yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Thet619:
I am having essentially the same problem. I am using a Samsung S2 Tab (T715) with LineageOS installed. For rooting I used Magisk v11.1 only, not SuperSU. Before flashing LineageOS, I made sure that SuperSU from previous uses was properly removed (su files in system/bin and system/xbin). I also made sure that USB/ADB Debugging is disabled in Dev options.

The thing I am unsure about is the kernel issue. As far as I understand, LOS does not make changes to the kernel structure regarding the bootloader status. As was written in this post, Samsung stock kernels are known to cause problems with Magisk and MagiskHide. So I thought about using a different Kernel, however, I dont know what "features" custom Kernels must possess in order to work with Magisk? Does this have something to do with Kernels being permissive or enforcing?
[Magisk] Filip013:
Hmm... But is it exactly the same problem? What is your result is SafetyNet Helper? Is Basic Integrity true? Can you see that Magisk Hide unmounts directories in the log? I have a hunch that a lot of devices cannot run custom ROMs that are very different from stock and pass SafetyNet. And finally does Pokemon Go work?
[Magisk] RayGarden:
Can't figure out what is wrong with the set-up.

I'm not sure if I can use that script in order to trace old SU files and delete them eventually.

USB Debugging was already toggled off.

Hope you can support.....
[Magisk] Thet619:
SafetyNet Helper was giving me false for the CTS profile match and the basic integrity. Somehow the SafetyNet of Magisk did not work. Therefore I moved back to MM Stock Rom with a modified Exynos-Kernel. Just installing the Kernel (permissive or regular) lets me play PGO, although the SafetyNet test fails for the permissive Kernel (Basic Integrity, however, stays true). When using Magisk and Magisk Hide, SafetyNet obiously also fails but so does the Base Integrity. PGO gets stuck at the loading screen (the one AFTER the white Niantic logo), here I get the message of "Failed to Authenticate".

The Magisk log file and the SafetyNet Helper says the following:

Any help is appreciated :)
[Magisk] Filip013:
Not sure I can help because I don't have your device, but I'll give it a go.

What you said so far makes perfect sense. When you flash stock ROM, I assume that you can't play POGO because SafetyNet knows your bootloader is unlocked. (A custom kernel includes hacks that lie to SafetyNet that your bootloader is locked.)

Now, I think that MIUI is fairly similar to TouchWiz. If it is, try flashing Magisk uninstaller and then flashing Magisk v11 (the previous version). Also uninstall Magisk Manager v4.1 and download v4.0 apk. Then go to Google Play and disable auto-update for Magisk Manager. You have to disable Magisk Hide, reboot and then enable it.

See if that works.
[Magisk] Thet619:
Thanks a lot. I will try asap. Would you recommend to try that with the Exynos-Kernel (permissive or regular) or rather with the stock boot.img?
[Magisk] Filip013:
No idea. Some people say that Samsung stock kernels give them issues... Try both, I guess... My experience is that custom kernels don't interfere with SafetyNet.
[Magisk] reis1996:
What's the point. PoGo doesn't appear in the older versions of magisk in the hide menu
[Magisk] teddy0209:
In doesn't matter really... There is no point in hiding from pokemon go app as it does nothing, it relies on SN...
[Magisk] xstahsie:
Search for my username in this thread and you shall find your answer. Short answer is yes.
[Magisk] reis1996:
I did. When was it posted. Too many results
[Magisk] mayosan:
Hi All,

Had the same problem of SN. Had xposed, supersu and magisk installed and tried a lot of solutions like UnSu.zip, boot.img, etc. Best solution was actually the simple one.

