel

Update:Magisk v16.4 working fine.
[Magisk] elwhiteboy01:
Works on the SM-T550 using deadmans unofficial lineage os 14.1 nightly.
[Magisk] ChrisAntono:
Hello everyone, I have a problem with magisk.. I have galaxy s4 i9505 and I've just flashed new optimized lineage os rom and its awesome..but just when i flash magisk, many system apps force close right when I open them..without magisk it's all good..some say there was a problem with the version of android system webview but when i installed a different one, it didn't change..any suggestions???
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Have you installed the v16.6 beta? If so, that's a known issue that's on the bugs list, and you're likely better of using the stable release.

Otherwise:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/Magisk#hn_Apps_are_force_closing
[Magisk] ChrisAntono:
nope I have the latest stable. I will see the link you sent me and I will report back! thanks!