Flash Stock (OTA 3.5.6) via TWRP, boot, reboot to recovery TWRP, install Magisk 11.1 zip, boot, (I had Magisk Manager still installed (latest), started Magisk Manager, Settings Hide Disable/Enable, test and it passed. Did another SN test with SafetyNet Test Ap and passed also. PoGo starts properly.

o/
[Magisk] reis1996:
What happens if you have xposed. I want to cheat and play
[Magisk] xstahsie:
See post https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=70956223&postcount=2208
[Magisk] boilavera1980:
Magisk doesn't seem to work on the newest BQA7 firmware for the Samsung Galaxy S6 Edge+.I just flashed it freshly via odin today and have no idea why it isn't working.....

It takes ages to boot and shows that magisk is not installed. Installing supersu prior to that fixes it and magisk is running correctly.
[Magisk] Setialpha:
I guees it's the kernel (Sammy Stock kernels are picky). On my S6 (and my own ROM) it works perfect with arter97 kernel.
[Magisk] boilavera1980:
could be, dont want to to use arter its too old and drains much more like stock ... i wish we had a modified stock kernel without all that extra stuff....
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Your own rom? As in one you've created?

I feel your pain. No recent kernels and none without a bunch modifications for the note 5 either. I've been looking for a custom kernel without SU patched for use with Magisk. Wish we could get a bit more development on Samsung devices. Note 5 development is pretty much dead.
[Magisk] boilavera1980:
S6 Edge+ is the same .. in the past i did not have that many issues with magisk and stock kernels .. it always worked fine..
[Magisk] wit.cz:
Clean install of MIUI 8.2 from xiaomi eu, flash Magisk 11.1, reboot, install Magisk Manager 4.5 but PoGo doesn't work :( I have tried older versions (remove everything Magisk-related before) but w/o success :(
[Magisk] gerardroid:
Latest firmware DQB7with working pokemon

S7 edge

Follow steps in post #2225 member inright
[Magisk] wit.cz:
I tried #2225 before posting. Doesn't work. I cannot pass through SN test even without magisk - basic integrity is true, but CTS not. It is MIUI 8.2 dev rom from xiaomi.eu.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Are you sure you have no other things interfering with magisk? Go to the magisk general discussion thread and post more details such as logs and screenshots maybe...
[Magisk] Filip013:
You can't have CTS profile match on MIUI developer ROM only on Stable, but you don't need it to play Pokemon GO. If you have Basic Integrity: true, there's no reason why POGO shouldn't work.
[Magisk] negroxxx:
Works perfect with the new version
[Magisk] CasperSwayze:
Hey guys, I had a problem installing magisk manager. On playstore it is showing me that the version is incompatible. Tried downloading using a browser but still it's shpwing there was some problem parsing the package. The story starts when i saw a video on youtube. The link in the description was perfect. They said i gotta reset my phone to the factory version, i did. And after all that while installing the zip files in recovery mode of my phone there was an error message that i couldn't be installed. After a reboot i tried to install magisk manager it showed me that they couldn't parse that package. So.. what do i get from this? I won't be able to play pokemon go?

My phone

Samsung S4 active GT-i9295

Kitkat 4.4.2

Rooted via odin, it has supersu. I'm not sure about 'systemless' or no.

SOS
[Magisk] jhedfors:
Ugh. If your issue is not being able to install Magisk, it does not belong in the Pokemon Go thread.
[Magisk] CasperSwayze:
Okay! Flipflop
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Well, you can stop trying until you've updated your phone. Android 5.0+ only (as the release thread title states).
[Magisk] Indashio:
How to install Magisk on Xperia Z2? PokemonGo does not work on my Z2
[Magisk] iNewbcake:
I have the same issue, its weird. magisk v9 works, but anything past that doesn't (v11 did, but that was pulled)
[Magisk] kiki059:
Don't work for me .. :'(
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Looks like everything's as it should be to me... :)

Check this link for tips:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=70426733&postcount=7120

PoGo doesn't need CTS to pass though, only basic integrity, I believe.

(Hint: don't use SuperSU)
[Magisk] kiki059:
I try ..Don't work ..
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You can't have read the link very careful, because I distinctly remember putting something in there about providing logs and details if you can't get it to work...
[Magisk] Jv1391:
Hello I need help.

I tried to clean install magisk on my galaxy s5 with 6.0.1 marshmallow.

For clean I mean from a clean firmware without supersu, to use Magisksu.

Before install Magisk I tried safetynet and Pokemon go and it worked fine...

But after I flashed the zip from TWRP recocery and then I installed Magisk Manager but here is the problem:

It displays correctly Magisksu but ask me to install magisk .-.

Even If I download magisk and install it with Magisk Mmanager it keeps asking me to install Magisk.

It displays also CTS error in safety.

I nees help.

If I use Supersu SR3 It works with magisk as expectws but safetynet is not green. It keeps displaying the CTS error.... but at least magisk works.

So if anyone can help me?
[Magisk] mayosan:
Looks like you only installed the manager. You have to flash the magisk11.1.zip via TWRP to install Magisk properly. After that, tick the Magisk hide in the manager.
[Magisk] Jv1391:
I install it again and again but it displays the same
[Magisk] mayosan:
Hmmm, try this:

-download magisk uninstaller

- reboot to recovery TWRP

- flash uninstaller

- flash magisk

- tick the magisk hide

-reboot

- untick and tick magisk hide
[Magisk] :
Haven't had time to follow up but unless anything changed magiskhide won't work on stock rom for the galaxy s5. I could be wrong but I've had no success myself after a stock wipe. I thought i read the possibility of a custom kernel (boaffla kernel maybe) allowing it to work but honestly haven't tried. Might give it another shot soon.

Magisk v10 was the last one i tried. And it worked. But magiskhide would not.
[Magisk] Pedroc1999:
Any way to have Xposed enabled during Pokémon Go (to use the Snorlax module)?

Right now I disable xposed and reboot, but any ways other than that?

S6 + Magisk + Systemless Xposed
[Magisk] kiki059:
Nothing work for me :(

OxygenOS root with SuperSu + Magisk 11 NOK

LineageOS root with Magisk 11 NOK

How do working Magisk with Pokemon go ? Please
[Magisk] zorrigas:
Impossible to use Pokego on Samsung Galaxy S7 Exynos SM-G935F w/Magisk
[Magisk] teddy0209:
You can use rootswitch, but it only supports system xposed... At least last time I checked...

(Magisk+magisksu+magiskhide, system xposed+rootswitch to disable xposed) soft reboot and your module should still be active... ?
[Magisk] Arju:
When you open up Magisk Manager does all the 3 fields give you green light or is there any red bars giving you any error message?
[Magisk] andrew2432:
This works past November security? This may Be the only way out there to use xposed+updated roms
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It's Chainfires suhide that has issues with the November security patch, not Magisk Hide.

The mentioned method has been reported to work many times in this thread.
[Magisk] Hyoretsu:
Clean flashed my ROM, flashed magisk and enabled MagiskHide and MagiskSU, but root checker says I don't have root and I can't pass safetynet.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
MagiskHide hides root... Go to the general discussion of magisk and provide more details... The more the better...
[Magisk] andrew2432:
Sorry I'm on suhide etc, looking to update, just checking in.

To be clear: marshmallow ROMs past november can clear SN/log into pgo and working xposed with: newest magisk: magisk zip, phhsu but they are combined in new release, root switch to turn off xposed, system xposed 87 official. You are able to run xposed modules after soft reboot? Mac address spoofers, go controls and snorlax, LTE only mods, lock screen stuff, icon bar edits, all work on updated ROM with this setup?
[Magisk] Hyoretsu:
Gave up and uninstalled Magisk, but I still can't pass safetynet.
[Magisk] TouchLeclouds:
i cant find magisk hide in magisk manager settings
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Not many people here can read minds. I'm assuming you're asking for help, so please provide some details. Magisk version? Manager version? Root solution?
[Magisk] TouchLeclouds:
Device: Galaxy s6 European verison

Rom: Noble Experience 2.0

Recovery: TWRP (latest version)

Magisk manager: Latest 4.25

trying to flash Magisk verions 10.2, also tried 11.1 still getting the error 1 in twrp.

Root solution: SuperSU 2.79
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Now, there's your problem... No Magisk Hide without having successfully installed Magisk and not with SuperSU.

If you wan't to use Magisk Hide, you'll need to remove SuperSU and since your ROM comes pre-rooted there's probably gonna be some patches in the boot image as well that needs removing (by flashing a clean boot image). Error 1 probably comes from the pre-patched boot image, but without a recovery log from the installation it's impossible to say.
[Magisk] TouchLeclouds:
where do i find a clean boot image?

btw v9 works with supersu but still cant find the hide magisk in the settings

Edit: i flashed boot.img from the original firmware, got stuck on Samsung logo. luckily i had boot backed-up.
[Magisk] Battlecreed5:
Hey guys currently I'm running Mokee 7.1.1 on Redmi 2 but after incremental update Magisk is removed and when I reinstall it and try to play pokemon go , simply the game doesn't work. How can I fix it.
[Magisk] ken2802:
Open any costum Rom zip and take the boot.img you need out there.

Gesendet von meinem SM-G925F mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] dmalott8409:
G935W8. SuperStock v2.4. SuperStock v2.0 kernel. Running Magisk 10.2. Fails Safetynet but PoGo works. I tried updating to v2.5 of the rom which includes Magisk v11.1. Go through all the loops I've read to pass Safetynet and still fails. PoGo doesn't work either. Restored my back up of previous setup and I'm back in business with PoGo. I've tried other rims using v11.1 Magisk and have had no luck passing Safetynet or having PoGo work.

Not a huge deal to me but if things stop working I might have to give up root again if I wanna keep playing.
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
After coming from a good setup. Systemless Su, Suhide .55, rootswitch 1.3.3.2 and xposed 86.2. Im able to play PoGo with all the modules on 3 old devices that I have.(Nexus 4, Nexus 7 tablet, and what used to be my daily driver LG G3)

A few moths ago I upgraded to LG G5, the same setup mentioned above didn't work. I put the phone to stock 6.0.1.

Just yesterday I installed the latest masisk with the manager. I was able to play PoGo but without xposed. I followed the steps above and now I'm able to have root and play PoGo with Snorlax and Pokemon Go Controls.

Thanks for the wonderful support.
[Magisk] xstahsie:
Glad to see another Pokémon Go player got this working. Just to provide clarification for some folks who are having trouble getting this to work, here is a more thorough walk through:

Here is how I got Xposed to work with Magisk for the purpose of playing Pokémon Go: I did a factory restore using the Skipsoft Android toolkit, installed TWRP using the same toolkit, I booted into Android, downloaded Magisk Manager via the Google Play Store, downloaded the official Xposed 87, downloaded Magisk via the Magisk Manager and flashed Magisk and the official Xposed 87 via TWRP, cleared the dalvik cache and cache, booted back into Android (optimization expected), enabled MagiskHide, downloaded and installed Root Switch 1.3.3.2 and Xposed Installer (by dvdandroid), downloaded and enabled the Snorlax module, launched Root Switch and made sure Xposed is enabled, hard rebooted my phone, once I was back in Android, I launched Root Switch, I clicked to disable Xposed, did a soft reboot as promoted, and once I was back in Android again, I launched Magisk Manager and I checked SafetyNet to make sure it was green. If SafetyNet is green, it pretty much means I can launch Pokémon Go with the Snorlax Xposed module.

Do keep in mind that not all Xposed modules will work with this method; the Snorlax and Pokémon Go Controls modules are working with this method. Root will continue to work. I had used Chainfire Suhide as well as phh Superuser hidesu but I found that Magisk is a lot easier to work with. Not to mention, Chainfire Suhide causes performance issue with Nexus 6P.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
You mentioned doing a factory restore, am I sage to assume you're using stock rom and stock kernel? Have you tried any payment/banking apps?
[Magisk] xstahsie:
Yep--stock ROM and kernel. Funny you mentioned payment/banking apps... I was at McDonald's this morning and paid with Android Pay. As long as SafetyNet in Magisk is green you're good.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Unfortunately I have green on all three but pay doesn't work. PoGo works but not pay
[Magisk] arrrgh:
Anyone using RootSwitch on Nexus 7 (2013) latest stock ROM? For some reason RootSwitch completely disables xposed modules instead of leaving them to the glitched state where they still work. Everything else seems to be working like it is supposed to though.
[Magisk] xstahsie:
That's odd. Remove and add your card again to see if that helps.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Strange, I can remove/add and verify my debit card without issue but when I attempted a purchase it triggers a loop of asking for my lock pin and reapply messages. Any ideas? I don't have Xposed installed yet. Just Magisk v12, Manager 5 on stock 6.0.1 and custom kernel
[Magisk] xstahsie:
Where did you get Magisk 12 and Magisk manager 5 from? As far as I am aware, the latest official version of Magisk is 11.1 and the latest Magisk Manager is 4.2.6.

Also, are you using a stock ROM and kernel?
[Magisk] biggdevon:
It's posted in the Magisk forum here https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/unofficial-magisk-v10-beta-built-t3521901

I'm running stock 6.0.1 with arter97's kernel. SM-N920T
[Magisk] xstahsie:
If possible, you should try the official version of Magisk to see if it works with Android Pay. I've stayed away from custom kernels because they could introduce problems that are different to fix.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Unfortunately the stock Samsung kernel doesn't play well with Magisk. I've used a few versions 10.1, 11.1, and a couple 12betas. Haven't had a lot of time to devout to figuring out it until now.
[Magisk] xstahsie:
Sorry, I don't think I'll be able to help since I don't have a Samsung device.
[Magisk] Hyoretsu:
What root method are you using and Snorlax or Snorlax Reloaded? Also, any additional steps for Pokémon Go controls?
[Magisk] xstahsie:
MagiskSU is the root method that I am using. And no additional steps needed for Pokémon Go Controls beyond what has been stated above.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
That's a problem I've gotten when I restored a TWRP backup and had to delete my lock settings files to get back into my device. The only way I've found to fix it is clean flashing stock firmware - otherwise Android Pay thinks you don't have a screen lock set up for some reason. That's an issue not related to Magisk, though.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
I started with a dirty flash of the stock boot.img from the stock tar file. I haven't tried a full wipe, that shouldn't include internal storage though should it? I'd love to get PoGo, pay, and Xposed working. I ok with having to toggle as long as it works. Although disabling/re-enabling does cause a rather long boot time due to optimizing apps
[Magisk] Hyoretsu:
Am on LineageOS 14.1, flashed Magisk and enabled Magisk Hide, but I can't pass safetynet.
[Magisk] reis1996:
Not all devices are supported yet. Wait for magisk updates
[Magisk] pepek112:
Pokemon not work

Hello. I have untypical problem ;/

Magisk 1.11 magisk hide ON safety test Pass, pokemon not work

ht tp://i.imgur.com/OgJOq6E.png

ht tp://i.imgur.com/ImnUkQX.png

ht tp://i.imgur.com/vjgdxVm.png
[Magisk] dynospectrum:
In MagiskHide, select Pokemon & System UI. Then go into developer options and disable USB Debugging. Reboot & enjoy.
[Magisk] pepek112:
Thx for try help but still not work

ht tps://imgur.com/gallery/IQRWp
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
I'm using the same tablet to play PoGo from home.

Here are my steps.

1. Restore the tablet to Marshmallow 6.0.1 (built MOB30X). Install TWRP.

2. Download the SR3-SuperSU-v2.78-SR3 systemless SU from chainfire. Download suhide-v.055, download xposed-v86.2 (this one works with systemless) and xposedinstaller by dvdandroid.apk. Download rootswitch 1.3.3.2 All of them can be found here at xda.

3. Go into recovery and install SuperSu in systemless mode. To do this go into terminal in TWRP and type echo SYSTEMLESS=true>>/data/.supersu. After that flash SR3-SuperSU-v2.78-SR3 , then flash suhide-v.055, Reboot.

4. Make sure you boot up correctly. And that you have SuperSU app in the tablet. Go to recovery again and flash xposed-v86.2. Reboot. Now install xposed installer. And rootswitch.

4. Open rootswitch. Make sure "stop all SU daemons" it's check and disabled root.

5. Profit.
[Magisk] shivam883:
Hi I am using magisk 11.1 in my yuphoria and I am having a problem in pokemon go that the loading screen is not moving at all. What should I do please tell me some solution.http://cloud.tapatalk.com/s/58b3bda5d4435/Screenshot_2017-02-27-11-12-07.png?
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
Make sure everything is green in Magisk Manager and that magisk hide is enabled in settings
[Magisk] shivam883:
Yes bro every thing is green but I have installed systemless xposed so the safty net fails but when I disable closed and restart my phone saftynet also pass without any problem
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
The problem is systemsless xposed. Uninstalled it. After that Go to xposed app and install official xposed v87.

Install rootswitch 1.3.3.2. And disable Xposed.
[Magisk] shivam883:
But bro if I install root switch and disable xposed will I able to use any xposed modules like "xposed pokemon".
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
OK I got you. Read post #2208 by xstahsie and follow his instructions...You need official xposed v87 for this to work. That's the setup that work for me.

For me only the only modules that work pokemon go controls and snorlax reloaded work. The most important ones.

Sorry if I don't answer no more but it's pass 1:30 here in NYC. Just go to that post mentioned above
[Magisk] shivam883:
OK thanks for your time I will try now and tell you if it work or not
[Magisk] notavalidusername:
Sprint HTC M8 here. Installed Xposed v87 through the Xposed installer, installed rootswitch. Whenever I disable Xposed in rootswitch and the phone soft reboots, it freezes at the "HTC One" boot screen.
[Magisk] HeNaFi:
Do you have all green in Magisk Manager. For me the HTC M8 works well with systemless SuperSU, Suhide, xposed 86.2, and rootswitch.

Have you tried that.
[Magisk] qwasy:
Pokemon is not working for me either.

I'm using a Xiaomi Mi4C, Xiaomi.eu 7.2.24 rom with Android 7.

Installing and rooting works fine, but PoGo is not starting. Also, in the Log files, there are no infos about the pokemon process...

I tried the beta builds as well, and also switching Magisk Hide.

Without Magisk, it's working fine.

Any ideas?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Don't use Magisk?

There's not supposed to be anything about Pokemon in the logs. It depends on SafetyNet to discover if your device is safe or not. Providing said logs goes a long way towards getting any help...
[Magisk] reis1996:
No it doesn't. Many people including me have logged in even though our safety net doesn't pass and is red
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yes it does.

The reason you can play with a triggered SafetyNet is because Pokemon Go only checks basic integrity (a lower level of security) and not the CTS profile. In other words: SafetyNet doesn't have to fully pass for you to be able to play PoGo.
[Magisk] reis1996:
Then why does my pokemon not login after magisk?

I flashed a version of my lineage rom. This version was when they just started no in built root in their sources. Pokemon logged in. As soon as I flashed magisk it wouldn't. I used the hide feature and did the restart and toggle hide
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Check if you pass basic integrity or not (SafetyNet helper works). And provide logs...
[Magisk] reis1996:
I don't but I could login before flashing magiskv11.1
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Then something with your current setup doesn't work with Magisk Hide. Impossible to know exactly what on the amount of information you've given so far (although I've seen several people reporting issues with LineageOS).